article
stringlengths 0
745k
| abstract
stringlengths 0
92.7k
|
|---|---|
neutrinos were first proposed in 1930 by wolfgang pauli to explain , among other problems , the missing energy in nuclear beta decay . towards the end of that decade ,
the role of nuclear reactions as an energy source for stars was recognized and the hydrogen fusion chains were discovered by bethe @xcite and von weizscker @xcite .
it is intriguing , however , that these authors did not mention neutrinos for example , bethe writes the fundamental pp reaction in the form @xmath0 .
it was gamow and schoenberg in 1940 who first stressed that stars must be powerful neutrino sources because beta processes play a key role in the hydrogen fusion reactions and because of the feeble neutrino interactions that allow them to escape unscathed @xcite .
moreover , the idea that supernova explosions had something to do with stellar collapse and neutron - star formation had been proposed by baade and zwicky in 1934 @xcite , and gamow and schoenberg ( 1941 ) developed a first neutrino theory of stellar collapse @xcite .
solar neutrinos were first measured by ray davis with his homestake radiochemical detector that produced data over a quarter century 19701994 @xcite and since that time solar neutrino measurements have become routine in many experiments . the neutrino burst from stellar collapse
was observed only once when the star sanduleak @xmath1 in the large magellanic cloud , about 160,000 light years away , exploded on february 23 , 1987 ( supernova 1987a ) .
the sun and sn 1987a remain the only measured astrophysical neutrino sources .
stars for sure are prime examples for neutrinos being of practical relevance in nature .
the smallness of neutrino masses compared with stellar temperatures ensures their role as radiation .
the weak interaction strength ensures that neutrinos freely escape once produced , except for the case of stellar core collapse where even neutrinos are trapped , but still emerge from regions where nothing else can directly carry away information except gravitational waves .
the properties of stars themselves can sometimes provide key information about neutrinos or the properties of other low - mass particles that may be emitted in analogous ways .
the sun is used as a source of experimental neutrino or particle measurements .
the sn 1987a neutrino burst has provided a large range of particle - physics limits .
measuring a high - statistics neutrino light curve from the next nearby supernova will provide a bonanza of astrophysical and particle - physics information .
the quest for such an observation and measuring the diffuse neutrino flux from all past supernovae are key targets for low - energy neutrino astronomy .
the purpose of these lectures is to introduce an audience of young neutrino researchers , with not much prior exposure to astrophysical concepts , to the role of neutrinos in stars and conversely , how stars can be used to gain information about neutrinos and other low - mass particles that can be emitted in similar ways .
we will describe the role of neutrinos in ordinary stars and concomitant constraints on neutrino and particle properties ( section [ sec : ordinarystars ] ) .
next we turn to the sun as a measurable neutrino and particle source ( section [ sec : sun ] ) .
the third topic are collapsing stars and the key role of supernova neutrinos in low - energy neutrino astronomy ( section [ sec : sn ] ) .
an ordinary star like our sun is a self - gravitating ball of hot gas .
it can liberate gravitational energy by contraction , but of course its main energy source is nuclear binding energy . during the initial phase of hydrogen burning , the effective reaction is @xmath2 in detail , the reactions can proceed through the pp chains ( table [ tab : ppchains ] ) or the cno cycle ( table [ tab : cno ] ) .
the latter contributes only a few percent in the sun , but dominates in slightly more massive stars due to its steep temperature dependence .
neutrinos carry away a few percent of the energy , in detail depending on the reaction channels .
based on the solar photon luminosity of . ]
@xmath3 one can easily estimate the solar neutrino flux at earth to be about @xmath4 .
.hydrogen burning by pp chains .
[ cols= " < , < , < , < , < " , ] the most pronounced flavor - dependent feature in the sn neutrino signal is the prompt @xmath5 burst , which in addition is rather model independent @xcite . in the normal hierarchy
, it would completely oscillate into the @xmath6 flavor so that it could not be seen in the charged - current ( cc ) channel of a liquid argon detector , whereas the electron - scattering signal would be reduced by about a factor of 7 .
on the other hand , in the inverted hierarchy , we would have @xmath7 and thus a significant cc signal .
existing detectors , however , do not have a sufficient @xmath5 sensitivity for a clear detection
. signal in water cherenkov or scintillator detectors for different oscillation scenarios .
for the regeneration effect ( right panel ) an 8000 km path length in the earth is assumed.[fig : eartheffects],scaledwidth=100.0% ] another option is to look for a signature in the @xmath8 channel . during the accretion phase ,
the expected @xmath8 and @xmath9 fluxes are very different ( fig .
[ fig : basel ] ) so that the expected detection signal depends strongly on the oscillation scenario ( fig .
[ fig : eartheffects ] ) .
however , in the absence of a quantitatively reliable prediction of the flavor - dependent fluxes and spectra it is difficult to distinguish between these cases .
one model - independent signature would be the matter regeneration effect if the sn signal is received through the earth in a `` shadowed '' position @xcite .
the earth effect would imprint energy - dependent modulations on the received @xmath8 signal ( right panel of fig . [
fig : eartheffects ] ) with a frequency that depends on the distance traveled through the earth . in principle , these `` wiggles '' can be resolved , but not with present - day detectors @xcite . with the water cherenkov technique one would need a megaton class detector , whereas with a scintillator detector
a few thousand events would be enough due to the superior energy resolution .
one may also compare the signals between a shadowed and an unshadowed detector @xcite .
the signal rise time is generically different between @xmath8 and @xmath9 ( fig .
[ fig : promptburst ] ) so that the rise time of the oscillated @xmath8 signal depends on the mixing scenario .
conceivably , this signature can be used to determine the hierarchy , although the effect is subtle @xcite . during the sn cooling phase ,
the shock wave propagates through the envelope , eventually disturbs the resonance region , and may imprint detectable features on the time - dependent neutrino flux @xcite .
of course , the expectation of strong signatures was originally driven by the perception of a strong flavor dependence of the cooling fluxes that is not borne out by modern simulations with the full range of neutrino interaction channels . therefore , any such signatures are likely somewhat subtle
. moreover , the matter behind the shock wave will exhibit stochastic density fluctuations from turbulent matter flows that can lead to flavor equilibration @xcite .
a major new issue was recognized only a few years ago , the impact of collective or self - induced flavor conversions .
the neutrinos streaming from the sn core are so dense that they provide a large matter effect for each other .
the nonlinear nature of this neutrino - neutrino effect renders its consequences very different from the ordinary matter effect in that it results in collective oscillation phenomena @xcite that can be of practical interest in the early universe for the oscillation of neutrinos with hypothetical primordial asymmetries @xcite .
these effects are also important in sne in the region up to a few 100 km above the neutrino sphere @xcite , an insight that has triggered a torrent of recent activities @xcite .
collective effects are important in regions where the effective neutrino - neutrino interaction energy @xmath10 exceeds a typical vacuum oscillation frequency @xmath11 . in an isotropic ensemble
we have @xmath12 with @xmath13 the neutrino density .
the current - current nature of low - energy weak interactions implies that a factor @xmath14 appears in the interaction potential where @xmath15 is the angle between neutrino trajectories .
if the background is isotropic ( approximately true for ordinary matter ) , this term averages to 1 . on the other hand , neutrinos streaming from a sn core become more and more collinear with distance , so the average interaction potential is reduced by a suitable average @xmath16 .
one finds that @xmath10 effectively decreases with distance as @xmath17 where two powers derive from the geometric flux dilution , another two powers from the increasing collinearity .
therefore , collective effects are important only fairly close to the neutrino sphere .
let us assume for now that collective effects are not affected by matter .
let us further assume that we have a pronounced hierarchy of number fluxes @xmath18 that certainly applies after bounce and during the accretion phase , but probably does not apply during the cooling phase . in this scenario
the impact of collective oscillations is straightforward .
nothing new happens for normal hierarchy ( nh ) , whereas for the inverted hierarchy ( ih ) the @xmath8 flux is swapped with the @xmath9 flux . in addition , the @xmath5 flux is swapped with the @xmath6 flux , but only for @xmath19 where the energy @xmath20 marks a sharp `` spectral split , '' separating the swapped part of the spectrum from the unswapped part ( fig .
[ fig : split ] ) .
@xmath21 is fixed by the condition that the net @xmath5 flux @xmath22 is conserved @xcite .
in other words , there is no net flavor conversion : essentially one has self - induced collective pair conversions @xmath23 .
, scaledwidth=70.0% ] collective oscillations at first seemed unaffected by matter because its influence does not depend on neutrino energies @xcite .
however , depending on emission angle , neutrinos accrue different matter - induced flavor - dependent phases until they reach a given radius .
this `` multi - angle matter effect '' can suppress self - induced flavor conversion @xcite . based on schematic flux spectra ,
this was numerically confirmed for accretion - phase sn models where the density near the core is large @xcite .
self - induced conversion requires that part of the spectrum is prepared in one flavor , the rest in another .
the collective mode consists of pendulum - like flavor exchange between these parts without changing the overall flavor content @xcite .
the inevitable starting point is a flavor instability of the neutrino distribution caused by neutrino - neutrino refraction .
an exponentially growing mode can be detected with a linearized analysis of the evolution equations @xcite .
this method was applied to realistic multi - angle multi - energy neutrino fluxes and also confirm the suppression of self - induced conversion for the investigated accretion - phase models @xcite .
if these results turn out to be generic , then for the accretion phase the survival probabilities of table [ tab : survival ] remain applicable .
likewise , the prompt @xmath5 burst should not be affected by collective oscillations with the possible exception of very low - mass progenitor stars . in this case
the matter density is so low even at shock break out that the msw region is very close to the possible collective oscillation region . in this case ,
interesting combined effects between msw and collective conversion have been identified @xcite . and
@xmath24 , each time for inverted hierarchy ( ih ) and normal hierarchy ( nh ) .
red lines @xmath25flavor , blue @xmath26flavor . shaded regions mark swap intervals .
[ fig : multisplits],scaledwidth=60.0% ] during the cooling phase , the matter profile has become so low that self - induced flavor conversions can operate unimpeded .
the flavor hierarchy of fluxes and spectral energies is not large , allowing for more complicated conversion patterns see fig .
[ fig : multisplits ] for an example .
multiple spectral swaps and splits are possible @xcite , where however multi - angle effects play a crucial role @xcite . at the present time it is not obvious if one can arrive at generic predictions for what happens during the cooling phase .
the interacting neutrino gas , however , remains a fascinating system for collective motions of what is effectively an interacting spin system @xcite , with analogies in the area of superconductivity @xcite .
the physics of stars is inseparably intertwined with that of neutrinos and we have discussed some of the many fascinating topics at the interface of these fields .
solar neutrinos play a special role in that the measured @xmath5 flux provided first evidence for flavor oscillations : a deep particle - physics issue was directly connected to low - energy neutrino astronomy . learning about the exact chemical composition of the solar interior is the next frontier of solar neutrino spectroscopy . beyond the sun , neutrinos play a crucial role as an energy - loss channel that is a necessary ingredient for understanding stellar evolution . in the same spirit , we can use observed properties of stars , notably in globular clusters , to learn about neutrinos , such as their electromagnetic properties , or about other low - mass particles such as axions .
these hypothetical particles would also emerge from the sun .
the search for solar axions with the cast experiment has provided important constraints and a next - generation axion helioscope is being discussed .
it would probe deeply into realistic parameter space .
of course , the royal discipline of neutrino astrophysics is their role in stellar core collapse and the dynamics of supernova explosions .
sn 1987a remains the only observed astrophysical neutrino source other than the sun .
it has confirmed our basic understanding of supernova physics and has provided several particle - physics limits that remain of topical interest to date .
detecting the diffuse neutrino background from all past supernovae in the universe is the next milestone for low - energy neutrino astronomy .
a high - statistics neutrino observation of the next nearby supernova with one of the operating or future large - scale experiments will provide a bonanza of astrophysical , neutrino and particle - physics information .
many questions remain open about supernova dynamics , nucleosynthesis in the neutrino - driven wind , and flavor oscillations in an environment of dense matter and neutrinos .
the next generation of large - scale detectors remains to be developed and built .
so while we wait for the next supernova neutrino observation , a lot of numerical , theoretical , and experimental work remains to be done .
t. a. weaver , g. b. zimmerman and s. e. woosley , astrophys .
j. * 225 * ( 1978 ) 1021 . g. raffelt and d. seckel , phys .
d * 52 * ( 1995 ) 1780 .
k. nakamura et al .
( particle data group ) , j. phys .
g * 37 * ( 2010 ) 075021 .
r. b. stothers , phys .
* 24 * ( 1970 ) 538 .
f. j. hasert et al .
b * 46 * ( 1973 ) 121 and 138 .
e. braaten and d. segel , phys .
d * 48 * ( 1993 ) 1478 .
n. itoh , h. hayashi and a. nishikawa , astrophys .
* 102 * ( 1996 ) 411 .
j. bernstein , m. ruderman and g. feinberg , phys .
* 132 * ( 1963 ) 1227 .
j. schechter and j. w. f. valle , phys .
d * 24 * ( 1981 ) 1883 ; ( e ) ibid . * 25 * ( 1982 ) 283 .
e. k. akhmedov , phys .
b * 213 * ( 1988 ) 64 . c. s. lim and w. j. marciano , phys .
d * 37 * ( 1988 ) 1368 .
o. g. miranda , t. i. rashba , a. i. rez and j. w. f. valle , phys .
* 93 * ( 2004 ) 051304 .
o. g. miranda , t. i. rashba , a. i. rez and j. w. f. valle , phys .
d * 70 * ( 2004 ) 113002 .
g. raffelt and t. rashba , phys . atom .
* 73 * ( 2010 ) 609 .
s. ando and k. sato , phys .
d * 68 * ( 2003 ) 023003 .
e. k. akhmedov and t. fukuyama , jcap * 0312 * ( 2003 ) 007 .
a. g. beda et al . , phys .
* 7 * ( 2010 ) 667 .
g. g. raffelt , phys . rev .
* 81 * ( 1998 ) 4020 .
m. t. ressell and m. s. turner , comments astrophys .
* 14 * ( 1990 ) 323 .
s. d. biller et al . , phys .
* 80 * ( 1998 ) 2992 .
g. g. raffelt , _ stars as laboratories for fundamental physics _
( university of chicago press 1996 ) .
w. e. harris , `` globular clusters : the view from hst , '' proc .
space telescope science institute symposium ( baltimore , md , usa , 1114 april 2000 ) , ed . by m. livio , k. noll , m. stiavelli .
space telescope science institute symposium series , vol .
14 ( cambridge university press , 2003 ) , pp 78100 . g. g. raffelt , astrophys . j. * 365 * ( 1990 ) 559 .
m. catelan , j. a. d. pacheco and j. e. horvath , astrophys .
j. * 461 * ( 1996 ) 231 .
g. g. raffelt , phys .
* 198 * ( 1990 ) 1 .
g. g. raffelt , ann .
nucl . part .
* 49 * ( 1999 ) 163 .
r. d. peccei , lect .
notes phys .
* 741 * ( 2008 ) 3 .
p. sikivie , lect .
notes phys .
* 741 * ( 2008 ) 19 .
g. g. raffelt , lect .
notes phys .
* 741 * ( 2008 ) 51 .
j. e. kim and g. carosi , rev .
* 82 * ( 2010 ) 557 .
m. dine , w. fischler and m. srednicki , phys .
b * 104 * ( 1981 ) 199 .
a. r. zhitnitsky , sov .
j. nucl . phys .
* 31 * ( 1980 ) 260 [ yad . fiz .
* 31 * ( 1980 ) 497 ] .
g. raffelt and a. weiss , phys .
d * 51 * ( 1995 ) 1495 .
g. g. raffelt , phys .
b * 166 * ( 1986 ) 402 .
j. isern , e. garca - berro , s. torres and s. cataln , astrophys .
j. lett .
* 682 * ( 2008 ) l109 .
j. isern , s. cataln , e. garca - berro and s. torres , j. phys .
* 172 * ( 2009 ) 012005
. j. isern , m. hernanz and e. garca - berro , astrophys . j. * 392 * ( 1992 ) l23 .
j. isern , e. garca - berro , l. g. althaus and a. h. corsico , astron .
astrophys . * 512 * ( 2010 ) a86 .
a. h. corsico , l. g. althaus , a. d. romero , m. m. m. bertolami , e. garca - berro and j. isern , arxiv:1108.3541 . g. g. raffelt , j. redondo and n. viaux maira , phys .
d * 84 * ( 2011 ) 103008 .
j. n. bahcall , a. m. serenelli and s. basu , astrophys .
j. * 621 * ( 2005 ) l85 . j. n. bahcall and a. m. serenelli , astrophys .
j. * 626 * ( 2005 ) 530 .
w. c. haxton and w. lin , phys .
b * 486 * ( 2000 ) 263 .
a. m. serenelli , w. c. haxton and c. pea - garay , astrophys .
j. * 743 * ( 2011 ) 24 .
r. davis , phys .
* 12 * ( 1964 ) 303 . j. n. bahcall , phys . rev .
* 12 * ( 1964 ) 300 .
r. j. davis , phys .
rev . * 97 * ( 1955 ) 766 .
r. j. davis , d. s. harmer and k. c. hoffman , phys .
lett . * 20 * ( 1968 ) 1205
. v. n. gribov and b. pontecorvo , phys .
b * 28 * ( 1969 ) 493 .
l. wolfenstein , phys .
d * 17 * ( 1978 ) 2369 .
s. p. mikheev and a. yu . smirnov , sov .
j. nucl .
* 42 * ( 1985 )
913 [ yad . fiz .
* 42 * ( 1985 ) 1441 ] .
h. a. bethe , phys .
* 56 * ( 1986 ) 1305 .
m. altmann et al .
( gno collaboration ) , phys .
b * 616 * ( 2005 ) 174 .
j. n. abdurashitov et al .
( sage collaboration ) , phys .
c * 80 * ( 2009 ) 015807
. s. fukuda et al .
( super - kamiokande collaboration ) , phys . rev .
* 86 * ( 2001 ) 5651 .
k. abe et al .
( super - kamiokande collaboration ) , phys .
d * 83 * ( 2011 ) 052010 .
j. n. bahcall , p. i. krastev and a. yu . smirnov , phys .
d * 58 * ( 1998 ) 096016 .
y. fukuda et al .
( super - kamiokande collaboration ) , phys .
* 81 * ( 1998 ) 1562 .
s. fukuda et al .
( super - kamiokande collaboration ) , phys .
* 86 * ( 2001 ) 5656 .
q. r. ahmad et al .
( sno collaboration ) , phys .
* 89 * ( 2002 ) 011301 .
k. eguchi et al .
( kamland collaboration ) , phys .
* 90 * ( 2003 ) 021802 .
s. abe et al .
( kamland collaboration ) , phys .
* 100 * ( 2008 ) 221803 .
g. bellini et al .
lett . * 107 * ( 2011 ) 141302 .
g. bellini , talk at taup 2011 conference , munich , 59 sept .
2011 , + http://taup2011.mpp.mpg.de g. l. fogli , e. lisi , a. marrone , a. palazzo and a. m. rotunno , phys .
d * 84 * ( 2011 ) 053007 .
m. c. gonzalez - garcia , m. maltoni and j. salvado , jhep * 1004 * ( 2010 ) 056 h. de kerret ( for the double chooz collaboration ) , talk at lownu , seoul , nov . 11 , 2011 http://workshop.kias.re.kr/lownu11 a. serenelli , arxiv:1109.2602 . n. grevesse and a. j. sauval , space sci .
* 85 * ( 1998 ) 161 . m. asplund , n. grevesse , a. j. sauval and p. scott , ann . rev
. astron .
astrophys . * 47 * ( 2009 ) 481 .
e. caffau , h .-
ludwig , m. steffen , b. freytag and p. bonifacio , sol .
* 268 * ( 2011 ) 255 .
g. mention , m. fechner , t. lasserre , t. a. mueller , d. lhuillier , m. cribier and a. letourneau , phys .
d * 83 * ( 2011 ) 073006 .
g. bellini et al .
( borexino collaboration ) , phys .
b * 696 * ( 2011 ) 191 .
g. g. raffelt , phys .
d * 31 * ( 1985 ) 3002 .
g. raffelt and l. stodolsky , phys .
b * 119 * ( 1982 ) 323 .
p. sikivie , phys .
* 51 * ( 1983 ) 1415 ; ( e ) ibid .
* 52 * ( 1984 ) 695 .
g. raffelt and l. stodolsky , phys .
d * 37 * ( 1988 ) 1237 .
d. m. lazarus et al . , phys .
* 69 * ( 1992 ) 2333 .
s. moriyama , m. minowa , t. namba , y. inoue , y. takasu and a. yamamoto , phys .
b * 434 * ( 1998 ) 147 .
y. inoue , t. namba , s. moriyama , m. minowa , y. takasu , t. horiuchi and a. yamamoto , phys .
b * 536 * ( 2002 ) 18 .
y. inoue , y. akimoto , r. ohta , t. mizumoto , a. yamamoto and m. minowa , phys .
b * 668 * ( 2008 ) 93 .
k. zioutas et al .
( cast collaboration ) , phys .
* 94 * ( 2005 ) 121301 .
s. andriamonje et al .
( cast collaboration ) , jcap * 0704 * ( 2007 ) 010 .
e. arik et al .
( cast collaboration ) , jcap * 0902 * ( 2009 ) 008 .
m. arik et al .
( cast collaboration ) , phys .
lett . * 107 * ( 2011 ) 261302 .
k. van bibber , p. m. mcintyre , d. e. morris and g. g. raffelt , phys . rev . d * 39 * ( 1989 ) 2089 .
s. hannestad , a. mirizzi , g. g. raffelt and y. y. y. wong , jcap * 1008 * ( 2010 ) 001 .
i. g. irastorza et al . , jcap * 1106 * ( 2011 ) 013 .
h. schlattl , a. weiss and g. raffelt , astropart .
* 10 * ( 1999 ) 353 .
p. gondolo and g. raffelt , phys .
d * 79 * ( 2009 ) 107301 .
a. burrows , ann .
nucl . part .
* 40 * ( 1990 ) 181 .
a. burrows , nature * 403 * ( 2000 ) 727 .
janka , k. langanke , a. marek , g. martnez - pinedo and b. mller , phys .
* 442 * ( 2007 ) 38 .
l. scheck , k. kifonidis , h .- t .
janka and e. mller , astron .
astrophys .
* 457 * ( 2006 ) 963 .
a. wongwathanarat , h .-
janka and e. mller , astrophys .
j. * 725 * ( 2010 ) l106 .
e. cappellaro and m. turatto , `` supernova types and rates , '' in : _ the influence of binaries on stellar population studies _
( dordrecht : kluwer academic publishers , 2001 ) [ astro - ph/0012455 ] .
a. goobar and b. leibundgut , ann .
nucl . part .
* 61 * ( 2011 ) 251 .
s. perlmutter et al .
( supernova cosmology project ) , astrophys .
j. * 517 * ( 1999 ) 565 .
a. g. riess et al .
( supernova search team ) , astron . j. * 116 * ( 1998 ) 1009
. o. krause , m. tanaka , t. usuda , t. hattori , m. goto , s. birkmann and k. nomoto , nature * 456 * ( 2008 ) 617 .
s. a. colgate , w. h. grasberger and r. h. white , astron .
j. * 70 * ( 1961 ) 280 .
s. a. colgate and r. h. white , astrophys .
j. * 143 * ( 1966 ) 626 .
j. r. wilson , `` supernovae and post - collapse behavior , '' in : numerical astrophysics , proc .
symposium in honour of james r. wilson , held at the university of illinois urbana champaign , october , 1982 . ed . by j.
m. centrella , j. m. leblanc and r. l. bowers ( boston : jones and bartlett publ . , 1985 ) p. 422 .
h. a. bethe and j. r. wilson , astrophys .
j. * 295 * ( 1985 ) 14 .
d. z. freedman , phys .
d * 9 * ( 1974 ) 1389 .
d. z. freedman , d. n. schramm and d. l. tubbs , ann .
nucl . part .
* 27 * ( 1977 ) 167 .
d. n. schramm and j. r. wilson , astrophys .
j. * 260 * ( 1982 ) 868 .
z. berezhiani and a. drago , phys .
b * 473 * ( 2000 ) 281 .
g. m. fuller , r. mayle , b. s. meyer and j. r. wilson , astrophys .
j. * 389 * ( 1992 ) 517 .
y. suwa , k. kotake , t. takiwaki , m. liebendrfer and k. sato , astrophys . j. * 738 * ( 2011 ) 165 .
b. dasgupta , e. p. oconnor and c. d. ott , phys .
d * 85 * ( 2012 ) 065008 .
j. hidaka and g. m. fuller , phys .
d * 76 * ( 2007 ) 083516 .
g. m. fuller , a. kusenko and k. petraki , phys .
b * 670 * ( 2009 ) 281 .
f. s. kitaura , h .-
janka and w. hillebrandt , astron .
astrophys .
* 450 * ( 2006 ) 345 .
f. hanke , a. marek , b. mller and h .- t .
janka , arxiv:1108.4355 .
j. m. blondin , a. mezzacappa and c. demarino , astrophys . j. * 584 * ( 2003 ) 971 .
n. ohnishi , k. kotake and s. yamada , astrophys . j. * 641 * ( 2006 ) 1018 .
t. foglizzo , p. galletti , l. scheck and h .-
janka , astrophys .
j. * 654 * ( 2007 ) 1006 .
a. marek , h .- t .
janka and e. mller , astron .
astrophys .
* 496 * ( 2009 ) 475 .
j. w. murphy , c. d. ott and a. burrows , astrophys .
j. * 707 * ( 2009 ) 1173 .
a. marek and h .- t .
janka , astrophys . j. * 694 * ( 2009 ) 664 .
c. y. cardall , nucl .
* 217 * ( 2011 ) 275 .
j. nordhaus , a. burrows , a. almgren and j. bell , astrophys .
j. * 720 * ( 2010 ) 694 .
a. burrows , e. livne , l. dessart , c. d. ott and j. murphy , astrophys . j. * 655 * ( 2007 ) 416 .
c. j. horowitz , phys .
d * 65 * ( 2002 ) 043001 .
t. fischer , s. c. whitehouse , a. mezzacappa , f. k. thielemann and m. liebendrfer , astron .
astrophys .
* 517 * ( 2010 ) a80 .
m. kachelriess , r. toms , r. buras , h .-
janka , a. marek and m. rampp , phys .
d * 71 * ( 2005 ) 063003 .
k. langanke , g. martnez - pinedo and j. m. sampaio , phys .
c * 64 * ( 2001 ) 055801 .
l. hdepohl , b. mller , h .-
janka , a. marek and g. g. raffelt , phys .
* 104 * ( 2010 ) 251101 ; ( e ) ibid .
* 105 * ( 2010 ) 249901 .
t. totani , k. sato , h. e. dalhed and j. r. wilson , astrophys .
j. * 496 * ( 1998 ) 216 . m. t. keil , g. g. raffelt and h .- t .
janka , astrophys .
j. * 590 * ( 2003 ) 971 .
a. burrows and j. m. lattimer , astrophys .
j. * 307 * ( 1986 ) 178 . w. keil and h .-
janka , astron .
astrophys .
* 296 * ( 1995 ) 145 .
h. suzuki , numer .
astrophys .
japan * 2 * ( 1991 ) 267 ; frontiers of neutrino astrophysics , ed . by h. suzuki and k. nakamura ( univ .
acad . press , tokyo , 1993 ) , p. 219 .
j. a. pons , s. reddy , m. prakash , j. m. lattimer and j. a. miralles , astrophys .
j. * 513 * ( 1999 ) 780 . g. g. raffelt , astrophys .
j. * 561 * ( 2001 ) 890 .
r. buras , m. rampp , h .- t . janka and k. kifonidis , astron .
astrophys .
* 447 * ( 2006 ) 1049 .
n. panagia , `` distance to sn 1987 a and the lmc , '' in :
_ new views of the magellanic clouds _ , iau symposium no . 190 , ed . by y .- h .
chu , n. suntzeff , j. hesser and d. bohlender , p. 549 .
a. gould and o. uza , astrophys .
j. * 494 * ( 1998 ) 118 . k. hirata et al .
( kamiokande - ii collaboration ) , phys .
* 58 * ( 1987 ) 1490 .
k. hirata et al .
( kamiokande - ii collaboration ) , phys .
d * 38 * ( 1988 ) 448 .
r. m. bionta et al .
( imb collaboration ) , phys .
* 58 * ( 1987 ) 1494 .
c. b. bratton et al .
( imb collaboration ) , phys .
d * 37 * ( 1988 ) 3361 .
e. n. alekseev , l. n. alekseeva , v. i. volchenko and i. v. krivosheina , pisma zh .
* 45 * ( 1987 ) 461 [ jetp lett .
* 45 * ( 1987 ) 589 ] .
e. n. alekseev , l. n. alekseeva , i. v. krivosheina and v. i. volchenko , phys .
b * 205 * ( 1988 ) 209 .
v. l. dadykin et al .
, pisma zh .
* 45 * ( 1987 ) 464 [ jetp lett .
* 45 * ( 1987 ) 593 ] .
m. aglietta et al . , europhys .
lett . * 3 * ( 1987 ) 1315 .
v. s. imshennik and o. g. ryazhskaya , pisma astron .
zhurnal , * 30 * ( 2004 ) 17 [ astron
. lett . * 30 * ( 2004 ) 14 ] .
m. koshiba , phys .
* 220 * ( 1992 ) 229 .
a. k. mann , _ shadow of a star : the neutrino story of supernova 1987a _ ( freeman , 1997 ) .
b. jegerlehner , f. neubig and g. raffelt , phys .
d * 54 * ( 1996 ) 1194 .
t. j. loredo and d. q. lamb , phys .
d * 65 * ( 2002 ) 063002 .
a. mirizzi and g. g. raffelt , phys .
d * 72 * ( 2005 ) 063001 .
g. pagliaroli , f. vissani , m. l. costantini and a. ianni , astropart .
* 31 * ( 2009 ) 163 .
p. vogel and j. f. beacom , phys .
d * 60 * ( 1999 ) 053003 .
a. strumia and f. vissani , phys .
b * 564 * ( 2003 ) 42 .
k. scholberg , j. phys .
* 203 * ( 2010 ) 012079 .
p. antonioli et al .
, new j. phys .
* 6 * ( 2004 ) 114 .
k. scholberg , astron .
* 329 * ( 2008 ) 337 .
supernova early warning system ( snews ) , http://snews.bnl.gov/ c. pryor , c. e. roos and m. s. webster , astrophys . j. * 329 * ( 1988 ) 335 .
f. halzen , j. e. jacobsen and e. zas , phys .
d * 49 * ( 1994 ) 1758 and * 53 * ( 1996 ) 7359 .
a. s. dighe , m. t. keil and g. g. raffelt , jcap * 0306 * ( 2003 ) 005 .
r. abbasi et al .
( icecube collaboration ) , astron .
astrophys .
535 ( 2011 ) a109 .
t. lund , a. marek , c. lunardini , h .- t .
janka and g. raffelt , phys .
d * 82 * ( 2010 ) 063007 .
f. halzen and g. g. raffelt , phys .
d * 80 * ( 2009 ) 087301 .
g. pagliaroli , f. vissani , e. coccia and w. fulgione , phys .
* 103 * ( 2009 ) 031102 .
j. f. beacom and m. r. vagins , phys .
* 93 * ( 2004 ) 171101 .
h. watanabe et al .
( super - kamiokande collaboration ) , astropart .
* 31 * ( 2009 ) 320 .
m. apollonio et al .
( chooz collaboration ) , phys .
d * 61 * ( 2000 ) 012001 ; eur .
j. c * 27 * ( 2003 ) 331 .
k. a. hochmuth , m. lindner and g. g. raffelt , phys .
d * 76 * ( 2007 ) 073001 .
m. wurm et al .
( lena collaboration ) , astropart .
* 35 * ( 2012 ) 685 .
j. f. beacom , w. m. farr and p. vogel , phys .
d * 66 * ( 2002 ) 033001 .
b. dasgupta and j. f. beacom , phys .
d * 83 * ( 2011 ) 113006 .
p. r. sala ( icarus collaboration ) , nucl .
* 217 * ( 2011 ) 186 .
i. gil botella and a. rubbia , jcap * 0408 * ( 2004 ) 001 .
d. autiero et al .
, jcap * 0711 * ( 2007 ) 011 .
j. engel , g. c. mclaughlin and c. volpe , phys .
d * 67 * ( 2003 ) 013005 .
c. a. duba et al .
, j. phys .
ser . * 136 * ( 2008 ) 042077 .
d. vnnen and c. volpe , jcap * 1110 * ( 2011 ) 019 .
s. van den bergh and r. d. mcclure , astrophys .
j. * 425 * ( 1994 ) 205 .
e. cappellaro , r. evans and m. turatto , astron .
astrophys .
* 351 * ( 1999 ) 459 .
r. diehl et al . , nature * 439 * ( 2006 ) 45 . for a review of supernova rates from various methods
see the supplementary material provided in the electronic version of the nature article and in astro - ph/0601015 .
r. g. strom , astron .
astrophys .
* 288 * ( 1994 ) l1 .
g. a. tammann , w. lffler and a. schrder , astrophys .
j. suppl .
* 92 * ( 1994 ) 487 .
e. n. alekseev and l. n. alekseeva , zh . eksp .
* 95 * ( 2002 ) 10 [ j. exp .
* 95 * ( 2002 ) 5 ] .
j. f. beacom and p. vogel , phys .
d * 60 * ( 1999 ) 033007 .
r. toms , d. semikoz , g. g. raffelt , m. kachelriess and a. s. dighe , phys .
d * 68 * ( 2003 ) 093013 .
a. mirizzi , g. g. raffelt and p. d. serpico , jcap * 0605 * ( 2006 ) 012 .
m. ahlers , p. mertsch and s. sarkar , phys .
d * 80 * ( 2009 ) 123017 .
a. odrzywolek , m. misiaszek and m. kutschera , astropart .
* 21 * ( 2004 ) 303 .
m. d. kistler , h. yksel , s. ando , j. f. beacom and y. suzuki , phys .
d * 83 * ( 2011 ) 123008 .
m. kowalski `` detecting extragalactic sne at south pole , '' talk at taup 2011 ( munich 59 sept .
2011 ) , http://taup2011.mpp.mpg.de j. f. beacom , ann .
nucl . part .
* 60 * ( 2010 ) 439 .
s. horiuchi , j. f. beacom and e. dwek , phys .
d * 79 * ( 2009 ) 083013 .
t. bays et al .
( super - kamiokande collaboration ) , phys .
d * 85 * ( 2012 ) 052007 .
d. n. schramm , comments nucl .
* 17 * ( 1987 ) 239 .
g. t. zatsepin , pisma zh .
* 8 * ( 1968 ) 333 [ jetp lett .
* 8 * ( 1968 ) 205 ] .
t. j. loredo and d. q. lamb , annals n. y. acad .
* 571 * ( 1989 ) 601 .
p. j. kernan and l. m. krauss , nucl .
b * 437 * ( 1995 ) 243 .
j. f. beacom and p. vogel , phys .
d * 58 * ( 1998 ) 053010 .
e. nardi and j. i. zuluaga , nucl .
b * 731 * ( 2005 ) 140 .
k. n. abazajian et al . , astropart .
* 35 * ( 2011 ) 177 .
g. barbiellini and g. cocconi , nature * 329 * ( 1987 ) 21 .
j. n. bahcall , _ neutrino astrophysics _
( cambridge university press , 1989 ) .
m. j. longo , phys .
d * 36 * ( 1987 ) 3276 .
l. stodolsky , phys .
b * 201 * ( 1988 ) 353 .
t. adam et al .
( opera collaboration ) , arxiv:1109.4897 .
m. j. longo , phys .
lett . * 60 * ( 1988 ) 173 . l. m. krauss and s. tremaine , phys .
lett . * 60 * ( 1988 ) 176 .
r. f. sawyer , d. j. scalapino and a. soni , `` the neutrino pulse from a newly born neuton star '' , proc .
neutrino 1979 , bergen , norway , 1822 june 1979 , vol . 2 ,
g. raffelt and d. seckel , phys .
lett . * 60 * ( 1988 ) 1793 .
m. s. turner , phys .
lett . * 60 * ( 1988 ) 1797 .
r. mayle , j. r. wilson , j. r. ellis , k. a. olive , d. n. schramm and g. steigman , phys .
b * 203 * ( 1988 ) 188 ; phys .
b * 219 * ( 1989 ) 515 .
s. cullen and m. perelstein , phys .
* 83 * ( 1999 ) 268 . c. hanhart , d. r. phillips , s. reddy and m. j. savage , nucl .
b * 595 * ( 2001 ) 335 . c. hanhart ,
j. a. pons , d. r. phillips and s. reddy , phys .
b * 509 * ( 2001 ) 1 .
s. hannestad and g. g. raffelt , phys .
d * 67 * ( 2003 ) 125008 ; ( e ) ibid .
* 69 * ( 2004 ) 029901 .
h. k. dreiner , c. hanhart , u. langenfeld and d. r. phillips , phys .
d * 68 * ( 2003 ) 055004 .
p. fayet , d. hooper and g. sigl , phys .
* 96 * ( 2006 ) 211302 h. davoudiasl , phys .
* 99 * ( 2007 ) 141301 .
s. hannestad , g. raffelt and y. y. y. wong , phys .
d * 76 * ( 2007 ) 121701 .
s. dutta and a. goyal , jcap * 0803 * ( 2008 ) 027 . c. biggio , m. blennow and e. fernandez - martinez , jhep * 0908 * ( 2009 ) 090 .
p. s. amanik and g. m. fuller , phys .
d * 75 * ( 2007 ) 083008 .
o. lychkovskiy , s. blinnikov and m. vysotsky , eur .
j. c * 67 * ( 2010 ) 213 a. s. dighe and a. yu . smirnov , phys .
d * 62 * ( 2000 ) 033007 .
a. dighe , nucl .
* 143 * ( 2005 ) 449 .
a. s. dighe , m. t. keil and g. g. raffelt , jcap * 0306 * ( 2003 ) 006 .
d. serpico , s. chakraborty , t. fischer , l. hdepohl , h .-
janka and a. mirizzi , phys .
d * 85 * ( 2012 ) 085031 .
r. c. schirato and g. m. fuller , arxiv : astro - ph/0205390 .
r. toms , m. kachelriess , g. raffelt , a. dighe , h .-
janka and l. scheck , jcap * 0409 * ( 2004 ) 015 .
g. l. fogli , e. lisi , a. mirizzi and d. montanino , jcap * 0504 * ( 2005 ) 002 .
b. dasgupta and a. dighe , phys .
d * 75 * ( 2007 ) 093002 .
s. choubey , n. p. harries and g. g. ross , phys .
d * 74 * ( 2006 ) 053010 .
a. friedland and a. gruzinov , arxiv : astro - ph/0607244 .
g. l. fogli , e. lisi , a. mirizzi and d. montanino , jcap * 0606 * ( 2006 ) 012 .
j. pantaleone , phys .
b * 287 * ( 1992 ) 128 .
s. samuel , phys .
d * 48 * ( 1993 ) 1462 .
s. samuel , phys .
d * 53 * ( 1996 ) 5382 .
s. pastor , g. g. raffelt and d. v. semikoz , phys .
d * 65 * ( 2002 ) 053011 .
r. f. sawyer , phys .
d * 72 * ( 2005 ) 045003 .
a. d. dolgov , s. h. hansen , s. pastor , s. t. petcov , g. g. raffelt and d. v. semikoz , nucl .
b * 632 * ( 2002 ) 363 .
y. y. y. wong , phys .
d * 66 * ( 2002 ) 025015 .
k. n. abazajian , j. f. beacom and n. f. bell , phys .
d * 66 * ( 2002 ) 013008 .
s. pastor , t. pinto and g. g. raffelt , phys .
* 102 * ( 2009 ) 241302 .
g. mangano , g. miele , s. pastor , o. pisanti and s. sarikas , jcap * 1103 * ( 2011 ) 035 ; phys .
b * 708 * ( 2012 ) 1 .
h. duan , g. m. fuller and y .- z .
qian , phys .
d * 74 * ( 2006 ) 123004 .
h. duan , g. m. fuller , j. carlson and y .- z .
qian , phys .
d * 74 * ( 2006 ) 105014 .
h. duan , g. m. fuller and y .- z .
qian , ann .
nucl . part .
* 60 * ( 2010 ) 569 .
g. g. raffelt and a. yu . smirnov , phys .
d * 76 * ( 2007 ) 081301 ; ( e ) ibid .
d * 77 * ( 2008 ) 029903 .
a. esteban - pretel , a. mirizzi , s. pastor , r. toms , g. g. raffelt , p. d. serpico and g. sigl , phys .
d * 78 * ( 2008 ) 085012 .
s. chakraborty , t. fischer , a. mirizzi , n. saviano and r. toms , phys .
d * 84 * ( 2011 ) 025002 ; phys .
lett . * 107 * ( 2011 ) 151101 .
s. hannestad , g. raffelt , g. sigl and y. y. y. wong , phys .
d * 74 * ( 2006 ) 105010 ; ( e ) ibid .
* 76 * ( 2007 ) 029901 .
h. duan , g. m. fuller , j. carlson and y .- z .
qian , phys .
d * 75 * ( 2007 ) 125005 .
r. f. sawyer , phys .
d * 79 * ( 2009 ) 105003 .
a. banerjee , a. dighe and g. raffelt , phys .
d * 84 * ( 2011 ) 053013 .
s. sarikas and g. raffelt , proc .
hanse 2011 , arxiv:1110.5572 .
s. sarikas , g. g. raffelt , l. hdepohl and h .-
janka , phys .
* 108 * ( 2012 ) 061101 .
s. sarikas , i. tamborra , g. raffelt , l. hdepohl and h .-
janka , phys .
d , in press ( 2012 ) , arxiv:1204.0971 .
h. duan , g. m. fuller , j. carlson and y .- z .
qian , phys .
* 100 * ( 2008 ) 021101 .
b. dasgupta , a. dighe , a. mirizzi and g. g. raffelt , phys .
d * 77 * ( 2008 ) 113007 .
j. f. cherry , m. r. wu , j. carlson , h. duan , g. m. fuller and y .- z .
qian , phys .
d * 84 * ( 2011 ) 105034 .
b. dasgupta , a. dighe , g. g. raffelt and a. yu . smirnov , phys .
* 103 * ( 2009 ) 051105 .
g. g. raffelt , phys .
d * 78 * ( 2008 ) 125015 .
h. duan and a. friedland , phys .
* 106 * ( 2011 ) 091101 .
a. b. balantekin and y. pehlivan , j. phys .
g * 34 * ( 2007 ) 47 .
g. g. raffelt and i. tamborra , phys .
d * 82 * ( 2010 ) 125004 .
g. g. raffelt , phys .
d * 83 * ( 2011 ) 105022 .
y. pehlivan , a. b. balantekin , t. kajino and t. yoshida , phys .
d * 84 * ( 2011 ) 065008 .
e. a. yuzbashyan , phys .
b * 78 * ( 2008 ) 184507 . | the role of neutrinos in stars is introduced for students with little prior astrophysical exposure .
we begin with neutrinos as an energy - loss channel in ordinary stars and conversely , how stars provide information on neutrinos and possible other low - mass particles .
next we turn to the sun as a measurable source of neutrinos and other particles .
finally we discuss supernova ( sn ) neutrinos , the sn 1987a measurements , and the quest for a high - statistics neutrino measurement from the next nearby sn . we also touch on the subject of neutrino oscillations in the high - density sn context . |
since early human history , centralization has been a major competitive advantage .
societies with centralized governance were able to develop more advanced technology , accumulate more resources and increase their population faster @xcite .
as societies evolved , the negative effects of centralization of power were revealed : corruption , inequality , preservation of the status quo and abuse of power .
as it turns out , some ` separation of powers ' @xcite is necessary . in modern times
, we strive to find a balance between the models , maximizing output and efficiency with centralized control , guarded by checks and balances of decentralized governance .
the original narrative of the web is one of radical decentralization and freedom@xcite . during the last decade ,
the web s incredible growth was coupled with increased centralization .
few large companies now own important junctures of the web , and consequently a lot of the data created on the web .
the lack of transparency and control over these organizations reveals the negative aspects of centralization once again : manipulation @xcite , surveillance @xcite , and frequent data breaches @xcite .
bitcoin @xcite and other blockchains @xcite ( e.g. , ethereum ) promise a new future .
internet applications can now be built with a decentralized architecture , where no single party has absolute power and control .
the public nature of the blockchain guarantees transparency over how applications work and leaves an irrefutable record of activities , providing strong incentives for honest behavior .
bitcoin the currency was the first such application , initiating a new paradigm to the web . the intense verification and public nature of the blockchain limits potential use cases , however .
modern applications use huge amounts of data , and run extensive analysis on that data .
this restriction means that only ` fiduciary code ' can run on the blockchain @xcite .
the problem is , much of the most sensitive parts of modern applications require heavy processing on private data . in their current design
, blockchains can not handle privacy at all .
furthermore , they are not well - suited for heavy computations .
their public nature means private data would flow through every full node on the blockchain , fully exposed .
there is a strange contradiction in this setup .
the most sensitive , private data can only be stored and processed in the centralized , less transparent and insecure model .
we have seen this paradigm lead to catastrophic data leaks and the systematic lack of privacy we are currently forced to accept in our online lives .
enigma is a decentralized computation platform with guaranteed privacy .
our goal is to enable developers to build privacy by design , end - to - end decentralized applications , without a trusted third party .
* enigma is private*. using _ secure multi - party computation _ ( _ smpc _ or _ mpc _ ) , data queries are computed in a distributed way , without a trusted third party .
data is split between different nodes , and they compute functions together without leaking information to other nodes .
specifically , no single party ever has access to data in its entirety ; instead , every party has a meaningless ( i.e. , seemingly random ) piece of it .
* enigma is scalable*. unlike blockchains , computations and data storage are not replicated by every node in the network . only a small subset perform each computation over different parts of the data .
the decreased redundancy in storage and computations enables more demanding computations .
the key new utility enigma brings to the table is the ability to run computations on data , without having access to the raw data itself .
for example , a group of people can provide access to their salary , and together compute the average wage of the group .
each participant learns their relative position in the group , but learns nothing about other members salaries .
it should be made clear that this is only a motivating example . in practice
, any program can be securely evaluated while maintaining the inputs a secret .
today , sharing data is an irreversible process ; once it is sent , there is no way to take it back or limit how it is used . allowing access to data for secure computations is reversible and controllable , since no one but the original data owner(s ) ever see the raw data .
this presents a fundamental change in current approaches to data analysis .
enigma is designed to connect to an existing blockchain and off - load private and intensive computations to an off - chain network .
all transactions are facilitated by the blockchain , which enforces access - control based on digital signatures and programmable permissions .
code is executed both on the blockchain ( public parts ) and on enigma ( private or computationally intensive parts ) .
enigma s execution ensures both _ privacy _ and _ correctness _ , whereas a blockchain alone can only ensure the latter .
proofs of correct execution are stored on the blockchain and can be audited .
we supply a scripting language for designing end - to - end decentralized applications using _ private contracts _ , which are a more powerful variation of _ smart contracts _ that can handle private information ( i.e. , their state is not strictly public ) .
the scripting language is also turing - complete , but this is not as important as its scalability .
code execution in blockchains is decentralized but not distributed , so every node redundantly executes the same code and maintains the same public state . in enigma , the computational work is efficiently distributed across the network .
an interpreter breaks down the execution of a private contract , as is illustrated in figure [ fig : code_exec ] , resulting in improved run - time , while maintaining both privacy and verifiability .
= [ draw , text width=5em , text centered , minimum height=2.5em ] = [ sensor , text width=6em , minimum height=12em , rounded corners ] at ( 6,2.7 ) ( x0 ) [ naveqs ] blockchain ; at ( 9,2.7 ) ( x1 ) [ naveqs ] enigma ; at ( 2,1 ) @xmath0 ; \(r ) at ( 2,4 ) @xmath1 ; ( r.north west)(r.three west ) ; ( r.three east)(r.south east ) ; ( @xmath2 ) to[out=-180,in=240 ] + + ( 0,1.5 ) to [ out=40,in=120]node[above , midway]public(x0 ) ; ( @xmath3 ) to [ out=-60,in=-120]node[below , midway]private(x1 ) ; the off - chain network solves the following issues that blockchain technology alone can not handle : 1 .
* storage*. blockchains are not general - purpose databases .
enigma has a decentralized off - chain _ distributed hash - table _ ( or _ dht _ ) that is accessible through the blockchain , which stores references to the data but not the data themselves .
private data should be encrypted on the client - side before storage and access - control protocols are programmed into the blockchain .
enigma provides simple apis for these tasks in the scripting language .
2 . * privacy - enforcing computation*. enigma s network can execute code without leaking the raw data to any of the nodes , while ensuring correct execution .
this is key in replacing current centralized solutions and trusted overlay networks that process sensitive business logic in a way that negates the benefits of a blockchain .
the computational model is described in detail in section [ sec : computation ] .
* heavy processing*. even when privacy is not a concern , the blockchain can not scale to clearing many complex transactions .
the same off - chain computational network is used to run heavy publicly verifiable computations that are broadcast through the blockchain .
off - chain nodes construct a distributed database .
each node has a distinct view of shares and encrypted data so that the computation process is guaranteed to be privacy - preserving and fault tolerant .
it is also possible to store large public data ( e.g. , files ) unencrypted and link them to the blockchain .
figure [ fig : node_view ] illustrates the database view of a single node .
( rect ) at ( 2,4)shares ; on a network level , the distributed storage is based on a modified kademlia dht protocol @xcite with added persistence and secure point - to - point channels , simulated using a broadcast channel and public - key encryption .
this protocol assists in distributing the shares in an efficient manner . when storing shares , the original kademlia distance metric is modified to take into account the preferential probability of a node .
in this section , we describe enigma s computational model . we begin with a brief introduction to publicly verifiable secure mpc based on state - of - the - art advances in cryptography .
then , we describe a series of performance improvements to secure mpc that makes the technology practical even when the network is large : hierarchical secure mpc , network reduction and adaptable circuits . to use enigma , developers write high - level code , where public parts are executed on the blockchain and private parts are run off - chain , on enigma s platform .
we call these _ private contracts _ , since they are smart contracts that can handle private information .
yao introduced the first solution to secure two - party computation protocols in 1982 @xcite . in the same paper
, yao suggested the popular _ millionaire problem _ , describing two millionaires interested in knowing which one of them is richer , without revealing their actual net worth . in the decades since
, the two - party problem has been generalized to mpc , which refers to the @xmath4-party case . for general - purpose mpc ,
in which every protocol could be composed from a circuit of elementary mpc gates , two major approaches have been developed over the years : yao s garbaled ( boolean ) circuits @xcite and mpc based on secret sharing .
the latter has been more commonly used in production systems ( e.g. , @xcite and @xcite ) and is our focus as well .
a threshold cryptosystem is defined by @xmath5 , where @xmath4 is the number of parties and @xmath6 is the minimal number of parties required to decrypt a secret encrypted with threshold encryption .
secret sharing is an example of a threshold cryptosystem , where a secret @xmath7 is divided among @xmath4 , s.t .
at least @xmath6 are required to reconstruct @xmath7 .
any subset of @xmath8 parties can not learn anything about the secret . a _ linear secret - sharing scheme _ ( or _ lsss _ )
partitions a secret to shares such that the shares are a linear combination of the secret . _
shamir s secret sharing _ ( or _ sss _ ) is an example of a lsss , which uses polynomial interpolation and is secure under a finite field @xmath9 @xcite . specifically , to share a secret @xmath7
, we select a random @xmath8 degree polynomial @xmath10 @xmath11 the shares
are then given by @xmath12_{p_i } = q(i).\ ] ] then , given any @xmath6 shares , @xmath10 could be trivially reconstructed using lagrange interpolation and the secret @xmath7 recovered using @xmath13 . since sss is linear , it is also additively homomorphic , so addition and multiplication by a scalar operations could be performed directly on the shares without interaction . formally
@xmath14_{p_i } \}_{i \in n}^{t+1}),\\ s_1 + s_2 = reconstruct ( \ { [ s_1]_{p_i } + [ s_2]_{p_i } \}_{i \in n}^{t+1}).\end{aligned}\ ] ] multiplication of two secrets @xmath15 and @xmath16 is somewhat more involved .
if each party would attempt to locally compute the product of two secrets , they would collectively obtain a polynomial of degree @xmath17 , requiring a polynomial reduction step ( @xmath18 ) .
for an information theoretic setting , this result adds an honest majority constraint ( i.e. , @xmath19 ) on privacy and correctness .
if we bound the adversary s computational power , both properties are assured for any number of corrupted parties , but fairness and deciding on an output still requires an honest majority @xcite . as to performance ,
a re - sharing step is required in the degree reduction step , implying all parties must interact with all other parties ( @xmath20 communications ) .
this makes mpc impractical for anything larger than a small constant number of parties @xmath4 .
while optimized solutions exist for improving the amortized complexity , they are based on assumptions that restrict functionality in practice .
conversely , we describe a generic solution to this problem for any functionality in section [ sec : hmpc ] , which makes secure mpc feasible for arbitrarily large networks . note that with secure addition and multiplication protocols , we can construct a circuit for any arithmetic function . for turing - completeness
, we need to handle control flow as well . for conditional statements involving secret values
, this means evaluating both branches and for dynamic loops we add randomness to the execution .
our general - purpose mpc interpreter is based on these core concepts and other optimizations presented throughout the paper .
so far we have discussed the _ privacy _ property .
_ liveness _ , namely that computations will terminate and the system will make progress , is also implied given an honest majority , since it is all that is needed for reconstruction of intermediate and output values .
however , in the current framework there are no guarantees about the _ correctness _ of the output ; party @xmath21 could send an invalid result throughout the computation process which may invalidate the output . while bgw @xcite presented an information - theoretic solution to verifiable mpc , its practical complexity could be as bad as @xmath22 , given a naive implementation @xcite .
therefore , our goal is to design an mpc framework that is secure against malicious adversaries but has the same complexity of the semi - honest setting ( @xmath20 ) .
later , we would further optimize this as well .
very recently , baum et al . developed a publicly auditable secure mpc system that ensures correctness , even when all computing nodes are covertly malicious , or all but a single node are actively malicious @xcite .
their state - of - the - art results are based on a variation of spdz ( pronounced _ speedz _ ) @xcite and depend on a public append - only bulletin board , which stores the trail of each computation .
this allows any auditing party to check the output is correct by comparing it to the public ledger s trail of proofs .
our system uses the blockchain as the bulletin board , thus our overall security is reduced to that of the hosting blockchain . *
spdz*. a protocol secure against malicious adversaries ( with dishonest majority ) , providing correctness guarantees for mpc .
in essence , the protocol is comprised of an expensive offline ( pre - processing ) step that uses _ somewhat homomorphic encryption _ ( or _ she _ ) to generate shared randomness .
then , in the online stage , the computation is similar to the passive case and there is no expensive public - key cryptography involved . in the online stage , every share is represented by the additive share and its mac , as follows : @xmath23_{p_i } , [ \gamma(s)]_{p_i}),\ s.t.\ \gamma(s ) = \alpha s,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath24 is a fixed secret shared mac key and @xmath25 denotes the modified secret sharing scheme which is also additively homomorphic . @xmath25-sharing works without opening the shares of the global mac key @xmath24 , so it can be reused .
as before , multiplication is more involved .
multiplication consumes @xmath26 triplets , s.t .
@xmath27 , that are generated in the pre - processing step ( many such triplets are generated ) . then , given two secrets @xmath15 and @xmath16 , that are shared using @xmath25-sharing , secret - sharing the product @xmath28 is achieved by consuming a triplet as follows
@xmath29 as mentioned , generating the triplets is an expensive process based on she . the full protocol including security proofs is found in @xcite .
verification is achieved by solving
@xmath30 where @xmath7 is the secret that , without loss of generality , can be the reconstructed result of any secure computation .
intuitively , this is just a comparison of the computation over the mac against the computed result times the secret mac key .
the reason we are not performing actual comparison is so that @xmath24 remains secret and can be reused .
we can now see that @xmath25-sharing has similar properties to sss , namely it is additively homomorphic and requires a re - sharing round for multiplication ( @xmath20 communication complexity ) , but in addition
it ensures correctness against up to @xmath31 active adversaries . the offline round
is easily amortized over many computations and can be computed in parallel while other computations are running , so it does not significantly affect the overall efficiency . * publicly verifiable spdz*. in the publicly verifiable case ,
macs and commitments are stored on the blockchain , therefore making the scheme secure even if all @xmath4 computing parties are malicious .
we follow the representation of @xcite , which defines @xmath32-sharing , as
@xmath33 where @xmath7 is the secret , @xmath34 is a random value and @xmath35 is the pedersen commitment , with @xmath36 serving as generators . @xmath32-sharing preserves additive homomorphic properties , and with a slightly modified multiplication protocol we can re - use the same idea of generating triplets ( @xmath37 ) offline .
a key observation here is that the nodes only need to compute over @xmath25-shared values and not over the commitments .
these are stored on the blockchain and could later be addressed by any public validator that has the output . even if a single node has broken its commitment , it would be evident to the auditor .
information - theoretic results show that secure mpc protocols require each computing node to interact with all other nodes ( @xmath20 communication complexity ) and a constant number of rounds . in the case of a lsss
, this computational complexity applies to every multiplication operation , whereas addition operations can be computed in parallel , without intercommunication .
as previously mentioned , secure addition and multiplication protocols are sufficient to construct a general - purpose interpreter that securely evaluates any code @xcite .
cohen et al @xcite recently proposed a method of simulating an @xmath4-party secure protocol using a log - depth formula of constant - size mpc gates , as illustrated in figure [ fig : builder2 ] .
we extend their result to lsss and are able to reduce the communication - complexity of multiplication from quadratic to linear , at the cost of increased computation complexity , which is parallelized .
figure [ fig : mpc_sim2 ] illustrates how vanilla mpc is limited by the number of parties , while our implementation scales up to arbitrarily large networks . to maximize the computational power of the network ,
we introduce a network reduction technique , where a random subset of the entire network is selected to perform a computation .
the random process preferentially selects nodes based on load - balancing requirements and accumulated reputation , as is measured by their publicly validated actions .
this ensures that the network is fully utilized at any given point .
code evaluated in our system is guaranteed not to leak any information unless a dishonest majority colludes ( @xmath38 ) .
this is true for the inputs , as well as any interim variables computed while the code is evaluated .
an observant reader would notice that as a function is evaluated from inputs to outputs , the interim results generally become less descriptive and more aggregative . for simple functions or functions involving very few inputs , this may not hold true , but since these functions are fast to compute -
no additional steps are needed .
however , for computationally expensive functions , involving many lines of code and a large number of inputs , we can dynamically reduce the number computing nodes as we progress , instead of having a fixed @xmath4 for the entire function evaluation process .
specifically , we design a feed - forward network ( figure [ fig : ffnet ] ) that propagates results from inputs to outputs . the original code is reorganized so that we process addition gates on the inputs first , followed by processing multiplication gates .
the interim results are then secret - shared with @xmath39 nodes , and the process is repeated recursively .
= [ < -,shorten < = 1pt ] = [ circle , fill = black!25,minimum size=17pt , inner sep=0pt ] = [ neuron , fill = green!50 ] ; = [ neuron , fill = red!50 ] ;
= [ neuron , fill = blue!50 ] ; = [ text width=4em , text centered ] / in 1, ... ,5 ( i- ) at ( 0,- ) ; / in 1, ... ,5 node[hidden neuron ] ( h- ) at ( , -cm ) ; / in 1, ... ,3 node[input neuron ] ( h1- ) at ( 2*,-cm ) ; / in 1, ... ,3 node[hidden neuron ] ( h2- ) at ( 3*,-cm ) ; \(o ) ; in 1, ... ,5 in 1, ... ,5 ( i- ) edge ( h- ) ; in 1, ... ,5 in 1, ... ,3 ( h- ) edge ( h1- ) ; in 1, ... ,3 in 1, ... ,3 ( h1- ) edge ( h2- ) ; in 1, ... ,3 ( h2- ) edge ( o ) ; ( il ) addition layer@xmath40 ; ( hl ) mult .
layer@xmath40 ; ( hl1 ) addition layer@xmath41 ; ( hl2 ) mult .
layer@xmath41 ; ( ol ) output layer ; as previously mentioned , end - to - end decentralized apps are developed using _ private contracts _ , which are further partitioned to on - chain and off - chain execution .
off - chain code returns results privately , while sending correctness proofs to the blockchain . for simplicity , the scripting language is similar in syntax to well - known programming languages .
there are two major additions to the scripting language that require more detail .
developers should use the _ private _ keyword to specify private objects .
this automatically ensures that any computation involving those objects remains secure and private .
when working with private objects , the data themselves are not locally available , but rather a reference of them .
there are three distinct decentralized databases living in the system , each accessible through a global singleton dictionary . specifically 1 .
* public ledger*. the blockchain s public ledger can be accessed and manipulated using @xmath42 .
for example , @xmath43 \gets 1 $ ] would update key @xmath44 for all nodes .
since the ledger is completely public and append - only , the entire history is stored as well and ( read - only ) accessible using @xmath45 .
2 . * dht*. off - chain data are stored on the dht and accessible in the same way the public ledger is . by default
, data are encrypted locally before transmission and only the signing entity can request the data back . otherwise , using @xmath46 , where @xmath44 is the key
, @xmath47 is the value and @xmath48 is a predicate , namely
@xmath49 , sets @xmath47 to be accessible through @xmath44 if and only if @xmath48 is satisfied .
we supply several built - in predicates in the language such as limiting access to a list of public keys .
if encryption is turned off , the default predicate is @xmath50 , so the data are public but distributed off - chain .
* mpc*. syntactically , using mpc is equivalent to dht , but the underlying process differs . in particular , executing @xmath51 secret shares @xmath47 .
the shares are distributed to potential computing parties that store their shares in their local view .
now @xmath48 can be used to specify who can reference the data for computation using @xmath52 $ ] , without revealing @xmath47 . by default
, only the original dealer can ask for the raw data back by running @xmath53 , which similar to the sharing process , collects shares from the various parties and reconstructs the secret value locally .
in addition , any other entities belonging to the same shared identity can reference the data for computation . for details about shared identities see section [ sec : identities ] .
note that for simplicity , we addressed all keys in @xmath42 , @xmath54 and @xmath55 dictionaries as using a single namespace , whereas in practice finer granularity is available , so that they can be segmented to databases , tables , and finer hierarchies .
in this section we show how enigma interoperates with a blockchain .
specifically , we detail how complex identities are formed using digital signatures , which are automatically compatible with blockchains .
we then continue to describe in detail the core protocols linking enigma s off - chain storage and computation to a blockchain .
a recent survey paper divided blockchain - inspired technologies into two : fully decentralized permission - less ledgers ( e.g. , bitcoin , ethereum ) and semi - centralized permissioned ledgers ( e.g. , ripple ) @xcite . in the paper ,
the author argues that there is an inherent trade - off between having a pseudo - anonymous system , where no one is trusted and all information must remain public , and having a somewhat centralized system with trusted nodes that can verify true underlying identities . with an off - chain technology linked to a blockchain , this trade - off can be avoided while the network remains fully decentralized .
for this to work , we define an extended version of identities , one that captures _
shared identities _ across multiple entities and their semantic meaning .
formally , the pseudo - anonymous portion of a shared identity is a @xmath56-tuple @xmath57 where @xmath4 denotes the number of parties
. it should be clear that for @xmath58 we revert to the special pseudo - identity case . to complete our definition of shared identities , we incorporate the idea of meta - data .
meta - data encapsulates the underlying semantic meaning of an identity .
primarily , these include public access - control rules defined by the same predicates mentioned earlier , which the network uses to moderate access - control , along with any other public or private data that is relevant .
for example , alice may want to share with bob her height , but not her weight .
alternatively , she may not even want to tell bob her exact height , but will allow him to use her height in aggregate computations . in this case ,
alice and bob can establish a shared identity for this purpose .
alice invokes a private contract that shares her height using @xmath59 = alice\_height$ ] , which bob can reference for computations , without accessing alice s height value directly .
the default mpc predicate establishes that alice s pseudonym is the owner of the shared information and that bob has restricted access to it .
the predicate , shared identity s list of addresses and a reference to the data are stored on the blockchain and collectively define the public meta - data , or in other words - information related to the identity that is not sensitive but should be used to publicly verify access rights .
any additional meta - data that is private , or in other words that only alice , bob and perhaps several others should have access to could be securely stored off - chain using the dht .
it should now be clear how our system solves the need for trusted nodes .
as always , public transactions are validated through the blockchain . with shared identities and predicates governing access - control stored on the ledger , the blockchain can moderate access to any off - chain resources . for anything else involving private meta - data , the off - chain network can act as a trustless privacy - preserving verifier .
we now discuss the core protocols linking the blockchain to off - chain resources .
specifically , we elaborate on how identities are formed and stored on the ledger ; and how off - chain storage ( dht ) and computation ( mpc ) requests are routed through the blockchain , conditional on satisfying predicates .
protocol [ alg : shared_identity ] describes the process of creating a shared identity and protocol [ alg : check_policy ] implements the publicly - verifiable contract for satisfying predicates .
@xmath60 parties , @xmath61 ledger @xmath42 stores reference to the shared identity .
@xmath62 @xmath63 @xmath64 @xmath65 @xmath66 \gets a[p_i]$ ] @xmath67 * send * signed tx(m ) to the network + @xmath68 \gets acl$ ] @xmath69the requesting party signature , @xmath70 the shared identity s address , @xmath71 a predicate verifying if @xmath21 has sufficient access rights . @xmath72 . @xmath73
@xmath74 $ ] @xmath75 * return * @xmath7 storing and loading data for direct access via the dht are shown in protocol [ alg : data ] . for storing data ,
write permissions are examined with the given @xmath76 predicate .
the storing party can provide a custom predicate for verifying who can read the data .
this is the underlying process that is abstracted away using the @xmath54 singleton object in the scripting language .
@xmath69 , @xmath70 , @xmath77 ( data ) , @xmath78 a predicate for verifying future read access .
if successful , returns @xmath79 the pointer to the data ( predicate ) , or @xmath80 o.w .
@xmath81a_x = ( addr_p x)@xmath81l[a_x]q_read^(x)@xmath81dht[a_x ] x@xmath82a_x@xmath83@xmath84pk^(p_i)_sig@xmath85addr_p@xmath85a_x@xmath86x@xmath87@xmath88q_read^(x ) l[a_x]@xmath89 * return * @xmath90 $ ] * return * @xmath80 share and compute , illustrated in protocol [ alg : share ] , are the mpc equivalent of store and load protocols , since they enable processing .
internally , they store and load shares from the dht and allow working with references to the data while keeping the data secure .
@xmath69 , @xmath70 , @xmath77 ( data ) , @xmath91 reference for computation , @xmath92 predicate verifying computation rights . if successful , returns pointer to @xmath91 for future computation , or @xmath80 o.w .
@xmath93_p \gets vss(n , t)$ ] @xmath94 sample @xmath4 peers * send * @xmath93_p^{(peer)}$ ] to @xmath95 on a secure channel * return * @xmath96 @xmath69 , @xmath70 , @xmath97 reference data address , @xmath98 unsecure code to be rewritten as a secure protocol .
if successful , returns @xmath99 without revealing @xmath77 , or @xmath80 o.w .
@xmath100 @xmath101 generate secure computation protocol from @xmath98 * return * @xmath102 * return * @xmath80
since enigma is not a cryptocurrency or a blockchain , the incentive scheme is based on fees rather than mining rewards , where nodes are compensated for providing computational resources .
full nodes are required to provide a security deposit , making malicious behaviour punishable .
a possible attack on mpc protocols takes advantage of the lack of guaranteed fairness in the protocol . under certain conditions ,
a malicious party can learn the output and abort the protocol before other parties learn the output as well . while this attack , when carried out by a majority , can not be prevented , it can be penalized .
using bitcoin security deposits for punishing malicious nodes in mpc has been investigated by several scholars recently @xcite .
we use a similar model , and extend it to penalize other malicious behaviors such as breaking correctness , which is validated by the spdz protocol ( see section [ sec : comp_correct ] ) . to participate in the network , store data , perform computations and receive fees , every full - node must first submit a security deposit to a private contract . after each computation
is completed , a private contract verifies correctness and fairness were maintained .
if a node is found to lie about their outcome or aborts the computation prematurely , it loses the deposit which is split between the other honest nodes .
the computation is continued without the malicious node ( e.g. , by setting its share of the data to 0 ) .
every request in the network for storage , data retrieval , or computation has a fixed price , similar to the concept of ` gas ' in ethereum . unlike ethereum where every computation is run by every node , in enigma
different nodes execute different parts of each computation and need to be compensated according to their contribution , which is measured in rounds .
recall that every function is reduced to a circuit of addition and multiplication gates , each of which takes one or more rounds .
a node participating in a computation is paid the weighted sum of the number of rounds it contributed to and the operations it performed ( addition , multiplication ) .
since the platform is turing - complete the exact cost of a request can not always be pre - calculated .
therefore , once the computation is finalized , the cost of each request is deducted from an account balance each node maintains . a request will not go through unless the account balance is over a minimum threshold .
fees for data storage are market based and time limited
. the hosting contract is automatically renewed using the owner s account balance . if the balance is too low , access to the data will be restricted and unless additional funds are deposited , the data will be deleted within a certain amount of time .
direct consumer to business marketplace for data . with guaranteed privacy , autonomous control and increased security , consumers will sell access to their data . for example , a pharmaceutical company looking for patients for clinical trials can scan genomic databases for candidates .
the marketplace would eliminate tremendous amounts of friction , lower costs for customer acquisition and offer a new income stream for consumers .
many companies today store large amounts of customer data .
they use the data to provide personalized services , match individual preferences , target ads and offers , etc . with enigma , companies can use the data for the same purposes they do today , without actually storing or processing the data on their servers , removing security risks and assuring the privacy of their customers .
large organizations can use enigma to protect their data and trade secrets from corporate espionage and rogue employees .
employees can still use and analyze data for the benefit of the organization , but wont be able to steal any data .
productivity inside organizations would be improved since more people can have access to more data , and costs on security would be lower .
voice , face and fingerprint recognition stored and computed on enigma . only the user ever has access to these data .
policies for when and if additional keys are required can be set inside a private contract , unexposed to any potential attacker .
authenticating and securely storing identities in a fully anonymous , yet provably correct , fashion is trivial on enigma and requires as little as several lines of code .
the process is simple a user secret - shares her personal information required for authentication .
when the user logs in , an authenticating private contract is executed , validating the user and linking her real identity with a public pseudo - identity .
the process is completely trust - less and privacy - preserving . store and share data with third parties while maintaining control and ownership . set specific policies for each service with private contracts .
identity is truly protected since the decision to share data is always reversible - services have no access to raw data , all they can do is run secure computations on it . run a full - service crypto bank without exposing private internal details .
users can take loans , deposit cryptocurrencies or buy investment products with the autonomous control of the blockchain , without publicly revealing their financial situation .
votes on anything , from political elections to company board meetings , without exposing anything besides the final outcome .
not only is the privacy of each voter is maintained , even the actual vote - count can remain private .
for example , if the elections require any kind of majority vote , but no details about the distribution , a unanimous decision would be indistinguishable from one decided by a single vote . 1 .
decentralized private key generation
multiple enigma nodes locally create a segment of the key , whereas the full key is only ever assembled by the user .
no trail of evidence is left anywhere .
decentralized transaction signing transactions signed without ever exposing the private key or leaving a trail .
3 . decentralized controls - set spending limits , multi - sig , checklocktimeverify like controls , and more with a private script .
lock time , limits or number of required signatures are completely invisible to a potential attacker .
clark , joseph bonneau andrew miller jeremy , arvind narayanan joshua a. kroll edward , and w. felten .
`` sok : research perspectives and challenges for bitcoin and cryptocurrencies . '' , security and privacy ( sp ) , 2015 ieee symposium on .
ieee , 2015 .
ben - or , michael , shafi goldwasser , and avi wigderson .
`` completeness theorems for non - cryptographic fault - tolerant distributed computation .
'' proceedings of the twentieth annual acm symposium on theory of computing .
acm , 1988 . | a peer - to - peer network , enabling different parties to jointly store and run computations on data while keeping the data completely private .
enigma s computational model is based on a highly optimized version of secure multi - party computation , guaranteed by a verifiable secret - sharing scheme . for storage ,
we use a modified distributed hashtable for holding secret - shared data .
an external blockchain is utilized as the controller of the network , manages access control , identities and serves as a tamper - proof log of events .
security deposits and fees incentivize operation , correctness and fairness of the system .
similar to bitcoin , enigma removes the need for a trusted third party , enabling autonomous control of personal data . for the first time , users are able to share their data with cryptographic guarantees regarding their privacy . |
the resonance transitions of the most abundant species in the universe as well as the electronic transitions of the most abundant molecules are in the ultraviolet ( uv ) range of the spectrum . hence , access to the uv range is instrumental for progress in astrophysics @xcite .
the world space observatory - ultraviolet ( wso - uv ) space telescope will grant this access in the post - hubble space telescope era .
wso - uv is a 170 cm diameter primary telescope with an efficient ritchey - chrtien configuration that will be operational in the 20172027 time frame .
wso - uv is a russian - led mission and will be equipped with instrumentation for uv spectroscopy and imaging ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
. the imaging and slitless spectroscopy instrument ( issis ) will be a key part of the wso - uv instrumentation .
issis is the first uv imager to be flown to high earth orbit , above the earth geocorona .
therefore , the uv background will be dominated by the zodiacal contribution and the diffuse galactic background due to dust - scattered starlight @xcite .
the instrument has been designed to make full benefit of the heritage left by the galactic evolution explorer ( galex ) mission .
galex has surveyed about 80% of the sky at uv wavelengths , providing for the first time a nearly complete view of the uv universe @xcite .
however , galex spatial resolution was @xmath0 arcsec and had very moderate spectroscopic capabilities .
issis resolution will be @xmath1 arcsec .
the fine guiding system of the wso - uv telescope will guarantee a very high pointing stability ( better than 0.1 arcsec at 3@xmath2 ) .
moreover , issis will be equipped with gratings for slitless spectroscopy with spectral resolution 500 in the full 11503200 spectral range . in imaging mode , the issis effective area is about 10 times that of the galex imagers .
issis is designed to be an instrument for analysis of weak uv point sources or clumpy extended sources , especially those with well defined geometry .
uv imaging instruments have been often equipped with prisms or very low dispersion grisms .
the rapid decay of the resolution of prisms , such as the available in the solar blind channel of the advanced camera system , makes very difficult its use to map extended line emission at wavelengths above some 1350 .
as the transmittance of narrow band filters in the far uv is @xmath3% , integral - field low - resolution spectroscopy is the main mean to map nebular emission .
issis gratings will make feasible to use the powerful uv diagnostic tools to determine the location of dusty blobs and measure electron densities and temperatures . in this contribution , the science that has driven to issis design is described in section 2 .
issis design is presented in section 3 and its performance is described in section 4 .
issis planning and a brief summary are provided in the concluding section 5 .
the key scientific drivers of the wso - uv project are : * galaxy formation : the evolution of the star formation rate with redshift ( @xmath4 ) and the role of the intergalactic medium ( igm ) as a mass supply for star formation at moderate redshifts ( @xmath5 ) to study the characteristics of the diffuse baryonic content of the universe and its chemical evolution ; to determine , in particular , the baryonic content of the warm and hot igm and of damped lyman-@xmath6 systems ; and to investigate the role of starbursts in the chemical evolution of galaxies and the igm . * the formation and evolution of the milky way to estimate the energy inputs of the gas interacting with stars ; and to investigate the role of magnetic fields on star formation .
* the physics of accretion and outflows : the astronomical engines to study stars , black holes , interacting binaries and , in general , all those objects where mass accretion has a relevant impact in the system evolution ; and to analise the efficiency and time scales of these phenomena as well as the role of magnetic fields , radiation pressure and disk instabilities . * extrasolar planetary atmospheres and astrochemistry in presence of strong uv radiation fields to measure the uv radiation field from t tauri stars and its impact on the chemical evolution of young planetary disks and planetary atmospheres . for this purpose ,
the wso - uv telescope is equipped with the imaging instrument issis and the three wso - uv spectrographs ( wuvs ; see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) : * vuves , the far - uv high - resolution echelle spectrograph operating in the 11151760 range with resolution r@xmath750,000 . *
uves , the near - uv high - resolution echelle spectrograph in the 17403100 range with resolution r@xmath750,000 . *
lss , the long - slit spectrograph ( lss ) for low - resolution ( r@xmath8 ) long - slit spectroscopy .
the width of the slit will be 1 arcsec and the spatial resolution 0.5 arcsec .
lss and issis provide together a powerful tool to study extended sources since the high resolution imaging of issis complements the lss field selection capability .
both issis and lss have similar spectral resolutions .
the main topics that could be investigated with the instrument issis cover a wide range of astronomical issues : * solar system the atmospheres of the planets and satellites will be investigated as well as the impact of the solar radiation in their evolution . the connection between the solar system and extrasolar planetary systems , especially the magnetospheric processes in jupiter and saturn and the photoevaporative processes in comets , will be addressed .
* stars in the milky way the studies concerning our galaxy will focus on various subjects : stellar clusters , for which an uv atlas will be constructed and information about proper motions and stellar evolution will be obtained ; planetary nebulae , their proper motions , expansion and shocks , as well as the search for companions in infrared - bright asymptotic - giant - branch and proto - planetary nebulae @xcite ; protostellar jets and the mechanisms at work in these interesting phenomena @xcite ; the connection between magnetic activity and mass from solar - like stars to brown dwarfs and planets @xcite ; peculiar objects , such as some of the members of the @xmath2 orionis cluster , which will provide information about the complete spectrum of stellar masses in the uv from o stars down to t tauri stars and brown dwarfs @xcite ; absorption features in the stellar radiation by the atmospheres of transiting planets @xcite . * extragalactic astronomy
the issis instrument will be able to observe efficiently extragalactic objects : studies of gravitationally lensed quasars will reveal the intrinsic variability of the nuclear continuum , as well as the effects on the lensing galaxy @xcite . lyman-@xmath6
emitters up to redshift @xmath9 not visible from earth can be investigated with the wso - uv ; atlases of massive stars in galaxies of the local group will be built , together with a detailed inspection of their winds @xcite .
high - mass x - ray binary systems and their environments will be monitored @xcite .
the issis scientific requirements @xcite driving the design are the following : * high - resolution mapping of weak and nebulous sources such as microjets or gravitational lenses . * mapping of uv emission lines in extended emission nebulae ( h ii regions , supernovae remnants , planetary nebulae ) and jets ( from protostars or compact objects ) .
* efficient spectroscopy of weak sources such as brown dwarfs , micro jets or star forming galaxies at low redshift ( @xmath10 ) . * resolution of at least r@xmath7500 to study the absorption of stellar radiation by transiting planets , or to derive the terminal velocity of winds from o stars in the local group . * enhancement of the dynamic range with coronographs or masks in order to map the faint emission close to bright sources ( e.g. disks , jets , binary components ) . * short time resolution to track the evolution of instabilities in disks surrounding compact sources .
the instrument is located below the primary mirror and above the optical bench .
this location imposes additional constraints to the design , in terms of weight and size : a maximum of 61.5 kg on the optical bench is allowed , and the full instrument has to be fit within a flat cylinder of height 17 cm .
issis is fed by the central part of the beam but a pick - up mirror is required to fold the beam from the telescope adding one reflection ( see fig . 1 ) .
+ the final design is a compromise between the scientific requirements and the telescope / platform requirements @xcite .
2 shows the layout of the instrument .
issis has two channels for imaging and slitless spectroscopy : * the far ultraviolet ( fuv ) channel : working in the range 11501750 . *
the near ultraviolet ( nuv ) channel : covering wavelengths in the 18503200 interval .
both channels are equipped with photo - cathods with micro channel plate ( mcp ) amplifiers and cmos reading .
csi and cste photocathods have been selected for the fuv and nuv channels , respectively .
the use of mcps imposes strong constraints to the instrument capabilities , in particular on the field of view ( fov ) , barely 70 arcsec , and on the dynamical range .
there are ongoing studies to increase the dynamical range by using masks .
a set of neutral filters has been included to be able to satisfy the sensitivity requirements keeping the possibility to observe sources of moderate brightness .
slitless spectroscopy is not only an efficient mean to analyse multi - objects fields , but at the same time it acts as a narrow - band filtering technique .
the issis layout is arranged as a telephoto system , where positive elements are followed by negative elements , to enlarge the overall focal length .
a refocusing mechanism , located at the coupling stage between the telescope and issis , changes the distance between the intermediate image from the telescope and the first mirror of issis .
the operation modes are imaging , spectroscopy , and calibration , and are selected through a mode selection mechanism ( msm ; see fig .
3 ) : * imaging : the msm uses flat mirrors aligned to direct the light into the selected channel ( fuv or nuv ) .
the optical filters are accommodated on two wheels for each channel ; there are long - pass and narrow - band filters for specific investigations , as well as two neutral filters for each channel , to increase the dynamical range .
* spectroscopy : the beam is directed to the dispersive elements , which are reflection gratings located at the msm . in the nominal spectroscopy mode ,
the filter wheels are positioned into a hole configuration ( no filter ) .
the fuv diffraction grating has peak efficiency at 1400 and groove density of 450 lines / mm , while the nuv one has the peak at 2300 and 250 lines / mm .
* calibration : a shutter is used to block the light from the telescope , and the beam is directed to the calibration subsystem in order to take flat - field images on a pixel - to - pixel basis .
the calibration unit includes the lamp , optics and shutter .
the total throughput of issis includes the reflectivity of the t-170 m telescope and issis mirrors , the diffraction grating reflectivity and the sensitivity curves of the mcp detectors . the expected value for the imaging mode will be of about 1% at 1300 ( fuv ) and 7% at 2500 ( nuv ) ,
while for slitless spectroscopy the peaks will be about 0.4% at 1300 and 3% at 2500 ( fuv and nuv , respectively ) .
the radiometric sensitivity of issis can be evaluated using the exposure time calculator ( etc ) described below .
4 shows the throughput of the various components and the estimated total throughput in the whole wavelength range .
+ one of the issis key drivers is the mapping of extended sources ; this implies a proper sampling of the the point spread function ( psf ) .
the fine guiding sensors in the wso - uv should provide a spatial resolution of 0.1 arcsec at 3@xmath2 .
thus , the issis optical system modifies the t-170 m focal length to have this psf sampled by 23 pixels . according to optical simulations
, an asymmetrical psf is expected : this effect can not be avoided at uv wavelengths , since the optical quality is dominated by geometrical , non - symmetric aberrations .
the asymmetry in the psf is close to 17% and to 8% in the fuv and nuv channels , respectively .
5 displays an example of psf simulation on two different scales ; since the two channels share the same optics , a similar psf behaviour is expected for both of them .
the field of view is limited by the photocathods sensitive area in the mcp detectors and the spatial resolution to @xmath71.2 arcmin .
this field of view will permit direct imaging as well as obtaining images of extended nebular objects in the most prominent spectral lines in the slitless spectroscopy mode .
table [ tabissis ] shows a summary of the main issis characteristics .
.characteristics and performance of the issis instrument . [ cols="<,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tabissis ] astronomers can use the etc developed by the science team at universidad complutense de madrid to evaluate the exposure time needed for an observation , in order to achieve a desired signal - to - noise ratio ( s / n ) , and vice versa . the etc is a web - based application available through the project website at http://www.wso-uv.es .
it appears as a user - friendly interface with five main fields shown in fig . 6 , which are : * channel : to select among the two issis channels ( fuv and nuv ) .
* mode : for each channel the spectroscopy or imaging mode are allowed , and the user can select the optical filters on the wheels . *
input data : the input can be given as a continuum flux , setting its value , a spectral line ( absorption or emission ) , or a predefined distribution uploaded by the user as an ascii file .
other options are a blackbody distribution
( by choosing the effective temperature and magnitude ) , or an atlas9 atmosphere model by @xcite .
* parameters : in this section the user gives the desired s / n , and obtains the exposure time from the calculations , or vice versa .
the output window shows the calculated s / n or time , depending on the user s choice , and three plots showing the input spectral distribution , the system throughput ( telescope + issis optical system ) , and the final observed flux .
the user is allowed to see the results as a table , either in ascii or html format .
this article presents issis design at the end of phase b. the instrument will be a versatile tool to analyse the uv sky that complements the other instruments onboard the wso - uv space telescope .
issis flight model is due to be deliver to the russian federal space agency ( roscosmos ) in 2015 for final integration and assembly .
the wso - uv launch is foreseen for 2017 .
issis development is being funded by ministry of industry , tourism and commerce of spain .
we acknowledge the spanish science team for their support in this project .
we also would like to thank to the referees for their detailed revision of this manuscript .
the science team at universidad complutense de madrid acknowledges the financial support of the ministry of economy and competitivity through grants aya2008 - 06423-c03 - 01 and aya2011 - 29754-c03-c01 .
bianchi , l. , herald , j. , efremova , b. , et al .
galex catalogs of uv sources : statistical properties and sample science applications : hot white dwarfs in the milky way .
ap&ss 335 , 161 - 169 , 2011 .
blay , p. , rib , m. , negueruela , i. very peculiar wind from bd+53@xmath112790 , the optical counterpart to 4u 2206 + 54 .
ap&ss 320 , 145 - 148 , 2009 .
caballero , j.a . ,
martn , e.l . , zapatero osorio , m.r .
a&a 445 , 143 - 153 , 2006 .
castelli , f. , kurucz , r.l .
new grids of atlas9 model atmospheres .
arxiv astrophysics e - prints : astro - ph/0405087 , 2004 . also available in the proceedings of the iau symp .
no 210 ; modelling of stellar atmospheres , eds .
n. piskunov et al .
2003 , poster a20 ( cd - rom publication ) .
coffey , d. , bacciotti , f. , woitas , j. , et al .
rotation of jets from t - tauri stars : new clues from hst / stis observations .
ap&ss 292 , 553 - 558 , 2004 .
garca , m. , herrero , a. , najarro , f. wso and the winds of massive stars : the gate to the metal - poor local universe .
ap&ss 335 , 91 - 96 .
goicoechea , l.j .
, shalyapin , v.n .
time delays in the gravitationally lensed quasar h1413 + 117 ( cloverleaf ) .
apj 708 , 995 - 1001 .
gmez de castro , a.i . , robles , a. herbig - haro objects .
esa sp-1237 , 1999 .
gmez de castro , a.i .
, wamsteker , w. , barstow , m. , et al .
fundamental problems in astrophysics .
ap&ss 303 , 133 - 145 , 2006 .
gmez de castro , a.i .
, maz - apellniz , j. , rodrguez , p. , et al .
the imaging and slitless spectroscopy instrument for surveys ( issis ) for the world space observatory - ultraviolet ( wso - uv ) .
ap&ss 335 , 283 - 289 , 2011 .
gmez de castro , a.i .
, marcos - arenal , p. extended magnetospheres in pre - main - sequence evolution : from t tauri stars to the brown dwarf limit .
apj 749 , i d .
190 , 2012 .
gmez de castro , a.i .
, snchez doreste , n. , sestito , p. , et al .
scientific requirements for the imaging and slitless spectroscopy instrument for surveys ( issis ) for the world space observatory - ultraviolet ( wso - uv ) , editorial complutense , madrid , 2012a .
gmez de castro , a.i .
, snchez , n. , sestito , p. , et al .
issis : the imaging and slitless spectroscopy instrument for surveys in the world space observatory - ultraviolet telescope .
proceedings of the spie 8443 , i d . 84432w , 2012 .
guerrero , m.a .
, ramos - larios , g. , massa , d. a fuse view of winds from the central stars of planetary nebulae .
pasa 27 , 210 - 213 , 2010 .
guerrero , m.a . ,
ruiz , n. , hamann , w .- r . , et al .
rebirth of x - ray emission from the born - again planetary nebula a30 .
apj 755 , i d .
129 , 2012 .
lecavelier des etangs , a. , vidal - madjar , a. , mcconnell , j.c . , et al .
atmospheric escape from hot jupiters .
a&a 418 , l1-l4 , 2004 .
lecavelier des etangs , a. , ehrenreich , d. , vidal - madjar , a. , et al .
evaporation of the planet hd 189733b observed in h i lyman-@xmath6 .
a&a 514 , i d .
a72 , 2010 .
martin , c. , barlow , t. , barnhart , w. , et al . the galaxy evolution explorer .
proceedings of the spie 4854 , 336 - 350 , 2003 .
murthy , j. , henry , r.c . ,
sujatha , n.v .
mapping the diffuse ultraviolet sky with the galaxy evolution explorer .
apj 724 , 1389 - 1395 , 2010 .
sachkov , m. uv observations of sdb stars and prospects of wso - uv mission for such studies .
a&ss 329 , 261 - 266 , 2010 .
sachkov , m. , shustov , b. , gmez de castro , a.i . , et al .
adspr , this volume , 2013a .
sachkov , m. et al .
adspr , this volume , 2013b .
shustov , b. , sachkov , m. , gmez de castro , a.i . , et al .
world space observatory - ultraviolet among uv missions of the coming years .
ap&ss 335 , 273 - 282 , 2011 .
sujatha , n.v . ,
murthy , j. , karnataki , a. , et al .
galex observations of diffuse uv radiation at high spatial resolution from the sandage nebulosity .
apj 692 , 1333 - 1338 , 2009 . | the imaging and slitless spectroscopy instrument ( issis ) will be flown as part of the science instrumentation in the world space observatory - ultraviolet ( wso - uv ) .
issis will be the first uv imager to operate in a high earth orbit from a 2 m class space telescope . in this contribution , the science driving to issis design , as well as main characteristics of issis are presented .
ultraviolet : general ; space vehicles : instruments = 0.5 cm |
in order to test the theory of strong interactions ( qcd ) it has long been common practice to confront experimental data with perturbative predictions and then extract fundamental parameters such as the strong coupling @xmath2 . a consistent extraction of @xmath2 from different experiments and different observables points at the correctness of assuming qcd as the underlying theory .
since qcd is a theory where non - perturbative effects play a clear role one has to first question the feasibilty of such an approach and review the role of perturbative qcd ( pqcd ) . the fact that one can make perturbative predictions to any extent is indeed a blessing and in the case of many observables factorisation theorems allow the separation of pqcd from non - perturbative effects
. simply stated a factorisation theorem implies for an observable @xmath3 @xmath4 in the above we indicate by @xmath5 any set of phase space variables on which the observable may depend and by @xmath6 the hard momentum scale .
@xmath7 is typically a universal operator matrix element which contains non - perturbative information and whose value can be extracted from experiment and tabulated , for example a parton distribution measure . @xmath8 and @xmath9 are perturbative coefficients calculated by using feynman graphs to represent the hard process .
the dots indicate the limitations of the perturbative approach .
the dots in the brackets tell us that there are missing terms in the perturbative series since any perturbative predictions ( even resummed ones ) are missing higher order pieces which can not be easily computed . while this is just a technological limitation in the sense that higher order calculations become rapidly prohibitive computationally , it is a common misconception that given adequate computing power one could have a well defined perturbative answer that would be arbitrarily accurate . that this belief is ill - founded
can most easily be seen by examining a particular type of contribution ( renormalon graphs ) ( see for examples and further references @xcite ) which give that for large enough @xmath10 the coefficients @xmath11 diverge factorially .
this does not mean that the concept of a perturbative expansion is useless .
what it implies is that pqcd gives an asymptotic approximation to the observable @xmath3 .
the error made in truncating the perturbative expansion is of the order of the first omitted term
. therefore one should carry out the perturbative expansion till the smallest term is reached . the optimal error which is of
the order of this smallest term is thus an unvoidable inherent ambiguity in the perturbative expansion and one finds @xmath12 where @xmath13 and @xmath14 depend on the observable and @xmath15 represents the uncertainty of the perturbative estimate .
the coefficient @xmath13 may contain dependence on one or more phase space variables on which @xmath3 depends . also in eq .
( 1 ) there are dots to indicate that the simple factorisation may not be correct at some level , e.g higher twist .
these contributions are also typically power behaved and the expectation is that in order to obtain an unambigous answer the ambiguity of the perturbative ( pt ) part is cancelled by an ambiguity in the definition of the non - perturbative ( np ) higher twist operators . assuming
further that the size of the ambiguity is proportional to value of np terms ( condensates ) one can use the ambiguity in the pt piece to model np effects which are of a power law type . in other words where there is a large power behaved ambiguity in the pt series it can be treated as a signal that np effects are damaging in proportion .
this assumption is known as ultraviolet dominance of higher twist .
having arrived at the notion that the ambiguity of the perturbative expansion is relevant to the study of power corrections , one is still faced with the task of computing it and comapring with experimental data .
this is conveniently done in the framework of the dispersive approach we shall next discuss .
this method was formulated by dokshitzer , marchesini and webber @xcite and relies on the assumption that the power correction to an observable is given by evaluating the perturbative renormalon graphs and estimating the ensuing ambiguity of the pt series . to investigate this method one
observes that inserting renormalon bubbles on gluon lines in a lowest order feynman graph for a given observable @xmath3 results in the appearance of a running coupling constant .
if this gluon is an internal line inserting renormalon bubbles gives for an observable @xmath3 @xmath16 with @xmath17 representing the gluon virtuality .
the role of the renormalon bubbles is simply to give rise to the running coupling in the integrand above . strictly within a perturbative context
the above integral gives a divergent result due to the divergence of @xmath2 at the landau pole .
this is just the factorial renormalon behaviour discussed previously . to generate power corrections from the above contribution
the assumption one makes is that the qcd coupling @xmath2 instead of diverging is a well behaved universal function down to small scales , i.e infrared finite .
further knowledge of the exact behaviour of the coupling is not required for us to proceed .
this is certainly not an assumption that can be justified from first principles .
however it leads to simple results that can be easily tested against a wealth of experimental data .
this exercise has been carried out for different observables and so far it seems that experimental data are in support of this notion of a universal ir finite coupling .
assuming that the coupling is analytic except a branch cut across the negative real axis which is a requirement of causality , it follows that one can write the formal dispersion relation @xmath18 where the spectral function @xmath19 represents the discontinuity across the cut , @xmath20 non - perturbative effects at long distances are expected to give rise to a modification in the strong coupling at low scales , @xmath21 , which generates a corresponding modification in the spectral function : @xmath22 from eqs .
( [ master][deltas ] ) it follows that the non - perturbative contribution to @xmath3 , trigerred by a virtual gluon with renormalon insertions and an np modified coupling can be written as @xmath23\ ] ] a similar equation holds for the real emission contribution and hence in what follws we shall remove the superscript and talk about the sum of real and virtual pieces . the quantity @xmath24 represents the @xmath25 virtual calculation performed with a finite gluon mass @xmath26 .
the gluon mass is just the dispersive variable in eq .
[ alphas ] and does not imply that one works with a massive gluon field and spoils gauge invariance .
after some further manipulation one gets the following non - perturbative contribution to @xmath3 @xmath27 where , setting @xmath28 , @xmath29 since @xmath30 is limited to low values of @xmath31 , the asymptotic behaviour of @xmath32 at large @xmath6 is controlled by the behaviour of @xmath33 as @xmath34 .
we see from eq .
[ gdef ] that no terms analytic at @xmath35 can contribute to @xmath32 . on the other hand for a square - root behaviour at small @xmath36 , @xmath37 where we defined the coupling moment
@xmath38 we can express @xmath39 in terms of the average value of @xmath40 in the infrared region , as follows .
we substitute for @xmath41 in eq .
( m^2 ) ( m^2 ) - ( m^2 ) , where @xmath42 represents the expression for @xmath40 corresponding to the part already included in the perturbative prediction .
if the perturbative calculation is carried out to second order in the renormalization scheme , with renormalization scale @xmath43 , then we have ( m^2 ) = ( ^2 ) + [ b(^2/m^2)+k]^2(^2 ) where for @xmath44 active flavours ( @xmath45 ) b = , k= .
the constant @xmath46 comes from a change of scheme from to the more physical scheme @xcite in which @xmath40 is preferably defined at low scales . then above some infrared matching scale @xmath47
we assume that @xmath48 and @xmath49 approximately coincide , so that [ a1exp ] _ 1 & & _
0^ dm((m^2)- ( ^2 ) - [ b(^2/m^2)+k]^2(^2 ) ) + & = & ( 0()- ( ^2 ) - [ b(^2/^2)+k+2b]^2(^2 ) ) , where [ a0def ] 0 ( ) _ 0^(m^2)dm .
studies of event shapes in @xmath50 annihilation suggest that @xmath51 for @xmath52 gev , which translates into a value of @xmath53 gev for @xmath54 gev .
here we shall concentrate on the phenomenology of power corrections to event shape variables measured by the h1 and zeus collaborations .
this study is carried out in the breit frame and the current hemisphere @xmath55 is used to define the variables , freeing us from contamination by the proton remnant jet .
some of the observables studied are defined below * current jet thrust this is constructed by summing the modulii of hadron components along the photon axis in the breit frame .
two normalisations are possible , to @xmath56 on one hand and to the energy in the current hemisphere ( provided this exceeds a certain preset minimum ) .
@xmath57 @xmath58 * current hemisphere jet mass [ rhodef ] = ( _ ah_cp_a)^2/q^2 .
* @xmath59-parameter the @xmath59-parameter is [ cdef ] c=6_a , bh_c|p_a||p_b|^2_ab / q^2
. there are still other possible definitions and variables studied in addition to the ones mentioned above ( an important one being the jet broadening ) but for illustrative purposes it is enough to restrict the discussion to the variables mentioned .
the power corrections for different event shape variables are given by following the dispersive recepie .
one first computes the one - loop graphs with a finite gluon mass @xmath60 for all the variables mentioned above the leading non - analytic behaviour at small @xmath61 is a @xmath62 singularity .
this leads to @xmath63 power corrections of the form of eq .
[ deltaf1 ] the coefficients @xmath64 differ from variable to variable and one gets @xmath65 the constant @xmath39 is expected to be approximately universal ( to about @xmath66)as observed in @xmath67 data and with similar values to those found there .
one point that needs to be made in the dis context is that the leading power corrections to most event shapes are independent of the bjorken variable @xmath5 .
this comes about since the @xmath63 effects in question are trigered by a soft gluon , the emission of which does not change the momentum fraction carried by the incoming projectile .
an exception to this is the jet broadening variable where an interplay between this emitted soft gluon and @xmath5 dependent perturbative radiation gives rise to an @xmath5 dependent power correction .
a complete estimate for the broadening power correction relies on a resummed perturbative calculation which shall be published shortly @xcite .
another point that needed to be addressed was one first raised by nason and seymour @xcite .
they pointed out that gluon decay can only be mimimcked by a massive gluon provided one can integrate inclusively over the gluon offspring .
in other words the machinary of the dispersive approach should only strictly be applied to inclusive observables which do not register offspring gluons .
event shapes are not such variables as the offspring gluon momenta affect the event shape .
hence one needs an improved approach where one explicitly treats gluon decay properly .
the two - loop calculations that take gluon decay into proper account were first performed for @xmath50 observables @xcite following this similar work was performed for dis observables @xmath68 .
the conclusions could at first sight be described as surprising .
taking two loop effects into account meant a simple rescaling of the old one - loop coefficients by a universal factor @xmath69 for @xmath70 .
hence the ratios of power corrections to different observables are still given by the ratios of the one - loop coefficents @xmath71 .
this surprising result came about as a result of * universality of soft gluon radiation . *
common geometrical properties of event shapes they are all linear in the emitted transverse momenta .
[ hum ] [ mbell ] another area of investigation at hera is the study of event shape differential distributions @xmath72 and power corrections . here
while data has been available for a while there was a lack of theoretical estimates .
although there are monte carlo programs to make fixed order estimates at @xmath73 this is not sufficient in the above case .
the presence of large logarithms as big as @xmath74 at @xmath75 perturbative order means that a fixed order expansion is not very useful in the small @xmath3 region . as in @xmath50 one needs to resum all orders till next - to leading logarithmic accuracy to describe the data .
this resummation program has been started @xcite and results for many variables are soon to be published @xcite .
however a preliminary comparison to data has already begun .
the power corrections to different event shape distributions result in simple shifts of the perturbative spectra , the amount of the shift is exactly equal to the @xmath63 correction to the corresponding mean values .
@xmath76 where @xmath64 for the different variables are quoted .
again the jet broadening is different and does not show a simple shift of the pt spectrum giving instead a variable dependent shift as in @xmath67 .
the experimental results from h1 and zeus ( see figs . 1 and 2 ) have been available for quite some time for mean values whereas fits to distributions are on the way . for the mean values
the fits are best summarised by plotting error ellipses in the @xmath77 plane where @xmath78 is the parameter introduced in eq .
[ a1exp ] .
some brief comments about the results are in order . in the h1 results one should note that the jet mass ellipse is shifted and falls in line with expectations from other variables provided one neglects hadron masses ( the relevant ellipse is labelled @xmath79 ) in keeping with the theoretical approximations made . for
a fuller discussion of this point see @xcite . in the zeus plot one
notices the effect of large systematic errors .
zeus have also studied the @xmath5 dependence of power corrections and as noted before in this article the power correction to the jet broadening variable displays a clear @xmath5 dependence which comes from the anomalous dimension matrix @xcite .
in addition one remarks that that the values of the @xmath80 parameter obtained from dis event shapes has similar values ( 0.40.5 ) as for @xmath67 variables and this seems to support the hypothesis of a universal infrared finite coupling .
the spread in @xmath2 values however is still uncomfortably large and is a potential area for improvement . finally turning to differential distributions one can use a nominal value of @xmath81 and @xmath82 and the resummation of @xcite .
the curves in fig .
3 are produced by binning like the h1 data which is responsible for their non - smooth nature .
preliminary indications are positive as shown by fig . 3 but detailed fits are awaited .
1 beneke m 1999 _ phys .
rept _ * 317 * p 1 .
dokshitzer yu l , marchesini g and webber b r 1996 _ nucl .
* b 469 * p 93 .
catani s , marchesini g and webber br 1991 _ nucl .
* b 349 * p 635 .
dasgupta m and salam g p in preparation .
nason p and seymour m h 1995 _ nucl .
phys . _ * b 454 * p 291 .
dokshitzer yu l , lucenti a , marchesini g and salam gp 1998 _ jhep _ * 9805 * p 001 .
dasgupta m and webber b r 1998 _ jhep _ * 9810 * p 003 .
martyn h u 2000 talk given at _
30th international conference on high - energy physics ( ichep 2000 ) _ , osaka , japan .
mccance g j 2000 talk given at _
35th rencontres de moriond : qcd and high energy hadronic interactions _ , les arcs , savoie , france .
antonelli v , dasgupta m and salam g p 2000 _ jhep _ * 0002 * p 001 . salam g p and wicke d 2001 , _
jhep _ * 0105 * p 061 . | this article provides a review of progress made in understanding inverse power law corrections @xmath0 where @xmath1 is the hard scale involved in a given qcd process .
particular attention will be paid to hera results . |
the `` pitch - drop - experiment '' @xcite , which received the ig - nobel price in physics 2005 , has brought to the attention that a fast process like drop formation @xcite can be retarded considerably if instead of a standard liquid like water it has a viscosity of @xmath0 at @xmath1c a material like pitch , with a viscosity around @xmath2 is selected .
the funnel was filled in 1930 @xcite , and today `` finally the ninth pitch drop has fallen from the world s longest running lab experiment '' @xcite and the 10th is awaited within the next 14 years . here the question arises whether those high viscosities may give access to so far not resolved phenomena . in a vessel with diameter of 120 mm .
the picture is taken from @xcite .
a movie showing the formation of rosensweig patterns can be accessed at @xcite.,width=323 ] in the following we are investigating this question for the case of the well known rosensweig or normal field instability @xcite .
it is observed in a horizontal layer of magnetic fluid ( mf ) @xcite with a free surface , when a critical value @xmath3 of the vertically oriented magnetic induction is surpassed .
figure [ fig : peaks ] presents a photo of the final hexagonal arrangement of static liquid peaks . beside the threshold ,
beyond which the instability occurs , two quantities characterizing the emerging pattern have been in the focus of various studies : the critical wave number of the peaks and the corresponding growth rate , where both are strongly influenced by the viscosity of the magnetic fluid .
that essential role of the viscosity for the dynamics of the pattern formation is reflected in the course of the analyses devoted to the rosensweig instability .
for an inviscid magnetic fluid ( the dynamic viscosity @xmath4 is zero ) and an infinitely deep container , @xcite provide a linear stability analysis already in the very first description of the normal field instability to find the critical threshold @xmath3 and the critical wave number @xmath5 .
this approach has been extended later by @xcite to fluids with non - zero viscosity , where the growth rate depends on @xmath4 , and to a finite depth of the container by @xcite .
first experimental investigations on the growth of the pattern are provided by @xcite , who also derive the growth rate for the case of a viscous magnetic fluid and an arbitrary layer thickness @xmath6 .
this theoretical analysis has been later extended to the case of a nonlinear magnetization curve @xmath7 by @xcite . whereas so far the growth rate of the emerging rosensweig pattern has been measured utilizing ferrofluids with @xmath8 @xcite and @xmath9 @xcite we are tackling here the growth process in a ferrofluid which is a thousand times more viscous than the first one .
such a ferrofluid is being created by cooling a commercially available viscous ferrofluid ( apg e32 from ferrotec co. ) down to @xmath10c .
the ferrofluid has now a viscosity of @xmath11 .
in such a cooled rosensweig ( sloppy _ frozensweig _ ) instability @xcite the growth of the pattern takes 60 seconds and can be measured with high temporal resolution in the extended system using a two - dimensional x - ray imaging technique @xcite .
that technique provides the full surface topography , as opposed to the fast , but one dimensional hall - sensor array , which had to be utilized for the low viscosity ferrofluids @xcite .
the potential of the retarded instability was demonstrated before @xcite , when the coefficients of nonlinear amplitude equations were determined in this way .
in addition a sequence of localized patches of rosensweig pattern could be uncovered most recently @xcite with that technique .
here we exploit a higher viscosity to investigate the linear growth rate in a regime , which was hitherto not accessible .
this expectation is based on a scaling analysis presented in ref.@xcite . for supercritical inductions larger than @xmath12 ( the dimensionless kinematic viscosity @xmath13 is defined in eq .
( [ eq : scaling_visc ] ) below ) the behavior of the growth rate is characterized by a _
square - root _ dependence on those inductions , as confirmed in @xcite .
contrary , for supercritical inductions smaller than @xmath12 the behavior of the growth rate is characterized by a _
linear _ dependence . in the present experiment we increase @xmath12 by six orders of magnitude due to the high viscosity of the ferrofluid apg e32 at @xmath10c .
thus a new territory of linear scaling is open for exploration .
the outline of the paper is as follows : the experimental setup and the measurements are sketched in the next sect .
[ sec : experiment ] .
the theoretical analysis is presented in sect .
[ sec : theory ] and compared with the experimental findings in the subsequent sect . [
sec : results ] .
in this section we describe the experimental setup ( sect.[subsec : setup ] ) , the ferrofluid ( sect.[subsec : fluid ] ) , the protocol utilized for the measurements ( sect.[subsec : measurements ] ) , and the way the linear growth rate is extracted from the recorded data ( sect.[subsec : extracting ] ) .
the experimental setup for the measurements of the surface topography consists of an tailor made x - ray apparatus described in detail before @xcite .
an x - ray point source emits radiation vertically from above through the container filled with the mf . underneath the container ,
an x - ray camera records the radiation passing through the layer of mf .
the intensity at each pixel of the detector is directly related to the height of the fluid above that pixel , as sketched in fig .
[ fig : setup](a ) .
therefore , the full surface topography can be reconstructed after calibration @xcite . the container , which holds the mf sample , is depicted in fig .
[ fig : setup](b ) .
it is a regular octagon machined from aluminium with a side length of @xmath14 and two concentric inner bores with a diameter of @xmath15 .
these circular holes are carved from above and below , leaving only a thin base in the middle of the vessel with a thickness of @xmath16 . on top of the octagon ,
a circular aluminium lid is placed , which closes the hole from above , as shown in fig .
[ fig : setup](b ) .
each side of the octagon is equipped with a thermoelectric element ` qc-127 - 1.4 - 8.5ms ` from quick - ohm , as shown in fig .
[ fig : setup](c ) .
the latter are powered by a @xmath17 kepco ` klp-20 - 120 ` power supply .
the hot side of the peltier elements is connected to water cooled heat exchangers .
the temperature is measured at the bottom of the aluminium container with a pt100 resistor .
the temperature difference between the center and the edge of the bottom plate does not exceed @xmath18k at the temperature @xmath19c measured at the edge of the vessel . a closed loop control , realized using a computer and programmable interface devices , holds @xmath20 constant within @xmath21 .
the container is surrounded by a helmholtz - pair - of - coils , thermally isolated from the vessel with a ring made from the flame resistant material ` fr-2 ` .
the size of the coils is adapted to the size of the vessel in order to introduce a `` magnetic ramp '' at the edge of the vessel .
this technique , as described more detailed in ref.@xcite , serves to minimize distortions by compensating partly the jump of the magnetization at the container edge .
filling the container to a height of @xmath22 with ferrofluid enhances the magnetic induction in comparison with the empty coils for the same current @xmath23 .
therefore @xmath24 is measured immediately beneath the bottom of the container , at the central position , and serves as the control parameter in the following .
0.5 cm + 0.5 cm ( a ) 5.5 cm ( b ) + + 0.5 cm ( c ) the vessel is filled with the commercial magnetic fluid apge32 from ferrotec co. up to a hight of 5 mm .
the material parameters of this mf are listed in tab .
[ tab : apge32_parameters ] .
the density was measured using a ` dma 4100 ` density meter from anton paar .
the surface tension was measured using a commercial ring tensiometer ( lauda ` te 1 ` ) and a pendant drop method ( dataphysics ` oca 20 ` ) .
both methods result in a surface tension of @xmath25 , but when the liquid is allowed to rest for one day , @xmath26 drops down to @xmath27 .
this effect , which is not observed in similar , but less viscous magnetic liquids like the one used in ref.@xcite , gives a hint that the surfactants change the surface tension at least on a longer time scale , when the surface is changed .
since indeed the pattern formation experiments do change the surface during the measurements , the uncertainty of the surface tension is @xmath28 , as given in tab .
[ tab : apge32_parameters ] .
lcdcc quantity & & value & error & unit + density at @xmath29 & @xmath30 & 1168.0 & @xmath31 & @xmath32 + surface tension at @xmath29 & @xmath26 & 30.9 & @xmath33 & @xmath34 + viscosity at @xmath35 & @xmath4 & 4.48 & @xmath36 & @xmath37 + saturation magnetization & @xmath38 & 26.6 & @xmath39 & @xmath40 + initial susceptibility at @xmath35 & @xmath41 & 3.74 & @xmath42 & + fit of @xmath7 with the model by ref.@xcite & & & & + exponent of the @xmath43-distribution & @xmath44 & 3.8 & @xmath31 & + typical diameter of the bare particles & @xmath45 & 1.7 & @xmath46 & @xmath47 + volume fraction of the magnetic material & @xmath48 & 5.96 & @xmath46 & % + fit of @xmath49 with the model by ref.@xcite & & & & + mean diameter of the bare particle & @xmath50 & 15 & & @xmath47 + volume fraction of the magnetic material & @xmath48 & 21.4 & @xmath46 & % + critical induction for a semi - infinite layer @xcite & @xmath51 & 10.5 & @xmath36 & @xmath52 + [ tab : apge32_parameters ] .
the black dashed line is a fit with the model by ref.@xcite .
the blue solid line marks an extrapolation to @xmath53c according to this model . ]
[ [ magnetization - curve ] ] magnetization curve + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the magnetization has been determined using a fluxmetric magnetometer ( lakeshore model 480 ) constructed to deal with larger samples of high viscosity at a temperature of @xmath54 .
figure[fig : magkurve ] shows the data , which have been fitted by the modified mean field model of second order @xcite , marked by the dashed black line . for a comparison with the pattern formation experiments performed at @xmath55
, this curve is extrapolated utilizing this model ( blue line ) .
the deviation between both curves is tiny , which was corroborated with a vibrating sample magnetometer ( lakeshore vsm 7404 ) at @xmath54 and @xmath56 .
note that the vsm offers the advantage that it can be tempered , but has a lower resolution in comparison to the fluxmetric device because of the smaller sample volume . to take into account the nonlinear @xmath7 ,
an effective susceptibility @xmath57 is defined by a geometric mean @xmath58 with the tangent susceptibility @xmath59 and the chord susceptibility @xmath60 @xcite . for any field
@xmath61 the effective susceptibility @xmath57 can be evaluated , when the magnetization @xmath7 curve is known .
[ [ viscosity ] ] viscosity + + + + + + + + + the viscosity @xmath4 deserves special attention for the experiments , as it influences the time scale of the pattern formation .
it has been measured in a temperature range of @xmath62 , using a commercial rheometer ( mcr301 , anton paar ) with a shear cell featuring a cone - plate geometry . at room temperature ,
the magnetic fluid with a viscosity of @xmath63 is @xmath64 times more viscous than water .
the value of @xmath4 can be increased by factor of @xmath65 when the liquid is cooled to @xmath66 .
the temperature dependent viscosity data can be nicely fitted with the well - known vogel - fulcher law @xcite @xmath67 with @xmath68 and @xmath69 , as described in detail in ref.@xcite . for the present measurements
, we chose a temperature of @xmath55 , where the viscosity amounts to @xmath70 according to eq .
( [ eq : vogelfulcher ] ) . [ [ magnetoviscosity ] ] magnetoviscosity + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + for a shear rate of @xmath71 . the @xmath72 ( @xmath73 ) mark measurements for increasing ( decreasing ) @xmath74 and
the solid line is a fit by eq .
( [ eq : shliomis1972 ] ) .
the upper abscissa displays the applied magnetic induction @xmath75 measured in the air gap beneath the magnetorheological cell . ]
the growth and decay of ferrofluidic spikes takes place in a magnetic field , which is known to alter the viscosity .
furnishing the rheometer with the magnetorheological device mrd 170 - 1
t from anton paar we exemplary measure the magnetoviscous behaviour for a shear rate of @xmath76 .
we use a plate - plate configuration with a gap of @xmath77 , where the upper plate has a diameter of 20 mm .
figure[fig : mag.viscosity ] displays the measured data together with a fit by @xmath78 which describes the magnetoviscosity according to shliomis @xcite . here
@xmath79 , denotes the ratio between the magnetic energy of the dipole in the field @xmath74 and the thermal energy @xmath80 , where @xmath81 is the domain magnetisation of saturated magnetite @xcite , and @xmath82 the magnetic active volume .
moreover @xmath83 captures the viscosity without a magnetic field , @xmath84 the additional rotational viscosity due to the presence of the magnetic field @xmath85 in the ferrofluid , and @xmath86 is the hydrodynamic volume fraction of the magnetite particles .
the brackets @xmath87 indicate a spatial average over the inclosed quantity .
note that in case of fig.[fig : mag.viscosity ] the angle @xmath88 between @xmath85 and the vorticity of the flow is @xmath89 . for the fit the internal field
was obtained via solving @xmath90 , assuming a demagnetization factor of @xmath91 .
the fit yields a hydrodynamic volume fraction of @xmath92 and @xmath93 . from @xmath82 one
estimates a mean diameter of @xmath94 for the magnetic particles .
this is almost a factor of ten larger than @xmath95 obtained from the magnetisation curve ( cf.table [ tab : apge32_parameters ] ) . assuming a spherical layer of oleic acid molecules of thickness @xmath96 around the magnetic particles @xcite
, the volume fraction of the magnetic active material is @xmath97 .
this is more than three times larger than the value obtained via the magnetisation curve ( cf.table [ tab : apge32_parameters ] ) .
the elevated values of @xmath98 and @xmath99 may be a consequence of magnetic agglomerates , which are not taken into account by eq.([eq : shliomis1972 ] ) . for @xmath100 ( red )
, @xmath101 ( black ) , and @xmath102 ( blue ) .
the crosses mark the measured data ( for clarity only every 5th data point is shown ) , whereas the solid lines display fits by eq.([eq : sisko ] ) . ] to test the flow behaviour of the ferrofluid , the viscosity was measured versus the shear rate for three exemplary magnetic inductions , as presented in fig.[fig : shear.thinning ] .
all curves exhibit a decay of the viscosity for increasing @xmath103 , i.e. shear thinning which is typical for dispersions @xcite . for a quantitative description of this effect
the measured data are fitted by the sisko equation @xcite @xmath104 adapted to the limit @xmath105 , where @xmath106 .
moreover @xmath107 denotes a factor and @xmath108 a scaling exponent .
table [ tab : sisko ] displays the fitting parameters obtained for the three inductions .
.the parameters obtained by fitting eq.([eq : sisko ] ) to the experimental data . [ cols="<,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tab : fit.para ] next we focus as well on the experimental data for the decay , which are plotted together with the growth data in fig .
[ fig : growthrate_comparison ] .
the decay rates ( @xmath109 ) are scattering more widely in comparison to the growth rates ( @xmath110 ) .
this may be due to the fact , that the decay rates could not be resolved in the bistability range , and thus not in the immediate vicinity of @xmath111 , in contrast to the growth rates .
the black dashed line marks the outcome of a fit of eq([eq : hat_omega2_hatm ] ) to _ all _ experimental values .
also in this extended range the fit describes the measured growth and decay rates to some extent . in table
[ tab : fit.para ] we present in line two the fit parameters for viscosity and surface tension .
the fitted surface tension is well within the error bars of the measured value , whereas the fitted viscosity is about 20 % above the measured one . ) and decay ( @xmath112)rates @xmath113 , respectively , of the pattern amplitude as a function of the magnetization @xmath114 .
the symbols represent the measured data .
the black dashed line shows a fit of eq.([eq : hat_omega2_hatm ] ) to the experimental growth and decay rates , with the parameters given in the line two of table [ tab : fit.para ] .
the orange dashed line marks as well a fit by eq.([eq : hat_omega2_hatm ] ) , but is taking into account a growth rate dependent surface tension , as described by eq.([eq : dyn.sigma ] ) . for the parameters
see line three of table [ tab : fit.para ] .
the solid blue line displays a fit taking into account a growth - rate dependent viscosity according to eq .
( [ eq : dyn.eta ] ) . for parameters
see line four of table [ tab : fit.para].,title="fig:",width=298 ] 0.4 cm most importantly , inspecting the measured data more closely , one observes a different inclination for growth and decay rates with respect to @xmath114 .
obviously this systematic deviation is not matched by eq.([eq : hat_omega2_hatm ] ) . as a possible origin for
the different inclinations one may suspect that utilizing the static surface tension in eq.([eq : hat_omega2_hatm ] ) is not a sufficient approximation .
indeed during the growth of the peaks new surface area is generated , and the diffusion of surfactants from the bulk of the ferrofluid towards the surface may lag behind . similarly during the decay of the peaks surface area is annihilated and the surface density of surfactants may there exceed the equilibrium concentration . therefore we adopt a growth - rate - dependent dynamic surface tension according to @xmath115 where @xmath116 denotes the static surface tension and @xmath117 a coefficient of dimension @xmath118 . in fig.[fig : growthrate_comparison ] the orange dashed line marks the outcome of the fit .
it follows the black dashed line , and thus can not explain the different inclinations . in a next attempt to describe the different inclinations we postulate a growth rate dependent viscosity in the form of @xmath119 where @xmath120 is a coefficient of dimension @xmath121 . in fig.[fig :
growthrate_comparison ] a fit by eq.([eq : dyn.eta ] ) is marked by the solid blue line .
obviously this phenomenological ansatz meets the data remarkeably well . a possible explanation of this complex behaviour is based upon the formation of chains of magnetic particles , which is indicated by the enhanced shear thinning as recorded in fig.[fig : shear.thinning ]
. the chain formation will be most prominent in the higher magnetic field in the spikes at the starting amplitude @xmath122 , marked in fig.[fig : frozenprotocol ] .
these chains are then increasing the magnetoviscosity during the decay of the spikes , which retards the decay ( cf.path @xmath123__2 _ _ and @xmath123__3b _ _ in fig.[fig : frozenprotocol ] ) . during the decay
they are partially destroyed . as a consequence , after switching again to an overcritical induction , the growth of the spikes ( path @xmath124__3a _ _ ) is comparatively faster . in contrast , our theory is based on newtonian fluids .
an extension to shear thinning and structured liquids has still to be developed .
we are next comparing the critical inductions in the last column of table [ tab : fit.para ] .
the static fit of the growth process yields @xmath125 and deviates by only 1% from the mean value @xmath126 obtained by a fit of the full dynamics by means of amplitude equations in ref.@xcite .
all other values for @xmath3 underestimate this value slightly more ( cf.line 2 - 4 ) . in the latter three cases the growth _ and _
decay was taken into account .
this is a conformation , that mainly the decay is affected by chain formation in the spikes .
eventually we will not hide _ four _ further effects which may have impact on our experiment : _ first _ , the experiments are performed in a finite container which comprises only 27 spikes on a hexagonal lattice , whereas the theory considers a laterally infinite layer .
our finite circular size does indeed suppress the onset of a hexagonal pattern , due to the ramp described above .
_ second _ , by seeding a regular hexagonal pattern at large amplitude the selected wavelength may differ from the wavelength of maximal growth .
this can in principle shift the experimental threshold towards higher values .
however , it was demonstrated by linear stability analysis that this effect can be neglected in the limit of high viscosities @xcite .
_ third _ , magnetophoresis may take place in the crests of the pattern , in this way creating an inhomogeneous distribution of magnetite . even though the timescale for separation in a low viscous mf comprise days @xcite and our measurements
last only hours , an effect can not completely excluded .
a _ fourth _ reason may be that instead of the shear viscosity the extensional viscosity has to be taken into account in eq.([eq : disprel ] ) .
indeed , besides a small viscous sublayer , the flow profile of surface waves can `` be described by a potential and is rotational free and purely elongational '' @xcite .
most recently a capillary - break - up - extensional - rheometer was subjected to magnetic fields oriented along the direction of the capillary @xcite . for increasing fields an enlarged elongational viscosity was observed .
this effect was also attributed to chain formation .
however , to measure the elongational viscosity of ferrofluids is a difficult task , and sensitive devices have still to be developed .
using a highly viscous magnetic fluid , the dynamics of the formation of the rosensweig instability can be slowed down to the order of minutes . therefore , it is possible to measure the dynamics using a two - dimensional imaging technique , in contrast to previous work @xcite , where only a one - dimensional cut through the two - dimensional pattern was accomplished . by means of a specific measurement protocol
we were able to seed regular patterns of small amplitude , suitable for a comparison with linear theory . from the evolution of their amplitudes
we could estimate the linear growth and decay rates , respectively . our experiment confirmed for the very first time a _ linear _ scaling of the growth rate with the magnetic inductions , as predicted @xcite for the immediate vicinity of the bifurcation point .
thus the scaling behavior of the growth rate is now confirmed for supercritical magnetizations not only above @xcite but also below the boundary of the two scaling regimes at @xmath12 . additionally , we uncovered , that the rates of growth and decay are slightly different , a phenomenon not predicted by the theory .
a possible origin of this discrepancy is the formation of chains of magnetic particles .
their presence in our ferrofluid is indicated by the magnetically enhanced shear thinning .
the build up of chains in the static spikes , and their subsequent destruction during the decay may change the effective viscosity of the structured ferrofluid , and thus explain the deviations .
so far our theory is based on newtonian liquids .
an extension to shear thinning and structured ferrofluids is referred to future investigations
. it may be able to reproduce the scaling of the effective viscosity as described phenomenologically by eq.([eq : scaling_visc ] ) .
we thank m. mrkl for measuring the surface tension of the used magnetic fluid .
the temperature - controlled container was made with the help of klaus oetter and the mechanical and electronic workshop the university of bayreuth .
moreover discussions with thomas friedrich , werner khler , konstantin morozov and christian wagner are gratefully acknowledged .
r.r . is deeply indebted to the emil - warburg foundation for financially supporting repair and upgrade of the magnetorheometer .
the coefficients for the forth and fifth order of @xmath127 in the scaling laws ( [ eq : hat_omega2_hatm ] , [ eq : hat_k_hatm ] ) are @xmath128}{4\bar\nu^5}\\ \label{eq : iota } & + \frac{407(2+a_\chi)^5}{64\bar\nu^9}\ ; , \\
\nonumber o = & \frac{3a_\chi(2a_\chi+1)+6b_\chi(3a_\chi+2+b_\chi)}{\bar\nu^2 } + \frac{3(2+a_\chi)^3(23a_\chi^2 + 158a_\chi+33b_\chi+125)}{\bar\nu^6}\\ \nonumber & - \frac{3(2+a_\chi)\left[36a_\chi^3+a_\chi^2(18b_\chi+217)+a_\chi(138b_\chi+282)+b_\chi(138 + 11b_\chi)+83\right]}{4\bar\nu^4}\\ \label{eq : o } & - \frac{491(2+a_\chi)^5}{32\bar\nu^8 } \ ; .\end{aligned}\ ] ] 45ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( )
@noop `` , '' @noop @noop * * , ( ) @noop `` , '' ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop `` , '' @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1017/jfm.2015.565 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) in @noop _ _ , vol . , , ( , , ) pp . @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) , @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) ,
, @noop _ _ , , vol .
( , , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1122/1.4902356 [ * * , ( ) ] | using a highly viscous magnetic fluid , the dynamics in the aftermath of the rosensweig instability can be slowed down by more than 2000 times . in this way
we expand the regime where the growth rate is predicted to scale linearly with the bifurcation parameter by six orders of magnitude , while this regime is tiny for standard ferrofluids and can not be resolved experimentally there .
we measure the growth of the pattern by means of a two - dimensional imaging technique , and find that the slopes of the growth and decay rates are not the same - a qualitative discrepancy to the theoretical predictions .
we solve this discrepancy by taking into account a viscosity which is assumed to be different for the growth and decay .
this may be a consequence of the measured shear thinning of the ferrofluid .
= 1 |
suppose @xmath0 is a commutative @xmath2-algebra , in the sense of @xcite , and @xmath3 is a commutative @xmath0-algebra .
we want to capture the properties and underlying structure of the homotopy groups @xmath4 of @xmath3 , by studying operations associated to the cohomology theory that @xmath0 represents . an important family of cohomology operations , called _ power operations _ ,
is constructed via the extended powers . specifically , consider the _ @xmath5th extended power _
functor @xmath6 on the category of @xmath0-modules , which sends an @xmath0-module to its @xmath5-fold smash product over @xmath0 modulo the action by the symmetric group on @xmath5 letters .
the @xmath7 s assemble together to give the _ free commutative @xmath0-algebra _
functor @xmath8 from the category of @xmath0-modules to the category of commutative @xmath0-algebras .
these functors descend to homotopy categories .
in particular , each @xmath9 gives rise to a power operation @xmath10 ( cf .
* sections i.2 and ix.1 ) and ( * ? ? ?
* section 3 ) ) . under the action of power operations , @xmath11 is an algebra over some operad in @xmath12-modules involving the structure of @xmath13 for all @xmath5 .
this operad is traditionally called a _ dyer - lashof algebra _ , or more precisely , a dyer - lashof _ theory _ as the _ algebraic theory _ of power operations acting on the homotopy groups of commutative @xmath0-algebras ( cf .
* chapters iii , viii , and ix ) and ( * ? ? ?
* section 9 ) ) .
a specific case is when @xmath0 represents a morava @xmath0-theory of height @xmath14 and @xmath3 is @xmath15-local .
morava @xmath0-theory spectra play a crucial role in modern stable homotopy theory , particularly in the work of ando , hopkins , and strickland on the topological approach to elliptic genera ( see @xcite ) . as recalled in @xcite , the @xmath15-local @xmath0-dyer - lashof theory is largely understood based on work of those authors . in @xcite ,
rezk maps out the foundations of this theory .
he gives a congruence criterion for an algebra over the dyer - lashof theory ( ( * ? ? ?
* theorem a ) ) .
this enables one to study the dyer - lashof _ theory _ , which models all the algebraic structure naturally adhering to @xmath11 , by working with a certain associative ring @xmath16 as the dyer - lashof _ algebra_. moreover , rezk provides a geometric description of this congruence criterion , in terms of sheaves on the moduli problem of deformations of formal groups and frobenius isogenies ( see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem b ) ) .
this connects the structure of @xmath16 to the geometry underlying @xmath0 , moving one step forward from a workable object @xmath16 to things that are computable . in a companion paper @xcite
, rezk gives explicit calculations of the dyer - lashof theory for a specific morava @xmath0-theory of height @xmath17 at the prime 2 .
the purpose of this paper is to make available calculations analogous to some of the results in @xcite , at the prime 3 , together with calculations of the corresponding power operations on the @xmath1-localization of the morava @xmath0-theory spectrum . as in @xcite ,
the computation of power operations in this paper follows the approach of @xcite : one first defines a total power operation , and then uses the computation of the cohomology of the classifying space @xmath18 for the symmetric group to obtain individual power operations .
these two steps are carried out in sections [ sec : total ] and [ sec : individual ] respectively . in section [ sec : total ] , by doing calculations with elliptic curves associated to our morava @xmath0-theory @xmath0 , we give formulas for the total power operation @xmath19 on @xmath20 and the ring @xmath21 which represents the corresponding moduli problem . in section [ sec :
individual ] , based on calculations of @xmath22 in @xcite as reflected in the formula for @xmath21 , we define individual power operations , and derive the relations they satisfy . in view of the general structures studied in @xcite
, we then get an explicit description of the dyer - lashof algebra @xmath16 for @xmath23-local commutative @xmath0-algebras . in section [ sec : k(1 ) ] , we describe the relationship between the total power operation @xmath19 , at height 2 , and the corresponding @xmath1-local power operations .
we then derive formulas for the latter from the calculations in section [ sec : total ] .
[ rmk : grading ] in section [ sec : total ] , we do calculations with a universal elliptic curve over _ all _ of the moduli stack which is an affine open subscheme of a weighted projective space ( cf .
proposition [ prop : c ] ) . at the prime 3
, the supersingular locus consists of a single closed point , and the corresponding morava @xmath0-theory arises _ locally _ in an affine coordinate chart of this weighted projective space containing the supersingular locus . in this paper
we choose a particular affine coordinate chart for computing the homotopy groups of the @xmath0-theory spectrum and the power operations ; we hope that the generality of the calculations in section [ sec : total ] makes it easier to work with other coordinate charts as well .
[ rmk : parameter ] the ring @xmath21 turns out to be an algebra with one generator over the base ring where our elliptic curve is defined ( cf . proposition [ prop : isog ] and ) .
this generator appears as a parameter in the formulas for the total power operation @xmath19 , and is responsible for how the individual power operations are defined and how their formulas look .
different choices of this parameter result in different bases of the dyer - lashof algebra @xmath16 .
the parameter in this paper comes from the relative cotangent space of the elliptic curve at the identity ( see proposition [ prop : isog ] , corollary [ cor : k ] , and remark [ rmk : k ] ) .
this choice is convenient for deriving adem relations in proposition [ prop : q ] , and it fits into the treatment of gradings in ( * ? ? ?
* section 2 ) ( see definition [ def : go ] and theorem [ thm : gamma ] ) .
we should point out that our choice is by no means canonical .
we do not know yet , as part of the structure of the dyer - lashof algebra , if there is a canonical basis which is both geometrically interesting and computationally convenient . somewhat surprisingly , although it appears to come from different considerations , our choice has an analog at the prime 2 which coincides with the parameter used in @xcite ( see remarks [ rmk : k ] and [ rmk : kk ] ) .
the calculations follow a recipe in hope of generalizing to other morava @xmath0-theories of height 2 ; we hope to address these matters and recognize more of the general patterns based on further computational evidence .
i thank charles rezk for his encouragement on this work , and for his observation in a correspondence which led to proposition [ prop : frob^2 ] and corollary [ cor : k ] .
i thank kyle ormsby for helpful discussions on section [ sec : total ] , and for directing me to places in the literature .
i thank tyler lawson for the sustained support from him i received as a student .
let @xmath24 be a prime , @xmath25 a power of @xmath24 , and @xmath14 a positive integer .
we use the symbols @xmath26 to denote a field with @xmath25 elements , the ring of @xmath24-typical witt vectors over @xmath27 , and the additive group of integers modulo @xmath14 , respectively .
if @xmath28 is a ring , then @xmath29 and @xmath30 denote the rings of formal power series and formal laurent series over @xmath28 in the variable @xmath31 respectively .
if @xmath32 is an ideal , then @xmath33 denotes the completion of @xmath28 with respect to @xmath34 .
if @xmath0 is an elliptic curve and @xmath5 is an integer , then @xmath35 $ ] denotes the multiplication - by-@xmath5 map on @xmath0 , and @xmath36 $ ] denotes the @xmath5-torsion subgroup scheme of @xmath0 .
all formal groups mentioned in this paper will be commutative and one - dimensional .
the terminology for the structure of the dyer - lashof theory will follow @xcite and @xcite ; some of the notions there are taken in turn from @xcite and @xcite .
a morava @xmath0-theory of height 2 at the prime 3 has its formal group as the universal deformation of a height-2 formal group over a perfect field of characteristic 3 .
given a supersingular elliptic curve over such a field , its formal completion at the identity produces a formal group of height 2 .
to study power operations for the corresponding @xmath0-theory , we do calculations with the universal deformation of that supersingular elliptic curve which is a family of elliptic curves with a @xmath37-structure ( see ( * ? ? ?
* section 3.2 ) ) where @xmath38 is prime to 3
. here is a specific model ( cf .
@xcite ) ) .
[ prop : c ] over @xmath39 $ ] , the moduli problem of nonsingular elliptic curves with a choice of a point of exact order 4 and a nowhere - vanishing invariant one - form is represented by @xmath40 with chosen point @xmath41 and one - form @xmath42 over the graded ring @xmath43 [ a , b , \delta^{-1}]\ ] ] where @xmath44 , @xmath45 , and @xmath46 .
let @xmath47 be the chosen point of exact order 4 .
since @xmath48 is 2-torsion , the tangent line of the elliptic curve at @xmath47 passes through @xmath48 , and the tangent line at @xmath48 passes through the identity at the infinity . with this observation ,
the rest of the proof is analogous to that of ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 3.2 ) . over a finite field of characteristic 3
, @xmath49 is supersingular precisely when the quantity @xmath50 vanishes ( cf .
* v.4.1a ) ) .
as @xmath51 is a homogeneous maximal ideal of @xmath52 corresponding to the closed subscheme @xmath53 , the supersingular locus consists of a single closed point , and @xmath49 restricts to @xmath54 as @xmath55 from the above universal deformation @xmath49 of @xmath56 , we next produce a morava @xmath0-theory spectrum which is 2-periodic .
we follow the convention that elements in algebraic degree @xmath14 lie in topological degree @xmath57 , and work in an affine tale coordinate chart of the weighted projective space @xmath58 [ a , b]$ ] ( see remark [ rmk : grading ] ) .
define elements @xmath59 and @xmath60 such that @xmath61 consider the graded ring @xmath62 \cong { { { \mathbb{z}}}}[1/4 ] [ a , \delta^{-1 } ] [ u^{\pm1}]\ ] ] where @xmath63 , and denote by @xmath2 its subring of elements in degree 0 so that @xmath64 [ c , \delta^{-1}]\ ] ] where @xmath65 .
write @xmath66 where @xmath67
let @xmath68 be an element generating @xmath69 over @xmath70 with @xmath71 .
we may choose @xmath72 and we have @xmath73 where @xmath74 is the maximal ideal of the complete local ring @xmath75 .
then by hensel s lemma , both @xmath60 and @xmath76 lie in @xmath75 , and both are invertible .
thus @xmath77
now @xmath49 restricts to @xmath2 as @xmath78 let @xmath79 be the formal completion of @xmath49 over @xmath2 at the identity .
it is a formal group over @xmath75 , and its reduction to @xmath80 is a formal group @xmath81 of height 2 in view of and . by the serre - tate theorem ( see @xcite ) , 3-adically the deformation theory of an elliptic curve is equivalent to the deformation theory of its 3-divisible group , and thus @xmath79 is the universal deformation of @xmath81 in view of proposition [ prop : c ] .
let @xmath0 be the @xmath82-ring spectrum which represents the morava @xmath0-theory associated to @xmath81 ( see ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 7.6 ) ) . then @xmath83\ ] ] where @xmath59 is in topological degree 2 , and it corresponds to a local uniformizer at the identity of @xmath49 . to study @xmath49 in a formal neighborhood of the identity , it is convenient to make a change of variables
. let @xmath84 the identity of @xmath49 is then @xmath85 , with @xmath59 a local uniformizer .
the equation of @xmath49 becomes @xmath86 [ prop : tors ] on the elliptic curve @xmath49 over @xmath52 , the @xmath87-coordinates @xmath88 of any nonzero 3-torsion point satisfy the identities @xmath89 and @xmath90 where @xmath91 $ ] are given by @xmath92 for explicit formulas for the polynomials @xmath93 , @xmath94 , @xmath95 , @xmath96 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 , @xmath99 , @xmath100 , and @xmath38 that appear in the proof .
] given the elliptic curve @xmath49 with equation , a nonzero point @xmath101 is 3-torsion if and only if the polynomial @xmath102 vanishes at @xmath101 ( cf .
* exercise 3.7f ) ) . substituting @xmath103 and clearing the denominators ,
we get a polynomial @xmath104 as @xmath105 in @xmath87-coordinates , we then have @xmath106 to get the polynomial @xmath107 , we take @xmath108 as variable and rewrite as a quadratic equation @xmath109 where the leading coefficient @xmath110 is invertible in @xmath111 [ a , b , \delta^{-1}]$ ] as @xmath46 .
define @xmath112 where @xmath108 and @xmath113 are formally the conjugate roots of so that we compute @xmath93 in terms of @xmath59 by substituting @xmath114 we then factor @xmath93 over @xmath52 as @xmath115 with @xmath107 the stated polynomial of order 8 .
we check that @xmath107 is irreducible by applying eisenstein s criterion to the homogeneous prime ideal @xmath51 of @xmath52 .
we have @xmath116 by and . to see @xmath117 ,
consider the closed subscheme @xmath118 $ ] of points of exact order 3 .
by @xcite it is finite locally free of rank 8 over @xmath52 . by the cayley - hamilton theorem , as a global section of @xmath119 , @xmath59 locally satisfies a homogeneous monic equation of order 8 , and this equation locally defines the rank-8 scheme @xmath119 .
since @xmath119 is affine , it is then globally defined by such an equation . in view of @xmath116 and
, we determine this equation , and ( up to a unit in @xmath52 ) get the first stated identity . to get the polynomial @xmath120 , we note that both the quartic polynomial @xmath121 and the quadratic polynomial @xmath122 vanish at @xmath123 , and thus so does their greatest common divisor ( gcd ) . applying the euclidean algorithm ( see appendix [ apx : tors ] for explicit expressions ) , we have @xmath124 where @xmath125 for some polynomials @xmath98 and @xmath99 , and @xmath126 in view of .
thus @xmath127 is the gcd of @xmath128 and @xmath129 , and hence @xmath130 to write @xmath123 in terms of @xmath131 from the above identity , we apply the euclidean algorithm to @xmath107 and @xmath98 .
their gcd turns out to be 1 , and thus there are polynomials @xmath100 and @xmath38 with @xmath132 by we then have @xmath133 , and thus @xmath134 where @xmath120 is as stated .
[ rmk : dmod3 ] the formula for @xmath107 in proposition [ prop : tors ] satisfies a congruence @xmath135 the two roots ( counted with multiplicity ) of @xmath136 which reduce to zero modulo 3 correspond to the two nonzero points in the unique order-3 subgroup of @xmath49 in a formal neighborhood of the identity .
[ prop : isog ] a. [ isog(i ) ] the universal degree-3 isogeny @xmath137 with source @xmath49 is defined over the graded ring @xmath138 \big/ \big ( w({\kappa } ) \big)\ ] ] where @xmath139 and @xmath140 and has target the elliptic curve @xmath141 where @xmath142 b. [ isog(ii ) ] the kernel of @xmath137 is generated by a point @xmath101 of exact order 3 with coordinates @xmath88 satisfying @xmath143 c. [ isog(iii ) ] the restriction of @xmath137 to the supersingular locus at the prime 3 is the 3-power frobenius endomorphism .
d. [ isog(iv ) ] the induced map @xmath144 on the relative cotangent space of @xmath145 at the identity sends @xmath146 to @xmath147 . for the power series expansion of @xmath108 and details of the calculations involving the group law on @xmath49 that appear in the proof .
] let @xmath148 be a point on @xmath49 , and @xmath105 be a nonzero 3-torsion point .
rewriting as @xmath149 we express @xmath108 as a power series in @xmath59 by substituting this equation into itself recursively . for the purpose of our calculations ,
we take this power series up to @xmath150 as an expression for @xmath108 , and write @xmath151 as in .
define functions @xmath152 and @xmath153 by @xmath154 where @xmath155 and @xmath156 denote the @xmath59-coordinate and @xmath108-coordinate of a point respectively . by computing the group law on @xmath49 ,
we express @xmath152 and @xmath153 as power series in @xmath59 : @xmath157 where the coefficients ( @xmath158 , @xmath159 , etc . ) involve @xmath160 , @xmath161 , and @xmath131 . in particular , in view of , we compute that @xmath158 satisfies @xmath162 with @xmath139 as stated in .
now define the isogeny @xmath163 by @xmath164 where we introduce the factor @xmath165 so that the equation of @xmath145 will be in the weierstrass form .
using ( see appendix [ apx : isog ] for explicit expressions ) , we then determine the coefficients in a weierstrass equation and get the stated equation of @xmath145 .
we next check the statement of .
in view of and , the kernel of @xmath137 is the order-3 subgroup generated by @xmath101 . in , the first identity is computed in ; we then compare it with the formula for @xmath120 in proposition [ prop : tors ] and get the second identity . for , recall from section [ subsec : ec ] that the supersingular locus at the prime 3 is @xmath53 .
over @xmath54 , since @xmath166 = 0 $ ] by ( * ? ?
* v.3.1a ) , @xmath101 coincides with the identity , and thus @xmath167 as the @xmath59-coordinate is a local uniformizer at the identity , @xmath137 then restricts to @xmath54 as the 3-power frobenius endomorphism .
the statement of follows by definition of @xmath158 in . in view of proposition
[ prop : isog ] , the formal completion of @xmath163 at the identity of @xmath49 is a _ deformation of frobenius _ in the sense of @xcite . when it is clear from the context , we will simply call @xmath137 itself a deformation of frobenius .
[ rmk : k ] from and we have @xmath168 in particular @xmath169 ( cf .
* proposition 7.5.2 and section 7.7 ) ) .
the analog of @xmath158 at the prime 2 coincides with @xmath131 as studied in ( * ? ? ? * section 3 ) .
recall from section [ subsec : ec ] that @xmath170 in which @xmath60 and @xmath68 are elements with @xmath171 and @xmath71 .
given the graded ring @xmath172 in proposition [ prop : isog ] , define @xmath173 / \big ( w({\alpha } ) \big)\ ] ] where @xmath174 ( cf .
the definition of @xmath2 from @xmath52 in ) . by (
* theorem 1.1 ) we have @xmath175 where @xmath176 is the _ transfer ideal_. in view of this and the construction of _ total power operations _ for morava @xmath0-theories in @xcite , we have the following corollary .
[ cor : psi3 ] the total power operation @xmath177 \big/ \big ( w({\alpha } ) \big)\ ] ] is given by @xmath178 where @xmath179 by proposition [ prop : isog ] , in @xmath180-coordinates , @xmath145 restricts to @xmath21 as @xmath181 where @xmath182 by ( * ? ? ?
* theorem b ) , since the above equation is in the form of , there is a correspondence between the restriction to @xmath21 of the universal isogeny @xmath137 , which is a deformation of frobenius , and the total power operation @xmath19 . in particular @xmath183
is given by @xmath184 .
as @xmath19 is a ring homomorphism , we then get the formula for @xmath185 .
we also have @xmath186 and thus @xmath187 or @xmath188 .
we exclude the former possibility in view of the congruence @xmath189 by ( * ? ? ?
* propositions 3.25 and 10.5 ) .
the congruence follows from remark [ rmk : dmod3 ] and .
recall from proposition [ prop : isog ] that over @xmath172 we have the universal degree-3 isogeny @xmath190 where @xmath191 is an order-3 subgroup of @xmath49 ; in particular , @xmath137 is a deformation of the 3-power frobenius endomorphism over the supersingular locus .
we want to construct a similar isogeny @xmath192 with source @xmath145 so that the composite @xmath193 will correspond to a composite of total power operations via ( * ? ? ?
* theorem b ) .
let @xmath194/g$ ] which is an order-3 subgroup of @xmath145 .
recall from section [ subsec : ec ] that @xmath49 is the universal deformation of a supersingular elliptic curve @xmath56 . since the 3-divisible group of @xmath56 is formal , @xmath195 $ ] is connected .
thus over a formal neighborhood of the supersingular locus , if @xmath191 is the unique connected order-3 subgroup of @xmath49 , @xmath196 is then the unique connected order-3 subgroup of @xmath145 . as in the proof of proposition
[ prop : isog ] , we define @xmath197 using a nonzero point in @xmath196 ( see and ) , and @xmath192 is then a deformation of frobenius . over the supersingular locus ,
the pair @xmath198 is _ cyclic in standard order _ in the sense of @xcite .
we describe it more precisely as below .
[ prop : frob^2 ] the following diagram of elliptic curves over @xmath172 commutes : @xmath199 \node ( lt ) at ( 0 , 2 ) { $ c$ } ; \node ( mt ) at ( 3.8 , 2 ) { $ c / g = $ } ; \node ( rt ) at ( 4.65 , 2.04 ) { $ c'$ } ; \node ( lb ) at ( 1.9 , 0 ) { $ c / c[3]$ } ; \node ( mb ) at ( 3.5 , 0 ) { $ \cong \frac{c / g}{c[3]/g } = $ } ; \node ( rb ) at ( 4.65 , 0.025 ) { $ \frac{c'}{g'}$ } ; \node at ( 4.95 , -0.15 ) { . } ; \draw [ - > ] ( lt ) -- node [ above ] { $ \scriptstyle \psi$ } ( mt ) ; \draw [ - > ] ( lt ) -- node [ left ] { $ \scriptstyle [ -3]$ } ( lb ) ; \draw [ - > ] ( rt ) -- node [ right ] { $ \scriptstyle \psi'$ } ( rb ) ; \end{tikzpicture}\ ] ] by @xcite , since @xmath200 is connected , we need only show that the locus over which @xmath201 $ ] is not empty , where by abuse of notation @xmath202 $ ] denotes the map @xmath202 $ ] on @xmath49 composed with the canonical isomorphism from @xmath203 $ ] to @xmath204 . recall from section [ subsec : ec ] that @xmath49 restricts to the supersingular locus @xmath54 as @xmath55 by proposition [ prop : isog ] both @xmath137 and @xmath192 restrict as the 3-power frobenius endomorphism @xmath205 .
by @xcite , in the endomorphism ring of @xmath56 , @xmath205 is a root of the polynomial @xmath206 with @xmath207 an integer satisfying @xmath208 moreover by ( * ? ? ?
* exercise 5.10a ) , since @xmath56 is supersingular , we have @xmath209 thus @xmath210 , 3 , or @xmath211 .
we exclude the latter two possibilities by checking the action of @xmath205 at the 2-torsion point @xmath212 .
it then follows from that @xmath213 agrees with @xmath202 $ ] on @xmath56 over @xmath54 .
analogous to proposition [ prop : isog ] , let @xmath214 be the element in @xmath172 such that @xmath215 sends @xmath146 to @xmath216 .
note that @xmath217 .
[ cor : k ] the following relations hold in @xmath172 : @xmath218 and @xmath219 the isogenies in induce maps on relative cotangent spaces at the identity . by proposition [ prop : isog ] we then have a commutative diagram ( lt ) at ( 0 , 2 ) @xmath220 ; ( rt ) at ( 4.65 , 2 ) @xmath216 ; ( lb ) at ( 1.9 , 0 ) @xmath146 ; ( rb ) at ( 4.65 , 0 ) @xmath146 ; at ( 4.95 , -0.125 ) . ; ( rt ) node [ above ] @xmath221 ( lt ) ; ( lb ) node [ left ] @xmath222^*$ ] ( lt ) ; ( rb ) node [ right ] @xmath223 ( rt ) ; ( lb ) ( rb ) ; thus for the first stated relation we need only show that @xmath224^*$ ] sends @xmath146 to @xmath225 . for @xmath226 , 2 , 3 , and 4 ,
let @xmath227 be a generator for each of the four order-3 subgroups of @xmath49 .
each @xmath227 can be chosen as @xmath101 in , and we denote the corresponding quantity @xmath158 in by @xmath228 .
define an isogeny @xmath229 with source @xmath49 by @xmath230 in view of , since @xmath224 $ ] has the same kernel as @xmath229 , we have @xmath231^ * ( du ) = s \cdot { \kappa}_1 { \kappa}_2 { \kappa}_3 { \kappa}_4 \cdot du\ ] ] where @xmath232 is a degree-0 unit in @xmath52 coming from an automorphism of @xmath49 over @xmath52 . in view of we
have @xmath233 we then compute that @xmath234 by comparing the restrictions of the two sides of to @xmath2 ( see for the definition of @xmath2 ) : @xmath224^*$ ] becomes the multiplication - by-3 map , and @xmath235 becomes @xmath211 ( cf . the constant term in ) .
thus @xmath224^*$ ] sends @xmath146 to @xmath225 .
the second stated relation follows by a computation from the first relation and the relation @xmath162 as in proposition [ prop : isog ] .
[ rmk : kk ] as noted in remark [ rmk : k ] , the ( local ) analog of @xmath158 at the prime 2 coincides with the parameter @xmath131 in ( * ? ? ?
* section 3 ) . in particular , with the notations there and the equation in (
* proposition 3.2 ) , @xmath131 and @xmath236 satisfy an analogous relation @xmath237 which locally reduces to @xmath238 ( the analog of the factor @xmath232 in the proof of corollary [ cor : k ] equals 1 ; cf .
* theorem 2.5.7 ) ) . these arise as examples of ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 3.21 ) .
[ rmk : k ] in view of , @xmath239 ( composed with the canonical isomorphism on the target ) turns out to be the dual isogeny of @xmath137 ( cf .
the proof of @xcite ) . if @xmath191 is the unique order-3 subgroup of @xmath49 in a formal neighborhood of the identity , then @xmath240 by remark [ rmk : dmod3 ] and .
thus in view of corollary [ cor : k ] and we have @xmath241 this congruence agrees with the interpretation of @xmath242 as defined by the tangent map of the verschiebung isogeny over @xmath54 ( see @xcite ) .
let @xmath3 be a @xmath23-local commutative @xmath0-algebra .
by @xcite and corollary [ cor : psi3 ] , we have a total power operation @xmath243 \big/ \big ( w({\alpha } ) \big).\ ] ] we also have a composite of total power operations @xmath244{\otimes}{_{e_0 [ { \alpha } ] } } ( e^0 b\sigma_3 / i ) \\ \cong \thinspace \thinspace & ~ \big ( a_0 [ { \alpha } ] \big/ \big ( w({\alpha } ) \big ) \big ) \tensor[^{\psi^3}]{\otimes}{_{e_0 [ { \alpha } ] } } \big ( e^0 [ { \alpha } ] \big/ \big ( w({\alpha } ) \big ) \big ) , \end{split}\ ] ] where the elements in the target @xmath245{\otimes}{_r } n$ ] are subject to the equivalence relation ( as well as other ones in a usual tensor product ) @xmath246 for @xmath247 , @xmath248 , and @xmath249 with @xmath250 in view of corollary [ cor : k ] .
define the _ individual power operations _
@xmath251 for @xmath252 , 1 , 2 , and 3 by @xmath253 [ prop : q ] the following relations hold among the individual power operations @xmath254 , @xmath94 , @xmath96 , and @xmath255 : a. [ q(i ) ] @xmath256 b. [ q(ii ) ] @xmath257 c. [ q(iii ) ] _ commutation relations _
d. [ q(iv ) ] _ adem relations _
@xmath259 e. [ q(v ) ] _ cartan formulas _
@xmath260 @xmath261 f. [ q(vi ) ] _ the frobenius congruence _ @xmath262 the relations in , , , and follow computationally from the formulas in corollary [ cor : psi3 ] together with the fact that @xmath19 is a ring homomorphism . for
, there is a canonical isomorphism @xmath203
\cong c$ ] of elliptic curves .
given the correspondence between deformations of frobenius and power operations in ( * ? ? ?
* theorem b ) , the commutativity of then implies that the composite lands in @xmath263 . in terms of formulas
, we have @xmath264 where each
@xmath265 is an @xmath20-linear combination of the @xmath266 s .
the vanishing of @xmath267 , @xmath268 , and @xmath269 gives the three relations in . for , by (
* propositions 3.25 and 10.5 ) we have @xmath270 in view of , the congruence in then follows from .
[ ex ] we have @xmath271 / ( u^2)$ ] . by definition of @xmath158 in , the @xmath272 s
act canonically on @xmath273 : @xmath274 we then get the values of the @xmath272 s on elements in @xmath275 from proposition [ prop : q]- .
[ def : go ] a. [ go(i ) ] let @xmath68 be an element generating @xmath69 over @xmath70 with @xmath71 .
define @xmath276 to be the associative ring generated over @xmath277 by elements @xmath278 , @xmath279 , @xmath280 , and @xmath281 subject to the following relations : the @xmath282 s commute with elements in @xmath283 , and satisfy _ commutation relations _ @xmath284 and _ adem relations _
@xmath285 b. [ go(ii ) ] write @xmath286 which is the kernel of @xmath287 with @xmath271 / ( u^2)$ ] . define @xmath288 as a @xmath276-module in the sense of @xcite with one generator @xmath59 by @xmath289 [ rmk : rank ] in definition [ def : go ] , an element @xmath290 corresponds to the multiplication - by-@xmath291 operation ( see ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 6.4 ) ) , and each @xmath282 corresponds to the individual power operation @xmath272 ( also cf . definition [ def : go ] and example [ ex ] ) . under this correspondence , the relations in proposition [ prop : q]- describe explicitly the structure of @xmath276 as that of a _ graded twisted bialgebra over @xmath20 _ in the sense of ( * ? ? ?
* section 5 ) .
the grading of @xmath276 comes from the number of the @xmath282 s in a monomial : for example , commutation relations are in degree 1 , and adem relations are in degree 2 . under these relations
, @xmath276 has an _ admissible basis _ : it is free as a left @xmath20-module on the elements of the form @xmath292 where @xmath293 ( @xmath294 gives @xmath295 ) , and @xmath296 , 2 , or 3
. if we write @xmath297 $ ] for the degree-@xmath131 part of @xmath276 , then @xmath297 $ ] is of rank @xmath298 .
we now identify @xmath276 with the dyer - lashof algebra of power operations on @xmath23-local commutative @xmath0-algebras .
[ thm : gamma ] let @xmath3 be a @xmath23-local commutative @xmath0-algebra .
let @xmath276 be the graded twisted bialgebra over @xmath20 as defined in definition [ def : go ] , and @xmath288 be the @xmath276-module in definition [ def : go ] .
then @xmath11 is an _
@xmath288-twisted @xmath299-graded amplified @xmath276-ring _ in the sense of ( * ? ? ?
* section 2 ) and ( * ? ? ?
* and 2.6 ) .
in particular , @xmath300 where @xmath301 is the free @xmath288-twisted @xmath299-graded amplified @xmath276-ring with one generator in degree @xmath131 .
formulas for @xmath276 aside , this result is due to rezk @xcite .
let @xmath16 be the graded twisted bialgebra of power operations on @xmath20 in ( * ? ? ?
* section 6 ) .
we need only identify @xmath16 with @xmath276 .
there is a direct sum decomposition @xmath302 $ ] where the summands come from the completed @xmath0-homology of @xmath303 ( see @xcite ) .
as in remark [ rmk : rank ] , we have a degree - preserving ring homomorphism @xmath304 which is an isomorphism in degrees 0 and 1 .
we need to show that @xmath305 is both surjective and injective in all degrees . for the surjectivity of @xmath305
, we use a transfer argument .
we have @xmath306 where @xmath307 is the 3-adic valuation , and @xmath308 is the @xmath131-fold wreath product . thus following the proof of (
* proposition 3.17 ) , we see that @xmath16 is generated in degree 1 , and hence @xmath305 is surjective . by remark [ rmk : rank ] and
( the @xmath20-linear dual of ) ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1.1 ) , @xmath297 $ ] and @xmath309 $ ] are of the same rank @xmath298 as free modules over @xmath20 .
hence @xmath305 is also injective .
let @xmath310 be the @xmath1-localization of @xmath0 .
the following diagram describes the relationship between @xmath1-local power operations on @xmath311 ( cf .
* section 3 ) and ( * ? ? ? * section ix.3 ) ) and the power operation on @xmath312 in corollary [ cor : psi3 ] : ( lt ) at ( 0 , 2 ) @xmath312 ; ( rt ) at ( 3 , 2 ) @xmath313 ; ( lb ) at ( 0 , 0 ) @xmath311 ; ( mb ) at ( 3 , 0 ) @xmath314 ; ( rb ) at ( 4.3 , 0 ) @xmath315 ; ( lt ) node [ above ] @xmath316 ( rt ) ; ( lt ) ( lb ) ; ( rt ) ( mb ) ; ( lb ) node [ above ] @xmath317 ( mb ) ; here @xmath318 is the @xmath1-local power operation induced by @xmath19 , and @xmath319 is the transfer ideal ( cf . ) .
recall from proposition [ prop : isog ] , , and corollary [ cor : psi3 ] that @xmath19 arises from the universal degree-3 isogeny which is parametrized by the ring @xmath172 with @xmath320 the vertical maps are induced by the @xmath1-localization @xmath321 . in terms of homotopy groups
, this is obtained by inverting the generator @xmath322 and completing at the prime 3 ( see ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 1.5.5 ) ) : @xmath323 \qquad { { \rm and}}\qquad f _ * = { { { \mathbb{z}}}}_9 \llbracket h \rrbracket [ h^{-1}]_3^\wedge [ u^{\pm1}]\ ] ] with @xmath324 the formal group @xmath79 over @xmath312 has a unique order-3 subgroup after being pulled back to @xmath311 ( cf . remark [ rmk : dmod3 ] ) , and the map @xmath325 classifies this subgroup . along the base change
@xmath326 the special fiber of the 3-divisible group of @xmath79 which consists solely of a formal component may split into formal and tale components .
we want to take the formal component so as to keep track of the unique order-3 subgroup of the formal group over @xmath311 .
this subgroup gives rise to the @xmath1-local power operation @xmath318 .
recall from that @xmath327 \big/ \big ( w({\alpha } ) \big)$ ] . since @xmath328 the equation @xmath329 has a unique root @xmath330 in @xmath331 ( cf . ) . by hensel
s lemma this unique root lifts to a root in @xmath332 ; it corresponds to the unique order-3 subgroup of @xmath79 over @xmath311 . plugging this specific value of @xmath333 into the formulas for @xmath19 in corollary [ cor : psi3 ]
, we then get an endomorphism of the ring @xmath311 .
this endomorphism is the @xmath1-local power operation @xmath318 . explicitly ,
with @xmath322 invertible in @xmath311 , we solve for @xmath333 from @xmath329 by first writing @xmath334 and then substituting this equation into itself recursively .
we plug the power series expansion for @xmath333 into @xmath335 and get @xmath336 similarly , writing @xmath322 as @xmath337 in @xmath329 , we solve for @xmath333 in terms of @xmath60 and get @xmath338
here we list long formulas whose appearance in the main body might affect readability .
the calculations involve power series expansions and manipulations of long polynomials with large coefficients ( division , factorization , and finding greatest common divisors ) .
they are done using the software _ wolfram mathematica 8_. the commands ` reduce ` and ` solve ` are used to extract relations out of given identities .
in the proof of proposition [ prop : tors ] , we have @xmath339 @xmath340
in the proof of proposition [ prop : isog ] , the power series expansion of @xmath108 in terms of @xmath59 up to @xmath150 is @xmath341 plugging the coordinates of @xmath355 and @xmath356 into , in view of , we then have in @xmath357 more extended power series expansions in @xmath59 for @xmath152 ( up to @xmath358 ) and @xmath153 ( up to @xmath359 ) are needed in to determine the coefficients in the equation of @xmath145 : @xmath360 @xmath361 @xmath362 m. ando , m. j. hopkins , and n. p. strickland , _
elliptic spectra , the witten genus and the theorem of the cube _ ,
invent . math .
* 146 * ( 2001 ) , no . 3 , 595687 .
http://www.ams.org/mathscinet-getitem?mr=1869850[mr1869850 ( 2002g:55009 ) ] matthew ando , _ isogenies of formal group laws and power operations in the cohomology theories @xmath363 _ , duke math . j. * 79 * ( 1995 ) , no . 2 , 423485 .
http://www.ams.org/mathscinet-getitem?mr=1344767[mr1344767 ( 97a:55006 ) ] matthew h. baker , enrique gonzlez - jimnez , josep gonzlez , and bjorn poonen , _ finiteness results for modular curves of genus at least 2 _ , amer
. j. math .
* 127 * ( 2005 ) , no . 6 , 13251387 .
http://www.ams.org/mathscinet-getitem?mr=2183527[mr2183527 ( 2006i:11065 ) ] r. r. bruner , j. p. may , j. e. mcclure , and m. steinberger , _
@xmath364 ring spectra and their applications _ , lecture notes in mathematics , vol .
1176 , springer - verlag , berlin , 1986 .
( 88e:55001 ) ] a. d. elmendorf , i. kriz , m. a. mandell , and j. p. may , _ rings , modules , and algebras in stable homotopy theory _
, mathematical surveys and monographs , vol .
47 , american mathematical society , providence , ri , 1997 , with an appendix by m. cole .
http://www.ams.org/mathscinet-getitem?mr=1417719[mr1417719 ( 97h:55006 ) ] p.
g. goerss and m. j. hopkins , _ moduli spaces of commutative ring spectra _ , structured ring spectra , london math . soc .
lecture note ser .
315 , cambridge univ . press , cambridge , 2004 , pp .
http://www.ams.org/mathscinet-getitem?mr=2125040[mr2125040 ( 2006b:55010 ) ] mark a. hovey , _
@xmath366-elements in ring spectra and applications to bordism theory _ , duke math . j.
* 88 * ( 1997 ) , no . 2 , 327356 .
http://www.ams.org/mathscinet-getitem?mr=1455523[mr1455523 ( 98d:55017 ) ] dale husemller , _ elliptic curves _ , second ed . ,
graduate texts in mathematics , vol .
111 , springer - verlag , new york , 2004 , with appendices by otto forster , ruth lawrence and stefan theisen .
http://www.ams.org/mathscinet-getitem?mr=2024529[mr2024529 ( 2005a:11078 ) ] nicholas m. katz and barry mazur , _ arithmetic moduli of elliptic curves _ , annals of mathematics studies , vol .
108 , princeton university press , princeton , nj , 1985 .
http://www.ams.org/mathscinet-getitem?mr=772569[mr772569 ( 86i:11024 ) ] mark mahowald and charles rezk , _
topological modular forms of level 3 _ , pure appl .
q. * 5 * ( 2009 ) , no . 2 ,
special issue : in honor of friedrich hirzebruch . part 1 , 853872 .
http://www.ams.org/mathscinet-getitem?mr=2508904[mr2508904 ( 2010g:55010 ) ] , _ the congruence criterion for power operations in morava @xmath0-theory _ ,
homology , homotopy appl .
* 11 * ( 2009 ) , no . 2 , 327379 .
http://www.ams.org/mathscinet-getitem?mr=2591924[mr2591924 ( 2011e:55021 ) ] joseph h. silverman , _ the arithmetic of elliptic curves _
, second ed . , graduate texts in mathematics , vol .
106 , springer , dordrecht , 2009 .
http://www.ams.org/mathscinet-getitem?mr=2514094[mr2514094 ( 2010i:11005 ) ] n. e. steenrod , _ cohomology operations _
, lectures by n. e. steenrod written and revised by d. b. a. epstein .
annals of mathematics studies , no .
50 , princeton university press , princeton , n.j . ,
http://www.ams.org/mathscinet-getitem?mr=0145525[mr0145525 ( 26 # 3056 ) ] vladimir voevodsky , _ reduced power operations in motivic cohomology _ , publ .
hautes tudes sci .
( 2003 ) , no .
98 , 157 .
http://www.ams.org/mathscinet-getitem?mr=2031198[mr2031198 ( 2005b:14038a ) ] | we give explicit calculations of the algebraic theory of power operations for a specific morava @xmath0-theory spectrum and its @xmath1-localization .
these power operations arise from the universal degree-3 isogeny of elliptic curves associated to the @xmath0-theory . |
x- and gamma - ray emission lines are valuable signatures of various high - energy processes at work in the universe , including heating of astrophysical gas to very high temperatures , particle acceleration and nucleosynthesis .
perhaps the most important realization of pioneering high - energy astronomy was that hot plasmas are found essentially everywhere in the universe .
more and more detailed observations of thermal x - ray lines provide detailed and often unique information on a wide variety of astrophysical sites , including stellar environments , supernova explosions , accreting compact objects , interstellar and intergalactic media and active galactic nuclei .
particle acceleration is believed to occur in most of these sites .
our understanding of acceleration mechanisms should greatly benefit from the detection of lines produced through atomic and nuclear interactions of energetic particles with ambient matter .
the sun provides valuable examples of these nonthermal radiation processes .
the study of nuclear de - excitation lines produced in solar flares has now become a proper domain of solar physics .
gamma - ray lines are also emitted in the decay of radioactive nuclei .
measurements of gamma - ray activities from cosmic radionuclei testify to the ongoing synthesis of chemical elements and their isotopes in the galaxy and beyond .
these observations are now cornerstones for models of nucleosynthesis in novae , supernovae and stellar interiors .
positron - electron annihilation radiation is relevant to almost all of high - energy astrophysics .
positrons can be produced by various pair - creation processes in relativistic plasmas , by accelerated particle interactions and by the @xmath0-decay of radioisotopes .
observations of their annihilations offer a unique vision of high - energy accreting sources , nucleosynthesis sites and the global structure of the milky way .
the aim of this text is to present the physical processes responsible for these various line emissions .
i also consider emission processes which have not been observed with assurance yet : x - ray line production from accelerated particle interactions and from the decay of cosmic radioactivities , and gamma - ray line emission from thermonuclear plasmas .
however , given the advent of new x - ray and gamma - ray satellites with unprecedented sensitivities and spectral resolutions ( see barret and kndlseder , this volume ) , i am optimistic that at least some of these emissions could be detected in the near future .
the scope of this review is restricted to emission lines .
in particular , i do not discuss x - ray absorption lines recently observed from a handful of active galactic nuclei , as well as cyclotron absorption features in intense magnetic fields , detected from several x - ray binaries . nor do i treat the high - energy gamma - ray emission from pion decay . the plan of this review is the following : in section
2 , i present the basic processes of x - ray line emission in both thermally ionized and photoionized plasmas ; in
3 , i consider nonthermal x - ray line production in interactions of accelerated electrons and ions with ambient gas ; in 4 , i deal with gamma - ray line emission from nuclear collisions and discuss thermonuclear reactions as well as accelerated ion interactions ; in 5 ,
i consider both the gamma - ray lines and the x - ray lines emitted by the decay of radioactive nuclei synthesized in stars ; finally , positron annihilation radiation is discussed in
thermal x - ray emission is observed from a great variety of sources in the universe ( see , e.g. , astronomy & astrophysics , volume 365 , for an overview of the recent _ xmm - newton _ observations ) . it is produced in various ion - electron plasmas , which can be first classified as a function of their optical depth in the x - ray energy range ( 0.1@xmath1@xmath2@xmath1100 kev ) : @xmath3 where @xmath4 is the linear absorption coefficient ( in c.g.s .
units of @xmath5 ) at photon energy @xmath2 and @xmath6 is the typical dimension of the emitting plasma ( cm ) is also called the _ extinction coefficient _ when it includes compton scattering of the x - rays against the free electrons ( e.g. rybicki & lightman @xcite ) . ] .
optically thick sources ( @xmath7@xmath81 ) such as isolated neutron stars essentially emit blackbody radiation , with some possible discrete spectral structures due to complicated radiation transfer effects ( e.g. rajagopal & romani @xcite ) .
optically thin sources include stellar coron , supernova remnants , superbubbles , the hot interstellar medium , clusters of galaxies and the intergalactic medium .
the emission properties of such sources are usually discussed in terms of the _ coronal model _ , based on the pioneering attempt of elwert ( @xcite ) to explain the x - ray emission of the solar corona . in this model ,
the plasma radiation is essentially due to collisions of thermal electrons with ions , but the mechanism for heating the electrons to temperature @xmath9 typically @xmath10 10@xmath11 k is not specified , i.e. @xmath9 is an external parameter of the model .
different x - ray emitting plasmas are found in astrophysical objects such as x - ray binaries and active galactic nuclei , in which a nebular gas of relatively high density can be strongly illuminated by the compact x - ray source .
the physical state and radiation of such photoionized plasmas are generally assumed to be primarily controled by the emission of the compact source and are usually described in terms of the _ nebular model _ , which owes its name to the resemblance of these objects with planetary nebulae . in this section ,
i briefly present the x - ray line production in the coronal model ( 2.1 ) and in the nebular model ( 2.2 ) and then discuss some diagnostics of plasma parameters based on high - resolution , x - ray line spectroscopy ( 2.3 ) .
the coronal model ( see mewe @xcite for a comprehensive description ) applies to an optically thin , tenuous , thermal plasma , in which ( i ) the electrons and the ions are relaxed to maxwellian energy distributions , ( ii ) the ions are essentially in their ground state , i.e. excited state configurations can generally be neglected for the calculation of the ionization balance and ( iii ) each x - ray photon emitted in a microscopic process does not further interact with the ambient ions and electrons .
first order deviations from the coronal model are discussed in raymond ( @xcite ) .
the ionization structure of each element of chemical symbol @xmath12 and atomic ( proton ) number @xmath13 is generally obtained by solving a set of @xmath13 + 1 coupled equations : @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the ionic fraction of ion @xmath16 ( @xmath17=1 ) , @xmath18 and @xmath19 ( in c.g.s .
units of @xmath20 s@xmath21 ) are the total ionization ( @xmath16@xmath22@xmath23 ) and total recombination ( @xmath16@xmath22@xmath24 ) rate coefficients , respectively , and @xmath25 is the electron density ( @xmath26 ) . note that the above equation is valid only if multiple ionizations can be neglected . if the ionization balance is in a steady - state equilibrium ( @xmath27=0 ) , the ionization structure of element @xmath12 is simply given by a set of equations connecting pairs of adjacent ionization states : @xmath28 the plasma is said to be at coronal equilibrium when all elements are at ionization equilibrium .
ionizations are induced by thermal electron collisions .
the ionization coefficient @xmath18 is obtained by averaging the collisional ionization cross section @xmath29 over the maxwell - boltzmann distribution @xmath30 of the relative collision velocity , which is generally very close to the velocity distribution of the much lighter electrons : @xmath31 with @xmath32~,\ ] ] where @xmath33 and @xmath9 are the electron mass and temperature and @xmath34 is the boltzmann constant .
the ionization cross sections are estimated from laboratory measurements combined with atomic physics theory ( in particular distorted wave calculations , e.g. younger @xcite and references therein ) .
apart from direct ionization ( @xmath16+@xmath35@xmath22@xmath23 + 2@xmath35 ) , ion @xmath16 can be stripped of one bound electron through the two - step process of excitation - autoionization ( @xmath16+@xmath35@xmath22@xmath36+@xmath35@xmath22@xmath23 + 2@xmath35 ) , which is due to the collisional excitation of an _ inner - shell _ electron to a bound level above the first ionization threshold , followed by autoionization .
the latter process is due to electron - electron interactions , which can break the compound excited state @xmath36 into its two components : ion @xmath23 and a free electron .
the contribution of excitation - autoionization to the total ionization cross section is calculated from the sum over all possible autoionizing levels _ a _ of the collisional excitation cross sections @xmath37 , weighted by the autoionization probability of each excited state .
recombination of a free electron can proceed either through a radiative free - bound transition ( @xmath23+@xmath35@xmath22@xmath16+@xmath38 ) or by a radiationless dielectronic recombination ( dr ) .
charge - transfer reactions are generally negligible for the hot plasmas considered in the coronal model , but can be very important for photoionized plasmas ( 2.2 ) . since radiative recombination ( rr ) is the inverse of photoionization , the rates of the two processes are connected through the principle of time - reversal invariance .
the application of this principle by means of the detailed balance theorem leads to the milne equation ( milne @xcite ) , which is generally used to calculate rr rate coefficients from photoionization data ( an example of the use of the milne equation is provided in
2.2.2 ) .
however , dr is often the dominant recombination process ( e.g. arnaud & rothenflug @xcite ) .
it is schematically represented in figure 1 .
the first step is a dielectronic capture ( dc ) , in which the energy lost by the plasma electron is expended in the simultaneous excitation of one of the bound electrons in the core of the recombining ion @xmath23 .
the atomic level _
a _ thus produced is said to be doubly - excited , because its configuration involves two electrons occupying subshells above those which they would occupy in the ground state configuration of ion @xmath16 .
dc is the inverse of autoionization , so that the dc rates can be calculated from the autoionization rates , by applying the principle of detailed balancing .
dr occurs if , instead of autoionizing , the doubly - excited state decays by a radiative transition to a level _ b _ below the first ionization limit ( fig .
the stabilizing decay of the core electron produces a so - called _ satellite line _ , as it is slightly shifted , usually to the long - wavelength side of the corresponding transition in ion @xmath23 , due to the electrostatic shielding induced by the spectator outer electron .
satellite line emission can provide very powerful diagnostics of plasma parameters ( 2.3 ) .
shown in figure 2 are the results of arnaud & raymond ( @xcite ) for the ionic fractions of fe at ionization equilibrium .
we see that ions with closed - shell configurations are more stable than those with partially filled l or m shells .
thus , he - like fe xxv ( fe@xmath39 ) , ne - like fe xvii ( fe@xmath40 ) and ar - like fe ix ( fe@xmath41 ) , whose ground state configurations are 1@xmath42 , 2@xmath422@xmath43 and 3@xmath423@xmath43 respectively , are dominant in large temperature ranges , because their ionization and dr rates are relatively low compared to those of adjacent ions . in the coronal model ,
the line spectrum is dominated by radiative decays following electron impact excitation , plus a smaller contribution of recombination lines .
collisional inner - shell ionization can however be important for plasma diagnostics based on fine spectroscopic analyses ( 2.3 ) . considering only the dominant process of collisional excitation
, the volume emissivity @xmath44 ( in units of photons @xmath26 s@xmath21 ) of a particular line transition @xmath45 in ion @xmath16 can be written as @xmath46 here , @xmath47 is the h atomic number density ( @xmath26 ) , @xmath48 is the abundance of element @xmath12 relative to h , @xmath49 ( @xmath20 s@xmath21 ) is the rate coefficient for electron impact excitation of ion @xmath16 from its ground state to its excited state @xmath50 and @xmath51 is the radiative branching ratio of the transition @xmath45 among all possible transitions from level @xmath50 : @xmath52 where @xmath53 is the transition probability ( s@xmath21 ) of the spontaneous decay @xmath45 ( collisional de - excitation is generally neglected ) .
the excitation rate coefficients @xmath49 are calculated by averaging the corresponding cross sections over the maxwellian electron velocity distribution ( see eq .
semi - empirical fitting formulae have been derived for the most significant exciting transitions in all relevant ions ( mewe @xcite and references therein ) .
the line spectrum is generally dominated by the `` allowed '' electric dipole ( @xmath54 ) transitions - coupling , which generally holds for the most abundant ions ( i.e. whose atomic number @xmath13@xmath5529 ) , the quantum selection rules of the @xmath54 transitions are ( e.g. sobelman @xcite ) : @xmath56=@xmath57-@xmath58=0 or @xmath591 , with @xmath57+@xmath58@xmath601 ; @xmath61=@xmath62-@xmath63=0 or @xmath591 ; @xmath64=@xmath65-@xmath66=0 or @xmath591 , with @xmath65+@xmath66@xmath601 ; @xmath67=@xmath68-@xmath69=0 ; @xmath70=-@xmath71 ; and @xmath72=@xmath73-@xmath74=@xmath591 . here ,
@xmath65 and @xmath68 are the orbital and spin angular momenta of the atomic energy level @xmath50 , which combine to the total angular momentum @xmath57 of magnetic quantum number @xmath62 ; @xmath70 is the parity of level @xmath50 ; and @xmath73 and @xmath74 are the orbital angular momenta of the individual `` jumping '' electron in the atomic states @xmath50 and @xmath75 , respectively .
radiative transitions which violate one of these selection rules are said to be `` forbidden '' and are usually weaker . ] .
however , forbidden lines can be relatively bright if they are produced by the decays of excited levels which can not de - excite by an @xmath54 transition . with the advent of new x - ray instruments with high sensitivity and resolution capabilities , such as those aboard the _ xmm - newton _ and _ chandra _ satellites , the correct modeling of relatively weak lines has become increasingly important .
the three main coronal - plasma emission codes , spex ( kaastra _ et al . _
@xcite ) , chianti ( landi _ et al . _
@xcite ) and apec ( smith _ et al . _
@xcite ) , now calculate tens of thousands of lines in the x - ray energy band .
= 30 mk , for three values of the ionization parameter . for @xmath76=10@xmath77
@xmath26 s , the plasma has reached the ionization equilibrium .
the calculations are normalized to the reduced emission measure @xmath78=10@xmath79 @xmath80 , where @xmath6 is the distance to the source and @xmath81 ( in @xmath26 ) is the total emission measure ( which is directly proportional to the x - ray production rate , see eq .
2.6 ) . in each panel , the spectra for @xmath76=10@xmath82 and 10@xmath77 @xmath26 s are divided by 100 and 10@xmath83 , respectively .
all spectra are plotted in energy bins of 10 ev.,title="fig : " ] + = 30 mk , for three values of the ionization parameter . for @xmath76=10@xmath77
@xmath26 s , the plasma has reached the ionization equilibrium .
the calculations are normalized to the reduced emission measure @xmath78=10@xmath79 @xmath80 , where @xmath6 is the distance to the source and @xmath81 ( in @xmath26 ) is the total emission measure ( which is directly proportional to the x - ray production rate , see eq .
2.6 ) . in each panel , the spectra for @xmath76=10@xmath82 and 10@xmath77 @xmath26 s are divided by 100 and 10@xmath83 , respectively .
all spectra are plotted in energy bins of 10 ev.,title="fig : " ] as an illustration of the dependence of the x - ray line spectrum on the ionization structure of a radiating plasma , figure 3 shows calculated emissions of a transient source , that has been instantaneously heated to @xmath9=30@xmath8410@xmath11 k at time @xmath85=0 .
i used the non - equilibrium ionization ( nei ) plasma model ( borkowski _ et al .
_ @xcite and references therein ) , recently implemented in the xspec v11 spectral software package ( see ballet , this volume ) .
assuming constant electron temperature and density , we see from eq .
( 2.2 ) that the evolution of the ionization structure can be entirely characterized by the product @xmath76 , which is called the ionization parameter .
the evolving line spectrum is superimposed on a quasi - static continuum , which , for @xmath9=30 mk , is mainly produced by the thermal bremsstrahlung of the plasma electrons ( free - free emission ) . however , the continuum radiation of plasmas with lower temperatures is often dominated by radiative recombinations ( mewe _ et al . _
this emission is considered in 2.2.2 .
the line emission generally shifts towards higher energies as the emitting ions become more and more ionized . for example , we see for @xmath76=10@xmath82 @xmath26 s in panel ( _ a _ ) , a prominent line forest at @xmath861 kev , which mainly consists of fe l lines , i.e. 3@xmath73@xmath222@xmath74 electronic transitions in ions fe xvii - xxiv .
this emission is much weaker for @xmath76=10@xmath77 @xmath26 s , because in a 30 mk plasma at ionization equilibrium the most abundant fe ion is the he - like fe xxv ( see fig . 2 ) .
the strongest line emission is then the fe k@xmath87 line complex ( 2@xmath88@xmath221@xmath89 transitions in the siegbahn notation ) at @xmath866.7 kev .
fe k lines are also produced by inner - shell excitation or ionization of less ionized fe , but as shown in panel ( _ b _ ) , their energies are slightly lower , because the atomic levels get closer as the electrostatic shielding induced by the bound electrons increases .
for example , the fe k@xmath87 line ( which is made of the two very close components k@xmath90@xmath912@xmath92@xmath221@xmath93 and k@xmath94@xmath912@xmath95@xmath221@xmath93 ) is at 6.40 kev for fe ii - xii , 6.70 kev for fe xxv and 6.97 kev for fe xxvi ( see panel _ b _ ) .
determinations of the precise energy and intensity of various lines thus provide direct information on the ionization structure of a coronal plasma .
the nebular model ( e.g. kallman & mccray @xcite , liedahl @xcite ) is intended to describe the physical state and emission of a plasma illuminated by intense x - ray radiation .
the most important applications of this model are accretion - powered x - ray sources : active galactic nuclei , x - ray binaries and cataclysmic variables . in these objects ,
circumsource material is believed to intercept some of the radiation emitted from a compact region near the accreting source and to reprocess it into line and continuum emission in other portions of the spectrum .
the main assumption of the nebular model is that the temperature and ionization structure of the illuminated gas are essentially governed by the interactions of the radiation field with the ion - electron plasma .
possible additional heating sources , such as shocks or magnetic - field reconnection , are thus generally neglected .
the temperature and ionization structure of a photoionized plasma are obviously intimately connected .
for example , recombination of thermal electrons affects both the charge state distribution and the plasma cooling rate .
thus , the state of the plasma has to be determined by solving a set of coupled equations describing the ionization balance together with the thermal equilibrium .
most photoionized - plasma models which have been developed so far ( see ferland _
_ @xcite and references therein ) assume that the ionization and energy balances are in a steady - state , i.e. that the time scales for variation in the compact source emission and in the plasma global parameters are long compared to the characteristic time scales for the atomic processes .
the ionic fractions of adjacent charge states are then connected through a generalization of eq .
( 2.3 ) , which obviously has to take into account the dominant process of photoionization , but also the possible contribution of charge - exchange reactions ( e.g. halpern & grindlay @xcite ) : @xmath96 = \eta_z^{i+1 } \cdot [ n_e\alpha_{z^{+(i+1)}}(t ) + k^r_{z^{+(i+1)}}(t)]~.\ ] ] here , @xmath97 is the photoionization rate ( in units of s@xmath21 ) , which depends on the flux of the illuminating radiation @xmath98 ( see below ) , and @xmath99 and @xmath100 are the effective ionization and recombination rates due to charge - transfer reactions ( also in s@xmath21 ) , which , for a gas of given composition and density , only depend on the ionic fractions of h and he , and on the plasma temperature @xmath101 .
ionization by thermal electron impact ( of rate coefficient @xmath102 ,
2.1.1 ) is often unimportant , because , contrary to coronal plasmas , the temperature of photoionized gas may not reach the ionization threshold energy of many ions .
lower temperatures can also modify the relative contributions of dr and rr to the total recombination rate coefficient @xmath103 ( 2.1.1 ) : in a photoionized plasma , radiationless dielectronic capture proceeds primarily through core excitations of relatively low energies , i.e. essentially transitions of core electrons to the same shell ( @xmath104=0 excitations , @xmath105 being the principal quantum number ) .
thus , rr generally dominates the total recombination rate for h - like and he - like ions , since these species have no available @xmath104=0 excitations . on the other hand
, dr can be the main recombination process for ions with partially filled l or m shells ( liedahl @xcite and references therein ) .
the photoionization rate @xmath97 is obtained by folding the radiation field with the corresponding photoionization cross section @xmath106 : @xmath107 where @xmath108 is the ionization threshold energy of ion @xmath16 and @xmath109 is the net energy flux at the distance @xmath110 from the compact source ( in c.g.s units of erg s@xmath21 @xmath111 erg@xmath21 ) .
for example , for an isotropic point source of total luminosity @xmath112 and spectrum @xmath113=@xmath112@xmath114 , assuming that the source radiation is not significantly attenuated by photoabsorption , the photoionization rate is simply given by @xmath115 however , photoionization is often enhanced by the emission of one or more auger electrons in addition to the original photoelectron .
for example , photoionization of a k - shell electron in an ion having two or more l - shell electrons leaves the resulting ion in an _ autoionizing _ state that can decay by ejecting at least one l - shell electron .
the l - shell vacancy thus produced can further be filled by an other radiationless auger transition if the ion has two or more m - shell electrons .
this cascade process can lead to the ejection of up to eight auger electrons following the creation of a k - shell vacancy in neutral iron ( kaastra & mewe @xcite ) .
thus , ionization balance calculations in the framework of the nebular model are generally complicated by the possible coupling of several charge states in each element ( weisheit @xcite ) .
note that additional ionization can be produced by collisions of the fast ejected electrons with neighbouring ions ( halpern & grindlay @xcite ) . however ,
if most of ambient h and he are ionized , these electrons will slow down primarily by elastic scattering with thermal electrons , thus depositing their energy as heat .
charge - transfer reactions can be very important for the ionization structure of a photoionized plasma , if a significant abundance of neutral h or he atoms ( i.e. with neutral fraction typically exceeding @xmath860.01 ) coexists with ionized heavy elements .
they are of the form @xmath116 where @xmath117@xmath91h or he and @xmath118 is the energy defect , which can be either a positive or a negative quantity depending on the reaction and on the atomic states involved in the electron transfer ( e.g. kingdon & ferland @xcite ) .
the rate coefficients are obtained by integrating the reaction cross sections over the maxwell - boltzmann distribution of the relative collision velocity .
detailed quantum mechanical calculations were performed for few important reactions . for other systems , the cross sections can be reasonably estimated by use of the landau - zener approximation ( kingdon & ferland @xcite and references therein ) . in the nebular model , the plasma temperature is determined by solving the equation of thermal equilibrium : @xmath119 where the left- and the right - hand sides represent the total heating and cooling rates ( erg @xmath26 s@xmath21 ) of the thermal bath , respectively . here , @xmath120 is the heating rate per free electron due to compton scattering~,\ ] ] where @xmath121 is the thomson cross section and @xmath122 is the speed of light .
the first term in the brackets represents the heating of relatively cold electrons by scattering with x - rays and includes the first order klein - nishina correction , and the second term represents the cooling of hot electrons by scattering with lower energy photons ( see also marcowith , this volume ) . ] ; @xmath123 is the effective photoionization heating rate , which includes heating by the auger electrons ( shull @xcite ) ; @xmath124=@xmath125@xmath84@xmath118 is the heating rate due to exothermic ( @xmath118@xmath100 ) charge - transfer recombinations or ionizations ( kingdon & ferland @xcite ) ; @xmath126 is the thermal bremsstrahlung cooling rate due to free - free emission ( see marcowith , this volume ) ; @xmath127 is the recombination cooling rate due to both rr and dr ( halpern & grindlay @xcite and references therein ) ; @xmath128 is the cooling rate due to collisional excitation or ionization by thermal electron impacts ; and @xmath129 is the cooling rate due to endothermic ( @xmath118@xmath550 ) charge - transfer reactions . alternatively ,
the thermal balance can be established by calculating the rate of removal or addition of energy to the local radiation field associated with each of the processes affecting atomic level populations ( kallman & bautista @xcite ) .
it is instructive to compare the line production in photoionized plasmas and in thermally ionized plasmas . in the coronal model ,
the electron population responsible for the plasma ionization structure is also an efficient source of collisional line excitation . on the other hand ,
a photoionized plasma is generally overionized relative to the electron temperature , since the thermal electrons are not the dominant source of ionization .
collisional excitation is then often unimportant in the x - ray energy range and the line emission is preferentially due to recombination of relatively low - energy electrons and to photon - induced fluorescence .
therefore , whereas in the coronal model , line production in ion @xmath16 is generally proportional to its ionic fraction @xmath15 ( eq . 2.6 ) , in the nebular model it is dominated by processes involving adjacent charge states : recombination of ion @xmath23 and inner - shell photoionization of ion @xmath24 .
this difference allows to distinguish between coronal and nebular gas emission of cosmic origin by observing various line intensity ratios from the same element .
for example , liedahl _ et al . _
( @xcite ) have shown that the ( 3@xmath89@xmath222@xmath88)/(3@xmath130@xmath222@xmath88 ) line ratios from fe xvii - xix can be used to discriminate between thermally ionized and photoionized plasmas , because the 3@xmath130 lines are preferentially produced by electron impact excitation in a hot coronal plasma ( 5 - 10 mk , see fig .
2 ) , whereas the 3@xmath89 lines are mostly formed by recombination in a cooler ( @xmath860.1 mk ) nebular plasma .
line emission in the x - ray energy range is dominated by the k lines of c , n , o , ne , mg , si , ar , ca , fe and ni and the l lines of fe and ni .
thus , recombination lines are produced in relatively highly ionized ions , having in their ground state at least one k - shell vacancy , or one l - shell vacancy for fe@xmath131 and ni@xmath131 . on the other hand , fluorescent lines being due to radiative transitions from the l or m shell following inner - shell photoionization , they are generally associated with colder , less ionized plasmas .
recombination radiation in overionized plasmas has been observed from several high mass x - ray binaries ( e.g. sako _ et al .
_ @xcite and references therein ) .
it consists of radiative recombination `` continua '' ( see below ) and lines produced through recombination to excited states followed by radiative cascades .
the volume emissivity ( photons @xmath26 s@xmath21 ) of a given line transition @xmath45 in ion @xmath16 can be written as @xmath132 where @xmath133 is the effective recombination rate coefficient to the level @xmath50 ( including recombination to higher levels followed by radiative transitions to level @xmath50 ) and the other quantities are defined above in eq .
radiative recombination continuum ( rrc ) is produced by the first free - bound transition .
the monochromatic specific emissivity ( photons s@xmath21 @xmath26 erg@xmath21 ) from radiative capture of a free electron of velocity @xmath134 is given by @xmath135 where the energy of the radiated photon is equal to the sum of the ionization potential of the recombined ion @xmath36 , which may or may not be formed in an excited state , plus the kinetic energy of the recombining electron , @xmath136 @xmath30 is the thermal electron velocity distribution ( eq .
2.5 ) and @xmath137 is the radiative recombination cross section , which is related to the corresponding photoionization cross section through the milne equation ( see e.g. mewe @xcite ) : @xmath138 here , @xmath139=2@xmath140 + 1 is the statistical weight of ion @xmath16 , whose total angular momentum is @xmath140 . combining these equations provides the rrc emissivity as a function of the electron temperature : @xmath141~.\ ] ] the photoionization cross sections are rapidly decreasing functions of photon energy from ionization thresholds . for example , they are about proportional to @xmath142 for hydrogenic ions ( see also fig
we see from the above equation that the rrc emissivities are steep functions of energy as well . in photoionized plasmas ,
the rrc emissions often appear as relatively narrow features in the spectrum ( sometimes `` line - like '' features ) , with approximate width @xmath143@xmath86@xmath144 ( liedahl @xcite ) .
analyses of rrc shapes can thus allow determination of the electron temperature of the emitting plasma .
fluorescent line emission has been observed from a number of galactic x - ray binaries ( e.g. ebisawa _ et al . _
@xcite , sako _ et al . _
@xcite ) and active galactic nuclei ( fabian _ et al .
_ @xcite and references therein ) .
it is produced when an inner - shell photoionization is followed by a radiative transition .
the volume emissivity of a fluorescent line @xmath45 is thus given by @xmath145 where @xmath146 is the inner - shell photoionization rate of ion @xmath24 , leading to ion @xmath16 in the excited level @xmath147 ( see eqs . 2.9 and 2.10 ) and @xmath148 is the @xmath45 line fluorescence yield , i.e. the number of photons emitted in the line @xmath45 per ion @xmath16 in the level @xmath147 .
note that the line @xmath45 is not necessarily produced in ion @xmath16 , since the first decay of the level @xmath147 can be an auger transition to an excited state @xmath149 of ion @xmath23 .
auger electron emission can repeat several times before the line @xmath45 is emitted in ion @xmath150 and the calculation of the overall process can become cumbersome , since millions of transitions can follow a single inner - shell ionization . for example , 5.1 millions of auger or radiative transitions are possible after an fe i k - shell ionization ( kaastra & mewe @xcite ) . the convention is therefore to refer to the inner - shell vacancy produced in ion @xmath24 , rather than to the excited atomic level @xmath147 of ion @xmath16 .
for example , we speak of the k@xmath87 fluorescence yield for _ neutral _ fe ( for which i will adopt the notation @xmath151@xmath91@xmath152 ) , although this quantity strictly describes an atomic property of ion fe@xmath153 . the fluorescence yield is a strongly increasing function of ion atomic number @xmath13 . for example
, @xmath154=@xmath155+@xmath156 varies approximately as @xmath157 for a k - shell vacancy produced in neutral atoms up to fe ( krause @xcite ) .
that explains why the most prominent fluorescent line observed so far is the k@xmath87 line from weakly - ionized fe , since this element has the highest product of k@xmath87 fluorescence yield ( @[email protected] for fe i - ix , kaastra & mewe @xcite ) and cosmic ( i.e. solar ) abundance ( @xmath159=3.2@xmath8410@xmath160 , anders & grevesse @xcite ) .
the line emission at @xmath866.4 kev is often accompanied by a sharp absorption edge at 7.1 kev , the k - shell electron binding energy in neutral or weakly - ionized fe : nearly 30% ( = @xmath158 ) of the photons absorbed above this threshold energy are `` re - emitted '' in the fe k@xmath87 line . however ,
if the nebular plasma is optically thick to the ionizing continuum in some portions of the spectrum , radiative transfer is generally important and has to be taken into account from a geometrical model of the emitting source ( e.g. fabian _ et al . _
the problem of continuum and line transfer at intermediate optical depth is a difficult one and is generally tackled from approximate solutions to the full transfer equation ( e.g. kallman & bautista @xcite ) .
it is particularly relevant for resonance lines , which correspond to allowed transitions to ground ionic levels and can be emitted following radiative recombination or collisional excitation .
indeed , photons emitted in such lines can have a high probability to be absorbed by the same transition which emitted them and `` re - emitted '' at a new frequency .
this frequency redistribution can repeat many times until the photon either escapes the gas or is destroyed by photoabsorption ( e.g. faurobert @xcite ) .
= 10@xmath161 @xmath26 , illuminated by a steady state , isotropic point source at @xmath110=0 . in panel ( _ b _ ) , the dashed line is the source spectrum , @xmath162@xmath163=1.45@xmath16410@xmath165@xmath84@xmath2@xmath21 erg s@xmath21 kev@xmath21 , and the grey area shows the source emission after transmittance through the shell .
the total emerging spectrum ( solid line ) is the sum of the transmitted source emission plus the thermal radiation ( mostly recombination radiation ) and fluorescence emission from the photoionized shell . ] by way of illustrated summary , i show in figure 4 calculated thermal structure and emission of a spherical gas shell photoionized by a central source .
i used the xstar version 2.1h computer code developed by kallman _
et al._. we see in panel ( _ a _ ) that the temperature is found to decrease from @xmath8610@xmath166 k ( @[email protected] ev ) in the internal region of the shell to nearly 10@xmath83 k in the outermost region .
thus , collisional excitation is negligible in the x - ray energy range and the line emission in panel ( _ b _ ) is mostly due to radiative recombination .
the fe k@xmath87 fluorescent line emission at @xmath866.5 kev and the corresponding absorption above 7.1 kev are also visible .
the irregular continuum emission from the photoionized shell is produced by overlapping radiative recombination continua and two - photon decays of metastable levels , which can not decay by a single - photon transition@xmath168 @xmath91 2@xmath169 and 2@xmath170 , respectively . in this usual notation , @xmath105 is the principal quantum number of the outermost occupied shell ; @xmath171 is the total orbital quantum number , which , in the russell - saunders @xmath172-coupling , is given by the vectorial sum of the individual electron orbital angular momenta ; @xmath173 is the total spin angular momentum , obtained by the vectoral coupling of the spin angular momentum ( @xmath89=@xmath174 ) of all the electrons ( @xmath175=@xmath176 is called the multiplicity of the level ) ; and @xmath177 is the total angular momentum , which is the vector sum @xmath171+@xmath173 for @xmath172 coupling .
the orbital quantum number @xmath171 is usually designated by the symbols @xmath173 , @xmath178 , @xmath6 , @xmath179 , @xmath180 (corresponding to `` harp '' , `` rincipal '' , `` iffuse '' , `` undamental '' and the subsequent letters to the alphabetical order ) for @xmath171=0,1,2,3,4 thus , the level 2@xmath169 of h - like ions corresponds to the electron being in the 2@xmath89 subshell and the level 2@xmath170 of he - like ions to the two electrons being in the 1@xmath89 and 2@xmath89 subshells with antiparallel spins ( @xmath173=0 ) .
it follows from the quantum selection rules that for these two levels , the 2@xmath89 electron can not decay by a single - photon transition ( e.g. sobelman @xcite ) . ]
( thermal bremsstrahlung is negligible in this energy domain ) .
the most prominent rrc in panel ( _ b _ ) is the triangular feature just above 54 ev ( i.e. in the extreme ultraviolet waveband ) , produced by free electron recombination to the k - shell of fully - ionized he .
as already mentioned , simple spectroscopic analyses of the x - ray line emission from a hot plasma can provide valuable information , such as the ionization processes ( photoionization and/or collisional ionization ) , the elemental abundances and the ionization balance .
the recent launch of x - ray instruments with high sensitivity and spectral resolution , such as the grating spectrometers aboard the _ xmm - newton _ and _ chandra _ satellites , allows more refined diagnostics of plasma parameters , among which those based on satellite lines and helium - like line triplets may deserve special attention .
satellite lines are produced by stabilizing transitions in the process of dielectronic recombination ( 2.1.1 ) .
the most important of such lines arise from the dielectronic capture of a free electron into the l - shell and appear on the long - wavelength side of the parent resonance line .
for example , the relatively strong satellite line @xmath181@xmath911@xmath892@xmath182[@xmath183@xmath221@xmath422@xmath88[@xmath184 is at 6.744 ( 1.838 kev ) for li - like si xii , whereas the corresponding resonance line @xmath185@xmath911@xmath892@xmath88[@xmath186@xmath221@xmath42[@xmath170 ] in he - like si xiii is at 6.647 ( 1.865 kev ; gabriel @xcite ) .
the dr satellite - to - resonance line intensity ratios are very sensitive to the electron temperature of a coronal plasma .
this is fundamentally due to the resonant character of the dr process ( fig .
1 ) compared to the collisional excitation process : a dr satellite line is produced only by free electrons of energy close to the excitation energy of the satellite line level ( within the small level width ) , whereas a resonance line can be excited by all electrons with any energy above the resonance line energy .
this also provides a way to evaluate a possible deviation of the electron velocity distribution from a maxwellian distribution .
thus , the existence of a high - energy tail of nonthermal electrons in turbulent plasmas could be identified through an increase of the resonance line intensities relative to the dr satellite line intensities ( gabriel & phillips @xcite ) .
collisional inner - shell excitation ( ie ) can also contribute to the emission of certain satellite lines , such as the line @xmath188@xmath911@xmath892@xmath892@xmath88[@xmath184@xmath221@xmath422@xmath89[@xmath169 ] ( at 6.718 in si xii ) . because the simultaneous excitation of two electrons is generally highly improbable , some lines ( @xmath181 for example ) can only be produced from excited state configurations ( 1@xmath422@xmath88 for line @xmath181 ) , which are negligible in low - density plasmas .
however , these excited levels can obtain a significant population at equilibrium for high electron density ( e.g. at @xmath25@xmath8610@xmath190@xmath26 for si xii ) , thus introducing a density dependence of satellite lines .
the intensity ratio of a ie satellite line to its parent resonance line is almost independent of temperature , since these two lines are excited by nearly the same electron population .
however , it does depend on the plasma ionization structure , as the intensity of an ie satellite line in ion @xmath16 is proportional to the ionic fraction @xmath15 , whereas the intensity of the corresponding resonance line in ion @xmath23 is proportional to @xmath191 .
thus , satellite lines can also provide diagnostics of the ionization state of a transient plasma .
.,width=283 ] i now briefly present diagnostics based on the well - known he - like @xmath105=2@xmath221 line triplet .
this system consists of three close lines ( fig . 5 ) :
the resonance @xmath54 line @xmath185 , the forbidden magnetic dipole ( @xmath192 ) line @xmath13 and the intercombination line @xmath193+@xmath194 , which is made of two unresolvable components that violate the selection rule @xmath67=0 ( see footnote 2 ) because of magnetic interactions . in si xiii for example , the lines are at 6.684 , 6.687 and 6.739 , for the @xmath193 , @xmath194 and @xmath13 transitions , respectively . as first shown by gabriel & jordan ( @xcite ) , the emissivity ratio of the forbidden to intercombination lines , @xmath195 is strongly sensitive to the electron density above a certain value ( @xmath865@xmath16410@xmath196 @xmath26 for si xiii and @xmath865@xmath16410@xmath197 @xmath26 for c v ) .
this is due to the collisional excitation of the metastable level 2@xmath198 to the close levels 2@xmath199 , which leads to a decrease of the @xmath200 ratio with increasing electron density .
this density measurement can be applied to recombination dominated plasmas as well as to coronal plasmas .
however , photoexcitation of the 2@xmath198 level to the 2@xmath201 term may not be negligible for photoionized plasmas illuminated by intense ultraviolet radiation ( porquet _ et al .
_ @xcite and references therein ) .
gabriel & jordan ( @xcite ) also showed that the emissivity ratio @xmath202 can be used to diagnose the electron temperature of a coronal plasma , since the collisional excitation rates have not the same temperature dependence for the resonance line as for the forbidden and intercombination lines .
this ratio can also serve as an indication of the validity of the coronal model ( e.g. porquet & dubau @xcite ) .
indeed , a strong resonance line is expected in plasmas dominated by collisional excitation . on the other hand , since radiative recombinations to the 2@xmath203 and 2@xmath201 triplet terms are favored as compared with the 2@xmath204 level , a significant contribution of photoionization leads to a relatively high @xmath205 ratio ( see also liedahl @xcite ) .
porquet & dubau ( @xcite ) and porquet _ et al . _
( @xcite ) have recently provided detailed calculations of the line ratios @xmath200 and @xmath205 for the most important he - like ions .
satellite lines and he - like triplet lines have proven to be very useful to characterize laboratory plasmas , as well as coronal plasmas heated by solar flares ( e.g. harra - murnion _ et al . _
the new generation of x - ray spectrometers now allows to use the same powerful diagnostics for cosmic sources ( e.g. weisskopf _ et al .
_ @xcite and references therein ; see also ballet , this volume ) .
nonthermal electron and ion populations are expected to occur in various astrophysical plasmas , when kinetic energy is deposited by acceleration processes into the tail of the distributions , at a rate that is sufficiently high to overcome the thermal equilibration processes .
the impacts of a nonthermal electron tail on the ionization balance and x - ray line emission of such `` hybrid '' plasmas were first studied for solar flares and more recently for supernova remnants and clusters of galaxies ( e.g. porquet _ et al .
_ @xcite and references therein ) . in the following ,
i consider nonthermal x - ray line production in a different context , namely from nonthermal particles escaping from the acceleration region and interacting in a distinct target medium .
it is the most usual situation in laboratory experiments , but paradoxically , it has received little attention in astrophysics .
fast electrons interacting in an ambient medium can produce x - ray lines by collisional excitation and inner - shell ionization .
nonthermal x - ray line production by suprathermal electron interactions has been proposed to account for the observation in impulsive solar flares of enhanced fe k@xmath87 line emission at @xmath866.4 kev that is coincident with the hard x - ray burst ( zarro _ et al . _
recently , valinia _ et al . _
( @xcite ) suggested that the interaction of low - energy cosmic - ray electrons with interstellar matter could make a significant contribution to the fe k line complex observed in the spectrum of the galactic ridge x - ray background .
here , i assume for simplicity that the interaction region is composed of neutral atoms , such that x - ray line emission can result from inner - shell ionization but not from collisional excitation
. however , the fast electrons can also produce continuum hard x - rays via nonthermal bremsstrahlung , which in turn can produce fluorescent line emission via photoionization .
thus , each line can generally result from a combination of collisional ionization and photoionization , with relative contributions depending on the accelerated electron spectrum and on ambient medium parameters .
i now discuss some fundamental differences between the two atomic processes . /@xmath206
, where @xmath207 is the stopping range in c.g.s . units of g @xmath208 from berger & seltzer ( @xcite ) and @xmath206 is the mass of the h - atom.,title="fig:",width=222 ] /@xmath206 , where @xmath207 is the stopping range in c.g.s . units of g @xmath208 from berger & seltzer ( @xcite ) and @xmath206 is the mass of the h - atom.,title="fig:",width=222 ] a compilation of cross sections for k - shell ionization is shown in figure 6a .
we see that whereas the photoionization cross sections are steep functions of energy ( they vary approximately as @xmath209 from ionization thresholds ) the cross sections for collisional ionization have a much harder energy dependence , in particular , a rise in the mev region caused by relativistic effects ( e.g. hoffmann _ et al . _
thus , while fluorescence is essentially produced by photons with energy contained in a range of a few kev above the ionization threshold , ultra - relativistic electrons can still produce significant x - ray line emission .
we also see that the relative contributions of collisional ionization and photoionization will generally depend on the target element @xmath12 . numerically , the k - shell ionization cross section scales approximately as @xmath210 for the electrons , whereas it scales about as @xmath211 for the photons .
propagation makes an other important difference between electron- and photon - induced ionization .
figure 6b shows the stopping range of low - energy electrons in a neutral h gas .
taking into account ambient he with @xmath212=0.1 reduces the plotted range , measured in h - atoms @xmath111 , by a factor of @xmath861.18 .
thus , suprathermal electrons @xmath55100 kev injected in a neutral atomic gas of solar composition would stop in 4@xmath8410@xmath213 h - atoms @xmath111 . as we will see below
, these electrons could produce in such a thick target an observable fe k@xmath87 line emission . in comparison
, the optical depth of @xmath107.1 kev x - rays with respect to photoelectric absorption is @[email protected] for @xmath215=4@xmath8410@xmath213 @xmath111 , such that fe k - shell ionizing photons would barely interact in the target region . as a basic introduction to nonthermal processes ,
let us now calculate the x - ray emission produced by the interaction of a steady state , suprathermal electron source with a thick target composed of neutral atoms with solar abundances . for simplicity , i assume that the nonthermal electron population does not modify the state of the ambient medium , i.e. that ionization and heat deposition are negligible .
i further assume that the typical column density of the interaction region is sufficiently low to safely neglect the fluorescent line emission due to photoionization of the ambient atoms by the bremsstrahlung x - rays . the differential x - ray production rate ( photons s@xmath21
kev@xmath21 ) can then be written as @xmath216 de_e ~,\ ] ] where @xmath217 is the differential injection rate of suprathermal electrons into the target region , measured in electrons s@xmath21 kev@xmath21 , @xmath218 is the differential x - ray production cross section for electron interactions with atoms @xmath12 ( @xmath91@xmath219 ) and @xmath220 is the electron energy loss rate per unit path length in the ambient medium , measured in kev @xmath5 . in this equation ,
the term in the brackets gives the monochromatic x - ray production by an electron of energy @xmath221 as it slows down to rest in the ambient medium , which has to be integrated over the energy distribution of the nonthermal electrons .
10@xmath213 @xmath111 ( see text ) . ] as h and he are by far the most abundant constituents of the interaction region , we have @xmath222~,\ ] ] where @xmath206 and @xmath223 are the h- and he - atom masses , and @xmath224 and @xmath225 are the electron stopping powers ( in units of kev g@xmath21 @xmath226 ) in ambient h and he , respectively ( berger & seltzer @xcite ) . inserting eq .
( 3.2 ) into eq . ( 3.1 ) , we see that under the assumption of thick target interactions , the x - ray production rate depends on the relative abundances @xmath48 of the ambient medium constituents , but _ not on the density_. i consider for the x - ray line production the k@xmath87 and k@xmath227 ( 3@xmath88@xmath221@xmath89 ) lines from ambient c ,
n , o , ne , mg , si , s , ar , ca and fe .
the corresponding cross sections can be written as @xmath228 where @xmath229 is the energy of line k@xmath230 ( k@xmath87 or k@xmath227 ) , @xmath231 is dirac s delta function , @xmath232 is the cross section for the k - shell ionization of atom @xmath12 by an electron of energy @xmath221 ( quarles @xcite ) and @xmath233 is the k@xmath230 fluorescence yield for atom @xmath12 ( firestone @xcite , appendix f , and references therein ) . note that @xmath156=0 for @xmath13@xmath23412 ( i.e. mg ) , since these atoms do not have 3@xmath88 electrons in their ground level . for the x - ray continuum emission ,
i take into account electron bremsstrahlung in ambient h and he only and calculate the corresponding differential cross sections from equation ( 3bn ) in koch & motz ( @xcite ) , with the elwert correction factor which is appropriate at nonrelativistic energies . the result is shown in figure 7 ( solid line ) for the differential injection rate of suprathermal electrons @xmath235 @xmath236 however , the calculated emission is obviously not realistic , since the assumption that the target region is sufficiently thick to stop @xmath55100 kev electrons implies that some photoelectric absorption must occur .
it generally has to be taken into account from a geometrical model of the emitting region . in figure 7 , the dashed line spectrum is intended for providing a simple illustration of the effect of photoelectric absorption .
it is obtained by multiplying @xmath237 by @xmath238 , where @xmath239 is the absorption cross section per h - atom of a medium of cosmic composition ( morrison & mccammon @xcite ) and @xmath215 is the mean h column density from the site of x - ray production to the edge of the emitting region .
i adopted for this quantity the stopping range of 100 kev electrons in the ambient medium , @xmath215=4@xmath8410@xmath213 @xmath111 .
the normalization of the source spectrum has been chosen such that the power continuously deposited by the electrons in the interaction region is @xmath240 in comparison , the total luminosity of the x - ray emission is @xmath241 this low radiation yield , @xmath242=@xmath243/@xmath244 , illustrates that x - ray production by supra - thermal electrons should generally not be efficient : in a neutral target region , almost all of the electron kinetic energy is preferentially used to ionize ambient h and he , whereas if these two species are already ionized , the fast electrons will lose most of their energy by collective long - range coulomb interactions . however , the main conclusion of this exercise is that nonthermal bremsstrahlung should often be accompanied by observable x - ray lines below 10 kev . in figure 7 , the k@xmath87 lines from o , ne , si and fe are the four most intense , with calculated equivalent widths of 355 , 107 , 73 and 290 ev , respectively
. a significant line emission from elements of relatively low atomic number , such as o and ne , could allow to distinguish x - ray line production by suprathermal electrons from fluorescence emission .
this is because in the case of electron impact , the strong decrease of the fluorescence yields with decreasing atomic number @xmath13 is compensated by the approximate @xmath210 dependence of the k - shell ionization cross section ( fig .
6a ) .
low - energy accelerated ions can produce x - rays by a variety of atomic processes ( tatischeff _ et al .
_ @xcite and references therein ; dogiel _ et al . _
@xcite ) . a calculated nonthermal x - ray spectrum from accelerated ion interactions
is shown in figure 8 .
as for the suprathermal electrons , i have considered a steady state , thick target interaction model , in which accelerated ions are injected at a constant rate into a neutral ambient medium of solar composition and produce x - rays as they slow down to energies below the thresholds of the various reactions .
the differential x - ray production rate is calculated from an equation similar to eq .
( 3.1 ) , but containing two more summations : one over the elemental abundances of the fast ions and the other one over their ionization states .
i assumed that the energetic particles have the same composition as the galactic cosmic - ray ions at their acceleration sources ( see ramaty _
@xcite , table 1 ) .
their ionic fractions are calculated under the assumption that the steady - state nonthermal ion population is at the ionization equilibrium in the interaction region ( see eq . 2.3 and tatischeff _ et al . _
i employed the same source spectrum for all ion species , @xmath245 which could result from strong shock acceleration in the nonrelativistic energy domain ( ramaty _ et al . _
@xcite ) . here , @xmath246 is the kinetic energy of the fast ions , measured in mev nucleon@xmath21 , and @xmath247 is a parameter introduced by ellison & ramaty ( @xcite ) for solar flare acceleration , which is related to the shock size and the acceleration time . for both clarity and simplicity , photoelectric
absorption in the ambient medium is not taken into account .
= 30 mev / nucleon .
the calculation is normalized to a power of 1 erg s@xmath21 deposited by the accelerated particles in the interaction region .
the total luminosity of the calculated x - ray emission ( see eq .
3.6 ) is 4.8@xmath8410@xmath160 erg s@xmath21 .
note that photoelectric absorption in the ambient medium is not taken into account , such that this value is to be considered as an upper limit .
ib : inverse bremsstrahlung ; seb : secondary electron bremsstrahlung ; rrc : radiative recombination continuum . ]
continuum x - rays are essentially produced by inverse bremsstrahlung ( ib ) , which is the kinematic inverse of normal bremsstrahlung , i.e. the radiation of an electron at rest in the moving coulomb field of a fast ion .
thus , for nonrelativistic protons of kinetic energy @xmath248 interacting in stationary h , the inverse bremsstrahlung cross section is almost identical to the bremsstrahlung cross section for electrons of energy @xmath249 also interacting in stationary h. also shown in figure 8 are the two continuum emissions from the radiative recombinations of ambient electrons to the k - shell of the fast ions ( rrc ; dogiel _ et al . _
@xcite , tatischeff & ramaty @xcite ) and from the secondary , knock - on electrons that subsequently produce bremsstrahlung by interacting with the ambient atoms ( seb ) .
these two emissions should generally be dominated by the ib production .
the narrow lines are due to k - shell vacancy production in the ambient atoms by the fast ions . in comparison with the similar lines produced by electron impact or by photoionization
, the lines produced by heavy ion collisions could be shifted by several tens of electron - volts , significantly broadened and split up into several components , owing to multiple simultaneous ionizations ( garcia _ et al . _
for example , the neutral fe k@xmath87 line produced by 1.9 mev / nucleon o impacts is blueshifted by @xmath8650 ev in comparison with that produced by proton impacts , and has a full width at half - maximum ( fwhm ) of @xmath86100 ev ( see figure 3.55 of garcia _ et al . _
such spectral signatures are within the capabilities of modern x - ray instruments .
the prominent , broad line features in figure 8 are due to atomic de - excitations in the fast ions following electron capture by charge - transfer reactions and collisional excitation .
we have considered the k@xmath87 and k@xmath227 lines from h- and he - like c , n , o , ne , mg , si , s and fe ( tatischeff _ et al . _ @xcite ) .
these lines should generally be broad for a steady - state nonthermal population at ionization equilibrium , because they are produced by de - excitations of fast moving ions .
for example , the o lines in figure 8 are produced at @xmath861 mev / nucleon .
the fe broad lines are emitted at @xmath8610 mev / nucleon and merge together to produce a characteristic bump in the spectrum , of width @xmath2502 kev .
however , if the ambient medium is partially ionized , since charge exchange could then be considerably reduced , the fast ions can significantly slow down before capturing electrons , thus producing narrower lines .
similar line emission has recently been observed from comets , most probably as a result of charge exchange between solar wind particles and cometary neutral gazes ( e.g. lisse _ et al . _
@xcite ) . however , the observed lines are much narrower than those of figure 8 , because the solar wind ions remain in high charge states at low energies ( about 1 kev / nucleon ) , since they do not reach the ionization equilibrium in the interplanetary space .
there are as yet no astrophysical observations from sources outside of the solar system that would unambiguously indicate an origin resulting from relatively low - energy , accelerated ion interactions .
together with nonthermal gamma - ray line production ( 4.2 ) , x - ray line emission from charge exchange may probably be one of the most promising signatures of such interactions and could provide , in particular , one of the best ways of studying galactic cosmic - ray ions at energies below 100 mev / nucleon .
let s now zoom in on the atomic nucleus , from the angstrm atomic scale to the fermi nuclear scale .
nuclear collisions can lead to gamma - ray line emission in a variety of ways .
these include the direct excitation of nuclear levels , the production of excited secondary nuclei , the production of radioactive species decaying into excited states of daughter isotopes and the production of neutrons and positrons .
the latter can originate from the decay of both @xmath0-emitting radionuclei and @xmath251 mesons , as well as from the de - excitation of nuclear levels by @xmath252-@xmath35 pair emission ( kozlovsky _ et al . _
@xcite ) . positron annihilation and the accompanying processes of positronium formation and annihilation are fundamentally important in almost all of high - energy astrophysics , as first pointed out by stecker ( @xcite ) .
it is considered in 6 . in the present section ,
i first discuss the gamma - ray line emission from thermonuclear reactions in high - temperature plasmas ( 4.1 ) , then consider the nonthermal gamma - ray line production from accelerated ion interactions ( 4.2 ) and finally treat the line emission at 2.22 mev resulting from the radiative capture of free neutrons by ambient protons ( 4.3 ) .
thermonuclear reactions are responsible for the nucleosynthesis of the elements in stars , but the associated gamma - ray production can not be observed because stars are opaque to gamma - rays .
observable thermonuclear gamma - ray line emission must be produced in optically thin astrophysical plasmas with ion temperature @xmath25310@xmath254 k ( @xmath2550.086 mev ) .
such high - temperature plasmas are believed to exist in the vicinity of accreting neutron stars and stellar black holes ( dubus , this volume ) , as well as in central energy sources of active galactic nuclei . in these environments ,
collisions of protons and @xmath87-particles ( which are the most abundant nuclear species ) with @xmath196c and heavier ions can bring nuclei to excited states , which can de - excite by a gamma - ray transition .
gamma - ray emission can also be produced through radiative nuclear capture , for example by the reaction @xmath196c(@xmath88,@xmath256)@xmath77n : @xmath257 c and ( _ b _ ) @xmath77n ( @xmath258=9.965 m ) .
also shown are ( _ a _ ) the energy thresholds for the breakup of @xmath196c into 3 @xmath87-particles ( 7.275 mev ) and into @xmath82b+p ( 15.957 mev ) and ( _ b _ ) the energy threshold for the breakup of @xmath77n into @xmath196c+p ( 1.944 mev ) .
the reaction @xmath196c(@xmath88,@xmath256)@xmath77n produces photons of energy ( in mev ) @xmath259=1.944+@xmath260 , where @xmath260 is the total kinetic energy of the @xmath196c+p interaction in its center - of - mass rest frame.,width=396 ] recently , bloemen & bykov ( @xcite ) and bykov _ et al . _
( @xcite ) proposed that the collective gamma - ray line production from an ensemble of unresolved accreting neutrons stars could contribute to the diffuse galactic emission .
they were motivated by comptel observations of the inner galaxy , which show some evidence for an excess emission with a wide latitudinal distribution ( @xmath8620@xmath261 fwhm ) , that could correspond to the large - scale height of low - mass x - ray binaries ( bloemen & bykov @xcite ) . however , the expected emission from binary sources crucially depends on the accretion model . thus , bildsten _ et al . _
( @xcite ) predicted very low gamma - ray line fluxes from the brightest neutron star x - ray binaries , if the accreting material is decelerated by coulomb collisions in the neutron star atmospheres .
indeed , these authors showed that the infalling heavy ions would then thermalize at higher altitudes in the atmosphere than the accreting protons , such that they would be efficiently destroyed by the fast protons , until drifting to the altitude where protons thermalize . on the other hand , bykov _ et al . _
( @xcite ) considered an accretion model in which the infalling ions slow down in a _
collisionless _ shock produced by the outgoing radiation . in this model
, heavy ions can coexist with protons and @xmath87-particles in the hot postshock plasma for a fraction of second and thermonuclear reactions could then produce an observable gamma - ray line emission .
_ suggested that this emission could be detected with _
integral _ from the nearest sub - eddington sources .
one of the strongest gamma - ray lines would then be at 4.438 mev from de - excitation of the first excited state of @xmath196c ( fig .
this level can be populated by the inelastic scattering reactions @xmath196c(@xmath88,@xmath88)@xmath196c@xmath262 and @xmath196c(@xmath87,@xmath87)@xmath196c@xmath262 , as well as by the spallation reactions @xmath263o(@xmath88,@xmath88@xmath87)@xmath196c@xmath262 and @xmath263o(@xmath87,2@xmath87)@xmath196c@xmath262c , 4.439 mev , is due to the recoil of the @xmath196c nucleus during photon emission . ] .
other important lines are those resulting from de - excitation of the most abundant heavy nuclei , e.g. at 6.129 mev from de - excitation of @xmath263o . to illustrate the main characteristics of thermonuclear gamma - ray line production , i discuss in the following the production of the 4.438 mev line by @xmath88+@xmath196c collisions .
i also consider the radiative capture reaction ( 4.1 ) , which produces a line at 2.365 mev at the resonance energy @xmath260=0.421 mev ( fig .
+ @xmath196c interactions , as a function of the ion temperature .
solid curves : productions of the 2.365 and 4.438 mev lines from the reactions @xmath196c(@xmath88,@xmath256)@xmath77n and @xmath196c(@xmath88,@xmath88@xmath256)@xmath196c , respectively . dashed curve : destruction of @xmath196c.,width=238 ] i show in figure 10 the corresponding thermonuclear reaction rates . for the @xmath196c(@xmath88,@xmath88@xmath264)@xmath196c reaction
, i used the cross section tabulated by kiener et al .
( @xcite ) and calculated the thermally - averaged rate from an equation similar to eq .
( 2.4 ) , @xmath265 which is appropriate for an ion plasma of isothermal temperature @xmath266 ( e.g. clayton @xcite ) . here
, @xmath267=@xmath268+@xmath269 is the reduced mass of the @xmath88+@xmath196c system , @xmath260 is the total kinetic energy of the reaction in its center - of - mass rest frame and @xmath270 is the reaction cross section .
the rate of the @xmath196c(@xmath88,@xmath271)@xmath77n reaction is obtained from the analytical formula derived by angulo et al .
( @xcite ) for stellar nucleosynthesis purposes , by considering only the contribution of the resonance at @xmath260=0.421 mev .
we see that the rate of the @xmath196c(@xmath88,@xmath88@xmath264)@xmath196c reaction several orders of magnitude higher than the one of the radiative capture reaction .
this is due to the fact that inelastic scattering reactions are mostly governed by the strong nuclear force , whereas radiative capture reactions are essentially electroweak interactions .
however , we also see that the 2.365 mev line is produced at lower temperature , because the proton capture reaction occurs at lower center - of - mass energy .
the expected width of the 4.438 mev line depends on the velocity distribution of the excited @xmath196c*. following higdon & lingenfelter ( @xcite ) , one can neglect the @xmath88+@xmath196c reaction kinematics and assume that this distribution is essentially the same as the maxwell - boltzmann velocity distribution of unexcited @xmath196c .
the line fwhm in kev is then @xmath869@xmath84(@xmath272/10@xmath273 k)@xmath274 , which gives about 90 to 300 kev for @xmath272 between 10@xmath161 and 10@xmath82 k. the broadening of the 2.365 mev line is related to the maxwellian velocity distribution of the center of mass of @xmath88+@xmath196c interactions .
one has to consider also the relatively large natural width of the first excited state of @xmath77n , @xmath275=32 kev ( ajzenberg - selove @xcite ) . in a first approximation ,
the 2.365 mev line width can then be estimated as fwhm@xmath86(@xmath276 + 2.3@xmath8410@xmath277@xmath278 , which gives about 35 to 60 kev for @xmath272 between 10@xmath279 and 10@xmath161 k ( fig .
in addition , lines produced in the vicinity of compact objects can be significantly redshifted , but also broadened if the gravitational potential varies over the emission volume ( shvartsman @xcite ) .
thermonuclear destruction of the heavy species can lead to a significant reduction in the gamma - ray line production ( guessoum & gould @xcite ; guessoum @xcite ) .
to illustrate this point , i show in figure 10 ( dashed curve ) the reaction rate for the breakup of @xmath196c by proton impact , which i calculated from eq .
( 4.2 ) using for the destruction cross section the fitting formula of bildsten _ et al . _
( @xcite , eq .
this cross section has been estimated by subtracting the 4.438 mev line production cross section from the total @xmath88+@xmath196c inelastic reaction cross section , which is justified by the fact that the excited states of @xmath196c above the 4.439 mev level decay primarily by particle emission - ray emission ( fig .
let @xmath280 be the averaged number of 4.438 mev gamma - rays emitted in a thermonuclear plasma by a @xmath196c nucleus prior to destruction .
we have ( bildsten _ et al . _
@xcite ) @xmath281 where @xmath55@xmath282@xmath283 and @xmath55@xmath282@xmath284 are the reaction rates for gamma - ray production and @xmath196c destruction , respectively .
thus , we see from figure 10 that @xmath280@xmath2851 for @xmath272@xmath28610@xmath82 k , which merely illustrates that destruction , rather than 4.438 mev line emission , is by far the most probable outcome for @xmath196c nuclei in such very high - temperature plasmas .
note that photon- and electron - induced reactions can also destroy heavy nuclei .
however , guessoum & gould ( @xcite ) estimated that these processes should generally be negligible as compared with breakup by proton collisions . as a conclusion ,
a near future observation of thermonuclear gamma - ray lines is uncertain , because the accreting heavy ions could be rapidly destroyed either by thermal or nonthermal processes .
however , the breakup of @xmath83he and heavier nuclei should be accompanied by a copious liberation of neutrons , that may eventually recombine with protons to produce a gamma - ray line emission at 2.22 mev ( 4.3 ) .
this line could be produced within the high - temperature plasma near the compact object ( bildsten _ et al . _
@xcite ) or in the atmosphere of the companion star ( jean & guessoum @xcite ) .
in fact , it may be the best gamma - ray line candidate for high - energy accreting sources .
the interaction of accelerated nuclei ( typically @xmath101 mev / nucleon ) with ambient matter can produce a wealth of gamma - ray lines with energies ranging from tens of kev to about 20 mev .
this nonthermal gamma - ray line emission is often observed from the sun during strong solar flares ( e.g. vestrand _ et al . _
@xcite ) and it has furnished valuable information on solar ambient abundances , density and temperature , as well as on accelerated particle composition , spectra and transport in the solar atmosphere ( e.g. ramaty & mandzhavidze @xcite ; share & murphy @xcite ) .
nonthermal gamma - ray line emission is also expected from various astrophysical sites in which ion acceleration is believed to occur , such as accreting compact stellar objects , supernova remnants and active galactic nuclei .
interactions of galactic cosmic - ray ions with interstellar matter should produce a diffuse emission that might be observed in the near future .
these observations would then shed new light on the global physical structure of the interstellar medium and on the sources of cosmic rays below 100 mev / nucleon , that are not detected near earth because of the solar modulation .
the most comprehensive treatment of nuclear de - excitation gamma - ray line emission was performed by ramaty _
( @xcite ) .
the authors took into account more than 150 reactions leading to the production of an excited nucleus and evaluated their cross sections from laboratory measurements combined with nuclear physics theory .
figure 11 shows a gamma - ray line spectrum which i calculated with the corresponding computer code .
i have considered the same steady state , thick target interaction model as for the nonthermal x - ray emission shown in figure 8 , in particular with the same composition ( crs ) and source spectrum ( eq .
3.7 ) for the accelerated ions .
the luminosity of the calculated gamma - ray line emission is @xmath287 which is comparable to the calculated x - ray luminosity ( @[email protected]@xmath8410@xmath160 erg s@xmath21 , see fig .
this should generally be the case , except if the accelerated ion spectrum is very soft : a high population of low - energy ions ( @xmath861 mev / nucleon ) can produce nonthermal soft x - rays without producing a significant gamma - ray line emission . deposited by the accelerated particles in the interaction region .
the dashed curve shows the estimated contribution from all unresolved gamma - ray lines in ions heavier than @xmath263o ( see text ) .
the very narrow dotted lines are from the decay of long - lived radionuclei .
the arrows point to the lines which are mentioned in the text .
the prompt lines are labelled with the excited nuclei from which the gamma - rays are emitted ( e.g. @xmath196c * ) , whereas the delayed lines are labelled with the parent long - lived radioisotopes ( e.g. @xmath288al ) .
the so - called @xmath87@xmath289@xmath87 line feature is mainly produced by @xmath87+@xmath87 fusion reactions ( see also fig .
12).,width=472 ] we see in figure 11 a combination of broad line features from de - excitations of fast heavy ions , narrower lines from gamma - ray transitions in heavy nuclei excited by energetic protons and @xmath87-particles and very narrow lines ( dotted lines ) from spallation - produced long - lived radionuclei , which can come essentially to rest in the ambient medium before decaying to an excited state of their daughter nucleus .
in addition , the prominent broad line feature at @xmath860.45 mev is mainly produced by the interactions of @xmath87-particles with ambient @xmath83he .
all these lines are superimposed on a continuum - like emission ( dashed curve ) , which is due to a large number of unresolved gamma - ray lines , mostly arising from cascade transitions in high - lying levels of heavy nuclei .
( @xcite ) estimated the intensity and the energy distribution of this unresolved emission from the data of zobel _ et al . _
( @xcite ) .
these authors measured the total production of gamma - rays of energies @xmath100.7 mev , in interactions of protons and @xmath87-particles with complex nuclei , at laboratory energies @xmath1010 mev / nucleon .
they found that for target nuclei heavier than o , the resolvable lines from de - excitation of the low - lying nuclear levels can account for only a fraction of the total gamma - ray production . in the spectrum of figure 11 , however , the unresolved component produces about half of the total gamma - ray emission below 3 mev .
new experiments could allow to specify the importance of this emission .
the broad lines tend to overlap , such that only few well - defined features from energetic heavy ions can be distinguished in the gamma - ray spectrum .
it is the case of the broad line feature from fast @xmath196c * , centered at 4.4 mev ( fig .
11 ) with fwhm of @xmath861.5 mev , which is produced by interactions of accelerated @xmath196c and @xmath263o with ambient h and he .
an other example is furnished by the broad line centered at 0.158 mev with fwhm of @xmath8650 kev , which is due to the de - excitation of the first excited state of @xmath290co , populated by the reaction in reverse kinematics @xmath291h(@xmath290fe,@xmath290co*)@xmath105 .
intense narrow lines are due to excitations of low - lying nuclear levels in abundant ambient ions , e.g. at 0.847 mev from @xmath290fe * , 1.37 mev from @xmath292 mg * , 1.63 mev from @xmath293ne * , 4.44 mev from @xmath196c * and 6.13 mev from @xmath263o*. other important narrow lines are those arising from transitions in the spallation products of abundant ambient nuclei , e.g. at 0.718 mev from @xmath161b * , which is produced by the spallation of ambient @xmath196c and @xmath263o , and at 0.931 mev from @xmath294fe * , which is essentially produced by the reaction @xmath290fe(@xmath88,@xmath88@xmath105)@xmath294fe*. the narrow lines produced in a gaseous ambient medium are generally broadened by the recoil velocity of the excited nucleus and their fwhm is about 0.5 - 5% of the transition energy .
however , some lines produced in interstellar dust grains can be very narrow , because some of the excited nuclei can stop in solid materials before emitting gamma - rays ( lingenfelter & ramaty @xcite ) .
it requires that ( i ) the mean life time of the excited nuclear level or of its radioactive nuclear parent is longer than the slowing down time of the excited nucleus in the grain material and ( ii ) the mean distance from the site of the nuclear interaction to the grain edge is higher than the stopping range of the excited nucleus in the grain .
the most promising candidates are from the de - excitation of the levels of @xmath290fe at 0.847 mev ( @xmath258=6.1 ps ) and 1.238 mev ( @xmath258=640 fs ) , of @xmath292 mg at 1.37 mev ( @xmath258=1.35 ps ) , of @xmath295si at 1.78 mev ( @xmath258=475 fs ) and of @xmath263o at 6.13 mev ( @xmath258=18.4 ps ) .
most of the interstellar fe , mg and si , which are refractory elements , could be contained in dust grains , whereas about half of the interstellar o could be in grains ( e.g. savage & sembach @xcite ) . the detection of these very narrow lines , maybe with the _ integral _ spectrometer ( spi ) , would provide unique information on the composition , size and spatial distribution of the interstellar grains . both the broad and the narrow lines could in principle have complex profiles that generally depend on the composition , energy and angular distributions of the accelerated particles , the composition of the ambient medium and the mechanism of the nuclear reactions producing the excited nuclei . in particular , the detailed calculation of line shapes requires the knowledge of the angular and energy distributions of the recoil nuclei and the angular distribution of the emitted gamma - rays .
et al . _ ( 1979 ) estimated the shapes of the various lines from a limited number of available laboratory data together with simplifying theoretical assumptions .
more recent works have shown that fine spectroscopic analyses of the gamma - ray line profiles could give valuable information on the directionality of the accelerated particles in the interaction region ( kiener _ et al .
_ 2001 and references therein ) . in figure 11 ,
the most intense narrow lines from spallation - produced radionuclei are at 0.478 mev from the decay of @xmath197be ( @xmath258=53.3 d ) , at 0.847 and 1.238 mev from the decay of @xmath290co ( @xmath258=77.3 d ) and at 1.275 mev from the decay of @xmath296na ( @xmath258=2.6 y ) .
these lines are very narrow only if the density of the ambient medium is high enough for the radionuclei to come essentially to rest prior to decay .
the line at 1.809 mev from @xmath288al decay should generally be very narrow , because the time to stop energetic ( @xmath55100 mev / nucleon ) @xmath288al in a medium of @xmath861 h - atom @xmath26 is shorter than its half - life ( @xmath258=7.4@xmath8410@xmath166 y ) .
but @xmath197be ions , which are mostly produced by the reaction @xmath83he(@xmath87,@xmath105)@xmath297be with recoil energy @xmath102 mev / nucleon , stop in a medium with solar abundances in less than 53.3 days only if the h density exceeds 10@xmath166 @xmath26 .
0.45 mev , for 4 values of the h density in the interaction region .
the total emission ( solid curves ) is the sum of the prompt lines from the reactions @xmath83he(@xmath87,@xmath105@xmath298)@xmath297be and @xmath83he(@xmath87,@xmath88@xmath299)@xmath297li ( dotted curves ) and the delayed line at 0.478 mev from @xmath297be decay ( dashed curves).,width=472 ] figure 12 shows detailed profiles of the gamma - ray emission at @xmath860.45 mev for lower values of the ambient h density ( tatischeff _ et al . _
the delayed line at 0.478 mev from @xmath197be decay is superimposed on a prompt emission from the reactions @xmath83he(@xmath87,@xmath105@xmath298)@xmath297be and @xmath83he(@xmath87,@xmath88@xmath299)@xmath297li .
the two prompt lines merge ( for the assumed isotropic distribution of energetic @xmath87-particles ) thus producing this characteristic emission feature , whose importance in gamma - ray astrophysics was first pointed out by kozlovsky & ramaty ( @xcite ) .
we see that the width of the delayed line decreases as the h density increases , because @xmath197be ions decay at lower energies in a denser propagation region .
this provides a potential density measurement , which could allow , in particular , to determine if low - energy cosmic - ray ions can penetrate into the core of interstellar molecular clouds . in summary ,
interactions of energetic particles with ambient material produce a great variety of nuclear de - excitation lines , that could provide a unique tool to study the acceleration processes at work in the galaxy and beyond , and also to examine the ultimate nature of the interaction regions .
in particular , observations of diffuse galactic emission would permit the first measurements of the isotopic composition of the interstellar medium , independent of the ionization and molecular states of its constituents .
10@xmath300 @xmath111 , as a function of the proton or @xmath87-particle bombarding energy . here , @xmath301 , @xmath302 ,
@xmath303 , @xmath304 and @xmath305 indicate neutron production in proton hydrogen , proton
helium , alpha particle helium , proton heavy nuclei and alpha particle heavy nuclei interactions , respectively .
the cross sections of the three neutron - producing reactions in proton helium interactions are shown separately ( dashed curves ) .
the @xmath304 and @xmath305 reaction cross sections take into account all isotopes equal to or heavier than @xmath196c ( see text ) .
all the cross sections include the neutron multiplicity.,width=321 ] free neutrons can be produced by the breakup of all isotopes equal to or heavier than @xmath306h , either by thermonuclear or nonthermal reactions .
their subsequent radiative capture by ambient nuclei can produce many specific gamma - ray lines , among which the line at 2.22 mev from the reaction @xmath291h(@xmath105,@xmath256)@xmath306h is expected to be the strongest in most astrophysical sites .
i show in figure 13 the cross section for important neutron - producing reactions .
the @xmath304 and @xmath305 reaction cross sections are from hua & lingenfelter ( @xcite ; see also ramaty _ et al . _
they are defined as @xmath307 where @xmath308 is the solar abundance of isotope @xmath230 with respect to @xmath291h , @xmath309 ( resp .
@xmath310 ) is the cross section for neutron production in collisions of protons ( resp
. @xmath87-particles ) with isotope @xmath230 and the summations are over all isotopes equal to or heavier than @xmath196c ( @xmath311=1.6@xmath8410@xmath312 )
. the cross sections of the @xmath301 , @xmath302 and @xmath303 reactions are from murphy _
( @xcite ; see also meyer @xcite ) .
these reactions should generally be the dominant neutron - producing processes in interactions of accelerated particles of energy @xmath1010 mev / nucleon and in thermonuclear plasmas . however , spallation of heavy nuclei plays an important role in solar flares , because the accelerated ions have generally a rapidly decreasing energy distribution .
h - atom and on a @xmath291h - atom contained in a water molecule ( dashed curve ) , and for the radiative capture reaction @xmath291h(@xmath105,@xmath256)@xmath306h , as a function of the neutron energy ( from horsley @xcite ) .
the radiative capture cross section satisfies @xmath313=2.44@xmath8410@xmath314/@xmath315 ( in b ) for @xmath316@xmath551 kev , where @xmath315 is the neutron velocity relative to that of light . ] shown in figure 14 are cross sections for @xmath105+h interactions .
we see that the neutrons have a much larger probability to scatter on ambient @xmath291h - atoms than to be captured .
they lose on average about half of their kinetic energy in each elastic scattering .
thus , most of them get thermalized before being possibly captured , if they havent decayed ( @xmath105@xmath22@xmath88+@xmath35+@xmath317 ) or escaped from the interaction region . in a medium of h density @xmath47 , the mean time for radiative capture is given by @xmath318 as @xmath313=2.44@xmath8410@xmath319/@xmath315 ( in cm@xmath306 ) for @xmath316@xmath551 kev ( fig .
this characteristic time must be compared with the mean time for neutron decay : @xmath321 where @[email protected] s is the neutron half - life ( groom _ et al . _
thus , significant gamma - ray line emission at 2.22 mev can only be produced in an ambient medium of h density exceeding @xmath8610@xmath263 @xmath26 , i.e. in a _
stellar environment_. the line should generally be narrow if the only broadening mechanism is thermal .
if it is the case , its fwhm exceeds the energy resolution of a germanium detector ( @xmath862.5 kev at 2.2 mev ) only if the ambient medium temperature is@xmath3225@xmath8410@xmath11 k. as pointed out by wang & ramaty ( @xcite ) , ambient @xmath323he can constitute an important non - radiative sink for the neutrons .
indeed , the cross section for the reaction @xmath323he(@xmath105,@xmath88)@xmath323h has the same form at low energies as that of the @xmath291h(@xmath105,@xmath256)@xmath306h reaction ( @xmath324 @xmath325 @xmath326 ) , but is @xmath861.6@xmath8410@xmath83 times larger , which is to be compared with the @xmath291h/@xmath323he solar abundance ratio , 7.23@xmath8410@xmath83 ( anders & grevesse @xcite ) .
in fact , this coincidence has allowed an original determination of the @xmath323he photospheric abundance , from observations of the 2.22 mev line produced in solar flares ( hua & lingenfelter @xcite ) .
the comptel all - sky survey at 2.22 mev revealed one point - like feature ( gro j0332 - 87 ) at the galactic coordinates ( @xmath73,@xmath75)=(300.5@xmath261,-29.6@xmath261 ) ( mcconnell _ et al .
_ @xcite ; schnfelder _ et al . _
the most interesting known source in the comptel location error box is re j0317 - 853 , which is one of the hottest ( @xmath32750,000@xmath261 k ) and most highly magnetized ( @xmath327340 mg ) white dwarfs , residing at a distance of only @xmath8635 pc . observations with _ integral _ are expected to provide a new insight into the origin of this yet mysterious emission .
observations of gamma - ray lines produced by the decay of radioisotopes synthesized in stars have long been recognized as a powerful tool for studying the nucleosynthesis processes at work in stellar interiors and explosions ( clayton @xcite and references therein ; kndlseder , this volume ) . however , among the hundreds of potential radioactive emitters of gamma - ray lines , only a few of them are suitable for astronomical observations .
first , nucleosynthesis sites are generally optically thick to gamma - rays , such that the appropriate radioisotopes must have a sufficiently long half - life ( typically @xmath258@xmath101 day ) so as to decay only after having left the dense production environment .
additionally , their production yields must be high enough for the decay activities to be observable by gamma - ray instruments , which , in the present state of the gamma - ray line astronomy , practically excludes all the radioisotopes beyond the fe peak .
.star - produced radioisotopes relevant to gamma - ray line astronomy . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ] @xmath328 sites which are believed to produce observable @xmath256-ray line emission .
nova : classical nova ; snia : thermonuclear supernova ( type ia ) ; ccsn : core - collapse supernova ; wr : wolf - rayet star ; agb : asymptotic giant branch star .
@xmath329 @xmath330 : orbital electron capture .
when an isotope decays by a combination of @xmath330 and @xmath0 emission , only the most probable decay mode is given , with the corresponding fraction in parenthesis .
@xmath331 half - lifes of the isotopes decaying by @xmath330 are for the neutral atoms ( see text ) .
@xmath332 number of photons emitted in the @xmath256-ray line per radioactive decay .
@xmath333 the underlined @xmath256-ray lines are those for which a positive detection has been reported at the time of writing .
@xmath334 it is noteworthy that the first excited ( isomeric ) state of @xmath335co at 59 kev decays with 98% probability by the emission of a conversion electron .
table 1 lists the most important cosmic radioactivities for gamma - ray line observations .
the astrophysical sites in which these isotopes are synthesized are discussed in the review paper of diehl & timmes ( @xcite ) .
the nuclear data are from firestone ( @xcite , and references therein for the @xmath330-@xmath0 decay branchings ) , except for the nuclei of mass number a=44 , 56 and 57 , for which i used the more recent data evaluations of cameron & singh ( @xcite ) , junde ( @xcite ) and bhat ( @xcite ) , respectively .
the half - life of the radioisotopes listed in the table should be compared with the characteristic time scale between two nucleosynthesis events which produced them in the galaxy , @xmath861 - 2 weeks for novae , @xmath8640 yr for ccsn and @xmath86300 yr for snia ( e.g. prantzos @xcite and references therein ) .
thus , we see that we expect the decays of the long - lived @xmath288al and @xmath335fe nuclei to produce diffuse gamma - ray line emissions , resulting from the superposition of numerous galactic sources . on the other hand
, the gamma - ray line activities of @xmath197be , @xmath290ni , @xmath336ni and @xmath337ti should be observed in individual transient events .
the case of @xmath296na is in a way intermediary : the line emission at 1.275 mev could be observed from nearby individual one novae ( @xmath551.1 kpc with spi , hernanz et al .
@xcite ) , but also from a broad region towards the galactic center , resulting from the cumulated production of few tens of active sources .
evidence for this latest unresolved emission has recently been reported by the comptel team ( iyudin _ et al . _
@xcite ) . in table 1 , six of the radioisotopes decay mainly or exclusively by orbital electron capture ( @xmath330 ) . as pointed out by mochizuki _
( @xcite ) for @xmath337ti , one has to be cautious when deducing the production yields of these isotopes from the delayed observations of their gamma - ray activities , since their decay rates depend on their ionization states .
thus , in the interstellar medium , fully ionized @xmath330-radioisotopes can only decay by highly improbable nuclear electron capture from continuum states , such that they are almost stable as compared with the age of the universebe against capture of free electrons in the core of the sun is @xmath32790 d ( bahcall & moeller @xcite ) , which is by coincidence comparable to the measured value for neutral atoms . ] .
( @xcite ) suggested that the ionization of @xmath337ti behind the reverse shock of the cas a supernova remnant ( snr ) could have significantly reduced its decay rate , thus leading to a lower mass of ejected @xmath337ti than previously inferred from the detected 1.157 mev line flux .
however , a more realistic model for the ejecta shows that the effect may not exceed a few percent ( laming @xcite ) .
the decay of an @xmath330-radioisotope can also produce x - ray line emission , when the electron vacancy in the daughter atom ( primarily in its k - shell ) is filled by a radiative transition .
leising ( @xcite ) has recently examined the exciting possibility of detecting cosmic radioactivities in x - rays .
many of them are not gamma - ray line emitters , because they decay directly to the ground state of their daughter nucleus .
the author listed 17 potentially important @xmath330-radioisotopes , among which the most promising for detection are @xmath294fe ( @xmath258=2.73 yr ) , @xmath337ti ( @xmath258=60 yr ) , @xmath338ni ( @xmath258=7.6@xmath8410@xmath83 yr ) and @xmath339mn ( @xmath258=3.74@xmath8410@xmath11 yr ) .
the @xmath330 decay of @xmath294fe could be observed through the emission of the mn k@xmath87 line , from very young snrs such as sn1987a .
the x - ray line emission which accompanies the @xmath337ti decay should be hunted for in the two snrs from which gamma - ray line emission at 1.157 mev has already been observed , cas a and rx j0852 - 4622 .
the detection of this x - ray line emission would constitute an interesting complement to the gamma - ray line measurements , because it would allow to determine the present ionization state of ti in the two snrs .
finally , the decays of @xmath338ni and @xmath339mn , producing k@xmath87 lines at 6.92 and 5.41 kev , respectively , could be observed from very close and reasonably young ( i.e. not too extended ) snrs and also as diffuse galactic emissions line at 6.92 kev is also expected from the decay chain @xmath335fe @xmath340 @xmath335co@xmath341 @xmath342 @xmath335co ( @xmath343 : internal transition ) , since the de - excitation of @xmath335co@xmath341 is essentially due to the conversion of a k - shell electron ( see table 1 ) .
the expected galactic flux is @xmath344 where @[email protected]@xmath8410@xmath160 @xmath256 s@xmath21 @xmath111 is the predicted flux for the 1.173 mev line from @xmath335co decay ( timmes & woosley @xcite ) , @xmath87=48 and @xmath346=40 are the total and k - shell conversion coefficients for the 59 kev transition ( king @xcite ) and @xmath347=0.33 is the k@xmath87 fluorescence yield for co. in comparison , leising ( @xcite ) predicted that the decay of @xmath338ni should produce a 6.92 kev line flux from the central steradian of the galaxy of @xmath861.7@xmath8410@xmath348 photons s@xmath21 @xmath111 . ] . as leising pointed out , it could be difficult to distinguish the electron capture line emission from astrophysical sources which are generally expected to be very luminous in x - rays
. in particular , detailed models of snrs are required to determine if the expected lines could be unambiguously identified among the other thermal and nonthermal x - ray line emissions .
however , one can reasonably hope that in a few cases , the clear detection of x - ray lines from cosmic radioactivities will constitute an important complement to the gamma - ray line studies of stellar nucleosynthesis .
positron - electron annihilation radiation can be produced in a variety of astrophysical sites .
the diffuse galactic emission at 511 kev is the brightest gamma - ray line of cosmic origin .
it is produced by the steady - state annihilation of @xmath861.4 - 4.3@xmath8410@xmath349 positrons s@xmath21 ( depending on the spatial distribution of the emission , kinzer _ et al . _
a large fraction of these positrons could result from the @xmath0 decay of @xmath290co and @xmath337sc ( synthesized as @xmath290ni and @xmath337ti in supernovae , see table 1 ) , with a smaller contribution from the @xmath0 decay of @xmath288al ( chan & lingenfelter @xcite ; dermer & murphy @xcite ) .
( @xcite ) have recently estimated that these three isotopes could supply 30 - 50% of the galactic positrons .
the decay of @xmath251 and radioisotopes produced by cosmic - ray interactions in the interstellar medium could make an additional contribution of a few percent ( e.g. ramaty & lingenfelter @xcite ) .
positrons are also produced in classical novae , from the decay of radioisotopes synthesized during the thermonuclear runaway .
the main @xmath0-radionuclei synthesized in novae are @xmath77n ( @xmath258=9.965 min ) , @xmath350f ( @xmath258=109.8 min ) , @xmath296na ( @xmath258=2.61 h ) and @xmath288al ( @xmath258=7.4@xmath8410@xmath166 y ) . the decay of the latter two isotopes could inject a small but non - negligible amount of positrons in the interstellar medium , but @xmath77n and @xmath350f have too short half - lifes , so that most of the positrons should annihilate in the relatively dense material ejected by the nova explosion .
the resulting gamma - ray emission could be detected with spi from relatively nearby novae during the first day after the explosionf(@xmath88,@xmath256)@xmath351ne and @xmath350f(@xmath88,@xmath87)@xmath352o , which are responsible for the thermonuclear destruction of @xmath350f ( coc _ et al . _
@xcite ) . ]
( hernanz et al .
@xcite ) . positron production can also occur in accreting compact objects , from the pair production reaction @xmath353 , from the materialization of photons in strong magnetic fields @xmath354 and from other less important processes such as @xmath355 , where @xmath356 or nucleus .
a significant fraction of these positrons could annihilate near the compact objects , thus producing a localized and possibly time - variable emission . the annihilation radiation from relativistic plasmas
is discussed by marcowith ( this volume ) .
here , i consider the emission produced by the injection of nonthermal positrons in various astrophysical environments . important processes leading to gamma - ray emission from positron annihilation are shown in figure 15 ( see guessoum _
@xcite for discussion of the various processes and update of the cross sections ) .
positrons produced by the decay of radioactive nuclei have initial kinetic energies typically ranging from several hundred kev to few mev .
they slow down mainly by coulomb interactions with free electrons and by excitations and ionizations of neutral atoms , and their characteristic slowing - down time is @xmath8610@xmath166/@xmath105 years , where @xmath105 is the ambient medium density in units of @xmath26 ( guessoum _ et al . _
positrons produced by other processes generally have higher initial energies .
having lost the bulk of its kinetic energy , a positron can either form a positronium ( ps ) atom in flight by charge exchange with an atom or a molecule ( at @xmath35750 ev in neutral h or h@xmath358 , bussard _ et al . _
@xcite ) or become thermalized with the free electrons .
thermal positrons either annihilate directly with free or bound electrons or form ps atoms through radiative recombination and charge exchange ( fig .
15 ) . as first pointed out by zurek ( @xcite )
, interstellar dust could play a significant role in annihilation of thermal positrons despite its low abundance , since its projected surface area ( @xmath8610@xmath359 cm@xmath306 per galactic h - atom ) can be larger than the cross sections for the other processes leading to positron annihilation .
collisions of thermal positrons with dust grains can lead to the reflection of the positrons from the grains , to the annihilation of the positrons within the grains and to the formation and subsequent escape of ps atoms back to the gas .
the contribution of these processes to gamma - ray emission crucially depends on the grain properties , including their compositions , sizes , charges and abundances in the ambient medium . the positronium atom , which is the simplest hydrogen - like system , is preferentially formed in the state of principal quantum number @xmath105=1 , either as a triplet ( @xmath198 ) in which the spins of the electron and positron are parallel , or as a singlet ( @xmath170 ) in which they are antiparallel line at 2430 and other lines in the uv , ir and radio bands , that could provide an other way to observe positron annihilation from astrophysical sources ( e.g. wallyn _ et al . _
@xcite ) . ] .
these states are called , respectively , orthopositronium and parapositronium , by analogy with the spectral designations for hydrogen . parapositronium annihilates with a lifetime @xmath360=1.25@xmath8410@xmath361 s into two photons of 511 kev in its rest frame , but orthopositronium decays with @xmath362=1.4@xmath8410@xmath277 s into three photons , which form a characteristic continuum at energies below 511 kev ( ore & powell @xcite ) .
ps atoms can be quenched before annihilation if the ambient medium density is @xmath32210@xmath77 @xmath20 .
let @xmath363 be the total number of positrons which annihilate in a given source , and @xmath364 and @xmath365 the number of photons emitted from this source in the 511 kev line and in the ortho - ps continuum , respectively . since the probability for formation of the lepton atom in the triplet state is three times the probability for its formation in the singlet state , we have @xmath366\ ] ] @xmath367 where @xmath368 is the fraction of positrons that annihilate via ps formation .
combining these two equations gives @xmath368 in terms of the observable quantity ( @xmath369 ) : @xmath370 to illustrate how an observation of the 511 kev line profile and the determination of @xmath368 can provide unique information on the annihilation environment , i show in figure 16 calculated spectra of the radiation produced by positron annihilation in the four phases of the interstellar medium .
i used equation ( 9 ) of guessoum _ et al . _
( @xcite ) with the rates of the various processes and the corresponding line widths given in that paper , except for the widths of the lines produced by radiative recombination and direct annihilation of thermal positrons , for which i used the more accurate results of crannell _ et al . _
( @xcite ; see guessoum _ et al . _
@xcite ) . for simplicity ,
i neglected the processes involving interstellar dust .
we see in panel ( _ a _ ) that in the cold phase , the line is relatively broad and the fraction of positrons which annihilate via ps formation is high .
indeed , in this neutral environment , most of the nonthermal positrons form ps in flight by charge exchange and the immediate annihilation of para - ps produces a broad line ( 6.4 kev fwhm , brown _ et al . _ @xcite ) . on this component
is superimposed a narrower line due to the direct annihilation of 10% of the positrons with bound electrons . in the warm neutral phase ( of temperature @xmath101=8000 k and ionization fraction @xmath371=@xmath372/(@xmath372+@xmath47)=0.15 , mckee & ostriker @xcite ) ,
the fraction of positrons forming ps in flight is reduced to 22% .
most of the positrons get thermalized and form ps by charge exchange just above the energy threshold ( 6.8 ev in the center of mass for @xmath252+h@xmath373ps+@xmath88 ) .
the annihilation line has a fwhm of 1.5 kev ( bussard _ et al . _
@xcite ) . in the warm ionized phase ( @xmath101=8000 k , @xmath371=0.68 ) ,
the 511 kev line is even narrower ( 1.1 kev fwhm ) , because a significant fraction of thermal positrons form ps through radiative recombination , which does not have an energy threshold .
finally , in the hot phase of the interstellar medium ( @xmath101=4.5@xmath8410@xmath166 k ) , all the positrons get thermalized and the annihilation line should be broad ( @xmath3277.4 kev fwhm ) due to the thermal motion of the the center of mass of the @xmath252-@xmath35 pairs which annihilate .
( @xcite ) estimated the width of the 511 kev line from both para - ps annihilation following radiative recombination and direct annihilation with free electrons as fwhm=11@xmath84(@xmath101/10@xmath11 k)@xmath274 kev .
however , the line width could be significantly reduced if annihilation on interstellar dust is important ( guessoum _ et al . _
the results shown in figure 16 are in good agreement with the recent calculations of dermer & murphy ( @xcite ) , except for the cold phase , for which they found the narrow line component from positron annihilation with bound electrons to be negligible .
harris _ et al . _
( @xcite ) have measured , with the tgrs instrument ( germanium detector ) on the _ wind _ spacecraft , the width of the 511 kev line from the galactic center region to be narrow , [email protected]@xmath590.14 kev , and the ps fraction to be large , @[email protected] , in good agreement with the most recent osse result : @[email protected] ( kinzer _ et al . _
the narrow line width suggests that most of the positrons can not penetrate deeply into molecular clouds and that annihilation in the hot interstellar phase is not predominant , unless dust grains sprinkled into the hot plasma are important sites of annihilation .
however , the ps fraction would then be very low ( @xmath550.5 , guessoum _ et al . _
@xcite ) , in conflict with the measured values .
thus , these observations favor a scenario in which the galactic positrons annihilate predominantly in the warm , partially ionized interstellar medium .
the spectroscopic - imaging capability of _ integral _ should allow a better determination of the nature and the spatial distribution of the emitting regions .
this would shed new light on the sources of the positrons and on the thermodynamic properties of the annihilation media .
01 anders , e. and grevesse , n. 1989 , geochim .
acta , 53 , 197 angulo , c. ( the nacre collaboration ) 1999 , nucl .
a656 , 3 ajzenberg - selove , f. 1991 , nucl .
, a523 , 1 arnaud , m. and raymond , j. 1992 , apj , 398 , 394 arnaud , m. and rothenflug , r. 1985 , a&as , 60 , 425 bahcall , j. n. and moeller , c. p. 1969 , apj , 155 , 511 baring , m. g. , jones , f. c. and ellison , d. c. 2000 , apj , 528 , 776 berger , m. j. and seltzer , s. m. 1982 , _ stopping powers and ranges of electrons and positrons _ , national bureau of standards report : nbsir 82 - 2550 , u.s .
dept . of commerce , washington , d.c .
20234 bhat , m. r. 1998 , nucl .
data sheets , 85 , 415 bildsten , l. , salpeter , e. e. and wasserman , i. 1992 , apj , 384 , 143 bildsten , l. , salpeter , e. e. and wasserman , i. 1993 , apj , 408 , 615 bloemen , h. and bykov , a. m. 1997 , proc . of the 4th compton symposium , dermer , c. d. , strickman , m. s. , kurfess , j. d. ( eds . ) , aip conf .
410 , p. 249 borkowski , k. j. , lyerly , w. j. and reynolds , s. p. 2001 , apj , 548 , 820 brown , b. l. , leventhal , m. , mills , a. p. , jr . and gildey , d. w. 1984 , phys .
letters , 53 , 2347 bussard , r. w. , ramaty , r. and drachman , r. j. 1979 , apj , 228 , 928 bykov , a. m. , bloemen , h. , ivanchik , a. v. , konstantinov , a. n. , krassilchtchikov , a. m. and lazarev , v. y. 1999 , in proc .
3rd integral workshop , _ the extreme universe _ , astrophys .
& comm . , 38 , 285 cameron , j. a. and singh , b. 1999 , nucl .
data sheets , 88 , 299 chan , k .- w . and lingenfelter , r. 1993 , apj 405 , 614 clayton , d. d. 1982 , _ essays in nuclear astrophysics _ , barnes , c. a. , clayton , d. d. and schramm , d. n. ( eds ) , ( cambridge : cambridge university press ) clayton , d. d. 1983 , _ principles of stellar evolution and nucleosynthesis _ ( chicago and london : the university of chicago press ) coc , a. , hernanz , m. , jos , j. and thibaud , j .-
2000 , a&a , 357 , 561 crannell , c. j. , joyce , g. , ramaty , r. and werntz , c. 1976 , apj , 210 , 582 dermer , c. d. and murphy , r. j. 2001 , proc .
of the 4th integral workshop , _ exploring the gamma - ray universe _ , ( esa publication sp-459 ) , p. 115
diehl , r. and timmes , f. x. 1998 , pasp , 110 , 637 dogiel , v. a. , ichimura , a. , inoue , h. and masai , k. 1998 , pasj , 50 , 567 ebisawa , k. 1996 , pasj , 48 , 425 ellison , d. c. and ramaty , r. 1985 , apj , 298 , 400 elwert , g. 1952 , z. naturf .
7a , 432 , 703 fabian , a. c. , iwasawa , k. , reynolds , c. s. and young , a. j. 2000 , pasp , 112 , 1145 faurobert , m. 1986 , a&a , 158,191 ferland , g. 1995 , _ the analysis of emission lines _ , ed by williams , r. and livio , m. , stsci symposium series 8 , ( cambridge university press ) , p. 83
firestone , r. b. 1996 , _ table of isotopes _
, ed . by shirley , s. v. , ( new york : wiley - interscience publication ) gabriel ,
a. h. 1972 , mnras , 160 , 99 gabriel , a. h. and jordan , c. 1969 , mnras , 145 , 241 gabriel , a. h. and phillips , k. j. h. 1979 , mnras , 189 , 319 garcia , j. d. , fortner , r. j. and kavanagh , t. m. 1973 , rev .
45 , 111 groom , d. e. ( particle data group ) 2000 , eur . phys .
jour . , c15 , 1 and 2001 partial update for edition 2002 ( url : http://pdg.lbl.gov ) guessoum , n. 1989 , apj , 345 , 363 guessoum , n. and gould , r. j. 1989 , apj , 345 , 356 guessoum , n. , ramaty , r. and lingenfelter , r. e. 1991 , apj , 378 , 170 guessoum , n. , skibo , j. g. and ramaty , r. 1997 , proc . of the 2nd integral workshop , _ the transparent universe _ , ( esa publication sp-382 ) , p. 113
halpern , j. p. and grindlay , j. e. 1980 , apj , 242 , 1041 harra - murnion , l. k. 1996 , a&a , 306 , 670 harris , m. j. , teegarden , b. j. , cline , t. l. , gehrels , n. , plamer , d. m. , ramaty , r. and seifert , h. 1998 , apj , 501 , l55 hernanz , m. , gmez - gomar , j. , jos , j. and coc , a. 2001 , proc . of the 4th integral workshop ,
_ exploring the gamma - ray universe _ , ( esa publication sp-459 ) , p. 65
higdon , j. c. and lingenfelter , r. e. 1977 , apj , 215 , l53 hoffmann , d. h. h. , brendel , c. , genz , h. , lw , w. , mller , s. and richter a. 1979 , z. phys a , 293 , 187 horsley , a. 1966 , nucl .
data , a2 , 243 hua , x .-
m . and lingenfelter , r. e. 1987a , solar phys .
, 107 , 351 hua , x .-
m . and lingenfelter , r. e. 1987b , apj , 319 , 555 iyudin , a. f. 2002 , to be published in proc . of baltimore gamma ray symp .
( aip conf .
series ) jean , p. and guessoum , n. 2001 , a&a , 378 , 509 junde , h. 1999 , nucl .
data sheets , 86 , 315 kaastra , j. s. and mewe , r. 1993 , a&as , 97 , 443 kaastra , j. s. , mewe , r. and nieuwenhuijzen , h. 1996 , in _ uv and x - ray spectroscopy of astrophysical and laboratory plasmas _ , ed . by yamashita , k. and watanabe , t. ( tokyo : universal academy press ) ,
p. 411 kallman , t. and bautista , m. 2001 , apjs , 133 , 221 kallman , t. r. and mccray , r. 1982 , apjs , 50 , 263 kiener , j. , de srville , n. and tatischeff , v. 2001 , phys .
c , 64 , 25803 king , m. m. 1993 , nucl .
data sheets , 69 , 1 kingdon , j. b. and ferland , g. j. 1996 , apjs , 106 , 205 kingdon , j. b. and ferland , g. j. 1999 , apj , 516 , l107 kinzer , r. l. , milne , p. a. , kurfess , j. d. , strickman , m. s. johnson , w. n. and purcell , w. r. 2001 , apj , 559 , 282 koch , h. w. and motz , j. w. 1959 , rev .
phys . , 31 , 920 kozlovsky , b. and ramaty , r. 1974 , apj , 191 , l43 kozlovsky , b. , lingenfelter , r. e. and ramaty , r. 1987 , apj , 316 , 801 kozlovsky , b. , murphy , r. j. and ramaty , r. 2002 , in preparation krause , m. o. 1979 , j. phys . chem . ref
. data , 8 , 307 laming , j. m. 2002 , to be published in proc . of the joint soho - ace workshop , _ solar and galactic composition _ , ( aip conf .
series ) landi , e. , landini , m. , dere , k. p. , young , p. r. and mason , h. e. 1999 , a&as , 135 , 339 leising , m. d. 2001 , apj 563 , 185 liedahl , d. a. 1999 , in _ x - ray spectroscopy in astrophysics _
by van paradijs , j. and bleecker , j. a. m. ( berlin : springer - verlag ) , p. 189 liedahl , d. a. , kahn , s. m. , osterheld , a. l. and goldstein , w. h. 1990 , apj , 350 , l37 lingenfelter , r. e. and ramaty , r. 1977 , apj , 211 , l19 lisse , c. m. , christian , d. j. , dennerl , k. , meech , k. j. , petre , r. , weaver , h. a. and wolk , s. j. 2001 , science , 292 , 1343 long , x. , liu , m. , ho , f. and peng , x. 1990 , at .
data nucl .
data tables , 45 , 353 mcconnell , m. , 1997 , proc . of the 4th compton symposium , dermer , c. d. , strickman , m. s. , kurfess , j. d. ( eds ) , aip conf . proc .
410 , p. 1099
mckee , c. f. and ostriker , j. p. 1977 , apj , 218 , 148 mewe , r. , lemen , j. r. and van den oord , g. h. j. 1986 , a&as , 65 , 511 mewe , r. 1999 , in _ x - ray spectroscopy in astrophysics _ , ed .
by van paradijs , j. and bleecker , j. a. m. ( berlin : springer - verlag ) , p. 109
meyer , j. p. 1972 , a&as , 7 , 417 milne , e. a. 1924 , philos . mag .
, 47 , 209 milne , p. a. , kurfess , j. d. , kinzer , r. l. and leising , m. d. 2002 , to be published in proc . of the workshop _ astronomy with radioactivities iii _ , new astronomy reviews mochizuki , y. , takahashi , k. janka , h .- th . , hillebrandt , w. and diehl , r. 1999 , a&a , 346 , 831 morrison , r. and mccammon , d. 1983 , apj , 270 , 119 murphy , r. j. , dermer , c. d. and ramaty , r. 1987 , apjs , 63 , 721 ore , a. and powell , j. l. 1949 , phys .
, 75 , 1696 porquet , d. and dubau 2000 , j. a&as , 143 , 495 porquet , d. , arnaud , m. and decourchelle a. 2001a , a&a , 373 , 1110 porquet , d. , mewe , r. , dubau , j. , raassen , a. j. j. and kaastra , j. s. 2001b , a&a , 376 , 1113 prantzos , n. 1999 , in proc .
3rd integral workshop , _ the extreme universe _ , astrophys .
lett . & comm .
, 38 , 337 quarles , c. a. 1976 , phys .
a , 13 , 1278 rajagopal , m. and romani , r. w. 1996 , apj , 461 , 327 ramaty , r. , kozlovsky , b. and lingenfelter , r. e. 1975 , space sci .
, 18 , 341 ramaty , r. , kozlovsky , b. and lingenfelter , r. e. 1979 , apjs , 40 , 487 ramaty , r. , kozlovsky , b. and lingenfelter , r. e. 1996 , apj , 456 , 525 ramaty , r. and lingenfelter , r. e. 1979 , nature , 278 , 127 ramaty , r. and mandzhavidze , n. 2000 , in _ highly energetic physical processes and mechanisms for emission from astrophysical plasmas _ , ed . by martens ,
tsuruta , s. and weber , m. a. ( san francisco : astron .
pacific ) , p. 123
raymond , j. c. 1988 , in _ hot thin plasmas in astrophysics _
, ed . by pallavicini ,
r. ( dordrecht : kluwer acad .
publ . ) , p. 3
ross , r. r. 1979 , apj , 233 , 334 rybicki , g. b. and lightman , a. p. 1979 , _ radiative processes in astrophysics _
( new york : wiley ) sako , m. , liedahl , d. a. , kahn , s. m. and paerels , f. 1999 , apj , 525 , 921 savage b. d. , sembach k. r. 1996 , ara&a , 34 , 279 schnfelder , v. , 2000 , a&as , 143 , 145 share , g. h. and murphy , r. j. 2001 , in proc . of the gamma 2001 symposium , aip conf .
587 , p. 603
shull , j. m. 1979 , apj , 234 , 761 shvartsman , v. f. 1972 , astrophysics , 6 , 56 smith , r. k. , brickhouse , n. s. , liedahl , d. a. and raymond , j. c. 2001 , apj , 556 , l91 sobelman , i. i. 1979 , _ atomic spectra and radiative transitions _ , ( berlin : springer - verlag ) stecker , f. 1969 , ap&ss , 3 , 479 tatischeff , v. , ramaty , r. and kozlovsky , b. 1998 , apj , 504 , 874 tatischeff , v. and ramaty , r. 1999 , in proc .
3rd integral workshop , _ the extreme universe _ , astrophys .
lett . & comm . , 38 , 465 tatischeff , v. , thibaud , j .-
p . , kiener , j. , cass , m. and vangioni - flam , e. 2001 , proc . of the 4th integral workshop ,
_ exploring the gamma - ray universe _ , ( esa publication sp-459 ) , p. 105 timmes , f. x. and woosley , s. e. 1997 , apj , 481 , l81 valinia , a. , tatischeff , v. , arnaud , k. , ebisawa , k. and ramaty , r. 2000 , apj , 543 , 733 verner , d. a. , yakovlev , d. g. , band , i. m. and trzhaskovskaya , m. b. 1993 , at .
data nucl .
data tables , 55 , 233 vestrand , w. t. , share , g. h. , murphy , r. j. , forrest , d. j. , rieger , e. , chupp , e. l. and kanbach , g. 1999 , apjs , 120 , 409 wallyn , p. , mahomey , w. a. , durouchoux , ph . and chapuis , c. 1996 , apj , 465 , 473 wang , h. t. and ramaty , r. 1974 , solar phys . , 36 , 129 weisheit , j. c. 1974 , apj , 190 , 735 weisskopf , m. c. , brinkman , b. , canizares , c. , garmire , g. , murray , s. and van speybroeck , l. p. 2002 , pasp , 114 , 1 younger , s. m. 1982 , phys .
rev . , a26 , 3177 zarro , d. m. , dennis , b. r. and slater , g. l. 1992 , apj , 391 , 865 zobel , w. , maienschein , f. c. , todd , j. h. and chapman , g. t. 1968 , nucl .
eng . , 32 , 392 zurek , w. h. 1985 , apj , 289 , 603 | this chapter is intended to provide a general presentation of the atomic and nuclear processes responsible for x - ray line and gamma - ray line emission in various astrophysical environments .
i consider line production from hot plasmas , from accelerated particle interactions , from the decay of radioactive nuclei synthesized in stars and from positron annihilation .
spectroscopic properties of these emissions are discussed in the light of the detection capabilities of modern space instruments . |
very recently , the icecube collaboration announced their observation of two events which could potentially represent the first detection of high - energy astrophysical neutrinos @xcite .
the analysis under consideration was designed to search for very high - energy ( @xmath2 pev ) and high - quality shower events over a period of 615.9 live days between 2010 and 2012 . over this time , the icecube experiment was in its nearly complete ( 79 string ) and complete ( 86 string ) configurations .
the two showers in question were observed on august 8 , 2011 and january 3 , 2012 , and each have an energy of approximately 1 pev ( 1.04 and 1.14 pev `` with a combined and statistical uncertainty of @xmath3 each '' @xcite ) .
both showers were fully contained within the volume of the detector , and there are no indications of any instrumental problems , or of any connection with atmospheric muons . at energies below @xmath01 pev ,
atmospheric neutrinos constitute icecube s primary background .
conventional atmospheric neutrinos , which are produced in the decays of pions and kaons present in cosmic ray induced cascades in the earth s atmosphere , follow a spectrum which falls - off rapidly with energy ( following a power - law spectrum with an index of approximately 3.7 ) .
although this background is negligible at energies above several pev , it can not be entirely discounted in the case of the analysis at hand .
in particular , the icecube collaboration expects 0.082@xmath4(stat.)@xmath5(syst . )
background fully contained events with energy 1or more pev ( including neutrinos from atmospheric muons , form decays of pions and kaons and prompt atmospheric neutrinos from decays of charmed mesons ) over the time period covered by their analysis .
the observation of two events with an expected background of 0.082 constitutes a p - value of @xmath6 , corresponding to a significance of 2.8@xmath7 .
in addition to the so - called conventional atmospheric neutrinos , a somewhat harder spectrum of prompt atmospheric neutrinos produced in the decays of heavy flavor ( charm , bottom ) mesons is also expected .
estimates of the event rate from this component of the atmospheric neutrino spectrum are less certain , although the lack of any correlation between the two observed events and hits in the icetop surface array appears to disfavor this interpretation ( efforts to quantify icetop s veto efficiency are currently ongoing ) . given the quite modest statistical significance ( 2.8@xmath7 ) represented by these two events , we can not at this time be confident that they are of cosmic origin .
that being said , if they are in fact cosmic neutrinos , then a few more years of data should reveal several more pev showers . at a continued rate of 2 events per 615.9 live days
, we estimate that this signal will become inconsistent with an atmospheric origin at the 5@xmath7 level after a total of approximately 7 years of data taking .
searches for muon - track events or partially contained showers could also shed a great deal of light on the question of whether these events in fact originate from beyond the earth s atmosphere . in this paper , we assume that this pair of intriguing events are astrophysical in nature and discuss the types of astrophysical sources from which they could potentially originate . in sec .
[ general ] , we discuss in general terms the astrophysical production of pev neutrinos and argue that these two events if , in fact , astrophysical in nature are likely to originate from the same class of objects that produce the bulk of the @xmath1 ev - scale cosmic rays . in particular , for such sources to produce the pev neutrino flux implied by icecube s two events , it is only necessary that on the order of ten percent of the energy in @xmath0@xmath1 ev cosmic rays is lost to photo - meson interactions . in this context ,
gamma - ray bursts are a particularly attractive possibility , which we discuss in sec .
we consider other possible sources such as active galactic nuclei in sec .
[ other ] , but find these scenarios less compelling unless the objects in question are surrounded by significant densities of high energy ( x - ray ) radiation .
we also present arguments for why these neutrinos are unlikely to be produced in the propagation of cosmic rays ( cosmogenic neutrinos ) or result from the decays of ultra - high energy neutrons . in sec .
[ predictions ] , we make predictions for future observations at icecube and , in sec .
[ summary ] , we summarize our results and conclusions .
pev - scale astrophysical neutrinos can be produced through three primary processes .
firstly , proton collisions with energetic photons can generate charged pions ( photo - meson production ) , which yield neutrinos in their decays . to exceed the threshold for pion production ,
however , one must consider circumstances in which the target radiation is fairly energetic ( 10 s of ev or above ) .
secondly , collisions between energetic protons ( or neutrons ) and gas can easily exceed the threshold for pion production . in sources of protons with enough energy to yield pev neutrinos , however , the number density of sufficiently energetic photon targets present will almost certainly be much larger than that of nucleons .
thus we only expect @xmath8 collisions to dominate neutrino production in sources of lower energy neutrinos .
mb , while bellow the pion production threshold that cross - section is highly suppressed .
the inelastic pp collisions cross - section is relatively constant at pev energies being @xmath9 59 mb for a 1 pev cr proton and 72 mb for a 10 pev cr proton colliding with an ism gas proton .
our arguments depend on the mean free path of a cr proton interacting with a target photon or proton , @xmath10 , @xmath11 with @xmath12 and @xmath13 .
@xmath14 , @xmath15 are the target photon and proton densities respectively . ] and lastly , pev electron anti - neutrinos can result from the decays of ultra high - energy neutrons . as only a small fraction of a neutron s energy goes into its neutrino decay product , however , neutron decay anti - neutrinos
are not predicted to be produced in sufficient numbers to account for the two events recently reported by the icecube collaboration ( see , for example , refs .
@xcite ) . with these considerations in mind
, we expect cosmic ray collisions with energetic photons to be the dominant mechanism behind icecube s two reported events ( assuming they are in fact astrophysical and not terrestrial in nature ) . and while one could also contemplate more exotic sources , such as the decays of ultra - heavy particles , we confine ourselves to conventional astrophysical scenarios in this paper .
each of the three production mechanisms described above involve very high - energy cosmic rays , providing us with a direct connection between the observation of high - energy neutrinos and the observed cosmic ray spectrum @xcite .
more specifically , one can place an upper bound on the diffuse neutrino flux that results from cosmologically distributed , optically - thin cosmic ray accelerators .
this argument , originally presented by waxman and bahcall in connection with cosmic rays of the highest energies @xcite , begins with the ( cosmologically ) local energy injection rate of ultra high - energy ( @xmath16 ev ) cosmic rays : @xmath17}}{\ln(10^{21}/10^{19 } ) } \approx 10^{44}\,\rm{erg}\,\rm{mpc}^{-3 } \rm{yr}^{-1}\,,\ ] ] where an injected energy spectrum @xmath18@xmath19 has been assumed .
the energy density of neutrinos produced through the photo - meson interactions of these protons can be directly tied to the injection rate of cosmic rays : @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the hubble time and @xmath22 is the fraction of the energy which is injected in protons lost to photo - meson interactions .
the factor of 3/8 comes from the fact that , near the threshold for pion production , roughly half the pions produced in photo - meson interactions are neutral and do not generate neutrinos , and three quarters of the energy of charged pion decays ( @xmath23 ) go into neutrinos .
taken together , the neutrino flux connected to the observed cosmic ray spectrum is given by : @xmath24_{\rm wb } & \approx & ( 3/8 ) \,\xi_z\ , \epsilon_\pi\ , t_{\rm{h}}\ , \frac{c}{4\pi}\,e^2_{\rm{cr } } \frac{d\dot{n}_{\rm{cr}}}{de_{\rm{cr } } } \nonumber \\ & \approx & 2.3 \times 10^{-8}\,\epsilon_\pi\,\xi_z\ , \rm{gev}\ , \rm{cm}^{-2}\,\rm{s}^{-1}\,\rm{sr}^{-1 } , \label{wbproton}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the parameter @xmath25 accounts for the effects of redshift dependent source evolution .
waxman and bahcall originally presented this argument as an upper bound , derived for the case of @xmath26 ( representing the maximum flux from a class of optically thin sources ) . if @xmath8 interactions had instead been assumed .
] at production , the neutrino flux from positively charged pion decays consists of equal fractions of @xmath27 , @xmath28 and @xmath29 .
after oscillations are taken in account , however , the muon neutrinos and anti - neutrinos become a roughly equal mixture of muon and tau flavors . for a distribution of sources which follows the star formation rate @xcite , source evolution increases the normalization of the waxman - bahcall flux by a factor of @xmath30 5.75
( see also @xcite ) .
we note that if we had used the grb source evolution model as described in @xcite , this factor would be larger , about 22 .
it should be noted that if we drop the assumption that the cosmic ray injection spectrum is of the form , @xmath31 , we could potentially increase the flux of 1 - 10 pev cosmic neutrinos , although not by more than a factor of about two @xcite . more significantly ,
if the sources of the ultra high - energy cosmic rays are not optically thin to photo - meson production , as assumed in the derivation of the waxman - bahcall bound , then the observed cosmic ray spectrum could be made up of only the tail of the distribution of accelerated cosmic rays which escape from their sources .
in such a case , much or even most of the energy that goes into accelerating ultra high - energy cosmic rays could be lost to the source environment , reabsorbing most would - be cosmic rays before they escape . from a class of such optically thick `` hidden '' sources , neutrino fluxes
could plausibly be produced that are in excess of the waxman - bahcall bound by more than an order of magnitude , without exceeding the observed cosmic ray spectrum or gamma - ray background @xcite .
so far , this calculation has assumed that the cosmic ray spectrum consists of only protons , rather than iron or other nuclei species .
heavy nuclei cosmic rays only produce charged pions after disintegrating into their constituent nucleons .
thus if the cosmic ray spectrum were dominated by heavy nuclei , the resulting neutrino flux would be further suppressed relative to the maximum value found in the standard waxman - bahcall calculation @xcite . in the cosmic ray energy range around @xmath0@xmath1
ev that leads to the production of @xmath01 - 10 pev neutrinos , however , there is evidence that the cosmic ray spectrum is dominated by protons ( although this appears to gradually evolve to a heavy nuclei dominated spectrum above @xmath32 ev ) @xcite .
we thus assume a proton dominated cosmic ray spectrum throughout this study . for a high - energy cosmic neutrino spectrum
, we can calculate the estimated rate of pev - scale showers expected at icecube .
hadronic showers can be generated through the neutral current interactions of all neutrino flavors i.e @xmath33 , @xmath34 ( @xmath35 notating additional products ) at @xmath36 energy of @xmath376.3 pev and a width of @xmath38 .
] , with a typical shower energy that is about a quarter of that possessed by the initial neutrino .
alternatively , charged - current interactions of electron neutrinos and anti - neutrinos ( @xmath39 , @xmath40 ) produce a superposition of electromagnetic showers ( evolving through the bremsstrahlung emission of a high energy photon from an electron / positron and through the subsequent @xmath41 pair production per interaction length ) and hadronic showers that in each interaction produce through the hadronization of quarks a wide variety of hadronic particles which subsequently decay into lighter particles including muons . in the charged current interactions the electromagnetic and
the hadronic showers collectively contain the entire energy of the incoming neutrino .
while electromagnetic and hadronic showers are , in principle , distinguishable by their respective muon content , such a separation is generally expected to be difficult .
in addition to producing tracks associated with charged leptons , charged current interactions of muon and tau neutrinos produce hadronic showers similar to those resulting from neutral current processes .
pev showers appear to the icecube detector as photo - electrons distributed over an approximately @xmath0@xmath42 m radius sphere .
although the two recently reported shower events were entirely contained within the volume of the experiment , icecube should be capable of detecting partially contained showers as well .
the probability that a neutrino passing through the effective area of icecube produces an observable shower via a neutral current interaction is given by @xmath43 where @xmath44 the avogadro number , @xmath7 is the neutrino - nucleon cross section @xcite , @xmath45 is the energy fraction transferred from the initial neutrino to the target nucleus , @xmath46 is the length of the detector and @xmath47 is the density of ice . for
charged - current electron neutrino interactions , all of the neutrino energy goes into the shower , leading instead to @xmath48 . in calculating the expected rate of pev - scale events at icecube , we must also account for neutrino absorption in the earth .
a @xmath01 pev neutrino has only a few percent chance of passing through the equatorial diameter of the earth without undergoing at least one interaction .
in contrast , for neutrinos with an inclined trajectory of 10 degrees below the horizon , only about half of such particles will undergo one or more interactions in the earth .
the effects of absorption are negligible for downward - going neutrinos in the energy range under consideration . in calculating the effects of neutrino absorption
, we adopt a simple density model of the earth , consisting of a 2500 km radius core with a uniform density of 11,000 kg / m@xmath49 and a uniform density outer region normalized to the overall mass and radius of the earth . for a high - energy cosmic neutrino spectrum that saturates the waxman - bahcall bound ( @xmath50 ) , from sources distributed without significant redshift evolution ( @xmath51 ) , we calculate that icecube should observe a rate of 13.6 showers per year , per cubic kilometer , with more than 1 pev of energy .
if we further require that the showers be initiated in the inner volume , restricting ourselves to fully contained events , the effective volume of icecube is reduced to roughly @xmath00.1 km@xmath49 , and thus we predict icecube to observe 1 or 2 fully contained pev - showers per year . in fig .
[ wbfigure ] , we compare the approximate neutrino flux required to explain the two pev showers reported by the icecube collaboration to the waxman and bahcall bound , both without source evolution and with source evolution that follows the star formation rate .
we also show the less stringent upper bound derived in the case of optically thick sources @xcite .
the fact that the neutrino flux required to explain icecube s two pev showers lies not far below the waxman - bahcall bound implies that a significant fraction ( @xmath210% ) of energy injected into @xmath0@xmath1 ev cosmic rays must be transferred into pions .
we also note that icecube s current ( 90% cl ) upper limit on the diffuse neutrino flux in this energy range is @xmath52 gev @xmath53 s@xmath54 sr@xmath54 , assuming an @xmath19 spectrum between @xmath55 and @xmath56 gev @xcite , which is very close to the flux required to account for the two reported events .
as the majority of such events are expected to occur at energies below a few pev , the precise spectral shape at higher energies impacts this rate only marginally . in the following section , we move away from these general arguments , and consider gamma - ray bursts as a specific class of sources that is particularly well suited to produce the required flux of neutrinos in the pev energy range .
gamma - ray busts ( grbs ) constitute one of the most promising sources of high and ultra - high energy cosmic rays , and may be capable of accelerating protons to energies as high as @xmath0@xmath57 ev @xcite .
furthermore , as their name implies , gamma - ray burst fireballs contain high densities of gamma - rays , enabling for the efficient production of neutrinos via the photo - meson interactions of high energy protons @xcite .
more specifically , typical grbs exhibit a broken power - law spectrum of the form : @xmath58 for @xmath59 mev and @xmath60 at lower energies @xcite .
furthermore , the radiation pressure resulting from the very high optical depth of grb fireballs leads to their ultra - relativistic expansion , accelerating the plasma to lorentz factors on the order of @xmath61 . in order for proton - photon collisions in this environment to exceed the threshold for pion production
, the proton must have an energy ( in the observer s frame ) that meets the following condition @xcite : @xmath62 where @xmath63 is the redshift of the burst . for any falling spectrum of high - energy protons
, such interactions will predominantly take place near this threshold . after taking into account that only about 20% of the proton s energy goes into the charged pion produced in such an interaction , and that each neutrino carries away only about a quarter of the charged pion s energy , this leads to the production of neutrinos of characteristic energy : @xmath64 thus for protons interacting with photons near the observed spectral break , the resulting neutrinos will have energies near that of the two events reported by icecube .
the neutrino flux at energies below this value will be suppressed by the lack of sufficiently high energy target photons in the fireball .
for this reason , the pev energy scale is where one roughly expects to observe the first grb neutrinos ( see also @xcite ) .
the overall normalization of the diffuse neutrino flux from all grbs depends on how much of the bursts internal energy goes into accelerating protons to energies of @xmath0@xmath65 ev and above .
it has been appreciated for some time that if the majority of the highest energy cosmic rays originate from grbs , then one should also expect an observable diffuse flux of high energy neutrinos @xcite . in our calculations , we adopt a ratio of ten between the energy that goes into accelerated protons and electrons @xcite , and also assume that @xmath661% of the energy in accelerated protons goes into neutrinos .
there are significant deviations in that factor between individual grbs @xcite , depending on the fireball environment .
a value of @xmath67 of the proton energy going to neutrinos corresponds to @xmath68 .
higher fractions of proton energy going to neutrinos would result in higher neutrino fluxes keeping all the other grb assumptions fixed .
most observed grbs exhibit maximum isotropic luminosities in the range of @xmath69 erg / s .- ray luminosity is synchrotron emission from internal shocks in the relativistic fireball @xcite , this emission will be relativistically beamed to within an opening angle on the order of @xmath70 . in our calculations , we use the isotropic equivalent luminosity related to the true luminosity by : @xmath71 .
this avoids overestimating the neutrino or photon fluxes .
we also estimate the total isotropic energy emitted to be @xmath72 .
@xmath73(for simplicity in the remaining text ) is the maximum isotropic equivalent luminosity ; the duration timescale as observed in hard x - rays and @xmath74-rays , is taken to be @xmath75 sec for high luminosity grbs and and @xmath76 sec for the low luminosity sample . here
, @xmath77 is taken as the timescale between which 25% and 75% of the total energy ( in x - rays and @xmath74-rays ) has been emitted ( see @xcite ) . ]
such bursts are referred to in literature as high luminosity grbs and are further divided into short and long duration bursts with observed timescales of 0.1 - 1 and 10 - 100 seconds , respectively ; with the majority of observed bursts being of long duration @xcite . in addition , a few low luminosity grbs with @xmath78 erg / s have been detected , potentially representing another distinct grb population @xcite ( see also ref .
these low luminosity grbs , which are potentially much more numerous than their high luminosity counterparts , generally exhibit smooth light curves , wider emission cones and longer durations ( 50 - 1000 s ) @xcite . both high and low luminosity grb populations can be described by a luminosity distribution parametrized as : @xmath79^{-1 } , \label{eq : lumindistr}\ ] ] where @xmath80 normalizes the luminosity distribution to 1 ( within 2 orders of magnitude above / below the luminosity break @xmath81 ) . at present , there is considerable variation in the values of these parameters as they appear in the literature @xcite . in our calculations , we adopt ranges based on 2 years of _ swift _ data as presented in ref .
@xcite : @xmath82 erg / s , @xmath83 , @xmath84 for high luminosity grbs and @xmath85 erg / s , @xmath86 , @xmath87 for low luminosity grbs .
these parameters lead to mean values ( of the grb distribution ) for the ( individual ) grb maximum isotropic luminosity of @xmath88 to @xmath89 erg / s for high luminosity grbs and @xmath90 to @xmath91 erg / s for low luminosity grbs . throughout the remainder of this study
, we will use as reference values @xmath92 erg / s and @xmath93 erg / s , but will also consider variations in order to test the assumptions of ref .
@xcite and @xcite ( see also @xcite for an alternative analysis on the impact of different luminosity distribution assumptions ) . for the redshift distribution ( co -
moving rate density ) of grbs , we adopt the star formation rate of ref .
@xcite ( model `` sf2 '' ) : @xmath94 high luminosity grbs occur at a local rate on the order of 1 gpc@xmath95yr@xmath54 @xcite , while the rate of low luminosity grbs is considerably higher , with estimate ranging from 230 @xcite to @xmath96 @xcite gpc@xmath95yr@xmath54 .
we take as reference values @xmath97 and @xmath98 gpc@xmath95yr@xmath54 . while it has been suggested @xcite that the grb rate redshift distribution does not follow the star formation rate , but is instead suppressed at @xmath99
, this would not affect the observed fluxes from high luminosity grbs by more than about a factor of 2 from our reference values for high luminosity grbs .
the diffuse flux of neutrinos or photons at the location of the earth from the population of all grbs is given by : @xmath100 where @xmath101 and @xmath102 refers to the observable neutrino / photon fluence from an individual grb located at comoving distance @xmath103 ( luminosity distance @xmath104 ) : @xmath105 @xmath106 is the equivalent injection neutrino / photon spectrum .
we take as @xmath107 , with @xmath108 does not impact our calculations by more than @xmath109 . ] which is the most distant grb that has been detected @xcite .
the spectrum of neutrinos ( and anti - neutrinos ) at injection can be approximated by a doubly broken power - law @xcite : @xmath110 the first of these spectral features ( at @xmath111 ) corresponds to the pion production threshold for scattering off photons at the observed break in the gamma - ray spectrum of grbs , while the higher energy break ( at @xmath112 ) appears as a result of the synchrotron cooling of muons and pions .
the exact locations of these breaks is different for typical high and low luminosity grbs due to differences in the strengths of the fireballs magnetic and radiation fields . in calculating the location of the first break ,
we assume a gamma - ray spectrum which breaks at 1 mev or 0.1 mev for high and low luminosity grbs , respectively .
furthermore the exact power - law index bellow our first break ( located between @xmath113 and @xmath114 gev ) in the injected neutrino spectrum of eq .
[ eq : nuinjspect ] can not influence the flux above at 1 pev , especially since the grb neutrino fluxes are normalized by their injected energy to neutrinos dominated by the contribution of neutrinos with energy between the two breaks of eq .
[ eq : nuinjspect ] .
deviations from the standard waxman - bahcall spectrum reproducible by the @xmath115 resonance can result from additional neutrino production modes @xcite .
these modifications of the spectrum once normalizing the injected energy to neutrinos -which is the main uncertainty- do not affect our calculations by more than a factor of 2 . in fig .
[ fig : grbvariations ] , we show the diffuse flux of neutrinos and anti - neutrinos from grbs for our default parameter choices , and for some representative variations of these parameters .
the solid and dashed lines represent the predicted flux for our default assumptions , from high and low luminosity bursts , respectively .
the dot - dashed line represents the contribution from high luminosity grbs with a redshift distribution which is suppressed above @xmath116 .
the dotted line shows the flux from high luminosity grb with alternative choices for the parameters leading to the location of the spectral breaks .
while these variations are by no means exhaustive , they demonstrate that for a fairly wide range of assumptions , grbs are expected to generate fluxes of pev neutrinos that are similar to that implied by icecube s two events ( see the dotted line in fig . 1 ) . in particular , for each of the four neutrino fluxes shown in fig
[ fig : grbvariations ] , one expects a rate of 4 - 7 showers with energies above 1 pev per cubic kilometer , per year . for an estimate of @xmath00.1 km@xmath49 for the effective volume for
fully contained showers , this range of rates is within about a factor of two of that required to account for the two events reported by icecube . among the various uncertainties that are involved in the calculation of the neutrino flux from grbs ,
a few stand out as particularly important .
first of these is the fraction of the energy that goes into accelerating protons to energies above @xmath65 ev . in the case of the contribution from high luminosity grbs , uncertainties in the luminosity function
are particularly significant .
for low luminosity grbs , the local rate of such objects constitutes a major uncertainty . at present , these uncertainties can collectively impact expectations for the diffuse neutrino flux by as much as an order of magnitude and will continue to do so until they are better observationally constrained . by restricting an analysis to events which correlate in time and/or direction to known grbs ,
it is possible to conduct a nearly background free search for neutrinos originating from grbs .
recently , the icecube collaboration has applied such a strategy , and used the results to derive a stringent upper limit on the flux of high energy neutrinos from observed grbs @xcite . under standard astrophysical assumptions
, this limit implies that grbs can not be the only sources of the highest energy ( @xmath117 ev ) cosmic rays ( see also , ref .
the two events being considered in this paper , however , could still originate from grb if either , 1 ) a greater fraction than expected of the high energy neutrinos from grbs originate from bursts which are not sufficiently luminous to be observed by gamma - ray or x - ray observatories , or 2 ) a significant fraction of the @xmath118 ev cosmic ray spectrum ( but not most of the @xmath117 ev cosmic ray spectrum ) originates from grbs .
this later possibility is attractive from the perspective of the cosmic ray spectrum s chemical composition .
measurements from the pierre auger observatory of the depth of shower maxima and its variation suggest that the highest energy cosmic rays are largely of heavy chemical composition ( closer in mass to iron nuclei than protons ) , while the composition becomes steadily lighter at lower energies , appearing to be dominated by protons at @xmath119 ev @xcite . as ultra high - energy nuclei accelerated in a grb
are expected to be entirely disintegrated into individual nucleons before escaping the fireball @xcite , the possibility that grbs provide much of the cosmic ray spectrum below @xmath0@xmath119 ev , but that another class of sources provide the bulk of the highest energy ( heavy nuclei ) cosmic rays , is a well motivated one .
the fact that the two pev shower events reported by icecube do not correlate in time with any known grb does not significantly disfavor the hypothesis that these events originate from grbs .
the ability of gamma - rays and x - ray observatories to monitor for grbs is , at present , substantially incomplete .
in particular , the _ swift _ burst alert telescope ( bat ) and the _ fermi _ gamma - ray burst monitor ( gbm ) collectively cover less than @xmath662/3 of the sky at any given time . with this in mind , one can not rule out the non - negligible possibility that the two pev shower events originated from grbs which happened to fall outside of the combined field - of - view of these instruments .
furthermore , many grbs , while in the field - of - view of either _ swift _ s bat or _ fermi _
s gbm , may still go undetected if they are of sufficiently low luminosity , or are sufficiently distant . to assess whether this later possibility is consistent with a grb interpretation of these events , we must attempt to estimate the efficiency with which neutrino - producing grbs are detected in the gamma - ray and x - ray bands @xcite . given the fluence sensitivity of the the _ swift _ s bat and _ fermi _ s gbm @xmath0@xmath120 erg @xmath53s@xmath54 and @xmath0@xmath121 erg @xmath53s@xmath54 ( at 20 kev ) respectively
, one can estimate how distant a grb ( of a given luminosity ) could be and still trigger these detectors .
we find that these experiments should be capable of detecting essentially all high luminosity grbs ( @xmath122 erg / s ) within their fields - of - view out to a distance of about 8 gpc @xmath123 .
thus the observed collection of high luminosity grbs is fairly complete ( within the given fields - of - view ) .
in contrast , low luminosity grbs ( @xmath124 erg / s ) are likely to be detected only within a radius of @xmath0@xmath125 mpc , suggesting that the vast majority of the diffuse neutrino flux from low luminosity grb will not be correlated in time or direction with any observed gamma - ray or x - ray signal .
the kinematics of high - energy neutrino production in active galactic nuclei ( agn ) is similar to that described for grbs in eqns .
[ grbc1]-[grbc2 ] , but with potentially important differences .
in particular , the lorentz factors of agn jets are significantly lower than those of grb shocks ; values of @xmath126 rather than @xmath0300 are thought to be typical @xcite . as a result
, @xmath010 - 100 pev protons can exceed the threshold for pion production much more easily , requiring only the presence of @xmath0kev photons ( rather than the @xmath0100 kev photons required in grbs ) . in grbs , the observed photon spectral break ( @xmath00.1 - 1 mev ) leads to a break at @xmath01 pev in the neutrino spectrum .
thus we may expect the first detections of grb neutrinos to appear at around this energy scale .
in contrast , agn do not typically exhibit a spectral peak at kev energies , but instead in the uv , typically at around @xmath010 ev .
this leads one to expect the neutrino spectrum to peak eev energies , much higher than that from grbs .
there is a considerable degree of model dependence in this conclusion , however , deriving in large part from uncertainties in the spectrum of the target radiation fields .
we illustrate the nature of this uncertainty in fig .
[ fig : agn ] , with a comparison of two canonical models of the diffuse neutrino emission from agn .
first , as a solid line , we show the diffuse neutrino spectrum as predicted by protheroe @xcite . in this model
, the scattering of ultra - high energy protons with uv radiation leads to a neutrino spectrum which peaks at eev energies . for this spectral shape
, most showers initiated within icecube s volume will be of energy 20 pev or greater . if icecube s existing data does not contain at least a few enormous ( non - contained ) showers of this energy , this agn model will not be able to account for the two reported pev events .
in contrast , the model of stecker et al . @xcite predicts a neutrino spectrum from agn which peaks at a much lower energy of a few pev , not unlike the predictions from grbs .
this is in large part due to the high density of ambient x - rays present in the stecker _
et al_. agn model .
we also point out that while neutrino emission from known grbs can be efficiently constrained by searching in the time window around the occurrence of a given burst , such a background - free strategy is not possible for agn . as a result , while it may be possible to rule out ( high luminosity ) grb as the source of icecube s two pev events by searching in the time and direction of known grbs
, it will be much more difficult to definitively test the hypothesis that these neutrinos originate from agn . collisions of cosmic rays with the radiation in galaxies undergoing periods of rapid star formation are predicted to yield significant fluxes of @xmath0tev - pev neutrinos @xcite . for reasonable assumptions , and calibrating to the observed fluxes of gamma - rays @xcite and radio emission from such objects , contributions to the diffuse neutrino flux
are expected to be on the order of @xmath0@xmath127 gev @xmath53 s@xmath54 sr@xmath54 @xcite .
while it is not clear whether this diffuse spectrum extends to energies as high as @xmath0pev , if it does , starburst galaxies could potentially contribute at a level capable of accounting for the two pev events reported by icecube . in order to generate @xmath01 - 10 pev neutrinos via the production and decay of charged pions , protons with energies on the order of of @xmath0@xmath128 pev are required .
furthermore , in order to exceed the threshold for pion production in the center - of - mass frame , these ultra - energetic protons must encounter a sufficient density of energetic photons ( or nucleons ) .
a @xmath1 ev proton , for example , can only produce pions by scattering off of photons in excess of approximately 1 ev . the intergalactic background densities of radiation at such energies are insufficient to lead to any significant amount of pion production @xcite , we restate the well known conclusion that the universe is transparent to @xmath1 ev protons , and thus find that cosmogenic neutrinos are unlikely to be the source of the two events reported by icecube ( see also @xcite ) . we also note that while electron anti - neutrinos from the decays of ultra - high energy neutrons could , in principle , contribute to the diffuse neutrino flux at pev energies , such neutrinos are insufficient to account for the events reported by icecube , even in heavy nuclei dominated cosmic ray scenarios @xcite .
finally , large scale intergalactic shock waves produced due to structure formation may be capable of accelerating both electrons and protons to lorentz factors as high as @xmath0@xmath129 @xcite . through inverse compton scattering
, the resulting cosmic ray electrons can produce up to @xmath010% of the observed isotropic gamma - ray spectrum above 50 gev .
the corresponding protons , are constrained to not produce through inelastic pp collisions significant fluxes of gamma - rays or neutrinos , unless the production of gev scale @xmath74-rays from cr electrons -setting the constraint for this sources- is highly suppressed ( see @xcite ) .
if the two pev shower events observed by icecube are , in fact , neutrino induced events , then one should expect them to be accompanied by a significant rate of corresponding muon track events .
once produced through the charged current interaction of a muon neutrino ( or antineutrino ) , a muon loses energy at a rate given by : @xmath130 where , in ice , @xmath131 and @xmath132 .
thus , before the energy of a propagating muon falls below @xmath133 , it travels a distance of : @xmath134.\ ] ] for pev - scale muons , this range will significantly exceed the linear scale of icecube , increasing the effective target mass of the experiment
. the probability of a muon neutrino producing a muon track with an energy greater than @xmath133 inside of the volume of icecube is given by : @xmath135 to make a comparison between the rate of shower and muon track events , we consider a spectrum of the form @xmath136 , and with the flavor ratios predicted from the decays of positively charged mesons , after accounting for oscillations ( @xmath137 ) . and
@xmath138 for non - zero values of @xmath139
. thus the rate of showers at the energy of the glashow resonance ( 6.3 pev ) could be used as a probe of this oscillation parameter @xcite . ] considering only neutrinos with energies in excess of 1 pev , we find that for every fully contained shower ( @xmath140 km@xmath49 ) , one expects 33 ( 11 ) muons tracks with more than 100 tev ( 1 pev ) of energy to travel through the volume of icecube .
we thus conclude that if these two fully contained pev showers are neutrino induced , then the existing data set from icecube should contain tens of pev muon track events , as well as tens of partially contained pev showers .
such events would be very valuable for searching for correlations in direction ( for track events ) and time with known gamma - ray bursts .
we also note that it may be possible for icecube to identify pev - scale events which are unique to tau neutrinos @xcite . following the approach of ref .
@xcite , and for the same assumptions as in the previous paragraph , we estimate that for every fully contained pev shower , one should expect approximately 0.7 lollipop events and 0.25 double bang events . while these are not particularly high rates , even one or two tau - unique events would be very helpful in confirming an astrophysical nature of the events in question .
experiments such as icecube were motivated in large part by the connection between the observed cosmic ray spectrum and high - energy cosmic neutrinos .
in particular , if a significant fraction of high - energy cosmic rays interact via photo - meson interactions , then it should be possible to observe the resulting diffuse flux of very high - energy cosmic neutrinos . with the observation of two showers with energies of @xmath661 pev at icecube
, we may very well be witnessing the first light in the field of high - energy neutrino astronomy .
and if so , the energy and flux implied by these events is strongly suggestive of a connection with the observed cosmic ray spectrum . in this paper , we have considered a number of possible sources and mechanisms that could produce pev neutrinos in a quantity capable of accounting for the two events observed by icecube .
we find that photo - meson interactions of @xmath010 - 100 pev protons to be the most promising possibility , which could plausibly be realized in a variety of astrophysical sources , including gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) , active galactic nuclei ( agn ) , and starburst galaxies . due to the observed break at 0.1 - 1 mev in the spectra of typical grbs ,
one expects the resulting neutrino spectrum from such objects to peak at the pev scale ; in fact we find that grbs can naturally explain the two observed events .
more specifically , we find that a neutrino flux comparable to that implied by the two events is predicted for a wide range of assumptions regarding the redshift distribution , luminosity function , and other physical characteristics of grbs . in contrast ,
the photon spectra in typical agn models peak at much lower energies , and thus neutrino spectra are predicted which peak at energies well above those of icecube s two events .
in fact , searches for even higher energy showers in icecube s existing data set may be capable of excluding some of such models .
cosmic ray collisions in starburst galaxies are also a promising possibility , but it is not clear whether neutrinos with energies as high as 1 pev can be generated in such sources .
lastly , we point out that the two fully contained shower events observed by icecube should be accompanied by tens of pev muon tracks and partially contained showers .
a more modest number of events unique to tau neutrinos should also be expected to appear .
thus as icecube s overall data set is further scrutinized , it should become increasingly possible to determine whether these two events are in fact cosmic in nature and , if so , to begin to constrain their origin .
m. g. aartsen , _ et al . _
[ icecube collaboration ] , arxiv:1304.5356 [ astro-ph.he ] .
e. roulet , g. sigl , a. van vliet and s. mollerach , arxiv:1209.4033 [ astro-ph.he ] . l. a. anchordoqui , h. goldberg , d. hooper , s. sarkar and a. m. taylor , phys .
d * 76 * , 123008 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv:0709.0734 [ astro - ph ] ] .
f. halzen and d. hooper , rept .
* 65 * , 1025 ( 2002 ) .
e. waxman and j. n. bahcall , phys .
d * 59 * , 023002 ( 1999 ) ; phys .
d * 64 * , 023002 ( 2001 ) .
h. yuksel , m. d. kistler , j. f. beacom and a. m. hopkins , astrophys . j. * 683 * , l5 ( 2008 ) . h. yuksel and m. d. kistler , phys .
d * 75 * , 083004 ( 2007 ) .
k. mannheim , r. j. protheroe and j. p. rachen , phys .
d * 63 * , 023003 ( 2001 ) ; arxiv : astro - ph/9908031 . l. a. anchordoqui , d. hooper , s. sarkar and a. m. taylor , astropart .
* 29 * , 1 ( 2008 ) [ astro - ph/0703001 ] .
j. abraham _ et al . _
[ pierre auger collaboration ] , phys .
lett . * 104 * , 091101 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1002.0699 [ astro-ph.he ] ] ; j. abraham _ et al .
_ [ pierre auger collaboration ] , arxiv:0906.2319 [ astro-ph.co ] .
d. hooper and a. m. taylor , astropart .
phys . * 33 * , 151 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0910.1842 [ astro-ph.he ] ] .
s. l. glashow , phys .
* 118 * , 316 ( 1960 ) r. gandhi , c. quigg , m. h. reno and i. sarcevic , phys .
d * 58 * , 093009 ( 1998 ) .
r. abbasi _ et al . _
[ icecube collaboration ] , phys .
d * 83 * , 012001 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1010.3980 [ astro-ph.he ] ] .
r. abbasi _ et al .
_ [ icecube collaboration ] , phys . rev .
d * 84 * , 082001 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1104.5187 [ astro-ph.he ] ]
. m. milgrom and v. usov , astrophys .
j. * 449 * , l37 ( 1995 ) ; e. waxman , phys .
lett . * 75 * , 386 ( 1995 ) ; m. vietri , phys .
lett . * 78 * , 4328 ( 1997 ) ; s. d. wick , c. d. dermer and a. atoyan , astropart . phys .
* 21 * , 125 ( 2004 ) .
e. waxman and j. n. bahcall , phys .
* 78 * , 2292 ( 1997 ) ; c. d. dermer and a. atoyan , phys . rev .
lett . *
91 * , 071102 ( 2003 ) .
d. guetta , d. hooper , j. alvarez - muniz , f. halzen and e. reuveni , astropart .
phys . * 20 * , 429 ( 2004 ) ; j. alvarez - muniz , f. halzen and d. w. hooper , phys .
d * 62 * , 093015 ( 2000 ) .
p. baerwald and m. bustamante and w. winter , jcap * 1210 * , 20 ( 2012 ) .
b. zhang , astrophys .
j. * 655 * , 989 ( 2007 ) ; j. l racusin , astrophys . j. * 738 * , 138 ( 2011 ) .
m. j. rees , p. meszaros , astrophys .
j. * 430 * , l93 ( 1994 ) .
w. s. paciesas _ et al .
_ , astrophys .
j. suppl .
* 199 * , 18 ( 2012 ) .
a. goldstein _ et al .
_ , astrophys .
j. suppl .
* 199 * , 19 ( 2012 ) .
f. w. zhang , l. shao , j. z. yan , d. m. wei , astrophys .
j. * 750 * , 88 ( 2012 ) .
e. liang , b. zhang and z. g. dai , astrophys .
j. * 662 * , 1111 ( 2007 ) .
h. lv , e. liang , b. zhang , b. zhang , astrophys . j. * 725 * , 1965 ( 2010 ) . n. gupta and b. zhang , astropart .
* 27 * , 386 ( 2007 ) .
k. murase , k. ioka , s. nagataki and t. nakamura , astrophys .
j. * 651 * , l5 ( 2006 ) .
d. m. coward , mon . not .
astron . soc .
* 360 * , l77 ( 2005 ) .
b. e. cobb and c. d. bailyn and p. g. van dokkum and p. natarajan , astrophys .
j. * 645 * , l113 ( 2006 ) .
e. pian _ et al .
_ , nature * 442 * , 1011 ( 2006 ) . f. daigne and r. mochkovitch , astron
. astrophys .
* 465 * ( 2007 ) .
o. bromberg and e. nakar and t. piran , astrophys .
j. * 739 * , l55 ( 2011 ) .
d. wanderman , t. piran , mon . not .
* 406 * , 1944 ( 2010 ) .
he _ et al .
_ , astrophys .
j. * 752 * , 29 ( 2012 ) . c. porciani and p. madau , astrophys .
j. * 548 * , 522 ( 2001 ) .
d. coward _ et al .
_ , mon . not .
soc . * 425 * , 1365 ( 2012 ) .
a. m. soderberg _ et al .
_ , nature * 442 * , 1014 ( 2006 ) .
a. m. soderberg , e. nakar and s. r. kulkarni , astrophys .
j. * 638 * , 930 ( 2006 ) .
a. cucchiara _ et al .
_ , astrophys .
j. * 736 * , 7 ( 2011 ) .
e. waxman and j. n. bahcall , phys .
d * 59 * , 023002 ( 1999 ) .
p. baerwald and s. hummer and w. winter , phys .
d * 83 * , 067303 ( 2011 ) .
r. abbasi
_ et al . _
[ icecube collaboration ] , nature * 484 * , 351 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1204.4219 [ astro-ph.he ] ] .
m. ahlers , m. c. gonzalez - garcia and f. halzen , astropart .
phys . * 35 * , 87 ( 2011 ) j. abraham _ et al . _
[ pierre auger collaboration ] , phys .
rev . lett . * 104 * , 091101 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1002.0699 [ astro-ph.he ] ] ; j. abraham _ et al .
_ [ pierre auger collaboration ] , arxiv:0906.2319 [ astro-ph.co ] ; m. unger [ pierre auger collaboration ] , arxiv:0706.1495 [ astro - ph ] .
a. atoyan and c. d. dermer , phys .
lett . * 87 * , 221102 ( 2001 ) ; k. mannheim , astron .
astrophys .
* 269 * , 67 ( 1993 ) ; k. mannheim , science * 279 * , 684 ( 1998 ) . k. mannheim , r. j. protheroe and j. p. rachen , phys . rev .
d * 63 * , 023003 ( 2001 ) [ astro - ph/9812398 ] , and references therein .
f. w. stecker , phys .
d * 72 * , 107301 ( 2005 ) [ astro - ph/0510537 ] ; f. w. stecker , c. done , m. h. salamon and p. sommers , phys . rev .
lett . * 66 * , 2697 ( 1991 ) [ erratum - ibid . *
69 * , 2738 ( 1992 ) ] .
a. loeb and e. waxman , jcap * 0605 * , 003 ( 2006 ) .
b. c. lacki , t. a. thompson , e. quataert , a. loeb and e. waxman , astrophys .
j. * 734 * , 107 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1003.3257 [ astro-ph.he ] ] . f. w. stecker , astropart .
* 26 * , 398 ( 2007 ) ; f. w. stecker , arxiv : astro - ph/0610208 ; t. a. thompson , e. quataert , e. waxman and a. loeb , astro - ph/0608699 .
d. de marco , t. stanev , todor and f. w. stecker , phys .
d * 73 * , 043003 ( 2006 ) .
m. ahlers , l. a. anchordoqui , m. c. gonzalez - garcia , f. halzen and s. sarkar , astropart .
phys . * 34 * , 106 ( 2010 ) .
u. keshet , e. waxman , a. loeb , v. springel and l. hernquist astrophys . j. * 585 * , 128 ( 2003 ) .
s. gabici , and p. blasi , astropart .
* 19 * , 679 ( 2003 ) .
k. murase and s. inoue and s. nagataki , astrophys .
j. * 689 * , l105 ( 2008 ) .
a. bhattacharya , r. gandhi , w. rodejohann and a. watanabe , jcap * 1110 * , 017 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1108.3163 [ astro-ph.he ] ] .
j. g. learned and s. pakvasa , astropart .
phys . * 3
* , 267 ( 1995 ) ; f. halzen and d. saltzberg , phys .
* 81 * , 4305 ( 1998 ) ; j. f. beacom , n. f. bell , d. hooper , s. pakvasa and t. j. weiler , phys . rev .
d * 68 * , 093005 ( 2003 ) [ erratum - ibid .
d * 72 * , 019901 ( 2005 ) ] . | the icecube collaboration has recently reported the observation of two events with energies in excess of 1 pev . while an atmospheric origin of these events can not be ruled out at this time
, this pair of showers may potentially represent the first observation of high - energy astrophysical neutrinos . in this paper
, we argue that if these events are neutrino - induced , then the neutrinos are very likely to have been produced via photo - meson interactions taking place in the same class of astrophysical objects that are responsible for the acceleration of the @xmath0@xmath1 ev cosmic ray spectrum . among the proposed sources of such cosmic rays , gamma - ray bursts stand out as particularly capable of generating pev neutrinos at the level implied by icecube s two events .
in contrast , the radiation fields in typical active galactic nuclei models are likely dominated by lower energy ( uv ) photons , and thus feature higher energy thresholds for pion production , leading to neutrino spectra which peak at eev rather than pev energies ( models with significant densities of x - ray emission , however , could evade this problem ) .
cosmogenic neutrinos generated from the propagation of ultra - high energy cosmic rays similarly peak at energies that are much higher than those of the events reported by icecube . |
quantum mechanics can not be described by local hidden - variable ( lhv ) theories .
this is the conclusion of bell s seminal work , in which he derived a strict limit to the strength of correlations achievable by all lhv models that is violated by quantum predictions @xcite .
bell s original inequality did not allow for imperfections and thus it was not accessible to experimental tests .
clauser , horne , shimony and holt ( chsh ) addressed this issue and developed the chsh inequality @xcite , which allowed for tests in actual experiments . since then a growing number of experiments have been reported ( for examples , see @xcite ) , and the overwhelming experimental evidence from these tests is in favour of quantum mechanics , ruling out lhv theories . it should be noted that , while no _ loophole - free _ bell test has been performed , the most significant potential loopholes , relating to detection efficiency and space - like separation of the choices of measurements settings , have both separately been closed @xcite .
both bell s inequality and the chsh inequality were formulated for testing the correlations between just two particles . for more than two particles , greenberger , horne and zeilinger ( ghz ) showed @xcite that a contradiction between lhv theories and quantum mechanics can be seen directly in perfect correlations , as opposed to statistically in imperfect ones . soon thereafter bell - type inequalities for more than two particles were developed @xcite .
quantum predictions can violate such inequalities by an amount increasing exponentially with the particle number @xcite .
all of the aforementioned inequalities are based on the assumption that local realism applies to each individual particle .
two - particle inequalities have been developed which are in conflict with quantum mechanics although they allow restricted , but physically motivated , nonlocal correlations @xcite .
these inequalities have recently been violated experimentally @xcite .
svetlichny showed that even if one allows unrestricted nonlocal correlations between any two of the constituent particles in a three - particle setting one can still find inequalities violated by quantum mechanical predictions @xcite .
the correlations allowed by svetlichny s model are strong enough to maximally violate three - partite inequalities , such as mermin s @xcite , which assume local realism for all particles involved .
a violation of such inequalities therefore can only rule out lhv theories , while a violation of svetlichny s inequality directly rules out a whole class of nonlocal hidden - variable theories @xcite .
svetlichny s work has since been generalized to the case of @xmath2 particles @xcite .
experimental tests have been performed confirming the violation of the mermin inequality @xcite , the mermin - ardehali - belinskii - klyshko ( mabk ) inequality @xcite , and the cluster state inequality developed by scarani et .
for an even number of particles only , a sufficiently large violation of the mabk inequality also rules out partially non - local hidden - variable models @xcite .
the violation of the mabk inequality in @xcite thus confirmed genuine four - particle entanglement and non - locality .
the original svetlichny inequality , however , remains untested .
here , we begin with a brief theoretical description of svetlichny s inequality .
we then experimentally produce high - fidelity three - photon ghz states and characterize them via quantum state tomography @xcite . using these states , modulo standard loopholes @xcite
, we experimentally demonstrate a convincing violation of svetlichny s inequality .
the two assumptions resulting in bell - type inequalities are locality and realism as they were introduced by einstein , podolsky and rosen @xcite .
we first review a straightforward method to derive the chsh inequality from these two assumptions following an argument described by peres @xcite .
pairs of particles are distributed to two distant parties , a and b. party a ( b ) can choose between two measurement settings @xmath3 and @xmath4 ( @xmath5 and @xmath6 ) . for each measurement setting ,
two outcomes , @xmath7 or @xmath8 , are possible .
realism assumes that the measurement outcomes are predetermined by some properties of the system investigated .
these properties are known as hidden variables because they are not necessarily accessible to observation .
the additional assumption of locality requires that the measurement outcomes on side a are independent of the measurement setting on side b , and vice versa .
thus for any given pair of particles the measurement outcomes have predetermined values @xmath9 and @xmath10 on side a and @xmath11 and @xmath12 on side b. these values identically satisfy the relations : @xmath13 if , for example , @xmath14 is averaged over many trials , the absolute value must be smaller than @xmath15 , which results in the chsh inequality @xcite : @xmath16 where the correlation , @xmath17 , is the ensemble average @xmath18 over the product of measurement outcomes @xmath19 and @xmath20 for measurement settings @xmath3 and @xmath5 , respectively .
this argument can be extended to three particles @xcite .
we will denote the particles as well as the measurement outcomes as @xmath19 , @xmath20 and @xmath21 , the measurement settings as @xmath3 , @xmath5 , @xmath22 .
the outcome of each measurement can be @xmath7 or @xmath8 .
if we assume local realism for each of the three particles , then for a given set of three particles the measurement outcomes @xmath19 , @xmath20 and @xmath21 as well as their primed counterparts will have predetermined values @xmath23 . using ( [ s2 ] ) we find that the following identity must hold : @xmath24 dividing this expression by two , and averaging over many trials yields mermin s inequality @xcite for three particles : @xmath25 where @xmath26 .
now assume that we allow arbitrary ( nonlocal ) correlations between just _ two _ of the particles , say @xmath19 and @xmath20 , while we still assume local realism with respect to the third particle , @xmath21 . in this case
we can not factorize @xmath14 as we did in ( [ s2 ] ) because outcomes for particle @xmath19 might nonlocally depend on the outcomes and/or measurement settings for particle @xmath20 .
however , we can still write @xmath27 where the parentheses are meant as a reminder that these quantities should be regarded as separate and independent quantities
. each of these quantities as well as @xmath21 and @xmath28 must take predetermined values @xmath23 because we assume local realism with respect to the third particle .
this model is strong enough to violate , and reach the algebraic maximum of mermin s inequality ( since @xmath29 can be @xmath30 ) .
thus no experimental violation of mermin s inequality can rule out this restricted nonlocal hidden - variable model . with this in mind
let us slightly modify our argument to derive svetlichny s inequality . because @xmath29 and @xmath31 are functions of the same four quantities , they are not independent .
for example , whenever one of the two quantities reaches its algebraic maximum @xmath30 , the other one will be @xmath32 . as a result
the following identity holds : @xmath33 averaging over many trials yields the svetlichny inequality : @xmath34 where we refer to @xmath35 as the svetlichny parameter .
it is remarkable that , although we started out by allowing nonlocal correlations between particles @xmath19 and @xmath20 while @xmath21 is local , one gets an expression identical to ( [ svetlichny ] ) if @xmath20 and @xmath21 are nonlocally correlated while @xmath19 is local , or if @xmath19 and @xmath21 are nonlocally correlated while @xmath20 is local .
every hidden - variable model that allows for nonlocal correlations between any two particles but not between all three can be seen as a probabilistic combination of models where the partition of the particles between nonlocal and local is made one or the other way .
all of these models fulfill the svetlichny inequality @xcite .
it was shown by svetlichny that his inequality can be violated by quantum predictions , and that the maximum violation can be achieved with ghz states .
assume we have a polarization - entangled ghz state @xmath36 , and let our measurement settings all be in the _ xy_-plane of the bloch sphere , i.e. we can write the corresponding states we project on as @xmath37 .
for example , the measurement settings @xmath3 and @xmath4 for particle @xmath19 correspond to projective measurements on the states @xmath38 and @xmath39 , respectively . here , the @xmath40 corresponds to the state the particle is projected on if the outcome of the measurement is @xmath23 . for particles @xmath20 and @xmath21 we choose an analogous notation .
then the quantum prediction for the left - hand side of ( [ svetlichny ] ) is @xmath41 with a suitable choice of angles , such as : @xmath42 this results in @xmath43 , which is the maximum violation of svetlichny s inequality achievable with quantum mechanics @xcite . since any hidden - variable model describing a three - particle state where only two particles are nonlocally correlated has to fulfill the svetlichny inequality
, its violation explicitly rules out this type of nonlocal hidden - variable theory .
our experiment uses a pulsed titanium : sapphire laser ( rep . rate 80mhz , @xmath44 avg .
power , @xmath45 nm center wavelength , @xmath46 nm fwhm bandwidth ) .
we frequency double the near - infrared beam , producing @xmath47mw average power near @xmath48 with a fwhm bandwidth of @xmath49 nm .
this upconverted beam is focused on a pair of orthogonally - oriented @xmath50-barium - borate ( bbo ) nonlinear crystals @xcite cut for type - i noncollinear degenerate spontaneous parametric down - conversion ( spdc ) with an external half opening angle of @xmath51 .
the pump polarization is set to @xmath52 such that each pump photon can produce a photon pair either in the first or the second bbo crystal . to compensate for temporal distinguishablity between the pairs created in the first and the second crystal the pump passes through a @xmath53 mm @xmath54-bbo crystal , a @xmath15 mm quartz crystal , and a @xmath55 mm quartz crystal , all cut for maximum birefringence . to compensate the @xmath56 m spatial walk - off between the horizontally and vertically polarized spdc photons observed in one of the output modes
, we insert a @xmath57 mm thick bibo crystal cut at @xmath58 and @xmath59 . for these cut angles
the crystal compensates the transverse walk - off without introducing additional time walk - off .
the photons are subsequently coupled into single - mode fibres .
we label the two corresponding spatial output modes as 1 and 2 , see figure 1(a ) .
fiber polarization controllers ensure that in mode 1 states in the hv basis remain unchanged while in mode 2 we flip the polarization , i.e. , @xmath60 . with this configuration
we achieve a two - photon coincidence rate of @xmath61 and single rates of about @xmath62 and @xmath63 for modes 1 and 2 , respectively .
the measured contrast of the pairs is @xmath64 in the h / v basis and @xmath65 in the @xmath66 basis when the source is adjusted to produce @xmath67 states . following the approach in @xcite we use the double - pair emission of the spdc source to produce 3-photon ghz correlations in the interferometer shown in figure 1(b ) .
a four - fold coincidence detection in the four outputs of the interferometer indicates the successful generation of the ghz state . to lowest significant order ,
a four - fold coincidence can only occur if two photons enter the interferometer via the spatial mode 1 , and their two partner photons enter it via mode 2 .
the two photons in input mode 1 impinge on a polarizing beam splitter ( pbs ) . in order for a four - fold coincidence event to occur
one of them must be h polarized and the other v polarized .
the v photon is reflected at the pbs .
its detection by detector @xmath68 serves as a trigger event .
the h photon passes through the pbs in mode 1 , and a @xmath69 plate oriented at @xmath70 rotates the polarization from @xmath71 to @xmath72 .
the two photons in mode 2 are split at the @xmath73 beam splitter ( bs ) with probability @xmath74 . only in this case
a four - fold coincidence can occur .
the transmitted photon and the @xmath72 polarized photon in mode 1 are overlapped on a pbs . a coincidence detection event in the two output modes of the pbs
can only occur if both photons are transmitted or both are reflected .
if these two possibilities are indistinguishable , hong - ou - mandel interference will occur @xcite . in the reflected mode of the bs
we compensate for a phase shift due to birefringence in the bs by tilting a @xmath75 plate .
a four - fold coincidence detection in the interferometer outputs can only occur if the trigger photon is @xmath76 polarized , and if the other three photons in the modes @xmath19 , @xmath20 and @xmath21 ( see figure 1(b ) ) are either @xmath77 or @xmath78 . by tilting a @xmath75 plate in output mode
@xmath19 we adjust the relative phase between these contributions such that a four - fold coincidence event signals a ghz state of the form @xmath79 . given this state ,
quantum mechanics predicts a maximum violation of svetlichny s inequality if we choose measurements of the form @xmath80 with the angles given in ( [ angles ] ) .
particles @xmath19 , @xmath20 and @xmath21 are identified with photons in the interferometer output modes @xmath19 , @xmath20 and @xmath21 , respectively . to test svetlichny s inequality each of the photons has to be measured in two measurement bases , and for each basis there are two possible outcomes , @xmath7 and @xmath8 . for each outcome
we have to set the polarization analyzer in the respective mode such that a photon detected after passing through the analyzer corresponds to that outcome .
the svetlichny parameter , @xmath35 ( see ( [ svetlichny ] ) ) , consists of @xmath81 correlations , each of which can be constructed from @xmath81 three - photon polarization measurements for a total of @xmath82 measurements .
each polarization analyzer consists of a @xmath69-plate followed by a @xmath75-plate and then a pbs .
the photons passing the pbss are detected with single - mode fibre - coupled single - photon counting modules ; the coincidence window is @xmath83 . in order to fully characterize the state produced by our setup we perform quantum state tomography . because all the measurement settings for the svetlichny inequality lie in the _ xy_-plane of the bloch sphere these alone are not tomographically complete . instead of performing an additional run apart from the measurements of the svetlichny settings , we add two additional projective measurements ( @xmath71 and @xmath84 ) for each of the particles , resulting in a total of @xmath85 three - photon polarization measurements .
our set of measurements is now actually tomographically overcomplete , which has been shown to produce better estimates of quantum states @xcite .
.[counts]experimentally - measured counts .
four - fold coincidences for the @xmath85 measurements performed for quantum state tomography . a subset of @xmath82 measured counts were used to test svetlichny s inequality ; these counts are shown in boldface type .
we cycled through all of the measurements @xmath86 times , counting for @xmath87 for each measurement .
the four - fold coincidences given are the result of integrating over all of these cycles . [
cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] in our setup the maximum four - fold coincidence rates of @xmath88 and @xmath89 were achieved for the correlations @xmath90 and @xmath91 , respectively .
to get statistically significant counts we integrated over @xmath92 per measurement . in order to reduce the negative effects of misalignment of the setup over time we realized this integration by counting for @xmath87 for each of the @xmath85 measurements , then repeating the full cycle of measurements @xmath86 times .
the resulting counts are given in table [ counts ] .
we applied the maximum likelihood technique @xcite to reconstruct the density matrix of our state .
its real and the imaginary part are shown in figure 2 .
the fidelity @xmath93 of the density matrix with the ghz state @xmath94 is @xmath95 .
the errors of quantities derived from the reconstructed density matrix were calculated via a monte carlo simulation , where we used each of the measured counts as the mean of a poissonian distribution . according to these distributions we generated random counts and ran the maximum likelihood algorithm .
this procedure was repeated @xmath96 times , and we report the standard deviation and mean for quantities derived from these reconstructed states .
the @xmath82 measurements that quantum mechanics predicts to violate svetlichny inequality are among the @xmath85 measured . after integrating over all @xmath86 cycles
we get a svetlichny parameter of @xmath97 ; the eight measured correlations are shown in figure 3 .
this value violates the svetlichny inequality by @xmath98 standard deviations .
it is , however , in good agreement with the value , @xmath99 , predicted by quantum mechanics given the reconstructed density matrix .
we used the double - pair emission from a pulsed type - i spdc source and projected the photons onto a ghz state using a linear optical interferometer .
we fully characterized the generated state and reconstructed the density matrix applying the maximum likelihood technique @xcite using an overcomplete set of measurements . from the reconstructed density matrix
, we found that our state matched the target ghz state with a fidelity of @xmath100 .
we experimentally demonstrated the violation of the original svetlichny inequality for a three - particle ghz state with a value of @xmath101 , which is greater than @xmath102 by @xmath98 standard deviations .
this value is in good agreement with that predicted by quantum mechanics from our reconstructed density matrix , @xmath103 . by violating svetlichny s long - standing inequality ,
we have shown that the correlations exhibited by three particles can not be described by hidden - variable theories with at most two - particle nonlocality .
we acknowledge financial support from nserc , oce , and cfi .
we thank @xmath104aslav brukner and philip walther for valuable discussions .
r.k . acknowledges financial support from iqc and ordcf . j.l . acknowledges financial support from the bell family fund .
klyshko d n 1993 _ phys .
a _ * 172 * 399 belinskii d n , and klyshko d n 1993 _ phys .
usp . _ * 36 * 653 ukowski m , and kaszlikowski d 1997 _ phys .
rev . a _ * 56 * r1682 gisin n , and bechmann - pasquinucci h 1998 _ phys
. lett . a _ * 246 * 1 cabello a 2002 _ phys .
a _ * 65 * 032108 seevinck m , and uffink j 2001 _ phys .
a _ * 65 * 012107 mitchell p , popescu s , and roberts d 2004 _ phys .
a _ * 70 * 060101(r ) tth g , ghne o , seevinck m , and uffink j 2005 _ phys . rev . a _ * 72 * 014101 ghose s , sinclair n , debnath s , rungta p , and stock r 2009 _ phys .
lett . _ * 102 * 250404 | it is well known that quantum mechanics is incompatible with local realistic theories .
svetlichny showed , through the development of a bell - like inequality , that quantum mechanics is also incompatible with a restricted class of _ nonlocal _ realistic theories for three particles where any two - body nonlocal correlations are allowed @xcite . in the present work ,
we experimentally generate three - photon ghz states to test svetlichny s inequality .
our states are fully characterized by quantum state tomography using an overcomplete set of measurements and have a fidelity of @xmath0 with the target state .
we measure a convincing , @xmath1 , violation of svetlichny s inequality and rule out this class of restricted nonlocal realistic models . |
the remarkable discovery by egret on - board _ cgro _ that blazars ( i.e. bl lacertae objects and flat - spectrum radio quasars ) are strong @xmath7-ray emitters has drawn in recent years the attention of the astronomical community to this class of objects .
observations indicate that the overall energy distribution of blazars shows the signature of two different types of emission mechanisms : beamed non - thermal jet radiation producing the overall broad band ( from radio to @xmath7-rays ) continuum emission common to all blazars , and quasi - isotropic thermal radiation by an accretion - disk producing a `` uv bump '' observed in a large number of quasars and seyfert galaxies but absent in bl lac objects ( e.g. sambruna , maraschi & urry , 1996 , elvis et al .
the non - thermal continuum consists of ir - optical and @xmath7-ray peaks .
the first peak is interpreted in terms of synchrotron emission and the second peak in terms of inverse compton emission ( see urry & padovani 1995 for a review on the subject ) . from object
to object , the observed different spectral characteristics may be due to the relative importance of one emission mechanism to the other which , in turn , is likely to be related to the amount of beaming in one object or the other ( e.g. dondi & ghisellini 1995 ) .
one of the most well - studied and characteristic example of blazars is the bright quasar 3c 273 ( [email protected] ) .
it is a good example where both non - thermal and thermal emission mechanisms might be observed because its broad band energy distribution exhibits two large peaks , one peaking in the ir - optical and one peaking in the @xmath7-rays with a ` uv bump' superimposed on it ( courvoisier et al .
1987 , lichti et al .
1995 , von montigny et al .
the study of its x - ray properties may provide important clues to understand the origin of both emission mechanisms because a ) soft - x - ray excess emission has been observed and interpreted as the high - energy tail of the uv bump ( turner et al .
1985 , courvoisier et al .
1987 , walter et al .
1994 , leach , mc hardy & papadakis 1995 ) and b ) the 2 - 10 kev spectrum which is most likely associated to the @xmath7-ray emission is known to be variable in time and shape ( turner et al .
1985 ) , thus allowing for tests of different x- and @xmath7-ray emission models . to clarify the mechanism responsible for the x - ray emission , high quality data are first necessary to disentangle the contributions from the different spectral components , namely the jet and seyfert components . in this paper
, we report on observations with _ asca _ during the first year of the mission .
the source spectral properties are shown with particular attention to calibration uncertainties , most relevant in this source because it was used for on - board calibration of the ccds .
we show evidence of complex spectral features ( soft - excess , fe k emission line , flux and spectral correlated variability ) and discuss their possible interpretation . throughout the analysis we use @xmath9 = 50 km
s@xmath10 mpc@xmath10 and @xmath11 = 0 .
over the period from 1993 june to 1993 december , 3c 273 was observed 9 times with the gas imaging spectrometer ( gis ) and solid - state spectrometer ( sis ) on - board the _ asca _ satellite ( tanaka , inoue & holt 1994 ) . the observation log is given in table 1 .
the sis was operating in 1 ccd faint mode during all the observations .
observations 2 , 3 , 5 and 6 have been used to calibrate each chip of the sis ( dotani et al .
1996 ) and the remaining pointings are part of a multi - wavelength campaign on 3c 273 ( von montigny et al . , 1997 ) .
dark frame error ( dfe ) and echo corrections ( otani & dotani 1994 ) have been applied to all the data . after removing hot and flickering pixels , standard selection criteria
were used to select good observational intervals .
the most relevant were an elevation and bright earth angles greater than 5@xmath12 and 25@xmath12 respectively , and a magnetic cutoff rigidity greater than 8 gev / c for sis and 7 gev / c for gis .
for all observations , source counts were extracted using circular region centered on the source of radius 6@xmath13 for the gis and 3@xmath13 for the sis .
hard x - ray emission was detected with _ sigma _ from a location about 15@xmath13 away from 3c 273 ( at r.a.[1950]=12@xmath1427@xmath1520@xmath16 , dec[1950]=02@xmath1730@xmath18 with an associated error of @xmath0 5@xmath18 ) ( jourdain et al .
we find no trace of such source in the _ asca _ field of views .
background spectra were obtained from the edges of the chips in the sis and from the blank sky files in the gis .
the gis background region was always chosen in regions uncontaminated by ngc 6552 and at similar off - axis distance as the source region ( see appendix a of cappi et al .
1997 for a detailed discussion ) .
owing to the high count - rate of this bright source and the fact that the background typically contributed less than a few percent to the average count - rates in each observations , different choices of backgrounds ( e.g. blank sky backgrounds for sis or local backgrounds for gis ) did not introduce significant differences in the spectral results reported below . in total , _ asca _ collected about half a million counts per detector for an effective exposure time of @xmath0 160 ks for gis and @xmath0 130 ks for sis .
data preparation and spectral analysis have been done using version 1.2 of the xselect package and version 9.0 of the xspec program ( arnaud et al 1991 ) .
official ea / psf - v1.0 files , gis[23]v4_0.rmf and rsp1.1alphapi1.6 matrices ( released in 1994 ) were used for all the observations reported in the following .
newer xrt calibration files ( ea / psf - v2.0 ) and related gis and sis responses were also used in 3.4 for the study of the iron line emission .
gis2/3 and sis0/1 pulse - height spectra were binned so as to have at least 200 counts per bin , in the energy ranges 0.7 - 10 kev and 0.4 - 10 kev , respectively .
light curves were accumulated for all observing periods , but none of these indicated significant variability ( although variations as high as @xmath0 10 - 20% per observation period can not be excluded ) .
all photons were , thus , accumulated observation - by - observation for the spectral analysis .
it is emphasized that 3c 273 was used to calibrate the sis response function imposing consistency with the gis results ( gis was assumed to be well calibrated by fitting the crab data with a single absorbed power law model ; see dotani et al .
1996 for details ) .
therefore , great care must be taken when interpreting the sis results since systematic effects could be present . as a rule , _ absolute _ values obtained from the sis ( only )
could not , in principle , be trusted .
however , _ relative _ measurements ( like flux and/or spectral variability ) obtained from comparing different observations are likely to give valuable information since , in this case , systematic effects should cancel each other .
moreover , all the observations were taken during the first year of the mission , and the last 8 observations were performed within a period of 12 days .
thus , we assumed that the instrument did not change significantly from one observation to the other .
first , gis and sis data were fitted separately with a single absorbed power law model , with the column density , @xmath19 , free to vary . throughout the analysis , the column density is calculated in the observer frame ( i.e. z=0 ) .
this model gives an acceptable description of all the spectra .
the best - fitting model results are given in table 2 .
it is emphasized that the 2 - 10 kev flux measurements ( column 4 in table 2 ) do not vary significantly even if @xmath19 is fixed at the galactic value ( 3.3 ) or if an iron emission line is added to the model ( 3.4 ) .
figure 1 clearly shows that the flux varied in time by up to @xmath0 60% on a time - scale of @xmath0 200 days .
significant ( 2030% ) shorter - term variations on a time - scale of @xmath0 1 day are also evident in the light - curve .
the luminosity varied , accordingly , from l@xmath20 @xmath0 1.4 @xmath1 10@xmath21 erg s@xmath10 in observation 1 to a l@xmath20 @xmath0 2.1 @xmath1 10@xmath21 erg s@xmath10 in observation 9 .
note that the photon indices obtained from the gis and sis are in excellent agreement , while there are slight , but significant , discrepancies in the measurement of the low energy absorption column .
this effect will be considered in more detail in the following section .
the 210 kev flux measured with the sis is also systematically @xmath0 1520% higher than that obtained from the gis .
the discrepancy is currently attributed to cross calibration uncertainties that have been largely reduced to less than 10% with the introduction of new ( ea / psf - v2.0 ) xrt calibration files . with the matrices used in the present analysis ,
the sis flux can be considered to be the most reliable with an absolute uncertainty of less than @xmath0 10% ( k. arnaud et al .
, _ asca _ calibration uncertainties , http:@xmath22heasarc.gsfc.nasa.gov@xmath23docs@xmath23asca@[email protected] ) .
the absolute value and long time - scale variations of the 2 - 10 kev flux of 3c 273 are roughly consistent with previous observations with _
exosat _ and _ ginga _ satellites ( turner et al . 1990 ) .
however , the better quality and temporal sampling of the present observations also reveal for the first time day - to - day variations of the 210 kev x - ray flux as large as @xmath0 20% .
90% confidence contours for the column densities versus photon indices obtained from the sis spectra with the above absorbed power law model ( table 2 ) are shown in fig .
the vertical lines represent the galactic absorption ( full line ) and associated estimated errors ( dotted lines ) as obtained from measurements at 21 cm ( dickey & lockman 1990 ) .
2 clearly illustrates three interesting results : ( 1 ) the best - fit column density was significantly lower than the galactic value during the first observation .
this result can be promptly interpreted as evidence for a soft - excess in the data ; ( 2 ) in all other observations , absorption was significantly , and systematically , higher than the galactic value ; ( 3 ) small , but significant , variations in the photon index are measured from observation to observation .
note that , though the gis is less sensitive than the sis at low energies , the soft - excess is also detected in the gis data .
indeed , the gis spectrum gives an upper limit for @xmath19 of @xmath0 0.65 @xmath1 10@xmath2 @xmath3 during the first observation ( significantly lower than @xmath25 @xmath0 1.79 @xmath1 10@xmath2 @xmath3 ) while all other observations give @xmath19 values consistent with the galactic absorption .
although this measurement is in agreement with that reported by yaqoob et al .
( 1994 ) , these authors did not report the detection of a soft - excess for this observation probably because , in their work , sis spectra were consistent with the galactic absorption .
this discrepancy is likely to be attributed to the fact that yaqoob et al .
( 1994 ) used older response matrices obtained from the preliminary calibrations of the gis and sis instruments .
the evidence for a soft - excess during observation 1 is further strengthened by the ratio of the pulse height spectra of observation 1 divided by observation 9 of the summed sis0 and sis1 spectra ( upper panel ) and the summed gis2 and gis3 spectra ( lower panel ) shown in fig .
similar results were obtained dividing observation 1 with the other observations , thus excluding the possibility that the steepening of the ratios below about 2 kev could be due to a slight increase of the absorption measured during observation 9 .
since pulse height spectral ratios directly compare the raw count - rates from two datasets , problems related to the calibration uncertainties of the instrumental response are in principle removed .
these further confirm the presence of a continuum soft - excess emission at energies below @xmath0 1.5 kev . in order to parameterize the measured soft - excess
, two - component emission models were fitted to the gis and sis data of observation 1 with the absorption fixed at the galactic value .
normalizations from the two detectors were free to vary independently
. results from the model - fittings are given in table 3 .
attempts to model the soft - excess with a raymond & smith ( 1977 ) plasma model and a warm absorber model , as proposed in previous work , are not reported here since both models gave poor fits to the data , consistent with the absence of any blend of emission lines around 0.80.9 kev ( quasar frame ) or absorption features around 0.71.0 kev ( quasar frame ) .
acceptable fits ( table 3 ) were obtained from either a black - body ( with kt @xmath0 100 ev ) plus power law model , a bremsstrahlung ( with kt @xmath0 240 ev ) plus power law model or a double power law model ( with @xmath26 3 ) .
it is interesting to note that the improvement in @xmath27 obtained with a double power law model is statistically significant when compared to the black - body ( @xmath28 ) or bremsstrahlung ( @xmath29 ) models at @xmath0 99.8% and @xmath0 96% confidence levels , respectively .
this is similar to the findings of leach et al .
( 1995 ) obtained from high quality _ rosat _ pspc data and confirm that the soft - excess is better modeled by a power law than by a thermal emission model .
this issue will be further addressed in 4.2 .
moreover , it is likely that this soft - excess is intrinsically variable with time ( in shape or in intensity ) because our simulations indicate that , if constant , it should have been detected at least during observation 7 , when the source was only @xmath0 15% brighter than in observation 1 .
the following 4 calibration observations and 4 ao - i observations are , instead , all consistent with a constant absorption column of @xmath0 34 @xmath1 10@xmath2 @xmath3 .
this value is significantly higher than the galactic absorption by @xmath0 2 - 3 @xmath1 10@xmath2 @xmath3 .
however , a physical interpretation of this result can not be made because the sis responses were calibrated from some of these observations ( table 1 ) assuming that 3c 273 was absorbed by the galactic column only . instead
, this column should , by definition , be taken as a systematic error of the _ asca _ sis response function for a standard analysis like the one presented in this work .
similar results have been reported from independent work on 3c 273 ( hayashida et al . 1995 ) and the coma cluster ( dotani et al .
1996 ; hashimotodani , private communication ) .
figure 2 also suggests small but significant variations of the power law photon index , at least from observation 2 to observation 9 .
however , because of the presence of the soft - excess and extra - absorption mentioned above , these variations may be due to an incorrect modeling of the low energy absorption .
to avoid such complications , only the data above 2 kev were considered .
since the photon indices obtained by separately fitting the gis and sis data were all consistent at @xmath0 90% confidence level , the data from the two instruments were fitted simultaneously tying the fitting parameters together but allowing the relative normalizations to be free .
a single power law model plus absorption fixed at the galactic value was used in all fits .
it is pointed out that since the sis best - fit spectra normally require a value of @xmath19 systematically higher than the galactic value when fitted between @xmath0 0.410 kev ( see 3.2 ) , by fixing the absorption at the galactic value , a systematic error will be introduced on the _ absolute _ value of the sis photon indices .
however , this ( small ) effect will not affect the measurements of _ relative _ values presented below .
gis results are not affected by these uncertainties .
best - fitting results are given in table 4 .
the variations of the 210 kev photon indices with the observed 210 kev fluxes are shown in fig . 4 for the ( a ) gis+sis data ( all observations ) and ( b ) gis+sis data , excluding calibration observations n. 2 , 3 and 5 .
the reason we ignored observations 2 , 3 and 5 in the dataset ( b ) is that these were performed using chips 0 , 2 and 3 of sis0 and chips 0 , 1 , 2 of sis1 in which the gain ( relative to the standard chip n.1 of sis0 and chip n. 3 of sis1 ) are uncertain by as much as @xmath0 2% ( dotani et al .
this could introduce systematic errors in the spectral slope of as much as @xmath0 0.05 which are much larger than our statistical errors and could , therefore , distort any significant statistical correlation .
figure 4 shows evidence for a spectral index change in 3c 273 . though the variations are not large ( @xmath30 0.1 ) , they are significant in both datasets ( table 5 ) .
this point is further illustrated in figure 3 which shows that , though the data are somewhat noisy above @xmath0 8 kev , the pulse height spectrum between 2 - 10 kev of observation 1 is steeper than that of observation 9 , for both the gis and sis data .
table 5 shows the results from @xmath27-tests against constancy , linear correlation coefficients and rank correlation coefficients for the two datasets considered .
the most interesting result obtained from this analysis is that there is a trend ( most noticeable in fig .
4 ) for the 210 kev photon index to be anti - correlated with the flux , i.e. a spectral flattening as the source brightens .
this result is significant at a @xmath0 99.95% and @xmath0 81% confidence level for the dataset ( a ) and at a @xmath0 99.999% and @xmath0 89% confidence level for dataset ( b ) , for a linear and non - parametric correlation respectively ( table 5 ) .
it is emphasized that the same trend was observed also in both sis and gis instruments taken individually , though with somewhat lower significance .
however , it should be noted that the significance of this result depends mostly on the 2 data points from observations 1 and 9 . if real , this behavior is opposite to that commonly seen in seyfert galaxies ( e.g. mushotzky , done & pounds 1993 and references therein ) and , on the contrary , provides an interesting analogy with bl lac objects as discussed in 4 .
the spectra have been inspected for the presence of an iron emission line .
our first analysis clearly reveals the presence of a broad ( @xmath4 0.4 kev ) fe k line with ew @xmath0 90100 ev during observations 1 and 7 ( table 6 ) .
confidence contours in the fe k parameters space @xmath31e and ew e ( observer frame ) obtained from fitting the observation 1 data are shown in fig . 5 as an example . a narrow line is also significant in 4 out of 7 of the remaining observations .
the emission lines are all consistent with a neutral or mildly ionized iron emission line ( at 6.4 kev in the quasar s frame ) at @xmath0 90% confidence level .
we find no significant correlation between the equivalent width of the fe k line and the computed x - ray flux but it is interesting that the 2 strongest lines are detected while 3c 273 was in its lowest states ( i.e. observations 1 and 7 reported in table 6 ) .
however , as is evident from the dashed contours shown in fig . 5 , the gis spectra of the crab which were used to calibrate the gis exhibit a miscalibration at similar energies which can be modeled with a broad ( @xmath32 0.4 @xmath33 0.05 kev ) line at e @xmath8 5.7 @xmath33 0.05 kev with an ew @xmath8 50 @xmath33 15 ev ( see also ebisawa et al .
1996 for more details about this miscalibration in the crab s gis spectra ) .
new calibration matrices ( ascaarf v2.62 with version 2.0 of the xrt matrices ) have , however , recently been distributed to the _ asca _ guest observers through the _ asca _ goddard guest observer facility ( k. ebisawa , http:@xmath22heasarc.gsfc.nasa.gov@xmath23docs@xmath23asca@xmath34xrt@xmath24new@xmath24response@[email protected] ) .
the new calibrations reduce the systematic differences in flux between gis and sis ( see 3.1 ) and corrects the gis and sis response matrices for the @xmath0 56 kev spectral feature detected in the crab spectra ( fukazawa , ishida & ebisawa 1997 , but see also gendreau & yaqoob 1997 ) .
it is emphasized that the use of this improved calibration does not affect our conclusions on flux variability , soft - excess and spectral variability because , as stated in 3 , only relative measurements have been considered .
it gives , however , significantly different results on the iron emission line measurements .
now , spectral fitting yields narrow ( @xmath31 @xmath35 0.21 kev and @xmath35 0.6 kev ) and weaker , ew ( @xmath0 25 ev and 27 ev , observer frame ) lines during observations 1 and 7 , respectively ( see table 7 ) .
the line is also reduced in all other observations yielding only upper limits ranging between @xmath0 1030 ev .
analysis with the latest available calibration suggests , therefore , that the line detected during observations 1 and 7 is very likely to be real but that , contrary to our first results with previous calibration , it is consistent with being narrow and with having an ew @xmath0 20 - 30 ev ( observer frame ) . in the quasar s frame ,
the fe k line best - fit parameters are [email protected]@xmath36 kev , 6.31@xmath37 kev and ew@xmath829@xmath38 ev , 31@xmath39 ev for observations 1 and 7 , respectively .
these results agree with the emission of a fluorescent narrow fe k@xmath5 line from neutral matter ( makishima 1986 ) .
the _ asca _ observations have shown that the 2 - 10 kev flux is variable with time by up to @xmath0 60% on a time - scale of @xmath0 200 days and shows day - to - day variations as large as @xmath0 20% . thus ,
unless it is relativistically beamed , the hard x - ray source must be smaller than r = c @xmath1 @xmath40 t @xmath0 10@xmath41 cm where the source doubling time - scale , i.e. the time necessary for the source to vary by a factor of two , can roughly be estimated as @xmath40 t @xmath0 @xmath42@xmath1@xmath43 , where z is the source redshift .
it is well known that 3c 273 shows a one - sided jet which is clearly observed at both radio and optical wavelengths ( bahcall et al . 1995 and references therein ) which is most likely produced by synchrotron emission from relativistic electrons ( 3c 273 exhibits superluminal motion with @xmath44 8.0 @xmath33 1.0 , e.g. vermeulen & cohen 1994 ) .
the main jet consists of a number of bright , elongated , knots extending from @xmath0 30 kpc to @xmath0 50 kpc from the quasar with kpc - scale transverse dimensions in both the radio and optical images .
therefore , the dimensions of the radio - optical jet are about 6 orders of magnitude larger than the x - ray source dimension .
this , together with the high x - ray luminosity of @xmath0 1.5 - 2 @xmath1 10@xmath21 erg s@xmath10 inferred from the x - ray data , excludes the possibility that the bulk of the x - ray emission is produced by the jet s knots only ( whatever the emission mechanism is ) .
therefore , if it is related to the jet , the 2 - 10 kev x - ray emitting region must be located in the innermost regions of the jet .
these conclusions are consistent with high resolution x - ray imaging ( e.g. _ rosat _ hri ) of the jet emission of 3c 273 ( rser et al
. 1996 ) .
for the first time in this source , we find evidence for a statistically significant anti - correlation between the 2 - 10 kev flux and spectral index , implying hardening of the spectrum as the source brightens .
this is opposite to lower luminosity agns ( e.g. seyfert 1 galaxies ) which often show a positive correlation ( grandi et al .
1992 , mushotzky , done & pounds 1993 , and references therein ) but similar to the anti - correlation flux - spectral index often observed in bl lacertae objects ( at least in x - ray selected bl lac objects ; e.g. giommi et al . 1990 , urry et al . 1996 ) .
this suggests that the bulk of the x - ray emission in 3c 273 is produced by a mechanism similar to the one supposed in bl lac objects , i.e. a process related to the existence of a beam of relativistic particles ( e.g. fichtel 1995 ) .
this is consistent with the recent results of von montigny et al .
( 1997 ) which show that the multi - wavelength spectrum ( from radio to @xmath7-rays ) of 3c 273 can be explained by any of the most prominent theoretical models ( e.g. synchrotron self - compton ( ssc , maraschi , ghisellini & celotti 1992 ) , inverse compton on external photons from an accretion disk or a broad - line region ( ec , sikora , begelman & rees 1994 ) or synchrotron from ultra - relativistic electrons and positrons in a proton - induced cascade ( mannheim & biermann 1992 ) ) for the explanation of the high @xmath7-ray emission of bl lac objects . on the basis of the present _ asca _ data , it is not possible , however , to distinguish between the different theoretical models since all of these could explain the observed spectral variability .
synchrotron losses , for example , have often been invoked to explain a steepening with decreasing flux ( e.g. in pks 2155 - 304 , sembay et al . 1993 ; in h0323 + 022 , kohmura et al .
1994 ; in mkn 421 , takahashi et al .
1996 ) . in these cases ,
the x - ray spectra were interpreted as the high energy tail of synchrotron emission , while the x - ray spectrum of 3c 273 is more likely due to compton emission ( von montigny et al .
however , one could expect that a similar behavior may hold also in the `` compton '' bump , though perhaps at a different time - scale because of a possibly different emission region .
moreover , hysteresis `` clockwise '' flux - index relations were reported in these bl lac objects .
further observations are clearly necessary to test this hypothesis in 3c 273 .
alternatively , there might be a mixture of , say , ssc and ec contributing to the x - ray emission , the spectrum being harder when the ec flux increases . or else , as discussed next , there might be a contribution from a seyfert - like spectrum with a steeper spectral slope , e.g. @xmath6 @xmath0 1.7 as commonly seen in seyfert galaxies ( mushotzky , done & pounds 1993 ) , which steepens the spectrum as the source becomes fainter .
a small contribution of @xmath010 - 20% in the 2 - 10 kev band could steepen the observed spectrum by @xmath45 @xmath0 0.1 thus explain the flux - index anti - correlation .
another interesting result from our analysis is that the spectra intermittently show clear evidence for a separate soft component below @xmath0 2 kev .
this component was observed only during the first observation , when the source was faintest .
the best fit values for this component ( see 3.2 ) are in good agreement with previous _ exosat _ , _
einstein_,_ginga _ and _ rosat _ findings ( e.g. courvoisier et al .
1987 , wilkes & elvis 1987 , turner et al .
1990 , staubert 1992 , leach et al .
1995 ) , in particular if one allows for cross - calibration uncertainties and considers that previous observations usually found , or fixed , the photon index between 2 - 10 kev at a slightly flatter value of @xmath46 1.5 than found with _
asca_. the issue of interpreting the soft continuum can not , however , be addressed in more detail with the present _ asca _ data since , as explained in @xmath47 , absolute values obtained from the sis can not in principle be trusted because 3c 273 was used to calibrate the sis response ( see dotani et al .
1996 for details on the calibration procedure ) .
for example , because of the systematic excess absorption found in 3.2 which is most likely attributed to a calibration uncertainty , we can not trust absolute values of the best - fit parameters for the soft - excess .
only relative measurements can be considered , which tell us that a soft excess component is indeed required by the data during observation 1 and not during the following observations .
it should be pointed out , however , that as found by leach et al .
( 1995 ) from the _ rosat _ pspc data , the soft component is modeled better by a single power law with absorption at the galactic value ( @xmath48 = 10 and 5 compared to the black - body and bremsstrahlung models , respectively ) .
this may indicate that the data are not well described by a model with a concave shape but rather prefer a straight or convex model . at this point , it is interesting to note that a recent _ beppo - sax _ observation of 3c 273 performed in july 1996 , when the source was at very low flux level ( @xmath0 7.1 @xmath1 10@xmath49 erg @xmath3 s@xmath10 ) , shows evidence for both a soft excess emission ( below @xmath0 0.3 kev ) and a strong absorption structure at @xmath0 0.5 kev indicating , possibly , the presence of a warm absorber in 3c 273 ( grandi et al .
_ asca _ observed 3c 273 simultaneously with _
beppo - sax _ on that occasion .
results of this observation will be presented elsewhere ( yaqoob et al . , in preparation ) . fitting the _ asca _
observation 1 with a warm absorber model only does not however improve the spectral fitting significantly since , clearly , the data require some extra emission below @xmath0 2 kev that can not be explained with absorption features alone .
addition of an absorption edge at @xmath0 0.5 kev to the double power model increases the quality of the fit slightly but not significantly .
the _ asca _ spectra also reveal evidence for iron line emission in 3c 273 on two different occasions , during observations 1 and 7 , when the source was faintest .
the best - fit parameters of the fe k line obtained from the fitting of the sis data only with the latest available response matrices are consistent with the line being narrow and weak ( ew @xmath0 20 - 30 ev in both observations 1 and 7 ) .
these values are in reasonable agreement with the _ ginga _ results of turner et al .
( 1990 ) and the _ beppo - sax _ results of grandi et al .
( 1997 ) , who both found a significant iron line in 3c 273 when the source was in a low ( f@xmath20 @xmath50 1 @xmath1 10@xmath51 erg @xmath3 s@xmath10 ) state , similar to the results reported here .
the line emission and , also the soft excess emission suggest that , at least during observations 1 and 7 , a seyfert - like component underlying a dominant simple power - law ( jet ? ) component contributes significantly to the x - ray spectrum of 3c 273 . in order to give a rough quantitative estimate of the contribution from the seyfert and to test this overall picture
, we tried to fit the broad - band ( @xmath00.4300 kev ) _ asca _ plus _ osse _ spectrum with a model consisting in the sum of : a power - law with @xmath6 @xmath8 1.5 - 1.6 , a `` typical '' seyfert - like spectrum ( nandra & pounds 1994 ) , i.e. a power - law ( with @xmath6=1.9 ) plus a reflection component ( with r=@xmath52=1 corresponding to a 2@xmath53 coverage of the reflector ) and associated iron line ( with an equivalent width fixed at 150 ev , with respect to the seyfert continuum , e.g. george & fabian 1991 ) , and a black - body .
the _ asca _
spectra are from observation 1 and the _ osse _ spectrum is from the observation performed during 1991 june 15 - 28 ( viewing period n.3 reported in johnson et al . 1995 ) . as demonstrated by the unfolded spectrum and residuals shown in fig .
6 , an acceptable fit is obtained with a black - body temperature of kt @xmath0 100 ev , slightly reduced compared to the results given in table 3 because of the seyfert power law contribution , and with the seyfert - like spectrum contributing about 30% at 1 kev and about 10 - 20% in the 2 - 10 kev energy band to the total spectrum .
however , it is stressed that while the present data are consistent with this picture , there is actually no direct evidence for a steep `` seyfert - like '' power - law , since its contribution can not be unambiguously disentangled from the softer black - body component .
however , we have also shown in 3.2 that the soft - excess emission is likely to be variable in time and , as discussed above , is better fitted with a model with a convex shape rather than a concave one .
these may be the indication that some direct , steep , seyfert - like component contributes partly to the soft - excess emission of 3c 273 .
an alternative explanation for the fe k line emission may be reflection off optically thick matter ( e.g. broad - line region blobs and/or a molecular torus and/or an accretion disk , located near the jet region ) from the jet continuum itself . in such case , the estimation of the expected iron line intensity is complicated by the possibility that the x - ray and hard x - ray radiation could be beamed in the direction of , or away from , the reflecting matter and its precise evaluation is beyond the scope of this paper . the effect of the unknown effective covering factor of the reflector should also be taken into account .
to date , _ asca _ has observed 3c 273 10 times . results from the first 9 observations ,
all performed during the first year of the mission have been presented here .
these confirm and expand the evidence that the x - ray emission of 3c 273 is complex , with different spectral components contributing to its x - ray emission . because 4 of the 9 observations were used for the on - board calibration of the ccds , great care had to be taken when interpreting the observational results for this source . as a rule , _ absolute _ values , in particular those obtained from the sis , require a detailed estimate and knowledge of the instrumental systematic errors to be trusted .
_ relative _ measurements ( like flux and/or spectral variability ) obtained from comparing different observations are , however , more reliable since they should not be affected by calibration uncertainties . with this caveat in mind
, it is found that : 1 .
a conservative systematic error at low energies that corresponds to an extra - absorption column of @xmath0 23 @xmath1 10@xmath2 @xmath3 is found for the sis response , consistent with the asca team s official prescriptions .
210 kev flux variations by up to @xmath0 60% on a time - scale of @xmath0 200 days and day - to - day variations as large as @xmath0 20% were observed .
extra soft x - ray emission is required by the data during the first observation , when the source was in its lowest flux level .
flux and spectral slope variations are clearly detected as well and , for the first time , there is a statistically significant evidence that the index and flux are anti - correlated .
iron line emission is detected in ( only ) the two observations with the lowest flux levels .
the line is in both cases weak ( ew@xmath020 - 30 ev ) , but statistically significant at more than 99% confidence level , narrow and consistent with fe k@xmath5 emission from neutral matter .
we then speculate that all the above observable properties of the x - ray spectrum of 3c 273 can be interpreted in terms of the sum of two emission mechanisms .
these are a non - thermal emission from the innermost regions of the jet which dominates the 2 - 10 kev region and whose signatures are the spectral variability and a flat ( @xmath54 ) power law continuum ( that extrapolates well into higher energies ) , plus a diluted seyfert - like spectrum whose signatures are the soft - excess and iron line emission . the newly discovered index - flux anti - correlation may be interpreted either by intrinsic variations of the jet power law index or by some contribution of the seyfert - like continuum spectrum ( say , a power law with @xmath55 ) as the jet component varies .
the overall scenario predicts that when the ( dominant ) jet component is in a low flux state , the spectral features produced by the seyfert - like spectrum should be more easily detected ( owing for variability of the seyfert - like spectrum itself ) .
we are grateful to the _ asca _ team in isas for their operation of the satellite and to the _ asca _ gof at nasa / gsfc for their assistance in data analysis .
m.c . acknowledges colleagues in the institute of physical and chemical research ( riken ) for their warm hospitality and the italian space agency ( asi ) for financial support
. c.o . acknowledges the special postdoctoral researchers program of riken for support .
kml gratefully acknowledges support through nag5 - 3307 ( _ asca _ ) .
we thank t. yaqoob , t. dotani , k. gendreau and t. kotani for very helpful discussion on the calibration - related issues and h. kubo and g. ghisellini for usefull comments .
@xmath56 @xmath27 value and corresponding probability ( p ) for a @xmath27 test against constancy .
@xmath57 linear correlation coefficient ( r ) and corresponding probability ( p ) for a linear correlation of the data .
@xmath58 spearman rank - order coefficient ( r@xmath59 ) and corresponding probability ( p ) for a non - parametric correlation of the data .
@xmath60 gis plus sis data excludind observations 2 , 3 and 5 which were used to calibrate the `` non - standard '' sis chips .
cccccc & & & & & + & & & & & + + obs . 1 & 1.63@xmath61 & 5.59@xmath62&0 ( fixed)&40@xmath63&1.44/454 + & 1.63@xmath61 & 5.67@xmath64&0.43@xmath65&100@xmath66&1.43/453 + obs . 7 & 1.57@xmath67 & 5.46@xmath62&0 ( fixed)&38@xmath68&1.21/372 + & 1.57@xmath67 & 5.44@xmath69&0.28@xmath70&81@xmath71&1.20/371 + + obs . 1 & 1.56@xmath61 & 5.59@xmath72&0 ( fixed)&25@xmath73&1.26/454 + & 1.56@xmath61 & 5.59@xmath74 & @xmath35 0.21&27@xmath75&1.26/453 + obs
7 & 1.52@xmath76 & 5.45@xmath77&0 ( fixed)&27@xmath78&1.23/372 + & 1.52@xmath62 & 5.45@xmath79&@xmath35 0.59 & 34@xmath80&1.23/371 + @xmath81 the continuum emission was fitted between 2 - 10 kev with a single absorbed power law with @xmath19=@xmath25=1.79 @xmath1 10@xmath2 @xmath3 .
note : intervals are at 90 % confidence for 1 interesting parameter ( @xmath82=2.71 ) . | results obtained from 9 x - ray observations of 3c 273 performed by _ asca _ are presented ( for a total exposure time of about 160 000 s ) .
the analysis and interpretation of the results is complicated by the fact that 4 of these observations were used for on - board calibration of the ccds spectral response . in particular , we had to pay special attention to the low energy band and 56 kev energy range where systematic effects could distort a correct interpretation of the data .
the present standard analysis shows that , in agreement with official recommendations , a conservative systematic error ( at low energies ) of @xmath0 23 @xmath1 10@xmath2 @xmath3 must be assumed when analyzing _ asca _ sis data .
a soft - excess , with variable flux and/or shape , has been clearly detected as well as flux and spectral variability that confirm previous findings with other observatories .
an anti - correlation is found between the spectral index and the flux in the 2 - 10 kev energy range . with the old response
matrices , an iron emission line feature with ew @xmath0 50100 ev was initially detected at @xmath0 5.6 - 5.7 kev ( @xmath0 6.5 - 6.6 kev in the quasar frame ) in 6 observations and , in two occasions , the line was resolved ( @xmath4 0.2 - 0.6 kev ) .
comparison with the crab spectrum indicates however that this feature was mostly due to remaining calibration uncertainties between 56 kev .
indeed , fitting the data with the latest publicly available calibration matrices , we find that the line remains unambiguously significant in ( only ) the two observations with lowest fluxes where it is weak ( ew @xmath0 20 - 30 ev ) , narrow and consistent with being produced by fe k@xmath5 emission from neutral matter .
overall , the observations are qualitatively consistent with a variable , non - thermal x - ray continuum emission , i.e. , a power law with @xmath6 @xmath0 1.6 ( possibly produced in the innermost regions of the radio - optical jet ) , plus underlying `` seyfert - like '' features , i.e. , a soft - excess and fe k@xmath5 line emission .
the data are consistent with some contribution ( up to a few 10% level in the _ asca _ energy band ) from a `` seyfert - like '' direct continuum emission , i.e. a power law with @xmath6 @xmath0 1.9 plus a reflection component , as well .
when the continuum ( jet ) emission is in a low state , the spectral features produced by the seyfert - like spectrum ( soft - excess , iron line and possibly a steep power law plus a reflection continuum ) are more easily seen . 24.0 cm -0.5 cm -1.5 cm accepted for publication in p.a.s.j . |
quantum game theory @xcite is a new field of science having its roots in both game theory and quantum information theory . for about a decade
quantum computer scientists have been searching for new methods of quantum algorithm design .
thorough investigation of different quantum games may bring new insight into the development of quantum algorithms .
it was shown that grover s algorithm @xcite can be treated as an example of a quantum parrondo s paradox @xcite .
operators used in grover s algorithm can be treated as parrondo games having separately zero expected values , however , if they are interwired , the expected value fluctuates .
this effect is well known in grover s algorithm .
implementation of a quantum parrondo s paradox has been described in papers @xcite . in this paper
we present a new implementation scheme of a capital - dependent parrondo s paradoxical games on a relatively small number of qubits .
parrondo s paradox consists of a sequence of games , where each game can be interpreted as a toss of an asymmetrical coin .
every success means that the player gains one dollar , every loss means that the player loses one dollar .
there are two games .
game @xmath2 has probability of winning @xmath3 .
game @xmath4 depends on the amount of capital accumulated by player .
if his capital is a multiple of three , the player tosses coin @xmath5 , which has probability of wining @xmath6 , otherwise the player tosses coin @xmath7 which has probability of wining @xmath8 .
originally @xmath9 , but generally it can be any small real number . both games @xmath2 and @xmath4 are biased and have negative expected gain .
but when a player has the option to choose which game he wants to play at each step of the sequence , he can choose such a combination of games which allows him to obtain positive expected gain .
it is known that sequences @xmath10 or @xmath11 give relatively high expected gain .
this fact is known as _ parrondo s
in @xcite the quantum versions of parrondo games were proposed .
the scheme introduced in @xcite realizes a history - dependent version of parrondo s paradox .
its disadvantage is that it needs a large number of qubits to store the history of the games . on the
other hand the scheme by meyer and blumer @xcite uses brownian motion of particle in one dimension and does not consume large amounts of quantum resources . the scheme presented by flitney , abott and johnson in @xcite
is based on multi - coin discrete quantum history - dependent random walk .
the implementation of the capital - dependent quantum parrondo s paradox introduced in this paper uses only @xmath0 qubits , where @xmath1 is the number of games played .
this allows to perform simulation even when a relatively large number of games are played ; for instance , if a strategy consists of five elementary games then 400 iterations require only 15 qubits .
to implement games @xmath2 and @xmath4 , three arbitrary - chosen one - qubit quantum gates @xmath12 , @xmath5 and @xmath7 are used .
each gate is described by four real parameters and our scheme as a whole is described by set of parameters : * @xmath13 : real numbers describing gates @xmath14 ; * @xmath15 : strategy any sequence of games @xmath2 , @xmath4 ; * @xmath1 : size of @xmath16 outcome register ( see below ) ; * @xmath17 : initial capital offset .
each gate is composed of elementary gates as presented in eq .
( [ equ : gate - comp ] ) : @xmath18 where @xmath19 and + @xmath20 .
the quantum register used to perform this scheme consists of three subregisters : * @xmath21 : one - qubit register representing the coin , * @xmath16 : @xmath1-qubit register storing player s capital , * @xmath22 : three - qubit auxiliary register .
register @xmath21 holds the state of the _
quantum coin_. gates @xmath12 , @xmath5 and @xmath7 acting on this register represent _ quantum coin tosses_. one should note that the register @xmath21 does not store information about history of the games .
after every execution of gates @xmath12 , @xmath5 and @xmath7 , the state of the register @xmath16 is changed according to the result of the _ quantum coin toss_. this register is responsible for storing the history of the games , that is , player s capital .
register @xmath22 is an ancillary register , which one need to check if the state of the @xmath16 register is a multiple of three . at the beginning of the scheme and after the application of the games gates this register is always set to @xmath23 .
games @xmath2 and @xmath4 are implemented using the conditional incrementation
decrementation ( cid ) gate and gates @xmath12 , @xmath5 and @xmath7 described above .
in addition , game @xmath4 uses gate @xmath24 . gate @xmath24 sets @xmath25 and @xmath26 registers to state @xmath27 iff the @xmath16 register contains a number that is a multiple of three : @xmath28 the cid gate is responsible for increasing and decreasing the player s capital . the circuit for this gate is presented in fig .
[ fig : cid ] .
this gate increments register @xmath16 if @xmath21 is in state @xmath27 and decrements if it is in state @xmath29 .
game @xmath2 is directly implemented by gate @xmath12 as presented in fig .
[ fig : game - a ] .
game @xmath4 , presented in fig .
[ fig : game - b ] , is more complicated . it uses gate @xmath24 to check if the player s capital is a multiple of three .
if it is the case gate @xmath7 is applied to register @xmath21 , otherwise , @xmath5 is applied .
one can easily check that all gates used in this scheme are unitary because they are composed of elementary unitary operations .
+ the game procedure is composed of the following steps : 1 .
preparation of @xmath21 in state @xmath30 .
2 . preparation of @xmath16 in state @xmath31 , where @xmath17 is a small integer number , 3 .
preparation of @xmath32 in @xmath23 state .
4 . application of gates @xmath12 and @xmath33 in some chosen order @xmath15 . after each application of gate @xmath12 or
@xmath33 the number stored in register @xmath16 is either incremented or decremented .
the initial state of register @xmath16 must be chosen in such way that integer overflow is avoided .
the maximum number of elementary games can not exceed the capacity of the register @xmath16 .
if our scheme is implemented on a physical quantum device it should be finalized by measurement .
this would give a single outcome representing the final capital .
thus , to obtain expected gain , the experiment should be repeated several times .
simulation allows to observe the state vector of the quantum system . using this property
the expected gain is calculated as the average value of @xmath34 in state @xmath35 obtained after tracing out the register with respect to coin and auxiliary subregisters : @xmath36
simulations of a quantum parrondo s paradox presented in this article were performed using qcl @xcite .
the source code of the implementation can be found on the webpage listed in ref .
@xcite . to carry out the simulation ,
gates @xmath12 , @xmath5 and @xmath7 were prepared with coefficients listed in table [ tab : ex1 ] .
those coefficients were chosen arbitrarly .
.coefficients of the experiment [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] in fig .
[ fig : sim - res ] the selection of results is presented .
as one can see there are strategies that give positive expected values . for @xmath37 ,
strategy @xmath38 gives a gain of @xmath39 after 400 steps .
for @xmath40 , strategy @xmath41 gives a gain of @xmath42 after 400 steps .
+ simulations have shown that finding the winning strategy for a given initial set of parameters is not trivial because they are uncommon .
we found that the initial value kept in register @xmath16 heavily influences the outcome , for example , see fig .
[ fig : sim - res ] . for different offsets different winning strategies can be found .
one should note that behavior of the strategy can change if the initial offset is altered , for example see , fig .
[ fig : sim - res - comp ] .
is wining for @xmath40 and losing for @xmath37 . ]
we have shown that it is possible to create a capital - driven scheme for quantum parrondo games using less than 20 qubits .
the main advantage of this scheme is that the size of the register grows as @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the number of steps .
we have found that the initial value of the register @xmath16 is important for selection of strategy .
simulations have shown that for an analyzed set of strategies composed of five elementary games , winning strategies are uncommon .
this paper has been supported by the polish ministry of scientific research and information technology under the ( solicited ) grant no .
pbz - min-008/p03/2003 . | we propose a quantum implementation of a capital - dependent parrondo s paradox that uses @xmath0 qubits , where @xmath1 is the number of parrondo games .
we present its implementation in the quantum computer language ( qcl ) and show simulation results . |
suppose that a system is placed at a certain metastable state surrounded by local potential minimum , the system would be unstable to decay to a global minimum assisted by either quantum or thermal fluctuations .
such processes are called false - vacuum decay and metastability relaxation , and they are considered to be non - perturbative in nature . hence , in order to calculate the decay rate ( life time ) , ingenious treatments have been invented so far @xcite .
those treatments rely on semi - classical approximation .
that is , the treatments take into account quadratic fluctuations around the field configuration which extremizes the euclidean action .
such field configurations are called instanton , bounce and ( critical ) droplet .
therefore , those treatments , just like the wkb approximation in wave mechanics , are not justified for strong fluctuations ( namely , short life time ) .
in addition , it is quite cumbersome to improve the approximation systematically . in order to compensate the above drawback
, first - principle calculation scheme free from any biased errors would be desirable .
as for discrete variable model ( kinetic ising model ) , actually , remarkable _ tour de force _ scheme was invented by gnther _
they introduced the so - called constrained - transfer - matrix method , which meets nonequilibrium situation .
then , they carried out extensive numerical calculations of the transfer matrix . in consequence , they extracted imaginary part of the free energy , which is to be identified as the decay rate . to the best of our knowledge , it is the first _ ab initio _ approach to the decay rate in the presence of many - body correlations .
their result supports the aforementioned analytic theory based on the droplet picture .
( besides this , monte - carlo simulation has been utilized to evolve the relaxation processes @xcite , where the number of monte - carlo steps is interpreted as time progression .
though the interpretation is , in a strict sense , not fully justified , the simulation result is fairly in accordance with the droplet picture actually . ) on the contrary , as for continuous - variable model such as the @xmath0 model , the above approach does not apply , and so far , no attempt at _ ab initio _ calculation has been reported . for quantum - mechanics level ( @xmath2 dimension ) , however , a number of substantial progresses are made @xcite : suzuki and yasuta obtained a compact expression for the decay ( tunnelling ) rate based on the weak - coupling expansion and succeeding borel resummation @xcite .
they succeeded in calculating the tunnelling rate beyond instanton calculus .
alternatively , from the weak coupling expansion , karrlein and kleinert obtained , remarkably enough , strong - coupling series by means of the so - called variational perturbation @xcite .
both approaches pursue first - principle calculation scheme beyond instanton calculus . as a consequence ,
these theories clarified how the instanton description fails for low potential barrier ; true decay rate is suppressed owing to inter - instanton interaction . at present , extension to many - body case appears to be unsuccessful @xcite .
the aim of this paper is to investigate the false - vacuum decay rate for many - body system through series expansion .
we studied the lattice @xmath0 model in @xmath1 dimensions , @xmath3 with the canonical commutation relations @xmath4=
{ \rm i } \delta_{ij}$ ] , @xmath5=0 $ ] and @xmath6=0 $ ] .
note that for @xmath7 , the potential is not bounded below , and renders the state @xmath8 unstable ( false vacuum ) .
the decay rate due to the quantum fluctuations is our concern
. we will show that in contrast to @xmath2 dimension mentioned above , the decay rate is _ enhanced _ owing to inter - instanton interaction .
the present paper is organized as follows . in the next section ,
we calculate the decay rate by means of strong - coupling expansion .
we explain methodological details , and check the validity by means of an alternative simulation . in the last section ,
we summarize the present study .
in this section , we will calculate the false - vacuum decay rate of the model ( [ hamiltonian ] ) through strong - coupling expansion . to begin with
, we will formulate the basis of the expansion . making use of the rescalings @xmath9 and @xmath10
, we arrive at the expression , @xmath11 where , @xmath12 according to the formula , the quadratic potential terms are regarded as perturbations , and so the ground - state energy is expanded in terms of the strong - coupling parameter @xmath13 ; @xmath14 where , @xmath15 note that the unperturbed hamiltonian @xmath16 is biquadratic .
hence , it is not quite straightforward to perform perturbation with respect to this limit . here , however , we will manage the perturbation expansion with the aid of computer calculations .
the unperturbed hamiltonian is a collection of independent anharmonic oscillators , and the perturbation introduces coupling among them . in such case , the linked - cluster expansion is useful to generate perturbation series .
the linked - cluster expansion is a method of , so to speak , computer - aided diagrammatic expansion @xcite . to perform cluster expansion
, we should set up unperturbed eigensystems nevertheless .
for that purpose , we must diagonalize the hamiltonian of each local anharmonic oscillator @xmath17 .
we carried out the diagonalization in the following way : ( a ) an oscillator spans infinite - dimensional hilbert space . in order to perform computer simulation , we need to restrict the number of bases .
for that purpose , we prepare low - lying @xmath18 states of _ harmonic _ oscillator with quadratic potential @xmath19 ; namely , @xmath20 ( @xmath21 ) .
note that the diagonalization of @xmath22 is now manageable , because the hilbert space is spanned by finite number of bases just prepared .
here , @xmath23 is a freely tunable variational parameter , and we had adjusted it so as to minimize @xmath24 ; namely , we chose @xmath25 .
( this idea is a reminiscence of feynman and kleinert @xcite , who calculated the thermodynamics of anharmonic oscillator by replacing biquadratic potential with an optimal quadratic one . )
( b ) with respect to the hilbert - space frame @xmath20 ( @xmath26 ) , we represented the anharmonic - oscillator hamiltonian @xmath22 , and diagonalized it to obtain the energy levels and the eigenvectors .
( c ) provided that those eigenvectors are at hand , we carried out secondary hilbert - space truncation : we extracted low - lying @xmath27 eigenvectors among @xmath28 , and discarded the others . henceforth , those @xmath27 vectors are to be used to span the ( intra - oscillator ) hilbert space .
( such hilbert space restriction scheme originates in wilson , who diagonalized huge cluster of conduction electrons @xcite . ) to summarize , we truncated the intra - oscillator bases through two steps .
first , we had utilized the eigenvectors of a _ harmonic _ oscillator to span the hilbert - space frame . those are not very efficient , and so , we prepared rather huge number of @xmath18 bases in practice . in that sense ,
the second truncation is significant , where we had remained only low - lying @xmath27 bases after solving the eigensystems of the intra - site hamiltonian @xmath22 .
these bases turned out to be very efficient ( see below ) , and only @xmath29 bases are necessary so as to achieve reliable calculations in the succeeding linked - cluster expansion .
( note that to perform the linked - cluster expansion , we need to store , in computer memory , huge hilbert - space vector for clusters consisting _ many _ oscillators . ) before going into cluster expansion , we will check the reliability of the hilbert - space restrictions .
we treat a single anharmonic oscillator ( namely , we ignore the inter - oscillator coupling ) with respect to the restricted hilbert space mentioned above .
we used the ordinary rayleigh - schrdinger perturbation theory , because the system is of one - body problem .
the strong - coupling perturbation coefficients are reported in the literature @xcite .
we observed following encouraging features : first , the choice of @xmath18 is sufficient .
namely , it reaches the limit of numerical round - off error ( we used extended precision of 16-byte real number ) , and further increase of @xmath28 just alters final few digits .
secondly , we found that rather small @xmath27 yields precise data .
for example , @xmath30 , which would seem exceedingly small , reproduces the perturbation coefficients reported in @xcite with high precision of order @xmath31 ( that is not relative but absolute error ) .
moreover , the precision is maintained even for high - order perturbation coefficients .
for example , the choice of @xmath18 and @xmath32 , for which the simulation takes ten minutes or so , is sufficient to reproduce the full result of @xcite .
encouraged by these findings , we performed the linked - cluster expansion for the lattice @xmath0 model .
we obtained the perturbation series up to eleventh order .
the strong - coupling series is given by , @xmath33 with uncertainties only in the final digits . in the above
, we obtained strong - coupling series expansion for @xmath34 ( [ series_expansion ] ) .
we plotted the result in .
we had truncated the series at various orders , which are indicated for respective curves .
we see that the curves start to deviate at @xmath35 , and higher - order data exhibit even worse convergence .
hence , it is suggested that the series ( [ series_expansion ] ) has finite convergence radius @xmath36 . in order to go beyond the convergence bound and extract meaningful physics , we have to process our data with some resummation trick .
we found that aitken s
@xmath37-process @xcite , @xmath38 is very useful to accelerate the convergence of our series . here ,
@xmath39 , @xmath40 and @xmath41 are three successive partial sums truncated at respective orders .
we plotted the resumed results in .
the symbol such as @xmath42-@xmath43-@xmath44 indicates that the data are accelerated with the partial sums of @xmath45 , @xmath46 and @xmath47 .
we see that the data exhibit pronounced convergence improvement .
our data may be valid up to @xmath48 . in order to check the convergence bound more definitely , we performed an alternative first - principle simulation with the density - matrix renormalization group .
our algorithm is standard . as for a comprehensive overview of this algorithm
, interested readers may consult with a proceeding @xcite .
full account of technical details specific to the @xmath1-dimensional scaler field theory will be found in our paper @xcite .
( in this paper , we studied field @xmath49 confined within the rigid - wall potential @xmath50 . in order to match the present case
, one has to replace @xmath50 with @xmath0 . ) the numerical error was checked throughly in @xcite , and it was found to reach @xmath51 .
we monitored the performance in the present case as well , and found that the precision is maintained .
the error would be far less than the symbol size shown in the plot [ figure2 ] .
the first - principle data are shown in as well .
we see that our resummed data are valid up to @xmath52 fairly definitely . finally , we mention a singularity occurring at @xmath53 ; see . it is noteworthy that for @xmath54 , the potential becomes double - well form .
therefore , at a certain critical @xmath55 , there would be an ising - type phase transition .
the singularity found in our data may indicate the onset of the transition .
determination of the critical point for the lattice @xmath0 model is attracting considerable attention recently in the context of quantum ferroelectric transition @xcite .
we will pursue this issue elsewhere , and in the present paper , we will not go into details any further . in the above , we attained good convergence of the series expansion ( [ series_expansion ] ) with the aid of the convergence - acceleration trick ( [ aitken ] ) .
armed by this achievement , in this subsection , we access the domain of @xmath7 through the analytic continuation @xmath56 . for @xmath7 , potential is not bounded below , and exhibits a local potential minimum in the vicinity of @xmath57 ( metastability ) . because the series expansion ( [ series_expansion ] ) is an irrational function in terms of @xmath58 , the analytic continuation renders imaginary part in the ground - state energy .
thereby , from it , we can read off the false - vacuum decay rate . in practice
, the analytic continuation is done through the path @xmath59 of @xmath60 .
that is , the term @xmath61 gives rise to the contribution @xmath62 after @xmath56 .
so far , as to calculate the decay rate , the instanton technique has been used .
the technique is justified for sufficiently large potential barrier ( small @xmath58 ) . in the following
we will show that our series - expansion approach covers the instanton theory . in
, we plotted the false - vacuum decay rate multiplied by @xmath58 , namely , @xmath63 , against @xmath64 .
the factor @xmath58 should kill the prefactor of a dominant exponential contribution : that is , the instanton theory predicts that the decay rate should obey the formula , @xmath65 where @xmath66 denotes the euclidean action of one instanton .
we solved the instanton solution numerically , and obtained the estimate , @xmath67 to be concrete , we will sketch the calculation method .
first of all , one must reformulate the hamiltonian formalism ( [ hamiltonian ] ) into the lagrangian formalism in the euclidean space - time .
thereby , we considered the system with 28 sites and imaginary time @xmath68 .
the imaginary time is discretized into 8000 intermediate time slices .
( note that now , the field is defined in the discretized space - time . )
because the instanton solution ( field configuration ) should minimize the euclidean action , the problem reduces to the minimization of multi - dimensional function . that computation
is readily achieved by the utilities supplied in simulation guide books such as @xcite .
the amount of error is estimated with changing the system sizes and discretization intervals .
we would like to draw reader s attention to the fact that the formula ( [ instanton ] ) has an essential singularity at @xmath69 .
that is why we had selected the strategy of approaching from @xmath70 rather than from @xmath69 .
let us turn to the discussion of our result of .
as is mentioned above , the instanton result ( [ instanton ] ) is validated for large @xmath64 . as a matter of fact , for @xmath71 , our data approaches the instanton prediction ; we had drawn the slope of . in this respect ,
the convergence - acceleration trick ( [ aitken ] ) is crucial in our study , because it enables us to attain good convergence up to @xmath72 , which appears to reach the instanton region . for @xmath73 ,
on the other hand , our data indicate rapid enhancement of the decay rate ; namely , the curve starts to deviate from the instanton prediction .
it is to be stressed that our treatment is justified for strong - coupling limit ( @xmath74 ) .
therefore , it is found that the inter - instanton correlation gives rise to _ enhancement _ of relaxation .
this feature is to be contrasted with that of @xmath2 dimension , where the inter - instanton correlation results in _ suppression _ of decay rate .
enhancement in @xmath1 dimensions was speculated in the former study @xcite , where the authors utilized the _ weak_-coupling expansion and the borel technique .
although their series does not show any indication of convergence , their result actually captures a signal of relaxation enhancement . according to kleinert , in the regime @xmath75 , the decay process is governed by ` sliding ' rather than instanton @xcite .
nevertheless , we stress that the present series - expansion approach covers both instanton ( @xmath71 ) and sliding ( @xmath76 ) regimes in a unified way .
moreover , our series is readily improved systematically just by performing cluster expansion further . in the above
, we found that at @xmath77 , there exists a crossover boundary separating two distinctive regimes .
our result supports the previous proposal of @xcite .
the authors calculated the effective potential , and found that for @xmath78 , the potential barrier is smeared out by quantum fluctuations .
their criterion would be sensible for separating instanton and sliding phases . in
, we see that the data of 9 - 10 - 11 and 8 - 9 - 10 show poor convergence . that may possibly be due to the fact that our 10th and 11th perturbation coefficients have rather few significant figures available .
finally , we recollect past findings for the @xmath0 theory in _ continuous _ space time .
brzin and parisi completed the instanton calculation , and obtained the formula @xmath79 @xcite .
we notice that the instanton action is similar to that of our lattice model
. perhaps , the decay process would be identical between the lattice model and the continuous - field theory .
so far , several _ ab initio _ approaches have been proposed in order to calculate the decay rate beyond semiclassical approximation . in particular , the @xmath0 model in @xmath2 dimension has come under through investigation @xcite , while the extension to many - body case remains unsuccessful . in the present paper , by means of the strong - coupling expansion , we studied the @xmath80-dimensional lattice @xmath0 model ( [ hamiltonian ] ) .
we demonstrated that the linked - cluster expansion method works very efficiently , provided that hilbert - space restriction is processed properly .
in addition , we found that the convergence - acceleration trick ( [ aitken ] ) is significant .
in fact , the convergence - accelerated sum reproduces the first - principle data for considerably wide range @xmath81 .
based on the above achievements , we surveyed the domain of metastability through the analytic continuation @xmath82 .
we are concerned in the false - vacuum decay rate @xmath83 ; see .
our result indicates that there are two regimes . for @xmath84 ,
our result obeys the prediction by the instanton theory .
it is to be stressed that the convergence acceleration ( [ aitken ] ) is significant to reach the instanton regime . for shallow potential barrier @xmath85 ,
the relaxation is no more described by instanton , but the relaxation rate acquires notable enhancement . according to kleinert , for @xmath85 , the relaxation is driven by sliding rather than instanton .
nevertheless , we stress that our series - expansion approach does cover both regions with a unified framework , and it is readily improved systematically just by continuing the perturbation further
. it would be promising that the present method is applied to other wide class of metastable systems .
as is mentioned above , we had performed the density - matrix - renormalization - group simulation as well . from the simulation data , we are able to extract perturbation coefficients by polynomial fitting . this technique is applicable to those models that even possess complicated interactions and spatial inhomogeneity .
tunnelling phenomena assisted by an impurity is of current interest @xcite .
however , ambiguities in estimating fitting errors are not fully resolved at present .
it is left for future study . | strong - coupling expansion is performed for the lattice @xmath0 model in @xmath1 dimensions .
because the strong - coupling limit itself is not solvable , we employed numerical calculations so as to set up unperturbed eigensystems . restricting the number of hilbert - space bases , we performed linked - cluster expansion up to eleventh order .
we carried out alternative simulation by means of the density - matrix renormalization group .
thereby , we confirmed that our series - expansion data with a convergence - acceleration trick are in good agreement with the simulation result . through the analytic continuation to the domain of negative biquadratic interaction , we obtain the false - vacuum decay rate .
contrary to common belief that tunnelling phenomenon lies out of perturbative treatments , our series expansion reproduces the instanton - theory behaviour for high potential barrier .
for shallow barrier , on the contrary , our result tells that the relaxation is no more described by instanton , but the decay rate acquires notable enhancement . |
the quest for the direct detection of dark matter in the form of weakly interacting massive particles ( wimps ) @xcite , the search for the neutrinoless double beta decay ( @xmath2 ) @xcite or other experiments involving very low rate processes ( the so - called rare event searches ) impose very challenging experimental requirements .
the most important of these requirements is the reduction of experimental backgrounds down to ever - decreasing levels .
the fight against backgrounds is performed in several ways , including active and passive shielding , operation in underground sites , event discrimination and especially selecting carefully the materials composing the detector and those in the surroundings so that they have the lowest radioactive traces that could induce background in the experiment .
all these practices have evolved toward a technical field itself , usually called _ ultra - low background techniques _
@xcite .
it is nowadays an adopted practice within low background experiments to exhaustively screen all materials and components present in the inner part of the experimental set - up .
several detection techniques have been developed and used for low level counting in the last three decades like for example proportional counters or nai(tl ) detectors . nevertheless , @xmath3-spectrometry using germanium detectors is , in most of the cases , the best way to make radiopurity measurements in a non - destructive way due to good intrinsic features of these detectors like their energy resolution .
gamma spectrometry , together with neutron activation analysis or mass spectrometry , are at present the most commonly used techniques in order to determine the radioactivity level of different materials . for the latest generation of rare event experiments ,
the requirements for radiopurity are so strong that this constitutes an important selection criteria for the detection technique itself .
compact and simple detector set - ups are preferred as they are supposed to be better subjected to radiopurity validation , i.e. scrupulous screening of all detector components , identification of potential sources of radioactivity and development of substitute radiopure components if possible .
complex detectors are , a priori , more likely to contain radioactive materials in their fabrication and it is therefore more difficult ( or impossible ) to develop radiopure versions of them .
this argument gets stronger when larger detector masses and volumes are needed , as is the case of the new generation of rare events experiments .
although gaseous time projection chambers ( tpcs)could offer unique features to rare event detection ( as it will be described in section [ res&tpc ] ) , they have been historically considered not suitable for these searches .
the reasons for this are mainly the complexity that the construction of readouts based on one or several plane of wires ( multi wire proportional chambers , mwpc ) implies when it comes to large volumes of detection , mechanical and electronics - wise ; but also issues related to the large volumes ( e.g. difficulty to shield ) and other features of the detection in gas ( e.g. stability and homogeneity issues ) which are not best suited for very long exposure high sensitivity operation .
however , this view is changing in the last years , thanks to several developments on tpc readouts , like the ones regarding micromegas ( micromesh gas structure ) readout planes , briefly explained in section [ mm_readout_plane ] , that are overcoming the traditional limitation of gas tpcs for rare event searches .
indeed , several ongoing initiatives plan to use tpcs , and in particular micromegas readouts , in the field of rare event searches as briefly explained in section [ res&tpc ] .
the present work is focused on a point of common interest for all these experiments : the radiopurity of micromegas readouts themselves .
the ultimate goal of this line of development is not only to assess the radiopurity of every type of current micromegas readout ( that has been partially studied and is presented in this article ) , but also to identify the less radiopure components ( whether raw materials or fabrication processes introducing radioactive traces ) , find alternative , more radiopure ones and to implement them in the manufacturing processes . in this article
first results of measurements of micromegas samples performed in the canfranc underground laboratory ( lsc ) with an ultralow background high purity germanium detector are presented , including a first assessment on the state - of - the - art of micromegas fabrication processes from the point of view of potential radiopurity . in section [ res&tpc ] , a summarized review of utilization of tpcs for rare event searches and the improvements achieved
is presented .
section [ mm_readout_plane ] presents a description of the micromegas readouts and some details on the fabrication materials and processes that may be of relevance for the goal are given .
the experimental set - up used to carry out the measurements as well as the description of the samples measured is described in section [ setup ] , while the obtained results are presented in section [ randd ] .
to finish , preliminary conclusions and outlook are developed in section [ conclusions ] .
it has long been recognized that gas tpcs could offer unique features to rare event detection .
gas tpcs provide very useful topological information that allows better identification of rare events discriminating them from background events . in the field of dark matter wimp detection , although tests are ongoing with directional - sensitive solid detectors or nuclear emulsions @xcite , gas tpcs present the most promising technique to measure the direction of the wimp - induced nuclear recoils . after a wimp collision ,
the nuclei recoil with typical energies of 1 - 100 , travel distances of the order of few 100 in solids , while in gases this distance can go up to the or scale , depending on the type and pressure of the gas .
an accurate measurement of the recoil direction would provide an unmistakable signature of a wimp , which no terrestrial background could mimic @xcite . in the decade of the 1990s ,
only one group , the drift collaboration @xcite , was exploring the use of mwpc - read tpcs for this purpose .
despite very recent encouraging results , the accurate measurement of the direction of low energy nuclear recoils with mwpcs remains very challenging . due to the mechanical limitations in the construction of the planes of wires ,
the best readout granularity achievable by these devices lies in the scale , very limiting , if not insufficient , for an accurate imaging of nuclear recoil tracks . only the advent of micropattern readouts and micromegas - like structures ,
has recently allowed more groups to further explore the detection of wimp directionality with gas tpcs @xcite . in the search for the @xmath2 decay
a similar situation can be drawn .
the topology of the @xmath2 signal in a gas tpc with a proper 3d readout ( two electron tracks ending in two ionization blobs ) is a powerful tool for background event rejection and signal identification .
this fact was proved in the 1990s by the gothard xenon gaseous tpc , which aimed to measure the @xmath2 signal of the @xmath4xe @xcite .
this experiment was an important milestone , successfully demonstrating the proof - of - principle .
however , the technique was not further pursued because of the drawbacks of mwpcs and tpcs mentioned above , and the fact that the obtained energy resolution of mwpcs in xe was insufficient for the next generation of double beta decay experiments .
however , in recent years important technical advantages in the readouts of tpcs have been achieved that may eliminate the traditional limitations of these detectors , opening new windows of application for them . in particular ,
rare event searches could now profit enormously from the signal identification potentiality of gas tpcs .
the key issue that has boosted the development activities of these devices has been the use of metallic strips or pads , precisely printed on plastic supports with photolithography techniques ( much like printed circuit boards ) .
these strips substitute the traditional wires to receive the drifting charge produced in the gas .
the simplicity , robustness and mechanical precision are much higher than those of conventional planes of wires . around this basic principle , first introduced by oed @xcite already in 1988 under the name
microstrip gaseous chamber ( msgc ) , several different designs have been developed , which differ in the way the multiplication structure is done , and that in general are referred to as micro pattern gas detectors ( mpgd ) .
one of the most promising mpgds , and certainly the one offering most attractive features for application in rare events , is the micromegas readout plane @xcite .
the micromegas concept dates back to 1996 , but since then it has been constantly and substantially improved , especially regarding the manufacturing techniques ( see later in section [ mm_readout_plane ] for more details ) .
the first real application of micromegas detectors in a rare event experiment has been in the cern axion solar telescope ( cast ) at cern @xcite .
cast used a single low - background micromegas detector since 2002 @xcite and three of them since 2007 @xcite .
cast has been a test ground for these detectors , where they have been combined with low background techniques like the use of shielding , radiopurity screening of detector components or advanced event discrimination techniques .
the last generation of cast micromegas detectors are providing outstanding low levels of background @xcite . the experience in cast
has clearly proved the interest of micromegas detectors for low background applications .
this has already been acknowledged by a number of groups that are proposing or considering micromegas - based tpcs for rare event searches . in wimp dark matter searches ,
the above mentioned drift collaboration has recently demonstrated experimentally that the experiment s basic technique ( the negative ion tpc concept ) works with micromegas planes @xcite , and could consider micromegas for future prototypes .
the mimac experiment @xcite has successfully built a micro - tpc with micromegas readout to measure nuclear recoil tracks in helium .
the japanese newage experiment @xcite is developing a similar detector with a micro - dot readout , another type of mpgd . the dmtpc collaboration , although testing a different approach based on optical readouts ( ccd ) , uses also a micromegas - like structure to produce the scintillation to be read @xcite . in the field of @xmath2 decay
recent proposals like those of next @xcite or exo @xcite collaborations have resuscitated the old xenon gas tpc but in the context of the newest advances in tpc readouts , and are considering micromegas as an option for their tpcs .
very recent developments seem to gather experimental evidence of enhanced energy resolution for micromegas detectors also at high energies @xcite , when compared to mwpc or other mpgds , which make them particularly suitable for @xmath2 searches .
the micromegas @xcite readouts make use of a metallic micromesh suspended over a ( usually pixelised ) anode plane by means of isolator pillars , defining an amplification gap of the order of 50 to 150 .
electrons drifting towards the readout , go through the micromesh holes and trigger an avalanche inside the gap , inducing detectable signals both in the anode pixels and in the mesh .
the particular micromegas amplification geometry has numerous advantages that have been studied and widely advertised in the literature .
they are specially relevant in the context of rare events .
for instance , it is known @xcite that the way the amplification develops in a micromegas gap is such that its gain @xmath5 is less dependent on geometrical factors ( the gap size ) or environmental ones like the temperature or pressure of the gas than in conventional mwpcs or other mpgds based on charge amplification .
this fact allows in general for higher time stability and spatial homogeneity in the response of micromegas , facilitating the scaling - up of prototypes as well as long term operation , both issues crucial in rare event experiments .
this same effect is responsible of the generally better energy resolution obtained with micromegas planes , also a valuable feature in general for rare events , as the detector usually works as calorimeter . in particular
, it is a very important feature for @xmath2 searches , as only a good energy resolution of the detectors will allow separation of the peak of the @xmath2 decay from the tail of the standard @xmath6 decay ( with emission of two neutrinos ) , which represent an irreducible background to the searched @xmath2 mode @xcite .
practical manufacturing and operation of micromegas detectors have been extremely facilitated by the development of fabrication processes which yield an all - in - one readout , in opposition to `` classical '' first generation micromegas , for which the mesh was mechanically mounted on top of the pixelised anode .
nowadays most of the applications of the micromegas concept for applications in particle , nuclear and astroparticle physics , follow the so - called _
bulk_-micromegas type of fabrication method or the more recent _ microbulk_-micromegas .
the _ bulk _ micromegas @xcite provides large area , robust readouts by integrating a commercial woven wire mesh together with the anode carrying the strips or pixels .
this is achieved by means of a photo resistive film having the right thickness , with which the mesh is laminated at high temperatures together with the anode printed circuit , forming a single object . by photolithographic methods
the photo - resistive material is etched removing the material between the mesh and the anode and thus creating the micromegas gap in all the readout area but in some specific spots which are left as supporting pillars .
the result is a robust , homogeneous and reproducible readout that can be made up to relatively large areas and low cost , and very little dead space .
the technique has achieved maturity and _ bulk_-micromegas in large quantities are being used in several particle physics experiments , like for example in the t2k experiment @xcite . single unit _
bulk_-micromegas of @xmath7 are being envisaged for the mamma project @xcite .
the _ microbulk _ micromegas is a more recent development performed jointly by cea and cern @xcite .
it provides , like the _ bulk _
, all - in - one readouts but out of double - clad kapton foils .
the mesh is etched out of one of the copper layers of the foil , and the micromegas gap is created by removing part of the kapton by means of appropriate chemical baths and photolithographic techniques . although the fabrication technique is still under development , the resulting readouts have very appealing features , outperforming the _ bulk _ in several aspects .
the mechanical homogeneity of the gap and mesh geometry is superior , and in fact these micromegas have achieved the best energy resolutions among mpgds with charge amplification .
because of this , time stability of _ microbulk _ is expected to be also better than _ bulk_. on the other hand , they are less robust than the _ bulk _ and at the moment the maximum size of single readouts are of only @xmath8 ( the limitation coming from equipment and not fundamental ) .
this type of readouts is being used in the cast experiment @xcite . however , the most relevant feature of _
microbulk_-micromegas for the purpose of this work and in general for application in rare events is their potential radiopurity .
the readout can be made extremely light and most of the raw material is kapton and copper , two materials known to be ( or to achieve ) the best levels of radiopurity @xcite .
of course , the experience in radiopurity tells that every sample needs to be measured and that materials present in negligible amounts can account , if they have high level of radioactive contamination , for the majority of the radioactivity budget of a sample .
it is necessary to stress that the fabrication methods followed up to now have not been optimized from the point of view of radiopurity .
therefore , the results here presented have to be taken as typical values for current micromegas detectors , expecting to achieve higher radiopurity levels by selecting better raw materials or by improving the fabrication processes
. a better understanding of these ways of improvement is one of the goals of the present work .
all the measurements presented in this work were done using a p - type germanium detector with closed - end coaxial geometry and a volume close to 190 and an approximate mass of 1 .
the crystal is encapsulated in a copper cryostat of 7.8 -diameter .
figure [ esquema_paquito ] shows a diagram of the detector and its dimensions and the position inside the copper cryostat .
the detector is placed inside a shielding composed by 10 of archeological lead and 15 of low radioactivity lead ( fig .
[ paquito]a ) . the lead box is closed with a pvc bag and a flux of nitrogen gas
is continuously introduced to prevent air intrusion .
the detector is located at the canfranc underground laboratory ( depth 2500 ) to avoid cosmic radiation .
the pulses coming from the detector , with an operation voltage of 3500 , pass through an electronic chain composed by a canberra 2001 preamplifier , a linear amplifier canberra 2020 and an analog to digital converter ( adc ) canberra 8075 , that is connected to a pc .
the daq system of the detector provides information about energy and time of each detected event to allow reconstruction of the energy spectrum , and also to study their time correlation and further remove artificial events , such as electric noise .
the detector has an intrinsic resolution ( full width at half maximum ) of 2.20 at 122 and 2.70 at 1332 . to determine the detection efficiency , measurements with calibrated gamma sources ( @xmath9eu and @xmath1k ) at different positions
have been made ; in addition , a geant4 simulation application has been developed including specifically the detector set - up .
the validity of this application has been checked simulating all the calibrations done with the gamma sources and comparing the corresponding efficiency curves .
the agreement between simulated and experimental curves is higher than 95 @xmath10 in all the cases .
a simulation implementing the measured sample ( specially geometry and composition ) is carried out to determine the efficiency , considering a 5 @xmath10 error deduced from the preliminary tests . using all the described set - up
, a background level of 0.5 has been measured from 50 to 3000 , the most important contributions being those from @xmath11bi , @xmath11pb and @xmath1k decays as it can be seen in fig .
[ paquito]b .
the samples measured and studied could be divided in two groups .
the first of them includes a full _ microbulk_-micromegas readout plane formerly used in the cast experiment ( fig . [
esquemas]a ) .
the readout has a complex structure made of three kapton layers ( and the corresponding intermediate copper ones ) glued together in order to constitute the mesh , pillars , anode pixels and necessary underlying strip layout .
the scheme of the structure of the different layers can be seen in fig .
[ esquemas]a .
the main components of this readout are copper , kapton ( double copper clad polyamide laminate sheldahl g2300 ) and epoxy ( isola de156 ) and it has to be noted that the readout has been removed from its support , implying that some additional traces of epoxy , used to glue the readout to its support , could remain on it .
the second sample of this group is part of a classical micromegas structure . here
, there is only the anode layer of a readout that has been used in the first phase of the cast experiment , and there is no mesh in the readout ( it has to be noted that in this type of classical micromegas , the mesh was mechanically attached on top of the anode plane as shown in fig . [ esquemas]b ) . for this sample ,
the main materials are copper and kapton , although again there could be some traces of epoxy since the detector had also been glued on a support . for the final purpose of this work ,
this second sample represents an earlier stage in the manufacturing process than the full _ microbulk _ structure of the first sample , in which further chemical baths have been applied to etch the kapton pillars and the mesh structure .
both samples of this group have a diameter of 11 due to their former application at the cast experiment @xcite , while the thicknesses are @xmath0145 for the _ microbulk _ detector and @xmath060 for the classical micromegas structure ( see fig . [ esquemas ] ) .
the masses are 2.8 for the full _ microbulk_-micromegas and 2.6 for the classical one .
the second group of samples represents the raw material used in the fabrication of _ microbulk _ readouts .
both samples consist of kapton metalised with copper on one or both sides .
one of them has a 25 - -thick kapton layer together with a 5 - -thick copper one ( kapton - copper sample ) , while the second one combines two 5 - -thick copper layers with a 50 - -thick kapton one ( copper - kapton - copper sample ) . in order to have samples as similar as possible to the readouts of the first group , four circles of material of the same diameter ( 11 )
have been taken , with corresponding masses of 5.9 for the kapton - copper sample , and 4.7 for the copper - kapton - copper one . the main motivation to consider this group of samples is to determine if the contamination present in a detector comes from the raw materials ( kapton and copper mainly ) or from the different treatments needed to complete the manufacture of the detectors
the radioactivity of all the samples described in section [ setup ] was measured by placing them close to the closed part of the germanium detector and inside the shielding .
the main gamma emission lines present in the spectra taken with the samples are compared to their corresponding lines in a _ background _ spectrum ( i.e. a spectrum taken without any sample inside the shielding like the one shown in fig .
[ paquito]b ) to obtain values , or upper limits , of the activities of the different isotopes .
the gamma lines that , in principle , are studied to estimate the activity of each isotope are summarized in table [ emissions ] .
the analysis of all these lines is especially interesting for the isotopes belonging to the natural radioactive chains .
this allows determination of the activity of the chain but also to detect if there is any isotope breaking the equilibrium .
.gamma lines ( in ) that are in principle studied to determine the radioactive contamination of different sotopes . [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ emissions ] the required measuring times are strongly related to the contamination of the sample in order to reach a good sensitivity level .
for this reason , samples expected to have higher levels of contamination need less measuring time than more radiopure samples to determine the activities . in any case
the best scenario is to make measurements long enough , so that the background level of the detector and its intrinsic sensitivity is the limiting factor of the radioactivity levels obtained , independently of the measured sample . taken this property into account , _
microbulk_-micromegas and micromegas without mesh were measured during 34 and 32 days respectively , the kapton - copper layer during 34 days and the copper - kapton - copper layer during 37 days , while the background spectra used for the analysis correspond to around 30 days of measurement taken before and after the sample measurements .
the obtained results , expressed in activity levels per unit surface , are presented for the radioactive chains ( @xmath12th , @xmath13u , @xmath14u ) , and for @xmath1k and @xmath15co isotopes , being summarized in table [ results ] .
it has been checked that the same activity is obtained from all the gamma lines analyzed corresponding to different isotopes of the same radioactive chain ( summarized in table [ emissions ] ) .
this is an indication that that @xmath12th , @xmath13u and @xmath14u chains are in equilibrium .
table [ results_ppb ] summarizes the contamination for @xmath12th and @xmath14u chains in ppb and for @xmath1k in units in order to facilitate the comparison with other measurements present in the literature , although it has to be stressed that the samples measured are not homogeneous . for this reason
the presented contamination levels could be not necessarily associated to the bulk of the samples , as a quantity induce to consider , and it could be for example a surface contamination . the results do not show radioactive contamination above the minimum detectable level ( mda ) of the set - up for the samples of raw material .
for the micromegas samples , some contaminations just above the mda are seen .
these values are in overall compatible between the two samples , although maybe slightly higher in @xmath1k for the case of the full microbulk readout .
this fact leads to the hypothesis that current radioactive control of _ microbulk _ micromegas is dominated by the added materials in the composition of the different layers ( like epoxy ) , or by the chemical treatment for the etching processes .
this hypothesis should be the starting point of future work to further enhance the radiopurity of these readouts .
nevertheless , the measured levels of radiopurity are already extremely positive .
although the requirements on radiopurity of a detector component depend on the specific application in question as well as on the expected sensitivity of the experiment , we can generically compare our measurements with typical values of surface radioactivity achieved in other kinds of readout components .
just for illustration , table [ results ] shows radiopurity measurements performed on photomultiplier tubes ( pmts ) which are currently in use or considered in experiments or projects of rare event searches , all of them with the highest requirements on radiopurity .
in particular , the hamamatsu pmt r852006 is being used by the xenon collaboration in their detectors @xcite , and has been the outcome of a dedicated development to produce radiopure pmt .
an array of these devices are at the core of the xenon10 detector , currently the most sensitive dark matter experiment , composing its light readout .
they are also being used in the bigger , and more sensitive , xenon100 detector , currently taking data at gran sasso .
the measured radioactivity per unit surface of micromegas readouts is substantially lower that those reported for the r852006 pmt , especially for @xmath1k and @xmath15co .
although they are not compatible ( pmts are developed for light detection and micromegas are charge readouts ) , the reference values of the r852006 pmt radiopurity are illustrative as the very low levels of surface radiopurity that are tolerable for leading low background experiments . therefore the state - of - the - art _ microbulk
_ micromegas are therefore very well qualified for an ultra low background experiment .
the nature of the selected samples , chosen without any special criterion regarding manufacture or radiopurity , leads to reasonably expect that even lower radioactivity levels could be achieved after some development work to identify and eventually remove ( or substitute ) the limiting components or treatments .
therefore , the planned work for the near future includes further measurements of individual materials ( glues , chemical baths , ... ) used in the manufacture of the planes from the raw materials , to identify the origin of the remaining contamination and , if possible , the identification and use of cleaner alternatives .
since the contamination levels obtained from the samples of raw materials ( composed by kapton and copper ) are limited by the sensitivity of the measurements , the use of alternative measurement techniques like mass spectrometry , neutron activation or improved ge detectors are contemplated .
micromegas readouts are being considered or used in several rare event searches , like detection of dark matter or @xmath2 , due to important features like its robustness , stability and improved energy resolution . since one of the most important requirements for a detector focused in rare event searches is a high level of radiopurity , it is important to know , as much as possible , the quantity , nature and origin of the radioactive contamination of the readouts . with this aim ,
two different samples of micromegas readouts have been screened , together with some raw materials used for their manufacture , using an ultralow background germanium detector located at lsc .
the obtained results have revealed very low levels of radioactivity coming from natural chains ( @xmath169.3 @xmath17bq/@xmath18 of @xmath12th,@xmath1613.9 @xmath17bq/@xmath18 @xmath13u and [email protected] @xmath17bq/@xmath18 @xmath14u ) being @xmath1k the highest contamination ( [email protected] @xmath17bq/@xmath18 ) .
these levels of radiopurity , compatible for both readouts measured , already fulfil the requirements demanded by the current most stringent low background experiments , demonstrating the high potentiality of the state - of - the - art of micromegas in the search for rare events .
the fact that the contamination levels of the raw materials are below the sensitivity of the detector used , indicates that the main contribution to the radioactive contamination ( specially @xmath1k ) comes from elements used for the treatment of the readouts and not from the raw materials .
future work will focus on measurements of the component materials separately trying to enclose the main radioactivity sources in the readout and to identify possible processes which add impurities , even using complementary measuring techniques like mass spectrometry or neutron activation analysis to obtain more sensitive results .
we want to thank our colleagues of the group of the university of zaragoza , as well as to colleagues from the cast , next and rd-51 collaborations for helpful discussions and encouragement .
we acknowledge support from the spanish ministry of science and innovation ( micinn ) under contract ref . fpa2008 - 03456 , as well as under the cup project ref .
csd2008 - 00037 and the cpan project ref .
csd2007 - 00042 from the consolider - ingenio2010 program of the micinn .
we also acknowledge support from the european commission under the european research council t - rex starting grant ref .
erc-2009-stg-240054 of the ideas program of the 7th eu framework program .
finally , we also acknowledge support from the regional government of aragn under contract pi001/08 . | micromesh gas amplification structures ( micromegas ) are being used in an increasing number of particle physics applications since their conception fourteen years ago .
more recently , they are being used or considered as readout of time projection chambers ( tpcs ) in the field of rare event searches ( dealing with dark matter , axions or double beta decay ) . in these experiments ,
the radiopurity of the detector components and surrounding materials is measured and finely controlled in order to keep the experimental background as low as possible . in the present paper ,
the first measurement of the radiopurity of micromegas planes obtained by high purity germanium spectrometry in the low background facilities of the canfranc underground laboratory ( lsc ) is presented .
the obtained results prove that micromegas readouts of the _ microbulk _ type are currently manufactured with radiopurity levels below 30 for th and u chains and @xmath060 for @xmath1k , already comparable to the cleanest detector components of the most stringent low background experiments at present .
taking into account that the studied readouts were manufactured without any specific control of the radiopurity , it should be possible to improve these levels after dedicated development .
time projection chamber , micromegas , radiopurity , rare event searches |
in this section , we give explicit expressions for the _
su_(4 ) superoperators for @xmath0 two - level atoms in terms of the pauli spin - operators . following hartmann @xcite , 18 superoperators @xmath15 , @xmath16 and @xmath17 are defined , where @xmath18 , @xmath109 although this list , eq .
( [ super ] ) , contains 18 operator definitions , only 15 of them are independent ( it is possible to write @xmath110 , @xmath111 , @xmath112 in terms of the others ) .
one can demonstrate that the 15 remaining superoperators are linear combinations of the familiar gell - mann matrices that are the generators of the _
su_(4 ) group , @xmath113 @xcite . in order to see this , consider first the fundamental one atom case , where we interpret the @xmath114 density matrix as a @xmath115 vector in the representing vector space ( _ i.e. _ liouville space ) .
@xmath116 the linear combinations are given by @xmath117 the commutation relations of the superoperators are given in both ref .
@xcite and @xcite
. we can also identify six _
su_(2 ) subalgebras , @xmath118=2\mathcal{o}_3,\;\;\ ; [ \mathcal{o}_3,\mathcal{o}_{\pm}]=\pm\mathcal{o}_{\pm},\ ] ] so that it is useful to define six corresponding quadratic superoperators @xmath119 , which commute with @xmath120 .
su_(4 ) group has 3 casimir operators , one of which is quadratic in the generators , and the others are of higher order .
the quadratic casimir operator @xmath121 can be expressed in terms of superoperators @xmath122
the fundamental representation of the _
su_(4 ) group , adapted to serve as basis of the single - spin density matrix , is given by @xmath19 , @xmath20 , @xmath21 , @xmath22 .
higher order representations can then be obtained from the fundamental representation and the symmetry type , which is described by the young tableau .
the basis for the fully symmetrical case is defined as @xmath23 which are eigenstates of both @xmath123 and @xmath17 @xcite , with eigenvalues @xmath124 where @xmath125 .
the eigenvalues are not independent , but can be expressed in terms of @xmath126 : @xmath127 then it is straightforward to determine actions of all the raising and lowering superoperators on @xmath58 , @xmath128 we note that the fully symmetrical basis are also eigenstates of the quadratic casimir operator @xmath121 with common eigenvalue @xmath129 .
analogous actions for the photon part are the simple harmonic oscillator relations : @xmath130
in order to project the density operator from the _ su_(4 ) basis onto the @xmath71 representation , let us first show that @xmath86 and @xmath87 are related to the @xmath132 by @xmath72 and @xmath73 . to see this , defining @xmath133 , we could get @xmath134 and by definition , we have @xmath135 therefore , the complex coefficients from the @xmath132 basis contributing to the matrix element for @xmath71 all satisfy @xmath72 and @xmath73 . with this in mind , we now describe a systematic algorithm to obtain the density matrix elements @xmath85 from the _
su_(4 ) expansion coefficients @xmath38 .
we illustrate our method by considering in detail the elementary case of three atoms .
the density matrix in the @xmath71 representation is block diagonal in @xmath62 ; the block matrices for all @xmath62 can be arranged in the shape of a pyramid as shown in fig .
for instance , the base layer corresponds to @xmath63 , with the matrix dimension being @xmath136 .
the second layer has @xmath137 and dimension @xmath138 , and so on .
furthermore there are @xmath77 copies associated with each layer , so that @xmath78 . taking @xmath139 for example , there are two layers , @xmath140 and @xmath141 with @xmath142 and @xmath143 , so that the hilbert space dimension is @xmath144 .
the density matrix needs to be built from the bottom layer upwards . in the bottom layer , we find that the only element contributing to @xmath145 is @xmath146 .
so the top left corner is @xmath91 .
we next apply the lowering operator @xmath88 to iteratively generate @xmath147 , with @xmath148 . to do this
, we need the recursion relation @xmath149 therefore , with the actions of the raising and lowering operators [ eq . ( [ act ] ) ] , we can derive all @xmath150 , _
i.e. _ the first row of the bottom layer .
using the fact that the density matrix is hermitian and @xmath151 , we could get all the elements for the first column by @xmath152 . by repeatedly applying the recursion relation [ eq .
( [ rec ] ) ] in each row , we then construct the full base layer . as an explicit example
, we have constructed the bottom layer , _
@xmath140 for the three atom case , @xmath153 in order to illustrate the use of the recursion relation , we now show how to get @xmath154 from @xmath155 . because @xmath156 and @xmath157 , we have @xmath158 . to construct the next layer
, we thus find out the top left matrix element first , and then apply the same procedure as before to determine the rest of the matrix elements .
let us first examine the three atom case .
the @xmath141 layer has two copies , each of which is a @xmath159 matrix . to find the top left element @xmath160 ,
noticing the constraint imposed by the trace of the density matrix , we derive @xmath161 so that @xmath162 . by applying the same method as in the bottom layer ,
we construct the block matrix for @xmath141 layer @xmath163 therefore in general , if we suppose that we have constructed the block matrix for @xmath164 , the formula to find the top left matrix element @xmath165 for layer @xmath62 is @xmath166 having the top left matrix element for each layer @xmath62 , we can easily construct the @xmath167 block matrix by applying the recursion relation based on the angular momentum lowering operator .
repeated iteration of these steps systematically fills in all sites of the pyramid . | we show that open quantum systems of two - level atoms symmetrically coupled to a single - mode photon field can be efficiently simulated by applying a _
su_(4 ) group theory to quantum master equations .
this is important since many foundational examples in quantum optics fall into this class .
we demonstrate the method by finding exact solutions for many - atom open quantum systems such as lasing and steady state superradiance .
although quantum mechanics actually describes the behavior of isolated and closed quantum systems , in practice most physical situations to which it is applied are open .
the open nature is necessary to treat basic irreversible processes such as the energy transfer with a heat bath , the particle or charge exchange with a reservoir , and quantum measurements .
open quantum systems can be treated under the born and markov approximations by the quantum master equation in the lindblad form @xcite , which has been applied across many fields of physics , including quantum optics and quantum information science @xcite , atomic and molecular physics @xcite , solid state physics @xcite , and optomechanics @xcite .
here we focus on a novel group - theoretic approach to find an efficient solution of the quantum master equation for an important class of quantum optical systems .
even though we focus on these systems , the methods we present could be more generally applied to other fields .
we consider specifically the symmetric coupling of a single - mode cavity field to an ensemble of @xmath0 two - level atoms ( analogous to pseudo - spin-1/2 systems or qubits ) .
the hamiltonian that describes this situation in the interaction picture is given by @xmath1 where the first term is the free energy , with @xmath2 being the detuning of the light field from the atomic transition , and the second term is the reversible atom - field coupling with strength @xmath3 .
the photon annihilation operator is @xmath4 , and @xmath5 and @xmath6 are pauli operators for the @xmath7th spin - component . in the presence of decoherence
, the full quantum evolution is described by the quantum master equation for the reduced density operator @xmath8 : @xmath9+\kappa\mathcal{d}[a]\rho\nonumber\\ & & + \sum_{j=1}^n\left(\gamma\mathcal{d}[\sigma_j^- ] + w\mathcal{d}[\sigma_j^+]+\frac{1}{2t_2 } \mathcal{d}[\sigma_j^3]\right)\rho\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath10\rho=(2\hat{o}\rho \hat{o}^\dagger-\hat{o}^\dagger \hat{o}\rho-\rho \hat{o}^\dagger \hat{o})/2 $ ] denotes the lindblad superoperator .
we have introduced the decay rate @xmath11 for the cavity , and population relaxation rates for the spin components @xmath12 ( for decay and pumping respectively ) and dephasing rate @xmath13 . in general , for all but smallest values of @xmath0 , exact analytic solutions to eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) are intractable , and it is necessary to resort to numerical simulation approaches such as the quantum trajectory method @xcite .
even so , treating more than about ten spins is difficult due to the exponentially increasing dimensionality of the underlying hilbert space ( scaling as @xmath14 ) .
it should be emphasized that the reduced basis of fully - symmetrical dicke states do not suffice to solve the quantum master equation even though the lindblad operator treats the spin - components symmetrically .
as will be shown below , all state vectors with mixed symmetry are in principle required .
recently , it was pointed out that this is not true in liouville space since the lindblad operators are invariant under _
su_(4 ) transformations @xcite .
this observation allows one to express all of the lindblad operators in terms of generators of the _
su_(4 ) group . for this purpose , 18 superoperators @xmath15 , @xmath16 and @xmath17 where
@xmath18 are defined and can be shown to be linear combinations of the 15 gell - mann matrices of the _
su_(4 ) lie algebra ( see supplementary material ) . as a consequence , it is possible to construct a reduced basis for the density operator using a multiplet of the _
su_(4 ) group . transcribing notation from the four - flavor quark model
a model that has the same symmetry structure the fundamental representation is given by @xmath19 , @xmath20 , @xmath21 , and @xmath22 ( up , down , strange , and charm ) . since the symmetry type of the basis is preserved under the action of the _
su_(4 ) generators , this leads to a tremendous reduction of the number of required basis states needed to provide an exact solution of the master equation .
for the fully symmetric case , the basis is : @xmath23 where @xmath24 denotes the symmetrizer and @xmath25 .
note that only basis states with @xmath26 have non - vanishing trace .
the three quantum numbers @xmath27 and @xmath28 have ranges @xmath29 , @xmath30 and @xmath31 , resulting in the dimensionality of the basis @xmath32 , _
i.e. _ of order @xmath33 . this tremendous reduction should be compared with the case in which one does not take advantage of the accessible subspace and instead uses the full dimensionality of the liouville space given by @xmath34 .
note that all the superoperators commute with three associated casimir operators ( analagous to the @xmath35 total spin operator for _
su_(2 ) ) , and this makes it possible to uniquely label the symmetry of the invariant subspace of liouville space in terms of the casimir eigenvalues . in this paper
, we apply the _
su_(4 ) group theory to find exact solutions to the quantum master equation in general form .
we show how to calculate the various basic observables of interest .
we demonstrate that the density matrix in the _
su_(4 ) basis representation can be precisely mapped to the collective spin - angular - momentum representation @xmath36 in hilbert space , which enables us to efficiently diagonalize the density matrix .
this allows us to provide complete information about the system , including functional properties of the density operator such as the purity and von neumann entropy . in order to solve eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) , we expand the density matrix as @xmath37 where @xmath38 are complex coefficients , and @xmath39 is the photon fock state .
the lindblad operators can be written compactly : @xmath40&=&-\frac{n}{2}\pm \mathcal{q}_3+\mathcal{q}_{\pm}\,,\nonumber\\ \sum_{j=1}^n\mathcal{d}[\sigma_j^{(3)}]&=&4\mathcal{m}_3 - 2 \mathcal{q}_3 - 2\sigma_3-n\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the completeness of @xmath41 and @xmath4 implies that an arbitrary hamiltonian can be expressed by them , _
e.g. _ from eq .
( [ eq : hamiltonian ] ) , @xmath42&=&-2i\delta\sigma_3\rho - i\omega \left[a(\mathcal{m}_++\mathcal{n}_+)\rho+a^\dagger ( \mathcal{m}_-+\mathcal{n}_-)\rho\right]\nonumber\\ & & \quad{}+i\omega\left[(\mathcal{u}_++\mathcal{v}_+)\rho a^\dagger + ( \mathcal{u}_-+\mathcal{v}_-)\rho a\right]\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] combining eqs .
( [ liv ] ) and ( [ ham ] ) with the action rules of the _ su_(4 ) and photon operators on the basis states ( see supplementary material ) gives a closed solution of eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) . in general , this can be solved analytically or numerically with standard methods .
having established the procedure for determining the time evolution of @xmath8 , it is now important to describe how to calculate physical observables .
we begin with the trace of the density operator , which is given by @xmath43=\sum_{m , q3}c_{n/2,q3,0}^{m , m}=1\ , , \label{eq : trace}\ ] ] which is an invariant during evolution to represent probability conservation .
average values @xmath44 and @xmath45 are found analogously .
for the spin - operators , we provide the following examples up to quadratic order : @xmath46/n,\\ & \langle\sigma_j^{(3)}\sigma_k^{(3)}\rangle=(4\mathrm{tr } [ ( \mathcal{q}_3 ^ 2-\sigma_3 ^ 2)\rho]-n)/[n(n-1)],\\ & \langle\sigma_j^{\pm}\rangle=\mathrm{tr}[(\mathcal{m}_{\pm } + \mathcal{n}_{\pm})\rho]/n,\\ & \langle\sigma_j^+\sigma_k^-\rangle=\mathrm{tr } [ \mathcal{v}_-(\mathcal{m}_-+\mathcal{n}_-)\rho- \mathcal{q}_-\rho]/[n(n-1 ) ] , \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath47 .
we do not provide @xmath48 quantities since they follow easily from the basic algebra of the pauli spin - operators . for coherence properties it is necessary to calculate products of operators evaluated at different times . of particular interest
are the first - order and second - order correlations , which can be found by applying the quantum regression theorem : @xmath49\right ] , \nonumber\\ \hspace*{-1pc } \langle\hat{o}_1(t)\hat{o}_1(t\!+\!\tau)\hat{o}_2(t\!+\!\tau ) \hat{o}_2(t)\rangle & = & \mathrm{tr}\left[\hat{o}_2e^{\mathcal{l}\tau } [ \hat{o}_2\rho(t)\hat{o}_1]\hat{o}_1\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath50 $ ] is the time propagation from eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) starting with the initial density matrix @xmath8 .
for example , in order to obtain the first - order correlation of @xmath51 and @xmath52 , one takes @xmath53 as an initial condition , time evolves it for @xmath54 according to eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) , applies @xmath51 , and computes the trace .
a similar procedure follows for the second - order correlation . in this way ,
field quantities , @xmath55 and @xmath56 are directly calculated . for spin - coherence , the required expressions are : @xmath57\right],\nonumber\\ & & \sum_{j , j',k , k'=1}^{n}\langle \sigma_j^+(t)\sigma_{j'}^+ ( t+\tau)\sigma_k^-(t+\tau)\sigma_{k'}^-(t)\rangle=\nonumber\\ & & \qquad\mathrm{tr}\left[\mathcal{v}_-(\mathcal{m}_-+\mathcal{n}_- ) e^{\mathcal{l}\tau}[\mathcal{v}_-(\mathcal{m}_-+\mathcal{n}_-)\rho]\right]\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] although at this point we have provided a theoretical framework that is complete and provides exact and efficient solutions to the general quantum master equation , it is often inconvenient to work in the @xmath58 representation of the density operator .
for example , it can be a nontrivial procedure to characterize the many - body spin - state in this representation by quantifying the degree of entanglement , which is derived from a functional ( _ i.e. _ @xmath59 $ ] ) .
for this reason , we illustrate now the procedure for efficiently projecting the density operator from the _
su_(4 ) basis representation onto the usual representation of density matrices formed from the hilbert space basis vectors .
these hilbert space basis vectors are specified by the angular momentum eigenket @xmath36 , where @xmath60 is the total spin and @xmath61 is the spin - projection .
note that @xmath62 also labels the symmetry of the states , e.g. @xmath63 corresponds to the fully symmetrical dicke states . in order to illustrate how this projection is done ,
it is instructive for us to first examine explicitly the @xmath64 case where the hilbert space is 4 dimensional .
two spins form a symmetric triplet state and an antisymmetric singlet state , corresponding to total spin @xmath65 and @xmath66 respectively . in this case , the complete density matrix from eq .
( [ ex ] ) for given @xmath67 is @xmath68 notice that the resulting matrix is block diagonal in the @xmath65 and @xmath66 subspaces ( a @xmath69 block and a @xmath70 block ) .
in addition , the complex coefficients contributing to the matrix element for @xmath71 all satisfy @xmath72 and @xmath73 . finally , the trace is simply @xmath74 .
these results can be systematically extended to higher @xmath0 . for any @xmath0 ,
the density matrix is block diagonal in @xmath62 , with each block given by @xmath75 where @xmath76 are density matrix elements for the symmetry type @xmath62 .
there are @xmath77 ways for @xmath0 spins to construct the basis for each @xmath62 , so that @xmath78 , _
i.e. _ the hilbert space dimension . to find @xmath77 , we note that @xmath36 forms a basis of the @xmath79-dimensional irreducible representation of the _
su_(2 ) group .
determining @xmath77 is accomplished with the help of the young tableau of the _
su_(2 ) group , where one can obtain the number of equivalent representations iteratively .
fig .
[ fig1](a ) shows the young tableau for the @xmath80 case . a corresponding tabular method for evaluating @xmath77 for any @xmath0
is shown in fig .
[ fig1](b ) , which contains about one half of the well - known pascal s triangle .
( a ) young tableau for determining the irreducible representations contained in the direct product representation of the _
su_(2 ) group for @xmath80 .
the dimension for @xmath81 is @xmath82 respectively , and @xmath83 , so the total hilbert space dimension is @xmath84 as expected .
( b )
pascal s triangle " to evaluate @xmath77 in an iterative way for any @xmath0 ( the case considered in ( a ) is the fourth row down from the top ) .
( c ) pyramid representation of the density operator in the @xmath36 representation for @xmath80 .
each layer of the pyramid represents the block matrix for each @xmath62 . ] with this in mind , one can now derive a systematic algorithm for obtaining density matrix elements @xmath85 given _
su_(4 ) expansion coefficients @xmath38 . the procedure is outlined as follows . for each layer of the pyramid [ cf .
fig .
[ fig1](c ) ] , one may start with a corner element ( @xmath86 and @xmath87 maximal ) and fill out the matrix by successive application of the angular momentum lowering operator @xmath88 ( noting that @xmath89 ) to recursively fill out each row , and @xmath90 ( or hermiticity of @xmath8 ) to fill out each column .
the layers are filled upwards from the base , starting with @xmath91 as the corner element of the lowest layer , and finding the corner element of higher layers by gaussian elimination from the trace constraint eq .
( [ eq : trace ] ) . in the supplementary materials ,
we demonstrate explicit application to 3 atoms , with extrapolation to higher @xmath0 straightforward .
being able to express the density operator in the @xmath36 representation makes easy the calculation of functionals , such as the purity @xmath92 $ ] , or the von neumann entropy @xmath93 where @xmath94 are eigenvalues of @xmath8 .
the point is that , because the density matrix is block diagonal in the @xmath36 representation , we do not need to diagonalize the whole density matrix , which would be a daunting task .
instead , we only need to diagonalize a series of @xmath95 blocks of dimension @xmath96 . in the following ,
we demonstrate the method by solving many - atom open quantum systems such as lasing and steady state superradiance .
we show the capability for finding exact solutions of large systems and are able to obtain full information about both the transient and steady - state density matrix .
first , let us consider a single - mode laser consisting of an ensemble of two - level atoms coupled to an optical cavity , which can be modeled by the general quantum master equation eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) @xcite . in this model
@xmath3 is the atom - cavity coupling , @xmath11 is the laser output coupling loss , @xmath97 is the incoherent laser pumping , and @xmath98 is the atom decay rate ( we will ignore @xmath99 dephasing in this example for simplicity ) .
the laser system is difficult to solve without approximation since it involves both many atoms and large numbers of photons when above threshold .
therefore , it constitutes an interesting test - case to illustrate the capability of the _
su_(4 ) approach . [ cols="^,^ " , ] fig .
[ fig3](a ) shows the average intracavity photon number of the laser as a function of the repumping rate , where the threshold is evident .
this result confirms the conventional laser theory prediction @xcite .
interestingly , the spin - spin correlation @xmath100 above the threshold is directly proportional to the photon number , which shows that the collective photon emission plays an essential role for the laser . in fig .
[ fig3](b ) , we show that the photon statistics of the laser changes from thermal below threshold to poisson above threshold . in fig .
[ fig3](c ) , we demonstrate that the laser linewidth narrows considerably as one goes above threshold . finally , in fig .
[ fig3](d ) , the laser threshold behavior is characterized by the intensity correlation @xmath101 and the entropy of the whole system .
it can be seen that @xmath101 jumps from two below threshold to one above threshold with the entropy increasing and saturating .
it is remarkable to have an exact solution to this fundamental system that rigorously confirms the standard laser theory results .
those results are based on various kinds of analytic approximations necessary to make the problem tractable .
( color online ) .
comparison of the second order intensity correlation @xmath102 as a function of the repump rate in the steady state superradiance .
the green symbols show the monte carlo results including the statistical errors for @xmath103 atoms from ref .
@xcite .
the red dots show the present calculation using the _
su_(4 ) theory . and the blue solid line shows the semiclassical results from ref .
@xcite .
inset : atom statistics for @xmath104 .
the length of the bars represents populations of the @xmath36 states .
] as a second example , we apply our approach to steady - state superradiance as previously proposed @xcite and demonstrated in a recent experiment @xcite .
the steady - state superradiance represents a novel regime of cavity quantum electrodynamics , where the highly coherent collective atomic dipole induces an extremely narrow linewidth for the generated light .
the bad - cavity mode only plays a role as the source of collective coupling for the atoms and the definition of the spatial mode for the output light @xcite .
the behavior of this system is also described by a master equation eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) , but in a completely different parameter regime to the conventional laser . for steady - state superradiance ,
the vacuum rabi splitting is much less than the cavity linewidth , @xmath105 and equivalently the photon number per atom in the cavity is much less than unity .
we present here calculations of the second order intensity correlation @xmath101 in steady - state as a function of the repump rate . as shown in fig .
[ fig4](a ) , the agreement of the present calculation and the quantum monte carlo result from ref .
@xcite is within error bars .
the quantum monte carlo simulations were of course significantly more numerically intensive . in the weak pumping limit ,
the light exhibits strongly super - poissonian fluctuations and deviates remarkably from the semiclassical prediction ( blue line in fig .
[ fig4](a ) ) .
the failure of the semiclassical prediction in the weak pumping limit indicates that the atoms are in a highly - correlated state . to reveal the atomic states in this case , we apply the techniques of projecting the density operator in the @xmath58 representation onto the @xmath36 representation and obtain the populations of the atoms on @xmath36 states .
the inset of fig .
[ fig4 ] shows explicitly that the atoms are mainly pumped into long - lived collective subradiant states @xcite @xmath106 and @xmath107 . from @xmath106 ,
the atoms can only be repumped to @xmath108 , from which they rapidly emit two photons and relax to @xmath107 . therefore
, our methods enable us to extract detailed information about the atomic states and has been essential to reveal the underlying quantum dynamics . in conclusion ,
we have formulated and applied a _
su_(4 ) theory to numerically solve the quantum master equation , which has reduced the exponential scaling of the problem to cubic in @xmath0 .
we have developed powerful methods to transform the density operator in the _
su_(4 ) basis representation to the @xmath36 representation .
this has enabled us to efficiently diagonalize the whole density matrix and thus provided complete information about the system , including state information and functional properties of the density operator .
we have included lasing and steady - state superradiance as examples in order to illustrate the potential for this method .
the method described here will find numerous applications for simulating open quantum systems with large system size .
we acknowledge stimulating discussions with j. cooper and d. meiser . this work has been supported by the darpa quasar program and the nsf .
99 g. lindblad , commun .
math .
phys . * 48 * , 119 ( 1976 ) . c. w. gardiner and p. zoller , `` quantum noise '' , springer , berlin ( 2004 ) .
j. carmichael , `` statistical methods in quantum optics 1 '' , springer - verlag ( 1998 ) .
h. uys , m. j. biercuk , a. p. vandevender , c. ospelkaus , d. meiser , r. ozeri , and j. j. bollinger , phys .
rev .
lett . * 105 * , 200401 ( 2010 ) .
a. blais , j. gambetta , a. wallraff , d. i. schuster , s. m. girvin , m. h. devoret , and r. j. schoelkopf , phys .
rev .
a * 75 * , 032329 ( 2007 ) .
j. d. teufel _ et .
al . _
nature * 475 * , 359 ( 2011 ) .
m. b. plenio and p. l. knight , rev .
mod .
phys .
* 70 * , 101 ( 1998 ) .
s. hartmann , arxiv:1201.1732v1 .
d. meiser , j. ye , d. r. carlson , and m. j. holland , phys .
rev .
lett . *
102 * , 163601 ( 2009 ) .
j. g. bohnet , z. chen , j. m. weiner , d. meiser , m. j. holland , and j. k. thompson , nature * 484 * , 78 ( 2012 ) .
d. meiser and m. j. holland , phys .
rev .
a * 81 * , 063827 ( 2010 ) .
r. h. dicke , phys . rev . * 93 * , 99 ( 1954 ) .
* supplementary material for + simulating open quantum systems using the simple lie group _
su_(4 ) * |
the network ( or graph ) is a useful way of expressing and investigating quantitatively the characteristics of complex systems in various disciplines .
it consists of a set of vertices representing entities , and edges associated with connections between vertices @xcite .
numerous complex systems can be and have been expressed in terms of networks , and they are often classified by the research field , such as social @xcite , technological @xcite , and biological networks @xcite , to name just a few .
early researches on the network focused mainly on the regular and the random networks from which many mathematical results for general structural characteristics have been extracted @xcite .
recently , due to the availability of computers and the internet , study on large - scale statistical properties of complex networks has been possible .
it was found that many complex networks had distinctive features in common , such as the power - law distribution of the degree and the clique of the network , resulting in the scale - free @xcite and the small world networks @xcite .
these uncovered characteristics , which differ from those of the regular and random networks , was the trigger that brought about considerable advances in the understanding of complex networks , including the development of numerous analysis tools and devising more accurate topological models for the observed networks @xcite .
more recently , the research on complex networks drifts also toward the community structure of the networks .
it has been shown that various complex networks can be organized in terms of the community structure ( or modularity ) , in which groups of vertices that are highly interconnected have looser connections between them .
the analysis of these structures has been a topic of intensive investigation in conjunction with many practical relevance , such as finding functional modules in biological networks @xcite and identifying communities in the web in order to construct , for instance , an efficient search engine @xcite .
various attempts have been made to find or identify community structures in complex networks @xcite .
examples include the hierarchical clustering @xcite ; methods based on the edge betweenness @xcite , the edge - clustering via the degree @xcite , the information centrality @xcite , and the eigenvector centrality @xcite ; the information - theoretic approach via the degree @xcite .
these methods are directly or indirectly related to the centrality measures . considering that resulting community structure depends on the choice of measures ( including the centrality measures ) adopted in various schemes
, it would be interesting to investigate any relation among the centrality measures .
the centrality ( or sociometric status ) has been studied particularly in the social science from the perspective of the social connectivity .
it is an incarnations of a concept that describes vertices prominence and/or importance in terms of features of their network environment @xcite .
it addresses an issue of which individuals are best connected to other or have most influence .
this relative importance was quantified by various measures , developed mainly by researchers of the social networks @xcite .
different measures for the centrality have been proposed in the social science . among them , four centrality measures are commonly used in the network analysis : the degree , the closeness , the betweenness , and the eigenvector centrality @xcite . in this paper , we empirically investigate correlations among the centrality measures in complex networks to gain some insight into the potential role of the measures in analyzing complex networks .
we restrict our analysis to undirected networks , since some of centrality measures , such as the eigenvector centrality , can not be defined unambiguously for directed networks .
we analyze the film actor network , the scientific collaboration network , the neural network of _ caenorhabditis elegans _ , the internet of both the autonomous system ( as ) and the router levels , and protein interaction networks .
analyzed organisms for protein interaction networks are _ saccharomyces cerevisiae _ , _ escherichia coli _ , _ caenorhabditis elegans _
, _ drosophila melanogaster _ , _
helicobacter pylori _ , and _ homo sapiens _ @xcite .
the centrality measures are introduced as a way of specifying and quantifying the centrality concept of a vertex in a network .
furthermore , they are often classified according to the extent to which a vertex has influence on the others : the immediate effects , the mediative effects , and the total effects centrality @xcite .
typical examples which belong to each class are : the closeness and degree for the immediate ; the betweenness for the mediative ; the eigenvector for the total effect centrality .
in addition , these measures are argued to be complementary rather than competitive because they stem from the same theoretical foundation @xcite .
although the measures are well known , we restate them here for the completeness with the emphasis on their implications .
the degree centrality is the most basic of all measures which counts how many vertices are involved in an interaction .
it is defined , for a vertex @xmath0 , as the number of edges that the vertex has .
that is , @xmath1 where @xmath2 is the number of vertices in the network , and @xmath3 if vertices @xmath0 and @xmath4 are connected by an edge , @xmath5 otherwise .
it measures the opportunity to receive information flowing through the network with everything else being equal .
the degree is also a prominent quantity whose distribution follows a power - law distribution in scale - free networks @xcite .
the eigenvector centrality can be understood as a refined version of the degree centrality in the sense that it recursively takes into account how neighbor vertices are connected .
that is , the eigenvector centrality @xmath6 of a vertex @xmath0 is proportional to the sum of the eigenvector centrality of the vertices it is connected to .
it is defined as @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the largest eigenvalue to assure the centrality is non - negative .
thus , @xmath6 is the @xmath0th component of the eigenvector associated with the largest eigenvalue @xmath8 of the network .
while the eigenvector centrality of a network can be calculated via the standard method @xcite using the adjacent matrix representation of the network , it can be also computed by an iterative degree calculation , known as the accelerated power method @xcite .
this method is not only more efficient , but consistent with the spirit of the refined version of the degree centrality .
the closeness centrality stems from the notion that the influence of central vertices spreads more rapidly throughout a network than that of peripheral ones .
it is defined , for each vertex @xmath0 , as @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the length of the shortest path ( geodesic ) connecting vertices @xmath0 and @xmath4 .
thus , the closeness is closely associated with the characteristic path length @xcite , the average path length of all paths between all pairs of vertices . the betweenness centrality , or the load @xcite , is a measure of the influence of a vertex over the flow of information between every pair of vertices under the assumption that information primarily flows over the shortest path between them .
it measures the accumulated number of information transmissions that occur through the pass .
the removal of high betweenness vertices sometimes results in disconnecting a network .
the betweenness centrality of a vertex @xmath0 is defined as @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the number of geodesics between @xmath4 and @xmath13 , and @xmath14 is the number of geodesics that pass through @xmath0 among @xmath12 . since @xmath15 is of the order @xmath16 , in this paper , we normalize @xmath15 with its maximum value of @xmath17 so that @xmath18 $ ] for all @xmath0 .
for every network , we compute the four centrality measures so that all four values are assigned to each vertex . the correlation between a pair of different measures
can be estimated by the correlation coefficient @xcite .
more specifically , it is a quantity which measures the linear correlation between vertex - wise pairs of data , @xmath19 , and is given as @xmath20 where @xmath21 and @xmath22 are the mean and standard deviation of the measurements of a centrality measure @xmath23 .
the value of @xmath24 ranges from -1 to 1 : 1 being totally correlated , and -1 being totally anti - correlated .
table i shows correlation coefficients estimated between pairs of data obtained from different centrality measures .
as shown in table i , the degree is strongly correlated with the betweenness and less strongly with the eigenvector centrality ; whereas the closeness is weakly correlated with the other measures .
this implies that the three measures ( the degree , the betweenness , the eigenvector centrality ) are closely inter - related . in general , correlation coefficients estimated from different variables
could be significantly overlapped .
that is , a certain amount of correlation found between any two measures may be tied in with correlations with the third . to take into account this point
, we introduce the partial correlation method @xcite .
the partial correlation is a method that determines the correlation between any two variables under the assumption that each of them is not correlated with the third .
that is , it estimates the correlation between two variables while the third variable is held constant .
formally , the partial correlation between variables @xmath23 and @xmath25 while holding @xmath26 constant is given in terms of the corresponding correlation coefficients as @xmath27 we estimate all possible partial correlations for each correlation coefficient , and results are shown in the parentheses of table i. from table i , we find that the partial correlation between the degree and the betweenness , while holding either the eigenvector or the closeness constant , differs little from the correlation coefficient between them .
this implies that the strong correlation between the degree and the betweenness is solely due to the two measures by themselves , and little affected by other measures .
in contrast , the partial correlation between the betweenness and the eigenvector ( or the betweenness and the closeness ) while holding the degree constant is anti - correlated .
this implies that the positive correlation between the betweenness and the eigenvector ( or the betweenness and the closeness ) is almost entirely due to correlations with the degree .
that is , a _ positive _ correlation between them would change dramatically to a _ negative _ correlation if they were not correlated with the degree centrality .
table i also shows that the correlation between the degree and the eigenvector is affected by the betweenness and closeness . from the correlation analysis
, we uncover that the degree and the betweenness are correlated much strongly than other centrality measures .
this is , in a sense , expected since vertices of a high degree would have better chance to be included in the shortest path along a pair of vertices . to address the correlation between the degree @xmath13 and the betweenness @xmath28
, we relate them , via the bayes theorem , as @xmath29 and focus on the conditional probability distribution @xmath30 of @xmath28 given @xmath13 . to obtain reliable statistics for the conditional distribution
, we choose the film actor network as an example since it is composed of the largest number of vertices ( over 370,000 vertices ) in this study .
figure 1(a ) shows a few conditional probability distributions @xmath30 . as shown in fig .
1(a ) , the conditional distribution approximately follows a power - law form with its exponent @xmath31 depending on @xmath13 , i.e. , @xmath32 the @xmath13-dependent exponent @xmath31 can be estimated from different degrees @xmath13 . as fig .
1(b ) suggests , @xmath31 depends roughly linearly on @xmath13 .
thus , we have @xmath33 where parameters @xmath34 and @xmath35 can be estimated by the least square fit . with eq .
( [ power ] ) and ( [ linear ] ) , the probability distribution @xmath36 of the betweenness @xmath28 can be expressed as @xmath37 under the assumption that @xmath38 does not blow up as @xmath13 increase , the dominant contribution of the summation comes from small values of @xmath13 .
thus , to the first approximation , we find that the betweenness follows a power - law distribution , independent of the degree distribution .
that is , @xmath39 with @xmath40 for the film actor network
. the power - law distribution of the betweenness can also be obtained by the direct estimate of the betweenness distribution .
figure 2 shows betweenness probability distributions of a few networks .
scale - free networks , such as the film actor and the protein interaction network of _
d. melanogaster _ , have a power - law in the distribution of the betweenness which was first found in ref . @xcite . considering that the degree is highly correlated with the betweenness , it is not surprising that the betweenness of scale - free networks follows a power - law distribution . from fig . 2
, we also find that the directly estimated exponent 2.36 for the film actor network is close to the derived exponent of @xmath40
. moreover , fig .
2 shows that the power - law distribution of the betweenness is not restricted to the scale - free network , but held true to other types of networks , such as the collaboration network and the neural network of _
c. elegans_. furthermore , as depicted in fig . 3 ,
the conditional probability distribution of non scale - free networks , for instance , the collaboration network , is also approximately a power - law distribution ; furthermore , the exponent of the distribution is insensitive to the degree @xmath13 .
the power - law of the conditional probability distribution is less clear for networks of small number of vertices .
this is probably due to insufficient number of data to obtain reliable statistics .
we , however , have seen the power - law of the conditional distribution for networks composed of relatively sufficient number of vertices , irrespective of the type of networks . from this
, we may infer that it is the power - law of the conditional probability distribution that is responsible for the power - law nature of the betweenness . for a comparison
, we apply the same analysis as above to the random network .
table ii shows correlation coefficients and partial correlations between measures estimated for the random network .
in contrast to the real networks , every centrality measure is very strongly correlated with every other measures .
this distinctive characteristic , however , changes dramatically once we introduce the partial correlation . from partial correlation estimates
, we find that correlation coefficients between all possible pairs of measures , except that between the degree and the betweenness , contain considerable amount of correlation tied in with the other measures .
similar to the real networks , a strong correlation between the degree and the betweenness is nearly maintained when these measures are assumed not to be correlated with the other measures .
we also examine the conditional probability distribution of the betweenness given the degree . a few conditional distributions
@xmath30 of the betweenness @xmath28 given the degree @xmath13 are depicted in fig .
4 . unlike complex networks ,
the distribution is not a power - law , but approximately a gaussian irrespective of the degree .
since the conditional distribution of the betweenness given the degree does not follow a power - law distribution , we expect that the betweenness distribution of the random network may as well differ from that of real networks . as shown in fig . 5
, it turns out that the betweenness distribution for the random network can be approximated as a log - normal distribution , @xmath41 where @xmath42 and @xmath43 are the scale and the shape parameters of the distribution , respectively .
in this paper , in order to investigate correlations among the measures , we applied four centrality measures ( the degree , the closeness , the betweenness , and the eigenvector centrality ) to various types of complex networks as well as the random network .
we found that the degree was strongly correlated with the betweenness , and the correlation was robust in the sense that the extent of correlation was little affected by the presence of the other measures .
this finding was confirmed by estimating the partial correlation between the degree and the betweenness , while holding either the eigenvector or the closeness constant .
based on the strong correlation existed between the two measures , we further uncovered the characteristics of the betweenness .
not only for scale - free networks but for other types of networks , the conditional distribution of the betweenness given the degree was approximately a power - law which , in turn , played a predominant role in understanding the power - law distribution of the betweenness .
this feature was distinct from the random networks in which the conditional distribution was roughly a gaussian . within complex networks ,
the scale - free network by itself implies the existence of a hierarchy with respect to the degree centrality @xcite .
similarly , the power - law distribution of the betweenness may suggest a new potential role of the betweenness in quantifying the hierarchy in conjunction with the community structure @xcite .
therefore , it may provide us with feasibility to use the betweenness and/or related quantities as a measure for constructing hierarchical and community structures of complex networks .
we like to thank m. newman for providing us with the scientific collaboration network data .
we also appreciate the open sources of various complex network data available at many urls .
this work was supported by the korea research foundation grant funded by the korean government ( moehrd ) ( krf-2005 - 041-h00052 ) .
99 for a review of the network theory , see , for example , m. newman , siam review * 45 * 167 ( 2003 ) ; r. albert and a .-
barab ' asi , rev .
phys . * 74 * , 47 ( 2002 ) ; s. dorogovtsev and j. mendes , adv . phys . * 51 * , 1079 ( 2002 ) . l. amaral , a. scala , m. barthelemy , and h. e. stanley , proc . natl .
usa * 97 * , 11149 ( 2000 ) .
m. newman , proc .
usa * 98 * , 404 ( 2001 ) .
m. faloutsos , p. faloutsos , and c. faloutsos , comput .
commun . rev .
* 29 * , 251 ( 1999 ) .
r. albert , h. jeong , and a .-
barab ' asi , nature ( london ) * 401 * , 130 ( 1999 ) .
n. guelzim , s. bottani , p. bourgine , and f. kepes , nature genetics * 31 * , 60 ( 2002 ) .
h. jeong , b. tombor , r. albert , z. litvai , and a .-
barab ' asi , nature ( london ) * 407 * , 651 ( 2000 ) .
p. erds and a. r ' enyi , pulb .
inst . hung .
sci . * 5 * , 17 ( 1960 ) ; b. bollob ' as , _ random graphs _
( academic press , london , 1985 ) .
barab ' asi and r. albert , science * 286 * , 509 ( 1999 ) .
d. watts and s. strogatz , nature ( london ) * 393 * , 440 ( 1998 ) .
e. ravasz and a .-
barab ' asi , phys .
e * 67 * , 026112 ( 2003 ) .
a. rives and t. galitski , proc .
usa * 100 * , 1128 ( 2003 ) .
g. flake , s. lawrence , c. giles , and f. coetzee , ieee computers * 35 * , 66 ( 2002 ) . for a review of the community structure and methods for finding it , see , for example , m.e.j .
newman , eur .
j. b * 38 * , 321 ( 2004 ) .
j. scott , _ social network analysis : a handbook _
( sage , london , 2000 ) , 2nd ed . ; s. wasserman and k. faust , _ social network analysis _ ( cambridge univ . press ,
cambridge , u.k .
m. girvan and m. e. j. newman , proc .
usa , * 99 * , 7821 ( 2002 ) .
j. tyler , d. wilkinson , and b. huberman , in _ proceedings of the first international conference on communities and technologies _ , edited by m. huysman , e. wenger , and v. wulf ( kluwer , dordrecht , 2003 ) .
f. radicchi , c. castellano , f. cecconi , v. loreto , and d. parisi , proc .
usa * 101 * , 2658 ( 2004 ) .
a. clauset , m.e.j .
newman , and c. moore , phys .
e * 70 * , 066111 ( 2004 ) .
h. yang , f. zhao , w. wang , t. zhou , and b. wang , e - print cond - mat/0508026 .
e. ziv , m. middendorf , and c. wiggins , phys .
e * 71 * , 046117 ( 2005 ) .
n. friedkin , am .
j. sociol . ,
* 96 * , 1478 ( 1991 ) .
l. c. freeman , soc .
* 1 * , 215 ( 1979 ) .
p. bonacich , j. math .
* 2 * , 113 ( 1972 ) .
the sources of network data are the following .
the film actors was obtained from http://www.nd.edu/~networks/ ; the scientific collaboration data was provided by m. neuman ; the internet of autonomous systems level was obtained from http://moat.nlanr.net/routing/rawdata/ ; the internet of router level is collected by the mercator and is available at http://www.isi.edu/scan/mercator/ ; protein interaction networks data are available at http://dip.doe-mbi.ucla.edu ; the somatic nervous system of _ nematode c. elegans _ was obtained from http://ims.dse.ibaraki.ac.jp / research/. w. press , s. teukolsky , w. vetterling , and b. flannery , _ numerical recipes : the art of scientific computing _ , ( cambridge univ .
press , cambridge , 2002 ) , chap .
h. hotelling , psychometrika * 1 * , 27 ( 1936 ) .
goh , b. kahng , and d. kim , phys . rev
. lett . * 87 * , 278701 ( 2001 ) .
see , for example , l. chao , _ statistics : methods and analyses _ ( mcgraw - hill , new york , 1969 ) .
j. johnston and j. dinardo , _ econometric methods _ , ( mcgraw - hill , irwin , 1984 ) , 3rd ed .
e. ravasz , a. l. somera , d. a. mongru , z. n. oltvai , and a .-
barab ' asi , science * 297 * , 1551 ( 2002 ) . of the betweenness @xmath28
given the degree @xmath13 in the film actor network : @xmath44 ( @xmath45 ) , @xmath46 ( @xmath47 ) , and @xmath48 ( @xmath49 ) .
the least - square fits ( dotted lines ) on the slope of @xmath44 , @xmath46 , and @xmath48 yield @xmath50 , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 , respectively .
plots for @xmath46 and 10 are shifted to the left for the display purpose .
( b ) ( inset ) the plot of the exponent @xmath31 in eq .
( [ power ] ) versus the degree @xmath13 . estimated values from the least square fit for eq .
( [ linear ] ) are @xmath53 and @xmath54 .
the errors associated with the fit are statistical uncertainties based on fitting a straight line . ] ) , the collaboration network ( @xmath47 ) , the protein interaction network of _ d. melanogaster _ ( @xmath49 ) , and the neural network of _ c. elegans _ ( @xmath55 ) .
estimated exponents ( dotted lines ) , by least square fits on slopes , are @xmath56 , @xmath57 , @xmath58 , and @xmath59 , respectively .
plots , except for the film actor network , are shifted horizontally for the display purpose . ] of the betweenness @xmath28 given degree @xmath13 of the scientific collaboration network : @xmath60 ( @xmath61 ) , @xmath62 ( @xmath63 ) , and @xmath64 ( @xmath65 ) .
the least - square fits ( dotted lines ) on the slope of the @xmath60 , @xmath62 , and @xmath64 yield @xmath66 , @xmath67 , and @xmath68 , respectively .
plots for @xmath62 and 9 are shifted to the left for the display purpose . ] of the betweenness @xmath28 given the degree @xmath13 : @xmath69 ( @xmath45 ) , @xmath48 ( @xmath47 ) , @xmath70 ( @xmath61 ) , and @xmath71 ( @xmath63 ) for the random network of 3000 vertices and the average degree @xmath72 .
each distribution of different @xmath13 is normalized such that @xmath73 , where @xmath74 and @xmath75 are the mean and standard deviation of @xmath28 . by the normalization , all distributions collapse to the standard gaussian distribution ( solid line ) . ] , together with the corresponding log - normal fit ( solid line ) .
the scale and shape parameters of the log - normal fit are estimated using the maximum likelihood estimate from the data . estimated the scale and shape parameters are @xmath76 and @xmath77 , respectively . ] | in this paper , we empirically investigate correlations among four centrality measures , originated from the social science , of various complex networks . for each network
, we compute the centrality measures , from which the partial correlation as well as the correlation coefficient among measures is estimated .
we uncover that the degree and the betweenness centrality are highly correlated ; furthermore , the betweenness follows a power - law distribution irrespective of the type of networks .
this characteristic is further examined in terms of the conditional probability distribution of the betweenness , given the degree .
the conditional distribution also exhibits a power - law behavior independent of the degree which explains partially , if not whole , the origin of the power - law distribution of the betweenness .
a similar analysis on the random network reveals that these characteristics are not found in the random network . |
brane - world scenarios introduced by arkani - hamed , dimopoulos and dvali add and randall and sundrum ( rs ) @xcite are motivated by string theory , where open strings end on branes . in the generalized rs scenario our 4-dimensional friedmann - lematre - robertson - walker ( flrw ) universe is a hypersurface of codimension one ( the brane ) embedded into a 5-dimensional charged vaidya - anti de sitter or reissner - nordstrm - anti de sitter space - time ( the bulk ) .
the radiation in the bulk , the charge and mass of the central bulk black hole can be switched off independently ( for a detailed discussion see @xcite ) , however the bulk will always have a negative cosmological constant , which balances the brane tension in such a way that the 4-dimensional ( 4d ) cosmological constant can be fine - tuned .
branes with various other symmetries were also examined , like the einstein brane einbrane , a kantowski - sachs type brane @xcite and the gdel brane @xcite .
all these cases bear in common unusual properties or exotic matter .
there were also various attemps to find black hole solutions on the brane ( for a recent review see @xcite ) .
for example in @xcite the charge term of the 4d reissner - nordstrm black hole solution was interpreted as arising from a tidal charge of the bulk weyl tensor ( and having arbitrary sign ) , rather than from electric charge .
the bulk containing this black hole however remains unknown .
gravitational lensing @xcite and galactic rotation curves @xcite were also studied in brane - world models .
black holes are not isolated objects . in any realistic model
they should be embedded in cosmological background .
the simplest _ general relativistic _
cosmological scenario admitting local inhomogeneities is the einstein - straus swiss - cheese model @xcite , in which schwarzschild black holes and surrounding vacuum regions are immersed into a flrw background .
this model was employed to show that cosmic expansion has no influence on planetary orbits and also to give corrections to the luminosity - redshift relation @xcite .
the einstein - straus model however is unstable against perturbations .
( it is also unsuitable for other type of symmetry then spherical , like cylindrical @xcite or axial @xcite . ) a more realistic model suitable for encompassing ( spherically symmetric ) inhomogeneities would be the mcvittie solution @xcite , which allows for both the flrw and the schwarzschild limits . according to this model
, the cosmic expansion drives the planetary orbits into an outward spiraling and galactic clusters into expansion , which however happen more slowly than the expansion of the cosmic background and consequently these effects are undetectable .
an excellent review of these topics can be found in the book of krasiski @xcite .
recently , the mcvittie solution was generalized both to arbitrary dimensions @xcite and to include charge in 4d @xcite .
such cosmological models with local inhomogeneities were not studied before in the context of the generalized rs scenario .
it is the aim of this paper to study the simplest such model , the swiss - cheese on the brane .
the difficulty in such an approach is threefold .
first , one has to join ( according to the lanczos - sen - darmois - israel junction conditions lanczos-@xcite ) black hole solutions with the cosmological background on the brane , both being solutions of a _ modified _
einstein equation @xcite , such that there is no distributional matter on the junction surface ( fig .
[ fig1 ] ) .
second , one has to extend somehow these black hole solutions into the bulk , which is far from trivial .
indeed , the simplest 4d schwarzschild solution could be embedded in the bulk only by extending the singularity into the fifth dimension @xcite , obtaining a _ black string_. in order to obtain a schwarzschild brane black hole with regular ads horizon , exotic matter has to be introduced in the bulk @xcite .
if the horizon is not compactified through the fifth dimension , gravitons from the black hole will escape into the fifth dimension even if there is an event horizon surrounding the hole on the brane .
the third task is to interpret _ geometrically _ such an inhomogeneous brane as a junction hypersurface .
obviously , for different matter content @xmath0 in the voids and outside them ( where @xmath1 is the brane tension , @xmath2 the brane metric and @xmath3 represents the energy - momentum tensor of ordinary matter on the brane ) , the lanczos equation @xmath4(with @xmath5 for @xmath6-symmetric embedding ) gives rise to different extrinsic curvatures @xmath7 for the voids and for the rest of the brane .
although the embedding ( given by the 1-form @xmath8 , the brane being at @xmath9 ) and the extrinsic curvature @xmath10 are closely interrelated , the latter also depends on the bulk metric @xmath11 and the associated connection @xmath12 . some of the difference in @xmath13 at voids and expanding background can be explained by the difference in @xmath14 due to how near or far the voids are , however the rest should be interpreted as humps and bumps in the brane embedding ( fig .
[ fig2 ] ) .
-0.5 cm in the simplest swiss - cheese model on the brane we will see that fulfilling the first task is restrictive enough to make the second and third ones redundant .
we suppose the bulk contains nothing but a cosmological constant and its weyl curvature is such that it has no electric part .
the embedding is @xmath6-symmetric . under these assumptions
the modified einstein equation is @xmath15where @xmath16 denotes a quadratic expression in @xmath17 : @xmath18the brane gravitational constant @xmath19 and the brane cosmological constant @xmath20 are related to the bulk gravitational constant @xmath21 , bulk cosmological constant @xmath22 and the ( positive ) brane tension @xmath1 through @xmath23 the brane is a 4-dimensional flrw space - time ( characterized by scale factor @xmath24 ) .
it contains perfect fluid ( characterized by energy density @xmath25 and pressure @xmath26 , both depending only on cosmological time @xmath27 ) .
the inhomogeneities on the brane are introduced as nonintersecting schwarzschild voids with arbitrary radii .
let us study the junction of one of these voids to the rest of the brane .
the interior solution in curvature coordinates @xmath28 is@xmath29this is a pure vacuum solution ( with @xmath30 ) of the modified einstein equation ( [ mode ] ) in the void regions .
the exterior solution in comoving coordinates is@xmath31 \
, \label{flrw } \\
\mathcal{h}(\chi ; k)=\left\ { \begin{array}{cc } \sin \ \chi \ & , \qquad k=1\ , , \\
\chi & , \qquad k=0\ , , \\
\sinh \ \chi & \ , \qquad k=-1\,.% \end{array}% \right .
\notag\end{gathered}\]]here the function @xmath32 has the properties:@xmath33the modified einstein equations ( [ mode ] ) reduce to a generalized friedmann and a generalized raychaudhuri equation:@xmath34 \ .
\label{raych}\end{gathered}\]]we have kept the cosmological constant in the exterior region for later convenience . in the limit @xmath35
the corresponding general relativistic equations are recovered .
we have identified the angular coordinates @xmath36 and @xmath37 in the two regions , as in principle the comoving coordinate systems can be centered on any chosen schwarzschild hole .
the junction conditions require the continuity of both the first and second fundamental forms ( induced metric and extrinsic curvature ) of the junction hypersurface . in the swiss - cheese model
the junction is made at some constant comoving @xmath38 .
therefore it is obvious to introduce @xmath39 as coordinates on the junction hypersurface .
the induced metrics in the two regions become : @xmath40 d\tau ^{2 } \notag \\ & & + r_{0}^{2}\left ( d\theta ^{2}+\sin ^{2}\theta d\varphi ^{2}\right ) \ , \\ ds_{ext}^{2 } & = & -d\tau ^{2}+a^{2}\left ( \tau \right ) \left [ \mathcal{h}% _ { 0}^{2}\left ( d\theta ^{2}+\sin ^{2}\theta d\varphi ^{2}\right ) \right ] \ , \end{aligned}\]]where @xmath41 and @xmath42 .
continuity of the induced metric implies@xmath43these equations characterize the motion of the boundary region of the schwarzschild void and formally they are the same as in the einstein - straus model .
however due to the modified cosmological evolution eqs .
( [ fried])-([raych ] ) , _ the motion of the boundary is changed _ accordingly .
-1 cm the extrinsic curvature of the junction hypersurface evaluated from the exterior region has only two nonvanishing components:@xmath44(we have employed eq .
( [ p1 ] ) in the derivation ) .
the corresponding extrinsic curvature components evaluated from the interior region are : @xmath45from continuity of these components , by employing eq .
( [ c1 ] ) we obtain a simple equation for @xmath46 @xmath47comparison of eqs .
( [ c2 ] ) and ( [ c3orig ] ) gives@xmath48finally the condition @xmath49 implies@xmath50after simplifying by @xmath51 , which is a nonvanishing constant . as the evolution of the scale factor
is known ( eqs .
( [ fried ] ) and ( [ raych ] ) ) , we can express both the central mass and the pressure in terms of the energy density:@xmath52 \frac{a^{3}\left ( \tau \right ) \mathcal{h}_{0}^{3}}{6}\ , \label{m } \\
p\left ( \tau \right ) & = & \frac{\lambda } { \kappa ^{2}\left ( 1+\frac{\rho \left ( \tau \right ) } { \lambda } \right ) } -\frac{\rho \left ( \tau \right ) ^{2}% } { 2\left [ \rho \left ( \tau \right ) + \lambda \right ] } \ .
\label{pp}\end{aligned}\]]due to cosmological symmetries , these equations derived on the boundary are valid everywhere in the flrw brane .
therefore eq .
( [ m ] ) can be also regarded as a relation between the mass and the comoving radius of the schwarzschild void .
there are two major differences in comparison to the general relativistic model .
the first is , that the cosmological perfect fluid is _ not _ dust . in the general relativistic limit @xmath53 . if the cosmological constant is chosen to vanish , similarly as in the interior region , the fluid is dust .
by contrast , in the brane - world scenario the nonlinear source term of eq .
( [ mode ] ) implies a @xmath54-dependent pressure ( or tension ) .
this agrees with the general relativistic limit in the low density regime ( @xmath55 ) , however differs considerably in the high energy limit ( @xmath56 ) , where @xmath57 .
while in this later limit the classical condition for dark energy @xmath58 is obeyed , still the perfect fluid with equation of state ( pp ) can not drive inflation .
indeed , the cosmic acceleration is given by the _ modified _ raychaudhuri equation ( [ raych ] ) , which becomes:@xmath59giving deceleration for any positive @xmath20 .
the second crucial difference is the evolution of the fluid energy density , which differs from the general relativistic case . to see this
, we integrate the continuity equation : @xmath60(which is an integrability condition of the system of eqs .
( [ fried])-([raych ] ) ) . after employing eq .
( [ pp ] ) we obtain by integration @xmath61 ^{-1}\ , \label{rhoaa}\]]with @xmath62 an integration constant .
( [ m ] ) gives then the mass of the black holes @xmath63 in the voids of the einstein - straus type swiss - cheese branes .
_ case _ @xmath30__. _ _ this is the standard choice in the swiss - cheese model . in the _ low density _
limit @xmath64 emerges , as in the general relativistic case . in the special case of
_ static _ branes ( @xmath65 constant ) , the continuity eq .
( [ conti ] ) implies @xmath66const and eqs .
( [ rhoaa ] ) and ( [ m2 ] ) do not arise any more.@xmath67then eq .
( [ pp ] ) gives @xmath68const as well .
moreover eq . ( [ raych1 ] ) implies @xmath69 and then eq . ( [ pp ] ) gives @xmath70 , thus the flrw region must be empty .
further , eq . ( [ c4 ] ) gives @xmath71 and then eq .
( [ c3 ] ) @xmath72 , thus the whole brane becomes trivial , a _ flat _ hypersurface .
_ case _ @xmath73__. _ _ again , for _ static _ branes it is evident from the continuity eq .
( [ conti ] ) that @xmath74const should hold , while from eq .
( [ pp ] ) @xmath75const emerges .
the raychaudhuri equation ( [ raych1 ] ) gives for the energy density of the fluid : @xmath76and also @xmath77 .
( therefore for a positive energy density we have to choose the @xmath78 sign in eq .
( [ rho1 ] ) . ) from eq .
( [ pp ] ) after some straightforward algebra we find the pressure:@xmath79the cosmological fluid @xmath80 turns out to be just another contribution to the cosmological constant .
the central mass is vanishing by virtue of eq .
( [ c4 ] ) and then eq . ( [ c3 ] ) implies once more @xmath72 . the brane is again _ flat , _ the 4-dimensional minkowski space - time .
both a cosmological constant and a nonvanishing perfect fluid are present on the flrw region of the brane , and they do not cancel , however the third , quadratic source term ( [ s ] ) of the modified einstein equation@xmath81cancels both by virtue of eq .
( [ rho1 ] ) @xmath82 g_{ab } & = & 0\ .\end{aligned}\ ] ]
we have found that as in the general relativistic case ( in the einstein - straus model ) , the voids on a swiss - cheese type brane - world reside in a dynamical universe .
the density of the fluid in the swiss - cheese brane evolves cf .
( [ rhoaa ] ) in a different way as compared to general relativity .
a static swiss - cheese universe can not exist neither on the brane , nor in general relativity , apart from the trivial empty and flat universe .
our no - go theorem for static swiss - cheese branes adds to various results concerning the staticity of brane stellar models @xcite-@xcite .
in particular , in @xcite it was shown that for an oppenheimer - sneider collapse on the brane the exterior space - time ( on the brane ) can not be static .
similarly it was shown that the vacuum exterior of a spherical star ( with vanishing pressure at the surface ) is in general not schwarzschild @xcite . in @xcite
the condition of vanishing pressure at the junction surface was lifted , as in our discussion .
it remains to see what type of inhomogeneous brane cosmological model can be found by lifting some of the original assumptions of the swiss - cheese model . an obvious way to do
this is by allowing a non - vanishing electric part of the bulk weyl curvature , which would contribute as source of the modified einstein equation .
in such a scenario the voids would be non - vacuum solutions in the classical general relativistic sense .
investigations of these issues are under way .
i am grateful for references , discussions and comments on the manuscript to viktor czinner , nathalie deruelle , roy maartens , mtys vasth and zoltn perjs , who was a gifted teacher and wonderful friend .
this work was supported by otka grants no .
t046939 and ts044665 . | we study the possibility of brane - world generalization of the einstein - straus swiss - cheese cosmological model .
we find the modifications induced by the brane - world scenario . at a first glance
only the motion of the boundary is modified and the fluid in the exterior region is allowed to have pressure .
the general relativistic einstein - straus model emerges in the low density limit . by imposing that
the brane is static , a combination of the junction conditions and modified cosmological evolution leads to the conclusion that the brane is flat .
thus no static swiss - cheese universe can exist on the brane .
the conclusion is not altered by the introduction of a cosmological constant in the flrw regions .
this result mimics a similar general relativistic result : static einstein - straus universes do not exist . |
recent calculations in quenched qcd at light valence quark mass have been refined to sufficient accuracy to allow detailed comparison with the predictions of quenched chiral perturbation theory @xcite .
the identification of quenched chiral loop effects in lattice data serves several purposes .
it allows one to perform sensible chiral extrapolations of quenched data and to extract the parameters of the qcd chiral lagrangian in the quenched approximation .
it also provides a standard of comparison for future studies of chiral behavior in full and partially quenched qcd , which will be crucial for obtaining complete control over chiral extrapolations in full qcd .
in particular , the study of quenched chiral loop ( qcl ) effects has identified several quantities for which the effects of quenching are clearly observable in the lattice data and in detailed agreeement with quenched chiral perturbation theory .
these quantities should be particularly useful in studying the transition from quenched to full qcd via partially quenched calculations .
the most striking of the observed qcl effects appears in the scalar , isovector ( valence or `` connected '' ) meson propagator which i will discuss in this talk .
the spectroscopy of scalar mesons is somewhat complicated phenomenologically . in a nonrelativistic quark - model framework ,
the lowest lying scalars are p - wave triplet states and would be expected to be substantially heavier than the lowest vector and pseudoscalar mesons , which are s - wave .
however , the experimental situation is somewhat unclear .
there is an @xmath2 state at 980 mev , but this is very close to the @xmath3 threshold , and may be a 4-quark state ( @xmath3 `` molecule '' ) .
the next @xmath2 meson is at 1474 mev .
there is also a strange scalar @xmath4 at 1412 mev . our data for the scalar isovector propagator exhibits not only the negative @xmath0-@xmath1 qcl effect , but also clear evidence of a positive short - range component corresponding to a heavy @xmath2 state .
fitting the data to a chiral lagrangian which includes a heavy scalar field , as discussed in section 3 , we obtain a chirally extrapolated scalar meson mass of @xmath5 mev ( statistical errors only ) .
further studies are required to estimate lattice - spacing and quenching effects , but the result appears to favor the 4-quark interpretation of the @xmath6 , with the states in the 1400 - 1500 mev range being the lowest - lying scalar @xmath7 states .
while most other qcl effects amount to relatively small modifications of full qcd behavior even at the lightest quark masses studied , the effect of quenching on the scalar isovector propagator is striking .
this effect arises from the @xmath0-@xmath1 intermediate state via the chiral loop graph depicted in fig .
1 . not only
does this graph dominate the entire propagator at small quark mass and large time separations , but the overall sign of the effect is _ negative _ i.e. opposite to that required by spectral positivity .
( this arises from a two ghost - meson state in the ghost - quark formulation of quenched @xmath8 . )
most of the results presented here were obtained from an ensemble of 300 gauge configurations on a @xmath9 lattice at @xmath10 , using clover - improved fermions with @xmath11 .
the mqa pole - shifting ansatz was used to resolve the exceptional configuration problem .
nine quark masses were used , corresponding to pion masses ranging from about 280 @xmath12 to 710 @xmath12 .
the qcl effect in the scalar isovector channel is clearly visible in the bizarre mass dependence of the raw lattice propagator . in fig .
2 we show this propagator for the heaviest and lightest quark masses studied . for the heavier quarks ,
the correlator is positive and exponentially falling , as would be expected for a heavy scalar meson state of mass @xmath13-@xmath14 gev
. the correlator completely changes character as the quark mass becomes small , developing a negative long - range component .
this component is convincingly explained as the effect of the @xmath0-@xmath1 chiral loop diagram in fig .
1 . the solid curve in fig .
2 is the _ zero parameter _ prediction of one - loop chiral perturbation theory , which uses only parameters obtained from previous chiral analysis of the pseudoscalar propagator .
define the one - loop bubble integral , fig . 1
, in momentum space @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the @xmath0 mass insertion , which has been determined @xcite by studying the pseudoscalar hairpin correlator ( @xmath17 in lattice units at @xmath10 ) .
the quenched scalar propagator is dominated by the @xmath0-@xmath1 intermediated state and given by @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the @xmath20 to @xmath21 coupling constant . in a chiral lagrangian framework ,
this coupling is not independently adjustable , but is determined by the slope parameter@xcite @xmath22 the constant @xmath19 is related to @xmath23 by a soft pion theorem : @xmath24 the excellent agreement between the long - range correlator and the @xmath8 prediction exhibited in fig .
2 shows that this soft pion theorem is quite well satisfied .
it is interesting to note that , with @xmath19 fixed by current algebra , the overall size of the one - loop qcl effect in the scalar propagator is determined by the @xmath0 mass insertion @xmath25 .
if we take this as a fit parameter , we obtain @xmath26 .
this is nearly as good a determination of the @xmath0 mass parameter as the one obtained directly from the hairpin correlator .
a full chiral lagrangian description of the lattice data for the scalar isovector propagator requires the incorporation of a heavy scalar field into the lagrangian .
the formalism of nonlinear chiral lagrangians @xcite allows the incorporation of heavy fields which only have specified transformation properties under the unbroken vector subgroup of the chiral group . to first order in symmetry breaking and ignoring derivative coupling terms , the relevant chiral lagrangian terms are @xmath27 where the last term is the anomaly - induced hairpin mass insertion , @xmath28
^ 2\ ] ] the values of @xmath29 and @xmath16 have been determined by analysis of the pseudoscalar valence and hairpin correlators .
we are interested in the correlator for a flavor nonsinglet quark bilinear @xmath30 .
this operator is related to the chiral lagrangian fields via the dependence of l on the spurion field @xmath31 .
this implies that the quark bilinear consists of two terms , which describe its coupling to the @xmath0-@xmath1 and scalar meson states , respectively , @xmath32 using this chiral lagrangian analysis , a resummed - bubble expression for the @xmath33 correlator was derived and used to fit the lattice correlator @xcite .
the scalar meson parameters obtained for @xmath10 are , in lattice units , in the chiral limit @xmath34 fits of the data to the resummed bubble expression for several quark masses are shown in fig .
3 . it is particularly significant that , over the entire range of quark masses , the fit parameters @xmath35 and @xmath36 show very little mass dependence , indicating that the dramatic mass dependence of the data is almost entirely explained by the change of the pion mass in the chiral loop integral .
9 w. bardeen , a. duncan , e. eichten , and h. thacker , phys .
d62:114505 ( 2000 ) .
w. bardeen , a. duncan , e. eichten , n. isgur , and h. thacker , phys .
d ( to be published ) s. weinberg , phys .
166:1568 ( 1968 ) . | the scalar isovector meson propagator is studied in quenched qcd . for the lightest quark masses
used , this propagator is dominated by a quenched chiral loop effect associated with the @xmath0-@xmath1 two - meson intermediate state . both the time dependence and the pion mass dependence of the effect are well - described by quenched chiral perturbation theory . |
the @xmath75 tridiagonal matrix @xmath71 has the following non - zero matrix elements : @xmath83 , @xmath73 for @xmath84 .
@xmath74 is tunable and @xmath85 is fixed .
the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of @xmath71 have the following properties .
+ let @xmath86 be all the eigenvalues of matrix @xmath71 , then @xmath87 .
it is easy to verify that @xmath88 , @xmath89 , and the relation @xmath90 .
therefore , one has @xmath91 and @xmath92 ( @xmath93 ) .
when @xmath1 is odd , @xmath94 , which means that at least one eigenvalue equals to zero regardless the values of @xmath74 and @xmath10 .
for the zero eigenvalue , the eigen - equation is @xmath95 , where @xmath96 . when expanded , the equation is turned into the following equations : @xmath97 there is only one non - trivial solution . for @xmath98 ,
it is given by @xmath99 with @xmath100 , @xmath101 , and @xmath102 where @xmath103 and @xmath104 is the normalization factor .
for @xmath105 , the solution is @xmath106 .
this shows matrix @xmath71 has one and only one eigenvalue equal to zero . + if @xmath107 , when @xmath1 is even , then @xmath108 .
thus all the eigenvalues of the matrix @xmath71 are nonzero .
when @xmath76 , it is obvious that @xmath109 .
there are zero eigenvalues . with @xmath76 , the tridiagonal matrix of @xmath71
is divided into two uncoupled subspaces , i.e. , @xmath110 , where @xmath111 is a tridiagonal matrix with nonzero elements @xmath112 .
it is clear that @xmath111 possesses property 1 and has only one zero eigenvalue .
@xmath71 thus has two zero eigenvalues .
when @xmath1 is odd , for the eigenvector @xmath78 of @xmath71 belonging to @xmath124 , the inequality @xmath125 holds for a finite range of parameters ; for an eigenvector @xmath78 of @xmath71 belonging to @xmath126 , one has that @xmath127 , whether @xmath1 is odd or even . according to eq.([ev ] ) , it is clear that the inequality @xmath79 is valid only when @xmath128 .
+ when @xmath126 , the two eigenvalues @xmath113 and @xmath114 are distinct and the corresponding eigenvectors are orthogonal to each other . with property 3 ,
one has @xmath129 when @xmath1 is odd ; @xmath130 when @xmath1 is even . with the normalization condition
@xmath131 , we immediately obtain that @xmath132 . c. brif , r. chakrabarti1 , and h. rabitz , new j. phys .
* 12 * , 075008(2010 ) .
t. salger , s. kling , t. king , c. geckeler , l. m. molina , and m. weitz , science * 326 * , 1241 ( 2009 ) .
m. grifoni , and p.hnggi , phys . rep . *
304 * , 229(1998 ) .
f. grossmann , t. dittrich , p. jung , and p. hanggi , phys .
lett . * 67 * , 516 ( 1991 ) ; z. phys .
b * 84 * , 315 ( 1991 ) .
d. h. dunlap and v. m. kenkre , phys .
b * 34 * , 3625 ( 1986 ) .
m. holthaus , phys .
lett . * 69 * , 351 ( 1992 ) ; m. holthaus and d. hone , phys .
b * 47 * , 6499 ( 1993 ) . c. e. creffield , phys . rev .
99 * , 110501 ( 2007 ) .
j. gong , d. poletti , and p. hanggi , phys .
a * 75 * , 033602(2007 ) .
x. luo , j. huang and c. lee , phys .
a * 84 * , 053847(2011 ) .
s. longhi , phys .
a * 71 * , 065801(2005 ) ; s. longhi and g. della valle , phys . rev .
a * 86 * , 042104(2012 )
. j. m. villas - bas , s. e. ulloa , and n. studart , phys .
b * 70 * , 041302(r ) ( 2004 ) .
j. t. stockburger , phys .
e * 59 * , r4709 ( 1999 ) .
x. luo , q. xie , and b. wu , phys .
a * 76 * , 051802(r)(2007 ) .
j. gong , l. morales - molina , and p. hnggi , phys .
* 103 * , 133002 ( 2009 ) .
s. longhi , phys .
a * 83 * , 034102 ( 2011 ) ; s. longhi , phys . rev .
a * 86 * , 044102(2012 ) . c. e. creffield and t. s. monteiro , phys
lett . * 96 * , 210403 ( 2006 ) ; c. e. creffield , phys . rev .
a * 75 * , 031607(r ) ( 2007 ) .
a. eckardt , c. weiss , and m. holthaus , phys .
lett . * 95 * , 260404 ( 2005 ) ; a. eckardt and m. holthaus , phys .
* 101 * , 245302 ( 2008 ) .
y. kayanuma and k. saito , phys .
a * 77 * , 010101(r)(2008 ) .
g. della valle , m. ornigotti , e. cianci , v. foglietti , p. laporta and s. longhi , phys .
lett . * 98 * , 263601 ( 2007 ) .
e. kierig , u. schnorrberger , a. schietinger , j. tomkovic , and m. k. oberthaler , phys .
lett . * 100 * , 190405 ( 2008 ) .
j. zhou , p. huang , q. zhang , z.wang , t. tan , x. xu , f. shi , x. rong , s. ashhab , j. du , arxiv:1305.0157 .
h. lignier , c. sias , d. ciampini , y. singh , a. zenesini , o. morsch , and e. arimondo , phys .
rev . lett . * 99 * , 220403 ( 2007 ) .
a. eckardt , m. holthaus , h. lignier , a. zenesini , d. ciampini , o. morsch , and e. arimondo , phys .
rev . a * 79 * , 013611 ( 2009 ) .
k. bergmann , h. theuer , and b. w. shore , rev .
mod . phys . * 70 * , 1003 ( 1998 ) .
i. l. garanovich , s. longhi , a. a. sukhorukov , and y. s. kivshar , phys . rep .
* 518 * , 1 ( 2012 )
. s. longhi , laser and photon . rev . * 3 * , 243 ( 2008 ) .
a. szameit , y. v. kartashov , m. heinrich , f. dreisow , r. keil , s. nolte a. tnnermann , v. a. vysloukh , f. lederer , and l. torner , opt lett . * 34 * , 2700 ( 2009 ) .
a. szameit , y. v. kartashov , f. dreisow , m. heinrich , t. pertsch , s. nolte , a. tnnermann , v. a. vysloukh , f. lederer , and l. torner , phys .
lett . * 102 * , 153901 ( 2009 ) . | we study a system of three coherently coupled states , where one state is shifted periodically against the other two .
we discover such a system possesses a dark floquet state at zero quasi - energy and always with negligible population at the intermediate state .
this dark floquet state manifests itself dynamically in terms of the suppression of inter - state tunneling , a phenomenon known as coherent destruction of tunneling .
we suggest to call it dark coherent destruction of tunneling ( dcdt ) . at high frequency limit for the periodic driving
, this floquet state reduces to the well - known dark state widely used for stirap .
our results can be generalized to systems with more states and can be verified with easily implemented experiments within current technologies .
two - state and three - state models are the simplest quantum systems . despite their simplicity
, they often provide very good approximations to describe realistic physical systems and are capable of revealing a variety of fascinating quantum effects .
the understanding of their ubiquitous features are nowadays being exploited for the manipulation and control of quantum states of small systems involving single atoms , photons , or nano - devices @xcite .
coherent destruction of tunneling ( two - state models ) and dark state ( three - state models ) are two of the elegant prototype examples where deep understanding gained from quantum coherent effects in these simple systems are impacting the development of quantum technology in communication and computation
. coherent destruction of tunneling ( cdt ) was discovered in a periodically - driving double well system @xcite .
it describes a fascinating phenomenon whereby coherent tunneling between two wells ( or the rabi oscillation between two states ) is turned off by an externally enforced periodic level shift .
its understanding is related to dynamical localization @xcite , which occurs at isolated degenerate points of the quasienergies @xcite .
cdt has thus far generated significant interest , and has been theoretically extended into various forms @xcite-@xcite .
it has also been observed experimentally in many physical systems : including modulated optical coupler @xcite , driven double - well potentials for single - particle tunneling @xcite , and a single electron spin in diamond @xcite .
more recently , it has also found application in tuning the tunneling parameter of a bose - einstein condensate @xcite .
dark state is often discussed in terms of a three - state system where two of them are coupled coherently to the intermediate state , as in the model system we study here .
when all coupling fields are on resonance with their respective coupled pair of states , we can adopt the rotating wave approximation and change into a suitable interaction picture with all coupling coefficients becoming time independent . in this case
, there always exists a dark state , whose eigenenergy becomes uniformly zero , and the corresponding eigenvector contains no projection onto the intermediate state .
it is called dark as the intermediate state is an excited state capable of emitting photons .
this type of dark state is also known as coherent population trapping @xcite , widely used in efficient population transfer through the stimulated raman adiabatic passage ( stirap ) protocol .
it has become the theoretical basis for several well - established implementations of quantum control and rudimentary quantum information processing gates . in this letter
we report our surprising finding of an intimate relationship between dark state and coherent destruction of tunneling by studying a three - state system . in this system ,
two states are coherently coupled to an intermediate state and one of the two states shifts periodically against the other two .
we find that cdt also exists in this three - state system , where the dynamical tunneling from one state to the other two is suppressed by the periodic driving over a range of parameters .
however , this cdt for the three - state system has its own distinct feature : it is related to a dark floquet state , which has zero quasi - energy and negligible population at the the intermediate state . quite interestingly
, this dark floquet state reduces to the well - known dark state in a non - driving three - state @xmath0-system@xcite at high - frequency limit .
therefore , we call this cdt _ dark coherent destruction of tunneling_(dcdt )
. these results can be generalized to @xmath1-state system .
we also discuss a feasible experimental scheme where the visualization of the dcdt can be achieved readily .
_ three - state system .
_ the driving three - state system is described by the schrdinger equation ( @xmath2 ) @xmath3 where @xmath4 , @xmath5 , and @xmath6 are the amplitudes at three states @xmath7 , @xmath8 , and @xmath9 , respectively .
@xmath10 is the coupling constant between the neighboring states .
energy state @xmath7 is shifted periodically against the other two with driving strength @xmath11 and frequency @xmath12 .
the normalization condition @xmath13 is assumed . to investigate the tunneling dynamics , we solve the time - dependent schrdinger equation ( [ coupled ] ) numerically with initial state @xmath14 .
the evolution of the probability distribution @xmath15 is presented in fig . [ fig1 ] for three typical driving conditions .
for @xmath16 ( fig .
[ fig1 ] ( a ) ) , we see that @xmath17 oscillates between zero and one , demonstrating no suppression of tunneling . for @xmath18 ( fig .
[ fig1 ] ( b ) ) , the oscillations of @xmath17 are seen limited between 0.8 and 1 , showing suppression of tunneling . at @xmath19 ( fig . [ fig1 ] ( c ) ) , @xmath17 remains near unity , signaling a complete suppression of tunneling between energy states .
this is the quantum phenomenon well known as cdt @xcite .
we emphasize that what we find here is not a simple re - discovery of cdt in a three - state system .
the cdt in this three - state model has its own distinct feature : the results shown in fig .
[ fig1 ] ( b , c ) indicate that the suppression of tunneling occurs over a wide range of system parameters .
this is in stark contrast to the cdt in a two - state system @xcite , which occurs only at isolated points of parameters .
the widening of the suppression regime found in the driving three - state system is more clearly demonstrated in fig .
[ fig1 ] ( d ) , where the minimum value of @xmath17 is used to measure the suppression of tunneling .
when ( @xmath17 ) is not zero , the tunneling is suppressed as the population is not allowed to be fully transferred from state @xmath7 to the other two states .
it is clear from fig .
[ fig1 ] ( d ) that the suppression occurs as long as @xmath20 . for comparison , the results for the standard driven two - state system is plotted as dash dotted line in fig . [ fig1 ] ( d ) , where the extremely narrow peak width indicates that cdt occurs only at isolated points of parameters .
@xmath15 for the system ( [ coupled ] ) for various driving conditions : ( a ) @xmath16 ; ( b ) @xmath18 ; ( c ) @xmath19 .
( d ) the minimum value of @xmath17 ( solid line ) as a function of driving parameter @xmath21 .
the two - state results are plotted as a dash dotted line for comparison .
the initial condition is @xmath22 .
the other parameters are @xmath23.,width=302 ] there exists a fundamental reason why the cdt occurs at isolated system parameters in a two - state model , where the cdt is related to the degeneracy of quasi - energy levels @xcite and the degeneracy usually happens only at isolated points .
therefore , the significant widening of the suppression parameter range that we see in fig . [ fig1 ] indicates that the cdt found here should have a different origin . to investigate this origin
, we turn to the floquet theory for a periodically - driving system .
similar to bloch states for systems with spatially periodic potentials , the modulated system ( [ coupled ] ) has floquet states , @xmath24 , where @xmath25 is the quasi - energy and the amplitudes @xmath26 are periodic with modulation period @xmath27 . our numerical results of the quasi - energies and floquet states for the modulated system ( [ coupled ] )
are plotted in fig .
[ fig2 ] .
there are three floquet states with quasi - energies @xmath28 , @xmath29 , and @xmath30 .
we immediately notice from fig .
[ fig2](a ) that the quasi - energy @xmath29 for the second floquet state is always _ zero _ for all values of @xmath21 .
we call this state _ dark floquet state _ in analogy to the well - known dark state .
this dark floquet state stands out not only for its zero quasi - energy but also for its unique population distribution among energy states .
we display the time - averaged population probability @xmath31 for a given floquet state @xmath32 in fig .
[ fig2](b - d ) .
the floquet state with @xmath33-th energy state . as seen in fig .
[ fig2](c ) , the dark floquet state has almost zero population at energy state @xmath8 while the population at @xmath7 @xmath34 .
in other words , the dark floquet state is localized at @xmath7 .
the other two floquet states have identical population distribution . since all their populations @xmath35 , these two floquet states are _ not _ localized . .
solid lines are for numerical results obtained from the original model ( [ coupled ] ) and circles are for the approximation results given by the effective model ( [ eq : ceff ] ) .
time - averaged populations for the floquet state in the quasi - energy level ( b ) @xmath28 , ( c ) @xmath29 , and ( d ) @xmath30 .
the other parameters are @xmath36.,width=302 ] it is not difficult to see the suppression of tunneling seen in fig .
[ fig1 ] is linked to the existence of the dark floquet state .
we expand the initial state in terms of the floquet states @xmath37 during the dynamical evolution , the expansion coefficient @xmath38 evolve as @xmath39 .
in other words , @xmath40s are time independent .
we look at the case @xmath19 , where @xmath41 has population one at state @xmath7 while the other two states have zero population at @xmath7 . in this case
, we have @xmath42 and @xmath43 , which corresponds to a complete suppression of tunneling from @xmath7 to @xmath8 and @xmath9 . for other values of @xmath21 ,
similar arguments can be made .
this shows that the cdt observed in fig .
[ fig1 ] has a different origin : it is the consequence of dark floquet states .
therefore , we call it _ dark coherent destruction of tunneling _ ( dcdt ) .
interestingly , this dark floquet state can be reduced to the well known dark state in a non - driven three - state @xmath0-system at high frequency limit . introducing the transformation
@xmath44 $ ] ( @xmath45 for @xmath46 and @xmath47 for @xmath48 ) and averaging out high frequency terms , one can obtain a non - driven three - state system @xmath49 where @xmath50 is the zeroth order bessel function . the famous dark state ( also known as coherent trapped state ) for eq .
( [ eq : ceff ] ) is given by @xmath51 , where @xmath52 ^ 2 $ ] .
this dark state corresponds to the dark floquet state .
similarly , this dark state is always localized at state @xmath7 as @xmath53 and has zero population at state @xmath8 .
this state is completely localized at state @xmath7 when @xmath54 .
we have computed the the eigenvalues of model ( [ eq : ceff ] ) and compared them ( circles ) with the quasi - energies ( black solid lines ) in fig .
[ fig2 ] ( a ) .
the agreement is almost perfect .
_ generalization to @xmath1-state system .
_ our analysis above is given for a three - state system and the original cdt was found in a two - state system .
these results can be generalized to an @xmath1-state system , where one state is shifted periodically against all the other states .
the equations of motion are @xmath55 where @xmath56 . as a function of @xmath21 for @xmath57 ( dash dotted line ) and @xmath58 ( solid line ) .
the initial conditions are @xmath59 .
quasi - energies versus @xmath21 for ( b ) @xmath57 and ( c ) @xmath58 .
solid lines are for numerical results obtained from the model ( [ coupledn ] ) and circles are for the approximation results given by the effective model ( [ effective ] ) .
( d ) the time - averaged probability distribution of the floquet state corresponding to @xmath60 in fig .
[ fig3 ] ( c ) .
the other parameters are @xmath36.,width=302 ] the quantum dynamics of the driven @xmath1-state systems is investigated by direct integration of the time - dependent schrdinger equation ( [ coupledn ] ) with the state initially prepared on the state @xmath7 .
the cdt is found to exist .
the minimum value of @xmath15 as a function of @xmath21 is presented in fig .
[ fig3 ] ( a ) for @xmath57 and @xmath58 .
when @xmath57 , the cdt occurs at an isolated point of parameters ( dash dotted line in fig .
[ fig3 ] ( a ) ) , where two of the four quasi - energy levels become degenerate ( fig .
[ fig3 ] ( b ) ) .
this is exactly the same as in the two - state system . when @xmath58 , the parameter range where cdt occurs is extended substantially ( solid line in fig .
[ fig3 ] ( a ) ) as in the three - state model .
furthermore , this five - state system also has a dark floquet state : as seen in fig .
[ fig3 ] ( c ) , one of the quasi - energies always equals to zero .
this dark floquet state has negligible population at all of even @xmath61-th states ( fig .
[ fig3 ] ( d ) ) .
these numerical results with @xmath62 , together with the known results for @xmath63 , clearly suggest that ( _ i _ ) the dark state and the associated dcdt exist in odd @xmath1-state systems ; ( _ ii _ ) the original cdt , which occurs at isolated parameter points , exists in all even-@xmath1-state system .
this general conclusion can be proved analytically at high frequency limit . following the procedure used in the three - state system , we introduce the transformation @xmath64 $ ] , @xmath65 $ ] , where @xmath66 are slowly varying functions . using the expansion @xmath67=\sum_k(\pm
i)^k j_k ( a/\omega)\exp(\pm ik \omega t)$ ] in terms of bessel functions and neglecting all orders except @xmath68 for high frequency limit , we can reduce the coupled equations ( [ coupledn ] ) to a non - driven model @xmath69 where @xmath70 .
the matrix @xmath71 is tridiagonal with @xmath72 , @xmath73 .
the effective coupling constant @xmath74 between state @xmath7 and state @xmath8 is tunable with the driving parameters .
the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the tridiagonal @xmath75 matrix @xmath71 enjoy some very interesting properties , whose rigorous proofs can be found in supplemental material .
\(a ) _ when @xmath1 is even , for any nonzero @xmath74 and @xmath10 , all the eigenvalues of the matrix @xmath71 are nonzero while two of the eigenvalues are zero for @xmath76 .
_ _ remark _ : this means that when @xmath1 is even , two quasi - energy levels of the driven model ( [ coupledn ] ) are degenerate at isolated points where @xmath77 .
the cdt occurs at these isolated points .
\(b ) _ when @xmath1 is odd , one and only one eigenvalue of @xmath71 always equals to zero and , for the corresponding eigenvector @xmath78 of @xmath71 , the inequality @xmath79 holds for a finite range of parameters ; for any other eigenvector @xmath78 of @xmath71 , one has @xmath80 .
_ _ remark _ : when @xmath1 is odd , the system always has one and only one dark floquet state , which is localized over a finite range of parameters . correspondingly , dcdt occurs over a finite range of parameters . _
experimental observation .
_ by mapping the temporal evolution of quantum systems into the spatial propagations of light waves , the engineered waveguides have provided an ideal platform to investigate a wide variety of coherent quantum effects@xcite .
the phenomenon of dcdt can also be observed with this kind of waveguide system .
the discrete model ( [ coupledn ] ) can be simulated by the light propagation in an array of @xmath1 waveguides placed closely and with equal spacing .
periodic driving is realized by the harmonic modulation of the refractive index of the waveguides along the propagation direction@xcite . for our system ,
the periodic modulation of the first waveguide has a phase difference of @xmath81 against the modulations for all other @xmath82 waveguides .
when @xmath1 is odd , the dcdt can be readily observed with current experimental capacity@xcite . in summary , we find that the cdt also happens in a three - state quantum system , where one energy state is shifted periodically against the other two states .
we call this type of cdt dark coherent destruction of tunneling ( dcdt ) as it is related to the existence of a dark floquet state in the three - state system
. the dark floquet state has zero quasi - energy and negligible population at the intermediate state .
it reduces to the well known dark state of a non - driven three - state system .
these results can be generalized to a periodically driven @xmath1-state system .
we have also pointed out that observation of dcdt is well within the capacity of current experiments .
this work is funded by the nsf of china ( 10965001 , 11165009 ) , the nsf of jiangxi province ( 2010gqw0033 ) , the jiangxi young scientists training plan ( 20112bcb23024 ) , the financial support provided by the key subject of atomic and molecular physics in jiangxi province and zhengzhou mbost ( 20120409 ) .
b. w. is supported by the nbrp of china ( 2012cb921300,2013cb921900 ) , the nsf of china ( 11274024 ) , the rfdp of china ( 20110001110091 )
. l. y. is supported by the nsf of china ( 11004116 ) and by most 2013cb922000 of the national key basic research program of china . |
heavy fermion ( hf ) compounds with elements from the lanthanide or actinide series share some rather general features in the fermi liquid phase , namely a strong enhancement of the effective carrier mass and a similarly enhanced pauli susceptibility with a wilson ratio typically of the order , but larger than one @xcite .
in addition to this well - understood fermi liquid phase @xcite , hf systems also exhibit a variety of phase transitions , among them magnetic and superconducting phases .
this aroused the strong interest of both experimentalists and theorists , as @xmath0-electrons conventionally tend to suppress superconductivity .
the discovery of quantum critical phenomena @xcite eventually showed the intimate link between the latter two . in spite of the rather large collection of experimental results ,
an accepted theoretical description of superconductivity has not yet been established . moreover ,
the role of phonons on the low - energy properties of hf compounds and in particular their relevance for a microscopic theory of superconductivity in hf systems has not yet been addressed in detail @xcite .
we present the first results of a study of the kondo lattice model with an effective attractive interaction among the conduction electrons .
the latter can be thought to be obtained from an optical phonon mode treated in the antiadiabatic limit ( a more realistic description employing a true optical phonon in the calculation is the subject of ongoing investigations ) .
our model is thus @xmath1 where @xmath2 annihilates ( creates ) a conduction electron at lattice site @xmath3 with spin @xmath4 , @xmath5 is the effective interaction between conduction electrons , and @xmath6 the kondo exchange .
note that in our notation antiferromagnetic coupling means @xmath7 .
finally , @xmath8 denotes the vector of pauli spin matrices .
we solve the model with dynamical mean - field theory ( dmft ) @xcite and wilson s numerical renormalization group ( nrg ) @xcite .
calculations were performed for a bethe lattice with infinite coordination number . in order to study superconductivity we allow for a corresponding symmetry broken phase @xcite .
note that we can not include unconventional order parameters here , as dmft only allows for @xmath9-wave phases @xcite .
) at half filling with @xmath10 at @xmath11 .
right : low - energy scale obtained from the width of the gap in the attractive case @xmath12 for @xmath10 .
the inset shows the different gaps for small repulsive and attractive @xmath5 . ,
title="fig:",scaledwidth=65.0% ] ) at half filling with @xmath10 at @xmath11 .
right : low - energy scale obtained from the width of the gap in the attractive case @xmath12 for @xmath10 .
the inset shows the different gaps for small repulsive and attractive @xmath5 .
, title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] it is necessary to stress that the model ( [ eq:1 ] ) does not show the usual symmetry @xmath13 under simultaneous exchange of spin and charge , i.e. its physics can not be inferred from the corresponding magnetic properties of the model with repulsive interaction . in fig .
[ fig:1 ] we compare the two cases @xmath14 and @xmath12 .
superficially , for weak interaction @xmath15 , both seem to be rather similar
. however , as is evident from the inset to the right part and the behavior for larger interaction the insulator is much stronger for repulsive @xmath5 .
it here originates from the formation of a local spin singlet rather than being of mott - hubbard type @xcite . for attractive @xmath12 ,
on the other hand , we find that kondo screening is strongly suppressed and the system eventually recovers mott - hubbard physics in the charge sector for large @xmath16 .
this difference can be easily understood . for attractive @xmath5 the conduction system
namely experiences strong correlations in the charge sector , while the kondo exchange tries to develop such feature in the spin sector . obviously , when @xmath17 , where @xmath18 is the kondo scale for @xmath19 , spin fluctuations will efficiently be suppressed , leading to the observed behaviour .
the suppression of the kondo scale is actually stronger than exponential , as shown in the right part of fig .
[ fig:1 ] . from these results
we draw two conclusions : 1 ) phonons are clearly extremely important even to the paramagnetic phase of the kondo model and thus to properly account for the low - energy scale of hf systems ; 2 ) as the low - energy scale is efficiently reduced by an attractive interaction among the conduction electrons , we expect that @xmath9-wave superconductivity will actually prevail in a large part of the phase diagram , in particular for small kondo coupling @xmath6 . in order to allow the system to show superconductivity
, we have to reformulate the dmft equations in nambu space and extend the nrg accordingly .
the latter has been accomplished some time ago already ( for a review see and references therein ; the actual way to combine dmft and nrg has been extensively discussed by bauer @xcite ) . for ( a ) @xmath20 , ( b ) @xmath21 and ( c ) @xmath22 .
, scaledwidth=65.0% ] for a very small kondo exchange interaction @xmath23 , the ground state of the model is dominated by superconductivity .
this becomes apparent from fig .
[ fig:3 ] , where the dos ( upper panels ) and the real part of the anomalous green s function ( lower panels ) is shown at half filling ( full curves ) as well as at finite filling @xmath24 ( dashed curves ) . as the low - energy scale of the model with @xmath19 is always largest at half filling @xcite , we can expect that this result remains stable for all fillings @xmath25 .
note that in none of the cases one does observe a significant dependence of the gap on the fillings , i.e. local correlations due to kondo screening are frozen out here since @xmath26 .
furthermore , @xmath27 and consequently one expects and observes a bcs like gap structure , only weakly smeared out by self - energy broadening . and
( a ) @xmath28 , ( b ) @xmath29 and ( c ) @xmath30.,scaledwidth=65.0% ] increasing @xmath31 has two effects .
first , there appears a finite , critical @xmath32 below which no superconducting solution exists .
this can be seen in fig .
[ fig:4]a , where dos and real part of the anomalous green s function are shown for @xmath33 and a small @xmath28 .
note that at half filling we find a kondo insulator , which has a gap in the dos . from that perspective
the result is actually indistinguishable from the superconducting phase .
the anomalous part , however , vanishes here , i.e. we have indeed a normal state and thus an insulator . for larger interactions
, the superconducting phase reappears .
compared to the case with small @xmath6 , we observe here visible reduction of the gap and also a broadening of the singularities at the gap edges .
we attribute this behavior to the correlations induced by the kondo exchange .
we have studied the kondo lattice model with an attractive interaction between the conduction electrons , which may arise in the presence of phonons , notably optical modes like breathing modes .
we found a tremendous effect of an attractive interaction on the low - energy scale , drastically reducing it already for comparatively modest @xmath16 .
this behavior can be understood in terms of a competition between a spin kondo effect and the charge fluctuations introduced by the attractive @xmath5 .
as the latter also favour superconductivity we can expect , and indeed do find , that for experimentally relevant values of the kondo coupling and interaction parameters the model shows an @xmath9-wave type superconducting ground state . for real systems
this underlines the importance of elastic degrees of freedom for a proper description of the physics of hf materials . | we study the kondo lattice model with additional attractive interaction between the conduction electrons within the dynamical mean - field theory using the numerical renormalization group to solve the effective quantum impurity problem .
in addition to normal - state and magnetic phases we also allow for the occurrence of a superconducting phase . in the normal phase we observe a very sensitive dependence of the low - energy scale on the conduction - electron interaction .
we discuss the dependence of the superconducting transition on the interplay between attractive interaction and kondo exchange . |
particles moving in a viscous fluid induce a local flow field that affects other particles . these long - range , many - body interactions , mediated by the solvent are commonly called hydrodynamic interactions ( hi ) . the presence of hi
is known to affect the dynamic properties of soft matter : they modify the values of diffusion coefficients in colloidal suspensions @xcite , affect the characteristics of the coil - stretch transition in polymers @xcite , change the kinetic pathways of phase separation in binary mixtures @xcite , alter the kinetics of macromolecule adsorption on surfaces @xcite or cause the polymer migration in microchannels @xcite .
they are also important in the dynamics of biological soft matter , such as dna @xcite , proteins @xcite or lipid membranes @xcite .
the proper account of hydrodynamic interactions is thus essential in simulation studies of soft matter in the flow .
unfortunately , hi depend in a complicated nonlinear way on the instantaneous positions of all particles in the system . for a system of spheres , exact explicit expressions for the hydrodynamic interaction tensors exist in the form of the power series in interparticle distances , which may be incorporated into the simulation scheme @xcite .
these are however relatively expensive numerically , thus various approximations are resorted to in order to make the computations more tractable .
the simplest one is based on the oseen tensor , which assumes that the particles can be regarded as point force sources in the fluid
. however , the diffusion matrix constructed in this way is not suitable for the brownian dynamics simulations , because it becomes non - positive definite when separations between the particles become small .
this is not only unphysical ( since the positivity of diffusion is a consequence of second law of thermodynamics ) but also leads to numerical problems in the brownian dynamics simulations , where a square root of diffusion matrix is needed .
another commonly used approximation is the rotne - prager - yamakawa tensor @xcite , which takes into account all the hi terms up to @xmath1 in the expansion in the inverse distance between the particles ( where @xmath2 is the particle radius ) .
nevertheless , if the particles overlap , @xmath3 , the rpy tensor again looses its positive definiteness . to avoid this ,
a regularization for @xmath3 has been proposed by @xcite , which is not singular at @xmath4 and positive definite for all the particle configurations .
the rotne - prager - yamakawa tensor with this regularization is by far the most popular method of accounting for hi in soft matter modelling @xcite .
notably , rpy tensor is divergence - free , which considerably simplifies the application of brownian dynamics algorithm @xcite .
however , when one goes beyond rpy approximation and includes many - body effects in hydrodynamic interactions , the divergence of mobility matrix becomes is non - zero and needs to be taken into account in brownian dynamics simulation schemes @xcite .
the present paper takes a close look at the rotne - prager - yamakawa approximation and generalizes it in a number of ways .
first , we re - derive the original rpy tensor using the direct integration of force densities over the sphere surfaces .
when the spheres overlap then this method gives us automatically the regularization correction . in this way we derive the rpy regularizations not only for the translational degrees of freedom
( already obtained by @xcite ) but also for rotational degrees of freedom , as well as for the shear disturbance matrix @xmath5 - another hydrodynamic tensor , which gives the response of the particles to the external shear flow .
the mobility evaluated using our technique may be applied for calculation of the diffusion tensor of complex molecules @xcite using bead models which include overlapping spheres .
finally , we show how these results can be generalized for other boundary conditions and corresponding propagators .
we consider a suspension of @xmath6 identical spherical particles of radius @xmath2 , in an incompressible fluid of viscosity @xmath7 at a low reynolds number .
the particles are immersed in a linear shear flow @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the constant velocity gradient matrix , e.g. for a simple shear flow @xmath10,\qquad\dot{\gamma}=\mathrm{{const.}}\label{eq : shear_matrix}\ ] ] due to the linearity of the stokes equations , the forces and torques exerted by the fluid on the particles ( @xmath11 and @xmath12 ) depend linearly on translational and rotational velocities of the particles ( @xmath13 , @xmath14 ) .
this relation defines the generalized friction matrix @xmath15 @xmath16 where @xmath17 ( with @xmath18 and @xmath19 ) are the cartesian tensors and the superscripts @xmath20 , @xmath21 and @xmath22 correspond to the translational , rotational and dipolar components , respectively .
the tensor @xmath23 is the symmetric part of @xmath9 in ( [ eq : shear_matrix ] ) and @xmath24 is the vorticity of the incident flow .
finally @xmath25 corresponds to the position of particle @xmath26 .
the reciprocal relation giving velocities of particles moving under external forces / torques in external flow @xmath27 is determined by generalized mobility matrix @xmath28 written after @xcite @xmath29 + \left ( \begin{array}{c } \mathbf{c}^{t}_{i } \\ \mathbf{c}^{r}_{i } \end{array } \right ) : \mathbf{e}_{\infty } , \label{eq : generalmobilitymatrixseparatedc}\ ] ] where the shear disturbance tensor @xmath30 elements are defined as [ eq : ctensor ] @xmath31 in the case of single particle the mobility matrixes reduce to @xmath32 where the friction coefficients for a spherical particle are given by @xmath33 and @xmath34 .
finding the mobility matrix ( or the associated diffusion matrix , @xmath35 ) is the problem of a fundamental importance in constructing the numerical algorithms for tracking the motion of the particles in viscous fluid .
the two main numerical methods used for this purpose are the _ stokesian dynamics _ , which corresponds to the numerical integration of [ eq : generalmobilitymatrixseparatedc ] and the _ brownian dynamics _ ,
used whenever the brownian motion of the particles can not be neglected @xcite . in the latter ,
the random displacements of the particles , @xmath36 , need to be added on top of the deterministic displacements governed by eq .
[ eq : generalmobilitymatrixseparatedc ] .
the fluctuation - dissipation theorem implies that the covariance of @xmath37 is connected to the mobility matrix , e.g. for the translational displacements @xmath38 hence the calculation of @xmath36 requires finding a matrix @xmath39 such that @xmath40 .
this is possible only when the mobility matrix is positively defined .
any valid approximation scheme for the hydrodynamic interactions should then not only correctly reproduce the particle mobilities but also guarantee the positive definiteness of the mobility tensors .
in principle the hydrodynamic interactions tensors can be calculated with arbitrary precision , following e.g. the multipole expansion or boundary integral method @xcite . in practice
, however , the exact approach turns out to be too demanding computationally , so various approximation procedures have to be resorted to . the most commonly used is the rotne - prager - yamakwa approximation @xcite , based on the following idea : when a force ( or torque ) is applied to particle @xmath26 , that particle begins to move inducing the flow in the bulk of the fluid .
the extent to which this additional flow affects translational and rotational velocities of another particle ( @xmath41 ) is then calculated using faxen s laws @xcite . in that way
one neglects not only the multi - body effects ( involving three and more particles ) but also the higher order terms in two - particle interactions ( e.g. we do not consider the impact of the movement of particle @xmath41 back on particle @xmath26 ) .
below , we follow this procedure to derive in a systematic way hydrodynamic tensors for both translational and rotational degrees of freedom . the stokes flow generated by a point force in the unbounded space
is given by the oseen tensor @xcite @xmath43 since @xmath44 is a green function for stokes equations , one can use it to calculate the translational @xmath45 and rotational @xmath46 flows generated by the sphere situated at @xmath47 , to which we apply force @xmath48 and/or torque @xmath49 : @xmath50\cdot\bm{\mathcal{f}},\qquad \rho_j > a,\\ \,\\
\frac{1}{\zeta^{tt}}\bm{\mathcal{f}},\qquad \rho_j \leq a , \end{array}\right.\label{eq : v0t}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath51 where @xmath52 is the distance from the sphere centre , @xmath53 denotes integration variable , @xmath54 is the unit normal vector to the sphere at point @xmath53 and @xmath55 denotes an integral over the surface of the sphere situated at @xmath56 .
the curl of a tensor is defined in the following way @xmath57 where the greek letters denote the cartesian components .
the faxen laws @xcite allow to express the velocity @xmath13 and angular velocity @xmath58 of a sphere @xmath26 immersed in an external flow @xmath59 placed in @xmath25 @xmath60 @xmath61 where the integration is performed over the sphere surface @xmath62 . thus substituting ( [ eq : v0t],[eq : v0r ] ) into equations ( [ eq : faxen_laws ] ) we obtain the contribution to velocity @xmath63 and angular velocity @xmath64 of a sphere @xmath26 due to the force / torque acting on a sphere @xmath41 @xmath65,\label{eq : u_final}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath66.\label{eq : omega_final}\end{aligned}\ ] ] at this stage let us introduce tensors @xmath67 where @xmath68 .
above tensors multiplied by force @xmath69 and torque @xmath70 have the interpretation of the force densities on the surface of the sphere due to the force and torque acting on the sphere .
we can now write down the following general formulae for the mobility matrix @xmath71 where we use the bra - ket notation defined in the following way @xmath72^{t}\cdot\mathbf{t}_{0}\left(\mathbf{r}'-\mathbf{r}''\right)\cdot\mathbf{w}_{j}^{q}\left(\mathbf{r}''\right),\label{eq : ypq}\ ] ] with @xmath73 and @xmath74 - tensor transposition .
the method of calculation of the integrals in ( [ eq : u_final])-([eq : omega_final ] ) is presented in the supplementary material . here
, we simply quote the final results denoting @xmath75 .
fortunately there is no need to integrate explicitly for non overlapping spheres . for the translational - translational mobility ,
we get : @xmath76,\quad r_{ij}>2a,\\ \\
\frac{1}{\zeta^{tt}}\left[\left(1-\frac{9r_{ij}}{32a}\right)\mathbf{1}+\frac{3r_{ij}}{32a}\hat{\mathbf{r}}_{ij}\hat{\mathbf{r}}_{ij}\right],\qquad r_{ij}\leq2a , \end{array}\right.\label{eq : mutt_final}\ ] ] which , in the limit of @xmath77 , yields the self mobility @xmath78 next , for the rotational degrees of freedom @xmath79,\qquad r_{ij}\leq2a , \end{array}\right.\label{eq : murr_final}\ ] ] with the self mobility given by @xmath80 finally , the translational - rotational mobility is described by the following tensor @xmath81^{t}=\left\ { \begin{array}{c } \frac{1}{2}\nabla\times\left(\mathbf{1}+\frac{a^{2}}{6}\nabla^{2}\right)\mathbf{t}_{\mathrm{0}}\left(\mathbf{r}_{ij}\right)=\frac{1}{2}\nabla\times\mathbf{t}_{0}\left(\mathbf{r}_{ij}\right)=\frac{1}{8\pi\eta r_{ij}^{2}}\boldsymbol{\epsilon}\cdot\hat{\mathbf{r}}_{ij},\qquad r_{ij}>2a,\\ \\
\frac{1}{16\pi\eta a^{2}}\left(\frac{r_{ij}}{a}-\frac{3}{8}\frac{r_{ij}^{2}}{a^{2}}\right)\boldsymbol{\epsilon}\cdot\hat{\mathbf{r}}_{ij},\qquad r_{ij}\leq2a , \end{array}\right.\label{eq : murt_final}\ ] ] with @xmath82 note that the formulae for the translational mobility matrix , both for @xmath83 and for @xmath84 were derived earlier by @xcite and @xcite and are known as rotne - prager - yamakawa mobility approximation .
the expressions for the other components of the mobility matrix @xmath85 and @xmath86 are also known @xcite but only for @xmath83 . however , to our knowledge , the regularizing corrections for @xmath85 and @xmath86 for the overlapping particles ( @xmath84 ) have not been derived so far .
importantly , as we will demonstrate in the section ( [ sec : pos_def ] ) , only with the use of these corrections the mobility matrix @xmath28 remains positive definite for all configurations of the particles .
contrastingly , in the point - force ( stokeslet ) model which is sometimes used for modelling the dynamics of colloidal suspensions @xcite , the mobility matrix , defined as follows @xmath87 is not positive definite even for non overlapping spheres and does not possess the property ( [ eq : self_tt ] ) .
the formula for the 3rd rank convection tensor @xmath30 can be obtained in the following way .
@xcite provide a solution for the excess flow @xmath88 , produced by a freely moving sphere situated at @xmath56 in the ambient shear flow @xmath89 , which is a difference between total flow @xmath90 and ambient flow @xmath91\overleftarrow{\bm{\nabla}}\right\ } : \mathbf{e}_{\infty},\label{eq : kimkarrila_flow-1}\ ] ] where @xmath92_{\alpha\beta\gamma}=\partial_{\gamma}t_{\alpha\beta}(\mathbf{r})$ ] .
the contribution to the surface force density due to the straining fluid motion is : @xmath93 , thus introducing tensor @xmath94 @xmath95 and using the green s formula we may express the excess flow over the shear flow @xmath89 in the following way @xmath96\overleftarrow{\bm{\nabla}}\right\ } : \mathbf{e}_{\infty},\quad \rho_j > a,\\ \\ -\mathbf{e}_{\infty}\cdot\bm{\rho}_j,\qquad
\rho_j \leq a. \end{array}\right.\label{eq : vc}\ ] ] now , by the faxen laws ( [ eq : faxen_laws ] ) the contribution to velocity and angular velocity of another sphere ( say number @xmath26 ) immersed in such flow is @xmath97 @xmath98 for the case of @xmath83 , the form of @xmath99 , @xmath100 is expressed using ( [ eq : faxen_laws ] ) and ( [ eq : vc ] ) in terms of differential operators @xmath101\overleftarrow{\bm{\nabla}}\right\}:\mathbf{e}_{\infty},\label{eq : c_hasimoto_def-1}\ ] ] @xmath102\overleftarrow{\bm{\nabla}}\right\}:\mathbf{e}_{\infty},\label{eq : c_r_definition-1}\ ] ] where @xmath103 denotes derivation with respect to @xmath104 and @xmath105_{\alpha\beta\gamma}=\partial_{\gamma}t_{\alpha\beta}(\mathbf{r}_{ij})$ ] .
this allows to write down the final results in the following form @xmath106 _ { \alpha\beta\gamma}=\left\ { \begin{array}{c } \frac{5}{6 } a \left[-\frac{16}{5}\frac{a^{4}}{r_{ij}^{4}}\hat{r}_{ij}^{\gamma}\delta_{\alpha\beta}+\left(-3\frac{a^{2}}{r_{ij}^{2}}+8\frac{a^{4}}{r_{ij}^{4}}\right)\hat{r}_{ij}^{\alpha}\hat{r}_{ij}^{\beta}\hat{r}_{ij}^{\gamma}\right],\qquad r_{ij}>2a,\\ \\ \frac{5}{6 } a \left[\left(-\frac{3}{5}\frac{r_{ij}}{a}+\frac{1}{4}\frac{r_{ij}^{2}}{a^{2}}\right)\hat{r}_{ij}^{\gamma}\delta_{\alpha\beta}-\frac{1}{16}\frac{r_{ij}^{2}}{a^{2}}\hat{r}_{ij}^{\alpha}\hat{r}_{ij}^{\beta}\hat{r}_{ij}^{\gamma}\right],\qquad r_{ij}\leq2a , \end{array}\right.\label{eq : ct}\ ] ] with the respective limit in the self case @xmath107 @xmath108 _ { \alpha\beta\gamma}=\left\ { \begin{array}{c } -\frac{5}{2}\left(\frac{a}{r_{ij}}\right)^{3}\epsilon_{\alpha\beta\zeta}\hat{r}_{ij}^{\zeta}\hat{r}_{ij}^{\gamma},\qquad r_{ij}>2a,\\ \\ -\frac{5}{2 } \left(\frac{3}{16}\frac{r_{ij}}{a}-\frac{1}{32}\frac{r_{ij}^{3}}{a^{3}}\right)\epsilon_{\alpha\beta\zeta}\hat{r}_{ij}^{\zeta}\hat{r}_{ij}^{\gamma},\qquad r_{ij}\leq2a , \end{array}\right.\label{eq : cr}\ ] ] and in the self case as limit @xmath109 the expressions for @xmath84 in ( [ eq : ct ] ) and ( [ eq : cr ] ) vanish for @xmath110 and match with the @xmath83 expressions at @xmath111 .
note that ( [ eq : c_hasimoto_def-1 ] ) and ( [ eq : c_r_definition-1 ] ) do not determine @xmath112 and @xmath113 uniquely , since they define only the symmetric and traceless parts of mobility matrix .
given this freedom , in ( [ eq : ct])-([eq : mu_rdself ] ) we take the matrices in the simplest algebraic form .
this completes our derivation making all the terms in mobility equation ( [ eq : generalmobilitymatrixseparatedc ] ) directly computable under the rotne - prager - yamakawa approximation .
it is now a straightforward task to demonstrate the positive definiteness of the mobility matrix given by ( [ eq : ypq ] ) . @xcite
provide a simple proof of positive definiteness of a quadratic form such as in ( [ eq : ypq ] ) , which we will now summarize .
consider the following quadratic form @xmath114 where @xmath115 is a complex valued function and the upper star is complex conjugation . we will show that from positive definiteness of @xmath116 follows that @xmath117 is positive definite . let @xmath118 where @xmath119 denotes an arbitrary vector .
now we write @xmath120 which ends the proof . note that the above proof of positivity does not hold for the point - force model ( [ eq : point_force ] ) . in this case
the off - diagonal ( @xmath121 ) terms of the mobility matrix can be cast in the form ( [ eq : ypq ] ) using @xmath122 .
the diagonal terms , however , would then become infinite due to the singularity at @xmath123 .
this problem is circumvented in the formulation ( [ eq : point_force ] ) by using single - particle mobilities @xmath124 for the diagonal terms .
however , the resulting point - force mobility matrix is not positive definite for arbitrary configuration , thus can not be used in brownian dynamics simulations .
in this section we consider a general case of particles interacting hydrodynamically e.g. in confined geometry , periodic boundary conditions or in the presence of interfaces .
we assume that for a given geometry a positive - definite green s function , @xmath125 , can be derived .
such solutions have indeed been constructed , e.g. for systems bounded by a cylinder and a sphere @xcite , for periodic system @xcite as well as for the system bounded by one @xcite and two walls @xcite .
we define the rotne - prager - yamakawa approximation for the positive definite mobility matrix in analogous way to ( [ eq : ypq ] ) @xmath126^{\mathrm{t}}\cdot \mathbf{t(r',r''})\cdot \mathbf{w}_{j}^{q}(\mathbf{r '' } ) .
\label{011}\ ] ] to clarify notation we introduce differential operators @xmath127 @xmath128 _ { \alpha \beta } = -\frac{1}{2}\epsilon _ { \alpha \beta \gamma } \frac{\partial } { \partial r_{\gamma } } , \quad \left [ \overleftarrow{\mathbf{d}^{r}}(\mathbf{r})\right ] _ { \alpha \beta } = \frac{1}{2}\epsilon _ { \alpha \beta \gamma } \overleftarrow{\frac{\partial } { \partial r_{\gamma } } } .
\label{008}\ ] ] where arrow points to the direction of action of differentiation operator .
we rewrite ( [ eq : v0 t ] ) and ( [ eq : v0r ] ) using these operators @xmath129 for the external flow @xmath130 which is regular ( has no sources within sphere @xmath26 ) , by the use of the definition of @xmath131 ( [ eq : wtr ] ) , the faxen laws may be written in analogy to ( [ eq : faxen_laws ] ) @xmath132^{t } \cdot \mathbf{v}_0 ( \mathbf{r } ' ) d \sigma ' = \overrightarrow{\mathbf{d}^{t}}(\mathbf{r}_{i})\cdot \mathbf{v}_0 ( \mathbf{r}_i ) , \quad \bm{\omega}_i = \int_{s_i } \left [ \mathbf{w}^{r}_i ( \mathbf{r } ' ) \right]^{t } \cdot \mathbf{v}_0 ( \mathbf{r } ' ) d \sigma ' = \overrightarrow{\mathbf{d}^{r}}(\mathbf{r}_{i})\cdot \mathbf{v}_0 ( \mathbf{r}_i ) .
\label{eq : faxen_laws_general}\ ] ] we can now write down the rotne - prager - yamakawa mobilities for the unbounded space ( for oseen propagator @xmath133 for@xmath134 using the differential operators @xmath135 now we decompose the arbitrary propagator @xmath136 as follows @xmath137 + \mathbf{t}_{0}(\mathbf{r}'-\mathbf{r}'')=\mathbf{t}^{\prime } ( \mathbf{r}',\mathbf{r}'')+\mathbf{t}_{0}(\mathbf{r}'-\mathbf{r } '' ) .
\label{012}\ ] ] the operator @xmath138 has no singularities at @xmath139 , thus see ( [ eq : faxen_laws_general ] ) , it has the property @xmath140 using ( [ 012 ] ) and ( [ 013 ] ) we can cast the mobility @xmath141 in the following form @xmath142 \nonumber \\ & = & \overrightarrow{\mathbf{d}^{p}}(\mathbf{r}_{i})\cdot \mathbf{t}(\mathbf{r}_{i},\mathbf{r}_{j})\cdot \overleftarrow{\mathbf{d}^{q}}(\mathbf{r}_{j})+\mathbf{y}^{pq}\mathbf{(r}_{ij } ) .
\label{014}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the correction @xmath143 is non zero only for @xmath144 and is independent of the propagator @xmath145 .
we write down explicitly the corrections for all components of the mobility matrix ( [ eq : mutt_final]),([eq : murr_final]),([eq : murt_final ] ) @xmath146 \right .
\\ & & \left .
-\frac{1}{8\pi\eta r_{ij}}\left[\left(1+\frac{2a^{2}}{3r_{ij}^{2}}\right)\mathbf{1}+\left(1-\frac{2a^{2}}{r_{ij}^{2}}\right)\hat{\mathbf{r}}_{ij}\hat{\mathbf{r}}_{ij}\right ] \right\ } , \end{array}\ ] ] @xmath147 \right . \\ & & \left .
+ \frac{1}{16\pi\eta r_{ij}^{3}}\left(\mathbf{1}-3\hat{\mathbf{r}}_{ij}\hat{\mathbf{r}}_{ij}\right ) \right\ } , \end{array}\ ] ] @xmath148 for the self case , @xmath149 the mobility @xmath150 is obtained from eq .
( [ 014 ] , upper line ) in the limit @xmath151 @xmath152 + \frac{1}{\mathbf{\varsigma } _ { 0}^{pq}}. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] to sum up , we have shown how to evaluate the rotne - prager - yamakawa approximation for an arbitrary propagator @xmath145 by applying to @xmath145 the differential operators in order to avoid the explicit and often infeasible surface integration .
this allows one to construct the positive definite hydrodynamic tensors in systems with non - trivial geometry ( e.g. in the presence of a wall , in a channel or in periodic systems ) .
for example , taking in ( [ 014 ] ) the green s function for a stokeslet in the presence of a wall @xcite leads ( for non - overlapping spheres ) to the rotne - prager - blake tensor derived before by @xcite , see also @xcite , and @xcite .
however , these authors did not derive the regularizing correction for this tensor , which also prevented them from obtaining the self - term in a manner analogous to our eq .
( [ 015 ] ) . on a final note ,
let us stress that the regularizing correction ( [ eq : y_correction ] ) has the same simple analytical form in all cases , independently of the particular green s function @xmath145 .
in this paper , we have re - visited the problem of constructing rotne - prager - yamakawa approximation for mobility and shear disturbance matrices .
a systematic method was presented which allows one to derive the rpy approximation in a systematic way , for translational , rotational and dipolar components of the generalized mobility matrix , both for non - overlapping and overlapping particles .
the regularization corrections for translational - rotational and rotational - rotational mobility tensors have not been previously derived .
these regularizations are crucial in obtaining positive - definite hydrodynamic matrices , which is essential for the brownian dynamics simulations .
the positive definiteness also allows for the evaluation of the diffusion tensor and mobility for the bead models ( including overlapping beads ) of complicated molecules .
additionally , we have shown how our approach can be generalized to other boundary conditions and corresponding propagators .
+ ew and km acknowledge the support of the polish national science centre ( grant no 2012/05/b / st8/03010 ) .
pjz acknowledges support of the foundation for polish science ( fnp ) through team/2010 - 6/2 project co - financed by the eu european regional development fund .
ps acknowledges the support of the polish ministry of science and higher education ( grant no n n202 055440 ) .
35 natexlab#1#1 2012 fibrinogen conformations and charge in electrolyte solutions derived from dls and dynamic viscosity measurements .
_ j. colloid interface sci . _ * 385 * , 244257 .
2013 on the importance of hydrodynamic interactions in lipid membrane formation .
_ biophys .
j. _ * 104 * , 96105 .
2005 hydrodynamic interactions of spherical particles in suspensions confined between two planar walls .
_ j. fluid mech . _ * 541 * , 263292 .
1971 a note on the image system for a stokeslet in a no - slip boundary . _
camb . philos .
soc . _ * 70 * , 303 .
1991 stokesian dynamics simulations of particle trajectories near a plane .
fluids a _ * 3 * , 1853 .
1988 stokesian dynamics .
fluid mech . _ * 20 * , 111157 .
1994 friction and mobility of many spheres in stokes flow .
_ j. chem .
phys . _ * 100 * , 37803790 .
2000 friction and mobility for colloidal spheres in stokes flow near a boundary : the multipole method and applications .
_ j. chem .
phys . _ * 112 * , 25482561 .
1996 _ an introduction to dynamics of colloids_. elsevier science .
1978 brownian dynamics with hydrodynamic interactions . _ j. chem .
phys . _ * 69 * , 1352 .
1988 many - body hydrodynamic interactions in suspensions . _
physica a _ * 151 * , 116 .
2009 striking effects of hydrodynamic interactions on the simulated diffusion and folding of proteins .
_ j. chem .
theory comput . _
* 5 * , 242256 .
2009 fluid transport at low reynolds number with magnetically actuated artificial cilia .
j. e _ * 28 * , 231242 .
1959 on the periodic fundamental solutions of the stokes equations and their application to viscous flow past a cubic array of spheres .
_ j. fluid .
* 5 * , 317328 .
1991 _ microhydrodynamics : principles and selected applications_. london : butterworth - heinemann .
2006 electro - osmosis at inhomogeneous charged surfaces : hydrodynamic versus electric friction .
_ j. chem .
phys . _ * 124 * , 114709 .
1989 coil - stretch transitions in mixed shear and extensional flows of dilute polymer solutions
. _ macromolecules _ * 22 * , 30043010 .
1978 stokes flow due to a stokeslet in a pipe .
_ j. fluid .
_ * 86 * , 727744 .
1896 a general theorem concerning the motion of a viscous fluid and a few consequences derived from it .
* 5 * , 168175 .
1982 many - sphere hydrodynamic interactions and mobilities in a suspension . _
physica a _ * 115 * , 2157 .
2006 brownian dynamics simulations . in _ computational condensed matter physics _
s. blgel , g. gompper , e. koch , h. mller - krumbhaar , r. spatschek & r. g. winkler ) .
forschungszentrum jlich .
1927 _ neuere methoden und ergebnisse in der hydrodynamik_. akademische verlagsgesellschaft .
1981 hydrodynamic interaction effects on local motions of chain molecules .
_ j. chem .
_ * 74 * , 6922 .
1992 _ boundary integral and singularity methods for linearized viscous flow_. cambridge university press .
2006 hydrodynamic interactions in colloidal and biological systems .
phd thesis , university konstanz .
1969 variational treatment of hydrodynamic interaction in polymers .
_ j. chem .
phys . _ * 50 * , 48314837 .
2005 the dynamics of single - molecule dna in flow .
_ j. non - newton .
* 130 * , 128 .
2010 controlled surface - induced flows from the motion of self - assembled colloidal walkers .
usa _ * 107 * , 535540 .
2011 hydrodynamic effects in proteins . _ j. phys . : condens . matter _ * 23 * , 033102 .
2001 interplay between wetting and phase separation in binary fluid mixtures : roles of hydrodynamics .
_ j. phys . :
* 13 * , 46374674
. 2007 improved calculation of rotational diffusion and intrinsic viscosity of bead models for macromolecules and nanoparticles .
_ j. phys . chem .
b _ * 111 * , 955961
. 2007 transverse migration of a confined polymer driven by an external force .
lett . _ * 98 * , 098301 .
2004 brownian dynamics : divergence of mobility tensor .
_ physica a _ * 335 * , 339358 .
1998 influence of hydrodynamic interactions on the kinetics of colloidal particles adsorption .
lett . _ * 80 * , 754757 .
1970 transport properties of polymer chains in dilute solution : hydrodynamic interaction . _ j. chem .
phys . _ * 53 * , 436443 .
the configuration of the two spheres @xmath26 and @xmath41 and the notation is presented in figure 1 .
the @xmath153 axis is chosen in the direction of the vector @xmath154 connecting the centres of the spheres .
the variable @xmath155 is a position vector with respect to the centre of the sphere @xmath26 and @xmath53 - a position vector with respect to the centre of the sphere @xmath41 . to demonstrate the method it is enough to calculate explicitly one of the integrals appearing in ( 3.6)-(3.7 ) and ( 3.21)-(3.22 ) .
we take the first one , @xmath156 the integration is performed over the surface of sphere @xmath26 , thus @xmath155 is expressed in spherical coordinates @xmath157 associated with sphere @xmath26 which leads to @xmath158+\frac{1}{2\zeta^{tt}}\mathbf{1}\left(1-\frac{r_{ij}}{2a}\right),\label{eq : mu_general_appendix}\ ] ] where @xmath159 is the meridional angle at which the two spheres intersect ( see figure 1 ) , defined by @xmath160 and the vector @xmath161 in the cartesian basis has the form @xmath162 the last term in ( [ eq : mu_general_appendix ] ) results from integration of the @xmath163 expression in ( 3.2 ) from @xmath164 to @xmath165 .
all the azimuthal integrals in ( [ eq : mu_general_appendix ] ) are easily calculated to yield @xmath166\nonumber \\ & & + \frac{3}{16\zeta^{tt}}\hat{\mathbf{r}}_{ij}\hat{\mathbf{r}}_{ij}\int_{0}^{\theta_{0}}\mathrm{d}\theta\sin\theta\left(\frac{a^{3}}{r^{\prime3}}-\frac{a^{5}}{r^{\prime5}}\right)\left[2\left(\frac{r_{ij}}{a}+\cos\theta\right)^{2}-\sin^{2}\theta\right],\label{eq : app_mu_tt}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and for the choice of coordinate axes as in figure 1 we have @xmath167.\label{eq : rr}\ ] ] the calculation of @xmath168 is now straightforward .
since @xmath169 @xmath170 @xmath171 @xmath172 @xmath173 @xmath174 the @xmath175 component of the mobility matrix takes the form @xmath176,\label{eq : app_mu_tt_final}\ ] ] as in ( 3.11 ) . | rotne - prager - yamakawa approximation is one of the most commonly used methods of including hydrodynamic interactions in modelling of colloidal suspensions and polymer solutions .
the two main merits of this approximation is that it includes all long - range terms ( i.e. decaying as @xmath0 or slower in interparticle distances ) and that the diffusion matrix is positive definite , which is essential for brownian dynamics modelling . here , we extend the rotne - prager - yamakawa approach to include both translational and rotational degrees of freedom , and derive the regularizing corrections to account for overlapping particles .
additionally , we show how the rotne - prager - yamakawa approximation can be generalized for other geometries and boundary conditions . |
flavor changing neutral current ( fcnc ) @xmath7 transitions are forbidden in the standard model ( sm ) at tree level that occur at loop level , and therefore provide consistency check of the sm at quantum level .
these decays induced by the fcnc are also very sensitive to the new physics beyond the sm . new physics embedded into rare decays through the wilson coefficients which can take values different from their sm counterpart or through the new operator structures in an effective hamiltonian ( see @xcite and references therein ) . among the hadronic , leptonic and semileptonic decays , the last decay channels are very significant , since they are theoretically , more or less , clean , and they have relatively larger branching ratio .
from theoretical side there are many works in which the semileptonic decay channels due to @xmath7 transitions are investigated .
these decays contain many observables like forward backward asymmetry @xmath1 , lepton polarization asymmetries , etc .
, which are very useful and serve as a testing ground for the sm and looking for new physics beyond the sm @xcite . from experimental side ,
belle @xcite and babar @xcite collaborations provide recent measurements of the branching ratios of the semileptonic decays due to the @xmath8 transitions , which can be summarized as : ( b k^^+ ^- ) \
{ lc ( 16.5^+2.3_-2.2 0.9 0.4 ) 10 ^ -7 & @xcite , + + ( 7.8^+1.9_-1.7 1.2 ) 10 ^ -7 & @xcite , .
+ + b(b k ^+ ^- ) \ { lc ( 5.5^+0.75_-0.70 0.27 0.02 ) 10 ^ -7 & @xcite , + + ( 3.4 0.7 0.3 ) 10 ^ -7 & @xcite . .
+ + b(b x_s ^+ ^- ) \ { lc ( 4.11 0.83^+0.85_-0.81 ) 10 ^ -6 & @xcite , + + ( 5.6 1.5 0.6 1.1 ) 10 ^ -6 & @xcite . .
another exclusive decay which is described at inclusive level by the @xmath9 transition is the baryonic @xmath10 decay . unlike mesonic decays , the baryonic decays could maintain the helicity structure of the effective hamiltonian for the @xmath11 transition @xcite .
radiative and semileptonic decays of @xmath12 such as @xmath13 , @xmath14 , @xmath0 @xmath15 and @xmath16 have been extensively studied in the literature @xcite@xcite . more about heavy baryons , including the experimental prospects , can be found in @xcite . among the various models of physics beyond the sm
, extra dimensions attract special interest , because they include gravity in addition other interactions , giving hints on the hierarchy problem and a connection with string theory .
the model of appelquist , cheng and dobrescu ( acd ) @xcite with one universal extra dimension ( ued ) , where all the sm particles can propagate in the extra dimension , are very attractive .
compactification of the extra dimension leads to kaluza
klein ( kk ) model in the four dimension .
in this model the only additional free parameter with respect to the sm is @xmath2 , i.e. , inverse of the compactification radius .
the restrictions imposed on ued are examined in the current accelerators , for example , tevatron experiments put the bound about @xmath17 .
analysis of the anomalous magnetic moment @xcite , and @xmath18 vertex @xcite also lead to the bound @xmath17 .
possible manifestation of ued models in the @xmath19@xmath20 mass difference , parameter @xmath21 , @xmath22@xmath23 mixing , @xmath24 mass difference , and rare decays @xmath25 , @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 , @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 , @xmath32 and @xmath33 are comprehensively investigated in @xcite and @xcite .
exclusive @xmath34 , @xmath35 and @xmath36 decays are studied in the framework of the ued scenario in @xcite . in the present work we study the @xmath0 decay in the ued model .
the plan of the paper is as follows . in section 2
we briefly discuss the main ingredients of acd model and study the rare @xmath0 decay in it .
section 3 is devoted to the numerical analysis and conclusions .
before presenting a detailed derivation of the matrix element of @xmath37 decay , let us discuss the main ingredients of acd model , which is the minimal extension of the sm in @xmath38 dimensions , and we consider the simplest case @xmath39 . the five dimensional acd model with a single ued uses orbifold compactification .
the fifth dimension that is compactified in a circle of radius @xmath40 , with points @xmath41 and @xmath42 that are fixed points of the orbifolds .
generalization to the sm is realized by the propagating fermions , gauge bosons and the higgs fields in all five dimensions .
the lagrangian can be written as = d^4x dy \ { l_a + l_h + l_f + l_y } , where _ a - w^mna w_mn^a - b^mn b_mn , + l_h ( d^m ) ^_m - v ( ) , + l_f | q ( i ^m d_m ) q + |u ( i ^m d_m ) u + | d ( i ^m d_m ) d , + l_y - | q _
u ^c u - | q _
d + .here @xmath43 and @xmath44 running over 0,1,2,3,5 are the five dimensional lorentz indices , @xmath45 are the field strength tensor for the @xmath46 electroweak gauge group , @xmath47 are that of the @xmath48 group , and all fields depend both on @xmath49 and @xmath50 . the covariant derivative is defined as @xmath51 , where @xmath52 and @xmath53 are the five dimensional gauge couplings for the @xmath46 and @xmath48 groups . the five
dimensional @xmath54 matrices are defined as @xmath55 and @xmath56 . in the case
o a single extra dimension with coordinate @xmath57 compactified on a circle of radius @xmath40 , a field @xmath58 would be periodic function of @xmath50 , hence can be written as f(x , y)=_n=-^+ f_n(x ) e^iny / r .
the fourier expansion of the fields are b_(x , y ) b_^(0 ) + _ n=1^
b_^(0 ) ( x ) ( ) , + b_5(x , y ) _ n=1^
b_5^(n ) ( ) , + q(x , y ) _
n=1^ , + u(d)(x , y ) u_r^(0 ) + _
n=1^ .under parity transformation @xmath59 fields having a correspondent in the four dimensional sm should be even , so that their zero mode in the kk can be interpreted as the ordinary sm field .
fields having no correspondent in the sm should be odd . from this expansion
we see that fifth component of the vector field is odd under @xmath60 transformation .
one important property of acd model is the kk parity is conserved .
the parity conservation leads to the result that there is no tree level contribution of kk modes in low energy processes ( at the scale @xmath61 ) and single kk excitation can not be produced in ordinary particle interaction .
finally note that in the acd model there are three additional physical scalar modes @xmath62 and @xmath63 .
the zero mode is either right handed or left handed .
the nonzero modes come in chiral pair .
this chirality is a consequence of the orbifold boundary conditions .
lagrangian of the acd model can be obtained by integrating over @xmath57 _ 4 ( x ) = _ 0 ^ 2r l_5 ( x , y ) dy .note that the zero mode remains massless unless we apply the higgs mechanism .
all fields in the four dimensional lagrangian receive the kk mass @xmath64 on account of the derivative operator @xmath65 acting on them.the relevant feynman rules are derived in @xcite and for more details about the acd model we refer the interested reader to @xcite and @xcite . after this preliminary introduction ,
let us come back and discuss the main problem .
in this section we present the matrix element of @xmath5 decay , as well as expressions of the branching ratio , forward backward asymmetry and lepton polarizations . at quark level ,
@xmath0 decay is described by @xmath66 transition .
effective hamiltonian governing this transition in the sm with @xmath67 , @xmath68 is described in terms of a set of local operators [ e7601 ] h = v_tb v^_ts _ 1 ^ 10 c_i ( ) o_i ( ) , where @xmath69 is the fermi constant , @xmath70 are the elements of the cabibbo kobayashi maskawa ( ckm ) matrix .
explicit forms of the operators , which are written in terms of quark and gluon fields can be found in @xcite .
the wilson coefficients in ( [ e7601 ] ) have been computed at nnlo in the sm in @xcite . at nlo
the coefficients are calculated for the acd model including the effects of kk modes , in @xcite and @xcite , which we have used in our calculations .
it should be noted here that , there does not appear any new operator in the acd model , and therefore , new effects are implemented by modifying the wilson coefficients existing in the sm , if we neglect the contributions of the scalar fields , which are indeed very small . at @xmath71 level , only @xmath72 , @xmath73 , @xmath74 , @xmath75 and @xmath76 are different from zero , and the remaining coefficients are all zero . in the following
we do not consider the contribution to @xmath5 decay from the lepton pair being created from @xmath77 resonance due to the @xmath78 operators .
it can be removed by applying appropriate cuts to invariant dilepton mass around mass of the resonance . in the sm , at quark level , @xmath0 decay is described with the help of the operators @xmath79 , @xmath80 and @xmath81 as follows : [ e7602 ] h_eff v_tb v^_ts \
{ c_7 |s i _ ( 1 + _ 5 ) q^|^+ c_9 |s _
( 1-_5 ) b | ^ + c_10 |s _
( 1-_5 ) b | ^ _ 5 } .
the renormalization scheme independent coefficient @xmath82 @xcite is given by [ e7603 ] c_7^(0)eff(_b ) ^ c_7^(0)(_w)+ ( ^ -^ ) c_8^(0)(_w)+c_2^(0)(_w ) _
i=1 ^ 8 h_i ^_i , where , and c_2^(0)(_w)=1 , c_7^(0)(_w)=- d^(x_t,1/r ) , c_8^(0)(_w)=- e^(x_t,1/r ) , with the superscript @xmath83 referring to leading log approximation , and coefficients @xmath84 and @xmath85 are given as a_1 , a_2= , a_3= , a_4=- , a_5= 0.4086 , a_6=-0.4230 , + a_7 -0.8994 , a_8=0.1456 + + h_1 2.2996 , h_2=-1.0880 , h_3=- , h_4=- , h_5=-0.6494 , h_6=-0.0380 , + h_7 -0.0185 , h_8=-0.0057 the functions @xmath86 and @xmath87 , which describe electromagnetic and chromomagnetic penguins , respectively , are calculated in @xcite and @xcite , and lead to the following results ( see also @xcite ) [ e7604 ] d^_0(x_t ) - + x_t , + + [ e7605 ] e^_0(x_t ) - + x_t , + + [ e7606 ] d^_n(x_t , x_n ) + + , + + [ e7607 ] e^_n(x_t , x_n ) + x_n(1+x_n)(-1 + 3 x_n ) + , where the functions with and without @xmath88 correspond to the kk and sm excitation contributions , respectively . using the prescription presented in @xcite and @xcite , and summing over @xmath89 , we get the following expressions : [ e7608 ] _ n=1^d^_n(x_t , x_n ) + , + + [ e7609 ] _ n=1^e^_n(x_t ,
x_n ) + , where [ e76010 ] j(r,)=_0 ^ 1 dy y^ .
the wilson coefficient @xmath80 in the acd model and in the ndr scheme is [ e7611 ] c_9()=p_0^ndr+y(x_t,1/r ) ^2 _ w -4 z(x_t,1/r)+p_e
e(x_t,1/r ) , where @xmath90 @xcite and the last term is numerically negligible .
the functions @xmath91 and @xmath92 are defined as : [ e7612 ] y(x_t,1/r ) y_0(x_t)+_n=1^c_n(x_t , x_n ) , + z(x_t,1/r ) z_0(x_t)+_n=1^c_n(x_t , x_n ) , with [ e7613 ] y_0(x_t ) , + + z_0(x_t ) + x_t + + [ e7614 ] c_n(x_t , x_n ) , and [ e7615 ] _
n=1^c_n(x_t , x_n ) = - . finally the wilson coefficient @xmath81 , which is scale independent , is given by : [ e7616 ] c_10= - . with these coefficients and the operators in ( [ e7601 ] ) the inclusive @xmath93 transitions
have been studied in @xcite .
the amplitude of the exclusive @xmath94 decay is obtained by calculating the matrix element of the effective hamiltonian for the @xmath66 transition between initial and final baryon states @xmath95 .
it follows from eq .
( [ e7616 ] ) that the matrix elements [ e7117 ] & & |s _ ( 1 - _ 5 ) b _ b , + & & |s _ ( 1 + _ 5 ) b _ b , are needed in order to calculate the @xmath94 decay amplitude .
these matrix elements parametrized in terms of the form factors are as follows ( see @xcite ) [ e7618 ] |s _ b _ b |u_u__b , + [ e7619 ] |s _ _ 5 b _
b |u_u__b , where @xmath96 .
the form factors of the magnetic dipole operators are defined as [ e7620 ] using the identity _ _ 5 = - _
^ , the following relations between the form factors are obtained : [ e7621 ] f_1^t - f_3^t , + g_1^t g_3^t .
using these definitions of the form factors , for the matrix element of the @xmath94 we get [ e7622 ] m v_tbv_ts^ \ { | _ ( 1-_5 ) |u_u__b + f_1^t+g_1^t ( -2 m_b c_7 ) + f_1-g_1 c_9^eff , + a_2 a_1 1 2 , + a_3 a_1 1 3 , + b_1 a_1 g_1 - g_1 ; g_1^t - g_1^t , + b_2 b_1 1 2 , + b_3 b_1 1 3 , + d_1 c_10 f_1-g_1 , + d_2 d_1 1 2 , + d_3 d_1 1 3 , + e_1 d_1 g_1 - g_1 , + e_2 e_1 1 2 , + e_3 e_1 1 3 . from these expressions
it follows that @xmath97 decay is described in terms of many form factors .
it is shown in @xcite that heavy quark effective theory reduces the number of independent form factors to two ( @xmath98 and @xmath99 ) irrelevant of the dirac structure of the corresponding operators , i.e. , [ e7624 ] ( p _ ) |s b ( p__b ) = |u_u__b , where @xmath100 is an arbitrary dirac structure and @xmath101 is the four velocity of @xmath12 . comparing the general form of the form factors given in eqs .
( [ e7617])([e7620 ] ) with ( [ e7623 ] ) , one can easily obtain the following relations among them ( see also @xcite ) [ e7625 ] g_1 f_1 = f_2^t= g_2^t = f_1 + f_2 , + g_2 f_2 = g_3 = f_3 = , + g_1^t f_1^t = q^2 , + g_3^t m__b + m _ , + f_3^t - m__b - m _
, where @xmath102 . in what follows
, we will be looking for the possible manifestation of ued theory in branching ratio , as well as in lepton polarizations .
for this purpose , we present the decay rate for the @xmath10 taking into account lepton polarizations . in th rest frame of lepton @xmath103 the unit vectors along the longitudinal , normal and transversal components of the @xmath103 are chosen as : [ e7626 ] s^-_l 0,_l^-= 0 , , + s^-_n 0,_n^-= 0 , , + s^-_t 0,_t^-= 0,_n^- _ l^- , where @xmath104 and @xmath105 are the three momenta of the leptons @xmath103 and @xmath106 baryon in the center of mass frame ( cm ) of @xmath107 system , respectively . the longitudinal component of the lepton polarization is boosted to the cm frame of the lepton pair by lorentz transformation , yielding [ e7627 ] s^-_l _ cm , , where @xmath108 and @xmath109 are the energy and mass of @xmath103 in the cm frame .
the remaining two unit vectors @xmath110 , @xmath111 are unchanged under lorentz boost .
the differential decay rate for @xmath0 decay along any spin direction @xmath112 along the @xmath113 can be written as : [ e7628 ] = _ 0 , where @xmath114 corresponds to the unpolarized differential decay rate , @xmath115 and @xmath116 , @xmath117 and @xmath118 represent the longitudinal , normal and transversal polarizations of @xmath119 , respectively , and has the following form : [ e7629 ] _ 0 = v_tb v_ts^^2 ^1/2(1,r , ) v , where @xmath120 is the triangle function and @xmath121 is the lepton velocity .
the polarizations @xmath116 , @xmath117 and @xmath118 are defined as : [ e7629 ] p_i^ ( ) ( ) = , where @xmath122 .
one of the efficient tools for establishing new physics effects is study of the forward backward asymmetry @xmath1 which is defined as _
fb = , where @xmath123 dependence of the differential decay rate can be implemented by making the replacement _ 0 ( ) + _ 2 ( ) _ 0()+t_1 ( ) z + t_2 ( ) z^2 , on the right - hand side of eq .
( [ e7628 ] ) , and @xmath124 is the angle between @xmath12 and @xmath103 in the cm of leptons .
explicit expressions of @xmath125 , @xmath126 and @xmath127 can be found in @xcite .
it is well known that in the @xmath34 decay the zero position of @xmath1 is practically independent of the form factors @xcite .
for this reason , determination of zero position of @xmath1 , as well as it magnitude , is very promising in looking for new physics beyond the sm .
note also that the combined analysis of the lepton polarizations can give additional information about the existence of new physics since in the sm @xmath128 , @xmath129 and @xmath130 ( in the @xmath131 limit ) .
therefore any nonzero value resulting from these combined polarizations can be considered as an confirmation of new physics .
in this section we present our numerical results for the polarization asymmetries @xmath116 , @xmath117 and @xmath118 when one of the leptons is polarized .
the values of the input parameters we use in our calculations are : @xmath132 , @xmath133 , @xmath134 .
@xmath135 @xcite , @xmath136 @xcite and @xmath137 . from the expressions of asymmetries
it follows that the form factors are the main and the most important input parameters necessary in the numerical calculations .
the calculation of the form factors of @xmath138 transition does not exist at present .
but , we can use the results from qcd sum rules in corporation with hqet @xcite .
we noted earlier that , hqet allows us to establish relations among the form factors and reduces the number of independent form factors into two . in @xcite , the @xmath139 dependence of these form factors
are given as follows f ( ) = .
the values of the parameters @xmath140 and @xmath141 are given in table 1 .
@xmath142 note that the first analysis of the hqet structure of the @xmath143 transition is performed in @xcite ( see also @xcite ) .
in order to have an idea about the sensitivity of our results to the specific parametrization of the two form factors predicted by the qcd sum rules in corporation with the hqet , we also have used another parametrization of the form factors based on the pole model and compared the results of both models .
the second set of form factors which have the dipole form predicted by the pole model are given as : f_1,2(e _ ) = n_1,2 ( ) ^2 , where e_= , and @xmath144 , @xmath145 and @xmath146 @xcite . in figs . 1 and 2 we present the dependence of the branching ratio for the @xmath147 and @xmath148 decays on the compactification parameter @xmath2 , respectively . for a comparison , in these figures we also present the sm prediction for this decay using both set of form factors . from these figures we se that the branching ratios are larger compared to the sm result for both decay modes and practically they are insensitive to the form factors .
the value of the branching ratio for @xmath4 is approximately @xmath3 larger compared to that of the sm prediction .
but this difference decreases as @xmath2 gets larger .
therefore measurement of the value of branching ratio of the @xmath97 , @xmath149 decays can serve as a good test for physics beyond the sm .
analysis of the lepton polarizations leads to the following results : * maximum value of the difference between the sm and adc models ( for the minimum value of @xmath4 ) predictions , as far as longitudinal polarization is concerned , is about @xmath150 . * practically , there is no difference between the predictions of the sm and acd models fo the @xmath151 lepton with longitudinal polarization . *
these two models lead to the same result for the @xmath152 lepton with transversal polarization case . *
up to @xmath153 , the maximum difference in the predictions of these two models is about @xmath154 for the @xmath151 lepton with transversal polarization case . *
normal polarization of lepton contributes very small and the difference between predictions of the two models for this polarization can never be measured in the experiments . for the @xmath151 lepton case
the difference @xmath155 is quite a challenging to be measured . from this discussion
we conclude that measurement of polarizations of lepton is not useful for establishing the ued models .
we can now discuss the prediction of the acd model for the forward backward asymmetry . in fig .
3 we show the dependence of of @xmath1 on @xmath156 at four fixed values of @xmath2 and sm , for the @xmath147 decay when the first set of form factors are considered . for the sake of completeness , we also present in this figure the forward
backward asymmetry prediction of sm . from this figure
we see that the zero position of @xmath1 is sensitive to the compactification parameter @xmath2 , similar to the @xmath34 decay case and in all cases it is shifted to the left compared to that of the sm prediction . therefore , experimental determination of zero position @xmath1 can give invaluable information about new physics effects . it should be noted that the zero position of @xmath1 is practically insensitive to the choice of form factors and it coincides for both sets . in conclusion
, we have studied the rare @xmath97 decay in the acd model with a single universal extra dimension .
we investigate the sensitivity of the branching ratio , lepton polarizations and lepton forward
backward asymmetry in the @xmath97 decay to the compactification parameter @xmath2 .
we found that the branching ratio and zero position of the forward
backward asymmetry are very sensitive to the presence of the compactification parameter @xmath2 and can be useful for establishing new physics effects due to the compactification of the fifth dimension .
one of the authors ( t. m. a ) is grateful to tbitak for partially support of this work under the project 105t131 . 99 t. m. aliev , m. savci , jhep * 05 * ( 2006 ) 1 .
et al . _ ,
belle collaboration , prep : hep ex/0410006 ( 2004 ) .
m. iwasaki _
et al . _ ,
belle collaboration , phys .
rev . * d72 * , 092005 ( 2005 ) .
b. aubert _ et .
al _ , babar collaboration , prep : hep ex/0507005 ( 2005 ) .
b. aubert _ et .
al _ , babar collaboration , phys .
93 * , 081802 ( 2004 ) .
t. mannel and s. recksiegel , j. phys .
g * 24 * , 979 ( 1998 ) .
p. bialas , j. g. krner , m. krmer , and k. zalewski , z. phys .
c * 57 * , 115 ( 1993 ) ; f. hussain , j. g. krner , and r. migneron , phys .
b * 248 * , 406 ( 1990 ) ; * 252 * 723 ( e ) ( 1990 ) ; j. g. krner and m. krmer , phys . lett .
b * 275*,495 ( 1992 ) ; t. mannel and g. a. schuler , phys .
d * 279 * , 194 ( 1992 ) ; m. gronau and s. wakaizumi , phys .
d * 47 * , 1262 ( 1993 ) ; m. tanaka , phys .
d * 47 * , 4969 ( 1993 ) ; m. gronau , t. hasuike , t. hattori , z. hioki , t. hayashi , and s. wakaizumi , j. phys .
g * 19 * , 1987 ( 1993 ) ; z. hioki , z. phys .
c * 59 * , 555 ( 1993 ) ; b. knig , j. g. krner , and m. krmer , phys .
d * 49 * , 2363 ( 1994 ) ; m. gremm , g. kpp , and l. m. sehgal , phys .
d * 52 * , 1588 ( 1995 ) ; c. s. huang and h. g. yan , phys .
d * 56 * , 5981 ( 1997 ) ; s. balk , j. g. krner , and d. pirjol , eur .
j. c * 1 * , 221 ( 1998 ) ; j. g. krner and d. pirjol , phys .
b * 334 * , 399 ( 1994 ) ; phys .
d * 60 * , 014021 ( 1999 ) .
m. gremm , f. krger , and l. m. sehgal , phys .
b * 355 * , 579 ( 1995 ) ; t. mannel and s. recksiegel , acta phys .
b * 28 * , 2489 ( 1997 ) ; c. k. chua , x. g. he , and w. s. hou , phys . rev .
d * 60 * , 014003 ( 1999 ) ; g. hiller and a. kagan , phys .
d * 65 * , 074038 ( 2002 ) .
m. krmer and h. simma , nucl .
* 50 * , 125 ( 1996 ) .
c. h. chen and c. q. geng , and j. n. ng , phys .
d * 65 * , 091502 ( 2002 ) .
t. m. aliev , a. zpineci , m. savci , and c. yce , phys .
b * 542 * , 229 ( 2002 ) .
c. h. chen and c. q. geng , phys .
d * 63 * , 054005 ( 2001 ) .
t. m. aliev , a. zpineci , and m. savci , phys .
d * 65 * , 115002 ( 2002 ) ; + t. m. aliev , m. savci , j. phys .
g * 26 * , 997 ( 2000 ) .
t. m. aliev , a. zpineci , and m. savci , nucl .
b * 649 * , 1681 ( 2003 ) .
t. m. aliev , a. zpineci , and m. savci , phys .
d * 67 * , 035007 ( 2003 ) .
t. m. aliev , v. bashiry , and m. savci , nucl .
b * 709 * , 115 ( 2005 ) .
j. g. krner , m. krmer , and d. pirjol , prog .
phys . * 33 * , 787 ( 1994 ) .
et al . _ , report of snowmass 2001 working group e2 : electron positron colliders from the @xmath157 to the @xmath158 , in _ proc . of the aps / dpf / dpb summer study on the future of particle physics ( snowmass 2001 ) _ ed .
r. davidson and c. quigg , hep ex/0201047 ( 2002 ) .
t. appelquist , h. c. cheng and b. a. dobrescu , phys . rev . *
d64 * , 035002 ( 2001 ) .
k. agashe , n. g. deshpande and g. h. wu , phys .
b * 511 * , 85 ( 2001 ) ; t. appelquist and b. a. dobrescu , phys .
b * 516 * , 85 ( 2001 ) .
j. f. oliver , j. papavissiliou and a. santamaria , phys . rev .
* d67 * , 056002 ( 2002 ) .
a. j. buras , m. sprangler and a. weiler , nucl .
b * d660 * , 225 ( 2003 ) . a. j. buras , a. poschenrieder , m. spranger nucl . phys .
b * d678 * , 455 ( 2004 ) .
p. colangelo , f. de fazio , r. ferrandes , t. n. pham , prep : hep ph/0604029 ( 2006 ) . c. bobeth , m. misiak and j. urban , nucl .
b * 574 * , 291 ( 2001 ) ; a. ghinculov , t. hurth , g. isidori and y. p. yao , nucl .
b * 685 * , 351 ( 2004 ) ; c. bobeth , p. cambino , m. gorbahn and u. haisch , jhep * 0404 * , 071 ( 2004 ) . a. buras , m. misiak , m. mnz and s. pokorski , nucl .
b * 424 * , 374 ( 1994 ) .
m. misiak , nucl .
b * 393 * , 23 ( 1993 ) ; erratum ibid b * 439 * , 161 ( 1995 ) ; b. buras , m. mnz , phys . rev .
d * 52 * , 186 ( 1995 ) .
g. burdman , phys . rev .
d * 52 * , 6400 ( 1995 ) .
c. h. chen and c. q. geng , phys .
d * 64 * , 074001 ( 2001 ) .
t. mannel , w. roberts , and z. ryzak , nucl .
b * 355 * , 38 ( 1991 ) .
s. eidelman _
et al . _ , particle data group , phys .
b * 592 * , 1 ( 2004 ) .
cdf collaboration , prep : hep ex/0507091 . c. s. huang , h. g. yan , phys .
d * 59 * , 114022 ( 1999 ) .
f. hussain , j. g. krner , m. kramer and g. thompson , z. phys .
c * 51 * , 321 ( 1991 ) .
f. hussain , d. liu , j. g. krner , m. kramer and s. tawfiq , nucl .
b * 370 * , 259 ( 1992 ) .
c. h. chen , c. q. geng , phys .
d * 64 * , 114024 ( 2001 ) .
1 * the dependence of the branching ratio for the @xmath159 decay on the compactification parameter @xmath2 , for the first set of form factors i and the second set of form factors ii , respctively . + + * fig .
2 * the same as fig . 1 , but for the @xmath160 decay .
+ + * fig .
3 * the dependence of the forward backward asymmetry @xmath6 on @xmath156 at four fixed values of @xmath2 and in the sm , for the @xmath159 decay . | we study the exclusive @xmath0 decay in the appelquist , chang , dobrescu model within one universal extra dimension .
we investigate the sensitivity of the branching ratio , lepton polarization and forward backward asymmetry @xmath1 to the compactification parameter @xmath2 we obtain that the branching ratio changed about @xmath3 compared to the sm value , when @xmath4 and zero position of the forward backward asymmetry is shifted to the left compared to the sm result .
therefore measurement of the branching ratio of @xmath5 decay and determination of zero position of @xmath6 are very useful in looking for new physics in the framework of the ued models . 0^*0
5_5 s_s^ ? ?
o _ ^0
_ pacs numbers : 12.60.i , 13.30.a , 14.20.mr |
l1527 irs is a class 0 protostar , at a distance of @xmath1140 pc , in its earliest stages of formation .
it has a mass of @xmath10.2 solar masses and is surrounded by a flared rotating envelope of about one solar mass , as recently reported by @xcite who observed it in the continuum ( at 1.3 and 3.4 mm wavelength ) and on the @xmath9co(2 - 1 ) line using the submillimeter array ( sma ) and the combined array for research in millimeter astronomy ( carma ) .
these observations suggest a mass accretion rate of and a disc diameter at the arcsecond scale .
they were followed by measurements and analyses of the 1.3 mm dust polarization by @xcite and @xcite , which reveal a toroidal magnetic field configuration .
alma observations of molecular lines have been reported very recently : of c@xmath0o and so by @xcite , of cyclic - c@xmath10h@xmath11 and so by @xcite and of cch , cs , h@xmath11co and ch@xmath10oh by @xcite .
all above observations establish the presence of in - falling cool gas ( t@xmath130 k ) onto a rotating disc surrounding the protostar and having its axis close to the east - west direction , here taken as @xmath12 axis .
surprisingly , they have also revealed major differences between the responses of so , h@xmath11co and ch@xmath10oh and those of co , cch , cs and cyclic - c@xmath10h@xmath11 : the latter display double - peaked doppler velocity distributions while the former display single peaks .
this is interpreted by the authors as evidence for different molecules populating different radial regions , the former being confined to the inner part of the envelope , close to the disc , and absent from the foreground gas , while the latter are distributed over the foreground gas and subject to absorption .
the in - falling motion of the foreground gas explains the small red - shift of the observed absorption dip .
the presence of a keplerian disc having a diameter at the arcsecond scale is generally accepted , the rotation velocity of the envelope decreasing faster at larger distances .
the mechanism governing the disc dynamics , in particular the relative roles of magnetohydrodynamic turbulences and of self - gravitation are still unclear ( for a recent review see * ? ? ?
the above mentioned very recent observations follow a long series of earlier observations that have established the presence of an outflow along the east - west direction , with an opening angle of some 40@xmath8 @xcite and tilted eastward by some 10@xmath8 from north .
we refer the reader to the abundant literature quoted in the recent publications in the reference list attached to the present article . in
what follows , we produce a simple model of the gas envelope that relies exclusively on its morphologic and kinematic properties , without reference to what is causing the strong absorption detected above systemic velocity .
this is at variance with earlier models and contributes significant new information to the understanding of the underlying accretion mechanism .
the observations used in the present article were made in cycle 1 of alma operation on july 20 , 2014 .
the time spent on source was 36 minutes .
the number of antennas was 35 for part of the time , 36 otherwise , the longest baseline being 783.5 m ; the two sets of data have been merged and reduced by the alma staff .
the systemic velocity used as origin of the doppler velocity scale is .
the maps of the c@xmath0o(2 - 1 ) line emission are centred on the maximum of the continuum emission with right ascension of and declination of .
the synthetized beam size ( fwhm ) is 0.6 @xmath13 0.5 arcsec@xmath14 with a @xmath15 position angle from north .
these data have a better spatial resolution but are otherwise similar to the cycle 0 observations used by @xcite .
pixels are 0.15 @xmath13 0.15 arcsec@xmath14 and the velocity bins are 0.16 kms@xmath3 wide . the data used in the present work are limited to a region in the plane of the sky covering 17 pixels in @xmath12 and 57 pixels in @xmath16 , namely 2.55 and 8.55 arcsec respectively , over which a significant signal can be reliably detected . in practice
we limit the analysis to distances of the order of 4 arcsec where filtering out at large distances is not significant , the minimum baselines being essentially the same here and in the observations used by @xcite .
we use orthonormal coordinates with @xmath17 along the line of sight , @xmath12 and @xmath16 in the plane of the sky , @xmath12 pointing east and @xmath16 pointing north . throughout the article we assume a distance of 140 pc from the sun , implying that an angular distance of 1 arcsec corresponds to an actual distance of 140 au in the plane of the sky .
accordingly , we use indifferently arcsec or au to measure distances , including along the line of sight . as mentioned earlier ,
the continuum data are only used to define the origin of coordinates .
indeed , gaussian fits to the @xmath12 and @xmath16 distributions of the continuum flux give full widths at half - maximum ( fwhm ) of 0.47 and 0.71 arcsec respectively with the same beam size as for the line data : the source is unresolved in @xmath12 and has a size at the scale of @xmath10.4 arcsec in @xmath16 , consistent with the size of the disc .
the map of the line flux integrated over doppler velocities , @xmath18 , is shown in fig .
[ fig1 ] together with its projections on the @xmath12 and @xmath16 axes .
the projected distributions are shown together with their reflections with respect to the origin , demonstrating the good agreement between the centres of the continuum and line maps .
a small north - south asymmetry is visible on the @xmath16 distribution , the southern flux exceeding the northern flux by some 10% below 1 arcsec and by an average of @xmath120% between 1 and 4 arcsec .
however , this asymmetry is real and not the result of an offset centre .
we evaluated the position and width of the effective noise , meaning the peak observed at low values in the distribution of the flux density , in each velocity bin separately . in the low velocity bins where the signal is large enough to significantly contribute to nearly all pixels
, we extrapolated from the values taken in pixels outside the restricted map used in the analysis .
the rms value of the peak varies between 3 and 5 and the offsets between 0 and 5 depending on the intensity of the integrated signal measured in the bin . to each flux density measurement
we attach an uncertainty obtained by adding in quadrature the rms of the effective noise and half the value of the offset , the value of the flux density being corrected for the offset .
we normally retain for the analysis , unless specified otherwise , flux densities exceeding twice the uncertainty ( we speak of a 2-@xmath19 cut ) . figure [ fig2 ] displays the distributions of the ratio of the flux densities and their associated uncertainties both inside and outside a central rectangle covering 0.8 @xmath13 1.2 arcsec@xmath14 in @xmath20 . in the central region , nearly each pixel has a significant content .
as well known from previous studies , the envelope of l1527 is seen edge - on and its axis is oriented east - west , namely along the @xmath12 axis . in practice ,
the approximate symmetry plane of the envelope ( referred to as the `` disc plane '' for simplicity ) may slightly differ from the ( @xmath21 ) plane
. a rotation about the line of sight ( @xmath17 axis ) would be immediately visible on the sky map as an angle @xmath22 between its approximate symmetry axis and the @xmath16 axis .
a rotation about the @xmath16 axis by an angle @xmath23 is more difficult to reveal and must be obtained from the east - west extension of the measured integrated flux along the @xmath12 direction , which however combines the effect of @xmath23 with those of the beam size and of the intrinsic disk thickness .
@xcite using l band imaging from the gemini north telescope , quote a value of 5@xmath8 for each of @xmath22 and @xmath23 . in the present data , we find that @xmath22 does not exceed a degree ( fig . [ fig3 ] left ) when @xmath24 is limited to 3 arcsec but beyond @xmath24 @xmath13 arcsec , deviations reaching @xmath10.4 arcsec in @xmath12
are observed , eastward in the southern hemisphere and westward in the northern hemisphere , corresponding to a counter - clockwise tilt at the 10@xmath8 scale visible in fig .
[ fig1 ] ( left ) .
the evaluation of the angle @xmath23 is obtained from figure [ fig3 ] ( right ) , which displays the @xmath12 distribution of @xmath18 for @xmath25 for different values of @xmath26 . in the central region ,
its fwhm is 0.85 arcsec , compared with 0.47 arcsec for the continuum , meaning @xmath10.70 arcsec after beam deconvolution .
the fwhm of the @xmath16 distribution is @xmath27 arcsec , meaning @xmath28 arcsec in reality : we may place an upper limit of @xmath29 on the value of @xmath23 . in the following
we shall usually work in the approximation where both @xmath22 and @xmath23 cancel .
figure [ fig4 ] displays the distribution of the flux density on the doppler velocity @xmath30 and the sky map of its mean .
the dominant feature of the map is the north - south anti - symmetry revealing the well - known rotation of the envelope about the @xmath12 axis .
closer inspection reveals another significant asymmetry : blue - shifted emission is shifted westward and red - shifted emission eastward ( namely having the same inclination with respect to the @xmath16 axis as the flux excesses noted above for @xmath31 arcsec ) ; this is further illustrated in the lower right panel of the figure , displaying the dependence on @xmath16 of the mean value of @xmath12 weighted by the mean doppler velocity in each pixel .
a linear fit gives a slope of @xmath320.17 , corresponding to a tilt of @xmath33 east of north .
namely , while the `` disc planes '' defined by the symmetry of the intensity ( figure [ fig3 ] right ) or of the doppler velocity ( figure [ fig4 ] lower right ) are both centred at the origin to within one pixel , they differ by about @xmath34 in terms of their inclination ( @xmath22 ) with respect to the ( @xmath21 ) plane .
however , the latter ( using velocity ) matches the tilt of the former ( using intensity ) observed at @xmath31 arcsec and mentioned in sub - section 3.1 .
the doppler velocity spectrum is split in two by a central dip giving evidence for the major role played by absorption in these observations . indeed
, an optically thin disc of cool gas could not display such a dip .
two explanations have been invoked in earlier publications : absorption of the continuum emission by the foreground gas , extending typically over @xmath35 arcsec in @xmath16 and slightly red - shifted because of the in - fall contribution to the velocity of the foreground gas ; and absorption of the envelope emission by the foreground gas . as the dip is seen both inside and outside the continuum region ( figure [ fig4 ] upper right )
, absorption can not be exclusively blamed on the continuum and an important contribution of extended foreground gas , not only of the envelope , is to be expected @xcite . while the cool outer envelope , meaning @xmath24>@xmath10.6 arcsec ,
is expected to be optically thin at the scale of the present observations , it is seen behind an extended cloud that covers the full map and causes the presence of a dip in the velocity spectrum , again slightly red - shifted because of the average in - falling velocity of the foreground cloud , and extending over the whole @xmath16 range
. a closer look at the dependence of @xmath30 on the location of the source is given in fig .
[ fig5 ] , displaying position - velocity diagrams , with the doppler velocity as abscissa .
the ordinate is one of the sky coordinates and each diagram covers a specified interval of the other coordinate . to first order , they are characteristic of a rotating envelope having its axis along the @xmath12 axis and displaying symmetries in @xmath12 ( changing @xmath12 in @xmath36 leaves both doppler velocity and flux densities invariant ) and in @xmath16 ( changing @xmath16 in @xmath37 changes the sign of the doppler velocity and leaves the flux density invariant ) .
but they also reveal the effects of absorption mentioned above : the absence of emission in the two velocity bins above systemic velocity , namely @xmath38 kms@xmath3 , is ubiquitous . to further illustrate this point
, we show in fig .
[ fig6 ] doppler velocity spectra averaged over @xmath39 arcsec and different intervals of @xmath24 .
absorption is confined to low velocities , slightly red - shifted .
if symmetry in @xmath16 is obeyed , the velocity spectra measured at two opposite values of @xmath16 are related by reflection about the origin .
this is made clear in the figure by comparing the direct spectrum in the northern hemisphere with the reflected spectrum in the southern hemisphere .
if symmetry were obeyed , they would be identical .
however , absorption being red - shifted breaks the symmetry : it suppresses the red - shifted part of the direct spectrum and the blue - shifted part of the reflected spectrum , as is clearly observed on the figure . in what follows we use this feature to select data that are not too strongly affected by absorption . at variance with earlier studies
@xcite we prefer not to rely on a description of the absorption mechanism , which we would find difficult to model reliably .
adopting such an approach , a detailed study of the spectra displayed in figure [ fig6 ] shows that four velocity bins , covering the interval between @xmath320.16 and 0.48 kms@xmath3 are essentially lost for analysis .
however , if one assumes symmetry under both @xmath12 and @xmath16 reflections about the origin , namely invariance of the flux density under transformations of @xmath40 into @xmath41 and @xmath42 , the number of lost velocity bins can be reduced to two by retaining the blue - shifted part of the direct spectra and the red - shifted part of the reflected spectra in fig .
[ fig6 ] , applying small corrections on the neighbouring bins .
this feature is being made use of in the following section .
figure [ fig7 ] ( right ) displays the dependence of the integrated flux over position angle within an elliptic ring surrounding the star as shown in the left panel .
more precisely , we use as abscissa @xmath43 which is simply related to the position angle @xmath44 .
the right panel gives direct evidence for the @xmath6 shape of the flared envelope at large distances visible in the left panel .
the in - falling flux is enhanced within @xmath45 in @xmath46 from the @xmath16 axis , meaning within @xmath47 in @xmath48 .
this direct evidence for an enhancement of the in - falling flux at intermediate values of @xmath48 , or equivalently of a depression of the in - falling flux in the neighbourhood of the disc plane , will be confirmed and discussed in the following sections .
we now use the information obtained in the preceding section to produce a simple model of the gas envelope .
we assume perfect symmetry in both @xmath12 and @xmath16 and rotation invariance about the @xmath12 axis . the preceding section has shown that these are reasonable approximations and has given quantitative evaluations of the amount by which the data deviate from such an ideal situation .
moreover , we do not attempt fitting the density and temperature distributions separately ; instead we absorb them in a single quantity , the effective emissivity @xmath49 , defined such that @xmath50 where @xmath51 is the measured flux density and where the @xmath17 axis is parallel to the line of sight while the @xmath12 and @xmath16 axes point east and north respectively .
the justification for considering the effective emissivity rather than the temperature and the actual density is twofold : first , having data on a single co line , we have no simple access to the temperature and second , the important absorption near systemic velocity , which cuts away from analysis a significant fraction of the data , would require a detailed knowledge of the morphology and kinematics of the cloud in which the source is embedded as well as a detailed description of the continuum source , both of which are out of reach .
as the c@xmath0o component is expected to be optically thin , it remains reasonable to assume axisymmetry of the effective emissivity .
the symmetries of the model imply that we may symmetrize the data , averaging flux densities @xmath51 and @xmath52 as well as @xmath51 and @xmath53 .
the latter average implies accounting for the slight red - shift of the dip as explained in the preceding section . in practice ,
two velocity bins are excluded from the analysis , , and the contents of the neighbour bins are corrected , the uncertainty attached to each measurement being increased accordingly .
the flux densities are evaluated by integration along the line of sight up to 7 arcsec ( meaning @xmath11000 au ) in @xmath17 and distributed among the pixels using a gaussian beam profile in both @xmath12 and @xmath16 .
the @xmath54 is evaluated using as uncertainties the sum in quadrature of the above mentioned uncertainties and 10% of the measured flux density .
we have checked that different reasonable choices essentially lead to the same results as presented below .
we have paid much attention at introducing as small as possible a number of parameters to describe the morphology and kinematics of the gas volume . to allow the reader who is not interested in details to jump directly to the end of the section ( sub - section 4.3 ) we describe them briefly in the present paragraph .
guided by elementary hydrodynamics considerations , implying a smooth transition from flared disc to centrally symmetric in - fall , we describe the flux as spiralling on paraboloids having as axis the symmetry axis .
a parameter @xmath55 is used to describe their shape and a scaling parameter @xmath56 to label them ( increasing for paraboloids becoming less open and more distant from the origin ) .
the total velocity is tangent to the relevant paraboloid and is the sum of a rotation component , normal to the axis , and an in - fall component , contained in the meridian plane ( @xmath57 ) with @xmath58 pointing along a radius of the disc .
the scale of the former is given by a single parameter @xmath59 and its radial dependence by a power law index going from @xmath321 at infinity to @xmath60 at short distances , the transition being defined by a single parameter , @xmath61 .
the scale of the latter is given by a single parameter @xmath62 and its radial dependence by a power law index going to @xmath63 at large distances and becoming larger at smaller distances as governed by a second parameter @xmath64 .
in practice , we find that both @xmath65 and @xmath64 are very poorly defined and that the data are satisfied with a nearly constant in - fall velocity
. an important result of our analysis is the evidence for a significant depression of the effective emissivity near the disc plane as previously mentioned in section 3.4 . in order to parameterise its shape ,
we need two parameters , @xmath66 measuring its extension around the disc plane and @xmath67 measuring its scale .
the stationary isothermal regime that can be described by the above parameters is used here as a reference , but is obviously improper to describe reality .
an additional parameter @xmath68 is introduced to measure the deviation of the flux from such an ideal regime .
a last parameter @xmath69 describes the observed dependence of the rotation velocity when moving away from the ( @xmath21 ) plane ( figure [ fig5 ] lower left ) . in total
, the model uses eleven parameters in addition to the scale factor @xmath70 readily obtained by normalisation of the integrated flux predicted by the model to the measured flux . of these eleven parameters , two , @xmath65 and @xmath64 turnout
to be so poorly constrained that they could as well be omitted and one , @xmath69 , is trivially obtained from the data .
we are therefore dealing effectively with a 8-parameter model to describe the morphology and kinematics of the envelope .
we model ( fig .
[ fig8 ] ) the trajectories of the gas molecules as spiralling on paraboloids of equation with the cylindrical radius ( note that the choice of 3 arcsec in the denominator is arbitrary ) .
the velocity is parameterised as the sum of a component @xmath71 perpendicular to the ( @xmath58,@xmath12 ) plane and a velocity @xmath72 tangent to the parabola in the ( @xmath58,@xmath12 ) plane .
if @xmath73 is the angle between the ( @xmath58,@xmath12 ) plane and the plane of the sky , the component of @xmath71 on @xmath17 is @xmath74 .
the unit vector tangent to the parabola has components @xmath75 on @xmath12 and @xmath76 on @xmath58 with @xmath77^{-\sfrac{1}{2}}$ ] .
the component of @xmath72 on @xmath17 is @xmath78 .
hence @xmath79 our hypothesis of rotational invariance implies that the morphology and kinematics of the envelope are independent of @xmath80 .
we parameterise both @xmath71 and @xmath72 as functions of the distance to the origin , .
the rotation velocity is known to evolve from an inverse distance law at large distances from the protostar to keplerian at short distances @xcite , which we translate as a power law in @xmath4 of index @xmath81 , giving @xmath82 at @xmath83 and @xmath84 at @xmath85 with @xmath61 measuring the distance from the protostar at which the transition takes place .
moreover , we allow for a small decrease of the rotation velocity when moving away from the @xmath86 plane ( @xmath12=0 ) as seen in the lower left panel of fig .
[ fig5 ] and we write @xmath87
. the velocity @xmath72 must cancel when approaching the disc and behave as a power law at large distances , which we write as @xmath88 reaching its maximum at @xmath89 and behaving as @xmath90 at large distances .
note that at variance with earlier models @xcite our evaluation of the in - fall velocity rests exclusively on the kinematics of the envelope , without any constraint from the absorption .
we parameterise the density @xmath91 as a multiple of the density @xmath92 associated with a constant accretion rate @xmath93 in a stationary regime . at a distance @xmath58 from the @xmath12 axis , the mass of gas flowing in a time @xmath94 across @xmath58 between paraboloids @xmath95 and @xmath96 is @xmath97.\end{aligned}\ ] ] to parameterise @xmath98 , we remark that it must decrease rapidly when @xmath95 increases in order to leave room for the broad outflow about the @xmath12 axis .
however , a gaussian form @xmath99 $ ] can not reproduce the depression observed at small values of @xmath95 near the plane of the disc ( fig .
[ fig7 ] right ) .
we write therefore @xmath100-\epsilon\,\exp[-\sfrac{1}{2}(\lambda/\lambda_1)^2]\}\ ] ] at constant temperature and in a non - turbulent optically thin regime in local thermal equilibrium , the effective emissivity @xmath101 is simply proportional to @xmath92 . in order to account for deviations from such an ideal situation
, we simply include a factor @xmath102 in the denominator of @xmath92 with @xmath68 measuring the importance of such deviations , namely @xmath103-\epsilon\,\exp[-\sfrac{1}{2}(\lambda/\lambda_1)^2]\}}{2\pi\zeta r^q v_{fall}(x_0+\zeta^2/3)k}\ ] ] the result of the best fit is summarized in table [ tab_bestfit ] and illustrated in figures [ fig9 ] to [ fig11 ] .
the quantities @xmath104 listed in the table are amounts by which the parameter has to increase ( @xmath105 ) or to decrease ( @xmath106 ) for @xmath54 to increase by 5% , other parameters being kept constant . they should not be rigorously understood as real uncertainties but as giving an evaluation of the sensitivity of the quality of the fit to each parameter separately . yet
, their definition has been chosen in such a way as to give a sensible estimate of the actual uncertainties . [
cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] figure [ fig9 ] illustrates the quality of the fit , both the integrated flux and the doppler velocity distributions are rather well reproduced in the domain covered by the model ( @xmath107 arcsec ; @xmath108 arcsec ; the figure makes full use of the symmetries of the model by displaying symmetrized data .
figure [ fig10 ] displays the dependences on @xmath4 and @xmath95 of the main parameters of the model .
figure [ fig11 ] shows the map of the space - reconstructed effective emissivity in the plane as given by the best fit and illustrates typical spiral trajectories .
the results obtained in the preceding section are qualitatively consistent with earlier descriptions of the protostar envelope but contribute significant new quantitative information on its morphology and kinematics . figure [ fig12 ] displays maps of the deviation between the model and the data , both in absolute value ( right panel ) and as an asymmetry ( left panel ) .
the former are dominated by pixels close to the limit of the central region excluded from the fit while the latter do not exceed @xmath120% for @xmath1093 arcsec . beyond this value ,
the individual pixel contents are close to noise level . in general
, the maps illustrate the good quality of the fit given the very simple form of the model . over most of the explored range the kinematics
is dominated by rotation , with an accurately measured velocity .
the choice of having velocities tangent to paraboloids is very well accommodated by the data , attempts to use different shapes did not bring any significant improvement to the quality of the fit . however , we can not claim evidence for this particular choice of trajectories being unique .
the limitation of the analysis to values of @xmath24 exceeding @xmath1100 au prevents a reliable exploration of the central region where the keplerian disc is located .
while the need for @xmath110 to increase toward small @xmath4 values is clearly required by the data , the value of @xmath61 , @[email protected] arcsec , an approximate measure of the distance from the star where the transition to a keplerian regime occurs , is poorly constrained : the existence of a keplerian disc having a diameter at the arcsecond scale is consistent with the present observations , which , however , do not provide a more accurate evaluation of its dimensions .
extending the analysis to lower values of @xmath24 would require a reliable modelling of the emission and absorption properties of the protostar , the disc and the molecular cloud in which they are embedded .
evidence for an additional small decrease of the rotation velocity when moving away from the disc plane , already apparent in the raw data ( fig .
[ fig5 ] lower left ) , is confirmed by the fit with a @xmath19 of @xmath69=0.28 , meaning 1.2 arcsec ( 2.8 arcsec fwhm ) at a distance @xmath58=3 arcsec from the disc axis .
the sensitivity of the present observations is sufficient to give evidence for in - fall , but insufficient to measure its variation precisely over the explored domain : the best fit values of @xmath72 are confined between 0.44 and 0.41 kms@xmath3when @xmath4 spans between 1 and 5 arcsec .
namely , we may retain a mean in - fall velocity of [email protected] kms@xmath3over the explored range with no evidence for a significant @xmath4-dependence .
@xcite did not adjust the in - fall velocity to best fit their data but adopted a different approach : having remarked that setting the in - fall velocity to its free fall value gives a bad fit to the data , they reduced it by a factor of 2 for @xmath1111.8 arcsec ( to better match their co data ) and by a factor of 5 for @xmath1120.9 arcsec ( to better match their so data ) and were satisfied with the result . in the range @xmath1114 arcsec ,
where the total velocity is not too strongly dominated by the rotation velocity , therefore where the in - fall velocity can be best measured , the value assumed by @xcite agrees well with that obtained from the present analysis .
good agreement is also obtained at small values of @xmath4 where both analyses require the in - fall velocity to tend to zero .
however , the sudden jump postulated by @xcite in the [email protected] arcsec interval , reaching high values of 1.5 kms@xmath3 , is not required by the present analysis .
@xcite need such a jump to reproduce the velocity profile measured at the central star position ( [email protected] arcsec@xmath14 )
. however , the fit that they obtain is poor ( their figure 1c ) .
moreover the central star region is strongly influenced by absorption and has been excluded from the present analysis as being too difficult to describe reliably .
the space velocity , @xmath114 , increases when @xmath4 decreases as shown in fig .
[ fig10 ] ( middle ) .
writing that the total energy is conserved and cancels at infinity provides an estimate of the mass @xmath115 contained in the central region .
the measured velocity @xmath116=1.3 kms@xmath3at @xmath4=1.5 arcsec being then equal to @xmath117 ( where @xmath118 is newton s gravitation constant ) we measure @xmath1190.2 solar masses .
this measurement agrees well with the evaluation made by @xcite using @xmath9co ( 2 - 1 ) carma observations .
they find @[email protected] solar masses from the rotation curve measured at distances from the star not exceeding 100 au ( 0.7 arcsec ) , namely below the range explored in the present analysis .
the quoted error reflects only the quality of the fit but excludes systematic uncertainties attached to the reliability of the method .
however , when fitting @xmath116 to a power law in @xmath4 over the whole observed range , we find a much better fit for a power index of @xmath320.7 instead of @xmath320.5 as required by the energy conservation argument quoted above .
this was also noted by @xcite .
it is to be seen in conjunction with the important deviation from zero measured for @xmath68 , [email protected] , illustrating the approximate nature of the assumptions made in constructing and/or interpreting the model ( no viscosity , stationarity , no turbulences , thermal equilibrium , optical thinness , etc . ) . in particular , a non - zero value of @xmath68 is straightforwardly generated by variations of the temperature with @xmath4
this suggests , rather than comparing kinetic energy with potential energy , to compare instead their variations with @xmath4 . writing that the kinetic energy increase is compensated by an equal decrease of the gravitational potential energy at @xmath4=1.5 arcsec
, we find a value of @xmath115 0.7/0.5 times larger than previously obtained , namely @xmath10.3 solar masses .
the very approximate nature of these evaluations must be kept in mind and we retain an estimate of [email protected] solar masses contained within @xmath1121.5 arcsec , where the uncertainty is meant to account for systematic contributions .
possible mechanisms causing the in - fall velocity to be significantly smaller than the free - fall velocity have been reviewed in the earlier literature .
they do not need to be repeated here as the present analysis does not provide new arguments that could favour one of these over the others . the dependence on @xmath95 of the accretion rate is accurately measured and could as well have been modelled by a gaussian enhancement in @xmath95 having a mean value of @xmath120=0.156 and a @xmath19 of 0.088 ( fig .
[ fig10 ] left ) .
there is clear evidence for a strong depression in the disc plane as well as over a broad solid angle about the disc axis where outflow is known to take place .
we prefer to talk of a depression in the disc plane rather than an @xmath6-shaped enhancement because simple gravity requires the density to increase toward the disc plane .
the geometry of the observed depression makes it very unlikely that it be the result of an artefact of the model or of opacity .
it is therefore reasonable to assume that it reveals an actual depression of the co(2 - 1 ) emission .
as well - known ( for a recent review see * ? ? ?
* ) the proximity of the gas temperature to the co sublimation temperature implies that freeze - out of co molecules on cold dust grains - or conversely sublimation - is a dominant process in the dynamics that govern the evolution of gas envelopes .
many astrochemical models predict a protoplanetary disc structure similar to what is found here ( for a recent example see * ? ? ?
another example of the importance of the role played by co freeze - out on ( or sublimation from ) dust grains is a recent study @xcite suggesting that protostars such as l1527 undergo significant bursts once every 20000 years causing sublimation of the frozen - out co molecules .
this suggests an interpretation of the observed depression in terms of co molecules freezing out on cold dust preferably near the median disc plane .
ultimately ( see figure 14 of * ? ? ?
* ) this is indeed what is expected and it is not unreasonable to assume that it is starting to take place in the case of l1527 .
the normalisation between the effective emissivity obtained in the model and observed in the data , fixing @xmath70 , gives an evaluation of the accretion rate of 3.5 10@xmath7 m@xmath5yr@xmath3 , where we assume a constant temperature of 30 k and a c@xmath0o to molecular hydrogen ratio of 4.9 10@xmath121 @xcite .
this number is evaluated at a distance of 1 arcsec from the star
. a significantly higher accretion rate of 6.6 10@xmath7 m@xmath5yr@xmath3was suggested by @xcite using luminosity arguments .
however , this evaluation is very indirect and the uncertainty attached to it is large . rather than being a cause of concern
, the fact that the two numbers differ by a factor of nearly 2 suggests that the associated methods measure different quantities that are subject to very different systematic uncertainties .
in particular , the evaluation obtained from the present analysis depends on the distance from the star , decreasing by a factor @xmath122 when moving away to a distance of 2 arcsec . taking this into account
, we retain a value of [email protected] 10@xmath7 m@xmath5yr@xmath3at a distance of 1 arcsec ( 140 au ) from the star .
the envelope thickness at @xmath16=0 , measured by a fwhm of @xmath10.55 in @xmath95 ( fig .
[ fig10 ] left ) meaning @xmath10.7 arcsec , is consistent with the value quoted in sub - section 3.1 from which an upper limit of @xmath123 was placed on a possible tilt @xmath23 between the disc plane and the @xmath86 plane about the @xmath16 axis .
the observed @xmath124 tilt @xmath22 about the @xmath17 axis of the map of @xmath125 that was mentioned in sub - section 3.2 and illustrated in fig .
[ fig4 ] deserves some comments .
as remarked then , such a tilt is also seen in the integrated flux for distances from the star exceeding @xmath13 arcsec , not only in the present data ( figures [ fig1 ] left and [ fig3 ] left ) , but also in infrared observations @xcite .
the difference of inclination of the central part of the envelope , as measured from the integrated flux , and of the outer part , including the outflow , is not due to some trivial geometric effect but is real .
many factors may play a role in this context , such as magnetic field ( see for example the review of * ? ? ? * ) or binarity @xcite .
in summary , the main original contribution of the present analysis to our understanding of the formation process of l1527 is the presentation of a simple 3d parameterisation of the morphology and kinematics of the gas envelope based solely on the observation of the c@xmath0o ( 2 - 1 ) line emission from regions that are not dominated by absorption . in the explored range , the model , which uses eight relevant parameters , reproduces observations significantly better than earlier attempts .
this was made possible by assuming central symmetry and axisymmetry about the @xmath12 ( west - east ) axis and by excluding from the analysis doppler velocities between 0 and 0.32 kms@xmath3and a band of the sky map of @xmath20.675 arcsec about the @xmath12 axis .
moreover we have reduced the radial dependences of the temperature and density to a single quantity , the effective emissivity .
we have presented arguments showing that such assumptions are indeed reasonable .
the main conclusions of the analysis are : + a ) _ rotation _ : the model uses successfully trajectories spiralling down toward the disc on paraboloids coaxial with it . we give evidence for the dominance of rotation over the explored range and confirm that the rotation curve is as expected from a transition from an inverse distance law to a keplerian regime .
the rotation velocity decreases from @xmath11.66 kms@xmath3to @xmath10.34 kms@xmath3when @xmath4 increases from 1 to 5 arcsec .
however , the range explored is too distant from the star to allow direct observation of the disc .
+ b ) _ in - fall velocity _ : we measure a mean in - fall velocity of [email protected] kms@xmath3over the explored range , smaller than free fall velocity , with no evidence for a significant @xmath4-dependence , in particular no evidence for the sudden jump to @xmath11.5 kms@xmath3required by @xcite to describe the absorption - dominated central region .
+ c ) _ central mass _ : using simple arguments of energy conservation we evaluate a central mass of [email protected] solar masses contained within a distance of 1.5 arcsec from the star , in agreement with earlier estimates obtained from a different range of distances @xcite .
we discuss the systematic uncertainty attached to the fact that the in - fall velocity is increasingly smaller than the free - fall velocity when getting closer to the star .
+ d ) _ disc plane depression _ : in addition to a strong depression of the in - falling flux about the disc axis , where outflow is known to be present , we observe a similar depression in the neighbourhood of the disc plane , resulting in an @xmath6 shaped flow directly visible on the data .
we argue that it is not an effect of opacity and suggest that it be caused by the freeze - out of co molecules on cold dust grains occuring preferably near the disc plane .
+ e ) _ accretion rate _ : we measure a value of @xmath126 m@xmath5yr@xmath3at a distance of 1 arcsec ( 140 au ) from the star , however subject to systematic uncertainties again associated with the deviation from a stationary flow , in relation with the deviation of the in - fall velocity from free fall .
this is a factor of nearly 2 smaller than obtained by @xcite from luminosity arguments .
however , we argue that the apparent disagreement should be understood as evidence for the two evaluations actually measuring different quantities .
+ f ) _ orientation in space _ : we give an upper limit of @xmath1@xmath127 on a possible tilt of the disc plane about the south - north ( @xmath16 ) axis . a tilt of @xmath1@xmath34 about the line of sight ( @xmath17 axis )
is observed at large distances ( @xmath1283 arcsec ) , matching earlier infrared observations @xcite , but cancels at smaller distances .
a same tilt of @xmath34 is observed on the map of the mean doppler velocity .
this paper makes use of the following alma data : ads / jao.alma#2012.1.00647.s .
alma is a partnership of eso ( representing its member states ) , nsf ( usa ) and nins ( japan ) , together with nrc ( canada ) , nsc and asiaa ( taiwan ) , and kasi ( republic of korea ) , in cooperation with the republic of chile .
the joint alma observatory is operated by eso , aui / nrao and naoj .
the data are retrieved from the jvo portal ( http://jvo.nao.ac.jp/portal ) operated by the naoj .
we are indebted and very grateful to the alma partnership , who are making their data available to the public after a one year period of exclusive property , an initiative that means invaluable support and encouragement for vietnamese astrophysics .
we particularly acknowledge friendly support from the staff of the alma helpdesk .
we express our deep gratitude to professors anne dutrey and stphane guilloteau for having introduced us to the physics of star formation and for very helpful comments and suggestions on the the manuscript .
we are also deeply grateful to doctor pierre lesaffre for having clarified points related with the dynamics of the in - fall and accretion mechanisms .
financial support is acknowledged from the vietnam national satellite centre ( vnsc / vast ) , the nafosted funding agency under contract 103.99 - 2015.39 , the world laboratory , the odon vallet foundation and the rencontres du viet nam . | using alma observations of the c@xmath0o(2 - 1 ) line emission of the gas envelope of protostar l1527 , we have reconstructed its morphology and kinematics under the assumption of axisymmetry about the west - east axis . the main original contribution to our understanding of the formation process of l1527 is the presentation of a simple 3d parameterisation based solely on regions that are not dominated by absorption . in the explored range ( @xmath10.7 to 5 arcsec from the star )
the model reproduces observations better than earlier attempts .
the main results include : a measurement of the rotation velocity that confirms its evolution to keplerian toward short distances ; a measurement of the mean in - fall velocity , [email protected] kms@xmath3 , lower than free fall velocity , with no evidence for the significant @xmath4-dependence suggested by an earlier analysis ; a measurement of the central mass , [email protected] m@xmath5 within a distance of 1.5 arcsec from the star , in agreement with earlier estimates obtained from a different range of distances ; evidence for a strong disc plane depression of the in - falling flux resulting in an @xmath6 shaped flow possibly caused by the freeze - out of co molecules on dust grains ; a measurement of the accretion rate , [email protected] 10@xmath7m@xmath5yr@xmath3at a distance of 1 arcsec ( 140 au ) from the star ; evidence for a 10@xmath8 tilt of the symmetry plane of the envelope about the line of sight , cancelling below @xmath13 arcsec from the star , but matching infrared observations and being also apparent on the sky map of the mean doppler velocity . [ firstpage ] circumstellar matter stars : individual ( l1527 irs ) stars : low - mass stars : protostars radio lines : stars . |
since the world health assembly announced the intention to eradicate polio worldwide in 1988 , all countries except pakistan , afghanistan , and nigeria have [ line - through]*certified elimination*interrupted indigenous transmission of all three wild poliovirus ( wpv ) serotypes at least once @xcite .
nigeria may be the next country to achieve wild - type polio elimination .
the most recent case of wild - type 1 ( wpv1 ) in nigeria occurred in july 2014 @xcite .
the most recent case of wild - type 3 ( wpv3 ) seen globally occurred in nigeria in november 2012 @xcite .
is nigeria wild - polio - free ?
is wpv3 eradicated globally ?
furthermore , the last case of wpv1 in africa occurred in somalia at the tail end of the horn of africa outbreak in august 2014 . is africa wild - polio - free ?
the primary mechanism for detecting poliovirus in a population is surveillance for paralytic poliomyelitis .
the incidence of poliomyelitis is tracked by the acute flaccid paralysis ( afp ) surveillance and global polio laboratory network @xcite .
the certification period to declare that a polio serotype has been eliminated from a previously endemic region with certification - standard surveillance is three or more years without a polio case associated with indigenous wpv circulation@xcite .
this criterion is based on experience with regional elimination @xcite and is necessarily long because paralysis due to polio is uncommon . estimated
case - to - infection ratios in fully - susceptible individuals are 1:200 for wild type 1 , 1:1900 for wild type 2 , and 1:1150 for wild type 3 @xcite .
previous modeling work has supported that the three year rule of thumb is reasonable , but that more precise estimates of the elimination time depend on the case - to - infection ratio for each serotype and the local conditions leading up to elimination @xcite .
polio elimination in the most challenging settings has been driven by supplemental immunization activities that require extensive resources and prolonged community engagement to be successful @xcite . operational capacity and community engagement
can be difficult to maintain for years in the presence of political instability , humanitarian crises , and substantial health care needs unrelated to polio @xcite . while it is reasonable to maintain the three year certification period as the gold standard ,
the operational , humanitarian , and financial requirements support the need for specific , data - driven estimates of the likely period of silent polio persistence .
the need for specific silent duration estimates is especially important in the context of the plan to stop all use of trivalent oral polio vaccine ( topv ) in april 2016 and replace it with bivalent opv ( bopv ) containing only serotypes 1 and 3 to prevent the seeding of new type 2 circulating vaccine - derived polio ( cvdpv2 ) outbreaks @xcite .
cvdpv outbreaks can occur when vaccine strains transmit for sufficient time to allow for genetic reversion of the markers of attenuation @xcite .
opv2 is the most common source of cvdpv globally @xcite , and nigeria has had ongoing transmission of cvdpv2 since 2005 @xcite . in 2014 , cvdpv2 was the dominant cause of poliomyelitis in nigeria @xcite , and this is likely because nigeria has been primarily using bopv to drive the successes in wpv control @xcite . however , due to expanded use of topv and combined topv / inactivated polio vaccine campaigns from the second half of 2014 @xcite , cvdpv2 cases in nigeria abruptly stopped appearing at the end of november 2014 after producing 30 cases earlier that year @xcite .
are the established cvdpv2 lineages gone ? will they be gone before the planned april 2016 topv cessation deadline ? when is it reasonable for nigeria to switch from a strategy focused on wpv elimination to one focused on cvdpv2 ? to estimate the probabilities of elimination from nigeria given the data available at the time of preparation , march 31 , 2015 , i built a model appropriate to answer the question : how long do we have to wait before a chain of transmission either terminates or produces another case ?
the model is based on four premises : ( 1 ) that elimination only depends on the last few hundred to few thousand infections in a much larger population , ( 2 ) that we only need to see one more case to know elimination did not occur , ( 3 ) that we do not care where infected people are located because afp surveillance will find any cases in proportion to the surveillance sensitivity , and ( 4 ) that the few remaining pockets of infection have similar transmission dynamics to the many sources of polio cases in the past .
the model incorporates both the parametric and stochastic uncertainties that limit our knowledge of polio transmission .
it provides estimates of the probability of elimination given no new cases and the time to the next case if elimination does not occur , and the results are appropriate for supporting the rational analyses @xcite of planned polio vaccination policies .
* added july 10 , 2015 * : on june 26 , 2015 , a paralytic polio case caused by ongoing circulation of established cvdpv2 lineage was confirmed by the global polio laboratory network .
the date of paralysis onset was may 16 , 2015 , 181 days after the previous case . with this new information ,
i assess the accuracy of the predictions for elimination and case detection in the first version of the paper and provide an updated forecast for the time to cvdpv2 elimination if no cases are detected .
new sections are marked by the `` added july 10 , 2015 '' tag .
the left column of fig . [ resultsfig ] depicts elimination : it shows the probability by date that each serotype been eliminated if no new cases are detected .
the right column depicts case detection : it shows the probability of the time to the next case if elimination does not occur [ line - through]*under the assumption that surveillance is of sufficiently high quality that no polio cases are missed*. the dashed line indicates march 31 , 2015 .
the solid blue curves provide estimates based on models with mean effective reproductive number equal to 1 ( mean growth rate of the number of active infections equal to 0 ) . for a fixed surveillance sensitivity
, @xmath5 is the worst - case scenario because it maximizes the possible duration of silent transmission without elimination .
deviations from this assumption either make elimination easier @xmath6 or make the silent period between cases shorter @xmath7 . for wpv1 and wpv3 , the green curves provide less conservative estimates based on the assumption that vaccination quality maintains mean @xmath8 ( growth rate @xmath9 ) at the level estimated at the time of the last case . for cvdpv2
, the green curve assumes that the mean growth rate is held at one standard deviation below zero .
comments below summarize results from the green curves unless otherwise stated . for wpv1 and wpv3 ,
the dashed blue curves provide conservative estimates under the assumptions that @xmath5 and surveillance is only likely to detect @xmath10 of polio cases .
the poor surveillance curves are not shown for cvdpv2 because elimination is very unlikely , occurring in less than 1 in 100 000 simulations .
* worst - case * scenario with mean @xmath5 and perfect surveillance , [ line - through]*and * the green curve shows a less conservative scenario with mean @xmath8 and perfect surveillance , and the dashed blue curve shows a conservative scenario with mean @xmath5 and @xmath10 surveillance sensitivity . for cvdpv2
( c , f ) , the orange curve depicts an optimistic scenario in which the mean @xmath11 is held at the lowest value ever observed and the standard deviation is reduced to one - fourth of its observed value . ]
[ [ wpv1 . ] ] wpv1 .
+ + + + + the most recent wpv1 case in nigeria occurred on july 24 , 2014 .
as of march 31 , 2015 , there is an @xmath0 chance that wpv1 has been eliminated from nigeria .
the chance of elimination will be [ line - through]*@xmath1*@xmath12 by the end of 2015 if no new cases are seen even under the worst - case scenario for surveillance and the force of infection ( fig .
[ resultsfig]a , dashed blue curve ) .
if wpv1 does not eliminate before making another case , there is a @xmath13 chance we will see a new case by the end of june 2015 and a @xmath4 chance by the end of 2015 ( fig .
[ resultsfig]b ) .
the most recent case outside of nigeria occurred in somalia on august 11 , 2014 at the tail end of the horn of africa outbreak that begin in 2013 , 69 days after the case preceding it @xcite .
the corresponding predictions from the model for somalia are thus essentially identical to those for nigeria .
the combined probability that both countries have eliminated ( and thus all of africa ) is the square of the nigeria values , and so the model estimates a @xmath14 chance that africa is wild - polio - free as of march 31 , 2015 .
[ [ wpv3 . ] ] wpv3 .
+ + + + + the most recent wpv3 case globally occurred on november 11 , 2012 in nigeria .
as of march 31 , 2015 , there is a @xmath2 chance that wpv3 has been eliminated from nigeria [ line - through]*and thus eradicated globally*. the most recent case detected anywhere outside of nigeria was in pakistan seven months earlier ( april 2012 ) .
the detection of the other serotypes since 2012 in both ( and neighboring ) countries indicates that surveillance is able to detect wpv3 if it were present , and so elimination from nigeria likely represents global eradication . in the unlikely event wpv3
has not been [ line - through]*eradicated*eliminated , there is a @xmath2 chance we will see a new case by the end of 2015 .
[ [ cvdpv2 . ] ] cvdpv2 .
+ + + + + + + the most recent cvdpv2 case in nigeria occurred on november 16 , 2014 from a genetic lineage that has been in circulation since 2005 .
as of march 31 , 2015 , it is unlikely that the known cvdpv2 lineages @xcite have been eliminated from nigeria .
if the known cvdpv2 lineages are still in circulation , there is an @xmath0 chance the next case will appear by the end of june 2015 , and a @xmath15 chance a case will appear by the end of 2015 .
this model prediction for silent persistence is consistent with the longest observed interval of approximately 7 months seen from november 2012 to june 2013 @xcite .
the prediction for the probability of cvdpv2 elimination is sensitive to assumptions about future type 2 immunity .
the rapid disappearance of cases in late 2014 ( from one case every 10 days on average in 2014 to no cases in over 4 months ) implies that type 2 immunity is higher in the relevant population than it has been at any time previously , and so models based on historical transmission rates are likely too conservative .
as population immunity affects transmission dynamics through herd effects that reduce the force of infection @xcite , consider three scenarios for the force of infection in 2015 and beyond : * historically typical topv coverage ( blue ) : for the historically typical coverage scenario , the model assumes that the future force of infection is described by the historical estimates the mean growth rate is zero ( @xmath5 ) and the standard deviation is described in the methods . under this scenario
[ line - through]*if the mean growth rate is zero ( @xmath5 ) * , elimination is unlikely with a @xmath16 chance prior to june 2015 .
the estimated probability of elimination without seeing a case rises to @xmath13 by april 2016 , but does not reach @xmath4 until june 2017 . * good topv coverage ( green ) : for a good coverage scenario , the model assumes that topv coverage improvements will maintain a reduction in the mean force of infection to [ line - through]*if growth rates persist at * one standard deviation below the historical norm [ line - through]*but*and so not at unprecedented levels , @xmath17 ( such that mean @xmath18 ) . under this scenario
, there is only a @xmath19 chance of elimination by the end of june 2015 and an @xmath3 chance that cvdpv2 will be eliminated by april 2016 if no new cases are seen .
the probability of elimination rises to @xmath20 by the end of 2017 . * excellent topv coverage ( orange ) : for the excellent coverage scenario , the model assumes that topv coverage improvements will maintain the mean growth rate at the lowest level transiently observed in the last ten years , @xmath21 ( such that mean @xmath22 ) , and will also reduce the variability of the growth rate to one - fourth of the historical standard deviation .
[ line - through]*if the recent improvements in topv vaccination quality and higher topv campaign frequency maintain the mean growth rate at the lowest level observed in any interval for any serotype in the last ten years @xmath21 ( such that mean @xmath22 ) and reduce the variability of the growth rate to one - fourth of the historical standard deviation , * under this scenario , there is a @xmath23 chance of elimination by the end of june 2015 and a @xmath1 chance cvdpv2 will be eliminated by april 2016 if no new cases are seen .
this analysis is focused solely on estimating the elimination probability for established cvdpv2 lineages and does not account for the emergence of new cvdpv2 lineages . in the event of a new emergence
, these estimates would remain valid for the current genetic lineages , but additional modeling would be required to produce estimates for any new lineages and thus cvdpv2 overall .
* added july 10 , 2015 : * the new cvdpv2 case on may 16 , 2015 provides information to validate the previous model and to update the cvdpv2 forecast .
the original forecast was accurate in that it both correctly predicted that elimination was very unlikely prior to may 2015 ( fig .
[ julyresultsfig]a ) , and the observed case occurred at the @xmath24-percentile of the prediction interval for the time to the next case given the data available as of march 31 , 2015 ( fig .
[ julyresultsfig]b ) . ) .
( c ) updated forecast prepared on june 30 , 2015 for elimination if no new cases are observed and ( d ) probability of the time to the next case if elimination does not occur .
( e ) overlay of new forecast ( solid lines ) and original forecast ( dashed lines ) for easier comparison . as in fig .
[ resultsfig ] , the solid blue curve shows the conservative scenario with mean @xmath5 and perfect surveillance , [ line - through]*and * the green curve shows the scenario most consistent with the recent 6-month silent period with mean @xmath8 and perfect surveillance , and the orange curve depicts an optimistic scenario in which the mean @xmath11 is held at the lowest value ever observed and the standard deviation is reduced to one - fourth of its historical value . starting from may 16 ,
@xmath25 of all simulations in the blue scenario eliminate without producing another case , @xmath26 eliminate in the green scenario without a case , and @xmath27 eliminate in the orange without a case . ] for each of the three scenarios considered for the original forecast , i estimated the probablility that each scenario produced the observed outcome .
for the historically typical topv coverage scenario ( blue ) , the observed outcome of a case after 181 days occured in 8 of 100 000 simulations ; for the good topv coverage scenario ( green ) , 23 of 100 000 simulations ; and for the optimistic scenario ( orange ) , 4 of 100 000 simulations .
the absolute probabilites are low because any specific point outcome is unlikely , but the differences in the probabilities provide evidence to weight how consistent each scenario is with the observed outcome . that the green scenario is most likely to produce
the observed outcome supports the assumption of the original paper that a scenario in which the mean @xmath28 is below 1 but not at unprecedentedly low levels is reasonable to describe the present situation .
as described in the methods , i used the set of previous simulations consistent with the observed outcome to estimate the prevelance of cvdpv2 infection in nigeria on may 16 .
the median estimated infection prevalence on may 16 , 2015 is 103 infections , which is roughly 16-fold lower than the median estimated prevelance in november 2014 .
thus , the new case , while unfortunate , provides evidence of significant reductions in cvdpv2 prevalence . from the estimated initial condition distribution ,
the model produces updated forecasts from may 16 , 2015 for the probability of elimination given no new cases ( fig .
[ julyresultsfig]c ) and the time to the next case if elimination does not occur ( fig .
[ julyresultsfig]d ) . under the most likely of the three simulated scenarios for @xmath28 in which the mean effective reproductive number is one standard deviation below the historical norm ( green ) , the probability of elimination if no new cases occurs is @xmath29 by the end of 2016 , @xmath30 by april 2016 , and @xmath1 by the end of 2016 .
these results are essentially unchanged from the estimate prepared on march 31 ( fig .
[ julyresultsfig]e ) .
the model actually increases its estimate of the probability of elimination in the next few months because the new case reduces the uncertainty in the space of possible trajectories that allow for persistance through may without cases or elimination . if elimination does not occur , the median predicted date of onset of the next case is july 15 , and there is a @xmath31 chance of another case by the end of the year ( fig .
[ julyresultsfig]d ) .
as of march 31 , 2014 , the model predicts that wpv3 has been eradicated globally and there is an @xmath14 chance that africa is completely wild - polio free for the first time in history .
furthermore , in the now unlikely situation that wpv1 has not yet been eliminated from nigeria and that it persists with the worst - case mean reproductive number of exactly 1 and only @xmath10 surveillance sensitivity , we can expect to see it or for it to eliminate with [ line - through]*@xmath4*@xmath12 certainty by the end of 2015 .
thus , this author believes it will be reasonable to conclude that africa is wild - polio free if no new wpv cases are seen by the end of 2015 .
this estimate for time to elimination of at most 14 months is significantly shorter than estimated in previous work @xcite because the model takes into account the low infection prevalence at the time of the most recent case that is implied by the long interval between the most recently observed cases . for cvdpv2 , despite the dramatic reduction in incidence implied by the lack of new cases since november 2014
, we must be cautious about concluding too soon that the established lineages are gone .
the low case to infection ratio of type 2 makes it the most difficult strain to detect at low prevalence , and the high rate of incidence in 2014 implies that the reservoir of existing silent infections in november 2014 was approximately 22 times larger for cvdpv2 than for wpv1 at the time of its last case .
the larger reservoir delays elimination even with sufficient herd immunity . furthermore
, continued topv use may lead to new cvdpv emergences in populations with insufficient herd immunity .
the disappearance of cases indicates that substantial improvement in type 2 immunity has significantly reduced the national incidence rate , but the historical stability of the effective reproductive number near 1 suggests that the dynamics in the populations that continue to transmit are more stable than the national trend overall .
estimates here apply only to the known endemic lineages and new emergences may change expectations for the time to complete cvdpv2 elimination even if no new cases are seen from the established lineages .
the above points suggest to this author that it would be reasonable for the polio program in nigeria to place more emphasis on cvdpv2 prevention by the end of 2015 .
however , until the world is wild - polio - free , the risk of the re - importation of wpv1 must be balanced with the risk of ongoing cvdpv2 transmission and new cvdpv emergence .
furthermore , certification of polio - free status is a stringent goal [ line - through]*wiith*with additional requirements for surveillance and specimen containment @xcite , and so these estimates need to be considered in that context .
the model was designed to help policymakers manage that balance .
involved parties may use the probabilities over time to weight different scenarios and inform their planning @xcite , and the model can be easily extended to consider alternative scenarios about the future dynamics of the force of infection .
if a new case is detected , then these model predictions are no longer valid . however , since the silent periods as of march 31 , 2015 are much longer than typical , a new case would likely represent one of two scenarios
. it would either be the last orphan case very near elimination , or it will be the first case of a new outbreak for which more cases will shortly follow . in the event another case occurs but is not followed by an outbreak , this analysis can be repeated to provide updated estimates . in the event of an outbreak ,
surveillance sensitivity is not the primary policy concern .
the model assumes that the balance of birth and vaccination maintains stationary dynamics for the force of infection with constant mean infection growth rate and random variability . with additional data about birth demographics and vaccination activities
, this model can be extended to include non - random structure in the statistical model of the force of infection .
one could inform such models by correlating the apparently random changes in the force of infection with the supplemental vaccination calendar @xcite to estimate how future campaigns may affect the force of infection and subsequent probability of elimination .
the model is based solely on afp surveillance and ignores any role for alternative active surveillance strategies such as environmental surveillance @xcite .
certification - quality afp surveillance provides a representative sample from all populations regardless of location .
it is not obvious how to include environmental surveillance ( es ) in the model because es is only sensitive at fixed locations , but the model makes no assumptions about spatial structure .
furthermore , at a given es site , there is not yet any practical way to quantify the meaning of a negative sample . and
while positive environmental samples provide unambiguous evidence of local transmission at the time of the sample , we do not yet know how to quantify the effect of a positive sample on quantitative estimates of prevalence and thus future elimination probabilty . because es can dramatically improve the sensitivity in well - characterized populations @xcite , the role of es in certifying elimination warrants further empirical and theoretical study .
* added july 10 , 2015 : * after this paper was submitted , the gpei reported an environmental sample from march ( kaduna state , nigeria ) that was positive for cvdpv2 from an established lineage @xcite , and a new case from the same lineage with a date of onset of may16 , 2015 was reported on june 30 in the federal capital territory , confirming the predictions of this paper that cvdpv2 elimination was unlikely at that time and that a new case was likely within a few months of march 31 , 2015 .
the model estimates that this one case does not significantly change the forecast for cvdpv2 elimination by april 2016 .
this perhaps counter - intuitive result occurs because the new case is consistent with a substantial drop in cvdvp2 prevalence over the last 6 months .
the median predicted time to the next case is 2 months under the most likely scenario for the future effective reproductive number .
if another case with a date of onset prior to the end of july 2015 is observed , then it will be likely that cvdpv2 prevalence is rising , and this would lead to significantly more pessimisitc forecasts for cvdpv2 elimination by april 2016 .
i will continue to provide updated forecasts if new cases occur .
the persistent intervals prior to elimination and the silent periods between cases given no elimination are determined by the force of infection , the case - to - infection ratio for each serotype , the mean infectious duration , and the number of extant infections at the time of the most recent case .
in contrast to complex models with many elements that explicitly model assumptions about the influences of demographics , contact patterns , heterogeneous immune states , and vaccination history on transmission @xcite , this model reduces all the complexity of transmission into a statistical model for the time - varying force of infection .
this design facilitates efficient marginalization over the substantial uncertainty in transmission dynamics in a manner consistent with the limited available data .
the range of the simulated outcomes from the model honestly represents the contributions of both parametric and stochastic uncertainties to the estimates of the probabilities of elimination .
[ [ dynamical - model . ] ] dynamical model .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the deterministic approximation to the model is given by a single equation : @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the number of infected people at time t , @xmath34 is the time - varying force of infection , and @xmath35 is the inverse of the mean infectious duration .
the growth rate is @xmath36 and the effective reproductive number is @xmath37 . in the stochastic version of the model ,
new infections occur at the inhomogeneous poisson rate @xmath38 and existing infections are cleared at poisson rate @xmath35 .
this simple linear model is appropriate to model transmission near elimination because we can make a few assumptions that are not generally true .
( 1 ) there are many fewer infected than susceptible people and so the force of infection is independent of the susceptible fraction .
( 2 ) to know if elimination does not occur , we only need to predict the next paralytic case and do not need to correctly model outbreak size or duration .
( 3 ) since we do not need to model the non - linear dynamics during an outbreak , but we want to explore the wide range possible transmission histories that could occur between cases or prior to elimination , a flexible statistical model of the force of infection is more appropriate than a specific dynamical model with mechanistic assumptions .
[ [ statistical - model - for - the - time - varying - force - of - infection . ] ] statistical model for the time - varying force of infection .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + a statistical model of the force of infection was constructed from published polio incidence data ( ) . the paralytic polio cases were re - binned to count the number of cases , @xmath39 , in @xmath40 month intervals and the growth rate between intervals was estimated as @xmath41 .
when there are no cases in an interval , the growth rate was assumed to be the same as in the nearest bin for which there was data ( fig .
[ casefig ] ) .
): wpv1 ( b ) , wpv3 ( d ) , cvdpv2 ( f ) .
note that while the overall case counts vary over time by two orders of magnitude , the reproductive number mean and range are stable .
this motivates the assumption that transmission dynamics are stable among the populations that support ongoing transmission even as the number of such populations is lower now than a decade ago . ]
the distribution of growth rates is approximately normal .
there are no significant differences by serotype ( fig .
[ modelspecfig]a ) or significant deviations from normality ( ks - test , @xmath42 ) .
the mean growth rate is @xmath43 and insignificantly different from 0 ; the standard deviation is @xmath44 ; there is no significant dependence of the growth rate with time .
it is more intuitive to consider the effective reproductive number . for a mean infectious duration of 2 weeks , @xmath45 , the estimated mean effective reproductive number is 0.99 as expected for an endemic disease , and the standard deviation is 0.14 . to test for temporal correlations indicative of seasonality
, i examined the fourier power spectra of each growth rate time series .
the spectrum for wpv1 indicates the existence of seasonality with peak power at a 1 year period , but there are no clear peaks for wpv3 or cvdpv2 ( data not shown ) . despite decreases in polio prevalence and increases in vaccination quality since 2004 @xcite , the observed growth rate mean and range appear to be stable .
b , d , f ) vs a normal distribution with mean 0 and standard deviation @xmath46 .
there are no significant differences between serotypes or deviations from normality ( ks - test , @xmath42 ) .
( b ) dynamical model cartoon : the model simulates the fade out and persistence of chains of transmission among a small number of people in a larger population .
( c ) example model trajectories .
simulations were terminated when either enough infections were created to cause a new case or when elimination occurred .
( d - g ) example simulated growth rate trajectories for the model ( also indicated is @xmath11 for @xmath45 ) .
compare with fig .
[ casefig ] b , d , f . ]
the estimator is insensitive to changes in the surveillance quality over time as long as the fraction change in surveillance sensitivity , @xmath47 , in the estimation time interval is small .
the growth rate estimator with a term for the unknown changing surveillance sensitivity is : @xmath48 .
the typical size of the first term is the standard deviation of the growth rate , and so as long as @xmath49 , the change in surveillance sensitivity can be ignored .
the national non - polio afp detection rate has roughly doubled since 2005 @xcite .
thus , while the slow increase in surveillance sensitivity is significant over the ten year period , its impact on the statistical model for the force of infection is negligible ( @xmath50 per quarter ) . to model possible trajectories for the time - varying force of infection
, i constructed time series for the growth rate @xmath51 from independent samples for each 3 month interval from the growth rate distribution .
the assumption of independence between intervals is justified because weak seasonality has little influence on the interval between cases ( fig .
example trajectories are shown in fig .
[ modelspecfig ] .
the mean infectious duration was drawn from a uniform prior for @xmath35 on the interval @xmath52 $ ] .
the range of the prior is determined from the range of observed mean poliovirus shedding durations in various historical and immunological settings @xcite .
this statistical model represents changes in the balance of vaccination coverage , demographic dynamics , and relevant heterogeneities as assumptions about the mean , variance , and temporal correlation of the force of infection .
it is based on the assumption that there are no long - term trends in the force of infection .
this assumption is conservative in the sense that trends in either direction shorten duration of silent transmission by either making outbreaks or elimination more likely .
finally , note that this model is designed to simulate disease dynamics near elimination .
the model would not work well if the saturating nonlinearities that determine outbreak size and duration were important because the model is inherently linear .
[ [ model - of - the - interval - between - cases . ] ] model of the interval between cases .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + to model the interval between cases , simulations were initialized at the time of the most recent observed case .
i assumed that progression from infection to paralysis can be modeled as a bernoulli trial with probability @xmath53 .
accordingly , the probability that infection number @xmath33 is the next paralytic case is geometrically distributed , @xmath54 @xcite .
estimated case - to - infection ratios for individuals fully susceptible to paralysis are 1:200 for wpv1 , 1:1150 for wpv3 , and 1:1900 for cvdpv2 @xcite under the assumption that cvdpv2 has an indistinguishable phenotype from wild type 2 @xcite .
the impact of imperfect afp surveillance with only @xmath10 sensitivity ( such that half of all polio cases can be missed on average ) was modeled by reducing the case - to - infection ratios to 1:400 for wpv1 , 1:2300 for wpv3 , and 1:3800 for cvdpv2 .
since the case - to - infection ratios above describe paralysis - susceptible infections only , and the statistical model for the force of infection is based on paralytic cases only , the model of new infections explicitly represents only infections in the cohort of people who are susceptible to paralysis .
it does not represent infections in individuals that are protected from paralysis by prior immunity but are not fully protected from infection @xcite .
the model is agnostic to the details of how transmission between paralysis - susceptible individuals is mediated , and the role of individuals who can be infected but can not be observed is subsumed into the empirical model for the force of infection between paralysis - susceptible individuals .
[ [ initial - condition - distribution . ] ] initial condition distribution . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the interval between the two most recent observed cases provides a target to calibrate the initial prevalence .
the range of initial infections was calibrated to match the median interval between cases in the model to the observed interval between the two most recent cases .
this is based on the assumption that prior to observing a silent period , the next case interval is expected to be similar to the previous one . for wpv1 , the most recent case occurred on july 24 , 2014 and the observed interval to the case prior to it was @xmath55 days earlier @xcite .
( for comparison , since the start of 2012 , the typical interval between wpv1 cases was @xmath56 $ ] days ( mean [ @xmath4 interval ] ) . ) for wpv3 , the most recent case occurred on november 11 , 2012 and the interval to the previous was @xmath57 days @xcite ( vs. @xmath58 $ ] days ) . for cvdpv2 ,
the most recent case occurred on november 16 , 2014 and @xmath59 days @xcite ( vs. @xmath60 $ ] days ) . for each @xmath35 ,
gradient descent was used to reduce the absolute difference between the median time to the next case in the model and the target interval to at most one day .
the resulting fits of the initial conditions to the median intervals are closely approximated by a simple curve that depends on @xmath35 , the case - to - infection ratio for each serotype , the target interval between cases , and a factor of order 1 : @xmath61 with @xmath62 , @xmath63 , and @xmath64 .
the initial condition curves indicate that at the time of the most recent case , the prevalence of cvdpv2 was approximately 22 times greater than the prevalence of wpv1 and 73 times greater than wpv3 at the times of their most recent cases .
* added july 10 , 2015 : bayesian data assimilation for updated cvdpv2 initial conditions .
* for the updated cvdpv2 forecast , a bayesian data assimilation procedure was used to identify appropriate initial conditions . from the set of simulations from the march forecast that are consistent with the data as described in the results , i built a mixture distribution for the initial number of infections on may 16 , 2015 : @xmath65 with @xmath66 and normally - distributed initial conditions given the scenario @xmath67 [ [ simulation - procedure . ] ] simulation procedure .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the stochastic version of the model was coded in c # and trajectories were simulated using the gillespie s direct method for time - varying rates @xcite .
for each run of the model , the parameters @xmath35 , @xmath34 , and the number of infections required to produce the next case were sampled from their distributions , and the simulation was stopped when elimination occurred or the number of infections required to produce a case was reached . for all scenarios , at least 20 000 simulations and up to 200 000 simulations
were run to produce fig .
[ resultsfig ] .
[ [ probabilities - of - elimination - and - the - time - to - the - next - case . ] ] probabilities of elimination and the time to the next case .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the probability of elimination without seeing another case was estimated as : @xmath68 where @xmath69 is the number of simulations that eliminate at or before time @xmath70 and @xmath71 is the number of simulations that persist past time @xmath70 .
the probability of the time to the next case given elimination does not occur and given the observed silent period through march 31 , 2015 is estimated as the number of simulations that produce a case after march 31 , 2015 but at or before time @xmath70 over the number of simulations that produce a case at any time after march 31 , 2015 .
* added july 10 , 2015 : * for the updated cvdpv2 forecast , the probability of the time to the next case given elimination does not occur is estimated as the number of simulations that produce a case after may 16 , 2015 but at or before time @xmath70 over the number of simulations that produce a case at any time after may 16 , 2015 .
* polio case incidence data table for 20042014 .
* the polio case incidence rates for for wpv1 and wpv3 through september 2014 were scraped from the figures of refs . @xcite with the aide of the datathief software package ( b. tummers , datathief iii .
2006 : http://datathief.org/ [ http://datathief.org/ ] ) .
the cvdpv2 incidence data was taken from the supplement of ref .
@xcite through the end of 2011 and extended through september 2014 with scraped data from refs . @xcite .
the remaining data after september 2014 was derived from the weekly tally sheets available at ref .
the author would like to thank kevin mccarthy , hil lyons , guillaume chabot - couture , hao hu , and philip eckhoff ( idm ) for helpful feedback at various points during this project , dr . faisal shuaib ( federal ministry of health , federal republic of nigeria ) [ line - through]*comments on * and the anonymous reviewers for comments that improved the manuscript , and christopher lorton , basil bayati , joshua proctor , and min roh ( idm ) for sharing their efficient and easy - to - use c # compartmental model solver .
kew om , cochi sl , jafari hs , wassilak sgf , mast ee , diop om , et al . .
morbidity and mortality weekly report .
available from : http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm6345a4.htm . .
abuja : national primary health care development agency ; 2013 .
available from : http://www.polioeradication.org/portals/0/document/infectedcountries/nigeria/nigeria_nationalpolioeradicationemergencyplan_2014.pdf . | wild poliovirus type 3 ( wpv3 ) has not been seen anywhere since the last case of wpv3-associated paralysis in nigeria in november 2012 . at the time of writing ,
the most recent case of wild poliovirus type 1 ( wpv1 ) in nigeria occurred in july 2014 , and wpv1 has not been seen in africa since a case in somalia in august 2014 .
no cases associated with circulating vaccine - derived type 2 poliovirus ( cvdpv2 ) have been detected in nigeria since november 2014 .
has wpv1 been eliminated from africa ?
has wpv3 been eradicated globally ? has nigeria interrupted cvdpv2 transmission ?
these questions are difficult because polio surveillance is based on paralysis and paralysis only occurs in a small fraction of infections .
this report provides estimates for the probabilities of poliovirus elimination in nigeria given available data as of march 31 , 2015 .
it is based on a model of disease transmission that is built from historical polio incidence rates and is designed to represent the uncertainties in transmission dynamics and poliovirus detection that are fundamental to interpreting long time periods without cases .
the model estimates that , as of march 31 , 2015 , the probability of wpv1 elimination in nigeria is @xmath0 , and that if wpv1 has not been eliminated , a new case will be detected with @xmath1 probability by the end of 2015 .
the probability of wpv3 elimination ( and thus global eradication ) is @xmath2 .
however , it is unlikely that the ongoing transmission of cvdpv2 has been interrupted ; the probability of cvdpv2 elimination rises to @xmath3 if no new cases are detected by april 2016 .
* added july 10 , 2015 * : on june 26 , 2015 , a paralytic polio case caused by ongoing circulation of established cvdpv2 lineage was confirmed by the global polio laboratory network .
the date of paralysis onset was may 16 , 2015 , 181 days after the previous case .
the case provides new information about the prevalence of cvdpv2 in nigeria that can be used to both assess the accuracy of the predictions for elimination and case detection in the first version of the paper and provide the basis for an updated forecast for the time to cvdpv2 elimination if no cases are detected .
the model predictions for cvdpv2 pepared on march 31 , 2015 proved to be accurate : elimination did not occur and the observed case occurred within the @xmath4 prediction interval .
the updated forecasts predict that this one case has little impact on the estimates for the probability of elimination by april 2016 .
this counter - intuitive result was found because the 6-month silent interval following the previous 13-day interval indicates that cvdpv2 prevalence has fallen roughly 16-fold in nigeria since november 2014 and that the recent mean effective reproductive number for ongoing cvdpv2 transmission in nigeria is below 1 . under the most likely scenario for the transmission dynamics in the near future , the median time to the date of onset of the next case if elimination does not occur is july 15 , 2015 .
i intend to provide further updates to this manuscript if new cases occur .
it is important to note that if another case occurs before the end of july 2015 , it will likely indicate increasing prevalence and so forecasts for elimination by april 2016 would then be more pessimistic . |
the equation of motion for a supernova remnant ( snr ) can be modeled by a single law of motion or multiple laws of motion when the appropriate boundary conditions are provided .
examples of a single law of motion are : the sedov expansion in the presence of a circumstellar medium ( csm ) with constant density where the radius , @xmath2 , scales as @xmath3 , see @xcite , and the momentum conservation in the framework of the thin layer approximation with csm at constant density where @xmath4 , see @xcite .
examples of piece - wise solutions for an snr can be found in @xcite : a first energy conserving phase , @xmath3 followed by a second adiabatic phase where @xmath5 . at the same time
it has been shown that in the first ten years of 1993j @xmath6 , which means an observed exponent larger than the previously suggested exponents , see @xcite .
the previous analysis allows posing a basic question : ` is it possible to find an analytical solution for snrs given the three observable astronomical parameters , age , radius and velocity ? ' . in order to answer the above question ,
section [ secprofiles ] introduces three profiles for the csm , section [ secmotion ] derives three pad approximated laws of motion for snrs , and section [ secastro ] closes the derived equations of motion for four snrs .
this section introduces three density profiles for the csm : an exponential profile , a gaussian profile , and a self - gravitating profile of lane emden type .
[ secprofiles ] this density is assumed to have the following exponential dependence on @xmath2 in spherical coordinates : @xmath7 where @xmath8 represents the scale .
the piece - wise density is @xmath9 the total mass swept , @xmath10 , in the interval @xmath11 $ ] is @xmath12 this density has the gaussian dependence @xmath13 and the piece - wise density is @xmath14 the total mass swept , @xmath10 , in the interval @xmath11 $ ] is @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the error function , see @xcite . the lane
emden profile when @xmath0 , after @xcite , is @xmath17 @xmath18 the total mass swept , @xmath10 , in the interval @xmath11 $ ] is @xmath19
the conservation of the momentum in spherical coordinates in the framework of the thin layer approximation states that @xmath20 where @xmath21 and @xmath22 are the masses swept at @xmath23 and @xmath2 , and @xmath24 and @xmath25 are the velocities of the thin layer at @xmath23 and @xmath2 . assuming an exponential profile as given by eq .
( [ profile_exponential ] ) the velocity is @xmath26 where @xmath27 and @xmath28 in the above differential equation of the first order in @xmath2 , the variables can be separated and integration gives the following non - linear equation : @xmath29 in this case is not possible to find an analytical solution for the radius , @xmath2 , as a function of time .
we therefore apply the pad rational polynomial approximation of degree 2 in the numerator and degree 1 in the denominator about the point @xmath30 to the left - hand side of eq .
( [ eqn_nl_exp ] ) : @xmath31 the resulting pad approximant for the radius @xmath32 is @xmath33 and the velocity is @xmath34 @xmath35 and @xmath36 assuming a gaussian profile as given by eq .
( [ prof_gaussian ] ) the velocity is @xmath37 where @xmath38 and @xmath39 the appropriate non - linear equation is @xmath40 the pad rational polynomial approximation of degree 2 in the numerator and degree 1 in the denominator about @xmath30 for the left - hand side of the above equation gives @xmath41 the resulting pad approximant for the radius @xmath32 is @xmath42^{\frac{1}{2 } } \bigg \ } \label{rmotiongauss } \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and the velocity is @xmath43 @xmath44 and @xmath45 assuming a lane
emden profile , @xmath0 , as given by eq .
( [ profile_lane ] ) , the velocity is @xmath46 where @xmath47 and @xmath48 the connected non - linear equation is @xmath49 the pad rational polynomial approximation of degree 2 in the numerator and degree 1 in the denominator for the left - hand side of the above equation gives @xmath50 where @xmath51 the pad approximant for the radius is @xmath52 where @xmath53 and @xmath54 and the velocity is @xmath55 where @xmath56 and @xmath57
in the previous section , we derived three equations of motion in the form of non - linear equations and three pad approximated equations of motion .
we now check the reliability of the numerical and approximated solutions on four snrs : tycho , see @xcite , cas a , see @xcite , cygnus loop , see @xcite , and sn 1006 , see @xcite .
the three astronomical measurable parameters are the time since the explosion in years , @xmath58 , the actual observed radius in pc , @xmath2 , and the present velocity of expansion in kms@xmath59 , see table [ tablesnrs ] . . observed astronomical parameters of snrs [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the goodness of the approximation
is evaluated through the percentage error , @xmath60 , which is @xmath61 where @xmath32 is the pad approximated radius and @xmath62 is the exact solution which is obtained by solving numerically the non - linear equation of motion , as an example eq .
( [ eqn_nl_exp ] ) in the exponential case .
the numerical values of @xmath60 are reported in column 6 of tables [ tablesnrsexp ] , [ tablesnrsgauss ] and [ tablesnrslaneemden ] .
another useful astrophysical variable is the predicted decrease in velocity on the basis of the pad approximated velocity , @xmath63 , in 10 years , see column 7 of tables [ tablesnrsexp ] , [ tablesnrsgauss ] and [ tablesnrslaneemden ] .
the expansion of an snr can be modeled by the conservation of momentum in the presence of a decreasing density : here we analysed an exponential , a gaussian and a lane
emden profile .
the three equations of motion have complicated left - hand sides but simple left - hand sides , viz . , @xmath64 .
the application of the pad approximant to the left - hand side of the complicated equation of motion allows finding three approximate laws of motion , see eqs ( [ rmotionexp ] , [ rmotiongauss ] , [ rmotionlaneemden ] ) , and three approximate velocities , see eqs ( [ vmotionexp ] , [ vmotiongauss ] , [ vmotionlaneemden ] ) .
the astrophysical test is performed on four spherical snrs assumed to be spherical and the four sets of parameters are reported in tables [ tablesnrsexp ] , [ tablesnrsgauss ] and [ tablesnrslaneemden ] . the percentage of error of the pad approximated solutions for the radius is always less than @xmath1 with respect to the numerical exact solution , see column 6 of the three last tables . in order to produce an astrophysical prediction , the theoretical decrease in velocity for the four snrs here analysed
is evaluated , see column 7 of tables [ tablesnrsexp ] , [ tablesnrsgauss ] and [ tablesnrslaneemden ] .
h j 1870 on the theoretical temperature of the sun , under the hypothesis of a gaseous mass maintaining its volume by its internal heat , and depending on the laws of gases as known to terrestrial experiment _ american journal of science _ * 148 * , 57 b j , chomiuk l , hewitt j w , blondin j m , borkowski k j , ghavamian p , petre r and reynolds s p 2016 an x - ray and radio study of the varying expansion velocities in tycho supernova remnant _ _ * 823 * l32 ( _ preprint _ ) | in this paper we derive three equations of motion for a supernova remnant ( snr ) in the framework of the thin layer approximation using the pad approximant .
the circumstellar medium is assumed to follow a density profile of either an exponential type , a gaussian type , or a lane
emden ( @xmath0 ) type .
the three equations of motion are applied to four snrs : tycho , cas a , cygnus loop , and sn 1006 .
the percentage error of the pad approximated solution is always less than @xmath1 .
the theoretical decrease of the velocity over ten years for snrs is evaluated .
_ keywords _ : supernovae : general ism : supernova remnants supernovae : individual ( tycho ) supernovae : individual ( cas a ) supernovae : individual ( cygnus loop ) supernovae : individual ( sn 1006 ) |
this paper is sub - divided in four sections : we give a brief overview of the gaia satellite and introduce the data processing and analysis consortium ( dpac ) .
following on from this we describe the overall system architecture for gaia processing and finally take a more detailed look at the core processing .
the gaia payload consists of three distinct instruments for astrometric , photometric and spectroscopic measurements , mounted on a single optical bench .
unlike hst and sim , which are pointing missions observing a preselected list of objects , gaia is a scanning satellite that will repeatedly survey in a systematic way the whole sky .
the main performances of gaia expressed with just a few numbers are just staggering and account for the vast scientific harvest awaited from the mission : a complete survey to 20th magnitude of all point sources amounting to more than one thousand million objects , with an astrometric accuracy of 12@xmath0 at 15th magnitude and @xmath1 for the few million stars brighter than 13th magnitude ; radial velocities down to 17th magnitude , with an accuracy ranging from 1 to @xmath2 ; multi - epoch spectrophotometry for every observed source sampling from the visible to the near ir . beyond its sheer measurement accuracy
, the major strength of gaia follows from ( i ) its capability to perform an all - sky and sensitivity limited absolute astrometry survey at sub - arcsecond angular resolution , ( ii ) the unique combination into a single spacecraft of the three major instruments carrying out nearly contemporaneous observations , ( iii ) the huge number of objects and observations allowing to amplify the accuracy on single objects to large samples with deep statistical significance , a feature immensely valuable for astrophysics and unique to gaia .
the dpac has been formed to answer the announcement of opportunity ( ao ) for the gaia processing .
the dpac is formed around a series of `` coordination units '' ( cu ) , themselves sub - divided into `` development units '' ( du ) .
the cus are supported by a set of data processing centres ( dpc ) .
the overall coordination is performed by the consortium executive ( dpace ) .
the structure is shown in fig . [
fig : dpacorgan ] and described in more detail below .
consider that there are over 270 scientists and developers currently registered in dpac who will contribute to the scientific processing on gaia .
+ the cus are small in number , with clearly - defined responsibilities and interfaces , and their boundaries fit naturally with the main relationships between tasks and the associated data flow
. there will be several areas of involvement across these boundaries , but in first instance it is up to the coordination units to ensure that a group of tasks is prepared and optimised , as well as fully tested and documented , as required by the project .
the coordination units will have a reasonable amount of autonomy in their internal organisation and in developing what they consider as the best solution for their task .
however they are constrained by the fact that any such solution has to meet the requirements and time schedules determined by the consortium executive for the overall data processing . in this respect the data exchange protocol and the adherence to the data processing development cycles are mandatory to ensure that every group can access the data it needs in the right format and at the right moment . while the coordination units are intended to reflect the top level structure of the data processing , with completely well - defined responsibilities and commitments to the dpac ,
they could for practical reasons be sub - divided into more manageable components , called development units ( du ) .
this is a more operational level with a lighter management which will take the responsibility for the development of a specific part of the software with well defined boundaries . not
every cu will organise its dus ( if any ) in the same way , and how they interact with the cu level is left to the cu management .
responsibilities of the coordination units include : ( a ) establishing development priorities ; ( b ) procuring , optimizing and testing algorithms ; ( c ) defining and supervising the development units linked to them .
each coordination unit is headed by a scientific manager and one or two deputy managers .
the cus will also comprise software engineers .
the development activities of each cu are closely associated with at least one dpc ( data processing centre ) where the computer hardware is available to carry out the actual processing of the data .
a technical manager from this centre belongs to the upper management structure of every cu .
the software development and the preparation and testing of its implementation in a dpc are parallel activities within every cu and their mutual adequacy must be closely monitored by the cu manager with his dpc representative .
advancement reports are regularly presented to the dpac executive .
our overall organisation gives the cus much autonomy in the way they handle their part of the data processing , and the internal organisation and management structures do not need to be uniform across cus .
however there is a single goal shared by all the cus , and they must follow a common schedule and adhere strictly to many interfaces so that the results produced by one group are available in a timely manner and may be used efficiently by other groups . a variety of standards and conventions , the content and structure of the mdb ( main database ) and the processing cycles must be agreed collectively . therefore in addition to a local management of each cu , the overall dpac is coordinated and managed by an executive committee , called dpace for `` data processing and analysis consortium executive '' .
this overall management structure of the consortium deals with all the matters which are not specific to the internal management of a cu and is meant to make an efficient interaction between the cus possible .
the dpace responsibilities are primarily coordination tasks although it will make important decisions to be implemented by all cus which are akin to real management .
any large system is normally broken down into logical components to allow distributed development .
gaia data processing is on a very large and highly distributed scale .
the approach taken to the decomposition has been to identify major parts of the system which may operate relatively independently , although practically all parts of the gaia processing are in fact interdependent from the point of view of the data . from a development point of view however , a well defined icd ( interface control document ) would allow completely decoupled components to be developed and even operated in disparate locations .
the approach is driven by the fact that this is a large system which will be developed in many countries and by teams of varying competence .
hence at this level of decomposition libraries or infrastructure are not considered to be components . at some lower level
these components may indeed share libraries and infrastructure but this is not a cornerstone for the architecture .
only the top level components and their interaction are considered in this decomposition .
figure [ fig : sysarc ] shows the logical components of the system and the data flow between them .
* mission control system ( mcs ) * data distribution system ( dds ) * initial data treatment and first look ( idt / fl ) * simulation ( sim ) * intermediate data update ( idu ) * astrometric global iterative solution ( agis ) * astrometric verification unit ( avu ) * object processing ( obj ) * photometric processing ( phot ) * spectroscopic processing ( spec ) * variability processing ( vari ) * astrometric parameters ( astp ) * main database ( mdb ) * archive gaia processing is all about data .
the data flow is the most important description of the system and has been under discussion within the community for some time .
the result of these discussions is the data flow scheme depicted in fig .
[ fig : sysarc ] . the flow lines in fig .
[ fig : sysarc ] are labeled and these labeled are referred to in the text below .
the data flow is divided into two categories , near - realtime and scientific processing .
the near - realtime data flow represents the data flow on a time scale of approximately 1 or 2 days , corresponding to the activities of the mission operations ground segment .
the mission operations centre ( moc ) at esoc receives all telemetry from the space segment [ 1.1 ] via the ground stations .
the science operations centre ( soc ) at esac will receive all telemetry directly from the ground station also [ 1.2 ] .
the raw data flow from the satellite is not shown explicitly in the diagram . over the nominal mission duration of five years
the payload will yield a total uncompressed data volume of roughly 100 tb .
the satellite will have contact with the ground station once a day for a mean duration of 11 hours . during this period , or
`` pass '' , an uncompressed data volume of roughly 50 gb is downlinked from the satellite via its medium - gain antenna , at a mean rate of about 5 mbit / s .
the raw telemetry data received by the ground station will be transmitted to the mission control system ( mcs ) at the moc and to the soc .
housekeeping data will be transmitted to the mcs within one hour after reception at the ground station .
the mcs will provide an immediate assessment on the spacecraft and instrument status through analysis of the housekeeping data .
all telemetry received by the moc systems will be ingested into the data distribution system ( dds ) [ 2 ] .
the dds will also contain data that were generated on - ground ( e.g. orbit data , time correlation data ) , operations reports ( telecommand history and timeline status ) , satellite databases used by the mcs and a copy of all telecommands sent to the spacecraft .
science telemetry is received by the soc [ 1.2 ] for processing by the idt .
data is also retrieved from the dds by the moc interface task at the soc and passed to the idt [ 3.1 ] .
the idt processing will decode and decompress the telemetry .
it will also extract higher - level image parameters and provide an initial cross matching of observations to known sources ( or else to new ones created in this step ) .
finally it will provide an initial satellite attitude at sub - arcsec precision .
the primary objective of the first look ( fl ) is to ensure the scientific health of gaia .
this information is returned to the mcs [ u1 ] .
first look processing will carry out a restricted astrometric solution on a dataset from a small number of great - circle scans . to perform some of its tasks
idt / fl requires reference data , such as up - to - date calibration data as well as positions , magnitudes etc . of bright objects that are expected to be observed by gaia during the time period to be processed .
this data will be made available to idt / fl [ 3.2 ] from the mdb .
fl will also calibrate the current data set itself and this calibration will be used by idt .
the telemetry is received by the mcs which does basic system monitoring .
the first look diagnostics produced by fl [ u1 ] will indicate if there are anomalies in the scientific output of the satellite which can be corrected on - board .
after interpretation of the diagnostics , the flight control team is informed of the anomaly , which can be resolved either through immediate commanding or during the next mission planning cycle . on a regular basis the mcs will send the prepared command schedule to gaia [ u2 ] , taking into account normal planning and inputs from idt / fl . during a ground station pass , immediate
commanding is also possible .
the outputs of idt / fl are made available to all tasks on a daily basis [ 4,5 ] and ingested into the main database [ 5.1 ] .
the raw database will be a repository for all raw data [ 5.2 ] .
copies of the raw database are expected at esac , bsc and cnes .
other tasks may retrieve the data according to their requirements [ 5.3 ] .
raw data will only be transmitted on a daily basis i.e. , it does not form part of the main database and is not foreseen to be sent again later .
data processing centres may produce ` science alerts ' from the gaia observations .
science alerts are sent to the soc for immediate distribution to the scientific community and for archiving in the main database [ 7 ] .
scientific processing represents the production of the gaia data products by the data processing ground segment from intermediate data .
the timescale for each iteration of this process is much longer than that of the near - realtime processing , of the order of six months or more .
it will continue after routine satellite operations have finished and will culminate in the production of the gaia catalogue .
the outputs of processing from each cu will be sent for incorporation in the main database [ 7 ] .
the main database is the hub of all data in the gaia data processing system .
our plan is to version this database at regular intervals , probably every six months .
the science processing is in general iterative .
hence each version of the main database is derived from the data in the previous version . by fixing the versions of the entire dataset at some point in time we avoid tracking individual object versions for the billions of objects in the database .
as described above the core processing involves idt , fl , idu and agis . in this section
we will look at the astrometric global iterative solution ( agis ) in a little more detail .
the astrometric core solution is the cornerstone of the data processing since it provides calibration data and attitude solution needed for all the other treatments , in addition to the astrometric solution of @xmath3 million _ primary sources_. the main equations to be solved can be summarized by relating the observed position on a detector to a general astrometric and instrument model as , @xmath4 where * @xmath5 is the observed one - dimensional location of the source at the instant determined by the centroiding algorithm applied to the observed photo - electron counts .
* @xmath6 is the astrometric model which for the primary stars should only comprise the five astrometric parameters ( @xmath7 .
* @xmath8 represents the parameters used to model the attitude over a given interval of time .
they are , for example , the cubic spline coefficients of the quaternion describing the orientation of the instrument with respect to the celestial reference frame as function of time .
* @xmath9 represents the global parameters such as the ppn parameters or other relevant parameters needed to fix the reference frame of the observations . *
@xmath10 comprises all the parameters needed for the instrument modelling : geometric calibration parameters ( both intra- and inter - ccds ) , basic angle , chromaticity effect and other instrumental offsets .
* @xmath11 is the gaussian white noise which can be estimated from the photon counts and centroiding for every observation and used to weigh the equations .
a test is performed at the end to validate the assumption on the noise . assuming some @xmath12 primary stars , the total number of unknowns for the astrometric core solution includes some @xmath13 astrometric parameters , @xmath14 attitude parameters , and a few million calibration parameters .
the condition equations connecting the unknowns to the observed data are intrinsically non - linear , although they generally linearise well at the sub - arcsec level . direct solution of the corresponding least - squares problem is unfeasible , by many orders of magnitude , simply in view of the large number of unknowns and their strong inter - connectivity , which prevents any useful decomposition of the problem into manageable parts . the proposed method is based on the _ global iterative solution _ scheme ( esa 1997 , vol . 3 , ch .
23 ) , which in the current context is referred to as the _ astrometric gis _ ( agis ) since related methods are adopted for the photometric and spectroscopic processing .
it is necessary to have reasonable starting values for all the unknowns , so as to be close to the linear regime of the condition equations .
these are generally provided by the initial data treatment .
the idea of agis is then quite simple , and consists of the following steps : 1 .
assuming that the attitude and calibration parameters are known , the astrometric parameters can be estimated for all the stars .
this can be done for one star at a time , thus comprising a least - squares problem with only 5 unknowns and of order 1000 observations .
moreover , this part of the solution is extremely well suited for distributed processing .
2 . next , assuming that the astrometric parameters and the calibration parameters are known , it is possible to use the same observations to estimate the attitude .
this can be done for each uninterrupted observation interval at a time . for a typical interval of one week ,
the number of unknowns is about 500000 and the number of observations @xmath15 .
the number of unknowns may seem rather large for a least - squares problem , but the band - diagonal structure of the normal equations resulting from the spline fitting makes the memory consumption and computing time a linear function of the number of unknowns , rather than the cubic scaling for general least - squares solutions .
the problem is thus easily manageable .
3 . assuming then that the astrometric and attitude parameters are known , the calibration parameters can be estimated from the residuals in transit time and across - scan field angles .
it is necessary to iterate the sequence of steps 1 , 2 , 3 as many times as it takes to reach convergence .
once the linear regime has been reached , the convergence should be geometric , i.e. , the errors ( and updates ) should decrease roughly by a constant factor in each cycle .
based on simple considerations of redundancy and the geometry of observations , a convergence factor of @xmath16@xmath17 is expected .
if a geometric behaviour is indeed observed , it may be possible to accelerate the convergence by over - relaxation .
the iteration must be driven to a point where the updates are much smaller than the accuracy aimed at in the resulting data .
5 . after convergence ,
the astrometric and attitude parameters refer to an internally consistent celestial reference frame , but this does not necessarily , and in general will not , coincide with the international celestial reference system ( icrs ) . a subset of the primary stars and quasars , with known positions / proper motions in the icrs , is therefore analyzed to derive the nine parameters describing a uniform rotation between the two systems , plus the apparent streaming motion of quasars due to the cosmological acceleration of the solar - system barycentre .
the astrometric and attitude parameters are then transformed into the icrs by application of a uniform rotation .
it is envisaged that the whole sequence 15 is repeated several times during the processing , initially perhaps every 6 months during the accumulation of more observations .
these repeats are called outer agis iterations .
optionally , the iteration loop 13 may also include an estimation of global parameters . to facilitate the execution of the agis algorithms
a data driven approach has been followed .
the notion is that any data should only be read once and passed to algorithms rather than each algorithm accessing data directly .
a process , termed the data train , sits between the data access layer and the algorithm requiring data .
it accesses the data and invokes the algorithm thus providing an absolute buffer between scientific code and data access .
the data train is a manifestation of the intermediary pattern [ gamma 1994 ] and has the advantage that different implementations of varying complexity may be provided .
hence a scientist may run a simplified agis on a laptop for testing which does not require the full hardware of the data processing centre .
esac currently hosts agis on a sixteen node cluster of dual processor dell xeon machines .
a 6 tb storage area network ( san ) is used to host the oracle database containing the data .
the system is entirely written in java and runs on the 64-bit sun jdk1.5 .
the current implementation is executing with simulation data and reaches convergence within 27 outer iterations for very noisy input data .
the simulated dataset is of 1.1 million sources with five years of observation amounting to about @xmath12 observations .
convergence is declared when the median added to the width of the parallax update histogram is below 1 @xmath18as .
see also [ hernandez 2007 ] .
gaia is an ambitious space mission where the instrument and data processing are intimately related .
an overall distributed data processing architecture has been outlined .
a distributed management structure is in place to ensure the processing software is built .
rapid development of key software modules is underway , for example the core astrometric solution has been presented in this paper .
dpac has made an excellent start but a difficult road lies ahead to achieve the demanding accuracies required by the gaia mission . | gaia is esa s ambitious space astrometry mission with a main objective to astrometrically and spectro - photometrically map not less than 1000 million celestial objects in our galaxy with unprecedented accuracy .
the announcement of opportunity ( ao ) for the data processing will be issued by esa late in 2006 .
the gaia data processing and analysis consortium ( dpac ) has been formed recently and is preparing an answer to this ao .
the satellite will downlink around 100 tb of raw telemetry data over a mission duration of 56 years . to achieve its required accuracy of a few tens of microarcseconds in astrometry , a highly involved processing of this data
is required .
in addition to the main astrometric instrument gaia will host a radial - velocity spectrometer and two low - resolution dispersers for multi - colour photometry .
all instrument modules share a common focal plane made of a ccd mosaic about 1 square meter in size and featuring close to 1 giga pixels .
each of the various instruments requires a relatively complex processing while at the same time being interdependent .
we describe the composition and structure of the dpac and the envisaged overall architecture of the system .
we shall delve further into the core processing - one of the nine , so - called coordination units comprising the gaia processing system . |
the atlas detector at the lhc @xcite , shown in fig .
[ atlas ] , was designed primarily for precise measurements in the highest - energy proton - proton collisions , particularly to discover new high - mass particle states .
however , it is also a very capable detector for the measurement of heavy ion collisions at the highest energies achieved to date , already a factor of 14 higher than available at the relativistic heavy ion collider .
the atlas inner detector is immersed in a 2 tesla solenoid magnetic field and provides precise reconstruction of particle trajectories typically with three pixel layers and four double sided silicon strip detectors out to @xmath2 , as well as a transition radiation tracker , out to @xmath3 .
the longitudinally segmented atlas calorimeter provides electromagnetic and hadronic measurements out to @xmath4 , with particularly high spatial precision in the @xmath5 direction . finally , the atlas muon spectrometer is located outside the calorimeters ( which range out most of the hadronic backgrounds ) and measures muon tracks out to @xmath6 . the lhc provided lead - lead collisions to the three large experiments in november and december 2010 , and atlas accumulated almost ten inverse microbarns of luminosity , as shown in the right panel of fig .
[ atlas ] .
the analyses shown here typically use up to eight inverse microbarns , during which the main solenoid was activated . a smaller dataset with field off was used for multiplicity analyses .
( left ) schematic diagram of the atlas detector , showing the three main subsystems : the inner detector ( @xmath7 ) , the calorimeter ( @xmath8 ) and the muon spectrometer ( @xmath6 ) .
( right ) integrated luminosity taken by atlas in the 2010 heavy ion run vs. time .
, title="fig : " ] ( left ) schematic diagram of the atlas detector , showing the three main subsystems : the inner detector ( @xmath7 ) , the calorimeter ( @xmath8 ) and the muon spectrometer ( @xmath6 ) .
( right ) integrated luminosity taken by atlas in the 2010 heavy ion run vs. time .
, title="fig : " ]
( top ) inclusive charged particle multiplicity per participant pair , measured for the 6% most central collisions , compared with the earlier alice result , as well as a compilation of lower energy data .
( bottom ) the centrality dependence of the multiplicity per participant pair , compared with alice data and an average of the rhic data . ] global observables , such as the total multiplicity and elliptic flow , address crucial issues related to the basic properties of the hot , dense medium .
the charged particle multiplicity is important both from a thermodynamic standpoint , as it is proportional to the initial state entropy , as well as from the perspective of energy loss calculations which require an estimate of the initial gluon density . in atlas
, the multiplicity has been measured @xcite with the solenoid field turned off to mitigate the losses from the bending of low momentum particles .
the pixel layers within @xmath9 are used to minimize the non - primary backgrounds by only using hits consistent with a minimum - ionizing particle emanating from the primary vertex .
the pixel hits are assembled both into `` tracklets '' ( two hits , both consistent with the measured primary vertex ) and full tracks ( three points , reconstructed with the main atlas tracking software ) . in all , three methods are used , each with quite different systematic uncertainties , providing accurate measurements up to the highest particle densities and uncertainties of only a few percent .
the collision centrality is estimated using the total transverse energy measured in the atlas forward calorimeter ( fcal , covering @xmath10 ) and bins are selected using an estimated sampling fraction of @xmath11 .
the multiplicity results are shown in fig .
[ paper_dndetanpart ] .
the yield averaged over @xmath12 , @xmath13 , agrees well ( consistent within the stated systematic uncertainties ) with the previously - available alice data @xcite , both in the most central 0 - 6% events and as a function of collision centrality ( parametrized by @xmath14 ) . after scaling the rhic data by the observed factor of 2.15 , the centrality dependence at the lhc is also seen to be quite similar to that observed at a much lower energy .
elliptic flow as a function of transverse momentum for the 40 - 50% centrality bin , compared with data from rhic and the lhc .
] the collective response of the system to the initial geometric configuration of the nucleons in the colliding nuclei is typically characterized by the `` elliptic flow '' , or a @xmath15 modulation in the azimuthal angular distributions relative to a measured `` event plane . '' in atlas , the event plane is measured in the fcal which subtends @xmath16 .
elliptic flow is measured using tracks in the inner detector out to @xmath2 .
the effects of `` non flow '' are minimized by maximizing the gap between the track and the event plane measurement by using the event plane from the opposite fcal hemisphere to the measured track @xcite . the elliptic flow ( @xmath17 ) as a function of transverse momentum and pseudorapidity has been measured out to @xmath18 gev and @xmath7 for eight centrality bins .
there is no substantial pseudorapidity dependence out to the maximum measured @xmath5 , but there is a strong @xmath19 dependence with a pronounced rise in @xmath17 out to @xmath20 gev , a slower decrease out to @xmath21 gev and then a very weak dependence out to the highest measured @xmath19 .
[ v2_vs_pt ] compares the atlas data with already - published alice @xcite data as well as lower energy data from phenix @xcite and star @xcite , all from the 40 - 50% centrality bin ( except star data from 40 - 60% ) .
one finds that all of the data is quite similar , even at high @xmath19 within the large statistical errors of the phenix @xmath22 data .
it is not obvious if this apparent scaling behavior is consistent with expectations from differential energy loss .
higher order fourier coefficients ( @xmath23 ) as a function of transverse momentum for six centrality bins .
it is observed that while @xmath17 varies strongly with centrality , @xmath24 are nearly invariant . ] after the realization that initial state fluctuations can induce higher fourier modes in the overlap region of the two nuclei @xcite , elliptic flow has now been joined by the study of higher - order harmonic flow coefficients @xcite .
these are measured each in their own event plane .
the resolution has been evaluated by a variety of subdetector combinations and it is found that atlas can resolve modes up to @xmath25 in the most central 40% of events .
these are shown as a function of @xmath19 in fig .
[ vn_vs_pt ] in six centrality bins .
one sees the rapid change of @xmath17 with centrality , expected from previous measurements , but only a modest change in the higher order coefficients , suggesting that the latter are mainly sensitive to fluctuations of nucleon positions .
still , it is expected that the information from these higher coefficients can distinguish between competing physics scenarios attempting to explain the initial state as well as providing new information on the viscosity to entropy ratio .
measured two - particle correlation function for @xmath26 gev and @xmath27 in the 1% most central collisions ( open circles ) .
the reconstructed correlation function using the coefficients from the event plane measurement ( and @xmath28 from the two - particle measurement ) is also shown and agrees quite well with the directly measured correlation function , using both full fcal ( solid line ) and fcal@xmath29 ( dashed line ) methods . ]
a longstanding puzzle at rhic is the observation of unusual structures ( e.g. the mach cone @xcite ) in the two particle correlation function , particularly on the `` away side '' relative to a high @xmath19 particle .
both star @xcite and phenix @xcite observed a strongly - modified away - side peak which even developed a `` dip '' at @xmath30 in the most central events .
however , this was explained to arise most likely from the presence of higher flow coefficients beyond elliptic flow @xcite . in atlas
, the correlation function has been measured with large separation in @xmath5 to suppress the contribution from jets and a discrete fourier transform ( dft ) is used to extract coefficients out to @xmath25 @xcite .
these are found to agree quite well with the @xmath31 extracted using event plane approaches . more interestingly , when the event plane coefficients are used to construct a comparable two particle correlation function @xmath32 , one finds a striking agreement with the correlations measured directly , as shown in fig .
this suggests that what were formerly thought to be indications of jet - medium interactions may well result simply from the presence of higher - order flow harmonics , arising through a combination of nucleon position fluctuations and viscous effects .
( left ) single muon spectrum measured for the 0 - 10% most central events , with the templates for @xmath33 bosons and heavy flavor ( indicated as `` background '' ) also shown to illustrate the yield extraction procedure .
( right ) @xmath34 for @xmath33 bosons as a function of centrality , showing consistency with binary collision scaling .
the dotted line is a fit to a constant .
, title="fig : " ] ( left ) single muon spectrum measured for the 0 - 10% most central events , with the templates for @xmath33 bosons and heavy flavor ( indicated as `` background '' ) also shown to illustrate the yield extraction procedure .
( right ) @xmath34 for @xmath33 bosons as a function of centrality , showing consistency with binary collision scaling .
the dotted line is a fit to a constant .
, title="fig : " ] high @xmath0 processes produced by perturbative physics in the first collisions of the two nuclei ( also known as `` hard probes '' ) provide a means to probe the conditions of the collision at very early times .
this is typically done by means of `` suppression '' observables which indicate deviations from the expected scaling of yields by the number of binary collisions , estimated using glauber modeling ( e.g. the atlas @xmath35 measurement @xcite ) . to establish baseline behavior ,
atlas has used the spectrum of single muons at large @xmath19 to extract the yield of @xmath1 bosons , by a simultaneous fit of a template trained on simulated @xmath36 as well as a parameterization of muons from heavy flavor quark decays , as shown in the left panel of fig .
a sample of roughly 400 @xmath33 bosons has been extracted .
the binary scaling of the measured yields is studied using the variable @xmath37 , defined as the ratio of yields measured in different centrality classes to the yield measured in the 10% most central events , with all yields scaled by the corresponding number of binary nucleon - nucleon collisions .
the right panel of fig .
[ w ] shows @xmath37 as a function of centrality @xcite . using a fit to a constant value , which gives @xmath38 = [email protected] with a @xmath40 for 3 degrees of freedom , a significant consistency with binary scaling
is observed .
@xmath41 for r=0.4 ( left ) and r=0.2 ( right ) jets , as a function of centrality , with 60 - 80% used as the peripheral sample . in this convention ,
the most central events are on the left and the most peripheral are on the right .
, title="fig : " ] @xmath41 for r=0.4 ( left ) and r=0.2 ( right ) jets , as a function of centrality , with 60 - 80% used as the peripheral sample . in this convention ,
the most central events are on the left and the most peripheral are on the right .
, title="fig : " ] ( left ) transverse fragmentation function for r=0.2 anti-@xmath42 jets , comparing central 0 - 10% events with peripheral 40 - 80% .
( right ) the similar comparison for the longitudinal fragmentation function .
, title="fig : " ] ( left ) transverse fragmentation function for r=0.2 anti-@xmath42 jets , comparing central 0 - 10% events with peripheral 40 - 80% .
( right ) the similar comparison for the longitudinal fragmentation function .
, title="fig : " ] atlas has already published striking results on dijet asymmetries @xcite .
new results are reported here on the measurement of inclusive jet yields as a function of jet @xmath43 , in order to test models of qcd energy loss more directly @xcite .
jets are reconstructed using the anti-@xmath42 algorithm with the jet size set to both r=0.2 and r=0.4 , based on `` towers '' composed of calorimeter cells integrated over regions of size @xmath44 .
the ambient background is removed at the cell level by excluding regions near jets and calculating the mean energy , as well as any azimuthal modulation , in strips of width @xmath45 .
an iterative procedure is applied to remove any residual effect of the jets on the background subtraction .
the final jets are corrected for jet energy scale and resolution based on pythia jets embedded into hijing , with conservative systematic uncertainties assigned to account for the small differences between the fluctuations seen in data and simulation .
jets are restricted to @xmath46 , to stay within the main barrel and endcap regions of the calorimeter .
figure [ jet_rcp ] shows @xmath47 ( defined similarly to @xmath37 bin , but defined relative to the 60 - 80% centrality interval ) as a function of centrality for jets in three fixed @xmath43 bins ( @xmath48 gev , @xmath49 gev and @xmath50 gev ) . a smooth evolution of @xmath47
is observed going from the 50 - 60% central events on the right to the 0 - 10% central events on the left , where a suppression of roughly a factor of two is observed for all @xmath43 bins and for both r=0.4 as well as r=0.2 .
the invariance with r is suprising given the general tendency of radiative calculations to predict a modified fragmentation functions for quenched jets .
however , a direct measurement of longitudinal and transverse fragmentation functions , shown in fig .
[ frag_func ] , confirms that no substantial modification of the fragmentation function can be observed comparing peripheral and central events . in other words , the increased suppression of the jet rates
is not accompanied by any evident modification of the jets themselves .
( top ) charged particle @xmath47 measured relative to the 60 - 80% bin , for all tracks measured within @xmath51 , @xmath52 and @xmath7 .
( bottom ) @xmath47 for @xmath53 gev as a function of centrality .
, title="fig : " ] ( top ) charged particle @xmath47 measured relative to the 60 - 80% bin , for all tracks measured within @xmath51 , @xmath52 and @xmath7 .
( bottom ) @xmath47 for @xmath53 gev as a function of centrality .
, title="fig : " ] to study this phenomenon further , charged particle spectra have been measured out to @xmath54 and @xmath55 gev @xcite .
tracks are reconstructed in the full inner detector , with stringent requirements on the number of hits per track in order to suppress fake tracks . with these requirements , efficiencies are typically 70 - 80% while fake rates
near @xmath56 are less than a percent , although both efficiency and purity are reduced somewhat going to forward rapidity .
while tracks are measured in atlas at transverse momenta well past 30 gev , the measured track impact parameter errors ( which are also used to reject fake tracks ) are not well described by the full atlas simulation . figure [ charged_rcp ] top shows @xmath41 measured for charged hadrons relative to the 60 - 80% centrality interval .
the trend is similar to that seen in charged particle @xmath57 measured by alice @xcite .
there is a peak at 2 - 3 gev , a minimum around 7 gev and then a rise which has not yet leveled off even at @xmath55 gev .
the value of @xmath41 averaged over @xmath19 from 20 to 30 gev , shown in the bottom panel of fig .
[ charged_rcp ] , is found to decrease smoothly from a value near unity for 50 - 60% to approximately 0.4 for the 0 - 10% most central collisions , a trend both qualititatively and quantitatively similar to that found for fully reconstructed jets .
results are presented from the atlas detector from the 2010 lhc heavy ion run .
the charged particle multiplicity increases by a factor of two relative to the top rhic energy , with a centrality dependence very similar to that already measured at rhic . measurements of elliptic flow out to large transverse momentum also show similar results to what was measured at rhic , but no significant pseudorapidity dependence .
measurements of higher harmonics have also been made , which seem to explain structures in the two - particle correlation previously attributed to jet - medium interactions .
single muons at high momentum are used to extract the yield of @xmath1 bosons and are found to be consistent with binary collision scaling .
conversely , jets are found to be suppressed in central events by a factor of two relative to peripheral events , with no significant dependence on the jet energy .
fragmentation functions are also found to be the same in central and peripheral events .
finally , charged hadrons have been measured out to 30 gev , and are found to have a centrality dependence ( relative to peripheral events ) similar to that found for jets .
10 atlas collaboration , g. aad et al . ,
jinst * 3 * , s08003 ( 2008 ) . y. chen , these proceedings . atlas collaboration , `` measurement of the centrality dependence of the charged - particle pseudorapidity distribution in lead - lead collisions at @xmath58 tev with the atlas detector , '' to be submitted to phys .
b. alice collaboration , k. aamodt _ et al .
_ , phys .
* 106 * ( 2011 ) 032301 .
a. trzupek , these proceedings .
j. jia , these proceedings .
atlas collaboration , `` pseudorapidity and transverse momentum dependence of elliptic flow for charged particles in lead - lead collisions at @xmath59 tev with the atlas detector at the lhc , '' to be submitted to phys .
b. atlas - conf-2011 - 074 ( http://cdsweb.cern.ch/record/1352458 . ) a. adare _ et al .
_ phenix collaboration , phys .
( 2010 ) 142301 .
j. adams _ et al .
_ , star collaboration , phys . rev .
c 72 ( 2005 ) 014904 .
b. alver and g. roland , phys .
c * 81 * , 054905 ( 2010 ) [ erratum - ibid .
c * 82 * , 039903 ( 2010 ) ] .
j. casalderrey - solana , e. v. shuryak , d. teaney , j. phys .
* 27 * , 22 - 31 ( 2005 ) .
j. adams _ et al .
_ , phys .
* 95 * ( 2005 ) 152301 .
a. adare _ et al .
_ , phys .
c * 77 * ( 2008 ) 011901 . the atlas collaboration , g. aad _ et al .
_ , phys .
lett . *
b697 * ( 2011 ) 294 .
r. sandstrm , these proceedings .
atlas - conf-2011 - 078(http://cdsweb.cern.ch / record/1353227 . )
atlas collaboration , g. aad _ et al .
_ , phys .
* 105 * ( 2010 ) 252303 .
b. cole , these proceedings .
angerami , these proceedings .
atlas - conf-2011 - 075 ( http://cdsweb.cern.ch/record/1353220 . ) a. milov , these proceedings .
atlas - conf-2011 - 079 ( http://cdsweb.cern.ch/record/1355702 . ) k. aamodt _ et al .
_ , phys . lett .
b * 696 * ( 2011 ) 30 . | results are presented from the atlas collaboration from the 2010 lhc heavy ion run , during which nearly 10 inverse microbarns of luminosity were delivered .
soft physics results include charged particle multiplicities and collective flow .
the charged particle multiplicity , which tracks initial state entropy production , increases by a factor of two relative to the top rhic energy , with a centrality dependence very similar to that already measured at rhic .
measurements of elliptic flow out to large transverse momentum also show similar results to what was measured at rhic , but no significant pseudorapidity dependence .
extensions of these measurements to higher harmonics have also been made , and can be used to explain structures in the two - particle correlation functions that had long been attributed to jet - medium interactions .
new hard probe measurements include single muons , jets and high @xmath0 hadrons .
single muons at high momentum are used to extract the yield of @xmath1 bosons and are found to be consistent within statistical uncertainties with binary collision scaling .
conversely , jets are found to be suppressed in central events by a factor of two relative to peripheral events , with no significant dependence on the jet energy .
fragmentation functions are also found to be the same in central and peripheral events .
finally , charged hadrons have been measured out to 30 gev , and their centrality dependence relative to peripheral events is similar to that found for jets . |
with the start of data taking at the large hadron collider ( lhc ) , particle physics will , for the first time , directly probe the tera scale , i.e. the scale of electroweak symmetry breaking according to the standard model ( sm ) , around @xmath2 . while the sm has been confirmed experimentally to be a very precise effective description of the physics below the tera scale ,
there are many serious contenders for the more fundamental theory beneath the sm .
for quite some time , superstring theory has been a leading candidate for the fundamental theory unifying all known interactions .
there are certain solutions of superstring theory with additional spatial dimensions , where the characteristic string scales are low enough to allow experimental tests at the lhc and the planned international @xmath3 linear collider ( ilc ) .
one spectacular prediction @xcite of superstring theory is the emergence of a noncommutative ( nc ) structure of spacetime at a scale @xmath4 associated with nonvanishing commutators @xmath5 = { \mathrm{i}}\theta_{\mu\nu } = { \mathrm{i}}\frac{1}{\lambda_{\text{nc}}^2}c_{\mu\nu}\ ] ] of spacetime coordinates that correspond to oriented minimal resolvable areas of size @xmath6 . while a nonvanishing commutator like ( [ eq : nc - geometry ] ) had been proposed much earlier @xcite as a regulator of divergencies in quantum field theory ( qft ) and quantum gravity , the observation of @xcite caused intense renewed interest in qft on nc spacetimes ( ncqft ) .
the commutator ( [ eq : nc - geometry ] ) can be conveniently realized on a _ commuting _
spacetime by replacing all products of functions by moyal - weyl @xmath7-products @xmath8 a prescription for constructing arbitrary gauge theories on a nc spacetime was presented in @xcite .
these so - called seiberg - witten maps ( swm ) realize nc gauge transformations in the nc theory as ordinary commutative gauge transformations on an effective commutative gauge theory . by going to the enveloping algebra of the lie algebra of a given gauge group , this approach @xcite circumvents obstructions like charge quantization in @xmath9 gauge theories and the prohibition of @xmath10 gauge groups in the earlier attempts . in particular , this prescription allowed the construction of the so - called noncommutative standard model ( ncsm ) @xcite as an anomaly - free @xcite canonical nc extension of the sm without having to introduce additional particles gauge theory and subsequently break the extraneous symmetries , introducing additional particles that must be removed from the observable spectrum @xcite . ] . in the first order of an expansion in @xmath0
, one has only three new bounded parameters that depend on the choice of the representation of the enveloping algebra of the sm lie algebra and describe new couplings among gauge bosons @xcite .
these couplings vanish in the minimal ncsm , where the enveloping algebra is realized by matrices acting in the vector space of the adjoint representation .
furthermore , the bosonic sector of the minimal ncsm was shown to be renormalizable at one loop @xcite , where all counter terms can be expressed through the usual field strength and coupling constant renormalizations .
also the nonminimal ncsm is renormalizable at one - loop , if a _ finite _ gauge invariant @xmath1-term is added to the action @xcite .
finally , the fermionic sector can be shown to require a finite number of gauge invariant four - fermion operators as additional counter terms in one loop order @xcite . in euclidean nc space
, the renormalizability of scalar and gauge models has been shown to all orders in @xmath0 @xcite . using the effective theory in the first order of the @xmath0-expansion ,
several phenomenological studies were performed for past , present , and future colliders @xcite . in a preceding paper @xcite , we have studied the associated production of photons and @xmath11-bosons at hadron colliders ( tevatron and lhc ) showing that at the lhc one can reach a noncommutativity scale @xmath4 slightly above @xmath2 @xcite . moreover , we have found that it is necessary to go beyond the first order in @xmath0 , because of significant contributions from partonic center of mass energies exceeding the noncommutativity scale that can actually be probed . while it is possible in simple cases to derive expressions for families of swm to all orders in @xmath0 @xcite , an explicit parameterization of the most general solution has not been given .
therefore , we start in this paper by constructing the most general swm for the ncsm in the second order of the @xmath0-expansion . the importance of this systematic approach is stressed _ a posteriori _ by discovering ambiguities in the swm that have been missed in earlier @xmath12 constructions of swm @xcite . while these authors expected all ambiguities to cancel in observable quantities
, we find that they do _
not_. in fact , using @xmath13 as an example , we will calculate the ambiguity in the corresponding scattering amplitude explicitly .
the outline of this paper is as follows . in section [ sec : swm ]
we derive the general swm up to second order in the noncommutativity @xmath0 .
particular emphasis will be given to the ambiguities resulting from the homogeneous solutions of the gauge equivalence equations .
furthermore , the lagrangian and the feynman rules of the neutral current sector of the ncsm are constructed in section [ sec : feynman ] .
section [ sec : ambiguities ] presents our analysis of the impact of the swm ambiguities on physical observables .
we will demonstrate by an explicit calculation of @xmath14 that not all ambiguities cancel in the @xmath12 contribution to the cross section . in section [ sec : summary ]
we conclude with a brief summary .
all expressions that are needed for the main results of this paper will be given in full , either in the main text or in the appendices .
complete expressions in second order in @xmath0 that are too lengthy to be included in this paper can be found in the appendix of @xcite .
the purpose of the swm is to realize noncommutative gauge transformations by representations of the enveloping algebra using nonlinear functions of ordinary , commutative fields that reside in representations of the given lie algebra .
this requirement is expressed by a set of so - called gauge equivalence equations for noncommutative gauge fields @xmath15 , gauge parameters appear in the lagrangian in the guise of faddeev - popov ghosts , if the gauge fixing is performed before application of the swm . ] @xmath16 and matter fields @xmath17 as functions of the commutative gauge fields @xmath18 , gauge parameters @xmath19 and matter fields @xmath20 .
general swm are defined as solutions of the gauge equivalence equations ) could be relaxed by demanding that the two sides of equation ( [ eq : swm - condition ] ) lie in the same gauge orbit , but are not identical @xcite . since by construction the corresponding ambiguities must cancel in the gauge invariant yang - mills action to all orders in @xmath0 , we can ignore them in the rest of this paper . ] : [ eq : swm - condition ] @xmath21 where @xmath18 and @xmath20 transform as usual : [ eq : gauge - transformations ] @xmath22 here , we have used the notation @xmath23 and @xmath24 , @xmath25 being the generators of the gauge group . in practice ,
the gauge equivalence equations ( [ eq : swm - condition ] ) can be solved order by order in an expansion in @xmath0 .
the physical predictions of qft , in particular the on - shell @xmath26-matrix elements and scattering cross sections , do not depend on the choice of interpolating fields @xcite .
in fact , any two theories which are related by non - singular local field redefinitions [ eq : reparametrization ] @xmath27 and the corresponding change in the lagrangian @xmath28 will predict identical scattering cross sections .
this reparametrization invariance can be proven both in axiomatic qft @xcite and in perturbation theory for effective qft @xcite .
it provides the basis for the application of the powerful and now ubiquitous methods of effective qft to elementary particle physics phenomenology @xcite .
the fact that the reparametrization ( [ eq : reparametrization ] ) corresponds to a change of integration variables in the path integral , provides a particularly intuitive proof of the invariance . since the swm @xmath29 appear to be just a reparametrization like ( [ eq : reparametrization ] )
, one might expect that its application has no effect on the calculation of observables . for a noncommutative @xmath9 gauge theory with unit charge @xcite
it can be shown that this is indeed the case . however , in theories with multiple @xmath9 charges and @xmath10 gauge groups , the enveloping algebra is strictly larger than the lie algebra and the swm ( [ eq : swm ] ) must therefore be singular .
the ncsm is a prominent representative of such theories , whence we must expect nontrivial effects of the swm on observables , as can readily be seen from @xcite .
it was noted from early on , that the solutions of ( [ eq : swm - condition ] ) are not unique @xcite .
consequently , the construction of nc extensions of the sm via swm is a priori not unique as well .
only those ambiguities that correspond to non - singular reparametrization like ( [ eq : reparametrization ] ) are guaranteed to cancel in observables .
this leaves us with the crucial problem of genuine ambiguities in physical quantities .
to first order in @xmath0 it has been shown by explicit calculations that all ambiguities cancel in on - shell scattering amplitudes . in turn
, one can use these cancellations as a powerful consistency check for numerical calculations of cross sections @xcite .
however , there is no general theorem or physical argument that implies the cancellation of all ambiguities in the swm to all orders in the @xmath0-expansion .
below we will identify ambiguities in the second order swm that affect cross sections . in an examination of the effective action of @xmath1-ncqed @xcite showing that the swm in first order corresponds to a field redefinition
, it was already conjectured that this is not the case in second order .
our results provide a proof for this conjecture from a completely different angle .
furthermore , some of the ambiguities in second order are discussed in @xcite , but no claim is made of completeness .
in fact , we have found additional ambiguities .
a recursive solution of the gauge equivalence equations ( [ eq : swm - condition ] ) to all orders in @xmath0 , including ambiguities , has been given in @xcite .
unfortunately , the ambiguities are not given as an explicit function of an independent set of parameters and it is not straightforward to search for observable effects in the ncsm in this form .
thus we do not rely on @xcite for a discussion of the general solution of ( [ eq : swm - condition ] ) and derive the higher order terms anew .
still , the existence of ambiguities with observable effects does not render the ncsm proposed in @xcite unphysical and thus rather useless .
it merely adds more free parameters , not unlike those originating from the freedom of choosing the representation of the enveloping algebra , already discussed in @xcite .
the most serious aspect of such additional parameters is the question to which extent deviations from sm predictions could be hidden by particular choices of the ambiguous contributions , making the ncsm untestable by experiment .
the non - linear gauge equivalence equations ( [ eq : swm - condition ] ) are most easily solved by going over to the equivalent set of equations for infinitesimal gauge transformations . in the commutative case ,
the latter are given by [ eq : delta ] @xmath30 \\ \label{eq : delta - psi } \delta_\alpha \psi & = { \mathrm{i}}\alpha\psi\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] while the noncommutative infinitesimal gauge transformations read [ eq : hat - delta ] @xmath31 \\ \label{eq : hat - delta - psi } \hat\delta_\alpha \hat\psi(\psi , a,\theta ) & = { \mathrm{i}}\hat\lambda(\alpha , a,\theta)\ast\hat\psi(\psi , a,\theta)\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] from ( [ eq : delta ] ) and ( [ eq : hat - delta ] ) , one readily obtains the infinitesimal versions of the gauge equivalence equations ( [ eq : swm - condition - a ] ) and ( [ eq : swm - condition - psi ] ) : [ eq : swm - condition - infinitesimal ] @xmath32 where the commutative gauge transformation @xmath33 acts on the arguments of the noncommutative gauge and matter fields via the chain rule . however , the equations ( [ eq : swm - condition - infinitesimal ] ) are not sufficient .
the existence of a noncommutative gauge parameter @xmath16 in ( [ eq : swm - condition ] ) requires that the commutator of two infinitesimal gauge transformations closes to another gauge transformation just as in the commutative case : @xmath34 } \hat\psi\,,\ ] ] where @xmath35 $ ] denotes the bracket in the commutative lie algebra . applying ( [ eq : swm - condition - infinitesimal - psi ] ) twice and taking into account that the commutative gauge transformation of the noncommutative gauge parameter @xmath16 does not vanish because it depends on @xmath18 , one has @xmath36 where all unnecessary arguments have been omitted .
substituting the above in ( [ eq : closure ] ) and factoring out @xmath37 , the additional consistency condition reads @xmath38 = \hat\lambda(-{\mathrm{i}}[\alpha,\beta],a,\theta)\,.\ ] ] the infinitesimal consistency equations ( [ eq : swm - condition - infinitesimal ] ) and ( [ eq : swm - condition - infinitesimal - lambda ] ) still contain all orders of @xmath0 and closed expressions for their solutions are not yet known .
however , we can express the swm as formal power series in @xmath0 : @xmath39 expand the equations ( [ eq : swm - condition - infinitesimal ] ) and ( [ eq : swm - condition - infinitesimal - lambda ] ) and solve them order by order in @xmath0 , starting at @xmath40 with the commutative gauge theory : @xmath41 writing all terms involving the unknown function @xmath42 on the left - hand side , the expansion of ( [ eq : swm - condition - infinitesimal - lambda ] ) results in the inhomogeneous linear equation @xmath43 - { \mathrm{i}}\left[\alpha,\lambda^{(1)}(\beta , a,\theta)\right ] \\ - \lambda^{(1)}(-{\mathrm{i}}[\alpha,\beta],a,\theta ) = - \frac{\theta^{\mu\nu}}{2 } \left[\partial_\mu\alpha,\partial_\nu\beta\right]_+\,.\end{gathered}\ ] ] the general solution is given by @xmath44_+ + { \mathrm{i}}c_\lambda^{(1 ) } \theta^{\mu\nu } \left [ \partial_\mu \alpha , a_\nu \right]\ ] ] involving one free parameter @xmath45 . using this solution , we can proceed analogously with ( [ eq : swm - condition - infinitesimal ] ) and derive the linear equations for @xmath46 , @xmath47 \\ = \partial_\mu \lambda^{(1 ) } - { \mathrm{i}}\left[a_\mu,\lambda^{(1)}(\alpha , a,\theta)\right ] + \frac{\theta^{\rho\sigma}}{2 } \left[\partial_\rho a_\mu,\partial_\sigma\alpha\right]_+\,,\end{gathered}\ ] ] and @xmath48 , @xmath49 where the right - hand sides depend on the free parameter @xmath45 via @xmath50 .
for each value of @xmath45 , we then find the general solutions @xmath51_+ - \frac{1}{4}\theta^{\mu\nu}[a_\mu,\partial_\nu a_\rho]_+ \\ + { \mathrm{i}}c_\lambda^{(1 ) } \,\theta^{\mu\nu } [ d_\rho^{\text{adj } } a_\mu , a_\nu ] - 2{\mathrm{i}}c_a^{(1)}\,\theta^{\mu\nu } d_\rho^{\text{adj } } f_{\mu\nu}\end{gathered}\ ] ] and @xmath52 \psi + \frac{c_\psi^{(1)}}{2}\theta^{\mu\nu}f_{\mu\nu}\psi\,,\ ] ] parametrized by the free parameters @xmath53 and @xmath54 , respectively .
notice that all terms proportional to @xmath45 , @xmath53 , or @xmath54 are lie algebra valued .
therefore , they correspond to field reparametrizations and will cancel in observables .
in fact , only the anticommutators in the expression ( [ eq : swm - a-1 ] ) for @xmath55 require the enveloping algebra and carry the potential to affect observables . in second order in @xmath0
, we again start with the closure relation ( [ eq : swm - condition - infinitesimal - lambda ] ) for gauge transformations : @xmath56 - { \mathrm{i}}\left[\lambda^{(2)}(\alpha , a),\beta\right ] - \lambda^{(2)}(-i[\alpha,\beta],a ) \\
= - \frac{{\mathrm{i}}}{8}\theta^{\mu\nu}\theta^{\kappa\lambda } \left[\partial_\mu\partial_\kappa\alpha , \partial_\nu\partial_\lambda\beta\right ] + { \mathrm{i}}\left[\lambda^{(1)}(\alpha , a),\lambda^{(1)}(\beta , a)\right ] \\ - \frac{1}{2}\theta^{\mu\nu } \left(\left[\partial_\mu\lambda^{(1 ) } ( \alpha , a),\partial_\nu\beta\right]_+ - \left[\partial_\mu\lambda^{(1 ) } ( \beta , a),\partial_\nu\alpha\right]_+\right)\,,\end{gathered}\ ] ] where we have suppressed the dependence on @xmath0 in @xmath57 for brevity .
again , the right - hand side depends on the free parameter @xmath45 via @xmath58 . for @xmath45 fixed , we find that the general hermitian solution of ( [ eq : swm - condition - infinitesimal - lambda-2 ] ) involves 15 new free parameters , @xmath59 , , @xmath60 . for the present discussion it is sufficient to describe the general characteristics of the solutions and to give explicit expressions only for a specific choice of the free parameters . in appendix
[ app : swm - lambda ] we spell out the specific solution corresponding to @xmath61 in the case @xmath62 .
the lengthy complete expression can be found in the appendix of @xcite .
it can be shown that the solutions given in @xcite and @xcite are both contained in our 16-parameter family of solutions .
proceeding with the expansion of the gauge equivalence equations ( [ eq : swm - condition - infinitesimal ] ) in powers of @xmath0 , one obtains the second order equations for gauge and matter fields : [ eq : ge2 ] @xmath63 \\
= \partial_\rho\lambda^2(\alpha , a ) - { \mathrm{i}}[a_\rho , \lambda^{(2)}(\alpha , a ) ] - { \mathrm{i}}[a^{(1)}_\rho(a ) , \lambda^{(1)}(\alpha , a ) ] \\ + \frac{1}{2}\theta^{\mu\nu } \big(\big[\partial_\mu a^{(1)}_\rho(a),\partial_\nu\alpha\big]_+ + \big[\partial_\mu a_\rho,\partial_\nu\lambda^{(1)}(\alpha , a)\big]_+\big ) + \frac{{\mathrm{i}}}{8}\theta^{\mu\nu}\theta^{\kappa\lambda } \partial_\mu\partial_\kappa a_\rho \partial_\nu\partial_\lambda\alpha\end{gathered}\ ] ] and @xmath64 where the right - hand sides now depend on @xmath45 , @xmath53 , @xmath54 , @xmath59 , , and @xmath60 . substituting ( [ eq : swm - lambda-1 ] ) and ( [ eq : swm - a-1 ] ) for @xmath58 and @xmath65 , respectively , and the general solution @xmath66 from @xcite in ( [ eq : ge2-a ] ) , one gets the general hermitian solution for @xmath67 which depends on 6 additional parameters @xmath68 .
the latter define a convenient basis for the solutions of the homogeneous equation : [ eq : c2/a ] @xmath69_\pm \\
a^{(2)}_{\rho,2,\pm } & = c^{(2)}_{a,2,\pm } \frac{{\mathrm{i}}}{2 } \theta^{\mu\nu } \theta^{\kappa\lambda } \bigl [ f_{\mu\kappa } , d^{\text{adj}}_\rho f_{\nu\lambda } \bigr]_\pm\\ a^{(2)}_{\rho,3,\pm } & = c^{(2)}_{a,3,\pm } \frac{{\mathrm{i}}}{2 } \theta^{\mu\nu } \theta^{\kappa\lambda } \bigl [ f_{\kappa\lambda } , d^{\text{adj}}_\rho f_{\mu\nu } \bigr]_\pm\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the three commutator terms @xmath70 are contained in the lie algebra and correspond to field redefinitions that must cancel in observables .
in contrast , the three anticommutator terms @xmath71 need not be part of the lie algebra and can , in principle , give non - vanishing contributions to scattering amplitudes as we will demonstrate in section [ sec : example ] . an explicit expression for a specific solution of @xmath72
is given in appendix [ app : swm - a ] .
the solution presented in @xcite can be shown to be contained in our set of general solutions @xcite .
in contrast , the solution presented in @xcite is not .
in fact , one can verify that the solution as written in @xcite does not satisfy the gauge equivalence equation ( [ eq : ge2-a ] ) and must therefore be considered incorrect . in addition , the solutions @xmath73 of the homogeneous equation are missing . as we will see later ,
@xmath74 plays a particularly important rle .
while the size of the expressions makes it hard to pinpoint the actual error in @xcite , we want to mention that our results have been obtained and verified by long but straightforward algebraic manipulations using ` form ` @xcite .
plugging ( [ eq : swm - lambda-1 ] ) for @xmath58 , ( [ eq : swm - psi-1 ] ) for @xmath75 , and the general solution for @xmath66 given in @xcite into ( [ eq : ge2-psi ] ) , we obtain a three - parameter family of matter field swm .
a suitable basis for the solutions to the homogeneous equations is given by @xmath76 this result confirms the corresponding result in @xcite . in appendix
[ app : swm - psi ] we present a specific solution for @xmath77 . for the general solution we again refer to @xcite .
following the prescription of @xcite for constructing a ncqft , we replace all field products in the yang - mills lagrangian @xmath78 by @xmath7-products , and obtain an action for fields in the enveloping algebra that is invariant under nc gauge transformations and follows from the lagrangian @xmath79 with @xmath80 $ ] and @xmath81 $ ] , respectively . in a second step , we apply the swm ( [ eq : swm ] ) to obtain an action for fields residing in the lie algebra that is invariant under commutative gauge transformations and results from @xmath82 from ( [ eq : ncym ] ) , one can derive the feynman rules for the nc extension of the original commutative gauge theory .
since the terms in ( [ eq : ym ] ) and ( [ eq : ncym ] ) that are quadratic in the fields are identical , we can perform gauge - fixing and introduce faddeev - popov ghosts directly to ( [ eq : ncym ] ) in terms of the commuting gauge fields .
hence , the ghost interactions are not modified by nc contributions . for the purposes of the present paper , we are mainly interested in the cubic and quartic couplings in the neutral current sector of the ncsm that contribute to boson pair production in fermion - antifermion annihilation , @xmath83 , at tree level up to second order in @xmath0 . with _ all _ momenta incoming , including outgoing fermions
, we define the vertex factors as follows : [ eq : vertices ] @xmath84 } \cdot v_{\mu_1\mu_2\mu_3}(k_1,k_2,k_3)\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath85}$ ] denotes the three - gauge boson coupling that depends on the choice for the representation @xmath86 of the enveloping algebra . in a @xmath9 gauge theory
we can choose an arbitrary hermitian matrix @xmath87 as a generator , normalized to @xmath88 .
consequently the squares of the eigenvalues of @xmath87 are bounded , @xmath89 , and we find @xmath90 } \le g$ ] , with @xmath85}=0 $ ] for @xmath91 and @xmath85}=g$ ] for @xmath92 . only in the latter case ,
the anticommutator remains in the lie algebra representation .
since the chiral structure of the fermionic currents remains unaffected by the swm , we have written the following vertex factors for pure vector currents .
the necessary substitutions @xmath93 depending on the fermion flavor and the type of vector boson coupled can be copied directly from the sm lagrangian . using the notations @xmath94 and @xmath95 ,
the vertex factors ( [ eq : vertices ] ) up to second order in @xmath0 are given by @xmath96\ ] ] @xmath97\end{gathered}\ ] ] @xmath98\end{gathered}\ ] ] @xmath99 \\
+ \text{terms vanishing by equations of motion}\end{gathered}\ ] ] @xmath100 + \left ( k_1 \theta k_2 \right ) \left [ k_{3,\mu_1 } g_{\mu_2\mu_3 } - g_{\mu_1\mu_3 } k_{3,\mu_2 } \right ] \\ + \bigl [ ( k_1\theta)_{\mu_1 } \left [ k_{2,\mu_3 } k_{3,\mu_2 } - ( k_2 k_3 ) g_{\mu_2\mu_3 } \right ] - ( \mu_1 \leftrightarrow \mu_2 ) - ( \mu_1 \leftrightarrow \mu_3 ) \bigr ] \\ + \text{cyclical permutations of}\ ; \bigl\ { ( \mu_1,k_1 ) , ( \mu_2,k_2 ) , ( \mu_3,k_3 ) \ , \bigr\}\end{gathered}\ ] ] @xmath101 \\ + \text{cyclical permutations of}\ ; \bigl\ { ( \mu_1,k_1 ) , ( \mu_2,k_2 ) , ( \mu_3,k_3 ) \ , \bigr\}\,.\end{gathered}\ ] ] note that the triple gauge boson vertex ( [ eq : ggg2 ] ) at @xmath12 is generated by the swm alone .
there are no contributions from the moyal - weyl @xmath7-product . in this paper
, we will apply the ncsm feynman rules to the process @xmath102 at tree level . in the above ,
we have therefore given only the on - shell expression for the @xmath103 contact term ( [ eq : fbarvvf - on - shell ] ) , dropping terms which vanish by equation of motion .
the complete expressions can be found in @xcite .
as noted in section [ sec : swm1 ] , all swm ambiguities to first order in @xmath0 , i.e. all terms in the swm proportional to @xmath45 , @xmath53 , and @xmath54 correspond to lie algebra valued field redefinitions and must cancel in observables such as on - shell scattering amplitudes to this order .
this is explicitly checked for @xmath83 in ( [ eq : amplitude(1 ) ] ) .
note , however , that the above @xmath1 parameters reappear in the swm in higher order .
we have already pointed out , that beyond @xmath1 there are no such general arguments for or against the cancellation of the swm ambiguities that do not correspond to non - singular field redefinitions in observables .
therefore , we can approach this question presently only by studying specific examples .
for that we choose the ncqed process @xmath13 as a prototype process in the neutral current sector of the ncsm .
the additional @xmath11-boson couplings , their chiral structure and the @xmath11-mass in the ncsm will not add to our conclusions about the swm ambiguities .
the feynman diagrams contributing to @xmath13 in ncqed are depicted in figs .
[ fig : diagrams0]-[fig : diagrams2 ] .
the feynman rules to @xmath1 and @xmath12 are given in section [ sec : feynman ] .
+ feynman diagrams contributing to @xmath13 in qed.,title="fig : " ] + feynman diagrams contributing to @xmath13 in @xmath1 in ncqed .
the open squares denote @xmath1-vertices.,title="fig : " ] + feynman diagrams contributing to @xmath13 in @xmath12 in ncqed .
the filled squares denote @xmath12-vertices.,title="fig : " ] actually , it is possible to demonstrate the dependence of the scattering amplitude on the free @xmath12 parameter @xmath104 and the interplay of reparametrization invariance and the enveloping algebra even without performing a complete calculation .
the term in ( [ eq : c2/a/1 ] ) relevant for the tree level diagrams of fig .
[ fig : diagrams2 ] contains two gauge fields . suppressing terms with more than two gauge fields
, one has @xmath105 this term contributes both to the contact and the three - gauge boson vertex .
explicitly , from the feynman rule ( [ eq : fbarvvf - on - shell ] ) for the contact term one finds the following contribution to the scattering amplitude : @xmath106 + \ldots\,.\end{gathered}\ ] ] since @xmath104 is absent from the on - shell @xmath107-vertex , this contribution can not be cancelled by any term coming from the @xmath108- or @xmath109-channel diagrams .
therefore , a cancellation must involve @xmath110-channel diagrams , which however are proportional to the representation dependent coupling @xmath85}$ ] as can be seen from ( [ eq : vvv ] ) .
consequently , the cancellation can at most take place for a particular value of @xmath85}$ ] , namely for @xmath85}=g$ ] , when the noncommutative gauge fields do not leave the lie algebra and the swm are just field reparametrizations . as a side remark , the non - vanishing , a priori undetermined contribution ( [ eq : contact2r ] ) to the tree level amplitude of @xmath111 results from one of the swm ambiguities missed in @xcite .
we will now corroborate these preliminary remarks by a complete tree level calculation of @xmath13 up to second order in @xmath0 .
it is useful to split the full scattering amplitude in the following pieces : @xmath112 } a_s^{(1 ) } + g^2 a^{(2 ) } + gg_{[\rho ] } a_s^{(2)}\,,\ ] ] which are self - explaining .
it should be noted that the @xmath110-channel contributions @xmath113 must be separately gauge invariant , because their normalization depends on the choice of the representation of the enveloping algebra . for completeness
, we restate the familiar qed amplitude from the diagrams in fig .
[ fig : diagrams0 ] : @xmath114 with @xmath115 and @xmath116 , as well as the @xmath1-amplitude in ncqed @xcite : @xmath117 with @xmath118 u(p_1)\,,\ ] ] which collects all contributions from the @xmath108- and @xmath109-channel diagrams as well as the contact diagram in fig .
[ fig : diagrams1 ] containing no pole .
as expected , all contributions from ambiguous terms in the swm cancel in @xmath119 after application of the equations of motion . note that the @xmath120- and @xmath121-pole terms in ( [ eq : amplitude(1 ) ] ) result solely from the expansion of the moyal phases to order @xmath0 .
this can be easily seen by combining the phase factors which multiply the vertices in a given diagram . for momenta
@xmath122 , @xmath123 and @xmath124 flowing into a vertex momentum conservation implies the identities @xmath125 in the @xmath108-channel one thus obtains the total phase factor @xmath126 from which the corresponding phase factor in the @xmath109-channel follows by exchanging @xmath127 : @xmath128 turning to the @xmath110-channel amplitude @xmath129 , one finds that the @xmath130-pole contributions cancel in all contributions from the swm yielding @xmath131 with the @xmath130-pole coming from the moyal - weyl @xmath7-product alone : @xmath132 u(p_1 ) \,,\ ] ] and @xmath133 given in ( [ eq : a - nopole ] ) .
this ensures that all effects from the swm cancel for @xmath85}=g$ ] as they should , since in this case the swm are non - singular field reparametrizations .
to second order in @xmath0 , we obtain from the diagrams in fig .
[ fig : diagrams2 ] @xmath134 with @xmath135 u(p_1)\,.\end{gathered}\ ] ] note that the @xmath120- and @xmath121-pole terms in ( [ eq : amplitude(2 ) ] ) follow again from the expansion of the combined moyal phases and contain no contribution from the swm .
however , in contrast to @xmath133 , the second order amplitude @xmath136 does depend on ambiguous terms in the swm . in the case at hand ,
this is signalled by the appearance of the free parameters @xmath53 and @xmath104 .
the exact cancellation for the choice @xmath137 appears to be accidental . as in first order in @xmath0 , we find that all @xmath130-poles cancel in the @xmath110-channel terms coming from the swm .
since the moyal - weyl @xmath7-product only contributes to the three - photon couplings in odd orders of @xmath0 there is no @xmath130-pole term at all in @xmath12 .
the result is exactly the negative of [ eq : a2-nopole ] : @xmath138 leading again to the cancellation of all contributions from the swm in the case @xmath85}=g$ ] , including the ambiguous terms involving the free parameter @xmath139 .
however , in general , the cross section for @xmath13 is affected by this swm ambiguity .
we have investigated the noncommutative extension of the standard model up to second order in @xmath0 . as our main result
, we find that the general solution for the corresponding seiberg - witten maps contains more ambiguous terms than those reported previously , and that the swm ambiguities do not necessarily cancel in observables .
furthermore , studying the scattering amplitude for @xmath13 as an explicit example we have shown that the ambiguities remaining in the scattering amplitude can be traced to the necessary extension of the lie algebra of the gauge group to its enveloping algebra , which elevates the swm from a unobservable field reparametrization to a source of new effective interactions .
our results imply that the parameter space of the ncsm @xcite in @xmath12 is larger than assumed so far .
there is every reason to expect that higher orders in @xmath0 will introduce even more ambiguities and evidence for this has been found in ncqed @xcite . as an outlook
, phenomenological consequences of the ncsm at @xmath12 with the focus on collider searches will be presented in an upcoming paper @xcite .
this research is supported by deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft , grant ru 311/1 - 1 and research training group 1147 _ theoretical astrophysics and particle physics _ , and by bundesministerium fr bildung und forschung germany , grant 05h4wwa/2 .
a.a . gratefully acknowledges support from evangelisches studienwerk e.v .
thanks the members of slac theory group for their kind hospitality .
for each value of @xmath45 , we find a family of hermitian solutions to ( [ eq : swm - condition - infinitesimal - lambda-2 ] ) depending on the free parameters @xmath59 , , @xmath60 .
the specific solution corresponding to @xmath61 for the case @xmath62 is given by @xmath140 for the general expression we refer to the appendix of @xcite . a representative of the six - parameter family of second order swm @xmath141 corresponding to the parameter choice @xmath142 is given by @xmath143 + [ \partial_\mu a_\kappa , \partial_\rho \partial_\lambda a_\nu ] \big)\\ \nonumber + \frac{1}{16}\theta^{\mu\nu}\theta^{\kappa\lambda } & \big ( + 2a_\mu a_\kappa \partial_\nu \partial_\lambda a_\rho - a_\mu a_\kappa \partial_\nu \partial_\rho a_\lambda + a_\mu a_\kappa \partial_\rho \partial_\lambda a_\nu\\ \nonumber & + 4a_\mu \partial_\nu a_\kappa \partial_\lambda a_\rho - 4a_\mu \partial_\nu a_\kappa \partial_\rho a_\lambda - 2a_\mu \partial_\kappa a_\nu \partial_\lambda a_\rho\\ \nonumber & - 2a_\nu \partial_\lambda a_\rho \partial_\mu a_\kappa + 3a_\nu \partial_\rho a_\lambda \partial_\mu a_\kappa + 4a_\kappa \partial_\nu \partial_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu\\ \nonumber & + 2a_\lambda \partial_\nu a_\rho \partial_\mu a_\kappa - a_\lambda \partial_\rho a_\nu \partial_\mu a_\kappa - a_\rho \partial_\mu a_\kappa \partial_\lambda a_\nu\\ \nonumber & - 4\partial_\mu a_\kappa a_\nu \partial_\lambda a_\rho + \partial_\mu a_\kappa a_\nu \partial_\rho a_\lambda + \partial_\mu a_\kappa a_\lambda \partial_\rho a_\nu\\ \nonumber & - \partial_\mu a_\kappa \partial_\lambda a_\nu a_\rho + 2\partial_\nu a_\kappa \partial_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu - 3\partial_\nu a_\kappa \partial_\rho a_\lambda a_\mu\\ \nonumber & + 2\partial_\nu a_\rho \partial_\mu a_\kappa a_\lambda - 2\partial_\kappa a_\nu \partial_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu + \partial_\kappa a_\nu \partial_\rho a_\lambda a_\mu\\ \nonumber & + 2\partial_\lambda a_\nu a_\rho \partial_\mu a_\kappa + 2\partial_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu \partial_\nu a_\kappa - 4\partial_\lambda a_\rho \partial_\mu a_\kappa a_\nu\\ \nonumber & - \partial_\rho a_\lambda a_\mu \partial_\nu a_\kappa - \partial_\rho a_\lambda a_\mu \partial_\kappa a_\nu + 4\partial_\rho a_\lambda \partial_\mu a_\kappa a_\nu\\ \nonumber & + 2\partial_\nu \partial_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu a_\kappa + \partial_\nu \partial_\rho a_\lambda a_\mu a_\kappa - \partial_\rho \partial_\lambda a_\nu a_\mu a_\kappa \big)\\ \nonumber + \frac{{\mathrm{i}}}{32 } \theta^{\mu\nu}\theta^{\kappa\lambda } & \big ( - 4a_\mu a_\nu a_\kappa \partial_\lambda a_\rho + 3a_\mu a_\nu a_\kappa \partial_\rho a_\lambda - 2\partial_\rho a_\lambda a_\mu a_\kappa a_\nu \\ \nonumber & + 4a_\mu a_\kappa a_\nu \partial_\lambda a_\rho - 2a_\mu a_\kappa a_\nu \partial_\rho a_\lambda - 4a_\mu
a_\kappa a_\lambda \partial_\nu a_\rho \\ \nonumber & - 2a_\mu a_\kappa \partial_\nu a_\lambda a_\rho + 2a_\mu a_\kappa \partial_\lambda a_\nu a_\rho - 8a_\mu \partial_\nu a_\kappa a_\lambda
a_\rho \\ \nonumber & - 4a_\nu a_\kappa \partial_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu + 4a_\nu a_\kappa \partial_\rho a_\lambda a_\mu + 8a_\nu a_\lambda a_\rho \partial_\mu a_\kappa \\ \nonumber & - 4a_\nu \partial_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu a_\kappa - 2a_\nu \partial_\rho a_\lambda a_\mu a_\kappa - 4a_\kappa a_\nu \partial_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu \\ \nonumber & - 2a_\kappa a_\nu \partial_\rho a_\lambda a_\mu - 4a_\kappa a_\lambda \partial_\nu a_\rho a_\mu + a_\kappa a_\lambda \partial_\rho a_\nu a_\mu \\ \nonumber & - 8a_\kappa \partial_\lambda a_\nu a_\rho a_\mu - 4a_\kappa \partial_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu a_\nu + a_\kappa \partial_\rho a_\lambda a_\mu a_\nu \\ \nonumber & - 4a_\lambda a_\nu a_\rho \partial_\mu a_\kappa - 4a_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu \partial_\nu a_\kappa + 4a_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu \partial_\kappa a_\nu \\ \nonumber & + 8a_\lambda a_\rho \partial_\mu a_\kappa a_\nu - 4a_\lambda \partial_\nu a_\rho a_\mu a_\kappa + 4a_\lambda \partial_\rho a_\nu a_\mu a_\kappa \\ \nonumber & - 2a_\rho a_\mu a_\kappa \partial_\nu a_\lambda - 2a_\rho a_\mu a_\kappa \partial_\lambda a_\nu + 8a_\rho a_\mu \partial_\kappa a_\nu a_\lambda \\ \nonumber & - 2a_\rho \partial_\mu a_\kappa a_\nu a_\lambda + 2a_\rho \partial_\mu a_\kappa a_\lambda a_\nu + 2\partial_\mu a_\kappa a_\nu a_\lambda a_\rho \\ \nonumber & + 2\partial_\mu a_\kappa a_\lambda a_\nu a_\rho - 4\partial_\nu a_\kappa a_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu
+ 4\partial_\nu a_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu a_\kappa \\ \nonumber & - 4\partial_\nu a_\rho a_\mu a_\kappa a_\lambda + 4\partial_\kappa a_\nu a_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu - 8\partial_\lambda a_\nu a_\rho a_\mu a_\kappa \\ \nonumber & - 4\partial_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu a_\nu a_\kappa + 4\partial_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu a_\kappa a_\nu + 3\partial_\rho a_\nu a_\mu a_\kappa a_\lambda \big)\\ \nonumber + \frac{1}{32}\theta^{\mu\nu}\theta^{\kappa\lambda } & \big ( - 3a_\mu a_\nu a_\kappa a_\lambda a_\rho + 2a_\mu a_\kappa a_\nu a_\lambda a_\rho - 4a_\nu a_\kappa a_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu\\ \nonumber & + 4a_\nu a_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu a_\kappa - 4a_\nu a_\rho a_\mu a_\kappa a_\lambda + 4a_\kappa a_\nu a_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu\\ \nonumber & - 4a_\kappa a_\lambda a_\nu a_\rho a_\mu - 2a_\kappa a_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu a_\nu - 8a_\lambda a_\nu a_\rho a_\mu a_\kappa\\ \nonumber & - 4a_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu a_\nu a_\kappa + 4a_\lambda a_\rho a_\mu
a_\kappa a_\nu\\ \nonumber & - 3a_\rho a_\mu a_\nu a_\kappa a_\lambda + 2a_\rho a_\mu a_\kappa a_\nu a_\lambda\big)\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , we have arranged the terms according to the power of @xmath18 , for the benefit of deriving feynman rules .
the general solution can be found in @xcite . as pointed out in section [ sec : swm2-a ] , this solution is related to the one presented in @xcite , but incompatible with the one in @xcite . choosing @xmath144 , we obtain the following representative of the three - parameter family of matter field swm : @xmath145 again , the terms are ordered according to the power in the gauge field . for
the general solution one may consult @xcite .
b. jurco , l. mller , s. schraml , p. schupp and j. wess , eur .
j. c * 21 * , 383 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0104153 ] .
x. calmet , b. juro , p. schupp , j. wess and m. wohlgenannt , eur .
j. * c23 * , 363 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0111115 ] ; b. melic , k. passek - kumericki , j. trampetic , p. schupp and m. wohlgenannt , eur .
j. c * 42 * , 483 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0502249 ] ; b. melic , k. passek - kumericki , j. trampetic , p. schupp and m. wohlgenannt , eur .
j. c * 42 * , 499 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0503064 ] .
c. p. martin , nucl . phys .
* b652 * , 72 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0211164 ] ; f. brandt , c. p. martin and f. r. ruiz , jhep * 0307 * , 068 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0307292 ] .
m. chaichian , p. presnajder , m. m. sheikh - jabbari and a. tureanu , eur
j. c * 29 * , 413 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0107055 ]
. m. buric , d. latas and v. radovanovic , jhep * 0602 * , 046 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0510133 ] ; m. buric , v. radovanovic and j. trampetic , jhep * 0703 * , 030 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0609073 ] ; d. latas , v. radovanovic and j. trampetic , [ arxiv : hep - th/0703018 ] .
r. wulkenhaar , jhep * 0203 * , 024 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0112248 ] .
h. grosse and r. wulkenhaar , lett .
* 71 * , 13 ( 2005 ) ; j. nonlin .
phys . * 11 * suppl . ,
9 ( 2004 ) ; commun .
phys . * 256 * , 305 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0401128 ] ; v. rivasseau , f. vignes - tourneret and r. wulkenhaar , commun .
phys . * 262 * , 565 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0501036 ] ; h. grosse and m. wohlgenannt , [ arxiv:0706.2167 ] . w. behr , n. g. deshpande , g. duplancic , p. schupp , j. trampetic and j. wess , eur . phys .
j. c * 29 * , 441 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0202121 ] ; g. duplancic , p. schupp and j. trampetic , eur .
j. c * 32 * , 141 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0309138 ] ; p. schupp , j. trampetic , j. wess and g. raffelt , eur .
j. c * 36 * , 405 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0212292 ] ; p. minkowski , p. schupp and j. trampetic , eur .
j. c * 37 * , 123 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0302175 ] ; b. melic , k. passek - kumericki and j. trampetic , phys
* d72 * , 054004 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0503133 ] ; b. melic , k. passek - kumericki and j. trampetic , phys .
rev . * d72 * , 057502 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0507231 ] ; m. buric , d. latas , v. radovanovic and j. trampetic , phys . rev . *
d75 * , 097701 ( 2007 ) .
t. ohl and j. reuter , phys . rev . * d70 * , 076007 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0406098 ] ; t. ohl and j. reuter , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0407337 ] . a. alboteanu , t. ohl and r. rckl , phys . rev . *
d74 * , 096004 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0608155 ] ; pos * hep2005 * ( 2006 ) , 322 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0511188 ]
. g. barnich , f. brandt and m. grigoriev , nucl . phys . *
b677 * , 503 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0308092 ] .
j. rauh , diploma thesis , university of wrzburg , 2006 ; j. zeiner , phd thesis , university of wrzburg , 2007 .
t. asakawa and i. kishimoto , jhep * 9911 * , 024 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9909139 ] .
r. haag , phys . rev . * 112 * , 669 ( 1958 ) ; h. j. borchers , nuovo cim . * 25 * , 270 ( 1960 ) ; d. ruelle , helv .
acta * 35 * , 34 ( 1962 ) .
s. r. coleman , j. wess and b. zumino , phys . rev . * 177 * , 2239 ( 1969 ) ; c. g. callan , s. r. coleman , j. wess and b. zumino , phys . rev .
* 177 * , 2247 ( 1969 ) . s. weinberg , physica a * 96 * , 327 ( 1979 ) .
j. m. grimstrup and r. wulkenhaar , eur .
j. c * 26 * , 139 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0205153 ] .
j. a. m. vermaseren , _ symbolic manipulation with ` form ` version 2 : tutorial and reference manual _ , can ( amsterdam , 1992 ) . | we derive the most general seiberg - witten maps for noncommutative gauge theories in second order of the noncommutative parameter @xmath0 .
our results reveal the existence of more ambiguities than previously known .
in particular , we demonstrate that some of these ambiguities enter observables like scattering cross sections and enlarge the parameter space of the noncommutative standard model beyond @xmath1 . |
a quantum state can not be squeezed down to a point in phase space .
but there are quantum states that closely approximate classical states , such as the coherent states of a harmonic oscillator
. one characterization of the coherent states is based on the wigner function : they are the only states for which the wigner function is both strictly positive and rotationally symmetric around its center ( here we assume a specific scaling of the axes appropriate for the given oscillator )
. one can also express the quantum mechanics of _ discrete _ systems in terms of phase space . in this paper
we consider a system of @xmath0 qubits described in the framework of ref .
@xcite , in which the discrete phase space can be pictured as a @xmath2 array of points . in this framework , the discrete wigner function preserves the tomographic feature of the usual wigner function , but the points of the discrete phase space are defined abstractly and do not come with an immediate physical interpretation . as in the continuous case
, a point in discrete phase space is _ illegal _ as a quantum state : it holds too much information .
but one can ask whether there are quantum states that , like coherent states , approximate a phase - space point as closely as possible .
we would like to identify such states and thereby to give more physical meaning to the discrete phase space . in this paper
we focus primarily on the second of the two properties mentioned above : invariance under rotations .
we will see that one can make sense of this notion in the discrete space and that rotationally invariant states exist for any number of qubits .
the most interesting property of these states is that they minimize uncertainty in a well defined sense .
the product @xmath3 , where @xmath4 and @xmath5 are position and momentum , has no meaning in our setting because our variables have no natural ordering .
we therefore express uncertainty in information - theoretic terms , specifically in terms of the rnyi entropy of order 2 ( which we call simply rnyi entropy " for short ) .
moreover we consider not just the `` axis variables , '' but also variables associated with all the other directions in the discrete phase space .
( in the continuous case these other directions would be associated with linear combinations of @xmath4 and @xmath5 . )
we will find that _ each _ rotationally invariant state minimizes the rnyi entropy , averaged over all these variables .
this will leave us with the question of picking out a most pointlike " of the rotationally invariant states , if such a notion can be made meaningful ; we address this question briefly in the conclusion .
over the years there have been many proposals for generalizing the wigner function to discrete systems .
( see , for example , refs .
@xcite and papers cited in ref .
here we adopt the discrete wigner function proposed by gibbons _
@xcite , which is well suited to a system of qubits .
the basic idea is to use , instead of the field of real numbers in which position and momentum normally take their values , a _ finite _ field with a number of elements equal to the dimension @xmath6 of the state space .
there exists a field with @xmath6 elements if and only if @xmath6 is a power of a prime ; so this approach applies directly only to quantum systems , such as a collection of qubits , whose state - space dimension is such a number .
the two - element field @xmath7 is simply the set @xmath8 with addition and multiplication mod 2 , but the field of order @xmath9 with @xmath0 larger than 1 is different from arithmetic mod @xmath9 .
for example , @xmath10 consists of the elements @xmath11 , in which @xmath12 and @xmath13 act as in @xmath7 and arithmetic involving the abstract symbol @xmath14 is determined by the equation @xmath15 .
the discrete phase space for a system of @xmath0 qubits is a two - dimensional vector space over @xmath1 ; that is , a point in the phase space can be expressed as @xmath16 , where @xmath4 and @xmath5 , the discrete analogues of position and momentum , take values in @xmath1 . in this phase space it makes perfect sense to speak of lines and parallel lines ; a line , for example , is the solution to a linear equation . the key idea in constructing a wigner function is to assign a pure quantum state , represented by a one - dimensional projection operator @xmath17 , to each line @xmath18 in phase space .
the only requirement imposed on the function @xmath17 is that it be translationally covariant . "
this means that if we translate the line @xmath18 in phase space by adding a fixed vector @xmath16 to each point , the associated quantum state changes by a unitary operator @xmath19 associated with @xmath16 .
the unitary translation operator @xmath19 is defined to be @xmath20 where @xmath21 and @xmath22 are pauli operators and @xmath23 and @xmath24 , which are elements of @xmath7 , are components of @xmath4 and @xmath5 when they are expanded in particular `` bases '' for the field : e.g. , @xmath25 , where @xmath26 is the basis chosen for the coordinate @xmath4 . and @xmath5 can not be chosen independently : each must be proportional to the _ dual _ of the other@xcite .
] one finds that the requirement of translational covariance severely constrains the construction : 1 .
states assigned to parallel lines must be orthogonal . a complete set of parallel lines , or `` striation ,
'' consists of exactly @xmath6 lines ; so the states associated with a given striation constitute a complete orthogonal basis for the state space .
in other words , each striation is associated with a complete orthogonal measurement on the system .
2 . the bases associated with different striations must be _ mutually unbiased_. that is , each element of one basis is an equal - magnitude superposition of the elements of any of the other bases .
there are exactly @xmath27 striations , so this construction generates a set of @xmath27 mutually unbiased bases .
( such a set is just sufficient for the complete tomographic reconstruction of an unknown quantum state . ) despite these constraints , there are many allowed functions @xmath17 .
this implies that there are many possible definitions of the wigner function for a system of qubits , because once we have chosen a particular assignment of quantum states to phase - space lines , the wigner function of any quantum state is uniquely fixed by the requirement that the sums over the lines of any striation be equal to the probabilities of the outcomes of the corresponding measurement .
in the finite field , consider a quadratic polynomial @xmath28 that has no roots .
then the equation @xmath29 with @xmath30 taking all nonzero values in @xmath1 , defines what we will call a set of `` circles '' centered at the origin .
fixing the values of @xmath31 and @xmath32this is somewhat analogous to fixing the scales of the axes in the continuous case we define a _
rotation _ to be any linear transformation of the phase space that leaves each circle invariant .
( we consider only rotations around the origin . a state centered at the origin
can always be translated to another point by @xmath19 . ) for example , in the two - qubit phase space , our circles can be defined by the equation @xmath33 and an example of a rotation is the transformation @xmath34 defined by @xmath35 one can check that this particular rotation has the property that if we apply it repeatedly , starting with any nonzero vector , it generates the entire circle on which that vector lies . in this sense @xmath34 is a _ primitive _ rotation . with every unit - determinant linear transformation @xmath36 on the phase space ,
one can associate ( though not uniquely ) a unitary transformation @xmath37 on the state space whose action by conjugation on the translation operators @xmath19 mimics the action of @xmath36 on the corresponding points of phase space@xcite .
is proved in ref .
one can show that every rotation has unit determinant and must therefore have an associated unitary transformation .
for example , for the rotation @xmath34 given above , if we expand both @xmath4 and @xmath5 in the field basis @xmath38 , the following unitary transformation acts in the desired way on the translation operators : @xmath39 thus just as @xmath40 we have that @xmath41 for any number @xmath0 of qubits , let @xmath34 be a primitive rotation , and let @xmath37 be a unitary transformation associated with @xmath34 in the above sense .
( techniques for finding @xmath37 can be found in refs .
then from the action of @xmath37 on the translation operators , it follows that @xmath37 acts in a particularly simple way on the mutually unbiased bases associated with the striations of phase space : starting with any one of these bases , repeated applications of @xmath37 generate all the other bases cyclically . that there always exists a unitary @xmath37 generating a complete set of mutually unbiased bases for @xmath0 qubits
has been shown by chau @xcite . in our present context
, we will reach the same conclusion by showing , in the following paragraph , that there always exists a primitive rotation .
the existence of such a unitary matrix @xmath37 leads naturally to a simple prescription for choosing the function @xmath17 : ( i ) use the translation operators to assign computational basis states to the vertical lines .
( ii ) apply @xmath37 repeatedly to these states , and @xmath34 repeatedly to the lines , in order to complete the correspondence .
this prescription results in a definition of the wigner function that is `` rotationally covariant , '' in the sense that when one transforms the density matrix by @xmath37 , the values of the wigner function are permuted among the phase - space points according to @xmath34 .
how does one find a primitive rotation @xmath34 ?
first , for any number of qubits , there always exists a _
primitive _ polynomial of the form @xmath42 @xcite , which one can use to define circles by the equation @xmath43 .
then the linear transformation @xmath44 is guaranteed to cycle through all the nonzero points of phase space @xcite , and it always takes circles to other circles .
raising @xmath36 to the power @xmath45 gives us a unit - determinant transformation that preserves circles and is indeed a primitive rotation .
moreover , one can write @xmath34 explicitly in terms of @xmath32 : @xmath46 with @xmath17 chosen in the way we have prescribed , the eigenstates of @xmath37 are our rotationally invariant states . when we apply @xmath37 to _ any _ state , the wigner function simply flows along the circles in accordance with the rotation @xmath34 .
but an eigenstate of @xmath37 does not change under this action , so its wigner function must be constant on each circle .
consider again our complete set of @xmath27 mutually unbiased bases , and let @xmath47 be the @xmath48th vector in the @xmath49th basis .
these vectors together have the following remarkable property : for any pure state @xmath50 , the probabilities @xmath51 satisfy @xcite @xmath52 now consider the rnyi entropy @xmath53 of the outcome - probabilities of the @xmath49th measurement when applied to the state @xmath50 .
this entropy is a measure of our inability to predict the outcome of the measurement .
the _ average _ of @xmath54 over all the mutually unbiased measurements can be bounded from below @xcite : @xmath55 \geq -\log_2\left[\left(\frac{1}{d+1}\right)\sum_{ij } p_{ij}^2\right ] = \log_2(d+1 ) - 1 , \label{ineq}\ ] ] with equality holding only if the rnyi entropy is _ constant _ over all the mutually unbiased measurements .
now , for any of the rotationally invariant states defined in the last section , the rnyi entropies associated with the @xmath27 mutually unbiased measurements are indeed equal . by the inequality ( [ ineq ] ) , such states therefore minimize the average rnyi entropy over all these measurements , that is , over all the directions in phase space .
the one - qubit case is very simple .
the three mutually unbiased bases generated in our construction are the eigenstates of the pauli operators @xmath21 , @xmath56 , and @xmath22 .
it is not hard to find a unitary transformation that cycles through these three bases .
such a transformation rotates the bloch sphere by @xmath57 around the axis @xmath58 .
the two eigenstates of this unitary transformation , which are the eigenstates of @xmath59 , are rotationally invariant : each of their wigner functions is constant on the only circle in the @xmath60 phase space . and
each of these states minimizes the average rnyi entropy for the measurements @xmath21 , @xmath56 , and @xmath22 .
it is interesting to note that one of these two states has a positive wigner function .
clearly there is nothing intrinsically special about these two states .
they are special only in relation to the three measurements @xmath21 , @xmath56 , and @xmath22 , which are associated with the three striations of the phase space .
but in the context of quantum cryptography , the entropy - minimization property is quite relevant . in the six - state scheme ( in which the signal states are the eigenstates of @xmath21 , @xmath56 , and @xmath22 ) ,
if eve chooses to eavesdrop by making a complete measurement on certain photons , her best choice is to make a measurement whose outcome - states are entropy - minimizing in our sense : it turns out that such a choice minimizes eve s own rnyi entropy about alice s bit .
an interesting example comes from the 3-qubit case .
the relevant field is @xmath61 , which can be constructed from @xmath7 by introducing an element @xmath32 that is defined to satisfy the equation @xmath62 . in our @xmath63 discrete phase space
, we can define circles via the equation @xmath64 where @xmath30 can take any nonzero value .
a primitive rotation preserving these circles is ) is not of the form we used in reaching eq .
( [ l ] ) , in that it is not based on a primitive polynomial , the matrix @xmath34 is nevertheless a primitive rotation . ]
@xmath65 one finds that of the eight eigenvectors of any unitary @xmath37 corresponding to @xmath34 , all of which are rotationally invariant , exactly one has a positive wigner function for a specific , fixed function @xmath17 associated with @xmath37 .
this state is also easy to describe physically . for a particular choice of @xmath37
, it is of the form @xmath66 where @xmath67 and @xmath68 are the two eigenstates ( with a specific relative phase ) of the operator @xmath59 .
if we regard @xmath50 as analogous to a coherent state at the origin , then the coherent - like states at the 63 other phase - space points can be obtained from @xmath50 by applying pauli rotations to the individual qubits .
the wigner function of each of these states has the value 0.319 at its center , the largest value possible for any three - qubit state .
we have found that one can make sense of the notion of rotational invariance in a discrete phase space for a system of @xmath0 qubits .
the rotationally invariant states are in this respect analogous to the energy eigenstates of a harmonic oscillator , but the analogy is not perfect .
our rotationally invariant states are all states of minimum uncertainty with respect to the various directions in phase space , whereas except for the ground state , the harmonic oscillator eigenstates do not have this property ( the uncertainty , even in our rnyi sense , increases with increasing energy ) .
we have considered the further restriction to positive wigner functions but so far have found examples of such states only for a single qubit and for three qubits .
however , for any number of qubits , one can show that at least one of our rotationally invariant states takes a value at its center equal to the maximum value attainable by the wigner function of _ any _ state .
perhaps this latter property , rather than positivity , should be taken as the defining feature of a most pointlike " state . | the quantum state of a system of @xmath0 qubits can be represented by a wigner function on a discrete phase space , each axis of the phase space taking values in the finite field @xmath1 . within this framework
, we show that one can make sense of the notion of a `` rotationally invariant state '' of any collection of qubits , and that any such state is , in a well defined sense , a state of minimum uncertainty . |
the unification of the electromagnetic and weak interactions in 1968 @xcite , the discoveries of the neutral currents in 1973 @xcite , of the charm quark in 1974 @xcite , of the and bosons in 1983 @xcite were very successful steps for the theory of the electroweak ( ew ) interactions , the standard model ( sm ) @xcite .
after the discoveries of the top quark in 1995 @xcite and the tau neutrino in 2000 @xcite the electroweak sm became the commonly accepted theory of the fundamental electroweak interactions .
it is a gauge invariant quantum field theory based on the symmetry group @xmath0 , which is spontaneously broken by the higgs mechanism .
the renormalizability of the sm @xcite allows us to make precise predictions for measurable quantities at higher orders of the perturbative expansion , in terms of a few input parameters .
the higher - order terms , radiative corrections ( rc ) or quantum corrections , contain the self - coupling of the vector bosons as well their interactions with the higgs field and the top quark .
their calculation provides the theoretical basis for the ew precision tests . in the last thirty five years in high energy physics
two distinct and complementary strategies have been used for gaining new understanding of the nature : * the direct discovery of the new phenomena at high energy accelerators * the precision measurements of the known phenomena at existing accelerators with high luminosity the excellent example is the ratio ( fig .
1 ) r_e^+e^- . @xcite . ]
both strategies have worked very well for the studies of the ew interactions first at sps and lep1/slc , and later at lep2/sld and the tevatron , and in the future such interplay of the proton and electron colliders will be applied for the lhc and ilc / clic .
the second strategy has always demanded from the theory the prediction of physical quantities with high precision , @xmath1 at the level of quantum corrections . for the interpretation of the precision experiments
the rc play the crucial role .
in the context of the sm any electroweak process can be computed at tree level from ( the fine structure constant measured at values of @xmath2 close to zero ) , ( the w - boson mass ) , ( the z - boson mass ) , and ( the cabbibo - kobayashi - maskawa flavor mixing matrix elements ) @xcite . when higher order corrections are included , any observable can be predicted using the on - shell renormalization scheme @xcite as a function of : & = & ( , _ , _ , _ , _ , _ , v_jk ) , where the effects of heavy particles do not decouple , and there is the sensitivity to the top mass @xcite and to less extend to the higgs mass @xcite .
vertex , involving a virtual top quark @xcite.,width=377 ] since the discovery of the presence of hard @xmath3 corrections to the @xmath4 vertex ( see fig .
2 ) @xcite the calculation of the ew rc has been theoretically well established and many higher - order contributions of the radiative corrections have become available over past decades to improve and stabilize the sm predictions .
the experimental data for testing of the ew theory have achieved an impressive accuracy . after taking the measured mass , besides and ( the fermi constant measured in the muon decay ) , for completion of the input , & = & ( 91.18750.0021 ) , + _ & = & ( 1.166 371 0.000 006 ) 10 ^ -5 ^ -2 , + ^-1 & = & 137.035 999 7100.000 000 096 each other precision observable provides a test of the electroweak theory ( fig .
the predictions are calculated with computer programs zfitter @xcite and topaz0 @xcite , which incorporate state - of - the - art calculations of the ew , qed and qcd radiative corrections .
theoretical predictions of the sm depend on the mass of the top quark and of the as yet experimentally unknown higgs boson through the virtual presence of these particles in the loops . as a consequence
, precision data can be used to pin down the allowed range of the mass parameters .
this is shown in fig .
4 , which compares the information on and obtained at lep1 and sld , with the direct measurements performed at lep2 and the tevatron .
the measured at tevatron mass @xmath5 @xcite agrees better than 10 % with the value predicted within the sm on the basis of the precision ew measurements . taking all direct and indirect data into account , one obtains the pillar of the precision electroweak physics @xcite : the best constraints on the possible mass of unseen higgs . the global electroweak fit results in the @xmath6 curve shown in fig .
the lower limit on obtained from direct searches is close to the point of minimum @xmath7 . at 95% c.l .
, one gets @xcite 114.4 < < 160 . versus , from the global fit to the ew data .
the vertical band indicates the 95% exclusion limit from direct searches @xcite.,width=226 ]
in the on - shell scheme @xcite the three - level formula @xmath8 is a definition of the renormalized @xmath9 to all orders in perturbation theory , @xmath1 , ^2_w^ ^2 = 1 - _ ^2_^2 .
a precise determination of the on - shell ew mixing angle has been performed by the nutev collaboration @xcite for the first time through the measurements of the pashos - wolfenstein ratio @xcite : r^- & & from deep inelastic neutrino scattering on isoscalar targets .
the nutev collaboration finds @xmath10 which is 3.0 @xmath11 higher than the sm predictions . from this experimental value one obtains the mass of boson @xcite = 80.14 0.08 which is smaller than other measurements of at lep / sld and the tevatron ( see fig .
6 ) .
the nutev result should be considered as preliminary until a reanalysis of data will be completed including all experimental and theoretical information .
apart from the still missing higgs boson , the sm provides an elegant theoretical framework for the description of the known experimental facts in particle physics .
the sm has been impressively confirmed by successful collider experiments at the particle accelerators lep , slc and tevatron during the last fifteen years .
future colliders like the upcoming lhc or an ilc / clic offer great prospects , and in turn represent a great challenge for theory to provide even more precise calculations .
accurate predictions are necessary not only to increase the level of precision of sm tests , but also to study the indirect effects of possible new particles .
i would like to thank the organizers of the uae - cern workshop for kind invitation to give a plenary talk and for the hospitality at al - ain .
i am grateful to j. vidal for support and to d. hertzog , z. hioki and a. shiekh for remarks and comments . | the status of the precision tests of the electroweak interactions is reviewed in this paper .
an emphasis is put on the standard model analysis based on measurements at lep / slc and the tevatron .
the results of the measurements of the electroweak mixing angle in the nutev experiment and the future prospects are discussed .
= 18pt |
the basic motivation behind a quantum cosmological model is two - fold .
one is the fact that when the linear dimension of the universe reaches the planck scale ( @xmath0 cm ) , the universe is indeed governed by a quantum picture .
the second is the hope that a quantum description might be able to produce a singularity free birth of our universe .
the quantum state of the universe is described by a wave function @xmath1 which is the solution of the wheeler dewitt equation on a minisuperspace . for a comprehensive review
, we refer to @xcite .
+ one critical problem in quantum cosmology is certainly that of a suitable choice of time against which the evolution of the universe is investigated .
this is because the notion of time has different implications in general relativity and quantum mechanics .
systematic attempts towards resolving this problem started in the 90s@xcite .
the strategies also include a scenario where the notion of time plays no role whatsoever@xcite .
for a recent review of different strategies , see @xcite .
+ if matter is taken as a perfect fluid , the strategy adopted by schutz@xcite becomes extremely useful as a set of canonical transformations leads to one conjugate momentum associated with the fluid giving a linear contribution to the hamiltonian .
the corresponding fluid variable thus qualifies to play the role of time in the relevant schr@xmath2dinger equation . in an ever expanding model
, the fluid density has a monotonic temporal behaviour , the time orientability is thus ensured .
+ schutz s formalism has been extensively used by alvarenga _
et al_@xcite for isotropic cosmological models .
the investigation involves spatially flat , open and closed models .
matter content is taken as a perfect fluid with an equation of state @xmath3 .
they found finite norm wave packet solutions of the wheeler - dewitt equations .
one important finding is that some singularity free models could be constructed even without violating the energy conditions .
a later work involves anisotropic bianchi
i cosmology@xcite , which is the anisotropic generalization of a spatially flat isotropic model .
anisotropic models have problems , particularly that of non - unitarity .
the hamiltonian , although hermitian , is not self - adjoint .
this is discussed in some detail in ref@xcite . + it is well known that a standard copenhagen interpretation of a quantum cosmological model is not tenable .
a `` bohm - de broglie '' interpretation normally does better . for a comprehensive review ,
we refer to @xcite . in the anisotropic case
, the non unitarity leads to futher problems in the interpretation . as the norm of the wave function becomes time dependent , bohmian trajectories
are not conserved and the bohm - de broglie interpretation also becomes vulnerable@xcite .
it appears that the philosophy of interpretation might require a dramatic extension so as to incorporate anisotropic cosmologies . in the present work schutz s formalism
is utilized to quantize bianchi type v and type ix perfect fluid cosmological models which are the anisotropic generalzations of open and closed isotropic models respectively . in section 2
we discuss the formalism and use that to quantize bianchi type v models . in section 3 , a type ix model is quantized .
some concluding remarks are made in section 4 .
the relevant action for gravity with a perfect fluid can be written as @xmath4 where @xmath5 is the induced metric over three dimensional spatial hypersurface which is the boundary @xmath6 of the four dimensional manifold @xmath7 and @xmath8 is the extrinsic curvature . here
units are so chosen that @xmath9 is equal to one .
@xmath10 is the pressure due to the perfect fluid .
the perfect fluid satisfies an equation of state @xmath11 where @xmath12 .
this restriction stems from the consideration that sound waves can not propagate faster than light . in schutz s formalism @xcite
the fluid s four velocity can be expressed in terms of six potentials .
however , two of them are connected with rotation . in bianchi
v or ix models permit timelike geodesics which are hypersurface orthogonal , the rotation tensor @xmath13 vanishes , and one can write the four velocity in terms of only four independent potentials as @xmath14 here @xmath15 , @xmath16 , @xmath17 and @xmath18 are the velocity potentials having their own evolution equations , where the potentials connected with vorticity are dropped .
the four velocity is normalized as @xmath19 although the physical identification of velocity potentials are irrelevant for the formulation , @xmath15 and @xmath16 can be identified with the specific enthalpy and specific entropy respectively .
this identification facilitates the representation of fluid parameters in terms of thermodynamic quantities .
the metric for the bianchi v anisotropic model is written as @xmath20\ ] ] where @xmath21 is called the lapse function . while @xmath22 are functions of the cosmic time @xmath23 , @xmath24 is a constant .
bianchi type i model is recovered when @xmath25 . eliminating the surface terms
, the first and second terms of the action ( 1 ) give @xmath26 \ , , \ ] ] where an overhead dot indicates a differentiation with respect to time @xmath23 and @xmath27 is contribution of geometry to the action .
so the gravitational lagrangian density can be easily identified as @xmath28 if we now choose the three metric coefficients as @xmath29 then we get @xmath30 and @xmath31 - 6e^{\beta_0}nm^2 \ , .\ ] ] now @xmath32 , @xmath33 and @xmath34 will be treated as the relevant variables in place of @xmath35 , @xmath36 and @xmath37 .
the corresponding conjugate momenta are then @xmath38 the hamiltonian of the gravity sector is now given by @xmath39 where momentum @xmath40 is replaced in terms of @xmath41 using equation ( [ mom ] ) .
for the fluid part , the action can be written using thermodynamic relations for @xmath15 and @xmath16 @xcite .
the relevant equations are @xmath42 where @xmath43 , @xmath44 , @xmath45 and @xmath46 are temperature , total mass energy density , rest mass density and specific internal energy respectively . rewriting the third equation of ( [ thermo ] )
we get @xmath47 \quad .\ ] ] it then follows that , @xmath48 and @xmath49 . we can show that the equation of state takes the form @xmath50 in a comoving system @xmath51 , and equation ( [ nor ] ) yields @xmath52 \ , , \ ] ] @xmath53 being the fluid part of the action .
as @xmath54 so @xmath55 . if we try the canonical methods used , for example , in @xcite the hamiltonian for this action can be written in a very simple form with the canonical transformations @xmath56 along with @xmath57 .
here @xmath58 , @xmath59 and @xmath60 , the lagrangian density of the fluid , is the expression inside the square bracket of equation ( [ af ] ) .
the hamiltonian for this perfect fluid can now be written as @xmath61 the advantage of using this method , i.e. , using canonical transformations , is that we could find a set of variables where the system of equations is more tractable , while the hamiltonian structure of the system remains intact .
it also deserves mention that amongst the four velocty potentials mentioned , actually two are used , namely @xmath17 and @xmath16 .
this is because @xmath17 and @xmath15 are related by @xmath62 ( see ref@xcite ) and one other , namely @xmath18 can be settled using the normalization ( [ nor ] ) .
the super hamiltonian for the minisuperspace of this anisotropic quantum model is @xmath63 \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath64 acts as a lagrange multiplier taking care of the classical constraint equation @xmath65 .
using the usual quantization procedure @xcite , we write the schr@xmath2dinger - wheeler - dewitt equation for our super hamiltonian with the ansatz that the super hamiltonian operator annihilates the wave function , @xmath66 there are attempts@xcite to show that the classical hamiltonian for a cosmological spacetime is zero , if one takes into account both the matter sector and the geometry sector together , like the present situation . but
these attempts involves pseudotensorial calculations and the result depends on the minisuperspace chosen@xcite .
the problem perhaps stems from the fact that localization of energy in general relativity is not uniquely defined . whatever be the status of the constraint ( [ wdwe1 ] ) in the most general case
, we shall be using this following the standard practice .
+ with @xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 equation ( [ wdwe1 ] ) can now be written as @xmath70\ , \psi(\beta_0,\beta_+,t ) = 0 \ , \ , .\ ] ] in this equation @xmath71 is the cosmic time co - ordinate if we choose the gauge @xmath72 and this follows from hamilton s classical equations as @xmath73 .
now it must be mentioned that while constructing the schr@xmath2dinger - wheeler - dewitt equation ( [ wdwe ] ) we have considered a particular choice of factor ordering for @xmath74 and @xmath75 .
we will discuss other choices of factor orderings and its consequences on our prime results in the subsequent section .
we require that the super hamiltonian must be hermitian , so the wave function @xmath1 must satisfy these conditions @xcite ; @xmath76 in order to solve for the wave function @xmath1 from equation ( [ wdwe ] ) we employ a separation of variables as , @xmath77 we get @xmath78 where @xmath79 is the separation constant .
further if we write @xmath80 we get @xmath81 the solution for @xmath82 is @xmath83 where @xmath84 is the integration constant and @xmath85 is again a constant of separation which has to be real so that the wave function is normalizable .
the equation for @xmath86 is @xmath87 for @xmath25 , this equation reduces to the corresponding equation for the bianchi i model @xcite .
it is very difficult to solve this equation analytically for all allowed values of @xmath88 . here
we will study the solution for some particular values of @xmath88 . with @xmath90 equation ( [ vs1 ] )
becomes @xmath91 the solution of equation ( [ phi1 ] ) is known in terms of bessel function and now we can write the wave function of equation ( [ wdwe ] ) as @xcite @xmath92 ~,\ ] ] where @xmath93 , @xmath94 are the integration constants .
now we can construct a regular wave packet superposing these solutions . in principle
this can be easily done by considering the arbitrary integration constants to be suitable gaussian functions of the parameters @xmath85 and @xmath79 ( see ref @xcite ) .
defining @xmath95 we can write the form of the wave packet as @xmath96 where @xmath97 and @xmath98 and @xmath99 are arbitrary positive constants .
the above integrals can be explicitly evaluated and the wave packet becomes @xmath100 where @xmath101 .
the norm of the wave packet is @xmath102 where @xmath103 .
clearly we can see that the norm is time dependent and hence the model is not unitary .
this is not surprising as we know that the anisotropic quantum cosmological models are non - unitary @xcite .
the expectation value of any variable @xmath104 can now be calculated as @xmath105 for @xmath106 we find @xmath107 where @xmath108 and @xmath109 is a numerical factor @xmath110 .
now @xmath111 this describes the cosmological evolution of the spatial volume and this model predicts a bounce from a minimum volume universe with no singularity .
of course this result is facilitated by the choice of the gauge @xmath112 as mentioned after equation(21 ) .
it is easy to see that the minimum volume is obtained at @xmath113 and the corresponding length scale is @xmath114 . as already mentioned , @xmath115 .
so the linear size of the universe can be set in the model by choosing the vaule of @xmath98 .
for @xmath116 , @xmath117 it deserves mention that @xmath33 is in fact a constant in time .
the plot of the norm of the wave packet against @xmath32 and @xmath33 shows a well behaved pattern , and even at @xmath113 , does not show any sign of blowing up ( see figure [ [ fig3 ] ] ) .
this is consistent with the fact that there exists a minimum of the proper volume and thus the pathology of a singular state of the universe can be avoided in this model .
furthermore , the plots are given for two different time , namely @xmath113 and @xmath118 in some units , and the qualitative nature of the plots remain similar .
now let us have a closer look at equation ( [ wnorm ] ) . as @xmath119
so we infer that the norm of the wave packet is time - dependent hence the model is non - unitary .
we now investigate the time dependence of the norm ( @xmath120 ) as a function of time ( @xmath121 ) in figure [ [ norm1 ] ] .
it is observed that with the increase of @xmath121 , the norm flattens , i.e. , almost becomes a constant .
this indicates that the problem of non - unitarity is somewhat diluted at least for a large time .
it deserves mention that this feature may be facilitated by our choice of gauge @xmath122 which makes @xmath123 a constant . [ cols="^ " , ] with @xmath125 equation ( [ vs1 ] ) becomes @xmath126 the solution is obtained in terms of bessel function and we can write @xmath127 where @xmath128 and @xmath129 are the integration constants . the wave function can now be written as @xmath130~.\ ] ] with @xmath132 equation ( [ vs1 ] ) becomes @xmath133 the solution can be written in terms of confluent hypergeometric function ( @xmath134 ) and associated laguerre function ( @xmath135 ) , @xmath136 ~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath137 , @xmath138 are the integration constants .
the expression for the wave function can be written as @xmath139 ~.\end{aligned}\ ] ]
the bianchi ix metric is written as @xmath140 d\phi^2 + 2 a^2 \cos \theta ~ dr d\phi ~.\ ] ] the gravitational lagrangian density is written as @xmath141 where @xmath142 .
the hamiltonian for this gravitational lagrangian density becomes @xmath143 where @xmath144 and @xmath145 are the canonical conjugate momenta for the variables @xmath35 and @xmath146 . applying schutz s mechanism @xcite and the canonical methods described in @xcite we can evaluate the hamiltonian for the fluid as @xmath147 the super hamiltonian for the minisuperspace of this model is @xmath148 we shall calculate the wave function of the bianchi ix universe with @xmath149 .
using the quantization procedure as described in @xcite we write the schr@xmath2dinger - wheeler - dewitt equation as @xmath150 now we have to apply the method of separation of variables for the solution of this equation .
we write the wave function as @xmath151 which leads to @xmath152 with the separation @xmath153 we get @xmath154 and @xmath155 here @xmath85 is the separation parameter
. the solutions of ( [ pv ] ) and ( [ pu ] ) are known in terms of modified bessel functions of first ( @xmath156 ) and second ( @xmath157 ) kind and can be written as @xmath158\ ] ] and @xmath159 ~,\ ] ] where @xmath160 and @xmath161 .
@xmath162 s are the arbitrary integration constants .
so the final expression of the wave function is @xmath163~[~ c_9 ~{\cal i}_{\nu'}~ ( ia^2)~ + ~ c_{10 } ~{\cal k}_{\nu ' } ~(ia^2)~]\end{aligned}\ ] ]
bianchi type v and type ix perfect fluid models are quantized following schutz s formalism . as the wheeler - dewitt equation for a general equation of state @xmath3 is too involved ,
some specific examples are taken up . in bianchi type
v models , the solution for the wave function for the universe comes out as a combination of bessel functions for the case @xmath164 . but it deserves mention that the problem of non - unitarity exists in this model , the norm of the wave packet is indeed time dependent .
a clever operator ordering can only alleviate the problem in the sense that the norm becomes a constant for a large time .
but the problem is only alleviated and not eradicated ! in addition to the operator ordering , the choice of a gauge as @xmath122 also may have its say .
the proper volume shows a bounce from a finite minimum and thus the singularity of a zero proper volume can be avoided . by a choice of parameter
, the minimum length scale obtained can be tuned to a desired value , say the planck length .
however , this is obtained as a bonus , as the chief motivation of the work had been to check the merits and problems of the particular method of quantization for the anisotropic cosmological models . only one case ,
namely @xmath164 has been solved here as an example .
this is simply because this case could be integrated anayltically .
for some other cases also the wave functions are obtained analytically .
but the complete analysis could not be done as the wave packet could not be integrated .
so the work is nowhere near a general investigation of the problem .
however , so long there is not a complete resolution of the quantum cosmology , one has to look for various examples .
so although potentially schutz formalism gives us a beautiful way of handling the problem of the choice of time , it also leads to other problems , namely that of non unitatiry .
this could be a generic feature of anisotropic models as indicated in @xcite .
the philosophy of interpretation also seems to be awaiting a new direction .
100 s.w . hawking .
quantum cosmology from _ relativity groups and topology _ , eds .
b.dewitt and r. stora , north holland ( 1984 ) .
k.v.kuchar in _ conceptual problems of quantum gravity _ , eds a.ashtekar and j.stachel ( birkhauser , boston , 1991 ) + k.v.kuchar in _ arguments of time _ , ed j.butterfield ( oxford university press , oxford , 1999 ) + c.j.isham in _ integrable systems , quantum groups and quantum field theory _ , eds l.a.ibort and m.a.rodriguez , ( kluwer , dordrecht , 1993 ) .
c. rovelli ; arxiv : gr - qc/0903.3832 .
e. anderson ; arxive : gr - qc/1009.2157 .
b.f . schutz , phys . rev . * d2 * , 2762 ( 1970 ) . b.f .
schutz , phys .
* d4 * , 3559 ( 1971 ) .
f.g.alvarenga , j.c.fabris , n.a.lemos and g.a.monerat ; gen . relativ . gravit . * 34 * , 651 ( 2002 ) .
n. pinto - neto , quantum cosmology , _ notas de fisica _
, cbpf - nf-006/97 ; cnpq , brazil .
alvarenga , a.b .
batista , j.c .
fabris and s.v.b .
goncalves , gen .
. grav . * 35 * , 1659 ( 2003 ) .
v.g . lapchinskii and v.a .
rubakov , theor .
phys . * 33 * , 1076 ( 1977 ) .
charles w. misner , phys . rev . * 186 * , 1319 ( 1969 ) . bryce s. dewitt , phys . rev . * 160 * , 1113 ( 1967 ) .
cooperstock , gen .
* 26 * , 323 ( 1994 ) ; + n. rosen , gen .
* 26 * , 319 ( 1995 ) .
n. banerjee and s. sen , pramana , * 49 * , 609 ( 1997 ) + j.m.nester , l.l.so and t.vargas , phys .
d , * 78 * , 044035 ( 2008 ) .
lemos , j. math . phys . * 37 * , 1449 ( 1996 ) .
batista , j.c .
fabris , s.v.b .
gonalves and j. tossa , phys . rev . * d65 * , 063519 ( 2002 ) .
w.w . bell , _ secial functions for scientists and engineers _ ; van nostrand reinhold co. , london ( 1968 ) . | the present paper deals with quantization of perfect fluid anisotropic cosmological models .
bianchi type v and ix models are discussed following schutz s method of expressing fluid velocities in terms of six potentials .
the wave functions are found for several examples of equations of state . in one case
a complete wave packet could be formed analytically .
the initial singularity of a zero proper volume can be avoided in this case , but it is plagued by the usual problem of non - unitarity of anisotropic quantum cosmological models .
it is seen that a particular operator ordering alleviates this problem .
* perfect fluid quantum anisotropic universe : merits and challenges * + barun majumder and narayan banerjee + department of physical sciences , + indian institute of science education and research - kolkata , + mohanpur campus , p.o .
bckv main office , district nadia , + west bengal 741252 , india .
_ pacs numbers : 04.20.cv . , 04.20.me_ |
engines are machines that convert some form of energy ( e.g. , thermal or electrical energy ) into work .
their efficiency , defined as the ratio of the extracted work to the invested energy , is restricted to @xmath0 at most by the energy - conservation law .
while mechanical engines may reach this bound , carnot showed @xcite that the efficiency of any heat engine that cyclically operates between two thermal baths is universally limited by the ratio of the bath temperatures , regardless of the concrete design @xcite .
the universality of this bound led to the formalisation of the second law of thermodynamics and the introduction of the notion of entropy by clausius @xcite . in terms of entropy
, the carnot bound is attained by ( idealised ) heat engines that operate reversibly , so that the total entropy of the engine and the baths is unaltered over a cycle @xcite .
this corresponds to the minimum amount of heat being dumped into the cold bath , so as to close the cycle , and hence to the maximum input heat being transformed into work . by contrast , in an irreversible cycle , a larger amount of heat must be dumped into the cold bath , so that less input heat is available for conversion into work , causing the engine efficiency to decrease @xcite . as part of the effort to understand the rapport between quantum mechanics and thermodynamics @xcite
( see @xcite for recent reviews ) , the carnot bound has been challenged for quantum engines that exploit non - thermal quantum baths @xcite . in this respect ,
a distinction is to be drawn between two types of non - thermal engines @xcite , ( i ) engines wherein the working medium equilibrates to a thermal state whose temperature is adjustable ( e.g. , by the phase of the coherence in a `` phaseonium '' bath @xcite ) , which qualify as genuine heat engines with a controllable carnot bound , and ( ii ) engines wherein the non - thermal ( e.g. , squeezed @xcite ) bath may render the working - medium state non - thermal , making the carnot bound irrelevant .
the efficiency bound of the latter type of engines has been addressed @xcite but still needs elucidation : what is particularly puzzling is that , contrary to heat engines , their efficiency bound can not be deduced from the requirement of reversible operation : reversibility may entail an efficiency bound that not only surpasses the carnot bound but also unity @xcite , making it unachievable .
hence , the question naturally arises whether such engines are limited by constraints other than the second law .
the second law for quantum relaxation processes is widely accepted @xcite to be faithfully rendered by spohn s inequality @xcite .
here we show that the inadequacy of assessing the maximum efficiency via this standard reversibility criterion arises whenever the engine s working medium is in a non - passive quantum state @xcite .
the definition @xcite of a non - passive state is that its energy can be _ unitarily _ reduced until the state becomes passive , thereby extracting work .
non - passive states may thus be thought of as being `` quantum batteries '' @xcite or `` quantum flywheels '' @xcite ( fig . [ fig_ergotropy ] ) .
the maximum amount of work extractable from such states ( their `` work capacity '' ) has been dubbed `` ergotropy '' in ref .
for example , every population - inverted state is non - passive and so are , e.g. , coherent or squeezed field states , whereas thermal states are passive .
as we show , the standard reversibility criterion provides an inequality for the change in the engine entropy which may be much too loose ( non - tight ) to be useful if non - passive states are involved .
the distinction between non - passive and passive states is at the heart of our analysis and underlies our division of the energy exchanged between a quantum system and a bath into a part that _ necessarily _ causes an entropy change , and ergotropy .
our proposed division is in fact a new unraveling of the first law of thermodynamics for quantum systems . in scenarios where non - thermal baths may create non - passive states of the working medium ,
we derive a new inequality for the entropy change which yields a physical efficiency limit of the engine that never surpasses unity .
this efficiency limit is universal and in general can not be assessed by the standard reversibility criterion .
concrete examples of such engines are given .
for an arbitrary process taking the initial state @xmath1 of a quantum system to an evolving state @xmath2 , which may be governed by a time - dependent hamiltonian @xmath3 and a bath , energy conservation implies @xmath4 where @xmath5 is the change in the system energy @xmath6 $ ] .
its two constituents are [ eq_defs_ediss_work ] @xmath7{\mathrm{d}}t^\prime,\ ] ] which is the non - unitary dissipative energy change due to the interaction with the bath , and @xmath8{\mathrm{d}}t^\prime,\ ] ] which is the work @xcite due to changes of the system hamiltonian . contrary to the energy change @xmath5 ,
both @xmath9 and @xmath10 are process variables that generally depend on the evolution path , not only on the initial and final states . for thermal baths ,
the energy is commonly identified with the transferred heat @xcite .
the energy @xmath9 vanishes for a closed ( isolated ) system whose state evolves unitarily according to the von neumann equation @xmath11 $ ] . if the hamiltonian is constant , then there is no work , @xmath12 .
we here consider general scenarios , wherein the bath and/or the system may be in a non - thermal state and strive to better understand the nature of the exchanged energy and , in particular , its relation to entropy change .
as we show , only part of the exchanged energy @xmath9 is necessarily accompanied by a change in entropy .
( extractable as work , here illustrated by a lighted bulb ) and its temperature ( colour of the battery : red hot , blue
cold ) represents passive ( here : thermal ) energy @xmath13the higher the temperature the larger the passive energy . (
a ) the battery is partly charged and hot : this represents a non - passive state which allows for work extraction .
as the battery is not completely charged , the light bulb appears dim .
( b ) the battery is discharged , but its temperature is the same as in ( a ) .
this state is the passive state of ( a ) and , consequently , the light bulb does not shine .
( c ) the battery is in a non - passive state whose ergotropy is higher than in ( a ) ( the battery is fully charged ) but the passive energy is lower ( the battery is colder ) .
although the total energy in ( a ) and ( c ) may be the same , more work can be extracted from the state ( c ) , causing the light bulb to shine brighter than in ( a ) . ] to elucidate this issue , we resort to the concept of non - passive states ( see fig .
[ fig_ergotropy ] and appendix [ app_ergotropy ] ) .
the energy @xmath14 of a non - passive state @xmath2 can be decomposed into ergotropy @xmath15 and passive energy @xmath16 .
ergotropy is the maximum amount of work that can be extracted from such a state by means of unitary transformations @xcite .
by contrast , the passive energy , which is the energy of the passive state @xmath17 , can not be extracted in the form of work .
the von neumann entropy @xmath18 $ ] of a non - passive state @xmath2 is the same as that of its passive state @xmath17 since the two are related by a unitary transformation .
hence , a change in entropy requires a change in the passive state @xmath17 . equation , however , does not discriminate between @xmath2 and @xmath17 : a change in @xmath2 may cause a non - zero @xmath9 but not necessarily a change in entropy .
by contrast , a change in @xmath17 results in entropy change . in order to explicitly account for a change in the _ passive _ state
, we may decompose the dissipative energy change as follows , @xmath19 where [ eq_defs_heat_passive_work ] @xmath20{\mathrm{d}}t^\prime\ ] ] is the dissipative ( non - unitary ) change in passive energy and @xmath21{\mathrm{d}}t^\prime\ ] ] is the dissipative ( non - unitary ) change in the system ergotropy due to its interaction with the bath .
the microscopic decomposition of the exchanged energy into dissipative change in passive energy and dissipative ergotropy change is a new unraveling of the first law of thermodynamics for quantum systems that constitutes one of our main results .
the decomposition carries with it the following insights : ( a ) although ergotropy may be transferred from a non - thermal bath to the system in a non - unitary fashion , it may afterwards still be extracted from the system in the form of work via a suitable unitary transformation .
( b ) consistently , any _ unitary _ changes ( in either ergotropy or in passive energy due to time - dependent changes of the hamiltonian ) are associated with work .
if the hamiltonian is constant , then @xmath22 is only the change in passive energy without work , @xmath23-{\operatorname{tr}}[\pi_0h]$ ] , where @xmath24 is the passive counterpart of the initial state @xmath1 .
likewise , @xmath25 is then the change in ergotropy without work performance .
( c ) while a non - zero @xmath22 entails a change in the passive state @xmath17 and hence in entropy , a non - zero @xmath9 , by contrast , does not necessarily imply an entropy change , as shown below .
the correspondence of @xmath22 and @xmath26 is plausible since they have the _ same _ sign provided a majorisation relation @xcite holds for @xmath2 , as detailed in appendix [ app_majorisation ] .
let us illustrate these insights for a single cavity mode ( harmonic oscillator at frequency @xmath27 ) prepared in a pure coherent state @xmath28 that interacts ( via a leaky mirror ) with the surrounding electromagnetic - field bath ( fig .
[ fig_examples]a ) , which for optical frequencies is very close to the vacuum state @xcite .
being in contact with a bath , the cavity - mode state evolves in a non - unitary fashion ( according to a quantum master equation @xcite ) . since the hamiltonian is constant , the work vanishes , @xmath12 . while the cavity field exponentially decays to the vacuum state , @xmath29 , where @xmath30 is the leakage rate , its entropy does not change , @xmath31 , so that the passive state @xmath32 is constant .
consequently , @xmath33 and the entire energy change is due to dissipated ergotropy , @xmath34 .
b ) obtained by a numerical integration of the master equation .
the energies are given in units of @xmath35 and the entropy in units of @xmath36 .
parameters : @xmath37 and squeezing parameter @xmath38 , @xmath30 being the decay rate of the cavity . ] as another example , consider again a single cavity mode , this time prepared in its vacuum state @xmath39 , that interacts with an outside bath in a squeezed - vacuum state @xcite ( appendix [ app_master_equation_squeezed_bath ] ) , eventually converging to a squeezed - vacuum state inside the cavity ( fig .
[ fig_examples]b ) .
although the initial and the steady state have zero entropy , this is not true during the evolution ( fig .
[ fig_squeezed_cavity ] ) .
consequently , both dissipative passive - energy change @xmath22 and dissipative ergotropy change @xmath40 occur .
figuratively , this process corresponds to a non - unitary charging of a battery .
in non - equilibrium thermodynamics , the accepted criterion for the irreversibility or reversibility of the system relaxation to its steady state is the non - negativity of the entropy production @xcite . for quantum systems in contact with ( thermal or non - thermal ) markovian baths , spohn @xcite put forward an expression for the entropy production @xmath41 . here
, we are interested in relaxation to steady state , for which we define @xmath42 , satisfying ( appendix [ app_spohn ] ) @xmath43 where the equality sign is the reversibility condition . for a constant hamiltonian
, it evaluates to @xmath44 , where @xmath45 $ ] is the entropy of the system initialised in a state @xmath1 at @xmath46 relative to the steady state @xmath47 to which it relaxes . for a slowly time - varying hamiltonian @xcite , eq . gives rise to an inequality for the the change @xmath48 of the system ( von neumann ) entropy , given in appendix [ app_spohn ] . the common @xcite identification of eq .
with the second law appears plausible for systems in contact with thermal baths : it then evaluates to @xmath49 , where @xmath50 is the dissipative change in the system energy defined in eq .
( in the limit @xmath51 ) . here we contend that although inequality is a formally correct statement of the second law ( under standard thermodynamic assumptions ) , it may not provide a meaningful estimate of @xmath48 if a system is initialised in a non - passive state and/or interacts with a non - thermal bath .
physically , this is because , as discussed above , the exchanged energy @xmath50 may be non - zero even if the entropy does not change .
consider the decay of an initially non - passive state @xmath1 to a ( passive ) thermal state @xmath52 via contact with a thermal bath at temperature @xmath53 .
based on the decomposition , the reversibility condition evaluates to ( at @xmath51 ) @xmath54 where both dissipative change in passive energy and dissipated ergotropy appear . in
what follows we shall revise this inequality , which may greatly overestimate the actual entropy change . as shown below
, a tight inequality for @xmath48 is indispensable for correctly assessing the maximum efficiency of an engine .
as we have seen , dissipative ergotropy change is not necessarily linked to a change in entropy .
therefore , the lower bound on @xmath48 in eq . may be not tight ( maximal ) .
it is obtained from spohn s inequality for the relaxation of an initially non - passive state in a thermal bath .
however , one may resort to the fact that the entropy @xmath55 is a state variable , so that @xmath56 is path - independent , i.e. , its value only depends on the initial state @xmath1 and the ( passive ) thermal steady state @xmath52 . hence , spohn s inequality may well be applied to alternative evolution paths from @xmath1 to @xmath52 , giving rise to different inequalities for the _ same _ @xmath48 .
in particular , we now consider a path that does not involve any dissipation of ergotropy to the bath : namely , one may start the process by performing a unitary transformation to the passive state , @xmath57 .
thereafter , this state is brought in contact with the thermal bath , yielding the steady - state solution @xmath52 .
inequality applied to this alternative path yields @xmath58 where @xmath59 is the same as in eq . .
the steady state attained via contact with a thermal bath is passive , hence the system ergotropy must decrease as a result of the relaxation , @xmath60 , where @xmath61 is the initial ergotropy stored in the state @xmath1 .
hence , inequality always entails inequality and is thus a tighter and more relevant estimate of @xmath48 .
this has a crucial consequence : if the initial state is non - passive , inequality rules out the equality sign in inequality , so that the considered decay via contact with a thermal bath can never be reversible according to criterion .
we now consider the more general situation wherein the system is governed by a constant hamiltonian and interacts with an arbitrary bath ( that may not be parameterised by a temperature ) until it reaches the steady state @xmath47 . in order to obtain an optimal ( the tightest ) inequality for the entropy change @xmath48 ,
we here instead of inequality ( @xmath62 for such a bath is given in appendix [ app_sigma_non - thermal ] ) propose to adopt the mathematical relation @xmath63 as shown in appendix [ app_sigmap_optimal ] , eq .
provides generally a tight inequality for @xmath48 . the motivation for eq .
is , as before , that the entropy of any state @xmath64 is the same as that of its passive counterpart @xmath65 .
if @xmath66 is a thermal state , we recover eq . .
we now allow the hamiltonian @xmath3 to slowly vary during the evolution @xcite .
contrary to the case of a constant hamiltonian , the dissipative passive - energy change and the ergotropy change in the r.h.s . of eq .
are now path - dependent .
namely , they are not only determined by the initial state @xmath1 and the steady state @xmath67 , which is a thermal state under the hamiltonian @xmath68 . since during the evolution the time - dependent hamiltonian may generate a non - passive state (
even if the initial state is passive and the bath is thermal ) we can not , in general , find an alternative path void of dissipated ergotropy for the same @xmath3 .
notwithstanding , we may still consider a path void of _ initial _ ergotropy in the spirit of the previous section by extracting the ergotropy of the initial state in a _
unitary _ fashion prior to the interaction with the bath , resulting in the passive state @xmath24 .
afterwards , this passive state is brought into contact with the thermal bath , yielding the steady state @xmath67 .
spohn s inequality can be applied to the latter step , yielding @xmath69 with the energy @xmath70{\mathrm{d}}t\ ] ] exchanged with the bath along the alternative path . here
@xmath71 is the solution of the same thermal master equation that governs @xmath2 but with the initial condition @xmath72 .
in the case that the initial state @xmath1 is already passive , we have @xmath73 , @xmath74 and eqs . and
coincide . for a constant hamiltonian , eq .
evaluates to eq . .
consider now the more general situation where a quantum system interacts with a non - thermal bath and eventually relaxes to a unitarily - transformed thermal state @xmath75 .
a prime example is a harmonic oscillator that interacts with a squeezed thermal bath @xcite : its steady state is a squeezed thermal state
. then one can show ( appendix [ app_liouvillian ] ) that this situation can be traced back to the interaction of a unitarily - transformed state @xmath76 with a _
thermal _ bath , provided that the hamiltonian @xmath3 commutes with itself at all times ; a harmonic oscillator with a time - dependent frequency and time - independent eigenstates is an example .
this requirement will be adopted in the remainder of this paper for any interaction of a system with a non - thermal bath .
the relaxation of a possibly non - passive state @xmath77 in a thermal bath pertains to the scenario considered above upon replacing @xmath2 by @xmath77 there .
equation thus also holds for this class of non - thermal baths ( the generalisation to arbitrary non - thermal baths is discussed in appendix [ app_time - dependent_hamiltonian ] ) .
the new entropic inequality is the second main result of our work .
for the special case of a constant hamiltonian , it reduces to inequality .
in view of our new inequality , does inequality always provide a true bound on the engine efficiency ?
namely , is reversibility indeed the key to operating a quantum engine at the highest possible efficiency ?
this question arises for cyclic engines fuelled by non - thermal ( e.g. , squeezed ) baths , since such baths may transfer both passive thermal energy and ergotropy to the system while eq .
does not distinguish between these two different kinds of energies . .
the engine operates in an arbitrary cycle wherein work is extracted by a piston and an amount of energy @xmath78 is dumped into the cold thermal bath . ] here we consider a quantum engine ( fig . [ fig_engine ] ) that operates between a cold thermal bath ( at temperature @xmath79 ) and a hot non - thermal bath ( whose thermal component has the temperature parameter @xmath80 ) subject to a time - dependent drive ( the `` piston '' @xcite ) .
existing treatments of such engines have taken the interactions with the baths to be isochoric , i.e. , subject to a constant system hamiltonian @xcite .
we here relax this restriction and allow for stroke cycles wherein the working - medium ( wm ) hamiltonian is allowed to slowly change during the interaction with the baths @xcite .
more restrictively , during the interaction with the non - thermal bath , the hamiltonian is assumed to commute with itself at all times , as previously mentioned in the discussion on the validity of eq .
for such a bath .
we only impose the condition that the wm attains its steady state at the end of the energising stroke ( wherein it interacts with the hot non - thermal bath ) and the resetting stroke ( wherein it interacts with the cold thermal bath ) .
the energising stroke is described by a master equation @xcite that evolves the wm state to a unitarily - transformed thermal state @xmath81 , hence eq .
holds . after this stroke ,
the wm is in a non - passive state , whose ergotropy is subsequently extracted by the piston via a suitable unitary transformation . since we seek the efficiency bound , we assume that no ergotropy is dissipated in the cold bath ( and thus lost ) , hence the requirement to extract it from the wm before its interaction with that bath .
we note that in cycles where both baths are simultaneously coupled to the wm ( as in continuous cycles @xcite ) , part of the ergotropy is inevitably dissipated into the cold bath , so that such cycles are inherently less efficient than stroke cycles adhering to the above requirement .
the engine s wm must return to its initial state after each cycle .
this implies that @xmath82 over a cycle , hence the importance of having a tight estimate for the entropy change within each stroke .
the entropy changes in the two relevant strokes satisfy @xmath83 and @xmath84 . here
@xmath85 is the change in the wm energy due to its interaction with the cold thermal bath and @xmath86 is the change the wm energy would have , had the non - thermal bath been thermal [ as in eq . ] .
taking into account that the wm is passive prior to its interaction with the cold bath , so that eqs . and
coincide for that stroke , the condition of vanishing entropy change over a cycle ( which must hold in any cycle ) then yields the inequality @xmath87 the efficiency of the engine is defined as the ratio of the extracted work to the invested energy , @xmath88 , where @xmath89 is the total energy ( the sum of passive thermal energy and ergotropy ) imparted by the non - thermal bath during the energising stroke . using the first - law statement , this ratio may be expressed through the energy transfers @xmath78 and @xmath90 ( see appendix [ app_efficiency ] ) .
condition on these energy transfers then restricts the efficiency to @xmath91 the bound underscores the physicality of our inequality : in the usual regime of functioning of the engine , @xmath86 and @xmath92 ( i.e. , the hot bath provides energy and increases the wm entropy ) , the bound is limited by unity , @xmath93 , which is reached in the `` mechanical''-engine limit @xmath94 where the non - thermal bath only provides ergotropy .
by contrast , the bound @xmath95 that stems from the reversibility condition ( derived in appendix [ app_efficiency ] ) may surpass @xmath0 ( see ref .
@xcite ) . in the opposite , heat - engine , limit @xmath96 where only passive thermal energy but no ergotropy is imparted by the hot bath , eq .
reproduces the carnot bound @xmath97 .
as shown below , if the hamiltonian is kept constant during the interaction with the non - thermal bath , then eq
. is restricted by @xmath98 .
therefore , for such engines our new bound is always tighter than the second - law bound @xmath95 .
the bound is valid in the regime @xmath85 and @xmath99 wherein the cold bath serves as an energy dump .
as shown in @xcite , there exists a regime wherein such a machine acts simultaneously as an engine and a refrigerator for the cold bath .
the efficiency then evaluates to @xmath100 ( see appendix [ app_efficiency ] ) .
we have thus reached a central conclusion : the efficiency bound of the engine increases with the decrease of the ratio of the energy that an alternative thermal engine would have received ( in the same energising stroke ) to the total energy imparted by the non - thermal bath ( in the actual engine cycle ) . in the limit of thermal baths
@xcite we recover the standard carnot bound for the efficiency of heat engines , even if the engine ( in any cycle ) exhibits quantum signatures ( e.g. , quantum coherence in the wm due to the piston action @xcite ) or the wm bath interactions are time - dependent @xcite .
we now pose the question : which bound is more relevant , @xmath95 ( whose explicit form is given in appendix [ app_efficiency ] ) that stems from the reversibility condition , or @xmath101 given by eq . ?
contrary to the carnot bound , the efficiency bound not only depends on the parameters of the baths but also on the energising stroke through the stroke s initial condition and the hamiltonian that determine the integrals @xmath90 and @xmath89 . yet , the functional form is independent of the choice of the non - thermal bath or the wm . whether or not this bound is reached by an engine that implements this chosen energising stroke is then determined by condition . in complete generality ,
the tighter of the alternative efficiency bounds derived here , @xmath102 is the relevant one .
relation is the universal thermodynamic limit on quantum engine efficiency , which never surpasses unity . notwithstanding the alternatives that may be offered by eq .
, we now discuss two generic practically - relevant engine cycles for which one can explicitly show that @xmath103 .
such engines are thus not restricted by the second law , but by other constraints on their entropy . and temperature @xmath79 ( lower left corner ) .
in stroke @xmath0 , the mode undergoes an adiabatic compression to frequency @xmath104 and temperature @xmath80 .
thereafter , in the energising stroke @xmath105 , the frequency is slowly reduced to @xmath106 while the mode is connected to the squeezed thermal bath , yielding a squeezed thermal steady state .
its ergotropy is extracted in stroke @xmath107 by an `` unsqueezing '' unitary operation , resulting in a thermal state with temperature @xmath108 . in stroke
@xmath109 , the frequency is again adiabatically reduced to @xmath110 such that the mode attains the temperature @xmath79 .
finally , stroke @xmath111 is an isothermal compression back to the initial state . ]
we consider a photonic carnot - like engine fuelled by a squeezed - thermal bath , as depicted in fig .
[ fig_carnot ] .
it contains the four strokes of the regular thermal carnot cycle @xcite , as well as an additional ergotropy - extraction stroke ( stroke @xmath107 in the figure ) . in the regular thermal carnot cycle ,
the interactions with the baths are isothermal . ) during stroke @xmath105 of the modified carnot cycle in fig .
[ fig_carnot ] as a function of the stroke duration obtained by a numerical integration of the master equation .
the upper ( blue ) curve corresponds to the reversibility criterion ; it is seen that the inequality @xmath112 is far from being saturated .
by contrast , our proposed inequality is saturated ( i.e. , the equality sign applies ) for sufficiently long stroke duration ( red central curve ) . then , as seen from the lower ( orange ) curve , also @xmath113 , due to the fact that the squeezing only occurs at the beginning of the stroke .
equation here also holds for a finite cycle duration .
parameters : oscillator frequency @xmath114 , @xmath115 and squeezing parameter @xmath116 . ] based on eq . , we have in the second stroke @xmath117 , since the master equation void of squeezing induces isothermal expansion wherein the state @xmath71 is always in thermal equilibrium ( fig .
[ fig_carnot_engine ] ) .
stroke @xmath111 is isothermal compression , i.e. , @xmath118 .
the condition of vanishing entropy change over a cycle , @xmath119 , corresponds to the equality sign in condition .
hence , the efficiency of this cycle is the bound .
consequently , the bound @xmath101 is lower than @xmath120 for all possible engine cycles that contain a `` carnot - like '' energising stroke , namely , a stroke characterised by a slowly - changing hamiltonian and an initial thermal state at temperature @xmath108 , such that @xmath117 . ) may be realised in a micromaser setup where a beam of entangled atom pairs passes through the cavity @xcite .
( b ) the unsqueezing operation in stroke @xmath107 of fig .
[ fig_carnot ] may be implemented by a suitable modulation of the cavity frequency @xcite . ]
such a photonic carnot engine energised by a squeezed bath may be implemented as a modification of the photonic carnot cycle based on a cavity in a micromaser setup in the seminal work by scully et al .
@xcite : instead of a beam of coherently - prepared three - level atoms ( `` phaseonium '' ) that constitute an effective thermal bath for the cavity - mode wm , we here suggest , following ref .
@xcite , to use a beam of suitably - entangled atom pairs passing through a cavity that may act as a squeezed - thermal bath for the same wm ( fig .
[ fig_implementation]a ) .
a major advantage of this method is that it allows for very high squeezing parameters . in order to extract the ergotropy that is stored in the cavity mode after its interaction with the squeezed bath and before its interaction with the cold bath ( where it would be lost ) , a unitary transformation that `` unsqueezes '' the cavity field
must be performed , e.g. , as in refs .
@xcite , where the cavity - mode frequency is abruptly ramped up and then gradually ramped down ( fig .
[ fig_implementation]b ) .
next , we consider a quantum otto cycle @xcite that consists of two isentropic strokes ( adiabatic compression and decompression of the wm ) , two isochoric strokes ( interaction with the baths at a fixed hamiltonian ) and an additional ergotropy - extraction stroke .
this cycle amounts to setting @xmath121 and @xmath122 in fig .
[ fig_carnot ] .
since the hamiltonian is now kept constant during the energising stroke , we have @xmath123 , where @xmath124 is the change in passive energy during the hot stroke , and @xmath125 , where @xmath126 is the change in ergotropy during that stroke . the efficiency of this otto - like cycle is bounded by eq . , @xmath127 but this bound is only attained in the `` mechanical '' limit @xmath128 , where only ergotropy is transferred from the non - thermal bath and no net entropy change occurs during the strokes . by contrast , the carnot - like cycle always operates at maximum efficiency , even when both passive thermal energy and ergotropy are imparted by this bath . in general , any engine cycle wherein the interaction with the hot bath is isochoric ( has constant hamiltonian ) and sufficiently long ( for the wm to reach steady state ) abides by the bound , which is lower than the bound @xmath95 imposed by the second law ( fig .
[ fig_efficiency_otto ] ) . moreover , their efficiency bound always surpasses the carnot bound , @xmath129 .
and alternative efficiency bounds ( the explicit expressions are summarised in appendix [ app_figures ] ) for an otto - like cycle implemented with a harmonic - oscillator working medium and a squeezed thermal bath as a function of ( a ) the frequency ratio and ( b ) the squeezing parameter .
the bounds only hold in the regime @xmath85 ( see text ) .
parameters : @xmath130 and ( a ) squeezing parameter @xmath131 and ( b ) oscillator frequencies @xmath132 . ]
our analysis has been aimed at comparing the efficiency bounds and the conditions for their attainment in quantum engines energised by thermal and non - thermal baths .
these respective bounds turn out to be very different since , unlike thermal baths , non - thermal baths may exchange thermal ( passive ) energy and ergotropy with the working medium ( wm ) . to this end
we have revisited the first law of thermodynamics and identified as passive - energy change the part of the energy exchange with the bath that _ necessarily _ causes a change in the wm entropy [ eq . ] .
this division of the exchanged energy relies on the distinction between passive and non - passive states of the wm .
only the latter states store ergotropy that may be completely extracted in the form of work .
we note that our approach based on non - passive states conceptually differs from the energetic division involving `` housekeeping heat '' previously provided for classical systems @xcite .
based on the distinction between passive and non - passive states , we have put forward a new estimate of the entropy change in quantum relaxation processes , which turns out to be the key for understanding the limitations of quantum engines fuelled by arbitrary baths .
cyclic engines whose passive energy is altered by the baths are restricted in efficiency by limits on their entropy change . yet , for a wide class of practically - relevant engines , including all engines whose energising stroke is either isochoric or carnot - like , the restriction imposed by inequality on the entropy change is stricter than what the second law would allow . by contrast , the commonly used reversibility is a global condition on the wm and the baths combined that is imposed by the second law , and hence not necessarily a relevant characterisation of engine efficiency .
an alternative formulation of our main insight is that , for any baths , entropy change limits the engine efficiency in the _ same _ way as in traditional heat engines
condition is the same whether the energising bath is thermal or not .
namely , maximal efficiency is reached when ( a ) no ergotropy ( extractable work ) is dumped into the cold bath and ( b ) no entropy is generated within the engine , or , equivalently , minimal energy is dumped into the cold bath @xcite . for thermal engines ,
this criterion of minimal energy dumping and the reversibility criterion coincide , but the two criteria differ if the energising bath is non - thermal .
another important insight is that the same efficiency bound ensues whether the wm is energised by a non - thermal bath or by a thermal bath ( that supplies thermal energy ) combined with a battery ( that supplies ergotropy ) provided the total energy imparted by the wm remains the same .
this supports the description of non - thermal engines as hybrids of thermal ( thermal - energy - fuelled ) and `` mechanical '' ( ergotropy - fuelled ) engines @xcite .
our theory provides better understanding of the operation principles of quantum engines : these are shown not to follow only from the laws of thermodynamics , but require discrimination between different ( passive and non - passive ) quantum states of the system ( wm ) and the baths involved .
the present generalisation of the treatment of standard thermal processes for quantum systems is not only the key to the construction of the most efficient hybrid engines that are unrestricted by the carnot bound .
it may also open a new perspective on quantum - channel communications @xcite where entropic constraints play a key role .
we thank the us
israel bsf , aeri and vatat for support .
the energy @xmath133 of a state @xmath64 with respect to a hamiltonian @xmath134 can be decomposed into ergotropy @xmath135 and passive energy @xmath13 .
ergotropy is the maximum amount of work that can be extracted from the state by means of cyclic unitary transformations , meaning that the hamiltonian before and after the unitary coincide @xcite .
the passive energy , by contrast , can not be extracted in the form of work .
states that only contain passive energy are called _ passive states_. ergotropy is defined as @xmath136 where the minimisation is over the set of all possible unitary transformations . consequently , any state @xmath64 can be written as @xmath137 , i.e. , as a unitarily - transformed passive state @xmath65 , where @xmath138 is the unitary that realises the minimum appearing on the r.h.s . of eq . .
the energy of the state @xmath64 thus reads @xmath139+{\operatorname{tr}}[(\rho-\pi)h].\ ] ] explicitly , the passive state and its energy read @xmath140=\sum_n r_n e_n,\label{eq_app_passive_energy } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath141 are the ordered ( @xmath142 ) eigenvalues of @xmath64 and @xmath143 is the ordered ( @xmath144 ) eigenbasis of @xmath134 .
when @xmath134 is non - degenerate , @xmath65 is unique .
if @xmath134 is degenerate , its eigenbasis and , consequently , the passive state , may be not unique .
however , the energies of all passive states corresponding to @xmath64 are the same and equal the passive energy of @xmath64 .
assume @xmath146 for any @xmath147 in some time interval @xmath148 ( @xmath149 ) , namely that @xmath150 majorises @xcite @xmath151 in this interval , i.e. , @xmath152 where @xmath153 ( @xmath154 ) are the ordered eigenvalues of @xmath155 [ cf .
and @xmath156 is the dimension of the hilbert space of the system .
let us consider the sign of the dissipative passive - energy change @xmath59 under this majorisation condition .
we may write in the form @xmath157=\int_{0}^{t}{\mathrm{d}}\tau \lim_{h\rightarrow 0}f(\tau , h),\ ] ] where we have defined @xmath158 where @xmath159 are the ordered eigenvalues of the hamiltonian [ cf .
using summation by parts and the normalisation of the density matrix , this function may be rewritten as @xmath160\sum_{m=1}^n\frac{r_m(\tau)-r_m(\tau+h)}{h}.\ ] ] the first factor is non - negative due to the monotonically - ordered energies .
the second factor is also non - negative if eq .
holds in the entire integration domain @xmath161 $ ] . in this case , the majorisation relation implies @xmath162 .
let us now turn to the sign of the entropy change .
if @xmath163 , then @xmath164 @xcite .
hence , we have the relation @xmath165 where @xmath166 .
similarly , one can show that the opposite relation holds , @xmath167 . when the hamiltonian is non - degenerate , @xmath22 and @xmath26 can be shown to vanish iff the passive state corresponding to @xmath155 is constant ( i.e.
, the evolution of @xmath155 is unitary ) for @xmath168 $ ] . for the case of a constant hamiltonian ,
relation was obtained in ref . @xcite . in this case ,
@xmath169 and hence eq
. implies that the passive energy of @xmath170 is greater than or equal to the passive energy of @xmath171 if @xmath163 or , equivalently , if @xmath172 , where @xmath173 is the passive state corresponding to @xmath174 ( @xmath175 ) .
in the interaction picture , the master equation for a harmonic oscillator that interacts with a squeezed thermal bath reads @xcite @xmath176+\kappa n\mathcal{d}(a^\dagger , a)[\rho]\\-\kappa m\mathcal{d}(a , a)[\rho]-\kappa m\mathcal{d}(a^\dagger , a^\dagger)[\rho],\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath177{\mathrel{\mathop:}=}2a\rho b - ba\rho-\rho ba$ ] . here
@xmath30 denotes the decay rate and ( w.l.o.g .
we have set the squeezing phase to zero ) @xmath178 where @xmath179)-1]^{-1}$ ] is the thermal excitation number of the bath at the oscillator frequency @xmath27 and @xmath180 the squeezing parameter .
the results in fig .
[ fig_squeezed_cavity ] were obtained by a numerical solution of eq . with @xmath181 .
defining @xmath182 , where @xmath183 $ ] is the unitary squeezing operator , the master equation can be cast into the lindblad form @xcite @xmath184+\kappa \bar{n}\mathcal{d}(b^\dagger , b)[\rho].\ ] ] its steady - state solution is the squeezed thermal state @xmath185\right)\right]s^\dagger(r)$ ] .
spohn s inequality for the entropy - production rate reads @xcite @xmath186 where @xmath187 $ ] .
inequality holds for any @xmath2 that evolves according to a lindblad master equation @xcite @xmath188 @xmath189 being the liouvillian ( lindblad operator ) .
its steady - state solution obeys @xmath190 .
then , upon defining @xmath191 , the time - integrated inequality yields @xmath192 note that eq . may not hold for non - markovian baths @xcite . as shown in refs .
@xcite , spohn s inequality can be generalised to time - dependent hamiltonians under the condition that @xmath3 varies slowly compared to the relaxation time of the reservoir @xcite .
the corresponding master equation then reads @xmath193 where @xmath194 is the same liouvillian as in eq . , but with time - dependent coefficients ( cf .
its invariant state @xmath195 satisfies @xmath196 .
the generalisation of inequality then reads @xcite @xmath197 upon integration , eq .
evaluates to the inequality @xmath198{\mathrm{d}}t\geq0\ ] ] for the entropy change @xmath199 . in the case of a constant hamiltonian ,
. reduces to eq . .
if the liouvillian describes the interaction with a thermal bath at temperature @xmath53 , i.e. , @xmath200 , then @xmath201 , where @xmath202 is a thermal state for the ( instantaneous ) hamiltonian @xmath3 .
equation then yields @xmath203{\mathrm{d}}t= \frac{\mathcal{e}_\mathrm{d}}{t},\ ] ] with the dissipated energy @xmath50 defined in eq . .
let us consider @xmath62 in the case of a constant hamiltonian [ eq . ] for a non - thermal bath that gives rise to a non - passive steady state @xmath204 via the liouvillian @xmath205 .
this @xmath62 can be related to that of a passive state , as follows . since the relative entropy is invariant with respect to a unitary transformation of its arguments , eq .
can be recast in the form @xmath206 where @xmath207 .
thus , @xmath62 equals the entropy production obtained under the relaxation of an open system from the unitarily - transformed state @xmath208 to the passive state @xmath66 . in particular ,
when @xmath66 is the thermal state @xmath52 , @xmath62 equals the entropy production obtained under thermalisation of the system starting from the state @xmath208 and we have @xmath209 where @xmath210 is the change in the energy @xmath211 $ ] of the transformed state @xmath212 .
consider now a slowly - varying @xmath3 such that inequality holds .
the invariant state of @xmath213 now reads @xmath214 , with the ( instantaneous ) thermal state .
inequality then yields @xmath215{\mathrm{d}}t\geq 0,\ ] ] where the appearing integral is the generalisation of @xmath210 from inequality .
it is shown in appendix [ app_liouvillian ] that @xmath216 equals a thermal liouvillian acting on a unitarily - transformed state [ eq . ] .
hence , also for a time - dependent hamiltonian , the evaluation of @xmath62 in a non - thermal bath reduces to the case of a transformed state that decays via contact with a thermal bath .
equation provides a generally tighter inequality for @xmath48 than eq . [ or ] . indeed , eq .
can be written as @xmath217 , where @xmath218 $ ] .
this inequality is the tightest ( i.e. , its r.h.s
. is maximal ) on the set of all states @xmath208 which differ from @xmath1 by a unitary transformation , when @xmath219 is minimal on this set .
note that @xmath66 commutes with the hamiltonian and the eigenvalues of @xmath220 do not decrease as a function of the eigenvalues of the hamiltonian .
thus , @xmath220 can be considered , in a sense , as an effective `` hamiltonian '' , for which @xmath219 is the average `` energy '' in the state @xmath208 .
the average energy amongst unitarily - accessible states is known to be minimised in the passive state .
when @xmath134 is non - degenerate , then the passive state @xmath24 corresponding to @xmath134 is also the passive state corresponding to the effective `` hamiltonian '' @xmath220 ; hence , @xmath219 is minimal for @xmath221 .
by contrast , if @xmath134 is degenerate there is generally no unique passive state ( appendix [ app_ergotropy ] ) . in this case
, @xmath219 is minimal not for each @xmath24 but iff @xmath24 is also a passive state of the effective `` hamiltonian '' , i.e. , iff @xmath24 commutes with @xmath66 .
one can show that there exists , at least , one such state @xmath24 .
thus , eq . provides the tightest inequality for @xmath48 among all inequalities of the form or .
the time evolution of an initial state @xmath1 under the liouvillian @xmath205 as defined in appendix [ app_sigma_non - thermal ] may be replaced by an alternative time evolution involving a _ thermal _ bath .
these two equivalent evolution paths can be lucidly represented by the diagram ( see also @xcite and appendix [ app_master_equation_squeezed_bath ] ) @xmath222 \arrow[d,"u^\dagger " left , mapsto , bend right , dashed ] & \rho(t)=u\tilde\rho(t)u^\dagger \\ \tilde{\rho}_0=u^\dagger\rho_0 u \arrow[r,"\mathcal{l}_\mathrm{th}",mapsto , bend right , dashed ] & \tilde\rho(t ) \arrow[u,"u " right , mapsto , bend right , dashed ] \end{tikzcd}.\ ] ] according to eq . , the evolution of @xmath1 induced by a non - thermal bath towards @xmath47 ( solid arrow ) may be replaced by a three - stage process ( dashed arrows ) wherein the system is in contact with a thermal bath only in the second step .
this may be shown as follows .
the liouvillian @xmath205 in the interaction picture may be cast into the general lindblad form @xcite @xmath223.\ ] ] we now consider the unitarily transformed master equation @xmath224,\ ] ] where we have defined @xmath225 and @xmath226 .
the right - hand side of eq .
is thus again a lindblad superoperator , @xmath227 .
now , since @xmath228 is the steady - state solution of @xmath205 , the state @xmath229 must be the steady state of @xmath230 .
hence , @xmath230 has to be a thermal generator , i.e. , @xmath231 , and therefore @xmath232 hence , the solution of @xmath233 may be written as @xmath234u^\dagger.\ ] ] if @xmath3 is slowly varying in time and commutes with itself at all times , we have time - dependent @xmath235 in eq . @xcite
. since the above derivation does not depend on these rates , we have @xmath236
equation for a thermal bath was derived based on the alternative ( dashed ) path @xmath237 \rho_0 \arrow[r,"\dot\rho(t)=\mathcal{l}_\mathrm{th}(t)\rho(t)","\mathcal{e}_\mathrm{d}"',mapsto ] \arrow[d,"\mathrm{unitary}"',mapsto , bend right , dashed ] & \rho_\mathrm{th}(\infty ) \\
\varrho_0=\pi_0 \arrow[ru,"\dot\varrho(t)=\mathcal{l}_\mathrm{th}(t)\varrho(t)"',"\mathcal{e}_\mathrm{d}^\prime",mapsto , bend right , dashed ] \end{tikzcd}.\ ] ] the energies @xmath50 ( along the original path ) and @xmath238 ( along the alternative path ) are those that appear on the r.h.s . of the entropic inequalities and .
the @xmath62-inequality for the situation where the invariant state is non - passive is given in eq . and may be recast in the form @xmath239uh(t)\big]{\mathrm{d}}t.\ ] ] owing to eq .
, this inequality is equivalent to @xmath240h(t)\big]{\mathrm{d}}t,\ ] ] where @xmath241 and @xmath242 is a thermal liouvillian with the same temperature and the same @xmath3 as in @xmath213 .
the problem of a state @xmath2 that evolves subject to a non - thermal bath has thus been reduced to the problem of a state @xmath77 that evolves according to a thermal bath .
this is the situation considered in the original ( solid ) path in eq . upon replacing @xmath2 by @xmath77 there .
this yields eq . , thus extending it to the case of a non - passive invariant state . in the general case that @xmath243 is not a thermal state , inequality
is replaced by @xmath244u\ln\pi_\mathrm{ss}(t)\big]{\mathrm{d}}t.\ ] ] one can then proceed as above , but @xmath242 is then replaced by a `` passive '' liouvillian @xmath245 whose invariant state is @xmath243 . the resulting inequality for @xmath48 [ the generalisation of eq . ,
i.e. , the counterpart of eq . ] then reads , @xmath246\ln\pi_\mathrm{ss}(t)\big]{\mathrm{d}}t,\ ] ] where @xmath247 .
note that the latter integral can not be identified with energy transfer .
equation holds also for the case of a passive invariant state @xmath248 , where now @xmath249 .
energy conservation [ eq . ] over a cycle yields @xmath250 where @xmath78 ( @xmath89 ) is the dissipative energy change of the wm due to its interaction with the cold thermal ( hot non - thermal ) bath .
as mentioned in the main text , we assume that the wm is thermal and hence passive prior to its interaction with the cold thermal bath .
the efficiency of the engine is defined as the ratio of the extracted work to the invested energy ( passive thermal energy and ergotropy ) @xmath251{\mathrm{d}}t$ ] provided by the non - thermal bath , yielding @xmath252 this expression holds for @xmath85 and @xmath253 ; see below a discussion of the opposite case . according to the reversibility condition ,
the requirement of vanishing entropy change over a cycle then yields @xmath254 where @xmath255 [ the integral in eq . ]
is the energy change during the interaction with the thermal bath along the dashed path in eq . .
consequently , according to this criterion the efficiency is bounded by @xmath256 this bound surpasses @xmath0 if @xmath257 , which , e.g. , is the case if the bath is `` over - squeezed '' : this means that , due to the excessive bath squeezing , the interaction with the thermal bath along the alternative path of eq
. decreases the energy while that with the non - thermal bath along the initial path increases it .
by contrast , our inequality yields the condition and hence the bound . if the hamiltonian is constant during the energising stroke , then @xmath258 , where @xmath259 is the ergotropy lost to the effective thermal bath in the second step of the alternative path in eq . .
a comparison of eq . with our bound eq .
for a constant hamiltonian then yields @xmath260 .
if @xmath261 ( @xmath262 ) , then also the cold bath provides energy , which has to be taken into account in the efficiency .
the latter now reads @xcite @xmath263 which can not be further restricted by any inequality for @xmath48 .
in fig . [ fig_efficiency_otto ] we have used the energies here @xmath265 ( @xmath266 ) is the oscillator frequency before ( after ) the compression stroke .
furthermore , we have defined @xmath267)-1]^{-1}$ ] and @xmath268 for @xmath269 , where @xmath180 denotes the squeezing parameter @xcite . additionally , we have used the actual efficiency @xcite @xmath270 70ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` # 1''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop _
( , , ) @noop _ _ , ed .
( , , ) @noop _ _ , ed .
( , , ) `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1002/andp.18652010702 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.2.262 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1007/bf01614224 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1007/bf01011769 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1088/0305 - 4470/12/5/007 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1126/science.1078955 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1209/epl / i2004 - 10101 - 2 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1038/nature06873 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1038/nature10123 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1038/ncomms3059 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1038/ncomms5185 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1073/pnas.1411728112 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1038/nphys3169 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevx.5.031044 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1038/ncomms11895 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1126/science.aad6320 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.3390/e15062100 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1016/bs.aamop.2015.07.002 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1088/1751 - 8113/49/14/143001 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1080/00107514.2016.1201896 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1209/0295 - 5075/88/50003 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.86.051105 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1209/0295 - 5075/106/20001 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.112.030602 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1038/srep12953 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1088/1367 - 2630/18/8/083012 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.93.052120 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.3390/e18070244 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1038/srep03949 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' \doibase 10.1023/b : opsy.0000047566.72717.71 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.98.240601 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1088/1367 - 2630/11/7/073008 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.107.140404 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.87.063845 [ * * , ( ) ] in link:\doibase 10.1142/9789814425193_0003 [ _ _ ] , ( , , ) p.
`` , '' link:\doibase 10.1209/0295 - 5075/107/50007 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.91.032119 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.93.062134 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , ) `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1063/1.523789 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1088/1367 - 2630/15/3/033022 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.87.042123 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1209/0295 - 5075/103/60005 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.111.240401 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1088/1367 - 2630/17/7/075015 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevx.5.041011 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.91.052133 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1088/1367 - 2630/18/11/113028 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.93.062328 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' https://arxiv.org/abs/1701.00699 [ ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.93.052119 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1038/ncomms4826 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ , ed .
( , , ) @noop _ _ , ed .
( , , ) `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1038/srep35568 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.42.487 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.87.012140 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.94.062109 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1080/09500348714550801 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.67.3665 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.50.5301 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1063/1.461951 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.70.046110 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.76.031105 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1038/srep06208 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.86.3463 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' https://arxiv.org/abs/1607.05262 [ ( ) ] | the efficiency of heat engines is limited by the carnot bound , attained when the engine cycle is reversible .
quantum engines fuelled by non - thermal ( e.g. , squeezed - thermal ) baths have been shown to surpass this bound . yet , their maximum efficiency can not be determined by the reversibility condition , which may yield an unachievable efficiency bound above @xmath0 .
this prompts the question : what does really limit the efficiency ? we identify the fraction of the exchanged energy between a quantum system and a bath that necessarily causes an entropy change and derive a new inequality for the latter .
this formulation reveals a universal efficiency bound for quantum engines which is invariably attained for the least dissipation over the engine cycle but does not imply reversibility , unless the baths are thermal .
this bound thus can not be solely deduced from the laws of thermodynamics .
we illustrate these results for the practically - relevant carnot- and otto cycles energised by non - thermal baths , which are both shown to be restricted by our new efficiency bound . |
through their specific properties , transition metal borides became attractive both from scientific and technical point of view .
for instance , yb@xmath1 , like some other rare - earth and actinide hexaborides , shows superconductivity below 7.1 k @xcite and has been considered as a possible candidate for high - temperature thermoelectric materials @xcite .
detailed knowledge of the electronic structure of a material is a key ingredient for an in - depth understanding of many of its macroscopic features .
a combination of experimental methods as well as computations on an _ ab - initio _ level has proved very efficient , in particular relating electronic structure calculations to results of nuclear magnetic resonance ( nmr ) technique .
the value of the electric field gradient ( efg ) , measured by nmr quadrupole interaction , is directly determined by the charge distribution around the nucleus .
thus , theoretical efg studies based on the electronic structure are important in order to give a reliable interpretation of the experimental data .
one of the strengths of nmr measurements is that , being a microscopic tool , they are sensitive to the symmetry of the crystallographic sites and in particular to the electron density in the vicinity of the nucleus . in a recent study ,
this sensitivity was used to provide criteria for the determination of crystal structures that are still under debate @xcite . in the present paper ,
we report the efg values for yb@xmath1 and yb@xmath0 and the determination of the knight shifts by using the magic - angle spinning ( mas ) technique .
the experimental efgs are compared and interpreted with the theoretical ones obtained from _ ab - initio _ calculations .
the structure of cubic yb@xmath1 ( space group @xmath16 , no .
221 ) consists of a simple cubic lattice of corner - connected b@xmath1 octahedra with y atoms filling the cubic holes . in this and other borides with the same structure the b
b distance between neighbouring octahedra is slightly shorter than within the octahedron ( for yb@xmath1 : 1.64 compared to 1.75 ) . in agreement with this crystallographic structure
there is only a single efg value . a previous @xmath2b nmr study for yb@xmath1 @xcite reported the spin - lattice relaxation time and the spectrum .
however , the authors were unable to determine the efg because of the widely broadened satellite lines and the weak nmr signal used in their instrumentation . on the other hand , tetragonal yb@xmath0 ( space group @xmath17 , no .
127 ) has a quasilayer structure with alternating sheets of y atoms and b@xmath1 octahedra linked together laterally by b@xmath18 units . in this structure five different nearest - neighbour b
b distances between 1.64 and 1.81 are observed . in yb@xmath0
the boron atoms are situated in three different crystallographic positions with different efgs for each of them , as will be demonstrated in the present paper .
for confirmation of the validity of the available experimental lattice parameters and the atomic positions , calculations have been performed using the vienna _ ab - initio _ simulation package ( vasp ) @xcite . by this method the kohn
sham equations of density - functional theory @xcite with periodic boundary conditions are solved within a plane - wave basis set with electron ion interactions described by the projector augmented wave ( paw ) method @xcite . for exchange and correlation the general gradient approximation ( gga )
@xcite was applied .
the structural parameters were calculated by atomic forces and stress - tensor minimization . for each of the
two borides two different energy cutoffs for the plane - wave basis were used ( 400 ev and a cutoff higher by at least a factor of 2 ) , which lead to practically the same results , so that adequate convergence is ensured .
the experimental and calculated structural parameters for yb@xmath0 and yb@xmath1 are given in tables 1 and 2 , respectively .
for cubic yb@xmath1 , where the lattice parameter @xmath19 and the positional parameter of the b atom are the only free parameters , the minimum - energy structure was also found by the full - potential linearized augmented plane - wave ( flapw ) method within the lda approximation which is described in the next section .
the structural parameters optimized by vasp have been used to calculate the efgs for yb@xmath1 and yb@xmath0 .
.experimental and calculated structural parameters for yb@xmath0 adopting the thb@xmath0 structure ( @xmath17 , no .
the lattice parameters are in . [ cols= " < , < , <
, < , < " , ] [ table6 ] the knight shifts , @xmath20 , measured for both compounds , are found to be very small , i. e. , 0.6 ppm and @xmath21 ppm for yb@xmath1 and yb@xmath0 , respectively .
the accuracy of the @xmath20 values were estimated to be @xmath22 ppm , where the uncertainty results from an incomplete reduction of the strong dipolar interaction in the mas experiment , mainly between the boron nuclei .
these values of @xmath20 are much smaller than those observed in mgb@xmath18 , where @xmath23 ppm @xcite and in yni@xmath18b@xmath18c , where @xmath24 ppm @xcite ( both values are for room temperature ) .
this comparison indicates that the values for the densities of states ( dos ) at the fermi level for the boron sites are much lower than those in the borides mentioned above .
especially the lack of @xmath25-type dos , which is usually the contribution with the largest hyperfine field , reduces significantly the shifts .
indeed , the @xmath25-type dos per boron atom is , in yb@xmath1 @xcite , over 20 times smaller than in mgb@xmath18 @xcite .
also the @xmath26-type dos per b atom is significantly smaller in yb@xmath1 compared to mgb@xmath18 .
these data are compatible with the present electronic band structure calculations ( see next section ) which show that @xmath25- and @xmath26-type boron states are located mainly below the fermi energy and thus the contribution to the dos at the @xmath27 is small .
the first theoretical investigation of metal borides of general formula @xmath28b@xmath1 has been performed fifty years ago by longuet - higgins and roberts @xcite using the tight - binding approximation . according to these authors the octahedral arrangement of the b atoms leads to ten bonding states which , when filled with the 18 b @xmath25 and @xmath26 plus two metal valence electrons , will correspond to an insulator .
a metal will be obtained when the hexaboride of a trivalent metal is considered instead of a divalent metal . in their paper
the states below the fermi level are not only characterized in terms of their bonding or antibonding properties but also as regards their participation in bonds within a single b@xmath1 octahedron or between neighbouring octahedra .
later @xcite the higher lying valence and conduction bands of yb@xmath1 have been calculated by a discrete variational method in a non - selfconsistent fashion .
recent electronic - structure calculations for yb@xmath1 can be found in ref .
@xcite ( dos only ) and in ref .
@xcite where also the band structure is given . for yb@xmath0
only the dos has been published so far @xcite . in both references , however , the lowest b @xmath29 band is not shown although it is of crucial importance for the chemical bonding in both borides as will be argued below . in the case of yb@xmath1 shein
@xcite designate it erroneously as `` quasi - core b @xmath29 band '' obviously mainly because it is a low - lying band . in fig .
2 the band structures for yb@xmath0 and yb@xmath1 are presented .
the dos curves for yb@xmath0 and yb@xmath1 are given in fig . 3 together with the local partial dos components .
for both borides the states at energies of ca .
@xmath30 ev are dominated by b @xmath29 character with a considerable amount of b @xmath31 character .
such states appear for all b atoms constituting the b@xmath1 octahedra , but not for b(2 ) , which belongs to the b@xmath18 unit of which each b atom is linked to two different octahedra . in this energy range
hybride orbitals are formed which lead to strong covalent @xmath32 bonds between the boron atoms within a b@xmath1 unit which can be seen from the corresponding electron densities shown in fig .
after an energy gap of about 3.7 ev a complex of bands appears in both compounds where in the lower energy range b @xmath25 states prevail with an admixture of b @xmath26 states except for the b(2 ) atoms .
these states correspond mainly to bonds between different b@xmath1 octahedra and @xmath25@xmath25 @xmath32 bonds in the b@xmath18 units of yb@xmath0 . at higher energies below the fermi level
b @xmath26 states are predominant apart from a relatively small b @xmath25 and a considerable y @xmath33 contribution .
also in this energy range the interoctahedral bonds are dominant except for the region very near the fermi level in yb@xmath1 where the intraoctahedral b
b bonds again become important . in yb@xmath1 the y @xmath33 states
have mostly @xmath34 character which can be seen from the valence electron densities in fig . 5 .
this figure also shows that this is not the case for yb@xmath0 although near the fermi level @xmath34-like character , i. e. , @xmath35 character , is predominant .
our results for yb@xmath1 are in very good agreement with the detailed semiempirical tight - binding investigation by longuett - higgins and roberts @xcite . in order to make the comparison we performed crystal - field splittings for the b @xmath26 ( and y @xmath33 )
we thus obtained the distinction between their radial ( @xmath36 ) and tangential orbitals ( @xmath37 ) . together with electron - density plots for certain energy ranges , the regions for the different site orbitals for the b@xmath1 octahedron could be identified .
we obtained the following order ( increasing energy ) : @xmath38 ( band at ca .
@xmath30 ev ) , @xmath39 , @xmath40 , @xmath41 , and @xmath42 .
( the nomenclature is taken from ref .
@xcite and refers to the irreducible representations for the whole octahedron . ) in fig .
6 the valence electron densities in the ( 001 ) plane through the b atoms in yb@xmath0 and yb@xmath1 is displayed .
apart from the structural differences between both borides ( irregular heptagonal arrangement of the b atoms outside the octahedra in yb@xmath0 compared to an almost regular octagon in yb@xmath1 ) the slightly higher valence electron densities between the b atoms outside the octahedra in both compounds can be seen as well as the deep density minima which designate the much weaker covalent y
y bonds perpendicular to the ( 001 ) plane .
for yb@xmath0 and yb@xmath1 we have performed electric - field gradient and knight shift measurements for the b sites .
the aim of the paper has been a comparison of the nmr results and the available structural data with the results of accurate first - principles calculations .
we have therefore optimized the structures by atomic forces and stress - tensor minimization . for the optimized structures efg calculations have been performed .
perfect agreement was found between the experimental and calculated structural parameters and electric - field gradients thus confirming the structure models available in the literature .
based on calculated total and local partial dos as well as electron - density plots , we analyse the bonding situation in both compounds and conclude that the lowest valence bands are of particular importance for the stabilty of both yttrium borides . the authors would like to thank p. vajda for stimulating discussions and the austrian science foundation ( project no . ) for financial support .
the calculations were performed on the schrdinger ii linux cluster of the vienna university computer centre .
99 b. t. matthias , t. h. geballe , k. andres , e. corenzwit , g. w. hull , j. p. maita , science 159 ( 1968 ) 530 .
y. imai , m. mukaida , m. ueda , a. watanabe , intermetallics 9 ( 2001 ) 721 .
o. j. oga , w. wolf , p. herzig , a. h. vuorimki , e. e. ylinen , p. vajda , phys .
b 64 ( 2001 ) 214110 .
w. wolf and p. herzig , phys . rev .
b 66 ( 2002 ) 224112 .
w. wolf and p. herzig , j. alloys comp . 356357 ( 2003 ) 73 .
t. ohno , y. kishimoto , t. kanashiro , s. kunii , czech . j. phys .
46 ( 1996 ) suppl .
g. kresse , j. furthmller , phys .
b 54 ( 1996 ) 11169 . g. kresse , j. furthmller , comput . mater . sci . 6 ( 1996 ) 15 .
p. hohenberg , w. kohn , phys .
136 ( 1964 ) b 864 .
w. kohn , l. j. sham , phys . rev .
140 ( 1965 ) a 1133 .
p. e. blchl , phys .
b 50 ( 1994 ) 17953 .
g. kresse , d. joubert , phys .
b 59 ( 1998 ) 1758 .
j. p. perdew , j. a. chevary , s. h. vosko , k. a. jackson , m. r. pederson , d. j. singh , c. fiolhais , phys .
b 46 ( 1992 ) 6671 .
a. guette , m. vlasse , j. etourneau , r. naslain , c. r. acad .
paris , ser .
c 291 ( 1980 ) 145 .
h. p. klesnar , p. rogl , high temp .- high press . 22
( 1990 ) 453 .
n. n. zhuravlev , i. a. belousova , r. m. manelis , n. a. belousova , sov .
crystallogr . 15
( 1971 ) 723 [ kristallografiya 15 ( 1970 ) 836 ] .
f. binder , radex - rdsch .
1977 , 52 .
m. korsukova , proc .
boron , borides , and related compounds , tsukuba , 1993 , jjap series 10 ( 1994 ) 15 .
y. takahashi , k. ohshima , f. p. okamura , s. otani , t. tanaka , j. phys .
68 ( 1999 ) 2304 . o. k. andersen , phys . rev .
b 12 ( 1975 ) 3060 .
d. d. koelling , g. o. arbman , j. phys .
f : metal phys . 5 ( 1975 ) 2041 .
e. wimmer , h. krakauer , m. weinert , a. j. freeman , phys .
b 24 ( 1981 ) 864 . h. j. f. jansen , a. j. freeman , phys . rev .
b 30 ( 1984 ) 561 . b. i. min , t. oguchi , h. j. f. jansen , a. j. freeman , j. magn .
magn . mat .
5457 ( 1986 ) 1091 .
l. hedin , b. i. lundqvist , j. phys .
c : solid st . phys . 4 ( 1971 ) 2064 .
l. hedin , s. lundqvist , j. phys .
( paris ) 33 ( 1972 ) c3 - 73 .
p. herzig , theoret .
67 ( 1985 ) 323 .
p. blaha , k. schwarz , p. herzig , phys .
54 ( 1985 ) 1192 .
p. blaha , k. schwarz , p. h. dederichs , phys .
b 37 ( 1988 ) 2792 .
d. massiot , f. fayon , m. capron , i. king , s. le calve , b. alonso , j .- o .
durand , b. bujoli , z. gan , g.hoatson , magn .
40 ( 2002 ) 70 .
h. nth , b. wrackmeyer , in _
nmr basic principles and progress _ , vol . 14 , edited by p. diehl , e. fluck , r. kosfeld , ( springer , 1978 ) , p. 1 .
d. sundholm , j. olsen , j. chem .
94 ( 1991 ) 5051 .
p. pyykk , z. naturforsch .
47a ( 1992 ) 189 . k. schwarz , h. ripplinger , p. blaha , z. naturforsch .
51a ( 1996 ) 527 .
a. p. gerashenko , k. n. mikhalev , s. v. verkhovskii , a. e. karkin , b. n. goshchitskii , phys .
b 65 ( 2002 ) 132506 .
b. j. suh , f. borsa , d. r. torgeson , b. k. cho , p. c. canfield , d. c. johnston , j. y. rhee , b. n. harmon , phys .
b 54 ( 1996 ) 15341 .
i. r. shein , s. v. okatov , n. i. medvedeva , a. l. ivanovskii , cond - mat/0202015 ( 2002 ) .
h. c. longuet - higgins , m. de v. roberts , proc .
london 224 ( 1954 ) 336 .
p. f. walch , d. e. ellis , f. m. mueller , phys .
b 15 ( 1977 ) 1859 . | two compounds , tetragonal yb@xmath0 and cubic yb@xmath1 , have been investigated by electric - field gradient ( efg ) and knight shift measurements at the boron sites using the @xmath2b nuclear magnetic resonance ( nmr ) technique and by performing first - principles calculations . in yb@xmath1 @xmath2b ( @xmath3 )
nmr spectra reveal patterns typical for an axially symmetric field gradient with a quadrupole coupling frequency of @xmath4 khz . in the second boride ( yb@xmath0 ) three different efgs were observed corresponding to the three inequivalent crystallographic sites for the boron atoms ( @xmath5 , @xmath6 , and @xmath7 ) .
they correspond to : @xmath8 khz with an asymmetry parameter @xmath9 , @xmath10 khz , @xmath11 , and @xmath12 khz , @xmath13 .
the knight shifts measured by magic - angle spinning ( mas ) nmr at room temperature are very small being @xmath14 ppm and @xmath15 ppm for yb@xmath0 and yb@xmath1 , respectively . for the theoretical calculations structure optimizations were performed as a first step . for the obtained structural parameters
the efgs were computed within the local - density approximation .
very satisfactory agreement between experimental and theoretical results is obtained both for the structural parameters and the b efgs thus confirming the underlying structural models .
in addition to the efgs , band structures , densities of states , and valence - electron densities are presented and the bonding situation in the two yttrium borides is discussed .
the band - structure results are compatible with the very low values for the knight shifts mentioned above .
metal borides ; electronic band structure ; electric field gradient ; chemical bonding ; nmr |
electron energy loss spectroscopy ( eels ) in the transmission electron microscope ( tem ) is a well - established experimental technique to study the electronic structure of materials .
@xcite energy loss is directly linked to the imaginary part of the inverse dielectric function , and therefore many other properties of interest can be extracted from these measurements . combined with the imaging capabilities of the microscope , as well as optical and x - ray emission spectroscopies that can be performed in the tem ,
eels is an excellent tool for materials characterization . in the past decades
, the tem has experienced an impressive improvement in its performance .
modern microscopes equipped with field - emission guns and monochromators routinely achieve an energy resolution of 0.5 ev or even 0.1 ev , @xcite while the resolution in the momentum transfer is better than 0.1 @xmath1 .
equally strikingly , in scanning tems with aberration correction units the electron beam can attain diameters of sub - ngstrom dimensions .
this provides unprecedented opportunities to study electronic structure at the atomic scale .
@xcite as a first approximation , a spatially - resolved electron energy loss spectrum can be viewed as the weighted convolution of momentum - dependent energy loss spectra .
thus , the analysis of spatially - resolved spectroscopic information of complex inhomogeneous materials requires the understanding of momentum - resolved electron energy loss spectra of its constituents . since theoretical tools to accurately calculate momentum - dependent dielectric functions
have also matured , @xcite it is very timely to pose an important question : how do results of state - of - the - art theoretical spectroscopy compare to measurements performed in modern tems ? in this work ,
we address this question taking three bulk noble metals , cu , ag , and au , as model systems .
we focus on low ( valence ) energy losses .
the study of optical and dielectric properties of bulk metals is a mature field in fundamental research , and has been such for quite some time .
@xcite to illustrate this , it suffices to say that the first successful theoretical analysis of optical properties of simple metals at the microscopic level , the celebrated drude model , precedes the formulation of quantum mechanics by almost three decades .
transition metals with fully or partially occupied @xmath2 states are certainly more complex than simple metals , @xcite but their optical properties have been studied extensively also for decades , both experimentally and theoretically .
@xcite it may thus seem that no aspect concerning valence excitations is left unknown in these metals .
while to a certain extent this is certainly true for dielectric properties up to 10 ev ( visible , near , mid , and far ultraviolet ) , a lot less is known about excitations with energies of several tenths ( up to @xmath3100 ) of ev ( extreme ultraviolet ) .
lying between the optical range and shallow semi - core and core edges , these excitations are , in some sense , no - man s land .
surprisingly , though being very important in the measurements of spatially - resolved electronic response , the momentum dependence of the electron energy - loss spectra in this energy range is little understood .
therefore , the main objective of the present work is the study of momentum - dependent eels spectra of cu , ag , and au for energies higher than 10 ev .
this paper is organized as follows . in section
[ theory ] the methodology to calculate response functions as well as loss functions and dynamic structure factors is outlined .
the experimental setup and the post - processing of raw experimental data is described in section [ expt ] .
loss functions for small momentum transfers are analyzed and compared to experimental results in section [ loss - q - zero ] .
momentum - dependent loss functions are presented and analyzed in section [ loss - q ] .
in particular , the dispersion of the low - energy plasmon in ag is computed and compared with experimental data . in section [ conclusions ] , the main results are summarized and the impact of our findings is discussed .
in the case of a periodic solid , the double - differential scattering cross section per unit volume for momentum transfer @xmath4 and electron energy loss @xmath5 is given by ( in atomic units ) : @xcite @xmath6 here @xmath7 is the fourier - transform of the coulomb interaction , @xmath8 is the dynamic structure factor ( per unit volume ) , @xmath9 is the relativistic factor for incident electrons , @xmath10 and @xmath11 are the initial and the final electron momenta ( @xmath12 ) .
@xmath8 describes quantum - mechanical electron density fluctuations of the physical system @xcite and is directly related to the macroscopic density response function @xmath13 : @xmath14 by definition , @xmath13 determines the macroscopic dielectric function via : @xmath15 and thus the double differential scattering cross section in eq .
( [ ddscs - eels ] ) can be also expressed as : @xmath16 the imaginary part of the inverse dielectric function @xmath17 is a dimensionless quantity and is traditionally called the loss function . the dynamic structure factor is also an important quantity in inelastic x - ray scattering spectroscopy ( ixs ) . in ixs ,
the double - differential scattering cross - section is ( in atomic units ) : @xcite @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the fine structure constant , @xmath20 and @xmath21 are polarizations of the incident and the scattered wave . in the current paper
, we will use the terms dynamic structure factor and momentum - dependent loss function interchangeably .
they are related through @xmath22 and the relative merits preferring one over the other depend on the context .
for example , the dynamic structure factor is more convenient when discussing x - ray scattering , since the double - differential scattering cross section in ixs is directly proportional to @xmath8 . at variance
, the loss function is sometimes more convenient when discussing eels , even though the expression for the double - differential scattering cross section of electrons has an additional prefactor @xmath23 . according to eq .
( [ dsf ] ) , the main quantity that needs to be calculated is the macroscopic density - response function @xmath13 .
the macroscopic quantity is related to its microscopic counterpart @xmath24 via @xcite @xmath25 here @xmath26 is the reciprocal lattice vector , and @xmath27 , so that @xmath28 is confined to the first brillouin zone . within the linear - response formulation of time - dependent density functional theory ( tddft ) ,
@xcite the microscopic density - response function @xmath29 of the interacting many - electron system is related to the density - response function @xmath30 of the corresponding non - interacting kohn - sham system through the dyson equation , which is , symbolically : @xmath31 @xmath32 is the exchange - correlation kernel that accounts for all many - body effects , and @xmath30 is given as @xmath33 here , @xmath34 , @xmath35 , @xmath36 are single - particle wavefunctions , their eigenvalues , and occupation numbers , respectively ; indices @xmath37 and @xmath38 span all bands , so both so - called resonant and non - resonant terms are included in this approach ; @xmath39 is the volume of the unit cell . while the approach is formally exact , approximations are needed in practice .
@xcite in this work , we use two different simple approximations . setting @xmath32 to 0 yields the random - phase approximation ( rpa ) , in which only the classical coulomb field of the induced charge density is accounted for when calculating @xmath29 .
the second approximation is the adiabatic local density approximation ( alda or tdlda ) , in which @xmath32 is given by @xcite @xmath40 the tdlda kernel is local in space and time .
thus , its fourier transform in time is frequency - independent , and the transform in real space , @xmath41 , depends only on @xmath28 and @xmath42 .
more complicated kernels , such as those that attempt to include excitonic effects , are not used in this work as we are dealing with metals only . an important concept in studying response functions
is that of crystal local fields . taking the rpa as an example , we obtain from eq .
( [ dyson ] ) : @xmath43
the calculation of @xmath29 therefore involves the inversion of the matrix @xmath44 for each value of @xmath28 and @xmath5 .
calculations are numerically involved as one needs to include a sufficient set of reciprocal lattice vectors for the representation of microscopic quantities , so that the final result is converged .
neglecting all off - diagonal elements , or crystal local fields , is equivalent to dealing with scalar functions rather than matrices .
this is equivalent to the assumption that the screening charge is independent of the position of the test charge inside the unit cell .
the comparison of response functions calculated with or without the inclusion of local fields shows to what extent this assumption is realistic in a given material . in this work ,
the response functions have been determined via all - electron full - potential calculations based on the linearized augmented plane - wave ( fp - lapw ) method , as implemented in the exciting code .
@xcite for all metals , the experimental lattice constants have been used .
ground - state electron densities , as well as kohn - sham orbitals and eigenvalues have been calculated with the pbe exchange - correlation functional@xcite ( below just referred to as the generalized - gradient approximation , gga ) .
the product of the muffin - tin radius and the largest @xmath26 vector in the interstitial region , @xmath45 , was set to 8.0 .
an off - center 20@xmath4620@xmath4620 k - point mesh has been used for the brillouin zone sampling in most cases .
for very large momentum transfers we have found it necessary to increase the mesh to 25@xmath4625@xmath4625 , while for an accurate determination of the plasmon dispersion in ag a 30@xmath4630@xmath4630 grid has been employed . to account for local - field effects , at least three shells of @xmath26 vectors ( @xmath47 27 vectors ) have been used .
the summation in eq .
( [ chi_0 ] ) has been performed with a finite @xmath48 , in most cases 0.1 ev .
thin metallic films have been produced on freshly cleaved nacl substrates .
cu and ag films have been prepared by sputtering , while the au film has been produced by evaporation .
this led to poly - crystalline samples with grain sizes of 10 - 50 nm and only very little texturing .
the film thickness @xmath2 was about 55 nm for cu , 50 nm for ag , and 35 nm for au .
the films have been produced immediately before being transferred to the microscope to avoid oxidation .
eels analysis has shown no detectable oxygen contamination .
eels data for cu and au were acquired on a fei tecnai f20 tem equipped with a field - emission gun and a post column gatan imaging filter .
the instrumental resolution was about 0.7 ev measured as the fwhm of the zero - loss peak without the specimen .
the spectra were acquired in the diffraction mode , using a large selected area aperture to integrate over many crystal orientations .
the momentum transfer was selected by varying the spectrometer s entrance aperture and camera length and moving the diffraction pattern projected on the spectrometer entrance aperture with the projective deflection coils . for cu ,
the same camera length and spectrometer entrance aperture was used over the whole acquisition range , while for au the collection angle was increased when moving away from the central spot , allowing for a better signal at the expense of a lower angular resolution .
the collection semi - angle was 0.1 mrad for cu and varied from 0.05 to 0.86 mrad for au .
the spectra where acquired up to about 2/3 of the distance to the first diffraction ring , since for larger angles the total intensity started rising again , an indication that the intensity coming from the first diffraction ring was no longer negligible . after the acquisition , the spectra where corrected for multiple scattering following the procedure by batson and silcox .
@xcite a spectrum in the image mode needed for this procedure was acquired using a large collection semi - angle of 25 mrad .
this spectrum was subtracted from each of the angular resolved spectra after scaling the intensities of the zero - loss peaks .
measurements for ag have been performed with a jeol 2200 fs tem , equipped with a shottky field - emission gun , an in - column omega - filter , and a 2k@xmath462k gatan ultrascan ccd camera .
the instrumental resolution was 0.8 ev .
the spectrum was taken in the image mode with a large selection area aperture .
for small or vanishing momentum transfers and for energies @xmath4915 ev , loss functions of cu , ag , and au have been extensively analyzed before.@xcite common features and distinctions for all three metals are rather well understood . in particular ,
the origin of the 3.8 ev plasmon peak in ag is known , @xcite and reasons why a similar excitation does not develop in cu and is severely damped in au , have been formulated .
@xcite for the sake of consistency we provide a short review of low - energy dielectric properties of all three metals in the supplemental material.@xcite we discuss the importance of the band structure in the theoretical description of those properties , complementing the analysis of cazalilla _ et al . _
@xcite from a semi - classical perspective . for higher energies ( @xmath50 10 ev ) , the features in the loss functions have been to some extent addressed for cu in ref . [ ] , ag in ref .
[ ] , and au in ref . [ ] . , title="fig:",width=283 ]
+ the calculated loss functions are compared to the experimental data of werner _ et al .
_ @xcite in fig .
[ q - zero - fig ] .
the experimental losss functions were obtained from reflection eels ( disks ) using an algorithm to separate surface and bulk contributions and to take into account multiple scattering.@xcite the calculations are all based on the gga band structure but use three different approximations to determine response functions : rpa calculations taking local - field effects into account ( `` gga - rpa , with lfe '' , black solid lines and shaded areas ) , tdlda calculations with local - field effects ( `` gga - tdlda , with lfe '' , solid purple lines ) , and rpa calculations without local field effects ( `` gga - rpa , w / o lfe '' , dashed lines ) .
calculations without local field effects reproduce earlier results @xcite in which the interband contribution was evaluated strictly for @xmath51 , and the intra - band contribution had the analytic drude form with appropriate parameters . the most important conclusion that can be readily drawn from fig . [ q - zero - fig ]
is that the two most accurate theoretical treatments ( gga - rpa with lfe and gga - tlda with lfe ) overall provide an excellent desription of loss functions . more specifically : ( i ) in agreement with the established knowledge of low - energy optical properties of these three metals,@xcite only in ag does a well - defined low - energy plasmon ( peak ( 1 ) ) develops , while it is severely suppressed in cu and au .
this is explained in more detail in ref .
@xcite ( ii ) loss functions of all three metals are characterized by a broad structure with several well - defined peaks ; the origin of the peaks will be discussed in section [ peaks ] .
( iii ) in the case of ag and au , local field effects are essential for energies @xmath50 40 ev .
only the inclusion of these effects brings the calculated loss functions in agreement with experiment . at variance ,
local - field effects are much less pronounced for cu .
this surprising asymmetry between metals with very similar nominal electron configurations is explained in section [ lfe ] and ref .
@xcite ( iv ) the effect of including a finite exchange - correlation kernel is approximately an order of magnitude smaller than that of the local fields .
consequently , it is almost completely irrelevant for cu .
this will be discussed in more detail in section [ lfe ] .
the origin of the peaks in the loss function below 10 ev has been analyzed before,@xcite and reviewed in ref .
@xcite . in short , in cu peaks ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) in cu are characterized by the a small real part of the dielectric function @xmath52 , and have to be classified as plasmon resonances .
these resonances are severely damped due to a significant value of the imaginary part of the dielectric function @xmath53 .
similar reasoning applies to peak ( 2 ) of ag and peak ( 1 ) of au .
@xcite ar variance , peak ( 1 ) of ag is a proper plasmon peak that originates from drude - type oscillations in the @xmath54 band renormalized by interband transitions from the 4@xmath2 state to the states above the fermi energy.@xcite we note in passing that all these peaks have been observed experimentally in numerous occasions .
for example , peak ( 2 ) in ag has been used to image ag nanoparticles .
@xcite the origin of higher - energy peaks in the loss functions of cu , ag , and au can be understood in terms of a system of classical drude - lindhard oscillators.@xcite the corresponding model is presented in more detail in ref .
@xcite . in short
, the analysis shows that for each peak in @xmath53 there is an associated peak at slightly larger energies in the loss function , and the difference between the two frequencies decreases for higher - lying peaks .
furthermore , the absolute value of the peak in the loss function is inversely proportional to the background value of @xmath52 at the peak position .
( solid line ) , @xmath53 ( dashed line ) , and loss function ( shaded ares ) of cu , ag , and au in the energy range 11 - 60 ev .
most important peaks due to excitations of valence electrons are marked in numbers .
n@xmath55 and o@xmath55 edges of ag and au are also shown.,width=317 ] indeed , as shown in fig .
[ epsilon - large ] , these trends hold for peaks ( 3 ) and ( 4 ) of cu , peaks ( 3)-(7 ) of ag , and peaks ( 2)-(7 ) of au .
this indicates that these excitations originate mainly from interband transitions and also implies that the drude plasmon does not play a significant role at such energies .
a peak at @xmath5656 ev in the loss function of ag ( fig .
[ epsilon - large ] ) corresponds to the n@xmath55 core edge ( excitations from 4@xmath57 bands ) , the experimental value being @xmath5662 ev .
this shows that the 4@xmath57 states are significantly under - bound in gga , even more so than 4@xmath2 states .
similarly , a peak at @xmath58 ev in the loss function of au corresponds to the o@xmath55 edge ( excitations from 5@xmath57 bands ) , while the m@xmath55 edge in cu appears above 60 ev . since our main focus is on excitations of valence electrons , however , we will neglect core excitations in subsequent discussions .
the conclusion that eminent features in the loss function for energies @xmath50 10 ev are caused by interband transitions from @xmath2 states is probably expected and not surprising , and has been already suggested in ref . [ ] for cu .
the existence of these features on top of a broad background indicates that even at energies as high as 50 - 60 ev above the fermi level ( i.e. , more than 45 ev above the vacuum level ) electrons still feel the influence of the underlying atomic cores .
indeed , for optical transitions from @xmath2 states to free - electron levels high above the fermi energy one would not expect any sharp features in the loss function .
this finding is not new , however .
in fact , already three decades ago speier _ et al . _
performed bremsstrahlung isochromate spectroscopy ( bis ) measurements for cu and ag.@xcite bis is a variant of the inverse photoemission spectroscopy and measures the unoccupied density of states .
_ found that for energies @xmath50 10 ev the unoccupied dos for cu and ag show several well pronounced peaks .
in fact , there is a very nice correlation between peaks in the bis spectra and peaks in the eel spectra . in the case of ag , for example , for each of the peaks ( 3)-(7 ) in the eel spectrum there is a corresponding peak in the bis spectrum at about 4 ev lower energies .
this nice correspondence underpins the interpretation that pronounced features in the loss functions arise because of interband transitions from occupied @xmath2 states to a part in the unoccupied continuum with a larger density of states .
this conclusions is especially important for photo - electron spectroscopies , in which excited photo electrons of energies comparable to these ones are often described by plane waves .
the loss function ( eq . ) as measured in eels or ixs , naturally contains lfes , their strength , however , not being experimentally accessible .
while the occurence of local - field effects in inhomogeneous solids has been known for decades @xcite , their importance varies from solid to solid . from a theoretical perspective one
can get insight by considering the dielectric response of materials with and without these effects . where local fields are important both
it has been demonstrated that the inclusion of lfes is very important for excitations from core @xcite and semi - core @xcite levels to the lowest unoccupied states .
clearly , localized atomic - like states are far from the homogeneous electron gas model for which lfes vanish .
sturm and oliveira@xcite have shown , however , that these effects also influence collective excitations in simple metals .
these excitations couple to short wave - length ( large @xmath59 ) charge fluctuations via lfes and this significantly affects the width and the dispersion of the resulting plasmon for small @xmath59 .
it was subsequently discovered that also the opposite effect can be observed : collective excitations that occur for small @xmath59 affect electron - hole excitations that occur at very large @xmath59 ( beyond the first brillouin zone).@xcite this interaction is small in si , where a plasmon fano antiresonance forms,@xcite while in mgb@xmath60 @xcite and compressed li @xcite the interaction is much stronger and leads to replicas of the plasmon at higher brillouin zones . here , we discuss lfe for cu , ag , and au for small @xmath59 .
lfe at finite @xmath59 are analyzed in section [ lfe2 ] .
the results in fig .
[ q - zero - fig ] show that for small @xmath59 the inclusion of local - field effects does not lead to notable differences for energies @xmath49 10 ev , but these effects are very pronounced at larger energies , especially for ag and au .
since at larger energies , loss functions correspond to transitions from occupied @xmath2 states to planewave - like unoccupied states high above the fermi level , lfes reflect the rather localized nature of the @xmath2 orbitals
. however , this conclusion seems to contradict the result that , between 10 and 60 ev , lfes are substantially smaller in cu than in ag and au .
indeed , cu 3@xmath2 are more localized than ag 4@xmath2 or au 5@xmath2 states , and one would naturally expect lfes effects to reflect this trend . however , as shown in ref .
@xcite , paradoxically , it is _ because _ of a larger degree of localization of cu 3@xmath2 that lfes are relatively small in the energy range studied .
indeed , we find that lfes indirectly probe the density of @xmath2 states in reciprocal space .
this density is significantly more spread out for cu than for ag and au . as a result ,
it is being probed by planewave - like unoccupied states at higher energies .
this is confirmed by our calculations .
however , excitations from semi - core cu 3@xmath57 states start to overlap with excitations from 3@xmath2 states at the same energies .
the effect of local fields on momentum - dependent loss functions is discussed in section [ lfe2 ] .
it is clear from eqs . and that in the optical limit , i.e. , @xmath61 and @xmath62 , the tdlda kernel does not change the dielectric functions when local field effects are neglected . indeed , in this case @xmath63\chi^0_{00}(\mathbf{q,\omega}))$ ] . since @xmath64 is finite for all @xmath26 , including @xmath61 , and @xmath65 , the effect of the xc kernel is vanishing for small @xmath59
thus , the choice of the tdlda kernel is important only when lfes are included . as seen in fig .
[ q - zero - fig ] , the effect of the tdlda kernel on the loss function is in general small , i.e. , much smaller than that of local fields .
this finding is in line with previous studies .
@xcite as a result , the effect is totally negligible for cu for the energies studied here .
@xmath66 and @xmath67 are indicated , where @xmath68 is the lattice constant.,title="fig:",width=321 ]
the calculated momentum - dependent loss functions for all three metals are shown in fig .
[ loss - q - fig ] .
the momentum transfer is along the [ 111 ] direction , and varies between 0.030 and 2.262 @xmath1 for cu , 0.026 and 1.849 @xmath1 for ag , and 0.027 and 1.921 @xmath1 for au .
the upper limits correspond to momenta @xmath69 , where @xmath68 is the lattice constant .
the special points @xmath70 and @xmath67 are indicated in fig .
[ loss - q - fig ] . despite several individual features ,
most of the trends are the same for all three metals .
while the loss functions for small momentum transfers are characterized by several well - pronounced peaks , as discussed above , their relative intensity tends to decrease with increasing momentum transfer .
qualitatively , this can be understood by analyzing the density - response function of non - interacting electrons @xmath30 ( eq . ) . for small @xmath28 , @xmath71 , and thus
only dipole - allowed transitions contribute , provided local field effects are neglected .
hence , the structure of the loss function is determined mainly by transitions from occupied @xmath2 to unoccupied states with @xmath57 and @xmath72 character . for
larger @xmath59 , other transitions set in that , on average , smear out the peaks .
this can also be seen by comparing the loss function for small @xmath59 ( mainly dipole - allowed transitions ) with the weighted joint density of states for optical transitions , defined as @xmath73 ( not shown ) .
it does not discriminate between states of different symmetry .
while all the peaks apparent in the loss function can be identified in the joint density of states , these are much less pronounced in the latter . another important conclusion that can be drawn from fig .
[ loss - q - fig ] is that peaks caused by interband transitions show little dispersion as @xmath59 increases .
even though for certain peaks the position of their maxima varies by as much as one electron volt , this is not very significant given that the peak widths range from one to a few ev .
in contrast to peaks that originate from interband transitions , plasmon peaks or peaks that have a plasmon component ( see section [ peaks ] ) show a different dependence on the momentum .
peak ( 1 ) of ag is the only well - defined plasmon peak the dispersion of which is clearly parabolic ( see section [ plasmon - ag ] ) .
nevertheless , also other low - energy peaks in cu , ag , and au have a parabolic component in their dispersion . since these peaks are either broad or not well - defined , it is difficult and probably not very useful to quantify their dispersion . in the case of ag , it is interesting to note that one observes a slight increase in intensity of peak ( 2 ) with momentum transfer where peaks ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) seem to overlap . a general trend which can be readily seen in fig . [ loss - q - fig ]
is that , for the energies studied , the absolute value of the loss function decreases with increasing momentum .
the f - sum rule @xcite must be fulfilled for all @xmath28 , implying that the weight is redistributed from smaller to larger energies with increasing momentum transfer .
this aspect is discussed in more detail in ref
. @xcite .
the reason behind can be already understood by analyzing the loss function of the homogeneous electron gas , i.e. , the lindhard dielectric function .
the presented analysis pertains to loss functions that are calculated using gga single - particle eigenvalues .
the conclusions still hold when approximate @xmath74 corrections are applied ( figure not shown ) . indeed
, we find that only peak ( 1 ) of ag is significantly affected .
the intensity and dispersion of peaks that originate from interband transitions is barely altered .
the only difference is that these peaks move to higher energies , reflecting the downward shift of @xmath2 states .
this finding underpins that these peaks are caused by optical transitions from @xmath2 states .
the loss functions presented in fig . [ loss - q - fig ] correspond to momentum transfer @xmath28 in the [ 111 ] direction . due to difficulties in sample preparation
, electron microscopy work is often performed on polycrystalline samples , like those described in section [ expt - res ] .
it is thus important to understand to what extent the conclusions reached in the previous section apply to other crystallographic directions . in fig .
[ anisotropy - fig ] , we show the calculated loss function of ag for various momentum transfers ( 0.076 , 0.526 , 1.052 , and 1.730 @xmath1 ) along the high - symmetry directions [ 111 ] , [ 001 ] , and [ 110 ] .
as expected , the anisotropy is very small for the smallest momenta and becomes slightly more pronounced for larger ones .
however , even for the largest momentum transfer of 1.730 , differences between different crystallographic directions are only quantitative . indeed ,
loss functions for @xmath59 along different directions possess essentially the same features . despite the lack of very obvious differences ,
certain minor distinctions can still be identified .
for example , anisotropy is quite visible for the loss function at about 35 ev , which corresponds to peak ( 5 ) for smaller momenta ( cf .
[ loss - q - fig](b ) ) .
the results in fig .
[ anisotropy - fig ] show that the rate of decrease is slightly different for various crystallographic directions , being fastest for the [ 111 ] direction , slightly slower for [ 110 ] , and slowest for [ 001 ] .
we can conclude that the overall anisotropy is quite small for the considered momenta .
differences between loss functions along different directions are certainly much smaller than those between measured and calculated spectra ( section [ expt - res ] ) .
this , to a certain extent , justifies the comparison of loss functions obtained from polycrystalline samples with calculations performed for high - symmetry directions .
@xmath75 in the [ 111 ] direction .
black solid line ( shaded region ) : the response function calculated at the rpa level including local - field effects ( lfe ) ; blue dashed line : the same without lfe ; solid purple line : the response function calculated including the adiabatic lda kernel ( tdlda ) and lfes ; red dashed line : the same without lfes.,width=283 ] for all three metals that we study here , the effects of local fields and the treatment of exchange - correlation effects in the response functions for larger momenta are overall quite similar to those at small momenta , as shown in fig .
[ large - q ] . like for small @xmath59 ,
local - field effects are very pronounced at larger energies , but they seem to kick in already at lower energies .
the inclusion of the tdlda kernel has already an effect even without an inclusion of local fields , but in accord with the case @xmath77 , its impact is but a fraction of that of the local - field effects .
theoretical and measured momentum - dependent loss functions of cu for different momentum transfers are compared in fig .
[ cu - expt - th-1 ] .
the experimental curves were normalized as described in ref .
their energy resolution was of the order of one ev , thus an additional gaussian smearing was applied to the theoretical curves for a more meaningful comparison .
the smearing parameter was kept the same for all momentum transfers and was chosen to obtain the best possible overall agreement for all energies and momenta . as a matter of fact ,
the experimental energy resolution was better for smaller momenta .
this can be explained by longer acquisition times needed for larger momentum transfers . for the smallest momentum transfer of @xmath78 @xmath1 ,
the experimental loss functions agrees excellently with the calculated one .
peaks ( 2 ) , ( 3 ) , and ( 4 ) , as well as the structure of peak ( 1 ) can be identified in the experimental loss function .
the low - energy peaks are not very apparent in the theoretical curve due to a relatively large smearing parameter .
as explained at the beginning of the present section , the relative intensity of the theoretically obtained peaks decreases with increasing momentum transfer for all three metals .
this trend is reproduced in the experimental curves . indeed , for the largest momentum transfer , @xmath79 @xmath1 , peaks ( 3 ) and ( 4 ) are less pronounced than in the case of smaller @xmath59 , both in experiment and theory . .
the experimental spectra are taken on polycrystalline samples , the calculated data correspond to @xmath59 in the [ 111 ] direction.,width=321 ] as experimental loss functions tend to acquire more weight at higher energies as compared to their theoretical counterparts , the agreement between experiment and theory is slightly getting worse for larger momentum transfers .
we assign this fact to an incomplete removal of multiple - scattering contributions by the procedure used in the present work .
indeed , the importance of multiple scattering increases with increasing scattering angle . however , despite these small drawbacks , we come to the conclusion that experiment and theory agree very well with each other . theoretical and experimental loss functions of au for various momentum transfers are compared in fig .
[ au - expt - th-1 ] . while for the smallest momentum transfer , @xmath80 @xmath1 , peaks ( 1 ) , ( 2 ) , ( 3 ) , and ( 4 ) ( cf . fig .
[ q - zero - fig ] ) can be identified in the experimental loss functions , this is not the case for peaks ( 5 ) , ( 6 ) , ( 7 ) , which are , however , clearly visible in the reflection eels experiment of ref .
[ ] ( also fig .
[ q - zero - fig ] ) . similarly to the case of cu , the visibility of the peaks decreases with increasing @xmath59 , in full accord with theoretical results . the largest disagreement with theory concerns the visibility of peak ( 7 ) for large momentum transfers ( fig .
[ loss - q - fig](c ) ) . indeed , fig .
[ loss - q - fig](c ) indicates that peak ( 7 ) should be quite pronounced even for large momenta .
the results in fig .
[ au - expt - th-1 ] do not confirm this .
one possibility is that multiple scattering contributions have not been completely removed by the present procedure , like in the case of cu .
however , we can not draw a firm conclusion at this moment .
overall the agreement between experiment and theory in the case of au is very good . in the [ 111 ] direction.,width=321 ] measurements of momentum - dependent loss functions of ag using a novel technique based on energy - filtered tem techniques
are in progress in our laboratory .
@xcite in contrast to all other peaks in the loss function , the energy of the plasmon in ag is very sensitive to the accuracy of the band structure . in particular
, the position of @xmath2 states plays a crucial importance .
@xcite one thus would also expect that the same applies to the dispersion of the plasmon .
therefore , in calculating properties associated with the low - energy plasmon we have applied approximate corrections based on @xmath74 calculations of marini _ et al._,@xcite .
the corrections are functions of energy only . in fig .
[ plasmon_111 ] , we plot the loss functions in the energy range @xmath49 10 ev for momenta @xmath81 @xmath1 along the [ 111 ] direction .
spectra corresponding to different @xmath59 are offset for clarity .
as @xmath59 increases , the plasmon peak moves to higher energies , becomes broader , and gets completely damped for a critical momentum of @xmath82 @xmath1 .
@xmath83 in ag is much smaller than in simple metals like al , where @xmath84 @xmath1.@xcite the explanation for this is quite straightforward . in ag ,
the plasmon has a much smaller energy due to renormalization by interband transitions.@xcite thus , as @xmath59 increases it enters the region of electron - hole excitations for much smaller @xmath59 .
this can be expressed by an approximate relationship @xmath85 , @xcite where @xmath86 is the fermi velocity .
ev calculated within the rpa based on the gga ( upper pannel ) and the @xmath74 ( lower pannel ) band structure .
spectra are offset for clarity.,width=264 ] we have determined the plasmon dispersion by taking the plasmon - peak energy as a function of momentum .
this allows a direct comparison with experimental results , where the identical definition is most frequently used.@xcite the corresponding dependence of the plasmon energy is shown in fig .
[ dispersion_plasmon ] for three high - symmetry directions .
the approximate @xmath74 corrections affect not only the position and the width of the plasmon peak but also its dispersion . while it is parabolic for low momentum transfers , it departs from this behavior for momenta @xmath87 @xmath1 .
for the uniform electron gas , it has been shown to be best described by the dispersion relation @xmath88.@xcite however , there is no good reason why this function should be used for a more complicated plasmon like that of ag .
thus , in this work we choose a different procedure . in refs .
[ ] the plasmon dispersion was measured , and for momenta smaller than 0.4 @xmath1 was fitted to a parabola of the following form : @xmath89 due to the limited energy resolution and a small number of momentum transfers , the departure from parabolicity may not have been detected in this experiment .
thus , to compare to these data , we have also fitted the results of fig .
[ dispersion_plasmon ] to the above given dispersion relation ( eq . ) in the same momentum range .
the results of this fit are presented in table [ plasmon - table ] . as mentioned before , the plasmon energy at zero momentum @xmath90 calculated at the gga level , departs significantly from the experimental value , and the agreement is noticeably improved with @xmath74 corrections .
similarly , the dispersion coefficient @xmath91 is found to be @xmath92 in gga ( the error bar here comes from averaging over the three high - symmetry directions ) , a bit higher than the measured value of @xmath93@xcite or @xmath94.@xcite in contrast , the @xmath74 value of @xmath95 agrees very well with the measurements . we have also performed a fit including momenta @xmath96 @xmath1 only ( table [ plasmon - table ] ) , obtaining coefficients @xmath91 of @xmath97 in the case of gga and @xmath98 for @xmath74 , respectively .
these values could be compared to that of the homogeneous electron gas having the density of @xmath54 electrons in ag .
to do so , requires an additional parameter , the `` optical '' electron mass , which basically yields the fermi level relative to the bottom of the @xmath54 band ( not to be confused with the effective electron mass @xmath99 high above the fermi level ) . using @xmath100 , we obtain @xmath101 for the homogeneous electron gas .
this shows that for very small momenta the plasmon dispersion in ag does not significantly depart from that in the homogeneous electron gas , despite the large difference in the corresponding plasmon energies .
band structure .
, width=245 ] as discussed in section [ loss - q - zero ] , local field effects are not very substantial for energies below 10 ev
. indeed , when lfes are included , plasmon energy and dispersion do not change much .
this is illustrated in fig .
[ dispersion_plasmon ] for calculations including approximate @xmath74 corrections .
when local fields are included , the plasmon energy increases slightly from 3.53 ev to 3.56 ev , thus getting closer to the experimental value of 3.78 ev , while the plasmon dispersion becomes slightly smaller .
for the [ 111 ] direction , the coefficient @xmath91 decreases by about 3% . to judge about the importance of local field effects
, however , more accurate measurements would be desirable .
these should ideally probe also the region where the dispersion departs from the parabolic shape .
we mention here a recent theoretical work by yan _
et al . _ for the ag(111 )
surface using an orbital - dependent functional .
@xcite significant improvement was found in the description of the plasmon dispersion in the parabolic region @xmath102 @xmath1 ; the coefficient @xmath91 , however , was not discussed in that study .
.parameters of the plasmon dispersion in ag for @xmath103 @xmath1 and for @xmath96 @xmath1 .
heg stands for the homogeneous electron gas with the electron density corresponding to one electron per ag unit cell . [
cols="<,^,^,^,^ " , ] [ plasmon - table ]
in this work , we have performed a comparative analysis of momentum - dependent loss functions ( dynamic structure factors ) of the three coinage metals cu , ag , and au .
while their dielectric properties have been studied in detail for more than half a century , our purpose was to extend these studies to higher energies ( @xmath50 10 ev ) and larger momentum transfers .
as a logical step towards quantitative studies in these less investigated regimes , we have also discussed the dielectric functions for small energies and have provided additional insight into the differences and similarities between the three materials .
the main question guiding our work was , to which extent response functions calculated using state - of - the - art electronic structure techniques , like time - dependent density functional theory in the linear - response regime , agree with those measured in modern electron microscopes .
we have shown that in the majority of cases the agreement is indeed excellent .
pronounced peaks in loss functions at energies @xmath104 ev originate from interband transitions from @xmath2 states .
all - electron electronic structure methods like those used in the present work are predestined to achieve a reliable description of these features both at small and at finite momentum transfers .
we arrive at the conclusion that the existing theoretical methodologies are indeed able to achieve a very reliable quantitative description of dielectric properties of the coinage metals cu , ag , and au .
it seems that given this excellent performance of modern theoretical tools improvements on the experimental side are now necessary to challenge electronic - structure theory .
this includes better sample quality , post - processing of data , as well as advanced methodologies to measure momentum - dependent loss functions.@xcite due to strong electron - electron interactions samples for tem measurements should necessarily be very thin . as a result ,
sample preparation remains one of the most challenging tasks , in particular regarding means to avoid surface contamination . as a step in this direction , new sample preparation and measurements techniques in the case of ag will be presented in a future publication .
this work has been supported by the swiss snf , project 200021 - 120308 , the austrian science fund , project p16227 , and the sterreichische forschungsfrderungsgesellschaft , project _
atomat_. we acknowledge y. ma ( universitt osnabrck , germany ) and g .-
rignanese ( universit louvain - la - neuve ) for sharing their @xmath74 results of cu and au , respectively .
we thank c. g. van de walle ( uc santa barbara ) for drawing our attention to the relevance of some of our results to photoemission experiments , and g. lucas ( epfl ) for carefully reading the manuscript .
a. alkauskas , s. d. schneider , s. sagmeister , c. ambrosch - draxl , and c. hbert , ultramicrsocopy * 110 * , 1081 ( 2010 ) ; c. hbert , a. alkauskas , b. jouffrey , s. lffler , and p. schattschneider , eur .
. phys . * 54 * , 33510 ( 2011 ) .
y. q. cai , p. c. chow , o. d. restrepo , y. takano , k. togano , h. kito , h. ishii , c. c. chen , k. s. liang , c. t. chen , s. tsuda , s. shin , c. c. kao , w. ku , and a. g. eguiluz , phys .
lett . * 97 * , 176402 ( 2006 ) . | we present a comparative theoretical and experimental study of dynamic structure factors ( momentum - dependent loss functions ) of the noble metals cu , ag , and au in the energy range of 0@xmath060 ev .
the emphasis is on theoretical results that are compared with new as well as available experimental data .
dynamic structure factors are calculated within the linear - response formalism of time - dependent density - functional theory , using the full - potential linearized augmented plane - wave ( fp - lapw ) method . for the studied energy range , local - field effects
are found to be very important for ag and au and only marginally relevant for cu .
we present an explanation for this surprising behavior .
loss functions of all three metals possess a complex multi - peak structure .
we classify the features in the loss function as being related to collective excitations , interband transitions , or mixed modes .
the impact of short - range correlations on the dynamic response functions are evaluated by comparing the results of the random - phase approximation to those of the time - dependent local - density approximation .
exchange correlation effects are found to be weak for small momentum transfers , but increasingly important for larger momenta .
the calculated structure factors agree well with experiments . |
a cellular automaton ( ca ) is a discrete dynamical system consisting of a regular array of cells@xcite .
each cell takes only a finite number of states and is updated in discrete time steps .
although the updating rules are simple , cas often exhibit very complicated time evolution patterns which resemble natural phenomena such as chemical reactions , turbulent flow , nonlinear dispersive waves and solitons .
a typical ca exhibiting a solitonic behaviour is the box and ball system ( bbs ) which is a reinterpretation of the ca proposed by takahashi and satsuma@xcite .
the bbs is _ integrable _ in the sense that it is obtained from the kdv equation through a limiting procedure called ultradiscretization@xcite .
it can also be obtained from a two dimensional integrable lattice model and its relation to combinatorial @xmath0 matrices of @xmath1 is well established@xcite .
the original box - ball system is defined as a dynamical system of a finite number of balls in an _ infinite _ one dimensional array of boxes .
however , it is possible to extend the time evolution rule to a system consisting of a _ finite _ number of boxes with periodic boundary conditions@xcite .
the bbs with periodic boundary condition ( pbbs ) is also connected to the combinatorial @xmath0 matrix of @xmath1 and , its time evolution rule is represented as a boolean recurrence formula related to the algorithm for calculating the @xmath2th root . as a ca , the pbbs is composed of a finite number of cells , and it can only take on a finite number of patterns .
hence the time evolution of the pbbs is necessarily periodic . in the present article
, we investigate the fundamental cycle , _
i.e. _ , the shortest period of the discrete periodic motion of the pbbs . in section 2 , we review the pbbs and present its conserved quantities .
the formula for the total number of patterns for a given set of conserved quantities is also presented . in section 3
, we define several notions which are necessary to prove the formula for the fundamental cycle .
the fundamental cycle for an arbitrary initial state is derived in section 4 .
section 5 is devoted to the concluding remarks .
let us consider a one dimensional array of @xmath3 boxes . to be able to impose a periodic boundary condition
, we assume that the @xmath3th box is the adjacent box to the first one .
( we may imagine that the boxes are arranged in a circle . )
the box capacity is one for all the boxes , and each box is either empty or filled with a ball at any time step .
we denote the number of balls by @xmath4 , such that @xmath5 .
the balls are moved according to a deterministic time evolution rule .
there are several equivalent ways to describe this rule .
for example , 1 . in each filled box , create a copy of the ball .
2 . move all the copies once according to the following rules .
3 . choose one of the copies and move it to the nearest empty box on the right of it .
4 . choose one of the remaining copies and move it to the nearest empty box on the right of it .
5 . repeat the above procedure until all the copies have moved .
delete all the original balls .
an example of the time evolution of the pbbs according to this rule is shown in fig .
[ fig : pbbs-1 ] .
it is not difficult to prove that the obtained result does not depend on the choice of the copies at each stage and that it coincides with the evolution rule of the original bbs when @xmath3 goes to infinity .
an advantage of the above description is that we can easily extend the evolution rule to the system with many kinds of balls and many kinds of box capacities . in the present article , however , we restrict ourselves to the pbbs with only one kind of ball and with box capacity one , and we revert to the following description which is more convenient to determine the fundamental cycle .
we denote an empty box by @xmath6 and a filled box by @xmath7 .
then the pbbs is regarded as a dynamical system of a finite sequence of @xmath6s and @xmath7s .
because of the periodic boundary condition , we consider the last entry in the sequence to be adjacent to the first entry .
( in this sense , the sequence should be regarded as a ring which consists of @xmath6s and @xmath7s . )
we say two sequences are _ equivalent _ if one coincides with the other by translation .
for example , the sequence @xmath8 is equivalent to @xmath9 .
the updating rule of the sequence is given as : 1 .
connect all the @xmath10s in the sequence with arc lines .
2 . neglecting the @xmath11 pairs which were connected in the first step ,
connect all the remaining @xmath12 with arc lines .
repeat the above procedure until all the @xmath7s are connected to @xmath6s .
4 . interchange every @xmath7 and @xmath6 which are connected to each other by an arcline .
this rule is illustrated in fig .
[ fig : pbbs-2 ] and some examples of time evolutions of the pbbs are shown in figs . [ fig : pbbs-3 ] . just as the original bbs@xcite
, the pbbs has a number of conserved quantities .
let @xmath13 be the number of the @xmath11 pairs in a state of the pbbs , which are connected with arc lines in the first step of the above time evolution rule .
similarly , we denote by @xmath14 the number of @xmath11 pairs connected in the 2nd step , by @xmath15 those in the 3rd step , ... , and by @xmath16 those in the last step .
clearly @xmath17 .
for example , in the state shown in fig .
[ fig : pbbs-2 ] , @xmath18 .
[ conservation ] the numbers @xmath19 in the weakly decreasing series of integers @xmath20 are conserved quantities for the time evolution of the pbbs . to prove proposition [ conservation ] , we prepare two lemmas .
the number of @xmath10s in a state of the pbbs is equal to that of @xmath21s , for they coincide with the number of the set of consecutive 1 s ( or 0 s ) . according to the evolution rule
, a @xmath10 at @xmath22 turns into a @xmath21 at @xmath23 and all the @xmath21s at @xmath23 are created in this way .
hence we find that the number of @xmath10s at @xmath22 is equal to that of @xmath21s at @xmath23 .
thus we have the following lemma : [ lemma1 ] the number of @xmath10s in the pbbs does not change in time .
it also coincides with the number of @xmath21s at each time step .
when we eliminate the @xmath10s in a state , we obtain a new sequence .
hereafter we call this operation _
@xmath11-elimination_. ( in order to associate this new sequence to the state of a pbbs with a smaller number of boxes and balls , we have to determine the position of the first entry of the sequence .
we shall consider this problem in the subsequent section however , as it is not necessary for the proof considered here . )
the operation _
@xmath24-elimination _ is defined in a similar way . by @xmath11-elimination ,
all the series of consecutive @xmath7s and consecutive @xmath6s in the state have their length reduced by one .
the @xmath24-elimination has the same effect on the state , hence , the sequence obtained by @xmath24-elimination is equivalent to the one by @xmath11-elimination . when the sequence obtained by @xmath11-elimination is updated according to the time evolution rule , it becomes equivalent to the sequence obtained by @xmath24-elimination on the state in the next time step .
( this fact is easily understood from fig . [
fig : pbbs-2 ] . )
thus we have [ lemma2 ] both @xmath11-elimination and @xmath24-elimination commute with the updating rule of the pbbs , that is , the sequence obtained by @xmath11-elimination ( or @xmath24-elimination ) at @xmath23 is equivalent to the one updated from the sequence obtained by @xmath11 elimination ( or @xmath24-elimination ) at @xmath22 . from lemma [ lemma1 ] ,
@xmath13 does not change in time . since @xmath14 is the number of @xmath10s in the sequence obtained by @xmath11-elimination , from lemma [ lemma1 ] and [ lemma2 ] , it is also a conserved quantity in time . repeating the @xmath11-elimination and using lemma [ lemma1 ] and [ lemma2 ]
, we find that all the @xmath25 are conserved in time . since @xmath20 is a weakly decreasing series of positive integers
, we can associate it with a young diagram with @xmath25 boxes in the @xmath26-th column ( @xmath27 ) .
then the lengths of the rows are also weakly decreasing positive integers , and we denote them @xmath28 where @xmath29 .
the set @xmath30 is an alternative expression of the conserved quantities of the system .
let @xmath31 , and @xmath32 then , for a fixed number of boxes @xmath3 and conserved quantities @xmath33 , the number of possible states of the pbbs @xmath34 is given by the following proposition .
[ statescount ] @xmath35 although the proposition can be proved by elementary combinatorial arguments , it is convenient to use notions defined in subsequent sections and we thus refer the proof to appendix a. the fact , however , that the right hand side of ( [ numberofstates ] ) is an integer is confirmed using the lemma : [ lemma3 ] let @xmath36 be @xmath37 positive integers and suppose that the @xmath38 do not have a common divisor , @xmath39 , @xmath40 .
if there exists a @xmath41 such that @xmath42 then @xmath41 is an integer .
let the boxes be numbered @xmath43 from left to right .
accordingly , the position of an entry in the associated @xmath24 sequence is denoted by the number of the corresponding box .
because of the periodic boundary condition , we always use the convention that the numbers are defined in @xmath44 , that is , @xmath45 , and an inequality such as @xmath46 means that @xmath47 . in order to explain some important features of the pbbs
, we assign an integer index to every entry of the sequences obtained at each time step in the updating rule . precisely speaking , we define the map @xmath48 in the following way . 1
. choose the @xmath11 pairs in the construction of the conserved quantity @xmath13.if the positions of @xmath7s and @xmath6s are @xmath49 and @xmath50 respectively , then @xmath51 @xmath52 .
2 . next ,
choose the @xmath11 pairs for the conserved quantity @xmath14 . if the positions of @xmath7s and @xmath6s are @xmath53 and @xmath54 respectively , then @xmath55 @xmath56 .
3 . similarly , the indices @xmath57 are assigned to the positions of the @xmath11 pairs in the construction of @xmath58 .
4 . for the positions of @xmath6s which are not connected with @xmath7s in the construction of the conserved quantities ,
the indices are @xmath59 .
we say that the entry ( @xmath6 or @xmath7 ) in the position @xmath26 at time @xmath22 has index @xmath60 . from this definition , we notice that @xmath61 entries take the largest index @xmath62 . furthermore ,
if we denote the number of entries of index @xmath41 by @xmath63 , then @xmath63 does not change in time and is given as @xmath64 for example , the indices of the sequence * 16@ c 0 & 0 & 0 & 1 & 1 & 1 & 0 & 0 & 1 & 1 & 0 & 1 & 1 & 0 & 0 & 0 are given as * 16@ c -4&-@xmath65 & -@xmath65 & 4 & 2 & 1 & -1 & -2 & 3 & 1 & -1 & 2 & 1 & -1 & -2 & -3 using the index , we define _ solitons _ and their position .
a soliton consists of @xmath7s in a @xmath24 sequence and can be determined by the following process . 1
. choose one of the @xmath7s whose index is @xmath62 .
we suppose its position is @xmath66 .
2 . choose the @xmath7 which is the nearest @xmath7 with index @xmath67 in the counterclockwise direction from the position @xmath66 .
( _ i.e. _ to the right " of that position . )
let @xmath68 be its position .
similarly , let @xmath69 be the position of its ( counterclockwise ) nearest @xmath7 with index @xmath70 .
4 . repeat the procedure until the @xmath7 at @xmath71 is determined .
then we define the set of @xmath7s at @xmath72 to constitute a soliton with length @xmath62 and position @xmath71 .
perform the same procedure starting from one of the other @xmath73 @xmath7s with index @xmath62 , and repeat it until all the @xmath61 solitons with length @xmath62 have been determined .
the largest index of the remaining @xmath7s is @xmath74 .
repeat the above procedure to the remaining @xmath7s and determine all @xmath75 solitons with length @xmath74 .
8 . in a similar manner , we determine @xmath76 solitons with length @xmath77 , @xmath78 solitons with length @xmath79 , ... , and finally we determine @xmath80 solitons with length @xmath81 . in fig . [ fig : solitons ] , there are eight solitons ( length @xmath82 @xmath83 @xmath84 , length @xmath85 @xmath83 @xmath84 , length @xmath86 @xmath83 @xmath86 , and length @xmath84 @xmath83 @xmath82 ) .
the @xmath7s with @xmath87 at the bottom constitute the largest soliton and those with @xmath88 constitute the second largest soliton .
their position is marked by @xmath89 .
next , we define the notion of _ a block_. recall that we drew arc lines between @xmath11 pairs to determine the time evolution of pbbs . as is shown in fig .
[ fig : solitons ] , a state of the pbbs is divided into disjoint @xmath24 sequences of such arc lines .
we call each disjoint sequence _ a block_. for example , there are two blocks in fig .
[ fig : solitons ] .
the following properties of a block are obvious from its definition . 1 . the numbers of @xmath6s and @xmath7s in a block are the same .
there is only one soliton with the largest length in each block .
3 . after time evolution @xmath90 ,
all the @xmath6s in a block at @xmath22 , turn into @xmath7s , and all the @xmath7s into @xmath6s .
if the length of the largest soliton in a block is @xmath91 , the @xmath7 at the left edge of the block has index @xmath91 and the @xmath6 at the right edge of the block has index @xmath92 .
the length of a block is twice the sum of the lengths of solitons contained in the block .
the following proposition , which plays an important role in subsequent proofs is a direct consequence of the definition of soliton and block .
[ solitonicnature ] suppose that @xmath7s at the positions @xmath93 constitute a soliton with length @xmath94 , and that the @xmath6s which form the @xmath11 pairs with these @xmath7s are at the positions @xmath95 .
the @xmath7 at @xmath96 has index @xmath41 and the @xmath6 at @xmath97 has index @xmath98 .
then , 1 .
if an entry is located between @xmath99 and @xmath96 , the absolute value of its index is less than @xmath41 .
2 . if an entry is located between @xmath100 and @xmath101 , the absolute value of its index is less than or equal to @xmath41 .
3 . if we eliminate all the @xmath7s at @xmath93 and all @xmath6s at @xmath95 , the entries with positions inbetween @xmath99 and @xmath96 and @xmath97 and @xmath101 @xmath102 constitute disjoint blocks . 4 . let @xmath103 be the difference of the number of @xmath7s and @xmath6s contained between @xmath104 and @xmath41 , then @xmath105 .
in particular , @xmath106 iff @xmath107 and @xmath108 for @xmath109 . similarly , let @xmath110 be the difference of the number of @xmath6s and @xmath7s contained between @xmath41 and @xmath111 , then @xmath112 .
in particular , @xmath113 iff @xmath114 .
let us discuss some important properties of such a block .
we assume that the length of the largest soliton in the block is @xmath94 , and that it is constituted by @xmath7s at positions @xmath93 , where @xmath7 at @xmath96 forms a @xmath11 pair with @xmath6 at @xmath97 ( @xmath115 ) .
first we divide a block into two parts .
[ fig : block ] ) the _ right part _ of a block is the @xmath24 sequence which is located on the right side ( counterclockwise ) from the position of the largest soliton in the block .
in other words , the right part is the sequence from @xmath116 to @xmath111 .
the remainder is called the _ left part _ of the block .
it is the sequence from @xmath117 to @xmath71 .
the following properties are obvious . 1 .
the number of @xmath7s in the left part is greater by @xmath94 than that of @xmath6s . on the contrary ,
the number of @xmath7s in the right part is less by @xmath94 than that of @xmath6s .
2 . the entries at the edges of the left part are @xmath7 and those of the right part are @xmath6 .
furthermore , from the rule for making @xmath11 pairs , we have the following proposition .
[ 01sequence ] 1 . in any sequence starting from the left edge of the left part , the number of @xmath7s is greater than that of @xmath6s .
2 . in any sequence ending at the right edge of the left part
, the number of @xmath7s is greater than that of @xmath6s .
3 . in any sequence ending at the right edge of the right part , the number of @xmath6s is greater than that of @xmath7s .
4 . in any sequence starting from the left edge of the right part ,
the number of @xmath6s is greater than or equal to that of @xmath7s . the statements 1 and 3 are obvious .
for the statement 2 , we assume that the sequence starts from position @xmath41 and that @xmath118 . from proposition
[ solitonicnature ] , there can only be solitons with length less than or equal to @xmath119 inbetween @xmath120 and @xmath121 . from proposition [ solitonicnature]-2 and -3 , the difference of the number of @xmath6s and @xmath7s between @xmath41 and @xmath122 is less than or equal to @xmath119 . on the other hand ,
there are @xmath123 more @xmath7s than @xmath6s between @xmath124 and @xmath71 .
hence statement 2 holds .
the statement 4 is proved in the similar manner .
next we discuss some features of the time evolution of solitons .
a state of pbbs at time step @xmath125 is divided into blocks .
we pay attention to a single one of them .
the following proposition is essential to understand the movement of solitons .
[ blockinvariance ] in a block , the number and type of solitons at @xmath125 do not change at @xmath22 .
furthermore , the position of the solitons at @xmath22 does not depend on the pattern outside the block at @xmath125 .
the above proposition is proved by induction using the lemmas given below .
let @xmath94 be the length of the largest soliton in the block .
the position of its components is denoted by @xmath126 and that of the pairing @xmath6s by @xmath127 .
we refer to the sequence which , at @xmath22 , is updated from the left ( right ) part of the block at @xmath125 as the left ( right ) part at @xmath22 .
[ fig : att ] shows the left and right parts at @xmath22 which are updated from the state shown in fig .
[ fig : block ] . [ lemma4 ] for @xmath128 , if @xmath10s are eliminated in the left part at @xmath22 , there are at least three consecutive @xmath6s in the left edge . if further @xmath11-elimination is possible and is performed on the sequence , there are at least four consecutive @xmath6s in the left edge . in general ,
if @xmath11-elimination is performed @xmath123 times ( @xmath129 ) , there remain at least @xmath130 consecutive @xmath6s in the left edge .
recall that all the @xmath6s in a block at @xmath125 turn into @xmath7s , and all the @xmath7s into @xmath6s . from proposition
[ 01sequence]-2 we have that every @xmath7 in the left part at @xmath22 has its pair @xmath6 within the left part .
let @xmath103 be the difference of the number of @xmath6s and @xmath7s inbetween @xmath104 and @xmath41 . from proposition [ 01sequence]-1 or
[ solitonicnature]-4 we find that @xmath131 } \delta(k ) \ge 1 $ ] .
suppose that @xmath132 at @xmath133 @xmath134 , then the entry at @xmath135 is @xmath7 and the entry at @xmath136 is @xmath6 .
hence , if we eliminate @xmath10s , the @xmath7s at @xmath135 are removed .
let @xmath137 be the set of positions @xmath138\}$ ] . since @xmath139,there are at least three @xmath6s in the left edge of the reduced sequence .
to prove the lemma , proceed in a similar manner .
[ lemma5 ] suppose that @xmath128 .
in the left part at @xmath22 , if we perform @xmath11-elimination @xmath140 times , only @xmath94 consecutive @xmath6s remain and no @xmath7 is left . as in the proof of lemma [ lemma4 ] , we consider the difference @xmath103 .
since @xmath11-elimination always erases a @xmath7 and @xmath6 simultaneously , the value @xmath103 also indicates the difference of @xmath6 and @xmath7 in the reduced sequence , between its left edge @xmath104 and the entry at the ( original ) position @xmath41 . from proposition
[ solitonicnature]-4 , @xmath103 ( @xmath141 ) can only take its maximum value @xmath94 at @xmath142 .
on the other hand , from lemma [ lemma4 ] , at least @xmath94 consecutive @xmath6s remain after @xmath140 @xmath11-eliminations .
hence only @xmath94 consecutive @xmath6s can remain in the left part at @xmath22 .
[ lemma6 ] in the left part , the number and type of solitons at @xmath125 do not change at @xmath22 except for the largest soliton .
furthermore , the position of the solitons at @xmath22 does not depend on the pattern outside the block at @xmath125 .
if @xmath143 , there is no @xmath7 in the left part at @xmath22 and the above statement becomes trivial .
we therefore suppose @xmath128 .
consider a state of a smaller pbbs of the same size as the left part in consideration .
we assume that the pattern of the state coincides with the left part at @xmath125 except for the @xmath7s which constitute the largest soliton , which all are replaced with @xmath6s .
the number of @xmath6s in this state is greater than that of @xmath7s , by an amount of @xmath94 .
if we update according to the time evolution rule , this pattern is exactly equal to that of the left part at @xmath22 ( proposition [ solitonicnature]-3 ) . since the number and type of solitons does not change in the sequence ( proposition [ conservation ] ) , to prove the lemma , it suffices to show that no @xmath7 of the left part belongs to a soliton whose position is outside that part and that no @xmath7 from the outside belongs to a soliton whose position is in the left part . from proposition [ 01sequence]-2 , @xmath7 does not form a pair with @xmath6 at the right edge ( at the position @xmath71 ) , which , at the same time , means that no @xmath7 forms a pair with @xmath6 in the outside .
( remember that a pair means a @xmath7 and a @xmath6 which are connected by an arc line according to the time evolution rule at @xmath22 . )
since the pattern of the left part at @xmath22 is the same as the sequence considered above , the indices of @xmath7s coincide with those of that sequence .
hence the largest index of the left part at @xmath22 is at most @xmath140 .
there are @xmath94 more @xmath6s than @xmath7s in the left part at @xmath22 , and the index of the @xmath6 at @xmath71 is less than or equal to @xmath144 .
since the largest index in the left part is at most @xmath140 , from proposition [ solitonicnature]-1 , a @xmath7 in the left part does not belong to a soliton whose position is outside the left part .
there are at least two consecutive @xmath6s in the left edge of the left part at @xmath22 .
the index of the second @xmath6 from the left edge is at most @xmath145 , and , by proposition [ solitonicnature]-1 , no @xmath7 in the outside belongs to a soliton whose position is in the left part if its index is less than or equal to @xmath145 .
suppose that a @xmath7 of index @xmath41 ( @xmath146 ) outside the left part constitutes a soliton with @xmath7s inside , whose indices are @xmath147 .
when we perform @xmath11-elimiantion @xmath148 times , from lemma [ lemma4 ] we have that there are at least two consecutive @xmath6s between the inside @xmath7 with index @xmath149 and the outside @xmath7 of index @xmath41 , which contradicts our definition of a soliton .
thus we find that no @xmath7 on the outside constitutes a soliton whose position is in the left part , which completes the proof . as for the right part , we have the following lemmas .
[ lemma7 ] for @xmath150 , if @xmath10s are eliminated in the right part at @xmath22 , there are at least three consecutive @xmath7s in the right edge . if possible , further @xmath11-elimination is performed , there are at least four consecutive @xmath7s in the right edge . in general ,
if @xmath11-elimination is performed @xmath123 times ( @xmath129 ) , there remain at least @xmath130 consecutive @xmath7s in the right edge .
the proof is analogous to the proof of lemma [ lemma4 ] .
[ lemma8 ] if we eliminate @xmath10s in the right part at @xmath22 , @xmath151 times , the reduced sequence consists of @xmath94 consecutive @xmath7s and no @xmath6 .
let @xmath152 @xmath153 be the set of positions of the entries in the right part at @xmath22 which remain after @xmath123 @xmath11-eliminations and that do not constitute @xmath130 consecutive @xmath7s in the right edge . then ,
as in the proof of lemma [ lemma4 ] , we have an inequality : @xmath154 . for @xmath155
, this inequality implies that the sequence has the form @xmath156 hence , by applying @xmath11-elimination @xmath151 times , we obtain a pattern with @xmath94 consecutive @xmath7s and no @xmath6 .
now we give the proof of proposition [ blockinvariance ] from proposition [ 01sequence]-4 , any sequence starting from the left edge of the right part at @xmath22 contains a number of @xmath7s , larger than or equal to that of @xmath6s .
( recall that @xmath6 and @xmath7 in a block at @xmath125 turn to @xmath7 and @xmath6 at @xmath22 . )
hence a @xmath6 in the right part at @xmath22 forms a pair with one of the @xmath7s in the right part , and the pair is not affected by the outside pattern .
there are just @xmath94 @xmath7s which do not form pairs with inside @xmath6s .
these @xmath7s are those obtained by @xmath11-eliminations as in lemma [ lemma8 ] .
if their indices at @xmath22 are @xmath157 , then since the index of @xmath6 at @xmath71 is at most @xmath144 and all the indices in the right part are less than or equal to @xmath94 ( lemma [ lemma8 ] ) , no @xmath7 outside the right block can belong to the inside solitons ( proposition [ solitonicnature]-1 ) and the @xmath94 @xmath7s constitute a soliton with length @xmath94 whose position does not depend on the outside pattern .
in fact , its position is always @xmath111 .
then , together with lemma [ lemma6 ] , the solitons in the block do not depend on the outside pattern .
in other words , the positions of solitons at @xmath22 , exactly coincide with those in the case where no other block exists in the state . according to proposition [ conservation ] ,
the solitons are preserved in time evolution and the proposition is proved . therefore we now only have to show that the indices of the @xmath94 consecutive @xmath7s , which are obtained by @xmath11-eliminations in the right block at @xmath22 , are @xmath157 . by the definition of a block , the entry at @xmath158 is necessarily @xmath6 , and the @xmath7 at the right edge @xmath111 forms a pair with it .
hence its index is @xmath84 and the statement is true for @xmath159 . when we eliminate all the @xmath10s in the state , the right edge of the reduced " block is @xmath7 ( lemma [ lemma7 ] ) .
since all the blocks , for which the largest soliton was of length @xmath84 , are eliminated , and since the other blocks have at least one @xmath6 in the left edge , this @xmath7 forms a pair with a @xmath6 and its index is @xmath86 and the statement is true for @xmath143 .
similarly , when we eliminate the @xmath10s once more , the right edge of the reduced block is still @xmath7 ( lemma [ lemma7 ] ) . since all the blocks with the largest soliton
whose length @xmath143 are eliminated , lemma [ lemma4 ] assures that the next right entry of the @xmath7 is @xmath85 . repeating this argument
, we find that the consecutive @xmath7s have indices @xmath160 , which completes the proof . in the above proof
, we have also shown that the position of the largest soliton at @xmath22 is the right edge of the block . from proposition
[ solitonicnature]-3 and the fact that the length of the block is twice the sum of the lengths of solitons in the block , we obtain the following corollary [ scatteringlength ] the position of the largest soliton is updated to the right edge of the block . the difference between the position of the largest soliton at @xmath22 and that at @xmath125 is @xmath161 . since the @xmath6s in the right part at @xmath22 form pairs with the @xmath7s in the right part
, we have [ rightpartcoinsidence ] the pattern of the right part at @xmath125 coincides with the pattern in the same region at @xmath23 .
finally the movement of solitons is expressed by the theorem : [ solitonmovement ] suppose that a pbbs has @xmath4 solitons .
let @xmath162 and @xmath163 @xmath164 be the positions and lengths of the solitons at @xmath125 . then , their positions at @xmath22 , @xmath165 @xmath164 , satisfy @xmath166 \qquad \mbox{\rm modulo $ n$},\ ] ] where the soliton at @xmath165 has length @xmath163 and the coefficients @xmath167 ( @xmath168 ) satisfy @xmath169 . in particular , if @xmath170 is the position of the largest soliton , @xmath171 or @xmath84 .
we prove the theorem by induction on the number of solitons @xmath4 . for @xmath172 ,
the statement is trivial ( @xmath173 ) .
let @xmath174 and assume that the theorem is true for @xmath175 .
when there are @xmath176 solitons , if the state at @xmath125 consists of multiple blocks , the latter part of proposition [ blockinvariance ] can be applied to each block and the theorem is proved .
when the state consists of one block , as shown in the proof of lemma [ lemma6 ] , except for the largest soliton the other solitons in the left part are updated as if the largest soliton did not exist .
hence they satisfy ( [ solitonformula ] ) by the induction hypothesis .
let @xmath177 be the position of the largest soliton at @xmath125 . from corollary [ scatteringlength ] , @xmath178 , \label{moveoflargest}\end{aligned}\ ] ]
where @xmath179 if the @xmath26th soliton is in the right part and otherwise @xmath180 .
hence the largest soliton satisfies ( [ solitonformula ] ) . on the other hand , by proposition [ rightpartcoinsidence ] , the solitons in the right part at @xmath22 are supposed to move to their positions at @xmath125 if there is no soliton outside the region . by the induction hypothesis
this movement satisfies ( [ solitonformula ] ) . then , if the @xmath26th soliton is in the right part at @xmath22 , @xmath181 , @xmath182 , \quad \mbox{modulo $ n$}\ ] ] where @xmath183 and @xmath184 when the @xmath185th or @xmath26th soliton is outside the right part . since @xmath179 for the @xmath26th soliton in the right part , if we put @xmath186 , @xmath187 @xmath188 , then @xmath189 .
\quad \mbox{modulo $ n$}\ ] ] thus the theorem also holds true for @xmath190 , which completes the proof .
so far , we have not obtained concrete expressions for @xmath191 , however , theorem [ solitonmovement ] and corollary [ scatteringlength ] are enough to determine the fundamental cycle of the pbbs for a given initial state . in the subsequent section , we shall use some properties of solitons with length @xmath84 .
hereafter we often refer to such a soliton as a _
@xmath84-soliton_. the following proposition is easily obtained from proposition [ solitonicnature ] [ 1-soliton - pattern ] let @xmath192 be the position of a 1-soliton .
the entry at @xmath193 is necessarily a @xmath6 .
if the entry at @xmath194 is @xmath7 , then its index is greater than @xmath86 . on the contrary , if the entries at @xmath195 are @xmath196 , then @xmath192 is the position of a 1-soliton . similarly if the entries at @xmath195 are @xmath197 and the index of @xmath7 at @xmath194 is greater than two , then @xmath192 is the position of a 1-soliton . in particular , if the entries from @xmath194 to @xmath198 are @xmath199 , then @xmath192 is the position of a 1-soliton . as for the movement of the 1-soliton
, we have [ move-1-soliton ] the position of a 1-soliton is updated by @xmath200 or @xmath201 .
first we assume that the distance between the 1-solitons is at least @xmath85 .
let @xmath192 be the position of a @xmath84-soliton at @xmath22 .
the entry at @xmath193 must be @xmath6 .
if the entry at @xmath202 is @xmath7 , then the entries from @xmath192 to @xmath202 form a pattern @xmath196 at @xmath23 and we see that the position changes by @xmath200 . when the entry at @xmath202 is @xmath6 , then the entry at @xmath194 is @xmath6 by proposition [ 1-soliton - pattern ] .
the index of @xmath6 at @xmath202 is either @xmath59 or @xmath98 @xmath203 . if it is @xmath59 , the entries from @xmath192 to @xmath202 become a @xmath196 pattern at @xmath23 and we have that the position changes by @xmath200 .
if it is @xmath98 , the index of @xmath6 at @xmath194 , @xmath204 , satisfies @xmath205 , hence the entries from @xmath206 to @xmath202 are updated as either @xmath207 or @xmath199 . by proposition [ 1-soliton - pattern ] , the position of the soliton is @xmath194 and hence it changes by @xmath201 .
when the distance between the 1-solitons is just @xmath86 , they form a sequence like @xmath208 .
let @xmath192 be the position of the leftmost 1-soliton .
then we repeat the same arguments as above and find that all the solitons move by @xmath200 when the entry at @xmath209 is @xmath7 or @xmath6 with index @xmath59 and by @xmath201 when it is @xmath6 with index @xmath98 .
in this section , we consider the fundamental cycle ( the shortest period ) of a pbbs for a given initial state .
a key idea to determine the fundamental cycle is to establish a relation between the pbbs and the one obtained from it by @xmath11-elimiantion . for a given state of the pbbs , we obtain a pattern of the state of a smaller pbbs by @xmath11-elimination .
a soliton with length @xmath94 ( @xmath150 ) turns into a soliton with length @xmath151 , and a 1-soliton disappears .
however , it is convenient to think of it as turning into a _ @xmath210-soliton _ a soliton with length @xmath210 which has no entry but has a _ position_. to make the idea clear , consider the following example .
a state @xmath211 contains two 1-solitons , the @xmath7s which are underlined . by @xmath11-elimination
, we obtain a new pattern @xmath212 in this new sequence , however , we can denote the places where @xmath84-solitons existed before the 10-elimination as @xmath213 so we may think that @xmath210-solitons exist between two consecutive entries separated by a @xmath89 . of course , the notion of a _
@xmath210-soliton _ only has meaning when we eliminate @xmath84-solitons by @xmath11-elimination .
an advantage to consider the @xmath210-solitons is that we can devise a reverse operation for @xmath11-elimination .
i.e. we can reconstruct the original state from the new sequence if we allow the existence of @xmath210-solitons .
when there are solitons with the same length , we can define the _ effective distance _ between two of them with respect to the notion of a @xmath210-soliton .
[ effective - distance ] when there are two solitons with the same length , we perform @xmath11-elimination repeatedly and turn them into @xmath210-solitons .
we denote the distance between these two @xmath210-solitons by the effective distance between them . here the distance between the two @xmath210-solitons is understood as the number of entries between them .
for example , the effective distance between the above two @xmath84-solitons is five .
an important property of the effective distance is [ conservation - distance ] the effective distance between two solitons does not change in time . by lemma [ lemma2 ]
, @xmath11-elimination commutes with the updating rule of a pbbs .
hence it is enough to prove the proposition for two @xmath84-solitons .
if there is no soliton with length more than one , the proposition is trivial . if the @xmath84-solitons themselves form blocks , _
i.e. _ , if they do not belong to a block together with a larger soliton , the statement of the proposition is also obvious because they will move by @xmath200 and the number of @xmath10s between the two solitons does not change at the next time step . at time
@xmath22 , let us consider the block to which one of the @xmath84-solitons belongs .
the block is composed of consecutive @xmath7s and @xmath6s and they change to @xmath6s and @xmath7s at the next time step .
let @xmath16 and @xmath214 , respectively , be the position of the @xmath7 at the left edge of the block and of the @xmath6 at the right edge .
suppose that there are @xmath215 @xmath10s on the right of the @xmath84-soliton in the block , and @xmath216 @xmath10s on the left of it .
( hence there are @xmath217 @xmath10s in the block . ) when we eliminate @xmath10s at @xmath22 the number of entries in the block decreases by @xmath218 .
let the distance between the @xmath210-soliton and the right ( left ) edge of the reduced block be @xmath219 ( @xmath220 ) . from proposition [ move-1-soliton ] , the @xmath84-soliton moves by @xmath200 or @xmath201 in the next time step .
if it moves by @xmath200 , the number of @xmath10s in the block which exist to the right of the @xmath84-soliton does not change .
( we take into account the @xmath10 at the right edge of the block as well . )
since the total number of @xmath10s does not change in a block at @xmath22 , the number of @xmath10s to the left of the @xmath84-soliton does not change either . on the other hand , when it moves by @xmath201 , the number of @xmath10s to its right increases by one and the number of those on its left decreases by one . hence
, if we eliminate @xmath10s at @xmath23 , the distance between the @xmath210-soliton and the @xmath7 next to the right edge of the block , which was originally at the position @xmath221 , is also @xmath219 in both cases .
it is also clear that the distance between the @xmath210-soliton and the @xmath6 next to the left edge , which was at the position @xmath222 , is also @xmath220 .
therefore , when we perform @xmath11-elimination , the position of the @xmath210-soliton in the reduced block does not change by the updating rule , where the reduced block at @xmath23 is defined as the sequence starting from the @xmath6 which was at @xmath222 to the @xmath7 which was at @xmath221 . since the distance between the reduced blocks does not change under time evolution , even for a block of @xmath210-soliton obtained from a block of @xmath84-solitons , the effective distance between two @xmath84-solitons does not change in time evolution , which completes the proof . from the above proposition , we know that the effective distance is also a conserved quantity of the pbbs .
the pbbs sometimes has some hidden symmetry which makes it difficult to determine the fundamental cycle .
the symmetry appears when there are solitons with the same length .
suppose that there are more than one solitons with length @xmath94 . by applying @xmath11-elimination for @xmath94 times ,
these solitons turn into @xmath210-solitons .
let @xmath223 be the size of the reduced pbbs .
we denote the positions of the @xmath210-solitons in this reduced pbbs by @xmath224 . here
@xmath19 is understood as the position of the right box adjacent to the @xmath185th @xmath210-soliton .
let @xmath225 be the smallest positive integer which satisfies @xmath226 ( note that the positions are defined modulo @xmath223 . )
the number @xmath225 ( @xmath227 ) is a divisor of @xmath223 and we put @xmath228 . by proposition
[ conservation - distance ] , @xmath229 does not change in time .
in this situation , we define the effective symmetry as follows .
[ effective - symmetry ] let @xmath229 be the positive integer defined above .
then , the solitons with length @xmath94 in the pbbs are said to have effective translational symmetry of order @xmath229 .
for example , a sequence @xmath230 has three @xmath84-solitons . by @xmath11-elimination , we have @xmath231 _ i.e. _ ; @xmath232 , @xmath233 and hence the @xmath84-solitons have effective translational symmetry of order @xmath85 .
now we fix the system and its initial state at @xmath234 . as in section 1
, we consider a pbbs with @xmath3 boxes .
we assume that the initial state has @xmath235 solitons with length @xmath163 @xmath236 , where @xmath29 .
we also put @xmath31 , and @xmath237 the initial state turns to a state of a smaller pbbs by @xmath11-elimination . by
pbbs _ , we denote the pbbs which has as an initial state , the one obtained by @xmath238 times @xmath11-elimination performed on the original initial state .
the position of the origin of the @xmath41-th pbbs can be determined arbitrarily .
the size of the @xmath41-th pbbs , @xmath239 , is given as @xmath240 in particular , @xmath241 .
the pbbs is then updated according to the time evolution rule and after some time period it will take the same pattern as the initial state except for some translation .
we call such period as a _ relative cycle_. the shortest relative cycle is called _ the fundamental relative cycle_. apparently , the fundamental cycle is a relative cycle and an integer multiple of the fundamental relative cycle .
the following lemma is used to establish the relation between the fundamental cycle of the @xmath41-th pbbs and the fundamental relative cycle of the @xmath176-th pbbs .
[ lemma9 ] when the smallest soliton has length @xmath242 in a pbbs , the fundamental relative cycle of the pbbs coincides with that of the reduced pbbs obtained by @xmath11-elimination . from lemma [ lemma2 ] , we have that the fundamental relative cycle of the pbbs is the relative cycle of the reduced pbbs .
since the number of solitons does not change by @xmath11-elimination in this case , we can reconstruct the pattern from the reduced pattern by adding @xmath10s to the left of the solitons .
thus the fundamental relative cycle of the reduced pbbs is also a relative cycle of the original pbbs . for a pattern in a pbbs which contains at @xmath22 a @xmath84-soliton
, we obtain a pattern for a reduced pbbs by @xmath11-elimination .
the @xmath84-soliton turns into a @xmath210-soliton in that pattern .
if we now shift this pattern such that the position of this @xmath210-soliton is situated at the left ( the midpoint between the position @xmath210 and @xmath84 ) , we can define a map from a sequence of the pbbs to a sequence of the reduced pbbs .
we shall denote this map by @xmath243 .
here @xmath244 denotes the position of the @xmath84-soliton .
for example , a sequence @xmath245 is mapped by @xmath246 to @xmath247 where @xmath89 denotes the position of @xmath210-soliton .
an important property of this map is that it commutes with time evolution , namely , [ lemma10 ] let @xmath248 be a sequence of a pbbs at @xmath22 with a @xmath84-soliton at position @xmath244 .
then we have @xmath249 where @xmath250 denote the time evolution in the reduced pbbs . by lemma [ lemma2 ] ,
the sequence @xmath251 is equivalent to @xmath252 .
hence it suffices to show that the position of one specific soliton coincides in both sequences .
the sequence @xmath248 consisits of blocks .
first we consider the case where the @xmath84-soliton at @xmath244 itself constitutes a block .
let @xmath220 be the distance between the @xmath84-soliton at @xmath22 and the right edge of the block nearest to it on the left . since the position of the largest soliton in the block becomes the right edge of the block ( corollary [ scatteringlength ] ) , after @xmath11-elimination , there are @xmath253 @xmath6s between the @xmath210-soliton and the nearest soliton on its left .
namely , the position of the soliton nearest to it on the left , is @xmath254 . on the other hand ,
the blocks of the sequence @xmath255 are obtained by eliminating all the @xmath10s , changing indices @xmath41 to @xmath149 and @xmath98 to @xmath256 @xmath257 , and letting the position of the @xmath210-soliton be the midpoint between the entries at position @xmath210 and @xmath84 . since the updating rule is equivalent to changing @xmath6s in the block to @xmath7s and @xmath7s to @xmath6 , we find that the position of the largest soliton in the block becomes @xmath254 at @xmath23 .
thus , we find that relation ( [ commuting.property ] ) holds .
next we consider the case where the @xmath84-soliton belongs to a block together with a larger soliton . as is shown in the proof of proposition [ conservation - distance ] , the distance ( number of entries ) between the @xmath210-soliton and the right edge of the block at @xmath22 , coincides with that between the position of the largest soliton and the @xmath210-soliton at @xmath23 .
since the distance from the @xmath210-soliton to the right edge is equal to the position of the largest soliton of the block in @xmath252 , the position of the largest soliton in the block in @xmath251 coincides with that in @xmath252 , which completes the proof . from this lemma , and because the effective distance between @xmath84-solitons does not change by proposition [ conservation - distance ] , we find that the positions of all the @xmath210-solitons in @xmath255 coincide with those in @xmath251 .
we state this fact as a lemma : [ lemma11 ] the positions of all the @xmath210-solitons in @xmath255 coincide with those in @xmath251 using these lemmas , we can prove the key proposition : [ fundamental - relation ] the fundamental cycle of the @xmath41-th pbbs is a relative cycle of the @xmath176-th pbbs . if the smallest solitons in the @xmath176-th pbbs do not have effective translational symmetry , it is the fundamental relative cycle of the @xmath176-th pbbs .
we denote the pattern at @xmath22 of the @xmath176-th pbbs by @xmath248 .
we choose one of the @xmath84-soliton and denote its position at @xmath22 by @xmath244 . without loss of generality , we can assume the sequence of the @xmath41-th system at @xmath234 to coincide with @xmath258 . by lemma [ lemma10 ]
, we have @xmath259 where @xmath250 is the time evolution operator for the @xmath41-th pbbs .
therefore we find @xmath260 if @xmath261 is the fundamental cycle of the @xmath41-th pbbs , ( [ commutativity ] ) implies @xmath262 since by lemma [ lemma11 ] the above relation holds up to the position of @xmath210-solitons , @xmath263 is equivalent to @xmath264
. therefore @xmath261 is a relative cycle of the @xmath176-th pbbs .
conversely , if @xmath261 is the fundamental relative cycle of the @xmath176-th pbbs , @xmath263 is equivalent to @xmath264 , and @xmath265 .
however , if the @xmath84-solitons in the @xmath176-th pbbs do not have the effective translational symmetry , @xmath192 must be @xmath266 by lemma [ lemma11 ] .
thus we find @xmath267 which means that @xmath261 is a cycle of the @xmath41-th pbbs .
since @xmath261 is the shortest relative cycle of the @xmath176-th pbbs and the fundamental cycle of @xmath41-th pbbs is a relative cycle of the @xmath176-th pbbs , @xmath261 is the fundamental cycle of the @xmath41-th pbbs .
now we determine the fundamental cycle of the pbbs for a given initial state .
we divide the initial states into two cases .
first we assume that no soliton has effective translational symmetry .
since there are only solitons with length @xmath268 and the size of the system is @xmath269 , the fundamental cycle of the first system @xmath270 is obtained as @xmath271 where @xmath272 denotes the least common multiple of @xmath269 and @xmath268 . during this period
, a soliton passes the origin ( the position of the @xmath210-soliton ) of the first pbbs exactly @xmath273 times , where @xmath274 from proposition [ fundamental - relation ] , the fundamental relative cycle of the second pbbs is @xmath270 .
the fundamental cycle @xmath275 is an integer multiple of the relative cycle . to determine @xmath275 , we look for the distance @xmath276 over which the largest soliton will move during the period @xmath270 .
since the largest soliton in the second pbbs has length @xmath277 and it collides @xmath273 times with each one of the smaller solitons during the fundamental relative cycle , by corollary [ scatteringlength ] , we obtain @xmath278 hence , the fundamental cycle of the second system is given as @xmath279 , where @xmath280 during this period @xmath275 , the largest soliton passes @xmath281 times through the origin of the second pbbs , where @xmath282 in a similar manner , the largest soliton in the third pbbs has length @xmath283 and its shift during the period @xmath275 is given as @xmath284 the fundamental cycle @xmath285 is given as @xmath286 , where @xmath287 and it passes the origin @xmath288 times , where @xmath289 repeating the above procedure , we find that the fundamental cycle of the pbbs is given by the following theorem [ maintheorem1 ] when there is no effective translational symmetry of solitons in a pbbs , the fundamental cycle @xmath261 of the pbbs is given as @xmath290 where @xmath291 is obtained recursively as @xmath292 here @xmath293 and @xmath239 @xmath294 are defined as in ( [ ell_j ] ) and ( [ n_j ] ) . in order to rewrite this formula in a compact way , we note first that @xmath295 equation ( [ s_k - n_k - relation ] ) is proved by induction . we give a proof in appendix b. noticing the identity @xmath296 we have @xmath297 where @xmath298 and @xmath299 the map @xmath300 @xmath301 is naturally extended to the map @xmath302 as @xmath303 } 3^{\max[a_2,b_2 ] } 5^{\max[a_3,b_3 ] } 7^{\max[a_4,b_4]}\cdots \quad ( a_j , b_j \in \z ) .
\label{extensionlcm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we also define @xmath304 _ etc .
_ , as @xmath305 . from ( [ new - t_k ] ) and ( [ q_k ] ) we obtain , @xmath306 and @xmath307
thus we have @xmath308 hence , from ( [ fundamental - cycle ] ) , we obtain [ fundamentalcorollary ] @xmath309 for example , the pbbs with the initial state @xmath310 has four types of solitons with lengths 5 , 4 , 2 , and 1 .
the values of the parameters are caluculated as @xmath311 , @xmath312 , @xmath313 , @xmath314 , @xmath315 , @xmath316 , @xmath317 , @xmath318 and @xmath319 .
hence its fundamental cycle is @xmath320 * case 2 * _ solitons with effective translational symmetry _
the main difference with the previous case is that the fundamental cycle of the @xmath41-th pbbs is a relative cycle of the @xmath176-th pbbs , but not necessarily the fundamental relative cycle .
when the largest solitons do not have effective symmetry however , the fundamental relative cycle can be determined easily and the above arguments require only slight modification . in the first pbbs
the @xmath210-solitons , obtained by @xmath11-elimination on the second pbbs , are arranged periodically . if we put @xmath321 , @xmath322 is the period of the translational symmetry .
hence the fundamental relative cycle of the second pbbs @xmath323 is given as @xmath324 if we put @xmath325 a largest soliton collides with @xmath210-solitons exactly @xmath326 times during the period @xmath323 .
hence , in the second pbbs , the largest soliton moves the distance @xmath327 where @xmath328 .
similarly , the fundamental relative cycle of the third pbbs is @xmath329 we can proceed in a similar manner to the above and find that all the formulae given in theorem [ maintheorem1 ] hold with the change @xmath330 , @xmath331 _ etc . _ , that is , the fundamental cycle @xmath261 of the pbbs is given as @xmath332 where @xmath333 is obtained recursively as @xmath334 here @xmath335 , @xmath336 , @xmath337 is the order of the effective translational symmetry of the @xmath41th largest solitons for @xmath338 , @xmath339 , and @xmath293 and @xmath239 @xmath294 are defined as in ( [ ell_j ] ) and ( [ n_j ] ) .
however , as in this case , there is no relation like ( [ s_k - n_k - relation ] ) , we so far have not found a compact expression like ( [ mainformula ] ) . when the largest soliton has effective translational symmetry , the determination of the fundamental cycle becomes a little complicated .
for example , the sequence of the first pbbs @xmath340 is updated as @xmath341 where @xmath89 denotes the @xmath210-solitons obtained from the second pbbs . apparently , the fundamental relative cycle of the second pbbs is just one time step .
although the largest soliton moves only two boxes , the distance between a pattern at @xmath22 and the same pattern at @xmath23 is eight .
hence , in this example , we have to think of the largest soliton as being shifted by a distance of eight boxes . in general
, when we shift the largest solitons by @xmath342 , the sequences coincide up to translation . here
@xmath337 denotes the order of the effective translational symmetry of the @xmath41th largest solitons .
then the fundamental relative cycle of the second pbbs is given as @xmath343 the distance separating it from the same pattern , @xmath344 , is calculated as follows .
let @xmath345 be a solution to the diophantine equation @xmath346 then @xmath347 in this expression , @xmath348 is the number of @xmath210-solitons between a largest soliton at @xmath22 and the ` corresponding ' largest soliton at @xmath349 ; @xmath350 is the number of largest solitons between the largest soliton at @xmath349 which ` really ' moved during the time period @xmath323 and the corresponding largest soliton at @xmath349 .
hence , in the second pbbs , the shift of the largest soliton is considered to be @xmath351 when @xmath352 , the second pbbs also has translational symmetry and the fundamental relative cycle of the third pbbs becomes @xmath353 , where @xmath354 the shift of the largest solitons in the third pbbs is obtained in a similar manner as @xmath355 where @xmath356 is a solution to the diophantine equation @xmath357 the fundamental relative cycle of the fourth pbbs is obtained from @xmath358 in a similar manner to ( [ newet_2 ] ) . repeating the same procedure , we obtain the fundamental cycle of the pbbs as @xmath359 , where @xmath360\nonumber \\ & & \quad + \prod_{i=3}^{j-1}t_i^ { * } \left [ 2\left(\frac{n_1+n_2}{k_2}p_2+n_3^{*}q_2\right ) \left(\sum_{i=3}^j \ell_j\right ) + \frac{n_2}{k_2 } p_2 \right]\nonumber \\ & & \qquad \quad \cdots \nonumber \\ & & \qquad + 2\left ( \frac{\sum_{i=1}^{j-1 } n_i}{k_{j-1}}p_{j-1 } + n_j^ { * } q_{j-1 }
\right)\ell_j + \frac{n_{j-1}}{k_{j-1 } } p_{j-1 } \label{news_j}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath361 is a solution to the diophantine equation @xmath362 therefore we have found a formula to obtain the fundamental cycle of the pbbs for an arbitrary initial state .
[ nexttheorem1 ] the fundamental cycle @xmath261 of the pbbs is given as @xmath363 where @xmath364 is obtained recursively from ( [ recursion2 ] ) if the largest solitons have no effective translational symmetry , or from ( [ newt_j ] ) in the general case .
in this article , we have shown a formula to determine the fundamental cycle of a pbbs for a given initial state .
the pbbs is obtained from the ultradiscretization of the discrete toda equation with periodic boundary condition .
since the toda equation with periodic boundary conditions has quasiperiodic solutions which are expressed by theta functions associated to hyperelliptic curves@xcite , one may expect that the fundamental cycle has some relation with the period matrices of the theta functions .
establishing such a relation is a problem we wish to address in the future .
although we have treated the pbbs with box capacity one and with only one kinds of balls , it can be extended to the case with box capacity larger than one and many kinds of balls .
the determination of the fundamental cycle for such an extended pbbs is also a future problem .
finally , we wish to point out one important property of the original bbs which can be derived from the results in the previous sections .
note that the bbs corresponds to the case of the pbbs where the number of boxes @xmath365 .
the solitons are defined in exactly the same way and they are also conserved in time . from corollary [ scatteringlength ] ,
lemma [ lemma10 ] and [ lemma11 ] , we obtain [ ninfty ] in the original bbs , after sufficient time steps , the solitons are arranged according to the order of their lengths and move freely . in the bbs ,
solitons as defined here behave like _ solitons _ in nonlinear differential equations , which justify the use of the word ` soliton ' .
* acknowledgements * the authors are grateful to prof
. j. satsuma and dr .
r. willox for helpful comments on the present work .
99 s. wolfram , _ cellular automata and complexity _ , addison - wesley , reading , ma ( 1994 ) .
d. takahashi and j. satsuma , _
jpn . _ * 59 * , 3514 ( 1990 ) .
d. takahashi , proceedings of the international symposium on nonlinear theory and its applications , nolta93 , 555 ( 1991 ) . t. tokihiro , d. takahashi , j. matsukidaira and j. satsuma , _ phys .
lett . _ * 76 * , 3247 ( 1996 ) .
k. fukuda , m. okado , and y. yamada , _ int .
phys . _ * a 15 * , 1379 ( 2000 ) .
g. hatayama , k. hikami , r. inoue , a. kuniba , t. takagi , and t. tokihiro , _ j. math . phys . _
* 42 * , 274 ( 2001 ) .
f. yura and t. tokihiro , _ j. phys . a : math .
gen . _ * 35 * , 3787 ( 2002 ) .
d. yoshihara , _
master thesis of university of tokyo _ ( in japanese ) ( 2001 ) .
m. kac and p. van moerbeke , _ proc .
usa _ * 72 * , 1627 , 2879 ( 1975 ) .
e. date and s. tanaka , _ prog .
phys . _ * 55 * , 457 ( 1976 ) ; _ prog .
suppl . _ * 59 * , 107 ( 1976 ) .
m. torii , d. takahashi and j. satsuma , physica * d92 * , 209 ( 1996 ) .
we use the terminology of sections 2 and 3 . for a given state of the pbbs
, we construct a state of the @xmath41-th pbbs by performing @xmath11-elimination @xmath238 times .
in particular , after @xmath62 eliminations , we obtain a sequence of @xmath366 consecutive @xmath6s .
we then fix the position of one of such @xmath6s . to obtain a state of the first system
, we should put @xmath61 @xmath210-solitons next to these consecutive @xmath6s .
the number of such possible configurations is @xmath367 .
each configuration corresponds to a state of the first system . to obtain a state of the second system
, we put @xmath75 @xmath210-solitons next to the previous state .
the number of possible configurations is @xmath368 . repeating this procedure
, we see that the number of states for a fixed @xmath6 is @xmath369 there are @xmath3 possibilities for the position of the fixed @xmath6 , but any one of @xmath366 @xmath6s gives the same results .
thus we find that the number of states @xmath34 is given as @xmath370
we prove ( [ s_k - n_k - relation ] ) by induction .
since @xmath371 , @xmath372 and @xmath373 , we have @xmath374\\ & = & t_1\left [ ( \ell_1+\ell_2)+\frac{\ell_1}{n_1}\cdot 2n_2 \ell_2 \right]\\ & = & \frac{t_1}{n_1}\left [ \ell_1\left ( \ell_0 + 2n_1(\ell_1+\ell_2 ) + 2 n_2 \ell_2 \right ) + \ell_0 \ell_2 \right]\\ & = & r_1 n_2 + \frac{t_1\ell_2 \ell_0}{n_1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] hence ( [ s_k - n_k - relation ] ) is true for @xmath375 .
suppose that ( [ s_k - n_k - relation ] ) holds up to @xmath376 @xmath377 .
we rewrite @xmath378 as @xmath379 + 2 r_{m-1 } n_m \ell_m \label{a0}\end{aligned}\ ] ] using the relation @xmath380 and @xmath381 , we have @xmath382 \label{a1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] by the induction hypothesis , @xmath383 and @xmath384 consecutive use of the induction hypothesis yields , @xmath385 substituting ( [ a2 ] ) into ( [ a1 ] ) , we obtain @xmath386 therefore ( [ s_k - n_k - relation ] ) is proved . | we investigate a soliton cellular automaton ( box - ball system ) with periodic boundary conditions .
since the cellular automaton is a deterministic dynamical system that takes only a finite number of states , it will exhibit periodic motion .
we determine its fundamental cycle for a given initial state . |
magnetic fields are a major agent in the ism and also control the density and propagation of cosmic rays .
the radio infrared correlation indicates that turbulent fields are strongest in star - forming regions .
magnetic fields and cosmic rays can provide the pressure to drive galactic outflows .
outflows from starburst galaxies in the early universe may have magnetized the intergalactic medium . in spite of our increasing knowledge of cosmic magnetic fields , many important questions ,
especially their origin , strength in intergalactic space , first occurrence in young galaxies and their dynamical importance for galaxy evolution remain unanswered .
the most promising mechanism to sustain magnetic fields in the interstellar medium of galaxies is the _
dynamo_. in young galaxies a small - scale dynamo probably amplified seed fields from the protogalactic phase to the energy density level of turbulence within less than @xmath2 yr ( schleicher et al .
@xcite ) . to explain the generation of large - scale fields in galaxies , the mean - field dynamo has been developed ( beck et al .
it is based on turbulence , differential rotation and helical gas flows , driven by supernova explosions ( gressel et al .
@xcite ) and cosmic rays ( hanasz et al .
the mean - field dynamo in galaxy disks predicts that within a few @xmath2 yr large - scale regular fields are excited from the seed fields ( arshakian et al .
@xcite ) , forming patterns ( `` modes '' ) with different azimuthal symmetries in the disk and vertical symmetries in the halo .
most of what we know about galactic magnetic fields comes through the detection of radio waves .
the intensity of _ synchrotron emission _ is a measure of the number density of cosmic - ray electrons and of the strength of the total magnetic field component in the sky plane .
the assumption of energy equipartition between the total cosmic rays and total magnetic fields allows us to calculate the total magnetic field strength from the synchrotron intensity ( beck & krause @xcite ) .
polarized emission originates from ordered fields .
as polarization `` vectors '' are ambiguous by @xmath3 , they can not distinguish _ regular ( coherent ) fields _ , defined to have a constant direction within the telescope beam , from _ anisotropic fields _ , which are generated from turbulent fields by compressing or shearing gas flows , so that their direction frequently reverses perpendicular to the flow direction .
unpolarized synchrotron emission indicates _ turbulent fields _ which have random directions .
the intrinsic degree of linear polarization of synchrotron emission is about 75% .
the observed degree of polarization is smaller due to the contribution of unpolarized thermal emission , by _ faraday depolarization _ along the line of sight and across the beam ( sokoloff et al .
@xcite ) and by geometrical depolarization due to variations of the field orientation within the beam . at radio wavelengths of a few centimeters and below , the orientation of the observed b vector is parallel to the field orientation , so that the magnetic patterns of many galaxies can be mapped directly ( e.g. beck @xcite ) . at longer wavelengths , the observed polarization vector is rotated in a magnetized thermal plasma by _
faraday rotation_. the rotation angle increases with the square of the wavelength @xmath4 and with the _ rotation measure ( rm ) _ , which is the integral of the plasma density and the strength of the component of the field along the line of sight . as the rotation angle is sensitive to the sign of the field direction , only regular fields give rise to faraday rotation , while anisotropic and random fields do not .
the gravitational potential of strongly barred galaxies drives noncircular orbits and gas inflow . in many barred galaxies
a circumnuclear ring is formed .
numerical models show that gas streamlines are deflected in the bar region along shock fronts , behind which the cold gas is compressed in a fast shearing flow ( athanassoula @xcite ) .
the compression regions traced by massive dust lanes develop along the edge of the bar that is leading with respect to the galaxy s rotation because the gas rotates faster than the bar pattern .
20 galaxies with large bars were observed with the very large array ( vla ) and with the australia telescope compact array ( atca ) ( beck et al .
the total radio luminosity ( a measure of the total magnetic field strength ) is strongest in galaxies with high far - infrared luminosity ( indicating high star - formation activity ) , a result similar to that in non - barred galaxies .
the average radio intensity , radio luminosity and star - formation activity all correlate with the relative bar length .
polarized emission was detected in 17 of the 20 barred galaxies .
ngc 1097 ( fig .
[ fig : n1097 ] ) is one of the nearest barred galaxies and hosts a huge bar of about 16kpc length .
the total and polarized radio intensities are strongest in the downstream region of the dust lanes ( southeast of the center ) by compression of turbulent fields in the bar s shock .
the pattern of field lines in ngc 1097 is similar to that of the gas streamlines as obtained in numerical simulations ( athanassoula @xcite ) .
this suggests that the ordered magnetic field is aligned with the flow and amplified by shear .
remarkably , the optical image of ngc 1097 shows dust filaments in the upstream region which are aligned with the ordered field ( fig .
[ fig : n1097 ] ) . between the region upstream of the southern bar and the downstream region
the field lines smoothly change their orientation by almost @xmath5 .
the ordered field is also hardly compressed , probably coupled to the diffuse gas and strong enough to affect its flow ( beck et al .
@xcite ) . the polarization pattern in barred galaxies can be used as a tracer of shearing gas flows in the sky plane and complements spectroscopic measurements of radial velocities .
barred galaxies can create a gas reservoir and starburst in the central kiloparsec , fuelling an agn needs other processes ( e.g. davies et al .
the central regions of barred galaxies are often sites of ongoing intense star formation and strong magnetic fields .
bright radio emission has been observed in several galaxies with the following equipartition strengths of the total magnetic fields ( beck et al .
@xcite ) : * ngc 1097 : @xmath6@xmath7 g in the circumnuclear ring , 50@xmath7 g in the ring knots * ngc 1365 : @xmath8@xmath7 g in the dust lanes ( no ring ) * ngc 1672 : @xmath9@xmath7 g in the ring knots * ngc 7552 : @xmath10@xmath7 g in the ring note that these values are lower limits because the energy densities of cosmic - ray protons and electrons in starburst regions are reduced by various losses ( thompson et al .
this is supported by an investigation of the @xmath11-ray and radio emission from the starburst galaxies m 82 and ngc 253 which suggests that most of the radio emission is from secondaries undergoing strong bremsstrahlung and ionization losses ( lacki et al .
@xcite ) .
one of the key problems of agn physics is how to fuel the nucleus with gas from the central region , which needs outwards transport of angular momentum ( davies et al .
magnetic fields can help here .
the circumnuclear ring of ngc 1097 is bright in the optical , ir and radio spectral ranges .
it has a diameter of about 1.5kpc and an active nucleus in its center ( fig .
[ fig : n1097_center ] ) .
the nonthermal and weakly polarized radio emission is a signature of strong turbulent magnetic fields ( beck et al .
@xcite ) . magnetic stress in the differentially rotating circumnuclear ring can drive mass inflow ( balbus & hawley @xcite ) at a rate of : @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the surface mass density , @xmath14 its angular rotation velocity and @xmath15 is the magnetic stress tensor . @xmath16 and @xmath17 denote the radial and azimuthal field components .
its dominant component can be written in terms of the alfvn velocity @xmath18 as @xmath19 .
this yields : @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the scale height of the gas , @xmath22 the strength of the turbulent field and @xmath23 that of the ordered field .
the correlation between @xmath24 and @xmath25 is generated by shear from differential rotation .
for ngc 1097 , @xmath26pc , @xmath27km / s at 1kpc radius , @xmath2850@xmath7 g and @xmath2910@xmath7 g give an inflow rate of several @xmath30/yr , which is sufficient to fuel the activity of the nucleus of this galaxy ( beck et al .
this mechanism can be expected to operate in many galaxies .
equipartition between the energy densities of cosmic rays and magnetic fields yields : @xmath31 where @xmath32 is the total field strength , @xmath33 is the radio synchrotron intensity which is proportional to the infrared intensity @xmath34 ( the radio - infrared correlation ) and hence to the star - formation rate @xmath35 .
the relation between the bolometric luminosity of agns @xmath36 and the @xmath35 of their hosts ( e.g. trakhtenbrot & netzer @xcite ) can be explained by this scenario .
the relation between the accretion rate and sfr ( eq .
3 ) should be tested with a sample of galaxies .
the ordered field in the ring of ngc 1097 has a spiral pattern and extends towards the nucleus .
its pitch angle agrees with that of the spiral filaments seen in dust and h@xmath37 ( prieto et al .
@xcite , davies et al .
@xcite ) , suggesting gas inflow along the magnetic field lines .
radio emission is a tracer of star formation also in distant galaxies .
the radio infrared correlation holds to redshifts of at least @xmath38 ( murphy @xcite ) , indicating strong magnetic fields in young galaxies , probably generated by the turbulent dynamo mechanism ( schleicher et al .
infrared observations indicate that star formation in the hosts of the most luminous agns peaked at @xmath38 and decreased at later epochs ( serjeant et al .
@xcite ) , which is consistent with the evolution of the accretion rate onto supermassive black holes ( trakhtenbrot et al .
the strong magnetic fields in young galaxies may serve as the link between star formation and accretion .
ngc 253 is a prototypical starburst galaxy , hosting a starburst nucleus ( brunthaler et al .
its high inclination of @xmath39 allows observing the extraplanar emission . the bright radio halo ( fig .
[ fig : n253 ] ) is probably a result of a galactic wind with a speed of about 300km / s ( heesen et al .
@xcite ) .
radio observations of the inner starburst region with high resolution revealed four filaments with widths of less than 40pc and lengths of at least 500pc ( fig .
[ fig : n253_center ] ) .
these are interpreted as the boundaries of the outflow cone of hot gas interacting with the halo gas ( heesen et al .
the equipartition strength of the total field in the filaments is at least 40@xmath7 g , that in the central region @xmath1 g .
faraday rotation measures ( rm ) between 3 cm and 6 cm wavelengths are consistent with an axisymmetric , even - parity , spiral magnetic field in the disk at radii of more than 2kpc , while the field in the inner disk is anisotropic ( heesen et al .
@xcite ) . near the se minor axis , in the region of the x - ray outflow cone ( fig .
[ fig : n253_x ] ) , rm jumps between + 300radm@xmath40 and -300radm@xmath40 .
this is interpreted as the faraday rotation of the polarized emission from the background disk by the helical field in the walls of the outflow extending to at least 1.2kpc from the center ( fig .
[ fig : n253_model ] ) . only the inner part of this helical field structure is seen in emission ( fig .
[ fig : n253_center ] ) .
the northern outflow cone is located behind the disk , so that its x - ray emission is mostly absorbed and can not faraday - rotate the radio emission .
the galaxy ngc 3079 hosts an energetic wind - driven outflow which extends 3kpc above and below the plane ( duric & seaquist @xcite ) and emits strong and highly polarized synchrotron emission , in contrast to ngc 253 .
radio - bright nuclear outflows seem to be rare .
magnetic fields in the central regions of galaxies are dynamically important .
magnetic stress drives gas inflow from the circumnuclear regions towards the nuclei .
this process connects the star formation activity to the accretion rate and could be important for the formation of supermassive black holes . ordered fields as observed by polarized radio emission may trace the direction of gas in- and outflows .
results have been obtained so far only for radio - bright and nearby galaxies .
a better insight into the interaction between gas and magnetic fields , especially near galactic nuclei , needs higher resolution and higher sensitivity .
the _ evla _ has largely improved the sensitivity for radio continuum observations .
the _ evla _ project _ changes _ ( pi : judith irwin ) will search for outflows in a large sample of edge - on galaxies .
the goal for the next decade is the _ square kilometre array ( ska ) _ with a collecting area of about 100x that of present - day telescopes .
the ska will open a new era in the observation of cosmic magnetic fields ( beck @xcite ) .
starburst galaxies will be observable out to redshifts of @xmath38 ( murphy @xcite ) . | radio continuum observations of barred galaxies revealed strong magnetic fields of @xmath0 g in the circumnuclear starbursts .
such fields are dynamically important and give rise to magnetic stress that causes inflow of gas towards the center at a rate of several solar masses per year , possibly along the spiral field seen in radio polarization and as optical dust lanes .
this may solve the long - standing question of how to feed active nuclei , and explain the relation between the bolometric luminosity of agn nuclei and the star - formation rate of their hosts .
the strong magnetic fields generated in young galaxies may serve as the link between star formation and accretion onto supermassive black holes .
magnetic fields of @xmath1 g strength were measured in the central region of the almost edge - on starburst galaxy ngc 253 .
four filaments emerging from the inner disk delineate the boundaries of the central outflow cone of hot gas .
strong faraday rotation of the polarized emission from the background disk indicates a large - scale helical field in the outflow walls . |
proteins do not appear to fold by means of a unique mechanism and over the years several phenomenological models have been proposed for protein folding @xcite .
the framework model , for example , is based on the idea that the formation of the hydrogen - bonded secondary structural elements precedes the formation of tertiary structure @xcite , and the diffusion - collision model assumes that part of the protein folding process involves the interaction of metastable regions of structure which , when in contact , may provide additional stabilization @xcite .
chymotrypsin inhibitor 2 , a small , single domain , two - state folder with 64 residues , epitomizes the so - called nucleation - condensation ( nc ) mechanism for protein folding .
the latter was firstly investigated by shakhnovich , in the context of monte carlo lattice simulations @xcite , and by fersht through extensive protein engineering studies @xcite termed @xmath0-value analysis .
the nc mechanism can be viewed as a modified version of the nucleation - growth mechanism originally proposed by wetlaufer @xcite .
the basic premise of the nc model is the idea that once a specific set of contacts , named the folding nucleus ( fn ) , forms there is a concerted consolidation of secondary and tertiary interactions as the whole protein rapidly collapses to the native fold .
more recently , the topomer search model , which emphasizes native state s topology as a major determinant of protein folding rates has been proposed @xcite and investigated in the context of off - lattice langevin simulations @xcite . while it seems well established that the native topology , as measured by the contact order parameter @xcite , and other related quantities @xcite , is a major determinant of two - state protein folding kinetics , the question of understanding the relative roles played by native structure @xcite and protein sequence @xcite in determining the folding mechanism remains to be elucidated ( reviewed in @xcite ) . in their seminal work
@xcite , abkevich and coworkers have found that native structure is a more robust determinant of the folding mechanism than sequence for 36-mer lattice proteins .
indeed , the results of monte carlo simulations reported by abkevich and coworkers @xcite suggest that three non - homologous sequences sharing the same native fold also share a common fn . here
we use this result as the starting point of a study that is based on a novel methodology and on rather extensive statistics . a nucleation pattern driven exclusively by native structure ( and therefore by native topology )
is compared with patterns driven by the combined effects of protein structure and sequence .
if the fn is determined by native structure alone the nucleation patterns of different sequences , with the same native fold , should be similar and in addition , they should be similar to the nucleation pattern of a model whose folding dynamics is driven strictly by the structural features of the native fold .
this paper is organized as follows .
the next section describes the models used and computational methodologies adopted .
we then propose a _
new _ strategy to identify folding nuclei and present and discuss the simulation results obtained based on it for three different model proteins .
finally we draw some conclusions and compare our results with those obtained using other strategies and simulation efforts .
we consider a simple three - dimensional lattice model of a protein molecule with chain length @xmath1 .
in such a minimalist model amino acid residues , represented by beads of uniform size , occupy the lattice vertices . the peptide bond that covalently connects amino acids along the polypeptide chain ,
is represented by sticks with uniform ( unit ) length corresponding to the lattice spacing ( fig [ fold ] , top ) . in order to mimic the protein s relaxation towards the native state we use a standard monte carlo ( mc ) algorithm @xcite together with the kink - jump move set @xcite .
local random displacements of one or two beads ( at the same time ) are repeatedly accepted or rejected in accordance with the standard metropolis mc rule @xcite .
a mc simulation starts from a randomly generated unfolded conformation and the folding dynamics is monitored by following the evolution of the fraction of native contacts , @xmath2 , where @xmath3 is the number of contacts in the native fold and @xmath4 is the number of native contacts formed at each mc step .
the number of mc steps required to fold to the native state ( i.e. , to @xmath5 ) is the first passage time ( fpt ) .
the native conformation used in this study together with its contact map representation is shown in figure [ fold ] .
+ unless otherwise specified , folding is studied at the so - called optimal folding temperature , @xmath6 , the temperature that minimizes the folding time , @xmath7 , @xcite which is computed as the mean first passage time ( mfpt ) of 100 simulations .
this optimal folding temperature may differ from the folding transition temperature , @xmath8 , at which the probability for finding the protein in an unfolded state is the same as the probability for finding it in the native state . in the context of a lattice model @xmath8
may be defined as the temperature at which the average value of the fraction of native contacts @xmath9 is equal to 0.5 @xcite . in order to determine @xmath8 we averaged @xmath10 , after collapse to the native state , over mc simulations lasting at least 20 times longer than the folding time computed at @xmath6 .
protein energetics is modeled using the g and the shakhnovich models . in the g model
@xcite the energy of a conformation , defined by the set of bead coordinates @xmath11 , is given by the contact hamiltonian @xmath12 where the contact function @xmath13 , is unity if any beads @xmath14 and @xmath15 are in contact but not covalently linked , and is zero otherwise .
the g potential is based on the idea that the native fold is very well optimized energetically .
accordingly , it ascribes equal stabilizing energies , @xmath16 , to all pairs of beads @xmath14 and @xmath15 that form a contact in the native structure , and neutral energies , @xmath17 , to all non - native contacts .
by contrast with the g model , which ignores the protein s chemical composition , the shakhnovich model ( see e.g. , @xcite ) addresses the dependence of protein folding dynamics on the amino acid sequence by considering interactions between the @xmath18 different amino acids used by nature in the synthesis of real proteins .
accordingly , the contact hamiltonian that defines the energy of each conformation is given by @xmath19 where @xmath20 represents an amino acid sequence , and @xmath21 stands for the chemical identity of bead @xmath14 .
in this case both the native and the non - native contacts contribute energetically to the folding process .
the interaction parameters @xmath22 are taken from the @xmath23 miyazawa - jernigan matrix , derived from the distribution of contacts of native proteins @xcite .
two non - homologous sequences , numbered 1 and 2 , were studied within the context of the shakhnovich model .
the latter were designed to fold into the native conformation shown in figure [ fold ] with the method developed by shakhnovich and gutin based on random heteropolymer theory and simulated annealing techniques @xcite .
table [ tabdata ] summarizes some kinetic and thermodynamic properties of the model proteins discussed above .
[ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ]
we define the fn as a _ specific _ set of native contacts which , once formed , prompts rapid and highly probable folding to the native state . in what follows
we render a methodology to investigate the existence of folding nuclei in the folding of 48-mer lattice polymers whose energetics are modeled by the g or by the mj potential . the vast majority of small ( i.e. with less than 100 amino acids ) , single domain proteins fold in a two - state manner with a relaxation rate following single - exponential kinetics @xcite .
two - state folding is often rationalized through a ` classical ' mass - action scheme @xcite .
accordingly , the ensemble of conformations that make up the unfolded state ( @xmath24 ) is separated from the native fold ( @xmath25 ) by a free energy barrier along some appropriately defined reaction coordinate .
the ensemble of conformations that lie on the top of the reaction barrier is the so - called transition state ( ts ) . by definition ,
ts s conformations have folding probability @xmath26 ( in other words , ts s conformations have a probability 0.5 to fold before they unfold ) @xcite .
if folding occurs via nucleation , conformations that rapidly reach the native state with high probability @xmath27 are post - transition state conformations in which the fn is formed .
the latter is indeed a postcritical fn since its formation inevitably leads to the formation native state @xcite . in the present study
we are therefore interested in postcritical folding nuclei .
an appropriate structural analysis of a significantly large ensemble of such conformations should therefore reveal , with a high degree of statistical confidence , a set of common contacts which is the fn .
to build such an ensemble we consider 1000 different folding events and , for each individual event , we identify the earliest formed conformation ( efc ) that folds rapidly and with high probability , @xmath28 . in order to determine the efc for a given folding event
conformations are sampled at times @xmath29 where @xmath30 is an appropriate sampling interval and @xmath31 .
more precisely , starting with @xmath32 , the folding probability , @xmath33 , of the conformation collected at time @xmath34 is computed ; this amounts to determining the fraction of folding simulations ( in a set of 100 mc runs ) which , starting from that conformation reach the native state without passing through conformations with @xmath35 , i.e. , the protein folds before it unfolds ( we consider a protein to be unfolded if its fraction of native contacts is smaller than some cut - off @xmath36 ) . if @xmath37 the conformation is discarded .
otherwise , if the folding time @xmath7 is smaller than some cut - off time @xmath38 , the procedure described above is repeated for @xmath39 etc .
the efc for a given folding event is the conformation corresponding to the largest @xmath40 which has @xmath28 and @xmath41 . in the following section we discuss in some detail the procedure used to fix the parameters @xmath36 , @xmath30 and @xmath38 . while it is trivial to identify the native state ( since is the unique conformation with @xmath5 ) it is not straightforward to decide weather a conformation belongs to the ensemble of unfolded conformations or is kinetically close ( i.e. , rapidly converts ) to the native state .
the fraction of native contacts @xmath10 has been extensively used in simulation studies as a reaction coordinate , i.e. , as a parameter that quantifies the degree of folding @xcite . in general , however , @xmath10 measures closeness to the native structure in energetic ( or thermodynamic ) terms only .
it has been argued that , unless the energy landscape is considerably smooth , thermodynamic closeness does not necessarily imply kinetic proximity to the native structure @xcite .
however , even if the suitability of @xmath10 as a reaction coordinate is questionable , very small @xmath10s must necessarily identify unfolded conformations ( i.e. , that are thermodynamically and kinetically distant from the native fold ) . in order to distinguish unfolded conformations from other conformers
we have computed the probability of finding a conformation with a fraction of native contacts @xmath10 as a function of @xmath10 in a sample of 200 different folding events .
two peaks are apparent in the graph reported in figure [ free ] : a high - probability peak centered at @xmath42 and another one , of considerably lower probability , that appears immediately prior to the native fold .
the high probability peak is clearly associated with the unfolded states .
the cut - off @xmath36 is chosen such that more than half of the unfolded peak lies to the left of @xmath43 . in what follows
we take @xmath44 but note that other values of @xmath36 were tested and were found to lead to the same results .
the probability for the protein to be in high-@xmath10 conformations is small but non negligible ( fig [ free ] ) .
this happens because the optimal folding temperature @xmath6 , at which data was collected , is well below the system s folding transition temperature @xmath8 ( table [ tabdata ] ) .
accordingly , the protein may be trapped in low energy conformations that share a high degree of structural similarity with the native fold ( i.e. , whose fraction of native contacts is @xmath45 ) . by definition , the formation of the fn prompts rapid and highly probable folding ( @xmath28 ) .
the cut - off parameter @xmath38 ( i.e. , the maximum number of mc steps in which the protein is required to reach the native fold ) is therefore a particularly important step of the procedure proposed to identify the fn .
a tentative sampling interval ( about 2 orders of magnitude smaller than the folding time for this model protein ) was used to collect an ensemble of @xmath46 conformations with @xmath47 from 100 different folding events . the vast majority ( @xmath48% ) of such conformations
were found to reach the native state in time @xmath7 less than @xmath49x@xmath50 mcs while about 10% take a considerably longer time to fold ( figure [ ftime ] ) .
two ( folding ) time scales are clearly distinguished in this ensemble of conformations .
the shorter time scale corresponds to conformations where the fn has the highest probability of being formed , while the longer one is associated with folding events during which the protein is trapped in low energy states which , despite despite sharing a large similarity with the native fold , do not have the fn formed ( figure [ free ] ) . in order to eliminate the latter conformations @xmath38
was set to @xmath49x@xmath50 mcs .
the efficiency of the sampling procedure may be improved by choosing the sampling interval , @xmath30 , appropriately .
let @xmath51 be the number of mc steps required to complete folding once the efc forms at time @xmath52 in a given folding event .
we define @xmath53 as the average folding time of the efc of 100 folding events ( i.e. , @xmath53 is the average of @xmath54 computed over 100 folding events ) .
ideally , the sampling interval should be smaller than @xmath53 , or at least of the same order of magnitude . in practice , for a tentative @xmath30 , we compute @xmath53 by averaging @xmath55 in 100 folding events where @xmath25 is the maximum value of @xmath40 for each event .
we fix @xmath30 if the corresponding @xmath53 lies between 5@xmath30 or 10@xmath30 . for the model protein considered in this section
we have found that @xmath56 for @xmath57 mcs , which means that , on average , the efcs are collected at a sampling time @xmath58 . in figure [ prob ]
the dependence of @xmath33 on @xmath40 is shown for a single folding event .
the folding probability is zero when @xmath59 but as time approaches the fpt ( i.e. for @xmath60 ) the protein explores a series of conformations , with @xmath61 and reaches the native state with @xmath62 when @xmath63 .
the conformations corresponding to @xmath32 and @xmath39 have @xmath62 as well and reach the native state in time @xmath64 .
thus , the efc for this folding event is the conformation which corresponds to @xmath39 .
having fixed the parameters @xmath36 , @xmath30 and @xmath38 we ran 1000 different folding events from which an ensemble of 1000 conformations ( one conformation per folding run ) were collected .
the latter are all efcs , i.e. , the earliest conformations in folding events that collapse rapidly to the native state ( i.e. , their folding time is @xmath65 mcs ) with unit folding probability .
the average fraction of native contacts of this ensemble of conformations is @xmath66 .
we start by labeling the 57 native contacts as in table [ t1 ] .
& r@xmath67 & * contact * & r@xmath68 & r@xmath67 & * contact * & r@xmath68 & r@xmath67 & * contact * & r@xmath68 & r@xmath67 & * contact * & r@xmath68 & r@xmath67 + 0 & 0 & 41 & 12 & 6 & 35&24 & 21 & 26 & 35 & 32 & 35 & 46 & 5 & 44 + 1 & 7 & 44 & 13 & 23 & 26 & 25 & 5 & 42 & 36 & 1 & 20&47 & 14 & 33 + 2 & 10 & 47 & 14 & 27 & 34 & 26 & 6 & 41 & 37 & 2 & 21 & 48 & 15 & 34 + 3 & 11 & 32 & 15 & 28 & 33 & 27 & 7 & 40 & 38 & 3 & 22 & 49 & 17 & 36 + 4 & 12 & 33 & 16 & 0 & 35 & 28 & 8 & 39 & 39 & 4 & 23&50 & 18 & 37 + 5 & 14 & 25 & 17 & 1 & 34 & 29 & 9 & 38 & 40 & 6 & 27 & 51 & 24 & 29 + 6 & 15 & 26 & 18 & 2 & 27 & 30 & 11 & 36 & 41 & 8 & 35 & 52 & 25 & 28 + 7 & 17 & 34 & 19 & 4 & 29 & 31 & 12 & 17 & 42 & 9 & 36 & 53 & 28 & 31 + 8 & 40 & 43 & 20 & 5 & 30 & 32 & 13 & 16 & 43 & 0 & 39 & 54 & 30 & 45 + 9 & 0 & 37 & 21 & 6 & 31 & 33 & 15 & 20 & 44 & 2 & 41 & 55 & 31 & 46 + 10 & 1 & 18 & 22 & 7 & 46 & 34 & 16 & 19 & 45 & 3 & 42 & 56 & 32 & 47 + 11 & 4 & 27 & 23 & 8 & 47 + for each native contact we define the contact probability as the number of conformations in which the contact is formed normalized to the total number of conformations in the sample
. results reported in figure [ hist ] show that the contact probability varies considerably among the 57 native contacts , an observation that is particularly evident for probabilities larger than 50% .
this finding strongly suggests that , while the establishment of some contacts ( e.g. , 12 and 41 , which are present in over 95% of the conformations analyzed ) is an essential requirement to ensure rapid folding , the formation of others ( e.g. , 2 and 54 which appear with probability @xmath6940% ) does not appear to be a requisite to fast folding . the set of 9 contacts , involving residues 6 , 8 , 9 , 11 , 28
, 31 - 33 , 35 , and 36 ( figure [ nat ] , left ) , and identified by contact number in figure [ hist ] , seems to be particularly relevant .
indeed , each individual contact is formed in more than 85% of the conformations analyzed , and all of the 9 contacts are _ simultaneously _ formed in 64% of the conformers . moreover , on average , @xmath70 of them are present in the ensemble of conformations considered .
the fact that rapid folding is associated with the formation of a set of highly probable contacts suggests that such a contact set is the fn .
there is , of course , a certain degree of arbitrariness in the choice of the probability cut - off that is used to identify the highly probable contacts , and therefore the set of contacts identified above is a _ putative _ fn . in order to investigate the importance of amino acid sequence in the formation of the fn , we studied the folding of two non - homologous sequences ( numbered 1 and 2 ) ( table [ tabdata ] ) . in the g model the so - called topological frustration @xcite results from polymer properties of the chain such as connectivity @xcite , excluded volume effects , and quirks of the native topology , such as lack of symmetry @xcite .
topological frustration is the only type of frustration in models which , like the g model , are native centric . on the other hand , by taking into account the protein chemistry , the shakhnovich model also exhibits energetic frustration .
the latter typically leads to longer folding times and , at temperatures below the folding transition temperature , the chain is prone to get trapped in low energy states @xcite .
this implies that , in contrast with the g model , for which @xmath6 is well below @xmath8 , the two shakhnovich protein sequences have optimal folding temperatures which are close to the system s folding transition temperatures ( table [ tabdata ] ) .
thus , although the observed folding times are longer than those found for the g model ( table [ tabdata ] ) , the shakhnovich model proteins do not get trapped in high-@xmath10 , low energy states .
indeed , the @xmath10 probability distributions are not peaked in the high-@xmath10 ( @xmath71 ) region ( figure [ mjprob ] ) although both models exhibit a well defined , high - probability low-@xmath10 peak , at @xmath72 , corresponding to the unfolded states . applying the same criterion for the choice of cut - off @xmath36 , one considers a conformation unfolded if @xmath73 .
as before , we have found that the results for the fn are robust with respect to small variations in the choice of @xmath36 .
+ in order to fix @xmath38 , a set of @xmath74 1200 conformations ( per sequence ) , with @xmath75 , is collected from 100 different folding events and the corresponding folding times are measured . for sequence 1 ,
two folding time scales are observed ( figure [ mjtime ] , top ) .
the fraction of native contacts in the ensemble of sequence 1 s conformations is @xmath76 .
since there is a small probability for sequence 1 to be in conformations with @xmath77 0.7 ( figure [ mjprob ] ) the longer time - scale may be ascribed to the population of these relatively high-@xmath10 conformations which , being local energy minima , will slow down folding . in order to disregard these conformations the cut - off time is set to @xmath78 mcs . by contrast ,
for sequence 2 the folding times are all of the same order of magnitude ( figure [ mjtime ] , bottom ) and there is no need to use a cut - off time , @xmath38 .
the reason for taking @xmath79 , instead of @xmath80 as in the go model , is that the latter leads , in the shakhnovich model , to an ensemble of conformations with a high average fraction of native contacts ( @xmath81 ) .
the latter are practically folded and thus are not suitable to distinguish the contacts that belong to the fn from other trivial contacts . + to improve the efficiency of the sampling procedure we have , also for the shakhnovich model proteins , optimized the sampling intervals as described previously .
we have found that @xmath57 mcs works well for both proteins yielding @xmath82 mcs and @xmath83 mcs for sequence 1 and 2 respectively , i.e. , on average the efcs for sequence 1 are collected at @xmath84 while for sequence 2 they are collected at @xmath85 .
two ensembles , each comprising 1000 efcs , were obtained for sequences 1 and 2 using the parameters discussed in the previous section , with @xmath86 and @xmath87 for sequences 1 and 2 respectively .
these values of @xmath9 are similar to that of the g model and considerably lower than those obtained if @xmath80 is used for the shakhnovich model , allowing the distinction of the contacts in a putative fn from other spurious contacts .
the native structure of sequences 1 and 2 is the same as that of the g model and the same numbering of native contacts is used ( table [ t1 ] ) .
+ from the analysis of the contact histograms we observe that some native contacts are present with very high probability ( @xmath88)(figure [ histmj ] ) .
we consider the _ putative _ fn as the set of the most probable contacts . for sequence 1 the fn is thus formed by 10 native linkages ( identified by contact number in figure [ histmj ] , top ) involving 12 residues ( namely , 2 , 4 , 6 , 7 , 27 , 28 , 33 , 34 , 35 , 40 , 41 , and 43)(figure [ nat ] , center ) .
the 10 contacts forming the fn are _ simultaneously _ present in 82% of the efc conformations analyzed and , on average , the latter have 9.7 of these contacts formed .
it is interesting to note that the average stability of the contacts forming the fn is 62% higher than the average stability of the 57 native contacts of the folded protein ( table [ t2 ] ) . for sequence 2
the fn is formed by 8 native contacts ( identified by contact number in figure [ histmj ] , bottom ) and 10 residues ( namely , residues 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 32 , 35 , 39 , 40 , 44 , and 46 ) ( figure [ nat ] , right ) .
the 8 contacts forming the fn are _ simultaneously _ present in 90% of the efc conformations analyzed and , on average , the latter have 7.9 of these contacts formed . in this case
the average stability of the fn s contacts is 53% higher than the average stability of the protein s native contacts ( table [ t2 ] ) .
the two folding nuclei have 2 native contacts ( 12 and 27 ) and 4 residues in common .
these native contacts are non - local linkages between residues 6 and 35 and between residues 7 and 40 , suggesting that the establishment of the corresponding long range interactions might be determinant to ensure rapid folding . structurally speaking the fn of sequence 1
consists of two loops , one formed by residues 2 , 27 , 41 , and 6 and the other by residues , 41 , 6 , 40 , and 7 ( figure [ nat ] , center ) .
each of these loops is formed by contacts located in the interior of the protein , while in sequence 2 a significant fraction of the fn s contacts are located on the fold s surface ( figure [ nat ] , right ) .
the g fn shares 22% of its contacts with sequence 1 and 33% with sequence 2 .
the presence of these contacts in the folding nuclei of the shakhnovich models is driven by native topology .
indeed , the average stability of the shakhnovich contacts that are also present in the g model is up to 25% lower than the average stability of the remaining contacts in the fn ( table [ t2 ] , columns 3 and 4 ) but they are formed with equally high probability @xmath89% .
the extremely high probability ( @xmath741 ) of the contact between residues 6 and 35 ( i.e. contact 12 in the contact histograms ) in all the three model proteins is a robust feature of the nucleation mechanism .
another interesting observation regarding these residues is that they make - up a network of 7 native contacts in the fold ( whose average range is 25 units of backbone distance ) and about half of these contacts are present in each fn which suggests that they might be key residues in the folding process .
we have performed exhaustive single - point mutations in all of the 48 residues and , in agreement with the above hypothesis , we have found that two mutations , one on residue 6 , and the other on residue 35 , lead to the largest increases in folding times ( the folding time increases by up to 6-fold with respect to that of the wild - type sequence ) @xcite .
the average stability of the g fn s contacts that do not participate in the shakhnovich folding nuclei , of sequences 1 and 2 , is up to 66% lower than the protein s 57 native contacts ( table [ t2 ] , columns 1 and 5 ) .
by contrast , the contacts that are exclusive to the shakhnovich folding nuclei are up to 90% more stable than the protein s 57 native contacts ( table [ t2 ] , columns 1 and 4 ) .
moreover , as we have already pointed out , the shakhnovich folding nuclei are up to 81% more stable than the protein s 57 native contacts ( table [ t2 ] , columns 1 and 2 ) .
clearly , by ascribing different stabilities to the protein s native contacts , the protein sequence promotes an overall change of the nucleation scenario , which in the g model is driven solely by the topological features of the native fold . to see how this happens in more detail we investigated the effect of contact stability in the contact histogram ( i.e. in the determination of the fn ) of sequence 2 .
the most stable contacts in this case are contacts 1 , 16 , 23 , 25 , 28 , 35 , 41 , 43 , 46 , 56 ( figure [ inthist ] ) and , not surprisingly , half of them belong to the fn ( figure [ histmj ] ) .
it is interesting to note that , by being particularly stable , some contacts may indirectly promote an increase in the probability of occurrence of other less stable contacts .
this feature is well illustrated by residue 47 and the three contacts it establishes in the fold .
the latter appear with considerably high probabilities in the contact histogram .
the probabilities of contacts 23 and 56 ( which are considerably lower in the g model ) may be ascribed to their very high stabilities .
however , contact 2 is a neutral one and , in spite of its relative low stability , its probability is higher when compared with other stable contacts in the protein .
this presumably happens because the very high stability of contacts 23 and 56 forces residue 47 to be in its native environment ( i.e. to have all of its native contacts formed simultaneously ) which naturally increases the probability with which contact 2 is formed .
stability is indeed a considerably determinant factor for the shakhnovich fn , but is not the whole story .
the presence of g contacts in the nucleus , is not energetically favorable ( table [ t2 ] , columns 2 and 3 ) , but is very relevant from a functional point of view as discussed in the next section . &
protein & s@xmath90 & s@xmath90 @xmath91 g@xmath90 & s@xmath90 @xmath91 ( @xmath74 g@xmath90 ) & ( @xmath74 s@xmath90 ) @xmath91 g@xmath90 + sequence 1 & -0.427 & -0.691 & -0.579 & -0.719 & -0.424 + sequence 2 & -0.471 & -0.854 & -0.783 & -0.896 & -0.283 + despite clear differences , which are driven by contact stability , the three folding nuclei are nonetheless topologically similar .
the residues that participate in the set of native contacts forming the folding nuclei split into two groups located in different regions of the protein chain . indeed , in all cases there is a group of 4 residues located in one region of the chain that comprises residues 2 to 11 and there is another group of 6 ( or 8) residues located in a distant part of the chain that extends between residue 27 and residue 46 .
this is illustrated in figure [ nat ] where the residues whose number along the sequence is less than 12 are colored in blue while those whose number along the sequence is larger than 26 are colored in red .
it then follows that more than two thirds of the contacts that make up the folding nuclei are non - local contacts whose range lies between 18 to 30 units of backbone separation . in the three protein models the fn performs the same ` topological ' role , that of linking residues located in two distant parts of the protein chain
in the present work we have proposed and discussed in detail a methodology to the identify the folding nucleus ( i.e. a specific subset of native contacts which , once formed , prompts very rapid and highly probable folding ) in small lattice proteins and applied it to investigate the nucleation mechanism of three model proteins with chain length n=48 .
we have found that a folding nucleus ( fn ) which is solely driven by the native fold s topological features ( as it happens in the g model ) is not globally robust with regard to protein sequence .
the latter distinguishes native contacts , based on the stability of their interaction energies , and the nucleation pattern is biased towards the most stable contacts . in other words : in a ( more realistic ) lattice model , like a sequence - specific one , the fn is , to some extent , formed by the most stable contacts , and the presence of other less stable contacts in the fn is uniquely determined by the fold s topology .
however , we have found that , independently of protein sequence , the residues forming the three folding nuclei are distributed along the protein chain in a similar and well defined manner .
accordingly , the nucleation mechanism comprises the coalescence of two distinct and distant parts of the protein chain through the establishment of the long range interactions corresponding to the non - local contacts forming the fn .
therefore we conclude that the fold s topology determines , to a large extent , the overall position of the fn in the protein chain .
however , as shown by tiana _
et al . _
@xcite , sequences as dissimilar as ours may have a different set of key residues ( _ e.g. _ residues 6 and 35 in our models ) in the fn , which may lead to the latter being topologically distinct .
a particularly interesting finding of this work regards the existence of 2 residues which , in the three model systems , are involved in about 30% of the contacts forming the fn and appear to be determinant in ensuring fast folding .
we speculate that the network of native contacts formed by these residues is sufficient to determine the overall fold of the protein in a way that is similar to that found by vendruscolo _
et al . _
@xcite for a 98-residue protein model off - lattice .
previous simulation efforts on lattice models have focused on smaller ( namely n=28 @xcite and n=36 @xcite ) as well as on proteins with the same chain length @xcite .
we have found that the size of the fn is similar to the size of the nuclei identified by shakhnovich and collaborators ( containing between 8 and 11 native contacts ) which suggests that , at least for small proteins , the size of the fn does not depend on the size of the chain .
this could provide an explanation for the small correlation between chain length and folding rates found in real proteins @xcite .
generalizations of the methodology described here , may be useful to investigate the folding pathways of model proteins .
a very preliminary analysis of our data indicates that there is a higher degree of structural similarity among the efcs of the shakhnovich model than among those of the g model .
indeed , we have determined how many different native contacts exist between each pair of conformations in the three ensembles that were used to identify the fns ( i.e. in the three ensembles of efcs ) and computed its mean value over the total number of possible pairs .
we have found that , on average , two efcs in the g model differ by 11.3 native contacts . sequences 1 and 2 , on the other hand , differ by 9.7 and 7.2 native contacts respectively .
we speculate that the higher structural similarity between conformations in the shakhnovich model may be related to a smaller number of rapid folding pathways .
however , a definite conclusion requires further quantitative analysis .
pfnf would like to thank fundao para a cincia e tecnologia ( fct ) for financial support through grant sfrh / bpd/21492/2005 .
this work was also supported by fct s grants poci / fis/55592/2004 and pocti / isfl/2/618 .
rdmt wishes to thank eugene shakhnovich and guido tiana for helpful and elucidating discussions . | * for the vast majority of naturally occurring , small , single domain proteins folding is often described as a two - state process that lacks detectable intermediates .
this observation has often been rationalized on the basis of a nucleation mechanism for protein folding whose basic premise is the idea that after completion of a specific set of contacts forming the so - called folding nucleus the native state is achieved promptly . here
we propose a methodology to identify folding nuclei in small lattice polymers and apply it to the study of protein molecules with chain length n=48 . to investigate the extent to which protein topology is a robust determinant of the nucleation mechanism we compare the nucleation scenario of a native - centric model with that of a sequence specific model sharing the same native fold . to evaluate the impact of the sequence s finner details in the nucleation mechanism we consider the folding of two non- homologous sequences .
we conclude that in a sequence - specific model the folding nucleus is , to some extent , formed by the most stable contacts in the protein and that the less stable linkages in the folding nucleus are solely determined by the fold s topology .
we have also found that independently of protein sequence the folding nucleus performs the same ` topological ' function .
this unifying feature of the nucleation mechanism results from the residues forming the folding nucleus being distributed along the protein chain in a similar and well - defined manner that is determined by the fold s topological features . * |
recent observations are just beginning to reveal the epoch of cosmological reionization , which defines a fundamental transition in the universe , separating the cosmic dark ages ( e.g. rees 1997 ) from the epoch of galaxy formation and evolution .
the appearance of a gunn - peterson trough ( gunn & peterson 1965 ) in quasar spectra indicates that reionization was ending at @xmath1 ( e.g. becker et al .
2001 ; fan et al .
2002 ; white et al . 2003 ) , while the large - angle polarization anisotropy of the cosmic microwave background observed by the wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe ( spergel et al .
2006 ) indicates the universe may have been significantly reionized by @xmath2 ( page et al .
observations of lyman-@xmath3 emitting galaxies at @xmath4 are posing puzzles with regard to the reionization history at those redshifts ( e.g. haiman 2002 ; hu et al .
2002 ; malhotra & rhoads 2004 ) . in order to answer these questions
much theoretical effort is underway .
numerical studies have provided insights into the asymmetric nature of ionization fronts ( abel , norman & madau 1999 ; ciardi et al .
2001 ; alvarez , bromm , & shapiro 2006a ) , radiative feedback ( ricotti , gnedin , & shull 2002 ; shapiro , iliev , & raga 2004 ; whalen , abel , & norman 2004 ; kitayama et al . 2004 ; abel , wise , & bryan 2007 ; susa & umemura 2006 ; johnson , greif , and bromm 2006 ; ahn & shapiro 2007 ) , the reionization history ( gnedin & ostriker 1999 ; ciardi , ferrara , & white 2003 ; sokasian et al .
2004 ) , and the large - scale structure of reionization ( kohler , gnedin , & hamilton 2005a ; iliev et al . 2006a ; zahn et al .
2007 ) . because of practical limitations , numerical studies are expensive and it is difficult to know which processes to simulate directly and which to parameterize .
analytical studies can play a complementary role .
early studies modelled reionization by considering the growth of h ii regions around sources of ionizing radiation in a homogeneous expanding universe with a clumping factor ( e.g. shapiro & giroux 1987 ) . while simplistic , models based on this assumption have proved valuable ( e.g. haiman & loeb 1997 ; madau , haardt , & rees 1999 ; haiman & holder 2003 ; iliev , scannapieco , & shapiro 2005 ) . studies that describe
the thermodynamics of the igm have added additional affects such as non - equilibrium ionization and heating and an evolving uv background ( e.g. arons & wingert 1972 ; shapiro , giroux , & babul 1994 ; miralda - escude & rees 1994 ; hui & gnedin 1997 ; miralda - escude , haehnelt , & rees 2000 ; hui & haiman 2003 ; choudhury & ferrara 2005 ) . in order to understand the large scale structure of reionization , analytical models for the sizes h
ii regions during reionization have recently been developed ( wyithe & loeb 2004b ; furlanetto , zaldarriaga , & hernquist 2004 hereafter fzh04 ; furlanetto & oh 2005 ; furlanetto , mcquinn , & hernquist 2006a ; wyithe & loeb 2006 ; cohn & chang 2007 ) .
fzh04 found that typical h ii region sizes during reionization were 1 - 10 mpc .
these predictions were qualitatively verified by the radiative transfer simulations of zahn et al .
while they did not directly compare their simulations to the analytical predictions , they did develop a `` hybrid '' technique and showed that it gives strikingly similar results to their radiative transfer simulations .
the fzh04 model has been used to predict the 21cm background ( mcquinn et al .
2006 ) as well as the kinetic sunyaev zeldovich effect ( mcquinn et al . 2005 ) .
furlanetto , zaldarriaga , & hernquist ( 2006b ) used it to predict the effect of reionization on ly@xmath3 galaxy surveys , while dijkstra , wyithe , & haiman ( 2007 ) used it to provide a lower limit to the ionized fraction at @xmath5 .
kramer , haiman , & oh ( 2006 ) extended the fzh04 model to include the effects of feedback on the size distribution .
alvarez et al . ( 2006b ) used the model to estimate the cross - correlation between the cosmic microwave and 21cm backgrounds on large scales .
measurement of individual h ii region sizes would provide strong constraints on the sources responsible for reionization . until now
, such detection has remained elusive , due to complexities in the interpretation of quasar spectra .
these difficulties arise in the interpretation of the `` transmission gap '' between the quasar s ly@xmath3 line and the onset of the gunn - peterson trough .
this gap has been interpreted as corresponding to the quasar s own h ii region ( e.g. , mesinger & haiman 2004 ; wyithe & loeb 2004a ) . alternatively the gap may be determined by a combination of the flux from the quasar and the background uv radiation field the gunn - peterson trough sets in whenever their combined flux can not keep the igm sufficiently ionized ( e.g. , yu & lu 2005 ; fan et al .
2006 ; bolton & haehnelt 2007 ) . in this case
, the h ii region could be much larger than the size corresponding to the transmission gap , but note sizes near overlap , paying particular attention to the effect of recombinations on the mean free path of ionizing photons , while lidz , oh , & furlanetto ( 2006 ) , bolton & haehnelt ( 2007 ) , mesinger & haiman ( 2007 ) , and maselli et al .
( 2007 ) examined the effects on quasar spectra due to density fluctuations in the igm . here
we will model the size of pre - existing hii regions that existed around high redshfit quasars before they began to shine .
we will use the conditional h ii region size distribution , which describes statistically the size distribution of h ii regions that surround haloes of a given mass . in
2 we review the model and derive the distribution . in
3 we discuss the implications for quasar h ii regions , and conclude with a discussion in 4 .
we adopt parameters based on wmap 3-year observations ( spergel et al .
2006 ) , @xmath6 , @xmath7 , @xmath8 , @xmath9 , @xmath10)=(0.13,0.022,0.73,0.95,0.74 ) .
in the model of fzh04 , the size of the h ii region in which a point lies is determined by finding the largest spherical region centered on the point for which the mean collapsed fraction @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is an efficiency parameter which describes how many ionizing photons are produced per collapsed atom . by using the extended press - schechter formalism , this condition can be expressed in terms of the mean overdensity of the region , @xmath13 , by _
m_x(m , z)_c(z)-k()^1/2 , where @xmath14 is the mass of the region , @xmath15 is the variance of density fluctuations , @xmath16 is the threshold overdensity for collapse , and @xmath17 is the variance on the scale of the minimum halo mass which contributes to reionization , @xmath18 . by finding a linear approximation to the `` barrier '' , _
x(m , z)b(m , z)b_0(z)+b_1(z)^2(m ) , where b_0(z)=_c - k()_min , b_1(z)= , and @xmath19 , they were able to derive the mass function of ionized regions , m_b=|| .
[ mdist_uncond ] additional details can be found in fzh04 . what is the probability , @xmath20 , that a halo of mass @xmath21 will be located in an ionized bubble with a size between @xmath22 and @xmath23 ?
this can be found by considering the halo to be the locus of the first upcrossing of a random walk in @xmath24 .
first , we determine the conditional probability , @xmath25 , that a point which first crossed the barrier at @xmath26 and @xmath27 , crosses the halo barrier @xmath28 between @xmath29 and @xmath30 . as has been discussed previously ( e.g. sheth 1998 ) , this can be accomplished by using the standard expression for the distribution of up - crossings of a linear barrier for trajectories starting from @xmath31 and @xmath32 , f(s,_c|0,0)ds= , but moving the origin to @xmath33 ( see also furlanetto , mcquinn , & hernquist 2006a , equation 2 ) , f(s,_c|s_b,_b)ds = ds .
the conditional probability that the first up - crossing of the bubble barrier occured between @xmath34 and @xmath35 , given that it crosses the halo barrier @xmath28 at @xmath36 , is f(s_b,_b|s,_c)ds_b = f(s,_c|s_b,_b)ds_b .
thus , the probability that a halo of mass @xmath21 is inside an ionized bubble of mass between @xmath22 and @xmath23 is @xmath37^{3/2}\left|\frac{ds_b}{dm_b}\right|\times\\ \nonumber & & { \rm exp}\left\lbrace\frac{\delta_c^2}{2s}-\frac{\delta_b^2}{2s_b}-\frac{[\delta_c-\delta_b]^2}{2(s - s_b)}\right\rbrace dm_b . \label{mdist}\end{aligned}\ ] ] shown in fig .
[ halopanels ] are the median , 68% , and 95% contours of the distribution @xmath38 , for different halo masses @xmath39 , as well as the `` global '' relationship given by equation ( [ mdist_uncond ] ) .
the figure shows comoving radius rather than mass , defined by the relation @xmath40^{1/3}$ ] .
, as labelled .
we assumed a minimum source halo virial temperature of @xmath41 k. [ halopanels ] , width=259 ]
in this section we will discuss the implications of the conditional h ii region size distribution on observations of quasar h ii regions . before proceeding ,
we briefly describe what we mean by quasar h ii region , especially near the end of reionization .
late in reionization , close to percolation , the h ii region sizes grow rapidly .
this is of course the expected behaviour , but it is not clear what meaning to attach to any given h ii region when most of the universe is already ionized . for h ii regions around very rare quasar host halos ,
it is reasonable to expect that the central h ii region in which the quasar forms is much larger than the surrounding h ii regions .
while the mean global ionized fraction may be high , the fluctuations in ionized fraction outside of the central h ii region are likely to be on much smaller scales . the variation in the size of _ pre - existing _ h ii regions that surround quasars when they begin to shine manifests itself in a theoretical uncertainty in the determination of properties of quasars , such as their ionizing photon luminosity and age , as well as properties of the surrounding medium , such as the neutral fraction and gas density .
for a quasar that has been on for a time @xmath42 and has an ionizing photon luminosity @xmath43 , the observed line - of - sight radius of its h ii region , @xmath44 , is related to the radius of the h ii region in which it initially lies , @xmath45 , by v=(r _
obs^3-r_b^3)=v_0(1-r_b^3/r_obs^3 ) , where @xmath46 is the volume enclosed by the observed h ii region , @xmath47 is the hydrogen number density , @xmath48 is the ionized fraction , and we have assumed that the apparent age of the quasar , @xmath42 , is less than the recombination time , @xmath49^{-3}$ ] , where @xmath50 is the clumping factor . because the h ii region size is measured along the line of sight , this equation is correct even when the ionization front velocity is relativistic ( e.g. white et al . 2003 ; shapiro et al .
the quantity @xmath51 is the volume that is actually ionized by the quasar itself , _ excluding _ the volume already ionized by existing nearby sources , @xmath52 .
( equation [ error ] ) , for a given observed comoving h ii region radius , @xmath53 mpc ( dotted ) , 40 mpc ( dashed ) , and 60 mpc ( long dashed ) , for a central halo mass @xmath54 , a minimum source halo virial temperature of @xmath41 k , and and efficiency @xmath55 .
thus upper panels are the cumulative distribution , while the lower panels are the differential distribution .
[ robs ] , width=259 ] what is the uncertainty in the determination of @xmath51 , given that the initial radius of the h ii region , @xmath45 , is unknown ?
we express this uncertainty in terms of an error _ err , [ error ] which is the fractional amount by which the uniform - igm estimate for the volume ionized by the quasar , @xmath56 , exceeds the actual one , @xmath51 .
we obtain = , where @xmath57 is the cumulative probability , e.g. @xmath58 , @xmath59 is the conditional bubble size distribution as defined in equation ( 8) , @xmath60 , and @xmath61 .
the error distribution is shown in fig .
[ robs ] for different values of @xmath44 . for larger observed h ii regions , the overestimate of @xmath51 is smaller .
if the ionizing luminosity and age of the quasar are known , as well as the density of the surrounding gas , then the neutral fraction can be determined according to 1-xx_hi=. of course , the luminosity , age , and density are not known exactly , but arguments can be made based upon their likely values ( e.g. wyithe & loeb 2004a ) .
the error in @xmath51 is related to an error in @xmath62 by @xmath63 , where @xmath64 is the neutral fraction inferred by assuming the quasar began to shine in a completely neutral medium . since @xmath65
, the neutral fraction is always underestimated when the presence of existing h ii regions is not taken into account .
there are therefore two reasons why higher neutral fractions lead to smaller h ii regions .
first , higher neutral fractions lead to slower ionization fronts propagating away from the quasar and thus to smaller h ii regions .
second , the higher the neutral fraction , the smaller the pre - existing h ii region , which also leads to a smaller observed h ii region .
fan et al .
( 2006 ) define `` proximity zones '' as regions where the transmission is greater than ten percent , but do not explicitly associate them with the size of the quasar s h ii region .
these proximity zones have radii which increase steeply over the range @xmath66 , from @xmath67 to @xmath68 comoving mpc ( fig . [ fan ] ) .
these values are similar to the size of h ii regions around @xmath69-halos ( a likely minimum value for host halo masses of observed quasars at @xmath1 ; e.g. volonteri & rees 2006 ; li et al . 2006 ) near the end of reionization ( fig .
[ halopanels ] ) . shown also in fig .
[ fan ] is the typical size of h ii regions surrounding halos with masses @xmath70 for a model in which the ionized fraction reaches unity at @xmath71 and the integrated thomson scattering optical depth ( assuming once ionized helium ) is @xmath72 .
the theoretical expectation for the evolution h ii region sizes agrees quite well with the measured proximity zone sizes .
this suggests that the evolving sizes of the proximity zones measured by fan et al .
( 2006 ) can be explained by the growth of cosmic h ii regions driven by clustered sources around the quasars alone .
taking into account the contribution from the quasars could change the theoretical prediction , since the flux contributed by the quasar at distances greater than the size of the pre - existing bubble may be large enough to increase transmission there . for a quasar with a spectral shape @xmath73 ( e.g. , bolton & haenelt 2007 ) and ionizing photon luminosity @xmath74 , ionization equilibrium implies that the neutral fraction at a comoving distance @xmath75 is f_hi410 ^ -6 ( ) ^ ( ) ^2 ( ) ^-1 , while the neutral fraction necessary to obtain a gunn - peterson optical depth @xmath76 is given by ( fan et al .
2006 ) , f_hi410 ^ -6 ( ) ( ) ^-3/2 . for reasonable igm clumping factors and quasar ionizing photon luminosities , therefore , the quasar by itself is able to cause transmission at a distance of 40 comoving mpc , very similar to the size of the transmission gaps of the highest redshift quasars measured by fan et al .
thus , there are two possible explanations for the rapid increase in the size of the trasnmission gaps : 1 ) hii regions , defined as regions where hydrogen is mostly ionized , are much larger than the observed transmission gaps at @xmath77 .
the transmission gaps correspond to smaller regions , within which the evolving uv intensity from a combination of nearby galaxies and the quasar ionizes the igm to a level sufficient to allow transmission , or 2 ) the transmission gaps correspond to the extent of the hii regions themselves , which grow rapidly as overlap takes place at @xmath1 .
the uv background intensity within these hii regions is dominated by galaxies clustered around the central quasar and is sufficient to cause the observed transmission .
halo vs. redshift for a model with @xmath78 and @xmath71 . also shown are the `` proximity zone '' radii ( triangles ) of sixteen quasars as determined by fan et al .
the dotted lines are the ionized and neutral fractions multiplied by 100 .
shown also is a linear fit ( long dashed ) of the proper size vs. redshift , as in fan et al .
[ fan ] , width=268 ]
we have used the conditional h ii region size distribution around halos with a mass @xmath79 to model observations of quasar h ii regions .
our results can be summarized as follows : * due to the biased location of quasars , the h ii regions that surround them just before they begin to emit ionizing radiation are likely to be large , with radii of order tens of mpc , even when the mean ionized fraction is of order thirty percent . * for observed quasar h ii regions with sizes of order tens of mpc , it is difficult to determine the properties of the surrounding medium , due to uncertainties in the size of pre - existing h ii regions neutral fractions will be underestimated for a given quasar luminosity and lifetime .
this effect is strongest for small observed h ii regions around quasars late in the reionization epoch .
* the observed transmission gaps around high - redshift quasars may have a direct correspondence to cosmic h ii regions created by galaxies clustered around the central quasar .
the steep increase in the transmission gap size at @xmath77 can be explained by the rapid growth of these h ii regions at the epoch of overlap .
we expect conclusion 1 to be generally true , but conclusions 2 and 3 require further explanation . for conclusion 2
, the situation is more complicated when quasar h ii region sizes are obtained from transmission gaps in their spectra . in this case
, effects such as a boost in the neutral hydrogen abundance due to clumping and ly@xmath3 absorption from the damping wing of neutral gas outside the h ii region can cause the inferred h ii region size to be smaller than it actually is ( bolton & haehnelt 2007 ; maselli et al .
this underestimate leads to an overestimate of neutral hydrogen abundance for a given quasar luminosity and lifetime . neglecting the h ii region created by the nearby galaxies and their progenitors , on the other hand ,
leads to an underestimate of the neutral fraction .
a natural question is which of these two competing effects is stronger .
for example , maselli et al .
( 2007 ) find that the physical radius corresponding to the transmission gap is about 40 percent larger than that of the h ii region , which corresponds to an underestimate of its volume by a factor of 3 , and an overestimate of the neutral fraction by that same factor . in order to offset this effect
, @xmath80 would be necessary .
for example , the probability that a quasar surrounded by a 40 comoving mpc h ii region will have @xmath80 is about 30 percent , for @xmath81 at @xmath82 with @xmath83 k , as shown in fig .
2 . at earlier times and lower ionization fraction , @xmath84 and @xmath5 , the probability is only ten percent .
the two competing effects are thus similar in magnitude when the ionized fraction is high , @xmath85 , but the `` apparent shrinking '' reported by maselli et al .
( 2007 ) is likely to dominate at earlier times , when @xmath86 .
these estimates are quite uncertain , however
rarer sources and/or quasar hosts could make these probabilities higher by increasing the pre - existing bubble size , and more detailed calculations will be necessary to refine these estimates further . for conclusion 3 to be valid ,
it is necessary for the uv radiation field within ionized bubbles to keep the volume - averaged neutral fraction low enough to create the observed transmission gaps .
this is plausible , since the uv radiation field near quasars is likely enhanced due to their biased environment ( e.g. , yu & lu 2005 ) , with a size approaching that of the mean free path imposed by lyman - limit systems ( @xmath87 comoving mpc at @xmath88 ; gnedin & fan 2006 ) .
there have been recent suggestions that detection of large ( @xmath89 comoving mpc ) h ii regions by 21cm tomography can reveal the locations of quasars and bright galaxies that just underwent an agn phase ( wyithe , loeb & barnes 2005 ; kohler et al .
our results here suggest that large , h ii regions may be visible at relatively low redshifts , @xmath90 , where foreground contamination of the 21cm observations is lowest .
thus , the 21cm observations hold the most promise for descriminating between the two possible explantations for the evolution of transmission gap sizes discussed here . in addition , measurement of the sizes of h ii regions around bright quasars by 21cm tomography , when combined with the conditional h ii region size distribution , will provide powerful constraints on the theory of reionization and the nature of high - redshift quasars . in our model
the global ionized fraction is proportional to the collapsed fraction , so that the same ionizing efficiency is assigned to collapsed matter , regardless of halo mass , epoch , or environment . in such a model
, the ionized fraction grows exponentially with time .
the reionization history is likely to be more complex than this , especially in light of the optical depth measured by wmap .
for example , self - regulated reionization , in which the lowest mass objects do not produce ionizing photons when they form within existing h ii regions , can extend the reionization epoch , relieving the tension between a percolation at @xmath1 and the wmap value of @xmath91 ( haiman & bryan 2006 ; iliev et al .
we note , however , that our best - fitting model to the evolution of the transmission gap sizes , in which overlap is complete at @xmath92 and @xmath72 , is in marginal agreement with the value obtained from wmap 3 year polarization data , @xmath93 ( spergel et al .
this indicates that the level of early reionization demanded by the wmap measurement may be quite modest , while still allowing for a late overlap at @xmath94 .
the fact that h ii regions are likely to surround quasars before they begin to shine , and that their size will have a strong redshift dependence , are likely to be crucial in developing a more complete understanding of observations of the high redshift universe .
we wish to thank zoltan haiman and peng oh for a careful reading of an early draft , and xiaohui fan and miguel morales for helpful discussion .
this work was partially supported by nsf career award ast-0239709 from the national science foundation . | cosmic reionization progresses as h ii regions form around sources of ionizing radiation .
their average size grows continuously until they percolate and complete reionization .
we demonstrate how this typical growth can be calculated around the largest , biased sources of uv emission such as quasars by further developing an analytical model based on the excursion set formalism .
this approach allows us to calculate the sizes and growth of the hii regions created by the progenitors of any dark matter halo of given mass and redshift with a minimum of free parameters .
statistical variations in the size of these pre - existing hii regions are an additional source of uncertainty in the determination of very high redshift quasar properties from their observed hii region sizes .
we use this model to demonstrate that the transmission gaps seen in very high redshift quasars can be understood from the radiation of only their progenitors and associated clustered small galaxies . the fit sets a lower limit on the redshift of overlap of @xmath0 .
this interpretation makes the transmission gaps independent of the age of the quasars observed .
if this interpretation were correct it would raise the prospects of using radio interferometers currently under construction to detect the epoch of reionization .
[ firstpage ] galaxies : formation intergalactic medium quasars : general cosmology : theory |
the set of exceptional slopes on a boundary component of a cusped hyperbolic manifold has generated a lot of interest in the literature ; there are many restrictions on the set of exceptional slopes on a boundary component of a hyperbolic 3-manifold @xmath1 and its corresponding fillings , for example , no such @xmath1 has two distinct @xmath2 fillings @xcite or more than 10 exceptional slopes @xcite .
however , it is still not known if a hyperbolic knot exterior in @xmath2 can have a reducible filling , or if @xmath1 can have a pair of exceptional slopes @xmath3 and @xmath4 corresponding to a lens space and toroidal space so that the _ distance _ ( minimal number of intersections ) between @xmath3 and @xmath4 is 4 .
conjecturally , neither are possible , see @xcite and @xcite respectively .
moreover , it is conjecturally the case that the figure - eight knot exterior is the unique one - cusped hyperbolic manifold with 10 exceptional slopes @xcite and that the figure - eight knot exterior and its sister are the unique one - cusped hyperbolic manifolds having two exceptional slopes at distance 8 , see @xcite . in this article , by classifying the sets of exceptional slopes and the corresponding fillings for all manifolds obtained by surgery on the minimally twisted 5-chain link ( see the rightmost link in figure [ sequence : fig ] ) , we provide experimental evidence that supports these conjectures : [ flash ] if @xmath1 is a cusped hyperbolic manifold obtained by surgery on the minimally twisted 5-chain link then : * @xmath1 is not the exterior of a knot with a reducible filling ; * @xmath1 does not have a lens space and toroidal filling at distance 4 ; * if @xmath1 has 10 exceptional slopes then @xmath1 is the figure-8 knot exterior ; * if @xmath1 has exceptional slopes at distance 8 then @xmath1 is either the figure-8 knot exterior or the figure-8 knot exterior sister .
a notable collection of chain links is described in @xcite ; they are the figure-8 knot , the whitehead link , the 3-chain link , the 4-chain link with a half twist , and the minimally twisted 5-chain link .
these links are shown in figure [ sequence : fig ] .
we follow @xcite and denote these chain links by 1cl , 2cl , 3cl , 4cl and 5cl , and their exteriors by @xmath5 , @xmath6 , @xmath7 , @xmath8 , @xmath9 respectively .
the significance of this sequence of links comes from the following facts : each @xmath10 is the ( or conjecturally the ) smallest volume hyperbolic 3-manifold with @xmath11 cusps , see @xcite and @xcite ; more than @xmath12 of the cusped hyperbolic 3-manifolds from the callahan - hildebrand - weeks census @xcite are surgeries on 5cl ( personal communication with nathan dunfield ) ; 5cl relates to the program of enumerating exceptional pairs at maximal distance , in particular , all knots realising half - integral toroidal surgeries @xcite , many of the knots realising lens space surgeries @xcite , and all cusped hyperbolic 3-manifolds with distinct reducible and toroidal fillings at maximal distance @xcite are obtained by surgery on 5cl .
it is easy to see that if @xmath13 is equipped with the usual ( meridian , longitude ) homology basis then a @xmath14 filling on any boundary component of @xmath15 results in @xmath16 , and , as a result , that any manifold obtained by surgery on @xmath17cl is obtained by surgery on @xmath18cl .
a classification of the exceptional surgeries on 3cl is given in @xcite together with a complete description of the set of exceptional slopes , and corresponding exceptional fillings , on the boundary components of all hyperbolic manifolds obtained by surgery on 3cl .
a classification of exceptional surgeries on 5cl is found in @xcite ; in this article we completely describe the sets of exceptional slopes and corresponding exceptional fillings of any manifold obtained by surgery on 5cl .
to simplify matters , we only consider the ` new ' manifolds obtained by surgery on 5cl ; namely we only consider surgeries on 5cl and 4cl that are not obtained by surgery on 3cl .
in particular , theorems [ 5cl_thm ] and [ 4cl_thm ] provide explicit descriptions of the sets of exceptional slopes and corresponding fillings for all hyperbolic surgeries of 5cl not obtained by surgery on 3cl , and theorem [ flash ] will be an easy consequence .
we start with section [ basics ] where we recall the classification from @xcite . in order to do so
, we begin by recalling and introducing terminology in subsection [ introbasics ] .
the main results of this article are stated and proved in section [ mr ] and refer to the tables found in section [ tables ] .
the results of this article were obtained as a graduate student at the university of pisa under the supervision of carlo petronio and bruno martelli .
the current presentation of the results has benefited from discussions with daniel matignon and mark lackenby , and from email correspondences with carlo petronio , bruno martelli and nathan dunfield .
we begin with some general terminology , and we introduce the notion of an exceptional filling instruction " used in theorems [ 5cl_thm ] and [ 4cl_thm ] .
fix an orientable compact 3-manifold @xmath19 with @xmath20 consisting of tori : * a _ slope _ on a boundary component @xmath21 of @xmath19 is the isotopy class of a non - trivial unoriented loop on @xmath21 ; * a _ filling instruction _
@xmath3 for @xmath19 is a set consisting of either a slope or the empty set for each component of @xmath20 ; * the _ filling _ @xmath22 given by an instruction @xmath3 is the manifold obtained by attaching one solid torus to @xmath20 for each ( non - empty ) slope in @xmath3 , with the meridian of the solid torus attached to the slope .
we recall that if @xmath1 is a hyperbolic non - compact finite - volume 3-manifold then @xmath23 with @xmath20 consisting of tori , and that @xmath24 is hyperbolic for all but finitely many @xmath3 s consisting of one slope and @xmath25 s @xcite . *
if the interior of @xmath19 is hyperbolic but the interior of @xmath22 is not , we say that @xmath3 is an _ exceptional filling instruction _ for @xmath19 and that @xmath22 is an _ exceptional filling _ of @xmath19 ; * we say that an exceptional filling instruction @xmath3 on a hyperbolic @xmath19 is _ isolated _ if @xmath26 is hyperbolic for all @xmath4 properly contained in @xmath3 ; for such an @xmath3 we call @xmath22 an _ isolated exceptional filling _ of @xmath19 . a _ surgery _ on a link @xmath27 corresponds to a filling of the exterior of @xmath27 , that is , to a filling of @xmath28 where @xmath29 is an open regular neighbourhood of @xmath27 . by a _ surgery instruction _ for @xmath27 we mean a filling instruction on the exterior of @xmath27 .
we now recall some standard notation used in the description of the set of exceptional slopes on a fixed boundary component of a hyperbolic manifold , see for example @xcite .
if @xmath19 is a hyperbolic 3-manifold with boundary consisting of tori and @xmath21 is a fixed boundary component of @xmath20 then the set of exceptional slopes on @xmath21 is denoted by @xmath30 , and the cardinality of @xmath30 by @xmath31 . to describe @xmath32
we introduce the following definition : let @xmath3 be a filling instruction on a manifold @xmath19 .
we say that @xmath3 _ factors through _ a manifold @xmath33 if there exists some filling instruction @xmath34 such that @xmath35 .
note that if @xmath3 is exceptional for @xmath19 and factors through a hyperbolic @xmath33 with @xmath35 , then @xmath36 is exceptional for @xmath33 .
our description of the exceptional fillings of @xmath37 will employ the notation now discussed for seifert manifolds with orientable base surface .
given integers @xmath38 , with @xmath39 and @xmath40 an orientable surface with @xmath41 boundary components @xmath42 , we let @xmath43 denote the surface obtained by removing @xmath18 open discs from @xmath40 and we denote by @xmath44 the @xmath18 newly introduced boundary circles .
we fix an orientation on @xmath45 and orient @xmath46 so that @xmath47 , @xmath48 is a positive basis of @xmath49 with @xmath50 oriented as @xmath51 .
we denote by @xmath52 , the manifold obtained by performing a dehn filling on each @xmath50 along @xmath53 for @xmath54 . in our case
, @xmath40 will be either the disc @xmath55 , the annulus @xmath56 , or the sphere @xmath57 . given seifert manifolds @xmath19 and @xmath33 with orientable base surfaces with boundary as described above , and @xmath58 with @xmath59 , we define @xmath60 unambiguously to be the quotient manifold @xmath61 where @xmath62 for @xmath63 and @xmath64 arbitrary boundary components of @xmath19 and @xmath33 respectively , and @xmath65 acting on homology by @xmath66 with respect to the bases described above . the case @xmath67 , @xmath68 is also allowed and we write the quotient manifold as @xmath69 . for the purposes of theorem [ 5cl_thm ] and [ 4cl_thm ]
, we employ a flexible notation for seifert manifolds .
we will formally identify an @xmath25 slope with @xmath70 and allow parameters @xmath71 to be arbitrary elements of @xmath72 . by ordering the components of 5cl cyclically , surgery instructions on 5cl
can be naturally identified with @xmath73 .
given such an instruction @xmath3 , the symmetry group of @xmath74 has a natural action on the boundary components of @xmath74 .
this action induces an action on the filling instructions on @xmath74 . among the most significant actions arising we mention those coming from the symmetry group of @xmath9 ,
see ( [ first : eqn])-([3rd : eqn ] ) below , a symmetry of @xmath8 which may be deduced from the fenn - rourke blow - down move on 5cl , see ( [ blow : eqn ] ) , and from the amphichirality of the figure-8 knot @xmath75 , see ( [ figure8:eqn ] ) ; see @xcite for full details .
@xmath76 since the action of the maps ( [ first : eqn ] ) and
( [ second : eqn ] ) is very easily understandable while that of ( [ 3rd : eqn])-([figure8:eqn ] ) is more involved , we introduce the symbol @xmath77 $ ] for the equivalence class of a filling instruction @xmath3 under ( [ first : eqn ] ) and ( [ second : eqn ] ) only , and the symbol @xmath78\!]$ ] for the equivalence class of @xmath3 under ( [ first : eqn])-([figure8:eqn ] ) . for a filling instruction @xmath3 on @xmath9
we will often simplify notation by omitting empty slopes but leaving the subscripts on non - empty slopes .
for example , @xmath79 corresponds to the filling instruction @xmath80 with @xmath81 the ( meridian , longitude ) basis of the homology of the @xmath82 cusp . note that for any @xmath83 and @xmath84 one has @xmath85=[((\frac pq)_j)]$ ] , so the fillings @xmath86 are defined without ambiguity .
our convention will be that a filling instruction @xmath87 on @xmath9 with four non - empty slopes and no subscripts represents @xmath88 .
we now state the main result of @xcite . [
main : teo ] every exceptional filling instruction on @xmath9 is equivalent up to a composition of the symmetries _ ( [ first : eqn])-([figure8:eqn ] ) _ to a filling instruction containing one of : @xmath89 descriptions of the corresponding exceptional fillings may be found in @xcite .
we remark that the second , third , and fourth filling instructions factor through @xmath7 , and we assign the names @xmath90 , @xmath91 , and @xmath92 to the manifolds @xmath93 , @xmath94 , and @xmath95 respectively .
we now precisely describe the classification of exceptional slopes of every hyperbolic surgery on 5cl by describing @xmath32 for every @xmath3 not factoring through @xmath7 .
we split the result according to whether or not @xmath3 factors through @xmath8 .
[ 5cl_thm ] let @xmath96 be a hyperbolic filling instruction on @xmath9 containing at least one @xmath25 and not factoring through @xmath8 , and let @xmath21 be a boundary component of @xmath97 ; then either @xmath98 and , with respect to the basis induced from @xmath9 , we have @xmath99 and @xmath100 or @xmath101 and * @xmath102 for some @xmath3 in tables _ [ tb1]_-_[tb4 ] _ in section [ tables ] , and with respect to the basis induced from @xmath9 we have @xmath103 where @xmath104 are found in tables _ [ tb1]_-_[tb4]_. * identities _ ( [ 5clinf])-([5cl0 ] ) _ hold and @xmath105 , @xmath106 are shown in tables _ [ tb1]_-_[tb4]_. ordering the components of @xmath8 cyclically , identifying filling instructions on @xmath8 with @xmath107 and adopting the convention that a filling instruction @xmath108 on @xmath8 with three slopes and no subscripts represents @xmath109 , the corresponding result for @xmath8 is : [ 4cl_thm ] let @xmath96 be a hyperbolic filling instruction on @xmath8 containing at least one @xmath25 and not factoring through @xmath7 , and let @xmath21 a boundary component of @xmath110 ; then either @xmath111 and , with respect to the basis induced from @xmath8 , we have @xmath112 and @xmath113 or @xmath114 and * @xmath115 for some @xmath3 in tables _ [ tb5]_-_[tb6 ] _ , in section [ tables ] , and with respect to the basis induced from @xmath8 we have @xmath116 where @xmath104 are found in tables _ [ tb5 ] _ and _ [ tb6]_. * identities _ ( [ 4clinf])-([4cl0 ] ) _ hold , and the @xmath105 , @xmath117 are shown in tables _ [ tb5 ] _ and _ [ tb6]_. while proving theorems [ 5cl_thm ] and [ 4cl_thm ] we will often see identities between fillings of the @xmath10 .
when a homeomorphism @xmath118 follows as a consequence of maps ( [ first : eqn])-([figure8:eqn ] ) we will write @xmath119 .
in addition to realising homeomorphisms between fillings of @xmath9 , we will often use the rolfsen twist ( see @xcite ) to obtain homeomorphisms between fillings of the @xmath10 ; when @xmath120 is induced from a ( composition of ) rolfsen twist(s ) , we will write @xmath120 . proof of theorem [ 5cl_thm ] . by ( [ first : eqn])-([figure8:eqn ] ) , we have @xmath121\ ! ] & = [ ( 1)]\sqcup[(\infty)]\sqcup[(0 ) ] ; \label{1action } \\ [ \![(-1)]\ ! ] & = [ ( -1)]\sqcup[(\tfrac12)]\sqcup[(2 ) ] ; \label{-1action } \\ [ \![(-2)]\ ! ] & = [ ( -2)]\sqcup [ ( -\tfrac12)]\sqcup [ ( \tfrac13)]\sqcup [ ( \tfrac23)]\sqcup [ ( \tfrac32)]\sqcup [ ( 3 ) ] \label{-2action}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] theorem [ main : teo ] implies that all slopes in @xmath122\!]$ ] are exceptional , moreover , any instruction containing a slope in @xmath123\!]$ ] factors through @xmath8 .
so for @xmath21 a boundary component of a hyperbolic @xmath37 we have @xmath124 and @xmath125 ; when @xmath96 does not factor through @xmath8 no slope in @xmath123\!]$ ] is contained in @xmath96 . identity ( [ 5clinf ] ) is established in @xcite , and identities ( [ 5cl1 ] ) and ( [ 5cl0 ] ) are established using ( [ first : eqn])-([3rd : eqn ] ) and ( [ 5clinf ] ) .
we will now describe up to ( [ first : eqn])-([3rd : eqn ] ) all hyperbolic @xmath96 s not factoring through @xmath8 with @xmath126 . for such @xmath96 , using ( [ first : eqn])-([second : eqn ] ) , we may assume that @xmath21 corresponds to the neighbourhood of the fourth chain component of 5cl .
so we suppose that @xmath127 , with @xmath128 a hyperbolic filling instruction on @xmath9 that does not factor through @xmath8 . if @xmath4 is an exceptional slope on @xmath37 then , up to ( [ first : eqn])-([3rd : eqn ] ) , @xmath129 contains one of the seven isolated exceptional filling instruction from theorem [ main : teo ] .
if @xmath130 then any such isolated exceptional filling instruction contains at most one slope in @xmath123\!]$ ] , and contains two slopes in @xmath131\!]$ ] ( see theorem [ main : teo ] and ( [ -2action ] ) ) .
thus at least one of the slopes in @xmath96 belongs to @xmath131\!]$ ] .
it is a routine consequence of maps ( [ first : eqn])-([3rd : eqn ] ) that we may assume without loss of generality that @xmath132 and that @xmath21 remains the boundary corresponding to the neighbourhood of the 4th chain component of 5cl .
so for @xmath96 hyperbolic , not factoring through @xmath8 , we have @xmath133\!]=[\![\alpha]\!]$ ] where @xmath134 and @xmath132 .
we define @xmath135 to be @xmath136 .
if @xmath4 is an exceptional slope of @xmath74 then @xmath135 contains an isolated exceptional filling instruction by theorem [ main : teo ] .
moreover , using theorem [ main : teo ] , if @xmath135 contains an isolated exceptional filling instruction then either @xmath4 is a slope in @xmath122\!]$ ] , or @xmath4 is a slope in @xmath123\!]$ ] and @xmath135 factors through @xmath7 , or @xmath137 .
as we are assuming that @xmath3 does not factor through @xmath8 , if @xmath135 factors through @xmath7 then we require @xmath138 .
we define the following sets of @xmath135 s ; * we define @xmath139 to be the set of exceptional @xmath135 s such that @xmath140 is in @xmath141 ; * we define @xmath142 to be the set of exceptional @xmath135 s factoring through @xmath7 with @xmath143 ; * we define @xmath144 to be the set of exceptional @xmath135 s factoring through @xmath7 with @xmath145 ; * we define @xmath146 to be the set of exceptional @xmath135 s factoring through @xmath7 with @xmath147 ; we know that , every @xmath96 with @xmath37 a hyperbolic manifold , @xmath96 not factoring through @xmath8 , and @xmath126 has @xmath133\!]=[\![\alpha]\!]=[\![(\alpha_0,\alpha_1,\alpha_2,\alpha_3)]\!]$ ] where @xmath132 .
the set @xmath148 is the set of all exceptional filling instructions @xmath135 factoring through @xmath7 with @xmath74 hyperbolic not factoring through @xmath8 and @xmath132 , and the set @xmath139 is the set of all exceptional filling instructions @xmath135 not factoring through @xmath7 with @xmath132 .
so , up to ( [ first : eqn])-([3rd : eqn ] ) every hyperbolic filling instruction @xmath96 not factoring through @xmath8 with @xmath126 is equivalent to a filling instruction @xmath3 of the form @xmath149 , every @xmath149 with @xmath150 and @xmath149 not factoring through @xmath8 is some @xmath3 in @xmath151 , and every exceptional slope on @xmath152 not in @xmath153 is some @xmath4 in @xmath151 .
now we can easily describe , up to @xmath154 , all such @xmath3 with more than 3 exceptional slopes .
let @xmath155 be defined by @xmath156 .
for @xmath3 in @xmath157 define @xmath158 to be the set of all @xmath4 s such that @xmath135 is contained in @xmath151 .
it is clear that @xmath159 and that @xmath160 is a complete list of all @xmath161 pairs with @xmath162 , @xmath74 hyperbolic and @xmath163 .
we now explicitly construct the sets @xmath164 .
* construction of the set @xmath139 : * we can see using maps ( [ first : eqn])-([figure8:eqn ] ) that every @xmath135 with @xmath165 with @xmath132 and @xmath3 hyperbolic not factoring through @xmath8 is contained in the following set @xmath166 before constructing the sets @xmath167 we make some initial remarks .
it is easy to see that if a surgery instruction on 5cl contains @xmath168 , then it factors through @xmath7 .
up to the action of maps ( [ first : eqn])-([figure8:eqn ] ) the surgery instruction @xmath168 is equivalent to the following surgery instructions : @xmath169 , [ ( ( \tfrac 12)_0 , ( \tfrac 23)_2 ) ] , [ ( ( \tfrac 12)_0 , 3_1 ) ] , [ ( ( \tfrac 12)_0 , ( \tfrac 32)_1 ) ] , [ ( ( \tfrac 23)_0 , 2_1 ) ] , \\ [ ( ( \tfrac12)_0 , ( \tfrac13)_2 ) ] , [ ( 2_0 , ( -\tfrac 12)_2 ) ] , [ ( ( \tfrac 13)_0 , 2_1 ) ] , [ ( ( -1)_0 , 3_2 ) ] , [ ( ( -1)_0,(\tfrac 32)_2 ) ] , \\ [ ( 2_0 , ( -2)_2 ) ] , [ ( ( -1)_0 , ( -\tfrac 12)_1 ) ] , [ ( ( -1)_0 , ( -1)_2 ) ] , [ ( ( -1)_0 , ( \tfrac12)_2 ) ] , \\ [ ( ( \tfrac12)_0 , ( 2)_2 ) ] , [ ( ( -1)_0 , ( 2)_1 ) ] , [ ( ( -1)_0 , ( \tfrac12)_1 ) ] , [ ( ( 2)_0 , ( 2)_2)]\big\ } \end{aligned}\ ] ] we will now see that the requirements of @xmath3 being hyperbolic and not factoring through @xmath8 allow us to completely construct @xmath167 .
* construction of the set @xmath142 : * in this case , for @xmath170 , we have @xmath171 , and @xmath135 is an exceptional filling of @xmath9 if and only if @xmath172 contains an isolated exceptional filling instruction on @xmath7 ; i.e. using the classification in @xcite we can see that @xmath14 is an exceptional slope on @xmath74 if @xmath172 contains an isolated instruction in @xmath173 for @xmath3 non - exceptional and not factoring through @xmath8 , no slope in @xmath3 is in [ ( 1 ) ] or @xmath174 $ ] ; that is @xmath175 , @xmath176 , @xmath177 . with these conditions
it is easy to see that @xmath4 is an exceptional slope on a hyperbolic @xmath74 if and only if one of the following holds : * @xmath178 + * @xmath179 + * @xmath180 belongs to @xmath181 + * @xmath182 belongs to @xmath183 + * @xmath184 belongs to @xmath185 + * @xmath186 belongs to @xmath187 thus , the set of all @xmath188 constructed in the above analysis is the set @xmath142 .
* construction of the set @xmath144 : * reasoning as in the case @xmath143 we see @xmath135 factors through @xmath7 when one of @xmath189 is in @xmath190 or @xmath191 ( see @xmath192\!]$ ] shown above ) .
we examine each of these 6 cases individually and enumerate all @xmath193 with the desired properties .
if @xmath194 then @xmath195 the result is that @xmath196 is an exceptional slope on @xmath197 if and only if one of the following holds ; @xmath198 , @xmath199 , @xmath200 , @xmath201 .
if @xmath202 then @xmath203 we conclude that @xmath196 is an exceptional slope on @xmath197 if and only if one of the following holds ; @xmath204 , @xmath205 , @xmath206 , @xmath200 , @xmath207 , @xmath208 , @xmath209 , @xmath210 , @xmath211 , @xmath212 , @xmath213 .
if @xmath214 then @xmath215 the result is that @xmath196 is an exceptional slope on @xmath197
if and only if one of the following holds ; @xmath216 , @xmath217 , @xmath218 , @xmath219 , @xmath220 .
if @xmath221 then @xmath222 we see that @xmath196 is an exceptional slope on @xmath197 if and only if one of the following holds ; @xmath223 , @xmath224=@xmath220 , @xmath225 . if @xmath226 then @xmath227 we find that @xmath196 is an exceptional slope on @xmath197 if and
only if one of the following holds ; @xmath228 , @xmath229 , @xmath220 .
if @xmath230 then @xmath231 the result is that @xmath196 is an exceptional slope on @xmath197 if and only if one of the following holds ; @xmath232 , @xmath233 , @xmath219 , @xmath234 .
thus , the set of all @xmath193 constructed in the above analysis is the set @xmath144 .
* construction of the set @xmath146 : * for @xmath235 to factor through @xmath7 we need one of @xmath189 to be in @xmath236 or @xmath237 ( see @xmath192\!]$ ] shown above ) .
we construct all @xmath135 for each of these 6 cases individually . if @xmath238 then @xmath239 when no @xmath240 , @xmath241 , @xmath242 is a slope in @xmath122\ ! ] , [ \![(-1)]\!]$ ] we have @xmath243 and @xmath244 . from @xcite
we see that 2 is exceptional if and only if one of the following holds ; @xmath245 , @xmath246 , @xmath200 .
if @xmath247 then @xmath248 using @xcite we get that @xmath249 is exceptional on @xmath74 if and only if one of the following holds ; @xmath250 , @xmath251 , @xmath252 , @xmath253 .
if @xmath254 then @xmath255 we find that @xmath249 is exceptional on @xmath74 if and only if one of the following holds ; @xmath256 , @xmath257 , @xmath253 .
if @xmath258 then @xmath259 we observe that @xmath249 is exceptional on @xmath74 if and only if one of the following holds ; @xmath256 , @xmath260 , @xmath220 .
if @xmath261 then @xmath262 we get that @xmath249 is exceptional on @xmath74 if and only if one of the following holds ; @xmath263 , @xmath264 , @xmath265 , @xmath253 .
if @xmath266 then @xmath267 the result is that @xmath249 is an exceptional slope on @xmath74 if and only if one of the following holds ; @xmath268 , @xmath269 , @xmath220 , @xmath270 , @xmath271 .
thus , the set of all @xmath272 constructed in the above analysis is the set @xmath273 .
this completes the construction of @xmath151 and the sets @xmath274 .
the last step is to reduce the size of @xmath274 using maps ( [ first : eqn])-([figure8:eqn ] ) .
the result is shown in tables [ tb1]-[tb4 ] .
the corresponding exceptional manifolds shown in tables [ tb1]-[tb4 ] are written down using the description of isolated exceptional fillings of @xmath7 and @xmath9 provided in @xcite and @xcite respectively .
@xmath275 the proof of theorem [ 4cl_thm ] follows a similar line of reasoning : proof of theorem [ 4cl_thm ] .
we let @xmath276 be a hyperbolic filling instruction on @xmath8 with at least on @xmath25 slope .
we translate the problem on 4cl into a problem on 5cl ; using the rolfsen twist we see that @xmath277 where @xmath278 ( here @xmath279 , @xmath280 should be read as @xmath25 when @xmath281 , @xmath282 ) .
now the argument proceeds exactly as in the proof of theorem [ 5cl_thm ] .
we use identities ( [ first : eqn])-([3rd : eqn ] ) to assume without loss of generality that @xmath283 and that @xmath21 is the boundary corresponding to the neighbourhood of the 4th chain component of 5cl ; namely we can assume @xmath284 is a hyperbolic filling instruction on @xmath9 that does not factor through @xmath7 , and that some slope of @xmath285 is in @xmath286 . the conditions of @xmath285 being non - exceptional and not factoring through @xmath7 means that @xmath287 and @xmath288 .
theorem [ main : teo ] implies that every @xmath289 is an exceptional slope on @xmath290 , and so @xmath291 and @xmath292 .
identities ( [ 4clinf])-([4cl1 ] ) follow directly from identities ( [ 5clinf])-([5cl0 ] ) while ( [ 4cl0 ] ) is established using ( [ blow : eqn ] ) and then a composition of ( [ first : eqn])-([3rd : eqn ] ) .
more generally , theorem [ main : teo ] implies that if @xmath4 is an exceptional slope on @xmath290 then @xmath289 , or @xmath293 factors through @xmath7 , or @xmath294 .
the @xmath293 coming from @xmath91 are given by @xmath295 , @xmath296 , @xmath297 , @xmath298 .
this implies that @xmath4 is in one of @xmath122\!]$ ] , @xmath123\!]$ ] , @xmath131\!]$ ] , @xmath299\!]$ ] .
every slope in @xmath300\ ! ] , [ \![(-2)]\ ! ] , [ \![(-3)]\!]\}$ ] is examined individually as in the proof of theorem [ 5cl_thm ] to obtain a complete list of all @xmath301 pairs that have @xmath302 hyperbolic not factoring through @xmath7 with @xmath303 .
lastly , the list of @xmath285 produced is reduced using the maps ( [ first : eqn])-([figure8:eqn ] ) , and a positive twist about the zeroth component of the 5cl gives the list of @xmath3 s on @xmath8 and the exceptional slopes @xmath304 on @xmath305 shown in table [ tb5]-[tb6 ] .
the corresponding exceptional manifolds shown in tables [ tb5]-[tb6 ] are written down using the description of exceptional fillings on @xmath7 and @xmath9 provided in @xcite and @xcite .
@xmath275 we finish by pointing out that theorems [ 5cl_thm ] and [ 4cl_thm ] imply that any one - cusped hyperbolic manifold @xmath1 obtained by surgery on 5cl with 10 exceptional slopes , or having two exceptional slopes at distance 8 , is obtained by surgery on 3cl and that the only such @xmath1 s obtained by surgery on 3cl are the figure-8 knot exterior and its sister ( see the appendix in @xcite ) which shows the final two assertions of theorem [ flash ] .
the second assertion in theorem [ flash ] is a simple consequence of the fact that , up to ( [ first : eqn])-([figure8:eqn ] ) , the only @xmath74 with a pair of exceptional slopes at distance 4 with @xmath3 not factoring through @xmath7 is @xmath306 with the slopes @xmath307 ( see tables [ tb2]-[tb1 ] ) , and @xmath308 , @xmath309 are not lens spaces ; all @xmath310 with a pair of exceptional slopes at distance 4 can be found in @xcite , and it is not hard to check that the corresponding pair of exceptional fillings are never a lens space , toroidal pair .
lastly , we remark that the description of exceptional fillings provided in theorems [ 5cl_thm ] and [ 4cl_thm ] , and @xcite can be used to easily enumerate all examples of exceptional pairs at maximal distance ; one such enumeration shows that no counterexample to the cabling conjecture is obtained by surgery on 5cl ( see @xcite for full details ) .
.@xmath3 a filling instruction on @xmath9 not factoring through @xmath8 with @xmath311 , and @xmath312 . [ tb1 ] [ cols="^,^,^ " , ] roukema , f.w.m . ,
_ dehn surgery on the minimally twisted five - chain link _ , ph.d .
thesis , supervised by c. petronio and b. martelli 2011 , available at http://etd.adm.unipi.it/theses/available/etd-09212011-102615/ | it has been observed that most manifolds in the callahan - hildebrand - weeks census of cusped hyperbolic @xmath0-manifolds are obtained by surgery on the minimally twisted 5-chain link ; a full classification of the exceptional surgeries on the 5-chain link has recently been completed . in this article , we provide a complete classification of the sets of exceptional slopes and fillings for all cusped hyperbolic surgeries on the minimally twisted 5-chain link , thereby describing the sets of exceptional slopes and fillings for most hyperbolic manifolds of small complexity and providing supporting evidence for some well - known conjectures . |
dwarf galaxies in the local group ( lg ) are among the most well - studied galaxies in the universe .
detailed determinations of their kinematics , metallicities , and stellar contents serve as a basis for much of what we understand about the formation and evolution of both individual and groups of galaxies ( see reviews by * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
in particular , we can directly determine the history of star formation and chemical evolution for individual galaxies using hubble space telescope ( hst ) observations of resolved stellar populations in nearby and lg galaxies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
although we often draw on results from lg studies to explain the evolution of galaxies in the broader universe , whether lg dwarf galaxies are representative of all dwarf galaxies remains an open question ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
the lg is a relatively dense environment with a specific history of mass accretion and interaction , which may have influenced dwarf galaxy evolution differently than nearby field or galaxy groups ( e.g. , the m81 group ) . because we often extrapolate results from the lg to the more distant universe , it is important to establish the degree to which the lg dwarfs represent the broader dwarf galaxy population .
the local volume contains a diverse set of galaxies and environments , some of which have no analogs in the lg .
for example , the m81 group is known to have undergone a recent major interaction ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , which has likely influenced star formation and gas - loss in the m81 group dwarf galaxies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , and which may be responsible for the creation of new tidal dwarf galaxies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
at the opposite extreme in density , isolated ` field ' dwarf galaxies may have fewer or no interactions with more massive companions , which could result in distinctly different patterns of star formation and chemical evolution when compared to typical group members ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) .
lcccccc ursamin & mw & -7.13 & 0.08 & 0.11 & dsph & 3.3 + lgs3 & m31 & -7.96 & 0.61 & 0.14 & dtrans & 1.7 + and v & m31 & -8.41 & 0.78 & 0.41 & dsph & 2.8 + draco & mw & -8.74 & 0.09 & 0.09 & dsph & 3.0 + carina & mw & -8.97 & 0.10 & 0.21 & dsph & 2.7 + leo ii & mw & -9.23 & 0.20 & 0.06 & dsph & 1.7 + and iii & m31 & -9.30 & 0.72 & 0.19 & dsph & 3.5 + and ii & m31 & -9.33 & 0.65 & 0.21 & dsph & 2.4 + antlia & m31 & -9.38 & 1.30 & 0.24 & dtrans & -0.1 + sculptor & mw & -9.77 & 0.08 & 0.06 & dsph & 2.8 + cetus & m31 & -10.18 & 0.77 & 0.10 & dsph & 0.5 + phoenix & mw & -10.22 & 0.41 & 0.05 & dtrans & 0.8 + and vi & m31 & -10.80 & 0.83 & 0.21 & dsph & 1.7 + and i & m31 & -10.87 & 0.76 & 0.18 & dsph & 3.7 + leo i & mw & -10.97 & 0.25 & 0.12 & dsph & 1.5 + ddo210 & m31 & -11.09 & 0.94 & 0.17 & dtrans & 1.6 + pegasus & m31 & -11.47 & 0.95 & 0.22 & di & 1.2 + sagdig & mw & -11.49 & 1.11 & 0.40 & di & -0.3 + fornax & mw & -11.50 & 0.14 & 0.07 & dsph & 2.3 + andvii & m31 & -11.67 & 0.94 & 0.64 & dsph & 2.0 + leoa & mw & -11.70 & 0.79 & 0.07 & di & 0.1 + sagittarius & mw & -12.80 & 0.03 & 0.40 & dsph & 4.0 + tucana & mw & -12.94 & 0.86 & 0.11 & dsph & -0.1 + sexa & mw & -13.71 & 1.30 & 0.14 &
di & -0.6 + sexb & mw & -13.88 & 1.40 & 0.10 & di & -0.7 + wlm & m31 & -13.95 & 0.93 & 0.12 & di & 0.3 + n185 & m31 & -14.76 & 0.61 & 0.61 & dsph / de & 3.5 + n147 & m31 & -14.79 & 0.72 & 0.58 & dsph / de & 3.0 + ic1613 & m31 & -15.57 & 0.74 & 0.08 & di & 0.9 [ lgtab ] directly comparing the stellar contents of lg dwarf galaxies to those in the nearby universe requires uniform data sets of comparable quality and size .
historically , studies of resolved stellar populations in nearby dwarf galaxies have focused on small samples or individual galaxies , and have employed a variety of analysis techniques , leading to larger systematic uncertainties when comparing different studies .
recent projects described by @xcite and @xcite have resulted in two uniformly processed multi - color photometric databases of the resolved stellar populations of dwarf galaxies in the lg and local volume , which , for the first time , allow a direct unbiased study of dwarf galaxies in a large volume , spanning a wide range of environments . in this paper
, we present a comparison of the cumulative sfhs and morphology density relationships of dwarf galaxies in the lg and the local volume .
we have measured the sfhs from uniformly processed photometry , using the same sfh code and stellar evolution models , minimizing the effects of potential systematics for comparison of the relative sfhs . for the lg
, we use the best fit sfhs from updated analysis of the lg sample @xcite , initially presented in @xcite .
sfhs for the local volume are taken from the measured sfhs of angst dwarf galaxies @xcite .
we specifically address the question of whether or not the most likely cumulative sfhs of the lg dwarfs are comparable to those of the angst sample . in addition to comparing the _ mean _ cumulative sfhs , we also consider effects that can potentially introduce biases in the measured sfhs , such as population gradients and systematic uncertainties in the underlying stellar models . this paper is organized as follows . in [ data ] , we summarize the sample selection and data .
the technique of measuring sfhs from optical color - magnitude diagrams ( cmds ) is briefly reviewed in
[ sfhs ] . in
[ discuss ] , we address the question of whether the sfhs of lg dwarf galaxies are consistent with those in the local universe , by comparing cumulative sfhs from the angst and lg dwarf galaxy samples .
we then examine the morphology density relationship for both lg and and angst dwarfs , and discuss demographic differences in the samples in [ morph ] .
cosmological parameters used in this paper assume a standard wmap-7 cosmology @xcite .
for this comparison , we consider a sample of lg dwarf galaxies based on those discussed in @xcite ( see table [ lgtab ] ) .
all galaxies have multi - color optical imaging taken with either the advanced camera for surveys ( acs ; * ? ? ? * ) or the wide field planetary camera 2 ( wfpc2 ; * ? ? ?
* ) aboard hst .
following the convention of @xcite , we have excluded the lmc and smc from this paper .
similarly , we have omitted ngc 3109 , ngc 205 , ngc 6822 , and ngc 55 as these are sufficiently luminous galaxies that their status as dwarfs is ambiguous ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
similarly , we have excluded ` ultra - faint ' lg dwarf galaxies ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) and andromeda companions discovered more recently than and vii ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) from this comparison ; these sets of galaxies do not yet have publicly available hst photometry that has been processed in the same way as the galaxies we consider in this paper .
the resulting lg sample covers a range of @xmath1 from @xmath27.13 ( ursa minor ) to @xmath215.57 ( ic1613 ) .
we divide the sample into three categories , dwarf spheroidal / elliptical ( dsph ) , dwarf irregular ( di ) , and transition dwarf ( dtrans ) galaxies according to the morphological classifications in @xcite .
we combine dwarf spheroidals and the two dwarf ellipticals ( de ; ngc 147 and ngc 185 ; e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) into a canonical gas - poor galaxy ( dsph ) category .
following the convention of @xcite , we designate dtrans as those which have detectable amounts of hi and no _ significant _ recent star formation , as measured by h@xmath3 .
we note that @xcite classifies pegasus as a dtrans , but @xcite detect significant levels of h@xmath3 , and thus we consider it to be a di .
we also exclude ic 10 due to its low galactic latitude and high foreground extinction ( @xmath4 @xmath5 2.5 ; * ? ? ?
* ) , making both its distance and sfh highly uncertain . in total , the lg sample has 18 dsphs , 7 dis , and 4 dtrans ( table [ lgtab ] ) .
lcccccc kk230 & m31 & -8.49 & 1.3 & 0.04 & dtrans & -1.0 + kkr25 & m31 & -9.94 & 1.9 & 0.03 & dtrans & -0.7 + fm1 & m82 & -10.16 & 3.4 & 0.24 & dsph / de & 1.8 + kkh86 & m31 & -10.19 & 2.6 & 0.08 & di & -1.5 + kkh98 & m31 & -10.29 & 2.5 & 0.39 & dtrans & -0.7 + bk5n & n3077 & -10.37 & 3.8 & 0.20 & dsph / de & 2.4 + sc22 & n253 & -10.39 & 4.2 & 0.05 & dsph & 0.9 + kdg73 & m81 & -10.75 & 3.7 & 0.06 & dtrans & 1.3 + ikn & m81 & -10.84 & 3.7 & 0.18 & dsph & 2.7 + e294 - 010 & n55 & -10.86 & 1.9 & 0.02 & dtrans & 1.0 + e540 - 032 & n253 & -11.22 & 3.4 & 0.06 & dtrans & 0.6 + kkh37 & i342 & -11.26 & 3.4 & 0.23 & di & -0.3 + kdg2 & n253 & -11.29 & 3.4 & 0.07 & dtrans & 0.4 + ua292 & n4214 & -11.36 & 3.1 & 0.05 & di & -0.4 + kdg52 & m81 & -11.37 & 3.5 & 0.06 & dtrans & 0.7 + kk77 & m81 & -11.42 & 3.5 & 0.44 & dsph / de & 2.0 + e410 - 005 & n55 & -11.49 & 1.9 & 0.04 & dtrans & 0.4 + hs117 & m81 & -11.51 & 4.0 & 0.36 & di & 1.9 + ddo113 & n4214 & -11.61 & 2.9 & 0.06 & di & 1.6 + kdg63 & m81 & -11.71 & 3.5 & 0.30 & dsph / de & 1.8 + ddo44 & n2403 & -11.89 & 3.2 & 0.13 & dsph & 1.7 + gr8 & m31 & -12.00 & 2.1 & 0.08 & di & -1.2 + e269 - 37 & n4945 & -12.02 & 3.5 & 0.44 & dsph & 1.6 + ddo78 & m81 & -12.04 & 3.7 & 0.07 & dsph & 1.8 + f8d1 & m81 & -12.20 & 3.8 & 0.33 & dsph / de & 3.8 + u8833 & n4736 & -12.31 & 3.1 & 0.04 & di & -1.4 + e321 - 014 & n5128 & -12.31 & 3.2 & 0.29 & di & -0.3 + kdg64 & m81 & -12.32 & 3.7 & 0.17 & dsph / de & 2.5 + ddo6 & n253 & -12.40 & 3.3 & 0.05 & dtrans & 0.5 + ddo187 & m31 & -12.43 & 2.3 & 0.07 & di & -1.3 + kdg61 & m81 & -12.54 & 3.6 & 0.23 & dsph / de & 3.9 + u4483 & m81 & -12.58 & 3.2 & 0.11 & di & 0.5 + ua438 & n55 & -12.85 & 2.2 & 0.05 & dtrans & -0.7 + ddo181 & m81 & -12.94 & 3.0 & 0.02 & di & -1.3 + u8508 & m81 & -12.95 & 2.6 & 0.05 & di & -1.0 + n3741 & m81 & -13.01 & 3.0 & 0.07 & di & -0.8 + ddo183 & n4736 & -13.08 & 3.2 & 0.05 & di & -0.8 + ddo53 & m81 & -13.23 & 3.5 & 0.12 & di & 0.7 + ddo99 & n4214 & -13.37 & 2.6 & 0.08 & di & -0.5 + n4163 & n4190 & -13.76 & 3.0 & 0.06 & di & 0.1 + ddo125 & n4214 & -14.04 & 2.5 & 0.06 & di & -0.9 + e325 - 11 & n5128 & -14.05 & 3.4 & 0.29 & di & 1.1 + ddo190 & m81 & -14.14 & 2.8 & 0.04 & di & -1.3 + ho i & m81 & -14.26 & 3.8 & 0.15 & di & 1.5 + ddo165 & n4236 & -15.09 & 4.6 & 0.08 & di & 0.0 + ic5152 & m31 & -15.67 & 1.9 & 0.08 & di & -1.1 + n2366 & n2403 & -15.85 & 3.2 & 0.11 & di & 1.0 + ho ii & m81 & -16.57 & 3.4 & 0.10 & di & 0.6 [ angsttab ] the sfhs used for this comparison are based on cmds presented in @xcite and @xcite that have been re - measured and analyzed @xcite with updated padova stellar evolution models @xcite .
these sfhs are based on photometry of hst / wfpc2 imaging that was uniformly processed using hstphot @xcite as part of the local group stellar populations archive @xcite .
five of the lg dwarfs ( cetus , tucana , ic 1613 , leo a , and lgs3 ) were more recently observed with acs as part of the local cosmology with isolated dwarfs program ( lcid ; * ? ? ?
* ) , and have significantly deeper cmds compared to the corresponding wfpc2 photometry ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
photometry of acs observations was performed with dolphot , an update of hstphot with an acs specific module , which allows us to include these five sfhs without compromising uniformity .
the acs nearby galaxy survey treasury ( angst ; * ? ? ?
* ) sample contains dwarf galaxies located beyond the zero velocity surface of the lg @xcite and within @xmath6 @xmath5 4 mpc ( see table [ angsttab ] ) .
the sample contains a mixture of field and group galaxies , the latter of which are located in the m81 group ( d@xmath7 @xmath5 3.6 mpc ) and in the direction of the ngc 253 clump ( d@xmath8 @xmath5 3.9 mpc ) in the sculptor filament @xcite . for comparison , we have selected all dsphs , dis , and dtrans for the angst dwarf sample , as defined in @xcite .
we note that several angst galaxies ( antlia , gr8 , sex a , sex b , ic 5152 , and ugca 438 ) are considered to be in the lg of @xcite . of these galaxies ,
antlia , sex a , and sex b are on the periphery of the lg , and we classify them as part of the lg sample for the purposes of this study .
trgb distance determinations ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) place ic 5152 , gr8 , and ua 438 clearly beyond the zero velocity surface of the lg , and we thus include them in the angst sample for this comparison .
the angst sample contains several reported des , all within the m81 group : f8d1 , bk5n , kdg 61 , kdg 64 , kk 77 , fm 1 , and ddo 71 @xcite .
we include these in the dsph category .
although the term de has often been used to describe early type dwarf galaxies outside the lg ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , here we adopt the term dsph , which has historically been used in lg studies ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * and references therein ) as a number of the early type angst dwarf galaxies have luminosities and cmds that are similar to dsphs in the lg .
we discuss potential differences between des and dsphs in this sample in [ morph ] .
the faint end of the angst galaxy luminosity function is likely not complete due to selection biases against identifying faint low luminosity surface brightness galaxies .
for example , the angst sample does not include a number of recently discovered low surface brightness m81 group galaxies @xcite , as they do not yet have hst imaging publicly available .
the final sample of angst galaxies in this paper includes 12 dsphs , 25 dis , and 11 dtrans , spanning a range in @xmath1 from @xmath28.49 ( kk230 ) to @xmath216.57 ( ho ii ) .
the sfhs of the angst dwarf galaxies are presented in @xcite .
data reduction and analysis , i.e. , photometry and sfhs , have been done in a manner consistent with the lg sample , making it possible for a direct comparison .
we briefly summarize the technique of measuring a sfh from a cmd , based on more detailed discussions of the methodology described in @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite .
for this technique , we specify an imf , binary fraction , and allowable ranges in age , metallicity , distance , and extinction .
photometric errors and completeness are characterized by artificial star tests . from these inputs ,
the code generates many synthetic cmds spanning the desired age and metallicity range . for this work , we used synthetic cmds sampling stars with logarithmic age and metallicity spreads of 0.05 and 0.1 dex , respectively .
these individual synthetic cmds were then linearly combined along with a model foreground cmd to produce a composite synthetic cmd .
the linear weights on the individual cmds are adjusted to obtain the best fit as measured by a poisson maximum likelihood statistic ; the weights corresponding to the best fit are the most probable sfh
. this process can be repeated at a variety of distance and extinction values to solve for these parameters as well . in this study , we consider the cumulative sfhs , which give the fraction of stellar mass formed prior to a given time .
we prefer this presentation to the more traditional plot of star formation rate ( sfr ) vs. time , as the cumulative sfhs allow galaxies of different masses to be directly compared , and cumulative sfh measurements are not subject to covariant sfrs in adjacent time bins ( see appendix a of @xcite ) .
we specifically compute an average cumulative sfhs per morphological type for both the lg and angst samples , which is the unweighted mean of the individual cumulative sfhs of galaxies within each group .
this scheme weights all galaxies equally , so that the resulting sfh indicates what s ` typical ' for a particular morphological type .
the resulting mean cumulative sfhs are shown in figure [ cum_sfh ] .
we assign uncertainties to the mean cumulative sfhs using the method of error analysis outlined in @xcite and @xcite .
first , we divide the total uncertainty in the derived sfh into random and systematic components .
random uncertainties are due to poisson uncertainties of the number of stars used to derive the sfr in a given time bin .
the random uncertainties include observational effects , such as photometric errors and completeness corrections , which can affect the number of stars in each model time bin . to compute the random component of the uncertainty in the mean cumulative sfh , we add the uncertainties in the sfrs per time bin from the individual sfhs in quadrature .
these random uncertainties are shown as the error bars in the left panel of figure [ cum_sfh ] .
for well - populated cmds , including most of those used to measure the sfhs considered in this paper , the amplitude of random uncertainties are typically @xmath0 10% . the second source of uncertainty we consider are systematic uncertainties .
systematics are introduced into the measured sfhs through biases in the underlying stellar models that change as a function of photometric depth of the observed cmd .
the photometric depth of a cmd determines the presence of age sensitive features ( e.g. , ancient ms turn - off , horizontal branch ) available for measuring a sfh ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
for extremely deep cmds that include the ancient main sequence turn off ( msto ) , systematics are typically small , because of the reliability of ms stellar evolution models . for shallower cmds , including the majority of those used for sfh measurements in this paper , we must rely on the evolved star populations ( e.g. , rgb , hb ) to constrain the sfh .
the physics of evolved stars is not yet fully understood , and consequently sfhs derived from cmds that primarily contain evolved stars may be systematically biased ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
appendix b in @xcite demonstrates the effect of systematic biases on sfh measurements . for comparison of sfhs in this paper
, we are interested in the differential systematic uncertainties between the lg and angst samples .
specifically , we wish to understand how the different typical photometric depths between the two samples affects the derived sfhs . to estimate the systematic uncertainties , we follow the procedure outlined appendices b and c in @xcite .
briefly , this technique uses the differences in sfhs derived using the basti @xcite and padua stellar evolution models as an estimate of systematic errors . in the case of the lg and angst galaxies
, we did the following exercise to gauge the systematic uncertainties in the derived sfhs .
first , we simulated a cmd assuming constant sfh using the basti stellar evolution models at photometric depths equivalent to those in the lg and angst samples .
we then recovered the sfh of each simulated cmd using the padua models .
next , we took the cumulative sfh of each realization and computed the mean of the ensemble population .
for example , for each of the 18 angst dsphs , we simulated a cmd assuming a constant sfh to the depth of the observed cmd , using the basti models , and then recovered the sfh using the padua models . from these 18 realizations
, we then computed the mean cumulative sfh for this collection of simulations .
this exercise was then repeated for all the other morphological sub - groups , e.g. , lg dsphs , angst dis , etc .
we now want to compare the differences in the observed cumulative sfhs with the size of the systematic uncertainties .
to do this , we simply take the difference of the observed cumulative sfhs and the simulated cumulative sfhs , and compare the amplitude of the difference per time bin . as a concrete example
, we can consider the systematics associated with the dsphs .
we first compute the difference in the mean cumulative sfhs , and show them as the black points in panel ( a ) of figure [ cum_sfh ] .
the error bars on each point are the random uncertainties .
we then compute the difference in the mean recovered sfhs of the lg and angst dsphs samples .
this difference is plotted as the red points in panel ( a ) of figure [ cum_sfh ] . in general , if the value of the red points are greater than those of the black points , the systematic uncertainties are larger than the difference in the measured sfhs .
note that this exercise is an equivalent to a single monte carlo realization for each ensemble , and thus provides an _ estimate _ of the systematic uncertainties .
we consider an additional source of uncertainty , which is due to the limited areas ample by the lg hst observations . from studies of lg dwarfs
, it has long been known that the central regions of dwarfs typically have larger numbers of young or intermediate age stars , while populations further from the center tend to have older average ages ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
because of their close proximity , lg dwarf galaxies have large angular areas relative to hst s field of view and , in most cases , the deepest available hst observations target the central regions of dwarf galaxies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
the implications for this study are that the lg sfhs derived for the central regions may not be representative of the entire galaxies .
in contrast , the angst galaxies are distant enough that a single hst field typically covers the entire extent of a dwarf galaxy @xcite .
the net effect of this bias is that sfhs of the lg dwarfs are likely weighted toward somewhat younger ages .
however , quantifying such an effect on sfhs must wait for wide - field cmds that reach the ancient msto .
finally , as evidenced by the amplitude of the systematic uncertainties ( shown on the right side of figure [ cum_sfh ] ) , we can not reliably compare sfhs prior to z @xmath5 1 ( @xmath9 7.6 gyr ago ) . at these early epochs , only ultra - deep cmds reaching the ancient main sequence turnoff
can reliably decipher the details of the ancient sfhs , e.g. , the epoch of the peak ancient sfr .
although some such cmds are available within the lg sample , none are present for the more distance galaxies in the angst sample .
thus , while the two samples are generally comparable in their cumulative sfhs , studies of the detailed ancient sfhs indicate that galaxies can show wide variation in their patterns of star formation at the oldest epochs ( e.g. , * ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
these early variations may show correlations with environment or other galaxy properties .
however , we are not able to discern such differences for the vast majority of galaxies in our samples .
in the left panel of figure [ cum_sfh ] , we compare the mean cumulative sfhs of the angst and lg samples per morphological type .
the plotted error bars represent only the random uncertainties in the sfhs , i.e. , .
the expected amplitude of systematic uncertainties are shown in the right panel .
we first compare the mean cumulative sfhs of the angst and lg samples .
taken at face value , the sfhs in the left panel of figure [ cum_sfh ] indicate that the cumulative sfhs of dsphs and dtrans are generally comparable , for the angst and lg volumes . in particular , the typical dsph or dtrans galaxy in either sample formed @xmath5 70% of its stars by z @xmath5 1 ( 7.6 gyr ago ) , the look back time to which the typical angst cmd is sensitive @xcite . at more recent times , we see some differences between the cumulative sfhs of the two dsph populations . the lg dsphs appear to have formed a slightly higher percentage of stars by z @xmath5 0.2 , but the two sample show agreement for times more recent than z @xmath5 0.1 .
in contrast , the cumulative sfhs of lg and angst dis do not generally agree within the random uncertainties .
in particular , the typical lg di has formed @xmath5 50% of its stars by z @xmath5 1 ( 7.6 gyr ago ) , which the typical angst di has formed @xmath5 65% by the same epoch , although we note that accounting for effects of population gradients would likely increase the percent of stellar mass formed an ancient times for the lg dis , brining the samples into closer agreement . for meaningful comparison of the sfhs
, we can not take the mean sfhs at face value , and instead must consider the influence of systematic effects on the derived sfhs . as outlined
[ sfhs ] we have estimated the systematic effects as a function of varying numbers of galaxies observed at varying depths of photometry , and find that , overall , the differences between the lg and angst dwarf galaxy sfhs are typically smaller than the systematic and statistical uncertainties , suggesting that the sfhs of the two samples are likely not very different .
we see that the systematic effects on the mean cumulative sfhs are largest for the the dsph galaxy samples ( i.e. , the colored points are usually larger than the black points ) for ages older than 4 gyr . for the dtrans samples the differences are very comparable to the systematic uncertainty estimates , and for the dis samples , the systematic uncertainties are generally less than the observed differences in the mean cumulative sfhs .
thus , the sfhs of the dsphs and dtrans in the lg and angst volumes appear to be be fairly similar .
interpreting the differences in the cumulative sfhs of the lg and angst dis is not straightforward .
on one hand , the differences their mean cumulative sfhs seem to exceed the estimates of the systematic uncertainties .
taken at face value , this suggests that the dis in the two samples are not consistent . however , there are two effects which convolute this interpretation .
first , is the effect of population gradients , which tend to bias the ancient sfhs of lg dis to somewhat younger ages .
because we can not quantify the size of this effect , we only note that the cumulative sfhs of the lg dis are likely lower limits .
the second issue is interpreting the meaning of the systematic uncertainties .
we have used the differences in sfhs recovered from two sets of stellar models as a proxy for systematic uncertainties . yet
, these models share a degree of similarity in their underlying physics , for example nuclear reaction rate and stellar atmospheres , which may make similarities in these models larger than the similarity between any one model and observed data .
thus , in some sense , the systematics we consider in this study are also lower limits due to the inherent similarity of the underlying stellar models .
while it is not clear if the observed difference in the sfhs of the lg and angst dis is indicative of different modes of sf or simply the result of several biases , we do suggest that , at minimum , these sfhs are not drastically different . the comparison shown in
[ comp_sfhs ] suggests that the differences in the sfh between the lg and angst dwarfs are not pronounced .
we therefore now consider the sfh and morphological properties of the combined sample of @xmath5 80 galaxies . from the sfh perspective
, the sfhs of the entire lg and angst dwarf population confirm the findings of @xcite .
namely , we verify that the dsphs , dtrans , and dis have very similar cumulative sfhs until z @xmath5 0.7 .
subsequent to this time , the average dsphs formed a higher fraction of its stellar mass , and appear to have little sf more recently than z @xmath5 0.1 .
in contrast , dis formed higher fractions of their stellar mass at more recent times .
dtrans straddle the middle between the dsphs and dis .
the combined lg - angst dwarf sample also gives us excellent dynamic rang for probing the morphology density relationship . in figure
[ mdr ] , we see that the lg and angst samples show clear and well - matched morphology density relationships .
the dis in both samples span a broad range of predominantly negative tidal indices ( @xmath10 , a useful probe of local density ; * ? ? ?
* ) indicating that dis are preferentially found away from dense environments .
this result is consistent with previous studies of both the lg ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and dwarf galaxies in the wider universe ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the angst sample has more dis with @xmath10 @xmath11 @xmath21.5 , which is due to the large field population of the sample .
dsphs in the two samples typically have positive tidal indices and fainter values of @xmath1 when compared to the dis . a kolmogorov - smirnov ( ks ) test confirms that dis and dsphs
are not drawn from the same distribution in either environment or luminosity , with a less than @xmath12 probability of having identical distributions .
in contrast with the sharp division in properties between dis and dsphs , dtrans have properties that are intermediate between the two classes .
dtrans galaxies occupy environments that are statistically indistinguishable from those of dis , according to a ks test .
their environments are statistically distinct from those occupied by dsphs , with only a @xmath13 probability of being drawn from the same distribution of @xmath10 .
the luminosities of the dtrans galaxies have the opposite behavior .
their luminosities are statistically indistinguishable from those of dsphs , but are statistically lower luminosity than dis , with only a @xmath14 probability of being drawn from the same distribution of luminosities .
to first order , the results above suggest that the majority of dtrans are consistent with being the low mass end of the di population . at these low masses ,
there are seldom more than a few hii regions per galaxy ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) leading to a dtrans classification .
however , we note that gas - rich galaxies with little h@xmath3 can form in multiple ways ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) suggesting that not every dtrans has a similar evolutionary history .
those with higher tidal indices may be interacting galaxies in the process of transforming to gas - poor dsphs ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) .
we refer the reader to @xcite for a more detailed discussion of the nature of dtrans .
although we have grouped all early type dsphs and des together into a single ` dsph ' category , it is interesting to search for distinguishing characteristics between the two morphological types .
figure [ mdr ] reveals that the two des in the lg , ( @xmath1514.79 ) and ngc 185 ( @xmath1514.76 ) , are conspicuously more luminous than other early type dwarfs .
their intrinsic brightness is likely linked to the relatively large amount of intermediate age sf ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
in contrast , the seven des in the angst volume ( f8d1 , bk5n , kdg 61 , kdg 64 , kk 77 , fm 1 , and kdg 63 ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , span a broad range of lower luminosities from fm 1 ( @xmath1510.16 ) to kdg 61 ( @xmath1512.54 ) . examining the global sfhs of the angst des ,
we find that the two lowest luminosity angst des ( fm 1 and bk5n ) are dominated by stellar populations older than @xmath5 10 gyr , while the more luminous des ( kk 77 , kdg 63 , f8d1 , kdg 64 , and kdg 61 ) have larger fractions of intermediate sf , albeit at a lower absolute sfr than the two lg des ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the predominance of old stellar populations in the two low luminosity des is more consistent with the lg and angst dsph populations , suggesting a dsph designation would be more accurate .
interestingly , two of the most luminous angst des ( f8d1 and kdg 61 ) have high tidal indices ( @xmath10 @xmath5 4 ) that are comparable to the lg des .
this suggests that , like ngc 147 and ngc 185 which have a history of interaction with m31 ( @xcite and references therein ) , f8d1 and kdg 61 may have have experienced interactions with their most gravitationally influential neighbor , m81 .
the two lg des may be examples of formerly gas - rich , rotationally supported dis that are in the process of being transformed into gas - poor , pressure supported dsphs / des ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
further detailed study of the stellar kinematics of f8d1 and kdg 61 may help determine if these galaxies are undergoing a similar process , and may provide insight into the possible physical mechanisms ( e.g. , ram pressure , stellar mass loss ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) driving this transformation .
we present a comparison of the cumulative sfhs of lg and angst dwarf galaxies from high quality cmds based on hst imaging . in order to minimize systematics
, the sfhs from each samples were derived using identical techniques and input parameters .
the typical lg and angst dwarf galaxy appear to have formed the majority of their stellar mass prior to z @xmath5 1 ( 7.6 gyr ago ) . comparing the sfhs between the morphological types , we find that the dsphs and dtrans in the angst and lg samples have similar cumulative sfhs .
in contrast , the lg and angst dis exhibit differences in their sfhs at ancient times , when taken at face value . we show that the observed differences are likely lower limits , due to the effects of population gradients , and the lower limit systematic uncertainties we have calculated .
give that similarity of the lg and angst dwarf populations , we combine them into a single large sample .
this combined sample exhibits a well - defined morphology density relationship , with dis showing higher degrees of isolation than dsphs .
a ks test reveals that dtrans occupy similar environments to dis but have luminosities comparable to dsphs .
we further identify two m81 group des with luminosities , tidal indices , and sfhs which may be analogs to this rare class of galaxy in the lg .
the excellent agreement between the two samples , and among the broader universe , underlines the importance of environmental factors in the evolution of dwarf galaxies . in summary , we find that the cumulative sfhs and morphology - density relationships of the lg and angst samples are not drastically different .
this finding suggests that the lg dwarf galaxies are reasonably representative of dwarf galaxies in the wider universe . the authors would like to thank the anonymous referee for a number of insightful comments that have helped to improve this paper .
drw is grateful for support from the university of minnesota doctoral dissertation fellowship and penrose fellowship .
idk is partially supported by rfbr grant 10 - 02 - 00123 .
support for kmg is provided by nasa through hubble fellowship grant hst - hf-51273.01 awarded by the space telescope science institute .
this work is based on observations made with the nasa / esa hubble space telescope , obtained from the data archive at the space telescope science institute .
support for this work was provided by nasa through grants go-10915 , dd-11307 , and go-11986 from the space telescope science institute , which is operated by aura , inc . , under nasa contract nas5 - 26555 .
this research has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration .
this research has made extensive use of nasa s astrophysics data system bibliographic services .
_ facility : _
aparicio , a. , & hidalgo , s. l. 2009 , , 138 , 558 belokurov , v. , et al .
2006 , , 647 , l111 butler , d. j. , & martnez - delgado , d. 2005 , , 129,2217 caldwell , n. , armandroff , t. e. , da costa , g. s. , & seitzer , p. 1998
, , 115 , 535 chiboucas , k. , karachentsev , i. d. , & tully , r. b. 2009 , , 137 , 3009 cole , a. a. , tolstoy , e. , gallagher , j. s. , iii , & smecker - hane , t. a. 2005 , , 129 , 1465 cole , a. a. , et al . 2007 , , 659 , l17 cowie , l. l. , songaila , a. , hu , e. m. , & cohen , j. g. 1996 , , 112 , 839 da costa , g. s. 2007 , from stars to galaxies : building the pieces to build up the universe , 374 , 247 dalcanton , j. j. , et al .
2009 , , 183 , 67 dolphin , a. e. 2000 , , 112 , 1383 dolphin , a. e. 2002 , , 332 , 91 dolphin , a. e. , weisz , d. r. , skillman , e. d. , & holtzman , j. a. 2005 , arxiv : astro - ph/0506430 dolphin , a. e. , et al . , 2010 , in prep .
ford , h. c. , et al .
1998 , , 3356 , 234 gallart , c. , zoccali , m. , & aparicio , a. 2005 , , 43 , 387 gallart , c. , & the lcid team 2007 , iau symposium , 241 , 290 geha , m. , blanton , m. r. , masjedi , m. , & west , a. a. 2006 , , 653 , 240 han , m. , hoessel , j. g. , gallagher , j. s. , iii , holtsman , j. , & stetson , p. b. 1997 , , 113 , 1001 hidalgo , s. l. , aparicio , a. , martnez - delgado , d. , & gallart , c. 2009 , , 705 , 704 hidalgo , s. l. , et al .
2011 , , 730 , 14 hodge , p. w. 1971 , , 9 , 35 hodge , p. w. 1973 , , 182 , 671 holtzman , j. a. , burrows , c. j. , casertano , s. , hester , j. j. , trauger , j. t. , watson , a. m. , & worthey , g. 1995 , , 107 , 1065 hunter , d. a. , & gallagher , j. s. , iii 1986 , , 98 , 5 irwin , m. , & hatzidimitriou , d. 1995 , , 277 , 1354 geha , m. , van der marel , r. p. , guhathakurta , p. , gilbert , k. m. , kalirai , j. , & kirby , e. n. 2010 , , 711 , 361 girardi , l. , et al .
2010 , , 724 , 1030 grebel , e. k. , gallagher , j. s. , iii , & harbeck , d. 2003 , , 125 , 1926 holtzman , j. a. , afonso , c. , & dolphin , a. 2006 , , 166 , 534 jarosik , n. , et al . 2010 ,
arxiv:1001.4744 karachentsev , i. d. , et al .
2003 , , 404 , 93 karachentsev , i. d. , karachentseva , v. e. , huchtmeier , w. k. , & makarov , d. i. 2004 , , 127 , 2031 kazantzidis , s. , lokas , e. l. , callegari , s. , mayer , l. , & moustakas , l. a. 2010 , arxiv:1009.2499 makarova , l. n. , et al .
2002 , , 396 , 473 marigo , p. , girardi , l. , bressan , a. , groenewegen , m. a. t. , silva , l. , & granato , g. l. 2008 , , 482 , 88 marigo , p. , et al .
2010 , iau symposium , 262 , 36 mateo , m. l. 1998 , , 36 , 435 mayer , l. , governato , f. , colpi , m. , moore , b. , quinn , t. , wadsley , j. , stadel , j. , & lake , g. 2001 , , 547 , l123 mayer , l. , governato , f. , colpi , m. , moore , b. , quinn , t. , wadsley , j. , stadel , j. , & lake , g. 2001 , , 559 , 754 mcconnachie , a. w. , et al .
2009 , , 461 , 66 monelli , m. , et al .
2010 , , 720 , 1225 monelli , m. , et al .
2010 , , 722 , 1864 pietrinferni , a. , cassisi , s. , salaris , m. , & castelli , f. 2004 , , 612 , 168 reddy , n. a. , steidel , c. c. , pettini , m. , adelberger , k. l. , shapley , a. e. , erb , d. k. , & dickinson , m. 2008 , , 175 , 48 reddy , n. a. , erb , d. k. , pettini , m. , steidel , c. c. , & shapley , a. e. 2010 , , 712 , 1070 sabbi , e. , gallagher , j. s. , smith , l. j. , de mello , d. f. , & mountain , m. 2008 , , 676 , l113 schlegel , d. j. , finkbeiner , d. p. , & davis , m. 1998 , , 500 , 525 skillman , e. d. 1996 , the minnesota lectures on extragalactic neutral hydrogen , 106 , 208 skillman , e. d. , ct , s. , & miller , b. w. 2003 , , 125 , 593 tolstoy , e. , hill , v. , & tosi , m. 2009 , , 47 , 371 van den bergh , s. 2000 , the galaxies of the local group , by sidney van den bergh . published by cambridge , uk : cambridge university press , 2000 cambridge astrophysics series series , vol no : 35 , isbn : 0521651816 .
walter , f. , et al .
2011 , , 726 , l11 weisz , d. r. , skillman , e. d. , cannon , j. m. , dolphin , a. e. , kennicutt , r. c. , jr . , lee , j. , & walter , f. 2008 , , 689 , 160 weisz , d. r. , et al .
, 2011 , submitted yun , m. s. , ho , p. t. p. , & lo , k. y. 1994 , , 372 , 530 yun , m. s. 1999 , galaxy interactions at low and high redshift , 186 , 81 zaritsky , d. , harris , j. , thompson , i. b. , & grebel , e. k. 2004 , , 128 , 1606 zucker , d. b. , et al .
2004 , , 612 , l121 | we compare the cumulative star formation histories ( sfhs ) of local group ( lg ) dwarf galaxies with those in the volume - limited acs nearby galaxy survey treasury ( angst ) sample ( d @xmath0 4 mpc ) , in order to understand how typical the lg dwarf galaxies are relative to those in the nearby universe .
the sfhs were derived in a uniform manner from high quality optical color - magnitude diagrams constructed from hubble space telescope imaging .
we find that the _ mean _ cumulative sfhs of the lg dwarfs are comparable to the mean cumulative sfhs of the angst sample for the three different morphological types ( dwarf spheroidals / ellipticals : dsph / de ; dwarf irregulars : di ; transition dwarfs : dtrans ) .
we also discuss effects such as population gradients and systematic uncertainties in the stellar models that may influence the derived sfhs . both the angst and local group dwarf galaxies show a consistent and strong morphology - density relationship , emphasizing the importance of environment in the evolution of dwarf galaxies .
specifically , we confirm that dis are found at lower densities and higher luminosities than dsphs , within this large sample .
we also find that dtrans are located in similar environments to those occupied by dwarf irregular galaxies , but have systematically lower luminosities that are more comparable to those of dwarf spheroidals .
the similarity of the sfhs and morphology - density relationships of the lg and angst dwarf galaxies suggests that the lg dwarfs are a good representation of dwarf galaxies in the local universe . |
lvy flights describe a class of random walks whose step lengths follow a power - law tailed distribution @xcite . in a lvy flight , the probability @xmath0 that the walker performs a jump of length @xmath1 is given by @xmath2 with @xmath3 .
lvy flights have been proven to be the best strategy that can be adopted in random searches @xcite .
in particular , viswanathan and collaborators proved that , independently of the dimensions of the space where the search is performed , the optimal exponent is @xmath4 if ( i ) the target sites are sparse , ( ii ) they can be visited multiple times , and ( iii ) the searcher can detect the target only when it is in its close vicinity @xcite . an important case where these conditions are naturally fulfilled concerns foraging animals looking for scarce preys , and in fact lvy flights have been observed in the patterns of movement of different species ranging from albatrosses @xcite to marine predators @xcite , and from monkeys @xcite to mussels @xcite .
although in some cases further analysis is needed @xcite , the overall pattern appears to be robust @xcite .
the evidence for lvy strategies in humans has become manifest in the last few years .
indirect measurement as banknote spreading indicate that corrected lvy flights account for large scale movement of individuals in industrialized countries @xcite , while the dobe ju/ohoansi foraging patterns appear to conform more strictly to the lvy step distribution @xcite , as chilean purse - seiners perform @xcite .
remarkably , also different cognitive processes have been explained in terms of lvy flights .
it has been argued that memory retrieval could be explained in terms of a lvy processes @xcite , while more recently it was shown that lvy flights describe not only movement patterns in real space , but also searches performed by humans in non - physical spaces during online games @xcite .
in addition , this turns out to be the optimal strategy to be adopted , and an evolutionary model accounts for the emergence of this unconscious behavior @xcite .
the emerging picture is surprising .
lvy flights underlie many aspects of human dynamics and behavior , and have the potential to become a unifying concept for problems traditionally addressed by different disciplines , such as urban planning , social science and cognitive science . here
we review and discuss the key evidence provided in the recent literature , which is relatively small and scattered across different journals in different disciplines .
our aim is to present a coherent picture of conceptually related findings that may have gone unnoticed to many potentially interested researchers .
we also argue that the ubiquity of the lvy pattern , both in behavior and cognition of humans and animals , suggests that the brain regions responsible for implementing it are likely to be evolutionarily old ( i.e. no frontal cortex is involved ) , and that fmri techniques might help shed light on this hypothesis .
a neat evidence for the existence of lvy flights in human mobility comes from the analysis of online bill - tracking websites , which track the movement of individual banknotes in space and time @xcite .
motivated by the difficulty to access data about human mobility , the rationale beyond this approach is that banknote displacement mirrors human travel .
brockman et al .
@xcite analyzed approximately @xmath5 reports of the bill - tracking website www.wheresgeorge.com and found that their spatial jumps follows a lvy flight with exponent @xmath6 . beyond this clear signature for the displacement distribution of human travels , the same analysis highlighted the existence of scale - free periods of rest attenuating the dispersal patterns . even taking this element into account , however , the observed dynamics remains superdiffusive .
in particular the lvy flight signature appears to be significantly robust , and independent from the considered observation time windows . while providing a first large scale evidence of a lvy behavior in human mobility
, this study could not provide all the information required to assess individual movement strategies at small scale .
the movement of banknotes , in fact , reflects the combined movement of more individuals who carried the bills between two successive reports to the online tracking system .
more fine - grained insights into human mobility have been gained from the analysis of the mobile phones traces of a set of @xmath7 individuals , whose position were recorded every time their mobile device was actively or passively engaged in a phone call or text message communication @xcite . here , the spatial resolution is determined by the density of the @xmath8 mobile towers , having an average service area of approximately @xmath9 km@xmath10 ( but @xmath11 of which with a covered area smaller or equal to @xmath12 km@xmath10 ) .
gonzlez and coworkers found a distribution of displacements compatible with ( truncated ) lvy flights , with an exponent of @xmath13 , essentially agreeing with the findings of the bank note analysis in @xcite .
however , the mobile phone data set allows for a deeper investigation of the patterns emerging from the aggregated data .
in particular , it turns out that individuals display significant regularities , and spend most of their time in few locations ( work , home , etc . ) .
the conclusion is that the truncated lvy flight pattern observed in aggregated data , and already revealed by the banknote analysis @xcite , is the convolution between individual lvy trajectories and a population heterogeneity emerging when the radius of gyration of different individuals is considered .
a further validation of the lvy behavior was provided by rhee and coworkers @xcite .
the principal merit of their study concerns the unprecedented spatial and temporal resolution at which human mobility has been observed .
the analysis relies on the gps signal of the mobile phones of @xmath14 individuals , whose position was recorded every @xmath15 seconds and with an accuracy of @xmath9 meters in two university campuses , on theme park , one metropolitan area and one state fair .
the total signal amounts to @xmath16 displacement events .
the results indicate that both the flight distribution and the pause - time distribution exhibit heavy tail , compatible with a power - law behavior ( @xmath17 , in the different experiments ) , but also with a weibull or log - normal distributions .
however , a nice corroboration of the lvy flight hypothesis comes by a truncated lvy flight model that accurately reproduces the experimental curves @xcite .
it is also interesting noticing that individuals seem to follow a super - diffusive pattern on short time - scales ( shorter than one hour ) and a sub diffusive one afterwards , even though this is due to individuals reaching the boundary of their individually confined area .
overall , the unparalleled temporal and spatial resolution of this study allows to conclude that lvy flights are genuinely intrinsic to human movements , and that , as the author stress , human intentions instead of geographical artifacts play a major role in producing such a behavior @xcite .
lvy flights have been used to explain not only the movement patterns of individuals , but also those of groups of individuals . this has been observed for groups of spider - monkeys @xcite as well as for groups of human hunter - gatherers @xcite .
the movements analyzed by brown et .
concern the dobe band of the ju/hoansi population living in deserted areas in botswana and namibia@xcite .
this group used to live at the dobe waterhole during the dry season , while during and after the rains small groups moved out into the hinterland building camps somehow near seasonal water sources where plant food and game was available . when resources were exhausted in the proximity of a camp
, they would move again to build another camp or even returning for a short visit to the dobe waterhole . at odds with the studies of section [ s : macromob ] ,
the anthropological investigation could count on a much more limited data set , consisting of the locations of the camps that were occupied by a small kin group during approximately @xmath18 months in @xmath19 , and documented in @xcite . in total , this reduced to @xmath20 displacements and @xmath21 camps . notwithstanding
this limitation , the analysis of @xcite shows that the lvy flight distribution fits the observed foraging pattern better than a normal , exponential or uniform distributions .
furthermore , the exponents for the length of the displacements is @xmath22 , i.e. extremely close to the optimal value @xmath4 @xcite .
thus , when foraging , humans apparently adopt the same optimal strategy of other animals .
another evidence in favor of lvy flights in human foraging patterns comes from the displacement of peruvian purse - seiners @xcite .
bertrand et .
analyzed @xmath23 fishing trips of @xmath24 vessels , equipped with satellite transmitters that record their positions , during @xmath25 months .
the analysis showed that the displacements length follows a clear power law , and aggregating the data for different vessels on a monthly bias provides exponents @xmath26 , with a mode around @xmath27 .
interestingly the primary goal of the study is to infer the spatial distribution of anchovy , under the assumption that the distribution in space of preys should be somehow mirrored in the foraging pattern of the predator through a a sort of `` behavioral cascade '' in space @xcite .
however , the authors do not find any correlation between the observed lvy flight exponent and the total surface occupied by the anchovy or with a measure of spatial concentration , but only with a fractal dimension of anchovy distribution that admittedly has `` no intuitive interpretation '' @xcite . in light of the results discussed above , and
in particular considering that the lvy behavior is optimal in case of a scarce prey @xcite , we believe that a very likely , as well as simple , explanation is that the lvy flight movements of purse - seiners are largely independent of the anchovy distribution , some knowledge of which is more likely to determine small variations at the level of the lvy exponent , rather than being responsible for the overall lvy behavior .
the first study of lvy flights in human cognition concerns an experimental investigation of memory retrieval .
nine subjects were asked to recall as many names as possible within a @xmath28 minutes span , and their inter - retrieval interval was recorded @xcite .
interestingly , rhodes and turvey , the authors of the study , observed an exponential increase in the interval between retrievals interrupted by bursts of shorter retrieval intervals .
overall , the retrieval times follow a power law behavior , with exponents @xmath29 for the different subjects .
the authors propose a suggestive analogy between spatial foraging and memory retrieval , and suggest that particular words are randomly and sparsely located in their respective spaces at sites that are not known a priori " . the lvy behavior would therefore result in an adaptive advantage related to the cognitive power of the _ homo sapiens _
species @xcite .
while this explanation is certainly intriguing , we note that alternative explanations might perhaps account for the observed behavior .
in particular , if we consider the process of word recall as a random - walk exploration of a semantic network @xcite , we see that the task the subjects had to undergo corresponds to the classical problem of network coverage , the experimental focus being on the lag times separating two successive discoveries of new nodes . in this framework
, it has been shown that a tree - like topology , for example , is sufficient to trigger the emergence of heavy tailed distributions of lag times @xcite . however , notwithstanding these possible explanations , the original proposal of @xcite remains plausible , and further investigations in this context can shed new light on the processes underlying memory coverage . in this respect , the recent theoretical extension of lvy flights to complex networks and the evidence that such strategies reduce the coverage time provide new and important conceptual and technical tools @xcite . the clearest evidence for a lvy flight in nature concerns human mental searches @xcite .
if often , in foraging and mobility studies , `` two orders of magnitude of scaling can represent a luxury '' @xcite , here the power law decay has in fact been observed over four orders of magnitude .
the system under scrutiny consisted of users engaging in lowest unique bids ( lub ) on online websites .
a lub is an auction where such prizes as tvs or even cars are won by the participant who offers the lowest and unmatched price .
the minimum increment step for bids is one cent .
so , for example , if three participants bid on one cent , three of them on two cents , and just one of them on three cents , the latter wins the auction .
the revenue for the organizer of the lub comes from the fees that participants pay for each bid they place . on the other hands
, users can win the right to buy the prize for just a few cents .
the authors of the present review , together with l.a.n .
amaral , inspected the jumps between consecutive bids in the bidding ( one - dimensional ) space for @xmath30 participants to @xmath31 auctions in @xmath9 different websites and found a neat indication that individuals sample a power law distribution with exponent @xmath32 , and that _ all _ the individuals who placed enough bids to be analyzed singularly follow the same behavior .
remarkably , performing a lvy flight with that exponent turns out to be the optimal and rational strategy to be adopted in such a competitive arena ( i.e. , a nash equilibrium ) , even though playing a lub is irrational ( no economic gain is expected ) .
subsequently , we also showed that a simple evolutionary model is able to account for the emergence of the observed behavior in a population of individuals performing lubs @xcite . at the beginning
different individuals are endowed with different price - line exploration strategies ( i.e. exponents of the sampled jump distribution ) and let play the lub . as in the classical moran process @xcite , the winner of the lub reproduces transmitting her strategy , possibly slightly mutated , to a new individual ( her ` offspring ' ) which enters the population replacing a randomly extracted user .
remarkably , it can be shown that the population converges towards a lvy flight distribution with the observed exponent irrespective of the initial conditions , and even if at the beginning no individual performs a lvy flight ( i.e. all exponents are larger than @xmath9 or smaller than @xmath12 ) .
thus , the empirically measured lvy behavior turns out to be not only a nash equilibrium , but also an evolutionary stable strategy .
the evidence for lvy behavior in human dynamics has affected different disciplines .
understanding individual mobility patterns in modern societies is crucial for the correct characterization and modeling of the spreading of human infectious diseases @xcite .
a correct description of human movements is crucial also to quantify the role of physical proximity on the creation of social networks @xcite , which in their turn are the substrate for a large spectra of diffusion processes , ranging from mobile routing problems @xcite , epidemic or norm spreading @xcite to language dynamics @xcite . in the same way ,
the lvy behavior has been largely neglected by archaeologists and anthropologists , but it is likely to have an impact on both theoretical and , through the fractal pattern of movements it implies , field excavations @xcite . from the cognitive point of view , on the other hand , identifying the processes underlying memory exploration and retrieval could have a significant impact on the understanding of neurodegenerative diseases @xcite , while it has been argued that the universality of patterns observed for mental searches could impact not only cognitive science , but also behavioral economics @xcite . in conclusion , lvy flights appear to be ubiquitous not only among foraging animals , but also in human behavior and cognition , in such different manifestations as individual mobility , group foraging , industrial fisheries and mental searches .
it is therefore natural to ask the reason for this ubiquity .
where does the lvy conduct come from ?
it seems clear that the adoption of a lvy strategy in both the physical world and in mental representation is beneficial ( if not optimal ) , but it is largely unconscious even for humans .
we therefore raised the hypothesis that there is likely no frontal cortex involvement @xcite .
we hope that fmri techniques will shed light on the nature of the underlying processes responsible for the observed lvy behaviors in near future .
d. w. sims , e. j. southall , n. e. humphries , g. c. hays , c. j. bradshaw , j. w. pitchford , a. james , m. z. ahmed , a. s. brierley , m. a. hindell , et al . , scaling laws of marine predator search behaviour , nature 451 ( 7182 ) ( 2008 ) 10981102 .
g. ramos - fernndez , j. l. mateos , o. miramontes , g. cocho , h. larralde , b. ayala - orozco , lvy walk patterns in the foraging movements of spider monkeys ( ateles geoffroyi ) , behavioral ecology and sociobiology 55 ( 3 ) ( 2004 ) 223230 .
a. m. edwards , r. a. phillips , n. w. watkins , m. p. freeman , e. j. murphy , v. afanasyev , s. v. buldyrev , m. g. da luz , e. p. raposo , h. e. stanley , et al . , revisiting lvy flight search patterns of wandering albatrosses , bumblebees and deer , nature 449 ( 7165 ) ( 2007 ) 10441048 .
s. bertrand , j. m. burgos , f. gerlotto , j. atiquipa , lvy trajectories of peruvian purse - seiners as an indicator of the spatial distribution of anchovy ( engraulis ringens ) , ices journal of marine science : journal du conseil 62 ( 3 ) ( 2005 ) 477482 . | lvy flights represent the best strategy to randomly search for a target in an unknown environment , and have been widely observed in many animal species . here , we inspect and discuss recent results concerning human behavior and cognition .
different studies have shown that human mobility can be described in terms of lvy flights , while fresh evidence indicates that the same pattern accounts for human mental searches in online gambling sites .
thus , lvy flights emerge as a unifying concept with broad cross - disciplinary implications .
we argue that the ubiquity of such a pattern , both in behavior and cognition , suggests that the brain regions responsible for this behavior are likely to be evolutionarily old ( i.e. no frontal cortex is involved ) , and that fmri techniques might help to confirm this hypothesis .
lvy flights , human mobility , behavior , cognition |
motivated by numerical observations by alexander , yorke , you and kan @xcite and sommerer and ott @xcite , the term _ intermingled basins _ was introduced to the mathematics literature by kan in @xcite : `` [ ] any open set which intersects one basin in a set of positive measure also intersects each of the other basins in a set of positive measure '' , and he showed the existence of an open set of diffeomorphisms with two intermingled basins on a three - dimensional manifold .
the degree of intermingledness was soon quantified by the _ uncertainty exponent _
@xcite originally introduced in @xcite . in @xcite this exponent
is calculated numerically for a certain model of point particle motion subject to friction and periodic forcing in a two - dimensional potential ( which does not display intermingled but riddled basins ) , and the authors support their findings theoretically by calculations carried out for a simple piecewise linear model , that has the form of a skew product over two - leg base map with two full linear branches and for which the dynamics are essentially equivalent to that of a random walk with two regimes of transition probabilities .
later , a related quantity denoted _ stability index _ was introduced in @xcite and further studied in @xcite . while the uncertainty exponent measures the degree of intermingledness averaged over points that are equidistant to one of the attractors , the stability index measures intermingledness close to individual points , so it resembles a local dimension . in the present paper we provide rigorous derivations of the two exponents mentioned before for nonlinear generalizations of the piecewise linear system .
we use thermodynamic formalism and large deviations theory for the base map in order to study a nonlinear version of the two - regime random walk .
the class of systems we investigate includes examples from @xcite and also some of the maps from @xcite that serve as models of _ indeterminate competition _ in two species systems . for a particular family of such systems
the numerical analyses in the spirit of @xcite was carried out in @xcite . in the remainder of this section
we introduce the class of skew product danamical systems studied in this paper and some basic concepts related to them . in section 2
we recall the characterization of intermingledness through normal lyapunov exponents , define the stability index and the uncertainty exponent and state our three main theorems , whose proofs are deferred to section 3 .
we study skew product dynamical systems @xmath0 , @xmath1 , defined as follows : @xmath2 denotes the family of all skew product transformations @xmath3 on @xmath4 where @xmath5 is a standard borel space and @xmath6 is a @xmath7-measurable transformation , @xmath8 is a compact interval that we choose as @xmath9 $ ] for convenience , the maps @xmath10 are diffeomorphisms with @xmath11 and negative schwarzian derivative @xmath12 , where @xmath13 , and finally we require that @xmath14 is measurable . for the iterates @xmath15 of @xmath3 we adopt the usual notation @xmath16 .
hence @xmath17 . for @xmath18 and @xmath19
this includes the identity @xmath20 .
denote by @xmath21 the space of all @xmath22-invariant probability measures on @xmath5 and by @xmath23 the family of all ergodic @xmath24 .
as @xmath5 is assumed to be standard borel , non - ergodic invariant probability measures can be decomposed into ergodic ones .
let @xmath25 .
a measurable function @xmath26 is an _ invariant graph _ , if @xmath27 if @xmath24 and the identity holds for @xmath28-almost every @xmath29 we call @xmath30 a _ @xmath28-a.e .
invariant graph_. ( the slight abuse of terminology underlines that we are mostly interested in properties of the graph of @xmath30 as a subset of @xmath4 . ) observe that each @xmath25 has the two constant invariant graphs @xmath31 .
a. let @xmath25 and @xmath32 .
if the limit @xmath33 exists , it is called the normal lyapunov exponent of @xmath3 in @xmath34 . b. let @xmath35 . if @xmath30 is a @xmath28-a.e .
invariant graph with @xmath36 , its lyapunov exponent w.r.t .
@xmath28 is defined as @xmath37 the following proposition is a consequence of negative schwarzian derivative .
[ prop : jbm ] let @xmath25 and @xmath38
. then @xmath39 .
the basin of @xmath40 is @xmath41 denote @xmath42 and @xmath43 , and observe that @xmath44 and @xmath45 are invariant graphs .
part a ) of the following proposition can be found in @xcite . in a slightly different setting ,
both parts were proved in the earlier paper @xcite .
the reader can easily adapt the proof of part b ) to the present setting .
[ prop : two - basins ] let @xmath25 , @xmath35 .
then exactly one of the following three possibilities occurs : a. if @xmath46 and @xmath47 , then @xmath48 @xmath28-a.e .
so that @xmath49 , and @xmath50 . b. if @xmath51 , then @xmath52 @xmath28-a.e .
so that @xmath53 , and @xmath54 . c. if @xmath55 , then @xmath56 @xmath28-a.e .
so that @xmath57 , and @xmath58 . in particular
, there are at most three @xmath28-equivalence classes of invariant graphs , namely @xmath59 , @xmath60 and @xmath61 .
the fact that there are at most three @xmath28-equivalence classes of invariant graphs is , of course , due to the assumption of negative schwarzian derivative .
in order to keep the notation as simple as possible , we specialize already from here on to one - dimensional mixing markov maps at the base : [ hypo:1 ] @xmath62 is a finite interval , and @xmath63 is a piecewise expanding and piecewise @xmath64 mixing markov map with finitely many branches .
it is a well known fact , often called the folklore theorem @xcite , that @xmath22 has a unique invariant probability measure @xmath65 equivalent to lebesgue measure @xmath66 on @xmath67 .
case , but the proof carries over to piecewise @xmath64 maps . ] an early reference for intermingled basins ( with quadratic fibre maps ) is the paper @xcite .
[ def : intermingled ] let @xmath25 .
we say that the two basins @xmath68 and @xmath69 are _ intermingled _ , if the intersections of both basins with any open set has positive lebesgue - measure .
[ prop : intermingled ] if @xmath70 and @xmath71 and if there are @xmath72 such that @xmath73 and @xmath74 , then @xmath69 and @xmath68 are intermingled .
this is precisely the situation we are looking at , so we state this as a further hypothesis .
[ hypo:2 ] @xmath70 and @xmath71 , and there are @xmath72 such that @xmath73 and @xmath74 ( so that proposition [ prop : intermingled ] applies ) .
[ ex:1 ] let @xmath75 , @xmath76 , @xmath77 with @xmath78 , and define @xmath79 where @xmath80 and @xmath81 are determined such that @xmath11
. then @xmath12 . for a numerical example we use the doubling map as base transformation @xmath82 that leaves the lebesgue measure invariant ,
and we choose the following parameters : @xmath83,\ ; b=0.4,\;c=0.9,\;d=0.8 $ ] .
this choice guarantees that @xmath84 and @xmath85 .
when @xmath86 $ ] , then the lyapunov - exponent of the 4-periodic point @xmath87 on the circle @xmath88 and that of the 5-periodic point @xmath89 on the circle @xmath90 are strictly positive.the equidistributions on these orbits thus play the role of the measures @xmath91 and @xmath92 .
it seems that for @xmath93 the lower and upper invariant graph are uniformly attracting .
hence there is @xmath94 such that @xmath95\times[-1+\delta,1-\delta]$ ] is invariant under @xmath96 , and all @xmath96-invariant measures are supported by @xmath61 and have a negative vertical lyapunov exponent under @xmath96 .
therefore lemma 5.1 in @xcite suggests that @xmath61 is continuous .
( we say `` suggests '' , because the baker map at the base is not a homeomorphism as required in that lemma . )
[ fig:1 ] in those cases where @xmath61 is a continuous curve bounded away from @xmath59 and from @xmath60 , the box dimension of the graph of @xmath61 is known : bedford @xcite studied systems that include our examples and showed that the box dimension is the unique zero of the pressure function @xmath97 provided this zero is bigger than @xmath98 .
as in @xcite , which was strongly motivated by @xcite , we define a local stability index @xmath99 of a point @xmath100 w.r.t .
@xmath69 and @xmath68 in the following way : let @xmath101 where @xmath102\times[x-\epsilon , x+\epsilon]$ ] . obviously , @xmath103
define @xmath104 where @xmath105 of course , the limits in ( [ eq : local - scaling ] ) need not exist for every @xmath34 , but observe that @xmath106 @xmath107 always .
hence @xmath108 and @xmath109 are non - negative , and at most one of them can be strictly positive .
observe also that @xmath110 for all @xmath100 .
( this is essentially theorem 2.2 of @xcite . )
denote by @xmath111 the @xmath112-dimensional lebesgue measure on @xmath4 restricted to @xmath113 then @xmath114 is just the local dimension of the measure @xmath111 at @xmath34 . in order to obtain precise quantitative information about @xmath115
, we require some regularity of @xmath116 : [ hypo:3 ] the function @xmath117 is @xmath118-hlder continuous on each set @xmath119 where @xmath120 is a markov interval of @xmath82 .
a first step towards evaluating @xmath115 is the following result which is similar to theorem 2.1 in @xcite .
its proof is provided in section [ subsec : prooftheo - exponential ] .
[ theo : exponential ] let @xmath25 and assume hypotheses [ hypo:1 ] - [ hypo:3 ] .
there are @xmath121 ( both defined by thermodynamic formalism , see below ) such that @xmath122 the numbers @xmath123 are uniquely determined as positive zeros of the pressure functions @xmath124 ( to be more precise , we mean the pressure function of the topological markov chain that encodes @xmath22 . ) indeed , @xmath125 and @xmath126 by hypothesis [ hypo:2 ] ( see e.g. @xcite ) , so that the convex functions @xmath127 and @xmath128 have unique positive zeros provided @xmath129 and @xmath130 .
this latter property is guaranteed by the existence of the measures @xmath91 and @xmath92 from hypothesis [ hypo:2 ] .
[ remark : comparison1 ] this formula for @xmath131 is in good agreement with the formula for the corresponding quantity @xmath132 in @xcite .
as the authors work with a diffusion approximation and restrict to negative @xmath133 close to zero , @xmath131 can be approximated by the positive zero of the log - laplace transform of a normal distribution with mean @xmath134 and variance @xmath135 .
this log - laplace transform has the form @xmath136 so its positive zero is @xmath137 , where we used the convention @xmath138 as in @xcite .
numerical studies in @xcite and later in @xcite confirm this approximate formula for the exponent .
[ theo : main ] let @xmath25 and assume hypotheses [ hypo:1 ] - [ hypo:3 ] .
let @xmath35 be a gibbs measure , and denote @xmath139 .
then for @xmath28-a.e .
@xmath140 , @xmath141 [ remark : main ] a. the requirement that @xmath35 is a gibbs measure can be considerably relaxed , see ( * ? ? ?
* remark 5 ) .
b. because of hypothesis [ hypo:2 ] , @xmath142 ; so for @xmath143 the above five possibilities form an exhaustive list . c.
note that @xmath144 in case 2 and @xmath145 in case 4 . in case 3 , @xmath146 by proposition [ prop : two - basins ] , so that @xmath147 .
d. for general gibbs measures @xmath38 , i can not exclude the possibility that @xmath148 or @xmath149 .
in that case the analysis is much more involved .
indeed , if @xmath150 and @xmath148 , one can show that @xmath151 , but i do not attempt to provide a proof in this paper .
a similar result holds when @xmath152 and @xmath149 .
let @xmath25 be as before .
as in @xcite we define the uncertainty exponent of @xmath3 in the following way : choose @xmath153 and denote by @xmath154 the probability that two points chosen at random with distance at most @xmath155 on the line @xmath156 belong to different basins .
more formally , @xmath157 [ theo : uncertainty ] let @xmath25 and assume hypotheses [ hypo:1 ] - [ hypo:3 ] .
for every @xmath153 we have @xmath158 where @xmath159 is determined by the pressure function @xmath160 details on @xmath159 are provided in equations ( [ eq : phi1 ] ) and ( [ eq : phi ] ) in section [ subsec : proof_theo - uncertainty ] .
one can not expect this estimate to be sharp , because the asymptotics of @xmath154 depend crucially on the large deviations behaviour of the time a trajectory needs to enter the final regime , when it is attracted to either @xmath59 or @xmath60 .
but this is governed ( at best ) by @xmath161 , an exponent of which we do not know more than the bounds @xmath162 ( because of negative schwarzian derivative ) . as this is the exponent of a measure supported by the graph of the highly discontinuous function @xmath61 , it is unlikely to be characterizable by thermodynamic quantities related to the base transformation .
this is only one reason why it would be difficult to compare our @xmath159 to the approximate expression for @xmath159 derived in @xcite or to the numerical results provided in for @xmath159 provided in @xcite .
further issues are that the authors of @xcite treat riddled basins , which can be modeled by a single random walk , while we need for the intermingled case two random walks ( one for each attractor ) that are moreover negatively correlated .
we return to this in remark [ remark : ott ] after the proof of theorem [ theo : uncertainty ] , where we derive an approximate formula for @xmath159 that yields a value twice as large as that used in @xcite .
this might explain why not only in ( * ? ? ?
* figure 13 ) , but also in ( * ? ? ?
* figure 6b ( small @xmath163 ) ) , the numerically observed values for @xmath159 are roughly twice as large as the values suggested by the formula used there .
[ remark : distortion ] denote by @xmath164 the family of all interval neighbourhoods @xmath165 of @xmath166 such that @xmath167 is a diffeomorphism .
it is a well known fact ( e.g. @xcite ) that under hypotheses [ hypo:1 ] and [ hypo:2 ] there is a distortion constant @xmath168 such that for all @xmath169 , all @xmath140 , all @xmath170 and all @xmath171 @xmath172 and ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 2.6 ) @xmath173 [ lemma : ld - prep1 ] let @xmath94 .
there are @xmath186 and @xmath187 which depend only on @xmath188 with the following property : for all @xmath140 , @xmath189 , @xmath190 and @xmath191 such that @xmath192 @xmath193 holds : @xmath194 choose @xmath195 such that @xmath196 , where @xmath118 is the hlder exponent from hypothesis [ hypo:3 ] and @xmath168 is the distortion constant from remark [ remark : distortion ] .
hypothesis [ hypo:3 ] allows in particular to fix @xmath187 such that @xmath197 for all @xmath198 , all @xmath140 , @xmath189 and all @xmath190 .
now consider @xmath29 , @xmath199 and @xmath200 as in the assumption of the lemma and denote @xmath201 .
as @xmath190 , we have @xmath202 for all @xmath203 . for @xmath204
there is @xmath205 between @xmath199 and @xmath206 such that @xmath207 and observe that @xmath208 by the assumptions of the lemma .
then we have in view of ( [ eq : distortion2 ] ) @xmath209 recall that @xmath210 for @xmath211 , so that @xmath212 . hence ,
for @xmath204 , @xmath213 for @xmath204 it follows inductively that @xmath214 ( recall that @xmath208 ) . hence @xmath215 ) . for the lower estimate
observe that the reasoning leading to ( [ eq : dist - intermediate ] ) also yields @xmath216 and that @xmath217 for @xmath218 , as we just showed .
we follow closely ( * ? ? ?
* sections 4.1 and 7 ) : for @xmath220 denote by @xmath221 the transfer operators @xmath222 and let @xmath223 be its spectral radius .
then @xmath224 , and this is a strictly convex differentiable function of @xmath225 , see e.g. @xcite .
we prove only the identity for the limit that evaluates to @xmath226 , the other one is proved in the same way .
so fix any @xmath227 and choose @xmath94 such that @xmath228 .
there is a constant @xmath229 such that @xmath230 + let @xmath195 and @xmath237 be as in lemma [ lemma : ld - prep1 ] and consider @xmath238 .
then @xmath239 in view of the upper estimate in lemma [ lemma : ld - prep1 ]
. hence @xmath240 by lemma [ lemma : ld - prep2 ] . taking logarithms and dividing by the ( negative ! ) quantity @xmath241 yields the lower bound .
[ lemma : ld - prep3 ] for all @xmath242 and @xmath243 there exist @xmath244 and @xmath245 such that for all @xmath246 , each interval @xmath247 of length at least @xmath248 and all @xmath191 holds : @xmath249 where @xmath250 denotes the middle third of @xmath251 .
indeed , one can choose @xmath252 , where the minimum extends over the family @xmath253 of all markov intervals of @xmath82 .
fix @xmath246 , @xmath234 and an interval @xmath254 , and denote by @xmath255 the family of all maximal monotonicity intervals @xmath256 of @xmath257 which contain a point @xmath258 such that @xmath259 .
( such an interval need not exist for each @xmath242 . )
denote for the moment the inverse of @xmath260 by @xmath261 .
then , for each @xmath262 , @xmath263 where we used ( [ eq : distortion3 ] ) for the second inequality and the monotonicity of @xmath264 for the last one . in view of the distortion bound ( [ eq : distortion1 ] )
this implies @xmath265 therefore @xmath266 for the last inequality we used that @xmath267 contains at least one markov interval when @xmath191 and @xmath195 is sufficiently large . choosing @xmath268 even larger , if necessary , the at most two @xmath262 which are not fully contained in @xmath251 are disjoint to @xmath250 .
hence @xmath269 it remains to prove that @xmath270 is strictly positive : let @xmath271 and suppose for a contradiction that there is some markov interval @xmath272 of @xmath82 such that @xmath273 for all @xmath29 in a full measure subset @xmath274 of @xmath272 . as @xmath82 is a mixing markov map , there is @xmath275 such that @xmath276 .
hence , for @xmath66-a.e .
@xmath277 there is @xmath278 such that @xmath279 , which is incompatible with proposition [ prop : intermingled ] . in order to relate the expression @xmath280 to @xmath281
, we invoke a rather immediate consequence of the fact that maps with negative schwarzian derivative satisfy a variant of the one - sided koebe principle ( * ? ? ? *
section iv.1 , property 4 and corollary 2 ) : @xmath282 indeed , this follows most directly from the very transparent discussion in ( * ? ? ?
* appendix a ) by applying their formula ( 71 ) with @xmath283 in the limit where their interval @xmath284 shrinks to the point @xmath285 .
+ for later use we prove a slightly stronger statement , namely : @xmath286 $ \limsup_{\epsilon\to0}\frac{\log m\{\omega\in i_\epsilon:\,\varphi_c(\omega)<\varphi^-+\epsilon)\}}{\log \epsilon}\leqslant t_*^-$.}\ ] ] fix any @xmath287 , e.g. @xmath288 . if @xmath140 , @xmath289 and @xmath234 are such that @xmath290 , then @xmath291 : indeed , otherwise @xmath292 so that ( [ eq : os - koebe ] ) implies @xmath293
. hence lemma [ lemma : ld - prep3 ] yields for each @xmath294 with @xmath295 and @xmath296 @xmath297 so that , for any choice of @xmath298 , @xmath299 exactly as in ( * ? ? ?
* eqs.(4.9 ) and ( 4.10 ) ) , the choice @xmath300 with @xmath301 allows to identify this large deviations limit as @xmath226 ( using the theorem of plachky and steinebach @xcite ) .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the limits @xmath302 exist , and there are sequences of integers @xmath303 and of reals @xmath304 such that the symmetric @xmath305-neighbourhoods @xmath306 of @xmath29 satisfy @xmath307 and such that it is enough to evaluate @xmath308 along the sequence @xmath309 , see ( * ? ? ?
* remark 5(a ) and beginning of section 5 ) .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ in view of the distortion bound ( [ eq : distortion1 ] ) for @xmath82 we have @xmath315 next observe that @xmath316 , where @xmath317 satisfies @xmath318 as in lemma [ lemma : dist - prep ] . there
it is proved that @xmath319 therefore , observing also that @xmath320 , we have for @xmath310 @xmath321 where we used theorem [ theo : exponential ] ( in its strengthened form ( [ eq : stronger - statement ] ) ) for the equality . in a similar way one derives the lower bound @xmath322 and we note that corresponding statements hold for @xmath109 .
a. @xmath324 : +
then @xmath325 and @xmath326 for sufficiently large @xmath327 by theorem [ theo : exponential ] , so that the borel cantelli lemma yields @xmath328 hence @xmath329 , and it follows from ( [ eq : sigma+upper ] ) and ( [ eq : sigma+lower ] ) that @xmath330 . in the same way one proves @xmath331 .
b. @xmath332 : + in this case we can assume that @xmath333 @xmath28-a.e .
, so that @xmath46 by proposition [ prop : two - basins ] . as @xmath334 , there is @xmath335 such that @xmath336 . by monotonicity of the branches
@xmath337 it follows that @xmath338 for each @xmath339 $ ] .
so we can apply lemma [ lemma : dist - folklore ] and conclude that @xmath340 for @xmath28-a.e . @xmath29 and @xmath341 . referring to ( [ eq : sigma+upper ] ) and ( [ eq : sigma+lower ] )
this implies for such @xmath34 @xmath342 and it follows that @xmath331 . c. @xmath343 : + as in ( b@xmath344 ) one proves @xmath345 and @xmath330 for @xmath28-a.e . @xmath29 and @xmath346 .
d. @xmath150 and @xmath347 : + this means that @xmath348 , so that one can apply lemma [ lemma : ld - prep1 ] with @xmath349 for large @xmath327 to get @xmath350 for @xmath351 and @xmath352 , so that @xmath353 and hence @xmath331 for @xmath28-a.e .
@xmath29 and @xmath354 .
e. @xmath152 and @xmath355 . :
+ as in ( c@xmath344 ) one proves @xmath356 and @xmath330 for @xmath28-a.e . @xmath29 and @xmath357 .
[ subsec : proof - of - uncertainty ] as @xmath22 is an irreducible and aperiodic markov map , there are @xmath358 such that @xmath359 ( possibly except for the endpoints ) for all markov intervals @xmath360 , and such that each point in @xmath67 has at most @xmath361 preimages under @xmath362 .
denote by @xmath365 the smallest integer such that @xmath366 .
we denote the maximal monotonicity and continuity interval of @xmath367 around @xmath29 by @xmath368 .
observe that the distortion estimate ( [ eq : distortion1 ] ) guarantees that the length of each @xmath368 is between @xmath369 and @xmath155 .
in particular , @xmath370 where @xmath371 denotes the @xmath155-neighbourhood of @xmath29 in @xmath67 . from each collection @xmath372 one can extract a moran cover @xmath373 of @xmath67 , that is a disjoint ( modulo endpoints ) collection of sets @xmath368 covering all of @xmath67 ( modulo endpoints ) , see e.g. ( * ? ? ? * section 13 ) . by construction ,
each @xmath374 is a maximal monotonicity interval of some @xmath375 .
with these conventions we have @xmath376 because of lemma [ lemma : dist - prep ] , there is a constant @xmath377 such that for each @xmath378 holds @xmath379 and similarly @xmath380 observing that @xmath381 for all @xmath374 , we conclude @xmath382 where @xmath383 when @xmath384 . in the next step
we compare @xmath385 to @xmath386 : as all branches @xmath337 have negative schwarzian derivative , we have @xmath387 so that @xmath388 as @xmath389 , it follows that @xmath390 let @xmath391 ( recall that @xmath199 is fixed ) .
then @xmath392 for @xmath393 and @xmath394 define @xmath395 . then the last inequality can be rewritten as @xmath396 so that @xmath397 similarly , @xmath398 therefore , observing ( [ eq : first - estimate - for pi ] ) and the monotonicuty of @xmath399 , @xmath400 we determine the asymptotics of this integral when @xmath401 using varadhan s integral lemma .
this needs some preparation : consider the three - variate process @xmath402 we will determine the large deviations of this process and related ones . as @xmath403 and @xmath404
are hlder continuous on each set @xmath119 , one can use transfer operators to prove the existence , convexity and smoothness of the asymptotic log - laplace transform @xmath405 indeed , @xmath406 coincides with the pressure function ( [ eq : pressure - function ] ) defined in theorem [ theo : uncertainty ] . here
are some particular values of @xmath406 that help to understand its geometry : @xmath407 negative schwarzian derivative of the branches implies furthermore : @xmath408 this is a direct consequence of propossition [ prop : jbm ] , because the partial derivatives are precisely the exponents for the equilibrium state associated with @xmath409 . in particular , @xmath406 is unbounded below and above .
let @xmath410 be the legendre - fenchel transform of @xmath406 .
the grtner - ellis theorem guarantees that the large deviations principle with rate @xmath411 and with good convex rate function @xmath412 holds for the sequence @xmath413 ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2.3.6(c ) ) .
even more holds in the present situation : @xmath414}$. fix $ m\in{{\mathbbm n}}$ and $ 0=t_0<t_1<\dots <
t_m\leqslant1$. then the process $ \tilde{y}_n:=\left(y_n(t_1),y_n(t_2)-y_n(t_1),\dots , y_n(t_m)-y_n(t_{m-1})\right)$ satisfies the ldp in $ ( { { \mathbbm r}}^3)^m$ with good rate function \begin{equation * } \psi_m^*:({{\mathbbm r}}^3)^m\to[-\infty,\infty],\quad \psi_m^*(z)=\sum_{i=1}^m(t_i - t_{i-1})\psi^*\left(\frac{z_i}{t_i - t_{i-1}}\right ) .
\end{equation * } } \ ] ] this is exactly condition ( a-1 ) from @xcite . observe that @xmath415 is the legendre - fenchel transform of @xmath416 .
we show in lemma [ lemma : laplace ] at the end of this section that @xmath417 is the asymptotic log - laplace transform of @xmath418 and that it is convex and smooth
. then the grtner - ellis theorem guarantees the ldp as claimed in ( [ eq : ldp - a-1 ] ) .
as @xmath419 , one can apply , as a next step , the time change techniques from ( * ? ? ?
* sections 2 - 4 ) : theorem 1 from @xcite together with theorem 1 from @xcite allow to apply theorem 4 ( and the subsequent further discussion ) from @xcite and to conclude is treated in @xcite .
a look at that paper , hovever , reveals that the results from @xcite and @xcite referred to in @xcite apply to our situation as well and that the proof of theorem 4 in @xcite carries over without any changes . ] .
however , the distortion property ( [ eq : distortion1 ] ) and the uniform expansion of @xmath22 immediately imply that the difference @xmath420 is bounded uniformly in @xmath155 and in @xmath29 .
in particular , both processes are exponentially equivalent so that one can be replaced by the other without changing the large deviations behaviour .
a related question is also discussed after theorem 2 of @xcite . ] : @xmath421,\quad j(x^-,x^+,y)=y\cdot \psi^*\left(\frac{x^-}{y},\frac{x^+}{y},\frac{1}{y}\right ) .
\end{equation } } \ ] ] next we apply varadhan s lemma ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 4.3.1 ) to the process @xmath422 and the continuous function @xmath423 in order to evaluate @xmath424 namely : @xmath425 the following lemma , whose proof is deferred to the end of this section , relates this to the estimate of ( [ eq : intermediate - phi ] ) we are looking for : it remains to evaluate the expression ( [ eq : phi1 ] ) for @xmath159 . to that end we introduce some more notation .
define @xmath432 , @xmath433 so that @xmath434 and @xmath435
. then @xmath436 , @xmath437 , is convex with @xmath438 and @xmath439 by ( [ eq : values-1 ] ) .
therefore ( [ eq : values-3 ] ) implies that there are uniquely determined @xmath440 such that @xmath441 for all @xmath442 , @xmath443 , and @xmath444 if and only if @xmath445 .
observe also that @xmath446 is real analytic by the implicit function theorem , because @xmath406 and @xmath248 are .
we claim that @xmath447 has a unique maximum ( that is attained inside the interval @xmath448 , of course ) . indeed : @xmath449 so that @xmath450 as @xmath451 , as @xmath452 and as @xmath406 is convex , this implies @xmath453 as we can not guarantee strict concavity of @xmath406 , this inequality might possibly be non - strict . but assume that there are @xmath454 such that @xmath455 is constant for @xmath456 .
as @xmath457 is analytic in @xmath442 , this implies @xmath455 for all @xmath442 .
but this contradicts the sign change of @xmath446 at @xmath458 noted above .
denote by @xmath459 the unique @xmath460 where @xmath457 attains its maximum .
obviously @xmath461 , @xmath462 and @xmath463 .
let @xmath464 , @xmath465 and @xmath466 , @xmath467 .
then @xmath468 , @xmath469 , and @xmath470 because @xmath441 for all @xmath460 and @xmath463 .
in particular , @xmath471 and @xmath472 have the same sign , and as @xmath473 and @xmath474 they are the exponents @xmath475 and @xmath476 for some equilibrium state @xmath477 , they must both be negative , see proposition [ prop : two - basins ] for details .
now we are ready to prove that @xmath478 in view of ( [ eq : phi1 ] ) , @xmath479 for the upper estimate recall that @xmath480 from ( [ eq : balance ] ) and the lines thereafter .
hence @xmath481 where we used the convexity of @xmath406 for the last equality .
this finishes the proof of theorem [ theo : uncertainty ] .
let @xmath482 and @xmath483 .
for @xmath484 let @xmath485 . a straightforward short calculation based on theorem [ theo : exponential ] yields that @xmath486 and @xmath487 .
we prove that @xmath488 for each @xmath427 . indeed : + if @xmath489 , then @xmath490 and @xmath491 , so that @xmath492 and @xmath493 .
+ if @xmath494 , then @xmath495 and @xmath496 , so that @xmath497 and @xmath498 . + if @xmath499 , then @xmath500 and @xmath501 as @xmath495 , we have @xmath502 .
hence @xmath503 if @xmath504 , the first summand of this estimate is bounded by @xmath505 .
otherwise it is bounded by @xmath506 .
+ in any case we have @xmath507 which tends to zero when @xmath401 .
this is ( [ eq : phi-1 ] ) .
[ remark : ott ] we compare the exponent @xmath159 with the corresponding one from @xcite ( also called @xmath159 in those papers ) , which is derived there for the case of riddled basins .
that formula is taken as a reference in @xcite , although the authors of that paper study numerically the model from @xcite , which has intermingled basins .
so we take the chance to derive an approximate formula in the style of @xcite for the model studied in @xcite , although it has the full logistic map as its driving system .
but as that map is smoothly conjugated to the full symmetric tent map ( with singularities only at the points @xmath511 and @xmath98 ) , it is not hard to see that our theorem [ theo : uncertainty ] carries over to this case .
the fibre maps are @xmath512 , which have negative schwarzian derivative as @xmath513 .
note first that @xmath514 and @xmath515 .
observing the symmetry properties of the invariant density of the driving map and of the cosine function , it is easy to check that not only @xmath516 , but that indeed the log - laplace transform @xmath406 is symmetric in the variables @xmath517 and @xmath518
. it follows that @xmath519 so that the convex function @xmath520 satisfies @xmath521 and hence attains its minimum at @xmath522 .
hence @xmath523 is determined by @xmath524 . as @xmath525 is cohomologous to @xmath526
, one can show that @xmath527 , so that @xmath528 . in a diffusion approximation with @xmath529 close to zero
this yields @xmath530 , where @xmath531 denotes the asymptotic correlation matrix of the two components of the diffusion .
using the approximation @xmath532 from remark [ remark : comparison1 ] , this yields @xmath533 neglecting the correlation term , this is precisely twice the value found in @xcite , and this might explain why not only in ( * ? ? ?
* figure 13 ) , but also in ( * ? ? ?
* figure 6b ( small @xmath163 ) ) , the numerically observed values for @xmath159 are roughly twice as large as the values suggested by the formula .
[ lemma : laplace ] let the processes @xmath413 and @xmath418 be defined as in ( [ eq : yn - def ] ) and ( [ eq : ldp - a-1 ] ) , respectively , and denote by @xmath534 the asymptotic log - laplace transform of @xmath413 defined in ( [ eq : psi - def ] ) .
then @xmath416 is the asymptotic log - laplace transform of @xmath418 .
it is convex and smooth .
we argue by induction on @xmath66 : for @xmath535 we only observe that @xmath536 .
for @xmath537 let @xmath538 and @xmath539 , @xmath540 then @xmath541})$ ] - at least up to small errors of oder @xmath542 that are immaterial for the asymptotics . for a proof of this fact we recall that @xmath543 is a partial sum process of the form @xmath544 .
hence , for @xmath545 , @xmath546}-t_{i-1}y_{[nt_{i-1 } ] } = \frac{t_i}{[nt_i]}\sum_{k=0}^{[nt_i]-1}v_k - \frac{t_{i-1}}{[nt_{i-1}]}\sum_{k=0}^{[nt_{i-1}]-1}v_k\\ & \approx \frac{1}{n}\sum_{k=[nt_{i-1}]}^{[nt_i]-1}v_k = \frac{1}{n}\sum_{k=[nt_{i-1}]-[nt_1]}^{[nt_i]-[nt_1]-1}v_k\circ s^{[nt_1]}\\ & = \frac{1}{n}\sum_{k=0}^{[nt_i]-[nt_1]-1}v_k\circ s^{[nt_1 ] } - \frac{1}{n}\sum_{k=0}^{[nt_{i-1}]-[nt_1]-1}v_k\circ s^{[nt_1]}\\ & \approx \frac{t_i'}{[nt_i']}\sum_{k=0}^{[nt_i']-1}v_k\circ s^{[nt_1 ] } - \frac{t_{i-1}'}{[nt_{i-1}']}\sum_{k=0}^{[nt_{i-1}']-1}v_k\circ s^{[nt_1]}\\ \\ & = \left(t_i'y_{[nt_i']}-t_{i-1}'y_{[nt_{i-1}']}\right)\circ s^{[nt_1 ] } = \left(y_{n}(t_i')-y_{n}(t_{i-1}'\right)\circ s^{[nt_1]}\ . \end{split}\ ] ] now @xmath547}\rangle\ , \ ] ] so that @xmath548}\rangle\right)\cdot \exp\left(n\langle\lambda',\tilde{y}_n'\rangle\right)\circ s^{[nt_1]}\,dm\\ & \approx \frac{1}{n}\log\int { { \mathcal l}}_{\lambda_1}^{[nt_1]}(1)\cdot \exp\left(n\langle\lambda',\tilde{y}_n'\rangle\right)dm \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath549 denotes the laplace - perron - frobenius operator with extra weight @xmath550 as @xmath551 converges uniformly to a strictly positive function as @xmath552 ( see e.g. @xcite ) , the limit in ( [ eq : last - one ] ) equals @xmath553 where we used the inductive hypothesis for the term @xmath554 . | skew product systems with monotone one - dimensional fibre maps driven by piecewise expanding markov interval maps may show the phenomenon of intermingled basins @xcite . to quantify the degree of intermingledness the uncertainty exponent @xcite and the stability index @xcite
were suggested and characterized ( partially ) . here
we present an approach to evaluate / estimate these two quantities rigorously using thermodynamic formalism for the driving markov map . |
understanding the formation history of stellar halos is one of the classical pursuits of galactic astronomy .
the problem is generally framed within the context of two competing scenarios : one of `` rapid collapse '' ( eggen , lynden bell & sandage 1962 ) , in which the stellar halo is formed by the rapid collapse of a proto galaxy within a dynamical timescale ( @xmath0 10@xmath1 yr ) , and one of `` galactic assembly '' @xcite , whereby the stellar halo is assembled on a longer timescale ( @xmath0 10@xmath2 yr ) by the accretion of `` building
blocks '' , each with separate enrichment histories .
both scenarios have their strengths and weaknesses , and it would appear that a hybrid model is the most plausible option consistent with extant data ( e.g. : @xcite ; @xcite ) . an intriguing piece of the halo formation `` puzzle '' is provided by comparing the stellar halo of our own milky way with that of its neighbour , m31 .
first , despite their comparable total galactic luminosities , the stellar halo of m31 is _ apparently _ much more metal rich than that of the milky way ( e.g. : @xcite ; @xcite ; durrell , harris & pritchet 2001 ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) .
in fact , the halo of m31 bears a closer resemblance to that of ngc 5128 ( e.g. , @xcite ) , despite their differing morphological classifications . the stellar halo
galaxy formation symbiosis has been further brought to light by the recent work of mouhcine et al .
( see also tikhonov , galazutdinova & drozdovsky 2005 ) . the deep hubble space telescope ( hst hereafter ) imaging of nearby spiral galaxy stellar halos in @xcite suggests a significant correlation between stellar halo metallicity and total galactic luminosity . on the surface
, this correlation appears to leave our own milky way s halo as an outlier with respect to other spirals , with a stellar halo metallicity @xmath01 dex lower than spirals of comparable luminosity ( such as m31 , as alluded to earlier ) .
however , it must be noted that the metallicity of the galactic halo in the solar neighbourhood ( e.g. , in ryan & norris 1991 ) comes from spectroscopic metallicities in a kinematically selected sample , whereas that of the m31 halo , as well as those of the stellar halos of nearby spiral galaxies @xcite , have been derived primarily from photometric metallicities in geographically selected samples . because it is now becoming possible to obtain spectroscopic metallicities for significant samples of kinematically selected giants in the m31 halo ( e.g. : @xcite ; @xcite )
, it will be crucial to assess the consistency of the m31 stellar halo metallicity as derived from kinematically and from geographically selected samples , respectively . a grasp of the true scatter around the general trend in the halo metallicity
luminosity relation awaits a larger observational data set , however any theory which attempts to explain such a relation needs to simultaneously account for the _ apparent _ metallicity discrepancy between the milky way and the andromeda stellar halos .
the question arises as to what is driving the scatter of halo metallicity for galaxies of comparable luminosity ? in what follows , we investigate whether differences in the stellar halo assembly history can explain the diversity seen in halo metallicities . using chemo
dynamical numerical simulations , we have constructed a sample of 89 model disc galaxies , spanning @xmath04 magnitudes in luminosity , and sampling a wide range of assembly histories at a given luminosity ( or mass ) .
we contrast the derived stellar halo metallicity galactic luminosity relation with the recent empirical determination of @xcite .
the numerical framework in which the simulations have been conducted is described in section 2 , while sections 3 and 4 present the results and the related discussion , respectively .
the simulations employed here are patterned after the semi cosmological adiabatic feedback model of @xcite , and were constructed using the chemo dynamical code gcd+ @xcite .
gcd+ self consistently treats the effects of gravity , gas dynamics , radiative cooling , star formation , and chemical enrichment ( including type ii and ia supernovae , relaxing the instantaneous recycling approximation ) .
this semi
cosmological version of ` gcd+ ` is based on the seminal work of @xcite .
the initial condition for a given model is an isolated sphere of dark matter and gas .
this `` top hat '' overdensity has an amplitude @xmath3 at initial redshift @xmath4 , which is approximately related to the collapse redshift @xmath5 by @xmath6 ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
we set @xmath7 , which determines @xmath3 at @xmath8 .
small scale density fluctuations based on a cdm power spectrum are superimposed on the sphere using ` cosmics ` ( @xcite ) , and the amplitude of the fluctuations is parameterised by @xmath9 .
these fluctuations are the seeds for local collapse and subsequent star formation .
body rotation corresponding to a spin parameter @xmath10 is imparted to the initial sphere to incorporate the effects of longer wavelength fluctuations . for the flat cdm model described here ,
the relevant parameters include @xmath11 , baryon fraction @xmath12 , @xmath13 km s@xmath14 mpc@xmath14 , spin parameter @xmath15 , and @xmath16 .
we employed 14147 dark matter and 14147 gas / star particles , for the 89 simulations presented here . using the same number of particles , collapse redshift @xmath17 , and
spin parameter @xmath10 , a series of 89 simulations were completed spanning a factor of 50 in mass in four separate mass `` bins '' : m@xmath18 = 1@xmath1910@xmath20 m@xmath21 ; 5@xmath1910@xmath20 m@xmath21 ; 1@xmath1910@xmath22 m@xmath21 ; 5@xmath1910@xmath22 m@xmath21 . for each total mass , we run models with different patterns of small scale density fluctuations which lead to different hierarchical assembly histories .
this was controlled by setting different random seeds for the gaussian perturbation generator in cosmics .
our grid of 89 simulations were employed to populate the redshift @xmath23 = 0 stellar halo metallicity luminosity plane ( i.e. @xmath24[fe / h]@xmath25 m@xmath26 ) shown in fig . 1 ( filled symbols[fe / h]@xmath25 , which is the source of the apparently `` quantised '' centroid values in fig . 1 . ] ) .
we have been conservative in our geometrical definition of `` stellar halo '' , adopting a projected cut off radius of 15 kpc to delineate the halo from ( possible ) disc bulge contaminants .
such a choice should also allow an easier comparison with the observations of halo fields in nearby spiral galaxies .
the stellar metallicity distribution function ( mdf ) was then generated using all stellar particles from the halo `` region '' , convolved with a gaussian of @xmath27@xmath28}$ ] = 0.15 dex , representing the typical observational uncertainties ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
the peaks of the derived mdfs are shown100 halo stellar particles are included in the analysis here . ] in fig . 1 ;
68% of the stellar particles within a given ( simulated ) mdf typically span 1.4 dex in metallicity .
we confirmed that the derived halo mdfs are insensitive to projection effects , even in the most massive ( largest ) models , suggesting that our @xmath29 15 kpc definition for the halo `` region '' is sufficient for minimising disc and bulge contamination .
the optical properties of our simulated stellar populations were derived using the population synthesis models of @xcite , taking into account the age and the metallicity of each stellar particle .
we note that the v - band luminosity shown along the abscissa of fig .
1 is the _ total _ galactic luminosity ( i.e. halo + bulge + disc ) . }
\rangle_{\rm halo}$ ]
m@xmath26 ) .
filled squares correspond to the peak of the mdf for each of our simulations .
open ( unlabelled ) squares represent the data of mouhcine et al .
( 2005 ) ; open ( labelled ) squares represent additional data taken from the literature ( see the text for details ) .
68% of the stars in the simulated ( observed ) mdfs are typically enclosed within @xmath300.7 dex ( @xmath300.35 dex ) of the peak of the respective mdf.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] fig .
1 also shows the corresponding observed halo metallicity luminosity values for 13 nearby spirals , taken primarily from @xcite , supplemented with data from the literature ( @xcite ; @xcite ; harris , harris & poole 1999 ; brooks , wilson & harris 2004 ) . for the observational datasets , we calculated the mdf peak and 68% `` dispersions '' exactly as we did for the simulated datasets ; 68% of the stars in the observed mdfs are typically enclosed within @xmath300.35 dex of the mdf peak , a factor of @xmath02 narrower than the simulations . what is readily apparent from fig .
1 is that significant variation in halo metallicity ( @xmath311 dex ) exists at any given total galactic luminosity in our simulations . for a set of models with the same initial total mass , the only difference among these models
can be traced to the random pattern of initial small - scale density fluctuations ; this translates directly into differing hierarchical assembly histories .
qualitiatively , it would appear that assembly history alone may account for the diversity in halo metallicity at a given galactic luminosity , and thus account for the apparent outliers in the observed trend . for the simulations with @xmath32 = 10@xmath22 m@xmath33 .
_ lower panels _ : the associated stellar age distributions at @xmath34 for the galaxies in the upper panels
. the solid ( dotted ) histogram corresponds to the stellar age distribution function for the entire galaxy ( stellar halo ) .
the corresponding halo metallicities are denoted in each panel.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] fig .
2 shows snapshots of the gas particles at redshift @xmath23 = 1.5 and the associated @xmath23 = 0 stellar age distribution function ( adf ) for three of the models with m@xmath18 = 10@xmath22 m@xmath21 .
these representative models demonstrate that the simulated galaxies with the more metal rich halos are assembled over a longer timescale , and thus possess a broader adf ( both in the halo and in the associated galaxy ) .
such a scenario is consistent with the evidence , presented by @xcite , of a substantial intermediate - age metal - rich population in a geographically - selected halo field of m31 .
conversely , the simulated galaxies with the more metal poor halos are assembled earlier through more of a monolithic process , with a consequently narrower adf .
our simulations suggest that the halo metallicity reflects directly the formation and assembly history of the host galaxy .
distribution function and the peak of the halo mdf in our simulations.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] further , the most metal poor stellar halos in our simulations ( which , recall , formed preferentially via more of a monolithic collapse ) possess @xmath35elements to iron ratios a factor of @xmath02 higher than the most metal rich halos ( which formed preferentially over more extended period of hierarchical clustering ) , as shown in fig .
such a trend is expected if the different amount of @xmath35elements and iron released by type ii and ia supernovae over different timescales is taken into account ( e.g. : timmes , woosley & weaver 1995 ; @xcite ) .
[ fe / h]@xmath25 @xmath36 ) : in the left panel , our fiducial models with m@xmath37 = 10@xmath22 m@xmath21 and 14147@xmath192 particles are shown , while the middle panel shows the corresponding lower resolution models with 5575@xmath192 ( crosses ) and 9171@xmath192 ( open squares ) particles .
the metallicity error bars indicate the 68% confidence level . the average number of halo particles is shown in the bottom right corner of each panel .
models with fewer than 100 stellar halo particles ( r@xmath3815 kpc ) are not included here . models a c of fig .
2 are denoted in the left and middle panels .
the right panel shows the @xmath24[fe / h]@xmath25 @xmath36 relation for all the simulations . _
lower panels _ : halo metallicity stellar mass relation ( @xmath24[fe / h]@xmath25 m@xmath39 ) : in the left panel , our fiducial models with m@xmath37 = 10@xmath22 m@xmath21 , while the middle panel shows the corresponding lower resolution models .
the right panel shows the @xmath24[fe / h]@xmath25 m@xmath39 relation for all the simulations.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] the upper panels of fig .
4 show the stellar halo metallicity
i - band surface brightness relation ( @xmath40}\rangle_{\rm halo}$ ]
@xmath36 ) for models with m@xmath18 = 10@xmath22 m@xmath21 ; the surface brightness was measured at a projected distance of 20 kpc from the dynamical centre of each simulation . the halo metallicity stellar mass relation ( @xmath24[fe / h]@xmath25 m@xmath39 ) is shown in the lower panels of fig . 4 .
the three galaxies presented in fig .
2 are also labelled in fig .
an immediate correlation is apparent with the more massive halos possessing higher surface brightness and also higher metallicity .
this is consistent with a picture in which galaxies that experienced more extended assembly histories have more massive stellar halos , with both higher halo metallicities and halo surface brightnesses - i.e. higher stellar halo densities .
similar trends are observed in our other total mass models , as shown in the right panels of fig .
the issue of model convergence ( resolution ) is always a concern when interpreting cosmological simulations ( particularly when including baryons ) .
to test this , we conducted a series of simulations for m@xmath18=10@xmath22 m@xmath21 , with 5575@xmath192 and 9171@xmath192 particles , to supplement the default grid ( which used 14147@xmath192 particles ) ; the middle panels of fig . 4
show where these lower resolution simulations sit in the halo metallicity
surface brightness plane and in the halo metallicity
stellar mass plane , respectively .
the consistency between higher ( left panels ) and lower ( middle panels ) resolution models is reassuring and leads us to conclude that our simulations are not affected significantly by numerical resolution.100 halo stellar particles , the @xmath41@xmath3828 mag arcsec@xmath42 region of the halo metallicity surface brightness plane and the m@xmath39@xmath4310@xmath44m@xmath33 region of the halo metallicity
stellar mass plane are underpopulated by the lower resolution models ( middle panels of fig . 4 ) .
we have presented here an analysis of the characteristics of spiral galaxy stellar halos formed within a large grid of numerical simulations , with particular emphasis placed upon the relationship between stellar halo metallicity and the associated galactic luminosity .
we have demonstrated that at any given total luminosity ( or , conversely , total dynamical mass ) , the metallicities of these simulated stellar halos span a range in excess of @xmath0 1 dex .
we suggest that the underlying driver of this metallicity spread can be traced to the diversity of galactic mass assembly histories inherent within the hierarchical clustering paradigm .
galaxies with a more protracted assembly history possess more metal rich and younger stellar halos , with an associated greater dispersion in age , than galaxies which experience more of a monolithic collapse .
for a given total luminosity ( or dynamical mass ) , those galaxies with more extended assembly histories also possess more massive stellar halos , which in turn leads to a direct correlation between a stellar halo s metallicity and its surface brightness ( as anticipated by earlier semi analytical models - e.g. , @xcite ) . by extension ,
such a correlation may prove to be a useful diagnostic tool for disentangling the formation history of disc galaxies .
recently , @xcite have presented an observed correlation between stellar halo metallicity and total galactic luminosity , as shown in fig . 1 .
the observed dispersion in the mean halo metallicity at a given galactic luminosity is _ smaller _ than what we find in our simulations .
_ however _ the latter can account for the outliers in the observed trend . since our motivation has been to study which is the effect of the pattern of the initial density fluctuations _
alone _ on the stellar halo features at redshift zero in simulated spiral galaxies , it is worth to note that galaxy formation , as it is observed , is an ongoing process which is the result of the interplay among different parameters , of which the pattern of initial density fluctuations ( thus the merging history ) is one .
we have shown that the merging history _ alone _ may be held responsible of the dispersion in halo metallicity at a comparable total galactic luminosity , as _ apparently _ observed for example in our milky way and in andromeda ( see section 1 ) .
this begs the question ... _which is normal _ ?
our study suggests that if the stellar halo was assembled ( primarily ) through more of a monolithic collapse , such a low metallicity is indeed what should be expected ; conversely , the fact that the m31 stellar halo is significantly metal rich is suggestive of a more protracted assembly history .
an observational consequence of these differing formation histories is the prediction that the m31 stellar halo should possess a high surface brightness ; observations tentatively support this prediction ( reitzel , guhathakurta & gould 1998 ; @xcite ; @xcite ) .
further observations are needed to tighten our grasp of the strength and scatter of the stellar halo metallicity
luminosity relation , which we have shown to be a useful diagnostic tool for disentangling the formation history of disc galaxies .
we thank the anonymous reviewer for careful comments which improved the manuscript .
we acknowledge the financial support of the australian research council through its discovery project and linkage international schemes , and the australian and victorian partnerships for advanced computing .
ar acknowledges the hospitality of the observatoire astronomique de strasbourg and of the tuorlan observatorio , and the swinburne supercomputer facility support team .
dk acknowledges the financial support of the japan society for the promotion of science , through a postdoctoral fellowship for research abroad . 299 azzalini a. , 2005 , scand . j. stat .
, 32 , 159 bellazzini m. , cacciari c. , federici l. , fusi pecci f. , rich m. , 2003 , a&a , 405 , 867 bertschinger e. , 1998 , ara&a , 36 , 599 binney j. , merrifield m. , 1998 , galactic astronomy , princeton university press , princeton , new jersey , usa brook c.b .
, kawata d. , gibson b.k . ,
flynn c. , 2004 , mnras , 349 , 52 brooks r.s . ,
wilson c.d . ,
harris w.e . , 2004 ,
aj , 128 , 237 brown t.m . , ferguson h.c . ,
smith e. , kimble r.a .
, sweigart a.v .
et al . , 2003 ,
apj , 592 , l17 brown t.m . , 2003 , ( ` astro - ph/0308298 ` ) chiba m. , beers t.c . , 2000 ,
aj , 119 , 2843 durrell p.r . , harris w.e . ,
pritchet c.j , 2001 , aj , 121 , 2557 durrell p.r . ,
harris w.e .
, pritchet c.j , 2004 , aj , 128 , 260 eggen o.j . ,
bell d. , sandage a.r .
, 1962 , apj , 136 , 748 elson r.a.w . , 1997 , mnras , 286 , 771 ferguson a.m.n . , irwin m.j .
, ibata r.a . ,
lewis g.f .
, tanvir n.r . , 2002 , aj , 124 , 1452 ferguson a.m.n .
et al . , 2005 ,
apj , 622 , l109 freeman k. , bland - hawthorn j. , 2002 , ara&a , 40 , 487 guhathakurta p. et al . , 2005 , ( ` astro - ph/0502366 ` )
ibata r.a .
, irwin m.j . , lewis g.f . ,
ferguson a.m.n .
, tanvir n.r . , 2001 ,
nature , 412 , 49 ibata r.a . , chapman s. , ferguson a.m.n . , irwin m.j . ,
lewis g.f . ,
mcconnachie a.w . , 2004 , mnras , 351 , 117 irwin m.j . , ferguson a.m.n . , ibata r.a .
, lewis g.f . , tanvir n. , 2005 , apj letters , in press ( ` astro - ph/0505077 ` ) harris w.e . , harris g.l.h . , 2001 ,
aj , 122 , 3065 harris g.l.h . , harris w.e . ,
poole g.b . , 1999 , aj , 117 , 855 katz n. , gunn j.e . , 1991 , apj , 377 , 365 kawata d. , gibson b.k . , 2003 , mnras , 340 , 908 larson r.b . , 2005 , ( ` astro - ph/0406624 ` ) mouhcine m. , lanon a. , 2003 , a&a , 402 , 425 mouhcine m. , ferguson h.c . , rich r.m . , brown t.m . ,
smith t.e . , 2005 , submitted mould j. , kristian j. , 1986 , apj , 305 , 591 padmanabhan t. , 1993 , structure formation in the universe , cambridge university press , cambridge , uk reitzel d.b . , guhathakurta p. , gould a. , 1998 , aj , 116 , 707 renda a. , kawata d. , fenner y. , gibson b.k .
, 2005 , mnras , 356 , 1071 ryan s.g .
norris j.e . , 1991 ,
aj , 101 , 1865 searle l. , zinn r. , 1978 , apj , 225 , 357 tiede g.p .
, sarajedini a. , barker m.k . , 2004 ,
aj , 128 , 224 tikhonov n.a .
, galazutdinova o.a .
, drozdovsky i.o .
, 2005 , a&a , 431 , 127 timmes f.x .
, woosley s.e . ,
weaver t.a . , 1995 , apjs , 98 , 617 woosley s.e . , heger a. , weaver t.a . , 2002 , reviews of modern physics , 74 , 1015 | the stellar halos of spiral galaxies bear important chemo dynamical signatures of galaxy formation .
we present here the analysis of 89 semi cosmological spiral galaxy simulations , spanning @xmath0 4 magnitudes in total galactic luminosity . these simulations sample a wide variety of merging histories and
show significant dispersion in halo metallicity at a given total luminosity - more than a factor of ten in metallicity .
our preliminary analysis suggests that galaxies with a more extended merging history possess halos which have younger and more metal rich stellar populations than the stellar halos associated with galaxies with a more abbreviated assembly . a correlation between halo metallicity and
its surface brightness has also been found , reflecting the correlation between halo metallicity and its stellar mass .
our simulations are compared with recent hubble space telescope observations of resolved stellar halos in nearby spirals .
[ firstpage ] galaxies : halos galaxies : formation galaxies : evolution galaxies : structure numerical methods |
novel magnetic and magneto - optic phenomena , of interest for optoelectronic applications , have been found in the rare earth ( r ) metaphosphate glasses ( remg ) with compositions in the vicinity ( r@xmath30@xmath4)@xmath5(p@xmath30@xmath6)@xmath7 . for example , these paramagnetic materials exhibit the largest known magnetic contributions to the low temperature specific heats in oxide glasses @xmath8 x - ray diffraction and exafs studies@xmath9 have shown that the structure of remg comprises a 3-d network of corner - linked po@xmath10 tetrahedra , with the rare - earth ions , which in several instances are known to be trivalent r@xmath11 occupying sites within the po@xmath10 skeleton . in recent work @xmath12
we have shown that it is possible to study the spin dynamics of rare earth ions in metaphosphate glasses using @xmath0p nmr as a probe .
the present investigation has extended the nmr measurements to a number of remg systems containing er , nd , sm and gd ions . for some of these systems , la or y ions have been used as a buffer in order to lower the concentration of magnetic ions while preserving the metaphosphate glass structure .
information on the dynamics of the rare earth ions has been obtained using the model developed previously @xmath13 .
the local fields set up by paramagnetic ions lead to nuclear resonance frequency shifts and the establishment of an exclusion barrier of radius @xmath14 , inside which spins are excluded from the observed nmr signal , together with a diffusion barrier of radius @xmath15 inside which nuclear spin diffusion does not operate@xmath13 . in highly paramagnetic systems of the type studied here , nuclear spin systems are thus composed of three distinct spatial regions corresponding to spin diffusive , non - diffusive and exclusion zones .
the theory of nuclear spin lattice relaxation ( nslr ) due to localized , isolated paramagnetic centres in magnetically dilute crystals@xmath16 has been extended to account for magnetically concentrated systems@xmath17 . in such systems ,
nuclear spin diffusion may be inoperative in appreciable fractions of sample volume , and nuclei may relax to multiple paramagnetic sites .
the average relaxation rate for nuclei in diffusive regions is given by @xmath18 in the diffusion limited [ dl ] case , and @xmath19 in the rapid diffusion [ rd ] case , with @xmath20 @xmath21 is the nuclear spin diffusion coefficient , @xmath22 is the magnetic ion concentration and @xmath23 is the nuclear larmor frequency@xmath13 .
the net electronic relaxation rate for ions with a crystal field splitting includes direct , raman and orbach relaxation rates@xmath24 : @xmath25 _ c _ @xmath26 _ , c_@xmath27 _ _ and _
c_@xmath28 are relaxation constants for the direct , raman and orbach processes , respectively .
@xmath29 is the crystal field splitting . in gd@xmath30
doped glasses , there is no crystal field splitting , and the ground state is a multiplet , so the net relaxation rate may be expressed as @xmath31 equations [ tau_e ] and [ tau_gd ] assume a debye phonon density of states .
this is consistent with recent work@xmath32 including the soft potential model approach , which suggests that vibrational modes in these systems are phonon - like . fractons@xmath33 and excess modes@xmath34 involving low - energy excitations
do not appear to play a role in the relaxation processes in these systems .
the samples were prepared from the melt at bath university with original stoichiometry@xmath35 ( r@xmath3o@xmath4)@xmath36(x@xmath3o@xmath4)@xmath37(p@xmath3o@xmath38)@xmath39 , and @xmath40 in the range @xmath41 to @xmath42 ( nominally ) , for r = er@xmath30 , nd@xmath30 , sm@xmath30 and gd@xmath30 , and x = y@xmath30 or la@xmath30 .
@xmath0p@xmath43nmr measurements at 8.5mhz ( 0.49 t ) and 19.25mhz ( 1.1 t ) were carried out using a pulsed nmr spectrometer and a varian water - cooled electromagnet .
preliminary epr measurements were carried out on er and gd remg using a commercial x - band bruker esp380e pulsed epr spectrometer and an oxford continuous - flow helium cryostat to achieve low temperatures .
nuclear resonance lineshapes have been characterised in terms of the moments of the resonance line determined from the fourier transform frequency - domain nmr spin - echo waveforms for samples with large inhomogeneous broadening .
the average nuclear relaxation rates for diffusive regions were extracted from the magnetization recovery data as a function of time @xmath44
using@xmath45 @xmath46 , \label{relax}\ ] ] where @xmath47 is a scaling factor , introduced because the degree of nuclear saturation is not known precisely , and @xmath48 is the diffusive fraction of nuclei .
the first and second terms describe nslr in diffusive and non - diffusive regions , respectively .
the relaxation rate for non - diffusive regions has been expressed in the form @xmath49 for convenience , where @xmath50 is the ratio of the average relaxation rates for nuclei in diffusive and non - diffusive regions .
we were unable to observe epr free induction decay or spin - echo signals in the samples investigated , probably due to extremely short spin - spin relaxation times in these systems .
direct measurements of the electron spin - lattice relaxation time using pulsed epr techniques have , therefore , not been possible .
nuclear resonance lineshapes have been characterised in terms of the moments of the resonance line , using @xmath51 , and the moment ratio , @xmath52 .
the nmr resonance line is inhomogeneously broadened due to coupling of the nuclear and paramagnetic ion moments .
1a shows plots of the inhomogeneouosly broadened @xmath0p nuclear resonance linewidth and moment ratio @xmath53 versus inverse temperature for a 1% er remg at b = 1.1 t. the linewidth increases with decreasing temperature , eventually reaching a plateau at approximately 20 k. the ratio _
r _ is close to 3 at low temperatures , suggesting a characteristically gaussian lineshape .
the natural dipolar linewidth is estimated to be approximately 3.8 khz , so there is appreciable inhomogeneous broadening of the linewidth even at the highest temperatures at which measurements were made . following the onset of motional narrowing , _ r _ increases to around 5 , implying a change in lineshape .
this behaviour is typical of all the glasses studied .
1b shows plots of linewidth versus inverse temperature for various er remg samples . for each sample ,
the linewidth increases while the signal amplitude decreases with decreasing temperature , eventually becoming unobservably weak over a small temperature range . the signal - to - noise ratio increases with increasing resonance frequency so that , for a given sample , the temperature range over which the line can be observed is somewhat larger for a larger applied field .
it appears that the maximum observed linewidth depends on the magnetic ion concentration , the particular ion present and the magnetic field . in all cases ,
the nmr signal became immeasurably broad over a very small temperature range at sufficiently low temperatures .
the relatively low maximum observed linewidth ( @xmath54 25 khz ) and the difference in maxima for different experiments strongly suggest that the abrupt loss of signal at low temperatures is not associated with limited spectrometer bandwidth .
this loss of signal appears to be linked to the overlapping of diffusion barriers when two or more ions contribute to the line - broadening process for a majority of nuclear spins in all regions of the sample .
the @xmath0p spin - spin relaxation time , @xmath55 determined from the spin - echo envelope , is 260 @xmath56s . for the er@xmath30 , nd@xmath30 and sm@xmath57 ion doped glasses
, the electron correlation time approaches the nuclear @xmath58 value at temperatures in the vicinity of 5 k. for gd@xmath30 , the temperature at which @xmath59 becomes comparable to @xmath58 is approximately 50 k. when @xmath59 @xmath60 @xmath58 , we expect the diffusion and exclusion barrier radii to reach their maximum values .
2a shows plots of @xmath0p relaxation rates @xmath61 versus @xmath62 for the 1% nd , 6% nd and metaphosphate nd remg for @xmath63 = 4.9 kg .
the peak in the relaxation rate for the 1% nd data corresponds to @xmath64 = 1 .
the temperature range over which measurements could be made on the 6% nd and metaphosphate nd remg before the line broadened dramatically rendering the signal unobservable , was insufficient to observe the peak .
it is easily seen that the nuclear relaxation rate is proportional to the magnetic ion concentration , but it appears that the metaphosphate nd remg contains a magnetic ion concentration lower than the nominal 25% .
the data have been analysed using eq.[dl ] [ dl ] and eq.[rd ] [ rd ] .
the curves represent the best fits to the data of the [ rd ] and [ dl ] expressions .
the nd@xmath65 data are well - described by the [ rd ] expression above 20 k , and follow the [ dl ] expression at lower temperatures . in nd@xmath11
the contributions to electronic relaxation from the raman and direct processes are negligible , and the data were analysed taking only the orbach process into account for the temperature range covered in these experiments .
all three nd data sets were fitted using the same orbach relaxation parameters .
both the lineshape data and the relaxation data provide no evidence that spin - spin interactions between the rare earth ions are important over the temperature range covered in the present experiment .
2b shows plots of @xmath0p relaxation rates @xmath66 versus @xmath62 for the 1% nd , 1% er , and 20% sm remg .
the nuclear relaxation rates for the nd and er remg are similar at high temperatures .
the peak in the nd data occurs at a lower temperature than in the er and sm data .
this suggests faster electronic relaxation in the nd@xmath30 ions , which results from a smaller crystal field splitting than in the other remg .
nuclear relaxation in the 20% sm remg is much faster than in the er and nd remg because of the much higher dopant concentration . for the 1% gd remg ,
electronic relaxation is much less efficient than in the other remg due to the absence of the orbach process .
the condition @xmath67 = 1 is not satisfied within the temperature range , and all the data are on the low temperature side of the relaxation peak ( fig .
2c ) . in gd@xmath11
the whole data set is well described by the [ dl ] expression .
the direct relaxation process dominates relaxation below 20 k , while the raman process is most important at higher temperatures .
electronic relaxation parameters for nd@xmath30 , er@xmath30 , and sm@xmath30 ions appear in table 1 . for gd@xmath30 ions ,
the orbach process is not operative and direct and raman processes determine the ionic relaxation time .
we obtain c@xmath68 = 8.1(2)@xmath69 10@xmath1(s.k ) and c@xmath27 = 2.9(2 ) @xmath70 ( s.k@xmath71 ) for the gd@xmath30 remg .
the parameters listed in table 1 , together with c@xmath27 and c@xmath72 for gd@xmath11 have been used to generate plots of the electronic relaxation rate @xmath73 vs. @xmath62 for the magnetic ions studied ( fig .
it can be seen that the relaxation rates for ions with a crystal field splitting are much higher than for the gd@xmath30 ions . as noted above
, it is clear from fig . 2b
that the relaxation behaviour of the 1% nd and 1% er glasses is very similar at higher temperatures .
3 shows that a crossover in electron correlation times for these two systems occurs at around 15 k. the quality of the fits of the relaxation expressions to the experimental data and the consistency of the fitting parameters between data sets provide strong support for the model as well as for the use of electronic relaxation expressions assuming a phonon density of states .
measurements of the @xmath0p spin - lattice relaxation time in metaphosphate glasses doped with rare earth ions have provided information on the spin dynamics of these ions over a wide range of temperature . for er , nd and sm ions ,
the observed behaviour with temperature is similar , with the spin correlation time being determined by a two - phonon orbach process .
the local environment of the ions is a distorted octahedron of oxygen atoms which give rise to crystal field splittings .
estimates of the splitting are provided by the present work for the ions mentioned above . in the case of gd ions , where no crystal field splitting occurs , the paramagnetic ion correlation time is determined by direct and raman processes .
the approach we have established for determining details of paramagnetic ion behaviour in these systems should be widely applicable to similar systems . | the spin dynamics of rare earth ions ( er , nd , sm and gd ) in heavily doped phosphate glasses have been investigated using @xmath0p nmr .
correlation times in the range 10@xmath1 to 10@xmath2 s have been obtained for temperatures between 4 k and 100 k. no evidence of spin - spin coupling between the ions has been found and spin relaxation occurs via conventional phonon processes , including the orbach process . a model involving inhomogeneous broadening of the nmr resonance lines , with distinct sample regions corresponding to the presence or absence of nuclear spin diffusion , has been used in extracting the electron spin correlation times from the nmr measurements . |
open quantum systems attract attention in both theoretical @xcite and experimental @xcite research .
the theoretical investigation of open quantum systems uses a great variety of different tools @xcite .
typically , these methods allow the determination of a reduced density matrix @xcite or a quantum state vector @xcite of an open quantum system .
usually , the reduced density operator carries also unnecessary information about different correlations in the open quantum system that are inaccessible to experimental observation . to study only the relevant information about an open quantum system it is appropriate to use methods of non - equilibrium thermodynamics .
as for the theoretical study of open quantum systems , several approaches to non - equilibrium thermodynamics have been proposed .
these include methods based on projection operators by robertson @xcite , mori @xcite , kawasaki and gunton @xcite , zubarev s non - equilibrium statistical operator @xcite , or more recently the generic formalism by ttinger and grmela @xcite . at first sight
these methods seem to differ from each other and often they are different from canonical methods used in the theory of open quantum systems @xcite . nevertheless , all the methods mentioned above are based on similar ideas and can be used for the description of open quantum systems . in this article
we apply concepts of non - equilibrium thermodynamics to open quantum systems and derive an alternative local in time non - markovian master equation .
after that , we illustrate the formalism with the description of the dynamics and thermodynamics of two open quantum systems , namely , the damped harmonic oscillator and the damped driven two - level system .
the article is organised as follows . in section
ii we describe the main ideas of non - equilibrium thermodynamics and derive a new type of local in time master equation . the short section iii deals with thermodynamical relations , which follows from the considered formalism . in section iv we apply our formalism to a general open system . in sections v and
vi we study two concrete open systems , namely , the damped harmonical oscillator and the driven two level system . finally , in section vii we conclude .
some additional details are discussed in several appendices .
non - equilibrium thermodynamics is based on two general assumptions @xcite : ( i ) the non - equilibrium macroscopic state is specified by a set of observables which are the average values @xmath0 of some relevant dynamical variables @xmath1 , where the superscript @xmath2 indicates time - dependence .
these variables give the reduced description of the system on the chosen time scale .
the existence of different time scales is due to the `` hierarchy '' of basic relaxation times in macroscopic systems ; ( ii ) in order to obtain a closed system of generalized transport equations for the observables , we have to construct a special solution of the liouville equation , which is a functional of these observables .
the hypothesis of the `` hierarchy '' of basic relaxation times implies that a relaxation of a system goes sequentially through several stages .
the closer the system comes to equilibrium the fewer relevant variables are necessary . in many cases
the equilibrium state is defined only by one parameter , namely , the free energy or the thermodynamically conjugate entropy . further away from equilibrium ,
the number of relevant variables increases .
once a set of relevant variables is chosen , one can move to the second assumption above . here
we construct the relevant distribution from the principle of maximum information entropy @xmath3 where @xmath4 is the density operator of the system .
this idea lies at the basis of many methods of non - equilibrium thermodynamics @xcite , but , traditionally , is ignored in the theory of open quantum systems .
the relevant distribution , which maximizes the information entropy , has the following form @xmath5 where the massieu - planck function @xmath6 , is determined from the normalization condition for the relevant distribution and has the form @xmath7 the lagrange multipliers @xmath8 are determined from the self - consistency conditions @xmath9 to derive the dynamical equation for @xmath10 it is effective to use some kind of projection operator @xmath11 , which satisfies the condition @xmath12 where @xmath4 is an arbitrary solution of the liouville equation .
one of the most general types of projection operators , was introduced by kawasaki and gunton @xcite .
the time - dependent kawasaki - gunton projection operator @xmath13 acts on an arbitrary operator @xmath14 as @xmath15 notice , that the kawasaki - gunton projection operator generalizes other types of time - dependent projection operators @xcite .
for example , the robertson @xcite and mori @xcite projectors can be easily obtained as a partial case of . moreover
, the kawasaki - gunton projection operator technique can be directly connected to zubarev s non - equilibrium statistical operator @xcite .
once the projection operator is chosen one can apply a standard procedure to derive a master equation @xcite .
the resulting master equation has a structure , which is analogue to the famous nakajima - zwanzig master equation @xcite , but is now more complicated due to the explicit time - dependence of the projection operators . at this stage ,
a variety of different approaches can be used , that where developed for the simplification of the nakajima - zwanzig master equation . with the help of the so - called , time - convolutionless projection operator technique ( tcl ) @xcite
the integro - differential nakajima - zwanzig equation can be cast in the form of a differential equation due to the inversion of the evolution of the total system and manipulation of the integral term in the master equation .
application of the tcl technique to the kawasaki - gunton master equation leads to a master equation local in time of the following form @xmath16 where @xmath17^{-1}\mathcal{p}(t),$ ] @xmath18^{-1}\mathcal{g}(t , t_0)\mathcal{q}(t_0),$ ] @xmath19 @xmath20 the superoperators @xmath21 @xmath22 and @xmath23 are the propagator and the inverse propagator , while the symbol @xmath24 denotes the chronological ( antichronological ) ordering ; @xmath25 is the liouville superoperator .
notice , that formally eq . has the same structure of a traditional tcl master equation @xcite , except for the explicit time - dependence of the projectors . at the same time eq . is a new type of a master equation , which has a few significant differences from the traditional one .
some of them will be discussed below .
the master equation relates to the known kawasaki - gunton master equation @xcite like the traditional nakajima - zwanzig master equation @xcite relates to the tcl master equation @xcite .
namely , ( i ) they have the same ranges of applicability ; ( ii ) the differential tcl master equation is simpler to study than the corresponding integro - differential nakajima - zwanzig master equation ; and an additional interesting fact @xcite ( iii ) the tcl master equation describes the exact dynamics of the systems more accurately than the corresponding nakajima - zwanzig master equation of the same order.for these reason we consider the equation to be an interesting new type of master equations .
an amazing feature of the above theory is the explicit connection between the dynamical variables and the thermodynamic parameters that resemble the relations in equilibrium thermodynamics .
let us define the entropy corresponding to the statistical operator . from the self - consistency conditions we have @xmath26 using eqs . and
one easily finds the following relations @xmath27 note , that the index @xmath28 in the above equation may be continuous , in this case partial derivations must be replaced by functional derivatives and sums must be replaced by integrals .
now , we turn to the construction of the relevant distributions for open quantum systems . traditionally , an open system is supposed to consist of two weakly interacting parts @xcite .
the weak interaction means that the correlation between the parts does not necessarily have to be taken into account and the density operators of the total system may be chosen as a direct product of density operators , corresponding to its subsystems .
one part , called a thermostat or a bath , is a large system with a huge number of degrees of freedom .
this subsystem is usually assumed to be in some equilibrium state .
the most commonly used thermal equilibrium state is characterized by the free energy only and the density operator for such state is written as @xmath29/\mathrm{tr}\exp[-\beta h],$ ] where @xmath30 is the inverse equilibrium temperature and @xmath31 is the hamiltonian of the thermostat . the second part of the total system , namely the open system itself , is generally assumed to be in some non - equilibrium state .
unfortunately , there is no universal criterion for the choice of the relevant variables for this case . for a low - dimensional system one can choose all possible dynamical variables as relevant , and
the above theory is completely equivalent to the traditional nakajima - zwanzig approach . on the other hand , infinite dimensional systems , or even high - dimensional systems ,
do not allow to consider all possible sets of dynamical variables . in this case
the set of relevant variables must be limited .
let us assume that the open system consists of one component or several weakly interacting components , labelled by @xmath32 .
the annihilation operator @xmath33 the creation operator @xmath34 and the occupation numbers operator @xmath35 can be chosen as relevant variables for such a system @xcite . in other words , this set includes momentum or position and energy of the @xmath32th component of the open system , which are directly accessible to experiments . in the case of strongly interacting parts of an open system individual characteristics of the parts are not relevant and the set of observables has to be chosen as @xmath36 @xmath37 and @xmath38 @xcite .
thus , the relevant distribution for an open system , can be written as follows @xmath39\otimes \exp[-\beta h_b],\ ] ] where @xmath40 is the hamiltonian of the thermostat , @xmath41 is the set of relevant variables , which characterise the @xmath42th subsystem of the open system , and @xmath43 are the massieu - planck functions of the subsystems .
below we present examples to illustrate the suggested approach .
the simplest model of an open system is the damped harmonic oscillator .
the rotating wave hamiltonian of the system is @xmath44 where @xmath45 and @xmath46 are the boson annihilation and creation operators , @xmath47 and @xmath48 are the annihilation and creation operators of @xmath49th oscillator in the bath , @xmath50 and @xmath51 are the frequencies of the oscillator and @xmath49th oscillator in the bath and @xmath52 are the interaction strengths.the first step of the formalism is to choose the relevant distribution .
the open system consists of only one component , but the dimension of the open system space is infinite .
so , we choose as the relevant variables the free hamiltonian of the bath @xmath53 the free hamiltonian of the oscillator @xmath54 and , also , the annihilation and creation operators @xmath55 . the relevant distribution can be written as @xmath56\exp[-\beta h_b].\ ] ] in the above equation @xmath57=\exp[f_2(t)+f_1(t)f_3(t)/f_2(t)]/(\exp[f_2(t)]-1)$ ] and @xmath58,$ ] @xmath30 is the inverse thermodynamical temperature of the bath .
the self - consistency conditions can be easily solved and the result is @xmath59 now an explicit formula for the entropy in terms of the mean values of the relevant variables can be derived @xmath60 where , @xmath61 is the equilibrium entropy of the bath .
this fundamental result arises automatically as a part of the formalism .
such a simple connection of dynamics and thermodynamics is a significant feature of the considered method .
in fact , eq . is a generalization of the informational entropy to the non - markovian and non - equilibrium cases for the damped harmonic oscillator .
the knowledge of the thermodynamical entropy allows to determine other thermodynamical parameters . for instance
, the non - equilibrium inverse temperature is @xmath62 by definition @xcite .
one can check that for the system under consideration @xmath63 .
the form of the above expression for the non - equilibrium entropy does not depend on details of the dynamical evolution . to apply this expression
it is necessary to determine the non - equilibrium average of the relevant variables .
the dynamics of the relevant observables is governed by eq . .
for the considered model , up to terms of the second order in the coupling constant , we obtain @xmath64 \langle a^\dagger\ ! a \rangle^{t}\nonumber\\ & + & \frac{1}{2}\left[f(t,\beta)+f^*(t,\beta)-f(t)-f^*(t)\right ] \label{osc_trans1}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] in the above equations we introduced the following correlation functions @xmath65 where @xmath66 is the spectral density of the bath .
eqs . and
seem identical to equations derived with the help of the traditional tcl master equation @xcite for the model .
nevertheless , the solution of eqs . and completely determines the non - equilibrium dynamics to second order in the coupling constant as opposed to the traditional approach , where for the model one has to solve an infinite system of the dynamical equations . to clarify the difference
let us determine the correlation function @xmath67}^2+\langle n\rangle^t-[\langle a\rangle^t\langle a^\dagger\rangle^t]^2.$ ] clearly , to find this correlation function from the traditional master equation one has to find a dynamical equation for the function and resolve it .
the solution of eqs . - can be written as @xmath68 @xmath69 and @xmath70 @xmath71 @xmath72where @xmath73 is the free term in eq . .
now , choosing the spectral density as @xmath74 where @xmath75 is the cutoff frequency , and substituting the solution of the equations and in we find the non - equilibrium entropy .
moreover , the inverse temperature is @xmath76 thus , we described the thermodynamical properties of the open system in addition to the dynamical properties .
the typical evolution of the thermodynamical entropy and the inverse temperature is shown in fig . 1
. the markovian evolution corresponds to the parameters @xmath77 and @xmath78 .
the system relaxes from the initial state @xmath79 and @xmath80 it is clearly seen that the thermodynamical parameters go to the equilibrium value , and the equilibrium temperature is equal to the temperature of the bath . in the non - markovian case
the thermodynamical parameters reach equilibrium faster and oscillate around the equilibrium value . , title="fig : " ] , title="fig : " ]
the second example which we consider is a damped driven two - level system .
the hamiltonian of the system is @xmath81 where @xmath82 is monochromatic classical field with frequency @xmath83 and rabi frequency @xmath84 @xmath85 and the @xmath86 are spin matrices . in this case
the open system has a finite number of degrees of freedom . as relevant variables we can choose all possible observables .
the relevant distribution has the form @xmath87\!\exp[\!-\!\beta h_b\!],\!\!\ ] ] where @xmath88=2\cosh(\frac{1}{2}\sqrt{4f_1(t)f_3(t)+f_2(t)^2})$ ] and @xmath58.$ ] the solution of the self - consistency conditions is @xmath89 where we introduced the functions @xmath90 and @xmath91 .
thus , the non - equilibrium entropy of the system has the form @xmath92 the expression for the thermodynamical entropy is valid for the non - markovian and the non - equilibrium cases .
this result generalises the results obtained in @xcite for markovian dynamics .
the dynamics of the two - level system is governed by the master equation of the form . for the model under consideration
the equations up to the second order in the coupling constant are written as @xmath93 in the above equations the functions @xmath94 and @xmath95 are the same as for the previous model .
the dynamical equations - are identical to the usual result derived with the help of the tcl master equation @xcite . for this model
the two approaches give the same results .
this is due to the fact that we considered all possible dynamical variables of the open system as relevant .
the particular choice of the spectral density allows to solve the equations - numerically .
the entropy of the open system is given by and the non - equilibrium inverse temperature is @xmath96 where @xmath97 is defined by .
thermodynamical entropy and inverse temperature , which correspond to spectral density @xmath74 are shown in fig . 2 .
the markovian evolution corresponds to the functions @xmath78 and @xmath98 the system relaxes from the initial state @xmath99 it is clearly seen that the thermodynamic parameters relax to the same quasi - equilibrium state in both the markovian and non - markovian cases . at the same time , in the non - markovian case @xmath100 and @xmath101 have oscillatory nature at sufficiently large times , while markovian dynamics does not show such behaviour .
the quasi - equilibrium temperature of the open system is higher than the corresponding equilibrium temperature of the bath ( we plotted the inverse temperature in fig .
this effect can be easily understood if we remember that the system interacts with the external classical field .
the classical field carries the energy to the system , in other words the system is continuously heated .
this contribution of the external field is responsible for the difference between the equilibrium temperature of the bath and the quasi - equilibrium temperature of the open system .
, title="fig : " ] , title="fig : " ]
in this article we have suggested to describe open quantum systems by unifying ideas of non - equilibrium thermodynamics and the time - convolutionless master equation . as significant features of the approach we can indicate the following : ( i ) the method allows to study only necessary dynamical variables , in contrast to nakajima - zwanzig and related techniques , which either use a full set of the system variables or a diagonal subset . in this sense
the suggested method is more flexible ; ( ii ) the method includes a connection between dynamical and thermodynamical characteristic of an open system , given by the self - consistency conditions .
the solution of the self - consistency condition is much easier than the direct calculation of thermodynamical parameters using the definition ; ( iii ) the main non - markovian master equation is local in time and can be efficiently studied with the help of usual methods of analysis ; ( iv ) the approach can be easily modified to take into account a non - stationarity of a bath state .
this work is based upon research supported by the south african research chair initiative of the department of science and technology and national research foundation .
let us firstly indicate the significant properties of the kawasaki - gunton projection operators ( eq . ( 4 ) ) @xmath102 namely @xmath103 in the above expressions @xmath104 is an arbitrary density operator .
the proof of these expressions can be found in @xcite .
through action of the kawasaki - gunton projection operator on both side of the liouville equation @xmath105 we derive the system @xmath106 where @xmath107 is the additional operator .
the formal solution of eq . can be written as @xmath108 where @xmath109 is the propagator . substituting this result in we obtain the generalized kawasaki - gunton master equation .
the master equation local in time is derived by inversion of the solution of the initial liouville equation @xmath110 and substituting this expression for ( b3 ) .
the explicit form of the superoperator @xmath111 is given in the main text .
after some algebra we derive @xmath112\mathcal{q}(t)\rho(t)=\mathcal{g}(t , t_0)\mathcal{q}(t_0)\rho(t_0)+\sigma(t)\mathcal{p}(t)\rho(t).\ ] ] multiplying both sides of the above equation by @xmath113^{-1}$ ] and substituting the result for we obtain the local in time master equation ( eq .
( 5 ) in the main text ) . expanding the right - hand side of eq .
( 5 ) in the main text with respect to the small interaction constant up to the second order we obtain @xmath114dt_1,\label{mat1}\\ \mathcal{i}(t)=\mathcal{p}(t)l(t)\mathcal{q}(t_0)+\int_{t_0}^t[\mathcal{p}(t)l(t)l(t_1)\mathcal{q}(t_0)-\mathcal{p}(t)l(t)\mathcal{p}(t_1)l(t_1)\mathcal{q}(t_0)]dt_1\label{mat2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the expressions - is the generalised local in time master equation of the second order , which holds for any projection operator .
particularly , time - independent projection operators yield the well - known tcl master equation @xcite .
the usual simplification for such equations is a special choice of initial conditions , namely , @xmath115 and it leads to absence of the inhomogeneity in the master equation .
this simplification was used in the main text .
to use the kawasaki - gunton projection operator technique it is convenient to multiply both sides of the master equation by some relevant variable @xmath116 and to take the trace , after that , using the linearity of the derivatives and trace and self - consistency conditions , the master equation can be re - written as a so - called generalized transport equation . performing this operation for all relevant variables
one obtains a system of generalized transport equations . as example let us consider the damped harmonic oscillator , which is the first model in the main text .
the hamiltonian in the interaction picture is @xmath117 where @xmath118 it is clear that @xmath119=0.$ ] so , the second order master equation for the model is @xmath120dt_1.\ ] ] using the cyclic permutation under the trace sign it is easy to show that @xmath121 for arbitrary operator @xmath14 .
thus , in the above equation the kawasaki - gunton projection operator can be replaced by the robertson projection operator , which acts as @xmath122 multiplication of both sides of the master equation by a relevant variable @xmath1 and taking the trace one obtains @xmath123dt_1 p_m\right\rbrace,\ ] ] where we used @xmath124 substituting for @xmath1 specific relevant variables , namely @xmath125 @xmath126 and @xmath127 leads to the generalized transport equations ( eqs .
( 13 ) and ( 14 ) ) .
notice , that we used the following expression for the bath correlation functions @xmath128/2\ ] ] and @xmath129/2.\ ] ] to study the second model we transform the initial hamiltonian to the interaction picture with respect to the hamiltonian @xmath130 the corresponding evolution operator is @xmath131 where @xmath132\!+\!\frac{i ( \omega_l-\omega_0)}{k}\sin[\frac{k}{2}(t - t ' ) ] \!\!\right)\!\!,\nonumber\\ d(t , t')\!=\!\frac{\omega}{ik}e^{\frac{i}{2}(t+t')\omega_l}\sin[\frac{k}{2}(t - t ' ) ] , \
, k\!=\!\!\sqrt{\omega^2+(\omega_l-\omega_0)^2}.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the transformed hamiltonian @xmath133 is defined as @xmath134 the generalized transport eqs . ( 18 ) and ( 19 ) are the particular case of eq . with the hamiltonian in the case of the exact resonance @xmath135 and not very strong intensity of the classical field @xmath136
to describe the thermodynamical properties of an open system one has to solve the self - consistency conditions @xmath137 formally , the non - equilibrium averages @xmath138 are known and one has to resolve the conditions with respect to @xmath139 the simplest way to derive an explicit form of the self - consistency conditions is to calculate the massieu - planck function @xmath140 in this case the required relations are given by @xmath141 ( eqs .
( 7 ) of the main text ) . for the damped harmonic oscillator we have @xmath142/(\exp[f_2(t)]-1),$ ] which can be found in the main text .
differentiation of the massieu - planck function with respect to @xmath8 gives @xmath143 the solution of the system above is presented in the main text ( eqs .
( 10 ) and ( 11 ) of the main text ) . for the driven two - level system we have @xmath144 .
differentiation of the massieu - planck function with respect to @xmath8 gives @xmath145 the solution of the system above is presented in eq .
a remarkable property of the spectral density of the bath @xmath146 , is the existence of an analytical form of an inverse fourier transformation , even for non - zero temperature of the bath . | open quantum systems are studied from the thermodynamical point of view unifying the principle of maximum informational entropy and the hypothesis of relaxation times hierarchy .
the result of the unification is a non - markovian and local in time master equation that provides a direct connection of dynamical and thermodynamical properties of open quantum systems .
the power of the approach is illustrated with the application to the damped harmonic oscillator and the damped driven two - level system resulting in analytical expressions for the non - markovian and non - equilibrium entropy and inverse temperature . |
the fatigue notion was founded on the concept of degraded or tired material and linked to the observation of material damage subjected to cyclic loading , which never reaches a level sufficient to cause failure in a single application ( see @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and schu ) .
it is apparent that fatigue produces progressive damage involving plastic deformation , crack nucleation , creep rupture and finally rapid fracture .
material damage is the gradual process of mechanical deterioration , that basically results in a structural component failure ( see @xcite kork and @xcite ) . among the first and most important mathematical models of fatigue , we recall
caputo s papers @xcite , @xcite and @xcite , where he proposes a definition of fatigue using the fractional derivative defined by him in @xcite .
this model estimates fatigue as function of the maximum strain applied , related to the number of cycles and of their frequency .
fremond and co - authors in @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and fre4 introduce a scalar variable @xmath0 describing the damage of the material and then suggest a definition of fatigue by the mechanical work that the system has performed starting from its initial or virgin state at the time @xmath1 .
the variable @xmath0 , in the following called phase field , describes the internal structural changes related to the damage of the material . in this paper , we denote by @xmath2 the stress tensor of the virgin material ( no damage ) , then the stress connected with damage is defined by@xmath3 \\
\mathbf{\tilde{t}}(x , t ) & for~\varphi < 0 \\ \mathbf{0 } & for~\varphi > 1% \end{array}% \right . \label{1}\]]so that we can denote the equation ( [ 1 ] ) by the following synthetic formula @xmath4where @xmath5 \\ 1 & for~\varphi > 1 \\ 0 & for~\varphi < 0% \end{array}% .\right.\ ] ] so , we can define fatigue @xmath6
\mathbf{\tilde{t}}(x,\tau ) \cdot \mathbf{l}(x,\tau ) dt , \label{2a}\]]where @xmath8 denotes the velocity and @xmath9 .
we observe that the stress , expressed by ( [ 1 ] ) and ( [ 2a ] ) , decreases with the increase of damage @xmath0 .
thus , the stress @xmath10 drops to zero and we have fracture . in this framework , the evolution of @xmath0 will be described inside the ginzburg - landau ( g - l ) theory , which allows to represent phenomena that exhibit internal structural changes . inside of this outline
, the g - l theory provides the differential equation@xmath11where @xmath12 denotes the density@xmath13 the diffusivity and @xmath14 are suitable positive coefficients , while @xmath15 and @xmath16 are the derivatives of two suitable potentials @xmath17 and @xmath18 .
finally , @xmath19 denotes the sourge of damage , that in the following , we shall suppose zero . from ( [ 3 ] ) , we may state that from the properties of the potentials @xmath17 and @xmath18 , when fatigue @xmath20 overlaps @xmath21 the phase @xmath0 increases and reaches @xmath22 for this study , we associate to the equation ( [ 3 ] ) the motion equation@xmath23where @xmath12 denotes the density and @xmath24 the body forces . in the paper , the gibbs free energy @xmath25 , reduced to a function of @xmath0 and @xmath26 only , contains the following terms@xmath27 ^{2}\right .
\notag \\ & & \left .
+ \mathcal{f}(x , t)f(\varphi ( x , t))+\mathcal{f}_{0}(x)g(\varphi ( x , t))\right \ } dx .
\label{5.1}\end{aligned}\]]the equation ( [ 3 ] ) is coherent with the definition of the gibbs free energy ( [ 5.1 ] ) , because we obtain the second member of ( [ 3 ] ) by @xmath28 .
so that , using ( [ 3 ] ) and ( [ 5.1 ] ) , we have@xmath29 it is worth to observe that , in the first part of the paper , the notion of fatigue is defined and studied in a general framework , without to characterize the constitutive equations of materials . then , in the next sections , fatigue and damage are defined for elastic and fading memory materials . for this fatigue model ,
it is basic to prove a maximum theorem for the phase field @xmath0 , that is proved in the section 6 , together to a uniqueness theorem .
hence , in the section 7 , we study the fatigue behavior under changes of temperature , because damage can be sensitive to frequent temperature variations and to high gradients or thermal shocks .
in this section , we regard simple materials non undergoing to fatigue phenomena . following the papers truesdell and noll @xcite , noll noll and coleman and owen @xcite ( see also @xcite ) , we define the properties of a thermomechanical solid material by the concept of dynamic system , which makes use of the notion of state and process .
let us consider a material point @xmath30 of a body @xmath31 . at time
@xmath32 $ ] @xmath33 , the _ configuration _ @xmath34 is given by the pair@xmath35where @xmath36 denotes the _ deformation gradient _ and @xmath37 the _ absolute temperature . _ a _ thermomechanical process _
@xmath38 of duration @xmath39 is a piecewise continuous function in the interval @xmath40 , given by the triplet@xmath41with @xmath42 the velocity gradient , @xmath43 and @xmath44 , while @xmath45 in the following , we denote by @xmath46 the process restricted to the interval @xmath47 , with @xmath48 a thermomechanical material in a point @xmath49can be view as a dynamic system , where the process @xmath38 is the input , while the output @xmath50 is defined by the functions@xmath51with@xmath52 the stress tensor,@xmath53 the internal heat power and @xmath54 the heat flux .
as defined in @xcite , @xcite and @xcite , a simple thermomechanical dynamic system is defined by the set @xmath55 , where a - @xmath56 is an open , connected subset of @xmath57 of configurations @xmath58 , b - @xmath59 is the set of smooth thermokinetic processes , c - @xmath60 is a metric space , defined by the state set , d - @xmath61 is the evolution function , such that@xmath62where @xmath63 is the initial state and @xmath64 is the state obtained from @xmath65 by the process @xmath66 moreover , the map @xmath67 is such that , if @xmath68 and @xmath69 , then @xmath70where @xmath71 denotes the composition of @xmath72 with @xmath73 so that , a thermomechanical material is defined by the functional @xmath74 , whereby@xmath75 moreover , we define the null process of duration @xmath76 @xmath77finally , the null state @xmath78is such that@xmath79for any null process @xmath80 of duration @xmath81
fatigue describes the material wear resulting from cyclic loading . while damage features the progressive mechanical deterioration that can involve crack nucleation , dislocation , plastic deformation , such that ultimately can bring in component failure . because , damage and fatigue are related to one another , we need to supplement the notion of state with a new variable @xmath82 , describing the changes of the internal material structure consequent to damage and related to fatigue .
hence , in this framework the variable @xmath83 represents variations of internal material structure .
therefore , the notion of state and process will be modified by the new definitions@xmath84while the response of the material @xmath85 assumes the new representation@xmath86where @xmath87 is defined as in ( [ 1 ] ) , while the fatigue @xmath88 is given in ( [ 2a ] ) , which in this framework we write@xmath89 \mathbf{\tilde{t}}(\sigma ( \tau ) , p(\tau ) ) \cdot \mathbf{l}(\tau ) d\tau , \label{13}\]]where @xmath90 is the initial state at time @xmath1 , while @xmath91 and @xmath92 in the following of this paper , we shall restrict the study to mechanical processes only .
whereby , the process is given by @xmath93 and the response by @xmath94 for the whole study of the problem , we need to introduce an equation for the phase field @xmath95 because this variable describes the variation of the internal structure of the material , the natural representation is given by the ginzburg - landau equation ( [ 3 ] ) with @xmath96 , which for this problem assumes the form@xmath97where @xmath98 denotes the diffusivity . in this paper , we choose the two potentials @xmath99 and @xmath100 given by @xmath101 in the following , we shall denote @xmath102 @xmath103 together with the equation ( [ 14 ] ) , we consider the motion equation , that is@xmath104 of course , the material properties will be defined by the constitutive equation on the stress tensor @xmath10 , which in this framework is fixed by the equation ( [ 1 ] ) , that we may even write in the equivalent form @xmath105 ^{2}\mathbf{\tilde{t}}(\sigma ( x , t),p(x , t ) ) \label{17}\]]so@xmath106 ^{2}\mathbf{\tilde{t}}(\sigma ( x , t),p(x , t))\cdot \nabla \mathbf{v}(x , t ) ; \label{17b}\]]then , if we suppose to consider processes leaving from an initial state @xmath107 at the time @xmath1 , the equation ( 17b ) can be written@xmath108 \frac{d}{dt}\int_{t_{0}}^{t}\left [ 1-\breve{% \varphi}(\tau ) \right ] \mathbf{\tilde{t}}(\sigma ( \tau ) , p(\tau ) ) \cdot \nabla \mathbf{v}(\tau ) d\tau .
\label{18a}\ ] ] hence , by the definition ( [ 13 ] ) of fatigue we have@xmath108 \mathbf{\tilde{t}}(\sigma ( t),p(t))\cdot \nabla \mathbf{v}(t)-\breve{\varphi}(t)\frac{d}{dt}\mathcal{f}(\tilde{\sigma}^{i},% \tilde{p}_{t } ) .
\label{18b}\ ] ]
in order to claim the dissipation principle for any @xmath109 , we define the internal mechanical power @xmath110 and the internal structural power @xmath111at time @xmath112 @xmath113 \mathbf{\tilde{t}}(\sigma ( t),p(t))\cdot \nabla \mathbf{v}(t)-% \breve{\varphi}(t)\frac{d}{dt}\mathcal{f}(\tilde{\sigma}^{i},\tilde{p}_{t})% \text { , } \label{19}\]]@xmath114 ^{2}+\left \ { \frac{1}{2\kappa } \left [ \nabla \varphi ( t)\right ] ^{2}\right \ } ^{\cdot } + \mathcal{f}_{0}\dot{g}(\varphi ( t))+\mathcal{f}(% \tilde{\sigma}^{i},\tilde{p}_{t})\dot{f}(\varphi ( t))\text { , } \label{20}\]]where the dot @xmath115 denotes the partial time derivative . *
dissipation principle .
* there exists a state function @xmath116 , called free energy , such that@xmath117 by using ( [ 19 ] ) and ( [ 20 ] ) , we obtain from ( [ 21 ] ) @xmath118 \mathbf{\tilde{t}}(\sigma ( t),p(t))\cdot \nabla \mathbf{v}(t)-\breve{\varphi}% ( t)\frac{d}{dt}\mathcal{f}(\tilde{\sigma}^{i},\tilde{p}_{t } ) \notag \\ & & \quad + \rho \left [ \dot{\varphi}(t)\right ] ^{2}+\left \ { \frac{1}{2\kappa } % \left [ \nabla \varphi ( t)\right ] ^{2}\right \ } ^{\cdot } + \mathcal{f}_{0}\dot{g% } ( \varphi ( t))+\mathcal{f}(\tilde{\sigma}^{i},\tilde{p}_{t})\dot{f}(\varphi ( t))\quad \label{22a}\end{aligned}\]]and hence , on account of ( [ 15a])@xmath119 , we have @xmath118 \mathbf{\tilde{t}}(\sigma ( t),p(t))\cdot \nabla \mathbf{v}(t)+\rho \left [ \dot{\varphi}(t)\right ] ^{2 } \notag \\ & & \quad + \left \ { \frac{1}{2\kappa } \left [ \nabla \varphi ( t)\right ] ^{2}\right \ } ^{\cdot } + \mathcal{f}_{0}\dot{g}(\varphi ( t))+\frac{d}{dt}\left [ \mathcal{f}(\tilde{\sigma}^{i},\tilde{p}_{t})f(\varphi ( t)\right ] , \quad \label{23}\end{aligned}\]]or@xmath118 \mathbf{\tilde{t}}(\sigma ( t),p(t))\cdot \nabla \mathbf{v}(t)+\rho \left [ \dot{\varphi}(t)\right ] ^{2 } \notag \\ & & \quad + \frac{d}{dt}\left \ { \frac{1}{2\kappa } \left [ \nabla \varphi ( t)% \right ] ^{2}+\mathcal{f}_{0}g(\varphi ( t))+\mathcal{f}(\tilde{\sigma}^{i},% \tilde{p}_{t})f(\varphi ( t))\right \ } \text{.\quad } \label{24}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this inequality may be written in the equivalent form@xmath120 ^{2}+ \notag \\ & & \quad \frac{d}{dt}\left \ { \frac{1}{2\kappa } \left [ \nabla \varphi ( t)% \right ] ^{2}+\mathcal{f}_{0}g(\varphi ( t))+\mathcal{f}(\tilde{\sigma}^{i},% \tilde{p}_{t})f(\varphi ( t))\right \ } \text{.\quad } \label{24b}\end{aligned}\ ] ] now , we denote by @xmath121 the free energy related to virgin material ( no damage ) , so that@xmath122 then , from ( [ 24 ] ) and ( [ 25 ] ) we have that the free energy @xmath123 can be written as@xmath124where @xmath125 is the damage component of free energy . otherwise , if we define the pseudo fatigue energy @xmath126 as @xmath127 ^{2}+\mathcal{f}_{0}g(\varphi ( t))+\mathcal{f}(% \tilde{\sigma}^{i},\tilde{p}_{t})f(\varphi ( t))\right \ } ; \label{27}\]]then , from ( [ 24 ] ) , we obtain @xmath128 \leq \left [ 1-\breve{\varphi}(t)\right ] \mathbf{\tilde{t}}(\sigma ( t),p(t))\cdot \nabla \mathbf{v}(t)+\rho \left [ \dot{\varphi}(t)\right ] ^{2}. \label{27 - 1}\ ] ] of course , once assigned the constitutive equations of virgin material , the mathematical shape of @xmath129 can be well defined
. otherwise , we may study the behavior of the pseudo energy @xmath126 with @xmath130 and @xmath100 defined in ( [ 15a ] ) .
so that , if we consider the graph of @xmath131 , as a function only of the field @xmath0 , varying the fatigue , we obtain different shape of @xmath126 represented in fig.1 and fig.2 .
fig.1 the free energies corresponding to different fatigues , with minima in @xmath132 fig.2 in this pictures , the free energies with minima in @xmath133 therefore , the increase of the fatigue shifts the minimum of the free energy @xmath126 toward the extreme value @xmath134 this involves the material breaking due to energy instability .
in this section , we consider fatigue model for a material whose virgin state is elastic . in such a case , the stress tensor @xmath2 assumes the following form@xmath135where @xmath136 is a positive and symmetric fourth order tensor and @xmath137 denotes the displacement vector .
so fatigue is given by@xmath138
\mathbf{a}\nabla \mathbf{u}(\tau ) \cdot \nabla
\mathbf{\dot{u}}(\tau ) d\tau \notag \\ & & \quad = \frac{1}{2}\left [ 1-\breve{\varphi}(t)\right ] \mathbf{a}\nabla \mathbf{u}(t)\cdot \nabla \mathbf{u}(t)+\frac{1}{2}\int_{t_{0}}^{t}\left [ \breve{\varphi}(\tau ) \right ] ^{\cdot } \mathbf{a}\nabla \mathbf{u}(\tau ) \cdot \nabla \mathbf{u}(\tau ) d\tau , \qquad \label{27c}\end{aligned}\]]where we have supposed that @xmath139 and @xmath140 then , from ( [ 27 ] ) , ( [ 15a])@xmath119 and ( [ 27c])@xmath141 , we obtain the free energy @xmath142 as a function of @xmath143@xmath144 ^{2}\right . \\ & & \quad \left . + \mathcal{f}_{0}g(\varphi ( t))\right \ } = -\frac{1}{2\rho } % \breve{\varphi}(t)\left \ { \left [ 1-\breve{\varphi}(t)\right ] \mathbf{a}% \nabla \mathbf{u}(t)\cdot \nabla \mathbf{u}(t)+\right .
\\ & & \quad \left . \int_{t_{0}}^{t}\left
[ \breve{\varphi}(\tau ) \right ] ^{\cdot } % \mathbf{a}\nabla \mathbf{u}(\tau ) \cdot \nabla \mathbf{u}(\tau ) d\tau \right \ } + \frac{1}{\rho } \left \ { \frac{1}{2\kappa } \left [ \nabla \varphi ( t)% \right ] ^{2}+\mathcal{f}_{0}g(\varphi ( t))\right \ } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] while the inequality ( [ 24 ] ) , using ( [ 27c])@xmath119 , assumes the form@xmath118 \mathbf{a}\nabla \mathbf{u}(t)\cdot \nabla \mathbf{\dot{u}}(t)+\rho \left [ \dot{\varphi}(t)\right ]
^{2 } \\ & & \quad + \frac{d}{dt}\left \ { -\breve{\varphi}(t)\int_{t_{0}}^{t}\left [ 1-% \breve{\varphi}(\tau ) \right ] \mathbf{a}\nabla \mathbf{u}(\tau ) \cdot
\nabla \mathbf{\dot{u}}(\tau ) d\tau + \frac{1}{2\kappa } \left [ \nabla \varphi ( t)% \right ] ^{2}\right . \\ & & \quad \ , \left
. + \mathcal{f}_{0}g(\varphi ( t))\right \ } = -\breve{\varphi}(t)% \mathbf{a}\nabla \mathbf{u}(t)\cdot \nabla \mathbf{\dot{u}}(t)+\rho \left [ \dot{\varphi}(t)\right ] ^{2}+\frac{1}{2}\frac{d}{dt}\left \ { [ 1-\breve{\varphi% } ( t)\right . \qquad \\ & & \quad + \breve{\varphi}^{2}(t)]\mathbf{a}\nabla \mathbf{u}(t)\cdot \nabla \mathbf{u}(t)-\breve{\varphi}(t)\int_{t_{0}}^{t}\left [ \breve{\varphi}(\tau ) % \right ] ^{\cdot } \mathbf{a}\nabla \mathbf{u}(\tau ) \cdot \nabla \mathbf{u}% ( \tau ) d\tau \\ & & \quad \left .
+ \frac{1}{\kappa } \left [ \nabla \varphi ( t)\right ] ^{2}+2% \mathcal{f}_{0}g(\varphi ( t))\right \ } .\end{aligned}\]]hence , the free energy for these materials is given by@xmath145 \mathbf{a}%
\nabla \mathbf{u}(t)\cdot \nabla \mathbf{u}(t)\right .
\\ & & \quad \left .
-\breve{\varphi}(t)\int_{t_{0}}^{t}\dot{\varphi}(\tau ) % \mathbf{a}\nabla \mathbf{u}(\tau ) \cdot \nabla \mathbf{u}(\tau ) d\tau + \frac{% 1}{\kappa } \left [ \nabla \varphi ( t)\right ] ^{2}+2\mathcal{f}_{0}g(\varphi ( t)))\right \ } .\qquad \end{aligned}\ ] ]
now , we consider the differential system for a fatigue mechanical problem given by the equations ( [ 14 ] ) and ( [ 16 ] ) , inside a smooth domain @xmath146 and in a time domain @xmath147 \subset \mathbb{r}.$ ] in the case of an elastic material @xmath2 and @xmath148 are defined in ( [ 27a ] ) and ( [ 27c ] ) , so , by using ( [ 17 ] , we have the differential system @xmath149 \mathbf{a}(x)\nabla \mathbf{u}(x,\tau ) \cdot \nabla \mathbf{\dot{u}}(x,\tau ) d\tau , \label{33b } \\ & & \rho ( x)\frac{\partial ^{2}\mathbf{u}(x , t)}{\partial t^{2}}=\nabla \cdot \left
\ { \left [ 1-\breve{\varphi}(t)\right ] ^{2}\mathbf{a}(x)\nabla \mathbf{u% } ( x , t)\right \ } + \rho ( x)\mathbf{b}(x , t ) , \label{33c}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the initial and boundary conditions @xmath150@xmath151 in order to define the week solutions of the problem ( [ 33b])-[33f ] ) , we introduce the set of the functions @xmath152 and @xmath153 where@xmath154and@xmath155moreover , we suppose @xmath156 , @xmath98 , @xmath157 .
a pair @xmath158 is called week solution of the problem ( [ 33b])-[33c ] ) , with initial conditions ( [ 33d ] ) and boundary conditions ( [ 33f ] ) , if satisfies , for all @xmath159 and @xmath160 , the integral forms @xmath161 \mathbf{a}(x)\nabla \mathbf{u}(x,\tau ) \cdot \nabla \mathbf{% \dot{u}}(x,\tau ) d\tau \dot{\psi}(x , t ) \notag \\ & & \quad \left .
+ \mathcal{f}_{0}\mathcal{(}x)\left \langle 2\varphi ( x , t)-% \frac{\varphi ^{2}(x , t)}{2}\right \rangle \dot{\psi}(x , t)\right \ } dxdt=0 \label{33g}\end{aligned}\]]and @xmath162 ^{2}\mathbf{a}% ( x)\nabla \mathbf{u}(x , t)\right .
\notag \\ & & \qquad \left .
\cdot \nabla \mathbf{\dot{w}}(x , t)\right \ } dxdt=\int_{0}^{t}\int_{\omega } \rho ( x)\mathbf{b}(x , t)\cdot \mathbf{\dot{w}}% ( x , t)dxdt .
\label{33h}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in order to obtain the well position of the differential problem ( [ 33b])-[33f ] ) it is crucial to prove the following maximum theorem .
any solution of the equation ( [ 33b ] ) , with initial conditions @xmath163 , with boundary condition @xmath164 satisfies the restriction@xmath165 multiplying the equation ( [ 33b ] ) by @xmath166 $ ] and integrating on @xmath167 we obtain@xmath168 \mathbf{a}\nabla \mathbf{u}(\tau ) \cdot \nabla \mathbf{\dot{u}}(\tau ) d\tau dx .
\label{33l}\end{aligned}\]]it is easy to prove from the initial condition @xmath169 $ ] , that@xmath170 \mathbf{a}\nabla \mathbf{u}(\tau ) \cdot
\nabla \mathbf{\dot{u}}(\tau ) d\tau dx=0;\]]then , because @xmath171 , we obtain from ( [ 33l ] ) for any @xmath172@xmath173 dxdt=0,\end{aligned}\]]from which@xmath174 ^{2}+% \frac{1}{\kappa } \int_{0}^{t}\left [ \nabla \varphi _ { \_}(t)\right ] ^{2}dt\right \ } dx=0 , \label{33q}\]]because @xmath175thus , from ( [ 33q ] ) , @xmath176 for any @xmath177 and @xmath178 for any @xmath179 $ ] a.e .
@xmath180 hence , the restriction that @xmath181 is satisfied in ( [ 33b ] ) . to show that @xmath182 , let us to consider the function @xmath183and suppose that @xmath184
thus , multiplying ( [ 33b ] ) by @xmath185 , after an integration on @xmath167 we have@xmath186 dx \notag \\ & & \ ; \qquad = -\left \langle -1\right \rangle \int_{\omega } ( \varphi -1)_{+}\int_{0}^{t}\left [ 1-\breve{\varphi}(\tau ) \right ] \mathbf{a}\nabla
\mathbf{u}(\tau ) \cdot \nabla \mathbf{\dot{u}}(\tau ) d\tau dx \label{33qq}\end{aligned}\]]and hence , by integrating on @xmath187 $ ] , it follows that@xmath188 dxdt \\ & & \quad = -\int_{0}^{t}\int_{\omega } \left \langle -1\right \rangle ( \varphi -1)_{+}\int_{0}^{t}\left [ 1-\breve{\varphi}(\tau ) \right ] \mathbf{a}\nabla \mathbf{u}(\tau ) \cdot \nabla \mathbf{\dot{u}}(\tau ) d\tau dxdt=0,\qquad \end{aligned}\]]since by hypothesis @xmath184 , then @xmath189 . by integrating the first term and observing that in the third term also @xmath190 under the hypothesis @xmath184
, this equation reduces to@xmath191 ^{2}+% \frac{1}{\kappa } \int_{0}^{t}\left [ \nabla ( \varphi -1)_{+}(t)\right ] ^{2}dt\right \ } dx=0 , \label{33qr}\]]that is the sum of two positive quantities ; therefore , each of these must be equal to zero .
thus , it follows that @xmath192 for any @xmath193 and also @xmath194 for any @xmath32 .\ $ ] hence , the hypothesis @xmath184 is not satisfied ; on the contary the inequality @xmath182 holdsand the restriction ( [ 33i ] ) has been proved .
the thesis of this theorem can be confirmed by the simulations represented in fig . 3 , and 4
, corresponding to several selections of parameters fig.3 .
the first graphic describes the behavior of the phase field @xmath0 corresponding to different values of the density @xmath195 and a time @xmath196 , with the same frequency @xmath197 . in the second graphic ,
the frequency is the same @xmath197 , but the densities @xmath198 fig .
these graphics describe the behavior of @xmath0 for different values of the frequency @xmath199 , with the same time @xmath200 , but with two values of the density .
let us now study a uniqueness theorem for the null solution .
so that , we consider zero initial data and supplies .
the system ( [ 33g])-[33h ] ) with zero initial data and supplies admits only the null solution . from the system ( [ 33g])-[33h ] ) with @xmath201 and @xmath202 and initial and boundary conditions@xmath203@xmath204we obtain @xmath205 ^{2}+\frac{1}{2}\frac{1}{\kappa ( x)}\frac{\partial } { \partial t}\left [ \nabla \varphi ( x , t)\right ] ^{2}\right . \notag \\ & & \quad + \left \langle -1\right \rangle \int_{t_{0}}^{t}\left [ 1-\breve{\varphi% } ( x,\tau ) \right ] \mathbf{a}(x)\nabla \mathbf{u}(x,\tau ) \cdot \nabla \mathbf{\dot{u}}(x,\tau ) d\tau \dot{\varphi}(x , t ) \notag \\ & & \quad \left .
+ \mathcal{f}_{0}\mathcal{(}x)\left \langle 2\varphi ( x , t)-% \frac{\varphi ^{2}(x , t)}{2}\right \rangle \right \ } \dot{\varphi}(x , t)dxdt=0 \label{33m}\end{aligned}\]]and@xmath206 ^{2}\mathbf{a}(x)\nabla \mathbf{u% } ( x , t)\cdot \nabla \mathbf{\dot{u}}(x , t)dxdt=0 . \label{33n}\]]summing these equations and taking into account the previous result @xmath207 and the corresponding expressions of the interested quantities , we obtain@xmath208 ^{2}% \mathbf{a}(x)\nabla \mathbf{u}(x , t)\cdot \nabla \mathbf{u}(x , t)\right .
\right .
\notag \\ & & \ ; \left .
\left . + \frac{1}{\kappa ( x)}\left [ \nabla \varphi ( x , t)\right ] ^{2}\right \ } + \mathcal{f}_{0}\mathcal{(}x)\left ( 2\varphi ( x , t)-\frac{% \varphi ^{2}(x , t)}{2}\right ) \dot{\varphi}(x , t)\right ) dxdt \notag \\ & = & \int_{0}^{t}\int_{\omega } \left \ { -\rho ( x)\left [ \dot{\varphi}(x , t)% \right ] ^{2}+\frac{1}{2}\dot{\varphi}(x , t)\int_{0}^{t}\dot{\varphi}(x,\tau ) % \mathbf{a}(x)\nabla \mathbf{u}(x,\tau ) \right .
\notag \\ & & \ ; \left .
\cdot \nabla \mathbf{u}(x,\tau ) d\tau -\frac{1}{2}\dot{\varphi}% ( x , t)\left [ 1-\varphi ( x , t)\right ] \mathbf{a}(x)\nabla \mathbf{u}(x , t)\cdot \nabla \mathbf{u}(x , t)\right \ } dxdt.\qquad \quad \label{33r}\end{aligned}\]]then , using the initial conditions ( [ 33o ] ) , there exists a @xmath209 such that for all @xmath210 $ ] @xmath211 \mathbf{a}(x)\nabla \mathbf{u}% ( x , t)\cdot \nabla \mathbf{u}(x , t)\right \ } ; \notag\end{aligned}\]]then , we have by ( [ 33r ] ) and by the initial and boundary conditions ( 33o)-([33p ] ) , that@xmath212 ~and~a.e.\text { } x\in \omega .
\label{33w}\]]finally , after an iteration procedure , we can prove that ( [ 33w ] ) is satisfied for any @xmath213 .$ ]
it is apparent that fatigue may be affected by the temperature ( see @xcite , @xcite ) .
thus , fatigue life of a material could change under different temperatures , especially , when the variations of temperature are frequent and with high gradients or thermal shock . in this framework
, we have to introduce the heat equation .
so that , we consider the first law of thermodynamics@xmath214where @xmath215 is the internal energy , @xmath216 the internal mechanical power , @xmath217 the internal heat power and @xmath218 the internal structural power . moreover , in this paper we confine the study to a _ simple material _ ( see @xcite , @xcite ) , for which the internal mechanical work @xmath216 is given by@xmath219with a view to well define the differential system , we introduce the motion equation@xmath220 + \rho ( x)\mathbf{b}% ( x , t),~\ \varkappa > 0 , \label{35}\]]where @xmath37 is the absolute temperature and @xmath221 is the identity tensor , the heat equation@xmath222and the ginzburg - landau equation@xmath223the fatigue @xmath224 is now defined by@xmath225 \left [ -\frac{\mathcal{p}_{h}^{i}(\tau ) } { \theta ( \tau ) } + % \mathbf{q}\cdot \nabla \theta ^{-1}(\tau ) \right ] d\tau \notag \\ & = & \int_{t_{0}}^{t}\left [ 1-\breve{\varphi}(\tau ) \right ] \left \ { [ \mathbf{% \tilde{t}}(\sigma ( \tau ) ,
p(\tau ) ) \cdot \nabla
\mathbf{v}(\tau ) + \mathcal{p}% _ { s}^{i}(\tau ) \right .
\notag \\ & & \quad \left .
-\rho ( x)\dot{e}(\tau ) ] \theta ^{-1}(\tau ) + \mathbf{q}(\tau ) \cdot \nabla \theta ^{-1}(\tau ) \right \ } d\tau , \label{38}\end{aligned}\]]which on closed cycles assumes the form@xmath226 [ \mathbf{\tilde{t}}(\sigma ( \tau ) , p(\tau ) ) \cdot \mathbf{l}% ( \tau ) \theta ^{-1}(\tau ) \notag \\ & & \,+\mathcal{p}_{s}^{i}(\tau ) \theta ^{-1}(\tau ) + \mathbf{q}(\tau ) \cdot \nabla \theta ^{-1}(\tau ) ] d\tau -\oint_{t_{0}}^{t}\rho ( x)\left [ 1-\breve{% \varphi}(\tau ) \right ] \frac{\dot{e}(\tau ) } { \theta ( \tau ) } d\tau .\quad \label{39}\end{aligned}\ ] ] then , by ( [ 37a ] ) the balance of the structural power provides@xmath227 = \rho ( x)\dot{\varphi}^{2}(x , t)+\frac{1}{\kappa ( x)}% \nabla \varphi ( x , t)\cdot \nabla \dot{\varphi}(x , t ) \\ & & \qquad \qquad \qquad \qquad \qquad + \mathcal{f(}\hat{\sigma}(t))\dot{f}% ( \varphi ( x , t))+\mathcal{f}_{0}\mathcal{(}x)\dot{g}(\varphi ( x , t)).\end{aligned}\]]so , the internal structural power is defined by@xmath228 this equation for an elastic material takes the wording @xmath231and from ( [ 40c ] ) , @xmath224 assumes the form@xmath232 \mathbf{a}\nabla \mathbf{u}(\tau ) \cdot
\nabla \mathbf{\dot{u}% } ( \tau ) \theta ^{-1}(\tau ) \notag \\ & & + \mathbf{q}(\tau ) \cdot \nabla \theta ^{-1}(\tau ) ( d\tau .
\label{41}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the author has been partially supported by italian g.n.f.m
. - i.n.d.a.m and by university of bologna .
the figures 3 and 4 were generated using the software package mathematica ( ver .
8.0.4 ) . finally , the author is grateful to professors caputo and fremond for their suggestions and advises .
r. minichmayr , m. riedlera , g. wintera , h. leitnera and w. eichlsede , _ thermo - mechanical fatigue life assessment of aluminum components using the damage rate model of sehitoglu _ , international journal of fatigue , * 30 * 298 - 304 ( 2008 ) . | in the paper we present an isothermal model for describing damage and fatigue by the use of the ginzburg - landau ( g - l ) equation .
fatigue produces progressive damage , which is related with a variation of the internal structure of the material .
the g - l equation studies the evolution of the order parameter , which describes the constitutive arrangement of the system and , in this framework , the evolution of damage . the thermodynamic coherence of the model is proved . in the last part of the work
, we extend the results of the paper to a non - isothermal system , where fatigue contains thermal effects , which increase the damage of materials .
keywords : damage , fatigue , phase transition , thermodynamics . |
the study of granular systems has attracted much interest in the last years .
the practical importance of these systems , which are present in many situations in daily life , together with the richness and complexity of their behavior@xcite , have motivated many researches trying to describe and understand the physical mechanisms governing granular flows .
of course , the variety of what we call granular media makes it necessary to use different theoretical descriptions depending on the problem we wish to address . in the context of rapid , low density , granular flows ,
the application of the methods of the kinetic theory for molecular ( elastic ) systems has proven to be a very useful tool .
the starting point for this description has been in many cases the extension to inelastic collisions of the boltzmann equation , which is derived under the same hypothesis as in elastic systems . from this kinetic equation ,
closed hydrodynamic equations with explicit expression for the fluxes and the associated transport coefficients ( up to second order in the gradients ) for inelastic hard particles have been derived @xcite .
this hydrodynamic picture has been found to provide an accurate description of granular systems in very different situations , driven and not driven .
the boltzmann equation has also been used to study the velocity distribution of a granular gas , modeled in most of the cases as a system of inelastic hard particles .
of course , the shape of the distribution depends on the state of the system .
the simplest possibility is the so - called homogeneous cooling state ( hcs ) , the state of a homogeneous , freely evolving granular gas @xcite . in that case , the boltzmann equation is shown to admit a solution whose time dependence can be scaled through its second moment .
deviations from gaussianity in the hcs have been quantified by computing the kurtosis of the distribution @xcite and by establishing the existence of exponential velocity tails @xcite .
the possible solutions of the boltzmann equation in the case of a vibrated system in absence of gravity have also been investigated , and the conditions for the existence of a steady solution whose space dependence is scaled out also through the second moment has been established @xcite . in spite of its extended use and clear success in many cases ,
the validity of the boltzmann equation to describe granular flows has been questioned since the early developments of the kinetic theory of granular systems .
one of the first objections raised against its use was based on the tendency of these systems to form density clusters .
since it is only valid in the low density limit , the boltzmann equation is not suitable to describe the cluster evolution .
this is not a fundamental objection , and in fact it can also be raised against the applicability of the boltzmann equation to molecular systems in inhomogeneous states . the value of the density limits indeed the applicability of the boltzmann description , but both in the elastic and the inelastic case .
on the other hand , if we start from an homogeneous , low density , initial configuration of a granular gas , under conditions that clusters will develop eventually , it can be expected that the boltzmann equation will be valid to describe the first stages of the cluster formation , as long as regions with a too large density do not show up . a different objection concerns the validity of the molecular chaos hypothesis , which is on the basis of the boltzmann description .
as collisions in granular systems tend to make the particle velocities more parallel , velocity correlations may develop from the early stages of the evolution of a granular gas , making the molecular chaos hypothesis invalid .
this problem was directly addressed by soto et al @xcite , who studied the short - range velocity correlations in the hcs of a granular fluid , concluding that they were not relevant in the low density case .
pagonabarraga et al @xcite also studied the validity of the molecular chaos hypothesis in a homogeneous granular system , but in this case driven by a random force .
again , it was found that , for dilute systems , deviations from molecular chaos were not significant . to put this work in a proper context
, it should be taken into account that the driving force introduced by the authors induced some velocity correlations , as pointed out by them .
the previous mentioned studies are restricted to homogeneous states of a granular gas .
they correspond to very special situations , so the conclusions can not be extrapolated to more general cases .
a different situation was investigated recently by nakanishi @xcite , who studied the time evolution of the velocity distribution of a freely evolving granular fluid in conditions such that the hcs is unstable .
he found that the kurtosis of the distribution did not remain stationary , but evolved towards the gaussian value from the early stages of the evolution of the system , even before the clustering instability shows up .
he argues that this is in contradiction with the predictions of kinetic theories based on the boltzmann equation , being a clear indication of the growth of velocity correlations , which invalidate the molecular chaos hypothesis .
he also found that the return to the gaussian behavior became slower the more dilute the system , but as changing the density implies changing the `` clustering time '' , it was not clear to the author how the boltzmann behavior could be recovered .
the object of this work is to investigate the possible differences in the behavior of the velocity distribution function of a initially dilute , homogeneous , granular gas and the predictions of the boltzmann equation when the system is under conditions such that the hcs is unstable .
we will compare the results from molecular dynamics ( md ) simulations at different average densities with those from the direct simulation monte carlo ( dsmc ) method , which is a method to solve numerically the boltzmann equation @xcite .
the plan of the paper is as follows : in section [ s2 ] the kinetic theory predictions for the hcs are briefly discussed , while the details of the simulations and the properties to be studied are given in sec .
the results for the dsmc and md simulations are presented in secs .
[ sec4 ] and [ sec5 ] .
some final comments and discussion are made in sec .
let us consider a a system of @xmath0 smooth inelastic hard particles , spheres ( @xmath1 ) or disks ( @xmath2 ) , of mass @xmath3 and diameter @xmath4 .
the loss of energy in collisions is characterized by a constant coefficient of normal restitution @xmath5 , which implies that the velocities of two colliding particles @xmath6 , @xmath7 before and after the collision are related by @xmath8 where the primes denote velocities after the collision , @xmath9 is the relative velocity , and @xmath10 a unit vector joining the centers of particles @xmath6 and @xmath7 at contact .
let us notice that @xmath11 , and that the value @xmath12 corresponds to elastic collisions .
the above rule implies that , in each collision , the component of the relative velocity in the direction of @xmath13 is reduced in a factor @xmath5 : @xmath14 the boltzmann equation describing the evolution of the velocity distribution @xmath15 of a system of freely evolving hard particles has the form : @xmath16 \ , , \ ] ] where @xmath17 is the ( inelastic ) boltzmann collision operator : @xmath18= \sigma^{d-1 } \int d{\bf v}_{1 } \int d\widehat{\mbox{\boldmath$\sigma$}}\ , \theta ( { \bf g}\cdot \widehat{\mbox{\boldmath$\sigma$ } } ) ( { \bf g}\cdot \widehat{\mbox{\boldmath$\sigma$ } } ) ( \alpha^{-2 } b^{-1}-1)f({\bf r},{\bf v},t ) f({\bf r},{\bf v}_{1},t)\ , .\ ] ] here @xmath19 is the heaviside step function and @xmath20 an operator transforming velocities @xmath21 and @xmath22 to its right into their precollisional values . as it is the case with elastic particles , the derivation of this equation
is based on the molecular chaos hypothesis , i.e. , the factorization of the two - particle distribution function in the precollisional sphere : @xmath23 , where @xmath24 .
if spatial and/or velocity correlations are present between colliding particles , this factorization does not hold and the assumption of molecular chaos fails .
when a system of inelastic particles such as the one described evolves freely , its simplest possible state is the hcs .
it is a homogeneous state with no fluxes , whose temperature @xmath25 , defined as proportional to the average kinetic energy , evolves according to haff s law@xcite , @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the time characterizing the energy decay .
when the system is in the hcs , the boltzmann equation admits a solution @xmath28 that obeys the scaling law @xcite @xmath29 where @xmath30 is the homogeneous density , and @xmath31 the thermal velocity of the system , defined as @xmath32 , with @xmath33 the boltzmann constant .
therefore , in the hcs all the time dependence of the velocity distribution can be scaled out through its second moment .
the function @xmath34 is determined from the boltzmann equation .
although its exact expression is not known , it was found that it does not deviate much from a gaussian @xcite .
then , it is sensible to expand it using the sonine polynomials , @xmath35 , whose explicit expression can be found in @xcite , @xmath36 normalization and scaling imply @xmath37 and @xmath38 .
the coefficient @xmath39 is related to the kurtosis of the distribution @xmath40 \ , , \label{eq : a2}\ ] ] and its value has been estimated from the boltzmann equation up to linear order in @xmath39 @xcite . both theoretical calculations and numerical simulations of the boltzmann equation @xcite show that , for not too inelastic systems , @xmath39 is very small .
deviations from gaussianity are important if we consider the tails of the distribution , which are exponential .
again , this has been verified from theoretical arguments based on the boltzmann equation @xcite and from dsmc simulations @xcite .
the time @xmath27 characterizing the kinetic energy decay in the hcs has also been computed by using the boltzmann equation @xcite , and its expression reads : @xmath41 where @xmath42 is a function that depends only on the coefficient of restitution @xmath5 , and that , for not too inelastic systems reads @xcite @xmath43 in terms of the average number of collisions per particle , @xmath44 , haff s law takes the form : @xmath45 i.e. , the kinetic energy decays exponentially with the number of collisions .
it is a well known result @xcite that the homogeneous cooling state of a granular gas is unstable against long wavelength perturbations . in practice
, this implies that , if the system size is larger than a critical value , @xmath46 , it will spontaneously develop spatial inhomogeneities .
the value of the critical size has also been determined from the boltzmann equation @xcite , and it reads : @xmath47 here , @xmath48 is the homogeneous mean free path , @xmath49 if @xmath2 and @xmath50 if @xmath1 , and @xmath51 is a function of @xmath5 related to the viscosity of a granular gas , whose expression can be found in @xcite .
both md @xcite and dsmc @xcite simulations of freely evolving granular gases show that , in the development of inhomogeneities , first velocity vortices appear in the system and then the density becomes also very inhomogeneous . of course
, once the instability has set in , the velocity distribution of the system will no longer be the one of the hcs .
therefore , one expects the scaling to fail and @xmath39 to become time dependent .
the question is whether the boltzmann equation is valid to describe how the system departs from the hcs .
it might happen that , as pointed out by nakanishi @xcite , the development of velocity correlations are very important from the early stages of this departure , and then the boltzmann equation fails .
this is the main point we want to clarify in this work .
given that we want to check the validity of the boltzmann equation to describe granular gases , we will compare md simulations of initially homogeneous , low density , granular systems with the predictions of the boltzmann equation . since the analytical solution of the latter is not known , we will use the dsmc method developed by bird @xcite to construct numerical solutions of the boltzmann equation under the desired conditions .
it must be remembered that this method mimics the dynamics behind the boltzmann equation by uncouplig the free flow of particles and collisions during a small enough time interval .
besides , collisions are always treated as if there were no correlations between colliding particles . in practice , this implies that space is divided in cells of size smaller than the mean free path , and particles within a cell collide with a probability proportional to their relative velocity .
technical details about the dsmc method have been extensively discussed in the literature @xcite .
the only point we want to stress is that , when using this method , the simulated system is _ by definition _ in the low density limit , where the boltzmann equation is supposed to apply , no matter how many simulated particles there are in a given space region .
the simulations we will present in the following correspond to a two - dimensional system of freely evolving hard disks in a square box of side @xmath52 , larger than the critical size @xmath46 given by eq . (
[ eq : lc ] ) .
periodic boundary conditions will be considered in all the cases . in the md simulations , the event driven algorithm @xcite will be used . for our purposes , it is important to study the effect of lowering the density on the evolution of the system . for that reason , two different , low values , of the density
will be studied in the md simulations , namely @xmath53 and @xmath54 .
nevertheless , it must be noticed that , for a given @xmath5 , changing the density implies changing the critical size of the system , as it follows from ( [ eq : lc ] ) . as a consequence , if the systems have the same size @xmath52 , the characteristic time governing the growth of instabilities will be also changed , and the departure from the hcs will be faster in the denser system .
therefore , if we want to have the same `` distance to stability '' in systems with different densities , their sizes must be changed correspondingly , so @xmath55 remains the same .
the same value of this scaled size should be considered in the dsmc simulations , again to expect the same characteristic time governing the departure from the hcs .
moreover , we have used a fixed value of the restitution coefficient , @xmath56 , which is not too inelastic , but lies outside of what can be considered the quasi - elastic region . for this value of @xmath5 ,
( [ eq : lc ] ) leads to @xmath57 .
as we want the system to be well inside the unstable region , we have chosen the system size to be @xmath58 .
then , for @xmath53 the number of particles in the system was @xmath59 , while for @xmath54 , @xmath60 . in the dsmc simulations ,
@xmath61 particles were considered , but it must be reminded that this number has only a statistical meaning . in all the cases , we started with the particles homogeneously distributed in the system and with a gaussian velocity distribution .
this situation was let to evolve with elastic collisions during several collisions per particle , until the system was equilibrated .
then , the inelasticity was switched on , and this time is taken as the origin , @xmath62 , of our simulations .
the initial elastic period ensures that the structure of the fluid at @xmath62 is the equilibrium one .
as the aim of the paper is to investigate the departure of the velocity distribution of the system from the hcs distribution , this will be one of the properties to be studied in the simulations . to be more precise
, we will compute the second @xmath63 and fourth @xmath64 velocity moments of the total velocity distribution , and from them we will compute also @xmath39 , given by eq .
( [ eq : a2 ] ) .
as far as the system stays in the hcs , @xmath39 will be constant .
it is important to notice that , as in ref .
@xcite , we will study the global velocity distribution of the system , even if inhomogeneities have appeared , causing local averages of the physical quantities to be quite different from their global values . the growth of inhomogeneities will be controlled by following the evolution of the density @xmath65 , and velocity @xmath66 , fields . to compute them ,
the system is divided into 30x30 square cells of size @xmath67 , and properties are averaged in each cell . again , while the system remains in the hcs , @xmath65 should be constant and @xmath68 ( apart from statistical noise ) .
once the instability develops , vortices and also density inhomogeneities will show up .
the question remains of how the departure of the velocity distribution from the hcs one is related to the development of these inhomogeneities .
the possible failure of the molecular chaos hypothesis will be investigated by the study of several collisional averages , i.e. , averages over colliding pairs of particles .
these averages contain information about the two - particle distribution of colliding particles , which is the function whose factorization is assumed in the molecular chaos hypothesis .
the first of the collisional averages we will consider is the pair distribution function at contact , @xmath69 . in a elastic system , if there are no correlations between colliding particles , as it is in fact assumed by the boltzmann equation , @xmath70 . in the case of a system of inelastic disks , the pair distribution function at contact can be easily computed by using @xcite ( notice that there is a miss - print in the expression for @xmath69 provided in the cited reference ) : @xmath71 where we are summing over all collisions @xmath72 taking place in the interval @xmath73 , and the @xmath19 function implies that we are using the pre - collisional values of the quantities in the sum . when the system is in the hcs , it has been found @xcite that @xmath74 does not depend on time , and takes the value : @xmath75 with @xmath76 the equilibrium elastic pair distribution function at contact , that in the two dimensional case is accurately given by @xcite @xmath77 in our simulations , time will be discretized so the average over collisions in ( [ eq : g ] ) will be done not over the whole simulation time , but over collisions occurring in a given interval . in this way , we can study the evolution of the collisional averages and , in particular , of the pair distribution function at contact . needless to say ,
@xmath78 will only be computed in the md simulations , as in the dsmc method its value is given .
another test of the validity of the molecular chaos hypothesis will be provided by the probability distribution of the impact parameter , @xmath79 , where @xmath80 is the angle formed by the impact relative velocity @xmath81 and the unit vector @xmath13 . in a system of hard disks , and if there are no correlations , the impact parameter is uniformly distributed .
soto et al @xcite measured this distribution in the hcs and found no deviations from uniformity . here , we will consider the same discretization discussed above to construct the distribution of impact parameters in each time interval , and study its possible time dependence .
again , the impact parameter distribution will be studied only in the md simulations , as the dsmc method assumes its uniformity .
the possible velocity correlations will also be studied .
a quantity that has been used to study them is the collisional average @xmath82 defined as @xmath83 with @xmath84 the number of collisions in the interval @xmath73 , and @xmath6 , @xmath7 the particles involved in collision @xmath72 . if there is neither macroscopic velocity field nor velocity correlations in the system , it is @xmath85 . therefore , in the hcs , non - zero values of @xmath86 are a clear signal of the presence of velocity correlations in the system . when the system leaves the hcs
, there is another possible reason for these non - zero values .
the build - up of velocity vortices implies that @xmath87 is different from zero , and then , even if there are no velocity correlations , @xmath86 will be different from zero . let us notice that @xmath82 can be measured both in molecular dynamics and dsmc simulations .
finally , the distribution of the angle @xmath34 formed by the velocities @xmath88 , @xmath89 , of colliding particles , will also be computed .
we are not aware of any analytic expression for this quantity in the elastic case , and , therefore , we will use the initial , elastic part , of the simulations to obtain the elastic distribution of the @xmath34 angle .
the parallelization mechanism inherent to inelastic collisions may cause deviations from this behavior , even in the hcs . in any case , this distribution shows if there is a predominance of collisions between particles moving more or less parallel in the system .
again , this distribution will be measured both in md and dsmc simulations .
it is important to remark the different physical information behind the distributions @xmath90 and @xmath91 .
the former is related to the spatial distribution of the incident flux over colliding particles , while the latter contains only information about the relative direction of the velocities of colliding particles .
the results we will present correspond , as we have already stated , to md and dsmc simulations of a freely evolving system of hard disks with @xmath56 and @xmath58 , i. e. , in conditions such that the hcs is well inside the unstable region . in the following , the mass @xmath3 of the particles will be used as the unit of mass , and the initial kinetic energy as the unit of energy .
the results we will present have been averaged over several trajectories in all the cases in order to improve the statistics . besides , the time evolution of the system will be expressed in terms of the number of collisions per particle , @xmath44 . as the system is prepared in an initially homogeneous situation
, we expect it to stay in the hcs for a transient period , until the instability sets in . from that moment
, the different physical properties will depart from their hcs values . in fig .
[ fig:1 ] we have plotted the evolution of the average kinetic energy per particle , @xmath92 , in the system .
this quantity is proportional to the granular temperature as far as there is no macroscopic velocity field , i.e. , while @xmath93 .
also plotted is haff s law , eq .
( [ eq : haff ] ) , describing the evolution of this property in the hcs . in all the cases
there is an initial period in which the energy follows haff s law and , after that , the average kinetic energy of the system decays slower than in the hcs .
the departure form haff s law occurs sooner in the md simulations than in the dsmc one , but it is important to notice that , if we compare the two md simulations , it occurs sooner in the case of larger density .
therefore , it seems that , although there are differences between the behavior of a finite density granular gas and the predictions of the boltzmann equation , they are smaller the smaller the density
. then , it seems sensible to expect that the boltzmann equation predictions provide indeed the correct picture in the analytic low density limit , @xmath94 .
the evolution of @xmath39 is plotted in figs .
[ fig:2 ] . in fig .
[ fig:2](a ) , the initial evolution of this quantity is shown : there is an initial , very fast , decay from the initial gaussian , @xmath95 , value to the hcs one , followed by a steady period while the velocity distribution of the system remains in the hcs .
the complete time evolution of the system is given in fig .
[ fig:2](b ) . again , in all the cases we observe a similar behavior . after the initial steady period
, @xmath39 grows , reaches a maximum , and afterwards it decays in time .
the approximate duration of the steady period , @xmath96 , is @xmath97 for @xmath53 , @xmath98 for @xmath54 and @xmath99 in the dsmc simulation .
the position of the maximum , @xmath100 , is @xmath101 for @xmath53 , @xmath102 for @xmath54 , and @xmath103 in the dsmc simulation .
the height of the maximum is also larger the larger the density . a first conclusion that can be extracted from figs .
[ fig:2 ] is that the qualitative behavior of @xmath39 that follows from the boltzmann equation is the same found in the md simulations .
besides , the differences between the md simulations and the dsmc one are smaller the smaller the density in the formers , showing again a tendency to the boltzmann behavior in the limit of very low density .
comparison of figs .
[ fig:1 ] and [ fig:2 ] is interesting in order to determine the sensitivity of haff s law to the exact shape of the velocity distribution function .
it is found that , for @xmath104 , when @xmath39 begins to depart from the steady value , the temperature takes the value predicted by haff s law in all the cases , as it is expected .
what it might be surprising is that , at the maximum @xmath100 , the deviations from the haff value are relatively small , the temperature being at most @xmath105 times the haff s value .
this is in agreement with simulations of homogeneous systems of inelastic hard disks , that show that the evolution of the temperature follows quite approximately haff s law , unless the fourth moment of the velocity distribution is very large as compared with the second one @xcite .
once the validity of the boltzmann description as a limit to the behavior of a granular gas for vanishing density has been established ( at least with regards to the behavior of the second and fourth moment of the velocity distribution ) , a natural emerging question is which is the mechanism taking the velocity distribution out of the hcs shape . with that purpose ,
the evolution of the density and velocity fields have been studied .
it must be noticed that , as we expect them to be inhomogeneous , and their spatial distribution changes from one realization to another , these fields can not be averaged over different runs .
let us consider first the evolution of the density field .
in all the cases we observe that the system remains homogeneous during what we have called the steady period , @xmath96 . between @xmath96 and @xmath100
small density inhomogeneities begin to show up , but they are not very significant .
the situation changes from @xmath100 on : there is a very fast growth of density inhomogeneities , and in all the cases , elongated clusters of particles are formed , similar to those observed in previous studies of freely evolving granular systems .
this behavior of the density field is quantified in figs .
[ fig:3 ] and [ fig:4 ] . in the first of the them , the evolution of the dispersion of the density fluctuations , @xmath106 is plotted .
let us notice that this quantity is non - zero even in a homogeneous state , due to statistical noise , and its value in the homogeneous state depends on the number of particles per cell , which is different in each of the simulations .
for that reason @xmath107 has been scaled with its value in the elastic part of the simulation , @xmath108 .
it is observed in the figures that , in all the cases , @xmath107 has not increased much over its elastic value at @xmath109 , but from then on there is a very sharp growth of the density fluctuations as a consequence of the formation of clusters in the system .
a similar behavior is exhibited by the maximum value of the density , @xmath110 , which is plotted in fig .
[ fig:4 ] , scaled with the homogeneous density . while the system is in a homogeneous state , @xmath110 is a measure of the statistical noise .
let us remember that the systems were divided in 30x30 cells to compute the hydrodynamics fields : as the number of particles is smaller in the denser system , the noise in the fields will be larger , and that is the reason why , in the homogeneous part of the evolution , @xmath111 is larger the larger the density .
it must be also pointed out that , once the clustering begins , there is a time interval in which the growth of @xmath110 can be fitted to an exponential , @xmath112 where @xmath113 and @xmath114 are constants whose value is not relevant for the present discussion , and @xmath115 for @xmath116 , @xmath117 for @xmath118 , and @xmath119 in the dsmc simulation .
again , the discrepancies between the boltzmann behavior and the one at finite density are smaller as we lower the density , being the growth rate almost the same for the lower density case and the dsmc simulation . in a freely evolving granular system
, it has been shown that , when using @xmath44 as the time variable , the growth rate of the scaled transversal velocity mode is @xmath120 where @xmath121 is a non - dimensional wave - vector defined as @xmath122 , with @xmath123 the wave - length of the perturbation . in a simulation ,
the maximum allowed wavelength , which is the one that grows faster , is @xmath124 . for the values of the parameters used in this work , the theoretical prediction is @xmath125 .
it has been argued @xcite that the density inhomogeneities growth in a freely evolving granular system is a consequence of the non - linear coupling between the transversal velocity mode and the other hydrodynamic fields , in particular , the density .
if that is indeed the case , the growth rate of the density , at least in its first stages , should be @xmath126 .
here , @xmath127 , which is very close to the value of @xmath128 found in the dsmc and in the md lowest density simulation , confirming once again the picture described above .
this agreement indicates the hydrodynamical character of the density fluctuations in the clustering regime .
the growth of the scaled velocity field has also been followed in our simulations , and we found that vortices begin to develop quite soon in the system . to quantify this ,
we introduce @xmath129 , the scaled average value of @xmath130 , as @xmath131 . again , due to statistical noise , @xmath129 will be different from zero when computed from a simulation , even if there are no fluxes . for that reason , in fig .
[ fig:5 ] we have plotted @xmath129 scaled with its value in the elastic part of the simulation , @xmath132 .
all the simulations show that the velocity field grows from the very early stages of the evolution .
in fact , there is a first part of the growth of @xmath133 , which can be quite well approximated by an exponential , that is common to all the simulations .
after that , there is a saturation effect that translates into deviations from the exponential growth for larger times , occurring sooner the larger the density .
in fact , the saturation occurs for times of the order of @xmath100 , which is the time when the clustering is triggered .
the evolution of the collisional averages in the system has been computed by discretizing the time in intervals @xmath134 .
properties are averaged over collisions taking place in each interval .
also , all the results have been averaged over several runs . in fig .
[ fig:6 ] we have plotted the evolution of the pair correlation function at contact , @xmath69 , from the md simulations . also included is the theoretical prediction in the hcs for the two values of the density displayed in the figure , calculated from eq .
( [ eq : ghcs ] ) . in both cases
it is found that , when the velocity distribution begins to depart from the hcs one , i.e. , at @xmath104 , the pair correlation function takes still the hcs value and , in fact , deviations from it are quite small even at @xmath109 .
after that , there is a very fast increase of @xmath69 due to the formation of clusters in the system .
therefore , the increase in @xmath39 shown in fig .
[ fig:2 ] is not due to the development of positional correlations of colliding particles .
these correlations do appear , but at rather later times .
we have also investigated the evolution of the impact parameter distribution , @xmath90 and found that in none of the md simulations discussed in this work it deviated significantly from uniformity for the times shown in this manuscript .
velocity correlations were investigated through the behavior of @xmath86 defined in eq .
( [ eq : gam ] ) , and of the distribution function of the angle formed by the velocities of colliding particles , @xmath34 . in fig
. [ fig:7 ] , the evolution of @xmath86 for the three simulations is shown .
it must be noticed that , in a finite system , even if there are no correlations , @xmath86 takes a finite value that depends on the number of particles , which is different in the three cases .
so , even in the elastic part of the simulation , @xmath86 is different in each case , being larger in the denser system , as it has less particles . besides
, the value of @xmath86 is different in a elastic system and in a inelastic one in the same conditions .
therefore , when the inelasticity is switched on at @xmath62 , there is a very fast increase of @xmath86 to its hcs value .
then , there is a quite steady period that lasts longer the lower the density , followed by an almost exponential increase of @xmath86 .
it is found that the growth rate in this period depends on the density , becoming larger as @xmath135 decreases .
finally , there is a slowing down in the increase of @xmath86 , and it seems that it saturates in the end to a value which is larger the larger the density . also the slowing down begins sooner the larger the density . in any case , we find again that by lowering the density in the md simulations , the behavior of the system approaches the one predicted by the boltzmann equation .
one could be tempted to conclude that the increase of @xmath86 is due to the development of correlations between velocities of colliding particles , this happening from the early stages of the evolution of the system .
but one must be cautious when interpreting this result .
let us remember that in our system a velocity field is also being built up from the beginning of the evolution , as it was shown in fig .
[ fig:5 ] , and this leads to an increase in the value of @xmath86 that has nothing to do with the failure of the factorization of the two - particle distribution function of colliding particles , i.e. , with a violation of the molecular chaos hypothesis .
in fact , the behavior of @xmath86 displayed in fig .
[ fig:7 ] is quite reminiscent of the one of the fluctuations of the velocity field .
also , in the dsmc simulation , it must be taken into account that the molecular chaos hypothesis is assumed in the very basis of the algorithm , so the increase of @xmath86 in that case can not be due to the presence of pre - collisional velocity correlations .
we conclude then that the growth of @xmath86 displayed in fig .
[ fig:7 ] is due to the instability of the scaled transversal velocity mode , that leads to the formation of vortices and , as a consequence , the velocities of colliding particles become more and more parallel .
the existence of the parallelization mechanism is investigated also by studying the evolution of the distribution of the angle formed by the velocities of colliding particles , @xmath136 . in fig .
[ fig:8 ] this distribution is plotted at different times for the md simulation with @xmath118 .
we have included the distribution at @xmath137 , which is constructed from the elastic part of the simulation .
while the system remains in the hcs , the distribution of the @xmath34 angle is indistinguishable from the elastic one , so there are no apparent angle correlations in this part of the evolution of the system .
the situation changes at @xmath138 ( @xmath98 in this case ) , when deviations from the elastic distribution begin to show up .
the relative number of collisions with larger relative angles of the velocity begin to decrease with respect to the elastic case . as time proceeds ,
this tendency becomes stronger , and for the final times considered in the simulation , most of the collisions correspond to particles that are moving almost parallel .
the distortion of the angle distribution begins precisely at the time when the kurtosis of the total velocity distribution begins to depart from the hcs value .
it seems sensible to conclude then that the behavior of the velocity distribution of the system is a consequence of the parallelization mechanism , which is inherent to inelastic collisions , and that , when the system is unstable , induces a collective behavior of the velocities of particles , that translates into a departure of the velocity distribution from the hcs one .
the qualitative behavior of @xmath136 discussed for @xmath118 also holds for the larger density md simulation and for the dsmc one .
of course , the deviation from the elastic distribution occurs sooner the larger the density , but it is also present in the boltzmann description . to have a clear picture of the parallelization of the velocities of colliding particles in the three cases , in fig .
[ fig:9 ] we have plotted the evolution of @xmath139 in the three simulations . the value of this quantity in an equilibrium , elastic fluid , is @xmath140 . in the three cases ,
the system remains with the elastic value of @xmath139 during what we called the steady period , and then it begins to decrease with time , indicating that there is a tendency to have more collisions with velocities that form a small angle .
it must be also remembered that , in the md simulations , the impact parameter distribution did not show deviations from uniformity for the times considered in this work .
the simulation of a system on freely evolving hard disks in conditions such that the hcs is unstable shows that the boltzmann description provides a valid picture for the behavior of a low density granular gas .
this has been established by showing that there are no qualitative differences between the results obtained in low density md simulations and those that follow by using the dsmc method .
it has been shown that , when the density is lowered in the suitable way in the md simulations , i.e. , leaving the characteristic time for the development of instabilities unchanged , the behavior of the system tends to the boltzmann one . nevertheless , it is also true that the deviations from the boltzmann behavior are larger in a system in these conditions of instability than in a stable one , for the same values of the density and restitution coefficient .
the reason for this seems to be that , when the hcs in unstable , there is a parallelization of velocities of colliding particles that is more efficient the higher the density , although it is also present in the boltzmann description .
the role of the spatial correlations between colliding particles has been investigated in this work by studying the pair distribution at contact and the probability distribution of impact parameters .
the former only deviate from the hcs value when density inhomogeneities are already developed in the system , while the latter remains always uniform .
this implies that , in a low density granular gas , the development of spatial correlations does not play a significant role in the early departure from the hcs .
the above results seem to indicate that , when trying to extend the inelastic boltzmann equation to finite higher density , the effect of velocity correlations between colliding particles must be incorporated .
at least , in the physical situation considered in this paper , velocity correlations become important quite before the system develops significant spatial correlations , as measured by the pair distribution function at contact .
it is sensible to expect that this effect increases as the inelasticity of the system increases .
if this picture were right , kinetic equations for inelastic dense gases should not be based on enskog - like equations , taking into account only spatial correlations , but new approximations incorporating the effect of velocity correlations in the precollisional sphere are needed .
this implies a rather strong departure from the traditional methods of kinetic theory for elastic systems . | the departure of a granular gas in the instable region of parameters from the initial homogeneous cooling state is studied .
results from molecular dynamics and from direct monte carlo simulation of the boltzmann equation are compared .
it is shown that the boltzmann equation accurately predicts the low density limit of the system . the relevant role played by the parallelization of the velocities as time proceeds and the dependence of this effect on the density
is analyzed in detail . |
the tremendous progress in the field of quantum electrodynamics ( qed ) with solid - state superconducting circuits @xcite has recently triggered massive efforts aiming at the investigation of propagating quantum microwaves @xcite . towards this end ,
the analysis of propagating microwave light at frequencies of a few gigahertz and with power levels below a single photon on average has become an important task .
however , due to the low signal energy of typically only a few attowatt per megahertz bandwidth , the measurement of such signals requires amplification . for a long time , phase - insensitive high electron mobility transistor ( hemt ) amplifiers are considered as a good choice .
they feature a broad operation bandwidth , high gain , but still add 10 - 20 noise photons @xcite to the signal .
this noise can be significantly reduced by using josephson parametric amplifiers ( jpa ) @xcite , which achieve amplification via a high - frequency modulation of a josephson inductance . in the phase - insensitive or non - degenerate operation mode ,
the jpa noise temperatures approach the standard quantum limit dictated by the heisenberg uncertainty relation @xcite .
even better , jpas can in principle amplify a single signal quadrature without adding any noise @xcite .
this property is intimately connected to the fact that a jpa can squeeze a single quadrature below the level of the vacuum fluctuations .
hence , in combination with lately developed state reconstruction methods for propagating quantum microwaves @xcite , a jpa is the ideal tool to study the rich physics of squeezed microwave states .
recently , the squeezed vacuum generated by the jpa investigated in this work was successfully used to generate distributable path entanglement @xcite .
in addition , squeezing is considered as a key ingredient for the creation of quantum memories for entangled continuous - variable states@xcite . here
, we present a comprehensive study on the squeezing physics produced by a flux - driven jpa @xcite . the particular advantage of this design is the large isolation between the pump and signal ports .
for this reason , the elimination of the pump tone becomes obsolete @xcite and , thus , experimental complexity is greatly reduced . after characterizing the basic properties of our jpa with a spectroscopy setup and a standard homodyne detection scheme , we reconstruct the wigner functions of the jpa output states using dual - path cross - correlation techniques @xcite .
the latter allows us to investigate squeezed vacuum , squeezed thermal and squeezed coherent states .
we find a maximum squeezing of @xmath1 and confirm that the dependence of photon number and displacement on the squeezed and coherent state angle follow the expectations from theory .
in addition , a detailed noise analysis shows that our jpa is operated near the quantum limit in the phase - insensitive mode and that its noise temperature is below the standard quantum limit in the degenerate mode .
all in all , our work illuminates in unprecedented detail the fundamental physics of single - mode squeezing in the microwave domain .
the paper is organized as follows : in section [ section_jpa_characterization ] , we discuss the characterization of the flux - driven jpa using spectroscopy and homodyne detection . after introducing sample and measurement setups ,
we analyze signal and idler gain , the associated bandwidths , compression effects , and the noise properties in non - degenerate mode .
next , we investigate in section [ section_squeezing ] the squeezing of vacuum and thermal states with both homodyne detection and the dual - path state reconstruction method . in section [ section_squeezed_coherence ] ,
we extend our discussion to squeezed coherent states by operating the jpa in the degenerate mode with coherent input signals . after discussing the jpa noise properties in the degenerate mode based on dual - path measurements in section [ section_noise ] ,
we summarize our main results and give a short outlook in section [ section_conslusions ] .
in this subsection , we describe the operation principle of a flux - driven jpa in general and our sample in particular .
a parametric amplifier is an oscillator whose resonant frequency is modulated periodically in time . in the case of the jpa ,
the oscillating system is a quarter - wavelength transmission line resonator whose resonant frequency is determined by its capacitance and inductance ( see figure [ fig : operation principle](a ) ) .
the latter can be varied by a dc superconducting quantum interference device ( squid ) , which consists of a superconducting loop interrupted by two josephson junctions and acts as a flux - dependent non - linear inductor .
thus , by modifying the magnetic flux @xmath2 threading the squid loop , the resonant frequency can be adjusted ( see figure [ fig : operation principle](b ) ) . by fitting a physical model to the experimental data ( black squares )
, we can estimate a josephson coupling energy @xmath3 for each junction , where @xmath4 is the planck constant .
the slightly different values compared to those in the supplementary material of @xcite result from the fact that , here , we employ a more sophisticated distributed - element model @xcite instead of a simple lumped - element approach . periodically varying the resonant frequency with an ac flux ( pump tone ) at @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is the operation point frequency , results in parametric amplification :
a signal at @xmath7 impinging at the signal port is amplified by the signal gain @xmath8 and reflected back out of the signal port . at the same time , an idler mode at @xmath9 is created , whose amplitude is determined by the intermodulation gain @xmath10 .
this operation principle is depicted in figure [ fig : operation principle](c ) .
if the incoming signal consists of vacuum fluctuations , this process is the analogue of parametric downconversion in optics , where a pump photon is split into a signal and an idler photon .
therefore , strong quantum correlations between the signal and idler mode are established which finally result in squeezing .
an optical micrograph of the sample is shown in figure [ fig : sample ] .
the resonator and antenna are patterned from a sputtered @xmath11 thick nb film . at the contacts , @xmath12 of gold
is deposited on top of a @xmath13 titanium bonding layer . as substrate
we use thermally oxidized ( @xmath14 ) silicon with a thickness of @xmath15 . in the last step ,
the aluminum dc squid is fabricated using shadow evaporation @xcite .
each al electrode has a thickness of @xmath11 .
the sample chip is placed between two alumina printed circuit boards inside a gold - plated copper box . the spectroscopy setup used to characterize the jpa and the homodyne setup to detect squeezing
are sketched in figure [ fig : setup ] . in jpa characterization and homodyne measurements , the same cryogenic setup ( see figure [ fig : setup](a ) ) is used .
the sample is anchored to the sample stage of a dilution refrigerator and its temperature ranges between @xmath16 and @xmath17 .
the signal , generated either by a microwave source or a vector network analyzer ( vna ) , passes a series of warm ( -40 to -@xmath18 ) and cold attenuators ( @xmath19 ) as shown in figure [ fig : setup](a ) .
the signal power levels stated in this work are referred to the output of the 30-attenuator in figure [ fig : setup](a ) , while the pump power level is estimated at the input of the jpa sample box .
the transmission from the @xmath20-attenuator output to the spectrum analyzer has been determined by sweeping the temperature of the @xmath20-attenuator and measuring the power of the emitted black body microwave radiation @xcite .
we subtract this value from the total transmission between the microwave source output and the spectrum analyzer to calibrate for the loss of the input line . for signal and idler gain measurements
, a coherent signal is fed through the attenuated input line via the measurement circulator to the jpa .
this circulator separates the outgoing from the incoming signal and protects the jpa from the noise generated by the amplification chain .
the amplified output signal can be detected by a vna or a spectrum analyzer ( see figure [ fig : setup](b ) ) .
the vna allows to investigate the complex reflection coefficient of the jpa .
the spectrum analyzer is used to investigate the idler gain and the degenerate operation of the jpa ( see subsection [ sec : degenerate gain ] ) . figure [ fig : setup](c )
shows the homodyne receiver used in the squeezing measurements presented in section [ section_squeezing ] .
it consists of a local oscillator microwave source and a mixer which downconverts the signal and idler modes onto the same intermediate frequency ( if ) .
the resulting interference reveals the strong correlations established between the idler and signal modes .
if the interference is destructive , fluctuations can be squeezed below the level of the vacuum fluctuations . the first step in characterizing
the jpa is to determine a suitable operating point . to this end
, we measure the signal gain with a vna while synchronously sweeping the pump tone , fulfilling the relation @xmath21 .
since the vna measurement bandwidth of @xmath22 is much smaller than @xmath23 , only the signal mode is detected preventing interference effects present in the degenerate mode .
we emphasize that this measurement is different from the signal bandwidth measurements discussed in subsection [ subsection_the bandwidth ] , where the pump tone is at a fixed frequency and only the signal frequency is swept . in figure
[ fig : operation point ] , we have plotted the measured signal gain when synchronously sweeping the pump and signal frequency for different flux values . for lower frequencies , the signal gain is increasing because the dependence of the resonant frequency on the flux becomes steeper ( see also figure [ fig : operation principle](b ) ) .
we choose our operating point @xmath6 between @xmath24 and @xmath25 , depending on the measurement .
as it can be seen from figure [ fig : operation point ] , our operation point is located in the center of a region where the signal gain is appreciable and its frequency dependence is well behaved . at this operation frequency , the external quality factor is measured as @xmath26 , and the isolation between antenna and resonator is at least @xmath27 .
when the signal frequency is detuned from half the pump frequency , signal and idler modes are at different frequencies and can be observed individually .
this mode of operation is therefore called `` non - degenerate mode '' .
figure [ fig : gain pump power ] shows the pump power dependence of the non - degenerate signal and idler gain for a detuning of @xmath23 . for low pump power , no significant signal gain is observed and the idler gain is small . for large pump power , the two curves converge and both idler and signal gain reach @xmath28 .
besides the gain properties described above , bandwidth is an important feature of an amplifier .
therefore , we determine the instantaneous bandwidth of signal and idler modes at a fixed operation point ( constant flux and pump frequency ) by measuring the signal and idler gain for various detuning between half the pump frequency @xmath29 and the signal frequency @xmath30 .
as shown in figure [ fig : bandwidth pump ] , we observe a signal and idler bandwidth of @xmath31 for a pump power of @xmath32 .
we define the gain - bandwidth - product ( gbp ) , which is defined as the product of the voltage gain in linear units and the bandwidth of our amplifier . in the large gain limit ,
the gbp is nearly constant and close to the theoretical limit of @xmath33 @xcite ( see figure [ fig : bandwidth pump](c ) ) .
going to low values of the signal gain , the idler gain vanishes and the signal gain approaches one because the signal gain is normalized to the pump - off condition .
therefore , we expect the idler gbp to decrease and signal gbp to increase .
however , in the low gain limit the signal bandwidth measurement is very sensitive to the calibration data and fluctuations . consequently , the signal gbp does not diverge in contrast to expectations from theory .
another important figure of merit for amplifiers is their @xmath34-compression point .
it denotes the power where the signal gain is @xmath34 below the value expected for a perfectly linear device @xcite . in other words , at some point the signal gain starts to decrease as a function of input power due to the nonlinearity of the amplifier . in figure [ fig : compression](a ) bandwidth measurements of the signal gain are displayed .
in contrast to figure [ fig : bandwidth pump ] , here the pump power is fixed at -39@xmath35 and the dependence on the signal power is studied . for small signal powers ( @xmath36 )
the curves overlap meaning that the gain is constant and that the amplifier is in the linear regime . for larger signal powers
a reduction of the gain is observed .
figure [ fig : compression](b ) shows the maxima of the signal gain of figure [ fig : compression](a ) for several signal powers .
the @xmath34-compression point occurs at @xmath37 .
an analogous analysis for the idler gain ( data not shown ) reveals that the compression occurs for both the idler and signal gain at the same input power . for a circuit qed experiment with a cavity decay rate of @xmath38 , this power level is equivalent to 10 photons on average .
a low noise temperature of an amplifier is very important when using it for measuring signals at the quantum level . here
, we use the spectroscopy setup for a rough characterization of the noise properties of our jpa when it is operated in the phase - insensitive mode . for details on the noise temperature in the degenerate mode
, we refer to section [ section_noise ] . in order to determine the jpa noise properties , we measure the amplified noise power emitted by the @xmath20-attenuator
, whose temperature is controlled in the range @xmath39 .
the total noise power @xmath40 at the spectrum analyzer is given by @xmath41 + k_{\rm b}t_{\rm total}\right\ } , \label{eq : boseplanck}\ ] ] where @xmath8 denotes the total gain , @xmath42 the detection bandwidth , @xmath43j@xmath44s the planck constant , @xmath45 the boltzmann constant and @xmath46 the total noise temperature of the complete detection chain , which includes the measurement circulator , the jpa and the amplification chain .
@xmath46 is related to the number of photons @xmath47 added by the complete detection chain by @xmath48 .
the first term in ( [ eq : boseplanck ] ) describes thermal fluctuations and vacuum fluctuations according to @xcite .
possible deviations between the electronic temperature of the attenuator and the measured temperature are taken into account by @xmath49 .
we set the signal gain to @xmath50 at the operation point @xmath6 .
however , sample heating due to the pumping process and compression effects at high noise source temperatures may cause the signal gain to deviate from this value . therefore
, we measure the dependence of the gain - corrected power on the noise source temperature @xmath51 ( see figure [ fig : noise temperature ] ) . to this end , we implement the following protocol for each temperature point : after measuring the signal gain with the vna , we turn off the vna and measure the total noise power using a spectrum analyzer .
we obtain the gain corrected power by dividing the total noise power at each temperature point by the effective jpa gain for white uncorrelated noise , @xmath52 . here
, we consider the idler gain using @xmath53 @xcite .
taking into account the cable and connector losses between the noise source and the measurement circulator , we estimate @xmath54 , which corresponds to @xmath55 for the noise photons added by the whole detection chain referred to the input of the measurement circulator . this value is close to the standard quantum limit for phase - insensitive amplifiers of 0.5 photons ( @xmath56 ) .
in addition , we find @xmath57 to be reasonably small . in order to demonstrate the usability of our jpa as a phase - dependent amplifier
, we investigate the degenerate gain . in this mode of operation , the pump frequency is twice the signal frequency .
thus , the idler mode is created at the frequency of the amplified signal mode .
this results in an interference of the two modes which is constructive or destructive depending on the phase between the idler and the signal modes , which can be controlled by shifting the phase difference between the probe signal and the pump tone .
the degenerate gain is measured with a spectrum analyzer , where a measurement with zero pump power is used as a reference . in figure [ fig : degenerate gain ] , the degenerate gain is plotted as a function of the phase between the probe signal and the pump for different pump power levels .
we observe a maximum degenerate gain of @xmath58 and a maximum deamplification of @xmath59 .
the former value is consistent with the signal and idler gain of @xmath28 ( see sec .
[ subsection_the nondegenerate gain ] ) , since the constructive interference of equal amplitudes results in a @xmath60 increase of gain .
[ sec : degenerate gain ]
as mentioned in the discussion of the operation principle ( subsection [ subsection_sample ] ) , the jpa creates quantum correlations between the signal and idler modes . in the degenerate operation mode
, these correlations result in deamplification or amplification depending on the quadrature direction . in the case of deamplification
, the quadrature fluctuations can be squeezed below those of the vacuum . in this section ,
we investigate squeezed vacuum fluctuations generated by the flux - driven jpa with two different detection techniques : homodyne detection and dual - path state reconstruction @xcite . to define the squeezing level @xmath61 in decibel
, we compare the variance of the squeezed quadrature @xmath62 with the quadrature variance of vacuum fluctuations , obtaining @xmath63\}.\ ] ] we note that @xmath64 indicates squeezing and @xmath61 is positive .
larger @xmath61 corresponds to a higher squeezing level .
@xmath65 indicates no squeezing and @xmath61 equals zero .
hence , in this work we use the nomenclature that the term `` squeezing '' is equivalent to `` squeezing below the vacuum level '' .
first , we detect the output signal of the jpa with the homodyne detector shown in figure [ fig : setup](c ) . by sweeping the temperature of the @xmath20-attenuator from @xmath66 to @xmath67 with inactive jpa
, we calibrate the gain and the noise temperature of the detection chain using ( [ eq : boseplanck ] ) .
then , we cool the attenuator to @xmath68 and investigate the squeezed vacuum state . in figure
[ fig : squeezing](a ) , the ratio @xmath69 is plotted as a function of the relative phase between the pump and the local oscillator and the detected intermediate frequency @xmath70 .
the latter is obtained by downconverting the signal using a fixed local oscillator frequency @xmath71 . for these settings , signals at @xmath72 and @xmath73 , representing the signal and idler modes ,
are downconverted to the same intermediate frequency @xmath70 . therefore , the homodyne detector is sensitive to the correlations between the two modes created by the jpa . here , @xmath74 and @xmath75 are the power spectral densities recorded with the jpa pump power on and off , respectively . in figure
[ fig : squeezing](b ) , the average @xmath76 of @xmath77 calculated in the frequency range @xmath78 is plotted . whenever @xmath79 , the noise detected at the spectrum analyzer referred to the input of the amplification chain
is smaller than the vacuum noise emitted by the attenuator .
this demonstrates the effect of vacuum squeezing . from the minimal value @xmath80 indicated in the inset of figure [ fig : squeezing](b ) , we calculate the squeezing level @xcite @xmath81.\ ] ] here , @xmath82 is the noise temperature of the detection chain with the jpa off . taking into account the cable losses , reference spectrum fluctuation and thermal population at the input of the jpa , we retrieve a lower bound of @xmath83 of squeezing at the input of the amplification chain .
the estimation of the squeezing level with the homodyne detection setup only yields a lower bound for the amount of squeezing . rather than improving this setup , we choose to fully reconstruct the squeezed state emitted by the jpa with the dual - path setup , which is based on cross - correlation techniques and realtime data processing @xcite .
first , we introduce the dual - path setup in figure [ fig : dp setup ] .
we split the signal under study described by the bosonic annihilation and creation operators @xmath84 and @xmath85 using a microwave beam splitter and feed them into two amplification and detection paths . during the splitting process vacuum fluctuations
are added to the split signals .
while the signal is emitted from our jpa sample , the vacuum fluctuations are realized by terminating the other input port of the beam splitter with a broadband @xmath86 load . at the two output ports , we first amplify the signals using cold hemt and room temperature amplifiers and
then downconvert them to an intermediate frequency ( if ) of @xmath87 using iq - mixers .
the resulting orthogonal quadrature signals @xmath88 and @xmath89 are then digitized by four analog - digital - converters ( adcs ) , and processed in real time by a field programmable gate array ( fpga ) logic . based on the beam splitter relations and the fact that the noise contributions from two detection paths are independent , we get access to all quadrature moments of signal and the two detection paths up to fourth order . in the setup
, we still have the same temperature - controllable @xmath20-attenuator at the end of the jpa input line to calibrate the photon number conversion factors which relate the autocorrelations measured in our detector ( in units of @xmath90 ) to photon numbers at the input of the beam splitter .
after post - processing the ensemble averages of the noisy quadrature moments , the reconstructed signal and noise moments have the form of @xmath91 and @xmath92 , respectively . here ,
@xmath93 and @xmath94 represent annihilation and creation operators of the noise mode in the detection path 1 and path 2 , and @xmath95 , @xmath96 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 @xmath99 , with @xmath100 and @xmath101 . following @xcite , with the third and fourth moments we calculate the third and fourth order cumulants to verify the gaussianity of the state .
furthermore , we use the first two moments to reconstruct the signal wigner functions at the input of the beam splitter . at the same time , the noise moments of the two detection paths are obtained .
we find that the detection chains add @xmath102 and @xmath103 photons referred to the beam splitter input which corresponds noise temperatures of @xmath104 and @xmath105 for the detection path 1 and path 2 , respectively .
again , the error bars we provide are of purely statistical nature . in all dual - path experiments ,
the temperature of the jpa sample is stabilized at @xmath66 . selected wigner
function reconstructions of the state at the input of the beam splitter are plotted in figure [ fig : wigner ] . when the @xmath20-attenuator is stabilized at @xmath66 ,
vacuum fluctuations are present at the input of the jpa .
as shown in figure [ fig : wigner](a ) , the increase in pump power , which corresponds to an increase of signal gain , causes an increase of the squeezing level and an increase of the photon number ( see also figure [ fig : sqdb](a ) ) .
we achieve a maximum squeezing level of @xmath1 below vacuum at @xmath0 signal gain .
however , if we further increase the signal gain , the squeezing level decreases again . this behavior is expected @xcite because the squeezing becomes suppressed when the jpa enters the bifurcation regime . in this regime ,
also the higher order cumulants do not vanish anymore .
indeed , we observe this effect in our data for signal gains larger than @xmath0 .
in addition , from the jpa input output relation @xcite we identify the signal voltage gain in the non - degenerate mode in linear units as @xmath106 . applying this relation ,
we obtain from the photon number of a squeezed state , @xmath107 , the expression @xmath108 , where @xmath109 is the signal power gain in linear units .
therefore , we expect that the photon number increases linearly with @xmath110 in the non - degenerate mode with a slope of one .
figure [ fig : sqdb](b ) confirms this behavior for small signal gains below the bifurcation regime .
next , we fix the signal gain at @xmath34 .
when the temperature of the @xmath20-attenuator is increased ( see figure [ fig : wigner](b ) and figure [ fig : sqdb](c ) ) , more and more thermal photons are incident at the input port of the jpa . thus the squeezing level decreases and at some point the output state of the jpa is not squeezed below vacuum any more .
-attenuator is at @xmath66 .
the lines are guides to the eyes .
( b ) photon number as a function of signal power gain in linear units .
green dashed line : linear fit .
inset : signal gain range equivalent to that shown in panel ( a ) . the two data points with the largest signal gain are excluded from the fit .
( c ) squeezing level ( ) and photon number ( ) plotted as a function of the @xmath20-attenuator temperature for @xmath34 signal gain .
the lines are guides to the eyes .
all error bars are of statistical nature . ]
[ fig : sqdb ]
in addition to the squeezed vacuum and squeezed thermal states discussed in the previous section , we here analyze a more general squeezed state : the squeezed coherent state .
there are two ways to obtain a squeezed coherent state .
first , one can squeeze the vacuum state @xmath111 and apply a displacement operation @xmath112 . here , @xmath113 denotes the complex squeeze parameter @xmath114 with squeeze factor @xmath97 and squeezing angle @xmath115 .
second , one can apply a displacement operator on the vacuum state @xmath116 , and subsequently squeeze this displaced vacuum @xmath117 .
we define the coherent phase @xmath118 as the angle between displacement direction and @xmath119-axis , and the anti - squeezed angle @xmath120 as the angle between the anti - squeezed quadrature and the @xmath119-axis .
we illustrate the difference of the two methods in figure [ fig : squeezed coherent theory ] . for the former method ,
the final displacement of the squeezed coherent state only depends on the displacement operation and is independent of the squeeze factor @xmath97 ( figures [ fig : squeezed coherent theory](a)(c ) )
. however , the displacement of the squeezed coherent state obtained from the second method depends on both the displacement and squeezing operations . when the anti - squeezed quadrature is parallel to the displacement direction of a coherent state , the final displacement of the squeezed coherent state is maximum ( figure [ fig : squeezed coherent theory](d ) ) .
contrary , the final displacement reaches its minimal value when the anti - squeezed quadrature is perpendicular to the displacement direction ( figure [ fig : squeezed coherent theory](e ) ) . in this section
, we present an analysis on squeezed coherent states generated with the second method and detected with the dual - path setup . to this end , we pump the jpa in the presence of a weak coherent signal .
one measurement trace always records four regions : vacuum ( v ) region with both jpa pump and coherent signal off , coherent signal ( c ) region with jpa pump off and coherent signal on , squeezed coherent ( sc ) region with both jpa pump and coherent signal on , and squeezed vacuum ( sv ) region with jpa pump on and coherent signal off .
figure [ fig : timetrace ] shows typical averaged time traces of selected first and second moments from a single measurement , which corresponds to the situation in figure [ fig : squeezed coherent theory](f ) .
four wigner function reconstructions are placed on top of the time trace . when both jpa pump and coherent signal are off , we can clearly identify the vacuum wigner function with its maximum centered at the origin .
once we turn on the coherent signal , which is a displacement operation , the vacuum state is equally displaced along @xmath119- and @xmath121-quadratures and becomes a coherent state with phase @xmath122 referred to the beam splitter input .
next , keeping the coherent signal on , we turn on the jpa pump which gives a squeezing operation with the @xmath119-quadrature as the squeezed quadrature and the @xmath121-quadrature as the anti - squeezed quadrature ( @xmath123 ) .
this results in a suppression of the displacement of the state along the @xmath119-quadrature and a corresponding amplification of the displacement along the @xmath121-quadrature .
also the @xmath119-quadrature variance is squeezed and the @xmath121-quadrature variance is amplified , turning the circular profile of the vacuum and coherent state wigner function into an elliptic profile .
thus , the state becomes a squeezed coherent state with squeezing level @xmath61@xmath124 .
finally , keeping the pump on , we turn off the coherent signal to generate a squeezed vacuum state with squeezing level @xmath61@xmath125 . in this context , we would like to point to the following experimental aspect . compared with a coherent state , whose phase @xmath126 is referred to the beam splitter input , in the case of a squeezed coherent state , we use @xmath118 as the phase of the coherent state before applying the squeezing operator , and @xmath118 is referred to the jpa input . during the propagation of the coherent state from the input of the jpa to the input of the beam splitter ,
the phase of the coherent state evolves .
we account for this effect by a constant phase difference @xmath127 .
we note that the angle @xmath128 always refers to the squeezed vacuum state recorded in each measurement trace . from theory @xcite
, we expect the displacement of a squeezed coherent state after the squeeze operation to depend on the angles as @xmath129 here , @xmath130 $ ] is the complex amplitude of the coherent state before the squeeze operation and @xmath131 the angle of the complex squeeze parameter . by fixing the anti - squeezing angle of squeezed vacuum states
@xmath128 at @xmath132 , @xmath133 , @xmath134 , and @xmath135 and rotating the phase @xmath126 of the coherent signal , we map out the dependence of the displacement of a squeezed coherent state on @xmath128 and @xmath118 . in figure [ fig : displacement ] , we display the displacement , which is the center of the individual states in phase space given by their first moment @xmath136 for various values of @xmath126 and @xmath128 .
the squeezed vacuum states are centered at the origin , and the coherent states are located on a circle around the origin . if we turn on the jpa pump and rotate the phase of a coherent signal , the squeezed coherent state moves mainly along the @xmath128 direction .
the displacement of the squeezed coherent states reaches its maximum when @xmath137 , where @xmath138 .
geometrically , this means that the anti - squeezed direction is collinear to the displacement vector pointing from the origin to the center of the state . for our choice of @xmath128
, we obtain a characteristic star - shaped pattern .
similar to the center of the wigner function , which represents the displacement , the photon number of a squeezed coherent state varies when we rotate the phase of the coherent signal @xmath126 while keeping the anti - squeezed angle @xmath128 constant . following @xcite
, we obtain : @xmath139 where @xmath140 describes the thermal photons present in the vacuum state at the jpa input and @xmath141 is the number of photons in the coherent state .
as we see from figure [ fig : nphoton ] , the photon number oscillates and reaches a maximum when @xmath137 , @xmath138 .
thus , the photon number is maximal when the displacement of the sc state is maximal .
we emphasize that the various states detected in our experiments are referred to the input of the beam splitter .
to fit to theory , we need to shift the reference plane of the coherent state from the beam splitter input with phase @xmath126 to the jpa input with phase @xmath118 . fitting the experimental data , we retrieve @xmath142 and a squeezing factor @xmath143 .
this @xmath97 value is quite close to the value @xmath144 measured for the individual states . from theory
, we expect that the only difference between a sc state and the corresponding sv state is a displacement in phase space without any rotation or deformation .
therefore , we analyze the statistics of the variances @xmath145 and @xmath62 of the anti - squeezed and squeezed quadratures and that of the angle @xmath128 for the sc and sv states . as displayed in table [ table : scandsvcompare ] , our data show that no significant rotations or deformations are present .
lccc @xmath42 & @xmath146 & @xmath147 & @xmath148 + @xmath145 & 0.43&@xmath149 & @xmath150 + @xmath62 & 0.015 & @xmath151 & @xmath152 + @xmath128 & 0.87 & &
a jpa operated in the degenerate mode can not only generate vacuum squeezing , it can also be used as a low - noise phase - sensitive amplifier which , in principle , does not need to add any noise to the amplified quadrature@xcite . with the dual - path setup
, we therefore study the noise properties of our jpa in the degenerate mode .
more precisely , we perform a temperature sweep of the 30-attenuator shown in figure [ fig : dp setup ] . the variance of the fluctuations at the frequency @xmath6 generated with this procedure is @xmath153 where @xmath154 has the unit of photon number . at each temperature
, the jpa pump is operated in the pulsed mode .
consequently , a single time trace in our measurement always contains a region corresponding to a non - squeezed thermal state and a region corresponding to a squeezed thermal state . for any quadrature
, the variance @xmath155 at the output of the jpa is related to the variance @xmath156 at the input via the relation @xcite @xmath157 here , @xmath158 is the gain for this quadrature and @xmath159 is the noise added by the amplifier referred to the output . in principle
, we could determine the variance of the thermal state at the input of the jpa using the dual - path reconstructed signal moments at the input of the beam splitter taking into account the cable , circulator and jpa losses .
however , the dual - path reconstruction detects a thermal population of 0.1 photons in the vacuum @xcite which would result in a significant underestimation of the jpa noise . for this reason
, we calculate @xmath160 based on ( [ eq : noise ] ) , and model the cable loss between the @xmath20-attenuator output and the measurement circulator input with beam splitters , and account for the temperature gradients . in this way , we model an equivalent amplifier consisting of the measurement circulator , jpa , and cables to the beam splitter input .
the noise contributions of all these components are represented by the noise temperature of the equivalent amplifier .
therefore , the latter is a pessimistic estimate for the noise properties of the jpa itself .
lcc & @xmath158 ( @xmath161 ) & @xmath159 + @xmath162 & @xmath163 & @xmath164 + @xmath165 & @xmath166 & @xmath167 + @xmath159 has the unit of photon number .
+ ( @xmath168 ) differently from the squeezed quadrature , where the added noise refers to the jpa output , this number refers to the jpa input for the anti - squeezed quadrature . in figure
[ fig : noise dp ] , we show the anti - squeezed and squeezed quadrature variance as a function of the noise source temperature . obviously , there is good agreement between theory and experiment .
the corresponding numerical results are displayed in table [ table : noise sum ] .
most importantly , we observe a variance of @xmath169 photons ( referred to the input ) for the noise added by our jpa to the anti - squeezed quadrature .
this value is clearly below the standard quantum limit of 0.25 photons for a single quadrature of a phase - insensitive amplifier .
the relevant noise number for the use of the jpa as a squeezer is the noise it adds to the squeezed quadrature at the jpa output .
we do not refer the added noise from the squeezed quadrature to the input of the equivalent jpa , because systematic uncertainties in the setup @xcite dominate the squeezed quadrature noise variance at the jpa output and would be amplified by @xmath170 when referring to the jpa input . however , these uncertainties are negligible for the anti - squeezed quadrature . instead ,
following @xcite we calculate a lower bound for the squeezed quadrature noise variance at the jpa input from the experimentally more robust quadrature gains @xmath171 and @xmath172 of the squeezed and anti - squeezed quadrature and anti - squeezed quadrature noise variance .
using the values from table [ table : noise sum ] , we obtain the relation @xmath173 , where subscript in " indicates the jpa input .
in summary , we present a detailed analysis of the physics of squeezed microwave light generated with a flux - driven jpa .
we first determine the operation point of the jpa and characterize its basic amplification properties , including non - degenerate gain , bandwidth , @xmath34-compression point and degenerate gain .
we then use the jpa to squeeze vacuum fluctuations and find @xmath1 of squeezing at @xmath0 signal gain .
furthermore , we investigate displacement and photon number of squeezed coherent microwave fields and find excellent agreement with theoretical expectations . in the degenerate mode , we verify that our jpa , as a phase - sensitive device , adds less noise to the amplified quadrature than an ideal phase - insensitive amplifier .
this property is of utmost importance for high efficiency detection , state tomography and quantum communication applications in the microwave domain .
furthermore , with the setup used in this work , i.e. , squeezed states incident at a linear beam splitter , the generation of path entanglement between continuous - variable propagating quantum microwaves was demonstrated in @xcite .
considering recent work on the engineering of tunable beam splitter hamiltonians @xcite , our setup could be extended to the interesting case of dynamical switching between two separable single - mode squeezed states and a path - entangled two - mode squeezed state .
we thank c. probst , k. neumaier and k. uhlig for providing their expertise in cryogenic engineering .
furthermore , we acknowledge financial support from the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft via the sonderforschungsbereich 631 , the german excellence initiative via the ` nanosystems initiative munich ' ( nim ) , from the eu projects solid , ccqed , promisce and scaleqit , from mext kakenhi `` quantum cybernetics '' , the jsps through its first program , the project for developing innovation systems of mext , the nict commissioned research , basque government it472 - 10 , spanish mineco fis2012 - 36673-c03 - 02 and upv / ehu ufi 11/55 .
10 url # 1#1urlprefix[2][]#2 blais a , huang r s , wallraff a , girvin s m and schoelkopf r j 2004 _ phys .
http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physreva.69.062320[*69 * 062320 ] menzel e p , deppe f , mariantoni m , araque caballero m , baust a , niemczyk t , hoffmann e , marx a , solano e and gross r 2010 _ phys . rev .
lett . _ http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.105.100401[*105 * 100401 ] menzel e p , di candia r , deppe f , eder p , zhong l , ihmig m , haeberlein m , baust a , hoffmann e , ballester d , inomata k , yamamoto t , nakamura y , solano e , marx a and gross r 2012 _ phys .
lett . _ http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.109.250502[*109 * 250502 ] mariantoni m , menzel e p , deppe f , araque caballero m , baust a , niemczyk t , hoffmann e , solano e , marx a and gross r 2010 _ phys .
lett . _ http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.105.133601[*105 * 133601 ] baust a 2010 _ characterization of flux - driven josephson parametric amplifiers _ diploma thesis technische universitt mnchen http://www.wmi.badw - muenchen.de / publications / theses / baust , ale% xander_diplomarbeit_2012.pdf[http://www.wmi.badw - muenchen.de / publications / theses / baust , ale% xander_diplomarbeit_2012.pdf ] reuther g m , zueco d , deppe f , hoffmann e , menzel e p , weil t , mariantoni m , kohler s , marx a , solano e , gross r and hnggi p 2010 _ phys . rev .
b _ http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevb.81.144510[*81 * 144510 ] | josephson parametric amplifiers ( jpa ) are promising devices for applications in circuit quantum electrodynamics ( qed ) and for studies on propagating quantum microwaves because of their good noise performance . in this work ,
we present a systematic characterization of a flux - driven jpa at millikelvin temperatures .
in particular , we study in detail its squeezing properties by two different detection techniques . with the homodyne setup
, we observe squeezing of vacuum fluctuations by superposing signal and idler bands . for a quantitative analysis
we apply dual - path cross - correlation techniques to reconstruct the wigner functions of various squeezed vacuum and thermal states . at @xmath0 signal gain , we find @xmath1 squeezing below vacuum .
in addition , we discuss the physics behind squeezed coherent microwave fields . finally , we analyze the jpa noise temperature in the degenerate mode and find a value smaller than the standard quantum limit for phase - insensitive amplifiers . |
multivariate analysis often involves understanding the relationship among variables of different types .
our motivating data set is from the quality in acute stroke care ( qasc ) study , which implemented a multidisciplinary intervention to manage fever , hyperglycaemia and swallowing dysfunction in acute stroke patients @xcite .
this study was one of the largest rigorously evaluated clinical trials which showed that organised stroke unit care significantly reduced death and disability among stroke patients .
there were 19 acute stroke units in new south wales , australia that participated in the study , and they were randomly assigned to an intervention group ( 10 units ) and a control group ( 9 units ) .
a pre - intervention and a post - intervention cohort of patients were recruited , their demographic variables such as age , gender and marital status were obtained , and process of care variables such as temperature , time from onset to hospital and length of stay in hospital were recorded .
the researchers were interested to see if the implementation of the protocols reduced death and dependency , and improved physical and mental health scores .
the four primary outcome variables considered were : ( 1 ) modified rankin scale ( an ordinal variable ranging from 0 to 6 , measuring the degree of disability or dependence in daily activities ) ; ( 2 ) barthel index ( an ordinal variable ranging from 0 to 100 , which also measures performance in activities of daily living .
it is usually reported as a dichotomised variable with 60 or more and 95 or more as cut points ) ; ( 3 ) mean sf-36 mental component summary score ; ( 4 ) mean sf-36 physical component summary score .
mental and physical component summary scores were measured on continuous scales between 0 and 100 . in the qasc study , all the four outcome variables had moderate amounts of missing data and most of the explanatory variables had missing values as well ( table 1 ) . ignoring all the patients with missing values , which is known as complete case analysis , is a commonly used approach to handle missing data but may lead to biased estimates and reduced statistical power .
in other words , the remaining cases may not be representative of the target population if we ignore them completely .
the smaller sample size also decreases the power to detect significant treatment effects . due to the potential for positive dependence among units within the same cluster ,
this is especially serious in multilevel data sets .
case - wise deletion reduces the sample size of patients within hospitals and the number of hospitals at the same time if any information at the hospital level is missing . as a consequence
, both the variations between and within hospitals may not be accurately estimated .
an alternative approach is to ` impute ' missing values , so that after imputation complete data analysis can be performed using standard software .
some ad - hoc procedures include mean imputation and last observation carried forward .
more principled imputation methods are model - based , such as joint modelling @xcite and fully conditional specification @xcite
. current methods to handle missing data are potentially inadequate to apply to the qasc study which is complicated by the clustering effect and the mix of variable types .
@xcite proposed using a semiparametric copula model based on the extended rank likelihood to analyse multivariate data of mixed types .
we extend the work of @xcite by adding random effects to introduce correlation among individuals within clusters . the model in @xcite
can only be used for continuous and ordinal variables , so we consider a multinomial probit model to handle nominal variables .
we then evaluate our model by its ability to recover missing data and estimate the true parameters in some models of interest in both a simulation study and a real data study .
the structure of this manuscript is as follows . in section 2
we briefly summarize some popular multivariate techniques to perform missing data imputation and review the general gaussian copula model and the extended rank likelihood for semiparametric copula estimation as discussed in @xcite . in section 3
we describe this extended rank likelihood with random effects and combine the copula model with a multinomial probit model .
we outline our algorithm to impute missing data in a multilevel data set using our proposed copula model . in section 4 ,
we present and discuss the results of our simulation and real data studies to evaluate our model .
the proposed model is compared against several conventional methods using readily available software packages .
section 5 provides concluding remarks and discusses some future research .
let @xmath0 denote the ` complete ' data , with observed part @xmath1 and missing part @xmath2 .
let @xmath3 denote the parameter describing the ` complete ' data @xmath4 . throughout this paper
we assume the data are missing at random ( mar)@xcite , meaning that the probability of missing an entry only depends on the observed data , not on the entry value itself , so that inference about @xmath5 can be made based on only the observed data @xmath1 , and no extra effort is needed to model the missing data process @xcite .
the mar assumption can not be tested except in artificial simulation settings , however , it is a simplifying assumption which can be made more reasonable by expanding the model to include more variables that are related to the missing data .
data augmentation @xcite is often used as a simulation based computational algorithm to approximate the joint posterior distribution of @xmath6 .
it draws @xmath2 from @xmath7 and @xmath3 from @xmath8 iteratively .
the @xmath3 can be treated as coming from the marginal distribution @xmath9 and the @xmath2 can be treated as coming from @xmath10 , if our interest lies in filling in the missing values to create complete data sets .
having obtained guesses for the missing data from an imputation model ( which will be discussed further below ) , we can not treat them as the ` true ' data because of the uncertainty due to nonresponse .
@xcite proposed multiple imputation ( mi ) to obtain @xmath11 independent draws of @xmath2 from @xmath10 to create @xmath11 complete data sets .
combining rules are then applied to the parameter estimates from each of the @xmath11 complete data sets to obtain a single inferential result , as follows . let @xmath12 be the target population quantity of interest , for example , the coefficients of a regression model .
suppose @xmath13 is the point estimate of @xmath12 from the @xmath14 imputed complete data set and @xmath15 is an associated measure of sampling variance , @xmath16 .
three quantities are required for inference on @xmath12 : @xmath17 the analyst uses @xmath18 as the point estimate of @xmath12 .
the sampling variance of @xmath18 is estimated by @xmath19 .
the total variance associated with @xmath18 is a function of the within imputation variance and the between imputation variance .
next we discuss common approaches to impute missing values .
a good imputation method aims to preserve relationships among survey variables of interest .
the joint modelling ( jm ) approach usually assumes the data follow an elliptical joint distribution , for example , a multivariate normal or a multivariate @xmath20 distribution . for continuous variables
, some transformations may be needed to approximate the assumed distribution @xcite .
discrete variables are treated as if they were generated from the underlying continuous variables and then discretized .
most software packages implement the joint modelling approach by first transforming any variables with missing values into responses that follow a multivariate normal distribution .
the transformed responses are then regressed against the fully observed variables .
the software packages that implement this approach include _ norm _ @xcite and _ amelia _
@xcite in r and proc mi in sas .
other joint modelling techniques include loglinear models and general location models specifically designed for categorical data and mixed data respectively @xcite . another useful package in r - _ pan _
@xcite is designed to impute missing values in panel data , assuming a multivariate gaussian distribution with random effects .
@xcite further extended schafer s multilevel imputation model by allowing for multivariate response variables at all levels of a data hierarchy , and used box - cox type normalizing transformations for continuous non - gaussian responses .
although elliptical distributions allow for parsimonious description of data , they are restrictive in the marginal distributions which are fully determined by the parent joint distribution and are restrictive in capturing complex dependencies among variables . the fully conditional specification ( fcs ) @xcite approach breaks the joint model into a series of univariate regression models .
generalized linear models are often specified to accommodate different types and shapes of variables as well as adding constraints among variables .
this method has been implemented by many software packages , for instance , _ mice _
@xcite and _ mi _ @xcite in r , _ ice _ in stata @xcite and a sas - based software iveware @xcite . to the best of our knowledge ,
there are no available packages to implement the multilevel fully conditional specification except for the ` mice.impute.2l.norm ' function in the _ mice _ package in r , which fits mixed effects linear regression models for variables with missing values . because of the lack of packages for practitioners , some authors have investigated including indicator variables for clusters @xcite in the imputation models or ignore the clustering effects .
the main criticism of the fully conditional methods , however , is the lack of theoretical justification to ensure the univariate conditional distributions converge to a proper joint distribution .
several papers have compared jm and fcs mi , but there is no clear conclusion under which circumstances practitioners should favour one over the other . @xcite
performed simulations under three missing data mechanisms and their results showed that jm and fcs produce similar results despite the data not being multivariate normal .
@xcite not only assessed the accuracy of the coefficients fitted to models of interest , but also the accuracy of imputed values .
their study found that fcs imputed more accurately for categorical variables than jm but the differences were small for continuous variables .
@xcite studied the performance of jm and fcs in multilevel settings , and showed using simulations that fcs mi outperforms jm mi in having less bias , and when the intraclass corrlation is small , more accurate parameter estimates are obtained from both jm and fcs . to provide more flexibility in the marginal distributions while at the same time ensuring a proper joint distribution , we consider copula modelling approaches to impute missing values .
the word ` copula ' means ` a link , tie , bond ' . in mathematics and statistics , it means joining together one - dimensional distribution functions to form a multivariate distribution function . specifically , the distribution functions for the random variables @xmath21 are @xmath22 .
sklar s theorem @xcite shows that there always exists a function @xmath23 , such that , @xmath24 , where the function @xmath23 is called the copula function .
each of the variables is modeled by the marginal distribution @xmath25 , @xmath26 , which is uniformly distributed , and their dependence is captured by the copula function @xmath23 .
copula modelling has proven to be very powerful for modeling variables of different types and shapes , when there is an underlying dependence among them .
it adopts a ` bottom - up ' strategy where the starting point is the marginal distributions @xmath27 , which are then glued together by the copula function @xmath23 . in the ` top down ' joint modelling approach ,
the marginal distributions are fully determined by their parental joint distribution so that there is no flexibility to model them .
in addition , copula models guarantee the existence of a compatible joint distribution which is not guaranteed by the fully conditional specification approach . existing models , like multinomial ( ordered ) probit models for ( ordered ) categorical data can be treated as special cases of copulas , because the underlying latent variables corresponding to each category are assumed to follow a multivariate gaussian distribution @xcite . in a copula model ,
the parameters are the marginal distributions @xmath27 and the copula function @xmath23 .
@xcite developed a fully bayesian estimation procedure to model the joint distribution of both sources of parameters .
however , specifying each of the marginal distributions is labour intensive and variables in real data sets may not be accurately represented without a large number of parameters .
some authors suggested transforming the variables using the empirical distribution @xmath28 to get pseudo data @xcite and avoid the parametric estimation of marginal distributions .
however , this only applies to continuous variables . to link the discrete variables with continuous latent variables ,
@xcite provided a simple way of analysing the correlation among variables with meaningful ordering ( continuous and ordered categorical variables ) , via the extended rank likelihood .
this makes use of the fact that the order of the underlying latent variable is consistent with the observed data , and inference about the association parameters can be drawn from the ` rank - based ' latent variables through a simple parametric form .
the extended rank likelihood has already been applied to other closely related models , for example , a general bayesian gaussian copula factor model proposed by @xcite and a bifactor model considered by @xcite , can be treated as imposing a special structure on the correlation matrix of a gaussian copula .
using the copula model as an imputation engine is relatively new but has drawn some attention in the literature .
@xcite were among the first authors to consider imputation using a gaussian copula where the missing data pattern was monotone .
@xcite found that copula based imputation from the archimedian family compared favourably with nearest neighbour donor imputation and regression imputation by the em algorithm .
@xcite compared the performance of imputation by the copula model using the extended rank likelihood approach @xcite with jm ( as implemented in amelia ) and fcs ( as implemented in mice ) and concluded that the copula imputation approach maintained the prediction accuracy at least as well as the other two approaches but with faster convergence of the sampling algorithm .
among a variety of copulas , we focus on the gaussian copula in this paper . for further theoretical details of copulas , see @xcite and for a good summary of some applications of copulas , see @xcite . rather than assuming a gaussian distribution on the data @xmath4 directly , the gaussian copula specifies a joint multivariate gaussian distribution on the corresponding latent variables as defined next .
let @xmath26 denote the index of the @xmath29 random variable .
then the @xmath29 latent variable is @xmath30 , where @xmath31 .
that is , @xmath32 , where @xmath33 is the cumulative distribution function of the p - variate normal distribution , with mean zero and correlation matrix @xmath34 .
note that the gaussian copula can reach the full range of pairwise correlation ( -1,1 ) and the parameters that need to be estimated only come from the correlation matrix @xmath34 .
@xcite derived a rank - based likelihood to estimate the correlation matrix @xmath34 so that there is no need to specify the marginal distributions @xmath27 .
the idea is that since we know @xmath35 is a monotone transformation , the ordering of data @xmath4 provides partial information about what @xmath36 should be , that is , @xmath37 implies @xmath38 .
suppose we have in total @xmath39 observations , @xmath40 .
observing @xmath41 tells us that @xmath42 must lie in the set : @xmath43 .
let ` @xmath44 ' denote the set of all possible @xmath36 which is consistent with the ordering of @xmath45 . then
the event ` @xmath46 ' can be treated as the observed event upon which inference of @xmath34 is made . the full likelihood can be decomposed as @xmath47 @xcite proved that it is partial sufficient ( in the sense of g - sufficient and l - sufficient ) to carry out inference about @xmath34 based on the density @xmath48 and he referred to it as the ` extended rank likelihood ' .
in doing so , we lose the information about @xmath34 from the density @xmath49 , but we do not need to estimate the potentially complicated marginal distribution functions and the extended rank likelihood provides a more general and flexible framework for joint modelling . to take into account clustering effects , we extend hoff s work by adding random effects to the gaussian copula model at the latent variable level .
the idea is that the clustering of the observed data is carried through to the latent variable level .
our model can be described as @xmath50 where @xmath51 is the group index , @xmath52 is the individual index within group @xmath53 , @xmath54 is a correlation matrix and @xmath55 is a variance - covariance matrix for @xmath56 and @xmath57 . both @xmath56 and @xmath57
are vectors of length @xmath58 , because we are considering @xmath59 variables jointly . in this model ,
the parameters that need to be estimated are in @xmath60 , which can be thought of as splitting the total correlation into two parts , the variability within groups and the variability between groups . however , like any model that relies on the ordering of the data but not their magnitude , model ( [ extended copula ] ) suffers from an identifiability problem without constraints on @xmath54 . to see this ,
if we shift the location of the latent variable @xmath61 by @xmath62 and scale it by @xmath63 , the model remains unchanged because the new latent variables satisfy the order of the observed data as well .
the extended rank likelihood contains only the information about the relative ordering of @xmath36 but no information about their location and scale . to solve the identifiability problem of scale , we fix @xmath54 to be a correlation matrix instead of a covariance matrix . in other words
, there is no need to estimate the variances of @xmath36 conditional on the random effects , so we fix them as 1 .
because the marginal distributions of @xmath36 have mean equal to 0 , there is no identifiability issue for location .
we will briefly describe how to add covariates in the discussion section so that the mean of @xmath36 is no longer 0 .
notice that the extended rank likelihood described above only applies to continuous and ordinal variables , since it makes no sense to consider meaningful numeric values for nominal variables ( categorical variables without ordering ) . to include nominal variables in the copula model as well
, we consider a multinomial probit model @xcite which can be treated as a gaussian copula . the idea is to relate a nominal variable to a vector of latent variables which can be thought of as the unnormalized probabilities of choosing each of the categories .
suppose a single nominal variable @xmath45 has @xmath64 categories , and we define @xmath65 latent variables for unit @xmath53 as @xmath66 which follow a multivariate gaussian distribution .
since all the variables appear on one side and we model them jointly , there are no covariates as predictors for now , therefore we only include the intercept term @xmath67 vector to represent the relative differences between each category @xmath68 compared with the baseline category @xmath64 .
to add a second level to the hierarchy , again we have the random effects @xmath69 in the model @xmath70 the rule of deciding the category is a mapping from the latent variables vector to the observed category . the category @xmath71 is observed if the @xmath72 element of the vector @xmath73 is the largest and greater than 0 ; the last category @xmath64 is observed if the largest element in @xmath73 is smaller than 0 .
we also fix the diagonal elements of @xmath74 equal 1 to be identifiable . to provide a unified framework of multivariate analysis for mixed type variables , we combine model ( [ extended copula ] ) for variables with ordering and model ( [ multinomial probit model ] ) for variables without ordering as follows @xmath75 the correlations between variables @xmath21 and @xmath76 are modelled through the off - diagonal matrices @xmath77 and @xmath78 at the group level and the individual level respectively .
since both @xmath54 and @xmath74 have diagonal elements fixed to be 1 , the big matrix @xmath34 is an identifiable correlation matrix .
a gibbs sampling scheme is constructed to approximate the joint posterior distribution @xmath79 where the unknown quantities in model ( [ combined ] ) are the parameters @xmath80 and the latent variables @xmath81 as well as missing data @xmath82 .
a simple conjugate prior does not exist for a correlation matrix , and we follow the idea in @xcite of employing a parameter expansion approach @xcite to facilitate the mcmc sampling .
specifically , we put an inverse wishart prior on the matrix @xmath83 which is the semi - conjugate prior in a multivariate gaussian sampling model .
then the full conditional distribution of @xmath83 can be derived analytically . after updating @xmath83 in each iteration
, we rescale it to be a correlation matrix @xmath34 . for ease of computation , we put an improper flat prior on @xmath67 and a semi - conjugate inverse wishart prior on @xmath84 , where the hyperparameters are the degrees of freedom @xmath85 and the scale matrix @xmath86 @xmath87 under these priors , it is straightforward to derive the full conditional distributions for the parameters @xmath88 as follows 1 .
@xmath89 ; 2 .
@xmath90 , where @xmath91 + @xmath92}=\tilde \gamma_{[g , h]}/\sqrt{\tilde \gamma_{[g , g]}\tilde \gamma_{[h , h ] } } , g , h=1, ... ,p$ ] , @xmath34 is rescaled from @xmath83 after each sampling ; 3 .
@xmath93 , where @xmath94 .
+ from the joint gaussian distribution of @xmath95 , we can derive the following conditional distributions for the latent variables @xmath96 : 4 .
@xmath97 ; 5 .
@xmath98 ; + @xmath56 and @xmath99 should be sampled from a truncated gaussian distribution and a gaussian distribution under the observed category constraint respectively , see below for details .
@xmath100,where @xmath101 .
the operator @xmath102 is the kronecker product and @xmath103 is the operator that vectorizes a matrix by stacking its columns . updating the latent variable @xmath36
is achieved by sampling from a truncated multivariate gaussian distribution , where the lower and upper bounds for each single entry @xmath104 are determined by : @xmath105 and @xmath106 respectively , and @xmath107 is the index that searches over all the rows in the @xmath29 variable .
for example , the lower bound for @xmath104 is the maximum value of the latent variable @xmath36 in the @xmath29 column whose corresponding @xmath45 is smaller than @xmath108 and the upper bound can be defined accordingly . updating the latent variable @xmath109 is achieved by sampling from a multivariate gaussian distribution under the constraint of the observed category by an acceptance and rejection algorithm @xcite .
specifically , we sample a @xmath109 vector from the multivariate gaussian distribution and accept this draw if and only if the maximum element of @xmath109 occurs at the place of the observed category and is greater than 0 , or all the elements in @xmath109 are smaller than 0 and we observe the reference category @xmath64 . we continue to sample @xmath109 until a draw is accepted .
when there are missing values in @xmath110 , the lower and upper bounds in @xmath36 are undefined , and/or any missing value occurs in @xmath76 , the observed category in @xmath76 does not exist . in these cases ,
we just sample @xmath36 and/or @xmath109 from the multivariate gaussian distributions without the constraints .
to sample missing values for variables with ordering , we apply the monotone transformation on @xmath36 : @xmath111 , l=1, ... ,p$ ] , where @xmath28 is the univariate empirical distribution function of variable @xmath112 . to sample the missing values in nominal variables , we choose the category corresponding to the largest element in @xmath109 if it is greater than 0 , and choose the reference category if the largest element in @xmath109 is smaller than 0 .
we evaluated the performance of the proposed model through two simulation studies : ( i ) simulated artificial data with missing values and ( ii ) the qasc data set with randomly deleted records .
we compared the proposed imputation model with other commonly used procedures to treat missing data .
we generated 100 complete multilevel data sets with correlated variables of different types , and then deleted some entries under the mar assumption .
the total number of clusters in each data set was 20 , the cluster size was 50 , and the five variables @xmath113 had gamma , binary , nominal , ordinal , and normal distributions respectively .
the variable @xmath114 followed a skewed gamma distribution : @xmath115 .
we assumed all the subsequent variables were generated depending on the previous ones , to introduce correlation among variables .
specifically , @xmath116 was a binary variable such that @xmath117 , where @xmath118 is the probability that @xmath116 equals 1 and @xmath119 .
the nominal variable @xmath120 had 4 categories and was generated by a multinomial probit model , so that 3 latent variables were needed : @xmath121 , where @xmath122 is a randomly generated coefficient matrix of dimension @xmath123 and @xmath124 is a correlation matrix of dimension @xmath125 . the category in @xmath120 was chosen to be @xmath126 ( for k=1,2,3 ) if @xmath127 was the largest component and was greater than 0 ; and was chosen to be 4 if @xmath128 . because we aimed to create a data set with a multilevel structure , we let the ordinal variable @xmath129 be generated from a random intercept model , @xmath130 , with @xmath119 , @xmath131 , and @xmath132 a vector of length 3 , corresponding to the 3 categories in @xmath120 .
three thresholds were used to determine four levels , they were the 20% , 30% , 50% quantiles of @xmath133 .
lastly , the normally distributed variable @xmath134 was also generated from a random intercept model , @xmath135 , where @xmath119 , @xmath136 , and @xmath132 and @xmath137 are vectors of length 3 .
to create missing data under the mar assumption , we assumed @xmath134 was completely observed and that the probabilities of missingness in @xmath138 ( @xmath139 ) depended on @xmath134 .
specifically , let @xmath140 be the probability that observation @xmath53 is missing its value for the @xmath138 variable and we assumed that @xmath141 . by adjusting the parameters @xmath142
, we can control the missingness in each variable .
we varied the parameters that generated the data to consider different scenarios : ( 1 ) missing rates for each variable from low ( 10% ) , median ( 30% ) to high ( 50% ) ; ( 2 ) clustering effect from low ( @xmath143 ) to high ( @xmath144 ) , corresponding to intra - class correlation coefficients of 0.17 and 0.5 respectively . in the imputation step ,
we set the number of imputations to be @xmath145 @xcite . to compare the performance of the proposed method with others , we considered six competing methods , some of which have already been implemented in some software packages .
these methods are listed in table 2 .
we used the package _ mitools _ in r @xcite to implement the combining rules ( [ combining rule ] ) after @xmath11 complete data sets had been generated .
the assessment of the relative performance of each method was based on the comparison of the imputation accuracy as well as the 95% coverage rates of the coefficients in the following random intercept logistic regression as a model of interest .
we chose this model arbitrarily , and believe that the results would also hold for other models of interest .
for each of the 100 simulated complete data sets , we fitted the model @xmath146 .
we used the glmer ( ) function in the _ lme4 _ package in r to obtain parameter estimates for @xmath147 .
these are our ` true ' parameter values .
after deletion of records by mar , we applied each of the missing data methods listed in table 2 , and calculated point and variance estimates for @xmath67 , using the combining rules .
we reported the average of the squared bias of the coefficient estimates over the 100 data sets as well as the coverage rates of 95% confidence intervals .
table 3 summarizes the results of the simulation experiments under the three missingness rates ( 10% , 30% and 50% ) using the seven methods , when the icc used to generate the variables @xmath129 and @xmath134 is 0.17 .
when the missingness rate is 10% , all the approaches give reasonably good results in terms of achieving the nominal coverage rate - 95% , though _ cc _ and the two joint modelling approaches ( _ jm _ and _ cluster jm _ ) do worse than the others .
a possible reason for this is that in the joint modelling approaches , multivariate gaussian distributions were specified and this is clearly not true in our data generating process , whereas in the sequential imputation approaches ( _ fcs _ and _ cluster fcs _ ) more flexible univariate imputation models were allowed to best accommodate different variable types . for the copula - based methods ,
the empirical distribution function transformations were applied before fitting a multivariate gaussian distribution on the latent variable scale where the dependence among the variables was captured .
in addition , the squared bias increases with an increase in missingness rate as expected . with a moderate to high level of missingness , _
cluster fcs _ and our proposed method ( _ cluster copula _ ) tend to outperform _ fcs _ and _ copula_hoff_. while all the methods suffer from under - coverage when the missing rates are 30% and 50% , _ cc _ seems to be the worst , producing the most biased results .
the results meet our expectation because as the percentage of missing data increases , there is less observed data available to capture the complex dependency among variables . under the mar assumption , _ cc _ causes the most biased results by only using the complete records while its alternatives make use of all the observed data .
table 4 is similar to table 3 except that the performance is evaluated at icc=0.5 . in other words ,
the data sets exhibit higher levels of clustering . compared to the results in table 3 , the results are worse across all methods for the higher icc value .
the imputation methods which take into account clustering effects almost always do better than their counterparts , which is not that obvious in table 3 when icc=0.17 .
conditional imputation methods do better than joint modelling approaches , and the two copula - based methods tend to achieve the best results , for almost half of the simulation settings with the smallest squared bias
. we also compared the imputation accuracy .
that is , for each data value we calculated the discrepancy between the average of the 10 imputed values and the before - deletion true values .
note that this comparison is not applied to the _ cc _ method .
the euclidean distance was used to measure the imputation accuracy in the continuous variable @xmath114 and the ordinal variable @xmath120 : @xmath148 , and the misclassification rate was used to measure the imputation accuracy in the binary variable @xmath116 and the nominal variable @xmath129 : @xmath149 .
figure 1 shows the results of the imputation accuracy for each simulation study .
the points are the means of the euclidian distances / misclassification rates over the missing observations in a single data set , and the error bars show the @xmath150 and @xmath151 quantiles over the 100 data sets . for variable
@xmath114 which follows a gamma distribution , there is not much difference in imputation accuracy over the six methods . for the nominal variable @xmath120
our proposed _
cluster copula _ method always performs the best except for the top - left panel , while the _ jm _ approach is always the worst .
the misclassification rates for the binary variable @xmath116 are smallest in all the scenarios when using our proposed _
cluster copula _ model but do not differ much from those of the other methods .
the misclassification rates for the ordinal variable @xmath129 are again highest for _ jm _ and the rates for the copula - based methods are smaller than the others when the missing rates are 30% and 50% . generally speaking ,
the copula based methods tend to impute more accurately for categorical variables but also do no worse than other methods for continuous variables .
the joint modelling methods , especially _ jm _ , give the least accurate imputation as the multivariate gaussian distribution assumption does not hold .
as the missingness rate and/or icc increase , all the methods for every variable perform comparatively worse in terms of having a larger disparity compared with the true values and higher misclassification rates , but the patterns of relative performance between the six methods remains broadly the same .
quantiles over the 100 data sets.,width=623,height=680 ] we also ran simulation studies using the qasc data set to evaluate our proposed method and other competing methods . here
we treated all the complete cases in the qasc data set ( 75.34% of the original data set ) as the ` true ' data , and sub - sampled 300 patients , 100 times to create 100 sub data sets .
then for each of the sub data sets , missing values were created , trying to mimic the missing data pattern in the original data set .
we distinguish between the demographic variables which we treat as mcar and the process of care variables which we treat as mar .
specifically , for the demographic variables : ` atsi ' , ` age ' , ` education ' and ` marital status ' , values were randomly deleted to roughly match the missingness percentages in table 1 . for the process of care variables and outcome variables , we assumed their missingness depended on the completely observed variables .
a missing indicator variable was associated with every variable with missing data which equaled 1 if an entry was missing .
for the missing indicators , we fitted logistic regression models on the original data set for ` time taken to hospital ' , ` mean temperature ' , ` modified rankin scale ' , ` bartell index ' , ` physical health score ' and ` mental health score ' respectively against ` gender ' , ` period ' and ` treatment ' , and the probabilities of missingness for the sub - sampled data sets were decided by the predicted values of these logistic regression models .
we noticed that 9.39% of ` bartell index ' , ` physical health score ' and ` mental health score ' were missing together , and we also took this into account when creating missing data . the relative performance for each method was also compared based on the average imputation accuracy and the squared bias and 95% coverage rate of interval estimates of parameters for some models of interest .
ten imputations were created for all the six imputation methods .
the accuracy is shown in table 5 .
all the discrepancies between the imputed values and the true values were measured by euclidean distance except for the nominal variables ` marital status ' and ` atsi ' which used the misclassification rates .
our proposed imputation model achieves the smallest disparity more than half of the time ( 7/11 ) and _ copula_hoff _ is superior in performance to the other four methods .
it is interesting to note that joint modelling methods perform better than their fcs counterparts ( _ jm _
vs._fcs _ and _ cluster jm _
vs._cluster fcs _ ) and adding clustering effects enhances the imputation accuracy .
the models of interest are based on the models fitted in @xcite .
they fitted logistic regression models for the dichotomous outcomes - ` bartell index ' with cut points equal to 60 and 95 , and ` modified rankin scale ' with cut point equaled to 2 ; and linear models for the continuous variables ` physical health score ' and ` mental health score ' , including as predictors the variables ` treatment ' , ` period ' and the interaction between ` treatment ' and ` period ' .
the models are @xmath152 the coefficient @xmath153 and its p - value were used to see if the pre - post change in the intervention group was statistically significant to the change in the control group .
all the models included a random intercept term , @xmath154 , to capture the clustering effects .
we first fitted the five models of interest on the completely observed patients in each of the 100 sub data sets , and obtained the parameter estimates @xmath155 and treated them as the true values .
then the parameter estimates from all the seven competing methods were compared against the true parameters , and the 95% coverage rates were obtained from the 100 repetitions .
the results are reported in table 6 .
approach has the largest bias and the smallest coverage rate .
this is not unexpected because the missing data were generated under the mar assumption and by _ cc _ only about 40% of the data were used to fit the models so that the coefficient estimates are biased with large uncertainty .
the proposed method _
cluster copula _ and _ copula_hoff _ outperform the other methods with _
copula_hoff _ doing marginally better than _ cluster copula _ for the first and second logistic models ` mrs2 ' and ` bi60 ' , and _ cluster copula _ doing better for the fifth linear model for ` pcs ' .
there is little difference between the two copula based methods , because the clustering effects were small in the qasc data set ( icc in the models of interest lay between 0.009 and 0.026 ) , and only one nominal variable ( marital status ) was considered in the imputation models but did not enter into the models of interest later . in other words , taking the clustering effect into account and giving special treatment to the nominal variable does not affect the inference too much in this case .
however , we do observe that when icc is higher in the variable ` pcs ' , our proposed model achieves better imputation accuracy .
we now apply our proposed method to impute missing data in the original qasc data set with a total of 1480 patients . unlike in section 4.3 where we deliberately deleted some records so that we knew the true values
, we do not know the true missing values here and therefore can not measure imputation accuracy .
we check the imputation quality by using diagnostics discussed in @xcite and @xcite . specifically , we examined the trace plots of the parameters and convergence in our proposed model ( not shown here ) and plotted the univariate densities / frequencies of the fully observed values ( in black ) and the average imputed values ( in six colors ) for some variables ( see figure 2 ) .
all the imputation methods generally agree with the complete data for the continuous variables ` length of stay ' and ` age ' and there are small disagreements for the variables ` mental health score ' and ` physical health score ' .
the imputed values seem to be more spread out for ` bartell index ' than the observed data which is concentrated around 0 .
overall , the frequencies of the categorical variables match the observed data with a few exceptions , for example , _ fcs _ imputes significantly more at level 4 for ` marital status ' ; and _ jm _ does not have any imputed values that fall into level 6 for ` modified rankin scale ' .
the departure from the observed data does not necessarily mean the imputation is poor , rather it may mean that the distribution of the missing data is different from what is observed , probably because of the missing data process is mar rather than mcar , lack of fit in the imputation model , etc .
we also report the point estimates of coefficients as well as the standard deviations and p - values of the five models of interest in table 7 , by _
cc _ and the six imputation methods
. while there are differences in the parameter estimates , the p - values across all the methods generally agree with each other , leading to the same clinical conclusions .
there are some exceptions , for example in the random intercept logistic regression model for ` bartell index 60 ' , the coefficient of the interaction term @xmath153 is significant at the 0.1 level for the methods _ cc _ , _ fcs _ and our proposed _
cluster copula _ method , but significant only at the 0.05 level for the methods _ jm _ , _ cluster jm _ , _
cluster fcs _ and _
in this paper , we developed a copula based imputation model for multilevel data sets with mixed data .
copula based imputation models have a sound theoretical foundation and we have shown through simulations that copula based imputation models achieve reasonably accurate predictions of the missing values and recovery of parameters in some models of interest .
the copula based imputation models outperform the competing methods , especially when the variable distributions depart from normality .
we also recommend taking into account clustering effects to incorporate information from the grouping structure in the analysis .
this is confirmed from our simulation results , that when the icc is high , imputation models with random effects added achieve better results .
one extension to our models is to add some ` fixed ' covariates . for the copula models in section 3
, all the variables appear on one side of the equations in ( [ combined ] ) and we model their relationship through the correlation matrices on the latent variable scale . but
it is often of interest to see both the relationship among variables on the response side and the relationship between the responses and some covariates .
for example in the qasc data set , ` treatment ' is fixed by design at hospital level , so we can treat it as a regressor . by doing so
, the treatment effects on some process of care variables can be detected directly through the copula model on the latent variable scale .
here we consider variables with ordering , and extension to nominal variables is straightforward .
let @xmath156 be the group index , @xmath157 be the individual index within group @xmath53 , and @xmath158 be the variable index .
suppose the first @xmath126 variables have common covariates @xmath159 at the group level , in other words , they are fixed within group @xmath53 .
the correlation matrices for residual and random effects @xmath154 are @xmath34 and @xmath84 respectively as before , but the mean of the latent variables @xmath36 is no longer zero .
again we use the monotone transformation @xmath160 to obtain the extended rank likelihood , then the model becomes : choosing the form of copula is another issue which is a critical yet complicated task .
@xcite , @xcite provide some guidance on choosing among existing copulas or creating new families of copulas . in this paper , we focused on the gaussian copula because it is easy to extend to higher dimensions and computationally convenient .
however , the main drawbacks of the gaussian copula are the symmetry assumption and absence of tail dependence @xcite .
therefore , some goodness - of - fit tests should be examined to check for a need to use other forms of copulas , for example , a ( mixture of skewed ) t - copulas .
eddings , w and marchenko , y. accounting for clustering with mi impute .
available online at http://www .
com / support / faqs / statistics / clustering - and - mi - impute/ , checked on _
, 120 ( 5):0 2013 , 2011 . graham , john w ; olchowski , allison e , and gilreath , tamika d. how many imputations are really needed ? some practical clarifications of multiple imputation theory . _ prevention science _ , 80 ( 3):0 206213 , 2007 .
gruhl , jonathan ; erosheva , elena a ; crane , paul k , and others , . a semiparametric approach to mixed outcome latent variable models : estimating the association between cognition and regional brain volumes . _
the annals of applied statistics _ , 70 ( 4):0 23612383 , 2013 .
kropko , jonathan ; goodrich , ben ; gelman , andrew , and hill , jennifer .
multiple imputation for continuous and categorical data : comparing joint and conditional approaches .
_ columbia university , department of statistics .
new york _ , 2013 .
middleton , sandy ; mcelduff , patrick ; ward , jeanette ; grimshaw , jeremy m ; dale , simeon ; deste , catherine ; drury , peta ; griffiths , rhonda ; cheung , n wah ; quinn , clare , and others , .
implementation of evidence - based treatment protocols to manage fever , hyperglycaemia , and swallowing dysfunction in acute stroke ( qasc ) : a cluster randomised controlled trial . _ the lancet _ , 3780 ( 9804):0 16991706 , 2011 .
murray , jared s ; dunson , david b ; carin , lawrence , and lucas , joseph e. bayesian gaussian copula factor models for mixed data .
_ journal of the american statistical association _
, 1080 ( 502):0 656665 , 2013 .
raghunathan , trivellore e ; lepkowski , james m ; van hoewyk , john , and solenberger , peter . a multivariate technique for multiply imputing missing values using a sequence of regression models .
_ survey methodology _ , 270 ( 1):0 8596 , 2001 .
raghunathan , trivellore e ; solenberger , peter w , and van hoewyk , john .
iveware : imputation and variance estimation software .
_ ann arbor , mi : survey methodology program , survey research center , institute for social research , university of michigan _ , 2002 .
schafer , joseph l and yucel , recai m. computational strategies for multivariate linear mixed - effects models with missing values .
_ journal of computational and graphical statistics _
, 110 ( 2):0 437457 , 2002 .
su , yu - sung ; gelman , andrew ; hill , jennifer ; yajima , masanao , and others , .
multiple imputation with diagnostics ( mi ) in r : opening windows into the black box .
_ journal of statistical software _ , 450 ( 2):0 131 , 2011 . | we propose a copula based method to handle missing values in multivariate data of mixed types in multilevel data sets .
building upon the extended rank likelihood of @xcite and the multinomial probit model , our model is a latent variable model which is able to capture the relationship among variables of different types as well as accounting for the clustering structure .
we fit the model by approximating the posterior distribution of the parameters and the missing values through a gibbs sampling scheme .
we use the multiple imputation procedure to incorporate the uncertainty due to missing values in the analysis of the data .
our proposed method is evaluated through simulations to compare it with several conventional methods of handling missing data .
we also apply our method to a data set from a cluster randomized controlled trial of a multidisciplinary intervention in acute stroke units .
we conclude that our proposed copula based imputation model for mixed type variables achieves reasonably good imputation accuracy and recovery of parameters in some models of interest , and that adding random effects enhances performance when the clustering effect is strong . |
the pleiades open cluster has become a favorite location for brown dwarf ( bd ) searches .
this privilege is due to its proximity , young age , low extinction and compactness ( the same properties that make it easily recognized to the naked eye ) .
such advantages were recognized over ten years ago , when the first ccd surveys of the cluster began ( jameson & skillen @xcite ; stauffer et al .
since then , there has been many efforts to reach fainter magnitudes and cover more area ( see hambly @xcite for a review ) , which have revealed many bd candidates .
a breakthrough in our understanding of bds has come from the successful application of the lithium test ( rebolo , martn & magazz @xcite ; magazz , martn & rebolo @xcite ) , which is an efficient observational method for distinguishing young bds from very low - mass ( vlm ) stars .
the first object at the substellar limit with a li detection was ppl 15 ( basri , marcy & graham @xcite ; hereafter bmg ) and soon after li was detected in the bds teide 1 and calar 3 ( rebolo et al . 1996 ) .
the detection of lithium in ppl 15 and the non - detection in hhj 3 ( marcy et al .
1994 ) was used by bmg to infer an age of @xmath1115 myr for the pleiades cluster , which is substantially older than the canonical cluster age of 75 myr inferred from standard calculations of the upper main - sequence turnoff .
they argued that the turnoff age increases when core convective overshoot is included in the evolutionary calculations , an effect that could account for the difference between dating the cluster with high - mass stars and with vlm objects .
ppl 15 was shown to lie on the binary infrared cluster sequence ( zapatero - osorio , martn & rebolo @xcite ) , and recently it has been found to be a spectroscopic double - lined bd binary ( basri & martn @xcite ) .
thus , the luminosity used by bmg was overestimated because they assumed that the object was single .
this is relevant for the discussion of the cluster age , because the luminosity and lithium of ppl 15 implied that it had to be younger than 125 myr .
since the luminosity of the primary in the ppl 15 binary is lower , the age could be older . in this paper
we present the discovery of a new object in the pleiades , which has a luminosity similar to the ppl 15 system .
this object is located on the cluster sequence for single objects , and thus its luminosity is not expected to be affected by a close companion .
we have detected lithium in it , which confirms its cluster membership , and makes it an important object for defining the lithium substellar boundary and constraining the cluster age .
the object presented in this paper was discovered in a ccd survey of the pleiades carried out using the 0.82 m iac80 telescope at the observatorio del teide in november and december of 1995 , and january 1996 .
we used a thomson 1048@xmath2 ccd with a field of view of 54.5 arcmin@xmath2 and @xmath3 filters .
two exposure of 1800s were obtained for each filter .
we observed 13 different fields , forming a mosaic of 590 arcmin@xmath2 .
the images were bias subtracted , flat fielded , corrected for bad columns , and searched for pointlike sources using daophot routines within iraf .
the fwhm of the stars in our frames were in the range 1``.5 to 2''.5 .
the instrumental magnitudes were calibrated with a secondary standard field within the pleiades that we had observed in previous runs ( zapatero - osorio , rebolo & martn @xcite ) . due to variable seeing conditions
, we did not reach the same sensitivity in all the fields .
we estimate that our completeness limits are in the range @xmath4=18.519.0 mag .
near - infrared ( nir ) follow - up observations of the bd candidates found in the ccd survey were carried out on 1996 nov 2 and 1997 sep 2123 at the calar alto 2.2 m telescope with magic , and the lick 1 m telescope with lircii , respectively .
the standard @xmath5 and @xmath6 filter set was used .
total exposure times ranged from 60 to 120 s in each filter .
we used the iraf daophot package to reduce the frames and extract the photometry .
instrumental aperture magnitudes were corrected for atmospheric extinction and transformed into the cit system using observations of the stars in the field of the bd calar 3 as standards ( zapatero - osorio et al .
only one bd candidate had optical and infrared photometry consistent with being a pleiades member .
we named it teide pleiades 2 ( from now on abreviated simply to teide 2 ) because it resulted from the extension of the pleiades survey at the teide observatory .
a preliminary report of this discovery was made by gallegos et al .
( @xcite ) .
the coordinates and @xmath7 photometry are listed in table [ tab1 ] and the finding chart is shown in figure [ fig1 ] .
teide 2 is included in the recent cfht survey ( bouvier et al .
@xcite ) , where it has a magnitude of @[email protected] which is 0.2 mag brighter than ours .
we have compared directly the cfht and iac80 ccd images and find that teide 2 has changed its brightness with respect to field reference stars .
for the j - band , the magnitudes obtained in calar alto and lick differ by 0.12 mag , which is somewhat larger than the expected error bars . teide 2 is probably variable in @xmath4 , and perhaps also in @xmath5 .
this suggestion needs to be confirmed with photometric monitoring , which might measure the rotation period if the variability is due to photospheric spots .
low - resolution spectroscopy of teide 2 was obtained on 1996 dec 8 and 9 using the isis double - arm spectrograph at the wht ( we only used the red arm ) with the grating r158r and a tek 1024@xmath2 ccd detector ; and the lris spectrograph with the 1200 line mm@xmath9 grating and a tek 2048@xmath2 ccd detector at the keck ii telescope . the spectral resolution ( fwhm ) and
wavelength coverage provided by each instrumental setup were 5.8 and 650915 nm , and 1.9 and 654775 nm , respectively .
reduction and calibration procedures were the same as described in zapatero - osorio et al .
( @xcite ) .
high - resolution spectroscopic observations were obtained on 1997 dec 3 and 7 , at the keck i telescope equipped with the hires echelle spectrometer .
the instrumental configuration and data reduction have been discussed by marcy et al .
( 1994 ) and bmg .
the resolving power obtained was r=31000 .
we took two spectra of teide 2 with exposure times of 3600 s and 4000 s. however , the sky was cloudy when the first spectrum was taken and we obtained a factor of 2 less counts than in the second spectrum .
we also obtained one 2700 s exposure of ppl 1 , a bd candidate discovered by stauffer et al .
( 1989 ) which has a similar brightness to teide 2 .
a color - magnitude diagram displaying the position of teide 2 and ppl 1 with respect to other members of the pleiades is presented in figure [ fig2 ] together with a theoretical 120 myr isochrone ( dashed line ) , and the main - sequence of field m - dwarfs ( solid line ) shifted to the pleiades distance ( 127 pc ) and mean reddening ( a@xmath10=0.12 ) .
teide 2 falls close to the theoretical isochrone , whereas ppl 15 clearly lies above it , suggesting that it could be a binary ( zapatero - osorio et al .
basri & martn ( 1998 ) confirmed that ppl 15 is indeed a double - lined spectroscopic binary with a mass ratio close to unity , implying that both components have nearly identical luminosities .
thus , we have indicated in figure [ fig2 ] that the i magnitude of each component in the ppl 15 system is @xmath10.75 mag .
fainter , while the @xmath11 color remains about the same .
ppl 15 now falls right on the 120 myr isochrone for a mass of 0.06 m@xmath12 , well below the substellar boundary .
the location of teide 2 in figure [ fig2 ] indicates a mass of 0.072 m@xmath12 which is just below the expected substellar limit ( 0.075 m@xmath12 , cf .
baraffe et al .
1998 ) . the position of ppl 1 above the isochrone might be due to measurement errors , photometric variability , binarity or younger age .
we can not presently distinguish between these possibilities .
radial velocities for teide 2 and ppl 1 were obtained by cross - correlating three hires echelle orders covering the ranges 786.4797.5 nm , 804.2815.6 nm and 822.9834.6 nm with the m6v template gl 406 ( @[email protected] km s@xmath9 ; x. delfosse , private communication ) observed using the same instrumental configuration .
the radial velocities obtained are given in table [ tab1 ] .
the error bars listed come from the dispersion among the different echelle orders , and correspond to about 0.4 pixels .
no significant radial velocity variation was detected between the two spectra of teide 2 taken on dec 3 and dec 7 .
stauffer et al .
( @xcite ) obtained a radial velocity for ppl 1 of 14.3@xmath810 km s@xmath9 , which is consistent with our measurement .
the radial velocity of teide 2 is consistent with known cluster members , while that of ppl 1 is a little on the high side .
the mean velocity of nearby field dwarfs in the line of sight toward the pleiades is also similar to the cluster members ( stauffer et al .
@xcite ) , hence radial velocity alone is not very reliable as a membership criterion .
there are more spectroscopic indicators that allow us to further investigate the membership of our objects in the pleiades .
one is the strength of h@xmath14 in emission , which is typically greater than 3 in proper motion m4m6 cluster members ( hodgkin , jameson & steele @xcite ) . for teide
2 we measured h@xmath14 equivalent widths of 9.5@xmath15 , 8.5@xmath15 and 4.7@xmath16 in our isis , lris and hires spectra , respectively . for ppl 1 we measured 2.3@xmath17 in our hires spectrum .
stauffer et al .
( @xcite ) and martn , rebolo & zapatero osorio ( @xcite ) published h@xmath14 measurement for ppl 1 of 4.8 and 6.5 , respectively .
the h@xmath14 emission of both teide 2 and ppl 1 has variable strength , but on the average they are comparable to those of late m - type proper motion pleiades members .
we measured the rotational broadening of teide 2 and ppl 1 in our hires spectra .
we artificially broadened gl 406 ( [email protected] km s@xmath9 ; delfosse et al .
@xcite ) with different values of vsin_i _ until we found the best match to the observed broadening of our pleiades objects .
the results are given in table [ tab1 ] .
field m4m6 dwarfs usually have vsin_i_@xmath1810 ( delfosse et al .
thus , the vsin_i _ of teide 2 and ppl 1 also indicate that they are young .
a third clue to membership comes from the general features seen in the low - resolution spectrum of teide 2 , which shows prominent tio and vo molecular absorption bands and strong atomic lines of ki ( 766.5 and 769.9 nm ) and nai ( 818.3 and 819.5 nm ) characteristic of a cool dwarf .
the spectral type of teide 2 is [email protected] according to the pseudocontinuum indices defined by ( martn et al .
@xcite ) . teide 2 nicely fits the sequence of pleiades members in the @xmath4-magnitude versus spectral type diagram of martn et al .
( @xcite ) .
summarizing , the radial velocities , h@xmath14 emission , vsin_i _ , spectral type and photometric properties of teide 2 and ppl 1 support their pleiades membership with a high level of confidence . in the top half of figure [ fig3 ] we compare the spectra of ppl 1 , teide 2 and ppl 15 .
the spectrum of ppl 1 is noisier than those of the other two objects because it was taken with the 2.5 m isaac newton telescope ( martn et al .
@xcite ) . teide 2 and ppl 1 have similar spectral type within the error bars , and ppl 15 is somewhat cooler but not more than one spectral subclass .
teide 2 confirms that the dividing line between stars and bds in the pleiades is at spectral type @xmath1m6 ( martn et al .
this result strengthens the recent identification of objects m6m8 in several star - forming regions ( orion , taurus , @xmath19 oph ) as likely brown dwarfs .
briceo et al .
( @xcite ) and luhman et al .
( @xcite ) have shown that the nai lines of some bd candidates in taurus are much weaker than those of dwarfs , indicating that the very young bds have low gravities .
we note that the equivalent width of the nai ( 818.3 and 819.5 nm ) measured in our wht spectrum of teide 2 is [email protected] .
this line is stronger than those of the taurus bds of similar spectral type as expected because the pleiades is much older , but slightly weaker than those of old m6 field dwarfs .
in the bottom half of figure [ fig3 ] we compare the hires spectra of hhj 3 and teide 2 .
marcy et al .
( 1994 ) placed an upper limit to the lii equivalent width of hhj 3 of 0.19 .
our spectrum of teide 2 has lower s / n ratio than their spectrum of hhj 3 , because our target is fainter and we had worse weather conditions .
however , the lii feature in teide 2 is clearly much stronger than in hhj 3 and we were able to detect it in our spectra .
we measured an equivalent width of [email protected] with respect to the local pseudocontinuum .
our spectrum of ppl 1 has a factor of about 2 lower s / n ratio than that of teide 2 .
we degraded the resolution by performing a rebinning of 6 pixels and found a feature at the position of the lii line .
however , we are not completely confident of a lithium detection in ppl 1 , and hence we place a conservative upper limit to its equivalent width .
we have compared the spectrum of teide 2 with that of ppl 15 ( bmg ) and we conclude that their lii strengths are similar .
the conversion from the observed lines to photospheric lithium abundance needs the use of synthetic spectra .
the main problem lies with our incomplete knowledge of the transitions of the tio molecule , which is the main absorber in this spectral region .
new calculations by pavlenko ( @xcite ) suggest that the lithium abundances of teide 2 and ppl 15 could be close to the interstellar value , implying that these objects have suffered little depletion .
the estimate made by bmg that ppl 15 had preserved @xmath11% of its initial lithium is a conservative lower limit .
furthermore , their measure of the lii equivalent width is compromised by its binary nature .
the vlm members of the pleiades ( @xmath200.1 m@xmath12 ) are non - degenerate , fully convective objects that derive most of their luminosity from gravitational contraction .
hence , their evolution is relatively simple and can even be computed analytically ( bildsten et al .
the faintest pleiades member for which lithium is undetected gives a lower limit to the age .
this is currently hhj 3 , and bmg obtained an age older than about 110 myrs for it .
we have checked with new theoretical models ( baraffe et al .
@xcite ; bildsten et al .
1997 ; burrows 1997 ( private communication ) ; dantona & mazzitelli @xcite ) that the lower age limit set by hhj 3 is in the range 100120 myr taking into account the observational error bars .
this result is not sensitive to the choice of theoretical models .
on the other hand , the brightest bds for which lithium is detected provide an upper limit to the cluster age .
we have converted the @xmath21 photometry and spectral type of teide 2 to bolometric luminosity by employing relationships derived for cool field dwarfs ( tinney et al .
since teide 2 shows lithium , its luminosity implies that it has to be younger than 120 myr according to all the available models .
we have also compared directly the absolute @xmath22magnitudes of teide 2 with the predictions of baraffe et al .
( 1998 ) and find similar results .
teide 2 and hhj 3 can only be coeval if both of them have ages in the narrow range 100120 myr . with only a few objects around the cluster substellar
limit we can not rule out the possibility of an age spread , but their location close to the 120 myr isochrone in figure [ fig2 ] indicates that they are essentially coeval .
all the recent models also agree that the mass of teide 2 is just below the substellar limit .
taking into account the observational error bars and the different models , we estimate a mass of [email protected] m@xmath12 .
teide 2 is most likely a single bd , or if it is a binary the secondary does not contribute much to the optical - nir fluxes .
hence , teide 2 can be considered a benchmark object defining the borderline between bds and stars in the pleiades .
_ acknowledgments _ : this research is based on data collected at the w. m. keck observatory , which is operated jointly by the university of california and caltech ; the wht telescope operated by the isaac newton group funded by pparc at the spanish observatorio del roque de los muchachos of the instituto de astrofsica de canarias ; the 2.2 m telescope at the german - spanish observatorio de calar alto ; the nickel 1 m telescope at lick observatory run by the university of california ; and the iac80 telescope at the observatorio del teide ( tenerife , spain ) . we thank drs .
i. baraffe , a. burrows , x. delfosse and f. dantona for sending results in advance of publication .
em acknowledges the support from the f.p.i .
program of the spanish ministry of education and culture .
gb acknowledges the support of nsf through grant ast96 - 18439 .
basri , g. , marcy , g. , & graham , j. r. 1996 , , 458 , 600 basri , g. , & martn , e.l .
1998 , in brown dwarfs and extrasolar planets , eds .
r. rebolo , e. l. martn and m. r. zapatero osorio , asp conf .
series , vol .
134 , p. 284 baraffe , i. , chabrier , g. , allard , f. , & hauschildt , p.h .
1998 , a&a , submitted bildsten , l. , brown , e.f . ,
matzner , c.d .
& ushomirsky , g. 1997 , , 482 , 442 bouvier , j. , stauffer , j. r. , martn , e.l . , barrado y navascus , d. , wallace , b. & bejar , v.j.s .
1998 , a&a , in preparation briceo , c. , hartmann , l. , stauffer , j. & martn , e.l .
1998 , , in press dantona , f. , & mazzitelli , i. 1998 , in `` cool stars in clusters and associations '' , eds .
g. micela , r. pallavicini & g. sciortino , mem.s.a.it .
, in press delfosse , x. , forveille , th . ,
perrier , ch . & mayor , m. 1998 , a&a , 331 , 581 gallegos , j. e. , rebolo , r. , zapatero osorio , m. r. , & martn , e. l. 1998 , in 18th texas symposium on relativistic astrophysics , a. olinto , j. frieman and d. schramm ( eds ) , world scientific press , in press hambly , n. c. 1998 , in brown dwarfs and extrasolar planets , eds .
r. rebolo , e. l. martn and m. r. zapatero osorio , asp series , vol .
134 , p. 11
hambly , n. c. , hawkins , m. r. s. , & jameson , r. f. 1993 , a&as , 100 , 607 hodgkin , s. t. , jameson , r. f. , & steele , i. a. 1995 , mnras , 274 , 869 jameson , r. f. , & skillen , i. 1989 , mnras , 239 , 247 luhman , k.l . ,
briceo , c. , rieke , g.h .
, & hartmann , l. 1998 , , 493 , 909 magazz , a. , martn , e. l. , & rebolo , r. 1993 , , 404 , l17 marcy , g. , basri , g. & graham , j. r. 1994 , , 428 , l57 martn , e. l. , rebolo , r. , & zapatero osorio , m. r. 1996 , , 469 , 706 oppenheimer , b. r. , basri , g. , nakajima , t. & kulkarni s. r. 1997 , , 113 , 296 pavlenko , ya .
1997 , astronomy reports , 41 , 537 rebolo , r. , martn , e. l. , basri , g. , marcy , g. w. , & zapatero osorio , m. r. 1996 , apj , 469 , l53 rebolo , r. , martn , e. l. , & magazz , a. 1992 , , 389 , l83 stauffer , j. r. , hamilton , d. , probst , r. , rieke , g. , & mateo , m. 1989 , apj , 344 , l21 stauffer , j. r. , liebert , j.r . , giampapa , m. , macintosh , b. , reid , n. , & hamilton , d. 1994 , aj , 108 , 160 tinney , c. g. , mould , j. r. , & reid , n. 1993 , , 105 , 1045 zapatero osorio , m. r. , martn , e. l. , & rebolo , r. 1997a , , 323 , 105 zapatero osorio , m. r. , rebolo , r. , & martn , e. l. 1997b , , 317 , 164 zapatero osorio , m. r. , rebolo , r. , martn , e. l. , basri , g. , magazz , a. , hodgkin , s.t . ,
jameson , r.f . , cossburn , m.r .
1997c , , 491 , l81 lcc ra@xmath23 & & 3h 52 m 06.7s @xmath24 dec@xmath23 & & 24@xmath25 16 01
@xmath26 @xmath27 & & 20.05@xmath28 @xmath29 & 17.73 & 17.82@xmath30 @xmath31 & 15.42 & 15.45@xmath30 @xmath32 & 14.34 & 14.46@xmath33 spt & m6.5@xmath15 & m6@xmath34 ew ( lii ) ( ) & @xmath201.8 & 0.77@xmath35 ew ( h@xmath14 ) ( ) & 6.52.3 & 9.54.7 @xmath13 & 15.4@xmath36 & 11.2@xmath15 @xmath37sin_i _ & 18.5@xmath17 & 13.0@xmath15 log @xmath38 & @xmath39 & @xmath40 | we present the discovery of an object in the pleiades open cluster , named teide 2 , with optical and infrared photometry which place it on the cluster sequence slightly below the expected substellar mass limit .
we have obtained low- and high - resolution spectra that allow us to determine its spectral type ( m6 ) , radial velocity and rotational broadening ; and to detect h@xmath0 in emission and lii 670.8 nm in absorption .
all the observed properties strongly support the membership of teide 2 into the pleiades .
this object has an important role in defining the reappearance of lithium below the substellar limit in the pleiades .
the age of the pleiades very low - mass members based on their luminosities and absence or presence of lithium is constrained to be in the range 100120 myr .
e - mail addresses : [email protected] , [email protected] [email protected],[email protected],[email protected],[email protected] |
in hadron colliders the dominant mode of top quark production is via quark - antiquark annihilation or gluon - gluon fusion , @xmath1 however there are other modes , @xmath2 in this list i have not included processes which pick a @xmath3-quark out of the hadron .
these processes are approximately ordered according to their rates in hadron colliders .
1(a ) has the rates for the first three processes at the tevatron assuming that the dominant decay model for the top quark is @xmath4 .
the channel , positron plus jets , was chosen so that the final state for all three processes is positron , @xmath5 plus jets .
the qcd , @xmath6-gluon and @xmath7 processes have two , one and zero non-@xmath3-quark jets , respectively .
( a)(b ) fig .
1(b ) contains the qcd cross section for @xmath8 verses @xmath9 for both proton - proton colliders and for proton - antiproton colliders . at @xmath10
the gluon - gluon fusion is only 10% of the cross section for a proton - antiproton collider , the tavatron , whereas at a @xmath11 proton - proton collider , the lhc , gluon - gluon fusion is 90% of the cross section . for an accurate determination of the qcd top cross section , we need to consider the next to leading order calculations and the soft gluon resummation of the next to leading order calculations@xcite . in fig .
2 , the results of these calculations using the same structure functions are shown . at high
top quark masses the difference between these two calculations is at the 20% level .
the standard model decays of the top are @xmath12 for @xmath13 , the total width of the top quark is approximately @xmath14 .
the ckm suppressed decays are expected to be less than 0.1% of the non - suppressed decays . whereas the decays including a @xmath15 or higgs will be extremely small unless the on - mass shell decay is kinematically allowed .
flavor changing neutral currents , @xmath16 have branching ratios less than @xmath17 in the standard model .
both cdf@xcite and d0@xcite presented detailed results on the search for top at the tevatron .
the data presented included both the dilepton and the lepton plus jets mode for the decay of the @xmath0 pair .
however , neither collaboration presented data on the six jet mode .
theoretical calculations suggest that with an efficient @xmath3-quark tag , that this mode will be accessible at the tevatron .
a detailed summary of the experimental results present can be found in the review of hadron collider physics by shochet@xcite .
cdf observes a @xmath18 ( 0.26% ) effect which is not sufficient to firmly establish the existence of top but which , if interpreted as top , yields @xmath19 and @xmath20 .
d0 does not observe a significant excess of events due to @xmath0 production .
the probability for the background to fluctuate to give greater than or equal to the observed number of events is 7.2% ( @xmath21 ) . if @xmath22 then @xmath23 .
orr@xcite presented the results of a study on the effects of soft gluon radiation in the determination of the top quark momentum .
the results of this study will be important for precision measurements of the top quark mass at hadron colliders .
in the standard model the couplings of the top quark to each of the gauge bosons , @xmath24 and @xmath25 are determined , including radiative corrections .
therefore potential new physics could show up as deviations of these vertices from standard model expectations .
kao@xcite and rizzo@xcite discussed corrections to the qcd coupling , @xmath26 . kao s paper concentrated on the one - loop weak corrections in both the standard model and the minimal supersymmetric standard model .
whereas rizzo considered the effects of an anomalous chromomagnetic moment to this coupling .
schmidt@xcite summarized top quark physics at @xmath27 colliders and in particular discussed the signatures of deviations to the @xmath28 and @xmath29 vertices at such machines . of course the top quark could present more dramatic surprises such as charged higgs decays , @xmath30 , large flavor changing neutral current decays , + @xmath31 or enhanced production through a new resonance .
this latest possibility could occur either through the quark - antiquark production mode@xcite , as expected in top - color models of electroweak symmetry breaking or via the gluon - gluon fusion@xcite as suggested by some technicolor models . in both cases
the @xmath0 pair is produced by the decay of a heavy new particle , top - color boson or techni - eta , which distorts the @xmath32 , @xmath33 and @xmath34 distributions from the standard model expectation .
3 is the change in the shape of the @xmath34 distribution in the top - color model discussed by hill and parke@xcite .
we should think of top quark production as a new drell - yan process probing extremely high mass scales , greater than 500 gev .
the top quark is an exciting new window on very high mass scale physics . while exploring the vista from this window we should be on the lookout for any deviation from the standard model which will provide us with information about that elusive beast , the mechanism of electro - weak symmetry breaking . because the mass of the top quark is very heavy , this quark is the particle most strongly coupled to the electro - weak symmetry breaking sector
. therefore the deviations could be seen at zeroth order or may require more subtle measurements .
\99 . # 1#2#3 nucl . phys . *
b#1 * # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3 phys
b#1 * # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3 phys .
* # 1 * # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3 phys . rev . *
# 1 * # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3 phys . rev .
* d#1 * # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3 phys . rep . *
# 1 * # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3 rev .
phys . * # 1 * # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3 z. phys .
* c#1 * # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3 comm .
phys . * # 1 * # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3_ibid . _ * # 1 * # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3 jetp lett .
* # 1 * # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3 sov .
# 1 * # 3 , ( # 2 ) j. benlloch , _ ` results from the cdf top search in the dilepton channel , ' _
+ g. watts , _ ` cdf top results in the lepton plus jets channel , ' _ + j. konigsberg , _ ` discussion of results of the cdf top searches , ' _
+ b. harral , _ ` kinematics properties of lepton plus multijet events at cdf , ' _ + these proceedings .
k. genser , _ ` search for top with d0 detector in the dilepton channel , ' _
+ d. chakraborty , _ ` search for top in the lepton plus jets channel at d0 , ' _
+ w. cobau , _ ` search for the top quark in electron plus jets plus b - quark tag using the d0 detector , '
_ + p. bhat , _ ` search for the top quark using multi - variate analysis techniques , ' _ + these proceedings . | i briefly review standard top quark physics at hadron colliders and summarize the contributions to this conference .
the possibility of new mechanisms for @xmath0 production are also discussed .
fermilab - conf-94/322-t + hep - ph/9409312 + september 13 , 1994 + |
since the pioneering works of carelli et al@xcite and oppenlnder et al@xcite , a lot of work has been devoted to the development of superconducting quantum interference filters ( sqifs ) for sensitive absolute magnetometry or for rf applications . indeed ,
since the response of the sqif is non - periodic in magnetic field , there is no need of a feed - back loop to maintain a fixed functioning point
. not only the absolute value of the magnetic field can be therefore measured , but the band - width of the device is not limited by the feed - back electronics anymore ( typically a few mhz usually @xcite ) .
in addition , one can chose the arrangement of the squids in the array to match the impedance of the device to the read - out system .
this paves the way for rf applications of sqifs , such as compact low noise amplifiers and sub - wavelength broad band antennas ( for a review see mukhanov et al@xcite ) . in the recent years , different architectures and geometries of sqifs
have been explored , 1d in series and parallel configuration @xcite , 2d in series / parallel configurations @xcite , using conventional squids and bi - squids@xcite to obtain the best performances in terms of sensitivity , linearity and noise . for high - frequency applications ,
very interesting results have been obtained such as 8 - 15 ghz antennas in the near field@xcite , and rf amplifiers in the 12 ghz range@xcite .
these performances have been obtained using low @xmath2 materials , mainly nb , operating at liquid - he temperature .
a lot of applications can not afford the related costly and power consuming cryogenics which is needed in that case .
high @xmath2 superconductors ( htsc ) such as @xmath0(ybco ) appear therefore as promising candidates to make sqifs operating at high temperature , easily accessible with compact and low energy consumption cryocoolers .
htsc sqifs have been fabricated for dc magnetometry applications @xcite and rf ones@xcite , using mainly bicrystal grain - boundary jj . by construction
they all lie on the same line , which put stringent constraint on the circuit design .
if 1d arrays can be easily realized , it is more challenging to achieve a high performance 2d htsc sqif along a geometrically one - dimensional grain boundary @xcite .
an alternative technology to make large arrays of htsc squids is the irradiation technique developed by the san diego group@xcite , and more recently by bergeal et al@xcite . starting from a commercial ybco film , the circuit and the jj are patterned by ion - irradiation through photoresist masks .
the induced defects within the htsc material lower the @xmath2 locally to fabricate sns ( superconductor - normal metal - superconductor ) jj , and make it insulating at high fluence to draw the circuit . superconducting devices such as thz josephson mixers were recently realized by this method@xcite .
large 2d arrays of jj@xcite and sqifs@xcite have been developed successfully . in this article
, we present the properties of sqifs made by ion irradiation , and explain the emergence of an optimal operating point ( bias current and temperature ) .
a deep understanding of the operation of sqif devices is necessary for future performance improvement .
for that , the first step is to figure out how a single squid made by ion irradiation works , since it is the key element of sqifs .
we performed numerical simulations to describe the characteristics of single squids that we measured experimentally .
we then extended them to a small series sqif , and drew conclusions about its optimal working point , and its sensitivity to dispersion in junction characteristics .
finally , a 2000 squid in series sqif is presented with a transfer function in the @xmath3 range .
in this study , we used commercial 150 nm thick ybco films in - situ covered by a 100 nm gold layer@xcite . to start with
, the latter is removed from the surface of the sample with the exception of the contact pads .
the superconducting circuit is created by a first @xmath4 oxygen ions irradiation at a fluence of @xmath5 performed through a patterned photoresist . @xmath6
wide slits located across superconducting microbridges are then patterned in a pmma resist by e - beam lithography .
a second oxygen ions irradiation at lower fluence ( typically @xmath7 ) is performed to locally decrease @xmath2 and create sns jjs .
figure [ figure1 ] shows optical pictures of different devices such as a single squid ( a ) , a 2000 loops series sqif ( b ) and an array of 18 squids in series that can be measured individually ( c ) .
the first two devices were achieved on one chip and the last one , on another substrate .
details of the fabrication process can be found elsewhere @xcite .
it is worth noting that same irradiation conditions were kept for all devices .
moreover design does not include large flux focussing areas around the loops or any transformers .
squid with @xmath8 wide branches corresponding to geometric inductance @xmath9=11 ph .
( b ) sqif with 2000 squids in series , with @xmath8 wide branches and areas ranging from @xmath10 to @xmath11 ( @xmath9=4.9 to 22 ph ) .
( c ) 18 squids in series with @xmath8 wide branches and areas ranging from @xmath12 to @xmath13 ( @xmath9=5.1 to 13.3 ph ) .
the first two devices ( a ) and ( b ) were realized on a same chip and the ( c ) on another one . ] under such conditions , josephson coupling occurs at around @xmath14 , and extends over typically @xmath15 ( see figure [ figure2 ] ( a ) for a single squid ) .
below , a flux flow regime takes place , for temperatures smaller than the critical temperature of the irradiated part called @xmath16 .
all measurements presented here were done in a magnetically unshielded pulse - tube cryocooler .
the magnetic field was applied perpendicular to the sample by an external helmoltz coil system .
we choose to not use a magnetic shield in order to explore the effect of a real environment on devices .
first , we measured the resistance of the device as a function of temperature as depicted in figure [ figure2].a .
the device exhibited two distinct superconducting transitions at 88k and 73k .
the highest transition refers to that of the electrodes ( the same as the unprocessed film ) and the second to @xmath17 , below which the josephson regime starts .
we then measured the i - v characteristics for the squid , shown in figure [ figure2].b in zero magnetic field ( b=0 ) and for several temperatures . in the josephson regime ,
i - v characteristics of the squid follow a modified resistively shunted junction ( rsj ) model , with a non - linear normal state resistance @xmath18@xcite , where @xmath19 is the bias current , @xmath20 the resistance in the regular rsj model @xcite , and @xmath21 is a parameter determined by fitting the experimental data .
given the rather high operation temperature @xmath22 , thermal smearing has to be taken into account in the fit through the parameter @xmath23 ( @xmath24 is the squid critical current for b=0 , @xmath25 the flux quantum and @xmath26 the boltzmann constant ) .
fits of the i - v characteristics ( see figure [ figure2 ] ( b ) ) give access to @xmath20 and @xmath24 , and therefore to the @xmath27 product which has a dome shape as a function of temperature@xcite ( see figure [ figure2 ] ( a ) ) .
this is an essential feature of htsc jj made by ion irradiation .
this shape is due to specific dependences of the critical current and the normal resistance versus temperature .
indeed , @xmath20 decreases linearly with temperature to reach a null value at @xmath16 ( the intrinsic critical temperature of the irradiated part ) and @xmath24 increases quadratically with temperature : this leads to a maxima of the @xmath27 product .
, @xmath28 and @xmath16 ( see text ) and the @xmath27 product ( extreme left scale ) showing a pronounced dome shape . the resistance @xmath20 ( see main text )
is reported for @xmath29 .
( b ) i - v characteristics in the josephson regime , for different temperatures .
color symbols are experimental data and black broken lines are fits with the modified rsj model ( see text ) .
inset shows a zoom around the critical current area for t=65 , 67 and 73k .
, width=415 ] figure [ figure3 ] ( a ) shows typical voltage modulations of the squid as a function of an applied magnetic field @xmath30 measured in an unshielded environment for different temperatures . from these v - b curves , we extracted the evolution of the transfer function @xmath31 as a function of bias current ( figure [ figure3 ] ( b ) ) .
as expected , all the curves show a peak in @xmath32 at a bias current approximately equal to the noise - free critical current determined by the screening parameter @xmath33 ( where @xmath34 is the loop inductance ) for @xmath35 @xcite .
this comes from the existence of thermal fluctuations which allow the squid to display a voltage modulation in magnetic field for bias currents lower than its critical current .
@xmath36-@xmath30 curves recorded for several temperatures allowed us to extract the evolution of @xmath32 as a function of temperature .
a particularity is the presence of a maximum in temperature for @xmath32 at @xmath37 . to get more insight on this behavior , we compared our data with semi - empirical formulae given by koelle et al@xcite and enpuku et al@xcite , and with numerical simulations of the rsj model .
we performed numerical simulations starting from the fit of the i - v curves with the modified rsj model ( see above ) to extract @xmath20 and @xmath24 for different temperatures .
we used the inductex software to calculate the inductance of the squid which includes geometric ( @xmath9 ) and kinetic inductance ( @xmath38 ) since for these temperature this latter is not negligible anymore .
@xmath38 depends on the superconducting penetration depth @xmath39 , which varies with temperature according to the gorter - casimir formula @xcite : @xmath40 ( with @xmath41 , @xmath42 , @xmath43 ) .
all parameters are listed in table [ table1 ] .
the resulting @xmath32 is shown in figure [ figure3 ] ( b ) , in very good agreement with experimental data as well as a function of the bias current than as a function of temperature .
.parameters used for the simulations .
[ cols="<,<,<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] the quite unusual behavior in temperature of @xmath32 is well reproduced in our simulations .
in fact , this comes from the non - monotonic variation of the @xmath27 product with temperature as mentioned above . in figure
[ figure4 ] , we plotted @xmath32 measured at optimum current ( which is temperature dependent ) as a function of temperature , and compared to our simulations and to the semi - empirical formulae . on the same graph
are also reported the @xmath27 product with its characteristics dome shape , and the value of @xmath44 .
the maximum of @xmath32 at 67 - 68 k comes from the convolution of @xmath27 ( maximum at 66 - 67 k ) with the decreasing @xmath44 .
indeed , @xmath32 is proportional to @xmath45 for small @xmath44@xcite , as seen in the koelle s and enpuku s formulae .
enpuku s expression describes correctly the experimental results in a restricted high temperature region , while the koelle s one and our simulations do it on the full range .
an important message here is that the optimum working point in current and temperature for the squid corresponds to @xmath46 as marked by the dashed green arrow in figure [ figure4 ] , and not for @xmath47 .
for all squids that we measured , the optimum as well as for @xmath32 than for @xmath48 is reached for high @xmath44 value .
this seems to be inherent to squids made by ion irradiation . as a function of the bias current for different temperatures .
symbols are experimental data and solid lines are the result of our simulations based on the rsj model ( see text ) . ,
width=453 ] of the squid at optimum bias current as a function of temperature ( data black symbol , our simulation blue solid line , enpuku model violet broken line , koelle model pink dash - dotted line ) .
is also plotted @xmath27 ( red triangles , extreme left scale ) , and @xmath44 ( green open circles , right scale ) .
, width=453 ]
sqifs are very promising devices for sensitive magnetometry , since their performance scale with the number of squids ( linearly for the series configuration ) .
however , the collective behavior is complex , since relevant parameters such as @xmath44 vary with the loop size on the one hand , and since deviations from the canonical fully symmetric squid and the dispersion in individual squids characteristics are unavoidable on the other hand . as a result , optimization of the array is not straightforward , and one would benefit from a thorough investigation of its detailed operation . on the way of making sqifs with thousands squids ,
we designed a 18 squids sqif in a series configuration with loop sizes ranging from @xmath12 to @xmath49 ( @xmath9 from 5.1 to 13.3 ph ) , where the squids can be measured individually ( see figure [ figure1 ] ( c ) ) . for the whole device , we recorded the @xmath50 curves .
as depicted in the figure [ figure5a ] ( a ) , a sqif response is observed .
it is weak , since the number of squids is moderate , but clearly seen , with an amplitude @xmath51 at the maximum . from v - b curves
, we then extracted the parameter @xmath52 .
figure [ figure5a ] ( b ) shows @xmath32 as a function of the bias current for different temperatures ( similar results are obtained for @xmath53 ) .
the overall picture is similar to that of a single squid , with an optimum bias current for each temperature , and an optimum temperature at t=56k ( this device displays a josephson regime at temperatures lowers than the two others devices presented ) . to explain this behavior , we numerically modeled the v - b characteristics of a device with the same geometry as the experimental one .
we first simulated an array where all the jj were identical .
we used characteristics from a typical individual squid ( namely @xmath20 , @xmath24 and @xmath21 for different temperatures ) and computed the sqif response by summing the contribution of the squids with different loop sizes .
we knowingly neglected mutual inductive coupling between squids , since the distance between nearest neighbors ( @xmath54 is large enough .
we also took into account the temperature dependence of both @xmath44 and @xmath55 .
the result is shown in figure [ figure5a ] ( c ) displaying @xmath32 as a function of the current bias for different temperatures .
there is a clear discrepancy with experimental data , with a restricted range in current where the sqif behavior can be observed , and an optimum temperature lower than the one experimentally obtained .
we then introduced a dispersion in the jj characteristics ( @xmath56 in @xmath24 and in @xmath57 , where @xmath58 is equal to the standard deviation divided by the mean for a gaussian distribution ) .
recent statistical studies of ion - irradiated jj in a pb - shielded cryostat lead to a typical dispersion of @xmath59 , while our measurements in unshielded environment show that dispersion varies from @xmath60 to roughly @xmath61 depending on the temperature@xcite .
we therefore used an upper bound estimate in our simulations . .
( b ) measured transfer function @xmath32 as a function of bias current for different temperatures for the 18 squids sqif .
( c ) calculated transfer function as a function of bias current for different temperatures , without dispersion in the jj characteristics
( c ) idem with a dispersion in characteristics of @xmath61 ( see main text ) .
( d ) , width=453 ] by introducing a dispersion in jj characteristics , we can notice ( figure [ figure5a ] ( d ) ) that the range in bias current where the sqif voltage modulation is observed is larger at low temperatures but tends to be reduced at higher temperatures .
besides , a clear optimum occurs in temperature .
it is worth noting that the optimal temperature is shifted toward higher temperature as compared to the case of null dispersion , and corresponds to that experimentally measured .
moreover , presence of dispersion tends to decrease the transfer function as compared to the ideal case .
these results are consistent with computations and experiments reported in the literature@xcite .
to explain this behavior , it is necessary to come back to the behavior of the individual squids .
figure [ figure6 ] shows the transfer functions vs bias current for 18 squids with different characteristics for two temperatures : 50k , panel ( a ) and 56 k , panel ( c ) .
figures [ figure6 ] ( b ) and ( d ) depict @xmath32 plotted as a function of the normalized current @xmath62 for each temperature .
these two temperatures correspond to two different squid working regimes . at low temperature ( i.e. 50k ) , for a given current , only a very small fraction of squids works together which impedes the existence of a sqif voltage modulation . by increasing the temperature ,
the overlap of voltage modulation of squids is more important raising the number of squids working together .
thus , a sqif behavior can be observed with a well - defined voltage modulation .
the reason is the following . at low temperatures
, @xmath44 is large and the thermal parameter @xmath55 small for all squids .
that means that each squid displays a voltage modulation in magnetic field in a restricted current range centered around its critical current ( figure [ figure6 ] ( b ) ) . in the presence of dispersion in jj characteristics ,
the different squids in the array will have distinct optimal currents and thus a collective behavior of the array is strongly disadvantaged .
moreover , even if the transfer function of individual squids is higher at low temperature , the potential sqif response will be moderate , and will decrease with decreasing temperature , since fewer and fewer squids contribute . on the contrary , at high temperature , each squid displays a voltage modulation in magnetic field on an extended range of current centered around its critical current , which leads to a collective behavior of the array .
for a given current , the situation with squids operating in low - beta regime favors the contribution of many squids to the sqif response , but the amplitude of each squid voltage modulation being smaller at high temperature , @xmath32 decreases as the temperature increases .
( see main text ) .
( left panels ) computed @xmath32 as a function of the bias current at two different temperatures : ( a ) 50k and ( c ) 56k .
in the former case @xmath63 and @xmath64 , and in the latter one @xmath65 and @xmath66 .
( right panels ) same data normalized by @xmath24 .
the peak at low temperature is narrower than the one at high temperature . ,
width=453 ] dispersion in the jj characteristics for symmetric squids ( pink line ) , and with in addition @xmath61 asymmetry in the critical currents of the two jj in each squids ( black line).,width=453 ] this is why an optimum in temperature is observed as summarized in figure [ figure5b ] , where both experimental data and simulations with , and without dispersion are shown .
we can go one step further and include an asymmetry in the critical currents of the jj in single squids .
it is worthwhile reminding that an asymmetry in the critical current of the squid is equivalent to a non - zero magnetic field within the squid loop .
we introduced a @xmath61 difference in the critical currents for all squids in our simulations , corresponding to the measured dispersion for single jj@xcite .
the result is the curve shown in figure [ figure5b ] ( black solid line ) , a bit closer to our experimental data . in the same spirit of the previous arguments
, asymmetry will impair the collective behavior at low temperature when few squids contribute to the sqif response .
moreover , the shift in v - b curves of squid has more dramatic effect in this situation .
individual squids do not respond simultaneously , which leads to the the reduction , or even the disappearance of the sqif voltage modulation .
this effect is less deleterious at high temperature . as a consequence
, a more pronounced optimal temperature appears in the presence of asymmetry in critical current . experimentally
, since we perform our experiment in an unshielded environment to stay close to the real applications of sqifs , we can not distinguish between potential asymmetry in jj characteristics and uncontrolled stray fields which would have the same effect on the sqif response . as a summary ,
these results and their analysis based on our rsj simulations show that sqif effect in our devices is quite robust against dispersion in jj characteristics and asymmetries .
nevertheless , dispersion acts on the operating point by shifting it toward high temperature and low bias current .
we made series arrays of 2000 squids with loop sizes ranging from @xmath10 to @xmath11 ( @xmath9=4.9 to 22 ph ) and @xmath8 wide branches to make a sqif ( see figure [ figure1 ] ( b ) ) , which operates between 65k and 75k .
@xmath32 and @xmath67 as a function of bias current for different temperatures are reported in figure [ figure7 ] ( a ) and ( b ) respectively , and display optimum operating conditions as ( see figure [ figure7 ] ( c ) ) .
this is coherent with previous experiment and simulations reported above .
the optimum temperature in both cases is @xmath68 , where @xmath69 , and @xmath70 .
these numbers compare favorably with previous reports in the literature . using the ion - irradiation technique , cybart _ et al _
reported @xmath71 and @xmath72 for 280 squids @xcite .
oppenlnder and co - workers using grain - boundary htsc jj published @xmath32 values between @xmath73 and @xmath74 and a @xmath67 in the @xmath75 range for 100 - 200 squids in series@xcite .
et al _ recently reported @xmath76 in a 2d htsc sqif with 20 000 jj@xcite .
( a ) and sqif voltage modulation amplitude @xmath67 ( b ) as a function of bias current for different temperatures of the 2000 squids sqifs in a series configuration .
( c ) @xmath32 ( black symbols and left scale ) and @xmath67 ( blue symbols and right scale ) at the optimum bias current for different temperatures .
( d ) maximum sqif response @xmath77 as a function of an applied magnetic field in an unshielded environment ( @xmath78 , and @xmath79 ) . , width=453 ] low frequency noise measurements were performed on this device at the optimum point ( @xmath80 and @xmath79 ) .
two low - noise amplifiers ( noise level @xmath81 ) were used in parallel , and only the correlated noise has been measured .
the obtained spectrum ( figure [ figure8 ] ) exhibits @xmath82 noise rising up at rather low frequency , namely below @xmath83 .
such a value has been achieved with high @xmath2 devices only by using bias reversal techniques@xcite .
neither bias - reversal nor flux - locked loop electronics were used here .
the sqif displays a white voltage noise level of @xmath84 , in good agreement with theoretical predictions@xcite . taking into account the obtained transfer function value @xmath69 for the bare sqif ( with no transformer )
, the voltage noise level can be translated into a magnetic field sensitivity of @xmath85 .
values found in the literature are generally lower@xcite .
however , the comparison is limited since the number of squids involved is more than an order of magnitude different , and the total impedance of the system is very different as well .
based on these results , an optimization of the sqif design is being made to achieve better performances . vs frequency f of a 2000 squids in series - sqif .
the sqif is operated at 72 k inside an unshielded cryostat .
the peaks at @xmath86 50 hz and higher harmonics are due to the grid .
, width=377 ]
both htsc squids and sqifs made by ion - irradiation present an optimum operating point in bias current and temperature .
the specific dome like temperature dependence of the @xmath87 product is important to understand the maximum in temperature .
the sqif behavior is more complex to analyze .
our simulations based on the rsj model enable us to qualitatively reproduce our experimental results on small sqif in a unshielded environment , provided we introduce a dispersion in the individual squids characteristics , coming from differences in jj or from uncontrolled magnetic fields . both spread and high temperatures favor a sqif response from many squids , but with a small amplitude , while low temperature operation provides larger amplitudes but on a limited number of squids .
this is the main reason for the optimum operating point observed .
finally , the 2000 squids in series sqif displays interesting features in an unshielded environment , such as sensitivity in the @xmath3 range and a low noise level .
these performances look promising for the realization of performing htsc sqifs .
the authors thank yann legall for ion irradiations . this work has been supported by trt through a cifre phd fellowship , the t - sun anr astrid program , the emergence program contract from ville de paris and by the rgion ile - de - france in the framework of the dim nano - k and sesame programs .
9 carelli p , castellano m g , flacco k , leoni r and torrioli g 1997 _ europhys .
oppenlnder j , hussler ch and schopohl n 2000 _ phys .
b _ 63 024511 . oppenlnder j 2003 _ adv . in solid state phys . _ 43 731 .
clarke j and braginski a 2004 _ the squid handbook , vol i _ , wiley - vch .
mukhanov o a , prokopenko g and romanofsky r 2014 _ ieee microwave magazine _ 15 57 .
oppenlnder j , hussler ch , trauble t , caputo p , tomes j , friesch a and schopohl n 2003 _ ieee trans .
kornev v k , soloviev i i , klenov n v and mukhanov o a 2009 _ supercond .
_ 22 114011 .
prokopenko g v , mukhanov o a and romanofsky r r , 2015__ieee isec _ _ 1 1 .
schultze v , ijsselsteijn r , boucher r , meyer h g , oppenlnder j , hussler ch , and schopohl n 2003 _ supercond .
_ 16 1356 .
schultze v , ijsselsteijn r , meyer h g , oppenlnder j , hussler ch , and schopohl n 2003 _ ieee trans .
caputo p , tomes js , oppenlnder j , hussler ch , friesch a , trauble t and schopohl n 2005 _ ieee trans .
_ 15 1044 .
caputo p , tomes j , oppenlnder j , hussler ch , friesch a , trauble t and schopohl n 2006 _ appl . phys . lett . _ 89 062507 .
caputo p , tomes j , oppenlnder j , hussler ch , friesch a , trauble t and schopohl n 2007 _ ieee trans .
snigirev o v , chukharkin m l , kalabukhov a s , tarasov m a , deleniv a a , omukhanov o a and winkler d 2007 _ ieee trans .
schultze v , ijsselsteijn r and meyer h g 2006 _ supercond .
mitchell e e , hannam k e , lazar j , leslie k e , lewis j c , grancea a , keenan s t , lam s k h and foley c p 2016 _ supercond .
_ 26 06lt01 .
chen k , cybart s a and dynes r c 2004 _ appl .
_ 85 2863 .
katz a s , sun a g , woods s i and dynes r c 2004 1998 _ appl .
. n. bergeal , x. grison , j. lesueur , g. faini , m. aprili and j.p .
contour , _ appl .
_ 87 102502 ( 2005 ) .
bergeal n , lesueur j , sirena m , faini g , aprili m , contour j p and leridon b 2007 _ j. appl .
_ 102 083903 .
malnou m , feuillet - palma c , ulysse c , faini g , febvre p , sirena m , olanier l , lesueur j and bergeal n 2014 _ j. appl .
_ 116 074505 . malnou m , luo a , wolf t , wang y , feuillet - palma c , ulysse c , faini g , febvre p , sirena m , lesueur j and bergeal n 2012 _ appl
_ 101 233505 .
cybart s a , anton s m , wu s m , clarke j and dynes r c 2009 _ nano letters _ 9 3581 .
cybart s a , wu s m , anton s m , siddiqi i , clarke j and dynes r c 2008 _ appl .
lett _ 93 182502 ( 2008 ) .
ouanani s , kermorvant j , crt d g , lematre y , mage j c , marcilhac b , bergeal n , malnou m , lesueur j , mailly d and ulysse c 2014 _ j. of physics : conference series _ 507 42008 .
http://www.ceraco.de ouanani s , phd thesis 2015 _ etude de rseaux de jonctions josephson haute temprature critique _ , orsay university .
katz a s , woods s i and dynes r c 2000 _ j. appl .
_ 87 2978 .
mccumber d e 1968 _ j. appl .
_ 39 2503 .
stewart w c 1968 _ appl .
tesche c d and clarke j 1977 _ j. low temp .
koelle k , kleiner r , ludwig f , dantsker e and clarke j 1999 _ rev .
k , shimomura .
y and kisu .
t 1993 _ j. appl .
_ 73 7929 .
k 1993 _ jpn .
_ 32 l1407 .
tinkham m 1996 _ introduction to superconductivity , 2d edition _ , mcgraw - hill , new - york .
terai h , hidaka m , satoh t and tahara s 1997 _ appl .
_ 70 2690 .
wolf t , bergeal n , lesueur j , fourie c j , faini g , ulysse c and febvre p 2013 _ ieee trans .
_ * 23 * , 1101205 .
ryhnen t and sepp h 1989 _ j. low temp .
wu s m , cybart s a , anton s m and dynes r c 2013 _ ieee trans .
_ 23 1600104 .
berggren s and de escobar a l 2015 _ ieee trans .
_ 25 1600304 .
likharev k k 1986 _ dynamics of josephson junctions and circuits _
, gordon and breach science publishers s.a . ,
clarke j , goubau w m and ketchen m b 1976 _ j. low temp . | superconducting quantum interference filters ( sqifs ) are arrays of superconducting loops of different sizes including josephson junctions ( jj ) . for a random distribution of sizes
, they present a non - periodic response to an applied magnetic field , with a large transfer function and a magnetic field sensitivity potentially improved with respect to that of a single squid .
such properties make sqifs interesting devices to detect the magnetic component of electromagnetic waves at microwave frequencies .
we have used the highly scalable technique of ion irradiation to make squids and sqifs based on commercial @xmath0films , and studied their properties .
both display optimum performances as a function of temperature and bias current , that can be understood in the frame of numerical simulations that we developed .
the role of asymmetries and dispersion in jj characteristics ( routinely found in high tc superconductors technologies ) is also studied .
we have found that both do not impede the existence of a sqif effect but play a role on the emergence of the optimal point .
we finally present results on sqif made with 2000 squid in series , showing a transfer function @xmath1 . |
the pace of cosmic evolution is marked out by the condensation of stars from the ism .
starbursts , regions of intense massive star formation which can dominate the bolometric output of galaxies , are crucial to our understanding of this evolution at all redshifts . in the local universe about 25% of high mass star formation
is contained within starburst galaxies ( heckman , 1997 ; gallego _ et al._1995 ) . at high redshift ( @xmath3 ) , starbursts are the the easiest galaxies to detect , and can be used to directly trace the rate of evolution ( madau _ et al . _
so , to understand the cosmological pace of evolution , we must understand starbursts .
we would like to know how to derive intrinsic star formation rates and the physics that determines these rates .
can the starburst `` knob '' be cranked up to arbitrary levels or is its amplitude limited ?
recently we imaged a small sample of starbursts in the ultraviolet ( uv ) using the hst ( meurer _ et al . _ 1995
; hereafter m95 ) . the basic uv structure of a starburst
consists of prominent compact star clusters embedded in a more diffuse cloud . in the nearest starbursts
the diffuse light starts to resolve into stars , hence star formation within starbursts occurs in both clustered and diffuse modes . in m95
we compared the effective surface brightness , @xmath0 ( the surface brightness within the radius containing half the total emission ) , of starbursts and concluded that there is an upper limit to @xmath0 .
this suggests that the intensity of starbursts is limited .
lehnert and heckman ( 1996 ) found a similar surface brightness limit in their combined fir/ study .
this prompted our more comprehensive investigation of starburst surface brightnesses ( meurer _ et al . _
1997 ; hereafter m97 ) which we report on here .
vacuum - uv imaging is indispensable for understanding starbursts since it allows the direct detection of the hot - high mass stars that power starbursts . in contrast
other tracers of high - mass stars , such as ( and other emission lines ) , radio continuum , and far - infrared ( fir ) emission originate in the ism and only indirectly trace star formation .
dust presents the biggest obstacle to understanding uv observations , since dust extinction and scattering are strongest in the uv resulting in a net attenuation of the uv flux .
fortunately , our work has proven that uv observations can reveal essential properties of high mass star formation , even in the presence of modest amounts of dust .
we are saved because dust is not a sink for photons ; the absorbed radiation is reemitted thermally in the fir .
hence the ratio of fir to uv fluxes is an indication of net attenuation .
figure 1 shows a positive correlation between uv spectral slope @xmath4 and @xmath5 for a sample of strongly star forming galaxies as indicated by their strong recombination emission line spectra . _ a priori _ we expect their uv spectra to be that of an ionizing population , and hence to have an intrinsic color in the hatched region of the plot .
this correlation is readily understood in terms of a simple foreground screen dust geometry , as shown by the model line .
although the dust distribution , in exact detail , may not be a _ homogeneous _
foreground screen , and other quantities may be involved in the correlation , this is largely unimportant for determining the attenuation correction .
so long as the fir emission results from dust reradiating the light absorbed in the uv and optical , any model that reproduces the correlation in fig . 1 will recover the uv flux of ionizing populations to within a factor of @xmath63 ( corresponding to the spread in @xmath7 ) .
the evidence for a starburst intensity limit is summarized in figs 2 and 3 . in fig .
2 we show measurements of our rest frame uv sample after dust attenuation correction as outlined above . for comparison with the other samples , shown in fig . 3 , luminosities and surface brightnesses are converted to bolometric units following the models of leitherer & heckman ( 1995 ) . note that the shape of the low @xmath0 end of the distributions in fig . 3 are determined by ( largely arbitrary ) selection effects .
however there is no selection against high surface brightness .
the three starburst @xmath0 distributions have 90th percentile upper limits within a factor of three of @xmath8 , which we call the starburst intensity limit .
this limit is very robust , applying to starbursts with @xmath9 to 10 kpc , to both local starbursts , and systems out to redshift @xmath10 , to both uv / optically selected starbursts and fir selected starbursts , and to observations obtained in the uv , , fir , and radio continuum .
the lack of a strong @xmath11 effect , indicates that it corresponds to a limit on star formation intensity rather than being an opacity effect , and is further vindication of the uv attenuation estimates .
this limit strongly indicates that the global intensity of star formation is regulated within starbursts .
in m97 we explored two physical mechanisms that may be responsible for the intensity limit : galactic winds ( heckman _ et al . _ 1990 ) , and gravitational stability of the inner disk ( following kennicutt , 1989 ) .
although we find evidence that the intensity limit is related to both mechanisms , neither predicts the value of the intensity limit , nor its robustness .
hence _ determining the physics of the starburst intensity remains a major theoretical challenge_. although robust , this limit does not hold for all star forming scales .
in particular it does not hold for the star clusters embedded within starbursts .
these are small @xmath12 pc ( m95 ) and can have @xmath0 two orders of magnitude or more intense than @xmath13 .
this is not a contradiction because @xmath13 refers to a global quantity dominated by diffuse light , whereas individual clusters usually do not dominate the total luminosity of starbursts .
star formation in normal disk galaxies is typically three orders of magnitude less intense than in starbursts , as seen in fig .
3 . however
, this may largely reflect the different star formation patterns .
typically star formation fills the central regions of starburst galaxies , whereas in normal galaxies it usually consists of regions , often arranged in spiral arms or rings , but otherwise fairly isolated .
we illustrate how large a difference covering factor can make in the bottom panel of fig . 3 using a uit uv image of m81 ( hill _ et al .
its disk averaged @xmath0 , marked `` d '' , is the surface brightness within the elliptical aperture containing half the uv light ( the same technique used to measure the @xmath14 values shown in the bottom panel ) .
the _ isophotal _ @xmath0 , marked `` i '' , is the surface brightness within the isophote containing half the total flux ( in other words , pixels having this or higher surface brightness comprise half the total uv flux ) .
in effect , this value does not include any of the `` empty space '' between regions .
the @xmath0 of one of m81 s brightest regions is marked `` h '' .
this comparison suggests that star formation in normal galaxies , averaged over only the actively star forming regions , may occur with the same intensity distribution as starbursts .
more measurements of normal galaxies are needed to test this hypothesis .
our results have far reaching implications .
we demonstrated that intrinsic uv fluxes of starbursts can be recovered from uv data alone ( fig . 1 ) .
this confirms the importance of uv observations to the study of extragalactic high mass star formation .
the dust attenuation corrections are significant in the uv .
the median @xmath15 of our uv sample corresponds to an attenuation factor of @xmath6 8 at @xmath16 and @xmath17 at @xmath18 .
the latter value corresponds to the rest @xmath11 of the lyman drop out galaxies observed at high redshift ( madau _ et al . _
these have properties ( including @xmath4 ) consistent with those of local uv selected starbursts .
et al . _ ( 1996 ) use the uv luminosity density of these systems to infer that the universe was fairly quiescent ( low star formation rate density , or equivalently metal production rate ) at redshift @xmath19 .
however they applied no dust extinction corrections . after applying our uv attenuation corrections , and adopting the same cosmology as madau _
et al . _
( @xmath20 , @xmath21 ) we find a lower limit of @xmath22 for the metal production rate at @xmath19 .
this is about six times higher than their estimate of the hubble time averaged metal production rate .
we find that rather than being quiescent we are observing an active but moderately obscured early universe .
i thank my collaborators for their work in the m95 and m97 papers : don garnett , anne kinney , matt lehnert , claus leitherer , james lowenthal , carmelle robert , and especially tim heckman . those papers and this benefited from many stimulating discussions with daniela calzetti .
calzetti , d. , kinney , a.l . , & storchi - bergmann , t. 1994 , apj , 429 , 582 ( c94 ) gallego , j. , zamorano , j. , aragn - salamanca , a. , & rego , m. 1995 , apj , 455 , l1 heckman , t.m . , armus , l. , & miley , g.k .
1990 , apjs , 74 , 833 heckman , t.m .
1997 , in star formation near and far , edited by s.s .
holt & l.g .
mundy , ( aip , woodbury ny ) , p. 271 hill , j.k . , _
et al . _
1992 , apjl , 395 , l37 kennicutt , r.c .
1989 , apj , 344 , 685 lehnert , m. , & heckman , t.m .
1996 , apj , 472 , 546 leitherer , c. , & heckman , t.m .
1995 , apjs , 96 , 9 madau , p. , ferguson , h.c . ,
dickinson , m.e . ,
giavalisco , m. , steidel , c.c . , & fruchter , a. 1996 , mnras , 283 , 1388 meurer , g.r . , heckman , t.m .
, leitherer , c. , kinney , a. , robert , c. , & garnett d.r .
1995 , aj , 110 , 2665 ( m95 ) meurer , g.r . ,
heckman , t.m .
, lehnert , m.d . , leitherer , c. , & lowenthal , j. 1997 , aj , _ in press _
( m97 ; astro - ph/9704077 ) | our recent work on starbursts , particularly in the ultraviolet ( uv ) , is summarized .
the intrinsic uv fluxes of uv selected starbursts can be derived from uv data alone because , to first order , their dust behaves like a foreground screen .
this allows a comparison of the bolometric effective surface brightness @xmath0 of uv selected starbursts to other starburst samples .
starbursts have a robust ( 90th percentile ) upper limit @xmath1 , which strongly suggest that their global star formation intensities are regulated .
the mechanism(s ) involved in the regulation are not yet clear .
the dust attenuation corrections for high-@xmath2 starbursts are significant . calculations of the rate of evolution in the early universe based on zero dust interpretations are probably underestimated by about an order of magnitude .
hence the early universe was not quiescent , but obscured . |
measure equivalence is an equivalence relation between discrete countable groups and is defined so that two such groups are equivalent if there exists a measure space , called a coupling , equipped with certain measure - preserving actions of those groups ( see definition [ defn - me ] ) .
this is closely related to orbit equivalence between measure - preserving actions of discrete countable groups on probability measure spaces .
we refer to @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and @xcite for recent developments and related topics on measure and orbit equivalence . in @xcite , given two discrete countable groups @xmath0 , @xmath1 satisfying rigidity in the sense of measure equivalence , we present a construction of an amalgamated free product @xmath2 satisfying rigidity of the same kind .
the first step for the proof of this result is to show the coupling rigidity of @xmath3 with respect to the automorphism group of the bass - serre tree @xmath4 associated to the decomposition of @xmath3 , which is proved on the assumption that @xmath0 and @xmath1 satisfy property ( t ) . as a consequence , for any discrete countable group @xmath5 that is measure equivalent to @xmath3
, we can find a simplicial action of @xmath5 on @xmath4 and obtain information on the structure of @xmath5 through the bass - serre theory .
the purpose of the present paper is to establish coupling rigidity in the case where @xmath0 and @xmath1 do not necessarily satisfy property ( t ) ( see theorem [ thm - coup - rigid ] for a precise statement ) .
we apply it to proving rigidity results for amalgamated free products of mapping class groups . in this introduction ,
we state a result on orbit equivalence rigidity for such a group and give examples .
let us introduce terminology to state theorem [ thm - oer ] .
we mean by a discrete group a discrete and countable group .
a borel action of a discrete group @xmath3 on a measure space @xmath6 is said to be _
_ if @xmath7 is a finite positive measure on @xmath8 and if the action is essentially free and preserves @xmath7 , where f.f.m.p .
" stands for essentially free and finite - measure - preserving " .
a measure - preserving action @xmath9 is said to be _ aperiodic _ if any finite index subgroup of @xmath3 acts on @xmath6 ergodically . two ergodic f.f.m.p .
actions of discrete groups , @xmath9 and @xmath10 , are said to be _ orbit equivalent ( oe ) _ if there exists a borel isomorphism @xmath11 between conull borel subsets of @xmath8 and @xmath12 such that @xmath13 and @xmath14 are equivalent and the equality @xmath15 holds for a.e .
@xmath16 .
let @xmath17 be a connected , compact and orientable surface which may have non - empty boundary . throughout the paper , we assume a surface to satisfy these conditions unless otherwise stated .
let @xmath18 be the _ extended mapping class group _
, i.e. , the group of isotopy classes of homeomorphisms from @xmath17 onto itself , where isotopy may move points in the boundary of @xmath17 . as shown in @xcite and @xcite , @xmath18 satisfies rigidity in the sense of measure and orbit equivalence if @xmath17 is non - exceptional . for a group @xmath19 and a subgroup @xmath20 of @xmath19 , we set @xmath21<\infty\,\}\ ] ] and
call it the _ left - quasi - normalizer _ of @xmath20 in @xmath19 .
we say that @xmath20 is _ almost malnormal _ in @xmath19 if @xmath22 is finite for any @xmath23 .
we note that if @xmath20 is infinite and almost malnormal in @xmath19 , then the equality @xmath24 holds .
[ thm - oer ] let @xmath17 be a surface of genus @xmath25 with @xmath26 boundary components .
we define an amalgamated free product @xmath27 , where @xmath28 and @xmath29 satisfy one of the following two conditions : 1 .
let @xmath28 be a finite index subgroup of @xmath18 with @xmath30 and @xmath31 .
let @xmath29 be an infinite and almost malnormal subgroup of @xmath28 .
2 . let @xmath28 be a finite index subgroup of @xmath18 with @xmath32 and @xmath33 .
let @xmath29 be a subgroup of @xmath28 such that the equality @xmath34 holds and the group @xmath35 is amenable for each @xmath36 .
let @xmath9 be an ergodic f.f.m.p .
action such that the restriction @xmath37 is aperiodic .
if the action @xmath9 is oe to an ergodic f.f.m.p .
action @xmath10 of a discrete group @xmath5 , then those two actions are indeed conjugate .
we obtain this theorem as a direct consequence of the result that the cocycle @xmath38 associated with the oe is cohomologous to the cocycle arising from an isomorphism from @xmath3 onto @xmath5 ( see corollary [ cor - oer ] for a precise statement ) .
let us present three kinds of examples of @xmath28 and @xmath29 satisfying the assumption in theorem [ thm - oer ] .
the groups @xmath28 and @xmath29 in the first example fulfill condition ( a ) in theorem [ thm - oer ] , and those in the second and third examples fulfill condition ( b ) .
* let @xmath28 be a finite index subgroup of @xmath18 with @xmath30 and @xmath31 .
define @xmath29 as the stabilizer in @xmath28 of the pair of pseudo - anosov foliations for a pseudo - anosov element .
* let @xmath28 be a finite index subgroup of @xmath18 with @xmath32 and @xmath33 .
define @xmath29 as the stabilizer in @xmath28 of a pants decomposition of @xmath17 .
* let @xmath28 be a finite index subgroup of @xmath18 with @xmath39 and @xmath40 .
define @xmath29 as the stabilizer in @xmath28 of a teichmller disk so that @xmath29 contains a pseudo - anosov element .
this paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec - group ] , we review basic facts on discrete measured groupoids and their amenability . in section [ sec - b - ame ] ,
given an action of a discrete group on a tree , we present a sufficient condition for the action on the boundary of the tree to be amenable in a measure - theoretic sense .
this is applied to the action on the bass - serre tree for an amalgamated free product of two discrete groups in classes @xmath41 and @xmath42 , introduced in sections [ sec - c - f ] and [ sec - c - a ] , respectively .
basic properties and examples of groups in those classes are also discussed . in particular , mapping class groups of certain surfaces are shown to belong to these classes . in section
[ sec - coup - rigid ] , we prove coupling rigidity of an amalgamated free product @xmath3 of two discrete groups in classes @xmath41 and @xmath42 . applying results in @xcite ,
we show orbit equivalence rigidity of an ergodic f.f.m.p .
action of @xmath3 .
the aforementioned three examples of subgroups of mapping class groups are discussed in section [ sec - mcg ] .
in this section , we collect basic facts on discrete measured groupoids .
we recommend the reader to consult @xcite and chapter xiii , 3 in @xcite for basic knowledge of standard borel spaces and discrete measured groupoids , respectively .
we mean by a _ standard finite measure space _ a standard borel space with a finite positive measure .
when the measure is a probability one , we refer to it as a _ standard probability space_. for a discrete measured groupoid @xmath43 on a standard finite measure space @xmath6 and a borel subset @xmath29 of @xmath8 with positive measure , we denote by @xmath44 the groupoid restricted to @xmath29 , where @xmath45 are the range and source maps , respectively .
if @xmath29 is a borel subset of @xmath8 , then @xmath46 stands for the saturation @xmath47 which is a borel subset of @xmath8 .
we say that a discrete measured groupoid @xmath43 on a standard finite measure space @xmath6 is _ finite _ if for a.e .
@xmath16 , @xmath48 consists of at most finitely many points .
we say that @xmath43 is of _ infinite type _ if for a.e .
@xmath16 , @xmath48 consists of infinitely many points . given a borel action of a discrete group @xmath3 on a standard borel space @xmath8 , we say that a @xmath49-finite positive measure @xmath7 on @xmath8 is _ quasi - invariant _ for that action if it preserves the class of @xmath7 . in this case
, the action @xmath9 is said to be _ non - singular_. we denote by @xmath50 ( or @xmath51 if there is no confusion ) the discrete measured groupoid associated with that action .
this is equal to @xmath52 as a set , and the range and source maps @xmath53 are defined by @xmath54 and @xmath55 for @xmath56 and @xmath16 .
the product is defined by @xmath57 for @xmath58 and @xmath16 . for @xmath16 , the unit at @xmath59
is defined to be @xmath60 , where @xmath61 is the neutral element of @xmath3 .
there is a close connection between orbit equivalence and isomorphism of discrete measured groupoids associated with group actions .
let @xmath9 and @xmath10 be ergodic f.f.m.p . actions on standard finite measure spaces , and let @xmath43 and @xmath62 be the associated groupoids , respectively .
it follows that @xmath43 and @xmath62 are isomorphic as discrete measured groupoids if and only if the two actions are oe .
if there are borel subsets @xmath63 and @xmath64 with positive measure such that @xmath65 and @xmath66 are isomorphic , then the two actions are said to be _ weakly orbit equivalent ( woe)_. let us say that a discrete measured groupoid @xmath67 on a standard finite measure space @xmath6 is _ nowhere amenable _ if for any borel subset @xmath29 of @xmath8 with positive measure , the restriction @xmath68 is non - amenable .
we refer to @xcite for amenability of discrete measured groupoids .
we shall recall a definition of amenable actions in a measure - theoretic sense , originally introduced in @xcite in a different way . for a discrete group @xmath3 , we mean by a _
@xmath3-space _ a countable discrete set on which @xmath3 acts by bijections .
let @xmath3 be a discrete group and @xmath69 a @xmath3-space .
suppose that @xmath3 acts on a standard probability space @xmath6 non - singularly .
invariant measurable system of means _ for the @xmath3-space @xmath69 over @xmath6 is a family of means @xmath70 on @xmath71 such that for each @xmath72 , * the function @xmath73 is @xmath7-measurable ; and * the equality @xmath74 holds for any @xmath56 and @xmath7-a.e .
@xmath16 , where the action @xmath75 is defined by @xmath76 for any @xmath56 , @xmath72 and @xmath77 .
let @xmath78 be a borel action of a discrete group @xmath3 on a standard borel space @xmath8 . 1 .
let @xmath7 be a probability measure on @xmath8 quasi - invariant for the action of @xmath3 .
we say that the action @xmath9 is _ amenable _ if there exists an invariant measurable system of means for the @xmath3-space @xmath3 over @xmath6 , where @xmath3 acts on @xmath3 by left multiplication .
we say that the action @xmath78 is _ amenable in a measure - theoretic sense _ if the action @xmath9 is amenable for any probability measure @xmath7 on @xmath8 quasi - invariant for the action @xmath78 .
we note that a non - singular action @xmath9 is amenable in the above sense if and only if the associated groupoid is amenable .
the following are useful criteria for actions or groupoids to be amenable . in this paper , we mean by a subgroupoid of @xmath43 a borel subgroupoid of @xmath43 whose unit space is the same as that of @xmath43 .
[ prop - ext - ame ] let @xmath3 be a discrete group acting on a standard probability space @xmath6 non - singularly , and let @xmath5 be a subgroup of @xmath3 . if there is an invariant measurable system of means for the @xmath3-space @xmath79 defined by left multiplication , over @xmath6 , and if the action @xmath80 is amenable , then the action @xmath9 is also amenable .
[ thm - ext - ame ] let @xmath3 be a discrete group acting on two standard probability spaces @xmath6 and @xmath81 non - singularly .
suppose that there is a @xmath3-equivariant borel map @xmath82 with @xmath83 .
if the action @xmath84 is amenable , then the action @xmath9 is also amenable .
[ prop - ame - subgrd ] suppose that a discrete group @xmath3 acts on a standard borel space @xmath85 and acts on a standard probability space @xmath6 non - singularly .
let @xmath86 be a subgroupoid of the associated groupoid @xmath87 . if the action @xmath88 is amenable in a measure - theoretic sense and if there is a borel map @xmath89 satisfying the equality @xmath90 for a.e .
@xmath91 , then @xmath86 is amenable .
the last proposition can be obtained by following the proof of theorem 5.10 in @xcite after exchanging symbols appropriately .
we make use of amenability to find a fixed point when a groupoid acts on a space . such a fixed point is formulated as follows .
[ defn - inv - map ] let @xmath43 be a discrete measured groupoid on a standard probability space @xmath6 , and let @xmath17 be a standard borel space .
suppose that we have a borel action of a discrete group @xmath3 on @xmath17 and a groupoid homomorphism @xmath92 .
a borel map @xmath93 is said to be _
@xmath94-invariant _ if it satisfies the equality @xmath95 when @xmath96 is understood from the context , this map @xmath97 is said to be _
@xmath67-invariant_. more generally , if @xmath29 is a borel subset of @xmath8 with positive measure and if a borel map @xmath98 satisfies the above equality for a.e .
@xmath99 , then we also say that @xmath97 is _
@xmath67-invariant_. we will often apply amenability of actions or groupoids in the context of the following proposition , which directly follows from the formulation of amenability in terms of the fixed point property ( see @xcite and theorem 4.2.7 in @xcite ) . [ prop - ame - basic ] let @xmath43 be a discrete measured groupoid on a standard probability space @xmath6 , @xmath3 a discrete group , and @xmath92 a groupoid homomorphism .
suppose that @xmath3 acts on a compact metrizable space @xmath100 continuously .
we denote by @xmath101 the space of probability measures on @xmath100 , on which @xmath3 naturally acts .
if @xmath43 is amenable , then there exists a @xmath67-invariant borel map from @xmath8 into @xmath101 . finally , we present an observation on invariant borel maps , which will be used repeatedly in sections [ sec - c - f ] and [ sec - c - a ] .
[ lem - inv - ext ] let @xmath43 be a discrete measured groupoid on a standard probability space @xmath6 .
suppose that we have a borel action of a discrete group @xmath3 on a standard borel space @xmath17 and a groupoid homomorphism @xmath92 .
if @xmath29 is a borel subset of @xmath8 with positive measure and if @xmath98 is a @xmath67-invariant borel map , then @xmath97 extends to a @xmath67-invariant borel map from @xmath102 into @xmath17 . in section 2.4 of @xcite
, we introduced normal subgroupoids of a discrete measured groupoid , based on @xcite and section 4.6.1 in @xcite .
this is a generalization of normal subrelations of a discrete measured equivalence relation and also a generalization of normal subgroups of a discrete group .
let @xmath43 be a discrete measured groupoid on a standard probability space @xmath6 and @xmath45 the range and source maps , respectively .
let @xmath86 be a subgroupoid of @xmath43 .
we denote by @xmath103 the set of all borel maps @xmath104 , where @xmath105 is a borel subset of @xmath8 , such that 1 . for a.e .
@xmath106 , the equality @xmath107 holds ; and 2 . for a.e .
@xmath108 , we have @xmath109 let @xmath67 be a discrete measured groupoid on a standard probability space @xmath6 .
a subgroupoid @xmath86 of @xmath43 is said to be _ normal _ in @xmath43 if there exists a collection of countably many maps in @xmath103 , @xmath110 , such that for a.e . @xmath111 , we have @xmath112 and @xmath113 for some @xmath114 . in this case
, we write @xmath115 .
the following basic properties are immediately verified .
we refer to lemma 2.16 in @xcite for a proof of assertion ( ii ) .
the following assertions hold : 1 . let @xmath19 be a discrete group acting on a standard probability space @xmath6 non - singularly , and let @xmath20 be a normal subgroup of @xmath19 .
then @xmath116 is a normal subgroupoid of @xmath117 .
let @xmath43 be a discrete measured groupoid on a standard probability space @xmath6 and @xmath86 a normal subgroupoid of @xmath43 .
if @xmath29 is a borel subset of @xmath8 with positive measure , then @xmath118 is normal in @xmath65 .
given an amalgamated free product @xmath2 of discrete groups , one associates a simplicial tree @xmath4 , called the bass - serre tree , on which @xmath3 acts by simplicial automorphisms .
theorem [ thm - ame - action ] stated below gives a sufficient condition for the action of @xmath3 on the boundary @xmath119 of @xmath4 to be amenable in a measure - theoretic sense .
let @xmath4 be a connected simplicial tree which has at most countably many simplices and is not necessarily locally finite .
we denote by @xmath120 the set of vertices of @xmath4 .
let @xmath121 be a path metric on @xmath4 so that each edge of @xmath4 is isometric to the unit interval @xmath122 $ ] with the euclidean metric .
an ideal boundary @xmath119[boundary ] of @xmath4 is defined as the set of all equivalence classes of infinite geodesic rays in @xmath4 , where two geodesic rays in @xmath4 are equivalent if the hausdorff distance between them is finite .
for any two distinct points @xmath59 , @xmath123 in the union @xmath124[delta - t ] , there exists a unique geodesic path from @xmath59 to @xmath123 . we denote it by @xmath125[geodesic ] and
often identify @xmath125 with the sequence of vertices that @xmath125 passes through . for @xmath126 and a subset @xmath29 of @xmath120
, we define the set @xmath127 the following theorem defines a topology on @xmath128 and gives basic properties of it .
the collection of the sets @xmath129 for all @xmath126 and all finite subsets @xmath29 of @xmath120 defines an open basis for a topology on @xmath128 satisfying the following properties : 1 .
the space @xmath128 is compact and hausdorff .
the set @xmath120 is dense in @xmath128 , and the boundary @xmath119 is a @xmath130-subset and in particular a borel subset of @xmath128 .
any simplicial automorphism of @xmath4 is uniquely extended to a homeomorphism from @xmath128 onto itself .
the relative topology on @xmath119 coincides with the topology on it as the gromov boundary of @xmath4 .
it is known that for each word - hyperbolic group , its action on its boundary is amenable in a measure - theoretic sense .
this fact is originally proved by adams @xcite . the construction of the map @xmath20 in the proof of the following theorem basically relies on germain s proof of this fact in appendix b of @xcite .
[ thm - ame - action ] let @xmath4 be a connected simplicial tree with at most countably many simplices and @xmath121 the metric on @xmath4 defined above .
let @xmath3 be a discrete group acting on @xmath4 by simplicial automorphisms .
suppose that the following three conditions hold : 1 .
the boundary @xmath119 is non - empty .
the action of @xmath3 on @xmath120 has only finitely many orbits . 3 .
there is a positive integer @xmath131 such that for any two vertices @xmath132 with @xmath133 , their stabilizer in @xmath3 defined as @xmath134 is amenable .
then the action @xmath135 is amenable in a measure - theoretic sense .
this proof follows the author s argument in theorem 3.19 of @xcite , where the action of the mapping class group on the boundary of the complex of curves is dealt with . to prove amenability of that action
, we constructed a certain map @xmath20 associated to a @xmath136-hyperbolic graph satisfying properties ( f1 ) and ( f2 ) , which were originally introduced by bowditch @xcite .
it is easy to check these properties for our tree @xmath4 .
( in the notation right before lemma 2.8 in @xcite , it is enough to put @xmath137 , @xmath138 , @xmath139 and @xmath140 . ) as discussed in theorem 2.9 and remark 2.2 in @xcite , we can construct a map @xmath141 satisfying the following properties , where @xmath142 is the banach space of all @xmath143-functions on @xmath120 : * for any @xmath144 and any @xmath145 , the function @xmath146 on @xmath119 is borel .
* for each @xmath147 , the function @xmath148 on @xmath120 is non - negative and satisfies @xmath149 . * for each number @xmath150
, the value @xmath151 converges to @xmath152 as @xmath153 , uniformly for @xmath154 and @xmath144 with @xmath155 . * the equality @xmath156 holds for any @xmath147 and any @xmath56 , where the action @xmath157 is defined by @xmath158 for any @xmath56 , @xmath159 and @xmath160 .
pick a probability measure @xmath7 on @xmath119 quasi - invariant for the action @xmath135 . fix @xmath161 . for each @xmath145
, we define a function @xmath162 on @xmath163 by setting @xmath164 we then have @xmath165 for any @xmath154 and @xmath166 for any @xmath56 .
it follows from remark 3.2.6 in @xcite ( see also theorem a.2 in @xcite ) that there exists an invariant measurable system @xmath167 of means for the @xmath3-space @xmath120 over @xmath168 . recall that @xmath169 is a mean on @xmath170 for each @xmath154 .
let @xmath171 be a set of representatives of orbits for the action @xmath172 . since @xmath173 is finite by condition ( b ) , the equality @xmath174 holds for @xmath7-a.e .
@xmath154 , where @xmath175 is the @xmath3-orbit in @xmath120 containing @xmath176 .
we then have @xmath177 , where for each @xmath178 , we define a @xmath3-invariant borel subset @xmath179 of @xmath119 as @xmath180 to prove the theorem , it is enough to verify that the action of @xmath3 on @xmath179 equipped with the restriction of @xmath7 is amenable for each @xmath178 with @xmath181 . by normalization
, we get an invariant measurable system of means for the @xmath3-space @xmath175 over @xmath179 .
let @xmath182 denote the stabilizer of @xmath176 in @xmath3 .
since @xmath175 is identified with @xmath183 as a @xmath3-space , the theorem is a consequence of proposition [ prop - ext - ame ] and the following lemma , where condition ( c ) will be used . in the notation of theorem [ thm - ame - action ] , the action @xmath184 is amenable in a measure - theoretic sense for any @xmath160 , where @xmath182 is the stabilizer of @xmath176 in @xmath3 .
fix @xmath160 and let @xmath7 be a probability measure on @xmath119 quasi - invariant for the action @xmath184 .
we put @xmath185 where @xmath131 is the number in condition ( c ) of theorem [ thm - ame - action ] .
the set @xmath17 is then @xmath182-invariant .
for each @xmath154 , let @xmath186 be the unique point in the intersection of @xmath17 and the geodesic from @xmath176 to @xmath59 .
the map @xmath187 is then borel and @xmath182-equivariant .
let @xmath188 be a set of representatives of orbits for the action @xmath189 .
for each @xmath190 , we put @xmath191 where @xmath192 is the @xmath182-orbit in @xmath17 containing @xmath193 .
the set @xmath194 is a @xmath182-invariant borel subset of @xmath119 for each @xmath190 , and the equality @xmath195 holds . to prove the lemma , it is enough to show that the action @xmath196 is amenable for each @xmath190 with @xmath197 .
we claim that there is an invariant measurable system of means for the @xmath182-space @xmath198 over @xmath199 for each @xmath190 with @xmath197 .
the lemma follows from this claim and proposition [ prop - ext - ame ] because @xmath200 is amenable by condition ( c ) in theorem [ thm - ame - action ] and the action @xmath201 is thus amenable .
note that @xmath198 is identified with @xmath192 as a @xmath182-space . for each @xmath202
, we define a mean @xmath169 on @xmath203 by the formula @xmath204 the family @xmath205 is then an invariant measurable system of means for the @xmath182-space @xmath192 over @xmath199 .
[ cor - ame - action ] in the notation of theorem [ thm - ame - action ] , let @xmath206 be the quotient space of @xmath207 by the action of the symmetric group of two letters defined by exchanging the coordinates . then the action @xmath208 induced by the diagonal action @xmath209 is amenable in a measure - theoretic sense .
this is a direct consequence of theorem [ thm - ame - action ] .
we refer to lemma 5.2 in @xcite or lemma 4.32 in @xcite for a precise proof .
in this section , we introduce class @xmath41 of discrete groups and discuss its basic properties .
we also present examples of groups in that class .
let @xmath4 be a connected simplicial tree with at most countably many simplices . in what follows , we mean by a tree one satisfying these conditions unless otherwise stated .
let us denote by @xmath210 the simplicial automorphism group of @xmath4 equipped with the standard borel structure arising from the pointwise convergence topology .
when @xmath119 is non - empty , we define @xmath206 to be the quotient space of @xmath207 by the action of the symmetric group of two letters defined by exchanging the coordinates .
we denote by @xmath120 and @xmath211 the sets of vertices and simplices of @xmath4 , respectively . unless there is a confusion , @xmath120
is often identified with the set of 0-simplices of @xmath4 .
[ defn - c - f ] we say that a discrete group @xmath3 belongs to class @xmath41 if @xmath3 is infinite and the following statement holds : let @xmath9 be a measure - preserving action on a standard probability space and @xmath43 the associated groupoid .
suppose that we have a tree @xmath4 with @xmath212 and a borel cocycle @xmath213 satisfying the following three conditions : 1 .
for any three mutually distinct vertices @xmath214 , the subgroupoid of @xmath67 defined as @xmath215 is finite .
2 . for any borel map
@xmath216 , the subgroupoid of @xmath67 defined as @xmath217 is amenable .
3 . for any @xmath56 and a.e .
@xmath16 , the automorphism @xmath218 of @xmath4 has no inversion
. then there exists a @xmath219-invariant borel map @xmath220 .
we now explain a motivation for introducing class @xmath41 .
let @xmath2 be an amalgamated free product of discrete groups , and let @xmath4 be the bass - serre tree associated to the decomposition of @xmath3 .
suppose that we have a self - coupling of @xmath3 and the me cocycle @xmath221 associated with it , where @xmath8 is a fundamental domain for the action of @xmath222 on that coupling ( see section [ sec - coup - rigid ] for these terms ) .
it is shown that if @xmath0 and @xmath1 belong to @xmath41 and if @xmath29 is almost malnormal in both @xmath0 and @xmath1 , then for each @xmath223 , there exists a borel map @xmath224 with @xmath225 these maps @xmath226 and @xmath227 play an important role in the proof of coupling rigidity of @xmath3 with respect to @xmath210 , discussed in section [ sec - coup - rigid ] .
we show a few consequences of the existence of the @xmath94-invariant borel map @xmath97 in definition [ defn - c - f ] and give hereditary properties of groups in class @xmath41 .
if there is such an invariant borel map into @xmath120 , then one can construct a canonical invariant borel map valued in @xmath211 as follows .
[ lem - inv - s ] let @xmath9 be a measure - preserving action of a discrete group on a standard probability space and @xmath43 the associated groupoid
. suppose that we have * a tree @xmath4 with @xmath212 and a borel cocycle @xmath213 satisfying condition ( i ) in definition [ defn - c - f ] ; and * a borel subset @xmath29 of @xmath8 with positive measure and a subgroupoid @xmath86 of @xmath65 of infinite type .
if there exists an @xmath228-invariant borel map from @xmath29 into @xmath120 , then the following assertions hold : 1 .
there exists an essentially unique , @xmath228-invariant borel map @xmath229 such that for any borel subset @xmath230 with positive measure and any @xmath228-invariant borel map @xmath231 , the inclusion @xmath232 holds for a.e .
if @xmath234 is a subgroupoid of @xmath65 with @xmath235 , then the map @xmath236 in assertion ( i ) is @xmath234-invariant .
the idea of the following construction of @xmath236 appears in lemma 3.2 of @xcite .
let @xmath237 be the set of all @xmath228-invariant borel maps from @xmath29 into @xmath211 . by assumption , @xmath237 is non - empty .
for each @xmath238 , we set @xmath239 one can find @xmath240 with @xmath241 .
it follows from condition ( i ) for @xmath96 in definition [ defn - c - f ] that this @xmath236 satisfies the desired property in assertion ( i ) .
we give only a sketch of the proof of assertion ( ii ) because this is a verbatim translation of the proof of lemma 6.7 in @xcite after exchanging symbols appropriately .
let us denote by @xmath242_{{\mathcal}{s}}$ ] the set of all maps @xmath243 in @xmath244 such that the composition @xmath245 is injective on a conull borel subset of @xmath246 , where @xmath247 is the range map for @xmath67 .
for each @xmath248_{{\mathcal}{s}}$ ] , one can prove that the map @xmath249 is @xmath86-invariant .
it follows from the property of @xmath236 stated in assertion ( i ) that the inclusion @xmath250 holds for a.e .
@xmath251 . by considering the `` inverse '' of @xmath243 , i.e.
, the map in @xmath252_{\mathcal{s}}$ ] defined by @xmath253 one can prove the converse inclusion .
the reader should consult the cited reference for more details .
since @xmath254 is generated by @xmath252_{\mathcal{s}}$ ] , the map @xmath236 is @xmath254-invariant .
[ prop - basic - c ] class @xmath41 satisfies the following properties : 1 .
let @xmath3 and @xmath5 be discrete groups with @xmath255 and @xmath256<\infty$ ] . then @xmath257 if and only if @xmath258 .
if @xmath3 and @xmath5 are discrete groups with @xmath259 and @xmath258 , then we have @xmath257 .
no amenable group belongs to @xmath41 .
let @xmath3 and @xmath5 be discrete groups with @xmath255 and @xmath256<\infty$ ] .
assuming that @xmath3 belongs to @xmath41 , we prove that so does @xmath5 .
pick a measure - preserving action @xmath10 on a standard probability space and a borel cocycle @xmath260 satisfying the three conditions in definition [ defn - c - f ] .
let @xmath9 be the action of @xmath3 induced from the action @xmath10 .
choose representatives @xmath261 of left cosets of @xmath5 in @xmath3 with @xmath262 and @xmath263 $ ] .
note that we have @xmath264 .
let us define a borel cocycle @xmath213 in the following way : given @xmath56 , @xmath265 and @xmath266 , we can uniquely find elements @xmath267 and @xmath268 with @xmath269 and define @xmath270 . in particular , we have @xmath271 for any @xmath266 and @xmath265 .
we now prove that @xmath96 is in fact a borel cocycle . given any @xmath272 and @xmath16 , we uniquely choose elements @xmath273 , @xmath265 and @xmath274 with @xmath275 we thus have @xmath276 by definition , the equalities @xmath277 holds .
it follows that @xmath96 is a borel cocycle .
the cocycle @xmath96 satisfies the three conditions in definition [ defn - c - f ] for the action @xmath9 .
there exists a @xmath278-invariant borel map @xmath220 because @xmath3 belongs to @xmath41 .
the restriction of @xmath97 to @xmath12 is then @xmath279-invariant .
it follows that @xmath5 belongs to @xmath41 .
the converse of assertion ( i ) is a direct consequence of the fact shown in the previous paragraph and assertion ( ii ) .
we now prove assertion ( ii ) .
let @xmath3 and @xmath5 be discrete groups with @xmath259 and @xmath258 . pick a measure - preserving action @xmath9 on a standard probability space and a borel cocycle @xmath213 as in definition [ defn - c - f ] .
since @xmath5 belongs to @xmath41 , there exists a @xmath280-invariant borel map from @xmath8 into @xmath120 .
let @xmath281 be the @xmath280-invariant borel map given in lemma [ lem - inv - s ] .
it follows from @xmath259 that @xmath236 is also @xmath282-invariant .
we can then construct a @xmath282-invariant borel map from @xmath8 into @xmath120 by using lemma [ lem - inv - ext ] and condition ( iii ) in definition [ defn - c - f ] .
it thus turns out that @xmath3 belongs to @xmath41 . finally , we prove assertion ( iii ) .
let @xmath3 be an infinite amenable group and pick an ergodic f.f.m.p .
action @xmath9 . by a theorem due to ornstein - weiss @xcite or connes - feldman - weiss @xcite ,
there exists an ergodic f.f.m.p .
action @xmath283 such that the two groupoids @xmath51 and @xmath284 are isomorphic with respect to the identity on @xmath8 .
let @xmath4 be the cayley graph of @xmath285 with respect to the set of generators @xmath286 , and define a cocycle @xmath287 so that for any @xmath288 and @xmath16 , @xmath289 is the translation on @xmath4 defined by @xmath290 .
the cocycle obtained by composing @xmath96 with the isomorphism @xmath291 satisfies the three conditions in definition [ defn - c - f ] , while there exists no @xmath282-invariant borel map from @xmath8 into @xmath120 .
we then see that @xmath3 does not belong to @xmath41 .
let @xmath4 be a connected simplicial tree with at most countably many simplices . in this subsection , we collect basic properties of invariant borel maps valued in the space of probability measures on @xmath128 .
we first review some natural maps associated to geometry of @xmath4 . for a compact hausdorff space @xmath292 ,
we denote by @xmath293 the space of probability measures on @xmath292 . for each borel subset @xmath294 of @xmath292
, we set @xmath295 which is a borel subset of @xmath293 .
* map @xmath296 .
* let @xmath297 be the set of all non - empty finite subsets of @xmath120 , on which @xmath210 naturally acts .
the map @xmath296 is defined to be the @xmath210-equivariant map associating the barycenter to each element of @xmath297 in the following manner : for each @xmath298 , let @xmath299 be the set of vertices of the minimal connected subtree of @xmath4 containing @xmath300 , and put @xmath301 .
let us define a subset @xmath302 of @xmath120 as @xmath303 inductively , where @xmath304 denotes the set of all vertices in @xmath305 whose neighbors in @xmath305 consist of exactly one vertex . since @xmath306 is finite , there exists a unique number @xmath307 such that @xmath305 consists of either a single vertex or two adjacent vertices .
this @xmath305 is denoted by @xmath308 .
the map @xmath309 is clearly @xmath210-equivariant .
* map @xmath310 . *
suppose that @xmath119 contains at least three points .
we set @xmath311 on which @xmath210 acts so that @xmath312 for any @xmath313 and @xmath314 .
let @xmath315 denote the set of all finite subsets of @xmath120 whose cardinalities are at least three , on which @xmath210 naturally acts .
we define a borel map @xmath310 so that for each @xmath314 , the set @xmath316 consists of all vertices in the union @xmath317 whose distances from the single point in the intersection @xmath318 are at most one .
* map @xmath319 .
* this is defined to be an @xmath210-equivariant borel map associating to each @xmath143-function @xmath320 the union of the points of @xmath315 on which @xmath11 takes its maximal value .
* map @xmath321 .
* this is an @xmath210-equivariant borel map defined so that for any @xmath322 and @xmath323 , the set @xmath324 consists of all vertices in the geodesic(s ) connecting a point of @xmath325 with @xmath326 whose distances from @xmath326 are at least one and at most three .
suppose that we have a measure - preserving action @xmath9 of a discrete group on a standard probability space and a borel cocycle @xmath213 satisfying condition ( i ) in definition [ defn - c - f ] .
given a subgroupoid @xmath86 of @xmath51 of infinite type , we study @xmath228-invariant borel maps into @xmath327 in the following lemmas . for each measure
@xmath328 , we denote by @xmath329 the support of @xmath7 .
[ lem - two - supp ] let @xmath9 be a measure - preserving action of a discrete group on a standard probability space and @xmath43 the associated groupoid .
suppose that we have * a tree @xmath4 with @xmath212 and a borel cocycle @xmath213 satisfying condition ( i ) in definition [ defn - c - f ] ; * a borel subset @xmath29 of @xmath8 with positive measure and a subgroupoid @xmath86 of @xmath65 of infinite type ; and * an @xmath228-invariant borel map @xmath330 .
then the following assertions hold : 1 . if @xmath331 for a.e .
@xmath332 , then @xmath333 consists of at most two points of @xmath119 for a.e . @xmath332 .
the map @xmath97 thus induces an @xmath228-invariant borel map from @xmath29 into @xmath206 .
there exists an essentially unique borel partition @xmath334 such that @xmath331 for a.e .
@xmath335 and @xmath336 for a.e .
@xmath337 . to prove assertion ( i ) , we may assume that @xmath119 contains at least three points .
if there were a borel subset @xmath230 of positive measure with @xmath338 for each @xmath233 , then the restriction of the product measure @xmath339 on @xmath340 to @xmath341 would not be zero for each @xmath233 . by normalizing the restricted measure and by composing the map
@xmath342 we obtain an @xmath228-invariant borel map from @xmath85 into @xmath315 .
this contradicts condition ( i ) for @xmath96 in definition [ defn - c - f ] because @xmath228 is of infinite type .
assertion ( i ) is proved .
we next prove assertion ( ii ) . if there were a borel subset @xmath230 such that for any @xmath233 , both @xmath343 and @xmath344 are positive
, then we would have two @xmath228-invariant borel maps @xmath345 the latter is obtained by using the map @xmath296 .
the map @xmath346 is then @xmath228-invariant .
we can deduce a contradiction as in the proof of assertion ( i ) .
assertion ( ii ) thus follows .
[ lem - inv - spe ] we define @xmath67 , @xmath4 , @xmath96 , @xmath29 , @xmath228 and @xmath97 as in lemma [ lem - two - supp ] .
let @xmath334 be the partition in lemma [ lem - two - supp ] ( ii ) .
then we have two @xmath228-invariant borel maps @xmath347 satisfying the following two conditions : 1 . for each @xmath223 ,
let @xmath348 be a borel subset of @xmath349 with positive measure and @xmath350 an @xmath228-invariant borel map .
then the inclusions @xmath351 hold for a.e .
@xmath352 and a.e .
2 . if @xmath234 is a subgroupoid of @xmath68 with @xmath354 , then @xmath226 and @xmath227 are @xmath234-invariant .
the construction of @xmath226 is almost the same as that of @xmath236 in lemma [ lem - inv - s ] .
let @xmath237 denote the set of all @xmath228-invariant borel maps from @xmath355 into @xmath327 .
it follows from lemma [ lem - two - supp ] ( ii ) that each @xmath238 satisfies the equality @xmath331 for a.e .
@xmath335 . for each @xmath238 , we set @xmath356 there exists @xmath357 with @xmath358 .
this map @xmath226 then satisfies condition ( a ) .
the existence of @xmath227 follows from lemma [ lem - inv - s ] . if @xmath234 is a subgroupoid of @xmath68 with @xmath354 , then @xmath227 is @xmath234-invariant by lemma [ lem - inv - s ] ( ii ) .
an argument of the same kind as in the proof of lemma [ lem - inv - s ] ( ii ) shows that @xmath226 is @xmath234-invariant . combining results on invariant borel maps proved in section [ subsec - nat - maps ] , we obtain the following hereditary property of groups in class @xmath41 .
[ prop - ex - c ] let @xmath3 be a discrete group .
suppose that we have a positive integer @xmath114 and infinite subgroups @xmath359 and @xmath360 for @xmath361 satisfying the following three conditions : * for each @xmath361 , we have @xmath362 . * for each @xmath363 , we have @xmath364 and @xmath365 .
* @xmath3 is generated by @xmath366 .
if @xmath0 belongs to @xmath41 , then so does @xmath3 .
let @xmath9 be a measure - preserving action on a standard probability space , and let @xmath213 be a borel cocycle satisfying the three conditions in definition [ defn - c - f ] . for each @xmath361
, we set @xmath367 since @xmath0 belongs to @xmath41 , there exists a @xmath368-invariant borel map from @xmath8 into @xmath120 , which is obviously @xmath369-invariant . applying lemma [ lem - inv - s ] ( ii ) , we obtain a @xmath370-invariant borel map from @xmath8 into @xmath211 . repeating this process , for each @xmath361 , one can find a @xmath371-invariant borel map from @xmath8 into @xmath211 . by lemma [ lem - inv - s ] , for each @xmath361 , there exist a @xmath371-invariant borel map @xmath372 and an @xmath373-invariant @xmath374 satisfying the following three conditions : * if @xmath375 is a @xmath371-invariant borel map , then we have @xmath376 for a.e . @xmath16 . *
if @xmath377 is an @xmath373-invariant borel map , then we have @xmath378 for a.e . @xmath16 .
* @xmath379 is @xmath371-invariant .
the first and third conditions imply that for each @xmath307 , the inclusion @xmath380 holds for a.e .
since @xmath381 is also @xmath373-invariant , the second condition implies that for each @xmath307 , the inclusion @xmath382 holds for a.e .
it follows that @xmath381 and @xmath379 coincide a.e .
on @xmath8 for each @xmath307 . on the other hand , for each @xmath363 , the inclusion @xmath383 implies that @xmath384 for a.e .
similarly , we have @xmath385 for a.e . @xmath16 .
the inclusion @xmath386 thus holds for a.e .
@xmath16 , and all @xmath381 coincide a.e . on @xmath8 .
this single map is then @xmath282-invariant since @xmath51 is generated by @xmath387 .
we now present examples of groups in class @xmath41 .
[ prop - exa - c ] a discrete group @xmath3 belongs to class @xmath41 if it is non - amenable and satisfies one of the following two conditions : 1 .
there is an infinite , amenable and normal subgroup @xmath131 of @xmath3 .
2 . there is an infinite normal subgroup @xmath131 of @xmath3 such that the pair @xmath388 satisfies relative property ( t ) of kazhdan - margulis .
let @xmath9 be a measure - preserving action on a standard probability space , and let @xmath213 be a borel cocycle satisfying the three conditions in definition [ defn - c - f ] .
we set @xmath389 in case ( a ) , since @xmath390 is amenable , there exists an @xmath390-invariant borel map from @xmath8 into @xmath327 . by lemma [ lem - two - supp ] ( ii )
, there exists a borel partition @xmath391 such that one can construct an @xmath390-invariant borel map from @xmath355 into @xmath206 and an @xmath390-invariant borel map from @xmath392 into @xmath211 .
since @xmath67 is nowhere amenable , the equality @xmath393 holds up to null sets by lemma [ lem - inv - spe ] and condition ( ii ) for @xmath96 .
we therefore obtain a @xmath67-invariant borel map from @xmath8 into @xmath211 . by using lemma [ lem - inv - ext ] and condition ( iii ) in definition [ defn - c - f ] ,
one obtains a @xmath67-invariant borel map from @xmath8 into @xmath120 .
it follows that @xmath3 belongs to @xmath41 . in case
( b ) , one can find an @xmath390-invariant borel map from @xmath8 into @xmath120 by a relative version of a theorem due to adams - spatzier @xcite .
lemma [ lem - inv - spe ] then implies existence of a @xmath67-invariant borel map from @xmath8 into @xmath120 .
[ prop - c - f - mcg ] let @xmath17 be a surface of genus @xmath25 with @xmath26 boundary components .
if @xmath30 , then any finite index subgroup of @xmath18 belongs to class @xmath41 . to prove this proposition , let us introduce terminology .
we say that a simple closed curve in @xmath17 is _ essential _ if it is neither homotopic to a point of @xmath17 nor isotopic to a boundary component of @xmath17 .
let @xmath394 denote the set of isotopy classes of essential simple closed curves in @xmath17 .
let @xmath395 denote the geometric intersection number , i.e. , the minimal cardinality of the intersection of representatives for two elements of @xmath394 .
the _ mapping class group _ @xmath396 of @xmath17 is defined to be the group of isotopy classes of orientation - preserving homeomorphisms from @xmath17 onto itself .
the _ pure mapping class group _ @xmath397 of @xmath17 is defined to be the group of isotopy classes of orientation - preserving homeomorphisms from @xmath17 onto itself fixing each boundary component of @xmath17 as a set .
note that @xmath396 and @xmath397 are finite index subgroups of @xmath18 .
if @xmath398 , then @xmath397 is generated by the dehn twists about curves in the family @xmath399 described in figure [ fig - seq ] ( a ) , where @xmath400 is excluded if @xmath401 .
if @xmath402 , then @xmath396 is generated by the half twists about curves in the family @xmath403 described in figure [ fig - seq ] ( b ) .
we refer to @xcite and theorem 4.5 in @xcite for these facts , respectively .
we first assume @xmath398 . we claim that it suffices to find a positive integer @xmath114 and @xmath404 satisfying the following two conditions : 1 .
@xmath405 for each @xmath363 and @xmath406 .
@xmath397 is generated by @xmath407 , where @xmath408 is the dehn twist about @xmath409 for each @xmath307 . for each @xmath361 ,
let @xmath360 be the infinite cyclic subgroup generated by @xmath410 , and let @xmath359 be the stabilizer of @xmath409 in @xmath397 .
it follows from the equality @xmath411 ( see lemma 4.1.c in @xcite ) that for each @xmath361 , @xmath360 is contained in the center of @xmath359 .
condition ( 1 ) implies @xmath364 for each @xmath363 and @xmath365 .
it follows from @xmath30 that each @xmath359 is non - amenable .
propositions [ prop - ex - c ] and [ prop - exa - c ] show that @xmath397 belongs to @xmath41 , and therefore so does any finite index subgroup of @xmath18 by proposition [ prop - basic - c ] ( i ) .
the claim follows .
we now find a sequence of curves satisfying conditions ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) . if @xmath412 , then the sequence @xmath413 is a desired one .
assume @xmath401 .
we have @xmath414 and define an essential curve @xmath415 as in figure [ fig - seq ] ( a ) . the sequence @xmath416 , @xmath415 , @xmath417 , @xmath418 , @xmath419 @xmath420 , @xmath417 , @xmath415 is a desired one .
we assume @xmath402 .
we then have @xmath421 . as in the first paragraph in the proof
, it is shown that it suffices to find a positive integer @xmath114 and @xmath404 satisfying condition ( 1 ) and the following condition : 1 .
@xmath396 is generated by @xmath422 , where @xmath423 is the half twist about @xmath409 for each @xmath307 .
if @xmath26 is odd , then the sequence @xmath416 , @xmath424 @xmath425 , @xmath426 , @xmath427 @xmath428 is a desired one . if @xmath26 is even , then the sequence @xmath416 , @xmath424 @xmath428 , @xmath426 , @xmath427 @xmath425 , @xmath429 is a desired one .
in section [ sec - coup - rigid ] , we will prove coupling rigidity of an amalgamated free product @xmath430 of discrete groups such that @xmath0 and @xmath1 belong to class @xmath41 and @xmath29 is an infinite , almost malnormal subgroup of both @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
it is however often difficult to find almost malnormal subgroups of a given group .
we now introduce class @xmath42 of discrete groups , smaller than class @xmath41 , so that coupling rigidity of @xmath430 will also be proved when @xmath0 and @xmath1 belong to @xmath42 and a milder condition is imposed on the subgroup @xmath29 . in this section
, we discuss basic properties and examples of groups in class @xmath42 .
[ defn - c - a ] we say that a discrete group @xmath3 belongs to class @xmath42 if @xmath3 is infinite and the following statement holds : let @xmath9 be a measure - preserving action on a standard probability space and @xmath43 the associated groupoid .
suppose that we have a tree @xmath4 with @xmath212 and a borel cocycle @xmath213 satisfying conditions ( ii ) and ( iii ) in definition [ defn - c - f ] and the following condition : 1 .
for any three mutually distinct vertices @xmath214 , the subgroupoid of @xmath67 defined as @xmath215 is amenable .
then there exists a @xmath94-invariant borel map @xmath220 .
let @xmath43 be a discrete measured groupoid on a standard probability space @xmath6 .
suppose that we have a tree @xmath4 with @xmath212 and a borel cocycle @xmath431 . in this subsection
, we introduce a canonical @xmath67-invariant borel map , called the fixed point map for @xmath67 .
this map will be used to find examples of groups in class @xmath42 .
let @xmath432 denote the set of all non - empty connected subtrees in @xmath4 , which can be identified with a subset of @xmath433 , the power set of @xmath120 .
we define a map @xmath434 as follows : pick @xmath435 . if @xmath436 , set @xmath437 . if @xmath438 , define @xmath439 as the shortest path in @xmath4 joining @xmath440 and @xmath441 . in the above notation , 1 .
the set @xmath432 is a borel subset of @xmath433 , where @xmath433 is equipped with the product topology .
2 . the map @xmath442 is borel .
let @xmath443 be the set of geodesics in @xmath4 whose lengths are at least one and finite .
for each @xmath444 , we identify @xmath445 with the set of vertices of @xmath4 through which @xmath445 passes and denote by @xmath446 the set of end vertices of @xmath445 .
we then have the equality @xmath447 which shows assertion ( i ) .
it then follows that the set @xmath448 consisting of all elements @xmath449 of @xmath450 with @xmath436 is borel and that the map @xmath451 is borel on @xmath448 .
pick @xmath444 and put @xmath452 . for each @xmath223 , let @xmath453 be the maximal connected subtree of @xmath4 containing @xmath454 and no other vertices of @xmath445 .
the set @xmath455 then consists of all elements @xmath449 of @xmath450 with either @xmath456 and @xmath457 or @xmath458 and @xmath459 .
assertion ( ii ) thus follows .
we say that a pair @xmath460 of @xmath160 and a borel subset @xmath29 of @xmath8 with positive measure is _
@xmath67-invariant _ if there exists a countable borel partition @xmath461 such that for each @xmath114 , the constant map on @xmath462 with its value @xmath176 is @xmath67-invariant . for each @xmath160 , there exists an essentially unique borel subset @xmath179 of @xmath8 such that if @xmath460 is a @xmath67-invariant pair , then @xmath29 is essentially contained in @xmath179 . the fixed point map for @xmath67 is defined by collecting all @xmath67-invariant pairs as follows .
we define a borel map @xmath463 so that we have @xmath464 if @xmath465 .
let us call @xmath466 the _ fixed point map _ for @xmath67 .
[ lem - fix - point ] in the above notation , the following assertions hold : 1 . if @xmath29 is a borel subset of @xmath8 with positive measure , then the fixed point map for @xmath68 is equal to the restriction of @xmath466 to @xmath29 .
if @xmath228 is a normal subgroupoid of @xmath67 , then the fixed point map for @xmath228 is @xmath67-invariant .
we have @xmath467 for a.e .
@xmath16 . for each @xmath160 and each borel subset @xmath85 of @xmath29 with positive measure
, the pair @xmath468 is @xmath68-invariant if and only if it is @xmath67-invariant .
assertion ( i ) thus follows .
assertion ( ii ) can be verified along an argument of the same kind as in the proof of lemma [ lem - inv - s ] ( ii ) .
assertion ( iii ) holds because for any two vertices @xmath193 , @xmath176 of @xmath4 , any automorphism of @xmath4 fixing each of @xmath193 and @xmath176 fixes each vertex in the geodesic connecting @xmath193 and @xmath176 .
we first present hereditary properties of groups in class @xmath42 .
[ prop - per - c - a ] class @xmath42 satisfies the following properties : 1 .
we have the inclusion @xmath469 .
2 . let @xmath3 and @xmath5 be discrete groups with @xmath255 and @xmath256<\infty$ ]
. then @xmath470 if and only if @xmath471 .
3 . if @xmath3 and @xmath5 are discrete groups with @xmath259 and @xmath471 , then @xmath470 . assertion ( i ) follows by definition .
we prove assertion ( iii ) .
let @xmath3 and @xmath5 be discrete groups with @xmath259 and @xmath471 . to prove @xmath470 , pick an action @xmath9 and a cocycle @xmath431 as in definition [ defn - c - a ] , where we put @xmath472 .
it follows from @xmath471 that @xmath5 is non - amenable and there exists a @xmath280-invariant borel map from @xmath8 into @xmath120 . using condition ( ia ) for @xmath96 and the method to construct the map @xmath236 in lemma [ lem - inv - s ] , we can find a @xmath280-invariant borel map @xmath281 such that if @xmath220 is a @xmath280-invariant borel map , then the inclusion @xmath232 holds for a.e .
this @xmath236 can be shown to be @xmath282-invariant since we have @xmath259 .
assertion ( iii ) then follows .
using assertion ( iii ) , we can show assertion ( ii ) along the same argument as in the proof of proposition [ prop - basic - c ] ( i ) .
the following proposition gives a sufficient condition for a discrete group to be in @xmath42 . for
a group @xmath19 and subgroups @xmath473 and @xmath474 of @xmath19 , let us write @xmath475 if we have @xmath476 and @xmath477 , where @xmath20 is the subgroup of @xmath19 generated by @xmath473 and @xmath474 .
[ prop - ex - c - a ] a discrete group @xmath3 belongs to class @xmath42 if there are subgroups @xmath478 of @xmath3 satisfying @xmath479 and the following five conditions : * for each @xmath480 , @xmath360 is non - amenable . * for each @xmath481 , we have @xmath482 .
* @xmath483 contains infinite amenable subgroups @xmath484 and @xmath485 which generate @xmath483 and satisfy @xmath486 for each @xmath487 . * for each @xmath487 , @xmath488 contains an infinite subgroup @xmath489 such that @xmath490 , and @xmath491 and @xmath492 generate the free product of them . *
@xmath3 is generated by @xmath478 . to prove this proposition , we need the following : [
lem - m - non - ame ] let @xmath493 and @xmath494 be infinite amenable groups and define @xmath495 to be the free product @xmath496 of them .
suppose that we have a measure - preserving action @xmath497 on a standard probability space , and let @xmath498 denote the associated groupoid . for each @xmath223 ,
let @xmath499 denote the subgroupoid of @xmath498 associated to the action of @xmath500 .
then for any borel subset @xmath29 of @xmath8 with positive measure , the groupoid @xmath501 is non - amenable .
we define @xmath4 to be the bass - serre tree associated to the decomposition @xmath502 ( see the paragraph right after theorem [ thm - coup - rigid ] for a definition of @xmath4 ) . let @xmath503 denote the vertices whose stabilizers in @xmath495 is equal to @xmath493 and @xmath494 , respectively . for each @xmath223 , let @xmath504 denote the set of vertices in the link of @xmath454 in @xmath4 . let @xmath505 be the @xmath500-equivariant map associating to each point @xmath59 in @xmath506 the single point in the intersection of @xmath504 with the geodesic between @xmath59 and @xmath454 . using this map @xmath507 and the assumption that @xmath500 is infinite , we can show that for each @xmath223 , the constant map on @xmath29 with its value the dirac measure on @xmath454 is the only @xmath499-invariant borel map from @xmath29 into @xmath327 .
we put @xmath508 .
if @xmath509 were amenable , then there would exist an @xmath509-invariant borel map from @xmath29 into @xmath327 , which is @xmath510-invariant and @xmath511-invariant .
this is a contradiction .
let @xmath9 be a measure - preserving action on a standard probability space and @xmath43 the associated groupoid .
let @xmath4 be a tree with @xmath212 and @xmath213 a borel cocycle satisfying condition ( ia ) in definition [ defn - c - a ] and conditions ( ii ) and ( iii ) in definition [ defn - c - f ] .
we set @xmath512 for each @xmath480 and each @xmath487 .
[ claim - inv - n ] for each @xmath487 , there exists an @xmath513-invariant borel map from @xmath8 into @xmath120 .
we prove the claim in the case of @xmath514 .
a verbatim argument can be applied in the other case .
let @xmath237 be the set of all @xmath515-invariant borel maps from @xmath8 into @xmath327 .
since @xmath484 is amenable , the set @xmath237 is non - empty . for each @xmath238
, we put @xmath516 there exists @xmath517 with @xmath518 .
we then have @xmath519 for a.e .
@xmath520 , where we put @xmath521 .
assuming @xmath522 , we deduce a contradiction .
if we furthermore assume that there exists a borel subset @xmath29 of @xmath12 with positive measure and @xmath523 for each @xmath332 , then we can find an @xmath515-invariant borel map from @xmath29 into @xmath120 by using the maps @xmath310 and @xmath296 introduced in section [ subsec - nat - maps ] , and this contradicts the maximality of @xmath524 .
we thus see that @xmath525 consists of at most two points for a.e .
@xmath520 and that @xmath526 induces an @xmath515-invariant borel map from @xmath12 into @xmath206 .
as in the proof of lemma [ lem - inv - spe ] , we can then find an @xmath369-invariant map from @xmath12 into @xmath206 .
since @xmath527 is non - amenable , this contradicts condition ( ii ) for @xmath96 . for each @xmath487 ,
let @xmath528 be the fixed point map for @xmath513 .
note that claim [ claim - inv - n ] implies @xmath529 for a.e .
we set @xmath530 there exists an @xmath369-invariant borel map from @xmath8 into @xmath211 .
we can find a countable borel partition @xmath531 and a vertex @xmath532 such that for each @xmath114 , the constant map on @xmath533 with its value @xmath534 is @xmath515-invariant and @xmath535-invariant .
we set @xmath536 for each @xmath487 and each @xmath114 .
since we have @xmath537 for each @xmath487 , for each @xmath114 , there exists an @xmath538-invariant borel map from @xmath533 into @xmath120 .
lemma [ lem - m - non - ame ] shows that @xmath538 is nowhere amenable . along an argument of the same kind
as in the proof of lemma [ lem - inv - s ] ( i ) , using condition ( ia ) for @xmath96 , we can construct a borel map @xmath539 which is @xmath538-invariant and @xmath369-invariant since we have @xmath540 for each @xmath114 . we therefore obtain an @xmath369-invariant borel map @xmath541 . on the other hand , the restrictions of @xmath542 and @xmath543 to @xmath294 are @xmath369-invariant by lemma [ lem - fix - point ] ( ii ) .
the map @xmath544 defined by @xmath545 for each @xmath546 is also @xmath369-invariant .
note that for a.e .
@xmath546 , the tree @xmath547 consists of at most finitely many vertices . using this @xmath226 and the map @xmath296 introduced in section [ subsec - nat - maps ] , we obtain an @xmath369-invariant borel map from @xmath294 into @xmath211 . along an argument of the same kind
as in the proof of lemma [ lem - inv - s ] ( i ) , using nowhere amenability of @xmath369 and condition ( ia ) for @xmath96 , we can find an @xmath369-invariant borel map @xmath548 satisfying the following condition : if @xmath29 is a borel subset of @xmath8 with positive measure and if @xmath549 is an @xmath369-invariant borel map , then we have the inclusion @xmath550 for a.e .
let us call this condition for @xmath551 the _ maximal condition _ as an @xmath369-invariant borel map .
we now prove that @xmath551 is @xmath67-invariant , and this concludes the proposition . as in lemma
[ lem - inv - s ] ( ii ) , the maximal condition implies that @xmath551 is also @xmath552-invariant and @xmath553-invariant because we have @xmath554 for each @xmath555 . as in the previous paragraph
, we can find an @xmath553-invariant borel map @xmath556 with the maximal condition as an @xmath553-invariant borel map .
the map @xmath557 is then @xmath369-invariant because we have @xmath558 .
the maximal conditions for @xmath551 and @xmath557 imply the equality @xmath559 for a.e .
@xmath16 . repeating this argument
, we conclude that @xmath551 is @xmath373-invariant for each @xmath560 and is @xmath67-invariant because @xmath3 is generated by @xmath561 .
we present applications of proposition [ prop - ex - c - a ] .
if @xmath562 are non - amenable discrete groups with @xmath479 and if @xmath0 contains a subgroup isomorphic to a non - abelian free group , then the direct product @xmath563 belongs to class @xmath42 .
setting @xmath564 , we identify each @xmath359 with a subgroup of @xmath3 .
let @xmath491 and @xmath492 be infinite cyclic subgroups of @xmath0 which generate the non - abelian free group of rank two .
we put @xmath565 and @xmath566 and define @xmath483 as the group generated by @xmath491 and @xmath492 . for each @xmath567
, we put @xmath568 and put @xmath569 . applying proposition
[ prop - ex - c - a ] , we see that @xmath3 belongs to @xmath42 .
[ prop - c - a - mcg ] let @xmath17 be a surface of genus @xmath25 with @xmath26 boundary components . if @xmath32 and @xmath33 , then any finite index subgroup of @xmath18 belongs to class @xmath42 .
we first note that if @xmath325 and @xmath570 are elements of @xmath394 with @xmath571 , then the squares of the dehn twists about @xmath325 and @xmath570 generate the non - abelian free group of rank two ( see theorem 3.2 in @xcite ) . as mentioned right after proposition [ prop - c - f - mcg ] , if @xmath398 , then the dehn twists about curves in the family @xmath572 described in figure [ fig - seq ] ( a ) generate @xmath397 , where @xmath400 is excluded if @xmath401 .
when @xmath398 , we aim to construct a sequence of pairs of curves in @xmath17 , @xmath573 such that 1 .
@xmath574 for any @xmath575 ; 2 .
@xmath576 for any @xmath577 and any @xmath578 ; and 3 .
@xmath579 .
once such a sequence is found , for each @xmath575 , we define @xmath360 as the subgroup of @xmath397 generated by the dehn twists about @xmath580 and @xmath581 .
condition ( 1 ) implies that each @xmath360 contains a non - abelian free subgroup .
condition ( 2 ) implies that for each @xmath577 , any element of @xmath360 and any element of @xmath582 commute .
condition ( 3 ) implies that @xmath583 generate @xmath397 . by proposition [ prop - ex - c - a ]
, @xmath397 belongs to @xmath42 .
it follows from proposition [ prop - per - c - a ] ( ii ) that any finite index subgroup of @xmath18 belongs to @xmath42 .
_ case @xmath39_. we define a curve @xmath584 in @xmath17 as in figure [ fig - seq ] ( a ) and put @xmath585 .
the sequence of pairs of curves in @xmath17 , @xmath586 then satisfies conditions ( 1)(3 ) .
_ case @xmath587 and @xmath414_. we put @xmath588 .
let @xmath415 be the curve described in figure [ fig - seq ] ( a ) , which is essential because @xmath414 .
the sequence of pairs of curves in @xmath17 , @xmath589 then satisfies conditions ( 1)(3 ) .
_ case @xmath401 and @xmath590_. we put @xmath591 . for each @xmath592 , choose two curves @xmath593 with @xmath594 for any @xmath487 . they exist because @xmath590 .
the sequence of pairs of curves in @xmath17 , @xmath595 then satisfies conditions ( 1)(3 ) .
_ case @xmath402 and @xmath596_. label boundary components of @xmath17 as @xmath597 , where indices are regarded as elements of @xmath598 . for each @xmath599
, we define a curve @xmath600 as described in figure [ fig - seq ] ( b ) .
we put @xmath601 .
as mentioned right after proposition [ prop - c - f - mcg ] , the half twists about curves in @xmath300 generate @xmath396 .
the sequence of pairs of curves in @xmath17 , @xmath602 then satisfies conditions ( 1)(3 ) .
a verbatim argument shows that any finite index subgroup of @xmath18 belongs to @xmath42 .
one can also prove that if either @xmath603 or @xmath604 , then for any finite index subgroup @xmath3 of @xmath18 , there exists no collection of at least two subgroups of @xmath3 , @xmath478 , satisfying all the assumptions in proposition [ prop - ex - c - a ] .
we do not present a proof of this fact because it will not be used in the sequel .
we begin with the definition of measure equivalence ( see @xcite for basics ) .
[ defn - me ] two discrete groups @xmath3 and @xmath5 are said to be _ measure equivalent ( me ) _ if one has a standard borel space @xmath605 with a @xmath49-finite positive measure and a measure - preserving action of @xmath606 on @xmath605 such that there exist borel subsets @xmath607 of finite measure satisfying the equality @xmath608 up to @xmath609-null sets . in this case
, the space @xmath605 equipped with the action of @xmath606 is called a _ coupling _ of @xmath3 and @xmath5 . when @xmath3 and @xmath5 are me , we write @xmath610
. let @xmath3 be a discrete group .
we mean by a _ self - coupling _ of @xmath3 a coupling of @xmath3 with itself .
given a homomorphism from @xmath3 into a standard borel group @xmath19 , we define a rigidity property of self - couplings of @xmath3 , called coupling rigidity .
once this property is obtained , for any discrete group @xmath5 with @xmath610 , one gets a homomorphism from @xmath5 into @xmath19 thanks to a theorem due to furman @xcite ( see theorem 3.5 in @xcite for a precise statement ) .
this leads to understanding of structure of @xmath5 .
[ defn - coup - rigid ] let @xmath3 be a discrete group , @xmath19 a standard borel group and @xmath611 a homomorphism .
we say that @xmath3 is _ coupling rigid _ with respect to the pair @xmath612 if * for any self - coupling @xmath613 of @xmath3 , there exists an almost @xmath614-equivariant borel map @xmath615 , where the action of @xmath616 on @xmath19 is defined by the formula @xmath617 for any @xmath58 and @xmath618 ; and * the dirac measure on the neutral element of @xmath19 is the only probability measure on @xmath19 that is invariant under conjugation by any element of @xmath619 .
when @xmath620 is understood from the context , @xmath3 is simply said to be coupling rigid with respect to @xmath19 .
it is known that if @xmath17 is a surface of genus @xmath25 with @xmath26 boundary components satisfying @xmath30 and @xmath31 , then any finite index subgroup @xmath3 of @xmath18 is coupling rigid with respect to the pair @xmath621 , where @xmath622 is the inclusion of @xmath3 into @xmath18 ( see corollary 5.9 of @xcite ) . as a consequence of argument
so far , we obtain the following coupling rigidity of amalgamated free products of discrete groups in classes @xmath41 and @xmath42 .
[ thm - coup - rigid ] let @xmath2 be an amalgamated free product of discrete groups such that @xmath29 is infinite and proper in @xmath359 for each @xmath223 ; and either of the following conditions ( a ) or ( b ) holds : 1 . for each @xmath223 , we have @xmath623 , and the group @xmath624 is finite for each @xmath625 .
2 . for each @xmath223
, we have @xmath626 , the group @xmath624 is amenable for each @xmath625 , and the equality @xmath627 holds .
then @xmath3 is coupling rigid with respect to the pair @xmath628 , where @xmath4 is the bass - serre tree associated with the decomposition @xmath2 and @xmath629 is the homomorphism arising from the action of @xmath3 on @xmath4 .
let us recall the bass - serre tree @xmath4 associated with an amalgamated free product @xmath2 .
we refer to @xcite for details .
the sets of vertices and edges of @xmath4 are defined to be @xmath630 respectively . for each @xmath56 , the edge corresponding to the coset
@xmath631 joins the two vertices corresponding to the cosets @xmath632 and @xmath633 .
the group @xmath3 then acts on @xmath4 as simplicial automorphisms by left multiplication .
most of the proof is a verbatim translation of that of theorem 4.4 in @xcite .
let @xmath613 be a self - coupling of @xmath3 .
to distinguish the two actions of @xmath3 on @xmath613 , we put @xmath634 and @xmath635 .
let @xmath636 be a fundamental domain for the action of @xmath637 on @xmath613 .
we then have the natural action of @xmath638 on @xmath8 and the me cocycle @xmath221 defined by the condition @xmath639 for each @xmath56 and a.e .
we denote by @xmath67 the groupoid associated with the action @xmath640 . for each @xmath160
, we define a subgroupoid @xmath641 of @xmath67 by setting @xmath642 .
pick @xmath160 .
the first step for the proof of theorem 4.4 in @xcite is to find a @xmath643-invariant borel map @xmath644 . in that proof
, we found it by using property ( t ) of @xmath641 . in the present setting
, the stabilizer in @xmath3 of any two distinct edges of @xmath4 is contained in a conjugate of @xmath624 for some @xmath645 , which is finite ( resp .
amenable ) if we assume condition ( a ) ( resp .
the composition of the cocycle @xmath221 and the homomorphism @xmath629 thus satisfies condition ( i ) in definition [ defn - c - f ] ( resp .
condition ( ia ) in definition [ defn - c - a ] ) .
it satisfies condition ( ii ) by proposition [ prop - ame - subgrd ] and corollary [ cor - ame - action ] and satisfies condition ( iii ) because @xmath3 acts on @xmath4 without inversions . since @xmath182 belongs to class @xmath41 ( resp .
@xmath42 ) , there exists a @xmath643-invariant borel map from @xmath8 into @xmath120 .
the rest of the proof is obtained by following the same argument as in the proof of the cited theorem .
let @xmath5 be a discrete group me to the group @xmath3 in theorem [ thm - coup - rigid ] .
as a consequence of that theorem , by the argument in section 5.1 of @xcite , we can find a subgroup @xmath646 of @xmath5 with its index at most two and a simplicial action of @xmath646 on @xmath4 without inversions .
moreover , for each simplex @xmath326 of @xmath4 , the stabilizer of @xmath326 in @xmath3 and that of @xmath326 in @xmath646 are me by lemma 5.2 in @xcite .
we refer to sections 5.2 and 5.4 in @xcite for results on the quotient graph for the action of @xmath646 on @xmath4 .
the following corollary is immediately obtained by combining theorem [ thm - coup - rigid ] with corollary 6.5 of @xcite .
let us say that a group @xmath19 is _ icc _ if any conjugacy class in @xmath19 other than @xmath647 consists of infinitely many elements .
[ cor - oer ]
let @xmath2 be the amalgamated free product in theorem [ thm - coup - rigid ] .
we now assume that for each @xmath223 , there exist a discrete group @xmath648 and an injective homomorphism @xmath649 such that @xmath359 is coupling rigid with respect to the pair @xmath650 .
let @xmath5 be a discrete group and suppose that two ergodic f.f.m.p .
actions @xmath9 and @xmath10 are woe .
we furthermore suppose the following two conditions : * if we denote by @xmath651 and @xmath652 the domain and range of the borel isomorphism , respectively , that gives the woe between the actions @xmath9 and @xmath10 , then we have @xmath653 ; and * either the action @xmath37 is aperiodic or both of the actions @xmath654 and @xmath655 are aperiodic , the action @xmath37 is ergodic , and @xmath29 is icc
. then we have @xmath656 , and the cocycle @xmath38 associated with the woe is cohomologous to the cocycle arising from an isomorphism from @xmath3 onto @xmath5 .
in particular , the two actions @xmath9 and @xmath10 are conjugate .
theorem [ thm - oer ] then follows from propositions [ prop - c - f - mcg ] and [ prop - c - a - mcg ] and the coupling rigidity of mapping class groups proved in corollary 5.9 of @xcite .
in this section , we present three kinds of subgroups @xmath29 of the mapping class group @xmath28 such that the group @xmath657 satisfies the assumption in theorem [ thm - coup - rigid ] . in section [ subsec - pa ] ( resp .
sections [ subsec - pants ] and [ subsec - disk ] ) , we present a subgroup @xmath29 for which @xmath657 satisfies condition ( a ) ( resp .
( b ) ) in that theorem . in section [ subsec - rem ] , we make a brief comment on difficulty of finding a subgroup @xmath29 with @xmath657 me rigid . throughout this section ,
we denote by @xmath17 a surface of genus @xmath25 with @xmath26 boundary components unless otherwise stated . in this subsection
, we assume @xmath30 . let @xmath658 denote the thurston boundary for @xmath17 .
this is an ideal boundary of the teichmller space for @xmath17 , and the group @xmath18 acts on it continuously .
the quotient of @xmath18 by its center , which is of order at most two , acts on @xmath659 faithfully .
we recommend the reader consult @xcite and @xcite for fundamental facts on @xmath659 .
pick a pseudo - anosov element @xmath660 .
it is known that there exist exactly two points @xmath661 of @xmath659 fixed by @xmath11 .
let us call the set @xmath662 the _ pair of pseudo - anosov foliations _ for @xmath11 .
the following two facts are also known : * the stabilizer of the pair @xmath662 in @xmath18 contains the cyclic subgroup generated by @xmath11 as a subgroup of finite index ( see lemma 5.10 in @xcite ) . * after exchanging @xmath663 and @xmath664 if necessary , for any compact subset @xmath100 of @xmath665 and any open neighborhood @xmath666 of @xmath663 in @xmath659 , we have @xmath667 for any sufficiently large @xmath114 ( see theorem 3.5 in @xcite ) .
[ lem - pa ] let @xmath3 be a finite index subgroup of @xmath18 .
pick a pseudo - anosov element @xmath660 and define @xmath29 to be the stabilizer of the pair of pseudo - anosov foliations for @xmath11 in @xmath3 .
then @xmath29 is almost malnormal in @xmath3 .
pick @xmath56 with @xmath669 infinite .
the first fact mentioned above implies that for some non - zero integer @xmath114 , we have @xmath670
. since @xmath671 fixes the pair @xmath672 , so does @xmath668 .
this implies @xmath673 and thus @xmath674 .
we assume @xmath30 . recall that @xmath394 denotes the set of isotopy classes of essential simple closed curves in @xmath17 .
we define @xmath675 to be the set of all non - empty finite subsets @xmath49 of @xmath394 with @xmath676 for any @xmath677 . for each @xmath678 , we denote by @xmath679 the surface obtained by cutting @xmath17 along mutually disjoint representatives of elements of @xmath49 .
this ambiguity will be of no importance in the sequel .
we put @xmath680 and call an element of @xmath681 a _ pants decomposition _ of @xmath17 .
we note that for each @xmath678 , we have @xmath682 if and only if each component of @xmath679 is homeomorphic to a pair of pants , i.e. , a surface of genus zero with three boundary components
. 1 . if @xmath684 , then the group generated by all dehn twists about curves in @xmath49 is of finite index in @xmath685 . in particular , @xmath685 is amenable .
2 . if @xmath686 satisfy @xmath687 , then the orbit for the action @xmath688 containing @xmath689 consists of infinitely many elements . assertion ( ii )
implies the equality @xmath690 for each @xmath678 .
let @xmath28 be a finite index subgroup of @xmath18 .
for each @xmath678 , we set @xmath691 .
it follows that for each @xmath684 , the group @xmath692 fulfills condition ( b ) in theorem [ thm - coup - rigid ] . for each surface @xmath693 ,
let @xmath694 denote the subset of @xmath695 consisting of all projective classes of pseudo - anosov foliations on @xmath693 associated to a pseudo - anosov element of @xmath696 . for each @xmath678
, we define a subset @xmath697 of @xmath659 to be the set of all projective classes of measured foliations on @xmath17 defined as the sum @xmath698 with @xmath699 , @xmath700 and @xmath701 , where @xmath693 runs through all components of @xmath679 that are not homeomorphic to a pair of pants .
the reader should consult section 2 of @xcite for measured foliations and their sums . for each @xmath702 , we denote by @xmath703 the stabilizer of @xmath300 in @xmath18 . along the same argument as above
, one can verify that for each @xmath702 , the group @xmath703 is amenable and we have @xmath704 throughout this subsection , we assume @xmath17 to be a closed surface of genus at least two .
we first summarize known facts on teichmller disks , whose details and related topics are found in @xcite and @xcite .
let @xmath234 denote the teichmller space for @xmath17 .
pick a point @xmath705 and let @xmath8 be a riemann surface associated with @xmath59 . for each holomorphic quadratic differential @xmath97 on @xmath8 , one can construct a totally geodesic subspace @xmath706 of @xmath234 containing @xmath59 and isometric to the poincar disk , with respect to the teichmller metric on @xmath234 . this @xmath706 is called the _ teichmller disk _ determined by @xmath97 .
we now focus on the stabilizer @xmath707 of @xmath706 for the action of @xmath18 on @xmath234 .
we have the homomorphism @xmath708 where @xmath709 is the isometry group of @xmath706 .
since the action of @xmath18 on @xmath234 is properly discontinuous ( see chapter 8 in @xcite ) , @xmath710 is finite and @xmath711 is discrete in @xmath712 .
the group @xmath713 is often called the _ veech group _ for @xmath706 .
let us recall fundamental properties of teichmller disks . 1 .
if @xmath715 is elliptic or the identity , then @xmath11 is of finite order .
2 . if @xmath715 is parabolic , then @xmath11 is reducible .
3 . if @xmath715 is hyperbolic , then @xmath11 is pseudo - anosov . 1 . for any two teichmller disks @xmath716 and @xmath717 in @xmath234 , we have @xmath718 if and only if @xmath719 .
2 . for any pseudo - anosov element @xmath660 ,
there exists exactly one teichmller disk @xmath706 with @xmath720 . in the last theorem , assertion ( i )
is proved in lemma 3.1 of @xcite , and assertion ( ii ) follows from assertion ( i ) and the fact that for each pseudo - anosov element @xmath11 , there exists exactly one geodesic in @xmath234 stabilized by @xmath11 .
this is proved by combining results in sections 6 and 9 of @xcite and theorem 7.3.a of @xcite . using these theorems , we obtain the following : [ lem - teich ] let @xmath3 be a finite index subgroup of @xmath18 , and pick a pseudo - anosov element @xmath660 .
let @xmath706 be the teichmller disk with @xmath720 , and set @xmath721 .
then the equality @xmath722 holds and the group @xmath669 is amenable for each @xmath723 .
pick @xmath723 and put @xmath724 .
the group @xmath85 is equal to @xmath725 .
if the index @xmath726 $ ] were finite , then for some positive integer @xmath114 , @xmath668 would lie in @xmath85 .
since @xmath727 , this contradicts theorem [ thm - disk2 ] ( ii ) .
we thus obtain the equality @xmath722 .
theorem [ thm - disk1 ] and theorem [ thm - disk2 ] ( ii ) imply that each element of @xmath728 acts on @xmath706 as an elliptic or parabolic isometry .
it then follows from theorem 2.4.4 of @xcite that @xmath729 is an elementary subgroup of @xmath730 and is thus amenable . 1 . an infinite , icc , proper and almost malnormal subgroup @xmath29 of @xmath18 when @xmath30 and @xmath31 ; or 2 . an icc and proper subgroup @xmath29 of @xmath18 such that we have the equality @xmath731 and the group @xmath669 is amenable for each @xmath732 when @xmath32 and @xmath33 , then the following rigidity result is obtained as a consequence of theorem 7.10 of @xcite and theorem [ thm - coup - rigid ] : for each finite index subgroup @xmath28 of @xmath18 , the amalgamated free product @xmath733 is coupling rigid with respect to the abstract commensurator of @xmath3 .
in particular , @xmath3 is _ me rigid _
, that is , any discrete group me to @xmath3 is virtually isomorphic to @xmath3 .
we can also obtain a rigidity property of every ergodic f.f.m.p .
action of @xmath3 .
it however seems difficult to find a subgroup @xmath29 of @xmath18 satisfying the above condition ( 1 ) or ( 2 ) .
the following proposition shows that it is impossible to find an @xmath29 satisfying condition ( 1 ) in the class of subgroups of @xmath18 containing a reducible element of infinite order .
we say that an element @xmath734 is _ reducible _ if @xmath11 fixes an element of @xmath675 .
let @xmath17 be a surface with @xmath30 , and let @xmath28 be a subgroup of @xmath18 containing a reducible element of infinite order .
if @xmath28 is almost malnormal in @xmath18 , then the equality @xmath735 holds .
recall that we have the equality @xmath736 where @xmath737 denotes the dehn twist about @xmath738 ( see lemma 4.1.c in @xcite ) .
let @xmath739 be a reducible element of infinite order and choose @xmath740 and a positive integer @xmath114 with @xmath741 and @xmath742 .
the above equality shows that @xmath743 and @xmath668 commute .
it follows that @xmath743 belongs to @xmath28 since @xmath28 is almost malnormal in @xmath18 .
the following results on teichmller disks show us difficulty of finding a subgroup @xmath29 of @xmath18 satisfying condition ( 2 ) . as discussed in section 1.8 of @xcite , there is a one - to - one correspondence between integrable meromorphic quadratic differentials on @xmath17 and flat structures on @xmath17 with cone singularities .
the latter viewpoint is often helpful in understanding the group @xmath707 for a teichmller disk @xmath706 . among other things , examples of @xmath706 with @xmath711 a lattice in @xmath712
are found in @xcite ( see also section 5 in @xcite ) .
notice that any lattice in @xmath712 is icc .
many such examples of @xmath706 are obtained by using billiards in rational polygons .
we refer to section 1 in @xcite for construction of the flat structure on @xmath17 associated to the billiard in a rational polygon .
proposition 3 in @xcite however shows that if @xmath706 is the teichmller disk associated to such a billiard , then @xmath710 is non - trivial .
it follows that @xmath707 can not be icc since @xmath710 is finite . c. j. earle and f. p. gardiner , teichmller disks and veech s @xmath750-structures , in _ extremal riemann surfaces _
( san francisco , ca , 1995 ) , 165189 , contemp .
, 201 , amer .
soc . , providence , ri , 1997 .
s. vaes , rigidity for von neumann algebras and their invariants , in _ proceedings of the international congress of mathematicians ( hyderabad , india , 2010 ) , vol .
iii _ , 16241650 , hindustan book agency , 2010 . | we present amalgamated free products satisfying coupling rigidity with respect to the automorphism group of the associated bass - serre tree . as an application
, we obtain orbit equivalence rigidity for amalgamated free products of mapping class groups . |
the average continuum observed in active galactic nuclei ( agn ) is shown in fig . 1 from the optical to x - ray range , as obtained from a composite optical - uv spectrum of francis et al .
( 1991 ) and zheng et al .
( 1997 ) , and from an average ( slightly modified ) soft x - ray spectrum of laor et al .
it is widely admitted since several years that the optical - uv part of this continuum is produced by a warm ( temperature of the order of @xmath2 k ) , optically thick or effectively thick medium , most likely an accretion disc .
moreover , one deduces from the spectral distribution in the hard x - ray range , in particular the 30 kev hump observed in many seyfert 1 galaxies , and from the presence of other features like the iron k line around 7 kev , that this medium is irradiated by a hard x - ray source , which is partly reprocessed and reemitted ( improperly named reflected " ) .
so one sees a combination of the primary and of the reflected spectra ( ross & fabian 1993 , and many subsequent works ) . in another interpretation the uv - x continuum is produced by clouds from a disrupted disk ( collin - souffrin et al .
1996 , czerny & dumont 1998 ) , and in this case one would also see the spectrum emitted by the non illuminated surface of the clouds . in both interpretations
the uv - soft x spectrum is emitted by a dense and thick shell ( density higher than 10@xmath3 @xmath4 , thomson thickness higher than unity ) , irradiated by an x - ray continuum .
similar conditions are met in x - ray binary stars .
it is necessary to compute the structure of such an irradiated medium to predict the observed spectrum .
therefore one has to build `` intermediate''codes , between those designed for planetary nebulae or narrow or broad line regions in agn , and those designed for stellar atmospheres .
these codes have to be valid for thick or semi - infinite dense media , eventually hot , irradiated by a non thermal continuum extending in the hard x - rays , to cover the whole range of situations encompassed in agn and in binary stars .
owing to the high optical thickness of the medium in several frequency ranges , such codes require that the transfer of both the continuum and the lines be solved in an `` exact '' way , that is avoiding approximations such as local escape approximation ( for the lines ) or one stream approximation ( for the continuum ) . since the medium is generally dense and sometimes close to local thermodynamical equilibrium ( lte ) , they require that all processes and inverse processes be carefully handled .
being irradiated by an x - ray continuum , the medium contains a large number of ionic species , from low to high ionization , which should all be introduced in the computation .
finally , the medium being hot and thick , not only thomson , but also compton scattering , should be taken into account .
we have undertaken to build a code which satisfies these requirements , to compute the emission spectrum produced by irradiated thick and hot media like those commonly assumed in agn close to the black hole , in a wide range of photon energy .
precisely we have built several interconnected codes , which allow more flexibility .
the ensemble is far from being perfect and still contains several approximations which restrict its use , but we improve it gradually . titan is designed to study the structure of a warm or hot thick photoionized gas , and to compute its emission - reflection - transmission spectrum from the infrared up to about 20 kev .
it solves the energy balance , the ionization and the statistical equilibria , the transfer equations , in a plane - parallel geometry , for the lines and the continuum .
then , given the thermal and ionization stratification , the computation of the emitted spectrum from 1 kev to a few hundreds kev is performed with noar which uses a monte - carlo method taking into account direct and inverse compton scattering ( it allows also to study various geometries ) . in a previous paper ( dumont , abrassart & collin 2000 ) titan and its interconnection with noar were described .
we recall here the main characteristics of the code , and we describe recent improvements as well as new results , focussing only on the aspects which are not treated in a standard way .
we briefly summarize below the physical processes ( section 2 ) , the transfer method and the iteration procedure ( section 3 ) .
the influence of the physical parameters , of the atomic data , and of the density distribution , are discussed in section 4 .
the coupling of titan and noar is briefly described in section 5 .
in titan , the physical state of the gas ( temperature , ionic abundances and level populations of all ionic species ) , is computed at each depth , assuming stationary state , i.e. : local balance between ionizations and recombinations , local balance between excitations and deexcitations , local energy balance , and finally total energy balance ( equality between inward and outward fluxes ) .
the ionization equilibrium equations include radiative ionizations by continuum and line photons , collisional ionizations and recombinations , radiative and dielectronic recombinations , charge transfer by h and he atoms , the auger effects , and ionizations by high energy electrons arising from ionizations by x - ray photons . the emission - absorption mechanisms of the continuum include free - free and free - bound processes , two - photon process , and thomson electron scattering .
inverse processes ( except autoionization for dielectronic recombinations , and recombinations onto excited levels for some ions , see next section ) are computed through the equations of detailed balance .
induced processes are taken into account .
energy balance equations include the same processes and compton heating / cooling .
hydrogen and hydrogen - like ions are treated as 5 or 6-level atoms . in a first step , in order to save computation time , non hydrogen - like ions were treated with a rough approximation : interlocking between excited levels was neglected and the populations of excited levels were computed separately using a two - level approximation .
this approximation does not predict correctly the details of the line spectrum , including the resonance lines themselves .
moreover ionizations from excited levels were not taken into account , though recombinations onto excited states were taken into account in the ionization equilibrium .
this approach is is not correct close to lte , and even far from lte , if ones wants to predict accurately detailed spectral features ( cf .
section 4.2 ) .
however it gives a correct overall spectral distribution in this last case .
such are the upper layers of an irradiated atmosphere where at the same time the fractional abundances of heavy elements in high ionization states are important , and the ground level of these ions is strongly overpopulated with respect to lte .
but it is not the case in the deep layers of a disk atmosphere , emitting the uv part of the spectrum , where the density is high , and the influence of the external irradiation is small .
this is why helium - like ions treated as complete 8-level atoms and lithium - like ions treated as complete 5-level atoms have been recently implemented in the code .
all processes are thus taken into account for each level .
this treatment is valid as far as the upper levels are in lte with the continuum . to handle intermediate cases ,
we replace the missing upper levels which are very important especially for helium - like ions by adding an additional recombination rate , not compensated by ionization . in the future we plane to add several other levels , and to sum the contributions of the higher levels to handle at the same time cases close to and cases far from lte .
photoionization cross sections are fitted from topbase ( cf .
cunto et al 1993 ) .
cross sections of neutral and once ionized heavy elements are not well represented , but they do not have any influence on these hot media .
the gas composition include 10 elements ( h , he , c , n , o , ne , mg , si , s , fe ) , and all their ionic species . the slab is divided in about 300 layers with variable thicknesses .
the code can work with a prescription for the density or for the pressure , such as a constant pressure or a pressure corresponding to hydrostatic equilibrium .
the external illumination can be characterized by an ionization parameter " , which we choose here as @xmath5 , @xmath6 being the frequency integrated flux incident on one side of the slab and @xmath7 the hydrogen number density at this surface .
note that there are several other definitions of the ionization parameter , for instance @xmath8 , or @xmath9 , but they correspond basically to the same concept , namely a parameter which determines the ionization state .
it is possible to take also into account a flux incident on the back side of the slab .
presently we mimic a semi - isotropic illumination , but with the ali transfer method which is implemented ( cf .
below ) it will be possible to take into account the angular distribution of the incident radiation .
we are concerned by media with a continuum optical thickness larger than unity in a range of frequencies rich in emission or in absorption lines , and having a very inhomogeneous structure .
moreover in the hot photoionized layers , the absorption coefficient is weak at all wavelengths and thomson diffusion is dominant . on
the contrary absorption dominates and must be carefully treated to compute the spectrum emitted by the non illuminated cold part of the medium .
radiation transfer requires therefore some attention .
the transfer equation is @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the distance to the illuminated surface , @xmath12 is the cosine of the angle between the normal and the light ray , @xmath13 is the absorption coefficient ( for the continuum it is due to photoionizations and free - free transitions ) , @xmath14 is the diffusion coefficient ( here thomson scattering ) , @xmath15 is the emissivity ( due to radiative recombinations and free - free emission ) , and @xmath16 is the mean intensity , equal to @xmath17 ( all these quantities are local , @xmath18 depends on the direction and on the frequency @xmath19 , and j , @xmath13 and @xmath15 depend on the frequency ) . introducing the source function @xmath20 and the optical depth @xmath21 , eq .
1 can be written : @xmath22 with @xmath23 which can be separated between j - dependent and j - independent components : @xmath24 the formal solution is : @xmath25 in the previous version of the code ( dumont et al .
2000 ) we used the same method for line and continuum transfer , described in section 3.2 .
presently the transfer of the continuum is performed with the * accelerated lambda iteration * method ( ali ) , which was set up with the help of subroutines kindly provided to us by f. paletou ( cf .
auer & paletou 1994 , and kunasz & auer 1988 ) . in this method @xmath26
is written with the help of an operator @xmath27 : @xmath28.\ ] ] ali uses an operator splitting , described first by cannon ( 1973 ) , then by olson et al .
( 1986 ) : @xmath29 where @xmath30 is an approximate @xmath31 operator chosen to facilitate the inversion , and @xmath32 has been calculated in the previous iteration .
one obtains : @xmath33^{-1 } [ s - s^*].\ ] ] we use here a parabolic interpolation in the evaluation of the integral giving the intensity from the source function , and an acceleration type ng ( in this method , at every fourth iteration a least squares extrapolation is made in order to reduce the residuals , cf .
ng 1974 ) . to perform this computation
, one needs to know the opacities and emissivities at each frequency as functions of @xmath11 , hence the temperature and the populations at each depth , so an iteration procedure is required .
* for each layer , starting from the illuminated side , the ionization and thermal balance equations are solved by iteration ; the temperature , the opacity and the emissivity are computed ; * when the back side of the cloud is reached , the transfer is solved with the ali method , and @xmath34 is computed ; * the whole calculation is repeated until convergence with the new values of @xmath34 .
it is stopped when the energy balance is achieved for the whole slab ( i.e. when the flux entering on both sides of the slab is equal to the flux coming out from both sides ) .
this method is almost as slow as the previous one , albeit more secure .
2 shows that the difference in the spectrum computed with the previous transfer method and with ali is very small .
it is certainly due to the fact that the continuum optical thickness is never very large ( at most 10@xmath1 ) .
this is not the case at the center of intense lines , which are typically 100 times thicker .
we are presently implementing ali for the line transfer and we expect to find more important differences for a few lines like oviii l@xmath35 which are not completely converged even after 1000 iterations ( cf .
dumont et al .
2000 ) .
since ali is presently not implemented for the line transfer , it is treated like in the previous version with a simple method based on the eddington two - stream approximation . in this approximation
the transfer equations are written : @xmath36 the mean intensity @xmath37 is equal to @xmath38 , and the flux @xmath39 defined as usual by @xmath40 is equal to @xmath41 . the reflected " flux is equal to @xmath42 , and the outward flux to @xmath43 .
the optical depth and the total optical depth are defined as : @xmath44 where @xmath45 is the total thickness of the slab . for @xmath46
the formal solution of the transfer equations between @xmath47 and @xmath11 is : @xmath48 we approximate the source function @xmath49 by a constant in the interval @xmath50 .
it leads to : @xmath51 \label{eq - trans6}\ ] ] and : @xmath52 .
\label{eq - trans7}\ ] ] we calculate @xmath53 and the mean intensity @xmath54 from eq . 3 and from : @xmath55 , \label{eq - trans10 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] assuming a constant @xmath56 ( actually it is not constant so the formulae are more complicated but do not deserve to be given here ) .
the procedure is then the following : * for each layer , after computation of the temperature and the source function , @xmath57 is transferred through the layer according to eq .
12 , while @xmath53 and @xmath58 are buffered for each layer and each frequency ; * when the back side of the cloud is reached , new values of @xmath59 are calculated , starting from the back side where @xmath60 is given by eq .
12 , and using eq . 13 with the previous values of @xmath53 and @xmath58 ( actually we use the values given by several previous iterations to accelerate the procedure with a ng method ) .
this method requires a large number of iterations to get a complete convergence of the model , and one can not be sure to have reached the correct value .
it is why we are now changing for the ali method .
we assume presently complete redistribution in the lines , and partial redistribution in intense lines is mimicked by assuming complete redistribution in a pure doppler profile .
it will be possible to treat partial redistribution with the ali method .
a line profile is represented by a voigt function at several frequencies distributed symmetrically around the line center .
the frequencies in the profile are chosen to take into account the fact that the doppler width may decrease by one order of magnitude inside the slab , owing to large temperature variations . moreover , to solve the statistical equilibrium equations one needs to know the total line intensity weighted by the profile @xmath61 , while to compute the thermal and ionization equilibria one simply needs the line intensity integrated over frequencies @xmath62 . for intense lines , the first integral is dominated by the doppler core , and the second by the wings .
the set of frequencies chosen to describe the line must therefore cover at least two orders of magnitude .
the integrals over the line profiles are achieved with a 15-point gauss - legendre quadrature .
we also assume that the lines do not overlap , which is valid as far as multiplets are treated globally , and because the number of lines taken into account in titan is relatively small ( presently 580 , including subordinate lines in the optical - uv range ) . as shown by fig .
3 , the profiles of @xmath63 and @xmath64 for oviii ly@xmath65 vary considerably from the surface to the deepest layers .
we shall call reference model " a model with the following characteristics : * it is a plan - parallel slab with a constant density , equal to 10@xmath3 @xmath4 , * its column density equals 10@xmath66 @xmath67 ( corresponding to a thomson thickness @xmath68 of 80 ) , * it is illuminated on one side by an incident power law continuum proportional to @xmath69 from 0.1 ev to 100 kev , * the ionization parameter is @xmath70 erg cm s@xmath71 , * there is no illumination on the other side , * the abundances are ( in number ) : h : 1 , he : 0.085 , c : 3.3 10@xmath72 ,
n : 9.1 10@xmath73 , o : 6.6 10@xmath72 , ne : 8.3 10@xmath73 , mg : 2.6 10@xmath73 , si : 3.3 10@xmath73 , s : 1.6 10@xmath73 , fe : 3.2 10@xmath73 . in several examples given below
, we also use a smaller value of the ionization parameter , @xmath74 ( corresponding to a value of the usual ionization parameter @xmath8 equal to 0.88 ) , allowing an easier comparison with computations made with cloudy or with xstar . figs .
4 and 5 show the results corresponding to different values of the ionization parameter , the other parameters being the same as in the reference model .
these results were obtained with the previous version of the code .
indeed each model takes a long time to run , and all models have still not been recalculated with the ali method .
however , we have checked in several cases that the results obtained with the new version differ very slightly from the previous ones .
4 displays the temperature versus the depth .
close to the surface the temperature is high and reaches the compton temperature for the highest value of @xmath75 .
the extension of this region ( called the hot skin " ) increases with the value of @xmath75 .
its optical thickness reaches @xmath76 for @xmath77 .
as we shall see later , this is quite different from the case of constant pressure , where the thickness of this zone is always limited to @xmath78 .
this hot skin is almost absent for low values of @xmath75 .
below the hot skin the temperature decreases smoothly , again at contradistinction with the case of a constant pressure .
this decrease is followed by a region of a quasi constant temperature , which is in a state of quasi - lte " , i.e. each process important for the energy equilibrium ( lines , free - bound from and onto ground levels , free - free ) is exactly balanced , due to the high optical thickness and relatively high density .
however the region is not in lte , in the sense that the fractional ionic abundances do not satisfy saha equations .
we shall discuss this issue in more detail in the next section . on fig .
5 are displayed the `` reflected '' spectrum emitted by the illuminated side of the slab , and the `` outward '' spectrum emitted by the back side .
note that the outward spectrum is distinct from the transmitted one , as it includes also _ emission _
( actually our transfer method does not allow to separate emission and transmission , contrary to approximate methods using for instance on the spot " approximation ) .
the outward spectrum lies only in the optical near uv range , owing to the low temperature of the back side ( cf .
this is due to the large column density of the model which does not allow any transmission in the x - ray range .
note the strong edges in emission ( including a balmer edge ) , and the cut off of the spectrum at a few tens of ev , due to absorption by heii and by low ionization heavy element species .
the reflected spectrum shows a characteristic shape with a smooth powerlaw " soft x - ray excess , and displays many lines and ionization edges whose intensity decreases with increasing values of @xmath75 , owing to the increasing influence of pure reflection when the ionization state increases . note that the lyman discontinuity is in emission for low @xmath75 and in absorption for high @xmath75 .
6 illustrates the influence of the column density on the reflected and on the outward spectra for @xmath79 , the other parameters being the same as in the reference model .
first we see that the reflected spectrum saturates " above 10@xmath80 @xmath67 , because all the available photons have been absorbed and no longer succeed in escaping from the illuminated side .
second , the optical - uv part of the outward spectrum saturates above 10@xmath80 @xmath67 , but not the x - ray part , which is due to transmission .
as the column density decreases , the slab becomes more transparent and less emissive , so the outward spectrum becomes basically only the transmitted spectrum , while the reflected spectrum decreases in intensity .
note that the saturation " of the reflected spectrum would occur at a larger value of the column density for a larger @xmath75 , as the hot reflecting skin becomes thicker .
it is thus _ necessary to take into account deeper layers , exceeding a thomson thickness @xmath68 of few units , to compute correctly the reflected spectrum in the uv range for @xmath81 , when dealing with constant density slabs_. this has always been overlooked in the past . in the first version of the code ,
non hydrogen - like ions were treated with a rough approximation : the populations of the excited levels were computed separately using a two - level approximation , i.e. interlocking between excited levels was neglected , as well as ionizations from these levels .
moreover only a very small number of levels ( at most four ) were taken into account .
however recombinations onto excited states were taken into account in the ionization equilibrium , and the transfer of these photons was treated in an approximative way , according to an escape probability formula proposed by canfield & ricchiazzi ( 1980 ) .
each recombination was also assumed to produce a resonant photon after cascades .
hydrogen and hydrogen - like ions were - and are - treated as 6-level atoms .
levels 2s and 2p are treated separately , while full l - mixing is assumed for higher levels .
all processes including collisional and radiative ionizations and recombinations are taken into account for each level ( cf .
mihalas 1978 ) . in the previous version ,
recombinations onto levels higher than five were not taken into account , which amounted assuming that the higher levels were in lte with the continuum .
it was true for hydrogen in the conditions in which this code is presently used , but not for other hydrogen - like ions .
we have therefore recently added recombinations onto higher levels , and we intend to implement fictive " levels to take ionizations from upper levels into account as it is done for instance in cloudy or xstar .
level populations are obtained as usual by matrix inversion .
the rough treatment of non hydrogen - like ions could have several consequences .
* first it should _ not predict correctly the details of the line spectrum _ , since it neglects subordinate lines and even important resonance lines . *
also it can lead to a _
bad estimation of the energy losses _ and consequently to a change of the temperature .
the recombination continuum corresponds generally to a smaller absorption coefficient than the neglected lines , and therefore can escape more easily from the deep layers .
it would correspond to an overestimation of the losses and an underestimation of the temperature .
but other parameters , such as the ionization state , play also a crucial role in the energy balance , so the net effect is difficult to predict . fortunately in these models cooling due to lines is not predominant except in some regions .
* it can lead to important errors in the _ fractional ion abundances_. this effect is self - cumulating " , as an increased proportion of a given ion leads to a stronger ionization edge , which in turns inhibits further photoionizations .
so again the net effect is not predictable . *
finally recombinations onto excited levels are not balanced by ionizations from these levels .
it is not important in conditions prevailing in a photoionized slab far from equilibrium ( like for instance in the hot skin of an irradiated accretion disk ) , as the lowest atom levels are strongly overpopulated with respect to lte . but this treatment is not valid in the innermost layers of a disk atmosphere , where the density is very high so complete lte is almost reached .
we have recently introduced interlocked multi - level computations for he - like and li - like ions , in order to obtain a better description of the spectrum , and to treat cases closer to lte .
however we are for the moment restricted to 8 levels for he - like ions and 5 for li - like ones , which is not sufficient close to lte .
we take into account recombinations onto the levels higher than 8 for he - like ions ( respectively 5 for li - like ) , adding them as a contribution to the recombination of the highest level .
this treatment is similar to the old one , except that it takes into account many subordinate lines and ionizations from excited levels , and it is valid as far as lte is not reached for the highest levels and ionizations are dominated by the ground level .
like for hydrogen - like ions we plane to add several other levels , and to mimic the contributions of the higher levels .
we mention also that radiative recombinations are computed differently according to the relative values of @xmath82 to the photon energy bin , in order to get an accurate frequency dependence . figs .
7 to 10 illustrate the influence of the new treatment with respect to the old one , for the reference model ( except that the thickness is only @xmath83 instead of 80 ; we have already mentioned that above this value nothing varies anymore for @xmath70 , cf .
4 ) . in this model
the level populations and the ionization degrees are far from lte , even in the deepest layers .
it is quite comparable to a classical photoionized model , where excited levels are populated by radiative recombinations and depopulated by deexcitations onto lower levels .
note that these results are obtained with the new transfer treatment .
7 shows the new temperature profile .
except at the surface @xmath84 is increased with respect to the previous computation .
the change is quite important , reaching a factor two in the transition layer .
8 shows the change of fractional abundances of hydrogen , helium , and iron .
it is relatively important in the hot skin for hei , but the abundance of this ion is completely negligible in this region , so it should not induce any change in the emitted spectrum around the ionization edge , i.e. 20 ev .
the result of a computation with full he - like and li - like atoms , but without additional recombinations on the highest level , is also shown . except precisely for hei in the hot skin ,
the results with and without the additional term are quite similar .
figs . 9 and 10
display the reflected spectrum for this model , computed with the old and the new atomic treatment , with a low resolution in the whole energy range ( fig .
9 ) , and with a higher resolution in a smallest but interesting energy range ( fig . 10 ) .
the spectral distribution does not differ much for the two treatments .
this is not the case of the detailed features , as it can be seen on fig .
the flux of the main lines of h - like ions in the reflected spectrum are almost not changed ( which is expected since the treatment is the same ) . for the he - like and
li - like ions , the total flux for all lines is multiplied by a factor 3 or 4 . to illustrate this effect , fig .
11 displays the fluxes of the ovi , ovii , and oviii lines .
even the resonant lines differ in both treatments , as the energy is distributed among a much larger number of lines : for instance the oviii line at 665 ev decreases by one order of magnitude with the new treatment .
the net increase of line flux is simply due to the redistribution of continuum recombination photons into line photons through cascades , an effect which was only partly taken into account in the previous treatment . besides
, we have added the result of a computation performed with the complete treatment of he - li - like ions , when suppressing the recombination rates added on the highest level ( cf .
figs . 9 and 10 ) .
this suppression does not affect at all the spectral distribution , and only slightly the detailed features of the spectrum .
the next further step is to introduce forbidden lines , which could be important for the cooling of the medium in some places .
note that all the results given in the following sections are obtained without li - like and he - like complete atom models .
: up to now , we have presented results only for slabs of constant density .
it is a peculiar case , as the pressure is thus varying according to the density and the temperature . when the pressure is imposed and not the density , one is faced to the well - known problem of thermal instability described first in the framework of agn by krolik , mckee & tarter ( 1981 ) .
if the pressure is imposed , three ( or even more ) solutions to the gain = loss equation can exist , and one of these solutions is unstable .
the gas has therefore to shift either to the compton dominated hot solution at a temperature close to the compton value , or to the cold solution dominated by atomic processes , at a few @xmath85 k. krolik et al
. were considering optically thin media with a uniform temperature , whose value is given by the external irradiating spectrum . here
we are considering a stationary case , where the temperature changes across the slab because the mean intensity @xmath37 is modified as a function of depth .
since @xmath37 is absorbed in the soft x - ray band , its spectral distribution becomes more dominated by uv as the depth increases , and such a spectrum does not lead to the s - shape curve characteristic of thermal instability ( cf .
krolik et al .
however , even if there is no instability , the temperature decreases very rapidly with increasing depth , as the constancy of the pressure leads to an increase of the density , therefore to an increase of the cooling , and to a further decrease of temperature ( note that the temperature is not strictly inversely proportional to the density , as radiation pressure generally exceeds gas pressure ) .
this is illustrated on fig .
12 which shows the gain - loss function versus the temperature for different layers .
the model is a slab with a constant pressure , a density at the surface equal to 10@xmath86 @xmath4 , an ionization parameter equal to 1000 .
the illuminating spectrum is a power law @xmath87 , chosen because such a flat spectrum is well known to correspond to an s - shape " curve with a strong instability .
however we see that as the temperature decreases with the depth , there are never multiple solutions of the gain = loss equation .
note that it is by no means a general result .
in particular , a medium with a more rapid variation of the pressure with the depth , like given by hydrostatic equilibrium , could likely lead to a thermal instability , as the transition to the cold region occurs in a region where the spectrum is less absorbed than in a constant density medium ( cf .
nayakshin , kazanas & kallman 2000 ) .
also if the uv band is absorbed before the soft x - ray one , which is the case when the ionization parameter is small , it should lead to a thermal instability .
13 displays the temperature versus depth for slabs of constant density and slabs of constant pressure , with different ionization parameters .
note that it would be better to speak of ionizing flux " instead of ionizing parameter in the constant pressure case .
actually the comparison is performed with the same incident fluxes . as expected , and
in contrast with the constant density case where there is a smooth decrease of the temperature with increasing depth , the constant pressure case gives a sharp transition between the hot and dilute , and the cold and dense , parts of the slab .
moreover the thickness of the hot skin " is smaller for the same flux in the constant pressure case , in particular for high illumination .
for instance , for @xmath70 the thomson thickness of the hot skin is about unity in the constant density case , and only 0.4 in the constant pressure case .
all these effects have strong consequences on the emission spectrum . for constant pressure
the spectrum displays a narrow uv bump , while the constant density the uv bump is more extended in frequency , as it corresponds to intermediate temperatures which do not exist in the constant pressure case ( cf .
the difference between the two cases is particularly apparent for high illumination , as expected .
it is interesting to note that the lyman edge is quite weak in the constant pressure case , since the uv spectrum is closer to a blackbody .
this is a point that constant density models have difficulties to account for in agn .
the distribution of fractional ionic abundances is also completely modified . as an illustration ,
15 displays the fractional abundances of iron versus depth .
the most remarkable difference is the presence at @xmath88 of low ionization species , such as feiv or fev , which are completely absent in the constant density case .
one notes also that the extension of highly ionized species is smaller than in the constant density case , as expected .
for instance fexiv is present up to @xmath89 for constant pressure , instead of @xmath90 for constant density . as a consequence ,
the iron k lines produced are different from the constant density , as we shall see later . : in order to describe an irradiated accretion disk , we have introduced in collaboration with a. rosanska and b. czerny a variation of the density given by the hydrostatic equilibrium law .
titan treats then only the layer at the surface of the disc where the diffusion approximation does not hold . in this case
there is a flux incident on the back side of the slab , equal to the flux generated by viscous dissipation inside the disk .
iterations are needed with the hydrostatic equilibrium equations ( for more details see raska et al .
2001 ) .
16 shows the results for the following case : @xmath91 m@xmath92 , @xmath93 , @xmath94 , and an x - ray irradiating powerlaw spectrum , with a spectral index 0.9 in flux , and an x - ray flux @xmath95 , i.e. equal to half the viscous flux .
note that the temperature decreases abruptly like in the constant pressure case , and that the hot skin is very thin .
the temperature reaches that given by viscous dissipation at about @xmath96 .
the reflected spectrum displays a prominent blue bump with no soft x - ray excess , and a strong absorption in the uv range due to low ionization species in the deep layers of the atmosphere .
it is important to note that such a spectrum differs strongly from that of an irradiated disc in which the density is assumed to be constant ( ross & fabian 1993 , and subsequent works , cf .
raska et al .
2001 for a detailed discussion ) .
our results are similar to those of nayakshin , kazanas & kallman ( 2000 ) .
in order to compute the effect of compton scattering on the high energy part of the reprocessed radiation and to determine precisely the compton heating - cooling rate in the energy balance equation , one needs another numerical approach . in this aim
abrassart ( 1998 ) developed a monte carlo code , noar ( cf .
dumont et al .
the asset of such an approach is also that it enables to investigate an arbitrary geometry and to determine the angular dependence of the observed spectra .
moreover , it allows to easily extract time variability information .
noar takes into account direct and inverse compton scattering , according to the method proposed by pozdniakov , sobol & sunyaev ( 1983 ) and by gorecki & wilczewski ( 1984 ) .
given all the fractional abundances and the temperature in each layer provided by titan , it computes the absorption cross sections in each layer .
free - free absorption is taken into account , as well as recombination continua of hydrogen and helium like ions ( the spectral distribution of the recombination continuum is determined by the local temperature ) .
the proper yields to account for the competition with the auger effect are used for the fluorescence lines .
fluorescence of iron xvii to xxiii is suppressed by resonant trapping ( but not in titan ) . for the pseudo fluorescence of iron xxv and xxvi ,
a simplifying prescription is adopted which includes the two most probable outcomes of a k shell photoionization , that is : direct recombination on ground level or l - k transition .
other line emission is not included .
one use of noar is to provide titan with the local compton gains and losses in each layer .
this is necessary , because compton heating - cooling is dominated by energy losses of photons @xmath97 20 kev for high values of @xmath75 . in dumont
et al . ( 2000 ) it was shown that given an incident spectrum the dependence of the compton heating - cooling over @xmath75 ratio on the thomson depth depends only slightly on @xmath75 except for high values of @xmath75 .
the compton heating - cooling rate obtained with noar is fitted analytically as a function of @xmath11 , which is transferred to titan .
the spectra computed with titan are then completed .
( cf . fig .
17 , and also figs .
14 and 16 ) .
titan and noar lead to similar energy distributions of the reflected spectra in the 1 - 20 kev range .
the reflected spectrum above 10 kev exhibits a `` compton hump '' depending on the high energy cut - off of the incident spectrum , which is here 100 kev , and on the ionization parameter .
the spectrum in the higher energy range is used for the energy balance .
comptonisation leads also to line broadening , and when it is important , to smearing of the ionization edges .
direct compton downscatterings produce a red wing , while inverse compton upscatterings produce a blue wing . the effect can be comparable to relativistic broadening near the black hole , and can account partly for the broad profiles of the iron line in agn ( abrassart & dumont 1998 ) . fig .
18 displays ( with a relatively high resolution , in order to show detailed features ) the spectrum around 7 kev in the constant density case , for different values of @xmath75 , the other parameters being as in the reference model . the feature near 7 kev is made of a mixture of iron edges and of several iron lines : - for @xmath75 equal to a few hundreds erg cm s@xmath71 , the iron line is dominated by low ionization stages , smaller than iron xvii ; the absorption edge is proeminent above 7 kev ; - for @xmath75 equal to @xmath98 erg cm s@xmath71 , fexxv and fexxvi lines are apparent , modified by compton scattering .
the lines are significantly broadened , the broadening is asymmetric , the profile is skewed towards the red .
the absorption edge is still important , but extends from 8 to 10 kev , due both to comptonization and to the influence of several edges ; - for @xmath75 equal to @xmath85 erg cm s@xmath71 , the line has a large red compton wing and a weak blue wing , and it is weak . the absorption edge is completely erased .
19 displays the iron line complex for the constant pressure case , to be compared to the constant density case . both a cold line " at 6.4 kev and fexxv and xxvi lines
are present in the constant pressure case , while only highly ionized species are visible in the constant density case . for constant pressure
the cold layers are indeed closer from the surface than in the constant density case , so the photons emitted by these layers are able to leave the medium .
the coupling of titan and noar allows to compute the structure and the emission of hot compton thick irradiated media , by solving consistently the energy balance of the medium .
moreover it allows also to take into account compton broadening of the lines and of the edges in the x - ray range . in the previous description of the code ( dumont et al .
2000 ) , we had already recalled the importance of the returning flux , which is often neglected , even for relatively low column densities , and we had compared the line transfer treatment for the lines with the escape probability approximation generally used in these problems . here
we have in addition stressed the influence of the pressure law , by showing the strong differences existing both in the structure and in the emitted spectrum , between a constant density medium , a constant pressure medium , or a medium in hydrostatic equilibrium .
we have also shown that the atom models are of fundamental importance as they determine the ionization state , the energy balance , the temperature , and in fine the detailed spectral features which will be soon accessible through x - ray spectroscopy .
the accelerated lambda iteration method is used now for the continuum .
we will soon implement it for the lines , which are the most difficult to converge .
it will in particular allow to treat partial redistribution in the lines . in collaboration with s. coupe and m.c .
artru ( coupe et al .
2001 ) we have begun to take into account subordinate lines for all ions by solving a complete multi - level atom for li - like and he - like ions , after h - like ions which were already introduced in the previous version of the code . in the future we plan to implement other iso - electronic sequences , and to add to the present ones several other levels .
in particular we will try to get a better representation of the highest levels for computations close to lte .
we will take into account forbidden lines , which could be important for the cooling of the medium in some places .
we also intend to add to the line transfer an option allowing the uv and soft x - ray photons to escape from the medium through compton scattering .
abrassart a. & dumont a .- m .
1998 , proceedings of the first xmm workshop on science with xmm " , m. dahlem ( ed . )
abrassart a. 1999 , proceedings of the 32nd cospar scientific assembly , nagoya , japan , advances in space research , vol 25 issue/3 - 4 , p 465 auer h.l . , paletou f. 1994 , a&a 284 , 675 canfield r.c . , ricchiazzi p.j .
1980 , apj 239 , 1036 cannon c.j .
1973 , j. quant .
radiat.transfer 13 , 627 cunto w. , mendoza c. , ochsenbein f. , zeippen c.j .
1993 , a&a 275 , l5 coupe s. , dumont a - m
. , artru , m - c . , collin s. 2001 , in preparation collin - souffrin s. , czerny b. , dumont , a. m. & zycki p.t .
1996 , a&a 314 , 393 czerny b. & dumont a .- m .
1998 , a&a , 338 , 386 dumont a .-
, abrassart a. , collin s. 2000 , a&a 357 , 823 francis p.j . ,
1991 , apj 373 , 465 ferland g.j . , korista t. , verner d.a . , ferguson j.w . , kingdom j.b
verner e.m . , 1998 ,
pasp 110 , 761 gorecki a. , wilczewski w. 1984 , acta astronomica 34 , 141 krolik , j.h . , mckee , c.f . , tarter , c. b. , 1981 , apj 249 , 422 kunasz p. & auer h. l. 1988 , j. quant .
transfer 39 , 67 laor , a. , fiore , f. , elvis , m. , wilkes , b.j . ,
mcdowell , j.c .
1997 , apj 477 , 93 ng k. c. 1974 , j. chem .
61 , 2680 olson g.l .
, auer l.h . ,
buchler j.r .
1986 , j. quant .
transfer 35 , 431 pozdniakov l.a .
, sobol i.m . ,
sunyaev r.a .
1983 , astrophysics and space physics reviews 2 , 189 ross r.r . , fabian a.c . , 1993 ,
mnras 261 , 74 raska a. , czerny b. , dumont a - m .
collin , s. 2001 , a&nnna , submitted zheng w. , kriss g.a .
, telfer r.c . ,
grimes j.p . , davidsen a.f . 1997 , apj 475 , 469 | we describe a code designed for hot media ( t @xmath0 a few 10@xmath1 k ) , optically thick to compton scattering .
it computes the structure of a plane - parallel slab of gas in thermal and ionization equilibrium , illuminated on one side or on both sides by a given spectrum .
this code has been presented in a previous paper ( dumont , abrassart & collin 2000 ) , where several aspects were already discussed .
so we focus here mainly on the recent developments .
presently the code solves the transfer of the continuum with the accelerated lambda iteration method ( ali ) and that of the lines in a two stream eddington approximation , without using the local escape probability formalism to approximate the line transfer .
this transfer code is coupled with a monte carlo code which allows to take into account direct and inverse compton diffusions , and to compute the spectrum emitted up to mev energies , in any geometry .
the influence of a few physical parameters is shown , and the importance of the density and pressure distribution ( constant density , pressure equilibrium , or hydrostatic equilibrium ) is stressed .
recent improvements in the treatment of the atomic data are described , and foreseen developments are mentioned .
# 1_#1 _ # 1_#1 _ = # 1 1.25 in .125 in .25 in |
motivated by the increasing body of evidence that most of the mass in the universe consists of invisible `` dark '' matter , and by the particle physicist s inference that this dark matter is made of exotic non - baryonic particles , a new and on the long run more fruitful approach to study the formation of galaxies has been developed : rather than to model the formation and evolution of galaxies from properties of present day galaxies , it is attempted to prescribe a set of reasonable initial conditions .
the evolution of galaxies is then modeled starting from these initial conditions .
physical processes are taken into account that are considered to be relevant such as gravity , gas dynamics , radiative cooling and star formation .
the outcome at different epochs is then confronted against observational data .
one scenario that has been extensively tested in that way is the model of hierarchical clustering , currently the most successful paradigm of structure formation in the universe . in this scenario ,
structure grows as objects of progressively larger mass merge and collapse to form newly virialized systems .
the probably best know representative of this class of models is the _ cold dark matter _
( cdm ) scenario .
the initial conditions consist of the cosmological parameters ( @xmath1 ) and of an initial fluctuation spectrum such as the cdm spectrum .
the remaining free parameter , the amplitude of these initial fluctuations , is calibrated by observational data , e.g. , the measured anisotropies of the microwave background . over the past few years
, limits on the values allowed for these parameters have been consistently refined by improved observational techniques and theoretical insight , and it is widely accepted that a new `` standard '' model has emerged as the clear front - runner amongst competing models of structure formation .
this @xmath2cdm model envisions an eternally expanding universe with the following properties ( bahcall et al.1999 ) : ( i ) matter makes up at present less than about a third of the critical density for closure ( @xmath3 ) ; ( ii ) a non - zero cosmological constant restores the flat geometry predicted by most inflationary models of the early universe ( @xmath4 ) ; ( iii ) the present rate of universal expansion is @xmath5 km s@xmath6 mpc@xmath6 ( @xmath7 km s@xmath6 mpc@xmath8 ) ; ( iv ) baryons make up a very small fraction of the mass of the universe ( @xmath9 ) ; and ( v ) the present - day _ rms _ mass fluctuations on spheres of radius 8 @xmath10 mpc is of order unity ( @xmath11 ) .
the hierarchical structure formation process in this @xmath2cdm scenario is illustrated in figure 1 , which depicts the growth of structure within a @xmath12mpc box between redshifts nine and zero .
the @xmath2cdm model is consistent with an impressive array of well - established fundamental observations such as the age of the universe as measured from the oldest stars , the extragalactic distance scale as measured by distant cepheids , the primordial abundance of the light elements , the baryonic mass fraction of galaxy clusters , the amplitude of the cosmic microwave background fluctuations measured by cobe , boomerang , maxima and dasi , the present - day abundance of massive galaxy clusters , the shape and amplitude of galaxy clustering patterns , the magnitude of large - scale coherent motions of galaxy systems , and the world geometry inferred from observations of distant type ia supernovae , among others .
the hierarchical build - up is also thought to determine the morphology of a galaxy , most noticeably the difference between disk like systems such as spiral galaxies ( some of them barred ) and spheroidal systems such as elliptical galaxies and bulges .
this picture envisions that whenever gas is accreted in a smooth fashion , it settles in rotationally supported disk - like structures in which gas is slowly transformed into stars .
mergers , however , convert disks into spheroids .
the hubble type of a galaxy is thus determined by a continuing sequence of destruction of disks by mergers , accompanied by the formation of spheroidal systems , followed by the reassembly of disks due to smooth accretion .
this picture of a hierarchical origin of galaxy morphology has been schematically incorporated in so - called semi - analytical galaxy formation models used to study the evolution of the galaxy population , but its validity in a cosmological setting has just recently been directly demonstrated ( steinmetz & navarro 2002 ) .
numerical simulations have been an integral part in the detailed analysis of the virtues of the cdm scenario .
only numerical techniques can account for the highly irregular structure formation process and for at least some of the complicated interaction between gravity and other relevant physical processes such as gas dynamical shocks , star formation and feedback processes .
simulations also provide the required interface to compare simulations with observational data and are able to link together different epochs .
while simulations of structure formation on the larger scales have mainly used large massively parallel supercomputers , studies how individual structures such as galaxies or clusters of galaxies form in the @xmath2cdm scenario have heavily used special purpose hardware like the grape ( = gravity pipe ) family of hardware n - body integrators ( sugimoto et al.1990 ) . in this review
i will concentrate on some examples , how high resolution gas dynamical simulation using special purpose hardware have illustrated some successes but also also some failures of @xmath2cdm scenario in reproducing structures as observed on the scales of galaxies .
although gas dynamical simulations were considerably successful in explaining some details of the galaxy formation process , the largest impact so far is related to the properties of qso absorption systems .
numerical simulations can reproduce the basic properties of qso absorbers covering many orders of magnitude in column density ( cen et al.1994 ; hernquist et al.1996 ; zhang , anninos & norman 1995 ) . indeed , gas dynamical simulations were even responsible for a paradigm shift , as qso absorbers are no longer considered to be caused by individual gas clouds .
absorbers of different column density ( ly-@xmath0forest , metal line systems , lyman limit systems and damped ly-@xmath0absorption systems ) are rather reflecting different aspects of the large - scale structure of the universe . while the lowest column density systems ( @xmath13 ) arises from gas in voids and sheets of the `` cosmic web '' ,
systems of higher column density are produced by filaments ( @xmath14 ) or even by gas that has cooled and collapsed in virialized halos ( @xmath15 ) .
the kinematics of damped ly-@xmath0absorption systems ( dlas ) at high redshift serves as a very nice example to demonstrate how oversimplifying assumptions may lead to wrong implications on the validity of a cosmological model , while a full numerical treatment can avoid those artificial contradictions .
dlass have often been interpreted as large , high - redshift progenitors of present - day spirals that have evolved little apart from forming stars ( wolfe 1988 ) .
kauffmann ( 1996 ) , however , studied the evolution of dlass in the cdm structure formation scenario in which disks form by continuous cooling and accretion of gas within a merging hierarchy of dark matter halos and found that the total cross section was dominated by disks with comparably low rotation velocities ( typically 70 km / sec ) .
prochaska & wolfe ( 1998 ) however , observed much larger velocity spreads ( up to 200km / s ) and came to the conclusion that only models in which the lines - of - sight ( los ) intersects rapidly rotating large galactic disks can explain both the large velocity spreads and the characteristic asymmetries of the observed low ionization species ( e.g. , siii ) absorption profiles , in strong contradiction to the prediction of the ( semi - analytical ) cold dark matter model .
so how may a numerical simulation solve this problem ?
the critical assumption that enters semi - analytical models is that dlass are equilibrium disks .
numerical simulations ( haehnelt , steinmetz & rauch 1998 ) demonstrate that this is a poor assumption and that asymmetries and non - equilibrium effects play an important role .
figure 2 shows a typical configuration that gives rise to a high redshift dlas with an asymmetric siii absorption profile .
the velocity width of about 120km / s is also quite similar that of typical observed systems .
no large disk has yet been developed and also the circular velocity of the collapsed object is only 70km / s .
the physical structures that underlie dlass are turbulent gas flows and inhomogeneous density structures related to the merging of two or more clumps , rather than large rotating disks similar to the milky way .
rotational motions of the gas play only a minor role for these absorption profiles .
a more detailed analysis also demonstrates that the numerical models easily pass the statistical tests proposed by prochaska and wolfe , i.e. , hierarchical clustering , in particular the cdm model , is consistent with the kinematics of high-@xmath16 dlass .
while the irregular structure of a galaxy in the process of formation was helpful to alleviate the problem concerning the kinematics of dlass , one may wonder whether it hurts the assembly of large galactic disks at low redshifts as major mergers are usually associated with the transformation of spirals into ellipticals ( for a review , see barnes & hernquist 1992 ) .
indeed , gas dynamical simulation are capable of producing disk like structures ( see also section 4 ) , but a closer inspection reveals that these model disks are too concentrated compared to observed spiral galaxies ( navarro & benz 1991 ; navarro , frenk & white 1995 ; navarro & steinmetz 1997 ) .
however , this problem is not encountered in semi - analytical models , which relatively easily can reproduce the sizes of present day galaxies .
one may again ask : what is the difference between the semi - analytical model ( mo , mao & white 1997 ) and the numerical simulations , in particular since they are based on the same structure formation model ? again , the reason can be found in the assumptions that enter the semi - analytical models : semi - analytical models assume that gas collapses under conservation of angular momentum ( fall & efstathiou 1980 ) , an assumption that , as will be shown , is only very poorly fulfilled .
figure 3 ( left ) shows the specific angular momentum of dark matter halos and of their central gaseous disks at @xmath17 , as a function of mass .
if , as suggested by fall & efstathiou ( 1980 ) , the collapse of gas would proceed under conservation of angular momentum , the baryonic component would have the same specific angular momentum @xmath18 as the dark matter , however , its corresponding mass would be a factor of 20 smaller ( for @xmath19 , @xmath20 cdm scenario .
the problem is , however , generic to all hierarchical models and can also be seen in more recent simulations of galaxy formation in a @xmath2cdm cosmology ] ) .
these disks would be located only slightly below the box for spiral galaxies .
however , figure 3 demonstrates clearly that the spins of gaseous disks are about an order of magnitude lower than that . this is a direct consequence of the formation process of the disks .
most of the disk mass is assembled through mergers between systems whose own gas component had previously collapsed to form centrally concentrated disks . during these mergers , and because of the spatial segregation between gas and dark matter , the gas component owing to dynamical friction transfers most of their orbital angular momentum to the surrounding halos . while the specific angular momentum of dark matter halos increases with decreasing redshift , that of gaseous disk decreases ( figure 3 , right ) .
up to now , it is unclear how this discrepancy can be overcome .
one potential solution envisions the presence of strong feedback processes ( weil et al . , 1998 , thacker & couchman 2002 ) that prevent gas form clumping early on and that thus reduce the transfer of angular momentum due to dynamical friction .
alternatively , the low angular momentum gas may be ejected during early phases of galaxy formation or absorbed in the bulge component ( dominguez - tenreiro et al.1998 , van den bosch et al . , 2002 ) .
if these solutions turn out to be unable to solve this problem , one may also have to consider modifying the cdm paradigm on the smallest scale , i.e. , reducing number of mergers , e.g. , by considering _ warm dark matter _ ( wdm ; see , e.g. , somer - larson & dolgov , 2001 ) .
a more realistic modeling of galaxy formation requires , of course , the inclusion of star formation and related feedback processes such as supernovae or stellar winds .
unfortunately , the physics of star formation and of the interaction of evolving stars with the interstellar medium is only ill understood .
explicit inclusion of these effects in direct numerical simulations can only be accomplished in the form of numerical `` recipes '' that contain a number of free parameters which can be calibrated e.g. such that kennicutt s ( 1998 ) relation between the hi surface density and the star formation rate per unit area ( schmidt s law ) is reproduced in isolated galaxy test cases .
the level of detail with which it is now possible to model the formation of individual galaxies is illustrated in figure 4 and 5 which convincingly demonstrate that numerical simulations are now able to capture the main stages of galaxy formation , and to resolve their main morphological components .
in particular , the following phases can be identified : * * formation of first disks . * at @xmath21 the first proto galactic clumps are numerically resolved ( i.e. more than 500 particles per halo ) .
small disks ( diameter @xmath22kpc ) form near the centers of these clumps . * * mergers and bulge formation .
* the proto galactic clumps frequently merge ( @xmath23 ) with objects of comparable size and mass .
the small disks at the center are destroyed in this process and a central spheroidal component forms . * * regeneration of disks . * in the absence of major mergers , disk - like structures around the bulge regenerate from gas accreted both smoothly and through minor mergers ( @xmath24 ) .
these objects feature all the major dynamical components of a bright spiral galaxy like the milky way : a rotationally supported disk of young stars , a centrally concentrated bulge , and a stellar halo of older stars . *
* minor mergers and the formation of rapidly rotating bars .
* tidal torques during the close encounter with a minor satellite ( mass ratio @xmath25 ) can trigger the formation of a rapidly rotating bar in the disk .
the bar pattern persists long after the disruption of the culpable satellite .
the bar extends out to about 2.5 kpc and has a corotation radius of slightly less than 3 kpc , implying , in agreement with the few barred galaxies where this ratio has been measured ( debattista & sellwood 1999 ) , that the bar is fast " .
the bar pattern is clearly visible for more than 30 orbital periods , a consequence of repeated triggering by orbiting satellites aided by the fact that the baryonic component dominates the central potential ( 75% of the mass within 3 kpc is in the disk ) .
although the process described here is likely not the only bar formation mechanism acting in real galaxies , the simulation shows nevertheless a direct link between the presence of a bar pattern and the existence of satellites that may act as tidal triggers . *
* major mergers and the formation of elliptical galaxies .
* mergers between close to equal mass galaxies effectively destroy disks and give rise to the formation of an elliptical galaxy .
residual gas in the disk progenitors is effectively channeled to the center where it is transformed to stars in a starburst like manner ( @xmath26 ) .
the resulting object is mainly composed of `` old '' stars with a sprinkle of young stars at the center that formed during the last major merger .
figure 4 illustrated the formation history for a galaxy that encountered a major merger at relatively low redshift ( @xmath27 ) and experience little accretion of mass afterwards .
the morphology at @xmath17 thus corresponds to that of an elliptical galaxy .
figure 5 shows a simulation of a different halo that did not experience any major merger after redshift 1.5 , but more mass has been added by smooth accretion between @xmath28 and @xmath17 .
consequently , its final morphology is similar to that of a major disk galaxy .
the examples shown in figures 4 and 5 demonstrate that high resolution simulations of the formation of individual galaxies are now capable to directly validate the long standing hypothesis , that depending on their merging history galaxies may repeatedly change their morphology and that morphology may be a transient phenomenon .
these simulations also highlight some of the potential shortcomings and open issues of hierarchical galaxy formation scenarios .
for example , is the large fraction of stars observed in disks today consistent with the ` lumpy ' accretion histories expected in cdm - like scenarios ?
can one account for the observed frequency , size , and dynamical properties of ` pure disk ' ( bulge - less ) galaxies ?
can variations in accretion history with environment account for the morphology - density relation ?
these questions are critical to the success of the hierarchical model and remain challenging puzzles to be elucidated within this so far highly successful paradigm .
it will take a substantive computational effort to address them through direct simulation , but one that is within reach of today s technological capabilities
. 0.1 cm
the success of such a model can be further assessed by testing , to what extent such a model can reproduce scaling relations that link total luminosity , rotation speed , and angular momentum of disk galaxies such as the tully fisher ( tf ) relation .
figure 6 shows the results of such an investigation , the simulated @xmath29-band tf relation at @xmath17 for the @xmath2cdm and for the @xmath2wdm scenario .
the simulated tf relation is compared with the data of giovanelli et al .
( 1997 ) , mathewson , ford & buchhorn ( 1992 ) and han & mould ( 1992 ) .
the slope and scatter of the simulated tf relation are in fairly good agreement with the observational data .
this result also holds in other bandpasses : the model tf relation becomes shallower ( and the scatter increases ) towards the blue , just as in observational samples ( see steinmetz & navarro 1999 ) .
the model tf relations are also very tight . in the i - band the _ rms
_ scatter is only 0.25 mag , even smaller than the observed scatter of @xmath30mag .
this must be so if the results are to agree with observations : scatter in the models reflects the intrinsic dispersion in the tf relation , whereas the observed scatter includes contributions from both observational errors and intrinsic dispersion . if , as it is usually argued , both effects contribute about equally to the observed dispersion in the tf relation , then the intrinsic scatter in the i - band should be comparable to the @xmath31mag found in the models .
in addition , the zero - point is in rough agreement with observational data , at closer inspection the simulated galaxies appear to be @xmath32mag too dim .
this disagreement can be accounted to a still sub optimal modeling of the star formation history in these models . due to the particular parameterization of star formation ,
a large fraction of stars form already at high redshift resulting in a fairly high stellar mass - to - light ratio of 2 - 2.5 in i - band while observations indicate a value closer to 1 - 1.5 ( bottema 1997 ) .
it is also interesting that the zero - point of the tf relation seems to strongly depend on the assumed cosmological scenario .
a similar simulation performed for a @xmath33 , @xmath34 cdm scenario results in a very in serious disagreement of the zero point with the data , the simulated @xmath33 tf relation being almost two magnitudes too faint at given rotation speed .
another interesting clue on the origin of the tully - fisher relation is that the small scatter and the zero - point ( for a given cosmological scenario ) is only weakly dependent on the particular star formation and feedback parameterization : very similar results can be obtained for quite different star formation prescriptions ( navarro & steinmetz , 2000 ) .
this is a surprising result since the fraction of baryons that ends up in a disk strongly depends on the particular feedback model and can vary by factor 3 - 5 between different parameterizations .
the weak dependence of the scatter on the feedback parameterization is an immediate consequence of how the rotation velocity of the galactic disk responds to changes in the ratio between stellar and dark mass . as more and more baryon
assemble in the central stellar disk , their luminosity increases but also the disk rotation velocity due to the gravity of the additional matter near the center .
this effect is amplified as the additional gravity also pulls dark matter towards the center .
consequently a variation in the star to dark matter fraction results in a shift predominately parallel to the tf relation which thus does not cause substantial additional scatter ( see navarro & steinmetz 2000 for a detailed discussion )
i presented some results of recent efforts to model the formation and evolution of galaxies in a hierarchical structure universe using high - resolution computer simulations .
i demonstrated that only numerical simulation can take full account of the dynamics of the formation process and the complicated interplay between different physical processes such as , e.g. , accretion and merging , star formation and feedback , photo heating and radiative cooling .
observational data can easily be misinterpreted if these effects are not properly included .
for example , the apparent inconsistency of hierarchical structure formation models and the kinematics of high-@xmath16 damped ly-@xmath0absorption systems could be easily solved by properly accounting for the complicated non - equilibrium dynamics of galaxies in the process of formation .
interestingly , the opposite is the case for the example of the galaxy spin .
the simplifying assumption of collapse under conservation of angular momentum combined with success of this model in explaining the sizes of disk galaxies may lure someone to consider the origin of the sizes of disk galaxies as being solved .
however , at closer inspection using numerical simulation , the physics behind the sizes of disk galaxies may be far more complicated .
maintaining the hierarchical build - up of galaxies and simultaneously avoiding substantial exchange of angular momentum from the gas to the dark matter due to mergers appears to be a major challenge to the scenario , and it can not be excluded that the angular momentum crisis may finally lead to substantial revisions of the hierarchical structure formation scenario .
this article includes work from collaborations with v. eke , m. haehnelt , j. navarro and m. rauch
. this work has been supported by the national aeronautics and space administration under nasa grant nag 5 - 7151 and nag 5 - 10827 , by the national science foundation under nsf grant 9807151 , and by fellowships from the alfred p. sloan foundation and the david and lucile packard foundation .
bahcall , n. , ostriker , j.p . , perlmutter , s. , steinhardt , p. 1999 , _ science _
, 284 , 1481 .
barnes , j. , hernquist , l. , 1992 , ara&a , 30 , 705 .
bottema , r. , 1997 , a&a 328 , 517 cen , r. , miralda - escud , j. , ostriker , j.p . ,
rauch , m. , 1994 , apj , 437 , 9 .
debattista , v.p . ,
sellwood , j. 1999 , apj , 493 , l5 .
fall , s.m . ,
efstathiou , g. , 1980 , mnras , 193 , 189 .
giovanelli , r. , haynes , m.p . , herter , t. , vogt , n.p . , 1997 ,
aj , 113 , 22 .
haehnelt , m. , steinmetz , m. , rauch , m. , 1998 , apj , 495 , 647 .
han , m. , mould , j.r . , 1992 , apj , 396 , 453 .
hernquist , l. , katz , n. , weinberg , d.h .
escude j. , 1996 , apj , 457 , l51 .
kauffmann , g. , 1996 , mnras , 281 , 475 .
kennicutt , r.c . , 1998 , ara&a , 36 , 189 . mathewson , d.s . , ford , v.l . ,
buchhorn , m. , 1992 , apjs , 81 , 413 mo , h.j . ,
mao , s. , white , s.d.m .
, 1998 , mnras , 295 , 319 .
navarro , j.f .
, benz w. , 1991 , apj , 380 , 320 .
navarro , j.f .
, frenk , c.s . , white , s.d.m . , 1995 , mnras , 275 , 56 .
navarro , j.f . , steinmetz , m. , 1997 , apj , 478 , 13 .
navarro , j.f . ,
steinmetz , m. , 2000 , apj , 538 , 477 .
prochaska , j. x. , wolfe , a. m. 1998 , apj , 507 , 113 .
somer - larson , j. , dolgov , a. 2001 , apj , 551 , 608 .
steinmetz , m. , navarro , j.f .
, 1999 , apj , 513 , 555 .
steinmetz , m. , navarro , j.f .
, 2002 , new astronomy , submitted .
sugimoto , d. , chikada , y. , makino , j. , ito , t. , ebisuzaki , t. , umemura , m. , 1990 _ nature _ * 345 * 33 thacker , r. , couchman , h.m.p .
, 2001 , apj , 555 , l17 .
van den bosch , f.c . , abel , t. , croft , r.a.c .
, hernquist , l. , white , s.d.m . , 2002 ,
apj , submitted ( astro - ph/0201095 ) .
weil , m. , eke , v.r . ,
efstathiou , g.p .
1998 , mnras , 300 , 773 wolfe , a.m. , 1988 , in _ qso absorption lines : probing the universe _ , proc . of the qso absorption line meeting , baltimore , 1987 , cambridge university press .
zhang , y. , anninos , p. , norman , m.l . , 1995 , apj , 453 , l57 . | i review recent progress in numerically simulating the formation and evolution of galaxies in hierarchically clustering universes .
special emphasis is given to results based on high - resolution gas dynamical simulations using the n - body hardware integrator grape .
applications address the origin of the spin of disk galaxies , the structure and kinematics of damped ly-@xmath0systems , and the origin of galaxy morphology and of galaxy scaling laws .
# 1_#1 _ # 1_#1 _ = # 1 1.25 in .125 in .25 in |
there is now a substantial amount of observational evidence that the universe is dominated by a dark component which is causing its expansion rate to accelerate .
the analysis of the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) anisotropy power spectra @xcite combined with results from large scale structure ( lss ) surveys @xcite strongly suggest that about @xmath4 of the energy in the universe is in an exotic form of matter which we refer to as dark energy ( de ) .
measurements of the luminosity distance to supernova type ia ( snia ) independently confirm these conclusions by showing that high redshift supernovae are dimmer than in a matter dominated universe @xcite
. further evidence , which has recently become available , is the detection of the integrated sachs - wolfe ( isw ) effect using the cmb / lss cross - correlation @xcite .
this evidence is complementary in nature to the snia data . rather than probing the overall expansion of the universe
, it detects the slow down in the growth of density perturbations that occurs when the universe ceases to be matter dominated .
cmb photons traveling to us from the surface of last scattering blueshift and redshift as they fall into and climb out of gravitational potentials along their paths . during matter domination ,
the large scale potentials remain constant in time , hence the blueshift and the redshift exactly cancel each other out . however , any deviation from a constant total equation of state results in a time variation of the potentials and a net change in the photon energy .
this is observed as an additional cmb temperature anisotropy , which is the isw effect @xcite .
detecting the isw effect from measurements of cmb temperature anisotropy alone is not feasible because the signal is hard to separate from the primordial anisotropy from the last scattering surface . to circumvent this ,
it was proposed to correlate the cmb temperature maps with the local distribution of matter @xcite .
the cross - correlation arises from cmb anisotropies produced after the cosmic structures were formed . on large angular scales
the cross - correlation signal is dominated by the isw effect , while at small angles an additional contribution comes from the sunyaev - zeldovich effect @xcite .
the cosmological constant @xmath5 is the simplest model of dark energy that provides a satisfactory fit to the existing data . despite the success of the concordance @xmath5 cold dark matter scenario ( @xmath5cdm ) ,
it is difficult to explain why the cosmological constant value is so extremely small compared to the expectations of particle physics without involving anthropic selection @xcite . on the other hand , the observations are also consistent with an evolving dark energy , such as quintessence models where the dark energy originates from a scalar field @xcite . establishing whether the dark energy is constant or evolving is one of the main challenges for modern cosmology . in the friedmann - robertson - walker ( frw ) universe the evolution of dark energy is completely determined by its equation of state , which is defined as the ratio of pressure to energy density : @xmath6 . for scalar field quintessence ,
the sound speed is unity and @xmath1 determines the clustering properties of de . depending on the model @xmath1 can be constant or change with time .
models with @xmath7 correspond to evolving de , while @xmath8 corresponds to @xmath5 . the time dependence of the dark energy equation has been constrained by fitting various forms of @xmath0 to the snia data , often in combination with cmb and the lss measurements @xcite .
however the data are not accurate enough to distinguish between the cosmological constant and many forms of dynamical dark energy . moreover
degeneracies between dark energy parameters strongly limit the possibility to test whether @xmath1 is constant or not .
as we shall describe in this paper , the cmb / lss correlation can provide another probe of the evolution of @xmath0 .
the sensitivity of the cross - correlation to the dark energy evolution has previously been investigated in @xcite . in this paper
we study constraints expected from correlating surveys such as des and lsst with the cmb data .
we introduce a novel way of parameterizing @xmath0 that has the average @xmath2 ( eq .
( [ def : aver ] ) ) as an explicit parameter .
this helps to separate information contained in the estimate of the distance to last scattering from that in the isw contribution .
we then proceed to show that the cross - correlation , in the absence of errors , is more sensitive to the details of the high redshift evolution of @xmath0 than other available observables .
this sensitivity , however , is off - set by large statistical errors due to a large primordial contribution to the cmb signal .
we forecast the expected uncertainties in de parameters ( using two different models ) extracted from cmb / lss correlation that will be possible in the next five years ( wmap / des ) and in the next ten years ( planck / lsst ) .
we also calculate corresponding constraints from the sne data ( snls in short term and snap in long term ) .
we find that in long term , cross - correlation can provide competitive constraints on the evolution of @xmath0 .
the paper is organized as follows . in section
[ theory ] we discuss the dark energy modeling and the details of the calculations .
section [ sec : exp ] describes the observations considered in the paper . in section [ results ] we discuss some advantages of including the cross correlation information and give the resulting parameter constraints .
finally in section [ conc ] we present our conclusions .
many models of dark energy have been proposed : cosmological constant ( @xmath5 ) , quintessence , k - essence , tangled defects , etc . for simplicity
, we will focus on quintessence based models where the dark energy arises from a scalar field currently slow - rolling down a potential , which is effectively inflation occurring at late times .
perturbations in the dark energy are easily incorporated in such models , and the sound speed is typically of order the speed of light . the shape of the potential , which determines the evolution of the dark energy , is generally a free function .
this makes it difficult to predict the time dependence of the de equation of state , so one is potentially left with constraining a completely arbitrary function of redshift .
the problem must be simplified by considering some parameterization of the function @xmath0 .
several parameterizations have been suggested in a vast literature , but any resulting constraints are very sensitive to the choice of parameterization . for instance
it was shown in @xcite that fitting a constant @xmath1 will tend to favor lower negative values if the de equation of state is time dependent .
even two - parameter taylor expansions are too simplistic , resulting in a strong dependence on the assumed priors and generally biased against dynamical models @xcite .
one of the most popular two - parameter formulae is the linear change in the scale factor @xmath9 @xcite given by , w(a)=w_0+(a-1)_w , [ lin ] [ w : linder ] where @xmath10 and @xmath11 being the value at some early time , such as the radiation - matter equality . from eq .
( [ lin ] ) it appears evident that with two parameters one can fix the value of the equation of state today and at high redshift , but the time evolution between the two extremes can not be changed ( i.e. @xmath12 ) . as consequence of this ,
a linear expansion can not allow for rapid variation in the equation of state and particularly in the case of quintessence , for which @xmath13 , this bias will tend to favor small values of @xmath14 . despite these potential problems , eq .
( [ lin ] ) has become a common tool of testing the capability of future experiments to constrain de models ( see @xcite ) . due to its wide use in the literature
, we will consider this parameterization here to help the comparison of our results with previous works .
we shall refer to it as model i. in order to avoid the pitfalls introduced by the taylor expansion we also consider a phenomenological approach and model @xmath0 according to some minimal requirements , which are : 1 ) the form of @xmath0 depends on a minimal number of parameters which are of simple physical interpretation , 2 ) the parameterization is not biased against any particular time behavior and can account for both rapid ( large ) or slow ( small ) variation of the equation of state , 3 ) the parameterization reproduces the evolution of several proposed models of de such as quintessence . in this regard ,
a general formula constructed to follow these guidelines was proposed in @xcite and is usually referred to as the `` kink '' model @xcite . within the class of the kink models we consider a unique new parameterization .
we start with the functional form w(z)= + tanh , [ def : tanh ] which describes a transition from @xmath15 for @xmath16 , to @xmath17 for @xmath18 , with parameters @xmath19 and @xmath20 describing the width and the central redshift of the transition .
the novelty is in using the average equation of state ( @xmath2 ) as an explicit parameter , where @xmath21 is defined as [ def : aver ] . here
@xmath22 is the scale factor ( @xmath23 today ) , @xmath24 is the scale factor at the surface of last scattering and @xmath25 is the ratio of the de energy density to the critical density .
it is well known @xcite that on small scales the cmb temperature anisotropy spectra are insensitive to the details of @xmath0 except for its average value as defined in eq .
( [ def : aver ] ) . specifying @xmath2 roughly fixes the distance to the last scattering surface @xcite , which determines positions of the acoustic peaks in the cmb temperature anisotropy spectrum .
the cmb temperature data , combined with a prior knowledge of @xmath26 and under the assumption that the universe is flat , is capable of constraining the value of @xmath2 with a very high accuracy . by explicitly specifying @xmath2 we preserve the information that would be obtained from fitting a constant @xmath1 to the cmb , while still allowing for a varying @xmath0 .
hence , a direct control on the value @xmath2 allows us to reduce the four dimensional parameter space to a much smaller observationally allowed region , which corresponds to a narrow range of possible values of @xmath2 .
note that for @xmath2 close to @xmath27 , as favored by the data , most choices of @xmath28 would lead to @xmath0 changing between @xmath27 and @xmath29 , where @xmath30 .
also note that in a large class of quintessence models either @xmath15 or @xmath17 is @xmath27 .
this is the case when the scalar field is initially in a slow - roll regime ( @xmath31 ) as in , , the doomsday model @xcite . similarly for tracker models , where the quintessence field starts tracking
the background component and evolves at late time settling to a minimum of its potential ( i. e. @xmath32 ) @xcite .
hence , fixing the value of either @xmath17 or @xmath15 to @xmath27 is physically and observationally motivated and allows us to reduce the number of parameters in eq .
( [ def : tanh ] ) from four to three .
thus , instead of using the four parameters of eq .
( [ def : tanh ] ) , @xmath15 , @xmath17 , @xmath20 and @xmath19 , we use three parameters : @xmath2 , @xmath28 and @xmath19 . here
, @xmath20 is chosen to reproduce the desired value of @xmath2 .
( alternatively , we could explicitly specify @xmath20 and use eq .
( [ def : aver ] ) to find the corresponding value of @xmath19 . )
since we are primarily interested in determining whether @xmath0 is varying or constant , @xmath28 is the main parameter of interest .
the role of the third parameter , @xmath20 or @xmath19 , is only to allow for sufficient freedom in the ansatz . in this paper
, we will stay with the choice of @xmath2 , @xmath28 and @xmath19 and refer to this parameterization as our model ii .
representative plots of @xmath0 versus @xmath3 for model i and model ii are shown in fig .
[ fig : eos ] . the cmb temperature anisotropy due to the isw effect can be written as @xmath33 - \dot{\psi}\left[(\eta_0-\eta ) \hat{\bf
n},\eta \right ] \right ) , \label{def : dt_isw}\ ] ] where @xmath34 is a direction on the sky , @xmath35 is the conformal time , @xmath36 is some initial time far into the matter era , @xmath37 is the time today , @xmath38 and @xmath39 are the gravitational potentials in the newtonian gauge , and the dot denotes differentiation with respect to @xmath35 . the isw temperature anisotropy can be correlated with the distribution of galaxies on the sky using , @xmath40 where @xmath41 is the overdensity of galaxies in the direction @xmath34 , @xmath42 is the number of galaxies in the pixel corresponding to the direction @xmath34 , and @xmath43 is the mean number of galaxies per pixel .
we assume here that we sample galaxies in a fixed redshift region , characterized by a normalized galaxy selection function , @xmath44 . for simplicity , we initially consider a single selection function , but below we consider correlations arising between different redshift bins as well .
the galaxy number overdensity @xmath41 is assumed to be tracing the cold dark matter ( cdm ) density contrast @xmath45 via @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the linear galaxy bias , which is possibly redshift dependent .
the cdm density contrast can be written as an integral over conformal time , @xmath48 where @xmath49 is the three - dimensional density contrast and is directly related to the gravitational potentials .
we are interested in calculating the cross - correlation function @xmath50 where the angular brackets denote ensemble averaging and @xmath51 is the angle between directions @xmath52 and @xmath53 .
calculations are often simplified when @xmath54 is decomposed into a legendre series , @xmath55 the coefficients @xmath56 can be evaluated using @xcite : @xmath57 where @xmath58 is the wave - number , @xmath59 is the primordial curvature power spectrum , and functions @xmath60 and @xmath61 are defined as @xmath62 ) \nonumber \\ & \times & ( c_{\phi \psi } \dot{\phi}(k,\eta ) - \dot{\psi}(k,\eta))\label{tisw } \nonumber \\
m_\ell(k ) & = & b_g c_{\delta \psi } \int_{\eta_k}^{\eta_0 } d\eta \ j_\ell(k[\eta-\eta_0])\nonumber \\ & \times & \dot{z } w_g(z(\eta ) ) \delta ( k,\eta ) \label{mlk}\ . \label{delta_isw}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the above , the integration starts at an early time @xmath63 , when a given mode @xmath58 is well - outside the horizon , @xmath64 are the spherical bessel functions , @xmath65 , @xmath66 and @xmath67 are the evolution functions defined in @xcite along with the numerical coefficients @xmath68 and @xmath69 : @xmath70 where @xmath71 and @xmath72 and @xmath73 are the photon and relativistic neutrino densities . above we have considered the correlations between the cmb and a sample of galaxies defined by a single galaxy selection function .
future surveys will enable us to separate galaxies into many redshift slices with photometric redshift slices ( bins ) , and we can consider separate correlations with each of the slices , @xmath74 .
we calculate these as above using the different selection functions , @xmath75 , each of which has a corresponding weighting function @xmath76 . for each bin
, we consider a different possible bias factor @xmath77 , but as we discuss in section [ sec : bias ] , these can be determined sufficiently well by the observations of the galaxy - galaxy correlation functions .
the galaxy - galaxy correlations are evaluated in a similar way .
we have many correlation functions @xmath78 , corresponding to correlations between all possible redshift bins labeled by indices @xmath79 . similarly to eq .
( [ eval : x_l ] ) , the legendre coefficients of these correlations are given by @xmath80 the full cmb auto - correlation @xmath81 contains the primary anisotropy from the last scattering surface as well as contributions from the isw , the sz and other effects : @xmath82 the uncorrelated anisotropies from the last scattering surface dominate the noise in the cross correlation detection .
the isw contribution dominates the galaxy - cmb cross - correlation on large scales ( where the signal is strongest ) , while the sz effect is anti - correlated at wmap frequencies and affects only the small angular scales @xcite . in principle
the sz signal can be eliminated by smoothing the cmb maps on scales smaller than the typical angular size of a cluster ( @xmath83 ) , therefore we will not include the sz in our analysis .
we evaluate the cmb / lss correlation coefficients @xmath84 , as well as all other relevant spectra , using an appropriately modified version of cmbfast @xcite .
for all models , we assume a flat universe with adiabatic initial conditions for all particle species , including the quintessence .
we use the usual fisher method @xcite for parameter estimation forecasts to study the potential of the cmb / lss cross - correlation for dark energy constraints .
we assume that the universe has evolved from adiabatic initial conditions with a nearly scale - invariant spectrum of density fluctuation , negligible tensor component and no massive neutrinos .
it is also assumed to be flat with a quintessence field parameterized by @xmath0 .
in addition to the dark energy parameters @xmath85,@xmath14 ] of model i or [ @xmath2,@xmath28,@xmath19 ] of model ii , our parameter space @xmath88 includes the matter fraction of total energy density @xmath89 , the hubble parameter @xmath90 , the baryon density @xmath91 , the reionization optical depth @xmath92 , the scalar spectral index @xmath93 and the amplitude of the initial power spectrum @xmath94 . in total , we have @xmath95 parameters for model i and @xmath96 parameters for model ii .
in addition , for the sne analysis , we account for @xmath97 the intrinsic supernova magnitude .
cross - correlation parameters also include the bias factors for each photometric bin , as described in section [ sec : bias ] .
the cross - correlation fisher matrix can be written as f^x_,=f_sky _ = _ min^_x _ i , j x^i_p
_ cov^-1 ( x_^i x_^j ) x^j_p_. [ fisher : x ] here @xmath98 , as well as the partial derivatives , are evaluated at the fiducial values ( see sec . [
sec : fid ] ) .
the sky fraction , @xmath99 , is the smallest of the cmb and the galaxy survey sky coverage fractions .
we used @xmath100 as the summation limit , although most of the contribution comes from @xmath101 .
the smallest value of @xmath102 can be approximately determined from @xmath103 .
the covariance matrix @xmath104 is given by ( x_^i x_^j ) = ( ^tt_^(i , j ) _
+ x^i_x^j_)/(2 + 1 ) , [ cov : x ] where @xmath105 and @xmath106 are defined in eqns .
( [ cmb : noise ] ) and ( [ galaxy : noise ] ) and include the contributions from the noise .
note that the contribution to the @xmath81 from the surface of last scattering is much larger than that from the isw effect , while @xmath107 is not sensitive to the last scattering physics at all .
this results in a very large variance in @xmath107 that significantly impairs its potential for parameter estimation .
for cmb measurements , the fisher information matrix is given by f^_,=f_sky_=2^ _ _ a , b ^a_p _ ^-1(^a_^b _ ) ^b_p _ , [ fisher : cmb ] with the covariance matrices for @xmath108 given explicitly in @xcite . in the above ,
@xmath109 was taken to be @xmath110 for wmap and @xmath111 for planck , safely above the maximum @xmath102 allowed by the angular resolution of each experiment .
the partial derivatives and the covariance matrix are evaluated at a fiducial choice of parameters that is specified in the next subsection .
the quantity directly measured from sne observations is their redshift - dependent magnitude m(z ) = m + 5 + 25 [ def : mz ] where @xmath97 is the intrinsic supernova magnitude and @xmath112 the luminosity distance ( in mpc ) .
the luminosity distance is defined as [ lumdis ] d_l(z)=(1+z ) _
0^z dz h(z ) , where @xmath113 is the hubble parameter with a current value of @xmath26 .
the information matrix for sne observations is f^_,= _
i^n 1(z_i)^2 m(z_i)p _ m(z_i)p_. [ fisher : sne ] where the summation is over the redshift bins and @xmath114 is the value given by eq .
( [ sigma_m ] ) at the midpoint of the @xmath115-th bin .
given the fisher matrix , the lower bound on the uncertainty in determination of a parameter @xmath116 is given by p_i c_ii = ( f^-1)_ii , where @xmath117 is the error matrix .
one can forecast constraints from a combination of measurements by adding the individual fisher matrices .
for example , cross - correlation measurements can be combined with measurements of the cmb spectra by planck as f^planck+x_,=f^planck_,+ f^x _ , .
forecasts obtained using fisher analysis are sensitive to the choice of the fiducial model .
we will consider the same fiducial models for the two dark energy parameterizations discussed above and plotted in fig .
[ fig : eos ] . the fiducial parameters for model i were taken to be @xmath118 and @xmath119 . for model ii we chose @xmath120 , @xmath121 and @xmath122 .
we take all other cosmological parameters to be the same for both models .
we have set the hubble parameter @xmath123 , baryon density @xmath124 , total matter density @xmath125 , spectral index @xmath126 , optical depth @xmath127 and the amplitude of scalar fluctuations @xmath128 ( as defined in @xcite . )
all of current data is consistent with @xmath129 at @xmath130 level @xcite .
both , model i and model ii , have the same weighted average @xmath131 .
this assures that these two models have nearly identical cmb spectra as shown in fig .
[ fig : cmb ] . in fig .
[ fig : pk ] we compare the matter power spectra predicted by the two models . plotted
are the linear cdm spectra at @xmath132 .
the bias , non - linear effects and the redshift space distortion would modify the three spectra in a similar way . while one can not compare these linear spectra to the data without accounting for the above - mentioned corrections , we include the sdss data points @xcite to illustrate the uncertainty in the current determination of @xmath133 .
models i and ii are also consistent with current estimates of the change in luminosity distance @xmath134 obtained from the snia measurements . in fig .
[ fig : lumin ] we plot the percent difference in @xmath135 between the model with constant @xmath136 and models i and model ii .
the differences between the models are of order @xmath137% , well below the current level uncertainty and comparable to the projected accuracy of snap .
hence , present data can not distinguish between @xmath129 and our models i and ii and both are perfectly consistent with all available observations .
we are interested in forecasting the errors in dark energy parameters that can be extracted from cmb / lss correlation studies and compare them to those expected from the luminosity distance measurements .
we make short- ( less than 5 years ) and long- ( ten years ) term predictions based on the ongoing and planned cmb , galaxy and sne observations . for our short term predictions
we assume the 4-year cmb temperature and polarization data from wmap @xcite , the expected galaxy counts from the dark energy survey ( des ) @xcite , and the sne from the nearby supernova factory ( nsnf ) @xcite and the supernovae legacy survey ( snls ) @xcite .
in addition , we impose a gaussian prior on the value of @xmath90 corresponding to a @xmath130 uncertainty of @xmath138 from the hubble space telescope s key project ( hstkp ) @xcite . for the long term predictions we assume the 14 months cmb temperature and polarization data by planck satellite @xcite , the galaxy catalogues by the large synoptic survey telescope ( lsst ) @xcite , and the sne from the supernovae acceleration probe ( snap ) @xcite complemented by those from the nsnf .
to describe the distribution of galaxies from a given survey , we take the total galaxy number density to have the following redshift dependence @xcite : @xmath139 where @xmath140 is a parameter that is adjusted to reproduce the expected median redshift of the survey .
the galaxies are further divided into photometric redshift bins , i. e. @xmath141 following reference @xcite , we assume that the photometric redshift errors are gaussian distributed , and that their rms fluctuations increase with redshift as @xmath142 . the bins sizes are chosen to increase proportionally to the errors .
the resulting photometric redshift distributions are given by , @xmath143 , \label{eq : erfc}\ ] ] where erfc is the complementary error function .
for a given photometric redshift bin , the normalized selection function is given by @xmath144 where @xmath145 is the total number of galaxies in the @xmath115-th bin .
the poisson noise is uncorrelated between bins and contributes only to the galaxy angular auto - correlation as @xmath146 where @xmath147 is the kronecker delta and @xmath148 is the galaxy number per solid angle in the @xmath115-th bin .
the observed correlation @xmath106 is the sum of the signal and the poisson noise : [ galaxy : noise ] ^(i , j)_^(i ,
j)_+ n^(i , j ) _ the dark energy survey ( des ) is designed to probe the redshift range @xmath149 with an approximate 1-@xmath150 error of @xmath151 in photometric redshift .
this roughly corresponds to four bins ( see fig .
[ fig : des ] ) and a median redshift of @xmath152 .
the total expected number of galaxies is approximately @xmath153 million in a @xmath154 sq .
area on the sky , or @xmath155 .
the proposed lsst survey is expected to cover up to @xmath156 sq .
deg . of the sky and catalogue over a billion galaxies
out to @xmath157 .
we consider two cases : the conservative scenario case with @xmath158 and @xmath159 photometric redshift bins out to @xmath160 , and the desired case with @xmath161 and @xmath162 photometric redshift bins out to @xmath157 . for both cases
we assume @xmath163 gal@xmath164arcmin@xmath165 . the assumed galaxy number distributions for the two cases are shown in figs .
[ fig : lsst_cons ] and [ fig : lsst_goal ] . in
what follows , we will refer to the two lsst cases as `` _ conservative _ '' and `` _ goal _ '' .
the photometric redshift errors used in our analysis should be seen as the optimistic values for the respective experiments . for a discussion of potential sources of systematic errors in photo - z
estimates the reader is referred to @xcite .
the latest expected values for the sensitivity and the resolution parameters of the 4-year wmap and 14 months planck missions are available in @xcite . to make comparison with previous results easier
, we opted to use similar , although somewhat different , parameters employed in @xcite for the three highest frequency channels of wmap and the lowest three planck hfi channels .
we have checked that using the exact parameters given in @xcite would lead to an insignificant modification of our results .
the relevant parameters are listed in table [ tab : wmap ] . .
the relevant parameters of wmap @xcite and planck @xcite .
we use the three highest frequency wmap channels and the lowest planck hfi frequency channels . [ cols= " <
, > , > , > , > , > , > " , ] in the longer term , i.e. in the next ten years , we should expect to have the results from planck cmb measurements , galaxy catalogues from lsst and the sne measurements from snap .
these will significantly improve the constraints on the de parameters . in certain models , as we show here on the example of our model ii
, cmb / lss cross - correlation can play a competitive role .
as in the previous subsection , we begin by considering the linear de model with two different sets of the fiducial values : one where they match a cosmological constant ( @xmath166 ) and another where @xmath1 evolves but still consistent with present observations ( model i ) . in fig .
[ fig : lcdm_long ] and fig .
[ fig : comb1_long ] we show the @xmath130 projected contours for the linear models . on these plots , the cross - correlation and
the sne prediction includes the information from planck .
combining with planck is equivalent to applying strong priors on all cosmological parameters .
the constraints in the absence of any priors can be found in table [ tab : long ] .
planck and snap are by far the most dominant information sources for these models , with cross - correlation adding a relatively weak contribution . for model
ii we start by presenting the individual error contours for the three experiments ( fig .
[ fig : m2_ind_long ] ) , with the purpose of explicitely showing degeneracy directions .
we will see that , once we consider its combination with planck , the relative utility of the cross - correlation is significantly higher for model ii .
the contours in fig .
[ fig : comb2_long ] show that the cross - correlation can provide constraints on @xmath2 and @xmath28 that are competitive with those from snap .
the improvement on planck is especially strong without the polarization data .
the full list of parameter constraints is given in table [ tab : long ] .
our results confirm that sne measurements are more suitable for constraining variations in @xmath0 at low redshifts . at higher redshifts ,
the cross - correlation becomes useful and can provide an independent constraint @xmath28 .
figure [ fig : alt_comb2_long ] illustrates how a different choice of model ii fiducial parameters affects the constraining capabilities of the different probes .
the alternative model has @xmath167 instead of @xmath168 .
was not modified as the transition time would be pushed to very high redshifts if it approached -1 . on the other hand , @xmath2 smaller than @xmath169
are strongly disfavored by current data .
] in this case we note the snap+planck constraint for @xmath28 is noticeably tighter than that from the planck / lsst correlation .
also note that this is mainly due to improvement in the sensitivity of the sne , as the transition in this model happens at a lower redshfit .
the size of the error on @xmath28 from the cross - correlation is only marginally increased compared to fig .
[ fig : comb2_long ] .
we have studied the potential of the cmb / lss correlation for constraining the evolution of the de equation of state .
we proposed a new parameterization , a `` kink '' model which has the average equation of state @xmath2 as an explicit parameter .
a direct control on the value of @xmath2 preserves the tight constraints on @xmath1 obtained from the distance to last scattering measurements , while allowing @xmath0 to vary in other ways . using fisher analysis ,
we have made forecasts of the expected uncertainties in de parameters extracted from the upcoming cmb , sne and cmb / lss correlation data .
we have considered both short- ( wmap , des , snls ) and long- ( planck , lsst , snap ) term prospects .
we find that in long term the cross - correlation will provide competitive constraints on the evolution of @xmath0 , in particular , on the total change in @xmath1 , provided a sufficiently generic parameterization is used .
we also note that the transition length parameter , @xmath19 , will not be well constrained even with the long - term combined data .
our results encourage further investigation of the cmb / lss correlation as a probe of dark energy .
the cross - correlation has a clear weakness a large variance that hinders its utility as a precision cosmology probe .
however , it also has certain attractive features , that in some cases can out weigh the lack of accuracy .
these features are : * the cross - correlation probes _ the rate _ of the growth of structure as well as the growth .
* it is practically independent of reionization details ( @xmath92 ) and the details of the initial spectrum ( @xmath93 ) .
* it probes the large scales ( @xmath170 ) , where the evolution of structure is safely inside the linear regime and there is no need for higher order corrections . * on linear scales contributing to the isw / lss correlation
the galaxy bias is expected to be independent of scale .
* cross - correlation is linear in bias , compared to the matter power spectrum that is quadratic . in fact , if one used a cross - correlation estimator that is normalized to the auto - correlations , that estimator would be independent of bias and the overall normalization of the primordial spectrum .
* cross - correlation can probe the evolution of dark energy at relatively high redshifts , inaccessible by luminosity distance measurements . in this work
we have restricted our attention to quintessence models for which the effective sound speed is of order of unity , so that the dark energy perturbations only affect the evolution of the largest structures . however ,
if the dark energy clusters on smaller scales , it may leave a distinctive signature which can be detected with cross - correlation measurements .
although current data do not provide any constraints on the dark energy sound speed @xcite , the constraints from the next generation of galaxy surveys have been studied in @xcite .
we have only considered flat frw models . without the flatness assumption , cmb constraints on @xmath89 and @xmath90
weaken because of a well - known degeneracy @xcite , also relaxing constraints on @xmath0 .
we will explore constraints on de using isw without the flatness prior in a future work .
the model ii type parameterization of @xmath0 considered in the paper is not necessarily the most optimal for underscoring the power of cross - correlation constraints ( although clearly better suited for this purposed than model i ) .
a more comprehensive study using a principal component approach @xcite is a subject of ongoing research .
another potential use of the isw cross - correlation is to measure the amplitude of the scalar perturbations and indirectly constrain the amplitude of the tensor modes when combined with the normalization of cmb spectra @xcite .
this is because the distribution of the large scale structures is not correlated with a stochastic background of gravitational waves .
it has been also suggested @xcite that cmb / lss studies may help to differentiate between quintessence and models with modified gravity . for a fixed total number of galaxies the information extracted from the isw studies depends on the choice of the redshift binning .
the role of cross - correlation in constraining @xmath0 may be further increased by optimizing the bin selection .
such an optimization is a topic of ongoing research .
we thank niayesh afshordi , bruce bassett , wayne hu , justin khoury and ryan scranton for useful comments and discussions .
we thank eric linder for very helpful critical comments on the first version of the paper .
thanks tufts institute of cosmology for hospitality .
the code used for calculating the cross - correlation was developed in collaboration with jaume garriga and tanmay vachaspati and was based on cmbfast @xcite .
p.s.c . is supported by columbia academic quality fund .
d. spergel ( wmap team ) , astrophys . j. suppl .
* 148 * , 175 ( 2003 ) .
w. j. percival , mont . not .
r. astron .
soc . * 327 * , 1297 ( 2001 ) ; m. tegmark , astrophys . j. * 606 * , 70 ( 2004 ) .
a. riess , astron .
j. * 116 * , 1009 ( 1998 ) ; s. perlmutter , astrophys .
j. * 517 * , 565 ( 1999 ) .
a. d. linde , rept .
phys . * 47 * , 925 ( 1984 ) ; a. vilenkin , phys .
* 74 * , 846 ( 1985 ) ; g. efstathiou , mnras * 274 * , l73 ( 1995 ) ; s. weinberg , phys .
59 * , 2607 ( 1987 ) ; h. martel , p. r. shapiro and s. weinberg , astrophys .
j. * 492 * , 29 ( 1998 ) ; j. garriga , m. livio and a. vilenkin , phys .
rev . * d61 * , 023503 ( 2000 ) ; s. a. bludman , nucl .
* a663 * , 865 ( 2000 ) ; j. garriga and a. vilenkin , phys .
rev . * d67 * , 043503 ( 2003 ) ; l. pogosian , a. vilenkin , m. tegmark , astro - ph/0404497 , jcap 0407 ( 2004 ) 005 a. albrecht and c. skordis , phys . rev . * d64 * , 023514 ( 2001 ) , astro - ph/9908085 ; t. barreiro , e.j .
copeland and n.j .
nunes , phys .
* d61 * , 127301 ( 2000 ) , astro - ph/9910214 ; e.j .
copeland , n.j .
nunes and f. rosati , phys .
* d62 * , 123503 ( 2000 ) , hep - ph/0005222 . | we present an analysis of the constraining power of future measurements of the integrated sachs - wolfe ( isw ) effect on models of the equation of state of dark energy as a function of redshift , @xmath0 . to achieve this
, we employ a new parameterization of @xmath1 , which utilizes the mean value of @xmath0 ( @xmath2 ) as an explicit parameter .
this helps to separate the information contained in the estimation of the distance to the last scattering surface ( from the cmb ) from the information contained in the isw effect .
we then use fisher analysis to forecast the expected uncertainties in the measured parameters from future isw observations for two models of dark energy with very different time evolution properties .
for example , we demonstrate that the cross correlation of planck cmb data and lsst galaxy catalogs will provide competitive constraints on @xmath0 , compared to a snap like sne project , for models of dark energy with a rapidly changing equation of state ( e.g. `` kink '' models ) .
our work confirms that , while sne measurements are more suitable for constraining variations in @xmath0 at low redshift , the isw effect can provide important independent constraints on @xmath0 at high @xmath3 . |
it was experimentally observed in the 1960s that a quark of high generation can decay into a quark of low generation : a diagram of the mixed quark decay .
( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/user:army1987/quark ) this phenomenon , referred to as _ the mixed quark decay _ in this article , has been thought to be explained by the ckm theory @xcite in which it is assumed that the weak interaction pairs are @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 rather than the more natural pairs @xmath5 , @xmath6 and @xmath7 , where @xmath8=v\left[\begin{matrix } d\cr s \cr b \end{matrix}\right]\ ] ] with @xmath9 being the ckm matrix @xmath10.\ ] ] for example , via weak interaction , instead of decaying into @xmath11 , @xmath12 decays into @xmath13 , and hence decays into @xmath14 , @xmath15 or @xmath11 with the relative probability @xmath16 , @xmath17 and @xmath18 respectively . in this theory , the ckm matrix @xmath9 is simply an input parameter whose actual value must be determined by experiments , but one thing is clear : @xmath9 has to be unitary _ exactly_. a great success of this theory is the prediction of the third generation of quarks , for which kobayashi and maskawa shared one half of the 2008 nobel physics prize in physic @xcite . from the particle data group @xcite , the best experimental determination for the magnitudes of the ckm matrix elements
is @xmath19 @xmath20 . }
\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is worth to mention that , the values of @xmath21 and @xmath22 quoted here ( the highlighted matrix entries ) are obtained under the theoretical assumption that @xmath23 , see equation ( 11.13 ) of page 159 in ref . @xcite and the line above this equation .
if we took the experimentally determined value of @xmath24 , i.e. , @xmath25 , we would have @xmath26 the phases of the ckm matrix elements determine the amount of cp violation . with the observed amount of cp violation taken into account , the currently best known standard
" fit for the ckm matrix elements in the sense of chau and keung @xcite is @xmath27 @xmath28 .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that only the two highlighted entries are not nearly being real numbers .
because of this observation , _
@xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 , @xmath32 , @xmath33 shall be assumed to be real numbers hereafter_. the assumption that @xmath12 interacts with @xmath34 ( rather than @xmath11 ) via weak interaction is made purely for explaining the mixed quark decay .
there is no theoretical reason why this must be so . in any case , this assumption is mysterious and now the experimental data strongly suggests that it is incorrect . for example , the norm square of the 3rd column should be exactly @xmath35 ; however , based on the experimental data for the 3rd column , a simulation of any size @xmath36 shows that this norm square has an average @xmath37 , a standard deviation @xmath38 , and is less than @xmath39 more than @xmath40 of time .
it is perhaps not a secret among some experts that the ckm theory is less than accurate .
however , to reject the ckm theory , one must provide an alternative theory which is both theoretically sound as well as quantitatively more accurate .
a major message in this article is that such a theory indeed exists .
in a recent article @xcite of this author , it was shown that one can indeed derive the existence of quarks and leptons provided that one is willing to make a new modification for the twin pillars of fundamental physics , as shown in the last stage of the following chain of modifications : _ classical mechanics _
+ _ galilean structure _ @xmath41 _ quantum theory _
+ _ galilean structure _ @xmath42 _ quantum theory _ + _ lorentz structure _ @xmath43 _ quantum theory _
+ _ euclidean jordan algebra_. this new modification is comparatively conservative because lorentz structure is a secondary structure hidden inside euclidean jordan algebra , rather than an approximation to it . with this new modification , quarks and leptons , the four fundamental forces and the broken electric - weak symmetry , matter generations , and other experimentally found phenomena , appear naturally in the theoretical framework .
moreover , a short - range 5th fundamental force accompanying gravity is predicted .
this 5th force is predicted to violate the cp symmetry and transform quarks among its various generations , so it immediately predicts mixed quark decay and the related cp violation .
for example , since @xmath15 decays to @xmath14 via the 5th force and @xmath14 decays to @xmath44 via the weak force , @xmath15 must decay to @xmath44 .
the theoretical framework offered above sounds very simple and leaves no mysteries behind , but in order for this to be a valid theory it must be able to withstand quantitative checks with experiments .
since the precise mathematical form for the 5th force is not available at the moment , one has to make some reasonable assumptions on the 5th force in order to proceed . with this in mind , by using simple rules in quantum mechanics one can derive the following _ inexact _ formulae for @xmath45 , @xmath0 , @xmath46 : @xmath47 here , @xmath48 means the complex conjugate , and
@xmath49 is some unknown complex constant . to test the accuracy of these formulae
, one takes as input data the experimentally determined magnitude for the matrix entries entered into the right hand side of formulae ( [ formula ] ) , but with this sign convention chosen : diagonal entries are all positive , @xmath50 and @xmath51 . to be more precise , we take @xmath52 @xmath53 } \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath54 ( page 159 in ref .
@xcite ) as our input data , then compute @xmath45 , @xmath0 and @xmath46 according to formulae ( [ formula ] ) . note that @xmath46 can not be computed from the formulae because @xmath49 is unknown , however , its standard deviation , which is independent of the actual value of @xmath49 , can be computed . in our actual computation
we set @xmath55 . in the ckm theory , the orthogonality for the first two columns and first two rows plus the unity of the norm square of the 3rd row yields the following very accurate formulae for @xmath56 , @xmath31 and @xmath45 : @xmath57 as the input data for the computation via formulae ( [ ckmformula ] ) , we take @xmath58 as before and @xmath59 , see page 159 in ref .
@xcite . by performing a numerical test with a sample size @xmath60 ,
one gets the following result : [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] -15pt note that the uncertainties in the output come from the uncertainties of the experimental data for the matrix entries entered into the right hand side of formulae ( [ formula ] ) and ( [ ckmformula ] ) . in the tests ,
each ckm matrix entry on the right hand side of formulae ( [ formula ] ) or formulae ( [ ckmformula ] ) is assumed to be a gaussian random variable with the normal distribution determined by the experimental data .
for example , @xmath29 is assumed to be the gaussian random variable with the normal distribution having average equal to @xmath61 and standard deviation equal to @xmath62 . in the 5th force
based predictions , the precision is good , so is the accuracy except for @xmath21 .
the inaccuracy for @xmath21 has a known reason : the unknown complex constant @xmath49 in formulae ( [ formula ] ) was set to be zero in the numerical test .
in contrast , in the ckm based predictions , neither precision nor accuracy fares well , especially for @xmath63 and @xmath64 . in summary , the _ inaccurate _ formulae deduced from the 5th force produces a much better result than the ckm theory s _ accurate _ formulae .
thus , considering this result , as well as observation that the 5th force theory is natural and is also part of a bigger natural theory proposed in ref .
@xcite , the 5th force theory does a better job than the ckm theory at predicting mixed quark decay .
the goal of this section is to derive formulae ( [ formula ] ) based on the 5th force and the weak force . here
the 5th force transforms up quarks ( down quarks respectively ) among their different generations , but the weak force is still the one in the classical standard model , i.e. , it transforms up quarks and down quarks into each other only in the same generation .
in contrast , in the ckm theory , since the mixed quark decays is solely due to the weak force , the weak force must be assumed to transform a up quark into a linear supoposition of down quarks from various generations .
apparently these are two conflicting theories for mixed quark decays . for the purpose in this article , we are only interested in computing the following transition amplitude matrix : @xmath65.\ ] ] here @xmath66 denotes the total transition amplitude ( due to both the weak force and the 5th force ) for quark @xmath67 spontaneously decaying into quark @xmath11 . note that the matrix @xmath68 is a scalar multiple of @xmath9 up to the complex conjugation of some entries . for the purpose of comparing with @xmath9 ,
hereafter we shall assume that @xmath69 modulo the complex conjugation of some entries .
the precise form of the 5th force is not known at the moment , otherwise one would be able to compute @xmath68 directly . in spite of this fact , based on rules in quantum theory and some plausible physics assumptions , one can still derive some useful information . as a simple exercise ,
let us derive the following formula @xmath70 which corresponds to the simplest identity in formulae ( [ formula ] ) .
it is reasonable to assume that the weak force transition amplitude between the up quark and the down quark in each generation is a same positive number @xmath71 when suitable relative phases are chosen .
then @xmath72 here @xmath73 is the transition amplitude contributed from the decaying process involving @xmath74 first decaying to @xmath44 via the 5th force , @xmath75 is the transition amplitude contributed from the decaying process involving @xmath12 first decaying to @xmath44 via the 5th force , and @xmath76 is the transition amplitude contributed from the decaying process involving @xmath12 first decaying to @xmath74 via the 5th force .
it is reasonable to assume that @xmath77 have the same amplitude and are real , then @xmath78 . among the four possible choices of signs ,
only this one @xmath79 produces result that matches the experiment well , so @xmath80 .
then @xmath81 , which is essentially formula ( [ simplef ] ) .
note that , because of the sign ambiguity one actually has four formulae for @xmath82 , but the one we chose is the one that matches experiment the best . to derive the complicated identities in formulae ( [ formula ] ) ,
let us introduce a few more notations .
denote by @xmath83 the 5th force transition amplitude from quark @xmath67 to quark @xmath11 .
here @xmath67 and @xmath11 are either all up quarks or all down quarks .
let @xmath84 and @xmath85 these are of course the simple transition amplitudes . for the convenience of readers , some of these transition amplitudes have been recorded in the following diagram : @xmath86 in the next step , we use the basic rules in quantum mechanics to figure out the interesting transition amplitudes in terms of the preceding simple transition amplitudes . of course
, we must ignore gravity , the electric force and the strong force in our analysis here .
these transition amplitudes are computed according to the rules in quantum mechanics .
for example , to compute @xmath82 , one notes that there are exactly two routes from @xmath12 to @xmath15 , one via @xmath74 which contributes @xmath87 to @xmath82 and one via @xmath11 which contributes @xmath88 to @xmath82 , so @xmath89 as another example , to compute @xmath90 , one notes that there is only one route from @xmath11 to @xmath74 , i.e. , the one via @xmath15 which contributes @xmath91 to @xmath90 , so @xmath92 ( the route via @xmath12 is not available because @xmath11 can not spontaneously decay to @xmath12 which is heavier than @xmath11 . ) a few more exercise of this kind yields the following equation @xmath93\end{aligned}\ ] ] the matrix @xmath68 at the moment is useless as far as predictions are concerned .
however , one notes that any match with experiment has to be more than just numerical , it must meet all reasonable physics expectations , too .
for example , with suitable relative phases fixed , it is very reasonable to expect that , up to sign , @xmath94 ( say @xmath95 ) , @xmath96 ( say @xmath97 ) , and @xmath98 ( say @xmath99 ) , @xmath100 , @xmath101 ( say @xmath102 ) .
further , if we assume hydrogen atom s spontaneous transition amplitudes hold roughly , we expect @xmath103 and @xmath104 .
this last physics expectation is reasonable in view of ref .
@xcite in which the elementary particles are proposed to be modeled on the hydrogen atom . with this in mind , a numerical match with @xmath105 which is either nearly zero or too big would not be considered as a match on physics ground . in the further analysis , it shall be assumed @xmath106 then @xmath107\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath108 .
note that , there are seven variables here : @xmath95 , @xmath97 , @xmath99 , @xmath91 , @xmath109 , @xmath110 and @xmath111 , so @xmath68 has predictive power now , that is because , with the identification of @xmath68 with @xmath9 , this form of @xmath68 yields the complicated identities in formulae ( [ formula ] ) .
note also that , if @xmath46 and @xmath0 are both positive , the match with experiments is also good numerically , but then the ratio @xmath112 is very tiny , so has to be rejected on physics ground ; on the other hand , if @xmath46 and @xmath0 are both negative , the match with experiments is good both numerically and on physics ground because @xmath113 is indeed close to @xmath35 in this case .
thanks to the more refined experimental data existing today , the mixed quark decay is better explained by a 5th force based theory than the ckm theory . since the 5th force is quite weak , its effect is very small so that only in certain special cases such as the one examined here can one possibly find a serious mismatch between the standard model and experiments .
of the decay of muons is due to the 5th force . in view of the amount ( @xmath114 ) of cp violation
observed for the decay of kaons , the actual amount of cp violation in the decay of muons is about @xmath115 , i.e. , about @xmath116 , which is too small to be observed . ] the program proposed in ref .
@xcite is based on a conservative modification of the twin pillars of fundamental physics .
the research presented here provides a successful quantitative test of this program , and in the process serious flaws in the established ckm theory are exposed .
i would like to thank my colleagues k. chen , b. y. jing , j. s. li , q. m. shao , t.z .
qian , m. yan , l. j. zhu for helpful discussions and advices , and z. ligeti for a clarification of the fit result for ckm matrix in ref .
i would also like to thank c. taubes for thoughtful discussions , advices , encouragement , and various important suggestions on improving this article .
l.l . chau and w
keung , _ phys .
lett . _ * 53 * ( 1984 ) , 1802 - 1805 .
the currently best known values for the standard parameters are @xmath117 they are taken from the wikipedia page titled cabibbo - kobayashi - maskawa matrix " . | in a recent article , this author proposed a program for physics beyond the standard model , solely based on modifying the twin pillars of fundamental physics by replacing lorentz structure with euclidean jordan algebra while keeping quantum theory .
this program predicts not only quarks and leptons but also a short - range 5th fundamental force accompanying gravity .
this 5th force predicts quark mixing and the related cp violation , which in fact was a phenomena observed in labs about fifty years ago .
thus , there are two conflicting theories as of now , the one based on the 5th force which _ predicts _ this phenomena and the established cabibbo - kobayashi - maskawa ( ckm ) theory which was invented to _
explain _ this phenomena . in this article
a test of these two theories against the recent experimental data is presented .
it is found in this test that the ckm theory fares poorly , whereas the one based on the 5th force withstands the test well , in both accuracy and precision .
for example , for the ckm matrix entry @xmath0 , we have @xmath1 |
in this paper , we investigate the hausdorff young inequality for a nonlinear version of the fourier transform , and establish theorem [ thm : main ] below . before stating it
precisely , we briefly discuss the linear case . given a complex - valued integrable function @xmath1 on the real line , we normalize its fourier transform as follows : @xmath2 in this way , the fourier transform is a contraction from @xmath3 to @xmath4 and it extends to a unitary operator on @xmath5 .
standard interpolation tools can then be used to show that , for any @xmath6 $ ] , the fourier transform is also a contraction from @xmath7 to @xmath8 , where @xmath9 denotes the exponent conjugate to @xmath10 .
this is the content of the classical hausdorff young inequality .
its sharp version was first established by babenko @xcite in the case when the exponent @xmath11 is an even integer , and then by beckner @xcite for general exponents .
it states that , if @xmath6 $ ] , then @xmath12 for every @xmath13 , where the optimal constant is given by @xmath14 an easy computation shows that gaussians , i.e. functions of the form @xmath15 with @xmath16 and @xmath17 , turn inequality into an equality . in other words , gaussians are _ extremizers _ for inequality .
in the converse direction , lieb @xcite has shown that all extremizers for inequality are in fact gaussians . recently , christ @xcite further refined inequality by establishing the following sharpened version : given @xmath18 , there exists a constant @xmath19 such that , for every nonzero function @xmath13 , @xmath20 here , the distance from @xmath13 to the set of all gaussians , denoted @xmath21 , is naturally defined as @xmath22 we now describe the nonlinear setting of the present paper .
we are interested in the simplest nonlinear model of the fourier transform , also known as the _ dirac scattering transform _ or the _
@xmath23-scattering transform_. to describe it precisely , take a measurable , bounded , and compactly supported function @xmath24 , which will often be referred to as a _
potential_. consider the initial - value problem @xmath25 for each @xmath26 , this problem has a unique solution @xmath27 , @xmath28 in the class of absolutely continuous functions .
we simply write @xmath29 , @xmath30 in place of the limits @xmath31 , @xmath32 , and define the nonlinear fourier transform of the potential @xmath1 to be the function @xmath33 if @xmath1 vanishes outside some interval @xmath34 $ ] , then the initial condition in translates into @xmath35 , @xmath36 , while @xmath37 can be interpreted as @xmath38 respectively . the differential equation forces
@xmath39 which in particular means that a certain size of the above vector is retained by the quantity @xmath40 alone . occasionally it is more convenient to add an extra column and turn the above vector into a @xmath41 matrix belonging to the classical lie group @xmath42 , see e.g. @xcite .
sources of motivation for considering this precise instance of the nonlinear fourier transform include the eigenvalue problem for the dirac operator , the study of completely integrable systems and scattering theory , and the riemann hilbert problem ; see the expository paper @xcite for further information , and the notes @xcite for several related examples in the discrete setting .
the dirac scattering transform is the simplest case of a more general transform , the akns
zs nonlinear fourier transform ; see @xcite , @xcite for details .
there is a strong parallel between the nonlinear and the linear fourier transforms .
it is a straightforward exercise to verify the following analogues of the symmetry rules for the linear fourier transform . *
_ unimodular homogeneity _ : if @xmath43 , where @xmath44 , then @xmath45 * _ modulation symmetry _ : if @xmath46 , where @xmath47 , then @xmath48 * _ translation symmetry _ : if @xmath49 , where @xmath50 , then @xmath51 * _ @xmath0-normalized dilation symmetry _ : if @xmath52 , where @xmath53 , then @xmath54 * _ conjugation symmetry _ : if @xmath55 , then @xmath56 * _ a substitute for additivity _ : if @xmath57 , where the support of @xmath58 lies to the left of that of @xmath59 , then @xmath60 we proceed to describe some nonlinear analogues of standard estimates for the linear fourier transform .
the nonlinear riemann lebesgue estimate , which follows easily from grnwall s inequality , states that @xmath61 for every potential @xmath1 .
the nonlinear plancherel identity , which is a well - known scattering identity that can be established via complex contour integration ( see e.g. the appendix in @xcite ) , states that @xmath62 for every potential @xmath1 as before .
this equality can even be used to extend the definition of @xmath63 for functions @xmath1 that are only square - integrable , but in this case the existence of the pointwise limits @xmath31 , @xmath32 for a.e .
@xmath64 is a well - known open problem ( see @xcite , @xcite ) .
even if interpolation is not available in the present nonlinear setting , the work of christ and kiselev on the spectral theory of one - dimensional schrdinger operators @xcite , @xcite establishes a version of the nonlinear hausdorff young inequality which translates into the present context as follows : if @xmath6 $ ] , then there exists a constant @xmath65 , such that @xmath66 for every potential @xmath1 .
an interesting question raised in @xcite is whether the constants @xmath67 can be chosen uniformly in @xmath10 , as @xmath68 .
this has been confirmed in a particular toy model in @xcite , but remains an open problem in its full generality . by considering truncated gaussian potentials @xmath69}(x)\ ] ] as @xmath70 and linearizing
, one can check that the constant in is at least as large as beckner s constant , i.e. @xmath71 .
one may be tempted to conjecture that the optimal constant in is actually @xmath72 .
while these questions are left open by the present work , we are able to provide some further supporting evidence of their validity by considering the behaviour of the nonlinear hausdorff young ratio for sufficiently small potentials .
the main result of this paper is the following theorem .
[ thm : main ] let @xmath18 , @xmath9 , and @xmath73 .
let @xmath74 .
then there exist @xmath75 and @xmath76 , depending on @xmath77 , with the following property : if @xmath78 is an interval of length @xmath79 , and @xmath80 is a measurable function such that @xmath81 and @xmath82 , then @xmath83 a few remarks may help to further orient the reader . * the parameters @xmath84 provide upper bounds for the _ height _ and the _ width _ of the function @xmath1 , respectively .
they are fixed but can be arbitrarily large .
* inequality implies with an optimal constant @xmath72 , but only within the restricted class of potentials considered in the theorem , and this class is allowed to depend on @xmath10 . that way theorem [ thm : main ] does not claim uniform boundedness of the constants in for any particular family of functions .
it rather fixes the value of @xmath10 and shows that the nonlinear hausdorff young inequality beats the linear one in the asymptotic regime when @xmath85 .
in particular , the constant @xmath86 is never attained for nonzero potentials in a sufficiently small neighborhood of the zero function ( depending on @xmath87 ) . * between the lines of the first part of the proof below ( see [ sec : far ] ) , one can easily obtain @xmath88 estimate provides a cheap version of , with @xmath89 replaced by @xmath90 , as @xmath91 , but the interest lies , of course , in obtaining the estimate with a negative sign . however , at least shows that the mere uniformity of the constants @xmath67 is trivial for potentials that are controlled in the @xmath0 norm .
* it is easy to observe that is invariant under @xmath0-normalized dilations applied to @xmath1 .
that way one can trade width for height or vice versa , and conclude that @xmath92 depend only on the _ product _ @xmath93 .
this fact can also be checked by tracking the dependence of various parameters in the proof .
let us briefly comment on the proof of theorem [ thm : main ] , which spans over the next three sections .
the upshot is that for most choices of @xmath1 one can simply estimate the error arising from linearization , while for the remaining ones we verify that the nonlinear effect actually improves the estimate . to implement this strategy
, we set up a case distinction , depending on whether the function @xmath1 is far or close to the set of gaussians , in an appropriate sense .
the former case is the subject of [ sec : far ] , where we invoke christ s sharpened hausdorff young inequality in order to absorb the error terms coming from linearization .
the latter case is the subject of [ sec : close ] , where we use a perturbative argument to expand the functional in question around a suitable gaussian that provides a good approximation for @xmath1 in _ both _ the @xmath94 and the @xmath0 senses .
we are naturally led to study a certain quartic operator @xmath95 and its quadrilinear variant @xmath96 , which enjoy various symmetries .
the operator @xmath95 can in turn be pointwise dominated by a power of the maximally truncated fourier transform , defined as follows : @xmath97 where the supremum is taken over all intervals @xmath98 .
the classical menshov paley
zygmund inequality states that , for every @xmath18 , there exists @xmath99 such that , for every @xmath13 , @xmath100 the argument makes crucial use of estimate in order to control the error terms , and to verify that the second order variation about the aforementioned gaussian has the correct sign .
proofs of several technical lemmata are deferred to
[ sec : proofs ] .
finally , in the last section [ sec : counterexample ] , we provide a counterexample to the natural question of whether an inequality @xmath101 might hold for a general bounded compactly supported potential @xmath1 .
more precisely , when @xmath102 , we exhibit an explicit linear combination of indicator functions of six contiguous intervals of unit length that disproves .
because of this , we believe that theorem [ thm : main ] can not be established solely by regarding as a small perturbation of . * notation . *
if @xmath103 are real numbers , we write @xmath104 or @xmath105 if there exists a finite absolute constant @xmath106 such that @xmath107 . if we want to make explicit the dependence of the constant @xmath106 on some parameter @xmath108 , we write @xmath109 or @xmath110 .
we also write @xmath111 and @xmath112 .
the real and imaginary parts of a complex number @xmath113 are denoted by @xmath114 and @xmath115 .
the indicator function of a set @xmath116 is denoted by @xmath117 . throughout the paper
it will be understood that all constants may depend on the admissible parameters @xmath77 .
let @xmath80 satisfy the assumptions of theorem [ thm : main ] .
our first task is to make precise what it means for @xmath1 to be far away from the set of gaussians .
the following notion will be suitable for our purposes : assume that @xmath118 where @xmath119 is shorthand notation for @xmath120 here , @xmath86 denotes beckner s constant and @xmath121 is the constant promised by christ s refinement .
this precise choice of @xmath119 will become clear as the proof unfolds .
in particular , note that @xmath122 . going back to the defining ode , it is straightforward to check that the functions @xmath123 and @xmath124 satisfy the integral equations @xmath125 adding the two equations , the triangle inequality yields @xmath126 taking the @xmath127 norm in @xmath128 and invoking minkowski s integral inequality , we obtain @xmath129}\big\|_{\textup{l}^q(\mathbb{r } ) } + \int_{-\infty}^x |f(t)| \big\| |b(t,\xi)| + |a(t,\xi ) - 1| \big\|_{\textup{l}^q_\xi(\mathbb{r } ) } { \,{\rm d}}t.\ ] ] to estimate the quantity @xmath130}\|_{\textup{l}^q(\mathbb{r})}$ ] , we further split the analysis into two cases .
_ @xmath131 in this case , for each @xmath132 we have that @xmath133}-g\|_{\textup{l}^p(\mathbb{r } ) } \geq \|f - g\|_{\textup{l}^p(\mathbb{r } ) } - \|f\mathbbm{1}_{(x,+\infty)}\|_{\textup{l}^p(\mathbb{r } ) } \geq \frac{\gamma}2 \|f\|_{\textup{l}^p(\mathbb{r})}.\ ] ] it follows that @xmath134},\mathfrak{g } ) \geq \frac{\gamma}2 \|f\mathbbm{1}_{(-\infty , x]}\|_{\textup{l}^p(\mathbb{r})},\ ] ] and christ s improved hausdorff
young inequality yields @xmath135}\big\|_{\textup{l}^q(\mathbb{r } ) } \leq \big ( { \bf b}_p - c_p\big(\frac{\gamma}2\big)^2 \big ) \|f\mathbbm{1}_{(-\infty , x]}\|_{\textup{l}^p(\mathbb{r } ) } \leq \widetilde{\bf b}_p \|f\|_{\textup{l}^p(\mathbb{r})},\ ] ] where @xmath136 is defined as @xmath137 note that @xmath136 is not really a constant , since @xmath119 depends on the @xmath0 norm of @xmath1
. _ case 2 .
_ @xmath138 in this case , the sharp hausdorff young inequality yields @xmath135}\big\|_{\textup{l}^q(\mathbb{r } ) } \leq { \bf b}_p \|f\mathbbm{1}_{(-\infty , x]}\|_{\textup{l}^p(\mathbb{r } ) } \leq { \bf b}_p \big(1-\big(\frac{\gamma}{2}\big)^p\big)^{\frac{1}{p } } \|f\|_{\textup{l}^p(\mathbb{r})}.\ ] ] bernoulli s inequality can then be invoked to verify that @xmath139 provided @xmath140 is chosen to be sufficiently small .
here we also use that @xmath141 . in both cases , we obtain @xmath142 grnwall s lemma then implies @xmath143 letting @xmath144 and estimating @xmath145 , we finally have that @xmath146 the obtained inequality shows that , in this case , the only loss in passing from the linear to the nonlinear setting amounts to the exponential factor , which tends to @xmath147 as @xmath85 .
recall the choice of @xmath119 from .
it remains to choose @xmath148 small enough , so that holds , and @xmath149 thus we have verified the desired inequality in the case when the function @xmath1 is far from the gaussians .
we analyse the complementary situation in the next section , where an additional smallness condition will be imposed on @xmath150 .
we are now working under the assumption @xmath151 where @xmath119 was defined in .
in particular , @xmath152 . thus , there exists a gaussian @xmath132 , such that @xmath153 this readily implies @xmath154 provided @xmath155 .
recall our working assumptions that @xmath1 vanishes outside an interval @xmath156 of length @xmath79 , that @xmath157 is bounded from above by @xmath158 , and that it satisfies @xmath159 . under these conditions ,
@xmath160 the penultimate step in this chain of inequalities follows from the choice of @xmath119 and log - convexity of the @xmath94 norms . as a consequence , @xmath161 provided @xmath140 is small enough .
this readily implies @xmath162 inequalities and ensure that the gaussian @xmath163 is a good approximation for the function @xmath1 on the whole real line , both in the @xmath94 and in the @xmath0 senses .
we now proceed to derive the first nontrivial term in the expansion of the left - hand side of inequality for any @xmath164 .
the first observation is that @xmath165 where the reflection coefficient @xmath166 satisfies riccati s differential equation @xmath167 in other words , the reflection coefficient is given by the integral equation @xmath168 from identity we obtain @xmath169 i.e. @xmath170 using the integral equation to substitute for @xmath171 on the right - hand side of , @xmath172 the first summand on the right - hand side can be recognized as @xmath173 repeating this procedure once again , i.e. substituting for @xmath174 and symmetrizing in the variables @xmath175 and @xmath176 , we conclude that @xmath177 where @xmath95 is the quartic operator defined as @xmath178 and @xmath179 is the nonlinear operator given by @xmath180 we now use the first numerical inequality established in lemma [ lm : inequalities ] below .
substituting @xmath181 into the inequality from part ( a ) of lemma [ lm : inequalities ] , and then integrating in @xmath128 , we conclude from that @xmath182 where the second term is given by @xmath183 and the remainder @xmath184 is bounded by a linear combination ( with coefficients depending only on @xmath11 ) of integrals @xmath185 and , if @xmath186 , also @xmath187 approximating the function @xmath1 with the gaussian @xmath163 as discussed at the beginning of this section , we are thus reduced to showing that @xmath188 is a large enough positive quantity , that @xmath188 provides a good approximation for @xmath189 , and that the remainder term @xmath184 is appropriately small .
this is accomplished via the following sequence of lemmata , whose proofs are deferred to the next section in order not to obscure the main line of reasoning .
all of them hold under the ongoing assumption that @xmath1 satisfies the hypotheses of theorem [ thm : main ] , and that @xmath132 approximates @xmath1 in the sense of .
the first lemma shows that the quantity @xmath188 is not too small .
[ lm : hbounds ] @xmath190 the second lemma shows that @xmath188 provides a good approximation for @xmath189 .
[ lm : diffhbounds ] @xmath191 the third lemma shows smallness of the remainder term @xmath184 .
[ lm : rbounds ] @xmath192 we are now in a position to finish the proof of the theorem . if the parameter @xmath140 is chosen to be small enough , then so is @xmath119 , and the three lemmata combine with bounds , to yield @xmath193 if @xmath76 is small enough , then this inequality together with , , , lemma [ lm : hbounds ] , and the sharp hausdorff young inequality imply @xmath194 one last application of bernoulli s inequality finally yields @xmath195 as desired .
this completes the proof of theorem [ thm : main ] modulo the verification of the lemmata , which is the content of the next section .
we start with some elementary numerical inequalities . [ lm : inequalities ] given an exponent @xmath196 ,
the following inequalities hold . * for @xmath197 and @xmath198
one has @xmath199 with some finite constant @xmath200 depending only on @xmath11 . * for @xmath197 and @xmath198
one has @xmath201 with some finite constant @xmath202 depending only on @xmath11 .
\(a ) no generality is lost in assuming that @xmath203 .
we can then divide both sides of the inequality by @xmath204 , and substituting @xmath205 we are left with checking that @xmath206 if @xmath207 denotes the quotient of the two sides of the inequality , @xmath208 then we need to show boundedness from above of the function @xmath209 on @xmath210 .
this is a simple consequence of the continuity of @xmath209 and finiteness of the limits : @xmath211 \(b ) this time the substitution @xmath205 turns the inequality into @xmath212 if we again denote the quotient of the two sides by @xmath207 , then the inequality follows as before from the continuity of @xmath209 and finiteness of the limits : @xmath213 start by noting that the quotient @xmath214 is invariant under arbitrary scalings , modulations , translations , and @xmath0-normalized dilations . indeed , if @xmath215 for some @xmath216 , then @xmath217 . moreover , if @xmath218 for some @xmath219 , then @xmath220 .
similarly , if @xmath49 for some @xmath221 , then @xmath220 . finally , dilation invariance is easily seen from the fourier representation @xmath222 where the function @xmath223 is given by @xmath224 here we are integrating over a region in the affine hyperplane @xmath225 with respect to the @xmath226-dimensional hausdorff measure @xmath227 .
the constant @xmath228 is unimportant and it is coming from the non - orthogonal choice of coordinates .
it follows that , if @xmath229 , then @xmath230 on the other hand , @xmath231 this shows that the expression is invariant under @xmath0-normalized dilations , as claimed .
now , going back to and writing @xmath232 one sees that any gaussian can be brought to standard form by an application of an appropriate scaling , modulation , translation , and dilation .
given the symmetries of just discussed , in verifying the claim of the lemma we can assume that the gaussian approximation @xmath163 coincides with the standard gaussian , @xmath233 .
in this case , we are reduced to checking that @xmath234 . again writing @xmath235 as the fourier transform of some function @xmath223
, then from formula above with @xmath236 it immediately follows that @xmath223 is nonnegative and not identically zero . also , @xmath237 is the fourier transform of another gaussian function @xmath238 , given by @xmath239 which is clearly strictly positive .
it remains to invoke unitarity of the linear fourier transform and observe that @xmath240 this concludes the proof of the lemma .
the proofs of the two remaining lemmata rely on the observation that @xmath241 can be pointwise controlled by the maximally truncated fourier transform @xmath242 , defined in .
indeed , @xmath243 in a similar way , @xmath244 can be controlled pointwise by @xmath242 . to see this , start by noting that the reflection coefficient satisfies @xmath245 .
it then follows from the integral equation that also @xmath246 .
this time we get @xmath247 we start by rewriting @xmath248 as @xmath249 set @xmath250 .
part ( b ) of lemma [ lm : inequalities ] allows us to bound the first integral in by a multiple of @xmath251 to bound these integrals , start by observing that estimates and imply @xmath252 hlder s inequality and the hausdorff young inequality then imply @xmath253 where the last inequality is a consequence of , , and . in particular
, this term is acceptable . in a similar way
, @xmath254 is likewise acceptable for @xmath255 .
now we focus on the second integral from .
it is useful to introduce the quadrilinear operator @xmath96 by @xmath256 so that @xmath257 .
it can be estimated either by @xmath258 or ( similarly as @xmath95 ) by @xmath259 so the @xmath260 norm of this function is controlled using , , and hlder s inequality by @xmath261 invoking the menshov paley
zygmund inequality , , , and then gives @xmath262 finally , yet another application of hlder s inequality combined with the linear hausdorff young inequality for @xmath163 bounds the second integral in by a constant times @xmath263 as noted before , this concludes the proof of the lemma .
the proof parallels that of the previous lemma , and so we shall be brief . using hlder s inequality , the pointwise estimates and , and that fact that the maximally truncated fourier transform @xmath264 satisfies the estimate , we conclude that the five integrals in and are respectively controlled by @xmath265 since @xmath266 , the result follows .
for @xmath267 , respectively.,title="fig:",width=226 ] for @xmath267 , respectively.,title="fig:",width=226 ] + for @xmath267 , respectively.,title="fig:",width=226 ] for @xmath267 , respectively.,title="fig:",width=226 ] now we disprove inequality . for computational simplicity ,
take @xmath102 .
define : @xmath268 and consider the potential @xmath269 for a variable parameter @xmath270 .
graphs of the function @xmath271 for several values of @xmath108 are depicted in figure [ fig : examples ] .
let us remark that already for @xmath272 the graph looks almost identically as the one of @xmath273 , due to the effects of linearization .
straightforward numerical computation of the @xmath274 norms for @xmath272 provides a direct counterexample to : @xmath275 the above decimal numbers were evaluated using the _ mathematica _ @xcite command _ nintegrate _ with options _
workingprecision @xmath276 _ and _ accuracygoal @xmath277_. the step - function [ eq : fcounter ] was discovered by numerical evaluation of the @xmath278-linear generalization of the form @xmath279 for indicator functions of arbitrary intervals @xmath280 , where @xmath281 for each @xmath282 , and subsequent numerical optimization of the coefficients .
v.k . was supported in part by the croatian science foundation under the project 3526 .
v.k . and j.r .
were partially supported by the bilateral daad - mzo grant _ multilinear singular integrals and applications_. d.o.s .
was partially supported by the hausdorff center for mathematics and dfg grant crc1060 .
this work was started during a pleasant visit of the second author to the university of zagreb , whose hospitality is greatly appreciated .
m. christ and a. kiselev , _ wkb asymptotic behavior of almost all generalized eigenfunctions for one - dimensional schrdinger operators with slowly decaying potentials _ , j. funct .
, * 179 * ( 2001 ) , no . 2 , 426447 . v. e. zakharov , a. b. shabat , _ a refined theory of two dimensional self - focussing and one - dimensional self - modulation of waves in non - linear media _ ( russian ) , zh .
. fiz . * 61 * ( 1971 ) 118134 . | the nonlinear hausdorff young inequality follows from the work of christ and kiselev .
later muscalu , tao , and thiele asked if the constants can be chosen independently of the exponent .
we show that the nonlinear hausdorff young quotient admits an even better upper bound than the linear one , provided that the function is sufficiently small in the @xmath0 norm .
the proof combines perturbative techniques with the sharpened version of the linear hausdorff young inequality due to christ . |
a fundamental question of communication theory is : at what rate can information be transmitted reliably over a noisy channel ? there is more than one way to go about answering this question .
for instance , consider an erasure channel where the parameter @xmath0 denotes the probability with which a transmission on the channel is lost ; with probability @xmath1 the transmission is received without error .
the traditional approach for describing the rate of reliable communication for the erasure channel is to cite its shannon capacity , which is @xmath1 bits per channel use for a channel with binary inputs and outputs .
if feedback is available to notify the sender when a channel input is erased , then the capacity can be achieved by retransmitting lost inputs @xcite .
alternatively , the rate of reliable communication can be described by the _
maximum stable throughput_. in this setting , we view the channel input as a packet of fixed length that arrives at a random time to a sender and is stored in an infinite - capacity buffer while awaiting its turn to be sent over the channel .
the packets in the buffer form a queue that is emptied in a specified order , traditionally in first - in - first - out ( fifo ) order .
a transmission protocol , for instance an automatic repeat request ( arq ) protocol , provides a form of redundancy to ensure that the packet is received correctly .
the maximum stable throughput is the highest rate ( in packets per channel use ) at which packets arrive to the sender while ensuring that the queue remains finite . in the case of the erasure channel ,
if we assume that packets arrive to the sender according to a bernoulli process , feedback is available to notify the sender of lost packets , and the transmission protocol consists of retransmitting lost packets , then the buffer at the sender forms a discrete - time @xmath2 queue with maximum departure rate @xmath1 .
the maximum stable throughput is @xmath1 , which is identical to the shannon capacity . for _ multiuser systems
_ , the relation between the shannon capacity and the maximum stable throughput for communication over an erasure channel has been explored in the context of random multiple access , where user @xmath3 transmits with probability @xmath4 at each transmission opportunity .
this form of random channel access is a variation on abramson s aloha protocol @xcite and is particularly attractive for use in mobile ad - hoc networks because it is robust to variations in the network topology and can be implemented without coordination among the transmitting nodes .
the finite - user , buffered random access problem was first formulated by tsybakov and mikhailov @xcite , who provided a sufficient condition for stability and thus a lower bound on the maximum stable throughput .
the problem they considered was a system in which finitely many source nodes with infinite - capacity queues randomly access a shared channel to send messages to a central station .
feedback was used to notify the source nodes of failed transmissions and a retransmission scheme was used to ensure eventual successful reception at the central station .
the users were assumed to access a _ collision channel _ , in which transmission by more than one source results in the loss of all transmitted packets with probability 1 .
this collision channel model is equivalent to an erasure channel , where for user @xmath3 , @xmath5 .
further progress on this problem was made in @xcite , in which stochastic dominance arguments were explicitly introduced to find the stable throughput region for a system with 2 source nodes , and in @xcite , wherein a stable throughput region based on the joint queue statistics was found for 3 source nodes .
an exact stability result for arbitrarily ( but finitely ) many users has not been found , but bounds have been obtained in @xcite and @xcite .
recently , the authors of @xcite improved upon the collision channel model used in all previous works and studied a channel with multipacket reception ( mpr ) capability .
they showed that the stable throughput region transfers from a non - convex region under the collision channel model to a convex region bounded by straight lines for a channel with mpr .
the shannon capacity region of a random access system was considered in @xcite and @xcite , which both obtained the capacity region for finitely many source nodes transmitting to a central station under the collision channel model .
that capacity result can be viewed as the capacity of an asynchronous multiple access channel , which was obtained in @xcite and @xcite .
the more recent contribution of @xcite shows explicitly how the random access capacity region in @xcite is obtained from the results in @xcite , in addition to analyzing the capacity for a channel in which packets involved in a collision can be recovered .
it was noted by massey and mathys @xcite and rao and ephremides @xcite that the stable throughput and shannon capacity regions coincide for the special cases of two source nodes and infinitely - many source nodes .
as with the point - to - point erasure channel , this result is surprising in that it suggests that the bursty nature of arriving packets , which is captured in the stability problem but not in the capacity problem , is immaterial in determining the limits on the rate of reliable communication .
it has been conjectured that the stable throughput region for finitely - many source nodes transmitting to a central station ( which is an unsolved problem ) coincides with the corresponding capacity region .
this conjecture was explored in @xcite , in which it was shown to hold in a special case involving correlated arrivals of packets at the source nodes .
recently , further progress was made in @xcite towards showing that the stable throughput and shannon capacity regions coincide for transmission over a channel with mpr .
however , a complete proof has still not been found . in this work
we explore the relation between the stable throughput and shannon capacity for a random access system in which source nodes _ multicast _ their messages to multiple receivers .
specifically , we consider a system with two source nodes and two destination nodes .
the source nodes randomly access the channel to transmit to the two destination nodes .
we first characterize the shannon capacity region of the system , which is similar to ahlswede s result @xcite on the capacity for two senders and two receivers .
we then move to the queueing stability problem and characterize the stable throughput region for our random access multicast system with two different transmission policies .
the first is a retransmission policy , which is the policy used in previous works on queueing stability for a ( single ) central station .
next , we study random access multicast with random linear coding , which is inspired by the recent development of network coding @xcite and fountain coding @xcite .
our results show that for multicast transmission , the maximum stable throughput under the retransmission policy does not reach the shannon capacity , however , the random linear coding scheme provides a maximum stable throughput that asymptotically approaches the shannon capacity .
, the reception probabilities are as shown above.,scaledwidth=30.0% ] the system we consider throughout this work is shown in fig . [
fig : general_2sour2dest ] .
two source nodes , indexed by @xmath3 , each generate messages to be multicast to two destination nodes , indexed by @xmath6 , over a shared channel .
the data generated at source @xmath7 is assumed independent of the data generated at source @xmath8 .
time is slotted ; one time slot corresponds to the amount of time needed to transmit a single packet over the shared channel .
a packet is a fixed - length vector of bits . in each time slot , if source @xmath3 has a packet to transmit , then we refer to the source as being _ backlogged _ ; otherwise the source is _ empty_. a backlogged source transmits in a slot with probability @xmath4 .
we refer to @xmath4 as the transmission probability ; it encapsulates random access to the channel .
we assume the value of @xmath4 to be fixed in time .
( i.e. , we do not assume retransmission control , in which @xmath4 is varied over time according to the history of successful transmissions . )
the channel model we consider is similar to the model used in @xcite .
a transmitted packet is received without error with a certain probability .
otherwise , the packet is lost and can not be recovered .
we assume that the channels between different source - destination pairs are independent .
we introduce the following _ reception probabilities _ for sources @xmath9 and destinations @xmath10 .
@xmath11 @xmath12 we assume throughout that interference can not increase the reception probability on the channel , i.e. , @xmath13 .
the reception probabilities inherently account for interference and also allow for multipacket reception ( mpr ) .
note that these probabilities can capture the effects of fading on the wireless channel by setting them equal to the probability that a fading signal , represented by a random variable , exceeds a certain signal to interference plus noise ( sinr ) threshold . the collision channel model used in a number of previous works
is given by @xmath14 , @xmath15 .
we first analyze the system under consideration in an information - theoretic framework to determine the shannon capacity region .
thus we assume in this section that the sources are always backlogged .
coding is performed on the data at the source nodes , and we view each transmitted packet as a codeword symbol , where a collection of @xmath16 codeword symbols constitutes a codeword . in order to allow for random access of the channel , we assume that while codeword symbols are synchronized ( equivalently , time is slotted ) , the codewords for the two sources do not necessarily begin and end in the same time slots .
we analyze this system first for a general discrete memoryless channel ( dmc ) and then apply our random access channel model to obtain the capacity region .
the discrete memoryless channel we consider consists of discrete alphabets @xmath17 and @xmath18 and transition probability matrix @xmath19 .
the channel can be decomposed into two multiple access channels , each corresponding to a destination node and defined as follows .
@xmath20 we assume that there is no feedback available on the channel , which differs from the assumption made in the model for the stable throughput problem presented in section [ section : stablethroughputregion ] .
source node @xmath3 generates a sequence of messages @xmath21 where the @xmath22 message @xmath23 takes values from the message set @xmath24 .
the messages are chosen uniformly from @xmath24 and independently over @xmath3 . the encoding function @xmath25 at source @xmath3
is given by the mapping @xmath26 the encoder output consists of a sequence of codewords @xmath27 , @xmath28 .
the system is asynchronous in the following sense .
each source and each destination maintain a clock .
let @xmath29 denote the amount of time that the clock at source @xmath3 is running ahead of the clock at destination @xmath6 .
the @xmath29 are assumed to be integers , meaning that time is discrete and transmissions are symbol - synchronous .
the time at each clock can be divided into _ periods _ of length @xmath16 corresponding to the length of a codeword .
let @xmath30 denote the offset between the start of periods at source @xmath3 and destination @xmath6 , where @xmath31 .
we assume that @xmath30 are uniform over @xmath32 $ ] for all @xmath16 .
the codeword @xmath33 is sent at time @xmath34 on the clock at source @xmath3 .
a sequence of channel outputs are observed at each destination , where the outputs at destination @xmath6 each take values from the alphabet @xmath35 .
the decoder operates on a sequence of @xmath36 channel outputs to form an estimate of a sequence of @xmath37 messages .
a decoder is defined as follows .
@xmath38 where @xmath39 denotes the @xmath40-fold cartesian product of @xmath41 .
since the decoder must synchronize on a particular source @xmath3 , the decoding function is defined separately for each source .
the output of the decoder is a sequence of message estimates @xmath42 , where @xmath43 denotes the estimate at destination @xmath6 of the @xmath22 message sent by source @xmath3 .
the error criterion we consider is the average probability of error @xmath44 defined as @xmath45 the rate pair @xmath46 is _ achievable _ if there exists encoding functions @xmath47 and decoding functions @xmath48 such that @xmath49 for all @xmath50 as @xmath51 .
the capacity region is the set of all achievable rate pairs the model we consider here is a compound version of the _ totally asynchronous multiple access channel _ treated in @xcite and @xcite . as shown in those works , the asynchrony in the system results in the lack of a convex hull operation , and this holds as well in our compound version of the problem .
the capacity region is presented below and the proof of the theorem is described in appendix [ app : proofcapreg ] .
the capacity region of the asynchronous compound multiple access channel is the closure of all rate points @xmath52 that lie in the region @xmath53[c]{c } \bigcap_{m } \left\{(r_1,r_2):\begin{ieeeeqnarraybox}[\relax][c]{r'l'l } r_1 & \!\ ! < \!\ ! &
i(x_1;y_m | x_2 ) \\
r_2 & \!\ ! < \!\ ! & i(x_2;y_m
r_1+r_2 & \!\ ! < \!\ ! & i(x_1 , x_2;y_m ) \end{ieeeeqnarraybox } \right\ } \end{ieeeeqnarraybox}\ ] ] for some product distribution @xmath54 .
[ thrm : capreg ] we now turn our attention to a random access system and apply theorem [ thrm : capreg ] to determine the capacity region of the system . each codeword symbol corresponds to a packet transmitted over the channel shown in figure [ fig : general_2sour2dest ] .
we define the common input alphabet as @xmath55 , where @xmath56 , for @xmath9
. a channel input @xmath57 can be either a packet of length @xmath58 bits ( an information - bearing symbol ) or an idle symbol .
the @xmath34 symbol is the idle symbol and we let pr@xmath59 according to the random access transmission probability .
we assume a uniform distribution on the information - bearing codeword symbols , @xmath60 , @xmath61 , meaning that a packet is equally likely to be any sequence of @xmath58 bits .
the channel output at receiver @xmath6 is given by @xmath62 where @xmath63 denotes the packet from source @xmath3 and @xmath64 .
the @xmath65 symbol denotes a packet in error .
the introduction of the idle symbol @xmath34 results in additional protocol or timing information being transmitted over the channel .
the information content of this idle symbol is @xmath66 , where @xmath67 denotes the binary entropy function .
the term @xmath68 appears in the proof provided below and represents the protocol information that is studied by gallager in @xcite . because we would like our capacity result to represent the rate of reliable communication of data packets , we will aim to exclude this timing information
we do so by considering capacity in packets / slot in the limit as @xmath69 , meaning that the data packets grow large and the fraction of timing information transmitted approaches @xmath34 .
the timing information is excluded in previous work on random access capacity . in @xcite , prior to the start of transmission , a `` protocol sequence '' indicating the occurrence of idle slots is generated at the source and communicated to the receiver , effectively eliminating timing information . in @xcite , the capacity for @xmath70 is presented .
the capacity of the random access multicast system is given in the following corollary to theorem [ thrm : capreg ] .
the capacity region of the random access system with two sources and two destinations is the closure of @xmath52 for which @xmath71 for some @xmath72 ^ 2 $ ] .
[ cor : capacity ] the result follows by applying the assumptions about the input distribution and channel reception probabilities to the expressions given in theorem [ thrm : capreg ] .
we first solve for @xmath73 by conditioning on @xmath74 to obtain @xmath75 an expression for @xmath76 can be found from the following sequence of equalities .
@xmath77 where @xmath78 holds since @xmath74 is independent of @xmath79 and since @xmath80 .
for @xmath81 we have @xmath82 combining expressions ( [ eqn : hx1givenx2_1 ] ) and ( [ eqn : hx1givenx2_2 ] ) results in @xmath83 since one packet corresponds to @xmath58 bits , we divide by @xmath58 to obtain a result in units of packets per slot .
we then let @xmath70 to obtain @xmath84 by following a similar approach , we can show that @xmath85 is given as follows . @xmath86 the bound on the sum rate can be found by breaking up @xmath87 into four terms .
@xmath88 for @xmath9 , the terms @xmath89 can be expressed as @xmath90 the last two terms in ( [ eqn : ix1x2;y4terms ] ) can be found in the following manner .
@xmath92 by substituting ( [ eqn : hxn ] ) , ( [ eqn : hx1giveny1x2 ] ) , and ( [ eqn : hx2giveny ] ) in ( [ eqn : ix1x2;y4terms ] ) , dividing by @xmath58 and taking @xmath69 , we obtain @xmath93 since @xmath94 , the bound on the sum rate is superfluous in terms of describing the capacity region .
the result follows .
in this section we treat the system shown in fig . [
fig : general_2sour2dest ] as a network of queues and state the stable throughput region of the system , which is a generalization of previous results on the stable throughput for a system with a single destination node .
the model we consider is as follows .
we no longer assume that the sources are always backlogged ; instead a random bernoulli process with rate @xmath95 packets / slot , @xmath9 models the arrival of packets at each source .
packets that are not immediately transmitted are stored in an infinite - capacity buffer maintained at each source .
transmissions occur according to the random access protocol with source @xmath3 transmitting with probability @xmath4 when it is backlogged .
if a source is empty in a given slot , it does not access the channel .
each source - destination pair is assumed to maintain an orthogonal feedback channel so that instantaneous and error - free acknowledgements can be sent from the destinations to the sources .
we find the stable throughput region for two different transmission schemes : retransmissions and random linear coding .
the queue at each source is described by its arrival process and departure process .
as @xmath95 represents the arrival rate , we let @xmath96 denote the departure or service rate . in general , a queue is said to be stable if departures occur more frequently than arrivals , i.e. , @xmath97 .
this statement is made precise by loynes result @xcite , which states that if the arrival and departure processes are non - negative , finite , and strictly stationary , then @xmath97 is a necessary and sufficient condition for stability . stability of the queue is equivalent to ergodicity of the markov chain representing the queue length .
the stable throughput region for a given transmission policy is defined as the set of all @xmath98 for which there exists transmission probabilities @xmath99 such that both queues remain stable .
the difficulty in finding the stable throughput region for our system ( and for any buffered random access system ) arises from the interaction of the queues .
in particular , the service rate @xmath96 of source @xmath3 will vary according to whether the _ other _ source is empty or backlogged and can create interference on the channel . to overcome
this difficulty , the technique provided in @xcite of introducing a dominant system can be used to decouple the sources . in a dominant system ,
one of the sources behaves as if it is always backlogged by transmitting `` dummy '' packets when it empties .
the queue length in a dominant system stochastically dominates ( i.e. , is never smaller than ) the queue length in the system of interest , meaning that stability in a dominant system implies stability in the original system . since one source always behaves as if it is backlogged , the service rate in the dominant system can be easily found .
let @xmath100 denote the service rate at source @xmath3 when the other source is backlogged and @xmath101 the service rate when the other source is empty . using the dominant systems approach
, the stable throughput region for a system with two sources can be found exactly .
this region is stated in the following theorem , which is a generalization of the result in @xcite .
note that in the stable throughput region presented below , the service rates @xmath100 and @xmath101 are functions of @xmath4 , @xmath9 ( although not explicitly shown in these expressions ) .
@xcite [ thrm:2x2stabreg ] for a network with two sources and two destinations , the stable throughput region is given by the closure of @xmath102 where @xmath103 and @xmath104[c]{r'l'l } \lambda_1 & \!\ !
< \!\ ! & \frac{\lambda_2}{\mu_{2b } } \mu_{1b } + \left ( 1 -\frac{\lambda_2}{\mu_{2b}}\right ) \mu_{1e } \\
\lambda_2 & \!\ ! < \!\ ! & \mu_{2b } \end{ieeeeqnarraybox } \right\}\ ] ] @xmath105[c]{r'l'l } \lambda_1 & \!\ ! < \!\ ! & \mu_{1b } \\
\lambda_2 & \!\ ! < \!\ ! & \frac{\lambda_1}{\mu_{1b } } \mu_{2b } + \left ( 1 - \frac{\lambda_1}{\mu_{1b } } \right ) \mu_{2e } \end{ieeeeqnarraybox } \right\}\ ] ] for some @xmath72 ^ 2 $ ] .
in addition to the stable throughput region , we will be interested in the throughput region of the random access system shown in fig .
[ fig : general_2sour2dest ] .
the throughput region is the closure of the service rates @xmath100 for all @xmath4 , @xmath9 , where both sources are assumed to be backlogged . in finding the throughput region
, there is no interaction between the sources , and the problem is simpler than finding the stable throughput problem .
previous work on buffered random access systems has shown that in all cases in which the stable throughput region has been found , it is known to coincide with the throughput region , suggesting that the empty state of the buffer is insignificant in determining stability .
the relation between stable throughput and throughput is explored in @xcite .
additionally , in @xcite , it is proved that for a random access system with two sources and two destinations , the stable throughput region coincides with the throughput region .
this result is restated below .
@xcite the stable throughput region of the random access system with two sources and two destinations is equivalent to the throughput region , which is given by the closure of @xmath98 for which @xmath106 for some @xmath72 ^ 2 $ ] .
[ theorem : throughput ] we derive the backlogged and empty service rates @xmath100 and @xmath101 for two different transmission schemes .
together with theorems [ thrm:2x2stabreg ] and [ theorem : throughput ] , this provides us a complete characterization of the stable throughput region .
in this section we describe the stable throughput region under assuming that a retransmission protocol is used to ensure reliable communication . in the retransmission scheme , as long as source @xmath3 has not received feedback acknowledgements from both destinations @xmath10 , it will continue to transmit the packet over the channel with probability @xmath4 in each slot .
as soon as the source has received acknowledgements from both destinations , it will remove the packet from its queue and begin transmitting the next packet waiting in its buffer , if any .
let random variable @xmath107 denote the service time for source @xmath3 , given by the total number of slots that transpire before the packet from source @xmath3 is successfully received at both destinations .
( note that the service time includes slots during which the source does not transmit , which happens with probability @xmath108 ) .
since each completed service in the retransmission scheme results in 1 packet being removed from the queue , the average service rate is given by @xmath109 $ ] .
we first find the backlogged service rates @xmath100 .
let @xmath110 denote the number of slots needed for successful reception of a packet from source @xmath3 at destination @xmath6 , @xmath10 .
the @xmath110 are geometrically distributed according to the transmission probabilities @xmath4 and reception probabilities @xmath111 , @xmath112 .
we introduce the following notation .
let @xmath113 denote the probability of successful reception of the packet from source @xmath3 at destination 1 given that source @xmath3 transmits and that both sources are backlogged .
similarly , @xmath114 denotes the probability of successful reception at destination 2 given that both sources are backlogged and that source @xmath3 transmits .
for instance , @xmath115 and @xmath116 are given by @xmath117 where @xmath118 .
when source 2 is backlogged , @xmath119 is geometrically distributed with parameter @xmath120 and @xmath121 is geometrically distributed with parameter @xmath122 .
the total service time for source 1 when source 2 is backlogged will be given by the maximum of the service times to each destination , @xmath123 similarly , when source 1 is backlogged , the service time for source 2 is given by @xmath124 where @xmath125 the expected maximum value @xmath126 $ ] can be readily found and the backlogged service rates are given by @xmath127 where @xmath128 denotes the probability that a packet sent from @xmath3 is received at both destinations given that source @xmath3 transmits , e.g. , @xmath129 .
the empty service rates @xmath101 can be found directly from @xmath100 as @xmath130 the backlogged and empty service rates for random access multicast with retransmissions have also been found in @xcite . in that work
, a different approach is used in which a markov chain is used to model which destinations have received the packet currently under transmission .
the result is identical to the one presented above .
we now compare the stable throughput region for the retransmissions scheme to the shannon capacity region .
we consider the backlogged service rate @xmath100 , since , by theorem [ theorem : throughput ] , this is the term that bounds the stable throughput for source @xmath3 .
the expected service time for source 1 when source 2 is backlogged is bounded as @xmath131 = e[\max_m t_1^{(m ) } ] & \stackrel{(a ) } \geq & \max_m e[t_1^{(m ) } ] \\ & \stackrel{(b ) } = & \max_m \frac{1}{p_1 ( 1-p_2 ) q_{1|1}^{(m ) } + p_1 p_2 q_{1|1,2}^{(m ) } } \\ & = & \frac{1}{\min_m p_1 ( 1-p_2 ) q_{1|1}^{(m ) } + p_1 p_2 q_{1|1,2}^{(m)}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath78 follows from jensen s inequality and @xmath132 follows from the expected value of a geometrically distributed random variable . then the backlogged service rate @xmath133 is bounded as @xmath134 }
\leq \min_m p_1 ( 1-p_2 ) q_{1|1}^{(m ) } + p_1 p_2 q_{1|1,2}^{(m ) } \label{eqn : boundretransservrate}\ ] ] and @xmath135 can be bounded similarly .
note that the right - hand side of ( [ eqn : boundretransservrate ] ) is equal to the bound on the shannon achievable rate @xmath136 given in corollary [ cor : capacity ] .
thus we should expect that the shannon capacity region outer bounds the stable throughput region for the retransmission scheme .
in this section we present two different approaches to analyzing the stable throughput region for a transmission scheme in which groups of @xmath137 packets at the front of the queue are randomly encoded and transmitted over the channel . by encoded , we mean that a random linear combination of the @xmath137 packets is formed , and we refer to this random linear combination as a coded packet .
as soon as a destination has received enough coded packets and is able to decode the original @xmath137 packets , it does so and sends an acknowledgement to the source over its feedback channel .
once the source receives acknowledgements from both destinations , it removes the @xmath137 packets it has been encoding and transmitting from its queue and begins encoding and transmission of the next @xmath137 packets waiting in its buffer .
the stable throughput region for a similar system with @xmath138 is found in @xcite .
for a given source , let @xmath139 denote the @xmath137 ( binary ) packets at the front of the queue .
random linear coding is performed in the following manner .
a coded packet is randomly generated as @xmath140 where the coefficients @xmath141 are generated according to @xmath142 , @xmath143 , and @xmath144 denotes modulo-2 addition .
a coded packet formed in this way is the same length as one of the original packets @xmath145 and can be transmitted over the channel within the same time period of a slot . for each coded packet
sent , the coefficients @xmath141 used in generating the packet will be appended to the header of the packet . in each slot
, the source generates a coded packet according to ( [ eqn : rlccodedpacket ] ) and sends it over the channel . regardless of
whether a previously - generated coded packet has been received , the source generates a new coded packet in each slot and transmits it with probability @xmath4 .
we first analyze the random linear coding scheme by examining the expected service time in a manner similar to the approach used for the retransmission scheme in section [ section : stabilityretrans ] .
let @xmath146 denote the service time for source @xmath3 , which is the number of slots that elapse from the transmission of the first coded packet until the source has received acknowledgements from both destinations .
since each completed service in the random linear coding scheme results in @xmath137 packets being removed from the queue , the average service rate is given by @xmath147 $ ] .
the service time will be a random variable dependent upon the random access transmission probabilities @xmath4 , the reception probabilities @xmath111 and @xmath112 , and the number of coded packets needed to decode .
let @xmath148 denote the number of coded packets received from source @xmath3 at destination @xmath6 before destination @xmath6 can decode the original @xmath137 packets .
the @xmath148 will be identically distributed over @xmath3 and @xmath6 since all coded packets are generated in the same way according to ( [ eqn : rlccodedpacket ] ) .
additionally , @xmath148 will be independent over @xmath3 since the two sources generate their coded packets independently .
however , @xmath148 will be correlated over @xmath6 , since a given source @xmath3 will generate and transmit the same coded packets to both destinations @xmath10 . for a fixed value of @xmath137 , let @xmath149 denote the common cumulative distribution function ( cdf ) of @xmath148 , or the probability that the number of coded packets needed for decoding is less than or equal to @xmath150 . with each coded packet it receives
, the destination collects a binary column of length @xmath137 in a matrix , where the column consists of the coefficients @xmath141 , @xmath143 .
then @xmath149 is the probability that decoding can be performed ( by solving a system of linear equations , or equivalently , by gaussian elimination ) if the matrix has at most @xmath150 columns .
thus @xmath151 note that for @xmath152 the matrix can not possibly have rank @xmath137 and @xmath153 .
for @xmath154 , we can write an expression for @xmath149 following the procedure in @xcite by first counting up the number of @xmath155 non - singular matrices , which is given by @xmath156 in the product above , each term accounts for a row of the @xmath157 binary matrix and reflects that the row is neither zero , nor equal to any of the previous rows , nor equal to any linear combination of previous rows . since the total number of @xmath155 binary matrices is @xmath158 , we obtain @xmath159 the probability mass function ( pmf ) of @xmath148 , or the probability that decoding can be performed when the destination has received exactly @xmath150 columns and no fewer , is given by @xmath160 from ( [ eqn : cdfn ] ) and ( [ eqn : pmfnascdfn ] ) the expected value of @xmath148 can be computed , where @xmath161 \geq k$ ] .
the ratio @xmath162}{k } & = & \prod_{i=0}^{k-1 } ( 1 - 2^{-k+i } ) + \frac{1}{k } \sum_{j = k+1}^{\infty } j \left ( \prod_{i=0}^{k-1 } ( 1 - 2^{-j+i } ) - \prod_{i=0}^{k-1 } ( 1 - 2^{-j+1+i } ) \right ) \\ &
\longrightarrow & 1 \quad \mbox { as } k \rightarrow \infty\end{aligned}\ ] ] for all @xmath163 . with the distribution of @xmath148 characterized , we can now describe the service time from source @xmath3 to destination @xmath6 , which we denote @xmath164 .
the number of slots needed for the successful reception of each coded packet will be geometrically distributed and in total @xmath148 coded packets must be received .
then @xmath164 can be modeled as the sum of @xmath148 independent geometrically distributed random variables . @xmath165 in the above expression , @xmath166 , @xmath167 , will be geometrically distributed with a parameter that depends on the reception probabilities and on the assumption of whether the other source is backlogged .
for instance , when source 2 is backlogged @xmath168 and when source 2 is empty , @xmath169 the total service time is given as @xmath170 as in the case of random access with retransmissions , we argue that the stable throughput region for random access with random linear coding will be outer bounded by the shannon capacity region . in the case
that source 2 is backlogged , the expected service time for source 1 is now bounded as @xmath171 = e[\max_m \widetilde{t}_1^{(m ) } ] & \stackrel{(a ) } \geq & \max_m e[\widetilde{t}_1^{(m ) } ] \\ & \stackrel{(b ) } = & \max_m \frac{e[n_{1}^{(m)}]}{p_1 ( 1-p_2 ) q_{1|1}^{(m ) } + p_1 p_2 q_{1|1,2}^{(m ) } } \\ & \stackrel{(c)}= & \frac{e[n_{1}^{(m)}]}{\min_m p_1 ( 1-p_2 ) q_{1|1}^{(m ) } + p_1 p_2 q_{1|1,2}^{(m)}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath78 again follows from jensen s inequality , @xmath132 holds since @xmath172 are independent , identically distributed , and @xmath173 holds since @xmath174 is identically distributed over @xmath6 , meaning that @xmath175=e[n_{1}^{(2)}]$ ] . the backlogged service rate @xmath176 is bounded as @xmath177 } & \leq & \frac{k}{e[n_{1}^{(m ) } ] } \min_m p_1 ( 1-p_2)q_{1|1}^{(m ) } + p_1p_2q_{1|1,2}^{(m ) } \\ & \leq & \min_m p_1 ( 1-p_2)q_{1|1}^{(m ) } + p_1p_2q_{1|1,2}^{(m)}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] then the shannon capacity region outer bounds the stable throughput region for random access with random linear coding .
unfortunately a difficulty arises in finding the service rates @xmath100 and @xmath101 in closed form from @xmath178 $ ] .
this difficulty arises for a number of reasons : @xmath179 and @xmath180 are not independent , and @xmath164 is distributed according to a composite distribution function , for which the pdf is not easily expressed in closed form .
in fact , even if these two difficulties were to be removed , @xmath181 $ ] can not be easily handled .
for instance , let us assume that @xmath179 and @xmath180 are independent and that @xmath182 are deterministic ( which means that the pdf is no longer composite ) . in that case , @xmath164 is the sum of @xmath183 iid geometric random variables , meaning that @xmath164 follows a negative binomial distribution .
let us further make the assumption that @xmath184 and @xmath185 , which means that @xmath164 are identically distributed over @xmath6 .
in this very simplified case , @xmath178 $ ] is the expected maximum of two iid negative binomial random variables .
the computation of this expected value is treated in @xcite , and the result involves a periodic function which is approximated by a fourier series .
thus , even in this very simplified case , we can at best approximate @xmath186 $ ] , and this approximation must be computed numerically . as an alternative to the analysis presented above , we now develop a markov chain model which allows us to find the queueing service rates . for a given source node ,
we set up a vector markov chain with state @xmath187 corresponding to the number of linearly independent coded packets that have been received from the source node . in this model
, @xmath188 represents the number of linearly independent coded packets that have been received at destination 1 , and @xmath150 represents the number of linearly independent packets that have been received at destination 2 .
since the coded packets are generated by the same source , some of the coded packets received at destination 1 may also have been received at destination 2 , and @xmath189 represents the number of such packets , where @xmath190 .
the variable @xmath189 allows us to track the correlation between @xmath191 and @xmath192 , which was a difficulty in our previous approach described above .
the markov chain evolves in discrete time over the time slots in our system model .
the state space of the markov chain is the three - dimensional discrete set of points @xmath193 ^ 3 $ ] .
there are @xmath194 absorbing states given by @xmath195 , @xmath196 , which represent the reception of @xmath137 linearly independent coded packets at both destinations , for which the service of @xmath137 packets at the source has been completed .
transitions in the markov chain can only occur `` upward '' , corresponding to the reception of a new linearly independent packet , and a transition results in an increase of the indices @xmath197 by at most 1 , meaning that at most 1 new linearly independent packet can be received in a slot .
we use the notation @xmath198 to denote the transition from state @xmath199 to state @xmath200 .
the markov chain is irreducible and aperiodic , and because it has a finite state space , a stationary distribution exists .
let @xmath201 denote the steady - state probability of @xmath187 .
the steady - state probabilities are found by solving the set of equations @xmath202 and @xmath203 the service rate @xmath204 is equal to @xmath137 times the probability of transitioning into an absorbing state @xmath195 , @xmath205 .
there are only a few ways to transition into an absorbing state ; let @xmath206 denote the set of states which have a one - step transition into the absorbing state @xmath195 .
for @xmath207 $ ] we have @xmath208 and for @xmath209 , @xmath210 note that we define @xmath211 in this way since the states @xmath212 and @xmath213 violate @xmath190 .
the service rate for source @xmath3 is given by @xmath214 the transition probabilities @xmath215 for source @xmath3 can be written assuming that the other source is either backlogged or empty , leading to the service rates @xmath216 and @xmath217 .
as an example , consider the transition @xmath218 in the markov chain for source 1 when source two is backlogged .
assume first that source two does not transmit , which happens with probability @xmath219 .
then there are two ways for the transition @xmath220 to occur .
first , destination 2 could receive no packet , which happens with probability @xmath221 , while destination 1 receives a coded packet which is neither an all - zero packet nor equal to any linear combination of the @xmath188 packets it has already received , which happens with probability @xmath222 .
alternatively , both destinations could receive a coded packet , but that packet is either the all zero packet or some linear combination of the packets that have been received by destination 2 and _ not _ by destination 1 .
this happens with probability @xmath223 .
the same two alternatives are possible in the case that source 2 does transmit , which happens with probability @xmath224 , except that the reception probabilities are now given by @xmath225
. then the transition @xmath218 for source 1 when source 2 is backlogged occurs with probability @xmath226.\end{gathered}\ ] ] the same transition probability can be used when source 2 is empty by setting @xmath227 .
similar arguments can be used to find all transition probabilities for our markov chain model ; we have stated those probabilities in appendix [ app : rlcmctransprob ] .
ultimately , we would like to find closed - form expressions for the service rates @xmath216 and @xmath217 , but due to the size of the state - space , this is a difficult task .
instead we have computed some numerical examples based on the markov chain model presented above , and those are presented next .
, @xmath228 , and @xmath229 . the stable throughput region for random linear coding
is abbreviated rlc.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] we have computed a number of numerical examples of the shannon capacity region and the stable throughput regions for retransmissions and random linear coding .
the results for random linear coding have been computed with the service rates given by equation ( [ eqn : murlcmc ] ) .
[ fig : resultsstrongmpr ] shows results for a `` good '' channel with relatively large reception probabilities while fig .
[ fig : resultsweakmpr ] shows results for a `` poor '' channel with smaller reception probabilities . in both figures ,
we have plotted the stable throughput for random linear coding ( abbreviated `` rlc '' ) with various values of @xmath137 .
the results show that the shannon capacity region is strictly larger than the stable throughput regions for both the retransmissions and random linear coding schemes .
additionally , the stable throughput region for random linear coding grows with @xmath137 and appears to approach the capacity as @xmath230 .
the random linear coding scheme does not necessarily outperform the retransmission scheme . for small values of @xmath137 ,
the coding scheme is inefficient in the sense that the ratio @xmath231 $ ] is small .
this inefficiency is largely due to the fact that an all - zero coded packet can be generated and transmitted ; this possibility is not precluded in ( [ eqn : rlccodedpacket ] ) and occurs more often for small values of @xmath137 .
the inefficiency of the coding scheme means that the retransmission of @xmath137 packets requires a service time that is less than @xmath232 $ ] for small values of @xmath137 .
this effect seems to become more pronounced as the channel improves , since for a `` good '' channel , packets are more often received correctly and do not need to be retransmitted . , @xmath228 , and @xmath233 .
the stable throughput region for random linear coding is abbreviated rlc.,scaledwidth=70.0% ]
one conclusion to draw from our work is that for sufficiently large blocklengths , given by @xmath137 in our model , coding over packets in a queue yields a higher stable multicast throughput than simply retransmitting lost packets . in light of the recent developments on network coding and fountain codes ,
this result is not surprising .
however , we have also shown that if the blocklength is too small and the code is not designed appropriately , then a retransmission scheme can provide a higher stable throughput than coding . furthermore , we have combined random access with random linear coding to yield an efficient multicast scheme that can operate in a completely distributed manner .
we have shown that the merging of random access with random linear coding results in good performance in the sense that the stable throughput approaches the shannon capacity . in the process , we have presented a model that represents random coding of packets in a queue .
another significant outcome of our work is that we have provided an example of a transmission policy for which the stable throughput region _ does not _ coincide with the shannon capacity region of a random access system .
this outcome contradicts a widely - held ( yet unproved ) belief that the stability and capacity regions coincide for random access .
this result sheds further light on the relation between the stable throughput and the shannon capacity as representations for the rate of reliable communication .
let @xmath234 denote the error probability for the @xmath22 message from the sources at receiver @xmath6 .
@xmath235 the following lemma provides a condition equivalent to @xmath49 and is used in the proof of theorem [ thrm : capreg ] . the average error @xmath236 if and only if @xmath237 .
[ lemma : errorcond ] the average error @xmath44 can be upper bounded by the union bound as follows : @xmath238 . a similar lower bound also holds , namely @xmath239 .
thus @xmath240 and the result follows .
achievability for our system is shown by first establishing achievability for the mac @xmath241 .
this is shown in @xcite and @xcite ; the approach presented in @xcite is summarized here .
each codeword symbol in the codebook for source @xmath3 is generated according to the distribution @xmath242 , independently over codeword symbols and independently over messages .
the following two properties are assumed . 1 .
the codewords @xmath243 and @xmath244 are reserved for use as preambles . a preamble is sent after every sequence of @xmath245 messages and @xmath243 and @xmath244 are used as preambles in an alternating fashion . in @xcite it is shown that by using the preamble , the receiver can synchronize on codeword boundaries with arbitrarily small probability of synchronization error .
2 . in a sequence of @xmath37 messages ( including a preamble ) ,
no messages are repeated . as a result ,
any two disjoint subsets of @xmath36 codeword symbols ( corresponding to @xmath37 messages ) are independent .
for @xmath246 the resulting loss in rate is negligible . by observing the channel outputs ,
the decoder @xmath247 can detect the preambles @xmath248 and @xmath249 to determine that the output symbols in between correspond to inputs @xmath250 .
let @xmath251 denote the sequence of @xmath36 symbols corresponding to @xmath250 augmented by portions of the preambles @xmath248 and @xmath252 .
at the channel output , @xmath251 will overlap with a sequence @xmath253 consisting of @xmath36 symbols input by source 2 , including @xmath16 preamble symbols .
let @xmath254 denote the output sequences corresponding to @xmath251 and @xmath253 at destination @xmath6 .
the decoder @xmath247 outputs the unique sequence of messages @xmath255 that lies in the set of typical @xmath256 sequences . with this approach
it is shown in @xcite that @xmath257 for all @xmath50 .
a similar technique can be used by decoder @xmath258 to show that @xmath259 . then by the union bound , @xmath260 for all @xmath50 . finally , if the rate pair @xmath52 lies in the intersection of the achievable rates for macs @xmath261 and @xmath262 , then @xmath263 and thus @xmath236 for all @xmath50 by lemma [ lemma : errorcond ] . the converse for the mac @xmath241
is shown in @xcite and @xcite by using fano s inequality , the data processing inequality , and the concavity of mutual information .
then @xmath264 implies that the rate pair @xmath52 must lie within the intersection of the capacity regions of @xmath261 and @xmath262 .
in the markov chain analysis of section [ subsection : rlcmarkovchain ] , the state @xmath187 represents @xmath188 linearly independent coded packets received at destination 1 , @xmath150 linearly independent coded packets received at destination 2 , and @xmath189 coded packets which have been received at both destinations , @xmath265 . when source 2 is backlogged , the non - zero transition probabilities for source 1 are given as follows for @xmath266 .
rl ( i , j , k ) ( i , j , k ) : & _ 1 + p_1 + ( i , j , k ) ( i+1,j , k ) : & p_1 + ( i , j , k ) ( i , j+1,k ) : & p_1 + ( i , j , k ) ( i+1,j+1,k+1 ) : & p_1 + rl ( i , k , k ) ( i , k , k ) : & _ 1 + p_1 + ( i , k , k ) ( i+1,k , k ) : & p_1 + ( i , k , k ) ( i+1,k , k+1 ) : & p_1 + rl ( k , j , k ) ( k , j , k ) : & _ 1 + p_1 + ( k , j , k ) ( k , j+1,k ) : & p_1 + ( k , j , k ) ( k , j+1,k+1 ) : & p_1 +
the authors wish to thank gerhard kramer for helpful comments which greatly improved the manuscript .
p. j. grabner and h. prodinger , `` maximum statistics of @xmath3 random variables distributed by the negative binomial distribution , '' _ combinatorics , probability and computing _ , vol .
179183 , 1997 . | we study and compare the shannon capacity region and the stable throughput region for a random access system in which source nodes multicast their messages to multiple destination nodes . under an erasure channel model which accounts for interference and
allows for multipacket reception , we first characterize the shannon capacity region .
we then consider a queueing - theoretic formulation and characterize the stable throughput region for two different transmission policies : a retransmission policy and random linear coding .
our results indicate that for large blocklengths , the random linear coding policy provides a higher stable throughput than the retransmission policy .
furthermore , our results provide an example of a transmission policy for which the shannon capacity region strictly outer bounds the stable throughput region , which contradicts an unproven conjecture that the shannon capacity and stable throughput coincide for random access systems .
wireless multicast , random access , aloha , queueing , stability , throughput , capacity , retransmissions , random linear coding |
gamma - ray burst ( grb ) explosions harbor both spherical supernova ( sn ) ejecta and highly collimated engine - driven jets @xcite .
this `` spherical+jet '' paradigm for the geometry of grbs implies that both explosion components must be studied independently .
early ( @xmath9 few days ) optical observations trace the synchrotron radiation produced from the engine - driven relativistic jets , while late - time ( @xmath10 days ) observations probe the optical emission from the non - relativistic spherical sn ejecta , powered by the decay of @xmath4ni .
such observations allow us to address the following fundamental questions regarding the grb / sn connection : what is the diversity among grb - associated sne , and how does the sample compare to local type ibc supernovae ( sne ibc ) ?
three of the best studied events , sne 1998bw , 2003dh 2003lw ( associated with grbs 980425 , 030329 and 031203 , respectively ) were strikingly similar , with brighter optical luminosities and faster photospheric velocities than local sne ibc @xcite .
these events suggested that the supernovae associated with grbs belong to a distinct sub - class of `` hyper - energetic '' supernovae .
however , there are also several counter - examples : under - luminous sne associated with grbs and x - ray flashes ( xrfs ; events very similar to grbs but differentiated by a soft prompt energy release peaking in the x - ray band ; @xcite ) with optical luminosities significantly fainter than sn1998bw . the most extreme examples are grb010921 ( @xcite ; but see @xcite ) and xrf040701 @xcite , for which the associated sne are at least @xmath11 and @xmath12 magnitudes fainter than sn1998bw , respectively .
motivated by our fundamental questions , we began a _ hubble space telescope _
( _ hst _ ) program to study the diversity in supernovae associated with grbs and xrfs ( go-10135 ; pi : kulkarni ) . in @xcite , we presented the results of our _ hst _ supernova search in xrfs 020903 , 040701 , 040812 and 040916 .
we showed that at least some xrfs are associated with sne , but that there may be a significant dispersion in their optical peak magnitudes . here
we present the results from our _ hst _ study of the supernovae associated with grbs 040924 ( @xmath0 ) and 041006 ( @xmath1 ) . in section
[ sec : targets ] we show that each is associated with a sn1998bw - like supernova dimmed by @xmath2 and @xmath3 magnitudes , respectively , making grb040924 the faintest grb - associated sn detected to date .
these two events suggest a notable dispersion of peak optical magnitudes for grb - associated sne .
finally , we compile optical peak magnitudes and @xmath4ni mass estimates for all grb / xrf - associated sne and local sne ibc to study the diversity among these two samples . in [ sec : summary ] we address the question of whether both samples are drawn from the same parent population of core - collapse supernovae .
in modeling the grb - associated sne , we adopted optical data for the local sne 1994i @xcite , 1998bw @xcite and 2002ap @xcite as templates .
these three sne were selected based on their well - sampled optical light - curves which represent an overall spread in the observed properties of type ibc supernovae . to produce synthesized light - curves for each of these template sne , we compiled optical @xmath13 observations from the literature and smoothed the extinction - corrected ( foreground plus host galaxy ) light - curves .
we then redshifted the light - curves by interpolating over the photometric spectrum and stretching the arrival time of the photons by a factor of @xmath14 .
the details of each template dataset are described in @xcite .
using the _ wide - field camera _ ( _ wfc _ ) of the _ advanced camera for surveys _
( _ acs _ ) on - board _ hst _ , we imaged the fields of grbs 040924 and 041006 . for each target
we undertook observations at several epochs , spanning @xmath15 and @xmath16 days , in order to search for optical emission associated with an underlying supernova .
each epoch consisted of 2 to 4 orbits during which we imaged the field in filters , f775w and/or f850lp , corresponding to sdss @xmath17- and @xmath18- bands , respectively .
the _ hst _ data were processed using the multidrizzle routine @xcite within the stsdas package of iraf .
images were drizzled using pixfrac=0.8 and pixscale=1.0 resulting in a final pixel scale of 0.05 arcsec / pixel .
drizzled images were then registered to the first epoch using the xregister package within iraf . to search for source variability and remove host galaxy contamination , we used the _ isis _ subtraction routine by @xcite which accounts for temporal variations in the stellar psf .
adopting the final epoch observations as template images , we produced residual images .
these residual images were examined for positive sources positionally coincident with the afterglow error circle . to test our efficiency at recovering faint transient sources , false stars with a range of magnitudes
were inserted into the first epoch images using _ iraf _ task mkobject .
the false stars were overlayed on top of the diffuse host galaxy emission at radial distances similar to that measured for the afterglow .
an examination of the false stellar residuals provided an estimate of the magnitude limit ( @xmath19 ) to which we could reliably recover faint transients .
photometry was performed on the residual sources within a 0.5 arcsec aperture .
we converted the photometric measurements to infinite aperture and calculated the corresponding ab magnitudes within the native _ hst _ filters using the aperture corrections and zero - points provided by @xcite .
for comparison with ground - based data , we also converted the photometric measurements to johnson @xmath20- and @xmath21-band ( vega ) magnitudes using the transformation coefficients derived by @xcite and adopting the source color given by the first epoch f775w and f850lp observations . in the following sections we summarize the afterglow properties for both targets and the photometry derived from our _ hst _ sn study .
a log of the _ hst _ observations for the grbs follows in table [ tab : hst ] .
grb040924 was detected by the wide - field x - ray monitor ( _ wxm _ ) on - board the high energy transient explorer ( _ hete-2 _ ) satellite on 2004 september 24.4951 ut .
preliminary analysis showed the peak of the spectral energy distribution was soft , @xmath22 kev , and the ratio of x - ray ( @xmath23 kev ) to @xmath24ray ( @xmath25 kev ) fluence , @xmath26 , classifying this event as an x - ray rich burst @xcite . using the roboticized palomar 60-inch telescope ( _ p60 _ ; cenko _ et al .
_ , in prep ) , we discovered the optical afterglow at position @xmath27 , @xmath28 ( j2000 ) with an uncertainty of 0.2 arcsec in each coordinate @xcite , well within the 6.4 arcsec ( radius ) localization region .
as shown by our extensive _ p60 _
monitoring , the afterglow was @xmath29 mag at @xmath30 minutes and subsequently decayed .
we continued to monitor the afterglow emission from @xmath31 to 1 day after the burst ( table [ tab : grb040924 ] ) , producing a well - sampled @xmath32-band light - curve .
as shown in figure [ fig : grb040924_sn_curve ] , these data show a shallow initial decay , followed by a steepening at @xmath33 days . in an effort to characterize the light - curve behavior , we fit a smoothed , broken power - law model ( e.g. @xcite ) of the form @xmath34^{-1/s}\ ] ] where @xmath35 is the break time in days , @xmath36 is the normalized flux density at @xmath37 , and @xmath38 and @xmath39 are the asymptotic indices at @xmath40 and @xmath41 , respectively . here
@xmath42 is used to parameterize the sharpness of the break . a best fit ( @xmath43 )
is found for the following parameters : @xmath44jy , @xmath45 , @xmath46 , @xmath47 days , and @xmath48 . to interpret this steepening as a jet break
@xcite would imply a electron spectral index , @xmath49 with @xmath50 .
this value is significantly lower than those typically observed ( @xmath51 ; @xcite ) and far below the range predicted by the standard blastwave model , @xmath52 $ ] @xcite .
we therefore ascribe this early afterglow phase ( and steepening ) to another process , perhaps similar to that observed for the initial slow decay of grb021004 @xcite , interpreted as interaction with a stellar wind medium @xcite .
@xcite report that the afterglow was @xmath53 mag at @xmath54 days .
comparison with the @xmath32-band afterglow model at the same epoch provides a spectral index , @xmath55 with @xmath56 , between the @xmath32- and @xmath57-bands . adopting this spectral index , we interpolate our @xmath32-band afterglow model to the @xmath20- and @xmath21-bands for comparison with our late - time _ hst
_ observations ( [ sec : hst_040924 ] ) .
optical spectroscopy later revealed that the burst was located at a redshift of @xmath58 , based on identification of several host galaxy emission lines @xcite .
_ hst / acs _ imaging was carried out on 2004 november 2.4 , 26.5 and 2005 february 19.0 ut ( @xmath59 , 63 and 147 days after the burst ) .
for the first and third epochs , we observed with both the f775w and f850lp filters , while the second epoch consisted of just f775w observations .
we astrometrically tied the _
hst _ and _ p60 _ images using four sources in common resulting in a final systematic uncertainty of 0.22 arcsec ( @xmath60 ) .
our _ hst _ observations reveal that the optical afterglow error circle coincides with a strongly variable source at @xmath61 , @xmath62 ( j2000 ) , lying @xmath63 arcsec nw of the host galaxy nucleus .
we interpret this source as a combination of afterglow plus supernova emission .
figure [ fig : grb040924_hst ] shows the first epoch , template image and first epoch residual for both the f775w and f850lp filter observations .
there is no evidence for a point source in our third epoch ( template ) images .
we therefore make the reasonable assumption that the transient source flux is negligible at that time .
the resulting _ hst _ photometry is listed in table [ tab : hst ] .
figure [ fig : grb040924_sn_curve ] shows the _ hst _ photometry along with our @xmath20- and @xmath21-band afterglow models ( see [ sec : ag_040924 ] ) and some early - time data compiled from the gcns @xcite , all corrected for galactic extinction . by comparing the afterglow models with the _ hst _ photometry , we find evidence for a @xmath64 magnitude rebrightening at @xmath65 days .
we note that the timescale of this rebrightening is roughly consistent with the peak time of sn1998bw at @xmath0 .
we interpret the observed late - time rebrightening as an associated supernova component .
comparison with our synthesized ( redshifted ) supernova light - curves reveals that an associated sn1998bw - like supernova would be @xmath66 magnitudes brighter than the _ hst _ observation at @xmath65 days , while sn1994i and sn2002ap - like light - curves are fainter by @xmath67 and @xmath66 magnitudes , respectively .
to fit the _ hst _ observations , we add the contribution from a template sn light - curve ( see [ sec : templates ] ) to the afterglow model .
we allow the brightness of the synthesized template to be scaled but do not allow for the light - curve to be stretched . moreover , we assume the grb and sn exploded at the same time . by fitting the _ hst _ @xmath20- and @xmath21-band data simultaneously , we find a best fit solution ( @xmath68 ) for a sn1998bw - like supernova dimmed by @xmath69 magnitudes ( figure [ fig : grb040924_sn_curve ] ) .
we note that on this timescale , the supernova emission clearly dominates that of the afterglow model . therefore , even if the afterglow underwent a late - time ( @xmath70 days ) jet break , our supernova fits would not be significantly affected .
host galaxy extinction could affect our sn light - curve fits since it implies the associated sn was more luminous than the observations suggest .
fortunately , we can constrain the host galaxy extinction using optical / ir afterglow observations , since extinction will produce an artificial steepening of the synchrotron spectrum . making the reasonable assumption that the synchrotron cooling frequency was above the optical / ir bands at early - time , we have @xmath71 and thus @xmath72 . for @xmath73
the standard blastwave model is violated , therefore implying the spectral index must be steeper than @xmath74 . adopting this limit for the intrinsic spectral index of the afterglow
implies a constraint on the host - galaxy extinction of @xmath75 mag .
this corresponds to limits on the observed extinction of @xmath76 mag , implying the associated sn was at least @xmath11 magnitudes fainter than sn1998bw .
we therefore conclude that the supernova associated with grb040924 was between 1.3 and 1.5 magnitudes fainter than sn1998bw at maximum light , making this event the faintest grb - associated sn ever detected .
grb041006 was discovered by the _
hete-2/wxm _ on 2004 october 6.513 ut . the ratio of @xmath77 kev and @xmath25 kev channel fluences showed the event was an x - ray rich burst .
the event was localized to a 5.0 arcmin ( radius ) localization region centered at @xmath78 , @xmath79 ( j2000 ; @xcite ) . using the siding springs observatory ( _ sso _ )
40-inch telescope , we discovered the optical afterglow at @xmath80 , @xmath81 ( j2000 ; @xcite ) , consistent with the _
hete-2 _ error circle .
as our early time ( @xmath82 to 0.122 days ; table [ tab : grb041006_sso ] ) _ sso _ 40-inch and 2.3 meter observations show , the afterglow was @xmath83 mag at @xmath84 minutes and subsequently faded in the @xmath85- , @xmath86- and @xmath87-bands .
@xcite have presented an extensive compilation of ( extinction - corrected ) @xmath32-band afterglow data from @xmath88 to 64 days , primarily from the multiple mirror telescope ( mmt ) and from the gcns ( see references therein ) .
they fit the evolution of the early light - curve ( up to @xmath89 days ) with the broken power - law model given in equation 1 , finding best fit parameters of @xmath90jy , @xmath91 , @xmath92 , @xmath93 days , and @xmath94 . as in the case of grb040924 ( [ sec : ag_040924 ] ) , this observed steepening is too shallow to be interpreted as a jet break under the standard blastwave model .
we instead interpret this early afterglow phase as due to another process , possibly the result of an off - axis viewing angle as proposed by @xcite .
combining our early - time _
sso _ data with those compiled by @xcite , we estimate the spectral index of the optical / ir afterglow to be @xmath95 by fitting a power - law to the @xmath85- , @xmath86- , @xmath32- and @xmath87-band data .
adopting this spectral index , we interpolate the @xmath32-band model to the @xmath20- and @xmath21-bands for comparison with our late - time _ hst _ observations ( [ sec : hst_041006 ] ) .
optical spectroscopy at @xmath96 days revealed that the burst was located at @xmath97 , based on tentative identification of several absorption lines in the low signal - to - noise spectrum @xcite . to confirm this redshift measurement , we acquired a spectrum of the optical afterglow with the gemini multi - object spectrograph ( gmos ) on gemini north ( gn-2004b - q-5 ; pi : price ) commencing at 2004 october 7.36 ut ( @xmath98 days ) . using the r400 grating and a 1 arcsec slit , we obtained four individual 1800 sec exposures .
data were reduced and extracted using the gemini.gmos package within iraf . we identify four absorption lines and one emission line ( table [ tab : grb041006_spec ] and figure [ fig : grb041006_z ] ) , which we interpret as arising from , and [ ] at a redshift of @xmath99 , in broad agreement with the earlier measurement by @xcite .
based on the high equivalent widths and the presence of [ ] , this is likely the redshift of the host galaxy , and not due to an intervening system along the line of sight .
using the @xmath32-band afterglow model and the photometrically derived spectral index , we flux calibrate the spectrum and obtain an approximate [ ] emission line flux of @xmath100 erg/@xmath101/s . adopting the conversion factor of @xcite , this line flux corresponds to a star formation rate of 0.5 m@xmath102/yr at the redshift of the host galaxy .
km / s / mpc and @xmath103 . ]
_ hst / acs _ imaging was carried out on 2004 november 2.3 , 27.4 , december 23.4 and 2005 february 10.5 ut ( @xmath104 , 52 , 78 and 127 days after the burst ) .
for the first and fourth epochs , we observed with both the f775w and f850lp filters , while the second and third epochs consisted of just f775w observations .
we astrometrically tied the _
hst _ and _ sso _ images using five sources in common resulting in a final systematic uncertainty of 0.53 arcsec ( @xmath60 ) .
our _ hst _ observations reveal that the optical afterglow error circle coincides with a strongly variable source at @xmath105 , @xmath106 ( j2000 ) .
the source is situated directly on top of a faint host galaxy which is at the detection limit of our _ hst _ images .
we note the presence of a brighter galaxy @xmath107 arcsec from the afterglow position which was misidentified as the host galaxy by @xcite based on ground - based images .
figure [ fig : grb041006_hst ] shows the first epoch , template image and first epoch residual for both the f775w and f850lp filter observations . from the figure , it is clear that the source is still faintly detected in our final epoch ( template ) observations . to assume negligible source flux in the template images is therefore not valid .
we estimate the flux of the source in our template images by performing psf photometry on the object . in calculating the magnitude of the source in the first , second and third epochs
, we add the template epoch flux to the residual image photometry .
the resulting _ hst _ photometry is given in table [ tab : hst ] .
figure [ fig : grb041006_sn_curve ] shows the _ hst _ photometry along with our @xmath20- and @xmath21-band afterglow model ( see [ sec : ag_041006 ] ) and some early - time data compiled from the gcns @xcite , all corrected for galactic extinction . by comparing the afterglow model with the _ hst _ data , we find evidence for a @xmath108 magnitude rebrightening at @xmath109 days , roughly consistent with the peak time of a sn1998bw - like supernova at @xmath1 .
we note that this rebrightening was discovered earlier ( @xmath110 days ) using ground - based facilities and interpreted as the emerging flux from an associated supernova @xcite . as discussed in
[ sec : ag_041006 ] , @xcite presented an extensive compilation of @xmath32-band observations which span the epoch of rebrightening . by removing the contribution from the afterglow
, they find evidence for an associated sn with a peak magnitude @xmath111 mag brighter than sn1998bw and with a light - curve stretched by a factor of 1.35 in time . to confirm this result , we compared our redshifted template sn light - curves with our late - time _ hst _ observations and found that an associated sn1998bw - like supernova would be @xmath112 mag brighter than the _ hst _ observation at @xmath109 days , while sn1994i- and sn2002ap - like supernova light - curves are fainter by @xmath113 and @xmath114 magnitudes , respectively . in an effort to characterize the light - curve of the associated sn , we fit the _ hst _ observations in a manner similar to that done for grb040924 ( [ sec : sn_040924 ] ) . by fitting the _ hst _ @xmath20- and @xmath21-band data simultaneously
, we find a best fit solution ( @xmath115 ) for a sn1998bw - like supernova dimmed by @xmath63 magnitudes .
we emphasize that this fit does not include any stretching of the light - curve .
moreover , we find no improvement in the quality of the fit when template stretching is included .
this result is inconsistent with the findings of @xcite .
we attribute this discrepancy to contamination from the host and nearby galaxy ( see figure [ fig : grb041006_hst ] ) which plagues the @xcite late - time photometry .
we note that the presence of host galaxy extinction would imply that the associated sn was brighter than our estimates .
we use the optical / ir afterglow observations to constrain the host galaxy extinction in a manner similar to that performed for grb040924 ( [ sec : sn_040924 ] ) .
however , in this case , the observed spectral index ( @xmath95 ) is comparable to the theoretical limit and is therefore consistent with negligible host galaxy extinction .
we conclude that the supernova associated with grb041006 was @xmath63 magnitudes fainter than sn1998bw at maximum light and decayed at a comparable rate .
in the sections above , we showed that grbs 040924 and 041006 were each associated with a supernova similar to sn1998bw but dimmed by @xmath2 and @xmath3 magnitudes , respectively .
these two events clearly show that there is a significant spread in the luminosity of grb - associated sne , suggesting a dispersion in the production of @xmath4ni .
such a dispersion has already been observed for local sne ibc @xcite . to better study this dispersion ,
we compile optical peak magnitudes ( rest - frame ) and @xmath4ni mass estimates for grb / xrf - associated sne and local sne ibc from the literature ( tables [ tab : grb_mv_ni ] and [ tab : sn_mv_ni ] ) . in this compilation
we consider all the grb / xrf - associated sne with spectroscopic redshifts of @xmath116 ; sn searches at higher redshifts are plagued by uv ( rest - frame ) line - blanketing .
since spectroscopic confirmation of the sn component is only available for the four nearest events in this sample ( grbs 980425 , 020903 , 031203 and 030329 ; see table [ tab : grb_mv_ni ] ) , photometric data is used to constrain the brightness of an associated sn .
we note , however , that uncertainty associated with host galaxy extinction and decomposition of the afterglow emission from the sn can impose a non - negligible uncertainty in the estimated sn peak magnitude .
for the local sample , we include only the events with published photometry .
the latter may impose a slight bias in favor of brighter and peculiar sne . ] . in figure
[ fig : mv_ni_hist ] ( top panel ) , we show @xmath4ni mass estimates and peak optical magnitudes for grb / xrf - associated sne and local sne ibc . from the figure ,
it is clear that ( 1 ) peak magnitude scales roughly with @xmath4ni mass , and ( 2 ) grb - associated sne do not necessarily synthesize more @xmath4ni than ordinary sne ibc .
we next compare their peak optical magnitudes , since the correlation between @xmath4ni mass and peak optical magnitudes should manifest itself as a similar dispersion . in figure
[ fig : mv_ni_hist ] ( bottom panel ) we show a histogram of peak optical magnitudes for all grb / xrf - associated sne and local sne ibc .
examination of the two samples reveals noticeable overlap ; while grb / xrf - associated sne tend to cluster toward the brighter end of the distribution , some of the faintest sne ibc observed are in fact associated with grbs and xrfs ( e.g. grbs 010921 , 040924 , xrf040701 ) and the most luminous events are actually drawn from the local sample .
apparently , grb / xrf - associated sne are not necessarily over - luminous in comparison with local sne ibc . moreover , by assuming a rough scaling of @xmath4ni production with peak optical magnitude , this implies a notable overlap between the two samples with respect to their dispersion in synthesized material , consistent with the data shown in the upper panel .
the following question naturally arises : are both grb / xrf - associated sne and local sne ibc drawn from the same population of events ? to address this issue , we performed a kolmogorov - smirnov ( k - s ) test on the two sets of sn peak magnitudes .
our k - s test reveals that the probability the two samples have been drawn from the same parent population is @xmath117 .
it is therefore conceivable that both sne ibc and grb / xrf - associated sne belong to the same sn population , and thus share a common @xmath4ni production mechanism .
this result may imply that grb / xrf - associated sne and local sne ibc share a common progenitor system and/or explosion mechanism .
yet we know from radio observations of local sne that most type ibc s lack the engine - driven relativistic ejecta observed in grbs @xcite . this may be accounted for in the spherical+jet paradigm where the production of @xmath4ni and relativistic ejecta are independent parameters of the explosion , each of which can be individually tuned
. additional studies of both grb / xrf - associated sne and local sne ibc will enable us to better map out this two - dimensional parameter space and address in detail the nature of the progenitors and explosion mechanisms .
the authors are grateful for support under the space telescope science institute grant hst - go-10135 .
a.m.s . acknowledges support by the nasa graduate student researchers program .
e.b . is supported by nasa through hubble fellowship grant hst - hf-01171.01 awarded by the stsci , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc .
, for nasa , under contract nas 5 - 26555 . a.g .
acknowledges support by nasa through hubble fellowship grant # hst - hf-01158.01-a awarded by stsci .
kr is supported by the gemini observatory , which provided observations presented in this paper , and which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc .
, under a cooperative agreement with the nsf on behalf of the gemini partnership : the national science foundation ( united states ) , the particle physics and astronomy research council ( united kingdom ) , the national research council ( canada ) , conicyt ( chile ) , the australian research council ( australia ) , cnpq ( brazil ) and conicet ( argentina ) .
grb040924 & 2004 november 2.4 & 38.9 & 3064 & f775w & @xmath118 & @xmath119 & @xmath120 + & 2004 november 2.5 & 39.0 & 3211 & f850lp & @xmath121 & @xmath122 & @xmath123 + & 2004
november 26.5 & 63.0 & 3932 & f775w & @xmath124 & @xmath119 & @xmath125 + & 2005 february 18.5 & 147.0 & 3932 & f775w & & & + & 2005 february 19.5 & 148.0 & 3932 & f850lp & & & + grb041006 & 2004
november 2.3 & 26.7 & 3832 & f775w & @xmath126 & @xmath127 & @xmath128 + & 2004
november 2.3 & 26.7 & 3430 & f850lp & @xmath129 & @xmath130 & @xmath131 + & 2004
november 27.4 & 51.9 & 4224 & f775w & @xmath132 & @xmath127 & @xmath133 + & 2004 december 23.4 & 77.8 & 4224 & f775w & @xmath134 & @xmath127 & @xmath135 + & 2005 february 10.3 & 126.8 & 4224 & f775w & @xmath136 & @xmath127 & @xmath137 + & 2005 february 11.2 & 127.7 & 4224 & f850lp & @xmath138 & @xmath130 & @xmath139 + [ tab : hst ] 2004
september 24.506 & 0.011 & @xmath140 + 2004
september 24.509 & 0.014 & @xmath141 + 2004
september 24.512 & 0.017 & @xmath142 + 2004
september 24.513 & 0.018 & @xmath143 + 2004
september 24.514 & 0.019 & @xmath142 + 2004 september 24.517 & 0.022 & @xmath143 + 2004
september 24.519 & 0.024 & @xmath144 + 2004
september 24.526 & 0.030 & @xmath145 + 2004
september 24.527 & 0.032 & @xmath145 + 2004
september 24.530 & 0.035 & @xmath146 + 2004
september 24.539 & 0.044 & @xmath147 + 2004 september 24.875 & 0.380 & @xmath148 + 2004
september 24.894 & 0.399 & @xmath149 + 2004
september 24.909 & 0.414 & @xmath150 + 2004
september 24.926 & 0.430 & @xmath149 + 2004
september 24.942 & 0.447 & @xmath150 + 2004
september 24.957 & 0.462 & @xmath151 + 2004
september 24.972 & 0.477 & @xmath151 + 2004
september 24.988 & 0.493 & @xmath150 + 2004
september 25.003 & 0.508 & @xmath152 + 2004
september 25.018 & 0.523 & @xmath153 + 2004
september 25.036 & 0.540 & @xmath153 + 2004
september 25.050 & 0.555 & @xmath154 + 2004
september 25.066 & 0.571 & @xmath155 + 2004
september 25.081 & 0.586 & @xmath152 + 2004
september 25.097 & 0.602 & @xmath152 + 2004
september 25.224 & 0.729 & @xmath155 + [ tab : grb040924 ] 2004 october 6.537 & 0.024 & @xmath86 & 40-inch & @xmath156 + 2004
october 6.541 & 0.028 & @xmath86 & 40-inch & @xmath157 + 2004 october 6.546 & 0.033 & @xmath86 & 40-inch & @xmath158 + 2004 october 6.550 & 0.037 & @xmath86 & 40-inch & @xmath159 + 2004 october 6.555 & 0.042 & @xmath86 & 40-inch & @xmath160 + 2004 october 6.582 & 0.069 & @xmath85 & 40-inch & @xmath161 + 2004 october 6.586 & 0.073 & @xmath85 & 40-inch & @xmath162 + 2004 october 6.590 & 0.077 & @xmath85 & 40-inch & @xmath163 + 2004 october 6.595 & 0.082 & @xmath86 & 40-inch & @xmath164 + 2004 october 6.605 & 0.092 & @xmath87 & 2.3-meter & @xmath165 + 2004 october 6.612 & 0.099 & @xmath87 & 2.3-meter & @xmath166 + 2004 october 6.620 & 0.107 & @xmath87 & 2.3-meter & @xmath167 + 2004 october 6.627 & 0.114 & @xmath87 & 2.3-meter & @xmath168 + 2004 october 6.635 & 0.122 & @xmath87 & 2.3-meter & @xmath169 + [ tab : grb041006_sso ] grb970228 & 0.695 & @xmath175 & @xcite & & + grb980425 & 0.0085 & @xmath176 & @xcite & @xmath177 & @xcite , + & & & & & woosley _ et al . _
( 1999 ) + grb980703 & 0.966 & @xmath178 & @xcite & & + grb990712 & 0.434 & @xmath179 & @xcite & & + grb991208 & 0.706 & @xmath180 & @xcite & & + grb000911 & 1.058 & @xmath181 & @xcite & & + grb010921 & 0.45 & @xmath182 & @xcite & & + grb011121 & 0.36 & @xmath183 & @xcite & & + grb020405 & 0.698 & @xmath184 & @xcite & & + xrf020903 & 0.251 & @xmath185 & @xcite & & + grb021211 & 1.006 & @xmath186 & @xcite & & + grb030329 & 0.169 & @xmath187 & @xcite & @xmath188 & @xcite + grb031203 & 0.1055 & @xmath189 & @xcite & & + xrf040701 & 0.2146 & @xmath190 & @xcite & & + grb040924 & 0.859 & @xmath191 & this paper & & + grb041006 & 0.716 & @xmath192 & this paper & & + [ tab : grb_mv_ni ] sn1983n & @xmath193 & @xcite & 0.25 & @xcite + sn1983v & @xmath194 & @xcite & & + sn1984l & @xmath195 & @xcite & @xmath196 & @xcite + sn1987 m & @xmath197 & @xcite & @xmath198 & @xcite + sn1990b & @xmath199 & @xcite & & + sn1991d & @xmath200 & @xcite & 0.7 & @xcite + sn1992ar & @xmath201 & @xcite & @xmath202 & @xcite + sn1994i & @xmath203 & @xcite & @xmath204 & @xcite + sn1997ef & @xmath205 & @xcite & @xmath206 & @xcite + sn1999as & @xmath207 & @xcite & @xmath208 & @xcite + sn1999ex & @xmath209 & @xcite & 0.16 & @xcite + sn2002ap & @xmath210 & @xcite & @xmath211 & @xcite + sn2003l & @xmath212 & soderberg _ et al .
_ , ( in prep ) & & + [ tab : sn_mv_ni ] | we present the results from a _ hubble space telescope / acs _ study of the supernovae associated with gamma - ray bursts 040924 ( @xmath0 ) and 041006 ( @xmath1 ) .
we find evidence that both grbs were associated with a sn1998bw - like supernova dimmed by @xmath2 and @xmath3 magnitudes , respectively , making grb040924 the faintest grb - associated sn ever detected .
we study the luminosity dispersion in grb / xrf - associated sne and compare to local type ibc supernovae from the literature .
we find significant overlap between the two samples , suggesting that grb / xrf - associated sne are not necessarily more luminous nor produce more @xmath4ni than local sne .
based on the current ( limited ) datasets , we find that the two samples may share a similar @xmath4ni production mechanism .
# 1#2#3#1@xmath5#2@xmath6#3@xmath7 # 1#2#3@xmath8 |
motivated by their potential applications in spintronics and quantum computing @xcite , the search for three - dimensional topological insulators ( 3dti ) has attracted considerable theoretical and experimental interest @xcite .
these materials are called `` topological '' because they are distinguished from ordinary insulators by the so - called @xmath0 topological invariants associated with the bulk band structure @xcite . on the theory side , the state - of - the - art first - principles calculations guided by topological band theory @xcite has provided a powerful tool for uncovering new families of 3dti . based on this approach , it has been recently predicted that ternary half - heusler compounds can realize the topological insulating phase with proper strain engineering @xcite .
there are several ways to determine the band topology of an insulator .
intuitively , one can count the number of band inversions within the entire brillouin zone an _ odd _ number indicates that the material may be a 3dti @xcite .
this method depends on an accurate interpretation of the atomic origin of the bands and is better suited for crystals with a high - symmetry lattice . a more rigorous method is to directly evaluate the @xmath0 topological invariants . for materials with inversion symmetry
, the parity criteria developed by fu and kane @xcite can be readily applied . on the other hand , if the inversion symmetry is absent , one must resort to the more elaborated lattice computation of the @xmath0 invariants @xcite .
we have recently applied this method to study the distorted half - heuslers @xcite and the noncentrosymmetric chalcopyrite compounds @xcite . in practical calculations ,
both methods require an accurate knowledge of the bulk band structures .
so far , previous works on 3dti have employed either the local density approximation ( lda ) @xcite or generalized gradient approximation ( gga ) @xcite for the exchange - correlation potential .
however , it is well known that these approximations have the tendency to underestimate the bandgap . in particular ,
if the material has a small positive bandgap , this underestimation may yield a negative value .
therefore , these approximations may falsely predict an inverted band structure when the band order is actually normal . recently , a new semilocal potential that combines the modified becke - johnson ( mbj ) exchange potential and the lda correlation potential , called mbjlda @xcite , was proposed to obtain accurate bandgaps and band order .
the mbjlda potential are computationally as cheap as lda or gga , but it has similar precision compared with the more expensive hybrid functionals and gw method .
it has been demonstrated @xcite that the mbjlda potential can be used to describe many types of solids , including wide bandgap insulators , small bandgap @xmath1 semiconductors , and strongly correlated @xmath2 transition - metal oxides .
more importantly , the mbjlda potential can effectively mimic the behavior of orbital - dependent potential around the bandgap , so it is expected to obtain accurate positions of states near the band - edge , which are the keys to determine the band inversion and the band topology . in this work
we perform a systematic investigation of the band topology of the half - heusler family using the mbjlda potential , and compare it with the lda result .
the improved accuracy of the mbjlda potential over lda is tested in the ordinary insulator cdte and the topologically nontrivial 3d - hgte , whose band structures are known experimentally and can be used as a benchmark .
we then focus on the ternary half - heusler compounds . by calculating the band inversion strength ,
we confirm our previous prediction that a large number of half - heuslers are possible candidates for 3dti or 3d topological metal @xcite .
the difference between lda and the mbjlda potential is also discussed and a clear discrepancy is found between these two methods . the sensitivity of the calculated band structure due to the type of exchange - correlation potential calls for more detailed experimental works . , @xmath3 , and @xmath4 state
are denoted by red , black , and blue color , respectively .
the size of dots is proportional to the probability of s - orbit projection .
( b ) and ( e ) is schematically experimental band structure of cdte and hgte , the red solid dots denote the s - orbit originated @xmath5 state . the band inversion strength is defined as @xmath6 .
the calculated and experimental energy of @xmath5 , @xmath3 , and @xmath4 state are listed in table [ tab : energy].,width=336 ]
the band structure calculations in this work were performed using full - potential linearized augmented plane - wave ( fp - lapw ) method @xcite , implemented in the package wien2k @xcite .
a converged ground state was obtained using 10,000 k points in the first brillouin zone with @xmath7 , where @xmath8 represents the muffin - tin radius and @xmath9 is the maximum size of reciprocal - lattice vectors .
wave functions and potentials inside the atomic sphere are expanded in spherical harmonics up to @xmath10 and @xmath11 , respectively .
spin - orbit coupling is included by a second - variational procedure @xcite , where states up to 9 ry above fermi level are included in the basis expansion , and the relativistic @xmath12 corrections were also considered for @xmath13 and @xmath14 orbit in order to improve the accuracy @xcite .
we first test the mbjlda potential for the binary compounds cdte and hgte .
the energy bands of both compounds at the @xmath15 point near the fermi level split into @xmath5 ( 2-fold degenerate ) , @xmath3 ( 2-fold degenerate ) , and @xmath4 ( 4-fold degenerate ) states due to the zinc - blende crystal symmetry and strong spin - orbit interaction .
the experimental band order of cdte and hgte are ( from high to low energy ) @xmath5 , @xmath4 , @xmath3 ( ref . ) and @xmath4 , @xmath5 , @xmath3 ( ref . ) , respectively .
they are schematically shown in fig .
[ fig : order](b ) and [ fig : order](e ) . from the viewpoint of band topology
, the main difference between these two compounds is that cdte possesses a normal band order , i.e. , the @xmath16-like @xmath5 state sits above the @xmath17-like @xmath4 state , while hgte possesses an inverted band order in which the @xmath5 state is occupied and sits below the @xmath4 state .
we then define the band inversion strength @xmath18 as the energy differences between these two states , i.e. @xmath19 a negative @xmath18 typically indicates that the materials are in a topologically nontrival phase , while those with a positive @xmath18 are in a topologically trivial phase .
figure [ fig : order ] shows the lda and mbjlda band structures of cdte and hgte at their experimental lattice constants 6.48and 6.46 , respectively @xcite .
the calculated energy of the @xmath5 , @xmath3 , and @xmath4 states together with their experimental values are listed in table [ tab : energy ] .
for cdte , the lda potential yields a serious underestimation of @xmath18 . for hgte , it obtains the wrong band order of the @xmath5 and @xmath3 states ( but it does predict an inverted band order ) . on the other hand , the mbjlda result shows an excellent agreement with experiments for both compounds .
we therefore conclude that the mbdlda potential is better suited to calculate the topological band structure .
ccddd & & & & + & @xmath20 & 0.221 & 1.549 & 1.475 + cdte & @xmath21 & 0.0 & 0.0 & 0.0 + & @xmath22 & -0.897 & -0.795 & -0.95 + & @xmath21 & 0.0 & 0.0 & 0.0 + hgte & @xmath20 & -1.191 & -0.234 & -0.29 + & @xmath22 & -0.822 & -0.721 & -0.91 + ( color online ) crystal structure of half - heusler compound xyz in the @xmath23 space group .
green spheres at ( 0.5,0.5,0.5 ) are atom x , dark blue spheres at ( 0.25,0.25,0.25 ) are atom y , and pink spheres at ( 0,0,0 ) are atom z.,width=226 ] having established the improved accuracy of the mbjlda potential over lda , we now turn to the ternary half - heusler compounds described by space group @xmath23 .
the chemical formula of these materials is @xmath24 , where @xmath25 and @xmath26 are transition or rare earth metals and @xmath27 a heavy element .
it can be regarded as a hybrid compound of @xmath28 with rock - salt structure , and @xmath29 and @xmath30 with the zinc - blende structure ( see fig .
[ fig : struct ] ) . in our band structure calculations ,
the lattice constants are taken from experimental data library @xcite .
for compounds without experimental lattice constant , we use the value obtained by total energy minimization in first - principles calculations .
the band structures of half - heuslers are very similar to cdte / hgte .
in particular , the low - energy electron dynamics is dominated by energy bands at the @xmath15 point .
therefore , the band topology of half - heuslers can be characterized by the band inversion strength @xmath18 defined in eq . .
in order to systemically explore their topological phase , we have calculated @xmath18 by both lda and mbjlda for 24 half - heusler compounds , as shown in fig .
[ fig : map](a ) and ( b ) , respectively .
following our previous work ( ref . ) , we have also calculated the @xmath0 invariant for all half - heusler compounds investigated here .
the calculated @xmath0 invariant agrees with the intuitive band inversion picture , that is , materials with negative @xmath18 are in topologically nontrivial phase . as shown in fig .
[ fig : map](b ) , we have identified 9 half - heusler compounds , luptsb , laptbi , yptbi , scptbi , thptpb , laaupb , yaupb , lupdbi , luptbi as possible candidates for topological insulators or topological metal .
( note that scptbi , thptpb , laaupb here are virtual compounds . ) here , the band structures of the first 6 compounds are with zero band - gap similar to that of hgte , and the last 3 compounds possess the nontrivial metallic band structures similar to fig .
[ fig : bands](e ) or the conduction bands droping below the fermi level near the x point .
as shown in section iii.a , the lda result generally yields a smaller value of the band inversion strength @xmath18 when compared with the mbjlda result , which agrees much better with the experimental data .
we emphasize that , unlike the usual energy gaps , here @xmath18 can take on both positive and negative values , hence a positive @xmath18 is always larger than a negative one .
this trend is also confirmed for half - heuslers . as shown in fig .
[ fig : map ] , @xmath18 by mbjlda is always larger than that by lda . in particular , if lda calculation predicts a small negative @xmath18 , it may become positive when using mbjlda potential , such as scaupb , and ypdbi .
this suggests that when predicting topological phases , one must be careful with the types of exchange - correlation potentials . to illustrate the general difference between the lda and mbjlda results , we present four scenarios shown in fig .
[ fig : bands ] using some typical examples .
both lda and mbjlda calculations predict that laptbi [ fig .
[ fig : bands](a ) and [ fig : bands](b ) ] has an inverted band structure , which is very similar to hgte .
the main difference is the band order exchange between @xmath5 and @xmath3 state .
although the band topology will not change , the lda result clearly underestimates the @xmath18 due to the downward movement of @xmath5 state . for ypdbi ,
the problem is much more severe as the two potentials give different band topology . as shown in fig .
[ fig : bands](c ) and [ fig : bands](d ) , the lda result shows an inverted band order but the mbjlda result shows a normal band order .
the two types of exchange - correlation potentials also affects the electronic behavior around the fermi level as shown for yptbi in fig .
[ fig : bands](e ) and [ fig : bands](f ) .
the metallic phase predicted by lda calculation becomes a zero - bandgap semiconductor in mbjlda calculation .
the band order of @xmath5 and @xmath3 is also exchanged , just like laptbi .
bands ( marked by red dots ) to jump below the valence band top , providing the necessary band inversion that leads to a nontrivial topological order .
the other labels are the same as fig .
[ fig : order].,width=302 ] as mentioned in our previous work @xcite , for half - heusler compounds with small band gaps , the nontrivial topologically phase can be generally realized by applying hydrostatic strain to change the band order .
for example , lapdbi has normal band order in its native state , a @xmath31 change in the lattice constant converts the trivial topological phase into a nontrivial topological phase ( fig .
[ fig : lapdbi ] ) .
again , there are different effects on the band order under the same hydrostatic strain when using different exchange - correlation potentials . for example , when one stretches lattice constant to @xmath32 , lda calculation will yield an inverted band structure [ fig .
[ fig : bands](g ) ] , while it still has a normal band order by mbjlda calculation[fig .
[ fig : bands](h ) ] .
in summary , we have systematically investigated the topological band structure of the half - heusler family using both lda and mbjlda exchange - correlations potential .
our result shows that a large number of half - heusler compounds are candidates for three - dimensional topological insulators .
we also discussed the main differences between the lda and mbjlda potentials this work was supported by nsf of china ( 10674163 , 10974231 ) and the most project of china ( 2007cb925000 ) , welch foundation ( f-1255 ) and doe ( de - fg02 - 02er45958 , division of materials science and engineering ) , and by supercomputing center of chinese academy of sciences(sccas ) and texas advanced computing center(tacc ) .
100 j. e. moore , nature * 464 * , 194 ( 2010 ) .
l. fu and c. l. kane , phys .
b * 76 * , 045302 ( 2007 ) .
d. hsieh , d. qian , l. wray , y. xia , y. s. hor , r. j. cava , and m. z. hasan , nature * 452 * , 970 ( 2008 ) .
h. zhang , c .- x .
qi , x. dai , z. fang , and s .- c .
zhang , nature physics * 5 * , 438 ( 2009 ) .
y. xia , d. qian , d. hsieh , l. wray , a. pal , h. lin , a. bansil , d. grauer , y. s. hor , r. j. cava , and m. z. hasan , nature physics * 5 * , 398 ( 2009 ) . y. l. chen , j. g. analytis , j .- h .
chu , z. k. liu , s .- k .
mo , x. l. qi , h. j. zhang , d. h. lu , x. dai , z. fang , s. c. zhang , i. r. fisher , z. hussain , and z .- x .
shen , science * 325 * , 178 ( 2009 ) .
b. yan , c .- x .
liu , h .- j .
zhang , c .- y .
qi , t. frauenheim , and s .- c .
zhang , europhysics letters * 90 * , 37002 ( 2010 ) .
h. lin , r. s. markiewicz , l. a. wray , l. fu , m. z. hasan , and a. bansil , phys .
lett . * 105 * , 036404 ( 2010 ) .
t. sato , k. segawa , h. guo , k. sugawara , s. souma , t. takahashi , and y. ando , phys .
. lett . * 105 * , 136802 ( 2010 ) .
y. chen , z. liu , j. g. analytis , j .- h .
chu , h. zhang , s .- k .
mo , r. g. moore , d. lu , i. fisher , s. zhang , z. hussain , and z .- x .
shen , arxiv:1006.3843v1 ( 2010 ) .
d. xiao , y.g .
yao , w. feng , j. wen , w. zhu , x .- q .
chen , g. m. stocks , and z. zhang , phys .
lett . * 105 * , 096404 ( 2010 ) .
h. lin , l. a. wray , y. xia , s. xu , s. jia , r. j. cava , a. bansil , and m. z. hasan , nature materials * 9 * , 546 ( 2010 ) . s. chadov , x. qi , j. kbler , g. h. fecher , c. felser , and s. c. zhang , nature materials * 9 * , 541 ( 2010 ) . c. l. kane and e. j. mele , phys .
. lett . * 95 * , 146802 ( 2005 ) .
l. fu and c. l. kane , phys .
b * 74 * , 195312 ( 2006 ) . l. fu , c. l. kane , and e. j. mele , phys . rev
. lett . * 98 * , 106803 ( 2007 ) . j. e. moore and l. balents , phys .
b * 75 * , 121306 ( 2007 ) .
r. roy , phys .
b * 79 * , 195322 ( 2009 ) .
t. fukui and y. hatsugai , j. phys .
76 , 053702 ( 2007 ) .
w. feng , j. ding , d. xiao , and y. yao , arxiv:1008.0056 ( 2010 ) .
w. kohn and l. j. sham , phys .
rev . * 140 * , a1133 ( 1965 ) .
j. p. perdew and y. wang , phys .
b * 45 * , 13244 ( 1992 ) .
j. p. perdew , k. burke , and m. ernzerhof , phys .
lett . * 77 * , 3865 ( 1996 ) .
f. tran , and p. blaha , phys .
lett . * 102 * , 226401 ( 2009 ) .
d. j. singh , _
planewaves , pseudopotentials and the lapw method _
( kluwer academic , boston , 1994 ) .
p. blaha , k. schwarz , g. madsen , d. kvaniscka , and j. luitz , _
wien2k , an augmented plane wave plus local orbitals program for calculating crystal properties _
( vienna university of technology , vienna , austria , 2001 ) .
p. larson , phys .
b * 68 * , 155121 ( 2003 ) .
p. lemasson , solid state commun . * 43 * , 627 ( 1982 ) .
d. w. niles , and h. hchst , phys .
b * 43 * , 1492 ( 1991 ) .
n. orlowski , j. augustin , z. golacki , c. janowitz , and r. manzke , phys .
b * 61 * , r5058 ( 2000 ) . j. c. woolley , and b. ray , j. phys
solids * 15 * , 27 ( 1960 ) .
p. villars , and l. d. calvert , _ pearson s handbook of crystallographic data for intermetallic phases _ ( amer soc metals , 1991 ) .
springermaterials - the landolt - bnstein database , http://www.springermaterials.com / navigation/. s. h. vosko , l. wilk , and m. nusair , can
. j. phys . *
58 * , 1200 ( 1980 ) . | we systematically investigate the topological band structures of half - heusler compounds using first - principles calculations .
the modified becke - johnson exchange potential together with local density approximation for the correlation potential ( mbjlda ) has been used here to obtain accurate band inversion strength and band order .
our results show that a large number of half - heusler compounds are candidates for three - dimensional topological insulators .
the difference between band structures obtained using the local density approximation ( lda ) and mbjlda potential is also discussed . |
the x - ray populations of external galaxies have been well studied for the last @xmath020 years .
historically , studies of the individual sources have been severely limited by low count rates and signal to noise , and several methods have been used to derive the x - ray luminosity of a source from its intensity .
grimm et al . ( 2003 , hereafter known as g03 ) used chandra and asca surveys of nearby starburst galaxies , along with asca , mir - kvant / ttm and rxte / asm observations of hmxbs in our galaxy and the magellanic clouds to obtain a correlation between the x - ray properties of hmxbs and the star formation rate ( sfr ) of their host galaxies .
they chose their sample of galaxies to have sufficiently high sfr to total mass ratios so that their x - ray populations would be dominated by hmxbs , with negligible lmxb contributions .
g03 used published chandra x - ray luminosity functions ( xlfs ) , scaled assuming the hubble constant to be 70 km s@xmath1 mpc@xmath1 .
they found the xlfs of these galaxies to be strikingly similar , when normalised by the sfr of the galaxy , and proposed a universal hmxb xlf .
additionally , they found that the number of sources with 210 kev luminosities @xmath22@xmath310@xmath4 erg s@xmath1 to be proportional to sfr@xmath5 .
furthermore they discovered a linear relation between the total hmxb x - ray flux of a galaxy and its sfr , for sfrs @xmath64 m@xmath7 yr@xmath1 .
several different methods were used to convert from x - ray intensity to luminosity when creating the xlfs for galaxies in the g03 sample .
some xlfs were derived assuming a standard x - ray binary emission model ( a power law with spectral index , @xmath8 , @xmath01.7 or a 5 kev bremsstrahlung ) with galactic line - of sight absorption ( e.g. zezas et al .
, 2002 ; soria & kong , 2002 ) .
others used the x - ray colours to estimate the emission spectrum , using galactic absorption ( e.g. eracleous et al . , 2002 ) , or deriving the absorption from the colours also ( e.g. lira et al . , 2002 ) .
also , some xlfs were derived using best fit spectra to individual bright sources ( smith & wilson , 2001 ) , or to the stacked x - ray population ( roberts et al . , 2002 ) .
xmm - newton ( xmm ) is the most sensitive x - ray imaging telescope in the 0.310 kev band .
we can therefore use deep xmm observations of nearby galaxies to glean the accuracy of these methods by comparing their resulting xlfs with the xlf derived from freely fitting each x - ray source . to do this , we chose xmm - newton observations of ngc 253 .
ngc 253 is a star - bursting spiral galaxy in the sculptor group at a distance of @xmath04 mpc ; it is almost edge on , with a d@xmath9 region of @xmath025@xmath10@xmath37@xmath10 .
we fully describe our analysis of the observations in barnard et al .
( 2007 , mnras submitted , hereafter known as b07 ) , and concentrate here on the 2003 , 110 ks xmm observation of ngc253 .
removing intervals of high background left good times of 45 ks in the pn and 69 ks in the mos .
we combined the cleaned mos and pn images , and ran the source detection algorithm provided with the xmm - newton data analysis suite sas version 7.0 , producing a list of 185 sources that had no other sources within 10@xmath11 . in fig .
[ 3im ] we present a three - colour , combined epic image ( @xmath12 ) of ngc253 .
north is up , east is left .
the white ellipse represents the v band d@xmath9 isophot for ngc 253 .
we see that ngc 253 covers @xmath020% of the field ; the vast majority of sources outside this region are likely to be background agns and foreground stars , but a few could be associated with globular clusters belonging to ngc 253 .
both populations of x - ray sources , inside and outside the d@xmath9 isophot , clearly display a wide range of colours .
we also show a linearly - scaled close - up of the central 2@xmath13 region , showing several point sources in a region that looks like one unresolved source in the main image .
rccc model & @xmath14 / 10@xmath15 atom @xmath16 & @xmath8 & @xmath17 / 10@xmath18 @xmath16 erg s@xmath1 + model i : standard model & 0.013 & 1.7 & 4006 + model ii : best fit to all ngc253 sources ( total ) & 0.34 & 2.49 & 8252 + model iii : total@xmath19ulx & 0.19 & 2.40 & 5365 + model iii : ulx & 0.5 & 2.65 & 11693 + for every source , we obtained an extraction region with radius 1240@xmath11 .
in general , we used radius of 20@xmath11 , except for sources with large psfs due to high off - axis angle , where a 40@xmath11 radius was used , or in very crowded regions , where a radius of 1215@xmath11 was used .
we also created a corresponding background region for every source .
we required that the background be on the same ccd as the source for all three epic cameras , that there be no point sources in the background , and that its intensity per unit area be smaller than for the source region .
the resulting background regions had areas 135 times greater than their corresponding source regions ; for 75% of sources , the background : source area ratio @xmath2 3 .
we extracted pn and mos source and background spectra in the 0.310 kev range , combining the mos1 and mos2 spectra if the source was present in both cameras .
we obtained fits to 140 sources with @xmath250 source counts in the pn and/or mos spectra , using power law , blackbody and bremsstrahlung models ; all models included line - of - sight absorption .
we considered all fits with null hypothesis probability @xmath200.05 as acceptable . if none of these spectral models provided a good fit , we considered a two - component model consisting of a power law and blackbody , as seen in galactic x - ray binaries .
we used the best fit model to obtain a 0.3 - 10 kev , unabsorbed flux for each source .
for these 140 sources , we obtained fluxes from the source intensities using some of the methods employed when creating the xlfs used by g03 .
b07 describes this comparison in detail , but here we consider luminosities obtained using : ( i ) a standard emission model with galactic line - of - sight absorption , ( ii ) the best fit power law model to the summed spectrum of all sources within the d@xmath9 of ngcc253 ( iii ) best summed spectra of ngc253 point sources divided into ulxs and non - ulxs .
when converting from intensity to luminosity using particular emission models , we corrected the observed intensities for background , vignetting and encircled energy . hence , we obtained for each source the intensity of an equivalent on - axis source with a 15@xmath11 extraction radius .
we then used xspec to find the conversion factor for each model , i.e. the unabsorbed flux required to give 1 count s@xmath1 in the 0.310 kev band for an on - axis source with 15@xmath11 extraction radius .
the parameters of these models are summarised in table 1 , along with their conversion factor .
we immediately see that luminosities obtained from these different methods vary by a factor of 3 for the ulxs and a factor of 2.1 for the normal population .
we also note that the major influence on the conversion factor appears to be the absorption , which is 2050 times higher for the best fit models than for the standard model assuming galactic absorption . in fig .
[ sbc ] , we compare the 90% upper and lower flux limits from the best fit to each of the 140 bright sources with @xmath250 counts in the pn and/or mos spectra with the flux obtained from assuming a standard model ( model i ) .
the flux limits are represented by stepped lines , while the points represent pimms fluxes .
the x - axis is not numbered as it serves only to separate the sources ; the sources were ordered by decreasing best fit flux for clarity .
the y - axis is log - scaled and shows the 0.310 kev flux .
the standard model fluxes are consistent with the individually fitted fluxes for only @xmath030% of the sources ; the fluxes agree more at lower fluxes , but the standard model systematically underestimates the individually fitted fluxes for the brighter sources .
this is probably because brighter x - ray binaries are systematically softer , and hence the xmm intensity to flux correspondence is non - linear .
the total flux from freely modelling spectra of all sources within the d@xmath9 of ngc253 excluding the nuclear region is 2.8 times higher than the model i flux for the same sources ; the freely modelled total flux is 40% higher than for model ii , and 10% higher than for model iii .
it is unsurprising that model iii is most successful at reproducing the freely fit luminosity , as it employs two conversion factors to ngc253 sources grouped by luminosity , rather than a single conversion factor ; hence , model iii best samples the non - linear conversion between flux and intensity .
subdivision of the x - ray population into intensity bands , and obtaining corresponding conversion factors ( like roberts et al . , 2002 ) , is therefore likely to be the best approach to fitting low - photon data .
in fig . [ lf1_2 ] we show xlfs inside and outside the d@xmath9 region of ngc253 , for the 140 sources bright enough to fit , excluding the nuclear region and two agns from the ngc253 population , and the foreground star from the background population ; the 0.310 kev luminosity is plotted on the x - axis , and the number of sources per square degree with higher fluxes given on the y - axis .
the d@xmath21 region and background region cover 137 and 570 square arcminutes respectively , assuming a circular field of view with 15@xmath10 radius .
the black lines represent the ngc253 xlfs , while the grey lines represent the background xlfs ; solid lines are xlfs derived from individually fit models , and dashed lines are xlfs derived from the standard model .
the luminosities given assume a distance of 4 mpc , although this is unlikely to apply for many of the background sources .
a kolmogorov - smirnoff test shows that the ngc253 and background populations have a probability of 1.8@xmath310@xmath22 for being drawn from the same population .
we first note that the spatial density of x - ray sources for the ngc253 population is a factor of @xmath04 times higher than that of the background population ; this is in keeping with the idea that the ngc253 population mainly belongs to ngc 253 , while the background population consists mainly of background or foreground objects .
we next note that for ngc253 , the xlf derived from individual spectral fits is considerably flatter than the xlf obtained using the standard model ( model i ) .
we used the sherpa fitting software to model these xlfs with broken power law models , using cash statistics to obtain uncertainties .
the goodness of fit of the best fit broken power law models were then tested using a method adopted from that of crawford , jauncey & murdoch ( 1970 ) , who developed a goodness of fit estimation for modelling unbinned data such as lumiosity functions .
the best if ngc253 model consists of a broken power law that changes spectral index from [email protected] to [email protected] at a 0.310 kev luminosity of [email protected]@xmath310@xmath24 erg s@xmath25 ; the good fit probability was 0.14 .
the best sm ngc253 model breaks from [email protected] to [email protected] at [email protected]@xmath310@xmath24 erg s@xmath1 , with a good fit probability of 0.19 .
we note that luminosities lower than the break are likely artefacts of incompleteness , and are not particularly meaningful .
we applied the best fit sm model to the if xlf , and found that the good fit probability was only 0.003 ; hence the differences between the xlfs are statistically significant . the higher conversion factors of models ii and iii with respect to model i mean that their xlfs are correspondingly flatter .
grimm et al . ( 2003 ) report a universal hmxb xlf derived from published xlfs of several nearby galaxies .
they also derive relations between the star formation rate and ( i ) the total luminosity of the point x - ray sources in the galaxies and ( ii ) the number of x - ray sources in a galaxy with 210 kev luminosity @xmath22@xmath310@xmath4 erg s@xmath1 .
however , the published xlfs were produced using a number of methods , in most cases assuming galactic line - of - sight absorption .
we have tested several of these models using a deep xmm - newton observation of the nearby galaxy ngc253 , included in a secondary sample of grimm et al .
we obtained freely modelled luminosities for the 140 brightest sources in the field and also obtained the conversion factors from intensity to flux for some of these different models .
we found them to vary by a factor of @xmath03 .
we found the biggest influence on the conversion factor to be the absorption ; model i assumed galactic line - of - sight absorption , while absorptions 2050 times higher than this were obtained for the other methods . since the universal xlf and relations between sfr and x - ray properties were obtained using a mixture of methods , we find them to be inconclusive .
we have also found from freely fitting the spectra of 140 bright sources that the corresponence between count - rate and flux is non - linear ; this is largely due to the systematic softening of the spectra of more luminous sources .
hence it is unwise to employ a single emission model when describing the x - ray populations of nearby galaxies .
ideally , one would construct xlfs only from luminosities derived from free spectral modelling . to get the most out of the low - photon data , we recommend the stacking method of e.g. roberts et al .
( 2002 ) . , d. f. , jauncey , d. l. , & murdoch , h. s. 1970 , apj , 162 , 405 , m. , shields , j. c. , chartas , g. , & moran , e. c. 2002 , apj , 565 , 108 , h .- j . , gilfanov , m. , & sunyaev , r. 2003 , mnras , 339 , 793 , p. , ward , m. , zezas , a. , alonso - herrero , a. , & ueno , s. 2002 , mnras , 330 , 259 , t. p. , warwick , r. s. , ward , m. j. , & murray , s. s. 2002 , mnras , 337 , 677 , d. a. & wilson , a. s. 2001 , apj , 557 , 180 , r. & kong , a. k. h. 2002 , apjl , 572 , l33 | there is a large body of work that has used the excellent chandra observations of nearby galaxies with neglible low mass x - ray binary ( lmxb ) populations .
this has culminated in a `` universal '' x - ray luminosity function ( xlf ) for high mass x - ray binaries ( hmxbs ) . however , a number of methods have been used to convert from source intensities to luminosities when creating these xlfs .
we have taken advantage of the xmm - newton observations of the nearby starbursting spiral galaxy ngc 253 to test some of these methods .
we find the luminosities derived from these various methods to vary by a factor of @xmath03 .
we also find the most influential factor in the conversion from intensity to luminosity to be the absorption .
we therefore conclude that a more consistent approach is required for determining the true universal xlf for hmxbs .
ideally , this would involve individual spectral fitting of each x - ray source .
certainly , the line - of - sight absorption should be determined from the observations rather than assuming galactic absorption .
we find the best approach for obtaining an xlf from low - count data to be the splitting of the x - ray sources into two or more intensity intervals , and obtaining a conversion from intensity to flux for each group from spectral modelling of the summed spectrum of that group . |
space- and time - resolved brillouin light scattering ( bls ) spectroscopy is a well established technique to investigate the spin - wave dynamics in thin magnetic films @xcite .
however , this method is based on a simple counting of inelastically scattered photons .
thus it only allows for the spatial and temporal mapping of spin - wave intensities .
no phase information about magnetic excitations is accessible by conventional bls . at the same time the phase information is crucial to answer questions concerning problems such as formation of coherent states in a magnon gas and evolution of nonlinear spin - wave eigenmodes
@xcite as well as nonlinear phase accumulation @xcite , peculiarities of spin - wave excitation process @xcite , 2-dimensional phase structure of spin - wave beams in magnetically anisotropic media , etc . + the first realization of a phase - sensitive bls setup as well as the results obtained by means of phase - sensitive bls spectroscopy have been presented by us in ref .
it was shown that the implementation of phase resolution into brillouin light spectroscopy leads to a complete picture of the underlying physical processes by combining space- , time- and phase - resolution into the measurement .
+ here we report on further improvement of this technique by implementation of a new type of magneto - optic modulator , based on brillouin light scattering in a thin ferrite film .
furthermore we demonstrate that the use of the magneto - optic modulator also improves the bls dynamical range .
to understand the principle of phase sensitivity it is important to notice that the inelastically scattered light , which is detected in the bls measurements , is determined by both amplitude and phase of the scattering spin wave .
however , the phase information is lost when the photon is received by a photodetector , it only can register the arrival of a photon , i.e. quantum of energy .
+ to access phase information we use interference between inelastically scattered light created in the process of propagation of the probing laser beam through the sample with reference scattered light provided by the magneto - optic modulation .
+ without a fixed phase correlation , the intensity of the sample beam @xmath0 and the reference beam @xmath1 combine to @xmath2 if conditions for interference are fulfilled , the sample beam and the reference beam combine to @xmath3 with an additional phase - term .
+ the magneto - optic modulator used here was produced on the base of an yttrium - iron - garnet ( yig ) ferrite film .
as one can see in fig .
[ figure1 ] the laser beam is initially focused on a 10 @xmath4 thick in - plane magnetized yig film stripe in the magneto - optic modulator . the bias magnetic field is oriented parallel to the spin - wave propagation direction , and thus a backward volume magnetostatic spin wave ( bvmsw ) @xcite is excited in the film . as a result of nonelastic light scattering by this wave , a part of the beam is now frequency shifted and simultaneously rotated in polarization by 90@xmath5 forming the reference beam .
focussing of the laser beam is necessary to enhance the efficiency of the scattering process .
firstly , the beam is focussed near to the exciting antenna , where the intensity of the spin wave and scattering - probability is highest and secondly , as we have a propagating and not a standing spin wave , the phase of the scattered light is well defined only if the scattering process occurs in an area which length is small compared to the wavelength of the spin wave .
+ note that a great part of the laser light passes the modulator unchanged in frequency and polarization .
some part of this undisturbed light undergoes a second scattering process in the sample and forms the sample beam .
having the same polarization direction and the same frequency , the reference beam and the sample beam now fulfill the condition for interference at the photodetector .
+ the modulator is driven by the same microwave signal which is used to excite the spin waves .
this guarantees not only that the reference light has exactly the same frequency as the inelastically scattered light but also the necessary phase coherence between both signals .
the amplitude of the reference signal and the phase difference @xmath6 can be adjusted by using a microwave attenuator and a phase shifter respectively ( see fig .
[ figure1 ] ) . since the light in the signal and the reference channnels share the same spatial path , thermal and mechanical stability is ensured .
+ the resulting interference picture allows us to visualize the phase fronts and to calculate the phase profiles ( i.e. the time - dependent phase difference between the exciting microwave signal and the spin wave at any given point ) of the investigated spin waves from measured interference maps with different additional phase shifts between reference and signal . for a more detailed description of the underlying analysis procedure and the phase - sensitive bls setup see refs .
+ before the implementation of the _
magneto_-optic modulator , the necessary frequency shift for the reference beam was created by using an _
electro_-optic modulator based on a lithium - niobate crystal @xcite .
however phase - resolved bls spectroscopy of magnetic excitations using the proposed magneto - optic modulation has several advantages compared to the previous electro - optic - modulation .
+ _ ( i ) _ in order to increase the conversion efficiency , the lithium - niobate - crystal in our electro - optic modulator was placed inside a microwave cavity . due to the strong distortion of the electric field inside the cavity by influence of this dielectric ( @xmath7 ) material ,
the adjustment of the modulator was very complicated and as a result only a few fixed frequencies were accessible .
this restriction does not exist for a magneto - optic modulator which can be tuned continuously in frequency by an external magnetic field .
thus , the rf - frequency can be implemented as an additional free parameter during a measurement . _
( ii ) _ another important advantage of a magneto - optic modulator , which is based on brillouin light scattering , is that the polarization of the reference beam and the sample beam is the same , i.e. both beams change polarization with respect to the light source . on contrary , the electro - optic modulator does not change the polarization of the frequency - shifted light and as a result no interference with non - elastically scattered light occurs without special disalignment of the polarization filter placed before the interferometer . in conventional bls spectroscopy this filter is used to block the elastically - scattered light and thus consequently decreases the noise . in this way
the disalignment of the filter , necessary when using an electro - optic modulator , allows interference but also significantly increases the noise level .
this disalignment is not necessary for the proposed magneto - optic modulator , where the polarization condition for the best interference is fulfilled automatically .
and reference pulse @xmath8 .
an additional reference pulse @xmath9 is recorded with a time delay of 900 ns.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] in the following we present example measurements with the new setup .
spin - wave pulses are excited in a 4,5 mm long yig - film in bvmsw - configuration .
figure [ figure2 ] shows the comparison between the time profiles of the sample pulse ( @xmath0 , dashed line ) and the constructive interference ( @xmath10 , solid line ) between sample pulse and reference pulse @xmath8 . the data for the intensity of the sample pulse is obtained by switching off the exciting microwave - current in the modulator .
the duration is 300 ns for the reference pulse and 100 ns for the sample pulse , respectively .
the pulse carrier frequency is 7 ghz at a bias magnetic field @xmath11 of 1815 oe . to obtain the information about spatial and temporal distribution of the background , an additional reference pulse @xmath9 was recorded with a time delay of 900 ns . + the spatial distribution of the propagating spin - wave packet is shown in fig .
[ figure3 ] .
the first column shows the decaying intensity of the spin - wave packet propagating in the sample . in the second column the interference pattern of the sample - beam and reference beam is depicted .
it is clearly observable that , for the long propagation times , the spin wave is much more visible in the interference patterns in comparison to the intensity profiles .
thus an increase in the dynamic range of the bls setup is obtained .
+ ) at 286 ns and the time delayed reference pulse @xmath9 . in the third panel
the interference pattern is divided by the intensity profile of the time delayed reference beam , resulting in eq .
( [ eq : three ] ) .
thus signal variations caused by optic nonuniformities are removed ( white arrows ) .
each profile is normalized to the respective maximum value at 286 ns.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] the sample beam in eq .
( [ eq : two ] ) contains all information about the spin wave and the pure reference component @xmath1 can be regarded as a background , including defects and optic nonuniformities in the yig - film .
the resulting picture can be improved by just dividing the interference profile by the intensity profile of the time delayed reference beam . @xmath12 since reference beam and sample beam share the same spatial path , both are influenced by the same disturbances .
thus by dividing both signals , the noise can be significantly reduced .
the result of this calculation is presented in fig .
[ figure4 ] .
spurious signals , e.g. the spot at the upper right corner , are completely erased from the interference pattern and the distribution of the spin wave itself can be distinguished better from the homogenous white noise . | a recently reported phase sensitive brillouin light scattering technique is improved by use of a magnetic modulator .
this modulator is based on brillouin light scattering in a thin ferrite film . using this magnetic modulator in time- and space brillouin light scattering measurements
we have increased phase contrast and excluded influence of optical inhomogeneities in the sample .
we also demonstrate that the quality of the resulting interference patterns can be improved by data postprocessing using the simultaneously recorded information about the reference light . |
origin of tiny neutrino masses and mixing is one of the most widely studied problems in modern day particle physics . since the standard model ( sm ) of particle physics fails to provide an explanation to neutrino masses and mixing , several well motivated beyond standard model ( bsm ) frameworks
have been proposed to account for the tiny neutrino mass observed by several neutrino oscillation experiments @xcite .
more recently , the neutrino oscillation experiments t2k @xcite , double chooz @xcite , daya - bay @xcite and reno @xcite have also confirmed the earlier results and also made the measurement of neutrino parameters more precise . the latest global fit values for @xmath3 range of neutrino oscillation parameters @xcite
are shown in table [ tab : data1 ] .
another global fit study @xcite reports the 3@xmath4 values as shown in table [ tab : data2 ] .
.global fit @xmath3 values of neutrino oscillation parameters @xcite [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ table : deltacl ] with charged lepton correction to scaling , scaledwidth=100.0% ] in the second mechanism we adopt to give correction to the scaling neutrino mixing , we do not add corrections to the neutrino mass matrix originating from type i seesaw , but incorporate corrections to the neutrino mixing matrix originating from charged lepton mixing . diagonalizing
the scaling neutrino mass matrix from type i seesaw matrix gives @xmath5 which is related to the leptonic mixing matrix @xmath6 through the charged lepton diagonalizing matrix @xmath7 .
we first numerically evaluate @xmath5 by using the best fit values of neutrino mass squared differences and two mixing angles @xmath8 .
we also substitute the best fit values of neutrino mixing angles in pmns mixing matrix and then compute the charged lepton diagonalizing matrix as @xmath9 we keep the dirac cp phase @xmath2 as free parameter so that @xmath10 is a function of it .
the numerical form of @xmath7 for @xmath11 is shown in table [ table : ul ] .
assuming the same diagonalizing matrix of charged leptons and dirac neutrino mass matrix ( a generic case in grand unified theories operating at high scale ) , we can write down the modified dirac neutrino mass matrix as @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the scaling type dirac neutrino mass matrix we choose earlier . we choose a diagonal form of @xmath14 while keeping
the lightest right handed neutrino mass @xmath15 in the appropriate flavor regime of leptogenesis and varying the heavier right handed neutrino masses @xmath16 between @xmath15 and the grand unified theory scale @xmath17 gev .
for such a choice of @xmath14 , we numerically evaluate the parameters in @xmath13 by equating the type i seesaw term @xmath18 to the numerically fitted type i scaling neutrino mass matrix .
the numerical values of @xmath14 which give baryon asymmetry closest to the observed in each flavor regime are shown in table [ table : mrrcl ] .
the numerical form of dirac neutrino mass matrices in each flavor regime for @xmath11 are shown in table [ table : mlrcl ] .
the predictions for baryon asymmetry as a function of @xmath2 are shown in figure [ fig7 ] .
the values of dirac cp phase which give rise to correct baryon asymmetry are listed in table [ table : deltacl ] .
we have studied a specific type of neutrino mass matrix based on the idea of strong scaling ansatz where the ratio of neutrino mass matrix elements belonging to two different columns are equal . out of three such possibilities , we focus on a particular scaling neutrino mass matrix which predicts zero values of reactor mixing angle @xmath0 .
this choice was motivated by several recent works where the leading order neutrino mass matrix obeying certain symmetries predict @xmath1 and suitable corrections to the neutrino mass matrix or leptonic mixing matrix give rise to small but non - zero values of @xmath0 . in this work ,
we have assumed type i seesaw to give rise to scaling neutrino mass matrix which ( in the diagonal charged lepton basis ) gives @xmath1 and inverted hiearchical mass pattern with @xmath19 .
then we consider two different possible corrections to scaling : one with type ii seesaw which gives rise to deviations from both @xmath1 and @xmath19 , the other with charged lepton correction which gives non - zero @xmath0 while keeping @xmath19 .
we also assume both the corrections to give rise to non - trivial dirac cp phase @xmath2 as well . in both the cases
, we first numerically evaluate the type i seesaw scaling neutrino mass matrix by using the best fit values of neutrino mass squared differences and two mixing angles : solar and atmospheric .
we then calculate the necessary corrections to scaling neutrino mass and mixing by keeping the dirac cp phase as free parameter .
we further constrain the dirac cp phase by calculating the baryon asymmetry through the mechanism of leptogenesis and comparing with the observed baryon asymmetry .
the important results we have obtained in the case of type ii seesaw correction to scaling can be summarized as : * type ii seesaw correction to scaling neutrino mass matrix with @xmath20 can result in both normal as well as inverted hierarchy with non - zero @xmath0 as well as non - trivial dirac cp phase @xmath2 . * for inverted hierarchy with @xmath21 that is @xmath22 , correct values of baryon asymmetry
is obtained through the mechanism of leptogenesis only when the lightest neutrino mass @xmath23 is of same order as the heavier ones @xmath24 . * for inverted hierarchy with @xmath25 that is @xmath26 , both large and mild hierarchy among neutrino masses
give rise to correct baryon asymmetry through leptogenesis .
* for normal hierarchy with @xmath22 , both large and mild hierarchy among neutrino masses can give rise to correct baryon asymmetry in the one flavor regime .
in the two flavor regime however , the lightest neutrino mass @xmath23 should be of same order as @xmath27 to give correct baryon asymmetry .
* for normal hierarchy with @xmath26 , the lightest neutrino mass @xmath23 should be of same order as @xmath27 to give correct baryon asymmetry in both one and two flavor regimes .
* observed baryon asymmetry can not be generated in the three flavor regime of leptogenesis in this framework .
similarly , the important results in the case of charged lepton correction to scaling are : * charged lepton correction to scaling neutrino mixing predicts only inverted hierarchy with @xmath19 , but gives rise to correct values of @xmath0 and non - trivial @xmath2 . *
correct baryon asymmetry can be obtained through leptogenesis for one , two and three flavor regimes if @xmath2 is restricted to certain range of values .
since the dirac cp phase is restricted in all these cases discussed , from the demand of producing the correct baryon asymmetry , future determination of @xmath2 should be able to shed some light on these scenarios .
future experiments may however , measure a different value of @xmath2 than the ones which give correct baryon asymmetry through the mechanism of leptogenesis in the models we have studied here .
this will by no means rule out the neutrino mass models based on strong scaling ansatz we discuss , but will only hint at a different source of baryon asymmetry than the one discussed in our work .
similarly , determination of neutrino mass hierarchy in neutrino oscillation experiments will further constrain the models and only charged lepton correction to scaling may not be sufficient to reproduce the correct neutrino data if inverted hierarchy gets disfavored by experiments . from theoretical point of view ,
such scaling neutrino mass matrix can find a dynamical origin within discrete flavor symmetry models as pointed out by @xcite .
since scaling is not affected by renormalization group running , additional physics are required in order to produce correct low energy neutrino oscillation data .
undisturbed by such running effects , scaling can be valid all the way from grand unified theory scale down to the tev scale , where new physics affects like higgs triplet in type ii seesaw can give rise to the necessary correction to scaling neutrino mass matrix .
although we have studied only one particular type of scaling neutrino mass matrix giving @xmath20 , the other two possibile scaling mass matrices could also give rise to correct neutrino phenomenology if suitable corrections are incorporated , which is left for our future studies .
the work of m. k. das is partially supported by the grant no .
42 - 790/2013(sr ) from university grants commission , government of india . 99 s. fukuda et al .
( super - kamiokande ) , phys . rev . lett . * 86 * , 5656 ( 2001 ) , hep - ex/0103033 ; q. r. ahmad et al .
( sno ) , phys .
lett . * 89 * , 011301 ( 2002 ) , nucl - ex/0204008 ; phys .
lett . * 89 * , 011302 ( 2002 ) , nucl - ex/0204009 ; j. n. bahcall and c. pena - garay , new j. phys . * 6 * , 63 ( 2004 ) , hep - ph/0404061 ; k. nakamura et al . ,
j. phys . * g37 * , 075021 ( 2010 ) .
k. abe et al .
[ t2k collaboration ] , phys .
lett . * 107 * , 041801 ( 2011 ) , [ arxiv:1106.2822 [ hep - ex ] ] .
y. abe et al . , phys .
lett . * 108 * , 131801 ( 2012 ) , [ arxiv:1112.6353 [ hep - ex ] ] .
f. p. an et al .
[ daya - bay collaboration ] , phys .
lett . * 108 * , 171803 ( 2012 ) , [ arxiv:1203.1669 [ hep - ex ] ] .
j. k. ahn et al .
[ reno collaboration ] , phys .
lett . * 108 * , 191802 ( 2012 ) , [ arxiv:1204.0626][hep - ex ] ] .
m. c. gonzalez - garcia , m. maltoni and t. schwetz , jhep * 1411 * , 052 ( 2014)[arxiv:1409.5493 [ hep - ph ] ] .
d. v. forero , m. tortola and j. w. f. valle , phys .
rev . * d90 * , 093006 ( 2014)[arxiv:1405.7540[hep - ph ] ] .
p. a. r. ade _ et al .
_ [ planck collaboration ] , astron .
* 571 * , a16 ( 2014 ) .
v. a. kuzmin , v. a. rubakov and m. e. shaposhnikov , phys . lett . *
b155 * , 36 ( 1985 ) .
m. fukugita and t. yanagida , phys . lett .
* b174 * , 45 ( 1986 ) . j. ellis , s. lola and d. v. nanopoulos , phys . lett . *
b452 * , 87 ( 1999 ) ; g. lazarides and n. d. vlachos , phys . lett . *
b459 * , 482 ( 1999 ) ; m. s. berger and b. brahmachari , phys . rev . *
d60 * , 073009 ( 1999 ) ; m. s. berger , phys . rev . *
d62 * , 013007 ( 2000 ) ; w. buchm@xmath28ller and m. plumacher , int . j. mod . phys . *
a15 * , 5047 ( 2000 ) ; k. kang , s. k. kang and u. sarkar , phys . lett . * b486 * , 391 ( 2000 ) ; h. goldberg , phys . lett . *
b474 * , 389 ( 2000 ) ; r. jeannerot , s. khalil and g. lazarides , phys . lett . * b506 * , 344 ( 2001 ) ; d. falcone and f. tramontano , phys . rev . *
d63 * , 073007 ( 2001 ) ; d. falcone and f. tramontano , phys . lett . * b506 * , 1 ( 2001 ) ; h. b. nielsen and y. takanishi , phys . lett . *
b507 * , 241 ( 2001 ) ; e. nezri and j. orloff , jhep * 0304 * , 020 ( 2003 ) .
a. s. joshipura , e. a. paschos and w. rodejohann , nucl . phys . *
b611 * , 227 ( 2001 ) .
s. davidson , e. nardi and y. nir , phys . rept . *
466 * , 105 ( 2008 ) .
d. borah and m. k. das , phys . rev . *
d90 * , 015006 ( 2014 ) .
d. borah , nucl . phys . * b876 * , 575 ( 2013 ) ; d. borah , s. patra and p. pritimita , nucl . phys . * b881 * , 444 ( 2014 ) ; d. borah , int . j. mod .
a29 * , 1450108 ( 2014 ) ; m. borah , d. borah , m. k. das and s. patra , phys . rev . *
d90 * , 095020 ( 2014 ) ; r. kalita and d. borah , arxiv:1410.8437 .
p. minkowski , phys . lett . *
b67 * , 421 ( 1977 ) ; m. gell - mann , p. ramond , and r. slansky ( 1980 ) , print-80 - 0576 ( cern ) ; t. yanagida ( 1979 ) , in proceedings of the workshop on the baryon number of the universe and unified theories , tsukuba , japan , 13 - 14 feb 1979 ; r. n. mohapatra and g. senjanovic , phys .
lett * 44 * , 912 ( 1980 ) ; j. schechter and j. w. f. valle , phys . rev .
* d22 * , 2227 ( 1980 ) .
r. n. mohapatra and g. senjanovic , phys .
d23 * , 165 ( 1981 ) ; g. lazarides , q. shafi and c wetterich , nucl .
b181 * , 287 ( 1981 ) ; c. wetterich , nucl . phys . *
b187 * , 343 ( 1981 ) ; j. schechter and j. w. f. valle , phys . rev . *
d25 * , 774 ( 1982 ) ; b. brahmachari and r. n. mohapatra , phys .
rev . * d58 * , 015001 ( 1998 ) ; r. n. mohapatra , nucl .
suppl . * 138 * , 257 ( 2005 ) ; s. antusch and s. f. king , phys .
b597 * , ( 2 ) , 199 ( 2004 ) .
r. n. mohapatra and w. rodejohann , phys .
* b 644 * , 59 ( 2007 ) .
a. blum , r. n. mohapatra and w. rodejohann , phys .
d76 * , 053003(2007 ) ; a. s. joshipura , w. rodejohann , phys . lett . * b678 * , 276 ( 2009 ) ; m. obara , arxiv:0712.2628 ; m. chakraborty , h. z. devi , a. ghosal , arxiv:1410.3276 ; w. rodejohann , prog .
. phys . * 64 * , 321 ( 2010 ) .
w. grimus , l. lavoura , j. phys . *
g31 * , 683 ( 2005 ) ; w. grimus , l. lavoura , phys .
rev * d62 * , 093012 ( 2000 ) ; l. lavoura , phys .
rev * d62 * , 093011 ( 2000 ) .
b. adhikary , m. chakrabarty , a. ghosal , phys . rev . * d86 * , 013015 ( 2012 ) ; s. verma , phys . lett . * b714 * , 92 ( 2012 ) ; m. yasue , phys . rev . * d86 * , 116011 ( 2012 ) ; m. yasue , arxiv:1209.1866 ; s. dev , r. r. gautam , l. singh , phys .
rev * d89 * , 013006 ( 2014 ) .
e. w. kolb and m. s. turner , the early universe , frontiers in physics , vol .
69 , addison - wesley , redwood , 1990 ; a. pilaftsis , int . j. mod
. phys . * 44 * , 1811 ( 1999 ) ; e. a. paschos and m. flanz , phys . rev . *
d58 * , 113009 ( 1998 ) .
r. barbieri , p. creminelli , a. strumia and n. tetradis , nucl .
* b575 * , 61 ( 2000 ) ; a. abada , s. davidson , f. -x .
josse - michaux , m. losada and a. riotto , jcap * 0604 * , 004 ( 2006 ) ; e. nardi , y. nir , e. roulet and j. racker , jhep * 0601 * , 164 ( 2006 ) ; a. abada , s. davidson , a. ibarra , f. -x .
josse - michaux , m. losada and a. riotto , jhep * 0609 * , 010 ( 2006 ) ; p.
s. b. dev , p. millington , a. pilaftsis and d. teresi , nucl . phys . *
b886 * , 569 ( 2014 ) .
g. lazarides and q. shafi , phys . rev .
* d58 * , 071702 ( 1998 ) ; t. hambye and g. senjanovic , phys . lett .
* b582 * , 73 ( 2004 ) . j. c. pati and a. salam , phys .
* d10 * , 275 ( 1974 ) ; r. n. mohapatra and j. c. pati , phys .
* d11 * , 2558 ( 1975 ) ; g. senjanovic and r. n. mohapatra , phys . rev . * d12 * , 1502 ( 1975 ) ; r. n. mohapatra and r. e. marshak , phys .
lett . * 44 * , 1316 ( 1980 ) ; n. g. deshpande , j. f. gunion , b. kayser and f. i. olness , phys . rev .
* d44 * , 837 ( 1991 ) . n. cosme , jhep * 0408 * , 027 ( 2004 ) . | we study a very specific type of neutrino mass and mixing structure based on the idea of strong scaling ansatz ( ssa ) where the ratios of neutrino mass matrix elements belonging to two different columns are equal .
there are three such possibilities , all of which are disfavored by the latest neutrino oscillation data .
we focus on the specific scenario which predicts vanishing reactor mixing angle @xmath0 and inverted hierarchy with vanishing lightest neutrino mass . motivated by several recent attempts to explain non - zero @xmath0 by incorporating corrections to a leading order neutrino mass or mixing matrix giving @xmath1 , here we study the origin of non - zero @xmath0 as well as leptonic dirac cp phase @xmath2 by incorporating two different corrections to scaling neutrino mass and mixing : one where type ii seesaw acts as a correction to scaling neutrino mass matrix and the other with charged lepton correction to scaling neutrino mixing .
although scaling neutrino mass matrix originating from type i seesaw predicts inverted hierarchy , the total neutrino mass matrix after type ii seesaw correction can give rise to either normal or inverted hierarchy .
however , charged lepton corrections do not disturb the inverted hierarchy prediction of scaling neutrino mass matrix .
we further discriminate between neutrino hierarchies , different choices of lightest neutrino mass and dirac cp phase by calculating baryon asymmetry and comparing with the observations made by the planck experiment . |
discovering a few years ago a new family of iron based superconductors gave rise both to intensive investigation of the fundamental properties of these materials ( see reviews @xcite and refs . therein ) and to seeking for their potential application .
the fabrication of high - quality thin films is of great importance for potential applications of these new materials in superconducting devices as well as for a deeper fundamental study of their superconducting properties .
numerous experiments were undertaken to study the superconducting state of iron based superconductors , however less attention was paid to the investigation of films , due to the more complicated preparation . in this paper
we present first point - contact andreev reflection ( pcar ) spectroscopy investigation of lafeaso@xmath1f@xmath2 and smfeaso@xmath1f@xmath2 films .
the main goal was to measure of the superconducting gap(s ) and its temperature dependence for the mentioned films to compare these data with existing similar measurements on bulk samples @xcite and to clarify some issues as to the presence of multiband structure on pcar spectra and pcar spectra asymmetry .
@xmath0feaso@xmath1f@xmath2 ( @xmath0=la , sm ) films with superconductivity onset below 34k have been fabricated using pulsed laser deposition . the successful growth of high quality @xmath0feaso@xmath1f@xmath2 thin films @xcite enables the investigation of fundamental properties .
details of the preparation of lafeaso@xmath1f@xmath2 films are described in ref .
the same parameters were also used for smfeaso@xmath1f@xmath2 film growth .
the temperature dependence of the resistance of the @xmath0=sm film used in our experiments is shown in fig.[rt ] .
the onset of the superconducting transition of about 34k is well below the maximal transition temperature for optimally doped smfeaso@xmath1f@xmath2 crystals likely due to severe fluorine loss under film preparation .
also the superconducting transition sufficiently broadens in a magnetic field , what can be due to nonuniform fluorine doping through the film thickness .
the @xmath0=la film was of lower quality with a much broader superconducting transition .
therefore , we concentrated in this study mainly on measurements of the @xmath0=sm film .
[ b ] f@xmath2 thin film at zero field and at 9 t .
arrow shows @xmath7 .
inset : temperature dependence of the resistance of the film up to room temperatures.,width=321 ] the pcs were established by the standard `` needle - anvil '' method @xcite touching of the film surface by a sharpened thin cu wire . the differential resistance @xmath8 was recorded by sweeping the dc current @xmath9 on which a small ac current @xmath10 was superimposed using the standard lock - in technique . the measurements of pcar spectra were performed in the temperature range between 3 and 33k applying a magnetic field up to 7 t perpendicular to the film surface .
in pcar spectroscopy some conditions must be fulfilled , namely , the contact diameter @xmath11 has to be smaller than the inelastic electron mean - free path @xmath12 as well as smaller than the superconducting coherence length @xmath13 .
the latter is anisotropic in the @xmath0feaso@xmath1f@xmath2 family and does not exceed a few nm @xcite .
the contact size can be estimated from its resistance @xmath14 above @xmath15 using modified wexler formula @xcite for the case of heterocontact with a metal , where its resistivity is negligible compared with that of @xmath0feaso@xmath1f@xmath2 : @xmath16 here , @xmath17 is the so called barrier strength @xcite .
we estimated the product @xmath18 using the upper limit for the electron carrier concentration @xmath19@xmath20 as inferred from hall data = la is about 3 times lager at low temperatures than that for @xmath0=sm , which points to a 3 times larger electron density in @xmath0=sm . at the same time for @xmath0=sm with an onset of superconductivity at 36k , similar as in our film ,
the electron density is estimated to be about @xmath21@xmath20 @xcite . ] for @xmath0=la just above @xmath15 @xcite . making use of the drude free electron model we calculated @xmath22@xmath23 .
the residual resistivity @xmath24 of @xmath0feaso@xmath1f@xmath2 compounds , estimated by extrapolation @xmath25 , has value of about 100@xmath26 cm for @xmath0=la , whereas @xmath24 is higher for other @xmath0feaso@xmath1f@xmath2 compounds.=sm is 2 - 3 times larger at low temperatures than that of @xmath0=la .
] using the calculated value of @xmath18 and the mentioned resistivity @xmath24 , we find 10 nm as upper limit for the elastic electron mean free path @xmath27 for @xmath0feaso@xmath1f@xmath2 compounds . in table
i , we present estimations of the pc diameter , according to eq.([wexler ] ) , for pcs with three different resistances using both the lower limit of @xmath24=100 @xmath26 cm ( for high quality samples ) and the higher value @xmath24=1m@xmath28 cm , taken from the literature for @xmath0feaso@xmath1f@xmath2 .
.calculation of the pc diameter for three pc resistances according to eq.([wexler ] ) for @xmath17=0 and two values of resistivity and for @xmath17=0.6 ( last column ) . [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] thus , in order to fulfil the condition that the dimension of the pc has to be smaller than the elastic mean free path of electrons and/or the coherence length the pc resistance must be well above a few hundred ohms , which is not the case for pcs both investigated in this paper and in existing pcar studies cited in ref.@xcite
. therefore all pcar measurements have been done at least in the diffusive regime when elastic mean free path is small , i. e. @xmath29 .
although the diffusive regime does not prevent pcar spectroscopy , it favors the shortening of the diffusive inelastic mean free path @xmath30 of electrons so that a transition to the thermal regime @xmath31min@xmath32 ) @xcite with increasing of applied voltage is getting more probable .
taking into account that the resistivity in all @xmath0feaso@xmath1f@xmath2 has a remarkable slope ( increase ) just above @xmath15 , e. g. , for @xmath0=la , @xmath33 behaves like @xmath34 below @xmath35 200k @xcite , the inelastic , likely electron - electron , scattering in @xmath0feaso@xmath1f@xmath2 is starting already at very low temperatures shortening an inelastic mean free path @xmath36 and @xmath37 .
[ t ] curves of a smfeaso@xmath1f@xmath2 - cu contact ( @xmath38 = 26@xmath39 ) for varying temperature .
bottom panel : temperature dependencies of the fitting parameters : superconducting gap @xmath40 ( triangles ) , barrier parameter @xmath17 ( diamonds ) , scaling parameter @xmath41 ( squares ) , position of minima in @xmath42 ( stars ) for the pc from the upper panel .
the broadening parameter @xmath43 is equal to zero .
the solid line represents the bcs - like gap behavior .
inset : symmetrized and normalized , as it follows from the measurement in a magnetic field , see , e.g. , ref.@xcite .
it means that , so - called , normal state curve used for normalization can be slightly different for different temperatures .
therefore we have used for normalization of each @xmath8 a weak parabolic - like curve which fitted the same @xmath8 at biases @xmath4410mv , i.e. above the gap minima . ]
@xmath42 curve at @xmath45 = 3k ( points ) together with curves calculated according to the generalized btk theory : dashed ( blue ) and solid ( red ) lines - fit with @xmath40=3.35mv , @xmath43=0 , @xmath17=0.38 , @xmath41=0.5 and @xmath40=3.47mv , @xmath43=0.25mv , @xmath17=0.41 , @xmath41=0.58 , respectively.,width=302 ] on the other hand , the coherence length @xmath13 is also much smaller than the contact size , what can result in a distribution of superconducting properties ( e.g. , critical temperature , gap value ) within the pc and in a suppression of superconductivity in some part of the pc with current increase .
thereby , regardless of the pc resistance ( of course the higher the resistance the higher probability to be in the spectral regime ) , each @xmath8 curve should be critically analyzed if it suits for spectroscopy of the superconducting gap .
because of mentioned above reasons , it was difficult to get `` clean '' pcar @xmath42 spectra having no humps , spikes and other irregularities , which are connected with deviations from the spectral regime in pc .
fig.[dvdi ] shows one of the best series of @xmath42 curves , which demonstrate clear andreev - reflection ( gap ) structure , namely pronounced minima at @xmath46mv at @xmath47 which are to a great extend free from unwanted features . to get the superconducting gap value @xmath40 and other parameters from the pcar spectra the blonder - tinkham - klapwijk ( btk ) theory @xcite including so - called broadening parameter @xmath43
has been used .
the temperature dependence of the superconducting gap @xmath40 has been established ( see fig.[dvdi ] ) from the fitting within the btk theory .
we tried to keep constant such fitting parameters as @xmath43 , the barrier @xmath17 and the scaling @xmath41 .
[ t ] curves of several smfeaso@xmath1f@xmath2 cu contacts measured at 3k .
pc resistance is shown for each curve . vertical dashed
stripes mark reproducible ar minima.,width=302 ] here , the parameter @xmath41 corresponds to the ratio of the experimental @xmath42 intensity to the calculated one .
= 1 , but @xmath48 1 happens very often too .
the possible reasons are connected with deviation of the pc structure from theoretical model and are described in more detail in appendix of ref.@xcite . ]
it is seen from fig.[dvdi ] that @xmath4 is in line with the bcs curve ( solid line ) , however , the resulting critical temperature of @xmath49 21.6k obtained by extrapolating the bcs curve to @xmath40= 0 is significantly lower than @xmath50 determined from the temperature dependence of the resistivity of the smfeaso@xmath1f@xmath2 film ( see fig.[rt ] ) . at the same time , the superconducting main minimum in @xmath42 for the investigated pc disappears close to 30k as shown in fig.[dvdi ] which approximately corresponds to the midpoint ( @xmath51 ) of the superconducting transition in fig.[rt ] .
however , by approaching this temperature , the shape of the @xmath42 minimum starts to deviate from the theoretically expected behavior already above 20k as shown in fig.[dvdi ] .
this is likely due to inhomogeneities of the superconducting state in the pc region in the case if its size @xmath11 is larger than the coherence length @xmath13 . also with increasing temperature inelastic scattering increases favoring the transition to the thermal regime
this hinders a determination of the gap in this temperature range .
therefore , the determination of the gap of the pc shown in fig.[dvdi ] is restricted to temperatures below 20k . investigating a dozen of pcs with clear double minima ar structure around @xmath52mv (
see , fig.[dvdis ] ) , we , nevertheless , could not observe or detect reproducible structures at a higher voltage , which were found , e.g. , in the representative two - band superconductor mgb@xmath53 @xcite .
also an about 3 times larger second gap features reported for bulk smfeaso@xmath1f@xmath2 samples @xcite could not be unambiguously resolved for the investigated pcs of the smfeaso@xmath1f@xmath2 film . instead ,
for increasing bias usually a peaked structure or other irregularities appear in the @xmath42 characteristics testifying the transition to the non - spectral regime . but
even if the similar to the second gap features are observed as , e.g , shallow minima slightly above @xmath54mv in the upper pc spectrum in fig.[dvdis ] ( see also low temperature spectra in fig.[dvdi ] ) , then this gap structure expected around @xmath55(9 - 12)mev is hardly to resolve for the other pc spectra ( see , e.g. , the bottom spectrum in fig.[dvdis ] ) . moreover , already a weak magnetic field suppresses the mentioned structure , nevertheless no presence of any second gap features appears ( see fig.[dvdim ] ) . the same concerns @xmath42 of pc with @xmath56 , where a shoulder is seen above @xmath55 10mv often taken as a larger gap structure .
the shoulder is washed out in magnetic field 7 t , while the small - gap minima are only slightly suppressed at the same field .
on the contrary , in the mentioned mgb@xmath53 the small gap is vanished more quickly in magnetic field than the larger one ( see circles in fig.15 in @xcite ) .
[ t ] curves of pc from fig.[dvdi ] measured at 3k in a magnetic field .
inset shows dependence of @xmath40 ( triangles ) and @xmath43 ( squares ) vs magnetic field as determined from the btk - fitting of @xmath42 curves from the main panel . here , @xmath570.38 and @xmath580.5 .
linear extrapolation of @xmath40 to zero result in a critical field of about 30t.,width=302 ] the above mentioned larger gap structure is also badly resolved in a recent tunneling study of smfeaso@xmath1f@xmath2 compounds @xcite .
the authors concluded that interband quasiparticle scattering has a crucial effect on the shape of the tunneling spectra smearing out in particular a larger gap structure in the electronic dos .
taking into account the very short elastic electron mean free path in smfeaso@xmath1f@xmath2 compounds the interband quasiparticle scattering is expected to be quite strong . from another tunneling measurements
@xcite , a distribution of gaps ( conductance peaks ) @xmath59 between 6 and 8mev with a mean value of 7mev was derived , which results in a reduced gap 2@xmath60 .
also from these tunneling spectra , no second gap structure was resolved .
we show in fig.[his ] a histogram of the gap distribution measured for pcs with the pronounced double minimum ar structure .
the distribution has a maximum around @xmath61=6mv and a high energy tail around 10mv .
we connect this large gap value and its broad distribution with the inhomogeneities of the superconducting properties on the film surface due to fluorine loss .
supposing that the critical temperature for the pc with the gap of around 10mev is close to the onset of superconductivity of @xmath62 34k in fig.[rt ] , then @xmath63 will be again close to the bcs value of 3.5 .
[ t ] of smfeaso@xmath1f@xmath2 cu contacts with pronounced double minimum ar structure .
inset shows an example of @xmath8 for pc with @xmath6410mev.,width=302 ]
[ t ] curves of a smfeaso@xmath1f@xmath2 cu contacts measured at 3k ( solid curves ) for a broader bias range .
dashed curves have been measured for the same contacts at higher temperature .
pc in panel ( a ) is the same as shown in fig.[dvdi ] .
right panels : antisymmetric part @xmath65 for the corresponding curves from the left panels .
voltage polarity is given for the film.,width=302 ] a characteristic feature of @xmath8 of pcs with @xmath0feaso@xmath1f@xmath2 is their pronounced asymmetry . from our study of this phenomenon
we conclude that the asymmetry of @xmath8 is present independent of the superconducting features .
fig.[as ] shows @xmath8 curves for a few pcs , where clear ar double minima are observed ( fig.[as]a ) or the superconducting structure is superimposed on a broad maximum ( fig.[as]c ) or no superconducting features , but only a sharp zero - bias maximum is present ( fig.[as]e ) . in all cases ,
the antisymmetric part of @xmath8 shows similar behavior and even the same relative value independent of the drastic difference in @xmath8 shape corresponding to different mechanisms of @xmath8 formation .
such robustness of the asymmetry of @xmath8 testifies that this phenomenon is not related to the pc properties , but mainly determined by the properties of the bulk material ( or the film ) .
one common and plausible reason of @xmath8 asymmetry can be the thermoelectric ( seebeck ) effect if the pc is heated up at increasing bias in the thermal regime @xcite .
it is known that @xmath0feaso@xmath1f@xmath2 compounds have a huge seebeck coefficient at low temperatures which reaches -80@xmath66v@xmath67k@xmath68 for @xmath0=sm just above @xmath15 for a sample with @xmath15=53k @xcite and even more ( -140@xmath66v@xmath67k@xmath68 ) for a sample with @xmath15=36k @xcite ( similar as in our film ) .
taking thermoelectric effects in the case of heterocontacts into account , the @xmath8 asymmetry was explained both for heavy - fermion high - resistive compounds @xcite and for diluted kondo - alloys @xcite , where the seebeck coefficient is strongly enhanced .
it seems that an equilibrium heating of the pc is not the only condition for the appearance of thermoelectric effects .
the electron distribution function in ballistic and diffusive pcs is in a highly nonequilibrium state which can be represented by two fermi spheres shifted from each other by applied voltage e@xmath69 @xcite .
this nonequilibrium electronic state produces nonequilibrium phonons with an effective temperature @xmath70ev/4 @xcite which is close to the temperature ev/3.63 @xcite reached in the thermal regime .
therefore , we suggest that the nonequilibrium state in the pc can also cause a thermoelectric voltage in the case of heterocontacts .
this results in a @xmath8 asymmetry similar as observed in pcs in the thermal regime @xcite .
we also would like to draw attention that asymmetry of the stm spectra , see figs.5 , 6 in ref.@xcite , variates and even has different sign for the spectra with similar structure . since stm spectra reflects in a direct way electronic density of states ( dos ) , then the non - reproducible asymmetry of stm spectra point out also to the non - dos nature of the asymmetry , what strengthen our arguments .
as mentioned above , the investigated lafeaso@xmath1f@xmath2 film has a rather poor quality showing a broad superconducting transition already at zero - field which is comparable with that of the smfeaso@xmath1f@xmath2 film at 9 t ( see fig.[rt ] ) .
additionally , a kink appears in @xmath33 ) at temperatures around 18k .
the inset in fig.[la ] shows @xmath42 of lafeaso@xmath1f@xmath2 cu pc with andreev - reflection minima for varying temperature along with gap behavior evaluated by fitting of the @xmath42 curves .
similar as for the smfeaso@xmath1f@xmath2 film only small gap minima are found .
again , the critical temperature obtained by extrapolating the bcs curve to @xmath40=0 is low , i. e. about 18k ( close to the kink in @xmath33 ) , while superconducting features in @xmath42 are seen even at 25k as shown in fig.[la ] .
we attribute this behavior with the variation of the superconducting properties in the pc region due to the short coherence length and the sample inhomogeneity .
[ t ] ( triangles ) from the fitting of @xmath42 curves shown in the inset .
the position of minima in @xmath42 is marked by stars .
the solid line represents the bcs - like gap behavior .
inset : @xmath42 curves of a lafeaso@xmath1f@xmath2 cu contact ( @xmath38 = 10@xmath39 ) for varying temperature .
, width=302 ]
we investigated the superconducting energy gap in @xmath0feaso@xmath1f@xmath2 ( @xmath0=la , sm ) films by pcar spectroscopy .
the mean value of the reduced superconducting gap 2@xmath71 is found to be close to the bcs value of 3.5 what is in agreement with pcar data reported in @xcite .
a second larger gap feature is hardly to resolve on pcar spectra
. the reason can be strong interband quasiparticle scattering , which smears out the larger gap structure in the electronic dos both in the tunneling @xcite and in the pcar spectra .
note also that all superconducting features in @xmath42 , including these of non - andreev nature , have disappeared above @xmath7 .
we demonstrate that the asymmetry of @xmath8 curves is independent of the shape of the curves or whether superconducting or ar features are present or not in @xmath8 .
therefore , the asymmetry is not related to the spectroscopy but reflects bulk properties of @xmath0feaso@xmath1f@xmath2 .
very probably the asymmetry is caused by the thermoelectric effect .
two of the authors ( yu.g.n .
@xmath72 o.e.k . ) would like to thank the alexander von humboldt foundation for the support and dr .
k. nenkov for the technical assistance .
s.h . and m.k .
would like to acknowledge the financial support by dfg ( under project ha5934/1 - 1 ) .
gonnelli r s , daghero d , tortello m , ummarino g a , stepanov v a , kremer r k , kim j s , zhigadlo n d , karpinski j 2009 physica c * 469 * 512 ; daghero d , tortello m , gonnelli r s , stepanov v a , zhigadlo n d and karpinski j 2009 phys .
b * 80 * 060502(r ) jaroszynski j , riggs s c , hunte f , gurevich a , larbalestier d c , boebinger g s , balakirev f f , migliori a , ren z a , lu w , yang j , shen x l , dong x l , zhao z x , jin r , sefat a s , mcguire m a , sales b c , christen d k , and mandrus d 2008 phys .
b * 78 * 064511 tropeano m , fanciulli c , ferdeghini c , marre d , siri a s , putti m , martinelli a , ferretti m , palenzona a , cimberle m r , mirri c , lupi s , sopracase r , calvani p and perucchi a 2009 supercond .
* 22 * 034004 | point - contact ( pc ) andreev - reflection ( ar ) measurements of the superconducting gap in iron - oxipnictide @xmath0feaso@xmath1f@xmath2 ( @xmath0=la , sm ) films have been carried out .
the value of the gap is distributed in the range @xmath3 510mev ( for @xmath0=sm ) with a maximum in the distribution around 6mev .
temperature dependence of the gap @xmath4 can be fitted well by bcs curve giving reduced gap ratio @xmath5 ( here @xmath6 is the critical temperature from the bcs fit ) . at the same time , an expected second larger gap feature was difficult to resolve distinctly on the ar spectra making determination reliability of the second gap detection questionable .
possible reasons for this and the origin of other features like clear - cut asymmetry in the ar spectra and current regime in pcs are discussed . |
it is well known that the qcd lagrangian with @xmath8 massless flavours has the @xmath9 symmetry spontaneously broken to @xmath10 giving the @xmath11plet of pseudoscalar massless goldstone mesons ( pions ) @xmath12 ( @xmath13 ) .
their interactions at low momenta are described by the chiral lagrangian ( see e. g. @xcite ) @xmath14 where the pion constant @xmath15mev is defined by @xmath16 ( @xmath17 is the pion flavour wave function ) , and dots mean terms with more derivatives .
light quark masses can be included perturbatively , and lead to extra terms in ( [ lpi ] ) .
@xmath9 transformations act as @xmath18 .
let s define @xmath19 , @xmath20 ; it transforms as @xmath21 where @xmath22 is a @xmath23 matrix depending on @xmath24 .
the vector @xmath25 and the axial vector @xmath26 transform as @xmath27 , @xmath28 .
there is a freedom in transformation laws of matter fields such as @xmath29 because it is always possible to multiply them by a matrix depending on @xmath30 .
the only requirement is the correct transformation with respect to @xmath10 ( @xmath31 ) .
it is convenient to choose @xmath32 .
then the covariant derivative @xmath33 transforms as @xmath34 .
covariant derivatives of tensors with more flavour indices are defined similarly .
hadrons with a heavy quark are now successively investigated in the framework of the heavy quark effective theory ( hqet ) ( see @xcite for review and references ) . to the leading order in @xmath35 ,
the heavy quark spin does not interact and can be rotated or switched off at all ( spin flavour and superflavour symmetry ) .
the @xmath36 mesons with a spinless heavy quark form the @xmath37 @xmath8plet @xmath29 .
the @xmath38 baryons can have @xmath39 or @xmath40 giving the scalar flavour
antisymmetric @xmath41plet @xmath42 and the vector flavour symmetric @xmath43plet @xmath44 .
switching the heavy quark spin on gives degenerate @xmath45 and @xmath46 @xmath47 and @xmath48 mesons , @xmath49 @xmath50 baryons , and degenerate @xmath49 and @xmath51 @xmath52 and @xmath53 baryons .
interaction of these ground state heavy hadrons with soft pions is described by the heavy hadron chiral theory @xcite ( see @xcite for review and references ) .
we start from the hhct lagrangian with the heavy quark spin switched off @xcite : @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the @xmath52@xmath50 mass difference .
the possibility of consideration of the @xmath56 interaction in hhct relies on the fact that this difference is small compared to the chiral symmetry breaking scale though formally both of them are of the order of the characteristic hadron mass scale .
the matrix elements of the axial current between heavy hadrons are easily obtained using pcac : @xmath57 where @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath60 are the @xmath61 , @xmath50 , @xmath52 wave functions , and the nonrelativistic normalization of the states and wave functions is assumed .
if we switch the heavy quark spin on , we obtain the usual hhct lagrangian @xcite . the hhct couplings @xmath62 should be in principle calculable in the underlying theory hqet , but this is a difficult nonperturbative problem .
some experimental information is available on @xmath63 and @xmath64 . if we neglect @xmath65 corrections , then @xmath66 , and similarly for @xmath67 ( with the extra @xmath68 ) .
the experimental upper limit @xmath69mev combined with the branching ratio @xmath70 @xcite gives @xmath71 .
a combined analysis of @xmath72 pionic and radiative decays @xcite gives @xmath73@xmath74 .
the recent cleo measurement @xcite of the @xmath75 decays gives @xcite @xmath76 .
the decay @xmath77 is kinematically forbidden ; therefore , the direct measurement of @xmath78 is not possible . in the constituent quark model
, @xmath63 is the axial charge @xmath79 of the constituent light quark in the heavy meson .
moreover , following the folklore definition `` constituent quark is @xmath47 meson minus @xmath80 quark '' , this is the most clear way to define @xmath79 of the constituent quark .
the baryonic couplings @xmath3 are also equal to @xmath79 in this model .
the most naive estimate is @xmath81 ; the nucleon axial charge is @xmath82 in the constituent model , and in order to obtain @xmath83 we should assume @xmath84 .
sum rules @xcite were successfully used to solve many nonperturbative problems in qcd and hqet .
the currents with the quantum numbers of the ground state mesons and baryons with the heavy quark spin switched off are @xmath85})q , \quad \vec{\jmath}\,^{ij}_{\sigma1}=(q^{t(i}c\vec{\gamma}q^{j)})q , \label{curr}\ ] ] where @xmath86 is the spinless static quark field , @xmath87 is the charge conjugation matrix , @xmath88 means @xmath89 transposed , @xmath90 and @xmath91 $ ] mean symmetrization and antisymmetrization .
there are also currents @xmath92 and @xmath93 with the additional @xmath94 .
correlator of the mesonic currents was investigated in @xcite , and of the baryonic ones in @xcite .
the sum rules results are in a qualitative agreement with the constituent quark model : the massless quark propagator plus the quark condensate contribution simulate the constituent quark propagation well enough .
the sum rules method was generalized to the case of a constant external field for calculation of such static characteristics of hadrons as the magnetic moments @xcite .
sum rules in an external axial field were used @xcite for calculation of @xmath95 of light baryons . in the present work we use hqet sum rules in an axial field to estimate @xmath96 .
we introduce the external axial field @xmath97 ( @xmath98 ) by adding the term @xmath99 to the lagrangian .
we are going to calculate correlators of the currents ( [ curr ] ) up to the terms linear in @xmath100 ( these terms are denoted by the subscript @xmath100 ) .
the light quark propagator in the gauge @xmath101 gets the contribution ( whose first term was found in @xcite ) @xmath102 the @xmath103 term in @xmath104 vanishes after the vacuum averaging ; we are not going to calculate gluonic contributions beyond @xmath103 and hence may omit this term .
the axial field induces the quark condensates @xmath105 \nonumber\\ & & \quad { } + \frac{m_1 ^ 2 f_\pi^2}{36 } \left ( 5 x^2 \rlap{/}{a}\,^i_j - 2 a^i_j\cdot x\rlap{/}{x }
\right ) \bigr ] \gamma_5 \bigr\}^\alpha_\beta , \label{qcond}\\ & & { < } q^{ia\alpha}g\tilde{g}\,^a_{\mu\nu}\overline{q}_{jb\beta}{>}_a = - \frac{\left(t^a\right)^a_b}{12c_f n } m_1 ^ 2 f_\pi^2 \left(a^i_{j\mu}\gamma_\nu - a^i_{j\nu}\gamma_\mu \right)^\alpha_\beta , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath106 @xcite is defined by @xmath107 , @xmath108 is the number of colours , @xmath109 ( the sum rule considered in @xcite yields the relation @xmath110 ) .
this formula has been first obtained in @xcite , with the wrong sign of @xmath111 terms ( this sign was changed in @xcite , where a flavour singlet external field was considered ) .
we assume @xmath112 where @xmath113 is the momentum of the field @xmath100 ; in general these formulae should contain @xmath114 .
the @xmath115 coupling was estimated @xcite from the sum rules in an external axial field at a finite @xmath116 with the accuracy up to @xmath111 term .
this last term is incorrect ; however , it is rather small .
the large @xmath116 limit was analyzed in @xcite .
we think that the treatment of the phenomenological side of the sum rule in @xcite is not quite convincing ( see sec .
[ mes ] ) . in our previous work
@xcite , we used an incorrect formula for the induced condensates , which leads to the wrong sign of the @xmath111 term . after correcting this , the result agrees with @xcite . in @xcite ,
the two current product sandwiched between the vacuum and a soft pion was considered ; this is equivalent to the two point sum rules in an external axial field .
both finite and infinite mass case are discussed in this work , with the extra power correction @xmath117 included ( it is rather small ) .
cone sum rules for both finite and infinite quark mass were considered in @xcite ( see also @xcite ) . in this approach ,
the leading term of the correlator and power corrections are determined by the leading and subleading twist pion wave functions at @xmath118 .
these values were determined from qcd sum rules @xcite , and are not so accuratly known as the parameters of the external
field sum rules , @xmath119 and @xmath120 . in the soft pion limit ,
the formulae of @xcite are reproduced ( without the highest power correction ) . the @xmath115 coupling ( at both finite and infinite quark mass )
was also considered in the framework of 3point qcd sum rules , double borel @xcite and double moments @xcite .
it is difficult to compare this approach with the one considered here , because there correlators are determined by a completely different set of contributions ( with even dimensions ) .
perturbative corrections to sum rules were not discussed in the above works . here
we present the next to leading perturbative term in the infinite mass limit . with this term taken into account ,
the correlator used in the @xmath63 sum rule is one of the best known correlators : in addition to the leading term , one perturbative correction and three successive power corrections are known . in spite of this , the sum rule is not very stable ( sec .
[ mes ] ) .
we also discuss sum rules for the baryonic couplings @xmath3 ( sec .
[ bar ] ) , following @xcite with some corrections .
the results for diagonal @xmath50@xmath52 and nondiagonal @xmath52@xmath121 correlators suggest @xmath122 .
the sum rules based on nondiagonal @xmath50@xmath52 and diagonal @xmath52@xmath52 correlators have strong borel parameter dependence and therefore yield no definite predictions .
the correlator of the meson currents ( [ curr ] ) has the @xmath100term @xmath123 that depends only on @xmath124 and not @xmath125 .
the correlator possesses the usual dispersion representation at any @xmath97 .
the meson contribution at @xmath126 is @xmath127 where @xmath128 is the meson energy and @xmath129 ( the usual meson constant is @xmath130 ) .
switching on the external field produces the energy shift @xmath131 ( @xmath132 is the meson spin projection ) .
therefore the meson contribution is @xmath133 where the second term originates from the change of @xmath134 . besides that there is a smooth continuum contribution @xmath135 .
thus we obtain @xmath136 in other words , the lowest meson s contribution in both channels ( fig .
[ fphys]a ) gives the double pole at @xmath137 ; mixed lowest higher state contributions ( fig .
[ fphys]b ) give a single pole at @xmath137 plus a term with a spectral density in the continuum region after the partial fraction decomposition ; higher states contributions ( fig .
[ fphys]c ) have a spectral density in the continuum region only .
we can also calculate the correlator using ope .
gluons do nt interact with the heavy quark in the fixed point gauge @xmath101 .
the leading perturbative diagram ( fig .
[ fmes]a ) vanishes .
in fact , all diagrams with non cut light quark line , including gluon condensate contributions ( fig . [
fmes]b ) and higher loop corrections ( fig .
[ fmes]c ) , vanish .
the reason is that we can anticommute @xmath138 out , and obtain a correlator of two currents ( one of which contains @xmath138 ) in a constant spatial vector field . by virtue of the ward identity
, it is equal to the derivative of the correlator without external field with respect to the spatial momentum flowing along the light quark line .
this is minus derivative with respect to the spatial momentum flowing along the heavy quark line .
but the hqet propagator does not depend on the spatial momentum , and hence the derivative vanishes .
we have checked by a direct calculation , using the technique of @xcite , that the two loop correction ( fig .
[ fmes]c ) vanishes in the case of naive anticommuting @xmath138 ( which is the correct one to use in the weak current ) .
the diagram with cut line ( fig .
[ fmes]c ) gives @xmath139 thus the appearance of @xmath95 of the constituent quark is entirely caused by interaction with the quark condensate .
the first three terms in ( [ opemes ] ) agree with @xcite ; the fourth one is taken from @xcite .
the correlator ( [ opemes ] ) corresponds to the spectral density @xmath140 we have calculated the one loop correction to the leading dimension contribution .
only the one particle irreducible diagram ( fig .
[ fmes]e ) has to be calculated , all the other contributions can be taken from @xcite .
the correlator of bare currents in @xmath141 dimensions is @xmath142 .
\label{bare}\ ] ] after renormalization of the heavy
light hqet currents , it gives the finite result @xmath143 , \nonumber\\ & & \rho_a(\omega ) = \frac{f_\pi^2}{4 } \left[\delta(\omega ) - 6c_f\frac{\alpha_s}{4\pi}\frac{1}{\omega } \right ] .
\label{ren}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in order to obtain the coordinate
space result at @xmath144 , one has to calculate the exact @xmath145dimensional spectral density , take its laplace transform , and go to the limit @xmath146 only at the end : @xmath147 , \label{rad}\ ] ] where @xmath148 is the euler constant . using the technique of @xcite , it is not difficult to calculate the two loop correction to ( [ ren ] ) . however , we decided not to derive the next to next to leading term in the sum rule for @xmath149 , because the sum rule for @xmath134 is known only with the next to leading accuracy @xcite .
as usual , we assume that the excited states contribution is dual to that of the theoretical spectral density ( [ ren ] ) above the effective continuum threshold @xmath150 . equating the phenomenological expression for the correlator to the theoretical one at an imaginary time @xmath151 we obtain the sum rule @xmath152\ , , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath153 the @xmath154dependence of the right hand side of ( [ srmes ] ) coincides with that of @xmath155 , with the accepted accuracy .
the correction appears to be about @xmath156 at @xmath157 gev and therfore is important . as a function of borel parameter @xmath158 : dashed line without the perturbative correction , solid lines with the perturbative correction ( @xmath159mev @xcite , @xmath157gev , @xmath160 , @xmath161 , continuum threshold @xmath162gev , @xmath163gev , @xmath164gev ) . ]
we can multiply ( [ srmes ] ) by @xmath165 and differentiate in @xmath158 in order to exclude @xmath166 .
this procedure is equivalent to finding a plato linear in the borel parameter @xcite .
the result is shown in fig .
[ fgmes ] .
the value of @xmath167 is a subject of controversy in the current literature .
we choose the middle value of @xcite @xmath168 as a reference point ; the sum rule produces @xmath149 , therefore lower values of @xmath134 yield larger values of @xmath63 .
the ope series ( [ srmes ] ) behaves as @xmath169 , so it seems that the expansion is applicable at @xmath170mev .
this is close to the lower bound of the applicability region of the ordinary sum rule @xcite .
the continuum contribution is small until very large values of @xmath158 , because the continuum only appears at the @xmath171 level ( [ ren ] ) . at large @xmath158
the sum rule ( [ srmes ] ) ( without the perturbative correction ) leads to @xmath172 at lower @xmath158 , stability of this sum rule is not very good .
our final numerical estimate is @xmath0 .
the effect of the perturbative correction is moderate , and dependence on the continuum threshold is very week .
the numerical results of the previous works differ from each other largely due to different choices of the value of @xmath134 . expressed in a common scale , they are remarkably similar : @xmath173 @xcite ,
@xmath174 @xcite , @xmath175 @xcite ( in the last result only diviation with borel parameter is indicated and 20% level of accuracy is assumed ) , @xmath176 @xcite .
the perturbative correction was not included in earlier works , and hence they had the continuum spectral density equal to zero .
ovchinnikov @xcite included the first excited state in the phenomenological side , assuming its energy known .
however , he only included @xmath177 in @xmath178 , and not @xmath179 .
we see no justification for such an assumption . taking @xmath180 into account
would add one more unknown parameter @xmath181 to the problem .
correlators of the @xmath182 and @xmath183 currents have the @xmath100terms @xmath184}_{j')}\delta(\vec{x})\pi_a(x_0 ) .
\label{bcor}\end{aligned}\ ] ] if we define @xmath185 , @xmath186 , then the physical states contributions to the correlators ( fig .
[ fphys ] ) are @xmath187 it is impossible to separate the @xmath64 term from the mixed @xmath50excited and @xmath52excited contributions unambiguously .
we can do it approximately if @xmath188 because in such a case partial fraction decomposition of the first term would give large contributions to @xmath189 with the opposite signs while the natural scale of @xmath190 in ( [ bphys ] ) is @xmath191 .
this is not a defect of the sum rule but the uncertainty inherent to @xmath64 which can be defined only when @xmath55 is small compared to the chiral symmetry breaking scale .
we choose to require @xmath192 ; the choices @xmath193 or @xmath194 would be equally good .
the baryonic correlators in the ope framework are described by the diagrams in fig .
the diagrams fig .
[ fbar]a c with the non cut quark line interacting with the axial field vanish due to ( [ prop ] ) .
we use the factorization approximation for the four quark condensate in fig .
[ fbar]e . in this approximation
two diagonal correlators @xmath195 and @xmath196 coincide in both @xmath182 and @xmath183 cases , as well as @xmath197 and @xmath198 .
this is similar to the usual heavy baryon sum rules @xcite , and confirms the observation that @xmath199 and @xmath200 within the factorization approximation to the sum rules .
only even dimensional condensates contribute to the diagonal @xmath182 and the nondiagonal @xmath183 correlators : @xmath201 , \label{opebar1}\ ] ] where @xmath202 ( this term comes from the diagram fig .
[ fbar]f ) . only odd
dimensional condensates contribute to the nondiagonal @xmath182 and the diagonal @xmath183 correlators : @xmath203 .
\label{opebar2}\ ] ] these correlators correspond to the spectral densities @xmath204 , \quad \rho_a(\omega)=-\frac{2n!\,{<}\overline{q}q{>}\omega}{3n\pi^2 } \label{rho}\ ] ] ( plus @xmath205 and its derivatives ) .
we use the standard continuum model @xmath206 . equating the ope ( [ opebar1 ] , [ opebar2 ] ) and the spectral representation at @xmath151
, we obtain the sum rules @xmath207\\ & & \quad=-\frac{4{<}\overline{q}q{>}}{\pi^2}e^2 \left[f_1\left(\varepsilon_c / e\right ) + \frac{\pi^2f_\pi^2}{2e^2 } \left(1-\frac{m_0 ^ 2}{16e^2}-\frac{5m_1 ^ 2}{36e^2}\right ) \right ] , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath208\\ & & \quad=-\frac{4{<}\overline{q}q{>}}{\pi^2}e^2 \left[f_1\left(\varepsilon_c / e\right ) + \frac{\pi^2f_\pi^2}{2e^2 } \left(1-\frac{m_0 ^ 2}{16e^2}-\frac{5m_1 ^ 2}{36e^2}\right ) \right ] , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath209 .
( solid and dashed lines ) : a diagonal @xmath182 and nondiagonal @xmath183 sum rules ; b nondiagonal @xmath182 and diagonal @xmath183 sum rules.,title="fig : " ] ( solid and dashed lines ) : a diagonal @xmath182 and nondiagonal @xmath183 sum rules ; b
nondiagonal @xmath182 and diagonal @xmath183 sum rules.,title="fig : " ] now we can start the numerical analysis .
we adopt the energies and residues of @xmath50 and @xmath52 obtained from the hqet sum rules @xcite : @xmath210 we assume that the effective continuum threshold for the @xmath100terms of the @xmath52@xmath52 correlators is the same as without the external field : @xmath211gev ; for the @xmath50@xmath52 correlators we use @xmath212gev . fig .
[ fgbar]a shows the results for @xmath213 and @xmath214 obtained from the diagonal @xmath52@xmath52 and the nondiagonal @xmath50@xmath52 correlators ( the first formulae in ( [ srule ] ) and ( [ srule1 ] ) ) .
the spectral density ( [ rho ] ) behaves like @xmath215 , and hence the continuum contribution to the sum rules ( [ srbar ] ) quickly grows : it is equal to the result at @xmath216mev and is three times larger than the result at @xmath217mev .
if we assume that the uncertainty in the continuum contribution is , e. g. , 30% , then we ca nt trust the sum rules at @xmath218mev .
the lower bound of the applicability region is determined by the convergence of the ope series for the correlators .
it behaves like @xmath219 for the @xmath52@xmath52 correlator ; in the @xmath50@xmath52 case @xmath220mev enters instead of @xmath221mev .
it seems that ope should be applicable at @xmath222mev .
the sum rules in this window are unstable and therefore yield no definite predictions .
[ fgbar]b shows the results for @xmath213 and @xmath223gev@xmath224 ) obtained from the nondiagonal @xmath52@xmath52 and the diagonal @xmath50@xmath52 correlators ( the second formulae in ( [ srule ] ) and ( [ srule1 ] ) ) .
the spectral density ( [ rho ] ) behaves like @xmath225 , and the continuum contribution grows not so quickly : it is equal to the result at @xmath226gev and is three times larger than the result at @xmath227gev .
the ope series behaves like @xmath228 $ ] , and the applicability region starts at a larger @xmath158 .
stability of these sum rules is quite good .
the sum rules give @xmath122 .
* in conclusion * , the meson sum rule in an external axial field , with the perturbative correction and three successive power corrections , gives the value @xmath229 , which is much lower than the constituent quark model expectation @xmath2 unless a substantially lower value of @xmath134 is used .
the sum rules for @xmath3 following from nondiagonal @xmath52@xmath52 and diagonal @xmath50@xmath52 baryon correlators in an external axial field suggest @xmath6 , while diagonal @xmath52@xmath52 and nondiagonal @xmath50@xmath52 baryon sum rules have too large uncertainties .
* acknowledgements*. we are grateful to v. m. belyaev , v. m. braun , v. l. chernyak , and a. yu . khodjamirian for useful discussions . a. g. g.s work was supported in part by bmbf under contract no .
06 mz865 ; he is grateful to institut fr physik , mainz , for hospitality during the final stage of the work .
o. i. y.s work was supported in part by bmbf under contract no .
05 7wz91p ( 0 ) .
m. b. wise , _ phys .
_ * d45 * ( 1992 ) r2188 ; + g. burdman and j. f. donoghue , _ phys .
_ * b280 * ( 1992 ) 287 ; +
cheng , c .- y .
cheung , g .-
lin , y. c. lin , and h .- l .
yu , _ phys .
_ * d46 * ( 1992 ) 1148 ; ( e ) * d55 * ( 1997 ) 5851 ; + p. cho , _ phys . lett .
_ * b285 * ( 1992 ) 145 ; _ nucl .
_ * b396 * ( 1993 ) 183 ; ( e ) * b421 * ( 1994 ) 683 .
cho and h. georgi , _ phys .
_ * b296 * ( 1992 ) 408 ; ( e ) * b300 * ( 1993 ) 410 ; + j. f. amundson , c. g. boyd , e. jenkins , m. luke , a. v. manohar , j. l. rosner , m. j. savage , and m. b. wise , _ phys .
_ * b296 * ( 1992 ) 415 ; + h .- y .
cheng , c .- y .
cheung , g .-
lin , y. c. lin , t .-
yan , and h .- l .
yu , _ phys .
_ * d47 * ( 1993 ) 1030 . | we estimate the couplings in the heavy hadron chiral theory ( hhct ) lagrangian from the qcd sum rules in an external axial field . we take into account the perturbative correction to the meson correlator in the infinite mass limit . with the perturbative correction and three successive power corrections ,
the meson correlator in an axial field becomes one of the best known correlators . in spite of this , the corresponding sum rule is not very stable .
it yields the result @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the central value of the heavy meson decay constant with the perturbative correction @xcite .
this result is surprisingly low as compared with the constituent quark model estimate @xmath2 .
the sum rules for @xmath3 following from nondiagonal @xmath4 and diagonal @xmath5 baryon correlators in an external axial field suggest @xmath6 , while diagonal @xmath4 and nondiagonal @xmath5 baryon sum rules have too large uncertainties .
wue / itp97016 + hep - ph/9706421 couplings of heavy hadrons with soft pions + from qcd sum rules + a. g. grozin@xmath7 + _ institut fr physik , johannes gutenberg universitt , _ + _ staudinger weg 7 , d55099 mainz , germany _ + o. i. yakovlev@xmath7 + _ institut fr theoretische physik ii , bayrische maximilians universitt _ , + _ am hubland , d97074 wrzburg , germany
_ @xmath7 on leave from budker institute of nuclear physics , novosibirsk 630090 , russia . |
the classification of quantum deformations of lorentz symmetries described by classical r - matrices was given firstly by zakrzewski @xcite ( see also @xcite ) , and has been further extended to the classification of classical r - matrices for poincar algebra in @xcite .
the classification of dual hopf - algebraic quantum deformations of poincar group were presented in @xcite .
subsequently , the infinitesimal r - matrix description of the deformations of poincar algebra presented in @xcite has been extended in several papers to finite hopf - algebraic deformations , with conclusive results obtained in @xcite .
because majority of studied deformations were triangular , i.e. described by the twist deformations , they permitted ( see e.g. @xcite ) to derive explicit formulas for the non - commutative algebra of deformed space - time coordinates by the use of so - called star product realizations .
the study of deformations of spacetime supersymmetries and the corresponding deformed superspaces were less systematic , related mostly either with the supersymmetrization of simplest abelian canonical twist deformation of poincar symmetries @xcite@xcite or with the supersymmetric extension of @xmath2-deformation @xcite .
the supersymmetrization of such a canonical twist @xmath3 for @xmath4 poincare superalgebra looks as follows @xmath5 where @xmath6 , @xmath7 and @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the @xmath10-grading of the superalgebra element @xmath11 with definite grading .
the classification of the supersymmetric triangular deformations for finite - dimensional simple lie superalgebras was firstly given in a mathematical framework by one of the present authors @xcite ; one should add also that already long time ago the nontriangular drinfeld - jimbo deformation has been provided for all complex finite - dimensional simple lie superalgebras in @xcite but without discussion of its real forms .
recently however ( see @xcite ) the classification of poincar r - matrices in @xcite has been extended to @xmath12 poincare and euclidean @xcite supersymmetries , which provided physically important deformations of non - semisimple lie superalgebras .
new result in this paper is the presentation of the list of d=4 n=2 classical super - poincar and super - euclidean r - matrices .
we add that there were also considered twisted euclidean @xmath4 and @xmath13 supersymmetries ( see e.g. @xcite ) but only under the assumption that the fermionic part of the twist factor was a supersymmetric enlargement of canonical abelian twist ( see ( [ 1a1 ] ) ) . in our recent paper by considering partial classification of @xmath4 complex @xmath14matrices and their pseudoreal ( euclidean ) and real ( poincar ) forms @xcite we have obtained large class of @xmath4 supersymmetric twists which provide new d=4 superspaces with lie - algebraic deformation of bosonic spacetime sector . in quantum deformations
approach the basic primary notion is the hopf - algebraic deformation of ( super)symmetries which subsequently implies the modification of ( super)spacetime algebra .
it follows that for classifying the possible deformations of ( super)symmetries one should list the deformations of corresponding hopf ( super)algebras . in non - supersymmetric case the most complete discussion of such hopf - algebraic approach to field theories deformed by canonical twists @xmath3 ( see ( [ 1a1 ] ) ) was presented in @xcite ; for poincar and euclidean supersymmetries such way of introducing deformations via supertwist , firstly advocated in @xcite , was presented recently in @xcite . in present paper
we supplement classical @xmath13 super poincar @xmath14matrices which generate the corresponding n=2 supersymmetric twist ( triangular ) deformations . subsequently using @xmath15product formulation @xcite
one can provide effective formulae for the description of quantum - deformed n=2 superspaces .
we add that the particular supersymmetric @xmath13 twist deformations considered in earlier studies @xcite@xcite appear as particular cases in the list of n=2 deformations presented in this paper . in sect . 2 and
3 we shall consider in some detail inhomogeneous @xmath16 algebra with its real forms and the n=1,2 superextensions ; in sect . 4 and 5 we present our partial results describing n=1,2 supersymmetric poincar and euclidean r - matrices .
more detailed plan of our paper is the following : in sect .
2 we shall consider complex @xmath17 and inhomogeneous @xmath18 algebras and its @xmath4 susy extension .
we shall also provide their real and pseudoreal forms defining @xmath19 poincare , euclidean and kleinian algebras and corresponding @xmath4 real / pseudoreal superalgebras . in sect .
3 we shall discuss complex @xmath13 superalgebras with two central charges and odd sector described by @xmath20 independent complex supercharges ( @xmath21 , @xmath22 ) . further following @xcite@xcite and by using suitable conjugations or pseudoconjugations ( real or pseudoreal forms )
we shall describe @xmath13 real poincar and kleinian superalgebras as well as complex selfconjugate euclidean superalgebras . in order to compare with earlier results for n=0 ( nonsupersymmetric case ) and n=1 we shall provide in sect .
4 the tables of classical poincar ( super)-r - matrices given in @xcite and @xcitematrices obtained by zakrzewski @xcite there is one class which satisfies modified yb equation .
we shall consider 20 classes of @xmath14matrices which lead to triangular deformations . ] . in sect .
5 we present new results : we use the set of real poincar classical r - matrices provided by zakrzewski in @xcite , and describe the ones which do have n=2 supersymmetric extension ; we present also n=2 d=4 euclidean supersymmetric r - matrices . finally in sect .
6 we present final remarks . in appendix
a we shall outline the general theory of conjugations and pseudoconjugations for lie superalgebras .
the list of @xmath13 complex supersymmetric r - matrices and their kleinian @xmath23 real counterparts satisfying suitable ( pseudo)reality conditions will be presented in our next publications .
it is known that there are four real forms of complex orthogonal lie algebras @xmath26 corresponding to three different nondegenerate @xmath19 metric signatures and the fourth one which can be obtained by imposing quaternionic structure ( see e.g. @xcite ) : \i ) @xmath27 euclidean case \ii ) @xmath28 lorentzian case can be described by complex conjugated generators of @xmath29 and @xmath30 ( see ( [ bch1 ] ) ) . ]
\iii ) @xmath31 @xmath32 @xmath33 kleinian case \iv ) @xmath34 @xmath35 quaternionic case .
+ the quaternionic origin of the fourth real form follows from isomorphism with orthogonal quaternionic algebras @xcite @xmath36 in first three cases ( euclidean , lorentzian , kleinian ) one can lift the corresponding real forms to inhomogeneous algebra @xmath0 , where the complex abelian generators describe complexified momentum fourvectors ( @xmath37 ) .
in fourth case one can introduce the momenta as complex @xmath38 vectors described by second order fourcomponent @xmath39 complex spinors .
the corresponding inhomogeneous algebra @xmath40 can be endowed with quaternionic structure if we perform the following contraction of the quaternionic symmetric coset ( see also ( [ quater1 ] ) ) @xmath41 where @xmath42 has eight real dimensions , i.e. the dimensionality of @xmath43 is not reduced .
we add that the inhomogeneous @xmath38 algebra does not play known significant role in the description of physically relevant @xmath19 geometries .
the most known real form of @xmath25 is the @xmath19 poincar lie algebra @xmath44 generated by the poincar fourmomenta @xmath45 and six lorentz rotations @xmath46 ( @xmath47 ) and looks as follows : @xmath48\!\ ! & = \!\ ! & i\bigl(g_{\nu\lambda}\,l_{\mu\rho}- g_{\nu\rho}\,l_{\mu\lambda}+g_{\mu\rho}\,l_{\nu\lambda}-g_{\mu\lambda}\ , l_{\nu\rho}\bigr)~,\qquad l_{\mu\nu}\!\ ! & = \!\ ! & -l_{\nu\mu}~,\\[12pt ] [ l_{\mu\nu},\,p_{\rho}]\!\ ! & = \!\ ! & i\bigl(g_{\nu\rho}\,p_{\mu}- g_{\mu\rho}\,p_{\nu}\bigr)~,\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\quad\ ; [ p_{\mu},\,p_{\nu}]\!\!&=\!\!&0~ , \end{array}\ ] ] where @xmath49 is the minkowski ( lorentzian ) metric .
if we replace in ( [ 2a1 ] ) such a metric by the euclidean one i.e. @xmath50 , one gets the @xmath51 euclidean algebra @xmath52 , described by euclidean generators @xmath53 : @xmath54\!\ ! & = \!\ !
& -i\bigl(\delta_{\nu\lambda}\,\cal{l}_{\mu\rho}- \delta_{\nu\rho}\,\cal{l}_{\mu\lambda}+\delta_{\mu\rho}\,\cal{l}_{\nu\lambda}-\delta_{\mu\lambda}\ , \cal{l}_{\nu\rho}\bigr)~,\qquad \cal{l}_{\mu\nu}\!\ ! & = \!\ ! & -\cal{l}_{\nu\mu}~ , \\[12pt ] [ \cal{l}_{\mu\nu},\,\cal{p}_{\rho}]\!\ ! & = \!\ ! & -i\bigl(\delta_{\nu\rho}\,\cal{p}_{\mu}- \delta_{\mu\rho}\,\cal{p}_{\nu}\bigr)~,\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\quad\ ; [ \cal{p}_{\mu},\,\cal{p}_{\nu}]\!\!&=\!\!&0~. \end{array}\ ] ] the poincar algebra can be obtained from euclidean one by the following substitution ( @xmath55 ) @xmath56 or equivalently @xmath57 , @xmath58 , where @xmath59 and @xmath60 , @xmath61 .
the imaginary unit occurring in ( [ 2a2 ] ) effectively change in ( [ 2a1 ] ) the euclidean metric @xmath62 into the lorentzian one @xmath63 .
if we choose the metric with kleinian ( neutral ) signature @xmath64 one gets lie algebra @xmath65 , which can be obtained by the following change of the euclidean generators @xmath66 for describing the @xmath38 algebra with quaternionic structure one should split the real @xmath17 generators as follows @xmath67 and multiply the coset generators by `` @xmath68 '' .
in order to embed three cases of inhomogeneous algebras into unified framework one can consider the complex @xmath19 euclidean algebra @xmath69 and introduce its three real forms ( euclidean , poincar and kleinian ) .
these real forms are introduced with the help of three non - isomorphic antilinear involutive conjugations @xmath70 @xmath71 , where @xmath72 .
the following reality conditions imposed on the generators of @xmath73 ( @xmath74 ) @xmath75\label{2a5 } \cal{l}_{\mu\nu}^\ddagger = \cal{l}_{\mu\nu } , \qquad \cal{p}_{\mu}^\ddagger = \cal{p}_{\mu } \qquad \hbox{euclidean case } \\[12pt]\label{2a6 } { \cal l}^\oplus_{1\ , 3 } = { \cal l}_{1\ , 3},\quad { \cal l}_{2\ , 4}^\oplus = { \cal l}_{2\,4 } , \quad { \cal l}_{i\ , k}^\oplus = -{\cal l}_{i\ , k}\quad { \cal p}_i^\oplus = { \cal p}_i , \quad { \cal p}_{k}^\oplus = -{\cal p}_{k } \qquad \hbox{kleinian case}\end{aligned}\ ] ] define respectively real @xmath19 poincar , euclidean and kleinian algebras .
we observe that first two real structures ( conjugations ) coincide on @xmath76 subalgebra .
another convenient basis in complex @xmath77 algebra is obtained by introducing the pair of chiral ( left - handed ) and anti - chiral ( right - handed ) generators : @xmath78 describing two complex commuting @xmath79 subalgebras @xmath80 = i \epsilon_{ijk } m^{\pm}_k , & & [ m^\pm_r , m^\mp_s]=0 \ , , \\[10pt ] \label{bch1bis } \qquad [ m^{\pm}_r , { \cal p}_{s } ] = { i \over 2}(\epsilon_{rst}{\cal p}_t\mp \delta_{rs}{\cal p}_4 ) , & & [ m^{\pm}_r , { \cal p}_{4}]=\pm { i \over 2}{\cal p}_r \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the reality conditions ( [ 2a4][2a6 ] ) imposed on the complex generators @xmath81 look as follows ( we provide also the fourth reality condition related with quaternionic structure ; @xmath82 ) @xmath83\label{bch3 } ( m^{\pm}_r)^\ddagger = m^{\pm}_r \qquad\qquad \qquad \hbox{euclidean case } \\[12pt]\label{bch4 } ( m^{\pm}_{i})^\oplus = - m^{\pm}_{i } , \qquad ( m^{\pm}_2)^\oplus = m^{\pm } _ 2 \qquad \qquad \hbox{kleinian case } \\[12pt]\label{bch4x } ( m^{+}_r)^{\tilde{\oplus } } = m^{+}_r , \qquad ( m^{-}_i)^{\tilde{\oplus } } = - m^{-}_i , \quad ( m^{-}_2)^{\tilde\oplus } = m^{-}_2 \ \
\qquad \hbox{quaternionic case } \end{aligned}\ ] ] further we shall consider the supersymmetric n=1,2 extensions of the euclidean and poincar real forms ( [ bch2][bch4 ] ) .
the complexifications of real poincar , euclidean and kleinian algebras are equvalent , and one can consider as well in place of reality constraints ( [ 2a4])([2a6 ] ) the real forms of complexified poincar or kleinian algebras in order to provide the real poincar , euclidean and kleinian algebras .
it is quite useful to work further with lorentzian ( poincar ) canonical basis which is obtained after realification of the cartan - chevaley basis of @xmath84 .
be the cartan - weyl basis of @xmath85 with the commutation relations in the first line of ( [ bor4.2 ] ) . setting @xmath86 we obtain all commutation relations ( [ bor4.2 ] ) .
the real lie algebra @xmath87 generated by the elements @xmath88 with the defining relations ( [ bor4.1 ] ) is called realification of @xmath84 . ] in such a basis lorentz generators are defined as follows ( see @xcite ) @xmath89 h'&\!\!=&\!\!im_3\ , \qquad\;\ ; e'_{\pm}&\!\!=&\!\!i(m_1\pm n_2)\ , .
\end{array}\end{aligned}\ ] ] one obtains the following description of @xmath19 lorentz algebra @xmath90\!\!&=\!\!&\pm e_{\pm}^{},\qquad [ e_{+}^{},\,e_{-}^{}]\!\!&=\!\!&2h , \\[6pt ] [ h,\,e'_{\pm}]\!\!&=\!\!&\pm e'_{\pm}~,\qquad[h',\,e_{\pm}]\!\!&=\!\!&\pm e'_{\pm},\qquad [ e_{\pm}^{},\,e'_{\mp}]\;=\;\pm2h ' , \\[6pt ] [ h',\,e'_{\pm}]\!\!&=\!\!&\mp e_{\pm}^{},\qquad [ e'_{+},\,e'_{-}]\!\!&=\!\!&-2h \ , .
\end{array}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the fourmomenta generators with the components @xmath91 extend ( [ bor4.2 ] ) to the real poincar algebra as follows @xmath92&\!\!=&\!\!\pm p_{\pm},\qquad[h,\,p_{i}]&\!\!=&\!\!0\quad\;\;(i=1,2),\quad&&\qquad & & \\[5pt ] [ e_{\pm},\,p_{\pm}]&\!\!=&\!\!0,\qquad\;\;\;[e_{\pm},\,p_{\mp}]&\!\!=&\!\!2p_{1},\quad\;\ ; [ e_{\pm},\,p_{1}]&\!\!=&\!\!p_{\pm},\quad\;\;[e_{\pm},\,p_{2}]&\!\!=&\!\!0 \ , , \end{array}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath93&\!\!=&\!\!0,\qquad\ ; [ h',\,p_{1}]&\!\!=&\!\!-p_{2},\qquad [ h',\,p_{2}]&\!\!=&\!\!p_{1},\qquad\qquad\quad & & \\[5pt ] [ e_{\pm}',\,p_{\pm}]&\!\!=&\!\!0,\qquad[e_{\pm}',\,p_{\mp}]&\!\!=&\!\!\mp2p_{2},\quad \;\;[e_{\pm}',\,p_{1}]&\!\!=&\!\!0,\qquad[e_{\pm}',\,p_{2}]&\!\!=&\!\!\mp p_{\pm}\ , .
\end{array}\end{aligned}\ ] ] three reality conditions imposed on these canonical generators are now @xmath94 @xmath95 p_{\pm}^{\ddagger}&\!\!=&\!\!-p_{\mp},\quad p_{i}^{\ddagger}\;=\;p_{i}\quad ( i=1,2 ) \qquad\qquad\qquad\hbox { ( euclidean case ) } \end{array}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath96 p_{\pm}^{\oplus}&\!\!=&\!\!-p_{\pm},\quad \tilde{p}{}_{\pm}^{\oplus}\;=-\ ; \tilde{p}{}_{\pm}^\oplus , \quad \tilde{p}{}_{\pm } \;=\ ; p_{1 } \pm i p_2\qquad\quad\hbox { ( kleinian case ) } \end{array}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in this paper we shall consider the superalgebra generators in purely algebraic way , without reference to concrete realizations . in this subsection
we shall recall the complex @xmath19 @xmath4 euclidean superalgebra ( see e.g. @xcite ) describing simple ( @xmath4 ) supersymmetrization of @xmath98 ( inhomogeneous @xmath16 ) complex algebra .
such superalgebra is obtained by adding to the generator of complex @xmath19 euclidean algebra @xmath99 four independent complex supercharges @xmath100 transforming as fundamental representations under `` left '' and `` right '' internal symmetry groups @xmath101 and @xmath102 has a spinorial covering @xmath103 .
the @xmath104 spinors have undotted spinorial indices , and dotted indices characterize @xmath105 spinors .
these two groups are also called chiral ( left ) and antichiral ( right ) projections of @xmath106 group . ] .
the supercharges @xmath107 extend the @xmath19 complex euclidean algebra ( [ 2a3 ] ) by the following algebraic relations @xmath108 \label{2s211 } & \left [ { \mathcal l}_{\mu\nu } , q_\alpha \right ] = -(\sigma^e_{\ \mu\nu})_{\alpha}^{\
\ \beta } \ , q_\beta \qquad \qquad \qquad \left [ { \mathcal l}_{\mu\nu } , \bar q_{\dot{\alpha } } \right ] = \bar q_{\dot{\beta}}({\tilde{\sigma}}^e_{\ \mu\nu})^{\dot{\beta}}_{\ \dot{\alpha } } \\ & \qquad \quad \left [ { \mathcal p}_\mu , q_\alpha \right ] = \left [ { \mathcal p}_\mu , \bar q_{\dot{\alpha } } \right ] = 0 \ , , \label{2s212 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the euclidean sigma matrices @xmath109 are expressed by standard pauli matrices @xmath110 as follows @xmath111 and satisfy the known reality conditions under hermitean matrix conjugation @xmath112 the matrices @xmath113 and @xmath114 describe the following realizations of the pair of commuting @xmath115 algebras @xmath116 the complexified euclidean fourmomenta @xmath117 transform under the complex euclidean rotations @xmath118 described by the product of two commuting lorentz groups @xmath119 as follows ( @xmath120 , @xmath121 ) @xmath122 where @xmath123 and @xmath124 .
finally one can check that the relations ( [ 2s210][2s212 ] ) are invariant under the complex rescaling transformation ( c is a complex number ) @xmath125 the rescaling ( [ 2s221 ] ) is described by @xmath126 abelian group and represents the one - parameter complex internal symmetries of @xmath19 simple complex euclidean superalgebra .
the n=1 internal @xmath127 generator @xmath128 satisfies the algebraic relation @xmath129=q_\alpha \qquad [ t , \bar q_{\dot\alpha}]=-\bar q_{\dot\alpha } \ , .\ ] ] the reality conditions ( [ 2a5 ] ) defining @xmath19 euclidean space - time algebra @xmath130 can be extended to the sector of euclidean spinorial supercharges if we use the corresponding spinorial covering group @xmath131 which requires a pair of independent two - component complex @xmath132 spinors .
this property of doubling of @xmath19 euclidean spinorial components in comparison with standard relativistic @xmath19 case leads to the known conclusion that contrary to the poincar case the four - component real ( majorana ) euclidean spinors do not exist . in the algebraic framework one can however extend in odd supercharges
sector the conjugation ( [ 2a5 ] ) as the pseudoconjugation ( see appendix a , ( [ 3s3b]b ) ) which should be consistent with @xmath4 complex euclidean algebra ( [ 2s210][2s212 ] ) under the assumption that the generators @xmath133 , @xmath134 are real euclidean , i.e. satisfy the reality conditions ( [ 2a5 ] ) . the @xmath4 pseudoconjugation of euclidean supercharges is an involution of fourth order ( see also ( [ 3s3b]b ) ) satisfying the relation @xmath135 and it look as follows @xcite @xmath136 it can be shown that the map @xmath137 leaves the superalgebra ( [ 2s210][2s212 ] ) invariant provided that we choose the parameter @xmath138 ( see appendix , a ( [ 3s31 ] ) ) in accordance with the relation @xmath139 we obtain the following two cases : @xmath140 ( standard choice ) in this case the product of odd ( fermionic operators @xmath141 which are odd powers of supercharges are conjugated as follows @xmath142 and leads to standard supersymmetry scheme with pseudoconjugation @xmath143 which can be represented on complex grassmannian variables @xmath144 as the complex conjugation @xmath145 .
it should be added that all applications of pseudoconjugations to the description of real @xmath4 euclidean susy use the case @xmath146 ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
@xmath147 ( exotic choice ) in this case the product of odd ( fermionic ) operators @xmath141 which are odd powers of supercharges and grassmann variables are conjugated as follows @xmath148 such choice leads to nonstandard supersymmetry scheme , which can be realized in complex superspace described by odd grassmann variables @xmath149 , @xmath150 with the products transformating under conjugation in the nonstandard way @xmath151 such type of grassmann variables was considered as mathematically consistent choice in @xcite but it has not been applied in the literature to describe the physical supersymmetric systems , therefore exotic . in the exotic case the conjugation @xmath152 ( antilinear antiautomorphism of second order ) in bosonic sector of the euclidean superalgebra defining the reality condition ( [ 2a5 ] )
is lifted in fermionic sector of supercharges to the antilinear antiautomorphism of fourth order defining pseudoconjugation .
one can show that for both values @xmath153 in the scaling transformations ( [ 2s221 ] ) the parameter @xmath154 should be real , what means that the invariance of ( [ 2s222b ] ) under the pseudoconjugation ( [ 3s312 ] ) is valid if @xmath155 , i.e. @xmath4 internal symmetry @xmath156 is reduced to @xmath157 for pseudoreal @xmath4 euclidean superalgebra .
@xmath4 poincar superalgebra is obtained from the relations ( [ 2s210][2s212 ] ) after imposing the following extension of the poincar reality condition ( [ 2a4 ] ) to the supercharges sector @xmath158 if @xmath159 the formula ( [ sp2_0 ] ) describe conjugation and lead to standard @xmath4 real poincar supersymmetry .
if @xmath160 we get @xmath161 and relations ( [ sp2_0 ] ) describe pseudoconjugation ( pseudoreality condition ) defining exotic supersymmetry with grassmann variables satisfying relations ( [ x2.39 ] ) . after introducing @xmath162 , @xmath163 ( see [ 2a2 ] ) one gets from ( [ 2s210][2s212 ] ) the well - known n=1 poincar superalgebra with the pair of supercharges represented by two - component complex weyl spinors @xmath164\!\!&=\!\!&[p_\mu^{},\,\bar{q}_{\dot{\alpha}a}]\;\;=\;\;0 \ , , \\[7pt ] \{q^{}_{\alpha},\,q^{}_{\beta}\}\!\!&=\!\!&0,\qquad\qquad\qquad \{\bar{q}_{\dot{\alpha}},\,\bar{q}_{\dot{\beta}}\}\!\!&=\!\ ! & 0 \ , , \\[7pt ] [ l_{\mu\nu},\,q^{}_{\alpha}]\!\ ! & = \!\!&-\displaystyle{(\sigma_{\mu\nu})_{\alpha}}^{\beta}q^{a}_{\beta},\qquad [ l_{\mu\nu},\,\bar{q}_{\dot{\alpha}a}]\!\ ! & = \!\!&\displaystyle\bar{q}_{\dot{\beta}a}{(\tilde{\sigma}_{\mu\nu})}_{\dot{\alpha}}^{\dot{\beta } } \ , , \end{array}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the lorentzian @xmath165matrices are defined as follows @xmath166 \sigma_{\mu\nu } & = & ( \sigma_{ij}\;=\;\sigma^{e}_{ij},\;\;\sigma_{4i}\;=\;- i \sigma^{e}_{4i})]\ , , \\[7pt ] \tilde{\sigma}_{\mu\nu } & = & ( \tilde{\sigma}_{ij}\;=\;\widetilde\sigma^{e}_{ij},\;\;\tilde\sigma_{4i}\;=\;- i \tilde\sigma^{e}_{4i } ) \ , .
\end{array}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is easy to see that for @xmath153 the pair of relations ( [ 2s222b ] ) is invariant under the conjugation ( [ sp2_0 ] ) if @xmath167 , i.e. the internal symmetry of @xmath4 poincar supersymmetry is described by the restriction of @xmath168 to @xmath169 .
the @xmath4 kleinian @xmath23 superalgebra is obtained after the following extension of the reality condition ( [ 2a6 ] ) to the supercharges sector @xmath170 i.e. the supercharges ( [ sp2_0k ] ) form a pair of respectively @xmath171 and @xmath172 real spinors . imposing on complex superalgebra ( [ 2s210][2s212 ] ) the reality condition ( [ sp2_0k ] ) one gets the following real superalgebra @xmath173 where @xmath174 and @xmath175 with @xmath176 describing @xmath177 real @xmath165matrices @xmath178 the inhomogeneous @xmath23 algebra can be described more conveniently if we use the formulation of complex euclidean algebra @xmath98 using formulae ( [ bch1][bch1bis ] ) . in kleinian case
the `` complex '' generators @xmath179 become the set of real generators ( i.e. generating real lie superalgebra with real structure constants ) @xmath180\!\!&=\!\!&-\frac{1}{2}{(\tilde{\sigma}_{r})_{\alpha}}^{\beta}q^{a}_{\beta},\qquad\ ; [ m^{(-)}_{r},\,q^{a}_{\alpha}]\!\!&=\!\!&0 , \\[7pt ] [ m^{(+)}_{r},\,\bar q_{\dot{\alpha}a}]\!\!&=\!\!&0,\qquad\qquad\qquad\quad [ m^{(-)}_{r},\,\bar q_{\dot{\alpha}a}]\!\!&=\!\!&\frac{1}{2}\bar q_{\dot{\beta}a}{(\tilde{\sigma}_{r})^{\dot{\beta}}}_{\dot{\alpha } } \ , .
\end{array } \end{aligned}\ ] ] we add that similarly as in poincar case , the choice @xmath181 leads to standard @xmath4 kleinian supersymmetry with ( [ sp2_0k ] ) describing conjugation @xmath182 ( reality conditions ) , and if @xmath183 one gets ( see also sec .
2.3.1 ) exotic supersymmetry with pseudoconjugation implying the exotic antiautomorphism which leads to relations ( [ x2.39 ] )
. finally for both values of @xmath184 the relations ( [ 2s222b ] ) are consistent with the reality condition ( [ sp2_0k ] ) if @xmath185 , i.e. real @xmath4 kleinian symmetry is endowed with @xmath186 internal symmetry .
in this subsection we shall describe @xmath13 superization of complex inhomogeneous @xmath16 algebra .
basic n=1 relations ( [ 2s210 ] ) are extended to @xmath13 as follows ( @xmath188 ) : @xmath189 \nonumber \\[-6pt ] \label{2s2111 } \left\ { q^a_\alpha , q^b_{{\beta}}\right\}=\epsilon_{\alpha\beta}\epsilon^{ab}z\ , , & & \left\ { \bar q_{\dot{\alpha}a } , \bar q_{\dot{\beta}b}\right\ } = \epsilon_{\dot{\alpha}\dot{\beta}}\epsilon_{ab}\tilde z \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath190 describe a pair of complex scalar central charges .
the relations ( [ 2s2101 ] ) are invariant under the internal symmetries @xmath191 , where @xmath192 the presence of central charges breaks only internal symmetry @xmath193 to @xmath194 , what follows from the relation @xmath195 valid for complex @xmath196 matrices @xmath197 due to the equivalence @xmath198 .
the @xmath199 generators @xmath200 ( @xmath201 ) @xmath202\!\!&=\!\ ! & i\ , ( { \delta^{j}}_{k}{t_{i}}^{l } -{\delta^{l}}_{i}{t_{c}}^{k})\end{aligned}\ ] ] are restricted to @xmath203 by the condition @xmath204 .
one can describe @xmath13 internal symmetries algebra @xmath199 in convenient way by replacing four generators @xmath205 by generators @xmath206 ) adjusted to further description of @xmath207 internal symmetry @xmath208 where @xmath209 ; @xmath210 are three @xmath211 hermitean pauli matrices .
the @xmath199 covariance relation of @xmath13 supercharges looks as follows @xmath212\!\ ! = \!\ !
-\frac{1}{2}{({\sigma_{a}}^{})^{a}}_{b}q^{b}_\alpha \ , , \qquad [ { t_{a}},\,\bar q_{\dot{\alpha}a}]\!\!=\!\!\frac{1}{2}\bar q_{\dot{\alpha}b}{({\sigma_{a}}^{})^{b}}_{a } \ , , \ ] ] where the @xmath211 matrices @xmath213 provide the fundamental realizations of @xmath214 generators ( [ x1 ] ) of the generators in the relations ( [ 2s227x ] ) .
] . using known relation ( @xmath55 )
@xmath215 one gets from ( [ 2s227x ] ) and ( [ x1 ] ) the @xmath13 internal symmetry algebra @xmath216 @xmath217= i \epsilon_{rst}t_t \qquad [ t_0 , t_r]=0 \ , .\ ] ] three generators @xmath218 span @xmath203 algebra which is preserved even in the case of nonvanishing central charges @xmath219 ; the abelian generator @xmath220 describing coset @xmath221 is broken in the presence of central charges . if we consider the chiral projections of euclidean @xmath16 generators ( see ( [ bch1])([bch1bis ] ) ) one gets from ( [ x1a ] ) the commutators exposing the chiral ( antichiral ) nature of supercharges @xmath222 @xmath223 @xmath224\!\!&=\!\!&-\frac{1}{2}{(\sigma_{r})_{\alpha}}^{\beta}q^{a}_{\beta}\ , , \qquad\ ; [ m^{(-)}_{r},\,q^{a}_{\alpha}]\!\!&=\!\!&0\ , , \\[7pt ] [ m^{(+)}_{r},\,\bar q_{\dot{\alpha}a}]\!\!&=\!\!&0\ , , \qquad\qquad\qquad\quad [ m^{(-)}_{r},\,\bar q_{\dot{\alpha}a}]\!\!&=\!\!&\frac{1}{2}\bar q_{\dot{\beta}a}{(\sigma_{r})^{\dot{\beta}}}_{\dot{\alpha}}\ , . \end{array}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the vanishing commutators in ( [ 2s230 ] ) illustrate that the supercharges @xmath225 are left - handed ( chiral ) and the supercharges @xmath226 are right - handed ( antichiral ) . + the reality conditions for supercharges can take the form ( see e.g. @xcite ) : @xmath227 the reality condition for well - known @xmath13 real poincar superalgebra with central charges @xcite is obtained if we put @xmath228 ( see ( a.1 ) ) and @xmath229 . in such a case
we impose on the complex generators @xmath230 of centrally extended @xmath13 complex euclidean superalgebra the reality constraints which extend consistently the conjugation ( [ 2a3 ] ) in bosonic sector to odd superalgebra generators .
in particular in the representation which permits the hermitean conjugation of supercharges the conjugation ( [ sp2 ] ) can be seen as hermitean conjugation .
further the reality constraints on the internal symmetry generators @xmath231 ( see ( [ x1 ] ) and ( [ xx ] ) ) and the central charges ( @xmath232 ) , which are consistent with the relations ( [ 2s2101][2s2111 ] ) , ( [ x1a ] ) and ( [ xx ] ) are the following @xmath233 where the generator @xmath220 describes internal symmetry only in the case when central charges vanish .
if the central charges are not vanishing from first set of the relations ( [ sp3 ] ) one can see that the algebra @xmath203 is constrained to @xmath234 algebra .
if we use the formulae ( [ sp3_0 ] ) for minkowskian @xmath235-matrices , it follows from ( [ 2a2 ] ) and ( [ 2s213 ] ) that @xmath236 and we get the following real @xmath13 poincar superalgebra with one complex central charge @xmath237 : @xmath238 \{q^{a}_{\alpha},\,q^{b}_{\beta}\}\!\!&=\!\!&\epsilon^{ab}\epsilon_{\alpha\beta}z,\qquad\qquad \{\bar{q}_{\dot{\alpha}a},\,\bar{q}_{\dot{\beta}b}\}\!\!&=\!\!&\epsilon_{ab}\epsilon_{\dot{\alpha}\dot{\beta}}\bar{z } , \\[7pt ] [ l_{\mu\nu},\,q^{a}_{\alpha}]\!\ ! & = \!\!&-\displaystyle{(\sigma_{\mu\nu})_{\alpha}}^{\beta}q^{a}_{\beta},\qquad [ l_{\mu\nu},\,\bar{q}_{\dot{\alpha}a}]\!\ ! & = \!\!&\displaystyle\bar{q}_{\dot{\beta}a}{(\tilde{\sigma}_{\mu\nu})}_{\dot{\alpha}}^{\dot{\beta } } , \\[7pt ] [ t_{r},\,q^{a}_{\alpha}]\!\!&=\!\!&-\displaystyle { ( t_{r})^{a}}_{b}q^{b}_{\alpha},\qquad\qquad [ t_{r},\,\bar{q}_{\dot{\alpha}a}]\!\!&=\!\!&\displaystyle\bar{q}_{\dot{\alpha}b}{(t_{r})^{b}}_{a},\\[7pt ] [ p_{\mu}^{},\,q^{a}_{\alpha}]\!\!&=\!\!&[p_\mu^{},\,\bar{q}_{\dot{\alpha}a}]\;\;=\;\;0,\qquad\quad [ t_{r},\;t_{s}]\!\!&=\!\ ! & i \epsilon_{rsm}t_{m}\ , .
\end{array}\end{aligned}\ ] ] if @xmath239 the @xmath13 internal symmetries ( @xmath240-symmetries ) are described by @xmath234 algebra , with the fundamental @xmath196 matrix realizations ( see ( [ 2s210 ] ) and ( [ sp4 ] ) ( the fourth line ) ) described by hermitean pauli matrices ( @xmath241 ) .
if @xmath242 in relations ( [ sp4 ] ) one can add fourth @xmath240-symmetry generator @xmath220 describing the extension of @xmath234 to @xmath243 .
in such a case the complex @xmath168 rescaling in complex n=2 euclidean superalgebra generated by @xmath220 ( see ( [ x1 ] ) and ( [ xx ] ) ) ; is restricted to @xmath169 phase transformations @xmath244 if @xmath160 the map ( [ sp2 ] ) describes a pseudoconjugation , but requires the exotic version ( @xmath161 ) of formula ( [ 3s31 ] ) , i.e. we get the following relation between @xmath184 in ( [ sp2 ] ) and parameters @xmath138 ( see ( [ 3s31 ] ) ) @xmath245 further it can be shown that the antiautomorphism ( [ sp2 ] ) leads to the following reality constraints on central supercharges @xmath219 @xmath246 the antiautomorphism of complex @xmath13 relations ( see ( [ 2s2101])([xx ] ) ) leads for both cases @xmath153 to the same restriction of internal @xmath247 to its subgroup : @xmath248 in the presence of central charge ( @xmath249 ) and @xmath207 if @xmath242 .
we see therefore that we obtain the same internal symmetry sectors for the standard conjugation ( @xmath250 ) and nonstandard pseudoconjugations ( @xmath160 ) .
we shall consider now the @xmath13 complex euclidean superalgebra with the supercharges @xmath251 and @xmath252 ( see sect . 3.1 ) .
the pseudoconjugation map ( [ 3s312 ] ) for @xmath4 superalgebra can be extended to @xmath13 as follows ( see also @xcite ) : @xmath253 in order to obtain the antiautomorphism of @xmath13 complex superalgebra ( see sec .
3.1 ) we should postulate the relation ( [ x2.36 ] ) implying that @xmath228 ( see ( a.1 ) ) for @xmath160 and @xmath161 for @xmath229 .
we get therefore two prolongations to fermionic sector of the euclidean conjugation ( [ 2a4 ] ) .
the invariance of the relation ( [ 2s2101][2s2111 ] ) under the pseudoconjugation maps ( [ 3s314 ] ) implies the following reality conditions for central charges @xmath254 @xmath255 i.e. we obtain two real ( @xmath161 ) or imaginary ( @xmath228 ) central charges .
it is easy to show that the @xmath13 supersymmetrization of complex @xmath256 algebra becomes selfconjugate under pseudoconjugation ( [ 3s314 ] ) under the assumption that the euclidean fourmomentum generators @xmath133 are real ( see ( [ 2a5 ] ) ) .
further , using the relations @xmath257 , we should choose for @xmath258 generators the euclidean reality conditions .
the invariance of superalgebra under the pseudoconjugation ( [ 3s314 ] ) requires that ( see ( [ sp4 ] ) ) @xmath259 where @xmath260 is the complex conjugation of @xmath196 matrix elements describing fundamental realizations of @xmath199 generators @xmath261 .
if central charges are absent the reality constraints ( [ 3s316 ] ) restrict the complex internal @xmath199 algebra to its real form @xmath262 .
the presence of scalar central charges @xmath219 commuting with euclidean @xmath17 and internal symmetry generators reduces the internal symmetries @xmath263 to its subgroup @xmath264 ; i.e. the @xmath265 subalgebra of @xmath262 remains not broken for any value of central charges ( [ 3s317 ] ) and describes n=2 euclidean @xmath240-symmetry . if @xmath13 it is possible to introduce as well the following conjugation @xmath266 with involutive property @xmath267 which is an antilinear antiautomorphism describing the superextension of conjugation ( [ 2a5 ] ) .
it can be checked that ( [ 3s320 ] ) describes conjugation if @xmath250 and pseudoconjugation if @xmath268 . due to the relation if @xmath269 if @xmath229 ( [ 3s320 ] ) provides standard antiautomorphism of complex @xmath13 superalgebra with @xmath228 ; if @xmath160 one should postulate nonstandard antiautomorphism ( see ( a.1 ) ) with @xmath161 .
the restrictions on @xmath13 central charges @xmath219 which follow from the isomorphism of @xmath13 euclidean superalgebra under the ( pseudo)conjugation ( [ 3s320 ] ) are the following @xmath270 the covariance of relations ( [ x1a ] ) under the conjugation ( [ 3s320 ] ) implies that the generators @xmath231 of internal symmetry @xmath214 satisfy the reality conditions ( @xmath271 ) @xmath272 one can express in @xmath13 case the relations ( [ x1a ] ) consistently with ( [ 3s320 ] ) as follows @xmath273 = - { 1\over 2}q^a_\alpha \quad [ t_r , q^a_\alpha ] = -{1\over 2}(\sigma_r)^a_{\ b } q^b_\alpha \ , .\ ] ] the generators @xmath218 and @xmath220 due to relations ( [ 2x ] ) and ( [ x1 ] ) describe the internal @xmath13 algebra @xmath274 ( see also e.g. @xcite ) . in the realizations of superalgebra permitting to define the hermitean conjugation of supercharges @xmath275 , @xmath276 the antilinearity of the automorphism ( [ 3s320 ] )
can be realized explicitly .
if @xmath250 ( i.e. @xmath228 ) one can introduce the following counterpart of the conjugation ( [ 3s320 ] ) which employs the hermitean conjugation @xmath277 in such a case one can define the following two complex conjugated n=2 euclidean superalgebras @xcite : holomorphic n=2 euclidean superalgebra @xmath278 generated by supercharges @xmath279 antiholomorphic n=2 euclidean superalgebra @xmath280 generated by hermitean conjugated supercharges @xmath281 .
the reality conditions described by conjugation ( [ y3.25 ] ) maps @xmath282 , i.e. they describe the inner automorphism of real n=2 euclidean superalgebra @xmath283
. such form of n=2 euclidean reality conditions has been employed in earlier applications , e.g. for the description of n=2 euclidean supersymmetric field
theoretic models , formulated in complex n=2 superspace ( see e.g. @xcite ) for @xmath13 kleinian real supersymmetry we have the following possible reality conditions : @xmath284 which extend from @xmath4 to n=2 kleinian reality condition ( [ sp2_0k ] ) .
the @xmath13 kleinian superalgebra for @xmath228 because of the condition @xmath269 takes the following form ( see also ( [ kk2][ykk2 ] ) ) @xmath285 \nonumber \\[-6pt ] \label{k2s2a } \left\ { q^a_\alpha , q^b_{{\beta}}\right\}=\epsilon_{\alpha\beta}\epsilon^{ab}z\ , , & & \left\ { \bar q_{\dot{\alpha}a } , \bar q_{\dot{\beta}b}\right\ } = \epsilon_{\dot{\alpha}\dot{\beta}}\epsilon_{ab}\tilde z \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the reality conditions for two central charges look as follows @xmath286 the internal symmetry generator @xmath231 @xmath287 ( see ( [ x1 ] ) , ( [ xx ] ) ) satisfy for vanishing central charges the reality condition @xmath288 if central charges do not vanish the r - symmetry @xmath289 is reduced to @xmath290 .
we shall follow the method used in our previous paper @xcite based on the following steps : \i ) consider zakrzewski list of 21 real classical @xmath14matrices satisfying classical yang - baxter ( yb),matrices , given in @xcite only one set , denoted with @xmath291 , does not satisfy homogeneous classical yb equation , i.e. can not be lifted to twisted hopf algebra . ] and use in their presentation the canonical poincar basis ( sec .
2.1 ) ; \ii ) remove the poincar reality conditions ( see ( [ 2a3 ] ) or ( [ bor4.1 ] ) ) imposed in @xcite .
the generators @xmath292 are becoming complex and we obtain corresponding class of classical @xmath14matrices for complex inhomogeneous @xmath293 algebra .
iii ) extend supersymmetrically the complex classical @xmath14matrices obtained in ii ) to n=1 and n=2 by adding suitable terms which depend on supercharges @xmath294 ( @xmath295 ) .
for n=2 we consider as well terms in classical r - matrix which depend on complex @xmath13 central charges @xmath219 ( see ( [ 2s2111 ] ) ) in such a way that the supersymmetric n=2 complex @xmath14matrices satisfy the classical super - yb equation . in sect .
4.2 we recall the zakrzewski list of d=4 real poincar and d=4 self conjugate euclidean r - matrices from @xcite as well as d=4
n=1 real super poincar and pseudoreal super - euclidean r - matrices obtained in @xcite . in sect . 5 we present new results for supersymmetric r - matrices with standard n=2 poincar reality conditions ( see sect .
3.2 ) and n=2 euclidean ( pseudo)reality conditons ( see sect .
3.34 ) .
let us present the real d=4 poincar r - matrices listed in @xcite ( see also @xcite )
. using the decomposition of @xmath296 @xmath297 where ( @xmath298 denotes the fourmomenta generators ) @xmath299 zakrzewski @xcite obtained the following list ccccc @xmath154 & @xmath300 & @xmath301 & @xmath302 & @xmath303 + @xmath304 & @xmath305 & @xmath306 & @xmath307 & @xmath308 + @xmath309 & @xmath310 & @xmath305 & @xmath308 & @xmath307 + @xmath311 & @xmath312 & @xmath313 & @xmath308 & @xmath314 + @xmath311 & @xmath315 & @xmath316 & @xmath307 & @xmath317 + @xmath318 & @xmath319 & @xmath319 + @xmath320 & @xmath305 & @xmath305 & @xmath308 & @xmath321 + @xmath322 & @xmath319 & @xmath319 + @xmath323 & @xmath324 & @xmath305 & @xmath308 & @xmath325 + @xmath305 & @xmath310 & @xmath305 & @xmath308 & @xmath326 + @xmath311 & @xmath327 & @xmath305 & @xmath308 & @xmath20 + @xmath311 & @xmath328 & @xmath329 & @xmath307 & @xmath330 + @xmath311 & @xmath331 & @xmath319 & @xmath332 & @xmath333 & @xmath334 & @xmath307 & @xmath335 + @xmath311 & @xmath336 & @xmath337 & @xmath308 & @xmath338 + @xmath311 & @xmath339 & @xmath340 & @xmath314 & @xmath341 + @xmath311 & @xmath342&@xmath343 & @xmath307 & @xmath344 + @xmath311 & @xmath345&@xmath343 & @xmath307 & @xmath346 + @xmath311 & @xmath347&@xmath343 & @xmath308 & @xmath348 + @xmath311 & @xmath349&@xmath343 & @xmath307 & @xmath350 + @xmath311 & @xmath351&@xmath352 & @xmath308 & @xmath353 + @xmath311 & @xmath354&@xmath355 & @xmath308 & @xmath356 + @xmath311 & @xmath305 & @xmath357 & @xmath305 & @xmath358 + @xmath319 & @xmath355 & @xmath305 & @xmath359 + @xmath319 & @xmath360 & @xmath308 & @xmath361 + where we use cartan chevaley basis for @xmath362 ( see ( [ bor4.1][bor4.2 ] ) ) and @xmath363 . besides @xmath364 , @xmath365
are given by the expressions : @xmath366 b_{p_{2}}^{}\!\!&=\!\!&2p_{1}\wedge h'+p_{-}\wedge e'_{+}-p_{+}\wedge e'_{-}~ , \end{array } \ ] ] and provide r - matrices describing light - cone ( @xmath367 ) and tachyonic ( @xmath368 ) @xmath2-deformation @xcite .
in @xcite we have presented the list of possible supersymmetric d=4 n=1 super poincar r - matrices @xmath369 .
it appears that only 7 out of 21 classes of r - matrices present in table 1 can be supersymmetrized .
the n=1 super poincar r - matrices decomposed as follows : @xmath370 where @xmath371 ( @xmath372 denote n=1 poincar supercharges ) .
the list of r - matrices ( [ luk4.4 ] ) looks as follows : cccccc @xmath154 & @xmath300 & @xmath301 & @xmath373 & @xmath303 + @xmath374@xmath374@xmath311 + @xmath309 & @xmath310 & @xmath305 & @xmath375 & @xmath307 + @xmath376 & @xmath312 & @xmath313 & @xmath377 & @xmath314 + @xmath374@xmath374@xmath311 + @xmath323 & @xmath324 & @xmath305 & @xmath378 & @xmath325 + @xmath374@xmath374@xmath311 + @xmath305 & @xmath310 & @xmath305 & @xmath375 & @xmath326 + @xmath311 & @xmath327 & @xmath305 & @xmath379 & @xmath20 + @xmath311 & @xmath380 & @xmath329 & @xmath379 & @xmath330 + @xmath311 & @xmath351 & @xmath381 & @xmath382 & @xmath353 + we see that the superextension is realized in all cases except @xmath383=6 with the help of unique supersymmetric term @xmath384 , where @xmath385 is purely imaginary , which is invariant under the n=1 super poincar conjugation .
the list of n=1 complex euclidean supersymmetric r - matrices , which are self - conjugate under the pseudoconjugation ( [ 3s312 ] ) with @xmath268 looks as follows : cccccc @xmath154 & @xmath300 & @xmath301 & @xmath373 & @xmath303 + & & & & & + @xmath304 & @xmath305 & @xmath386 & @xmath387 & @xmath308 + + @xmath311 & @xmath388 & @xmath343 & @xmath387 & @xmath344 + @xmath311 & @xmath389 & @xmath343 & @xmath387 & @xmath346 + @xmath311 & @xmath390 & @xmath343 & @xmath387 & @xmath348 + @xmath311 & @xmath349 & @xmath343 & @xmath391 & @xmath350 + @xmath374@xmath374 + @xmath311 & @xmath305 & @xmath392 & @xmath393 & @xmath358 + @xmath319 & @xmath394 & @xmath395 & @xmath359 + @xmath319 & @xmath360 & @xmath396 & @xmath361 + where @xmath397 and @xmath398 denote n=1 complex euclidean supercharges ( @xmath399 ) ( see ( [ 2s210][2s212 ] ) ) . due to inner automorphisms of n=1 euclidean superalgebra
the selfconjugate term can be chosen only as @xmath400 , with parameter @xmath401 purely imaginary .
we observe that among supersymmetric r - matrices in table 2 the r - matrices with @xmath383=2,3 and 7,8 contain term @xmath367 characterizing light - cone @xmath2-deformation @xcite , and the super r - matrix @xmath383=6 contains term @xmath368 describing tachyonic @xmath2deformation @xcite .
it should be added that the standard `` time like '' @xmath2-deformation characterized by the term @xmath402 , is not present in tables 13 .
further we comment that in euclidean case without supersymmetry ( table 1 ) and with n=1 supersymmetry ( table 3 ) , the r - matrices characterizing @xmath2-deformations are not present .
the n=2 superextensions of d=4 poincar and euclidean r - matrices can be decomposed in the following way compare with formula ( [ cr3 ] ) @xmath403 where @xmath404 contains contributions from central charges @xmath405 @xmath406
@xmath407 and @xmath408 , where @xmath409 denote n=2 supercharges . we shall list in sect .
5.1 the r - matrices ( [ lukb5.2 ] ) invariant under n=2 poincar reality condition ( [ sp2])([sp3 ] ) and in sect .
5.2 the ones invariant under the pseudoconjugation ( [ 3s314 ] ) and conjugation ( [ y3.25 ] ) . due to the reality condition ( [ sp3 ] ) n=2 poincar superalgebra depends on one complex supercharge @xmath410 .
in such a case to every zakrzewski r - matrix ( see table 1 ) one can add unique term bilinear in central charges ( see ( [ lukb5.2 ] ) ) @xmath411 it follows from table 2 that only zakrzewski r - matrices with @xmath412 admit @xmath4 supersymmetrization , realized by universal term @xmath413 .
it appears that for n=2 d=4 super poincar r - marices the term @xmath414 in formula ( [ lukb5.1 ] ) is also universal and described by ( @xmath415 real , @xmath416 , @xmath417 ) @xmath418 the term ( [ lukb5.4 ] ) provides n=2 supersymmetrization of r - matrices or @xmath419 then we obtain only n=1 supersymmetrization . ] described in table 2 .
if we denote @xmath420 ( @xmath421 ; see ( [ lukb5.2 ] ) ) such a term is possible only for supersymmetric r - matrices if @xmath422 .
these additional terms linearly dependent on central charges , can be added only for @xmath423 by the following universal expression ( @xmath424 complex ) @xmath425 for @xmath426 one can add consistently with cybe the following complex term belonging to @xmath427 ( @xmath428 complex ) @xmath429 unfortunately , term ( [ lukb5.6 ] ) can not satisfy the poincar reality conditions .
listed above supersymmetric @xmath430-matrices can be presented as a sum of subordinated @xmath430-matrices which are of super - abelian and super - jordanian types .
the subordination enables us to construct a correct sequence of quantizations and to obtain the corresponding twists describing the quantum deformations .
these twists are in general case the super - extensions of the twists obtained in @xcite . contrary to the n=2 super poincar case , when there is only one conjugation providing reality condition ( see sect . 3.2 in relation ( a.1 ) ) what corresponds to the choice @xmath229 in ( [ sp2 ] ) . ] ) , in n=2 case we have two types of reality structure : a ) : : defined by pseudoconjuation ( [ 3s314 ] ) ( we consider @xmath228 and @xmath160 ) , which is the straightforward extension of pseudoreality structure considered for n=1 in ( [ 3s312 ] ) .
b ) : : defined by the conjugation ( [ y3.25 ] ) .
we further assume that the hermitean conjugation @xmath431 is well defined . )
can be defined for suitable class of realizations of supercharges @xmath432 . ]
then one can formulate n=2 euclidean superalgebra in a hermitean form if we impose the subsidiary condition which follows from ( [ y3.25 ] ) ( @xmath433 ) @xmath434 or more explicitly @xmath435 we see that the supercharges @xmath436 can be expressed by @xmath437 , @xmath438 and n=2 superalgebra can be described by two pairs of complex hermitean conjugated supercharges which equivalently can be expressed as hermitean
conjugated pair of four component dirac spinors ( a=1,2,3,4 ) @xmath439 we shall consider below separately the n=2 euclidean r - matrices selfconjugate under pseudoconjugation ( [ 3s314 ] ) and conjugation ( [ lukbb5.9 ] ) .
we consider the complex n=2 @xmath440 r - matrices which are invariant under the map ( [ 3s314 ] ) ; we choose the standard version of formula ( a.1 ) with @xmath228 what implies @xmath441 .
for n=2 we should take into consideration only the poincar r - matrices from table 1 with @xmath442 ( see also table 3 ) which allow n=1 supersymmetrization . if we consider the relations ( [ 3s317 ] ) with @xmath228 , we get the pair of independent n=2 euclidean central charges @xmath237 , @xmath443 which are purely imaginary .
they provide euclidean counterpart of formula ( [ lukb5.3 ] ) describing universal contribution to n=2 super - r - matrices .
the fermionic part @xmath444 of n=2 super euclidean r - matrix ( [ lukb5.1 ] ) for @xmath445 is described by the following pair of two forms bilinear in supercharges ( @xmath446 are real ) @xmath447 to either of two terms ( [ lukbb5.13 ] ) one can add the unique term @xmath448 which takes the form ( @xmath415 complex , @xmath428 real ) @xmath449 for @xmath450 we can again choose pair of the purely fermionic terms @xmath444 , which are described by formulae ( [ lukbb5.13 ] ) ; the terms @xmath451 , linear in @xmath452 , are however not universal , different for three cases @xmath453 and 21 . in this case
the algebraic structure does not have a counterpart in the formulae obtained by euclidean n=1 supersymmetryzation ( see table 3 ) .
the task consists in finding such n=2 complex @xmath440 r - matrices which are consistent with n=2 super euclidean reality conditions ( [ lukbb5.10 ] ) . we should mention that it is necessary to consider the n=2 supersymmetrization of poincar r - matrices for all @xmath454 .
we obtain the following list of fermionic and central charge dependent terms for varius choices of @xmath383 + + * @xmath415 ) * @xmath455 there are possible the following independent four fermionic two - forms @xmath456 ( @xmath457 @xmath458 real ) @xmath459 the additional bosonic terms @xmath460 which are linear in real central charges @xmath452 satisfying ( for @xmath229 ) the reality conditions ( [ 3x ] ) is described again by formula ( [ lukbb5.14 ] ) .
+ + * @xmath401 ) * @xmath383=1921 . for such values of
@xmath383 one can add any of four three
parameter term @xmath461 below , bilinear in supercharges ( @xmath462 real ) : @xmath463 the additional bosonic terms @xmath464 linear in central charges and fourmomenta are different for considered three classes of r - matrices , namely ( @xmath465 real ) @xmath466 finally we point out that among all 21 zakrzewski classes of complex @xmath467 r - matrices only for @xmath383=5 we could not find the superextension of complex @xmath16 r - matrices to @xmath468 ( @xmath469 ) supersymmetric r - matrices , i.e. we were not able for @xmath383=5 to provide any consistent fermionic term @xmath414 in ( [ lukb5.1 ] ) .
this paper provides firstly systematic discussion of real forms of @xmath16 , @xmath470 , @xmath471 and @xmath472 , where @xmath473 describes complex d=4 n extended euclidean superalgebra . in sect . 2 and
3 we consider the reality and pseudoreality conditions ( reality constraints ) . to the poincar and euclidean ( pseudo)real forms we added also the ( pseudo)real forms for the kleinian signature @xmath474 . in particular we also considered the ( pseudo ) reality conditions leading to exotic supersymmetry scheme , with odd ( grassmann ) coordinates conjugated in nonstandard way ( see e.g. ( [ x2.39])([xy2.39 ] ) , with @xmath161 ) . our second aim was to present the extension of zakrzewski list of classical d=4 poincar r - matrices to euclidean case and n=1,2 supersymmetrizations .
the d=4 n=1 poincar and euclidean supersymmetric classical r - matrices already considered in @xcite were presented in sect .
4 . in sect . 5
we describe partial results for the classification of d=4 n=2 supersymmetric r - matrices for various d=4 signatures .
we consider in this paper n=2 poincar and euclidean signatures and these results are new .
it should be pointed out that we considered also the terms depending on a pair of n=2 central charges ( for @xmath472 ) ; they are complex - conjugated for poincar and real for euclidean cases .
we did not consider the deformations of n=2 kleinian supersymmetry and corresponding classical r - matrices .
more systematic approach , with more complete list of complex classical @xmath472 r - matrices and their various real forms will be considered in our subsequent publication .
the paper was presented at xxiiith international conference on integrable systems and quantum symmetries , prague ( june 2015 ) . the presenting author ( jl )
would like to thank prof .
cestimir burdik for warm hospitality .
the paper has been supported by the polish science center ( ncn ) , project 2014/13/b / st2/04043 ( a.b . and j.l . ) , rfbr grant no 14 - 01 - 00474-a ( v.n.t . ) .
in order to describe the supersymmetries of physical systems one should consider real and pseudoreal forms of complex lie superalgebra @xmath475 , which are defined in algebraic framework with help of the conjugations and pseudoconjugations . the conjugations and pseudoconjugations
are usually defined as abstract antilinear antiautomorphisms @xmath476 of second and fourth order preserving the @xmath10 grading of superalgebra and satisfying the properties ( @xmath477 ; @xmath478 ( @xmath479 ) describes the parity of even ( odd ) element @xmath480 ) , where @xmath481 denotes enveloping algebra of @xmath475 : @xmath482 where @xmath483 defines two types of antilinear antiinvolution map in @xmath481 and @xmath484 , @xmath485 describe complex conjugation in @xmath486 .
further ( x^)^= x & ) , & [ 3s33a ] + ( x^)^= - x & ) . &
[ 3s3b ] for lie superalgebras the property ( [ 3s3b]b ) occurs only in odd parity sector , i.e. for any @xmath487 both relations ( [ 3s33a]a ) and ( [ 3s3b]b ) can be written together as @xmath488 where @xmath489 ( resp .
@xmath490 ) denotes conjugations ( resp .
pseduconjugation ) and we recall that @xmath491 describe the grading of superalgebra element @xmath480 . the conjugations ( [ 3s33a]a ) in matrix and hilbert space realizations of superalgebra can be identified with the hermitean conjugation , and pseudoconjugations in odd sector of the matrix superalgebras with @xmath490 were introduced as graded hermitean conjugation @xcite ( see also @xcite ) . in the case of conjugations ( a.3a ) the hermitean elements @xmath492 of complex lie algebra @xmath475 are defined as follows @xmath493 where @xmath494 and @xmath495 . in the case of conjugation
the superalgebras @xmath496 are the subsuperalgebras which can be defined as fixed points of the conjugation map , and @xmath497 provides the formula describing the realification of @xmath475 . in the case of pseudoconjugations ( [ 3s3b]b ) the elements ( [ 3ss34 ] ) of complex lie algebra satisfy the set of relations @xmath498 with elements @xmath499 satisfying involutive relations of fourth order @xmath500 we comment that one uses for description of real supersymmetries in classical physics an alternative conjugations and pseudoconjugations , which are antilinear automorphism with the property @xmath501 the remaining relations ( [ 3s32 ] ) , ( [ 3s33a]a b ) are unchanged .
one can add that authomorphisms ( [ 3ss39 ] ) for classical physical systems are usually represented by complex conjugation , and antiauthomorphisms adjusted to quantum systems are realized as ( graded ) hermitean conjugation in suitable hilbert space framework .
99 s. zakrzewski , _ lett . math . phys . _ , * 32 * , 11 ( 1994 ) .
tolstoy , _ bulg .
j. phys . _
* 35 * ( 2008 ) 441459 ; ( proceedings of vii international workshop `` lie theory and its applications in physics '' . ed .
dobrev et al , heron press , sofia , 2008 ) [ http://arxiv.org/abs/0712.3962[0712.3962 [ math.qa ] ] ] .
zupnik , _ phys .
_ , * b627 * , 208 ( 2005 ) ; [ http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0506043v3[hep-th/0506043v3 ] ] ; _ theor . math . phys .
_ * 147 * , 670 ( 2006 ) ; [ http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0602034v2[hep-th/0602034v2 ] ] .
p. kosinski , j. lukierski , p. maslanka and j. sobczyk , _ j. phys .
_ , * a27 * , 6827 ( 1994 ) ; [ http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9405076v1[hep-th/9405076v1 ] ] ; _ ibid .
_ * a28 * , 2255 ( 1995 ) ; [ http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9411115v1[hep-th/9411115v1 ] ] . v.n .
tolstoy , _ nankai tracts in mathematics `` differential geometry and physics '' .
proceedings of the 23-th international conference of differential geometric methods in theoretical physics ( tianjin , china , 20 - 26 august , 2005 ) .
editors : mo - lin ge and weiping zhang .
wold scientific _ , 2006 , vol . * * 1**0 , 443 - 452 ; [ http://arxiv.org/abs/math.qa/0701079v1[qa/0701079v1 ] ] .
m. chaichian , p.p .
kulish , _ phys .
_ , * b 234 * , 72 ( 1990 ) .
khoroshkin , v.n .
tolstoy , _ commun .
_ , * 141 * , 599 ( 1991 ) .
a. borowiec , j. lukierski , v.n .
tolstoy , _ new twisted quantum deformations of d=4 super - poincar algebra _ , proc . of dubna workshop `` supersymmetries and quantum symmetries ( sqs07 ) '' , 30.074.08.2007 , ed .
s. fedoruk , e. ivanov ; arxiv:0803.4167 .
a. borowiec , j. lukierski , m. mozrzymas , v. n. tolstoy , jhep 1206 , 154 ( 2012 ) ; [ http://arxiv.org/abs/1112.1936[hep-th/1112.1936 ] ] .
n. seiberg , _ jhep _ , * 0306 * , 010 ( 2003 ) ; [ http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0305248v1[hep-th/0305248v1 ] ] . | we provide the classification of real forms of complex d=4 euclidean algebra @xmath0 as well as ( pseudo)real forms of complex d=4 euclidean superalgebras @xmath1 for n=1,2 .
further we present our results : n=1 and n=2 supersymmetric d=4 poincar and euclidean r - matrices obtained by using d= 4 poincar r - matrices provided by zakrzewski @xcite for n=2 we shall consider the general superalgebras with two central charges . |
the nearby lenticular ( s0 , @xmath3 ) galaxy ic310 located in the perseus cluster exhibits an active galactic nucleus ( agn ) .
this object has been detected at high energies ( above 30gev ) with _
fermi_/lat @xcite as well as at tev energies @xcite .
the jet of ic310 , extending in the outward direction from the center of the cluster led to early assignment of this object as a head - tail radio galaxy @xcite .
however , using the very - long - baseline interferometry ( vlbi ) technique , a parsec - scale one - sided jet was found to follow the large - scale jet within about @xmath4 @xcite .
the alignment of the jet at different scales , without any hints of bending put in doubt the above classification .
instead , the inner jet appears to be blazar - like with a missing counter jet due to relativistically boosted emission .
further indications for transitional behavior between a radio galaxy and a blazar were found in ic310 in various energy ranges @xcite .
the mass , @xmath5 , of the black hole of ic310 can be inferred from its relation with the velocity dispersion , @xmath6 , of the host galaxy @xcite , namely @xmath7 .
magic ( major atmospheric gamma imaging cherenkov ) is a system of two 17-m diameter imaging atmospheric cherenkov telescopes located on la palma , canary islands .
it allows observations of gamma - ray sources with energies above 50gev . during the observations of the perseus cluster performed in the end of 2012 magic telescopes revealed an extreme gamma - ray flare from ic310 on the night of 12/13@xmath2 of november @xcite .
in addition , the source was observed in radio band by european vlbi network ( evn ) during october / november 2012 . in section [ sec :
results ] we report the data analysis and results of the magic observations during the flare and the radio observations . in section
[ sec : interp ] we discuss possible interpretation of the ultrafast variability of the gamma - ray emission observed from ic310 .
magic telescopes were observing the perseus cluster on the night of 12/13@xmath2 of november for 3.7h .
the observations consisted of 4 pointings , two of the them with a standard offset of 0.4@xmath8 with respect to ic310 and the remaining ones are at a distance @xmath9 away from the object .
the signal extraction and calibration of the data , the image parametrization , the direction and energy reconstruction as well as the gamma - hadron separation were applied with the standard analysis software mars as described in @xcite . in the night of the flare a strong signal of 507 gamma - like events above 300gev in the region around ic310 in excess of the background estimated as 47 events was observed . due to still limited statistics of events and a very rapid variability behavior ,
the classical approach for the calculation of light curves in gamma - ray astronomy which is based on the fixed width of the time bins is not optimal in this case .
we used instead a method similar to the one commonly used for data of x - ray observatories for the computing of energy spectra .
we first identify all periods in the data during which the telescopes were not operational ( in particular @xmath10min gaps every 20min when the telescope is slewing and reconfiguring for the next data run ) .
afterwards , we bin the remaining time periods based on a fixed number ( in this case 9 ) of on events per bin .
we estimate the number of background events in each time bin from four off - source regions at the same distance from the camera center . using toy mc simulations we validated that this method limits the bias in flux value and its error @xcite . as the signal to
background ratio above 300gev is much larger than 1 this assures that the precision of individual points in the light curve is close to @xmath11 .
the resulting light curve is presented in fig .
[ lightcurve ] . , 2012 , above 300gev .
as a flux reference , the two gray lines indicate levels of @xmath12 and @xmath13 times the flux level of the crab nebula , respectively . the precursor flare ( mjd 56243.97256243.994 ) has been fitted with a gaussian distribution .
the figure is reprinted from @xcite .
, scaledwidth=49.0% ] the mean flux above 300gev during this period is @xmath14@xmath15s@xmath16 .
this is four times higher than the high state flux of @xmath17@xmath15s@xmath16 reported in @xcite .
the emission is highly variable , fitting the light curve in the full time range with a constant reveals a @xmath18 of 199/58 corresponding to a probability of @xmath19 .
we use the rapidly rising part of the 1@xmath20 big flare ( mjd 56244.062056244.0652 ) in order to compute the conservative , slowest doubling time , @xmath21 , which is still consistent with the magic data .
we fit the light curve with a set of exponential functions , each time assuming a given @xmath21 value and computing the corresponding fit probability .
we obtain that @xmath22 is the largest value of @xmath21 , which can still marginally fit the data with probability @xmath23 ( see the blue line in fig . [ figs4 ] ) . note that the corresponding time scale in the frame of reference of ic 310 will be slightly shorter : @xmath24 .
the observed spectrum can be described by a simple power law ( see fig .
[ sed ] ) : @xmath25 the flux normalization at 1tev obtained from the fit is @xmath26 even while the mean flux during the flaring night is @xmath27 larger than previous measurements , the spectral index , @xmath28 is consistent with them within the statistical and systematic errors .
no significant bend or cut - off is seen in the spectrum up to tev energies . as part of the observation
was carried out with a higher then usual offset angle from the camera center the systematic error on the flux normalization is slightly larger ( 12% ) then reported in @xcite .
the error of the energy scale is 15% .
ic310 has been observed with the evn at 1.7 , 5.0 , 8.4 and 22.2ghz between 2012 - 10 - 21 and 2012 - 11 - 07 .
the data were amplitude and phase calibrated using standard procedures with the astronomical image processing system ( aips , @xcite ) and imaged and self - calibrated using difmap @xcite . in inset panel of fig .
[ skymap ] we present the image with the highest dynamic range obtained from the observation at 5.0 ghz from 2012 - 10 - 29 . , 2012 , with the magic telescopes .
the inset shows the radio jet image of ic310 at 5.0ghz obtained with the european vlbi network ( evn ) on october 29 , 2012 .
contour lines ( and associated to them color scale ) increase logarithmically by factors of 2 starting at three times the noise level .
the ratio of the angular resolution between magic and the evn is 1:580000 .
the figure is reprinted from @xcite .
, scaledwidth=49.0% ] the image has a peak flux density of 77mjy / beam and a 1@xmath6 noise level of 0.027mjy / beam .
the restoring beam has a major and minor axis of @xmath29mas@xmath30 with the major axis at a position angle of @xmath31 .
it contains a total flux density of @xmath32 , which we conservatively assume to be accurate to 10% .
the dynamic range @xmath33 of the image , defined as the ratio of the peak flux density to tripled noise level in the image is @xmath34 .
the angle @xmath35 of the radio jet to the line - of - sight can be determined from doppler boosting arguments for a given jet speed @xmath36 and spectral index @xmath37 by considering the ratio @xmath38 of the flux density in the jet and counter - jet : @xmath39 following @xcite we use the @xmath33 as an upper limit for the detection of a counter - jet .
this gives us an upper limit of @xmath35 : @xmath40 substituting @xmath33 in eq .
[ eq1 ] , assuming a flat spectral index of @xmath41 and @xmath42 , we obtain an upper limit for the angle between the jet and the line - of - sight of @xmath43 .
additionally , the extension of the projected one - sided kpc radio jet of @xmath44kpc measured at a wavelength of 49 cm @xcite yields an estimate of a lower limit for the angle . de - projecting the jet using the upper limit quoted above would results in a lower limit of the jet length of @xmath451mpc .
radio galaxies typically show jets extending up to 150kpc-300kpc @xcite .
the maximal length of radio jets has been measured to be a few mpcs which corresponds to an angle of @xmath46 in the case of ic310 .
smaller angles would rapidly increase the de - projected length of the jet to values far above the maximum of the distribution of the jet lengths .
gev and tev gamma - ray emission from blazars and radio galaxies is often explained in terms of shock - in - jet models .
charged particles are accelerated in an active region moving along the jet .
causality condition provides that the variability time scale of the observed emission can be used to constrain the size of the emission region . a conservative estimate of the shortest variability time scale in the frame of reference of ic310 yields @xmath47 min .
using the best mass estimate of ic310 black hole this measurement corresponds to @xmath48 of the light travel time across the event horizon .
even allowing for the factor 3 uncertainty in the mass the fraction , @xmath49 , is still below one .
the ultrafast variability casts a shadow of doubt on the current shock - in - jet paradigm .
the moving shock plasma leads to a shortening of the observed variability time scale @xmath50 compared with the variability time scale @xmath51 in a frame comoving with the shock given by @xmath52 .
this effect is often used to explain ultrafast variability from blazars @xcite in which @xmath53 can be nearly arbitrarily large providing that the jet moving with large lorentz factor is observed at a very small angle . in the case of ic310
however the estimation of the observation angle @xmath54 obtained from the radio observations constrain the maximum doppler factor to be @xmath55 .
all of these attempts to explain the sub - horizon scale variability with relativistic projection effects alone encounter a fundamental problem @xcite . if the perturbations giving rise to the blazar variability are injected at the jet base , the time scale of the flux variations in the frame comoving with the jet is affected by time dilation with lorentz factor @xmath56 . in blazars where @xmath57 , the lorentz factor cancels out , and
the observed variability time scale is ultimately bounded below by @xmath58 .
additionally , a very high value of the doppler factor is required to avoid the absorption of the tev gamma rays due to interactions with low - energy synchrotron photons .
such synchrotron photons are inevitably produced together with the gamma rays in the shock - in - jet scenario . the optical depth to pair creation by the gamma rays
can be approximated by @xmath59 .
adopting , conservatively , a non - thermal infrared luminosity of @xmath60 of the gamma - ray luminosity during the flare , the emission region would be transparent to the emission of 10 tev gamma rays only if @xmath61 . in summary
, trying to interpret the ic310 flare in the framework of the shock - in - jet model meets difficulties .
alternative models can involve stars falling into the jet @xcite , mini - jet structures within the jets @xcite or magnetospheric models @xcite . in the case of ic310 star - in - jet model can not provide sufficient luminosity to explain the tev flare @xcite .
also jets - in - jet models suffer from rapidly dropping luminosity at larger observation angles @xcite .
moreover the magnetic reconnection which can led to production of such mini - jets is expected to occur in the main jet rather at larger distances from the black hole . in magnetospheric models ,
particle acceleration is assumed occur in electric fields parallel to the magnetic fields .
this mechanism is common to the particle - starved magnetospheres of pulsars , but it could also operate in the magnetospheres anchored to the ergospheres of accreting black holes ( see fig .
[ gap ] ) .
( black sphere ) accretes plasma from the center of the galaxy ic 310 . in the apple - shaped ergosphere ( blue )
extending to @xmath62 in the equatorial plane , poynting flux is generated by the frame - dragging effect .
the rotation of the black hole induces a charge - separated magnetosphere ( red ) with polar vacuum gap regions ( yellow ) . in the gaps ,
the electric field of the magnetosphere has a component parallel to the magnetic field accelerating particles to ultra - relativistic energies .
inverse - compton scattering and intense pair production due to interactions with low - energy thermal photons from the plasma accreted by the black hole leads to the observed gamma rays .
the figure is reprinted from @xcite .
, scaledwidth=49.0% ] electric fields can exist in vacuum gaps when the density of charge carriers is too low to cause their shortcut , i.e. below the so - called goldreich - julian charge density .
electron - positron pairs in excess of the goldreich - julian charge density can be produced thermally by photon - photon collisions in a hot accretion torus or corona surrounding the black hole .
it has also been suggested , that particles can be injected by the reconnection of twisted magnetic loops in the accretion flow @xcite .
a depletion of charges from thermal pair production is expected to happen when the accretion rate becomes very low . in this late phase of their accretion history ,
supermassive black holes are expected to have spun up to maximal rotation .
black holes can sustain a poynting flux jet by virtue of the blandford - znajek mechanism @xcite .
jet collimation takes place rather far away from the black hole , i.e. at the scale of the light cylinder beyond @xmath63 .
gaps could be located at various angles with the jet axis corresponding to the polar and outer gaps in pulsar magnetospheres leading to fan beams at rather large angles with the jet axis .
as the gap height and seed particle content depend sensitively on plasma turbulence and accretion rate , the gap emission is expected to be highly variable .
for an accretion rate of @xmath64 of the eddington accretion rate and maximal black hole rotation , the gap height in ic 310 is expected to be @xmath65 @xcite which is in line with the variability times seen in the observations .
depending on the electron temperature and geometry of the radiatively inefficient accretion flow , its thermal cyclotron luminosity can be low enough to warrant the absence of pair creation attenuation in the spectrum of gamma rays . in this picture , the intermittent variability witnessed in ic 310 is due to a runaway effect .
as particles accelerate to ultrahigh energies , electromagnetic cascades develop multiplying the number of charge carriers until their current shortcuts the gap .
the excess particles are then swept away with the jet flow , until the gap reappears .
radio galaxies and blazars with very low accretion rates allow us to obtain a glimpse of the jet formation process near supermassive black holes .
observations of ic310 performed with the magic telescopes showed variability with time scale below 5min , shorter than the light crossing time of the event horizon of its black hole .
the commonly used in agns shock - in - jet models have troubles to explain such emission .
a plausible explanation involves emission from vacuum gaps in the magnetosphere of ic310 .
interestingly , such explanation invite to explore analogies with pulsars where particle acceleration takes place in two stages . in the first stage ,
particle acceleration occurs in the gaps of a charge - separated magnetosphere anchored in the ergosphere of a rotating black hole , and in a second stage at shock waves in the force - free wind beyond the outer light cylinder .
we would like to thank the instituto de astrofsica de canarias for the excellent working conditions at the observatorio del roque de los muchachos in la palma . the support of the german bmbf and mpg , the italian infn , the swiss national fund snf , and the spanish micinn is gratefully acknowledged .
this work was also supported by the cpan csd2007 - 00042 and multidark csd2009 - 00064 projects of the spanish consolider - ingenio 2010 programme , by grant 127740 of the academy of finland , by the dfg cluster of excellence `` origin and structure of the universe '' , by the croatian science foundation ( hrzz ) projects 09/176 , by the university of rijeka project 13.12.1.3.02 , by the dfg collaborative research centers sfb823/c4 and sfb876/c3 , and by the polish mniszw grant 745/n - hess - magic/2010/0 .
we thank also the support by dfg wi 1860/10 - 1 .
j. s. was supported by erdf and the spanish mineco through fpa2012 - 39502 and jci-2011 - 10019 grants .
e. r. was partially supported by the spanish mineco projects aya2009 - 13036-c02 - 02 and aya2012 - 38491-c02 - 01 and by the generalitat valenciana project prometeo/2009/104 , as well as by the cost mp0905 action black holes in a violent universe. the european vlbi network is a joint facility of european , chinese , south african and other radio astronomy institutes funded by their national research councils . the research leading to these results has received funding from the european commission seventh framework programme ( fp/2007 - 2013 ) under grant agreement no .
283393 ( radionet3 ) .
99 f. aharonian , _ et al .
_ , _ apj _ * 664 * , l71 ( 2007 ) .
j. albert , _
_ , _ apj _ * 669 * , 862 ( 2007 ) .
j. aleksi , _ et al .
_ , _ apj _ * 723 * , l207 ( 2010 ) .
j. aleksi , _ et al .
_ , _ astroparticle physics _ * 35 * , 435 ( 2012 ) .
j. aleksi , _ et al .
_ , _ a&a _ * 563 * , a91 ( 2014a ) .
j. aleksi , _ et al .
_ , _ science _ , * 346 * , 1080 ( 2014b ) .
j. aleksi , _ et al .
_ , arxiv:1409.5594 ( 2014 ) m. v. barkov , f. a. aharonian , v. bosch - ramon , _
apj _ * 724 * , 1517 ( 2010 ) .
w. bednarek , r. j. protheroe , _ mnras _ * 287 * , l9 ( 1997 ) . v. s. beskin , y. n. istomin , v. i. parev , _ sovast _ * 36 * , 642 ( 1992 ) .
r. d. blandford , r.l .
znajek , _ mnras _ * 179 * , 433 ( 1977 ) .
a. domnguez , _ et al .
_ , _ mnras _ * 410 * , 2556 ( 2011 ) .
d. giannios , d. a. uzdensky , m. c. begelman , _ mnras _ * 402 * , 1649 ( 2010 ) .
e. w. greisen , _ information handling in astronomy - historical vistas _ * 285 * , 109 ( 2003 )
. k. gltekin , _ et al .
_ , _ apj _ * 698 * , 198 ( 2009 ) .
m. kadler , _ et al .
_ , _ a&a _ * 538 * , l1 ( 2012 ) .
a. levinson , f. rieger , _ apj _ * 730 * , 123 ( 2011 ) .
m. l. lister , _ et al .
_ , _ aj _ * 146 * , 120 ( 2013 ) . g. k. miley , _ annu
_ * 18 * , 165 ( 1980 ) .
r. narayan , & t. piran , _ mnras _ , * 420 * , 604 ( 2012 ) .
a. neronov , f. a. aharonian , _ apj _ * 671 * , 85 ( 2007 ) .
a. y. neronov , d. v. semikoz , i. i. tkachev , _ new journal of physics _
* 11 * , 065015 ( 2009 ) .
a. neronov , d. semikov , i. vovk , _ a&a _ * 519 * , l6 ( 2010 ) . m. j.neeser , s. a. eales , j. d. law - green , _ apj _ * 451 * , 76 ( 1995 ) . t. a. rector , j. t. stocke , e. s. perlman , _ apj _ * 516 * , 145 ( 1999 ) . f. m. rieger , k. mannheim , _
a&a _ * 353 * , 473 ( 2000 ) .
m. ryle , m. d. windram , _ mnras _ * 138 * , 1 ( 1968 ) .
m. c. shepherd , t. j. pearson , g. b. taylor ( 1994 ) , vol .
987 - 989 .
d. sijbring , a. g. de bruyn , _
a&a _ * 331 * , 901 ( 1998 ) r. zanin , _ et al .
_ , _ proc .
to the 33@xmath66 icrc , i d .
0773 , rio de janerio , brazil _ | ic 310 has recently been identified as a gamma - ray emitter based on observations at gev energies with fermi - lat and at very high energies ( vhe , @xmath0 gev ) with the magic telescopes . despite ic 310 having been classified as a radio galaxy with
the jet observed at an angle @xmath1 degrees , it exhibits a mixture of multiwavelength properties of a radio galaxy and a blazar , possibly making it a transitional object . on the night of 12/13@xmath2 of november 2012 the magic telescopes observed a series of violent outbursts from the direction of ic 310 with flux - doubling time scales faster than 5 min and a peculiar spectrum spreading over 2 orders of magnitude .
such fast variability constrains the size of the emission region to be smaller than 20% of the gravitational radius of its central black hole , challenging the shock acceleration models , commonly used in explanation of gamma - ray radiation from active galaxies . here
we will show that this emission can be associated with pulsar - like particle acceleration by the electric field across a magnetospheric gap at the base of the jet . |
the dawning of the era of precision cosmology demands that we understand the history of our universe theoretically with the same accuracy as experiment .
the _ wmap _ determination of acoustic peaks in the cmb spectrum to 1% accuracy has given strong support to the existence of an era of inflation @xcite .
inflation , famously , predicts the primordial power spectrum of density fluctuations underlying all structure in the universe .
this ability of _ wmap _ and future _ planck _ data @xcite to constrain theoretical models of the early universe has set off a scramble to delineate a theoretically controlled computation of the primordial inflationary power spectrum .
the textbook approach makes a number of explicit and implicit assumptions , each of which can affect the power spectrum at the accuracy measured .
the main assumption is that the density spectrum can be reduced to that of an adiabatic fluid whose excitations are always weakly coupled to gravity .
this can be conveniently encoded in a single scalar field lagrangian with bunch - davies initial conditions in a fixed inflationary cosmology without metric fluctuations .
the most obvious issue with these assumptions is that the redshifts implied by the 60 @xmath1-folds of inflation necessary to solve the horizon and flatness problem , place the relevant momentum scales in an energy regime far beyond the planck - scale , where in principle gravitational backreaction and quantum - gravity corrections can not be ignored @xcite .
turning the issue around , it also implies a window of opportunity that quantum gravity or any other new physics arising at high energy scales could have a measurable effect on the power spectrum .
this question was actively pursued some time ago with the conclusion that in toy models @xcite one can obtain measurable corrections of the order @xmath0 , comparable to intrinsic cosmic variance , with @xmath2 the hubble scale and @xmath3 the scale of new physics @xcite . to truly connect with the data one needs the _ universal generic _ model - independent corrections to the power spectrum in terms of an effective field theory that encodes order by order the corrections due to new physics at high scales as well as deviations from adiabaticity .
how to account for new physics is formally well - understood in terms of wilsonian effective actions , and for the adiabatic mode this has been actively pursued recently @xcite . however , wilsonian effective actions are only consistent provided adiabaticity is maintained @xcite . in practice
this has meant that energy is assumed to be a conserved quantity .
but precisely this is impossible in a cosmological time - dependent background
. redshifts continuously mix the regimes of various scales and strictly speaking a well - defined separation of energy can not be maintained .
this long - standing paradox has fundamentally hampered the construction of low energy effective theories in cosmological spacetimes , _ literally _ since energy is not a conserved quantity . in a previous letter
@xcite we provided an algorithmic solution to this obstacle to compute the generic new physics corrections to the inflationary power spectrum .
one can generate the universal low energy effective action by integrating out a massive field in any particular new physics model .
this is sensible in a cosmological setting , as long as one computes late time expectation values directly in non - equilibrium real - time qft via the schwinger - keldysh approach .
one of the principal difficulties found in previous approaches was the correct procedure to implement an energy and momentum scale cutoff in a time - dependent background ; in intermediate steps the order of energy and momentum integrals now no longer commute .
we have overcome this through the realization that the contributions from the massive field may be reliably captured in a stationary - phase approximation for vertex evaluation .
this localizes interactions to fixed moments in time and allows us to unambigously implement the cutoff in momenta .
there are several noteworthy features that this algorithmic solution reveals : * most importantly , new physics and non - adiabatic corrections no longer separate . integrating out the heavy field not only causes changes in the action , but also in the effective density matrix of the low - energy field .
the former can account for non - adiabatic effects .
* the non - adiabatic terms are non - local in position space , but localized on a new physics hypersurface where the physical momentum @xmath4 equals the mass of the heavy field @xmath5 .
intuitively this is what should happen and was the basis of many earlier _ ad hoc _ models .
here it is a consequence of integrating out the heavy field . *
these terms can be interpreted as modified initial conditions for the low - energy adiabatic inflaton .
this again confirms the qualitative insights gained from toy models , but now quantitatively . in this article
we apply this cosmological effective field theory approach to the cosmologically relevant scenario of slow - roll inflation .
we compute the corrections to the scalar power spectrum resulting from interactions with a heavy field . parametrizing the corrections in a manner expedient to comparison with observational data ,
the _ universal generic _ correction to the scalar power spectrum due to unknown high - energy physics equals @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the first slow - roll coefficient .
the power of the approach , however , is that each of the variables @xmath8 can be _ computed _ in terms of the parameters of whichever theoretical model for the unknown new physics one has in mind . for the power spectrum the result is merely an amplitude correction , but it will be very interesting to see the effect in higher - order correlation functions . this article is organized as follows . in
2 we present a simple model of slow - roll inflation containing new physics at high energies and analyze the field fluctuations in two gauges which will prove useful . in
3 we review the in - in formalism and how to compute field fluctuation correlations for our theory . in
4 we calculate the scalar and tensor power spectra in the spatially flat gauge , then convert these to the uniform density gauge and parametrize the answer in a way which facilitates easy comparison against observation . in 5 we discuss observational prospects and
the minimal action description for inflation is a scalar field coupled to gravity , @xmath9 = \int d^4 x \sqrt{g } \left [ \frac{1}{2 } m_{\rm pl}^2 r - \frac{1}{2 } ( \partial \phi)^2 - v_{\rm inf}(\phi ) \right ] .\ ] ] we assume a spatially homogeneous ansatz for the background metric @xmath10 defining @xmath11 , the background equations of motion are @xmath12 ^ 2 - \frac{12 \pi}{m^2_{\rm pl } } h ( \phi)^2 & = & - \frac{32 \pi^2}{m^4_{\rm pl } } v(\phi).\end{aligned}\ ] ] primes denote derivatives with respect to the field , while overdots denote derivatives with respect to coordinate time . to facilitate analysis of inflating solutions , one defines the ( first ) hubble slow - roll parameter @xmath7 @xmath13 ^ 2.\ ] ] inflation occurs for @xmath14 and ends when @xmath15 , which we use to define @xmath16
. it will prove useful to also define a second slow - roll parameter , @xmath17 one could continue defining an infinite hierarchy of such parameters @xmath18 , but this will be sufficient for our purposes .
of course there is a direct relationship between @xmath19 and @xmath20 .
this is given by @xmath21 it will be helpful to define the so - called
potential slow- roll " parameters @xmath22 we can then invert this to express @xmath20 in terms of @xmath23 , with exact solutions possible in the case of power - law inflation .
we may take the initial value of the inflaton to be @xmath24 , so that the potential near this point is approximated as @xmath25 where @xmath26 are all constants .
thus @xmath23 , and hence @xmath20 , can be solved for in terms of these coupling constants . to the inflationary action ( [ sinf ] )
we then add a massive field @xmath27 with renormalizable interactions to the inflaton : @xmath28 & = & - \int d^4 x \sqrt{g } \left [ \frac{1}{2 } ( \partial \chi)^2 + \frac{1}{2 } m^2 \chi^2 \right .
\\ & & \left .
\hspace{1 in } + \frac{g_1}{2 } \phi^2 \chi + \frac{g_2}{2 } \phi \chi^2 \right ] .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] we will be working to cubic order in field fluctuations , but are only interested in single contractions of the heavy field fluctuations , justifying our expansion in @xmath27 to second order .
the combined action @xmath29 will then produce an inflationary period but contain new physics at scales determined by the couplings @xmath30 and mass scale @xmath3
. a naive approach , based on static background quantum field theory intuition , might be the following : since we are presumed to be below the energy scale where @xmath27-quanta can be created , we can simply integrate out this field to yield the following effective ` new physics ' potential for @xmath31 : @xmath32 this is incorrect , for a variety of reasons . in the remainder of this article
we will delineate the correct procedure to obtain the effective description .
let us now assume that the spatially - homogeneous component @xmath33 satisfies its own equations of motion to lowest order in @xmath30 and consider fluctuations around this background , @xmath34 although our observable of interest is the @xmath35-power spectrum which does not usually require gauge - fixing , we wish to incorporate the effects of interactions for which the inflaton field and metric fluctuations mix together , requiring the construction of gauge - invariant quantities .
we therefore also consider tensor fluctuations .
utilizing the adm formalism , we parametrize the metric as @xmath36 with @xmath37 the lapse function and @xmath38 the shift vector .
substituting this into the action produces @xmath39 \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath40 the equations of motion for @xmath37 and @xmath38 are just the hamiltonian and momenta constraints , @xmath41 \\ \nonumber & & - \frac{\partial_i \phi ( { \dot \phi } - n^j \partial_j \phi)}{n } - \frac{\partial_i \chi ( { \dot \chi } - n^j \partial_j \chi)}{n}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] in solving for @xmath37 and @xmath38 we can ignore the effect of @xmath27 ; as we assume a single - field inflation model , rather the the hybrid - inflation model of @xmath31 and @xmath27 .
this is valid because the corrections to the free equations of motion will be @xmath42 .
since this is the same order as the fluctuations we are computing , we may trust our unperturbed background solution .
there are two choices of gauge we will employ : spatially flat and uniform density . that is , using different gauges we may exchange perturbations in @xmath31 for ( certain ) perturbations in @xmath43 and vice - versa
. both will be useful at different points in our calculation .
we will perform the interaction calculations inside the horizon using the spatially flat gauge .
this corresponds to the choice @xmath44 fluctuations are then parametrized by @xmath45 and @xmath27 .
we now need the solution for @xmath46 in terms of these fluctuations .
since we are interested in quadratic fluctuations of @xmath35 and @xmath47 , it suffices to compute the background corrections to first order .
this is because any third order terms for the background would multiply the zero - order terms for the fields , which are automatically satisfied .
we denote @xmath48 so that @xmath49 is a first - order perturbation , as is @xmath38 .
the solutions are given by @xmath50 substituting this back into the action ( [ admaction ] ) yields ( to lowest relevant order ) @xmath51 .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] note the appearance of a small inflaton mass induced from the gauge - fixing . in writing this
we have omitted the @xmath52 mass - mixing term which is subleading in @xmath0 .
additionally , we have neglected all interactions which do not contain @xmath27 , since we are only interested in the effect of this heavy field .
one of these neglected terms , the @xmath53 coupling , produces an @xmath54-scale interaction and it would be interesting to compare this to the result obtained here .
we save this for a future study .
at the moment of scalar fluctuation horizon crossing we then convert these to the uniform density gauge since these will then stay constant and are good observables .
this gauge corresponds to the choice @xmath55 , \\
\partial_i { \gamma}_{ij } & = & 0 , \hspace{0.4 in } { \gamma}_{ii } = 0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the @xmath27 and @xmath56 fluctuations remain identical , while scalar fluctuations are now parametrized by @xmath57 .
the conversion between gauges is @xmath58 of course , were we to include the effects of @xmath27 on the background evolution , this hybrid - inflation model would _ not _ have constant scalar fluctuations . but as addressed previously , the leading - order @xmath27-fluctuations employ a single - field background and hence these fluctuations will still have constant superhorizon @xmath57 .
quantum field theory in a static background most often employs the `` in - out '' formalism to produce scattering amplitudes . defining the states @xmath59 and @xmath60 in the asymptotic past and future , respectively ,
amplitudes are defined as @xmath61 cross - sections are then obtained by squaring the amplitude . for non - equilibrium systems , such as a cosmological background , the fundamentally sound approach to computing expectation values such as the power spectrum is the schwinger - keldysh approach @xcite .
the procedure is the following . at some early time @xmath62 ( in the present context , the onset of inflation )
we begin with a pure state @xmath63 , then evolve the system for the bra- and ket - state separately until some late time @xmath64 , when we evaluate the expectation value : @xmath65 traditionally , the in - state @xmath59 is taken to be the bunch - davies vacuum state @xcite , but this is not necessarily so . expanding cosmological backgrounds allow for a more general class of vacua , which can be heuristically considered to be excited states of inflaton fluctuations . in the present context , we will find that integrating out high - energy physics generically results in boundary terms in the effective action , which represent such excited states . if we denote the fields representing the `` evolving '' ket to be @xmath66 and those for the `` devolving '' bra to be @xmath67 , the in - in expectation value ( [ inincorrelation ] ) can be computed from the action @xmath68 - s[\varphi_- , \chi_-,{\gamma}_{ij,- } ] .\ ] ] together with the constraint that @xmath69 , @xmath70 and @xmath71 .
it is then helpful to transform into the keldysh basis , @xmath72 in this basis the total action ( [ keldyshaction ] ) equals @xmath73 = \\
\label{skeld } \nonumber & & - \int d^3 { \bf x } dt \ a(t)^3 \left [ - m^2_{\rm pl } \partial { \bar \gamma}_{ij } \partial { \gamma}_{ij } + \partial { \bar \varphi } \partial \phi + j \phi \right . \\ \nonumber & & + \left ( m^2 - \frac{2}{a^3 } \frac{d}{dt } \left ( a^3 h \epsilon_1 \right ) \right ) { \bar \varphi } \phi + \partial { \bar \chi } \partial { \rm x } + m^2 { \bar \chi } { \rm x } \\ \nonumber & & + g_1 { \bar \varphi } \phi { \bar \chi } + \frac{g_1}{2 } \left ( { \bar \varphi}^2 + \frac { { \phi}^2}{4 } \right ) { \rm x } + g_2 { \bar \chi } { \rm x } { \bar \varphi}+ \frac{g_2}{2 } \left ( { \bar \chi}^2 + \frac { { \rm x}^2}{4 } \right ) { \phi } \\ \label{keldyshinteractions } & & \left .
+ { \bar { \gamma}}_{ij } \partial_i { \bar \chi } \partial_j { \rm x } + \frac{1}{2 } \gamma_{ij } \left ( \partial_i { \bar \chi } \partial_j { \bar \chi } + \frac{1}{4 } \partial_i { \rm x } \partial_j { \rm x } \right ) \right].\end{aligned}\ ] ]
although we started with a pure state in ( [ inincorrelation ] ) , in general we could take expectation values with respect to a mixed state , @xmath74 here the density matrix @xmath75 is normalized so that @xmath76 . in the path integral
language , the density matrix is equal to the logarithm of the imaginary component of the action , so that @xmath77 we will find that integrating out @xmath27 will generically lead to a mixed state for @xmath35 and @xmath56 , since we are removing states from a unitary process .
the equations of motion for the fluctuations are @xmath78 we will now solve these perturbatively .
the feynman rules are summarized by figure [ feynman ] , where we have used the same diagrammatic notation as in @xcite . , dashed single lines indicate those of @xmath79 , with analogous notation for double lines indicating the heavy field components @xmath80 , wiggly lines indicating the graviton component @xmath81 and circled dots for @xmath82 . ,
title="fig:",width=336 ] + + + we first consider the free fluctuation equations of motion . to do this
it is helpful to switch to conformal time @xmath83 defined by @xmath84 neglecting the interactions in equations ( [ perts ] ) , then fourier transforming into the comoving momentum basis , they become @xmath85 here we have introduced the conformal hubble parameter @xmath86 and suppressed all indices on @xmath87 . the solution for @xmath88
is given by the hankel function of the first kind , @xmath89 if we expand in terms of the slow - roll parameters , this is the familiar expression @xmath90 the linearly independent solution @xmath91 is simply the complex conjugate and hence uses @xmath92 . for the massive @xmath27-fluctuations
the free field solution is also a hankel function but can written more transparently using the wkb approximation as @xmath93}{\sqrt { 2 } \left ( k^2 + \frac{m^2}{h(\tau)^2 \tau^2 } \right)^{1/4 } } .\ ] ] the time - dependent frequency here is @xmath94 , and the wkb approximation @xmath95 is always valid for @xmath96 . for @xmath97-fluctuations the free solution is again given by hankel function but of a different order , @xmath98 we may then iteratively solve for higher - order solutions to the fluctuations , @xmath99 fourier transforming into comoving momentum , these vertices can be evaluated using the retarded green s function @xmath100 can be written in terms of the fluctuation solutions , @xmath101 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] these are shown in figure [ classical_perturbations ] .
the advanced green s function @xmath102 is then simply the time - reversal of this : @xmath103 note that comoving momentum is conserved at vertices .
a similar procedure applies for @xmath104 and @xmath105 using their corresponding retarded green s function @xmath106 and @xmath107 , @xmath108 , \\
\nonumber \mathcal g^a_{\bf k}(\tau_1,\tau_2 ) & \equiv & \mathcal g^r_{\bf k}(\tau_2,\tau_1 ) , \\
\mathbb g^r_{\bf k}(\tau_1,\tau_2 ) & \equiv & i \langle { \bar \gamma}^{(0)}_{\bf k } ( \tau_1 ) \gamma^{(0)}_{\bf -k}(\tau_2 ) \rangle \\ \nonumber & = & - 2 \theta(\tau_1-\tau_2 ) { \rm i m } \left [ w_{\bf k}(\tau_1 ) w^*_{\bf k } ( \tau_2 ) \right ] , \\ \nonumber \mathbb g^a_{\bf k}(\tau_1,\tau_2 ) & \equiv & \mathbb g^r_{\bf k}(\tau_2,\tau_1 ) .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] of course the solution may then be iterated again to obtain yet even higher - order solutions , @xmath109 note that for fluctuations the slow - roll parameters @xmath110 are implicitly included , and that the order of the solution refers to the order of the couplings @xmath30 .
induced by interactions .
crosses indicate the zeroth - order solution @xmath111 or @xmath112.,title="fig : " ] induced by interactions .
crosses indicate the zeroth - order solution @xmath111 or @xmath112.,title="fig : " ] after obtaining @xmath113 to our desired order , we may then take statistical averages of the zeroth order solutions via @xmath114 , \\ 0 &
= & \langle \phi^{(0)}_{\bf k}(\tau_1 ) \phi^{(0)}_{\bf -k}(\tau_2 ) \rangle , \\
\mathcal f_{\bf k}(\tau_1,\tau_2 ) & = & \langle { \bar \chi}^{(0)}_{\bf k}(\tau_1 ) { \bar \chi}^{(0)}_{\bf -k}(\tau_2 ) \rangle \\ & = & { \rm re } \left [ v_{\bf k}(\tau_1 ) v^*_{\bf k } ( \tau_2 ) \right ] , \\ 0 & = & \langle { \rm x}^{(0)}_{\bf k}(\tau_1 ) { \rm x}^{(0)}_{\bf -k}(\tau_2 ) \rangle , \\
\mathbb f_{\bf k}(\tau_1,\tau_2 ) & = & \langle { \bar \gamma}^{(0)}_{\bf k}(\tau_1 ) { \bar \gamma}^{(0)}_{\bf -k}(\tau_2 ) \rangle \\ & = & { \rm re } \left [ w_{\bf k}(\tau_1 ) w^*_{\bf k } ( \tau_2 ) \right ] , \\ 0 & = & \langle \gamma^{(0)}_{\bf k}(\tau_1 ) \gamma^{(0)}_{\bf -k}(\tau_2 ) \rangle \end{aligned}\ ] ] to get correlations .
this can be heuristically thought of as gluing the crosses together in all possible ways .
an example is shown in figure [ classical_corrections ] .
@xmath115 @xmath116 @xmath117 while this may produce feynman diagrams with loops , representing integrals over comoving momentum , _ they are nonetheless completely classical_. an important difference of the in - in formalism is that loops may represent statistical , but not quantum , fluctuations .
-fluctuation backreaction .
this can be absorbed into the definition of @xmath118.,title="fig : " ] + the introduction of fluctuations means that the background solution will be slightly modified due to backreaction .
this is an @xmath119 correction to the linear coupling @xmath118 , as shown in figure [ linear_bg_corrections ] , having the value @xmath120 the apparent time - dependence is illusory , as follows .
let us convert the integral over comoving momentum into one over physical momentum .
in static - background qft loop regularization one imposes a uv cutoff @xmath121 on the wick - rotated 4-momentum , thus respecting lorentz symmetry .
since the quasi - de sitter background of inflation breaks lorentz symmetry ( ` energy ' is ill - defined ) we can not impose such a cutoff , but comoving momentum _ is _ conserved , and therefore we can perform an equivalent procedure as follows . via ( [ chisol ] ) the @xmath27-field s conjugate variable to time is given by @xmath122 thus we may place a cutoff on @xmath123 at some scale , effectively imposing a cutoff on @xmath124 .
let us momentarily assume that @xmath2 is constant , allowing us to estimate the correction as @xmath125 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] this is independent of @xmath2 , assuring us that it is the same answer one would get from a static spacetime answer had we simply truncated @xmath126 .
this time - independent correction can then be cancelled by appropriate redefinition of @xmath118 .
a similar procedure can of course be done for the tadpole of @xmath27 , as shown in figure 3 .
here we will give the explicit formula for computing the scalar and tensor power spectrum in our high - energy model .
we will need to know the correlation of inflaton fluctuations at the moment of horizon crossing , @xmath127 to evaluate this perturbatively , substitute the classical solution @xmath128 into this expression . in the decoupling limit @xmath129 or @xmath130 ,
the inflaton fluctuation power spectrum is simply @xmath131 where @xmath132 is the horizon - crossing time of mode @xmath133 , @xmath134 .
the first order corrections are then : @xmath135 there are no interactions in the action ( [ keldyshinteractions ] ) which will produce this , and so we turn to the second order contributions , @xmath136 there are a total of four diagrams which could possibly contribute at @xmath137 , shown in figure [ ps_corrections ]
. we will give explicit expressions for the first two , @xmath138 \mathcal f_{\bf q+k}(\tau_1,\tau_2 ) f_{\bf q}(\tau_1,\tau_2 ) \left [ -i g^a_{\bf k}(\tau_2,\tau_k ) \right ] , \\ p^{({\rm b})}_{\varphi}(k ) & = & \frac{k^3}{2 \pi^2 } \left ( -i g_1 \right)^2 \int_{\tau_{\rm in}}^{\tau_k } d \tau_1 \
a(\tau_1)^4 \int_{\tau_{\rm in}}^{\tau_k } d \tau_2 \
a(\tau_2)^4 \times \\ & & \hspace{-0.9 in } \int \frac{d ^3 \bf q}{(2 \pi)^3 } \left [ -i g^r_{\bf k}(\tau_k,\tau_1 ) \right ] [ - i g^r_{\bf k}(\tau_1,\tau_2 ) ] \left [ -i \mathcal g^r_{\bf 0}(\tau_1,\tau_2 ) \right ] [ -i g^a_{\bf q}(\tau_2,\tau_k ) ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] + we first dissect the interaction at the vertex before evaluating the full diagram .
since the time coordinate is integrated over , vertex evaluation is very different than in standard quantum field theory .
writing out the green s and wightman s functions in terms of @xmath139 s and @xmath140 s , we see there are three types of cubic vertices .
we will evaluate each .
the first is @xmath141 the superscript @xmath133 indicates there is some dependence upon the moment that the mode leaves the horizon .
since we assume all interactions happen well inside the horizon , a good approximation is @xmath142 , \hspace{0.2 in } k | \tau| \gg 1\ ] ] where @xmath143 is given by ( [ varphisol ] ) . to leading order in the slow - roll parameters ,
the scale factor is given by @xmath144 substituting this into ( [ vertexa ] ) results in the expression @xmath145 where the phase is given by @xmath146 let us now introduce the rescaled time coordinate @xmath147 such that @xmath148 to obtain the differential , recall that the hubble scale changes with time as @xmath149 where @xmath150 is some reference time and @xmath151 is some the hubble scale at this time .
then @xmath152 in this variable it is clear that @xmath153 admits a stationary phase approximation at the energy - conservation moment @xmath154 .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] the variation in slow - roll phase is given by @xmath155 and so is higher - order in slow - roll and can be neglected .
the solution then defines the nph , @xmath156 expanding the phase near this stationary point gives the inflection @xmath157 then to leading order in @xmath0 and slow - roll parameters the amplitude is @xmath158^{1/4 } \sqrt{hm}}\right|_{\tau_c } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the physics of this is clear .
this diagram accounts for the threshold production / decay of heavy particles at high redshift in the early universe .
although this induced term is localized in time , it is @xmath133-dependent and thus does not represent a physical boundary .
rather , it represents a ` hypersurface ' representing the energy scale of interaction , precisely as expected in the new physics hypersurace approach .
the second possible vertex is identical to @xmath153 but with one @xmath139 conjugated , @xmath159 this has only imaginary - time saddlepoint solutions .
since our @xmath83-integral is confined to the real axis we will never pass over this point in our integration , and so this amplitude will be suppressed as @xmath160 except for @xmath161 , when the saddlepoint moves to infinity and the inflection vanishes . in all other cases we may neglect such interactions .
finally we consider @xmath162 which has both @xmath139 s conjugated and so admits no saddlepoint solutions , and thus can also be neglected . in both @xmath163 and @xmath164
coordinate systems .
constant-@xmath83 contours are shown in blue , and a constant-@xmath123 contour is shown in red .
the low - energy phase space allowed in our integration is shown in gray.,width=288 ] after the vertex evaluation it remains to perform the integration over loop momentum .
let us first consider diagram @xmath165 , @xmath166 this is non - trivial for two reasons .
first , we wish to implement a physical cutoff , and so a change of coordinates is required .
second , loop momentum influences the time of vertex interaction via @xmath167 , and so affects the hubble scale .
thus we need to convert the integral over comoving momentum to one over time of interaction . to accomplish this ,
first simplify the 3d integral to 2d , @xmath168 now replace the coordinates @xmath169 with @xmath170 via the definitions @xmath171 of course the definition of @xmath83 coincides with @xmath172 , since this is the stationary - phase localized time of interaction . inverting these coordinate systems gives @xmath173 the measure transforms as @xmath174 the integral in ( [ pa ] ) is then transformed as @xmath175 the phase @xmath31 cancels out in this amplitude and so we need not evaluate it .
we can now easily place limits on the region of integration in terms of the energy scale @xmath121 : [ [ maximal - q ] ] maximal @xmath176 + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + as done previously , we place a limit on the physical energy to be @xmath121 . using the fact that the vertex with a virtual @xmath35 and an external @xmath35 of comoving momentum @xmath177 have precisely the energy of the @xmath27-field , the bound is found to be @xmath178 [ [ minimal - e ] ] minimal @xmath123 + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + since @xmath179 this places a minimal limit on @xmath123 , @xmath180 although this is time - dependent , it remains scale - invariant because it contains only the combination @xmath181 .
[ [ initial - and - final - tau ] ] initial and final @xmath83 + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + of course we require @xmath182 . their equality will determine the earliest and latest times for which this condition is valid , an equation which is quadratic in @xmath83 .
the two solutions are given by @xmath183 where we have defined @xmath184 the later root is @xmath185 whereas the earlier root is @xmath186 this will always be after the point where the external energy parameter @xmath187 reaches @xmath121 , so we are assured that all energy scales under consideration are below @xmath121 .
figure [ loopspace ] shows the phase space in the two coordinate systems .
this gives us a window @xmath188 in which to integrate out this high - energy interaction in a controlled way .
note that choosing @xmath189 makes this window vanish , a reassuring fact since ( by definition ) there should not be any interactions below the scale of new physics .
there is an upper bound on @xmath121 as well : the interactions must cease before the gauge - transformation at the horizon - exit near @xmath190 ( whereupon our plane - wave approximation would break down ) .
this means we are allowed to set the cutoff scale in the window @xmath191 for a typical value of @xmath192 , this means we can set @xmath193 , which should be adequate for the low - energy behavior .
we now expand the hubble rate around the reference point @xmath194 , and keeping only the leading term in @xmath195 , the integral is evaluated as @xmath196 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the power spectrum correction is then @xmath197 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] diagram b can be evaluated in an identical fashion , except for two subtleties : the heaviside function in the green s function allow only half of the gaussian fluctuations to contribute , and the two @xmath198 s produce a sign change .
thus @xmath199 diagrams c and d can also be evaluated in a similar fashion , and to leading order in @xmath0 they cancel .
summing diagrams a , b , c and d results in the following total shift in the scalar power spectrum , @xmath200 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath201 and @xmath202 , the correction then scales as @xmath203 .
figure [ pk ] shows these corrections to the power spectrum in the example theory . as a result of the hubble scale changing.,width=288 ]
we did not include a @xmath204 coupling in our high - energy model , nor are there any induced by gauge - fixing ; hence the tensor spectrum is the same as the standard slow - roll case .
the gravitational power spectrum is @xmath205 in the de sitter limit of @xmath206 , the result is a perfectly scale - invariant correction , @xmath207 let us verify that we should have anticipated this by simply computing the physical momentum @xmath208 at the nph for some fluctuation of comoving momentum @xmath133 : @xmath209 so the nph is indeed at a fixed energy scale for all modes .
a second verification is to compute the period of interaction near this nph .
after all , we used a stationary phase approximation which includes the gaussian fluctuations around the stationary phase , giving the nph a finite width .
re - expressed in terms of physical time @xmath210 shows this interaction period also remains scale - invariant : @xmath211 figure [ tpschematic2 ] shows a schematic of this .
is again indicated , as well as the cutoff scale @xmath121 .
the comoving momentum of a fluctuation is given by its slope .
the high - energy interactions in the blue region can be effectively described as excited initial states for the inflaton .
the fact that all fluctuations encounter new physics at ( nearly ) the same energy scale ensures that the answer is ( nearly ) scale - invariant . ]
the dependence upon @xmath0 is also worth commenting upon .
recall the argument presented by @xcite in considering the low - energy expansions of local operators , @xmath212 .\ ] ] fluctuations frozen at @xmath213 will then have a power spectrum scaling as @xmath214 displaying high - energy corrections at order @xmath215 .
the addition of boundary terms such as @xmath216 then modifies the power spectrum at order @xmath0 , potentially a more significant observable effect .
clearly , ( [ psa ] ) does not reflect this expectation . where did the argument fail ?
the answer lies in the assumption of a local operator expansion .
the operators in a uv - complete theory are of course local , and this property is also respected by the low - energy ( @xmath217 ) expansion of massive green s functions in static spacetime : @xmath218 \delta^4(x - y ) .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the green s ( and wightman s ) function used in quasi - de sitter backgrounds , however , do not yield local effective forms . instead ,
the appropriate expansion parameter is @xmath96 which we have seen via the stationary phase approximation is an approximation to energy conservation . in this expansion ,
non - local operators are generated which betray the expectation of the small momentum expansion .
this was explicitly shown in @xcite . using the gauge - conversion in eq .
( [ gaugeconversion ] ) , the scalar perturbation is then @xmath219 the advantage of using comoving @xmath133 to parametrize the power spectrum is that there is a well - defined map to the cmb @xmath220-modes . to compare such predictions
to observation requires summarizing the power spectrum ( [ finalps ] ) by a few parameters which can then be constrained by the data .
the late - time limit of the modefunction is @xmath221 .\ ] ] here we have used the abbreviation @xmath222 where @xmath56 is the euler - mascheroni constant .
following the example of martin and ringeval @xcite , we can then parametrize the scalar power spectrum as : @xmath223 where @xmath224 , \\ \nonumber a^{\rm ( s)}_1 & = & - 2 \epsilon_1 - \epsilon_2 - \frac{g_1 ^ 2
\lambda^3}{24 \pi m^4 h _ * } \left ( 6 \epsilon_1 + \epsilon_2 \right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] while the search for oscillations in the _ wmap3 _ data @xcite failed to show evidence for such high - energy oscillations , the _ planck _ satellite data will be of much higher resolution and is worth investigating .
we discuss this matter further in the concluding section . for the gravity waves , which have no explicit high - energy interactions
, the spectrum reduces to the standard slow - roll result .
the late - time limit of the modefunction is @xmath225.\ ] ] the parametrization is then @xmath226 where @xmath227
in summary , we have developed a technique to explicitly calculate the generic corrections to the inflaton power spectrum from fundamental high energy physics .
these can be connected to microscopic models through a `` generalized '' boundary effective field theory as in @xcite .
why does the naive effective action of the power spectrum fail ? for three reasons : 1 .
correlation functions ( such as the power spectrum ) must be computed using the in - in formalism , significantly altering the role of classical and quantum fluctuations .
the expanding background means that heavy fluctuations can now be excited on - shell .
3 . the interactions producing such heavy modes ( whether on - shell or virtual ) are now localized at specific moments in time , giving rise to effective interaction boundary terms .
because there are no distinct features in the power spectrum , any visible new physics will probably need to be found in higher order correlations .
the bispectrum , or 3-point correlation @xcite , for this example model will vanish to leading order in slow - roll , but more general models should have the effects of inflaton self - interactions and modified vacua multiplying @xcite .
our results justify the conjecture made in @xcite that effective actions and modified vacua are expected in tandem .
one distinct hope is that the bispectrum may be oscillatory . for the trispectrum , or 4-point correlation @xcite ,
little has been done in the way of categorizing such correlations and we can not give a complete analysis here , but let us summarize a few basic ideas .
our model has leading - order trispectrum terms of types @xmath228 and @xmath229 .
these include the characteristic oscillations which are now squared , and would display high - energy signatures even if the oscillation frequency @xmath230 were too small to be observed by the power spectrum . looking towards complete understanding , further details of the cutoff procedure ,
renormalization group properties and vacuum selection in an expanding background need to be well - understood .
we would like to thank a. achcarro , r. easther , s. galli , b. greene , d. langlois , j. martin , p. d. meerburg , s. mooij , g. palma , c. ringeval , d. spergel , t. van der aalst , b. wandelt and especially m. kleban for helpful discussions and comments on this article .
this research was supported in part by a vidi and a vici innovative research incentive award from the netherlands organisation for scientific research ( nwo ) , a van gogh grant from the nwo , and the dutch foundation for fundamental research on matter ( fom ) .
e. komatsu _ et al .
_ [ wmap collaboration ] , arxiv:1001.4538 [ astro-ph.co ] ; d. larson _
_ [ wmap collaboration ] , arxiv:1001.4635 [ astro-ph.co ] .
[ planck collaboration ] , `` planck : the scientific programme , '' arxiv : astro - ph/0604069 .
r. easther , b. r. greene , w. h. kinney and g. shiu , phys .
d * 67 * , 063508 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0110226 ] .
r. easther , b. r. greene , w. h. kinney and g. shiu , phys .
d * 66 * , 023518 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0204129 ] .
m. porrati , arxiv : hep - th/0409210 .
j. hamann , s. hannestad , m. s. sloth and y. y. y. wong , jcap * 0809 * , 015 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0807.4528 [ astro - ph ] ] .
a. achucarro , j. o. gong , s. hardeman , g. a. palma and s. p. patil , jcap * 1101 * , 030 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1010.3693 [ hep - ph ] ] .
a. a. starobinsky and i. i. tkachev , jetp lett .
* 76 * , 235 ( 2002 ) [ pisma zh .
. fiz . * 76 * , 291 ( 2002 ) ] [ arxiv : astro - ph/0207572 ] .
s. h. chen and j. b. dent , arxiv:1012.4811 [ astro-ph.co ] .
a. ashoorioon , g. shiu , jcap * 1103 * , 025 ( 2011 ) .
[ arxiv:1012.3392 [ astro-ph.co ] ] .
l. bergstrom and u. h. danielsson , jhep * 0212 * , 038 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0211006 ] .
j. martin and c. ringeval , phys .
d * 69 * , 083515 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0310382 ] .
j. martin and c. ringeval , phys .
d * 69 * , 127303 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0402609 ] . j. martin and c. ringeval , jcap * 0501 * , 007 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0405249 ] .
r. easther , w. h. kinney and h. peiris , jcap * 0505 * , 009 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0412613 ] . c. cheung , p. creminelli , a. l. fitzpatrick , j. kaplan and l. senatore , jhep * 0803 * , 014 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0709.0293 [ hep - th ] ] . l. senatore and m. zaldarriaga , arxiv:1009.2093 [ hep - th ]
. s. weinberg , phys .
d * 72 * , 043514 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0506236 ] .
a. h. guth , phys .
d * 23 * , 347 ( 1981 ) .
a. d. linde , phys .
b * 108 * , 389 ( 1982 ) .
a. albrecht and p. j. steinhardt , phys .
lett . * 48 * , 1220 ( 1982 ) .
a. d. linde , phys .
b * 129 * , 177 ( 1983 ) .
e. calzetta and b. l. hu , phys .
d * 37 * , 2878 ( 1988 ) .
t. s. bunch and p. c. w. davies , proc .
lond . a * 360 * , 117 ( 1978 ) .
m. van der meulen and j. smit , jcap * 0711 * , 023 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv:0707.0842 [ hep - th ] ] .
j. martin and c. ringeval , jcap * 0608 * , 009 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0605367 ] .
m. b. einhorn and f. larsen , phys .
d * 68 * , 064002 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0305056 ] .
m. d. niemack _ et al .
_ , proc .
spie int .
eng . * 7741 * , 77411s ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1006.5049 [ astro-ph.im ] ] .
d. baumann _ et al .
_ [ cmbpol study team collaboration ] , aip conf . proc . * 1141 * , 3 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0811.3911 ] d. baumann , m. g. jackson _ et al . _
[ cmbpol study team collaboration ] , aip conf .
proc . *
1141 * , 10 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0811.3919 ] .
e. komatsu _ et al .
_ , arxiv:0902.4759 [ astro-ph.co ] .
d. meerburg , j. p. van der schaar and p. s. corasaniti , jcap * 0905 * , 018 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0901.4044 [ hep - th ] ] .
d. meerburg , j. p.
van der schaar and m. g. jackson , jcap * 1002 * , 001 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0910.4986 [ hep - th ] ] .
d. meerburg , arxiv:1006.2771 [ astro-ph.co ] .
m. g. jackson and k. schalm , arxiv:1202.0604 [ hep - th ] .
j. r. fergusson , d. m. regan and e. p. s. shellard , arxiv:1012.6039 [ astro-ph.co ] .
m. g. jackson , arxiv:1203.3895 [ hep - th ] . | we compute the universal generic corrections to the power spectrum in slow - roll inflation due to unknown high - energy physics .
we arrive at this result via a careful integrating out of massive fields in the `` in - in '' formalism yielding a consistent and predictive low - energy effective description in time - dependent backgrounds .
the density power spectrum is universally modified at leading order in @xmath0 , the ratio of the scale of inflation to the scale of new physics ; the tensor power spectrum receives only subleading corrections . in doing so ,
we show how to make sense of a physical momentum - cut - off in loop integrals despite dynamical redshifts , and how the result can be captured in a combined effective action / effective density matrix , where the latter contains non - adiabatic terms which modify the boundary conditions . |
@xcite proposed that neutron star mergers will be accompanied by macronovae ( kilonovae ) , which are optical infrared transients powered by radioactive decay of the merger s debris .
these macronovae are among the most promising electromagnetic counterparts to gravitational - wave merger events ( e.g. @xcite ) .
recently , macronova candidates have been discovered in the afterglows of several short gamma - ray bursts @xcite .
@xcite re - analyzed the afterglow light curves of historical nearby short gamma - ray bursts and suggested that macronovae are ubiquitous in short grbs afterglows .
the radioactive heat generated by @xmath0-process nuclei play an essential role in powering macronovae .
due to strong adiabatic cooling the ejecta s initial internal energy is practically negligible at the time that the ejecta become optically thin , i.e. when @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is the optical depth and @xmath7 is the velocity of the ejecta .
as we discuss later , with typical parameters the peak emission time is around a few days and hence this is the important timescale to focus on .
detailed computations using nuclear database and numerical simulations have been widely used to obtain the radioactive heating rates @xcite . another approach to calculate the heating rate is to consider the @xmath0-process material as a statistical assembly of radioactive nuclei .
incorporating fermi s theory of beta decay with such an approach provides a clear physical understanding of the nuclear heating rate ( see , e.g. , @xcite for a discussion on the energy generation by fission products ) .
we follow this approach and use the fermi theory to estimate the heating rate in neutron star mergers ejecta .
* see also @xcite ) considered this approach to estimate the radioactive luminosity of supernovae .
but they used only the relativistic regime of fermi s theory , which is not relevant on the macronova peak timescale as we discuss later .
furthermore , they assumed that each element decays to a stable one rather than following a decay chain , which we consider in this paper . in this paper
, we analytically derive the nuclear heating rate of macronovae based on fermi s theory . in [ sec : summary ] , we begin with a brief summary of the basic concepts and the outcome of this work . in [ sec : fermi ] , we introduce the key ingredients of the theory needed to calculate the heating rate .
we derive the heating rate of the beta decay chains of allowed transitions in [ sec : heat ] .
we discuss , in
[ sec : discussion ] , the role of forbidden transitions and other effects that we ignore and we estimate their possible effect .
we summarize the results and discuss the implication to macronova studies in [ sec : conclusion ] .
radioactive nuclei that are far from the stability valley are produced in @xmath0-process nucleosynthesis .
these nuclei undergo beta decay without changing their mass number .
a series of beta decays in each mass number is considered as a decay chain . because the mean lives of radioactive nuclides typically become longer when approaching the stability valley , the nuclei in a decay chain at given time @xmath8 stay at some specific nuclide with a mean life @xmath9 .
this means that the number of decaying nuclei in a logarithmic time interval is constant , i.e , the decay rate is @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is the total number of nuclei in the chain
. then the beta decay heating rate per nucleus is given by @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the disintegration energy of the beta decay as a function of the mean life .
as we will see later , two important concepts in beta decay theory enable us to determine @xmath13 .
first , there are four physical constants in the problem , the fermi s constant @xmath14 , the electron mass @xmath15 , the speed of light @xmath16 , and the planck constant @xmath17
. the fundamental timescale of beta decay @xmath18s can be obtained from these physical constants .
second , there is a well known relation between the disintegration energy and mean life as @xmath19 .
therefore , the heating rate per nucleus can be roughly estimated as @xmath20 this gives a correct order of magnitude and a reasonable estimate of the time dependence of the beta decay heating rate of @xmath0-process material . in the following we refine these ideas .
the nature of beta decay was successfully described by @xcite . here
we briefly describe key ingredients of fermi s theory needed for obtaining the macronova heating rate . in a beta decay one of the neutrons in a nucleus disintegrated to a proton , an electron , and an anti - neutrino . using fermi s golden rule ,
the beta - disintegration probability of a beta - unstable nucleus per unit time in a unit momentum interval of the electron is written as @xmath21 where @xmath22 and @xmath23 are momentum and kinetic energy of the electron , @xmath24 is the matrix element of the interaction hamiltonian responsible for the beta disintegration , and @xmath25 is the number density of final states of the light particles between @xmath23 and @xmath26 .
the number of final states is assumed to be proportional to the volume of the accessible phase space of the light particles : @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the total disintegration energy , @xmath29 is momentum of the neutrino , and energy conservation @xmath30 has been used .
we use the fact that the neutrino mass is sufficiently small compared to @xmath31 and assume that there is no angular correlation between the electron and neutrino . here
we imagine that the whole system is enclosed in a large box with a volume @xmath32 .
hereafter we change the notation as @xmath33 and @xmath34 . in fermi s theory ,
the four particles interact at a single point with a coupling constant @xmath14 so that the matrix element is written as @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the wave function of each particle involved in the beta disintegration , @xmath37 and @xmath38 are operators acting on the light particle s spin , nucleon s spin and isospin ( see , e.g. , @xcite for a discussions on beta interaction ) .
the wave function of the light particles can be evaluated at @xmath39 because their de broglie wavelengths are much larger than the nuclear size .
when the light particles do not carry off orbital angular momentum with respect to the central nucleus , the wave function of each light particle at @xmath40 is just a normalization factor of @xmath41 with a coulomb correction for the electron s wave function .
thus the square of the matrix element can be written as @xmath42 is the coulomb correction factor , @xmath43 is the proton number of the daughter nucleus , and @xmath44 is the nuclear matrix element .
the transitions described here are _ allowed _ transition .
more specifically , allowed transitions are transitions which satisfy both conditions that the light particles do nt carry off orbital angular momentum and the parity of the nucleus does not change via its disintegration .
otherwise the transition is a _ forbidden _ transition .
because the population of allowed transitions is larger and because of their simplicity , we focus on allowed transitions in this and the next sections
. we will discuss the role of forbidden transitions in 4 .
integrating eq .
( [ fermi ] ) over the accessible phase space , the mean - life of a beta - unstable nuclide with the disintegration energy of @xmath31 is obtained as @xmath45 where the variables in the integral are in units of @xmath46 and @xmath16 and @xmath47 is the fundamental timescale of beta decay : @xmath48 note that , although this fundamental timescale is a characteristic timescale of allowed beta decay , the lifetime of beta unstable nuclides spreads over many orders of magnitude because of the phase space factor of eq .
( [ mean ] ) .
the coulomb correction factor in the matrix element is obtained by evaluating the electron s wave function at the nuclear radius @xmath49 @xcite : @xmath50 } ( 2p\rho)^{2s-2 } e^{\pi\eta } \left|(s-1+i\eta ) !
\right|^2 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath51 , @xmath7 is the velocity of the electron , @xmath52 , @xmath53 , @xmath54 is the electron charge , and @xmath55 is the fine - structure constant . for @xmath56 ,
the coulomb correction factor slowly increases with @xmath57 as @xmath58 .
a simple form of the coulomb correction factor is obtained in the non - relativistic limit of eq .
( [ cc ] ) , @xmath59 and @xmath60 : @xmath61 the coulomb correction factor is unity for @xmath62 and approaches to @xmath63 for @xmath64 .
this enhances the transition probability at lower energies . at these energies
the electron is pulled by the nucleus due to the coulomb force and the amplitude of the electron s wave function is larger near the nucleus . as a result ,
the lifetime of beta unstable nuclei becomes shorter than the one estimated without the coulomb correction and the dependence of the lifetime on @xmath31 is weakened .
note that one can also obtain an identical form to eq .
( [ cn ] ) by solving the schr@xmath65dinger equation and evaluating the electron s wave function at @xmath40 . as the integral in eq .
( [ mean ] ) is easily calculated for given @xmath28 and @xmath43 , comparative half - lives @xmath66 are often used for comparison with the experimental data : @xmath67 although @xmath68 of each beta transition can not be calculated within fermi s theory , @xmath69 can be determined from the measurements of the lifetime and the electron s spectrum .
it is sufficient for our purpose to know the statistical distribution of this quantity . for allowed transitions ,
the distribution of @xmath66 is known to have a peak around @xmath70s corresponding to @xmath71 ( e.g. @xcite ) , which we take as a reference value in this paper.h , the comparative half - lives are @xmath72 s corresponding to @xmath73 .
such transitions are called as _ superallowed _ transitions .
these transitions are , however , absent in @xmath0-process material . ]
one can show that @xmath74 attains simple forms in the following three regimes : @xmath75 where @xmath76 .
the non - relativistic regime exists only for @xmath77 , and thus , there is no such a regime in @xmath0-process material . in previous a work @xcite applied only the relativistic regime @xmath19 .
however , as we will see later , the mean - lives of the nuclei are rather proportional to @xmath78 or @xmath79 on the relevant timescale of macronovae , i.e. , a few days . , where @xmath80 is euler number.,width=302 ] in the context of macronovae , we are interested in the relation between the lifetime and the mean electron s energy since the neutrinos do nt contribute to the heat deposition in the merger ejecta .
the fraction of energy of the electrons to the total energy is : @xmath81 in the three regimes discussed earlier @xmath82 satisfies : @xmath83 where we assumed @xmath84 .
neutron - rich nuclei produced via the @xmath0-process undergo beta decay towards the beta - stable valley without changing their mass number . a series of beta decays of nuclei in each mass number
can be considered as a decay chain .
here we consider ideal - chains of radioactive nuclei with a series of mean lives ( @xmath85 ) , in which each chain conserves the total number of nuclei throughout the decay process and sufficiently many chains exist . within this approximation ,
the number of decaying nuclei in a logarithmic time interval is constant and the beta decays at a given time @xmath8 are dominated by nuclides with mean - lives of @xmath9 ( see fig .
[ fig : dn ] ) .
this is , of course , valid for @xmath86 , where @xmath87 is the mean life of the first nuclide in a decay chain .
the heating rate per unit mass is then @xmath88 where @xmath89 is the mean mass number of the @xmath0-process material , and @xmath90 is the atomic mass unit .
note that @xmath80 is the euler number , which arises from the fact that the decay rate of each nuclide is proportional to @xmath91 .
one can obtain @xmath92 by using eq .
( [ mean ] ) and ( 11 ) . in the relativistic and non - relativistic coulomb regimes
, we can derive simple explicit forms of eq .
( [ heat ] ) . as the lifetime of beta - unstable nuclides
monotonically increases with decreasing @xmath31 , the relativistic regime is valid at early times and the non - relativistic coulomb regime is valid at late times .
more specifically , the relativistic regime is valid until @xmath93 and the non - relativistic coulomb regime is valid after @xmath94 . using eqs .
( [ f ] ) and ( [ e ] ) , we obtain the heating rate in these regimes : @xmath95 where @xmath96 is time in units of a day , @xmath97 is the mean mass number normalized by @xmath98 , and @xmath99 is the mean proton number normalized by @xmath100 .
note that the overall magnitude of the heating rate is determined by the mean values of the nuclear quantities , @xmath101 , @xmath43 , and @xmath44 .
these values should be constant within an order of magnitude , and thus , the magnitude of the heating rate does not depend significantly on the details of the abundance pattern of the @xmath0-process nuclei .
furthermore , we emphasize that the formula of eq .
( [ heat2 ] ) is independent of the distribution of the nuclear decay energy .
figure [ fig : heat ] depicts the heating rate obtained from eq .
( [ heat ] ) and the one derived using a nuclear database ( @xcite ; see also similar heating rates in @xcite ) .
we find that the heating rate based on the simple analytic formula reproduces the one based on the database remarkably well . in order to see more details , the right panel of fig .
[ fig : heat ] shows the heating rates normalized to the values obtained for the relativistic regime ( eq .
[ heat2 ] ) .
the normalized analytic heating rate ( blue solid line ) is flat at early times and it approaches the non - relativistic coulomb regime ( magenta dotted line ) at late times .
it is worthy noting that the formula with the non - relativistic coulomb limit reproduces the full heating rate after @xmath102s , even though it should be valid only after @xmath103s .
this can be understood as follows .
the mean life is approximately proportional to @xmath104 between the relativistic and the non - relativistic regimes , and thus , the energy generation rate evolves as @xmath105 .
in addition , in this stage , @xmath106 changes from @xmath107 to @xmath108 , which approximately corresponds to @xmath109 . as a result , the electron heating rate is @xmath110 , which is quite similar to the one in the non - relativistic coulomb regime .
note that @xcite and @xcite assume that a nucleus that undergoes a radioactive decay reaches the valley of stability in a single step . in this case
the total number of radioactive nuclei decreases with time .
this assumption is valid if the radioactive nuclei are distributed just next to the stable nuclei , i.e. , at late times .
under such an assumption , the resulting heating rate declines more steeply as @xmath111 in the relativistic regime . as we will discuss in the next section
, the actual situation is in between these two assumptions .
the analytic formula derived in the previous section reproduces remarkably well the result based on the nuclear database . however , there are two important effects that have not been taken into account . here
we discuss the role of these effects . _ higher orbital - angular momentum transitions ( unique forbidden ) _ : the light particles wave function in the matrix element eq .
( [ matrix ] ) can be expanded in a series of spherical harmonics , of which the @xmath112th term is proportional to @xmath113 , where @xmath114 is the total momentum of the light particles .
the @xmath112th transition corresponds to the transition in which the light particles carry off orbital angular momentum of @xmath115 .
this expansion converges rapidly on the energy scale of beta decay on the length scale of nucleus @xmath116 . as a result ,
the @xmath112th transition probability is suppressed by a factor of @xmath117 . for first unique forbidden transitions , an additional shape factor @xmath118 should be multiplied in the electron spectrum of eq .
( [ mean ] ) .
this shape factor results in @xmath119 in the non - relativistic coulomb regime , which can be seen in fig .
[ fig : half ] ( a blue dotted line ) . even though the number of beta unstable nuclides that disintegrate mainly via unique forbidden transitions is small
, they may play a role by increasing the heating rate after a few hours . _ relativistic transitions ( parity forbidden ) _ : some interactions mix the large and small components of dirac spinor of the nucleon in the matrix element eq .
( [ matrix ] ) . a transition due to
such an interaction is a _
parity forbidden _ transition as it changes the nucleus parity without removing the orbital angular momentum ( see magenta crosses in fig . [
fig : half ] ) .
the corresponding amplitude is suppressed by a factor of @xmath120 or @xmath121 compared to allowed transitions . here
the velocity of nucleons @xmath122 is typically @xmath123 . as a result , the probability of these transitions is lower than the allowed ones by a factor of @xmath124 or @xmath125 .
the theoretical curves of the first order parity forbidden transitions are shown as the dashed and the dot - dashed lines in fig .
[ fig : half ] .
here we use a suppression factor of @xmath126 and @xmath127 , respectively .
the first order parity forbidden transitions have an electron spectral shape that is similar to the allowed transitions .
as one can see in this figure , the curves of these transitions have the same shapes to the allowed one with a constant shift in the half - life .
the existence of these transitions in addition to the allowed ones increases the heating rate .
the lifetimes of second order parity forbidden transitions , in which angular momentum of @xmath17 is carried off by the light particles , are too long to be relevant for the macronova heating rates ( see green points in fig .
[ fig : half ] ) .
-process nuclides .
open circles , closes , filled squares , and filled circles are allowed , first parity forbidden , first unique forbidden , and second parity forbidden transitions respectively . here the data points are taken from evaluated nuclear data file endf / b - vii.1 library @xcite .
each curve depicts the theoretical expectation with a constant nuclear matrix element of each type of transitions : the allowed ( red solid ) , the first parity forbidden ( magenta dashed and dot - dashed ) , the first unique forbidden ( blue dotted ) , and the second parity forbidden ( green ) . here we adopt @xmath128 and @xmath129 for all analytic models but @xmath130 for the first unique transition . ,
width=302 ] beta decay chains terminate when they reach stable nuclides .
once this happens these terminated chains do nt contribute to the heating rate any more .
the overall lifetime of a chain , @xmath131 , can be estimated from the sum of the half - lives of nuclides in the chain .
the cumulative distribution of the chains for @xmath132@xmath133 as a function of the chains lifetime is shown in fig .
[ fig : chain ] . the number of the chains begins to decrease slowly as @xmath134 at @xmath135s .
after about @xmath136 days it decreases slightly faster as @xmath137 . this steep decline at late times due to the termination of the decay chains is consistent with the assumption made by @xcite and @xcite .
in summary , the contribution of forbidden transitions to the heating rate slightly increases the heat generation at late times .
on the contrary , at the same time , the termination of the beta decay chains slightly decreases it . as a result
, the combined effects on the heating rate somehow cancel out .
note that these corrections to the heating rate depend on the actual abundance distribution of the chains .
we derive an analytic form of the macronova heating rate by considering statistical assembly of radioactive @xmath0-process nuclides and fermi s theory of beta decay .
the resulting analytic formula reproduces the heating rate derived from the nuclear database remarkably well . within the assumption that the ideal decay chains of allowed beta transitions generate radioactive heats ,
we show that the heating rate evolves as @xmath138 at early times and @xmath139 at late times .
the overall magnitude of heating rate is determined by the mean value of the nuclear matrix elements , mass and atomic number of beta unstable nuclides involved in the decay chains .
is the sum of the half - lives of beta unstable nuclides of a decay chain.,width=302 ] we discuss the role of forbidden transitions and the deviation from the ideal - chains approximation .
the former slightly increases the heating rate at late times and the latter slightly decreases it . as a result , these corrections somehow cancel out with each other .
the robust and simple form of the heating rate suggests that observations of the late - time bolometric macronova light curve can provide and observational evidence that is is driven by a radioactive decay of @xmath0-process material .
furthermore , determination of the bolometric luminosity will enable us to estimate the total amount of @xmath0-process nuclei produced in a merger . using the non - relativistic coulomb regime of eq .
( [ heat2 ] ) , the late - time bolometric light curve is written as @xmath140 where @xmath141 is the ejecta mass .
this expression is valid after the peak time given by @xmath142 where @xmath143 is the ejecta velocity and @xmath144 is the bound - bound opacity of @xmath0-process elements @xcite . confirming
this behavior by observation may be difficult because the light curve may have large fluctuation due to the temperature and density dependent opacity @xcite .
however , as suggested in the context of supernovae ( @xcite ) , the time - weighted integral of the bolometric luminosity after the peak provides a more robust estimate the radioactive power in the ejecta .
in this method , the time - weighted integral of the bolometric luminosity should behave as @xmath145 .
the bolometric luminosity that we derived here is the total radioactive power emitted in the electrons . at late times , this power is not necessarily thermalized in the ejecta ( see @xcite for a detailed study ) .
the inefficiency of the electron thermalization may reduce the bolometric luminosity by a factor of @xmath146 on the macronova timescale . at the same time
, we have ignored , additional heating due to @xmath147-rays , @xmath148-particles and fission fragments .
the role of these decay products in the macronova heating is still under debate .
for instance , it has been suggested that the heat generation by spontaneous fission and @xmath148-decay can be comparable to or even larger than the beta decay heating ( see @xcite ) .
we explore the role of these effects in the estimating the total amount of @xmath0-process material ejected in a macronva from the integrated bolometric light curve in a separate work .
we thank michael paul , kohsaku tobioka , and shinya wanajo for useful discussions .
this research was supported by an erc advanced grant ( trex ) and by the i - core program of the planning and budgeting committee and the israel science foundation ( grant no 1829/12 ) , and an isf grant . | macronovae ( kilonovae ) that arise in binary neutron star mergers are powered by radioactive beta decay of hundreds of @xmath0-process nuclides .
we derive , using fermi s theory of beta decay , an analytic estimate of the nuclear heating rate .
we show that the heating rate evolves as a power law ranging between @xmath1 to @xmath2 .
the overall magnitude of the heating rate is determined by the mean values of nuclear quantities , e.g. , the nuclear matrix elements of beta decay .
these values are specified by using nuclear experimental data .
we discuss the role of higher order beta transitions and the robustness of the power law .
the robust and simple form of the heating rate suggests that observations of the late - time bolometric light curve @xmath3 would be a direct evidence of a @xmath0-process driven macronova .
such observations could also enable us to estimate the total amount of @xmath0-process nuclei produced in the merger .
[ firstpage ] stars : neutron@xmath4gamma - ray burst : general |
granular matter is characterized by the existence of dissipative forces between particles . in order to sustain a collective motion ,
it is necessary to provide energy continuously .
when power supply is sufficiently copious , the assembly of granular particles attains a non equilibrium steady state ( ness)@xcite .
it is customary to define the granular temperature as the second moment of the velocity distribution .
it is a source of both fascination and inconvenience that the well - know properties of temperatures characterizing thermal systems are not necessarily transferable to granular temperatures . in particular
, recent work , both theoretical@xcite and experimental@xcite , has shown that in a binary granular system the two species have different granular temperatures that are non - trivial functions of the microscopic parameters ( mass , size , restitution coefficient , ) . although the absence of equipartition is not surprising for a dissipative system sustained in a ness , a more complete investigation is necessary since the granular temperatures play an important role in hydrodynamic descriptions of these systems ( in particular the absence of equipartition in binary mixtures yields granular temperature gradients which enhance segregation@xcite ) .
in addition , the extension of the fluctutation - dissipation theorem is an important issue in the context of granular gases@xcite .
other consequences of the absence of equipartition include the ability of a binary system to exhibit a segregation phenomena in a `` maxwell demon '' experiment@xcite .
see also the homogeneous cooling state of a granular mixture@xcite and the impurity problem@xcite .
most of the above - referenced studies examined assemblies of spherical particles . yet , in reality , the particles composing granular systems are to some degree anisotropic and , in many cases , strongly so
. even if the particles are smooth , each collision results in some exchange and , possibly loss , of rotational kinetic energy .
there are relatively few studies of these systems ( but see for example , refs.@xcite ) and fewer still that focus specifically on equipartition .
huthmann et al .
@xcite used kinetic theory to examine the free cooling of a system of granular needles in three dimensions and , more recently , two of the present authors studied a two - dimensional system composed of a single granular needle in a thermalized bath of point particles @xcite in a ness . for inelastic needle - point collisions , the rotational granular temperature is smaller than the translational one while both are less than the bath temperature .
the validity of the theoretical predictions were confirmed by comparison with numerical simulations of the model .
while this study provided useful insights , infinitesimal width of the particle is obviously an idealization .
the objective of present article is to consider a more realistic system where both the tracer particle and bath particles are of finite extent .
specifically , we consider a discorectangle in a bath of thermalized hard disks .
fortunately , despite the increased complexity , it is still possible to obtain an analytic solution of the steady state kinetic equations .
the principal difference between the discorectangle - disk and needle - point systems is that two kinds of collision are possible in the former compared to one in the latter .
specifically , a disk can collide with either the sides or the caps of the discorectangle .
if each type of collision is characterized by different normal restitution coefficients we show that equipartition between the translational and rotational degrees of freedom can be obtained for specific values of these parameters .
consequently , for appropriate ranges of the restitution coefficients the translational granular temperature may be less than or greater than the rotational one .
we investigate a two - dimensional system consisting of a discorectangle of total length @xmath1 , radius @xmath2 and mass @xmath3 with a moment of inertia @xmath4 ( the value of which is given in appendix a ) .
the bath consists of disks of mass @xmath5 and of radius @xmath6 .
the vector positions of the center of mass of the discorectangle and a disk particle are denoted by @xmath7 and @xmath8 , respectively .
the orientation of the discorectangle is specified by a unit vector @xmath9 that points along the long axis .
let @xmath10 and @xmath11 denote a vector perpendicular to @xmath9 .
a collision between a discorectangle and a disk can take place either on the linear part or on the circular parts of the former , @xmath12 if @xmath13 , and @xmath14 if @xmath15 , where @xmath16 denotes the unit vector of the collision axis .
( see fig .
[ fig:1 ] ) .
the relative velocity of the point of contact @xmath17 is given by @xmath18 where @xmath19 denotes the angular time derivative and @xmath20 the vector from the center of the discorectangle to the point of impact .
( 0,0 ) denotes a vector joining the point labeled @xmath21 and the center of the discorectangle ; @xmath9 is a unit vector along the axis of the discorectangle , @xmath22 is the algebraic distance between the center of the discorectangle and the point of impact and @xmath23 is a unit vector perpendicular to the axis of the discorectangle .
( b ) collision between the circular part of the discorectangle and a disk .
@xmath24 denotes the angle between the direction of the long axis of the discorectangle and the axis defined by the contact point and the center of the disk.@xmath25 and @xmath26 are unit vectors normal and tangential to the surface at the point of contact , respectively .
, title="fig : " ] # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 6054,4306)(979,-3671 ) ( 4636,-1366)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3421,-3166)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5851,-2311)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5356,-2806)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2881,-2401)(0,0)[lb ] + ( 0,0 ) denotes a vector joining the point labeled @xmath21 and the center of the discorectangle ; @xmath9 is a unit vector along the axis of the discorectangle , @xmath22 is the algebraic distance between the center of the discorectangle and the point of impact and @xmath23 is a unit vector perpendicular to the axis of the discorectangle .
( b ) collision between the circular part of the discorectangle and a disk .
@xmath24 denotes the angle between the direction of the long axis of the discorectangle and the axis defined by the contact point and the center of the disk.@xmath25 and @xmath26 are unit vectors normal and tangential to the surface at the point of contact , respectively .
, title="fig : " ] # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 6054,4582)(1159,-3947 ) ( 6744,-2085)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6811,-1621)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6180,-3113)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5446,-3751)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5041,-2491)(0,0)[lb ] the pre- and post - collisional quantities ( the latter are labeled with a prime ) satisfy : * total momentum conservation @xmath27 * angular momentum conservation with respect to the point of contact @xmath28 where @xmath29 is a unit vector perpendicular to the plane . as a result of the collision ,
the relative velocity of the contacting points changes instantaneously according to the following relations : @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the normal restitution coefficient and @xmath32 and @xmath9 denote the unit vectors of the collision along the rectilinear part of the discorectangle .
when the collision occurs on the circular parts of the discorectangle , the collision rules are given by @xmath33 where @xmath16 and @xmath34 denote the unit vectors associated with the circular part of the discorectangle ( see fig [ fig:1]b ) .
the tangential restitution coefficient is set to one for the sake of simplicity .
this choice is reflected in the form of eqs .
( [ eq:6]-[eq:8 ] ) . by combining eqs .
( [ eq:2])- ( [ eq:5 ] ) one obtains , after some algebra , the change of the discorectangle momentum @xmath35 for a collision along the linear part @xmath36 for @xmath37 and at the two ends of the discorectangle @xmath38 for @xmath15 with @xmath39 .
since we are interested in the homogeneous state , the distribution function @xmath40 of the discorectangle obeys @xmath41 where @xmath42 is the total number of disks , @xmath43 is the distribution function of the discorectangle and a disk , and @xmath44 is the collision operator between a discorectangle and a disk . defining the granular temperatures as quadratic average of the appropriate velocity distribution , one has @xmath45 and @xmath46 for the translational and rotational granular temperatures , respectively ( the angular brackets denote the average ) . by taking the second moment with respect of the velocity and of the angular velocity of eq.([eq:10 ] ) , one obtains @xmath47 @xmath48 in the stationary state the time derivatives of the left - hand side of these two equations are equal to zero . to build the collision operator between the discorectangle and a disk , @xmath49 , one must include the change in quantities ( i.e. velocity and angular momentum ) produced during the infinitesimal time interval of the collision .
this operator is different from zero only if the two particles are in contact and if the particles were approaching just before the collision@xcite . for a collision between a disk and the rectilinear part of the discorectangle , the explicit form of the operator given by @xmath50 where @xmath51 is an operator that changes post - collisional quantities to pre - collisional quantities and
@xmath52 is the heaviside function , and for a collision at two ends of the discorectangle @xmath53 where @xmath51 is an operator that converts pre - collisional to post - collisional quantities .
the others terms of the collision operator correspond to the necessary conditions of contact @xmath54 , and approach @xmath55 in the first case and @xmath56 , and approach @xmath57 in the second case . by taking the second moments of the distribution function of the discorectangle and after substitution of the collision operator ( eq.([eq:13 ] ) ) , one obtains explicitly for the translational kinetic energy @xmath58 = 0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] a similar equation can be written for rotational kinetic energy .
since the impulse of the collision depends on the location of the impact , it is easy to show that the solution is not a maxwell distribution function , a property already observed in the model of a needle and points@xcite .
however , since the deviations from the maxwell distribution are small , we use it as a trial function .
that is we assume that @xmath59 where @xmath60 and @xmath61 are the ratios of the translational and rotational discorectangle temperatures to the bath temperature , respectively . in summary , in order to obtain the granular temperatures of the discorectangle , it is necessary to : ( i ) calculate the change of translational and rotational energy occurring during a collision ( ii ) perform an average over all degrees of freedom of the collision integral .
when a disk collides with the discorectangle , the change of the translational kinetic energy of the latter is given by @xmath62 for @xmath63 , and @xmath64 for @xmath65 .
the collision results in a change of rotational energy , for @xmath66 , @xmath67 and for @xmath15 , @xmath68 + after inserting eq .
( [ eq:15 ] ) in eq .
( [ eq:14 ] ) it is necessary to perform integrations over each variable in the corresponding equation for the rotational energy .
details of this rather technical task are given in the appendix b. after some tedious calculation , one obtains the following set of equations @xmath69 where @xmath70 @xmath71 @xmath72 and @xmath73 and @xmath74 and @xmath75 are given by @xmath76 explicit expressions for the integrals appearing in eqs .
( [ eq:18 ] ) and ( [ eq:19 ] ) are given in appendix c. eq .
( [ eq:19 ] ) is an implicit equation for @xmath77 that , for a given value of @xmath31 , can be solved with standard numerical methods .
@xmath78 is then easily obtained by calculating the ratio of integrals of eq .
( [ eq:18 ] ) .
finally , from the values of @xmath77 and @xmath78 , @xmath60 and @xmath61 can be obtained from eqs.([eq:20])-([eq:21 ] ) .
a first check is the elastic case , @xmath79 , for which one obtains @xmath80 which gives @xmath81 and , since @xmath82 , @xmath83 i.e. , the temperatures of translational and rotational degrees of freedom are the same and correspond to the bath temperature , a property of an equilibrium system . in the limit @xmath84 and @xmath85 , for which @xmath86 corresponding to a needle in a bath of point particles , one recovers the results of ref@xcite .
more interesting is the limit @xmath84 with @xmath6 remaining finite , i.e. , a needle in a bath of _
disks_. by using eq.([eq:22 ] ) one obtains that @xmath87 . since @xmath88 ,
unlike the simple needle - point system , there is a contribution resulting from collisions between bath particles and the needle s tips .
this type of collision is dominant when the bath particles are larger than the longest size of the anisotropic particle . to illustrate the effect of this contribution , figures [ fig:2]a and b compare the system of a needle in a bath of point particles and the system of a needle in a bath of disks , the radius of disks @xmath6 are equal to @xmath89 in fig [ fig:2]a and @xmath90 in fig [ fig:2]b .
it is noticeable that the translational and rotational temperatures of the latter system are smaller than those of the needle in a bath of points , an effect that becomes more pronounced when the radius of the disks becomes larger than the length of the needle .
the difference @xmath91 are shown in the insets for the needle and the bath of points and for the needle and the bath of disks .
note that the translational temperature is always larger than the rotational temperature and that the difference depends very weakly on the size of the radius of the bath .
additionally , the difference increases when the restitution coefficient decreases from @xmath92 ( elastic case ) , reaches a maximum for a value of @xmath93 and decreases slightly when the restitution coefficient still decreases .
figure [ fig:3 ] shows the influence of the anisotropy of the tracer particle .
the rotational temperature is still lower than the translational temperature what ever the elongation of the particles , but the effect is greater when the elongation is large .
the two upper curves correspond the translational ( full curve ) and rotational ( dashed curve ) temperature of the discorectangle when @xmath94 , the two intermediate curve to granular temperatures when @xmath95 , and the two lower curves for a discorectangle with @xmath96 .
when the anisotropy of the discorectangle approaches zero , i.e. @xmath97 , @xmath98 , one can show by using eqs.([eq:18])-([eq:19 ] ) that @xmath99 which is the the result of martin and piasecki@xcite for a spherical tracer particle in a bath of spherical particles .
moreover , the limit @xmath97 leads equipartition between the rotational and translational granular temperatures , a result which is different from a model of pure spherical particles where , in the absence of tangential friction , the particles can not exchange rotational energy . in physical systems ,
the particles are never completely spherical and our model shows that if an infinitesimal amount of anisotropy is present , the translational and rotational temperatures are equal in the steady state .
although our analysis provides no quantitative information about the relaxation time to reach this ness , it is certain to be very long in this limit of small anisotropy .
we consider a homogeneous discorectangle of mass @xmath3 in a bath of disks each of mass @xmath5 for which @xmath100 . when @xmath101 one obtains , from eqs.([eq:18])-([eq:19 ] ) , that @xmath102 i.e. , equipartition between the degrees of freedom of the tracer particle , but not between the bath and the tracer particle .
this is , moreover , the same result for a needle in a bath of point particles .
we conjecture that this result is general in the sense that we expect equipartition between the different degrees of freedom of the tracer particle in a bath of light particles , whatever the shape of the tracer particle and the dimension of the system . the behavior for finite values of the ratio @xmath103 is shown in fig.[fig:4 ] .
the granular temperatures decrease when the ratio @xmath103 increases , and the translational temperature remains higher than the rotational temperature for each value of @xmath31 .
in practice it may be difficult to construct a discorectangle for which the restitution coefficient is constant over the entire perimeter .
it is clear , for example , that if the object is composed of a homogeneous viscoelastic material , collisions with the ends will be characterized by a smaller restitution coefficient than collisions with the linear part .
this effect becomes more pronounced as the elongation ( @xmath104 ) increases .
other possibilities exist for a non - homogeneous discorectangle composed of two or more materials .
for example , a hard material may be used to construct the caps .
in addition , the restitution coefficient could depend on the relative velocity of the point of impact@xcite , an effect that one neglects here as a first approximation . as a first approach to describe this possibility
, we consider in this section a discorectangle where the restitution coefficient is equal to @xmath105 for a collision along the rectilinear part of the object and equal to @xmath106 for one along the circular part : see fig.[fig:5 ] .
( 0,0 ) ( rectilinear part ) and @xmath106 ( circular part).,title="fig : " ] # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 3305,1368)(1159,-1334 ) ( 4398,-190)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3668,-38)(0,0)[lb ] using the procedure outlined above one obtains the following set of closed equations @xmath107 figure [ fig:6 ] shows the ratio of translational and rotational temperature of a discorectangle with @xmath108 and @xmath109 to the temperature of the bath as a function of the normal restitution coefficient @xmath106 with a fixed @xmath110 .
one notes that the translational temperature becomes smaller than the rotational temperature for @xmath111 .
when the two curves cross , equipartition is recovered , but unlike the limiting cases discussed above of a discorectangle with a uniform restitution coefficient ( light bath particles , infinitely small anisotropy ) , for a non - trivial value of restitution coefficient @xmath106 and , moreover , for larger values of @xmath106 the ratio of temperatures is inverted .
one can determine in general when equipartition is recovered for a discorectangle with two restitution coefficients . using the relation @xmath112 ( assumption of equipartition ) and eqs.([eq:23])- ( [ eq:24 ] ) , one obtains two implicit equations with the three parameters @xmath105 , @xmath106 and @xmath77 .
a simple numerical procedure allows us to obtain the @xmath106 as a function of @xmath105 .
figure [ fig:7 ] shows the equipartition lines in the @xmath113 space . above each line , corresponding to a given elongation of the rectangle , @xmath114 while the reverse inequality applies to the region below the line .
it is noticeable that as the elongation increases , the region of the @xmath113 space where @xmath114 decreases .
figure [ fig:8 ] shows the role of the size of the bath particles on the existence of equipartition of a discorectangle of length @xmath115 . for small bath particles ,
only a small range of @xmath105 , ( between @xmath116 and @xmath117 ) with a smaller range of @xmath106 ( between @xmath118 and @xmath92 ) allows equipartition for the tracer particle . for larger bath disks ,
all values of @xmath105 ( between @xmath116 and @xmath92 ) are available with a smaller corresponding range of @xmath106 .
we have investigated the influence of the anisotropy of a tracer particle in a bath of thermalized disks in two dimensions . by using a mean - field approach ,
we have obtained analytical results for the rotational and translational temperatures . for a homogeneous discorectangle with a uniform normal restitution coefficient
, the translational temperature is always higher than the rotational temperature , with the difference depending on the elongation of the tracer particle , the size of the bath particles and the mass ratio . at present
, the exact dependence of the restitution coefficient on the position of the point of impact is unknown .
it seems likely , however , that it is not constant along the perimeter . as a first approximation
, we considered an extension of the model where it takes on two values , one for collisions with the linear part and another for collisions with the caps .
in this case the difference between the translational and rotational granular temperatures can be either positive or negative depending on the values of the restitution coefficients and the other parameters .
it is clearly possible to generalize the calculation to allow for a continuously varying restitution coefficient
. it would also be interesting to investigate a system of a tracer particle with a small anisotropy where the tangential restitution coefficient has a non - trivial value ( @xmath119 ) where the limits correspond to a perfectly rough and a perfectly smooth surface , respectively .
the intermediate situation corresponds to some friction which is important in some granular systems .
for a homogeneous discorectangle , the moment of inertia is given by @xmath120 and the mass of the system is @xmath121 which gives @xmath122.\ ] ] by substituting the density as a function of the total mass of the discorectangle .
@xmath123\ ] ] two well - known limits are recovered @xmath124 for an inhomogeneous discorectangle , the moment of inertia depends on the mass distribution . however , it is possible to determine the lower and upper bounds for allowable values .
a trivial lower bound of zero is obtained when the mass is concentrated at the center .
conversely , when the mass is distributed equally at the two extremities of the object ( point masses of @xmath125 at a distance of @xmath126 from the center on each side ) , one obtains @xmath127 which gives the upper bound for the moment of inertia .
as for binary mixtures of spheres@xcite , we use a gaussian ansatz for the distribution functions and introduce two different temperatures corresponding to the translational and rotational degrees of freedom of the needle .
the homogeneous distribution functions of the needle and of the points are then given respectively by @xmath128 @xmath129 where @xmath130 is the temperature of the bath , @xmath60 and @xmath61 the ratio of the translational ( and rotational ) temperature of the needle to the bath temperature .
we introduce the vectors @xmath131 and @xmath132 such that @xmath133 the scalar products @xmath134 and @xmath135 can be expressed as @xmath136\nonumber\\ & + \omega_1\lambda \\\label{eq:27 } { \bf v}.{\bf u}_r & = h\big[(\gamma_t-1){\bf \chi}.{\bf u}_r+\sqrt{\gamma_t}\big(\sqrt{\frac{m}{m}}+\sqrt{\frac{m}{m}}\big){\boldsymbol \nu}.{\bf u}_r\big]\nonumber\\ & + \omega_1\frac{l}{2}\sin\theta\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath137 .
let us introduce @xmath138 .
the translational energy loss is given by the formula @xmath139
= 0\end{aligned}\ ] ] since eq .
( [ eq:26 ] ) depends only on @xmath140 and @xmath141 , one can freely integrate over the direction of @xmath9 for the vectors @xmath131 and @xmath132 , and similarly for eq.([eq:27 ] ) .
the integration over @xmath142 can be easily performed .
if we introduce the three dimensional vectors @xmath143 and @xmath144 with components : @xmath145 and @xmath146 respectively , one has introduces @xmath147 and @xmath148 vectors associated with collisions on the circular parts of the discorectangle by changing @xmath32 in @xmath149 and @xmath22 by @xmath150 . by inserting eq .
( [ eq:16 ] ) in eq .
( [ eq:28 ] ) , the average energy loss can be rewritten as @xmath151\nonumber \\ & + ( r+r)\int_0^{2\pi } d\theta\int d{\bf s}_{u_r}\exp(-{\bf s}_{u_r}^2)|{\bf g}_{u_r}.{\bf s}_{u_r}|\theta(p{\bf g}_{u_r}.{\bf s}_{u_r})\nonumber\\ & \bigg[\frac{1}{2m}\frac{(1+\alpha)^2({\bf g}_{u_r}.{\bf s}_{u_r})^2}{(\frac1m+\frac1m+\frac{l^2\sin^2\theta}{4i})^2}\nonumber \\ & -\frac{(1+\alpha){\bf g}_{u_r}.{\bf s}_{u_r}}{\frac1m+\frac1m+\frac{l^2\sin^2\theta}{4i}}\sqrt{\frac{2t}{m\gamma_t+m}}\big(\gamma_ts_1+\sqrt{\frac{m\gamma_t}{m}}s_2\big)\bigg]=0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] by defining a new coordinate system in which the @xmath152-axis is parallel to @xmath153 , one find that the integrals of eq .
( [ eq:29 ] ) involve gaussian integrals of the form @xmath154 and @xmath155 which finally leads to eq .
( [ eq:18 ] ) . the equation for rotational energy
is derived following exactly the same procedure .
the coupled equations ( [ eq:18])- ( [ eq:19 ] ) depend on the eight integrals @xmath156 , @xmath157 , @xmath158 , @xmath159@xcite , @xmath160 , @xmath161 , @xmath162 , @xmath163 which can be expressed in terms of transcendental and special functions . for completeness , we give below their expressions .
@xmath164 where @xmath169 and @xmath170 denote the complete elliptic integral of the first kind and the incomplete elliptic integral of the third kind respectively .
@xmath171 where @xmath172 denotes the complete elliptic integral of the second kind .
@xmath173 and finally @xmath174 | by using the enskog - boltzmann approach , we study the steady - state dynamics of a granular discorectangle placed in a two - dimensional bath of thermalized hard disks . hard core collisions are assumed elastic between disks and inelastic between the discorectangle and the disks , with a normal restitution coefficient @xmath0 . assuming a gaussian ansatz for the probability distribution functions , we obtain analytical expressions for the granular temperatures .
we show the absence of equipartition and investigate both the role of the anisotropy of the discorectangle and of the relative ratio of the bath particles to the linear sizes of the discorectangle .
in addition , we investigate a model of a discorectangle with two normal restitution coefficients for collisions along the straight and curved surfaces of the discorectangle . in this case
one observes equipartition for a non trivial ratio of normal restitution coefficients . |
the aim of this paper is to elucidate a phenomenon that has been studied for the symmetric group @xmath2 by studying the underlying geometry .
here we sketch the phenomenon , along with our geometric interpretation and generalization . for @xmath3 divisible by @xmath0 , recall that the @xmath0-divisible partition lattice @xmath4 is the poset of partitions of the set @xmath5 with parts divisible by @xmath0 , together with a unique minimal element @xmath6 when @xmath7 . in @xcite ,
calderbank , hanlon and robinson showed that for @xmath7 the top homology of the order complex @xmath8 , when restricted from @xmath9 to @xmath2 , carries the _ ribbon representation _ of @xmath2 corresponding to a ribbon with row sizes @xmath10 .
wachs @xcite gave a more explicit proof of this fact .
their results generalized stanley s @xcite result for the mbius function of @xmath11 , which generalized g. s. sylvester s @xcite result for 2-divisible partitions @xmath12 .
ehrenborg and jung extend the above results by introducing posets of _ pointed partitions _
@xmath13 parametrized by a composition @xmath14 of @xmath15 with last part possibly @xmath16 , from which they obtain all ribbon representations .
more importantly , they explain why specht modules are appearing by establishing a homotopy equivalence with another complex whose top homology is naturally a specht module .
ehrenborg and jung construct their pointed partitions @xmath17 by distinguishing a particular block ( called the _ pointed block _ ) and restricting to those of type @xmath14 .
they show that @xmath18 is homotopy equivalent to a wedge of spheres , and that the top reduced homology @xmath19 is the @xmath2-specht module corresponding to @xmath14 .
their approach is to first relate @xmath13 to a selected subcomplex @xmath20 of the simplicial complex @xmath21 of ordered set partitions of @xmath22 with last block possibly empty . in particular , they use quillen s fiber lemma to show that @xmath18 is homotopy equivalent to @xmath20 .
they then give an explicit basis for @xmath23 that identifies the top homology as a specht module .
ehrenborg and jung recover the results of calderbank , hanlon and robinson @xcite and wachs @xcite by specializing to @xmath24 . taking a geometric viewpoint
, one can consider @xmath21 as the barycentric subdivision of a distinguished facet of the standard @xmath15-simplex having vertices labeled with @xmath25 .
as such , it carries an action of @xmath2 and is a balanced simplicial complex , with each @xmath20 corresponding to a particular type - selected subcomplex . under this identification , the poset @xmath26 corresponds to linear subspaces spanned by faces in @xmath20 .
we propose an analogous program for all well - generated complex reflection groups by introducing _
well - framed _ and _ locally conical _ systems .
we complete the program for all irreducible _ finite _ groups having a presentation of the form @xmath27 with @xmath28 for all @xmath29 .
each such group has an irreducible faithful representation as a complex reflection group .
the irreducible finite coxeter groups are precisely those with each @xmath30 , i.e. , those with a real form .
the remaining groups are _ shephard groups _ , the symmetry groups of regular complex polytopes .
the family of coxeter and shephard groups contains 21 of the 26 exceptional well - generated complex reflection groups . using shephard and todd s numbering , the remaining five groups are @xmath31 .
let @xmath32 denote an @xmath33-dimensional @xmath34-vector space .
a _ reflection _ in @xmath32 is any non - identity element @xmath35 of finite order that fixes some hyperplane @xmath36 , and a finite group @xmath37 is called a _ reflection group _ if it is generated by reflections .
henceforth , we assume that @xmath38 acts irreducibly on @xmath32 .
shephard and todd gave a complete classification of all such groups in @xcite .
given a ( finite ) reflection group @xmath37 , we may choose a positive definite hermitian form @xmath39 on @xmath32 that is preserved by @xmath38 , i.e. , @xmath40 for all @xmath41 and @xmath42 .
we always regard @xmath32 as being endowed with such a form , which is unique up to positive real scalar when @xmath38 acts irreducibly on @xmath32 .
we let @xmath43 denote the associated norm , defined by @xmath44 for all @xmath45 . as a special case of a complex reflection group , consider a finite group @xmath46 that is generated by reflections through hyperplanes . by extending scalars
, we consider @xmath38 as acting on @xmath47 , and regard @xmath38 as a reflection group .
we will call a ( complex ) reflection group that arises in this way a _ ( finite ) real reflection group_. a subgroup @xmath37 naturally acts on the dual space @xmath48 via @xmath49 , and this action extends to the symmetric algebra @xmath50 .
an important subalgebra of @xmath51 is _ the ring of invariants _ @xmath52 , whose structure actually characterizes reflection groups : a finite group @xmath37 is a reflection group if and only if @xmath52 is a polynomial algebra @xmath53 $ ] .
when @xmath38 is a reflection group , such generators @xmath54 of algebraically independent homogeneous polynomials for @xmath52 are not unique , but we do have uniqueness for the corresponding _ degrees _ @xmath55 .
it is well - known that the minimum number of reflections required to generate @xmath38 is either @xmath56 or @xmath57 .
if there exists such a generating set @xmath58 with @xmath59 , we say that @xmath38 is _ well - generated _ and that @xmath60 is a _
well - generated system_. ( finite ) real reflection groups form an important class of well - generated reflection groups .
another important family consists of symmetry groups of _ regular complex polytopes _ ; these are known as _ shephard groups _ , and were extensively studied by both shephard @xcite and coxeter @xcite .
the ( complex ) reflecting hyperplanes of a real reflection group @xmath38 intersect the embedded real sphere @xmath61 to form the _ coxeter complex _ , a simplicial complex with many wonderful properties .
we call the maximal simplices of a coxeter complex _ chambers_. the real cone @xmath62 over a chamber @xmath63 is called a _ ( closed ) weyl chamber _ , and one nice feature of the coxeter complex is its algebraic description when @xmath60 is a _ simple system _ ,
i.e. , when @xmath58 is the set of reflections through walls of a weyl chamber . in this case
, the poset of faces for the complex has the alternate description @xcite as the poset of parabolic cosets @xmath64 ordered by reverse inclusion , i.e. , @xmath65 naturally , one can define such a poset @xmath66 for an arbitrary group @xmath38 with set of _ distinguished generators _ @xmath58 . in @xcite , babson and reiner
show that the geometry of this general construction is still well - behaved when @xmath58 is finite and minimal with respect to inclusion .
in particular , they show that such posets @xmath66 are _ simplicial posets _ , meaning that every lower interval is isomorphic to a boolean algebra .
in fact , each @xmath66 is _ pure _ of dimension @xmath67 and _ balanced_. in other words , there is a coloring of the atoms using @xmath68 colors so that each maximal element lies above exactly one atom of each color .
the natural coloring given by @xmath69 recall that when such a coloring is present , we can select subposets by restricting to particular colors .
precisely , from each subset @xmath70 , we obtain the following subposet _ selected by @xmath71 _ : @xmath72 we will often write @xmath73 in place of @xmath66 , and @xmath74 in place of @xmath75 .
when @xmath38 is a reflection group , the lattice of intersections of reflecting hyperplanes for @xmath38 under reverse inclusion is denoted @xmath76 , or simply @xmath77 .
it is a subposet of the lattice @xmath78 of all @xmath34-linear subspaces of @xmath32 ordered by reverse inclusion . for a subset @xmath79
, we define @xmath80 these are the only notions of span and hull that will appear in this paper .
the following definitions aim to extend the relation between @xmath77 and @xmath66 for simple systems of real reflection groups to well - generated systems for complex reflection groups . for @xmath60 a well - generated system , a _ frame _
@xmath81 is a collection of nonzero vectors with @xmath82 here , @xmath83 is the reflecting hyperplane for reflection @xmath84 .
we say that @xmath85 is a _
framed system_. we will sometimes index a generating set @xmath58 and frame @xmath86 with @xmath87 instead of @xmath88 , writing @xmath89 and @xmath90 .
this is usually done when @xmath38 is the symmetry group of a regular polytope and @xmath86 is chosen from the vertices of the barycentric subdivision in such a way that each @xmath91 corresponds to an @xmath29-dimensional face of the polytope ; see figures [ fig : our ] , [ fig : cubeexample ] , and section [ background ] . before stating the next definition , we make precise what is meant by ( piecewise ) @xmath92-linearly extending a map @xmath93 on vertices of a simplicial poset @xmath73 .
identifying @xmath73 with a @xmath94-complex as in @xcite , each point @xmath95 is contained in a unique ( open ) cell @xmath96 . because @xmath73 is a simplicial poset , the cell admits a characteristic map @xmath97 that maps the standard @xmath98-simplex onto @xmath99 while restricting to a bijection between vertices ( @xmath16-cells ) .
thus , there are unique scalars @xmath100 so that @xmath101 we extend @xmath102 to all of @xmath73 by defining @xmath103 we can now state the main definitions of this paper .
[ def : well - framed ] let @xmath85 be a framed system . define @xmath104 by the following map on vertices @xmath105 where @xmath106 * we say that @xmath85 is _ well - framed _ if the equivariant map @xmath107 is an embedding . *
if , in addition , each @xmath108 contains the image of at least one @xmath109-face under @xmath107 , then we say that @xmath85 is _
strongly stratified_. [ convention ] given a well - framed system @xmath85 , we will often identify the abstract simplicial poset @xmath66 and the geometric realization @xmath110 afforded by @xmath107 .
observe that a system @xmath85 is well - framed if and only if for any positive real constants @xmath111 , the system @xmath112 is well - framed .
[ example : coxeter ] let @xmath60 be a simple system , i.e. , an irreducible finite real reflection group @xmath38 with @xmath58 the set of reflections through walls of a weyl chamber . if @xmath38 is a weyl group , one can obtain a real frame by choosing @xmath86 to be the set of fundamental dominant weights . more generally , a real frame is obtained by choosing one nonzero point on each extreme ray of a weyl chamber corresponding to @xmath58 .
the resulting system @xmath85 is strongly stratified and @xmath110 is homeomorphic to the coxeter complex via radial projection ; figure [ fig : embedding ] illustrates the construction for @xmath113 , the dihedral group of order 10 . . ]
we say that @xmath60 is _ well - framed _ or _ strongly stratified _ if there exists a frame @xmath86 for which @xmath85 is well - framed or strongly stratified , respectively . for @xmath38 a real reflection group
, the following example suggests that only simple systems @xmath60 can be well - framed by a real frame @xmath114 . in other words ,
the well - framed systems @xmath85 with @xmath86 real and @xmath38 a ( complexified ) finite real reflection group are completely characterized in example [ example : coxeter ] ; see corollary [ corollary : coxeter ] below .
[ nonembedding ] let @xmath113 , the dihedral group of order @xmath115 , and let @xmath116 , where @xmath117 are the reflections indicated in figure [ fig : nonembedding ] . in this case
, @xmath60 is not a simple system , as the corresponding hyperplanes @xmath118 do not form a weyl chamber ; see the shaded region .
two real frames are shown in the figure , one with @xmath119 ( left ) and one with @xmath120 ( right ) .
both fail to yield a well - framed system . for example , on the right in figure [ fig : nonembedding ] , when @xmath120 , the map @xmath121 is a double covering . that are not well - framed for @xmath113 , @xmath116 , and real @xmath122 . ] comparing figures [ fig : embedding ] and [ fig : nonembedding ] , we see that for a fixed @xmath38 , it is possible to have both good and bad choices for @xmath58 and @xmath86 . also observe that @xmath85 being well - framed is a global property , not a local one . for example
, figure [ fig : nonembedding ] shows that for @xmath123 large , one has to check for intersections of the simplices @xmath124 and @xmath125 .
though some systems @xmath60 do not give a well - framed triple @xmath85 for any _ real _ @xmath126 , one may still be able to choose a good frame @xmath127 , as in the following example .
[ triangleexample ] let @xmath128 and let @xmath116 , where @xmath117 and @xmath129 are the reflections indicated in figure [ fig : triangleexample ] .
as in example [ nonembedding ] , @xmath60 is not a simple system because the corresponding hyperplanes @xmath118 do not form a weyl chamber .
if @xmath130 are real and as shown in figure [ fig : triangleexample ] , the triple @xmath85 is not well - framed .
in fact , for every choice of a real frame @xmath131 , the resulting system @xmath85 is not well - framed . however , it is still possible to construct a well - framed system from @xmath60 using @xmath132 .
let @xmath133 be the ( complex ) reflecting hyperplanes for @xmath134 , respectively , and choose coordinates so that @xmath135,\quad h_2=\mathbb c\left[\begin{matrix}0\\ 1\end{matrix}\right],\quad h_3=\mathbb c\left[\begin{matrix}\sqrt{3}\\ 1\end{matrix}\right].\ ] ] let @xmath136 \quad\text{and}\quad \lambda_1=i\left[\begin{matrix } 0 \\ 1\end{matrix}\right ] .\ ] ] then it is straightforward to verify that @xmath85 is a well - framed system .
for example , the two segments @xmath137 + ( 1-t)\frac{1}{4}\left[\begin{matrix}\sqrt{3}\\ -1\end{matrix}\right]\ : \ 0\leq t\leq 1\right\}\\ \intertext{and } \sigma_2&=w\sigma_1=\left\{s\frac{i}{2}\left[\begin{matrix } \sqrt{3 } \\ -1\end{matrix}\right ] + ( 1-s)\frac{1}{2}\left[\begin{matrix } 0 \\ 1\end{matrix}\right ] \ :
\ 0\leq s\leq 1\right\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] do not intersect , since they have distinct endpoints and there is no real solution to @xmath138 note also that the linear form @xmath139 is nonzero on @xmath140 and @xmath141 , implying that @xmath142 neither intersect @xmath140 nor @xmath141 . with @xmath128 and @xmath116 .
the system @xmath60 is well - framed for some nonreal @xmath143 , but not for any real @xmath144 . ]
though @xmath66 is generally only a boolean complex , existence of a well - framed system @xmath85 forces it to be a simplicial complex : [ proposition : simplicial ] if @xmath85 is well - framed , then @xmath145 is a balanced simplicial complex .
the image of a face under @xmath107 is determined by its vertices .
because @xmath107 is assumed to be an embedding , it follows that any two faces of @xmath73 with equal vertex sets must be the same face . as a corollary
, we see that every well - framed system @xmath85 with @xmath38 a real reflection group and @xmath114 is of the type constructed in example [ example : coxeter ] .
we make this precise in the following corollary , whose proof is straightforward and left to the reader . [
corollary : coxeter ] let @xmath60 be a well - generated system with @xmath38 a ( finite ) real reflection group . assume that @xmath114 is a real frame .
then @xmath85 is well - framed if and only if @xmath146 are the extreme rays of a weyl chamber .
moreover , if @xmath85 is well - framed , then @xmath60 is a simple system .
we now come to the notion of _ support_. note that in the following definition , we could very well replace @xmath147 with @xmath148 , given convention [ convention ] .
however , it will be helpful to distinguish between the two .
let @xmath85 be well - framed .
we define the _ support _ map @xmath149 and let @xmath150 viewed as a subposet of @xmath78 . as for @xmath76 , we will often write @xmath151 in place of @xmath152 . we start by observing that for a well - framed system , @xmath153 .
[ pi : l ] for a well framed system @xmath85 , we have @xmath154 with equality if and only if @xmath85 is strongly stratified .
consider a coset @xmath155 , and recall that @xmath156 .
using the definition of @xmath86 , we also have that @xmath157 the inclusion follows .
the second claim follows from the definition of a strongly stratified system by considering dimension .
the main theorem of this section is that the equivariant support map for a well - framed system has a purely algebraic description .
the mechanism enabling this characterization is the _
galois correspondence _
, an analogue of barcelo and ihrig s galois correspondence ; see @xcite , where they utilize the tits cone to establish a result generalizing the real case to all coxeter groups . in order to state the correspondence , we introduce the poset of _ standard parabolics _ @xmath158 ordered by inclusion ,
i.e. , @xmath159 note that @xmath38 acts on @xmath160 via conjugation .
[ galois ] for @xmath85 a well - framed system , @xmath161 is an @xmath38-poset isomorphism , with inverse @xmath162 using the fact that @xmath107 is an equivariant embedding of a balanced complex , @xmath163 regarding the inverse , we have @xmath164 the promised algebraic interpretation of support is now encoded in an equivariant commutative diagram : [ commutative ] for a well - framed system @xmath85 , we have the following commutative diagram of equivariant maps : @xmath165 & \delta\ar@{.>>}[d]^-{}_-{}\ar@{->}[rrr]^-{\sim}_-{\rho } & & & \rho(\delta ) \ar@{->>}[d]^-{\linspan}_- { } & \\ gw_jg^{-1 } & { \par}\ar@<.8ex>[rrr]^-\fix_- { } & & & \pi_w \ar@<.8ex>[lll]^-\stab_-\sim \ar@<-.4ex>@{^{(}->}[r]^-{\iota}_- { } & \l_w } \ ] ] if @xmath60 is strongly stratified , then @xmath166 .
this section introduces the main objects of this paper , the generalizations of ehrenborg and jung s pointed objects . recall that the _ ( closed ) star _ @xmath167 of a simplex @xmath96 in a simplicial complex @xmath168 is the subcomplex of all faces that are joinable to @xmath96 within @xmath168 .
that is , @xmath169 we will write @xmath170 for the join @xmath171 .
[ pointedobjects ] let @xmath85 be a well - framed system .
let @xmath172 .
the _ subcomplex pointed by @xmath173 _ is @xmath174 as a subposet of @xmath76 . for @xmath70 ,
let @xmath175 note that by theorem [ commutative ] , we have @xmath176 , showing that @xmath177 figure [ fig : our ] illustrates the construction of @xmath178 for @xmath179 and eight choices of @xmath71 and @xmath173 .
we have written `` @xmath173 '' above each element of @xmath173 , and `` @xmath71 '' below each element of @xmath71 in the coxeter diagram @xmath180 of @xmath60 . labeling the generators @xmath181 , a vertex marked @xmath29 in @xmath180 represents the reflection @xmath182 whose hyperplane can be written as @xmath183 recall that @xmath38 is the symmetry group of the tetrahedron @xmath184 , so the barycentric subdivision @xmath185 of the boundary of @xmath184 is homeomorphic to the coxeter complex via radial projection .
the vertex of @xmath73 marked with @xmath29 corresponds to @xmath91 .
it happens that @xmath38 is also a shephard group , because @xmath184 is a regular polytope . in the later notation of shephard groups
, vertex @xmath29 will correspond to a face @xmath186 in a distinguished _ base flag _ @xmath187 ( a chamber in the flag complex @xmath188 for the polytope @xmath184 ) . for @xmath189.,title="fig : " ] similarly , figure [ fig : cubeexample ] illustrates the construction for the hyperoctahedral group @xmath190 of @xmath191 signed permutation matrices . recall that this is the symmetry group of the @xmath15-cube @xmath184 , so its coxeter complex is a radial projection of the barycentric subdivision @xmath185 of the boundary of @xmath184 .
again , we let @xmath29 denote our choice of @xmath91 , and in later notation , a face @xmath186 of a distinguished base flag @xmath192 in the flag complex @xmath188 of @xmath184 . for @xmath193 . ]
recall that a map @xmath194 of posets is _ order - preserving _ if @xmath195 whenever @xmath196 , and _ order - reversing _ if @xmath197 whenever @xmath196 .
a @xmath198-poset is a poset with a @xmath198-action that preserves order , and a map @xmath194 of such posets is _
@xmath198-equivariant _ if it is a mapping of @xmath198-sets , i.e. , if @xmath199 for all @xmath200 and @xmath201 . the order complex of a poset @xmath202 , i.e. , the simplicial complex of all totally ordered subsets of @xmath202 , is denoted @xmath203 .
the _ face poset _
@xmath204 of a simplicial complex @xmath168 is the poset of all _ nonempty _ faces ordered by inclusion .
finally , @xmath205 denotes homotopy equivalence , with added decoration to indicate equivariance .
note that the barycentric subdivision @xmath206 is homeomorphic to @xmath168 .
the aim of this section is to establish a sufficient condition for the order complex of @xmath207 to be equivariantly homotopy equivalent to @xmath178 .
our main tool is a specialization if @xmath208 is an order - preserving @xmath198-equivariant map of @xmath198-posets such that each fiber @xmath209 is @xmath210-contractible .
theorem [ webb ] specializes @xmath202 to @xmath204 and replaces @xmath211 with its _ opposite _ @xmath212 , using the fact that @xmath213 and @xmath214 .
recall that @xmath212 is obtained from @xmath211 by reversing order .
] of thvenaz and webb s equivariant version of quillen s fiber lemma .
[ webb ] let @xmath211 be a @xmath198-poset , and let @xmath168 be a simplicial complex with a @xmath198-action . if @xmath215 is an order - reversing @xmath198-equivariant map of @xmath198-posets such that the order complex @xmath216 is @xmath210-contractible for all @xmath217 , then @xmath218 . consider a simplicial complex @xmath168 and order - reversing map @xmath215 of posets . since @xmath219 is an order ideal in @xmath204 , it is the face poset @xmath220 of some subcomplex @xmath221 .
call such a subcomplex @xmath222 a _
quillen fiber_. note that @xmath216 is homeomorphic to @xmath222 , so quillen s fiber lemma concerns contractibility of quillen fibers .
the following definition of a _ locally conical system _ is central to our work . in particular
, we will show that for such systems , theorem [ webb ] can be applied to establish the desired homotopy equivalence . a well - framed system @xmath85 is _ locally conical _ if for each nonempty @xmath172 , every quillen fiber @xmath223 of @xmath224 has a cone point .
recall that a _ cone point _ @xmath225 of a simplicial complex @xmath168 is a vertex of @xmath168 that is joinable in @xmath168 to every simplex of @xmath168 , i.e. , every maximal simplex of @xmath168 contains @xmath225 .
[ prop : contraction ] let @xmath168 be a simplicial complex with a @xmath198-action . if @xmath168 has a cone point , then @xmath168 is @xmath198-contractible .
the union of all cone points must form a @xmath198-stable simplex of @xmath168 , whose barycenter @xmath225 is therefore a @xmath198-fixed point of the geometric realization @xmath226 .
since @xmath225 lies in a common simplex with every simplex of @xmath168 , this space @xmath226 is star - shaped with respect to the @xmath198-fixed point @xmath225 , and a straight - line homotopy retracts @xmath226 onto @xmath225 in a @xmath198-equivariant fashion . before employing theorem [ webb ] ,
recall that @xmath227 and that the action of @xmath38 on @xmath73 preserves types .
hence , the subcomplex @xmath228 is a @xmath229-poset .
it follows that @xmath230 is an order - reversing @xmath229-equivariant map .
[ equivalence ] let @xmath85 be a locally conical system .
let @xmath172 be nonempty and @xmath70 .
then @xmath231 is @xmath229-homotopy equivalent to @xmath178 .
we apply theorem [ webb ] to the map @xmath232 let @xmath233 , and consider first the quillen fiber @xmath234 for the unrestricted map @xmath224 . by definition of locally conical system , @xmath222 has a cone point @xmath225 .
since @xmath73 is balanced , the subcomplex @xmath222 is also balanced .
it follows that @xmath225 is the unique vertex of @xmath222 of its type .
choose @xmath235 with @xmath236 . by the construction of @xmath237 , the vertices of the join @xmath238
are contained in @xmath239 for some @xmath42 . because @xmath240 is a linearly independent set
, @xmath241 implies that @xmath225 is a vertex of @xmath96 , and hence a vertex of @xmath178 .
therefore , the restricted quillen fiber @xmath242 also has @xmath225 as a cone point .
it follows from proposition [ prop : contraction ] that @xmath243 is @xmath244-contractible .
by applying the homology functor to theorem [ equivalence ] , we have the following [ theorem : main ] let @xmath85 be a locally conical system .
let @xmath172 be nonempty and @xmath70
. then @xmath245 and @xmath246 are isomorphic as graded @xmath247-modules .
recall that a simplicial complex @xmath168 is _ cohen - macaulay _
( over @xmath248 ) if for each @xmath249 we have @xmath250 whenever @xmath251 , where @xmath252 denotes the _ link _ : @xmath253 the complex @xmath168 is _ homotopy cohen - macaulay _ if for each @xmath249 we have @xmath254 whenever @xmath255 .
homotopy cohen - macaulay implies cohen - macaulay ( over @xmath248 ) , and cohen - macaulay implies cohen - macaulay over any field ; see the appendix of @xcite .
this section is devoted to establishing explicit descriptions for the modules in theorem [ theorem : main ] when @xmath73 is cohen - macaulay .
we start with the following [ cm : typed ] let @xmath85 be a well - framed system .
let @xmath256 . if @xmath73 is cohen - macaulay ( resp .
homotopy cohen - macaulay ) , then @xmath178 is cohen - macaulay ( resp .
homotopy cohen - macaulay ) .
it is an easy exercise to show that stars inherit the cohen - macaulay ( resp .
homotopy cohen - macaulay ) property .
the nontrivial step is concluding that @xmath178 is cohen - macaulay ( resp .
homotopy cohen - macaulay ) .
this follows from a type - selection theorem for pure simplicial complexes ; see bjrner ( * ? ? ?
* thm . 11.13 ) and bjrner , wachs , and welker @xcite .
[ lemma : contractible ] let @xmath85 be a well - framed system . if @xmath257 , then @xmath178 is contractible .
this is immediate from @xmath258 .
[ homology ] let @xmath85 be a well - framed system .
let @xmath256 , and assume that @xmath73 is cohen - macaulay .
if @xmath257 , then the top homology @xmath259 is trivial ; otherwise , @xmath260 as virtual @xmath247-modules . specializing to type @xmath1 and to ehrenborg and jung s objects ( see section [ section : ehrenborg ] ) , lemma [ lemma : contractible ] translates to @xmath20 being contractible whenever @xmath14 ends with a zero ; this is precisely lemma 3.1 in @xcite . the condition that @xmath261 collapses to the condition that @xmath14 not end with zero .
we also note that the virtual modules in are well - known to be the natural generalization of ribbon representations to all coxeter and shephard groups ; see @xcite and @xcite .
though the proof of theorem [ homology ] is entirely standard , we first need a particular description of @xmath178 when @xmath262 .
the following intermediate description is straightforward .
[ parabolic : typed ] let @xmath60 be a well - generated system .
then for @xmath256 we have @xmath263 when @xmath66 is a simplicial complex , one has that @xmath60 satisfies the _ intersection condition _ @xmath264 in fact , satisfying the intersection condition is equivalent to @xmath66 being a simplicial complex ; see ( * ? ? ?
the following lemma is a straightforward application of the intersection property , and the desired description of @xmath178 is obtained by applying the lemma to .
[ induced ] let @xmath60 be well - framed . if @xmath262 , then the map @xmath265 is a @xmath247-poset isomorphism .
the proof of theorem [ homology ] now follows : the first claim follows from lemma [ lemma : contractible ] .
when @xmath262 , the result follows from the description of @xmath178 obtained through lemmas [ parabolic : typed ] and [ induced ] by applying the standard argument using cohen - macaulayness and the hopf trace formula , as is detailed by solomon in @xcite .
other good sources include @xcite and the notes of wachs @xcite .
in the case of type @xmath1 , ehrenborg and jung constructed _ pointed objects _ @xmath266 and subcomplexes @xmath267 indexed by compositions @xmath268 of @xmath15 that have positive entries @xmath269 but _ nonnegative _ last entry @xmath270 .
figure [ fig : ehrenborg : s3:poset ] shows ehrenborg and jung s @xmath271 and @xmath272 , each carrying an action of @xmath273 . in
@xcite , they show that the top homology of @xmath20 is homotopy equivalent to the order complex of @xmath274 , and that the top homology is given by a ribbon specht module of @xmath2 with row sizes determined by @xmath14 . the aim of this section is to present the underlying geometry of ehrenborg and jung s objects by showing how our objects @xmath275 specialize to theirs .
it will follow that applying our results to this specialization recovers their main results , even upgrading their homotopy equivalence to an equivariant one .
the translations between objects of this section are well - known , and we will largely follow the discussion of aguiar and mahajan ; see @xcite .
let @xmath276 and let @xmath277 be the usual generating set of adjacent transpositions , i.e. , @xmath278 the symmetric group @xmath9 is the symmetry group of the standard @xmath15-simplex @xmath279 with vertices labeled by @xmath5 .
the barycentric subdivision @xmath280 of the boundary of @xmath279 is homeomorphic to the coxeter complex via radial projection .
letting @xmath91 be the vertex of @xmath280 indexed by @xmath281 yields a well - framed system @xmath85 with @xmath282 .
note that , in particular , @xmath86 lies on the _ distinguished face _
@xmath283 of @xmath279 that has vertex set @xmath22 ; see figure [ e : intro ] .
we call @xmath85 the _ standard system for @xmath9_. with the subdivision of facet @xmath284 shaded.,title="fig : " ] a _ set composition _ of @xmath3 is an ordered partition @xmath285 of @xmath286 $ ] with nonempty blocks .
the collection of all set compositions of @xmath3 form a simplicial complex @xmath287 under refinement , with chambers having @xmath3 singleton blocks ; see figure [ fig : ehrenborg : s3 ] .
the _ type _ of a set composition is the composition of its block sizes , i.e. , @xmath288 given a composition @xmath14 of @xmath3 , the subcomplex of @xmath287 generated by the faces of type @xmath14 is denoted @xmath289 .
the map @xmath290 obtained by letting @xmath291 and extending by the action of @xmath38 , is an equivariant isomorphism @xmath292 ; see figure [ fig : ehrenborg : map ] . under this isomorphism
, a face @xmath293 of type @xmath14 corresponds to a face of type @xmath294 note also that those faces of @xmath295 in the star of @xmath283 either have @xmath3 contained in the last block or have last block equal to @xmath296 .
the lattice of hyperplane intersections @xmath76 for @xmath38 also has a simple description obtained from set compositions . under the identification of @xmath237 and @xmath287
, the support map corresponds to forgetting the order on the blocks .
that is , @xmath297 the induced partial order is given by refinement .
a _ pointed set composition _
of @xmath15 is an ordered partition @xmath293 of @xmath298 $ ] with last block @xmath299 possibly empty .
we denote the collection of all pointed set compositions of @xmath298 $ ] by @xmath21 .
the previous discussion shows that by removing @xmath3 from blocks in elements of @xmath287 , the barycentric subdivision of the facet @xmath283 can be identified with @xmath21 ; see figures [ fig : ehrenborg : map ] and [ fig : ehrenborg ] .
more accurately , @xmath21 is @xmath2-equivariantly isomorphic to @xmath300 . given a composition @xmath14 of @xmath15 with last part possibly @xmath16 , the corresponding selected complex is denoted @xmath301 , which is ehrenborg and jung s complex @xmath20 ; see figure [ fig : ehrenborg ] . by distinguishing terminal blocks before taking the image of @xmath20 under the support map , one obtains their pointed poset @xmath13 after removing any ( possibly distinguished ) empty blocks ; see figure [ fig : ehrenborg : s3 ] . and
@xmath272 from figure [ fig : ehrenborg : s3:poset].,title="fig : " ] ehrenborg and jung distinguish a block by underlining it .
thus , the above map is @xmath302 for all possible choices of @xmath303 ( with last part is allowed to be @xmath16).,title="fig : " ] the following proposition summarizes the correspondence outlined above . [
prop : conversion ] let @xmath85 be the standard system for @xmath9 , and let @xmath304 be a composition of @xmath15 with last part @xmath305 possibly @xmath16 .
then the following diagram composed of @xmath306-equivariant maps is commutative : @xmath307 ^ -{}_-{\supp } \ar@{<->}[rrrrr]^-{\sim}_- { } & & & & & \delta_{\vec{c}}\ar@{->>}[d ] & { \scriptstyle{b_1\dash b_2\dash \cdots\dash b_k } } \ar@{|->}[d]^{\supp } \\ & \pi_{{\rm{des}}(\vec{c})}^{\{r_n\ } } \ar@{<.>}[rrrrr]^-\sim_- { } & & & & & { \pi_{\vec{c}}^\bullet } & { \scriptstyle{b_1|b_2|\cdots|\underline{b_k } } } } \ ] ] the main result of @xcite is the following [ thm : ej ] let @xmath268 be a composition of @xmath3 with last part @xmath305 possibly @xmath16 .
then we have the following isomorphism of top ( reduced ) homology groups as @xmath2-modules : @xmath308 proposition [ prop : conversion ] shows that theorem [ thm : ej ] is implied by combining theorem [ c : thm ] or theorem [ s : thm ] below with theorem [ equivalence ] ( or theorem [ theorem : main ] ) .
the main theorem of this section is that we can apply all previous results to finite irreducible coxeter groups .
[ c : thm ] let @xmath60 be a simple system for a finite irreducible real reflection group @xmath38 , and let @xmath309 consist of one nonzero point from each extreme ray of a weyl chamber corresponding to @xmath58 . then the following hold : a. @xmath85 is strongly stratified.[c : stronglystratified ] b. @xmath237 is homeomorphic to the coxeter complex of @xmath60 via radial projection.[c : complex ] c. @xmath145 is homotopy cohen - macaulay .
[ c : c - m ] d. @xmath85 is locally conical.[c : locallyconical ] properties - are well - known .
the aim of this section is to establish .
we will need the following [ lemma : proj ] let @xmath38 be a finite irreducible real reflection group , and let @xmath310 be nonzero vectors on extreme rays of a fixed weyl chamber .
then the orthogonal projection of @xmath311 onto @xmath312 is nonzero .
this follows from the claim that , for all @xmath313 , one has @xmath314 for any set @xmath315 of nonzero vectors on the extreme rays of a weyl chamber @xmath63 . to see this claim ,
let @xmath316 be the simple system of roots associated with @xmath63 .
in particular , @xmath317 is orthogonal to @xmath318 and its direction is chosen so that @xmath319 . recall that the @xmath317 form an obtuse basis for @xmath32 , i.e. , a basis with @xmath320 it follows from ( * ? ? ? * ch.v ,
5 , lemma 6 ) that @xmath321 .
this implies the weak inequality , i.e. , @xmath322 for all @xmath313 .
one can now obtain the desired strict inequality by using the connectivity of the coxeter diagram for @xmath38 and the fact that the @xmath317 are obtuse ; see ( * ? ? ?
8) for an outline .
we will also need some basic facts regarding convexity of the coxeter complex ; see @xcite , particularly section 3.6 , for details and a more general treatment .
let @xmath323 be a finite real reflection group , and let @xmath168 denote its coxeter complex . recall that @xmath168 is a _ chamber complex _ , meaning that all maximal simplices ( called _ chambers _ ) are of the same dimension , and any two chambers can be connected by a gallery . here ,
a _ gallery _ connecting two chambers @xmath63 , @xmath324 is a sequence of chambers @xmath325 with the additional property that consecutive chambers are adjacent , meaning that they share a codimension-1 face .
a _ _ root _ _ in @xmath326 ( vectors perpendicular to reflecting hyperplanes ) are in canonical 1 - 1 correspondence with roots of @xmath168 .
the notion of root extends to arbitrary thin chamber complexes by introducing the notion of a folding .
the terminology is due to tits , who characterized abstract coxeter complexes as precisely those thin chamber complexes with `` enough '' foldings ; see ( * ? ? ?
of @xmath168 is the intersection of @xmath168 with a closed half - space determined by a reflecting hyperplane , and a subcomplex of @xmath168 is called _ convex _ if it is an intersection of roots .
each convex subcomplex @xmath327 is itself a chamber complex in which any two maximal simplices can be connected by a @xmath327-gallery .
moreover , a chamber subcomplex @xmath327 is convex if and only if any shortest @xmath168-gallery connecting two chambers of @xmath327 is contained in @xmath327 . the main tool for proving theorem [ c : thm ] is an iterative method for detecting cone points .
the following discussion and lemma make this precise .
choose a nontrivial subset @xmath172 and consider a nontrivial simplex @xmath328 .
choose @xmath329 to be a chamber of @xmath330 containing @xmath331 .
from a sequence @xmath332 of distinct vertices of @xmath329 , we construct a descending sequence of convex subcomplexes @xmath333 where we set @xmath334 and define @xmath335 we call the sequence @xmath336 _ cone - approximating _ for the triple @xmath337 if the following two conditions hold : 1 .
@xmath338 is a cone point of @xmath339 for @xmath340 .
2 . @xmath341 for @xmath340 .
note that @xmath342 implies the existence of cone - approximating sequences , since @xmath173 is nontrivial .
the main result is that any cone - approximating sequence can be extended to contain a vertex of @xmath96 : [ c : approx ] in the above setting , a maximal cone - approximating sequence @xmath343 for @xmath337 has @xmath344 .
supposing @xmath345 , we have that @xmath346 . from this
it follows that @xmath347 first note that @xmath348 is a convex subcomplex .
set @xmath349 the _ distinguished chamber _ of @xmath348 containing @xmath96 , and let @xmath350 be another chamber of @xmath348 .
since @xmath348 is convex , we have that @xmath351 is a convex chamber subcomplex of @xmath330 .
thus , there is a gallery in @xmath352 that connects chambers @xmath353 and @xmath354 .
therefore , there is a sequence of reflections @xmath355 that induces a gallery from @xmath356 to @xmath350 in @xmath348 . since @xmath355 ( sequentially ) stabilizes @xmath348 , meaning that @xmath357 for every reflection @xmath182 in @xmath358 , the sequence @xmath355 also stabilizes both @xmath359 and its orthogonal complement in @xmath360 .
because @xmath361 is fixed by @xmath355 and lies strictly on one side of @xmath359 in @xmath360 , it follows that @xmath355 fixes the orthogonal complement pointwise .
this implies that the orthogonal projection @xmath362 of the vector @xmath361 onto @xmath359 in @xmath360 is fixed by @xmath355 . from lemma [ lemma : proj ]
we have @xmath363 we claim that this projection has nontrivial intersection with the cone over @xmath356 .
that is , @xmath364 to see this , note first that @xmath365 forms a chamber for a coxeter complex .
the claim now follows from the fact that pairs of walls in a chamber do not intersect obtusely ; indeed , writing @xmath366 for the reflections in two distinct walls of a chamber , we have @xmath367 and the dihedral angle formed by the walls is @xmath368 , where @xmath369 is the order of @xmath370 . by , the line @xmath371 intersects a face @xmath102 of @xmath356 that is minimal in the sense that no proper face of @xmath102 meets @xmath372 . therefore , if @xmath372 is fixed by a reflection , the face @xmath102 is fixed pointwise by the reflection .
choose @xmath373 to be some vertex of @xmath102 .
we conclude that any gallery in @xmath348 that contains @xmath356 has @xmath373 as a cone point . by connectivity
, this implies that @xmath348 has @xmath373 as a cone point . as we also have @xmath374 and @xmath375 , we can append @xmath373 to obtain a longer approximating sequence .
let @xmath172 be nonempty and @xmath376 .
choose @xmath329 to be a chamber of @xmath330 containing @xmath331 .
consider the quillen fiber @xmath377 for the map @xmath378 , as in of theorem [ equivalence ] , and let @xmath379 be a maximal cone - approximating sequence for @xmath337 . by lemma
[ c : approx ] , @xmath380 has cone point @xmath361 that is also a vertex of @xmath96 .
we want to show that @xmath361 is also a cone point for the quillen fiber . since @xmath381 and @xmath382 for some particular @xmath108
, it follows that @xmath383 , and hence @xmath384 let @xmath385 .
we want to show that the join @xmath386 is also in the fiber .
since @xmath387 , we need only show that @xmath388 .
but this is clear , since @xmath389 and @xmath390 .
_ shephard groups _ form an important class of complex reflection groups .
they are the symmetry groups of regular complex polytopes , as defined by shephard @xcite . here
we will follow coxeter s treatment @xcite .
let @xmath184 be a finite arrangement of complex affine subspaces of @xmath32 , with partial order given by inclusion .
we call its elements _ faces _ , denoting an @xmath29-dimensional face by @xmath391 .
a @xmath16-dimensional face is called a _
vertex_. allowing _ trivial faces _ @xmath392 and @xmath393 , all other faces are called _
proper faces_. a totally ordered set of proper faces is called a _
flag_. the simplicial complex of all flags is called the _ flag complex _ and is denoted @xmath188 .
this is the order complex of @xmath184 with its improper faces @xmath394 and @xmath32 omitted .
such an arrangement @xmath184 is a _ polytope _ if the following hold : a. @xmath395.[poly:1 ] b. if @xmath396 and @xmath397 , then the open interval @xmath398 is connected , i.e. , its hasse diagram is a connected graph.[poly:2 ] c. [ poly:3 ] if @xmath396 and @xmath399 , then the open interval @xmath400 contains at least two distinct @xmath401-dimensional faces @xmath402 for each @xmath401 with @xmath403 .
for @xmath184 a polytope , note that properties and enable one to extend any partial flag @xmath404 in @xmath188 to a maximal flag ( under inclusion ) of the form @xmath405 we call maximal flags in @xmath188 _ chambers_. if the group @xmath37 of automorphisms of @xmath184 acts transitively on the chambers of @xmath184 , then we say that @xmath184 is _ regular _ and that @xmath38 is a _ shephard group_. the complexifications of the two ( affine ) arrangements shown in figure [ starry ] are examples of regular ( complex ) polygons . both polygons have symmetry group @xmath406 , the dihedral group of order 10 . .
] if @xmath184 contains a pair of distinct vertices that are at the minimum distance apart ( among all pairs of distinct vertices ) with no edge of @xmath184 connecting them , then @xmath184 is _ starry _ ; see @xcite .
for example , the first polytope of figure [ starry ] is _ starry _ , whereas the second is _
nonstarry_. from the work of coxeter , each shephard group @xmath38 is the symmetry group of two ( possibly isomorphic ) nonstarry regular complex polytopes ; see tables iv and v in @xcite . henceforth , we assume that all polytopes are nonstarry .
though currently unmotivated , the importance of this assumption will be made clear by theorem [ s : thm ] . given a regular complex polytope @xmath184 and a choice of maximal flag @xmath407 called the _ base chamber _
, for each @xmath29 the group @xmath408 is generated by some reflection @xmath182 .
choosing such an @xmath182 for each @xmath29 yields an associated set @xmath89 that generates @xmath38 .
we call @xmath58 a set of
_ distinguished generators_. in the case that @xmath184 has a real form , each @xmath182 is uniquely determined , and they give the usual coxeter presentation for @xmath38 . in general , coxeter shows that one can always choose the reflections @xmath182 so that for some integers @xmath409 the group has the following coxeter - like presentation with defining relations @xmath410 these relations are encoded by _ symbol _
@xmath411p_1[q_1]p_2\cdots p_{\ell-2}[q_{\ell-2}]p_{\ell-1},\ ] ] which is uniquely determined by @xmath38 up to reversal .
the corresponding nonstarry polytopes are denoted @xmath412 the second called the _ dual _ of the first . if we denote one of the two polytopes by @xmath184 , then the other is denoted by @xmath413 .
the two polytopes have dual face posets and isomorphic flag complexes .
the complete classification of shephard groups is quite short : * the symmetry groups of real regular polytopes , i.e. , the coxeter groups with connected unbranched diagrams : types @xmath414 .
* @xmath415p_1 $ ] with @xmath416 not both @xmath417 , and @xmath418 satisfying @xmath419 where @xmath420 if @xmath421 is odd . using shephard and todd s numbering , these groups are @xmath422 . *
@xmath423 with @xmath424 .
the group can be represented as @xmath191 permutation matrices with entries the @xmath425th roots of unity .
* @xmath4263[3]3=g_{26}$ ] * @xmath4273[3]3=g_{25}$ ] * @xmath4273[3]3[3]3=g_{32}$ ] .
the following list summarizes notation and assumptions that will remain fixed when dealing with shephard groups .
* @xmath38 is a shephard group .
* @xmath184 is a non - starry regular complex polytope with symmetry group @xmath38 .
* @xmath188 is the flag complex of @xmath184 , consisting of all flags of ( proper ) faces .
* @xmath428 is a chosen base flag in @xmath188 .
* @xmath58 is a set of distinguished generators for @xmath38 corresponding to @xmath429 .
one can choose @xmath58 to satisfy the presentation found in the classification above , but doing so is unnecessary .
* let @xmath172 with @xmath430 and @xmath431 .
then @xmath432 * @xmath76 is the lattice of hyperplane intersections for @xmath38 under reverse inclusion .
the aim of this section is to present an analogue of theorem [ c : thm ] for shephard groups .
if @xmath38 is the symmetry group of a _ real _ regular polytope @xmath184 , then the coxeter complex @xmath168 is obtained by intersecting the reflecting hyperplanes with the real sphere @xmath433 .
a radial projection sends @xmath168 homeomorphically onto the barycentric subdivision of @xmath184 .
moreover , it is a geometric realization of the ( a priori ) poset of _ standard cosets _
@xmath434 ordered by reverse inclusion .
this section presents the analogous picture for shephard groups , as established by orlik @xcite and orlik , reiner , shepler @xcite .
the _ vertices _ of a face @xmath102 of @xmath184 are the vertices of @xmath184 lying on @xmath102 , and the _ centroid _
@xmath435 of @xmath102 is the average of its vertices .
centroids play an important role in what follows .
a _ shephard system _ is a triple @xmath85 with the following properties : a. @xmath38 is the symmetry group of a nonstarry regular complex polytope @xmath436 .
b. @xmath58 is a set of distinguished generators corresponding to a chosen base flag @xmath437 c. @xmath438 is defined by setting @xmath439 .
we start by observing that such triples are framed systems .
a shephard system is a framed system .
recall from section [ background ] that for @xmath440 , the reflection @xmath441 stabilizes @xmath442 in particular , centroid @xmath443 of @xmath186 is fixed by all @xmath444 with @xmath445 .
in other words , @xmath446 let @xmath185 denote the ( topological ) subspace of @xmath32 that consists of all real convex hulls of centroids of flags under inclusion , i.e. , @xmath447 we can now state the analogue of theorem [ c : thm ] for shephard groups : [ s : thm ] let @xmath85 be a shephard system .
then the following hold : a. @xmath85 is strongly stratified.[s : stronglystratified ] b. @xmath448.[s : b ] c. @xmath145 is homotopy cohen - macaulay .
[ s : c - m ] d. @xmath85 is locally conical.[s : locallyconical ] note that figure [ starry ] illustrates why the non - starry assumption is necessary ; indeed , @xmath107 fails to be an embedding in the starry case when @xmath449 and @xmath450 is a maximal flag .
the remainder of this section explains - , while will be established in the next section . during our discussion
, the reader should take note of our use of theorems [ barycentric ] and [ theorem : orliksolomon ] , two _ uniformly stated _ theorems that are _ proven case - by - case_. in particular , theorem [ barycentric ] relies on a theorem of orlik and solomon that says a shephard group and an associated coxeter group have the same discriminant matrices , a result relying on the classification of shephard groups ; see @xcite .
however , up to the use of theorems [ barycentric ] and [ theorem : orliksolomon ] , our approach for theorem [ s : thm ] is case - free . for each shephard group ,
the invariant @xmath451 of smallest degree @xmath452 is unique , up to constant scaling .
for example , if @xmath38 has a real form , then @xmath453 for some suitable set of coordinates . the _ milnor fiber of @xmath38 _ is defined to be @xmath454 , where @xmath451 is regarded as a map @xmath455 . in @xcite
, orlik constructs a @xmath38-equivariant strong deformation retraction of the milnor fiber @xmath454 onto a simplicial complex @xmath456 homeomorphic to @xmath185 , which he shows is a geometric realization of the flag complex @xmath188 .
[ barycentric ] let @xmath457 be a shephard group with invariant @xmath455 of smallest degree .
then there exists a simplicial complex @xmath458 called the _ milnor fiber complex _ containing the vertices of @xmath184 such that 1 . 1 .
there is an equivariant strong deformation retract @xmath459 .
2 . for each @xmath108 , the set @xmath460 is a subcomplex of @xmath456 , and @xmath461 restricts to a strong deformation retract of @xmath462 onto @xmath463 .
[ skeleton ] let @xmath464 and @xmath465 denote the @xmath401-skeleton of each complex . then 1 .
@xmath466 for all @xmath401 , and 2 .
@xmath467 is a disjoint union .
[ realization ] 1 .
@xmath456 is @xmath38-equivariantly homeomorphic to @xmath185 , and 2 .
@xmath185 is a geometric realization of the flag complex @xmath188 via @xmath468 parts ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) are ( * ? ? ?
* thm 4.1(i)-(ii ) ) , while ( 3 ) uses the proof of ( * ? ? ?
* thm 5.1 ) .
a nice discussion of the related theory is found in @xcite . using the additional property that @xmath454 has an isolated critical point at the origin , orlik was able to describe the topology of the flag complex @xmath188 : [ cm ] @xmath188 is homotopy cohen - macaulay , and is homotopy equivalent to a wedge of @xmath469-spheres of dimension @xmath470 .
we will establish and of theorem [ s : thm ] by combining theorem [ barycentric ] and theorem [ cm ] with the following [ parabolic ] let @xmath38 be a shephard group of @xmath184 , and let @xmath187 be a base flag with corresponding distinguished generating set @xmath58 .
then the map @xmath471 is a @xmath38-equivariant isomorphism the crux of the proof is that @xmath472 the type function on @xmath188 is naturally given by @xmath473 notice that @xmath107 factors as @xmath474 where @xmath290 is as in theorem [ parabolic ] , and @xmath475 is provided by theorem [ barycentric](a ) .
hence , the triple @xmath85 is well - framed and @xmath448 .
employing theorem [ cm ] yields .
all that remains for establishing - is to show that each @xmath108 contains the image under @xmath107 of a @xmath109-simplex of @xmath73 .
this follows from the following beautiful theorem that merges work of orlik and solomon ( * ? ? ?
* thm . 6 ) and orlik ( * ? ? ?
4.1(iii ) ) ; this amalgamation appears in the latter paper of orlik .
[ theorem : orliksolomon ] let @xmath38 the symmetry group of a nonstarry regular complex polytope @xmath184 .
let @xmath108 , and write @xmath476 .
then there exists strictly positive integers @xmath477 such that @xmath478 and @xmath479 is the @xmath401-skeleton of the restricted milnor fiber complex @xmath480 .
consider @xmath108 with @xmath481 . by theorem [ theorem : orliksolomon ]
, @xmath482 is nonempty if @xmath483 , as this implies that the right side of is strictly positive .
but this is clear , since @xmath484 for any set of basic invariants @xmath54 .
( in fact , @xmath485 , with equality if and only if @xmath38 is a real reflection group . ) by theorem [ barycentric ] , each @xmath486-simplex of @xmath487 corresponds to an @xmath486-simplex of @xmath488 .
hence , @xmath489 is nonempty .
since @xmath490 , it follows by considering dimension that @xmath236 for some @xmath491 .
this section is dedicated to proving of theorem [ s : thm ] . throughout
, @xmath85 will be a fixed shephard system , and @xmath391 will denote an @xmath29-dimensional face of @xmath184 . because we will need to work with faces of @xmath184 instead of centroids , we start with some straightforward results relating the two .
the most important of these results says that centroids of a maximal flag ( together with the origin @xmath492 ) form an _ orthoscheme _ ; see @xcite .
more precisely , we have the following [ prop : orthoscheme ] let @xmath184 be a regular complex polytope , and let @xmath493 be a maximal flag of faces .
then the vectors @xmath494 form an orthogonal basis for @xmath32 . by taking partial sums in , we obtain the following [ orthoscheme_basis ]
let @xmath495 be a maximal flag of a regular polytope @xmath184 .
then the centroids @xmath496 form a basis for @xmath497 .
two particularly important results follow from lemma [ orthoscheme_basis ] .
[ orthospan ] @xmath498 for all @xmath499 .
[ flagintersection ] if @xmath500 are two subflags of a fixed flag @xmath501 , then @xmath502 we are now ready to present the main tool that will be used in the proof of theorem [ s : thm ] : [ unique ] let @xmath108 of dimension @xmath503 , and suppose that @xmath504 and @xmath505 are two @xmath401-flags with @xmath506 set @xmath507 .
for @xmath508 , if @xmath102 is a face such that @xmath509 , then one of the following holds : a. @xmath510 .
b. @xmath511 for all @xmath512 .
suppose that @xmath513 with @xmath514 and @xmath512 maximal .
using the definition of a polytope , we can extend @xmath515 to a maximal flag @xmath501 . by doing so
, corollaries [ orthospan ] and [ flagintersection ] imply that @xmath516 similarly , @xmath517 by comparing dimension , we have that @xmath518 .
our first claim is that @xmath519 are minimal faces of @xmath102 containing @xmath520 .
certainly the intersection is contained in @xmath521 ( and @xmath522 ) .
moreover , it contains the centroid @xmath523 ( resp .
@xmath524 ) , which can not be contained in any proper face of @xmath521 ( resp .
@xmath522 ) by corollary [ orthospan ] . assume without loss of generality that @xmath525 . from the equalities of and
, we have @xmath526 .
the definition of a polytope implies the existence of a face @xmath527 , which must therefore necessarily contain both @xmath528 and @xmath524 .
we claim that @xmath529 .
this follows immediately if @xmath530 , since faces and centroids determine each other ; see theorem [ barycentric](3)(b ) , for example .
the other case is slightly more work .
suppose that @xmath531 .
extend @xmath532 to a maximal flag @xmath533 and recall that the centroids for @xmath533 form an orthoscheme . combining corollary [ orthospan ] with proposition [ prop : orthoscheme ]
, it follows that the vector of @xmath528 is perpendicular to @xmath532 .
as @xmath524 is also in @xmath532 , this implies that @xmath534 is perpendicular to @xmath528 .
hence , @xmath535 because @xmath531 , we therefore have @xmath536 this contradicts regularity , since there is a unitary @xmath42 with @xmath537 , i.e. , with @xmath538 .
having established that @xmath539 , the minimality of @xmath522 forces equality .
let @xmath172 be nonempty .
identifying @xmath73 with @xmath188 , we have @xmath229 corresponds to @xmath540 , and @xmath541 with @xmath542 given by @xmath543 .
let @xmath544 .
we claim that for some face @xmath545 of @xmath184 , the quillen fiber @xmath546 has @xmath545 as a cone point .
this implies the desired claim of @xmath85 being locally conical . from the definition of @xmath547 and theorem [ barycentric ] ,
we can write @xmath548 for some @xmath401-flag @xmath549 in @xmath330 .
because @xmath501 can be extended to a flag in @xmath73 containing @xmath540 , we can fix a nontrivial face @xmath550 and choose @xmath551 such that one of the following holds : a. @xmath552 is the maximal face of @xmath501 that is weakly contained in @xmath102 , or b. @xmath552 is the minimal face of @xmath501 that weakly contains @xmath102 .
we claim that @xmath552 is a cone point of @xmath222 . to establish this , suppose @xmath553 is another @xmath401-flag in @xmath330 with support @xmath554 . using lemma [ unique ]
, we will show that @xmath555 suppose first that we are in case ( a ) , i.e. , @xmath556 . because @xmath557 can be extended to a maximal flag containing @xmath540 , either 1 . an element of @xmath557 is weakly contained in @xmath102 , or 2 .
each element of @xmath557 strictly contains @xmath102 . however , ( 2 ) is not a valid possibility .
supposing otherwise , we can extend @xmath557 by @xmath552 to obtain a strictly larger flag with support equal to @xmath554 . considering dimension yields a contradiction . in the case of ( 1 )
, lemma [ unique ] shows that @xmath558 .
if we are instead in case ( b ) , i.e. , @xmath559 , we can use the same argument , applied to the dual polytope @xmath413 , to conclude that @xmath560 .
the aim of this section is to relate ribbon representations of shephard groups to the group algebra , the exterior powers of the reflection representation , and to the coinvariant algebra .
recall that the group algebra @xmath561 $ ] of a finite group @xmath198 over @xmath34 is semisimple , and thus the grothendieck group @xmath562 of the category of finite dimensional @xmath198-representations is the free @xmath248-module with basis the isomorphism classes of irreducible @xmath198-modules .
the map sending each irreducible module to its character linearly extends to an isomorphism of @xmath563 and the space of complex class functions on @xmath198 .
in fact , this is an isomorphism in the category of finite - dimensional hilbert spaces , where the form @xmath564 on @xmath563 is that for which the irreducible @xmath198-modules form an orthonormal basis , and the form @xmath39 on class functions is given by @xmath565 . in what follows
, we make no notational distinction between elements of @xmath563 and class functions .
let @xmath60 be a simple system , and @xmath566 be the sign representation , defined by @xmath567 for @xmath568 . in @xcite
, solomon showed that @xmath569 for @xmath570 , where @xmath571 the @xmath38-modules @xmath572 are known as _ ribbon representations _ due to their alternate description when @xmath573 and @xmath574 for @xmath575 . considering this case ,
let @xmath70 , write @xmath576 with @xmath577 , and let @xmath578 be the ribbon skew shape corresponding to composition @xmath579 ; see figure [ tableau : fig ]
. filling @xmath578 with @xmath580 in increasing order from southwest to northeast produces a tableau whose rows are stabilized by @xmath581 and whose columns are stabilized by @xmath582 .
thus , @xmath583 is the _ young symmetrizer _
@xmath584 , and hence @xmath572 is the @xmath2-specht module of ribbon skew shape @xmath578 . . ] for a simple system or shephard system @xmath60 , define @xmath585 for @xmath70 .
we call these _ ribbon representations _ , noting that in the case of coxeter groups @xmath586 regarding solomon s group algebra decomposition , applying mbius inversion to the equality @xmath587 yields [ cs : decomp ] for @xmath60 a simple system or shephard system , @xmath588 . another extension of a main theorem in @xcite is [ theorem : steinberg ] let @xmath60 be a simple system or shephard system . for @xmath70 , the ribbon representation @xmath589 contains a unique irreducible submodule isomorphic to @xmath590 and has no submodule isomorphic to @xmath591 for @xmath592 .
one can follow the same proof as in @xcite , replacing with theorem [ cs : decomp ] . however , for the reader s convenience , we supply a simple and significantly shorter argument .
since @xmath593 occurs in @xmath594 with multiplicity equal to its dimension @xmath595 , by theorem [ cs : decomp ] it will suffice to show @xmath596 for each @xmath70 .
fixing @xmath70 , so that @xmath597 , it suffices to show for each subset @xmath598 that @xmath599 if @xmath600 , then @xmath601 is the regular representation and @xmath602 , so follows . assuming that @xmath603 , there are disjoint nonempty sets @xmath604 such that @xmath605 with each @xmath606 acting irreducibly on @xmath607 , thus yielding a decomposition @xmath608 on which each @xmath606 acts trivially on all factors except @xmath609 ; see ( * ? ? ? * ch .
the resulting decomposition of the exterior power @xmath610 combined with frobenius reciprocity , implies that @xmath611 by a theorem of steinberg ( * ? ? ?
* ch . 5 , 2 , exercise 3 ) , the @xmath606-modules @xmath612 are irreducible and distinct for @xmath613 .
hence @xmath614 and follows .
a central object in invariant theory is the coinvariant algebra @xmath615 of a finite subgroup @xmath37 .
this is the graded quotient of @xmath51 by the ideal @xmath616 generated by homogeneous invariants of positive degree .
recall that @xmath38 is a reflection group if and only if @xmath615 affords the regular representation as an ungraded module .
this section concerns the decomposition of the coinvariant algebra of a shephard group @xmath38 into ribbon representations .
more precisely , we give a determinantal expression for the multivariate generating function @xmath617 where @xmath618 is defined below , and @xmath619 denotes the graded inner product @xmath620 of an element @xmath621 and a graded @xmath38-module @xmath622 . for a shephard system @xmath60 and subset @xmath623 ,
define @xmath624}=w_{\{r_k\ : \
i\leq k\leq j\}},\ ] ] where @xmath625 is the trivial subgroup , we set @xmath626 , and the _
hilbert series _ of a graded module @xmath622 is the formal power series @xmath627 .
recall that the generators of a shephard system @xmath60 inherit an indexing from the associated chosen flag of faces @xmath192 .
however , in what follows it will be convenient to shift all indices by 1 , thus writing @xmath628 .
[ lineardiagram ] let @xmath60 be a shephard system . then @xmath629}(q ) } & \frac{1}{w_{[1,2]}(q ) } & \cdots & \frac{1}{w_{[1,\ell]}(q ) } \\ t_1 - 1 & t_1 & \frac{t_1}{w_{[2,2]}(q ) } & \cdots & \frac{t_1}{w_{[2,\ell-1]}(q ) } \\ 0 & t_2 - 1 & t_2 & \cdots & \frac{t_2}{w_{[3 , \ell-2]}(q ) } \\ \vdots & \ddots & \ddots & \ddots & \vdots \\ 0 & \cdots & 0 & t_{\ell}-1 & t_{\ell } \end{matrix}\right].\ ] ] for a ( finite ) coxeter system @xmath60 , the _ multivariate @xmath421-eulerian distribution _ is defined to be @xmath630 where @xmath631 is the usual length function on coxeter groups , and @xmath632 is the descent set of @xmath633 .
in the case of real shephard groups , reiner @xcite , following stembridge @xcite , established theorem [ lineardiagram ] with @xmath634 in place of @xmath635 .
thus , @xmath636 for real shephard groups .
extending to other shephard groups is a problem of considerable interest .
fix @xmath70 and consider the coefficient of @xmath618 in @xmath635 . by frobenius reciprocity , we have @xmath637 recall that for a reflection group @xmath638 , one has @xmath639 as graded @xmath198-modules .
it follows that @xmath640 for any @xmath623 , and that the graded @xmath38-module @xmath615 affords graded character @xmath641 .
therefore , @xmath642 consider now the right - hand side of . from the usual permutation expansion of the determinant , we have the following general equation : @xmath643 thus
, the right - hand side of is equal to @xmath644}(q ) w_{[i_1 + 1,i_2 - 1]}(q)\cdots w_{[i_j+1,\ell]}(q ) } \prod_{\stackrel{1\leq i\leq \ell}{i\neq i_1,\ldots , i_j}}(t_i-1),\ ] ] which , using the fact that @xmath645 for @xmath399 , can be written as @xmath646 taking the coefficient of @xmath618 yields @xmath647 .
in section [ section : well - framed ] we introduced well - framed and strongly stratified systems @xmath85 .
the well - framed systems subsequently studied were additionally strongly stratified , locally conical , and produced cohen - macaulay complexes @xmath66 . however , there are well - framed systems @xmath60 lacking many of these properties , including that of @xmath648 being homotopy equivalent to @xmath228 .
we discuss some of these here .
consider @xmath279 the boundary of the standard @xmath15-simplex having vertices labeled by the set @xmath5 .
its symmetry group is @xmath9 , and a minimal generating set of reflections corresponds to a spanning tree @xmath71 of the complete graph @xmath649 on @xmath5 by identifying an edge @xmath650 of @xmath71 with the transposition @xmath651 ; see @xcite .
we will focus on the generating set @xmath652 of @xmath9 that corresponds to the star graph with center @xmath3 .
we leave the proof of the following result to the reader . [
prop : star ] let @xmath279 be as above .
let @xmath653 be the vertices of @xmath279 , indexed so that @xmath654 corresponds to the vertex labeled by @xmath29 .
let @xmath655 be pairwise linearly independent over @xmath92 , and set @xmath656 .
then @xmath657 is well - framed . for @xmath658 ,
a system @xmath657 as in proposition [ prop : star ] is neither locally conical nor strongly stratified .
moreover , for @xmath659 , it is no longer true that @xmath228 is homotopy equivalent to @xmath648 for every @xmath256 with @xmath173 nonempty .
these assertions are straightforward after first considering let @xmath660 be a system as in proposition [ prop : star ] with @xmath661 .
the link of a @xmath662-simplex in @xmath73 has 6 vertices supporting 3 lines ; see figure [ fig : triangleexample ] .
thus , the system is not locally conical .
moreover , it fails to be strongly stratified , since the vertices of @xmath73 support only the 5 complex lines spanned by the vertices of @xmath663 .
the link @xmath664 of a vertex is isomorphic to @xmath665 .
the latter is isomorphic to the @xmath666 _ chessboard complex _ , which is known to be a 2-torus ; see ( * ? ? ?
* example 3.1 ) and @xcite . on the other hand ,
@xmath667 is easily seen to be the face poset of the barycentric subdivision of @xmath668 , hence its order complex is a 2-sphere .
this subsection provides evidence that our main results partially extend to the remaining well - generated reflection groups .
[ theorem : well - generateds ] if @xmath60 is a well - generated system , then @xmath66 is a simplicial complex .
our proof relies on each subgroup @xmath669 being _ parabolic _ , meaning the pointwise stabilizer of a subset @xmath670 .
the following can be obtained from the classification by considering cases .
[ theorem : parabolic ] let @xmath37 be well - generated by @xmath58 .
then each standard parabolic @xmath671 is parabolic .
more precisely , @xmath672 . to establish the intersection property ( see section [ section : homology ] ) , first note that @xmath673 for @xmath674 .
thus , @xmath675 where the third equality follows from the obvious inclusion by comparing dimensions .
consider the rank 1 reflection group @xmath676 generated by a primitive 6th root of unity @xmath677 .
observe that @xmath678 is a minimal generating set with @xmath679 and @xmath680 simplicial .
thus , a well - generated group @xmath38 and minimal generating set @xmath58 may yield a simplicial complex even when @xmath38 is not well - generated by @xmath58 .
let @xmath38 be a well - generated group , and let @xmath58 be a minimal generating set of reflections under inclusion .
is @xmath66 necessarily a simplicial complex ?
for which non - well - generated groups @xmath38 is @xmath66 a simplicial complex for some @xmath58 ?
let @xmath60 be a well - generated system .
motivated by , define @xmath681 and let @xmath682 for @xmath256 . recall that we identify @xmath228 with the poset of faces of a simplicial complex , and thus @xmath683 is obtained from @xmath228 by removing its unique bottom element @xmath38 .
call @xmath60 _ ( abstractly ) locally conical _ if for each @xmath256 with @xmath173 nonempty , every quillen fiber of @xmath684 has a cone point .
note that if @xmath60 is ( abstractly ) locally conical , then @xmath231 is @xmath229-homotopy equivalent to @xmath228 for all @xmath256 with @xmath173 nonempty .
[ conjecture : conical ] for each well - generated reflection group @xmath38 , there exists a well - generating @xmath58 for which @xmath60 is ( abstractly ) locally conical .
further , we predict the following partial extension of theorems [ c : thm ] and [ s : thm ] .
[ conjecture : main ] for each well - generated reflection group @xmath38 , there exists a generating set @xmath58 and a frame @xmath86 such that a. @xmath59 .
b. @xmath85 is strongly stratified .
c. @xmath85 is locally conical .
it is well - known @xcite that the coxeter complex @xmath456 for a finite coxeter group is _ shellable _ , meaning that its facets can be ordered @xmath685 so that the subcomplex @xmath686 is pure of dimension @xmath687 for all @xmath688 .
the question of whether the flag complex @xmath188 of a regular complex polytope @xmath184 is lexicographically shellable appears in ( * ? ? ?
* question 16 ) and @xcite . by section [ section : shephard:2 ]
, @xmath188 is isomorphic to @xmath66 for @xmath60 a shephard system for @xmath184 .
it is straightforward to shell those of rank 2 , as they are connected graphs , and it is also straightforward for @xmath689 .
those of coxeter type are shellable , as mentioned in question [ q : shelling ] .
the author used a computer to produce shellings in the remaining cases : [ shellingthm ] let @xmath60 be a coxeter or shephard system .
then @xmath66 is shellable .
[ q : shelling ] is there a uniform way of shelling the flag complex @xmath188 of a regular complex polytope ? this would give a more direct proof that @xmath188 is homotopy cohen - macaulay .
the following was inspired by a personal communication with taedong yun and ( * ? ? ?
* section 8) .
let @xmath60 be a coxeter or shephard system .
is @xmath690 shellable for all @xmath256 ?
this work forms part of the author s doctoral thesis at the university of minnesota , supervised by victor reiner , whom the author thanks for suggesting some of these questions .
he is also grateful to marcelo aguiar and volkmar welker for their helpful suggestions and corrections , richard ehrenborg and jiyoon jung for making their work available , stephen griffeth , jia huang , gus lehrer , and vivien ripoll for helpful conversations , and michelle wachs for writing a set of truly wonderful notes @xcite .
p. orlik and l. solomon , complexes for reflection groups , in `` algebraic geometry : proceedings '' ( l. libgober and p. wagreich , eds . ) , 193 - 207 , lecture notes in mathematics , vol .
862 , springer - verlag , berlin / new york , 1981 | ehrenborg and jung @xcite recently related the order complex for the lattice of @xmath0-divisible partitions with the simplicial complex of _ pointed ordered set partitions _ via a homotopy equivalence .
the latter has top homology naturally identified as a specht module .
their work unifies that of calderbank , hanlon , robinson @xcite , and wachs @xcite . by focusing on the underlying geometry ,
we strengthen and extend these results from type @xmath1 to all real reflection groups and the complex reflection groups known as _ shephard groups_. [ section ] [ theorem]proposition [ theorem]lemma [ theorem]corollary [ theorem]conjecture [ theorem]definition [ theorem]example [ theorem]observation [ theorem]convention [ theorem]observations [ theorem]question [ theorem]remark l |
the large n limit of four dimensional non - abelian gauge theories is interesting from the view point of qcd phenomenology @xcite and string theory @xcite .
lattice qcd is a useful technique for extracting fundamental results in the large n limit of qcd .
fermions are naturally quenched in the t hooft limit of large n qcd and this significantly reduces the computational cost in a lattice calculation .
in addition , there is a concept of continuum reduction @xcite , namely , physics does not depend on the size of box @xmath0 for @xmath1 and @xmath2 is a physical critical size .
these two observations have been used to extract physical results in the large n limit of qcd using numerical techniques on the lattice .
large n qcd on a continuum torus @xmath0 has several phases @xcite depending upon the size of the torus as shown in fig .
[ fourd ] .
the continuum action has @xmath3 symmetries associated with the polyakov loops in the four directions and the various phases correspond to the number of directions in which this symmetry is broken .
the continuum limit is obtained by going to the top - right corner of fig .
[ fourd ] and different approaches to this corner will result in one of the five continuum phases .
the @xmath4h - phase present for @xmath5 for all @xmath6 is an unphysical phase that does not survive the continuum limit .
the @xmath4h to @xmath4c transition is associated with the single plaquette operator opening up a gap around @xmath7 in its eigenvalue distribution .
gauge fields come in disconnected pieces in all the @xmath8c - phases due to the presence of the gap in the single plaquette operator @xcite .
the @xmath4c - phase is the confined phase of large n qcd and the @xmath9c - phase is the deconfined phase and @xmath10 .
an immediate consequence of continuum reduction is that large n qcd does not feel temperatures below @xmath11 @xcite .
numerical analysis has shown that lattice spacing effects are small in the @xmath4c - phase and it is sufficient to work at @xmath12 and @xmath13 to extract continuum results .
therefore , numerical computations can be performed on a serial computer and a cluster of computers can be efficiently used to generate statistics in a monte - carlo calculation .
since physics does not depend on the box size in @xmath4c - phase , one should show that chiral symmetry is spontaneously broken in finite volume in order to properly reproduce physics in this phase @xcite .
the order of limits are important and one has to take the large n limit before taking the quark mass to zero at finite phsyical volume . the low lying spectrum of the massless dirac operator shows evidence for spontaneous chiral breaking since the eigenvalues , @xmath14 , scales like @xmath15 with @xmath16 obeying a universal distribution .
the chiral condesate , @xmath17 , is independent of @xmath18 .
results of a calculation of the chiral condensate on the lattice is shown in fig .
[ sigma ] .
results from chiral random matrix theory @xcite were used to extract the chiral condensate at a fixed @xmath19 , @xmath6 and lattice coupling .
two lowest non - zero eigenvalues in the @xmath20 and @xmath21 topological sectors were used to show consistency .
the plot shows that there is a limit as @xmath22 and this limit is independent of @xmath6 .
results obtained at different lattice couplings yield @xmath23
since chiral symmetry is broken in large n qcd even in finite volume , one should be able to observe massless pions in finite volume .
this result emerges in the following manner @xcite .
properties of a single quark in a background gauge field @xmath24 can not depend on a shift of @xmath25 for arbitrary @xmath26 since the @xmath3 symmetries associated with the polyakov loops are not broken in the @xmath4c - phase .
but the propagator of a non - singlet meson will depend on @xmath26 , if one quark sees @xmath27 and the other sees @xmath28 as their respective gauge fields .
this is referred to as the quenched momentum prescription @xcite for the computation of meson propagators in the large n limit of qcd .
one can use the results for the chiral condensate , @xmath29 , and critical lattice size , @xmath30 , to plot the pion mass as a function of @xmath31 .
the results fall on a single universal curve as shown in fig .
[ pion ] and @xmath32 .
the @xmath4c to @xmath9c phase transition is the confinement - deconfinement phase transition since the @xmath33 symmetry associated with one of the polyakov loops is broken .
this transition is first order since there is a latent heat associated with the single plaquette @xcite .
the fermion determinant does matter in the @xmath9c - phase and it picks the correct boundary conditions for fermions in the broken direction , namely , anti - periodic with respect to the polyakov loop @xcite .
the lowest eigenvalue of the dirac operator with the correct boundary conditions can be used to study the gap in the @xmath9c - phase and one finds that chiral symmetry is restored in the @xmath9c - phase @xcite .
furthermore , the chiral transition is first order as shown in fig .
if one were to super - cool the @xmath9c - phase into the @xmath4c - phase , a second order transition with a square root singularity would be observed at @xmath34 .
non - abelian gauge theories in the confined phase are strongly interacting at large distances and weakly interacting at short distances .
if this is seen as a phase transition in some observable , one could use the universal behavior of this transition to connect the low energy physics of qcd to the high energy physics of qcd .
the wilson loop operator as a function of its size is the most likely candidate to study this transition within the @xmath4c - phase of large n qcd @xcite .
such a transition exists in two dimensional large n qcd @xcite and it is claimed that the transition in four dimensional qcd is in the same universality class . this transition is referred to as the durhuus - olesen phase transition in fig [ fourd ] .
wilson loop operators suffer from a perimeter divergence in four dimensions and one has to eliminate it when defining this operator if one were to study its eigenvalue distribution .
one possible way to suppress the perimeter divergence is to use smeared operators on the lattice .
numerical studies of the eigenvalue distribution of the smeared wilson loop operator on the lattice shows clear evidence for a phase transition as a function of the size of the wilson loop @xcite .
the universality class is the same as the one found in two dimensional large n qcd as shown in fig .
[ wilson ] and the critical loop size is roughly @xmath35 .
r. n. would like to thank the organizers of caqcd-06 for a stimulating atmosphere .
r. n. acknowledges partial support by the nsf under grant number phy-0300065 and partial support from jefferson lab . the thomas jefferson national accelerator facility ( jefferson lab )
is operated by the southeastern universities research association ( sura ) under doe contract de - ac05 - 84er40150 .
h. n. acknowledges partial support by the doe under grant number de - fg02 - 01er41165 at rutgers university .
a. v. manohar , arxiv : hep - ph/9802419 .
o. aharony , s. s. gubser , j. m. maldacena , h. ooguri and y. oz , phys . rept .
* 323 * , 183 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9905111 ] .
j. kiskis , r. narayanan and h. neuberger , does the crossover from perturbative to nonperturbative physics in qcd phys .
b * 574 * , 65 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - lat/0308033 ] .
r. narayanan and h. neuberger , pos * lat2005 * , 005 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - lat/0509014 ] .
j. kiskis , r. narayanan and h. neuberger , phys .
d * 66 * , 025019 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - lat/0203005 ] .
t. d. cohen , phys .
* 93 * , 201601 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0407306 ] .
r. narayanan and h. neuberger , nucl .
b * 696 * , 107 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - lat/0405025 ] .
j. j. m. verbaarschot and t. wettig , ann .
nucl . part .
sci . * 50 * , 343 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0003017 ] .
r. narayanan and h. neuberger , phys .
b * 616 * , 76 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - lat/0503033 ] .
d. j. gross and y. kitazawa , nucl .
b * 206 * , 440 ( 1982 ) .
j. kiskis , arxiv : hep - lat/0507003 .
r. narayanan and h. neuberger , phys .
b * 638 * , 546 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0605173 ] .
r. narayanan and h. neuberger , jhep * 0603 * , 064 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0601210 ] . b. durhuus and p. olesen , nucl
. phys .
b * 184 * , 461 ( 1981 ) . | some physical results in four dimensional large n gauge theories on a periodic torus are summarized . |
the dominant dark component of matter in the universe is clustered in bound halos which form the skeleton of all astronomical objects of cosmological interest , from dwarf galaxies to rich galaxy clusters .
the determination of the inner structure of such halos has been addressed both analytically and by numerical simulations .
the analytical approach to this problem was pioneered by gunn & gott ( 1972 ) , who adopted the simplifying assumption that halos grow through spherical infall , i.e. , the monolithic collapse of a density fluctuation of isotropically distributed , cold , collisionless matter in an otherwise homogeneous expanding universe .
this allowed them to derive the density profile resulting from self - similar initial conditions in an einstein - de sitter universe up to the onset of shell crossing .
the effects of shell crossing and of adopting more and more realistic initial conditions were addressed and the whole treatment was refined in a series of subsequent papers @xcite . according to these studies , after the collapse of some initial seed , a stationary regime is reached , the so - called secondary infall , in which the system grows inside - out .
this is the consequence of the fact that the orbital period of particles in any shell is smaller than the characteristic time of secular variation of their apapsis ( or turn - around radius ) owing to shell crossing of the infalling layers .
accordingly , 1 ) particles spend most of the time near the apapsis of their orbits , which makes their time - averaged radius close to that value , and 2 ) shell crossing gently alters the initial apapsis ( corresponding to maximum expansion ) of layers , making them contract by a monotonously varying factor of order two and , hence , with no apapsis crossing .
this is an important result since , provided the infall rate of matter is known , the inside - out growth condition completely determines the halo density profile .
much progress has been achieved in the last twenty years in the modeling of halo mass growth . in particular
, the extended press - schechter ( ps ) model @xcite makes accurate predictions on the rate at which halos increase their mass in hierarchical cosmologies @xcite .
unfortunately , in such cosmologies , halos develop from small to large scales by successive aggregations rather than through smooth spherical infall .
there are different ways in the literature to refer to the mass assembly process .
some authors call each individual aggregation event `` merger '' ( e.g. , @xcite ) , while others use the word `` accretion '' to refer to their cumulative effect ( e.g. , @xcite , hereafter w02 ; @xcite ) . in @xmath0-body or monte carlo simulations ,
it is also usual to use the words `` merger '' and `` accretion '' depending on whether the captured clumps are resolved or not , respectively ( e.g. , @xcite ) . on the other hand , if one is only interested in the _ mass growth _ of halos , the distinction between `` major '' and `` minor '' mergers or `` fast '' and `` slow '' accretion is not important as it represents solely an arbitrary classification of captures according to the mass increase they produce .
however , in dealing with the structural and kinematical effects of aggregation events on a given halo , such a distinction is crucial .
when a halo captures a much less massive clump its structure is essentially unperturbed while , in the case that both objects have comparable masses , the system is brought far from equilibrium and violently relaxes again @xcite , thus loosing the memory of the previous history .
the new equilibrium state is characterized by a normal distribution of the velocities of the different constituents similar to that yielded by two - body relaxation , although independent of the particle mass .
consequently , were halos unperturbed after any such dramatic event , they would end up as spherical systems with uniform , isotropic velocity dispersion .
for this reason , halos are often modeled as isotropic , monomassic , isothermal spheres ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
however , halos are not isolated systems and they continue collecting matter during violent relaxation , which makes the final state difficult to predict ( e.g. , @xcite ) . in addition , the frontier between minor and major captures is rather blurred and intermediate captures have their own specific dynamical effects .
the associated clumps undergo substantial dynamical friction and spiral to the halo center rather than move along stable orbits .
then , the density distribution is neither unaltered nor completely rearranged , but becomes a little cuspier at the halo center .
the situation is therefore quite complicated and difficult to implement in an analytical model .
for this reason some authors have turned to numerical experiments .
navarro , frenk , & white ( 1996 ; 1997 , hereafter nfw ) found , through @xmath0-body simulations of several hierarchical cosmologies , that the spherically averaged density profile of current halos of a wide range of masses is always well fitted by the simple analytical expression @xmath1 hereafter referred to as the nfw profile .
in equation ( [ nfw ] ) , @xmath2 is the radial distance to the halo center , and @xmath3 and @xmath4 are the halo scale radius and characteristic density , respectively .
the latter two parameters are related to each other and to the mass @xmath5 of the halo through the condition that the average density within the virial radius @xmath6 of the system is equal to @xmath7 times @xmath8 , with @xmath7 a constant factor independent of mass and @xmath8 some characteristic density of the universe .
nfw adopted @xmath8 equal to the critical density @xmath9 , and @xmath10 , although @xmath8 equal to the mean cosmic density @xmath11 and other values of @xmath7 are also often adopted .
on the other hand , @xcite showed that the spherically averaged , locally isotropized , velocity dispersion profile @xmath12 is well fitted by the solution of the jeans equation for hydrostatic equilibrium and negligible rotation @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the gravitational constant , @xmath15 the density profile given in equation ( [ nfw ] ) and @xmath16 the corresponding mass profile , for the boundary condition of null pressure at infinity .
these results have been extensively confirmed ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
there is only some controversy on the exact slope of the density profile at very small radii @xcite , the most affected by the limited resolution of simulations .
nonetheless , in spite of the substantial progress in our knowledge on the inner structure of halos afforded by @xmath0-body simulations , the physical origin of the halo density and velocity dispersion profiles remains poorly understood .
another well known result inferred from @xmath0-body simulations is that , in all the cosmologies investigated , the halo concentration @xmath17 decreases with increasing halo mass .
nfw proposed that this is a consequence of the fact that , in hierarchical cosmologies , more massive halos form later when the mean density of the universe is lower .
they demonstrated that the empirical mass - density relation is automatically recovered when the proportionality @xmath18 is assumed .
they were forced , however , to define the formation time @xmath19 as the time some progenitor collected _ one hundredth _ of the final halo mass .
salvador - sol , solanes , & manrique ( 1998 , hereafter ssm ) showed , nonetheless , the robustness of that result using a better - motivated definition of the halo formation time : the last time the system was rearranged in a major merger .
they also showed that the relation @xmath20 ( strictly with @xmath9 instead of @xmath11 , though this makes no difference for the typical halo formation times in any popular cosmology ) is equivalent to a universal dimensionless density profile for newborn halos , thus bringing some physical motivation to the assumed proportionality .
unfortunately , the @xmath21-dependence of the concentration predicted by such an assumption is not corroborated by @xmath0-body simulations ( bullock et al .
2001 , hereafter b01 ) .
a more promising result found by @xcite was that the density profile of halos that have not been subjected to any major merger is very similar to the nfw profile .
as discussed below , the continuous aggregation of small clumps proceeds essentially as secondary infall .
it is therefore well understood why , using the spherical infall model from quite a realistic density profile of the initial perturbation such as the typical density run around peaks , @xcite also found a density profile similar to the nfw one . on the other hand ,
since halos grow inside - out during secondary infall , these results are also consistent with the finding by @xcite and @xcite that the density profile of halos growing inside - out ( or through stable clustering as the former authors call this process ) and having not experienced a major merger is similar to the nfw profile .
however , the density profiles obtained from spherical infall do not satisfy the correct mass - concentration relation : the predicted concentration is substantially higher than that of simulated halos .
therefore , the role of spherical infall in the density profile of halos is still debatable . in this one respect , is also important mentioning that the inside - out growth condition is inconsistent with the dynamical effects of intermediate mass captures as mid - size clumps tend to migrate to the halo center .
@xcite have examined the possibility that the nfw profile results from the repeated action of this kind of captures , concluding that it might explain the central cusp ( see also @xcite ) .
but , as shown by @xcite , when the specific effects of intermediate captures are taken into account , the resulting density profile deviates more from the nfw profile than the one obtained under strict accretion the role , in this scheme , of the tidal stripping of captured clumps has been also examined by @xcite .
thus , before spherical infall can be confirmed as the main responsible for the density profile of halos , it is necessary to understand why the alterations induced by intermediate captures do not show up more frequently .
more importantly , all these works do not take into account the dramatic effects of major mergers ( or fast accretion ) . by definition ,
this process causes the rearrangement of the system destroying in this way the density profile developed until that moment by spherical infall .
of course , this would go unnoticed if the density profile emerging from violent relaxation turns out to be very similar to the one a halo of the same mass would have developed through spherical infall .
surprisingly enough , numerical simulations indicate that this is just what happens . indeed ,
high - resolution @xmath0-body simulations show that `` the occurrence of a recent [ major ] merger is not an important factor affecting the [ shape and the ] concentration '' of simulated halos ( w02 , p. 568 ) .
likewise , the phase space density , @xmath22 , of halos in simulations of hierarchical cosmologies is found to follow , independently of their assembly history , a power - law for more than two decades in radius with logarithmic slope close to that predicted by @xcite using the spherical infall model ( @xcite ) .
furthermore , the density profile of halos obtained in numerical simulations of monolithic collapse are very similar to those obtained in hierarchical cosmologies , which indicates that `` the merger history does not play a role in determining the halo structure '' ( @xcite , p. 1147 ; see also @xcite ) . in other words ,
the density profile of simulated halos is always the same regardless of whether ( and when ) their structure has been rearranged by major mergers .
this necessarily implies that the density profile emerging from violent relaxation must be very similar to that developed through spherical infall .
but what is the reason for such a coincidence ? the present paper attempts to answer all these questions .
we begin in [ mps ] by describing the basic equations of a variant of the extended ps model that are used in the computations of subsequent sections .
we then examine , in
[ acc ] , whether pure accretion , which yields density profiles of the nfw type , can recover the mass - concentration relation of simulated halos . in [ merg ] , we analyze the effects of mergers and intermediate captures .
the results are summarized and discussed in [ diss ] .
the modified press - schechter ( mps ) model ( ssm ; @xcite , and 2001 , hereafter rgs ) is a variant of the extended ps model intended to describe not only the mass growth of dark - matter halos in hierarchical cosmologies , but their inner structure as well . to this end
it distinguishes between major and minor aggregation events ( i.e. , major and minor mergers or fast and slow accretion ) according to whether they cause or not the complete rearrangement of the system , based on the usual comparison of the resulting fractional mass increase with respect to the reference halo with some pre - established threshold , @xmath23 , separating the two regimes .
note that a given aggregation event may be seen as major or minor depending on the partner halo considered . for consistency
, we say that halos are destroyed in major aggregation events while they survive in minor ones .
we will follow here the most usual notation adopted in observational studies ( and in ssm ) and refer to major aggregation events as `` mergers '' and to the continuous aggregation of small clumps as `` accretion '' ( one should avoid confusion with the different meaning of these words in other works ; [ intro ] ) . according to the definition of @xmath23 , the accretion rate ,
that is , the rate at which halos with @xmath5 at @xmath24 increase their mass between two mergers , is @xmath25 with @xmath26 the instantaneous transition rate at @xmath24 from halos with @xmath5 to halos between @xmath27 and @xmath28 , provided by the extended ps model @xcite @xmath29^{-3/2 } \nonumber\\ & \times&\exp\left\{-{{\delta_{\rm c}}^2(t)\over 2\sigma^2(m')}\left [ 1-{\sigma^2(m')\over\sigma^2(m)}\right]\right\}\ , .
\label{umr } \end{aligned}\ ] ] in equation ( [ umr ] ) , @xmath30 is the linear extrapolation to the present time @xmath31 of the critical overdensity of primordial fluctuations collapsing at @xmath24 , and @xmath32 is the r.m.s .
fluctuation of the density field at @xmath31 smoothed over spheres of mass @xmath5 . both @xmath30 and @xmath33
depend on the cosmology .
the @xmath34 track followed , during accretion , by halos with @xmath35 at @xmath36 is therefore the solution of the differential equation @xmath37 \label{act}\ ] ] for the initial condition @xmath38 .
strictly speaking , this is the _ average _ track followed by those halos .
real accretion tracks actually diffuse from it owing to the random effects of individual captures .
the scatter remains nonetheless quite limited along the typical lifetime of halos ( see rgs ) .
the destruction of a halo does not necessarily imply the formation of a new one : the largest partner participating in the merger can perceive it as minor and survive . only those mergers in which _ all _ initial halos are destroyed or , equivalently , none of them survives do mark the formation of a new halo .
( the definitions of halo destruction and survival imply , indeed , that there is at most one surviving halo in any aggregation event . )
thus , the formation of a halo corresponds to the last time the system was rearranged in a merger . to derive the formation rate we need to introduce the capture rate , @xmath39 , giving the rate at which a halo with mass @xmath27 at @xmath24 results from a major merger of a halo with mass @xmath5 to @xmath40 @xmath41 \nonumber \\ & \times&\frac{n(m , t)}{n(m',t)}\,{{\rm d}}m\,{{\rm d}}t \label{cap}\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath42 given by equation ( [ umr ] ) , @xmath43 the ps mass function , and @xmath44 the heaviside function . as shown by rgs ,
mergers leading to the formation of new halos are essentially binary .
this is consistent with the fact that the capture rate is closely symmetrical around @xmath45 ( see fig . [ 1 ] in rgs ) , at least in the range @xmath46 $ ] corresponding to captures leading to the formation of new halos .
note that a fractional mass relative to the initial object equal to @xmath23 represents a fractional mass relative to the final object equal to @xmath47 .
since each symmetric pair of such captures produces the formation of one new halo with mass @xmath27 , the formation rate of halos of this mass is @xmath48 the probability distribution function ( pdf ) of formation times can then be derived by taking into account that the mass evolution of a halo since its formation is given by the accretion track @xmath34 solution of equation ( [ act ] ) .
thus , the cumulative number density of halos at @xmath49 with masses in the arbitrarily small range @xmath50 to @xmath51 that pre - exist at a time @xmath52 or , equivalently , the spatial number density of halos that evolve by accretion from @xmath24 to @xmath49 ending up with a mass between @xmath50 and @xmath51 is @xmath53\ , { { \rm d}}t'\right\}.\label{pre}\ ] ] consequently , the pdf of formation times for halos with masses between @xmath50 and @xmath51 at @xmath49 is given by @xmath54\,\exp\biggl\{-\int_t^{t_{\rm i } } { r^{\rm f}}[m(t'),t']\,{{\rm d}}t'\biggr\}\ , .
\label{dft}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the median for this distribution defines the typical halo formation time .
the validity of all preceding analytical expressions was checked against numerical simulations in rgs .
the fact that the simulations performed by @xcite used in that comparison have low resolution by today standards should not affect the conclusions drawn in rgs as they refer to the way halos grow and not to their inner structure .
however , it is worth re - examining , now with the help of high - resolution simulations , the correct behavior of the mass accretion rate ( eq . [ [ accr ] ] ) determining the density profile of halos in the present model ( see next section ) . in figure [ 1 ] , we compare the accretion histories predicted from the mps model with those obtained by w02 from the high - resolution simulations of b01 .
the accretion histories of w02 have been converted to the definition of halo mass used in the present work ( see [ acc ] for the values of @xmath7 and @xmath8 adopted ) .
note also that since the latter accretion histories include both major and minor aggregations they must be compared with our theoretical predictions drawn from equation ( [ accr ] ) _ for @xmath23 equal to unity_. as can be see , there is good agreement between theory and simulations . only for halo masses above the critical mass for collapse , @xmath55 , there is an increasing departure .
this seems to reflect the difficulty of the ps formalism to correctly model the mass growth of halos towards large masses ( see , e.g. , monaco 1997 ) , although no such departure is detected in fig .
the rearrangement , through violent relaxation , of a halo at its formation produces a more or less spherical system with a new density profile independent of the past history of the halo . on the other hand ,
accretion consists of frequent multiple captures of very small halos .
thus , the graininess of accreted matter can be neglected in a first approximation . the resulting configuration ( i.e. , a central relaxed spherical object surrounded by a rather smooth distribution of matter falling into it ) approximately satisfies the conditions met in secondary infall .
consequently , halos grow inside - out during accretion , making it possible to determine the growth of their density profile from the accretion rate derived in the preceding section .
consider a halo with current mass @xmath5 having formed at @xmath19 . during the subsequent accretion phase
, the halo follows the @xmath34 track solution of the differential equation ( [ act ] ) . according to the inside - out growth condition
, the mass accreted at any moment @xmath24 is deposited at the instantaneous radius @xmath57 of the system without altering the inner density profile .
consequently , we have @xmath58 with @xmath59 and @xmath60 the mass and radius at formation and @xmath15 the density profile developed since that moment . by differentiating equation ( [ mt ] ) and taking into account the definition of the virial radius @xmath61^{1/3 } \label{rad}\ ] ] and equation ( [ act ] )
, we are led to the expression @xmath62 } { { { \rm d}}\ln { \rho_{\rm u}}\over { { \rm d}}t } \right\}^{-1 } \label{dens}\ ] ] giving the density at @xmath63 . equations ( [ rad ] ) and ( [ dens ] ) therefore define , in the parametric form , the density profile developing by accretion from the initial seed at @xmath19 , at any radius @xmath64 . notice that , owing to the abovementioned dispersion of real @xmath34 tracks around the solution of equation ( [ act ] ) , the previous theoretical profile represents , like the nfw profile , the _ average _ density profile of halos with @xmath5 at @xmath24 , with individual profiles fluctuating around it .
the shape of this theoretical profile depends on the values of @xmath7 and @xmath8 entering the definition of the virial radius ( eq . [ [ rad ] ] ) .
the need to choose appropriate values for these two quantities in order to obtain good predictions from the ps model is not new .
for instance , the conditional as well as the unconditioned mass functions of halos showing a given abundance depend on the radius adopted to define the halo mass . in figure
[ 2 ] , we plot the theoretical density profiles predicted from @xmath65 and @xmath11 in a flat , @xmath66 cdm cosmology assuming that accretion operates from a very small seed . as can be seen , @xmath67 leads to a monotonous decreasing density profile , while @xmath65 leads to a density profile which tends to level off at those radii corresponding to cosmic times when @xmath68 becomes dynamically dominant . since such radial behavior
is not observed in real or simulated halos , we conclude that the best value of @xmath8 to use is @xmath11
. the resulting profile can then be further truncated , of course , at any smaller radius if necessary .
this will be done when comparing our theoretical profile with the nfw profile that uses @xmath65 .
concerning @xmath7 , the theoretical density profile is little sensitive to it , any usual value yielding similar results . accordingly , unless we state otherwise , we will use @xmath10 as in nfw .
the theoretical density profile also depends ( through eq . [ [ accr ] ] ) on the value of @xmath23 , the effective threshold for mergers .
as explained in rgs , the comparison between theory and simulations in terms of halo masses alone puts no constraint on this parameter .
in contrast , the inner structure of halos can be used to fix the value of this parameter . in figure [ 3 ] , we show the effects of varying @xmath23 within the range [ 0.3,0.7 ] around the best value of @xmath69 ( see below ) , which we use hereafter .
once the values of @xmath23 , @xmath8 , and @xmath7 have been fixed , the theoretical density profile of halos with @xmath5 at @xmath24 having evolved by accretion from the initial seed formed at the last major merger can be inferred from equations ( [ rad ] ) and ( [ dens ] ) . in figure
[ 4 ] , we show the profiles obtained assuming _ pure accretion _ , meaning that the last major merger leading to the formation of the halo took place long ago , and we compare them to the corresponding nfw profiles .
we plot only three cosmologies , although similar results are obtained in any of the cosmologies studied by nfw . taken as a whole
, there is a good agreement between the theoretical and empirical profiles down to @xmath70 for halos spanning at least four decades in mass .
however , a systematic tendency is observed for the accordance to worsen beyond @xmath55 , becoming substantial at about 10 times @xmath55 .
this departure is likely caused by the abovementioned deviation for large halo masses between the accretion histories predicted by the mps model and those obtained in high - resolution simulations .
but the most massive halos are scarce and seldom virialized ( typically they have formed recently ) , so the disagreement between our model and the data is not important in practice .
both the theoretical and empirical profiles shown in figure [ 4 ] for different halo masses are completely fixed in shape _ as well as in scale_. this means that our approach yields not only a density profile similar to the nfw one ( at least for moderate and small halo masses ) , but also good values of @xmath71 . in this respect , it is worth noting that the nfw expression is a fit , i.e. , only a good approximation to the real density profile of simulated halos , and that the empirical mass - concentration relation is inferred from a small number of halos of different masses in each cosmology ( the few points in the mass - concentration diagram in fig . [ 5 ] ) .
this affects , of course , the comparison between the theoretical and empirical halo profiles performed in figure [ 4 ] .
hence , to better assess the quality of the predictions of our formalism it is preferable to adjust , through @xmath72 minimization , the theoretical profiles corresponding to different halo masses by the nfw expression , as if they were the profiles of individual simulated halos , and compare the resulting theoretical mass - concentration relation with @xmath0-body data .
as shown in figure [ 5 ] , the theoretical mass - concentration relations above @xmath73 deviate strongly from the empirical data , particularly for power - law spectra . as indicated by the @xmath72 values , this departure is due to the progressive disagreement between the theoretical profile and the nfw expression with increasing halo mass .
in contrast , below @xmath73 , the empirical mass - concentration relationships for the cosmologies studied by nfw are well bracketed for @xmath23 between 0.3 and 0.7 , with the lower and upper bounds tending to yield too large and too small concentrations , respectively .
hence , were the effective frontier between accretion and mergers lowered to exclude intermediate captures , the predicted concentration would be larger than that found in simulated halos , in agreement with the results of @xcite , @xcite and @xcite . in
[ merg ] we will provide , however , justification for the classification of intermediate captures as accretion . since our model can be applied to any redshift , we can also derive the redshift dependence of @xmath71 for halos of a fixed mass and compare it to that found by b01 in @xmath0-body simulations of the @xmath68cdm cosmology .
these authors adopted a halo radius @xmath6 defined according to equation ( [ rad ] ) with @xmath67 as here , but @xmath7 varying from 337 to 178 as @xmath21 shifts from 0 to 5 according to the top - hat collapse model in the @xmath68cdm cosmology .
therefore , in order to carry out this comparison one can derive the theoretical profile using @xmath10 as above , and then truncate or extend it to the same @xmath21-dependent radius as in b01 or , alternatively , one can take advantage of the fact that the theoretical profile is little sensitive to @xmath7 and derive it directly using the same @xmath74 of b01 . in the former case
, the halo mass can only be known a posteriori after the appropriate truncation or extension of the halo density profile , while , in the latter case , it coincides with the mass used by b01 . for this reason ,
we have chosen to follow the latter approach . in figure [ 6 ] we show the predicted @xmath75 relation and compare it to that found by b01 for a halo mass equal to @xmath76 m@xmath77 , the central logarithmic value of the mass range @xmath78
@xmath79 @xmath80 studied by these authors .
this mass is small enough , along the whole range of redshifts involved in the comparison , for the theoretical profile to always be well adjusted by the nfw expression while , at the same time , it is sufficiently large to guarantee that simulated halos have a large number of particles and , hence , that their concentration is well determined .
the agreement between the predicted and empirical @xmath75 relations is good .
we want to stress that this is the first correct prediction of @xmath75 made by a physical model .
previous predictions based on the proportionality @xmath81 proposed by nfw ( corresponding to a universal dimensionless density profile of halos at formation ; ssm ) have been proved , on the contrary , not correct regardless of the exact definition of @xmath19 used ( see fig . [ 6 ] ) , while other analytical expressions which correctly fit the empirical function @xmath75 are but toy models ( b01 ; @xcite ) . what is wrong then with the assumption @xmath81 ?
according to the present model , all halos lying , at different epochs , along a given accretion track @xmath34 have the same density profile , though truncated at their respective virial radii .
the fact that the theoretical density profile of halos at @xmath56 is reasonably well fitted by the nfw expression over the whole radial range implies that all those halos have essentially the same values of the scale parameters @xmath4 and @xmath3 ( though not of @xmath71 , which varies with @xmath21 owing to the time dependence of @xmath6 ) .
in other words , @xmath4 and @xmath3 do not change along accretion tracks .
consequently , they remain constant for halos evolving by accretion ( in agreement with the results of @xmath0-body simulations ; @xcite ) . in particular ,
the value of @xmath4 _ does not depend on the formation time of halos _ , but on their ( last ) accretion track .
the preceding theoretical profile has been derived assuming pure accretion and the inside - out growth of halos during such a process .
this presumes : 1 ) that halos have not undergone any merger for a very long period of time and 2 ) that the capture of clumps with intermediate masses has a negligible contribution in the accretion process . but both conditions are far from realistic in hierarchical cosmologies .
for instance , @xmath0-body simulations @xcite show that the average numbers of aggregations producing , in the standard cdm cosmology , a fractional mass increase in halos of cluster scale above 0.1 , 0.2 , and 0.5 along the age of the universe are , respectively , @xmath82 , @xmath83 , and @xmath84 .
these values reduce to @xmath85 , @xmath86 , or @xmath87 if we only consider the time elapsed since the formation of the halos , defined as in the original extended ps model , i.e. , the time that half the mass of the halo was first collected in some progenitor @xcite , while our definition of halo formation time ( see [ mps ] ) leads to intermediate values . though rare ,
mergers are actually frequent enough to invalidate the assumption of pure accretion .
this is illustrated in figure [ 4 ] .
arrows mark the radii of the seeds formed at the typical last merger of halos inside which the density profile predicted assuming pure accretion should be replaced by that yielded by violent relaxation .
however , as mentioned in [ intro ] , the latter profile is eventually very similar to the one the system would have developed through pure spherical infall .
we want to emphasize that this is not a consequence of our modeling but an empirical fact drawn from high - resolution cosmological simulations . as shown next , such a `` coincidence '' emanates from the fact that violent relaxation takes some finite time to proceed during which accretion keeps going on .
the final density profile then adopts the _ unique _ inner structure compatible with the boundary conditions imposed by the accreting layers .
we begin by showing first that the velocity dispersion profile @xmath12 of halos in the outer accreted region is uniquely determined .
it could be derived , of course , from the jeans equation ( [ heq ] ) provided we knew the value it takes at some given radius .
but this is information that we do not have a priori ( we are avoiding any unjustified assumption at infinity ) .
what we only know is that the velocity dispersion profile of seeds emerging from violent relaxation in real non - isolated systems deviates from the uniform one expected for ideal isolated systems owing to the boundary conditions imposed by the infalling matter .
this suggests the following iterative way to determine the value of @xmath88 at @xmath89 , the frontier between the inner seed and the outer accreted region .
the zero - order solution of @xmath90 at @xmath89 is given by the squared value of the uniform velocity dispersion that violent relaxation tends to establish , given by equation ( [ heq ] ) with null logarithmic derivative of @xmath90 and logarithmic derivative of @xmath91 corresponding to the known outer density profile .
but violent relaxation takes a finite time to proceed ,
during which the instantaneous radius of the halo shifts outwards . consequently , the same condition will hold at the new edge of the system after some arbitrarily small time .
we can therefore derive in the same way the zero - order value of @xmath90 at this new edge of the system .
those two values of @xmath90 can then be used to determine the zero - order logarithmic derivative of @xmath90 at @xmath89 and , by substituting this derivative into the equation ( [ heq ] ) , to infer the first - order value of @xmath90 at that point .
this iterative procedure rapidly converges to the wanted value of @xmath92 .
once we know the value of @xmath93 , we can infer the velocity dispersion profile in the outer accreted region where the density profile is known ( eqs .
[ [ rad ] ] and [ [ dens ] ] ) from the jeans equation ( eq . [ 2 ] ) . but
this velocity dispersion profile must coincide with the one that can be obtained by directly applying the previous iterative procedure at any point of the outer region as both solutions satisfy , by construction , the jeans equation for the same density profile and have identical values at @xmath60 . to sum up , thanks to the uniform velocity dispersion profile that violent relaxation _ tends _ to establish in the inner seed , the velocity dispersion profile emerging in the outer accreted region is fully determined , turning out to be also _ as close to uniform as allowed by the density run there_. in figure [ 7 ] , we compare , for the same halo masses and hierarchical cosmologies as in figure [ 4 ] , the velocity dispersion profile of simulated halos @xcite with the theoretical one inferred following the previous iterative procedure over the whole radial range as would correspond to the case of pure accretion . as can be seen , the agreement between the theoretical and empirical velocity dispersion profiles is as good as in the case of the density profiles .
we can now proceed with our reasoning and focus on the density profile of the inner seed .
since violent relaxation lasts for some time during which matter is continuously falling into the halo , the final mass distribution adapts to the boundary conditions imposed by this matter infall .
thus , it must be in steady state , compatible with the shell crossing of infalling layers , and with a velocity dispersion as close to uniform as possible .
but these are the same conditions satisfied by the halo during the accretion process .
it is therefore well understood why the density profile emerging from a major merger coincides with the profile that would have developed by means of pure accretion .
furthermore , since the concept of orbital decay is meaningless during violent relaxation , there is no difference between intermediate and small captures during that process apart from the distinct mass increase they produce .
therefore , intermediate captures must be included in the formal accretion rate leading to the same density profile as violent relaxation .
it might be argued that the previous reasoning presumes that violent relaxation proceeds to completion , while the relaxation time , equal to , say , three crossing times of the system at the time of the major merger , @xmath94^{-1/2}\,,\label{trel}\ ] ] with @xmath95 the circular velocity of the halo , is long enough for that condition not always to be satisfied .
however , the nfw expression describes the average profile of halos having a relaxed appearance .
that is , those halos observed before violent relaxation has gone to completion are not taken into account .
provided that halos do not undergo intermediate captures after the completion of violent relaxation at their last major merger , their density profile will develop inside - out as explained in
strictly , there is no need , in the present case , for accretion to include intermediate captures , although given that the outermost profile is quite insensitive to the value of @xmath23 used ( see fig . [ 3 ] ) this makes almost no difference in practice . if , on the contrary , halos undergo intermediate captures in such a late phase , as one would naively expect from the larger frequency of intermediate captures as compared to major ones , the density profile will become cuspier and deviate from the nfw profile .
what is therefore crucial to understand the shape of the nfw profile of relaxed halos is to see that such intermediate captures are quite improbable .
this is not in contradistinction with the relatively high average numbers quoted by @xcite .
here we must only consider those intermediate captures restricted to occur after the completion of the violent relaxation of the halo accompanying its last merger _ and
_ early enough for the captured clump to have completed its orbital decay by the time the halo is observed .
this latter bound is necessary , indeed , to guarantee that the halo does not show any substructure and can then be identified as a relaxed system .
the low frequency of intermediate captures subject to these two constraints seems to be supported by the results of @xmath0-body simulations @xcite .
let us therefore calculate the probability @xmath96 that the last intermediate merger of a halo with @xmath5 at @xmath24 occurred after the completion of violent relaxation and the time at which the eventual intermediate merger should take place for the merged clump to reach the halo center by the time the halo is observed .
this probability is given by @xmath97 with the integrand giving the joint probability that the halo was formed from @xmath19 to @xmath98 and underwent the last intermediate merger with a clump of instantaneous fractional mass between @xmath99 and @xmath100 in the infinitesimal interval of time around @xmath24 .
this joint probability is simply equal to the product of the probabilities @xmath101 , given in equation ( [ dft ] ) , and @xmath102 , calculated in the appendix . in equation ( [ paff ] ) , @xmath103 is the time of completion of violent relaxation after the last major merger at @xmath19 , with the relaxation time @xmath104 given by equation ( [ trel ] ) , and @xmath105 is the time at which the intermediate merger should occur for the clump to have reached the halo center at @xmath31 .
the characteristic time of orbital decay of a clump of mass @xmath106 in a circular orbit of radius @xmath2 is ( e.g. , @xcite ) @xmath107}\frac{{v_{\rm c}}(r ) \,r^2 } { g\,m{_{\rm s}}}\label{tod}\,,\ ] ] with @xmath108^{1/2}$ ] the circular velocity at @xmath2 .
hence , by integrating @xmath109 under the approximation of a singular isothermal halo ( for which the integral is analytical ) from 0 to the radius of the initial orbit , @xmath57 , at the time @xmath24 of the merger , we have an estimate of the time spent by the clump to spiral to the halo center owing to dynamical friction @xmath110}\frac{{v_{\rm c}}(t{})\ , r(t{})^2 } { 2\,g\,m{_{\rm s } } } = \nonumber \\ & = & -\frac{0.13{\delta}^{-1}}{\ln(0.3{\delta } ) } \left[g\bar\rho(t{})\right]^{-1/2}\label{df}\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath34 and @xmath111 are , respectively , the total mass and circular velocity of the halo at the time of the merger .
thus , @xmath112 is given by the previous expression for a time @xmath24 solution of the implicit equation @xmath113 .
note that in deriving equation ( [ df ] ) , we have assumed , for simplicity , that @xmath106 remains constant and equal to about 30% of the mass of the merged clump after the initial tidal stripping , i.e. , @xmath114 , with @xmath99 the fractional mass increase of the halo relative to the final object . according to @xcite , the mass of clumps
is reduced to 30% of its initial value after their orbits have already achieved a substantial decay . but these authors assume clumps with a density profile steeper than the nfw one at large radii , which means that their clumps are more difficult to tidally strip than real ones . on the other hand , we expect the real orbits of merged clumps to be typically elliptical rather than circular as we are assuming here , which should diminish their time of orbital decay . however , this effect should be balanced by the fact that , in the elliptical case , clumps fall deeper in the halo at their pericenter and , hence , are more severely truncated by tides since the beginning .
the upper bound for @xmath99 in equation ( [ paff ] ) is not @xmath115 but @xmath116 since the fractional mass increase @xmath99 is relative to the mass @xmath34 of the halo _
after _ the merger .
the lower bound @xmath117 is the value of @xmath99 yielding a characteristic time of orbital decay for the initial orbit ( eq . [ [ tod ] ] with @xmath118)$ ] , equal to @xmath119 $ ] , that is , the solution of the implicit equation @xmath120\}}}= t_0-[{t_{\rm f}}+t{_{\rm rel}}({t_{\rm f}})].\ ] ] values of @xmath99 smaller than this limit correspond to clumps that do not suffer any significant orbital decay . in figure [ 8 ] , we show , for different halo masses and cosmologies , the quantity @xmath121 giving the probability that intermediate captures can affect the halo density profile that would emerge from the last major merger and the subsequent accretion phase , calculated in [ acc ] .
as can be seen , this probability decreases with increasing mass .
it becomes negligible for halos more massive than about @xmath55 in all cosmologies , but even for the smallest halo masses considered by nfw , equal to @xmath122 for cdm spectra or @xmath123 for power - law ones , it is quite small . certainly , the exact values shown in this plot should not be taken too literally given that they depend on the exact definitions of @xmath104 and @xmath124 adopted .
but it is equally true that equation ( [ paff ] ) gives an upper bound for @xmath121 since , in its derivation , it has been implicitly assumed that the mass increase in captures comes from one unique clump , while it might also be produced by two or more less massive clumps not falling then into the category of intermediate captures .
what is more important , more than one intermediate merger is required to affect appreciably the density profile , while the probability that two or more intermediate captures take place in the right time interval is obviously much smaller .
we have presented a simple analytical model for the density profile developed by halos during accretion based on their inside - out growth in that regime .
the resulting density profile is found to be similar to the nfw profile in agreement with previous works .
however , contrarily to these same works , we also find good agreement between theory and simulations concerning the mass - concentration relations of halos at @xmath56 .
more importantly , our physical model correctly predicts the mass - concentration relation at any redshift .
an analytical model such as the one presented here , able to make reasonable predictions on the density profile of halos at any epoch and in any cosmology , should be then very useful in the modeling of galaxy formation and evolution .
caution must be taken , however , in using the present model on halos more massive than @xmath125 , with @xmath126 the typical mass for collapse at @xmath24 .
for masses this large , the theoretical profile shows a substantial departure from the empirical one likely due to a deficient modeling of halo growth by the ps formalism at the large mass end .
the success of our model compared to previous ones appears to rely on the inclusion of intermediate - mass captures in the accretion regime despite the fact that they do not satisfy the inside - out growth condition .
this is justified by the realization that the halo density profile is actually not set during accretion ( except for the narrow outermost radial range , in logarithmic units ) , but at the time of the last major merger , both processes leading to halos with essentially the same shape .
given that there is no difference between the dynamical effects of minor and intermediate captures during the violent relaxation resulting from mergers , it is then understandable why intermediate captures must be included formally in the accretion process .
the fact that major mergers yield essentially the same density profile than pure accretion is an important result of high - resolution numerical simulations that has been pointed out only by a few authors ( w02 ; @xcite ) . we have shown here that this unexpected coincidence is simply due to the unicity of the steady structure compatible with the boundary conditions imposed by the ever falling surrounding material .
thus , we have been able to reconcile the well - known result that pure accretion ( or spherical infall ) yields density profiles of the nfw form with the fact that , in hierarchical cosmologies , halos endure from time to time important mergers ( or short periods of intense accretion ) that bring them far from equilibrium and cause the rearrangement of their preceding structure . besides
, we have demonstrated that there is no time for intermediate captures to alter the density profile la nfw established after the last merger without giving the halo a non - relaxed appearance .
finally , we want to remark that our aim here was not to infer an accurate density profile for dark - matter halos , but to investigate its possible origin . for this reason we have considered the simplified case of pure dark - matter halos while , in the real universe , about @xmath127 of the halo mass is in the dissipative baryonic component .
this might have appreciable effects on the density profile of real systems .
likewise , we have assumed spherical symmetry and neglected halo rotation , as well as the possible anisotropy of the local velocity tensor .
real halos have , on the contrary , some angular momentum and are immersed in large filamentary structures making them accrete matter preferentially along one privileged direction @xcite and feel the tidal field of such anisotropic structures @xcite . moreover , even with perfect spherical symmetry , some velocity anisotropy will prevail in the halo outskirts , as observed , owing to the distinct evolution of the radial and tangential velocity dispersions of infalling layers .
we note , however , that our density profile is independent of the actual degree of anisotropy of the velocity tensor .
we thank guillermo gonzlez - casado for helpful discussions and julio navarro for kindly providing the data of the mass - concentration relations .
we also thank julio navarro , james bullock , and their respective collaborators for making public the codes necessary to reproduce their results .
this work was supported by the spanish dges grant aya2000 - 0951 .
a.m. acknowledges the hospitality of the cida staff in mrida ( venezuela ) where part of this work was carried out .
let us consider the rate of intermediate captures up to some given fractional mass increase @xmath99 of halos with final mass @xmath27 at @xmath24 @xmath128 following the same reasoning leading to the pdf of formation times , but adapted to the previous range of intermediate captures , we have that the cumulative number density of current halos with masses in the arbitrarily small range @xmath5 to @xmath129 that have undergone the last intermediate merger up the fractional mass increase @xmath99 at some time smaller than @xmath24 is @xmath130\ , { { \rm d}}t'\right\},\label{last}\ ] ] where @xmath131 stands for the accretion track calculated using a modified threshold for mergers @xmath132 corresponding to @xmath133 to take into account that , on the final phase , accretion should not include intermediate captures .
hence , the pdf of times that halos with current mass @xmath5 underwent their last intermediate merger yielding a fractional mass increase from @xmath99 to @xmath100 is simply @xmath134 bond , j. r. , cole , s. , efstathiou , g. , & kaiser , n. 1991 , , 379 , 440 bower , r. j. 1991 , , 248 , 332 bullock , j. s. , kolatt , t. s. , sigad , y. , somerville , r. s. , kravtsov , a. v. , klypin , a. a. , primack , j. r. , & dekel , a. 2001 , , 321 , 559 ( b01 ) cohn , j. d. , bagla , j. s. , & white , m. 2001 , , 325 , 1053 cole , s. , & lacey , c. 1997 , , 281 , 716 dekel , a. , devor , j. , & hetzroni , g. 2003 , , ( in press ) dekel , a. , arad , i. , devor , j. , & birnboim y. 2003 , , ( in press ) del popolo , a. , gambera , m. , recami , e. , & spedicato , e. 2000 , , 353 , 427 engineer , s. , kanekar , n. , & padmanabhan , t. 2000 , , 314 , 279 fillmore , j. a. , & goldreich , p. 1984
, , 281 , 1 fukushige , t. , & makino , j. 2001 , , 557 , 533 gott , j. r. 1975 , , 201 , 296 gunn , j. e. 1977 , , 218 , 592 gunn , j. e. , & gott , j. r. 1972 , apj , 176 , 1 henriksen , r. n. , & widrow , l. m. 1999 , , 302 , 321 hoffman , y. , & shaham , j. 1985 , , 297 , 16 huss , a. , jain , b. , & steinmetz , m. 1999a , , 517 , 64 huss , a. , jain , b. , & steinmetz , m. 1999b , , 308 , 1011 jing , y. p. , & suto , y. 2000 , , 529 , l69 king , i. r. 1972 , , 174 , l123 kitayama , t. , & suto , y. 1996 , , 280 , 638 klypin , a. , kravtsov , a. v. , bullock , j. s. , & primack , j. r. 2001 , , 554 , 903 kull , a. 2000 , , 516 , l5 lacey , c. , & cole , s. 1993 , , 262 , 627 lacey , c. , & cole , s. 1994 , , 271 , 676 okas , e. l. 2000 , , 311 , 423 okas , e. l. , & hoffman , y. 2000 , , 542 , l11 lynden - bell , d. 1967 , , 136 , 101 monaco , p. 1997
, , 290 , 489 manrique , a. , salvador - sol , e. 1996 , , 467 , 504 moore , b. , governato , f. , quinn , t. , stadel , j. , & lake , g. 1998 , , 490 , 493 moore , b. , quinn , t. , governato , f. , stadel , j. , & lake , g. 1999 , , 310 , 1147 navarro , j. f. , frenk , c. s. , & white , s. d. m. 1996 , , 462 , 563 navarro , j. f. , frenk , c. s. , & white , s. d. m. 1997 , , 490 , 493 ( nfw ) eke , v. r. , navarro , j. f. , & steinmetz , m. 2001 , apj , 554 , 114 nusser , a. , & sheth , r.k .
1999 , , 303 , 685 nusser , a. 2001 , , 325 , 1397 percival , w. j. , miller , l. , & peacock , j. a. 2000 , , 318 , 273 power , c. , navarro , j. f. , jenkins , a. , frenk , c. s. , white , s. d. m. , springel , v. , stadel , j. , & quinn , t. 2003 , , 338 , 14 press , w. h. , & schechter , p. 1974
, , 187 , 425 raig , a. , gonzlez - casado , g. , & salvador - sol , e. 1998 , , 508 , l129 raig , a. , gonzlez - casado , g. , & salvador - sol , e. 2001 , , 327 , 939 ( rgs ) ryden , b. s. 1988 , , 333 , 78 ryden , b. s. , & gunn , j. e. 1987 , , 318 , 15 salvador - sol , e. , & solanes , j. m. 1993 , , 417 , 427 salvador - sol , e. , solanes , j. m. , & manrique , a. 1998 , , 499 , 542 ( ssm ) saslaw , w. c. 1987 , gravitational physics of galactic and stellar systems ( ed with corrections ; cambridge : cambridge university press ) shapiro , p. r. , iliev , i. t. , & raga , a. c. 1999 , , 307 , 203 somerville , r. s. , & kolatt , t. s. 1999 , , 305 , 1 taylor , j. e. , & navarro , j. f. 2001 , , 563 , 483 tormen , g. , bouchet , f. r. , & white , s. d. m. 1997 , , 286 , 865 tormen , g. 1997 , mnras 290 , 411 subramanian , k. , cen , r. , & ostriker , j.p .
2000 , , 538 , 528 syer , d. , & white , s. d. m. 1998 , , 293 , 337 wechsler , r. h. , bullock , j. s. , primack , j. r. , kravtsov , a. v. , & dekel , a. 2002 , , 568 , 52 ( w02 ) west , m. j. 1994 , , 268 , 79 zaroubi , s. , & hoffman , y. 1993 , , 416 , 410 zhao , d. h. , mo , h. j. , jing , y. p. , & brner , g. 2003 , , 339 , 12 | we calculate by means of the press - schechter formalism the density profile developed by dark - matter halos during accretion , i.e. , the continuous aggregation of small clumps .
we find that the shape of the predicted profile is similar to that shown by halos in high - resolution cosmological simulations .
furthermore , the mass - concentration relation is correctly reproduced at any redshift in all the hierarchical cosmologies analyzed , except for very large halo masses .
the role of major mergers , which can cause the rearrangement of the halo structure through violent relaxation , is also investigated .
we show that , as a result of the boundary conditions imposed by the matter continuously infalling into the halo during the violent relaxation process , the shape of the density profile emerging from major mergers is essentially identical to the shape the halo would have developed through pure accretion .
this result explains why , according to high - resolution cosmological simulations , relaxed halos of a given mass have the same density profile regardless of whether they have had a recent merger or not , and why both spherical infall and hierarchical assembly lead to very similar density profiles . finally , we demonstrate that the density profile of relaxed halos is not affected either by the capture of clumps of intermediate mass . |
the last decades have witnessed the fast - paced development of a wide range of quantum chemical methods@xcite .
examples are highly accurate but also computationally demanding wave - function - based approaches like coupled cluster and configuration interaction@xcite and density functional theory@xcite .
the latter allows for the description of large molecular systems consisting of hundreds of atoms usually at reduced accuracy , however .
today , these computational approaches are firmly established in chemistry , and they are crucial for basically all areas of chemical research . underlying all these methods is the time - independent schrdinger equation , @xmath0 where @xmath1 is the sought - for wave function characterizing the system under investigation , @xmath2 the energy associated with this wave function , and @xmath3 is the hamiltonian operator . in nonrelativistic quantum chemistry ,
the hamiltonian of an assembly of ( point - like ) atomic nuclei and electrons is given by @xmath4 ( in hartree atomic units , in which the elementary charge , the mass of the electron , the reduced planck constant , and @xmath5 take a value of one used throughout this work , unless otherwise stated ) .
the indices @xmath6 , @xmath7 and @xmath8 , @xmath9 run over all nuclei and electrons , respectively .
@xmath10 denotes the mass of nucleus @xmath6 , @xmath11 its charge number , and @xmath12 is the spatial distance between particles @xmath8 and @xmath9 .
the laplacian is defined as @xmath13 the first two terms in eq .
( [ eq : nonrelativistic_hamiltonian ] ) are the kinetic energy operators of the nuclei and electrons , while the last three terms describe the electron nucleus attraction , the electron electron repulsion , and the nucleus nucleus repulsion , respectively .
the rather complicated hamiltonian of eq .
( [ eq : nonrelativistic_hamiltonian ] ) is usually simplified by invoking the well - known born
oppenheimer approximation , in which the nuclear coordinates are treated as ( fixed ) parameters .
we may then define the electronic hamiltonian @xmath14 and the corresponding electronic schrdinger ( eigenvalue ) equation @xmath15 the molecular structure , defined as an assembly of atomic nuclei fixed in space , is a direct consequence of this approximation . for a given assembly of atomic nuclei and electrons ,
the nonrelativistic electronic hamiltonian is unequivocally defined .
the methods mentioned in the beginning aim at an approximate solution of the electronic schrdinger equation . in principle , all observables and molecular properties of interest can then be calculated from the wave function , which contains all information that can be known about the system@xcite .
therefore , quantum chemical methods provide us with a wealth of information about a certain system , but only _ after _ this very system has been specified in terms of the nuclear framework . for the design of new functional molecules or materials one encounters the reverse situation , where a desired property is known and a molecule featuring this very property is searched for . given the `` forward '' direction from structure to property , extensive screening of structures is necessary to find a molecule with a predefined property ( one example for this approach is drug design ) .
it is thus highly desirable to develop computational approaches which would render such time- and cost - intensive trial - and - error procedures obsolete . in order to achieve this goal
, the direction needs to be reversed , i.e. , from property to structure .
such approaches are called `` inverse approaches '' .
inverse problems do not only occur in the field of chemistry , but play an important role in diverse areas such as geophysics ( where the composition of the earth s mantle is infered from gravimetric measurements@xcite ) , medical imaging ( where , for example , attempts are made to clarify the internal structure of tissues by ultrasonic pressure waves@xcite ) and computer vision ( where three - dimensional data from lower - dimensional images is constructed@xcite ) .
accordingly , the theory of inverse problems constitutes a whole branch of mathematics with important contributions made in the first half of the 20th century by russian researchers ( see ref .
@xcite for an extensive bibliography ) .
clearly , since inverse problems represent an important aspect in many fields of research , the study of inverse problems in quantum chemistry may well benefit from developments made in other fields@xcite . as we will see , the greatest challenge an inverse chemical application
faces is the huge size of chemical space , i.e. , the space of molecules accessible by contemporary synthetic protocols .
it has been estimated that this size is between 10 ^ 20^ and 10 ^ 24^ molecules@xcite .
however , an estimation of the total size of chemical space highly depends on the assumptions made ; for example , the number of molecules having up to 30 carbon , nitrogen , oxygen , and sulfur atoms has been estimated to be larger than 10@xmath16@xcite , while the number of proteins that could theoretically exist is roughly 10@xmath17@xcite ( for an average size of 300 amino acid residues per protein )
. this might be the reason for the fact that inverse quantum chemical approaches have only emerged during the past 20 years , although the basic idea has been presented much earlier@xcite .
it is the purpose of this work to review all existing approaches in this field and to analyze their potential for future applications .
we will first review in section [ sec : ist ] the mathematical concepts developed for inverse sturm liouville problems , where important results emerged as early as 1929 and strongly influenced research carried out between 1950 and 1970 on inverse quantum scattering .
then , we review inverse techniques which have either already found widespread application in rational compound design or exhibit a great potential .
we discuss the inverse perturbation analysis in section [ sec : ipa ] and the use of model equations in section [ sec : modeq ] .
next , we move on to more recent approaches , which rely on sophisticated sampling and optimization techniques , such as the optimization of wave functions in section [ sec : optimwf ] , quantitative structure activity relationships in section [ sec : qsar ] , and the optimization of solid state compounds in sections [ sec : ssc ] and [ sec : ibsa ] .
we review two very recent approaches , namely the linear combination of atom - centered potentials in section [ sec : lcacp ] and alchemical potentials in section [ sec : alchpot ] .
finally , we also highlight developments from our research group in sections [ sec : tracking ] and [ gdmc - sec ] followed by general conclusions in section [ sec : conclusion ] .
inverse spectral theory is the branch of mathematics which studies what can be deduced about the structure of ( differential ) operators given that some of their properties are known@xcite . in quantum chemistry , this translates to the question whether it is possible to reconstruct the hamiltonian from a predefined set of eigenvalues .
the soviet armenian physicist viktor ambarzumian@xcite investigated to which extent a differential equation is defined by its eigenvalue spectrum@xcite .
basic inverse questions
although not explicitly stated as such have been studied earlier in a purely mathematical context ( see , for example , ref .
in fact , lord rayleigh briefly discussed an inverse problem already in 1877 in his work about acoustic waves@xcite .
moreover , ambarzumian was well aware of the fact that the ability of reconstructing the hamiltonian from its eigenvalue spectrum would yield great insight into the structure and properties of matter@xcite .
he studied the simple case of an oscillating string , mathematically modeled by a differential equation of second order , @xmath18 with the boundary conditions @xmath19 where @xmath20 describes the oscillation as a function of position @xmath21 .
@xmath22 is a continuous function , and @xmath23 is a constant .
he showed that the series of eigenvalues @xmath24 is only consistent with the differential equation , eq .
( [ eq : ambarzumian ] ) , if @xmath25 .
it is easily seen that eq .
( [ eq : ambarzumian ] ) resembles the schrdinger equation for a particle in a one - dimensional box if we take @xmath23 as proportional to the energy eigenvalue and @xmath22 as a position - dependent potential .
note , however , that the boundary conditions employed by ambarzumian are different from the ones of the particle in a one - dimensional box .
ambarzumian studied so - called natural boundary conditions , where the first derivative of the function must vanish at the box boundaries , whereas for the particle in the box model the function itself must be zero at the boundaries . from the results of ambarzumian
, it follows that we can reconstruct the potential @xmath22and concomitantly the full hamiltonian if we know the ( complete ) set of energy eigenvalues ( see also ref .
for example , we can choose a potential @xmath26 such that the resulting hamiltonian features an eigenvalue spectrum of @xmath27 with @xmath28 , @xmath29 and @xmath30 ( i.e. , @xmath31 is not possible and the lowest eigenvalue is shifted from @xmath31 to @xmath32 ) .
thus , we can selectively shift only the lowest eigenvalue while leaving all others unchanged . in this case , the ( unnormalized ) wave function corresponding to the lowest eigenvalue @xmath33 can be shown@xcite to be given by @xmath34},\ ] ] where the denominator is defined as @xmath35 = f(x)\frac{{\rm d}g(x)}{{\rm d}x } - \frac{{\rm d}f(x)}{{\rm d}x}g(x),\ ] ] the so - called wronskian of @xmath36 and @xmath37 .
the function given in eq .
( [ eq : trubowitz ] ) is depicted in fig .
[ fig : trub]a ) for @xmath38 , and compared to the ( regular ) ground state wave function of an electron in a one - dimensional box , i.e. , for @xmath39 .
to @xmath40 while all others remain unchanged .
b ) potential @xmath22 producing the wave function of eq .
( [ eq : trubowitz ] ) with @xmath38.[fig : trub ] ] the corresponding potential can easily be constructed numerically by inserting eq .
( [ eq : trubowitz ] ) into the schrdinger equation for a particle in a one - dimensional box and solving for @xmath26 .
it is plotted in fig .
[ fig : trub]b ) . several different methods to construct a hamiltonian from a given energy spectrum have been developed .
however , in 1946 , the swedish mathematician gran borg generalized ambarzumian s work@xcite . in his seminal paper ,
borg showed that in the general case , one _ can not _ determine the function @xmath22 from only one eigenvalue spectrum .
instead , one also needs the spectrum of a `` complementary '' eigenvalue problem ( e.g. , the same differential equation with different boundary conditions ) in order to fully determine the corresponding differential operator .
thus , in the general case we can not deduce the form of the hamiltonian by predefining a suitable set of energy eigenvalues , as is done in the above example .
it was pointed out that such an inversion is in general not possible , since different hamiltonians ( representing different molecules ) can actually feature comparable properties@xcite .
even if it would be possible to strictly invert the schrdinger equation in the most general way , it can well be imagined that among the infinitely many different molecules , there will always be molecules that feature almost identical values for a given property .
one can thus intuitively understand that for a given application , several molecules can exhibit the correct property .
therefore , different approaches have to be devised to tackle this difficult problem . in the following
, we will review the most important of these approaches .
in molecular spectroscopy , one is often interested in determining the potential leading to a certain energy spectrum as accurately as possible
. nowadays , there exist many different approaches to accomplish this task@xcite , and there are also specialized computer programs available ( see , e.g. , ref .
@xcite ) . for the sake of brevity
, we shall not extensively dwell here on the details of all these approaches .
however , we would like to highlight one method , which is very general in its scope of use and can also serve as motivation for the development of more advanced inverse approaches , as we shall see . in 1975 ,
kosman and hinze developed a method they called inverse perturbation analysis ( ipa ) which allows one to calculate accurate potential energy curves@xcite .
they started from the one - dimensional schrdinger equation for a diatomic molecule ( note , however , that the method itself is not limited to diatomics ) , @xmath41 where @xmath42 is the reduced mass of the molecule under consideration , @xmath43 the internuclear distance , @xmath44 the nuclear wave function , and @xmath2 the corresponding energy eigenvalue . @xmath45 is the potential energy function , which is usually not known exactly . however , many approximate potentials are known , which are often very close to the unknown exact potential like the well - known rydberg klein rees potential .
one of the central ideas of ipa is now to write the exact potential as a sum of a known approximate potential @xmath46 and a ( small ) correction term @xmath47 , @xmath48 if the approximate potential is a good approximation to the exact curve , the correction term is expected to be small , and can consequently be searched for with an iterative perturbative approach , where @xmath47 is the perturbation .
first , eq .
( [ eq : radialeq ] ) is solved numerically for the wave functions @xmath49 and energy eigenvalues @xmath50 with the approximate potential @xmath46 . since
the true energy eigenvalues @xmath2 can be obtained experimentally by spectroscopic techniques , one can calculate an energy correction @xmath51 which can be approximated by the first - order energy correction @xmath52 if one expands the potential correction into a set of predefined suitable basis functions , @xmath53 , @xmath54 then the energy correction becomes @xmath55 which can be solved by standard methods to obtain the best set of coefficients @xmath56 .
once this set is obtained , one can use the coefficients to improve on the representation of the actual potential energy curve by employing eq .
( [ eq : ipapot ] ) . with this improved potential
, one can iterate the procedure outlined above to obtain an even better potential function .
thus , one can stepwise improve the description of the potential energy until the energy correction term @xmath57 is below a given threshold . in their original paper ,
kosman and hinze successfully applied their method to hgh .
however , they found that their results heavily depend on the particular choice of basis functions @xmath53 . while kosman and hinze employed global polynomials ( i.e. , polynomials defined over the entire definition range of @xmath43 , @xmath58 ) , hamilton and coworkers relied on local gaussian functions and found accurate and rapidly convergent results several years later@xcite .
still , hamilton and coworkers experienced some numerical instabilities ( the results were very sensitive to changes in the parameters of the basis functions ) .
these instabilities are a characteristic of inverse problems : they are typically ill - conditioned . in our case ,
the behavior of the potential energy function @xmath45 in regions where the wave function @xmath44 is zero is not determined , as can be seen by inspection of eq .
( [ eq : ipade ] ) , and , therefore , the solution of this equation is not unique . we may recall that it can be mathematically proven that a single energy eigenvalue spectrum is in general not sufficient to determine the underlying potential uniquely . to remedy this problem of numerical instability
, wu and zhang proposed to solve eq .
( [ eq : ipade ] ) by means of a singular value decomposition and found that their approach is fast , accurate and numerically stable@xcite .
we thus have a working method to produce accurate molecular potential energy functions , given the exact energy spectrum is known and a good approximate potential can be found as a starting point .
this is certainly very interesting for the inverse point of view .
however , we are still confronted with two major problems : first , we are usually not that much interested in a molecule featuring a given energy eigenvalue spectrum , but rather in a molecule with a specific property ( such as a specific dipole moment ) .
these properties can , however , usually not be directly related to a specific energy spectrum .
furthermore , even if we could somehow overcome this problem and come up with a certain molecular potential , it would not automatically be clear how the underlying molecular structure would be composed of atomic nuclei and electrons .
however , this problem could be solved in a quite elegant fashion by employing some sort of atom - based basis functions , such that each basis function would represent one ( abstract ) atom the actual type of the atom would then be determined by the final expansion coefficient @xmath56 . in the above optimization procedure , one would ,
of course , not only have to search for the expansion coefficients , but also for the position at which the basis functions are centered ( which enter as a parameter in these local functions and denote the position of the nuclei in space ) , unless one uses a comparatively large number of such basis functions , such that they can simply be distributed uniformly in space . at a position where no nuclei should be
, we can expect that the respective expansion coefficient is close to zero .
in fact , such approaches have been emerging during the past few years , see sections [ sec : lcacp ] and [ sec : alchpot ] .
even though there appears to be no general solution of the first problem mentioned above , we shall see in the sections to come that we might find other ways of directly relating the molecular potential to properties other than the energy eigenvalue spectrum , thereby making this approach a very promising one .
we close this section with a reference to work by politzer and murray @xcite who elaborated on the central role of the electrostatic potential created by atomic nuclei and electrons as the determinant of molecular properties and reactive behavior .
a completely different and very interesting approach is the development of ( simple ) model equations .
this technique has been successfully employed by marder _
et al . _ in 1991 .
they describe possibilities to increase the first electronic hyperpolarizability of conjugated organic molecules@xcite .
we illustrate the underlying design approach in the following , but note that the design of molecules with optimal optoelectronic properties has been studied by many groups@xcite .
if a molecule is placed in an external electric field , its charge density is polarized .
when the external electric field has only a comparatively small effect on the electronic structure of a given molecule , the polarization @xmath59 can be written as a power series @xmath60 where @xmath61 is the external electric field , and the constants @xmath23 , @xmath62 , and @xmath63 are the polarizability , first hyperpolarizability , and second hyperpolarizability , respectively .
we note in passing that in the general case , the ( hyper-)polarizabilities are not scalar quantities but instead described by tensors .
however , for the following discussion , our approximation does not constitute any loss of generality .
since the electric field constitutes only a minor perturbation of the molecule , perturbation theory is a suitable method to calculate @xmath23 , @xmath62 , and higher order corrections ( in cases where the wave length of irradiation is much larger than the size of the molecule , the perturbation hamiltonian describes the interaction of the molecular dipole moment with the external electric field ) .
the first hyperpolarizability @xmath62 can thus be obtained by correcting the wave function to second order in the electric field@xcite .
the resulting expression is rather complicated , involving sums over all occupied orbitals .
however , it is often observed that the first hyperpolarizability is dominated by contributions from only the first few excited states .
this motivates a simplification by taking only the ground state `` g '' and the first excited state `` e '' into account .
the resulting two - state approximation reads@xcite , @xmath64 with the matrix elements defined as @xmath65 the influence of the three quantities @xmath66 , @xmath67 , and @xmath68 on the first hyperpolarizability can be studied at a simple two - orbital system following ref .
@xcite , for which we may write the wave function as a linear combination of these two orbitals , @xmath69 this linear combination is to be understood as a quantum - mechanical model wave function constructed from orbitals @xmath70 defined on different parts of the complete molecule ( this model is in the spirit of classical molecular orbital theory like hckel theory , i.e. , a proper construction of a wave function as an antisymmetrized hartree product and the consideration of spin are left aside ) .
we now define the energy expectation values @xmath71 and @xmath72 such that the energy difference between the two orbitals @xmath73 and @xmath74 is @xmath75 .
the coupling strength between the two orbitals is then defined as @xmath76 with these definitions , we can write the time - independent schrdinger equation in matrix form as @xmath77 for this system of homogeneous equations to have a nontrivial solution , i.e. , @xmath78 , @xmath79 , the determinant of the 2@xmath802 matrix must be zero , which yields an equation to determine the energy @xmath2 . with the two solutions @xmath81 and the first equality of eq .
( [ eq : hmat ] ) , @xmath82 we can establish the relation @xmath83 for each of the two energy eigenvalues , we get a separate set of coefficients @xmath56 , such that we obtain two wave functions , @xmath84 and @xmath85 expressions for the individual coefficients can be obtained from the normalization condition , i.e. , @xmath86 we can thus calculate expressions for @xmath66 , @xmath67 , and @xmath68 as well as for @xmath62 as a function of @xmath87 .
these functions are given in fig .
[ fig : modeleq ] .
we see that the combination of the individual expressions leads to a maximum of @xmath62 at about @xmath88 when the overlap between @xmath73 and @xmath74 and the coupling strength @xmath89 are set to 0.5 .
the task is now to find a molecule corresponding to these values , which is by far not trivial . of a simple two - orbital system
calculated from its components @xmath66 , @xmath67 , and @xmath68 according to eq .
( [ eq : beta ] ) as a function of @xmath87 , where @xmath75 is the energy difference between the two orbital energies . in this figure ,
the overlap between the two orbitals as well as the coupling strength @xmath89 were set to 0.5.[fig : modeleq ] ] in their publication , marder _ et al .
_ also exploited the mathematical expression for the first hyperpolarizability @xmath62 given in eq .
( [ eq : beta ] ) , but for a somewhat more sophisticated model system consisting of four orbitals ( corresponding to donor , acceptor , and bridge orbitals)@xcite .
_ could relate the above expressions to actual molecular building blocks , in such a way that they were able to come up with specific design strategies to construct the desired molecules@xcite .
unfortunately , the deduction of an actual molecular ( sub-)structure is not straightforward at all , but requires often a considerable amount of chemical knowledge and intuition .
especially this last fact is a notable drawback , limiting the applicability of this method to a rather narrow subspace of chemical compound space .
therefore , this approach suffers from the same fundamental problem as the qspr techniques ( see below ) .
this severe limitation has long been recognized@xcite . in 1996 ,
kuhn and beratan proposed a new strategy in order to overcome this problem , which can be regarded as a first truly inverse approach in rational compound design@xcite .
they suggested to search for an optimal molecular structure by optimizing the corresponding mathematical objects describing it , i.e. , the hamiltonian and its wave function .
the authors also point out that this inverse problem is ill - conditioned as not enough information is present in order to carry out the optimization ( recall section [ sec : ipa ] ) .
this problem can be lifted by introducing additional constraints .
for example , bonding in molecules is local by nature , leading to characteristic patterns in the hamiltonian matrix .
this can be conveniently illustrated by the example of the simple hckel molecular orbital method@xcite , where a linear conjugated hydrocarbon chain corresponds to a tridiagonal hamiltonian matrix due to a nearest - neighbor approximation .
the overlap of basis functions located at distant atoms is in fact usually negligibly small , and thus also in more advanced electronic structure theories the hamiltonian matrix is usually sparse . with the hckel method , for a linear chain of three orbitals centered at @xmath90 , we can write the hamiltonian in matrix form as @xmath91 where the @xmath92 represent the orbital energies and the @xmath93 the coupling between adjacent orbitals . since we are free in our choice of energy origin , we can arbitrarily set one of the @xmath92 to zero .
furthermore , we can also choose any suitable unit for the energy , which allows us to set one of the @xmath93 to @xmath94 . with this , we can write @xmath95 the task is now to find values for the remaining parameters such that a given property is optimized . as an example , kuhn and beratan chose the electric dipole operator , the matrix elements of which can be written as @xmath96 if overlap contributions are neglected ( @xmath97 is the expansion coefficient of the @xmath8-th orbital in wave function @xmath98 as in section [ sec : modeq ] ) and optimized the transition dipole moment @xmath99 . within our simple approach ,
@xmath100 is a function of only three variables , namely @xmath101 , @xmath102 , and @xmath103 .
if we arbitrarily set @xmath104 , we can plot @xmath100 as a function of only @xmath101 and @xmath102 , as shown in fig .
[ fig : optimwf ] .
it is straightforward to optimize @xmath100 with respect to these two parameters . for @xmath105 ,
one finds that @xmath100 is minimized for @xmath106 and @xmath107 , which yields @xmath108@xcite .
the global minimum , however , appears to be at @xmath109 and @xmath107 . with these values
, one finds @xmath110 . on the two parameters @xmath101 and @xmath102 , respectively .
all data are given in arbitrary units.[fig : optimwf ] ] in their pioneering study , kuhn and beratan proposed also to optimize not only the elements in the hamiltonian matrix , but also the coefficients of the wave function ( while the energy eigenvalues were held fixed ) .
they applied their method to a few very simple `` toy '' examples like the one given above in order to demonstrate the general concept .
however , for many years after its publication , the method could not be applied to find an actual molecule exhibiting a desired property , as was hoped by the authors .
the problem was not so much the sheer size of chemical compound space , but rather the fact that it is extremely difficult to construct a molecule from its hamiltonian matrix or wave function@xcite .
however , in 2006 , beratan and coworkers established a general framework which can circumvent this problem ( see section [ sec : lcacp ] ) .
quantitative structure activity relationships ( qsar ) and the closely related quantitative structure property relationships ( qspr ) are central for design attempts in chemistry , biology , and materials research@xcite . the origins of qsar trace back to as early as 1863 , when cros described a relation between the toxicity of primary aliphatic alcohols and their solubility in water@xcite .
however , the actual mechanistic basis of contemporary qsar approaches was laid in 1964 by hansch and fujita with the development of the linear hansch equation@xcite , which was based on the famous work of hammett , who proposed an equation to relate equilibrium constants of a particular reaction involving benzene derivatives to some structural parameter , which depends on the particular type of benzene substituents , and a reaction parameter , which depends on the type of reaction under study@xcite .
the basic assumption of qspr is that every physical , chemical , and biological property depends in a systematic way on the underlying molecular structure .
the functional form of this dependence is then searched for by trying to establish a model relating a given property to one or more descriptive parameters of the structure ( so called descriptors ) . in a typical qspr study , a training set of molecular structures and corresponding properties
is taken as input .
the descriptors are then usually calculated directly from the molecular structure . as descriptors ,
diverse quantities such as the molecular weight , the number of ring systems , the dipole moment , or the solvent - accessible molecular surface can be employed@xcite . even though one could also use descriptors which are obtained experimentally , it is advantageous to employ descriptors which can be obtained directly from the ( three - dimensional ) molecular structure without the need of time - consuming measurements .
once all desired descriptors have been obtained , a statistical analysis of these data is carried out in order to find a mathematical relation between the descriptors and the target property . in some cases , a simple linear function can already be used to relate one descriptor to a target property , while in other cases more complex , nonlinear , multivariate expressions might be necessary . in contemporary qspr studies ,
sophisticated methods such as artificial neural networks and support vector machines are employed in order to establish a functional dependence between properties and descriptors@xcite .
once such a dependence has been established , one can easily predict the desired properties for arbitrary molecules ( although one has to be careful when predicting a property for a molecule which is very different from any molecule of the original training set@xcite ) .
let us illustrate this by a very simple example .
given a set of nine trigonal - bipyramidal molybdenum complexes shown in the top right corner of fig .
[ fig : qsar ] , we would like to find an expression giving the mo
n@xmath111 binding energy as a function of some descriptor(s ) . as the mo
n bond length can be expected to depend on the binding energy , it appears natural to choose this bond length as a descriptor .
[ fig : qsar ] shows the binding energies as a function of the mo
n bond length@xcite . in a first approximation
, this dependence can be described by a linear function . with a least - squares fit
, the binding energy @xmath2 can be obtained from the mo
n bond length @xmath112 as @xmath113 as one can see from fig . [ fig : qsar ]
, this relation is overly simplified . even though the mo
n bond length can be used as a first , rough criterion to estimate the bond strength , it is certainly not the only factor affecting this quantity .
this can be seen from two complexes in fig .
[ fig : qsar ] , which have almost the same bond length ( namely , about 198.5pm ) , but largely differ in their binding energy .
our calculated expression above would predict the same binding energy for both complexes , thus overestimating the value for one complex and underestimating it for the other .
a descriptor which could be better suited to judge the mo
n@xmath111 binding energy would be the stretching frequency of the mo
n bonds . with such an approach , a relationship between the n
n stretching frequency and the degree of activation of dinitrogen for a series of schrock - type nitrogen fixating catalysts was established@xcite .
binding energy @xmath2 on the mo
n bond length @xmath112 of the trigonal - bipyramidal molybdenum complexes with the general structure shown in the top right corner .
calculated data for the molecules are taken from ref .
@xcite and are shown as black squares ( labeled with the individual residues r ) .
a linear least - squares regression is given by the black line.[fig : qsar ] ] of course , the development of a robust qspr for a given quantity is not trivial , and can not be simply automatized .
in particular , it is often not _ a priori _ clear which descriptors should be chosen .
furthermore , a given qspr is usually only valid for a comparatively small subset of chemical compound space , namely for molecules which are very similar to each other in terms of their molecular structures .
therefore , these techniques are only of limited applicability for a truly inverse approach , to which the entire chemical compound space should be accessible . moreover , even though it is easy to identify the descriptor values necessary for a given desired property once a mathematical relation between this property and its descriptors has been found , the construction of a molecule corresponding to a given set of descriptors is not straightforward at all . an approach to tackle this problem
is denoted as inverse qsar@xcite . in this approach ,
one aims at constructing a library of chemical compounds similar to a given lead compound ( which is known to exhibit some favorable property ) . in this context
, chemical similarity is defined as the euclidean distance of two molecules in the space spanned by all descriptors used .
therefore , the more similar the descriptor values are for two compounds , the more chemically similar they are expected to be .
the generation of new molecules is accomplished by connecting different predefined building blocks with each other in order to obtain a chemically reasonable structure .
then , the descriptors of this new structure are computed .
they can be used in an optimization algorithm such as simulated annealing in order to find structures which exhibit a predefined similarity to the lead compound .
one can thus identify further compounds worth to be closely investigated without the need of screening huge molecular libraries .
powerful computer systems and clever optimization algorithms ( e.g. , simulated annealing@xcite , genetic algorithms@xcite , and monte carlo sampling@xcite ) allow us to sample a comparatively huge part of chemical space .
the application of such algorithms is the most important approach in rational compound design .
therefore , we shall also review these approaches , although they are not strictly inverse , since they do not directly aim at predicting a structure featuring a predefined set of properties , but rather follow the more traditional approach where the properties of a predefined molecular structure are calculated . during the early 1990s , schn and
jansen developed a sophisticated technique for synthesis planning@xcite .
they proposed a modular computer program , which searches chemical space by means of a global optimization technique and identifies promising structure candidates , that can subsequently be refined and analyzed .
after some external boundary conditions ( e.g. , initial number of atoms , external pressure , etc . ) have been specified , the algorithm sets up an elementary cell .
the unit cell vectors ( length and orientation ) are chosen randomly , as are the positions and composition of atoms . then , all these parameters are globally optimized employing a fast but not very accurate electronic - structure method . the final result is then subjected to a more accurate refinement .
the global optimization is carried out multiple times , starting with different random simulation cells . the resulting collection of promising compounds
can then be analyzed in terms of their composition and physical properties .
jansen and coworkers have applied their methodology to a range of example systems as , for example , noble gas mixtures@xcite and binary ionic compounds@xcite .
a similar approach has been mentioned in 1994 by werner _
et al . _ who proposed to tailor a band structure reflecting the desired properties and to subsequently search for a solid exhibiting this very band structure@xcite .
they termed this problem of finding a solid with a suitable band structure the `` inverse band structure problem '' .
unfortunately , they could not come up with a working solution to this problem . at this point
, we should illustrate how complex this optimization problem is .
consider a comparatively simple system , such as the pseudo - binary alloy a@xmath114b@xmath115c with a unit cell of 128 lattice sites ( 64 cation sites , occupied by either a or b , and 64 anion sites , all of which are occupied by c ) .
then , the total number of possible configurations is given by the binomial coefficient of 64 and 16 , i.e. , it is on the order of 10@xmath116@xcite .
needless to say that exhaustive enumeration of such a big search space is simply not possible .
however , only five years later , franceschetti and zunger published a computational procedure which successfully addresses the inverse band structure problem@xcite . similarly to the approach by schn and jansen , they start with an elementary cell of a given configuration .
they define an atomic configuration in terms of a vector @xmath117 where @xmath118 is the atom type at lattice site @xmath8 . a given property @xmath119 ( such as the band gap )
is a function of the atomic configuration .
the goal of the optimization is to find a configuration with one or several predefined target properties @xmath120 , i.e. , one attempts to minimize the function @xmath121 where @xmath122 is the weight assigned to the property @xmath123 . in the original approach by franceschetti and zunger ,
this function is minimized by a simulated annealing algorithm .
atomic configurations are generated by monte carlo moves ( e.g. , changing the type of a given atom ) . even though this algorithm is able to find the global minimum significantly faster than it would be possible with exhaustive enumeration
, it still requires sampling of several thousand atomic configurations .
it is therefore very important to have a fast method at hand to evaluate the properties of a given atomic configuration .
franceschetti and zunger relied on a valence - force - field method to optimize the positions of the atoms of a given atomic configuration@xcite , and utilized a semiempirical hamiltonian , where each atom is replaced by a pseudopotential@xcite , in order to evaluate the properties .
furthermore , they applied a special technique for the diagonalization of the hamiltonian , which focuses on the few eigenvalues around the band gap@xcite .
franceschetti and zunger predicted@xcite the configuration of an al@xmath114ga@xmath115as alloy with a maximum band gap .
recently , zunger and coworkers studied a quaternary ( in , ga)(as , sb ) semiconductor@xcite .
the original approach has continuously been further developed and improved .
for example , it is also possible to employ a genetic algorithm instead of simulated annealing@xcite , which generally leads to a faster convergence .
we should note here that the _ general _ method of finding the optimal species with regard to a given property in a subset of chemical space is also employed and further developed by many other groups , although they do not specifically aim at an inverse approach .
for example , nrskov and coworkers have identified the 20 most stable four - component alloys of 32 transition , noble and simple metals in both face - centered cubic and body - centered cubic structures@xcite . for this
, they searched a subspace of no less than 192016 compounds by means of an evolutionary algorithm@xcite .
given the limited space here , we refer the reader to refs .
@xcite for further examples of computational materials design and to refs.@xcite for an example of environment - enhanced reactivity provided by inverse solvent design of a condensed phase reaction .
the approach by franceschetti and zunger is specifically tailored for the design of solid - state materials , and its extension to the design of isolated molecules is not necessarily straightforward . in the above procedure
, the total number of atoms is defined from the outset , as a certain unit cell with a given number of lattice sites is defined .
however , for an isolated molecule , this approach is not valid .
one would therefore have to abandon this constraint and introduce different ones .
for example , by means of simple valence rules , one could define the total number of atoms coordinating to a given atom ( i.e. , the number of nearest neighbors ) .
furthermore , in the design of solid - state materials one can apply periodic boundary conditions , and therefore in principle study a crystal of infinite size .
for an isolated molecule , however , this is not possible , and one therefore encounters the problem of unsaturated valencies .
one of the more daunting problems in the field of rational design is the fact that individual molecules represent discrete points in chemical space , whereas most optimization methods are developed to work with continuous functions . in 2006 ,
beratan , yang and coworkers addressed this problem@xcite .
they started from the well - known fact that within the framework of density functional theory any molecular system is characterized by the external potential @xmath124@xcite , which represents the attraction between electrons and nuclei , and the total number of electrons .
they then treated this external potential as a continuous variable to be optimized .
et al . _
even presented a functional of external potentials together with a corresponding variational principle@xcite .
one major issue with this approach is that not all external potentials correspond to a molecule , even though all molecules map unequivocally to a given @xmath124 .
an external potential which corresponds to a chemical structure is called c - representable .
beratan , yang and coworkers very elegantly solved this problem of c - representability by expanding the potential @xmath124 into a set of atomic potentials@xcite , @xmath125 where @xmath126 is the expansion coefficient of the potential term @xmath127 , which denotes the potential of atom @xmath128 at position @xmath129 .
this approach has been called `` linear combination of atomic potentials '' ( lcap ) , and it constrains the external potential to be necessarily c - representable .
the optimization problem then reduces to finding the best set of expansion coefficients for these atomic potentials .
it is important to note that not only individual atoms can be represented by such atomic potentials but a collection of such potentials can be contracted to represent e.g. , a functional group , @xmath130 and can be optimized as a whole . in order to correspond to an actual molecule
, the coefficients @xmath126 must be either 0 or 1 denoting either the absence or the presence of the atom or functional group , respectively , represented by @xmath127 .
however , since the expansion coefficients are treated as continuous variables during the optimization , one can find non - integer values for them . in this case , rounding to the nearest integer is necessary .
while this approach of continuous optimization is rather new in quantum chemistry , zunger and coworker pointed out that bendse and kikuchi had already presented a similar approach in the context of materials design@xcite . in their original publication@xcite , beratan , yang and coworkers investigated as a proof of concept a rather simple problem , constructed from two sites ( fixed in space ) , for which they searched for the best potential such that the resulting hyperpolarizability is maximized . in doing so , they started from a small library of six different chemical substituents modeled by different potentials , and investigated how the optimal potential is composed of these `` atomic '' potentials .
they finally found that h@xmath111s@xmath111 has the largest hyperpolarizability of all molecules present in the small chemical space considered ( six substituents at two sites give a total of 2 ^ 6^ = 64 possible molecules ) which was in agreement with the results found by exhaustive enumeration . with the same methodology ,
keinan _ et al . _ successfully optimized the first hyperpolarizability of porphyrin - based nonlinear optical materials@xcite .
davezac and zunger recently published results showing that the approach by yang and coworkers is very efficient for optimizing the atomic configurations of alloys@xcite . in recent years
, the group of yang continuously developed and improved the method further . in 2007
, they implemented it into an am1 semiempirical framework@xcite . in 2008 , a gradient - directed monte carlo approach , which is able to `` jump '' between chemical structures , and thus to overcome barriers between local minima , was presented@xcite .
the approach was also implemented within a tight - binding framework@xcite .
furthermore , these authors studied different optimization procedures and found that a combination of their lcap approach with a best - first search algorithm ( bfs , an algorithm searching a graph by stepwise expanding the most promising node@xcite ) improves the performance of the optimization@xcite .
the lcap and related approaches have reached a state of maturity which allows them to be applied to rather complex problems@xcite . however , the position of the potentials is fixed in space ( and only optimized in the course of a standard structure optimization ) , which restricts the space of chemical compounds studied .
this bears the danger of overlooking a good candidate , simply because it is not in the sampled space .
this problem could be remedied by employing an extremely large library and allowing potentials at many different sites . however
, this would also dramatically increase the computational cost of the resulting optimization problem .
nevertheless , as computer systems become more and more powerful , the lcap will certainly be applied to increasingly complex problems . another interesting approach to convert chemical space into a continuous space has been developed by von lilienfeld _
_ starting again from the hohenberg
kohn theorem@xcite , von lilienfeld _
et al . _ noted that any molecular property @xmath131 can be written as a functional of the nuclear charge distribution @xmath132 and as a function of the total electron number @xmath133@xcite , i.e. , @xmath134(n_{\rm el})$ ] .
pictorially speaking , molecules are superpositions of electron and nuclear charge distributions . the electron density , however , is ( up to a constant factor ) fully determined by the total electron number and the external potential , which itself is a functional of the nuclear charge distribution . rational compound design can thus be described as an optimization problem within the space spanned by nuclei and electrons , which leads us to the minimization problem@xcite @xmath135(n_{\rm el } ) - o_0 \right|^2,\ ] ] where @xmath136 is the desired target property .
a continuous optimization in the space of electrons and nuclei implies fractional electronic and nuclear charges . at this point
, we should note that some controversy concerning fractional electrons emerged some years ago and is still not fully resolved ( see , e.g. , ref .
@xcite ) . in practice , in von lilienfeld s
approach fractional atomic and electronic charges are generated by means of a suitably parametrized effective core potential ( ecp)@xcite .
therefore , there are no explicit fractional electrons occurring in the computation , but they are rather implicitly dealt with in the ecp . in order to efficiently search the space spanned by electrons and nuclei , von lilienfeld _
_ worked out a mathematical expression for the derivative of the total electronic energies with respect to the nuclear charge distribution@xcite .
this has subsequently become known as the nuclear chemical potential @xmath137 ( in analogy to the electronic chemical potential ) , which , for a discrete nuclear charge distribution and perturbation theory to the first order , is found to be the electrostatic field @xmath138 , @xmath139 where the integration is over the entire space .
the nuclear chemical potential is a function of space and is related to the proton affinity@xcite . at the position of a nucleus , it measures the tendency of this nucleus to `` mutate '' into a different type@xcite . at these specific points , the nuclear chemical potential
is usually called the alchemical potential@xcite .
von lilienfeld and tuckerman demanded a rigorous description of chemical space@xcite .
they found that such a description is tightly connected to grand - canonical ensemble theory and , hence , could benefit from earlier developments .
it was soon recognized@xcite that molecular properties such as the potential energy represent a state function within the space of @xmath132 and @xmath133 , and hence , any two points in this space can be connected by an order parameter , which is usually denoted as @xmath140 .
this parameter can be used to interpolate between any two molecules ( similar to the thermodynamic integration ) and to study the variation of a given property as one molecule is continuously changed into the other@xcite . in such studies , von lilienfeld found that the path connecting any two molecules is generally not linear@xcite .
this makes the prediction of properties of unknown molecules based on results of known compounds very difficult .
a general method of linearizing these connection paths has yet to be found , and von lilienfeld even offers a prize ( the equivalent of an ounce of gold ) to the person finding a solution to this complicated problem@xcite .
so far , this approach has not been applied to many problems yet . as a proof of principle von lilienfeld _
et al._@xcite designed a nonpeptidic anticancer drug candidate by optimizing the atoms constituting the peptide unit in a peptidic starting structure ( even though this peptidic structure already showed strong antitumoral activity , it would be cleaved _ in vivo _ by proteases , such that it can essentially not be employed as drug ) . in 2007 , marcon _
_ showed that the energy of the highest occupied molecular orbital in benzene and its bn - doped derivatives can be precisely tuned@xcite .
in this section we consider subspace iteration techniques that we have devised to target molecular vibrations , for which one can either provide a simple structural distortion as a first guess ( mode - tracking ) or which pick up intensity in some spectroscopic set - up ( intensity - tracking ) .
both mode- and intensity - tracking are rather different from all of the above - mentioned approaches in the sense that they do not aim for the rational design of a molecular compound or material .
however , they belong to the realm of inverse methods as they turn the usual procedure in quantum chemical calculations upside - down@xcite .
more specifically , mode - tracking@xcite allows for the iterative , but direct optimization of qualitatively predefined ( local or collective ) molecular vibrations without the need of first calculating the entire hessian matrix ( as would be the case in the standard approach ) .
similarly , intensity - tracking enables one to iteratively converge a spectrum based on the most intense vibrations starting from intensity carrying structural distortions@xcite .
thus , these two methods directly target selected molecular vibrations of some predefined characteristic and allow one to obtain these at lower computational cost than with the traditional methodologies .
the standard approach to calculate the @xmath98-th vibrational frequency of a molecule is to solve the harmonic eigenvalue problem @xmath141 where the eigenvector @xmath142 is called the @xmath98-th normal mode and the eigenvalue @xmath143 is proportional to the square of the @xmath98-th vibrational angular frequency .
@xmath144 is the mass - weighted hessian matrix ( in cartesian coordinates ) , the entries of which are given by@xcite @xmath145 where @xmath10 and @xmath146 denote the mass and spatial position of nucleus @xmath6 ( @xmath147 ) , respectively . in the following
, we will abandon these two - component subscripts in favor of only one subscript ranging from 1 to 3@xmath148 written in lower case .
the idea of mode - tracking is to selectively calculate certain normal modes without first computing the entire hessian matrix , which is the most time - consuming step of a standard vibrational analysis@xcite .
it is usually straightforward to create a molecular distortion as an approximation for the desired vibration .
one can therefore start with a guess mode @xmath149 where the sum runs over all cartesian coordinates of the @xmath148 nuclei , @xmath150 is the displacement magnitude of the mode in the @xmath8-th component , and @xmath151 are the mass - weighted nuclear cartesian basis vectors .
taking @xmath152 as a first approximation to the desired normal mode @xmath142 , one can calculate the @xmath98-th element of the left - hand side of eq .
( [ eq : hq ] ) as @xmath153 the last equality means that @xmath154 can be calculated by computing the directional derivative of the nuclear gradient along the collective distortion @xmath152 , which can be conveniently done in a semi - numerical fashion@xcite . in mode - tracking ,
the target mode is iteratively improved by a davidson - type subspace iteration method@xcite . in every iteration @xmath155 ,
a new vector @xmath156 is generated , and concomitantly , also a new vector @xmath157 is obtained .
the @xmath8 vectors generated up to iteration @xmath8 can be assembled into the matrices @xmath158 and @xmath159 , respectively , to produce the matrix @xmath160 i.e. , it is not necessary to calculate the full hessian matrix @xmath144 .
we then solve the small eigenvalue problem @xmath161 where the matrices @xmath162 and @xmath163 contain the the @xmath8-th approximations to the target eigenvalue @xmath143 and target normal mode @xmath142 , respectively .
the best approximations , which we will denote as @xmath164 and @xmath165 , are selected from @xmath162 and @xmath163 , and the residuum vector @xmath166 is calculated . from this residuum vector , a new basis vector @xmath167
is generated , @xmath168 where @xmath169 is a preconditioner .
the convergence characteristics of the mode - tracking algorithm strongly depend not only on the initial guess mode , but also on the particular choice of @xmath169 .
however , experience shows that also very simple choices for the preconditioner ( e.g. , a unit matrix ) facilitate fast convergence@xcite .
the mode - tracking approach has successfully been applied in studies of a large [ ( ph@xmath170pau)@xmath171c]@xmath172 cluster@xcite , molecular wires ( i.e. , long carbon chains)@xcite , adsorbate vibrations@xcite , and tetrameric methyl lactate clusters@xcite .
furthermore , in 2008 , herrmann _ et al .
_ integrated the mode - tracking methodology into a qm / mm framework@xcite .
recently , kovyrshin and neugebauer@xcite presented a similar tracking methodology for the selective calculation of electronic excitations in the framework of time - dependent dft .
intensity - tracking generally works according to the same subspace - iteration principle explained above for mode - tracking .
however , the approach does not aim at refining a given user - defined vibration , but to yield those normal modes which are associated with highest intensities ( for a given vibrational spectroscopy ) .
therefore , the most important difference to mode - tracking consists in the choice of the starting guess mode .
a suitable guess mode is a molecular distortion that attains intensity .
such intensity carrying modes can generally be derived from an eigenvalue problem defined for the particular spectroscopy under consideration .
this guess depends strongly on the kind of vibrational spectroscopy for which the highest - intensity modes are to be obtained .
we have developed intensity - tracking for conventional infrared spectroscopy@xcite , raman and raman optical activity spectroscopy@xcite , as well as resonance raman spectroscopy@xcite .
mode- and intensity - tracking demonstrate that subspace iteration methods are a feasible way to iteratively solve an inverse problem here , to optimize normal modes from pre - defined molecular distortions .
the ultimate criterion for the stability of a given molecule is the gibbs ( or helmholtz ) free energy .
however , in ( chemical ) processes involving energy changes much larger than the thermal energy rt the entropic ( and temperature ) contributions may be neglected as the change in free energy is then dominated by the change in electronic energy .
this situation simplifies the design problem as it is governed by the electronic structure of the reactants in the chemical process under study .
the electronic energy difference is calculated from the electronic energies of the reactants .
the latter are determined as stationary points on the born oppenheimer potential energy surface @xmath173 of eq .
( [ els - gl ] ) , which is the mathematical object that relates all electronic energies calculated for fixed nuclear frameworks of a given number of atomic nuclei ( and electrons ) .
consequently , a characteristic of stable reactants _ and _ of first - order transition structures is a vanishing first derivative of the electronic energy with respect to all nuclear coordinates , i.e. , a vanishing geometry gradient .
therefore , the geometry gradient is the central property for determining the stability of a molecule .
this fact is utilized in _ gradient - driven molecule construction _ ( gdmc ) @xcite , a new concept that we have proposed for the rational design of functional molecules in 2012 @xcite . given some desired structural feature within a molecule or a molecular assembly , the length of the gradient on the atoms in the isolated structural feature , i.e. , the length of the fragment s gradient , @xmath174},\ ] ] with @xmath175 ( @xmath176 ) being a nuclear cartesian coordinate , is in general different from zero and not even small .
the gradient components of this fragment can become vanishingly small upon embedding of the fragment in an appropriate molecular environment .
thus , the vanishing gradient criterion of gdmc can be exploited for the search of molecular scaffolds that fulfill a certain chemical purpose provided that this purpose can be pre - defined in terms of a molecular structure .
for instance , one may ask the question which chelate ligand can stabilize a molecular fragment , such as a transition metal binding a small inert molecule , by designing the scaffold of the chelate ligand in such a way that the geometry gradient at each nucleus in the compound system vanishes .
the structure of the fragment may even be chosen in such a way that some bonds are elongated compared to the isolated reactants , from which the fragment is formed , so that the situation in the fragment represents some degree of activation with respect to the isolated reactants . for example , when a dinitrogen molecule binds to a transition metal center , its triple bond might remain more or less intact upon coordination and thus the n@xmath177n bond length hardly changes .
on the other hand , upon binding of the dinitrogen ligand electron transfer can lead to an activation in such a way that a diazenoid double bond or even a hydrazinoid single bond is formed with the respective characteristic bond lengths @xcite .
hence , prototypical bond lengths and angles can be pre - defined as necessitated by the overall chemical process of which the species to be designed is an intermediate .
hence , a design may be carried out for each node of a reaction network and mutual stability dependencies may also need to be fulfilled resulting in a highly complex optimization problem . however , different optimization approaches are possible within gdmc , and we have explored some of them in our study on dinitrogen binding molybdenum complexes @xcite . in a first approach , the schrock complex , which is known to bind molecular nitrogen ( see fig . [
fig : gdmc ] ) , was taken as an example of an existing nitrogen - binding complex that could be used as a known reference to validate the approach . in one optimization procedure
, a range of model complexes was deduced from this compound in which a central mo
n@xmath111 fragment was taken from the full schrock complex but where the ligand sphere was modeled by the variable substituents r@xmath178 and r@xmath111 .
then , the atoms or functional groups for r@xmath178 and r@xmath111 were searched such that the geometry gradient on all atoms of the complex was minimal , leading to a stable complex featuring the predefined bond lengths mentioned above .
[ fig : gdmc ] ] this procedure is illustrated in fig .
[ fig : gdmc ] . in a first optimization cycle ,
different atoms ( oxygen , nitrogen , carbon , and phosphorus ) were placed at r@xmath178 and all valencies were saturated with hydrogen atoms .
an analysis of the resulting geometry gradient revealed that oxygen is best suited for minimizing the geometry gradient .
one can further reduce the gradient by varying r@xmath111 in further optimization cycles .
we found that with an ethyl group for r@xmath111 , our model complex featured a gradient which was already very close to the reference gradient of the original schrock complex .
so far we have taken only the first steps within the gdmc approach , but we expect that it can be turned into a black - box inverse as well as high - throughput screening tool for the design of molecules with well - defined structural features in one of its fragment structures .
in this work we have aimed at providing an overview on inverse approaches in quantum chemistry for the direct rational design of molecular properties and function .
the rational design of molecules and materials remains a challenging task , despite the many achievements accomplished in this field over the past decades .
the most advanced contemporary methods all rely on sophisticated optimization algorithms and powerful computer hardware .
therefore , future advances in these areas will enable us to tackle increasingly complicated problems . apart from new theoretical and algorithmic developments in inverse quantum chemistry , the possibility to carry out quantum chemical calculations ( almost ) instantaneously ,
i.e. , in real time and thus interactively @xcite will further enhance our capabilities ( with respect to automated procedures as well as with respect to manually steered quantum - chemical design protocols @xcite ) .
clearly , massive screening approaches are now feasible and help us better understand the relation between molecular structure and property .
this knowledge should put us in a position to devise improved or novel inverse methods , which can be set up to serve certain well - defined design goals .
this work has been supported by the swiss national science foundation snf ( project 200020_144458/1 ) . _ inverse problems in medical imaging and nondestructive testing : proceedings of the conference in oberwolfach , federal republic of germany , february 410 , 1996 _ ; engl , h. w. ; louis , a. k. ; rundell , w. , eds . ;
springer : wien , * 1997*. note that one often encounters the english transliterations `` ambartsumian '' and `` hambardzumyan '' for the last name . in this paper , however , we adopt the transliteration as reported in ambarzumian s paper@xcite .
these data are calculated with the program adf , version 2010.02b@xcite , utilizing the bp86 exchange
correlation functional@xcite and the tzp basis set without frozen cores@xcite at all atoms .
scalar - relativistic effects were taken into account by means of the zeroth order regular approximation@xcite . | the rational design of molecules and materials is becoming more and more important . with the advent of powerful computer systems and sophisticated algorithms ,
quantum chemistry plays a decisive role in the design process . while traditional quantum chemical approaches predict the properties of a predefined molecular structure , the goal of inverse quantum chemistry is to find a structure featuring one or more desired properties . herein , we review inverse quantum chemical approaches proposed so far and discuss their advantages as well as their weaknesses . *
inverse quantum chemistry : concepts and strategies for rational compound design * thomas weymuth and markus reiher + eth zrich , laboratorium fr physikalische chemie , + vladimir - prelog - weg 2 , 8093 zrich , switzerland date : = march 9 , 2014 + status : printed in _ int .
j. quantum chem . _ _ 114 _ * 2014 * 823837 + |
spin systems consisting of chain- or ladderlike structures as basic building blocks have recently attracted much attention .
these systems are of interest on the one hand as one - dimensional ( 1d ) model systems allowing to study quantum phase transitions related to the existence of a spin gap and their dependence on the exchange parameters @xcite ; on the other hand they describe an increasing number of real materials when an additional ( small ) exchange coupling in the remaining two dimensions is introduced @xcite .
a material of particular recent experimental interest is @xmath1 @xcite .
we have performed an investigation of the dynamics of such systems with a twofold aim : ( i ) we discuss the spectrum @xmath2 of the low - lying triplet excitations in the ideal 1d system over a wide range of exchange parameters using both series expansions and exact diagonalization , in order to determine the range of applicability of the series expansion approach and to study the validity of using an effective interaction between dimers . we find and discuss in particular a regime in phase space with extremely small dispersion and a minimum of @xmath2 at finite wavevector @xmath3 .
( ii ) we extend the dimer expansion to include 3d couplings and apply this method in particular to a discussion of the dynamics of the quasi zigzag - ladder material kcucl@xmath4 in terms of microscopic exchange parameters . of particular interest as an 1d building block for this type of materials is the @xmath5 zig - zag chain , as shown in fig .
[ fig : leitmod ] and defined by the following hamiltonian : @xmath6 on the theoretical side , this generic 1d model interpolates between a number of seemingly different limiting cases : it is an alternative way to formulate the hamiltonian for the generalized @xmath5 spin ladder generalized to include one diagonal interaction or equivalently the @xmath5 chain with nearest neighbour ( nn ) alternating exchange and next nearest neighbour exchange ( we use the shorthand nnna - chain in the following ) . it thus covers the well - known limiting models of the isotropic @xmath5 heisenberg chain ( haf , @xmath7 ) , the standard antiferromagnetic @xmath5 ladder ( @xmath8 ) , the weakly interacting dimer chain ( @xmath9 ) and the @xmath10 antiferromagnetic ( haldane ) chain ( @xmath11 ) .
it can alternatively be considered as a two legged spin ladder with rung coupling @xmath12 , leg coupling @xmath13 and additional diagonal coupling @xmath14 .
the theoretical interest in the dynamics of the nnna - chain goes back to the work of shastry and sutherland @xcite , who identified the elementary excitations without alternation as free particles ( spinons ) , which may become bound . a variational approach to the excitations of the nnna - chain based on this concept @xcite
has recently been shown to cover qualitatively the transition from free spinons to the haldane triplet . in a first approximation real materials
are often considered as examples of 1d chains with a hamiltonian as given in eq .
( 1 ) ; then they realize different points in the phase diagram spanned by the interaction constants @xmath15 and illustrate the interest to describe systematically the variation of static and dynamic properties with the parameters @xmath15 .
static properties , such as susceptibility and specific heat , however , have turned out to be rather insensitive to the details of the microscopic hamiltonian @xcite and , in the case of @xmath16 @xcite have even not been able to reveal the basic interactions as two- instead of one - dimensional .
thus for a description of real materials a systematic microscopic treatment of the dynamics is of particular importance . in section
ii we present a systematic overview of the dynamics of the 1d system , discussing both general properties as well as comparing results from exact diagonalization to results from series expansions . in section
iii we use the series expansion approach to calculate the low - lying excitations in a 3d material with the structure of @xmath1 in terms of the microscopic hamiltonian .
this will allow us to go beyond the determination of effective dimer exchange parameters in recent work @xcite and to determine the microscopic exchange parameters .
a summary will be given in the concluding section iv .
we start with a short summary of the symmetries of the 1d system ( the chain direction is denoted as @xmath17axis ) : translational symmetry is described by the wavevector @xmath18 defined in a brillouin zone @xmath19 ; the unit cell of length @xmath20 contains two spins , or equivalently one dimer ( one singlet in the limit @xmath21 ) .
we thus use the conventional notation for ladders : @xmath20 is the distance between rungs , whereas the distance between spins in the nnna - chain picture is @xmath22 .
we thus expect two basic excitations per unit cell .
we will use units @xmath23 in the following .
excitation frequencies at wavevectors @xmath18 and @xmath24 are equal owing to reflection symmetry along the chain
. for special points in the phase diagram additional symmetries exist : without alternation ( @xmath25 ) it is natural to use a unit cell of length @xmath26 containing only one spin .
our brillouin zone is half of this brillouin zone of the uniform chain and the excitations of the conventional spin chain will appear folded back to our smaller brillouin zone . for the ladder symmetry ( @xmath27 )
there exists a quantum number parity , @xmath28 , resulting from the interchange of the two legs and we can classify states as positive or negative under this reflection .
each dimer in the singlet ( triplet ) state contributes a factor of @xmath29 to this parity .
an alternative notation introduces the component @xmath30 with values 0 ( corresponding to @xmath31 ) and @xmath32 ( corresponding to @xmath33 ) .
the ground state is a singlet in the whole phase plane and the lowest excited state is generally a triplet .
the ground states for the ladder symmetry ( @xmath34 ) have parity @xmath35 for @xmath36 even .
we have studied the dispersion @xmath2 of the basic triplet excitation for a typical variety of paths in the @xmath37 parameter space by two methods : ( i ) by exact numerical diagonalization , using the lanczos algorithm , we have calculated @xmath2 for the lowest excited states ( between 2 and 4 states ) for 24 spins , i.e. for 7 different values of wavevector @xmath18 .
( ii ) we have performed series expansions around the dimer point , @xmath38 , up to third order analytically and up to 10th order after implementation of the cluster algorithm @xcite on an alpha work station .
thus we have obtained the ground state energy @xmath39 and an effective hamiltonian which can be diagonalized by a fourier transformation .
finally we get the dispersion relation for the lowest excited state expressed as series @xmath40 . in the follwoing we present a number of results for the 1d zig - zag chain which prepare the stage for
the first application of the method to a nontrivial 3d system in section iii and also add some new aspects to the large number of previous studies on the 1d system defined by eq .
( 1 ) in recent years . to give a short review of existing work
we mention first that the dimer series expansion approach started when the work of brooks harris @xcite was revived by uhrig @xcite in the context of @xmath41 .
the expansion for the triplet dispersion was extended to high orders recently by oitmaa et al @xcite for ladders to @xmath42 order , by barnes et al @xcite for the heisenberg alternating chain to @xmath43 order and by singh et al @xcite for the disorder line to @xmath44 order ( using a special symmetry on this line ) .
the model of eq .
( 1 ) was also treated by alternative methods as random phase approximation @xcite , brckner theory for the equivalent dilute bose gas @xcite , exact diagonalization @xcite , and continued fraction expansion based on ed results @xcite and dmrg @xcite . from these studies a rather complete picture of the low - energy dynamics of the 1d zigzag chain has emerged . in this section
we supplement this picture by the following two remarks .
we start from the neighbourhood of the dimer point where an expansion in @xmath15 to low orders is sufficient .
up to third order the following result for the dispersion is obtained ( as given in ref . , frequency and exchange constants are measured in units of the intradimer exchange @xmath12 from now on ) :
@xmath45\!\cos q_x \nonumber \\ & - & \frac 1 4 \left(j_2 - \frac{j_1}{2}\right)^2\left(1+j_2+\frac{j_1 } 2 \right)\!\cos 2q_x \nonumber \\ & + & \frac 1 8 \left(j_2 - \frac{j_1}{2}\right)^3\!\cos 3q_x .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] in first order perturbation theory in @xmath14 and @xmath13 the spectrum is dispersionless on the shastry - sutherland line @xmath46 ( also known as disorder line ) .
( 2 ) also shows the general feature that the location of the minimum of the dispersion curve shifts from @xmath47 to @xmath48 somewhere close to crossing this line . in recent approximate theoretical treatments of interacting dimer systems @xcite
the exchange interactions between individual were reduced to an effective interaction between dimers . for the present 1d zigzag chain the result of this approximation is that only the combination @xmath49 enters into the dispersion . in more detail ,
the result is @xmath50 where @xmath51 is the dispersion in lowest order , i.e. the result of simple propagation of an excited dimer triplet without considering its coupling to higher energy modes .
evidently this is true in lowest order of the expansion ; it is seen , however , already from eq .
( 2 ) that additional terms which depend on the individual exchange interactions enter in higher order . comparing the higher order coefficients in the series expansion
we find that the effective dimer approximation of eq .
( 3 ) amounts to keeping only the leading ( i.e. lowest ) powers in @xmath15 for each coefficient @xmath52 of @xmath53 . for a quantitative check of the effective dimer approximation
we refer first to ref . where the dispersion on the disorder line , i.e. for fixed @xmath54 is shown .
the effective dimer approximation is reasonable for a large part of the line but deteriorates rapidly when the non - alternating limit @xmath55 , i.e. the majumdar - ghosh point is approached . for the more generic value @xmath56
we show the dispersion in fig .
[ fig : fig5mi ] ; it is seen that the effective dimer approximation is of very limited value in this case .
in addition these results , comparing the series expansion results to spectra from exact diagonalization , we find the following limits of validity for the dimer series expansion method : whereas the @xmath57 order spectra coincide with exact diagonalization results within a few percent for @xmath58 and @xmath59 the accuracy deteriorates rapidly when the symmetric ladder ladder configuration ( @xmath60 ) is approached . whereas the dispersion is flat on the disorder line to first order in @xmath15 , but develops maxima and minima in higher orders with an apparent jump of the minimum energy form @xmath61 to @xmath62 close to this line ,
it was noted already before @xcite from exact diagonalization results that a regime with extremely flat dispersion and a minimum at finite wavevector @xmath3 might exist in a narrow regime in @xmath37 parameter space .
we have investigated this point again using the series expansions to @xmath63 order which provide us with a continuous wavevector dependence and have confirmed the earlier speculation : in fig . [ fig:6a ] , [ fig:6 ]
we show two examples for spectra on the lines @xmath64 resp .
@xmath65 : the points in fig .
[ fig:6a ] were discussed before in ref .
@xcite ; fig .
[ fig:6a ] demonstrates that the shallow minimum of the dispersion curve at a wavevector in the middle of the brillouin zone is reproduced in the series expansions . as further example
we show in fig .
[ fig:6 ] the flat dispersion for somewhat smaller values of @xmath14 . in fig .
[ fig : minicomp ] we show the development of the wavevector @xmath66 for the minimum value of @xmath67 on the line @xmath65 in the @xmath37 parameter space ( corresponding to the case of fig .
[ fig:6 ] ) .
the gradual transition of @xmath66 between @xmath68 and @xmath69 , possibly with infinite slope at the end points , is clearly seen .
the comparison between results in @xmath42 and @xmath57 order illustrate the convergence of the expansion . at present , however , the series expansions do not give a hint to a possible fundamental reason for nearly flat dispersion : we have examined the expansion coefficients @xmath52 of @xmath53 up to @xmath57 order , but we do not find any indication of a convergence to zero for @xmath70 .
in real materials consisting of weakly interacting chains such as @xmath71 @xcite and @xmath72 @xcite it is clear from inelastic neutron scattering experiments that there is considerable dispersion for wavevectors perpendicular to the double chain direction . for weakly interacting chains ,
the series expansion approach is to be considered as the only reliable systematic approach which ( by comparing results in subsequent orders ) allows a consistency check .
whereas the series expansions have been extended to cover systems coupled in 2d and interesting results have been obtained for the spin peierls material @xmath72 @xcite , for the 1/5 depleted square material @xmath73 @xcite as well as for general parameters @xcite , we present in the following the first results using the expansion for weakly interacting dimers for a 3d coupled system with particular application to investigate the magnon dispersion in the material @xmath71 .
the zig - zag chain system @xmath71 actually appears to be closer to the dimer point than the systems treated so far and therefore is supposed to be a better candidate for this expansion .
the structure of @xmath71 is shown schematically in fig .
[ fig : fig7 ] in a projection to what is conventionally called the @xmath74plane : the fundamental dimers which are shown as solid lines form zig - zag chains in the @xmath17direction , neighbouring zig - zag chains are shifted with respect to each other in @xmath75direction by half a lattice constant @xmath76 ; this shift as well as the tilting of the internal dimer direction are indicated in fig .
[ fig : fig7 ] by giving the @xmath75coordinate for each line of spins in @xmath17direction ( @xmath77 is an integer which numbers the different planes ) .
the elementary cell consists of two dimers , dimer @xmath78 at the origin @xmath79 and dimer @xmath80 at position @xmath81 and the two spins forming each dimer , 1 and 2 , are at positions @xmath82 for spin 1 and @xmath83 for spin 2 , for definiteness we take @xmath84 . for the exchange interactions between spins we will use the following notation :
the main intradimer exchange is denoted as @xmath12 .
the exchange interaction per bond between spins in dimers separated by a lattice vector @xmath85 is denoted as @xmath86 for the exchange between equivalent spins ( pairs ( 11 ) or ( 22 ) ) of the corresponding dimers and as @xmath87 for the exchange between nonequivalent spins ( pairs ( 12 ) or ( 21 ) ) .
the following exchange interactions will be considered : @xmath88 for pairs ( 11 ) and ( 22 ) , @xmath89 for the pair ( 12 ) and @xmath90 for the pair ( 12 ) , and for the two cases @xmath91 and @xmath92 : @xmath93 for the pair ( 11 ) starting from dimer @xmath78 and for the pair ( 22 ) starting form dimer @xmath80 , @xmath94 for the pair ( 22 ) starting from dimer @xmath78 and for the pair ( 11 ) starting from dimer @xmath80 , @xmath95 for pairs ( 12 ) starting from either dimer @xmath78 or dimer @xmath80 .
alternatively we can look at the structure projecting on the plane spanned by the directions @xmath96 and @xmath97 . in a schematic picture which shows the topology of the exchange interactions only , we obtain fig . [
fig : fig8mi ] ; the 3d structure of @xmath1 results when identical planes are stacked and the fundamental dimers are connected by zig - zag interactions .
evidently the planar structure of fig .
[ fig : fig8mi ] can be reduced to a number of limiting cases including coupled alternating chains ( @xmath98 ) or coupled ladders ( @xmath99 ) .
if the dispersion is considered only to first order @xcite or if higher orders are included in an rpa - like approximation @xcite , @xmath12 and @xmath100 for a given @xmath101 enter only in the combination @xmath102 , where @xmath103 is the number of exchange paths between the interacting dimers ; @xmath104 is denoted as effective dimer interaction .
as already seen in the 1d case of section 2 , a correct treatment beyond first order involves @xmath12 and @xmath100 independently .
according to previous work @xcite the main exchange interactions in addition to the basic intradimer exchange are between dimers separated by @xmath105 . except for @xmath106
these dimer - dimer interactions involve both @xmath12 and @xmath100 and it is our aim in the following to discuss the validity of the effective dimer approximation for @xmath1 and to investigate to what extent the exchange interactions between individual spins can be determined from the present status of experimental results .
a calculation up to second order in the ratios @xmath107 leads to the following expression for the frequency of the basic triplet ( frequency and coupling constants are measured in units of the basic dimer exchange constant @xmath12 and wavevectors @xmath108 are given in units with the crystallographic lattice constants @xmath109 set equal to unity ) : @xmath110 here @xmath111 is the dispersion to first order in the exchange constants , i. e. the effect of simple propagation of an excited dimer triplet . in eq .
[ eq : gl5 ] we have used for simplicity an extended zone scheme : since there are two dimers in the proper crystallographic unit cell , there are two branches of triplet excitations for each wave vector in the crystallographic brillouin zone ( @xmath112 ) . owing to the symmetry of the exchange interactions in the hamiltonian , these two branches join to the unique smooth expression given in eq .
[ eq : gl5 ] , when the doubled zone @xmath113 is used .
each triplet excitation , however , is present at all equivalent wavevectors of the crystallographic reciprocal lattice . for a discussion of dipole transition amplitudes
the noninteracting triplet approximation can be used as sufficient guide and gives the follwing results @xcite : for momentum tranfer perpendicular ( parallel ) to @xmath96 the branch of eq .
[ eq : gl5 ] in the first ( second ) crystallographic brillouin zone gives the only nonvanishing contribution .
( a change form the first to second crystallographic brillouin zone then corresponds to a change in either @xmath114 or @xmath115 by @xmath116 , i.e. to a change of sign in the second and third line of eq .
[ eq : gl5 ] ) .
we note that the wavevector @xmath115 should be distinguished from the quantity @xmath30 which is often used to denote the two values of the quantum number parity discussed in section ii as @xmath117 .
this wavevector is measured in units of @xmath118 , where @xmath119 is the rung length , which differs from the reduced lattice constant @xmath120 . in experiments
so far only the basic triplet with @xmath121 has been observed and the interchange of minima with variation of @xmath115 is an effect of the crystallographic lattice geometry and not of the 1d ladder geometry .
excitations with @xmath122 are excitations with two dimer quanta and have a minimum energy of twice the gap energy @xmath123 . in order to obtain results which are quantitatively reliable
we have performed series expansions for the 3d coupled system to @xmath124 order following the lines described in section ii . because of the complex lattice we did not characterize the clusters which results in a large number of clusters : 5532 clusters in 4th order .
the convergence of these series expansion results is excellent for the small values of the expansion parameters @xmath125 in the application to @xmath1 . in figs .
[ fig9mi ] and [ fig10mi ] we show results for dispersions along typical lines in @xmath126space together with the data points from ref . .
dispersions are plotted only for the branch which has nonvanishing dipole transition amplitude in lowest order leading to @xmath127 or @xmath128 sign in eq .
[ eq : gl5 ] as discussed above .
we assume that the effective dimer exchange takes the values determined in previous work @xcite and have therefore fixed the following combinations of exchange parameters : @xmath129 the interactions @xmath130 are found to be negligibly small . in order to demonstrate the relevance of the individual spin exchange parameters ( as opposed to the effective description ) we discuss the separations @xmath131 and @xmath132 independently : in fig .
[ fig9mi ] we present the variation of the dispersions @xmath133 in selected directions in @xmath134 space for different values of the coupling @xmath135 with the remaining parameters fixed as given above .
it is seen that the distribution of the effective dimer interaction between parallel and diagonal terms essentially shifts the dispersion curve by constant amounts .
a comparison to the corresponding neutron scattering results leads to the conclusion that @xmath136 is the most likely value .
the analogous results for different values of the diagonal ( zig - zag ) coupling @xmath137 are shown in figs .
[ fig10mi ] . here the frequency @xmath138 ( which is the energy gap for @xmath139 and the dip energy for @xmath140 ) depends only on the effective interaction , whereas the frequency @xmath141 ( which is minimum for @xmath142 and a dip energy for @xmath143 ) allows to determine the exchange between individual spins . comparison of our series expansion results to the neutron scattering data then leads to the following values for the exchange constants between individual spins , not yet determined by the values for the effective dimer interactions published so far : @xmath144 these values imply that the ladder system in @xmath1 is much closer to an alternating spin chain than was believed so far and the leg interaction tends to be ferromagnetic if it is nonzero at all .
the results for the interchain interactions in ( @xmath145 ) direction are much less conclusive .
the most likely values are @xmath146 however , the error is large and data actually may be compatible also with smaller values for @xmath147 .
we have investigated the dispersion curve for the low energy triplet excitations of one - dimensional and of weakly coupled zig - zag chains starting from the limit of noninteracting dimers and performing an expansion in the interdimer interactions .
the series up to @xmath57 order in the 1d case and up to @xmath124 order in the 3d case were evaluated explicitly after implementation on a work station . in the 1d case
the dispersion curves agree with those obtained from exact diagonalization using the lanczos algorithm for a large regime around the dimer point ; in this regime the method provides a reliable approach to calculate the dispersion in its continuous dependence on the wavevector . in a narrow regime close to the shastry - sutherland line
we find the minimum of the dispersion curve at an intermediate wavevector @xmath148 . as an application of the 3d case we present the application of the method to the @xmath149structure .
fitting to the dispersion as measured in inelastic neutron scattering experiments @xcite we determine the exchange interchange interactions between individual spins in addition to the effective interaction between dimers determined before .
it is shown that the effective dimer approximation , when treated in the random phase approximation , sums up the leading powers of the dimer expansion .
we gratefully acknowledge useful discussions with a. kolezhuk and with u. neugebauer , who participated in the early stage of this work .
we are grateful to n. cavadini for correspondance and for communicating the data points of ref . in detail .
the work was supported by the german ministry for research and technology ( bmbf ) under contract no . 03mi5han5 .
e. dagotto and m. rice , science * 271 * , 618 ( 1996 ) s. brehmer , h .- j .
mikeska and u. neugebauer , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 9 * , 7161 ( 1996 ) e. dagotto , preprint cond - mat/9908250 t. kato , k. takatsu , h. tanaka , w. shiramura , m. mori , k. nakajima and k. kakurai , j. phys .
japan * 67 * , 752 ( 1998 ) n. cavadini , w. henggeler , a. furrer , h .- u .
gdel , k. krmer and h. mutka , eur .
j. b*7 * , 519 ( 1999 ) ; + physica b * 276 - 278 * , 540 ( 2000 ) b. s : shastry and b. sutherland , phys . rev .
letters * 47 * , 964 ( 1981 ) s. brehmer , a.k .
kolezhuk , h .- j .
mikeska and u. neugebauer , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 10 * , 1103 ( 1998 ) t. nakamura and k. okamoto , phys .
rev . b*58 * , 2411 ( 1998 ) a.w .
garrett , s.e .
nagler , d.a .
tennant , b.c .
sales and t. barnes , phys .
. lett . * 79 * , 745 ( 1997 ) a. weisse , g. bouzerar and h. fehske , eur .
j. b*7 * , 5 ( 1999 ) g.s .
uhrig , b. normand , phys .
rev . b*58 * , r14705 ( 1998 ) m.p .
gelfand , r.r.p . singh and d.a .
huse , j. stat .
phys * 59 * , 1093 ( 1990 ) m.p .
gelfand , sol .
stat . com .
* 98 * , 11 ( 1996 ) a. brooks harris , phys .
rev . b*7 * , 3166 ( 1973 ) g.s .
uhrig , phys .
lett . * 79 * , 163 ( 1997 ) j. oitmaa , r.r.p .
singh and zheng weihong phys .
rev . b*54 * , 1009 ( 1996 ) t. barnes , j. riera and d.a .
tennant , phys .
rev . b*59 * , 11384 ( 1999 ) r.r.p .
singh and zheng weihong phys .
rev . b*59 * , 9911 ( 1999 ) g.s .
uhrig and h.j .
schulz , phys .
rev . b*54 * , r9624 ( 1996 ) v.n .
kotov , o.p .
sushkov and r. eder , phys .
rev . b*59 * , 6266 ( 1999 ) p.v .
shevchenko , v.n .
kotov and o.p .
sushkov , phys .
b*60 * , 3305 ( 1999 ) g. bouzerar , a.p .
kampf and g.i .
japaridze , phys .
b*58 * , 3117 ( 1998 ) s. mori , i. harada and t. tonegawa , j. phys .
japan * 67 * , 1409 ( 1998 ) s. pati , r. chitra , d. sen , s. ramasesha and h.r .
krishnamurthy , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 9 * , 219 ( 1997 ) s. gopalan , t.m .
rice and m. sigrist , phys .
b * 49 * , 8901 ( 1994 ) j.p .
boucher and l.p.regnault , j. phys .
i ( france ) * 6 * , 1939 ( 1996 ) zheng weihong , j. oitmaa and c.j .
hamer , phys .
rev . b*58 * , 14147 ( 1998 ) a. koga and n. kawakami , preprint cond - mat 9908458 | we investigate the elementary excitations of quasi one - dimensional @xmath0 systems built up from zig - zag chains with general isotropic exchange constants , using exact ( lanczos ) diagonalization for 24 spins and series expansions starting from the decoupled dimer limit .
for the ideal one - dimensional zig - zag chain we discuss the systematic variation of the basic ( magnon ) triplet excitation with general exchange parameters and in particular the presence of practically flat dispersions in certain regions of phase space .
we extend the dimer expansion in order to include the effects of 3d interactions on the spectra of weakly interacting zig - zag chains . in an application to @xmath1
we show that this approach allows to determine the exchange interactions between individual pairs of spins from the spectra as determined in recent neutron scattering experiments . 1000 0.5 cm |
human behavior , as an academic issue in science , has a history about one century from watson @xcite . as a joint interest of sociology , psychology and economics ,
human behavior has been extensively investigated during the last decades .
a basic assumption embedded in the previous analysis on human dynamics is that its temporal statistics are uniform and stationary , which can be properly described by a poisson process .
accordingly , the interevent time distribution should have an exponential tail @xcite .
however , through studying the distributions of interevent time of the human behavior such as the people to send out or reply e - mail and surface mail , albert barabsi discovered that these human behaviors present obvious deviation to the poisson process : long time silent and short time high frequency eruption simultaneously present in these human behaviors , and their distributions of interevent time have power law fat tail @xcite . from e - mail communications @xcite to surface mail communications @xcite and short message communications @xcite , from financial activities to library loans @xcite , from web browsing @xcite to on - line
movie watchings @xcite , and more and more examples show that the distributions of interevent time of the human behavior can not be described by a poisson process but may use power function to fit well . according to the previous studies about human dynamics
, we find that its methodology , excavating statistical laws from the historical records of human activities , can apply to analyze other issues .
for instance , we can also use some of those datasets to quantify the herd behavior of an individual , that is to say , following the opinions of the majority of people in his / her social surrounding in an irrational way . with the development of information technology ,
web surfing has become a part of people s daily life , including e - mail communication , dealing with financial matters , reading news online , browsing web , downloading software and so on . in the cyber world
, @xmath0 forum provides people a platform for mutual communication .
those behaviors like `` lurking , spamming , sofast '' , etc .
are the ways in which netizens publicly express their ideas .
the means of expression is so unique for its dual role of `` openness '' and `` concealment '' .
therefore the @xmath0 forum is loved by the majority of internet users . on the @xmath0 forum ,
the new threads and internet users are increasing , and the internet users can browse information and express their own points . in the process of browsing information and expressing their own points , the most common group is formed on the @xmath0 forum , that is to say , browsing the posts of the same subject will form a provisional group , different themes has different groups .
however , in the provisional group , some people simply browse information , and others will publish their own opinions
. then there are the amounts of view and reply on the @xmath0 forum .
so what is the difference between the different groups , and how are these differences reflected are the interesting issues to be researched . in our paper
, we focus on the actions of internet users through the @xmath0 forum to solve these problems .
the dates come from the @xmath3 forum and @xmath4 forum , the first one is the largest chinese community and the other one is the current leader in free online chat rooms .
our paper is organized as follows . in sec.[sect2 ] , we present that the amounts of view and reply of posts which follow the power law distributions and have different power exponents . in sec.[sect3 ] , we address the nonlinearity relationship of the amounts of view and reply of posts and we also calculate the fitted line to characterize the forum . according to the fitted line
, we find that the differences between the different forums . in sec.[sect4 ]
, we analyze the burstiness and memory in replying time series .
under computer program s help , we can carry on the statistics to the amounts of view and reply about posts of different themes . here
we collect the dates from @xmath3 community forum and @xmath4 forum .
@xmath3 community forum is the world s largest chinese community and the internet s most comprehensive well - known @xmath0 , has a huge core group of users , the theme of the plate covers culture , life , society , current affairs , sports , entertainment and other areas @xcite .
we got the amounts of view and reply about posts of the entertainment , sports , life , economics themes from @xmath3 community forum . economic commentary : from april 17 , 2001 to november 11 , 2008 , there were 32,480 posts .
pet club : from december 1 , 2005 to november 17 , 2008 , there were 39,950 posts .
china football : from june 14 , 2001 to july 13 , 2008 , there were 95,891 posts .
pastime puzzles : from november 19 , 2004 to july 8 , 2008 , there were 49,346 posts .
and their maximum likelihood power - law fits , for the posts of the amounts of view and reply from @xmath3 community forum.the red lines stand for the reply of cumulative distribution and the blue lines stand for the view of cumulative distribution . , scaledwidth=95.0%,height=377 ] @xmath4 is the current leader in free online chat rooms .
most of users are from the usa , canada , australia and the united kingdom . and
it offers a very active message forum with over 120,000 members , an arcade , and photo gallery @xcite .
we got the amounts of view and reply about posts of world events - politics and news , jokes , general , and graphics forum .
world events - politics and news : from june 10 , 2006 to february 23 , 2009 , there were 1,558 posts .
jokes : from june 10 , 2006 to february 25 , 2009 , there were 1,583 posts .
general : from june 10 , 2006 to march 3 , 2009 , there were 1,250 posts graphics forum : from june 10 , 2006 to march 13 , 2009 , there were 1,131 posts .
according to the number of posts from @xmath3 forum and @xmath4 forum , we can see that the chinese internet forums are more active than foreign ones .
and their maximum likelihood power - law fits , for the posts of the amounts of view and reply from @xmath4 forum .
the red lines stand for the reply of cumulative distribution and the blue lines stand for the view of cumulative distribution .
, scaledwidth=95.0%,height=377 ] a power law distribution is observed when we inspect the total number of views and replies a post receives ( see fig.[power ] and fig.[fp ] ) , indicating that the vast majority of posts generates little interest , while a few posts are highly popular . at the same time , the distribution of the amounts of view and reply has the different power exponents .
mostly the power exponents of reply are larger than that of view , although the amounts of reply are smaller than that of view ( see table [ valuepower ] ) .
the power exponents @xmath5 range from @xmath6 to @xmath7 .
the values of power exponent and @xmath8 are based on the method of ref.@xcite . from table
[ valuepower ] , we also can discover that the exponents of view from @xmath4 forum are bigger than those of view from @xmath3 community forum .
but the exponent of reply is no much difference .
this shows that the viewers of posts from @xmath3 community forum have greater range , this may be related to the forum rules more attended posts will be topped and forum also can recommend some wonderful posts to internet users .
[ t]|c|c|c|c|c|c| forum & theme & & + & & @xmath5 & @xmath8&@xmath5 & @xmath8 + & economic commentary&2.05 & 256&2.91 & 57 + @xmath3&pet club & 1.94 & 207&2.66 & 13 + & china football&1.87 & 119&3.06 & 60 + & pastime puzzles&1.62 & 92&2.51 & 46 + & world news & 2.57&382&2.81&26 + @xmath4&jokes & 3.5&213&3.31&7 + & general & 2.52&570&2.5&31 + & graphics & 1.98&175&3.22&49 + besides , we also study other themes from @xmath3 forum , all of them have the similar broad distribution . in the table [ others ] , we list the values of power exponent and @xmath8 of other themes from @xmath3 forum . and they have the similar characteristic , namely the values of power exponent range from @xmath6 to @xmath7 , and the power exponents of view are smaller than those of reply . [ t]|c|c|c|c|c|c| forum & theme & & + & & @xmath5 & @xmath8&@xmath5 & @xmath8 + & arrange finance&2.07 & 232&2.12 & 9 + & education viewpoint & 1.61 & 1121&1.92 & 3 + & postgraduate communication&2.04 & 2372&2.13 & 5 + & diet forum&1.92 & 493&3.28 & 17 + @xmath3 & 08european cup & 2.05&162&2.55&35 + & film television world & 1.81&1144&2.74&94 + & people gossip & 2.12&896&2.38&38 + & the ebb and flow of overseas & 1.93&394&2.69&47 + & words on world&2.09&13689&2.18&8 + some questions should be put forward , for example , why the distribution of the amounts of view and reply follow the power but have the different power exponents , and what relationship exists between the views and replies .
we will solve these questions in the next section .
the relationship between the amounts of view and those of reply can be observed through the fig.[scatterplot ] , and it shows non - linearity which could be described by eq.([eq1 ] ) .
@xmath9 where @xmath10 stands for the amounts of reply , @xmath11 stands for the amounts of view . from analysis of sect.[sect2 ] , we know that the amounts of view and those of reply can be described by power law distribution .
therefore , here we suppose that probability density function of views is @xmath12 the probability density function of replies is @xmath13 from eq.([eq1 ] ) and eq.([eq3 ] ) , we can get that @xmath14 contrasting to eq.([eq3 ] ) , we can find that @xmath15 @xmath16 from eq.([eq5 ] ) and eq.([eq6 ] ) we can evaluate that @xmath17 @xmath18 here @xmath19 and @xmath20 are known quantities , so we must evaluate unknown quantities @xmath21 and @xmath22 .
we know the probability density function is @xmath23 according to the characteristic of the probability density function @xmath24 we can evaluate the value of @xmath25 .
@xmath26 where @xmath27 stands for the number of @xmath28 , @xmath29 can be used from table [ valuepower ] , @xmath30 is the largest number which can easily get from the series of views or replies .
@xmath31 stands for the all number of @xmath32 .
therefore , we can easily evaluate the value of @xmath21 and @xmath22 @xmath33 @xmath34 so we can get the value of @xmath35 @xmath36 according to eq.([eq1 ] ) , we can know that the fitted line is determined by the parameters @xmath35 and @xmath1 .
for the same amounts of view , when the value of @xmath1 is larger , there would be more people to reply the post .
the value of @xmath37 gives the probability of the first viewer to reply the post .
the value of @xmath38 gives the number of people who had viewed the post before there is the first reply to the post . in terms of the above analysis , from table [ value ] , we can know that when there is the same amounts of view , the groups in the @xmath39 forum reply more than the groups in the @xmath3 forum .
most people in the @xmath3 forum prefer viewing to replying the posts .
the differences between @xmath4 forum and @xmath3 forum come from the different culture and social environment possibly .
[ t]|c|c|c|c|c| forum&theme&@xmath35&@xmath1&@xmath40 + & economic commentary & -2.74 & 0.550 & 4.98 + @xmath3&pet club & -3.35 & 0.566&5.92 + & china football&-3.44 & 0.422&8.15 + & pastime puzzles&-3.70 & 0.411&8.39 + & world news & -5.17&0.967&5.35 + @xmath4 & jokes & -7.83&1.08&7.25 + & general & -3.53&1.01&3.50 + & graphics & -0.456&0.441&1.03 +
the dynamics of a wide range of real systems display a bursty , characterized by short timeframes of intense activity followed by long times of no or reduced activity . in ref.@xcite k .- i .
goh and a .-
barabsi propose to characterize the bursty nature of real signals using orthogonal measures quantifying two distinct mechanisms leading to burstiness : the interevent time distribution ( see eq.[eq12 ] ) and the memory(see eq.[eq13 ] ) .
@xmath41 where @xmath42 and @xmath43 are the mean and the standard deviation of @xmath44 , respectively .
@xmath45 where @xmath46 is the number of interevent times measured from the signal and @xmath47 and @xmath48 are sample mean and sample standard deviation of @xmath49 s ( @xmath50 s ) , respectively(@xmath51=@xmath52 ) .
the time of posting and replying can be as a time signal , then we can easily calculate the interevent time distribution and the memeory ( see table [ tab3 ] ) .
[ t]|c|c|c|c| forum & theme&@xmath1&@xmath2 + & people gossip & 0.8243 & 0.0378 + @xmath3 & the ebb and flow of overseas & 0.7856&0.0457 + & words on world&0.7296&0.01108 + & world news&0.8897 & 0.0057 + @xmath53 & jokes & 0.8337&0.0057 + & graphics & 0.8258&0.0348 + in table [ tab3 ] , the themes of people gossip , the ebb and flow of overseas and words on world belong to @xmath3 community forum , and the themes of world news , jokes and graphics come from @xmath4 forum . from the table
[ tab3 ] , we can discover that all the themes of the values @xmath1 and @xmath2 have no much differences which will further explain that the replying behaviors of @xmath3 community forum and @xmath4 forum are similarity .
all of them can illustrate that the replying time series are bursty signal , in other words , the front people who reply the post can not affect the behind ones , they would reply a post depending on their interests .
in this paper we discovered that the amounts of view and reply on @xmath0 forum appear the power law distributions , the power exponents range from @xmath6 to @xmath7 .
moreover , mostly the power exponents of reply are bigger than that of view .
furthermore , we found that the amounts of view and those of reply has the nonlinear relationship . according to the relationship
, we presented two parameters the slope and intercept of the log - log straight line which can evaluate human s interests on replying or viewing . with the above measurements and statistics , we find some differences between @xmath3 community forum and @xmath4 forum , which may be caused by cultural , social environments , and forum rules . at last , we analyze the burstiness and memory in replying time series .
it could be found that all the time series have similar qualitative properties .
the @xmath3 community forum and @xmath4 forum have no much differences in replying time series .
this paper is supported by nsfc under the grant nos . 70771011,70471080 .
99 j. b. watson , psychology as the behaviorist views it , psychological review * 20 * , 158 - 177(1913 ) f. a. haight , handbook of the poisson distribution , wiley , new york , ( 1967 ) a. -l .
barabsi , the origin of burst and heavy tails in human dynamics , nature * 435 * , 207 - 211(2005 ) a. -l .
barabsi , k. -i .
goh , a. vzquez , reply to comment on ` the origin of bursts and heavy tails in human dynamics ' , arxiv : physics/0511186 j. g. oliveira , a. -l .
barabsi , darwin and einstein correspondence patterns , nature * 435 * , 1251(2005 ) a. vzquez , j. g. oliveira , z. dezs@xmath54 , k. -i .
goh , i. kondor , a. -l .
barabsi , modeling burst and heavy tails in human dynamics , phys .
e * 73 * , 036127(2006 ) n. n. li , z. j. deng , n. zhang , j. m. li , y. qin , t. zhou , empirical analysis on temporal statistics of human correspondence patterns , physica a * 387 * , 6391(2008 ) w. hong , x. p.
han , t. zhou , b. -h .
wang , heavy - tailed statistics in short - message communication , chin .
lett * 26 * , 028902(2008 ) z. dezs , e. almaas , a. lukcs , b. rcz , i. szakadt , a. -l .
barabsi , dynamics of information access on the web , phys .
e * 73 * , 066132(2006 ) t. zhou , h. a. -t .
kiet , b. j. kim , b. -h .
wang , p. holme , role of activity in human dynamics , epl * 82 * , 28002(2008 ) http://people.sina.com.cn/ http://www.chat-avenue.com/about.html aaron clauset , cosma rohilla shalizi , m. e. j. newman , power - law distributions in empirical data , arxiv : 0706.1062vl k. -i .
goh and a. -l .
barabsi , burstiness and memory in complex systems , epl * 81 * , 48002(2008 ) | quantitative understanding of human behaviors provides elementary comprehension of the complexity of many human - initiated systems . in this paper
, we investigate the behavior of people on the @xmath0 forum by the statistical analysis of the amounts of view and reply of posts . according to our statistics , we find that the amounts of view and reply of posts follow the power law distributions with different power exponent .
furthermore , we discover that the amounts of view and reply of posts have nonlinear relationship .
they are related by power function and show us straight line in log - log plot .
based on the estimation of slope and intercept of the line , we can characterize the behaviors quantitatively and know that people of chinese forum and those of foreign forum have different preference towards replying to and viewing the posts . at last ,
we analyze the burstiness and memory in replying time series .
they show some universal properties among different forum .
all of them locate themselves in the high-@xmath1 , low-@xmath2 region .
* keyword * : human dynamics , @xmath0 forum , burstiness and memory * pacs * : 89.75.da - systems obeying scaling laws ; 89.20.hh - world wide web , internet ; 89.65.-s - social and economic systems |
supermassive black holes ( smbhs ) have been considered as the most likely power sources of the activity in quasars and active galactic nuclei ( lynden - bell 1969 ; rees 1984 ) .
smbhs at the centers of all galaxies are now recognized as ubiquitous , whose mass @xmath0 is proportional to the spheroidal bulge mass of the host galaxy or the galactic bulge luminosity ( kormendy & richstone 1995 ; magorrian et al .
1998 ; richstone et al . 1998 ) and is strongly correlated with the velocity dispersion of the host galaxy ( ferrarese & merritt 2000 ; gebhardt et al . 2000a ; ferrarese 2002 ) .
recently , evidence for the existence of a smbh in the center of our galaxy has been added ( eckart & genzel 1997 ; genzel et al .
1997 ; ghez et al .
1998 ) . though searches for smbhs are primarily based on spatially resolved kinematics , another possible way to infer the presence of smbhs and to shed light on the physical condition is to examine spectral energy distribution over a wide range from the radio to the hard x - ray frequencies .
this emission spectrum is produced by an accreting matter , as the surrounding gas accretes onto the central smbh ( e.g. , frank et al .
1992 ; ho 1999 ) .
several attempts have been made in utilizing this fact to estimate smbh masses ( yi & boughn 1998 , 1999 ; franceschini et al . 1998 ; lacy et al .
2001 ; ho 2002 ; alonso - herrero et al . 2002 ; cao & jiang 2002 ) .
it has been also suggested that advection - dominated accretion flows ( adafs ) are responsible for the observed radio and x - ray luminosities of some of the x - ray bright galactic nuclei ( fabian & rees 1995 ; di matteo & fabian 1997 ; yi & boughn 1998 , 1999 ) .
moreover , yi & boughn ( 1999 ) discussed that the observed radio / x - ray luminosity relation in terms of the standard adaf model and demonstrated that it could be used as a relatively effective and consequently suitable tool to estimate unknown black hole masses . in this study
we further explore this possibility both by increasing the number of data available and by deriving similar relations for the models with additional features , such as , truncations , winds , and investigate sensitivities of the method yi & boughn suggested on modifications of the standard adaf model .
this paper begins with model descriptions for the standard adaf model and modified versions of the model in @xmath1 2 .
we derive analytical expressions to describe the radio / x - ray luminosities for various models .
we present the calculated ratios of the luminosities and compare them with the observational data in @xmath1 3 .
we discuss and conclude in @xmath1 4 .
when a mass accretion rate is below a critical rate , the radiative cooling becomes slower than the viscous heating . as a result of this ,
the dissipated accretion energy is inefficiently radiated away and advected inward to the central object with the accreted matter , which is a key idea of adaf models ( see rees et al .
1982 ; narayan & yi 1994 , 1995a , b ) .
detailed numerical calculations based on this idea have been performed , and the resulting spectra have been successfully applied to a number of extra galactic systems ( e.g. , narayan et al . 1995 ; lasota et al .
1996 ; mahadevan et al . 1996 ; manmoto et al .
1997 ; narayan et al .
1998 ) .
in this study we apply analytical scaling laws for self - similar solutions to derive the luminosity relation for adaf - variations ( narayan & yi 1994 ; mahadevan 1997 ) .
we adopt the following dimensionless variables : mass of the smbh @xmath2 , where @xmath3 is the solar mass ; radius from the smbh @xmath4 , where @xmath5 ; and mass accretion rate @xmath6 , where @xmath7 when @xmath8 .
we assume that the flows are spherically symmetric as the adaf is quasi - spherical ( narayan & yi 1995a ) .
however , the anisotropic extinction of host galaxies is not taken into account explicitly .
this fact should be considered carefully if one wishes to elaborate this method .
the advection fraction @xmath9 is determined such that the ion and electron energy balance equations are met .
the quantities of interest are the volume - integrated quantities which are obtained by integrating the heating rate and cooling rates throughout the volume of the flows . for
spherically symmetric flows the volume - integrated quantities are defined by @xmath10 where @xmath11 denotes any quantity of interest ( cf .
mahadevan 1997 ) . as canonical values in a model for the adafs parameters
are taken to be @xmath12 , @xmath13 , @xmath14 , and @xmath15 , where @xmath16 and @xmath17 represent the inner and the outer boundaries of the disk , respectively , @xmath18 is the viscosity parameter , and @xmath19 is the ratio of the gas pressure to the total pressure .
the results of this study are insensitive to these values unless these parameters are very small .
the lower limit of the integration corresponds to the last stable orbit for the schwarzschild black hole , and the upper limit is not very crucial since most of radiation and heating occur around the central black hole .
we assume that the electron temperature is constant for @xmath20 , as suggested by narayan & yi ( 1995b ) . the total heating by the viscous dissipation for ions @xmath21 is given by @xmath22 where @xmath23 is a constant defined as in mahadevan ( 1997 ) .
we neglect the possibility of the viscous heating of the electrons , since we expect that the fraction of viscous energy transferred to the electrons is in the mass ratio of the electron to the ion , @xmath24 .
the electrons are assumed to gain energy only by coulomb interactions with the ions .
the total heating of the electrons due to the coulomb interaction is given by stepney & guilbert ( 1983 ) @xmath25 where @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 being a modified bessel function , @xmath29 , @xmath30 , and @xmath31 being the boltzmann constant , the electron mass , and the speed of light , respectively , @xmath32 is a constant given in narayan & yi ( 1994 ) .
the synchrotron photons are self - absorbed and give a blackbody radiation upto a critical frequency @xmath33 .
for a given @xmath34 , the synchrotron spectrum @xmath35 is given by @xmath36 where @xmath37 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 , @xmath40 , @xmath41 , @xmath42 and @xmath43 being the electron charge , the magnetic field strength , respectively .
the radio luminosity @xmath44 at @xmath45 is defined by @xmath46 .
the highest radio frequency arises from the innermost radius of the accretion flows , @xmath47 ; @xmath48 . at this peak frequency
the peak radio luminosity is given by @xmath49 we obtain the total power due to synchrotron radiation from @xmath50 we set @xmath51 , since @xmath52 is much smaller than @xmath53 .
we neglect the comptonization of bremsstrahlung emission and consider the comptonization of synchrotron emission alone .
a contribution by compton up - scattered synchrotron photons to the hard x - ray luminosity becomes important as @xmath57 increases , while bremsstrahlung emission dominates the hard x - ray luminosity when @xmath57 is substantially low .
we approximate the comptonized spectrum by assuming that all the synchrotron photons to be comptonized have an initial frequency of @xmath53 .
the maximum final frequency of the comptonized photon is @xmath58 , which corresponds to the average energy of the photon for saturated comptonization in the wien regime . on average
, we assume that all the photons would see one half the total optical depth ( mahadevan 1997 ) , which is written as @xmath59 . the spectrum of the emerging photons at frequency @xmath45 has the power - law shape @xmath60 where @xmath61 is the initial luminosity at the initial frequency @xmath62 of the photons that are comptonized , @xmath63 , @xmath64 being the mean amplification factor in a single scattering .
the total compton power is therefore given by @xmath65^{1-\alpha_c}-1 \biggr\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for given @xmath66 , the total heating of the electrons should be balanced to the sum of the individual cooling ; @xmath67 .
the electron temperature is obtained by adjusting until this equality is satisfied .
adafs have the positive bernoulli constant , which is a kind of total energy of the fluid , and , therefore , are susceptible to outflows ( e.g. , narayan & yi 1994 ) .
it might be the case that jets are present near the inner region of adafs .
radio emission due to adafs at the high frequency will be suppressed if the inner part of the accretion flow is truncated by low frequency jets . in order to simulate this situation ,
we truncate adafs at a certain inner radius .
we suppose that the truncation occurs at @xmath68 .
an observation of ngc 4486 ( m87 ) indicates that the jet is formed in a smaller radius than @xmath69 ( junor et al .
this is also about where is the maximum radius that 15 ghz radio emission is generated for @xmath70 .
note that @xmath71 can be estimated by @xmath72 .
we consequently set @xmath16 in expressions in the previous subsection to @xmath73 instead of @xmath74 in corresponding expressions in the truncation case in order to obtain the radio luminosity and the x - ray luminosity .
since the frequency at which the radio luminosity is the highest arises from the innermost radius of the accretion disk , @xmath75 , the truncation radius affects the peak radio luminosity at this frequency according to eq .
in addition to a jet or outflows , since the gas in adaf solutions is generically unbound winds may also carry away infalling matter ( see , e.g. , blandford & begelman 1999 ; di matteo et al .
1999 ; quataert & narayan 1999 ) .
we allow @xmath57 to vary with @xmath71 as @xmath76 , where @xmath77 is the mass accretion rate at @xmath17 , @xmath78 is the parameter which controls the effects of winds ( see , e.g. , blandford & begelman 1999 ) .
the mass loss causes a significant effect on a model spectrum for a large value of @xmath78 .
bremsstrahlung and synchrotron emissions decrease with increasing @xmath78 , due both to the lower density and to the lower @xmath34 in inner parts .
compton emission decreases with increasing @xmath78 even more strongly than the other two emissions since it depends both on @xmath79 and @xmath80 .
as @xmath57 is replaced by @xmath81 , expressions for the standard adafs are to be modified as described below .
the total heating for ions @xmath21 reads @xmath82 where @xmath83 .
similarly , @xmath84 is given by @xmath85 where @xmath86 .
we assume that @xmath87 and @xmath34 are constants with @xmath71 and @xmath57 as an approximation , as suggested by narayan & yi ( 1995b ) .
given @xmath87 , the cutoff frequency at each radius is given as @xmath88 .
the synchrotron spectrum is given by @xmath89 the peak frequency and the radio luminosity at the peak frequency are correspondingly reduced so that we have @xmath90 the total synchrotron power is also rewritten by @xmath91 for bremsstrahlung emission the total power and the spectrum are respectively given by @xmath92 , \\
l^{brem}_{\nu}&=&2.29 \times 10^{24 } \alpha^{-2 } c_1^{-2 } m \dot{m}_{out}^2 r_{max}^{-2p } f(\theta_e)t_e^{-1}\exp(-h \nu / k t_e)\biggl[\frac{1}{2p } ( r^{2p}_{max}-r^{2p}_{min})\biggr ] .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that as the exponent @xmath78 approaches to 0 , @xmath93 $ ] becomes @xmath94 .
for the comptonization of the synchrotron photons we take @xmath95 as @xmath96 . the compton spectrum and the total compton power
are respectively given by @xmath97^{1-\alpha_c}-1 \biggr\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ]
figure 1 shows a plot of the ratio of the 15 ghz radio luminosity to the 2 - 10 kev x - ray luminosity versus the x - ray luminosity in logarithmic scales as the luminosities are derived in the last section .
the solid lines are standard adaf model predictions for smbh masses of @xmath98 , the dotted lines are adaf model predictions with truncations at @xmath99 , the short dashed lines and the long dashed lines are adaf model predictions with winds , where @xmath100 and @xmath101 , respectively .
values of @xmath78 considered correspond to the moderate wind case , and the strong wind case .
the case of @xmath102 may represent the adafs where the convection is present in adafs in that the density scales @xmath103 with the radius instead of a power of @xmath104 ( narayan , igumenshchev , & abramowicz 2000 ; quataert & gruzinov 2000 ) .
for each curve , a constant @xmath57 for non - windy models or @xmath77 for windy models varies from @xmath105 ( upper left corner ) to @xmath106 ( lower right corner ) . a general trend of model predictions from the standard adaf , the truncated adaf , and the moderately windy adaf is somewhat similar and overlapped .
as long as the canonical model parameters remain unchanged , however , the strongly windy adaf model with large @xmath78 , which represents the convection , results in quite different trends . besides the trend ,
none of data points fall on the area defined by the convective adaf model predictions .
the open circles denote the observed core radio luminosity at 15 ghz , and the filled circles the spatially resolved core radio luminosity which are converted from ones at 5 ghz to at 15 ghz using the @xmath107 power law ( cf . yi & boughn 1999 ) .
we need such a conversion in order for a direct comparison of these luminosities at different frequency .
sources generally fall into the region where theoretical curves predict .
for instance , the mass of the central black hole in ngc 3377 is known as about @xmath108 ( kormendy & richstone 1995 ) . according to our theoretical predictions from the models except the strong wind adaf model
, the mass of the central black hole in ngc 3377 falls in between @xmath109 to @xmath110 . apparently , even though the inherent radio / x - ray luminosity relation provides an estimate of the central smbh masses currently available , radio / x - ray flux relations are yet insufficiently accurate to give unambiguous estimates of the smbh mass . or , the observed radio / x - ray fluxes should be analyzed to extract disk components more carefully
. as for the sources which do not agree with the predictions very well , it is thought either because they have non - adaf sources in their centers or because the observed radio and/or x - ray flux is due to a non - adaf origin .
the predicted mass of ngc 224 ( m31 ) is smaller than the estimated mass at least by two orders of magnitude .
ngc 224 has a very low core radio luminosity , which is even lower than predicted with the mass accretion rate that the x - ray luminosity implies on the basis of an adaf model .
ngc 224 seems to harbor a double nucleus ( lauer et al .
1993 ; bacon et al .
it is unclear whether adaf is viable under such circumstance .
predicted masses of ngc 1068 , ngc 3031 ( m81 ) , ngc 3079 , ngc 4151 are @xmath111 to @xmath112 a few @xmath113 . on the other hand ,
reported mass estimates of smbhs of these galaxies are less than @xmath114 .
masses of these sources are thought to be over - estimated due to high radio / x - ray luminosities resulting from strong jet - related activities .
moreover , uncertainties in x - ray flux measurements and intrinsic variations could cause errors in our predictions .
ngc 1068 is famous in that it has a strong compact radio source , which results in a much higher radio / x - ray luminosity ratio than other seyferts ( gallimore et al .
the radio core of ngc 3031 ( m81 ) is also highly variable on many timescale ( ho 1999 ) .
moreover , ngc 3031 is substantially brighter in x - rays relative to the uv than in luminous agns ( ho 1999 ) , and its core luminosity in the 2 - 10 kev band varies by a factor of @xmath115 in a timescale of years ( ishisaki et al .
1996 ) . in ngc 3079
the high radio luminosity may be due to an unresolved small - scale jet .
the radio morphology of ngc 4151 suggests that the emitting material has been energized from the nucleus and that the jet interacts with the ambient medium ( carral et al .
1990 ) . in figure 2 ,
the predicted core radio luminosity is shown as a function of the smbh mass in a logarithmic scale , with plots of smbh candidates whose mass estimates are publicly known . from top to bottom , for each pair of lines , the mass accretion rate corresponds to @xmath116 and @xmath105 .
the line types and symbols are same as those in figure 1 .
although the radio flux data are in high angular resolution there appears a somewhat wide range of radio luminosities , which is likely the result of small , and thus invisible , radio jets or other components of various frequencies rather than the pure adaf emission . in particular
, the radio luminosity of objects such as ngc 3079 , ngc 3031 , and ngc 1068 seems too high to be explained by the pure adaf emission . in figure 3 ,
the x - ray luminosity for the 2 - 10 kev band is shown as a function of the smbh mass in a similar way as in figure 2 .
quoted x - ray fluxes of ngc 4486 and ngc 3377 should be considered as upper limits ( reynolds et al . 1999 ; pellegrini 1999 ) .
note that the observed x - ray flux of ngc 3377 in the energy band of 0.2 - 4 kev is converted to the value in the energy band of 2 - 10 kev , assuming a power - law with the canonical spectral index for seyfert 1 galaxies , i.e. , @xmath117 .
high resolution x - ray images have revealed discrete x - ray sources for ngc 224 ( trinchieri et al .
1999 ) , ngc 3031 ( ishisaki et al .
1996 ) , ngc 4736 ( roberts et al .
for these sources we adopt core or bulge x - ray fluxes .
one of important predictions of the adaf model is the radio / x - ray luminosity relation which can be used to estimate central smbh masses .
we compute the theoretical predictions of the radio / x - ray luminosity relation for the adaf models with various modifications and compare the predicted relation with that from the available smbh candidates .
several nearby extra galaxies have consistent ratios of radio to x - ray luminosities with the adaf predictions for an estimated mass of the central smbh .
if the type of the accretion flow is provided by observations with a high angular resolution , the inherent radio / x - ray luminosity relation provides a direct estimate of the central smbh mass .
we show the logarithm of the ratio of radio to x - ray luminosities against the logarithm of the x - ray luminosity for several smbh masses in figure 1 .
the observations for several extra galactic objects are consistent with the predictions of adaf models , as can be checked in figures 2 and 3 .
it is , however , interesting to note that the model representing the adafs with the strong wind can be ruled out unless the microphysics in the standard adaf model has to be modified significantly . in this study
, we implicitly assume that all the smbhs are non - rotating .
when the black hole rotates , the last stable circular orbit is no longer 3 @xmath118 .
it becomes smaller than this value and eventually the event horizon when the black hole spin parameter @xmath119 .
if this is the case the boundary condition should change as well as the dynamical properties of the flows in inner parts ( gammie & popham 1998 ; popham & gammie 1998 ) . besides dynamics of the flows , a rotating black hole may power a jet by the blandford - znajek process ( blandford & znajek 1977 ) . therefore , even if the black hole rotates slowly , the rotation should be properly taken into account in order to make this method robust .
another crucial modification could be made in terms of microphysics we simplified .
we have assumed that the viscously generated energy mainly heats the ions , heat exchanges between ions and electrons occur only due to the coulomb interaction , other physical processes , such as , mhd turbulence , pair production , are ignored .
many works have been done to quantify the effects of such processes ( e.g. , zel et al .
2000 ) . once clear understanding is incorporated in the method we present here , its implication can be more robust .
on the other hand , at the moment , the peak luminosity of the radio is unlikely to be modified though the wings of the radio spectrum are modified by the nonthermal electrons .
therefore , as long as we use the peak radio luminosity instead of whole structure , this method is not seriously defected .
alonso - herrero , a. , ivanov , v. d. , jayawardhana , r. , & hosokawa , t. 2002 , apj , 571 , l1 bacon , r. , emsellem , e. , monnet , g. , & nieto , j. l. 1994 , a&a , 281 , 691 baganoff , f. k. et al .
2001 , astro - ph/0102151 blandford , r. d. , & begelman , m. c. 1999 , mnras , 303 , l1 blandford , r. d. , & znajek , r. l. 1977 , mnras , 179 , 433 cagnoni , i. , della ceca , r. , & maccacaro , t. 1998 , apj , 493 , 54 carral , p. , turner , j. l. , & ho , p. t. p. 1990 , apj , 362 , 434 colbert , e. j. m. , & mushotzky , r. f. 1999 , apj , 519 , 89 cao , x. , & jiang , d. r. 2002 , mnras , 331 , 111 di matteo , t. , & fabian , a. c. 1997 , mnras , 286 , 393 di matteo , t. et al .
1999 , mnras , 305 , 492 dressler , a. , & richstone , d. o. 1988 , apj , 324 , 701 eckart , a. , & genzel , r. 1997 , mnras , 284 , 576 fabian , a. c. , & rees , m. j. 1995 , mnras , 277 , l55 ferrarese , l. 2002 , in current high - energy emission around black holes , ed .
lee & h .- y .
chang(singapore : world scientific ) , in press .
ferrarese , l. , & merritt , d. 2000 , apj , 539 , l9 ford , h. c. et al .
1994 , apj , 435 , l27 forster , k. , leighly , k. m. , & kay , l. e. 1999 , apj , 523 , 521 franceschini , a. , vercellone , s. , & fabian , a. c. 1998 , mnras , 297 , 817 frank , j. , king , a. r. , & raine , d. 1992 , accretion power in astrophysics + ( cambridge : cambridge university press ) gammie , c. f. , & popham , r. 1998 , apj , 498 , 313 popham , r. & gammie , c. f. 1998 , apj , 504 , 419 gallimore , j. f. , baum , s. a. , odea , c. p. , & pedlar , a. 1996 , apj , 458 , 136 gebhardt , k. et al .
2000a , apj , 539 , l13 gebhardt , k. et al .
2000b , apj , 543 , l5 genzel , r. , eckart , a. , ott , t. , & eisenhauer , f. 1997 , mnras , 291 , 219 ghez , a. m. , klein , b. l. , morris , m. , & becklin , e. e. 1998 , apj , 509 , 678 greenhill , l. j. , gwinn , c. r. , antonucci , r. , & barvainis , r. 1996 , apj , 472 , l21 ho , l. c. 1999 , apj , 516 , 672 ho , l. c. 2002 , apj , 564 , 120 ishisaki , y. et al .
1996 , pasj , 48 , 237 iwasawa , k. et al .
1997 , mnras , 285 , 683 iyomoto , n. et al .
1997 , pasj , 49 , 425 junor , w. , biretta , j. a. , & livio , m. 1999 , nature , 401 , 891 kormendy , j. , & richstone , d. 1995 , ara&a , 33 , 581 lacy , m. et al .
2001 , apj , 551 , l17 lasota , j. p. et al .
1996 , apj , 462 , 142 lauer , t. r. et al .
1993 , aj , 106 , 1436 lynden - bell , d. 1969 , nature , 223 , 690 magorrian , j. et al .
1998 , aj , 115 , 2285 mahadevan , r. 1997 , apj , 477 , 585 mahadevan , r. , narayan , r. , & yi , i. 1996 , apj , 465 , 327 makishima , k. et al .
1994 , pasj , 46 , l77 manmoto , t. , mineshige , s. , & kusunose , m. 1997 , apj , 489 , 791 miyoshi , m. et al .
1995 , nature , 373 , 127 nandra , k. et al .
1997 , apj , 477 , 602 narayan , r. , & yi , i. 1994 , apj , 428 , l13 narayan , r. , & yi , i. 1995a , apj , 444 , 231 narayan , r. , & yi , i. 1995b , apj , 452 , 710 narayan , r. , igumenshchev , i. v. , & abramowicz , m. a. 2000 , apj , 539 , 798 narayan , r. , yi , i. , & mahadevan , r. 1995 , nature , 374 , 623 narayan , r. et al .
1998 , apj , 492 , 554 zel , f. , psaltis , d. , & narayan , r. 2000 , apj , 541 , 234 pellegrini , s. 1999 , a&a , 351 , 487 ptak , a. et al .
1998 , apj , 501 , l37 ptak , a. , serlemitsos , p. , yaqoob , t. , & mushotzky , r. 1999 , apjs , 120 , 179 quataert , e. , & gruzinov , a. 2000 , apj , 539 , 809 quataert , e. , & narayan , r. 1999 , apj , 520 , 298 rees , m. j. , phinney , e. s. , begelman , m. c. , & blandford , r. d. 1982 , nature , 295 , 17 rees , m. j. 1984 , ara&a , 22 , 471 reynolds , c. s. et al .
1996 , mnras , 283 , 111 reynolds , c. s. , heinz , s. , fabian , a. c. , & begelman , m. c. 1999 , apj , 521 , 99 richstone , d. et al .
1998 , nature , 395 , a14 roberts , t. p. , warwick , r. s. , & ohashi , t. 1999 , mnras , 304 , 52 saikia , d. j. , pedlar , a. , unger , s. w. , & axon , d. j. 1994 , mnras , 270 , 46 stepney , s. , & guilbert , p. w. 1983 , mnras , 204 , 1269 svensson , r. 1982 , apj , 258 , 335 terashima , y. et al .
1998 , apj , 496 , 210 trinchieri , g. et al .
1999 , a&a , 348 , 43 turner , j. l. , & ho , p. t. p. 1994
, apj , 421 , 122 turner , t. j. , george , i. m. , nandra , k. , & mushotzky , r. f. 1997 , apjs , 113 , 23 wandel , a. , peterson , b. m. , & malkan , m. a. 1999 , apj , 526 , 579 yi , i. , & boughn , s. p. 1998 , apj , 499 , 198 yi , i. , & boughn , s. p. 1999
, apj , 515 , 576 | optically thin and geometrically thick accretion flows are known to be responsible for the observed radio / x - ray luminosity relation of the x - ray bright galactic nuclei .
it has also been suggested that supermassive black hole masses can be estimated from measurements of the core radio luminosity and the x - ray luminosity by using the advection - dominated accretion flow ( adaf ) model . in this study
we increase the number of data available by compiling the radio / x - ray fluxes and the mass in published literatures , and compare the observed ratio of the luminosities with predictions from various models of optically thin accretion flows .
semi - analytically derived relations of the luminosities are presented in cases of the standard adaf model and modified adaf models , in which a truncation of inner parts of the flows and winds causing a reduction of the infalling matter are included .
we show that the observed relation can be used indeed to estimate the supermassive black hole mass , provided that properties of such accretion flows are known . having investigated sensitivities of the method on modifications of the standard adaf model
, we find that a general trend of model predictions from the standard adaf , the truncated adaf and the windy adaf are somewhat indistinguishable .
we also find , however , that the extreme case of the windy model is inconsistent with currently available observational data , unless microphysics parameters are to be substantially changed .
high resolution radio observations , however , are required to avoid the contamination of non - disk components , such as , a jet component , which , otherwise , results in the over - estimated smbh mass . |
at a distance of @xmath4kpc ( @xcite ) , sgra * , the compact radio , nir and x - ray source at the galactic center , is thought to mark the position of a super - massive black hole of mass @xmath5 ( @xcite,@xcite ) .
proper motions of sgra * ( @xcite ) confirm that it traces a significant amount of the mass that is inferred by stellar motions and orbits .
due to its proximity , sgra * is the only galactic nucleus that can be studied with vlbi on sub - au linear scales ( @xmath6 ) .
the ionized ism , however , scatter - broadens images of sgra * with a @xmath7 dependence , and vlbi at the highest frequencies is the only available means to set important limits on intrinsic structures near the event horizon .
vlbi at 7 mm and 3.5 mm has detected evidence for intrinsic structure of sgra * , but these observations remain dominated by scattering effects , and the intrinsic sizes at these wavelengths ( set by the optical depth of the emission ) are much larger than the apparent size of the event horizon ( @xcite , @xcite ) .
evidence from light curves of sgra * flares from the radio to xray ( @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) implicate structures on smaller ( @xmath8 ) scales . only at frequencies above 230ghz
does the scattering size become smaller than the vlbi array resolution allowing direct measurement of intrinsic structure on these scales corresponding to the innermost accretion region . over the past decade ,
mit haystack observatory has focused on developing next - generation wideband vlbi instrumentation capable of significantly increasing the sensitivity of mm / submm vlbi arrays .
the observations described herein used this instrumentation to show that 1.3 mm vlbi of sgra * can now probe the event horizon of this super - massive black hole candidate .
the focus of new vlbi instrumentation has been to process higher bandwidths using commercially available digital technology . for vlbi ,
this has translated into a re - conceptualization of the two main components of the traditional vlbi backend : the digitization / formatting stage and the recording stage .
prior to recording data for subsequent correlation , the if ( intermediate frequency ) at each vlbi telescope must be sampled and channelized in frequency .
the mark4 system ( similar to the system in use at the vlba ) uses a bank of analog filters to break the if into sub - bands . with the advent of mature fpga ( field programmable gate array ) technology
, it is now feasible to channelize the if signal using a polyphase filterbank approach that is realized in digital signal processing after the sampling stage .
a collaboration between haystack observatory and the space science laboratory at uc berkeley has focused on developing a fully digital fpga - based vlbi backend , which produces an output suitable for recording on modern hard - disk based recorders .
this system , the dbe , is capable of sampling two 480mhz wide ifs , and producing two 2gigabit / sec output streams ( nyquist sampled , 2-bit resolution ) .
the dbe ( figure [ dbe_photo ] ) represents a reduction in backend cost by a factor of @xmath9 over the previous mark4 data acquisition system and is 5 times smaller in size ( the size of a single pc ) .
the next - generation dbe ( imaginatively called dbe2 ) , is currently under development , and will use the xilinx virtex5 family of fpga chips to double the data throughput to @xmath10 gigabits / sec .
the digital backend ( dbe ) system developed to process two 480mhz wide if bands , producing an aggregate vlbi data output rate of 3.84 gigbit / sec . ]
the mark5 system was developed at haystack observatory in collaboration with conduant corp as the first high - data - rate vlbi data system based on magnetic - disc technology .
incorporating primarily low - cost pc - based components , the mark5 system now supports data rates up to 2048 mbps , recording to an array of 8 inexpensive removable hard disks .
the mark 5 system ( figure [ mk5_photo ] ) was developed primarily to re - packaged the disks into convenient 8-pack modules and over 100 mark5 units are in use throughout the vlbi community .
support for mark 5 development at mit haystack observatory was provided by bkg , evn , kvn , mpi , nasa , nrao , nsf , and usno .
the mark5 system replaces a magnetic tape system , which used a non - standard reel - to - reel recorder and a special - purpose tape media whose cost was not likely to decrease over time .
the new system is over a factor of 5 smaller in size than the previous recorder with a data rate improvement of x4 .
the cost for this new recording system is @xmath9 times less than the tape system and uses standard commercial disk media whose cost ( per gigabyte ) is projected to substantially decrease over time .
efforts to increase recording rates to 4gigabits / sec are underway , and the new mark5c recorder will be capable of recording data from 10gigabit ethernet inputs . the mark5 hard disk vlbi data recorder .
each hard disk module holds up to 8 individual hard disks . with current disk sizes ,
a full module can record 6 tbytes .
maximum recording rates are now 2gb / s but will increase to 4gb / s in 2009 . ]
in april 2007 , sgra * and several quasar calibrators were observed over two consecutive days at a wavelength of 1.3 mm with a three station vlbi array ( @xcite ) .
the array included the james clerk maxwell telescope ( jcmt ) on mauna kea , the arizona radio observatory submillimeter telescope ( aro / smt ) on mt graham in arizona , and one 10 m dish of the coordinated array for research in millimeter - wave astronomy ( carma ) in california . projected baseline lengths on sgra * ranged from @xmath11 on the shortest baseline to @xmath12 on the longest .
an effective bandwidth of 960 mhz was recorded , resulting in an aggregate recording data rate of 3.84 gigabits / sec at each site ( 2 bits / sample , nyquist sampling ) .
data were processed on the mit haystack observatory mark4 correlator to produce complex visibilities with 0.5 second time resolution .
calibration quasars were robustly detected on all three baselines , validating operation of the vlbi array and allowing refinement of telescope positions for processing of the sgra * observations . because the geometry of vlbi baselines in an array is not typically known to @xmath13 precision , it is standard practise to search for detections over a grid of interferometric delay and delay - rate .
a peak in signal - to - noise ratio of the visibility amplitude , found over a range of nyquist - sampled delay and delay - rate space , is deemed a detection if the probability of false detection is sufficiently low . at an observing wavelength of 1.3 mm ,
atmospheric turbulence limits the time over which the vlbi signal can be coherently integrated .
therefore , a technique of incoherent averaging ( @xcite ) was used , to perform the fringe search over each 10 minute vlbi scan and to determine the vlbi signal amplitude .
incoherent averaging extends the effective integration time , but builds signal to noise more slowly than @xmath14 . after measuring the coherence losses due to atmospheric effects over a range of time scales ,
the atmospheric coherence time was found to be @xmath10 seconds , and the vlbi detection searches were thus made by incoherently averaging 8 second intervals of coherently averaged data .
these searches resulted in robust detections and correlated flux density measurements of sgra * on both the aro / smt - jcmt and aro / smt - carma baselines ( see figure [ detections ] ) .
no detections were found on the carma - jcmt baseline , which is attributable to the lower sensitivity of that baseline compared with the others .
the error associated with each visibility amplitude was calculated by adding in quadrature the noise determined from the detection search with a 10% calibration error .
measurements of sgra * made with the carma array during the vlbi observations yield a total flux density of sgra * of @xmath15jy , which was observed to be stable over both days , suggesting that sgra * was observed in a quiescent state .
errors in the total flux density measurement are dominated by pointing and calibration .
detections of sgra * and nearby calibrator at 1.3mm@xmath16 on a 3500 km projected baseline between the submillimeter telescope on mt .
graham , az and the james clerk maxwell telescope on mauna kea , hi . shown are searches in signal to noise ratio over interferometer delay and delay - rate for 10 minute scans for quasar pks b1921 - 293 on april 11 , 2007 at 14:00ut ( left ) and for sgra * the same day at 12:00ut ( right ) .
the data were segmented into 8 second intervals to reduce coherence loss due to atmospheric turbulence and the amplitudes were averaged incoherently .
the formal probability of false detection ( pfd ) in each search is computed by comparing the observed signal to noise ratio with maximal peaks derived from pure noise over the same search space , and is @xmath17 for both fringe searches shown above .
contours in each plot begin at signal to noise ratio of 2.0 and increase in steps of @xmath18 .
peak signal to noise is 7.9 and 5.8 on the left and right searches respectively . ]
a circular gaussian model was fit to the vlbi data ( shown in figure [ uvdist ] ) .
the weighted least - squares best - fit model has a total flux density of @xmath19jy and full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) of 43 ( + 14,-8 ) @xmath0as where errors are @xmath3 . on the assumption of a gaussian profile , the intrinsic size of sgr a * can be extracted from our measurement assuming that the scatter broadening due to the ism adds in quadrature with the intrinsic size . at a wavelength of 1.3 mm the scattering size extrapolated from previous longer - wavelength vlbi ( @xcite )
is @xmath20as . removing the scattering effects results in a @xmath3 range for the intrinsic size of sgr a * equal to 37 ( @xmath1,@xmath2 ) @xmath0as .
the @xmath3 intrinsic size upper limit at 1.3 mm , combined with a lower limit to the mass of sgr a * of @xmath21 from measured proper motions yields a lower limit for the mass density of @xmath22 .
this density lower limit and central mass would rule out most alternatives to a black hole for sgr a * because other concentrations of matter would have collapsed or evaporated on timescales that are short compared with the age of the milky way ( @xcite ) .
shown are the correlated flux density data on the aro / smt-carma and aro / smt-jcmt baselines plotted against projected baseline length ( errors are @xmath23 ) .
squares show aro / smt-carma baseline data and triangles show aro / smt-jcmt data , with open symbols for 10 april and filled symbols for 11 april .
the solid line shows the weighted least - squares best fit to a circular gaussian brightness distribution , with fwhm size of 43.0 @xmath0as .
the dotted line shows a uniform thick - ring model with an inner diameter of 35 @xmath0as and an outer diameter of 80 @xmath0as convolved with scattering effects due to the interstellar medium .
the total flux density measurement made with the carma array over both days of observing is shown as a filled circle . an upper limit for flux density of 0.6 jy , derived from non - detection on the jcmt-carma baselines ,
is represented with an arrow near a baseline length of @xmath24 . ]
it should be noted , however , that while structure on @xmath25 scales is present in sgra * , models other than the circular gaussian can be fit to the data .
this is illustrated by the dotted line in figure [ uvdist ] , which shows the expected flux density as a function of baseline length for a uniform circular annulus with inner diameter 35@xmath0as and outer diameter 80@xmath0as that has been scatter broadened by the ism .
future higher - sensitivity observations will distinguish between these two models by allowing detections of sgra * on the carma - jcmt baseline , which is now represented in figure [ uvdist ] only as an upper limit . because of gravitational lensing effects due to the extreme gravity near the assumed black hole , radiation emitted from near the event horizon of a non - spinning black hole will have an apparent size of @xmath26 .
for sgra * , this expected diameter is @xmath27as , which differs by @xmath3 from the size derived from a gaussian model . even if the black hole is maximally spinning ( a=1 ) , the diameter of the event horizon in the equatorial plane ( @xmath28as ) would still exceed the estimated size .
this suggests that sgra * is not an optically thick emission region that symmetrically enfolds the black hole .
rather , it is likely due either to emission from a jet or from the approaching ( and therefore doppler enhanced ) side of an accretion disk that is inclined to our line of sight ( @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) .
either scenario results in emission that is offset from the black hole position .
this marks the first time that astronomical observations of any kind have directly constrained the spatial relationship between sgra * and the black hole .
the technology to significantly increase the sensitivity of vlbi at wavelengths of 1.3 mm and shorter is now enabling observations of sgra * on schwarzschild radius scales .
efforts to extend the capabilities of the current 1.3 mm vlbi array include : phasing together radio telescopes on mauna kea and at carma to increase collecting area ( discussed elsewhere in these proceedings ) , continuing to pursue increases in recording bandwidth , and bringing new mm / submm vlbi sites on - line . by 2009 , the international collaboration ( see the author list of @xcite ) that has carried out these observations , will field a higher sensitivity 1.3 mm vlbi array that will be sensitive to time variable structures in sgra*. the closure phase is the sum of interferometric phases around a triangle of baselines , is largely immune from calibration errors , and deviates from zero in the presence of asymmetric source structure .
projected sensitivities will allow monitoring of the closure phase on @xmath9 second time scales , and enable tests for periodic structure variation in sgra * as is predicted by orbiting hot - spot models of the accretion flow ( @xcite , @xcite ) . by timing periodicities in the closure phase
, one can extract the fundamental black hole spin parameter ( @xcite ) .
thus , by spatially resolving the innermost accretion region surrounding sgra * , mm / submm vlbi is now positioned to address fundamental issues in black hole physics .
vlbi at mm / submm wavelengths would not be possible without the dedicated support of staff and scientists as all participating facilities .
vlbi work at the mit haystack observatory is supported through grants from the national science foundation . | advances in vlbi instrumentation now allow wideband recording that significantly increases the sensitivity of short wavelength vlbi observations .
observations of the super - massive black hole candidate at the center of the milky way , sgra * , with short wavelength vlbi reduces the scattering effects of the intervening interstellar medium , allowing observations with angular resolution comparable to the apparent size of the event horizon of the putative black hole .
observations in april 2007 at a wavelength of 1.3 mm on a three station vlbi array have now confirmed structure in sgra * on scales of just a few schwarzschild radii . when modeled as a circular gaussian ,
the fitted diameter of sgra * is 37@xmath0as ( @xmath1,@xmath2 ; @xmath3 ) , which is smaller than the expected apparent size of the event horizon of the galactic center black hole .
these observations demonstrate that mm / sub - mm vlbi is poised to open a new window onto the study of black hole physics via high angular resolution observations of the galactic center . |
the physics phenomena of nuclei are largely understood by considering the interaction between their building blocks , the nucleons . in 1935 , yukawa described the nucleon - nucleon ( nn ) force by the exchange of massive mesons @xcite in analogy to the electromagnetic interaction which can be represented by the exchange of a massless photon .
several phenomenological nucleon - nucleon potentials have been derived based on yukawa s theory and are able to reproduce data points in neutron - proton and proton - proton scattering with extremely high precision .
these so - called high - quality nn potentials are used in faddeev equations @xcite to give an exact solution of the scattering problem for the three - nucleon system .
already , for the simplest three - nucleon system , the triton , an exact solution of the three - nucleon faddeev equations employing two - nucleon forces ( 2nfs ) underestimates the experimental binding energy @xcite , showing that 2nfs are not sufficient to describe the three - nucleon system accurately .
the existence of an additional force , the three - nucleon ( 3n ) interaction , was predicted a long time ago by primakov @xcite and confirmed by a comparison between precision data and state - of - the - art calculations @xcite .
many high - precision measurements of nucleon - deuteron scattering processes at intermediate energies were carried out in the past decades with the aim to study 3nf effects and to compare the experimental observations with the predictions from rigorous faddeev calculations . in general , adding 3nf effects to the modern nn potentials gives a better agreement between the cross section data for the proton - deuteron scattering processes and the corresponding calculations @xcite , whereas a similar comparison for the spin observables yields various discrepancies @xcite .
the overall conclusion is that the spin - dependent parts of the 3nfs are poorly understood and that more studies in this field are needed .
the 3nf effects are in general small in the three - nucleon system .
a complementary approach is to examine heavier systems for which the 3nf effects are significantly enhanced in magnitude .
naively , one might expect that the 3nf effects increase by the argument that the number of three - nucleon combinations with respect to two - nucleon combinations gets larger with increasing number of nucleons .
we , however , note that the saturation of 3nf effects sets in very quickly for large nuclei as well .
this simple counting rule is supported by a comparison between predictions and data for the binding energies of light nuclei @xcite .
the predictions of a green s function monte - carlo calculation based on the argonne v18 @xcite nn interaction ( av18 ) and the illinois-2 ( il2 ) 3nf @xcite are compared to experimental data . while a calculation which only includes the av18 nn potential deviates significantly from the experimental results , the predictions of calculations which include as well a 3nf come much closer to the data , especially for the first few light nuclei .
note that the effect of the 3nf on the binding energy for the triton is 0.5 - 0.8 mev , whereas the effect increases significantly for the four - nucleon system , @xmath0he , to @xmath14 mev .
for this , it was proposed to study the four - nucleon system at intermediate energies since the experimental database for this is presently poor in comparison with that of three - nucleon systems @xcite .
most of the available data have been measured at very low energies , in particular below the three - body break - up threshold of 2.2 mev .
also , theoretical developments are evolving rapidly at low energies @xcite , but lag behind at higher energies .
this situation calls for extensive four - nucleon studies at intermediate energies .
this paper addresses the feasibility of measuring polarization observables in the three - body break - up channel in deuteron - deuteron scattering , @xmath2 , for an incident beam energy of 65 mev / nucleon .
this work is part of a more extensive experimental program which was carried out at kvi and that aims to provide precision data in various four - nucleon scattering processes at intermediate energies . with these data
, we will significantly enrich the four - nucleon scattering database at intermediate energies and , thereby , provide a basis to test future calculations with the long - term aim to understand the details of 3nf effects .
e , followed by a wall of thick segmented scintillators ( e ) .
the backward ball is not shown in this picture , since it was not used in the analysis presented in this paper . ]
deuteron - deuteron scattering below the pion - production threshold leads to 5 possible final states with a pure hadronic signature , namely : + 1 .
elastic channel : @xmath3 ; 2 .
neutron - transfer channel : @xmath4 ; 3 .
proton - transfer channel : @xmath5 ; 4 .
three - body final - state break - up : @xmath6 ; 5 .
four - body final - state break - up : @xmath7 .
the study and identification of these final states require an experimental setup with specific features , namely , a large phase space coverage , a good energy and angular resolution , and the ability for particle identification .
the experiment presented in this paper was carried out at kvi using the big instrument for nuclear - polarization analysis , bina , which meets all these requirements @xcite .
this work is devoted to the three - body final state .
bina is a setup with a nearly @xmath8 geometrical acceptance and has been used in various few - nucleon scattering experiments to measure the scattering angles and energies of protons and deuterons with the possibility for particle identification .
the detector is composed of a forward part ( forward wall ) and a backward part .
figure [ bina1 ] shows a side view of the forward part of bina which consists of a multi - wire proportional chamber ( mwpc ) , and an array of thin plastic scintillators ( @xmath9e ) with a thickness of 1 mm , followed by a wall of thick segmented scintillators ( e ) with a thickness of 12 cm each .
all scintillators were read out by photo - multiplier tubes ( pmts ) on both ends . the signals from these pmts are integrated using a qdc to measure their energy loss in the scintillator .
the discriminated signals from the constant fraction discriminators ( cfds ) are fed into time - to - digital converters ( tdcs ) .
the time difference between the signals from both ends of the scintillators allows to determine the position of the incoming particle .
in addition , information about the time - of - flight ( tof ) of the particles can be extracted .
the thick scintillators were mounted in a cylindrical shape , thereby , facing the target .
the thickness of these scintillators is sufficient to stop all the protons and deuterons originating from the processes described in this work .
the forward wall has a complete azimuthal coverage for scattering angles from 10@xmath10 to 32@xmath10 , which is advantageous for the determination of the beam polarization and spin observables . with the wire spacing of 2 mm and for a distance of 29.7 cm between mwpc and target
, we obtain an overall accuracy of 0.4@xmath11 for the polar angle and between 0.6@xmath11 and 2.0@xmath11 for the azimuthal angle .
the detection efficiency of the mwpc was obtained by using an unbiased and nearly background - free data sample of elastically - scattered deuterons and was found to be typically 98% with an absolute uncertainty of 1% .
a polarized beam of deuterons originating from the polarized ion source ( polis ) @xcite was accelerated by agor ( acclrateur groningen orsay ) to a kinetic energy of 65 mev / nucleon and bombarded on a liquid - deuterium target @xcite .
the polarization of the deuteron beam was measured in the low - energy beam line with a lamb - shift polarimeter ( lsp ) @xcite as well as in the high - energy beam line with bina @xcite . for the polarization measurements using the lsp ,
the low - energy beam was decelerated and focused on to the lsp detection system . the number of deuterons in the spin - up state , n@xmath12 , spin - zero state , n@xmath13 , and spin - down state , n@xmath14 , were counted to measure directly the vector and tensor polarizations of the beam .
in addition , the polarization of the beam of deuterons was obtained at the high - energy beam line employing bina via @xmath15-asymmetry measurements of the @xmath16 reaction based on its well - known analyzing power .
note that the same detector was used as well for the measurement of the polarization observables of the deuteron - deuteron break - up reaction . with the self - calibrating bina setup ,
regular asymmetry measurements of the elastic deuteron - proton scattering process were performed during the actual experiment by switching rapidly the liquid target to a solid ch@xmath17 target .
the polarization of the beam of deuterons was studied as a function of time to check the stability of polarization during the measurement .
also , the polarization values by bina were compared with those measured with the lsp .
the results for the vector ( top panel ) and tensor ( bottom panel ) polarizations of the deuteron beam from bina and lsp are shown in fig .
[ resultpol ] as a function of time .
each filled circle represents the average value of the measured polarizations deduced from different scattering angles with bina in a range from 55@xmath10 to 140@xmath10 in the center - of - mass frame .
the corresponding analyzing powers were taken from an angle - dependent fit of literature values @xcite .
polarization values obtained for different scattering angles were found to be in good agreement within uncertainties .
the values of the polarization obtained with lsp are depicted as filled squares .
the shaded bands represent the results of a constant - value fit through the data including the results obtained with bina and lsp .
the width of the band corresponds to a 2@xmath18 error of the fit .
the polarization values were found to be @xmath19 and @xmath20 .
the total uncertainties of the polarizations was estimated by adding quadratically the statistical error and the systematic error .
the systematic uncertainty stems from the uncertainty in the analyzing powers , and was found to be 6% and 5% for the vector and tensor polarizations , respectively .
a comparison between the results demonstrates that the beam polarization was stable during the experiments and that there is a good agreement between the measured values obtained at the low - energy beam line with the lsp and those measured at the high - energy beam line with bina .
the beam current was monitored during the experiments via a faraday cup at the end of the beam line .
the faraday cup is made of a copper block containing a heavy alloy metal as the actual beam stopper .
the current meter was connected to the faraday cup with a short cable to avoid the voltage drop and pickup effect .
the current meter was calibrated using a precision current source with an uncertainty of 2% .
the beam current was typically 4 pa during the experiment .
an offset of [email protected] pa in the beam current was observed in the @xmath22 experiment through a comparison of @xmath23 in elastic scattering , measured with bina and the one measured with another experimental setup ( bbs ) @xcite .
the elastic channel , neutron transfer channel , and break - up channels leading to three- and four - body final states were uniquely identified using the information on the energies of the outgoing particles , their scattering angles , and their tof . in this work ,
the deuteron - deuteron break - up into the three - body final - state ( four - body final - state ) is further referred to as the three - body break - up ( four - body break - up ) .
this is the first time that spin observables in the three - body break - up reaction in @xmath24 scattering process at intermediate energies have been measured in a background - free experiment .
the analysis procedure and a part of the results of the three - body break - up channel are presented in this paper .
the kinematics of the three - body break - up reaction are determined unambiguously by exploiting the scattering angles of the proton and the deuteron ( @xmath25 ) and the relation between their energies presented by the kinematical curve which is referred to as the @xmath26-curve . the angles @xmath27 and @xmath28 are the polar angles of the proton and the deuteron , respectively , and @xmath29 is the difference between their azimuthal angles .
the energies of the proton , @xmath30 , and deuteron , @xmath31 , were transferred into two new variables , @xmath32 and @xmath26 .
the variable @xmath26 is the arc - length along the @xmath26-curve with the starting point chosen arbitrarily at the point where e@xmath33 is minimum and @xmath32 is the distance of the ( @xmath30 , @xmath31 ) point from the kinematical curve .
scattering is shown as @xmath26-curves for several kinematical configurations .
the kinematics are defined by ( @xmath34 ) , the polar scattering angles of the deuteron and proton , respectively , and their relative azimuthal angle . ]
the @xmath26-curves for several kinematical configurations are shown in fig .
[ kinema ] .
each @xmath26-curve is labeled by three numbers .
for example , the label ( @xmath35 ) shows a kinematical relation of energies of a deuteron that scatters to @xmath36 and a proton that scatters to @xmath37 , and the azimuthal opening angle , @xmath29 , between them is equal to @xmath38 . for the analysis of the three - body break - up data we measured the kinetic energies and the polar and azimuthal angles of the two coincident charged particles .
we performed the analysis of the three - body break - up reaction for that part of the phase - space in which the deuteron and the proton were detected in coincidence in the forward part of bina .
for some parts of the @xmath9e detector , the yield of scintillation light reaching the photomultipliers was not sufficient to obtain a good particle identification .
we , therefore , decided to make use of the time - of - flight to perform a particle identification instead .
we note that the procedure was checked by a successful comparison with an analysis using those @xmath9e detectors which were operating according to specifications . for the particle identification
, we measured the tof of each registered particle and compared its result with the expectation from the kinematics of the three - body break - up reaction .
the tof was determined by discriminating the signals from the two pmts from each scintillator .
the output of the constant - fraction discriminators were fed into time - to - digital converters ( tdcs ) which were used in a common - stop mode .
the common stop signal was derived from the radio frequency of the cyclotron . for the analysis of the break - up data
, the tdc output corresponding to the left- and right - hand side pmts , @xmath39 and @xmath40 , were added together for each event .
the sum of @xmath41 and @xmath40 is independent of hit position along the scintillator slab .
we call this sum tof@xmath42 with @xmath43 referring to the different particles that hit the forward wall . for particle identification
, we compared these results with the expected tof that was calculated from the energy of a particle , calculating a path length from a scattering angle and assuming a certain particle type .
more precisely , the difference between the measured tof of particles 1 and 2 from the information of the tdcs , @xmath44 , and that extracted from the energies and the scattering angles , @xmath45 , has been used to define the variable @xmath9tof .
we note that @xmath9tof is a difference of differences , and that it compares data with a kinematics calculations , both of which yield a difference .
the identification of the break - up channels proceeds by analyzing @xmath9tof .
figure [ tof_tdc_e ] shows the value of @xmath9tof for two particles that are detected in coincidence in the forward wall .
the scattering angle of both particles is fixed to be @xmath46 and the difference between the azimuthal angles of the two particles is @xmath47 .
we note that @xmath9tof does not depend upon @xmath26 and that the detected particle in each hit can be a proton or a deuteron .
three clear peaks can be recognized corresponding to proton - deuteron , proton - proton , and deuteron - proton coincidences .
the identification of the peaks were confirmed using the @xmath9e responses . for this spectrum , we assumed in the calculation of @xmath45 that the first particle is a deuteron and the second one a proton
. if our assumption is correct , events which correspond to a deuteron - proton combination will give a peak around zero in the @xmath9tof spectrum .
note that a clear signal ( peak on the left - hand side of fig .
[ tof_tdc_e ] ) of the three - body break - up events can be observed corresponding to a final - state consisting of a deuteron - proton combination .
the peak on the most right - hand side corresponds to three - body break - up events , but with a proton - deuteron combination in the final state .
the peak in the middle of the spectrum has been identified as two protons that stem from the four - body break - up reaction .
tof for two particles that are detected in coincidence in the forward wall .
the scattering angle of both particles is fixed to be @xmath48 and the difference between the azimuthal angles of the two particles is @xmath47 . ] the top - left panel of fig .
[ chanid_tdc ] represents the correlation between the energy of two particles that are detected in coincidence in the forward wall .
the scattering angle of both particles is fixed to be @xmath48 and the difference between the azimuthal angles of the two particles is @xmath47 .
the energies were obtained by a charge - integration of the signals from the pmts of the forward scintillators .
this spectrum contains events from two different reactions , namely three- and four - body break - up reactions .
the proton - deuteron or deuteron - proton coincidences from the three - body break - up reaction can be separated by choosing events corresponding to the peak of interest as shown in fig [ tof_tdc_e ] .
the results are shown in the top - right and bottom - right panels .
the bottom - left panel contains events which correspond to the peak in the middle of fig [ tof_tdc_e ] .
they originate from the four - body break - up channel .
figures [ tof_tdc_e ] and [ chanid_tdc ] demonstrate the particle identification capabilities of the detection system .
the identification of the proton and deuteron enables us to measure the missing particle in the three - body break - up reaction in deuteron - deuteron scattering .
the missing particle in this reaction is neutron as well .
this particle can be identified using the missing mass technique .
we used the energy and scattering angles of the identified particles to calculate the rest mass of the undetected particle .
figure [ missmass ] shows a typical result of the calculated mass of the undetected particle using the energy , polar and azimuthal angles of the detected proton and deuteron .
the scattering angle of both detected particles is fixed to be @xmath49 and the difference between the azimuthal angles of the two detected particles is @xmath47 .
the dashed ( solid ) curve represents the results of the calculated missing particle mass before ( after ) applying the identification cut on fig .
[ tof_tdc_e ] .
after applying the identification cut the mass spectra show a clear peak corresponding to the mass of neurons with a fwhm of 6.38 mev which confirms the accuracy of pid procedure .
the events on the right - hand side of the peak correspond to break - up events that undergo a hadronic interaction in the scintillator .
these are discarded in the analysis and properly accounted for in the final analysis of cross sections with the help of simulations . .
the scattering angle of both detected particles is fixed to be @xmath48 and the difference between the azimuthal angles of the two detected particles is @xmath47 . ] the next step in the event selection for the three - body break - up channel is to find the energy correlation between the final - state protons and deuterons for a particular kinematical configuration ( @xmath50 ) .
the number of break - up events in an interval @xmath51 , and @xmath52 was obtained by projecting the events on a line perpendicular to the @xmath26-curve ( @xmath32-axis ) .
the value of @xmath53 was @xmath54 mev for the forward wall data .
-bin onto the @xmath32-axis is shown in the inset . ]
figure [ 25 - 25 - 180 ] depicts the correlation between the energy of protons and deuterons in coincidence for the kinematical configuration , ( @xmath55 . the solid curve is the expected correlation for this configuration .
one of the many @xmath26-intervals and the corresponding @xmath32-axis are also shown .
the result of the projection of events on the @xmath32-axis for a particular @xmath26-bin is presented in the inset of fig . [ 25 - 25 - 180 ] .
this spectrum consists of mainly break - up events with a negligible amount of accidental background .
most of the particles of the break - up events deposit all their energy in the scintillator , which gives rise to a peak around zero in the variable @xmath32 .
the events on the left - hand side of the peak at zero correspond to break - up events that undergo a hadronic interaction in the scintillator ( same as those on the right side of the peak in fig . [ missmass ] ) .
the interaction of a polarized beam with an unpolarized target produces an azimuthal asymmetry or an azimuthally uniform change in the scattering cross section .
the magnitude of this effect is proportional to the product of the polarization of the beam and an observable that is called the analyzing power .
the expression for the cross section of any reaction induced by a polarized spin-1 projectile is @xcite : @xmath56 where @xmath18 and @xmath57 are the polarized and unpolarized cross sections , respectively , and @xmath58 represents the configuration @xmath59 . note that eq .
[ ddbreakcrosfurmola ] does not contain terms with @xmath60 , @xmath61 , @xmath62 , @xmath63 and @xmath64 .
these contributions vanish because we took explicitly @xmath65 and @xmath29 is the absolute value of the difference between the azimuthal angles of the two outgoing particles .
the angle @xmath66 is the angle between the polarization axis and the momentum of the incoming beam . in this work , the variables @xmath67 , @xmath68 and @xmath69 will be referred to as @xmath70 , @xmath23 and @xmath71 , respectively .
the quantities @xmath70 and @xmath72 are the vector - analyzing power and the vector beam polarization , respectively .
the observables @xmath23 and @xmath71 are the tensor - analyzing powers , @xmath73 is the tensor polarization of the beam , and @xmath15 is the azimuthal scattering angle of the deuteron .
mev ) . ] for a deuteron beam with a pure vector polarization , the ratio @xmath74 should show a @xmath75 distribution where @xmath18 and @xmath57 are the polarized and unpolarized cross sections , respectively .
when a pure tensor - polarized deuteron beam is used , the ratio @xmath76 should show a @xmath77 distribution .
these asymmetries are exploited to extract the vector - analyzing power , @xmath70 and the tensor - analyzing powers , @xmath23 and @xmath71 , for every kinematical configuration , @xmath78 .
for a measurement of the analyzing powers , we compare the distribution of the scattered particles at different azimuthal angles for each polarization state with that obtained with the unpolarized beam . the @xmath15-distribution obtained with the polarized beam is normalized to that obtained with an unpolarized beam to obtain the ratio @xmath74 .
this ratio depends on the the number of counts under the peak after background subtraction and the total integrated charge collected in the faraday cup . with this normalization
other parameters like the geometrical asymmetries , inefficiencies , and target thickness are eliminated .
figure [ ddbasy ] shows the ratio @xmath76 for a pure vector - polarized deuteron beam ( top panel ) and a pure tensor - polarized deuteron beam ( bottom panel ) for ( @xmath79 , @xmath80 , @xmath81 , @xmath82 mev ) .
the curves in the top and bottom panels are the results of a fit based on eq .
[ ddbreakcrosfurmola ] through the obtained asymmetry distribution for a beam with a pure vector and tensor polarization , respectively .
the amplitude of the @xmath83 modulation in the top panel equals to @xmath84 and that of the @xmath85 modulation in the lower panel equals to @xmath86 .
the offset from 1 in the lower panel is @xmath87 .
the vector- and tensor - analyzing powers for a few kinematical configurations of the three - body break - up reaction were extracted .
figure [ dd1 ] represents the vector- and tensor - analyzing powers at @xmath88 ( open squares ) and @xmath89 ( filled circles ) as a function of @xmath26 for different azimuthal opening angles .
the gray lines in all panels show the zero level of the analyzing powers .
only statistical uncertainties are indicated . the total systematic uncertainty for the analyzing power is estimated to be @xmath90 which mainly stems from the uncertainty in the measurement of the beam polarization via elastic scattering and to a much lesser extent from the error of the beam - current correction in the analysis of the t20 in the elastic d + d channel .
this paper demonstrates for the first time the feasibility of obtaining precision data of the three - body break - up channel in deuteron - deuteron scattering at the energy of 65 mev / nucleon .
the three - body break - up reaction has been clearly identified using the measured scattering angles , energies , and tof of the final - state protons and deuterons . in this work
, we analyzed a part of the data in which the protons and deuterons were scattered into the forward wall of bina .
we have provided precision data for the vector and tensor analyzing powers of the three - body break - up reaction for an incident deuteron beam of 65 mev / nucleon @xcite .
these four - body scattering experiments at kvi will provide in the near future a complete database in deuteron - deuteron scattering at intermediate energies including the elastic , transfer , three - body break - up , and four - body break - up channels .
together with the upcoming state - of - the - art ab - initio calculations @xcite , these data will provide the basis to understand the mechanisms behind many - body force effects .
the authors acknowledge the work by the cyclotron and ion - source groups at kvi for delivering a high - quality beam used in these measurements .
this work was performed as part of the research program of the `` stichting voor fundamenteel onderzoek der materie '' ( fom ) .
furthermore , the present work has been performed with financial support from the university of groningen ( rug ) , the helmholtzzentrum fr schwerionenforschung gmbh ( gsi ) , darmstadt , the nederlandse organisatie voor wetenschappelijk onderzoek ( nwo ) , the polish 2008 - 2011 science founds as a research project no .
n n202 078135 and iran ministry of science , research , and technology , kashan university .
cdb and ejs acknowledge support from the us national science foundation through grant phy 04 - 57219 .
9 h. yukawa , proc .
* 17 * , 48 ( 1935 ) .
l. d. faddeev , sov .
* 12 * , 1014 ( 1961 ) .
w. glckle , h. witaa , d. hber , h. kamada and j. golak , physics reports * 274 * , 107 ( 1996 ) .
r. b. wiringa , a. r. smith , and t. l. ainsworth , phys .
* 29 * , 1207 ( 1984 ) .
h. primakoff , and t. holstein , phys . rev .
* 55 * , 1218 ( 1939 ) .
h. witaa , w. glckle , d. hber , j. golak and h. kamada phys .
* 81 * , 1183 ( 1998 ) .
h. shimizu _ et al .
a * 382 * , 242 ( 1982 ) .
h. sakai _ et al .
84 * , 5288 ( 2000 ) .
k. ermisch _ et al .
86 * , 5862 ( 2001 ) .
k. ermisch _ et al .
c * 68 * , 051001 ( 2003 ) .
h. hatanaka _ et al .
j. a * 18 * , 293 ( 2003 ) .
e. stephan _ et al .
c * 76 * , 057001 ( 2005 ) .
k. ermisch _ et al .
c * 71 * , 064004 ( 2005 ) .
k. sekiguchi _ et al .
* 95 * , 162301 ( 2005 ) .
h. mardanpour _ et al .
j. a * 31 * , 383 ( 2007 ) .
a. ramazani - moghaddam - arani _ et al .
_ , few - body system * 44 * , 27 ( 2008 ) .
a. ramazani - moghaddam - arani _ et al .
c * 78 * , 014006 ( 2008 ) .
h. witaa , t. gornelius and w. glckle , few - body system * 15 * , 67 ( 1993 ) .
e. j. stephenson , h. witaa , w. glckle , h. kamada , and a. nogga phys .
c * 60 * , 061001(r ) ( 1999 ) .
j. g. messchendorp _ et al .
b * 481 * , 171 ( 2000 ) .
r. bieber _ et al .
lett . * 84 * , 606 ( 2000 ) .
r. v. cadman _ et al .
lett . * 86 * , 967 ( 2001 ) .
j. kuro - onierczuk , _ et al .
c * 66 * , 024003 ( 2002 ) .
k. sekiguchi _ et al .
c * 65 * , 034003 ( 2002 ) .
k. hatanaka _ et al .
c * 66 * , 044002 ( 2003 )
. h. o. meyer _ et al .
lett . * 93 * , 112502 ( 2004 ) .
k. sekiguchi _ et al .
c * 70 * , 014001 ( 2004 ) .
mehmandoost - khajeh - dad _ et al .
b * 617 * , 18 ( 2005 ) .
b. v. przewoski _ et al .
c * 74 * , 064003 ( 2006 ) .
s. kistryn _ et al .
b * 641 * , 23 ( 2006 ) .
a. biegun _ et al .
_ , acta phys . pol .
b * 371 * , 213 ( 2006 ) .
h. amir - ahmadi _ et al .
c * 75 * , 041001 ( 2007 ) .
e. stephan _ et al .
c * 76 * , 057001 ( 2007 ) .
h. mardanpour , ph.d .
thesis , university of groningen ( 2008 ) .
s. c. pieper , v. r. pandharipande , r. b. wiringa , and j. carlson , phys .
c * 64 * , 014001 ( 2001 ) .
r. b. wiringa , v. g. j. stoks , and r. schiavilla , phys .
c * 51 * , 38 ( 1995 ) .
b. s. pudliner , v. r. pandharipande , j. carlson , and r. b.wiringa , phys .
lett * 74 * , 4396 ( 1995 ) .
v. bechtold , l. friedrich , m. s. abdel - wahab , j. bialy , m. junge , and f. k. schmidt , nucl .
phys . a * 288 * , 189 ( 1977 ) . c. alderliesten , a. djaloeis , j. bojowald , c. mayer - bricke , g. paic , and t. sawada , phys .
c * 18 * , 2001 ( 1978 ) .
f. ciesielski and j. carbonell and c. gignoux , phys .
b * 447 * , 199 ( 1999 ) .
a. c. fonseca , phys .
lett * 83 * , 4021 ( 1999 ) .
m. viviani , a. kievsky , s. rosati , e. a. george , and l. d. knutson , phys .
lett * 86 * , 3739 ( 2001 ) .
r. lazauskas , j. carbonell , a. c. fonseca , m. viviani , a. kievsky , and s. rosati , phys .
c * 71 * , 034004 ( 2005 ) .
n. kalantar - nayestanaki , j. mulder and j. zijlstra , nucl .
instr . and meth . in phys .
res . a * 417 * , 215 ( 1998 ) .
h. r. kremers , j.p.m .
beijers , n. kalantar - nayestanaki , and t.b .
clegg , nucl .
instr . and meth .
a * 516 * , 209 ( 2004 ) .
g. g. ohlsen , rep .
phys . * 35 * , 717 ( 1972 ) .
g. g. ohlsen , nucl .
179 * , 283 ( 1981 ) .
a. deltuva , and a. c. fonseca , phys .
c * 76 * , 021001(r ) ( 2007 ) .
a. deltuva , and a. c. fonseca , phys .
c * 75 * , 014005 ( 2007 ) .
a. deltuva , private communication . | in an experiment with a 65 mev / nucleon polarized deuteron beam on a liquid - deuterium target at kvi , several multi - body final states in deuteron - deuteron scattering were identified . for these measurements , a unique and advanced detection system , called bina ,
was utilized .
we demonstrate the feasibility of measuring vector and tensor polarization observables of the deuteron break - up reaction leading to a three - body final - state .
the polarization observables were determined with high precision in a nearly background - free experiment . the analysis procedure and some results are presented . |
the structure of quantum chromodynamic ( qcd ) matter at very high temperatures [ much higher than the critical temperature ( @xmath0 ) , which characterizes the hadron - quark deconfinement phase - transition ] is well understood by perturbation theory , for instance . but the entire quark - hadron phase structure still represents a great challenge to lattice qcd and particle scientists . on one hand , it is difficult to draw predictions for the properties of qcd matter , especially the partonic matter , at arbitrary finite temperatures and chemical potentials .
the reason is that qcd under extreme conditions of temperatures and densities remains strongly coupled . on the other hand , non - perturbative approaches , such as lattice qcd simulations , the only available first - principles calculation - tools ,
turn to be very reliable , especially at vanishing chemical potential .
this predicts that the crossover to the quark - gluon plasma ( qgp ) occurs at @xmath1 and might be tolerated to be implemented at finite chemical potentials but much less than the temperatures .
however , this approach ca nt be used at higher chemical potentials and lower temperatures which characterize the color - superconducting phase structure , for instance .
alternatively , the models that incorporate some of qcd properties are easier to be implemented in order to draw even a rough picture about the quark - hadron phase structure that might occur at almost arbitrary finite temperature and chemical potential .
nambu - jona - lasinio models @xcite , which exclude the gluonic degrees of freedom and replace the strong interaction by four - fermion interaction , are widely - used effective models .
another approach is the ( non)linear - sigma model , which was introduced by gell - mann and levy @xcite as a lagrangian theory of maps . in this qcd - like model ,
the spinless sigma meson , the scalar which was introduced earlier by schwinger , largely gives the degrees of freedom and is allowed to be mapped to a ( non)linear manifold called the target manifold .
this model is a prototype of spontaneous symmetry breaking and describes the quarks interaction through the exchange of pion- and sigma - meson fields .
the present paper is devoted to the utilization of mean field approximation of su(@xmath2 ) polyakov linear - sigma model ( plsm ) in order to characterize the quark - hadron phase structure by calculating the chiral order - parameter ( @xmath3 ) , and the light and strange quarks net - condensate ( @xmath4 ) at finite temperature and vanishing chemical potential . due to oppositely flying of charges approaching relativistic energy limits especially in off - central collisions of heavy ions , a huge magnetic field can be created in heavy - ion collision ( hic ) experiments .
because of the very short spending ( life - time ) of the evolution of such magnetic field , it is assumed to have almost no effect on the detector and its external magnet but remarkable influences on the strongly interacting qcd matter .
in addition to hot and dense qcd matter , the influence of a strong magnetic field ( @xmath5 ) on the structure of qcd matter is also a very interesting subject .
this kind of investigation has realistic relevance to phenomenology of relativistic heavy - ion collisions in which a strong magnetic field is produced in non - central collisions @xcite .
moreover , the expected values of the magnetic field strengths in the different hic experiments such as superproton synchrotron ( sps ) , relativistic heavy - ion collider ( rhic ) and large hadron collider ( lhc ) ranges between @xmath6 to @xmath7 and @xmath8 , respectively @xcite , where @xmath9 gauss . concerning the phenomenologically interesting consequence from the magnetic field effect on the qcd matter , there have been many investigations . the large hadron collider ( lhc ) , at cern ,
provides a possible signature of the cp violation and chiral symmetry restoration @xcite .
the qcd vacuum properties have been also studied by means of the holographic qcd models @xcite , chiral magnetic effect ( cme ) @xcite .
the presence of a magnetic field have been investigated previously within different frameworks , mainly using effective models @xcite , especially the njl model @xcite , plsm @xcite and chiral perturbation theory ( @xmath10pt ) @xcite .
recently , various qcd - like models have been devoted to study the influences of finite magnetic field on the strongly interacting qcd matter at finite temperature @xcite .
these can be compared with the studies on vanishing magnetic filed @xcite .
many of these studies have investigated the quark - hadron phase - transition in thermal and dense medium , which are conjectured to improve the description of the qcd phase - diagram . following this procedure ,
we perform our calculations for the quark - hadron phase - structure and qcd equation of state ( eos ) from plsm . furthermore
, we compare our results with the available recent lattice qcd calculations in zero @xcite and in nonzero magnetic field @xcite .
the su(@xmath2 ) plsm is utilized to characterize the respective influences of the magnetic field on the quark - hadron phase - transition in a wide range of temperatures .
prior to confronting our results to lattice qcd , we show that the order parameters have a reasonable agreement with the lattice simulations .
we also confront the various thermodynamic quantities to different lattice qcd calculations .
the characterization of the hadronic equation of state has been discussed in ref .
it was concluded that the characteristics of the speed of sound squared @xmath11 and @xmath12 ratio .
both are distinguishable below and above @xmath0 .
below @xmath0 , the thermal behavior of the speed of sound squared matches the @xmath12 ratio . above @xmath0 ,
the value of @xmath13 becomes larger than that of @xmath12 . at very high temperatures ,
both quantities get very close to each other and likely approach the asymptotic value , i.e. , @xmath14 @xcite . applying finite magnetic field on qcd matter
allows the description of important phenomenon such as the chiral magnetic effect ( cme ) and the magnetic catalysis @xcite .
cme is strongly related to the electric charge separation phenomenon that probably become measurable in hic experiments such as phenix @xcite and star @xcite at rhic and alice at lhc @xcite .
the magnetic catalysis characterizes the dependence of @xmath0 on the magnetic field strength .
the present paper is organised as follows . in section [ sec :
model ] , su(@xmath2 ) plsm in thermal and dense medium with and without magnetic field shall be introduced .
the comparison of plsm order parameters with the lattice qcd calculations shall be discussed in section [ structure ] .
the results of various thermodynamic quantities in zero and nonzero magnetic field shall be elaborated in section [ thermo ] .
section [ conclusion ] is devoted to the final conclusions .
the linear - sigma model is a widely acceptable approach for the investigation of meson states @xcite .
the chiral su(@xmath2 ) lsm lagrangian with @xmath15 consists of two parts ; @xmath16 . *
the first term expresses the quark contributions , eq .
( [ lfermion ] ) , which are coupled with a flavor - blind yukawa coupling @xmath17 @xcite , i.e. , quarks couple to mesons , @xmath18 ^ 2 -\lambda_2 \mathrm{tr}(\phi^{\dag } \phi)^2+c[\mathrm{det}(\phi)+\mathrm{det}(\phi^{\dag } ) ] + \mathrm{tr}[h(\phi+\phi^{\dag } ) ] , \label{lmeson}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath19 is @xmath20 matrix includes the nonet meson states as & = & _ a=0^n_f^2 - 1 t_a ( _ a -i _ a ) .
the number of generators ( @xmath21 ) is defined according to the number of quark flavors ( @xmath22 ) . at @xmath23 ,
the chiral lagrangian contains unitary matrices with su@xmath24su@xmath25 symmetry @xcite . in u@xmath26 algebra
, @xmath21 is determined by gell - mann matrices @xmath27 @xcite ; @xmath28 with @xmath29 .
lsm can be coupled to polyakov - loop potential in order to incorporate deconfinement phase - transition in the qcd system by adding color - gluon interaction such that @xmath30 .
thus , the added polyakov - loop potential should be fine - tuned through confrontation with lattice qcd simulations .
furthermore , it should have @xmath31 symmetry @xcite .
for example in pure gauge limit , a temperature - dependent potential can be used ; @xmath32 .
its @xmath31 center symmetry should be similar to that of the pure gauge qcd lagrangian @xcite .
the trace of color space of polyakov loop determines the creation operator of a static quark at the spatial position @xmath33 .
the color charges and gluons dynamics can then be given in dependence on the thermal expectation value of a color - traced wilson - loop in the temporal direction @xcite , = _ c ( ) /n_c , & & ^ * = _ c ^()/n_c .
[ phis ] then , the polyakov loop operator becomes identical to the wegner - wilson loop @xcite , @xmath34 } , \label{loop}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath35 is the temporal component of the euclidean gauge field @xmath36 @xcite and @xmath37 denotes the euclidean time component .
it was found that enlarging @xmath38 decreases the critical temperature of the deconfinement phase - transition @xcite .
thus , the polyakov loops @xmath39 and @xmath40 can be considered as order parameters for the deconfinement phase - transition @xcite .
there are different potential types for the polyakov loop @xcite . in the present work ,
we implement the polynomial form , @xmath41 where @xmath42 . with the parameters @xmath43 , @xmath44 , @xmath45 , @xmath46 , @xmath47 and @xmath48 @xcite ,
the pure gauge qcd thermodynamics is well reproduced . for a better agreement with lattice qcd simulations ,
the critical temperature @xmath49 is fixed at @xmath50mev for @xmath15 @xcite .
the possible differences in the critical temperatures ; @xmath51mev in the pnjl model and @xmath52mev in the plsm can be understood due to the introduction of quarks which leads to decreasing the deconfinement temperature in the pure gauge limit . in both models
the polyakov potential @xmath53 should be the same .
.summary of plsm s parameters .
a detailed description is given in ref .
@xcite [ tab:1a ] [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the lattice qcd simulations combine both light- and strange - quark condensates @xcite , _
l , s & = & , [ subtracted1 ] where @xmath54 and @xmath55 stand for antiquark - quark condensate and quark mass , respectively , with @xmath56 $ ] .
this quantity reads the ratio of net light- to strange - quark condensates at finite temperature ( @xmath57 ) to the net of light- to strange - quark condensates at @xmath58 @xcite .
it is apparent that the dependence of the quark masses ( @xmath55 ) on the corresponding chiral condensates at vanishing and finite temperature is essential . in the present work ,
we introduce calculations for degenerate light - quarks and heavy strange - quark from su(@xmath2 ) plsm . _
l , s = , [ subtracted2 ] where the flavor masses @xmath59 and @xmath60 are replaced by the explicit breaking strengths @xmath61 and @xmath62 , receptively .
furthermore , the lattice qcd simulations define the chiral order - parameter in terms of the chiral condensate @xcite , m_b & = & .
[ eq : mb ] the left - hand panel of fig .
[ fig : sbtrc1 ] ( a ) presents the subtracted chiral - condensates as a function of temperature at vanishing chemical potential and magnetic field @xmath63 ( solid curves ) and compares the plsm results with various ( @xmath64 ) lattice qcd simulations , in which asqtad @xcite and p4 @xcite improved staggered fermion actions with almost physical strange and light - quark masses and temporal extension @xmath65 are utilized .
the agreement between both sets of calculations is excellent .
the steeper decline in the subtracted chiral - condensate comes from the pure gauge potential in the grand canonical calculations in absence of the gluons interactions .
we observe that @xmath4 possesses a constant finite value at low @xmath57 .
when the temperature approaches about half @xmath0 , @xmath4 begins to decrease with increasing temperature .
this signal indicates the liberation of the quark and gluon degrees of freedom .
the hadron deconfinement and the restoration of broken chiral symmetry are conjectured to take place at @xmath0 .
it is noteworthy emphasizing that the introduction of the polyakov - loop correction improves the calculation of the pure gauge potential through improving the gluon contributions to the interaction .
the latter leads to a smooth chiral - transition or a repaid crossover @xcite .
the right - hand panel of fig .
[ fig : sbtrc1 ] ( b ) shows the temperature dependence of @xmath3 .
as introduced , @xmath3 , eq . ( [ eq : mb ] ) , combines the mass of strange quark ( @xmath60 ) with the light - quark condensate ( @xmath66 ) normalized to @xmath67 .
the plsm calculations are compared with hisq / tree lattice qcd with @xmath65 and two values for the quark masses , @xmath68 ( close circle ) and @xmath69 ( close square ) @xcite .
the agreement between the two sets of calculations is convincing , especially in vanishing magnetic field ( solid curve ) and in the crossover region , in which the rapid decline in @xmath3 indicates a smooth phase - transition from finite to vanishing @xmath3 .
the thermodynamic observables can be deduced from the total free energy , eq .
( [ potential ] ) .
for instance , the pressure at finite @xmath57 and @xmath70 but vanishing @xmath71 defines the free energy of the system of interest p(t , eb)=-(t , e b ) .
the free - energy density @xmath72 at @xmath73 can be given as f =- t s , where @xmath74 and @xmath75 being energy density and entropy density , respectively .
at finite magnetic field @xmath76 directed along the @xmath77-axis , the free energy density reads @xcite & = & ^ - ^ - t s = ^ - t s - e b , [ totalfree ] where @xmath78 is the total energy density consisting of energy density ( @xmath74 ) characterizes the system of interest and @xmath79 stemming from the influence of the magnetic field and @xmath80 is the magnetization .
the magnetic field @xmath70 is given in the units of the elementary charge @xmath81 .
we recall that in vanishing magnetic field , the partition function is given by an integral over the six - dimensional phase - space and integral over the dispersion relations . in this case
, the energy - momentum dispersion relation , @xmath82 , follows the lorentz invariance principle , but in finite magnetic field , the integral is dimensionality reduced and simultaneously accompanied by a considerable modification in the dispersion relations , themselves . at finite magnetic field @xmath5 , the velocity of a test particle with momentum @xmath83 can be deduced from the dispersion relations , v_p_z & = & c .
the lorentz invariance principle can be tested through the velocity of a test particle with momentum @xmath84 .
the causality is apparently guaranteed as @xmath85 does not exceed the speed of light ( @xmath86 ) , i.e. , as long as as the @xmath5-term is finite positive , which should be estimated , quantitatively , as a function of temperature and magnetic field strength .
( [ totalfree ] ) , the entropy density and the magnetization can be obtained as s & = & - , [ eq : entropy ] + & = & - .
[ eq : magnet ] the corresponding differential relation for pressure is to some extent involved . as the magnetic field marks a preferred direction , the pressure @xmath87 might be different along the geometrical effect of the magnetic field . the magnetic field is directed along the @xmath77-direction .
the volume of the system reads as @xmath88 .
thus , lattice qcd simulations distinguish between two different systems : * b - scheme : the magnetic field is kept fixed in all direction leading to an isotropic pressure p_x = p_y = p_z = - * @xmath19-scheme : the magnetic flux ( @xmath89 ) is kept fixed leading to an anisotropic pressure p_x = p_y = p_z - eb accordingly , the thermodynamic quantities should be corrected .
for instance , the trace anomaly ( interaction measure ) in @xmath19-scheme becomes i & = & - 3p_z + 2 eb .
[ interactionmeasure ] the speed of sound squared ( @xmath90 ) is an essential thermodynamic quantity to be estimated .
it determines the equation of state @xmath91 @xcite , where at a constant entropy it reads c_s^2 & = & ( ) _ s =/ = .
[ eq : cs2 ] the specific heat ( @xmath92 ) gives the thermal rate change of the energy density at a constant volume .
the stefan - boltzmann ( sb ) limits can be deduced from the lowest - order perturbation theory . for massless quarks and gluons @xcite @xmath93 where @xmath94 and @xmath95 are the degrees of freedom of quarks and gluons , respectively . in finite magnetic field ( @xmath70 ) @xcite t
( v , t , , eb ) = t^4 + b_1^ ( eb)^2 v ( ) + , where @xmath96 is a parameter to be fixed by leading - order perturbation theory and @xmath97gev is a renormalization scale @xcite .
the latter appears in the perturbation terms , exclusively .
the present work illustrates the capability of plsm in reproducing recent lattice qcd calculations , which can be characterized as follows . * in finite magnetic field , the equation of state from ( @xmath64 ) lattice qcd calculations with physical quark masses has been determined @xcite , as given in right - hand panel of figs .
[ trace ] , [ fig : cs2 ] , [ fig : scv ] and fig .
[ fig : magn_tceb ] .
the equation of state is sensitive to the change in the control parameters of the system .
these parameters include temperature , chemical potentials corresponding to the various conserved charges and , as in the present work , the presence of magnetic field along longitudinal direction @xmath98 . the lattice calculations use tree - level improved symanzik gauge action , and stout improved staggered quarks in the fermionic sector , fixed ratio of light- and strange - quark masses , @xmath99 and lattice size @xmath100 .
* the lattice qcd results presented in the left - hand panel of figs .
[ trace ] , [ fig : cs2 ] , [ fig : scv ] and [ fig : cv ] ( open circle ) are hotqcd simulations with @xmath64 flavor at finite temperature @xcite .
they are reliably extrapolated to the continuum limit .
various thermodynamic quantities are deduced as functions of temperature at vanishing chemical potential .
their reliable continuum extrapolated results on the equation of state have been performed with stout - smeared staggered action @xcite . at high temperature , this action effectively reduces taste symmetry violation effects , which remain large for @xmath101 cutoff , where @xmath102 is the lattice spacing @xcite .
the current continuum extrapolated results @xcite are obtained with the hisq action .
they show an excellent agreement with the stout action @xcite .
the light - quark mass is fixed as a fraction of the strange - quark mass @xmath103 .
the results are obtained at lattice size @xmath104 , where @xmath105 is temporal extent and @xmath106 is the spatial dimension .
it is apparent that the lattice qcd simulations at nonzero magnetic field @xmath107 @xcite give smaller quantities than that estimated in absence of the magnetic field @xcite . in nonzero magnetic field
, the system undergoes modifications due the presence of finite magnetization in the region of crossover region , where the magnetic field contribution to the suppression in the chiral condensate become large .
to express the free energy as an integral over the longitudinal momentum , which is directed towards @xmath77-axis , i.e. , @xmath108 , and a summation over the _ quantized _ landau levels , both should be performed numerically corresponding to eqs .
( [ ploykovplsmeb ] ) and ( [ potential ] ) . due to the occupation of the landau levels
, the thermal free - energy can be suppressed as the magnetic field grows @xcite . in the present work ,
we aim to reproduce the recent lattice qcd calculations from plsm . in doing this
, we assume that the quark - hadron coupling constant @xmath109 and the polyakov loop _ deconfinement _ temperatures ,
@xmath110mev in vanishing and finite magnetic field , respectively . the normalized trace anomaly , which can be derived , directly , from the trace of the energy - momentum tensor , @xmath111 , where @xmath112 being energy density ( pressure ) , determines the degrees of freedom and helps in deducing further thermodynamic quantities such as energy density , pressure , and entropy density of the system of interest . in qcd
, the trance anomaly can be related to the strong coupling constant , @xmath113 @xcite .
this quantity vanishes in scale invariant theory such as massless , collisionfree gas of quarks and gluons .
for a correlated gas ( nonvanishing interactions ) , the qcd scale parameter remains finite .
the qcd asymptotic freedom implies that the strength of the interaction weakens with the temperature [ far above the critical temperature ( @xmath0 ) ] . at temperatures smaller than @xmath0 ,
the trace anomaly increases with the temperature because more massive hadrons become relevant . in fig .
[ trace ] , the temperature dependence of the normalized trace - anomaly calculated from plsm at vanishing [ left - hand panel ( a ) ] and nonzero magnetic field [ right - hand panel ( b ) ] . in left - hand panel ( a ) , the trace anomaly normalized to @xmath67 in given in comparison with lattice qcd calculations extrapolated to continuum limit @xcite .
there is a well agreement with the lattice qcd simulations , especially in the hadronic phase .
this is also obvious near the phase transition region . at higher temperatures ,
a repaid decrease occurs in the interaction measurement .
it is faster than in the lattice qcd simulations . in right - hand panel of fig .
[ trace ] ( b ) , the modified , normalized trace anomaly , eq .
( [ interactionmeasure ] ) , is depicted as a function of temperature .
the thermodynamic modifications due to the presence of finite magnetization have been discussed in the previous section .
our plsm calculations are also given at different values of magnetic field strengths , @xmath114 ( dotted curve ) , @xmath115 ( dotted - dash curve ) and @xmath116gev@xmath117 ( double - dotted curve ) and compared with recent lattice qcd @xcite ( close square ) , ( open square ) and ( open triangle ) , respectively .
as discussed in the previous section , the thermodynamic quantities , which are derived from the free energy , are accordingly modified , especially due to the presence of finite magnetization .
the latter measures the response of the system of interest to applying finite magnetic field .
in finite magnetic field , the free energy from plsm is calculated as an integral over the longitudinal momentum along the direction of magnetic field @xmath108 and a summation over the _ quantized _ landau levels .
adding finite magnetization for the free energy affects various thermodynamic quantities .
furthermore , due to the occupation of the landau levels , the thermal free energy suffers from an additional suppression with increasing magnetic field .
thus , the total energy - density likely differs from the quantity depicted in the left - hand panel ( a ) . in the hadron phase , the trace anomaly becomes very small at low temperature , but increases with the temperature .
a peak appears at the critical temperature .
a further increase in the temperature decreases the trace anomaly , i.e. , derives the system strongly into the deconfined status .
the trace anomaly signals breaking of the scale invariance in the system of interest .
its peak around @xmath0 is conjectured to signal anomalous thermodynamic properties , for example , the bulk viscosity , which measures how easy or difficult for the system to relax back to equilibrium after going through scale transformation .
this would mean that the peak of the trace anomaly refers to maximum bulk viscosity , that is likely when the breaking of scale invariance becomes maximum .
analogy to the hydrodynamical approaches , which have been applied on the relativistic heavy - ion collisions and led to the rhic discovery of the new state of qcd matter @xcite , the speed of sound squared ( @xmath90 ) plays an essential role in estimating the equation of state @xmath118 . as discussed in ref .
@xcite , the definition of @xmath90 as in eq .
( [ eq : cs2 ] ) means that the energy fluctuations and other collective phenomena associated with the specific heat are not taken into account .
the speed of sound squared is related to the trace anomaly ( @xmath119 ) , where the conformal measure is given as & = & = 1 - 3 c_s^2 , which becomes maximum around the region of the phase transition , in which the speed of sound squared becomes small . at high temperatures , the speed of sound squared reaches the stefan - boltzmann ( sb ) limit of @xmath14 . in this limit , the conformal measure obviously vanishes . in left - hand panel of fig .
[ fig : cs2 ] ( a ) , the temperature dependence of the speed of sound squared calculated from the ratio @xmath120 and @xmath12 are compared with recent lattice qcd calculations with continuum extrapolation @xcite .
the right - hand panel ( b ) illustrates the ratio @xmath12 as a function of temperature and compares the plsm calculations with the recent lattice qcd in finite magnetic field @xcite .
left - hand panel of fig .
[ fig : cs2 ] ( a ) shows plsm results on @xmath12 ( dashed curve ) and on @xmath120 ( solid curve ) and compares them with lattice qcd calculations extrapolated to the continuum limits @xcite .
the lattice qcd results on both @xmath90 , ( open circles ) and @xmath12(open tingles ) are extrapolated to the continuum limits .
both quantities @xmath12 and @xmath120 are apparently confirmed from in the continuum extrapolation of lattice qcd @xcite . above @xmath0
, plsm seems to overestimate @xmath120 . at lower temperature , the opposite temperature - dependence is observed .
it is apparent that @xmath90 ( solid curve ) matches @xmath12 ( dashed curve ) .
the plsm and lattice qcd calculations confirm that there is a difference between @xmath90 , ( open circles ) @xmath12 ( open tingles ) .
the agreement is improved in the hadron phase but becomes poor in high temperature . in high - temperature region
, plsm overestimates the lattice calculations .
it is worthwhile to highlight that the temperature dependence of @xmath90 seems to be sensitive to the normalization to @xmath0 .
the lattice calculations are given in dependence on @xmath57 , which is normalized to @xmath121mev , while the plsm calculations are normalized to chiral restoration - temperature @xmath122mev .
also , it is obvious that the speed of sound squared @xmath90 approaches the stefan - boltzmann limit , i.e. @xmath14 , at very high temperatures .
the peak , which appears near the critical temperature , is due to the fast rate of the change of energy density with increasing temperature .
furthermore , the right - hand panel of fig .
[ fig : cs2 ] ( b ) presents plsm calculations of @xmath12 at @xmath114 ( dotted curve ) , @xmath115 ( dotted - dash curve ) and @xmath116gev@xmath117 ( double - dotted curve ) and compared to recent lattice qcd @xcite ( close square ) , ( open square ) and ( open triangle ) , respectively .
a good agreement is obtained , especially at low temperature .
it is obvious that the agreement can be improved with increasing the magnetic field strength .
it is noteworthy highlighting that the agreement looks better than that at @xmath73 .
( [ totalfree ] ) expresses the explicit dependence of the free energy - density on the temperature , the chemical potential and the magnetic field strength . per definition , in b - scheme , the background magnetic field directed along @xmath77-axis , the thermal pressure is isotropic .
the entropy can be estimated from eq .
( [ eq : entropy ] ) .
left - hand panel of fig .
[ fig : scv ] ( a ) shows the normalized entropy ( @xmath123 ) in a wide range of temperatures at vanishing chemical potential and vanishing magnetic field .
the temperature dependence continues even above @xmath0 , i.e. , @xmath123 keeps its rise with increasing @xmath124 .
then it becomes slightly higher than lattice results .
the dependence on the magnetic field is presented in the right - hand panel ( b ) .
the temperature dependence of normalized entropy density ( @xmath123 ) [ left - hand panel ( a ) ] is calculated from plsm at vanishing chemical potential and compared with recent lattice qcd simulations which are extrapolated to the continuum limit @xcite , as well as with the lattice qcd with p@xmath125 action and @xmath126 ( open triangles ) @xcite and @xmath127 ( solid circles ) @xcite .
a reasonable agreement with the lattice qcd simulations is obvious and the phase transitions seems to take place , smoothly .
the temperature dependence continues above @xmath0 , i.e. , @xmath123 keeps increasing with increasing @xmath124 until it becomes slightly lower than lattice results . in the previous section ,
we have characterized the temperature dependence of the entropy density in zero and finite magnetic field . besides entropy density the specific heat ( @xmath92 ) can be used in charactering the equation of state , i.e. , speed of sound squared . for a wide range of temperatures and at vanishing chemical potential , plsm calculations on @xmath92 are compared with recent lattice qcd @xcite in the left - hand panel of fig .
[ fig : cv ] ( a ) .
the plsm results indicate a reasonable agreement with the lattice qcd at low and high temperatures .
the peak that appears at @xmath0 can be interpreted from the definition of the specific heat ; @xmath128 .
it is apparent that the peak might be due to the rapid change in the energy density around @xmath0 .
furthermore , the appearance of the peak would be strongly related to the chemical potential . in a previous work
, we have shown that the peak declines with increasing chemical potential @xcite .
the specific heat grows with increasing temperature .
apart from the plsm peak that appears at the transition temperature , the specific heat approaches the corresponding sb - limit at high temperatures .
the deviation sb limits might be due to the differences in the contributing gluon degrees of freedom .
the overall agreement with the lattice qcd @xcite is excellent .
the right - hand panel ( b ) presents normalized specific heat as derived from modified free - energy , eq .
( [ totalfree ] ) , due to finite magnetization ( @xmath80 ) as a function of temperature at vanishing chemical potential and different magnetic field strengths , @xmath63 ( solid curve ) , @xmath114 ( dotted curve ) and @xmath116gev@xmath117 ( double - dotted curve ) .
unfortunately , no lattice qcd calculations exist to compare our plsm results with .
we notice that the deviation from sb - limit is relatively large .
as introduced in section [ thermo ] , the magnetization largely affects the thermodynamic properties of strongly interacting qcd matter .
the magnetization refers to the response of the system of interest on the applied magnetic field , which is very likely in hic . because of the relativistic , off - center motion of the spectators in peripheral collisions ( motion of electric charge generates magnetic field perpendicular to plane of both motion direction and electric field ) and because of local imbalance in the momenta that are carried by the colliding nucleons in peripheral and even central collisions ( such local imbalance leads to angular momentum and thus magnetic field ) @xcite .
such magnetic field can be very huge , @xmath129 , i.e. very much larger than the detector magnet field .
the magnetization ( @xmath80 ) can be derived from eq .
( [ eq : magnet ] ) in gev@xmath117 natural units .
the sign of magnetization signals an important magnetic property of the system of interest . in our case ,
the qcd matter is _
para_- or _
dia_-magnetic if @xmath130 or @xmath131 , respectively .
furthermore , from solid state physics , we borrow that * in _
dia_-magnetic qcd matter , the thermal qcd medium aligns oppositely to the direction of the magnetic field and produces an induced electric current , which spreads as small loops attempting to cancel the effects of the applied magnetic field , and * in _
para_-magnetic qcd matter , the thermal qcd medium aligns towards the direction of the magnetic field . in middle panel of fig .
[ fig : magn_tceb ] ( b ) , the magnetization @xmath80 is given as a function of temperatures at @xmath132 ( dotted ) , @xmath133 ( dashed ) , @xmath134 ( double - dotted ) and @xmath135 gev@xmath136 ( dash - dotted curve ) at vanishing chemical potential .
the results are compared with recent lattice qcd @xcite at @xmath114 ( closed square ) , @xmath133 ( open circle ) , @xmath134 ( open triangle ) and @xmath135 gev@xmath136 ( astride ) .
it is apparent that the sign of the magnetization is positive and @xmath130 increases with the magnetic field .
the positive sign of magnetization indicates that the paramagnetic contribution of qcd matter becomes dominant with increasing temperature . within the temperature range characterizing the hadron phase ( below @xmath0 ) , the plsm curve seems to resemble the lattice data in an excellent way . at temperatures characterizing qgp ( above @xmath0 ) ,
the plsm curve becomes larger than the lattice data , especially at very high temperatures . in this range of temperatures ,
the hadrons are conjectured to deconfine into color , quark and gluon degrees of freedom .
it seems that these degrees of freedom are not sufficient enough to achieve a good agreement at very high temperature .
furthermore , plsm has a temperature - limited applicability depending on the temperature - applicability of its order parameters , section [ sec : model ] . only within this limit the capability of plsm to characterize the magnetic properties of hot qcd matter
is guaranteed . in additional to the modifications in the thermodynamic quantities due to the finite magnetic field , which are mainly determined by the magnetization ( @xmath80 )
, it intends now to characterize the magnetic catalysis . as in quantum electrodynamic ( qed ) , the magnetic catalysis describes how the magnetic field dynamically generates masses .
furthermore , the meissner effect describes how the magnetic field changes the order of the phase transition in type - i superconductor .
these two phenomena are borrowed to study the possible influence of finite magnetic field on the qcd phase - space structure @xcite and/or the response of hadronic and partonic matter to nonzero magnetic field in thermal and dense medium @xcite .
the inclusion of finite magnetic field in the qcd - effective models is achieved through modification in the phase space , energy - momentum dispersion relations and landau levels occupations .
various works such as @xcite have been devoted to characterize the magnetic catalysis .
accordingly , the critical temperatures increase as the magnetic field increases . on the other hand ,
other works have concluded a decrease in the critical temperature as the magnetic field increases @xcite . in ref .
@xcite , it was argued that the increase in @xmath137 with the magnetic field is possible unless some parameters are fine - tuned and the coupling constant is assumed to vary with the magnetic field , i.e. , @xmath138 .
furthermore , it was remarked that @xmath139 does not enable plsm to reproduce @xmath137 as deduced from lattice qcd calculations , especially in magnetic field strengths @xmath140gev@xmath117 . in the present work ,
it intends to reproduce recent lattice qcd calculations from plsm calculations . in doing this
, we assume that the quark - hadron coupling constant @xmath141 and the polyakov loop deconfinement temperatures @xmath142 and @xmath50mev in vanishing finite magnetic field , respectively .
the main difference between this present work and literature is the outcome from the free energy at finite volume , eq .
( [ potential ] ) .
we find that the free energy at @xmath143 is utilized in eq .
( [ potential ] ) . while at finite values of @xmath5
, @xmath144 becomes active .
the delta function vanishes at all finite values of @xmath5 and vice versa .
accordingly , we dis- or in - clude the last term of eq .
( [ potential ] ) .
we conclude that temperature dependence of the thermodynamic quantities at finite magnetic fields are smaller than those at zero magnetic field .
this means that the results are shifted to lower , e.g. smaller @xmath0 as well , with increasing magnetic field . in this
regards , there are two different mechanisms .
the first one is that the magnetic field improves the phase - transition due to its contributions to the landau quantizations or levels .
the second mechanism assumes that , the magnetic field contributes to the suppression in the chiral condensates relevant to the restoration of the chiral symmetry breaking .
this suppression is known as inverse magnetic catalysis and manifests a decrease in the chiral critical temperature with increasing magnetic field .
the left - hand panel of fig .
[ fig : magn_tceb ] ( a ) illustrates the subtracted chiral - condensates and the deconfinement phase transition at different values of magnetic field @xmath63 ( solid curves ) , @xmath114 ( dotted curves ) , @xmath115 ( dashed curves ) , @xmath145 ( double - dotted curves ) and @xmath146gev@xmath117 ( dotted - dash curves ) . the increase in the magnetic field strength suppresses the chiral condensate relevant to the restoration of the chiral symmetry breaking .
again , the earliness of the chiral - condensate expiration ( suppression ) relative to the temperature points to chiral magnetic catalysis , where the critical temperature ( @xmath0 ) decreases with increasing the magnetic field .
accordingly , we can extract the variation of the critical temperature with raising the magnetic field in right - hand panel ( c ) of fig .
[ fig : magn_tceb ] . the right - hand panel of fig .
[ fig : magn_tceb ] ( c ) shows the variation of the critical temperature with increasing magnetic field at vanishing chemical potential .
the plsm critical temperature is to be estimated from the intersection point ( in temperature axis ) between the subtracted chiral condensate @xmath4 and the deconfinement phase transition .
it is apparent that the critical temperature decreases with the magnetic field .
furthermore , the plsm calculations indicate a good agreement with recent lattice qcd simulation @xcite .
in the present work , we have combined su(@xmath2 ) linear - sigma model with the polyakov - loop corrections in order to address the deconfinement phase - transition and characterize the chiral quark - meson structure .
the plsm calculations indicate that the chiral condensates ( @xmath66 and @xmath147 ) and deconfinement order parameters or polyakov loops ( @xmath39 and @xmath148 ) are relatively sensitive to the magnetic field strength .
the other order parameters of this model such as @xmath3 and subtracted condensate @xmath4 have a much better agreement with the recent lattice qcd simulations . in case of vanishing magnetic field ,
we observe a fair matching with the lattice qcd calculations , especially for the restoration of broken chiral symmetry .
this phase transition is not prompt but rather a _
slow _ crossover .
increasing the magnetic filed strength tends to suppress the chiral phase - transition and decrease the quasi - chiral temperatures .
concretely , we found that the chiral temperatures for light - quark condensate @xmath149 decreases faster than the chiral temperatures for strange - quark condensate @xmath150 .
the plsm in the presence of finite magnetic field assumes some restrictions to be added to the quarks due to the existence of free charges in the plasma phase .
the yukawa coupling of quarks seems to play an essential role in achieving an excellent agreement with recent lattice qcd .
furthermore , the qcd system undergoes modifications due to the presence of finite magnetization .
the free energy is given as an integral over the longitudinal momentum , which is directed towards @xmath77-axis , and then we apply landau theory ( landau quantization ) , which quantizes of the cyclotron orbits of charged particles in magnetic field . accordingly , we find that the value of the chiral condensates is suppressed with increasing the magnetic field . furthermore , in mean field approximation , we have constructed the partition function and then estimated various thermodynamic quantities , such as trace anomaly ( interaction measure ) , speed of sound squared , entropy density , specific heat and the magnetization .
their dependence on temperature highlights the effects of magnetic field on therm in both hadron and parton phases .
we have compared our calculations with recent lattice simulations at vanishing chemical potential and finite magnetic field @xcite .
we conclude that our calculations with a scalar coupling parameter simulate well the lattice qcd calculation in nonzero magnetic field @xcite . at low temperature , a good agreement between plsm and lattice qcd simulations is found . in this temperature limit , the meson fluctuations in the mean field approximation are dominated .
similarly , at high temperature , the gluon dynamics is not fully accomplished by the polyakov - loop corrections .
this explains the discrepancy with the lattice qcd calculations . as concluded from the hadron resonance gas model @xcite
, the quantities @xmath151 and @xmath120 should not be necessarily identical .
the difference between partial and complete differentiation might partly explain this at least from the mathematical point - of - view .
the physical point - of - view proposes that @xmath151 and @xmath120 do not take into consideration the same types of fluctuations . in an intensive study , tawfik _ et al . _
specified that the main differences between @xmath151 and @xmath120 are the energy fluctuations @xcite . in deriving specific heat
, several types of energy density susceptibilities , fluctuations and multiplicities appear @xcite .
a list of such fluctuations are listed in appendix a of ref @xcite .
an evidence supporting this interpretation has been reported , recently @xcite . the most solid support for this study
is offered by the phenomenological lattice qcd calculations @xcite .
accordingly , @xmath151 and @xmath120 differ from each other , especially below and above @xmath0 . at @xmath152
, @xmath153 is larger than @xmath13 , while at @xmath154 , @xmath13 becomes larger than @xmath153 . at @xmath155 ,
both expressions get very close to each other until they approach the asymptotic value , i.e. , @xmath14 .
the lattice simulations do not propose any reason why @xmath151 and @xmath120 should not be identical .
we conclude that increasing the magnetic field strength increases the thermodynamic quantities , especially in the hadron phase . at high temperatures , the plsm thermodynamics
is apparently limited below the stefan - boltzmann limits .
furthermore , we find that the quark - hadron phase boundary is shifted to lower values of temperatures with increasing magnetic field strength . the sign of magnetization signals para- or dia - magnetic property of qcd matter .
the excellent agreement between plsm and recent lattice calculations means that our plsm gives a well - suited description for the degrees of freedom in both hadron and parton phases .
the magnetic field seems to enhance the occurrence of chiral phase - transition due to its contributions to the landau quantizations .
the magnetic field also contributes to the suppression in the chiral condensates relevant to the restoration of the chiral symmetry - breaking .
this suppression is known as the inverse magnetic catalysis and seems to manifest a decrease in the chiral critical temperature with increase magnetic field .
it is noteworthy highlighting that he results estimated from plsm in vanishing and finite magnetic field can be trusted within the limits of the numerical calculations of the plsm order parameters , @xmath156 and @xmath148 in thermal and dense qcd medium . in this regard
, one has to recall that plsm has a temperature - limited applicability depending on the temperature - applicability of its chiral and deconfinement order - parameters . only within this limit the conclusions drawn about the equation of state , the magnetic properties of the qcd matter and the chiral phase - structure , etc
can be relatively certain .
99 y. nambu and g. jona - lasinio , _ `` dynamical model of elementary particles based on an analogy with superconductivity .
i '' _ , phys . rev . *
122 * , 345 ( 1961 ) .
y. nambu and g. jona - lasinio , _ `` dynamical model of elementary particles based on an analogy with superconductivity .
ii '' _ , phys . rev . * 124 * , 246 ( 1961 ) .
m. gell - mann and m. levy , _ `` the axial vector current in beta decay '' _ , il nuovo cimento * 16 * , 705 ( 1960 ) .
a. v. zayakin , jhep * 0807 * , 116 ( 2008 ) ; g. lifschytz and m. lippert , phys . rev .
d * 80 * , 066005 ( 2009 ) ; + g. lifschytz and m. lippert , phys . rev .
d * 80 * , 066007 ( 2009 ) ; + h. u. yee , jhep * 0911 * , 085 ( 2009 ) ; + s. l. cui , y. h. gao , y. seo , s. j. sin and w. s. xu , phys .
d * 81 * , 066001 ( 2010 ) ; + e. dhoker and p. kraus , jhep * 1003 * , 095 ( 2010 ) .
a. tawfik and a. diab , _
polyakov su(3 ) extended linear @xmath157-model : sixteen mesonic states in chiral phase - structure _ , phys . rev .
c * 91 * , 015204 ( 2015 ) .
a. tawfik and n. magdy , _ thermodynamics and higher order moments in su(3 ) linear -model with gluonic quasi - particles _ , j. phys .
g * 42 * , 015004 ( 2015 ) .
m. ruggieri , m. tachibana , and v. greco , jhep * 1307 * , 165 ( 2013 ) .
schaefer and j. wambach , phys .
d * 75 * , 085015 ( 2007 ) .
l. m. haas , r. stiele , j. braun , j. m. pawlowski , and j. schaffner - bielich , phys .
d * 87 * , 076004 ( 2013 ) . c. ratti , _ et al .
d * 73 * , 014019 ( 2005 ) .
s. rossner , c. ratti , and w. weise , phys .
d * 75 * , 034007 ( 2007 ) .
a. bazavov ( hotqcd collaboration ) _
`` chiral transition temperature and aspects of deconfinement in 2 + 1 flavor qcd with the hisq / tree action '' _ * pos lattice2011 * , 182 ( 2011 ) .
a. bazavov _ et .
d * 80 * , 014504 ( 2009 ) .
k. orginos and d. toussaint , phys .
d * 59 * , 014501 ( 1999 ) ; + g.p .
lepage , phys .
d * 59 * , 074502 ( 1999 ) ; + k. orginos , d. toussaint , and r. l. sugar [ milc collaboration ] , phys .
d * 60 * , 054503 ( 1999 ) .
miklos gyulassy and larry mclerran , _
new forms of qcd matter discovered at rhic _ , nucl .
a * 750 * , 30 ( 2005 ) .
a. tawfik , _
`` qcd phase - transition and chemical freezeout in nonzero magnetic field at nica '' _ , an invited contribution to epja topical issue `` nica white paper '' | in characterizing the quark - hadron phase structure , determining various thermodynamic quantities and investigating their temperature dependencies on vanishing and finite magnetic field , su(3 ) polyakov linear - sigma model ( plsm ) is utilized .
the dependence of the chiral order - parameter on vanishing and finite magnetic field is calculated in mean - field approximation . in a wide range of temperatures and magnetic field strengths ,
the thermodynamic observables including trace anomaly , speed of sound squared , entropy density , specific heat and magnetization are presented .
an excellent agreement is found when these are confronted to recent lattice qcd calculations .
the temperature dependence of these quantities confirms our previous result that the transition temperature is reduced with magnetic field .
furthermore , the temperature dependence of magnetization verifies the conclusion that the qcd matter has paramagnetic properties near and far above the critical temperature .
the excellent agreement with recent lattice calculations means that plsm possesses the correct degrees of freedom in both hadronic and partonic phases and describes well dynamics deriving confined hadrons to deconfined quark - gluon plasma .
the magnetic field seems to enhance the occurrence of chiral phase - transition due to its contributions to the landau quantizations and contribute to the suppression in the chiral condensates relevant to the restoration of the chiral symmetry - breaking .
the inverse magnetic catalysis leads to a decrease in the chiral critical temperature with increasing magnetic field .
we remark that plsm has a temperature - limited applicability depending on the temperature - applicability of its chiral and deconfinement order - parameters . only within this limit
the conclusions about equation of state , chiral phase - structure and magnetic properties , etc
. can be relatively certain . |
in recent years , there has been substantial interest in models in condensed matter physics with symmetry groups larger than su(2 ) , the group underlying the usual spin algebra . in particular ,
transition - metal oxides @xcite , where the electron spin is coupled to orbital degrees of freedom , have been described theoretically by models with su(4 ) symmetry @xcite . furthermore , there has been a growing interest in the su(@xmath2 ) generalization of the hubbard model @xcite motivated by possible experimental realizations in systems of ultracold atoms @xcite . in a previous paper @xcite
, we have used the su(@xmath2 ) haldane shastry model to make the case that the elementary excitations of su(@xmath2 ) spin chains transform under the representation _ conjugate _ to the representation of the su(@xmath2 ) spins on the chain , and only exist in one n@xmath3 of the brillouin zone . in this article , we will present for one thing the detailed calculations underlying our line of argumentation in @xcite . to this end , we focus on the su(3 ) haldane shastry model ( hsm ) @xcite , which serves as a paradigm for not only the su(3 ) spin chain , but , as we shall see , also illustrates some very general properties of su(@xmath2 ) chains .
in particular , we derive the quantum numbers of the elementary , fractionally quantized excitations , the analogs of the spinon excitations for su(2 ) , which we call colorons for su(3 ) .
as already mentioned , the key result is that these excitations transform under the su(@xmath2 ) representation conjugate to the representation of the original su(@xmath2 ) spins localized at the sites of the chain . in the case of su(3 ) , if a basis for the original spins is spanned by the colors blue , red , and green , a basis for the coloron excitations is given by the complementary colors yellow , cyan , and magenta ( see fig .
[ fig : reps ] ) .
this result is meaningless for su(2 ) , as the representations of su(2 ) are self - conjugate , but significant in all other instances of fractional quantization in su(@xmath2 ) chains and possible higher dimensional liquids , regardless of model specifics . in our analysis , however , we will primarily focus on the su(3 ) hsm , as this is the simplest model in which this general result can be illustrated through exact calculations , and only afterwards generalize our results to the case of su(@xmath2 ) .
the other significant advancement we report here is the construction of the exact , color - polarized two - coloron eigenstates .
we obtain those through derivation and solution of a sutherland - type equation which is similar to the case of two spinons in the su(2 ) hsm .
our explicit calculation implies that the colorons are , just like the spinons , non - interacting or free , but that the spacings in the difference of the individual coloron momenta @xmath4 and @xmath5 with @xmath6 are given by @xmath7 .
we will argue that this spacing is a direct manifestation of the fractional statistics @xcite of the colorons with statistical exclusion parameter @xmath1 .
this value is consistent with what we find by naive state counting .
we then proceed by calculating the su(3 ) spin currents , the eigenvalues of the diagonal components of the rapidity operator @xmath8 and @xmath9 , for the one- and two - coloron states .
thereafter , we interpret our results within the framework of the asymptotic bethe ansatz .
finally , we generalize some of our conclusions to the case of su(@xmath2 ) .
many details of our calculations have been exported , largely in the form of theorems and their proofs , into an extensive list of appendices .
the su(3 ) @xmath10 or haldane shastry model @xcite is most conveniently formulated by embedding the one - dimensional chain with periodic boundary conditions into the complex plane by mapping it onto the unit circle with the su(3 ) spins located at complex positions @xmath11 , where @xmath12 denotes the number of sites and @xmath13 .
the hamiltonian is given by @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the 8-dimensional su(3 ) spin vector , @xmath16 a vector consisting of the eight gell - mann matrices ( see app . [
app : conventions ] ) , and @xmath17 and @xmath18 are su(3 ) spin or color indices , which take the values blue ( b ) , red ( r ) , or green ( g ) . for all practical purposes ,
it is convenient to express @xmath19 directly in terms of colorflip operators @xmath20 : @xmath21 where the color sum includes terms with @xmath22 . and @xmath0 .
@xmath23 and @xmath24 denote the diagonal generators @xcite.,title="fig : " ] and @xmath0 .
@xmath23 and @xmath24 denote the diagonal generators @xcite.,title="fig : " ] the model is fully integrable even for a finite number of sites ; the algebra of infinitely many conserved quantities is generated by the total su(3 ) spin @xmath25}=0 , \quad{\boldsymbol{j}}=\sum_{\alpha=1}^n { \boldsymbol{j}}_\alpha,\ ] ] and rapidity operators @xmath26}=0,\quad { \lambda}^a=\frac{1}{2}\sum_{\alpha\neq\beta}^n\ , \frac{\eta_\alpha + \eta_\beta}{\eta_\alpha - \eta_\beta}\ , f^{abc}{j}_\alpha^b { j}_\beta^c,\ ] ] where @xmath27 and @xmath28 are the structure constants of su(3 ) defined through @xmath29}=2f^{abc}\lambda^c$ ] .
the total su(3 ) spin and rapidity operators do not commute mutually , @xmath30}=f^{abc}\lambda^c,\ ] ] and generate the infinite dimensional yangian algebra @xmath31 @xcite .
the ground state of @xmath19 for @xmath32 ( @xmath33 integer ) is most easily formulated by gutzwiller projection of a filled band ( or slater determinant ( sd ) state ) containing a total of @xmath12 su(3 ) particles obeying fermi statistics ( see fig . [
fig : sd]a ) @xmath34 the gutzwiller projector @xmath35 with @xmath36 eliminates configurations with more than one particle on any site , and , as the total number of particles equals the total number of sites , thereby effectively enforces single occupancy on all sites . as @xmath37 is an su(3
) singlet by construction and @xmath38 commutes with su(3 ) rotations , @xmath39 is an su(3 ) singlet as well .
if one interprets the state @xmath40 as a reference state and the colorflip operators @xmath41 and @xmath42 as `` particle creation operators '' , the ground state ( [ eq : su3-nnhgroundstate ] ) can be rewritten as @xcite @xmath43\ ; e_{z_1}^{\b\g}\ldots e_{z_m}^{\b\g } e_{w_1}^{\r\g}\ldots e_{w_m}^{\r\g}{\left|0_\g\right\rangle}\!,\ ] ] where the sum extends over all possible ways to distribute the positions of the blue particles @xmath44 and red particles @xmath45 over the @xmath12 sites ( see fig .
[ fig : sd]b ) .
the ground state wave function is given by @xmath46\equiv \prod^{m_1}_{i < j}(z_i - z_j)^2\prod^{m_2}_{k < l}(w_k - w_l)^2 \prod_{i=1}^{m_1}\prod_{k=1}^{m_2}(z_i - w_k ) \prod_{i=1}^{m_1}z_i\prod_{k=1}^{m_2}w_k \label{eq : su3-definitionpsi0}\ ] ] with @xmath47 , as derived in app .
[ app : gwstate ] .
the ground state energy is @xmath48 the total momentum , as defined through @xmath49/\psi_0[z_i , w_k]$ ] with @xmath50 , is @xmath51 regardless of @xmath33 .
( this is only true for su(@xmath2 ) with @xmath2 odd . )
-particle state .
b ) typical configuration in @xmath39.,title="fig : " ] -particle state .
b ) typical configuration in @xmath39.,title="fig : " ] we will now prove by explicit calculation that ( [ eq : su3-definitionpsi0 ] ) is an exact eigenstate of the hamiltonian ( [ eq : su3hamiltonian ] ) .
parts of this calculation will be used in sec .
[ sec : coloronwf ] to prove the exactness of our proposed wave function for the coloron excitation . to evaluate the action of @xmath19 on ( [ eq : su3-definitionpsi0 ] )
we first replace @xmath52 in ( [ eq : su3hamiltonian ] ) by @xmath53 , @xmath54 and then evaluate each term separately .
the first term @xmath55[z_i;w_k]$ ] , which vanishes unless one of the @xmath56 s is equal to @xmath57 , yields through taylor expansion @xmath58\!\![z_i;w_k]&= & \sum_{i=1}^{m_1}\sum_{\beta\neq i}^n \frac{\eta_\beta}{\vert z_i-\eta_\beta\vert^2 } \frac{\psi_0[\dots , z_{i-1},\eta_\beta , z_{i+1},\dots;w_k]}{\eta_\beta } \nonumber\\ & = & \sum_{i=1}^{m_1}\sum_{m=0}^{n-1 } \frac{a_mz_i^{m+1}}{m ! } \frac{\partial^m}{\partial z_i^m}\frac{\psi_0}{z_i}\nonumber\\ & = & \frac{m_1}{12}(n^2 + 8m_1 ^ 2 - 6m_1(n+1)+3)\,\psi_0\label{eq:1331}\\ & & -\frac{n-3}{2}\sum_{i=1}^{m_1}\sum_{k=1}^{m_2 } \frac{z_i}{z_i - w_k}\psi_0 + \sum_{i\neq j}^{m_1}\frac{z_i^2}{(z_i - z_j)^2}\psi_0\label{eq:1331a}\\ & & + 2\sum_{i\neq j}^{m_1}\sum_{k=1}^{m_2 } \frac{z_i^2}{(z_i - z_j)(z_i - w_k)}\psi_0\label{eq:1331b}\\ & & + \frac{1}{2}\sum_{i=1}^{m_1}\sum_{k\neq l}^{m_2 } \frac{z_i^2}{(z_i - w_k)(z_i - w_l)}\psi_0,\label{eq:1331c}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used @xmath59=n-1 $ ] and defined @xmath60 .
evaluation of the latter yields @xmath61 , @xmath62 , @xmath63 , and @xmath64 for @xmath65 ( see app .
[ app : formulas ] ) .
furthermore , we have used @xmath66 the second term @xmath67[z_i;w_k]$ ] can be treated in the same way and yields together with the first term in ( [ eq:1331a ] ) @xmath68 and with one part of ( [ eq:1331b ] ) and ( [ eq:1331c ] ) @xmath69 as well as similar expressions for @xmath70 . for the third term of ( [ eq : appsu3-hamiltonianforgs ] )
we obtain @xmath71&&\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\![z_i;w_k]= \sum_{i=1}^{m_1}\sum_{k=1}^{m_2}\frac{z_iw_k}{(z_i - w_k)^2 } \prod^{m_1}_{j\neq i}\left(1+\frac{z_i - w_k}{z_j - z_i}\right ) \prod^{m_2}_{l\neq k}\left(1-\frac{z_i - w_k}{w_l - w_k}\right ) \psi_0\nonumber\\ & = & \!\!\!\phantom{-}\sum_{i=1}^{m_1}\sum_{k=1}^{m_2 } \frac{z_iw_k}{(z_i - w_k)^2}\psi_0\label{eq - appsu3 - 1221first}\\ & & \!\!\!-\sum_{i\neq j}^{m_1}\sum_{k=1}^{m_2 } \frac{z_iw_k}{(z_i - z_j)(z_i - w_k)}\psi_0- \sum_{i=1}^{m_1}\sum_{k\neq l}^{m_2 } \frac{z_iw_k}{(w_k - z_i)(w_k - w_l)}\psi_0\label{eq : appsu3 - 1221second}\\ & & \!\!\!+\sum_{i=1}^{m_1}\sum_{k=1}^{m_2}\sum_{m=2}^{m_1 - 1}\frac{1}{m ! } \sum_{\{a_j\}}\frac{z_iw_k(z_i - w_k)^{m-2}}{(z_{a_1}-z_i)\cdots ( z_{a_m}-z_i)}\psi_0\label{eq : appsu3 - 1221third}\\ & & \!\!\!+\sum_{i=1}^{m_1}\sum_{k=1}^{m_2}\sum_{n=2}^{m_2 - 1}\frac{(-1)^n}{n ! } \sum_{\{b_l\}}\frac{z_iw_k(z_i - w_k)^{n-2}}{(w_{b_1}-w_k)\cdots ( w_{b_n}-w_k)}\psi_0\label{eq : appsu3 - 1221forth}\\ & & \!\!\!+\sum_{i=1}^{m_1}\sum_{k=1}^{m_2}\sum_{m=1}^{m_1 - 1}\sum_{n=1}^{m_2 - 1 } \frac{(-1)^n}{m!n!}\nonumber\\ & & \!\!\!\quad\;\sum_{\{a_j\}\{b_l\ } } \frac{z_iw_k(z_i - w_k)^{m+n-2}}{(z_{a_1}-z_i)\cdots(z_{a_m}-z_i ) ( w_{b_1}-w_k)\cdots(w_{b_n}-w_k)}\psi_0\label{eq : appsu3 - 1221fifth},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath72 ( @xmath73 ) is a set of integers between 1 and @xmath74 ( @xmath75 ) .
the summations run over all possible ways to distribute the @xmath76 ( @xmath77 ) over the blue ( red ) coordinates , where @xmath56 ( @xmath78 ) is excluded .
the two terms ( [ eq : appsu3 - 1221third ] ) and ( [ eq : appsu3 - 1221forth ] ) vanish due to [ theo : gstheorem ] let @xmath79 , @xmath80 , and @xmath81 distinct .
then , @xmath82 a proof of theorem [ theo : gstheorem ] is given in app .
[ app : gstheorem ] . the last term ( [ eq : appsu3 - 1221fifth ] ) can be simplified using a theorem due to ha and haldane @xcite : [ theo : appsu3-hahaldane ] let @xmath72 be a set of distinct integers between @xmath83 and @xmath74 , and @xmath73 a set of distinct integers between @xmath83 and @xmath75 .
then , @xmath84 furthermore , the two terms in line ( [ eq : appsu3 - 1221second ] ) , together with the remainder of ( [ eq:1331b ] ) and the corresponding expression from the second term of the hamiltonian , can be simplified to yield @xmath85 .
finally , the diagonal terms of ( [ eq : appsu3-hamiltonianforgs ] ) cancel the remainder of ( [ eq:1331a ] ) as well as ( [ eq - appsu3 - 1221first ] ) and yield the additional constant @xmath86\!.\ ] ] when collecting all terms evaluated above and setting @xmath87 we obtain the ground state energy ( [ eq : su3-gsenergym = n/3 ] ) .
we now turn to the heart of our analysis , the elementary and fractionally quantized excitations , which we call colorons . in principle , there are two possible , non - equivalent constructions for localized excitations starting from ( [ eq : su3-nnhgroundstate ] ) .
we may either create a particle with color @xmath17 on a chain with @xmath88 sites before gutzwiller projection , @xmath89 or annihilate a particle with color @xmath17 on a chain with @xmath90 : @xmath91 in both cases , @xmath92 or @xmath93 creates an inhomogeneity in color and charge before projection .
the projection once again enforces one particle per site and thereby removes the charge inhomogeneity , while it commutes with color and thereby preserves the color inhomogeneity .
consequently , the trial states @xmath94 and @xmath95 describe localized `` excitations '' of color @xmath17 or complementary color @xmath96 , respectively , at lattice site @xmath97 . since @xmath19 is translationally invariant , we of course expect neither of them , but only momentum eigenstates constructed from them via @xmath98 where @xmath2 is a momentum quantum number , to be eigenstates .
the important thing to realize now is that only ( [ eq : loctwocolorons ] ) or ( [ eq : loccoloron ] ) , but not both , can describe a valid excitation . to see this , let us assume @xmath99 for ease in presentation , and note that ( [ eq : loctwocolorons ] ) is apart from a normalization factor equivalent to @xmath100 creation of a blue particle before projection is tantamount to annihilation of both a red and a green particle at site @xmath97 . if momentum eigenstates constructed from @xmath95 via ( [ eq : ncoloron ] ) were energy eigenstates , the anti - red ( cyan ) and anti - green ( magenta ) coloron excitations in ( [ eq : loctwocolorons2 ] ) would individually seek to be momentum eigenstates , which implies that a trial wave function forcing them to sit on the same site would not be an energy eigenstate .
the same argument can be made the other way round . in the following ,
we show by explicit calculation that momentum eigenstates constructed from @xmath95 via ( [ eq : ncoloron ] ) are exact eigenstates of @xmath19 . for simplicity , we choose @xmath101 ( an anti - blue or yellow coloron ) and express @xmath102 through the corresponding wave function @xmath103= \prod_{i=1}^{m_1 } ( \eta_\gamma - z_i)\;\psi_0[z_i;w_k]\equiv\psi_\gamma\psi_0 , \label{eq : localizedcoloronwf}\ ] ] with @xmath104 given by ( [ eq : su3-definitionpsi0 ] ) and @xmath105 , @xmath106 .
the momentum eigenstate @xmath107 is then given by @xmath108= \frac{1}{n}\sum_{\gamma=1}^n(\bar{\eta}_\gamma)^n\;\psi_\gamma[z_i;w_k ] \label{eq : wfmomentumcoloron}\ ] ] ( where @xmath2 is shifted with respect to @xmath2 in ( [ eq : ncoloron ] ) by a constant depending on which momenta are occupied in the slater determinant state ) .
the momentum of ( [ eq : wfmomentumcoloron ] ) is @xmath109 the energy is given by @xmath110 & = e_0+\frac{2}{9}\frac{\pi^2}{n^2}\,+\,\epsilon(p ) , \label{eq : colorondisperion } \end{split}\ ] ] where we have defined the one - coloron dispersion relation ( see fig .
[ fig : dis ] ) @xmath111 for @xmath112 , @xmath113 vanishes identically .
( 16,7)(-1,0 ) ( 0,1)(1,0)13.5 ( 0,1)(0,1)5 ( 4,1)(6,8)(8,1 ) ( 4,1 ) ( 0,0)[t ] ' '' '' ( 8,1 ) ( 0,0)[t ] ' '' '' ( 12,1 ) ( 0,0)[t ] ' '' ''
( 0,0)(0,0)@xmath114 ( 4,0)(0,0)@xmath115 ( 8,0)(0,0)@xmath116 ( 12,0)(0,0)@xmath117 ( 13.7,0.4)(0,0)@xmath118 ( -1.3,6)(0,0)@xmath119 ( 6,1 ) ( 0,0 ) ' '' '' ( 6,1.5)(1,1)3 ( 12,5.3)(0,0)allowed momenta to prove that @xmath113 represents an energy eigenstate , note that all terms of the hamiltonian ( [ eq : appsu3-hamiltonianforgs ] ) yield the same expressions as for the wave function @xmath104 except those terms containing @xmath120 and @xmath121 .
hence , it is sufficient to investigate those further . to begin with ,
the polynomial @xmath122 defined in ( [ eq : localizedcoloronwf ] ) can be written as @xmath123 , where @xmath124 is the sum over all possible ways to choose @xmath125 coordinates out of @xmath44 , @xmath126 .
hence , we find in addition to ( [ eq:1331])([eq:1331c ] ) the two terms ( note that @xmath127 ) @xmath128 fourier transformation ( [ eq : wfmomentumcoloron ] ) of these yields @xmath129\psi_n -\frac{1}{n}\psi_0\sum_{\gamma=1}^n\sum_{i=1}^{m_1}\sum_{k=1}^{m_2 } \frac{z_i^2(\bar{\eta}_\gamma)^n}{(z_i - w_k)(\eta_\gamma - z_i)}\;\psi_\gamma .
\label{eq : appsu3-firstresult1331term}\ ] ] furthermore , @xmath130\!\![z_i;w_k]&=&\sum_{i=1}^{m_1}\sum_{k=1}^{m_2}\frac{z_iw_k}{(z_i - w_k)^2 } \prod^{m_1}_{j\neq i}\frac{z_j - w_k}{z_j - z_i } \prod^{m_2}_{l\neq k}\frac{w_l - z_i}{w_l - w_k } \psi_n\label{eq : appsu3-os1221first}\\ & & \hspace{-20mm}+\frac{\psi_0}{n}\sum_{\gamma=1}^n\sum_{i=1}^{m_1 } \sum_{k=1}^{m_2}\frac{z_iw_k(\bar{\eta}_\gamma)^n}{(z_i - w_k)(\eta_\gamma - z_i ) } \prod^{m_1}_{j\neq i}\frac{z_j - w_k}{z_j - z_i } \prod^{m_2}_{l\neq k}\frac{w_l - z_i}{w_l - w_k } \psi_\gamma.\label{eq : appsu3-os1221second}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the term on the right of ( [ eq : appsu3-os1221first ] ) is identical to a corresponding term in the ground state calculation , whereas ( [ eq : appsu3-os1221second ] ) taken together with the second term in ( [ eq : appsu3-firstresult1331term ] ) gives @xmath131\psi_n,\ ] ] where we have used [ theo : appsu3-onespinontheorem ] for @xmath132 , @xmath133 , @xmath134 distinct , @xmath135 distinct , and @xmath136 the following is valid : @xmath137 \sum^n_{\gamma=1}(\bar{\eta}_\gamma)^n \prod^{m_1}_{j\neq i}(\eta_\gamma - z_j)\\[3 mm ] & = \left[-\frac{1}{2}n(n+1)+\frac{1}{2}m_1(m_1 + 1)\right ] \sum^n_{\gamma=1}(\bar{\eta}_\gamma)^n\prod^{m_1}_{i=1}(\eta_\gamma - z_i ) .
\end{split } \label{eq : appsu3-spinontheorem}\ ] ] the proof of theorem [ theo : appsu3-onespinontheorem ] is given in app .
[ app : onecolorontheorem ] . collecting the terms obtained above
, we find that @xmath113 is an exact eigenstate of the hamiltonian ( [ eq : su3ham ] ) with energy ( [ eq : colorondisperion ] ) .
in the preceding section we have shown that the elementary coloron excitations are constructed by annihilation of a particle of color @xmath17 from an overall color singlet @xmath138 _ before _ gutzwiller projection .
since they are hole - like excitations , they transform according to the representation @xmath139 conjugate to the fundamental representation @xmath140 of the original particles on the sites of the chain .
this can also be seen by acting with the total su(3 ) spin generators ( [ eq : jtot ] ) on the wave function ( [ eq : localizedcoloronwf ] ) .
our result agrees with results obtained for the spectrum of the su(3)@xmath141 wess zumino witten ( wzw ) model by bouwknegt and schoutens @xcite .
it is straightforward to read off the quantum or exclusion statistics @xcite of color - polarized colorons ( colorons of the same color ) . consider a chain with @xmath90 sites and a single yellow coloron . according to ( [ eq : su3-nnhgroundstate ] ) , ( [ eq : loccoloron ] ) , and ( [ eq : ncoloron ] )
, there are as many single particle orbitals available to the coloron as there are blue particles in the slater determinant state , that is , @xmath33 .
if we now were to create three additional yellow colorons , the slater determinant state would have to contain three more particles , one of each color .
this implies there would be one additional orbital , while the three additional colorons would occupy three orbitals , meaning that the number of orbitals available for our original coloron would be reduced by two .
the statistical parameter is hence given by @xmath1 .
the fractional statistics manifests itself further in the exponents of the algebraic decay of the form factor of the dynamical structure factor @xcite as well as in the thermodynamics of the model @xcite .
a similar exclusion statistics exists in the conformal field theory spectrum of wzw models @xcite .
the exclusion statistics among colorons of different colors as well as the state counting for su(@xmath2 ) ( @xmath142 ) spin chains in general is highly non - trivial and will be subject of a future publication @xcite .
for @xmath143 , there are at least two colorons present .
two yellow colorons localized at lattice sites @xmath97 and @xmath144 are described by the wave function @xmath145= \prod_{i=1}^{m_1}(\eta_\gamma - z_i)(\eta_\delta - z_i)\;\psi_0[z_i;w_k ] \equiv \psi_{\gamma\delta}\;\psi_0 , \label{eq:2loccol}\ ] ] where @xmath146 and @xmath147 .
momentum eigenstates are once again constructed by fourier transformation @xmath148=\frac{1}{n^2}\sum_{\gamma\delta}^n ( \bar{\eta}_\gamma)^m(\bar{\eta}_\delta)^n\psi_{\gamma\delta}[z_i;w_k],\quad 0\le n \le m \le m_1 .
\label{eq:2momcol}\ ] ] in analogy to the su(2 ) hsm we neither expect these states for fixed @xmath149 and @xmath2 to be energy eigenstates , nor states with different sets of quantum numbers @xmath150 with the same @xmath151 ( and hence the same total momentum ) to be orthogonal to each other .
energy eigenstates , however , can be constructed as follows . as for the one - coloron states , application of the hamiltonian generates two contributions in addition to those familiar from the the ground state calculation .
first , for the terms containing @xmath120 we obtain ( [ eq : appsu3-os1331third ] ) with @xmath122 replaced by @xmath152 .
the first term in the resulting expression can be treated in analogy to the two - spinon states in the su(2 ) hsm @xcite . specifically , we find @xmath153 & + \left[-\eta_\gamma^2\frac{\partial^2}{\partial\eta_\gamma^2 } -\eta_\delta^2\frac{\partial^2}{\partial\eta_\delta^2 } + \frac{n-3}{2}\left(\eta_\gamma\frac{\partial}{\partial\eta_\gamma}+ \eta_\delta\frac{\partial}{\partial\eta_\delta}\right ) \right]\psi_{\gamma\delta}-\frac{1}{\eta_\gamma-\eta_\delta}\left [ \eta_\gamma^2\frac{\partial}{\partial\eta_\gamma}- \eta_\delta^2\frac{\partial}{\partial\eta_\delta }
\right]\psi_{\gamma\delta } \end{split}\ ] ] where we have used ( [ eq : appsu3-threezformula ] ) three times . applying this identity to the momentum eigenstates ( [ eq:2momcol ] ) , we obtain @xmath154\psi_{mn}\\[2 mm ] & -\sum_{\ell=1}^{\ell_\mathrm{m}}(m - n+2\ell)\psi_{m+\ell , n-\ell } , \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath155 , and we have used @xmath156 the second term of ( [ eq : appsu3-os1331third ] ) applied to the states @xmath157 yields @xmath158 the second contribution not familiar from the ground state calculation is given by terms arising in @xmath159\!\![z_i;w_k]&=&\sum_{i=1}^{m_1}\sum_{k=1}^{m_2}\frac{z_iw_k}{(z_i - w_k)^2 } \prod^{m_1}_{j\neq i}\frac{z_j - w_k}{z_j - z_i } \prod^{m_2}_{l\neq k}\frac{w_l - z_i}{w_l - w_k } \psi_{mn}\label{eq : twocolaux2}\\ & & \hspace{-25mm}+\frac{\psi_0}{n^2}\sum_{\gamma\delta}^n\sum_{i=1}^{m_1 } \sum_{k=1}^{m_2}\frac{z_iw_k(\bar{\eta}_\gamma)^m(\bar{\eta}_\delta)^n } { ( z_i - w_k)(\eta_\gamma - z_i ) } \prod^{m_1}_{j\neq i}\frac{z_j - w_k}{z_j - z_i } \prod^{m_2}_{l\neq k}\frac{w_l - z_i}{w_l - w_k } \psi_{\gamma\delta}\label{eq : twocolaux3}\\ & & \hspace{-25mm}+\frac{\psi_0}{n^2}\sum_{\gamma\delta}^n\sum_{i=1}^{m_1 } \sum_{k=1}^{m_2}\frac{z_iw_k(\bar{\eta}_\gamma)^m(\bar{\eta}_\delta)^n } { ( z_i - w_k)(\eta_\delta - z_i ) } \prod^{m_1}_{j\neq i}\frac{z_j - w_k}{z_j - z_i } \prod^{m_2}_{l\neq k}\frac{w_l - z_i}{w_l - w_k } \psi_{\gamma\delta}\label{eq : twocolaux4}\\ & & \hspace{-25mm}+\frac{\psi_0}{n^2}\sum_{\gamma\delta}^n\sum_{i=1}^{m_1 } \sum_{k=1}^{m_2}\frac{z_iw_k(\bar{\eta}_\gamma)^m(\bar{\eta}_\delta)^n } { ( \eta_\gamma - z_i)(\eta_\delta - z_i ) } \prod^{m_1}_{j\neq i}\frac{z_j - w_k}{z_j - z_i } \prod^{m_2}_{l\neq k}\frac{w_l - z_i}{w_l - w_k } \psi_{\gamma\delta}.\label{eq : twocolaux5}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first term ( [ eq : twocolaux2 ] ) is identical to the ground state calculation .
the two following terms ( [ eq : twocolaux3 ] ) and ( [ eq : twocolaux4 ] ) can be combined together with ( [ eq : twocolaux1 ] ) and theorem [ theo : appsu3-onespinontheorem ] to yield @xmath160\psi_{mn}.\ ] ] the last term ( [ eq : twocolaux5 ] ) can be simplified using [ theo : twocolorons ] for @xmath132 , @xmath161 , @xmath134 distinct , @xmath135 distinct , and @xmath162 , and @xmath155 the following is valid : @xmath163 = & \,(m_1-m)\sum^n_{\gamma\delta}(\bar{\eta}_\gamma)^m(\bar{\eta}_\delta)^n \prod^{m_1}_{i=1}(\eta_\gamma - z_i)(\eta_\delta - z_i)\\ & \,-\sum_{\ell=1}^{\ell_\mathrm{m}}(m - n+2\ell ) \sum^n_{\gamma\delta}(\bar{\eta}_\gamma)^{m+\ell } ( \bar{\eta}_\delta)^{n-\ell } \prod^{m_1}_{i=1}(\eta_\gamma - z_i)(\eta_\delta - z_i ) .
\end{split } \label{eq : twocoltheorem}\ ] ] a proof of theorem [ theo : twocolorons ] is given in app .
[ app : twocolorontheorem ] . after collecting all terms
, we obtain for the action of the hamiltonian on the momentum eigenstates ( [ eq:2momcol ] ) : @xmath164 { \left|\psi_{mn}\right\rangle}\\ & -\frac{4\pi^2}{n^2}\sum_{\ell=1}^{\ell_\mathrm{m}}(m - n+2\ell ) { \left|\psi_{m+\ell , n-\ell}\right\rangle}. \end{split } \label{eq : actiononpmn}\ ] ] this sutherland - type equation @xcite shows first of all that when we act with the hamiltonian on the non - orthogonal basis state ( [ eq:2momcol ] ) with @xmath165 , @xmath166 , @xmath167 , we only obtain terms ( [ eq:2momcol ] ) with @xmath168 and @xmath169 with fixed @xmath170 , but no terms with @xmath171 or @xmath172 .
consequently , states with @xmath173 or @xmath174 ( or both ) are exact eigenstates .
furthermore , we can obtain all the other exact eigenstates at each fixed @xmath151 ( or fixed total momentum ) by subsequently constructing an orthogonal basis of states starting from these exact eigenstates .
( we have shown previously @xcite that this method can be used to obtain all the spin polarized two spinon eigenstates of the su(2 ) hsm . ) with all the numerical constants in place , however , ( [ eq : actiononpmn ] ) provides much more information than the direction of the scattering .
we can solve for the energy eigenstates directly through the ansatz @xmath175 requiring @xmath176 then yields the recursion relation @xmath177 ( @xmath178 ) for the coefficients @xmath179 as well as @xmath180\!. \label{eq:2colenergy}\ ] ] for the two - coloron energies .
as we introduce single - coloron momenta according to @xmath181 the energy ( [ eq:2colenergy ] ) simplifies to @xmath182 with @xmath183 given by ( [ eq : su3-gsenergym = n/3 ] ) and the single - coloron dispersion relation @xmath119 given by ( [ eq : singlecolorondispersion ] ) .
the interpretation of ( [ eq : singlecoloronmomenta ] ) and ( [ eq:2colenergywithp ] ) is as follows . first , the coloron excitations in the su(3 ) hsm are ( like the spinon excitations in the su(2 ) model
@xcite ) free , and the total energy is simply given by the sum of the kinetic energies of the individual colorons .
this conclusion is consistent with the asymptotic bethe ansatz calculation by essler @xcite , who has shown that the coloron - coloron scattering matrix is trivial , a momentum independent phase .
second , the difference in the individual coloron momenta ( [ eq : singlecoloronmomenta ] ) is quantized as @xmath184 the minimal momentum spacing between color - polarized colorons is @xmath185 of the momentum spacing for fermions on a ring , @xmath186 .
we interpret this result as a manifestation of the fractional statistics of the colorons .
this result appears to indicate that the spacing for particles with exclusion statistics @xmath187 is given by @xmath188 this identification is obviously consistent with the familiar cases of bosons and fermions , and may even constitute the most direct manifestation of haldane s @xcite fractional exclusion principle _ per se_. the fractional momenta ( [ eq : singlecoloronmomenta ] ) may also be interpreted in terms of an effective change in the periodic boundary conditions ( pbcs ) .
the allowed values for the total momenta of the two - coloron states are those for conventional pbcs , @xmath189 where we have used the fact that @xmath190 in ( [ eq : singlecoloronmomenta ] ) is divisible by three .
this is also required , as the wave function must come back to itself under a full translation around the ring .
the allowed values for the difference in the momenta ( [ eq : coloronmomentaspacing ] ) , by contrast , are those of a ring threaded by a magnetic flux @xmath191 . in a certain sense , we may interpret this flux as a phase acquired by the wave function as one coloron goes `` through '' the other .
there are , however , several subtleties associated with this interpretation @xcite .
in this section , we calculate the su(3 ) spin currents , the eigenvalues of the diagonal rapidity operators @xmath8 and @xmath9 . to this end ,
we first rewrite them in terms of colorflip operators : @xmath192 the eigenvalue of @xmath9 is easier to evaluate . using the taylor expansion technique
we obtain @xmath193\!\![z_i;w_k]&= & \frac{\sqrt{3}}{4}\sum_{m=0}^{n-2}\frac{b_m}{m ! }
\left[\sum_{i=1}^{m_1}z_i^{m+1}\frac{\partial^m}{\partial z_i^m } \frac{\psi}{z_i}+\sum_{k=1}^{m_2}w_k^{m+1}\frac{\partial^m}{\partial w_k^m } \frac{\psi}{w_k}\right]\nonumber\\[2 mm ] & = & \frac{\sqrt{3}}{4}(n-2)(m_1+m_2)\psi- \frac{\sqrt{3}}{2}\left[\sum_{i=1}^{m_1}z_i^2\frac{\partial}{\partial z_i } \frac{\psi}{z_i}+\sum_{k=1}^{m_2}w_k^2\frac{\partial}{\partial w_k } \frac{\psi}{w_k}\right]\!,\label{eq : spincurrent}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the wave function has to satisfy @xmath194 and @xmath195 , and we have defined @xmath196 .
evaluation of the latter yields @xmath197 , @xmath198 , and @xmath199 for @xmath200 ( see app .
[ app : formulas ] ) . with ( [ eq : spincurrent ] ) we find for the ground state , the one - coloron states ( [ eq : wfmomentumcoloron ] ) , and the two - coloron states ( [ eq : twocolenergyes ] ) @xmath201 \lambda^8{\left|\psi_n\right\rangle}&=&-\frac{\sqrt{3}}{4}\left(\frac{n-2}{3}-2n\right ) { \left|\psi_n\right\rangle},\label{eq : sc2}\\[2 mm ] \lambda^8{\left|\phi_{mn}\right\rangle}&= & -\frac{\sqrt{3}}{4}\left(\frac{2n-8}{3}-2m-2n\right ) { \left|\phi_{mn}\right\rangle}\label{eq : sc3}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the eigenvalues of @xmath8 can be obtained either by explicit calculation or be determined as follows .
the fundamental representations of the yangian @xmath202 can be constructed @xcite from the representations of @xmath203 ( su(3 ) ) by the pull - back under the so - called evaluation homomorphism from @xmath202 into the universal enveloping algebra @xmath204 of @xmath203 .
explicitly , the ground state transforms according to the pull - back of the su(3 ) singlet representation under @xmath202 transformations , the one - coloron states transform according to the pull - back of the representation @xmath0 , and the two - coloron states investigated in sec .
[ sec : twocolorons ] according to the pull - back of the representation @xmath205 ( as the two colorons are coupled symmetrically ) . for the fundamental representations of @xmath202 constructed in this way
the ratio of the eigenvalues of @xmath8 and @xmath9 is equal to the ratio of the eigenvalues of @xmath23 and @xmath24 .
hence , as the states @xmath206 and @xmath207 are su(3 ) lowest weight states ( they are annihilated by @xmath208 , @xmath209 , and @xmath210 ; see fig .
[ fig : lwsreps ] ) , the eigenvalues of @xmath8 are simply @xmath211 times the eigenvalues of @xmath9 given in ( [ eq : sc1])([eq : sc3 ] ) . and @xmath205.,title="fig : " ] and @xmath205.,title="fig : " ]
let us now briefly compare our results with conclusions drawn from the asymptotic bethe ansatz ( aba ) .
we wish to stress that the aba is not an exact method . in the derivation of the aba equations one assumes the existence of an asymptotic region in which the particles ( or colorflips ) are non - interacting @xcite ; an assumption which is not valid rigorously .
in particular , the aba equations have no direct connection to the exact eigenstates of the hamiltonian @xcite as it is the case for the standard bethe ansatz .
it turns out , nevertheless , that the aba reproduces the spectrum of the model , hence there is an indirect relation between solutions of the aba equations and energy eigenstates .
let us now set up the formalism .
the eigenstates of the su(3 ) hsm are specified by two sets of pseudomomenta @xmath212 and @xmath213 satisfying the aba equations @xcite @xmath214 with two sets of mutually distinct integer ( or half - integer ) quantum numbers in the range @xmath215 s are real numbers , which means that we can only describe color - polarized states ( for the general case see @xcite ) .
the energy and momentum depend only on the first set of pseudomomenta , @xmath216 where @xmath217 $ ] .
the ground state is obtained by arranging the @xmath218 s densely around zero , by choosing @xmath219 and @xmath220 for a chain of length @xmath32 .
excitations are created by introducing holes into these sets of quantum numbers @xcite , for @xmath90 we obtain a single hole @xmath221 in the rank-2 quantum numbers by choosing @xmath222 and @xmath223 . in all practical applications we have to take the thermodynamic limit , such that the aba equations ( [ eq : abaequations ] ) turn into integral equations .
we introduce pseudomomenta densities @xmath224 as well as bare hole densities @xmath225 which describe the excitations
. then the aba equations ( [ eq : abaequations ] ) turn into integral equations with @xmath226-functions as integral kernels @xmath227 the latter are a special and distinguishing feature of the hsm . for the ground state we have @xmath228 and ( [ eq : sigmaeq ] )
is solved by @xmath229 and @xmath230 @xcite .
this shows the simple nature of the ground state , which is explicitly given by the gutzwiller state ( [ eq : su3-nnhgroundstate ] ) .
it is , however , not possible to derive the gutzwiller wave function from the ground state densities @xmath231 as there is no direct connection between solutions of the aba equations and the exact eigenstates of the hamiltonian .
one - coloron states correspond to single holes in the rank-2 pseudomomenta , @xmath232 and @xmath233 , which implies @xmath234 there is no `` hole - dressing '' in the surrounding pseudomomenta , or equivalently , the pseudomomenta densities are only affected through trivial shifts as we introduce holes .
this observation reflects once again the fact that colorons in the su(3 ) hsm ( as well as spinons in the hsm ) are free @xcite
. the densities ( [ eq : sigmacoloron ] ) yield the correct coloron momenta ( [ eq : coloronmomentum ] ) and energies ( [ eq : colorondisperion ] ) in the thermodynamic limit . holes in the rank-2 pseudomomenta represent excitations which transform under @xmath0 @xcite , hence we find again that colorons possess complementary colors @xcite .
we wish to stress , however , that this result can not be derived using the aba exclusively .
first , it can not be answered whether rank-1 or rank-2 holes represent elementary excitation , and second , the aba is not an exact method in contrast to calculations based on explicit wave functions . from ( [ eq : sigmacoloron ] )
we can further read off that when adding one coloron , the number of available orbitals described by @xmath235 is reduced by @xmath236 .
it is , however , not completely clear to us whether this can be interpreted directly as a derivation of the exclusion statistics of polarized colorons .
the results derived here generalize directly to the su(@xmath2 ) hsm . consider a chain with one particle per lattice site carrying an internal su(@xmath2 ) quantum number which transforms according to the fundamental representation n of su(@xmath2 ) .
the hamiltonian is given by @xmath238 where the operator @xmath239 annihilates a particle of flavor @xmath18 at site @xmath57 and creates a particle of flavor @xmath17 at the same site .
( once again , @xmath18 and @xmath17 may be equal in ( [ eq : su3-sunhamiltonian ] ) . in comparison to ( [ eq : su3hamiltonian ] ) ,
we have omitted a constant . )
the model again possesses a yangian symmetry @xcite and hence is integrable .
if we use a polarized state of particles of flavor @xmath2 as reference state and label the coordinates of the particles of flavor @xmath240 , by @xmath241 , the wave functions @xcite @xmath242=\prod_{\sigma=1}^{n-1 } \prod^{m_\sigma}_{i < j}(z_i^\sigma - z_j^\sigma)^2 \prod^{n-1}_{\sigma<\tau } \prod_{i=1}^{m_\sigma}\prod_{j=1}^{m_\tau}(z_i^\sigma - z_j^\tau ) \prod_{\sigma=1}^{n-1}\prod_{i=1}^{m_\sigma}z_i^\sigma \label{eq : su3-definitionsunpsi0}\ ] ] constitute exact eigenstates @xcite of the hamiltonian ( [ eq : su3-sunhamiltonian ] ) . for @xmath243 , @xmath244 , ( [ eq : su3-definitionsunpsi0 ] )
is the ground state of ( [ eq : su3-sunhamiltonian ] ) with energy @xcite @xmath245 the total momentum of this ground state is @xmath246 .
localized su(@xmath2 ) spinons are given by @xmath247=\prod_{i=1}^{m_1}(\eta_\gamma - z_i^1)\ ; \psi_0[z_i^\sigma ] \label{eq : su3-localspinon}\ ] ] for @xmath248 , @xmath249 , and @xmath250 .
as hole - like excitations they transform according to the representation @xmath251 .
energy eigenstates are obtained by fourier transformation of ( [ eq : su3-localspinon ] ) , @xmath252=\frac{1}{n}\sum_{\gamma=1}^n ( \bar{\eta}_\gamma)^m\psi_{\gamma}[z_i^\sigma],\quad 0\le m \le m_1 .
\label{eq : momsunspinon}\ ] ] their momenta are given by @xmath253 which fill the interval @xmath254 $ ] for @xmath2 even and @xmath33 odd , or the interval @xmath254 $ ] otherwise ( either @xmath2 odd or @xmath33 even or both ) .
the energy eigenvalues of the one su(@xmath2 ) spinon states ( [ eq : momsunspinon ] ) are given by @xmath255 with ( see fig . [
fig : disn ] ) @xmath256 \displaystyle \frac{n}{4}\left(\frac{\pi^2}{n^2}-(p-\pi)^2\right)\ ! , & \text{otherwise}. \end{array}\right.\ ] ] ( 16,9)(-1,0 ) ( -3,8)a ) @xmath2 even ( 0,1)(1,0)13.5 ( 0,1)(0,1)5 ( 12,1.3)(0,0.6)7 ' '' '' ( 0,4.5)(0.8,4.5)(1.5,1 ) ( 4.5,1)(6,8)(7.5,1 ) ( 10.5,1)(11.2,4.5)(12,4.5 ) ( 1.5,1 ) ( 0,0)[t ] ' '' '' ( 4.5,1 ) ( 0,0)[t ] ' '' '' ( 7.5,1 ) ( 0,0)[t ] ' '' '' ( 10.5,1 ) ( 0,0)[t ] ' '' '' ( 12,1 ) ( 0,0)[t ] ' '' '' ( 0,0)(0,0)@xmath114 ( 12,0)(0,0)@xmath117 ( 13.7,0.4)(0,0)@xmath118 ( -1.3,6)(0,0)@xmath119 ( 0.75,1 ) ( 0,0 ) ' '' '' ( 6,1 ) ( 0,0 ) ' '' '' ( 11.25,1 ) ( 0,0 ) ' '' '' ( 16,9)(-1,0 ) ( -3,8)b ) @xmath2 odd ( 0,1)(1,0)13.5 ( 0,1)(0,1)5 ( 4.5,1)(6,8)(7.5,1 ) ( 4.5,1 ) ( 0,0)[t ] ' '' '' ( 7.5,1 ) ( 0,0)[t ] ' '' '' ( 12,1 ) ( 0,0)[t ] ' '' '' ( 0,0)(0,0)@xmath114 ( 12,0)(0,0)@xmath117 ( 13.7,0.4)(0,0)@xmath118 ( -1.3,6)(0,0)@xmath119 ( 6,1 ) ( 0,0 ) ' '' '' the statistical parameter for polarized su(@xmath2 ) spinons is @xmath257 . in the framework of the aba
, the spinons are represented by holes in rank-@xmath258 pseudomomenta .
finally , let us add some remarks on the large-@xmath2 limit of the su(@xmath2 ) hsm .
first , there are no simplifications in the calculations which yield the results presented in this section .
when @xmath2 grows , we obtain solely terms similar to the ones treated in the appendix .
second , the interval of allowed spinon momenta shrinks to zero .
this does not mean that the number of spinon orbitals vanishes , as in the limit @xmath259 the number of lattice sites @xmath248 has to grow and hence the momentum spacing tends to zero as well .
third , we find @xmath260 as @xmath259 , meaning that the exclusion statistics between polarized spinons becomes fermionic in this limit .
this does not imply , however , that spinons in the su(@xmath2 ) hsm behave like free fermions in the large-@xmath2 limit .
their momenta fill only a narrow interval and the individual spinon momenta are not simply given by integer multiples of @xmath186 @xcite .
in conclusion , we have shown by explicit calculation that the elementary excitations of su(@xmath2 ) , but in particular su(3 ) , hsm transform under the representation conjugate to the representation of the su(@xmath2 ) spins on the chain . we have also shown that they obey fractional statistics , and only exist in one n@xmath3 of the brillouin zone .
we strongly believe these features to be generic features of `` antiferromagnetic '' su(@xmath2 ) spin chains . we have further endeavored to construct the polarized two - coloron eigenstates of the hsm explicitly , and
have thereby shown that they are free and that the spacings in the difference of the individual coloron momenta @xmath4 and @xmath5 with @xmath6 are given by @xmath261 .
we have interpreted this peculiar shift as a manifestation of the fractional statistics .
this indicates that fractional statistics in one dimension manifests itself not only through a fractional exclusion principle @xcite , but that there are berry s phases associated with anyons @xcite in one dimensions as well @xcite .
furthermore , we look forward to an experimental realization of su(3 ) spin chains in systems of ultracold atoms @xcite , and hence an observation of the complementary colors of the excitations .
mg would like to thank the organizers of the 2003 amsterdam summer workshop on flux , charge , topology and statistics , where this work was partially inspired .
ds was supported by the german research foundation ( dfg ) through gk 284 .
the gell - mann matrices are given by @xcite @xmath262 & \lambda^4=\left(\begin{array}{ccc}0&0&1\\0&0&0\\1&0&0\end{array } \right)\!\!,\quad \lambda^5 = \left(\begin{array}{ccc}0&0&-i\\0&0&0\\i&0&0\end{array } \right)\!\!,\quad \lambda^6 = \left(\begin{array}{ccc}0&0&0\\0&0&1\\0&1&0\end{array } \right)\!\!,\\[3 mm ] & \lambda^7=\left(\begin{array}{ccc}0&0&0\\0&0&-i\\0&i&0\end{array } \right)\!\!,\quad \lambda^8 = \frac{1}{\sqrt{3 } } \left(\begin{array}{ccc}1&0&0\\0&1&0\\0&0&-2\end{array}\right)\!\!. \end{split}\ ] ] they are normalized as @xmath263 and satisfy the commutation relations @xmath29}=2f^{abc}\lambda^c.$ ] the structure constants @xmath28 are totally antisymmetric and obey jacobi s identity @xmath264 explicitly , the non - vanishing structure constants are given by @xmath265 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , and 45 others obtained by permutations of the indices .
the su(3 ) spin operators are expressed in terms of the colorflip operators by @xmath268
let us begin by exploring a general consequence of particle - hole symmetry .
consider a chain of @xmath12 sites .
the wave function of @xmath269 fermions with momenta in the interval @xmath270 is given by @xmath271={\left\langle0\right|}c_{u_1}\cdots c_{u_l } \prod_{q\in i_1}c_q^\dagger{\left|0\right\rangle}\!. \label{eq : defphi}\ ] ] this wave function can be expressed in terms of @xmath272 fermions whose momenta fill the interval @xmath273\backslash i_1 $ ] , @xmath274&=&\biggl({\left\langle0\right|}\prod_{q\in i_1}c_q\ ; c_{u_l}^\dagger\cdots c_{u_1}^\dagger{\left|0\right\rangle}\biggr)^{\!\!*}\nonumber\\ & = & \text{sign}\cdot\biggl({\left\langle0\right|}\prod_{q\in i_1}c_q\ ; c_{v_1}\cdots c_{v_{n - l}}\prod_{q\in i_2}c_q^\dagger \prod_{q\in i_1}c_q^\dagger{\left|0\right\rangle}\biggr)^{\!\!*}\nonumber\\[2 mm ] & = & \text{sign}\cdot\phi_2^*[v_1,\ldots , v_{n - l}]\label{eq : etazsymmetry},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the coordinates @xmath275 are those coordinates on the chain which are not contained in the set @xmath276 , @xmath277={\left\langle0\right|}c_{v_1}\cdots c_{v_{n - l } } \prod_{q\in i_2}c_q^\dagger{\left|0\right\rangle}\ ! , \label{eq : defphi2}\ ] ] and the overall sign depends on the number and positions of the fermions .
( [ eq : etazsymmetry ] ) enables us to show that the ground state wave function is given by ( [ eq : su3-definitionpsi0 ] ) with @xmath47 . for @xmath32 , the wave function of the slater determinant state @xmath278
is ( see fig . [
fig : sd]a ) @xmath279= \phi_1[z_i]\phi_1[w_k]\phi_1[u_m ] , \label{eq : sdwf}\ ] ] where the interval @xmath270 is chosen to be @xmath280 $ ] and hence @xmath281=\prod_{i=1}^mz_i^{-\frac{m-1}{2}}\prod_{i < j}^m(z_i - z_j ) .
\label{eq : sdwf1}\ ] ] the prefactor in ( [ eq : sdwf1 ] ) shifts all momenta from the interval @xmath282 $ ] to @xmath270 .
the ground state of the su(3 ) hsm is obtained by gutzwiller projection , @xmath283 , which enforces that all coordinates @xmath56 , @xmath78 , and @xmath284 are distinct .
hence , we can express the coordinates @xmath284 in terms of the @xmath56 s and @xmath78 s using ( [ eq : etazsymmetry ] ) , @xmath285=\text{sign}\cdot\phi_2^*[z_i , w_k],\ ] ] where the wave function of the filled band with momenta in the interval @xmath273\backslash i_1 $ ] is ( up to a sign ) given by @xmath286=\prod_{i=1}^mz_i^{\frac{m+1}{2 } } \prod_{k=1}^mw_k^{\frac{m+1}{2}}\ , \prod_{i < j}^m(z_i - z_j)\prod_{k < l}^m(w_k - w_l ) \prod_{i=1}^m\prod_{k=1}^m(z_i - w_k).\ ] ] the ground state wave function is hence given by @xmath287&=&\phi_1[z_i]\phi_1[w_k]\phi_2^*[z_i , w_k]\nonumber\\[2 mm ] & = & \prod_{i=1}^{m}z_i^{-m}\prod_{k=1}^{m}w_k^{-m } \prod^{m}_{i < j}|z_i - z_j|^2\prod^{m}_{k < l}|w_k - w_l|^2 \prod_{i=1}^{m}\prod_{k=1}^{m}(z_i - w_k)^*,\label{eq : apppsi_0}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used the fact that the coordinates are located on the unit circle , @xmath288 .
using @xmath289 as well as @xmath290 we obtain from ( [ eq : apppsi_0 ] ) @xmath291=\prod_{i=1}^{m}z_i^{-3m}\prod_{k=1}^{m}w_k^{-3 m } \prod^{m}_{i <
j}(z_i - z_j)^2\prod^{m}_{k < l}(w_k - w_l)^2 \prod_{i=1}^{m}\prod_{k=1}^{m}(z_i - w_k ) \prod_{i=1}^{m}z_i\prod_{k=1}^{m}w_k.\ ] ] as the coordinates @xmath56 and @xmath78 are located at the lattice sites @xmath292 and @xmath32 , the prefactor reduces to one and @xmath293 $ ] takes the form ( [ eq : su3-definitionpsi0 ] ) .
some of the results presented in this appendix can be found in @xcite .
1 . @xmath294 2 .
@xmath295 3 .
@xmath296 + _ proof : _ rewrite ( [ eq : app - hssum5 ] ) as @xmath297 with @xmath298 a polynomial of degree @xmath299 , @xmath300 , and @xmath301 .
since the polynomial @xmath302 has degree @xmath299 and @xmath12 different zeros , it vanishes by the fundamental theorem of algebra @xcite .
4 . the previous statement implies @xmath303 5 .
@xmath304 + _ proof : _ using cauchy s theorem @xcite for the function @xmath305 with the contours drawn in fig .
[ fig : app - hscontours ] yields @xmath306 where we have used the theorem of residues @xcite in the last step .
@xmath307 + _ proof : _ we have @xmath308 7 .
for @xmath309 we have : @xmath61 by ( [ eq : app - hsfouriersum2 ] ) , @xmath62 by ( [ eq : app - hsfouriersum1 ] ) , and @xmath63 by @xmath310 .
furthermore , @xmath311 as the sums of the binomial coefficients of even sites and odd sites equal each other . 8 . for @xmath312
we have : @xmath197 , @xmath198 , @xmath199 for @xmath313 , and @xmath314 .
as ( [ eq : theo1 ] ) is symmetric in the @xmath56 s , we prove the theorem by showing that the lhs of ( [ eq : theo1 ] ) is independent of @xmath315 and vanishes identically . to this end , consider the auxiliary function @xmath316 for fixed and distinct @xmath317 . first , we show that ( [ eq : appaux6 ] ) is entire ( analytic on @xmath318 ) .
we can restrict ourselves to showing that @xmath319 is analytic at @xmath320 .
( [ eq : appaux6 ] ) can be rewritten as @xmath321 where @xmath322 is analytic at @xmath320 .
expanding the first term yields expressions like @xmath323 which can be shown to be analytic at @xmath320 by using ( [ eq : xysum ] ) .
second , as the degree of the denominator in ( [ eq : appaux6 ] ) is strictly greater than the degree of the numerator , @xmath319 vanishes for @xmath324 .
therefore , by liouville s theorem @xcite @xmath325 vanishes for all @xmath326 , which proves the theorem .
we prove the theorem in three steps .
first , we show that the lhs of ( [ eq : appsu3-spinontheorem ] ) does not depend on the @xmath78 s .
second , we eliminate the @xmath78 s .
third , we verify the remaining equation by explicit calculation . for the first step , note that ( [ eq : appsu3-spinontheorem ] ) is symmetric under permutations of the @xmath78 s .
it is hence sufficient to show that ( [ eq : appsu3-spinontheorem ] ) does not depend on @xmath327 . consider for fixed and distinct @xmath328 the auxiliary function @xmath329\\[3 mm ] & + \sum_{k=2}^{m_2}\frac{1}{z_1-w_k } \left[w_k\prod^{m_1}_{j=2}\frac{z_j - w_k}{z_j - z_1 } \prod^{m_2}_{l\neq k}\frac{w_l - z_1}{w_l - w_k } \cdot\frac{w_1-z_1}{w_1-w_k}-z_1\right]\!. \end{split } \label{eq : appsu3-auxiliaryfunction}\ ] ] we will show that @xmath325 is an entire function and bounded for @xmath330
. then liouville s theorem @xcite implies that @xmath325 is a constant , independent of @xmath327 . to see that @xmath325 is entire note that ( [ eq : appsu3-auxiliaryfunction ] ) is obviously analytic for @xmath331 . to investigate the point @xmath332 , we rewrite the first line of ( [ eq : appsu3-auxiliaryfunction ] ) as @xmath333,\ ] ] which shows that @xmath325 can be analytically continued to @xmath332
furthermore , as ( [ eq : appsu3-auxiliaryfunction ] ) is symmetric in @xmath334 , we may restrict ourselves now to showing that @xmath325 is analytic at @xmath335 .
for @xmath336 this is obviously the case .
for @xmath337 we write @xmath325 as @xmath338 where @xmath322 is analytic at @xmath335 .
now , @xmath339 can be rewritten as @xmath340\!\!. \end{split } \label{eq : appsu3-theoremauxiliary1}\ ] ] expanding the square brackets in ( [ eq : appsu3-theoremauxiliary1 ] ) leads to terms like @xmath341 which can be shown to be analytic at @xmath335 by using ( [ eq : xysum ] ) .
this concludes the proof that @xmath325 is an entire function of @xmath327 .
furthermore , @xmath325 tends to a constant for @xmath330 as in the first term of ( [ eq : appsu3-auxiliaryfunction ] ) , the degree of the denominator is greater or equal than the degree of the numerator , while in the second term the @xmath327-dependence cancels out for @xmath330 .
therefore , @xmath325 is constant by liouville s theorem @xcite . as we can replace @xmath315 by any @xmath56 in ( [ eq : appsu3-auxiliaryfunction ] )
, the lhs of ( [ eq : appsu3-spinontheorem ] ) does not depend on the @xmath78 s . in the second step ,
we eliminate the @xmath78 s from ( [ eq : appsu3-spinontheorem ] ) . in order to do
so we choose @xmath342 for @xmath343 , and @xmath344 with distinct values @xmath345 $ ] for @xmath346 .
we now have to study three different terms in ( [ eq : appsu3-spinontheorem ] ) .
first , the terms with @xmath347 yield as @xmath348 @xmath349 second , the terms with @xmath350 yield in the same limit @xmath351 third , the terms with @xmath352 vanish in this limit . hence ( [ eq : appsu3-spinontheorem ] ) reduces to @xmath353 with @xmath354 . the second term in the lhs of ( [ eq : appsu3-theoremauxiliary2 ] ) can be written as @xmath355 \prod^{m_1}_{k\neq i , j}(\eta_\gamma - z_k ) , \end{split } \label{eq : appsu3-theoremauxiliary3}\ ] ] where we have used @xmath356.\ ] ] in the third step , we complete the proof by explicit calculation .
for this we use @xmath357 where @xmath358 is the sum over all possible ways to choose @xmath359 coordinates out of @xmath360 .
then , using ( [ eq : appsu3-theoremauxiliary3 ] ) we write ( [ eq : appsu3-theoremauxiliary2 ] ) as @xmath361{0.3pt}{18pt}_{\;\mathrm{no}\;z_i } + \sum_{i\neq j}^{m_1}z_i\ , \mathcal{s}^{m_1 - 2}(z_1\cdots z_{m_1-n-1 } ) \rule[-8pt]{0.3pt}{18pt}_{\;\mathrm{no}\;z_i , z_j}\\ & + \frac{1}{2}\sum_{i\neq j}^{m_1}z_iz_j\ , \mathcal{s}^{m_1 - 2}(z_1\cdots z_{m_1-n-2 } ) \rule[-8pt]{0.3pt}{18pt}_{\;\mathrm{no}\;z_i , z_j}=f(n)\ , \mathcal{s}^{m_1}(z_1\cdots z_{m_1-n } ) .
\end{split } \label{eq : appsu3-theoremauxiliary4}\ ] ] with the relations @xmath362{0.3pt}{18pt}_{\;\mathrm{no}\;z_i}&= & ( m_1-n)\,\mathcal{s}^{m_1}(z_1\cdots z_{m_1-n}),\\ \sum_{i\neq j}^{m_1}z_i\ , \mathcal{s}^{m_1 - 2}(z_1\cdots z_{m_1-n-1 } ) \rule[-8pt]{0.3pt}{18pt}_{\;\mathrm{no}\;z_i , z_j}&= & ( m_1-n)n\,\mathcal{s}^{m_1}(z_1\cdots z_{m_1-n}),\\ \sum_{i\neq j}^{m_1}z_iz_j\ , \mathcal{s}^{m_1 - 2}(z_1\cdots z_{m_1-n-2 } ) \rule[-8pt]{0.3pt}{18pt}_{\;\mathrm{no}\;z_i , z_j}&= & ( m_1-n)(m_1-n-1)\,\mathcal{s}^{m_1}(z_1\cdots z_{m_1-n}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can verify ( [ eq : appsu3-theoremauxiliary4 ] ) and deduce @xmath354 . this concludes the proof of the theorem .
consider for fixed and distinct @xmath328 the auxiliary function @xmath363 & + \sum_{k=2}^{m_2}w_k\prod^{m_1}_{j=2}\frac{z_j - w_k}{z_j - z_1 } \prod^{m_2}_{l\neq k}\frac{w_l - z_1}{w_l - w_k } \cdot\frac{w_1-z_1}{w_1-w_k}. \end{split } \label{eq : tc - auxiliaryfunction}\ ] ] in analogy to the proof in app .
[ app : onecolorontheorem ] it can be shown by using ( [ eq : xysum ] ) that ( [ eq : tc - auxiliaryfunction ] ) is entire , and that @xmath325 tends to a constant for @xmath330 . by liouville s theorem @xcite @xmath325 is constant , and hence ( [ eq : twocoltheorem ] ) is independent of the @xmath78 s .
we can choose the @xmath78 s as @xmath342 for @xmath343 , and @xmath344 with distinct values @xmath345 $ ] for @xmath346 .
then , the lhs of ( [ eq : twocoltheorem ] ) simplifies to @xmath364 using ( [ eq : calonot ] ) we can rewrite ( [ eq : twocoltheorem ] ) as @xmath365{0.3pt}{18pt}_{\;\mathrm{no}\;z_i}\ , \mathcal{s}^{m_1 - 1}(z_1\cdots z_{m_1-n-1 } ) \rule[-8pt]{0.3pt}{18pt}_{\;\mathrm{no}\;z_i}\\ & \quad=\,(m_1-m)\,\mathcal{s}^{m_1}(z_1\cdots z_{m_1-m } ) \,\mathcal{s}^{m_1}(z_1\cdots z_{m_1-n})\\ & \qquad\;-\sum_{\ell=1}^{\ell_\mathrm{m}}(m - n+2\ell)\ , \mathcal{s}^{m_1}(z_1\cdots z_{m_1-m-\ell})\ , \mathcal{s}^{m_1}(z_1\cdots z_{m_1-n+\ell } ) .
\end{split } \label{eq : tcaux8}\ ] ] as all terms in ( [ eq : tcaux8 ] ) are completely symmetric in the @xmath56 s , we simplify the notation by imagining to have written an operator @xmath366 around each term and then order all terms inside , we replace @xmath367 the remainder of the proof makes use of the auxiliary theorem _ proof : _ replace first the lhs as @xmath372 in order to obtain the contribution @xmath373 , @xmath374 coordinates out of @xmath375 have to match @xmath374 coordinates out of @xmath376 , which yields @xmath377 terms for @xmath378 .
the remaining @xmath379 coordinates out of @xmath375 match @xmath380 , which yields @xmath381 terms.@xmath382 now , by application of this lemma the first term on the rhs of ( [ eq : tcaux8 ] ) simplifies to @xmath383,\ ] ] where @xmath384 and we have used @xmath385 .
the second term on the rhs of ( [ eq : tcaux8 ] ) reads @xmath386.\ ] ] in this equation we change the order of the summations according to @xmath387 on the lhs of ( [ eq : tcaux8 ] ) at least @xmath388 is present and hence we find @xmath389,\ ] ] where @xmath390 . by considering each @xmath374 separately , ( [ eq : tcaux8 ] ) simplifies to @xmath391 for @xmath392 , ( [ eq : last ] ) is trivially satisfied . for @xmath393 , ( [ eq : last ] ) reduces to @xmath394 which is easily verified .
this completes the proof of theorem [ theo : twocolorons ] . | in a recent publication , we proposed two possible wave functions for the elementary excitations of the su(3 ) haldane shastry model ( hsm ) , but argued on very general grounds that only one or the other can be a valid excitation . here
we provide the explicit details of our calculation proving that the wave function describing a coloron excitation which transforms according to representation @xmath0 under su(3 ) rotations if the spins of the original model transform according to representation 3 , is exact .
we further provide an explicit construction of the exact color - polarized two - coloron eigenstates , and thereby show that colorons are free but that their relative momentum spacings are shifted according to fractional statistics with parameter @xmath1 .
we evaluate the su(3 ) spin currents .
finally , we interpret our results within the framework of the asymptotic bethe ansatz and generalize some of them to the case of su(@xmath2 ) . |
structure formation and evolution in the universe and the formation and growth of supermassive black holes ( smbhs ) are two fundamental problems in astronomy which are still not fully understood . while recent progresses in the cosmic microwave background , the high redshift type ia supernovae survey , and the large optical surveys have significantly improved our understanding of the evolution of large scale structure , there are still several gaps in the picture of structure formation . the data at redshift of @xmath23 , where most of the cosmic star formation might have taken place , is still very limited . on scales of galaxies and cluster of galaxies ,
the feed back process from galaxies or agns could significantly alter structure formation models where gravitation is the only driving force .
the clustering of active galactic nuclei ( agns ) provides unique path to the solution of these problems because ( 1 ) the agns are often bright compared to normal galaxies and are easily seen at large cosmological distance ; ( 2 ) agns trace the violent growth phase of smbhs and hence their clustering properties provide a link between the dark matter halo to the agn activity .
large scale agn surveys have been traditionally carried out in the optical band with dedicated telescopes .
the most recent of these are the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss , schneider et al .
2004 ) and the two degree field survey ( 2df , croom et al .
2005 , c05 hereafter ) .
these surveys have demonstrated that the clustering of agns can be used to measure cosmological parameters ( croom et al .
2004 ; outram et al .
2004 ) , and to constrain gravitational lensing ( myers et al .
2003 ) . however , as has been found in recent _ chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ deep surveys , a large fraction of x - ray detected agns show little or no activity in optical observations ( e.g. barger et al .
2005 ) , most probably due to obscuration ( fabian & iwasawa 1999 ) but possibly with some contribution from light dilution of the host galaxy ( moran , filippenko , & chornock 2002 ) , though barger et al .
( 2005 ) argue this is not a dominant factor .
this results in a large fraction of agns being missed in the optical surveys . on the other hand , hard x - rays ( @xmath24 kev )
is almost unaffected by obscuring column densities @xmath25 @xmath26 , and the x - ray emission from the host galaxies is low compared to the agns . thus hard x - rays are at present the best energy band to find agns ( mushotzky 2004 ) .
recent optical follow - ups of _ chandra _ deep surveys have revealed that the hard x - ray sources are mostly found around @xmath27 instead of @xmath28 as seen in optically selected quasar samples .
the low redshift population is dominated by non - broadline objects , while broadline agns are found mostly at higher redshifts ( steffen et al .
2003 ) . given these new discoveries , it is important to know how the clustering properties of x - ray and optical selected agn differ .
the most extensive x - ray agn surveys so far performed used the _
telescope ( mullis et al . 2004 ) .
because the telescope is not sensitive above 2 kev , _ rosat _ misses a large fraction of hard x - ray sources .
the relatively poor spatial resolution of rosat also limits the accuracy of optical identifications .
most of the _ rosat _ detected agns show broad emission lines in their optical spectra .
both the optical quasar surveys and the rosat surveys suggest that agns have correlation properties similar to the local galaxies .
the results seem to be independant of the sample medium redshifts .
this result is puzzling because agns are believed to be preferentially form in high density peaks where interactions between galaxies are more common , and interactions in turn are thought to be crucial in agn fueling ( di matteo , springel , & hernquist 2005 ) .
the mass of the dark matter halos that host agns are hence likely to be more massive .
the clustering results on hard x - ray agns are so far contradictory .
earlier studies of a small number of individual _ chandra _ fields seem to indicate that the hard band number counts in these small fields has fluctuations larger than expected from poisson noise ( cowie et al . 2002 ; manners et al .
2003 ) but the result is contradicted with larger samples of _ chandra _ fields ( kim et al .
basilakos et al .
( 2004 ) found a 4@xmath29 clustering signal in hard x - ray sources at @xmath30 using angular correlation functions on a xmm detected agn sample from a 2 deg@xmath0 survey .
a similar result was also found earlier in our 0.4 deg@xmath0 _ chandra _ field ( see below ) using the count - in - cells technique ( yang et al .
2003 ) . using the limber equation basilacos et al .
( 2004 ) argue that the hard x - ray sources are likely to be more strongly clustered than the optically selected agns .
gilli et al .
( 2003 ) reported the detection of large angular - redshift clustering in the chandra deep field south , which seems to be dominated by hard x - ray sources .
using the projected correlation function for the optically identified x - ray sources from the chandra deep field north ( cdfn ) and south ( cdfs ) , gilli et al .
( 2005 ) found that the average correlation amplitude in the cdfs is higher than that in the cdfn , and the latter is consistent with the correlation amplitude found in optically detected quasars . in this paper
, we report our spatial correlation function analysis of the optically identified x - ray sources in the _ chandra _ large area synoptic x - ray survey of the iso lockman hole northwest region ( clasxs ) .
clasxs is so far the largest contiguous _ chandra _ deep field with a high level of spectroscopic identifications .
the size of the field is chosen to reduce the cosmic variance in the x - ray background to @xmath31 ( yang et al .
for comparison , we have also analyzed the correlation functions for the cdfn field , using the published x - ray catalog by alexander et al .
( 2003 ) and the optical catalog of barger et al .
( 2003 ) . because the two surveys use basically the same optical instruments in the follow - up observations , and thus have the same accuracy in redshift measurements
, the comparison is relatively straight forward .
the logn - logs of the cdfn agrees well with that of clasxs , also indicating that the cdfn is a `` typical '' field .
the depth of the cdfn is very useful in probing the correlation function at small separations . in [ sec_obs_data ]
we summarize our observations and data analysis . in [ sec_methods ]
we discuss the methodology we use in the clustering analysis .
the results of the correlation functions are presented in [ sec_results ] .
the evolution of agn clustering is presented in [ sec_evolution ] . in
[ sec_discussion ] we discussion the implications of our results .
finally summarize our results in [ sec_conclusion ] . throughout this paper , unless noted otherwise , we assume @xmath32 and a flat universe with @xmath33 and @xmath34 .
clasxs is a 0.4 deg@xmath0 contiguous field centered at @xmath35 , @xmath36 ( j2000 ) in the very low galactic absorption lockman hole northwest region .
it is the deepest 170@xmath37 m survey field observed by isophot instrument on board _ iso _ , and has recently been observed by the _ spitzer space telescope _
( lonsdale et al .
the _ chandra _
observation consists of 9 acis - i pointings separated from each other by @xmath38 to allow a close to uniform sky coverage .
the center field has an exposure time of @xmath39 ks while the other eight pointings , have exposure times of @xmath40 ks .
the exposure time were designed to give a uniform flux limit of @xmath41 , which is about a factor of 2 below the `` knee '' of the logn - logs curve .
this choice of sensitivity allows a proper sampling of the x - ray background sources and also achieves a highest source finding efficiency .
the sub - arcsecond spatial resolution of _ chandra _ observatory allows an unambiguous optical identification of the x - ray sources , particularly , for those which appear to be normal galaxies in optical band .
combined with follow - ups using the large keck and subaru optical telescopes , we identified and measured the redshifts in a large fraction of the x - ray detected agns in our survey .
the details and the catalogs of the survey can be found in yang et al .
( 2004 ) and steffen et al .
we performed spectroscopic observations for @xmath42 of the 525 detected x - ray sources .
a total of 272 spectroscopic redshifts have been obtained , while the spectra of the rest of the sources have a signal - to - noise ratio too low to obtain secure redshift measurements .
the redshift distribution of the identified sources are shown in figure [ z_dist ] .
the fraction of sources with spectroscopic redshift as a function of hard x - ray flux is shown in figure [ optical_id ] .
the 2 ms cdfn is so far the deepest _ chandra _ field , reaching a flux limit of @xmath43 ( alexander et al . 2003 ) .
this is @xmath44 times deeper than the clasxs field .
the areal density of sources in cdfn is also @xmath45 times higher .
the optical observation were performed using the same telescope as clasxs ( barger et al .
we use the published catalog , which contains 306 sources with spectroscopic redshift .
the redshift distribution of the cdfn sources is also shown in figure [ z_dist ] .
the fainter x - ray sources in the cdfn are more likely to be found at low redshift , @xmath46 , compared to the clasxs sources .
to quantify spatial clustering in a point process , the most commonly used technique is the two point correlation function . in short , a two point correlation function measures the excess probability of finding a pair of objects as a function of pair separation ( peebles 1980 ) .
@xmath47dv_{1}dv_{2 } \label{acf_def}\ ] ] where @xmath48 is the mean density and @xmath49 is the _ comoving _ distance between two sources .
observations of low redshift galaxies and clusters of galaxies show that the correlation function of these objects over a wide range of scales can be described by a power - law @xmath50 with @xmath51 ( peebles 1980 ; peacock 1999 ) .
it should be noted that the correlation function is in fact a function of redshift , which we will discuss in [ sec_evolution ] . because of the small sample sizes of most of the agn surveys , correlation functions over very wide redshift ranges are commonly used .
this only makes sense if the clustering is almost constant in comoving coordinates .
fortunately , this is very close to the truth , as we shall see in [ sec_evolution ] .
the nominal distance between sources calculated using the sky coordinates of the sources and their redshifts is sometimes called distance in _ redshift - space _ , we shall use @xmath52 instead of @xmath53 to indicate the distance calculated this way .
it is apparent that the line - of - sight peculiar velocity of the sources could also contribute to the measured redshift ( redshift distortion ) .
this effect is most important at separations smaller than the correlation length .
the projected correlation function , which computes the integrated correlation function along the line - of - sight and is not affected by redshift distortion , is often used to obtain the real - space correlation function ( peebles 1980 ) .
the projection , however , could make the correlation signal more difficult to measure . in small fields like the cdfn , the projected correlation function
is also restricted by the field size , and could be affected by cosmic variance .
we will calculate both the redshift - space and projected correlation functions in this paper .
this allows us to estimate the effects of redshift distortion . following davis & peebles 1983
, we define @xmath54 and @xmath55 to be the positions of two sources in the redshift - space , @xmath56 to be the redshift - space separation , and @xmath57 to be the mean distance to the pair of sources .
we can then compute the correlation function @xmath58 on a two dimensional grid , where @xmath59 and @xmath60 are separations along and across the line - of - sight respectively : @xmath61 @xmath62 the projected correlation function is defined as the line - of - sight integration of @xmath58 : @xmath63 where @xmath64 is the line - of - sight separation .
it has been shown ( davis & peebles 1983 ) that , when @xmath65 , @xmath66 satisfies a simple relation with the real - space correlation function .
if a power - law form in equation [ powerlaw ] is assumed , then @xmath67 in practice , the integration is not performed to very large separations because the major contribution to the projected signal comes from separations of a few times the correlation length @xmath68 .
integrating to larger @xmath59 will only add noise to the results .
after testing various scales , we found @xmath69 mpc produces consistent results for our samples . to obtain an unbiased estimate of the correlation function
, we must correct for selection effects .
usually , these selection effects are treated using random samples generated with computer simulations . by comparing the simulated and observed pair distributions ,
the selection functions effectively cancel .
we compute the correlation function using the minimum variance estimator @xmath70 where @xmath71 , @xmath72 and @xmath73 are the numbers of data - data , data - random and random - random pairs respectively , with comoving distances @xmath74 ( l - s estimator , landy & szalay 1993 ) .
the random catalog is produced through simulations described below to account for the selection effects in observations .
the random catalog usually contains a very large number of objects so that the poisson noise introduced is negligible .
we have checked our results using both l - s and the davis - peebles estimators ( davis & peebles 1983 ) and found very good agreement between the two methods .
there are two terms in the uncertainty of the correlation function : the statistical fluctuations and the cosmic variance .
the statistical uncertainty of the correlation function is estimated assuming the error of the dr and rr pairs are zero , and the uncertainty of dd is poissonian , @xmath75 in the case of small dd , where @xmath76 underestimates the error , we use the approximation formula ( gehrels 1986 ) to calculate the poisson upper and lower limits .
since the dds are in fact correlated , the use of poisson errors could underestimate the real uncertainty . in the literature _ bootstrap _ resampling ( efron 1982 ) is often used to calculate the errors of the correlation function .
the method is particularly useful in cases when the probability distribution function ( pdf ) of the variable is unknown , or in cases when the variables are derived from poissonian distributed data using complex transformations , which results in rather complex pdfs .
mo , jing , & boerner ( 1992 ) showed that in the case of large dd , the bootstrap error is @xmath77 of the poisson error .
we use poisson errors in our redshift - space correlation function estimates .
on the other hand , we use bootstrap methods when estimating the uncertainties of the projected correlation function .
this is because the numerical integration used in equation [ wp ] make it difficult to apply poisson errors directly .
cosmic variance is known to affect the estimation of the mean density when applied to small samples of normal galaxies from optical surveys .
such effect , however , is likely to be small on our x - ray selected agn sample for the following reasons .
the volumn of our survey is very large compared to the typical pensil - beam optical survey of normal galaxies that typically covers very narrow redshift ranges . on the other hand , the number density of agns is much lower than that of the normal galaxies , making it hard to trace individual structures at high enough sampling rate .
the window function of the spectroscopic follow - up in our survey is also very flat over a wide redshift range ( except in the redshift desert at @xmath78 ) .
the combination of these factors makes it very difficult for a small number of structures been over sampled and thus producing incorrect estimation of the mean density .
however , for ultra deep surveys with field size of a single _ chandra _ field , small number of velocity spikes can indeed affect the correlation analysis , as seen in the case of the chandra deep field south .
such structure , however , will affect number counts in the field at flux levels comparable to the depth of clasxs .
based on the very good agreement among the number counts found in the clasxs , cdfn , and other deep surveys ( yang et al .
2004 ) , we believe the uncertainty from cosmic variance on the whole sample is likely to be small
. however , the cosmic variance effect on subsamples could still be important , as seen in
[ sec_evolution ] .
in such cases , using statistical uncertainty alone could underestimates the true uncertainty . to account for the observational selection and edge effects
, we perform extensive simulations to construct a mock catalog .
the _ chandra _ detection sensitivity is not uniform because of vignetting effects , quantum efficiency changes across the field and the broadening of the point spread functions .
the consequence is that the sensitivity of source detection drops monotonically with off - axis angles . to quantify this we generate simulated observations of our 40 ks and 70 ks exposure in both soft and hard bands . using _
( freeman et al .
2002 ) on these images we obtain an estimate of the detection probability function at different fluxes and off - axis angles ( figure [ det_prob ] ) . with this probability , we can generate randomly distributed sources with the x - ray selection effects to the first order .
we use this method instead of running detections on a large number of simulated images because the detection program runs very slowly on these images .
we generate source fluxes based on the best fit logn - logs from yang et al .
( 2004 ) and then `` detections '' are run on each of the images . the resulting catalogs from all the nine simulated images are then merged in the same way as for the real data .
the resulting random source distribution and the resulting cumulative counts are shown in figure [ simulation ] .
we next consider the optical selection effects .
since our spectroscopic observation is close to complete for all sources with r@xmath79 , the sky coverage is uniform and only a very small number of sources which are very close to each other could be missed .
this might reduce the power at very small scales .
the redshift distribution of the sources shows a very weak dependence on the x - ray flux ( figure [ z_flux ] ) , which is due largely to the very broad luminosity function of agns .
we can thus `` scramble '' the observed redshifts and assign them to the simulated sample without introducing a significant bias .
the major selection effect in our optical observation is that the optical identifications are biased toward brighter sources .
we select the simulated sources based on their x - ray flux using the best - fit curve in figure [ optical_id ] as a probability function .
the optical selection removes a large fraction of x - ray dim sources and therefore reduces the non - uniformity in the angular distribution caused by the x - ray selection effects .
the redshift of the random sources were sampled from a gaussian smoothed ( @xmath80 ) redshift distribution from the observations .
the purpose of the smoothing is to remove possible redshift clustering in the random sample but still preserve the effect of the selection function .
we tested different smoothing scales @xmath81 and found the resulting correlation function effectively unchanged .
we calculate the redshift - space correlation function in the clasxs sample for non - stellar sources with @xmath82 and 28 kev fluxes @xmath83 , assuming constant clustering in comoving coordinates .
the total number of sources in the sample is 233 .
the median redshift of the sample is 1.2 .
by comparing the number of detected pairs with separations @xmath84 mpc with that expected by simulation , we found that on scales of 20 mpc , the significance of clustering is @xmath85 .
we use the maximum likelihood method in searching for the best - fit parameters ( cash 1979 ; popowski et al .
1998 ; mullis et al .
the method is preferable to the commonly used @xmath86 method because it is less affected by arbitrary binning .
the method uses very small bins so that each bin contains only 1 or 0 dd pair . in this limit
, the probability associated with each bin is close to independent .
the expected number of dd pairs in each bin is calculated using the dr , rr pairs using the mock catalog .
the likelihood is defined as @xmath87 where @xmath88 is the expected number of pairs in each bin and @xmath89 is the observed number of pairs . the likelihood ratio defined as @xmath90 where @xmath91 is the maximum likelihood .
the resulting @xmath92 approaches the usual @xmath86 distribution . since the maximum - likelihood does not provide a measure of the `` goodness - of - fit '' , we quote the @xmath93 derived from the binned correlation function ( as shown in the figures ) and the best - fit parameters from maximum - likelihood estimates .
we fit the correlation functions over three separation ranges . in figure [ clasxs_cor ]
we show the correlation function and the best - fit with 3 mpc@xmath7200 mpc .
the best - fit parameters for all three separation ranges are listed in table [ z_space_cor ] .
it is noticeable that the rather large @xmath93 seems to suggest that the single power - law model may not be a proper description of the data . for comparison
, we also computed the correlation function of the x - ray sources in cdfn in the same redshift interval .
we created a mock catalog 50 times larger than the observation .
the positions and redshifts of the random sources are generated by randomizing the observed positions and redshifts .
a large poisson noise was added to avoid artificial clustering in the mock catalog .
such randomization is justified because the clustering signal in a small field like the cdfn mainly comes from clustering along the line - of - sight direction .
the randomized sky coordinates are filtered using an image mask to take into account the edge effects .
we include all the non - stellar sources in the same redshift interval as we use for clasxs , which results in 252 sources in the sample .
the best - fit parameters for cdfn field over three scale ranges are also shown in table [ z_space_cor ] . the correlation function over 1 mpc@xmath7100 mpc
is shown in figure [ cdfn_cor ] .
there is a good agreement of the correlation lengths obtained in the two fields .
there seems to be a systematic flattening of the slope at small separations ( @xmath94 mpc ) in both samples .
when the correlation functions are fitted at small and large separations independently , the resulting @xmath93s are systematically smaller .
the projected correlation function is computed using the methods described in [ subsec_corr_func ] .
to test the method , we first compute the projected correlation function for the cdfn and compare the results with that published in gilli et al .
we selected the same redshift interval for the clasxs field .
a two dimensional correlation function is calculated on a @xmath95 grid on the ( @xmath96,@xmath59 ) plane .
the 5 intervals along @xmath96 axis covers 0.1620 mpc .
we integrate the resulting two dimensional correlation function along the line - of - sight to a @xmath97 mpc . our projected correlation function for cdfn
is shown figure [ projected ] , and it agrees perfectly with that reported in gilli et al .
( 2005 ) for @xmath98 , validating the techniques used in this paper .
we next compute the projected correlation function for the clasxs field .
the correlation function is calculated on scales of @xmath99 mpc .
the 2-d correlation function is integrated to @xmath100 mpc .
the result is also shown in figure [ projected ] .
the correlation functions of the cdfn and clasxs fields agree in general at @xmath101 mpc , where both surveys have very good s / n .
the slope , however , appears to be flatter in the cdfn field .
we perform a @xmath93 fit to the correlation functions using equation [ wp_n_real ] .
the best - fit parameters for the cdfn are @xmath15 mpc , @xmath16 , and the reduced @xmath102 .
this is in good agreement with the result from gilli et al .
( 2005 , @xmath103 mpc , @xmath104 ) .
the quoted errors in that paper is smaller than we obtained , but since we adopt a bootstrap error instead of poisson error in this analysis , the difference is expected .
the best - fit parameters for the clasxs field are @xmath13 mpc , @xmath105 , and the reduced @xmath106 .
the correlation length appears to be higher than that of the cdfn , but agrees within the errors .
the slope also seems steeper than that of the cdfn and agrees better with the slope of the redshift - space correlation function at @xmath107 mpc . since the clasxs sample does not cover separations @xmath108 mpc very well , it is hard to see a slope change in this sample alone . since the cdfn and clasxs connect very well at separations where both surveys are sensitive , we try to model the combined data points with a single power - law .
this yields @xmath109 mpc , @xmath110 , and @xmath111 .
the reduced @xmath93 is much worse than the two samples fitted separately , but does not reject the hypothesis of a single power - law fit .
this seems to suggest that the slope of the correlation function flattens at small separations .
such a trend need to be looked more closely with future large agn surveys with better signal - to - noise .
redshift distortion affects the correlation function ( power - spectrum ) by increasing the redshift - space correlation amplitude and changing the shape of the 2-d redshift - space correlation function at small scales ( such as the well known `` finger - of - god '' effect , e.g. hamilton 1992 ) .
since our data is too noisy at small separations to detect the effect , we only discuss the effect of the amplitude boosting of correlation function in redshift - space .
kaiser ( 1987 ) showed that to the first order , @xmath112 where @xmath113 and @xmath114 is bias . in principle , the redshift - space distortion can be estimated by comparing @xmath115 and @xmath116 . to quantify the effect
, we use the correlation function estimates at scales where both projected and redshift - space correlation functions are well determined . for the cdfn , we chose the correlation function estimates at 10 mpc and find @xmath117 , if the best - fit of @xmath115 on 1 - 100 mpc is used .
the choice of this scale is justified given that the slope possibly changes below and above 10 mpc , as seen in the projected correlation function .
since the slope of the redshift- and real - space correlation function is very similar in the cdfn , the ratio is almost constant .
for the clasxs field , we chose to estimate the ratio at 20 mpc , where the s / n is the best .
we find @xmath118 by using the best - fit on 1100 mpc for @xmath115 .
the ratio changes slowly with the scales probed , but is within the errors .
we find a general agreement between clasxs and cdfn .
to avoid the arbitrary choice of scales , and to make the best use of the data , we combine the two samples to study the redshift distortion effect on @xmath119 . since the projected correlation function of cdfn and and clasxs agree in general , we are encouraged to assume that the the two samples , even with the vast difference in flux limits , generally trace the large scale structure in the same way . in figure [ z_distortion ] .
we show the combined @xmath119 .
the contours show no significant signature of nonlinear redshift distortion , such as the `` finger - of - god '' .
we fit @xmath119 with equation [ distortion ] , assuming the best - fit parameters for the real - space correlation function from the combined sample ( @xmath120 mpc , @xmath121 ) , and ignoring the higher order redshift distortions .
we generate the 2-d correlation function at each grid point . by minimizing @xmath93 by changing @xmath122
, we found the best - fit @xmath17 , corresponding to @xmath123 , which agrees with the estimates from individual fields above . by fixing @xmath124
, we can estimate the bias factor of x - ray selected agns from @xmath122 .
the median redshift of the combined sample is 0.94 , and @xmath125 gives @xmath126 .
this yields @xmath127 using the relation @xmath128 .
we further test if there is any differences in clustering properties between the hard and soft spectra sources in the clasxs sample .
we use the hardness ratio , defined as @xmath129 ( where @xmath130 is the count rate ) , to quantify the spectral shape of the x - ray sources .
correlation functions of soft ( @xmath131 ) and hard ( @xmath132 ) sources are calculated the same way as above .
the fraction of broad - line agns is 56.4% in the soft sample and 15.4% in hard sample .
the median redshifts are 1.25 and 0.94 for soft and hard samples , respectively .
we compute @xmath115 for both soft and hard sources over scales of 3200 mpc . using a maximum - likelihood fit
, we found @xmath133 mpc , @xmath134 for hard sources and @xmath135 mpc , @xmath136 for soft sources .
we found no significant difference in clustering between the soft and hard sources .
this agrees with the results of gilli et al .
it is noticeable that the soft sources have a higher median redshift than the hard sources .
the interpretation of this result must include evolution effects . to avoid this complication , we restricted the redshift range to @xmath137 .
the best - fit parameters are @xmath138 mpc ( @xmath139 mpc ) and @xmath140 ( @xmath141 ) for hard ( soft ) sources .
the difference in clustering parameters between soft and hard sources are well within the measurement error . the same analysis on cdfn yields similar results .
thus there is no significant dependence of clustering on the x - ray color .
the cold dark matter ( cdm ) model of hierarchical structure formation predicts that massive ( and hence luminous ) galaxies are formed in rare peaks , and therefore should be more strongly clustered .
this is seen in normal galaxies ( e.g. giavalisco & dickinson 2001 ) . whether this relation can be extended to x - ray luminosity of agns
is unknown .
this is because the x - ray luminosity relates to the dark matter halo mass in a more complex and not well understood way .
the x - ray luminosity is directly linked to the accretion process , and the process is affected by factors such as accretion rate , radiative efficiency , blackhole mass and the details of the accretion process .
we have shown that at least in broadline agns , where the blackhole mass can be inferred from the line - width and nuclear luminosity , the eddington ratio is close to constant over two decades of 28 kev luminosity ( barger et al .
if this is the case for all x - ray selected agns , we should expect the agn luminosity to be mainly determined by the blackhole mass , which in turn , should be closely related to the halo mass ( ferrarese 2002 ) , even though the exact form of this relation is highly uncertain .
however , optical quasar surveys such as 2df found little evidence of a correlation between clustering amplitude and ensemble luminosity ( c05 ) , perhaps due to the small dynamical range in luminosity these surveys probe .
the x - ray luminosity of sources in the clasxs and cdfn cover a luminosity range of four orders of magnitudes , making it possible to make such a test .
the 28 kev rest frame luminosity @xmath142 is calculated from the hard band fluxes , with a k - correction made assuming a power - law spectra with photon index @xmath143 .
this yields @xmath144 where @xmath145 is the luminosity in observer s 2 - 8 kev band . in figure [ lum_dist ]
we show @xmath142 vs. redshift for both clasxs and cdfn . for a better comparison of the correlation amplitude
, we adopt the averaged correlation function within @xmath146 mpc , @xmath147 the quantity is chosen rather than @xmath148 because it measures the clustering ( directly linked to the rms fluctuations ) regardless of the shape of the correlation function . on scales of 20 mpc
the clustering is in the linear regime of density fluctuations .
the error in @xmath149 is from the single parameter @xmath150 confidence interval obtained by fixing the slope of the correlation function to the best - fit .
we split the clasxs ( cdfn ) sample into two subsamples at @xmath151 ( @xmath152 ) so that each subsample contain similar number of objects . in table
[ tab_lum ] we show the maximum - likelihood fits as well as @xmath149s .
it should be noted that the correlation amplitude is biased in redshift space .
the dominant part of this bias is characterized in equation [ distortion ] . comparing with other observations ( e.g. da ^ angela et al . 2005 ) ,
@xmath122 is likely a weak function of redshift in the redshift range probed by our sample , with @xmath153 ( [ sec_z_distortion ] ) , this translates to @xmath123 .
we correct the @xmath149 s for this bias by dividing them by 1.3 .
the correlation amplitude for the more luminous sources appears to be higher than that of the less luminous sources , which qualitatively agrees with expectations that x - ray luminosity reflects the dark matter halo mass .
the correlation amplitude for the more luminous subsamples are @xmath154 and @xmath155 higher than that of the less bright subsample in the clasxs and cdfn fields , respectively . however , since the more luminous subsamples also are preferentially found at higher redshifts , the evolution in @xmath115 should be taken into account . to reduce this complication , we restrict ourselves to sources within the redshift range of 0.31.5 , where the evolution effect is relatively small ( see also [ sec_evolution ] ) . in figure [ lum_depend ]
we show @xmath142 vs. @xmath149 for both clasxs and cdfn . by reducing the redshift range , the difference in correlation amplitude between the brighter and dimmer subsample
is significantly reduced , in the cdfn sample , to merely @xmath150 . for the clasxs field ,
on the other hand , the correlation amplitude for both subsamples do not show significant change . for comparison
, we also plot in figure [ lum_depend ] the correlation amplitude from the 2df survey ( c05 ) .
the x - ray luminosities for the qsos in the 2df are obtained by dividing the bolometric luminosities by 35 ( elvis et al .
we perform spearman s @xmath156 test for correlations between @xmath157 and @xmath158 .
we found the correlation coefficient @xmath159 for x - ray samples , or a corresponding null probability of 20% , indicating a weak correlation between the two quantities .
if the 2df samples are added , we found @xmath160 , and a null probability of 17% .
this means that with the x - ray sample , we have detected a weak correlation between clustering and luminosity .
we will discuss this in [ sec_xi_lx ] .
measuring the correlation function over a wide redshift range only makes sense if the correlation function is a weak function of redshift .
the best measurements of clustering of 2df quasars at high redshift show that the correlation function indeed exhibits only mild evolution ( c05 ) . in this section , we test the evolution of clustering of x - ray selected agns and compare them with other survey results .
we study the evolution of clustering in both clasxs and cdfn samples , using the redshift - space correlation function .
the sources are grouped in 4 redshift intervals from 0.1 to 3 .
the sizes of the intervals are chosen so that the number of objects in each interval is similar in the clasxs sample .
this result in a very wide redshift bin above @xmath161 .
the correlation functions for the clasxs , cdfn and clasxs+cdfn fields are shown in figures [ z_dep_clasxs ] , [ z_dep_cdfn ] , and [ z_dep_comb ] , respectively .
we group the pair separations in 10 bins in these figures to show the shape of the correlation function . in some bins there
could be no dd pairs , and the correlation function is set to -1 without errors .
we model the correlation functions using single power - laws and fit the data using the maximum - likelihood method .
as we mentioned earlier , the method is not affected by binning .
we found on 350 mpc scales that a single power - law provides a good fit to the data except , for the the @xmath162 interval in the cdfn , where the sample is too sparse and have very few close separation pairs , we use a separation range of 5200 mpc to obtain the fit .
the goodness - of - fit is quantified with @xmath93 . in the case where empty bins exist
, we increase the bin sizes until no bins are empty before we compute the @xmath93 .
the results are summarized in table [ tab_evolution ] and the @xmath149s as a function of redshift are shown in figure [ evolution3 ] .
we have tested fitting the correlation functions over different scale ranges , and found no significant difference in the resulting @xmath149s .
there is only mild evolution seen in both the clasxs and cdfn fields , in agreement with the assumption that clustering is close to constant in comoving coordinates .
there are some small discrepancies between the clasxs and the cdfn clustering strength .
these discrepancies give the sense of the field - to - field uncertainty and could be resolved with future larger surveys . at the highest redshift
, both samples show an increase trend of clustering , but only at the @xmath163 level . in figure [ evolution_compare ]
we plot @xmath149 as a function of redshift for clasxs , the combined clasxs and cdfn , as well as results from the 2df ( c05 ) , the _ rosat _ north galactic pole survey ( ngp , mullis et al .
2004 ) , and the asiago - eso / rass qso survey ( aerqs , grazian et al .
we did not correct for redshift distortion for observations which uses redshift - space correlation function .
this leads to overestimates of the real - space correlation amplitude .
our correlation functions show clear agreement with the evolution trend found in c05 . however , as seen in
[ sec_l_dependence ] , our measured correlation amplitude on average appears similar as that of 2df , even though the average luminosity of latter is much higher than that of the x - ray samples .
we compare the x - ray luminosities of the clasxs and clasxs+cdfn samples with those of the 2df in figure [ lum_comp ] .
the x - ray luminosities of 2df quasars are obtained the same way as in [ sec_l_dependence ] .
the luminosity difference between the 2df sample and x - ray samples is the largest at low redshift and decreases at higher redshift . at @xmath164 , the x - ray sample and the 2df samples have similar median luminosity .
the similarity in clustering amplitude can be understood in the light of the weak correlation between agn luminosity and clustering amplitude found in [ sec_l_dependence ] .
however , as we will see in [ sec_xi_lx ] , a correlation between dark halo mass and the x - ray luminosity predicts a rapid increase of correlation function above @xmath165 .
therefore , we should expect the optical sample being more clustered than x - ray samples at medium redshifts .
such a trend is not clearly seen in our samples .
the bias evolution of optical quasar is extensively discussed in c05 .
they found that the bias increases rapidly with redshift(@xmath166 ) .
we will follow these arguments to estimate the bias evolution of the x - ray samples . on scales of 20 mpc ,
the clustering of dark matter and agns are both in the linear regime , i.e. , @xmath167 .
this allows us to measure the bias , defined as the ratio of rms fluctuation of the luminous matter ( agns in our case ) and that of the underlying total mass , as a function of redshift by comparing the observed correlation function with the linear growth rate . in terms of correlation function
, the bias can be written as @xmath168 the averaged correlation function of mass can be obtained using @xmath169 where @xmath170 $ ] , @xmath171 is the rms fluctuation of mass at @xmath172 obtained by _ wmap
_ observation ( spergel et al . 2003 ) , and we choose the best - fit @xmath173 .
@xmath174 is the linear growth factor , for which we use the approximation formula from carroll , press , & turner ( 1992 ) .
the redshift - space distortion is taken into account to the first order through equation [ distortion ] and the bias factor is solved numerically . the result is shown in table [ tab_bias ] . the estimate of @xmath175 in the combined sample agrees with the result from the redshift - space distortion analysis in [ sec_z_distortion ] . in figure [ bias_mass](a )
we show the bias estimates for the cdfn and clasxs+cdfn samples .
the best - fit model from c05 qualitatively agrees with the x - ray results .
the simplest model for bias evolution is that the agns are formed at high redshift , and evolve according to the continuity equation ( nusser & davis 1994 ; fry 1996 ) .
the model is sometimes called the _ conserving model _ or the _ test particle model_. by normalizing the bias to @xmath172 , the model can be written as @xmath176 this model is shown in figure [ bias_mass](a ) as dash - dotted line .
the model produces a bias evolution which is slightly too shallow at high redshifts . the correlation function evolution based on this model
is also shown in figure [ evolution_compare ] , where it underpredicts the observed @xmath177 .
the model predicts a decrease of correlation function at high redshift , which is not true based on our results and that of the 2df .
this implies that the agns observed in the local universe are unlikely to have formed at @xmath178 .
one of the direct predictions of cdm structure formation scenario is that the bias is determined by the dark halo mass .
mo & white ( 1996 ) found a simple relation between the minimum mass of the dark matter halo and the bias @xmath179 . by adopting the more general formalism by sheth ,
mo , & tormen ( 2001 ) we can compute the `` typical '' dark halo mass of the sample .
it should be noted that the method assumes that halos are formed through violent collapse or mergers of smaller halos and hence is best applied at large separations , where the halo - halo term dominates the correlation function .
this requirement is apparently satisfied by agns .
following sheth , mo , & tormen ( 2001 ) , @xmath180 , \label{smt}\ ] ] where @xmath181 , a = 0.707 , c = 0.6 .
@xmath182 is the critical overdensity .
@xmath183 is the rms density fluctuation in the linear density field and evolves as @xmath184 where @xmath185 can be obtained from the power spectrum of density perturbation @xmath186 convolved with a top - hat window function @xmath187 , @xmath188 at the scale of interest ( @xmath189 mpc ) , the power spectrum can be approximated with a power - law , @xmath190 , with @xmath191 for cdm type spectrum .
integrating equation [ sigma0 ] gives @xmath192 where @xmath193 is the mean mass within @xmath194 mpc .
we can then solve equation [ smt ] for halo mass .
the resulting mass is shown in table [ tab_bias ] and figure [ bias_mass](b ) .
consistent with what s been found in c05 for the 2df , the halo mass does not show any evolution trend with redshift .
we found @xmath195 , which is consistent with the 2df estimates ( c05 , grazian et al .
2004 ) .
we have shown that over a very wide range of luminosity , the clustering amplitude of agns change very little .
this allows us to put useful constrains on the correlations among x - ray luminosity , blackhole mass @xmath196 , and the dark matter halo @xmath197 . using the equivalent width of broad emission lines as mass estimators , barger et al .
( 2005 ) found that the eddington ratio of broadline agns may be close to constant .
since the hard x - ray luminosity is an isotropic indicator of the bolometric luminosity , this implies that the blackhole mass is linearly correlated with x - ray luminosity .
barger et al .
( 2005 ) found that @xmath198 where @xmath199 is @xmath142 in units of @xmath200 .
a similar result is found at low redshift using a sample of broadline agns with mass estimates based on reverberation mapping relations ( kaspi et al .
2000 ; yang 2005 ) .
the relation , however , is only tested for broadline agns . deviations from this relation is also expected at low luminosities since many low luminosity agns tend to have a low eddington ratio ( ho 2005 ) .
blackhole mass have been shown to correlate with velocity dispersion of the spheroidal component of the host galaxies ( gebhardt et al .
2000 ; ferrarese & merritt 2000 ) .
this leads to a linear correlation between @xmath196 and the mass of spherical component .
this relation , however , could be different at high redshift ( akiyama 2005 ) . how these relationships translate to the @xmath201 relation
is also unclear and could likely be nonlinear .
ferrarese ( 2002 ) showed that @xmath196
@xmath197 can be modeled with a scaling law @xmath202 with @xmath203 and @xmath204 determined by the halo mass profile . combining the above and using equation [ smt ]
, we can calculate the correlation amplitude as a function of x - ray luminosity . in figure [ lum_depend ]
we show the model expectations compared with the observations from clasxs , cdfn and 2df . in calculating the bias
we have assumed the nonlinear power - law index @xmath205 in equation [ sigma0_m ] ( peacock 1999 ) , with the best fit @xmath206 .
the three lines represent three different halo profiles discussed in ferrarese ( 2002 ) .
we found that the @xmath207 relation is in fact dominated by the very nonlinear relation between halo mass and correlation amplitude .
the difference between different halo profiles is caused mainly by the normalization @xmath203 , or the fractional mass of blackhole mass , rather than the power - law index @xmath204 .
one of the important model predictions is that the correlation between x - ray luminosity and clustering is weak below @xmath208 and increases rapidly above that .
the lack of rapid change of correlation amplitude indicates the halo mass of agn can not be significantly higher than the corresponding threshold . under the assumed cosmology and bias model ,
the @xmath207 relation based on the weak lensing derived halo mass profile ( seljak 2002 ) is consistent with the data , while the nfw profile ( navarro , frenk , & white 1997 ) and the isothermal profile predicts a too steep correlation amplitude curve at high luminosity .
however , we can not rule out these profiles as a reasonable descriptions of the agn host halo because of the uncertainty in the shape of the correlation function and the fractional blackhole mass in dark halos at the redshift of our sample . in figure [ lum_depend ]
we also mark the model dark halo mass corresponding to the seljak ( 2002 ) mass profile .
the average correlation amplitude of the combined optical and x - ray sample ( dotted - line ) corresponds to a halo mass of @xmath209 . while the luminosity in our sample ranges over five orders of magnitudes , the range of halo mass may be much smaller .
the 2df sample has a high luminosity but has a similar or lower average correlation amplitude than that of the x - ray samples .
it is possible that the optical selection technique tends to select sources with a higher eddington ratio .
the correlation amplitude of the cdfn sample at @xmath210 , on the other hand , is higher than the model predictions .
this is expected because many agns with such luminosities are liners which are probably accreting with a low radiative efficiency .
it is now clear that the weak luminosity dependence of agn clustering is consistent with the simplest model based on the observed @xmath211 and @xmath201 relations , given the large error in the correlation functions . a large dynamical range in x - ray luminosity , as well as better measurements of correlation function ,
are needed to better quantify this relation .
the luminosity range of the 2df survey is too small and the optical selection method also likely is biased to high eddington ratio sources . by increasing our current clasxs field by a factor of a few will be helpful in better determine the luminosity dependence of agn clustering , and to put tighter constrains on agn hosts .
we look again at the @xmath196@xmath197 relation in the light of the mass estimates of the dark matter halos from _ chandra _ samples .
if the ferrarese ( 2002 ) relation is independent of redshift , the nearly constant dark halo mass implies little evolution for the blackhole mass . on the other hand ,
strong luminosity evolution is seen since @xmath212 in hard x - ray selected agns ( barger et al . 2005 ) .
this implies a systematic decrease of the ensemble eddington ratio with cosmic time .
barger et al .
( 2005 ) showed that the characteristic luminosity of hard x - ray selected agns @xmath213 where @xmath214 and @xmath215 for @xmath216 .
ueda et al . ( 2003 ) found a similar result with a slightly shallower slope .
if the typical blackhole mass does not change with redshift , the observed luminosity evolution indicates the ensemble eddington ratio increase by a factor of @xmath189 from @xmath172 to @xmath217 .
it is hard to understand such a change of the typical eddington ratio with redshift .
one possibility is that a large number of compton thick agns at @xmath27 are missed in the _ chandra _ surveys ( e.g. worsley et al . 2005 ) , leading to the observed strong luminosity evolution . alternatively , instead of @xmath196@xmath197 being independent of redshift
, the @xmath196@xmath218 could be unchanged with cosmic time , as suggested by shields et al .
this is theoretically attractive because the feedback regulated growth of blackholes implies a constant @xmath196@xmath218 relation .
this implies that @xmath196@xmath197 is in fact a function of redshift .
wyithe & loeb ( 2003 ) proposed a model(wl model here after ) showing that the blackhole mass inferred from the halo mass increases with redshift .
croom et al .
( 2005 ) show that this could lead to a close to constant eddington ratio in the 2df sample if the optical luminosity is used to compare with the derived @xmath196 . since the correlation function is only a weak function of luminosity , as we have demonstrated in
[ sec_l_dependence ] , it is better to estimate the evolution of the eddington ratio using the characteristic mass of the blackholes from the wl model , and the characteristic luminosity from equation [ l_star ] . in figure
[ eddington ] , we show the derived ensemble eddington ratio , assuming the dark halo mass to be constant and @xmath219 .
( we adopt the normalization of the wl model so that it matches the prediction of @xmath196
@xmath197 with a nwf type of halo profile .
however , the choice of this normalization is not crucial ) . in the figure
, we see a factor of @xmath220 change in the ensemble eddington ratio from @xmath172 to @xmath212 .
this change , however , is smaller than the typical scatter in both the luminosity and halo mass .
we now compare our clustering results with those for normal galaxies . using the sloan digital sky survey first data release , wake et al .
( 2004 ) found that the clustering of narrow - line agns in the redshift range @xmath221 , selected using emission - line flux ratios , have the same correlation amplitude as normal galaxies .
our samples are not a very good probe at these redshifts , and the best clustering analysis at a comparable redshift for normal galaxies is from deep2 ( coil et al .
2004 ) . at effective redshift @xmath222
, they found @xmath223 h@xmath6 mpc , and @xmath224 , which translates to @xmath225 .
the correlation amplitude from clasxs at @xmath226 is @xmath227 .
the clustering of agns in clasxs field appear the same as the clustering of normal galaxies in deep2 .
a higher correlation is found in the cdfn .
the difference shows the large uncertainty of our correlation function estimates . at higher redshifts ,
the best estimate for galaxy clustering is from the so called `` lyman break galaxies '' , named after the technique by which they are found .
adelberger et al .
( 1998 ) found , at a typical @xmath228 , these galaxies tend to have similar correlation function as galaxies in the local universe , indicating they are highly biased tracers of the large scale structure . in the @xmath229cdm cosmology , these authors found @xmath230 .
this is very similar to the bias found in the highest bin of our _ chandra _ fields ( @xmath231 ) , which has a median redshift of @xmath232 .
if we extrapolate the bias of the x - ray sources to @xmath233 , the bias of x - ray sources should be @xmath234 , consistent with the clustering strength of lymann break galaxies .
in this paper we study the clustering of the x - ray selected agns in the 0.4 deg@xmath0 _ chandra _ contiguous survey of the lockman hole northwest region . based on our previous study ,
the size of the clasxs field is large enough that the cosmic variance should not be important .
we supplement our study with the published data from the cdfn .
the very similar logn - logs of the clasxs and cdfn suggests that the cosmic variance should not be important when the cdfn is included in the analysis .
the very deep cdfn gives a better probe of the correlation function at small separations .
a total of 233 and 252 non - stellar sources from clasxs and cdfn respectively are used in this study .
we use the correlation function in the redshift - space as a major tool in our clustering analysis . for the whole sample
, we have also performed an analysis using the projected correlation function .
this allows us to quantify the effect of redshift distortion
. \1 .
we calculated the redshift - space correlation function for sources with @xmath2 in both the clasxs and cdfn fields , assuming constant clustering in comoving coordinates .
we found a @xmath85 clustering signal for pairs within @xmath235 mpc in the clasxs field . the correlation function over scale of 3 mpc@xmath7 200 mpc
is found to be a power - law with @xmath9 and @xmath10 mpc .
the redshift - space correlation function for cdfn on scales of 1 mpc@xmath7 100 mpc is found to have similar correlation length @xmath11 mpc , but the slope is shallower ( @xmath12 ) .
we study the projected correlation function of both clasxs and cdfn .
the best - fit parameters for the real - space correlation functions are found to be @xmath13 mpc , @xmath14 for clasxs field , and @xmath15 mpc , @xmath16 for cdfn field .
our result for the cdfn shows perfect agreement with the published results from gilli et al .
( 2004 ) . fitting the combined data from both fields
gives @xmath109 mpc and @xmath236 .
\3 . comparing the redshift- and real - space correlation function of the combined clasxs and cdfn fields
, we found the redshift distortion parameter @xmath17 at an effective redshift @xmath18 . under the assumption of @xmath229cdm cosmology , this implies a bias parameter @xmath127 at this redshift .
we tested whether the clustering of the x - ray sources is dependent on the x - ray spectra in the clasxs field . using a hardness ratio cut at @xmath237
, we found no significant difference in clustering between hard and soft sources .
this agrees with previous claims .
\5 . with the large dynamic range in x - ray luminosity
, we found a weak correlation between x - ray luminosity and clustering amplitude .
using a simple model based on observations that links the agn luminosity and halo mass , we show that the observed weak correlation is consistent with the model , except at low luminosities , where sources are likely to have lower eddington ratio .
the non - detection of a strong correlation between x - ray luminosity and clustering amplitude also suggests a narrow range of halo mass .
we study the evolution of the clustering using the redshift - space correlation function in 4 redshift intervals ranging from 0.1 to 3.0 .
we found only a mild evolution of agn clustering in both clasxs and cdfn samples .
this qualitatively agrees with the results based on optically selected quasars from 2df survey .
the x - ray samples , however , show a similar correlation amplitude as that of the 2df sample . this is consistent with the weak correlation between agn luminosity and the clustering amplitude found in this work .
we estimate the evolution of bias by comparing the observed clustering amplitude with expectations of the linear evolution of density fluctuations .
the result show that the bias increases rapidly with redshift ( @xmath238 and @xmath239 in clasxs field ) .
this agrees with the findings from 2df .
using the bias evolution model for dark halos from sheth , mo & tormen ( 2001 ) , we estimated the characteristic mass of agns in each redshift interval .
we found the mass of the dark halo changes very little with redshift .
the average halo mass is found to be @xmath240 .
our results have demonstrated that deep x - ray surveys are a very useful tool in studying how agns trace the large scale structure .
such knowledge provides an unique window to the understanding of agn activity , and its relation to structure formation .
the higher spatial density and much better completeness compared to current optical surveys allows us to study clustering on scales only accessible to very large optical surveys such as the 2df and the sdss .
the high spatial resolution and positional accuracy of _ chandra _ is critical for unambiguous optical identifications .
since our results on the evolution of agn clustering could still be affected by a small number of large scale structures , as seen in chandra deep field south , larger _
fields are still needed to improve the measurements .
we thank prof .
alex szalay , dr . xaviar barcons and dr .
takamitsu miyaji for very helpful conversations ; dr .
chris mullis for discussions on his paper .
we would like to thank the anonymous referee for his / her comments that help to improve the paper .
this work is partially funded by the ids program of r. f. m. we also gratefully acknowledge support from nsf grants ast 02 - 39425 ( a.j.b . ) and ast 04 - 07374 ( l.l.c . ) , the university of wisconsin research committee with funds granted by the wisconsin alumni research foundation , the alfred p. sloan foundation , and the david and lucile packard foundation ( a.j.b . ) .
lccclccc 10200 & @xmath241 & @xmath242 & 6.2/8 & 10100 & @xmath243 & @xmath244 & 7.9/8 + 330 & @xmath245 & @xmath246 & 3.8 /8 & 120 & @xmath247 & @xmath248 & 6.8/8 + 3200 & @xmath249 & @xmath250 & 10.6/8 & 1100 & @xmath251 & @xmath252 & 15.0/8 + [ z_space_cor ] cccccccc clasxs & 0.13.0 & 1.5 & @xmath253 & @xmath254 & @xmath255 & 7.2/8 & @xmath256 + & 0.13.0 & .73 & @xmath257 & @xmath258 & @xmath259 & 8.8/8 & @xmath260 + & 0.31.5 & 1.1 & @xmath261 & @xmath262 & @xmath263 & 9.2/8 & @xmath264 + & 0.31.5 & .81 & @xmath265 & @xmath266 & @xmath267 & 7.8/8 & @xmath268 +
cdf - n & 0.13.0 & .98 & @xmath269 & @xmath270 & @xmath271 & 8.2/8 & @xmath272 + & 0.13.0 & .51 & @xmath273 & @xmath274 & @xmath275 & 11.9/8 & @xmath276 + & 0.31.5 & .96 & @xmath277 & @xmath278 & @xmath279 & 11.1/8 & @xmath280 + & 0.31.5 & .63 & @xmath281 & @xmath282 & @xmath283 & 8.4/8 & @xmath284 + [ tab_lum ] lcccccccc clasxs & 0.10.7 & 0.44 & 57 & @xmath265 & @xmath285 & @xmath286 & 4.1/8 & @xmath287 + & 0.71.1 & 0.90 & 60 & @xmath288 & @xmath289 & @xmath290 & 5.9/8 & @xmath291 + & 1.11.5 & 1.27 & 49 & @xmath292 & @xmath293 & @xmath294 & 1.6/3 & @xmath295 + & 1.53.0 & 2.00 & 67 & @xmath296 & @xmath297 & @xmath298 & 3.1/3 & @xmath299 + cdfn & 0.10.7 & 0.46 & 111 & @xmath300 & @xmath301 & @xmath302 & 12.5/8 & @xmath303 + & 0.71.1 & 0.94 & 91 & @xmath304 & @xmath305 & @xmath306 & 5.6/8 & @xmath307 + & 1.11.5 & 1.22 & 28 & @xmath308 & @xmath309 & @xmath310 & 2.9/8 & @xmath311 + & 1.53.0 & 2.24 & 22 & @xmath312 & @xmath313 & @xmath314 & 1.4/7 & @xmath315 + clasxs+cdfn & 0.10.7 & 0.45 & 168 & @xmath316 & @xmath317 & @xmath318 & 5.3/8 & @xmath319 + & 0.71.1 & 0.92 & 151 & @xmath320 & @xmath321 & @xmath322 & 5.5/8 & @xmath323 + & 1.11.5 & 1.26 & 77 & @xmath324 & @xmath325 & @xmath326 & 1.8/8 & @xmath327 + & 1.53.0 & 2.07 & 89 & @xmath328 & @xmath329 & @xmath330 & 4.2/7 & @xmath331 + [ tab_evolution ] cccccc 0.44 & @xmath332 & @xmath333 & 0.45 & @xmath334 & @xmath335 + 0.90 & @xmath336 & @xmath337 & 0.92 & @xmath338 & @xmath339 + 1.27 & @xmath340 & @xmath341 & 1.26 & @xmath342 & @xmath343 + 2.00 & @xmath344 & @xmath345 & 2.07 & @xmath346 & @xmath347 + [ tab_bias ] 200 mpc .
maximum - likelihood contour for the single power - law fit .
contour levels are @xmath348 , corresponding to @xmath150 , @xmath349 and @xmath350 confident levels for two parameter fits .
[ clasxs_cor],title="fig : " ] 200 mpc .
maximum - likelihood contour for the single power - law fit .
contour levels are @xmath348 , corresponding to @xmath150 , @xmath349 and @xmath350 confident levels for two parameter fits .
[ clasxs_cor],title="fig : " ] for the cdfn except that the correlation function is calculated for separations 1 mpc@xmath7100 mpc .
[ cdfn_cor],title="fig : " ] for the cdfn except that the correlation function is calculated for separations 1 mpc@xmath7100 mpc .
[ cdfn_cor],title="fig : " ] contours for the clasxs+cdfn sample , the clasxs sample , and the cdfn sample , respectively .
are for @xmath150 , @xmath349 , and @xmath350 confident levels ; ( d ) the projected correlation function for clasxs ( open circles ) and cdfn ( black dots ) fields .
lines are the best - fit shown in ( a)-(c ) .
solid line : clasxs+cdfn ; dotted line : clasxs ; dashed line : cdfn [ projected ] ] of the combined clasxs and cdfn sample ( dashed - dotted contour ) .
solid line shows the best - fit model .
both the data and model correlation functions are smoothed using a @xmath351 boxcar to reduce the noise for visualization only .
[ z_distortion ] ] | we present the spatial correlation function analysis of non - stellar x - ray point sources in the _ chandra _ large area synoptic x - ray survey of lockman hole northwest ( clasxs ) .
our 9 acis - i fields cover a contiguous solid angle of 0.4 deg@xmath0 and reach a depth of @xmath1 in the 28 kev band .
we supplement our analysis with data from the chandra deep field north ( cdfn ) .
the addition of this field allows better probe of the correlation function at small scales .
a total of 233 and 252 sources with spectroscopic information are used in the study of the clasxs and cdfn fields respectively .
we calculate both redshift - space and projected correlation functions in comoving coordinates , averaged over the redshift range of @xmath2 , for both clasxs and cdfn fields for a standard cosmology with @xmath3 , and @xmath4 ( @xmath5 km s@xmath6 mpc@xmath6 ) .
the correlation function for the clasxs field over scales of 3 mpc@xmath7 200 mpc can be modeled as a power - law of the form @xmath8 , with @xmath9 and @xmath10 mpc .
the redshift - space correlation function for cdfn on scales of 1 mpc@xmath7 100 mpc is found to have a similar correlation length @xmath11 mpc , but a shallower slope ( @xmath12 ) .
the real - space correlation functions derived from the projected correlation functions , are found to be @xmath13 mpc , and @xmath14 for the clasxs field , and @xmath15 mpc , @xmath16 for the cdfn field . by comparing the real- and redshift - space correlation functions in the combined clasxs and cdfn samples ,
we are able to estimate the redshift distortion parameter @xmath17 at an effective redshift @xmath18 .
we compare the correlation functions for hard and soft spectra sources in the clasxs field and find no significant difference between the two groups .
we have also found that the correlation between x - ray luminosity and clustering amplitude is weak , which , however , is fully consistent with the expectation using the simplest relations between x - ray luminosity , blackhole mass , and dark halo mass .
we study the evolution of the agn clustering by dividing the samples into 4 redshift bins over 0.1 [email protected] mpc .
we find a very mild evolution in the clustering amplitude , which show the same evolution trend found in optically selected quasars in the 2df survey .
we estimate the evolution of the bias , and find that the bias increases rapidly with redshift ( @xmath20and @xmath21 ) .
the typical mass of the dark matter halo derived from the bias estimates show little change with redshift .
the average halo mass is found to be @xmath22 . |
threshold resummation @xcite plays an important role in extending and stabilizing the accuracy of perturbative results , and it may be of some relevance even for hadronic processes which are quite far from threshold @xcite , due to the fact that the underlying partonic process can be rather closer to threshold than the hadronic one @xcite .
all - order resummed results are known to lead to a divergent series when expanded out in powers of the strong coupling : this is physically due to the fact that resummation is obtained by choosing as a scale of the parton - level process the maximum energy of the radiated partons @xcite , which tends to zero in the threshold limit .
the divergence can be tamed by introducing suitable subleading contributions , such as exponentially suppressed terms outside the physical kinematic region @xcite , or power - suppressed terms @xcite . in ref .
@xcite it was suggested , within the context of a scet approach to threshold resummation , that the divergence can be tamed by making a hadronic choice of scale . in scet
this is possible because resummed results are characterized by a `` soft scale '' @xmath0 : the becher - neubert ( bn ) scale choice consists of expressing @xmath0 in terms of kinematic variables of the hadronic scattering process .
the meaning of this choice is not obvious in the conventional qcd approach , where , because of perturbative factorization , the partonic cross section , which is being resummed , is independent of the hadronic kinematic variables .
[ cols="<,^,^,^ , > " , ] in ref .
@xcite we have clarified this issue by explicitly exhibiting a relation between the @xmath0 dependent resummed scet result , and the standard ( @xmath0 independent ) qcd expression .
specializing to the bn scale choice ( while taking the drell - yan process @xcite as an example ) we were able to show that in the scet result , with the bn scale choice , the divergence is removed through terms which are logarithmically subleading in comparison to the logarithmic accuracy of the scet result of ref .
@xcite , which is by half a logarithmic order lower than that of the standard qcd result . here
we show that the accuracy of the scet result of ref .
@xcite can actually be increased to the same level as that of the qcd result , and we rederive , within this higher accuracy , our master formula , which thus becomes particularly transparent .
we then use this improved master formula to discuss various problems related to the bn scale choice .
we consider for definiteness inclusive drell - yan production , but the same discussion applies to other processes , such as higgs production in gluon - gluon fusion , with minimal modifications .
the dimensionless invariant mass distribution @xmath1 , with @xmath2 the invariant mass of the pair and @xmath3 the leading order partonic cross section , can be written schematically ( omitting a sum over partons ) in factorized form as [ sigma ] ( , m^2)=_^1@xmath4c(z , m^2 ) , where @xmath5 is the parton luminosity , @xmath6 the hadronic center - of - mass energy squared , and @xmath7 , so that the hadronic threshold limit is @xmath8 .
the perturbatively computable coefficient function @xmath9 is normalized so that @xmath10 at leading order in the strong coupling @xmath11 . in the sequel , without significant loss of generality
, we shall always choose the renormalization and factorization scales @xmath12 .
standard qcd resummation follows from a mellin - space renormalization - group argument @xcite : indeed , at the resummed level , both the convolution eq . and the gluon radiation phase space factorize , so at the resummed level one may write [ melsigma ] ( n , m^2)=_0 ^ 1d^n-1(,m^2 ) = ( n ) c(n , m^2 ) where the @xmath13-space resummed coefficient function has the form @xcite [ cqcd ] c_qcd(n , m^2)=|g_0@xmath14 |(m^2 , ) where @xmath15 ^ 2m^2)\ ) \bigg].\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the functions @xmath16 , @xmath17 and @xmath18 are power series in @xmath11 , with @xmath19 and @xmath20 . because resummation is obtained through exponentiation , it might seem natural to also exponentiate the function @xmath21 .
however , unlike @xmath22 , @xmath21 is independent of @xmath13 and only depends on @xmath14 . as a consequence ,
it turns out that simply including an extra term in @xmath21 at each order increases the logarithmic accuracy of the coefficient function by half a logarithmic order .
this is summarized in table [ tab : count ] , where the logarithmic accuracy obtained by including a given number of terms in @xmath21 , @xmath23 , and @xmath24 is summarized .
a given accuracy means that all and only the logarithmically enhanced contributions to the coefficient function listed in the last column are correctly predicted . at leading logarithmic ( ll ) accuracy only the largest power of @xmath25 at each order in @xmath11
is predicted ; adding one order in each of the functions @xmath23 , @xmath24 , and @xmath21 one then obtains the next - to - leading logarithmic ( nll ) accuracy , which correctly predicts two powers more , and so on to n@xmath26ll accuracy .
however , if @xmath21 is exponentiated and a power counting is performed at the level of exponents , it may seem more natural to include one less order in @xmath21 .
this results in the n@xmath26ll * accuracy , also shown in table , which is lower by one power of @xmath25 at each order in @xmath11 than the n@xmath26ll accuracy .
the resummed scet expression for drell - yan pair production is given by @xcite . ] [ cscet ] c_scet(z , m^2,_s^2 ) = h(m^2)u(m^2 , _
s^2 ) s(z , m^2,_s^2 ) where @xmath27 ( hard function ) is a power series in @xmath14 , [ eq : soft_func ] s(z , m^2 , _
s^2 ) = s_dy@xmath28 ( soft function ) depends on [ etadef ] = _ m^2^_s^2_cusp@xmath29 , _
cusp(_s)=a(_s ) , @xmath30 is a series in @xmath31 with @xmath32-dependent coefficients , and @xmath33,\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath34 is also a series in @xmath11 , with @xmath35 .
the scale @xmath36 is a soft matching scale of the effective theory , and @xmath37 formally does not depend on it , up to subleading terms .
however , the scet result resums powers of @xmath38 , so this choice of scale determines what is being resummed .
again , a given logarithmic accuracy is obtained by including a finite number of terms in the perturbative expansion of the functions which determine the resummed result , namely @xmath39 , @xmath40 , @xmath41 and @xmath42 , according to table [ tab : count ] . in ref .
@xcite , only the n@xmath26ll * accuracy was considered : in fact , the order called n@xmath26ll * in tab . [
tab : count ] is actually referred to n@xmath26ll ref .
@xcite , which might be the source of some confusion .
computations using either of these two definitions of the logarithmic accuracy have been presented in the past , either in the contex of qcd ( see e.g. ref @xcite , where n@xmath26ll * is referred to as n@xmath26ll@xmath43 ) or scet ( see e.g. ref .
@xcite , where n@xmath26ll is referred to as n@xmath26ll@xmath44 ) . here
we show that in fact the n@xmath26ll * of ref .
@xcite can be promoted to higher n@xmath26ll accuracy , by inclusion of the terms listed in the table .
this result is obtained in the next section , by explicitly computing the relation between this improved version of the scet result , and the qcd result .
an analytic comparison between the qcd and scet resummation formalisms can be performed @xcite in @xmath13 space , where the qcd result is naturally constructed , and where it admits a convergent perturbative expansion in powers of @xmath11 .
namely , we determine the ratio @xmath45 between the qcd and scet expressions , eqs . and : [ ccc ] c_qcd(n , m^2 ) = c_r(n , m^2,^2_s ) c_scet(n , m^2,_s^2 ) . in ref . @xcite we computed @xmath45 to nnll , using the definition of nnll of ref .
@xcite , which in tab .
[ tab : count ] we call nnll*. here we show that the accuracy of the scet expression can be upgraded , and the comparison can be carried out at full nnll according to the definition of table [ tab : count ] .
we first rewrite the qcd result in the more convenient form @xcite [ cqcd2 ] c_qcd(n , m^2)=g_0@xmath14 _ qcd(m^2 , ) with @xmath46 and @xmath47 , \label{ghatdef}\\ & \hat{{\mathcal{s}}}_{\rm\scriptscriptstyle qcd}\(m^2,\frac{m^2}{\bar{n}^2}\ ) = \int_{m^2}^{m^2/\bar{n}^2}\frac{d\mu^2}{\mu^2}\ , \bigg[a\({\alpha_s}(\mu^2)\)\ln\frac{m^2}{\mu^2\bar{n}^2}\nonumber\\ & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\quad+\hat d\({\alpha_s}(\mu^2)\)\bigg ] , \label{shatdef}\\ & a({\alpha_s})=\frac{a_1}{4}{\alpha_s}+\frac{a_2}{16}{\alpha_s}^2+\frac{a_3}{64}{\alpha_s}^3+{\mathcal{o}}({\alpha_s}^4),\label{aexp}\\ & \hat d({\alpha_s } ) = \frac12 d({\alpha_s } ) - 2\zeta_2 \frac{c_f}{\pi}\beta_0 { \alpha_s}^2 = \hat d_2{\alpha_s}^2+{\mathcal{o}}({\alpha_s}^3),\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath48 .
the functions @xmath23 , @xmath24 and @xmath21 are computed at nnll order according to table [ tab : count ] ; the relevant coefficients can be found in ref .
@xcite , except the two - loop contribution to @xmath21 , which can be determined by matching the expansion of eq .
to the nnlo drell - yan cross section in ref .
@xcite , @xmath49,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the coefficient @xmath50 , which we give here for completeness a_2=@xmath51 .
the explicit expression of @xmath52 is not needed here . on the other hand , at nnll the mellin transform of the scet result , eq .
, can be written as @xcite @xmath53 with @xmath54,\\ & e\(\frac{m^2}{\bar n^2},{\mu_s}^2\ ) = \tilde s_{\rm dy}\(\ln\frac{m^2}{{\mu_s}^2\bar n^2},{\mu_s}^2\ ) \exp\[-\frac{\zeta_2}{2 } \frac{c_f}{\pi } { \alpha_s}({\mu_s}^2)\],\label{eq : edef}\\ & \hat{\mathcal{s}}_{\rm\scriptscriptstyle scet}(n , m^2,{\mu_s}^2)= \int_{m^2}^{{\mu_s}^2 } \frac{d\mu^2}{\mu^2 } \bigg[\gamma_{\rm cusp}\({\alpha_s}(\mu^2)\ ) \ln\frac{m^2}{\mu^2\bar{n}^2 } \nonumber\\ & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad+\hat\gamma_w\({\alpha_s}(\mu^2)\ ) \bigg ] , \label{scetsfun}\\ & \hat \gamma_w({\alpha_s } ) = \gamma_w({\alpha_s } ) - \frac{\zeta_2}{2 } \frac{c_f}{\pi}\beta_0{\alpha_s}^2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath55 at this order . in comparison to ref .
@xcite , we now also include the two - loop contributions to the functions @xmath41 and @xmath42 , which were given explicitly in ref
. @xcite .
note that , in order to be accurate to order @xmath56 , the definition of the function @xmath57 slightly differs from ref .
@xcite .
putting everything together we find [ eq : cr ] c_r(n , m^2,_s^2 ) = @xmath58 with @xmath59 . \label{shat}\end{gathered}\ ] ] it is easy to see that [ wcrat ] = 1+@xmath60 , so to nnll accuracy eq .
can be written [ eq : cr2 ] c_r(n , m^2,_s^2 ) = @xmath58 . using the 2-loop expression of @xmath42 from ref .
@xcite in eq .
, we find e@xmath61=1+e_1(l)_s(_s^2)+e_2(l ) _
s^2(_s^2)+(_s^3 ) where @xmath62 \nonumber\\ & + \frac{c_fn_f}{\pi^2 } \[-\frac{41}{162 } -\frac{5}{72 }
\zeta_2+\frac{\zeta_3}{36 } \ ] , \label{eq : eser}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and l .
note that @xmath63 when the two arguments of @xmath57 are equal to each other .
establishes our first new result .
indeed , it is immediate to check that @xmath64 for @xmath65 , up to subleading ( nnnll * ) terms .
this means that with this scale choice the scet result now reproduces the qcd result to full nnll accuracy , rather than to the lower nnll * accuracy of ref .
@xcite .
we are however interested in studying @xmath66 for generic scale choices , and in particular with the bn scale choice .
the result becomes especially transparent by casting the ratio @xmath67 eq . in the form of an exponential of an integral , of the same kind as the form adopted in eq .
this can be done at the price of including terms of order @xmath68 or higher in the ratio , which is allowed at nnll .
the ensuing expression of @xmath66 is particularly simple and suitable for analytic comparisons .
it should however be kept in mind that a numerical comparison of the scet and qcd expressions should rather be performed using the exact expression eq . , and possibly also retaining the subleading terms in eq .
( [ wcrat ] ) .
we get @xmath69+{\mathcal{o}}({\alpha_s}^3).\end{aligned}\ ] ] using = _ _ s^2^m^2/|n^2 ^k and taking the running of @xmath11 into account , we finally obtain @xmath70 , \label{srexp}\end{gathered}\ ] ] which is our nnll master qcd - scet comparison formula .
it generalizes to full nnll the result of ref .
. its most notable feature , which determines the relative accuracy of the comparison , is that ( recall the expansion eq . )
the exponent in eq .
( [ srexp ] ) is of order @xmath68 .
note that this is however due to the exponentiation eq .
( [ eexp ] ) . if one does not exponentiate ( as in the original scet expression ) , when expanding @xmath66 in powers of @xmath11 , terms proportional to @xmath71 and @xmath50 only cancel up to @xmath72 .
as briefly discussed in sect .
[ sec : intro ] , the bn approach is based on the idea of choosing for @xmath0 a scale determined by hadronic , rather than partonic kinematics , namely @xmath73 . in ref .
@xcite a more general choice @xmath74 was considered , with @xmath75 : the distinction may be relevant for phenomenology , but it is immaterial for our present goal , which is to determine the logarithmic accuracy of the scet result with this scale choice .
since the variable @xmath76 refers to hadron kinematics , the comparison can only be performed at the level of the physical cross section , eq . .
we therefore define @xmath77 where @xmath78 and @xmath79 are the inverse mellin transforms of eqs . and , respectively , and in the scet case after performing the inverse mellin transform at fixed @xmath0 we have set @xmath80 .
of course , @xmath78 is given by a divergent series in powers of @xmath14 , so it should be understood as the order - by - order mellin inversion up to arbitrarily high but finite order .
using eq .
we find [ eq : sigma_master ] _
qcd(,m^2 ) = _ ^1 z _ scet@xmath81
c_r(z , m^2,m^2(1-)^2 ) where @xmath82 is the inverse mellin transform of eq . , performed at fixed @xmath0 and evaluated at @xmath80 . in order to compute @xmath82
it is convenient to rewrite eq . as [ eq : cr3 ] c_r(n , m^2,_s^2 )
= @xmath58 .
the first ratio is just a function of @xmath14 and @xmath31 , independent of @xmath13 , while @xmath58 = 1+f_r@xmath83 , where @xmath84 is of order @xmath68 .
the inverse mellin transform can be now computed using the results of ref .
we find @xmath85 , \label{eq : sigma_comparison}\end{gathered}\ ] ] where ( , m^2 , ) = _ ^1 z _ scet@xmath81 ^-11z for @xmath86 .
we have shown in app .
b of ref .
@xcite that @xmath87 can be expressed in terms of derivatives of @xmath88 with respect to @xmath89 , up to terms suppressed by positive powers of @xmath90 : [ eq : sigma_ser ] ( , m^2 , ) = _ k=0^c_k ( ) @xmath91 , with coefficients @xmath92 which do not depend on @xmath76 .
it follows that the term proportional to @xmath93 in eq . does not contain any extra logarithmic enhancement with respect to @xmath88 . on the other hand @xmath94+\ldots \label{ee } \\ & = 1 + 4e_2(0)\beta_0{\alpha_s}^3(m^2)\ln(1-\tau)+{\mathcal{o}}({\alpha_s}^4 ) .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] we conclude that the leading difference between the qcd and scet expressions is @xmath95 , \ ] ] where the ellipse denotes terms which are either of relative order @xmath96 , but without any logarithmic enhancement , or @xmath97 .
because the log counting is now done at the level of hadronic cross sections , it is based on counting powers of @xmath89 .
also , because the scet result violates standard qcd factorization ( i.e. , it does not factorize upon mellin transformation ) , the difference between @xmath98 and @xmath99 depends on the parton luminosity ( it is not universal ) through @xmath99 itself .
a generic leading - log term in @xmath99 has the form _
scet~_s^k^2k+p(1- ) , where @xmath100 is due to the leading log behavior of the coefficient function , and @xmath101 generally comes from the parton luminosity . if we assume that the parton luminosity does not lead to any logarithmic enhancement , then [ eq : sigma_diff ] _ qcd-_scet~_s^k+3 ^2k+1(1-)= _
s^h ^2h-5(1- ) , where we have set @xmath102 .
this corresponds to a nnnll * correction .
it is interesting to observe that , had we used the exponentiated version eq .
( [ srexp ] ) of @xmath66 , a nnnll , rather than nnnll * correction , would have been obtained .
the argument can be generalized to the case in which @xmath66 is computed to all orders in @xmath11 rather than just to order @xmath56 .
indeed , no leading logarithmic enhancement arises from the factor @xmath103 ; the only possible source of powers of @xmath89 in @xmath66 is the ratio @xmath104 .
it is easy to see , however , that all terms in the expansion eq .
are at most of order @xmath105 , with @xmath106 .
thus , the conclusion eq .
( [ eq : sigma_diff ] ) holds to all orders in @xmath11 . in conclusion , we restate three observations which were already made in ref . @xcite .
first , we note that the bn scale choice removes the divergence of the perturbative expansion at the cost of introducing logarithmically suppressed non - universal terms .
this is to be contrasted with the commonly used minimal prescription @xcite , which also introduces non - universal terms ( with support outside the physically accessible kinematic region ) but are more suppressed than any power , or with the borel prescription @xcite , which introduces power - suppressed but universal terms .
second , we observe that quite in general we do expect pdfs to contain logarithmically enhanced terms . in this case
the terms introduced by the bn scale choice to tame the perturbative divergence can become leading or even super - leading ( i.e. , more logarithmically enhanced than the leading log ) .
finally , we remark that threshold resummation is often useful in situations where @xmath76 is far from threshold , but nevertheless the partonic subprocess is close to threshold @xcite . in this case
@xmath107 , and consequently @xmath66 eq . (
[ eq : cr2 ] ) is actually leading log .
the phenomenological implications of our results remain to be investigated .
they are potentially of considerable interest , given the increasingly important role that threshold resummation , in its various implementations , is playing for lhc phenomenology .
we thank frank tackmann and christian bauer for stimulating discussions .
mb wishes to thank ben pecjak for an interesting conversation .
00 g. f. sterman , nucl .
b * 281 * ( 1987 ) 310 .
s. catani and l. trentadue , nucl .
b * 327 * ( 1989 ) 323 .
m. bonvini , s. forte and g. ridolfi , nucl .
b * 847 * ( 2011 ) 93 [ arxiv:1009.5691 [ hep - ph ] ] .
m. bonvini , s. forte and g. ridolfi , phys .
* 109 * ( 2012 ) 102002 [ arxiv:1204.5473 [ hep - ph ] ] .
s. catani , d. de florian and m. grazzini , jhep * 0105 * ( 2001 ) 025 [ hep - ph/0102227 ] .
h. contopanagos , e. laenen and g. f. sterman , nucl .
b * 484 * ( 1997 ) 303 [ hep - ph/9604313 ] .
s. forte and g. ridolfi , nucl .
b * 650 * ( 2003 ) 229 [ hep - ph/0209154 ] .
s. catani , m. l. mangano , p. nason and l. trentadue , nucl .
b * 478 * ( 1996 ) 273 [ hep - ph/9604351 ] .
s. forte , g. ridolfi , j. rojo and m. ubiali , phys . lett .
b * 635 * ( 2006 ) 313 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0601048 ] .
r. abbate , s. forte and g. ridolfi , phys .
b * 657 * ( 2007 ) 55 [ arxiv:0707.2452 [ hep - ph ] ] .
t. becher and m. neubert , phys .
* 97 * ( 2006 ) 082001 [ hep - ph/0605050 ] .
t. becher , m. neubert and g. xu , jhep * 0807 * ( 2008 ) 030 [ arxiv:0710.0680 [ hep - ph ] ] .
m. bonvini , s. forte , m. ghezzi and g. ridolfi , nucl .
b * 861 * ( 2012 ) 337 [ arxiv:1201.6364 [ hep - ph ] ] .
m. dasgupta and g. p. salam , j. phys .
g g * 30 * ( 2004 ) r143 [ hep - ph/0312283 ] .
r. abbate , m. fickinger , a. h. hoang , v. mateu and i. w. stewart , phys .
d * 83 * ( 2011 ) 074021 [ arxiv:1006.3080 [ hep - ph ] ] ; c. f. berger , c. marcantonini , i. w. stewart , f. j. tackmann and w. j. waalewijn , jhep * 1104 * ( 2011 ) 092 [ arxiv:1012.4480 [ hep - ph ] ] ; s. alioli , c. w. bauer , c. j. berggren , a. hornig , f. j. tackmann , c. k. vermilion , j. r. walsh and s. zuberi , arxiv:1211.7049 [ hep - ph ] .
r. hamberg , w. l. van neerven and t. matsuura , nucl .
b * 359 * ( 1991 ) 343 [ erratum - ibid .
b * 644 * ( 2002 ) 403 ] . | we summarize and extend previous results on the comparison of threshold resummation , performed , using soft - collinear effective theory ( scet ) , in the becher - neubert approach , to the standard perturbative qcd formalism based on factorization and resummation of mellin moments of partonic cross sections .
we show that the logarithmic accuracy of this scet result can be extended by half a logarithmic order , thereby bringing it in full agreement with the standard qcd result if a suitable choice is made for the soft scale @xmath0 which characterizes the scet result .
we provide a master formula relating the two approaches for other scale choices .
we then show that with the becher - neubert scale choice the landau pole , which in the perturbative qcd approach is usually removed through power- or exponentially suppressed terms , in the scet approach is removed by logarithmically subleading terms which break factorization .
such terms may become leading for generic choices of parton distributions , and are always leading when resummation is used far enough from the hadronic threshold .
qcd , soft - gluon , threshold , resummation , soft - collinear effective theory |
cosmological problems are as old as human history , but cosmology is a relatively new science . in recent years two main observational results have revealed a profound implication in our current knowledge of the universe .
these are the confirmation of the flat geometry and its accelerating expansion of our universe in the relatively recent epoch , i.e. , with redshift of roughly 0.5 or less , driving by an unidentified component as coined dark energy by m. turner @xcite .
the recent observations have dramatically changed our previous intuition .
the evolution of the universe was slowing down due to gravitational attractive force and also alleviated the universe age crisis problem with respect to the oldest stars and globular clusters in our milk way galaxy .
respectively , the first acoustic peak of the temperature fluctuations on the cosmic microwave background radiation ( cmbr ) is observed by the experiments of boomerang , maxima and wmap @xcite .
it favors a spatially flat universe and indicates our universe dominated by about 2/3 dark energy and 1/3 matter ( with mostly the named non - relativistic cold dark matter ) components .
the direct evidences from measurements of luminosity - redshift relations of sn ia @xcite suggest that there exists a mysterious component so called dark energy with a negative pressure .
it is as large as an anti - gravity contribution to accelerate the universe expansion .
a simple candidate which shows the properties of the dark energy is found in the vacuum energy or cosmological constant .
however , the energy scale to the cosmological constant is about 120 orders of magnitude smaller than that of the vacuum energy at the planck time . some fine tuning of parameters is necessary in almost all the models of particle physics .
thus a naturalness problem exists in some simple candidates .
furthermore , recent analysis of the observational data from wmap combined with 2df , sdss , dasi and the previous cmb observations@xcite disfavors the simplest cosmological constant explanation .
when describing the evolution of the universe , normally we start with solving the einstein equation . since we know that recent observations favors the flat , homogeneous and isotropic universe in large scale survey , it is a good approximation to use the energy - momentum tensor for the dominant matter or radiation mainly depends on time or temperature when we consider the global evolution of the universe . for the perfect fluid model ,
the energy - momentum tensor consists of the total energy density @xmath0 and smoothly distributed pressure @xmath1 by @xmath2 .
the isotropic and homogeneous universe can be explicated by friedmann - robertson - walker ( frw ) metrics . in this case einstein equation
reduces to only two relations .
one is friedmann equation : @xmath3 where @xmath4 is the scale factor in the frw metrics .
the other is the acceleration equation @xmath5 these equations are very successful to describe the evolution history of the universe from the `` first three minutes '' so far as we have observed .
furthermore , these can accommodate the relatively recent accelerating expansion of our universe if we accept the existence of a kind of vacuum energy or the cosmological constant - like term . on the other hand we have another solution to introduce an entity endowed with the sort of dark energy @xcite .
its energy density can govern the cosmological evolution in friedmann equations of standard cosmology @xcite . with the present observational data we can not finally distinguish yet whether the accelerating expansion comes from the cosmological constant or not .
the cosmological constant can be absorbed into the energy density @xmath0 and pressure @xmath1 by a re - definition in the above equations . to reconcile with the accelerating expansion of the universe we must have @xmath6 the lower bound , @xmath7 , corresponds to the cosmological constant .
when we consider the dark energy model that causes the accelerating expansion , the dominant substance has to satisfy this relation by its own @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
lots of previous works are reported in concentrating on a dynamical scalar field such as quintessence , spin - essence and so on . in such investigations
a slowly varying energy density has been employed to mimic an effective cosmological constant @xcite . as far as we know a very little number of works have been done in the study of the fermion field as the possible dark energy candidate .
one of the interesting candidate of the dark energy is postulated in the model with a fermion field . in some strong coupling fermion models dynamical
symmetry breaking takes place by the fermion and the anti - fermion condensation below a critical temperature .
as is well known , the chiral symmetry for quarks is broken down dynamically in qcd . the composite operator of the fermion and the anti - fermion develops the non - vanishing vacuum expectation value .
it can change behaviors of the energy density and pressure of the universe at low temperature as the relevant energy scale in the model can be adjusted accordingly .
therefore we launched our plan to make a systematic study of the strong coupling fermion models at finite temperature for a dark energy candidate . here
we take a four - fermion interaction model as one of such prototype models and discuss the possibilities to describe the dark energy characters by using the thermal quantum field theory technique @xcite .
the spacetime curvature also has an important effect on the phase structure of dynamical symmetry breaking in the early stage of the universe @xcite .
however , we consider the era when the main contribution to the evaluation of the energy - momentum tensor comes from the thermal effect .
we assume that the spacetime curvature and the expansion of the universe do not have a large influence to the evaluation of the energy - momentum tensor . as is known , the four - fermion interaction is non - renormalizable .
we regard the model is an effective theory which is stemming from a more fundamental theory at a high energy scale . in the present paper
we study a four - fermion interaction model as a dark energy candidate . by using the imaginary time formalism
we calculate the energy - momentum tensor in our model at finite temperature .
the eos is obtained from the energy - momentum tensor .
behaviors of the deceleration parameter are discussed to see the dark energy property of the four - fermion interaction model . throughout this paper
we use natural units with @xmath8 and assume the universe is geometric flat as astrophysical observation favors .
first we briefly review the definition of the energy - momentum tensor in the quantum field theory of fermion .
the four - fermion interaction model is one of the simplest model where dynamical symmetry breaking takes place @xcite . in @xmath9-dimensional spacetime
it is described by the action : @xmath10 , \label{ff}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the @xmath11 is a coupling constant , @xmath12 is the number of fermion flavors and @xmath13 is a vierbein that relates the metric @xmath14 and the local lorentz metric @xmath15 by @xmath16 .
below we omit the flavor index @xmath17 of fermion field .
the action ( [ ff ] ) has the global chiral symmetry under the transformation @xmath18 .
this symmetry prevent the fermion from having mass term . applying the auxiliary field method we rewrite the action as @xmath19 . \label{ac}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the non - vanishing vacuum expectation value of @xmath20 denotes the existence of the fermion and anti - fermion condensation , @xmath21 .
it is the signal for chiral symmetry breaking .
if the chiral symmetry broken down dynamically , the fermion acquire a mass term proportional to @xmath22 .
the classical definition of the energy - momentum tensor is @xcite @xmath23^{1/2 } } \frac{\delta s}{\delta g^{\mu\nu}(x ) } = \frac{v_{a(\mu}(x)}{{\rm det}[v(x ) ] } \frac{\delta s}{\delta v^{\nu)}_a(x)}.\ ] ] note that the labels @xmath24 refer to the local lorentz frame associated with the normal coordinates , while @xmath25 denote the general coordinate system @xmath26 . in the quantum field theory the expectation value of @xmath27
is defined in the sense of the path integral formalism as @xmath28^{1/4}\psi\bigr ) ~{\cal d}\bigl ( [ -g]^{1/4}\overline{\psi } \bigr ) \nonumber \\ & & \times ~{\cal d}\bigl ( [ -g]^{1/4}\sigma \bigr ) \frac{v_{a(\mu}(x)}{{\rm det}[v(x ) ] } \frac{\delta s}{\delta v^{\nu)}_a(x ) } ~e^{i s_y } , \label{tpath}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this equation is rewritten as @xmath29 } { \frac{\delta}{\delta v^{\nu)}_a(x ) } } \bigl(-i{\rm ln } z \bigr ) .
\label{def : em}\ ] ] where @xmath30 is the generating functional which is defined by @xmath31^{1/4}\psi\bigr ) ~{\cal d}\bigl ( [ -g]^{1/4}\overline{\psi } \bigr ) ~{\cal d}\bigl ( [ -g]^{1/4}\sigma \bigr ) ~e^{i s_y}.\ ] ] we would like to discuss the evolution of the energy - momentum tensor to study a fermionic dark energy model . as a first step we confine ourselves to the minkowski spacetime , here .
the friedmann - robertson - walker metric for the spatial flatness is conformally related to a minkowski line element . for the minkowski metric the generating functional
is give by @xmath32+o(1/n)\bigr\ } , \label{def : z}\ ] ] where @xmath33 $ ] is the effective action : @xmath34 = \int\ ! d^d x \left\ { \frac{-\sigma^2}{2\lambda_0 } -i { \rm tr}~{\rm ln } ( i\gamma^\mu \partial_\mu-\sigma ) \right\}. \label{def : eac}\ ] ] the energy - momentum tensor @xmath35 contains a zero - point vacuum energy and is divergent .
we use the point splitting prescription to regularize the expectation value of it @xcite . substituting the eqs.([def : z ] ) and ( [ def : eac ] ) into eq.([def : em ] )
we obtain @xmath36 in the leading order of @xmath37-expansion where @xmath38 denote the differentiation with respect to @xmath39 and @xmath40 is the feynman propagator for the free fermion with mass @xmath20 which satisfies @xmath41 the second term in the right hand side of eq.([tmunu ] ) corresponds to the expectation value of the energy - momentum tensor of the free fermion with mass @xmath20 .
therefore the energy - momentum tensor of the four - fermion interaction model is given by the sum of the quadratic potential term of @xmath20 , i.e. , the first term in the right hand side of eq.([tmunu ] ) , and the energy - momentum tensor of the massive free fermion in the leading order of @xmath37-expansion .
it should be noted that the fermion mass @xmath20 is a dynamical variable .
we can determine the dynamically generated fermion mass by evaluating the effective potential .
next we study the thermal effect to the energy - momentum tensor . as is shown in eq.([tmunu ] ) , the vacuum expectation value for the energy - momentum tensor is described by the free fermion propagator .
following the imaginary time formalism , the fermion propagator at finite temperature is obtained from the one at @xmath42 by the wick rotation and the replacements @xcite @xmath43 where @xmath44 .
the discrete variable @xmath45 is given by @xmath46 according to the anti - periodic boundary condition of the fermion field .
after these replacement and some calculations the energy - momentum tensor ( [ tmunu ] ) at finite temperature in the leading order of the @xmath37 expansion reads @xmath47\nonumber\\ & & \hspace{1.2 cm } -\langle 0|t^{00}|0\rangle , \label{c}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath48\nonumber \\ & & \hspace{1.2 cm } - \langle 0|t^{ii}|0 \rangle , \label{c2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath49 is the trace with respect to the fermion legs in an arbitrary dimensions @xmath9 , @xmath50 . since the zero - point of energy - momentum tensor is unknown parameter in the quantum field theory , we subtract the expectation value for @xmath42 , @xmath51 , to normalize it .
since the four fermion interaction is not renormalizable , we consider the spacetime dimension less than @xmath52 to regularize the theory .
here we regards the theory for @xmath53 with @xmath54 sufficiently small positive as a regularization of the one in four dimensions .
there is a correspondence between the positive regularization parameter @xmath54 and the cut - off scale @xmath55 of the theory @xcite , @xmath56 where @xmath57 is a renormalization scale . to obtain the expectation value of @xmath20 which corresponds to the dynamical fermion mass
we evaluate the effective potential @xmath58 of the four - fermion interaction model at finite temperature . in arbitrary spacetime dimensions @xmath59
it is given by @xcite @xmath60 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] at the large @xmath12 limit .
the expectation value of @xmath20 is determined by observing the minimum of the effective potential . in the present paper
we are interested in the influence of the chiral symmetry breaking .
hence we take the coupling @xmath11 larger than the critical one and numerically calculate the behavior of @xmath20 as is shown in fig .
[ fig : sigma ] . for @xmath61 as a function of @xmath62 .
@xmath63 is the expectation value at @xmath42.,width=257 ] the dynamical fermion mass is generated below a critical temperature , @xmath64 .
details of the generated fermion mass is disscussed in ref .
@xcite for @xmath65 . inserting the expectation value of @xmath20 into the eqs .
( [ c ] ) and ( [ c2 ] ) we obtain the energy - momentum tensor of the four - fermion interaction model at finite @xmath62 . for the case of chiral symmetry restoration ( i.e. @xmath66 )
the fermion is massless .
we get the traceless energy - momentum tensor @xmath67 where the density @xmath0 is introduced by @xmath68 which is always positive by numerical calculations and formally satisfies the photon like equation of state at high temperature , @xmath69 , with @xmath53 .
the behavior for @xmath69 is very reasonable because @xmath70 means the massless field model !
so its equation of state must be similar to the photon s . for the case of chiral symmetry breaking with @xmath20 nonzero
, we have @xmath71 where the small correction @xmath72 is also positive and the energy - momentum tensor elements also satisfy the eos for the dark energy with the background of temperature dependent cosmological constant @xmath73/(2\lambda)$ ] . the behavior of the energy - momentum tensor is illustrated in figs . [
fig : t00 ] and [ fig : tii ] . as is explained above , zero - point of @xmath74 can not be determined in the quantum field theory
. we normalize it which satisfies @xmath75 at @xmath42 .
as is clearly seen , the negative pressure is realized for a low temperature region .
the lines turn sharply at the critical temperature @xmath64 . for @xmath61 as a function of @xmath62.,width=257 ] for @xmath61 as a function of @xmath62.,width=257 ] in the following section we turn to the the classical cosmological tests of eos for our model .
in addition to the friedmann equation we have the important equation to satisfy when we solve the evolution of the universe . it is the conservation for the energy - momentum tensor of the cosmic fluid given by @xmath76 where subscript @xmath77 describes each species of the fluids in the considering universe .
here we mainly discuss the evolution of the universe which is dominated by the dark energy of our model .
since the recent observational data strongly suggest that our universe is spatially flat @xcite , that is @xmath78 in eq.([aa ] ) , we will also investigate only this case here . in this framework
we mainly discuss several classical observational tests @xcite for this mysterious dark energy problem .
a dimensionless quantity is more useful to discuss physical phenomena of our model . in the standard cosmology , for convenience ,
the density fraction of the world is expressed in terms of a critical density which is defined by the total energy density , i.e. @xmath79 . when we treat the flat , homogeneous and isotropic universe
, the comoving coordinates is convenient to describe the dynamical evolution of it . in this treatment the coordinates at any place do not vary with the evolution of the universe .
it is described by a scale factor @xmath4 that is a function of only cosmic time in the homogeneous and isotropic universe . if we find the relationship between the scale factor and the cosmic time , then the evolution of the universe is clearly understood .
for example , we can directly deduce the hubble parameter and the deceleration parameters as a function of time , the dependence of the luminosity distance on redshift and so on . by investigating its dynamical evolution in the dark energy dominant era
, we compare the observable quantities derived in our model with the experimental data .
we first consider a general case where equation of state is written by @xmath80 the parameter @xmath81 depend on the spacetime dimension @xmath9 and this dependence is assumed to be extremely small for low temperature region . by using the continuity equation ( [ ag ] ) and the eq.([ea1 ] ) , we easily obtain the evolution of the energy density @xmath0 which obeys @xmath82 where @xmath83 is the present energy density of the universe and @xmath84 is given by @xmath85 . substituting eq.([eb ] ) in the friedmann equation , we get @xmath86 , \label{ec}\ ] ] where @xmath87 is the hubble parameter today and @xmath88 is the density parameter defined by @xmath89 . since we consider the flat universe , the density parameters must satisfy the relation , @xmath90 .
it is hard to solve the friedmann equation ( [ ec ] ) in general situations , because we do not know the eos for the dark energy . from eq.([ec ] ) , however , we can easily obtain the evolution of the scale factor .
if we consider the dark energy dominant situation , the scale factor behaves as @xmath91 the latter solution shows the same behavior with the inflationally expansion when the energy scale is sufficiently high .
we may use it to describe the accelerating expansion with a cosmological constant in the low energy scale , as observed today .
the dynamical evolution factor is just the function of eos which is shown in fig .
[ scale ] . comparing the lines in the figure
, we can see that for the smaller value of @xmath84 the scale factor @xmath4 increases faster . ) as a function of cosmic time .
here we use the following values @xmath92 , @xmath93 . , width=257 ]
following the fact that our universe is expanding , one may ask a question that the expansion of our universe is accelerating or decelerating now , or how fast it expands ? a parameter to describe the evolution of the universe is not only the hubble parameter but also another important parameter , so called the deceleration parameter @xmath94 which is defined by @xmath95 the parameter @xmath94 is dimensionless parameter which describes the rate for slowing the expansion . by using eq.([ee ] ) we obtain @xmath96 as a first consideration we assume that the state equation parameter @xmath81 is constant in the dark energy dominant era . in the four - fermion interaction model
we show the evolution of the deceleration parameter in fig .
[ fig : w ] . as is clearly seen in fig .
[ fig : w ] @xmath81 is not a constant .
the evolutions of @xmath81 depend on both the temperature and the regularization parameter @xmath54 which is related to the cut - off scale of the theory .
however , we think that the constant @xmath81 is a good approximation when we consider the present evolution of our universe because our universe is bathed in enough low temperature now . generally speaking ,
the deceleration parameter @xmath94 is a function of both the present density @xmath97 and @xmath81 .
furthermore , it is also a function of the parameter @xmath54 because we consider a non - renormalizable model as a low energy effective theory .
with respect to @xmath98 .
we set @xmath61 .
, width=257 ] figure [ fig : w ] shows that the relationship between the parameter @xmath81 and the regularization parameter @xmath54 . the present @xmath81 ( low temperature region ) seems almost a monotone function of the parameter . the parameter @xmath81 smoothly falls down and the curves become flat as @xmath62 decreases . at the lower temperature limit @xmath81 approaches the cosmological constant limit .
it shows the exponential expansion of the present universe . as is shown in eq .
( [ es ] ) @xmath81 becomes @xmath99 at the high temperature limit .
it is a property of the massless fermion .
therefore the exponential expansion only appears at the low temperature region in our model without any fine tunings .
it is a very important property to a dark energy candidate .
slopes of each lines in fig.[fig : w ] are depend on the coupling @xmath11 . for larger coupling @xmath11
the slope becomes steeper .
however , the behaviors of @xmath81 does not change qualitatively as @xmath11 varies . from the recent sn ia and cosmic microwave background observations @xcite
a cosmological constant - like dark energy may exist today which accelerate the expansion of the universe .
it suggests that the decelerating parameter lies in a range , @xmath100 .
this observational constraint is naturally satisfied in the four - fermion interaction model .
recently there are many dark energy models of simple scalar fields like the quintessence @xcite , however , they all need fine tuning of some parameters to certain extents . in the present model , on the other hand , fine tuning is not necessary . in other words
the model has some properties which are realized in the quintessence scenario without any cosmological constant - like terms .
certainly we need more sn ia observational data to confirm the important constraint , which is just the main mission of the near future snap project .
we investigated the cosmological effects of the vacuum expectation value of energy momentum tensor in a four fermion interaction model . according to the imaginary time formalism we derive the explicit form of the energy momentum tensor .
the energy - momentum tensor depends on the temperature and the dynamically generated fermion mass .
the fermion field is massless and has the similar property as the radiation field above the critical temperature .
we consider that the temperature of the present universe is much less than the critical one and the chiral symmetry is broken down dynamically .
thus the composite operator of the fermion and the anti - fermion develops a non - vanishing vacuum expectation value in the present stage of the universe .
the vacuum expectation value plays a role of the cosmological constant - like . applying it to models of the universe without an explicit cosmological constant term , we discussed the dependence of the scale factor @xmath4 on the state equation parameter @xmath81 and evaluate the deceleration parameter @xmath94 .
we found that the behavior of the eos is dramatically changed at low temperature .
a dark energy property was naturally obtained in the four - fermion interaction model . in the present analysis
the fermion mass scale can be at the scale of neutrino , qcd , electroweak symmetry breaking , extra - dimension @xcite and so on .
we have had a loosely constrained parameter range for the cosmological constant @xcite .
for more concrete analysis we must apply the results to some cosmological tests with comparisons to observational data , which are under our investigations .
our model is only a prototype one , but we believe that the results are worth discussing further about the real world . by observational data analysis
we know the dark energy is almost smoothly distributed @xcite , which implies a kind of very weak interaction that we are not very clear about yet .
here we just employ the simple four - fermion interaction model to give the global energy momentum tensor which depends on temperature and some model parameters
. it might be too simple , however we found interesting results .
as a next step , it is very important to apply our analysis to other well - defined and more realistic models .
one of the interesting models is susy njl model @xcite . for the susy njl model the effective action is written as @xmath101 & = & \int d^4x \left [ { \rm tr}\ln(i\not{\!\partial}-\sigma ) \right .
\nonumber \\ & & \qquad \left .
-2 { \rm tr}\ln(\partial^2- \sigma^2 ) + n\sigma^2/(2\lambda ) \right ] . \label{db}\end{aligned}\ ] ] according to the supersymmetry , contributions from the fermion and boson loops cancel out each other exactly at @xmath42 .
since the thermal effect restore the chiral symmetry , dynamical symmetry breaking does not take place even at finite temperature .
if we introduce a soft susy breaking term such as @xmath102 and/or @xmath103 in the action @xcite , then the contribution from the boson loop is modified .
the composite operator @xmath104 can develop a non - vanishing vacuum expectation value which satisfies the dark energy property to some range .
the scalar mass depends on the coupling parameter .
when the coupling parameter is large enough , @xmath105 , the scalar mass @xmath106 becomes heavier than the dynamical fermion mass .
we can choose the coupling parameter @xmath107 to realize the appropriate scale for the cosmological constant and the negative pressure of the present universe accordingly .
so far the origin of the dark energy in the current cosmological models is still under discussions with many theoretical speculations .
it is accommodated in the standard friedmann cosmology based on the relativistic gravitational theory with a cosmological constant - like term .
it can also be interpreted in extended gravity scenarios and corresponding cosmological models , like the brane cosmologys .
that attracts us to further research works continuously .
the paper is started in x. h. meng s academic visit at hiroshima university supported from jsps invitation fellowship .
the authors have also benefited a lot from discussions with many people , especially , d. kimura , g. senjanovich , x. p.
wu , k. yamamoto and z. h. zhu .
this work is also supported partly by grant of no.nk-brsf g19990753 from ministry of science and technology of china .
99 see for example , s. perlmutter , m. s. turner and m. white , phys .
lett . * 83 * , 670 ( 1999 ) .
p. bernadis , _ et al _ , nature * 404 * , 955 ( 2000 ) ; + s. hanany , _ et al _ , astrophys .
* 545 * , l5 ( 2000 ) ; + a. balbi , _ et al _ , astrophys .
* 545 * , l1 ( 2000 ) ; + m. collers , astro - ph/0305051 ; + d. spergel , _ et al _ , astro - ph/0302209 ; + c. bennet , _ et al _ , astro - ph/0302207 for example . s. perlmutter , _ et al _ , nature * 391 * , 51 ( 1998 ) ; + j. tonry , _ et al _ , astro - ph/0305008 .
for example see , m. r. nolta , _ et al _ , astro - ph/0305097 and references therein s. perlmutter , _ et al _ , nature * 404 * , 955 ( 2000 ) ; astrophys .
j. * 517 * , 565 ( 1999 ) ; + a. riess , _ et al _ , astrophys .
j. * 116 * , 1009 ( 1998 ) ; ibid , * 560 * , 49 ( 2001 ) ; + p. peebles , astro - ph/0208037 ; astro - ph/0207347 and references therein .
for example see , p. peebles and b. ratra , astrophys . j. lett . * 325 * , l17 ( 1998 ) ; + c. wetterich , nucl .
b * 302 * , 668 ( 1998 ) ; + l. a. boyle , _ et al _ , astro - ph/0105318 ; + c. a. picon , _ et al _ , astro - ph/0004134 .
j. i. kapusta , _ finite - temperature field theory _ ( cambridge university press , 1989 ) ; + l. bellac , _ thermal field theory _
( cambridge university press , 1996 ) ; + a. das , _ finite temperature field theory _
( world scientific , 1997 ) .
t. inagaki , t. muta and s. d. odintsov , mod .
lett . a * 8
* , 2117 ( 1993 ) ; + t. inagaki , s. mukaigawa and t. muta , phys .
* d52 * , 4267 ( 1995 ) ; + k. ishikawa , t. inagaki and t. muta , mod .
a * 11 * , 939 ( 1996 ) ; + t. inagaki , int .
a * 11 * , 4561 ( 1996 ) ; + t. inagaki and k. ishikawa , phys . rev .
* d56 * , 5097 ( 1997 ) .
n. rius and v. sanz , phys . rev . *
d64 * , 075006 ( 2001 ) .
t. inagaki , t. muta and s. d. odintsov , prog .
phys . suppl . *
127 * , 93 ( 1997 ) .
y. nambu and g. jona - lasinio , phys . rev . *
122 * , 345 ( 1961 ) .
d. j. gross and a. neveu , phys . rev .
* d10 * , 3235 ( 1974 ) .
n. d. birrell and p. c. w. davies , _ quantum field theory in curved space _
( cambridge university press , 1982 ) ; + s. a. fulling , _ aspects of quantum field theory in curved space - time _ ( cambridge university press , 1989 ) ; + r. m. wald , _ quantum field theory in curved spacetime and black - hole thermodynamics _ ( the university of chicago press , 1994 ) .
l. dolan and r. jackiw phys . rev . * d9
* , 3320 ( 1974 ) , + s. weinberg , phys . rev . * d9 * , 3357 ( 1974 )
. t. inagaki , t. kouno and t. muta , int .
phys . a * 10 * , 2241 ( 1995 ) . c. pryke , astro - ph/0104490 . c. b. netterfield , _ et al _ , astro - ph/0104460 .
r. stompor , astro - ph/0105062 .
x. meng , _ et al _ , int .
j. mod .
d * 3 * , 369(2003 ) ; hep - ph/0210096 .
for example see , h. abe , k. fukazawa and t. inagaki , prog .
. phys . * 107 * , 1047 ( 2002 ) ; + h. abe and t. inagaki , phys .
d 66 * , 085001 ( 2002 ) .
s. weinberg , phys .
59 * , 2697 ( 1987 ) ; rev .
* 61 * , 1 ( 1989 ) .
p. avelino , j. p. m. de carvalho and c. j. a. p. martins , phys . rev . *
d64 * , 063505 ( 2001 ) . w. buchmuller and s. t. love , nucl .
b * 204 * , 213 ( 1982 ) .
i. l. buchbinder , t. inagaki and s. d. odintsov , mod .
a * 12 * , 2271 ( 1997 ) ; + t. inagaki , s. d. odintsov and y. i. shilnov , int .
a * 14 * , 481 ( 1999 ) .
j. hashida , t. muta and k. ohkura , phys .
b * 451 * , 343 ( 1999 ) ; + j. hashida , t. muta and k. ohkura , mod .
a * 13 * , 1235 ( 1998 ) . | cosmology enters precision testing period with the observational experiments advancement .
we have not arrived to decipher the origin of the dominant dark energy component of our universe , although we have located some of its characters . in such a situation
the possibilities of a simple four - fermion interaction model are investigated to describe dark energy characters .
we explicitly calculate the vacuum expectation value of the energy - momentum tensor and discuss the results with comparison to the equation of state for dark energy requirement .
it is found that the negative pressure is realized at low temperature .
it is an appropriate property as a dark energy candidate .
we also investigate some cosmological tests for the dark energy via its equation of state . |
the nernst effect in the cuprate superconductors has recently become a focus of attention both experimentally @xcite and theoretically @xcite .
the nernst effect is the electric field induced when the sample has a temperature gradient , @xmath1 , perpendicular to the magnetic field , @xmath2 ; this electric field is perpendicular to both @xmath1 and @xmath2 .
for some cuprate superconductors the nernst effect due to superconducting fluctuations is detectable at temperatures far above the transition temperature , @xmath3 @xcite .
@xcite calculated the low - field nernst effect for @xmath4 due to superconducting fluctuations , obtaining results in reasonable agreement ( in absolute units ) with experimental data .
they used the linearized time - dependent ginzburg - landau ( tdgl ) equation , which is identical to the aslamazov - larkin @xcite approximation for the microscopics .
linearized ( gaussian ) tdgl is applicable far enough above the mean - field transition temperature @xmath5 , where the order parameter fluctuations are small enough to neglect the nonlinear terms in the full ginzburg - landau free energy . to estimate the nernst effect closer to @xmath3 they also treated the nonlinearities in tdgl in the hartree approximation @xcite .
prominent in the phase diagrams of the cuprate superconductors in a magnetic field is the _ vortex liquid regime _ , where short - range superconducting correlations are strong ( because @xmath6 ) , but thermal phase and vortex fluctuations disrupt the superconducting coherence on longer scales .
the experimentally observed nernst effect remains large in this regime @xcite , which is not accessible to analytic calculations due to its strong correlations and fluctuations .
however , the tdgl equation with its full nonlinearity and driven by thermal fluctuations can be numerically simulated in this vortex liquid regime , and its nernst effect measured and compared to experiments , as we demonstrate below . when the tdgl approximation is used to model properties of cuprate superconductors ,
for which there is not a well - established more microscopic theory , or more generally when it is used well away from the zero - field critical temperature , as we do here , it constitutes a standard , widely - used , but essentially phenomenological approximation .
it has the virtue that most of the parameters that enter can be determined from experiments , as we discuss below . for bcs superconductors ,
the tdgl approximation can be systematically derived from the microscopics in some limited regimes @xcite , but here we are instead using it more broadly , in regimes where its justification is `` only '' phenomenological . the nernst effect in the vortex liquid can be described in terms of the vortices as the phase - slip voltage due to vortices being transported down the temperature gradient as heat carriers . however
, when one calculates the nernst effect at higher temperatures in linearized tdgl @xcite , what is happening is that superconducting order parameter fluctuations are transported along the temperature gradient and their phase patterns are twisted by this motion across the magnetic field , inducing a nernst voltage ; vortices play no role in the calculation . in a tdgl treatment of the vortex liquid regime
, there is no clean distinction between order parameter fluctuations and vortex motion , so both of these two different - sounding descriptions are in some sense correct . in this paper , we present the method for and results of simulations of thermoelectric transport in type - ii superconductors in the vortex liquid regime .
we simulate the tdgl equation with thermal noise .
we work in the strongly type - ii limit , @xmath7 , where the magnetic field in the sample is assumed to be uniform and not fluctuating .
mostly we work in two dimensions , but we also examine the crossover from two - dimensional to three - dimensional behavior . in our study of interlayer couplings
we see some indication that a substantial part of the entropy carried by the vortices in the vortex liquid may be the configurational entropy of their positions .
our simulations involve a dimensionless tunable parameter ( @xmath8 ) which sets the strength of the thermal fluctuations in the sample and hence can range from nearly mean - field behavior with very weak fluctuations to very strong fluctuations with strongly suppressed superconductivity .
we show that for an intermediate value of this parameter our results are in reasonably good qualitative and quantitative agreement with available experimental nernst - effect data on overdoped la@xmath9sr@xmath10cuo@xmath11 ( lsco ) @xcite . in this comparison
all the other parameters in the simulations are set by experimentally measured quantities .
we also discuss in brief the results of our simulations to model experiments on bi@xmath12sr@xmath12cacu@xmath12o@xmath13 ( bscco ) @xcite .
we briefly review some of the general theory of thermal and electrical transport coefficients in linear response in the presence of a magnetic field .
consider a sample at temperature @xmath14 subjected to small gradients in the potential @xmath15 and temperature @xmath16 .
one can then very generally write down the transport current densities in the system to linear order in @xmath15 and @xmath16 as @xmath17 @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the charge transport current density and @xmath20 is the heat transport current density . @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 and @xmath24 are the electrical conductivity , thermoelectric , electrothermal and thermal conductivity tensors .
the onsager relations for the transport coefficients tell us that @xmath25 .
the nernst coefficent ( @xmath26 ) can be defined in a configuration with a magnetic field @xmath27 and @xmath28 along with the condition @xmath29 as @xmath30 if the system shows no hall effect ( like the one we have simulated ) , then @xmath31 and @xmath32 one way to obtain transport coefficients from a simulation is via the kubo relations , thus measuring current - current correlations in the equilibrium dynamics .
alternatively , one can apply an electric field and/or a temperature gradient and measure the resulting currents .
we have used both methods , finding that our implementation of the latter method gives higher signal - to - noise ratio per unit computer time in the regime we have been studying .
the currents flowing in the sample have magnetization parts in addition to the transport parts considered above .
one could write down linear response relations for the total current densities analogous to the ones for the transport current densities but the coefficients appearing in those would not obey the onsager relations .
the total currents in the system can in general be computed in a straightforward manner but one has to extract the transport parts from these to calculate the transport coefficients .
this involves identifying and subtracting out the magnetization currents .
the procedure we use to that end in this work is outlined below and is based on the arguments of cooper _ et al .
_ @xcite .
let @xmath33 and @xmath34 be the total charge and heat current densities ( transport + magnetization ) at any point @xmath35 in the sample . if @xmath36 is the electric potential at @xmath35 , there exists a total energy current @xmath37 such that @xmath38 a similar relation holds between the transport parts of these current densities , @xmath39 the average electric current density @xmath40 and heat current density @xmath41 are given by averaging @xmath42 and @xmath43 over the whole sample . for a two dimensional sample @xmath44 and @xmath45 where @xmath46 is the area of the sample .
similar relations also hold for three dimensional samples . from eqns .
( 6 ) and ( 8) , we obtain @xmath47 we know that @xmath48 where @xmath49 and @xmath50 are the charge and energy magnetization current densities .
it can be shown on general grounds @xcite that there exist charge and energy magnetization densities @xmath51 and @xmath52 such that @xmath53 the charge magnetization of the system is nothing but the conventional magnetic moment density @xmath54 . if the material surrounding the sample is assumed to be non - magnetic , both @xmath55 and @xmath52 vanish outside the sample .
the magnetization currents are mostly at the boundaries because that is where the change in magnetization is the largest . thus we see that @xmath56 from eqns ( 9 ) and ( 12 ) , we obtain @xmath57 it should be noted that there is no heat magnetization density " @xmath58 analogous to @xmath55 and @xmath52 for which the heat magnetization current @xmath59 .
a consequence of this is that unlike @xmath60 and @xmath61 , @xmath62 in fact , it can be shown that @xmath63
we measure the transport coefficient @xmath64 by turning on an electric field @xmath65 and a magnetic field @xmath27 and measuring @xmath66 , the @xmath67 component of the average heat transport current density at constant temperature .
this is done in a system with mixed boundary conditions : it has free surfaces at the boundaries normal to @xmath68 , while it has periodic boundary conditions along the @xmath67-direction ( and along @xmath69 when we study 3d ) .
if , as in our model , the system does not have a hall response , under these conditions the @xmath67 component of the electric transport current vanishes at all points , @xmath70 .
thus from eqns .
( 2 ) and ( 13 ) , we obtain @xmath71 similarly , @xmath0 can be measured by introducing a temperature gradient @xmath72 and magnetic field @xmath27 with no external electric potential and measuring @xmath73 . from eqns .
( 1 ) and ( 12 ) , @xmath74 the two coefficients @xmath64 are @xmath0 can thus be obtained by measuring only the total currents in the system .
they are related to each other by the onsager relation and to the nernst coefficient by eqn .
the tdgl equation that we have simulated is @xmath75 we take @xmath76 to be real so there is neither hall effect nor seebeck effect @xcite .
this approximation of leaving out the hall effect should be reasonable as long as the hall angle is small , as it generally is in the vortex liquid regime of the cuprate superconductors .
we work in the type - ii limit where the magnetic field is assumed to be uniform and not fluctuating .
the noise correlator is @xmath77 the current operators we need are @xcite @xmath78 the tdgl equation is the simplest dynamical stochastic equation one can obtain from the ginzburg - landau free energy functional . as a consequence of its simple relaxational dynamics , it does not explicitly conserve either total charge or total energy .
it is implicitly in contact with and exchanging energy and charge with local reservoirs . in reality
these reservoirs are presumably the phonons , quasiparticles and other excitations not included in the tdgl equation .
nevertheless , the charge and energy currents carried by the superconducting order parameter @xmath79 and its fluctuations are as given above and can be measured and their transport properties determined within this model . charge and energy conservation can explicitly be taken into account in microscopic derivations of the tdgl theory , where only the contribution due to superconducting fluctuations is retained .
it can however be shown that other effects ( normal state contributions etc . )
do not contribute as significantly to the nernst effect as superconducting fluctuations @xcite .
an important feature of tdgl for the present work is that the parameter @xmath76 , which sets the time scale , does not enter in the values of the transverse thermoelectric coefficients that we are studying , @xmath0 and @xmath80 .
this allows quantitative comparison to experiments to be done without estimating @xmath76 , which is fortunate , because the value of @xmath76 is quite uncertain .
this tdgl equation with noise has a dimensionless parameter that gives the strength of the thermal fluctuations . to remove all the dimensional quantities ,
we use @xmath81 , the zero temperature coherence length , as our unit of length ; @xmath5 , @xmath82 , @xmath83 and @xmath84 as our units of temperature , energy , magnetic flux and time , respectively ; and @xmath85 , the zero - temperature order parameter magnitude , as our unit for the order parameter
. the resulting tdgl equation is then @xmath86 with noise correlator @xmath87 and @xmath88 is the fluctuation parameter , where @xmath89 is the number of spatial dimensions .
when @xmath90 , the actual critical temperature @xmath3 is near the mean - field critical temperature @xmath91 , while if @xmath92 then @xmath93 . the model has four parameters that remain after scaling to the units specified above : the temperature , the magnetic field , the cutoff , and the strength @xmath8 of the noise .
we initially simulate a two - dimensional system , thus ignoring interlayer coupling . we discretize space and time .
the spatial grid spacing is taken to be @xmath81 .
this rather coarse spatial grid is used to minimize the computer time needed to simulate samples large compared to this microscopic length .
there are noticeable quantitative effects of using such a coarse grid .
for example , in our units @xmath94 with this grid , while it is 1.0 for the continuum model .
however , recognizing that the model we are simulating is rather simple , so should not be expected to give highly precise quantitative results , our goal in the present study is to be quantitatively only as accurate as might be expected of such a simple model . although we do not know how accurate that really is , the general precision to which we have chosen to work is roughly 10% to 20% .
the quantitative shifts due to our using a coarse grid in the simulations are at most of this magnitude .
we have also verified that using a finer grid spacing would not alter our results in any significant way .
reduction of the grid spacing adds more degrees of freedom , resulting in increased fluctuations , and suppression of @xmath3 and @xmath95 .
however , if one also lowers the value of the fluctuation parameter @xmath8 a little , this increase in the fluctuations can be removed , and the resulting behavior of the system is only weakly dependent on the grid spacing . in the simulations ,
the time step is chosen to be between 0.02 and 0.1 in our units , with shorter steps at higher temperatures ; we check that our results are not affected by doubling the time step .
a first - order euler method is used , with 10000 to 20000 time steps used for equilibration , and 30000 to 50000 steps for averaging .
the two - dimensional data we show are for a 50@xmath9650 square grid .
we use the gauge - invariance of the tdgl equation to work as much as possible in terms of gauge - invariant quantities like @xmath97 and the gauge - invariant phase differences @xmath98 where @xmath99 .
the current densities are also written in terms of these quantities . at @xmath100 , for the two - dimensional system
there is a kosterlitz - thouless @xcite transition at @xmath3 , which we locate by measuring the helicity modulus . to obtain @xmath64
, we measure the transverse energy current due an electric field .
we then use the onsager relation to obtain @xmath101 .
we find that the signal to noise ratio for this measurement is significantly smaller than in a direct measurement of @xmath0 .
we have numerically verified the validity of this onsager relation by measuring @xmath0 both ways .
this also serves as a check that we are indeed measuring the proper transport coefficients .
we also confirm that our results agree with the analytic results @xcite in the higher - temperature regime where linearized tdgl applies .
the temperature enters the tdgl equation both in the term linear in the order parameter and in the intensity of the noise .
it can be shown that introducing a gradient in the linear term only adds to the magnetization currents , and thus for measuring the transport currents it is sufficient to include the temperature gradient only in the noise term .
we have also verified this numerically .
some results for @xmath0 from the two - dimensional simulations are shown in fig .
1 . we have chosen to compare these results to the experimental results of wang _ et al . _
@xcite obtained from nernst and resistivity measurements on an overdoped lsco sample with @xmath102 and @xmath103k . for this comparison , we present the simulation results in si units using the parameters from the experiment , @xmath104 t ( thus @xmath105 ) and layer spacing @xmath106 .
the fluctuation parameter has been adjusted to @xmath107 to give reasonable quantitative agreement between simulation and experiment .
we set the temperature scale using @xmath108k , which gives @xmath103k in the simulation .
note that @xmath0 is not directly measured in the experiments . for a system with negligible hall effect
, @xmath0 can be obtained from the measured nernst effect and the longitudinal resistivity .
thus for this comparison we require both these measurements to be made on the same sample over a substantial portion of the vortex liquid regime .
this requirement seriously limits the number of experimental results we can compare to .
looking at fig . 1 , we see that there is reasonably good general qualitative and quantitative correspondence between the simulation and experiment , considering how simple the model is and that we have adjusted only the strength of the thermal fluctuations @xmath8 to get this agreement .
the other parameters are all dictated by experiment .
our results are thus consistent with the proposition that the superconducting fluctuations modelled by the tdgl equation produce most , if not all , of the contributions to the large nernst effect seen in the vortex liquid regime for this cuprate sample . of course , the agreement between experiment and this simple model is not perfect .
one difference is seen at high field in the higher-@xmath14 panel of fig .
1 , where the simulations give a nearly - constant @xmath0 , while the experiment shows more variation .
one effect that is not included in our two - dimensional simulations is interlayer coupling .
for the cuprates , this can become important in the vortex liquid at low fields in the vicinity of @xmath3 , where there is a crossover to three - dimensional behavior as the correlation length normal to the layers becomes larger than one layer spacing .
note that the difference between simulation and experiment is large at low fields and @xmath110k .
we considered the possibility that this difference might be due to the crossover to three - dimensional behavior , which is not present in our two - dimensional simulation . to investigate this crossover , we have also simulated the lawrence - doniach @xcite version of the tdgl equation . in our units
this is where @xmath112 is the interlayer josephson coupling per unit area , and @xmath113 is the layer index .
the transition temperature is located by finding the intersections of the fourth - order cumulant ( binder ratio ) curves @xmath114 for different system sizes as functions of temperature at zero magnetic field .
2 shows results for @xmath0 as a function of field for various values of interlayer coupling @xmath112 at temperature @xmath115k , from samples of size 15@xmath9615@xmath9610 layers . for each
@xmath112 we set the the temperature scale ( @xmath91 ) so that @xmath116k as in the experiment .
the values of the other parameters in the simulations are as used in fig .
1 . as expected , the the largest value of @xmath112 shows the largest deviation from the two - dimensional behavior .
somewhat better correspondence between the behavior of @xmath0 obtained in simulation and experiment is obtained by adding this interlayer coupling . an interesting point to note in fig .
2 is that at low fields a rather small interlayer coupling @xmath112 produces a strong decrease in @xmath0 . describing this in terms of vortices , as seems appropriate in this low - field regime below @xmath3 ,
the force per unit length on a vortex line due to the temperature gradient is proportional to @xmath0 .
naively , this force is also set by the entropy per unit length transported by a moving vortex .
this transport entropy may come from internal degrees of freedom within one vortex , or it may come from the configurational entropy of the many possible spatial arrangements of the vortices .
the latter does not involve internal excitations within the vortices . in the quasi - two - dimensional layered superconductors that we are modelling , a vortex line running normal to the layers consists of pancake vortices " in each layer .
a weak interlayer coupling has little effect on the internal properties of a single pancake vortex , but it does produce an attraction between vortices in adjacent layers that reduces their relative motion , and thus can substantially reduce the configurational entropy of the vortices . the fact that at low fields a weak interlayer coupling greatly reduces the transport entropy of the vortices , as indicated by the reduction of @xmath0 seen in fig.2 , thus suggests that in this regime the configurational entropy of the vortices is a large part of their transport entropy , at least within this layered tdgl model .
we have also performed simulations to model the bscco sample studied by ri _
_ @xcite . the experimental data and the results of the simulation are shown in fig .
3 . the quantity plotted is the measured `` transport energy '' of the vortices , defined as @xmath117 .
we used a two - dimensional simulation with @xmath118 k , @xmath119 t , @xmath120 and @xmath121 .
again , there is reasonable quantitative agreement , in absolute units , between the experimental data and the simulations .
the clearest deviation here occurs for @xmath122k and @xmath123 t , in conclusion , we have measured the transverse thermoelectric transport coefficient @xmath0 in simulations of the vortex - liquid regime of superconductors modeled by the tdgl equation with thermal fluctuations .
we find that our simulations of a two - dimensional superconductor reproduce reasonably well much of the qualitative and quantitative features of available experimental data from some cuprate high - temperature superconductors .
we have also studied the crossover from two - dimensional to three - dimensional behavior in a layered superconductor .
this crossover study indicates that the configurational entropy of the vortices may constitute a large part of their transport entropy at low magnetic field just below @xmath3 .
we thank yayu wang and n. p. ong for providing us with the lsco data .
we also thank them , shivaji sondhi and especially iddo ussishkin for many useful discussions .
this work is supported by the nsf through mrsec grant dmr-0213706 .
a. i. larkin and a. a. varlamov , in _ handbook on superconductivity , vol 1 : conventional and high - t@xmath126 superconductors _ , edited by k. h. bennemann and j. b. ketterson , ( springer , berlin , 2003 ) . , , ,
* * , ( ) . | we measure the transverse thermoelectric coefficient @xmath0 in simulations of type - ii superconductors in the vortex liquid regime , using the time - dependent ginzburg - landau ( tdgl ) equation with thermal noise .
our results are in reasonably good quantitative agreement with experimental data on cuprate samples , suggesting that this simple model contains much of the physics behind the large nernst effect due to superconducting fluctuations observed in these materials . |
given a link @xmath2 and a linear group @xmath3 , a _ tracefree _
( or _ traceless _ ) @xmath3-representation of @xmath0 means a homomorphism @xmath4 sending each meridian to an element of trace zero . dated back to 1980 ,
magnus @xcite used tracefree @xmath5-representations to prove the faithfulness of a representation of braid groups in the automorphism groups of the rings generated by the characters functions on free groups .
lin @xcite used tracefree @xmath6-representations to define a casson - type invariant of a knot @xmath7 , and showed it to equal half of the signature of @xmath7 .
more interestingly , kronheimer and mrowka @xcite observed that for some knots @xmath7 , its khovanov homology is isomorphic to the ordinary homology of the space @xmath8 of conjugacy classes of tracefree representations of @xmath7 . in this context ,
zentner @xcite determined @xmath8 when @xmath7 belongs to a class of classical pretzel knots .
for related works , one may refer to @xcite , @xcite , etc .
there are relatively fewer results on tracefree @xmath5-representations . for a knot @xmath9
, nagasato @xcite gave a set of polynomials whose zero loci is exactly the tracefree characters of irreducible @xmath5-representations of @xmath7 .
nagasato and yamaguchi @xcite investigated tracefree @xmath5-representations of @xmath10 ( where @xmath7 is a knot in an integral 3-sphere @xmath11 ) , and related to those of @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the 2-fold cover of @xmath11 branched along @xmath7 . in this paper
, for each montesinos link , we completely determine the tracefree @xmath5-representations by given explicit formulas
. let @xmath14 .
note that each @xmath15 satisfies @xmath16 . by a tangle " we mean an unoriented tangle diagram .
given a tangle @xmath17 , let @xmath18 denote the set of directed arcs of @xmath17 , ( each arc gives two directed arcs ) . by a _
( tracefree ) representation _ of a tangle diagram @xmath17 , we mean a map @xmath19 such that @xmath20 for each @xmath21 and at each crossing illustrated in figure [ fig : crossing ] , @xmath22 . to present such a representation , it is sufficient to give each arc a direction and label an element of @xmath23 beside it .
[ h ] at each crossing , title="fig:",scaledwidth=30.0% ] + [ h ] , with the four ends directed outwards , title="fig:",scaledwidth=33.0% ] + let @xmath24 denote the set of tangles @xmath17 with four ends which , when directed outwards , are denoted by @xmath25 , as shown in figure [ fig : general ] . the simplest four ones are given in figure [ fig : basic ] . in @xmath24
there are two binary operations : _ horizontal composition _
@xmath26 and _ vertical composition _
@xmath27 ; see figure [ fig : composition ] .
[ h ] $ ] , ( b ) @xmath28 $ ] , ( c ) @xmath29 $ ] , ( d ) @xmath30$],title="fig:",scaledwidth=80.0% ] + [ h ] ; ( b ) @xmath31,title="fig:",scaledwidth=60.0% ] + for @xmath32 , the horizontal composite of @xmath33 copies of @xmath29 $ ] ( resp .
[ -1 ] ) is denoted by @xmath34 $ ] if @xmath35 ( resp .
@xmath36 ) , and the vertical composite of @xmath33 copies of @xmath29 $ ] ( resp .
[ -1 ] ) is denoted by @xmath37 $ ] if @xmath35 ( resp .
@xmath36 ) . given integers @xmath38 , the _ rational tangle _
@xmath39,\ldots,[k_{m}]]$ ] is defined as @xmath40\star [ 1/k_{2}]\cdot\ldots\star [ 1/k_{m } ] , & & \text{if\ \ } 2\mid m , \\ & [ k_{1}]\star [ 1/k_{2}]\cdot\ldots\cdot [ k_{m } ] , & & \text{if\ \ } 2\nmid m;\end{aligned}\ ] ] and its _ fraction _ is defined by @xmath41,\ldots,[k_{m}]])=[[k_{1},\ldots , k_{m}]]^{(-1)^{m-1 } } , \label{eq : fraction}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the _ continued fraction _
@xmath42\in\mathbb{q}$ ] is defined inductively as @xmath43=k_{1 } , \qquad [ [ k_{1},\ldots , k_{m}]]=k_{m}+1/[[k_{1},\ldots , k_{m-1}]].\end{aligned}\ ] ] denote @xmath39,\ldots,[k_{m}]]$ ] as @xmath44 $ ] if the right - hand side of ( [ eq : fraction ] ) equals @xmath45 . a _
montesinos tangle _ is a tangle of the form @xmath46\star\ldots\star [ p_{r}/q_{r}]$ ] .
the link obtained by connecting @xmath47 and @xmath48 with @xmath49 and @xmath50 , respectively , is called a _ montesinos link _ and denoted by @xmath51 .
given a representation @xmath52 of @xmath53 , denote @xmath54
suppose @xmath42=[p / q]$ ] with @xmath55 .
for a representation @xmath52 of @xmath44 $ ] , let @xmath56 denote the elements that @xmath52 assigns to the directed arcs shown in figure [ fig : rational ] .
call @xmath57 the _ generating pair _ of @xmath52 , indicating that @xmath52 is determined by @xmath58 and @xmath59 .
[ h ] , [ k_{2}],[k_{3}]]$],title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] + suppose @xmath60 .
then @xmath61 , hence each @xmath62 or @xmath63 can be expressed as @xmath64 , where @xmath65 are polynomials in @xmath66 that do not depend on @xmath67 .
we take a clever approach to derive formulas for the coefficients @xmath65 . for @xmath68 ,
put @xmath69 [ lem : standard ] ( i ) if @xmath52 is a representation of @xmath34 $ ] with @xmath70 and @xmath71 , then @xmath72 and @xmath73 .
\(ii ) if @xmath52 is a representation of @xmath37 $ ] with @xmath74 and @xmath75 , then @xmath76 and @xmath77 .
\(i ) suppose @xmath52 is a representation of @xmath29 $ ] with @xmath70 and @xmath71 , then @xmath78 , and computing directly , @xmath79 applying this repeatedly , we obtain the result .
( ii ) the proof is similar .
suppose @xmath80 and @xmath81 . by lemma [ lem : standard ] , @xmath82 , @xmath83 , and in general , @xmath84 with @xmath85 consequently , for @xmath86 , @xmath87 define @xmath88 , @xmath89 , inductively by @xmath90 so that @xmath91 $ ] , @xmath92 $ ] , then @xmath93 put @xmath94 i.e. , @xmath95^{(-1)^{m-1}}. \label{eq : tilde}\end{aligned}\ ] ] one can prove by induction on @xmath96 that @xmath97 we have @xmath98 hence @xmath99 for an integer @xmath9 , denote @xmath100 it can be written as a polynomial in @xmath101 .
noticing @xmath102 we obtain @xmath103 and when @xmath104 , @xmath105 as pointed out in the second paragraph of this section , these relations are actually valid for arbitrary @xmath67 . for @xmath106 ,
denote @xmath107 by @xmath108 .
[ rmk : regular ] for @xmath109 , call @xmath110 _ regular _ if there exists @xmath111 such that @xmath112 and @xmath113 with @xmath114 .
it is easy to see that @xmath110 is non - regular if and only if @xmath115 and @xmath116 , and under this condition , there exists @xmath111 such that @xmath112 and @xmath117 , where @xmath118 according to ( [ eq : ne])-([eq : se ] ) , the four pairs @xmath119 , @xmath57 , @xmath120 and @xmath121 are simultaneously regular or not .
given a representation @xmath52 , say @xmath52 is _ reducible _ if all the elements in @xmath122 have a common eigenvector ; in particular , say @xmath52 is _ abelian _ if @xmath122 is abelian .
call @xmath52 _ irreducible _ if it is not reducible .
suppose @xmath52 is a representation of @xmath123 .
let @xmath124 denote its restriction to @xmath125 $ ] , let @xmath126 denote the generating pair of @xmath124 , and assume @xmath127 .
up to conjugacy we may assume @xmath128 .
the @xmath129 s have a common value which we denote by @xmath130 , then for each @xmath131 , by ( [ eq : tr - h ] ) , @xmath132 with @xmath133 defined as in ( [ eq : tilde ] ) ; switching @xmath134 with @xmath135 if necessary , we have @xmath136 if @xmath52 is reducible and non - abelian , then @xmath137 is non - regular for at least one of the @xmath131 s , which is , by remark [ rmk : regular ] , equivalent to that the @xmath137 s are all non - regular , hence @xmath138 and @xmath139 with @xmath140 . by ( [ eq : ne ] ) , @xmath141 and @xmath142
are determined by each other ; by ( [ eq : linear ] ) , @xmath143 observing @xmath144 , we have @xmath145 conversely , when @xmath146 satisfy @xmath147 and ( [ eq : reducible ] ) holds , an arbitrary @xmath148 gives rise to @xmath149 and then @xmath150 for all @xmath131 through @xmath151 , ( [ eq : relation ] ) and ( [ eq : ne ] ) .
the @xmath150 s combine to define a non - abelian reducible representation of @xmath17 . if @xmath138 and @xmath137 is regular for each @xmath131 , then @xmath152 and @xmath153 is also regular .
conversely , given @xmath154 and @xmath155 such that @xmath156 and ( @xmath157 for convention ) @xmath158 for each @xmath131 , there is a unique representation @xmath52 of @xmath17 such that @xmath159 actually , @xmath142 is determined by @xmath160 and @xmath161 as in ( [ eq : sw ] ) : @xmath162 on the other hand , one can show that any given @xmath179 can be written as @xmath180 for some @xmath181 , hence any @xmath182 satisfying ( [ eq : x ] ) can be obtained as follows : take @xmath183 arbitrarily , and then take @xmath184 to fulfill ( [ eq : d - e ] ) .
suppose @xmath52 is irreducible and @xmath190 .
write @xmath191 , then for each @xmath131 , @xmath192 by ( [ eq : linear ] ) , @xmath193 observing @xmath194 , we are lead to @xmath195 which is , by ( [ eq : p - q ] ) , equivalent to @xmath196 if @xmath197 , then @xmath198 ( which is equivalent to @xmath199 ) , and @xmath200 we may assume @xmath201 where @xmath202 is the numerator of @xmath203 . if @xmath204 , then @xmath205 can be arbitrary , and @xmath206 should satisfy @xmath207 1 .
if @xmath52 is abelian , then it is determined by a unique tuple @xmath209 with ( [ eq : s - ell ] ) ; 2 . if @xmath52 is reducible but not abelian , then @xmath204 and up to the two choices @xmath210 , @xmath52 is determined by a unique tuple @xmath209 satisfying ( [ eq : s - ell ] ) and ( [ eq : condition ] ) ; 3 . if @xmath52 is irreducible with @xmath211 , then @xmath52 is determined by @xmath205 and a unique tuple @xmath212 such that ( [ eq : s - ell ] ) and ( [ eq : x ] ) are satisfied and @xmath213 for at least one @xmath131 ; 4 .
if @xmath204 and @xmath52 is irreducible with @xmath214 , then @xmath52 is determined by @xmath205 and a unique tuple @xmath215 with ( [ ineq : n ] ) and ( [ eq : final ] ) ; 5 . if @xmath197 and @xmath52 is irreducible with @xmath216 , then @xmath199 and @xmath52 is determined by a unique tuple @xmath215 with ( [ ineq : n ] ) and @xmath217 is not an integral multiple of @xmath203 . | given a link @xmath0 , a representation @xmath1 is _ tracefree _ if the image of each meridian has trace zero .
we determine the conjugacy classes of tracefree representations when @xmath0 is a montesinos link . |
the action of the auxiliary impurity problem that we minize in our calculations is @xmath74 where @xmath75 is the imaginary time , @xmath76 is the annihilation operator for the impurity electrons , @xmath77 and @xmath78 are the orbital and spin indices , and @xmath49 is the impurity hybridization function .
the on site electron - electron coulomb interaction between the d electrons is represented by the slater form : @xmath79 and @xmath80 here , @xmath81 are the radial part of the spherical harmonics , the index @xmath77 denotes @xmath82 , and @xmath83 are the slater integrals .
the explicit form of the frequency dependent hybridization @xmath84 can be written in terms of the projector @xmath85 , the kohn - sham hamiltonian ( without the spin - orbit coupling ) @xmath86 , the spin - orbit coupling hamiltonian @xmath87 , the self - energy @xmath88 , the local green s function @xmath89 and the double counting energy @xmath90
as@xcite @xmath91 the small latin indices @xmath92 enumerate the kohn - sham bands and include the spin as well .
@xmath93 is the crystal momentum .
the form of the spin - orbit coupling hamiltonian is @xmath94 .
forms of different projectors ( @xmath85 ) and double counting ( @xmath90 ) have been previously discussed in , for example , [ ] and [ ] .
@xmath95 , @xmath96 , @xmath86 , and @xmath87 are determined self consistently by extremizing the action ( [ equ : action ] ) , hence @xmath95 and @xmath96 obey the dmft self consistency condition and @xmath86 , and @xmath87 are determined from the self consistent electronic charge .
the impurity model is solved with the continous time quantum monte carlo ( ctqmc ) solver . in order to reduce the sign problem ,
we employ orbital and spin rotations ( @xmath97 ) that cast the hybridizaton @xmath49 in a diagonal form in the relevant low energy limit @xmath98 the hybridization is strongly frequency dependent , however , its eigenvectors do not change much with frequency . in other words , it is possible to obtain an _ almost diagonal hybridization _ by using a _ frequency independent _ rotation @xmath97 .
we ignore the off diagonal @xmath99 and as a result our ctqmc impurity solver suffers very little sign problem , even in the presence of spin - orbit coupling and low crystal symmetry .
unlike sr@xmath7iro@xmath8 , where spin - orbit coupling ( soc ) is necessary for the insulating behaviour , the compounds with the kgf structure that we consider can be mott insulators even in the absence of soc , because they have narrow bands in dft even without soc . in order to verify this point , we performed dft+dmft calculations without soc on rb@xmath7rhf@xmath23 and rb@xmath7irf@xmath23 .
the dos from these calculations , along with the dos with soc for comparison , are presented in figure 1 . as expected from a crystal structure with unconnected polyhedra , both of these compounds are mott insulators with wide charge gaps .
rb@xmath7irf@xmath23 has a smaller gap when soc is not taken into account , but the width of the gap of rb@xmath7rhf@xmath23 does not change much , in line with the small energy scale of the soc in this compound . as a result , we conclude that the soc in the tm - fluorides with the kgf structure is not responsible of the insulating behaviour , but it only changes the character of the insulating state . in the absence of soc , these compounds would be spin-1/2 mott insulators , whereas , due to soc , they become j@xmath34=1/2 mott insulators .
this difference is clear considering the character of the low energy degrees of freedom , and would be visible in magnetic properties , such as the stength of the magnetocrystalline anisotropy or the magnon dispersion .
irf@xmath23 and rb@xmath7rhf@xmath23 with and without spin orbit coupling . ]
in the main text , we generalized the @xmath53 states as @xmath59 + \big[-|e_-\downarrow\rangle+(\alpha - i\alpha^2)|e_-\uparrow\rangle\big ] \big)\ ] ] @xmath60 + \big[|e_-\uparrow\rangle+(\alpha+i\alpha^2)|e_-\downarrow\rangle\big ] \big)\ ] ] where @xmath100 @xmath101 @xmath102 and @xmath58 .
these states are the eigenstates of the soc hamiltonian under a trigonal distortion , which breaks the degeneracy of @xmath103 with @xmath104 .
the ideal j@xmath34=1/2 states @xmath53 are su(2 ) invariant : the ratio of orbital to spin angular momenta is @xmath105 and is independent of direction .
however , the generalized states @xmath106 do not satisfy these conditions .
for example , for @xmath17 being the axis of trigonal distortion , and @xmath107 , one gets @xmath108 . in this respect
, @xmath61 is a natural parameter to quantify the deviation of the system from an ideal j@xmath34=1/2 insulator .
the fact that the magnetic moment is anisotropic , and that the system is not in a heisenberg regime , has important consequences in the magnetic excitation spectrum .
for example , sr@xmath14ir@xmath7o@xmath21 , which has a @xmath64 that is much larger than sr@xmath7iro@xmath8 , has a large ( 92 mev ) magnon gap that is even wider than the magnon bandwidth in this compound.@xcite 4ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.81.195107 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.90.075136 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.111.246402 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.109.157402 [ * * , ( ) ] | discovery of new transition metal compounds with large spin orbit coupling ( soc ) coexisting with strong electron - electron correlation among the @xmath0 electrons is essential for understanding the physics that emerges from the interplay of these two effects . in this study , we predict a novel class of @xmath1 mott insulators in a family of fluoride compounds that are previously synthesized , but not characterized extensively .
first principles calculations in the level of all electron density functional theory + dynamical mean field theory ( dft+dmft ) indicate that these compounds have large mott gaps and some of them exhibit unprecedented proximity to the ideal , @xmath2 symmetric @xmath1 limit .
interest in @xmath3 compounds has been blossoming in the recent years in response to the scientific advances and applications in the areas of topological insulators , multiferroics , and thermoelectrics . at the forefront of this activity
are the ir compounds , because of the interesting interplay between itinerancy , the electronic correlations and strong spin - orbit coupling ( soc).@xcite this strong coupling between the spin and orbital degrees of freedom gives rise to various interesting phases , such as the exotic spin - liquid phase predicted in honeycomb iridates , or the recently observed fermi arcs and the spin - orbit induced mott insulating phase in the perovskite - related ir - oxides.@xcite in these latter systems , the soc splits the six - fold degenerate ir t@xmath4 states into 4 occupied @xmath5 and 2 half - occupied @xmath1 states .
the bands formed by the @xmath1 states are much narrower than the width of the whole @xmath6 manifold in the absence of soc , and as a result , the system can be easily drawn to a mott - insulating phase with even a modest amount of correlations on the 5d ir atom . @xcite
the most widely studied soc induced correlated insulator is sr@xmath7iro@xmath8 , which is an antiferromagnetic insulator below 240 k.@xcite there are numerous studies that involve strain , and pressure on this material ; and various related compounds are also extensively studied.@xcite however , despite being the prototypical system , sr@xmath7iro@xmath8 is far from being the ideal @xmath1 mott insulator : the existence of the insulating state above the neel temperature is due to short range order , which is around 100 lattice constants even 20k above the neel temperature,@xcite hence sr@xmath7iro@xmath8 was termed a _ `
marginal mott insulator'_. this marginal nature of the insulating state was confirmed theoretically , as the first - principles calculations , which neglect short range order , predict bad metallic state in the paramagnetic phase.@xcite also , the crystal structure of sr@xmath7iro@xmath8 is far from cubic : it has the tetragonal spacegroup i4@xmath9/acd . the tetragonal symmetry breaks the degeneracy of the t@xmath4 orbitals , and thus the @xmath1 orbitals mix , moving the system away from the ideal limit where the moments are @xmath2 invariant . since @xmath2 symmetric @xmath1 insulators
are proposed to exhibit superconductivity when doped,@xcite it is important to identify new compounds that are true @xmath1 mott insulators with sizeable gaps . in this study
, we predict a novel class of @xmath1 mott insulator compounds that are both very close to the @xmath2 limit and have large charge gaps in the paramagnetic state .
we achieve this by considering crystal structures that are not commonly studied in the context of correlated electron physics .
we focus on a group of already synthesized iridium and rhodium fluoride compounds and use first - principles calculations at the level of fully charge self - consistent dft+dmft to show the presence of the @xmath1 insulating state in these compounds .
we thus expand the search for new @xmath1 insulators to the family of fluorides , and for the first time show that the @xmath1 state can exist in a rhodium compound .
we begin our search for new @xmath1 insulators by the well known observation that lower bandwidth favours the mott insulating phase . the sr@xmath10v@xmath11o@xmath12 ruddlesden - popper ( rp ) series nicely demonstrates this point:@xcite the @xmath13 srvo@xmath14 is a correlated metal . in this compound , the oxygen octahedra are corner sharing , and the number of nearest neighbour transition metal ions is @xmath15 . with decreasing @xmath16
, @xmath17 decreases monotonically from @xmath15 to @xmath18 for sr@xmath7vo@xmath8 ( @xmath19 ) .
this leads to a decrease of the bandwidth as @xmath16 decreases , and as a result there is a metal - insulator transition as a function of @xmath16 , and sr@xmath7vo@xmath8 is a mott insulator.@xcite the sr@xmath10ir@xmath11o@xmath12 compounds also behave similarly : the perovskite sriro@xmath14 ( @xmath15 ) is a correlated metal , the @xmath20 sr@xmath14ir@xmath7o@xmath21 ( @xmath22 ) is barely an insulator , and the @xmath19 sr@xmath7iro@xmath8 ( @xmath18 ) is the well - known @xmath1 insulator.@xcite a strategy to obtain a small bandwidth and hence a possible @xmath1 mott insulator in an iridate compound is to look for crystal structures where the connectivity of anion octahedra is low .
the extreme case is a structure that consists of isolated iro@xmath23 octahedra that are not corner- , edge- , or face- sharing with any other octahedra .
but , to the best of our knowledge , there exists no structure with isolated mo@xmath23 units in transition metal oxides .
however , isolated hexafluoro- transition metal complexes ( mf@xmath23 ) are known to exist and are very common in fluoride compounds.@xcite the ir ion in many of these compounds have the d@xmath24 electronic configuration , and hence can lead to the @xmath1 mott insulating phase .
gef@xmath23 ( kgf ) crystal structure . ( b ) the mf@xmath23 octahedra are aligned parallel and form triangular layers .
the alkali metals are both above and below these layers , shown by green and red .
( c ) coordination environment of the transition metals in the kgf and ( d ) the @xmath19 rp structure .
chemically inequivalent f ions in the rp structure are shown by blue and red . ] as an example of this group of compounds , we consider the alkali metal hexafluoro - iridates and rhodates with the chemical formula a@xmath7mf@xmath23 and the so called k@xmath7gef@xmath23 ( kgf ) crystal structure@xcite shown in fig .
[ fig : structure ] . here
, a is the alkali metal ion and m is the transition metal ion .
each m ion ( in our case either ir or rh ) is in the center of an f@xmath23 octahedron .
the space group is trigonal p@xmath25m1 .
while there is no symmetry element that imposes the octahedra to be regular , all six m - f bondlengths are equal and the f - m - f angles are close to 90@xmath26 .
the site symmetry of the m ion is @xmath25 m , and the threefold degenerate @xmath6 states are split into 2 + 1 .
however , unlike in the rp compound sr@xmath7iro@xmath8 , all ligands are symmetry equivalent ( fig . [
fig : structure]c - d ) , and as a result an equally distorted octahedron is expected to cause a smaller splitting of the @xmath6 states in the a@xmath7mf@xmath23 compounds than in the rp compounds .
the m ions form regular triangular layers ( fig .
[ fig : structure]b ) .
the octahedra and the local coordinate axes of all m ions are aligned in a parallel fashion .
the out - of - plane lattice constant @xmath27 is smaller than the in - plane lattice constant @xmath28 , and as a result , the band structure is of 3-dimensional character .
the ir and rh cations we consider have 4 + formal valence and 5 electrons in their @xmath6 orbitals in this structure .
since the mf@xmath23 octahedra are isolated in the sense that there are no f ligands that are coordinated to two different m ions , the effective hopping between the m ions is small and hence the @xmath0 bands at the fermi level are expected to be extremely narrow - rendering the system a strong mott insulator .
irf@xmath23 and rb@xmath7rhf@xmath23 within density functional theory , with and without spin - orbit coupling . ] in fig .
[ fig : wiendos ] , we show the densities of states ( dos ) of rb@xmath7irf@xmath23 and rb@xmath7rhf@xmath23 , obtained from density functional theory in the generalized gradient approximation@xcite using the full - potential linear augmented wave formalism as implemented in wien2k@xcite , and using the experimental crystal structures.@xcite when the soc is not taken into account , both compounds have very similar dos ( fig . [
fig : wiendos]a - b ) : there is a narrow ( @xmath29400 mev ) band that consists of the transition metal @xmath6 states , which is partially occupied .
the @xmath6-@xmath30 splitting is @xmath293 ev , and the @xmath30 states are well above the fermi level .
there is no other state than the @xmath6 states around the fermi level for a 4 - 5 ev interval .
the strong spin orbit coupling due to the heavy ir ion in rb@xmath7irf@xmath23 dramatically alters the band structure of this compound ( fig .
[ fig : wiendos]c ) . the partially filled @xmath6 band near the fermi level is split into two bands , a lower lying @xmath5 band with 4 electrons , and a half filled @xmath1 band that crosses the fermi level .
the latter is extremely narrow ( @xmath29100 mev ) but since the mott physics is beyond dft , this theory predicts metallic state .
the rh ion in rb@xmath7rhf@xmath23 , which is above ir in the periodic table , introduces a much weaker soc than ir . as a result , even when soc is taken into account , the @xmath5 states are not energetically separated from the @xmath1 ones . however , it is still possible to identify the two overlapping peaks corresponding to these two groups of states in the dos .
both of these compounds have narrow , half filled @xmath1 bands near the fermi level , indicating that a small amount of on - site correlations can drive them into a mott - insulating state . while this state is beyond dft at the gga level , it is possible to capture the mott insulating phase using dynamical mean field theory ( dmft ) . which contains all feynman diagrams local to the ir ion is added to the kohn - sham hamiltonian .
the self energy is obtained by solving the local impurity problem using continuous time quantum monte carlo@xcite and full charge self - consistency is obtained by repeating dft and dmft steps .
] dft+dmft has been successfully applied to reproduce the properties of various mott insulators and it has been recently used to study the @xmath1 insulating phase in sr@xmath7iro@xmath8.@xcite as a result , it is the natural method of choice to study the possibly mott insulating electronic structure of the hexafluoro - iridates and -rhodates .
we chose the same on - site coulomb repulsion in these compounds as estimated for iridates in ref .
, i.e. , @xmath31ev and @xmath32ev .
we note that these values are the lower bound for more localized fluorides , hence we are possibly underestimating the size of the mott gap . ) and dos of ( a ) rb@xmath7irf@xmath23 , and ( b ) rb@xmath7rhf@xmath23 ( bottom ) . ] in fig .
[ fig : akw_rb ] , we present the result of our dmft calculations : the spectral functions a(k,@xmath33 ) of rb@xmath7irf@xmath23 and rb@xmath7rhf@xmath23 from dft+dmft . both compounds are mott insulators , with wide gaps close to @xmath292 ev . in rb@xmath7irf@xmath23 , the upper and lower hubbard bands are clearly separated and have @xmath1 character , indicating that rb@xmath7irf@xmath23 is a @xmath1 mott insulator . in rb@xmath7rhf@xmath23 ,
the lower hubbard band overlaps with the fully occupied , uncorrelated @xmath5 bands and so can not be clearly seen in the a(k,@xmath33 ) plot .
however , the upper hubbard band has a clear @xmath1 character and therefore this compound is a @xmath1 insulator as well . to the best of our knowledge ,
this is the first report of a @xmath1 insulator in a compound that does not contain iridium .
furthermore , both of these compounds have the largest gaps ever reported for a @xmath1 insulator .
both the large gaps , and the possibility of the @xmath1 state in a rhodate compound are thanks to the non - connectivity of the mf@xmath23 octahedra in the kgf structure , and the resulting very narrow @xmath1 bands . in passing , we note that replacing ir with rh in sr@xmath7iro@xmath8 leads to a metallic phase both because of the much weaker soc@xcite but also possibly because of the slightly larger electronegativity of the rh ion . in the kgf fluorides ,
the charge gap is large , which makes the electronegativity difference negligable , and also the soc is not necessary for the mott insulating phase ( it is essential only for the j@xmath34=1/2 character ) . as a result ,
even the rhodates in this structure are j@xmath34=1/2 mott insulators .
( see the supplamental material . ) encouraged by the success of our strategy to look for @xmath1 mott insulators in this class of coumpounds , we also performed dft+dmft calculations in three other compounds with the same crystal structure , cs@xmath7irf@xmath23 , k@xmath7irf@xmath23 , and k@xmath7rhf@xmath23 . while these compounds have significantly different lattice constants due to the different alkali metals they contain , we find all of them to be @xmath1 insulators with large gaps as well .
all of these compounds were synthesized and their crystal structures were studied before@xcite but there is very little information on their magnetic properties or conductivities .
our predictions call for more experiments to characterize these materials better .
we predict a fluctuating magnetic moment of 1.6 @xmath35 in both rb@xmath7irf@xmath23 and rb@xmath7rhf@xmath23 , which is smaller than the value expected for an ideal spin-1/2 mott insulator ( 1.73 @xmath36 ) because of the charge fluctuations ( there is a @xmath37 probability that there are 6 electrons in the @xmath6 orbitals ) .
these values are @xmath38 larger than what is measured in cs@xmath7irf@xmath23 in ref . , but @xmath39 smaller than the value measured in the rh compounds in ref . at room temperature .
the ideal @xmath1 state is @xmath2 invariant , and so it has no magnetic anisotropy .
however , systems such as sr@xmath7iro@xmath8 are observed not to be exactly at this limit due to deviations of the wave function from the ideal @xmath1.@xcite the reason is that sr@xmath7iro@xmath8 lacks cubic symmetry : it has the space group i4@xmath9/acd , which is tetragonal , and hence the three @xmath6 orbitals of the ir ion are split into a degenerate doublet and a singlet .
the deviation from ideal @xmath1 state is small but not negligible , and it depends strongly on biaxial strain and pressure.@xcite in the kgf structure , the space group is trigonal , and the @xmath6 irreducible representation is split into two , a singlet @xmath40 and a doublet @xmath41 , similar to sr@xmath7iro@xmath8 .
this also introduces a deviation from the @xmath1 state and a resultant magnetic anisotropy . in order to see how much the wavefunction is different from the ideal @xmath1 state
, we study the hybridization function @xmath42 used in the dmft calculation.@xcite it is given by @xmath43 where @xmath44 is the dmft self energy , @xmath45 are the dft kohn - sham eigenvalues , and @xmath46 and @xmath47 are the projector and the embedder on the transition metal site . in the high frequency limit @xmath48 , the eigenvalues of the @xmath49 matrix give the atomic energy levels ( including both the crystal field and the spin - orbit coupling ) and it is related to the single ion anisotropy . in the @xmath50 limit , it is related to the low energy electronic excitations .
the two eigenvectors of @xmath49 with the largest eigenvalues are the @xmath1-like states @xmath51 and @xmath52 .
the inner products of these with the ideal @xmath1 states @xmath53 can be used as a measure of how close the system to the @xmath2 limit is . however , this product is second order in the mixing , and a better measure is the coefficients in the expansions of @xmath54 .
this measure is used in ref . [ ] to study the effect of tetragonal symmetry breaking in sr@xmath7iro@xmath8 . under a trigonal perturbation ,
the @xmath6 orbitals are split into a singlet and a doublet as@xcite @xmath55 , @xmath56 , and @xmath57 , where @xmath58 .
a generalization of the @xmath1 states that takes into account this splitting is @xmath59 + \big[-|e_-\downarrow\rangle+(\alpha - i\alpha^2)|e_-\uparrow\rangle\big ] \big)\ ] ] @xmath60 + \big[|e_-\uparrow\rangle+(\alpha+i\alpha^2)|e_-\downarrow\rangle\big ] \big)\ ] ] here , @xmath61 quantifies the deviation from the ideal limit , and @xmath62 gives @xmath63 .
a large @xmath64 indicates strong deviation from the heisenberg regime , and leads to large magnon gaps , even larger than the spin wave bandwidth in sr@xmath14ir@xmath7o@xmath21.@xcite since hybridization is frequency dependent , so is @xmath61 . in rb@xmath7irf@xmath23 , the low frequency @xmath65 and the high frequency @xmath66 .
compared to sr@xmath7iro@xmath8,@xcite which has @xmath67 and @xmath68 ; the electronic state in rb@xmath7irf@xmath23 is much more isotropic , and closer to the ideal @xmath2 limit .
the rhodate compound rb@xmath7rhf@xmath23 , which has weaker soc , shows a more significant deviation from the ideal limit : it has @xmath69 and @xmath70 .
this very isotropic behaviour despite the noncubic spacegroup of rb@xmath7irf@xmath23 can be better understood considering the local coordination geometry of the transition metal ion .
the site symmetry of ir is @xmath71 .
the elements of the point group include various rotations , such as a threefold rotation around [ 001 ] and a twofold rotation around [ 100 ] ( fig .
[ fig : structure]c ) . as a result , all six f - ligands around a m ion are symmetry equivalent : they are chemically identical , and their f - m bond lengths are the same .
the deviation from the ideal cubic symmetry on the m site is only due to the presence of further neighbours that reduce the symmetry , and the deviation of the f - octahedra from a regular octahedron .
this latter effect is quite small ( the largest f - m - f bond angle variance in the compounds we consider is less than 6 degrees ) , and as a result , the ir ion is in an almost cubic environment . in the rp family of iridate compounds , the site symmetry of the ir ion
can be as high as @xmath72 .
however , despite a 4-fold rotation and various 2-fold rotation axes that pass through the ir ion ( fig .
[ fig : structure]d ) , there is no 3-fold rotation in the point group , and there are two _ chemically _ distinct ligands around each ir ion .
the apical oxygens , shown by red in fig .
[ fig : structure]d , are bonded to only one ir ion , whereas the other oxygens are bonded to two ir each .
this necessarily results in very a noncubic _ local _ environment of the ir ion , which leads to deviations from the ideal @xmath1 state even when the ir - o bondlengths are artificially set to be equal . in conclusion
, we identified a new class of @xmath1 mott insulators , which includes the first two examples of such compounds without iridium .
these materials are wide gap mott insulators , with no visible tendency towards magnetic ordering , and some of them are also closer to the isotropic @xmath2 limit than the well studied sr@xmath7iro@xmath8 .
this work extends the search for new materials which display an interplay of correlations with spin - orbit coupling to flouride compounds .
we posit that the @xmath1 mott insulating phase is very common in transition metal fluorides with isolated ir@xmath73f@xmath23 and rh@xmath73f@xmath23 complexes .
studying other structure types that satisfy this property would lead not only to the discovery of new @xmath1 mott insulators but also many other strongly correlated complex fluorides with interesting physical properties .
_ note : _ while this manuscript was under review , we became aware of a study on rucl@xmath14 which also reports a relativistic mott insulating phase in a 4d transition metal halide.@xcite we acknowledge fruitful discussions with n.a .
benedek and o. erten .
t. b. was supported by the rutgers center for materials theory , and k. h. was supported by nsf dmr-1405303 and nsf dmref-1233349 .
41ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1146/annurev - conmatphys-020911 - 125138 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.83.205101 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.101.226402 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1126/science.1251151 [ ( ) , 10.1126/science.1251151 ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.111.246402 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.105.216407 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.87.075112 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.101.076402 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.112.016405 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.109.027204 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.85.035101 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.107.266404 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.108.247212 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.108.086403 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.106.136402 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.43.181 [ * * , ( ) ] http://books.google.com.tr/books?id=ur77aaaaqbaj[__ ] , oxford classic texts in the physical sciences ( , ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.86.125105 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.81.195107 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.82.085111 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.109.157402 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.90.041112 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.75.155113 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.83.349 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.90.075136 [ * * , ( ) ] * supplemental information for + the @xmath1 mott insulating state in rh and ir fluorides " * |
eduard helly proved his classical theorem concerning convex subsets of euclidean spaces .
namely , suppose that @xmath4 is a collection of convex subsets of @xmath5 ( where @xmath6 ) such that the intersection of every @xmath7 of these sets in nonempty .
then the whole family has a nonempty intersection .
this result gave rise to the concept of helly dimension .
for a geodesic metric space @xmath8 we define its _ helly dimension _
@xmath9 to be the smallest natural number such that any finite family of @xmath10-wise non - disjoint convex subsets of @xmath8 has a non - empty intersection .
clearly , helly s theorem states that helly dimension of the euclidean space @xmath5 is @xmath11 .
it is very easy to find examples showing that it is exactly equal to @xmath12 .
mikhail gromov in @xcite gave a purely combinatorial characterization of @xmath13 cube complexes as simply connected cube complexes in which the links of vertices are simplicial flag complexes .
there is a well known result for @xmath13 cube complexes which states that , regardless their topological dimension , they all have helly dimension equal to one ( see @xcite ) .
note that in this case we additionally demand that convex subsets from the definition are convex subcomplexes .
systolic complexes were introduced by tadeusz januszkiewicz and jacek witkowski in @xcite and independently by frederic haglund in @xcite .
they are connected , simply connected simplicial complexes satisfying some additional local combinatorial condition ( see definition [ sysdef ] ) , which is a simplicial analogue of nonpositive curvature .
systolic complexes inherit lots of @xmath13-like properties , however being systolic neither implies , nor is implied by nonpositive curvature of the complex equipped with the standard piecewise euclidean metric .
one would expect for systolic complexes a similar kind of helly - like properties as for @xmath13 cube complexes .
however , let us consider an example of a single @xmath14-dimensional simplex with its codimension @xmath1 faces being a family of convex subcomplexes .
then the intersection of any subfamily of the cardinality @xmath14 is non - empty , but the intersection of the entire family is empty .
this example motivates the following modification of definition of helly dimension for systolic complexes .
namely , we say that a systolic complex @xmath8 has helly dimension @xmath15 if for every @xmath16-wise family of non - disjoint convex subcomplexes there is a single simplex which has a nonempty intersection with all these subcomplexes .
in this paper we prove that helly dimension of a systolic complex does not depend on its topological dimension .
we obtained the following results : ( see theorem [ tw7 ] in this text ) let @xmath8 be a @xmath0-systolic complex and let @xmath17 be pairwise intersecting convex subcomplexes .
then there exists a simplex @xmath18 such that @xmath19 for @xmath20 .
moreover , @xmath21 can be chosen to have the dimension at most two .
in other words @xmath0-systolic complexes have helly dimension less or equal to @xmath1 .
it is easy to see that this is not necessarily true for @xmath2-systolic complexes ( see figure [ greater ] ) , but we prove that any systolic complex has helly dimension less or equal to @xmath3 .
more precisely : .,scaledwidth=25.0% ] ( see theorem [ tw6 ] in this text ) let @xmath8 be a systolic complex and let @xmath22 be its convex subcomplexes such that every three of them have a nonempty intersection .
then there exists a simplex @xmath18 such that @xmath19 for @xmath23 .
moreover , @xmath21 can be chosen to have the dimension at most three . * acknowledgements*. i am grateful to my advisor pawe zawilak for his constant support , patience and many interesting discussions . without his help neither this thesis would happen , nor i would be in the place that i am today .
i also want to thank jacek witkowski for suggesting the topic of this thesis and many useful corrections and hints how to improve this paper .
in this section we recall basic definitions and some results concerning systolic complexes . a _ simplicial complex _ @xmath8 is a set of simplices that satisfy the following conditions .
any face of a simplex in @xmath8 is also in @xmath8 .
the intersection of two simplices of @xmath8 is a face of both of them .
a simplicial complex @xmath8 is _ flag _ if any finite set of vertices in @xmath8 that are pairwise connected by edges spans a simplex of @xmath8 . for any collection @xmath24 of simplices in a simplicial complex @xmath8
we define the following .
the _ closure _ of @xmath24 , denoted by @xmath25 , is the minimal subcomplex of @xmath8 that contains every simplex of @xmath24 .
the _ star _ of @xmath24 , denoted by @xmath26 , is the set of all simplices in @xmath8 that contain some face of a simplex of @xmath24 .
the _ link _ of @xmath24 , denoted by @xmath27 , equals @xmath28 .
a _ cycle _ in @xmath8 is a subcomplex @xmath29 isomorphic to some triangulation of @xmath30 .
we define the _ length _ @xmath31 of @xmath29 to be the number of its edges .
a _ diagonal _ of a cycle is an edge connecting its two nonconsecutive vertices .
[ sysdef](see definition @xmath32 in @xcite ) given a natural number @xmath33 a simplicial complex @xmath8 is called : * _ @xmath34-large _ if it is flag and every cycle in @xmath8 of length @xmath35 has a diagonal , * _ locally @xmath34-large _ if links of all simplices in @xmath8 are @xmath34-large , * _ @xmath34-systolic _ if it is connected , simply connected and locally @xmath34-large .
one often calls locally @xmath2-largeness a simplicial nonpositive curvature and it is common to abbreviate @xmath2-systolic to systolic .
as we already mentioned , systolic complexes inherit lots of @xmath13-like properties .
for example : they are contractible ( @xcite ) , the analogue of the flat torus theorem holds for them ( @xcite ) and every finite group acting geometrically on a systolic complex by simplicial automorphisms has a global fix point ( @xcite ) . moreover , @xmath0-systolic complexes are @xmath36-hyperbolic ( @xcite ) . recall that a _ geodesic metric space _ is a metric space in which every two points can be connected by an isometrically embedded segment called _
geodesic_. clearly , the @xmath1-skeleton of a systolic complex equipped with the standard combinatorial metric ( i.e. all edges have length @xmath1 ) is a geodesic metric space .
it is important to clarify that we consider only geodesics contained in @xmath1-skeleton , with both endpoints in the @xmath37-skeleton of a complex .
thus we can identify a combinatorial geodesic with a sequence of vertices contained in it .
we denote by @xmath38 a geodesic starting at @xmath39 , passing through vertices @xmath40 and terminating at @xmath41 .
we also denote by @xmath42 a geodesic from @xmath43 to @xmath44 .
a subcomplex @xmath45 of a simplicial complex @xmath8 is _ geodesically convex _ if for any two vertices @xmath46 , @xmath45 contains every shortest path in @xmath1-skeleton of @xmath8 between @xmath47 and @xmath48 .
a subcomplex @xmath45 of a simplicial complex @xmath8 is called _
@xmath49-convex _ if it is full and any combinatorial geodesic @xmath29 of length @xmath3 with both endpoints in @xmath45 is entirely contained in @xmath45 .
a subcomplex @xmath45 of a systolic complex @xmath8 is _ convex _ if it is connected and _ locally @xmath49-convex _ , i.e. for every every simplex @xmath50 , @xmath51 is @xmath49-convex in @xmath52 .
it turns out that a subcomplex of systolic complex is convex iff it is geodesically convex ( see proposition @xmath53 in @xcite ) .
we now recall an important tool often used in the study of systolic complexes .
we start with some definitions .
let @xmath54 be a triangulation of a 2-dimensional manifold .
let @xmath43 be a vertex of @xmath54 and let @xmath55 be a number of triangles containing @xmath43 .
defect _ of vertex @xmath43 ( denoted by @xmath56 ) is equal to @xmath57 for the interior vertices and to @xmath58 for the boundary vertices .
a vertex @xmath43 is called _ negative _ ( respectively _ positive _ ) if @xmath59 ( respectively @xmath60 ) .
( combinatorial gauss - bonnet)[gb ] let @xmath54 be a triangulation of a 2-dimensional manifold . then
: @xmath61 where @xmath62 denotes the euler characteristic of @xmath54 .
let now @xmath8 be a systolic complex .
any simplicial map @xmath63 , where @xmath64 is a triangulation of a @xmath3-disc , will be called a _
surface_. we say that a surface @xmath24 is _ spanned _ by a cycle @xmath29 if it maps @xmath65 isomorphically onto @xmath29 . by an _ area _ of a simplicial disc we mean the number of its triangles .
similarly , an _ area _ of a surface @xmath24 is the number of triangles of @xmath64 on which @xmath24 is injective .
if @xmath64 has the minimal area among surfaces extending map @xmath66 we call both the surface and the map associated to it _
minimal_. we say that a _ surface @xmath24 is systolic _ if @xmath64 is systolic .
the existence of minimal surfaces is given by the next lemma .
note that the original proof of lemma @xmath67 in @xcite deals only with the systolic case .
however , the same reasoning applies for the @xmath34-systolic case .
( see lemma @xmath67 in @xcite)[4.2 ] let @xmath8 be a @xmath34-systolic complex and let @xmath30 be a triangulated circle .
then any simplicial map @xmath68 can be extended to a simplicial map @xmath69 , where @xmath70 is a @xmath34-systolic disc such that @xmath71 .
moreover , any minimal surface extending @xmath72 is @xmath34-systolic . a surface @xmath63 is called _ flat _
if @xmath64 is _ flat disc _
, i.e. @xmath73 can be isometrically embedded into @xmath1-skeleton of the equilaterally triangulated euclidean plane @xmath74 .
we have the following easy characterization of flatness : ( see theorem @xmath75 in @xcite)[flatkus ] a simplicial disc @xmath70 is flat if and only if it satisfies the following three conditions : 1 .
every internal vertex of @xmath70 has defect @xmath37 , 2 .
@xmath70 has no boundary vertices of defect less than @xmath76 , 3 . on @xmath77 any two negative vertices are separated by a positive one .
we now focus on geodesic triangles in systolic complexes .
first , we recall the following : ( see lemma @xmath78 in @xcite)[4.3 ] if @xmath79 are vertices of a systolic complex @xmath8 , then for @xmath80 there exist geodesics @xmath81 with endpoints @xmath82 and @xmath83 ( we use the cyclic order of indices ) such that : 1 .
@xmath84 is a geodesic ( possibly degenerated ) with endpoints @xmath82 and @xmath85 2 .
if we denote the subgeodesic ( possibly degenerated ) with endpoints @xmath85 and @xmath86 by @xmath87 , then either @xmath88 or a minimal surface @xmath89 spanning the cycle @xmath90 has an equilaterally triangulated equilateral triangle as the domain .
before we move forward , we introduce some terminology .
let @xmath91 be cyclically ordered different points on a circle .
disc with @xmath14 horns _ is a quotient space @xmath92 } /_\sim$ ] where @xmath93 is an equivalence relation given by @xmath94 .
points @xmath95_\sim$ ] are called _ bottoms _ of the horn and points @xmath96_\sim$ ] are called _ tops _ of the horn . for every @xmath97 there is a distinguished segment from @xmath98 to @xmath83 , namely @xmath99=[x_i , x'_i ] \cup [ x'_i , x'_{i+1 } ] \cup [ x'_{i+1},x_{i+1}]$ ] , where @xmath100 $ ] is an arc in @xmath30 connecting bottoms @xmath101 and @xmath86 . as a corollary of lemma [ 4.3 ]
we have the following : [ generalus ] suppose that @xmath102 are three distinct vertices in a systolic complex @xmath8 . then there exist a simplicial map @xmath103 satisfying one of the following conditions : 1 .
@xmath104 is a segment and @xmath105 is an isometry ( this holds iff one of the points @xmath102 lies on some geodesic connecting other two of them ) .
2 . @xmath104 is a tripod and @xmath105 is an isometry ( this holds iff there exist geodesics @xmath106 connecting @xmath102 such that @xmath107 ) 3 .
@xmath104 is a equilaterally triangulated equilateral disc with @xmath108 horns and @xmath105 maps the segment @xmath99 $ ] isometrically onto some geodesic @xmath109 $ ] .
a map @xmath105 is called _ triangular surface _ spanned on vertices
it is called minimal if @xmath1 or @xmath3 holds , or in the case @xmath49 if @xmath104 has minimal area among domains of triangular surfaces spanned on @xmath110 .
a geodesic triangle between @xmath102 is called a _ minimal geodesic triangle _ if boundary of a minimal surface is mapped onto it .
systolic complexes are contractible .
therefore if @xmath8 is systolic then every map @xmath111 can be extended to a map @xmath112 .
similarly as for circles , @xmath3-dimensional spheres have fillings with special properties .
precisely , we have the following result : ( see theorem @xmath113 in @xcite)[4.4 ] let @xmath8 be a systolic complex and let @xmath24 be a triangulation of a @xmath3-sphere . then any simplicial map @xmath114 can be extended to a simplicial map @xmath115 , where @xmath116 is a triangulation of a 3-ball such that @xmath117 and @xmath116 has no internal vertices .
we start with the proof of a useful lemma in slightly more general setting : [ wlozenie ] let @xmath17 be three pairwise intersecting geodesically convex subcomplexes in a connected simplicial complex @xmath8 . then we can pick a triple of points @xmath118 such that @xmath119 , @xmath120 , @xmath121 and geodesics @xmath122 , @xmath123 , @xmath124 between them in such a way that either a geodesic triangle @xmath125 is isomorphic to a triangulation of @xmath30 or @xmath107 .
let @xmath119 , @xmath120 and @xmath121 .
since @xmath17 are convex , it follows that there are geodesics @xmath122 , @xmath123 , @xmath124 connecting @xmath45 with @xmath116 , @xmath116 with @xmath126 and @xmath126 with @xmath45 respectively .
if either all of these geodesics have a nonempty intersection or they only intersect at endpoints , lemma [ wlozenie ] is proved .
that @xmath127.,scaledwidth=44.1% ] suppose now that @xmath128 and that some pair of these geodesics , say @xmath129 and @xmath130 , have a nonempty intersection besides endpoints .
let @xmath131 be a vertex in this intersection .
since @xmath132 we can replace point @xmath126 by the point @xmath131 and obtain a new triple of points @xmath133 with the same properties ( see figure [ 7sys1 ] as an illustration ) .
we repeat this procedure until @xmath134 have no intersection except for the endpoints , hence until @xmath125 is isomorphic to some triangulation of @xmath30 .
now we can formulate and prove helly s theorem for @xmath0-systolic complexes : [ tw7 ] let @xmath8 be a @xmath0-systolic complex and let @xmath17 be pairwise intersecting convex subcomplexes . then there exists a simplex @xmath18 such that @xmath19 for @xmath20 .
moreover , @xmath21 can be chosen to have the dimension at most two . due to lemma [ wlozenie ]
we can choose a triple of points @xmath119 , @xmath120 , @xmath121 and geodesics @xmath135 , @xmath129 and @xmath130 , between them such that @xmath107 or @xmath125 is a cycle .
in the first case the theorem is proved .
otherwise we choose these geodesics in such a way that @xmath134 is a minimal geodesic triangle .
we know by lemma [ 4.2 ] that a minimal surface @xmath24 spanned by this cycle is @xmath0-systolic and since @xmath136 by lemma [ gb ] we have : @xmath137 since @xmath64 is @xmath0-systolic , the link of its every interior vertex is a cycle of length at least 7 and hence @xmath138 for every vertex @xmath139 .
the preimages @xmath140 by @xmath24 of @xmath141 and @xmath126 respectively belong to minimum one triangle , so the total contribution to the left hand side of the above equation from those points is at most @xmath2 .
consider now a geodesic @xmath142 , where @xmath143 denotes its length , @xmath144 , @xmath145 and set @xmath146 .
we will show that @xmath147 for @xmath148 , i.e. that every such vertex must be contained in at least three triangles .
indeed , if @xmath149 belongs to one triangle , there is an edge connecting @xmath150 and @xmath151 and the same holds for @xmath152 and @xmath153 .
this contradicts the fact that @xmath81 is a geodesic ( see figure [ 7sys2 ] ) .
similarly , if @xmath149 belongs to two triangles , let @xmath154 be their common vertex different from @xmath149 .
set @xmath155 and note that there is another geodesic @xmath156 connecting @xmath45 to @xmath116 ( see figure [ 7sys2 ] ) . note also that the geodesic triangle ( @xmath157 ) has a filling with smaller area than ( @xmath106 ) ( a restriction of the map @xmath24 to the disc @xmath64 with simplices @xmath158 and @xmath159 ) removed .
this contradicts the fact that ( @xmath106 ) has a minimal area .
we repeat the same reasoning for geodesics @xmath160 . must be contained in at least three triangles.,scaledwidth=92.5% ] we conclude that if @xmath64 is a domain of a minimal surface spanned by a minimal geodesic triangle , in order to satisfy gauss - bonnet lemma , it can not contain any interior vertex .
vertices @xmath161 have defect @xmath3 and the rest of boundary vertices have defect @xmath37 .
therefore due to lemma [ flatkus ] @xmath64 is flat .
it follows that @xmath64 is a single @xmath3-simplex and its image under @xmath24 satisfies demanded properties .
let @xmath118 be three distinguished points in a @xmath0-systolic complex @xmath8 .
then a minimal geodesic triangle between them consists of three geodesic segments and a @xmath1-skeleton of the one ( possibly degenerated ) @xmath3-simplex ( see figure [ 7sys3 ] ) .
-systolic complex.,scaledwidth=30.0% ]
we start with proving some useful lemmas and introducing some terminology .
[ digon ] let @xmath162 be two distinct points in a systolic complex @xmath8 and let @xmath163 and @xmath135 be two geodesics between them .
if these geodesics intersect only at endpoints , then a minimal surface spanned by @xmath164 is flat .
first let us consider the boundary vertices different from @xmath165 and @xmath166 . since they lay on a geodesic , any two such positive vertices are separated by a negative vertex ( see the proof of theorem @xmath167 in @xcite ) .
thus the total defect on each geodesic @xmath163 and @xmath135 , excluding endpoints , is less or equal to @xmath1 . by gauss - bonnet lemma
we have : since @xmath64 is systolic , the defect of every interior vertex is nonpositive . and
since @xmath163 and @xmath135 meet only at endpoints , vertices @xmath165 and @xmath166 have defect non greater then @xmath3 . in order to satisfy gauss - bonnet lemma
we see that every interior vertex has to have defect @xmath37 and on geodesics we have alternating vertices with defect @xmath1 and @xmath76 , possibly separated by vertices with defect @xmath37 .
therefore assumptions of lemma [ flatkus ] are satisfied and @xmath64 is flat . let @xmath162 be two distinct points in a systolic complex @xmath8 and let @xmath163 and @xmath135 be two geodesics connecting them .
then there exist a simplicial map @xmath169 satisfying one of the following conditions : 1 .
@xmath170 is a segment and @xmath171 is an isometry ( this holds iff @xmath172 ) , 2 .
@xmath171 is a simple digon , 3 .
there is a sequence @xmath173 s.t .
@xmath174 , @xmath175 , @xmath176 and @xmath177 has a form as in @xmath1 or @xmath3 .
[ conv ] let @xmath178 ( @xmath171 ) be a minimal triangular ( digonal ) surface spanned on vertices @xmath179 ( by @xmath163 , @xmath135 ) , which are contained in a convex subcomplex @xmath45 of a systolic complex @xmath8 .
then the image of the whole surface is contained in @xmath45 .
first consider @xmath63 being a simple digon spanned by geodesics @xmath180 , which connect @xmath162 .
since @xmath181 and @xmath45 is convex it follows that also @xmath182 .
we use the induction over the area of @xmath64 .
the statement is true for two points in distance @xmath1 or @xmath3 .
we proceed with the induction step . from the proof of lemma [ digon ] it follows that at least one of the vertices on each geodesic part of @xmath65 has defect @xmath1 ( see figure [ 6sysflat ] ) .
denote this vertex @xmath183 and let @xmath152 and @xmath153 be its neighbours on this geodesic .
let @xmath44 be a second common vertex of two triangles containing @xmath183 .
note that as @xmath184 and @xmath185 lie on a geodesic @xmath186 and thus @xmath187 is a geodesic .
we can replace a geodesic from @xmath47 to @xmath48 passing through @xmath183 by the one passing through @xmath44 .
if @xmath44 does not belong to the other geodesic of @xmath65 we obtain a simple digon with smaller area and we can use the inductive assumption . if @xmath44 belongs to the other geodesic of @xmath65 we consider two simple digons : one between @xmath47 and @xmath44 , second between @xmath44 and @xmath48 .
they both have smaller area than original digon hence we can use the inductive assumption to conclude the statement in this case . now consider @xmath63 being a triangular surface spanned on @xmath179 .
we use the induction over the length of a side of an equilateral triangle in @xmath64 .
the statement is obvious for an equilateral triangle with side of length @xmath1 .
we proceed with the induction step .
choose one side of the equilateral triangle in a @xmath64 and denote its vertices by @xmath188 .
pick a maximal geodesic @xmath189 in @xmath64 consisting of vertices in distance @xmath1 from the side @xmath190 ( see figure [ 6katwyp ] ) .
notice that @xmath191 and @xmath192 for @xmath193 belong to @xmath45 .
consider the image by @xmath24 of the path @xmath194 .
by theorem b in @xcite applied to @xmath64 with removed @xmath3-simplices containing preimages by @xmath24 of vertices @xmath179 the restriction of @xmath24 to any simplicial disc contained in it with a diameter less or equal to three is an isometric embedding .
hence the path @xmath195 is a geodesic in @xmath8 . from convexity of @xmath45
it follows that also @xmath196 belongs to @xmath45 . repeating this argument
we deduce that the image by @xmath24 of the entire geodesic @xmath189 is contained in @xmath45 .
it allows us to replace @xmath64 with a smaller equilateral triangle and obtain the statement from the inductive assumption . 1 .
a map @xmath198 , where @xmath24 is a triangulation of the @xmath3-sphere , 2 . an inclusion @xmath199 of a domain of a minimal triangular surface for any triple of different points @xmath200 , 3
. an inclusion @xmath201 of a domain of some specified digonal surface for every pair of different points @xmath202 .
consider any tree of these points , say @xmath141 and @xmath126 .
due to corollary [ generalus ] there is a minimal triangular surface @xmath206 spanned on these points .
denote by @xmath207 the geodesic between @xmath45 and @xmath116 from the minimal geodesic triangle associated to @xmath208 .
similarly set @xmath209 and @xmath210 .
similar minimal triangular surfaces and minimal geodesic triangles exist for every triple of points @xmath197 .
denote by @xmath211 the last common vertex of @xmath207 and @xmath209 , and similarly set @xmath212 and @xmath213 .
we use the similar notation for other triples .
the general situation is presented in figure [ 6sysgen ] , however some vertices can be identified .
for example , geodesics @xmath214 can have more common vertices than endpoints ( the same is true for any other pair of geodesics connecting the same pair of points ) , or geodesic segments @xmath215 and triangles @xmath216 can be degenerated .
all possible cases will be discussed later .
note that each point @xmath197 is contained in three convex sets ( from the assumption ) , every geodesic in two convex sets ( from the convexity ) and every triangular surface in one convex set ( from lemma [ conv ] ) . note that for two vertices @xmath141 there exist two ( not necessary equal ) geodesics @xmath207 and @xmath217 connecting them .
this defines the desired digonal surface @xmath218 . for simplicity
we denote this digonal surface by @xmath219 .
we now modify the map @xmath220 to obtain a simplicial map , which has a triangulated disc as a domain .
we do this similarly to the case presented in figure [ didisc ] and denote this map by @xmath221 .
we repeat this construction for every pair of points .
let @xmath222 be a disjoint union of @xmath223 and @xmath224 and let @xmath225 be defined as a respective digonal or triangular surface on each part of @xmath222 .
define @xmath24 to be a quotient space @xmath226 , where @xmath93 is an equivalence relation identifying two boundary points of @xmath223 and @xmath224 if they have the same image through @xmath227 .
we define @xmath205 to be a quotient of @xmath227 .
it follows from the construction that @xmath205 and @xmath24 satisfy demanded properties .
[ tw6 ] let @xmath8 be a systolic complex and let @xmath22 be its convex subcomplexes such that every three of them have a nonempty intersection .
then there exists a simplex @xmath18 such that @xmath19 for @xmath23 .
moreover , @xmath21 can be chosen to have the dimension at most three . from the assumption there
exist four points @xmath118 and @xmath228 such that @xmath229 , @xmath230 , @xmath231 , @xmath232 .
we choose these points in such a way that the sum of distances between them is minimal .
first note that if any of these points lies on some geodesic connecting two other , then it is contained in all convex subcomplexes @xmath22 and therefore satisfies desired properties .
thus we can assume the opposite .
now we examine a neighbourhood of the vertex @xmath228 .
set the notation as in the proof of lemma [ spherus ] .
suppose first that some of geodesic segments @xmath233 , @xmath234 or @xmath235 is nondegenerate and let @xmath236 be a vertex from the link of @xmath228 lying on this segment .
without loss of generality we can assume that @xmath237 .
since @xmath238 , it holds that @xmath239 .
note that @xmath240 , @xmath241 and @xmath242 . thus concerning
@xmath228 replaced with @xmath236 , we obtain another four points with the same properties as @xmath243 and @xmath228 , but with the smaller sum of distances between them .
this contradicts the minimality of this sum for @xmath197 .
therefore we can assume that all geodesic segments @xmath233 , @xmath234 and @xmath235 are degenerated , i.e @xmath244 . note that @xmath228 can not be equal to any of points @xmath245 ( since it does not lay on any geodesic connecting @xmath45 to @xmath116 , @xmath45 to @xmath126 or @xmath116 to @xmath126 ) .
denote by @xmath246 the point closest to @xmath228 on the geodesic @xmath247 .
similarly denote set @xmath248 , @xmath249 , @xmath250 , @xmath251 and @xmath252 . since @xmath253 , @xmath254 and @xmath255 span @xmath3-simplex in @xmath256 and @xmath257 is a simplicial map it follows that @xmath248 and @xmath246 are also connected if only @xmath258 .
same is true for pairs @xmath249 , @xmath250 and @xmath251 , @xmath252 .
similarly @xmath259 , @xmath260 and @xmath261 span @xmath3-simplex in @xmath262 and so @xmath248 and @xmath249 are connected by the fact that @xmath263 is a simplicial map and under the assumption that @xmath264 .
same is true for pairs @xmath246 , @xmath252 and @xmath250 , @xmath265 . if there are no identifications we end up in the situation presented on the figure [ 6kat ] .
we examine now possible identifications between these points .
note that @xmath266 ( otherwise the geodesic segment @xmath267 would nt be degenerated ) and similarly @xmath264 and @xmath268 .
if @xmath246 would be identified with any of these vertices , excluding @xmath248 or @xmath252 , it would imply that @xmath269 .
but then again replacing @xmath228 with @xmath246 , we obtain another four points with the same properties as @xmath197 and smaller sum of distances between them , which violates our assumption .
thus the only identifications left to concern are : @xmath246 with @xmath248 , @xmath249 with @xmath250 and @xmath252 with @xmath251 .
[ link ] if vertices @xmath248 , @xmath249 are both connected with another vertex @xmath270 , then there exists a pairwise connected triple of points @xmath271 in the link of @xmath228 , such that @xmath272 , @xmath273 and @xmath274 .
it is enough to show that there exist a pairwise connected triple of points @xmath275 @xmath276 and @xmath277 . if @xmath278 the statement is trivially true
otherwise we need to consider separately cases with the different numbers of identifications between vertices @xmath279 . 1 . no identifications .
if @xmath280 then @xmath281 form a pentagon .
note that every pentagon in a systolic complex , contains a vertex @xmath12 which is connected by edges with its two opposite vertices .
then @xmath282 , @xmath283 , @xmath284 ( if @xmath285 or @xmath286 ) or @xmath282 , @xmath287 , @xmath288 ( if @xmath289 ) or @xmath282 , @xmath283 , @xmath288 ( if @xmath290 ) or @xmath282 , @xmath287 , @xmath284 ( if @xmath291 ) .
see figure [ 6kata ] for an illustration .
case when @xmath292 is symmetric to the one described above .
+ . on the left @xmath293 . on the right @xmath294.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] 2 .
one identification .
assume that @xmath295 , then @xmath296 form a pentagon .
again we use the fact that every pentagon in a systolic complex , contains a vertex @xmath12 which is connected by edges with its two opposite vertices .
then @xmath282 , @xmath287 ( if @xmath289 or @xmath291 ) or @xmath297 , @xmath287 ( if @xmath298 ) or @xmath282 , @xmath283 ( if @xmath285 ) or @xmath297 , @xmath283 ( if @xmath299 ) cases when @xmath300 or @xmath301 are symmetric to the one described above .
3 . two identifications .
assume @xmath300 and @xmath301 .
then @xmath302 form a quadrilateral , which contains a diagonal from the fact that @xmath8 is systolic .
if @xmath303 form a diagonal then @xmath304 and similarly if @xmath305 form a diagonal then @xmath306 .
cases when @xmath307 or @xmath308 are symmetric and allow the same reasoning .
4 . three identifications . then @xmath300 , @xmath301 , @xmath295 and the statement of the claim is trivially satisfied .
now we are ready to give a crucial argument in this reasoning .
due to lemma [ spherus ] vertices @xmath197 determinate a simplicial map @xmath198 , where @xmath24 is a triangulation of the @xmath3-sphere . from lemma
[ 4.4 ] we know that this map can be extended to a simplicial map @xmath69 , where @xmath70 is a triangulation of a @xmath49-ball such that @xmath309 and @xmath70 has no internal vertices . set @xmath310 and similarly set @xmath311 .
also let @xmath312 and similarly set @xmath313 , @xmath314 , @xmath315 . since @xmath70 is a triangulation of a @xmath49-ball , there exists a vertex @xmath154 spanning , together with @xmath316 a @xmath49-simplex in @xmath116 .
let @xmath317 .
we will examine different positions of @xmath154 .
suppose first that @xmath318 for some @xmath319 .
then @xmath320 with the lower index @xmath43 .
thus @xmath321 with the lower index @xmath43 .
by the claim [ link ] there exists a pairwise connected triple of points @xmath322 in the link of @xmath228 , such that @xmath272 , @xmath323 and @xmath274 .
if @xmath324 or @xmath325 or @xmath326 the theorem is proved as @xmath327 span a simplex and @xmath328 .
otherwise let @xmath329 and similarly set @xmath330 . since @xmath331 and @xmath332
are not contained in the face of @xmath70 which is the preimage of @xmath333 there is a vertex opposite to @xmath236 . to be more precise there
exist a vertex @xmath334 different from @xmath236 , such that @xmath335 span a simplex .
set @xmath336 . since @xmath70 has no internal vertices @xmath337 for some @xmath338 .
again if @xmath339 the theorem is proved .
otherwise @xmath340 is contained in a digonal or triangular surface associated to @xmath228
. without loss of generality assume that @xmath341 .
we will show that @xmath342 .
we assumed that @xmath343 , so @xmath344 . if @xmath345 then @xmath346 span a @xmath347-simplex , which violates fact that @xmath70 is a triangulation of a @xmath49-ball .
thus @xmath348 is a geodesic so @xmath349 and @xmath350 .
notice if @xmath351 then image of @xmath352 is not a geodesic , a contradiction .
if @xmath353 and @xmath340 is a boundary vertex of a digon , then going by the image of a geodesic @xmath354 and then by an edge @xmath355 gives a path contradicting the distance between @xmath45 and @xmath228 . if @xmath353 and @xmath340 is an internal vertex in @xmath256 , there is another digonal surface @xmath356 with smaller area then @xmath256 .
this surface is the restriction of @xmath357 to a digon between @xmath358 and @xmath340 and a geodesic segment from @xmath340 to @xmath236 .
a contradiction with the assumption that @xmath357 is a minimal digonal surface spanned on @xmath359 . if @xmath340 is contained in the triangular surface the similar reasoning applies .
thus we conclude that @xmath342 .
now let @xmath360 be a vertex , which belongs to two convex subsets different from the one that @xmath12 belongs to . since @xmath361 is a geodesic and by @xmath49-convexity @xmath362 .
but then replacing @xmath228 with @xmath363 , we obtain another four points with the same properties as @xmath197 and smaller sum of distances between them , which violates our assumption .
now consider @xmath364 . if @xmath321 with the lower index @xmath43 , then above reasoning applies .
otherwise @xmath154 is an interior vertex of a simple digon contained in @xmath365 . by lemma [ digon ]
simple digons are flat .
consider a digon in @xmath74 , with the boundary consisting of two geodesics of length @xmath14 .
note that any interior vertex of this digon is at distance at most @xmath366 from any of vertices spanning it .
thus if we apply @xmath367 , we obtain a shortcut in a geodesic from @xmath228 to @xmath43 , which gives a contradiction .
suppose now that @xmath368 for some @xmath369 .
if @xmath154 is a vertex from a geodesic @xmath370 or @xmath371 , similarly we have @xmath321 and the previous reasoning applies .
if @xmath154 is at distance @xmath3 from @xmath236 ( there is only one such an internal vertex in @xmath372 ) , there is another triangular surface @xmath373 with smaller area then @xmath374 .
this surface is the restriction of @xmath374 to a domain bounded by @xmath375 .
a contradiction with the assumption that @xmath372 is a minimal triangular surface spanned on @xmath376 .
if @xmath154 is in distance greater than @xmath3 from @xmath236 , consider paths @xmath377 and @xmath378 .
it follows from the triangle inequality for @xmath372 that one of these paths is shorter than the respective geodesic . a contradiction .
finally we consider what happen either @xmath379 or @xmath380 for some @xmath369 . since @xmath381 , due to lemma [ conv ] we obtain that @xmath382 .
thus vertices @xmath383 span a @xmath49-simplex with desired properties .
v. chepoi , d. osajda , _ dismantlability of weakly systolic complexes and applications _ ,
( 2014 ) , to appear .
t. elsner , _ flats and the flat torus theorem for systolic spaces _ , geometry&topology 13 ( 2009 ) , 661 - 698 . t. elsner , _ systolic groups with isolated flats _ , submitted .
m. gromov , _ hyperbolic groups , essays in group theory _ , math .
, vol . 8 , springer , new york , ( 1987 ) , 75263 .
f. haglund , _ complexes simpliciaux hyperboliques de grande dimension _ , prepublication orsay 71 ( 2003 ) .
f. haglund , j. witkowski , _ separating quasi - convex subgroups in 7-systolic groups _ ,
groups , geometry and dynamics 2 ( 2008 ) , 223 - 244 .
t. januszkiewicz , j. witkowski , _ simplicial nonpositive curvature _ , publ .
ihes , 104 ( 2006 ) , 1 - 85 . m. roller , _ poc - sets , median algebras and group actions . an extended study of dunwoody s construction and sageev s theorem _ , preprint , 1998 . | we prove the analogue of helly s theorem for systolic complexes .
namely , we show that @xmath0-systolic complexes have helly dimension less or equal to @xmath1 , whereas @xmath2-systolic complexes have helly dimension bounded from the above by @xmath3 . |
the type - i susy seesaw model can be described by the superpotential : @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the superpotential for the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm ) , @xmath10 are the lepton flavour indices , @xmath11 are the majorana masses of the right - handed singlet neutrinos with generation indices @xmath12 , and @xmath13 , @xmath14 , @xmath15 are the chiral superfields for the right - handed singlet neutrinos , the left - handed lepton doublets and the higgs doublets , with @xmath16 and @xmath17 .
the relevant soft susy - breaking terms are given by @xmath18 the singlet sneutrino and anti - sneutrino states mix , giving rise to the mass eigenstates : @xmath19 where @xmath20 , that correspond to the mass eigenvalues @xmath21
for simplicity , we will concentrate on sl arising from a single sneutrino generation @xmath22 and in what follows we will drop that index .
after superfield phase rotations , we have three independent physical phases , they are @xmath23 eq . ( [ eq : soft_terms ] ) leads to cp asymmetries @xmath24 arising from self - energy diagrams induced by the bilinear @xmath7 term , @xmath25 where @xmath26 is the thermal factor associated to the difference between the phase - space , bose - enhancement and fermi - blocking factors for the scalar and fermionic channels , that vanishes in the zero temperature limit @xmath27@xcite .
regarding the flavour structure of the soft terms relevant for flavoured sl , we can distinguish two general possibilities : \1 . _
universal soft susy - breaking terms_. this case is realized in supergravity and gauge mediated susy - breaking models ( neglecting the renormalization group running of the parameters ) , in our notations corresponds to @xmath28 in this case the only flavour structure arises from the yukawa couplings and both the cp asymmetries @xmath29 and the corresponding washout terms are proportional to the same @xmath30 , resulting in mild enhancement of @xmath31 in efficiency from one - flavour approximation @xcite .
we refer to this case as _ universal trilinear scenario _ ( uts ) .
_ general soft susy - breaking terms_. the most general form for the soft - susy breaking terms is allowed , only subject to the phenomenological constraints from limits on flavour changing neutral currents ( fcnc ) and from lepton flavour violating ( lfv ) processes . to simplify the analysis
while still capture some of the main features of the general case , we choose @xmath32 such that the cp asymmetries become flavour independent , @xmath33 for each flavour . in what follows we will refer to this case as the _ simplified misaligned scenario _ ( sms ) . with this choice , since it is possible to reduce the washout in a particular flavour direction while keeping the corresponding cp asymmetry fixed , a much greater enhancement than the uts becomes possible . in both the uts and sms , from ( [ eq : cpphase1 ] )
, we see that we only have one unique phase @xmath34 .
we numerically solved the relevant boltzmann equations to obtain the final amount of @xmath35 asymmetry generated in the decay of the singlet sneutrinos ( assuming no pre - existing asymmetry ) which can be parametrized as : @xmath36 after conversion by the sphaleron transitions , the final baryon asymmetry is related to the @xmath35 asymmetry by @xmath37 we also define the @xmath38 decay parameter , @xmath39 which is related to the washout parameter @xmath40 as @xmath41 where @xmath42 is the total singlet sneutrino decay width , @xmath43 ( with @xmath44 gev ) , @xmath45 with @xmath46 the total number of relativistic degrees of freedom ( @xmath47 in the mssm ) and @xmath48 the planck mass . in the left panel of fig .
( [ fig : efficiency ] ) , we plot the efficiencies as a function of @xmath49 for both the scenarios uts and sms . deviating from the flavour equipartition case @xmath50 , in the sms
, we can obtain an enhancement up to @xmath6 compared to the one - flavoured approximation . with this enhancement , it is possible to push the values of @xmath7 up to natural values at tev scale for successful leptogenesis as shown in the right panel of fig .
( [ fig : efficiency ] ) . .
right : maximum values of @xmath7 which can lead to successful leptogenesis as a function of @xmath51 and @xmath52 .
the figures correspond to @xmath53=1 tev and @xmath54.,title="fig : " ] .
right : maximum values of @xmath7 which can lead to successful leptogenesis as a function of @xmath51 and @xmath52 .
the figures correspond to @xmath53=1 tev and @xmath54.,title="fig : " ]
as has been highlighted in ref .
@xcite , at sufficiently low temperatures the off - diagonal soft - susy breaking slepton masses can give rise to lepton flavour equilibration ( lfe ) , effectively damping all dynamical flavour effects . in the left panel of fig .
( [ fig : lfe ] ) , we show the dependence of the efficiencies ( normalized to the flavour equipartition case ) on the off - diagonal soft slepton mass parameter @xmath55 which for simplicity , we assume to be flavour independent .
we see that there is a cut - off value of @xmath56 for each @xmath57 such that the enhancement is totally damped out . in the right panel of fig .
( [ fig : lfe ] ) , we show that in most part of the susy parameter space that is relevant for sl , subjecting to low energy constraints , the large flavour enhancements can survive the lfe effects . .
right : excluded region ( shaded in yellow ) of @xmath56 versus @xmath58 arising from the present bound of @xmath59 , together with the minimum value of @xmath56 for which lfe effects start damping out flavour effects . three lines shown corresponds to @xmath60gev , @xmath61gev and @xmath62gev .
the vertical dashed line represents the value of @xmath63 required to explain the discrepancy between the standard model ( sm ) prediction and the measured value of muon anomalous magectic moment @xmath64 @xcite . in the plots , we assume @xmath54.,title="fig : " ] .
right : excluded region ( shaded in yellow ) of @xmath56 versus @xmath58 arising from the present bound of @xmath59 , together with the minimum value of @xmath56 for which lfe effects start damping out flavour effects . three lines shown corresponds to @xmath60gev , @xmath61gev and @xmath62gev .
the vertical dashed line represents the value of @xmath63 required to explain the discrepancy between the standard model ( sm ) prediction and the measured value of muon anomalous magectic moment @xmath64 @xcite . in the plots , we assume @xmath54.,title="fig : " ]
the speaker thanks concha gonzalez - garcia , enrico nardi and juan racker with whom he collaborated with in this work .
he is also grateful to the 2^nd^ young researchers workshop ( in conjuction with xv frascati spring school `` bruno touschek '' ) organizing committee for the hospitality during his stay in beautiful frascati .
y. grossman , t. kashti , y. nir and e. roulet , phys .
* 91 * ( 2003 ) 251801 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0307081 ] .
g. dambrosio , g. f. giudice and m. raidal , phys .
b * 575 * , 75 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0308031 ] . c. s. fong and m. c. gonzalez - garcia , jhep
* 0806 * ( 2008 ) 076 [ arxiv:0804.4471 [ hep - ph ] ] .
d. aristizabal sierra , m. losada and e. nardi , jcap * 0912 * , 015 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0905.0662 [ hep - ph ] ] . s. davidson , j. garayoa , f. palorini and n. rius , jhep * 0809 * , 053 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0806.2832 [ hep - ph ] ] . | successful soft leptogenesis ( sl ) requires a relatively low mass scale for the su(2 ) singlet neutrinos of @xmath0 gev .
however , conventional sl ( unflavoured ) requires an unnaturally small soft supersymmetry(susy)-breaking bilinear @xmath1 coupling for successful leptogenesis . on the other hand ,
in this regime , the interactions mediated by @xmath2 , @xmath3 ( and even @xmath4 ) charged lepton yukawa interactions are in equilibrium , making the lepton number asymmetries and the washouts flavour dependent .
hence , it is crucial to take into account the flavour effects . considering a general soft susy - breaking trilinear @xmath5 couplings
, it is possible to enhance the efficiency up to @xmath6 compared to the unflavoured case . with the enhanced efficiency
, we can raise the @xmath7 up to tev scale for successful leptogenesis .
taking into account the low energy constraints , we verify that the fast lepton flavour violation processes induced by the soft susy - breaking slepton masses would not destroy the enhancement .
= 11.6pt |
x - ray observations of wolf - rayet ( wr ) stars provide an important means of determining physical conditions in their powerful metal - rich winds and in hot wind - blown bubbles which can surround the star .
x - ray observations yield information on the temperature , emission measure , and luminosity of hot plasma that can be used to test models of wr x - ray emission , which are largely based on the idea that the x - rays arise in shocked winds .
photoelectric absorption of low - energy x - rays can reveal the presence of gas along the line - of - sight toward the star that is difficult to detect by other means .
high - resolution grating spectra can be obtained for the brightest wr x - ray sources and are capable of constraining the location of the x - ray emittng plasma relative to the star , wind parameters , and wind element abundances .
it has been nearly three decades since wr stars were discovered to be x - ray sources by the _ einstein observatory _
( seward et al . 1979 ) .
however , the origin of the x - ray emission is still not totally understood and more than one process may be involved . in the case of single wr stars ( and single ob stars ) , most theoretical work has focused on x - ray production in shocks that are formed in the wind via line - driven instabilities ( lucy & white 1980 ; lucy 1982 ; owocki , castor , & rybicki 1988 ; baum et al . 1992 ; feldmeier et al . 1997 ; gayley & owocki 1995 ) .
such x - ray emission is expected to be soft ( kt @xmath4 1 kev ) and x - ray emission lines lines in optically thick winds are predicted to be asymmetric with blueshifted centroids ( owocki & cohen 2001 ) .
alternate models which attribute shock production to plasmoids moving through the wind have also recently been proposed ( waldron & cassinelli 2009 ) .
the emission of wr binaries is potentially more complex than single stars since it may consist of intrinsic stellar wind - shock emission plus x - rays from a colliding wind shock between the two stars ( prilutskii & usov 1976 ; luo et al .
1990 ; stevens , blondin , & pollock 1992 ; usov 1992 ) .
the maximum x - ray temperature of an adiabatic colliding wind shock is proportional to the square of the wind speed perpendicular to the shock front ( luo et al .
values kt@xmath5 @xmath6 2 kev are expected for typical wr wind speeds of v@xmath7 @xmath8 1000 - 5000 km s@xmath9 .
attempts to confirm x - ray wind - shock models observationally have yielded mixed results .
some evidence supporting the colliding wind picture in massive binaries has been obtained from _
chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ grating observations of x - ray bright systems such as @xmath10 vel ( wc8 @xmath11 o7.5 ; skinner et al .
2001 ; schild et al .
2004 ) and wr 140 ( wc7 @xmath11 o4 - 5 ; pollock et al . 2005 ) . on the other hand ,
the radiative wind shock picture for single massive stars has not yet found broad observational support .
perhaps the best evidence for x - ray production in radiative wind shocks has come from grating observations of the o4f supergiant @xmath12 pup , which reveal wind - broadened emission lines ( hwhm @xmath13 600 - 1600 km s@xmath9 ) with blueshifted centroids ( cassinelli et al .
2001 ) and a substantial emission measure contribution from low - temperature plasma ( kahn et al .
however , grating spectra of other ob stars show narrower unshifted symmetric emission lines that are more difficult to reconcile with radiative wind shock predictions ( e.g. miller et al .
2002 ; schulz et al .
2000 ; cohen et al .
2008 ; skinner et al .
2008 ) .
compelling evidence for x - rays from radiative wind shocks in single wr stars is currently lacking .
but , very few sensitive pointed observations of single wr stars exist and there are no single wr stars yet known that are bright enough in x - rays to acquire good - quality grating spectra in reasonable exposure times .
even so , ccd observations without gratings are feasible and moderate resolution ccd spectra capable of distinguishing between cool plasma that could arise in radiative wind shocks and hotter plasma due to other processes such as colliding winds can be readily obtained .
we have thus initiated an x - ray survey of single wr stars with _ chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ aimed at broadening the observational data base and determining their basic properties such as x - ray temperature and luminosity .
our initial targets included both nitrogen - rich wn stars and carbon - rich wc stars .
they were selected from the viith catalog of galactic wolf - rayet stars ( van der hucht 2001 , herafter vdh01 ) , giving preference to objects lying closest to the sun with low a@xmath2 and no evidence for binarity .
so far , we have observed four apparently single carbon - type wc stars and , surprisingly , none was detected ( skinner et al .
2006 ; 2009 ) .
these are wr 5 ( wc6 ) , wr 57 ( wc8 ) , wr 90 ( wc7 ) , and wr 135 ( wc8 ) .
the most stringent upper limit is from a _
observation of wr 135 for which we obtained log l@xmath14(0.5 - 7 kev ) @xmath15 29.82 ergs s@xmath9 .
this is @xmath132 - 3 orders of magnitude below typical x - ray emission levels of wr binaries and x - ray detected wn stars that are not known to be binaries .
a non - detection of the wc5 star wr 114 was also reported by oskinova et al .
sensitive observations of a broader sample of single wc stars are still needed , but the lack of detections in these exploratory observations already suggests they are either intrinsically faint x - ray emitters , or perhaps x - ray quiet .
in contrast , high - confidence x - ray detections have been obtained for some apparently single wn stars ( skinner et al .
2002a , b ; ignace et al . 2003a
; oskinova 2005 ; naz et al .
these detections are confined primarily to spectral subtypes of wn6 and earlier .
very little is yet known about the x - ray properties of wn7 - 9 stars .
the x - ray luminosities of subtypes wn6 and earlier span a wide range log l@xmath14 @xmath8 31 - 33 ergs s@xmath9 .
it is remarkable that wn6 stars themselves have l@xmath14 values spanning nearly two orders of magnitude . in those cases where good x - ray spectra of early wn subtypes ( @xmath15wn6 ) exist ,
a multi - temperature plasma is invariably present with a cool component at kt@xmath16 @xmath4 0.6 kev and a hotter component at kt@xmath17 @xmath6 2 kev .
the cool plasma is compatible with radiative wind shock predictions but the hot plasma is not .
the existence of x - ray emission in late wn7 - 9 stars has not been thoroughly investigated .
but , there are indications that their x - ray luminosity levels are low . an _ xmm - newton _ observation of wr 40 ( wn8 ; gosset et al . 2005 ) yielded a non - detection with a conservative upper limit log l@xmath14 @xmath15 31.6 ergs s@xmath9 .
but , an archival _ rosat _ pspc image ( rp200150n00 ) reveals a marginal detection of the wn9 star wr 79a at a 12.2@xmath18 off - axis position , which was our primary motivation for reobserving it at higher sensitivity with _ xmm - newton_. we report here on sensitive x - ray observations of four wn stars of spectral subtypes wn2 - wn9 , namely wr 2 ( wn2 ) , wr 18 ( wn 4 ) , wr 134 ( wn6 ) , and wr 79 ( wn9 ha ) .
none of these is listed as either a binary or probable binary in the viith wr catalog ( vdh01 ) .
periodic line - profile spectroscopic variability in wr 134 at a period p = 2.25 d has been reported by morel et al .
( 1999 ) , but no companion has yet been found and other factors such as a rotationally - modulated wind may be responsible for the variability ( st .- louis et al .
all four wn stars were detected ( figs . 1 - 4 ) .
we supplement these new detections with selected x - ray archival data for other wn stars , summarize their x - ray properties , and discuss candidate emission mechanisms .
table 1 summarizes the general properties of the wn stars considered in this study .
the _ chandra _ observations are summarized in table 2 .
exposures were obtained using the acis - s ( advanced ccd imaging spectrometer ) imaging array in faint timed - event mode .
a reduced 1/4 subarray size was used for the brighter source wr 134 to minimize any photon pileup .
the wr star target was placed at the nominal aimpoint on ccd s3 of the array .
the ccd pixel size is 0.492@xmath19 .
approximately 90% of the encircled energy at 1.49 kev lies within 2@xmath19 of the center pixel of an on - axis point source .
more information on _ chandra _ and its instrumentation can be found in the _ chandra _ proposer s observatory guide ( pog ) .
the level 2 events file provided by the _
chandra _ x - ray center ( cxc ) was analyzed using standard science threads in ciao version 4.1.2 .
the ciao processing used calibration data from caldb version 4.1.2 .
source detection was carried out using the the ciao _ wavdetect _ tool , which correlates the input image with `` mexican hat '' wavelet functions of different scale sizes .
wavdetect _ on full - resolution images with a pixel size of 0.@xmath19492 using events in the 0.3 - 8 kev range to reduce the background .
the _ wavdetect _ threshold was set at @xmath20 = 1.5 @xmath21 10@xmath22 and scale sizes of 1 , 2 , 4 , 8 , and 16 were used .
the _ wavdetect _ tool provides source centroid positions and net source counts ( background subtracted ) inside the computed 3@xmath23 source region ( table 3 ) .
ciao _ specextract _ was used to extract source and background spectra for the wn stars along with source - specific response matrix files ( rmfs ) and auxiliary response files ( arfs ) .
we used the 3@xmath23 source ellipses from _ wavdetect _ to define the extraction regions and background was extracted from adjacent source - free regions .
background is negligible , contributing @xmath01 count ( 0.3 - 8 kev ) inside the source extraction regions over the duration of each observation .
spectral fitting was undertaken with the heasoft _ xanadu _ software package including xspec vers .
x - ray light curves were extracted using the ciao tool _
dmextract _ and checks for source variabilility were carried out on energy - filtered source event files using the kolmogorov - smirnov ( ks ) test ( press et al .
1992 ) and the bayesian - method ciao tool _ glvary _
( gregory & loredo 1992 , 1996 ) . table 2 summarizes the _ xmm - newton _ observation of wr 79a .
data were acquired with the european photon imaging camera ( epic ) , which provides charge - coupled device ( ccd ) imaging spectroscopy from the pn camera ( strder et al .
2001 ) and two nearly identical mos cameras ( mos1 and mos2 ; turner et al .
the observation was obtained in full - window mode using the thick optical blocking filter .
the epic cameras provide energy coverage in the range e @xmath13 0.2 - 15 kev with energy resolution e/@xmath24e @xmath13 20 - 50 .
the mos cameras provide the best on - axis angular resolution with fwhm @xmath13 4.3@xmath19 at 1.5 kev .
data were reduced using the _ xmm - newton _ science analysis system ( sas vers .
7.1 ) using the latest calibration data .
event files based on pipeline processing carried out at the _ xmm - newton _ science operations center were filtered to select good event patterns . further filtering based on event energies
was done to reduce background emission .
no time filtering was required .
spectra and light curves were extracted from circular regions of radius r@xmath25 = 15@xmath19 centered on wr79a , corresponding to @xmath1368% encircled energy at 1.5 kev .
this approach reduces the number of background counts while capturing most of the source counts .
total source counts ( table 3 ) were measured in a larger circular region of radius r = 45@xmath19 corresponding to @xmath1390% encircled energy at 1.5 kev .
background spectra and light curves were obtained from circular source - free regions near the source .
the sas tasks _ rmfgen _ and _ arfgen _ were used to generate source - specific rmfs and arfs for spectral analysis .
the data were analyzed using the heasoft _ xanadu _ software package we have examined _ chandra _ and _ rosat _ archive data for selected wn stars which are not known to be binaries .
our archive analysis is not exhaustive and was restricted to a few high - interest objects for which either good ccd spectra or useful upper limits were obtained .
analysis of _ chandra _ archive data was carried out using the same procedures described above ( sec .
_ rosat _ images were analyzed using the _ ximage _ image analysis tool , which is part of the heasoft _ xanadu _ package .
results of the archive analysis are summarized in section 3.3 and in tables 3 and 5 .
table 3 summarizes the x - ray properties of the four newly - detected wn stars and three wn stars from the _ chandra _ archive ( wr 20b , wr 24 , and wr 136 ) .
there is very good agreement between the x - ray positions and the optical positions of the wn stars given in the _ hst _ guide star catalog ( gsc ) .
radial offsets between the x - ray and optical positions are @xmath150.3@xmath19 for the new detections , being within the 1@xmath23 range of _ chandra _ and _ xmm _ positional accuracy .
similar offsets were obtained for the archive detections .
there is thus no reason to doubt that the x - ray sources are the optically - identified wr stars .
no significant x - ray variability was detected in any of the targets , but sampling in the time domain spans less than @xmath1310 hours for the four new detections and @xmath41 day for the archive sources .
thus , variability on longer timescales exceeding one day can not yet be ruled out .
the x - ray spectra of the four new detections are shown in figure 5 and the archive spectra in figure 6 .
all spectra show some absorption below @xmath130.8 kev as well as prominent emission lines or line complexes indicative of thermal emission .
the most prominent lines are the unresolved mg xi he - like triplet at 1.33 - 1.35 kev ( maximum line power temperature log t@xmath5 = 6.8 k ) and the unresolved si xiii triplet at 1.84 - 1.86 kev ( log t@xmath5 = 7.0 k ) .
the higher temperature s xv line at 2.46 kev ( log t@xmath5 = 7.2 k ) is also seen in all stars , but is very faint in wr 2 . the high - temperature line from he - like ar xvii ( log t@xmath5 = 7.3 k ) ,
is detected in several stars and is quite strong in wr 20b .
faint emission near 3.9 kev in the wn6h stars wr 20b and wr 136 may be due to he - like ca xix ( log t@xmath5 = 7.5 k ) but we classify this line only as a possible detection . the fe k@xmath26 complex ( fe xxv ; 6.67 kev log t@xmath5 = 7.6 k )
is detected in wr 20b , wr 134 , and wr 136 .
this line is a signature of very hot plasma , which is undoubtedly present in these latter three wn6h stars .
we have attempted to fit the spectra with various emission models , including the xspec variable - abundance optically thin plasma model @xmath27 ( smith et al .
2001 ) and the constant temperature plane - parallel shock model @xmath28 ( borkowski et al .
2001 , and references therein ) .
all models included a photoelectric absorption component ( xspec model @xmath29 ) which was used to determine the equivalent neutral h column density n@xmath30 .
element abundances are expected to deviate strongly from solar composition in wn stars as the result of advanced nucleosynthesis .
h is depleted along with c and o , while he and n are enriched ( van der hucht et al .
1986 ; hereafter vcw86 ) .
because of the moderate ccd spectral resolution of acis - s and epic and limited total source counts , we are not able to place tight constraints on element abundances using the x - ray spectra . we have thus adopted the generic wn abundances of vcw86 ( table 4 ) as starting values in spectral fits using the @xmath27 and @xmath28 models .
selected elements were allowed to deviate from the vcw86 values to improve the fits , as detailed in tables 4 and 5 .
the total x - ray absorption likely includes constributions from solar abundance material in the interstellar medium and stellar wind absorption from material enriched with heavy elements .
the ccd spectra do not provide sufficient information to disentangle solar and nonsolar absorption , and we have thus modeled x - ray absorption using solar abundances ( xspec @xmath29 ; anders & ebihara 1982 ) .
our main spectral analysis results can be summarized as follows : ( i ) single - temperature optically - thin plasma models ( 1 t @xmath27 ) do not provide acceptable fits , even if abundances are allowed to vary , ( ii ) two - temperature models ( 2 t @xmath27 ) are acceptable but the goodness - of - fit statistic ( @xmath31 ) is sensitive to abundances ; ( iii ) all stars show both a cool ( kt@xmath16 @xmath0 1 kev ) and hot ( kt @xmath1 2 kev ) plasma component , ( iv ) most stars show x - ray absorption in excess of that expected from their optical extinction a@xmath2 , ( v ) fits using isothermal plane - parallel shock models are not as good as 2 t @xmath27 ( wr 20b excepted ) . in all cases , the 2 t model requires a cool component at kt@xmath16 @xmath13 0.3 - 0.6 kev plus a hotter component at kt@xmath17 @xmath1 2 kev .
the best - fit value of kt@xmath17 for wr 2 is sensitive to the s abundance , which is not well - constrained by the data .
we thus quote only a lower 90% confidence bound on kt@xmath17 for wr 2 .
the respective normalization values ( @xmath32 ) for each component show that most of the emission measure in wr 2 , wr 18 , and wr 79a is associated with the cooler component , while the hotter component clearly dominates in wr 134 and wr 136 .
the best - fit neutral - h absorption column density ( n@xmath30 ) is a factor of @xmath132 - 4 lower in wr 2 than in the other three stars . using the conversion n@xmath30 @xmath33 2.22 @xmath21 10@xmath34 a@xmath35 @xmath36 ( gorenstein 1975 )
, it is apparent from table 4 that the x - ray derived n@xmath30 is consistent with that expected from a@xmath35 = 1.58 mag for wr 2 ( table 1 ) .
however , the n@xmath30 for wr 18 , wr79a , and wr 134 is a factor of @xmath82 - 4 greater than anticipated from a@xmath35 , implying the presence of x - ray absorbing gas ( e.g. the wind ) that does not contribute significantly to the optical extinction .
excess absorption is also present in the archive detection wr 20b .
some improvement in the 2 t @xmath27 fits was obtained by allowing elements with detectable line emission ( n , ne , mg , si , s , fe ) to deviate from the generic wn values ( table 4 and 5 notes ) .
in particular , our fits of several stars were improved by using s abundances larger than the value given in vcw86 ( which was based on cosmic mass fraction ) .
given the expectation that wr star x - ray emission may arise in shocked winds , we attempted to fit the spectra of all detections except wr 18 with @xmath28 in order to determine if a simplistic constant - temperature shock model could reproduce the spectra .
there are insufficient counts in wr 18 to establish a clear preference between thin plasma models and shock models .
the @xmath28 fits used data from the atomic plasma emission database ( aped ) to calculate the spectrum ( xspec option @xmath37 2.0 ) . for the new detections ,
reasonably good @xmath28 fits were obtained for both wr 2 and wr 134 , but we do not find a clear preference for @xmath28 over the 2 t @xmath27 model in either case . for wr 2 ,
@xmath28 gives shock temperatures in the range kt@xmath38 @xmath13 1.5 - 3.5 kev , but in order to obtain acceptable fits the abundances of elements with line emission above 2 kev ( most notably s and ar ) must be increased to very high values .
when abundances are fixed at the generic wn values , @xmath28 underestimates the hard flux above 2 kev .
when abundances are allowed to vary , the model attempts to correct for this flux deficit by running up the s and ar abundances while at the same time keeping kt@xmath38 @xmath13 2 kev .
this is likely a consequence of attempting to fit a multi - temperature plasma with an overly simplistic constant - temperature shock model . for wr 134 , high shock temperatures kt@xmath38 @xmath39 10 kev
are required and even with such high temperatures the @xmath31 fit statistic is not as good as obtained with 2 t @xmath40 . for the archive detections , the @xmath28 fits for wr 24 and wr 136 are reasonably good above 1 kev but the shock model underestimates the observed flux of the softer emission below @xmath131 kev .
wr 20b provides an interesting exception because the @xmath28 model actually provides a better fit to its spectrum than 2 t @xmath27 ( table 5 notes ) .
the inferred shock temperature kt@xmath38 = 3.9 kev is quite high .
however , the soft emission below 1 kev that can not be accurately reproduced with @xmath28 in the other stars is not detected in wr 20b ( fig .
thus , the good results obtained with @xmath28 for wr 20b may simply be a consequence of its higher absorption . * wr 2 ( wn2 ) * : wr 2 is a new _ chandra _ detection and is the earliest wn subtype in our sample .
the v = 12.73 mag object ( _ hst _ gsc [email protected] ) lying 13.9@xmath19 south of wr 2 was not detected by _
chandra_. wr 2 lies in a neutral hydrogen void ( arnal et al .
no significant spectroscopic variability was found for wr 2 in the recent study of st .-
louis et al .
however , unusual round - shaped emission line profiles have been reported for wr 2 that were interpreted as signaling rapid rotation near breakup ( hamann et al .
2006 ) .
as table 3 shows , it is the softest x - ray source of the detected wn stars as judged by its median photon energy e@xmath41 = 1.04 kev .
spectral analysis confirms that the x - ray absorption toward wr 2 is less than the other three stars , resulting in the detection of more soft photons below 0.7 kev and a lower median photon energy .
events were detected in wr 2 down to energies of @xmath130.3 kev as well emission at higher energies up to @xmath133 kev .
the _ chandra _ spectrum is interesting because it shows an emission feature near 0.5 kev that likely includes a contribution from the low - temperature hydrogen - like n vii ly @xmath26 line ( log t@xmath5 = 6.3 k ) . the intermediate temperature ne x line at 1.02 kev ( log t@xmath5 = 6.7
k ) is also detected , as well as faint emission from the higher - temperature si xiii and s xv lines .
thus , cool and hot plasma features are present in the same star .
two issues related to 2 t @xmath27 fits are worthy of note .
this model is able to reproduce most of the broad emission feature near 0.5 kev with the n vii ly@xmath26 line ( e@xmath42 = 500.3 ev ) .
but , there is some residual at slightly higher energies of 530 - 540 ev that is not reproduced by this line .
the o vii resonance line is not obviously detected and in any case it lies at a higher energy ( 574 ev ) and can not account for this residual .
however , other ions with lab energies slightly above that of n vii could be contributing to the residual including n vi ( 532.6 ev ) , s xiv ( 538.9 ev ) , and ca xvi ( 546.8 ev ) .
the 2 t @xmath27 model also has difficulty reproducing all of the flux in the faint feature near 2.46 kev ( s xv ) unless a very high s abundance is assumed . * wr 16 ( wn8h ) * : this star is of interest because of its later wn8h subtype and moderate extinction a@xmath2 = 1.8 mag ( vdh01 ) .
wr 16 was not detected in _
pspc image rp200715n00 , which has an exposure livetime of 7,465 s. our analysis of the pspc data gives a 3@xmath23 upper limit on the total band count rate @xmath151.8 c ksec@xmath9 .
the pspc is sensitive at lower energies of @xmath130.15 - 2.5 kev .
this equates to a conservative 3@xmath23 upper limit log l@xmath14(0.3 - 8 kev ) @xmath15 31.7 ergs s@xmath9 , assuming a distance d = 2.37 kpc ( vdh01 ) .
the conversion from pspc rate to unabsorbed flux and l@xmath14 was carried out using the portable interactive multi - mission simulator ( pimms ) assuming n@xmath30 = 4 @xmath21 10@xmath34 @xmath36 corresponding to a@xmath2 = 1.8 mag ( gorenstein 1975 ) and a raymond - smith thermal plasma model with emission measure equally distributed between a cool component at kt@xmath16 = 0.6 kev and a hotter component at kt@xmath17 = 3.0 kev . *
wr 18 ( wn4 ) * : this wn4 star is associated with the asymmetric nebula ngc 3199 , which has been modeled as a wind - blown bubble by dyson & ghanbari ( 1989 ) .
cold circumstellar molecular gas has been reported by marston ( 2001 , 2003 ) .
it is a new _ chandra _ detection and its spectrum shows a prominent si xiii line and the hotter s xv line . *
wr 20b ( wn6h ) * : this star was detected as a bright source in a previous _ chandra _ observation of the massive stellar cluster westerlund 2 ( obsid 6411 ; naz et al .
its x - ray emission is heavily - absorbed and exceptionally hard with a median photon energy e@xmath41 = 3.04 kev .
we were unable to obtain acceptable fits with a 1 t @xmath27 model but a 2 t @xmath27 model is satisfactory and requires a hot plasma component at kt@xmath17 @xmath13 4 - 5 kev . the isothermal plane - parallel shock model @xmath28 provides a slightly better fit with an inferred shock temperature kt@xmath38 = 3.9 kev .
the x - ray absorption is greater than for any other wn star in our sample .
the absorption determined from both @xmath27 and @xmath28 models yields a ratio of x - ray to optically - determined absorption n@xmath30/n@xmath43 @xmath13 3 .
the acis - i spectrum shows high - temperature emission lines including ar xvii ( 3.13 kev ) and fe xxv ( 6.67 kev ) .
the distance to wr 20b is quite uncertain .
values range from d = 2.27 kpc ( vdh01 ) up to 8 kpc ( naz et al .
2008 ) . even at the low end of this range ,
its x - ray luminosity is very high for a wn star ( log l@xmath14 @xmath1 33.5 ergs s@xmath9 ) .
its high l@xmath14 and hard spectrum are reminiscent of colliding wind binaries , suggesting that this object may not be a single star ( sec .
* wr 24 ( wn6 ha ) * : this star was detected as a bright off - axis x - ray source in an archival _ chandra _ guaranteed time observation ( gto ) of the carina region ( gto obsid 9482 ) . its acis - i spectrum shows a remarkably strong s xv emission line at 2.46 kev , as well as the high - temperature ar xvii ( 3.13 kev ) line and possible faint fe line emission in the 6.4 - 6.7 kev range .
a 2 t @xmath27 model provides a satisfactory fit with a hot plasma component at kt@xmath17 @xmath13 4 kev .
the absorption n@xmath30 = 0.76 [ 0.44 - 1.05 ] @xmath21 10@xmath44 @xmath36 is several times larger than would be expected from a@xmath2 = 0.56 mag ( vdh01 ) . at an assumed distance d = 3.24 kpc ( vdh01 ) , a high unabsorbed x - ray luminosity log l@xmath14 = 33.0 ergs s@xmath9 is inferred , only slightly less than for wr 20b . because of its high l@xmath14 and high l@xmath3 , wr 24 is another candidate unresolved binary system ( sec .
* wr 78 ( wn7h ) * : this wnl star is similar to wr 16 , having moderate extinction a@xmath2 = 1.5 mag and is relatively nearby at d = 1.99 kpc ( vdh01 ) .
a previous tabulation of wn star x - ray observations by oskinova ( 2005 ) listed wr 78 as a _
rosat _ pspc detection .
our analysis of archival _ rosat _ pspc images rp200716n00 does not confirm this .
we report a non - detection in the total band and soft band images .
weak signal may be present in the hard band pspc image , but the signal - to - noise ratio s / n @xmath13 2 is not sufficient to classify it as a detection .
we obtain a 3@xmath23 upper limit on the total band pspc count rate @xmath152.97 c ksec@xmath9 based on an exposure livetime of 10,121 s. the corresponding 3@xmath23 luminosity upper limit from pimms is log l@xmath14(0.3 - 8 kev ) @xmath15 31.7 ergs s@xmath9 ( at d = 1.99 kpc ) .
this assumes n@xmath30 = 3.3 @xmath21 10@xmath34 @xmath36 corresponding to a@xmath2 = 1.5 mag ( gorenstein 1975 ) and a 2 t raymond - smith thermal plasma model as for wr 16 above . *
wr 79a ( wn9 ha ) * : this is a new and important _ xmm - newton _ detection , being the latest wn subtype in our sample and the first unambiguous x - ray detection of a wnl star in the wn7 - 9 range .
there is a fainter near - ir source ( 2mass [email protected] ) at an offset of 4.@xmath198 from wr 79a ( see also mason et al .
1998 ) , but the x - ray positional accuracy is capable of distinguishing between this object and wr 79a . radio continuum emission has been detected ( bieging , abbott , & churchwell 1989 ) and follow - up observations suggest a nonthermal radio component may be present ( cappa , goss , & van der hucht 2004 ) .
wr 79a (= hd 152408 ) was formerly classified as o8:iafpe but was subsequently reclassified as wn9 ha based on the analysis of its optical , uv , and ir spectra by crowther & bohannan ( 1997 ) .
its epic spectrum reveals a strong si xiii line and higher temperature s xv and ar xvii lines .
since this star resembles an o8 supergiant , we have considered solar abundance spectral fits as well as the fit based on wn abundances given in table 4 .
the solar abundance fit gives comparable temperatures to the wn abundance fit but yields a slightly higher n@xmath30 and l@xmath14 ( table 4 notes ) .
regardless of the reference abundances used , the l@xmath14 of wr 79a is at the low end of the range found here for wn stars .
* wr 134 ( wn6h ) * : this is a new _ chandra _ detection and a luminous x - ray source with a very hot component .
it is surrounded by a ring nebula ( chu et al .
1983 ; miller & chu 1993 ) .
because of its unusual 2.25 d periodic spectroscopic variability , it has been the subject of numerous previous studies ( e.g. howarth & schmutz 1992 ; schulte - ladbeck et al .
1992 ; morel et al . 1999 ; st .- louis et al .
the possibility that the 2.25 d periodicity might be due to a compact companion has been debated but there are difficulties with this interpretation ( morel et al .
we discuss the compact companion hypothesis further in section 4.4 .
* wr 136 ( wn6h ) * : wr 136 is surrounded by the ring nebula ngc 6888 ( gruendl et al . 2000 ) which is a source of diffuse x - ray emission ( bochkarev 1988 ; gruendl , guerrero , & chu 2003 ; chu , gruendl , & guerrero 2006 ) .
the wr star was detected at @xmath138@xmath18 off - axis in a deep 93 ksec _
chandra _ exposure of ngc 6888 ( obsid 3763 ) .
the acis - s spectrum is faint , but quite remarkable .
the spectrum is dominated almost entirely by emission lines , including the high - temperature s xv line ( 2.46 kev ) , possible faint emission from ca xix ( 3.9 kev ) , and a feature near 6.67 kev that is likely fe xxv .
attempts to fit the spectrum with a 2 t @xmath27 model using a single absorption component were unstable and resulted in high runaway temperatures for the hot component . a modified 2 t @xmath27 model that allows for different absorptions toward the cool and hot component is stable and provides a good fit ( table 5 ) .
the absorption derived for the cool component is consistent with that expected for previous extinction estimates a@xmath2 = 1.73 @xmath46 0.32 mag ( vdh01 ) .
however , the best - fit absorption of the hot component is a factor of @xmath138 larger .
the physical picture that emerges from such a model is that the cool x - ray emission originates far from the star and incurs little or no wind absorption . in contrast
, the hot component originates deep within the wind and much closer to the star and is subject to strong attenuation by the wind .
the inferred x - ray luminosity is sensitive to the temperature of the cool component but most fits yield values of log l@xmath14(0.3 - 8 kev ) @xmath13 31.5 ergs s@xmath9 , assuming the _ hipparcos _ distance d = 1.64 kpc .
thus , wr 136 seems to be of lower x - ray luminosity than other wn6 stars in the sample .
the new observational results discussed above provide the most detailed picture to date of the x - ray emission of apparently single wn stars .
we comment below on specific aspects of their x - ray emission and possible emission processes .
the visual extinction a@xmath2 for the wn stars in our sample is dominated by interstellar material along the line - of - sight .
there is insufficient dust in the winds of wn stars to significantly affect a@xmath2 , in contrast to some wc stars whose dusty winds can absorb and re - radiate stellar light ( van der hucht , williams , & th 1987 ) .
the a@xmath2 values in table 1 can be used to calculate an equivalent neutral h absorption column density along the line - of - sight using the conversion n@xmath43 = 2.22 @xmath21 10@xmath34a@xmath2 @xmath36 ( gorenstein 1975 ) . assuming that the winds of wn stars have a negligible effect on a@xmath2
, the resulting value of n@xmath43 is a measure of interstellar absorption . in tables 4 and 5 we give the ratio of the x - ray to optically - derived absorption column densities n@xmath30/n@xmath43 .
this ratio is greater than unity for all wn stars except wr 2 .
that is , the x - ray absorption is greater than expected based on visual extinction estimates .
the largest absorption excesses are found for wr 20b and wr 134 . for the double - absorption model of wr 136 , there is no significant absorption excess for the cool component but a large excess is found for the heavily - absorbed hot component .
most of the excess x - ray absorption likely occurs in the metal - rich wr wind , but in some cases cold circumstellar molecular gas may also contribute .
it may not be a coincidence that wr 2 has little or no excess absorption given that it has the highest effective temperature of the four newly - detected stars ( t@xmath47 = 141 kk , hamann et al .
2006 ) and the lowest wind density parameter @xmath48/v@xmath7 .
higher temperatures ( along with higher ionization ) plus lower densities would increase wind transparency to x - rays .
if the x - rays are formed in the wind then some wind absorption is expected , especially for lower energy photons .
for an ideal spherical wind , the radius of optical depth unity r@xmath49 beyond which x - ray photons can escape ( the `` exospheric approximation '' ) depends on several factors including photon energy , mass - loss parameters , photoelectric absorption cross - sections , and wind abundances ( e.g. owocki & cohen 1999 ) . in figure 7 , we plot r@xmath49 as a function of photon energy for the four new detections .
we have assumed an ideal spherical , homogeneous , constant - velocity wind with the mass - loss parameters as given in table 1 , canonical wn abundances ( vcwh86 ) , and the photoelectric absorption cross - sections of baluciska - church & mccammon ( 1992 , hereafter bm92 ) .
it is apparent that under the above assumptions , soft photons with e @xmath0 1 kev emerge at large distances from the star r@xmath49 @xmath6 1000 r@xmath50 .
taking wr 134 as a specific example , the softest photons visible in its spectrum ( fig .
5 ) at e @xmath13 600 ev have r@xmath49(600 ev ) = 9262 r@xmath50 @xmath13 1750 r@xmath47 , assuming r@xmath47 = 5.29 r@xmath50 ( hamann et al . 2006 ) . the above estimates , which are based on the assumption that the wind is homogeneous and spherically symmetric , suggest that the softest x - ray photons detected in the wn star spectra emerge at large distances of thousands of stellar radii or more from the star . these are only rough estimates because wind abundances and mass - loss parameters are poorly - known .
furthermore , there is accumulating evidence that the winds of wr stars are clumped rather than homogeneous ( moffat et al .
1988 ; robert 1994 ; lpine et al .
2000 ) , in which case the x - rays could escape from smaller radii closer to the star . even if the wind is the dominant absorber , other factors such as cold dense circumstellar gas could also contribute .
such gas has been detected around wr 18 and may be a vestige of mass - loss in previous evolutionary phases ( marston 2001 ; 2003 ) .
the radiative wind shock picture can not explain the high - temperature plasma seen in the x - ray spectra of wn stars , but the temperature of the cooler plasma kt@xmath16 @xmath13 0.3 - 0.6 kev is compatible with radiative wind shocks .
of the four stars observed , wr 2 shows the coolest emission . assuming its cool plasma originates in wind shocks , we equate the best - fit temperature of the cool component with the shock temperature , that is kt@xmath16 = 0.32 [ 0.24 - 0.45 ] kev = kt@xmath51 . for an adiabatic shock the maximum shock temperature is kt@xmath51 = ( 3/16)mv@xmath52 , where v@xmath51 is the shock velocity perpendicular to the shock front ( luo et al .
1990 ) . for a helium - rich wn wind m = ( 4/3)m@xmath53 where m@xmath53 is the proton mass .
an equivalent form of this relation that is easier to apply is kt@xmath51 = 2.61[v@xmath51/1000 km s@xmath9]@xmath55 kev .
the inferred shock speed for wr 2 is then v@xmath51 = 350 [ 304 - 416 , 90% confidence range ] km s@xmath9 .
this value is plausible , being only about one - fifth the terminal wind speed ( table 1 ) and within the range of shock velocity jumps found in numerical simulations of radiatively driven winds in o - type stars ( owocki et al .
1988 ; feldmeier et al .
the slightly higher values kt@xmath16 @xmath13 0.6 kev for the other three stars give shock speeds v@xmath51 @xmath13 480 km s@xmath9 .
the unabsorbed flux of the cool x - ray component in wr 2 ( table 4 ) gives a cool - component luminosity log l@xmath56 = 32.47 ( ergs s@xmath9 ) and log [ l@xmath56/l@xmath57 = @xmath454.94 .
so there is sufficient wind kinetic energy to power the soft x - ray emission even at a rather low conversion efficiency from kinetic to radiative energy .
but , numerical models show that forward shocks decay with radius ( feldmeier et al .
1997 ) and it remains to be demonstrated by detailed simulations that x - ray emitting wind shocks can persist as coherent structures in wr winds out to large distances of hundreds to thousands of stellar radii ( sec .
we now consider another star , wr 20b , which is an interesting case because of the good fit obtained with an isothermal plane - parallel shock model .
the best - fit shock temperature kt@xmath51 = 3.86 [ 2.97 - 6.53 ] kev is too high to explain by radiative wind shocks , but is plausible for colliding wind shocks .
if the wind of wr 20b is shocking onto an unseen companion , then the inferred shock velocity perpendicular to the interface is v@xmath51 = 1216 [ 1067 - 1582 ] km s@xmath9 .
this estimate is for an adiabatic shock and assumes a pure he wind for the wn star .
the above value is reasonable , being comparable to the terminal wind speeds of wn6 stars ( crowther 2007 ; hamann et al .
. there are at present no detections of magnetic fields in wr stars to our knowledge .
but , if magnetic fields of sufficient strength exist then they could confine the ionized wind into two oppositely directed streams which collide near the magnetic equator and form a magnetically - confined wind shock ( mcws ) .
this mechanism is of interest because it is capable of producing hot x - ray plasma over a range of temperatures up to several kev ( babel & montmerle 1997 ) and could potentially explain the hotter plasma seen in the wn star spectra .
a rough estimate of the field strength needed to confine the wind can be obtained using the confinement parameter @xmath58 = b@xmath59r@xmath60/@xmath48v@xmath7 where b@xmath61 is the field strength at the magnetic equator ( ud - doula & owocki 2002 ) . for @xmath58 @xmath13 1
the wind is marginally - confined by the b - field , for @xmath58 @xmath62 1 the wind overpowers the field and is not confined , and for @xmath58 @xmath63 1 the wind is strongly - confined .
assuming @xmath58 @xmath13 1 ( marginal confinement ) and adopting the mass - loss parameters and stellar radii in table 1 , one obtains magnetic field strengths in the range b@xmath61 @xmath13 3.5 kg ( wr 134 ) up to 17 kg ( wr 2 ) .
these fields are for marginal confinement and larger fields would be needed for strong confinement . without concrete evidence for strong b fields in wr stars ,
this mechanism must be considered speculative .
our four new detections and archive sources were selected on the basis that they are so far not known to be close ( spectroscopic ) binary systems .
thus , any attempt to explain their x - ray emission by invoking an unseen companion is not strongly motivated on observational grounds .
however , it is worth keeping in mind that close companions at sub - arcsecond spacings are difficult to detect , especially when in low - inclination orbits . of the wn stars in our sample ,
wr 134 has been regarded as a possible close binary system because of its known 2.25 day periodic line profile changes .
this issue has been previously discussed by morel et al .
however , binarity has not yet been demonstrated and a rotationally - modulated wind is an alternative explanation for the variability ( st .- louis et al .
2009 ) . a close companion , if present ,
could potentially explain the hard x - ray emission in wr 134 .
hard x - rays could be produced by the wr wind accreting onto a compact object or by the wind shocking onto the surface of a normal ( nondegenerate ) stellar companion .
but this interpretation encounters some difficulties .
the most compelling example known so far of a wr star accreting onto a compact object is cyg x-3 .
it has a high x - ray luminosity l@xmath14 @xmath8 10@xmath64 ergs s@xmath9 and the companion is thought to be either a black hole or a neutron star ( van den heuvel & de loore 1973 ; schmutz , geballe , & schild 1996 ; lommen et al . 2005 ) .
if the putative companion of wr 134 were a neutron star , then the predicted x - ray luminosity from wind accretion is log l@xmath65 @xmath8 10@xmath66 ergs s@xmath9 ( morel et al . 1999 ) .
this exceeds the observed value for wr 134 ( table 4 ) by more than four orders of magnitude .
this interpretation is thus untenable unless some mechanism is operating to inhibit wind accretion ( see davidson & ostriker 1973 or lipunov 1982 for details on such mechanisms ) .
a similar luminosity mismatch has also been noted for the wn star wr 6 ( ez cma ) by skinner et al .
( 2002b ) .
it also undergoes periodic optical variability ( p = 3.76 d ; firmani et al .
1980 ) of unknown origin and a neutron star companion has been suggested as a possible explanation . in the case of wr 134 , there are other obstacles to overcome if the putative companion is a neutron star of typical mass m@xmath67 @xmath13 1.4 m@xmath50 .
if p = 2.25 d is interpreted as an orbital period , then kepler s third law gives a separation @xmath68 @xmath13 20 r@xmath50 @xmath13 4 r@xmath47 .
here we have adopted m@xmath69 = 19 m@xmath50 and radius r@xmath47 = 5.3 r@xmath50 for wr 134 ( hamann et al .
unless the wind is inhomogenous , x - rays at energies e @xmath13 2 - 3 kev ( obviously present in the spectrum ) could not escape from such small radii . specifically ,
if we use the mass - loss parameters for wr 134 in table 1 and canonical wn abundances ( vcw86 ) , then r@xmath49(2 kev ) @xmath13 89 r@xmath47 .
the slightly different mass - loss parameters for wn6 stars in crowther ( 2007 ) give r@xmath49(2 kev ) @xmath13 36 r@xmath47 .
given the luminosity mismatch obtained in the neutron star companion model , it seems more likely that any unseen companion is a normal ( nondegenerate ) star .
it would have been difficult for a massive companion ( m@xmath70 @xmath13 m@xmath69 ) to have escaped detection , but a lower mass star ( m@xmath70 @xmath62 m@xmath69 ) would be more difficult to detect .
the possibility of a low - mass companion was previously considered in our analysis of the similar wn - type star wr 6 ( skinner et al .
likewise , for wr 134 it can be shown that the hard - component x - ray luminosity could be accounted for by the wr wind impacting the surface of a lower - mass star of subsolar radius ( usov 1992 ) .
furthermore , the plasma temperature of the hot component of wr 134 is compatible with maximum values expected from a shocked wind at or near the terminal wind speed of wr 134 . specifically , v@xmath7 @xmath13 1700 - 1960 km s@xmath9 ( st .- louis et al .
2009 ) gives kt@xmath51 @xmath13 7.5 - 10 .
however , such a low - mass companion would be located very close to wr 134 if p = 2.25 d is the orbital period .
separations of @xmath05 r@xmath47(wr ) are inferred from kepler s third law , so again the escape of x - rays through the wind is potentially problematic .
this problem is mitigated if the wind is clumped or if an unseen companion is present at a larger separation than inferred above , resulting in a lower wr wind density at or near the companion surface .
the sample of single wn stars for which x - ray parameters have been reliably determined from good - quality ccd spectra is not yet large enough to establish any clear correlations between stellar and x - ray properties .
other factors such as uncertain distances , bolometric luminosities , and mass - loss parameters hinder correlation studies and can mask dependencies
. however , x - ray observations now span the full range of spectral subtypes from wn2 to wn9 and a few notable trends are beginning to emerge .
as figure 8 shows , there is an apparent falloff in l@xmath14 toward later wn7 - 9 subtypes .
the wn9 ha star wr 79a has the lowest l@xmath14 of any detected single wn star so far . and , the wn8h star wr 40 was undetected in a previous _ xmm - newton _ observation at an upper limit log l@xmath14 @xmath0 31.6 ergs s@xmath9 ( gosset et al . 2005 ) .
this upper limit is a factor of 3.5 below the l@xmath14 determined from the detection of wr 79a .
figure 8 also includes upper limits for wr 16 ( wn8h ) and wr 78 ( wn7h ) based on short - exposure _ rosat _ pspc archive images . since _
rosat _ was not sensitive to hotter plasma above @xmath132.5 kev , which is likely present , the pspc upper limits should be considered tentative until observations spanning a broader x - ray bandpass can be obtained .
the apparent decrease in l@xmath14 for wn7 - 9 subtypes is surprising because it is in the opposite sense of l@xmath3 , which is larger for wn7 - 9 stars than wn2 - 6 stars ( table 1 ; hamann et al .
2006 ; crowther 2007 ) .
we plot l@xmath14 versus l@xmath3 in figure 9 .
this figure clearly illustrates that even though the wn and wc stars observed to date have similar l@xmath3 , the wc stars ( all undetected ) are at least 1 - 2 orders of magnitude less luminous in x - rays . considering only the detected wn stars , one might be tempted to argue for a weak increase in l@xmath14 with l@xmath3 .
but , the absence of x - ray detections for three wnl stars with high l@xmath3 ( wr 16 , 40 , 78 ) is clearly at odds with this picture .
this result is contrary to the trend seen in ob stars , for which l@xmath14 generally increases with l@xmath3 , albeit with large scatter ( berghffer et al . 1997 ) .
thus , some other stellar parameters besides l@xmath3 are critical for determining x - ray luminosity levels in these wn stars , and wind properties may play a key role .
the classical theory of hot star winds in the exospheric approximation predicts that l@xmath14 @xmath71 ( @xmath48/v@xmath7)@xmath72 where s = 1 for optically thin winds and @xmath73 @xmath0 @xmath74 @xmath0 0 for optically thick winds ( owocki & cohen 1999 ) . the existing wn star data do not show any clear increase in l@xmath14 with @xmath48/v@xmath7 . on the contrary , wr 79a is the least luminous x - ray source amongst the new detections , but has the largest @xmath48/v@xmath7 . from the standpoint of observations ,
an increase in l@xmath14 with wind kinetic energy would seem to be more promising . in figure 10 , we plot l@xmath14 versus l@xmath75 = ( 1/2)@xmath48v@xmath76 for several wn stars for which good x - ray ccd spectra are available . despite uncertainties in @xmath48 , v@xmath7 , and distances
, there is a noticeable increase in l@xmath14 toward higher values of l@xmath75 for the stars considered in this study .
a notable outlier is wr 136 , which is underluminous in x - rays by at least a factor of @xmath85 compared to the other wn6 stars ( fig .
8) and also has a low l@xmath14 for its wind luminosity ( fig .
we have assumed d = 1.64 kpc for wr 136 based on its _ hipparcos _ parallax .
other distance estimates are less ( e.g. d = 1.26 kpc , vdh01 ) , so a distance underestimate is not likely to be responsbile for its lower l@xmath14 .
one way to correct for the low l@xmath14 is to postulate very cool undetected plasma ( kt @xmath0 0.2 kev ) that is masked by absorption
. if such plasma is present , then values log l@xmath14 @xmath1 32.0 ergs s@xmath9 are possible .
equally interesting is the non - detection of wr 40 in x - rays .
this is an important result because it has a slow terminal wind speed v@xmath7 = 650 - 840 km s@xmath9 ( hamann et al .
2006 ; gosset et al . 2005 ) and thus a high average wind density .
this may be a clue that x - ray emission ceases to be efficient ( or becomes totally absorbed by the wind ) in wn stars with slow dense winds .
x - ray observations of a larger sample of single wn stars spanning a broader range of mass - loss parameters are needed to firmly establish any dependencies between l@xmath14 and wind parameters .
observations of more wnl stars with slow winds ( v@xmath7 @xmath0 1000 km s@xmath9 ) would be particularly useful .
previous x - ray studies have shown that several wr @xmath11 ob or wr @xmath11 wr binaries have very high x - ray luminosities with typical values log l@xmath14 @xmath6 33.0 ergs s@xmath9 .
early evidence for this was found from _ einstein _
observations of wr stars .
the median x - ray luminosity of seven wn binaries detected by _ einstein _ was log l@xmath14(0.2 - 4 kev ) = 32.92 ergs s@xmath9 , with a range of 32.76 - 33.53 ergs s@xmath9 ( pollock 1987 ) .
more recent work has confirmed high x - ray luminosities in other wn binary systems . for example , _ xmm - newton _ observations of the wn8 @xmath11 ob system wr 147 gave log l@xmath14(0.5 - 10 kev ) = 32.83 ergs s@xmath9 ( skinner et al .
observation of the massive wn binary system wr 20a in westerlund 2 yielded log l@xmath14 = 33.69 ergs s@xmath9 based on 1 t spectral fits ( naz et al .
our analysis of the wr 20a _ chandra _ data with 2 t @xmath27 models gives even higher values log l@xmath14(0.3 - 8 kev ) @xmath1 34.0 ergs s@xmath9 for d @xmath1 2.37 kpc .
the closely - spaced wn5
@xmath11 o6 binary v444 cyg (= wr 139 ) is also worthy of mention because of its short @xmath134.2 d orbital period .
_ asca _ observations show that its x - ray luminosity varies with orbital phase , reaching maximum values log l@xmath14(0.7 - 10 kev ) @xmath1 33.1 ergs s@xmath9 for an assumed distance of 1.7 kpc ( maeda et al .
1999 ) .
thus , there is no doubt that _ some _ wr binaries are x - ray luminous .
but , are _ all _ wr binaries x - ray luminous
? we do not yet know the answer to that question because it can be very difficult to distinguish a closely - spaced binary from a single wr star .
it is very likely that some wr stars currently classified as single objects are in fact close unresolved binaries .
also , a high x - ray luminosity is not strictly required in a colliding wind wr binary system . for an adiabatic colliding wind system
the luminosity scales roughly as l@xmath14 @xmath71 @xmath77@xmath78d@xmath9 where @xmath48 and @xmath79 are the mass - loss rate and wind - speed of the dominant component and d is the binary separation ( luo et al .
1990 ; stevens et al . 1992 ) .
binaries with lower mass - loss rates or wide separations are expected to have lower l@xmath14 , all other factors being equal .
based on the above , which wn stars in our sample are good binary candidates ?
wr 24 would appear to be a very good candidate because of absorption lines in its optical spectrum ( vdh01 ) and its high l@xmath14 and l@xmath3 .
in fact , its position in the ( l@xmath3,l@xmath14 ) diagram is almost identical to that of the known binary wr 147 ( fig .
wr 20b is also a good candidate because of its exceptionally high x - ray luminosity , even when computed using the lowest current distance estimate of d = 2.37 kpc .
searches for close companions in these two stars are certainly justified .
apart from wr 20b and wr 24 , there are no other stars in our sample having high log l@xmath14 @xmath6 33.0 ergs s@xmath9 that could signal binarity . a particularly interesting case is wr 79a ( wn9 ha ) .
this star would seem to be a good candidate for binarity based on absorption lines in its spectrum and the possible presence of nonthermal radio emission ( cappa et al .
but its x - ray luminosity log l@xmath14 = 32.14 ergs s@xmath9 is at the low end of the detected wn stars .
if wr 79a is indeed a binary then its l@xmath14 is much less than other known wn binaries , or its distance has been underestimated .
wr 134 is another intriguing example . based on its known 2.25 day spectroscopic variability
it would seem to rank as a strong binary candidate . as noted in section 4.4 ,
the high temperature of its hot x - ray component is indeed consistent with that expected if the wind of wr 134 were shocking onto a companion at terminal speed .
but there are questions as to whether the x - rays could escape if produced in a closely - spaced colliding wind binary system , and the x - ray luminosity of wr 134 ( log l@xmath14 = 32.66 ergs s@xmath9 ) is not as high as other known wn binaries .
thus , the existing x - ray data for wr 134 do not provide an indisputable case for binarity . further observations of wr 134 aimed at determining whether its x - ray emission is modulated at the 2.25 day optical period would be useful since colliding wind binaries such as @xmath10 velorum and wr 140 do show orbital x - ray modulation ( willis , schild , & stevens 1995 ; zhekov & skinner 2000 ; pollock et al . 2005 ) .
our pilot survey has so far detected all four wn stars observed .
in contrast , x - ray observations at similar sensitivity levels did not detect any of the four wc stars in our sample , and a fifth went undetected in another _ xmm - newton _ program ( sec . 1 ) .
why is it that most wn stars are detected as x - ray sources , but wc stars are not ?
an important clue to solving this puzzle may lie in the excess x - ray absorption seen in the spectra of most of the wn stars ( sec .
such excess absorption has been seen in other wn stars such as wr 6 ( wn4 ; skinner et al .
the wind is likely responsible for most of this excess .
x - rays produced within the wind must overcome the wind opacity to escape , and the opacity increases toward lower photon energies , all other factors being equal .
thus , softer x - ray photons will be more heavily absorbed and the softest photons detected will have emerged from the wind at large distances from the star .
the wind opacity in wc stars is much higher than in wn stars due to metal - enrichment . for a given set of mass - loss parameters ,
x - rays of a given energy will have more difficulty escaping a wc wind than a wn wind . as a specific example
, we consider a generic wr star with a typical mass - loss rate of @xmath48 = 2 @xmath21 10@xmath22 m@xmath50 yr@xmath9 and v@xmath7 = 1800 km s@xmath9 .
adopting canonical wn and wc abundances ( vcw86 ) and bm92 cross - sections , the radius of optical depth unity for an x - ray photon of energy e = 1 kev is @xmath813 times greater for a wc star than for a wn star . even at higher energies
e = 3 kev the r@xmath49 ratio is still a factor of @xmath811 . thus ,
unless x - rays of moderate energy e @xmath13 1 - 3 kev are formed very far out in the wind of a wc star ( at thousands of solar radii ) they will be absorbed .
this is perhaps the most plausible explanation for the absence of wc star x - ray detections at present . but
a larger sample of wc stars needs to be observed in order to determine if hard x - rays might escape through the wind in some cases .
the best candidates for such observations would be wc stars with higher t@xmath80 and lower wind densities ( lower @xmath48 and higher v@xmath7 ) , which would conspire to reduce wind opacity .
the most important results of this study are the following : 1 .
x - ray emission has been detected from four recently - observed wn stars ranging in spectral type from wn2 - wn9 , none of which is so far known to be a binary system .
archive data provide detections for an additional three wn6h stars .
it is thus now established that both wne and wnl stars are x - ray sources .
the spectra of all stars are similar .
all show an admixture of cool ( kt@xmath16 @xmath0 1 kev ) and hot ( kt @xmath1 2 kev ) x - ray plasma and prominent emission lines from ions such as si xiii and s xv .
x - ray luminosities are typically log l@xmath14 @xmath8 32.5 ergs s@xmath9 , but there is a rather large scatter of @xmath461 dex around this value . some of this scatter is likely due to uncertain distances for many wr stars .
most of the detected wn stars show x - ray absorption in excess of that expected from published a@xmath2 estimates ( wr 2 being an exception ) .
a plausible explanation for the excess absorption is that the x - rays are formed within the wind and are strongly absorbed by the wind at lower energies .
the presence of high - temperature plasma in supposedly single wn stars is not predicted by radiative wind shock models .
other mechanisms are thus required to explain the hotter plasma .
close companion models are not clearly justified given the lack of evidence for binarity .
magnetic wind confinement models provide some promise , but the presence of magnetic fields in wr stars has so far not been demonstrated .
further theoretical work is needed to develop models that can account for such hot plasma .
although the sample of wn stars observed in x - rays is small , there is a noticeable trend toward lower l@xmath14 in the later wn7 - 9 subtypes .
this is in the opposite sense of l@xmath3 , which increases toward later wn7 - 9 subtypes .
thus , other factors besides l@xmath3 determine x - ray luminosity in single wn stars .
wind properties appear to be important , and sensitive x - ray observations of a broader sample of wn stars , particularly at low terminal wind speeds , are needed to determine if l@xmath14 depends on wind parameters .
this work was supported by _
award go8 - 9008x issued by the chandra x - ray observatory center ( cxc ) and by nasa / gsfc award nnx09ar25 g .
the cxc is operated by the smithsonian astrophysical observatory ( sao ) for , and on behalf of , the national aeronautics space administration under contract nas8 - 03060 .
we acknowledge use of _ chandra _ archive data for wr 24 obtained in a guaranteed time observation ( gto obdid 9482 , pi g. garmire ) .
this observation was part of a larger _ chandra _ acis survey of the carina nebula ( chandra carina complex project ; pi : l. townsley ) .
this work was partially based on observations obtained with xmm - newton , an esa science mission with instruments and contributions directly funded by esa member states and the usa ( nasa ) .
sz acknowledges financial support from bulgarian national science fund grant do-02 - 85 .
llcccccc wr 2 & wn2 & 2.51 & 1.58 & 3200 & @xmath152.0 & 0.89 & 5.45 wr 18 & wn4 & 2.20 & 2.63 & 1800 & 2.5 & 1.49 & 5.50 wr 79a & wn9 ha & 1.99 & 1.28 & 955 & 2.4 & 33.1 & 5.78 wr 134 & wn6 & 1.74 & 1.52 & 1820 & 4.0 & 5.29 & 5.60 wr 16 & wn8h & 2.37 & 1.80 & 650 & 5.0 & 19.9 & 6.15 wr 20b & wn6h & @xmath392.37 & 6.08 & ... & ... & ... & 5.86 wr 24 & wn6 ha & 3.24 & 0.56 & 2160 & 4.0 & 19.9 & 6.35 wr 78 & wn7h & 1.99 & 1.50 & 1385 & 5.0 & 16.7 & 6.20 wr 136 & wn6h & 1.64 & 1.73 & 1600 & 3.2 & 3.3 & 5.40 lllll date & 2008 june 30 & 2008 oct 29 & 2008 feb 10 & 2009 aug 30 obsid & 8943 & 8910 & 8909 & 0602020101 start time ( tt ) & 06:17:17 & 16:59:38 & 10:23:29 & 01:44:03 stop time ( tt ) & 11:17:51 & 23:06:05 & 16:31:11 & 11:59:17 exposure ( s ) & 15,444 & 19,684 & 19,301 & 35,033 ( pn ) , 36,617 ( per mos ) instrument & acis - s & acis - s & acis - s & epic frametime ( s ) & 3.1 & 3.1 & 0.9 & 0.073 ( pn ) , 2.6 ( mos ) llllllll + wr 2 & 01 05 23.05 & + 60 25 18.9 & 247@xmath4616 & [email protected] & 1.04 & 0.68 ( 0.92 ) & hst j010523.02 + 602518.9 ( 0.22 ) + wr 18 & 10 17 02.26 & -57 54 46.8 & 167@xmath4613 & [email protected] & 1.67 & 0.99 ( 0.91 ) & hst [email protected] ( 0.19 ) + wr 79a & 16 54 58.52 & -41 09 02.9 & 805@xmath4629 & [email protected] & 1.35 & 0.63 ( ... ) & hst [email protected] ( 0.30 ) + wr 134 & 20 10 14.19 & + 36 10 35.1 & 785@xmath4628 & [email protected] & 1.90 & 0.95 ( 0.95 ) & hst j201014.19 + 361035.1 ( 0.00 ) + + wr 20b & 10 24 18.39 & -57 48 29.9 & 643@xmath4626 & [email protected] & 3.04 & 0.24 ( 0.93 ) & hst [email protected] ( 0.26 ) + wr 24 & 10 43 52.24 & -60 07 04.2 & 1419@xmath4639 & [email protected] & 1.66 & 0.67 ( 0.97 ) & hst [email protected] ( 0.18 ) + wr 136 & 20 12 06.56 & + 38 21 18.2 & 238@xmath4617 & [email protected] & 1.96 & 0.99 ( 0.93 ) & hst [email protected] ( 0.46 ) + lllll star & wr 2 & wr 18 & wr 134 & wr79a model & 2 t vapec & 2 t vapec & 2 t vapec & 2 t vapec abundances & wn & wn & wn & wnn@xmath30 ( 10@xmath44 @xmath36 ) & 0.44 [ 0.08 - 0.99 ] & 1.37 [ 0.72 - 1.86 ] & 1.19 [ 0.83 - 1.45 ] & 0.75 [ 0.64 - 0.83 ] kt@xmath16 ( kev ) & 0.32 [ 0.24 - 0.45 ] & 0.65 [ 0.43 - 0.82 ] & 0.62 [ 0.53 - 0.71 ] & 0.55 [ 0.46 - 0.61 ] norm@xmath16 ( 10@xmath81 ) & 1.73 [ 0.99 - 70.0 ] & 2.24 [ 0.45 - 7.85 ] & 1.47 [ 0.34 - 3.70 ] & 2.04 [ 1.39 - 3.16 ] kt@xmath17 ( kev ) & @xmath392.6 & 3.51 [ 1.86 - ... ] & 8.57 [ 5.74 - 17.2 ] & 2.66 [ 1.66 - 5.60 ] norm@xmath17 ( 10@xmath81 ) & 0.56 [ 0.14 - 0.89 ] & 0.85 [ 0.33 - 1.48 ] & 3.75 [ 1.66 - 5.04 ] & 0.47 [ 0.27 - 0.73 ] @xmath31/dof & 17.2/14 & 4.0/7 & 57.6/56 & 46.4/48 @xmath82 & 1.23 & 0.57 & 1.03 & 0.97 f@xmath14 ( 10@xmath83 ergs @xmath36 s@xmath9 ) & 0.86 ( 4.56 ) & 0.58 ( 4.87 ) & 4.36 ( 12.5 ) & 0.64 ( 2.94 ) f@xmath56 ( 10@xmath83 ergs @xmath36 s@xmath9 ) & 0.37 ( 3.96 ) & 0.22 ( 4.16 ) & 0.68 ( 7.20 ) & 0.41 ( 2.53 ) log l@xmath14 ( ergs s@xmath9 ) & 32.54 & 32.45 & 32.66 & 32.14 log [ l@xmath14/l@xmath3 ] & @xmath456.49 & @xmath456.63 & @xmath456.52 & @xmath457.22 log [ l@xmath14/l@xmath57 & @[email protected] & @xmath454.96 & @xmath454.96 & @xmath454.70 n@xmath30/n@xmath43 & 1.3 [ 0.2 - 2.8 ] & 2.3 [ 1.2 - 3.2 ] & 3.5 [ 2.5 - 4.3 ] & 2.6 [ 2.2 - 2.9 ] llll star & wr 20b & wr 24 & wr 136 model & 2 t vapec & 2 t vapec & 2 t vapec abundances & wn & wn & wn n@xmath85 ( 10@xmath44 @xmath36 ) & 3.92 [ 2.96 - 7.45 ] & 0.82 [ 0.43 - 1.06 ] & 0.49 [ 0.36 - 0.72 ] kt@xmath16 ( kev ) & 0.44 [ 0.28 - 0.75 ] & 0.70 [ 0.64 - 0.83 ] & 0.56 [ 0.33 - 0.73 ] norm@xmath16 ( 10@xmath81 ) & 54.6 [ 24.9 - 76.0 ] & 5.61 [ 1.63 - 8.88 ] & 20.3 [ 10.2 - 103 . ] n@xmath86 ( 10@xmath44 @xmath36 ) & ... & ... & 3.98 [ 1.63 - 7.41 ] kt@xmath17 ( kev ) & 5.43 [ 3.16 - 9.09 ] & 3.33 [ 2.48 - 4.83 ] & 2.64 [ 1.53 - 18.0 ] norm@xmath17 ( 10@xmath81 ) & 5.56 [ 4.46 - 8.23 ] & 3.22 [ 2.32 - 4.36 ] & 87.0 [ 59.8 - 205 . ] @xmath31/dof & 55.6/50 & 110.2/99 & 49.6/46 @xmath82 & 1.11 & 1.11 & 1.08 f@xmath14 ( 10@xmath83 ergs @xmath36 s@xmath9 ) & 2.27 ( 60.6 ) & 2.51 ( 7.95 ) & 0.29 ( 1.02 ) f@xmath56 ( 10@xmath83 ergs @xmath36 s@xmath9 ) & 0.32 ( 56.0 ) & 1.10 ( 5.45 ) & 0.07 ( 0.27 ) log l@xmath14 ( ergs s@xmath9 ) & @xmath3933.57 & 33.0 & 31.51 n@xmath85/n@xmath43 & 2.9 [ 2.2 - 5.5 ] & 6.6 [ 3.5 - 8.5 ] & 1.3 [ 0.9 - 1.9 ] n@xmath86/n@xmath43 & ... & ... & 10.4 [ 4.2 - 19.3 ] abbott , d.c . ,
bieging , j.h . , churchwell , e. , & torres , a.v .
1986 , , 303 , 239 anders , e. , & ebihara , m. 1982 , , 46 , 2363 anders , e. , & grevesse , n. 1989 , , 53 , 197 arnal , e.m . ,
cappa , c.e . ,
rizzo , j.r .
, & cichowolski , s. 1999 , , 118 , 1798 babel , j. & montmerle , t. , 1997 , , 323 , 121 baluciska - church , m. & mccammon , d. 1992 , , 400 , 699 ( bm92 ) baum , e. , hamann , w .- r . ,
koesterke , l. & wessolowski , u. 1992 , , 266 , 402 berghfer , t.w . ,
schmitt , j.h.m.m . ,
danner , r. , & cassinelli , j.p . , 1997 , , 322 , 167 bieging , j.h . ,
abbott , d.c . , & churchwell , e.b . , 1989 , , 340 , 518 bochkarev , n.g . 1988 , , 332 , 518 borkowski , k.j . ,
lyerly , w.j . , & reynolds , s.p .
2001 , , 548 , 820 cappa , c. , goss , w.m .
, & van der hucht , k.a .
2004 , , 127 , 2885 cassinelli , j.p . , miller , n.a . , waldron , w.a .
, macfarlane , j.j .
, & cohen , d.h . , 2001 , , 554 , l55 chu , y .- h . ,
gruendl , r.a . , & guerrero , m.a .
2006 , in the x - ray universe 2005 ( esa sp-604 ) , ed .
a. wilson , 363 chu , y .- h . , treffers , r.r .
, & kwitter , k.b .
1983 , , 53 , 937 cohen , d.h . ,
kuhn , m.a .
, gagn , m. , jensen , e.l.n . , & miller , n.a .
2008 , 386 , 1855 crowther , p.a .
2007 , , 45 , 177 crowther , p.a . & bohannan , b. 1997 , , 317 , 532 davidson , k. & ostriker , j.p . 1973 , ,
179 , 585 dyson , j.e . & ghanbari , j. 1989 , , 226 , 270 feldmeier , a. , kudritzki .
p . , palsa , r. pauldrach , a.w.a . , & puls , j. , 1997 , , 320 , 899 firmani , c. , koenigsberger , g. , bisiacchi , g.f . ,
moffat , a.f.j . , & isserstedt , j. 1980 , , 239 , 607 gayley , k.g . &
owocki , s.p . , 1995 , , 446 , 801 gorenstein , p. 1975
, , 198 , 95 gosset , e. , naz , y. , claeskens , j .- f . , rauw , g. , vreux , j
.- m . , & sana , h. 2005 , , 429 , 685 gregory , p.c . & loredo , t.j .
1992 , , 398 , 146 gregory , p.c .
& loredo , t.j .
1996 , , 473 , 1059 gruendl , r.a . , chu , y .- h . , dunne , b.c . , & points , s.d . 2000 , , 120 , 2670 gruendl , r.a . ,
guerrero , m.a .
, & chu , y .- h . 2003 , baas , 35 , 746 hamann , w .- r . ,
grfener , g. & liermann , a. 2006 , , 457 , 1015 howarth , i.d . & schmutz , w. 1992 , , 261 , 503 ignace , r. , cassinelli , j.p . ,
quigley , m. , & babler , b. 2001 , , 558 , 771 ignace , r. , oskinova , l.m . , & brown , j.c .
2003a , , 408 , 353 ignace , r. , quigley , m.f . , & cassinelli , j.p .
2003b , , 596 , 538 kahn , s.m .
et al . , 2001 , , 365 , l312 lpine ,
s. et al . 2000 , , 120 , 3201 lipunov , v.m .
1982 , sov .
, 8 , 194 lommen , d. , yungelson , l. , van den heuvel , e. , nelemans , g. , & zwart , s.p .
2005 , , 443 , 231 lucy , l.b . , 1982 , , 255 , 286 lucy , l.b . & white , r.l . , 1980 , , 241 , 300 luo , d. , mccray , r. , & maclow , m - m . , 1990 , , 362 , 267 maeda , y. , koyama , k. , yokogawa , j. , & skinner , s. 1999 , , 510 , 967 marston , a.p . 2001 , , 563 , 875 marston , a.p . 2003 , in _ a massive star odyssey , from main sequence to supernova _
( iau symp .
212 ) , eds .
van der hucht , a. herrero , & c. estaban ( san francisco : asp ) , 732 mason , b.d .
gies , d.r . , hartkopf , w.i . ,
bagnuolo , w.g . ,
brummelaar , t.t . , & mcalister , h.a .
1998 , , 115 , 821 miller , g.j . & chu , y .- h .
1993 , , 85 , 137 miller , n.a . ,
cassinelli , j.p . , waldron , w.l . , macfarlane , j.j . , & cohen , d.h .
2002 , , 577 , 951 moffat , a.f.j . , drissen , l. , lamontagne , r. , & robert , c. 1988 , , 334 , 1038 morel , t. et al .
1999 , , 518 , 428 morrison , r. & mccammon , d. 1983 , , 270 , 119 naz , y. , rauw , g. , & manfroid , j. 2008 , , 483 , 171 oskinova , l.m .
2005 , , 361 , 679 oskinova , l.m . ,
ignace , r. , hamann , w .- r . , pollock , a.m.t . , & brown , j.c .
2003 , , 402 , 755 owocki , s.p . , castor , j.i .
, & rybicki , g.b . , 1988 , , 335 , 914 owocki , s.p .
& cohen , d.h .
2001 , , 559 , 1108 owocki , s.p . & cohen , d.h .
1999 , , 520 , 833 pollock , a.m.t .
1987 , , 320 , 283 pollock , a.m.t . ,
corcoran , m.f . , stevens , i.r . , & williams , p.m. 2005 , , 629 , 482 press , w.h . , teukolsky , s.a . , vetterling , w.t . , & flannery , b.p .
1992 , numerical recipes in fortran : the art of scientific computing ( 2nd ed . ; new york : cambridge univ .
press ) , 617 prilutskii , o.f . &
usov , v.v .
1976 , , 20 , 2 robert , c. 1994 , , 221 , 137 schild , h. et al .
2004 , , 422 , 177 schmutz , w. 1997 , , 321 , 268 schmutz , w. , geballe , t.r . , & schild , h. 1996 , , 311 , l25 schulte - ladbeck , r.e . ,
nordsieck , k.h . ,
taylor , m. , bjorkman , k.s . , magalhaes , a.m. , & wolff , m.j .
1992 , , 387 , 347 schulz , n.s . , canizares , c.r .
, huenemoerder , d. , & lee , j.c . , 2000 , , 545 , l135 seward , f.d . ,
forman , w.r .
, giacconi , r. , griffiths , r.e . ,
harnden , f.r . ,
jones , c. , & pye , j.p .
1979 , , 234 , 55 skinner , s.l . ,
gdel , m. , schmutz , w. , & stevens , i.r . , 2001 , , 558 , l113 skinner , s.l . ,
gdel , m. , schmutz , w. , & zhekov , s. 2006 , astrophys .
space sci .
, 304 , 97 skinner , s.l . ,
sokal , k.r . ,
cohen , d.h . ,
gagn , m. , owocki , s.p . , & townsend , r.h .
2008 , , 683 , 796 skinner , s.l . ,
zhekov , s. , gdel , m. , & schmutz , w. 2002a , , 572 , 477 skinner , s.l . ,
zhekov , s. , gdel , m. , & schmutz , w. 2002b , , 579 , 764 skinner , s.l . ,
zhekov , s. , gdel , m. , & schmutz , w. 2007 , , 378 , 1491 skinner , s.l . ,
zhekov , s. , gdel , m. , & schmutz , w. , & sokal , k. 2009 , baas , 41 , 470 smith , r.k . ,
brickhouse , n.s . ,
liedahl , d.a . , & raymond , j.c .
2001 , , 556 , l91 stevens , i.r . ,
blondin , j.m . , & pollock , a.m.t . , 1992 , , 386 , 265 st .-
louis , n. , chen , a .-
, schnurr , o. , & nicol , m .- h .
2009 , , in press strder , l. et al . , 2001 , , 365 , l18 turner , m.j.l .
et al . , 2001 , , 365 , l27 ud - doula , a. & owocki , s.p . , 2002 , , 576 , 413 usov , v.v . 1992 , , 389 , 635 van den heuvel , e.p.j
& de loore , c. 1973 , , 25 , 387 van der hucht , k.a . , 2001 ,
, 45 , 135 ( vdh01 ) van der hucht , k.a . ,
cassinelli , j.p .
, & williams , p.m. , 1986 , , 168 , 111 ( vcw86 ) van der hucht , k.a . , williams , p.m. , & th , p.s
1987 , , 28 , 254 waldron , w. & cassinelli , j.p . , 2009 , , 692 , l76 willis , a.j . ,
schild , h. , & stevens , i.r .
1995 , , 298 , 549 zhekov , s.a . & skinner , s.l .
2000 , , 538 , 808 | we summarize new x - ray detections of four nitrogen - type wolf - rayet ( wr ) stars obtained in a limited survey aimed at establishing the x - ray properties of wn stars across their full range of spectral subtypes .
none of the detected stars is so far known to be a close binary .
we report _ chandra _ detections of wr 2 ( wn2 ) , wr 18 ( wn4 ) , and wr 134 ( wn6 ) , and an _ xmm - newton _ detection of wr79a ( wn9 ha ) .
these observations clearly demonstrate that both wne and wnl stars are x - ray sources .
we also discuss _ chandra _ archive detections of the wn6h stars wr 20b , wr 24 , and wr 136 and _ rosat _ non - detections of wr 16 ( wn8h ) and wr 78 ( wn7h ) .
the x - ray spectra of all wn detections show prominent emission lines and an admixture of cool ( kt @xmath0 1 kev ) and hot ( kt @xmath1 2 kev ) plasma .
the hotter plasma is not predicted by radiative wind shock models and other as yet unidentified mechanisms are at work .
most stars show x - ray absorption in excess of that expected from visual extinction ( a@xmath2 ) , likely due to their strong winds or cold circumstellar gas .
existing data suggest a falloff in x - ray luminosity toward later wn7 - 9 subtypes , which have higher l@xmath3 but slower , denser winds than wn2 - 6 stars .
this provides a clue that wind properties may be a more crucial factor in determining emergent x - ray emission levels than bolometric luminosity . |
there is great interest in understanding the phase structure of quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) .
there are various regions of the @xmath2 phase diagram ( @xmath3 is temperature and @xmath4 is a chemical potential for baryon number ) which are extremely hard to model theoretically using traditional field theory techniques .
some of these regimes are being probed experimentally , and so there is additional interest in obtaining better theoretical understanding from an immediate phenomenological point of view . for almost a decade , progress in understanding the dynamics of extended objects in string theory has enabled several new techniques and a fresh and powerful new perspective to be brought to the study of strongly coupled gauge theory .
the techniques were sharpened further ( for large number of colours , @xmath1 , ) with holographic examples such as the ads / cft correspondence , and the study of gauge / gravity duals ( or , more properly , gauge / string duals ) has proven to be a fruitful and often elegant pursuit .
not long after the birth of ads / cft@xcite , where the finite temperature phase structure of @xmath5 @xmath0 ( at large @xmath1 ) was understood in terms of the thermodynamics of schwarzschild black holes in ads@xcite , it was recognized@xcite that progress could be made in understading the properties of gauge theories in the presence of a global current , akin to a chemical potential for baryon number or isospin , by studying the physics of charged black holes , such as riessner
nordstrom@xcite , or more general charged black holes with non
trivial scalars@xcite , in ads . the resulting @xmath6 or @xmath7 phase diagrams ( where @xmath8 is conjugate to @xmath9the analogue of baryon number ) of the @xmath5 guage theory were found to be rather rich , with _
e.g. , _ a first order phase transition line , and even a second order critical point in the @xmath7 plane@xcite .
this led to the hope that such studies might lead to insights into the physics of the qcd phase diagram .
the idea is that studies of the effect of the global @xmath10 symmetry even though it is not exactly baryon number might lead to physics in the same universality class as the more realistic gauge theories , giving insight into qcd at finite temperature and density .
a more firm footing for this idea should be obtained by the study of those dynamics in the presence of fundamental flavours of quark , a key feature of qcd that distinguishes it from the @xmath5 gauge theory ( which of course only has adjoint matter of very specific types and quantities allowed by supersymmetry ) . while it is notoriously difficult to study this problem as a string dual so far it is known@xcite how to place fundamental flavours into the theory , in the limit @xmath11 .
this is a sort of `` quenched '' limit where the quarks feel the gauge dynamics but whose presence does not effect the physics ( _ i.e. , _ the quarks do not back react ) .
while this limit can not capture a great deal of detailed qcd physics , it is hoped that it may well provide valuable clues in the study of the phase structure and will certainly be an instructive step along the path to fully understanding the case of fully interacting dynamical quarks .
the global symmetries in question in the case of the @xmath5 theory live in the @xmath12 subgroup of the large @xmath13 r symmetry enjoyed by the theory . in the string
dual this corresponds to that fact that the d3branes ( on whose worldvolume the gauge theory resides ) have an @xmath14 transverse to them , in the decoupling limit that gives the ads / cft duality , they correspond to a subset of the @xmath15 isometries of the explicit @xmath16 of the ads@xmath17 spacetime where the dual string theory propagates .
fundamental dynamical quarks enter the story as d7brane probes of the geometry . the @xmath5 supersymmetry is now replaced by @xmath18 and the quarks lie in hypermultiplets .
the @xmath14 now breaks into an @xmath19 transverse to both the d3branes and the d7branes , and an @xmath20 transverse to the d3branes , but internal to the d7branes . in the probe limit in question , the quarks are the ends of the strings stretching from the d7branes to the d3branes , their masses being set by the distance between the two sets of branes in the @xmath19 . in the decoupling limit ( where the @xmath1 d branes have been replaced by ads@xmath17 geometry ) , the location in the plane transverse to the d7brane controls the quark mass and a condensate of quarks , according to@xcite : @xmath21
where @xmath22 ( the bare quark mass ) and @xmath23 ( the quark condensate ) , @xmath24 is a radial coordinate in the decoupling limit , and @xmath25 in this paper .
the condensate actually breaks the @xmath10 symmetry corresponding to rotations in the @xmath19 , that acts chirally on the @xmath26 fields .
we explored the allowed values of the condensate @xmath27 as a function of quark mass @xmath28 at finite temperature @xmath3 ( where supersymmetry is broken ) , and with the system charged an amount @xmath8 under a global @xmath10 current .
we did two cases .
the first is the chiral current associated with rotations transverse to the d7branes , and the second is a @xmath10 that mixes transverse and parallel rotations .
we found a rich structure , upon which we will report in this paper .
we found that there are generalizations of the first order phase transition already observed ( and extensively studied , see refs.@xcite ) at @xmath29 for this case .
in addition , we found that at finite @xmath8 a new phase appears where there is a non zero condensate at zero quark mass @xmath28 .
this is an example of spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking in the presence of an analogue of finite fixed baryon number or isospin charge .
we study the meson spectrum of our model and identify the massless `` pions '' ( it is really a slight misnomer see ref.@xcite ) which play the role of the goldstone bosons of the chiral symmetry breaking .
we study the behaviour of the pion mass as a function of quark mass @xmath28 and find that it obeys the gell - mann oakes
renner relation@xcite .
crucially , we also verify that away from the range of @xmath8 where the symmetry breaking is present , the meson has no massless particle at @xmath30 , confirming our identification .
to source subgroups of the @xmath31 global symmetries corresponding to rotations in the transverse @xmath14 , we consider d3branes with angular momentum .
the supergravity description / metric for spinning d3branes is@xcite : @xmath32 where : @xmath33 in order to explore the decoupling limit ( @xmath34 ) , which we are interested in , we define : @xmath35 such that : @xmath36 with these definitions , in the decoupling limit , the metric is : @xmath37 where we have defined : @xmath38 there are two different cases that we consider : 1 . a single charge in the @xmath39 direction : @xmath40 and @xmath41 .
this case is a useful test case since it is the simplest problem to explore and provides valuable insight into the next , more complicated case .
2 . three equal charges : @xmath42 .
this case is of greater interest since the supergravity metric , upon compactification , corresponds to the ads
reissner nordstrom black hole@xcite ( the previous case gives charged black holes with an extra scalar field excited@xcite ) .
for the single charge case , we choose @xmath40 and @xmath41 in equation ( [ eqt : decoupled spinning brane metric ] ) , and the metric becomes : @xmath43 where @xmath44 although there is a change of variables that allows us to rewrite this metric in a more conventional form , it will be computationally convenient to work with the metric in equation ( [ eqt : single charge metric ] ) . in order to introduce dynamical quarks into our gauge theory ,
we probe the geometry with d7branes @xcite .
we choose the coordinates @xmath45 to be the transverse coordinates to the d7brane .
however , we will define radial coordinates in the @xmath46subspace transverse to the d3 branes via : @xmath47 although these radial coordinates are not transverse to each other , the non - zero @xmath48 component of the metric vanishes at the asymptotic boundary .
therefore , by expanding : @xmath49 we can still make sense of the coefficient @xmath28 as being the asymptotic separation of the d3 and d7 branes .
this will allow us to extract the bare quark mass and the condensate value .
it should be noted however that , unlike the zero charge case considered in refs.@xcite , we can not directly identify the coefficient @xmath50 with the quark condensate . the correct identification can be made after an appropriate change of variables that restores the @xmath16 symmetry of the geometry at the asymptotic boundary .
we will explicitly show this later .
we choose an ansatz @xmath51 and @xmath52 . with these choices ,
the worldvolume of the d7brane is given by : @xmath53 from here , we see that the worldvolume goes to zero for two particular cases : 1 .
this case is akin to the karch - katz like solutions described in ref.@xcite .
2 . @xmath55 .
this is akin to the condensate solutions described in ref.@xcite .
note the absolute value sign in ( [ eqt : single charge worldvolume ] ) .
this means that although the world volume goes to zero at this point , the d7brane does not actually end there .
the vanishing is a result of the coordinates we are using ; the d7brane continues through and terminates on the event horizon defined by @xmath56 .
we are only interested in d7brane embeddings that are smooth ( no kinks ) across this locus , as they correspond to the lowest energy solutions .
this condition of smoothness , which has only been checked numerically , is only satisfied for a particular boundary condition for our scalar fields on this locus , which we describe below .
we solve the equation of motion for @xmath57 numerically using a shooting technique .
we use @xmath58 @xmath59 @xmath60 and @xmath61 throughout our numerical calculations .
such a choice corresponds to measuring distances in units of the ads radius and to fixing the mass of the black hole , respecively .
it has become customary in the field @xcite to shoot from the event horizon towards infinity .
using ir boundary conditions for the uncharged case has meant that the correct uv boundary values are achieved automatically , and the bare quark mass and condensate are extracted in this way . for the charged case , because the ergosphere and the event horizon do not coincide , this introduces a new complication . for @xmath62 , near the event horizon , the equation of motion for the embedding resembles : @xmath63 where @xmath64 are functions of @xmath65 and @xmath66 . since @xmath67 at the event horizon , we use equation ( [ eqt : eom near horizon ] ) to obtain the necessary boundary condition , which is depicted in figure [ fig : bc eh ] .
.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] however , if we use this boundary condition to shoot to infinity , we find that @xmath68 diverges at the locus of points where the worldvolume vanishes . at first glance
, this may not be a problem , since it is a necessary condition if we wish to have a regular , non zero worldvolume across the locus .
however , in this case , the worldvolume diverges at the pseudo - horizon .
this results in the d7brane embedding to curve back on itself , as shown in figure [ fig : curve back ] .
we argue that these solutions do not correspond to physical d7brane embeddings , and , therefore , the boundary conditions specified at the event horizon are not the ones we are interested in .
we get similar results if we try to force the worldvolume to be regular and non zero across the same locus of points . )
results in embeddings curving back .
most ( black ) line is the event horizon ; the right most ( red ) line is the vanishing worlvolume locus .
the ( blue ) curve in between is the embedding solution.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] therefore , we impose a new `` physical '' condition on our embeddings ; we want @xmath68 to be at least continuously differentiable across the locus of vanishing worldvolume . in order to figure out the appropriate boundary conditions at this locus of points , we study the equation of motion near the locus : @xmath69 where @xmath70 depends on @xmath71 and @xmath66 , and @xmath72 is a strictly positive function of @xmath73 . since @xmath74 at the locus of vanishing worldvolume
, we use this equation to obtain the necessary boundary condition , which is depicted in figure [ fig : bc ph ] .
.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] therefore , for @xmath75 , we shoot from the locus described in point 2 above which is not where the d7brane ends , in knowledge that we are able to `` sew '' the rest of the d7brane that ends on the event horizon .
two examples of this sewing process are shown in figure [ fig : sew ] to illustrate that it can be done , and we refrain from plotting the sewed solutions on future plots .
we use the boundary conditions depicted in figure [ fig : bc ph ] . for @xmath54
, this corresponds to shooting from the location described in point 1 above , where the d7brane has ended .
the boundary condition is given by : @xmath76 these boundary conditions were also used in reference @xcite ; it is a result of requiring the absence of conifold singularities as the @xmath77 that the d7brane wraps shrinks to zero size .
+ figure [ fig : single charge l vs rho ] shows examples of the condensate and karch katz - like solutions as they approach their respective end points .
it is important to notice that in figure [ fig : linear c vs m ] , the karch katz - like solutions have a slope of @xmath78 for large @xmath28 , so this choice of the constant @xmath50 is not proportional to the condensate , as we remarked earlier .
this is a result of our choice of coordinates in the expansion of @xmath79 as given in equation ( [ eqt : l expansion ] ) , for which : @xmath80 in order to see this , we recall that for the zero charge case ( _ i.e. , _ the ads schwarzschild black hole studied in ref.@xcite ) , as @xmath81 , we have @xmath82 ; the constant @xmath50 is proportional to the quark condensate as shown by ref.@xcite .
the key geometric difference between the charged and uncharged case is that the @xmath83 gets distorted due to the presence of the charge @xmath8 . in order to be able to identify the condensate
, we want to restore the symmetry of the @xmath83 as much as possible as we move away from the horizon . by looking at the distorted @xmath83 part in equation ( [ eqt : decoupled spinning brane metric ] ) , one can see that , as we start moving away from the horizon ( i.e. when we see the effect of @xmath84 less and less ) , it starts conformally looking like : @xmath85 where @xmath86 following ref.@xcite , the change of variables that would restore the symmetry is given by : @xmath87 in view of this , for the single charge case , one defines the following radial coordinate : @xmath88 this allows us to rewrite : @xmath89 we can now define new coordinates : @xmath90 so that we have : @xmath91 then from the asymptotic behavior of @xmath92 for large @xmath24 : @xmath93 we can argue that @xmath94 has the expansion : @xmath95 using the standard argument from ref.@xcite we can show that : @xmath96 so , in these coordinates that restore the symmetry of the @xmath83 , the nave condensate value gets a constant subtraction .
henceforth , all future plots of @xmath27 will subtract off this term . the adjusted solution and the phase transition region
are shown in figure [ fig : more single charge solutions ] .
there are several important things to notice .
first , in figure [ fig : single charge c vs m ] , unlike the ads schwarzschild case , we begin to see the condensate becoming negative for small bare quark mass .
in addition , we see the appearance of _ apparently _ negative masses ( see figure [ fig : single charge origin ] ) .
this of course corresponds to negative @xmath97 value for @xmath98 .
this effect is to be interpreted as the constant coordinate @xmath39 flipping to @xmath99 .
this has been checked by extending @xmath57 to negative values and observing that we get the same physics , continued to the negative mass side .
this is simply the familiar case of realizing that a negative radial coordinate should be flipped back to positive values after taking into account the range of the angular coordinates . here
, by considering the fixed @xmath39 ansatz , we are required to extend the definition of @xmath57 to negative values . therefore , these solutions would have physical values given by @xmath100 and @xmath101 .
therefore , we see the appearance of a finite condensate gap between the @xmath102 solution and the @xmath103 .
our equal area law , discussed in ref.@xcite , tells us that the lower branch , corresponding to negative values of the condensate , has the lowest energy .
therefore , the system chooses the @xmath103 solution .
this means that the geometry breaks @xmath10 chiral symmetry spontaneously .
we plot the value of the condensate at zero bare quark mass in figure [ fig : single charge critical condensate vs q ] .
we see that there is a minimum amount of charge that is needed before chiral symmetry is broken .
we also notice that the condensate decreases toward zero asymptotically as @xmath104 .
when we set all three charges to be equal@xcite , ( _ i.e. , _ @xmath105 in equation ( [ eqt : decoupled spinning brane metric ] ) ) , the metric is given by : @xmath106 where @xmath107 from a computational point of view , it is again more convenient to use @xmath108 however , just like in the single charge case of last section , the karch katz like solutions exhibit a positive slope of @xmath78 for the condensate , which is again an artifact of the coordinates . to show that , we introduce a new radial coordinate @xmath109 satisfying : @xmath110 and the corresponding radial coordinates are : @xmath111 using that @xmath109 from equation ( [ eqn2 ] ) has the asymptotic behavior
: @xmath112 one can show that : @xmath113 note also that one can write : @xmath114 and following the standard argument presented in ref.@xcite one can show that : @xmath96 therefore , to explore the functional dependence of the condensate on the bare quark mass , we again choose @xmath115 and @xmath39 to be our transverse coordinates to the d7brane . with this choice , the worldvolume of the d7brane is given by : @xmath116 we see that when @xmath117 , the worldvolume goes to zero .
this corresponds to the karch katz like solutions that we saw for the ads schwarzschild black hole and our single charge case .
the other case where the worldvolume goes to zero is when : @xmath118 this is a similar situation as for the single charge case , where the worldvolume goes to zero , but the d7brane continues through and ends only at the event horizon determined by @xmath119
. we can solve the equation of motion for @xmath57 numerically ( using @xmath120 ) using the same boundary conditions as in equation ( [ eqt : bc ] ) for the karch - katz like solutions and the curve in figure [ fig : bc ph2 ] for @xmath62 , and we illustrate the two types of solutions in figure [ fig : three charge simple example ] .
.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] we see exactly the same behavior as in the single charge ; for large @xmath28 , the slope of the @xmath27 vs. @xmath28 plot , ( figure [ fig : three charge c vs m ] ) is given by @xmath121 , as can be expected from the arguments presented above .
therefore , as in the single charge case we will henceforth subtract this @xmath121 contribution from all future @xmath27 values displayed in our figures .
figure [ fig : three charge many solutions part 2 ] shows solutions for a variety of charges .
we can determine where the phase transition between condensate and karch katz like occurs from the equal - area law that we determined in ref.@xcite .
this allows us to avoid calculating the energy of the d7brane .
we again notice that , beyond a critical value of @xmath8 , we begin to see solutions with negative condensate value ( see figure [ fig : q=0.6 c vs m ] ) ; we saw this feature in the single charge case as well .
notice also that we again see the appearance of solutions with _ apparently _ negative bare quark mass ; this of course corresponds to negative @xmath97 value for @xmath98 , an effect seen in figure [ fig : three charge c vs m ] and can be explained as before . for those values ,
one simply swops @xmath122 .
therefore , we see the appearance of a discrete condensate gap between the @xmath102 solution and the @xmath103 . using our equal area law ,
it would tell us that the lower branch , corresponding to negative values of the condensate , has the lowest energy .
this means that our gauge theory will choose to have a non - zero condensate at zero bare quark mass .
this means the geometry breaks @xmath10 chiral symmetry spontaneously . as @xmath8 approaches its maximum value ( @xmath123 )
after which there is no event horizon , we begin seeing a multiplicity of condensate solutions for small bare quark mass , resulting from the rather beautiful spiral of solutions ( see the first quadrant in figures [ fig : q=0.6 c vs m origin ] and [ fig : q=0.62 c vs m origin ]
. using our equal area law again , we learn that the lowest branch of the spiral , corresponding to negative values of the condensate , has the lowest energy , and as we go `` deeper '' into the spiral every successive branch has higher energy ; the other zero mass condensates are simply metastable states .
therefore , again at zero bare quark mass , we have a non - zero negative condensate value and chiral symmetry breaking .
we plot the condensate value for zero bare quark mass as a function of the charge @xmath8 in figure [ fig : three charge critical condensate vs q ] .
we see again that there is a minimum @xmath8 below which chiral
symmetry is unbroken .
in order to confirm that we are indeed seeing chiral symmetry breaking , we calculate the quadratic fluctuations in the transverse coordinate @xmath39 about the embedding solutions for @xmath66 we found earlier . in the gauge theory
, this will correspond to a pseudo - scalar meson , as described in ref.@xcite . as a reminder , in ref .
@xcite , the exact meson spectrum for the ads@xmath124 background was found to be given by : @xmath125 where @xmath126 labels the order of the spherical harmonic expansion , and @xmath127 is a positive integer that represents the order of the mode . in our meson spectrum calculations ,
we have only considered the @xmath128 solutions for the fluctuations in @xmath57 and @xmath129 .
we will choose an ansatz of the form : @xmath130 where @xmath131=m$ ] corresponds to the meson s 4dimensional mass and @xmath132 $ ] corresponds to the inverse of the meson s lifetime .
we then recalculate the dbi action of the d7brane probe and expand the action to second order in @xmath133 .
the classical equations of motion for the fluctuation can then be derived using the euler lagrange equation .
the first thing we find is that near the event horizon , the equation of motion does not have the form of a heun equation ; this means that we do not have quasi
normal modes at the event horizon .
this means that the condensate embeddings and the mesons associated with their fluctuations are stable .
this is the opposite of what has been found for the ads schwarzschild black hole background @xcite .
therefore , we only need to consider the real part of @xmath134 in our analysis . in order to solve for the mass of the meson
, we again solve our equation of motion by shooting from where the worldvolume is zero towards infinity .
our boundary conditions for the condensate embeddings is determined by the equation of motion , as before to require that the function @xmath133 is smooth across the vanishing worldvolume locus .
@xmath135 where @xmath136 is shown in figure [ fig:1q_meson_bc_1 ] . for the single charge case , scaledwidth=45.0% ] our boundary conditions for the karch
katz like embeddings is simply given by : @xmath137 solutions for the single charge case are shown in figure [ fig : single charge meson ] for a case where we do not see chiral symmetry breaking and a case where we do see symmetry breaking .
we see that for the case where we claimed to see a non - zero condensate at zero bare quark mass ( @xmath138 ) , we definitely see a massless meson ( see figure [ fig : single charge massless ] ; for the case where we had no condensate at zero bare quark mass , we have no massless meson ( see figure [ fig : single charge massive ] ) .
in addition , we plot the small @xmath28 behavior of the meson in figure [ fig : single charge meson zoom ] .
if this is indeed the goldstone boson associated with chiral symmetry breaking , it should obey the gell - mann oakes
renner relation@xcite , which states that : @xmath139 where @xmath140 is the bare quark mass , and @xmath141 is the pion decay constant .
we can fit our curve nicely with a square root function as : @xmath142 meson .
the black line is the @xmath143 best fit curve , scaledwidth=45.0% ] which serves as a nice confirmation of our results .
we find we have very much the same results for the three charge case .
the equations of motion do not form a heun equation at the event horizon , so we have stable mesons .
the boundary conditions are the same as in equations ( [ eqt : 1q_meson_bc_bh ] ) and ( [ eqt : 1q_meson_bc_mk ] ) , with figure [ fig:1q_meson_bc ] showing the function @xmath136 .
for the three charge case , scaledwidth=45.0% ] solutions for the three charge case are shown in figure [ fig : three charge meson ] for a case where we do not see chiral symmetry breaking and a case where we do see symmetry breaking .
we again find a massless meson in the case where we have a condensate at zero bare quark mass ( see figure [ fig : three charge massless ] .
in addition , we can fit the curve nicely for small bare quark mass ( as shown in figure [ fig : three charge meson zoom ] ) as : @xmath144 meson .
the black line is the @xmath143 best fit curve , scaledwidth=45.0% ] once again confirming that we have chiral symmetry breaking beyond some critical value of @xmath8 .
we are grateful to nick evans , rob myers , and andreas karch for comments .
this research is supported by the us department of energy .
j. m. maldacena , `` the large n limit of superconformal field theories and supergravity , '' _ adv .
* 2 * ( 1998 ) 231252 , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9711200[hep-th/9711200 ] .
e. witten , `` anti - de sitter space and holography , '' _ adv .
* 2 * ( 1998 ) 253291 , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9802150[hep-th/9802150 ] .
s. s. gubser , i. r. klebanov , and a. m. polyakov , `` gauge theory correlators from non - critical string theory , '' _ phys .
* b428 * ( 1998 ) 105114 , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9802109[hep-th/9802109 ] .
e. witten , `` anti - de sitter space , thermal phase transition , and confinement in gauge theories , '' _ adv .
* 2 * ( 1998 ) 505532 , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9803131[hep-th/9803131 ] .
a. chamblin , r. emparan , c. v. johnson , and r. c. myers , `` charged ads black holes and catastrophic holography , '' _ phys .
* d60 * ( 1999 ) 064018 , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9902170[hep-th/9902170 ] .
a. chamblin , r. emparan , c. v. johnson , and r. c. myers , `` holography , thermodynamics and fluctuations of charged ads black holes , '' _ phys .
rev . _ * d60 * ( 1999 ) 104026 , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9904197[hep-th/9904197 ] .
m. cvetic and s. s. gubser , `` thermodynamic stability and phases of general spinning branes , '' _ jhep _ * 07 * ( 1999 ) 010 , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9903132[hep-th/9903132 ] .
a. karch and e. katz , `` adding flavor to ads / cft , '' _ jhep _ * 06 * ( 2002 ) 043 , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0205236[hep-th/0205236 ] .
m. kruczenski , d. mateos , r. c. myers , and d. j. winters , `` towards a holographic dual of large - n(c ) qcd , '' _ jhep _ * 05 * ( 2004 ) 041 , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0311270[hep-th/0311270 ] .
t. albash , v. filev , c. v. johnson , and a. kundu , `` a topology - changing phase transition and the dynamics of flavour , '' http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0605088[hep-th/0605088 ] .
j. babington , j. erdmenger , n. j. evans , z. guralnik , and i. kirsch , `` chiral symmetry breaking and pions in non - supersymmetric gauge / gravity duals , '' _ phys .
_ * d69 * ( 2004 ) 066007 , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0306018[hep-th/0306018 ] .
a. karch and a. obannon , `` chiral transition of n=4 super yang - mills with flavor on a 3-sphere , '' http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0605120[hep-th/0605120 ] .
i. kirsch , `` generalizations of the ads / cft correspondence , '' _ fortsch .
* 52 * ( 2004 ) 727826 , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0406274[hep-th/0406274 ] .
k. ghoroku , t. sakaguchi , n. uekusa , and m. yahiro , `` flavor quark at high temperature from a holographic model , '' _ phys .
* d71 * ( 2005 ) 106002 , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0502088[hep-th/0502088 ] .
d. mateos , r. c. myers , and r. m. thomson , `` holographic phase transitions with fundamental matter , '' http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0605046[hep-th/0605046 ] .
m. gell - mann , r. j. oakes , and b. renner , `` behavior of current divergences under su(3 ) x su(3 ) , '' _ phys . rev . _
* 175 * ( 1968 ) 21952199 .
p. kraus , f. larsen , and s. p. trivedi , `` the coulomb branch of gauge theory from rotating branes , '' _ jhep _ * 03 * ( 1999 ) 003 , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9811120[hep-th/9811120 ] .
m. cvetic _ et al .
_ , `` embedding ads black holes in ten and eleven dimensions , '' _ nucl .
phys . _ * b558 * ( 1999 ) 96126 , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9903214[hep-th/9903214 ] . j. g. russo , `` new compactifications of supergravities and large n qcd , '' _ nucl . phys . _
* b543 * ( 1999 ) 183197 , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9808117[hep-th/9808117 ] .
m. kruczenski , d. mateos , r. c. myers , and d. j. winters , `` meson spectroscopy in ads / cft with flavour , '' _ jhep _ * 07 * ( 2003 ) 049 , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0304032[hep-th/0304032 ] . c. hoyos , k. landsteiner , and s. montero , `` holographic meson melting , '' http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0612169[hep-th/0612169 ] .
d. mateos , r. c. myers , and r. m. thomson , `` thermodynamics of the brane , '' http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0701132[hep-th/0701132 ] . | we study , using a gravity dual , the finite temperature dynamics of @xmath0 gauge theory for large @xmath1 , with fundamental quark flavours in a quenched approximation , in the presence of a fixed charge under a global current .
we observe several notable phenomena .
there is a first order phase transition where the quark condensate jumps discontinuously at finite quark mass , generalizing similar transitions seen at zero charge .
we find a non zero condensate at zero quark mass above a critical value of the charge , corresponding to an analogue of spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking at finite number density .
we find that the spectrum of mesons contains the expected associated goldstone ( `` pion '' ) degrees of freedom with a mass dependence on the quark mass that is consistent with the gell - mann oakes renner relation .
our tool in these studies is holography , the string dual of the gauge theory being the geometry of @xmath1 spinning d3branes at finite temperature , probed by a d7brane . * global currents , phase transitions * * and * * chiral symmetry breaking in large @xmath1 gauge theory * * tameem albash , veselin filev , clifford v. johnson , arnab kundu * _ department of physics and astronomy _
_ university of southern california _ _ los angeles , ca 90089 - 0484 , u.s.a . _ albash , filev , johnson1 , akundu @usc.edu |
it is well - known that the ( co - moving ) space densities of the rarest , most powerful quasars and radio galaxies were much higher at epochs corresponding to @xmath1 than they are now ( longair 1966 ) .
the behaviour of the space density beyond these redshifts is the subject of this paper .
dunlop & peacock ( 1990 ) found evidence for a ` redshift cut - off ' ( a decline in the co - moving space density ) in the distribution of flat - spectrum radio sources over the redshift range @xmath2 . through failing to find any flat - spectrum radio quasars at @xmath3 in a large ( @xmath440 per cent of the sky ) survey ,
shaver et al ( 1996 , hereafter sh96 ) argued for an order - of - magnitude drop in space density between @xmath5 and @xmath6 , for this class of object .
as emphasised by sh96 , the crucial advantage of any radio - selected survey is that with sufficient optical follow - up , it can be made free of optical selection effects , such as increasing dust obscuration at high redshift .
it is chiefly for this reason that the work of sh96 provides the most convincing evidence to date for the existence of an intrinsic decline in the co - moving space density of any galaxy class at very high redshift .
we adopt a parameterisation of the rlf which is separable in 151-mhz luminosity @xmath7 and redshift @xmath8 with a single power - law in @xmath7 of the form @xmath9 .
we consider two cosmologies @xmath10 , @xmath11 ( cosmology i ) and @xmath12 , @xmath13 ( cosmology ii ) .
model a parameterises the redshift distribution as a single power - law of the form @xmath14 . for model
b the redshift distribution is parameterised as a gaussian , giving an overall expression for the co - moving space density of @xmath15 where @xmath16 and @xmath17 are the normalising term and power - law exponent respectively , @xmath18 is the gaussian peak redshift and @xmath19 is the characteristic width of the gaussian .
model c is described by the same model up to @xmath18 beyond which it becomes constant .
for sources in the top - decade in luminosity of the @xmath20 plane ( fig.1 ) our parametric fitting and likelihood analysis of model radio luminosity functions ( table 1 ) show that the data are inconsistent with a @xmath21 power - law in redshift ( model a ) , but are well fitted by both models b and c. these models are shown in fig.@xmath22 in the form of a log@xmath23 / log@xmath24 plot .
we conclude that although the relative likelihood for model b is @xmath25 times larger than for model c , this is not statistically significant enough to distinguish between the two models with any confidence .
this uncertainty is further compounded by the effects of assuming a mean spectral index in the model fitting .
this result is in very close agreement with the rlfs for radio loud quasars modelled by willott et al ( 1998 ) and various studies of agn at optical ( irwin et al 1991 ) and x - ray ( hasinger et al 1998 ) wavelengths .
this is in apparent contradiction to the findings of sh96 for flat - spectrum quasars .
if the relationship between the flat- and steep - spectrum populations is as described by unification models of agn then we might expect to see similar evolution in the two populations .
thus to determine the co - moving space density of radio sources at high - redshift , an understanding of the spectral index trends , @xmath26corrections and associated selection effects must first be achieved .
fig.@xmath22 also illustrates the contribution of powerful sources at high redshift to the total source count in a low - frequency survey .
we see that even for the no cut - off model ( model c ) the fractional contribution is very small .
this may render the location of the redshift cut - off virtually impossible to determine until the selection effects associated with radio surveys are fully understood .
blundell k.m . , rawlings s. , eales s.a . , taylor g.b .
, bradley a.d . , 1998 , mnras , 295 , 265 dunlop , j.s .
& peacock , j.a .
, 1990 , mnras , 247 , 19 eales s.a . , rawlings , s. , law - green , d. , cotter , g. , lacy , m. , 1997 , mnras , 291 , 593 hales , s.e.g . , baldwin , j.e . & warner , p.j .
, 1988 , mnras , 234 , 919 hasinger , g. , 1998 , astron . nachr . , 319 , 37 irwin , m. , mcmahon , r. & hazard , c. , 1991 , in the space distribution of quasars , ed .
crampton , aspcs 21 , 117 laing , r.a .
, riley , j.m .
& longair , m.s . , 1983 ,
mnras , 204,151 longair , m.s . , 1966 , mnras , 133 , 421 mcgilchrist m.m . ,
baldwin , j.e . , riley , j.m . ,
titterington , d.j . ,
waldram , e.m . ,
warner , p.j .
, 1990 , mnras , 246 , 110 shaver , p.a . , wall , j.v . ,
kellermann , k.i . ,
jackson , c.a . , hawkins , m.r.s . , 1996 , nature , 384 , 439 willott , c.j . , rawlings , s. , blundell , k.m . ,
lacy m. , 1998 , mnras , 300 , 625 | we use three samples ( 3crr , 6ce and 6c * ) to investigate the radio luminosity function ( rlf ) for the ` most powerful ' low - frequency selected radio sources .
we find that the data are well fitted by a model with a constant co - moving space density at high redshift as well as by one with a declining co - moving space density above some particular redshift .
this behaviour is very similar to that inferred for steep - spectrum radio quasars by willott et al(1998 ) in line with the expectations of unified schemes .
we conclude that there is as yet no evidence for a ` redshift cut - off ' in the co - moving space densities of powerful classical double radio sources , and rule out a cut - off at @xmath0 . |
it is well - known ( cf .
birkhoff s theorem @xcite ) that the only spherically symmetric solution @xmath2 to the einstein vacuum equations ( eve ) @xmath3 is the celebrated schwarzschild spacetime .
it was in fact the first non - trivial solution to the einstein field equations to be discovered @xcite .
in kruskal ( null ) @xmath4 coordinates the maximally extended metric reads @xmath5 where @xmath6 , @xmath7 , and the radius function @xmath8 is given implicitly by @xmath9 here the underlying manifold @xmath10 is endowed with the differential structure of @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is the open subset @xmath13 in the @xmath14 plane ; see figure [ krusk ] .
the spacetime has an essential curvature singularity at @xmath15 , ( the future component of ) which is contained in the interior of the black hole region , the quadrant @xmath16 .
in fact , a short computation shows that the gauss curvature of the @xmath14-plane equals @xmath17 and hence the manifold is @xmath18 inextendible past @xmath15 .
an interesting feature of this singularity is its spacelike character , that is , it can be viewed as a spacelike hypersurface .
yet another interesting feature of the schwarzschild singularity is its unstable nature from the evolutionary dynamical point of view . to illustrate this consider a global spacelike cauchy hypersurface @xmath19 in schwarzschild ( figure [ sigmaivp ] ) .
an initial data set for the eve consists of a riemannian metric @xmath20 on @xmath21 and a symmetric two tensor @xmath22 verifying the constraint equations @xmath23 where @xmath24 are the covariant derivative and scalar curvature intrinsic to @xmath20 .
the instability of the schwarzschild singularity ( w.r.t . the forward cauchy problem ) can already be seen by examining the maximal developments of initial data sets on @xmath21 arising from the celebrated kerr @xcite ( explicit ) 2-parameter @xmath25 family of solutions of which schwarzschild is a subfamily ( @xmath26 ) .
for @xmath27 the singularity completely disappears and the corresponding ( maximal ) developments extend smoothly up to ( and including ) the cauchy horizons ( which lie far beyond the hypersurface @xmath28 ) .
moreover , taking @xmath29 , the ` difference ' of the corresponding initial data sets from the schwarzschild one ( with the same @xmath7 ) , measured in standard sobolev norms , sobolev spaces used in the literature @xcite .
] can be made arbitrarily small .
in fact , the schwarzschild singularity is conjecturally unstable under _ generic _ perturbations on @xmath21 . according to a scenario proposed by belinski@xmath30-khalatnikov - lifshitz @xcite originally formulated for cosmological singularities , in general
, one should expect solutions to exhibit oscillatory behaviour towards the singularity.m @xcite for the euler - einstein system with bianchi ix symmetry .
] although this work was not supported by much rigorous evidence , it has received a lot of attention over the years , see @xcite and the references therein ( and @xcite for related numerics ) . on the other hand , there is a growing expectation that , at least in a neighbourhood of subextremal kerr , the dominant scenario inside the black hole is the formation of cauchy horizons and ( weak ) null singularities .
this has been supported by rigorous studies on spherically symmetric charged matter models , see works by poisson and israel @xcite , ori @xcite and recently by dafermos @xcite .
however , it is not inferred from the existing literature whether the non - oscillatory type of singularity observed in scwarzschild is an isolated phenomenon for the eve in some neighbourhood of the schwarzschild initial data on @xmath21 or part of a larger family . a priori
it is not clear what to expect , since one might argue that such a special singularity is a mathematical artefact due to spherical symmetry .
therefore , we pose the following question : _ is there a class of non - spherically symmetric einstein vacuum spacetimes which develop a first singularity of schwarzschild type ? _ the goal of the present paper is to answer the preceding question in the affirmative .
a schwarzschild type singularity here has the meaning of a first singularity in the vacuum development which has the same geometric blow up profile with schwarzschild and which can be seen by a foliation of uniformly spacelike hypersurfaces ; hence , not contained in a cauchy horizon .
we confine the question to the formation of one singular sphere in the vacuum development in the same manner as in schwarzschild , where each point on the sphere can be understood as a distinct ideal singular point of the spacetime in the language of tips @xcite .
ideally one would like to study the forward problem and identify initial data for the eve on @xmath21 ( figure [ sigmaivp ] ) that lead to such singularities .
although this is a very interesting problem , we find it far beyond reach at the moment .
instead we study the existence problem backwards - in - time .
more precisely , we adopt the following plan : let @xmath31 be a spacelike hypersurface in schwarzschild , tangent coordinates ( [ schw ] ) . ] at a single sphere of the singular hyperbola @xmath15 inside the black hole ; figure [ gens_fol ] .
we assume , without loss of generality , hypersurfaces ( figure [ krusk ] ) is killing and we may hence utilize it to shift @xmath0 and @xmath32 to whichever point on @xmath33 we wish ; figure ( [ gens_fol ] ) . ] that the tangent sphere is @xmath34 ) in kruskal coordinates ( [ schw ] ) .
consider now initial data sets @xmath35 on @xmath0 for the eve ( [ eve ] ) , which have the same singular behaviour to leading order at @xmath32 with the induced schwarzschild initial data set @xmath36 on @xmath0 and solve the eve backwards , as depicted in the 2-dim figure [ gens_fol ] , without symmetry assumptions . realizing the above plan we thus prove the existence of a class of non - spherically symmetric vacuum spacetimes for which @xmath37 the leading asymptotics of the blow up of curvature and in general of all the geometric quantities ( metric , second fundamental form etc . ) coincide with their schwarzschild counterparts , as one approaches the singularity , and @xmath38 the singularity is realized as the limit of uniformly spacelike hypersurfaces , which in the forward direction pinch off " in finite time at one sphere .
conversely , we visualise the backward evolution of @xmath39 in the following manner : at ` time ' @xmath40 the initial slice @xmath0 is a two ended spacelike ( 3-dim ) hypersurface with a sphere singularity at @xmath32 .
once @xmath0 evolves through ( [ eve ] ) , it becomes instantaneously a smooth spacelike hypersurface @xmath41 and the singular _ pinch _ opens up ; figure [ s_fol3d ] .
the main difficulty to overcome in the backward local existence problem is the essential singularity on @xmath0 , which of course renders it beyond the scope of the classical local existence theorem for the einstein equations @xcite , even its latest state of the art improvement by klainerman - rodnianski - szeftel @xcite , which requires at the very least the curvature of the initial hypersurface to be in @xmath42 . for the schwarzschild initial data set @xmath43 on @xmath0 , and
hence for perturbed initial data sets @xmath35 with the same leading order geometry at @xmath32 , it is not hard to check ( [ schwarz ] ) that the initial curvature is at the singular level @xmath44 to our knowledge , the only general local existence results , without symmetry assumptions , for the eve ( [ eve ] ) with singular initial curvature not in @xmath42 have been achieved only fairly recently by luk - rodnianski @xcite and luk @xcite for the characteristic initial value problem .
however , the singular level of the schwarzschild singularity is much stronger than the ones they consider ; delta curvature singularities @xcite and weak null singularities @xcite .
also , since we are interested in the spacelike character of the singularity of the perturbed spacetimes we wish to construct , the non - characteristic initial value problem seems to be a more natural setting to consider .
we proceed now to formulate a first version of our main results ; for more precise statements , in terms of weighted sobolev spaces , see theorems [ mainthm ] , [ mainthm2 ] , [ conststab ] .
[ thma ] there exists @xmath45 sufficiently large , such that for every triplet @xmath39 verifying : + @xmath46 the constraints ( [ const ] ) , + @xmath47 @xmath48 , @xmath49 , where @xmath50 are 2-tensors on @xmath0 bounded in @xmath51 respectively , + @xmath52 @xmath53 , + there exists a @xmath54 local solution @xmath55 to the einstein vacuum equations ( [ eve ] ) with initial data @xmath35 , unique up to isometry , in the backward region to @xmath0 , foliated by @xmath56}$ ] ( figure [ gens_fol ] ) ; the time of existence @xmath57 depends continuously on the norms of @xmath50 and the exponent @xmath45 .
the fact that non - trivial initial data sets in compliance with theorem [ thma ] exist is not at all obvious nor standard .
it has to be shown essentially that for any large parameter @xmath45 , the set of non - spherically symmetric solutions to the constraint equations ( [ const ] ) , having the asymptotics @xmath47 , is non - empty .
this is achieved in the following theorem .
[ thmb ] let @xmath45 be sufficiently large , consistent with theorem [ thma ] .
there exists a small ball @xmath58 , such that for every pair @xmath59 of 2-tensors defined on the boundary of @xmath0 , which lie inside that ball , there exists at least one extension of @xmath59 as 2-tensors in @xmath0 satisfying the assumptions of theorem [ thma ] .
in particular , the pair @xmath35 defined via @xmath47 in theorem [ thma ] satisfies the constraints ( [ const ] ) .
finally , let us emphasize the fact that the above spacetimes are very special in that they agree with schwarzschild at the singularity to a high ( but finite ) order this is captured by the large exponent @xmath45 in theorem [ thma ] and therefore are _ non - generic_. the need to choose @xmath60 large may be seen however natural to some extend in view of the instability of the schwarzschild singularity ; from the point of view of the forwards - in - time problem . indeed , the stable perturbations of the schwarzschild singularity must form a strict subclass of all perturbed vacuum developments .
the largest part of the paper is concerned with the evolutionary part of the problem , i.e. , proving theorem [ thma ] . due to the singular nature of backward existence problem described above , figure [ gens_fol ] ,
the choice of framework must be carefully considered .
the standard wave coordinates approach @xcite does not seem to be feasible in our situation ; one expects that coordinates would be highly degenerate at the singularity .
also , the widely used cmc gauge condition is not applicable , since the mean curvature of the initial hypersurface @xmath0 blows up ( [ schwarz ] ) .
instead , we find it more suitable to use orthonormal frames and rewrite the eve one order higher as a quasilinear yang - mills hyperbolic system of equations @xcite , under a lorentz gauge condition , for the corresponding connection 1-forms .
we recall briefly this framework in [ dee ] .
however , even after expressing the eve in the above framework , the singular level of initial configurations do not permit a direct energy estimate approach .
in addition to ( [ rnotinl2 ] ) , one can see ( [ schwarz ] ) that neither is the second fundamental form in @xmath42 @xmath61 note that the latter is at the level of one derivative in the metric .
hence , near the singularity the perturbed spacetimes we wish to construct do not even make sense as weak solutions of the eve ( [ eve ] ) .
therefore , it is crucial that we use the background schwarzschild spacetime to recast the evolution equations in a new form having more regular initial data .
we do this in [ stab ] by considering a new system of equations for the ` difference ' between the putative perturbed spacetime and schwarzschild .
the resulting equations have now regular initial data and they are eligible for an energy method , but there is a price to pay .
the coefficients of the new system will depend on the schwarzschild geometry and will necessarily be highly singular at @xmath15 .
we compute in [ schwarz ] the precise blow up orders of the schwarzschild connection coefficients , curvature etc .
nevertheless , the issue of evolving singular initial data has become the more tractable problem of finding appropriate weighted solution spaces for the final singular equations .
in [ whs ] we introduce the weighted sobolev spaces which yield the desired flexibility in proving energy estimates .
the right weights are given naturally by the singularities in the coefficients of the resulting equations , namely , powers of the schwarzschild radius function @xmath8 with a certain analogy corresponding to the order of each term .
after stating the general local existence theorems in [ main ] and a more precise version of theorem [ thma ] , we proceed to its proof via a contraction mapping argument which occupies section [ fixedpt ] .
therein we derive the main weighted energy estimates by exploiting the asymptotic analysis at @xmath15 of the schwarzschild components ( [ schwarz ] ) .
it is necessary in our result that the power of @xmath8 , @xmath45 , in the weighted norms is sufficiently large ; cf .
assumption @xmath47 in theorem [ thma ] . in the estimating process certain _ critical _ terms
are inevitably generated , because of the singularities in the coefficients of the system we are working with ; these terms are critical in that they appear with larger weights than the ones in the energy we are trying to control and thus prevent the estimates from closing .
the exponent @xmath45 is then picked sufficiently large such that these critical terms have an overall favourable sign ; this allows us to drop the critical terms and close the estimates .
the largeness of @xmath60 forces the perturbed spacetime to agree asymptotically with schwarzschild to a high order at the singularity .
although the latter may seem restrictive , it is quite surprising to us that there even exists a suitable choice of @xmath60 which makes the argument work in the first place .
a closer inspection of our method reveals that it is very sensitive with respect to certain asymptotics of the coefficients in the equations that happen to be just borderline to allow an energy - based argument to close .
the most important of these are the blow up order of the sectional curvature ( [ k ] ) and the rate of growth of the schwarzschild radius function @xmath8 backwards in time .
the latter corresponds to the ` opening up ' rate of the _ neck pinch _ of the singular initial hypersurface @xmath0 , figure [ s_fol3d ] . in this sense
the schwarzschild singularity is exactly at the threshold that our energy - based method can tolerate . in the last section , [ singconst ] ,
we study the constraint equations ( [ const ] ) in a perturbative manner about the schwarzschild singular initial data set @xmath43 on @xmath0 .
first we prescribe boundary data consists of two components diffeomorphic to @xmath62 .
] at @xmath63 close to schwarzschild ( in usual sobolev norms , see theorem [ thmb ] ) and then look for solutions @xmath35 to constraints inside the class of singular initial data sets that are compatible with our assumptions on the evolutionary problem ; cf .
theorem [ thma ] .
it is very likely that the _ generic _ behaviour at @xmath32 of solutions to ( [ const ] ) with this perturbed data at the boundary of @xmath0 will not agree with schwarzschild to a high enough order for theorem [ thma ] to be applicable .
however , we prove the existence of solutions for which the asymptotic behaviour required by theorem [ thma ] indeed holds .
we obtain theorem [ thmb ] as an application of the implicit function theorem .
the proof is based on properties of the constraint map @xcite , defined in the weighted sobolev spaces introduced above . in order to prove the surjectivity of the linearized constraint map around schwarzschild , we use an indirect argument from @xcite adapted to our context .
one of the main ingredients in the proof involves the fredholm property of a linearized operator , see proposition [ fred ] , which we prove in [ conffred ] by deriving certain weighted elliptic estimates . to our surprise
the present evolution bears some resemblance at an analytical level with a prior work on the stability of singular ricci solitons @xcite .
although of different nature , hyperbolic / parabolic ( respectively ) , they share a couple of key features such as the opening up rate of the singularity and the `` borderline '' singularities in the coefficients involved .
the understanding of the question of stability of singularities in einstein s equations and the behaviour of solutions near them is of great significance in the field .
however , in general very little is known . in terms of rigorous results ,
substantial progress has been made under symmetry assumptions in the presence of matter @xcite
@xcite @xcite @xcite .
moreover , certain matter models enjoy the presence of a monotonic quantity , which has been employed to study the stability of singularity formation in the general non - symmetric regime , cf .
recent work of rodnianski - speck @xcite on the flrw big bang singularity .
this is in contrast with the vacuum case and the unstable nature of the schwarzschild singularity .
we emphasize again the fact that the method developed herein does not impose any symmetry assumptions nor it relies on any monotonicity .
it should be noted as well that it does not depend on whether the particular singularity type is _ generic _ or not . on the contrary
, we hope that it can serve as a robust new method which can be generally employed to produce classes of examples of non - symmetric singular solutions to the einstein field equations , which until now are only known to exist under special symmetry assumptions and for which the general stability question may be out of reach .
after our treatment of singular initial data containing a single sphere of @xmath33 , a reasonable next step would be to study whether the construction of non - spherically symmetric vacuum spacetimes containing an arc of the singular hyperbola ( figure [ gens_fol ] ) is possible or even the whole singularity @xmath15 .
certainly this is a more restrictive question and at first glance not so obvious how to formulate it as a backward initial value problem problem for the eve .
however , we hope that the method developed herein could help approach this direction .
lastly , one could try to perform a global instead of a local construction by considering a cauchy hypersurface @xmath0 extending to spacelike infinity .
we expect this follows readily from the work here , but we do not pursue it further . perhaps a gluing construction could also be achieved .
i would like to thank my advisor spyros alexakis for his valuable suggestions and interest in this work .
i am grateful to mihalis dafermos for helpful comments on a preliminary version of the present paper .
thanks also go to yannis angelopoulos , jesse gell - redman , niky kamran , volker schlue , arick shao for useful discussions .
the author is supported by an onassis foundation fellowship .
the einstein vacuum equations ( [ eve ] ) , by virtue of the second bianchi identity , imply the vanishing of the divergence of the riemann curvature tensor . decomposing the latter with respect to an orthonormal frame , which satisfies a suitable gauge condition
, it results to a quasilinear second order hyperbolic system of equations for the connection 1-forms corresponding to that frame , which bears resemblance to the semilinear yang - mills @xcite .
recently this formulation of the eve played a key role in the resolution of the bounded @xmath42 curvature conjecture @xcite . in this section
we express the eve ( [ eve ] ) in the above setting , which we are going to use to directly solve the cauchy problem .
this necessitates some technical details which are carried out in appendix [ app1 ] . also , to avoid additional computations
we write all equations directly in scalar non - tensorial form .
let @xmath2 be a lorenzian manifold and let @xmath64 @xmath65 be an orthonormal frame ; @xmath66 .
assume also that @xmath67 has the differential structure of @xmath68 $ ] , where each leaf @xmath69 is a 3-dim spacelike hypersurface .
we denote the connection 1-forms associated to the preceding frame by @xmath70 where @xmath71 is the @xmath55-compatible connection of @xmath67 .
recall the definition of the riemann curvature tensor @xmath72 by the former definition of connection 1-forms , using @xmath73 to raise and lower indices , we write @xmath74 hence , we have @xmath75 therefore , we get the following expression for the components of the riemann curvature @xmath76 or setting @xmath77 } ( [ a_\mu , a_\nu])_{ij}= { ( a_\mu)_i}^k(a_\nu)_{kj}-{(a_\nu)_i}^k(a_\mu)_{kj}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we rewrite @xmath78)_{ij}-{(a_{[\mu})_{\nu]}}^k(a_k)_{ij},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where by standard convention @xmath79}}^k(a_k)_{ij}:= { ( a_\mu)_\nu}^k(a_k)_{ij}-{(a_\nu)_\mu}^k(a_k)_{ij}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the same manner we compute the covariant derivative of the riemann tensor : @xmath80 k})_{ij } -([a_\sigma , f_{\mu\nu}])_{ij}\end{aligned}\ ] ] recall the transformation law of the above quantities under change of frames : let @xmath81 be an orthonormal frame on @xmath67 such that @xmath82 and let @xmath83 be the corresponding connection 1-forms .
then @xmath84 in addition , from ( [ o ] ) we have @xmath85 or @xmath86 now we proceed by assuming that the _ curl _ of the ricci tensor of the metric @xmath55 vanishes : @xmath88 where @xmath89 .
a direct implication of the ( contracted ) second bianchi identity is that the divergence of the riemann curvature tensor satisfies @xmath90 thus , it follows from ( [ driem ] ) that @xmath91 k})_{ij } -([a^\mu , f_{\mu\nu}])_{ij}=0\end{aligned}\ ] ] or by ( [ fmunu ] ) @xmath92)_{ij}-e^\mu\big({(a_{[\mu})_{\nu]}}^k(a_k)_{ij}\big)\\ \notag=&\;{(a^\mu)^k}_{[\mu}(f_{\nu ] k})_{ij } + ( [ a^\mu , f_{\mu\nu}])_{ij},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath93 is the non - covariant box with respect to the frame @xmath94 . since @xmath95= \nabla_{e_\mu }
e_\nu- \nabla_{e_\nu } e_\mu={(a_{[\mu})_{\nu]}}^ke_k,\end{aligned}\ ] ] ( [ boxa ] ) takes the equivalent form @xmath96}}^ke_k(a_\mu)_{ij } + e^\mu([a_\mu , a_\nu])_{ij}+e^\mu\big({(a_{[\mu})_{\nu]}}^k(a_k)_{ij}\big)\\ & + { ( a^\mu)^k}_{[\mu}(f_{\nu ] k})_{ij } + ( [ a^\mu , f_{\mu\nu}])_{ij},\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath97 .
we remark that ( [ boxa2 ] ) is an equation of scalar functions .
note that the preceding equation is not of hyperbolic type .
we convert ( [ boxa2 ] ) into a quasilinear hyperbolic system of equations by imposing a lorentz gauge condition on the orthonormal frame @xmath98 : .
the coulomb gauge is another alternative which is used in @xcite .
we do not employ it here . ]
@xmath99 where by @xmath100 we denote some quadratic expression in the connection coefficients @xmath101 varying in @xmath102 .
this a freedom one has in choosing the frame @xmath94 ; see lemma [ gaugemap ] . under ( [ gauge ] ) , the equation ( [ boxa2 ] ) becomes the quasilinear second order @xmath103}}^ke_k(a_\mu)_{ij } + e^\mu([a_\mu , a_\nu])_{ij } + e^\mu\big({(a_{[\mu})_{\nu]}}^k(a_k)_{ij}\big)\\ & + { ( a^\mu)^k}_{[\mu}(f_{\nu ] k})_{ij } + ( [ a^\mu , f_{\mu\nu}])_{ij}+e_\nu(a^2)+e_\nu\big({(a^\mu)_\mu}^k(a_k)_{ij}\big)\end{aligned}\ ] ] following ( [ divriem])-([boxa3 ] ) we actually see that the equation @xmath104 holds true for every lorentzian metric @xmath55 and orthonormal frame @xmath98 , without any additional assumptions or gauge condition .
we call @xmath105 , i.e. , the system ( [ boxa3 ] ) , the reduced equations .
we note that even after the gauge fixing , the reduced equations are not equivalent to the eve ( [ eve ] ) , but only imply the vanishing of the _ curl _ of the ricci tensor ( [ curlric ] ) .
however , one may suitably prescribe initial data for ( [ boxa3 ] ) such that they lead to solutions of the eve and which are consistent with the lorentz gauge condition ( [ gauge ] ) .
now we address the initial value problem for the reduced equations @xmath105 aiming to the eve . to solve the equation ( [ boxa3 ] )
one needs an equation relating the evolution of the orthormal frame @xmath98 to that of the connection 1-forms .
let @xmath106 be a reference frame in @xmath68 $ ] ( @xmath107 transversal direction ) .
we express @xmath94 in terms of @xmath108 : @xmath109 by virtue of the diffeomorphism invariance of the eve , we may assume that the timelike unit vector of the orthonormal frame @xmath98 of the spacetime we solve for is @xmath110 .
doing so we deduce @xmath111)= o^b_i\mathcal{l}_{\partial_0}(\hat{\partial}_a)\partial_b+\hat{\partial}_a([e_0,e_i]),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath112 denotes the lie derivative and @xmath113 is the 1-form dual to @xmath108 . setting @xmath114=:\gamma^c_{[0b]}\partial_c$ ]
we rewrite @xmath115}+{(a_{[0})_{i]}}^ko^a_k.\end{aligned}\ ] ] now we proceed to formulate the necessary and sufficient conditions on the initial data set of the reduced equations ( [ boxa3 ] ) , coupled to ( [ partial_0frame ] ) , such that the corresponding solution yields a solution to the eve .
the following proposition is proved in [ app1.1 ] .
[ idprop ] let @xmath116 be a solution of ( [ boxa3]),([partial_0frame ] ) , arising from initial configurations subject to @xmath117 and @xmath118)_{i\mu}-{(a^{[\mu})_{\nu]}}^k(a_k)_{i\mu}=0\end{aligned}\ ] ] on @xmath0
. then the latter solution corresponds to an einstein vacuum spacetime @xmath2 and furthermore the frame @xmath98 ( [ epartial ] ) is @xmath55-orthonormal , @xmath110 , and satisfies the lorentz gauge condition ( [ gauge ] ) .
note that the second part of ( [ inita ] ) includes the constraints ( [ const ] ) ; @xmath119 , @xmath120 , on @xmath0 .
once we have chosen the orthonormal frame initially and the initial data components @xmath121 , which correspond to the @xmath107 derivative of @xmath98 , then the rest of the initial data set of ( [ boxa3 ] ) is fixed by the condition ( [ inita ] ) , i.e. , the lorentz gauge and the eve on the initial hypersurface @xmath0 ; see lemma [ gaugemap ] , remark [ initfixed ] .
we fix an explicit schwarzschild orthonormal reference frame and compute the corresponding connection coefficients , which we then use to find the leading asymptotics of the second fundamental form and curvature of the initial singular hypersurface @xmath0 in schwarzschild . knowing the precise leading blow up behaviour of these quantities is crucial for the study of local well - posedness in the next section . for distinction , we denote schwarzschild components with an upper left script @xmath122 .
let us consider a specific foliation of spacelike hypersurfaces @xmath123 , @xmath124 $ ] , for the backward problem in a neighbourhood of @xmath32 ; figure [ gens_fol ] .
for convenience let @xmath125.\end{aligned}\ ] ] ) in the interior of the black hole.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] in temporal and spatial coordinates @xmath126 @xmath127 the metric ( [ schw ] ) takes the form @xmath128 by ( [ uv]),([dtau , dx ] ) @xmath8 is related to @xmath126 via @xmath129 from which one can derive the following formulas : @xmath130 [ r2 ] the above first two identities yield the leading asymptotics : @xmath131 directly from the form of the induced metric on @xmath123 , @xmath132 we compute the corresponding induced volume form @xmath133\sin\theta dxd\theta d\phi\end{aligned}\ ] ] and its rate of change along @xmath134 using ( [ dr / dtau ] ) : @xmath135d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] normalizing , we define the schwarzschild orthonormal frame @xmath136 and the relative connection coefficients @xmath137 associated to it . a tedious computation,\partial_j)-{^sg}([\partial_i,\partial_j],\partial_\mu)+{^sg}([\partial_j,\partial_\mu],\partial_i )
\bigg]\end{aligned}\ ] ] ] shows that the non - zero components read @xmath138 recall the ( spacetime ) divergence formula of the connection 1-forms @xmath139 @xmath140 utilizing ( [ dr / dtau ] ) and ( [ a_mu_ij ] ) , we check that the first order term in the rhs of ( [ diva ] ) vanishes @xmath141 leaving @xmath142 thus , the orthonormal frame ( [ sframe ] ) satisfies a lorentz gauge type condition ( [ gauge ] ) .
[ overasym ] summarizing the above identities and formulas we obtain the following leading asymptotics at @xmath15 : @xmath143 depends on @xmath7 and @xmath144 .
notice that the latter asymptotics are sharp for @xmath145 and when @xmath146 .
in fact , the components of the second fundamental form of the slices @xmath147 , @xmath148 , are exactly at this level . in more geometric terms we have ( up to constants )
@xmath149),([rasym ] ) for @xmath40 , we see that both the scalar curvature and the second fundamental of the initial singular hypersurface @xmath0 are far from being square integrable @xmath150 the same holds for the mean curvature of @xmath0 .
in fact , a similar calculation shows @xmath151 , @xmath152 .
let @xmath35 be a perturbation of the schwarzschild initial data set @xmath43 on @xmath0 , verifying the constraints ( [ const ] ) , and let @xmath153 be an orthonormal frame of @xmath154 .
we fix a reference frame @xmath155 in @xmath156}$ ] , namely , the schwarzschild orthonormal frame ( [ sframe ] ) ; figure [ s_fol ] .
let @xmath98 , @xmath110 , be a frame extension in @xmath67 expressed in terms of @xmath157 via @xmath158 consider now the ( unique ) metric @xmath55 for which @xmath94 is orthonormal , @xmath66 , and the corresponding connection coefficients @xmath159 .
then proposition [ idprop ] asserts that the eve ( [ eve ] ) for @xmath55 , under the lorentz gauge condition ) . ]
@xmath160 reduce to the system of scalar equations @xmath161}}^ke_k(a_\mu)_{ij } + e^\mu([a_\mu , a_\nu])_{ij } + e^\mu\big({(a_{[\mu})_{\nu]}}^k(a_k)_{ij}\big)\\ & + { ( a^\mu)^k}_{[\mu}(f_{\nu ] k})_{ij } + ( [ a^\mu , f_{\mu\nu}])_{ij}+e_\nu\big((a_3)_{23}(a_2)_{ij}\big)+e_\nu\big({(a^\mu)_\mu}^k(a_k)_{ij}\big)\\ \notag \partial_0(o^d_c)=&-o^b_c{^s{(a_{[0})_{b]}}^d}+{(a_{[0})_{c]}}^ko^d_k,\qquad \nu , i , j , c , d\in\{0,1,2,3\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath162 and @xmath163}}^d}=[\partial_0,\partial_b]^d$ ] . however , the system ( [ system1 ] ) has singular initial data in the schwarzschild background which do not permit an energy approach directly .
for this reason we recast the equations in a way that captures the closeness to the schwarzschild spacetime .
let @xmath164}\to\mathbb{r } & & \nu , i , j\in\{0,1,2,3\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the components @xmath165 are the schwarzschild connection coefficients corresponding to the frame @xmath155 ( [ sframe ] ) and they are given by ( [ a_mu_ij ] ) .
we are going to use these new functions to control the evolution of the perturbed spacetime .
consider now the analogous system to ( [ system1 ] ) satisfied by the schwarzschild components @xmath166 . in view of the asymptotics ( [ overasym1 ] )
, we define @xmath167 to be a smooth function satisfying the bound @xmath168 depending on @xmath7 . taking the difference of the two analogous systems we obtain a new system for the functions @xmath169 written schematically in the form : @xmath170 where @xmath171 and each term in the rhs denotes some algebraic combination of finite number of terms of the depicted type ( varying in @xmath172 ) where the particular indices do not matter .
[ stabred ] evidently , the systems ( [ system1 ] ) and ( [ boxu ] ) are equivalent .
the benefit is that the assumption on the perturbed spacetime , being close to schwarzschild , implies that the functions @xmath169 are now small and regular .
thus , we have reduced the evolutionary problem to solving the pde - ode system of equations ( [ boxu ] ) .
however , the issue of singular initial data in ( [ system1 ] ) has become an issue of singularities in the coefficients of the resulting equations ( [ boxu ] ) , at @xmath173 , which do not make it possible to apply the energy procedure in standard spaces ; see also ( [ notl2 ] ) .
these singularities , in large part , are due to the intrinsic curvature blow up and can not be gauged away ; in particular the coefficients @xmath174 of the potential terms in ( [ boxu ] ) correspond to the schwarzschild curvature ( [ k ] ) .
some of the functions @xmath167 that appear in ( [ boxu ] ) , expressed in terms of schwarzschild connection coefficients ( [ a_mu_ij ] ) and their derivatives , are less singular than ( [ gamma_q ] ) , but representatives of the exact bound do appear in all the terms .
[ linfty1/r2 ] another crucial asymptotic behaviour that our method heavily depends on is that of the radius function @xmath8 . according to ( [ rasym ] )
, we observe that the best @xmath175 bound one could hope for the ratio @xmath176 is of the form @xmath177 which obviously fails to be integrable in time @xmath124 $ ] , for any @xmath57 .
this fact lies at the heart of the difficulty of closing a gronwall type estimate . in order to study the well - posedness of ( [ boxu ] ) we introduce certain weighted norms .
it turns out that the weights which yield the desired flexibility in obtaining energy estimates are the following .
[ wsp ] given @xmath45 and @xmath124 $ ] , we define the ( time dependent ) weighted sobolev space @xmath179 $ ] , as a subspace of the standard @xmath178 space on @xmath123 with the schwarzschild induced volume form satisfying : @xmath180:\;\;\ ; u\in h^s(\sigma_\tau),\;\;\;\|u\|_{h^{s,\alpha}[\tau]}^2:=\sum_{k\leq s } \int_{\sigma_\tau}\frac{[\partial^{(k)}u]^2}{r^{2\alpha-3(k-1)}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}<+\infty,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where by @xmath181 we denote any order @xmath144 combination of directional derivatives with respect to the components @xmath182 of the schwarzschild frame ( [ sframe ] ) .
for convenience , we drop @xmath183 from the notation whenever the context is clear .
observe that the weights in the norm @xmath184 in ( [ hsa ] ) blow up only at @xmath185 .
for @xmath186 fixed , the weights are uniformly bounded above by some positive constant @xmath187 , which becomes infinite as @xmath188 .
the dependence of the power @xmath189 on the number @xmath144 of derivatives corresponds to the singularities in the coefficients of the equation ( [ boxu ] ) .
[ sobprop ] the weighted @xmath190 spaces satisfy the properties : @xmath191 they are immediate consequences of definition [ wsp ] and and the fact that @xmath192 ) , ( [ sframe ] ) . let @xmath193}\big(\|(u_\nu)_{ij}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha } } + \|\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij}\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha-\frac{3}{2}}}\big)\\ & + \int^t_0\big(\|(u_\nu)_{ij}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+1}}+\|\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij}\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha-\frac{1}{2 } } } \big)d\tau\bigg]\\ & + \notag\sum_{c , d=0}^3\bigg[\sup_{\tau\in[0,t]}\|o^d_c-{i_c}^d\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{3}{2 } } } + \int^t_0\|o^d_c-{i_c}^d\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{5}{2}}}d\tau \bigg]\end{aligned}\ ] ] be the total weighted energy of the functions @xmath194 defined in @xmath56}$ ] ( [ fol ] ) , figure [ fol ] , the backward domain of dependence of @xmath0 with respect to the metric @xmath55 we are solving for . since the actual domain depends on the unknown solution , it will be fully determined in the end ; see section [ fixedpt ] . for brevity
we denote by @xmath195\\ \notag&+\sum_{c , d\in\{0,1,2,3\}}\|o^d_c-{i_c}^d\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}(\sigma_0)}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the energy at the initial singular slice @xmath0 .
[ ufanal ] it would seem more natural if the components @xmath196 were lying in @xmath197 , that is , one derivative less than @xmath198 .
however , this would create additional technical difficulties , which we choose to avoid by treating both @xmath196 , @xmath198 at the same footing ( number of derivatives ) , since it is an issue of the structure of the system ( [ boxu ] ) and not a singularity issue .
the following theorem is our first main local well - posedness result for the system ( [ boxu ] ) , whose proof occupies section [ fixedpt ] .
[ mainthm ] there exist @xmath45 sufficiently large and @xmath199 small such that if @xmath200 then the system ( [ boxu ] ) admits a unique solution , up to some small time @xmath201 , in the spaces @xmath202;h^{3,\alpha})\cap l^2([0,t];h^{3,\alpha+1})\qquad\qquad\nu , i , j\in\{0,1,2,3\}\\ \partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij}\in&\;c([0,t];h^{2,\alpha-\frac{3}{2}})\cap l^2([0,t];h^{2,\alpha-\frac{1}{2}})\\ \notag o^d_c-{i_c}^d\in&\;c([0,t];h^{3,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}})\cap l^2([0,t];h^{3,\alpha+\frac{5}{2}})\qquad\qquad c , d\in\{0,1,2,3\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ h - m ] @xmath46 the second part of condition ( [ initf ] ) , @xmath199 small , is necessary for the equation ( [ boxu ] ) to be hyperbolic , yielding sufficient pointwise control on the @xmath203 s ( [ h ] ) @xmath204 , since the energy @xmath205 controls the @xmath206 norm of @xmath207 by standard sobolev embedding .
+ @xmath47 how large the exponent @xmath60 has to be depends on the coefficients of the system ( [ boxu ] ) . in the final inequalities in [ fixedpt ] @xmath45 is picked large enough so that certain ` critical ' terms can be absorbed in the lhs and the estimates can close .
the above theorem is a local well - posedness result for the system ( [ boxu ] ) .
imposing now the proper conditions on the initial data set of ( [ boxu ] ) , the solution ( [ solsp ] ) yields a solution of ( [ system1 ] ) which in turn corresponds to an einstein vacuum spacetime ( [ eve ] ) .
[ mainthm2 ] let @xmath208 be such as in theorem [ mainthm ] and let @xmath39 be an initial data set for the einstein vacuum equations ( [ eve ] ) satisfying the constraints ( [ const ] ) , such that the components @xmath209 @xmath210 computed with respect to an orthonormal frame @xmath153 on @xmath154 , and @xmath211 then , there exists a solution @xmath55 to the eve ( [ eve ] ) in the backward region to @xmath0 , foliated by @xmath212}$ ] , with induced initial data set @xmath35 on @xmath0 and an orthonormal frame extension @xmath98 for which the corresponding ( spacetime ) functions @xmath213 ( [ u]),([omain ] ) lie in the spaces ( [ solsp ] ) .
+ if in addition @xmath214;h^{4,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}})$ ] , @xmath215 , then the einsteinian vacuum development is unique up to isometry .
the fact that such ( non - spherically symmetric ) initial data sets @xmath39 exist , in compliance with theorem [ mainthm2 ] , is shown in [ singconst ] .
we want to invoke theorem [ mainthm ] . for this purpose ,
we prescribe initial data for the system ( [ boxu ] ) : + @xmath46 the components ( [ initcond2 ] ) , ( [ initf2 ] ) , ( [ diffk ] ) are given .
+ @xmath47 since in the beginning of [ pertsp ] we assumed @xmath110 and since @xmath153 is initially tangent to @xmath0 , we set @xmath216 @xmath52 we ( freely ) assign or equivalently @xmath217 fix the @xmath107 derivative of the frame @xmath218 on @xmath0 ; see lemma [ gaugemap ] and remark [ initfixed ] .
] @xmath219 once we have prescribed the above , the components @xmath220 are fixed by the assumption ( [ inita ] ) on the initial data of the original system ( [ system1 ] ) ; see remark [ initfixed ] . indeed , subtracting the corresponding schwarzschild components from ( [ initfixed1]),([initfixed2 ] ) , which obvisouly satisfy the same initial relations , cf .
( [ diva2 ] ) , we obtain schematically : @xmath221 by ( [ sobprop1 ] ) and standard sobolev embedding we conclude that @xmath222 thus , the assumption ( [ initf ] ) is verified and theorem [ mainthm ] can be invoked . from proposition [ idprop ]
it follows that the solution ( [ solsp ] ) of ( [ boxu ] ) and hence of ( [ system1 ] ) yields indeed an einstein vacuum spacetime @xmath223},g)$ ] . to prove uniqueness ( up to isometry ) we rely on the uniqueness statement in theorem [ mainthm ] .
suppose there is another einsteinian vacuum development @xmath224 of the initial data set @xmath39 , diffeomorphic to @xmath56}$ ] , satisfying the hypothesis ( [ initcond2 ] ) , ( [ initf2 ] ) , ( [ diffk ] ) ; defined by pulling back the relevant quantities through the preceding diffeomorphism , taking differences etc . in order to use the uniqueness statement in theorem [ mainthm ] , we need the two spacetimes to have the same initial data for the system ( [ boxu ] ) . the part of the initial data set given by the assumptions in the statement of theorem [ mainthm2 ] is of course identical for both spacetimes .
the remaining components that we want to agree , other than the @xmath225 s , as noted in the previous paragraph , can be fixed by condition ( [ inita ] ) .
therefore , we get identical initial data components for the system ( [ boxu ] ) by constructing a lorentz gauge frame ( [ gaugemain ] ) @xmath226 for @xmath227 , which is initially equal to @xmath98 on @xmath0 and such that @xmath228 as well ; see lemma [ gaugemap ] .
the only assumption to be verified is the well - posedness of the system ( [ boxo2 ] ) for functions in the solution spaces ( [ solsp ] ) , after taking differences with the equation for the frame @xmath98 .
however , this falls in the category of the system ( [ boxu ] ) [ in fact simpler , being semilinear ] to which theorem [ mainthm ] can be applied .
the extra derivative that we have to assume in order to close , @xmath229 , is due to the @xmath230 term in the rhs of ( [ boxo2 ] ) .
throughout this section we will use the notation @xmath231 to denote an inequality between the quantities @xmath232 of the form @xmath233 , where @xmath234 is an absolute positive constant depending only on the schwarzschild mass @xmath7 .
the same for the standard notation @xmath235 , for a quantity bounded by @xmath236 , @xmath237 .
furthermore , all the estimates regard only the schwarzschild region foliated by @xmath56}$ ] ; figure [ gens_fol ] .
we prove theorem [ mainthm ] via a contraction mapping argument .
first we establish an energy estimate in the relevant weighted @xmath238 spaces in [ enest ] .
then we obtain a contraction , in
[ contr ] , in the corresponding spaces of one derivative less , see ( [ contr ] ) , which together with the energy estimate yield the desired solution ( [ solsp ] ) .
+ to derive these estimates we have to eliminate some _
critical _ terms which are generated due to the singularities in the coefficients of the equations , having larger weights than the ones in the norm ( [ hsa ] ) , and which prevent us from closing ( see propositions [ mainenest],[maincontrest ] ) .
this is where the role of the weights ( [ hsa ] ) comes in .
the parameter @xmath45 helps generate critical terms with a favourable sign .
being large enough , but finite , @xmath60 provides an overall negative sign for the critical terms , hence , rendering them removable from the rhs of the final inequalities .
this enables us to close the estimates and complete the proof .
the precise asymptotics of the singularities in the coefficients of the equations ( [ boxu ] ) , at @xmath173 , and the opening up rate of the radius function @xmath8 in @xmath186 play a crucial role here .
, the previous procedure would fail no matter how large @xmath45 is to begin with . ]
let @xmath239 be a scalar function defined on @xmath123 , represented by @xmath240 where @xmath241 is the @xmath242 coordinate chart .
we recall some standard inequalities : the classical sobolev embedding of @xmath243 in @xmath244 and the interpolation inequality @xmath245 for a bounded domain @xmath246 with ( piecewise ) @xmath18 boundary . in the following proposition @xmath239
is assumed to be regular enough such that the rhss make sense .
[ adaptineq ] for a general function @xmath247 , @xmath124 $ ] , with the appropriate regularity , the following inequalities hold : + the @xmath206 bound @xmath248 and the @xmath249 estimate @xmath250 from the embedding @xmath251 we have @xmath252 we argue similarly in the case of ( [ l4 ] ) .
we define now the mapping , which really corresponds to an iterative process .
let @xmath254 be a set of functions in the solution spaces ( [ solsp ] ) , verifying @xmath255 initially on @xmath0 .
let @xmath57 be sufficiently small such that @xmath256 we also assume , we must derive for the next set of functions @xmath257 below . ] @xmath258}\lesssim\mathcal{e}^2_0+\mathcal{e}_0&&\forall\tau\in[0,t],\;\;c , d=0,1,2,3.\end{aligned}\ ] ] _ iteration step _ : consider the following linear version of the system ( [ boxu ] ) , where we replace the functions @xmath207 in the following specific terms by the corresponding ones from the set @xmath259 : @xmath260 where @xmath261 .
observe that we kept in the rhs of ( [ modboxu ] ) the functions @xmath207 attached to the most singular coefficients of the system .
this is actually very important to our strategy .
had we replaced them with the corresponding functions @xmath262 as well , it would not be plausible to derive a weighted energy estimate .
we assume now there exists a solution @xmath194 of ( [ modboxu ] ) lying in the solution space ( [ solsp ] ) .
the existence of such a solution is based mainly on the energy estimate we will derive below and a standard duality argument which we omit .
+ _ claim _ : for a chosen large enough @xmath45 and @xmath57 sufficiently small ( depending on @xmath263 ) the following estimate holds @xmath264 the preceding @xmath238-weighted energy estimate , cf .
( [ wen ] ) , will be used in the next subsection to close the contraction argument that yields the existence and uniqueness of the solution ( [ solsp ] ) to ( [ boxu ] ) .
now we begin the proof of ( [ uenest ] ) : first note that by the fundamental theorem of calculus , following a @xmath107 integral curve and employing ( [ linfty ] ) , we readily obtain from our initial assumptions and ( [ norme_0barf ] ) the pointwise bound @xmath265}\|\overline{o}- i|\|_{l^\infty(\sigma_\tau)}\leq \varepsilon+ct\mathcal{e}_0<2\varepsilon,\end{aligned}\ ] ] provided @xmath266 and @xmath267 .
all the more , directly from the ode in ( [ modboxu ] ) we deduce the estimate : [ applying the bounds ( [ linfty ] ) , ( [ venest ] ) to @xmath268 and employing the asymptotics ( [ gamma_q ] ) ] @xmath269}\lesssim \mathcal{e}_0 ^ 2+\|o - i\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}[\tau]}+\|u\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha}[\tau]},\end{aligned}\ ] ] for all @xmath124 $ ] , @xmath270 . ) in the end , imply the analogue of ( [ norme_0barf ] ) for the functions @xmath271 . ] we derive ( [ uenest ] ) in the backward domain of dependence of @xmath0 w.r.t .
the metric @xmath272 , @xmath273 , whose inverse is given by @xmath274 ; compare to ( [ h ] ) .
the boundary of the domain is the backward incoming @xmath275-null hypersurface @xmath276 emanating from @xmath63 ( figure [ fol_v ] ) .
we foliate the domain by the @xmath277 hypersurfaces @xmath278 inside @xmath276 .
let @xmath279 be the scalar function defined near @xmath276 via @xmath280 where @xmath281 is the cylinder obtained from the flow of @xmath282 backwards along the integral curves of @xmath107 .
using @xmath279 we may write each leaf of the foliation as @xmath283}\{\rho_\tau = t - t^*\}\bigcup b_\tau & & \tau\in[0,t],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath284 and @xmath285 is simply the projection of @xmath286 onto @xmath287 through the integral curves of @xmath107 . since by definition @xmath288 is zero on @xmath276
, it follows that the @xmath289-gradient of @xmath288 , on @xmath276 , lies on the hypersurface itself and furthermore it is @xmath289-null , i.e. , @xmath279 satisfies the eikonal equation @xmath290 where @xmath291 . in this regard , we define the following adapted energy , which controls the part of the total energy ( [ wen ] ) that refers to @xmath292 : @xmath293(\tau):=&\frac{1}{2}\sum_{\nu , i , j}\sum_{|j|\leq s}\int_{\sigma_\tau^{\overline{u}}}\bigg[-\overline{h}^{00}\frac{\big[\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij , j}\big]^2}{r^{2\alpha-3|j|}}\\ & + \overline{h}^{ab}\frac{\partial_a(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j| } } \frac{\partial_b(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j| } } \notag+\frac{(u_\nu)_{ij , j}^2}{r^{2\alpha-3(|j|-1)}}\bigg]d\mu_{^s\overline{g}},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath294 and @xmath295 is a spatial multi - index ( containing only directions @xmath182 ) .
it is evident from ( [ linftybarf ] ) , @xmath261 , that @xmath296 is equivalent to the weighted @xmath297 norm of @xmath292 on @xmath287 .
we summarize in the following proposition the main energy estimates derived below .
[ mainenest ] the following two energy estimates hold : @xmath298 + 8m^2e^{-1}(1-\tau)\alpha e_{3,\alpha+1 } [ { u}]\\ \lesssim&\ ; ( \mathcal{e}_0^\frac{1}{2}+\mathcal{e}_0+\alpha^2+\alpha^3\mathcal{e}_0)e_{3,\alpha } [ { u}]+e_{3,\alpha+1 } [ { u}]+\mathcal{e}_0\| { o - i}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\\ & \notag + \| { o - i}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{5}{2 } } } + \alpha^3\mathcal{e}_0 ^ 2+\mathcal{e}_0 ^ 3\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath299+\mathcal{e}_0 ^ 2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] for all @xmath300 .
the overall energy estimate ( [ uenest ] ) follows from proposition [ mainenest ] : adding ( [ e_sest ] ) , ( [ oest ] ) we wish to close the estimate by employing the standard gronwall lemma .
however , this is not possible in general , because of the critical energies in the rhs , having larger weights than the ones differentiated in the lhs , namely , @xmath301 $ ] , @xmath302 instead of @xmath303,\| { o - i}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}$ ] .
it is precisely at this point that the role of the weights we introduced is revealed .
choosing @xmath45 large enough to begin with , how large depending on the constants in the above inequalities , we absorb the critical terms @xmath304,\| { o - i}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{5}{2}}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the lhs and then the standard gronwall lemma applies to give ( [ uenest ] ) .
let @xmath305 ^ 2}{r^{2\alpha-3|j| } } + \overline{h}^{ab}\frac{\partial_a(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j| } } \frac{\partial_b(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j| } } + \frac{(u_\nu)_{ij , j}^2}{r^{2\alpha+3 - 3|j|}}\bigg],\end{aligned}\ ] ] for any spatial multi - index @xmath295 with @xmath306 ; recall @xmath294 .
it follows from ( [ folsigma ] ) and the coarea formula that @xmath307 where @xmath308 stands for the gradient of @xmath279 with respect to the intrinsic connection on @xmath309 and @xmath310 is the schwarzschild induced volume form on @xmath282 .
note that the boundary term in ( [ e / dtau ] ) has a favourable sign .
since @xmath276 is @xmath275-incoming null , we show that the sum of all arising boundary terms has a good sign and therefore can be dropped in the end . to analyse the last two terms in ( [ e / dtau ] ) , we recall the @xmath134 differentiation formulas of the radius function @xmath8 ( [ dr / dtau ] ) , the estimate on volume form @xmath311 ( [ dmu / dtau ] ) and the commutator relation @xmath312={^s(a_{[0})_{b]}}^c\partial_c\overset{(\ref{overasym1})}{=}\gamma_{\frac{3}{2}}\partial$ ] : @xmath313 ^ 2}{r^{2\alpha-3|j| } } + \partial_0(\overline{h}^{ab})\frac{\partial_a(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j| } } \frac{\partial_b(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j|}}\bigg]d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\\ \notag&+\int_{\sigma_\tau^{\overline{u}}}\omega\bigg [ -\overline{h}^{00}\frac{\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij , j}\partial_0 ^ 2(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{2\alpha-3|j| } } + \overline{h}^{ab}\frac{\partial_a(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j| } } \frac{\partial_b\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j| } } \bigg]d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\\ \notag & + \int_{\sigma_\tau^{\overline{u}}}\omega \overline{h}^{ab}\frac{\partial_a(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j| } } \frac{\gamma_{\frac{3}{2}}\partial(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j|}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g } } + \int_{\sigma_\tau^{\overline{u } } } \omega\frac{(u_\nu)_{ij , j}\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{2\alpha+3-|j|}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first term on the lhs of ( [ intp / dtau ] ) is critical having a favourable sign of magnitude @xmath60 .
we use this term alone to absorb all arising critical terms in the process . recall @xmath314 , cf .
( [ linftybarf ] ) , and the asymptotics ( [ gamma_q ] ) . also , applying ( [ linfty ] ) to @xmath315 and ( [ norme_0barf ] ) we derive @xmath316 hence , by cauchy s inequality and ( [ venest ] ) we have @xmath317 ^ 2}{r^{2\alpha-3|j| } } + \partial_0(\overline{h}^{ab})\frac{\partial_a(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j| } } \frac{\partial_b(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j|}}\bigg]d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\\ \notag & + \int_{\sigma_\tau^{\overline{u}}}\omega \overline{h}^{ab}\frac{\partial_a(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j| } } \frac{\gamma_\frac{3}{2}\partial(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j|}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g } } + \int_{\sigma_\tau^{\overline{u } } } \omega\frac{(u_\nu)_{ij , j}\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{2\alpha+3-|j|}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\\ \lesssim&\;\mathcal{e } ( { \overline{u},\overline{o}};\alpha , t)^\frac{1}{2 } e_{3,\alpha } [ { u } ] + e_{3,\alpha+1 } [ { u}]\\ \notag\lesssim&\;\mathcal{e}_0^\frac{1}{2 } e_{3,\alpha } [ { u}]+e_{3,\alpha+1 } [ { u}]\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the next term we proceed by integrating by parts . doing so we pick up connection coefficients , since it is not covariant ibp . ] ( ibp ) , denoting by @xmath318 the outward unit normal on @xmath282 w.r.t .
schwarzschild metric @xmath20 on @xmath287 : @xmath319d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\\ = & -\int_{\sigma_\tau^{\overline{u}}}\omega\frac{\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j|}}\bigg [ \overline{h}^{00}\frac{\partial_0 ^ 2(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j| } } + \overline{h}^{ab}\frac{\partial_b\partial_a(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j| } } \bigg]d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\\ \notag&+\int_{\partial\sigma_\tau^{\overline{u}}}\omega \overline{h}^{ab}\frac{\partial_a(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j| } } \frac{\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j| } } n_b ds\\ & \notag -\int_{\sigma_\tau^{\overline{u}}}\bigg[\partial_b\big(\frac{\omega \overline{h}^{ab}}{r^{2\alpha-3|j|}}\big)\partial_a(u_\nu)_{ij , j}+\omega\overline { h}\frac{\gamma_\frac{3}{2}\partial(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{2\alpha-3|j|}}\bigg]\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij , j}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is immediate from the definition of the frame ( [ sframe ] ) and ( [ dr / dtau ] ) that @xmath320 hence , similarly to ( [ pest1 ] ) @xmath321\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij , j}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\\ \tag{$|j|\leq2$}&\lesssim\;(\mathcal{e}_0^\frac{1}{2}+\alpha^2 ) e_{3,\alpha } [ { u}]+e_{3,\alpha+1 } [ { u}].\end{aligned}\ ] ] _ remark _ : the term in the rhs of the preceding estimate with coefficient @xmath322 is not critical .
this is very important otherwise the overall estimates would not close , since the critical term with favourable sign in ( [ intp / dtau ] ) is only of magnitude @xmath60 .
we proceed to the boundary term in the rhs of ( [ pest2 ] ) .
recall that @xmath279 is constant on @xmath282 ( [ rhoconst ] ) , and decreasing in the interior direction of @xmath287 .
hence , the outward unit normal @xmath323 is the schwarzschild normalized gradient of @xmath279 on @xmath278 , @xmath324 .
since @xmath325 is a symmetric positive definite matrix , the following standard inequality holds : @xmath326 therefore , we have the bound @xmath327 ^ 2}{r^{2\alpha-3|j| } } -\frac{2\omega \overline{h}^{a0}\partial_a(\rho)}{|^s\overline{\nabla}\rho_\tau| } \frac{\big[\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij , j}\big]^2}{r^{2\alpha-3|j|}}ds\\ & \notag+\frac{1}{2}\int_{\partial\sigma_\tau^{\overline{u } } } \frac{\overline{h}^{ab}}{|^s\overline{\nabla}\rho|}\frac{\partial_a(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j| } } \frac{\partial_b(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j|}}ds\end{aligned}\ ] ] the remaining term to be estimated is the one on first line in the rhs of ( [ pest2 ] ) , which we rewrite @xmath328\frac{\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j|}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\\ = & -\int_{\sigma_\tau^{\overline{u}}}\big(\overline{h}^{ab}\partial_a\partial_b(u_\nu)_{ij , j}\big ) \omega\frac{\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{2\alpha-3|j|}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\\ \notag&+\int_{\sigma_\tau^{\overline{u}}}2\omega \overline{h}^{a0 } \frac{\partial_a\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij , j}\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{2\alpha-3|j| } } + \omega { h } \frac{\gamma_\frac{3}{2}\partial(u_\nu)_{ij , j}\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{2\alpha-3|j|}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] by taking the @xmath329 derivative ( @xmath295 spatial multi - index @xmath306 ) of the first equation in ( [ modboxu ] ) and commuting the differentiation in the lhs we obtain the equation @xmath330 + [ \overline{h}^{ab}\partial_a\partial_b,\partial^{(j)}](u_\nu)_{ij},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the commutator can in turn be written schematically as : [ recall ( [ overasym1]),([gamma_q ] ) ] @xmath331(u_\nu)_{ij}=&\ ; { \partial}^2 ( { \overline{h } } ) { \partial}^2(u_\nu)_{ij } + \big[\gamma_\frac{3}{2}\partial(\overline{h})+\gamma_3\overline{h}\big ] { \partial}^2(u_\nu)_{ij}\\ & \notag+ { \partial(\overline{h } ) } { \partial}^3(u_\nu)_{ij } + { \overline{h}\gamma_\frac{3}{2 } } { \partial}^3(u_\nu)_{ij}\\ \notag&+\big [ { \partial(\overline{h})\gamma_3}+\overline{h}\gamma_\frac{9}{2}\big ] { \partial}(u_\nu)_{ij}\qquad\text { if $ |j|=2$}\\ \notag[\overline{h}^{ab}\partial_a\partial_b,\partial^{(j)}](u_\nu)_{ij}=&\ ; \partial ( { \overline{h } } ) { \partial}^2(u_\nu)_{ij } + { \overline{h}\gamma_\frac{3}{2 } } { \partial}^2(u_\nu)_{ij}\qquad\qquad\text{if $ |j|=1$}\\ \notag&+ { \overline{h}\gamma_3 } { \partial}(u_\nu)_{ij}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we integrate by parts in the second term on the rhs of ( [ pest5 ] ) and argue similarly to ( [ pest3 ] ) to get @xmath332 ^ 2}{r^{2\alpha-3|j|}}n_a ds -\int_{\sigma_\tau^{\overline{u}}}\omega \partial_a(\overline{h}^{a0 } ) \frac{\big[\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij , j}\big]^2}{r^{2\alpha-3|j|}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\\ & \notag-\int_{\sigma_\tau^{\overline{u}}}\overline{h}^{a0 } \partial_a(\frac{\omega}{r^{2\alpha-3|j|}})\big[\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij , j}\big]^2d\mu_{^s\overline{g } } + \int_{\sigma_\tau^{\overline{u}}}\omega \overline{h}\gamma_\frac{3}{2 } \frac{\big[\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij , j}\big]^2}{r^{2\alpha-3|j|}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\\ & \notag+\int_{\sigma_\tau^{\overline{u}}}\omega \overline{h } \frac{\gamma_\frac{3}{2}\partial(u_\nu)_{ij , j}\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{2\alpha-3|j|}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\\ \notag\leq&\int_{\partial\sigma_\tau^{\overline{u}}}\omega \overline{h}^{a0 } \frac{\big[\partial_0(u_\nu)_{ij , j}\big]^2}{r^{2\alpha-3|j|}}n_a ds + c(\mathcal{e}_0^{\frac{1}{2}}+\alpha^2)e_{3,\alpha } [ { u } ] + ce_{3,\alpha+1 } [ { u}]\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , for the last and main term in the first line of the rhs of ( [ pest5 ] ) we recall that @xmath333 to obtain directly from cauchy s inequality @xmath334 we proceed by plugging the rhs of ( [ modboxu , j ] ) into the first term in the last inequality ( [ pest7 ] ) above and treat each arising group of terms separately .
employing the basic inequalities in proposition [ adaptineq ] along with the bounds of @xmath335 ( [ venest ] ) , ( [ norme_0barf ] ) and ( [ linftybarf ] ) we derive : @xmath336}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j|-\frac{1}{2}}}\big\|^2_{l^2}\\ \notag\lesssim&\;\| { \overline{o}}\|^2_{l^\infty}e_{3,\alpha+1 } [ { u } ] + \| { \partial(\overline{o})}\|^2_{l^\infty}e_{2,\alpha } [ { u}]+\| { u}\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha+1}}\\ & + \|\frac{\partial^{(j ) } ( { \overline{o } } ) \gamma_\frac{3}{2}\partial u}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j|-\frac{1}{2}}}\|^2_{l^2 } \notag+\|\frac{\partial^{(j ) } ( { \overline{o } } ) { \gamma_3 u}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j|-\frac{1}{2}}}\|^2_{l^2}\\ \tag{the last two terms appear only in the case $ |j|=2$}\lesssim&\;\mathcal{e } ( { \overline{u},\overline{o}};\alpha , t)e_{3,\alpha } [ { u}]+e_{3,\alpha+1 } [ { u } ] + \big(\| { u}\|^2_{l^\infty}+\|\partial u\|^2_{l^\infty}\big)\|\frac{\partial^{(j ) } ( { \overline{o}})}{r^{\alpha-\frac{1}{2}}}\|_{l^2}^2\\ \lesssim&\;\notag\mathcal{e}_0e_{3,\alpha } [ { u}]+e_{3,\alpha+1 } [ { u}]\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath337}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j|-\frac{1}{2}}}\big\|^2_{l^2}\\ \notag\lesssim&\;\| { o - i}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{5}{2 } } } + \| { \partial\overline{o}}\|^2_{l^\infty}\| { o - i}\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\\ & \notag+\big(\|\frac { { o - i}}{r^\frac{3}{2}}\|^2_{l^\infty}+\| { \partial(o - i)}\|_{l^\infty}^2\big)\|\frac{\partial^{(j ) } ( { \overline{o}})}{r^{\alpha-\frac{1}{2}}}\|^2_{l^2}\\ \tag{we include the last term only when $ |j|=2 $ and utilize ( \ref{norme_0barf}),(\ref{norme_0f } ) } \lesssim&\;\| { o - i}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{5}{2 } } } + ( \mathcal{e}_0 ^ 2+\mathcal{e}_0)\| { o - i}\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha+\frac{3}{2 } } } + \mathcal{e}_0\|o - i\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\\ \notag&+\mathcal{e}_0 ^ 3+\mathcal{e}_0\|u\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath338}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}|j|-\frac{1}{2}}}\big\|^2_{l^2}\\ \notag\lesssim&\;\bigg[\|\frac { { \overline{u}}}{r^\frac{3}{2}}\|^2_{l^\infty}+\|\frac { { \partial\overline{u}}}{r^\frac{3}{2}}\|^2_{l^\infty } + \| { \partial\overline{o}}\|^2_{l^\infty}\big(\| { \overline{u}}\|^2_{l^\infty}+\|\partial\overline{u}\|^2_{l^\infty}\big)\bigg]e_{3,\alpha } [ { \overline{u}}]\\ & \notag+\| { \overline{u}}\|^2_{l^\infty}\|\partial\overline{u}\|^2_{l^\infty}\| { \overline{o}-i}\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha+\frac{3}{2 } } } + \big(\| { \overline{u}}\|^4_{l^\infty } + \| { \overline{u}}\|^2_{l^\infty}\|\partial\overline{u}\|^2_{l^\infty}\big ) \| { \overline{u}}\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha}}\\ & \notag+\|\partial\overline{o}\|^2_{l^\infty}e_{3,\alpha } [ { \overline{u } } ] + \|\frac{\partial^2 ( \overline{o}-i)\partial^2 \overline{u}}{r^{\alpha-3-\frac{1}{2}}}\|^2_{l^2}+\|\partial\overline{u}\|^2_{l^\infty } \| { \overline{o}-i}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\\ \notag&+\big(\| { \partial\overline{o}}\|^4_{l^\infty}+\| { \partial\overline{o}}\|^2_{l^\infty}\| { \partial\overline{u}}\|^2_{l^\infty}\big)\big(\| { \overline{o}-i}\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}+e_{2,\alpha } [ { \overline{u}}]\big)\\ \lesssim&\;\notag\mathcal{e } ( { \overline{u},\overline{o}};\alpha , t)^2+\mathcal{e } ( { \overline{u},\overline{o}};\alpha , t)^3 + \|\frac{\partial^2 ( { \overline{o}})}{r^{\frac{\alpha}{2}-\frac{3}{2}-\frac{1}{4}}}\|^2_{l^4 } \|\frac{\partial^2 ( { \overline{u}})}{r^{\frac{\alpha}{2}-\frac{3}{2}-\frac{1}{4}}}\|^2_{l^4}\\ \tag{employing the $ l^4 $ estimate ( \ref{l4})}\lesssim&\;\mathcal{e}_0 ^ 2+\mathcal{e}_0 ^ 3+\alpha^3\mathcal{e}_0 ^ 2\end{aligned}\ ] ] by ( [ pest8])-([pest10 ] ) we have the following lemma . [ e_0e_0u ] @xmath339;h^{1,\alpha-3})\cap l^2([0,t];h^{1,\alpha-2})$ ] and
moreover the following estimate holds : @xmath340}\\ \lesssim&\ ; \mathcal{e}_0\big(e_{3,\alpha } [ { u}]+\| { o - i}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\big)+e_{3,\alpha+1 } [ { u } ] + \| { o - i}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{5}{2}}}\\ \notag&+\alpha^3\mathcal{e}_0 ^ 2 + \mathcal{e}_0 ^ 3,\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath341 , @xmath342 , @xmath300 . the proof follows by solving for @xmath343 in the equation ( [ modboxu ] ) and summing up the above estimates ( [ pest8])-([pest10 ] ) . to bound the commutator ( [ comm ] ) we treat the cases @xmath344 , @xmath345 separately . for @xmath345 : @xmath346(u_\nu)_{ij}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}-\frac{1}{2}}}\big\|^2_{l^2}\\ \notag=&\;\big\|\frac{\partial ( { \overline{h } } ) { \partial}^2(u_\nu)_{ij } + { \overline{h}\gamma_\frac{3}{2 } } { \partial}^2(u_\nu)_{ij } + { \overline{h}\gamma_3 } { \partial}(u_\nu)_{ij}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}-\frac{1}{2}}}\big\|^2_{l^2}\\ \notag\lesssim&\;\|\partial\overline { h}\|^2_{l^\infty}\|\frac{\partial^2(u_\nu)_{ij}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{3}{2}-\frac{1}{2}}}\|^2_{l^2}+ \|\overline { h}\|^2_{l^\infty}\|\frac{\partial^2(u_\nu)_{ij}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{1}{2}}}\|^2_{l^2 } + \|\overline { h}\|^2_{l^\infty}\|\frac{\partial(u_\nu)_{ij}}{r^{\alpha+1}}\|^2_{l^2}\\ \tag{employing ( \ref{e_0e_0uest } ) in the case $ \partial^2(u_\nu)_{ij}=\partial_0 ^ 2(u_\nu)_{ij}$}\lesssim&\;\mathcal{e}_0\big(e_{3,\alpha } [ { u}]+\| { o - i}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\big)+e_{3,\alpha+1 } [ { u } ] + \| { o - i}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{5}{2}}}\\ & \notag+\alpha^3\mathcal{e}_0 ^ 2 + \mathcal{e}_0 ^ 3\end{aligned}\ ] ] when @xmath344 we have @xmath347(u_\nu)_{ij}}{r^{\alpha-3-\frac{1}{2}}}\big\|^2_{l^2}\\ \notag\lesssim&\ ; \big\|\frac { { \partial}^2 ( { \overline{h } } ) { \partial}^2(u_\nu)_{ij } + \big[\gamma_\frac{3}{2}\partial(\overline{h})+\gamma_3\overline{h}\big ] { \partial}^2(u_\nu)_{ij}}{r^{\alpha-3-\frac{1}{2}}}\big\|^2_{l^2}\\ \notag&+\big\|\frac { { \partial(\overline{h } ) } { \partial}^3(u_\nu)_{ij } + { \overline{h}\gamma_\frac{3}{2 } } { \partial}^3(u_\nu)_{ij } + \big [ { \partial(\overline{h})\gamma_3}+\overline{h}\gamma_\frac{9}{2}\big ] { \partial}(u_\nu)_{ij}}{r^{\alpha-3-\frac{1}{2}}}\big\|^2_{l^2}\\ \tag{note that term $ \partial^3(u_\nu)_{ij}$ contains at most two $ \partial_0 $ derivatives}\lesssim&\;\|\frac{\partial^2 \overline{h}}{r^{\frac{\alpha}{2}-\frac{3}{2}-\frac{1}{4}}}\|^2_{l^4 } \|\frac{\partial^2(u_\nu)_{ij}}{r^{\frac{\alpha}{2}-\frac{3}{2}-\frac{1}{4}}}\|^2_{l^4 } + \|\partial \overline{h}\|^2_{l^2}\big(e_{3,\alpha } [ { u } ] + \|\partial_0 ^ 2(u_\nu)_{ij}\big\|^2_{h^{1,\alpha-3}}\big)\\ \notag&+\|\overline { h}\|^2_{l^\infty}\big(e_{3,\alpha+1 } [ { u}]+\big\|\partial_0 ^ 2(u_\nu)_{ij}\|^2_{h^{1,\alpha-2}}\big)\\ \tag{employing the $ l^4 $ estimate ( \ref{l4 } ) and ( \ref{e_0e_0uest})}\lesssim&\;\alpha^3\mathcal{e}_0e_{3,\alpha } [ { u}]+\mathcal{e}_0e_{3,\alpha } [ { u}]+e_{3,\alpha+1 } [ { u } ] + \mathcal{e}_0\| { o - i}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{3}{2 } } } + \| { o - i}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{5}{2}}}\\ \notag&+\alpha^3\mathcal{e}_0 ^ 2 + \mathcal{e}_0 ^ 3\end{aligned}\ ] ] * summary * : incorporating ( [ intp / dtau])-([pest12 ] ) in ( [ e / dtau ] ) we conclude that @xmath348+e_{3,\alpha+1 } [ { u}]+\| { o - i}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{5}{2}}}\\ & \notag+\mathcal{e}_0\| { o - i}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{3}{2 } } } + \alpha^3\mathcal{e}_0 ^ 2+\mathcal{e}_0 ^ 3\end{aligned}\ ] ] summing over the indices @xmath172 and @xmath295 , @xmath306 , we arrive at the desired estimate ( [ e_sest ] ) .
let @xmath295 , @xmath349 , be a spatial multi - index .
like in the case of ( [ e / dtau ] ) , it follows from the coarea formula and the asymptotics ( [ dr / dtau]),([dmu / dtau ] ) that @xmath350 where @xmath351 . by cauchy
s inequality we have ( @xmath352 ) @xmath353 taking the @xmath329 derivative of the ode in ( [ modboxu ] ) we obtain @xmath354+[\partial_0,\partial^{(j)}](o^d_c-{{i_c}^d})\end{aligned}\ ] ] the commutator in the rhs of ( [ mode_0f , j ] ) schematically reads @xmath355(o^d_c-{{i_c}^d})=&\;\gamma_\frac{3}{2}\partial(o^d_c-{{i_c}^d})&&\text{if $ |j|=1$}\\ \notag=&\;\gamma_3\partial(o^d_c-{{i_c}^d } ) + \gamma_\frac{3}{2}\partial^2(o^d_c-{{i_c}^d})&&\text{if $ |j|=2$}\\ \notag=&\;\gamma_\frac{9}{2}\partial(o^d_c-{{i_c}^d } ) + \gamma_3\partial^2(o^d_c-{{i_c}^d})&&\text{if $ |j|=3$}\\ & + \notag \gamma_\frac{3}{2}\partial^3(o^d_c-{{i_c}^d}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we note that at most one @xmath107 derivative of @xmath198 appears in the preceding expressions .
hence , we deduce directly from ( [ mode_0f , j ] ) : @xmath356(o^d_c-{i_c}^d)}{r^{\alpha+\frac{5}{2}-\frac{3}{2}|j|}}\|^2_{l^2}\\ \tag{exmploying lemma \ref{sobprop } and applying the $ l^\infty$ bound on $ ( { \overline{o}- i } ) { \overline{u}}$ } \lesssim&\ ; \| { o - i}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{5}{2}}}+e_{3,\alpha+1 } [ { u } ] + \| { \overline{o}- i}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\| { \overline{u}}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha}}\\ & \notag+\|\frac { { \gamma_\frac{3}{2}\partial}(o^d_c-{i_c}^d)}{r^{\alpha+\frac{5}{2}-\frac{3}{2}}}\|^2_{l^2 } + \|\frac { { \gamma_3\partial}(o^d_c-{i_c}^d ) + \gamma_\frac{3}{2}\partial^2(o^d_c-{i_c}^d)}{r^{\alpha+\frac{5}{2}-3}}\|^2_{l^2}\\ \notag&+\|\frac{\gamma_\frac{9}{2}\partial(o^d_c-{i_c}^d ) + \gamma_3\partial^2(o^d_c-{i_c}^d ) + \gamma_\frac{3}{2}\partial^3(o^d_c-{i_c}^d)}{r^{\alpha+\frac{5}{2}-\frac{9}{2}}}\|^2_{l^2}\\ \lesssim&\notag\ ; \| { o - i}\|^2_{h^{3,\alpha+\frac{5}{2 } } } + \mathcal{e } ( { \overline{u},\overline{o}};\alpha , t)^2 + e_{3,\alpha+1 } [ { u}]\end{aligned}\ ] ] combining ( [ f - i / dtau])-([f - iest2 ] ) we derive @xmath357+\mathcal{e}_0 ^ 2\end{aligned}\ ] ] taking into account the set of indices @xmath358 and @xmath295 , @xmath349 , we complete the proof of ( [ oest ] ) and hence of proposition [ mainenest ] . we proceed to show that the mapping defined via ( [ modboxu ] ) in the beginning of [ enest ] is a contraction .
let us consider another solution set @xmath359 of the analogous coupled system ( [ modboxu ] ) .
setting @xmath360 we obtain schematically the new system of equations ( depicting only the types of terms in the rhs suppressing the particular indices ) @xmath361\\ \notag&+ { \overline{o}}\gamma_3\partial(d { f } ) + ( { \overline{o}+\tilde{\overline{o}}})d { \overline{o}}\partial^2(\tilde{u}_\nu)_{ij}+g(d { \overline{u}},d { \overline{o}}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath362 and @xmath363 further , we assume that both sets of variables we have introduced are consistent with the energy estimate ( [ uenest ] ) we have established in the previous subsection : @xmath364 _ claim _ : for large enough @xmath45 and @xmath57 is sufficiently small the following contraction holds : @xmath365+\sum_{c , d}\|do^d_c\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\leq \kappa\big(e_{2,\alpha}[d { \overline{u}}]+\sum\|d { \overline{o}}\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\big),\end{aligned}\ ] ] for some @xmath366 .
[ contrh2 ] we are forced to close the contraction mapping argument in @xmath197 , having one derivative less than the space of the energy estimate ( [ tildeenest ] ) , see [ enest ] , as it is common in 2@xmath367-order quasilinear hyperbolic pde @xcite , because of the problematic term @xmath368 in ( [ boxdu ] ) , which is generated from the difference of the top order terms in the lhs . [ maincontrest ] under the above considerations ,
the following estimates hold : @xmath369 + 8m^2e^{-1}(1-\tau)\alpha e_{2,\alpha+1}[d { u}]\\ \notag\lesssim&\ ; ( \mathcal{e}_0^\frac{1}{2}+\mathcal{e}_0+\alpha^2)e_{2,\alpha}[d { u}]+e_{2,\alpha+1}[d { u } ] + \|d { f}\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha+\frac{5}{2}}}\\ & \notag+(\mathcal{e}_0+\mathcal{e}_0 ^ 2+\alpha^3\mathcal{e}_0)\big(e_{2,\alpha}[d { \overline{u}}]+\|d { \overline{o}}\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\big)\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath370+\mathcal{e}_0\big(e_{2,\alpha}[d { \overline{u}}]+\|d { \overline{o}}\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\big),\end{aligned}\ ] ] for all @xmath300 . assuming proposition [ maincontrest ] we prove the above claim ( [ contr ] ) . after summing ( [ contreest]),([contrfest ] )
, we absorb into the lhs the critical terms @xmath371,\|do\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha+\frac{5}{2}}},\end{aligned}\ ] ] which appear in the rhs of the above inequalities .
this is done by picking the parameter @xmath60 sufficiently large ( but finite ) . the contraction estimate ( [ contr ] ) then follows from gronwall s inequality for @xmath57 suitably small .
the proof follows exactly the lines of the proof of proposition [ mainenest ] .
the only notable difference lies in the estimation of the analogous term to ( [ pest7 ] ) , derived in ( [ pest8])-([pest12 ] ) .
we sketch the argument in the present situation : + let @xmath295 denote at most one spatial index , @xmath341 , either @xmath372 or @xmath373 .
the main term to be estimated is @xmath374\omega \frac{\partial_0(du_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{2\alpha-3}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\\ \lesssim\tag{recall $ \omega\lesssim\frac{1}{r^\frac{1}{2}}$}&\;\|\frac{\partial_0(du_\nu)_{ij , j}}{r^{\alpha-\frac{1}{2}}}\|^2_{l^2 } + \big\|\frac{\partial^{(j)}\big[\text{rhs of ( \ref{boxdu})}\big]}{r^{\alpha-2}}\big\|^2_{l^2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath375 .
plugging in ( [ boxdu ] ) and using the basic estimates in proposition [ adaptineq ] , along with the assumption ( [ tildeenest ] ) we obtain @xmath376}{r^{\alpha-2}}\big\|^2_{l^2}\\ \lesssim&\ ; \notag\big\|\frac{\partial^{(j)}\big ( { \overline{o}}\gamma_\frac{3}{2}\partial(d { u } ) + { \overline{o}}\gamma_3d { u } + \overline{o}\gamma_\frac{9}{2}d { o}\big)}{r^{\alpha-2}}\big\|^2_{l^2}\\ & \notag+\big\|\frac{\partial^{(j)}\big(d { \overline{o}}\big[\gamma_\frac{3}{2}\partial\tilde{u}+\gamma_3 { \tilde{u}}+\gamma_\frac{9}{2 } ( { \tilde{o}-i } ) + \gamma_3\partial { \tilde{o}}\big]\big)}{r^{\alpha-2}}\big\|^2_{l^2}\\ \notag&+\big\|\frac{\partial^{(j)}\big ( { \overline{o}}\gamma_3\partial(do)\big)}{r^{\alpha-2}}\big\|^2_{l^2 } + \big\|\frac{\partial^{(j)}\big [ ( { \overline{o}+\tilde{\overline{o}}})d { \overline{o}}\partial^2(\tilde{u}_\nu)_{ij}\big]}{r^{\alpha-2}}\big\|^2_{l^2}\\ \notag&+\|\frac{\partial^{(j)}g(d { \overline{u}},d { \overline{o}})}{r^{\alpha-2}}\|^2_{l^2}\\ \tag{recall the asymptotics ( \ref{gamma_q } ) } \lesssim&\;\|\frac{\partial^{(j)}\partial(d { u})}{r^{\alpha-\frac{1}{2}}}\|^2_{l^2 } + \|\frac{\partial(d { u})}{r^{\alpha+1}}\|^2_{l^2 } + \|\frac{d { u}}{r^{\alpha+\frac{5}{2}}}\|^2_{l^2 } + \mathcal{e}_0\big(\|\frac{\partial(d { u})}{r^{\alpha-\frac{1}{2}}}\|^2_{l^2 } + \|\frac{d { u}}{r^{\alpha+1}}\|^2_{l^2}\big ) \\ \notag&+\|\frac{\partial^{(j)}(do)}{r^{\alpha+\frac{5}{2}}}\|_{l^2}^2 + \|\frac{do}{r^{\alpha+4}}\|_{l^2}^2 + \mathcal{e}_0\|\frac{do}{r^{\alpha+\frac{5}{2}}}\|_{l^2}^2\\ \notag&+\mathcal{e}_0\|\frac{\partial^{(j)}(d { \overline{o}})}{r^{\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\|^2_{l^2}+\|\frac{d { \overline{o}}}{r^{\frac{3}{2}}}\|^2_{l^\infty}\big ( \| { \tilde{u}}\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha}}+\| { \tilde{o}-i}\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\big)\\ \notag&+\|\frac{\partial^{(j)}\partial(do)}{r^{\alpha+1}}\|^2_{l^2 } + \|\frac{\partial(do)}{r^{\alpha+\frac{5}{2}}}\|^2_{l^2 } + \mathcal{e}_0\|\frac{\partial(do)}{r^{\alpha+1}}\|^2_{l^2}\\ \notag&+\big\|\frac{\partial^{(j)}\big [ ( { \overline{o}+\tilde{\overline{o}}})d { \overline{o}}\partial^2(\tilde{u}_\nu)_{ij}\big]}{r^{\alpha-2}}\big\|^2_{l^2}+\|\frac{\partial^{(j)}g(d { \overline{u}},d { \overline{o}})}{r^{\alpha-2}}\|^2_{l^2}\\ \notag\lesssim&\;e_{2,\alpha+1}[d { u } ] + \mathcal{e}_0e_{2,\alpha}[d { u } ] + \|do\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha+\frac{5}{2 } } } + \mathcal{e}_0\|do\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\\ & \notag+\mathcal{e}_0\|d { \overline{o}}\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha+\frac{3}{2 } } } + \big\|\frac{\partial^{(j)}\big [ ( { \overline{o}+\tilde{\overline{o}}})d { \overline{o}}\partial^2(\tilde{u}_\nu)_{ij}\big]}{r^{\alpha-2}}\big\|^2_{l^2}+\|\frac{\partial^{(j)}g(d { \overline{u}},d { \overline{o}})}{r^{\alpha-2}}\|^2_{l^2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we proceed to the problematic term @xmath368 which can be controlled only in @xmath377 : @xmath378}{r^{\alpha-2}}\big\|^2_{l^2}\\ \lesssim\notag&\;\|\partial^{(j)}{(\overline{o}+\tilde{\overline{o}})}\|^2_{l^\infty } \|d { \overline{o}}\|^2_{l^\infty}\|\frac{\partial^2(\tilde{u}_\nu)_{ij}}{r^{\alpha-2}}\|^2_{l^2 } + \| { \overline{o}+\tilde{\overline{o}}}\|^2_{l^\infty}\|\frac{\partial^{(j)}(d { \overline{o}})}{r^{\frac{\alpha}{2}-1}}\|^2_{l^4}\\ \notag&\cdot\|\frac{\partial^2(\tilde{u}_\nu)_{ij}}{r^{\frac{\alpha}{2}-1}}\|^2_{l^4 } + \| { \overline{o}+\tilde{\overline{o}}}\|^2_{l^\infty } \|\frac{d { \overline{o}}}{r}\|^2_{l^\infty}\|\frac{\partial^{(j)}\partial^2(\tilde{u}_\nu)_{ij}}{r^{\alpha-2}}\|^2_{l^2}\\ \lesssim&\;\tag{employing the $ l^4 $ estimate ( \ref{l4 } ) } ( \mathcal{e}^2_0+\alpha^3\mathcal{e}^2_0)\|d { \overline{o}}\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , plugging in the nonlinearity ( [ g ] ) , we have the bound @xmath379+(\mathcal{e}_0 + 1)\|d { \overline{u}}\|^2_{l^\infty}\|\frac{\partial^{(j ) } { \partial\tilde{\overline{u}}}}{r^{\alpha-2}}\|^2_{l^2}+\|\frac{\partial^2 { ( \overline{o})}\partial(d { \overline{u}})}{r^{\alpha-2}}\|^2_{l^2}\\ \notag&+(\mathcal{e}_0+\mathcal{e}_0 ^ 2)\|d { \overline{o}}\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}+\|\frac{\partial(d { \overline{o}})\partial^2 { \tilde{\overline{u}}}}{r^{\alpha-2}}\|^2_{l^2 } + \|d { \overline{o}}\|^2_{l^\infty}\mathcal{e}_0 ^ 2\\ \lesssim&\;\notag ( \mathcal{e}_0+\mathcal{e}_0 ^ 2)\big(e_{2,\alpha}[d { \overline{u}}]+\|d { \overline{o}}\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\big)+\|\frac{\partial^2 { \overline{o}}}{r^{\frac{\alpha}{2}-1}}\|^2_{l^4}\|\frac{\partial(d { \overline{u}})}{r^{\frac{\alpha}{2}-1}}\|^2_{l^4}\\ & \notag+\|\frac{\partial(d { \overline{o}})}{r^{\frac{\alpha}{2}-1}}\|^2_{l^4}\|\frac{\partial^2 { \tilde{\overline{u}}}}{r^{\frac{\alpha}{2}-1}}\|^2_{l^4}\\ \lesssim&\;\tag{by the $ l^4 $ estimate ( \ref{l4 } ) } ( \mathcal{e}_0+\mathcal{e}_0 ^ 2+\alpha^3\mathcal{e}_0)\big(e_{2,\alpha}[d { \overline{u}}]+\|d { \overline{o}}\|^2_{h^{2,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\big)\end{aligned}\ ] ]
in this section we prove theorem [ thmb ] , our main stability result for the constraint equations ( [ const ] ) . the proof is based on mapping properties of the constraint map @xcite @xcite @xcite and the implicit function theorem . although similar results have been achieved in the smooth case and some rough backgrounds ( see @xcite for a general exposition ) , to our knowledge , the singular schwarzschild background ( [ schwarz ] ) eludes the standard references in the literature
. it would be interesting to obtain perturbations @xmath35 of the schwarzschild initial data set @xmath43 on the singular hypersurface @xmath0 , which satisfy the assumptions of theorem [ thma ] , in a more constructive way .
a general such construction would make use of the conformal method @xcite that we do not employ here . however , one of the main obstructions to overcome in this approach is that the mean curvature @xmath380 of the perturbation is unbounded .
in fact , one can check ( [ schwarz ] ) that @xmath381 the results in the literature of the constraints using the conformal method were restricted in the past to the constant mean curvature ( cmc ) or ` near cmc ' regime @xcite .
recently , there has been a number of advances to the case of large mean curvature , ` far from cmc ' , @xcite . yet
these results contain certain regularity assumptions which in particular imply that the mean curvature of the initial data set is in @xmath206 and therefore do not apply to our case .
we consider below various tensors living in the weighted spaces @xmath382 we have introduced ( [ hsa ] ) .
it will always be implied that this is understood by assuming their components , evaluated w.r.t .
the schwarzschild frame ( [ sframe ] ) , lie in the same spaces .
let @xmath383 denote the constraint map of the perturbed initial data @xmath384 on @xmath385 .
[ bdc1 ] @xmath386 is well - defined , bounded and @xmath387 ( frchet ) .
first , we express @xmath386 in terms of differences of perturbed and schwarzschild components .
since the schwarzschild pair @xmath388 ) satisfies the constraints ( [ const ] ) , we write schematically : @xmath389 where @xmath390 .
the boundedness of @xmath386 now follows in part from lemma [ sobprop ] , using the asymptotics ( [ overasym1]),([overasym2 ] ) , and by applying the @xmath206 bound ( [ linfty ] ) on the quadratic terms @xmath391 , @xmath392 , @xmath393 . realizing that @xmath394 is @xmath387 in the variable @xmath395 ( by expressing @xmath394 in terms of @xmath396 )
, we conclude that @xmath386 is also @xmath387 in the above weighted spaces ( taking into account the previous asymptotics and properties used ) .
[ hsa(x ) ] in view of the asymptotics ( [ rasym ] ) of the radius function @xmath8 , at @xmath40 , we may replace the @xmath190 norm ( [ hsa ] ) , at our convenience , with the equivalent norm @xmath397 where @xmath398 is the induced schwarzschild connection on @xmath399 ; we replace @xmath329 with @xmath400 in ( [ hsa ] ) as well , since the weights in the norm can exactly tolerate the most singular coefficients ( [ overasym1 ] ) of any additional generated terms .
our strategy is to fix the boundary components ( close to schwarzschild ) and then solve for the variables in the interior via a perturbation . for this purpose
we introduce the functions @xmath401 where by @xmath402 we denote the set of functions in @xmath403 having zero trace on the boundary of @xmath0 .
has two components diffeomorphic to the sphere .
] we fix @xmath404 and study @xmath386 under variations of the variables @xmath405 .
whence , we can view @xmath386 as a map @xmath406 let @xmath407 be the frchet derivative of @xmath386 w.r.t . the variables
@xmath408 about zero , that is , the schwarzschild initial data ; @xmath409 .
the following theorem is our stability result for the constraint equations .
[ conststab ] let @xmath45 be sufficiently large , consistent with theorems [ mainthm ] , [ mainthm2 ] .
then @xmath410 is surjective , and the level set @xmath411 is non - empty , for every pair @xmath412 in a sufficiently small ball of @xmath413 .
[ constexist ] the preceding theorem implies the existence of non - spherically symmetric perturbations @xmath414 . ] of the schwarzschild initial data set @xmath415 on @xmath0 , compatible with the constraint equations ( [ const ] ) , which lie inside the weighted spaces @xmath416 , satisfying the assumptions of the local - in time - existence theorems [ mainthm ] , [ mainthm2 ]
. [ halfs ] we can construct perturbed initial data sets @xmath417 verifying the constraints ( [ const ] ) and the assumptions of theorems [ mainthm ] , [ mainthm2 ] , which are identical to the schwarzschild initial data set @xmath43 on @xmath418 and not spherically symmetric on the other ` half ' @xmath419 ( and vice versa ) by applying the arguments in this section only to the @xmath420 ` piece ' of the initial data . unfortunately , the formula of @xmath410 is quite complex @xcite @xcite and it is not easy to prove directly the surjectivity of @xmath410 .
we do not present the formula of @xmath410 here , since we are not going to use it .
instead , we follow an indirect argument of @xcite , which we adapt in our context .
we consider the restriction of @xmath386 ( [ psi ] ) in the subdomain @xmath421 where @xmath422 .
then the constraint map ( [ psi ] ) becomes ( @xcite ) @xmath423,\\ \notag&\varphi^{-2}[{^s\overline{\nabla}}^j({^sk}+\mathcal{l}_x{^s\overline{g}})_{ij}+4\varphi^{-1}{(^sk+\mathcal{l}_x{^s\overline{g}})_i}^j{^s\overline{\nabla}}_j\varphi\\ \notag&-2\varphi^{-1}{^s\overline{\nabla}}_i\varphi(\text{tr}_{{^s\overline{g}}}{^sk}+\mathcal{l}_x{^s\overline{g } } ) ] \big)\end{aligned}\ ] ] further , the linearization of @xmath424 at @xmath425 reads @xmath426 recall ( [ overasym1 ] ) , ( [ rasym ] ) to find the leading asymptotics , as @xmath427 , @xmath40 , of the singular schwarzschild components of @xmath428 : @xmath429 is the following proposition .
[ fred ] the operator @xmath430 is fredholm . in particular
, it has finite dim kernel and cokernel .
assuming proposition [ fred ] , we proceed to the proof of theorem [ conststab ] .
evidently , @xmath431 and hence by proposition [ fred ] @xmath410 has finite dimensional cokernel .
it follows that range@xmath410 is closed .
since range@xmath410 is closed , range@xmath432 ; @xmath433 being the adjoint of @xmath410 . therefore , in order to prove surjectivity , it suffices to show that @xmath434 .
we now recall a lemma from @xcite : [ monc ] the kernel of @xmath433 is in one - to - one correspondence with the set of killing vector fields of the einsteinian vacuum development of @xmath35 , i.e. , the schwarzschild region ( [ fol ] ) foliated by @xmath56}$ ] . picking @xmath60 large enough
, we can guarantee that none of the schwarzschild killing vector fields ( @xmath435 ) lie in @xmath436 , the domain of @xmath433 .
therefore , for this @xmath60 the condition kernel@xmath437 is verified and hence @xmath410 is surjective .
the second part of theorem [ conststab ] follows by the implicit function theorem .
we realize the following plan ( which is an adaptation of a usual argument from the non - singular case ) : given @xmath438 we define the bounded operator ( see lemma [ bdc1 ] ) @xmath439 where @xmath440 are the identity maps for the variables @xmath441 respectively .
then we show : [ siso ] @xmath442 is an isomorphism for @xmath438 sufficiently large . using the preceding proposition
, we obtain the fredholm property claimed in proposition [ fred ] as follows : + since @xmath442 is an isomorphism ( for large @xmath438 ) , it has a bounded inverse .
in fact , @xmath443 is a compact operator by a weighted version of rellich s theorem . by definition ( [ s ] ) the operators @xmath444 are also compact , since the rhss of ( [ dpsihats ] ) consist of compositions of bounded with compact operators .
thus , @xmath445 is fredholm . +
a note is in order here .
the key ingredient in the previous proof is the invertibility of the operator @xmath442 ( [ s ] ) .
as we shall see below we are able to prove proposition [ siso ] thanks to the precise analogy in the leading blow up orders ( [ constcoeff ] ) of the schwarzschild components appearing in the expression of the linearized map @xmath445 ( [ dpsihat ] ) .
we divide the proof of proposition [ siso ] in two steps .
recall the formula ( [ dpsihat ] ) .
[ 1 - 1 ] for every @xmath446 , @xmath148 , the system @xmath447 has a unique weak solution @xmath448 , provided @xmath438 is sufficiently large .
define the bilinear form @xmath449 } \mathcal{b}:&\;h^{1,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}_0\times h^{1,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}_0\to\mathbb{r}\\ \notag&\mathcal{b}[(\eta , y),(\xi , x)]=\big(\text{lhs of ( \ref{spde})},(\frac{\xi}{x^{2\alpha+3}},-\frac{x}{x^{2\alpha+3}})\big)_{l^2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we want to apply lax - milgram . for
that we must establish the two estimates : @xmath450\big|\lesssim \big(\|\eta\|_{h^{1,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}+\|y\|^2_{h^{1,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\big)\big(\|\xi\|_{h^{1,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}+\|x\|^2_{h^{1,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\big)\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath451\gtrsim \|\eta\|^2_{h^{1,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}+\sum_i\|y_i\|^2_{h^{1,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the bound ( [ lmest1 ] ) follows easily by cauchy - schwartz , taking into account the asymptotics ( [ constcoeff ] ) of the coefficients of ( [ spde ] ) .
hence , it suffices to show ( [ lmest2 ] ) .
we proceed by integrating by parts , employing the asymptotics ( [ constcoeff ] ) : @xmath452=\big(\text{lhs of ( \ref{spde})},(\frac{\eta}{x^{2\alpha+3}},-\frac{y}{x^{2\alpha+3}})\big)_{l^2}\ge\\ 8\int_{\sigma_0}\frac{|{^s\overline{\nabla } } \eta|^2}{x^{2\alpha+3}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}-c\alpha\int_{\sigma_0}\frac{|\eta{^s\overline{\nabla}}_j\eta|}{x^{2\alpha+3+\frac{1}{2}}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}+\sigma\int_{\sigma_0}\frac{\eta^2}{x^{2\alpha+6}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\\ -\;c\int_{\sigma_0}\frac{|\eta{^s\overline{\nabla}}_jy_k|}{x^{2\alpha+3+\frac{3}{2}}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g } } + \int_{\sigma_0}\frac{|{^s\overline{\nabla } } y|^2}{x^{2\alpha+3}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}-\int_{\sigma_0}|\overline{r}_{ki}|\frac{|y^ky^i|}{x^{2\alpha+3}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\\ -\;c\alpha\int_{\sigma_0}\frac{|y_k{^s\overline{\nabla}}_ay_b|}{x^{2\alpha+3+\frac{1}{2}}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g } } + \sigma\int_{\sigma_0}\frac{y^2}{x^{2\alpha+6}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\\ -\;c\int_{\sigma_0}\frac{|y_i{^s\overline{\nabla}}_j\eta|}{x^{2\alpha+3+\frac{3}{2}}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}- c\int_{\sigma_0}\frac{|\eta y_i|}{x^{2\alpha+5}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\ge\\ \tag{utilizing the estimate $ |^s\overline{\text{r}}_{ki}|\lesssim x^{-2}$ and applying c - s } \int_{\sigma_0}\frac{|{^s\overline{\nabla } } \eta|^2}{x^{2\alpha+3}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g } } + \frac{1}{2}\int_{\sigma_0}\frac{|{^s\overline{\nabla}}y|^2}{x^{2\alpha+3}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g } } + ( \sigma - c\alpha^2)\bigg[\int_{\sigma_0}\frac{\eta^2}{x^{2\alpha+6}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\\ + \int_{\sigma_0}\frac{y^2}{x^{2\alpha+6}}d\mu_{^s\overline{g}}\bigg]\end{aligned}\ ] ] taking @xmath453 large enough , @xmath454 , we arrive at ( [ lmest2 ] ) .
thus , the lax - milgram theorem can be applied for the system ( [ spde ] ) , from which the conclusion of the present proposition follows .
away from @xmath455 the coefficients of ( [ spde ] ) are smooth and bounded ( locally ) . by standard interior elliptic regularity theory
we derive that the weak solution in proposition [ 1 - 1 ] @xmath441 lies in @xmath456 .
next , we show that the solution of ( [ spde ] ) is in fact @xmath457 .
this implies that @xmath442 ( [ s ] ) is one to one and onto , proving proposition [ siso ] .
[ ellreg ] the weak solution @xmath448 of ( [ spde ] ) furnished by proposition [ 1 - 1 ] satisfies @xmath457 .
@xmath458 : multiplying ( [ spde ] ) with @xmath459 , commuting covariant derivatives and integrating by parts twice we arrive at @xmath460 using the bound @xmath461 and applying cauchy s inequality we deduce for @xmath453 large ( @xmath454 ) : @xmath462 since @xmath446 .
likewise for the @xmath463 ( i.e. , the other rotational direction ) .
the @xmath464 derivative of the functions @xmath465 is estimated separately : from ( [ spde ] ) we have @xmath466 + \sigma\|y\|^2_{h^{1,\alpha+\frac{3}{2}}}\\ + \;\sigma\|\eta\|^2_{h^{1,\alpha+\frac{3}{2 } } } + \|\frac{h}{x^\alpha}\|^2_{l^2}+\sum_i\|\frac{z_i}{x^\alpha}\|^2_{l^2}<+\infty.\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , @xmath467 . the full @xmath468 estimate is obtained by differentiating the system ( [ spde ] ) in the rotational directions @xmath469 , applying the same argument with the analogous weights and then/ differentiating ( [ spde ] ) in the @xmath470 direction .
given a spacetime @xmath2 and an orthonormal frame @xmath98 , one may change to a lorentz gauge frame @xmath226 by solving the following semilinear system of equations , which is derived by taking the divergence of ( [ x(o ) ] ) : @xmath471 where the terms without indices in the rhs stand for an algebraic expression of a finite number terms of the depicted type .
[ gaugemap ] if the above system ( which we write schematically as ) @xmath472 is well - posed in a certain solution space , then there exists a unique orthonormal frame @xmath473 with @xmath474 lying in that particular space , which is identical to @xmath98 on the initial hypersurface @xmath0 , verifies the lorentz gauge condition ( [ gauge ] ) and such that the connection coefficients @xmath475 , @xmath476 , are equal to a priori assigned functions on @xmath0 ; within the corresponding space of one order of regularity less than @xmath474 . it suffices to show that the initial data for ( [ boxo2 ] ) is uniquely determined by the assertions .
we set @xmath477 let @xmath478 then the transition formula ( [ trans ] ) for @xmath479 reads @xmath480 thus , the components @xmath481 can be freely prescribed initially by choosing @xmath482 in ( [ inito2 ] ) accordingly .
we will leave the reader to fill in the details for the fact that the solution @xmath116 of ( [ boxa3]),([partial_0frame ] ) corresponds to a spacetime @xmath2 .
this is a consequence of the necessary initial assumption ( [ initao ] ) .
one such immediate consequence follows from ( [ partial_0frame ] ) for @xmath483 : @xmath484},&&o^a_0(\tau=0)-{i_0}^a=0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] which implies @xmath485 and hence @xmath110 everywhere , since @xmath486}=0 $ ] .
the set of functions @xmath487 defines the orthonormal frame @xmath98 in @xmath67 through ( [ epartial ] ) and hence completely determines the metric @xmath55 .
what remains to be verified is that the connection coefficients of @xmath98 are indeed the @xmath101 s of the given solution . in other words
, we have to show that the connection @xmath488 induced by the solution set @xmath101 , @xmath489 is the levi - civita connection @xmath71 of the metric @xmath55 .
formally , one can not take this for granted .
it has to be retrieved from the equations ( [ boxa3]),([partial_0frame ] ) and the initial assumption ( [ initao ] ) . for example , the compatibility of @xmath488 with respect to @xmath55 is encoded in the skew - symmetry of the @xmath101 s @xmath490 which also has to be verified , since it is a priori valid only initially ( [ initao ] ) .
the way to do this is by deriving the following new system of equations from ( [ boxa3 ] ) for the symmetric sums : @xmath491}}^ke_k\big((a_\mu)_{ij}+(a_\mu)_{ji}\big ) + e^\mu\big({(a_{[\mu})_{\nu]}}^k\big[(a_k)_{ij}+(a_k)_{ji}\big]\big)\\ & + e_\nu\big(a\big[(a)_{ij}+(a)_{ji}\big]\big ) + e_\nu\big({(a^\mu)_\mu}^k\big[(a_k)_{ij}+(a_k)_{ij}\big]\big),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have assumed that the sum ( @xmath492+(@xmath493 corresponding to the term @xmath100 in the gauge condition ( [ gauge ] ) can be expressed as @xmath494 $ ] .
since ( [ suma ] ) has zero initial data ( [ initao ] ) , the symmetric sums are zero everywhere and hence the skew - symmetry ( [ dg ] ) propagates . ) , which in the singular schwarzschild background is derived in [ enest ] for the more involved quasilinear system ( [ system1 ] ) . ]
recall ( [ redeq ] ) and the reduced equations @xmath105 . by assumption @xmath101 is a solution of ( [ boxa3 ] ) , i.e. , the rhs of ( [ redeq ] ) vanishes . taking the divergence of ( [ redeq ] ) with respect to the index @xmath495 , the first part of the lhs of ( [ redeq ] ) ,
corresponding to the curl of the ricci tensor , vanishes and we are left with @xmath496 the lorentz gauge condition is valid initially ( [ inita ] ) .
if the @xmath497 derivative of @xmath498 is zero as well on @xmath0 , then the lorentz gauge is valid in all of @xmath499 $ ] .
is of second order in @xmath500 and hence not at the level of initial data for ( [ boxa3 ] ) , which we are allowed to prescribe . if zero initially
, this should be a consequence of the geometric nature of the equations .
] this is in fact implied by ( [ redeq ] ) , putting @xmath501 we have @xmath502 by virtue of the vanishing of @xmath503 ( [ inita ] ) and the ( twice contracted ) second bianchi identity , @xmath504 , to replace if necessary a transversal derivative with tangential ones to @xmath0 . on the other hand , taking the @xmath505 divergence of ( [ redeq ] ) and commuting derivatives
we obtain @xmath506 where we employed again the twice contracted second bianchi identity and the fact that the scalar curvature @xmath507 vanishes everywhere : [ contracting @xmath508 in ( [ redeq ] ) ] @xmath509 now that we know the lorentz gauge is valid , the identities ( [ inita ] ) and ( [ redeq ] ) @xmath483 imply @xmath510 utilizing the second binachi identity @xmath511 once more , we conclude that @xmath512 vanishes and hence the initial data set of ( [ boxric ] ) is the trivial one .
thus , the initial condition @xmath513 ( [ inita ] ) propagates and the spacetime @xmath2 obtained from the solution of ( [ boxa3 ] ) verifies the eve ( [ eve ] ) . [ initfixed ] given the frame @xmath98 initially on @xmath0 , and once the components @xmath121 have been chosen , s are not fixed by the lorentz gauge condition ; cf .
lemma [ gaugemap ] .
they correspond to the @xmath107 derivative of the frame components @xmath94 , which we can freely assign initially .
] then the initial data set of ( [ boxa ] ) is fixed by condition ( [ inita ] ) , i.e. , the eve and lorentz gauge on @xmath0 .
indeed , the components @xmath514 , @xmath515 , are determined uniquely by the orthonormal frame @xmath153 on @xmath154 .
the @xmath516 s correspond to the components of second fundamental form @xmath517 of @xmath0 , which is given by the solution to the constraints ( [ const ] ) , included in ( [ inita ] )
. moreover , the expression of ( [ inita ] ) in terms of @xmath500 , for @xmath518 , reads ( schematically ) @xmath519 hence , the lhs functions are expressed in terms of already determined components .
finally , the rest components @xmath520 , @xmath515 , are fixed by the algebraic property of the riemann tensor @xmath521)_{ij}-{(a_{[\mu})_{\nu]}}^k(a_k)_{ij}=\\ e_i(a_j)_{0\nu}-e_j(a_i)_{0\nu}-([a_i , a_j])_{0\nu}-{(a_{[i})_{j]}}^k(a_k)_{0\nu}\end{aligned}\ ] ] or @xmath522 since all the terms in the rhs have been accounted for .
notice that the definition of riemann curvature was implicitly used in deriving ( [ boxric ] ) upon commuting covariant derivatives . | we study the backwards - in - time stability of the schwarzschild singularity from a dynamical pde point of view .
more precisely , considering a spacelike hypersurface @xmath0 in the interior of the black hole region , tangent to the singular hypersurface @xmath1 at a single sphere , we study the problem of perturbing the schwarzschild data on @xmath0 and solving the einstein vacuum equations backwards in time .
we obtain a local well - posedness result for small perturbations lying in certain weighted sobolev spaces .
no symmetry assumptions are imposed .
the perturbed spacetimes all have a singularity at a `` collapsed '' sphere on @xmath0 , where the leading asymptotics of the curvature and the metric match those of their schwarzschild counterparts to a suitably high order .
as in the schwarzschild backward evolution , the pinched initial hypersurface @xmath0 ` opens up ' instantly , becoming a smooth spacelike ( cylindrical ) hypersurface .
this result thus yields classes of examples of non - symmetric vacuum spacetimes , evolving forward - in - time from smooth initial data , which form a schwarzschild type singularity at a collapsed sphere .
we rely on a precise asymptotic analysis of the schwarzschild geometry near the singularity which turns out to be at the threshold that our energy methods can handle .
= 8 pt |
[ [ section ] ] large deviations of empirical measures have been widely studied in the literature since the celebrated sanov s theorem , which gives the large deviations principle in the scale of @xmath0 of the empirical measures of i. i. d. random variables with the relative entropy @xmath1 as the rate function .
another entropy , voiculescu s non - commutative entropy @xmath2 , arises in the study of fluctuations of eigenvalues of random matrices , see hiai & petz@xcite and the references therein .
chan @xcite interprets empirical measures of eigenvalues of random matrices as a system of interacting diffusions with singular interactions .
[ [ section-1 ] ] in this paper we study empirical measures which can be thought of as a decoupled version of the empirical measures generated by random matrices .
we are interested in empirical measures on @xmath3 generated by pairs of random variables that are tied together by a totally symmetric , and hence non - local , interaction , see formula ( [ f ] ) for the ( unnormalized ) joint density . under certain assumptions , we prove that the large deviation principle in the scale @xmath4 holds for the joint empirical measures , and the rate function is non - convex . as a corollary , we derive a large deviations principle for the univariate average empirical measures with a rate function that superficially resembles the rate function of random matrices , see corollary [ c2 ] ; an interesting feature here is the emergence of concave rate functions , see remark [ rc2 ] .
( eigenvalues of random matrices are exchangeable and the large deviation rate function for their empirical measures is convex ; infinite exchangeable sequences often lead to non - convex rate functions , see dinwoodie & zabell @xcite and ( * ? ? ?
* example 3 ) . )
[ [ section-2 ] ] let @xmath5 be a continuous function which satisfies the following conditions . [ b0 ] @xmath6 for all @xmath7 .
[ p - int ] for every @xmath8 , @xmath9 .
[ b1 ] @xmath10 is bounded , @xmath11 . in the following statements we use the convention that @xmath12 .
[ b2 ] the function @xmath13 has compact level sets : for every @xmath14 the set @xmath15 is compact .
the purpose of the next assumption is to allow singular interactions , where @xmath16 ; this assumption is automatically satisfied with @xmath17 if @xmath18 for all @xmath19 .
[ b3 ] there is a @xmath20 such that @xmath21 extends from @xmath22 to the continuous function on @xmath3 .
examples of functions that satisfy these assumptions are : the gaussian kernel @xmath23 for @xmath24 , see the proof of proposition [ iig2 ] ; and a singular kernel @xmath25 for @xmath20 , see the proof of proposition [ log ] .
define @xmath26 clearly , @xmath27 depends on @xmath0 ; we will suppress this dependence in our notation and we will further write @xmath28 as a convenient shorthand for @xmath29 . assumptions [ b0 ] , [ p - int ] , and [ b1 ] imply that @xmath27 is integrable
. indeed , since @xmath30 , @xmath31 @xmath32 we are interested in joint empirical measures @xmath33 considered as random variables with values in the polish space of probability measures @xmath34 ( equipped with the topology of weak convergence ) , with the distribution induced on @xmath34 by the probability measure @xmath35 defined by @xmath36 [ t1 ] if @xmath10 satisfies assumptions [ b0 ] , [ p - int ] , [ b1 ] , [ b2 ] , and [ b3 ] , then the joint empirical measures @xmath37 satisfy the large deviation principle in the scale @xmath4 with the rate function @xmath38 $ ] given by @xmath39 where @xmath40 and @xmath41 .
we say that @xmath42 is a negative definite kernel if @xmath43 and @xmath44 for all @xmath45 such that @xmath46 . condition ( [ neg - def ] ) is satisfied for @xmath47 , where @xmath48 is positive - definite .
consider the average empirical measures @xmath49 [ c2 ] suppose that the assumptions of theorem [ t1 ] hold true , and in addition @xmath50 is continuous and negative - definite .
then the average empirical measures @xmath51 satisfy the large deviation principle in the scale @xmath4 with the rate function @xmath52 and @xmath53 .
this follows from the contraction principle .
the mapping @xmath54 is continuous in the weak topology .
the rate function is @xmath55 .
write @xmath56 .
if @xmath57 then ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 3 ) implies that @xmath58 .
thus @xmath59 .
another form of the cited inequality is that for any two probability measures @xmath60 we have @xmath61 in particular , @xmath62 , which implies that @xmath63 .
[ rc1 ] inequality ( [ 2k ] ) implies that the rate function satisfies @xmath64
[ [ section-3 ] ] let @xmath65 . then @xmath66 and @xmath67 . denote by @xmath68 the @xmath69-th moment of a measure @xmath70 .
[ iig2 ] * if @xmath24 then the empirical measures @xmath71 satisfy the large deviation principle in the scale @xmath4 with the rate function @xmath72 * if @xmath73 then the average empirical measures @xmath49 satisfy the large deviation principle in the scale @xmath4 with the rate function @xmath74 ( in the formulas above , use @xmath75 if @xmath76 . ) the marginal density relevant in proposition [ iig2](i ) is @xmath77 [ rc2 ] both rate functions in proposition [ iig2 ] are concave .
\(i ) it is easy to see that the assumptions of theorem [ t1 ] are satisfied .
indeed , @xmath78 is continuous , bounded from below .
furthermore @xmath79 so @xmath50 has compact level sets . finally , for @xmath80 by a change of variables we see that @xmath81 so assumption [ p - int ] is satisfied , too .
the result follows by the contraction principle : taking a marginal of a measure in @xmath34 is a continuous mapping .
the rate function is @xmath82 .
but since @xmath83 is infinite on non - product measures , this is the same as @xmath84 . since @xmath85 here
, it remains to notice that @xmath86 .
\(ii ) this follows from corollary [ c2 ] : if @xmath87 then @xmath88 is positive - definite .
thus @xmath67 is a negative definite kernel .
[ [ section-4 ] ] next , we consider a model which can be interpreted as a decoupled " version of a model studied in relation to eigenvalue fluctuations of random matrices , where one encounters @xmath89 instead of our @xmath90 , compare ( * ? ? ?
* section 5 ) , ( * ? ? ?
* formula ( 1.9 ) ) .
we consider here a slightly more general situation when @xmath91 then @xmath92 and @xmath93 .
we assume that functions @xmath94 are continuous , @xmath20 , and that @xmath95 [ log ] the bivariate empirical measures @xmath96 defined by ( [ mu_n ] ) satisfy the large deviation principle in the scale @xmath4 with the rate function @xmath83 given by ( [ i ] ) . in particular , if @xmath97 , then the rate function is @xmath98 we verify that the hypotheses of theorem [ t1 ] are satisfied . assumption [ b0 ] holds trivially .
assumption [ b3 ] holds trivially since @xmath99 is continuous . to verify assumption [ b1 ] notice that @xmath100 since @xmath101 is a continuous function which by ( [ vw ] ) tends to infinity as @xmath102 , it is bounded from below , @xmath103 for some @xmath104
similarly , @xmath105 .
we now verify assumption [ b2 ] .
the set @xmath106 is closed since @xmath107 is lower semicontinuous . furthermore , ( [ k > v+w ] ) implies that @xmath108 is contained in a level set of the continuous function @xmath109 .
the latter set is bounded since @xmath110 for all large enough @xmath111 and similarly @xmath112 for all large enough @xmath113 . to verify assumption [ p - int ] we use inequality ( [ k > v+w ] ) again .
it implies @xmath114 by assumption ( [ vw ] ) , there is @xmath115 such that for @xmath116 we have @xmath117 . by the previous argument
the integrand is bounded ; thus @xmath118 . therefore , by theorem [ t1 ] the empirical measures @xmath96 satisfy the large deviation principle with the rate function @xmath119 .
if @xmath120 then @xmath121 by calculus .
the proof relies on varadhan s functional method , see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem t.1.3 ) , ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 4.4.10 ) .
it consists of two steps : verification that the varadhan functional @xmath122 is well defined for a large enough class of bounded continuous functions @xmath123 , and the proof of exponential tightness of @xmath37 .
denote by @xmath144 the set of absolutely continuous probability measures @xmath145 on @xmath146 with compact support @xmath147 , and continuous density @xmath27 .
let us first record the well - known fact .
since measures @xmath60 are absolutely continuous and have compact supports , for every integer @xmath155 we can find partitions @xmath156 and @xmath157 of @xmath158 , @xmath159 respectively such that @xmath160 then , denoting @xmath161\times[a_1,a_2]\times\dots\times[a_{n-1},a_n]$ ] and @xmath162\times[b_1,b_2]\times\dots\times[b_{n-1},b_n]$ ] , we have @xmath163 write @xmath164 . by our choice of the partitions , functions @xmath165}\ ] ] and @xmath166}\ ] ] are probability densities .
let @xmath167 integrating over a smaller set @xmath168 on the right hand side of ( [ ef ] ) we get @xmath134 @xmath169 using jensen s inequality , applied to the convex exponential function in the last integral , we get @xmath170 where @xmath171 lemma [ h ] says that the entropies @xmath175 are finite . thus the functions @xmath50 , @xmath176 , and @xmath177 are @xmath172-integrable .
applying claim [ int ] , we get @xmath178 , @xmath179 , and @xmath180 . therefore ,
@xmath181 combining inequalities ( [ * ] ) and ( [ mmm ] ) , we get @xmath185 since functions @xmath186 are continuous and @xmath60 have compact support and continuous densities @xmath27 , @xmath187 , therefore @xmath154-almost surely @xmath188 ( to see this , notice that for fixed @xmath189 , the sequence convergences for all @xmath190 such that @xmath191 . ) , and the functions are bounded .
since @xmath192 ranges over a finite set of values only we have @xmath193 @xmath194 letting @xmath195 in ( [ lu ] ) we obtain ( [ ll - low ] ) .
clearly the left - hand side of ( [ comp * ] ) can not exceed the right hand side . to show the converse inequality , fix @xmath214 and @xmath215 such that @xmath216 since the supremum is finite , see ( [ finite ] ) , and @xmath50 is bounded from below , therefore @xmath217 .
for @xmath218 large enough , define probability measures @xmath219 by @xmath220)}{\nu_j([-l , l ] ) } , \ , j=1,2.\ ] ] by definition , measures @xmath221 have compact support .
since @xmath222 and @xmath107 is @xmath172-integrable , by lebesgue s dominated convergence theorem @xmath223)\nu_2([-l , l])}= { { \mathbb k}}(\nu_1\otimes \nu_2).\ ] ] similarly , @xmath224 thus ( [ comp * ] ) follows .
trivially , @xmath226 to show the converse inequality , fix @xmath214 and compactly supported @xmath227 such that @xmath228 see lemma [ comp ] .
as previously , @xmath50 is @xmath172-integrable , see ( [ finite ] ) .
consider the convolution @xmath229 , where @xmath230 and @xmath231 .
measures @xmath232 have continuous densities , and since @xmath60 have compact supports , @xmath232 also have compact support .
thus @xmath233 and @xmath234 assumption [ b3 ] asserts that @xmath239 is a continuous function .
thus @xmath240 is bounded on the compact set @xmath241 . since the supports of @xmath242 are contained in @xmath241 , and @xmath243 ,
we get @xmath244 this concludes the proof if @xmath17 . if @xmath245 , then @xmath246 is @xmath172-integrable as a linear combination of integrable functions , @xmath247 .
therefore we have @xmath248 @xmath249 @xmath250 taking the lim sup as @xmath235 , from ( [ * 00 ] ) , ( [ * * ] ) , ( [ * * * ] ) , and ( [ * 1 ] ) we get @xmath251 @xmath252 since @xmath214 is arbitrary , to end the proof we use the following .
proof of claim [ log - est ] claim [ log - est ] is established by the argument in @xcite . for completeness , we repeat it here .
let @xmath254 be independent random variables with distributions @xmath60 respectively and let @xmath255 .
since @xmath256 is integrable , @xmath257 .
let @xmath258 $ ] be a r. v. independent of @xmath259 with the density @xmath260 .
it is easy to see that @xmath261 , and the inequality to prove reads @xmath262 for fixed @xmath263 we have @xmath264 indeed , since @xmath265 we get @xmath266 therefore , @xmath267 if @xmath268 we get @xmath269 .
if @xmath270 , then @xmath271 .
thus in both cases , ( [ joh ] ) holds true .
proof of theorem combining lemmas [ upper bound ] and [ lower bound ] we have @xmath277 @xmath278 @xmath279 @xmath280 by ( [ reduct ] ) , all of the above inequalities are in fact equalities .
thus ( [ ll ] ) holds true .
recall that @xmath37 is exponentially tight if for every @xmath281 there is a compact subset @xmath282 such that @xmath283 our proof of exponential tightness is a concrete implementation of de acosta @xcite .
assumption [ b1 ] implies that @xmath284 .
let @xmath285 $ ] be given by @xmath286 assumption [ b2 ] says that for every @xmath189 the set @xmath293 is a compact subset of @xmath3 .
for every @xmath294 by chebyshev s inequality we have @xmath295 thus @xmath292 is pre - compact , and its weak closure @xmath296 is compact .
notice that by ( [ ll ] ) used with @xmath301 we have @xmath302 . since @xmath303 is finite , see ( [ finite ] ) , therefore by lemma [ exp(q ) ] we have @xmath304 fix @xmath281 .
let @xmath305 be the pre - compact set from lemma [ pre - comp ] corresponding to @xmath306 .
proof of theorem [ t1 ] recall that the space @xmath310 of probability measures on @xmath3 with the topology of weak convergence is a polish space . by theorem [ exp - t ] , @xmath37 is exponentially tight .
theorem [ v - f ] says that the varadhan functional @xmath311 is defined on all functions @xmath131 given by ( [ phi ] ) , and @xmath312 @xmath313 thus @xmath314 functions @xmath131 defined by ( [ phi ] ) form a subset of @xmath315 which separates points of @xmath34 and is closed under the operation of taking pointwise minima .
thus by ( * ? ? ?
* theorem t.1.3 ) or ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 4.4.10 ) , the empirical measures @xmath37 satisfy the large deviation principle with the rate function @xmath316 here , the supremum is taken over all @xmath317 and @xmath318 is defined by ( [ phi ] ) . now consider @xmath323 .
assumptions [ b1 ] and [ b3 ] imply that @xmath324 is a bounded continuous function for every real @xmath325
. thus @xmath326 is given by ( [ phi ] ) .
since @xmath327 , from ( [ @ ] ) we get @xmath328 .
thus @xmath329 this together with ( [ i+ ] ) proves ( [ i ] ) for product measures . clearly , @xmath336 is a bounded continuous function , which vanishes on product measures . by the upper bound ( [ ll - u ] )
we therefore have @xmath337 .
so @xmath338 . since @xmath339 can be arbitrarily large , @xmath331 . | we prove the large deviation principle for the joint empirical measure of pairs of random variables which are coupled by a totally symmetric " interaction .
the rate function is given by an explicit bilinear expression , which is finite only on product measures and hence is non - convex .
= 7000 |
propagation of light rays from a distant source to the observer is governed by the gravitational field of intervening mass fluctuations as well as by the global geometry of the universe .
the images of background sources hence carry the imprint of the gravitational potential of intervening cosmic structures , and their statistical properties can be used to test the background cosmological models .
weak gravitational lensing is responsible for the weak shape - distortion and magnification of the images of background sources due to the gravitational field of intervening matter ( e.g. , bartelmann & schneider 2001 ; umetsu , futamase , & tada 1999 ) . to the first order ,
weak lensing gives rise to a few @xmath2 levels of elliptical distortions in images of background sources , responsible for the second - order derivatives of the gravitational lensing potential .
thus , the weak lensing signal , measured from tiny but coherent quadrupole distortions in galaxy shapes , can provide a direct measure of the projected mass distribution of cosmic structures . however , practical weak lensing observations subject to the effects of atmospheric seeing , isotropic / anisotropic psf , and ( residual ) camera distortion across the field of view , which must be examined from the stellar shape measurements and corrected for in the weak lensing analysis .
practical methods for psf corrections and shear measurements / calibrations have been studied and developed by many authors , such as pioneering work of kaiser , squires , & broadhurst ( 1995 , hereafter ksb ) , the shapelets technique which describes psf and object images in terms of gaussian - hermite expansions ( refregier 2003 ) , and recent systematic , collaborative efforts by the shear testing programme ( heymans et al .
2006 ; massey et al .
2007 ) .
thanks to these successful developments in weak lensing techniques as well as in instrument technology , the quadrupole weak lensing has become one of the most important tools in observational cosmology to map the mass distribution in individual clusters of galaxies ( e.g. , kaiser & squires 1993 ; broadhurst et al .
2005a ; okabe & umetsu 2007 ; umetsu & broadhurst 2007 ) , measure ensemble - averaged mass profiles of galaxy - group sized halos from the galaxy - galaxy lensing signal ( e.g. , hoekstra et al . 2001
; hoekstra et al . 2004 ; parker et al . 2005 ; mandelbaum et al . 2006 ) , study the statistical properties of the large scale structure of the universe from the cosmic shear statistics ( e.g. , bacon et al .
2000 ; van waerbeke et al . 2001 ; hamana et al .
2003 ) , and search for galaxy clusters by their mass properties ( e.g. , schneider 1996 ; erben et al . 2000 ; umetsu & futamase 2000 ; wittman et al .
2001 ) . in recent years
, there have been theoretical efforts to include the next higher order distortion effects as well as the usual quadrupole distortion effect in the weak lensing analysis ( goldberg & natarajan 2002 ; goldberg & bacon 2005 ; bacon et al .
2006 ; irwin & shmakova 2006 ; goldberg & leonard 2007 ; okura , umetsu , & futamase 2007 ) .
we have proposed in okura , umetsu , & futamase ( 2007 , hereafter ouf ) to use certain convenient combinations of octopole / higher multipole moments of background images which we call the higher order lensing image s characteristics ( holics ) , and have shown that holics serve as a direct measure for the next higher - order weak lensing effect , or the gravitational flexion ( goldberg & bacon 2005 ) and that the use of holics in addition to the quadrupole shape distortions can improve the accuracy and resolution of weak lensing mass reconstructions based on simulated observations .
recently , goldberg & leonard ( 2007 ) extended the holics approach for flexion measurements to include observational effects , namely the gaussian weighting in shape - moment calculations ( see the appendix therein ) and the isotropic psf effect , under the assumption that psf is nearly circular , and tested their extended holics approach with simulated and hst / acs observations .
leonard et al . (
2007 ) have applied the extended holics method to reconstruct the projected mass distribution in the central region of the massive galaxy cluster a1689 at @xmath0 , and revealed substructures associated with small clumps of galaxies .
further leonard et al . ( 2007 ) found that in dense systems such as galaxy clusters the holics technique is robust and less sensitive than the shapelet technique to contamination by light from the extended wings of lens / foreground galaxies . in the present paper
we develop a method for measuring flexion by the holics approach by fully extending the ksb formalism ; we take into account explicitly the effects of gaussian weighting in calculation of noisy shape moments and higher - order psf anisotropy as well as isotropic psf smearing .
we then apply our method to actual , ground - based subaru observations of a1689 , and perform a mass reconstruction in the central region of a1689 .
the paper is organized as follows .
we first summarize in 2 the basis of weak gravitational lensing and the flexion formalism . in 3 , we derive the relationship between holics and flexion by incorporating gaussian smoothing in shape measurements in the presence of isotropic and anisotropic psf . the practical method to correct the
isotropic / anisotropic psf effects will be presented in 4 . in section 5
we use simulations to test our flexion analysis method based on the holics moment approach .
we then perform a weak lensing flexion analysis of a1689 by our fully - extended holics approach , and perform a mass reconstruction of a1689 from the holics estimates of flexion .
finally summary and discussions are given in 6 .
we refer interested readers to a complete appendix for details of the derivation of flexion - observable relationships in practical observations .
in this section , we summarize general aspects of weak gravitational lensing and flexion formalism , following the complex derivative notation developed by bacon et al .
( 2006 ) . a general review of quadrupole weak lensing can be found in bartelmann & schneider ( 2001 ) .
we define the spin for weak - lensing quantities in the following way : a quantity is said to have spin @xmath3 if it has the same value after rotation by @xmath4 .
the product of spin-@xmath5 and spin-@xmath6 quantities has spin @xmath7 , and the product of spin-@xmath5 and spin-@xmath8 quantities has spin @xmath9 .
then , as we shall see in the next subsection , the lensing convergence @xmath10 is a spin-0 ( scalar ) quantity .
the complex shear @xmath11 and the reduced shear @xmath12 are spin-2 quantities .
the first and second flexion fields , @xmath13 and @xmath14 , are a spin-1 and a spin-3 quantity , respectively .
the gravitational deflection of light rays can be described by the lens equation , @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the effective lensing potential , which is defined by the two - dimensional poisson equation as @xmath17 , with the lensing convergence . here
the convergence @xmath18 is the dimensionless surface mass density projected on the sky , normalized with respect to the critical surface mass density of gravitational lensing , @xmath19 where @xmath20 , @xmath21 , and @xmath22 are the angular diameter distances from the observer to the deflector , from the observer to the source , and from the deflector to the source , respectively . by introducing the complex gradient operator , @xmath23 that transforms as a vector , @xmath24 , with @xmath25 being the angle of rotation , the lensing convergence @xmath10 is expressed as @xmath26 where @xmath27 denotes the complex conjugate .
similarly , the complex gravitational shear of spin-2 is defined as @xmath28 the third - order derivatives of @xmath16 can be combined to from a pair of the complex flexion fields as ( bacon et al .
2006 ) : @xmath29 if the angular size of an image is small compared to the scale over which the lens potential @xmath30 varies , then we can locally expand the lens equation ( [ eq : lenseq ] ) to have : @xmath31 to the second order , where @xmath32 is the jacobian matrix of the lens equation and @xmath33 is the third - order lensing tensor , @xmath34 the third - order tensor @xmath35 can be expressed with the sum of the two terms , @xmath36 , with the spin-1 part @xmath37 and the spin-3 part @xmath38 , composed of the real / imaginary part of the flexion fields : @xmath39 note that flexion has a dimension of inverse length ( or inverse angle ) , meaning that the flexion effect depends on the angular size of the source .
the shape quantities affected by the first flexion @xmath40 alone have spin-1 properties , while those affected by the second flexion @xmath41 alone have spin-3 properties .
these third - order lensing fields naturally appear in the transformation equations of holics between the lens and source planes . in the ksb approach ,
we use quadrupole moments @xmath42 of the surface brightness distribution @xmath43 of background images for quantifying the shape of the images : @xmath44{\delta\theta}_i { \delta\theta}_j}{\int d^2\theta\,q_i[i(\btheta)]},\ ] ] where @xmath45 $ ] denotes the weight function used in noisy shape measurements and @xmath46 is the offset vector from the image centroid .
the complex ellipticity @xmath47 is then defined as @xmath48 the @xmath47 transforms under the lens mapping as @xmath49}},\ ] ] where @xmath50 is the spin-2 reduced shear . in the weak lensing limit ( @xmath51 ) , equation ( [ eq : chis2chi ] ) reduces to @xmath52 . assuming the random orientation of the background sources , we average observed ellipticities over a sufficient number of images to obtain @xmath53 in the moment methods such as ksb , we quantify the shape of an image by measuring various moments of @xmath43 , in which the moments are calculated with respect to the observable centroid of the image @xmath54 , or the center of the light , defined by the first moment of @xmath43 .
however , in the presence of gravitational lensing , this apparent center can be different from the point @xmath55 that is mapped using the lens equation ( [ eq : lenseq ] ) from the center of the unlensed light , @xmath56 .
we refer to this point as the `` true '' center of the image .
the difference between these two centers , namely , the apparent and the true centers , causes a significant effect in evaluating the first flexion , as pointed out by goldberg & bacon ( 2005 ) .
the relationship between the two centers is @xmath57_i + \frac{1}{4}[g\chi^*]_i \right ) } \equiv \bar{\theta}_i - \delta_{l , i},\ ] ] where @xmath58 is the trace of @xmath42 , @xmath13 and @xmath14 are the reduce flexion , defined by @xmath59 and @xmath60 , respectively , and @xmath61 is the displacement vector from the true to the apparent center due to gravitational lensing .
therefore , by taking into account the centroid shift in shape measurements , we have the relation between @xmath62 and @xmath63 as @xmath64_i + \frac{1}{4}[g\chi^*]_i \right)}\nonumber\\ & = & { { \cal a}}_{ij}\delta{\theta}_j + \frac{1}{2}{{\cal d}}_{ijk}\delta\theta_j \delta\theta_k + \delta_{l , i}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] a detailed derivation of the above relation is given in appendix b of ouf .
the flexion fields , @xmath40 and @xmath41 , can be measured from proper combinations of higher - order shape moments with the corresponding spin properties and the dimension , as explicitly shown by ouf .
higher - order moments of images are defined as a straightforward extension of the quadrupole moment .
the octopole moment @xmath65 and the 16pole moment @xmath66 are defined as follows : @xmath67{\delta\theta}_i { \delta\theta}_j { \delta\theta}_k}{\int d^2\theta\,q_i[i(\btheta ) ] } \\ q_{ijkl}&\equiv & \frac{\int\ !
d^2\theta\ , q_i[i(\btheta)]{\delta\theta}_i { \delta\theta}_j { \delta\theta}_k { \delta\theta}_l}{\int d^2\theta\,q_i[i(\btheta)]}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] then , @xmath68 and @xmath69 of the spin-1 and spin-3 holics , respectively , are defined by @xmath70 where @xmath71 is the spin-0 normalization factor , @xmath72 finally , the transformation equations between unlensed and lensed holics are obtained as ( see ouf ) @xmath73}-5{{\rm re}\left [ f\iota_i^ * \right]}-{{\rm re}\left [ g{\iota_{i\hspace{-.1em}i\hspace{-.1em}i}}^ * \right]})},\nonumber\\ \label{eq : delta } \delta^{(s ) } & = & \frac{\delta-3g\zeta -\frac{1}{4}(10f\eta+7f^*\lambda - 18\frac{{\left ( { { \rm tr}q}\right)}^2}{\xi}f\chi + 3g)}{(1-\kappa)(1 - 4{{\rm re}\left [ g^*\eta \right]}-5{{\rm re}\left [ f\iota_i^ * \right]}-{{\rm re}\left [ g{\iota_{i\hspace{-.1em}i\hspace{-.1em}i}}^ * \right]})},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath74 and @xmath75 are dimensionless spin-2 and spin-4 quantities , respectively , defined with 16-pole moments , and @xmath76 , @xmath77 and @xmath78 are spin-1 , spin-3 , and spin-5 quantities , respectively , defined with @xmath79-pole moments ( see appendix and ouf ) .
we note that , the above equations ( [ eq : zeta ] ) and ( [ eq : delta ] ) are obtained under the sub - critical lensing condition , i.e. , @xmath80 ( see schneider & er 2007 ) . since the holics @xmath68 and @xmath69 are non - zero spin quantities with a direction dependence , the expectation value of the intrinsic @xmath68 and @xmath69 are assumed to vanish . to the first order in flexion
, we have the linear relations between the holics and flexion fields as @xmath81
for a practical application of the holics approach , we must take into account various observational effects such as noise in the shape measurement due to readout and/or sky background and the dilution of the lensing signal due to the isotropic / anisotropic psf effects .
thus , one can not simply use equations ( [ eq : zeta ] ) and ( [ eq : delta ] ) to measure the flexion fields . in this section ,
we introduce the gaussian weighting in moment calculations , as done in the ksb formalism for quadrupole weak lensing , and derive the relevant transformation equations between unlensed and lensed holics by taking into account explicitly the effect of gaussian smoothing .
now we introduce a weight function @xmath82 having a characteristic width @xmath83 for practical , noisy moment measurements , redefining the octopole and 16-pole moments of the brightness distribution @xmath43 as @xmath84 where @xmath85s here are no longer normalized with the corresponding _ flux _ of the image ( see equation [ [ eq : qij ] ] ) .
the redefined shape moments enter equation ( [ eq : holics ] ) .
we provide in appendix detailed definitions of holics in practical applications .
when weighted moments are used for calculating holics , the centroid shift due to lensing ( [ eq : csft ] ) , to the first order , is changed in the following way : @xmath86 where @xmath87 and @xmath88 are the apparent and the true centers of the image ( see [ subsec : csfgl ] ) , respectively , in the complex form calculated using the weight function @xmath89 , @xmath90 is the monopole shape moment ( or _ flux _ ) , quantities with subscript `` a '' represent those calculated with respect to the apparent center , and quantities with prime represent those measured with @xmath91 as the weight function instead of @xmath89 ; @xmath92 is the spin-0 coefficient in @xmath93 .
the deviation from unity in the denominator of @xmath92 is obtained by properly expanding the weight function w(x ) in moment calculations , and this term does not appear in goldberg & leonard ( 2006 ) s formulation .
hence , the complex displacement from the true image center , @xmath94 , can be expressed in terms of that from the apparent image center , @xmath95 , and the complex centroid shift , @xmath93 , as @xmath96 for interested readers , we refer to full appendix b.1 for detailed calculations of the lensing - induced centroid shift with a weight function . in weighted moment calculations ,
the transformation equations between holics and flexion must be modified accordingly . to the first order , we have @xmath97 where quantities with subscript `` t '' represent those calculated with respect to the true center , or using @xmath98 . by using equation ( [ eq : csf_complex ] )
, we can express @xmath99 and @xmath100 in terms of practically observable quantities ( with subscript `` a '' ) as @xmath101 to the first order . here the term @xmath102 in equation ( [ eq : zeta_t ] ) is again caused by the centroid shift in the weight function ( a similar , but different , expression was obtained by goldberg & leonard 2007 ) .
finally , we obtain the following transformation equations in the case of weighted moment calculations : @xmath103,\\ \delta^{(s ) } & \approx & \frac{1}{1-\kappa } \left [ \delta^a-\left(\frac{3}{4}+\frac{{\upsilon^a_0}'}{4\xi^a\sigma^2}\right)g \right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] we show the details of these calculations in full appendix b.3 .
in this section we present a detailed prescription for the psf anisotropy and circularization correction in holics - based flexion measurements by extending the ksb formalism .
we closely follow the treatment and the notation given in 4.6.1 of bartelmann & schneider ( 2001 ) .
the observed surface brightness distribution @xmath104 can be expressed as the true surface brightness @xmath43 convolved with an effective psf @xmath105 , @xmath106 following the ksb formalism , we assume that @xmath107 is nearly isotropic , so that the anisotropic part of @xmath107 is small .
we then define the isotropic part of @xmath107 as the azimuthal average over @xmath107 , and decompose @xmath107 into an isotropic part , @xmath108 , and an anisotropic part , @xmath109 , as @xmath110 where both @xmath108 and @xmath109 are normalized to unity .
we then define @xmath111 as the surface brightness distribution smeared by the isotropic part @xmath108 , @xmath112 the observed surface brightness @xmath113 is obtained by convolving @xmath111 with the anisotropy kernel @xmath114 as @xmath115 in the original ksb method for quadrupole weak lensing , only the spin-2 psf anisotropy described by the quadrupole moment of the anisotropy kernel @xmath109 has to be taken into account .
however , in order to correct holics with spin-1 and spin-3 properties for the anisotropic psf effects , we need to take into account the corresponding dipole and octopole moments of the anisotropy kernel @xmath109 having spin-1 and spin-3 properties .
we expand the integral of arbitrary function @xmath116 and @xmath113 to obtain @xmath117 where @xmath118 are the dipole , quadrupole , and octopole moments of the psf anisotropy kernel @xmath109 , respectively .
the psf anisotropy can cause a centroid shift between the images defined in terms of @xmath111 and @xmath113 .
this centroid shift is essentially due to the spin-1 psf anisotropy .
the observed weighted - center of image can be expressed in the complex form as @xmath119 where @xmath120 is the complex angular position .
similarly , the weighted - center of a hypothetical image defined in terms of @xmath121 is @xmath122 then , the offset between the two centers @xmath123 and @xmath124 is given as @xmath125 where @xmath126 and @xmath127 are the complex displacements to an arbitrary point @xmath128 .
expanding @xmath129 to the first order of @xmath109 yields @xmath130 where quantities with @xmath131 and @xmath132 refer to those calculated with @xmath133 and @xmath134 as the weight function , respectively , @xmath135 are spin-1 complex moments of the anisotropy kernel defined by @xmath136 and @xmath137 are certain combinations of shape moments defined as the coefficients in equation ( c11 ) of full appendix c.1.2 , associated with the complex dipole moment @xmath138 with spin-1 properties .
we note that @xmath129 , the psf - induced centroid shift , can not be constrained from observations ; however , as we shall see in the next subsection , one can constrain the spin-1 octopole component in @xmath129 , namely @xmath139 , in the first order approximation .
more detailed calculations are presented in full appendix c.1.2 .
we use equation ( [ eq : psfexp ] ) to relate observable holics ( with subscript `` obs '' ) to those defined in terms of @xmath121 ( with subscript `` iso '' ) . to the first order of @xmath109
, we have the following relations for the spin-1 and spin-3 quantities : @xmath140 where we have deffined the weighted first moment @xmath138 by @xmath141 and the spin-3 psf anisotropy @xmath142 by @xmath143 in general , the psf varies spatially over the field
. if the spatial variation of psf is sufficiently smooth , then one can measure @xmath144 and @xmath142 for a set of stars .
since @xmath145 and @xmath146 vanish for stars , the spin-1 and spin-3 psf anisotropies can be obtained as @xmath147 where quantities with asterisk denote those measured for stellar objects .
note that unlike the higher - order psf anisotropies @xmath144 and
@xmath142 , @xmath148 can not be determined from observations , so that @xmath149 can not be corrected for the anisotropic psf effect .
we show detailed calculations in full appendix c.1.3 .
this subsection provides the method of correcting for the isotropic psf effect on the flexion measurement .
firstly , from liouvelle s theorem we have @xmath150 with @xmath151 being the surface brightness distribution of the unlensed source .
we then consider @xmath152 where we have defined the brightness distribution @xmath153 convolved with the hypothetical psf @xmath154 , @xmath155 the @xmath156 can be regarded as an effective psf relating @xmath157 to @xmath158 ; the anisotropic part of @xmath156 is caused by lensing .
the octopole moment defined with @xmath159 is written as @xmath160 then , @xmath161 and @xmath162 of holics are defined in terms of @xmath163 and @xmath164 as @xmath165 substituting the expression for @xmath166 into the above equations and using equation ( [ eq : lbf ] ) , we obtain @xmath167 to the first order . here @xmath168s are certain combinations of shape moments defined in terms of @xmath121 ( see full appendix c.2 ) . in practice , however , one can replace @xmath121 with @xmath169 for calculating @xmath168s of first order in flexion .
next , we decompose @xmath170 into an isotropic part , @xmath171 , and an anisotropic part , @xmath172 , as @xmath173 with @xmath171 we define the surface brightness distribution @xmath174 smeared by the isotropic part @xmath171 as @xmath175 then , the relationship between @xmath176 and @xmath177 is the same as that between @xmath113 and @xmath111 except that @xmath178 instead of @xmath107 .
therefore , we obtain the following relations to the first order : @xmath179 where @xmath180 and @xmath181 are defined as @xmath182 @xmath183 and @xmath184 are spin-0 coefficients defined by certain combinations of shape moments ( see full appendix c.2 ) , and are calculated using @xmath185 instead of @xmath121 to the first order approximation . for stellar objects , @xmath186 , so that higher - order psf anisotropies of @xmath172 are obtained using equations ( [ hatiso ] ) and ( [ hat0 ] ) as @xmath187 further , to the first order approximation , we have @xmath188 finally , we can relate unlensed holics in terms of @xmath177 to observed holics corrected for the psf anisotropy by @xmath189 , \\ \hat \delta^0 & \approx & \frac{1}{1-\kappa } \left
[ \delta^{iso}- c^0_\delta g + \frac { ( c^0_{\delta } ) _ * } { ( p^0_{\delta } ) _ * } p^0_\delta g \right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] assuming @xmath190 for unlensed sources , we obtain the desired expressions for flexion as @xmath191 a detailed derivation of the above equations is provided in full appendix c.2 .
we use simulations to test and assess the limitations of our psf correction scheme for the flexion measurement . to do this ,
we assume particular models for describing the isotropic / anisotropic psf and the surface brightness distribution for a source . in
the present simulations observational noise and lensing effects are not taken into account .
first , we assume for the stellar surface brightness distribution a two - dimensional dirac delta function , @xmath192 , while for the galaxy surface brightness distribution a truncated gaussian as @xmath193 where @xmath194 and @xmath195 are the gaussian dispersion and the truncation radius of @xmath196 , respectively . in the following we set @xmath197 .
next , we assume the isotropic part of psf , @xmath108 , also follows a truncated gaussian of the form : @xmath198 where @xmath199 and @xmath200 are the gaussian dispersion and the truncation radius of @xmath108 , respectively . in the following we set @xmath201 .
finally , we adopt the psf anisotropy kernel @xmath114 of the following form : @xmath202 where @xmath203 is the normalization factor that controls the strength of psf anisotropy , and @xmath204 is the truncation radius .
we have chosen the direction of anisotropy along the @xmath205-axis ( @xmath206-axis ) .
thus , the anisotropy kernel @xmath114 has two free parameters , @xmath207 .
we vary the parameters @xmath207 to test our anisotropic psf correction scheme as a function of degree of psf anisotropy .
we take @xmath204 in the range of @xmath208 .
having set up the models , we then produce pixelized images for model stars and galaxies using the surface brightness distributions @xmath209 and @xmath210 , which are then convolved with the model psf to yield @xmath211 and @xmath212 . no observational noise or
intrinsic / gravitational flexion has been added in the present simulations .
here we consider the following set of gaussian source radii , @xmath213 .
for each set of @xmath207 , we measure various psf moments , such as @xmath214 , from mock stellar images using the gaussian weight function of dispersion @xmath215 . on the other hand ,
we measure various shape moments for mock galaxy images of @xmath212 using the gaussian weight of @xmath216 ( i.e. , gaussian dispersion of the psf - convolved image ) .
then , we correct observed holics @xmath217 for the psf anisotropy to obtain @xmath218 , which should vanish for a perfect psf correction .
we show in figures [ fig : psfsim_zeta ] and [ fig : psfsim_zratio ] results of anisotropic psf correction for the first holics @xmath68 of spin 1 .
figure [ fig : psfsim_zeta ] shows the dimensionless @xmath219 before ( solid ) and after ( dashed ) the anisotropic psf correction as a function of degree of psf anisotropy : @xmath203 ( left panel ) and @xmath204 ( right panel ) .
firstly , it clearly shows that the spin-1 psf anisotropy induced in mock galaxy images is considerably reduced after applying our psf correction method outlined in
[ sec : ksb+ ] .
secondly , we see a clear trend that the smaller the galaxy size , the more severe the anisotropic psf effect ; or that @xmath219 increases with decreasing galaxy size , @xmath194 .
in particular , when the source size is comparable to the size of psf ( @xmath220 ) , the effect is larger about one order of magnitude than that of large sources with @xmath221 .
figure [ fig : psfsim_zratio ] shows the ratio @xmath222 of residual to observed psf anisotropy in mock galaxy images .
we see that , overall , the fractional correction factor @xmath222 is larger for larger galaxy images .
similar trends are also found for the second holics @xmath69 of spin 3 , as shown in figures [ fig : psfsim_delta ] and [ fig : psfsim_dratio ] .
we apply our flexion analysis method based on the holics moment approach to subaru imaging observations of the cluster a1689 .
a1689 is a rich cluster of galaxies at a moderately low redshift of @xmath0 , having a large einstein radius of @xmath223 arcsec ( @xmath224 ; broadhurst et al .
a1689 is one of the best studied lensing clusters ( e.g. , tyson & fisher 1995 ; king , clowe , & schneider et al .
2002 ; bardeau et al . 2005 ; broadhurst et al .
2005a ; broadhurst et al .
2005b ; halkola et al .
2006 ; medezinski et al . 2007 ; leonard et al . 2007 ; limousin et al . 2007
; umetsu , broadhurst , takada 2007 ; umetsu & broadhurst 2007 ) , and therefore serves as an ideal target for testing our flexion analysis pipeline .
deep hst / acs imaging of the central region of a1689 has revealed @xmath225 multiply lensed images of @xmath226 background galaxies ( broadhurst et al .
2005b ) , which allowed a detailed reconstruction of the mass distribution in the cluster core ( @xmath227 ) .
broadhurst et al .
( 2005a ) developed a method for reconstructing the cluster mass profile by combining weak - lensing tangential shear and magnification bias measurements , and derived a model - independent projected mass profile of the cluster out to its virial radius ( @xmath228 mpc ) based on wide - field subaru / suprime - cam data .
the combination of weak shear and magnification data breaks the mass sheet degeneracy ( broadhurst , taylor , & peacock 1995 ) inherent in all reconstruction methods based solely on the shape - distortion information ( schneider & seitz 1995 ) .
broadhurst et al .
( 2005a ) found that the combined acs and subaru profile of the cluster is well fitted by an nfw profile ( navarro , frenk , & frenk 1997 ) with a virial mass of @xmath229 and a concentration of @xmath230 , which is significantly larger than theoretically expected ( @xmath231 ) for the standard lcdm model ( bullock et al .
2001 ; neto et al .
2007 ) . based on these subaru data , umetsu & broadhurst ( 2007 ) used a maximum likelihood method to reconstruct the two - dimensional mass map of a1689 from combined shear and magnification data , and found the azimuthally - averaged mass profile from the full two - dimensional reconstruction is in good agreement with the earlier results from the one - dimensional analysis by broadhurst et al .
( 2005a ) , supporting the assumption of quasi - circular symmetry in the projected mass distribution of a1689 .
recently , leonard et al . ( 2007 ) performed a weak lensing analysis of a1689 based on the acs data by incorporating measurements of flexion as well as weak shear and strong lensing , and their flexion reconstruction has revealed mass substructures associated with small clumps of galaxies , while no flexion signal has been detected at the cluster center , showing an under density around the location of the cd galaxy . for our flexion analysis of a1689 , we used suprime - cam @xmath232-imaging data ( broadhurst et al .
2005a ; umetsu & broadhurst 2007 ) , covering a field of @xmath233 with @xmath234 sampling .
the seeing fwhm in the co - added @xmath232 image is @xmath235 , and the limiting magnitude is @xmath236 for a @xmath237 detection within a @xmath238 aperture ( see broadhurst et al .
2005a ) . since the flexion signal is weaker at larger angular scales ( see ouf for detailed discussions ) , in the present flexion analysis we discarded outer boundaries from the analysis and only used the central @xmath239 pixel region , corresponding an angular scale of @xmath240 on a side , or a physical scale of @xmath241 mpc at the cluster redshift of @xmath0 .
we used our weak lensing analysis pipeline based on imcat ( kaiser et al .
1995 ) extended to include our holics moment method .
we selected a stellar sample of @xmath242 objects for measuring the anisotropic / isotropic psf effects . on the basis of the simulation results ,
we excluded from our background galaxy sample those small objects whose half - light radius ( @xmath243 ) and gaussian detection radius ( @xmath244 ) are smaller than or comparable to the psf ; here we selected galaxies with @xmath245 and @xmath246 , whereas the median values of stellar @xmath243 and @xmath244 are @xmath247 and @xmath248 using @xmath242 stars .
these lower cutoffs in the galaxy size are essential for reliable flexion measurements , because the smaller the object , the noisier its shape measurement due to pixelization noise ; and the shape of an image whose intrinsic size is smaller than or comparable to the psf size can be highly distorted and smeared , as we have seen in
[ subsec : sim ] .
faint objects will also yield noisy shape measurements , in particular for the case of higher order shape moments .
we thus selected bright galaxies with @xmath249 in the ab magnitude system .
further we excluded from our background sample those objects whose flexion estimates are significantly larger than the model prediction ( @xmath250 arcsec@xmath251 ) using the best - fitting nfw profile derived from the joint subaru and acs analysis ( broadhurst et al .
2005a ) ; with this model , we set an upper cutoff in flexion of @xmath252 arcsec@xmath251 , and an upper cutoff in the first holics of @xmath253 arcsec@xmath251 ( see equation [ [ eq : htof ] ] ) .
we note that the measurements of spin-3 holics @xmath69 were found to be quite noisy ( see ouf for detailed discussions ) , so that we discarded the second flexion measurements from the present study .
finally , these selection criteria yielded a sample of @xmath254 galaxies usable for our flexion analysis , corresponding to a mean surface number density of @xmath255 arcmin@xmath256 . using the background galaxy sample above
we found a mean value of @xmath257 arcsec@xmath251 and a dispersion of @xmath258 arcsec@xmath251 . in figure
[ fig : zetaq_field ] we show the spatial distribution of spin-1 psf anisotropy as measured from stellar images before ( left panel ) and after ( right panel ) the anisotropic psf correction . figure [ fig : zetaq ] compares the distribution of two components of complex spin-1 psf anisotropy before ( left panel ) and after(right panel ) the anisotropic psf correction . as clearly shown in figures [ fig : zetaq_field ] and [ fig : zetaq ] , the higher - order psf anisotropy in observational data is indeed significant , so that one needs to take into account the higher - order psf anisotropy correction in practical flexion measurements .
we use our first flexion measurements obtained with our moment - based analysis method to reconstruct the projected mass distribution of a1689 . to do this
we utilize the fourier - space relation between the first flexion @xmath13 and the lensing convergence @xmath10 ( 2.4 of ouf ; bacon et al .
2006 ) with the weak lensing approximation .
the field size for the mass reconstruction is @xmath259 , sampled with a grid of @xmath260 pixels , over which the unconstrained @xmath261 mode is set to zero .
figures [ fig : a1689_emode ] and [ fig : a1689_bmode ] show the @xmath262-mode convergence @xmath263 due to lensing and the @xmath6-mode convergence @xmath264 which is expected to vanish in the weak lensing limit and can thus be used to monitor the reconstruction error in the @xmath262-mode @xmath10 map .
a central @xmath265 region is displayed in figures [ fig : a1689_emode ] and [ fig : a1689_bmode ] .
the reconstructed @xmath10 maps were smoothed with a gaussian filter of @xmath266 .
table [ tab : stats ] lists basic statistics of the reconstructed @xmath262- and @xmath6-mode @xmath10 fields measured in the central @xmath265 field .
the rms dispersion in the gaussian smoothed @xmath6-mode @xmath10 map is obtained as @xmath267 .
the maximum and minimum values in the @xmath6-mode convergence field are @xmath268 and @xmath269 , corresponding to @xmath270 and @xmath271 fluctuations ( see table [ tab : stats ] ) .
figure [ fig : a1689_emode ] reveals two significant mass concentrations in the @xmath262-mode @xmath10 map associated with clumps of bright galaxies .
the first peak has a peak value of @xmath272 , and is detected at @xmath273 significance .
this first peak is associated with the central concentration of bright cluster galaxies including the cd galaxy , as shown in figure [ fig : a1689_image ] .
this central mass concentration associated with the brightest cluster galaxies was not detected in the earlier acs flexion analysis by leonard et al .
the acs / subaru best - fitting nfw model predicts @xmath274 at @xmath275 .
the second peak ( @xmath276 significance ) , on the other hand , is located @xmath277 to the northeast direction , and is associated with a local clump of bright galaxies ( see figure [ fig : a1689_image ] ) , having a peak value of @xmath278 .
this second mass peak has been detected in the earlier lensing studies based on the high resolution hst / acs data ( e.g , broadhurst et al .
2005b ; leonard
et al . 2007 ) , and its likely bimodality in the central region has been discussed previous studies ( miralda - escude & babul 1995 ; halkola , seitz , & pannella 2006 ; limousin et al 2007 ; saha , williams , & ferreras 2007 ) . however , as compared to the subaru weak lensing analysis by umetsu & broadhurst ( 2007 ) , the flexion - based mass reconstruction can not recover the global cluster structure on larger angular scales ( @xmath279 a few arcmin ) , as demonstrated by ouf .
in the present paper , we have developed a method for weak lensing flexion analysis by fully extending the ksb method to include the measurement of holics ( ouf ) .
in particular , we take into account explicitly the weight function in calculations of noisy shape moments and the effects of spin-1 and spin-3 psf anisotropies , as well as isotropic psf smearing , in the limit of weak lensing and small psf anisotropy ( @xmath109 ) .
the higher order weak lensing effect induces a centroid shift in the observed image of the background ( goldberg & bacon 2005 ; ouf ; goldberg & leonard 2007 ) . in weighted moment calculations
, this will yield in the flexion measurement additional correction terms ( relevant to @xmath280 ) that must be taken into account by properly expanding the weight function @xmath89 .
it is found that neglecting these additional terms originated from the taylor expansion of @xmath89 yields the same result as obtained by goldberg & leonard ( 2007 ; see appendix therein ) . we extended the ksb formalism to include the higher - order isotropic and anisotropic psf effects relevant to spin-1 and spin-3 holics by following the prescription given by ksb and bartelmann & schneider ( 2001 ) , which provides direct relations between the observable holics and underlying flexion in the weak lensing limit .
we have implemented in our analysis pipeline our flexion analysis algorithm based on the holics moment approach , and tested the reliability and limitation of our psf correction scheme using numerical simulations .
our simulation results show that ( i ) after applying our psf correction method the psf - induced anisotropies in holics of mock galaxy images can be considerably reduced by a factor of @xmath281@xmath282 , depending on the strength of psf anisotropy , ( ii ) those small galaxies whose angular size is smaller than or comparable to the size of psf suffer from severe anisotropic psf effects , and that ( iii ) there is an overall trend that the fractional correction factor is larger for larger galaxy images .
therefore , our simulation results support the reliability of our psf - correction scheme and its practical implementation .
based on the simulation results , we have applied our flexion analysis pipeline to ground - based @xmath232 imaging data of the rich cluster a1689 ( @xmath0 ) taken with subaru / suprime - cam . our flexion analysis of subaru a1689 data revealed a non - negligible , significant effect of higher - order psf anisotropy induced in stellar images ( figures [ fig : zetaq_field ] and [ fig : zetaq ] ) .
it is therefore important in practical flexion measurements to quantify and correct for the higher - order anisotropic psf effects .
our mass reconstruction from the first - flexion measurements shows two significant ( @xmath283 ) mass structures associated with concentrations of bright galaxies in the central cluster region : the first peak ( @xmath273 ) associated with the central concentration of bright galaxies including the cd galaxy , and the second peak ( @xmath276 ) associated with a clump of bright galaxies located @xmath284 northeast of the cluster center .
this significant detection of the second peak confirms earlier acs results from the strong lensing analysis ( broadhurst et al .
2005b ; halkola et al . 2006
; leonard et al . 2007 ) and the combined strong lensing , weak shear , and flexion analysis by leonard et al .
the central mass peak , however , was not recovered in the earlier flexion analysis by leonard et al .
( 2007 ) based on hst / acs data .
leonard et al . ( 2007 ) attributed this to their relatively large reconstruction error at the cluster center , although they have a very large number density of background galaxies , @xmath285 arcmin@xmath256 . on the other hand ,
owing to our conservative selection criteria for the background sample , the mean number density of background galaxies used for the present analysis is @xmath286 arcmin@xmath256 , which is almost one order of magnitude smaller than that of the acs data , and is about @xmath287 of a typical number density of magnitude / size - selected background galaxies usable for the quadrupole shape measurements in ground - based subaru observations ( @xmath288 ) .
however , we found that it is rather important to remove small / faint galaxy images and noisy outliers in flexion measurements since they are likely to be affected by the residual psf anisotropy and/or observational noise in the shape measurement ( [ subsec : sim ] ) . besides , the smaller the object , the larger the amplitude of intrinsic flexion contributions .
recall that flexion and holics have a dimension of length inverse : the response to flexion is size - dependent , and the amplitude of intrinsic flexion is inversely proportional to the object size .
indeed , we find that inclusion of smaller objects results in a noisy reconstruction .
similar values of the background number density , @xmath289 , have been used in recent quadrupole weak lensing analyses based on subaru observations ( e.g. , broadhurst et al .
2005a ; umetsu & broadhurst 2007 ; weak lensing cluster mass measurements of okabe & umetsu 2008 )
. in their studies only objects redder than the cluster sequence are selected in color - magnitude space for their weak lensing analysis , because such a red population is expected to comprise only background galaxies ( @xmath290 ; see , e.g. , medezinski et al .
2007 ) , made redder by relatively large @xmath291-corrections and with negligible contamination by cluster galaxies ( broadhurst et al .
2005a ; medezinski et al .
however , the smaller number of objects implies a coarser angular resolution in the map - making for achieving a proper signal - to - noise ratio ( e.g. , per - pixel @xmath292 ) . with @xmath293 for cluster quadrupole weak lensing , typical angular resolutions are about @xmath294 arcmin ( e.g. , gaussian fwhm , or boxcar width ) . on the other hand , flexion measures essentially the gradient of the tidal gravitational shear field ( i.e. , @xmath295 ) , and hence is relatively sensitive to small - scale structures .
therefore , our successful reconstruction of the mass substructures with a small background density , @xmath296 , could be attributed to the superior sensitivity of flexion to small scale structures ( see ouf for detailed discussions ) and the here - adopted selection criteria for a background galaxy sample for weak lensing flexion analysis .
finally , we emphasize that our holics formalism here is different from the earlier work by goldberg & leonard ( 2007 ) in that ( 1 ) additional correction terms for the centroid shift , relevant to the derivatives of the weight function , have been included and ( 2 ) the spin-1 and spin-3 psf anisotropies , as well as the isotropic psf smearing , have been taken into account under the assumption of small psf anisotropy ( @xmath297 $ ] ) , as done in the ksb formalism .
our flexion - based mass reconstruction of a1689 demonstrates the power of the generalized flexion analysis techniques for quantitative and accurate measurements of the weak gravitational lensing effects .
we thank masahiro takada for valuable discussions .
we thank the anonymous referee for invaluable comments and suggestions . the work is partially supported by the coe program at tohoku university . this work in part supported by the national science council of taiwan under the grant nsc95 - 2112-m-001 - 074-my2 .
in this appendix , we adopt the following notations to represent complex quantities with the degree @xmath3 and the spin number @xmath298 : @xmath299 here a quantity with the spin number of @xmath300 is equivalent to the complex conjugate of the corresponding spin-@xmath298 quantity . unless otherwise noted , we shall use @xmath301 to represent complex quantities in the image plane , and @xmath302 those in the source plane .
the product of @xmath301 and @xmath303 is expressed as @xmath304 for arbitrary complex numbers @xmath305 and @xmath306 the following identities hold : @xmath307}x^l_k & = & { \left ( wx^{n*}_m + w^*x^n_m \right)}x^l_k = wx^{n+l}_{k - m } + w^*x^{n+l}_{m+k},\\ 4{{\rm re}\left [ wx^{n*}_m \right]}{{\rm re}\left [ zx^{l*}_k \right]}&= & { \left ( wx^{n*}_m + w^*x^n_m \right)}{\left ( zx^{l*}_k + z^*x^l_k \right)},\nonumber\\ & = & wz{\left ( x^{n+l}_{k+m } \right)}^ * + wz^*x^{n+l}_{k - m } + w^*zx^{n+l}_{-k+m } + w^*z^*x^{n+l}_{k+m},\nonumber\\ & = & 2{{\rm re}\left [ wz{\left ( x^{n+l}_{k+m } \right)}^ * \right ] } + 2{{\rm re}\left [ wz^*x^{n+l}_{k - m } \right]}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] similarly , by operating @xmath309 on the weight function @xmath312 , one finds the following : @xmath313 where @xmath13 and @xmath14 are the first and the second flexion defined as @xmath59 and @xmath60 , respectively .
then , the complex displacement in the source plane , @xmath314 , is expressed in terms of the lensing convergence , shear and flexion as @xmath315.\ ] ] the integration measures in the source and image planes are related in the following way @xmath316 } { \hspace{-1mm}-\hspace{-1mm}}|g|^2 { \hspace{-1mm}+\hspace{-1mm}}\frac{1}{4}|f|^2x^2_0 { \hspace{-1mm}-\hspace{-1mm}}\frac{1}{4}|g|^2x^2_0\nonumber\\ & { \hspace{-1mm}+\hspace{-1 mm } } & \frac{1}{2}{{\rm re}\left [ f^2x^{2*}_2 \right ] } { \hspace{-1mm}-\hspace{-1mm}}{{\rm re}\left [ g^*fx^1_1 \right ] } { \hspace{-1mm}-\hspace{-1mm}}{{\rm re}\left [ g^*gx^{1*}_1 \right ] } { \hspace{-1mm}-\hspace{-1mm}}\frac{1}{2}{{\rm re}\left [ fg^*x^2_2 \right]}\biggr)d^2\theta\nonumber\\ & \approx&(1-\kappa)^2{\left ( 1- 2{{\rm re}\left [ fx^{1*}_1 \right ] } \right)}d^2\theta,\end{aligned}\ ] ] to the first order of reduced flexion ( e.g. ouf ) . | we have developed a method for measuring higher - order weak lensing distortions of faint background galaxies , namely the weak gravitational flexion , by fully extending the kaiser , squires & broadhurst method to include higher - order lensing image characteristics ( holics ) introduced by okura , umetsu , & futamase .
we take into account explicitly the weight function in calculations of noisy shape moments and the effect of higher - order psf anisotropy , as well as isotropic psf smearing .
our holics formalism allows accurate measurements of flexion from practical observational data in the presence of non - circular , anisotropic psf .
we test our method using mock observations of simulated galaxy images and actual , ground - based subaru observations of the massive galaxy cluster a1689 ( @xmath0 ) . from the high - precision measurements of spin-1 first flexion
, we obtain a high - resolution mass map in the central region of a1689 .
the reconstructed mass map shows a bimodal feature in the central @xmath1 region of the cluster .
the major , pronounced peak is associated with the brightest cluster galaxy and central cluster members , while the secondary mass peak is associated with a local concentration of bright galaxies . the refined , high - resolution mass map of a1689 demonstrates the power of the generalized weak lensing analysis techniques for quantitative and accurate measurements of the weak gravitational lensing signal . |
the first motivation for supersymmetric extensions of the standard model ( sm ) stems from the solution of the naturalness or fine tuning problem in the higgs sector of the sm @xcite ( besides the unification of the gauge couplings and the possibility to explain dark matter ) : in the sm with an ultraviolet cutoff @xmath6 much larger than the electroweak scale @xmath7 , the bare higgs mass squared @xmath8 must satisfy roughly @xmath9
. hence @xmath8 must be of the order @xmath10 , but must be finetuned relative to @xmath10 with a precision of the order @xmath11 .
this fine tuning is enormous for @xmath6 of the order of a gut scale , but only a tuning of @xmath12 is considered as natural . within supersymmetric ( susy ) extensions of the sm with susy breaking terms of the order @xmath13 , the necessary tuning between the parameters is of the order of @xmath14 , and hence independent from an ultraviolet cutoff @xmath6 .
first results of searches for susy by the atlas and cms collaborations at the lhc , based on @xmath15 fb@xmath16 of data taken at 7 tev center - of - mass energy , imply lower bounds on susy breaking gluino and up / down squark masses in the 1 tev range @xcite ( for the latest publications , see the atlas and cms notes on the web pages @xcite ) .
these bounds reduce the phenomenologically viable range of parameters in susy extensions of the sm . however , an obviously interesting question is the impact of these negative results on the necessary tuning between the parameters in the remaining parameter region .
it is well known that the non - observation of a higgs boson at lep @xcite implies already a `` little fine tuning problem '' in the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm ) ( see e.g. @xcite ) , where the field content in the higgs sector is as small as possible , but large radiative corrections are required in order to lift the mass of the lightest neutral cp - even higgs boson above the lower lep bound .
large radiative corrections require relatively large susy breaking top squark masses compared to the electroweak scale . via loop diagrams ,
large top squark masses lead to relatively large soft susy breaking higgs mass terms , which require some tuning among the parameters of the mssm such that the higgs vacuum expectation values ( vevs ) are of @xmath17 , well below the scale of the higgs mass terms .
the required tuning among the parameters of the mssm is typically of the order of a few % .
the `` little fine tuning problem '' of the mssm , originating from lep constraints , is alleviated in certain regions of the parameter space of the next - to - minimal supersymmetric standard model ( nmssm ) .
the nmssm is the simplest susy extension of the sm with a scale invariant superpotential , i.e. where the only dimensionful parameters are the soft susy breaking terms .
no supersymmetric higgs mass term @xmath18 is required as in the mssm , since it is generated dynamically by the vacuum expectation value of a gauge singlet superfield @xmath19 ( see @xcite for recent reviews ) .
together with the neutral components of the two su(2 ) doublet higgs fields @xmath20 and @xmath21 of the mssm , one finds three neutral cp - even and two cp - odd higgs states in this model .
the additional coupling @xmath22 of @xmath19 to @xmath20 and @xmath21 can lead to a larger mass @xmath23 of the sm - like neutral higgs boson @xmath24 , and to mixings of the physical cp - even higgs bosons in terms of the weak eigenstates @xmath19 , @xmath20 and @xmath21 , implying reduced couplings of the physical eigenstates to the @xmath25 boson . both phenomena make it easier to satisfy the lep bounds @xcite , and allow to alleviate the little finetuning problem @xcite .
( see @xcite for an evaluation of the upper bound on @xmath23 of about 140 gev if @xmath22 is required to remain perturbative below the gut scale ; if @xmath22 is allowed to be larger , @xmath23 can be even larger @xcite . )
moreover , @xmath24 can decay preferably into lighter nmssm - specific singlet - like higgs bosons . in this case
lep bounds on @xmath23 are lower , and again the required fine tuning can be considerably smaller than in the mssm @xcite .
consequently it becomes important to study the impact of the recent bounds from the lhc on the fine tuning within the nmssm , which is the purpose of this paper .
the most frequently used quantitative measure @xmath26 for fine tuning is the maximum of the logarithmic derivative of @xmath7 with respect to all fundamental parameters @xmath27 ( if the fundamental lagrangian is given at the gut scale ) @xcite : [ eq:1 ] = max\{_i^ } , _ i^ = || .
( see @xcite for alternatives ; sometimes @xmath28 instead of @xmath7 is used in the argument of the logarithm , which leads to an obvious additional factor of 2 .
subsequently we prefer to study linear relations between all masses and couplings . )
@xmath26 depends on the point in parameter space and is , roughly speaking , inversely proportional to the required fine tuning ( as discussed above ) between the parameters @xmath27 .
hence , for a given point in parameter space , @xmath26 should be as small as possible , preferably of @xmath29 .
preferred regions in the parameter space spanned by @xmath27 are those where @xmath26 is minimal ( denoted by @xmath30 ) . in practice , the value of @xmath26 depends on the choice of independent fundamental parameters defining the model , and on the implementation of phenomenological constraints as the dark matter relic density , the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon etc .. including wmap constraints on the dark matter relic density ( but leaving aside the top yukawa coupling @xmath31 in the list of @xmath27 ) , @xmath26 has been studied recently within the constrained mssm ( cmssm , with universal soft susy breaking terms at the gut scale ) in @xcite .
first investigations of the impact of the early lhc results on the susy parameter space in the cmssm have been performed in @xcite , in the cmssm with non - universal sfermion masses in @xcite , and within the general mssm in @xcite .
compared to alternative procedures as likelihood scans and/or bayesian techniques ( see @xcite for studies within constrained versions of the nmssm , and @xcite for a recent discussion ) a disadvantage of @xmath26 is that it does not allow to marginalise ( i.e. to integrate over ) parts of the parameters which , in turn , would allow to determine `` most likely '' values for given quantities as masses of specific particles , given all present experimental constraints .
( clearly , such predictions for `` most likely '' masses seem to be of limited use ; for instance , they would have failed miserably if applied to the sm - like higgs mass in the pre - lep era . )
one can also leave aside the issue of quantitative fine tuning , content oneself with the fact that the fine tuning in susy is always much smaller than in the sm with a large cutoff @xmath6 , and determine `` most likely '' values for parameters exclusively from best fits to data from electroweak precision experiments .
the impact of recent lhc bounds on such best fits has been studied recently in @xcite . on the other hand
, the constraints from recent or future lhc results on the quantitative fine tuning measure @xmath26 can contribute to the discussion on the impact of lhc results on supersymmetry in general .
hence we will compare these constraints within the parameter space of the semi - constrained snmssm ( where singlet - specific soft terms are allowed to be non - universal ) to the cmssm , obtained from the snmssm in the limit @xmath32 .
therefore we study the dependence of @xmath26 on the universal soft susy breaking parameters @xmath0 and @xmath1 ( gaugino and scalar masses , respectively ) and on the gluino and up / down squark masses .
in particular we investigate the relevance of nmssm specific scenarios in the higgs sector for fine tuning , as scenarios with large singlet / doublet mixing and scenarios with dominant @xmath33 decays @xcite . in the next section
we define the model , the procedure for the determination of @xmath26 , and discuss some specific properties of @xmath26 in the nmssm .
our results and their discussion are given in section 3 , and we conclude with a summary in section 4 .
the nmssm differs from the mssm by the presence of the gauge singlet superfield @xmath19 .
the higgs mass term @xmath34 in the superpotential @xmath35 of the mssm is replaced by the coupling @xmath36 of @xmath20 and @xmath21 to @xmath19 and a self - coupling @xmath37 , hence the superpotential @xmath38 is scale invariant in this simplest @xmath39-invariant version of the nmssm : [ eq:2 ] w_nmssm = s h_uh_d + s^3 + h_t h_uq t^c_r + h_b h_dq b^c_r + h_h_d l ^c_r , where we have confined ourselves to the yukawa couplings of @xmath20 and @xmath21 to the quarks and leptons @xmath40 , @xmath41 @xmath42 , @xmath43 and @xmath44 of the third generation ; a sum over the three generations is implicitly assumed .
( in ( [ eq:2 ] ) , for the first and the last time , the fields denote superfields . )
once @xmath19 assumes a vev @xmath45 , the first term in @xmath38 generates an effective @xmath18-term [ eq:3 ] _
= s . the soft susy
breaking terms consist of mass terms for the gaugino , higgs and sfermion fields -l_&= & + , + -l _ & = & m_h_u^2 | h_u |^2 + m_h_d^2 | h_d |^2 + m_s^2 | s |^2 + m_q^2|q^2| + m_t^2|t_r^2| + & & + m_b^2|b_r^2| + m_l^2|l^2|+m_^2|_r^2| , [ eq:4 ] as well as trilinear interactions between the sfermion and the higgs fields , including the singlet field -l _ & = & ( h_t a_t qh_u t_r^c + h_b a_b h_d q b_r^c + h_a_h_dl _
r^c + & & + a _
h_u h_d s + a _
s^3 ) + . [ eq:5 ] ( again , an effective mssm - like @xmath46-parameter @xmath47 is generated . ) all parameters in the above lagrangian depend on the energy scale via the corresponding renormalization group ( rg ) equations , which account for the dominant radiative corrections involving large logarithms . in the constrained nmssm ,
one imposes unification of the soft susy breaking gaugino masses , sfermion and higgs masses as well as trilinear couplings at the grand unification ( gut ) scale @xmath48 : & & m_1 = m_2 = m_3 m_1/2 , + & & m_h_u = m_h_d = m_q = m_t = m_b = m_l = m _ m_0 , + & & a_t = a_b = a_= a_a_0 . [ eq:6 ] since the singlet superfield could play a special role ( its couplings to a hidden sector , responsible for supersymmetry breaking , could differ from the mssm - like fields ) , we will allow for non - universal singlet - specific soft terms @xmath49 and @xmath50 at the grand unification scale .
this is the so - called semi - constrained nmssm , denoted by snmssm subsequently . including the top quark yukawa coupling due to its influence on the rg equations , the lagrangian of the snmssm depends on eight parameters @xmath27 at the gut scale : p_i^ = m_1/2 , m_0 , a_0 , , , m_s , a _ and h_t .
[ eq:7 ] the calculation of @xmath51 defined in ( [ eq:1 ] ) proceeds in two steps : first , we compute the variations [ eq:8 ] _
i^ = || with respect to the parameters @xmath52 at the susy scale ( the susy scale is defined to be of the order of the soft susy breaking terms ) . subsequently these variations are contracted with the jacobian [ eq:9 ] j_i j = || which takes care of the renormalization group running of the parameters between the susy and the gut scales .
then we obtain [ eq:10 ] _
i^ j_i j . the parameters @xmath52
at the susy scale are those appearing in the ( effective ) higgs potential , whose minimization determines the vevs @xmath53 of @xmath20 , @xmath54 of @xmath21 and @xmath45 of @xmath19 .
these vevs determine , in turn , the quantities [ eq:11 ] m_z^2 = ( v_u^2+v_d^2 ) , = _
= s . including the dominant top quark
/ squark induced radiative corrections , the three minimisation equations @xmath55 are given by @xcite e_1 : & m_h_u^2+_^2+^2v_d^2 + ( v_u^2-v_d^2 ) - _ ( a_+s ) + ( m_^2/m_top^2 ) = 0 , + e_2 : & m_h_d^2+_^2+^2v_u^2 + ( v_d^2-v_u^2 ) - _ ( a_+s ) = 0 , + e_3 : & m_s^2 + a_s + 2 ^ 2 s^2 + ^2(v_u^2+v_d^2)-2v_u v_d - a_= 0 , [ eq:12 ] where @xmath56 denotes an average value of the top squark masses .
( it is not necessary to be more precise here , in contrast to the radiative corrections to the physical higgs masses . )
it is straightforward to express the vevs @xmath53 , @xmath54 and @xmath45 in terms of @xmath28 , @xmath57 and @xmath58 with the help of these equations .
hence the relevant parameters @xmath52 at the susy scale are given by ( leaving aside the electroweak gauge couplings @xmath59 and @xmath60 , as well as @xmath56 inside the logarithm ) p_i^ = m_h_u , m_h_d , m_s^2 , a_ , a _ , , , and h_t .
[ eq:13 ] in order to compute the variations @xmath61 ( see ( [ eq:8 ] ) ) with respect to these parameters , we use 0 = e_j = _
i p_i^ + m_z+ + _ [ eq:14 ] for @xmath62 . since all partial derivatives of the equations @xmath63 can be computed explicitely , the three equations ( [ eq:14 ] )
can be solved for @xmath64 ( and , separately , for @xmath65 and @xmath66 ) as function of all @xmath67 , which allows to determine the variations @xmath61 in ( [ eq:8 ] ) . at this stage
it is useful to recall the origin of the `` little fine tuning problem '' in the mssm . neglecting the radiative corrections , the minimisation equations ( [ eq:12 ] ) of the higgs potential imply , with @xmath68 in the mssm , [ eq:15 ] m_z^2 -2 ^ 2 + . in the absence of fine tuning , all terms on the right hand side of ( [ eq:15 ] ) should be of comparable magnitude , and no large cancellations should occur ; hence both @xmath69 and @xmath70 should not be much larger than @xmath71 .
however , from the rg equations one typically obtains @xmath72 , which is often required to be much larger ( in absolute value ) than @xmath28 : at least within the mssm , the sm - like higgs scalar mass increases proportionally to @xmath73 due to top / stop induced radiative corrections . then , large values for @xmath56 are unavoidable in order to satisfy the lep bound .
albeit large stop masses are consistent with the non - observation of top squarks , they would generate an uncomfortably large value for @xmath74 which has to be cancelled by @xmath69 in ( [ eq:15 ] ) .
for large @xmath75 one finds for @xmath76 , following ( [ eq:8 ] ) with @xmath77 or @xmath78 , [ eq:16 ] _
m_h_u^ ~2 ~_^ ~2 .
accordingly large values for @xmath61 ( leading , generally , to large values for @xmath79 ) reflect well the necessary fine tuning if @xmath70 and hence @xmath69 are large . in the nmssm @xmath18 is replaced by @xmath80 . for large @xmath81 ,
the above reasoning remains essentially unchanged : for @xmath82 ( valid in most of the parameter space ) , @xmath83 in ( [ eq:12 ] ) gives [ eq:17 ] s ~ ( -a_- ) .
replacing @xmath84 and ( [ eq:17 ] ) for @xmath45 in ( [ eq:15 ] ) , one finds again from ( [ eq:8 ] ) [ eq:18 ] _
~_^ ~_^ ~ 2 in the nmssm .
hence , quite obviously , large values for @xmath70 are unnatural as well . however ,
due to the nmssm specific contributions to the higgs masses and mixings or nmssm specific higgs decays , lep bounds on the higgs sector can be satisfied for smaller top / stop induced radiative corrections , hence for smaller values of @xmath56 , allowing for smaller values for @xmath70 and @xmath85 .
it remains to express the variations of the parameters at the susy scale in terms of variations of the parameters at the gut scale , i.e. to compute the jacobian @xmath86 in ( [ eq:9 ] ) , via the integration of the rg equations for the parameters . in the cmssm
( with boundary conditions at the gut scale as in ( [ eq:6 ] ) ) one can always write [ eq:19 ] m_h_u^2 = a^(1)m_0 ^ 2 + a^(2)m_1/2 ^ 2 + a^(3)a_0 ^ 2 + a^(4)m_1/2a_0 and [ eq:20 ] ^2 = b _ 0 ^ 2 , where the coefficients @xmath87 and @xmath88 depend on the gauge and yukawa couplings . in the typical case
where _ all _ @xmath87 in ( [ eq:19 ] ) satisfy @xmath89 , one can verify that all variations @xmath90 , with @xmath91 , are less than 1 . at first sight , due to @xmath92 for these parameters @xmath27
, this seems to reduce the necessary fine tuning in the mssm .
however , due to @xmath93 , @xmath94 remains always large .
moreover , @xmath95 should generally be included in the list of parameters @xmath27 @xcite , and the corresponding variation @xmath96 can be large .
this holds particularly in the so - called focus point region of the mssm where @xmath97 , and @xmath98 in ( [ eq:19 ] ) for specific values of @xmath95 ( but a large derivative of @xmath99 with respect to @xmath95 ) . in the snmssm , additional terms @xmath100 and @xmath101
appear on the right hand side of ( [ eq:19 ] ) , which have little impact in practice . instead of ( [ eq:20 ] ) , the rg equations for @xmath22 , @xmath102 and @xmath103 will now play some role since
, replacing ( [ eq:17 ] ) for @xmath45 in @xmath58 , @xmath58 depends on these parameters ( apart from a dependence on @xmath104 ) .
in fact one can verify that , in the mssm limit of the nmssm where @xmath22 , @xmath105 , @xmath58 satisfies the _ same _ rg equation as @xmath18 .
all in all we can not expect dramatic effects on the fine tuning from the somewhat different running of the parameters between the susy and the gut scale in the nmssm . in practice our computation of the different variations @xmath51 in the space of parameters @xmath106 ( [ eq:7 ] ) , in order to find its maximum @xmath26 as function of @xmath107 ( see ( [ eq:1 ] ) ) at a specific point in the parameter space , is performed as follows : for each such point , the code nmspec @xcite inside nmssmtools @xcite is used in order to compute the higgs and sparticle spectrum including radiative corrections as described in these references .
constraints from lep , b - physics and the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon are taken care of according to the latest updates given on the web site http://www.th.u-psud.fr/nmhdecay/nmssmtools.html .
( no constraints on the dark matter relic density are imposed ; however , in most cases these could be satisfied by giving up the bino mass unification @xmath108 at the gut scale , i.e. chosing an appropriate mass for the lightest neutralino - like susy particle ( lsp ) without impact on the results relevant here . ) for phenomenologically acceptable points , @xmath109 is computed from the three minimization equations @xmath55 in ( [ eq:12 ] ) , following the procedure described above .
the jacobian @xmath86 , i.e. the variations of the parameters at the susy scale in terms of variations of the parameters at the gut scale , is computed numerically from the two loop rg equations .
this allows to obtain the necessary quantities @xmath51 , whose maximum with respect to all parameters @xmath106 ( [ eq:7 ] ) defines @xmath26 .
to start with , we apply our procedure to the cmssm , which allows for comparisons with the snmssm and the available literature . the relevant parameters @xmath110 at the gut scale are p_i^ ( ) = m_1/2 , m_0 , a_0 , _ 0 , b_0 , and h_t .
[ eq:21 ] as usual , @xmath18 and @xmath46 ( and hence @xmath111 and @xmath112 ) are determined by @xmath7 and @xmath57 , but they still contribute to the definition of @xmath26 .
next we scan over a grid of values of @xmath0 and @xmath1 . for each set of these values , we scan over @xmath113 and @xmath57 . keeping only sets of parameters
consistent with all phenomenological constraints , we look for values of @xmath113 and @xmath57 which minimize @xmath26 as defined in ( [ eq:1 ] ) for fixed @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
the resulting minimal values of @xmath26 can be represented in the plane @xmath114 , or in the plane @xmath115 ( where @xmath116 refers to squarks of the first generation ) in figs .
[ fig:1 ] . [ cols="^,^ " , ] our results for the minimal fine tuning
@xmath26 in the snmssm scenario ( 2 ) are shown in figs . [ fig:5 ] in the same planes as before .
similar to the snmssm scenario ( 1 ) , respecting just the pre - lhc constraints , the fine tuning measure @xmath26 can be as small as 9 for low values of @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
applying naively the bounds for the cmssm scenarios studied by the atlas and cms collaborations to the snmssm , we find that the smallest admissible value of @xmath26 becomes @xmath117 for @xmath118 gev , @xmath119 gev , hence below the smalles admissible value in the cmssm . in the region of low @xmath26
, the @xmath120 is larger than 80 % .
again , the values of the nmssm - specific coupling @xmath22 do not have to be large in order to favour @xmath121 decays once these are kinematically allowed ; the value of @xmath22 varies between 0.02 and 0.16 in figs .
[ fig:5 ] . in fig .
[ fig:6 ] we show the minimal value of @xmath26 as function of the mass @xmath122 of the now sm - like state @xmath24 , imposing lep constraints .
again the preferred value of @xmath122 is not always as small as possible ; now the minimal fine tuning is obtained for @xmath122 in the range @xmath123 gev , and increases again strongly for larger values of @xmath23 .
it is also interesting to study the dependence of the fine tuning on @xmath124 . at first sight
, @xmath26 depends hardly on @xmath124 within the snmssm , where @xmath104 differs from @xmath113 at the gut scale : a variation of @xmath124 from @xmath125 to @xmath126 gev ( still allowing for @xmath121 decays ) corresponds to a variation of @xmath127 from @xmath128 gev to @xmath129 gev at the gut scale , which has practically no effect on the fine tuning measure @xmath26 .
however , different values for @xmath124 correspond to different lower lep bounds on @xmath23 ; lower bounds @xmath23 , in turn , affect @xmath26 as in fig . [ fig:6 ] .
the resulting minimal values of @xmath26 as function of @xmath124 are shown in fig .
[ fig:7 ] . the structures in fig .
[ fig:7 ] can be explained as follows : for @xmath130 gev , lep bounds on @xmath131 ( here with @xmath132 , and @xmath133 ) apply , see figs . 3 in @xcite .
the corresponding lower bounds on @xmath23 are somewhat weaker for @xmath134 gev than for @xmath135 gev , leading to a lower fine tuning for @xmath136 gev where @xmath137 gev .
( for @xmath138 gev , the lower bound on @xmath23 has a dip implying a dip in @xmath26 . for @xmath139 gev , @xmath26 increases since @xmath140 gev is required for kinematic reasons ; here this scenario is obviously not preferred . ) for @xmath141 gev , strong lower bounds on @xmath23 from aleph @xcite on the @xmath142 apply at first sight .
however , due to a reduced branching ratio for @xmath143 form @xmath144 mixing @xcite , the window @xmath145 gev is hardly affected by these constraints , allowing for @xmath23 to assume values for which @xmath26 is minimal according to fig .
[ fig:6 ] .
( for @xmath146 gev , parameters have to be tuned in order to satisfy constraints from @xmath147 . )
hence we find two distinct regions for @xmath124 where @xmath121 decays allow for a considerable reduction of the fine tuning .
we have studied the amount of fine tuning in the parameter space of the semi - constrained nmssm , and compared it to the cmssm .
representing the minimal fine tuning in the plane @xmath148 allowed us to study the impact of early lhc results .
first we verified quantitatively , to what extend the nmssm - specific scenarios in the higgs sector allow to alleviate the lep constraints with respect to the mssm .
we found indeed that a considerable reduction of the fine tuning is possible in scenarios where the lightest cp - even higgs state is dominantly singlet like , or in scenarios where @xmath121 decays are possible , notably for @xmath149 gev and @xmath150 .
if one applies naively the early lhc constraints on the cmssm in the @xmath114-plane to the snmssm , the impact on the minimal fine tuning is stronger in the snmssm since these constraints affect in particular the region of smaller susy breaking terms where the fine tuning in the snmssm can be relatively small . still , the necessary fine tuning in the snmssm in scenarios where @xmath121 decays are possible is smaller than in the cmssm , but only if the susy breaking terms are not too large ( hence if sparticles are not too heavy ) .
otherwise , if the susy breaking terms are larger , the fine tuning does not originate from lep constraints on the higgs sector , but from the smallness of the weak scale with respect to the susy scale .
this hardly depends on details of the higgs sector of the susy model , as long as the fundamental parameters are defined at the gut scale and influence each other through the renormalization group running between the gut and the weak scale .
hence the same question should be re - analysed in the nmssm with gauge mediated supersymmetry breaking @xcite , where the susy breaking parameters can originate from much lower scales , and where the susy breaking higgs mass terms can differ considerably from squark mass terms .
u. e. acknowledges support from the french anr lfv - cpv - lhc . c. h. acknowledges support from the french anr tapdms ( anr-09-jcjc-0146 ) .
cms collaboration , `` search for supersymmetry in all - hadronic events with @xmath151 '' , cms - pas - sus-11 - 003 , presentation at the 2011 europhysics conference on high energy physics , grenoble , france , 21 - 27 july 2011 j. f. gunion , d. e. lopez - fogliani , l. roszkowski , r. r. de austri and t. a. varley , `` next - to - minimal supersymmetric model higgs scenarios for partially universal gut scale boundary conditions , '' arxiv:1105.1195 . | we study the fine tuning in the parameter space of the semi - constrained nmssm , where most soft susy breaking parameters are universal at the gut scale .
we discuss the dependence of the fine tuning on the soft susy breaking parameters @xmath0 and @xmath1 , and on the higgs masses in nmssm specific scenarios involving large singlet - doublet higgs mixing or dominant higgs - to - higgs decays . whereas these latter scenarios allow _ a priori _ for considerably less fine tuning than the constrained mssm , the early lhc results rule out a large part of the parameter space of the semi - constrained nmssm corresponding to low values of the fine tuning .
lpt orsay 11 - 63 + l2c 11- + lupm 11 - 002 + + * ulrich ellwanger@xmath2 , grgory espitalier - nol@xmath3 and cyril hugonie@xmath4 * + _ @xmath2 lpt , umr 8627 , cnrs , universit de paris sud , 91405 orsay , france + _
@xmath5 l2c , umr 5221 , cnrs , universit de montpellier ii , 34095 montpellier , france + _ @xmath4 lupm , umr 5299 , cnrs , universit de montpellier ii , 34095 montpellier , france + _ _ _ |
here we study the dispersive effect of atoms when they are trapped in a one dimensional optical lattice , as expected for the tapered fiber trap given in the paper .
we consider a situation where the atoms are not saturated with few photons @xmath91 , and therefore , the system is in the linear regime and the electric field operator can be presented by its expectation value , i.e. , @xmath92 . furthermore , since the atoms are periodically spaced , we can discretize the propagation of the electric field ( as shown in fig . 2 of the main text ) and
use the transfer matrix formalism to study multiple scattering events to all order @xcite . in the @xmath93th cell
, we define the forward ( backward)-propagating field as @xmath94 , respectively .
the fields in two consecutive cells are related by : @xmath95 where @xmath96 is the transfer matrix and the corresponding transmission ( reflection ) coefficient is given by : @xmath97 , respectively .
the transfer matrix of each cell is the product of two terms : @xmath98 .
the first term corresponds to the free propagation between two sites : @xmath99 where @xmath100 is the wave number of the incoming field , and @xmath101 is the lattice spacing .
the second represents the light scattering due to the presence of atoms : @xmath102 where @xmath103 characterizes the light scattering from the trapped atoms in a single site . in other words , the atomic transmission ( reflection )
coefficient is @xmath104 , respectively .
now , we study the scattering of photons from a single site ( i.e. single atom ) to find @xmath103 . a generic three - level system ( fig.[fig : three - level - system - coupled ] )
coupled to an electromagnetic waveguide can be described by the following hamiltonian @xcite : @xmath105 where the atomic term , in the rotating framce , is given by ( @xmath106 ) : @xmath107 where @xmath108 is the energy of the state @xmath109 for @xmath110 , and @xmath111 is the frequency of the control field .
we assume the waveguide has linear dispersion , so the hamiltonian of free propagating photons can be written as : @xmath112 where the annihilation operator for the left- ( right- ) going field at position @xmath113 is denoted as @xmath114 , respectively and @xmath115 is the group velocity in the waveguide .
finally , the atom - field coupling is described by : @xmath116 where the atom is located at @xmath117 and the atom - field coupling coefficient is @xmath118 .
assuming that there is only one excitation inside the system , the most general state of the system can be written as : @xmath119 where the first term in the ket refers to the atomic state and the second term refers to the photon fock state .
now , we consider a situation where the field is propagating to the right and scatter from the atom at location @xmath117 .
therefore , the photonic wave function will take the form @xmath120 where @xmath121 is the atomic transmission ( reflection ) coefficient , respectively . by solving the equation @xmath122
, we find that : @xmath123 note that we have added the effect of the spontaneous emission into the outside photonic modes by introducing a polarization decay term with the rate @xmath124 .
we assume the ground state decay is negligible . , respectively . the control field ( @xmath125 is detuned from e @xmath126 s transition by @xmath127 .
[ fig : three - level - system - coupled ] ] therefore , the reflection coefficient of light scattering at each site is given by : @xmath128 where @xmath129 is the spontaneous emission rate into the waveguide .
the total spontaneous emission rate is @xmath130 .
therefore , the scattering matrix of a single cell will be : @xmath131 where @xmath132 . by defining the lattice frequency as @xmath133
, we can write the probe wave number in terms of the detuning from the atomic transition : @xmath134 . for simplicity , we assume the resonant eit case @xmath135 .
the band structure of a 1d array of 50,000 sites is shown in fig.[fig : band_theory ] . due to the atomic periodic dispersion
, one can observe the appearance of a band gap and also the finite size oscillations at the band gap edge @xcite . note that number used in fig.[fig : band_theory ] are far from accessible regime in the current experiments @xcite . and
[ fig : band_theory],scaledwidth=40.0% ] as mentioned in the main text , for the numbers close to the experimental parameters , we recover a transmission spectrum similar to that of free space , as shown in fig . 3 of the main text .
there , the dips in the transmission spectrum corresponds to dressed states split by the rabi frequency of the control field , in direct analogy to eit in free space .
in this section , we discuss the adiabatic transfer of a single excitation from one lc resonator to another , using a dark state . first we consider a single cell where an atomic ensemble is coupled to a resonator . since the system is linear , we solve the problem for a single excitation
. the result can be easily generalized to any number of excitations , as long as the number of excitations remains smaller than than the number of atoms to guarantee the bosonic commutation relations @xcite .
the equations of motion are given by @xcite : @xmath137 where @xmath138 represents the state of the system : @xmath139 is the mircowave electric field , @xmath140 is the atomic coherence for @xmath141 transition , and @xmath142 is the atomic coherence for @xmath143 transition . the hamiltonian is where @xmath145 and the dimesionless detuning is @xmath146 we use @xmath147 for the unit of energy . in this case , the group velocity reduction factor is @xmath148 when the atmoic medium is inside a resonator , the slow light effect manifests itself as narrowing of the resonator bandwidth @xcite .
the energy spectrum of the system as a function of the control field which is characterized by @xmath149 is shown in fig .
[ fig : single - eit ] .
the zero energy state is the dark state @xmath150 , where @xmath151 represents the photonic state and @xmath152 represents the atomic coherence .
therefore , one can change the nature of the dark state from photonic to atomic by increasing @xmath149 , or equivalently decreasing the magnitude of the control field @xmath153 . .
note that the dark state has zero energy and is separated from the other states .
( b ) the dark state nature changes from photonic to atomic by changing the control field , characterized by @xmath149 .
[ fig : single - eit],title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] .
note that the dark state has zero energy and is separated from the other states .
( b ) the dark state nature changes from photonic to atomic by changing the control field , characterized by @xmath149 .
[ fig : single - eit],title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] now , we consider two cells to investigate the adiabatic passage of a single excitation between them , by simply changing their respective control field ( @xmath154 ) . the state of the system can be represented by @xmath155 , and the coupling matrix is : where @xmath157 and @xmath158 respresents the electric field coupling between resonators . before presenting the scheme
, we study the behavior of the system for different control field values @xmath159 .
in particular , we investigate the situation where they are inversely changed : @xmath160 and the control field values cross at @xmath161 .
the energy eigenstates of the system are detonated by @xmath83 with their corresponding energies @xmath84 .
the energy spectrum of such coupled system is shown in fig.[fig : double - eit ] .
due to coupling between the resonators , the dark states are split .
since the coupling between dark states is given by @xmath162 , this splitting is more pronounced when @xmath163@xmath164 .
if this was the only coupling mechanics , then at very large or small @xmath149 s , the splitting would vanish .
however , there is a finite splitting between the new dark states which is constant in those limits .
the latter splitting is due to coupling of the dark states to the bright and excited states . using second order perturbation theory
, we find that the energy corrections to the dark states are equal to @xmath165 for both large and small @xmath149 s .
when two cells are decoupled from each other , if @xmath166 ( and @xmath167 ) , then we have @xmath168 and @xmath169 .
therefore , in this limit , the coupled dark states are : @xmath170 and @xmath171 .
similarly , for the opposite limit , when @xmath172 ( and @xmath173 ) , we will have @xmath174 and @xmath175 .
, ( b ) probabilities of photonic and atomic components of the forth lowest eigenstate @xmath85 . by changing the control fields ( increasing @xmath71 and decreasing @xmath176 ) , the atomic coherence transfers from the second cell to the first cell , characterized by @xmath177 and @xmath178 , respectively . in these plots , @xmath179 and @xmath180 . [
fig : double - eit],title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] , ( b ) probabilities of photonic and atomic components of the forth lowest eigenstate @xmath85 . by changing the control fields ( increasing @xmath71 and decreasing @xmath176 ) , the atomic coherence transfers from the second cell to the first cell , characterized by @xmath177 and @xmath178 , respectively . in these plots , @xmath179 and @xmath180 .
[ fig : double - eit],title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] therefore , we can adiabatically transfer an atomic excitation from the resonator 2 to the resonator 1 while remaining in the dark state ( @xmath85 ) .
the adiabaticity condition is @xmath82 , where the sum is over all the states except the dark state of interest .
therefore , a slower transfer is more adiabatic .
however , a slower transfer leads to higher loss of the excitation which is characterized by : @xmath181 , where the first ( second ) term represents the photonic ( atomic ) loss , respectively .
the photonic loss is due to the intrinsic loss of the resonator . in general
, there should also be a term for the polarization ( @xmath182 ) loss ; however , for the dark state transfer , the probability of the excitation being in the excited state is negligible and therefore one can ignore that the polarization loss . combining these two conditions , we find that one should always satisfy @xmath183 , regardless of the control field changing rate .
we can use this condition to find optimized values of the detuning ( @xmath75 ) and the control field crossing @xmath74 .
an example of this optimization is shown in fig . 3 of the main text . | a complete physical approach to quantum information requires a robust interface among flying qubits , long - lifetime memory and computational qubits . here
we present a unified interface for microwave and optical photons , potentially connecting engineerable quantum devices such as superconducting qubits at long distances through optical photons .
our approach uses an ultracold ensemble of atoms for two purposes : quantum memory and to transduce excitations between the two frequency domains . using coherent control techniques
, we examine an approach for converting and storing quantum information between microwave photons in superconducting resonators , ensembles of ultracold atoms , and optical photons as well as a method for transferring information between two resonators . controlling
the interaction between quantum bits and electromagnetic fields is a fundamental challenge underlying quantum information science .
ideally , control allows storage , communication , and manipulation of the information at the level of single quanta .
unfortunately , no single degree of freedom satisfies all these criteria simultaneously @xcite . instead
, a hybrid approach may take advantage of each system s most attractive properties .
for example , optical photons provide a robust long - distance quantum bus @xcite , while microwave ( mw ) photons can be easily manipulated using superconducting qubits @xcite , and atoms can store quantum information for seconds or even minutes @xcite .
we propose an interface between optical , microwave photons and atomic excitations that takes advantage of each of these properties . in a recent proposal ,
the possibility of coupling ultracold atoms to a nanofibre in the vicinity of a superconducting waveguide / resonator was suggested [ fig.1(a ) ] @xcite .
the evanescent tail of the two - color laser field propagating in the fiber provides the necessary potential to trap atoms close to the nanofibre in the form of a 1d lattice , which has recently been demonstrated in ref .
. exponential decay of the optical trapping field allows the atoms to be held close to the superconducting waveguide , leading to a large atom - photon coupling in the microwave domain .
furthermore , the nanofibre provides an optical waveguide both for trap light and for optical access to atoms .
such a system would provide a simultaneous interface between optical and mw photons and atomic ensemble quantum memory .
( @xmath0 ) is manipulated using a classical control radio - frequency ( optical ) field with rabi frequency @xmath1 ( @xmath2 ) , respectively .
trapping lights are not shown in the figure .
( b ) the quantum ( @xmath3 ) and control ( @xmath1 ) electromagnetic fields arrive while the atomic system is in the ground state .
( c ) the quantum field is stored as an atomic spin excitation ( @xmath4 ) .
( d ) internal level structure of a @xmath5rb atom and transitions induced by the four electromagnetic fields .
@xmath6 are two - photon and one - photon detunings , respectively .
( e ) dimensions of an example lc resonator .
( f ) magnetic field profile viewed from the top , lighter colors show higher fields.,scaledwidth=44.0% ] in this letter , we theoretically illustrate how this proposed system enables storage , retrieval and conversion for optical and mw photons .
experiments have established @xcite that coherent control techniques of multilevel atoms @xcite , based on electric - dipole coupling in a @xmath7-system , allow for efficient storage and retrieval of optical photons into atomic excitations from an ensemble of atoms .
we adapt this approach to also store and retrieve mw photons .
we investigate the effect of finite bandwidth of mw photons on the storage - retrieval process and also the effect of periodicity of the atomic ensemble which can change the propagation of optical photons due to bragg scattering .
we conclude by discussing quantum communication and measurement protocols enabled by our interface as well as the use of non - alkali atoms for enhanced coupling @xcite .
the storage of photons ( either in the mw or optical domain ) in atomic excitations in a generic @xmath7-system forms the basis for our interface , and is shown in fig . 1 .
specifically , we start with an optically pumped ensemble of @xmath8 atoms in one of the hyperfine ground states , @xmath9 . a classical control field @xmath10 ( or @xmath11
is used to coherently manipulate the coupling between an intermediate state @xmath12 ( or @xmath13 ) and a final ground state @xmath14 .
these control fields in turn determine the propagation of the quantum field @xmath15 ( or @xmath16 ) coupling @xmath9 to @xmath12 ( @xmath13 ) , leading to electromagnetically induced transparency ( eit ) and slow light .
the evolution of such coupled system is best described by a bosonic dark state polariton @xcite , with creation operator : @xmath17 where @xmath18 corresponds to either optical ( o ) or mw domains ( m ) .
@xmath19 is spin wave creation operator associated with the atomic ground state coherence @xmath20 , in the continuum limit @xcite we discuss the effect of lattice later in the letter . here
@xmath21 is the electric ( magnetic ) dipole coupling between the atoms and the optical ( microwave ) waveguide photons , respectively , and @xmath8 is the total number of atoms . during the entire operation ,
quantum excitations remain in the form of a dark polariton and the ratio between the enhanced atom - photon coupling and the control field ( @xmath22 ) dictates the mixture between atomic and photonic parts . in particular , when the control is strong @xmath23 , the polariton is mostly photonic and the system is transparent , with a group velocity near to the speed of light .
in contrast , when the control is weak @xmath24 ) , the polariton is mostly atomic , with a group velocity approaching zero ( slow light ) .
changing the control field allows one to transform a photonic excitation into an atomic excitation and vice versa ( see ref .
@xcite ) : once the incoming pulse is entirely inside the system , the control field is adiabatically turned off ( @xmath25 ) , and the excitation will be stored as atomic spin excitations in the ground state manifold ( @xmath26 ) [ fig .
1(b , c ) ] . by reversing the control field(s ) in time ,
the stored atomic excitations can later be retrieved as mw or optical photons .
we first address the practical challenges for storing and retrieving mw photons . as an example case ,
we consider trapped @xmath5rb atoms coupled to the mw waveguide through the magnetic - dipole interaction , which is characterized by single - photon rabi frequency @xmath27 @xcite .
the optimal states to preserve the ground state coherence are the clock states @xcite : @xmath28 and @xmath29 , as shown in fig .
1(d ) .
the ground state decoherence rate is dominated by off - resonant scattering of photons from the trapping lasers which is relatively small @xmath30 @xcite . the quantum field ( @xmath3 ) and the classical radio - frequency control field ( @xmath1 )
are shown in fig .
1(d ) .
in order to isolate a single atomic transition to interact with the mw photon , we can use polarization and frequency selectivity .
furthermore , the application of a moderate magnetic field ( @xmath31 mt ) , leads to a necessary quadratic zeeman shift and makes the multilevel corrections negligible .
for example , as shown in fig .
1(d ) , a zeeman field can split the degeneracy within the hyperfine states so that only the two - photon transition between @xmath9 and @xmath14 is possible
. we review the conditions under which the standard optical eit storage technique is efficient @xcite and apply them to the microwave domain .
we focus on the free - space case , and the generalization to the resonator case can be done by replacement : @xmath32 , the resonator decay rate .
the bandwidth of the incoming ( or retrieval ) photon can not be arbitrarily large .
analytical and numerical calculations have shown that an adiabatic condition must be fulfilled @xcite , and photons with large bandwidth can not be stored since the system does not have fast enough response time .
this condition can be intuitively derived , as discussed in refs .
@xcite .
briefly , a single spin - wave excitation transfers into the waveguide with a rate @xmath33 and decays via a decoherence rate @xmath34 .
consequently , via time - reversal symmetry , the bandwidth of an incoming photon to be stored must satisfy @xmath35 , where @xmath36 is the pulse duration .
the retrieval efficiency is equal to the ratio between the transfer rate and the combined transfer and decay rates , i.e. @xmath37 . in the optical domain ,
this efficiency is simply given by the optical depth of the system , i.e. @xmath38 @xcite , where @xmath39 is total spontaneous emission rate of the optical transition and where @xmath40 is the single - photon electric - dipole coupling to the fiber .
for a given pulse duration , which satisfies the maximum bandwidth condition ( above ) , the medium should initially be transparent to the pulse @xmath41 , where @xmath42 is the width of the transparency window . at the same time
, the entire pulse should fit inside the medium : @xmath43 .
given that the group velocity @xmath44 and @xmath45 , the last two conditions can only be satisfied in the high cooperativity limit : @xmath46 . in the optical eit schemes , where the transition decay is dominated by radiative decay , the condition is equivalent to requiring large optical depth .
moreover , the required control field is optimal when the bandwidth of the incoming photon matches the reduced resonator linewidth ( due to a slow light effect ) @xcite , i.e. , @xmath47 .
the bandwidth of mw photons originating in the resonator is given by the resonator bandwidth ( @xmath48 ) .
we consider a lc resonator , schematically shown in the fig .
1(a ) , where the inductor part is long enough ( @xmath49 mm ) to accommodate many atoms ( @xmath8 = 8,000 ) .
using simulation software , we tune the capacitor to achieve a resonance with @xmath5rb around @xmath50 ghz ( for details see ref .
@xcite ) .
the magnetic field is relatively uniform along the inductor part , as shown in fig .
1(f ) .
the corresponding single - photon magnetic coupling is estimated numerically to be @xmath51 hz . assuming a quality factor @xmath52 , @xmath53
, the bandwidth condition can be satisfied . under these conditions
, the magnetic cooperativity is @xmath54 .
the required rf control field should be @xmath55 khz .
the optical coupling is characterized by the ratio between the spontaneous emission into the fiber and the total spontaneous emission , i.e. , @xmath56 .
this ratio is estimated to be @xmath57 @xcite .
therefore , the electrical cooperativity ( optical depth ) of the system is od@xmath58 .
the high electric ( magnetic ) cooperativity guarantees efficient transfer of excitations in the optical ( mw ) domain , respectively .
we now shift our attention to the new features of the optical components of our interface .
trapped @xmath5rb atoms are coupled to light in the optical fiber through the electric - dipole interaction . since the atoms are trapped in a one - dimensional lattice along the optical fiber , the light propagating inside the fiber experiences periodic scattering in the form of a bragg grating .
the effect of such multiple scatterings can lead to a bandgap structure , in direct analogy to two - level atoms in an optical lattice @xcite . since the atoms are not saturated by small numbers of photons @xmath59 , the system is linear , i.e. , away from the photon - blockade regime @xcite . as the atoms are periodically spaced , we can discretize the propagation of the electric field ( fig .
2(a ) ) and use the transfer matrix formalism to study these multiple scatterings , due to three - level transition ( @xmath60)(see the supplemental material for details ) .
the transmission spectrum of a 1d array of 8000 sites ( @xmath61 ) is shown in fig . [ fig : band_theory](b ) .
we find that our realistic numbers lead to behavior close to that of free space and no band gap structure is observed @xcite .
in particular , the dips in the transmission spectrum correspond to dressed states split by the rabi frequency of the control field , in direct analogy to eit in free space . in the middle of the transparency window ,
the excitations transform entirely into spin excitation of the atoms .
therefore , once the pulse is inside the atomic medium , by turning off the control field , the photonic excitation can be stored as atomic ground state excitation .
deviations from this behavior can occur , particularly for stronger single atom - field coupling , but this will be the subject of future research . ,
the lattice spacing @xmath62 nm , and one atom per site is considered .
( c ) atomic level configuration for detecting a single excitation.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] in such hybrid system , we can implement various protocols .
first , one can coherently transfer the optical photon , mw photons and atomic excitation to each other . as mentioned earlier , this process is efficient when the cooperativity is large @xmath63 and the photon pulse duration satisfies @xmath35 .
this enables a quantum - coherent interconnection between mw excitations and optical photons , which allows for a wide variety of quantum communication and quantum information protocols between distant systems , including quantum repeaters , teleportation - based gates , and distributed quantum computing @xcite .
second , in this interface , single photons can be detected with high quantum efficiency .
in particular , when the excitation is a photon ( either optical or mw ) , it can transferred to an atomic spin wave . in turn
, the atomic spin wave can be transferred to a hyperfine excitation detectable by absorption @xcite , as shown in fig .
2(c ) .
more specifically , the single atomic excitation in form of @xmath20 coherence can be efficiently transferred to @xmath64 , using mw and rf control fields @xcite . then , using the cycling transition , we can verify the number of original excitations with a high degree of confidence using , e.g. , bayesian inference .
third , we can generate entanglement between a mw photon and the atomic ensemble in analogy to off - resonant raman atom - photon entanglement generation @xcite .
the atomic ensemble should be prepared at @xmath65 level ; then applying a rf field coherently generates an anti - stokes mw photon accompanied with a atomic excitation in the coherence @xmath66 , where the outgoing mw photon and the atomic ensemble are entangled .
the efficiency of this process is similar to the storage - retrieval of single excitations , as discussed earlier .
fourth , we can envisage using the hybrid system to induce a large optical nonlinearity via known josephson junction - based microwave nonlinearities .
in particular , when the control fields @xmath67 are on , through a four - wave - mixing process , the optical and mw photons will be coupled to each other .
therefore , by adding a nonlinear element for mw photons ( e.g. , cooper pair boxes or superconducting qubits @xcite ) , a large optical nonlinearity can be induced for optical photons .
such a large nonlinearity could be harnessed to perform a two - qubit phase gate on optical photons , a key ingredient of deterministic optical quantum computing . and each having intrinsic loss @xmath68 )
, an adiabatic quantum state transfer can be performed , using atomic ensembles .
( b ) probabilities of having the excitation in the photonic ( normalized @xmath69 ) or atomic ( normalized @xmath70 ) form , as a function of control field @xmath71 , where @xmath72 , for optimized values of @xmath73 .
( c ) the combined adiabaticity - loss condition for crossing value of control fields ( @xmath74 ) and one - photon detuning ( @xmath75 ) , as shown in fig . 1 . , scaledwidth=45.0% ] finally , we can use this system to coherently transfer quantum excitations between two coupled cells , each comprising a resonator and atomic ensemble ( fig .
[ state_transfer](a ) ) @xcite , where the coupling rate is @xmath76 and the intrinsic resonator loss rate is @xmath68 . by changing the control field ( @xmath77 ) in each cell , one can dynamically control the resonator decay rate , i.e. @xmath78 and perform dynamical impedance matching @xcite . if @xmath79 , then the dark state in cell one ( two ) , is mostly photonic ( atomic ) , respectively .
therefore , by adiabatically going from @xmath80 to @xmath81 , we can transfer an atomic excitation from cell two to cell one .
the process can be performed with high fidelity because the photonic mode is never excited and the system remains in a dark state , as shown in fig.[state_transfer](b ) , where @xmath72 and the control field values cross at @xmath74 ( see the supplemental material for details ) . during this process , two conditions should be satisfied : ( 1 ) adiabaticity : @xmath82 where @xmath83 are energy eigenstates of the system and @xmath84 their corresponding energies , the dark state of interest is @xmath85 .
( 2 ) negligible loss : @xmath86 , where the first ( second ) term represents the photonic ( atomic ) loss , respectively . in order to satisfy both
, one should have @xmath87 ( see fig.[state_transfer](c ) ) .
for relevant experimental parameters @xmath88 , we find the optimized values for the crossing value of control fields and one - photon detuning to be @xmath73 , which makes @xmath89 .
while the coupling techniques and protocols proposed here have been presented for alkali atoms , they can be also implemented with rare earth elements . in particular , for ultracold fermionic dy @xcite , one can benefit from 10@xmath90-enhanced magnetic cooperativity in the rf regime , which , e.g. , reduces practical constraints on atom number , while allowing coherent state transfer to both the telecom regime ( 1322 nm ) and quantum dot transitions ( 953 nm , 1001 nm ) . in summary , we have illustrated that an atomic ensemble coupled to an optical and a microwave waveguide can serve as a long - lifetime memory as well as a photon converter between microwave and optical electromagnetic fields .
this research was supported by the u.s .
army research office muri award w911nf0910406 , aro atomtronics muri and by nsf through the physics frontier center at the joint quantum institute .
we thank a. gorshkov for fruitful discussions and e. tiesinga and s. polyakov for critical reading of the manuscript .
39 natexlab#1#1bibnamefont # 1#1bibfnamefont # 1#1citenamefont # 1#1url # 1`#1`urlprefix[2]#2 [ 2][]#2 , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , * * , ( ) . ,
* * , ( ) .
, , , , , , * * , ( ) .
_ et al .
_ , * * , ( ) .
_ et al . _ , * * , ( ) .
_ et al . _ , * * , ( ) . ,
* * , ( ) .
, , * * , ( ) . , _ et al . _ ,
arxiv:1108.2035 ( 2011 ) .
_ et .
al . _ ,
* * , ( ) , also at arxiv:1108.4153 .
, , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) .
_ et al . _ ,
* * , ( ) ; _ et al . _ , * * , ( ) _ et al .
_ , * * , ( ) . , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) .
_ et al . _ ,
* * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) .
_ et al .
_ , _ _ ( , ) . , , , , , , * * , ( ) .
_ et al . _ ,
* * , ( ) .
, , , * * , ( ) . , , , ,
* * , ( ) . , , , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , * * , ( ) .
, , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , * * , ( ) .
_ et al . _ ,
* * , ( ) .
_ et al . _ , * * , ( ) .
supplementary material |
wave propagation through a multiply scattering medium is an important problem for different disciplines , from optics to acoustics and microwaves @xcite , since it finds important applications from fundamental physics to biomedical imaging @xcite . for a monochromatic coherent input beam ,
the medium typically generates a speckle pattern @xcite - the result of complex interference between the scattered waves - that is usually considered a major drawback for imaging and focusing . in optics ,
wavefront shaping by spatial light modulators ( slms ) has emerged as a powerful tool to control the speckle and thus light propagation through such complex media @xcite .
different approaches have been proposed , in particular via optimization methods @xcite , to focus light through @xcite or into @xcite a complex medium . however
, a more general way to understand light propagation is to describe it via its transmission matrix ( tm ) @xcite , which in essence describes the fact that propagation through a disordered medium , however complex , remains a linear process , and therefore can be described by a linear operator @xmath0 linking input to output modes , i.e. it can be described as @xmath1 .
recently , we introduced a method to measure the monochromatic transmission matrix of a complex medium and to subsequently demonstrate focusing and imaging through it @xcite .
matricial methods are now widely used to characterize disordered media @xcite or multimode fibers @xcite , and even focusing inside complex media @xcite . generally speaking
, the medium has a spectrally dependent response , with a spectral correlation bandwidth , @xmath2 , that is inversely related to the confinement time of light in the medium @xmath3 ( @xmath4 ) @xcite.the monochromatic treatment is , therefore , only valid as long as the bandwidth of the source is contained within this spectral correlation bandwidth .
consequently , when light from a broadband source passes through a multiply - scattering medium , its different spectral components generates different speckle patterns .
this is the case where a short pulse - shorter than the average confinement time through the medium - is scattered in space and spread in time .
thanks to the inherent coupling between spatial and spectral degrees of freedom in a scattering medium @xcite , it is still possible to achieve spatiotemporal focusing through it by optimising the spatial input wavefront @xcite . in this work ,
we show that we are able to measure the multispectral transmission matrix ( mstm ) of a complex medium - i.e. the tridimensional matrix that is essentially a set of monochromatic tms - for several chosen wavelengths .
first , we show that we are able to retrieve the spectral correlation bandwidth of the medium from the spectral correlations in the mstm .
then , exploiting the mstm , we can achieve efficient and deterministic spatiospectral control of a broadband and spatially coherent light source , here a femtosecond pulse , by spatial - only wavefront shaping .
the mstm gives mores flexibility than both the optimization @xcite and the pulse shaping approach @xcite to control separately and individually spatial and spectral components of the output fields .
we demonstrate selective spatial focusing of a given wavelength as well as multispectral focusing .
finally , we show that the medium can be turned into a controllable dispersive optical element to focus different spectral components of the pulse at different spatial positions , similarly to a grating @xcite
. system ( @xmath5 mm ) conjugates the slm with the back focal plane of a low numerical aperture objective ( o@xmath6 , na = 0.3 ) that focuses the laser beam on a strongly scattering medium ( m ) . the transmitted light is then imaged on a ccd camera after polarization selection by a linear polariser ( p ) .
a spectrometer ( s ) is used to monitor the output wavelength of the laser .
( b - d ) examples of the speckle patterns at the output of a zno sample with spectral correlation bandwidth @xmath7 nm for three totally uncorrelated wavelengths : ( b ) @xmath8 nm , ( c ) @xmath9 nm , and ( d ) @xmath10 nm .
the white circles highlight the decorrelation of one bright speckle grain at the central wavelength @xmath9 nm .
( e ) normalised spectral correlation functions @xmath11 of different strongly scattering media obtained by correlating different speckle images acquired while scanning the laser wavelength from @xmath12 nm to @xmath13 nm with a step of @xmath14 nm .
the full width half maximum ( fwhm ) of these curves gives the spectral correlation bandwidth @xmath2 of the different samples : tio@xmath15 with @xmath16 nm ( circles ) , zno with @xmath17 nm ( squares ) , zno with @xmath18 nm ( diamonds ) , and zno @xmath19 nm ( triangles ) .
for the zno samples the correlation bandwidth was lowered by increasing the thickness of the scattering layer .
the shaded areas represent one standard deviation around the average values.,width=306 ]
in essence , in the monochromatic tm measurement approach , a set of input wavefronts , that describes a complete basis of the input modes , is sent through the medium .
part of the beam remains unmodulated and generates a stationary speckle that serves as a reference @xcite .
using phase - shifting interferometry , the amplitude and phase of the output signal can then be retrieved from a set of speckle images . in order to measure the full mstm ,
the laser is operated in cw mode at a given wavelength followed by the procedure for measuring the monochromatic tm of the medium @xcite ; this step is then reiterated at every desired wavelength by changing the laser wavelength . in this 3d matrix , the output field at the @xmath20-th pixel on the ccd camera is connected to the input field by @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the element of the mstm linking the @xmath20-th output ccd pixel to the @xmath23-th input slm pixel at frequency @xmath24 . just as in @xcite ,
the reference is an unknown speckle whose amplitude and phase information is encoded in the @xmath25 coefficients .
since this reference is frequency dependent , the information on the relative local phase between monochromatic tms can not be accessed in this type of measurement .
this measurement , therefore , precludes exact temporal control but still allows spatiospectral control of a broadband light source .
[ fig:1](a ) shows a simplified scheme of the experimental setup used to measure the mstm . a titanium - sapphire laser ( ti : sa , spectra - physics mai - tai ) illuminates a two - dimensional phase - only spatial light modulator ( slm , hamamatsu x10468 - 04 ) .
the laser is meant to work in mode - locked pulsed regime ( central wavelength tunable between @xmath26 nm and @xmath27 nm , pulse duration @xmath28 fs and corresponding bandwidth @xmath29 nm ) but it can also be unlocked and operated as a continuous wave ( cw ) , tunable laser between @xmath26 nm and @xmath27 nm with a coherence length of @xmath30 cm .
with such a coherence length , the laser in cw can be considered monochromatic for the scattering media studied in this work .
a spectrometer ( hr400 ocean optics ) is used to monitor the spectrum and the mode of operation of the laser , with a spectral resolution of 0.2 nm .
the illuminated slm pixels are grouped into macro - pixels , each of which induces a controllable phase shift @xmath31 between @xmath32 and @xmath33 .
the light is reflected by the slm and passes through a strongly scattering layer of zno or tio@xmath15 powder of different thicknesses @xcite . figs .
[ fig:1](b - d ) show examples of measured speckle patterns transmitted through the same zone of one sample at different wavelengths but for a same input wavefront : these speckles are strongly wavelength - dependent . by correlating speckle images taken while tuning the wavelength of the laser in cw mode by steps of 0.2 nm , the spectral correlation bandwidth of the medium
can be quantified @xcite .
[ fig:1](e ) shows these correlation curves for samples of different thicknesses and materials .
their full - width - half - maximum defines the spectral correlation bandwidth @xmath2 of the corresponding medium .
[ fig:2](a ) shows that the correlation between different spectral components of the mstm is consistent with the spectral correlation bandwidth of the medium as measured in fig .
[ fig:1](e ) . in order to maximise the information and minimise the amount of measurements required to control a polychromatic pulse of bandwidth @xmath34
, the spectral sampling of the mstm can be chosen to match the spectral correlation bandwidth @xmath2 of the medium .
the elements of the mstm are sufficiently uncorrelated and yet contain enough information to describe accurately the scattering process . here , therefore , the medium response is sampled by a mstm composed of @xmath35 monochromatic tms with @xmath36 ( fig .
[ fig:2](b ) ) . in the following ,
all measurements are performed on a sample with spectral correlation bandwidth of 1.6 nm , corresponding to an average confinement time of 625 fs .
the input light is a broadband pulse with a bandwidth of @xmath37 nm , corresponding to a fourier - limited duration of @xmath28 fs .
therefore , an experimental @xmath38 is chosen .
the number of input macro - pixels is set to 256 , corresponding to @xmath39 macro - pixels , and , on the ccd camera , an observation region , approximately corresponding to @xmath40 speckle grains , is selected . among different monochromatic transmission matrices ( tms ) for a zno medium ( @xmath7 nm ) measured in the wavelength range between @xmath12 nm and @xmath13 nm with a step of @xmath14 nm .
this correlation curve is consistent with the spectral correlation curve @xmath11 calculated by directly correlating speckle intensity images ( fig.[fig:1](e ) ) and here represented by the red dashed line .
the shaded areas represent one standard deviation around the average values .
( b ) in order to maximise the information about the scattering process and minimise the measurement time , the mstm is a 3d matrix composed of @xmath41 monochromatic matrices recorded at regular intervals within the bandwidth @xmath42 of the polychromatic pulse propagating though the scattering medium.,width=306 ]
the first most straightforward use of the mstm is as a set of monochromatic tms to focus light at a specific wavelength through a strongly scattering medium by phase conjugation , as shown in fig .
[ fig:3 ] .
this corresponds to selecting a vertical section of the mstm ( in the ccd - slm pixels plane ) in fig .
[ fig:2](b ) . in this case , only the fraction of the input beam at the chosen wavelength ( within the spectral correlation bandwidth ) will be effectively controlled @xcite .
[ fig:3](a - i ) show focusing images of monochromatic waves at various wavelengths ( columns ) using the phase mask given by a vertical section of the mstm recorded at a different wavelength ( rows ) . as expected , a focus appears only when the incident wavelength matches the wavelength at which the monochromatic tm was recorded .
nm , ( b , e , h ) @xmath9 nm , and ( c , f , i ) @xmath10 nm , using the phase mask given by a vertical section of the mstm , in the ccd - slm pixels plane , ( fig.[fig:2](b ) ) recorded at ( a - c ) @xmath8 nm , ( d - f ) @xmath9 nm , and ( g - i ) @xmath10 nm .
a focus appears only when the tm recorded at the corresponding wavelength of the beam is selected in ( a ) for @xmath8 nm , in ( e ) for @xmath9 nm , and in ( i ) for @xmath10 nm , respectively.,width=306 ] just like it is possible to focus in the monochromatic case in several points simultaneously by adding coherently the corresponding phase masks on the slm @xcite , it is also possible to focus several wavelengths at the same position by displaying a coherent sum of different phase - conjugate wavefronts for different wavelengths extracted from the mstm .
when one considers a single output position , an elegant way to formalize the above solution is to take a horizontal section of the mstm as shown in fig .
[ fig:4](a ) .
this section is a two - dimensional matrix @xmath43 that links the spectral components of the input slm pixels to the spectral components at a given output spatial position @xmath44 . in a quasi - monochromatic case ,
when the bandwidth of the polychromatic source is much smaller than the central wavelength , the dependency in @xmath24 at the input can be neglected . in this configuration , eq .
[ mstm ] reduces to @xmath45 this problem is equivalent to the one treated in @xcite but now the output dimension is spectral rather than spatial . for a given desired output spectrum vector @xmath46 , the input vector can be obtained by phase conjugation as @xmath47 . in this case , with homogeneous illumination and phase - only control , the phase of the calculated @xmath48 needs to be displayed on the slm . in order to focus spatially one spectral component @xmath24 , @xmath49 is set to 1 while all the other components are set to zero : the resulting wavefront is identical to what is obtained by phase conjugation of the monochromatic tm at @xmath24 . in order to focus all spectral components with the same weight , the imposed condition is @xmath50 . using a phase masks that focuses several wavelengths simultaneously , and scanning the wavelength in cw mode , figs .
[ fig:4](b - d ) show that all wavelengths are indeed focused at the same spatial position . .
( b - d ) focusing images for a monochromatic beam at various frequency for this optimal phase mask : ( b ) @xmath8 nm , ( c ) for @xmath9 nm , and ( d ) @xmath10 nm .
the focusing efficiency is reduced by a factor roughly @xmath51 compared to fig [ fig:3](a)(e ) and ( i ) since the phase mask tries to focus many wavelengths simultaneously.,width=306 ] , number of controlled wavelength : ( a ) sbr= 7.2 for @xmath52 , ( b ) sbr = 26.1 for @xmath53 , and ( c ) sbr = 30.7 for @xmath54 .
, width=306 ] this approach becomes even more relevant for broadband illumination .
[ fig:5 ] shows , for an ultrashort pulse , how the intensity at the focal point increases over the background when the number @xmath35 of different spectral components set to one in @xmath55 , all other components being set to zero . in fig .
[ fig:5](c ) , all 6 independent spectral components of the broadband pulse measured with the mstm are controlled , showing clear spatial focusing .
the signal to backroung ratio ( sbr ) , defined as the ratio between the average value of all the pixels inside the fwhm and the average value of the speckle image before focusing , is 30.7 . since these are linear images , they are not sensitive to possible fluctuations of the temporal duration of the pulse at this position .
when we use the speckle as reference , the relative phase between the different spectral components is unknown , and no temporal compression of the pulse occurs . as a last example , fig .
[ fig:6 ] demonstrates another possible use of the mstm by focusing different wavelengths to different positions . in this way
the scattering medium is used as a deterministic dispersive optical element @xcite . in fig .
[ fig:6](a ) , three different wavelengths of a broadband pulse are focused at three arbitrary positions along a line .
scanning the wavelength of a monochromatic laser reveals that each focus corresponds indeed to a different wavelength within the pulse ( 797 nm in fig .
[ fig:6](b ) , 800 nm in fig .
[ fig:6](c ) and 803 nm in fig .
[ fig:6](d ) ) .
these results can be interpreted as a generalized grating . in terms of resolution and efficiency
, the main difference between our approach and a conventional dispersive element is that , in our case , scattering by the medium itself determines both spectral resolution and spatial localization .
spectral resolution is given by the spectral correlation bandwidth of the medium , linked to the confinement time of the light in the medium , whereas the latter is diffraction - limited , i.e. limited by the effective numerical aperture of the medium .
on the other hand , the efficiency of the spatio - spectral focusing , given by the sbr , is ultimately limited by how many degrees of freedom are controlled , i.e. how many slm pixels and how many speckle grains are controlled simultaneously . in practice , the limitation in number of degrees of control is due to the measurement time , which is limited by the stability of the experimental setup and the medium . here
the measurement time is of the order of 15 minutes for 256 input modes and 6 wavelengths .
this can easily be scaled up by increasing the stability and the modulation speed .
the spectral control is , in this case , deterministic @xcite . interestingly , unlike a grating , the spatial dispersion of the different spectral foci can be arbitrary as demonstrated in fig .
[ fig:6 ] , since each independent wavelength can be focused at any spatial position .
in conclusion , we introduced a method to measure the spatially and spectrally resolved transmission matrix , or mstm , of a multiply scattering medium . compared to other approaches based on optimization
, the main advantage of our technique is that it is deterministic . exploiting the information contained in the mstm , we are able to selectively focus one or many spectral components of a broadband light source to one or many arbitrary spatial positions . as a proof of principle
, we demonstrate multispectral focusing of a short pulse , and show the medium can be turned into a deterministic dispersive optical element , thus generalizing the concept of grating . here
we demonstrate spatiospectral control , and our results are valid not only for short laser pulse , but also for temporally incoherent sources such as sleds or supercontinuum sources .
further control of the spectral phase with a plane wave as reference should enable deterministic spatiotemporal control of an ultrashort pulse .
99 p. sebbah , _ waves and imaging through complex media _ ( springer , 2001 ) a. ishimaru , _ wave propagation and scattering in random media _ ( wiley - ieee press , 1999 ) m. stoytchev and a. z. genack , phys .
b , * 55 * , 14 , ( 1997 ) .
p. sheng , _ introduction to wave scattering , localization , and mesoscopic phenoma _ ( academic press , new york , 1995 ) . lihong v. wang and hsin - i wu , _ biomedical optics : principles and imaging _ ( wiley , 2007 ) .
j. goodman , _ speckle phenomena in optics _ ( roberts and company publishers , 2010 ) .
a. p. mosk , a. lagendijk , g. lerosey and mathias fink , nat .
phot . * 6 * , 283292 ( 2012 ) .
i. vellekoop and a. mosk , optics letters , * 32 * , 12 ( 2007 ) .
i. vellekoop , a. lagendijk and a. mosk , nature photonics , * 4 * , 320 - 322 ( 2010 ) .
i. vellekoop , e. van putten , a. lagendijk and a. mosk , optics express , * 16 * , 67 - 80 ( 2008 ) . c. w. j. beenakker , rev .
phys . * 69 * , 731 ( 1997 ) .
s. m. popoff , g. lerosey , r. carminati , m. fink , a. c. boccara , and s. gigan , phys .
lett . * 104 * , 100601 ( 2010 ) .
s. m. popoff , g. lerosey , m. fink , a. c. boccara , and s. gigan , nat .
* 1 * , 81 ( 2010 ) .
y choi , td yang , c fang - yen , p kang , kj lee , rr dasari , m. s. feld and w. choi , phys .
. lett . * 107 * , 2 , 023902 ( 2011 ) .
m kim , y choi , c yoon , w choi , j kim , qh park and w choi , nature photonics * 6 * , 581 - 585 ( 2011 ) .
t. izmr and k. dholakia , optics express , * 19 * , 18871 - 18884 ( 2011 ) . c yoon , y choi , m kim , j moon , d kim and w choi , opt . lett . * 37 * , 21 ( 2012 ) . i. n. papadopoulos , s. farahi , c. moser and d. psaltis , biomed opt express . * 4 * , 260270 ( 2013 )
. s. bianchi , v. p. rajamanickam , l. ferrara , e. di fabrizio , c. liberale , and r. di leonardo , optics letters , * 38 * , 4935 - 4938 ( 2013 ) .
t. chaigne , o. katz , a. c. boccara , m. fink , e. bossy and s. gigan , nature photonics * 8 * , 5864 ( 2014 ) .
y. choi , t. r. hillman , w. choi , n. lue , r. r. dasari , p. t. c.
so , w. choi and z. yaqoob , physical chemistry chemical physics * 16 * , 27074 - 27077 ( 2014 ) e. small , o. katz , y. guan , and y. silberberg , opt .
* 37 * , 16 ( 2012 ) f. van beijnum , e. g. van putten , a. lagendijk , and a. p. mosk , opt .
* 36 * , 3 ( 2011 ) s. faez , p. m. johnson , and ad lagendijk , phys .
lett . , * 103 * , 053903 ( 2009 ) n. curry , p bondareff , m. leclercq , n. f. van hulst , r. sapienza , s. gigan , and s. grsillon , opt . lett . * 36 * , 17 ( 2011 )
. f. lemoult , g. lerosey , j. de rosny , and m. fink , phys .
, * 103 * , 173902 ( 2009 ) .
j. aulbach , b. gjonaj , p.johnson , a. mosk , and a. lagendijk , phys .
, * 106 * , 103901 ( 2011 ) .
o. katz , e. small , y. bromberg , and y. silberberg , nature photon .
, * 5 * , 372 ( 2011 ) .
h. p. paudel , c. stockbridge , j. mertz and t. bifano , optics express , * 21 * , 14 ( 2013 ) .
d. j. mccabe , a. tajalli , d. r. austin , p. bondareff , i. a. walmsley , s. gigan , and b. chatel , nat .
* 2 * , 447 ( 2011 ) .
i. freund , phys .
a , * 168 * , 4965 ( 1990 ) . j. h. park , c. park , h. yu , y. h. cho and y. k. park , opt .
lett . , * 37 * , 15 ( 2012 ) .
p. garca , r. sapienza , .
blanco , and c. lpez , adv .
* 19 * , 2597 ( 2007 ) .
b. redding , s. f. liew , r. sarma and h. cao , nature photon . ,
* 7 * , 746751 ( 2013 ) .
this work was funded by the european research council ( grant no .
278025 ) , anr rococo and programme emergence(s ) from the city of paris .
o.k . was supported by the marie curie intra - european fellowship for career development ( ief ) .
we thank david martina and mickael mounaix for helpful discussions .
s.g . ( gigan ) conceived the project . d.a .
, s.g . and s.g .
planned the experiment .
d.a . performed the experiment and analyzed the data .
s.p . proposed the analytic formalism for spatiospectral control .
, g.v . and s.g .
( gigan ) wrote the manuscript .
all authors discussed the results and revised the manuscript . | we present a method to measure the spectrally - resolved transmission matrix of a multiply scattering medium , thus allowing for the deterministic spatiospectral control of a broadband light source by means of wavefront shaping . as a demonstration
, we show how the medium can be used to selectively focus one or many spectral components of a femtosecond pulse , and how it can be turned into a controllable dispersive optical element to spatially separate different spectral components to arbitrary positions . |
[ cols="<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] [ tab : hlc2 ]
the hlc supplies a set of 229 derived quantities for each light - motion curve in the lmcc .
these quantities are aimed at describing the mean magnitudes , photometric variability and astrometric motion of the objects in the lmcc , and they are calculated using only light - motion curve entries that satisfy the quality constraints from section 2.3 . those quantities in the hlc related to photometry
are described in table [ tab : hlc1 ] , while those related to astrometry are described in table [ tab : hlc2 ] . in table
[ tab : hlc1 ] , if a tag name is associated with a 5-element array , then the 5 values represent the described quantity for each of the five sdss wave bands in the order @xmath6 , @xmath7 , @xmath8 , @xmath9 and @xmath10 . when a certain wave band has insufficent `` good '' light - motion curve entries to calculate a particular quantity , a value of zero is stored ( this also applies to table [ tab : hlc2 ] ) . for instance , the first value in the array mean_psfmag is set to zero for any light - motion curves with no `` good '' entries for the @xmath6 band . all quantities in table [ tab : hlc1 ] with clip at the end of the tag name
are calculated using a 4@xmath13-clip algorithm that rejects only the worst outlier at any one iteration , and terminates when no more outliers are identified .
similarly , all quantities in table [ tab : hlc1 ] with iter at the end of the tag name are calculated using the iterative procedure described in @xcite to dynamically reweight data points based on the size of the residuals from the mean .
both these sets of quantities have been designed to be more robust against outliers than a simple inverse variance weighted mean .
the sdss photometric pipeline performs a morphological star / galaxy separation , the quality of which is intimately related to seeing and sky brightness . while the accuracy is very good for bright objects , there can be confusion for faint objects .
the quantity mean_object_type in table [ tab : hlc1 ] is an unweighted mean of the sdss object type classification .
hence it has a value of 3 if the object is classified as a galaxy at all epochs , a value of 6 if the object is classified as a star at all epochs , and a value between 3 and 6 otherwise .
the reliability of mean_object_type for object type classification depends on the reliability of the sdss object type classifier and the number of epochs at which the object was observed .
the quantity mean_child in table [ tab : hlc1 ] is an unweighted mean of whether the child object bit is set or not . in other words ,
this quantity has a value of 1 if , at all epochs , the object results from the deblending of a parent object , a value of 0 if the object was never the result of the deblending of a parent object , and a value between 0 and 1 otherwise .
the galactic extinctions described by extinction in table [ tab : hlc1 ] are derived using the maps of dust column density from @xcite . for eclipse and flare detection in light curves
we include the statistics ecl_stat and flare_stat ( table [ tab : hlc1 ] ) in the hlc . in calculating these values ,
we assume that any eclipse / flare event in a light curve will include only one photometric data point since the time elapsed between consecutive scans is at least one day . hence , for each photometric data point ( using psf magnitudes only ) , we calculate the statistic @xmath14 , based on a matched filter from @xcite , and defined by : @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the chi - squared value of a constant fit for each wave band to the whole light curve , and @xmath17 and @xmath18 are the chi - squared and number of degrees freedom , respectively , of a constant fit for each wave band to the out - of - eclipse / flare light curve . in order to avoid false positives
, we only calculate @xmath14 for epochs with photometric data points that are `` good '' in at least two wave bands .
the adopted values of ecl_stat and flare_stat are then taken to be the largest values of @xmath14 for photometric data points fainter and brighter , respectively , than the mean .
we also record the corresponding values of @xmath19 for ecl_stat and flare_stat in the quantities ecl_redchisq_out and flare_redchisq_out respectively , along with the epoch of the putative eclipse / flare event in ecl_epoch and flare_epoch respectively . in table
[ tab : hlc1 ] , the stetson variability indices j , k and l ( @xcite ) for both the psf and exponential magnitudes are stored in the quantities with tag names starting stetson_index .
we chose the @xmath8 band as the comparison wave band and consequently the third element in each of these six quantity arrays is set to zero .
our final measure of light curve variability is via a quantity called the vidrih variability index .
rms magnitude deviations for non - variable lightcurves plotted versus mean magnitude @xmath20 in a given wave band ( referred to as an rms diagram ) are scattered around a three parameter empirical exponential function @xmath21 , while the rms magnitude deviation of variable sources is expected to be noticeably larger .
we consider two lightcurve samples , that of psf - like objects ( @xmath22 ) and non - psf - like objects ( @xmath23 ) .
for each lightcurve sample and wave band , we iteratively fitted @xmath24 to the corresponding rms diagrams using a 3@xmath13-clip algorithm , employing psf magnitudes for the star lightcurve sample and exponential magnitudes for the galaxy lightcurve sample . in each case
we also constructed a function @xmath25 describing the standard deviation of the scatter around @xmath24 via a four - degree polynomial fit to the standard deviation of the rms magnitude deviations measured in 0.25 magnitude bins .
then , for any light curve , the vidrih index @xmath26 was calculated as its rms magnitude deviation minus @xmath24 , normalized by @xmath25 , with negative values set to zero , and it is stored in the quantities with tag names starting vidrih_index ( table [ tab : hlc1 ] ) . note that due to the way the vidrih indices are constructed , vidrih_index_psf is only relevant to stars and vidrih_index_exp is only relevant to galaxies . in table
[ tab : hlc2 ] , we describe the quantities associated with the object astrometry . specifically we fit a proper motion model for celestial coordinates @xmath27 , in degrees , at heliocentric julian date @xmath28 , in days , for each light - motion curve : @xmath29 @xmath30 we set t0 as the weighted mean of the epochs of observation : @xmath31 where @xmath32 represents the set of heliocentric julian dates for the positional measurements , and @xmath33 represents the set of uncertainties on the measured celestial coordinates @xmath34 and @xmath35 .
the uncertainties @xmath33 are calculated via equation [ eqn : sig_coord ] .
we solve for the quantities ra_mean , ra_pm , dec_mean and dec_pm by minimising the appropriate chi - squared using a downhill simplex algorithm .
we calculate the uncertainties on these quantities , namely ra_mean_err , ra_pm_err , dec_mean_err and dec_pm_err , by assuming that @xmath36 ( a valid assumption for @xmath37 ) and noting that minimising the chi - squared for each of the resulting equations is a linear least - squares problem with an analytic solution .
we supply the best - fit chi - squareds via the quantities ra_chisq_lin and dec_chisq_lin , and we record the number of positional measurements used in the fit in the quantity n_pos_epochs .
we also supply the chi - squareds ra_chisq_con and dec_chisq_con for a model including only a mean position , which facilitates the calculation of the following delta chi - squared : @xmath38 the statistic @xmath39 may be used to calculate the significance of a proper motion measurement by noting that it follows a chi - square distribution with two degrees of freedom .
the whole fitting process is also iterated using a clipping algorithm that rejects the worst outlier at any one iteration , and terminates when the change in the fitted proper motion is smaller than 3 mas yr@xmath40 . consequently
, all the derived astrometric quantities described so far have a corresponding quantity calculated for the clipped positional measurements and stored in the hlc ( all quantities listed in table [ tab : hlc2 ] with a tag name ending clip ) .
the astrometric quantities derived from the clipped astrometric data are more robust than those derived from the unclipped astrometric data .
we strongly advise that any statistical studies undertaken with the astrometry in the hlc should only use the clipped quantities .
finally , we have attempted to detect the parallax signal for nearby stars by fitting a parallax model to each light - motion curve .
however , our investigation has made it clear that the distribution of observations during the same few months each year along with the positional accuracy of the astrometric measurements are not enough to enable the detection of a clean parallax signal .
the hlc is stored in eight fits binary tables , one for each hour in ra from 20@xmath2 to 4@xmath2 .
each record in the hlc corresponds to a single light - motion curve and stores 229 derived quantities with tag names listed and described in tables [ tab : hlc1 ] and [ tab : hlc2 ] .
the fits files ( @xmath41.9 gb compressed ) may be obtained by web download from _
http://das.sdss.org / value_added / stripe_82_variability / sdss_82_public/_. the idl astronomy user s library function `` mrdfits '' is a convenient way to read - in the hlc , storing the fits binary table automatically in an idl structure .
`` where '' function then becomes a very powerful tool for accessing subsets of data with ease .
the most relevant comparison of our catalogue photometry can be made by comparing our results to those of @xcite ( from now on iv07 ) who use 58 pre-2005 sdss - i imaging runs of stripe 82 , observed under mostly photometric conditions , to construct a standard star catalogue .
iv07 match unsaturated point sources satisfying high signal - to - noise criteria ( photometric uncertainties below 0.05 mag ) between runs and choose sources with at least 4 epochs .
those objects that are identified as non - varying , by requiring a @xmath41 per degree of freedom for the mean magnitudes of less than 3 in the @xmath7 , @xmath8 and @xmath9 bands , are chosen as candidate standard stars .
the standard star catalogue is then internally recalibrated , correcting for flat - field errors and time - variable extinction ( for example , due to clouds ) .
the main differences between the lmcc and the iv07 catalogue are that we use a different photometric recalibration method , but based on the same idea of spatially dependent photometric zeropoints , and that we include the generally non - photometric observations from the sdss - ii supernova runs .
not surprisingly , for the 886396 objects from the iv07 catalogue in the overlap area with the lmcc , we find unambiguous matches in the lmcc for 886191 objects using a match radius of 0.7 , where the missing fraction of @xmath40.02% can be explained by the different criteria used to construct the two catalogues .
of the 886191 matching objects in the lmcc , 219627 , 606658 , 879766 , 886028 and 856456 objects have at least 3 good epochs in the @xmath6 , @xmath7 , @xmath8 , @xmath9 and @xmath10 bands , respectively , and mean psf magnitudes brighter than 21.5 , 21.5 , 21.5 , 21.5 and 20.5 mag , respectively .
it is these objects that we use when constructing the histograms in figure [ fig : comp_ive ] . in figure
[ fig : comp_ive ] , each row of panels corresponds to a different wave band and the order employed is @xmath6 , @xmath7 , @xmath8 , @xmath9 and @xmath10 from the top row to the bottom row .
the left hand column of plots are normalised histograms of @xmath41 per degree of freedom for the mean psf magnitudes in the hlc , and they serve to confirm that the photometric uncertainties in the lmcc ( inherited from the sdss pipelines , with some adjustment during photometric recalibration ) are correct , since the histograms peak at a value of @xmath42 1 .
the middle column of panels in figure [ fig : comp_ive ] are normalised histograms of the uncertainties on the mean psf magnitudes in the hlc ( solid lines ) and on the mean magnitudes from the iv07 catalogue ( dashed lines ) .
it is clear that the mean magnitudes quoted in the hlc are approximately twice as precise as those from iv07 , which is due to the greater number of epochs included in the lmcc .
however , systematic errors are still likely to dominate the mean magnitudes at the @xmath41% level , which corresponds to the level of the photometric recalibrations and to the systematic error introduced by the slightly different band passes of each column of detectors in the sdss camera .
we do not correct the lmcc magnitudes for the different bandpasses in contrast to iv07 .
the right hand column of panels in figure [ fig : comp_ive ] are normalised histograms of the difference between the hlc mean psf magnitudes and the iv07 catalogue mean magnitudes .
a gaussian has been fitted to each histogram ( dotted lines ) , and the fitted centre and sigma are quoted in each panel .
the histograms are centred around zero at the millimagnitude level , except for the @xmath6 band where the iv07 photometry is slightly offset from the hlc photometry by @xmath44 mmag .
the histograms have sigmas of 28 , 13 , 11 , 10 and 16 mmag in @xmath6 , @xmath7 , @xmath8 , @xmath9 and @xmath10 , respectively , which are consistent with the scatter in the photometric zeropoints of the standard sdss runs derived in section 2.2 , and with the scatter in the similar internal photometric recalibrations of iv07 .
the data set used to construct the iv07 standard star catalogue is a subset of the data used to construct the lmcc , and therefore we can use our superior temporal coverage to identify standard star candidates that are actually photometrically variable . @xcite
use the hlc to systematically identify variable stars in stripe 82 , and we choose to follow all but one of their cuts on the hlc quantities .
of the 886191 objects from the iv07 catalogue that have matching objects in the lmcc , 878172 have at least 11 good epochs in the @xmath7 band , allowing for the calculation of reliable variability and object type indicators .
the requirement from @xcite that an lmcc object has a mean object type greater than 5.5 ensures that chosen variables are psf - like ( stars ) .
however , this implies that 16529 objects are probably non - psf - like , corresponding to a fraction of @xmath41.9% .
hence , we do not apply this requirement , and instead we directly apply the remaining requirements that a variable object should have a @xmath41 per degree of freedom greater than 3 for both the @xmath7 and @xmath8 band mean psf magnitudes , and a stetson l index greater than 1 for the @xmath7 band .
we find that just 570 iv07 standard stars , from 878172 , are variable , corresponding to a fraction of @xmath40.065% .
this confirms that even with the addition of many more photometric data , the iv07 standard stars are in general still found to be constant at the @xmath40.01 mag level . in considering the full iv07 catalogue with 1006849 candidate standard stars , we suspect that @xmath4650 are actually variables .
@xcite ( from now on gk04 ) carefully combine sdss data release 1 ( sdss dr1 ) and usno - b proper motions to produce a catalogue of 390476 objects with proper motions @xmath43 mas yr@xmath40 and magnitudes @xmath44 mag .
sdss dr1 proper motions are based on matches of sdss to usno - a2.0 ( @xcite ) , which suffer from mismatches causing spurious high proper - motion objects , and systematic trends in proper motion .
however , by cross - correlating sdss dr1 and usno - b , gk04 successfully removed the vast majority of spurious proper - motion stars .
furthermore , by considering the set of spectroscopically confirmed quasars in sdss dr1 , gk04 calibrate out the position - dependent astrometric biases , using a very similar method to our recalibration of sdss astrometry presented in section 2.4 .
we compare our proper motions in the hlc to those derived by gk04 for the 30546 stars from their catalogue with an unambiguous positional match in the hlc using a match radius of 0.7 . in figure
[ fig : comp_usno ] , we plot the running 3@xmath13-clipped mean difference between our hlc proper motions and those of gk04 ( middle points ) as a function of ra using a 1@xmath0 window ( upper panels ) , as a function of dec using a 001 window ( middle panels ) , and as a function of mean @xmath8 psf magnitude using a 0.1 mag window ( lower panels ) .
the mean difference is only calculated if there are at least 100 stars in the sliding window .
the left hand panels correspond to proper motion in ra and the right hand panels correspond to proper motion in dec .
we also plot the mean difference plus or minus the running 3@xmath13-clipped standard deviation as the upper and lower sets of smaller points , respectively , in each panel .
figure [ fig : comp_usno ] illustrates that the systematic differences between the hlc proper motions and those of gk04 are at a very small level , generally @xmath452 mas yr@xmath40 . we note one clear systematic trend that the gk04 dec proper motions are offset from the hlc dec proper motions by @xmath452 mas yr@xmath40 , which is especially visible in the bottom right hand panel of figure [ fig : comp_usno ] .
we are currently unable to identify unambiguously the origin of the small systematic offset .
the scatter in the proper motion differences ( represented by the upper and lower sets of smaller points in each panel ) is consistent with the stated proper motion uncertainties of @xmath43.9 mas yr@xmath40 in gk04 , and @xmath455 mas yr@xmath40 for these particular stars in the hlc .
each light - motion curve in the lmcc has a different temporal coverage and number of epochs , a situation which is highlighted in figure [ fig : tcov ] . consequently the uncertainties on the hlc proper motions exhibit a very inhomogeneous spatial distribution , and selecting proper motion objects using cuts on proper motion uncertainty results in a very inhomogeneous sample of objects . in figure
[ fig : pmerr ] , we present the mean proper motion uncertainty in the hlc as a function of mean @xmath8 psf magnitude , number of epochs and time span of a light - motion curve for psf - like objects ( mean_object_type = 6 ) .
the three panels from left to right correspond to different light - motion curve time spans of 3 , 5 and 7 years , respectively , while in each panel three curves are plotted , dotted , dashed and continuous , corresponding to @xmath4610 , @xmath4720 and @xmath4830 epochs , respectively .
the curves in each panel show the mean proper motion uncertainty in the hlc as a function of mean @xmath8 psf magnitude .
it is worth noting that @xmath476% of objects in the lmcc have at least 20 epochs , and that @xmath437% have at least 20 epochs with a time span of greater than 4 years .
we find that 312819 objects in the lmcc ( or @xmath48% ) have proper motions @xmath49 with @xmath50 .
the light - motion curve catalogue ( lmcc ) contains almost 4 million light - motion curves for stars and galaxies covering @xmath4249 deg@xmath5 in the sdss stripe 82 .
a light - motion curve provides wave band and time dependent photometric and astrometric quantities , where @xmath476 per cent of light - motion curves in the lmcc have at least 20 epochs of measurements .
the lmcc is complete to magnitude 21.5 in @xmath6 , @xmath7 , @xmath8 and @xmath9 , and to magnitude 20.5 in @xmath10 , making it the deepest large - area catalogue of its kind .
the photometric rms accuracy for stars is @xmath420 mmag at @xmath5118 mag and for galaxies it is @xmath430 mmag at @xmath5118 mag . in both the ra and dec coordinates , an rms accuracy of @xmath432 mas and @xmath435 mas at @xmath5118 mag
is achieved for pre-2005 data for stars and galaxies , respectively , and an rms accuracy of @xmath435 mas and @xmath446 mas at @xmath5118 mag is achieved for 2005 data for stars and galaxies , respectively . the lmcc is thus an ideal tool for studying the variable sky , and in order to aid in its exploitation , we have created the higher - level catalogue ( hlc ) .
the hlc consists of 229 derived photometric and astrometric quantities for each light - motion curve , and it is stored in a set of fits binary tables , a format that is widely used by the astronomical community .
the photometry presented in the hlc is fully consistent with the iv07 standard star catalogue and , since it is based on many more epochs , the random uncertainties in the mean magnitudes are smaller . reassuringly , we show that only a very small percentage of standard stars ( @xmath40.065% or @xmath4650 objects ) from iv07 are actually photometrically variable .
the hlc proper motions of 30546 stars are consistent to within uncertainties with those derived by @xcite by combining sdss dr1 and usno - b proper motions .
the power in using the hlc is well illustrated by the work of @xcite who construct a reduced proper motion diagram for stripe 82 in order to find rare white dwarf populations , and consequently they identify 8 new candidate ultracool white dwarfs and 10 new candidate halo white dwarfs .
also , @xcite report the discovery of an eclipsing m - dwarf binary system 2mass j01542930 + 0053266 , having employed the corresponding light - motion curve along with radial velocity measurements to determine the masses and radii of the stellar components .
we therefore encourage the astronomical community to actively use and explore these catalogues that are so ample in their content .
the calculations presented in this work were done using idl programs and the sun grid engine distributed computing software .
idl is provided , under license , by research systems inc .
we thank robert lupton for his advice on the photometric quality flags .
we also appreciate the useful comments on astrometry given by siegfried rser .
bramich is grateful to the particle physics and astronomy research council ( pparc ) for financial support .
s. vidrih acknowledges the financial support of the european space agency .
l. wyrzykowski was supported by the european community s sixth framework marie curie research training network programme , contract no .
mrtn - ct-2004 - 505183 `` angles '' .
funding for the sdss and sdss - ii has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national science foundation , the u.s .
department of energy , the national aeronautics and space administration , the japanese monbukagakusho , the max planck society , and the higher education funding council for england .
the sdss web site is http://www.sdss.org/. the sdss is managed by the astrophysical research consortium for the participating institutions .
the participating institutions are the american museum of natural history , astrophysical institute potsdam , university of basel , university of cambridge , case western reserve university , university of chicago , drexel university , fermilab , the institute for advanced study , the japan participation group , johns hopkins university , the joint institute for nuclear astrophysics , the kavli institute for particle astrophysics and cosmology , the korean scientist group , the chinese academy of sciences ( lamost ) , los alamos national laboratory , the max - planck - institute for astronomy ( mpia ) , the max - planck - institute for astrophysics ( mpa ) , new mexico state university , ohio state university , university of pittsburgh , university of portsmouth , princeton university , the united states naval observatory , and the university of washington .
lupton r.h .
, gunn j.e . , ivezi . , knapp g.r . , kent s. , 2001 , in asp conf .
238 , astronomical data analysis software and systems x. , ed .
harnden jr . , f.a .
primini & h.e .
payne ( san francisco : asp ) , 269 | we present a new public archive of light - motion curves in sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) stripe 82 , covering 99@xmath0 in right ascension from @xmath1 to 3.3@xmath2 and spanning 252 in declination from @xmath3126 to 126 , for a total sky area of @xmath4249 deg@xmath5 .
stripe 82 has been repeatedly monitored in the @xmath6 , @xmath7 , @xmath8 , @xmath9 and @xmath10 bands over a seven - year baseline .
objects are cross - matched between runs , taking into account the effects of any proper motion .
the resulting catalogue contains almost 4 million light - motion curves of stellar objects and galaxies .
the photometry are recalibrated to correct for varying photometric zeropoints , achieving @xmath420 mmag and @xmath430 mmag root - mean - square ( rms ) accuracy down to 18 mag in the @xmath7 , @xmath8 , @xmath9 and @xmath10 bands for point sources and extended sources , respectively .
the astrometry are recalibrated to correct for inherent systematic errors in the sdss astrometric solutions , achieving @xmath432 mas and @xmath435 mas rms accuracy down to 18 mag for point sources and extended sources , respectively . for each light - motion curve ,
229 photometric and astrometric quantities are derived and stored in a higher - level catalogue . on the photometric side ,
these include mean exponential and psf magnitudes along with uncertainties , rms scatter , @xmath11 per degree of freedom , various magnitude distribution percentiles , object type ( stellar or galaxy ) , and eclipse , stetson and vidrih variability indices . on the astrometric side ,
these quantities include mean positions , proper motions as well as their uncertainties and @xmath11 per degree of freedom .
the here presented light - motion curve catalogue is complete down to @xmath12 and is at present the deepest large - area photometric and astrometric variability catalogue available .
[ firstpage ] catalogues - stars : photometry , astrometry , variables - galaxy : stellar content - galaxies : photometry |
Subsets and Splits