article
stringlengths 0
745k
| abstract
stringlengths 0
92.7k
|
|---|---|
traditional ground based radial velocity searches for extra - solar planetary systems have used medium- and large - size telescopes assigned to the program for particular nights of observing . while this type of approach has been extremely successful , resulting in about 120 detections of planetary - mass companions to solar - type stars ,
the vagaries of the telescope scheduling process introduces certain restrictions and constraints on the optimal acquisition of time - critical observations . in radial velocity surveys
, it is often the case that once a candidate planetary system has been identified and a preliminary orbit determined , additional observations must be obtained at particular orbital phases in order to place tighter constraints on particular orbital elements . obtaining the necessary data at the optimal orbital phase may be extremely difficult if observing runs are scheduled for a few nights once per month , or even less frequently . thus a telescope that is queue scheduled , such as the hobby - eberly telescope , ( het ) permits the observer to react quickly to the data and to obtain timely follow - up observations of critical targets at the orbital phases where they are needed .
we report use of the het to detect a planetary companion in a 54.23day period orbit to the star hd37605 .
the ability of the het observing queue to accommodate our observing needs enabled us to discover the planet with only a total of 100 days ( slightly less than two orbital periods ) elapsing between the first and final observations .
we discuss both the detection of the planetary companion itself and the special attributes of the het that enabled the final orbital confirmation to be obtained in a very timely and expeditious manner .
the hobby - eberly telescope consists of an array of 91 hexagonal shape , spherical figure mirrors , each of 1meter diameter , in a fixed truss tilted at @xmath1 zenith distance , resulting in a maximum effective aperture of 9.2 m diameter .
declination ranges in the sky between @xmath2 and @xmath3 may be selected by rotating the telescope truss in azimuth .
a star is observed by tracking an optical fiber bundle along the telescope focal plane while the telescope structure remains fixed , and feeding the light into the spectrograph .
the het design was optimized for large - scale , low sky - density spectroscopic surveys .
the telescope is _ not _ assigned to a given program for a given night , but rather is queue scheduled , thus interleaving observations from a large number of different programs employing different instrument configurations .
the het data distribution policy is to allow the pi to gain access to the pervious nights data every morning allowing rapid feed back to the het astronomers .
this is an ideal mode of operation for our high - precision radial velocity program .
the high resolution spectrograph ( hrs ) @xcite for the het was built by a team headed by robert tull and phillip macqueen .
this spectrograph was designed to be able to make stellar radial velocity variation measurements with a precision of 3ms@xmath0 or better on stars as faint as @xmath4 .
the instrument is housed in an insulated enclosure in the basement of the het building , and thus is not moving with the telescope . the image scrambling provided by the 34.3 m long optical fiber feed helps ensure that the pupil seen by the spectrograph is always illuminated in a consistent manner .
only a set number of instrument configurations are available , and these are all defined by kinematic mounts for the grating and cross - disperser positions .
the i@xmath5 gas cell is contained in a collimated section in front of the spectrograph slit , so refocusing of any optics is unnecessary for i@xmath5 cell use .
the detector is a mosaic of two @xmath6 pixel e2v ccds . for our high - precision radial velocity observations ,
we use the hrs in a mode giving resolving power of 60,000 .
the echelle grating was used on the center of the blaze , and the cross disperser was positioned so that the break between the `` red '' and the `` blue '' ccd chips was at around 5940 . for most seeing conditions ,
a 2arcsec diameter optical fiber was used .
so far , we have observed 173 f - m dwarfs four or more times .
the f through k stars are selected to be stars with low levels of stellar activity based on x - ray emission , photometric variability , and measured ca ii h&k emission .
we intentionally do not bias the selection on stellar metallicity , but we do attempt to exclude stars with @xmath7 greater than about 15kms@xmath0 and known short - period binary stars . the separate m - dwarf survey and its selection criteria
are discussed by @xcite . of all of these stars ,
20 show large - amplitude variations indicative of previously unknown binary star systems , and 11 additional stars show rms variations greater than 20ms@xmath0 , but probably not large enough to be due to binary stellar companions .
these stars represent good candidates for short - period planetary companions .
figure [ het_rms ] shows a histogram of the velocity rms about the mean of our time - series measurements for the remaining 142 stars having an rms of 20ms@xmath0 or less , after any statistically significant linear velocity trends have been removed .
the time span of the data for each star ranges from one week to greater than three years .
the median rms of the 123 stars in figure [ het_rms ] with rms of 13ms@xmath0 or less is 4.0ms@xmath0 .
if we examine just the 112 stars with rms of 8ms@xmath0 or less ( the bulk of the sample ) , then both the mean and the median rms of the remaining `` stable '' stars are just 3.6ms@xmath0 .
the peak of the histogram is centered in the 2 - 3ms@xmath0 bin .
we note that a significant contributing factor to the observed velocity rms is intrinsic to the stars themselves .
we have _ not _ attempted to correct these rms values in any way for velocity variations induced by stellar photospheric and chromospheric activity ( `` jitter '' ) . in general , the stars for which we have obtained the lowest rms are old , inactive stars with spectra of high signal - to - noise ratio .
thus , figure [ het_rms ] clearly demonstrates that we have achieved routine radial velocity precision of 3ms@xmath0 or better with the het - hrs in routine `` production mode '' on a large sample of a wide variety of stars over a substantial time period .
indeed , a significant fraction of our stars are showing radial velocity precision of 2ms@xmath0 or better , which is comparable to the precision achieved for high snr observations with the eso vlt / uves by @xcite .
our 2 - 3ms@xmath0 precision is significantly better than that obtained with coralie @xcite or elodie @xcite , and is directly competitive with the 3ms@xmath0 precision which is achieved on the keck hires @xcite , aat @xcite , or the 2ms@xmath0 demonstrated by harps @xcite .
hd37605 ( hip 26664 , bd+05 985 , sao 113015 , g 99 - 22 ) is a v=8.69 k0v star .
the hipparcos @xcite parallax of 23.32mas corresponds to a distance of 42.9parsec , and gives an absolute magnitude of @xmath8 .
the stellar parameters : effective temperature , t@xmath9 , surface gravity , log@xmath10 , and microturbulence , @xmath11 listed in table [ star ] were derived using moog @xcite with atmospheres based on the 1995 version of the atlas9 code @xcite following the procedure outlined in @xcite and briefly described below . within iraf , we fit the 20 fei and 12 feii lines listed in table 1 of @xcite with gaussian profiles to obtain equivalent widths . the t@xmath9 was derived by requiring that individual line abundances be independent of excitation potential .
likewise , @xmath11 was derived by requiring that individual line abundances be independent of line strength .
the log@xmath10 was determined by forcing ionization equilibrium between neutral and singly ionized fe .
we adopted solar log@xmath12(fe ) of 7.52 from @xcite , which yields an [ fe / h ] for hd37605 of [email protected] .
lr@@xmath13l t@xmath9 & 5475 & 50k + log@xmath10 & 4.55 & 0.1 + @xmath11 & 0.8 & 0.2 km s@xmath0
+ [ fe / h ] & 0.39 & 0.07 + our typical het observing technique is to obtain about 4 - 5 initial radial velocity measurements over the course of 1 - 2 weeks , in order to search for short - period `` hot - jupiter '' rv variability .
if a star appears stable on short timescales , it is then scheduled for less frequent observations in order to search for longer period orbits . for hd37605 ( @xmath14 ) , exposure times were 900 seconds , giving a typical signal - to - noise ratio of about 250 per resolution element .
the initial set of observations of hd37605 were constant to within the observational error , but the next observation taken about one month later showed a decrease of about 200ms@xmath0 .
we then took advantage of the queue scheduled operations of the het to put the star back into the queue at high priority for frequent observations .
following our request for frequent coverage , the het resident astronomers then obtained spectra every 3 - 4 days during the decrease in radial velocity .
data from each night s observations were reduced and velocities computed the following morning .
we were easily able to fit a new orbital solution as the data from each night became available .
it quickly became obvious that the radial velocity minimum and periastron passage would occur just as the star was being lost from the het observability window ; the last het data points would be obtained during evening twilight .
it was critical to attempt to obtain nightly het velocity measurements during this orbital phase , as the depth of the velocity minimum would constrain the orbital eccentricity and the k velocity ( and hence the companion minimum mass ) . since these were going to be difficult het observations , and it was quite possible that the het would no longer be able to observe the star before the periastron passage was complete , we arranged for the mcdonald observatory 2.1 m telescope observer to obtain radial velocity measurements with the sandiford cassegrain echelle spectrograph @xcite and its i@xmath5 cell during this interval .
this instrument records the 5000 to 6000 region at resolving power of 60,000 .
these 2.1 m data would be of significantly lower velocity precision due to the much lower signal - to - noise ratio and the inherent mechanical and thermal instability of a large heavy cassegrain spectrograph , but they would certainly be adequate to cover this crucial interval when the het might not be able to observe the star .
the het data for hd37605 are shown as filled dots in figure [ rvcurve ] , and the 2.1 m sandiford echelle data are shown as open triangles .
the observed velocities from both telescopes are given in table [ rvtable ] .
the velocities in this table have been corrected for the different ( and arbitrary ) velocity zero points of the two instruments used .
the simultaneous orbital solution to both data sets is also shown in figure [ rvcurve ] .
the rms residual of the het / hrs data from this orbital solution is 4.7ms@xmath0 .
the rms residual of the 2.1 m sandiford echelle data from the solution is 44.2ms@xmath0 .
rrrc 53002.6715 & 94.7 & 8.4 & het hrs + 53003.6853 & 97.1 & 7.8 & het hrs + 53006.6620 & 92.8 & 7.0 & het hrs + 53008.6641 & 98.6 & 6.2 & het hrs + 53010.8048 & 90.8 & 6.2 & het hrs + 53013.7940 & 79.3 & 6.6 & het hrs + 53042.7280 & -126.4 & 7.0 & het hrs + 53061.6676 & 101.7 & 4.2 & het hrs + 53065.6468 & 94.8 & 4.8 & het hrs + 53071.6438 & 67.5 & 4.6 & het hrs + 53073.6382 & 64.9 & 4.2 & het hrs + 53082.6237 & 24.6 & 4.1 & het hrs + 53083.5954 & 18.2 & 5.6 & het hrs + 53089.5958 & -19.0 & 4.0 & het hrs + 53092.5980 & -47.9 & 4.1 & het hrs + 53094.5866 & -71.2 & 3.3 & het hrs + 53095.5864 & -89.6 & 3.5 & het hrs + 53096.5874 & -107.7 & 6.7 & het hrs + 53098.5763 & -190.0 & 4.2 & het hrs + 53102.5727 & -409.9 & 5.5 & het hrs + 53072.1363 & 69.5 & 25.99 & 2.1 m + 53097.6345 & -177.0 & 30.24 & 2.1 m + 53098.6555 & -181.7 & 27.91 & 2.1 m + 53101.6647 & -412.1 & 78.12 & 2.1 m + 53102.6034 & -297.5 & 23.58 & 2.1 m + 53103.5928 & -203.0 & 20.37 & 2.1 m + 53104.5972 & -79.7 & 29.20 & 2.1 m + we performed a simultaneous fit of the het - hrs and 2.1 m sandiford echelle velocity data using the @xmath15 @xcite software , which uses a robust estimation method to find the combined orbital solution , where the arbitrary velocity zero points of both data sets are included as fit parameters .
the combined orbital solution is given in table [ orbit ] , and is shown as the solid line in figure [ rvcurve ] .
the planet is in a highly eccentric orbit .
its eccentricity of 0.737 is exceeded only by hd80606b ( e = 0.93 ) and hd222582b ( e=0.76 ) .
the periastron distance of 0.070 au is large enough for the planet easily to have avoided tidal circularization over the lifetime of the system .
llr@@xmath13l p & [ days ] &
54.23 & 0.23 + t & [ jd ] & 2452994.27 & 0.45 + k & [ @xmath16 & 262.9 & 5.5 + @xmath17 & & 0.737 & 0.010 + @xmath18 & [ degrees ] & 211.6 & 1.7 + @xmath19 & [ solar masses ] & @xmath20 & @xmath21 + @xmath22&@xmath23 $ ] & 2.84 & 0.26 + @xmath24 & [ au ] & 0.26 & 0.01 + the shape of the observed radial velocity curve is very difficult to explain by any mechanism other than orbital motion .
nevertheless , we have examined the available data to ensure that our interpretation of the observed velocity variations as resulting from orbital motion is indeed correct .
the hipparcos photometry of hd37605 shows an rms variation of only 0.0020 magnitudes , which is comparable to the hipparcos photometric precision .
thus , the observed rv variations can not be linked to any photometric variability of the primary star .
we have also searched for evidence of chromospheric variability of hd37605 .
normally , we would prefer to measure the ca ii s index from the ca ii h and k lines , but the het primary mirror coatings and the het optical fibers result in a short - wavelength cutoff of the het hrs at around 4200
. we do have one spectrum of hd37605 obtained with the mcdonald observatory 2.7 m telescope 2dcoud spectrometer , which includes the ca ii h&k lines . from this spectrum
we measure a mcdonald s index @xcite of @xmath25 .
this @xmath26 is comparable to the value found in the old , inactive star @xmath27 ceti ( @xmath28 ) , thus indicating a low level of chromospheric activity for hd37605 .
we have also examined the profiles of the h@xmath29 absorption line for any possible variability that might be related to stellar activity . a careful alignment and normalization of the h@xmath29 line profile from all of our regular program spectra of hd37605 shows no variations beyond what is expected from photon noise .
thus we conclude that the observed radial velocity variations are indeed due to a planetary - mass companion moving in a highly eccentric orbit .
we report the first discovery of an extra - solar planet using the hobby - eberly telescope and its high resolution spectrograph .
the planetary - mass companion to the metal - rich star hd37605 is in a highly eccentric orbit .
we have demonstrated that the het high resolution spectrograph can produce a long - term velocity precision of 3ms@xmath0 or better over a multi - year timespan .
the queue - scheduled operation of the hobby - eberly telescope made the detection and characterization of the orbit far simpler than it would have been with a conventionally scheduled telescope .
once the possible orbital motion was detected , we were able to obtain immediate follow - up observations at the particular orbital phases that were crucial for the orbit determination .
this highly flexible mode of telescope operation , coupled with the large telescope aperture and the extremely stable high resolution spectrograph , makes the het - hrs an ideal and extremely efficient and flexible facility for large surveys for extrasolar planetary systems .
the hobby - eberly telescope ( het ) is a joint project of the university of texas at austin , the pennsylvania state university , stanford university , ludwig maximillians universitt mnchen , and georg august universitt gttingen .
the het is named in honor of its principal benefactors , william p. hobby and robert e. eberly .
this material is based upon work supported by the national aeronautics and space administration under grant nag5 - 13206 .
the authors are grateful the the university of texas hobby - eberly telescope time allocation committee for their generous allotment of observing time for this program .
pepe , f. , mayor , m. , queloz , d. , benz , w. , bonfils , x. , bouchy , f. , curto , g. l. , lovis , c. , megevand , d. , moutou , c. , naef , d. , rupprecht , g. , santos , n. c. , sivan , j. p. , sosnowska , d. , & udry , s. 2004 , a&a in press ( astro - ph/0405252 ) | we report the first detection of a planetary - mass companion to a star using the high resolution spectrograph ( hrs ) of the hobby - eberly telescope ( het ) .
the het - hrs now gives routine radial velocity precision of 2 - 3ms@xmath0 for high snr observations of quiescent stars .
the planetary - mass companion to the metal - rich k0v star hd37605 has an orbital period of 54.23 days , an orbital eccentricity of 0.737 , and a minimum mass of 2.84 jupiter masses .
the queue - scheduled operation of the hobby - eberly telescope enabled us to discovery of this relatively short - period planet with a total observation time span of just two orbital periods .
the ability of queue - scheduled large - aperture telescopes to respond quickly to interesting and important results demonstrates the power of this new approach in searching for extra - solar planets as well as in other ares of research requiring rapid response time critical observations . |
the capability of a high resolution and high signal - to - noise detector used to study properties of low energy recoils is demonstrated .
motivated by directional searches for dark matter , all measurements were taken at low pressures in the 25 - 100 torr range , where low energy tracks are long enough to be resolved .
we show that at these low pressures , with sufficient gas gain and light collection efficiency , the electron tracks produced from interactions of 5.9 kev @xmath0fe x - rays can be _ optically _ imaged and resolved using a low - noise , high quantum efficiency ccd ( charge - coupled device ) camera .
optical @xmath0fe spectra have been obtained with a pmt readout for a gem - based detector in 750 torr he / cf@xmath4@xcite and a capillary plate detector in 760 torr ar / cf@xmath1 @xcite but , to our knowledge , this is the first time it has been done using a ccd imaging system at such low pressures . in addition , the ability to operate at low pressures has allowed the low energy electrons tracks to be clearly resolved .
although this has been demonstrated using charge readouts ( e.g. , a pixellated readout ) for 5.9 kev recoils @xcite and optically for 15 - 22 kev recoils @xcite , to our knowledge this is the first time it has been done using optical imaging for @xmath0fe energies .
the detector used for the measurements was a low pressure tpc ( time projection chamber ) operating in 99.999% cf@xmath1 with gem ( gas electron multiplier ) and thick gem ( thgem ) amplification , and a ccd - based optical readout .
gems are a micro - pattern amplification device invented by sauli at the european organization for nuclear research ( cern ) @xcite ; further information on the operation of gems with ccd readout can be found in refs .
thgems are very similar to gems but with dimensions ( thickness , hole size , and pitch ) that are typically about one order of magnitude larger .
exceptionally high gas gains have been achieved in both types of amplification devices , but the thgems have been shown to excel at the very low pressures of interest here @xcite .
a schematic of the detector setup is shown in figure [ fig : detector ] . at each pressure
, the choice of amplification device between single gem / thgem or multiple gems / thgems was made to maximize stability , gas gain , and spatial resolution .
for the 100 torr measurements , the detector used a cascade of three standard copper gems separated by 2 mm ( figure [ fig : detector ] ) .
the gems were manufactured at cern using a 50 thick , @xmath5 @xmath6 7 @xmath7 sheet of kapton .
the sheet was copper - clad on both surfaces ( @xmath85 thick ) and chemically etched with a hexagonal array of bi - conical holes of diameter of 50/70 ( inner / outer ) , at a pitch of 140 . for a thorough review of gems ,
see ref .
a @xmath5 @xmath6 7 @xmath7 cathode was located 1 cm below the gem stack , defining the detection / drift volume .
the cathode was constructed from a @xmath8 360 @xmath9 m thick copper mesh with @xmath8500 pitch .
finally , a 1 mm pitch anode wire grid plane made from 20 thick gold plated tungsten wires was situated 3 mm above the top - most gem ( gem 3 ) , forming the induction gap ( further details of this detector can be found in ref .
@xcite ) . at pressures below 100 torr we replaced the triple - gem cascade with thgems , which are better suited for high gain operation at low pressures @xcite . even going from 100 torr to 75 torr , for example , the maximum stable gas gain in the triple - gem detector was no longer sufficient to image @xmath0fe tracks .
all thgems used in our studies were fabricated at cern using a 0.4 mm thick pcb with @xmath80.3 mm holes mechanically drilled in a hexagonal pattern with a pitch of @xmath80.5 mm . to eliminate burring from the drilling process , an annular region of thickness 0.05 mm
was chemically etched around each hole . in our 50 torr measurements a single thgem with an active region of @xmath10 @xmath7 was used . to better accommodate the longer tracks at these low pressures ,
the drift gap was increased from 1 cm to 2 cm .
in addition , the separation from the amplification device and the wire grid was increased from 3 mm to @xmath87 mm , which provided better stability at the lower pressures .
for the 35 torr measurements a double - thgem , with a @xmath11 @xmath7 active area @xmath7 thgems were not available .
] , was required to achieve the necessary gas gain . the drift gap , transfer gap between the thgems , and induction gap between the thgem and wire grid were 2 cm , 4 mm , and 9.5 mm , respectively .
in addition , the wire grid size was increased to match the thgem area by laying copper tape around the perimeter of the wire frame .
for all measurements , the detector was housed inside a @xmath810 liter cylindrical aluminum vacuum vessel .
calibration was done using internally mounted @xmath0fe ( 5.9 kev x - rays ) and @xmath12po ( 5.3 mev alphas ) sources , which could be individually turned on or off using a rotary feed - through ( figure [ fig : detectionvolume ] ) .
prior to powering up the gems / thgems , the vacuum vessel was pumped out to @xmath13 0.1 torr for at least one day before back - filling with pure ( 99.999% ) carbon tetrafluoride ( @xmath3 ) gas . a 4-inch diameter bk-7 glass window was positioned above the wire grid to allow scintillation light from the final amplification stage to be captured and imaged by the lens and ccd camera .
bk-7 is a material with a relatively high transmittance for the optical component of the @xmath3 scintillation , which peaks around 620 nm @xcite , and is lower cost compared to quartz .
the optical system consisted of a fast 58 mm f/1.2 nikon noct - nikkor lens mated to a back - illuminated finger lakes instrumentation ( fli ) ccd camera ( microline ml4710 - 1-mb ) through a 20 mm extension tube for close - focus imaging .
the whole setup was mounted on top of the vacuum vessel ( figure [ fig : detectorvessel ] ) in a light tight box .
the camera contained an e2v 18.8 mm diagonal sensor with a @xmath14 pixel array ( ccd47 - 10 - 1 - 353 ) , consisting of 13 @xmath15 13 @xmath16 pixels .
the mid - band coated ccd sensor had a peak quantum efficiency of 96@xmath17 at 560 nm and could be cooled down to a stable operating temperature of @xmath18c using the built - in peltier cooler .
two readout speeds were available , 700 khz and 2 mhz , with 16-bit digitization and a maximum @xmath19 on - chip pixel binning . at the lowest operating temperature and slowest readout mode ,
the read - out noise was @xmath810 e@xmath20 rms and the dark current was @xmath80.03 @xmath21/pix / sec with @xmath22 on - chip pixel binning . at our focusing distance
, the ccd - lens system imaged a @xmath8@xmath23 @xmath15 3 @xmath7 physical region of the gem / thgem surface .
the known pitch of the holes on this surface was used to calibrate the length - scale of the images .
the gas gain was determined using an ortec 448 research pulse generator and an ortec 142ih charge sensitive preamplifier , which read out the charge signal from the last gem / thgem surface .
the pulse generator output was connected to the test input of the preamplifier via a built - in 1 pf capacitor for calibration purposes .
this allowed the preamplifier gain ( fc / v ) to be determined .
the 5.9 kev @xmath0fe x - ray calibration source was then used to determine the effective gas gain from the output voltage signal of the preamplifier .
the conversion of the x - ray created 172 electron - ion pairs on average , which was calculated from the w - value ( the average energy per ionization ) of 34.2 ev for cf@xmath1 @xcite . for each pressure
the maximum stable gain was determined iteratively by raising the gem / thgem voltages and testing for stability .
the latter was done by firing a highly ionizing source ( @xmath12po alpha source ) into the detection volume .
if no sparks occurred over several hours , then the voltage setting was deemed stable and the procedure repeated until the maximum stable gain was found . at a pressure of 100 torr , a maximum stable effective gain of @xmath24 was achieved with gem @xmath25 v , gem @xmath26 v , and gem @xmath27 v , and a drift field of 400 v / cm . at these gem voltages
the transfer fields were 1.40 kv / cm and 1.67 kv / cm between gems 1 and 2 , and 2 and 3 , respectively , and the induction field was 260 v / cm between gem 3 and the grid .
a higher effective gas gain of @xmath28 was achieved with gems 1 and 2 = 290 v and gem 3 = 450 v , where the drift , transfer , and induction fields were 400 v / cm , 1.45 kv / cm , and 360 v / cm , respectively .
this setting , however , was not entirely stable under alpha irradiation , which initiated a spark about once per hour
. nevertheless , we were able to acquire @xmath0fe images and an energy spectrum without any sparks at this setting .
for the 50 torr measurements , the thgem was powered to a voltage of 830 v and the drift field was set to 200 v / cm ( same @xmath29 as in the 100 torr measurements ) .
the induction field was 824 v / cm with the wire grid set to a lower voltage than the top thgem surface so that all electrons produced in the avalanche were collected by this electrode .
the electrical stability at this voltage setting was similar to the highest gain setting at 100 torr in that both were moderately but not completely stable .
for this measurement we estimate the gain to be @xmath30 . finally , in the 35 torr measurements , the thgem voltage biases were thgem 1 = 573 v and thgem 2 = 470 v , where thgem 1 is the one facing the cathode and thgem 2 is nearest to the wire grid . the drift , transfer , and induction fields were 200 v / cm , 718 v / cm , and 495 v / cm , respectively . here
we estimate the gas gain , which was stable , to be @xmath8@xmath31 .
the ccd images ( or frames ) were calibrated using a set of co - averaged flat - field and dark frames .
both were taken with the same 5 second exposure time as the data images .
dark frames , taken with the camera shutter closed , were used to correct for the variable accumulation rate of dark current across the pixels in the ccd sensor .
flat - field frames , used to correct for vignetting and pixel to pixel variation in light sensitivity , were acquired by taking exposures of a uniformly illuminated screen . for each type of calibration frame ,
a set was acquired and co - averaged together to create a master calibration frame . for accuracy , the averaging required rejecting pixels in individual frames that suffered direct hits from cosmic rays or radioactivity .
this was done using an algorithm that compared the value of the same pixel across the set of frames , excluding those above three sigmas of the initial average of the pixels .
the average was re - computed and the process iterated until there was a convergence in the average value of the pixels .
finally , the data image was calibrated by subtracting the master dark frame and dividing the resulting frame by the normalized , master flat - field frame .
a sample image containing @xmath0fe tracks taken at the maximum stable gain setting in 100 torr cf@xmath1 is shown in figure [ fig : fimage100torr ] . on chip binning of @xmath32
was used for this image , resulting in each binned pixel imaging 165 in real space .
the signal is well above the noise in the ccd image and individual tracks are resolved . with this level of signal - to - noise and resolution one could easily characterize the spatial uniformity of the gas gain across the gems . the corresponding optically derived energy spectrum , using images of these tracks , is shown in figure [ fig : fspectrum100torr ] in units of adus1.3 @xmath21 produced in our ccd sensor .
] . the peak value in the spectrum is obtained from a fit which comprises of a single gaussian signal component and a constant plus exponential for the background components .
the range of the fit is set so as to exclude the secondary peak seen at @xmath83500 adu , which is due to pile - up events .
the fit has a reduced @xmath33 @xmath34 , a peak value of @xmath35 , and @xmath36 .
the fwhm energy resolution is 38% and we obtain an energy conversion factor of 275 adus / kev . in figures [ fig : fimage100torrmaxgain6x6 ] and [ fig : fspectrum100torrmaxgain6x6 ] , a sample image of @xmath0fe tracks imaged at @xmath37 binning and a higher gain of @xmath82@xmath38 in 100 torr cf@xmath1 is shown along with the corresponding energy spectrum .
the same procedure for fitting the spectrum as described above gives a peak value of @xmath39 , @xmath40 of @xmath41 , and energy conversion factor of 425 adus / kev .
interestingly , the fwhm energy resolution is 30% , significantly better than that of the moderate gain 100 torr data at the same image binning . for the @xmath19 high gain data , a sample image of @xmath0fe tracks and the corresponding energy spectrum
are shown in figures [ fig : fimage100torrmaxgain16x16 ] and [ fig : fspectrum100torrmaxgain16x16 ] .
a fit of the spectrum gives a peak value of @xmath42 , @xmath40 of @xmath43 , and energy conversion factor of 443 adus / kev .
the 4% difference in peak value between the @xmath37 and @xmath44 data could be the result of a reduced efficiency for finding the entire track due to a slightly lower signal to noise in the lower binned data .
alternatively , the difference could simply be due to drift in the gas gain over time between acquisition of the two data sets .
both high gain data sets , however , have the same fwhm energy resolution of 30% . in figure
[ fig : fe55 - 50torr ] , two sample images of @xmath0fe tracks taken at a pressure of 50 torr in cf@xmath1 are shown . as expected , the tracks are longer and much better resolved than those in the 100 torr data and , additionally , differences in ionization density are also clearly visible .
the corresponding energy spectrum is not shown because not enough images were taken at this pressure due to onset of electrical instability , which is not surprising given the low operating pressure and high gas gain .
nevertheless , as these images unambiguously show , ccd - based tpcs with sufficiently high signal - to - noise and imaging resolution can _ resolve _ electron recoils with energies as low as 5.9 kev . for the 35 torr data , a sample image containing @xmath0fe tracks
is shown in figure [ fig : fimage35torr ] .
as in the 50 torr data the tracks are clearly resolved but the resolution is poorer due to the presence of a second thgem and the transfer region within the double thgem amplification structure .
the energy spectrum obtained from a series of these images is shown in figure [ fig : fspectrum35torr ] .
a fit of the spectrum to a single gaussian signal component and a background component which consists of uniform and exponential components gives a reduced @xmath33 @xmath45 .
the fitted peak value is @xmath46 and @xmath47 .
this gives a fwhm energy resolution of 40% which is similar to , within errors , the energy resolution obtained from the moderate gain 100 torr data .
finally , in figure [ fig : fe55 - 25torr ] , we present sample images of @xmath0fe tracks acquired at a pressure of 25 torr pure cf@xmath1 .
however , there is insufficient data for an energy spectrum because electrical instabilities ( discharges ) prevented a long data run . but with additional fine tuning of thgem voltages and detector setup ,
it is conceivable that stable operation at this pressure with sufficient gas gain for imaging individual @xmath0fe tracks could be achievable .
two effects on the light yield in 100 torr cf@xmath1 were observed in our @xmath0fe calibration data .
the first was due to contamination from out - gassing , and the second was an indication of light quenching at high gas gains .
we discuss these here .
@xmath0fe calibrations were required over 8 days for a different application , providing us data to study the effects of possible gas contaminants on the light yield . before the start of the 8 day data run , the detector vessel was sealed and pumped out to @xmath130.1 torr overnight .
subsequently , each day of data taking started by back - filling the detector vessel to 100 torr with 99.999% pure cf@xmath1 , powering up the detector and acquiring @xmath870 minutes of @xmath0fe data .
this was followed by @xmath814 hours of neutron data and a second @xmath870 minute @xmath0fe exposure at the end of the day , after which the detector was powered down and the vessel pumped out for @xmath83 hours .
this procedure was repeated for each day of data taking .
the gems were powered up to the same voltages each day , with the values given in section [ sec : gain ] for the moderate , stable gas gain of @xmath48@xmath38 .
the electronic @xmath0fe spectrum was used to monitor the gas gain , which remained constant within 10% over the 8 days . the optical @xmath0fe data over this period , however , showed an increase in the light yield , which is highly sensitive to gas purity . with the detector
kept sealed over the 8 days , out - gassing would be the main source of contamination with the expectation that its rate would decrease over time .
the results of the data runs are plotted in figure [ fig : peak_vs_days ] , which shows the fitted peak value of the optical @xmath0fe spectrum at the start and end of each of the 8 days of data acquisition . the large difference in the start and end spectrum peak values for data
run 1 is most likely the result of insufficient time given between gem power up and data taking ; we found that the gems required about 1 - 2 hours after being brought up to voltage before stable operation ensued . with the exception of run 1 , the start and end spectrum peak values are always within 4% of each other , which suggests that that any compositional change of the gas does not affect the light output significantly over a single day .
the data , however , shows a clear rise in the spectrum peak value over the 8 days . between run 2 and run 8 the light output
increased by 21% in the end series , and by 19% in the start series . the light yield in
the end series is monotonically increasing whereas that in the start series has scatter due to variability in the time between gem power up and data taking .
nevertheless , the steady increase in light yield over the 8 days is consistent with improved gas purity due to a decrease in the out - gassing rate , which can have a long half - life in sealed vessels that have not been baked out .
the second effect , possibly due to light quenching , was the change in the ratio of the optical @xmath0fe spectrum peak and the corresponding effective gas gain for the two gain settings , @xmath48@xmath38 and @xmath8 2@xmath38 . in the lower gain data , this ratio was @xmath49 , and in the high gain data it was @xmath50 .
this ratio , which can be thought of as an effective photon yield ( photons per secondary electron ) , is lower by @xmath819% at the higher gas gain .
unfortunately , the low and high gain measurements were taken months apart so it is difficult to definitively attribute the lower photon yield to quenching .
we nevertheless describe the various possibilities as some of them have important implications for applications such as directional dark matter searches .
the first possibility is that it could be a charge density effect , where the photon yield decreases ( is quenched ) as the charge density increases at high gas gains .
of course , the emission spectrum from cf@xmath1 could also be affected at high charge densities , lowering the number of photons produced in the wavelength range of sensitivity for our ccd camera and lens .
another possibility is that there were more contaminants due to out - gassing in the high gain measurements , which could also explain the lower light yield .
lower light yields resulting from contamination due to out - gassing could be dealt with with a long pump down and/or continuous filtering of the gas in a circulation system . however , quenching due to high charge density arising from either high gas gains and/or high primary ionization densities has important consequences for applications where measuring the charge density along a recoil track is required .
an example is directional dark matter detection in which the sense ( vector direction ) of the ionization track is determined by measuring the asymmetry in the charge deposition along the track . if quenching plays a significant role in the low pressure regime where directional dark matter experiments operate , it could limit how well the directional signature can be measured in gas based tpcs operated at high gas gains .
fe energy spectrum at the start and end of the day over eight days of data taking . with the exception of the first data run , the start and end peak values are within 4% .
the large change ( @xmath51 ) seen between the start and end in the first data set is likely due to insufficient time for the gems to charge up and stabilize . the raising peak value with run number is likely the result of a reduction in concentration of contaminants with the additional pump down in - between runs . ,
we have shown that a gem and thgem based detector can be operated in low pressure cf@xmath52 ( 25 - 100 torr ) with gains exceeding @xmath53 .
this allowed individual @xmath0fe tracks to be imaged by a low noise ccd camera and for an optically measured spectrum to be obtained .
we found that it is important to pump down the detector for an extended period of time to reduce contaminants in the gas that can suppress light output .
we also noted a decrease in light yield at higher gas gains , which could be due to light quenching at high charge densities .
if confirmed , this could affect directional dark matter experiments that rely on the asymmetry in charge density to determine the recoil direction of a track .
finally , we showed that electronic recoils as low as 5.9 kev in energy can be optically resolved .
this is important for rare event searches such as direct dark matter detection experiments that rely on differences in stopping power to discriminate between different types of recoils .
this material is based upon work supported by the nsf under grant nos .
0548208 , 1103420 , and 1407773 .
f. a. f. fraga , et al .
instr . and
meth . phys .
res . a 442 ( 2000 ) 417 - 422 .
f. a. f. fraga , et al .
instr . and
meth . phys .
res . a 471 ( 2001 ) 125 - 130 .
f. a. f. fraga , et al .
instr . and
meth . phys
. res . a 478 ( 2002 )
357 - 361 . | the first optically resolved electron tracks from an @xmath0fe x - ray source are presented together with the resulting energy spectrum .
these tracks were produced in a tpc operating in low pressure carbon tetrafluoride ( cf@xmath1 ) gas , and imaged using a fast lens and low noise ccd optical system . using gem / thgem amplification devices , effective gas gains of @xmath2
were obtained in pure cf@xmath1 at low pressures in the 25 - 100 torr range .
the detector s very high signal - to - noise and the low gas pressures allowed individual ionization tracks from 5.9 kev x - ray interactions to be imaged and resolved .
the ability to resolve tracks of such low energies has important applications in dark matter and other rare event searches , as well as in x - ray polarimetry .
a practical application of the optical signal from @xmath0fe is that it provides a tool for mapping the detector spatial uniformity .
optical tpc , @xmath0fe electron tracks , gems , thick gems , @xmath3 , ccd camera |
analysis on post critically finite ( p.c.f . )
fractals has been well developed since kigami s original papers [ ki1,ki2 ] on the direct analytic construction of the laplacian on the familiar sierpinski gasket @xmath5 ( see fig .
1.1 ) , which now has been viewed as the `` post child '' for the theory .
recently , there are several works in connection with the differential calculus on fractals that involve derivatives , tangents , multiharmonic functions , higher order laplacians , analogous to the theory of analysis on manifolds .
please see [ bssy , cq , drs , dsv , nsty , s1-s3 , su , t2 ] and the references therein .
.,width=226 ] in [ s3 ] , strichartz developed a theory of derivatives and gradients on a class of p.c.f .
fractals with nondegenerate harmonic structure , which consummates the theory of normal derivatives and gauss - green s integration formula , and could be used to get an analogous theory of local taylor approximations at vertices on fractals .
there are also some other works concerned the gradients and tangents on fractals from different points of views , please see [ ki3 ] , [ ku ] and [ t2 ] . in teplyaev s work [ t2 ] one could find a discussion on the relations between the different definitions and results of kigami [ ki3 ] , kusuoka [ ku ] , teplyaev and strichartz on this topic .
in the end of strichartz s paper [ s3 ] , he post sevaral open problems that should be solved to complete the story of local taylor approximations .
two of them are as follows .
* question 1 . * _ for a smooth function @xmath3 defined near a vertex @xmath2 , could the higher order tangents @xmath6 at @xmath2 be expressible as limits of local multiharmonic functions that agree with @xmath3 in a suitable sense near @xmath2 ? _
* question 2 . * _ for a smooth function @xmath3 , is it possible to express @xmath7 as a uniform limit of a pointwise formula in terms of linear combinations of the values of @xmath3 at vertices approaching @xmath2 ? _ the main goal of this paper is to answer the above two questions .
we will mainly focus on the @xmath0 symmetric fractals , i.e. , those fractals whose boundary consists of @xmath8 points and all structures posses full @xmath0 symmetry .
the results can be extended to fully symmetric p.c.f .
fractals with suitable modification .
some of our results are extended to general p.c.f .
fractals .
this paper is organized as follows . in section 2
, we collect some notations and facts about laplacians and derivatives on general p.c.f .
fractals , most of which was introduced in [ ki5 , s4 ] . in section 3
, we introduce the theory of local monomials which form a basis of local multiharmonic functions near a vertex @xmath2 , using which we give a positive answer of question 1 .
this theory will also play a key role for solving question 2 . then in section 4 , the main part of this paper , we focus on question 2 and prove a pointwise formula for the higher order laplacians . in both section 3 and section 4
we only consider those @xmath0 symmetric fractals , since the full symmetric structures could provide many advantages for our discussion .
then in section 5 , we turn to consider the general p.c.f .
fractals to see to what extent can we extend our previous results . in section 6 ,
we show how to extend the previous results to those p.c.f .
self - similar sets with full symmetry , including some typical @xmath1 symmetric fractals , such as the tetrahedral sierpinski gasket and the vicsek sets .
finally , in appendix , we provide a recursion algorithm for the exact calculations of the boundary values of the monomials introduced in section 3 , for some typical @xmath0 or @xmath1 symmetric fractals , which are important for results in section 3 .
this algorithm is an improved version of the one developed in [ nsty ] , which presents to be more direct and shorter .
we recall some standard notations and results on kigami s laplacian and stirchartz s derivatives on p.c.f .
fractals , which are the necessary background of this paper
. please refer to [ ki1-ki2 , ki5 , s4 ] for any unexplained notion .
let @xmath9 be a _
self - similar structure_. that is , there is a finite set of contractive continuous injections @xmath10 on some metric space , with a compact invariant set @xmath11 satisfying @xmath12 .
we define @xmath13 as the space of _ words _
@xmath14 of length @xmath15 , taking values from the alphabet @xmath16 , then we could denote @xmath17 and call @xmath18 a @xmath19 level _ cell _ of @xmath11 . the term `` p.c.f . ''
means that @xmath11 is connected , and there is a finite set @xmath20 called the _ boundary _ of @xmath11 such that @xmath21 for different @xmath22 and @xmath23 with the same length .
moreover , each element in the boundary set @xmath24 is required to be the fixed point of one of the mapping of @xmath10 . without loss of generality , we write @xmath25 for @xmath26 , and @xmath27 for @xmath28 .
let @xmath29 denote the complete graph on @xmath24 .
we approximate @xmath11 by a sequence of _ graphs _
@xmath30 with vertices @xmath31 and edge relation @xmath32 defined by inductively applying the contractive mappings of @xmath33 to @xmath29 .
let @xmath34 be the collection of all vertices of @xmath11 .
suppose there is a regular _ harmonic structure _ on @xmath9 .
thus there is a sequence of _ renormalized graph energies _
@xmath35 on @xmath30 with @xmath36 for functions @xmath37 defined on @xmath31 , satisfying the self - similar identity @xmath38 where @xmath39 are the @xmath19-level _ conductances _ on graph @xmath30 , and @xmath40 are the _ renormalization factors _ satisfying @xmath41 . for @xmath42
, we use @xmath43 to denote the @xmath44-level conductances on graph @xmath29 . obviously , for @xmath32 , we have @xmath45 , where @xmath22 is the word of length @xmath19 such that @xmath46 , @xmath47 , with @xmath48 . furthermore
, if we denote @xmath49 , then the restriction of @xmath35 to @xmath50 equals @xmath51 , which means , if @xmath3 is defined on @xmath50 , then for all extension @xmath52 of @xmath3 to @xmath30 , the one @xmath53 that minimize @xmath35 satisfies @xmath54 .
hence the sequence @xmath55 is monotone increasing as @xmath19 goes to infinity for any function @xmath3 defined on @xmath11 , and thus we could define @xmath56 and by polarization identity , @xmath57 the domain @xmath58 of @xmath59 consists of continuous functions @xmath3 such that @xmath60 .
the self - similar identity for graph energy becomes @xmath61 a function @xmath62 is _ harmonic _ if it minimizes the energy from level @xmath19 to level @xmath63 for each @xmath19 .
all the harmonic functions form a @xmath64-dimensional space , denoted by @xmath65 , and hence any values on the boundary can uniquely determine a harmonic function on @xmath11 .
in fact , for every @xmath66 , there is linear map @xmath67 be defined by @xmath68 .
we call @xmath69 the @xmath70-th _ harmonic extension matrix_. let @xmath71 be the _ self - similar measure _ with a set of probability weights @xmath72 on @xmath11 ,
satisfying @xmath73 or equivalently , @xmath74 for @xmath75 , we denote @xmath76 the measure of @xmath18 .
the _ graph laplacian _
@xmath77 on @xmath30 is defined to be @xmath78 for @xmath79 .
the _ laplacian _ with respect to @xmath71 on @xmath11 is defined as the renormalized limit @xmath80 where @xmath81 .
( we avoid the notation @xmath82 without causing any confusion . ) here @xmath83 is a _ tent function _ which is harmonic on each @xmath19-level cell taking value @xmath84 at @xmath2 and @xmath44 at other vertices in @xmath31 .
more precisely , @xmath85 and @xmath86 means @xmath3 and @xmath87 are continuous and the above limit converges to @xmath87 uniformly on @xmath88 . there is an equivalent definition called _ weak formulation _ , which says that for @xmath89 and continuous function @xmath87 , @xmath85 with @xmath86 if and only if @xmath90 holds for all @xmath91 , where @xmath92 means those functions in @xmath58 that vanishes on the boundary @xmath24 .
there is a scaling identity @xmath93 the space of _ multiharmonic functions _ ( solutions of @xmath94 for some @xmath95 ) on fractals , analogous to _ polynomials _ on the unit interval plays an important role in describing the approximation behavior of smooth functions , such as in the theory of taylor approximations [ s3 ] , splines [ su ] , and power series expansions [ nsty ] .
let @xmath96 denote the collection of @xmath97-harmonic functions , the solutions of @xmath98 , which is of @xmath99-dimension .
the following is the _ gauss - green s formula _
, @xmath100 which connect the laplacian @xmath101 with the important concept of normal derivative .
we would not want to involve the general theory of derivatives for general p.c.f .
fractals . in the rest of this section ,
we restrict our attention to the _
@xmath0 symmetric fractals_. here @xmath0 symmetry means that all structures are invariant under any homeomorphism of @xmath11 . in this case ,
@xmath102 and we could choose all @xmath103 . now all the harmonic extension matrices @xmath69 only differ by permutations , and we must have @xmath104 and @xmath105 . we denote them by @xmath106 and @xmath71 for simplicity respectively .
we denote @xmath107 the value of @xmath108 .
( in the next two sections , we actually need @xmath109 for all @xmath110 . )
it is easy to verify that @xmath84 is the largest eigenvalue and @xmath106 is the second large eigenvalue of the matrix @xmath69 for @xmath111 .
we denote the _ third eigenvalue _ by @xmath112 . here
we require that the matrix @xmath69 to be nondegenerate . the familiar _ sierpinski gasket _
@xmath5 is a typical example , which is an invariant set generated by @xmath8 contractive mappings with fixed points @xmath113 the vertices of a triangle with contraction ratio @xmath114 . for @xmath5 , @xmath115 , @xmath116 , and @xmath117 .
two more examples are the _ level @xmath8 sierpinski gasket _ @xmath118 and the _ hexagasket _ @xmath119 . here
@xmath118 is an invariant set of six contractions of ratio @xmath120 as shown in fig .
2.1 , which has @xmath121 , @xmath122 , @xmath123 and @xmath124 . while @xmath119 , which is also named as star of david , is generated by six mappings with simultaneously rotating and contracting by a ratio of 1/3 as shown in fig .
2.2 , having @xmath125 , @xmath123 and @xmath126
. please refer to [ s4 ] for detailed information .
sierpinski gasket @xmath118.,width=226 ] .,width=226 ] the _ normal derivatives _ of a function @xmath3 at the boundary point @xmath127 is defined as @xmath128 ( cyclic notation @xmath129 ) , while the _ transverse derivatives _ at @xmath127 is defined as @xmath130 providing the limits exist . for hormonic functions
, these derivatives can be evaluated without taking the limit .
all the above notations and results are from global viewpoint .
now we turn to the localized ones .
we could localize the definition of derivatives as follows .
let @xmath2 be a boundary point of cell @xmath18 , that is , there exists a @xmath127 such that @xmath131 .
we define the normal derivative at @xmath2 with respect to @xmath18 by @xmath132 if the limit exists .
we denote the superscript @xmath22 since @xmath2 may be boundary points for different cells in the same level .
we will drop it when no confusion occurs . for @xmath85 ,
the sum of all normal derivatives of @xmath3 at @xmath2 must vanish .
this is called the _
match condition_. in general , it is necessary and sufficient for gluing together two functions whose laplacian is defined on neighboring cells . also at @xmath131 , there is a transverse derivative @xmath133 if the limit exists . for @xmath85 ,
the transverse derivatives at a point @xmath2 with respect to different cells may be unrelated .
there are scaling identities for localized derivatives .
@xmath134 and @xmath135 let @xmath136 .
suppose @xmath137 is the first value for which @xmath138 .
we say @xmath2 is a _ junction vertex
_ if there is at least two different @xmath137-cells containing @xmath2 , i.e. , @xmath2 has at least two different representations @xmath131 with @xmath139 .
otherwise , we call @xmath2 a _ nonjunction vertex _ , which has exactly one representation @xmath131 .
for both the two different types of vertices , there is a canonical system of _ neighborhoods _ for each @xmath2 . on each certain neighborhood , there is a space of _ local multiharmonic functions_. our definition is slightly different from the definition in [ s3 ] . * definition 2.1 .
* _ ( a ) for @xmath79 , define the m - neighborhood of @xmath2 as @xmath140 write @xmath141 for the sake of simplicity , which obviously is the largest one .
the boundary of the m - neighborhood @xmath142 is @xmath143 _ _ ( b ) on each @xmath142 , define local @xmath97-harmonic functions to be those functions @xmath62 on @xmath142 , with @xmath144 for each @xmath22 , and @xmath145 satisfying the matching conditions at @xmath2 for all @xmath146 .
( if @xmath2 is a nonjunction vertex , we say the matching conditions means @xmath147 for all @xmath146 ) .
write the space of all such functions @xmath148 .
_ here we remark that our notations differ from that in [ s3 ] when @xmath2 is a nonjunction vertex . in our setting
, we always view @xmath2 as an inner point in @xmath142 .
let @xmath149 denote the set of words of length @xmath137 such that there is a @xmath127 with @xmath131 .
call @xmath150 the _ order _ of @xmath2 .
obviously , @xmath151 when @xmath2 is a junction vertex , while @xmath152 when @xmath2 is a nonjunction vertex .
it is easy to verify that the dimension of the space @xmath148 is exactly @xmath153 for any @xmath79 . for convenience
, we always sort the elements in @xmath149 in lexicographical order .
we use @xmath154 to denote the contractive mapping on @xmath155 with @xmath156 for @xmath157 and @xmath158 .
it is easy to see that @xmath159 .
more generally , for a simple connected set @xmath160 , where @xmath161 is a finite set of words , we may define the _ boundary _ @xmath162 to be the vertices satisfying \1 ) @xmath163 .
\2 ) @xmath164 or @xmath165 is not a subset of @xmath166 for any @xmath19 .
then , analogous to the global case , we could define the local energy on @xmath166 as @xmath167 the domain @xmath168 is the space of continuous functions on @xmath166 having finite energy , and @xmath169 is the subspace of such functions which vanish at @xmath170 .
the laplacian localized to @xmath166 could be defined by the weak formulation in an analogous way .
we denote @xmath171 the domain of @xmath172 on @xmath166 .
we need to point out that if @xmath85 , then @xmath173 . additionally , the local multiharmonic function space is denote as @xmath174 with dimension @xmath175 .
the following gauss - green s formula holds .
@xmath176 for any @xmath177 and @xmath178 .
the matching condition holds at all vertices except the boundary points . for nonjunction vertices
, we still use the term `` matching condition '' like that used in definition 2.1 . in other words , nonjunction vertices always are viewed as inner points .
it should be careful that there exists the possibility that some boundary points of @xmath166 may belong to more than one component cells of @xmath166 simultaneously .
it never occurs for @xmath5 case .
2.3 for an example simple set in @xmath118 .
of course , at these boundary points , the matching condition does not need hold .
, with boundary points denoted by dots .
here the center point is a boundary point which belongs to two component cells.,width=151 ]
there are several bases of @xmath96 for different purposes . in [ nsty ] , to develop a theory of the local behavior of functions at a single boundary point , a basis of @xmath96 , analogous to the monomials @xmath179 on the unit interval , was described and studied on the sierpinski gasket @xmath5 .
this could be easily extended to fractals whose all structures posses full @xmath0 symmetry , as follows . throughout this section
, we drop the subscript @xmath71 of @xmath101 for simplicity . * definition 3.1 . * _ fix a boundary point @xmath127 .
the monomials @xmath180 for @xmath181 and @xmath182 in @xmath96 are the multiharmonic functions satisfying @xmath183 _ it is easy to verify that these monomials form a basis of @xmath96 with the dimension @xmath184 .
these monomials are related by the following identity , @xmath185 by the @xmath0 symmetry , @xmath180 for different @xmath70 s are same under simply rotations . @xmath186 and @xmath187 are symmetric while @xmath188 is skew - symmetric with respect to the reflection symmetry that fixes @xmath127 and interchanges the other two boundary points . moreover
, the monomials satisfy the following self - similar identities that describe the decay ratios of these functions near @xmath127 .
@xmath189 denote @xmath190 for @xmath191 . in [ nsty ]
, one can find an elaborate recursion algorithm of these numbers on the sierpinski gasket @xmath5 .
an important observation is that all these numbers are not equal to @xmath44 .
the calculation there is quite technical and is hard to be extended to the general @xmath0 case .
however , we still could verify that @xmath192 are never equal to @xmath44 for some typical fractals with full @xmath0 symmetric structures , for example , the level @xmath8 sierpinski gasket @xmath118 and the hexagasket @xmath119 .
we thus make a following technical assumption .
* assumption 3.2 . *
_ all the numbers @xmath193 and @xmath194 are not equal to @xmath44 .
_ we will give the calculations of @xmath195 and @xmath194 for @xmath5 , @xmath118 and @xmath119 in the appendix , by using a new algorithm modified from that in [ nsty ] , which seems to be shorter and more direct .
we need to extend the above definitions and discussions to all vertices in @xmath196 . naturally , we have the following localized version of monomials , which will play an essential role in answering both the two questions listed in the introduction section .
* definition 3.3 . *
_ fix a vertex @xmath136 .
the monomials @xmath197 in @xmath198 for @xmath181 , @xmath182 and @xmath158 are the local multiharmonic functions satisfying _ @xmath199 _ where @xmath23 is the next word to @xmath22 in @xmath149 in lexicographical order . _ * remark 1 . * for @xmath200 ,
the superscript @xmath22 is unnecessary , and we may not add it when discuss @xmath201 seperately . for nonjunction vertices , there are no monomials in @xmath202 case .
* remark 2 . *
it is easy to check that @xmath203 forms a basis of @xmath204 .
similar to ( 3.1)-(3.3 ) , the following self - similar identities hold @xmath205 which describe the decay behaviors of these monomials near @xmath2 . it is apparent that these monomials have symmetric properties analogous to the global case .
denote @xmath206 the rotations in @xmath0 symmetric group , with @xmath207 ( cyclic notation )
. * definition 3.4 . * _ fix a vertex @xmath136 . for @xmath181 , let @xmath208 be a linear projection from @xmath209 into itself satisfying @xmath210 for any @xmath211 , @xmath158 , @xmath146 .
let @xmath212 be a linear mapping on @xmath209 , defined by @xmath213 for @xmath214 , for any @xmath62 in @xmath209 .
_ clearly , @xmath215 is a linear combination of the monomials @xmath216 , and it is easy to check that @xmath217 as for @xmath212 , roughly speaking , it is an operator on @xmath209 which first rotates variables around @xmath2 , then takes mean values with weights proportional to @xmath218 .
let @xmath219 be the local symmetry in @xmath155 , which fixes @xmath220 and permutes the other two boundary points of @xmath18 for each @xmath158 .
* theorem 3.5 . * _ assume @xmath136 and @xmath221 , then the following identities hold @xmath222 _ _ proof . _ the following equalities are consequences of symmetric definitions of @xmath223 , @xmath224 and @xmath225 .
@xmath226 and @xmath227 which hold for @xmath158 , @xmath146 , for any @xmath221 .
these yield the result of the theorem . @xmath228 * corollary 3.6 . * _ assume @xmath136 and @xmath221 , then for each @xmath229 , @xmath230 if and only if @xmath231 for @xmath181 .
_ + in the rest of this section , we give an application of the local monomials , to show that the higher order weak tangents of smooth functions @xmath3 at any fixed vertex , could be expressible as limits of local multiharmonic functions that agree with @xmath3 at the boundary of @xmath142 .
this is question 1 which we want to solve in this paper . to be more precise
, we need the following definition of _ higher order weak tangents_. * definition 3.7 . * _ let @xmath2 be a vertex in @xmath88 and @xmath3 a function defined in a neighborhood of @xmath2 .
we say that an @xmath97-harmonic function @xmath62 is a weak tangent of order @xmath232 of @xmath3 at @xmath2 if _ @xmath233 and @xmath234 * theorem 3.8 . * _ assume assumption 3.2 holds .
let @xmath136 . then the following two conclusions hold .
_ _ ( a)an @xmath97-harmonic function @xmath62 on @xmath155 is uniquely determined by the values @xmath235 , and any such values may be freely assigned . _ _ ( b)let @xmath3 be a continuous function defined in a neighborhood of @xmath2 , and assume @xmath3 has a weak tangent of order n+1 at @xmath2 , denoted by @xmath62 .
let @xmath236 be the ( n+1)-harmonic function defined in @xmath155 , assuming the same values as @xmath3 at the boundary points of @xmath237 for all @xmath146 .
then @xmath236 converges to @xmath62 uniformly on @xmath155 .
_ * remark 1 .
* this theorem extends the previous result in [ cq , s3 ] for the @xmath84-order tangents and @xmath84-order harmonic functions . for the nonjunction vertices
, there is an implicit restriction that @xmath3 , @xmath62 and @xmath236 should satisfy the equation @xmath238 for all @xmath146 , since we always view @xmath2 as an inner point in @xmath155 . * remark 2 .
* there are some sufficient conditions to ensure the existence of the weak tangents .
one can find more detailed discussion on the weak tangents ( and _ tangents _ , _ strong tangents _ ) in [ s3 ] .
_ proof of theorem 3.8 .
_ ( a ) the map from @xmath198 to the values @xmath239 is obviously a linear map , and the dimemsion of @xmath198 is @xmath240 , which is exactly equal to @xmath241 .
thus to proof ( a ) , we only need to show that the map is injective .
fix a word @xmath158 with @xmath131 .
let @xmath211 .
for @xmath181 , notice that @xmath242 is a linear combination of @xmath180 , denote the combination coefficients of @xmath180 by @xmath243 .
we have the following equalities @xmath244 for @xmath245 where we denote @xmath246 for convenience .
thus the @xmath247 matrix @xmath248 induce a linear map from @xmath249 to the values @xmath250 .
we now show that the matrix @xmath248 is invertible for @xmath181 .
denote by @xmath251 an @xmath252 matrix with @xmath253 which is obviously invertible .
then by using the self - similar identities @xmath254 , we have @xmath255 which can be rewritten in matrix notation , @xmath256 from which it is obviously that all the matrices @xmath257 are invertible .
the above discussion shows that @xmath215 vanishs at @xmath258 if and only if @xmath259 . according to corollary 3.6 , @xmath62 vanishs at @xmath258 if and only if all @xmath215 vanishs at @xmath258 .
thus we have proved ( a ) .
\(b ) we need to study the ( n+1)-harmonic functions @xmath260 .
notice that formula ( 3.13 ) still holds for @xmath260 . for @xmath200
, we have @xmath261 .
thus @xmath262 according to @xmath263 , by using theorem 3.5 , we have @xmath264 , which gives that @xmath265 for @xmath202 , a similar discussion shows that @xmath266 according to ( 3.11 ) , still using theorem 3.5 , we have @xmath267 , and hence @xmath268 for @xmath269 , the same argument yields that @xmath270 using ( 3.12 ) and theorem 3.5 , we can get @xmath271 , so @xmath272 thus we have proved that for @xmath181 , @xmath273 converges uniformly to zero on each cell @xmath18 , which yields that @xmath236 converges uniformly to @xmath62 on @xmath155 .
in this section , we will deal with question 2 .
we still restrict to consider the @xmath0 symmetric fractals .
the subscript @xmath71 of the laplacian @xmath101 is still dropped for simplicity .
analogous to the pointwise formula of the laplacian , we will show that we can approach the @xmath95-order laplacian by the @xmath95 times iterating of the renormalized discrete laplacian , which means @xmath274 notice that @xmath275 may not be defined on all vertices in @xmath276 for @xmath277 .
for example , when @xmath278 , it is exact those vertices which are not connected with the boundary @xmath24 having the operation @xmath279 well - defined .
it is convenient to define the following notations . * definition 4.1 . * _ for two vertices @xmath280 , the m - distance @xmath281 between them is the minimal number of edges which connect @xmath2 to @xmath282 in @xmath30 .
_ it is easy to check that any vertex satisfying @xmath283 has a well - defined @xmath284 , and we denote @xmath285 the domain of the definition of @xmath286 .
4.1 for @xmath287 , the domain of @xmath288 for @xmath5 . for @xmath5 , denoted by dots .
, scaledwidth=40.0% ] for fixed @xmath289 , the calculation of @xmath284 involves the values of @xmath3 at those vertices with @xmath19-distance to @xmath2 no more than @xmath95 , which are collected as @xmath290 the area bounded by these vertices is obviously a neighborhood of @xmath2 , which may be written as @xmath291 ( see fig . 4.2 ) , with the following identity holds , @xmath292 with @xmath293 in the sierpinski gasket.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] with @xmath293 in the sierpinski gasket.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] it is natural that the _ boundary _ of @xmath291 is @xmath294 which is consistent with the boundary of @xmath142 and the boundary of simple set @xmath166 as introduced in section 2 . in our setting ,
nonjunction vertices still always be viewed as inner points .
it is easy to check that @xmath295
. it should be careful that there indeed exist vertices that belong to @xmath296 , which are not boundary points of @xmath291 .
for example , it is the case when we choose @xmath2 to be the bottom dotted vertex in fig 4.1 for @xmath5 for @xmath297 . * remark . *
the shape of @xmath291 varies for @xmath2 in @xmath298 and @xmath299 .
we could give a classification of them .
let @xmath289 and @xmath300 .
we say @xmath291 and @xmath301 belong to a same _ type _ if there exists some mapping @xmath302 which is a combination of rotations , reflections and scalings such that @xmath303 . we conclude that there are only _ finite types _ of @xmath291 for any fixed @xmath95 .
in fact , the second equality of ( 4.2 ) shows that if there are finite types of @xmath304 , then the types of @xmath291 is also finite
. this observation will be useful in the proof of the uniform convergence of the pointwise formula .
4.3 for the total types of @xmath305 in @xmath5 . in @xmath5.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=28.0% ] in @xmath5.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=38.0% ] in @xmath5.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=28.0% ] in @xmath5.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=38.0% ] the following theorem is an answer of question 2 , which will be proved in the subsequent subsections .
* theorem 4.2 . * _ ( a ) assume @xmath306 .
then the pointwise formula ( 4.1 ) holds with the limit uniformly on @xmath88 .
( b ) conversely , let @xmath307 and the right side of ( 4.1 ) converges uniformly to a continuous function @xmath308 on @xmath88 . then @xmath309 with @xmath310 on @xmath311 .
_ before proving , we remark that it looks that the ( b ) part of this theorem does not involve the whole information of the function @xmath3 , and it has something to do with the existence of harmonic functions with singularities at boundary points ( see more explanation on point singularities in [ bssy ] ) .
in fact , the conclusion is equivalent to that for any @xmath312 with @xmath313 , we have @xmath314 may be an @xmath95-harmonic function with singularity .
however , if there is no multiharmonic function with singularity , for example , the unit interval case , we can say that @xmath306 already .
we will take two steps to prove part ( a ) of theorem 4.2 .
first , we deal with those functions which are local @xmath97-harmonic near @xmath2 with @xmath289 , to get that @xmath315 holds without taking the limit .
then , we prove the result for general functions in @xmath316 .
* lemma 4.3 . *
_ let @xmath2 be a vertex in @xmath276 , @xmath62 be an @xmath97-harmonic function in @xmath148 .
then the following equality holds @xmath317 in particular , @xmath318 .
_ proof_. fix a word @xmath158 with @xmath131 .
note that @xmath319 is a linear combination of monomials @xmath186 .
in fact @xmath320 by comparing the values at @xmath2 when applying @xmath321 on both sides .
thus we have @xmath322 on the other hand , according to ( 3.8 ) , @xmath323 thus , @xmath324 the second equality above comes from the fact that @xmath325 always equal to @xmath84 . from the arbitrariness of @xmath62 ,
if we choose @xmath62 to satisfy @xmath326 in the above equality , this gives @xmath327 for all @xmath19 . by passing @xmath19 to infinity
, we get that @xmath318 .
thus we have proved the lemma .
@xmath228 * remark .
* we use the decomposition of @xmath62 based on the monomials in the above proof , which requires the harmonic extension matrices @xmath328 to be non - degenerate . however , this requirement is not necessary essentially .
in fact , we could alternatively start from an `` easy '' basis , which extends the conclusion to the degenerate cases .
we will give this method in section 6 when discussing the @xmath1 symmetric fractals .
it is interesting that the constant @xmath318 is universal for all @xmath0 symmetric fractals , which is an initial value for the calculations in appendix .
* lemma 4.4 . *
_ let x be a vertex in @xmath298 and @xmath329 , then @xmath330 _ _ proof_. it is obvious that @xmath331 for any @xmath282 with @xmath332 .
so we can apply lemma 4.3 to all points in @xmath333 .
thus we have @xmath334 since for each @xmath335 , @xmath336 belongs to @xmath337 , by a standard inductive argument , we then have @xmath338 hence we have proved the lemma .
@xmath228 now for each @xmath289 , we will define a global function @xmath339 supported in @xmath291 , belonging to @xmath340 , called _ @xmath95-tent function _
, which is piecewise @xmath95-harmonic and for any @xmath306 , it holds that @xmath341 we will define this function by an inductive argument .
in fact , when @xmath342 , we just need to choose @xmath343 , and we have @xmath344 when @xmath278 , first we define @xmath345 it is easy to check that @xmath346 now let @xmath347 where @xmath348 is the local green s function ( see [ kss , s4 ] ) on @xmath305
. we will show that it satisfies both the dirichlet and neumann boundary conditions at the boundary of @xmath305 , and thus could be extended to the whole @xmath11 by zero extension . then by gauss - green s formula , we have @xmath349 more generally , assume we already have constructed the @xmath350-level tent function @xmath351 for vertices @xmath2 in @xmath352 , with the dirichlet boundary condition at @xmath353 , satisfying @xmath354
. we will first define @xmath355 which obviously satisfies that @xmath356 then define @xmath357 where @xmath358 is the local green s function on @xmath291 .
we will show that @xmath339 satisfies both the dirichlet and neumann boundary conditions at @xmath359 , and then extend it to the whole @xmath11 by zero extension .
then @xmath360 thus for @xmath277 , @xmath339 defined using the above recipe will satisfy both the dirichlet and the neumann boundary conditions at the boundary @xmath361 .
the following lemma remains to be proved .
* lemma 4.5 . *
_ let @xmath277 .
suppose we have defined @xmath362 for vertices in @xmath352 , satisfying @xmath363 , with the dirichlet boundary condition holding at @xmath364 .
then the function @xmath339 defined by ( 4.5 ) and ( 4.7 ) satisfies both the dirichlet and neumann boundary conditions at the boundary of @xmath291 .
moreover , the equality ( 4.8 ) holds .
_ _ proof .
_ let @xmath62 be a multiharmonic harmonic function in @xmath365 . by the definition of @xmath366 ,
it is easy to check that @xmath367 where the second equality comes from the assumption of @xmath362 , the third equality is result of lemma 4.4 , and the forth equality follows from the fact that @xmath368 . on the other hand , by using the dirichlet boundary condition of @xmath362 and @xmath339 at the boundary of @xmath291 , and repeatedly using the gauss - green s formula , we have @xmath369 thus we have proved that @xmath370 holds for any @xmath371 , which yields that @xmath372 holds for any @xmath373 by the arbitrariness of @xmath62 , we have proved that @xmath339 satisfies both the dirichlet and neumann boundary conditions at @xmath361 . now for general function @xmath374 , by ( 4.6 ) , using the boundary conditions of @xmath339 at @xmath361 , and by using the gauss - green s formula , we finally prove that @xmath375 * lemma 4.6 . * _ for any @xmath19 , any @xmath289 , it holds that @xmath376 furthermore , for any same type sets @xmath291 and @xmath301 , we have @xmath377 if the @xmath19-level conductances on @xmath291 are proportional to those on @xmath301 .
_ _ proof_. applying the gauss - green s formula to ( 4.8 ) , using the dirichlet boundary condition of @xmath339 at @xmath361 , we have @xmath378 for any @xmath306 . choosing a multiharmonic function @xmath379 with @xmath380 and taking it into the above equality , using lemma 4.4 , we get @xmath381 let @xmath382 and @xmath301 be in same type .
it means there is a mapping @xmath302 which is a combination of rotations , reflections and scalings , satisfying @xmath303 .
it is easy to find that @xmath383 by scaling . hence @xmath384
@xmath228 since there are only finite types of @xmath291 , and for each type , there are only finite subtypes with proportional conductances , we have * corollary 4.7 . * _ let @xmath277 be fixed . for any @xmath19 , any @xmath289 , @xmath385 is uniformly bounded . _ _ proof of theorem 4.2(a)_. applying ( 4.9 ) , lemma 4.6 and corollary 4.7 , we have @xmath386 for some constant @xmath387 , where @xmath388 is the oscillation of @xmath389 in @xmath291 .
since @xmath389 is continuous on @xmath11 , @xmath388 will go to zero uniformly as @xmath19 goes to infinity .
thus we have ( 4.1 ) holds uniformly .
@xmath228 * remark . *
the proof provides that the ratio of the convergence in @xmath315 depends only on the _ modulus of continuity _ of @xmath389 . in this subsection
we will give the proof of the second part of theorem 4.2 .
for a simple set @xmath166 in @xmath11 , we use @xmath390 to denote the space of _ harmonic splines _ , which are harmonic on each @xmath19-level cell in @xmath166 .
for those harmonic splines vanishing at the boundary of @xmath166 , we denote the collection of them by @xmath391 . for any function @xmath392
, there is a unique solution @xmath393 satisfying @xmath394 in fact , for @xmath395 , we have @xmath396 , so that @xmath397 is an injection . comparing the dimension , one can find that @xmath397 is reversible . for convenience , we define @xmath398 the inverse operator of @xmath399 .
it means that for any @xmath392 , @xmath400 and @xmath401 we denote @xmath402 the local green s operator on @xmath166 , i.e. , for any continuous function @xmath308 on @xmath166 , @xmath403 , and satisfies @xmath404 the following lemma shows that @xmath398 will go to @xmath402 as @xmath19 goes to infinity , in some sense .
* lemma 4.8 . * _ for any simple set @xmath166 in @xmath11 , let @xmath405 and @xmath406 .
if @xmath407 converges to @xmath408 uniformly as @xmath19 goes to infinity , then @xmath409 converges to @xmath3 uniformly as @xmath19 goes to infinity .
_ _ proof_. first we will show @xmath410 are equicontinuous and uniformly bounded .
observe that for any function @xmath411 , @xmath412 noticing that @xmath409 satisfies the dirichlet boundary condition at @xmath162 , combining with the estimate @xmath413 , with @xmath414 the effective resistance metric ( see [ ki4 , s4 ] ) between @xmath2 and @xmath282 on a , we have @xmath415 for some constants @xmath416 , which results that @xmath417 since we have @xmath418 uniformly , @xmath419 is uniformly bounded .
so we have @xmath410 are uniformly bounded and equicontinuous .
denote @xmath420 , then @xmath421 are also uniformly bounded and equicontinuous .
moreover , @xmath422 all terms in the sum would converge to @xmath44 uniformly as @xmath19 goes to @xmath423 .
in fact , @xmath424 using the equicontinuous and uniformly boundedness of @xmath421 , we then have @xmath425 . together with the fact that @xmath426 satisfies the dirichlet boundary condition at @xmath162 , it yields the result of lemma 4.8 .
@xmath228 * remark .
* _ we may restate lemma 4.8 as follows .
suppose @xmath427 converges uniformly to a continuous function @xmath308 , then @xmath428 holds uniformly .
_ _ proof of theorem 4.2(b)_. assume we have @xmath429 uniformly on @xmath88 .
then by repeatedly using lemma 4.8 , on any @xmath166 not intersecting the boundary @xmath24 , we have @xmath430 converges uniformly .
so we have @xmath431 converges uniformly to the function @xmath432 .
now we prove @xmath433 .
recall that in lemma 4.3 , we have shown that for any @xmath97-harmonic function @xmath434 , @xmath435 must be some @xmath95-harmonic function , see ( 4.4 ) .
it is not hard to verify that the right side of ( 4.4 ) could go through all @xmath95-harmonic functions .
thus we have an inverse conclusion that for any @xmath95-harmonic function @xmath436 on @xmath166 , there is a @xmath97-harmonic function @xmath437 such that @xmath438 on @xmath439 .
now we apply the above discussion in our proof .
first we have the following equality , @xmath440 thus @xmath441 equals to some harmonic function on @xmath166 . since for each @xmath442 , @xmath443 by repeatlly using the above discussion
, we have that @xmath431 equals to some @xmath95-harmonic function on @xmath166 .
noticing that the space of @xmath95-harmonic functions on @xmath166 is of finite dimension , the uniform limit @xmath432 of @xmath431 is of course a @xmath95-harmonic function .
thus we have @xmath444 , and obviously @xmath445 on @xmath166 . by the arbitrariness of @xmath166 , we finally have proved @xmath445 on @xmath446
we have no idea on how to extend the previous results to other p.c.f . fractals . however , we still have some pointwise calculations of the higher order laplacian in general .
+ the following is an extension of the _ mean value property _ of harmonic functions .
* lemma 5.1 . *
_ let @xmath448 , @xmath449 , and @xmath450 with @xmath451 then there exists a function @xmath452 such that @xmath453 holds for any @xmath89 .
furthermore , if we additionally assume @xmath454 holds for any @xmath455 , then there is a unique such @xmath456 satisfying the @xmath44 boundary condition @xmath457 .
_ _ proof_. assume @xmath458 for some @xmath19 , we now find the function @xmath456 in @xmath459 , the space of continuous functions which are harmonic on each @xmath19-level cell of @xmath11 .
in fact , for any @xmath460 , we have @xmath461 it is easy to check that the map @xmath462 is injective from the space @xmath459 modulo constants to @xmath463 . additionally , by the gauss - green s formula , it always holds @xmath464 thus the map is a bijection from @xmath459 modulo constants to a @xmath465-dimensional subspace of @xmath463 by a counting dimension argument .
thus , we have proved the existence of function @xmath456 satisfying ( 5.1 ) .
if we additionally assume @xmath466 , then we have @xmath467 for any @xmath468 .
thus @xmath469 which yields that @xmath470 , since @xmath471 is an inner product on @xmath472 modulo constants .
so there exists a unique @xmath456 satisfying ( 5.1 ) with the dirichlet boundary condition . @xmath228
* theorem 5.2 .
( calculation of @xmath101 ) * _ let @xmath473 , @xmath449 and @xmath474 .
assume the following condition holds _
_ for some constant @xmath476
. then @xmath477_m}\mu_{[w]_m})^{-1}\sum_{j=1}^{l}a_jf(f_{[w]_m}y_j)\ ] ] uniformly on @xmath11 for any function @xmath85 . here
@xmath22 is an infinite word corresponding to @xmath2 and @xmath478_m}k$ ] denotes the according @xmath19-cell containing @xmath2 for each @xmath299 .
_ _ proof_. according to lemma 5.1 , there exists a piecewise harmonic spline @xmath456 satisfying ( 5.1 ) with the dirichlet boundary condition . using the gauss - green s formula , for each @xmath85 ,
@xmath479 consider a @xmath436 with @xmath480 , then @xmath481 , and so @xmath482 . by using a scaling of the identity ( 5.2 ) , for each @xmath299
, we get @xmath483_m}(y_j)=\int_k \phi\delta_\mu ( f\circ f_{[w]_m})d\mu = r_{[w]_m}\mu_{[w]_m}\int_k \phi(\delta_\mu f)\circ f_{[w]_m}d\mu.\ ] ] taking the limit as @xmath484 , we have proved the theorem .
@xmath228 + now we turn to the higher order case .
* lemma 5.3 . *
_ let @xmath448 , @xmath485 and @xmath486 with @xmath487 holding for any @xmath488 , then there exists a function @xmath489 with the dirichlet boundary condition , such that @xmath490 holds for any @xmath491 . _ _
proof_. for @xmath342 , it is just what lemma 5.1 says , so we get the initial function @xmath492 .
now , we assert that we could choose @xmath493 where @xmath494 is the green s function solving the dirichlet problem of the poisson equation on @xmath11 . in fact ,
assume lemma 5.3 holds for @xmath495 case , then @xmath496 , @xmath497 using the gauss - green s formula , by the assumption of @xmath498 , and using the dirichlet boundary condition of @xmath499 , @xmath489 , we have @xmath500 holds for any @xmath501 . noticing that @xmath502 goes through the whole space @xmath65
, we could get @xmath503 thus by using the gauss - green s formula again , we have @xmath504 + * theorem 5.4 . ( calculation of @xmath447 ) * _ let @xmath473 , @xmath449 , and @xmath450 .
assume the following condition holds @xmath505 for some constant @xmath476
. then @xmath506_m}\mu_{[w]_m})^{-n}\sum_{i=1}^{l}a_jf(f_{[w]_m}y_j),\ ] ] uniformly on @xmath11 for any function @xmath507 .
_ _ proof
. _ by lemma 5.3 , there exists a function @xmath489 satisfying ( 5.3 ) with the dirichlet boundary condition . combining it with the gauss - green s formula ,
we get @xmath508 let @xmath436 be any function with @xmath509 .
then @xmath481 and thus @xmath510 .
scaling the identity ( 5.4 ) , for each @xmath299 , we have @xmath483_m}(y_j)=\int_k \phi_n\delta_\mu^n ( f\circ f_{[w]_m})d\mu=(r_{[w]_m}\mu_{[w]_m})^n\int_k \phi_n(\delta_\mu^n f)\circ f_{[w]_m}d\mu.\ ] ] taking the limit as @xmath484 , we have proved the theorem .
@xmath228 * remark .
* from the proof of the theorem , it is easy to find that the ratio of the uniform convergence depends only on the modulus of continuity of @xmath7 as stated in section 4 .
in this section , we manage to extend the previous results to the @xmath1 symmetric p.c.f .
( actually it could be extended to those fully symmetric p.c.f .
fractals with regular harmonic structure . ) in this case , @xmath511 , @xmath512 , @xmath513 for @xmath514 , and we denote @xmath515 .
similar to the previous discussion , throughout this section , we assume @xmath516 it is well known that the _ vicsek set _ @xmath517 and the _ tetrahedral sierpinski gasket _ @xmath518 are two typical @xmath1 symmetric examples . consider a square with corners @xmath519 and center @xmath520 .
let @xmath521 be contractive mappings with ratio @xmath120 and fixed points @xmath127 .
the generated invariant set is called the vicsek set .
the fractal and the second step graph is as shown in fig .
it could be naturally extended to the @xmath95-branch vicsek set @xmath522 .
we omit it here .
please see [ z ] and [ csw ] for the spectral analysis of the laplacians on this family of sets .
@xmath518 is the fractal satisfying @xmath523 where @xmath524 and @xmath519 are the four vertices of a tetrahedron .
.,title="fig:",width=158 ] .,title="fig:",width=158 ] .,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] .,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ]
firstly , the results in section 4 could be extended to the @xmath1 symmetric case .
noticing that the harmonic extension matrices may be degenerate , for example , in the case of @xmath517 , to avoid the inconvenience of the definition of monomials , we will use the `` easy '' basis @xmath525 instead , which was introduced in [ su ] . the argument below
provides another proof of lemma 4.3 , in the @xmath1 version , with suitable modifications . here , the notations @xmath142 , @xmath291 , the boundary of simple sets @xmath162 and the renormalized graph laplacian @xmath397 are same as the previous ones .
+ * definition 6.1 . *
_ for @xmath191 , @xmath526 , define @xmath527 _ satisfying @xmath528 it is easy to check that @xmath529 form an `` easy '' basis of @xmath96 with the dimension @xmath530 . by the symmetry , we denote @xmath531 since @xmath532 , for @xmath533 , it is obvious that @xmath534 more generally , for any @xmath535 and any @xmath536 , we have @xmath537 which results that @xmath538 * lemma 6.2.(matching condition ) * _ let @xmath2 be a vertex in @xmath88 , @xmath62 be any @xmath97-harmonic function in @xmath148
. then for any @xmath536 , the following identity holds , @xmath539 _ _ proof .
_ the matching condition at @xmath2 is @xmath540 for each summand above , by scaling , we have @xmath541 where @xmath158 with @xmath131 .
thus we can rewrite the matching condition into ( 6.1 ) , using the fact that @xmath542 and @xmath511 . @xmath228
* lemma 6.3 . *
_ let @xmath2 be a vertex in @xmath276 , @xmath62 be any @xmath97-harmonic function in @xmath148 .
then the following equality holds , @xmath543 where @xmath544 is a sequence of constants satisfying @xmath545 with initial value @xmath546 , @xmath547 , @xmath548 . _
_ in fact , ( 6.2 ) follows from a transformation of the matching condition ( 6.1 ) .
when @xmath549 , ( 6.1 ) is just @xmath550 , and for convenience , we write it as @xmath551 when @xmath552 , ( 6.1 ) becomes @xmath553 which yields that @xmath554 recursively , for @xmath555 , ( 6.1 ) becomes @xmath556 so that @xmath557 thus , we have @xmath558 multiplying the both sides of the above equality with @xmath559 , we finally get @xmath560 having this lemma , the @xmath1 version of lemma 4.3 , we could follow the same steps to prove the pointwise formula of @xmath561 as shown in section 4 for @xmath1 symmetric fractals .
the argument is very similar , so we omit it . thus question @xmath562 still has a positive answer in @xmath1 symmetric case .
secondly , we turn to question @xmath84 . for simplicity
, we use the simplest @xmath1 fractal @xmath518 as an example to show how to deal with the @xmath1 symmetric fractals . here
we should require that all the harmonic extension matrices ( differ only by permutations ) to be nondegenerate .
it is easy to check that for @xmath1 symmetric fractals , the third and fourth eignvalues coincide , which we still denote by @xmath112 .
thus , we would view the related two derivatives as two components of the `` transverse derivative '' .
we then define all the four types of derivatives as introduced in [ s3 ] .
the _ normal derivative _ of a function @xmath3 at the boundary point @xmath127 is defined as @xmath563 ( cyclic notation @xmath564 ) , providing the limit exists , while the _ transverse derivatives _ at @xmath127 are defined as @xmath565 providing the limits exist .
of course , the definitions of these derivatives could also be localized to all vertices .
we omit the details .
the following is the definition of _ monomials _ on @xmath518 . * definition 6.4 . * _ fix a boundary point @xmath127 .
the monomials @xmath180 for @xmath566 and @xmath182 in @xmath96 are the multiharmonic functions satisfying @xmath567 _ the @xmath568 and @xmath569 are symmetric under rotations and reflections which fix @xmath127 , while @xmath570 are skew - symmetric under the reflection @xmath571 and @xmath572 are skew - symmetric under the reflection @xmath573 , where @xmath574 denote the reflection which preserves @xmath127 and @xmath575 and permutes the other two boundary points . the self - similar identities ( 3.1)-(3.3 ) for @xmath0 symmetric cases still hold for @xmath518 under suitable modification .
we keep using the notations @xmath576 analogous to @xmath0 symmetric cases , we can define the local monomials .
we omit the details .
still we hope to decompose the multiharmonic functions as in theorem 3.5 .
denote @xmath206 the rotations in the @xmath1 group with @xmath207 ( cyclic notation ) .
let @xmath136 and @xmath221 .
define @xmath577 to be a function satisfying @xmath578 for @xmath214 . for @xmath579 ,
let @xmath580 be the local symmetry in @xmath155 , which is @xmath581 on each component @xmath18 with @xmath582 .
now , for any @xmath211 , we could write @xmath583 with @xmath584 it is easy to check that for @xmath585 , @xmath586 we need the definition of _ weak tangent _ analogous to definition 3.7 .
* definition 6.5.*(@xmath518 ) _ let @xmath3 be a function which is continuous in a neighborhood of a vertex @xmath136 .
an @xmath97-harmonic function @xmath62 on @xmath155 is said to be a weak tangent of order @xmath232 to @xmath3 at @xmath2 if @xmath587 and @xmath588 _
now we could prove analogous results as stated in theorem 3.8 , for @xmath518 , providing that all the numbers @xmath589 are not equal to @xmath44 .
the method is similar , except that when discussing the transverse derivatives , we need to look at the values @xmath590 and @xmath591 instead of the left side of @xmath592 . for the calculations of @xmath589 , see appendix .
as an appendix of this paper , we focus on the calculation of @xmath593 , @xmath594 and @xmath194 , the boundary values of the monomials @xmath595
. we will mainly discuss the @xmath0 symmetric fractals .
the most typical example @xmath5 has been well studied in [ nsty ] , where an iterated calculation of the values as well as the derivatives of @xmath595 at the boundary were given . however , their method is indirect , since it involves the boundary values and inner products of functions in the `` easy '' basis , and need to transform data from the `` easy '' basis to our `` monomial '' basis .
here we provide a new algorithm , which is more direct and shorter , using which , we could calculate @xmath193 and @xmath194 on some other examples , including @xmath118,@xmath119 .
moreover , with some suitable modification , our algorithm will still be valid on @xmath1 symmetric fractals .
we will explain it on @xmath518 .
our approach is based on the relation of the laplacian and the graph laplacian of multihamonic functions , established in lemma 4.3 .
taking @xmath596 in ( 4.4 ) , we get a recursion relation , @xmath597 holding at all vertices @xmath598 for all @xmath335 . here in the second line of ( 7.1 ) , we use the identity @xmath599 .
thus , assuming we already have the values @xmath600 , ( 7.1 ) as well as the self - similar identities ( 3.1)-(3.3 ) form a system of equations to calculate @xmath601 from the values @xmath602 .
we do use this idea to solve the @xmath603 cases . also , we need a notation of _ infinite dimensional semi - circulant matrices _ @xmath608 . for example , @xmath609 , has @xmath610 for @xmath611 and @xmath612 for @xmath613 .
it is easy to check @xmath614 for @xmath611 , and the multiplications among these matices are commutable .
we will need a linear operator @xmath615 on such matrices defined by @xmath616 where @xmath107 is the scaling constant of the laplacian defined before .
first , for @xmath200 , by considering the symmetry , ( 7.2 ) becomes @xmath619 for @xmath335 , where we denote @xmath620 .
in addition , for @xmath621 , we have @xmath622 we could rewrite the above identities in matrix notation , @xmath623 by multiplying them with @xmath624 on both sides , where @xmath625 is the infinite matrix defined with @xmath626 for @xmath611 and @xmath627 for @xmath613 . eliminating @xmath625 , we get @xmath628 which results that @xmath629 .
so we get the recursion relation for @xmath593 . for @xmath202 , we can write ( 7.2 ) into @xmath630 for @xmath191 , where we denote @xmath631 .
thus by multiplying both sides with @xmath624 , we have @xmath632 with some calculation , we get @xmath633 which gives the recursion relation of @xmath594 . thus , to prove that @xmath636 is determined by ( 7.4 ) uniquely
, we only need to prove the equations @xmath641 has a unique solution @xmath642 , where @xmath643 is the symmetry that fixes @xmath127 and interchanges the other two vertices of @xmath24 .
first we need to look at the equation @xmath644 it is not hard to check that @xmath645 is the unique solution of ( 7.6 ) , where @xmath436 is the harmonic function with the same boundary values as those of @xmath646 , from which , one can find that @xmath647 now suppose @xmath3 is a solution of ( 7.5 ) .
write @xmath648 .
it is easy to check @xmath649 , and @xmath650 .
moreover , by using ( 7.7 ) and @xmath651 , the relation @xmath652 implies @xmath653 this could be simplified into @xmath654 since @xmath650 and @xmath655 .
thus we have @xmath656 , which implies that @xmath657 , and thus @xmath658 on @xmath659 .
the first level graph of @xmath118 contains 7 inner vertices , and we take the following notations @xmath660 the values of the functions @xmath661 on @xmath659 for @xmath662 are shown in figure 7.1 . analogous to @xmath663 ,
let @xmath664 be the infinite dimensional semi - circulant matrices generated by @xmath665 . and @xmath666 on @xmath659 .
( the values of @xmath667 are similar to those of @xmath668.),title="fig:",width=170 ] and @xmath666 on @xmath659 .
( the values of @xmath667 are similar to those of @xmath668.),title="fig:",width=170 ] ( 0,0 ) ( -11.7,-0)@xmath593 ( -6.85,0)@xmath593 ( -8.7,-0.3)@xmath669 ( -10.15,-0.3)@xmath669 ( -9.4,1.5)@xmath670 ( -11.3,1.3)@xmath671 ( -7.6,1.3)@xmath671 ( -8.3,2.6)@xmath672 ( -10.55,2.6)@xmath672 ( -5.05,-0)@xmath194 ( -0.25,0)@xmath673 ( -2.37,-0.3)@xmath674 ( -3.53,-0.3)@xmath675 ( -2.58,1.5)@xmath44 ( -4.65,1.3)@xmath676 ( -0.95,1.3)@xmath677 ( -1.7,2.6)@xmath678 ( -4.1,2.6)@xmath679 ( -9.3,3.0)@xmath680 ( -2.7,3.0)@xmath680 ( -10.7,0.4)@xmath681 ( -4.1,0.4)@xmath681 ( -7.8,0.4)@xmath682 ( -1.2,0.4)@xmath682 ( -9.3,0.4)@xmath683 ( -2.7,0.4)@xmath683 ( -8.5,1.7)@xmath684 ( -1.9,1.7)@xmath684 ( -10,1.7)@xmath685 ( -3.4,1.7)@xmath685 the recursion relations of @xmath608 can be solved from the above equations by eliminating @xmath664 . in matrix notation ,
the solutions are @xmath692 we can thus give the recursion relations of @xmath589 by using @xmath693 and @xmath124 .
@xmath694 with initial data @xmath618 . and @xmath666 on @xmath659 .
( the values of @xmath667 are similar to those of @xmath668.),title="fig:",width=170 ] and @xmath666 on @xmath659 .
( the values of @xmath667 are similar to those of @xmath668.),title="fig:",width=170 ] ( 0,0 ) ( -11.7,1.2)@xmath593 ( -6.85,1.2)@xmath593 ( -12,3.7)@xmath698 ( -6.85,3.7)@xmath698 ( -10.5,3.95)@xmath699 ( -8.4,3.95)@xmath699 ( -11.3,2.55)@xmath700 ( -7.6,2.55)@xmath700 ( -10.6,1)@xmath701 ( -8.4,1)@xmath701 ( -9.45,-0.2)@xmath702 ( -5.1,1.2)@xmath194 ( -0.25,1.2)@xmath673 ( -5.4,3.7)@xmath703 ( -0.25,3.7)@xmath704 ( -4.0,3.95)@xmath705 ( -1.8,3.95)@xmath706 ( -4.7,2.55)@xmath707 ( -1,2.55)@xmath708 ( -4,1)@xmath709 ( -1.8,1)@xmath710 ( -2.55,-0.2)@xmath44 ( -9.25,4.1)@xmath680 ( -2.65,4.1)@xmath680 ( -10.65,1.7)@xmath681 ( -4.05,1.7)@xmath681 ( -7.8,1.7)@xmath682 ( -1.2,1.7)@xmath682 ( -9.3,0.7)@xmath683 ( -2.7,0.7)@xmath683 ( -10.75,3.2)@xmath684 ( -4.15,3.2)@xmath684 ( -7.85,3.2)@xmath685 ( -1.25,3.2)@xmath685 by eliminating @xmath696 from the above equations , we get the following recursion relations of @xmath663 in matrix notation , @xmath718 similarly , substituting @xmath719 , we have the recursion relations in the explicit form @xmath720 for convenience , denote @xmath721 and let @xmath722 denote the infinite dimensional semi - circulant matrices generated by @xmath723 .
see the values of @xmath668 and @xmath666 on @xmath659 in fig .
we should point out that the identity ( 7.2 ) still holds for @xmath518 , since the harmonic extension matrices are nondegenerate for @xmath518 and hence the argument for proving lemma 4.3 remains to be valid .
( 0,0 ) ( -5.3,1.2)@xmath593 ( -2.3,0.3)@xmath593 ( -0.7,2.4)@xmath593 ( -4,2.9)@xmath699 ( -2.7,2.4)@xmath699 ( -1.8,3.3)@xmath699 ( -2.77,4.2)@xmath44 ( -4,0.6)@xmath724 ( -3.2,1.7)@xmath724 ( -1.5,1.4)@xmath724 by eliminating @xmath722 in the above matrix equations , we could solve the recursion relations of @xmath608 as follows , in the matrix notation , @xmath731 using the fact that @xmath732 , the recursion relations of @xmath589 in the explicit form are @xmath733 to get the initial data , we need to look at lemma 4.3 again .
in fact , we have @xmath734 for @xmath598 , for any @xmath735 with @xmath736 .
this gives that @xmath737 .
thus we have initial data @xmath738 in addition , it is easy to check that @xmath739 .
table 7.1 - 7.4 present numerical computations of @xmath193 and @xmath194 for @xmath118 , @xmath119 and @xmath518 , respectively .
( we are grateful to mr .
wei wei for providing an effective program . ) for @xmath118 and @xmath119 , it is easy to find that @xmath195 behave similar to geometric progressions when @xmath711 is large enough , with the reciprocal of common ratio @xmath740 for @xmath118 and @xmath741 for @xmath119 . as for @xmath518
, it is quite similar to @xmath5 case , calculated in [ nsty ] .
all @xmath593 and @xmath194 take positive values , and @xmath594 behaves like a geometric progression when @xmath742 , with the reciprocal of common ratio being @xmath743 .
in fact , for each case , the above mentioned reciprocal of ratio is the opposite of the least eigenvalue of @xmath744 , corresponding to an eigenfunction , which is symmetric with respect to the reflection fixing @xmath745 with both the value and the normal derivative at @xmath745 vanishing .
an explanation of this phenomenon comes from a slight generalization of theorem 2.9 in [ nsty ] ( for @xmath5 ) involving a rather detailed knowledge of the description of eigenfunctions of @xmath744 by the spectral decimation .
in fact , the natural of eigenvalues and eigenfunctions could be known explicitly via the method of spectral decimation for some fully symmetric p.c.f .
fractals(see [ fs , mt , sh1-sh2 , st , t1 ] ) .
we refer to the reader to find the spectral decimation recipes for @xmath118 , @xmath119 and @xmath518 in [ ds ] , [ bcdehkmst ] and [ fs ] respectively , using which , we could verify that @xmath746 is the eigenvalue of @xmath744 on @xmath118 with eigenfunction shown in fig .
7.4(a ) , @xmath747 is the eigenvalue on @xmath119 with eigenfunction shown in fig .
7.4(b ) , @xmath748 is the second neumann eigenvalue on @xmath518 with eigenfunction shown in fig .
7.4(c ) as the @xmath5 case .
[ bcdehkmst ] n. bajorin , t. chen , a. dagan , c. emmons , m. hussein , m. khalil , p. mody , b. steinhurst and a. teplyaev , _ vibration spectra of finitely ramified , symmetric fractals .
_ fractals , vol . 16 ( 2008 ) , no . 3 , 243 - 258 .
+ [ bssy ] n. ben - gal , a. shaw - krauss , r.s .
strichartz and c. young , _ calculus on the sierpinski gasket .
point singularities , eigenfunctions , and normal derivatives of the heat kernel . _ trans .
358 ( 2006 ) , no .
9 , 3883 - 3936 .
+ [ cq ] s. cao and h. qiu , _ some properties of the derivatives on sierpinski gasket type fractals . _ in submission .
+ [ csw ] s. constantin , r.s .
strichartz and m. wheeler , _ analysis of the laplacian and spectral operators on the vicsek set .
( 2011 ) , no . 1 , 1 - 44 . + [ drs ] j.l .
degrado , l.g .
rogers , r.s .
strichartz , _ gradients of laplacian eigenfunctions on the sierpinski gasket .
( 2009 ) , no . 2 , 531 - 540 .
+ [ ds ] s. drenning and r.s .
strichartz , _ spectral decimation on hambly s homogeneous hierarchical gasket .
_ illinois j. math .
53 ( 2009 ) , 915 - 937 .
+ [ dsv ] k. dalrymple , r.s .
strichartz and j.p .
vinson , _ fractal differential equations on the sierpinski gasket .
_ j. fourier anal .
appl . 5 ( 1999 ) , 203 - 284 .
+ [ fs ] m. fukushima and t. shima , _ on a spectral analysis for the sierpinski gasket .
_ potential anal . 1 ( 1992 ) 1 - 35 .
+ [ ki1 ] j. kigami , _ a harmonic calculus on the sierpinski spaces .
j. appl . math . 6
( 1989 ) , 259 - 290 .
+ [ ki2 ] j. kigami , _ harmonic calculus on p.c.f . self - similar sets . _
( 1993 ) , 721 - 755 .
+ [ ki3 ] j. kigami , _ harmonic metric and dirichlet form on the sierpinski gasket , in `` asymptotic problems in probability theory : stochastic models and diffusions on fractals , sanda / kyoto , 1990 , '' _ pitman res .
notes math .
201 - 218 , longman , harlow , 1993 .
+ [ ki4 ] j. kigami , _ effective resistances for harmonic structures on p.c.f .
self - similar sets . _ math .
soc . 115 ( 1994 ) , 291 - 303 . + [ ki5 ] j. kigami , _ analysis on fractals . _ cambridge university press , 2001 . + [ ku ] s. kusuoka , _ dirichlet forms on fractals and products of random matrices . _ publ .
inst . math .
sci . 25 ( 1989 ) , 659 - 680 . + [ kss ] j. kigami , d.r .
sheldon and r.s .
strichartz , _
green s functions on fractals .
_ fractal 8 ( 2000 ) , no . 4 , 385 - 402 .
+ [ mt ] l. malozemov and a. teplyaev , _ self - similarity , operators and dynamics .
geom . 6:3 ( 2003 ) , 201 - 218 .
+ [ nsty ] j. needleman , r.s .
strichartz , a. teplyaev and p. yung , _ calculus on the sierpinski gasket .
i. polynomials , exponentials and power series .
_ j. funct .
215 ( 2004 ) , no . 2 , 290 - 340 .
+ [ sh1 ] t. shima , _ on eigenvalue problems for the random walks on the sierpinski pre - gaskets .
_ japan j. indust .
( 1991 ) , 127 - 141 .
+ [ sh2 ] t. shima , _ on eigenvalue problems for laplacians on p.c.f .
self - similar sets .
_ japan j. indust .
( 1996 ) , 1 - 23 .
+ [ s1 ] r.s .
strichartz , _ piecewise linear wavelets on sierpinski gasket type fractals . _ j. fourier .
appl . 3 ( 1997 ) , 387 - 416 .
+ [ s2 ] r.s .
strichartz , _ some properties of laplacians on fractals .
_ j. funct .
164 ( 1999 ) , 181 - 208 .
+ [ s3 ] r.s .
strichartz , _ taylor approximations on sierpinski gasket type fractals .
_ j. funct .
174 ( 2000 ) , 76 - 127 .
+ [ s4 ] r. s. strichartz , _ differential equations on fractals : a tutorial . _ princeton university press , 2006 .
+ [ st ] r.s .
strichartz and a. teplyaev , _ spectral analysis on infinite sierpinski fractafolds .
_ j. anal .
( 2012 ) , 255 - 297 .
+ [ su ] r.s .
strichartz and m. usher , _ splines on fractals .
129 ( 2000 ) , 331 - 360 .
+ [ t1 ] a. teplyaev , _ spectral analysis on infinite sierpinski gaskets .
_ j. funct .
159:2 ( 1998 ) , 537 - 567 .
+ [ t2 ] a. teplyaev , _
gradients on fractals .
_ j. funct .
174 ( 2000 ) , 128 - 154 .
+ [ z ] d. zhou , _ spectral analysis on laplacians on the vicsek set . _ pac .
241 ( 2009 ) , no . 2 , 369 - 398 . | we study higher order tangents and higher order laplacians on p.c.f . self - similar sets with fully symmetric structures , such as @xmath0 or @xmath1 symmetric fractals .
firstly , let @xmath2 be a vertex point in the graphs that approximate the fractal , we prove that for any @xmath3 defined near @xmath2 , the higher oder weak tangent of @xmath3 at @xmath2 , if exists , is the uniform limit of local multiharmonic functions that agree with @xmath3 in some sense near @xmath2 .
secondly , we prove that the higher order laplacian on a fractal can be expressible as a renormalized uniform limit of higher order graph laplacians on the graphs that approximate the fractal .
the main technical tool is the theory of local multiharmonic functions and local monomials analogous to @xmath4 .
the results in this paper are closely related to the theory of local taylor approximations , splines and entire analytic functions .
some of our results can be extended to general p.c.f .
fractals . in appendix of the paper ,
we provide a recursion algorithm for the exact calculations of the boundary values of the monomials for @xmath0 or @xmath1 symmetric fractals , which is shorter and more direct than the previous work on the sierpinski gasket .
[ multiblock footnote omitted ] corresponding author . ] |
the defining property of a bose - einstein condensate is the macroscopic occupation of a single one - particle quantum state @xcite , a condition often referred to a off - diagonal long range order .
even though bose - einstein condensation has been long known to exist in systems such as superfluid @xmath0he , the off - diagonal long range order itself was inaccessible to direct experimental verification .
the achievement of bose - einstein condensation in dilute alkali gases @xcite , however , has revived interest in such direct experimental access .
indeed , after a number of theoretical studies @xcite , it has become possible to demonstrate off - diagonal long range order as made manifest by an interference experiment @xcite and that finding has been confirmed by excellent agreement between experiment and theory @xcite .
the ability of a bose - einstein condensate to produce an interference pattern of high visibility is closely related to the first order coherence of an optical laser beam .
more recently , two additional experiments have also explored certain aspects of the second @xcite and third order coherence @xcite of a trapped bose condensed gas .
it is therefore the aim of this paper to extend the theory of optical coherence @xcite to the description of trapped dilute bose gases .
our main focus will be on first and second order coherence . the preferred tools to study coherence are correlation functions .
while first order coherence relies on the properties of the reduced single - particle density matrix , which are expressed in the first order correlation function , second order coherence depends mainly on density correlations . here
, the strong short range repulsion between interacting atoms adds interesting new aspects to the discussion of atomic coherence , not present in its optical predecessor .
density correlations are an important object of study , of course , even apart from their bearing on coherence .
the paper is organized as follows .
we introduce in sec .
[ correlations ] appropriate first and second order correlation functions , which are then used in sec . [ coherence ] to define coherence .
it is the aim of the remainder of the paper to calculate these correlation functions for an externally trapped bose gas . in most of our explicit calculations
we assume a three - dimensional harmonic trapping potential and evaluate our results in the thermodynamic limit , i.e. , we will not account for effects due to a finite atom number .
this restriction is justified by the large number of atoms @xmath1 in recent experiments .
we thereby show that coherence is not only a function of temperature and chemical potential but also of the local position of the atoms .
we consider first in sec .
[ idealgas ] the case of an ideal bose gas .
this allows us to study some basic aspects of the problem and in particular the applicability of a local density approximation .
atomic interactions are added in sec .
[ interactinggas ] .
the main modifications are brought about by the existence of quasi - particle like excitations and by the strong short range repulsion between the atoms . in sec .
[ coherenceprop ] we discuss the coherence properties that follow from the correlation functions calculated earlier .
we also comment on the aforementioned measurements of higher order coherence @xcite and a previous theoretical interpretation @xcite .
we summarize our conclusions in sec .
[ conclusion ] .
we describe the atoms by a quantum field @xmath2 which obeys the equal - time commutation relations @xmath3&= & \delta({\bf r}-{\bf r}^\prime)\\ \lbrack\hat\psi({\bf r},t),\hat\psi({\bf r}^\prime , t)\rbrack&=&0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in general , physical properties of the gas can be expressed in terms of correlation functions , i.e. , expectation values of the field operators of the type @xmath4 here , a description of the dynamics using the heisenberg picture has been tacitly assumed .
however , we shall restrict ourselves to discussing spatial correlations at thermal equilibrium and at a fixed time .
we therefore omit further mention of the time arguments .
temporal correlations have been discussed recently in the context of condensate phase fluctuations @xcite . for later convenience
we introduce a special notation for the correlation functions @xmath5 the first order correlation function @xmath6 contains the same information as the reduced one - particle density matrix which furnishes the expectation values of one - particle observables like the momentum or position density .
the formal relation between first order correlation function and reduced one - particle density matrix is given by @xmath7 .
the first order correlation function can alternatively be expressed in terms of the wigner function @xmath8 which is a quantum mechanical analog of a classical single - particle phase space distribution .
the connection between the quantum mechanical correlation function and statistical mechanics is indeed illustrated by the fourier transform relation @xmath9 in contrast , the second order correlation function @xmath10 expresses the joint probability of detecting two different atoms at the locations @xmath11 and @xmath12 respectively .
its connection with the density correlation function is given by @xmath13 it is because the function @xmath14 is defined as the average of a normally ordered product of field operators , that it expresses the correlation of distinct pairs of atoms .
the delta function contribution in eq .
( [ ncorr ] ) represents by contrast the autocorrelation of individual atoms .
discussions of the coherence properties of fields are most conveniently phrased in terms of factorization of their correlation functions @xcite .
the autocorrelation contribution in eq .
( [ ncorr ] ) however stands in the way of any rigorous factorization of the density correlation into a product of functions of @xmath11 and @xmath12 .
we shall therefore concentrate on discussing the normally ordered correlation function @xmath10 which can indeed meet the factorization condition under suitable physical circumstances . in the optical context coherence
refers to a state of the system with interference properties that are as close as possible to those of a precisely defined classical field . in more technical terms ,
successive orders of coherence can be described by means of factorization conditions imposed upon a succession of field correlation functions .
the analog of @xmath15-th order coherence for the atomic field would require all normally ordered correlation functions of order @xmath16 to factorize into a form @xmath17 i.e. , into products of the same complex valued function @xmath18 .
if the field were in a pure coherent state , the factors @xmath18 could be regarded as field - expectation values @xmath19 .
this identification , however , is by no means necessary to secure the factorizations of eq .
( [ qocoherence ] ) .
it would even contradict the strict conservation of the total atom number . to identify the function @xmath18 we begin by considering first order coherence , which secures the maximum effects of intensity interference between
spatially separated parts of the system . in this sense ,
perfect first order coherence @xmath20 with @xmath21 will hold if all atoms occupy the same one - particle state @xmath22 . here
@xmath23 denotes the total atom number of the system .
this definition is an idealization of the penrose and onsager definition of bose - einstein condensation @xcite which requires the reduced one - particle density matrix to have a single macroscopic eigenvalue .
the function @xmath18 can thus be introduced without breaking the gauge symmetry associated with the conservation of total atom number .
the modulus of @xmath18 can be reexpressed in terms of the first order correlation function as @xmath24 in addition to the factorization of @xmath25 , perfect second order coherence implies the factorization condition
@xmath26 so that @xmath27 first order coherence does not , of course , require second order coherence to hold .
it does , however , imply a weaker factorization property of the function @xmath14 @xcite which includes the statement @xmath28 , only to an accuracy of order @xmath29 .
in fact , any real atomic system can exhibit coherence only in an approximate way . in order to define a local measure of coherence
we introduce correlation functions which are normalized to attain unit modulus in the case of perfect coherence .
the degree of first order coherence , in this sense , is expressed by @xmath30 while @xmath31 is a certain measure of second order coherence . in the language of a classical field theory @xmath32
characterizes local fluctuations of the phase of the complex field amplitude , while @xmath33 is related to fluctuations of its modulus .
the most important property of @xmath32 is its relation to the contrast achievable in an interference experiment @xcite .
the function @xmath33 , on the other hand , expresses the tendency of atoms either to cluster or to remain spatially separated . in many experimental contexts
, it will be difficult , to collect enough data to determine the dependence of the correlation functions on the two coordinates @xmath11 and @xmath12 .
it may then be simpler to measure volume integrated correlation functions @xmath34 in which a spatial integration over the mean coordinate has been performed . in condensed matter physics , for example , scattering experiments
are often used to obtain information about the volume integrated second order correlation function .
we define normalized versions of these functions @xmath35 which can also be interpreted as weighted volume averages of the normalized correlation functions of eqs .
( [ g1localdef ] ) and ( [ g2localdef ] )
. it will be the aim of the following sections to calculate the correlation functions we have defined for trapped dilute bose gases at finite temperatures .
the main emphasis will be put on systems that are large enough to allow a local density approximation .
the basic concepts for calculating the correlation functions of a trapped gas are most easily described for ideal gases with temperatures above the critical temperature .
the presence of a bose - einstein condensate at temperatures below the critical temperature gives rise to additional features which will be discussed in sec .
[ belowtc ] .
the influence of atomic interactions on both uncondensed and condensed gases will be later dealt with in sec .
[ interactinggas ] . in the simplest case
, we consider an ideal bose gas at temperature @xmath37 trapped by an external potential @xmath38 . in the grand canonical ensemble
different one - particle energy eigenstates @xmath39 of the trapping potential are populated independently . as a result we can write @xmath40 the statistical independence
we have assumed for the mode occupations would not , on the other hand , hold precisely for a canonical ensemble , i.e. , a system with a fixed total atom number . however , the error in the correlation function induced thereby is only of the order @xmath29 and can be neglected for large systems .
the occupation fluctuations characteristic of the grand canonical ensemble make the last line of eq .
( [ g2ideal ] ) vanish .
the second order correlation functions can then be written as @xmath41 the second term of @xmath14 or @xmath33 is a quantum statistical exchange term .
it manifests a tendency of bosonic atoms to cluster together . in the case of fermions
this term would have a negative sign reflecting the influence of the pauli exclusion principle .
since we may freely use the grand canonical ensemble at temperatures above @xmath36 , we need only determine the first order correlation functions @xmath6 and @xmath42 .
furthermore , no condensate exists in this regime and the normalized correlation functions have the limiting values @xmath43 in the following we compute the length scale of @xmath44 over which the correlation functions decrease . as a first step we calculate the first order correlation function for the case of a spherical harmonic oscillator potential @xmath45 with angular trap frequency @xmath46 .
we therefore occupy the harmonic oscillator states in eq .
( [ g1ideal ] ) with a bose - einstein distribution , so that @xmath47 with the inverse temperature @xmath48 , the fugacity @xmath49 , and the chemical potential @xmath50 . the energies @xmath51 have the zero point energy , @xmath52 , removed in order to limit the fugacity to values between zero and one , as in a homogeneous gas . if the summand of eq .
( [ g10be ] ) is expanded in powers of @xmath53 , the remaining sum over the state indices @xmath54 can be compactly expressed in terms of the single - particle propagator @xmath55 for motion governed by the harmonic oscillator hamiltonian , @xmath56 .
we obtain @xmath57 where @xmath58\ ] ] is derived from the green s function for the three - dimensional harmonic oscillator @xcite .
the fugacity @xmath53 must be determined self - consistently by using the relation @xcite @xmath59 in order to insure the proper total atom number @xmath23 .
a considerable simplification can be achieved if the energy spacing of the trap levels is much smaller than the thermal energy , i.e. , @xmath60 . in that case
@xmath61 reduces to @xmath62\ ] ] and the sum for @xmath25 can be written in the form @xmath63/2}{k_bt } \right]^k \,\exp\left[-\pi\frac{({\bf r}-{\bf r}^\prime)^2}{\lambda_t^2}\right]^{1/k } \nonumber\\ \label{g1ho } & = & \frac{1}{\lambda_t^3}g_{3/2}\left(\exp\left[\frac{\mu-[v({\bf r})+v({\bf r } ^\prime)]/2}{k_bt}\right],\exp\left[-\pi\frac{({\bf r}-{\bf r}^\prime)^2 } { \lambda_t^2}\right]\right)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used the thermal wavelength @xmath64 in addition we have introduced the generalized bose function @xmath65 which is related to the commonly used bose function @xmath66 and to the riemann zeta function @xmath67 through @xmath68 the implications of eq .
( [ g1ho ] ) can be made clearer by deriving an approximate form for it from eq .
( [ g1wigner ] ) .
there @xmath25 was expressed in terms of the wigner function .
we now employ the local density approximation which assumes the wigner function , @xmath69 , to be locally identical to the momentum distribution of a spatially homogeneous system with constant potential energy equal to the local value @xmath70 @xmath71 - 1}.\ ] ] this approximation implies that the atoms see an effective chemical potential @xmath72 which varies with position . if we fourier transform this wigner function as required by eq .
( [ g1wigner ] ) the correlation function can be expressed as @xmath73}{k_bt}\right],\exp\left[-\pi \frac{({\bf r}-{\bf r}^\prime)^2}{\lambda_t^2}\right]\right).\ ] ] the global chemical potential @xmath50 must then be chosen to secure the correct total atom number @xmath74 we can now compare eq .
( [ g1lda ] ) with eq .
( [ g1ho ] ) .
these expressions for @xmath25 in fact coincide for equal arguments @xmath75 .
however , for @xmath76 they treat the potential energy in a slightly different way .
the accuracy of the local density approximation evidently requires that the external potential vary slowly on a length scale given by @xmath77 . for a relative separation @xmath44 of this magnitude , the difference of the potential energy between eqs .
( [ g1ho ] ) and ( [ g1lda ] ) is only of the order @xmath78 and can thus be neglected .
this result can be no surprise if we consider that the thermal wavelength , written as @xmath79 , becomes smaller than the natural length unit @xmath80 of the trapping potential precisely in the limit @xmath81 .
for the trap parameters of ref .
@xcite , the thermal wavelength assumes a value of @xmath82 m at the critical temperature , which is three to ten times smaller than the harmonic oscillator length units of the anisotropic trapping potential .
we have thus shown that both the density distribution and correlations implicit in @xmath25 are well described by the local density approximation , as long as the separation of the trap levels is small compared to the thermal energy .
of course , application of the local density approximation is not restricted to an isotropic harmonic oscillator potential .
it can be applied to any trapping potential @xmath38 as long as the thermal wavelength is small compared to the length scale of the spatial variations of the potential .
since the correlation function decreases on the scale of the thermal wavelength it is consistent to use for small relative separations ( @xmath83 ) the alternative definitions @xmath84 for the normalization of the volume integrated correlation functions . for a harmonic oscillator potential the integration over the mean
coordinate @xmath85 of eq .
( [ g1lda ] ) can easily be carried out @xcite by using the series expansion of @xmath86 .
the results for the volume integrated correlation functions of eqs .
( [ g1volume ] ) and ( [ g1volumealt ] ) are then @xmath87,\exp\left[-\pi \frac{r^2}{\lambda_t^2}\right]\right)\\ \label{g1volumeharm } g^{(1)}({\bf r})&=&\frac { g_{3}\left(\exp\left[\frac{\mu}{k_bt}\right],\exp\left[-\pi \frac{r^2}{\lambda_t^2}\right]\right)}{g_{3}\left(\exp\left[\frac{\mu}{k_bt } \right]\right)}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the latter formula applies equally well to the case of an anisotropic harmonic potential when the replacement @xmath88 is made . as in the well known case of a spatially homogeneous system , the correlations decay on a length scale given by the thermal wavelength @xmath77 . however , the bose function @xmath89 appropriate to a harmonic oscillator potential is closer to a linear function of its argument than the function @xmath86 characteristic of a homogeneous system .
the properties of a bose - einstein distribution are thus less visible in the volume integrated correlation function of a harmonically trapped system than in that of a homogeneous system , since the atoms away from the trap center experience a lower local chemical potential . in view of this reduced tendency towards condensation for larger radii
it may be an acceptable approximation to assume a maxwell - boltzmann occupation distribution of the trap levels , or equivalently to restrict the summation in eq .
( [ g1ho ] ) to its lowest order term . in this approximation
we obtain the simple expressions @xmath90 numerical calculations confirm ( cf . fig .
[ gidealfig ] ) the accuracy of these simple expressions even at temperatures very close to the critical temperature . in sec .
[ abovetc ] we have calculated the first and second order correlation functions for uncondensed systems . the presence of a bose - einstein condensate , however , will lead to significant changes , especially in the second order correlation function . in principle , the presence of a bose - einstein condensate has no effect on the previously discussed expression , eq .
( [ g1ideal ] ) , for the first order correlation function @xmath25 . however , due to the relatively long ranged coherence of the condensate we have to perform the local density approximation in a slightly different way .
we therefore introduce a wigner function , @xmath91 , which describes only the uncondensed atoms .
the condensate , which corresponds to the ground state of the bare external potential , is still considered to have a wave function @xmath18 that obeys the schrdinger equation @xmath92 with @xmath93 corresponding to the zero point energy of the oscillator potential . the first order correlation function can then be decomposed into a condensed and an uncondensed or thermal part @xmath94 with @xmath95 again , the thermal wigner function @xmath96 describes the uncondensed part of the full wigner function .
the thermal correlation function @xmath97 is given by eq .
( [ g1lda ] ) , since the momentum integration which led to eq .
( [ g1lda ] ) does not account for the existence of a condensate .
however , in contrast to eq .
( [ condse ] ) , the chemical potential in @xmath96 is set equal to zero , ( @xmath98 ) , as it must be in the local density approximation .
the occupation of the condensate mode , furthermore , has to be determined from the normalization condition @xmath99 the limiting values of the normalized first order correlation function @xmath100 differ from those of an uncondensed gas ( cf .
( [ g1limits ] ) ) by the possibility of off - diagonal long range order .
the existence of a condensate causes the correlation length of @xmath32 to be much larger than the thermal wavelength @xmath77 . in the case of a spatially homogeneous gas
the correlation extends throughout the entire system .
the degree of first order coherence for large separations is then just given by the local condensate fraction .
the second order correlation function is affected by bose - einstein condensation in a more interesting way , as can be seen in eq .
( [ g2ideal ] ) .
the fluctuations of the number of atoms in the condensate mode depend sensitively on the statistical ensemble that is assumed for the calculation .
the fluctuations characteristic of the grand canonical ensemble greatly overestimate the condensate fluctuations in any experiment with a fixed total atom number .
instead we assume canonical condensate fluctuations which are of the order @xcite @xmath101 in the limit of a large system we can neglect the last term since it is much smaller than the first term which is of the order @xmath102 . to calculate the second order correlation function we refer back to eq .
( [ g2ideal ] ) and note that the fluctuations of the uncondensed modes can be well approximated by using the grand canonical ensemble . for the condensate mode , on the other hand , we can write @xmath103 , so that we have @xmath104 the limit for large relative separations is again given by @xmath105 a certain measure @xcite of second order coherence is @xmath106 this function , which is determined by the ratio of the local condensate density to the total density must reduce to unity everywhere in order to describe perfect second order coherence . in general , it can only be close to one near the center of the trap , where the condensate density is large .
the coherence properties of the thermal cloud outside the condensate , i.e. where @xmath107 , are not greatly different from those of an uncondensed gas .
in sec . [ idealgas ] we have studied the basic properties of the first and second order correlation functions of a trapped ideal gas . in this section
we discuss the way in which atomic interactions modify these results . in order to deal with recent bose condensation experiments
@xcite we focus on gases which are very dilute , but which contain atoms with a strong mutual repulsion . in this section
we discuss only bose condensed gases .
the properties of an uncondensed gas can easily be obtained as a specialisation of the following treatment . in the presence of atomic interactions
, the condensate wave function obeys the finite temperature gross - pitaevskii equation @xcite ( cf .
( [ condse ] ) ) @xmath108-\mu\right)\psi({\bf r})=0\ ] ] where the atomic interaction strength is measured by @xmath109 , with @xmath110 denoting the two - body scattering length .
the local density of thermal atoms @xmath111 is given by the still - to - be determined thermal part of the first order correlation function ( cf .
( [ g10 ] ) and ( [ g1wigner0 ] ) ) , @xmath112 in the case of an interacting gas , the local density approximation has to be applied not only to the distribution of thermal atoms but also to the condensate wave function in order to be consistent .
otherwise , the local kinetic energy of the condensate wave function could be larger than the kinetic energy of the low lying elementary excitations .
details of this argument will be presented later .
we have therefore to neglect the kinetic energy term in the gross - pitaevskii equation ( [ gpe ] ) , and that is appropriate if the kinetic energy is much smaller than the interaction energy . under present experimental conditions @xcite
this condition is well fullfilled in the core of the condensate .
however , the local density approximation can not be applied in a small region around the surface of the condensate , where the interaction energy ceases to dominate the kinetic energy .
the radial extent of this region is usually called the healing length .
it has a fixed thickness and therefore a vanishing relevance in the thermodynamic limit .
this local density or thomas - fermi approximation has already been used frequently for the description of bose - einstein condensation experiments . in this limit
, the condensate wave function is given by @xmath113 for positive arguments of the square root and by zero otherwise @xcite .
since the local density approximation fails close to the surface of the condensate we are only able to study correlation functions with both of their spatial arguments located within the condensate or outside of it . inside the condensate , the first order correlation function is given by @xmath114 with the condensate wave function defined by eq .
( [ psitf ] ) . for the calculation of the thermal wigner function
we have to take into account that the low lying excited states of the interacting bose gas are excitations of collective quasi - particle modes rather than single atoms . to be more specific ,
a proper treatment of the atomic interactions in the presence of a bose - einstein condensate starts with decomposing the atomic field operator into a condensate and a fluctuation part @xmath115 with @xmath18 obeying the gross - pitaevskii equation ( [ gpe ] ) . due to this choice of @xmath18 only second order terms in the fluctuations @xmath116 and higher
contribute to the interaction hamiltonian .
within the popov approximation third and fourth order terms in @xmath116 are treated in an averaged way , neglecting anomalous expectation values like @xmath117 .
this extends the idea of the bogoliubov approximation to finite temperatures since third and fourth order fluctuation terms are completely neglected in the latter .
it is then possible to introduce quasi - particle operators @xmath118 which diagonalize the approximate hamilton operator of the interacting system to @xmath119 the quasi - particle operators @xmath118 obey bose commutation relations . in a spatially homogeneous system with volume @xmath120
they are related to the fluctuation operator @xmath116 by @xcite @xmath121 by virtue of the local density approximation both the coefficients @xmath122 and @xmath123 as well as the hartree - fock energy @xmath124-\mu\nonumber\\ \label{ehf } & = & \frac{p^2}{2m}+u\,|\psi({\bf r})|^2\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the popov energy @xmath125 ^
2-\left[u\,|\psi({\bf r})|^2\right]^2}\nonumber\\ & = & \sqrt{\left[\frac{p^2}{2m}+u\,|\psi({\bf r})|^2 \right]^2-\left[u\,|\psi({\bf r})|^2\right]^2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] become functions of the position @xmath126 .
the local spectrum of elementary excitations @xmath127 coincides with the well known bogoliubov spectrum for a bose condensed homogeneous gas close to zero temperature .
the external potential and the interactions between uncondensed atoms influence the excitation spectrum only indirectly through the local condensate density ( cf .
( [ psitf ] ) ) . if the kinetic energy of an elementary excitation with momentum @xmath128 is smaller than the interaction energy of the condensate atoms , these excitations consist of phonon - like quasi - particles . for large kinetic energies ,
the popov energy @xmath127 coincides with the hartree - fock energy @xmath129 and the elementary excitations then consist of real particles instead .
( [ epopov ] ) also explains why it was necessary to extend the local density approximation to the condensate wave function .
had we not dropped the kinetic energy of the condensate from the definition of the chemical potential in eq .
( [ gpe ] ) , the popov energy would be given by @xmath130 ^ 2-\left[u\,|\psi({\bf r})|^2\right]^2}.\ ] ] for a positive kinetic energy of the condensate wave function the argument of the square root could become negative , leaving the popov energy undefined .
one might try intuitively to remedy this problem , for example , by restricting the phase space available to the quasi - particles .
however , numerical comparisons of several such schemes have yielded even less agreement with the results of an exact path integral monte carlo calculations @xcite than the complete neglect of the quasi - particle excitations that corresponds to the hartree - fock method .
finally , we obtain the thermal wigner function by assuming the quasi - particle states to be occupied by a bose - einstein distribution and by expressing the mode functions @xmath122 and @xmath123 in terms of energies @xcite @xmath131\frac{1}{\exp [ \epsilon({\bf p},{\bf r})/k_bt]-1}\nonumber\\ \label{wignert0 } & = & \frac{1}{(2\pi\hbar)^3}\frac{\epsilon_{\mbox{hf } } ( { \bf p},{\bf r})}{\epsilon({\bf p},{\bf r})}\frac{1}{\exp [ \epsilon({\bf p},{\bf r})/k_bt]-1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] outside the condensate , collective effects do not play any role in determining the spectrum of elementary excitations . the first order correlation function
is then given approximately by the formula ( [ g1lda ] ) for an uncondensed ideal gas @xmath132}{k_bt}\right],\exp\left[-\pi \frac{({\bf r}-{\bf r}^\prime)^2}{\lambda_t^2}\right]\right),\ ] ] in which the local chemical potential @xmath133 is reduced by the mean - field interaction between the uncondensed atoms .
however , these interactions are usually very weak and the correlation function is then essentially that discussed in sec .
[ idealgas ] . a numerical plot of the volume integrated , normalized correlation function @xmath134 for an interacting bose condensed gas is given in fig .
[ g1ifig ] . the effective strength of the atomic interaction is best expressed in terms of the universal scaling parameter @xmath135 @xcite , where @xmath136 is the critical temperature of the ideal gas .
this scaling parameter assumes values between @xmath137 and @xmath138 in most recent experiments .
as in the case of a condensed ideal gas , the correlation function decreases for relative separations much larger than the thermal wavelength , but smaller than the total size of the condensate , to the overall condensate fraction , i.e. , the system posesses an off - diagonal long range order .
however , for an interacting gas , the tail of the correlation function decreases much more slowly , as a result of the presence of the long wavelength quasi - particle excitations . the unintegrated correlation function @xmath6 depends strongly on its mean coordinate @xmath85 since the local condensate fraction varies significantly over the atomic sample .
atomic interactions affect the second order correlation function in a more fundamental way than just by changing the spectrum of elementary excitations .
atoms repel each other strongly at small separations .
it is therefore impossible to find two atoms at exactly the same location , i.e. , @xmath139 .
this effect is clearly not accounted for by eqs .
( [ g2belowtc ] ) and ( [ g2belowtc ] ) .
in order to study the influence of this hard core repulsion we briefly revisit the derivation of the time - dependent version of the gross - pitaevskii equation ( [ gpe ] ) .
the condensate dyad @xmath140 is part of the reduced one - particle density matrix @xmath141 , which contains the same information as the first order correlation function .
the dynamics of @xmath141 depends on the reduced two - particle density matrix @xmath142 through the schrdinger equation @xmath143 -\frac{i}{\hbar}\mbox{tr}_2\left\{\big[h_i,\rho^{(2)}\big]\right\}\ ] ] with the one - particle hamiltonian @xmath144 and the true atomic interaction potential @xmath145 in the coordinate representation @xmath146 the dynamics of the second order correlation function is similary linked to the third - order correlation function and so on , the entire set of @xmath23 coupled equations constituting the so - called bbgky hierarchy .
if it is possible , however , to express the reduced two - particle density matrix @xmath142 in terms of the reduced one - particle density matrix @xmath141 , the hierarchy can be truncated by turning eq .
( [ bbgky ] ) into a closed nonlinear equation . in most treatments , the time - dependent analog of the gross - pitaevskii equation ( [ gpe ] )
is obtained by replacing the true atomic interaction potential by the point interaction @xmath147 and by factorizing the reduced two - particle density matrix analogously to eq .
( [ g2belowtc ] ) . even though such an application of the first order born approximation to a suitably chosen pseudopotential properly reproduces the gross - pitaevskii equation , its implications for quantities other than the reduced one - particle density matrix require more careful examination .
for example , the above treatment implies that the second order correlation function @xmath148 corresponds to an ideal gas of quasi - particles with @xmath6 given by eq .
( [ g1i ] ) .
such a conclusion , however , incorrectly ignores the strong repulsion between atoms at small distances .
we therefore outline a more detailed derivation of the gross - pitaevskii equation @xcite which also describes the two - particle density matrix appropriately .
for this purpose we decompose the two - particle density matrix , @xmath149 , into a part @xmath150 representing products of the reduced single - particle density matrix ( cf .
( [ g20 ] ) ) and a part @xmath151 , which corrects for the true two - particle correlations . rather than neglecting the correlation part @xmath151 altogether , we turn eq .
( [ bbgky ] ) into a closed equation by solving the dynamics of @xmath151 analytically and by reexpressing the correlations , @xmath151 , in terms of @xmath150 .
of course , certain approximations have to be made in order to achieve a convenient analytical expression for @xmath151 .
the equation of motion of @xmath151 is simplified by the assumption of an atom density low enough to permit neglect of three - body and higher order collisions .
the two - particle correlations are therefore the result of two - particle scattering only . in the context of many - particle physics
this approach is often called a ladder approximation since the two - body collision is calculated up to arbitrary orders in the true interaction hamiltonian @xmath152 .
it is worth noting that a literal point - like potential does not lead to any two - particle scattering , and that is consistent with the assumption @xmath153 , but it is not at all realistic .
if we describe the two - particle scattering by the mller operator @xmath154 \exp[i ( h_{0,1}+h_{0,2})t/\hbar],\ ] ] it can be shown that the properly approximated two - particle density matrix is given by @xmath155 .
thus the equation of motion for @xmath141 reads @xcite @xmath156-\frac{i}{\hbar}\mbox{tr}_2\left\{\big[h_i,\omega\,\rho^{(2)}_0\ , \omega^\dagger\big]\right\}.\ ] ] the mller operator @xmath157 is related to the two - body @xmath37-matrix by the relation @xmath158 .
the matrix elements of the two - body @xmath37-matrix in momentum representation are identical to the scattering amplitude .
it is therefore the @xmath37-matrix rather than the atomic interaction potential @xmath152 which should be approximated by a delta function @xmath159 .
to lowest order in the scattering length , this equation of motion can be further reduced to @xmath160 -\frac{i}{\hbar}\mbox{tr}_2\left\{\big[t,\rho^{(2)}_0\big]\right\}\ ] ] which coincides with the previously outlined mean - field approximation .
the neglected terms , which are quadratic in the scattering length , describe small thermal energy shifts and the dissipative effects of collisions such as thermalization @xcite .
we conclude from the above derivation of the gross - pitaevskii equation that the second order correlation function that properly accounts for hard core repulsion is given by @xmath161 the correlation function is here defined as the operator @xmath162 with the understanding that its coordinate representation corresponds to @xmath10 . for reasons of simplicity
we calculate @xmath14 first for an uncondensed gas .
the scattering involves only the wave function for the relative coordinate @xmath163 of the two atoms .
if the incoming states are plane waves the effect of the mller operator is given by @xcite @xmath164\qquad(r\gg a)\ ] ] with the center - of - mass coordinate @xmath165 , the total momentum @xmath166 , and the relative momentum @xmath167 .
here , we have assumed that all relative momenta are small enough to permit taking only the momentum independent part , @xmath168 , of the scattering amplitude into account . with this approximation
we have neglected terms of order @xmath169 which is justified if @xmath170 . in a harmonic trap
the ratio @xmath171 is given by @xmath172 it is mainly determined by the scaling parameter @xmath173 @xcite which , as we have noted , assumes values between @xmath137 and @xmath138 in most recent experiments . as a consequence
, we can generally assume a ratio of @xmath174 at the critical temperature . in agreement with the local density approximation
, we evaluate @xmath14 for a spatially homogeneous gas with volume @xmath120 . denoting the relative coordinate once more as @xmath126 and the relative momentum as @xmath128
, we obtain for an uncondensed system ( cf .
( [ g2abovetc ] ) ) @xmath175 after multiplying this expression out term by term and making use of the spatial isotropy of the homogeneous gas we can write the second order correlation function as @xmath176\left(1-\frac{a } { |{\bf r}-{\bf r}^\prime|}\right)^2\nonumber\\ \label{g2i } & & + \left[g^{(1)}({\bf r},{\bf r})\,g^{(1)}({\bf r}^\prime,{\bf r}^\prime ) -|g^{(1)}({\bf r},{\bf r}^\prime)|^2\right]\left[\left(1+\frac{a } { |{\bf r}-{\bf r}^\prime|}\right)^2 - 1\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] an expression which should also be valid for a sufficiently slowly varying inhomogeneous system .
the first line of eq .
( [ g2i ] ) multiplies the correlation function of an ideal gas by the squared relative wave function in the limit of zero momentum scattering . the additional term on the second line accounts for the fact that the atoms have finite relative momenta with a distribution implicitly characterized by @xmath6 .
this correction term can only be neglected for very small @xmath171 ratios .
furthermore , only linear terms in @xmath177 are relevant for distances @xmath178 .
the extension of the previous calculation to bose condensed gases is straightforward though it requires a little more algebra due to the existence of quasi - particle excitations .
however , most of the required modifications are absorbed into the definition of the first order correlation function @xmath25 .
in addition one has to take into account the fact that the second order correlation function of a condensed ideal gas is given by eq .
( [ g2belowtc ] ) rather than by eq .
( [ g2abovetc ] ) . with these modifications
the second order correlation function of a condensed interacting gas is given by @xmath179\left[\left(1+\frac{a } { |{\bf r}-{\bf r}^\prime|}\right)^2 - 1\right]\nonumber\\ g^{(2)}({\bf r},{\bf r}^\prime ) & = & g^{(2)}_0({\bf r},{\bf r}^\prime)\ , \left(1-\frac{a}{|{\bf r}-{\bf r}^\prime|}\right)^2 +
\left[1-|g^{(1)}({\bf r},{\bf r}^\prime)|^2\right]\left[\left(1+\frac{a } { |{\bf r}-{\bf r}^\prime|}\right)^2 - 1\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] in fig .
[ g2i10fig ] we compare the volume integrated normalized correlation functions @xmath33 and @xmath180 for an uncondensed system at the critical temperature of an ideal gas @xmath136 .
the interaction strength is given by the scaling parameter @xmath181 .
even though the scattering length is much smaller than the thermal wavelength , with @xmath182 , the hard core repulsion significantly reduces the amount of bosonic attraction between the atoms .
it becomes apparent from fig .
[ g2i10afig ] that @xmath183 is dominated by @xmath184 corresponding to the first line of eq .
( [ g2i ] ) .
the additional terms contribute a @xmath185 correction .
they mainly suppress the residual effect of the hard core repulsion for distances of the order of the thermal wavelength and larger .
[ g2i10afig ] also illustrates the diluting effect of the volume integration on the range of the bosonic attraction . for comparison ,
we plot in fig .
[ g2i05fig ] the correlation function @xmath33 for a bose condensed gas at @xmath186 .
its maximum value is strongly reduced since condensate atoms do not exhibit any tendency to clump together due to wave function symmetrization . on the other hand
, the existence of quasi - particle excitations leads to a relatively long tail for the correlation function .
for this temperature , corrections to the term @xmath184 can be safely neglected , due to a larger thermal wavelength , i.e. , @xmath187 , and the long tail of the correlation function .
we summarize in this section the coherence properties of trapped bose gases based on our results for the first and second order correlation functions .
first order coherence describes the ability of atoms with an initial separation @xmath11 to form an interference pattern , when brought together . for an uncondensed gas , the visibility of such an interference pattern drops to zero on a length scale of @xmath11 measured by the thermal wavelength , which is roughly of the order of @xmath188 m in present experiments . in a bose condensed gas , however , the visibility decreases on the same length scale to a plateau given by the total fraction of condensed atoms .
this off - diagonal long range order allowed the experimental observation of an interference pattern @xcite which extended over the whole cloud of condensate atoms . for spatial separations larger than the the size of the condensate , the visibility drops to zero as well , because long range order can not extend beyond the system size .
second order coherence implies instead the absence of any density correlations other than the trivial autocorrelation pointed out in eq.([ncorr ] ) . in a dilute bose gas
, we can identify two sources of density correlations which limit the achievable degree of second order coherence .
an inevitable anticorrelation between atoms originates from their strong mutual repulsion .
the length scale of this repulsion is given by the scattering length @xmath110 which is of the order of a few nanometers and therefore much smaller than any other relevant length scale .
however , the relative wave function of two atoms increases as @xmath189 , which is to say very slowly .
anticorrelation effects are therefore still visible on the length scale of the thermal wavelength , which is about 200 times larger ( at @xmath190 ) than the scattering length .
the other limitation to second order coherence is due to the tendency of bosonic atoms to cluster together .
the range of this effective bosonic attraction is again limited by the thermal wavelength . however , its maximal amount is a function of temperature too , since the condensate atoms do not exhibit such a clustering effect . because of the interplay between hard core repulsion and bosonic clustering , the maximum of the second order correlation function depends on both the temperature and the scattering length .
it is nevertheless useful to characterize the local second order coherence by the maximum of the fictitious correlation function @xmath191 which does not account for hard core repulsion .
we illustrate in fig .
[ g2xxifig ] how this local measure of second order coherence , which is a function of the local condensate density , varies with the radial coordinate @xmath192 in a spherically symmetric system ( cf .
analogously , the maximum @xmath193 of the volume integrated correlation function offers a certain global measure of the second order coherence of the system .
fortunately , the quantity @xmath193 is experimentally accessible due to its relation to the total atomic interaction energy .
according to eq .
( [ g1kinetic ] ) the latter energy can be approximated by @xmath194 the overlap integral between the true atomic interaction potential and the relative wave function between the atoms is therefore approximately proportional to the maximum value of the otherwise fictitious volume integrated correlation function @xmath195 . in a recent experiment @xcite the interaction energy and
thereby @xmath193 were determined by measuring the release energy of the atoms after switching off the magnetic trap .
this experiment provided some evidence for a large degree of second order coherence of a trapped bose - einstein condensate at zero temperature . at finite temperature , however , a determination of the interaction energy from the release energy would require that the initial kinetic energy of the uncondensed atoms be measured independently . in a similar experiment the third order analog of @xmath193 has been determined by measuring three - body scattering rates @xcite .
the implications of these experiments for second and third order coherence has been discussed before @xcite .
however , it was wrongly concluded that these experiments measure the true second order correlation function @xmath14 or its third order analog .
the significant impact of the hard core repulsion on second and third order coherence has apparently not yet been fully appreciated .
finally , we discuss the temperature dependence of @xmath193 in fig .
[ g200ifig ] .
the numerical plot shows a rapid but continuous decrease of @xmath193 as the temperature falls below the critical temperature .
a comparison with a calculation in the hartree - fock limit shows that the existence of quasi - particle excitations has a small but noticeable effect on second order coherence .
we contrast these results with the second order coherence of both a spatially homogeneous and a harmonically trapped ideal bose gas . in a spatially homogeneous medium
one finds @xmath196 ^ 2,\ ] ] which is almost a linear function of temperature ( cf .
[ g200ifig ] ) .
in contrast the volume integrated second order correlation function of a harmonically trapped ideal bose gas @xmath197 experiences a sharp transition from the value two above the critical temperature to the value one below it .
the reason for this discontinuous transition is that the peak density of a harmonically trapped noninteracting bose gas becomes infinite as the thermodynamic limit is reached while the peak density of the thermal cloud retains a finite value .
of course , the presence of atomic interactions prevents any such unbounded growth of the condensate density for a real gas .
nevertheless , the spatial inhomogeneity accelerates the transition to a second order coherent ensemble as the temperature is decreased .
we have extended the concept of optical coherence , defined in terms of correlation functions , to dilute trapped bose gases . except for a small region around the surface of a bose - einstein condensate , these correlation functions can be calculated by using a local density approximation . even though the system behaves locally as if it were spatially homogeneous , the spatial dependence of the effective chemical potential adds some interesting new physical features .
the influence of both the bose - einstein distribution of uncondensed atoms and of quasi - particle like excitations is strongly reduced when a volume average over the mean coordinate of the correlation functions is performed .
nevertheless , consequences of quasi - particle excitations are still noticeable in the tails of the correlation functions .
the density correlation is dominated by a tendency of bosonic atoms to cluster together and , on the other hand , the existence of a hard core repulsion between these atoms . the quantum statistical attraction and the effect of coulomb repulsion
are found to be of comparable range for the conditions of most recent experiments .
it is in this sense incorrect to neglect the hard core repulsion in the discussion of density correlations . for the discussion of second order coherence , however , it is convenient to introduce a fictitious correlation function which does omit the effect of hard core repulsion .
this correlation function is experimentally accessible due to its close relation to the atomic interaction energy . by introducing this fictitious correlation function
, we are able to explain the results of recent experiments on second and third order coherence .
finally , we have observed that a harmonically trapped gas achieves second order coherence much more rapidly as the temperature is lowered below the critical temperature than does its spatially homogeneous counterpart .
it is a pleasure to thank m. holzmann for stimulating discussions and the opportunity to compare our calculations with the unpublished results of a numerical path integral monte carlo calculation @xcite .
m.n . acknowledges financial support by the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft . | we study first and second order coherence of trapped dilute bose gases using appropriate correlation functions .
special attention is given to the discussion of second order or density correlations .
except for a small region around the surface of a bose - einstein condensate the correlations can be accurately described as those of a locally homogeneous gas with a spatially varying chemical potential .
the degrees of first and second order coherence are therefore functions of temperature , chemical potential , and position .
the second order correlation function is governed both by the tendency of bosonic atoms to cluster and by a strong repulsion at small distances due to atomic interactions . in present experiments
both effects are of comparable magnitude . below the critical temperature
the range of the bosonic correlation is affected by the presence of collective quasi - particle excitations .
the results of some recent experiments on second and third order coherence are discussed .
it is shown that the relation between the measured quantities and the correlation functions is much weaker than previously assumed . |
electromagnetically induced transparency ( eit ) occurs when a three level system interacts with two resonant laser fields .
this interaction results in a sharp transparency window for one of the beams in the otherwise absorptive media .
the spectral width of this window can be narrower than the atomic line width .
eit was first predicted in 1989 by harris et al @xcite and realized experimentally shortly after in strontium vapor @xcite and in lead vapor @xcite . due to
its narrow spectral width eit is a prominent candidate for applications in spectroscopy and magnetometry @xcite .
the narrow window of eit is accompanied also by a steep dispersion leading to slow light @xcite .
eit has been extensively investigated using alkali vapors such as rubidium @xcite and sodium @xcite using the relevant hyperfine levels .
more recently eit was also demonstrated on the zeeman levels of metastable helium @xcite . due to the zero nuclear spin of @xmath1 ,
this system is unique for eit research as it is a @xmath2 system with pure electronic spin , unlike alkali vapors where eit is realized using hyperfine levels .
here we demonstrate for the first time eit in metastable neon .
@xmath3 has some special features that separates it from helium or alkali vapors .
similarly to @xmath1 , and unlike the alkali vapors , metastable neon is a closed two level system that possesses no nuclear spin .
the metastability of the eit ground state offers some unique advantages .
first , it preserves the coherence of the medium due to de - excitation collisions . in this case
the atom leaves the eit system and lowers the total population without affecting the total coherence of the system .
another advantage is the possibility of controlling the population ratio of the metastable neon via changing the excitation mechanism .
the stable neon atoms can potentially act as a buffer gas .
thus , no additional buffer gas is required .
although most properties of metastable neon are shared also by helium , there are few distinctions .
neon has approximately five times larger atomic mass @xcite , thus the eit resonance width is less limited due to the transit time broadening .
however , penning ionization in polarized metastable helium is suppressed by an additional two orders of magnitude relative to neon @xcite .
another difference is that the metastable neon system is suitable for electromagnetically induced absorption ( eia ) @xcite , while metastable helium is a true eit system .
the reason for this difference lies in the angular momentum of the two levels . in helium
the transition is @xmath4 @xcite , thus the excited state has a lower angular momentum than the ground state .
the transition in neon , on the other hand , is @xmath5 .
degenerate two level systems exhibit eia only when @xmath6 while eit is possible using all the configurations @xcite .
] we use the neon @xmath7@xmath8 closed transition .
this is a zeeman degenerate two level system with energy splitting corresponding to a wavelength of 640.2 nm , where an eit between two zeeman sublevels can be employed .
the ground metastable state @xmath9 has a total angular momentum quantum number of @xmath10 while the stable ground state @xmath11 has an angular momentum quantum number of @xmath12 .
hence , an electric dipole transition is excluded and thus the @xmath9 level is a very long metastable state with approximately 15 seconds lifetime @xcite . a schematic representation of the releveant neon energy levels is presented in fig .
[ fig : schematic - energy - level ] . ] figure [ fig : setup ] shows our experimental setup for observing eit in a hot metastable ne vapor .
the laser source is an amplified external cavity diode laser at @xmath131280 nm which is converted to the transition wavelength by second harmonic generation .
the laser is stabilized to the required transition using a standard saturation absorption locking setup @xcite .
the laser is split into pump and probe beams with different polarizations using a half wave plate .
the frequency of each beam is controlled using an acousto - optic modulator in a double pass configuration to avoid frequency dependent beam deflections .
after the frequency modulation the beams are combined using a glan - taylor calcite polarizer and pass through the neon cell spatially overlapping .
two quarter wave plates are inserted before and after the cell in order to change the polarization to circular relative to the beams propagation and back to linear polarization .
for some measurements two lenses are inserted in order to control the beam diameter .
after the neon cell the probe is separated from the pump using another glan - taylor polarizer and measured using a photodetector .
the metastable neon excitation is achieved by a coaxial resonator with helical inner conductor @xcite that surrounds the cell and resonates at 61 mhz with an un - loaded q factor of @xmath14 .
we also use a pair of helmholtz coils for axial magnetic field measurements .
the vapor cell is shielded by a mu - metal housing reducing stray magnetic field by a factor of @xmath13100 .
figure [ fig : eit](a ) shows the probe transmission spectra for different pump intensities .
both pump and probe beams are approximately gaussian with a waist of 1 mm .
the optical power of the probe is 0.3 mw .
three major observations can be inferred from fig .
[ fig : eit](a )
. first , higher pump intensities result in an increase of the overall transmission due to hole burning .
this is a broad feature due to the doppler broadening .
near the two photon resonance we observe two opposite features .
the first one is a broad ( few mhz ) absorption line .
this is attributed to optical pumping of the atoms to the maximal zeeman sublevel ( @xmath15 ) . due to the relevant clebsch - jordan coefficients this level has
the highest probe absorption cross section @xmath16 , thus an efficient pumping will cause an induced absorption .
when the pump and the probe have the same wavelength the population is pumped more efficiently , thus an absorption profile with a homogeneous linewidth is created .
the second feature is a narrow peak of enhanced transmission around the two photon resonance that is associated with eit .
[ fig : eit](b ) shows the power broadening of the eit peak .
the theory of doppler broadened eit with no collisions predicts a quadratic function of the pump rabi frequency @xmath17 @xcite : @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the ground state decoherence and @xmath20 is an effective pumping rate that depends on the power of the pump . for low intensities
such that @xmath21 , where @xmath22 is the doppler width and @xmath23 is the natural decay rate , only a small resonant fraction of the atoms participate in the eit .
the effective rate in this case is @xmath24 . in the opposite regime , @xmath25 ,
the intensity is strong enough to pump all the doppler broadened population and the effective rate is @xmath26 . in our experiment
10 mhz@xmath2740 mhz , @xmath23=8 mhz and @xmath281.3 ghz .
the ground state decoherence is governed mostly by the transit - time broadening @xcite .
our beam has a width of @xmath132 mm and the atomic ballistic velocity at room temperature is @xmath13500 m / s , thus the decoherence due to the transit - time can be estimated to be 250 khz .
taking into account velocity changing collisions ( vcc ) with the stable neon atoms the atomic motion becomes diffusive , increasing the transit - time .
for the pressure we use ( 200 mtorr ) the diffusive transit - time is @xmath29 longer than the ballistic one , making the decoherence @xmath13100 khz .
using these values reveals that our system should be in the low intensity limit , hence the power broadening should be @xmath30 .
strikingly , fig .
[ fig : eit](b ) depicts a linear trend with the intensity .
we fit the data to a linear function obtaining @xmath310.9 ghz which is very similar to @xmath22 .
it is important to note that goldfarb et al
. showed a similar effect in metastable helium that was attributed to many vcc that effectively explored all the doppler velocity range @xcite . in their experiment
they estimated @xmath32 collisions during the diffusion , but in our case due to smaller beam diameter and lower pressure the number of collisions is estimated to be @xmath33 .
figure [ fig : pressure ] shows the eit power broadening for several low pressure neon cells .
it is apparent that even at very low pressures , where the number of collisions is @xmath34 and the dynamics should be ballistic , the broadening is approximately linear , with @xmath35 . .
( b ) fwhm width of the eit peak as a function of the pump intensity .
the solid line is a linear fit to the data .
( c ) background transmission ( @xmath36 ) as a function of the rabi frequency .
solid line is a linear fit to the data .
( d ) eit peak height as a function of the rabi frequency .
solid line is a fit according to eq .
[ eq : peak_t ] . ]
another interesting aspect of eit is its peak height .
figure [ fig : eit](d ) shows the natural logarithm of the peak heights as a function of the rabi frequency .
the peak transmission can be estimated to be @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the optical density of the medium with @xmath39 taken from fig .
[ fig : eit](c ) and @xmath40 is the transmission with no pump field .
this expression is similar to the one used in @xcite , but with the exception of normalizing the transmission with the @xmath41 due to the hole burning effect .
the data was fitted to eq .
[ eq : peak_t ] with the best fit presented as the solid line in fig .
[ fig : eit](d ) .
the fit yields @xmath42 which is in good agreement with our estimation of the ground state decoherence .
( b ) . ] in our setup we can also control the rf power of the excitation , thus controlling the percentage of metastable neon .
figure [ fig : rf ] shows a comparison of the power broadening slope for different rf powers ( blue circles ) .
this slope was calculated in the same way as in fig .
[ fig : eit](b ) .
higher rf powers have smaller slopes suggesting a narrowing .
this narrowing can be explained when taking into consideration the effect of optical density such that @xcite : @xmath43 we use eq .
[ eq : odfix ] for normalizing the slope by multiplying with @xmath44 ( red squares ) .
the results clearly show that the narrowing effect is due to the more effective population transfer to the metastable state at high rf powers .
although we describe here an eit experiment , the full zeeman level scheme of metastable neon as described in fig .
[ fig : schematic - energy - level ] is not compatible with eit but rather with eia @xcite .
this is true because the upper level has a higher angular momentum than the lower one , @xmath5 .
we did not observe eia in our system but it is well known theoretically and experimentally that eit appears in eia systems under two conditions , a. when the degeneracy of the zeeman sublevels is lifted .
b. if the intensity of the pump is high enough such that @xmath45 @xcite .
all the results presented above were taken for high enough pump intensity such that the eia should become eit .
on the other hand , when we lowered the intensity no eia was discovered . regarding the degeneracy , the main process that can lift it is the magnetic field due to the rf excitation . for the highest rf power we use , the magnetic field
is estimated to be @xmath131 g which is equivalent to @xmath46 .
hence the magnetic field is not enough to lift the degeneracy .
moreover , we also applied a constant axial magnetic field of up to @xmath47 using an anti helmholz configuration .
this field shifted the two - photon eit resonance linearly with the applied magnetic field as expected by the zeeman splitting theory , but otherwise did not change any other eit attributes .
possible resolution of this quandary ( why eia was not observed ) may lie in the rf field .
this field has a frequency which is much higher than @xmath23 , thus the pump beam actually changes its magnetic axis causing a reduction in the effective coherence buildup between the eia excited levels .
this may cause a destruction of the eia but not eit , where only ground state coherence is needed .
another unique result is the linear broadening with @xmath48 even at the low power limit and with low pressure such that vcc does not affect the dynamics .
we did not find any simple explanation for this effect and it should be a part of further research in the future .
we present here the first observation of eit in metastable neon .
we measure linewidths as narrow as 200 khz , significantly narrower than the natural linewidth .
we measure the power broadening of the eit linewidth for different pressures and rf excitation powers .
the eit width is inversely proportional to the doppler width even for low pressures and intensities . by extrapolating the power broadening results we estimate the ground decoherence in our system to be 100 khz .
the dominant mechanism for this decoherence is the transit time , which was also verified by the hard sphere model .
using the stable neon atoms as a buffer gas and increasing the vcc rate through higher pressures may lead to a narrower eit that will be less restricted by the transit time broadening .
we wish to thank g. arrad and a. retzker for many fruitful discussions . we acknowledge
support of bikura grant 1567/12 and mafat .
31ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo
secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12
& 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1063/1.881806 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.66.2593 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.67.3062 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.58.2587 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.69.1360 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/s003400050581 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.83.1767 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.74.2447 [ * * , ( ) ] http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=aph&an=1568994&site=ehost-live [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.53.r27 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/josab.22.001062 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.51.r2703 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.74.670 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1119/1.3028309 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.74.666 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.54.3653 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.59.4773 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.80.023817 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/0295-5075/82/i=5/a=54002 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.84.023811 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.84.175 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.59.4732 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.69.053818 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.61.053803 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.1797771 [ * * , ( ) ] _ _ , @noop ph.d .
thesis , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.67.010501 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ , ed .
( , ) link:\doibase 10.1109/jrproc.1959.287128 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/ol.9.000056 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.77.633 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/0953-4075/34/i=23/a=322 [ * * , ( ) ] | we report here the first observation of electromagnetically induced transparency ( eit ) in @xmath0ne .
the power broadening of the eit linewidth is measured as a function of neon pressure and rf excitation power .
doppler effects on the eit broadening are found even at low pressures and low intensities , where the linewidth should be governed only by homogeneous effects . |
the aggregation processes of small particles have attracted a great theoretical interest in the last decade @xcite , due to their wide range of applications . on can distinguish particle - cluster aggregation , whose prototype is the witten - sander model @xcite , and cluster - cluster aggregation @xcite . while the former model applies to field - induced growth processes , such as electrodeposition @xcite , dielectric breakdown @xcite , viscous fingering @xcite , etc ... , the latter explains true aggregation processes such as polymerisation @xcite , oil in water emulsions @xcite , soot particles in flames @xcite , flocculation of colloidal particles @xcite . among
cluster - cluster aggregation processes one distinguishes diffusion - limited cluster - cluster aggregation ( dlca ) @xcite and chemically - limited ( also called reaction - limited ) aggregation ( rlca ) @xcite which correspond respectively to fast ( fully screened ) and slow ( partially screened ) aggregation of colloids @xcite .
the cca processes leads to a flocculation regime when the concentration is smaller than a characteristic gel concentration @xmath8 , and to a gelation regime otherwise . in flocculation regime
it remains a single fractal cluster at the end of the aggregation process with a fractal dimension @xmath9 equal to 1.45 in dlca case ( and 1.65 in rlca case ) . in the gelation regime
it appears an `` infinite '' cluster at a given time @xmath0 ( hereafter refered as the gelling cluster ) .
when working with a finite ( but large ) box , such a cluster is usually defined as touching the box from edge to edge as in the percolation theory @xcite . since both physical problems are quite similar , it is tempting to explain the infinite cluster formation in dlca by the percolation theory which excludes all dynamical phenomena and this has been done by several authors @xcite .
the fractal dimension of the infinite cluster of dlca has been found to be different than the one of percolation @xcite and it has been argued that this discrepancy is due to dynamical effects .
however , recent aggregation experiments @xcite on attractive coagulated particles suggest that percolation transition occurs at the particle concentration 0.42 . therefore the question is still open :
are cca models and percolation theory compatible ? in this paper
we show that the infinite cluster obtained at @xmath0 in cca models exhibits a crossover length @xmath1 between percolation and aggregation , for concentration values @xmath4 larger than the gel concentration @xmath8 .
furthermore , we show that @xmath1 vanishes when increasing @xmath4 , and for @xmath10 the percolation regime shows up at all length scales in the infinite cluster .
these results suggest that cca processes can be viewed as an irreversible percolation phenomenom , as the invasion percolation model without trapping @xcite and the model for a diffusion front@xcite .
the two - dimensional diffusion - limited cluster - cluster aggregation model consists in a monte carlo algorithm which builds clusters on a lattice within a square box of edge length @xmath11 .
initially particles are distributed randomly ( but uniformily in the space ) on the lattice sites up to volume fraction ( concentration ) @xmath4 . in order to insure that the diffusion coefficient of the clusters varies as the inverse of their radius @xmath12 , a particle ( or a cluster )
is chosen randomly according to a probability : @xmath13 where @xmath14 ( = @xmath15 ) is the kinetical exponent .
then the cluster performs a translational motion by one unit ( taking account periodic boundary conditions , pbc ) in any of the four directions @xmath16 chosen at random .
if the cluster does not collide with another , the displacement is performed and the algorithm goes on by choosing again another cluster . if a collision occurs between two clusters they stick together forming a new large cluster . in our simulation
we have considered that collision occurs when a particle of a cluster tries to occupy a particle of another cluster . in that case
the cluster is not displaced but a bond is established between the two contacting particles . if there are more than one collision at a given motion , only one bond is chosen at random .
this trick has used by kolb in a reversible diffusion - limited cluster aggregation model @xcite .
this important variant implies that there are no loops ( as in off - lattice dlca @xcite ) and that there is no intrinsic percolation at the begining of the process : the intitial concentration can be varied up to unity . for concentrations larger than @xmath8
there exists a gel time @xmath0 where a cluster becomes infinite .
this gelling cluster is stored for a numerical analysis , and to compare , we leave the aggregation process continuing up to the time where it remains only one cluster ( hereafter refered as the final cluster ) . in the case of reaction
limited cluster - cluster aggregation @xcite , in addition to the algorithm described above , it is introduced a sticking probabilty @xmath17 . after a collision a new bond is created only if a random number ( uniformly distributed between zero and one ) is smaller than @xmath18 . here ,
we have performed two - dimensional simulations in boxes of different sizes up to @xmath19 240 .
typical results that compare qualitatevely the resulting morphologies of the gelling cluster ( g ) and the final cluster ( f ) in dlca are are illustrated in figure 1 . in the case of the gelling cluster
the other remaining clusters have been discarded and therefore are not shown .
note that the morphology of the cluster shown in figure 1a is strongly reminiscent of that of a percolating cluster as obtained in standard percolation theory @xcite when occupying randomly the sites of a square lattice with the percolation probability @xmath20 . to make quantitative comparaisons between g and f , we have calculated the mass @xmath21 dependent box size @xmath22 using the mass - counting algorithm @xcite . in figure 2
we show the log - log plot of @xmath21 versus @xmath22 for the same concentration than those considered in figure 1 .
the resulting slope indicates that m scales as @xmath23 and @xmath24 , for g ( open circles ) and f ( black squares ) , respectively .
@xmath25 ( = 1.89 ) is close to the fractal dimension of the percolating cluster in two dimensions , and @xmath26(=2 ) is the spatial dimension .
if the mass of the gelling cluster g or the mass of the final cluster f scales as @xmath27 we might be tempted to conclude that the quantity @xmath28 should not depend on @xmath22 . to test this we show , in figure 3 , the curves giving @xmath29 as a function of @xmath22 . figures 3a and 3c corresponds to g for @xmath30 and d = d , respectively and figures 3b and 3d correspond to f for @xmath30 and d = d , respectively .
one observes on these figures that @xmath29 is independent on @xmath22 only in cases 3a and 3d and for sufficiently large concentrations , confirming our first guess of different fractal dimensions , 1.89 and 2.00 , for g and f respectively .
figures 3b and 3c are shown here as conter - examples to illustrate the high precisions on these estimates for the fractal dimensions .
in general , i.e. for not too large concentrations , one can define a @xmath4-dependent crossover length @xmath1 such that @xmath29 becomes independent on @xmath22 only for @xmath2 . for @xmath3 , another linear regime
is observed , which is better extended at very low concentration , with a slope of about -0.4 and -0.5 in cases 3a and 3d , respectively , corresponding to the fractal dimension @xmath31 , close to the one of dlca clusters .
therefore @xmath1 defines a change of scaling regime between dlca for short lengths and either percolation ( g ) or homogeneity ( f ) for large lengths .
in fact , @xmath1 should be proportional to the characteristic length correlation @xmath32 ( or average size ) of dlca fractal aggregates @xcite .
note that in all cases @xmath1 vanishes for @xmath10 , and this is the reason of the absence of crossover in the curves reported in figure 2 .
when estimating the fractal dimension of the aggregates @xmath33 in the range of lengths corresponding to the aggregation regime ( @xmath3 ) , we found , in both cases g and f , that it increases significantly with concentration ( the data are reported in figure 4 ) .
those results confirm previous conclusions in two dimensions @xcite as well as in three dimensions @xcite . as a consequence
the @xmath4-dependence of @xmath1 can not be annalysed as a simple scaling relation .
moreover , the discrete values of @xmath22 that require mass - counting calculations , and finite size effects , impedes us to determine @xmath1 within a sufficiently small range of error . anyway , all the results depicted in figs . 2 and 3 suggest that , at least for @xmath2 the mass of the gelling cluster g scales with @xmath22 as a standard percolation cluster .
however such results are not sufficient to insure that their morphologies are the same .
it is well known that there exist additional quantities ( different and independent on the fractal dimension ) to characterize a percolating cluster . in principle , the morphology is entirely characterized by an infinite set of exponents @xcite , but here we shall focuse on two particular exponents : the fractal dimensions of the `` backbone '' @xmath34 and the fractal dimension of the `` links '' @xcite . the backbone of a cluster is the ensemble which remains after removing dead - ends ( or dangling - ends ) . for a percolating cluster in two dimension the fractal dimension of the backbone @xmath35 is @xmath36 .
the links ( also called red bonds ) are the sites of the cluster that are singly connected , that is , if we take out a link the connection between the entire cluster is broken . for a percolating cluster in two dimensions the fractal dimension of links
@xmath37 is equal to 0.75 . in order to identify the backbone and the links of a given cluster ,
we have been obliged ( due to the pbc considered in the cca simulations ) to span the cluster out of the box , taking account of pbc .
then , we have applied to the new cluster configuration ( with size larger than the box size @xmath11 , in almost all situations ) a procedure suggested by hermann et al .
@xcite to identify the backbone and the links . finally , the resulting backbone ( and links ) is unspanned and returned inside the original box . in figures 1 ,
the sites depicted with strong grey and black colors denotes the backbone and the links , repectively .
we have calculated the fractal dimension of the backbone @xmath35 for both g and f clusters and different concentration values .
the results are depicted in figure 5 for two box sizes length @xmath11 = 90 ( black symbols ) and 120 ( open symbols ) .
note that for small concentration values the @xmath35 values , for both g and f clusters , are quite similar .
this can be understood , since , as mentioned above , the fractal dimension in the aggregation regime is almost the same in both cases .
this conclusion is more convincing for @xmath38 , but for larger @xmath4 values , @xmath35 of the gelling cluster g becomes smaller than @xmath35 of the final cluster f. furthermore , in the g case , @xmath35 reaches the value 1.61 ( the same value than for a percolating cluster ) for @xmath10 . for @xmath39 , @xmath35 saturates to 1.89 ( the value of the fractal dimension of a percolating cluster ) . in the f case ,
the same kind of saturation phenomenon occurs but , for @xmath39 , @xmath35 saturates to the spatial dimension @xmath26 .
the increasing value of @xmath35 suggests that the backbone structure is mainly reflecting the fractal aggregate structure ( which also increases with concentration as shown in figure 4 ) .
it is only when the crossover length @xmath1 vanishes that the backbone structure becomes characteristic of the one of a percolating cluster , since @xmath35 varies from 1.61 to 1.89 as shown in figure 5 .
in figure 6 it is shown that for @xmath4 smaller than about 0.5 , the fractal dimension @xmath37 of the links is approximately equal to 1 , suggesting that the mass of the links scales with @xmath22 in a trivial manner . however , for @xmath10 , @xmath37 reaches the value 0.75 as in a percolating cluster .
the @xmath37 undependence on the box size @xmath11 suggests that there exist a threshold concentration , close to @xmath40 where the entire g cluster scales exactly as a percolating cluster .
when @xmath4 is increased above this threshold , @xmath37 vanishes , similarly to the percolation theory when the occupation probability @xmath18 is increased above @xmath41 @xcite .
the vanishing links in the gelling cluster for large @xmath4 values suggest that , at very small scales , the system becomes homogeneous , even if , at large distances , the system scales as a percolating cluster as shown in figure 3 . in order to appreciate the degree of generality of our results , we have also performed some calculations in the reaction - limited case ( rlca ) . in figure 7
we have reported the @xmath42 curves and it can be shown that they exhibit the same qualitative behavior than in the dlca case ( figure 3 ) .
these results suggest that the percolation scaling could exist in other kinds of cca processes such as the ballistic - limited @xcite , the convection - limited @xcite and the fluctuating bond @xcite aggregation models .
in this paper we have shown that the infinite cluster obtained at the gel time @xmath0 in cca models exhibits a crossover length @xmath1 between aggregation and percolation .
moreover , @xmath1 vanishes at a critical concentration @xmath43 where the mass of the entire system ( and its backbone and links ) scales as for a percolating cluster obtained at @xmath41 . for @xmath7
the percolation regime persists at least at large scales , because the vanishing links suggest that an homogeneous regime apperas at small scales .
the value obtained here for @xmath5 is close to the value reported in the above mentioned experimental work @xcite ( @xmath44 ) , but typical statistical fluctuations to determine a critical value impedes us to insure if there are some relation between these two critical probabilities .
it might also be worth finding a relation between @xmath5 and the critical probability of the site percolation threshold ( @xmath20 ) on a square lattice .
on the other hand , the fact that close to @xmath5 the fractal dimension of the links @xmath37 becomes equal to that of the percolating clusters suggests that the critical behavior in both cases are the same , since the correlation lenght exponent @xmath45 is given by @xmath46 @xcite .
preliminary calculations on a cubic lattice suggest that the results reported here are quite general and extend in three dimensions .
one of us ( a. h. ) would like to acknowledge support from conicit ( venezuela ) .
the numerical calculations where done on the computers of the cnusc ( centre universitaire sud de calcul ) , montpellier , france , with support from cnrs . | numerical simulations of diffusion - limited and reaction - limited cluster - cluster aggregation processes of identical particles are performed in a two - dimensional box .
it is shown that , for concentrations larger than a characteristic gel concentration , the morphology of the resulting spanning cluster at the gel time @xmath0 exhibits a crossover length @xmath1 between percolation ( @xmath2 ) and aggregation ( @xmath3 ) .
@xmath1 vanishes when increasing @xmath4 , and , at a critical concentration value @xmath5 ( where @xmath6 ) the entire spanning cluster scales as the percolating cluster obtained by standard percolation .
even if for @xmath7 the long - range correlations are similar to that of percolation , the vanishing links in the structure suggest that an homogeneous regime appears at small scales . |
in this paper , we consider the following stochastic differential equation ( sde ) driven by lvy noises : @xmath18 where @xmath4 is a @xmath19-dimensional lvy process , and @xmath20 is a continuous vector field such that for any @xmath9 , @xmath21 holds for some constant @xmath22 .
it is a standard result that in this case the sde ( [ ito - sde ] ) enjoys the unique strong solution .
denote by @xmath0 the semigroup associated to ( [ ito - sde ] ) . if the initial value @xmath23 is distributed as @xmath24 , then for any @xmath16 , the distribution of @xmath25 is @xmath26 .
we are concerned with the exponential contractivity of the map @xmath27 with respect to the standard @xmath1-wasserstein distance @xmath28 for all @xmath29 . given two probability measures @xmath24 and @xmath30 on @xmath6 , the standard @xmath1-wasserstein distance @xmath28 for all @xmath2 ( with respect to the euclidean norm @xmath31 ) is given by @xmath32 equipped with @xmath28 , the totality @xmath33 of probability measures having finite moment of order @xmath34 becomes a complete metric space .
the following result is well known .
[ theorem1 ] suppose that there exists a constant @xmath35 such that @xmath36 then , for any @xmath37 and @xmath16 , @xmath38 the proof of this result is quite straightforward , by simply using the synchronous coupling , which is also called the basic coupling or the coupling of marching soldiers in the literature ( see , e.g. , @xcite , definition 2.4 and @xcite , example 2.16 ) .
the reader can refer to @xcite , page 2432 , the proof of theorem [ theorem1 ] for the case of diffusion processes .
( [ diss-1 ] ) is the so - called uniformly dissipative condition , which seems to be a limit in applications . for diffusion processes
, it follows from @xcite , theorem 1 , or @xcite , remark 3.6 ( also see @xcite , theorem 3.6 ) that ( [ w2 ] ) holds for any probability measures @xmath24 and @xmath30 if and only if ( [ diss-1 ] ) holds for all @xmath39 , @xmath40 . the first breakthrough to get rid of such restrictive condition in this direction for @xmath41-wasserstein distance @xmath42
was done recently by eberle in @xcite , at the price of multiplying a constant @xmath43 on the right - hand side of ( [ w2 ] ) .
see @xcite , corollary 2.3 , for more details , and @xcite , theorem 1.3 , for related developments on @xmath1-wasserstein distance @xmath28 with all @xmath2 on this topic . however , the corresponding result for sdes driven by lvy noises is not available yet now .
indeed , we will see later that in this case we need a completely different idea for the construction of the coupling processes , and a new approach by using the coupling argument , in particular the more delicate choice of auxiliary functions . throughout this paper , we assume that the driving lvy process has a symmetric @xmath5-stable process as a component .
that is , let @xmath30 be the lvy measure of the process @xmath4 , then @xmath44 where latexmath:[$c_{d,\alpha}=2^\alpha\gamma((d+\alpha)/2)\uppi^{-d/2 } measure of a symmetric @xmath5-stable process or fractional laplacian , that is , @xmath46 denote by @xmath47 the surface measure of the unit sphere in @xmath6 .
our main contribution of this paper is as follows .
[ main - result ] assume that for any @xmath9 , @xmath48 holds with some positive constants @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 and @xmath14 . then for all @xmath7 or for all @xmath49 $ ] with @xmath50 there exists a positive constant @xmath51 , such that for any @xmath52 the following two statements hold : if @xmath53 , then for all @xmath39 , @xmath40 and any @xmath16 , @xmath54 if @xmath55 , then for all @xmath39 , @xmath40 and any @xmath16 , @xmath56,\ ] ] where @xmath22 is a positive constant depending on @xmath57 , @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath58 and @xmath34 . theorem [ main - result ] above does provide new conditions on the drift term @xmath8 such that the associated semigroup @xmath0 is exponentially contractive with respect to the @xmath1-wasserstein distance @xmath28 for all @xmath37 .
in particular , when @xmath7 , the conclusion of theorem [ main - result ] is the same as that of @xcite , theorem 1.3 , for diffusion processes ; while for @xmath49 $ ] we need the restrictive condition ( [ main - result-1 - 1 ] ) ; see remark [ main-1 - 1 ] for a further comment .
indeed , ( [ main - result-1 - 1 ] ) is natural in the sense that , when @xmath49 $ ] the drift term plays the dominant role or the same role ( just in case that @xmath59 ) for the behavior of sdes driven by symmetric @xmath5-stable processes , see , for example , @xcite for ( dirichlet ) heat kernel estimates and @xcite for dimensional free harnack inequalities on this topic .
similarly , in considering the exponential contractivity of sde ( [ ito - sde ] ) , we need ( [ main - result-1 - 1 ] ) to control the locally non - dissipative part of the drift term .
note that ( [ main - result-1 - 1 ] ) holds true when @xmath60 are small enough . to show the power of theorem [ main - result ] , we consider the following example about the sde driven by symmetric @xmath5-stable processes with @xmath61 , which yields the exponential contractivity of the semigroup @xmath0 with respect to the @xmath1-wasserstein distance @xmath28 @xmath62 for super - convex potentials . [ 1-example-2 ]
let @xmath4 be a symmetric @xmath5-stable process in @xmath6 with @xmath61 , and @xmath63 with @xmath64 and @xmath65 .
then there exists a constant @xmath66 such that for all @xmath37 , @xmath39 , @xmath40 and @xmath16 , @xmath67.\ ] ] note that the uniformly dissipative condition ( [ diss-1 ] ) fails for example [ 1-example-2 ] ; see , for example , ( [ cg-1 ] ) below .
that is , one can not deduce directly from theorem [ theorem1 ] the exponential contractivity with respect to the @xmath68-wasserstein distance @xmath69 for all @xmath2 .
the remainder of this paper is arranged as follows . in the next section
, we will present the coupling by reflection mixed with the synchronous coupling for the sde ( [ ito - sde ] ) driven by lvy noise , and also prove the existence of coupling process associated with this coupling ( operator ) .
section [ section3 ] is mainly devoted to the proof of theorem [ main - result ] . for this
, we need more delicate choice of auxiliary functions and some key estimates for them , which are different between @xmath7 and @xmath49 $ ] .
the sketch of the proof of example [ 1-example-2 ] is also given here .
it is easy to see that the generator of the process @xmath70 acting on @xmath71 is @xmath72 in this part , we construct a coupling operator for the generator @xmath73 above . for any @xmath39 , @xmath74 and @xmath75 ,
we set @xmath76 it is clear that @xmath77 has the following three properties : @xmath78 and @xmath79 , that is , @xmath80 ; @xmath81 ; @xmath82 and @xmath83 .
next , for any @xmath84 , let @xmath85 now , let @xmath58 be the constant appearing in ( [ main - result-1 ] ) .
we will split the construction of the coupling operator into two parts , according to @xmath9 with @xmath86 or with @xmath87 .
first , for any @xmath84 and @xmath9 with @xmath86 , we define @xmath88 \\ & & { } + \int _ { \{|z|\le a{|x - y| } \ } } \bigl(f(x+z , y+z)-f(x , y)-\bigl\langle \nabla_xf(x , y ) , z\bigr\rangle \mathbf{1}_{\ { \\ & & \hspace*{63pt}{}-\bigl\langle\nabla_yf(x , y ) , z\bigr\rangle \mathbf{1}_{\{|z|\le 1\ } } \bigr ) \biggl(\nu(\mathrm{d } z)-\frac{c_{d,\alpha}}{|z|^{d+\alpha}}\ , \mathrm{d}z \biggr ) \\ & & { } + \int _ { \{|z|>a{|x - y| } \ } } \bigl(f(x+z , y+z)-f(x , y)-\bigl\langle \nabla_xf(x , y ) , z\bigr\rangle \mathbf{1}_{\{|z|\le1\ } } \\ & & \hspace*{63pt}{}-\bigl\langle\nabla_yf(x , y ) , z\bigr\rangle \mathbf{1}_{\{|z|\le1\ } } \bigr ) \nu(\mathrm{d}z ) \\ & & { } + \bigl\langle\nabla_x f(x , y ) , b(x)\bigr\rangle+ \bigl \langle\nabla_y f(x , y ) , b(y)\bigr\rangle,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath89 is a constant determined by later .
on the other hand , for any @xmath84 and @xmath90 with @xmath87 , we define @xmath91 we can conclude the following .
the operator @xmath92 defined by above is the coupling operator of the operator @xmath73 given by ( [ ope-0 ] ) .
since @xmath93 is a linear operator , it suffices to verify that @xmath94 where , on the left - hand side , @xmath95 is regarded as a bivariate function on @xmath96 , that is , @xmath97 for all @xmath98 . for any @xmath9 with @xmath87 ,
it is trivial to see that ( [ coup - proof ] ) holds true , and so we only need to verify that for @xmath90 with @xmath86 .
first , we have @xmath99 \\ & & { } + \int _ { \{|z|\le a{|x - y| } \ } } \bigl(f(x+z)-f(x)-\bigl\langle \nabla f(x ) , z\bigr\rangle \mathbf{1}_{\{|z|\le1\ } } \bigr ) \biggl(\nu ( \mathrm{d}z)- \frac { c_{d,\alpha}}{|z|^{d+\alpha } } \,\mathrm{d}z \biggr ) \\ & & { } + \int _ { \{|z| >
a{|x - y| } \ } } \bigl(f(x+z)-f(x)-\bigl\langle \nabla f(x ) , z\bigr\rangle \mathbf{1}_{\{|z|\le1\ } } \bigr ) \nu(\mathrm { d}z ) \\ & & { } + \bigl\langle b(x),\nabla f(x)\bigr\rangle.\end{aligned}\ ] ] by ( a1 ) and ( a2 ) , we know that the measure @xmath100 is invariant under the transformation @xmath101 .
this , along with ( a2 ) and the equality above , leads to @xmath102 this completes the proof .
\(1 ) here , we give an interpretation of the construction of the coupling operator @xmath103 above .
if @xmath87 , we use the synchronous coupling . if @xmath86 , then the coupling operator @xmath92 constructed above consists of two parts .
fix any @xmath104 .
if @xmath105 , then we adopt the coupling by reflection by making full use of the rotationally invariant measure @xmath106 ; while for the remainder term , we use the synchronous coupling again , where the components maintain at each step the same length of jumps ( i.e. , from @xmath107 to @xmath108 ) with the biggest rate @xmath109 when @xmath110 , and with the rate @xmath111 when @xmath105 . for the coupling by reflection for brownian motion and diffusion processes , we refer to .
\(2 ) recently , the coupling property of lvy processes has been developed in @xcite .
the corresponding property for ornstein uhlenbeck processes with jumps also has been successfully studied in @xcite . unlike lvy processes and ornstein uhlenbeck processes with jumps , it is impossible to write out an explicit expression for transition functions of the solution to the sde ( [ ito - sde ] ) with general drift term @xmath112 .
this observation indicates that all the approaches in @xcite are not efficient in the present setting .
this difficulty will be overcome by constructing proper coupling operators for the markov generator corresponding to the solution of the sde ( [ ito - sde ] ) , as done in @xcite
. however , different from @xcite which deals with the corresponding coupling property by making full use of large jumps part of lvy processes , here to consider the exponential contractivity of the associated semigroups @xmath0 with respect to wasserstein distances we need a new construction of the coupling operator .
as seen from propositions [ key1 ] and [ key2 ] below , the coupling for small jumps part of lvy processes [ i.e. , the coupling by reflection as mentioned in ( 1 ) ] is key for our purpose . in this part
, we will construct a coupling process associated with the coupling operator @xmath92 .
for this , we will frequently talk about the martingale problem for the operator @xmath73 given by ( [ ope-0 ] ) and the coupling operator @xmath92 .
let @xmath113 be the space of right continuous @xmath6-valued functions having left limits on @xmath114 , equipped with the skorokhod topology .
for @xmath115 , denote by @xmath25 the projection coordinate map on @xmath113 . a probability measure @xmath116 on the skorokhod space @xmath113
is said to be a solution to the martingale problem for @xmath117 with initial value @xmath118 if @xmath119 and for every @xmath120 @xmath121 is a @xmath116-martingale .
the martingale problem for @xmath117 is said to be well - posed if it has a unique solution for every initial value @xmath118 .
similarly , we can define a solution to the martingale problem for the coupling operator @xmath92 on @xmath122 .
note that , in @xcite an equivalence is proved between the existence of weak solutions to sdes with jumps and the existence of solutions to the corresponding martingale problem , by using a martingale representation theorem .
recently , kurtz @xcite studied equivalence between the uniqueness ( in sense of distribution ) of weak solutions to a class of sdes driven by poisson random measures and the well - posed solution to martingale problems for a class of non - local operators using a non - constructive approach .
note that in our setting the sde ( [ ito - sde ] ) has the pathwise unique strong solution . according to @xcite , theorem 1 , page 2 , the weak solution to
the sde ( [ ito - sde ] ) enjoys the unique ( in sense of distribution ) weak solution .
this , along with @xcite , corollary 2.5 , yields that the martingale problem for @xmath117 is well posed .
let @xmath123 be the constants in the definition of the coupling operator @xmath92 .
for any @xmath39 , @xmath40 and @xmath124 , set @xmath125 then , for any @xmath39 , @xmath40 and @xmath126 , we have @xmath127 { \mu } ( x , y,\mathrm{d}u_1,\mathrm{d}u_2 ) \\ & & \qquad { } + \bigl\langle\nabla_x f(x , y),b(x)\bigr\rangle+ \bigl\langle \nabla_y
f(x , y),b(y)\bigr\rangle.\end{aligned}\ ] ] furthermore , for any @xmath128 , by ( a2 ) , @xmath129 which implies that @xmath130 is a continuous function on @xmath96 .
note that @xmath112 is a continuous function on @xmath6 . according to @xcite , theorem 2.2
, there is a solution to the martingale problem for @xmath93 , that is , there exist a probability space @xmath131 and an @xmath132-valued process @xmath133 such that @xmath133 is @xmath134-progressively measurable , and for every @xmath84 , @xmath135 is an @xmath134-local martingale , where @xmath136 is the explosion time of @xmath133 , that is , @xmath137 let @xmath138 .
then @xmath139 and @xmath140 are two stochastic processes on @xmath141 .
since @xmath93 is the coupling operator of @xmath73 , the generator of each marginal process @xmath139 and @xmath140 is just the operator @xmath73 , and hence both distributions of the processes @xmath139 and @xmath140 are solutions to the martingale problem of @xmath73 . in particular , by our assumption and the remark in the beginning of this subsection , the processes @xmath139 and @xmath140 are non - explosive , hence one has @xmath142 a.s .
therefore , the coupling operator @xmath93 generates a non - explosive process @xmath133 .
let @xmath143 be the coupling time of @xmath139 and @xmath140 , that is , @xmath144 then @xmath143 is an @xmath145-stopping time .
define a new process @xmath146 as follows :
@xmath147 for any @xmath148 and @xmath16 , @xmath149 by the optimal stopping theorem and the facts that both @xmath150 and @xmath140 are solutions to the martingale problem of @xmath73 , @xmath151 and @xmath152 are martingales and so is @xmath153 ( see , e.g. , @xcite , section 3.1 , page 251 ) .
since the martingale problem for the operator @xmath73 is well - posed , @xmath153 and @xmath140 are equal in the distribution .
therefore , we conclude that @xmath154 is also a non - explosive coupling process of @xmath70 such that @xmath155 for any @xmath156 and the generator of @xmath154 before the coupling time @xmath143 is just the coupling operator @xmath93 .
in particular , according to @xcite , lemma 2.1 , we know that for any @xmath39 , @xmath40 and @xmath157 , @xmath158 and @xmath159 where @xmath160 is the expectation of the process @xmath154 with starting point @xmath107 .
we first assume that @xmath7 . for any @xmath161 , define @xmath162 $ ; \vspace*{3pt}\cr a\mathrm{e}^{c_2(r-2l_0)}+b(r-2l_0)^2 + \bigl(1-\mathrm{e}^{-2c_1l_0}-a \bigr ) , & \quad $ r\in [ 2l_0,\infty)$,}\ ] ] where @xmath163 @xmath164 is a positive constant such that @xmath165 , that is , @xmath166 and @xmath167 is a positive constant determined by later . with the choice of the constants @xmath168 and @xmath169 above ,
it is easy to see that @xmath170 .
then we have : [ key1 ] assume that @xmath7 .
then there exists a constant @xmath171 such that for any @xmath9 ,
@xmath172 \(1 ) in this part , we treat the case that @xmath104 with @xmath86 .
first , for any @xmath173 , by ( a3 ) , @xmath174 and so @xmath175 therefore , @xmath176 \\ & & \qquad\quad { } + \psi'\bigl(|x - y|\bigr ) \frac{\langle b(x)-b(y),x - y\rangle}{|x - y|}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is easy to see that @xmath177 such that @xmath178 , @xmath179 and @xmath180 on @xmath181 .
then , for any @xmath182 , @xmath183 where in the inequality we have used the fact that @xmath180 on @xmath181 . hence , according to the definition of @xmath184 and the inequality above , for all @xmath185 with @xmath86 and @xmath105 with @xmath89 , we have @xmath186 then we deduce that for any @xmath39 , @xmath40 with @xmath86 , @xmath187 c_1\mathrm{e}^{-c_1|x - y|}|x - y|,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where in the inequality @xmath188 denotes the first coordinate of @xmath189 , that is , @xmath190 , both equalities above follow from the rotationally invariant property of the measure @xmath100 , and in the last inequality we have used ( [ main - result-1 ] ) and the fact that @xmath191 .
now , taking @xmath192 we find that for any @xmath39 , @xmath40 with @xmath86 , @xmath193 since @xmath194 and @xmath195 on @xmath181 , @xmath196,\ ] ] which along with the estimate above yields that for any @xmath39 , @xmath40 with @xmath86 , @xmath197 where @xmath198 .
\(2 ) second , we consider the case that @xmath9 with @xmath199 . for any @xmath39 ,
@xmath40 with latexmath:[$l_0 < @xmath178 , @xmath201 on the other hand , also by ( [ main - result-1 ] ) and the fact that @xmath202 , for any @xmath9 with @xmath203 , @xmath204 |x - y|^{\theta-1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] next , we consider the function @xmath205 on @xmath206 .
it is easy to see that due to the definitions of the constants @xmath168 and @xmath169 , there is a unique @xmath207 such that @xmath208 and @xmath209= \frac { -2b}{c_2 } \biggl[1-\log \frac{2(c_1+c_2)}{c_2 } \biggr].\ ] ] since @xmath210 is large enough such that @xmath211 we have @xmath212 , which implies that @xmath213 for all @xmath214 . in particular , @xmath215 for any @xmath9 with @xmath203 .
that is , for any @xmath9 with @xmath203 , @xmath216 combining both estimates above with the definition of @xmath217 , we finally conclude that there is a constant @xmath218 such that for any @xmath39 , @xmath40 with @xmath87 , @xmath219 this along with the conclusion of part ( 1 ) yields the desired assertion .
next , we turn to the case of @xmath49 $ ] . for this , we first take the constant @xmath220 in the definition of the coupling operator @xmath93 , and then change the test function @xmath217 as follows , which is different from that in the case @xmath7 . for any @xmath161 , we define @xmath221 $ ; \vspace*{3pt}\cr a\mathrm{e}^{c_0(r-2l_0)}+b(r-2l_0)^2 + \bigl(2l_0-c(2l_0)^{1+\alpha}-a \bigr ) , & \quad $ r\in [ 2l_0,\infty)$,}\ ] ] where @xmath222,\qquad c_0= \frac{10\alpha}{l_0}.\ ] ] due to the choice of the constants above , @xmath223 and @xmath224 for all @xmath161 . [ key2 ]
assume that @xmath49 $ ] .
if @xmath225 then there exists a constant @xmath171 such that for any @xmath9 with @xmath226 , @xmath172 we mainly follow the proof of proposition [ key1 ] , and here we only present the main different steps . for @xmath9 with @xmath86 , we have @xmath227 & & \quad=\frac{1}{2 } \biggl[\int _ { \{|z|\le ( { 1}/{4}){|x - y| } \ } } \bigl(\psi \bigl ( \bigl|x - y+\bigl(z-\varphi_{x , y}(z)\bigr ) \bigr| \bigr)+\psi \bigl ( \bigl|x - y-\bigl(z- \varphi_{x , y}(z)\bigr ) \bigr| \bigr ) \\[-2pt ] & & \hspace*{12pt}\qquad{}-2\psi\bigl(|x - y|\bigr ) \bigr)\frac{c_{d,\alpha}}{|z|^{d+\alpha } } \,\mathrm{d } z \biggr ] \\[-2pt ] & & \qquad { } + \psi'\bigl(|x - y|\bigr ) \frac{\langle b(x)-b(y),x - y\rangle}{|x - y|}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath228 such that @xmath178 , @xmath179 and @xmath180 on @xmath229 , one can follow the proof of ( [ proof - one ] ) , and get that for all @xmath185 with @xmath230 and @xmath231 , @xmath232 & & \quad\leq4\psi '' \biggl(\frac{3}{2}|x - y| \biggr ) \frac{\langle x - y , z\rangle ^2}{|x - y|^2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] then we follow the argument of ( [ proof - two ] ) and deduce that for any @xmath39 , @xmath40 with @xmath233 , @xmath234|x - y|.\end{aligned}\ ] ] by assumption ( [ con - d1 ] ) , we know that for all @xmath104 with @xmath233 , @xmath235 next , we turn to the case that @xmath9 with @xmath199 . for any @xmath39 ,
@xmath40 with @xmath236 , by ( [ main - result-1 ] ) and @xmath178 , @xmath237 on the other hand , also by ( [ main - result-1 ] ) and the fact that @xmath202 , for any @xmath9 with @xmath203 , @xmath238 |x - y|^{\theta-1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] now , we consider again the function @xmath239 on @xmath206 .
it is easy to see that due to the definitions of the constants @xmath168 and @xmath169 , there is a unique @xmath207 such that @xmath208 and @xmath240= \frac { -2b}{c_0 } \biggl[1-\log \biggl(2+\frac{\alpha}{l_0c_0 } \biggr ) \biggr].\ ] ] noticing that @xmath241 , we get @xmath242 and so @xmath212 , which implies that @xmath213 for all @xmath214 . in particular , @xmath243 for any @xmath9 with @xmath203 .
that is , for any @xmath9 with @xmath203 , @xmath244 according to both estimates above and the definition of @xmath217 , we finally conclude that there is a constant @xmath218 such that for any @xmath39 , @xmath40 with @xmath87 , @xmath219 this along with the conclusion above yields the desired assertion .
[ main-1 - 1 ] according to the argument above , we can easily improve ( [ con - d1 ] ) , for example , by taking @xmath245 for @xmath246 $ ] and changing the integral domain @xmath247 in the definition of the coupling operator @xmath93 into @xmath248 with some proper choices of @xmath249 , @xmath250 $ ] and @xmath251 .
for simplicity , here we just set @xmath252 , @xmath253 , @xmath254 and @xmath255 .
we divide the proof of theorem [ main - result ] into two parts .
proof of theorem [ main - result ] for @xmath86 or @xmath53 we will make full use of the coupling process @xmath256 constructed in section [ section22 ]
. denote by @xmath257 and @xmath160 the distribution and the expectation of @xmath256 starting from @xmath107 , respectively .
for any @xmath16 set @xmath258 , and for @xmath259 define the stopping time @xmath260\bigr\}.\ ] ] for any @xmath39 , @xmath40 with @xmath261 , we take @xmath262 large enough such that @xmath263 .
let @xmath217 be the function given in proposition [ key1 ] if @xmath7 or the function given in proposition [ key2 ] if @xmath49 $ ] .
then @xmath264 therefore , @xmath265\leq\psi(r_0 ) \mathrm{e}^{-\lambda t}.\ ] ] since the coupling process @xmath256 is non - explosive , we have @xmath266 a.s . as @xmath267 , where @xmath143 is the coupling time of the process @xmath268 .
thus , by fatou s lemma , letting @xmath267 in the above inequality gives us @xmath269\leq\psi(r_0)\mathrm{e}^{-\lambda t}.\ ] ] thanks to our convention that @xmath270 for @xmath271 , we have @xmath272 for all @xmath271 , and so @xmath273 that is , @xmath274 as a result , if @xmath86 , then for any @xmath37 and @xmath16 , @xmath275 where the first inequality follows from the definitions of the test function @xmath217 in propositions [ key1 ] and [ key2 ] .
now for any @xmath9 with @xmath276 , take @xmath277 + 1\geq2 $ ] .
we have @xmath278 set @xmath279 for @xmath280
. then @xmath281 and @xmath282 ; moreover , ( [ proof.2 ] ) implies @xmath283 for all @xmath284 .
therefore , by ( [ small ] ) and ( [ proof.2 ] ) , @xmath285 in particular , the proof of the first assertion for @xmath53 in theorem [ main - result ] is completed . on the other hand , from ( [ small ] ) and the conclusion above , we also get the second assertion for @xmath55 with @xmath286 and all @xmath16 , or with @xmath287 and @xmath288 .
next , we turn to : proof of theorem [ main - result ] for @xmath199 and @xmath55 for @xmath87 , we use the synchronous coupling and the assertion of theorem @xmath289 for @xmath86 . in detail , with ( [ ito - sde ] ) ,
let @xmath290 be the coupling process on @xmath96 such that its distribution is the same as that of @xmath256 constructed in section [ section22 ] .
we now consider @xmath291 where @xmath292 and @xmath293 is the coupling time .
for @xmath271 , we still set @xmath294 .
therefore , the difference process @xmath295 satisfies @xmath296 note that the equality above implies that @xmath297 is a continuous function on @xmath298 such that @xmath299 . as a result , @xmath300 still denoting by @xmath301 , we get from ( [ main - result-1 ] ) that @xmath302 which implies that @xmath303 since @xmath55 and the continuity of @xmath304 on @xmath298 .
therefore , for any @xmath9 with @xmath87 , @xmath37 and @xmath305 , we have @xmath306 \\ & \le & c_1\mathbb{e } \bigl[|x_{t_{l_0}}-y_{t_{l_0}}|\mathrm{e}^{-\lambda ( t - t_{l_0 } ) } \bigr ] \\ & \le & c_1 l_0\exp(\lambda t_0 ) \mathrm{e}^{-\lambda t},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where in the first inequality we have used ( [ small ] ) , and the last inequality follows from ( [ rrr2 ] ) and the fact that @xmath307 . in particular , we have for all @xmath276 and @xmath305 , @xmath308 combining with all conclusions above , we complete the proof of the second assertion in theorem [ main - result ] .
we finally present the following .
proof of example [ 1-example-2 ] in this example , @xmath309 it follows from the proof of @xcite , example 5.3 , that for any @xmath90 , @xmath310 then , ( [ main - result-1 ] ) holds with @xmath311 , @xmath312 and any positive constants @xmath313 . in particular , ( [ main - result-1 - 1 ] ) holds for all @xmath49 $ ] and @xmath314 small enough .
then the required assertion is a direct consequence of theorem [ main - result ] .
the author would like to thank professor feng - yu wang and the referee for helpful comments and careful corrections .
financial support through nsfc ( no .
11201073 ) , jsps ( no .
26@xmath31504021 ) , nsf - fujian ( no .
2015j01003 ) and the program for nonlinear analysis and its applications ( no .
irtl1206 ) are gratefully acknowledged . | coupling by reflection mixed with synchronous coupling is constructed for a class of stochastic differential equations ( sdes ) driven by lvy noises . as an application
, we establish the exponential contractivity of the associated semigroups @xmath0 with respect to the standard @xmath1-wasserstein distance for all @xmath2 .
in particular , consider the following sde : @xmath3 where @xmath4 is a symmetric @xmath5-stable process on @xmath6 with @xmath7 .
we show that if the drift term @xmath8 satisfies that for any @xmath9 , @xmath10 holds with some positive constants @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 and @xmath14 , then there is a constant @xmath15 such that for all @xmath2 , @xmath16 and @xmath9 , @xmath17.\ ] ] ./style / arxiv - general.cfg |
our purpose is to provide a description of the semileptonic decays of the tau lepton that incorporates as many theoretical restrictions derived from the fundamental interaction , @xmath0 @xcite , as possible .
this is a very convenient scenario to investigate the hadronization of @xmath0 because one fermionic current is purely leptonic and thus calculable unambiguously so that we can concentrate our efforts on the other one , involving light quarks coupled to a @xmath3 current .
+ the decay amplitude for the considered decays may be written as : @xmath4 where the strong interacting part is encoded in the hadronic vector , @xmath5 : @xmath6 symmetries let us decompose @xmath5 depending on the number of final - state pseudoscalar ( @xmath7 ) mesons , @xmath8 .
+ one meson tau decays can be predicted in terms of the measured processes @xmath9 , since the matrix elements are related .
this provides a precise test of charged current universality @xcite . on the other side
, it can not tell anything new on hadronization . + the two - pion tau decay is conventionally parameterized -in the isospin limit , that we always assume- just in terms of the vector ( @xmath10 ) form factor of the pion , @xmath11 : @xmath12 where @xmath13 .
+ because @xmath14 is broken appreciably by the difference between @xmath15 and @xmath16 , two form factors are needed to describe the decays involving one pion and one kaon : @xmath17 where @xmath18 .
@xmath19 carries quantum numbers @xmath20 , while @xmath21 is the pseudoscalar form factor ( @xmath22 ) .
other two meson decays can be treated similarly and one should take advantage of the fact that chiral symmetry relates some of their matrix elements .
+ for three mesons in the final state , the most general decomposition reads : @xmath23 and @xmath24 @xmath25 , @xmath26 , correspond to the axial - vector current ( @xmath27 ) while @xmath28 drives the vector current ( @xmath29 ) . the form factors @xmath30 and @xmath31 have a transverse structure in the total hadron momenta , @xmath32 , and drive a @xmath33 transition . the pseudoscalar form factor , @xmath34 , vanishes as @xmath35 and , accordingly , gives a tiny contribution .
higher - multiplicity modes can be described proceeding similarly @xcite .
this is as far as we can go without model assumptions , that is , it is not yet known how to obtain the @xmath25 from @xmath0 .
however , one can derive some of their properties from the underlying theory , as we will explain in the following .
we use a phenomenological lagrangian @xcite written in terms of the relevant degrees of freedom that become active through the energy interval spanned by hadronic tau decays .
the chiral symmetry of massless @xmath0 determines @xcite the chiral invariant operators that can be written including the lightest mesons in the spectrum , the pseudoscalar ones belonging to the pion multiplet .
it was carefully checked @xcite that -as one expects- chiral perturbation theory , @xmath36 , can only describe a little very - low - energy part of semileptonic tau decays .
+ then one may attempt to extend the range of applicability of @xmath36 to higher energies while keeping its predictions for the form factors at low momentum : this is the purpose of resonance chiral theory , @xmath37 , @xcite that includes the light - flavoured resonances as explicit fields in the action .
+ at @xmath38 in the @xmath39 limit of @xmath0 @xcite one has as infinite tower of stable mesons that experience local effective interactions at tree level .
we depart from this picture in two ways : * we incorporate the widths of the resonances worked out consistently within @xmath40 @xcite . *
we attempt a description including the least possible number of resonance fields reducing -ideally- to the single resonance approximation , @xmath41 @xcite .
we take vector meson dominance into account when writing our lagrangian .
thus , it will consist of terms accounting for the following interactions ( @xmath42 , @xmath43 stand for the axial(-vector ) currents and @xmath44 and @xmath45 for the axial(-vector ) resonances ) : * those in @xmath36 at @xmath38 and @xmath36-like : @xmath46 , @xmath47 , @xmath48 with even - intrinsic parity ; and @xmath49 in the odd - intrinsic parity sector . * those relevant in @xmath40 -@xmath50 @xmath36 operators are not included to avoid double counting , since they are recovered and their couplings are saturated upon integration of the resonance contributions @xcite- .
they include : @xmath51 , @xmath52 , @xmath53 , @xmath54 and @xmath55 in the even - intrinsic parity sector and @xmath56 , @xmath57 and @xmath58 in the odd - parity one .
the explicit form of the operators and the naming for the couplings can be read from @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and @xcite .
+ the @xmath40 just determined by symmetries does not share the @xmath59 @xmath0 behaviour yet . for this , and for our purposes , we need to impose appropriate brodsky - lepage conditions @xcite on the relevant form factors .
explicit computation and these short - distance restrictions reduce appreciably the number of independent couplings entering the amplitudes which enables us to end up with a useful -that is , predictive- theory .
our framework describes pretty well the two - meson decays of the @xmath2 , as shown in the @xmath60 @xcite and @xmath61 @xcite cases .
two - meson modes including @xmath62 can be worked analogously .
the data in these modes are so precise that although the @xmath41 describes the gross features of the data , one needs to include the first excitations of the @xmath45 resonances to achieve an accurate description .
although @xmath19 is much more important than @xmath21 , one needs an appropriate pseudoscalar form factor to fit well the data , specially close to threshold @xcite .
+ the three meson modes are much more involved .
however , a good description of the data has been achieved through a careful study @xcite taking into account all theory constrains and experimental data on the @xmath63 and @xmath64 channels .
we predict the @xmath64 spectral function and conclude that the vector current contribution can not be neglected in these modes .
we will study the other three meson modes along the same lines .
in particular , our study of the @xmath65 channels might help improve the simultaneous extraction of @xmath15 and @xmath66 @xcite .
our expressions for the vector and axial - vector widths and the hadronic matrix elements have been implemented successfully in the tauola library @xcite .
this way , the experimental comunity will have as its disposal a way of analysing hadronic decays of the tau that includes as much as possible information from the fundamental theory
. we also plan to study @xmath67 at low energies what can eventually be used by @xcite .
i congratulate the local organizing committee for this first edition of the young researchers workshop as well as for the xiv lnf spring school bruno touschek held in parallel .
i am grateful to jorge portols for a careful revision and useful suggestions on the draft .
i acknowledge useful discussions with olga shekhovtsova . this work has been supported in part by the eu mrtn - ct-2006 - 035482 ( flavianet ) and by the dfg cluster of excellence origin and structure of the universe .
99 h. fritzsch , m. gell - mann and h. leutwyler , phys .
b * 47 * ( 1973 ) 365 .
d. j. gross and f. wilczek , phys .
* 30 * ( 1973 ) 1343 .
h. d. politzer , phys .
lett . * 30 * ( 1973 ) 1346 .
a. pich , nucl .
phys . proc
. suppl .
* 98 * ( 2001 ) 385 .
suppl . *
181 - 182 * ( 2008 ) 300 .
r. fischer , j. wess and f. wagner , z. phys .
c * 3 * ( 1979 ) 313 .
s. weinberg , physica a * 96 * ( 1979 ) 327 .
j. gasser and h. leutwyler , annals phys .
* 158 * ( 1984 ) 142 .
b * 250 * ( 1985 ) 465 .
g. colangelo , m. finkemeier and r. urech , phys .
d * 54 * ( 1996 ) 4403 .
g. ecker , j. gasser , a. pich and e. de rafael , nucl .
b * 321 * ( 1989 ) 311 .
g. ecker , j. gasser , h. leutwyler , a. pich and e. de rafael , phys .
b * 223 * ( 1989 ) 425 .
g. t hooft , nucl .
b * 72 * ( 1974 ) 461 , * 75 * ( 1974 ) 461 .
e. witten , nucl .
b * 160 * ( 1979 ) 57 .
d. gmez dumm , a. pich and j. portols , phys .
d * 62 * ( 2000 ) 054014 .
m. knecht , s. peris , m. perrottet and e. de rafael , phys .
lett . * 83 * ( 1999 ) 5230 .
d. ruiz - femena , a. pich and j. portols , jhep * 0307 * ( 2003 ) 003 .
d. gmez dumm , a. pich and j. portols , phys .
d * 69 * ( 2004 ) 073002 . v. cirigliano , g. ecker , m. eidemller , a. pich and j. portols , phys .
b * 596 * ( 2004 ) 96 .
p. roig , aip conf .
* 964 * ( 2007 ) 40 .
d. gmez - dumm , p. roig , a. pich , j. portols , to appear .
s. j. brodsky and g. r. farrar , phys .
* 31 * ( 1973 ) 1153 .
g. p. lepage and s. j. brodsky , phys .
d * 22 * ( 1980 ) 2157 .
f. guerrero and a. pich , phys .
b * 412 * ( 1997 ) 382 .
a. pich and j. portols , phys .
d * 63 * ( 2001 ) 093005 .
* 121 * ( 2003 ) 179 .
m. jamin , a. pich and j. portols , phys .
b * 640 * ( 2006 ) 176 phys .
b * 664 * ( 2008 ) 78 .
e. gmiz , m. jamin , a. pich , j. prades and f. schwab , phys .
* 94 * ( 2005 ) 011803 .
o.shekhovtsova , private communication . | we study two and three meson decays of the tau lepton within the framework of the resonance chiral theory , that is based on the following properties of @xmath0 : its chiral symmetry in the massless case , its large-@xmath1 limit , and the asymptotic behaviour it demands to the relevant form factors .
+ most of the couplings in the lagrangian are determined this way rendering the theory predictive .
our outcomes can be tested thanks to the combination of a very good experimental effort ( current and forthcoming , at b- and tau - charm - factories ) and the very accurate devoted monte carlo generators .
= 11.6pt |
a pair of compact objects ( black holes or neutron stars ) in binary orbit about one another is stable in newtonian gravity . in general relativity , however , the system will emit gravitational radiation , causing the bodies to spiral in towards one another .
the gravitational radiation given off by this system is a prime candidate for detection by upcoming gravitational wave telescopes such as virgo and ligo
. when the compact objects are far apart , all gravitational effects are weak and one can use the post - newtonian approximation , expanding in powers of @xmath1 . the final `` plunge '' , where the objects cease to orbit and collide rapidly , can be modelled by full general relativistic three - plus - one supercomputer simulations .
an intermediate late inspiral phase , where strong gravitational effects are important , but the fraction of total energy lost to gravitational radiation each orbit is small , can not be handled by supercomputer evolutions , which become unstable after several orbits . to handle strong gravity and slow inspiral
, we need to use an approximation scheme .
modelling this intermediate phase will allow us to determine the early gravitational wave signal as well as provide initial data for the final plunge simulations .
the idea , initially proposed by steven detweiler @xcite , is that if the inspiral is slow , the system is nearly periodic : after one orbit , the objects have returned almost to their original locations , and radiation which has moved out has been replaced with new radiation of approximately the same shape . if the objects orbits are circular rather than elliptical , the spacetime is nearly stationary . if the approximate orbital frequency is @xmath2 , moving forward in time by @xmath3 and rotating the resulting spatial slice by @xmath4 will not change the picture very much .
our approach is to replace the true spacetime , which has this approximate continuous symmetry , with another solution to einstein s equations in which the symmetry is exact .
this `` stationary quasi - solution '' , which must somehow replace the energy lost in radiation to prevent inspiral , should approximate the physical `` quasi - stationary solution '' over some time interval .
this replaces a three - plus - one - dimensional numerical evolution with a three - dimensional instantaneous solution , reducing greatly the computing power required and hopefully escaping some of the numerical instabilities associated with evolution . to further simplify the problem
, we will initially look for a spacetime with an additional translational symmetry orthogonal to the orbital plane .
this toy model of co - orbiting cosmic strings further reduces the numerical problem to two dimensions while hopefully retaining some of the qualitative features .
the rest of this paper consists of summaries of three techniques being developed for this project , but which may prove useful in other settings as well .
section [ sec:2kv ] describes research done in collaboration with joseph d. romano @xcite on the refinement of a formalism developed by geroch @xcite to simplify the einstein equations when the spacetime admits two commuting killing vectors , as is the case with the co - orbiting cosmic string model .
section [ sec : radbal ] discusses the construction of a stationary radiating solution to a wave equation without the use of external forces by finding a preferred solution containing a balance of incoming and outgoing radiation , the subject of a collaboration with william krivan and richard h. price @xcite .
section [ sec : cyl ] briefly touches on the concept of describing small - amplitude gravitational radiation as a perturbation not to minkowski spacetime but to the levi - civita solution @xcite for a single cosmic string .
the spacetime of two co - orbiting cosmic strings has two continuous symmetries , which are described by two killing vector fields .
one of these , which we call @xmath5 , represents the combination of time translation and rotation about the orbital axis which leaves the spacetime unchanged .
it can be thought of roughly in terms of traditional cylindrical cordinates as @xmath6 .
the other killing vector simply corresponds to translation along the strings and can be thought of as @xmath7 . in a numerical determination of the spacetime geometry ,
one seeks to fix the cordinate ( i.e. , gauge ) information completely , and thus calculate the minimum number of quantities necessary to define the geometry .
it is desirable , of course , to choose a gauge which takes advantage of the symmetries of the problem .
following from the example of static , axisymmetric spacetimes @xcite , we might wish to define two killing cordinates @xmath8 ( @xmath9 , @xmath10 ) , supplemented by two other cordinates @xmath11 ( @xmath12 , @xmath13 ) on a subspace orthogonal to the two killing vectors , and bring the line element into a block - diagonal form @xmath14 for our set of killing symmetries , however , this fails because the symmetry group is not _ orthogonally transitive _ , which means that it is impossible to construct two - surfaces everywhere orthogonal to both killing vector trajectories .
the measure of this failure is a pair of scalar fields @xmath15 given by @xmath16 the co - rotational killing vector @xmath5 is not surface - forming ( @xmath17 ) , which leads to the non - vanishing of @xmath18 , indicating a lack of orthogonal transitivity .
although the metric components in any cordinate basis will have non - vanishing `` cross terms '' @xmath19 between the killing and non - killing directions , it still possible to describe the geometry in terms of two matrices @xmath20 and @xmath21 along with the two scalars @xmath18 and @xmath22 .
this done using a construction due to geroch @xcite which defines a two - manifold @xmath23 of killing vector orbits .
the cordinates @xmath24 are cordinates on this two - manifold , and any tensor on the original four - dimensional spacetime manifold @xmath25 which has vanishing inner products with , and lie derivatives along , the killing vectors corresponds to a tensor on the two - manifold @xmath23 . in particular , the tensors and scalars on @xmath23 which describe the spacetime geometry are * the symmetric matrix of inner products @xmath26 * the metric on @xmath23 , which has components @xmath21 and corresponds to the projection tensor @xmath27 on @xmath25 ( where @xmath28 is the inverse of @xmath20 ) * the two scalars @xmath29 which define the lack of orthogonal transitivity . given these objects , it is possible to define a non - cordinate basis on the four - dimensional spacetime by @xmath30 and @xmath31 .
in this basis the metric has components @xmath32 the @xmath15 give the commutation cofficients of the non - commuting basis vectors : @xmath33\propto \lambda^{ab}c_a k_b\,.\ ] ] geroch s original paper contained four partial differential equations involving @xmath21 , @xmath34 , @xmath35 , @xmath36 , @xmath18 , and @xmath22 which were equivalent to the vacuum einstein equations @xmath37 .
we have found a streamlined derivation which treats the indexed quantities @xmath38 and @xmath29 as single entities , rather than dealing with each component individually .
we have also derived explicit expressions ( given in @xcite ) for the components @xmath39 , @xmath40 , and @xmath41 which can be used even when the stress - energy tensor is non - vanishing . in the case
where the off - block - diagonal components @xmath42 of the stress - energy tensor vanish , the einstein equations @xmath43 simply say that the scalars @xmath29 are constants . a convenient choice of gauge in which to solve the remaining six einstein equations is a basis in which @xmath44 these four functions @xmath45 , @xmath46 , @xmath47 , and @xmath48 of the two cordinates @xmath49 and @xmath50 provide a fixed gauge in which the problem can be solved numerically .
there are six block - diagonal einstein equations ( for @xmath51 and @xmath52 ) , but only four of them are independent because of the contracted bianchi identities @xmath53 .
these equations will be combined with a treatment of the cosmic string sources and the boundary conditions at infinity and the origin to produce a numerically determined spacetime .
the true physical spacetime which we are ultimately modelling contains gravitational radiation at infinity which is outgoing .
this loss of energy leads to decay of the orbits and inspiral of the compact objects in a non - stationary solution . in many radiative problems ,
a solution with outgoing radiation can be constrained to be stationary by an external force whose agent does not couple to the radiation . however , this is at odds with the idea that in general relativity all matter gravitates , so we should look instead for a solution where there is no net energy loss to infinity due to the radiation . a nave replacement for the outgoing radiation boundary conditions would be a standing wave condition . however , that turns out to be inappropriate , as standing waves require a node ( dirichlet ) or extremum ( neumann ) at a particular location , and a standing wave condition thus fails to converge to a well - defined limit as that location is moved out to infinity .
we have been investigating the question of how to implement a sensible boundary condition leading to a balance of radiation in the context of a simple theory : a nonlinear scalar field @xmath54 in two - plus - one dimensions , where the source @xmath55 and field @xmath56 are required to be co - rotating ( i.e. , depend only on @xmath57 and @xmath58 ) .
this causes the field equation to take the form @xmath59 in the numerical solution for the non - linear equation ( [ coroteqn ] ) , one uses a finite cordinate grid and specifies a set of boundary conditions at the large finite radius @xmath60 which marks the end of the grid .
table [ tab:1 ] [ tab:1 ] .some large - distance boundary conditions . purely ingoing or outgoing radiation has a well - defined limit as the radius @xmath61 at which it is applied
is taken to infinity , but standing wave conditions ( e.g. , neumann or dirichlet ) do not . [ cols=">,^,^",options="header " , ] shows several possible boundary conditions .
we call , e.g. , the solution resulting from the application of the outgoing boundary condition at a particular @xmath61 , @xmath62 .
the local conditions defining outgoing or ingoing radiation each produce well - defined limits ( which we call simply @xmath63 and @xmath64 ) as @xmath61 is taken to infinity , but the standing wave solutions do not converge to any limit . taking the average of the @xmath65 limits @xmath63 and
@xmath64 defines a function @xmath66 which has a balance of ingoing and outgoing radiation without reference to any particular radius @xmath61 . in the linear ( @xmath67 ) theory , where the principle of superposition holds
, it is a solution to the field equations , but in the non - linear theory it is not .
it is also not defined as the limit of any local boundary conditions ( in particular , the is average of out- and ingoing solutions is not produced by an average of out- and ingoing boundary conditions ) .
the tasks of defining a solution analogous to @xmath68 and numerically determining that solution in the absence of a local boundary condition can both be accomplished by a green s function method . if we define a green s function @xmath69 such that @xmath70 the differential equation ( [ coroteqn ] ) can be converted into an integral equation @xmath71 \ , .\ ] ] solving to the green s function equation ( [ gfeqn ] ) requires the application of boundary conditions at infinity , so there are actually a family of green s functions with boundary conditions `` built into '' them . for example , using the retarded green s function @xmath72 in ( [ nlinteqn ] ) gives the outgoing solution @xmath63 , using the advanced green s function @xmath73 gives the ingoing solution @xmath64 , and similarly for any of the boundary conditions defined at finite radii in table [ tab:1 ] .
since the green s function equation ( [ gfeqn ] ) is linear , even when the wave equation ( [ coroteqn ] ) is not , we can always average the retarded and advanced _
green s functions _ to give a time - symmetric green s function @xmath74 which defines a radiation - balanced solution @xmath75 . in the linear theory ,
this solution @xmath75 will be equal to the average @xmath68 of the ingoing and outgoing solutions .
in the non - linear theory , we can calculate the two numerically ( by iterating ( [ nlinteqn ] ) ) and compare them .
we are ultimately trying to use the outgoing piece of @xmath75 as an approximation for @xmath63 ( and thus as a further approximation for the actual inspiralling solution ) , and we expect that approximation to be good when @xmath76 .
numerical calculations @xcite for a strongly non - linear ( @xmath77 ) theory have shown that the approximation becomes good as the orbital velocity of the sources becomes non - relativistic .
figures [ fig:.25c ] and [ fig:.125c ] show the comparison between @xmath75 and @xmath68 for orbital velocities of one - fourth and one - eighth the speed of light , respectively .
this agreement occurs even when the theory is highly nonlinear because , even though @xmath64 and @xmath63 differ in the wave zone , they are approximately the same in the inner , strong - field region , as illustrated in figure [ fig : try ] .
the final step in the scalar field theory analysis will be to numerically extract the `` outgoing part '' from the time - symmetric solution @xmath75 and compare it directly to @xmath63 ; we expect that the two will agree when @xmath75 is approximately equal to @xmath68 .
in the three - plus - one binary inspiral problem , with non - extended sources , gravitational waves at infinity can be treated as perturbations to minkowski spacetime .
this is because at large distances , where higher multipoles of the non - radiative field can be ignored , the non - radiative part of the geometry is associated with the schwarzschild metric @xmath78 which contains a length scale @xmath79 ; taking @xmath80 reduces the schwarzschild line element to the minkowski one , which is just another way of saying that the schwarzschild solution is asymptotically flat . with infinitely extended sources ,
this is not possible .
far from the strings , where the internal structure is not felt , the non - radiative effects are approximated by the levi - civita solution @xcite of a single cosmic string at the origin with mass - per - unit length @xmath81 , whose line element is given for small @xmath81 by @xmath82 the mass parameter @xmath83 is now dimensionless ; this lack of a length scale means that levi - civita spacetime is _ not _ asymptotically flat and we must use levi - civita rather than minkowski as our background metric .
suppose the metric is given by the levi - civita metric plus a small perturbation @xmath84 .
( in our problem the @xmath85 and @xmath86 dependence will further be restricted to a function of @xmath87 , but we are thinking here of more general considerations . ) we can divide the components @xmath88 into those which are odd under inversion of the @xmath89 cordinate ( @xmath90 , @xmath91 , and @xmath92 ) and those which are even ( @xmath93 , @xmath94 , @xmath95 , @xmath96 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 , and @xmath99 ) . in the linearized theory , the odd and even sectors are uncoupled . to count the physical degrees of freedom ,
we consider the effects of a gauge transformation @xmath100 by a gauge parameter @xmath101 , as well as the hamiltonian constraint @xmath102 and the three components @xmath103 of the momentum constraint .
the three odd components of the metric perturbation consist of one gauge degree of freedom @xmath104 , one constraint @xmath105 , and one physical degree of freedom , which can be thought of as the `` cross polarization '' ( since it involves @xmath92 ) .
the seven even components include three gauge degrees of freedom @xmath106 , @xmath107 , and @xmath108 , three constraints @xmath102 , @xmath109 , and @xmath110 , and one physical `` plus polarization '' involving @xmath93 and @xmath99 .
the next step in a treatment akin to that done by moncrief @xcite for waves on a schwarzschild background will be to derive explicit wave equations for these two gauge - invariant physical degrees of freedom .
for the purposes of the quasi - stationary binary inspiral program , it may suffice to work with linearized versions of the gauge - fixed equations derived in @xcite , but the picture of general perturbations to levi - civita will at least be useful in interpreting the quantities involved .
the work described in section [ sec:2kv ] has produced non - linear differential equations which can be numerically implemented given a suitable treatment of the sources and the boundary conditions on the radiation at the outer boundary .
the study of radiation balance in the context of non - linear scalar field theory in section [ sec : radbal ] will be completed by the extraction of the outgoing part of the time - symmetric green s function solution and the comparison between that and the actual outgoing solution ( which we expect to be unavailable in the gravitational case ) .
application of these methods to general relativity will be complicated by the fact that it is probably not possible to formulate a ( linear ) green s function solution to the non - linear wave equation in that case .
the analysis of perturbations to levi - civita spacetime described in section [ sec : cyl ] is still in the early stages , and its full development may or may not be necessary to the understanding of our problem , which possesses the additional co - rotational killing vector .
finally , should the technique of finding a stationary solution with a balance of ingoing and outgoing radiation prove successful in the essentially two - dimensional problem of orbiting cosmic strings , it can be applied to the computationally more intensive three - dimensional problem .
the author would like to thank his collaborators j. d. romano , w. krivan , r. h. price , as well as c. torre , k. thorne , j. creighton , j. friedmann , s. morsink , a. held , and the relativity group at the university of utah , where this work was begun , and acknowledge the financial support of nsf grant phy-9734871 , swiss nationalfonds , and the tomalla foundation zrich .
99 j. k. blackburn & s. detweiler , _ phys .
_ * d46 , * 2318 ( 1992 ) .
s. detweiler , _ phys .
_ * d50 , * 4929 ( 1994 ) . | i describe the current status of a collaboration with j. d. romano , r. h. price , and w. krivan to model the geometry of and gravitational radiation emitted by a binary system of compact objects in the regime where non - perturbative gravitational effects exist , but the rate of inspiral is still small relative to the orbital frequency .
the method of looking for a stationary spacetime which approximates the evolving solution is initially being tested on a simpler model with an additional translational symmetry .
this report consists of a general description of the method , followed by summaries of three techniques in varying stages of development : the simplification of the einstein equations in the presence of two commuting killing vectors which form a non - orthogonally - transitive symmetry group , the boundary conditions appropriate to the balance of ingoing and outgoing radiation needed to reconcile a stationary radiating solution with conservation of energy , and the treatment of gravitational waves far from the sources as linearized perturbations to the levi - civita spacetime .
the poster presentation with which this paper is associated is available on line at http://www-itp.unibe.ch/@xmath0whelan/poster.ps.gz and the current status of the project is described at http://www-itp.unibe.ch/@xmath0whelan/qsbi.html i="10 |
sec:0 a real lie algebra @xmath4 is called _ compact _ if it is the lie algebra of a compact lie group ( ( * ? ? ?
there are many characterizations of compact lie algebras : thm:0.1 for a finite dimensional real lie algebra @xmath4 , the following are equivalent : * @xmath4 is compact .
* @xmath4 carries a positive definite invariant symmetric bilinear form .
* @xmath4 has a faithful finite dimensional unitary representation , i.e. , it is isomorphic to a subalgebra of @xmath5 for some @xmath6 . in this paper
we discuss variants of compactness for finite dimensional real lie superalgebras .
\(a ) a lie superalgebra @xmath7 over a field @xmath8 of characteristic zero is called _ reductive _ if @xmath0 is a semisimple module for the lie algebra @xmath1 with respect to the adjoint representation .
it is called _ semisimple _ if it contains no non - zero solvable ideal .
a simple reductive lie superalgebra is called _ classical _ ( cf .
@xcite ) . for a lie superalgebra @xmath0
we always assume @xmath9 , unless otherwise stated .
\(b ) a real lie superalgebra @xmath0 is called _ compact _ if @xmath1 is a _ compactly embedded subalgebra _ , i.e. , the subgroup of @xmath10 generated by @xmath11 has compact closure . since this implies that @xmath0 is a semisimple @xmath1-module , compact lie superalgebras are reductive .
\(c ) a real lie superalgebra @xmath0 is called _ unitary _ if it has a faithful unitary representation , i.e. , if it is isomorphic to a subalgebra of some lie superalgebra @xmath12 .
if @xmath0 is a real lie algebra , i.e. , @xmath13 , then compactness and unitarity are the same by theorem [ thm:0.1 ] . for lie superalgebras
it is easy to see that unitarity implies compactness , but that the converse is false in general .
the main goal of this paper is to describe the structure of unitary lie superalgebras .
this is in particular motivated by the theory of unitary representations of lie supergroups ( @xcite , @xcite ) , for which a thorough understanding of the finite dimensional unitary lie superalgebras is a fundamental ingredient . in our structural analysis of unitary lie superalgebras
we proceed as follows . in section [ sec:1 ]
we describe the classification of compact simple lie superalgebras ( theorem [ thm:1.4 ] ) and discuss some of their relatives .
there are only @xmath14 families : @xmath15 this classification result is derived from parker s classification of real forms of classical lie superalgebras ( @xcite ) by inspecting which of these real forms are compact . in section [ sec:2 ]
we take a first closer look at special properties of unitary lie superalgebras .
a crucial property of a unitary lie superalgebra is the existence of linear functionals @xmath16 on @xmath1 for which the symmetric bilinear form @xmath17)$ ] on @xmath18 is positive definite .
this implies in particular that the closed convex cone @xmath19 generated by the elements @xmath20 $ ] , @xmath21 , is pointed and that @xmath1 has non - trivial center ( cf .
although these requirements fail for some simple compact lie superalgebras , they always possess unitary central extensions .
section [ sec:3 ] provides the main information on the decomposition of reductive lie superalgebras into ideals .
since this analysis goes through without additional problem over fields of characteristic zero , it is carried out in this context . here
we focus on the essential case where @xmath0 is a reductive lie superalgebra satisfying @xmath22 $ ] , i.e. , where @xmath0 is generated by its odd part @xmath18 .
our main result is the structure theorem [ thm:3.8 ] which describes the commutator algebra @xmath23 $ ] as a quotient of a direct sum of the center and of lie superalgebras @xmath24 and @xmath25 by a central subspace . here
@xmath26 is a classical lie superalgebra and @xmath27 , where @xmath4 is a simple lie algebra and @xmath28 denotes the gramann algebra with @xmath29 generators .
the results in this section are closely related to elduque s results on reductive lie superalgebras over fields of characteristic zero ( @xcite ; see also @xcite ) . in principle
we could have derived our results from his , but our approach is rather elementary , very direct and never requires algebraic closedness of the base field .
in particular it works over @xmath30.-invariant bilinear form see @xcite . ] in the final section [ sec:4 ] everything is put together to obtain a description of the structure of unitary lie superalgebras .
here one of the main results is theorem [ thm:3.7 ] which asserts that if @xmath0 is unitary , then the ideals @xmath24 are isomorphic to @xmath31 here the lie superalgebras of the form @xmath32 , @xmath33 , and @xmath34 must be direct summands , whereas the lie superalgebras @xmath35 and @xmath36 intersect the center non - trivially .
the ideals @xmath25 are direct sums of a central ideal and a one - dimensional central extension of @xmath37 , where @xmath4 is a compact simple lie algebra .
finally , we show that all these types occur .
sec:1 in this section we start our analysis with the classification of compact simple lie superalgebras ( theorem [ thm:1.4 ] ) . in passing ,
we introduce some related extensions and discuss their matrix realizations .
we recall that a real lie superalgebra @xmath0 is called compact if @xmath1 is a compactly embedded subalgebra , i.e. , the subgroup of @xmath10 generated by @xmath11 has compact closure . according to @xcite ,
the classical simple complex lie superalgebras are grouped in @xmath38 infinite series and @xmath39 exceptional types . * @xmath40 * @xmath41 , @xmath42 , @xmath43 . *
@xmath44 , @xmath45 . *
@xmath46 , @xmath45 , @xmath43 . *
@xmath47 , @xmath48 , for @xmath45 ( the _ queer lie superalgebra _ ) . * @xmath49 , @xmath50 . *
@xmath51 , @xmath52 , and @xmath53 , where @xmath54 .
rem:1.2 the even parts of the complex classical nonexceptional lie superalgebras are @xmath55 @xmath56 in particular , the even part has non - zero ( one - dimensional ) center for @xmath57 and @xmath58 .
\(b ) according to @xcite , any real form @xmath0 of a complex classical lie superalgebra @xmath59 is determined up to isomorphism by its even part @xmath1 .
( c ) in view of ( * ? ? ? * thm . 1 ,
2.3.4 ) , the cartan
killing form of @xmath60 and @xmath61 vanishes , whereas the cartan killing form of @xmath62 , @xmath63 , and of @xmath58 is non - degenerate .
this further implies that all derivations of @xmath62 and @xmath58 are inner ( ( * ? ? ?
2.3.4 ) ) .
since derivations and cocycles are in one - to - one correspondence via the map @xmath64 where @xmath65 is the cartan killing form , and inner derivations correspond to trivial cocycles , it follows that all central extensions of @xmath62 , @xmath63 , and @xmath58 are trivial .
ex:1.3 ( a ) the prototype of a compact lie superalgebra is the real form @xmath66 of the complex lie superalgebra @xmath67
. then @xmath68 and the @xmath1-module structure on this space is equivalent to @xmath69 , so that @xmath18 is a simple @xmath1-module .
an odd element @xmath70 is contained in @xmath12 if and only if @xmath71 .
therefore the involution on @xmath67 that leads to the real form @xmath12 can be written as @xmath72 for later use we record the following property of @xmath0 : @xmath73 = 2 x^2 = 2i x^*x \not=0 \quad \mbox { for } \quad
0 \not= x \in \g_{{\bar{1}}}.\ ] ] \(b ) the lie superalgebra @xmath74 has the non - zero center @xmath75 and @xmath76 , so that @xmath77 acts trivially on @xmath78 . since @xmath79 is a simple module of @xmath1 , we see that for @xmath0 and also for the simple lie superalgebra @xmath80 , the representation of @xmath1 on @xmath18 is irreducible .
we also note that @xmath81 \quad \mbox { for } \quad x : = \pmat{0 & \1 \\ i\1 & 0 } \in \g_{\bar 1},\ ] ] shows that @xmath82 $ ] , that is , @xmath0 is a non - trivial central extension of @xmath83 . since the center of the even part of this quotient is trivial , it is not unitary ( cf .
lemma [ lem : form ] below ) ; all unitary representations @xmath84 of @xmath0 with @xmath85 kill the element @xmath86 , hence are trivial because the complexification @xmath87 of @xmath88 is a simple complex lie superalgebra ( see also @xcite ) . for @xmath63 ,
the center @xmath77 of @xmath89 is non - zero and acts non - trivially on @xmath90 .
\(c ) for @xmath42 , the lie superalgebra @xmath91 is a compact real form of @xmath92 .
accordingly , @xmath93 is a compact real form of the lie superalgebra @xmath61 , which is simple for @xmath94 .
note that @xmath95 shows that the module structure for @xmath96 on @xmath97 is equivalent to the adjoint representation on @xmath98 , hence irreducible .
we also note that @xmath99 , that @xmath100 $ ] and that it embeds naturally as a hyperplane ideal into @xmath101 therefore @xmath102 defines an exterior odd derivation of @xmath35 with @xmath103 .
\(d ) let @xmath34 be the compact real form of @xmath104 , @xmath45 , with @xmath105 and @xmath106 as @xmath107 is an irreducible @xmath108-module , the action of @xmath109 on @xmath110 is irreducible .
we also note that @xmath111 .
the cartan killing form of @xmath34 is non - zero , hence non - degenerate , and this implies that all derivations are inner and that all central extensions are trivial ( cf .
2.3.4 ) ) .
thm:1.4 ( compact classical lie superalgebras ) every compact simple real lie superalgebra @xmath0 is isomorphic to one of the following : * @xmath32 for @xmath112 . * @xmath88 for @xmath45 . *
@xmath113 , @xmath45 . *
@xmath34 , the compact real form of @xmath104 , @xmath45 .
for all these simple real lie superalgebras @xmath0 , the @xmath114-module @xmath18 is irreducible , @xmath115 for @xmath116 and @xmath117 , and @xmath118 for @xmath119 and @xmath34 .
the compactness of @xmath0 implies that it is classical .
if @xmath59 is not simple , then @xmath0 is a complex simple lie superalgebra , considered as real one .
then @xmath120 is a complex subalgebra of @xmath121 and this can only generate a relatively compact group of automorphisms if it is trivial , i.e. , @xmath122 , but this contradicts the simplicity of @xmath0 . therefore @xmath59 is simple and @xmath0 is a compact real form of the classical lie superalgebra @xmath59 . from the classification of the real forms in (
2.5 ) it follows that compact real forms are unique whenever they exist .
we also see that the exceptional algebras and the algebras @xmath123 have no compact real forms because the lie algebras @xmath124 , @xmath125 , @xmath126 , and @xmath127 , @xmath128 , are not compact .
further , the algebras @xmath129 , @xmath43 , and @xmath130 have no compact real form because the lie algebras @xmath131 , @xmath50 , in @xmath132 the subalgebra @xmath5 is maximally compact and equality implies @xmath133 .
are never compact . for @xmath62 , @xmath61 and @xmath58 ,
the compact real forms are given by ( a ) , ( b ) , ( c ) and ( d ) respectively .
the simplicity of the @xmath1-module @xmath18 follows from the discussion in examples [ ex:1.3 ] , which also implies the remaining assertion on @xmath134 . in @xcite ,
fioresi constructs compact real forms in terms of the root decomposition .
fixing a cartan subalgebra and a chevalley basis @xmath135 ( see ( * ? ? ?
* chapter 3 ) ) , she thus obtains for any classical lie superalgebra satisfying @xmath136=0 $ ] for all @xmath137 a compact real form .
sec:2 in this section we take a closer look at the class of unitary lie superalgebras and some of their specific properties . [ 1new ] a ( finite dimensional ) _ unitary representation _ for a finite dimensional lie superalgebra @xmath138 is a pair @xmath139 where @xmath140 is a finite dimensional complex super hilbert space with the corresponding sesquilinear positive definite even hermitian form @xmath141 , and @xmath142 is a ( real ) lie superalgebra homomorphism satisfying @xmath143 for @xmath144 and @xmath145 .
if we write @xmath146 then unitary representations correspond to homomorphism of lie superalgebras @xmath147 .
since we can form direct sums of unitary representations , we have the following trivial lemma : [ n1 ] for a finite dimensional lie superalgebra , the following are equivalent : * the finite dimensional unitary representations of @xmath0 separate the points .
* @xmath0 has a faithful finite dimensional unitary representation .
* @xmath0 is isomorphic to a subalgebra of some @xmath12 . [ unitary ] ( a ) we call a finite dimensional real lie superalgebra @xmath0 _ unitary _ if it has a faithful finite dimensional unitary representation .
\(b ) for a finite dimensional lie superalgebra @xmath0 , we write @xmath148 for the closed convex cone generated by the elements of the form @xmath20 $ ] , @xmath149 .
lem : form if @xmath0 is unitary then the following assertions hold : * @xmath0 is compact , i.e. , the even part @xmath1 is compactly embedded in @xmath0 .
* @xmath20 \not=0 $ ] for @xmath150 .
* @xmath151 is pointed , i.e. , @xmath152 .
* there exists a @xmath153-invariant linear functional @xmath154 , for which the form @xmath155)\ ] ] is positive definite . *
@xmath156 .
( i)-(iii ) we may assume that @xmath157 .
then ( i ) follows from the fact that @xmath158 is compactly embedded in @xmath159 , and ( ii ) from .
further implies that @xmath160 which implies that @xmath161 is pointed .
\(iv ) since the cone @xmath151 is pointed , its dual cone @xmath162 has interior points .
since the group @xmath163 generated by @xmath11 has compact closure by ( i ) , @xmath164 contains a fixed point @xmath16 for this group ( cf .
* lemma 5.1.2 ) ) .
then @xmath165 for any non - zero element @xmath166 , and therefore ( ii ) , ( iii ) imply that @xmath167 is positive definite on @xmath18 .
further , the invariance of @xmath16 under @xmath163 , and hence under @xmath1 , implies that @xmath167 is @xmath1-invariant .
\(v ) since @xmath16 is @xmath114-invariant , it vanishes on @xmath168 $ ] , so that @xmath169 $ ] implies that the center is non - zero .
combining lemma [ lem : form](v ) with theorem [ thm:1.4 ] , we obtain immediately : prop : simp - nonunit the simple compact lie superalgebras @xmath88 , @xmath128 , and @xmath117 , @xmath45 , are not unitary .
[ new3 ] ( a ) more examples of compact lie superalgebras which are not unitary can be obtained as follows .
a lie superalgebra @xmath0 is called a _
heisenberg lie superalgebra _ if @xmath170 .
then the bracket is completely determined by the symmetric bilinear form @xmath171.\ ] ] if @xmath172 and @xmath173 is indefinite , then @xmath174 is not pointed , so that @xmath0 is not unitary . in view of lemma [ lem : form ]
, unitarity even requires that @xmath173 is positive or negative definite .
the spin representation associated to a positive definite form @xmath173 implies that @xmath0 is unitary if @xmath173 is positive definite ( cf . subsection [ subsec:2.1 ] )
\(b ) if @xmath0 is a compact lie superalgebra , then @xmath175 is in particular a compact lie algebra ( ( * ? ? ?
12.1.4 ) ) .
hence the ideal @xmath176 $ ] of @xmath175 has a complement @xmath177 , and @xmath178 \oplus \g_{\bar 1 } ) \rtimes \fc \quad \mbox { with } \quad [ \fc , { [ \g_{{\bar{1 } } } , \g_{{\bar{1 } } } ] } ] = \{0\}.\ ] ] if , conversely , @xmath177 is a compact lie algebra and @xmath159 a compact lie superalgebra on which @xmath177 acts by even derivations @xmath179 with @xmath180 and @xmath181 relatively compact , then @xmath182 is a compact lie superalgebra .
therefore , for most issues concerning the structure theory of compact lie superalgebras , it suffices to assume that @xmath0 is generated by @xmath18 .
subsec:2.1 let @xmath183 and @xmath184 be finite dimensional complex hilbert spaces .
a representation of the _ canonical anticommutation relations ( car ) _ is an antilinear map @xmath185 satisfying @xmath186 for every complex hilbert space @xmath183 , we obtain a representation of the car on the exterior algebra @xmath187 , endowed with the natural scalar product , by @xmath188 and @xmath189 ( cf .
@xcite ) .
the complex _ clifford
heisenberg lie superalgebra _ associated to the complex hilbert space @xmath183 is the lie superalgebra @xmath190 : = ( \la v , w'\ra + \la v',w\ra,0,0).\ ] ] any representation of the car leads to a complex linear representation of @xmath191 by @xmath192 accordingly , we obtain a real form of @xmath191 by @xmath193 and any representation of the car defines a unitary representation of @xmath159 . for @xmath194 , we have @xmath195 = ( \la v , -iv \ra + \la v ,- iv \ra , 0,0 ) = ( 2i\|v\|^2 , 0,0).\ ] ] we now consider the lie superalgebra @xmath196 then @xmath197 acts non - trivially on @xmath198 .
the fock representation of the car extends to @xmath0 by @xmath199 we thus obtain for @xmath200 a unitary irreducible representation of @xmath0 satisfying @xmath201 . for a detailed study of spin representations
see @xcite . in this subsection
we discuss some aspects of central extensions of real lie superalgebras that will be needed in section [ sec:4 ] below .
if @xmath202 is a @xmath1-invariant symmetric bilinear form , i.e. , @xmath203,z ) + \beta(y,[x , z ] ) = 0 \quad \mbox { for } \quad x \in \g_{{\bar{0 } } } , y , z \in \g_{{\bar{1}}},\ ] ] then @xmath204 is a lie superalgebra @xmath205-cocycle , i.e. , @xmath206 : = ( \omega(x , x ' ) , [ x , x'])\ ] ] is a lie superalgebra with @xmath207 and @xmath208 . we have to check for homogeneous elements @xmath209 the relation @xmath210 ) = \omega([x , y ] , z ) + ( -1)^{|x| \cdot |y| } \omega(y,[x , z]).\ ] ] here the only non - trivial case is the situation where one argument , say @xmath86 , is even and the others are odd .
then @xmath210 ) = 0 = \beta([x , y ] , z ) + \beta(y,[x , z ] ) = \omega([x ,
y],z ) + \omega(y,[x , z])\ ] ] follows from the invariance of @xmath173 under @xmath1 .
prop:2.9 if @xmath173 is a positive definite @xmath1-invariant form on @xmath18 and @xmath211 is the central extension defined by the cocycle , then the cone @xmath212 is pointed .
the convex cone @xmath212 is generated by the elements @xmath213)$ ] , @xmath214 , and if @xmath173 is positive definite , it suffices to consider elements with @xmath215 .
this leads to the compact subset @xmath216 ) \ : x \in \g_{{\bar{1 } } } , \beta(x , x ) = 1\ } \subeq\r \times \g_{{\bar{0}}}\ ] ] whose convex hull does not contain @xmath217 .
therefore it generates a pointed convex cone .
every compact lie superalgebra @xmath0 has a compact central extension @xmath211 for which the cone @xmath212 is pointed .
since @xmath218 has compact closure , @xmath18 carries a positive definite @xmath1-invariant symmetric bilinear form @xmath173 .
then the corresponding centrally extended lie superalgebra @xmath211 has a pointed cone @xmath212 by proposition [ prop:2.9 ] .
sec:3 in this section we turn to the structure of a reductive lie superalgebra @xmath0 over a field @xmath8 of characteristic zero . since the results in this section will be applied to unitary ( and so compact ) lie superalgebras , and in this case @xmath0 is always a semidirect sum of an ideal of @xmath1 and the ideal of @xmath0 generated by @xmath18 ( cf .
remark [ new3](b ) ) , we assume in the following that @xmath219.\ ] ] the main goal of this section is to decompose @xmath0 into center and ideals which are central extensions of simple lie superalgebras or of algebras of the form @xmath37 , where @xmath4 is a simple lie superalgebra . let @xmath220=\{0\}\}.\ ] ] we note that @xmath221,\g_{\bar 1}]\subseteq [ \fb,\g_{\bar 0}]=\{0\}$ ] , and since @xmath0 is generated by @xmath18 , this leads to @xmath222\subseteq \fz(\g).\ ] ] since @xmath223 is @xmath224-invariant and @xmath18 is a semisimple @xmath1-module , we have a @xmath1-invariant decomposition @xmath225 with @xmath226 , where the @xmath227 are simple @xmath224-submodules of @xmath18 .
we then have @xmath228\subseteq\fa_k\cap(\fa_i+\fa_j)=\{0\}\quad\mbox { for } \quad k\not\in\{i , j\},\ ] ] and thus in particular @xmath229,\fa_k ] = \{0\ } \quad\mbox { for } \quad k\not= i.\ ] ] we likewise obtain @xmath230 , \fa_k ] \subeq \fa_k \cap ( \fb + \fa_j ) = \{0\ } \quad\mbox { for } \quad k\not = j.\ ] ] note that @xmath231 = [ \fb,\fb ] + [ \fb,\fa ] + [ \fa , \fa]= \underbrace{[\fb,\fb]}_{\subeq \fz(\g ) } + \sum_j [ \fb,\fa_j ] + \sum_{j , k } [ \fa_j , \fa_k].\ ] ] since the spaces @xmath232,\fa_i]$ ] and @xmath233 , \fa_i]$ ] are @xmath1-submodules of @xmath234 , they are either zero or equal to @xmath234 .
as @xmath235 $ ] is central by , the relations @xmath236 $ ] , , and imply that @xmath237,\fa_i ] = \fa_i \quad \mbox { or } \quad [ [ \fa_j , \fa_i],\fa_i ] = \fa_i \quad \mbox { for some } j \in j.\ ] ] we put @xmath238,\fa_k]=\fa_k\ } = \{k\in j\ : ( \exists k ' \in j)\ [ [ \fa_k,\fa_{k'}],\fa_k]=\fa_k\}.\ ] ] let @xmath239 and consider @xmath240 .
then @xmath241,\fa_k]=\{0\}$ ] by definition and so @xmath242,\fa_k]=[[\fb,\fa_k],\fa_k]=\fa_k$ ] follows from .
therefore leads to @xmath243,\fa_k]=\fa_k\hbox { and } \ ( \forall j\in j)\
[ [ \fa_k,\fa_j],\fa_k]=\{0\}\}.\ ] ] [ teh5 ] for each @xmath244 , there exists a unique @xmath245 such that @xmath246,\fa_k]$ ]
. then @xmath247 and @xmath248,\fa_{k'}]$ ] .
let @xmath244 and @xmath245 such that @xmath246,\fa_k]$ ] .
first we show that @xmath249 .
if @xmath250 , then @xmath251 , so that @xmath252 = [ \fa_k,[[\fb,\fa_{k'}],\fa_{k ' } ] ] \subeq [ [ \fa_k,\fa_{k'}],[\fb,\fa_{k'}]]+ [ \underbrace{[\fa_k,[\fb,\fa_{k'}]]}_{=0\ \text{by}\ \eqref{m12 - 4c}},\fa_{k'}]\subeq [ \fb,\fa_{k'}].\ ] ] with , this leads to the contradiction @xmath253,\fa_k ] \subeq [ [ \fb,\fa_{k ' } ] , \fa_k ] = \{0\}.$ ] next we show that @xmath254 $ ] .
we may assume that @xmath255 .
as @xmath247 by step @xmath256 , there exists a @xmath257 such that @xmath258,\fa_{k'}]$ ] . if @xmath259 , then @xmath252 = [ \fa_k,[[\fa_{k'},\fa_{k'}],\fa_{k ' } ] ] \subeq [ \underbrace{[\fa_k,[\fa_{k'},\fa_{k'}]]}_{=0},\fa_{k'}]+ [ [ \fa_k,\fa_{k'}],[\fa_{k'},\fa_{k ' } ] ] \subeq [ \fa_{k'},\fa_{k'}]\ ] ] leads with to the contradiction @xmath260,\fa_k ] \subeq
[ [ \fa_{k'},\fa_{k'}],\fa_k ] = \{0\}.\ ] ] thus @xmath261 .
if @xmath262 , then @xmath263 are distinct and so @xmath252 = [ \fa_k,[[\fa_{k'},\fa_t],\fa_{k ' } ] ] \subeq [ \underbrace{[\fa_k,[\fa_{k'},\fa_{t}]]}_{=0},\fa_{k ' } ] + [ [ \fa_k,\fa_{k'}],[\fa_{k'},\fa_{t } ] ] \subeq [ \fa_{k'},\fa_{t}]\ ] ] leads to the contradiction @xmath264,\fa_k ] \subeq [ [ \fa_t,\fa_{k'}],\fa_k ] = \{0\}$ ] .
we conclude that @xmath265 .
now we show the uniqueness of @xmath266 .
suppose that @xmath267 satisfy @xmath268=[\fa_k,[\fa_k,\fa_t]].\ ] ] by the symmetry proved in the previous step ,
@xmath269 \quad \mbox { and } \quad \fa_t=[\fa_t,[\fa_t,\fa_k]].\ ] ] this leads to @xmath270&=[[\fa_k,[\fa_t,\fa_k]],\fa_s ] \subseteq [ [ \fa_k,\fa_s],[\fa_t,\fa_k]]+[[[\fa_t,\fa_k],\fa_s],\fa_k]\\ & \subseteq [ \fa_t,\fa_k]+[[[\fa_s,\fa_t],\fa_k],\fa_k]+[[[\fa_s,\fa_k],\fa_t],\fa_k]\\ & \subseteq [ \fa_t,\fa_k]+[\fa_k,\fa_k].\end{aligned}\ ] ] similarly , @xmath271\subseteq [ \fa_s,\fa_k]+[\fa_k,\fa_k].\ ] ] if @xmath272 , then ( [ m12 - 4 ] ) and lead to the contradiction @xmath269\subseteq [ \fa_s,[\fa_t,\fa_k ] ] + [ \fa_s,[\fa_k,\fa_k]]=\{0\}.\ ] ] if @xmath273 , then @xmath274 and yield @xmath275\subeq [ \fa_t,[\fa_s,\fa_k ] ] + [ \fa_t,[\fa_k,\fa_k]]=\{0\},\ ] ] which is absurd . by symmetry , a similar argument works for the case @xmath276 .
this shows that @xmath277 and the proof is complete .
[ teh4 ] @xmath278,\fa_k]=\{0\}$ ] if and only if @xmath279\subseteq\fz(\g)$ ] .
this holds in particular for @xmath240 and @xmath280 with @xmath251 .
clearly @xmath279\subseteq\fz(\g)$ ] implies @xmath278,\fa_k]=\{0\}$ ] .
if , conversely , @xmath278,\fa_k]=\{0\}$ ] , then leads to @xmath281,\g_{\bar1}]=[[\fa_k,\fa_k],\fa]=[[\fa_k,\fa_k],\fa_k]=\{0\},\ ] ] so that @xmath279\subseteq\fz(\g)$ ] follows from @xmath282 $ ] . if @xmath283 , then @xmath278,\fa_k]=\{0\}$ ] by definition .
if @xmath280 and @xmath284 , then the uniqueness of @xmath266 implies that @xmath285 , \fa_k ] = \{0\}$ ] .
[ teh6 ] * if @xmath244 , then @xmath286\subseteq [ \fa_k,\fa_{k ' } ] \cap [ \g_{{\bar{0}}},\g_{{\bar{0}}}]$ ] . * @xmath287=\{0\}$ ] if @xmath240 and @xmath288 , or @xmath244 and @xmath289 . *
if @xmath290 and @xmath291 , then @xmath292 \cap [ \fa_j , \fa_{j ' } ] \subeq \fz(\g)$ ] .
\(i ) follows from @xmath293=[\fb,[\fa_k,[\fa_k,\fa_{k'}]]]\subseteq [ [ \fb,\fa_k],[\fa_k,\fa_{k'}]]+ [ \fa_k,\underbrace{[\fb,[\fa_k,\fa_{k'}]]}_{=0}]\subseteq [ \fa_k,\fa_{k ' } ] \cap [ \g_{{\bar{0}}},\g_{{\bar{0}}}].\ ] ] \(ii ) assume first that @xmath244 and @xmath289 .
then @xmath294&=[\fa_s,[\fa_k,[\fa_k,\fa_{k ' } ] ] ] \subseteq [ [ \fa_s,\fa_k],[\fa_k,\fa_{k'}]]+[\underbrace{[\fa_s,[\fa_k,\fa_{k'}]]}_{=0},\fa_k]\\ & \subseteq [ \fa_k,\fa_{k'}]\cap [ \fg_{\bar0},\g_{\bar0}].\end{aligned}\ ] ] if @xmath295 , then @xmath289 implies @xmath296 and we get similarly @xmath297\subseteq [ \fa_s,\fa_{s ' } ] \cap [ \g_{{\bar{0}}},\g_{{\bar{0}}}].\ ] ] thus @xmath298\subseteq [ \fa_s,\fa_{s'}]\cap [ \fa_k,\fa_{k'}]\cap[\g_{\bar0},\g_{\bar0}]$ ] , and ( [ m12 - 4b ] ) thus leads to @xmath299,\g_{{\bar{1 } } } ] = \{0\}$ ] , which in turn shows that @xmath297 \subeq [ \g_{{\bar{0 } } } , \g_{{\bar{0 } } } ] \cap \fz(\g ) \subseteq [ \g_{\bar0},\g_{\bar0}]\cap\fz(\g_{\bar0})=\{0\}.\ ] ] here we use that @xmath224 is reductive .
if @xmath300 , then @xmath270&=[\fa_k,[\fa_s,[\fa_s,\fb ] ] ] \subseteq[[\fa_k,\fa_s],[\fa_s,\fb]]+\underbrace{[[\fa_k,[\fa_s,\fb]]}_{=0\ \text{by } \eqref{m12 - 4c}},\fa_s]\\ & = [ [ \fa_k,\fa_s],[\fa_s,\fb ] ] \subseteq [ \underbrace{[[\fa_k,\fa_s],\fa_s]}_{=0\ \text{by } \eqref{teh2}},\fb ] + [ \underbrace{[[\fa_k,\fa_s],\fb]}_{=0},\fa_s ] = \{0\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the case @xmath283 and @xmath301 follows from the first part . finally assume that @xmath302 , @xmath303 .
then @xmath304=[\fa_k,[\fa_s,[\fa_s,\fb]]]\subseteq [ [ \fa_k,\fa_s],[\fa_s,\fb ] ] + [ \fa_s , \underbrace{[\fa_k,[\fa_s , \fb]]}_{=0\ \text{by } \eqref{m12 - 4c } } ] \subseteq [ \fa_s,\fb]\cap [ \g_{\bar0},\g_{\bar0}].\ ] ] we likewise get @xmath287\subseteq [ \fa_k,\fb]$ ] , so that leads to @xmath287 \subeq \fz(\g)$ ] , and thus to @xmath287\subseteq \fz(\g_{\bar0})\cap [ \g_{\bar0},\g_{\bar0}]=\{0\}$ ] .
\(iii ) let @xmath305 \cap [ \fa_j , \fa_{j'}]$ ] .
then shows that @xmath306 = [ \fz , \fa_k + \fa_{k ' } ] \subeq [ [ \fa_i , \fa_{j ' } ] , \fa_k+\fa_{k ' } ] = \{0\},\ ] ] so that the assertion follows from @xmath307 $ ] .
rem : subalg if @xmath308 is a @xmath1-invariant subspace , then @xmath309 \subeq \g$ ] is a @xmath1-invariant subalgebra of @xmath0 . in particular , @xmath310 \trile\g_{{\bar{0}}}$ ] is an ideal .
we now consider the following subalgebras of @xmath0 ( cf .
remark [ rem : subalg ] ) : @xmath311 + [ \fa_k , \fa_{k ' } ] + [ \fa_{k ' } , \fa_{k'}]\quad \mbox { for } \quad k\in j_s,\\ \fc(k):=\fa_k+[\fa_k,\fa_k ] + [ \fb,\fa_k ] \qquad \mbox { for } \quad k\in j_a .
\end{array}\ ] ] for @xmath284 in @xmath312 , the relation @xmath313 + [ \fa_{k'},\fa_{k ' } ] \subeq \fz(\g)$ ] ( lemma [ teh6 ] ) implies that @xmath314 \subeq [ \fa_k , \fa_{k'}].\ ] ] from lemma [ teh6](i ) , we obtain @xmath315=\sum_{k\in j_a}[\fb,\fa_k]+\sum_{k\in j_s}[\fb,\fa_k]\subseteq \sum_{k\in j_a}[\fb,\fa_k ] + \sum_{k\in j_s}[\fa_k,\fa_{k'}].\ ] ] by lemmas [ teh4 ] and [ teh6](ii ) we have @xmath316 = \sum_{k\in j_a}[\fa_k,\fa_k ] + \sum_{k'\not = k\in j_s}[\fa_k,\fa_k ] + \sum_{k\in j_s}[\fa_k,\fa_{k ' } ] \subeq \fz(\g ) + \sum_{k\in j_s}[\fa_k,\fa_{k'}].\ ] ] thus @xmath317+[\fb,\fa]+[\fa,\fa]}_{\g_{{\bar{0}}}}+\underbrace{\fb+\fa}_{\g_{{\bar{1 } } } } = \fb + [ \fb,\fb ] + \sum_{k\in j_a}\fc(k)+\sum_{k\in j_s}\g(k).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the structure of subalgebras @xmath318 and @xmath319 , @xmath320 and possibilities for the index sets @xmath312 and @xmath321 will be discussed in what follows , see for example proposition [ prop:3.5](iv ) , example [ ex : tk ] , remark [ new - late ] and example [ ex : tildetk ] .
prop:3.5 for every @xmath322 , the lie superalgebra @xmath24 is an ideal of @xmath0 with the following properties : * @xmath227 and @xmath323 are simple @xmath324-modules .
in particular , @xmath325 is a semisimple @xmath324-module . *
@xmath326 , @xmath327 and @xmath328 .
* @xmath329 is a classical lie superalgebra . * if @xmath330 and @xmath24 is compact , then @xmath331 .
this holds in particular for every @xmath332 if @xmath0 is compact .
first we observe that @xmath333 \subeq [ \fa_j , \fa_{j'}]$ ] by lemma [ teh6](i ) .
for @xmath291 we get @xmath334 = \{0\}$ ] from lemma [ teh6](ii ) .
this leads to @xmath335 = [ \fb + \fa_j + \fa_{j ' } , \fa_j + \fa_{j ' } ] \subeq \g(j).\ ] ] as @xmath307 $ ] and @xmath24 is @xmath1-invariant , this implies that @xmath336 .
\(i ) since all subspaces @xmath337 , @xmath291 , commute with @xmath24 by lemma [ teh6](ii ) and all subspaces @xmath338 $ ] , @xmath291 , commute with @xmath24 by , lemma [ teh6](i ) leads to @xmath339 \subeq \fz_{\g_{{\bar{0}}}}(\g(j ) ) + \g(j)_{{\bar{0}}}.\ ] ] therefore @xmath227 and @xmath323 are simple @xmath324-modules .
\(ii ) from the non - triviality of the simple @xmath324-modules @xmath227 and @xmath323 , it follows that the centralizer of @xmath324 in @xmath325 vanishes . in particular , @xmath340 . from lemma [ teh6 ]
it follows that @xmath341 = [ \fz,\fa ] = [ \fz,\fa_j + \fa_{j'}]= \{0\}$ ] , so that @xmath342 because @xmath18 generates @xmath0 .
as @xmath343 is @xmath1-invariant , it is an abelian ideal of the reductive lie algebra @xmath1 , hence central in @xmath1 .
\(iii ) let @xmath344 and @xmath345 be an ideal .
if @xmath346 , then @xmath347 .
suppose that @xmath348 . if @xmath349 , then @xmath350\subseteq i_{\bar 0 } \subseteq\fz(\h)$ ] , which leads to @xmath351=[i_{\bar1},[\h_{\bar1},\h_{\bar1}]]=\{0\}$ ] .
in view of ( ii ) , this contradicts @xmath348 .
we conclude that @xmath352 .
this implies that either @xmath353\not=\{0\}$ ] or @xmath354\not=\{0\}$ ] . by symmetry
, we may assume @xmath353\not=\{0\}$ ] .
then @xmath355\subseteq i_{\bar1}\cap\fa_{j}$ ] .
since the latter is a nonzero @xmath324-submodule of the simple @xmath324-module @xmath227 , we obtain @xmath356 .
we now get @xmath357\subseteq [ \fa_{j'},[\fa_{j'},i_{\bar 1 } ] ] \subseteq i_{\bar1},\ ] ] and thus @xmath358 .
this proves ( iii ) .
\(iv ) since @xmath24 is compact , the same holds for the quotient lie superalgebra @xmath359 which is classical by ( iii ) .
hence the assertion follows from theorem [ thm:1.4 ] .
ex : tk ( tangent superalgebras ) let @xmath4 be a simple lie algebra .
then the tangent algebra @xmath360 , @xmath361 $ ] , @xmath362 , carries the structure of a lie superalgebra , where @xmath363 and @xmath364 .
note that @xmath365 is an abelian ideal . here
the brackets of odd elements vanish .
since @xmath366 as a module of @xmath367 , this lie algebra is reductive .
it has an odd derivation @xmath368 now @xmath369 also is a reductive lie superalgebra and @xmath370 contains a subspace commuting with @xmath4 which is not central . in the terminology from above
, we then have @xmath371 , @xmath372 , and @xmath373 is a one - element set because @xmath374 = \{0\}$ ] .
let @xmath283 .
then @xmath375 is an ideal with the following properties : * @xmath376 $ ] is a simple lie algebra .
* @xmath377 . *
@xmath25 contains the nilpotent ideal @xmath378 $ ] , hence is not semisimple .
* let @xmath379 with @xmath380 \not=\{0\}$ ] .
then @xmath381 $ ] is a subalgebra of @xmath0 for which @xmath382 is semisimple .
( i ) , ( ii ) lemma [ teh6](ii ) implies that @xmath383 = \{0\}$ ] for @xmath384 . by and
, the centralizer of @xmath337 in @xmath1 contains @xmath385 , \quad [ \fa,\fa ] , \quad [ \fb , \fa_j ] , j \not = k.\ ] ] we conclude that @xmath386 $ ] , so that @xmath337 is also a simple module of the ideal @xmath387 $ ] of the reductive lie algebra @xmath1 and that @xmath4 has an ideal complement acting trivially on @xmath337 . for every @xmath379 ,
the operator @xmath388 is @xmath4-equivariant .
therefore the adjoint representation of @xmath4 is a sum of simple modules isomorphic to @xmath337 , hence semisimple and a direct sum of submodules isomorphic to @xmath337 .
in particular , @xmath4 is semisimple , hence a direct sum of simple ideals @xmath389 .
then the ideals @xmath390 are simple @xmath4-modules with respect to the adjoint action and for @xmath391 they are non - isomorphic because @xmath392 acts trivially on @xmath390 and vice versa .
this implies that @xmath133 and that @xmath4 is a simple lie algebra . using lemma [ teh4](ii ) , we see that @xmath25 is a central extension of the lie superalgebra @xmath393 which is isomorphic to the lie superalgebra @xmath394 from example [ ex : tk ] . note that @xmath4 annihilates a complement of @xmath337 in @xmath18 , @xmath279 $ ] is central , and @xmath395 = [ \fa_k,\fa_k]+ [ \fa_k,\fb]$ ] by lemma [ teh6](ii ) .
we conclude that @xmath396 = [ \fa_k , \g_{{\bar{1 } } } ] + [ \fk , \g_{{\bar{1 } } } ] \subeq \fc(k),\ ] ] and therefore @xmath375 is an ideal .
\(iii ) follows from @xmath279 \subeq \fz(\g)$ ] ( lemma [ teh4 ] ) .
\(iv ) let @xmath397 .
since @xmath25 is an ideal of @xmath0 , the subspace @xmath398 is a subalgebra .
now it follows from lemma [ teh4 ] , ( [ miss2 ] ) and ( i ) that @xmath399+\k[b , b]$ ] and @xmath400 for a derivation mapping @xmath401 with @xmath402 mapping @xmath337 in a @xmath4-equivariant fashion to @xmath4 .
this implies that it is isomorphic to @xmath403 . to see that @xmath403 is semisimple , let @xmath404 be a solvable ideal
. then @xmath405 must be an abelian ideal of @xmath406 , hence trivial . therefore @xmath407 and the ideal property implies @xmath408 = \{0\}$ ] , which leads to @xmath409 .
as @xmath380 \not=\{0\}$ ] , we obtain @xmath410 .
in any lie superalgebra @xmath0 we have @xmath23_{{\bar{1}}}= [ \g_{{\bar{0 } } } , \g_{{\bar{1}}}]$ ] .
if , in addition , @xmath0 is reductive , then the @xmath1-module @xmath18 is semisimple , so that @xmath411 intersects @xmath23 $ ] trivially .
therefore @xmath411 is a direct summand and it does no harm to assume that @xmath412 .
( structure theorem for reductive lie superalgebras ) thm:3.8 let @xmath0 be a reductive lie superalgebra generated by @xmath18 with @xmath413 .
then @xmath414 + \fb$ ] is a direct sum of vector spaces and the commutator algebra can be written as a sum of ideals of @xmath0 as follows : @xmath415 = \fz(\g ) + \sum_{j \in j_s } \g(j ) + \sum_{k \in j_a } \fc(k).\ ] ] moreover , the summation map @xmath416 has central kernel .
it is clear that the ideals @xmath24 and @xmath25 are contained in the commutator algebra @xmath23 $ ] and @xmath23_{{\bar{1}}}= \fa$ ] , as well as @xmath415_{{\bar{0}}}= \g_{{\bar{0}}}= [ \g_{{\bar{1 } } } , \g_{{\bar{1 } } } ] = [ \fa,\fa ] + [ \fa,\fb ] + [ \fb,\fb].\ ] ] as @xmath235 $ ] is central , @xmath417 \subeq \g(j)$ ] for @xmath322 ( lemma [ teh6](i ) ) , @xmath286 \subeq \fc(k)$ ] for @xmath283 , and @xmath316 \subeq \fz(\g ) + \sum_{j \in j_s } [ \fa_j , \fa_{j'}]\ ] ] ( lemma [ teh4 ] and lemma [ teh6](ii ) ) , we thus obtain @xmath415 = \fz(\g)_{{\bar{0}}}+ \sum_{j \in j_s } \g(j ) + \sum_{k \in j_a } \fc(k).\ ] ] now let @xmath418 and @xmath419 . if @xmath420 , we assume that either @xmath421 or @xmath422 vanishes .
suppose that @xmath423 .
since the sum of the subspaces @xmath227 and @xmath337 of @xmath424 is direct , all summands @xmath425 and @xmath421 are even and so they commute with @xmath223 . for @xmath283 , the element @xmath426 commutes with @xmath337 , so that @xmath425 does as well .
as it also acts trivial on a complement of @xmath337 in @xmath424 , it commutes with @xmath18 , and thus @xmath427 because @xmath0 is generated by @xmath18 .
likewise @xmath428 acts trivially on @xmath429 , hence @xmath421 does likewise and with the same argument as before we obtain @xmath430 .
new - late under the assumption that @xmath307 $ ] , the lie superalgebra @xmath0 is perfect ( that is @xmath431 $ ] ) if and only if @xmath432 = \fa$ ] , i.e. , if @xmath433 . if this is the case , then @xmath434 , so that @xmath0 is a central quotient of a direct sum of the ideals @xmath24 , @xmath322 .
rem : a for the even part , we obtain with lemma [ teh6 ] @xmath415_{{\bar{0}}}= \fz(\g)_{{\bar{0}}}+ \sum_{j \in j_s } [ \fa_j , \fa_{j ' } ] + \sum_{k \in j_a } [ \fb , \fa_k].\ ] ] here the ideals @xmath338 $ ] of @xmath1 are simple and act non - trivially only on the subspace @xmath337 of @xmath424 , whereas the ideals @xmath435 $ ] are reductive and act non - trivially only on the subspace @xmath429 of @xmath424 .
let @xmath0 be a reductive lie superalgebra with @xmath307 $ ] .
let @xmath436 be the centralizer of @xmath424 in @xmath223 and @xmath437 a complementary subspace for @xmath77 .
then @xmath438 + \fb_r$ ] is a lie superalgebra and @xmath439 is a direct sum of lie superalgebras , where the image @xmath440 of @xmath77 in @xmath441 is a central ideal and @xmath442 is semisimple .
the image @xmath440 of @xmath77 in @xmath443 is an abelian ideal because @xmath341 = [ \fz,\fb ] \subeq \fz(\g)_{{\bar{0}}}$ ] and @xmath444 = \{0\}$ ] .
we conclude that @xmath443 is a direct sum of @xmath442 and @xmath440 .
it remains to show that @xmath442 is semisimple , i.e. , that every solvable ideal @xmath445 is contained in @xmath446 .
first we observe that @xmath447 is a solvable ideal of the reductive lie algebra @xmath1 , hence central in @xmath1 .
since the subspaces @xmath337 , @xmath283 , and @xmath429 , @xmath322 , are pairwise non - equivalent @xmath1-modules by remark [ rem : a ] , the subspace @xmath448 is adapted to the decomposition @xmath449 . if @xmath283 and @xmath450 , then @xmath451 , and the relation @xmath452 = [ \fb,\fa_k ] \subeq \fr$ ] contradicts the solvability of @xmath453 .
if @xmath322 , then @xmath454 is a solvable ideal of @xmath24 , hence central ( proposition [ prop:3.5](iii ) ) , so that @xmath455 .
this implies that @xmath456 .
now let @xmath457 .
if @xmath380 \not=\{0\}$ ] for some @xmath283 , the simplicity of the ideal @xmath380 $ ] of @xmath1 contradicts @xmath458 . if @xmath459 \not=\{0\}$ ] for some @xmath322 , then @xmath459 \subeq [ \g_{{\bar{0 } } } , \g_{{\bar{0}}}]$ ] ( lemma [ teh6](i ) ) shows that @xmath459 $ ] is semisimple , which also contradicts the solvability of @xmath453 .
we conclude that @xmath460 = \{0\}$ ] .
hence @xmath461 and thus @xmath462 . as @xmath453 is an ideal
, we derive that @xmath463 \subeq \fr \cap \g_{{\bar{1}}}= \{0\}$ ] , and since @xmath18 generates @xmath0 , we see that @xmath464 is central in @xmath0 , so @xmath465 .
we conclude that every solvable ideal in @xmath442 is trivial .
let @xmath466 be the gramann algebra of degree @xmath29 over @xmath8 and @xmath467 for the lie superalgebra of its derivations . for a semisimple lie superalgebra @xmath468 ,
a slight modification of the arguments in @xcite shows that there exist real simple lie superalgebras @xmath469 and nonnegative integers @xmath470 such that @xmath471 where , for @xmath472 , @xmath473 is the centroid of @xmath474 and @xmath475 is the subfield killed by @xmath476 . if , in addition , @xmath468 is reductive , then the lie algebras @xmath477 must be reductive , which immediately implies that @xmath478 ( cf .
the information contained in our structure theorem [ thm:3.8 ] is much finer because we obtain @xmath479 where @xmath26 is simple .
sec:4 we now show how the decomposition derived in the previous section can be refined to unitary lie superalgebras .
the following lemma helps us to understand , for a compact lie superalgebra , the structure of @xmath24 in terms of the simple adjoint quotient ( proposition [ prop:3.5 ] ) .
more specifically , for @xmath483 , @xmath63 , and @xmath34 , all central extensions are trivial , for @xmath484 , the lie superalgebra @xmath36 is the universal central extension , and @xmath35 is the universal central extension of @xmath117 .
. then @xmath77 acts trivially on @xmath480 , so that the adjoint action of @xmath486 factors through an action of @xmath487 .
our assumption that @xmath488 is contained in @xmath489 $ ] implies that @xmath490 $ ] , so that the bracket map of @xmath480 factors through a surjective linear map @xmath491 since @xmath4 is a semisimple @xmath487-module , so is @xmath492 , and therefore @xmath480 also is a semisimple @xmath487-module .
we conclude that there exists an @xmath487-invariant complement of the center @xmath77 .
we may thus write @xmath493 = ( \omega(x , x ' ) , [ x , x']),\ ] ] where @xmath494 is a @xmath205-cocycle . since the corresponding decomposition of @xmath480 is @xmath487-invariant , @xmath495
. therefore @xmath16 is of the form @xmath496 where @xmath497 is an @xmath487-invariant symmetric bilinear map .
in particular , the odd component @xmath498 vanishes .
since the @xmath487-module @xmath499 is simple , the space @xmath500 is one - dimensional .
in fact , if @xmath501 is an @xmath487-invariant positive definite scalar product on @xmath499 , then any other invariant symmetric bilinear form @xmath502 can be written as @xmath503 for a symmetric @xmath487-intertwining operator @xmath504 .
then the diagonalizability of @xmath504 implies that @xmath505 , so that @xmath502 is a multiple of the scalar product , and thus @xmath500 is one - dimensional .
now the perfectness of @xmath480 implies that @xmath506 . for @xmath507 , @xmath63 , and @xmath34 ,
all central extensions are trivial because their complexification has this property by remark [ rem:1.2](c ) . in view of @xmath506
, @xmath36 must be the universal central extension of @xmath88 , and likewise @xmath35 is the universal central extension of @xmath117 .
we consider the compact simple lie superalgebra @xmath515 ( proposition [ prop:3.5](iii ) ) . in view of theorem [ thm:1.4 ] , it is isomorphic to one of the following @xmath516 for @xmath517 and @xmath34 , all central extensions are trivial by lemma [ lem : centext ] . since @xmath24 is perfect , we obtain in this case @xmath518 .
lem : centext ] also implies that the simple lie superalgebras @xmath88 and @xmath117 have a unique non - trivial central extension by a one - dimensional center . as @xmath519 in this case ,
the lie superalgebra @xmath4 is not unitary
. therefore @xmath24 must be isomorphic to the unique central extension @xmath480 .
\(a ) let @xmath4 be a simple compact lie superalgebra .
if @xmath520 or @xmath521 , then all derivations of @xmath4 are inner by remark [ rem:1.2](c ) .
this implies that , in any lie superalgebra @xmath0 , an ideal isomorphic to @xmath4 is a direct summand because @xmath522 .
\(b ) if @xmath523 or @xmath117 , then the situation is more complicated . from lemma [ lem : centext ]
we know that @xmath4 has a universal central extension isomorphic to @xmath36 or @xmath35 , respectively . in particular ,
all derivations of @xmath4 lift in a unique fashion to derivations of @xmath480 , so that @xmath524 . in @xmath525
the subspace @xmath526 of inner derivations is an ideal , and @xmath527 is compactly embedded in @xmath525 .
we therefore have an @xmath487-invariant splitting @xmath528 where all derivations in @xmath529 commute with @xmath487 , i.e. , @xmath530 for @xmath531 .
since any such @xmath504 is odd , this implies that @xmath103 .
any @xmath532 yields an @xmath487-intertwining operator @xmath533 .
conversely , an @xmath487-intertwining operator @xmath534 extends to an odd derivation annihilating @xmath487 if and only if @xmath535 = [ x , dy ] \quad \mbox { for } \quad x , y \in \fk_{{\bar{1}}}.\ ] ] for @xmath523 , the space @xmath536 is a simple @xmath487-module not isomorphic to any of the two ideals of @xmath487 .
therefore @xmath537 implies that @xmath538 .
accordingly , @xmath512= \{0\}$ ] for any ideal of this type .
\(c ) for @xmath539 , we have @xmath540 and @xmath541 with respect to the adjoint action . as @xmath542 is a simple complex lie algebra , the @xmath487-module @xmath499 is absolutely simple , i.e. , @xmath543 .
this implies that @xmath544 .
we have already seen in example [ ex:1.3](c ) that a non - zero odd outer derivation exists . for an ideal of this type , a one - dimensional quotient of @xmath223 may act non - trivially on @xmath24 . for @xmath513 the relation @xmath417 \not=\{0\}$ ] therefore leads to an embedding of @xmath514 ( cf .
example [ ex:1.3](c ) ) .
ex : tildetk let @xmath4 be a simple compact lie algebra and @xmath545 , be as in example [ ex : tk ] .
we write @xmath546 for the central extension of @xmath394 corresponding to a positive definite symmetric bilinear form @xmath65 on @xmath547 and @xmath548 for the corresponding center .
then @xmath549 is a clifford heisenberg lie superalgebra and @xmath550 .
now the faithful spin representation of @xmath159 ( cf .
subsection [ subsec:2.1 ] ) also carries a natural representation of @xmath4 because @xmath65 is @xmath4-invariant .
therefore @xmath551 is a unitary lie superalgebra .
if @xmath552 is a non - trivial central extension of lie superalgebras with @xmath553 $ ] , then the same arguments as in the proof of lemma [ lem : centext ] imply that @xmath554 , so that @xmath546 is the universal central extension of @xmath394 .
since @xmath394 is not unitary , it follows that , if @xmath0 is unitary and @xmath283 , then the ideal @xmath375 is isomorphic to @xmath555 . to this end
we use jakobsen s classification of unitary highest weight modules of basic classical lie superalgebras . in terms of (
9 ) the antilinear antiinvolution @xmath557 corresponds to the signs @xmath558 for the corresponding real form , ( * ? ? ?
* props .
9.7,9.8 ) represents a classification of the corresponding unitary highest weight modules .
since these modules are locally finite for the subalgebra @xmath1 whose real form is compact , ( * ? ? ?
5.2.5 ) implies that they are finite dimensional .
we conclude that the real lie superalgebra @xmath34 is unitary
. * acknowledgements . *
s. azam acknowledges the support of ipm ( grant no .
93160221 ) , and the banach algebra center of excellence for mathematics .
he would like to thank the people of department mathematik , friedrich - alexander universitt , for their hospitality during his visit . c. carmeli , g. cassinelli , a. toigo , v. s. varadarajan , _ unitary representations of super lie groups and applications to the classification and multiplet structure of super particles _ , comm .
263:1 * ( 2006 ) , 217258 .
neeb , h. salmasian , _ lie supergroups , unitary representations , and invariant cones _ , in " supersymmetry in mathematics and physics , r. fioresi , s. ferrara and v. s. varadarajan , eds .
notes in math .
* 2027 * ( 2011 ) , 195239 .
varadarajan , v. s. _ supersymmetry for mathematicians : an introduction _ , courant lecture notes in mathematics , 11 .
new york university , courant institute of mathematical sciences , new york ; american mathematical society , providence , ri , 2004 . | motivated by the theory of unitary representations of finite dimensional lie supergroups , we describe those lie superalgebras which have a faithful finite dimensional unitary representation .
we call these lie superalgebras unitary .
this is achieved by describing the classification of real finite dimensional compact simple lie superalgebras , and analyzing , in a rather elementary and direct way , the decomposition of reductive lie superalgebras ( @xmath0 is a semisimple @xmath1-module ) over fields of characteristic zero into ideals . + _ keywords : _ unitary , reductive , compact lie superalgebras , central extension , spin representation + _ msc : _ 17b20 ; 22e45 .
@xmath2 _ _
@xmath3 _ _ |
electron spin resonance from single - walled carbon nanotubes ( swcnts ) has been a subject of extensive studies in the recent past , starting in 1997 @xcite and continuing until most recently a set of new papers @xcite appeared . in several of the early papers response from localized and itinerant spins
was claimed as well as from various collective phenomena such as ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic ordering or even superconductivity @xcite .
the discussion about the observation of spins from itinerant electrons entered a new state with the publication of a recent theoretical work @xcite where electrons in a tomonaga - luttinger liquid state ( tll ) were postulated to have an extremely broad esr absorption line , even at temperatures below 4 k. the tll state was well demonstrated for swcnt from photo emission .
it is a consequence of the quasi - onedimensional ( 1d ) nature of the electrons in the tubes @xcite .
the discovery of possibilities to quantitatively separate semiconducting ( sc ) and metallic ( m ) tubes @xcite can be considered as a crucial step forward to tackle the problem , particularly if tubes were grown from non - magnetic catalysts @xcite .
this finding allowed for the possibility to study the esr response separately in the two types of tubes .
preliminary results were published recently for sc tubes immersed into ethanol as a tube carrying medium @xcite . however , in this case the solvent was interacting with the tubes obscuring intrinsic properties . here
we report on esr from fully m - sc separated swcnts grown from a non - magnetic ptrhre catalyst . even though no response from itinerant electrons could be detected down to 0.39 k significant differences in the esr response
were observed for the first time from the localized spins in the two tube systems .
the differences were particularly obvious for the line widths which were strongly enhanced at low temperatures for the m tubes and decreased with increasing @xmath0 .
in contrast , for the sc tubes , they were rather small at low temperatures but increased with @xmath0 . for the esr susceptibility a curie - weiss behavior was observed with ferromagnetic coupling . at @xmath1 a ferromagnetic state is obtained , without contributions of magnetic components .
interaction of the spins is suggested to be by indirect exchange with an additional contribution of long range rkky type interaction for the m tubes . in the latter
this interaction also dominates the line width whereas for the sc tubes the increase of the line width with @xmath0 is ascribed to spin lattice relaxation via an orbach process .
single - walled carbon nanotubes with an average diameter of 1.6 nm were grown by laser ablation using a ptrhre catalyst and m - sc separated to better than 97% as described previously @xcite .
bulk properties of the samples were characterized by transmission electron microscopy ( tem ) , x - ray diffraction and transport measurements .
tem revealed a clear bundling of the tubes with a bundle size between 20 and 100 nm and tapered ends @xcite . from x - ray diffraction a bundle peak at @xmath2nm@xmath3
was observed with slightly smaller and larger values for the m and for the sc tubes , respectively .
this corresponds to an average tube diameter of 1.6 nm in agreement with the observation from tem .
conductivity measurements revealed an almost temperature independent resistivity for the metallic tubes , following weak localization behavior .
this indicates good contact and evidences some 3d character of the metallic tubes .
in contrast , sc tubes exhibited an exponential increase of the resistivity with decreasing temperature following a variable range hoping behavior @xcite .
esr experiments were performed at x - band frequencies of 9.45ghz ( 39.07@xmath4ev ) in the temperature range between 1.5 and 200k with low power ( 30 db ) to avoid saturation . for temperatures between 0.39 and 1.7k a cylinder resonator
was used built into a he3 refrigerator and a superconducting magnet . in this case microwave power
was limited to 45 db .
samples from 500@xmath5c vacuum annealed tubes were prepared as bucky paper with high ( pt1 ) and low ( pt2 ) thickness compared to the skin depth of the microwaves .
the latter was evaluated from the dc conductance .
the tubes were inserted into a standard esr quartz tube and pumped to high vacuum before measurement .
spin concentration was estimated by a comparison to a `` strong pitch '' calibration sample from bruker .
this sample consists of pitch embedded into a kcl matrix with a standardized spin concentration of 1.2@xmath6 spins per cm length in a standard 4 mm esr quartz tube with 3 mm inner diameter .
calibration was performed at 1.5k where the peak to peak line width is 1.7 g .
considering the reduction of cavity quality factor by the nanotube samples we obtained 7.5@xmath7spins / g for the m tubes and 12@xmath7spins / g for the sc tubes . within experimental error
this is the same spin concentration and results in 1 spin per 1000 carbon atoms .
the esr spectra were fitted considering a dispersive signal contribution .
samples with high thickness behave textbook like as the m tubes show a well expressed asymmetry in the absorption whereas the absorption in the sc tubes remains nearly symmetric .
results for low temperature recording are depicted in fig.[fig : esrline ] . as indicated .
left side graphs : sc tubes , right side graphs : m tubes .
the smooth lines in the lower graphs are fits using eq.[eq : dyson ] with @xmath8 . for the fits of the upper graphs the anomalous skin effect had to be considered @xcite . ] for the case of the low thickness samples the esr response is nearly symmetric .
the remaining slight asymmetry was found to be well represented by the derivative of a dysonian line shape of the form @xmath9 where @xmath10 and @xmath11 are fitting parameters describing the signal amplitude , the resonance field , the line width , and a phase angle . for @xmath12
a contribution of the dispersive component of the susceptibility to the absorption line appears . since the analysis for the low thickness samples is much simpler , in the following results are reported only for the latter .
the esr susceptibility was evaluated as @xmath13 .
according to ref .
the line widths for the itinerant electrons should be around 1000 g at 4k for a tll parameter @xmath14 . for a very small decrease of @xmath15 due to bundling of only metallic tubes and for temperatures as low as
0.4k the line width should reduce to about 50 g , well within the range observable in our experiment .
however , even at the lowest temperature of 0.39 k no extra broad line is observed with a free carrier response signature . for the narrow lines depicted in fig .
[ fig : esrline ] we observe characteristic differences in the line widths between sc and m tubes with respect to their dependence on temperature and with respect to their values at low temperatures .
the line width increases with decreasing temperature for the m tubes but decreases for the sc tubes . as a consequence , at low temperatures
the line width for the former is significantly larger as compared to the line width of the latter .
examples are depicted in fig .
[ fig : msclw ] .
the increase of the line width for low temperatures is particularly dramatic for the m tubes before annealing .
the fit with an inverse power law yields 0.205 for the exponent and a constant _ residual line width _ of 3.3 g .
the observed increase in line width ( _ excess line width _ ) is more than a factor two from its residual width . for the annealed tubes a similar power law behavior is obtained for high and intermediate temperatures but the increase stops and levels off around 10k . in all cases the negative exponent is 0.2@xmath16 . for sc tubes the line width increases with temperature at least for high and intermediate temperatures , first in a quasi - linear manner with a trend to saturate for higher temperatures .
the total increase amounts up to 2 g for the temperature range under study .
the initial slope varies with sample treatment and decreases with tube annealing . at temperatures between 20 and
30k the line width becomes almost temperature independent with a noticeable re - increase for @xmath17 and a peak around 8k . due to the strong signal at these temperatures
the line widths were determined with a rms error of @xmath18 g which is approximately two times the size of the red dots in the insert .
in addition to the line width , the magnetic susceptibility was evaluated from the esr signal as a function of temperature .
the temperature dependence of @xmath19 exhibits a maximum value around 10k but is @xmath20 like for higher temperatures . as a consequence at high temperatures the lines are hardly detectable but recorded with high precision at low temperatures .
figure [ fig : temp1 ] depicts examples for for two samples as evaluated from amplitude @xmath21 and line width @xmath22 for m ( upper graphs ) and sc tubes ( lower graphs ) , respectively .
right part : @xmath23 vs @xmath0 in each case , together with a linear regression . @xmath24 and @xmath25 : averaged intersections of the regressions with the temperature axis . ] m and sc tubes .
the peak in the esr susceptibility coincides well with the leveling of the line width for the m samples at low temperatures and with the re - increase of the line width for the sc samples . using a curie - weiss law for @xmath19 as @xmath26 renders the spin - spin interaction as ferromagnetic rather than anti - ferromagnetic as the linear regressions in fig.[fig : temp1 ] intersect the temperature axis at positive values .
the observed peak in @xmath27 suggests a transition to a ferromagnetic state with a finite distribution of transition temperatures .
the lack of the observation of additional esr contributions from free carriers is consistent with a full tll state of the electrons even in the bundled metallic tubes with relaxed 1d character .
it is also consistent with recent experiments from photo emission where for metallic tubes tll signatures were observed in the spectral function @xcite .
the localized spins can be assigned to various defects such as single bonded covalent functionalization or defects on or inside the tubes .
the defect concentration is similar to the value of @xmath28/c reported in @xcite from magnetic measurements but considerably higher than values of @xmath29 given in @xcite .
the high spin concentration observed here is not surprising since both , purification and separation introduce defects .
this is also evidenced from raman scattering which revealed an increase of the d / g ratio by 33% from 0.06 to 0.08 ( 515 nm laser ) for the sc tubes and by 57.5% from 0.13 to 0.21 ( 647 nm laser ) for the m tubes .
the defects are in strong interaction with the tubes leading in general to similar behavior for m and sc tubes .
however , as far as transition temperatures and spin relaxation are concerned , significant differences are observed .
wave functions of the defect spins are in general spread out over a considerable number of hexagonal cells . for example
, dft calculations for hydrogen bonded to a small capped ( 3,3 ) swcnt yield a spin distribution over 5 and 8 hexagons in axial and radial direction , respectively @xcite .
this provides the possibility of exchange interaction in spite of the large distance between spins .
the interaction can be particularly enhanced by the indirect exchange mechanism across the carbon lattice , and , for m tubes , by interaction with free carriers according to the rkky mechanism . in the suggested ferromagnetic state we do not observe the esr response from the magnetically ordered spins , since the easy axes of the magnetic regions are randomly oriented following the random orientation of the nanotubes or bundles of nanotubes .
magnetic anisotropy can be traced back to an anisotropic curvature perpendicular and parallel to the tube axis and the concomitant anisotropy in the so coupling .
magnetic properties from defects in carbon systems have been reported in several publications @xcite .
apparently transversal extension of the tubes or the 3d nature of the bundles is enough to allow ferromagnetic or anti - ferromagnetic interaction but it is not enough to suppress tll nature of the electrons .
a decrease of spin susceptibility at low temperatures was recently reported for unseparated swcnts @xcite and speculated to originate from a spin gap opening or from an anti - ferromagnetic ordering of the defect spins as it was suggested for the magnetic behavior of nanohorns @xcite .
the low concentration of defect spins in @xcite may be a problem for such interpretation .
in contrast , in our case with the much higher spin concentration the temperature dependence of the inverse susceptibility exhibits clear ferromagnetic coupling for sc and m tubes .
indications for weak ferromagnetism in small parts of nanotube samples were also reported from magnetization measurements of swcnt with high concentration of defect spins in @xcite . however in this case it was suggested that ferromagnetic ordering occurs in metallic tubes only . in the m tubes the transition temperatures @xmath30 as evaluated from the linear regressions
are almost a factor two higher than in the sc tubes .
this is suggested to be due to the additional spin - spin interaction mediated by the free carriers . in low dimensional electronic systems
the rkky type interaction is very efficient since it extends as @xmath31 where @xmath32 is the distance between two spins and @xmath33 is the dimension of the system @xcite .
in swcnt it is particularly interesting since fermi wave vectors can be either zero or @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the nt translation vector @xcite . as a consequence
the rkky interaction is not oscillatory , at least not for tubes with @xmath36 .
rkky interaction is likewise important for the transition temperatures and for the line widths and was shown in @xcite to decrease with increasing @xmath0 .
the increase of the line width with increasing temperature for sc tubes suggests spin - lattice interaction ( sli ) as the relevant process for spin relaxation .
sli is usually mediated by either a direct process which is linear in @xmath0 , a raman process which goes with a high power of @xmath0 or an orbach process . since only the latter exhibits saturation with @xmath0
it is natural to invoke it for the description of the experiments . on the other hand ,
the re - increase of the line width at very low temperatures indicates additional contributions .
since it is suggestive that this increase is related to the ferromagnetic phase transition with the statistically distributed transition temperatures a gaussian temperature dependence is appropriate for its description .
considering homogeneous and inhomogeneous contributions we describe the line width obtained from the dysonian fits as @xmath37 where @xmath38 is a lorentzian type homogeneous line width following an orbach relaxation @xmath39 and @xmath40 considers the line width from gaussian fluctuations and possible concomitant variations of @xmath41 values .
@xmath42 is a temperature independent background line width .
this pythagorayan addition of line width components is a commonly used approximation which mimics a folding procedure @xcite .
@xmath43 and @xmath21 in the expression for the orbach process are the energetic distance to a higher electronic state for the spin excitation , and a scaling prefactor .
@xmath44 , @xmath45 , and @xmath46 are the parameters of the distribution from inhomogeneous fluctuations . as shown in fig.[fig : wfit ] , eq.[eq : orbgauss ] provides a very good representation of the experiments with @xmath21 , @xmath43 , @xmath44 , @xmath45 @xmath46 , and @xmath42 as parameters . for semiconducting samples versus temperature @xmath0 .
squares : line width from the experiment , line : fit according to eq.[eq : orbgauss ] ( left ) and explicit representation of the fit components ( right ) .
fit parameters were @xmath47 g , @xmath48k for the orbach relaxation and @xmath49 g , @xmath50k , @xmath51k for the gaussian distribution , and @xmath52 g for the background .
the insert shows the scheme for the orbach process . ] from the parameter values in the caption of fig.[fig : wfit ] the excitation energy is 3.8 mev ( 45.1k ) .
applying the same fitting procedure to the other sample gave very similar values .
@xmath43 was in particular found to be 44.5k for the second sample . in the case of a spin - lattice relaxation by an orbach process
the excited spin state @xmath53 and the ground state @xmath54 are coupled by a perturbation hamiltonian @xmath55 to an intermediate split off electronic state @xmath56 to which spins are excited before relaxation .
a scheme of this process is depicted in fig.[fig : wfit ] .
the perturbation is in general phononic or vibronic . in the original work of r. orbach
@xcite the extra electronic state came from crystal field splitting .
due to the large number of defects in our samples a rather large number of possible excited states can be expected which supports a spin - lattice relaxation by an orbach process .
the increase of the line widths for @xmath57k in the sc tubes is the signature of fluctuations when approaching the phase transition .
the values from fig.[fig : temp1 ] for @xmath58k are in good agreement with the value of @xmath59k used for the fit in fig.[fig : wfit ] .
fluctuations along with structural phase transitions are well known to broaden esr lines .
@xcite this broadening often follows a power law of the form @xmath60 with @xmath61 of the order of 1 .
the fit depicted in the insert of fig.[fig : msclw ] yields @xmath62 , slightly smaller than expected .
this deviation is very likely due to the statistical distribution of @xmath1 with the concomitant flattening of the slope .
for the metallic tubes a decrease of line width with increasing temperature is observed . since in our case
the defect spins are localized and do not show activated behavior motional narrowing can be ruled out for an explanation . increasing and even diverging line widths for decreasing @xmath0
were also reported for metallic spin systems which undergo a transition to a spin glass @xcite . however , in this case line widths of the order of 100 g are expected .
since this is not observed here we are left with an indirect exchange mechanism as responsible for the increase of line with decreasing temperature . in the metallic tubes
this mechanism has a strong contribution from the free carrier rkky interaction which increases with decreasing temperature as described above .
one may certainly ask why spin lattice interaction e.g. in the form of an orbach process is not active for the metallic tubes .
such behavior can indeed not be ruled out . as it would partly compensate the negative temperature coefficient observed for the metallic tubes such relaxation would result in an even stronger decrease of line width with temperature for the metallic tubes .
the surprise in the results for the line width concerns not only the different temperature dependence but even more the considerably larger line width for the m tubes as compared to the sc tubes at low temperatures .
this , together with the different temperature dependence , leads to a crossover of the line widths with increasing temperature .
while the ratio between the excess line width for the m tubes and for the sc tubes is 3.2 at 1.5k on average , it is only 0.6 at 200k .
this is suggested to be a consequence of the increasing spin - lattice interaction with increasing @xmath0 and the simultaneous decrease of the line width due to the decreasing rkky interaction .
in summary we have shown that m - sc separated swcnt reveal significant differences in their esr response . while for both types of tubes a ferromagnetic temperature dependence is observed for the spin susceptibility , the latter levels off at characteristic temperatures @xmath63 and eventually decreases .
this is interpreted as a transition to a ferromagnetic state .
the difference in the transition temperature for the two tube systems is suggested to originate from an rkky type interaction of the spins with the free carriers in the m tubes .
even more dramatic is the observed difference in the temperature dependence of the line width for the two tube systems .
it decreases with increasing temperature for the m tubes but increases for the sc tubes . since the behavior of the metallic tubes follows the temperature dependence of the rkky interaction the latter
is suggested to be responsible for the line narrowing .
in contrast , for sc tubes an orbach type relaxation process is suggested to be responsible for the broadening of the esr lines width increasing temperature . | the esr response from highly metal - semiconductor(m - sc ) separated swcnts for temperatures @xmath0 between 0.39 and 200k is characteristically different for the two systems .
the signal originates from defect spins but interaction with free electrons leads to a larger line width for m tubes . the latter decreases with increasing @xmath0 whereas it increases with @xmath0 for sc tubes .
the spins undergo a ferromagnetic phase transition below around 10k .
indirect exchange is suggested to be responsible for the spin - spin interaction , supported by rkky interaction in the case of m tubes . for sc tubes spin - lattice relaxation via an orbach process is suggested to determine the line width . |
in this paper , we investigated the effects of charging and applied perpendicular electric field on the electronic , magnetic and chemical properties of silicene and germanene by performing first - principles dft spin - polarized and spin - unpolarized calculations using pbc within supercell geometry with varying vacuum spacing @xmath3 .
we used pw , as well as local , atomic orbital ( ao ) basis sets .
first , we clarified how the effects of charging and perpendicular electric field calculated from first - principle pw method can depend on the vacuum spacing @xmath3 as an artifact of the method .
furthermore , we showed that this artifact can be eliminated if silicene or germanene , which are exerted by a @xmath10 or charged by excess electrons @xmath11 are treated using the ao basis set . with the premises that silicene and germanene
can attain new functionalities through the charging and the applied electric field , present results will be crucial for future theoretical and experimental studies . in order to show the effects of external effects , such as @xmath10 and @xmath11
, we did not consider the spin - orbit coupling , which also gives rise to a small band opening .
pw and local ao basis sets are used in numerical calculations through vasp@xcite and siesta@xcite packages , respectively
. the exchange - correlation potential is approximated by generalized gradient approximation using perdew , burke and ernzerhof ( pbe ) functional@xcite .
dipole corrections@xcite are applied in order to remove spurious dipole interactions between periodic images for the neutral calculations .
for all structures studied in this paper , the geometry optimization is performed by the conjugate gradient method by allowing all the atomic positions and lattice constants to relax . the convergence for energy
is chosen as 10@xmath12 ev between two consecutive steps . in atomic relaxations ,
the total energy is minimized until the forces on atoms are smaller than 0.04 ev / . a basis set with kinetic energy cutoff of 500 ev and projector - augmented wave potentials@xcite
are used in the pw calculations@xcite . in ao
calculations@xcite the eigenstates of the kohn - sham hamiltonian are expressed as linear combinations of numerical atomic orbitals . a 250 ryd mesh cut - off
is chosen and the self - consistent calculations are performed with a mixing rate of 0.2 .
core electrons are replaced by norm - conserving , nonlocal truoiller - martins pseudopotentials@xcite .
the grid of * k*-points used is 19x19x1 for ao calculations and
12x12x1 for pw calculations , which are determined by a convergence analysis with respect to the number of grid - points . explains how the excess electrons of silicene or germanene charged @xmath13 0 can spill to the vacuum region , when treated using pw within pbc .
`` a '' stands for atomic planes .
( b)same for the electric field @xmath10 , exerting perpendicular to silicene and germanene planes .
the vacuum spacing between the layers is denoted by @xmath3.,width=453 ]
before we start to investigate the effects of charging on the electronic structure of silicene and germanene , we first examine the limitations of pbc method , where two - dimensional silicene as well as germanene layers separated by large spacing @xmath3 are repeated periodically along the @xmath14-axis .
we carried out first - principles pw calculations as well as ao calculations and investigated the effect of charging on silicene and germanene layers . throughout the paper
, @xmath15 indicates the negative charging , namely the number of excess electrons per primitive cell ( corresponding to the surface charge density @xmath16 in @xmath17 , @xmath18 being the area of the primitive cell ) ; @xmath19 indicates the positive charging , namely number of depleted electrons per primitive cell ; and @xmath20 is the neutral cell . the calculated electronic structure of silicene and germanene
are presented in fig .
[ fig1 ] and fig .
[ fig2 ] . for neutral case ( @xmath11=0 ) ,
the work function , i.e. the minimum energy that must be given to an electron to release it from the single layer is the difference of the reference vacuum energy and fermi level .
the value of work function extracted from the band structure is @xmath21=4.57 ev ( @xmath21=4.37 ev for germanene ) . as seen , the calculated electronic structure using pw and ao are similar .
minute differences originate from different pseudopotentials used in calculations .
moreover , the perfect convergence of different basis sets can be achieved only by using very large cutoff values .
the negative charging can lead marked effects in the electronic structure of single layer silicene and germanene . when charged with @xmath22 electrons per primitive cell , the energy bands calculated for the vacuum spacing @xmath23 using pw in fig . [ fig1 ] ( a ) and ao basis sets in fig
. [ fig1 ] ( b ) are similar .
the dirac points dip below the fermi level and the semimetallic silicene becomes a metal .
similar effect is seen also in the band structure of germanene in fig.[fig2 ] .
however , when the same charged systems are treated with a relatively larger vacuum spacing of @xmath24 , the pw results dramatically deviate from those of ao .
parabolic bands are lowered and eventually the fermi level is pinned as shown in fig .
[ fig1 ] ( c ) .
such a situation does not occur when ao basis set is used .
hence , results obtained from ao calculations are independent of the size of vacuum spacing as seen in fig .
[ fig1 ] ( d ) .
the cause of this spurious dependence of vacuum size can be understood through the ( @xmath25)-plane averaged self - consistent field ( scf ) electronic potential along the @xmath14-direction . a schematic description of the situation , which explains how the excess electrons for negatively charged silicene or germanene layers can spill into the vacuum region as a result of the above spurious effect is shown in fig .
[ fig3 ] ( a ) .
earlier we made such analysis by plane - averaging of 3d , scf one - electron potential of graphene@xcite . here
the same situation is arising ; as schematically described , @xmath26 is lowered and passes through a minimum at the middle of vacuum spacing .
normally , for @xmath11=0 @xmath26 makes sharp dips at the atomic layers and rises and flattens at @xmath4 .
the maximum of @xmath26 corresponds to the vacuum potential .
however , in the actual case of single silicene ( or germanene ) layer , which is charged with @xmath130 , @xmath26 passes through a maximum near the surface and goes to @xmath27 as @xmath28 at both sides . then , in view the 1d wkb approximation , the electrons in the silicene ( or germanene ) layer might have spilled to vacuum only if they could tunnel across a wide triangular barrier . the width of the barrier
, @xmath29 decreases with increasing negative charging . under these circumstances ,
the spilling of electrons must have been negligibly low and hence excess electrons are practically trapped in the layer , if the value of @xmath30 is not very high .
however , when treated within pbc , @xmath26 of periodically repeating silicene ( or germanene ) layers with a vacuum spacing @xmath3 between them can make a dip reminiscent of a quantum well at the center of the spacing as shown in fig .
[ fig3 ] ( a ) . under these circumstances ,
kohn - sham hamiltonian using pw can acquire solutions in this quantum well , which are localized along the @xmath14-direction , but free - electron like in the ( @xmath25)-plane parallel to si planes .
these states form the parabolic bands in the ( @xmath31 ) plane as shown in fig .
[ fig1 ] ( c ) and fig .
[ fig2 ] ( c ) .
if the quantum well dips below the fermi level with increasing @xmath3 or @xmath11 , excess electrons in silicene or germanene start to be accommodated in these 2d free - electron like bands .
this ends up with the spilling of excess electrons into the vacuum region .
the amount of excess electrons spilled to the vacuum spacing increases with increasing @xmath3 and also increases with increasing negative charging at a fixed value of @xmath3 .
the situation in fig .
[ fig1 ] ( c ) and fig . [ fig2 ] ( c ) , where the fermi level pinned by the parabolic bands of electrons spilled to the vacuum for large @xmath3 , is an artifact of the pbc and give rise to the dependence on the size of vacuum .
as for ao calculations , the spurious quantum well like structure at the middle of vacuum spacing between silicene or germanene layers in pbc are devoid of basis set and hence can not support the bound electronic states , since the local atomic orbitals are placed only at the atomic sites .
this is why @xmath26 calculated by ao does not accommodate excess electrons in its minimum between silicene layers and hence the parabolic bands seen in fig .
[ fig1 ] ( c ) and fig . [ fig2 ] ( c ) do not appear in fig .
[ fig1 ] ( d ) and fig
. [ fig2 ] ( d ) , when it is further lowered below the fermi level with increasing @xmath3 .
the behavior of @xmath26 at the proximity of the surface is similar to the actual case , where @xmath32 .
accordingly , excess negative charge is prevented from spilling into the spacing between adjacent graphene layers , and hence remains in silicene as in the actual case consisting of one single silicene or germanene charged by @xmath330 .
in contrast to the above shortcomings arising in pw method in treating the negative charging @xmath130 , results obtained by ao and pw are in reasonable agreement for @xmath34 , since @xmath26 passes through a maximum at the center of @xmath3 between graphene layers . accordingly , a method using pbc and pw basis set is not affected significantly from the size of vacuum spacing @xmath3 , if @xmath34 . for positively charging ,
the fermi level shifts down the dirac points and the material becomes hole - doped and hence is metallized . ,
versus applied electric field @xmath10 for silicene . when obtained using ao , band gap values calculated for
various @xmath3 fall on the same line .
( b ) gap opening @xmath35 as a function of applied electric field @xmath10 calculated for different vacuum spacings @xmath3 .
gap openings induced by @xmath10 does not depend on the vacuum spacing @xmath3 , when calculated using ao.,width=453 ] in the case of @xmath10 , the mirror symmetry between the top side and the bottom side of silicene is broken , and hence the plane averaged electronic potential exhibits a sawtooth like variation in pbc . at high @xmath10 and large @xmath3
, a quantum well like structure occurs at the lowered side of @xmath26 .
when treated by pw method , this quantum well like structure can dip below the fermi level and hence electrons of silicene which can be accommodated in this quantum well end up with the electron spilling to vacuum by resulting in a similar situation above for @xmath330 .
this situation is schematically described in fig .
[ fig3 ] ( b ) .
this is the reason why the band gap opening under @xmath10 is depended on @xmath3 in dft calculations using the plane wave basis set@xcite . as a matter of fact , in the band structure presented in fig .
3 ( c ) of the recent plane wave based study@xcite , at high @xmath10 one sees a free electron like band touching the fermi level .
however , when treated by ao method , calculated values of the band gap as a function of @xmath10 fall on the same line as shown in fig . [ fig4 ] ( a ) .
this is better seen in fig .
[ fig4](b ) demonstrating that band gaps induced in different values of @xmath10 are practically independent of @xmath3 .
the behavior of gap opening with applied @xmath10 in germanene is similar to that in silicene .
spin - polarized calculations indicate that the non - magnetic ground state of silicene and germanene is practically unaltered upon charging or under electric field . however , the permanent magnetic moment of a ti atom adsorbed to silicene and germanene exhibit significant changes upon charging or under the electric field . however , it is argued that ordinary dft may not be appropriate to treat the strongly correlated @xmath36-orbitals , such as in adsorbed ti atom .
often approaches such as dft+u are used to address this issue@xcite .
surprisingly , in most cases concerning ti adsorbed on si and graphene surfaces , dft has provided reasonable predictions .
earlier , we examined the effects of correlation by performing lda+u calculations@xcite . since u parameters were not available for ti adsorbed on si surfaces , we carried out calculations by taking u as a parameter@xcite .
we also performed similar calculations for transition metal dichalcogenides , sco2 , nio2 and wo2 in single layer honeycomb structure@xcite .
we found that in these studies up to high values of u our predictions obtained by dft remained valid .
energetically , the most favorable bonding site of the ti adatom on silicene and germanene is found to be the hollow site , above the center of the hexagon .
we investigate the magnetic properties of ti covered silicene and germanene using supercell geometry in different levels of coverage , since the resulting magnetic ground states depend on the ti - ti coupling and hence on the coverage of ti atom .
first , we consider the case of very weak ti - ti coupling by using uniform coverage in which one ti adatom is adsorbed to each ( 4 x 4 ) supercell of silicene(germanene ) corresponding to @xmath37=1/32 ( i.e. one ti atom per 32 si(ge ) atoms ) and leading to the ti - ti distance of 15.39(16.06 ) . in the neutral case ,
both silicene and germanene have a spin - polarized , ferromagnetic ( fm ) ground state with a magnetic moment of @xmath38 @xmath39 ( i.e per ( 4 x 4 ) supercell ) .
the magnetic moment of the spin - polarized state of silicene increases to @xmath40 @xmath39 ( @xmath41 @xmath39 for germanene ) for @xmath42 + 1.0 e / cell . for the excess electronic charge of @xmath43 the magnetic moment increases to @xmath44 @xmath39 ( @xmath45 @xmath39 for germanene ) .
the variation of @xmath46 is due to the accommodation of different electronic charges of ti @xmath0-states for different values of @xmath11 .
similar effect can be generated also by the static electric field .
spin - polarization of ti adsorbed silicene and germanene show also significant changes with applied electric field @xmath10 . while their magnetic moments become unaltered for @xmath47 ( i.e. @xmath10 is directed towards ti adatom ) , they increase to @xmath48 for @xmath49 .
apparently , either by charging of ti+silicene ( ti+germanene ) @xmath50 complex or by exerting an electric field , @xmath51 one can modify the occupations of @xmath0-orbitals and hence can change the net magnetic moment .
when a significant ti - ti interaction sets in , the magnetic ground states show interesting changes as presented in table i. we consider the case of significant ti - ti coupling by using uniform coverage in which 4 ti adatoms are adsorbed to each @xmath50 supercell of silicene(germanene ) corresponding to @xmath52 coverage and leading to a ti - ti distance of 7.69 ( 8.03 ) .
this supercell geometry allows us to treat the antiferromagnetic ( afm ) order .
similar to the coverage of @xmath53 , silicene and germanene has fm spin polarized fm magnetic ground states at @xmath52 , except the case of afm ground state occurring under @xmath10=1 v / .
also we predict that an external effect like @xmath11 or @xmath10 causing charge depletion from ti adatom give rise to an increase in the magnetic moment .
.magnetic ground states ( afm : antiferromagnetic or fm : ferromagnetic ) and magnetic moments in @xmath54 per ti atom ( i.e. per ( 2x2 ) cell ) calculated as a function of charging and applied perpendicular electric field .
calculations are performed in the ( 4x4 ) supercell of silicene and germanene having 4 uniformly adsorbed ti atoms .
@xmath55 denotes for positive @xmath10=1 v / ( directed towards ti atom ) and vice versa for @xmath56 .
@xmath57 corresponds to the charging where one electron is removed from the ( 4x4 ) supercell and vice versa for @xmath58 . [
cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ] we predict that silicene uniformly covered with ti atom at @xmath52 is spin - polarized and has the permanent magnetic moment of @xmath46=3.0 @xmath54 and is a half - metal : namely it is metal for one spin direction , but semiconductor for the opposite spin direction . accordingly , this materials transport electrons only for one spin direction and can function as a spin valve . while silicene has afm ground state with zero net magnetic moment under @xmath10=1 v / , the ground state changes to fm when
the direction of the electric field is reversed causing charge transfer towards to ti atom .
in conclusion , single silicene and germanene can attain useful functionalities by charging and by perpendicular electric field .
while charging maintains the symmetry between both sides of honeycomb structure , this symmetry is broken down by the electric field perpendicular to the layer . as a result ,
linearly crossing bands split , where the band gap becomes linearly dependent on the value of the electric field .
also the work function as well as the binding energies of foreign adatoms become side specific . in particular , the occupations of @xmath0-orbitals of transition metal atoms adsorbed to silicene or germanene can be modified by charging or by applied electric field , which in turn , give rise to important changes in magnetic moments .
we showed that the vacuum space which can affect the calculated properties of silicene under excess charge or electric field can be eliminated by using local orbital basis sets .
this work was supported by tubitak and the academy of sciences of turkey(tuba ) .
part of the computational resources has been provided by tubitak ulakbim , high performance and grid computing center ( tr - grid e - infrastructure ) and uybhm at istanbul technical university through grant no : 2 - 024 - 2007 .
h. h. g " urel acknowledges the support of tubitak - bideb .
100 sahin , h. ; cahangirov , s. ; topsakal , m. ; bekaraoglu , e. ; akturk , e. ; senger , r.t . ; ciraci , s. monolayer honeycomb structures of group - iv elements and iii - v binary compounds : first - principles calculations .
b * 80 * , 155453 ( 2009 ) . vogt , p ; de padova , p. ; quaresima , c. ; avila , j. ; frantzeskakis , e. ; asensio , m.c . ; resta , a. ; ealet b. ; le lay , g. silicene : compelling experimental evidence for graphenelike two - dimensional silicon .
* 108 * , 155501 ( 2012 ) | using first - principles density functional theory calculations , we showed that electronic and magnetic properties of bare and ti adatom adsorbed single - layer silicene and germanene , which are charged or exerted by a perpendicular electric field are modified to attain new functionalities .
in particular , when exerted by a perpendicular electric field , the symmetry between the planes of buckled atoms is broken to open a gap at the dirac points .
the occupation of @xmath0-orbitals of adsorbed ti atom changes with charging or applied electric field to induce significant changes of magnetic moment .
we predict that neutral silicene uniformly covered by ti atoms becomes a half - metal at a specific value of coverage and hence allows the transport of electrons in one spin direction , but blocks the opposite direction .
these calculated properties , however exhibit a dependence on the size of the vacuum spacing between periodically repeating silicene and germanene layers , if they are treated using plane wave basis set within periodic boundary condition .
we clarified the cause of this spurious dependence and show that it can be eliminated by the use of local orbital basis set .
when charged or subjected to an external electric field , the electronic structure of two - dimensional ( 2d ) materials show important modifications . in particular graphene ,
a single layer of honeycomb structure of carbon atoms , is a semimetal and has an ambipolar character with @xmath1 and @xmath2 bands , which cross linearly at the fermi level .
depending on the polarity of the excess charge in graphene , the dirac points shift up or down the fermi level .
for example , the excess electrons cause the dirac points to dip below the fermi level . this way , semimetal graphene changes into a metal .
when electrons are depleted , the dirac points move up and graphene becomes hole - doped .
electric field applied perpendicular to graphene layers breaks the symmetry between both sides of the plane of carbon atoms .
however , the @xmath1 and @xmath2 bands continue to cross .
the effect of excess charge and perpendicular electric field on the electronic structure of graphene were investigated earlier@xcite .
electrons per primitive cell : ( a ) energy bands of neutral and charged cases calculated for @xmath3=12 using plane wave ( pw ) basis set are shown by green(light ) and blue(dark ) lines , respectively .
dirac points are lowered below the fermi level upon charging .
( b ) the same system in ( a ) is treated using the atomic orbital ( ao ) basis set .
( c ) same as ( a ) except for @xmath3=40 .
parabolic bands touching the fermi level are due to the free electron like states confined to the quantum well centered at @xmath4 as described in fig .
[ fig3 ] ( a ) .
( d ) same as ( b ) except for @xmath3=40 . as seen results obtained using ao calculations
do not depend on @xmath3 .
the inset at the top shows the buckled honeycomb structure of the silicene with buckling @xmath5 .,width=453 ] the dependence of the electronic structure of silicene when charged or subjected to perpendicular electric field is also of current interest .
the stability of this nanostructure in the buckled honeycomb geometry has been proven through ab - initio phonon calculations and extensive high temperature , first - principle molecular dynamics simulations by cahangirov _ _ et al.__@xcite .
similar to graphene , the @xmath1 and @xmath2 like bands of 2d silicene cross each other linearly at the fermi level leading to massless dirac fermion behavior with a fermi velocity @xmath6 , ( @xmath7 being the speed of light ) and they exhibit an ambipolar character with perfect electron - hole symmetry@xcite .
interestingly , quasi one - dimensional armchair nanoribbons of silicene were predicted to be semiconductors and they show a family behavior like graphene@xcite .
the synthesis of single - layer silicene@xcite which was achieved recently , has corroborated theoretical predictions by eliminating doubts about whether such a material can exist even though the parent silicon does not form a layered structure .
like silicene , germanene also displays similar properties .
both silicene and germanene lack strong @xmath1-@xmath1 interaction necessary for planar geometry , but they are stabilized through the @xmath8-hybridization followed by the @xmath9-dehybridization@xcite leading to buckling .
normally , electric field applied perpendicularly to the silicene or germanene layers , ( @xmath10 ) , breaks the symmetry between two si or ge - layers formed by these atoms situated at the alternating corners of buckled hexagons .
expectantly , linearly crossing bands split to open a band gap .
such a gap opening did not occur in graphene because of the planar geometry of constituent carbon atoms .
in fact , the gap opening of linearly crossing bands of silicene under @xmath10 have been studied earlier by two papers@xcite .
one of them@xcite carried out density functional ( dft ) calculations within periodic boundary conditions ( pbc ) using plane wave ( pw ) basis set and reported that the band gap depends on the vacuum spacing @xmath3 between adjacent layers . for germanene.,width=453 ] |
let @xmath0 be a closed orientable surface of genus @xmath1 . according to the nielsen - thurston classification @xcite , every non - periodic irreducible automorphism of @xmath0 is isotopic to a pseudo - anosov diffeomorphism .
thurston proved that the topological entropy of any pseudo - anosov diffeomorphism @xmath2 coincides with @xmath3 where @xmath4 is the dilatation of @xmath2 ( c.f .
* expos 10 ) ) . also by the work of bers @xcite ,
@xmath3 is known to be equal to the translation distance of @xmath2 on the teichmller space with respect to the teichmller metric .
the purpose of this paper is to demonstrate a `` random version '' of the work of bers and thurston .
let @xmath5 denote the mapping class group of @xmath0 .
we consider the random walk on @xmath5 which is determined by a probability measure @xmath6 on @xmath5 .
this @xmath6 induces a probability measure @xmath7 on @xmath8 . throughout the paper
we assume that @xmath6 has finite first moment with respect to the teichmller metric and the support of @xmath6 generates a non - elementary subgroup of @xmath5 ( see condition [ cond ] ) . before stating the main theorem
, we prepare several terminologies briefly .
formal definitions are given in
[ sec.pre ] .
first , the topological entropy @xmath9 of a sample path @xmath10 is defined using open coverings of @xmath0 , similarly to the one for surface diffeomorphisms .
this measures growth rate of the number of distinguishable orbits of the random walk .
next , karlsson @xcite proved that for @xmath7-a.e @xmath11 , the exponential growth rate of the length of the image @xmath12 of any simple closed curve @xmath13 with respect to any metric always gives the same quantity , which is called the `` lyapunov exponent '' @xmath14 of @xmath15 .
moreover , it is also proved that @xmath16 almost surely coincides with the drift @xmath17 with respect to thurston s asymmetric lipschitz metric on the teichmller space @xmath18 of @xmath0 .
roughly speaking , the drift is the translation distance of @xmath15 .
the goal of this paper is to show that those quantities are the same almost surely .
[ thm.main ] let @xmath6 be a probability measure on @xmath5 which satisfies condition [ cond ] and @xmath7 the probability measure on @xmath8 induced by @xmath6 . for @xmath7-a.e .
@xmath19 , we have the following equality .
@xmath20 where @xmath21 is the drift with respect to the teichmller metric .
these quantities are independent of @xmath15 and they are invariants of the random walk .
the strategy of the proof is similar to the one for pseudo - anosov diffeomorphisms in ( * ? ? ?
* expos 9 - 10 ) .
indeed , @xmath22 can be proved almost in the same way as the case of pseudo - anosov diffeomorphisms . to prove the opposite inequality for pseudo - anosovs , in @xcite
, a subshift of finite type is associated to the dynamics of a pseudo - anosov iteration by constructing so called a markov partition .
we will define a random subshift of finite type as a `` random version '' of a subshift of finite type ( see [ sec.random subshift ] ) .
then we will construct a semi - markov partition of @xmath0 which respects the dynamics of @xmath15 ( see definition [ defi.semi-markov ] ) and associate to it a random subshift of finite type .
the main difficulty , unlike pseudo - anosov diffeomorphisms , is that for @xmath7-a.e @xmath23 , some part of @xmath15 can be arbitrarily `` bad '' .
for example , the orbit @xmath24 of any point @xmath25 may have large backtrack . on the other hand , for a pseudo - anosov @xmath2 case
, the fact that @xmath2 acts as a translation on a teichmller geodesic is implicitly used in @xcite . to overcome the difficulty , in [ sec.markov]-[sec.main ] , we show that it suffices to observe only `` good '' elements in an orbit .
the existence of such `` good '' elements follows from ergodic theorems . to consider dynamics of @xmath15 on the surface
, we need to take representatives of mapping classes .
let @xmath26 denote the space of orientation preserving diffeomorphisms on @xmath0 .
let @xmath27 be a representative of @xmath28 and @xmath29 .
another difficulty occurs after taking representatives , that is , we can not use ergodic theorems .
this is because we can not take representatives so that they are compatible with the shift maps on @xmath8 , denoted @xmath30 .
notations @xmath31 are used instead of @xmath32 to warn readers this issue . our goal in [ sec.markov ] is to prove the following theorem .
[ thm.symbolic ] there exist a random subshift of finite type @xmath33 such that the following diagram commutes for any @xmath34 .
@xmath35 where @xmath36 is a continuous surjective map and @xmath37 is the shift map .
the topological entropy of @xmath37 in theorem [ thm.symbolic ] can be defined as the growth rate of the number of cylinder sets of length @xmath38 in @xmath39 .
let @xmath40 denote the topological entropy of @xmath37 .
the fact @xmath41 can be easily observed ( lemma [ lem.p - entropy ] ) . for pseudo - anosovs ,
the facts of type theorem [ thm.symbolic ] and @xmath41 suffice to prove a theorem of type theorem [ thm.main ] .
however , we need to vary structures of @xmath0 to construct a semi - markov partition . hence we need to discuss how structures , especially the lebesgue number of a fixed open covering , vary as the steps .
the lebesgue numbers are discussed in
[ sec.lebesgue ] , and the rest of [ sec.main ] is devoted for a proof of @xmath42 .
in this section , we prepare terminologies and basic facts which we need to prove theorem [ thm.main ] .
we briefly recall the teichmller spaces and related facts .
readers should refer @xcite for more details .
let @xmath0 be a closed orientable surface of genus @xmath43 . a _ marked riemann surface
_ is a pair of a riemann surface @xmath44 and a homeomorphism , called a _ marking _ ,
two marked riemann surfaces @xmath46 are said to be _ teichmller equivalent _ if there is a biholomorphic map @xmath47 such that @xmath48 is homotopic to @xmath49 .
the teichmller space @xmath18 of @xmath0 is the space of marked riemann surfaces modulo teichmller equivalence .
since each marking defines a complex structure on @xmath0 by pullback , we often confuse a point @xmath25 with a complex structure on @xmath0 .
the mapping class group @xmath5 acts on @xmath18 so that for @xmath50 with a representative @xmath51 , @xmath52 .
a holomorphic quadratic differential on @xmath25 is a family of holomorphic maps @xmath53 each defined on @xmath54 of a complex chart @xmath55 so that if @xmath56 then @xmath57 where @xmath58 . for @xmath25
, let @xmath59 denote the space of quadratic differentials . the vertical ( resp .
horizontal ) trajectories of a quadratic differential @xmath60 are curves @xmath61 such that @xmath62 ( resp .
@xmath63 ) . for each smooth arc @xmath64 ,
the transverse measures on the vertical and horizontal trajectories are defined by @xmath65 and @xmath66 respectively .
thus each @xmath67 defines two measured foliations called _ vertical _ and _ horizontal _ foliations as the vertical and horizontal trajectories equipped with the transverse measures respectively .
a theorem of teichmller says that given two points @xmath68 , there exists a quasi - conformal map @xmath69 and quadratic differentials @xmath70 and @xmath71 such that the map @xmath72 maps @xmath73 to @xmath74 so that it stretches ( resp .
contracts ) the horizontal ( resp .
vertical ) foliations .
the logarithm of the stretch factor coincides with the teichmller distance @xmath75 . by integrating the square root of a quadratic differential @xmath60
, we have a singular euclidean metric on @xmath76 .
with respect to the singular euclidean metric , the length of a smooth arc @xmath77 , denoted by @xmath78 , is equal to @xmath79 . for @xmath67
, we define the norm of @xmath60 by @xmath80 .
let @xmath81 .
we denote by @xmath82 the space of projective measured foliations .
we consider the thurston compactification @xmath83 on which @xmath5 acts continuously . by the work of thurston , @xmath82 is homeomorphic to the sphere of dimension @xmath84 @xcite .
we now recall the work of hubbard - masur .
[ thm.hm ] the map @xmath85 associating the equivalence class of the horizontal foliation to each @xmath86 is a homeomorphism .
let @xmath87 be transverse filling projective measured foliations .
let @xmath88 denote the teichmller geodesic corresponding to a quadratic differential with horizontal and vertical foliation @xmath89 and @xmath90 respectively ( see @xcite for the existence of such geodesics ) .
a projective measured foliation is called _ uniquely ergodic _ if its supporting foliation admits only one transverse measure up to scale .
let @xmath91 denote the space of uniquely ergodic foliations .
let @xmath90 be a countable group and @xmath92 $ ] a probability measure .
by @xmath93 ( resp .
@xmath94 ) , we denote the space of positive ( resp .
negative ) integers . for group elements
@xmath95 , the subset @xmath96:=\{\omega = ( \omega_{i})\in g^{\mathbb{z}_{+}}\mid \omega_{i } = x_{i } \text { for } 1\leq i\leq n\}\ ] ] is called a _
cylinder set_. the probability measure @xmath6 induces a probability measure @xmath7 on the space of sample paths @xmath97 so that @xmath98 ) = \mu(x_{0}^{-1}x_{1})\mu(x_{1}^{-1}x_{2})\cdots\mu(x_{n-1}^{-1}x_{n}),\ ] ] where @xmath99 is the initial element which is assumed to be the identity unless otherwise stated .
we also consider the _ reflected measure _ @xmath100 . let @xmath101 be the probability measure on @xmath102 induced by @xmath103
. then by the map @xmath104 , the probability measure @xmath105 induces a probability measure on @xmath106 which we again denote by @xmath7 .
we define the _ bernoulli shift _ , denoted by @xmath30 , as for any @xmath107 , @xmath108 recall that a subgroup of @xmath5 is called _ non - elementary _ if it contains two pseudo - anosov elements with disjoint fixed point sets in @xmath82 . from now on , we consider the random walk on @xmath5 which is determined by a probability measure @xmath6 which satisfies the following condition . [ cond ]
the probability measure @xmath109 $ ] satisfies that * @xmath6 has finite first moment with respect to the teichmller metric on @xmath18 i.e. for any @xmath25 , @xmath110 , and * the support of @xmath6 generates a non - elementary subgroup of @xmath5 .
let @xmath111 and @xmath112 be open coverings of @xmath0 . since @xmath0 is compact , each open covering has a finite subcover .
let @xmath113 denote the number of sets in a subcover of @xmath114 with minimal cardinality .
@xmath115 is said to be a _ refinement _ of a cover @xmath114 , denoted @xmath116 , if for any @xmath117 , there is @xmath118 such that @xmath119 .
it can readily be seen that if @xmath116 then @xmath120 .
we denote by @xmath121 the open cover @xmath122 . for an open covering @xmath114 of @xmath0 and a metric @xmath123 on s , the _ lebesgue number _
@xmath124 with respect to @xmath123 is defined to be @xmath125 where @xmath126 is the open ball centered at @xmath127 of radius @xmath128 with respect to @xmath123 .
let @xmath129 be less than the lebesgue number of @xmath114 .
then the covering consisting of all open balls of radius @xmath128 refines @xmath114 .
let @xmath130 .
we first choose an arbitrary representative @xmath131 of @xmath28 for each @xmath34 .
let @xmath132 .
for an open cover @xmath114 , let @xmath133 .
we define @xmath134 note that if @xmath116 , then @xmath135 .
the _ topological entropy _ of @xmath136 is @xmath137 where the supremum is taken over all open coverings of @xmath0 .
finally we define @xmath138 where the infimum is taken over all representatives of @xmath15 . unlike the definition of topological entropy of surface automorphisms , we do not take inverses .
this is natural because when we consider random walks , we multiply new elements from the right .
we define the drift of random walks , which we may regard as a `` translation distance '' of the random walk .
let @xmath139 be a metric space on which @xmath5 acts isometrically .
suppose the probability measure @xmath6 has finite first moment with respect to @xmath140 , i.e. @xmath141 where @xmath142 is arbitrary . by kingman s subadditive ergodic theorem , the limit @xmath143 exists for @xmath7-a.e .
@xmath15 and this limit is independent of @xmath127 and @xmath15 .
this limit is called the _ drift _ of @xmath19 with respect to @xmath140 .
let @xmath144 and @xmath145 denote the distance on @xmath18 by thurston s lipschitz metric and the teichmller metric respectively .
we here recall the work of choi - rafi .
[ thm.cr ] there is a constant @xmath146 depending on the surface @xmath0 and on @xmath147 such that for any @xmath148 in the @xmath147-thick part of @xmath18 , @xmath149 and @xmath150 differ from one another by at most @xmath146 . by theorem [ thm.cr ] , if the probability measure @xmath6 has finite first moment with respect to the teichmller metric , then it also has finite first moment with respect to thurston s lipschitz metric .
let @xmath151 ( resp .
@xmath152 ) denote the drift of @xmath15 with respect to @xmath144 ( resp .
@xmath145 ) .
since the drifts are also independent of the choice of base points , by taking a point in the thick part of @xmath18 , we have @xmath153 by theorem [ thm.cr ] .
we let @xmath154 . in @xcite ,
karlsson proved the following .
[ thm.kar ] there exists @xmath155 such that for @xmath7-a.e .
@xmath156 , for any isotopy class @xmath13 of essential simple closed curves and riemannian metric @xmath157 of @xmath0 , @xmath158 where @xmath159 denotes the infimum of the length of curves in @xmath13 with respect to @xmath157 .
moreover @xmath160 coincides with @xmath161 .
note that for theorem [ thm.kar ] , we do not need to take a representative of @xmath15 .
following @xcite , we call @xmath155 in theorem [ thm.kar ] the _ lyapunov exponent _ of the random walk . now we establish the following inequality .
[ lem.lemma1 ] let @xmath155 be the lyapunov exponent of the random walk determined by @xmath6 .
for @xmath7-a.e .
@xmath15 , we have @xmath162 we first fix a hyperbolic metric @xmath157 on @xmath0 , a universal covering @xmath163 and a representative @xmath164 of @xmath15 .
we also fix @xmath165 and @xmath166 in order to choose lifts @xmath167 of @xmath168 uniquely for all @xmath34 . in @xcite ,
a pseudo - anosov diffeomorphism @xmath169 is discussed .
one can prove the following lemma by exchanging @xmath170 with @xmath171 , and following the same argument as in @xcite .
[ lem.10.8 ] for any @xmath172 @xmath173 we may choose @xmath127 and @xmath174 in lemma [ lem.10.8 ] to be the endpoints of a lift of geodesic representative of a simple closed curve @xmath13 on @xmath0 .
then since @xmath175 , we have @xmath176 for any representative @xmath136 of @xmath15 . in order to prove @xmath177 ,
we need a notion of random subshift of finite type .
we define a random subshift of finite type which we use to prove theorem [ thm.main ] .
our goal is to associate a random subshift of finite type to a sample path @xmath19 . since we have to overcome certain difficulty which is described briefly in the introduction , we need to slightly modify the definition from the standard one ( see e.g. ( * ? ? ?
* definition 3.9 ) for the standard one ) .
the main difference is that we can only associate a random subshift of finite type to a representative @xmath136 of @xmath178 . for later convenience
, we use the notations with @xmath136 here .
let @xmath179 be a function .
suppose we have a family of @xmath180 matrices @xmath181 each of whose entry is @xmath182 or @xmath183 .
for any @xmath34 , let @xmath184 we define the coordinate so that for each element @xmath185 , we have @xmath186 . a random subshift of finite type is a pair @xmath33 where @xmath187 and @xmath188 is the standard left shift .
we consider the discrete topology on each @xmath189 and the product topology on @xmath190 .
let @xmath191 for @xmath192 .
the _ @xmath193-cylinder set _ in @xmath194 of @xmath195 is @xmath196
let @xmath197 denote the family of @xmath193-cylinder sets in @xmath194 .
note that @xmath198 .
a semi - markov partition with respect to @xmath19 is a sequence of partitions of the surface @xmath0 by _ birectangles _ with certain condition so that it respects the dynamics of @xmath15 ( see [ subsec.markov ] ) .
we first construct a birectangle decomposition , denoted @xmath199 , from two transverse uniquely ergodic foliations @xmath200 , and a marked riemann surface @xmath201 which represents a point @xmath76 on the teichmller geodesic @xmath202 . the riemann surface structure @xmath44 lets us fix measured foliation representatives @xmath203 and @xmath204 of @xmath205 and @xmath206 respectively so that @xmath203 and @xmath204 are the horizontal and vertical foliation of a holomorphic quadratic differential on @xmath44 of norm 1 .
their preimages by @xmath207 on @xmath0 are also denoted by the same notations .
let @xmath208 denote the set of singular points of @xmath209 .
note that with these representations , @xmath210 .
a subset @xmath211 is called an _
@xmath212-rectangle _ , or a _ birectangle _ if @xmath213 is the image of some continuous map @xmath214\times[0,1]\rightarrow s$ ] such that * @xmath215 is an embedding , and * for all @xmath216 $ ] , @xmath217\times\{t\})$](resp .
@xmath218)$ ] ) is a finite union of leaves and singularities of @xmath219 ( resp .
@xmath220 ) , and in fact in one leaf if @xmath221 .
we let @xmath222 , @xmath223\times \{0,1\})$ ] , @xmath224)$ ] , and @xmath225 .
a family of birectangles @xmath226 is called a _ birectangle partition _ if 1 .
@xmath227 , and 2 .
@xmath228 for @xmath229 . for a singular measured foliation ,
we call a leaf which departs from a singularity a
_ singular leaf_. any small neighborhood of a singular point is decomposed into several components by singular leaves .
we call each component a _ sector_. a _ saddle connection _ is a singular leaf which connects two singular points
. we will now construct a birectangle partition of @xmath0 .
we imitate the construction in ( * ? ? ?
* expos 9 ) . for each sector of @xmath220 of a singular point
, we take a subarc of the singular leaf of @xmath219 in the sector , which starts from the singular point and have @xmath230 measure 1 .
if @xmath219 has a saddle connection and we can not take a singular leaf of @xmath230 measure 1 , we instead take the whole saddle connection .
let @xmath231 denote the family of such subarcs and saddle connections .
then for each singular leaf of @xmath220 , we take the shortest subarc that starts from a singular point and intersects every element of @xmath77 which is not a saddle connection at least once . similarly to before , we take whole saddle connections if there are no such subarcs .
let @xmath232 denote the family of such subarcs and saddle connections .
then , for each @xmath233 , we truncate the component of @xmath234 which contains @xmath235 from @xmath236 , and denote by @xmath13 the resulting arc .
note that saddle connections remain unchanged .
let @xmath237 .
then we extend each element of @xmath238 until it meets @xmath64 exactly once more .
let @xmath239 denote the family of resulting subarcs .
then we let @xmath240 @xmath199 is a birectangle partition .
it suffices to prove that each element of @xmath241 is a birectangle .
if @xmath242 contains @xmath64 , then by construction @xmath213 does not contain singular points in the interior . by the singular euclidean structure determined by @xmath243
, we see that two components of @xmath244 are parallel and in particular @xmath213 is a birectangle .
if there were @xmath213 with @xmath245 , then @xmath242 must have contained a loop consisting of leaves of @xmath220 .
however , since @xmath220 is uniquely ergodic , there are no such loops .
let @xmath19 and @xmath164 be a representative of @xmath15 .
our goal in this subsection is to construct a semi - markov partition from a birectangle partition obtained in the previous subsection , so that it respects the dynamics of @xmath136 .
[ defi.semi-markov ] a sequence of birectangle partitions @xmath246 is a _ semi - markov partition _ with respect to @xmath136 if for every @xmath34 , 1 .
@xmath247 , @xmath248 , and 2 . for each @xmath249 and @xmath250 ,
if @xmath251 and @xmath252 intersects , then the intersection is a single birectangle .
we call it a _ semi_-markov partition because to have @xmath253 , we further need estimates for the size of birectangles .
we here carefully construct a semi - markov partition so that it further satisfies certain estimates which we give in [ sec.main ] .
recall that a markov partition for a pseudo - anosov diffeomorphism @xmath2 is constructed by using stable and unstable foliations @xmath254 and @xmath255 of @xmath2 . in terms of the thurston compactification @xmath256 , these foliations are characterized as limits @xmath257 where @xmath25 is an arbitrary point .
kaimanovich - masur proved that for the case of random walks , we have similar limits .
[ thm.km ] let @xmath6 be a probability measure which satisfies condition [ cond ] .
then 1 .
there exists a unique @xmath6-stationary probability measure @xmath258 on @xmath82 which is purely non - atomic and concentrated on @xmath259 .
2 . for @xmath7-a.e . @xmath260 and
any @xmath25 , the sequence @xmath261 converges in @xmath82 to a limit @xmath262 and the distribution of the limits is given by the measure @xmath258
. we may apply theorem [ thm.km ] both to @xmath6 and @xmath103 .
we denote by @xmath263 the @xmath103-stationary measure on @xmath82 . for @xmath7-a.e @xmath19 ,
let @xmath264 let @xmath265 denote the teichmller geodesic @xmath266 .
note that by the definition of the bernoulli shift @xmath30 , we have @xmath267 and @xmath268 , and hence @xmath269 .
we first fix @xmath270 on @xmath265 . by (
* lemma 1.4.3 ) , the function @xmath271 , @xmath272 is continuous where it is defined .
we fix open neighborhoods @xmath273 of @xmath274 and @xmath275 of @xmath276 with the following condition .
[ condi.u ] the neighborhoods @xmath277 satisfy * @xmath273 and @xmath275 have positive @xmath258 and @xmath263 measure respectively , and * for any @xmath278 and @xmath279 , there is the teichmller geodesic @xmath280 $ ] .
* @xmath281 is bounded from above by some constant @xmath282 .
the construction of semi - markov partition in this section works for any @xmath277 satisfying condition [ condi.u ] .
we give @xmath277 which satisfy further condition that we need to prove theorem [ thm.main ] in [ sec.refine ] .
finally let @xmath283 be small enough so that the @xmath284-neighborhood of @xmath270 is contained in the @xmath147-thick part of @xmath18 .
we now choose points in @xmath18 to construct a semi - markov partition .
see figure [ fig.position ] for a schematic picture .
first , we choose @xmath285 to be a closest point to @xmath270 on @xmath286 . for @xmath38
positive , we define @xmath287 inductively by x_n : = x_n & if @xmath288 and @xmath289 + _ n^-1_n-1x_n-1 , & otherwise .
we define @xmath290 for negative @xmath38 similarly .
we then define @xmath291 as follows . for positive @xmath38
, we set @xmath292 if @xmath293 for all @xmath294 , and @xmath295 for otherwise . for negative @xmath38
, @xmath296 is defined similarly .
we set @xmath297 .
then for @xmath38 positive , we define @xmath298 inductively x_n : = x_n & if @xmath292 + _ n^-1_n-1x_n-1 , & if @xmath295 .
we define @xmath298 for negative @xmath38 similarly .
these @xmath298 are in the @xmath147-thick part and @xmath299 are located according to the order of @xmath38 on @xmath265 .
even with this modification , the distance between @xmath300 and @xmath299 grows sublinearly .
[ lem.tio ] for above @xmath15 and @xmath301 , @xmath302 since one can prove the statement for negative @xmath38 similarly , we assume that @xmath38 is positive .
then since @xmath258 and @xmath263 are independent , @xmath303 hence by the ergodic theorem @xmath304 has positive density .
we now recall the work of tiozzo .
[ thm.tio ] for @xmath7-a.e .
@xmath19 , let @xmath305 denote the teichmller geodesic @xmath265 with parametrization by arc length and @xmath306
. then we have @xmath307 where @xmath161 is the drift with respect to the teichmller metric .
let @xmath308 since @xmath309 , @xmath310 is an integrable function .
hence kingman s subadditive ergodic theorem implies for @xmath7-a.e .
@xmath15 , @xmath311 then , we first estimate @xmath312 .
let @xmath313 . by above observations
, we may suppose that for large enough @xmath38 , we have @xmath314 where @xmath315 , and @xmath316 . then by definition
, we have @xmath317 hence we have @xmath318 now we estimate @xmath319 . if @xmath320 , then there exists @xmath321 such that @xmath322 .
suppose @xmath321 is chosen to be maximum with this property so that @xmath323 .
let @xmath313 .
we may suppose that @xmath38 is large enough so that @xmath324 for @xmath325 .
then we have two cases ; @xmath326 or @xmath327 .
since @xmath328 , in both cases we have , @xmath329 hence we have @xmath330 by theorem [ thm.tio ] and the triangle inequality , we have the conclusion .
let @xmath331 be a representative of @xmath270 . since each @xmath299 is on @xmath265 , there is the teichmller map @xmath332 that stretches @xmath274 and contracts @xmath276 such that @xmath333 represents @xmath299 .
then let @xmath334 , @xmath335 and @xmath336 .
we denote the corresponding measured foliation representatives of @xmath274 and @xmath276 by @xmath337 and @xmath338 respectively .
since @xmath299 are on @xmath265 , by the definition of @xmath296 , @xmath339 satisfies ( m1 ) .
we need to decompose each birectangles in @xmath340 further to have a partition which satisfies ( m2 ) . given two birectangle partitions @xmath341 with @xmath342 and @xmath343 ,
let @xmath344 denote the birectangle partition we get by cutting @xmath0 by @xmath345 .
let @xmath346 be indices which satisfy 1 .
@xmath347 , and 2 .
@xmath348 = 0 for all @xmath349 or @xmath350 , we define @xmath351 .
we note that @xmath352 is equal to @xmath353 for @xmath354 with @xmath295 , let @xmath321 be the largest integer which is less than @xmath38 and @xmath355 .
we define @xmath356 . for negative @xmath38
, @xmath357 is defined similarly . by the construction ,
@xmath358 still satisfies ( m1 ) .
[ lem.markov ] @xmath358 is a semi - markov partition with respect to @xmath164 .
if @xmath295 , the condition ( m2 ) is apparently satisfied . hence it suffices to prove for @xmath321 and @xmath38 with * @xmath359 and * @xmath360 for all @xmath361 , that for each @xmath362 and @xmath249 , the intersection @xmath363 is either empty or a single birectangle .
since @xmath358 satisfies ( m1 ) , we see that if the intersection @xmath364 , it is a family of birectangles .
note that each birectangle in @xmath365 or @xmath366 is a subset of a component of @xmath367 for some @xmath368 and @xmath369 . from each component @xmath370 of the intersection @xmath371 , a birectangle @xmath372 ( resp .
@xmath373 ) is obtained by decomposing @xmath370 vertically by leaves of @xmath206 ( resp .
horizontally by leaves of @xmath205 ) .
hence each @xmath363 is connected .
thus ( m2 ) follows .
we now associate a random subshift of finite type to the representative @xmath136 of @xmath15 by using the semi - markov partition @xmath358 constructed in
[ subsec.markov ] .
let @xmath374 denote the number of birectangles in @xmath357 .
we label birectangles in @xmath357 by @xmath375 .
we define @xmath376 matrices @xmath377 by setting @xmath378 if @xmath379 and @xmath380 for otherwise .
let @xmath33 be the random subshift of finite type with respect to @xmath381 .
then each element in @xmath194 corresponds to a point in @xmath0 .
[ lem.defi-p ] for any @xmath38 and @xmath382 , @xmath383 determines a single point in @xmath0 .
let us fix @xmath382 . by the properties ( m1 ) and
( m2 ) of semi - markov partitions , we have that for each @xmath321 , @xmath384 is a birectangle with exactly one component .
we consider the singular euclidean metric that determines the point @xmath299 on @xmath265 .
let @xmath305 denote @xmath265 with parametrization by arc length so that @xmath385 .
we will prove that the diameter of @xmath386 converges to @xmath182 as @xmath387 .
by lemma [ lem.tio ] , we see that points @xmath388 for negative @xmath321 are close to @xmath389 .
to construct @xmath390 , we considered arcs on @xmath391 of @xmath392 measure 1 which is @xmath393 measure almost equal to @xmath394 by lemma [ lem.tio ] and theorem [ thm.tio ] .
hence the horizontal diameter of @xmath386 converges to @xmath182 as @xmath395 . on the other hand , for @xmath321 positive the arcs @xmath396 travel on singular leaves of @xmath205 longer as @xmath321 increases .
since each infinite singular leaf is dense , it follows that the vertical diameter converges to @xmath182 as @xmath397 .
thus we have a point on @xmath398 . finally by the marking @xmath399
, we fixed above , we have a point on @xmath0 . by lemma [ lem.defi-p ]
, we define @xmath400 .
[ lem.p - surj ] the map @xmath401 is continuous and surjective .
since the image of a long cylinder set of @xmath194 is contained in a small birectangle , @xmath401 is continuous .
let @xmath402 .
for each @xmath403 , @xmath404 is an open dense set .
then by the baire category theorem , @xmath405 is dense .
each @xmath406 is contained in @xmath407 for some @xmath408 for every @xmath409 .
let @xmath410 .
we have @xmath411 , which implies @xmath412 .
since @xmath413 is dense and @xmath194 is compact , @xmath401 is surjective .
we are now ready to prove theorem [ thm.symbolic ] .
note that @xmath414 changes only the metric and does not change the image .
since @xmath400 is defined by using @xmath399 , we have @xmath415 .
we now consider the topological entropy of the shift map @xmath188 . in order to prove theorem [ thm.main ] , it suffices to prove that growth ratio of the number of elements of cylinder sets .
[ lem.p - entropy ] let @xmath33 be the random subshift of finite type defined above .
then for any @xmath416 , @xmath417 where @xmath161 is the drift of @xmath15 with respect to the teichmller metric . note that by the property ( m1 ) and ( m2 ) of semi - markov partitions , the intersections @xmath418 is also a birectangle partition . for a given birectangle partition @xmath419 ,
let @xmath420 denotes the number of birectangles . by the map @xmath401 , we see that @xmath421 hence we will give a bound of @xmath422 .
let @xmath423 be the shortest horizontal length of birectangles in @xmath424 measured by @xmath425 .
let @xmath426 denote the maximum of @xmath425 measures of the arcs @xmath427 .
each arc in @xmath428 cuts birectangles in @xmath424 at most @xmath429 times .
the number of singular leaves of @xmath430 is bounded from above by some constant @xmath431 which depends only on @xmath0 .
hence @xmath422 is at most @xmath432 . by lemma
[ lem.tio ] and theorem [ thm.tio ] , @xmath433 which implies @xmath434
in [ sec.markov ] , we have constructed a semi - markov partition @xmath358 for any representative of @xmath7-a.e .
@xmath19 . in this section
, we will prove that for @xmath7-a.e .
@xmath19 , we can find a representative @xmath435 of @xmath15 such that @xmath436 . in the case of pseudo - anosov diffeomorphisms ,
facts of type lemma [ lem.p - surj ] and [ lem.p - entropy ] suffice to prove that the topological entropy and the translation distance on the teichmller space agree .
this is because to construct a markov partition for a pseudo - anosov diffeomorphism , we only need to use a single point in @xmath18 . on the other hand , for random walks ,
we need to use different @xmath298 s for each @xmath38 .
one of the main difficulty caused for above reason is that the lebesgue number of a given open covering @xmath114 varies depending on the metric . in [ sec.lebesgue ] , we first give a suitable asymptotic bound for the lebesgue number .
every argument so far works for any @xmath277 satisfying [ condi.u ] . in [ sec.positive-nu]-[sec.refine ] , the neighborhoods @xmath277 of @xmath437 which we need to prove theorem [ thm.main ] are given . to have a bound of the lebesgue number ,
we first observe how singular euclid structures may change in the @xmath147-thick part of @xmath18 .
[ lem.bilipschiz ] there exists @xmath438 such that the following holds .
let @xmath76 be in the @xmath147-thick part of @xmath18 , and @xmath439 .
then the singular euclidean metric associated to @xmath440 and @xmath441 are @xmath442-bi - lipschitz . as pointed out in (
* lemma 9.22 ) , any two singular euclidean metrics are bi - lipschitz with some bi - lipschitz constant . since by theorem [ thm.hm ] , @xmath443 is homeomorphic to @xmath82 , a compact space , we see that for any @xmath25 , there exists @xmath444 such that any two singular euclidean metrics corresponding to elements in @xmath443 are @xmath445-bi - lipschitz .
since @xmath445 varies continuously and the @xmath147-thick part of the moduli space of @xmath0 is compact , we have a desired bound .
recall that the semi - markov partition @xmath358 is defined on @xmath446 with representative @xmath447 .
then there is a quadratic differential @xmath448 that is the initial quadratic differential of the teichmller geodesic connecting @xmath270 and @xmath298 .
let @xmath449 denote the complex structure we get by stretching ( resp .
contracting ) horizontal ( resp .
vertical ) foliation of @xmath450 so that it gives the same point as @xmath298 in @xmath18 .
let @xmath451 be the corresponding teichmller map . since two markings @xmath399 and @xmath452 gives the same point in the teichmller space
, there is a biholomorphic map @xmath453 so that @xmath454 is homotopic to @xmath207 .
hence by homotopy , we may suppose @xmath455 .
from now on , we use these representations and let @xmath164 .
we now fix an open covering @xmath114 of @xmath0 .
let @xmath456 be the quadratic differential on @xmath0 determined by @xmath457 and @xmath286 .
for a quadratic differential @xmath60 , we denote by @xmath458 the lebesgue number of @xmath114 with respect to the singular euclidean metric defined by @xmath60 . by the choice of the representative @xmath459 , @xmath460 is equal to the lebesgue number of @xmath461 with respect to the quadratic differential determined by @xmath265 and @xmath398 that we used to construct @xmath462 .
[ lem.lebesgue ] for @xmath7-a.e .
@xmath15 , the @xmath463 defined above satisfies @xmath464 we first note that if two singular euclidean metrics determined by @xmath60 and @xmath465 are @xmath442-bi - lipschitz , then we have @xmath466 .
since we have chosen @xmath298 so that they are in the @xmath147-thick part , we have @xmath467 and @xmath468 by lemma [ lem.bilipschiz ] . by the definition of @xmath469 ,
the ratio @xmath470 is bounded from above by @xmath471 .
hence @xmath472 therefore , by lemma [ lem.tio ] , we have the conclusion . the goal of this subsection is the following proposition .
the measure @xmath258 is from theorem [ thm.km ] .
[ prop.positive-nu ] for @xmath7-a.e .
@xmath15 , any open neighborhood @xmath413 of @xmath274 has positive @xmath258-measure .
we first recall the curve graphs and shadows .
the _ curve graph _ of @xmath0 , denoted @xmath473 , is the graph whose set of vertices are the set of isotopy classes of essential simple closed curves , and two vertices are connected by an edge of length @xmath183 if corresponding simple closed curves can be represented disjointly . for @xmath474 ,
the _ gromov product _ of @xmath174 and @xmath475 with respect to @xmath127 , denoted @xmath476 is defined by @xmath477 since @xmath473 is gromov hyperbolic by @xcite , it has the gromov boundary @xmath478 .
let @xmath479 .
a sequence of points @xmath480 converges to a point @xmath481 if @xmath482 .
we define a _ shadow set _ by @xmath483 by ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1.2 and 1.4 ) and the fact that @xmath274 is uniquely ergodic , we see that @xmath484 as subsets of @xmath82 for sufficiently large @xmath213 .
since @xmath485 converges to @xmath274 in @xmath486 , we see that for any @xmath431 , there exists @xmath487 such that for any @xmath488 , @xmath489 .
hence by the work of maher ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 2.13 ( 5 ) ) , for any @xmath313 , there is @xmath28 such that @xmath490 where @xmath491 .
note that in @xcite , the measure @xmath6 is assumed to have a finite support , however , the finiteness is not used for the proof of results we need here .
hence @xmath492 where @xmath493 is the @xmath38-fold convolution of @xmath6 .
since @xmath494 , we have @xmath495 .
we finally give neighborhoods @xmath273 and @xmath275 of @xmath274 and @xmath276 respectively .
we would like to find @xmath277 so that the vertical lengths of birectangles in @xmath358 are bounded from above .
recall that given two @xmath496 , we can construct a birectangle decomposition @xmath497 , where @xmath498 is a representative of a closest point projection @xmath499 on @xmath500 of @xmath270 . since the vertical length is independent of representatives of points of the teichmller space
, we denote birectangle partitions by @xmath501 .
we abuse notations similarly for @xmath64 and @xmath502 .
let @xmath503 denote the maximum of the vertical lengths of birectangles in @xmath504 .
since each @xmath357 is obtained from some @xmath501 by decomposing each birectangle in @xmath501 , it suffices to prove the following .
[ lem.u ] there exist @xmath505 and open neighborhoods @xmath273 and @xmath275 of @xmath274 and @xmath276 respectively so that the following holds .
suppose that * @xmath506 are written as @xmath507 respectively for some @xmath508
. then @xmath509 .
suppose the contrary .
then there are @xmath510 with @xmath511 and @xmath512 with @xmath513 such that @xmath514 .
let @xmath515 be the rectangle with vertical length @xmath510 .
note that since we assume that the total area is equal to @xmath183 , the horizontal length of @xmath516 converges to @xmath182 .
hence by taking a subsequence if necessary , the vertical boundary @xmath517 converges in the hausdorff topology to an infinite subarc of a singular leaf of @xmath276 , which intersects @xmath518 only twice .
however any infinite singular leaf of @xmath276 is dense , so such a singular leaf never exists . note
that since @xmath273 and @xmath275 are open , we see that @xmath519 and @xmath520 by proposition [ prop.positive-nu ] . by taking smaller open neighborhoods if necessary
, we may suppose that @xmath277 in lemma [ lem.u ] satisfy condition [ condi.u ] .
from now on , we consider the semi - markov partition @xmath358 constructed with such @xmath277 and corresponding representation @xmath136 of @xmath15 whose construction is given in
[ sec.lebesgue ] .
we now consider images of cylinders in @xmath194 by @xmath401 . for notational simplicity
, we call the image of cylinders by @xmath401 cylinders and omit to write @xmath401 .
let @xmath521 be the number so that the set of cylinders @xmath522 refines @xmath114 .
the existence of @xmath521 follows from lemma [ lem.defi-p ] .
we now prove that @xmath521 grows sublinearly . [ lem.c(n ) ] for the above @xmath521 , we have @xmath523 it suffices to find @xmath521 so that the horizontal and the vertical lengths with respect to @xmath456 of @xmath524-cylinders are less than @xmath525 .
let @xmath505 be the upper bound given by lemma [ lem.u ] .
then the horizontal and vertical length of any @xmath524-cylinder is bounded from above by @xmath526 and @xmath527 respectively . since
the bound for the horizontal length is given similarly , we only discuss the vertical lengths .
let @xmath528 and let @xmath313 be arbitrary . by lemma [ lem.tio ] and theorem [ thm.tio ] , for sufficiently large @xmath38 , we have @xmath529 .
we also have @xmath530 by lemma [ lem.lebesgue ] .
let @xmath531 be the smallest integer with @xmath532 .
then for large enough @xmath38 , @xmath533 refines @xmath114 .
hence for large enough @xmath38 , @xmath534 .
since @xmath313 is arbitrary , we have @xmath535 .
we are now ready to prove the main theorem . since @xmath536 , there exists @xmath537 such that @xmath538 for all @xmath539 .
therefore we have , @xmath540 by lemma [ lem.p - entropy ] , we have @xmath541 also by lemma [ lem.c(n ) ] , @xmath542 therefore , @xmath543 by putting all estimates together , we have @xmath544 hence the representative @xmath136 satisfy that for arbitrary open covering @xmath114 , @xmath545 .
putting together with theorem [ thm.kar ] and lemma [ lem.lemma1 ] , we have @xmath546 .
this work was partially supported by jsps research fellowship for young scientists .
99 r. l. adler , a. g. konheim , m. h. mcandrew . _ topological entropy_. transactions of the american mathematical society 114 ( 2 ) : 309 - 319 .
l. bers , _ an extremal problem for quasiconformal mappings and a theorem by thurston _ , acta . math .
, 141 ( 1978 ) , 73 - 98 . y. choi and k. rafi . _ comparison between teichmller and lipschitz metrics .
_ j. lond .
( 2 ) , 76(3):739 - 756 , 2007 . math.gt/0510136 .
a. fathi , f. laudenbach , v. ponaru et al .
, travaux de thurston sur les surfaces , astrisque 66 - 67 , socit mathmatique de france , 1979 . b. farb and d. margalit , _ a primer on mapping class groups ( pms-49 ) _ , princeton university press , 2011 .
f. gardiner and h. masur , _ extremal length geometry of teichmller space _
, complex variables and elliptic equations 16.2 - 3 ( 1991 ) : 209 - 237 .
gundlach and y. kifer , _ random hyperbolic systems _ ( english summary ) stochastic dynamics ( bremen , 1997 ) , 17 - 145 , springer , new york , 1999
. j. hubbard and h. masur , _ quadratic differentials and foliations _ , acta .
( 1979 ) , 221 - 274 .
v. kaimanovich and h. masur , _ the poisson boundary of the mapping class group _ , invent .
( 1996 ) 221 - 264 .
a. karlsson , _ two extensions of thurston s spectral theorem for surface diffeomorphisms _ , bull .
46 ( 2014 ) , no . 2 , 217 - 226 .
e. klarreich , _ the boundary at infinity of the curve complex and the relative teichmller space _ , unpublished manuscript , ann arbor 1999 .
j. maher , _ exponential decay in the mapping class group _
, j. lond .
( 2 ) 86 ( 2012 ) , no . 2 , 366 - 386 .
h. masur and y. minsky , _ geometry of the complex of curves .
i. hyperbolicity _ , invent .
, 138(1):103 - 149 , 1999
. w. p. thurston , _ on the geometry and dynamics of diffeomorphisms of surfaces _ , bulletin of the american mathematical society 19 , ( 1988 ) 417 - 431 .
g. tiozzo , _ sublinear deviation between geodesics and sample paths _ , duke math
. j. 164 ( 2015 ) , no .
3 , 511 - 539 . | for any pseudo - anosov diffeomorphism on a closed orientable surface @xmath0 of genus greater than one , it is known by the work of bers and thurston that the topological entropy agrees with the translation distance on the teichmller space with respect to the teichmller metric . in this paper
, we consider random walks on the mapping class group of @xmath0 .
the drift of a random walk is defined as the translation distance of the random walk .
we define the topological entropy of a random walk and prove that it almost surely agrees with the drift on the teichmller space with respect to the teichmller metric . |
in the pursuit of physics beyond the standard model ( sm ) it is very common to encounter one or more abelian gauge symmetry than the sm @xmath0 hypercharge .
two familiar examples are the grand unified theories ( guts ) based on @xmath3 that breaks to @xmath4 , where @xmath5 is the sm gauge group and @xmath6 which ultimately breaks to @xmath7 . because of their guts parentage the extra @xmath1 bosons from the breaking of the @xmath0 symmetries have tree level couplings to the sm particles ; in particular the fermions .
this makes them highly visible and their phenomenology has been well studied @xcite .
more recently extra dimensional models with extra @xmath0 gauge symmetries in the brane world scenario are increasingly popular .
a feature of this newer construction is that the extra @xmath0 factors can be hidden from the visible sector .
hidden sectors are motivated also by studies in supersymmetry breaking mechanisms .
independent of the theoretical motivation , extra @xmath1 bosons from hidden sector typically do not have direct couplings to the sm particles .
their phenomenology can be very different from visible extra @xmath1 s .
they are also harder to produce . as the start up of the lhc draws near ,
the search for extra @xmath1 bosons is a high priority item due to their relatively clean signatures from drell - yan processes .
clearly it is important to include hard to find extra @xmath1 bosons in this search .
although these bosons have no direct couplings to sm particles , they can manifest themselves through mixings with the sm @xmath1 boson , and so are not completely invisible . since the mixing is crucial for phenomenology we construct the simplest model of this kind to capture the physics of such an extra @xmath1 boson .
it has the gauge symmetry @xmath8 where the subscript denotes `` shadow '' ; the name will become clear later .
the sm fermions are singlet under @xmath9 .
this @xmath9 is broken by a shadow higgs sector which is just the abelian higgs model with a complex scalar @xmath10 .
the @xmath10 field is a sinlget under @xmath5 but interacts with the sm higgs bosons via renormalizable interactions .
the complete lagrangian is given by & = & _ sm - x^x _ - b^x _ + & + & | ( _ -g_s x _ ) _ s|^2 - v(_s , ) , where @xmath11 is the field strength tensor of the sm hypercharge @xmath12 , @xmath13 is the sm higgs field , and @xmath14 is the gauge coupling of the shadow @xmath9 .
for simplicity we have normalized the shadow charge of @xmath10 to unity .
the kinematic mixing of the two @xmath0 s is parameterized by @xmath15 , which a priori need not be a small number . for a visible extra @xmath1 this mixing term is expected to be only induced at the loop level @xcite , and thus @xmath16 is generally assumed in its phenomenological studies @xcite .
however , this need not be the case here .
indeed , a calculation in string theory of the mixing - generating vacuum polarization diagram shows that in general , one can expect kinetic mixing effects on the order of @xmath17 at the weak scale ( barring accidental cancellations in the tree level spectrum ) @xcite .
given the theoretical significance outlined above , we shall leave @xmath15 as a free parameter to be constrained by experiments in particular the electroweak precision tests ( ewpts ) .
now it is well known that the kinetic terms including the mixing can be recast into canonical form through a @xmath18 transformation .
explicitly , this is given by ( c x + b ) = ( cc c _ & 0 + - s _ & 1 ) ( c x + b ) , where [ eq : kinmix ] s_= , c_= .
after spontaneous symmetry breaking ( ssb ) @xmath19 and @xmath20 will mix resulting in a shift in the sm @xmath1 mass .
the physical bosons are now linear combinations of the two .
the photon will remain massless , and the @xmath21 bosons will be unchanged from the sm .
this is expected since the shadow sector only interacts with @xmath12 through the shadow higgs interactions .
the details of this symmetry breaking is given in sec .
[ sec : sbshw ] .
feynman rules for the model are also given there .
in this paper we focus on the phenomenology of the physical shadow sector neutral boson , @xmath22 .
since we are interested in collider physics we shall assume that vacuum expectation value ( vev ) of @xmath10 is of the order of the weak scale or higher . in sec .
[ sec : phem ] we study the impact @xmath22 has on electroweak precision measurements . from these , as well as anomalous magnetic moment of the muon and recent results from mller scattering , we derive constraints on the parameters of our model , in particular on @xmath2 .
we employ a conservative strategy and demand that the fits to the data are not much worse than that of the sm . with these limits in hand
we explore the prospect of observing the @xmath22 at the lhc and the ilc in sec .
[ sec : lhcilc ] .
finally we give our conclusions in sec .
[ sec : concl ] .
recent work with an extra @xmath1 similar to ours is given in @xcite and the older literature can be found in @xcite .
the most general renormalizable @xmath8 invariant scalar potential is : v ( , _ p ) & = & _ s^2 _ s^*_s + _ s ( _ s^ * _ s)^2 + 2 ( ^ ) ( _ s^*_s ) + & & + ^2^+(^)^2 .
this higgs potential is also used in phantom higgs models @xcite .
after ssb the scalars acquire nonzero vev , =( c 0 + v_0 ) , _ p = , with v_0 ^ 2 = - , v_s^2 = - . to ensure that the potential is bounded from below and the above values correspond to a global minimum we require @xmath23 and @xmath24 .
the @xmath25 symmetry is broken down to @xmath26 .
this pattern of breaking is peculiar in that the mass of the @xmath21 boson remains as in the sm , i.e. @xmath27 . in the neutral sector
we have a massless photon and two massive neutral bosons which are not yet in the mass eigenbasis . the usual sm definition : @xmath28 , electric charge @xmath29 , and @xmath30 remain intact . for the neutral gauge bosons the transformation between the weak and mass basis
is given by the following rotation : ( c b + a_3 + x ) =( ccc c_w & -s_w & 0 + s_w & c_w & 0 + 0&0&1 ) ( ccc 1&0&0 + 0 & c _ & -s _ + 0 & s _ & c _ ) ( c + z + z_s ) , where @xmath31 ( @xmath32 ) denotes @xmath33 ( @xmath34 ) and similarly for the rotation angle @xmath35 .
the first rotation is the standard one that gives rise to the sm @xmath1 and the second one diagonalizes the mixing of the two @xmath1 bosons .
the mixing angle is given by 2= , where @xmath36 .
for small @xmath2 and @xmath37 , @xmath38 .
the masses for the two massive neutral gauge bosons are readily found to be [ zmasses ] m^2_z , z_s= m_w^2 2 c_w^2 \ { ( c_w m_3 m_w)^2 + 1 + s_w^2 s_^2 .
+ . } , for the case where @xmath39 the @xmath1-@xmath22 mixing is proportional to @xmath2 , which is related to the amplitude of the kinetic mixing term @xmath40 .
the most stringent constraints on any extra @xmath1 model come from ewpts , and so we consider next the gauge fermion couplings .
these can be readily read off from the lagrangian . for the photon ( @xmath41 )
, the sm result is retained as it should : a^|ff : i ^e q_f . for @xmath1 , @xmath22 , the coupling are slightly different from the sm , but still flavor universal : [ eq : zff ] z^|ff : i ^ , + [ eq : zprimeff ] z_s^|ff : i ^ , where @xmath42 is the coupling of the sm @xmath1 to fermions .
we see that the neutral current couplings are not only rotated as indicated by the @xmath43 factor , but also contain an extra piece proportional to the fermion hypercharge due to @xmath0-@xmath9 mixing .
hence we need to reexamine the electroweak precision data using the full couplings as well as taking into account the effects due to virtual @xmath22 exchanges . for the pure gauge sector , it s straightforward to work out the feynman rules .
for example , the feynman rules for 4 gauge boson @xmath44 vertex read : -i g_2 ^ 2 c_4^v_1,v_2 , where the factor @xmath45 are listed below : [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] to give a measure of how well our model fits the data from ewpts compare to that using purely the sm , we define a number , @xmath46 , that measures the deviation between theory and experiment , [ chi2 ] _ 2(s _ , m_3 ) _ i ( _ exp^i- _ s^i^i_exp)^2 . for sm only , the deviation is _ 2^sm = _
2(0,m_3 ) = _ 2(s _ , ) = 34.908 . the parameter space allowed for @xmath2 and @xmath47 ( or @xmath48 ) will be determined by doing a simple least square fit .
we are interested in getting a solution which can lower the @xmath46 , or [ delchi2 ] _ 2 _ 2(s_,m_3)-_2^sm0 , indicating a better fit than the sm . however , for @xmath49 gev , our numerical search did not find any parameter space which can improve the global fitting listed in table [ tab : ewpt_tab ] .
this is easy to understand . for @xmath50 , @xmath51 and the @xmath52 corrections in the third column of the table
is not important .
one sees that about half of the ew observables get the wrong sign corrections .
therefore at most we can only make gain and loss balanced .
therefore , we demand that the allowed parameter space does not make the fitting worse and this is shown as the lower band in fig . [
fig : gfit_bm3_fig ] . and
@xmath47 from ewpt .
the upper band is the excluding region by too large a deviation from sm , @xmath53 .
the lower band in the parameter space gives comparable to sm results in the global fit .
and the middle one is the allowed region where @xmath54.,scaledwidth=35.0% ] the allowed parameter region is approximately given by [ m3limit ] m_3 > 166 |s_||s_| < 0.006 ( m_3 1 ) .
however , if we relax the global fitting a little , @xmath55 , the constraint can be much looser ( see the middle band in fig .
[ fig : gfit_bm3_fig ] ) .
hereafter , the ceiling boundaries of the middle and lower bands will be referred as @xmath56ewpt and @xmath57ewpt respectively .
here we calculate the @xmath22 drell - yan processes at the lhc given the constraints on its couplings obtained above .
one needs to fold in the parton distributions of @xmath58 and @xmath59 inside the proton .
this involves qcd corrections to the parton model , and are extensively studied with relatively good theoretical control @xcite .
it is also very well tested for the @xmath1 production at the tevatron .
assume narrow width approximation , ( q^2-m_z_s^2 ) , the expected number of observed events , say by reconstructing from the @xmath60 final states , is n_z_s=
l _ t(ppz_s x ^+^- x ) + c_z_s c , where c_z_s(z_s^+^-)= br(z_s^+^- ) + , @xmath61 is the luminosity , @xmath62 is the ratio of u(d)-parton distribution inside the proton . for the @xmath63 hadron collider , @xmath64 , @xmath65 , and @xmath66 for a very wide range of @xmath67 @xcite . in order to select a signal
, it is essential to know the branching ratios of @xmath22 .
the calculation for @xmath22 decays into fermion pair is straightforward . for the sm fermions , they are ( again setting @xmath68 ) : ( z_su|u)=1 24g_2 ^ 2c_w^2m_z_s[0.32739 s_^2(1-s_^2 ) + -0.129957 s_c_s_+0.43022 s_^2 ] , + ( z_sd|d)=1 24g_2 ^ 2c_w^2m_z_s [ 0.09629 s_^2(1-s_^2 ) + -0.277396 s_c_s_+0.55451 s_^2 ] , + ( z_se|e)=1 24g_2 ^ 2c_w^2m_z_s [ 0.28888 s_^2(1-s_^2 ) + -0.09293 s_c_s_+0.12571 s_^2 ] , + ( z_s|)= 1 24g_2 ^ 2c_w^2m_z_s [ 0.05777 s_^2(1-s_^2 ) + -0.240364 s_c_s_+ 0.25 s_^2 ] . after crossing the @xmath69 threshold
, @xmath22 can decay into a pair of t - quarks .
we find = [ 1 + 0.41176 + 0.7979 ^2 ] where @xmath70 and the @xmath71 term comes from the expansion of @xmath72 .
the decay into a @xmath73 pair has width ( z_sw^+w^-)=g_2 ^ 2 c_w^2 s_^2 192m_z_s^5 m_w^4 ( 1 - 4y)^3/2 + ( 1 + 20y+12y^2 ) ,
y = m_w^2m_z_s^2 .
if @xmath74 is heavier than @xmath75 , and the kinematics are favorable , there is a new decay channel opening up , ( z_sz h_1 ^ 0 ) & & g_2 ^ 2 c_^2 192c_w^2 ( c_+s_ws_s_)^2(s_-s_w s_c_)^2 + & & m_z_s(1 + 8 z ) , z = m_z^2m_z_s^2 , where we have ignored the mass difference between @xmath76 and @xmath1 to simplify the expression . the branching ratio of shadow z as a function of its mass is displayed in fig .
[ fig : zpbr_fig ]
. decays as functions of @xmath74 .
the curves shown here are generated with @xmath77 gev and @xmath78 , the higgs mixing angle as defined in eq .
( [ eq : higgsmix ] ) , set to one.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] in generating the figure we have treated @xmath74 and @xmath2 as independent parameters and used a very small value of @xmath79 .
this is consistent with the bound of fig .
[ fig : gfit_bm3_fig ] . in the large @xmath74 limit ,
say @xmath80 tev , the @xmath81-terms will dominate and we obtain a very simple expression for the decay width : _ z_s 2.37 g_2 ^ 2 m_z_s s_^2 24c_w^2 = 0.1742 ( m_z_s 1 ) ( s_^2 0.01 ) .
we see that for such a heavy @xmath22 its width is indeed very narrow , and the various branching ratios are approximately given by b_u= b_c = b_t & & 13.81% , + b_d = b_s = b_b & & 4.06% , + b_e = b_=b _ & & 12.19% , + b__e = b__=b _ _ & & 2.44% , + b_w^+w^- & & 1.219% , + b_hz & & 1.219 c_^2% .
for sm fermions , the branching ratio is roughly proportional to @xmath82 .
it s interesting to note that @xmath22 prefers to decay into @xmath83-type quarks and charged leptons than other sm fermions .
this is very different from the sm @xmath1 decay . if the ilc is available , and the @xmath22 is found , this unique prediction may be tested . at the lhc with the center of mass energy @xmath84 tev and using the bench mark luminosity of @xmath85 , we calculated the expected number of events of @xmath22 into different decay modes by simply folding in the branching ratio we obtained earlier and taking into account of the phase space factors .
more importantly , one has to carefully take into account the maximally allowed @xmath2 obtained from the global fit of low energy precision measurements as given previously .
the expected number of events depend on how restricted we are in taking the ewpts .
[ fig : lhclep ] shows the sensitivity to the @xmath86 events at the lhc for integrated luminosity of @xmath87 for a fixed @xmath74 , we have used the largest allowed @xmath2 comes from the global fit studied in previous section .
the left and right panes are for @xmath57ewpt and @xmath57ewpt respectively.,scaledwidth=48.0% ] which can lead to two orders of magnitude difference in the signature .
notice the dipping of the signals for smaller @xmath74 .
this is due to the much smaller values of @xmath2 allowed for these relatively light @xmath22 .
one way of distinguishing between different extra @xmath1 models will be measuring the branching ratios into different fermion species .
the @xmath22 has the feature that it has a relatively large branching ratio into charged leptons and the t - quarks . for sufficiently heavy @xmath22 the two branching ratios are almost equal .
whether this can be used as a diagnostic tool at the lhc depends on the t - jets and c - jets efficiencies .
the success of lep has demonstrated that @xmath88 colliders are powerful machines for studying neutral gauge bosons .
indeed the search of extra @xmath1 bosons has been conducted at lep and the results can be found in reference @xcite . looking forward to the ilc ,
the center of mass energy of the collider is lower than that of the lhc with @xmath89 tev .
we can still expect to see extra @xmath1 s of mass below 1 tev to be produced . on the other hand ,
facilities designed to have higher luminosity and a benchmark integrated luminosity of @xmath90 can be expected .
furthermore , the underlying processes involve much less qcd uncertainties than in hadronic machines , making it a cleaner environment for detecting the extra @xmath1 bosons .
thus , we can anticipate the branching ratios to be accurately measured .
moreover , the @xmath22 will be too narrow for the total width to be measured .
however , spikes will be seen at the mass where lhc `` discovered '' the new state . in fig .
[ fig : ilccs ] we display the result of such a hypothetical occurrence of a @xmath91 of mass @xmath92 gev and @xmath93 corresponding to the maximal allowed value from the @xmath56ewpt fit .
the familiar sm @xmath1 boson resonance peaks sit on the left hand side .
a new spike appears at @xmath74 .
we magnify the event shape around @xmath94 tev and we see the characteristic dip at the left base of the peak corresponding to an extra @xmath1 .
this dip is due to the negative contribution from @xmath95 and @xmath1-@xmath22 interference .
although the resonance factor @xmath96 dominates over @xmath97 , @xmath98 around @xmath74 , the @xmath96 gets an extra @xmath81 suppression in couplings compared to @xmath97 and @xmath98 which makes the dip visible . for @xmath57ewpt fit ,
not shown , the spike is not as pronounced and the width is thinner , thus its studies at the ilc will be more challenging . with a @xmath99 gev @xmath22 and @xmath93 .
( in the main frame , the spike tips have been chopped to avoid overlapping among curves.),scaledwidth=35.0% ] similarly , the ratio @xmath100 where @xmath101 sums over all quarks except the top , has a pronounced spike for @xmath56ewpt fit .
this is shown in fig .
[ fig : ilcratio ] .
the inlay magnifies the region around @xmath22 and illustrates the expected interference pattern of two spin-1 particles is clearly discernible .
the unique event shape is characteristic of this model which may be used to discriminate it from other extra @xmath1 models .
over @xmath102 with a @xmath99 gev @xmath22 and @xmath93.,scaledwidth=35.0% ] finally , the forward - backward asymmetry of muon v.s .
@xmath103 is shown in fig .
[ fig : ilcafb ] . with a @xmath99 gev @xmath22 and @xmath93.,scaledwidth=40.0% ]
we have studied in detail a simple model with an extra neutral @xmath0 boson , dubbed shadow @xmath1 .
the shadow @xmath1 mixes with the sm @xmath12 gauge boson kinetically which is parameterized by @xmath2 .
the higgs sector also contains a scalar field that interacts with the sm higgs field .
there is no direct coupling between the shadow @xmath1 and the sm fermions .
this simple model can easily be embedded in more elaborate model . since
our motivation is purely phenomenological we leave this aspect to a future study .
instead we embark on a detail analysis of the ewpt constraints and other low energy precision measurements on @xmath74 and @xmath2 .
it is well known that @xmath2 can vary greatly from model to model .
we found that the data constrain it to be very small for a wide range of extra @xmath1 boson masses ; see eq .
( [ m3limit ] ) .
we conclude that the data favors those models in which @xmath2 is radiatively generated .
not surprisingly the production of @xmath22 at the lhc and the ilc depends crucially on @xmath2 . in order to ascertain whether the signals are observable we define a figure of merit measure given by @xmath104 ( see eq .
( [ delchi2 ] ) ) which we found to be positive .
we conclude that the shadow @xmath1 does not give a better global fit to the ewpts .
however , we use @xmath105 to quantify the data tolerance to @xmath22 .
we found that @xmath106 will lead to an observable production of @xmath22 via the drell - yan process at the lhc .
to distinguish the shadow @xmath1 from other extra @xmath1 models ( see @xcite ) one has to do as many branching ratio measurements as possible .
the shadow @xmath1 has almost equal branching ratios into u - type quarks and charged leptons .
it also has a decay channel into the sm like @xmath1 and higgs boson although it is only 1.3% .
similarly for the decay into @xmath73 pairs . for this we find that the ilc will be invaluable for pinning down the nature of the extra @xmath1 boson .
after the completion of this paper our attention was drawn to an earlier work that had looked at similar @xmath107 models @xcite , and also the stueckelberg @xmath107 model which has almost identical collider signatures @xcite and a similar electroweak fit @xcite . we have checked that our results agree where they overlap .
a variant of the model has also been used in a recent leptogenesis study @xcite .
99 see , e.g. r. w. robinett and j. l. rosner , phys .
d * 25 * , 3036 ( 1982 ) , d * 27 * , 679 ( 1983 ) * ( e ) * ; p. langacker , r. w. robinett and j. l. rosner , phys .
d * 30 * , 1470 ( 1984 ) ; f. zwirner , int .
j. mod .
phys . a * 3 * , 49 ( 1988 ) .
p. a. vetter , d. m. meekhof , p. k. majumder , s. k. lamoreaux and e. n. fortson , phys .
lett . * 74 * , 2658 ( 1995 ) ; s. c. bennett and c. e. wieman , phys .
lett . * 82 * , 2484 ( 1999 ) , hep - ex/9903022 . | we consider the phenomenological consequences of a hidden higgs sector extending the standard model ( sm ) , in which the `` shadow higgs '' are uncharged under the sm gauge groups .
we consider a simple @xmath0 model with one higgs singlet .
one mechanism which sheds light on the shadow sector is the mixing between the neutral gauge boson of the sm and the additional @xmath0 gauge group .
the mixing happens through the usual mass - mixing and also kinetic - mixing , and is the only way the `` shadow @xmath1 '' couples to the sm .
we study in detail modifications to the electroweak precision tests ( ewpts ) that the presence of such a shadow sector would bring , which in turn provide constraints on the kinetic - mixing parameter , @xmath2 , left free in our model .
the shadow @xmath1 production rate at the lhc and ilc depends on @xmath2 .
we find that observable event rate at both facilities is possible for a reasonable range of @xmath2 allowed by ewpts . |
when boarding passengers , airline personnel usually call a limited number of rows at a time `` now seating rows 20 to 30 ! '' to ensure an efficient and orderly filling of the aircraft .
nevertheless , there are always some hurried individuals who unduly join the forming line before their row is called , only to be rebuked by the flight attendant . in most instances the line
is barely disrupted , while in some cases , such as delayed flights , the `` avalanching '' of disobedient passengers creates a long , disorderly line , absorbing nearly everyone .
why is this ?
let us consider the mechanism by which the line forms in greater detail .
first , the forty or so passengers whose rows have been called move toward the gate , initiating a line . next
, a few `` impatients '' ( or `` disobedients '' ) add to the ranks , and perhaps also some absent - minded physicists who stand up as soon as they hear an announcement and innocently approach the gate . seeing this
, some of the people still sitting and waiting calmly , might lose their patience and decide to join the growing line .
this `` domino effect '' may die out very soon , with just a few outsiders hiding in the queue , or it may continue , resulting in a catastrophic boarding process .
the line formation at a boarding gate incorporates all the elements of a _ breakdown phenomenon _
@xcite : it involves a large number of elements ( individuals ) , each in one of several possible states ( sitting or in line ) , which interact ( the longer the line , the stronger the temptation ) , and are driven as a whole ( calls of the flight attendant ) . furthermore
, different people have different `` obedience thresholds '' that depend on their personality , mood , schedule , etc . for a given length of the line ,
a fraction of these thresholds are crossed and the resulting disobedients stand up and move toward the gate .
equivalently , a sitting individual decides to stand up and join the queue with some probability ( dependent on the line s length ) , thereby introducing an element of stochasticity , or _
disorder_. similar features are present in a great variety of processes , occurring , for example , in materials under tension @xcite , conductors with an imposed current @xcite , magnets driven by an applied field@xcite , and social phenomena such as the `` boarding - gate problem . ''
the rupture of the material , destruction of the conductor , macroscopic flipping of the magnetization , or the failure of the social process , respectively , can be viewed as a breakdown of the system .
the present paper aims to draw a simple quantitative picture of breakdown phenomena in disordered systems , unifying the various realizations into a single formalism while still allowing for the details that distinguish each case .
the most drastic simplification underlying our approach is its `` mean - field '' nature , which relies on average quantities by ignoring fluctuations and , consequently , any idea of locality or modulated spatial correlation .
although such a crude description can depart significantly from three - dimensional reality , it is often accurate in higher dimensions and establishes a coarse framework which may then be refined to include fluctuations ( perturbatively )
. nevertheless , some systems , such as magnets with long - range interactions or the boarding - gate line , are properly described by a mean - field theory ; in the , for example , any notion of locality is absent from the interactions , as any passenger can see the line as well as any other . in addition to differences intrinsic to various examples , our approach should allow for the introduction of more than one type of disorder , as even a given system s behavior might very well depend on the character of the stochasticity present .
better , we would like to divide all the possible disorder distributions into classes , each associated with a distinct qualitative behavior . to achieve this
, we use a graphical scheme@xcite where we can _ draw _ different disorder distributions , enabling us to handle the latter in a very general fashion , without reference to a particular analytical or numerical form , and to distinguish the features relevant to the breakdown phenomenon@xcite .
these features define the various `` universality classes , '' identified by one of their ( drawn ) members or by a generic statement ( for example , `` the class of all _ continuous _ distributions '' ) .
a graphical method also avoids the possible misconceptions of a more specific treatment@xcite . indeed ,
if the qualitative behavior of a physical system changes upon making a particular , for example , gaussian , distribution wider , what is the associated key feature ? is it the variance of the gaussian or its maximum value ? finally , a graphical scheme allows us to `` follow '' the state of the system as it is driven , thus capturing the whole breakdown phenomenon in a single picture .
we develop the method in the context of fractures ( sec .
ii ) , for which it was originally devised@xcite , before applying it to two other realizations interesting in their own right . in sec .
iii , some quantitative results are obtained for the . section iv focuses on driven magnets , a workhorse of non - equilibrium statistical mechanics as well as a central model for hysteresis . in sec .
v , we introduce the notion of effective ( or phenomenological ) theory , a broader framework than the models examined .
we return to the discussion of driven magnets in this more general context by constructing a simple effective theory suited to the problem , and mention some natural extensions to richer , non - mean - field approaches . finally , we conclude ( sec .
vi ) with a summarizing picture and a brief allusion to dynamics .
the democratic fiber bundle model was introduced by peirce@xcite in 1926 , and formalized and studied in greater detail by daniels@xcite in 1945 .
it consists of @xmath0 ( @xmath1 ) fibers pulled by a force @xmath2 which they share uniformly ( democratically ) . as the force is increased , a fiber breaks if the stress it undergoes exceeds a threshold ( or strength ) , drawn from a distribution @xmath3 .
after each set of failures , the total force is redistributed over the remaining fibers . as members of the _ british cotton industry research association _ and the _ wool industries research association _ , respectively , peirce and daniels sought a more fundamental understanding of the ` hank ' and ` lea ' tests for wool and cotton yarns , in which a hank ( or bundle ) is stretched between two hooks until it ruptures .
a more life - threatening illustration of the model is offered by the failure of an elevator rope ( fig . 1 ) .
[ h ] = 6truecm the has further been applied to the study of cracks and fractures@xcite and earthquakes@xcite , as a simplified model that retains some of the essential features of the original problem . in a failing medium ,
stress is continually redistributed due to the nucleation , growth , and coalescence of cracks .
realistic descriptions of fractures and earthquakes may lie anywhere between this democratic or infinite - range limit embodied by the , also sometimes referred to as the `` global - load - sharing '' or `` equal - load - sharing '' model , and the local or short - range limit , the `` local - load - sharing '' model@xcite , in which the stress released by a broken bond is passed on to its immediate ( intact ) neighbors .
far from being one - dimensional or democratic , real - world systems may be ( effectively ) two- or three - dimensional , with connectivity properties that lead to a more complicated and richer picture . alluding to the applicability of the model to the testing of a cloth sample rather than a hank , daniels himself recognized@xcite that `` in closely woven fabrics the cross - threads afford a measure of support which introduces complications . '' beyond the obvious question of the bundle s strength ( maximum sustainable stress without full rupture ) addressed by peirce@xcite and daniels@xcite ,
we would like to uncover , in the large @xmath0 limit , its behavior characterized by the number @xmath4 of intact fibers as the force @xmath2 increases from @xmath5 to @xmath6 .
in particular , we investigate the critical properties of the fiber bundle upon approaching a macroscopic failure , and the generic classes in which they fall . upon incrementing the force from @xmath7 to @xmath2 , a few fibers whose thresholds
have been overshot , break . as a result ,
the stress increases on the remaining intact fibers , leading to a secondary set of failures .
this triggers a tertiary set of failures , and so on , until the bundle stabilizes at a non - vanishing @xmath4 or snaps off as a whole ( @xmath8 ) .
consider the @xmath9th rupture which leaves @xmath10 unbroken fibers , each now under a stress @xmath11 .
the thresholds of a fraction of intact fibers have been exceeded , namely @xmath12 , and the next set of failures brings their number down to @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the cumulative distribution defined by @xmath15 clearly , the function @xmath4 , defined as the number of fibers remaining unbroken under a total force @xmath2 , is none other than @xmath16 calculated at @xmath2 ( the limiting value of @xmath10 as @xmath17 ) .
problems stated in terms of a recursion relation often have an elegant graphical solution which displays in a single picture the presence or absence of convergence . here ,
a graphical scheme for the iteration is best constructed with the quantities @xmath18 , @xmath19 , and @xmath20 in terms of which eq .
( [ iterationn ] ) becomes @xmath21 the function @xmath22 increases monotonically from @xmath5 at @xmath23 to 1 at @xmath24 and a graphical iteration of eq .
( [ iterationx ] ) shows that @xmath25 is given by the right - most intersection of the curve @xmath26 with the straight line @xmath27 .
as the force is increased , the straight line becomes steeper and the abscissa @xmath28 of the intersection point moves to the left .
figure 2 illustrates the graphical scheme for three successive increments of the force .
first , @xmath29 is switched from 0 to @xmath30 ; for @xmath31 , the straight line is flat and intersects @xmath22 at @xmath24 ( as expected from @xmath32 ) and @xmath33 .
after the sudden switch , fibers with a threshold smaller than @xmath30 immediately break , causing more ruptures according to eq .
( [ iterationx ] ) .
the corresponding iterations are represented by dotted arrows , and terminate at the intersection point with abscissa @xmath34 .
next , @xmath29 is switched from @xmath30 to @xmath35 , and similarly , @xmath36 converges to @xmath37 .
finally , @xmath29 is switched to @xmath38 , and the iterations lead all the way to @xmath23 , which corresponds to a fully ruptured bundle .
if the force , rather than suddenly switching from @xmath30 to @xmath35 , goes through several intermediary steps , @xmath39 successively converges to the abscissa of the corresponding intersection points , but again ends up at @xmath40 when @xmath41 .
thus @xmath4 is a well defined function of @xmath2 , independent of the past history of the force as long as it is increased monotonically .
= 8truecm in what follows , we focus on a continuous steady increase of @xmath2 , which can be thought of as the limit of many small successive increments .
we assume that the iterations occur fast enough , or equivalently , that @xmath2 varies slowly enough for the convergence to be considered immediate . by analogy to thermodynamical processes
, we may say that the force is increased _ quasi - statically_. we are now in a position to investigate the critical behavior of the with various threshold distributions @xmath3 .
the graphical method provides generic conclusions , based on a ( drawn ) arbitrary curve @xmath42 .
thus the results are independent of a specific analytical or numerical form for @xmath3 , but follow from the qualitative features of the curve .
the latter identify a class of distributions , associated with a given behavior of the bundle . for continuous distributions , there are _ three generic classes_@xcite , as illustrated in fig . 3 .
these classes are distinguished by the character of @xmath43 at large argument , which dictates the bundle s behavior under large forces , through the slope @xmath44
= 8.1truecm = 8.7truecm _ class _ ( _ i _ ) . for @xmath45 ( @xmath46 ) with @xmath47 ( normalization requires @xmath48 ) ,
that is , distributions with an appreciable fraction of robust fibers , the bundle never fails completely . under any force @xmath2
, some intact fibers are left .
_ class _ ( _ ii _ ) . in the limiting case where @xmath49 as @xmath50 , the number of intact fibers goes continuously to zero at @xmath51 .
furthermore , the response function of the bundle or _ breaking rate _ @xmath52 diverges as @xmath53 , where @xmath54 is the subleading power entering the distribution function , @xmath55 .
following the nomenclature adopted in the field of critical phenomena , we may refer to the macroscopic rupture of the bundle associated with a diverging response function as a second - order transition with exponent @xmath56 .
an example of a `` fat - tail distribution '' is @xmath57 for any @xmath58 , with @xmath59 in class ( _ i _ ) and @xmath60 ( and exponent @xmath61 ) in class ( _ ii _ ) .
_ class _ ( _ iii _ ) . for any narrower distribution ,
such that @xmath62 for @xmath50 , there is a macroscopic failure of the bundle at a finite critical force @xmath63 at which the number of intact fibers falls discontinuously from @xmath64 to 0 .
the breaking rate diverges in general as @xmath65 a `` trivial '' exponent of @xmath66 is to be expected within a mean - field approach which ignores the effect of spatial fluctuations ( see sec .
v ) . of course , it is possible to choose a particular distribution with a `` bump '' such that @xmath67 , with @xmath68 an integer , instead of @xmath69 , but it reflects a fine - tuned choice rather than the generic one .
all continuous distributions with finite mean , subsumed in class ( _ iii _ ) , lead to a macroscopic failure of the bundle at a finite critical force , signaled by a diverging breaking rate .
although this divergence in the response is still reminiscent of a second - order transition , the situation differs from the usual case where the order parameter ( here @xmath4 ) is continuous at the singularity . to avoid any confusion
, we refer to ruptures of type ( _ iii _ ) as _ soft _ failures .
two examples of distributions which belong to class ( _ iii _ ) are @xmath70 and @xmath71 .
other examples include finite - support distributions , which are non - vanishing only in an interval @xmath72 $ ] , provided @xmath3 is continuous on @xmath73 and @xmath74 .
3(b ) illustrates the generic histories @xmath4 for each of the three classes .
clearly , by having more `` bumps '' ( @xmath75 on fig .
3(a ) has one ) , that is , variations in the convexity of @xmath22 , the bundle may undergo additional macroscopic ( finite fraction of @xmath0 ) failures at smaller forces . none of these , however , may lead to a complete rupture , which always corresponds to one of the three classes described above .
= 8truecm = 8.6truecm the examples given for class ( _ iii _ ) are valid for any value of the parameter @xmath76 .
thus , the threshold distribution may be as narrow and peaked ( @xmath77 ) as desired and still lead to a soft failure , provided @xmath3 is continuous .
an _ abrupt _ rupture of the bundle _ with no divergence in the breaking rate _ preceding it is possible only if @xmath22 has a non - differentiable point ( fig .
4)@xcite , which in turn requires a discontinuity in @xmath78 .
thus , abrupt failures in this mean - field model , far from being a generic feature associated with narrow disorder distributions , are an artifact of a singular point in @xmath78 .
the phenomenon is in fact even more particular , because the _ magnitude _ of the discontinuity matters . in the case of a finite - support distribution on @xmath73 with @xmath79 , for example
, no fiber breaks up to a force @xmath80 . at @xmath81 ,
an abrupt failure occurs only if @xmath82 , as can be shown by the graphical method , which requires a minimal jump @xmath83 . whether this macroscopic failure yields full rupture of the bundle or not depends on the detailed form of @xmath78 . if it does not , and if @xmath78 is continuous on @xmath73 , the global bundle failure is soft and belongs to one of the three cases examined above ( case ( _ iii _ ) if @xmath84 ) .
the description of a large @xmath0 bundle by a continuous distribution @xmath78 would seem more physical , unless it is made of fibers of a few different types , each with a well defined threshold .
consider for example a `` bimodal '' bundle with @xmath85 ( @xmath86 ) fibers of strength @xmath30 and @xmath87 fibers of strength @xmath88@xcite .
it is easy to see from the graphical method ( fig .
5 ) that if @xmath89 , the entire bundle snaps off abruptly at @xmath90 .
on the other hand , if @xmath91 it undergoes an abrupt failure at @xmath92 leaving the @xmath93 stronger fibers intact , and then ruptures completely ( again abruptly ) when the force reaches @xmath94 .
= 8truecm = 8.9truecm a physical medium which fails as a result of the growth of a single large crack is often referred to as `` ductile , '' in analogy with flexible materials , such as most metals , which rearrange under stress and can thus be pulled into long thin threads . at the other end of the spectrum , fragile or
`` brittle '' media are characterized by a sudden failure due to the coalescence of many microcracks . in the context of our mean - field model
, we may identify abrupt failures from markedly discontinuous distributions ( such as narrow finite - support ones or bimodal ones ) with brittleness , and soft failures from the continuous distributions of classes ( _ ii _ ) and ( _ iii _ ) with ductility .
thus the character of a medium s strength depends on the _ shape _ of the distribution of randomness . the failure of an element , whether a fiber in an elevator rope or a patch of a tectonic plate , is often accompanied by the emission of a sound@xcite . before an abrupt failure , nothing unusual
is heard , whereas an increasingly loud noise is produced by a soft failure .
thus impurities , dirt , and disorder might be salutary in times of calamity !
armed with the method developed in sec ii , we return to the boarding - gate problem of the introduction , and treat it in a quantitative fashion .
the similarity between the breaking of a fiber bundle and the growth of a boarding - gate line becomes more apparent through the following mapping of the degrees of freedom , disorder , driving agent , and coupling : @xmath95 nevertheless , the two problems are different in that the stress applied to any one intact fiber is inversely proportional to their total number , whereas the temptation here grows with the length of the line .
furthermore , for simplicity we focus on a single call of the flight attendant , say the first one . in the language of the , this corresponds to switching the force from zero to some value , and leaving it there .
finally , the `` thermodynamic limit '' we treat ( in implicitly assuming infinitely many passengers ) may be a poor approximation for a situation involving a few dozen or a few hundred people .
the fact that the first group of passengers called , and consequently the ones still waiting , may not be representative of the overall threshold distribution , for example , is one of the possibly important finite - size effects neglected .
let us say that the flight attendant first calls @xmath96 passengers , who readily form a line .
seeing the latter , a few disobedients join in , equal in number to @xmath97 , where @xmath98 is the total number of passengers waiting to board the flight and @xmath14 is the cumulative threshold distribution .
more precisely , @xmath99 is the probability that an individual unduly joins the line , when it reaches a length between @xmath39 and @xmath100 .
the process might stop at this point , leaving the few intruders in line , or might keep on `` avalanching . '' in general , we can write a recursive relation describing the growth of the line , analogous to eq .
( [ iterationn ] ) , as @xmath101 where @xmath102 is the number of people in line after @xmath9 iterations ( @xmath103 ) .
the avalanching terminates at the left - most intersection of the line @xmath104 with the curve @xmath105 and the eventual length of the line , @xmath106 , is read off as the abscissa of the intersection point . in other words , the length of the line is obtained as the smallest solution to @xmath107 leading to the following possible scenarios .
@xmath108 most optimistically , no one s threshold is lower than the length of the initial line , that is , @xmath109 ( fig . 6 ) .
no unexpected passenger shows up in the line , and the boarding runs smoothly .
@xmath108 more generally , for a large airplane with hundreds of passengers , we expect thresholds to be widely distributed .
we consider distributions with @xmath110 for all @xmath111 $ ] and @xmath112 , according to which there are always some disobedients who join the ranks no matter how small the temptation and no one is restrained enough to stay seated when the line includes nearly all the passengers . in this case , the behavior of the line s growth is governed by the character of @xmath78 at large argument ( fig .
7 ) , reminiscent of the solution of the with continuous distributions .
if @xmath113 , the line may anarchically absorb all passengers .
if @xmath114 , on the other hand , it must stabilize at @xmath115 , the precise value of which depends on the detailed form of the function @xmath78 .
= 9.2truecm = 9.2truecm @xmath116 often , there is a small fraction @xmath117 of _ complete _ disobedients , a small fraction @xmath118 of _ complete _ obedients , and the rest of the passengers thresholds scattered in between .
for such a contingency , the distribution reads @xmath119 where @xmath120 is a smooth function which , in a realistic model , is appreciable between two bounds @xmath121 and @xmath122 .
then , the growth of the line saturates at a length @xmath123 , which depends on the relative values of @xmath96 , @xmath124 , and @xmath121 ( fig
if @xmath125 , the eventual line includes few unexpected passengers except the physicists a situation easy to cope with , due to the small number of physicists .
however , if @xmath126 ( and in particular if @xmath127 is small ( @xmath128 very peaked ) ) , the few physicists drag flocks of others along , resulting in a line with all the passengers but the complete obedients and perhaps a few highly obedient individuals .
[ h ] = 11.3truecm there is no doubt that social phenomena involve a great many parameters making them highly complex in comparison to `` simple '' physical systems such as a fiber bundle .
however , in much the same way as the breaking of a wool hank is faithfully described without recourse to the molecular structure of the individual threads , a _ coarse _ picture of some human phenomena may be drawn while ignoring intricate psychological and other processes that each individual goes through . and
it is amusing that such a _ phenomenological _ approach yields a number of quantitative , testable results for the behavior of a human group .
in the most modest speck of dust , an incredible number of electrons are dancing around , creating small currents and with them magnetic moments .
each electron also carries its own spontaneous moment , and it is the complicated addition of all these effects which determines the total magnetization of the dust . in the spirit of foregoing intricate details in favor of a coarser but simpler picture , ising and
lenz proposed a model@xcite in which a material is divided into many elements ( labeled by their position @xmath129 ) , each carrying a ( unit ) magnetic moment , or _
spin _ , which tends to align with the local magnetic field it experiences , like a little compass . in the so - called `` ising model , ''
the spins are constrained to a given direction , may point upward ( @xmath130 ) or downward ( @xmath131 ) .
the average magnetization is defined as @xmath132 where @xmath133 is the total number of spins , and the local field is composed of the applied field and the one created by neighboring spins . on a mean - field level
, one assumes that the system may still be faithfully described if the many degrees of freedom are reduced to a single quantity , here the average magnetization .
this assumption becomes exact if the interaction between spins is infinite in range , that is , all spins interact with all others in the same way , so that they contribute to the local field equally everywhere .
even if the coupling has a limited range , we can imagine that such an approach becomes more and more accurate as the dimensionality is increased , as spins acquire more and more neighbors , thus `` averaging out '' their contributions to the local field . in fact , the mean - field approximation yields the correct critical behavior above a given , _
finite _ dimension ( see sec .
v ) . [ h ]
= 9truecm we confine our study to zero temperature , so that spins are always perfectly aligned with the local field , forbidding any _ thermal _ fluctuation . in real materials , however , the presence of impurities leads to _ random _ fluctuations .
in many cases , the effect of the impurities is to perturb the local magnetic field which acquires a stochastic component in addition to a uniform one ( fig .
more precisely , the mean - field , driven , disordered version of the ising model , first introduced in ref . [ bib : sethna ] , is defined by a local field @xmath134 where @xmath135 is a uniform field ( chosen by the experimentalist ) , @xmath136 is a _ random field _ chosen at each position @xmath137 from some probability distribution @xmath138 , and @xmath139 represents the strength of the spin - spin coupling .
the configuration of the system is then given by the `` alignment rule '' @xmath140 how does the driven disordered ising model evolve when the ( driving ) field @xmath135 goes from @xmath141 to @xmath6 ?
initially ( @xmath142 ) , all the spins point downward ( @xmath143 ) .
as @xmath135 is increased from @xmath141 , the local fields with large positive random fields soon become positive , and the associated spins flip upward .
these flips further increases the local field , which induces new spin flips , and so on .
once @xmath135 is incremented enough , the negative @xmath136 s tend to pin the corresponding spins downward , and the configuration results from the competition between the driving agent @xmath135 , the `` restoring '' force @xmath144 , and the pinning forces @xmath136 a common scenario for forced or driven random media@xcite .
the avalanching present in this simple model is reminiscent of fracture phenomena@xcite , and the driven disordered ising model can be mapped to the as @xmath145 as in the case of the boarding gate problem , the main difference with the arises from the way in which the individual degrees of freedom interact , and the iterative equation for the fraction @xmath146 of downward spins , in the driven disordered ising model , reads @xmath147 where @xmath148 is the cumulative distribution function .
equivalently , in terms of the magnetization @xmath149 , @xmath150 as before , the right - hand - side is a monotonically increasing function of the avalanching variable @xmath151 , and the so - called _ hysteresis _ curve @xmath152 is given by the left - most intersection of @xmath153 with the bisector ( @xmath154 ) .
rather than considering all possible types of disorders , we focus on three , commonly encountered in the literature@xcite .
\(1 ) _ gaussian disorder _ : @xmath155 .
as @xmath135 is increased , the curve @xmath156 is translated to the left and the intersection point consequently moves up ( and to the right ) .
three qualitatively different solutions are obtained , depending on whether the maximum slope @xmath157 is greater , equal , or lesser than 1 ( fig . 10 ) .
= 9.6truecm = 9truecm @xmath108 @xmath158 : for a small disorder , there is a jump in the magnetization at some field @xmath159 ) , signaled , as in the , by a square root divergence of the response function or susceptibility @xmath160 larger values of @xmath161 reduce the magnitude of the discontinuity , which ultimately shrinks to a point at @xmath162 .
@xmath108 @xmath163 : a specific value @xmath164 of the disorder yields a _
critical _ hysteresis curve , which , although continuous , displays a singular point at @xmath165 .
expanding @xmath156 , we easily obtain the nature of the singularity , as @xmath166 in a more general line of reasoning ( see sec .
v ) , we note that the asymmetry of @xmath167 about the origin ( at @xmath168 ) rules out even powers relating @xmath169 to @xmath135 as @xmath170 and in particular a quadratic dependence @xmath171 , leaving a cubic behavior @xmath172 as the best candidate ; inverting and differentiating readily leads to eq .
( [ susceptibility ] ) .
@xmath116 @xmath173 : at large disorders , the magnetization curve is smooth , with a finite susceptibility everywhere .
figure 10(b ) shows generic curves corresponding to the above three cases .
this phase diagram is very similar to that of the ( classes ( _ i_)(_iii _ ) ) , in that a discontinuous , first - order - like region terminates at a critical , or second - order , point with a different ( non - trivial ) exponent .
in fact , it is believed@xcite that , while the global phase diagram is unchanged in a local theory extending beyond a mean - field approach , the precursor divergence of eq .
( [ divergence ] ) is suppressed , resulting in proper first - order behavior .
( if a similar conclusion applies to fracture phenomena , it might help to explain the presumably abrupt failures often observed . ) furthermore , as @xmath174 approaches @xmath164 from below , @xmath175 decreases to zero , progressively hampering the hysteretic ( lagging ) nature of the solution ; for @xmath176 , both the remnant and coercive fields are vanishing .
again , this is an artifact@xcite of the present formulation .
these remarks point at the tip of an iceberg onto which the mean - field approximation often runs .
\(2 ) _ uniform disorder _ : @xmath177 for @xmath178 _ and vanishes elsewhere_. this form may be viewed as a `` digitized , '' roughened , or sharpened version of gaussian disorder .
again , the character of the solution depends on the magnitude of the slope @xmath179 relative to @xmath180 ( fig .
= 9.6truecm = 9.2truecm @xmath108 if @xmath181 ( small disorder ) , the magnetization switches from @xmath182 to @xmath183 at @xmath184 .
@xmath108 if @xmath185 ( large disorder ) , the magnetization is continuous and piecewise linear ; it starts to increase linearly from @xmath182 at @xmath186 , and reaches @xmath183 at @xmath187 .
as in the previous examples , the nature of the solution varies significantly from one type of disorder to the next .
in particular , we note that the discontinuity of the uniform distribution rules out any divergence or critical point , in agreement with our observations for the .
\(3 ) _ bimodal disorder _ : @xmath188/2 $ ] .
the bimodal distribution is often used as an alternative to the gaussian distribution , notably in computer simulations .
it represents an even more `` digitized , '' or sharpened , version of disorder , reminiscent of the with fibers of two different types .
the graphical scheme is illustrated in fig .
12 , along with typical solutions which fall , as above , into one of two classes .
the phase diagram is especially simple to understand for a bimodal disorder , which limits random fluctuations as much as possible and reduces the problem to a two - body one .
half of the spins ( those with @xmath189 ) flip upward when @xmath135 reaches @xmath190 , leading to a vanishing magnetization .
this further triggers the flipping of the remaining spins if their ( updated ) local field @xmath191 is positive , that is , if @xmath192 ( small disorder ) , resulting in a global switch from @xmath193 to @xmath194 at @xmath195 .
if @xmath196 ( large disorder ) , on the other hand , the magnetization remains at zero until the local field changes sign , at @xmath197 , when the remaining downward spins flip to yield @xmath194 .
= 9.7truecm = 9.2truecm in contrast to the gaussian and uniform cases , the large - disorder phase _ exhibits hysteresis _ :
@xmath198 is not symmetric about @xmath168 , there is a remnant magnetization @xmath193 ( if @xmath199 that is , @xmath181 ) and a coercive field which can be defined as @xmath200 .
clearly , a hysteretic behavior originates in the coexistence of more than one possible solution to a dynamical system@xcite . rather than being chosen by an optimum principle , the actual , physical solution follows from the _ history _ , or , in the case of a monotonically increasing @xmath135 , from the _ initial conditions_. thus , _
metastability _ and hysteresis are intimately related .
the random fluctuations tend to pin the system to a metastable state .
the thermal fluctuations , which we have ignored , play an opposite part in sweeping the system in its configuration space , thus favoring ergodicity .
an important question relates to the interplay of these two effects .
it is believed that disorder generally dominates and that thermal fluctuations are irrelevant at criticality , both in equilibrium@xcite and in non - equilibrium@xcite problems .
the path from elementary laws to the multitude of fascinating observed phenomena is definitely not a straight and plain one .
the situation is a bit like that of a shadow show in which shadows of dragons , wolves , and birds , are cast on a white drape by the moving hands of a pantomime .
the goal is to understand the unfolding story . focusing on the artist
s hands is probably not the most fruitful tactic , and surely not the easiest .
the shadows allow a more direct grasp of the story by retaining the important aspects of the hands intricate movements and shapes , while smearing away irrelevant details such as the nails or the hair on the fingers . in theoretical physics , the mime s hands are the fundamental laws , and the shadows are _ effective _ or _ phenomenological _ theories .
hydrodynamics constitutes a prominent example of an effective theory , where the molecular nature of a fluid is disregarded in favor of a description in terms of a homogeneous medium .
the collective motion of hundreds or millions of particles is reduced to that of their center of mass , that is , to a local average , which smears out a large number of details and fine characteristics , leaving a framework with a smaller number of variables than the original one . typically , a fluid is then described by fields of density , velocity vector , and temperature five quantities associated with each point in space and time substitute for the many molecular degrees of freedom around that point .
a delicate question relates to how much of the finer print , or _ fluctuations , _ needs to be included for an accurate description of a given phenomenon at a given length scale .
various effective theories may be constructed to describe a given system , the ones with the fewest allowed fluctuations being termed `` mean - field . '' often , spatial fluctuations are ignored altogether resulting in highly coherent behavior , and the system reduces to a single ( or a few ) degrees of freedom .
the hydrodynamic equations can be derived from symmetry and conservation principles alone .
these principles are satisfied at the molecular level and unspoiled by any averaging procedure .
thus , an effective theory ensues from robust properties that span many length scales , and is free from a specific ( mechanistic ) model .
it has lost the details involved in the latter , but gained the sturdiness of generality : an effective formulation encompasses all possible models lying within the constraints imposed by a set of symmetries .
it is therefore worthwhile to construct a phenomenological theory of breakdown phenomena ; in what follows , we shall concentrate on the driven disordered ising model@xcite .
in addition to its robustness , an effective field theory offers an analytical framework in which the range of the coupling between spins , the dimensionality of the systems , or other aspects may be modified and studied in a unified fashion , and for which a number of powerful tools have been developed@xcite . in the spirit of hydrodynamics
, we consider a spin _ field _ or _
@xmath201 regarded as a local average of magnetic moments at @xmath202 , where @xmath203 is the dimension of the system .
its value lies anywhere within an interval centered at zero , and we further generalize the problem by allowing @xmath204 . inspired by the model@xcite of sec .
iv and its solution as given by @xmath205 , we posit that the spin density at each point is obtained from an algebraic equation @xmath206 where @xmath135 is a uniform applied magnetic field and @xmath207 is a gaussian random field felt by the spins at @xmath208 .
this system of equations may have more than one solution ; if @xmath135 is monotonically increased as before , the spins start off very negative , and the physical solution corresponds to the `` left - most '' one , with smallest ( most negative ) @xmath209 s . if , rather , @xmath135 is monotonically decreased from a high positive value , we expect the same set of solutions with an opposite sign , consistent with the _ reflection symmetry _
@xmath210 a first constraint on the form of @xmath211 . as before ,
the quantities of interest are the overall spatial average @xmath212 of @xmath201 and its response to the applied field .
an effective , coarse - grained theory is clearly best suited to answer questions on the system s global properties , and in particular on its critical behavior which involves a collective response to an infinitesimal change in @xmath135 . from the study of the driven disordered ising model
, we expect the critical point to occur at @xmath213 .
( we note that this is also a special point in terms of the symmetries , due to the _ statistical invariance _ under @xmath214 . ) close to the latter , we may describe @xmath215 by an expansion in its arguments .
in contrast to fluid dynamics or pure critical phenomena , here quenched disorder imposes some spatial fluctuations , which we limit by considering a small random field , leading to @xmath216 along the lines of eq .
( [ general ] ) , where we have written the most general expansion consistent with the governing symmetries , we further expand the interactions . for example , we write @xmath217 if the couplings are invariant under translations and rotations , then @xmath218 , the odd powers in eq .
( [ expansion ] ) vanish and the even powers take a symmetric form , resulting in @xmath219 where @xmath220 and @xmath221 are numerical coefficients obtained from @xmath222 . the derivative terms couple neighboring spins by hampering ( or favoring , depending on the sign of the prefactors ) spatial fluctuations . in their interplay with disorder effects ,
such short - range interactions introduce higher complications . by analogy with the driven disordered ising model , we consider a mean - field approximation by substituting the derivative interactions with a uniform restoring force composed of @xmath223 , @xmath224 , @xmath225 , @xmath226 , etc .
if a similar procedure is applied to the various terms in @xmath211 , we obtain @xmath227 to get a flavor of the construction and treatment of a phenomenological theory , rather than to examine the problem in full rigor , we abandon the `` other terms '' for now we argue below that they do not change the critical properties .
furthermore , for ease of notation , we shall not drag along the many prefactors ; the reader may either imagine them present or assume that they have been set to unity .
thus , our task is now to solve eq .
( [ motion ] ) , which has been reduced to @xmath228 the prefactor of @xmath135 has been set to @xmath182 so that @xmath54 aligns along @xmath135 at large values of the latter .
this _ stability condition _ is imposed in addition to the various symmetries . in solving eq .
( [ simple ] ) , we think of @xmath212 as a given function of @xmath135 . if the resulting @xmath201 does not average to @xmath229 , our choice was not good , and we start over with a better guess for @xmath212 , until eventually the spatial average of @xmath201 is equal to @xmath212 for all @xmath135 . in practice ,
( [ simple ] ) may be solved iteratively by reshuffling the terms , as @xmath230 ^ 3-\ldots \label{iter_sol } \end{aligned}\ ] ] clearly , performing the average over space or over disorder is equivalent , and the self - consistency condition results in @xmath231 where @xmath232 . for large disorders ,
the magnetization @xmath212 is a non - singular function of @xmath135 . at a critical value @xmath233 , however , @xmath234 and the response function diverges as @xmath235 reproducing the critical exponent of the driven disordered ising model .
let us return to the `` other terms '' neglected in eq .
( [ simple ] ) , and argue that they do not modify the exponents . indeed , any one of them either vanishes upon averaging ( @xmath236 for example ) or is subleading in the limit @xmath237 ( for example , @xmath238 yields @xmath239 and @xmath240 upon averaging ) . in a third possibility , the additional terms modify the prefactors in eq .
( [ self - cons ] ) ( for example , @xmath241 yields @xmath242 upon averaging ) , but do not generate new types of terms . the symmetries are constraining enough to impose the cubic root behavior of the magnetization close to criticality . in a mean - field approach , in particular , where the system is reduced to a single degree of freedom , the exponents follow from an algebraic equation such as eq .
( [ self - cons ] ) .
this observation sheds some light on the ( then quite cryptic ) remark in sec .
ii , that an exponent @xmath243 `` is to be expected within a mean - field approach . '' without the reflection symmetry that we have assumed in the derivation of eq .
( [ self - cons ] ) , quadratic terms would appear and clearly lead to an inverse square root divergence in the response function . another way to understand the decoupling that occurs in a mean - field theory and its essentially zero - dimensional nature ( single degree of freedom )
is obtained in a formulation closer to equilibrium statistical mechanics where the central objects are probability weights and partition functions . from rewriting eq .
( [ simple ] ) as @xmath244 and the random field density @xmath245 where @xmath246 is a normalizing factor , the spin field is distributed according to @xmath247 \times \left|
\left| \text{jacobian}\right| \right| .\ ] ] again , we require the self - consistency condition @xmath248 and the problem reduces to a zero dimensional one : finding the average of @xmath54 at a single `` site . ''
the right - hand - side of eq .
( [ self ] ) may be evaluated by expanding the exponential in the super - quadratic terms of its argument and calculating gaussian integrals . in the absence of modulated interactions ,
the jacobian is easily evaluated as @xmath249 . beyond the mean - field picture , however , fluctuations matter regardless of their coupling to @xmath136 , and the need for and use of a jacobian becomes quite cumbersome . for a brief ( and very superficial ) discussion of richer theories , we return to the formulation of eq .
( [ simple ] ) , whose analog for the case of short - range interactions reads @xmath250 how does the coupling between neighboring spins , expressed in the laplacian term , modify the critical behavior ?
this question is best examined through the renormalization - group theory@xcite , which provides a systematic way to keep track of the role of each intervening term .
roughly speaking , it enables us to carry out an iterative solution ( or averaging ) , similar to that of eq .
( [ iter_sol ] ) , in successive steps corresponding to progressively larger scales .
interestingly , it is found that the answer depends only on the dimension @xmath203 of the system . above six dimensions , a system described by eq .
( [ short ] ) behaves just as the mean - field one of eq .
( [ simple])@xcite , as far as critical exponents go . in some sense
, it is bundled tightly enough so that a small push might move a lot .
( many hay stems are often dragged along when one is pulled out of a three - dimensional pile ; this does not happen if the hay stems are laying on the two dimensional surface of a pond . ) in @xmath251 ( called `` upper critical dimension '' ) , the situation is far less trivial , and novel exponents emerge from the interplay of the laplacian and random terms@xcite .
we might also expect intuitively that longer ranged interactions `` more easily '' lead to mean - field behavior and , indeed , they reduce the upper critical dimension .
the case in which @xmath252 explains the trivial , mean - field - like exponents associated with some observed critical phenomena that , _ a priori _ , involve many complicated interactions . in some instances ,
fluctuations bring about further surprises . a mean - field approximation somehow `` homogenizes '' the system , imposing a high degree of symmetry .
fluctuations might then break the latter into lower symmetries : a flat surface is invariant under any translation , whereas a periodically corrugated one is unchanged only under translations by the period s multiples .
new critical points then appear , corresponding to the new symmetries .
this is exactly what happens in a system defined by the vectorial generalization of eq .
( [ simple])@xcite , with the new degrees of freedom @xmath253 . at the mean - field level ,
the critical properties correspond to a full rotational symmetry ( in spin space ) . for short - range interactions ,
new critical points appear , associated with rotational invariance in subspaces of @xmath254@xcite .
it is truly remarkable that we are able to make precise predictions based on such a general approach , without a definite model or `` fundamental '' understanding of the details .
it is equally surprising that a complicated assembly of electrons and nuclei generates pure numbers , the critical exponents , which can be measured with great accuracy .
the models examined in secs ii iv are probably less interesting for their own sake than for their illustrative power . also , they provide motivation and inspiration for more complex , robust formulations closer to physical reality .
this is especially true of simple models involving ubiquitous features such as driving forces , elastic interactions , and disorder .
the breakdown of a disordered conductor under an applied current or voltage drop ( often thought of as a jumping board to fracture problems ) is yet another illustration . in a simple formulation@xcite
, it may in fact be mapped to the driven disordered ising model and the graphical scheme presented here is readily applicable to it .
the ability to solve such basic models serves as a first step toward the study of richer , more realistic physics .
a class of problems akin to breakdown phenomena relates to the depinning and transport of elastic manifolds through disordered media@xcite .
the many variations on this paradigmatic theme include charge density waves@xcite , surface growth@xcite , contact lines@xcite , polymers@xcite , flux lines in superconductors@xcite , fractures@xcite , and earthquakes@xcite .
another class of related examples pertains to social dilemmas , as illustrated by financial markets@xcite , traffic flow , and internet congestion problems@xcite .
given this wide range of interesting systems , it is worthwhile to acquire an elementary understanding and intuition from some simple related models . a rough `` conceptual web '' involved in the three examples we discussed in some detail
is illustrated in the following diagram .
@xmath255 @xmath256 @xmath257 @xmath258 + the main gap between our discussion and a more complete description of reality is the absence of any _
dynamics_@xcite in our formulation .
it takes some time for an elevator rope to break , during which stress is redistributed . at a boarding gate ,
sitting people are watching , thinking , and deciding _ while _ an impatient passenger walks up to the line .
a driven magnet responds with some delay , and different parts of the system are continually changing while they influence one another .
by contrast , our formulation proposes algebraic equations to describe the system rather than equations of motion . in the spirit of effective theories
, we can extend eqs .
( [ simple ] ) and ( [ short ] ) to include time dependences by letting @xmath201 depend explicitly on time and replacing the vanishing right - hand - side by a series such as @xmath259 this modification introduces correlations in time and leads to a wealth of results relating to fluctuations in time@xcite .
it is a pleasure to acknowledge professor mehran kardar s precious guidance and many interesting discussions .
the author is also grateful to paul de sa , as well as to sohrab ismail - beigi and joel moore , for commenting on the manuscript , and to the editors of the theme issue , harvey gould and jan tobochnik , for their careful review .
this work was supported by the nsf through grant no .
dmr-98 - 05833
. for a general introduction and review on conductor breakdown , fractures , and earthquakes , see b. k. chakrabarti and l. g. benguigui , _ statistical physics of fracture and breakdown in disordered systems _ ( clarendon press , oxford , 1997 ) .
j. p. sethna , k. dahmen , s. kartha , j. a. krumhansl , b. w. roberts , and j. d. shore , `` hysteresis and hierarchies : dynamics of disorder - driven first - order phase transformations , '' phys .
lett . * 70 * , 33473350 ( 1993 ) .
[ bib : sethna ] for a review of the random - field ising model , see t. nattermann , `` theory of the random - field ising model , '' in _ spin glasses and random fields _ , ed .
a. p. young ( world scientific , singapore , 1997 ) , which can also be found under cond - mat/9705295 .
for a review of non - equilibrium fluctuations of manifolds in random media and in particular polymers , flux lines , and interfaces , see m. kardar , `` nonequilibrium dynamics of interfaces and lines , '' phys .
rep . * 301 * , 85112 ( 1998 ) and references therein . for a review of transport of manifolds in random media , and in particular charge density waves ,
flux lines , cracks and faults , see d. s. fisher , `` collective transport in random media : from superconductors to earthquakes , '' phys . rep . * 301 * , 113150 ( 1998 ) and references therein .
an effective theory for magnetic systems was first introduced in l. d. landau , phys .
z. sowjetunion * 11 * , 26 ( 1937 ) , reprinted in collected papers of l. d. landau , ed .
d. ter haar ( pergamon , london , 1965 ) , p. 193 , and v. l. ginzburg and l. d. landau , zh .
. fiz . * 20 * , 1064 ( 1950 ) . for a review ,
see ref .
[ bib : ma ] , chapter 2 and ref .
[ bib : huang ] , chapter 17 . for an introduction to the renormalization - group theory ,
see ref .
[ bib : huang ] , chapter 18 , ref .
[ bib : parisi ] , chapters 79 .
other good books on the subject include ref .
[ bib : ma ] and d. j. amit , _ field theory , the renormalization group , and critical phenomena _
( world scientific , singapore , 1984 ) , 2nd ed . for a review of dynamical critical phenomena , see p. c. hohenberg and b. i. halperin , `` theory of dynamical critical phenomena , '' rev .
phys * 49 * , 435479 ( 1977 ) and ref .
[ bib : ma ] , chapters 1114 . | the rupture of a medium under stress typifies breakdown phenomena .
more generally , the latter encompass the dynamics of systems of many interacting elements governed by the interplay of a driving force with a pinning disorder , resulting in a macroscopic transition .
a simple mean - field formalism incorporating these features is presented and applied to systems representative of fracture phenomena , social dilemmas , and magnets out of equilibrium .
the similarities and differences in the corresponding mathematical structures are emphasized .
the solutions are best obtained from a graphical method , from which very general conclusions may be drawn . in particular , the various classes of disorder distribution are treated without reference to a particular analytical or numerical form , and are found to lead to qualitatively different transitions . finally , the notion of effective ( or phenomenological ) theory is introduced and illustrated for non - equilibrium disordered magnets . |
strong gravitational lensing systems provide valuable tools for studying the properties and evolution of galaxies and quasars , for measuring the distribution of dark matter , and for constraining cosmological parameters
. in particular , lensed quasar systems can provide information on , for example , intervening absorption line systems ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , properties of quasar host galaxies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , dark matter subtructure in the lens ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , and the stellar content of the lensing galaxy ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
moreover , when combined with time delay measurements and careful lens modeling , lensed quasar systems can provide powerful cosmological constraints that are complementary to those of other techniques ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
previously , large samples of lensed quasars have been found by surveys such as the cosmic lens all - sky survey ( class ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) in the radio and
the sloan digital sky survey quasar lens search ( sqls ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and the sdss - iii boss quasar lens survey @xcite in the optical . the dark energy survey ( des ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) is an ongoing imaging survey covering 5000 deg@xmath3 of the southern galactic cap in the @xmath4 filters using the dark energy camera @xcite , and it holds the promise of significantly increasing the numbers of lensed quasars . in particular , based on the forecasts of @xcite , we expect to find in des about 120 lensed quasar systems brighter than @xmath5 ( magnitude limit applies to the fainter image for pairs and third brightest image for quadruple systems , or quads ; see figure 1 of * ? ? ?
des , specifically with the external collaboration project strides ( pi t. treu ) , aims to use the resulting large lensed quasar sample for the primary science goal of improving constraints on cosmological parameters .
this lensed quasar sample is predicted to include about 20 of the very rare quad systems which will provide additional valuable information compared to pair systems for constraining lens models ( specifically extra constraints from 2 more positions and 2 more time delays ) , in particular for cosmology purposes ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) and substructure studies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) . to date
, we have discovered and spectroscopically confirmed three lensed quasar pair systems @xcite in des . here in this letter
we report the discovery and confirmation of the first lensed quasar quad ( or quad - like ) system , , in the dark energy survey .
we first describe our lensed quasar search procedure , system discovery , and photometric data in [ sec : search ] .
we then describe our spectroscopic observations and present our data in [ sec : spectra ] .
we summarize and conclude in [ sec : conclusions ] .
detailed photometry analysis and lens modeling for this system are presented in a companion paper , @xcite , to which we will refer the reader where relevant below .
the system was discovered during a systematic visual search for candidate strong lensing systems in the dark energy survey year 1 ( y1 ) data @xcite .
a number of different search methods have been applied to the des y1 data , but the specific method involved in this case was a `` blue - near - red '' technique , where we first automatically identified candidate systems of red galaxies with multiple neighboring blue objects within some radius , and then used visual inspections of these systems to rate them and to select the best candidates for subsequent spectroscopic follow - up .
this method has been used previously in the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) data to search for bright strong lensing systems and then to confirm them spectroscopically with good success ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
here we started with a des y1 red galaxy sample selected using the redmagic technique @xcite .
to minimize stellar contamination of this sample , we rejected objects with sextractor @xcite spread_model@xcite values @xmath6 .
we then identified as our initial set of candidates those redmagic galaxies with three or more blue objects within a radius @xmath7 , where we defined a blue object as one with colors @xmath8 and @xmath9 .
we did not apply any star / galaxy separation cut to the blue objects , but did reject objects that are saturated in any of the @xmath10 filters using a sextractor flags @xmath11 cut .
we also applied a magnitude cut @xmath12 on the blue objects to keep the number of candidates manageable for the visual inspection step and to have relatively brighter candidates to ease follow - up spectroscopic redshift measurements . applying the above criteria resulted in a list of 6526 systems that one of us ( hl ) then inspected visually by examining their des @xmath13 color composite images .
the discovery image of is shown in figure [ fig : images ] , where we see a central red galaxy ( g1 ) surrounded by three blue objects ( a , b , and d ) and a fourth red object ( g2 ) ( objects labeled as in * ? ? ?
this system stood out as a potential quadruply lensed quasar system , except that the fourth putative lensed quasar image has a conspicuously redder color than those of the other three images , suggesting that the fourth image may instead be that of a foregound red galaxy , which is possibly also associated with the central red lensing galaxy . here
the system would be a triple , where two of the quad s images are blended into one due to a fold configuration .
another possibility is that the fourth image is a blend of a foreground red galaxy with the fourth blue lensed quasar image , as the fourth image in figure [ fig : images ] appears not as red as the central galaxy .
regardless , the quad - like configuration of made it a very good candidate for subsequent spectroscopy , described in the next section .
we present a detailed lensing model for this system in the companion paper @xcite . in the des y1 catalog , is composed of three objects due to the fact that components d and g1 are blended and that b and g2 are also blended .
as such , the catalog contains entries from a , d+g1 , and b+g2 .
the sextractor segmentation map for the system is shown in figure [ fig : images ] , overplotted on the des @xmath14-band image of the system .
we need to point out here that all three catalog objects actually meet our blue object color criteria given before ( see figure [ fig : quadcolor ] , leftmost panel ) , so that the redmagic galaxy for this system is not g1 but rather the red galaxy g0 marked in figure [ fig : images ] .
g0 is about @xmath15 away from g1 and has a redmagic photometric redshift of @xmath16 , close to g1 s spectroscopic redshift of 0.597 ( see [ sec : spectra ] ) .
therefore in this case our blue - near - red method found the system via another red galaxy likely associated with the lensing galaxy , rather than directly via the red lensing galaxy itself .
the discovery was thus likely not coincidental , but was also not by the direct route as intended by the method .
in similar des y1 blue - near - red and related searches , we also see other cases in galaxy group and cluster environments where the lensing system is being indirectly found this way ( * ? ? ? * in preparation ) . the coordinates and photometry of the three des catalog objects
are given in table [ tab : phot ] , while we present in @xcite a more detailed analysis that provides the deblended positions and magnitudes of all five components in this system .
the des sextractor auto magnitudes of the three catalog objects are listed in table [ tab : phot ] , as are the near - infrared kron magnitudes @xcite from the vista hemisphere survey ( vhs ; * ? ? ?
* ) and the mid - infrared magnitudes from the wide - field infrared survey explorer ( wise ; * ? ? ?
* ) . for the near - infrared catalog
, magnitudes were obtained by cross - matching the des and vhs catalogs using a @xmath17 search radius .
component d+g1 does not have a @xmath18-band magnitude value due to blending with b+g2 in this band .
for the mid - infrared magnitudes , the des and wise catalogs were cross - matched using a @xmath19 search radius .
all components of the system are blended into a single wise source , which is why the same values of the @xmath20 and @xmath21 magnitudes are displayed in the table .
cccc ra & 62.091333 & 62.090469 & 62.089596 + dec & -53.900266 & -53.899641 & -53.899776 + @xmath22 & 19.99 @xmath23 0.01 & 20.45 @xmath23 0.01 & 19.74 @xmath23 0.01 + @xmath24 & 19.94 @xmath23 0.01 & 20.08 @xmath23 0.01 & 19.51 @xmath23 0.01 + @xmath14 & 19.75 @xmath23 0.01 & 19.57 @xmath23 0.01 & 19.18 @xmath23 0.01 + @xmath25 & 19.51 @xmath23 0.02 & 19.13 @xmath23 0.02 & 18.82 @xmath23 0.01
+ @xmath26 & 19.48 @xmath23 0.07 & 19.09 @xmath23 0.05 & 18.69 @xmath23 0.03 + @xmath18 & 19.58 @xmath23 0.06 & & 18.77 @xmath23 0.03 + @xmath27 & 19.62 @xmath23 0.08 & 18.90 @xmath23 0.04 & 18.65 @xmath23 0.03 + @xmath28 & 19.06 @xmath23 0.07 & 18.51 @xmath23 0.04 & 18.15 @xmath23 0.03 + @xmath20 & & 16.78 @xmath23 0.02 &
+ @xmath21 & & 16.51 @xmath23 0.02 &
+ after was first announced to the strides collaboration as a lensed quasar candidate from the blue - near - red search , a number of other search methods within strides were examined and also seen to identify the system as a candidate .
these other search methods are described in more detail in @xcite .
we provide here a brief summary : ( 1 ) the gaussian mixture model ( gmm ) method of @xcite , which uses supervised machine learning in a five - dimensional optical plus infrared color space and identified as a candidate pair ( d+g1 not found separately in @xmath18 band due to blending noted above ) ; ( 2 ) chitah @xcite , which uses pixel - based automatic recognition on @xmath4 cutout images and identified the system as a candidate pair ( not flagged as quad because fourth image g2 is too red ) ; and ( 3 ) the artificial neural network ( ann ) method of @xcite , which uses @xmath29 and @xmath30 magnitudes and identified as a candidate extended quasar .
figure [ fig : quadcolor ] shows the positions of des catalog objects a , b+g2 , and d+g1 in the color space used by the gmm method , illustrating how the system was flagged as a candidate due to the quasar - like colors of its components .
spectroscopic observations of were carried out using the gemini multi - object spectrograph ( gmos - s ) on the gemini south telescope , as part of a larger gemini large and long program ( llp ) ( pi e. buckley - geer ; program ids gs-2015b - lp-5 , gs-2016a - lp-5 ) of spectroscopic follow - up for des strong lensing systems and for des photometric redshift ( photo - z ) calibrations .
gmos - s was used in multi - object spectroscopy ( mos ) mode on 9 dec 2015 ut to take spectra of the three blue objects a , b , and d. the @xmath14-band gmos - s acquisition image is shown in figure [ fig : images ] ( top right ) .
a single slit mask was used , with one slit for a and a second slit for b and d together ; see blue slits in figure [ fig : images ] ( bottom right ) .
( another 38 slits were assigned to unrelated des photo - z calibration targets . ) two sets of spectra were taken : blue data using the b600 grating ( dispersion @xmath31 pixel@xmath32 ) and red data using the r400 grating ( dispersion @xmath33 pixel@xmath32 ) .
we used 4@xmath34900 second exposures for cosmic ray rejection and processed the data using the iraf gemini reduction package .
the seeing was @xmath35 , measured from spectra of mask - alignment stars in the science data . from the extracted ( but not flux calibrated ) 1d spectra shown in figure [ fig : spectra ] ( top panels )
, we clearly see that all three blue images a , b , and d show strong quasar emission lines at the same redshift , specifically ly@xmath36
1216 and civ 1549 in the blue spectra , and ciii ] 1909 and mgii 2800 in the red spectra .
from the ciii ] line , which shows the cleanest , most symmetric line profile among these four broad emission features , we use the emsao task in the iraf external package rvsao @xcite to report a redshift @xmath1 for the quasar . to compare the spectra of the three blue images in more detail ,
we also show in figure [ fig : spectra ] ( bottom panels ) the fractional differences between the blue and red spectra of images a and d relative to those of image b , which has the spectra with the most counts .
we first rescale the spectra of a and d so that they each have the same median counts as those of b over the respective blue and red wavelength ranges plotted .
the results in figure [ fig : spectra ] show generally good agreement among the spectra , especially for the red spectra . for the blue spectra
, we do see an overall slope for the spectrum of a relative to that of b ; we attribute this slope to extinction differences between the lines of sight to these two images , and/or to differences in atmospheric differential refraction between the two differently oriented slits ( figure [ fig : images ] ) used to observe images a and b. in addition , we also see conspicuous differences between the spectra of d and b at the locations of the strong ly@xmath36 and civ emission lines , and to a lesser extent at the ciii ] line .
we attribute these differences to the effects of microlensing by stars in the lensing galaxy , manifested as flux ratio differences , in pairs of lensed quasar images , for the continuum vs. the emission line regions in the spectra ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
subsequent to these observations that confirmed the three blue images as having the same quasar redshift , we designed a second mos slit mask targeting the central lensing galaxy g1 and the fourth image g2 , each allocated to a single slit .
the slits for g1 and g2 are shown in red in figure [ fig : images ] ( bottom right ) .
red r400 observations were obtained in the gemini south semester 2016a observing queue , on 9 apr 2016 , under @xmath37 seeing conditions and using the same observing setup as above .
blue b600 observations were also put into the queue , but no data were obtained before the system set in 2016a .
we show the r400 spectra in figure [ fig : more_spectra ] , where we see that g2 shows broad ciii ] and mgii emission at the same redshift as found for the three blue images , while g1 shows ca h+k absorption lines , indicating that g1 is an early - type lensing galaxy with redshift @xmath2 .
however , we also see that the g1 spectrum unexpectedly shows the same ciii ] emission line as in the lensed quasar spectra , leading us to suspect there is contaminating light from the neighboring lensed quasar image d , which is only about @xmath38 away ( cf . the @xmath37 seeing ) .
likewise , object b , the brightest quasar image , is only about @xmath37 away from the substantially fainter object g2 , suggesting that the ciii ] line seen in the g2 spectrum is similarly contamination from object b. using the image modeling code galfit @xcite , we simulate image b as a moffat profile with a fwhm of @xmath37 and find that about 12% of its light falls within the 1-wide slit and 2-long spectral extraction aperture used for g2 . though seemingly small
, this 12% fraction actually amounts to about 80% of the @xmath24-band light from g2 itself , given that @xmath39 and @xmath40 from table 1 of @xcite .
( we use @xmath24 band as the ciii ] line falls within that filter . )
this estimated contamination is thus substantial and unfortunately we are unable to correct for it as image b lies off the slit for g2 ( figure [ fig : images ] , bottom right ) and we do not have a concurrent spectrum of b. we thus can not rule out contamination from b as the source of the ciii ] line seen in the g2 spectrum ( likewise for d and g1 ) and will need future observations to verify whether g2 indeed shows quasar emission features or not .
was identified as a candidate lensed quasar quad system from the des first - year data .
subsequent follow - up spectroscopy confirmed the three bright blue objects in this system to be the images of a quasar at redshift @xmath1 , lensed by an early - type red galaxy with redshift @xmath2 .
another reddened object in the system , possibly a blend of a perturbing galaxy and the fourth lensed quasar image , was also observed spectroscopically , though without conclusive results .
our companion paper @xcite presents a detailed model of the system , from which we expect the longest time delay in the system to be about 80 days , making well suited @xcite for time delay measurements , which we are undertaking via a monitoring campaign within the strides collaboration .
the lensing model also constrains the mass of the possible perturbing galaxy and thus provides information about substructure in the lensing mass distribution .
further spectroscopic follow - up and high resolution imaging data should provide more needed details about the main lensing galaxy and its environment .
we thus expect this quad system to be particularly useful for the application of time delay cosmography ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) and substructure studies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
heralds a much larger sample of some 20 of these very rare and valuable quad lensed quasar systems anticipated to be discovered by the dark energy survey .
funding for the des projects has been provided by the u.s .
department of energy , the u.s
. national science foundation , the ministry of science and education of spain , the science and technology facilities council of the united kingdom , the higher education funding council for england , the national center for supercomputing applications at the university of illinois at urbana - champaign , the kavli institute of cosmological physics at the university of chicago , the center for cosmology and astro - particle physics at the ohio state university , the mitchell institute for fundamental physics and astronomy at texas a&m university , financiadora de estudos e projetos , fundao carlos chagas filho de amparo pesquisa do estado do rio de janeiro , conselho nacional de desenvolvimento cientfico e tecnolgico and the ministrio da cincia , tecnologia e inovao , the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft and the collaborating institutions in the dark energy survey .
the collaborating institutions are argonne national laboratory , the university of california at santa cruz , the university of cambridge , centro de investigaciones energticas , medioambientales y tecnolgicas - madrid , the university of chicago , university college london , the des - brazil consortium , the university of edinburgh , the eidgenssische technische hochschule ( eth ) zrich , fermi national accelerator laboratory , the university of illinois at urbana - champaign , the institut de cincies de lespai ( ieec / csic ) , the institut de fsica daltes energies , lawrence berkeley national laboratory , the ludwig - maximilians universitt mnchen and the associated excellence cluster universe , the university of michigan , the national optical astronomy observatory , the university of nottingham , the ohio state university , the university of pennsylvania , the university of portsmouth , slac national accelerator laboratory , stanford university , the university of sussex , texas a&m university , and the ozdes membership consortium .
the des data management system is supported by the national science foundation under grant number ast-1138766 .
the des participants from spanish institutions are partially supported by mineco under grants aya2012 - 39559 , esp2013 - 48274 , fpa2013 - 47986 , and centro de excelencia severo ochoa sev-2012 - 0234 .
research leading to these results has received funding from the european research council under the european union s seventh framework programme fp7/2007 - 2013 ) including erc grant agreements 240672 , 291329 , and 306478 . based on observations obtained at the gemini observatory ( acquired through the gemini observatory archive and processed using the gemini iraf package ) ,
which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc .
, under a cooperative agreement with the nsf on behalf of the gemini partnership : the national science foundation ( united states ) , the national research council ( canada ) , conicyt ( chile ) , ministerio de ciencia , tecnologa e innovacin productiva ( argentina ) , and ministrio da cincia , tecnologia e inovao ( brazil ) abazajian , k. n. , et al .
2009 , , 182 , 543 agnello , a. , et al .
2015 , , 448 , 1446 agnello , a. , et al .
2015 , , 454 , 1260 agnello , a. , et al .
2017 , , submitted belokurov , v. , et al .
2009 , , 392 , 104 bertin , e. , & arnouts , s. 1996 , , 117 , 393 bonvin , v. , et al .
2017 , , 465 , 4914 bouy , h. , et al .
2013 , , 554 , 101 browne , i. w. a. , et al .
2003 , , 341 , 13 chan , j. h. h. , et al .
2015 , , 807 , 138 dalal , n. , & kochanek , c. s. 2002 , , 572 , 25 dark energy survey collaboration , arxiv : astro - ph/0510346 dark energy survey collaboration 2016 , , 460 , 1270 desai , s. , et al .
2012 , , 757 , 83 diehl , h. t. , et al .
2009 , , 707 , 686 diehl , h. t. , et al .
2014 , proc .
spie 9149 , 91490v diehl , h. t. , et al .
2017 , in preparation flaugher , b. , et al .
2015 , , 150 , 150 inada , n. , et al .
2012 , , 143 , 119 kron , r. g. 1980 , , 43 , 305 kurtz , m. j. , & mink , d. j. 1998 , , 110 , 934 mcmahon , r. g. , banerji , m. , gonzalez , e. , koposov , s. e. , bejar , v. j. , lodieu , n. , rebolo , r. , vhs collaboration 2013 , the messenger , 154 , 35 more , a. , et al .
2016 , , 456 , 1595 motta , v. , mediavilla , e. , falco , e. , & muoz , j. a. 2012 , , 755 , 82 myers , s. .t . , et al .
2003 , , 341 , 1 oguri , m. , & marshall , p. j. 2010 , , 405 , 2579 oguri , m. , et al . 2006 , , 132 , 999 ostrovski , f. , et al .
2017 , , 465 , 4325 peng , c. y. , et al .
2006 , , 649 , 616 peng , c. y. , et al .
2010 , , 139 , 2097 rozo , e. , et al .
2016 , , 461 , 1431 schechter , p. l. , et al .
2014 , , 793 , 96 smette , a. , et al .
1995 , , 113 , 199 suyu , s. h. , et al . 2013 , , 766 , 70 suyu , s. h. , et al .
2016 , , submitted , arxiv:1607.00017 treu , t. , & marshall , p. j. 2016 , astronomy and astrophysics review , 24 , 11 wright , e. l. , et al .
2010 , , 140 , 1868 | we report the discovery and spectroscopic confirmation of the quad - like lensed quasar system found in the dark energy survey ( des ) year 1 ( y1 ) data .
this system was discovered during a search for des y1 strong lensing systems using a method that identified candidates as red galaxies with multiple blue neighbors .
consists of a central red galaxy surrounded by three bright ( @xmath0 ) blue objects and a fourth red object .
subsequent spectroscopic observations using the gemini south telescope confirmed that the three blue objects are indeed the lensed images of a quasar with redshift @xmath1 , and that the central red object is an early - type lensing galaxy with redshift @xmath2 .
is the first quad lensed quasar system to be found in des and begins to demonstrate the potential of des to discover and dramatically increase the sample size of these very rare objects . |
gravitationally lensed quasars have proven to be a useful tool for a variety of astrophysical and cosmological studies , as described e.g. , in @xcite
. applications of quasar lenses include constraints on cosmological parameters ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and measurements of mass distributions for galaxy- and cluster - scale halos ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , interstellar medium associated with lensing or intervening galaxies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , and the structure of quasar accretion disk and outflow ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
many of these applications take advantage of the time - variable nature of quasars and therefore are not available for galaxy - galaxy strong lenses .
the use of these quasar lenses can be enhanced by constructing a homogeneous lens sample with a well - characterized selection function .
for instance , the cosmic lens all sky survey ( class ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
* ) has provided a complete sample of 22 strong lenses selected among @xmath1116,000 radio sources , which has been used for a number of cosmological and astrophysical studies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
we have completed the sdss quasar lens search ( sqls ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , which is the current largest lensed quasar survey using optical data of the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ; * ? ? ?
as a result , we have discovered more than 40 lensed quasars including four lensed quasars presented in this paper .
we have also rediscovered many previously known lensed quasars located in the sdss footprint @xcite .
the total number of lensed quasars identified in the sdss data is 62 @xcite .
the statistical analysis for sqls lenses to constrain both cosmological parameters and the evolution of massive galaxies has been reported in @xcite . in this paper , we report the discovery of four lensed quasars from the sqls . since the description of the four lensed quasars in @xcite is so brief , we show the detailed properties of the four systems here .
we briefly describe the sdss data and our algorithm to locate lensed quasar candidates in [ sec : sdss ] .
we then present follow - up observations to confirm their lensing hypotheses in
[ sec : follow - up ] .
we carry out mass modeling in [ sec : model ] .
our result is summarized in [ sec : summary ] .
the sqls identifies lensed quasars among @xmath12 quasars @xcite from the sdss data release 7 ( dr7 ) .
the sdss is a survey using a dedicated wide - field 2.5-meter telescope @xcite at the apache point observatory ( new mexico , usa ) to conduct imaging and spectroscopic surveys for a quarter of the sky .
the imaging data were obtained through five broad - band filters ( @xmath13 , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) with astrometric accuracy better than @xmath14 @xcite and with photometric zeropoint accuracy better than @xmath15 mag @xcite .
quasar and galaxy candidates were selected by the sdss spectroscopic pipeline based on the imaging data @xcite .
the candidates were tiled in each plate according to the algorithm of @xcite , and were observed with multi - object fiber spectrographs ( @xmath16 ) covering 3800 to 9200 @xcite .
the sdss dr7 data have already been made public @xcite .
the procedure to identify lensed quasar candidates from the spectroscopic sdss quasars has been described in the series of sqls papers @xcite , which we outline here .
we use two selection methods .
one is to find quasars with nearby objects whose colors are similar to the quasars .
this method is tagged as the `` color selection '' .
the color selection does not always work well for the sdss data because of the relatively poor spatial resolution of sdss imaging data , whose seeing sizes are comparable to typical image separations of quasar lenses . therefore , in order to find lenses which are not deblended into multiple components in the sdss data , we also exploit the so - called `` morphological selection '' , in which we select spectroscopic quasars with extended morphologies as lensed quasar candidates .
sdss j0743 + 2457 and sdss j1128 + 2402 are selected by the morphological selection , whereas sdss j1405 + 0959 and sdss j1515 + 1511 are selected by both the color selection and the morphological selection .
the sdss properties of these four candidates are summarized in table [ tab : sdss ] .
we also show the sdss @xmath17-band images of the four objects in figure [ fig : fc ] .
we note that sdss j0743 + 2457 and sdss j1405 + 0959 have been reported as quasar lenses ulas 074352.6 + 245743 and ulas 140515.4 + 095931 , respectively , by the major ukidss - sdss cosmic lens survey ( muscles ) survey @xcite . in the muscles survey lens candidates
are selected by cross - matching sdss quasars with ukidss near - infrared images which typically have much better spatial resolution .
our identification of sdss j0743 + 2457 and sdss j1405 + 0959 as lens candidates is independent of the muscles survey result .
we carried out follow - up imaging and spectroscopic observations using the university of hawaii 2.2-meter telescope ( uh88 ) , the astrophysical research consortium 3.5-meter telescope ( arc ) , the 3.58-meter telescopio nazionale galileo ( tng ) , the subaru 8.2-m telescope , and the gemini north 8.1-m telescope , to confirm the lensing hypothesis of the four lensed quasar candidates .
all the four candidates are doubly imaged lens candidates , and therefore their lensing hypothesis should be confirmed by both similar spectral energy distributions ( seds ) for the two stellar components and the existence of an extended object between the two components that act as a lens .
we summarize the details of our follow - up imaging and spectroscopic observations in tables [ tab : image ] and [ tab : spec ] .
we clearly detect two stellar components in each original image of the follow - up imaging observations .
once we subtract two point spread functions ( psfs ) using galfit @xcite , we detect a significant residual , indicating an additional component in between the two psfs , for all four systems .
we then model the system with two psfs plus an extended component represented by a srsic profile .
as shown in figure [ fig : iband ] , an extended component is clearly visible after subtracting the two psfs .
the srsic parameters of the best - fitting model are summarized in table [ tab : sersic ] .
we also summarize the astrometric and photometric results for each system in table [ tab : opt ] .
results of the spectroscopic follow - up observations are shown in figure [ fig : allspec ] .
for each candidate , we aligned the slit direction such that we can observe the two stellar components simultaneously .
the good seeing condition ( fwhm@xmath1810 ) enabled us to extract the spectrum of each component easily using standard iraf tasks .
the spectra indicate that the seds of the two stellar components are quite similar for all four systems .
in particular , the two quasar components of the sdss j1405 + 0959 system have very similar broad absorption , which is in strong support of strong lensing interpretation of this system .
the fainter component of sdss j1515 + 1511 shows a strong absorption at @xmath19 , which corresponds to an absorber at @xmath20 , and is likely to be associated with the lensing galaxy ( see below ) .
first we examine our follow - up spectra carefully to look for any spectral signature of lensing galaxies .
we find that the spectrum of the fainter component of sdss j0743 + 2457 contains a significant amount of galaxy flux .
we extract the spectrum of the lensing galaxy g by subtracting the spectrum of image a , with an appropriate offset corresponding to the flux ratio , from that of image b. figure [ fig : spec0743 g ] clearly indicates that the lensing galaxy is an early - type galaxy at @xmath1 . for the other lens systems
, we estimate redshifts of the lensing galaxies based on their colors . for sdss j1405 + 0959
, the srsic concentration index suggests that the residual may be a late - type galaxy . in this case , the @xmath21 and @xmath22 colors imply that the redshift is @xmath23 ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
this is broadly consistent with @xmath24 derived in @xcite using the overall spectral shape of the lensing galaxy in their follow - up spectroscopic data . for sdss
j1515 + 1511 , the morphology is more robust in the @xmath17-band , where it is consistent with a late - type galaxy .
its color @xmath25 implies the redshift of @xmath26 , which is close to the redshift @xmath20 of the strong absorber seen in the spectrum of the fainter quasar image .
thus we tentatively assign its lens redshift to be @xmath9 .
it is difficult to estimate the photometric lens redshift of sdss j1128 + 2402 from the current data .
we model the lens systems adopting a singular isothermal ellipsoid ( sie ) mass model using _ glafic _ @xcite .
the number of parameters is eight ( the position and flux of the source quasar , the position of the lensing galaxy , the einstein radius , the ellipticity , and the position angle ) , while the number of constraints from the imaging observations is also eight ( the positions and fluxes of the two quasar components , and the position of the lensing galaxy ) .
thus the model has zero degrees of freedom .
we adopt the @xmath27-band imaging result as constraints for sdss j0743 + 2457 , sdss j1128 + 2402 , and sdss j1405 + 0959 . for sdss j1515 + 1511
, we use the @xmath17-band imaging result in spite of the lens being comparatively fainter , because the seeing was smaller , there were more stars available to build a psf , and both astrometry and morphology are more robust .
we summarize the parameters of the best - fitting ( @xmath28 ) models in table [ tab : model ] . as is common ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , there are large differences in the lensing galaxy shapes between the observations ( table [ tab : sersic ] ) and the best - fitting mass model parameters ( table [ tab : model ] ) .
this may partly be explained by nearby perturbers which affect the lens potentials .
we have confirmed the lensing hypothesis for four lens candidates selected by the sqls , based on the similar seds of the stellar components together with the existence of extended objects in between the stellar components , and the successful mass modeling of the observed configurations .
all four are doubly imaged quasar lens systems : sdss j0743 + 2457 ( @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath2 ) , sdss j1128 + 2402 ( @xmath3 , @xmath4 ) , sdss j1405 + 0959 ( @xmath5 , @xmath29 , @xmath7 ) , and sdss j1515 + 1511 ( @xmath8 , @xmath30 , @xmath10 ) .
two of them ( sdss j1405 + 0959 and sdss j1515 + 1511 ) are included in the sqls statistical sample @xcite and are used for cosmological constraints @xcite .
these lens systems represent likely the last quasar lenses to emerge from the sqls project .
the applications of the sqls lenses have been limited by the lack of high - resolution images for many of the sqls lenses .
we are therefore currently conducting a program to observe the sqls lenses with subaru telescope laser guide start adaptive optics system to accurately measure the quasar image positions and light profile of the lensing galaxy ( * ? ? ?
* c. e. rusu et al . , in preparation ) .
we are also carrying out a lensed quasar survey using the sdss - iii data @xcite from which we will be able to discover more quasar lenses .
this work was supported in part by the first program `` subaru measurements of images and redshifts ( sumire ) '' , world premier international research center initiative ( wpi initiative ) , mext , japan , and grant - in - aid for scientific research from the jsps ( 23740161 ) .
i. k. acknowledges support from mext kakenhi 24740171 .
use of the uh 2.2-m telescope for the observations is supported by naoj . based in part on observations obtained with the apache point observatory 3.5-meter telescope , which is owned and operated by the astrophysical research consortium , and on observations made with the italian telescopio nazionale galileo ( tng ) operated on the island of la palma by the fundacion galileo galilei of the inaf ( istituto nazionale di astrofisica ) at the spanish observatorio del roque de los muchachos of the instituto de astrofisica de canarias . based in part on observations obtained at the gemini observatory , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc .
, under a cooperative agreement with the nsf on behalf of the gemini partnership : the national science foundation ( united states ) , the national research council ( canada ) , conicyt ( chile ) , the australian research council ( australia ) , ministrio da cincia , tecnologia e inovao ( brazil ) and ministerio de ciencia , tecnologa e innovacin productiva ( argentina ) .
funding for the sdss and sdss - ii has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national science foundation , the u.s .
department of energy , the national aeronautics and space administration , the japanese monbukagakusho , the max planck society , and the higher education funding council for england .
the sdss web site is http://www.sdss.org/. the sdss is managed by the astrophysical research consortium for the participating institutions .
the participating institutions are the american museum of natural history , astrophysical institute potsdam , university of basel , cambridge university , case western reserve university , university of chicago , drexel university , fermilab , the institute for advanced study , the japan participation group , johns hopkins university , the joint institute for nuclear astrophysics , the kavli institute for particle astrophysics and cosmology , the korean scientist group , the chinese academy of sciences ( lamost ) , los alamos national laboratory , the max - planck - institute for astronomy ( mpia ) , the max - planck - institute for astrophysics ( mpa ) , new mexico state university , ohio state university , university of pittsburgh , university of portsmouth , princeton university , the united states naval observatory , and the university of washington .
kochanek , c. s. , schneider , p. , wambsganss , j. , 2006 , part 2 of gravitational lensing : strong , weak & micro , proceedings of the 33rd saas - fee advanced course , g. meylan , p. jetzer & p. north , eds .
( springer - verlag : berlin ) , 91 ccccccccc sdss j0743 + 2457 & 07:43:52.61 & + 24:57:43.6 & @xmath31 & @xmath32 & @xmath33 & @xmath34 & @xmath35 & @xmath36 + sdss j1128 + 2402 & 11:28:18.49 & + 24:02:17.4 & @xmath37 & @xmath38 & @xmath39 & @xmath40 & @xmath41 & @xmath42 + sdss j1405 + 0959 & 14:05:15.42 & + 09:59:31.3 & @xmath43 & @xmath44 & @xmath45 & @xmath46 & @xmath47 & @xmath48 + & 14:05:15.40 & + 09:59:29.3 & @xmath49 & @xmath50 & @xmath51 & @xmath52 & @xmath53 & + sdss j1515 + 1511 & 15:15:38.59 & + 15:11:35.8 & @xmath54 & @xmath55 & @xmath56 & @xmath57 & @xmath58 & @xmath59 + & 15:15:38.47 & + 15:11:34.7 & @xmath60 & @xmath61 & @xmath62 & @xmath63 & @xmath64 & + cccc sdss j0743 + 2457 & tek2k(@xmath65 ) & 2010jan16(@xmath66 ) , 2009apr16(@xmath67 ) , 2010jan17(@xmath68 ) & 720(@xmath66 ) , 300(@xmath67 ) , 960(@xmath68 ) + sdss j1128 + 2402 & tek2k(@xmath69 ) & 2007apr12(@xmath66 ) , 2010jan17(@xmath27 ) & 300(@xmath66 ) , 960(@xmath27 ) + sdss j1405 + 0959 & uh8k(@xmath69 ) , tek2k(@xmath67 ) & 2006mar25(@xmath69 ) , 2009apr16(@xmath67 ) & 270(@xmath66 ) , 400(@xmath67 ) , 450(@xmath27 ) + sdss j1515 + 1511 & tek2k(@xmath27 ) , s - cam(@xmath17 ) , ircs(@xmath70 ) , spicam(@xmath71 ) & 2009apr16(@xmath27 ) , 2011mar31(@xmath17 ) , 2011may7(@xmath70 ) , 2011mar26(@xmath71 ) & 400(@xmath27 ) , 90(@xmath17 ) , 1320(@xmath70 ) , 1080(@xmath71 ) + ccccccc sdss j0743 + 2457 & gmos & @xmath72 & gg455/r150 & 4600 - 9000 & 2010 mar 22 & 1200 + sdss j1128 + 2402 & gmos & @xmath72 & gg455/r150 & 4600 - 9000 & 2010 mar 22 & 900 + sdss j1405 + 0959 & dolores & @xmath72 & lr - b & 3700 - 7800 & 2008 mar 1 & 1800 + sdss j1515 + 1511 & dolores & @xmath72 & lr - b & 3700 - 7800 & 2008 apr 13 & 900 + ccccc sdss j0743 + 2457 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + sdss j1128 + 2402 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + sdss j1405 + 0959 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] + sdss j1515 + 1511 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] + cccccc + + a & @xmath76 & @xmath77 & @xmath78 & @xmath79 & @xmath80 + b & @xmath81 & @xmath82 & @xmath83 & @xmath84 & @xmath85 + g & @xmath86 & @xmath87 & & & @xmath88 + a & @xmath77 & @xmath77 & @xmath89 & & @xmath90 + b & @xmath91 & @xmath92 & @xmath93 & & @xmath94 + g & @xmath95 & @xmath96 & @xmath97 & & @xmath98 + a & @xmath99 & @xmath77 & @xmath100 & @xmath101 & @xmath102 + b & @xmath103 & @xmath104 & @xmath105 & @xmath106 & @xmath107 + g1 & @xmath108 & @xmath109 & @xmath110 & @xmath111 & @xmath112 + g2 & @xmath113 & @xmath114 & @xmath115 & @xmath116 & @xmath117 + a & @xmath99 & @xmath77 & @xmath118 & @xmath119 & @xmath120 + b & @xmath121 & @xmath122 & @xmath123 & @xmath124 & @xmath125 + g & @xmath126 & @xmath127 & @xmath128 & @xmath129 & @xmath130 + ccccc sdss j0743 + 2457 & 0.53 & 0.19 & 89.4 & 3.6 + sdss j1128 + 2402 & 0.42 & 0.06 & @xmath7475.4 & 6.0 + sdss j1405 + 0959 & 1.03 & 0.49 & 67.4 & 2.6 + sdss j1515 + 1511 & 0.90 & 0.60 & @xmath7425.0 & 2.8 + | we report the discovery of four doubly imaged quasar lenses .
all the four systems are selected as lensed quasar candidates from the sloan digital sky survey data .
we confirm their lensing hypothesis with additional imaging and spectroscopic follow - up observations .
the discovered lenses are sdss j0743 + 2457 with the source redshift @xmath0 , the lens redshift @xmath1 , and the image separation @xmath2 , sdss j1128 + 2402 with @xmath3 and @xmath4 , sdss j1405 + 0959 with @xmath5 , @xmath6 , and @xmath7 , and sdss j1515 + 1511 with @xmath8 , @xmath9 , and @xmath10 .
it is difficult to estimate the lens redshift of sdss j1128 + 2402 from the current data .
two of the four systems ( sdss j1405 + 0959 and sdss j1515 + 1511 ) are included in our final statistical lens sample to derive constraints on dark energy and the evolution of massive galaxies . |
the first extensive survey of the far - infrared sky was made by the _ infrared astronomy satellite _ ( iras ) launched in 1983 , more than two decades ago .
iras provided point source catalogs , as well as infrared sky maps , for almost the entire sky , revealing the infrared view of the universe .
the iras products became a standard dataset , not only for infrared astronomy but also for many other fields . with the widespread use of the iras dataset , observations in the infrared
are now considered an irreplaceable tool .
compared with the datasets at other wavelengths , the iras dataset appears rather shallow , although it provides an unbiased and wide area coverage survey .
however , a next - generation infrared dataset is needed to push the frontier of astrophysics . the far - infrared surveyor ( fis ) on the akari satellite @xcite was developed to provide this new dataset in the far - infrared region , taking advantage of recent technology , including the cryogenics @xcite .
the fis was designed to perform an all - sky survey in the far - infrared region with higher spatial resolution and higher sensitivity than the iras .
a combination of the infrared camera ( irc ) @xcite on the akari satellite also enables a wider wavelength coverage than iras . the _ spitzer space telescope _
( sst ) @xcite , which is used extensively in the observation of various objects in the infrared region , has brought new insights into the universe with its high spatial resolution and high sensitivity .
fis is a complementary instrument because of its capability of covering wide areas , and its multiple photometric bands .
furthermore , the fis has the advantage of allowing far - infrared spectroscopy with a fourier transform spectrometer ( fts ) .
the _ infrared space observatory _ ( iso ) @xcite demonstrated the potential of spectroscopy in the infrared region for diagnostics of the interstellar medium and radiation field . adopting two - dimensional array detectors , the fts of fis works as an imaging fts .
consequently , it affords high efficiency observations of the spatial structure in spectra .
this paper describes the design and operation of fis in two sections , and then discusses its flight performance and advantage .
the fis is a composite instrument , consisting of a scanner and a spectrometer . adopting the newly developed large format array detectors
, fis achieves high spatial resolution and sensitivity .
fig.[fig : fis ] shows a picture of fis during final integration ; the top cover is removed to show the interior .
fig.[fig : fis_optics ] illustrates the fis optical design .
fis is about 50 cm along the major axis and weighs about 5.5 kg . to reduce the size and resources required , the scanner and spectrometer share some optical components and detector units .
rotating the filter wheel selects the appropriate function .
light coming from the telescope is focused near the fis input aperture . after passing through the input aperture ,
the beam is bent into the fis optical plane and led to the collimator mirror .
the collimated beam goes to the filter wheel , which selects the scanner or the spectrometer by choosing the filter combination . in the scanner mode
, it selects a the combination of an open hole and a dichroic beam splitter .
the beam passes through the hole , and is reflected by a flat mirror to the dichroic filter on the filter wheel .
longer wavelength photons ( @xmath1 ) pass through the filter and shorter wavelength photons are reflected .
camera optics focus the beams onto the detector units according to their wavelength .
a fourier transform spectrometer ( fts ) serves as the spectroscopic component .
a polarizing michelson interferometer , the so - called martin puplett interferometer @xcite , is employed in the fts optics .
this type of interferometer requires input and output polarizers to provide linear polarization .
these two polarizers are on the filter wheel , and are selected in the spectrometer mode . the collimated beam is reflected by the input polarizer to the interferometer , while the remaining component is absorbed by a blocking wall .
a beam splitter divides the linearly polarized beam into two beams .
the beam splitter is also a polarizer , whose polarizing angle is rotated by 45 degrees relative to the incident linear polarized beam .
all polarizers are wire - grid filters printed on thin mylar films supplied by qmc instruments ltd .
the divided beams are reflected by roof - top mirrors ; one is fixed and the other is movable to change the optical path difference between two beams .
after that , the beam splitter recombines the two beams , and the interfered beam goes to the output polarizer .
finally , the elliptically polarized beam is separated into two axis components by the output polarizer .
each component is focused on the corresponding detector unit .
fis has a cold shutter at the input aperture to allow measurement of the dark current of the detector . for the calibration of the detectors ,
there are three light sources in the fis housing .
one is in the light path of the scanner , and the others irradiate the front of each detector .
the intensity and emitting duration of each lamp are independently controlled by commands independently .
these lamps can also simulate the light curve of the point source in the all - sky survey .
since the simulated light curve is quite stable and reproducible , the detector responses to a point source can be monitored at any time .
in addition to these calibration lamps , there is a blackbody source , whose temperature is controllable up to 40k , opposite the interferometer input that is used to check that operation of the fts .
furthermore , to improve the transient response of the long wavelength detector , a background light source , with controllable power , is placed on the detector unit to continuously irradiate detector pixels . at the current
setting , the incident power corresponds to a sky brightness of @xmath2100 mjy / sr .
we use two types of photoconductive detector array to cover the far - infrared wavelengths ( 50 180 @xmath0 ) .
one is the direct - hybrid monolithic ge : ga array @xcite for the shorter wavelength of 50 to 110 @xmath0 ( labeled sw ) , which was developed by the national institute of information and communications technology ( nict ) .
the ge : ga monolithic array is bump - bonded by indium with silicon - based cryogenic readout electronics @xcite .
the other is a compact stressed ge : ga array for longer wavelengths of 110 to 180 @xmath0 ( labeled lw ) , which is an evolved version of a previous model @xcite .
the lw detector also employs cryogenic readout electronics .
all ge : ga chips were supplied by nict .
there are two arrays in each detector unit for the different photometric bands wide - s and n60 for the sw detector and wide - l and n160 for the lw detector .
the array formats are @xmath3 , @xmath4 , @xmath5 , and @xmath6 for wide - s , n60 , wide - l , and n160 , respectively , as shown in fig.[fig : array_format ] .
several pixels did not work properly after fabrication ( shown by hatching in the figure ) ; however , no additional bad pixels appeared after the launch .
the fields - of - view ( fovs ) of wide - s and wide - l , n60 and n160 detectors overlap , although their coverage differs .
the pixel scales are designed to be comparable to the telescope s diffraction limits .
the arrays are rotated by 26.5 degrees relative to the scanning direction .
because of this configuration , the width of the stripe swept out on the sky is reduced to about @xmath7 of the array width , although the spatial sampling grid becomes half of the pixel pitch in the cross - scan direction .
the fovs of the sw and lw detectors were measured in space by observing point sources .
the measured fovs are shifted from the designed position by about 1 arcmin in both in - scan and cross - scan directions referred to the telescope s boresight ( see top panel of fig.[fig : array_format ] ) . in the spectrometer mode ( bottom panel of fig.[fig : array_format ] ) , the misalignment of each array is larger than in the scanner mode , which limits the observational efficiency of spectral mapping .
the distortion of the fovs due to the fis optics is evaluated by optical simulation .
although the actual distortion and magnification factor of the fis optics do not match precisely , no significant discrepancy with the design is indicated .
the four photometric bands of fis are defined by the combination of the optical filters and the spectral response of the detectors , as the incident photons reach the detectors through the optical filters .
the collimated beam passes through two blocking filters that block the mid- and near - infrared photons contributed mainly by stars .
the dichroic filter then divides the beam in the frequency domain : higher frequency photons ( @xmath8 @xmath9 in wavenumber ) are reflected and lower frequency photons are transmitted . finally , two filters on the front of each detector shape the photometric bands .
four photometric bands cover the 50 to 180 @xmath0 wavelength region ; two are wide bands ( wide - s and wide - l ) and the other two are narrow ( n60 and n160 ) . in the spectrometer mode ,
the dichroic beam splitter is replaced by a combination of three polarizers .
the other optical filters are the same as for the scanner mode .
only the wide bands ( wide - s and wide - l ) are used for spectroscopy .
the spectrometer could in principle take interferograms with narrow bands , although some of the outer pixels of the arrays will vignette the telescope beam .
fig.[fig : fis_bands ] shows the fis system s spectral response in the photometric mode .
the responses are normalized at the peak .
the filters and optics were measured in an end - to - end system configuration at room temperature , although the narrow band filters for n60 and n160 were measured individually at cryogenic temperature , since their properties depend on temperature .
the spectral responses of the detectors were evaluated by a spectrometer , each pixel of the detector array having a different spectral response .
this difference is larger in the lw detector , due to non - uniformity of the effective stress on the ge : ga chips .
the plot in fig.[fig : fis_bands ] provides typical profiles .
the spectral response of each pixel must be used to calculate precise pixel - to - pixel color corrections .
the spectral response can also be measured by the fis spectrometer itself , using the internal and external blackbody sources at different temperatures . in orbit , we confirmed the system spectral response of fis in this manner .
the spectra of the internal blackbody source taken in orbit are within @xmath10 of those measured in the laboratory after scaling the responsivity .
since the filters and optics are considered stable , the system spectral response of each photometric band is expected to be similar to that measured in the laboratory as shown in fig.[fig : fis_bands ] .
the blocking filters are expected to avoid leakage of the mid- and near - infrared photons .
the blocking efficiency required from the scientific observations is @xmath11 at 10 @xmath0 and @xmath12 at 0.5 @xmath0 , which are realized optimally , and will in future be checked by observations of well - known stars .
fis is designed primarily to perform an all - sky survey with four photometric bands .
the goal is to observe the entire sky for at least two independent orbits .
the first half year following the performance verification phase is dedicated to observations for the all - sky survey . during the remaining life
, supplemental survey observations will fill in the incomplete sky areas , sharing the observation time with dedicated science programs . during the survey ,
the detectors are read out continuously with a constant sampling rate for each array , corresponding to about three samples in a pixel crossing time .
detectors are reset to discharge the photo current at appropriate intervals of about 2 sec nominally , 0.5 sec for bright sky , and for each sampling ( correlated double sampling : cds ) at the galactic plane , whose reset intervals correspond to about 26 and 45 ms for the sw and lw detectors , respectively .
calibration flashes with illuminator lamps are inserted periodically every minute while keeping the shutter open to trace the detector responsivity . near the ecliptic poles ,
where the detectors sweep frequently , a one - minute calibration sequence with the shutter closed is executed for nearly every orbit to monitor the long term trend of the detector responsivity . before launch of the akari satellite ,
the project science team members selected the core programs and target sources were selected .
in addition to the core programs , some portion of the observation time was open to the community . for the scientific programs and the open time proposals ,
the akari instruments operate in a pointing mode .
the fis observations are categorized in three major astronomical observation templates ( aots ) , two for photometry and one for spectroscopy .
details of each aot are described below .
the fis01 template is used to observe point - like or small scale sources . in this aot , for one pointing observation
, the detectors sweep the sky two times in round trips . between two round trips ,
the scan path is shifted by either a few pixels ( 70 arcsec ) or half of the fov ( 240 arcsec ) in the cross - scan direction , which is selectable .
the other adjustable parameters are the reset interval and scan speed .
the scan speed is selectable from 8``/sec or 15''/sec , which are nearly 14 to 30 times slower than that of the all - sky survey .
the detection limits should be improved by a factor of the exposure time or more using the charge integration amplifier .
furthermore , using a slower scanning speed reduces the transient response effects of the detector response .
an observation sequence takes about 30 minutes as shown in the top panel of fig.[fig : fis_aot ] . during about 10 minutes of maneuvering to the spacecraft to point toward the target
, the standard calibration sequence is executed with the shutter closed , i.e. , measuring dark current , illuminating the calibration lamps continuously for about two min and flashing the calibration lamps several times .
after opening the shutter and waiting 210 sec , the scanning sequence begins and continues for about 12 minutes .
then , the shutter is closed again and the maneuver to the all - sky survey begins with the post observation calibrations . during scanning observations , at the scan turning points ,
the shutter is closed for 30 sec and the calibration lamps are turned on for about eight sec to monitor the drift of the detector responsivity during the pointing observation .
fis02 is the template for wide area mapping .
this aot executes only one round trip .
the detectors sweep a longer strip than for fis01 , but the detection redundancy is reduced .
overlapping scans are critical for high quality wide area mapping . by selecting the 15" / sec scan speed
, the strip length reaches over one degree .
the calibration sequences in the pre- and post observation phase and at the turning point are the same as for fis01 .
the middle panel of fig.[fig : fis_aot ] illustrates the observation sequence .
fis03 is the template for spectroscopic observations .
the bottom panel of fig.[fig : fis_aot ] illustrates the observation sequence . in this aot
, the target is locked on the detectors . to use the fts ,
the optics are switched to fts mode by rotating the filter wheel during the maneuver to the target position .
the sampling sequence changes for the fts and the movable mirror starts to operate .
important parameters in fis03 are the spectral resolution and array selection .
users choose from two spectral resolution modes : a full resolution mode and a low resolution mode ( named sed mode ) , with spectral resolution of 0.19 @xmath9 and 1.2 @xmath9 without apodization , respectively .
taking one interferogram in the full resolution mode takes four times longer than that in the sed mode .
consequently , in one pointing observation , 15 full resolution or 59 sed mode interferograms can be taken .
the other important parameter is the array selection , which was added after launch , because the fovs of the two detectors are misaligned as shown in fig.[fig : array_format ] .
depending on the position of the target on the detectors , there are three choices : nominal , sw , and lw positions . during the maneuver to the target position ,
the internal blackbody source is turned on at the proper temperature , with the shutter closed , and interferograms are taken as reference spectra
. a short calibration sequence using the calibration lamps is also conducted at the pre- and post observation phase .
after the observation , the observation mode changes to photometry mode for the all - sky survey , during the recovery maneuver to the all - sky survey .
parameters for each aot are summarized in table [ tab : aot_list ] .
fis can operate in parallel with the irc observations .
since the fovs of fis are separated from the fovs of the irc by about half a degree , they can not observe the same target .
nevertheless , taking data with fis is interesting in many cases as a serendipitous survey .
the nominal operation of the irc is to make observations with long exposure times to provide deep images or spectra .
since the fis photometry is designed for scanning mode , the pointed observations of the photometry are ineffective due to the narrow array formats and larger pixel scales .
therefore , fis is operated in the spectrometer mode , if the sky is bright enough to detect signals by the fts .
the observation sequence for parallel observation is the same as for fis03 .
these parallel observations are productive , especially for the large magellanic cloud , where irc is making systematic surveys , as well as toward bright complex regions like the galactic plane .
specific calibration sequences operates during the remaining irc oriented observations .
once a day , the calibration sequence to evaluate detector transient response is executed . about once every three days ,
the calibration lamp stability is also measured .
these calibration data are used to track long term trends in detector performance .
in orbit , all fis functions are working as designed .
the cold shutter and the filter wheel have operated constantly while in orbit , more than ten thousand times and a few hundred times , respectively .
all the functions are controlled by the onboard electronics without any difficulty . in the following subsections ,
the fis flight performance is described .
the point spread functions ( psfs ) of fis were measured in the laboratory using a pin hole source .
widths of the measured psfs were almost consistent with those expected from the optical simulation . in orbit ,
the system psfs including the telescope system are constructed from observations of bright point sources .
the psfs are similar to the laboratory measurements . as shown in fig.[fig : fis_psf ] , the psfs conform to the estimations from the optical model at more than the half maximum of the peak .
the full widths at the half maximum of the psfs , derived from gaussian fitting , are summarized in table [ tab : performance ] . at the tails of the psfs
, there are significant enhancements , whose power is about 30% of the total power .
this extended halo is a cause for the degradation of source detection . in the spectrometer mode ,
the psfs are evaluated by slow scan observations of the point sources with the spectrometer optics , and are about @xmath13 wider than in the photometer mode .
it is , however , possible to take spectra for each pixel and images with nearly one arc minute spatial resolution , simultaneously .
an additional factor degrades the imaging quality of the sw detector , namely , considerable cross talk between pixels in both axes of the arrays .
one possibility to explain this phenomenon is that the incident far - infrared photons diffuse into the monolithic ge : ga array during multiple reflection on the front and back surfaces of the detector substrate .
furthermore , both the sw and the lw detectors show significant ghost signals .
the reason for the ghost is , presumably , electrical cross talk in the multiplexer of the cryogenic readout electronics . in this case
, the ghost appears in other arrays of the same detector .
the images of the asteroid _ ceres _ observed by fis01 are shown in fig.[fig : fis_ghost ] , as an example . to enhance the effect of the cross talk , the color level has been adjusted . since the position and strength of the cross talk are stable , it should be possible to remove it from the original .
another possible degradation of the image quality comes from the detector s transient response . for pointed observations ,
the detector scans a source , both forward and backward on the same pixel .
the effect of transient response has been evaluated for each observation , and is not significant for slow scan observations .
the readout method for the fis detectors is based on a capacitive trans - impedance amplifier ( ctia ) using newly developed cryogenic devices @xcite .
although the ctia has a wide dynamic range , the linearity is rather poor , and the effective bias on the detectors drifts . in laboratory measurements ,
the relation between the output signal and the amount of the stored charge was well calibrated , and the relation is confirmed in orbit .
therefore , the photo current can be accurately reproduced from the output signal .
charged particle hits are another important influence on detector performance .
about once a minute , charged particles hit a pixel , and in some cases , the responsivity drifts for between several seconds and several minutes . near the south atlantic anomaly ( saa )
, the hit rate of charged particles is too high to observe the sky signal . after passing the saa region ,
the detector responsivity increases significantly and relaxes gradually with a decay on the order of hours . to cure the effect of the saa ,
bias boosting is applied just after passing through the saa . by increasing the bias voltage to breakdown for a short time
, the detector responsivity quickly relaxes to a stable level . finally , the pixel - to - pixel variations of the detector responsivity are shown in fig.[fig : fis_flat_field ] , which are the relative detector signals in the observation of flat sky .
the unevenness of the detector responsivity could come from the non - uniformity of the effective detector bias , due to the offset of the readout electronics .
this is particularly an issue for the lw detector , because of its small bias voltage .
in addition , due to variations of the spectral response for each pixel in the lw detector , it has poor flatness as compared to the sw detector . for absolute calibration ,
several kinds of astronomical sources are used well - modeled objects such as asteroids , planets , stars and galaxies , as well as the spectra of bright ir cirrus or interplanetary dust emission . to calibrate the absolute flux from point like sources
, the aperture photometry procedure must be defined , and then applied to the observations of asteroids , stars and galaxies with a wide range of fluxes .
the relation between the signal and the source flux for several sources has a good linear correlation as shown in fig.[fig : abs_flux_cal ] .
the uncertainties of the current signal to flux calibration are no more than 20% for the n60 and wide - s bands , and 30% and 40% for the wide - l and n160 , respectively .
our goal is to reach an absolute calibration accuracy of about 10% in all bands .
we will achieve this by mitigation of various image artifacts described in this paper , and through analyses of many repeated observations of our network of well - known calibration sources , that are performed continually . comparing the signals of the sky brightness measured by fis and dirbe on cobe , which provide a well calibrated infrared sky map ,
we can obtain the absolute calibration for sky brightness .
the observations of bright ir cirrus regions with no significant small scale structure are compared with values measured by dirbe to make an absolute calibration .
the resulting calibration , however , disagrees with the calibration derived from the point like sources by a factor of about two .
the absolute calibration for diffuse sources still has a large uncertainty due to the difficulty of baseline estimation .
furthermore , the contribution of detector transient response differs between the two calibration methods . according to the absolute calibration derived from the compact sources ,
the nominal detection limits evaluated from the signal - to - noise ratio of the detected sources are listed in table [ tab : performance ] .
the performance of the pointed observation is demonstrated by @xcite .
all the spectrometer functions work as they did in the laboratory . after tuning the control sequence of the movable mirror , interferograms of the internal blackbody source and sky were measured .
the fourier transformed spectra of the internal blackbody source are consistent with that taken in the laboratory , within a 10% error after scaling the responsivity , which means that the laboratory optical performance is reproduced in space . the data reduction to reproduce source spectra is difficult because the interferogram is distorted by the detector transient response as described above .
furthermore , a channel fringe in the interferogram also causes complications . through observations of well - known bright sources ,
line sensitivity and reproducibility of spectra were evaluated .
the fts system performance is almost same as the estimates from the laboratory measurements .
the line spectrum observed by the fts is shown in the fig.[fig : fts_line ] as an example .
the spectral resolution of the fts in full resolution mode is about 0.19 @xmath9 , which agrees well with the expected value of 0.185 @xmath9 .
interim detection limits of the fts derived for on - source pixels from observations of bright sources are roughly 20 jy , 50 jy and 100 jy for continuum spectra in wavenumber of @xmath14 @xmath9 , @xmath15 @xmath9 and @xmath16 @xmath9 , respectively , and , @xmath17 @xmath18 and @xmath19 @xmath18 for line emissions of [ cii](158 @xmath0 ) and [ oiii](88 @xmath0 ) , respectively , which are @xmath20 values for one - pointed observation . fis strives to provide an improved version of the all - sky survey performed by iras more than two decades ago .
the spectral coverage of fis is extended to longer wavelength by the wide - l and n160 bands , which cover up to 180 @xmath0 .
the longer wavelength coverage allows determination of the contribution of cold dust components , which perform important roles in the interaction of the interstellar medium and radiation field .
the advantage of longer wavelength capability has been demonstrated by the isophot serendipity survey ( isoss ) of iso @xcite .
although the sky coverage of isoss is about @xmath21 of the whole sky , the isoss 170 @xmath0 sky atlas is utilized in variety of fields , especially , related to galaxies and cold galactic sources .
this precursor survey indicates the benefit of the longer wavelength bands in the fis all - sky survey .
the high spatial resolution of the fis all - sky survey is a great advantage for source detection and detailed mapping .
as shown in above , the spatial resolution of the fis , which is about 0.7 acrmin for the n60 and wide - s bands , and about 1 arcmin for the wide - l and n160 bands , is more than five times better than iras even in the longer wavelength bands .
the higher spatial resolution comes from the progress of detector technology , although the 60 cm diameter telescope of iras is comparable with the akari telescope @xcite .
these advantages of the fis all - sky survey are demonstrated by @xcite and @xcite .
the point source flux levels at signal - to - noise ratio of five for one scan are listed in table [ tab : performance ] .
we processed the observed data using the preliminary version of the data - processing pipeline for the all - sky survey data .
we estimated the system sensitivity based on a series of observations of asteroids as calibration sources in the all - sky survey .
we used sussextractor , which is a point source extraction and photometry software dedicated for the akari all - sky survey @xcite , to make the photometry of the asteroids .
we derived noise levels by observing dark areas of the sky .
the estimated flux levels are significantly degraded from the detection limits estimated prior to the launch ( see table 3 in @xcite ) .
we found several causes for the degradation .
firstly , we observed several types of excess noise in orbit .
the current version of the pipeline successfully removed the effects of some types of noises .
secondly , we also observe the response to point sources is smaller than we expected .
this is partly due to the psfs described above , and partly due to the detector ac response .
thirdly , we reduced the bias voltage for wide - l and n160 in orbit to stabilize the behaviour of detectors after irradiation of high - energy particles .
furthermore , the actual source detection is degraded by various effects , e.g. frequent glitches due to high energy particles and low - frequency baseline fluctuation due to the change of the detector responsivity , in the data reduction process .
the potential performance of 90 @xmath0 band ( wide - s ) , however , is higher than that of the iras 100@xmath0 band .
unfortunately , the detection limits of the lw detector , which provides new wavelength bands , are also degraded .
the potential performance of the longer wavelength bands is comparable to or better than the isoss .
the galaxy list of isoss has a 170 @xmath0 completeness limit of about 2 jy @xcite , and is useful for a cross calibration of the all - sky survey .
the performance of the all - sky survey evaluated from an initial mini - survey will be discussed by @xcite .
the performance of the detailed observations using the pointing observation mode should be compared with the recent instrument mips on sst .
mips has advantages in spatial resolution and sensitivity , as a result of its larger telescope , small pixel scales , and long exposure capability .
the advantage of fis is that it has four photometric bands between 50 and 180 @xmath0 , whereas mips has only two bands ( 70 @xmath0 and 160 @xmath0 ) in the corresponding wavelength range .
multi - band photometry with fis is effective for determining a spectral energy distribution @xcite .
the performance of the slow scan observation is demonstrated by @xcite , who reported the detection limit at 90 @xmath0 ( wide - s ) achieves 26 mjy ( 3@xmath22 ) using the observations at the lockman hole . in the paper , they discuss about the source counts , and point out that the number of sources detected at 90 @xmath0 is significantly smaller at the faint end compared to the expected values from the model , which explains the mips source counts well .
this implies that fis is a complementary instrument to mips in the sed coverage . in the main observation phase , the low cirrus region near the south ecliptic pole ( sep )
is observed by fis intensively with almost the same sensitivity at the lockman hole for about 10 square degrees @xcite .
the deep survey near the sep will become a legacy survey of fis for extragalactic studies . the spectroscopic capability in the far - infrared region is a unique feature of fis in contrast to mips .
previously , lws on iso was available for far - infrared spectroscopy .
the wavelength coverage and the spectral resolution of lws in the grating mode are comparable with the fis spectrometer .
the sensitivity of fis in the spectrometer mode is not so excellent as mention above .
however , the spectrometer of fis has the advantage of high observational efficiency .
since it is an imaging fts , fis can take spectra with arcminute spatial resolution .
for example , fis could map the m82 galaxy with spectra in several pointed observations , which correspond to about one hour exposure time .
furthermore , the spectroscopic serendipity survey by parallel observations is expected to provide a unique dataset .
the far - infrared surveyor was designed to survey the far - infrared region with four photometric bands within 50 180 @xmath0 , with high spatial resolution and sensitivity .
additionally , a spectroscopic capability was installed as an imaging fourier transform spectrometer .
all functions of fis work very well in orbit .
fis performance is demonstrated in the initial papers of this volume .
the all - sky survey is performed continuously and should provide a new generation all - sky catalog in the far - infrared .
in addition to the all - sky survey , a large area deep survey ( @xmath23 square degrees ) near the south ecliptic pole and many scientific programs are being executed . to bring out the potential of the fis instrument ,
the data processing methods are continuously being improved . since
calibration data are accumulated constantly by the end of the mission life , the fis data quality should be substantially better than that listed here .
the akari project , previously named astro - f , is managed and operated by the institute of space and astronautical science ( isas ) of japan aerospace exploration agency ( jaxa ) in collaboration with the groups in universities and research institutes in japan , the european space agency , and korean group .
we thank all the members of the akari / astro - f project for their continuous help and support .
fis was developed in collaboration with isas , nagoya university , university of tokyo , national institute of information and communications technology ( nict ) , national astronomical observatory of japan ( naoj ) , and other research institutes .
the akari / fis all - sky survey data are processed by the international team which consists of members from the iosg ( imprerial college , uk , open university , uk , university of sussex , uk , and university of groningen , netherlands ) consortium , seoul national university , korea , and the japanese akari team .
the pointing reconstruction for the all - sky survey mode is performed by the pointing reconstruction team at european space astronomy center ( esac ) .
we thank all the members related to fis for their intensive efforts toward creating new frontier .
m. cohen s contribution to this paper was partially supported by a grant from the american astronomical society .
we would like to express thanks to dr .
raphael moreno for providing flux models of giant planets .
doi y. , et al .
, 2002 , adv . in space research , 30 , 2099 doi y. , et al . , 2007 , , 00 , 000 fujiwara m. , hirao t. , kawada m. , shibai h. , matsuura s. , kaneda h. , patrashin m.a . , & nakagawa t. , 2003 , , 42 , 2166 jeong w - s . , et al . , 2007 , , 00 , 000 kaneda h. , kim w. , onaka t. , wada t. ira y. , sakon i. , & takagi t. , 2007a , , 00 , 000 kaneda h. , et al .
, 2007b , , 00 , 000 kessler m.f . , et al . 1996 , , 315 , l27 martin d.h . , & puplett e. , 1969 , infrared phys . , 10 , 105 matsuhara , h. , et al
, 2006 , , 58 , 673 matsuura , s. , et al .
, 2007 , , 00 , 000 murakami h. , et al . 2007 , , 00 , 000 nagata h. , shibai h. , hirao t. , watabe t. , noda m. , hibi y. , kawada m. , & nakagawa t. , 2004 , ieee trans .
devices , 51 , 270 nakagawa t. , et al . , 2007 , , 00 , 0000 onaka t. , et al . 2007 , , 00 , 000 savage r. , et al . 2007 in preparation shibai h. , 2007a , adv . in space research , accepted for publication shibai h. , 2007b , in preparation stickel , m. , klaas , u. , and lemke , d. , 2007a , , 466 , 831 stickel , m. , krause , o. , klaas , u. , and lemke , d. , 2007b , , 466 , 1205 suzuki t. , kaneda h. , nakagawa t. , makiuti s. , doi y. , & shibai h. , 2007 , , 00 , 000 werner m.w . ,
2004 , , 154 , 1 lccc & * fis01 * & * fis02 * & * fis03 * + observation mode & & pointing + observation target & compact source & area mapping & spectroscopy + + - target position & & source + - reset interval & & [ 0.1 s , 0.25 s , 0.5 s , 1.0 s , ( 2.0 s ) ] + - parameter 1 & & spectral resolution + & & [ full res . , sed ] + - parameter 2 & shift size & - & array selection + & [ 70 `` , 240 '' ] & - & [ mod , sw , lw ] + amount of data & & 49.8 mb + + lccccl & * n60 * & * wide - s * & * wide - l * & * n160 * & + band center & @xmath24 & @xmath25 & @xmath26 & @xmath27 & [ @xmath0 ] + effective band width & @xmath29 & @xmath30 & @xmath31 & @xmath32 & [ @xmath0 ] + pixel scale & 26.8 & 26.8 & 44.2 & 44.2 & [ arcsec ] + pixel pitch & 29.5 & 29.5 & 49.1 & 49.1 & [ arcsec ] + + - measured fwhm & 37 @xmath33 1 & 39 @xmath33 1 & 58 @xmath33 3 & 61 @xmath33 4 & [ arcsec ] + + - variation & 19% & 14% & 43% & 53% & + + - survey mode & 2.4 & 0.55 & 1.4 & 6.3 & [ jy ] + - pointing mode & 110 & 34 & 350 & 1350 & [ mjy ] + + | the far - infrared surveyor ( fis ) is one of two focal plane instruments on the akari satellite .
fis has four photometric bands at 65 , 90 , 140 , and 160 @xmath0 , and uses two kinds of array detectors .
the fis arrays and optics are designed to sweep the sky with high spatial resolution and redundancy .
the actual scan width is more than eight arcmin , and the pixel pitch is matches the diffraction limit of the telescope .
derived point spread functions ( psfs ) from observations of asteroids are similar to the optical model .
significant excesses , however , are clearly seen around tails of the psfs , whose contributions are about 30% of the total power .
all fis functions are operating well in orbit , and its performance meets the laboratory characterizations , except for the two longer wavelength bands , which are not performing as well as characterized .
furthermore , the fis has a spectroscopic capability using a fourier transform spectrometer ( fts ) .
because the fts takes advantage of the optics and detectors of the photometer , it can simultaneously make a spectral map .
this paper summarizes the in - flight technical and operational performance of the fis . |
the seminal paper by @xcite opened a new frontier for understanding star formation in the universe . in the two decades since their discovery of co emission from ultraluminous infrared galaxy ( ulirg ) iras f10214 + 4724
, the field of detecting and characterizing the star forming interstellar medium ( ism ) has seen an explosion of activity . indeed , great progress has been made .
thanks to pioneering efforts on older facilities , as well as upgrades to cm / mm - wave telescopes , the detection of co through 6 has now become routine ( see , for example , the contribution by riechers in this volume ) .
similarly , the development of novel galaxy selection techniques in the optical , infrared and submillimeter has allowed for the discovery of copious numbers of star forming galaxies in the early universe .
the flood of new data has opened up a variety of questions regarding the nature of star formation in these galaxies , and , at times , presented a somewhat confusing picture .
for example , submillimeter - selected galaxies ( smg ; galaxies selected for @xmath3 mjy ) are the brightest unlensed galaxies in the universe ; whether or not they have local analogs is unclear .
naively , one might appeal to the argument that , since locally the brightest galaxies are all galaxy mergers , these might be as well .
indeed , some observations have provided clear evidence for this ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . on the other hand
, high - resolution co imaging of some smgs has shown unambiguous existence of rotating molecular disks @xcite .
it is not at all clear that local starbursts are direct analogs of those seen at high- .
similarly , open questions remain regarding how to relate the physics of star formation in high- galaxies to what is seen locally . as an example ,
observations of co ( as a tracer for molecular ) of both disk - like systems at 2 as well as galaxy mergers has suggested a potential bimodality in the normalization of the @xmath4 kennicutt - schmidt ( ks ) star formation relation . in this picture ,
mergers at both present epoch and high- form stars in a different `` mode '' than in normal , quiescent galaxies such that the timescale for star formation is much shorter in mergers .
this result is of course sensitive to the applicability of locally - calibrated co- conversion factors - factor in the literature .
these are equivalent definitions , and will be described in [ section : xco ] . ] to high- galaxies . in the same vein ,
even understanding the baryonic makeup of high- galaxies is not straightforward .
it is clear , for example , that galaxies at a given stellar mass form stars at higher rates at 2 than they do at = 0 @xcite . at face value ,
the likely explanation for this is the observed increased gas fractions ( defined as @xmath5 ) ) at high- relative to local systems ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
on average , however , the measured gas fractions are a factor 2 - 3 larger at 2 than is predicted by most cosmological galaxy growth models @xcite , suggesting a more dramatic increase of gas fraction with redshift than is predicted by models . in this contribution
, i will present the results of modeling efforts by myself and collaborators that aim to address many of these issues . while the space allocations for this proceeding were indeed generous , it is unlikely that i will be able to fully discuss the details of the presented work .
i encourage the interested reader to refer to the cited papers in each section for more details , and certainly welcome emails with questions as well .
submillimeter galaxies were originally detected in blind surveys by the james clerk maxwell telescope ( jcmt ) at 850 .
subsequent multi - wavelength followup observations showed that these galaxies reside principally between = 2 - 4 , and are among the most luminous , heavily star - forming galaxies in the universe ( for a review , see * ? ? ? * ) .
as described in [ section : intro ] , however , uncovering their physical origin has been difficult . .
the black solid line is the total for all smgs , while the subpopulations ( isolated disks , galaxy pairs and merger - driven starbursts ) are denoted with alternate lines and colors that are explained in the legend .
observed data is shown with symbols .
the hatched area shows where lensing is likely to boost the observed counts .
the figure is adapted from @xcite , and we refer the reader there for more details.[figure : smgnumbercounts ] ] we can get some intuitive guidance from the seminal review published by @xcite . as is clear from their appendix 2 , smgs at 2 have exceptionally large line widths , with median values ranging from @xmath6 . converting these line widths to simple dynamical masses results in galaxy stellar masses of order @xmath7 (
which is consistent with direct measurements by @xcite , though may be higher in some cases than measurements by @xcite ) .
we can now ask whether smgs are solely represented by major galaxy mergers ( with mass ratios @xmath8 1:3 ) . the dimensionless merger rate at this mass is approximately 1 per hubble time at 2 @xcite . even if the duty cycle for the submillimeter luminous phase is as long as @xmath9 years ( which is a substantial time for a merger - driven burst * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , the predicted counts would still be a factor @xmath10 less than their observed space densities @xcite .
it is clear that the full population of smgs can not be accounted for by major mergers alone . on the other extreme
, smgs can not be solely represented by isolated disk galaxies at these redshifts . @xcite
and @xcite showed that if one combines observed stellar mass functions at 2 - 3 with the observed schmidt relation , and numerically calibrated -sfr relation , that disks may make up the faint end of the observed smg number counts , but will fail catastrophically toward the bright end . instead
, smgs must be a mixed bag of sources , including isolated disk galaxies , galaxy mergers , and pairs of galaxies en route to merging that both contribute to the relatively large jcmt beam at 850 @xcite .
in @xcite , we explicitly examine the contribution of various mechanisms for smg formation to the observed smg number counts . to this end , we run a large suite of galaxy merger simulations over a large range of galaxy masses , and merger mass ratios , as well as isolated disk galaxies with a large range of galaxy masses . we combine these with dust radiative transfer calculations ( utilizing the publicly available dust radiative transfer code , , * ? ? ? * ) in order to explicitly calculate the synthetic submillimeter - wave flux density from our modeled galaxies . in this way
, we can directly compare our models to observations .
missing from the physical ingredients to the model thusfar , however , is a means to simulate a blank field survey . that is , the simulations are idealized and not cosmological . to infer cosmological statistics from our model ( what an observer would measure in a survey that is not limited by cosmic variance ) , we combine the submillimeter duty cycles and expected fluxes from our galaxy mergers and disk galaxies with measured galaxy stellar mass functions and theoretical galaxy merger rates as a function of redshift @xcite .
the full details of this procedure can be found in @xcite .
effectively , what this is doing is to say if i look in a field of a given area , how many galaxies of a given mass will i find , and how many galaxy mergers of a given mass and merger mass ratio are there ?
then , what is the submillimeter flux from galaxies of this mass and/or merger mass ratio ? the advantage of this methodology is that we are able to maintain relatively high spatial resolution ( compared to standard cosmological hydrodynamic simulations ) , while still inferring cosmological statistics . in @xcite and @xcite , we show that this model for smg galaxy formation provides a reasonable match to the observed spectral energy distributions ( seds ) , co line widths , excitation patterns , and connection with 24 sources . in figure [
figure : smgnumbercounts ] , i present the cumulative synthetic number counts at 1 mm from our model for smg formation ( presented originally in * ? ? ?
* ) , and overlay data from a number of recent surveys .
we compare at 1 mm rather than 850 since , as of the time of writing , the deepest and widest surveys have all been conducted at 1 mm .
the solid black line shows the total number counts predicted from our model , while the other lines denote the various contributors to the counts ( e.g. isolated disks , major mergers , and galaxy pairs ) . by and large , at low flux densities , disks tend to dominate , while at the bright end major merger play a significant role . at intermediate flux densities
, galaxy pairs can be an important constituent to the observed number counts . at the time of this writing , alma cycle 0 and cycle 1 observations are already examining samples of 2 submillimeter galaxies , and will provide an important observational test of this model .
already , an attractive aspect to this model is that it is able to provide an explanation for the observed menagerie of sources that appear to comprise smgs ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
we now take a brief diversion for this section to develop a model for the co- conversion factor in galaxies . this will be important when trying to then interpret the observed star formation law for starburst galaxies , as well as infer their baryonic gas fractions .
the full model that i summarize here is developed in @xcite and @xcite .
owing to the relative difficulty in exciting , @xmath11co ( as the second - most abundant molecule in the ism ) is typically used as a tracer of molecular gas .
observational calibrations of the conversion factor have come from a variety of methods , and are summarized nicely in bolatto s contribution in this volume .
the conversion factor can be defined either as @xmath12 , or @xmath13 .
the two are equivalent , and are related dimensionally via @xmath14 .
we will present the results here in terms of either .
largely , observations have found three main trends : ( 1 ) appears to have a remarkably narrow range of observed values in the galaxy , and nearby galaxies ( with the exception of both the galactic center and the smc ) ; ( 2 ) increases with decreasing gas phase metallicity ; ( 3 ) in heavily star - forming systems ( such as in nearby ulirgs ) , appears to be depressed from the mean galactic value by an average value of @xmath15 @xcite . for the purposes of starburst galaxies ,
the community has typically treated the conversion factor as bimodal : a mean galactic value for disks and quiescent galaxies , and a value @xmath16 times lower for starbursts and mergers .
locally , on average , for some time this has been a fine approximation , and indeed was motivated by observations @xcite .
however , as evermore sensitive and high - resolution observations began to probe high - redshift galaxies , the applicability of a bimodal @xmath17-factor has come into question .
for example , which of the bimodal values should one use for an early - coalescence merger ?
what about a minor merger ?
for high- disks , which can form stars at rates comparable to low- mergers , should one use the locally - calibrated merger value , or mean milky way value ?
a substantial amount of observational and theoretical work has been invested in this field , and
i refer the reader to the forthcoming bolatto et al .
review for a summary .
here , i concentrate principally on our own group s efforts in this field . in @xcite and @xcite
, we utilized a large suite of galaxy evolution simulations , similar to those explored in
[ section : smg ] , though with a large fraction of galaxies with virial properties scaled for = 0 as well .
the primary reason for the galaxy evolution simulations was to develop a large library of models that span a large dynamic range of physical conditions in the ism .
the neutral gas was treated as multiphase , with the -hi balance determined by the balance of photodissocation of by lyman - werner band photons against the growth rate on dust grains @xcite .
the fraction of carbon locked in co was determined following the model of @xcite , and the c/ abundance was set at @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is the metallicity scaled to solar .
the temperature of the ism was determined by a balance of the dominant heating processes ( grain photoelectric effect , cosmic ray heating ) , cooling processes ( cii or co line cooling ) , and energy exchange between gas and dust at high densities @xcite . in short , at low densities ,
the temperature of the gas is typically @xmath10 k owing to cosmic rays and the photoelectric effect dominating the temperature of the ism . at higher densities ( @xmath20 )
, thermal coupling between gas and dust begins to become quite important , and the temperature of the gas can rise toward the dust tempearture . is the gas column density divided by @xmath21 , the velocity - integrated line intensity . because the ground state of co ( the j=1 - 0 transition ) is typically in local thermodynamic equilibrium ( lte ) , and optically thick , @xmath21 increases with both gas kinetic temperature , as well as the velocity dispersion
in a galaxy merger or starburst environment , typically both increase dramatically .
the former owes to increased dust temperatures in the high radiation field typical of a starburst ( as well as the efficient energy exchange between gas and dust in dense environments ) , while the latter simply reflects the increased turbulence in the ism characteristic of a galaxy merger .
the column density of the gas of course increases with the star formation rate , but the combination of the temperature increase and velocity dispersion increase generally overwhelm this , and drive downward in heavily star - forming environments .
is also dependent on the metallicity of the gas . beyond c and o abundances depending on the metallicity ,
co typically requires columns of @xmath22 to survive from photodissociating radiation ( whereas can self - shield at much lower columns , * ? ? ?
as a result , in low metallicity gas , there can be `` co dark '' clouds that are abundant in , but lacking in co. in this case , will be elevated from the mean galactic value @xcite .
we can utilize the numerical simulations to derive a functional form for the @xmath17-factor as a function of observable properties of the ism .
as discussed , principally depends on the temperature , velocity dispersion , and gas phase metallicity .
the gas column density typically rises with the temperature and velocity dispersion , though more slowly than their product . as an observable ,
the velocity integrated co intensity serves as a reasonably good proxy for the gas temperature and velocity dispersion .
we perform a 2d levenberg - marquardt fit on our library of simulations to arrive at the relation : @xmath23 \times 10^{20}}{z'^{0.65}}\ ] ] where @xmath24 is the co intensity , and @xmath19 is the metallicity with respect to solar .
formally , @xmath25 is the luminosity weighted co intensity from all the gmcs in a given galaxy . in the limit of a relatively large volume filling factor for the ism , however , this simply reduces to @xmath26 , where @xmath27 is the co luminosity ( k -- pc@xmath28 ) , and @xmath29 is the area .
the minimum in the function is in place as a recognition that equation [ eq : xco ] can not increase indefinitely with decreasing @xmath21 .
eventually , gmcs tend toward fixed properties , and will plateau so long as the metallicity does not vary . equation [ eq : xco ] , in principle , can be used to directly determine the co- conversion factor from a galaxy with two observables : the co surface brightness and the gas phase metallicity .
this suggests that has a continuum of values that varies with the physical properties of the ism .
intuitively , this makes sense .
abundances vary with the physical conditions in a galaxy , as do co emission line strengths .
only a rather strong conspiracy would allow for constant or bimodal values of .
indeed , some observational constraints have provided some support for this model @xcite . in the subsequent sections ,
i discuss two potential applications for this functional form of the conversion factor .
the kennicutt - schmidt star formation relation is a natural application for the presented functional form for .
moreover , without having to rely on a bimodal @xmath17-factor , we can avoid some of the sticky questions related to which conversion factor to use for a given galaxy population , and can begin to understand how high- galaxies compare to local ones in terms of their sfr surface density - gas surface density relation . for local disks ,
3.6 for high- disks , and 0.8 for mergers ) , the resulting sfr relation is bimodal .
the solid and dotted lines overplotted are the best fit tracks for each `` mode '' of star formation as in @xcite .
_ right _ : sfr relation when applying equation [ eq : xco ] to the observational data , resulting in a unimodal sfr relation .
the power - law index in the relation is approximately 2 ( solid line ) . _
symbol legend _ : we divide galaxies into disc - like with filled circles , and merger - like with squares .
this assumes that high- galaxies are all disks , high- smgs and low- ulirgs are all mergers , though c.f .
[ section : smg ] . ] in figure [ figure : ks ] , i plot the kennicutt - schmidt star formation relation for resolved - regions in local galaxies , global measurements for local disks and ulirgs , high- disks and high- starbursts .
we plot the @xmath30-@xmath21 relation for these systems on the left , the @xmath31 relation assuming a bimodal .
we do this so as to remain consistent with assumptions typically made in the literature , though we note that this further underscores the motivation for deriving a functional form for , rather than relying on identifying galaxies as disks or mergers. ] @xmath17-factor in the middle , and the same relation utilizing our functional form for ( equation [ eq : xco ] ) in the right panel .
we assume a solar metallicity for each galaxy .
this figure was first presented in @xcite , and i refer the interested reader there for further details . as is clear , the application of a smoothly varying functional form for has significant impact on the interpretation of the kennicutt - schmidt star formation relation .
when utilizing the traditional bimodal @xmath17-factor ( the mean galactic value for disks at low and high , and a value a factor @xmath16 lower for mergers ) , a bimodal schmidt relation results @xcite .
this is shown in the middle panel of figure [ figure : ks ] .
the interpretation of this is that mergers and disks have different modes of star formation , with mergers inherently forming stars more efficiently ( that is , on a shorter timescale ) . when utilizing equation [ eq : xco ] for instead , we recover a unimodal star formation law ( right panel of figure [ figure : ks ] ) with best fit relation @xmath32 .
this has numerous implications for our understanding of high- star formation .
first , in this picture , there is no fundamental difference between disk galaxies and galaxy mergers .
this is most telling when comparing the black squares ( which represent local ulirgs ) and blue circles ( which represent heavily star - forming high- disks ) .
some moderate low- ulirgs have values intermediate between the canonical `` ulirg value '' and `` disk value '' , as do some heavily star - forming high- disks .
i show this more quantitatively in figure [ figure : xco_hist ] where i plot the distribution of derived values for all the galaxies in figure [ figure : xco_hist ] . while there are clear trends such that disks have larger values than mergers on average ,
there is substantial distribution among the more heavily star - forming galaxies .
high- disks can have values ranging from the mean milky way value to values representative of 0 ulirgs .
low- ulirgs on average have lower @xmath17-factors , though there is a tail toward larger values .
there is some tentative observational evidence for all of these trends in surveys of both high- disks , as well as low- ulirgs ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the index of 2 in the inferred @xmath4 power - law when utilizing our derived model for may be telling about the underlying physics that regulates the star formation rate in heavily star - forming systems . @xcite and @xcite present a model
in which , if supernova - driven turbulence controls the sfr and gas dominates the vertical gravity , the sfr surface density will scale with the gas surface density as a quadratic , similar to the derived relation in the right panel of figure [ figure : ks ] .
this sort of scenario is aimed at describing sfrs in starburst systems .
i note that a simple fit to the ks relation at a transition molecular gas surface density of @xmath33pc@xmath34 for the data in the right panel of figure [ figure : ks ] results in a roughly linear relation for galaxies with @xmath35 pc@xmath34 , and exponent @xmath2 for galaxies above this threshold .
this is the surface density above which gmcs are potentially no longer regulated by internal processes @xcite , and global galactic processes may be significant in dictating the structure of the ism .
.[figure : xco_hist ] ]
against stellar mass ( @xmath36 ) for disks and mergers at high- .
the blue filled circles are observed high- disks ; the red open squares are observed smgs ( assumed to be mergers ) , and the purple filled circles are optically faint radio galaxies ( which are of unknown physical form ) .
the black stars show results from main - sequence galaxies from the cosmological hydrodynamic simulations of @xcite , with dispersion noted by the error bars .
the top panels show the results when utilising the @xcite stellar masses , and the bottom panels when utilising the @xcite masses ( which are larger by a factor of a few ) .
the left panels show the @xmath37-@xmath38 relation when utilising the traditional locally - calibrated literature values , and right panel shows the effect of our model .
[ figure : fgas ] ] with a model for the formation of high- starburst galaxies , as well as the co- conversion factor in galaxies , we are now in a position to understand the baryonic gas fractions of high- galaxies . as shown in recent surveys by @xcite and @xcite , among others , the gas fractions of 2 galaxies ( ranging from 2 disks to smgs ) are larger than the @xmath39 seen in the local universe .
gas fractions ranging from @xmath40 have been observed .
similarly , most cosmological galaxy formation models suggest that galaxies at high redshift should have higher gas fractions than those today . while the sfrs ( i.e. gas consumption rates ) are on average larger , so is the gas accretion rate from the igm ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* as well as the contribution to these proceedings by lagos ) .
a generic feature of these simulations is that the gas fractions of galaxies should decrease monotonically with increasing galaxy sfr , a trend that has been observed in high- galaxies @xcite .
however , there is a tension between observations and simulations such that the observed gas fractions of high- galaxies are all a factor @xmath41 larger at a given stellar mass than those in models .
this is difficult to reconcile .
the gas accretion rate in simulations is principally determined by gravity .
so , unless the star formation rates in simulations were substantially reduced , it would be difficult to bring the gas fractions into agreement .
there is not much wiggle room , however .
the sfrs in simulated galaxies already lie below those observed ( that is , the simulated main sequence of galaxies is lower in normalization than what is observed at 2 ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
so , bringing the gas fractions into agreement via a decrease in the simulated sfrs would only serve to further exacerbate this issue .
one possibility is that the inferred gas masses from high- galaxies are systematically too large based on the usage of locally - calibrated co- conversion factors . as is clear from figure [ figure : xco_hist ] ,
the average @xmath17-factor of star - forming disks at 2 is a factor @xmath41 lower than the mean milky way value . since mean galactic values of
are typically applied to high- disks , this is one potential solution to the discrepancy between observed gas fractions at high- and simulated ones . in figure [
figure : fgas ] , i show the effect of applying our functional form of ( which is a smoothly varying conversion factor that depends on the physical conditions in the galaxy ) to the inferred gas fractions of 2 disks and starbursts ( as before , denoting disks with circles , and starbursts with squares ) .
i plot in terms of two different stellar mass measurements for the high- smgs as there is a significant debate in the literature as to the precise values of these masses which can differ by a factor @xmath42 .
this figure was first presented in @xcite .
the top row utilizes the @xcite stellar masses for high- smgs ( the open red squares ) , while the bottom row utilizes the @xcite masses .
the black stars denote the median gas fractions ( binned by stellar mass ) from the cosmological simulations of @xcite .
the effect of using our model for is qualitatively the same in both cases . while the inferred gas fractions are systematically larger than what is predicted from cosmological simulations when using the canonical values for @xmath17-factors , our functional form brings them into significantly better agreement .
moreover , the scatter is reduced by a factor @xmath2 . again , this owes to lower co- conversion factors in high - redshift disk galaxies that have warm , high - velocity dispersion molecular gas that is marginally unbound .
we have presented a model aimed at understanding the star formation properties of some of the more enigmatic star forming galaxies in the universe , the high - redshift submillimeter galaxy population .
one of the principle results of this work is a placement of high - redshift starburst galaxies on the @xmath31 kennicutt - schmidt star formation law . to do this required ( i ) a formation model for high- submillimeter galaxies and ( ii ) a model for the co- conversion factor in order to convert the observed co line emission from these galaxies into an gas mass .
we find that submillimeter galaxies are a mixed bag of sources , comprised of ( heavily star - forming ) isolated disk galaxies at the faint end , merger - driven starbursts at the bright end , and galaxy pairs contributing heavily to the intermediate flux density regime .
this model is able to reasonably reproduce the observed number counts , co properties , and uv - mm wave sed .
we combine this with a model for the co- conversion factor in galaxies that describes the smooth evolution of the conversion factor with the physical properties in galaxies .
the dominant physical drivers in the @xmath17-factor in our model are the gas kinetic temperature , velocity dispersion and metallicity .
we derive a functional form for the conversion factor in terms of observables : the gas phase metallicity and the co surface brightness .
we then apply these models to literature observations of both local and high- galaxies .
we find that galaxies from = 0 - 2 lie on a unimodal star formation law , with best fit power - law index ( over the entire dynamic range of observations ) of @xmath2 .
similarly , we find that the usage of our model form for implies large gas fractions for 2 galaxies ( @xmath43 ) though a factor @xmath0 lower than what would be inferred with locally - calibrated co- conversion factors . i am very much appreciative to the conference organizers for inviting me to this exciting meeting .
it was an honor giving a review talk at a meeting dedicated to the work of paul vanden bout , who has contributed so much to this field .
much of this research was done in very fun collaborations with chris hayward , mark krumholz , eve ostriker , lars hernquist , and romeel dav .
finally , thanks to the nsf for funding this work via grant ast-1009452 . c. c. , narayanan d. , jonsson p. , cox t. j. , kere d. , hopkins p. f. , hernquist l. , 2010 , conference proceedings for up2010 :
have observations revealed a variable upper end of the initial mass function ?
treyer , lee , seibert , wyder , neil eds . | i present a model for the star formation properties of 2 starburst galaxies . here , i discuss models for the formation of high- submillimeter galaxies , as well as the co- conversion factor for these systems .
i then apply these models to literature observations .
i show that when using a functional form for that varies smoothly with the physical properties in galaxies , galaxies at both local and high- lie on a unimodal kennicutt - schmidt star formation law , with power - law index of @xmath0 .
the inferred gas fractions of these galaxies are large ( @xmath1 ) , though a factor @xmath2 lower than most literature estimates that utilize locally - calibrated co- conversion factors . |
disk galaxies , when observed edge - on , often exhibit a box- or peanut - like structure . since this is confined to the inner parts of the galaxy , and since it extends in the vertical direction outside the disk , this structure has been called a boxy or peanut bulge .
yet there are many ways in which it differs from ordinary bulges .
the b / p structures have their maximum thickness not at the center of the galaxy , like in usual @xmath2 spheroids , but ` at two points symmetrically spaced on either side of the center ' @xcite .
another difference from @xmath2-bulges and ellipticals is that b / p structures rotate ` cylindrically ' , i.e. their observed rotation is independent of the height above the plane , which bulges and ellipticals do not ( e.g. kormendy & illingworth 1982 ) .
there is one more characteristic of b / p features related to their kinematics .
kuijken & merrifield ( 1995 ) and bureau & freeman ( 1999 ) have shown that there are important differences between the position velocity diagrams of b / p structures and those of bulges .
these have been used by bureau & athanassoula ( 1999 ) and athanassoula & bureau ( 1999 ) to develop diagnostics to detect the presence and orientation of a bar in edge - on disk galaxies .
the method relies on the presence of x2 orbits in the bars of the galaxies .
seen these differences , we will avoid calling the b / p features bulges , unless we are refering to particular observations .
recent statistical studies ( l``utticke , dettmar & pohlen 2000a ) using 1350 galaxies from the rc3 , show that 45% of the profiles of edge - on disc galaxies are box- or peanut - shaped .
observational studies ( e.g. bureau & freeman 1999 , l''utticke , dettmar & pohlen 2000b ) associate the b / p structure with the presence of a bar .
l"utticke et al .
( 2000b ) classify the bulges according to their boxiness and conclude that galaxies with a prominent b / p shape have a large bal / bul ratio , where bal is the projected bar length , and bul the bulge length . isolating photometrically the b / p structure from the bulge , they measure the ratio of the projected bar length to the length of the b / p structure ( bal / bpl ) .
unfortunately this is done only for six galaxies , and gives an average value of @xmath3 .
this ratio indicates a structure confined close to the center of the galaxy .
bars and edge - on b / p morphology are linked in all the above mentioned papers , as well as in many others .
however , the percentage of the bar which takes part in the b / p structure , i.e. whether we have a b / p feature on top of the bar , or whether we have a b / p - shaped bar in total , is an open question .
the morphological differences encountered among the various b / p features remains also to be explained . in a few cases ( e.g. ic 4767 , hickson 87a ) an ` x'-shaped structure
is found to be embedded in a boxy structure .
it differs from the usual peanut in that the branches of the ` x ' feature resemble segments of nearly straight lines that give the impression of intersecting each other . on the contrary the classical peanuts have typically much rounder isophotes ( see e.g. shaw 1993 ) and , even in cases where these isophotes come very close to the equatorial plane of the galaxy at the center , the visual impression is better described by the symbol ` ' than by an ` x ' central morphology .
l"utticke , dettmar & pohlen ( 2000c ) , studying a sample of b / p galaxies including cases with ` x ' features , estimated the angle between one branch of the ` x ' and the major axis to be around @xmath4 .
studies of individual galaxies give for this angle values ranging from @xmath5 for ic 4767 @xcite to @xmath6 for ngc 128 @xcite .
pfenniger & friedli ( 1991 ) , taking as an example the case of ic 4767 , claim that this feature is an optical illusion obtained when one uses a particular look - up - table for viewing the image .
this view , however , is not generally shared .
thus mihos , walker , hernquist et al .
( 1995 ) used the process of ` unsharp masking ' to enhance the ` x ' embedded in the bulge of the galaxy hickson 87a in order to compare this morphology with their model . in any case
one can speak about characteristic kinks of the isophotes in edge - on profiles of a few galaxies and of the corresponding isodensities in snapshots of some @xmath7-body simulations @xcite , which are aligned in such a way as to describe an ` x'-shaped feature .
there have been two approaches for explaining edge - on b / p profiles .
the first invokes internal reasons , like disk or orbital instabilities , and the second one external reasons , like encounters with companions , soft merging etc .
combes & sanders ( 1981 ) were the first to reproduce a b / p profile in @xmath7-body simulations of barred galaxies .
such structures were since then found in many other simulations ( e.g. combes , debasch , friedli et al .
1990 ; raha , sellwood , james et al . 1991 ; athanassoula & misiriotis 2002 ) and are now considered a standard development in bar - unstable disc simulations .
pfenniger ( 1984a , 1985 ) associated the b / p morphology with the instability of the x1 family at the 4:1 vertical resonance .
later , combes et al .
( 1990 ) suggested that the b / p shapes are due to the vertical 2:1 resonance , stressing the importance of having @xmath8 .
this mechanism invokes a conjunction of the two resonances , i.e. the radial 2:1 ( radial ilr ) and the vertical 2:1 ( v - ilr ) , and relates it to the appearance of a b / p edge - on morphology .
the 3d families introduced at higher order resonances exist typically over smaller energy intervals and thus are less probable to be populated by orbits to build the box , although in principle they could be used as well .
in such a case of course , they will support a thin morphological feature extending to large distances from the center , i.e. close to corotation .
the 2:1 vertical resonance is proposed as explanation of boxy structures also by pfenniger & friedli ( 1991 ) , who speak about thick b / p bars .
we mention that b / p features have also been found in edge - on profiles of orbital models of _ normal _ spiral galaxies with thick , 3d spirals embedded in discs @xcite .
berentzen , heller , shlosman et al .
( 1998 ) have shown that a peanut shape may disappear when there is substantial gas inflow to the center of the galaxy . building the peanut by accretion of material from satellite galaxies has been proposed initially by binney & petrou ( 1985 ) , while mihos et al .
( 1995 ) describe an encounter which produces the ` x ' feature in the galaxy hickson 87a . however , even in the cases where a companion is involved , the families of orbits that trap the infalling gas have to be studied . in the present paper
we investigate the vertical structure of bars using orbital theory .
we do not construct self - consistent models , but we explore changes that occur when the main parameters of the system vary .
we combine families of periodic orbits found in the models of paper i and in the models of skokos , patsis and athanassoula ( 2002b - hereafter paper ii ) , in order to build b / p features in the edge - on profiles .
we also compare the geometry and the dimensions of the resulting systems with the corresponding features of edge - on galaxies .
speaking about a ` bulge ' in the profiles of our models , we refer to a central enhancement of the density due to 3d orbits in our total potential .
as we will see , the families of orbits we use are mainly 3d bifurcations of the planar x1 orbits , i.e. related to the families of the x1-tree that make the 3d bar in our models .
the layout of this paper is as follows : in section 2 we describe the method we used to construct the vertical profiles of the families in the models and in section 3 and 4 we describe the properties of these profiles and the effect of combining several families together on the morphology of the models . in section 5
we discuss our results and compare them with observations found in the literature , and finally in section 6 we enumerate our conclusions .
our general model consists of a miyamoto disc , a plummer bulge and a ferrers bar . the total mass of the miyamoto disc is @xmath9 , and its horizontal and vertical scalelengths are @xmath10 and @xmath11 respectively .
we have taken in all models @xmath12 and @xmath13 .
the total mass of the plummer bulge is @xmath14 and its scalelength @xmath15 .
the mass of the ferrers bar component is indicated by @xmath16 and its semi - axes by @xmath17 , @xmath18 and @xmath19 , where @xmath20 = @xmath21 .
the masses of the three components satisfy @xmath22 , where @xmath23 is the gravitational constant .
the unit length is taken as 1 kpc , the time unit 1 myr and the mass unit 2@xmath2410@xmath25m@xmath26 .
details can be found in section 3.1 of paper i , while the values of the parameters characterizing each particular model are given in tables in the corresponding sections of the present paper . in papers
i and ii we calculated the families of periodic orbits which are the building blocks of 3d bars .
paper i presents in a fiducial case the x1-tree and the typical orbital behaviour of 3d bars in detail , while paper ii describes the differences observed in the orbital structure when the main parameters of the model vary .
these papers also give the morphology of the orbits of each family .
for the purpose of the present paper we are interested in the edge - on ( side - on and end - on ) structures supported by the families , when one considers them as dynamical blocks . in this section
we review briefly the properties of the main families we will discuss below . throughout the paper the bar major axis lies along the @xmath27 axis and the axis of rotation is the @xmath0 axis . _
x1v1_. in most of the models this is the first stable simple - periodic vertical bifurcation of x1 , i.e. it bifurcates at the lowest energy at which the stability index associated with the vertical perturbations becomes @xmath28 .
it is related to the 2:1 vertical resonance and both its @xmath29 and @xmath30 projections can be described as ` frowns ' ( ` @xmath31 ' ) and ` smiles ' ( ` @xmath32 ' ) .
several papers associate this family with the b / p bulges by combining its two branches which are symmetric with respect to the equatorial plane ( combes et al .
1990 , pfenniger & friedli 1991 ) . in many cases
this family has a complex unstable part close to the energy at which it bifurcates from x1 ( for an extensive description of complex instability in galactic potentials see e.g. zachilas 1993 ) . _
x1v3_. it is the stable 3d bifurcation of the models at the vertical 3:1 resonance .
it is one of the standard building blocks of the 3d bar .
its @xmath29 projection has a tilde - like shape ` ( @xmath33 ) ' , while the @xmath30 one is a kind of a ` ooo ' figure . _
x1v4_. this family is bifurcated as unstable from x1 , also at the vertical 3:1 resonance region , but in many models it has large stable parts for larger energies . thus frequently it is an important family of the system .
its @xmath29 projection resembles the @xmath30 projection of x1v3 , i.e. it is a ` ooo ' figure , while the @xmath30 one has a tilde - like shape . _
x1v5_. it is bifurcated at the vertical 4:1 resonance .
both its edge - on projections can be morphologically described with the letter ` w ' , and it was the first family proposed for building the peanut ( pfenniger 1984a , 1985 ) . in some models we have two x1v5-like families . _
z3.1s_. this family is important in the model which lacks an explicit plummer sphere bulge component in the potential .
morphologically it resembles the x1v4 family , but it is not related to the x1-tree . _
x2-like 3d families_. finally , in a couple of cases , we found stable 3d x2-like families , i.e. families whose @xmath34 projections have elliptical - like shapes elongated along the bar _ minor _ axis .
they are bifurcations from the planar x2 orbits .
we note that all families have counterparts which are symmetric with respect to the principal planes and one can take into account all these orbits in order to build a profile . the rest of the stable 3d families found in papers i and ii also contribute to the vertical profiles of the models , but play a less important role . in section 3
, we refer to some of them in the description of the profiles of each model . in order to estimate the edge - on morphologies that can be supported we use , as a tool , profiles built by sets of weighted periodic orbit . for this
we first calculate a set of stable periodic orbits and pick points along each orbit at equal time steps .
we also calculate the ` mean density ' of each orbit , by calculating at each step the density of the model at the point visited by the orbit , and then taking the mean of these values .
this ` mean density ' is used to weight the orbit , since it can be considered as a first approximation for its importance .
thus the relative significance of the stable families for the dynamics of our model can be estimated by weighting the orbits by their ` mean density ' .
this is particularly important in regions where several families coexist . using a program specifically made for this task and based on eso - midas routines ,
we construct an image ( normalized over its total intensity ) for each calculated and weighted orbit .
the selected weighted orbits are then combined to build a profile .
darker parts of the profile image correspond either to regions occupied by a single family of relatively high importance , or to regions where many different orbits coexist . to give a visual impression of the morphology supported by the different stable families we consider orbits from all families that could play a role .
these are families having stable parts for large energy intervals .
an exception are families born at the radial 3:1 resonance region , since as we have seen in papers i and ii , their role for the dynamics of the studied models is only local .
the selected orbits are equally spaced in their mean radius .
this step in mean radius was the same for all families in a model . by over - plotting these orbits
one gets a crude impression of the edge - on structure of a stellar model , constructed on the basis of the selected families .
such figures are not density maps like those presented in the 2d case in contopoulos & grosbl ( 1988 ) and patsis , contopoulos & grosbl ( 1991 ) , since we deal here only with periodic orbits . the diagrams should rather be considered as skeletons of supported structures .
the 3d families appear in pairs symmetric with respect to the @xmath35=0 , @xmath27=0 and @xmath0=0 planes .
the @xmath34 projections of the orbits of most families are identical to those of their symmetric pairs .
that means that in most cases there is no morphological difference in the face - on view if we add the symmetric branches . on the other hand , in several cases , it is necessary to populate all symmetric branches to obtain symmetric edge - on profiles .
we present for all our models both the profiles of each family separately and also combined profiles , where we consider all or some of the families of the model .
when we estimate the relative importance of periodic orbits for the building of the vertical profile in a galaxy we have to take into account the fact that stable periodic orbits may reach large distances in the @xmath0-direction .
this means that stable orbits with high @xmath36 values are of lesser importance than the orbits remaining close to the equatorial plane and enhancing the bar . for the sake of completeness ,
however , we included these orbits in our profiles and we comment on their importance in each individual case .
in this section we present the edge - on profiles of the various families in each model . in the present paper we again use model a1 as a fiducial case .
we describe the contribution of all its families to the profiles , while for the rest of the models we give mainly the differences of their orbital behaviour from what we find in model a1 .
model a1 , introduced in paper i , includes a typical ferrers bar , and has both a radial and a vertical 2:1 resonance . in fig .
[ a1yzall ] we give for this model the side - on profiles of all important 3d families we found in paper i. all panels are profiles of individual families . throughout the paper
we use a linear gray scale ( i.e. a linear look - up - table in midas ) to display images .
= 15.0 cm visually we can separate the profiles in two classes .
those for which the projections of their orbits pass through the projected center of the system , i.e. the ( 0,0 ) point , and those for which the ( 0,0 ) point is at the center of an empty region . to the first class belong the orbits of the families x1v4 ( fig .
[ a1yzall]c ) , x1v7 ( fig .
[ a1yzall]e ) , the family of the 3d x2-like orbits of multiplicity 2 ( fig .
[ a1yzall]g ) and the 3d banana - like orbits of the family ban3v1 ( fig .
[ a1yzall]h ) .
two of these families , x1v4 and x1v7 , belong to the x1-tree .
their common characteristic is that they are bifurcations of x1 in @xmath37 , i.e. they have initial conditions @xmath38 , with @xmath39 and @xmath40 , while @xmath41 and @xmath42 .
we note that the structures they support are more ` ' -like than ` x'-like features . in that respect
these families favour the presence of normal and not ` x'-shaped peanuts . the profiles that result from the superposition of stable orbits of the families x1v1 ( fig .
[ a1yzall]a ) , x1v3 ( fig .
[ a1yzall]b ) , x1v5 ( fig .
[ a1yzall]d ) and x1v9 ( fig . [ a1yzall]f ) , belong to the second class of profiles , which have an empty central region . in order to quantify the morphologies supported in the various cases we use the @xmath43 ratio . here
@xmath44 is the bar length and @xmath45 is the orbital length of the family under consideration .
@xmath44 is estimated by considering the extent of all stable orbits _ supporting _ the bar .
these are in general families of the x1-tree ( papers i & ii ) .
we project them on the semi - major axis , and the longest projection is @xmath44 . in some cases
( see the case of x1v7 family below ) we give in addition a second value for the @xmath43 ratio taking into account for the estimation of @xmath44 also orbits of a family which do not fully support the bar ( e.g. they have loops off the major axis , which extend in large distances ) .
this number can be less than 1 .
we estimate @xmath45 , the orbital length , again by projecting orbits on the semi - major axis .
however , for @xmath45 , we take into account only the orbits of the family we consider .
the ` bar length ' characterizes a model globally , while the ` orbital length ' characterizes the @xmath30 projection of a given family in the model .
since we investigate the contribution of the families to the boxy structures and to b / p features in general , these ratios should be compared with the corresponding ratios given by l"utticke et al .
( 2000b ) for observations and athanassoula & misiriotis ( 2002 ) for @xmath7-body simulations .
this will be done in section 5 .
in particular we can remark about the profiles of model a1 the following : in general , the families which have at the center an ` ' morphology are good candidates to build , or at least to support , the peanut feature .
family x1v4 ( fig . [ a1yzall]c ) has an ` @xmath46'-type profile with two density enhancements added to its sides .
tangents to the inner parts of this ` @xmath46 ' feature passing through the center have an angle to the major axis of @xmath47 .
the empty inner parts of the ` @xmath46 ' feature reflect the fact that this family is born as unstable and thus lacks members lying almost on the equatorial plane , i.e. with low @xmath36 .
the ` bar length ' , in model a1 reaches @xmath48 ( patsis , skokos , athanassoula 2002b , hereafter paper iv ) thus for the family x1v4 we have @xmath49 .
x1v7 ( fig .
[ a1yzall]e ) also clearly harbours an ` ' feature .
the angle to the major axis now is @xmath50 .
a box is vaguely defined , but now it is thin since the orbits remain close to the equatorial plane .
the profile is better described as having a ` @xmath46 ' morphology with a low @xmath36 and with two characteristic local enhancements of the surface density at @xmath51 along the major axis .
the @xmath43 ratio is @xmath52 if we consider as edges the enhancements , or @xmath53 if we include the few outermost orbits as well .
these outermost orbits are 4:1 rectangular - like orbits with loops at their four apocentra in their @xmath34 projections .
their contribution to the density of the bar and to its face - on morphology is discussed in paper iv .
nevertheless these outermost orbits are not considered as contributing to the extent of the bar towards corotation .
note that both x1v4 and x1v7 have local enhancements along the major axis , which are symmetric with respect to the center and are manifestations of the orbital character of the profile .
if the edge - on profile of a galaxy is determined by families like x1v4 and x1v7 , then both the ` ' morphology and the local enhancements on the major axis should be observed ( see section 5 below ) .
the peanut that could be supported by the x2mul2 family is confined to the central region of the disc ( fig .
[ a1yzall]g ) .
this is expected because the projections of the orbits of this family on the equatorial plane are oriented along the minor axis of the main bar .
for this family we have @xmath54 .
x2mul2 could be useful to explain structures embedded in the very centers of edge - on disc galaxies .
finally the ban3v1 3d banana - like orbits favour in this projection the presence of an ` ' structure in the central region of a model .
side - on profiles with empty regions around the central point ( 0,0 ) are provided by the families x1v1 and x1v5 , both proposed in the past as peanut - building families ( combes et al .
1990 , pfenniger & friedli 1991 ; pfenniger 1984a , 1985 ) .
the x1v1 profile ( fig .
[ a1yzall]a ) consists of two parts , an inner and an outer one .
this reflects the fact that the evolution of the stability of family x1v1 follows a ss transition ( paper i ) and thus its stable parts exist for two separated energy intervals .
the gap is formed because only stable orbits should be considered .
actually the missing complex unstable part of the family would have provided very useful members for building the boxy bulge , in the sense that this family now provides only orbits with either very low or with relatively high @xmath36 .
the outer part has at the left and right sides ` wings ' , which could bring in the system pieces of an ` x ' structure .
these pieces , however , do not continue towards the center .
the central area separates the two pieces of the ` x ' .
we will refer to this kind of morphology with the symbol ` ' .
we note that the wings reach from the equatorial plane to their maximum height very abruptly over a distance @xmath55 and that the successive weighted orbits overplotted form four sharp peaks .
the ` orbital length ' reaches a distance from the center @xmath56 , so the @xmath43 ratio for family x1v1 is about 2.1 . if the outer part of the family , after the stransition , is not populated , then we have @xmath57 . in this case , however , we would have orbits confined close to the center with small deviations from the equatorial plane .
velocity dispersion will smooth out such features and due to dust they will not be easily observed in edge - on real galaxies .
families x1v3 and x1v5 , although bifurcated at different vertical resonances , can give similar side - on profiles ( cf . fig .
[ a1yzall]b and d ) .
this is a good example to show that it is the superpositions of stable orbits of a family , i.e. the vertical profile in a model , and not just the morphology of single orbital representatives , that can decide about the supported morphologies .
since the ` bar length ' in model a1 is @xmath58 , both families have @xmath59 .
family x1v9 remains always close to the equatorial plane .
it does not directly support the bar , since its @xmath34 projection consists of 4:1 rectangular like orbits with big loops .
furthermore , it does not contribute much to specific features , like boxes , observed in vertical profiles . since it is not considered as a family helping the bar to come closer to corotation
, we do not give in this case orbital ratios . a common feature encountered in all four families in model a1 with a ` ' vertical morphology is that , independent of the vertical resonance at which they are bifurcated , their side - on profiles are characterized by three local maxima above the equatorial plane .
this is a disadvantage for using them for building peanuts , since b / p bulges have two such local maxima .
these families could nevertheless give to the model an overall boxy side - on morphology , but only if we consider orbits trapped around the periodic ones .
this can be easier done with the x1v1 family because its orbits reach higher @xmath36 distances . in fig .
[ a1xzall ] we give the end - on , @xmath29 , profiles for the 3d families in model a1 , i.e. we change our viewing angle by @xmath60 and view along the bar major axis .
= 15.0 cm comparing figs .
[ a1yzall ] and [ a1xzall ] we note that in several cases the side - on and the end - on views of the same family have different central morphology .
the families x1v3 and x1v4 are typical examples , since the @xmath29 morphology of one is similar to the @xmath30 morphology of the other .
since in the side - on views their profiles belong to different classes , the same holds for their end - on views , but now x1v3 has a ` ' and x1v4 a ` ' central morphology , i.e. opposite to their side - on projections .
the same happens to the profiles of x1v7 ( cf .
[ a1yzall]e with fig .
[ a1xzall]e ) , x2mul2 and the banana - like 3d orbits of family ban3v1 .
thus x1v3 is the only family with an ` ' type end - on morphology . viewing a barred galaxy end - on ,
it does not make sense to compare the extent of the @xmath29 projection of a family with the length of the bar , since the feature we study is _ across _ the bar .
so we will use the ratio of the corotation radius over the @xmath29 orbital length ( @xmath61 ) of the family in order to assess its relative length and its extent on the galactic disc .
` @xmath62 ' indicates the corotation radius , which in model a1 is 6.13 , and ` @xmath63 ' is the orbital length derived from the projection of the family on the minor axis ( similarly to the definition of ` @xmath45 ' for the projection on the major axis ) .
another general remark is that the @xmath29 projections of the profiles are in most cases smaller than their @xmath30 projections .
this is particularly true for the families which are introduced in the system at low energies , i.e. x1v1 , x1v3 and x1v4 shown in fig .
[ a1xzall]a , b and c respectively .
especially for x1v1 , if we consider only the part of the family before the stransition , then its end - on profile is tiny and thus the @xmath61 ratio becomes huge .
the rest of the 3d families bifurcated from x1 have comparable ` orbital lengths ' in both projections . however , we have to note that families of the x1-tree that are bifurcated closer to corotation remain confined close to the equatorial plane and thus are less likely to characterize the morphology of the b / p structure . in particular for the @xmath29 profiles of each family we can say the following : the x1v3 @xmath29 projection ( fig .
[ a1xzall]b ) harbours now an ` ' feature embedded in a boxy feature with @xmath64 .
all other profiles are of an ` ' -type morphology . the x1v1 family ( fig .
[ a1xzall]a ) has @xmath65 .
the end - on projection of the orbits of this family reveals a bulge - like component with pieces of an ` x ' feature located closer to the center than in the corresponding @xmath30 projection .
again one sees that the most useful orbits of this family for building an ` x ' are missing because they are complex unstable .
it is also evident that the end - on view of this family supports a morphology that is more extended in the @xmath0 than in the @xmath35 direction , if the outer part of the family is populated .
such a feature is not observed in edge - on disc galaxies .
that means that either such features are smoothed out by dispersion , or that they are embedded in larger and rounder bulge components , or that the x1v1 orbits beyond the first stransition are not populated . the @xmath29 projection of x1v4 ( fig .
[ a1xzall]c ) has three local maxima , and has @xmath66 , i.e. it is quite extended along the equatorial plane . this reflects the fact that many stable orbits of x1v4 in their @xmath34 projections are close to hexagons with roughly equal extensions along the @xmath35 and @xmath27 directions ( see paper i ) .
the same holds also for the family x1v7 ( fig .
[ a1xzall]e ) , which has @xmath67 and whose orbits are quite rectangular in their face - on projection .
the @xmath29 projection of x1v7 has a third local maximum , which , however , is very close to the equatorial plane . in this projection
the x2mul2 family supports a small peanut with @xmath68 .
the profile of family x1v9 ( fig .
[ a1xzall]f ) is very thin in this projection as well .
finally the 3d banana - like orbits of family ban3v1 ( fig .
[ a1xzall]h ) can contribute to the boxiness of a central structure , by enhancing the sides of a box at radii less than 1 kpc , even if the central area remains empty . to some degree ,
the presence of the third central local maximum seen in the profiles in fig .
[ a1yzall ] and [ a1xzall ] , depend on the viewing angle , considered always on the equatorial plane . in
the above we considered only the side - on and end - on views , but intermediate viewing angles can be considered in the same way . in most cases we examined there is a range of projection angles where the overlapping of orbits of a family can be responsible for the morphology of a continuous ` ' feature inside a box . in other words , by changing the viewing angle we can minimize the importance of the third local maximum in @xmath0 , which is not consistent with a peanut morphology , and at the same time bring the two separated pieces of an ` x ' closer .
however , one should not overestimate the role of rotation , because the range of viewing angles that reproduce the ` x ' morphology is narrow . in the case of the x1v1 family of model a1 , a ` x ' feature due to rotation is discernible only in an angle range @xmath69 close to the @xmath29-projection . in table
[ tab : a1tab ] we summarize the properties of the edge - on orbital profiles in model a1 .
the symbols used for describing the central morphologies are explained in the text , except for ` ] [ ' used for the central end - on morphology of the 3d banana - like orbits of the family ban3v1 .
the two branches of this family appear at the sides of the bar , symmetric with respect to its major axis , and leave a totally empty region at the center of the end - on profile .
[ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] in effect , in the box of the side - on morphology of x1v1 , which is essentially of ` ' type , we can see segments of a ` x ' feature .
segments of ` x ' can also be seen in the boxy end - on profile of the family x1v3 .
however due to its large @xmath61 ratio , the addition of dispersion in the velocities of the orbits will result in a boxy feature .
these peculiarities are indicated by the symbols we use in table [ tab : dtab ] .
so far we presented separately the building blocks that each family provides to the vertical structure of a model .
however , the vertical structure of a real galaxy could be specified by more than one family .
so we created composite profiles as well , taking into account all , or some , of the families of the model in each case . in this kind of representations the images of the profiles we have seen until now are added together to give a single image . in fig .
[ sc1yz]a , we consider all families of model a1 presented in fig .
[ a1yzall ] , except for the banana - like orbits .
if we select just the families x1v4 , x1v7 and x1v9 we obtain the profile we see in fig .
[ sc1yz]b .
= 8.0 cm = 8.0 cm in principle there is no reason to include in a system all families ( or all orbits of a family ) populated . internal and external factors , like resonance widths , formation history , influence of companions etc .
decide which of them will be populated in a real galaxy .
e.g. in fig .
[ sc1yz]a a boxy bulge could be built inside the ` borders ' indicated by arrows , which are imposed by the x1v1 orbits . however ,
if for some reason x1v1 is not populated and the bar , apart from the stable members of the 2d x1 orbits , is made out of the families x1v4 , x1v7 and x1v9 , we have again a b / p profile , as we see in fig .
[ sc1yz]b .
the main difference between the two configurations , that would reflect in the photometry of edge - on galaxies , is the @xmath43 ratio or a similar indicator . in the present case
a boxy bulge due to the x1v1 family would give @xmath70 , while the profile that is dominated by x1v4 has @xmath71 . the family bifurcated from x1 at lowest energy , if populated , will characterize qualitatively the boxiness of a model s profile , because it determines whether we will have a peanut , a boxy , or a flat edge - on profile .
the reason for this is that the orbits of a 3d family which bifurcated from x1 at a @xmath72 vertical resonance , have in general larger @xmath36 than the orbits of the family bifurcated at the @xmath73 vertical resonance .
the family x1v3 can be an exception to this rule in some models ( e.g. model a1 ) , if it undergoes a stransition when its orbits are still confined close to the equatorial plane without becoming stable for larger energies .
this stability behaviour , however , has been encountered only in specific models and is not the general rule . in our models we found profiles
whose vertical extent decreases as we move away from the center of the galaxy .
they present relatively abrupt height changes at distances from the center which are characteristic for each family .
so , the orbits of a given family reach a maximum distance from the center along an axis .
this is especially discernible in the case of the x1v1 family .
these ` stair - type ' edge - on profiles have been encountered in 3d spiral potentials @xcite and in almost axisymmetric disc models as well ( patsis , athanassoula , grosbl et al .
2002a ) .
blurred smoothed images are another informative representation of the profiles .
they are created by applying a gaussian smoothing filter on the images using the corresponding midas command . the smoothing radius , i.e the number of pixels `` around '' each central pixel , is 9 in both directions of the image .
so we have a 19@xmath2419 pixels smoothing neighbourhood . the mean and sigma values that have been used are 9 and 6 pixels respectively , again in both directions . in order to construct exact density maps we would need self - consistent models based on libraries of non - periodic orbits ( e.g. schwarzschild 1979 , pfenniger 1984b , contopoulos & grosbl 1988 ) .
this is beyond the scope of the present paper .
blurred images , however , show , in a first approximation , the coarse morphological features which are expected to be discernible in models made out of non - periodic orbits , trapped around the stable periodic ones .
thus our blurred images should not be considered as exact , but just as guiding the eye , for morphological features to be sought in the observations .
we did not include in our blurred images planar orbits , which would appear just as thick straight - line segments on the equatorial plane .
the blurred images of the profiles of fig .
[ sc1yz ] are given in fig .
[ blsc1yz ] .
we clearly see that = 8.0 cm we have boxy profiles both in ( a ) and in ( b ) .
the typical peanut morphology is better reproduced in fig .
[ blsc1yz]b indicating that it is the x1v4 family that is mainly responsible for this morphology . on the other hand , the boxy structure in fig . [ blsc1yz]a ( as the overplotted isodensities also show ) is characterized by a local maximum height at @xmath27=0 .
we note that families associated with vertical @xmath74:1 resonances with @xmath75 have little , if any , contribution to the vertical structures that dominate and characterize the profiles .
[ sc1xz ] is the end - on composite profile of model a1 , considering all the families , as in fig .
[ sc1yz]a . its blurred image ( fig . [ sc1xz]b ) clearly shows that also the @xmath29 profile has a boxy character , as the @xmath30 one .
now the box , as expected , is confined closer to the center .
isodensity contours also in this case help = 8.0 cm understand the relative importance of the various features .
the main contribution to the central dark box in fig .
[ sc1xz]b comes from the orbits of the 3d family of multiplicity 2 ( fig .
[ a1xzall]g ) .
we note that in the corresponding side - on profile the contribution of this family to the overall morphology is minimal , due to the confined extent of their @xmath30 projections ( they are elongated along the minor axis of the bar ) .
note the two surface density enhancements , symmetric with respect to the center , indicated by arrows .
model a2 , the slow rotating bar case , gives a characteristic example of a well defined b / p shape due to successive orbits of the x1v1 family ( fig .
[ a2yzall]b ) .
furthermore , it also gives a typical example of an ` x ' morphology resulting from the superposition of successive orbits .
the main reason for the sharpness of the ` x ' feature is that the ss transition of the x1v1 family in this model practically does not interrupt the succession of the stable orbits we consider , since x1v1 is complex unstable only over a very narrow energy interval . in this way
the ` x ' feature would be due to orbits trapped around the x1v1 family , rather than to orbits trapped around families of stable orbits on inclined orbital planes symmetric with respect to the rotational axis .
the imprint of the ` x ' in model a2 is given in fig .
[ ic_sc2yz]b .
note = 7.0 cm = 7.0 cm that the sides of the ` x ' emerge out of a boxy feature in the very center of the galaxy .
inspection of fig .
[ a2yzall]b explains the origin of this morphology . in the particular case of model a2 , in the very inner part we also have the contribution of family x2v1 with orbits with similar weights as those of x1v1 . because of these , the ` x ' feature does not extend with equal intensity all the way to the center , unless the x2v1 are little populated . note that an ` x ' feature like the one presented by whitmore & bell ( 1988 ) ( their fig.4 ) is passing through the center and has equal intensity along its sides . combining the profiles of x1v1 and x2v1 with those of x1v3 and x1v4
, we obtain an edge - on profile of model a2 which has a striking similarity with the edge - on galaxy ic 4767 ( fig .
[ ic_sc2yz]a ) .
we point with arrows at the enhancements of the surface density along the major axis in fig .
[ ic_sc2yz]b .
they clearly have their counterparts in the image of the galaxy ( fig . [ ic_sc2yz]a ) and are clearly revealed in the processed image in whitmore & bell ( 1988 , their fig .
let us now turn to the end - on view of model a2 ( fig .
[ sc2xz ] ) .
the family x2v1 contributes a cross - type end - on profile .
the remaining families contribute mainly to the building of a dark bulge at the center , which is slightly elongated along the rotational @xmath0 axis .
= 8.0 cm however , in this case corotation is at @xmath76 , so we have , even by considering x2v1 , a ratio @xmath77 , i.e. such features should be sought in the very central regions of end - on views of the discs of barred galaxies . the fast rotating bar of model a3 offers an example , where the @xmath30 profile is rather flat ( fig . [ sc3prof]a ) , mainly due to the complex instability of the x1v1 family .
the _ end - on _ profile is in this case boxy ( fig .
[ sc3prof]b ) .
the boxiness is introduced by the families x1v3 and x1v5 .
model b , without either radial or vertical 2:1 resonances , offers many possibilities of showing a strong b / p feature if we consider all families that may contribute to its vertical profile .
it even has a ` ' feature in its central part when viewed side - on ( fig .
[ smprof]a ) . note that in this case x1v1 orbits do not exist , since the first vertical bifurcation in model b is x1v5 introduced in the vertical 4:1 resonance ( paper ii ) .
the profile is made out of x1v5 , x1v5@xmath78 , x1v7 and z3.1s orbits , which give the ` ' morphology in the center .
blurred images are given in fig .
[ smprof]c and fig .
[ smprof]d for the profiles in fig .
[ smprof]a and fig .
[ smprof]b ( end - on view ) , respectively .
the morphological difference between the x1v1 ` x ' and the z3.1s ` x ' , is that the latter is characteristically curved ( i.e. it can be better described with the symbol ` ' ) , while the sides of the former are straight .
the overplotted isophotes on the blurred images in figs .
[ smprof]c , d reveal a peanut and a boxy profile respectively . from figs .
[ myz ] and [ smprof ] it is evident that the families x1v5 , x1v5@xmath78 support a boxy structure elongated along the major axis with , in the outer parts , an ansae - like morphology .
on the other hand the outer isophotes of z3.1s support the typical peanut morphology , while closer to the equatorial plane the isophotes have the kind of b / p shape encountered in several 3d bars of @xmath7-body models ( athanassoula 2002 , unpublished ) . in fig .
[ cxz ] we give in blurred representation also the edge - on ( a ) and end - on ( b ) profiles of the x1v1 family in model c. in both figures = 8.0 cm we have considered even orbits that reach @xmath79 , in order to show that the x1v1 orbits do not contribute to the observed boxy feature beyond the critical energy for which they start to increase their mean radii by increasing practically only their mean @xmath80 values . beyond the dashed lines ,
away from the equatorial plane , the corresponding density is too low .
we see that a bar with such a family as backbone , supports a peanut edge - on and a boxy end - on profile , and also that we have here a case where the x1v1 family supports the ` x ' feature in its central morphology . finally in model d ( fig .
[ shprof ] ) we have another case characterized by the dominance of x1v1 .
this family brings in the side - on morphology a b / p bulge and broken branches of a ` x ' feature .
the end - on profile of this model gives a rather roundish or rhomboidal central feature , which becomes elongated in the @xmath0 direction if we take into account orbits with mean @xmath79 ( fig . [ shprof]d ) .
in this paper we have investigated families of periodic orbits , as well as combinations of such families , that might be the building blocks for b / p edge - on morphologies in disc galaxies .
the @xmath43 ratios in the side - on views of the models vary . profiles with @xmath43 ratios less than 2 characterize models in which most of the bar s material forms a b / p structure . on the other hand , in cases with big @xmath43 ratios we have to do with b / p features concentrated close to the center of the model . in almost all cases
( except for the z3.1s family ) the orbits that contribute to a b / p profile are introduced in the system as bifurcations of the basic family x1 at vertical resonances .
for this reason we used orbits of these families in building possible orbital profiles .
in our study we present the orbital profiles as viewed from the two extreme edge - on viewing angles , namely the side- and the end - on view .
possible changes in the morphology of the profiles due to rotation have been discussed in section 3.1 .
there , we investigated the role of rotation in minimizing the effect of the presence of the third local maximum in the profiles of the x1v1 family in model a1 .
we concluded , that the morphological change from a structure with three local maxima to a kind of ` x'-feature happens only for a small angle range .
we find in general that the profiles keep their morphological similarity with their side - on views for viewing angles close to it , and the same happens with the end - on projections . if we rotate a b / p profile around the axis of rotation of the system , starting from the side - on view , we observe that the local minimum at its center rises above the equatorial plane and the profile becomes ` thicker ' at the center .
this , however , does not affect the overall morphology of a b / p structure .
we note that in blurred images of side - on projections , this minimum does not reach the equatorial plane ( fig .
[ blsc1yz]b , fig . [ ic_sc2yz]b ) .
nevertheless , the size of the bar altogether varies in different projections .
l"utticke et al .
( 2000b ) hold the view that the inner regions of barred disc galaxies , apart from the thin bar , are built by two further components , namely a spheroidal bulge and a b / p structure .
the spheroidal is a kinematically distinct component occupying the central region of the galaxy .
our models do not exclude the coexistence of spheroidals in the central regions of the disks .
furthermore , we find families of periodic orbits in the x1-tree , i.e. families of the 3d disc , that could support roundish structures , especially in their end - on projections .
it is also possible , as we found z3.1s , to find a plethora of ` z@xmath74 ' families that stay close to the rotational axis and could populate a spheroidal bulge ( e.g. family z5.1s given in fig .
13 of paper ii ) .
these orbits are not presented in this paper , since we discuss here only the presence and morphology of peanuts or boxes .
peanuts and boxes are structures associated with families of the bar , or , more generally , with families of the disc , since they can exist also in almost axisymmetric models ( patsis et al .
2002a ) , as well as in the case where instead of a bar we have a spiral perturbation ( patsis & grosbl 1996 ) . note also that the z3.1s family is bar - supporting ( paper ii ) .
peanuts made out of the x1v1 family ( i.e. related to the vertical 2:1 resonance ) and in which also orbits beyond the s transition are populated show a spheroidal structure in the middle , which introduces a third local maximum at the centers of the side - on profiles .
the central empty region of the ` ' feature is surrounded by parts of x1v1 orbits .
branches of a ` x ' are stuck in several cases to the left and to the right of this spheroidal structure .
we can clearly see it in fig .
[ sc1yz]a , between the features pointed with arrows , and also in the corresponding position of the edge - on profile of the strong bar model d ( fig .
[ shprof]a ) . in these cases
the ratio of the extent of the central pseudo - bulge over the extent of the peanut - shaped structure is almost 1 .
geometrical arguments are also useful when comparing b / p features of real galaxies or b / p features encountered in @xmath7-body simulations with b / p structures in our orbital models . unfortunately the various lengths involved are measured in different ways by different authors .
usually the way of measuring a length is intrinsic in the approach adopted by the authors in order to study edge - on profiles .
thus a direct comparison is problematic .
the peanut- or box - like features we find in the composite side - on profiles have @xmath43 ratios which vary from about 2.5 to close to 1 . in our measurements
the length of the bar @xmath44 is the length of the longest projection of bar - supporting orbits on the semi - major axis . in general
these are x1 orbits with loops on the major axis of the bar , or 2d rectangular - like orbits at the radial 4:1 resonance region ( paper iv ) .
thus , an upper limit to this length is defined in a rather precise way .
on the other hand , the orbital length along the major axis , @xmath45 , can not exceed the length of the projection of the outermost orbit of a family on the semi - major axis , but it can in principle take smaller values , depending on whether all or part of the family is populated in the profile we construct . in that sense
the @xmath43 ratios we give can be considered as minimum values for a profile dominated by a specific family , since we usually exclude only orbits that reach big heights above the equatorial plane , which do not contribute much to density profiles anyway .
nevertheless , if a family characterizes a profile this means that the majority of its orbits is populated and in this case the ratio can not be considerably larger than the number we give .
by taking all the above into account we could compare the ratios we find with corresponding quantities defined in athanassoula & misiriotis ( 2002 ) .
this paper examines quantitatively morphologies found in @xmath7-body models of barred galaxies . in an edge - on projection they estimate the extent of the bar and of the b / p feature by considering cuts of the projected surface density parallel to the equatorial plane . in the simulations where they find a strong b / p feature ,
the ratio of the maximum distance to which the ledge on the @xmath81 cut extends to the radius of very steep drops on cuts offset from @xmath81 , is @xmath82 .
this points to profiles dominated by orbits of families like x1v3 , x1v4 or x1v5 , which in their side - on profiles have @xmath43 ratios less than 2 . despite the differences that can be introduced due to the different kind of modeling and the different ways of estimating the various relative lengths
, the b / p features in athanassoula & misiriotis ( 2002 ) definitely occupy regions larger than the central region of the galaxy .
this indicates that a large fraction of the bar seen side - on has a b / p morphology .
l``utticke et al .
( 2000b ) find in their sample a ratio around 2.5 for the bar length over the b / p distortion ( bal / bpl ) . here
again we have to note the differences in the way they estimate the length of the bar and the length of the b / p structure . as in athanassoula & misiriotis ( 2002 )
they consider cuts parallel to the equatorial plane of edge - on disc galaxies .
the projected bar length , however , is estimated in the cut along the major axis at the distance where they find an increasing light distribution towards the center compared to the radial exponential light distribution .
the length of the b / p structure is defined as the distance between the maxima of the b / p distortion .
therefore , their bar length is systematically larger than both our @xmath44 and the bar length estimated in athanassoula & misiriotis ( 2002 ) .
also bpl in l''utticke et al .
( 2000b ) is systematically smaller than our orbital length @xmath45 , since for most families parts of the orbits extend also to the left and to the right of the maxima of the b / p feature .
an exception is family x1v1 for which the distance between the b / p maxima and the length of the projection of the orbital profile on the semi - major axis indeed almost coincide ( see e.g. fig .
[ a1yzall]a ) . as a result of all the above mentioned differences the bal / bpl ratio in l``utticke et al .
( 2000b ) is expected to be systematically larger than our @xmath43 in profiles dominated by the same family . for our models ratios around 2.5 point to x1v1 type peanuts or , in models without radial and vertical ilrs , to peanuts that are made of z3.1s orbits .
this , however , does not exclude that many galaxies in the l''utticke et al .
( 2000b ) sample could have @xmath43 less than 2 for the family which is mainly responsible for its vertical profile .
as a general rule we can say that , if the relative size of a b / p feature compared with the size of the bar is estimated smaller than 2 , this indicates that most probable candidates to be associated with it are families related to higher order vertical resonances ( e.g. x1v3 , x1v4 etc . ) and not the x1v1 family .
the main reason for this is that the x1v1 orbits , as energy increases approaching corotation , do not increase their projections on the major axis of the bar after a critical energy . beyond this energy ,
the x1v1 orbits grow practically only in @xmath0 . for cases of edge - on galaxies where the ratio of the bar to the b / p distortion s length is larger than 3 ,
the orbital models indicate that these features may be associated with nearly end - on projections of various families ( see fig .
[ a1xzall]b and g , fig .
[ a3xzall]b and c , fig .
[ hxz]b ) .
also existing x2-like 3d orbits would contribute to boxy end - on profiles .
x1v1 , the family associated with the vertical 2:1 resonance , does not give boxy end - on projections .
it contributes rather to a roundish central morphology ( figs .
[ a1yzall]a , [ hyz]a , [ shprof]d ) . at this point
we want to stress that side - on b / p profiles combined with slightly prolate end - on morphologies , as well as boxy , or even b / p , end - on profiles are encountered in 3d bars in @xmath7-body simulations ( athanassoula 2002 , unpublished ) .
another feature that we can geometrically quantify is the oblique angle between a branch of ` x ' and the major axis of the main bar . in the slow bar model
a2 the ` x ' is made mainly of the x1v1 orbits and this angle is about @xmath83 ( fig . [ a2yzall]b ) , close to the value whitmore & bell ( 1988 ) give for ic 4767 .
the x1v1 orbits of models a1 ( fiducial case ) and d ( strong bar case ) harbour ` x 's embedded in peanut - shaped bulges , which are characterized by the fact that they do not reach the major axis . as we explained , this results from the presence of the complex unstable part of this family which causes an empty inner region . in these cases
the angle is about @xmath84 . in the strong bar case ( model d )
the peanut feature with an ` x ' is particularly conspicuous , in agreement with the results of @xmath7-body simulations ( athanassoula & misiriotis 2002 , and athanassoula 2002 , unpublished ) .
the central ` ' feature made out of the z3.1s orbits in the model without 2:1 resonances does not include segments with straight lines .
however , tangents crossing through the center are inclined about @xmath85 to the major axis .
we can define an inner and an outer inclination for branches of the ` ' features due to the x1v4 family that might appear in several models .
in model a1 we measure this to be about @xmath86 if we consider stable x1v4 orbits with low energy , and @xmath84 if we consider stable x1v4 orbits with large energies ( fig .
[ sc1yz]b ) . a rough estimation of the angle of ` x ' in hickson 87a from fig .
4 in mihos , walker and hernquist ( 1995 ) , is about @xmath87 . l"utticke
( 2000c ) estimate this angle to be @xmath88 . to summarize , small `` x'-angles ' ( @xmath89 ) are build from orbits related to families introduced at higher order vertical resonances and to some degree slow rotating bars , while large `` x'-angles ' ( @xmath90 ) characterize ` x ' structures in typical x1v1 b / p bulges .
the overlapping of periodic orbits of some families form two enhancements of the projected surface density along the major axis of the models , which are symmetric with respect to the center .
similar features , seen along the major axes of edge - on disc galaxies with b / p bulges , e.g. ic 4767 @xcite , eso 417-g08 , ngc 4710 @xcite are often interpreted as rings or spirals . here
we present an alternative explanation . using families of periodic orbits as building blocks of the profiles of the edge - on barred galaxies we can easily see that the enhancements could be a kind of a projection effect due to the trapping of material around stable periodic orbits .
these enhancements actually exist in the profiles of all families . in composite profiles one can better see them at families with orbits close to the end of the bar .
the reason is that there are no other families of periodic orbits that fall on them smoothing out the profile more .
recently aronica , bureau , athanassoula et al .
( 2002 , and in preparation ) , detected these enhancements in a sample of edge - on galaxies observed in the k@xmath78 .
we note that we found b / p features in models without a radial 2:1 resonance ( model c , cf .
[ cxz ] ) and that we encountered a case ( model a3 ) where although the radial and vertical 2:1 resonances exist and are located at very close energy values ( paper ii ) , the model does not support a conspicuous b / p structure ( cf .
[ a3yzall ] ) .
thus in our response models we do not find any correlation of a conjuction of radial and vertical 2:1 resonance and the appearance of a b / p feature .
finally our models could support small inner discs , tilted with respect to the equatorial plane of the main disc .
this can be done by breaking the symmetry and considering only one of the symmetric branches of a family . in galaxies
this can be e.g. due to companions falling on a target galaxy at a skew angle , so that the system will show a preference in populating one of the two symmetric branches .
in this paper we investigated the vertical structure in barred potentials using orbital theory .
we combined families of periodic orbits in the models of papers i and ii in order to study the possible resulting vertical profiles and we discussed their geometry and their dimensions in comparison with structures found in edge - on disc galaxies and snapshots of @xmath7-body simulations .
here we enumerate our basic conclusions : 1 .
the vertical profiles of our models are of ` stair - type ' .
this means that families that offer the skeletons for the 3d bars and are bifurcated at higher energies ( i.e. closer to corotation ) have in general lower mean heights .
b / p features in vertical profiles can be supported mainly by the following families : * * x1v1*. this family is particularly useful for building a boxy central structure if it does not have a complex unstable part in the critical energy .
the best examples we found are in the slow rotating bar case and in the strong bar model . in these cases , for energies where the maximum @xmath0 of the orbits remains less than about 1 kpc , successive orbits of x1v1 have the maximal deviations of their edge - on projections from the equatorial plane aligned along almost straight segments .
these ` lines ' are in oblique angles to the major axis , not passing thorough the center in general , and their angle with the major axis is @xmath91 . in the slow bar case ,
however , this angle is @xmath92 . for this family the ratio _
@xmath43 is larger than 2_. @xmath93 for x1v1 ( as found in model a3 ) , indicate that only a small part of the family is populated and thus its contribution to the vertical structure of the model is not significant .
* * x1v4*. this family gives @xmath71 , i.e. brings the end of the peanuts close to the end of the bars .
it is introduced in the system after a us transition of x1 and has stable representatives for larger energies than the energy at the bifurcating point .
it exists over large energy intervals and , if populated , will provide the system with a b / p - shaped structure whose extent is near that of the bar .
it supports the peanut morphology especial in composite profiles without any contribution from x1v1 orbits ( fig .
[ blsc1yz]b ) . * * z3.1s * this family gives b / p features in models without radial or vertical ilrs , and is quite important for the dynamics of these models .
profiles characterized by the presence of this family ( fig .
[ smprof]c , fig .
[ myz]c ) have the characteristic local minimum of the density at the ( 0,0 ) position , like in the case of ngc 2788 a in fig .
[ twogal]a , which is indicated by a black arrow . *
the ansae - type profile is easiest made by orbits associated with the vertical 4:1 resonance and can be described as a stretched ` x ' ( fig . [ myz]a ) .
* finally the 3d * x2-like * families of orbits support boxy morphologies .
the latter are especially discernible in the end - on profiles of the model with the low pattern speed .
+ we have to note that if families bifurcated at high order vertical resonances are responsible for the peanut , then they will support a b / p bar morphology altogether .
coexistence of several 3d families should in general be expected .
in such a case it is the family which is bifurcated at the lowest energy that plays the most important role for the morphology of the model .
narrow extensions appear on the sides of many profiles ( see e.g. fig . [
blsc1yz]a ) these features result from the ` stair - type ' character of profiles constructed with families of periodic orbits , and have their counterpart in many images of edge - on disc galaxies .
the corresponding feature in the case of ngc 6771 is also indicated by white arrows in fig .
[ twogal]b .
+ = 5.0 cm 4 .
the projection of the orbits of a family on the equatorial plane is confined within certain limits . by this
we mean that moving on the characteristic towards corotation , we reach a certain distance from the center where the mean radius of the orbits increases only due to increasing of @xmath0 .
this is particularly evident in the case of the x1v1 family , which is related to the vertical 2:1 resonance and which in general is the 3d bifurcation of x1 closest to the center .
families of periodic orbits ( x1v3 , x1v4 , x1v5 , z3.1s , x2v1 ) can build boxy , or even peanut - boxy , _ end - on _ profiles .
we would thus like to suggest that boxy bulges in galaxies having a bar length over a b / p length larger than 3 , are related with the profiles of families seen end - on .
` x'-type features are found in the composite orbital profiles .
they are formed by alignment of successive orbits of the family x1v1 .
they are pronounced if the stransition in this family does not play an important role in the dynamics of a model .
the fact that ` x ' features are rare in real galaxies , indicates that , in most cases where a x1v1 family is populated in a galaxy , it has an important complex unstable part .
adequate successive projections of the orbits of a family in large energy intervals , like what we see in model b mainly due to the z3.1s orbits , give central morphologies that can be described with the symbol ` ' .
we note that the higher the order of the resonance of the family associated with ` x ' or ` ' structure is , the smaller the angle between the ` x'/`'-branch and the major axis we find . in the case of the x1v1 family
this angle is smaller in the slower rotating bar case .
discs out of the equatorial plane in the bulges are easiest made by breaking the symmetry and populating only one of the two symmetric branches of the 3d families .
characteristic local enhancements of the surface density along the major axis of the bar are predicted by the models merely due to the orientation of the successive orbits in the profiles .
aronica , g. , bureau m. , athanassoula , e. , bosma , e. , dettmar , r.j . , vergani , d. , pohlen , m. 2002 , in `` the evolution of galaxies iii .
from simple approaches to self consistent models '' , eds .
g. hensler , g. stasinska , s. harfst , p. kroupa , chr .
theis , in press athanassoula e. , bureau m. , 1999 apj 522 , 699 athanassoula e. , misiriotis a. , 2002 mnras 330 , 35 berentzen i. , heller c.h . , shlosman i. , fricke k.j . , 1998 ,
mnras 300 , 49 binney j. , petrou m. , 1985 mnras 214 , 449 burbidge e.m .
, burbidge g.r . , 1959 , apj 130 , 20 bureau m. , athanassoula e. , 1999 , apj 522 , 686 bureau m. , freeman k. , 1999 , aj 118 , 126 combes f. , sanders r. h. , 1981 a&a 96 , 164 combes f. , debbasch f. , friedli d. , pfenniger d. , 1990 , a&a 233 , 95 contopoulos g. , grosbl p. , 1988 a&a 197,83 donofrio m. , capaccioli m. , merluzzi p. et al . , 1999 ,
a&ass 134 , 437 kormendy j. , illingworth g. , 1982 , apj , 256 , 460 kuijken k. , merrifield m.r . , 1995 , apj 443 , l13 l"utticke r. , dettmar r - j , pohlen m. , 2000a , a&as 145 , 405 l"utticke r. , dettmar r - j , pohlen m. , 2000b , a&a 362 , 435 l"utticke r. , dettmar r - j , pohlen m. , 2000c , astron .
17 , 68 mihos j.c . ,
walker i.r . , hernquist l. , 1995 , apj 447 , l87 patsis p.a . , contopoulos g. , grosbl p. , 1991
, a&a 243 , 373 patsis p.a . , grosbl p. , 1996 , a&a 315 , 371 patsis p.a . , athanassoula e. , grosbl , skokos ch . , 2002a mnras _ in press
patsis p.a . ,
skokos ch . , athanassoula e. , 2002b ( _ paper iv - in preparation _ ) pfenniger d. , 1984a , a&a 134 , 373 pfenniger d. , 1984b , a&a 141 , 171 pfenniger d. , 1985 , a&a 150 , 112 pfenniger d. , friedli d. , 1991 , a&a 252,75 raha n , sellwood j.a .
, james r. a. , kahn f. d. , 1991 , nature 352 , 411 schwarzkopf u. , dettmar r .-
j . , 2000 ,
a&ass 144 , 85 shaw m. , 1993 , mnras 261 , 718 skokos ch .
, patsis p.a . ,
athanassoula e. , 2002a - mnras 333 , 847 ( _ paper i _ ) skokos ch .
, patsis p.a . ,
athanassoula e. , 2002b - mnras 333 , 861 ( _ paper ii _ ) whitmore b.c .
, bell m. , 1988 , apj 324 , 741 zachilas l. , 1993 , a&as 97 , 549
we acknowledge fruitful discussions and very useful comments by g. contopoulos and a. bosma .
we thank the referee for useful suggestions and valuable remarks , which improved the paper .
this work has been supported by e@xmath94et ii and k@xmath95 1994 - 1999 ; and by the research committee of the academy of athens .
chs and pap thank the laboratoire dastrophysique de marseille for an invitation during which essential parts of this work have been completed .
chs was partially supported by the `` karatheodory '' postdoctoral fellowship no 2794 of the university of patras . all image processing work has been done with eso - midas . | we present families , and sets of families , of periodic orbits that provide building blocks for boxy and peanut ( hereafter b / p ) edge - on profiles .
we find cases where the b / p profile is confined to the central parts of the model and cases where a major fraction of the bar participates in this morphology .
a b / p feature can be built either by 3d families associated with 3d bifurcations of the x1 family , or , in some models , even by families related with the @xmath0-axis orbits and existing over large energy intervals .
the ` x ' feature observed inside the boxy bulges of several edge - on galaxies can be attributed to the peaks of successive x1v1 orbits ( skokos et al .
2002a , hereafter paper i ) , provided their stability allows it .
however in general , the x1v1 family has to overcome the obstacle of a ss transition in order to support the structure of a b / p feature .
other families that can be the backbones of b / p features are x1v4 and z3.1s .
the morphology and the size of the boxy or peanut - shaped structures we find in our models is determined by the presence and stability of the families that support b / p features .
the present study favours the idea that the observed edge - on profiles are the imprints of families of periodic orbits that can be found in appropriately chosen hamiltonian systems , describing the potential of the bar .
@xmath1 wasyfont = = = = = = = = # 1 # 1 # 1 # 1 @mathgroup@group @mathgroup@normal@groupeurmn @mathgroup@bold@groupeurbn @mathgroup@group @mathgroup@normal@groupmsamn @mathgroup@bold@groupmsamn = `` 019 = ' ' 016 = `` 040 = ' ' 336 = " 33e = = = = = = = = # 1 # 1 # 1 # 1 = = = = = = = = [ firstpage ] galaxies : evolution kinematics and dynamics structure |
recently @xcite it was assumed that some kind of gravitational flux tube solutions in the 5d kaluza - klein gravity can be considered as string - like objects , namely @xmath0strings .
the idea is that the gravitational flux tubes can be very thin ( approximately @xmath1 ) and arbitrary long .
evidently that such object looks like to a string attached to two universes or to remote parts of a single universe .
the thickness of this object is so small that near to the point of attachment to an external universe the handles of a spacetime foam will appear between this object and the universe .
this is like a delta of the river flowing into the sea .
we call such objects as a @xmath0string .
the @xmath0string has interesting properties : it can transfer electromagnetic waves and consequently the energy ; the mouth is similar to a spread charge ; it is a realization of einstein - wheeler s idea about `` mass without mass '' and `` charge without charge '' ; it has wormhole and string properties ; in some sense it is some realization of einstein s idea that all should be constructed from vacuum ( in this case the @xmath0string is the vacuum solution of 5d gravitational equations ) . at first these gravitational flux tubes solutions
were obtained as 4d levi - civita - robertson - bertotti solutions @xcite in 4d einstein - maxwell theory .
it is an infinite flux tube filled with parallel electric @xmath2 and and magnetic @xmath3 fields @xmath4 where @xmath5 @xmath6 is an arbitrary constant angle ; @xmath7 and @xmath8 are constants defined by eq .
( [ intr-30 ] ) ; @xmath7 determines the cross section of the tube and @xmath8 the magnitude of the electric and magnetic fields ; @xmath9 is newton s constant ( @xmath10 , the speed of light ) ; @xmath11 is the electromagnetic field tensor . for @xmath12 ( @xmath13 )
one has a purely electric ( or magnetic ) field . in ref .
@xcite was obtained similar 5d solutions .
the properties of these solutions depend on the relation @xmath14 between electric @xmath15 and magnetic @xmath16 fields .
the purpose of this paper is to investigate more careful the properties of the gravitational flux tubes with @xmath17 .
in this section we will investigate the solutions of 5d einstein equations @xmath18 here @xmath19 are 5-bein indices ; @xmath20 and @xmath21 are 5d ricci tensor and the scalar curvature respectively ; @xmath22 .
the investigated metric is @xmath23 the functions @xmath24 and @xmath25 are the even functions ; @xmath26 is the magnetic charge .
the corresponding equations are @xmath27 the solution of maxwell equation is @xmath28 here @xmath29 is the electric charge .
it is interesting that equations - have not any contribution from the electric field .
nevertheless the electric field has an influence on the solution due the equation for initial values at the point @xmath30 @xmath31 as @xmath32 .
the first analysis was done in ref .
@xcite : the conclusion is that the solution depends on the magnitude of the magnetic charge @xmath26 .
it is found that the solutions to the metric in eq .
( [ sec2 - 20 ] ) evolve in the following way : 1 .
the solution is _ a finite flux tube _ located between two surfaces at @xmath34 where @xmath35 .
the throat between the @xmath34 surfaces is filled with electric flux .
2 . @xmath36 .
the solution is again _ a finite flux tube_. the throat between the surfaces at @xmath34 is filled with both electric and magnetic fields .
3 . @xmath37 . in this case
the solution is _ an infinite flux tube _ filled with constant electrical and magnetic fields .
the cross - sectional size of this solution is constant ( @xmath38 ) .
4 . @xmath39 . in this case
we have _ a singular finite flux tube _ located between two ( + ) and ( - ) electrical and magnetic charges located at @xmath40 . at @xmath41
this solution has real singularities which we interpret as the locations of the charges .
this solution is again _ a singular finite flux tube _ only with magnetic field filling the flux tube . in this solution
the two opposite magnetic charges are confined to a spacetime of fixed volume .
the results of numerical calculations of equations - are presented on fig .
[ fig1 ] , [ fig2 ] , [ fig4 ] and [ fig4 ] .
these numerical calculations allow us to suppose that there is the following relation between functions @xmath24 and @xmath25 @xmath43 in the next sections we will demonstrate the correctness of this relation by some approximate analytical calculations . [ fig3 ]
in this section we will consider the metric in the form @xmath45 and @xmath26 is small parameter @xmath46 .
@xmath47 the functions @xmath48 and @xmath49 are the solutions of einstein equations with @xmath44 .
the variation of equations - with respect to small perturbations @xmath50 and @xmath51 give us the following equations set @xmath52 the solution of this system is @xmath53 .
\label{sec3 - 110}\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] substituting into equation gives us @xmath54 but @xmath55 and @xmath56 therefore @xmath57 with an accuracy of @xmath58 .
in this section we will derive the solution by expansion in terms of @xmath59 . using the maple package we have obtained the solution with accuracy of @xmath60 @xmath61 + o\left ( { x}^{12}\right ) \label{sec4 - 40}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here we have introduced the following dimensionless parameters : @xmath62 and @xmath63 . the substitution in eq .
shows that it is valid .
one of the most important question here is : how long is the @xmath0string ?
let us determine the length of the @xmath0string as @xmath64 where @xmath65 is the place where @xmath66 ( at these points @xmath67 and @xmath68 ) .
this is very complicated problem because we have not the analytical solution and the numerical calculations indicate that @xmath65 depends very weakly from @xmath69 parameter : the big magnitude of this parameter leads to the relative small magnitude of @xmath65 .
the expansion allows us to assume that @xmath70 here @xmath71 ; @xmath72 .
if @xmath73 then @xmath74 using the maple package we have obtained @xmath75 with accuracy of @xmath76 @xmath77 it is easy to see that this series coincides with @xmath78 .
therefore we can assume that in the first rough approximation @xmath79
\right \}. \label{sec4 - 80}\ ] ] it allows us to estimate the length @xmath80 of the @xmath0string from equation as @xmath81 \right \ } = 2a(0 ) .
\label{sec4 - 90}\ ] ] for @xmath82 we have @xmath83 one can compare this result with the numerical calculations : @xmath84 , @xmath85 , @xmath86 ; @xmath87 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 ; @xmath90 , @xmath91 , @xmath92 .
we see that @xmath93 and @xmath94 have the same order .
this evaluation should be checked up ( in future investigations ) more carefully as the convergence radius of our expansion - is unknown .
the numerical calculations presented on fig s - show that the @xmath0string approximately can be presented as a finite tube with the constant cross section and a big length joint at the ends with two short tubes which have variable cross section , see fig . . for the model of the central tube
we take the part of the infinite flux tube solution with @xmath37 @xcite @xmath95 here we have parallel electric @xmath15 and magnetic @xmath16 fields with equal electric @xmath29 and magnetic @xmath26 charges . for a model of two peripheral ends ( cones )
we take the solution with @xmath44 ( equations - ) . here
we have only the electric field @xmath15 - . at the ends of the @xmath0string ( @xmath96 ) the function @xmath97 and
the term @xmath98 in equations - is zero that allows us to set this term as zero at the peripheral cones .
we have to join the components of metric on the @xmath99 ( here @xmath100 ) .
@xmath101 here @xmath102 and @xmath103 mean that the corresponding quantities are the metric components for @xmath104 and @xmath44 solutions respectively .
according to equations - @xmath105 \label{sec5 - 60}\\ \tilde{\tilde{a}}(r_1 ) & = & \tilde{a}(r_1 ) = a(0 ) \label{sec5 - 65}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath106 from equation - is replaced with @xmath107 and some coefficient @xmath6 is introduced as equations - with @xmath44 have the terms like @xmath108 and @xmath109 only .
it gives us @xmath110 since for the long @xmath0string @xmath111 .
the next joining is for @xmath112 here the constant term @xmath113 is added to solution @xmath114 since again equations - have @xmath115 and @xmath116 terms only .
consequently @xmath117 the last component of the metric is @xmath118 for the electric field we have @xmath119 and consequently @xmath120 thus our final result for this section is that at the first rough approximation the @xmath0string looks like to a tube with constant cross section and two cones attached to its ends .
in this section we want to present a model of attachment of the @xmath0string to a spacetime .
maybe the most important question for the @xmath0string is : what will see an external observer living in the universe to which the @xmath0string is attached . whether he will see a dyon with electric and magnetic fields or an electric charge ?
this question is not very simple as it is not very clear what is it the electric and magnetic fields on the @xmath0string .
are they the tensor @xmath11 and fields @xmath121 and @xmath122 @xmath123 or something another that is like to an electric displacement @xmath124 and @xmath125 ?
the answer on this question depends on the way how we will continue the solution behind the hypersurface @xmath126 ( where @xmath127 ) .
we have two possibilities : the first way is the simple continuation our solution to @xmath128 , the second way is a string approach - attachment the @xmath0string to a spacetime . in the first case @xmath129 by @xmath130 and @xmath131 by @xmath128
it means that by @xmath128 the time and 5th coordinate @xmath132 becomes respectively space - like and time - like dimensions .
it is not so good for us .
the second approach is like to a string attached to a d - brane .
we believe that physically the second way is more interesting .
let us consider maxwell equations in the 5d kaluza - klein theory @xmath133 here @xmath134 .
these 5d maxwell equations are similar to maxwell equations in the continuous media where the factor @xmath135 is like to a permittivity for @xmath136 equation and a permeability for @xmath137 equations .
it allows us offer the following conditions for matching the electric and magnetic fields at the attachment point of @xmath0 string to the spacetime @xmath138 here the subscript @xmath139 means that this quantity is given on the @xmath0string and on l.h.s there are the quantities belonging to the @xmath0string and on the r.h.s .
the corresponding quantities belong to the spacetime to which we want to attach the @xmath0string . as an example one can join the @xmath0string to the reissner - nordstrm solution with the metric @xmath140 then on the @xmath0string @xmath141 for the reissner - nordstrm solution @xmath142 therefore after joining on the event horizon @xmath143 ( @xmath144 ) we have @xmath145 here we took into account that @xmath146 . for equation
we have @xmath147 on the surface of joining @xmath148 consequently we have very unexpected result : the continuation of @xmath149 ( and magnetic field @xmath150 ) from the @xmath0string to the spacetime ( d - brane ) gives us zero magnetic field @xmath150 .
finally our result for this section is that the @xmath0string can be attached to a spacetime by such a way that it looks like to an electric charge but not magnetic one .
such approach to the geometrical interpretation of electric charges suddenly explain why we do not observe magnetic charges in the world .
in this paper we have considered some interesting properties of the @xmath0string .
we have shown that there is the relation between the metric components .
physically this relation shows that the cross section of @xmath0string is the same order on the interval @xmath151 .
in fact we can choose the cross section as @xmath1 that guarantees us that the cross section of @xmath0string is in planck region everywhere between points @xmath34 where the @xmath0string can be attached to d - branes .
it is shown that in some rough approximation the length of @xmath0string depends logarithmically from a small number which is connected with the difference between @xmath152 .
the calculations presented here give us an additional certainty that the string can have an inner structure and in gravity such string is the @xmath0string .
this approach is similar to einstein point of view that the electron has an inner structure which can be described inside of a gravitational theory as a vacuum topologically non - trivial solution .
another interesting peculiarity is that the gravitational flux tube solutions appear in a relatively simple matter in the classical 5d gravity .
this is in contrast with quantum chromodynamic where receiving a flux tube stretched between quark and antiquark is an unresolved problem . in both cases strings
are some approximation for the tubes .
it is possible that it is a manifestation of some nontrivial mapping between a classical gravity and a quantum field theory .
it is necessary to note that similar idea was presented in ref .
@xcite : the matching of two remote regions was done using 4d infinite flux tube which is the levi - civita - bertotti - robinson solution filled with the electric and magnetic fields .
i am very grateful to the istc grant kr-677 for the financial support .
v. dzhunushaliev , class .
grav . , * 19 * , 4817 ( 2002 ) ; v. dzhunushaliev , phys .
b. , * 553 * , 289 ( 2003 ) ; v. dzhunushaliev , `` @xmath0string - a hybrid between wormhole and string '' , gr - qc/0301046 . | the properties of 5d gravitational flux tubes are considered . with the cross section and 5th dimension in the planck region such tubes
can be considered as string - like objects , namely @xmath0strings . a model of attachment of @xmath0string to a spacetime
is offered .
it is shown that the attachment point is a model of an electric charge for an observer living in the spacetime .
magnetic charges are forbidden in this model .
_ dept .
phys . and microel . engineer . , krsu , bishkek , + kievskaya str .
44 , 720000 , kyrgyz republic _ |
the complex relationships among the nearby dwarf spheroidal ( dsph ) galaxies , the globular clusters and the general halo of our galaxy are far from clear , though all belong to baade s ( 1944 ) original population ii .
it is of interest to discuss the similarities and differences of their stellar populations in terms of possible scenarios for the origin of the galactic halo . according to eggen , lynden - bell & sandage ( 1962 ) the galactic halo , including the globular clusters , formed in a single monolithic event of gravitational collapse lasting about @xmath0 years .
during that time , the vast majority of halo stars and stars in the globulars formed to provide the present population ii .
an alternative scenario was suggested by searle & zinn ( 1978 ) in which the halo was accumulated by the capture of many small systems such as dsphs over a timescale at least an order of magnitude longer .
many current versions of hierarchical galaxy formation theories invoke similar scenarios ( e.g. klypin et al .
1999 , moore et al .
strong observational evidence in favor of at least some contribution of dsph systems to the halo was first provided by ibata , gilmore & irwin ( 1994 ) with the discovery that the galaxy is currently capturing the sagittarius system ( sgr ) with its attendant globular clusters .
more recent evidence ( e.g. yanny et al .
2003 , martin et al .
2004 ) indicates that the galaxy may well be absorbing or has absorbed additional systems .
in addition , the complicated history of gradual metal growth in @xmath1 centauri indicates that it probably orbited our galaxy for several gyr before being captured ( hughes & wallerstein 2000 ; hilker & richtler 2000 ) . that the galaxy , as well as m31 and presumably other similar spirals , are intimately surrounded by a number of dsphs
is made particularly clear in the graphic 3-dimensional galaxy distribution map of the local group given in grebel ( 1999 ) .
a full review of current ideas regarding the formation of the galaxy can be found in freeman & bland - hawthorn ( 2002 ) .
one approach that helps to constrain formation scenarios is to compare the populations of the surviving dsph systems with that of the halo .
if the halo is indeed made up in large part by dissolved systems initially like the dsphs we see today , one would expect to find many similarities in their stellar
. of various methods of comparison , three stand out as potentially the most viable .
the first is a comparison of the types and period distributions of variable stars ( renzini 1980 ) .
this method is not currently useable because of selection effects that plague any census of variables in the halo , although various surveys such as the sloan digital sky survey should help pin these down . the second is to compare the cmds in detail and try to set limits on the percentage of present day dsph populations that may have contributed to the halo . by comparing the turnoff colors in these systems , unavane , wyse & gilmore ( 1996 )
have set an upper limit of @xmath2 on this contribution , as the intermediate - age stars generally found in dsphs are lacking in the halo , hinting that dsphs may not be the generic galactic building blocks they are often imagined to be .
the third approach is a direct comparison of the detailed chemical compositions of stars from the two environments , based on high resolution spectroscopy .
a large sample of galactic field stars with detailed abundance analyses is now available ( e.g. mcwilliam 1997 ; burris et al .
2000 ; ryan , norris & beers 1996 , carretta et al .
2002 , nissen & schuster 1997 , fulbright 2002 , johnson 2002 , gratton et al . 2003a , stephens and boesgaard 2002 ) .
a kinematic analysis of these and other galactic field stars shows most belong to the halo below [ fe / h ] = -1 , although several thick disk stars have metallicities that extend below [ fe / h ] = -2 ( venn et al .
2004 ) . here
, we assume that stars with [ fe / h ] below -1 are representative of the galactic halo .
the complementary studies of stars in dsph systems have only recently begun . in a pioneering study , shetrone , bolte & stetson ( 1998 ) investigated four stars in the draco dsph .
they found a metallicity range from [ fe / h ] = @xmath3 to @xmath4 with a mean value of [ @xmath5/fe ] of + 0.2 and a spread in [ o / fe ] from + 0.38 to @xmath6 .
subsequently , shetrone , ct , & sargent ( 2001 - hereafter s01 ) published results for an additional two stars in draco , six in ursa minor and 5 in sextans , and shetrone et al .
( 2003 - hereafter s03 ) added five giants each in carina and sculptor ( hereafter scl ) , three in fornax and two in leo i. combining their studies , they find that at a given the dsph giants exhibit significantly lower [ /fe ] abundance ratios than stars in the galactic halo .
they conclude that the general galactic halo could not be built up of stars like those seen in their dsph samples . however , they find that a small subset of stars , represented by the , high @xmath7 , high @xmath8 halo stars studied by nissen & schuster ( 1997 ) , do mimic the dsph stars of similar in their detailed chemical composition and support nissen & schuster s claim that up to 50% of the halo could be explained by dsph accretion , although this relied on only two dsph stars of the appropriate .
however , venn et al . ( 2004 ) further analysed the nissen & schuster ( 1997 ) stars and find that the ni - na relationship , the basis for the s03 claim about 50% of the metal - rich halo possibly being stripped dsphs , is a general nucleosynthetic signature and not relevant to the discussion of merged galaxies .
finally , bonifacio et al . (
2000 ) , bonifacio and caffau ( 2003 ) , bonifacio et al .
( 2004 ) and smecker - hane & mcwilliam ( 2002 ) have studied a large sample of stars in the sgr dsph .
the latter find significant differences between sgr and galactic field stars of comparable , in particular with regards to al , na and elements , in the same sense as for the samples of shetrone and collaborators .
bonifacio et al .
( 2004 ) suggest that the chemical similarities of dsphs and damped lysystems , particularly in regard to their depressed , may demonstrate a common evolutionary history and nature .
gratton et al ( 2003a ) have used kinematics to divide field subdwarfs and early subgiants into two subpopulations , one which they ascribe to a dissipational collapse and one that is likely to represent accreted stars . in particular , they have compared the ratios of alpha - elements to iron in the two subpopulations .
they find that on average the supposed accreted population has lower [ /fe ] than their dissipative collapse counterparts .
if the accreted stars have been accumulated by the capture of systems like scl , their compositions should be similar to those of scl . to expand the data base for dsph galaxies and to further test the hypothesis that the halo of the milky way may have been sculpted " from galaxies like scl
, we have observed 4 red giants in the scl galaxy .
scl was one of the first two dsph companions to the milky way to be discovered ( shapley 1938 ) .
indeed , as the prototype , dsph galaxies were originally referred to as scl - like systems " ( e.g. shapley 1943 ) .
photometry in scl ( e.g. da costa 1984 , schweitzer et al .
1995 ) has shown that the red giant branch is broad , indicating a spread in metallicity ( as is seen in all dsphs and in @xmath1 cen ) . in a survey of 37 red giants in scl , tolstoy et al .
( 2001 ) used the ir caii triplet to derive metallicities rather than [ ca / h ] which was actually measured .
the translation from [ ca / h ] to can be problematical ( e.g. cole et al .
2000 ) , especially when [ ca / fe ] may vary between program objects and abundance calibrators . ] ranging from @xmath9 down to @xmath10 dex with most of the stars distributed between @xmath11 and @xmath12 .
the distribution is asymmetric with a mean of @xmath13 and a peak near @xmath11 .
both the mean and spread are very similar to @xmath1 cen ( norris , freeman & mighell 1996 ; sunzeff & kraft 1996 ) but the asymmetry in @xmath1 cen is opposite to that of scl with the peak of the distribution on the metal - poor side of the mean . apparently the two systems had slightly different rates of self - enrichment and star formation .
scl provides an excellent opportunity to compare the compositions of dsph stars with those in the halo . at a distance of 87 kpc ( mateo 1998 ) ,
it is one of the nearest dsphs .
its brightest giants , at @xmath14 , are therefore accessible to 8m - class telescopes equipped with high resolution spectrographs . since scl shows a spread in metallicity , there is the possibility to compare the ratios of various species to iron as a function of metallicity with the same elemental ratios in the halo field and the globular clusters . additionally , detailed abundances are required to disentangle age from effects when attempting to derive the star formation and chemical enrichment history of scl , as discussed by tolstoy et al .
( 2003 ) for their age determinations .
photometric data alone are not sufficient to break the age - metallicity degeneracy present in old intermediate age stellar systems .
accurate age determinations require the knowledge of the element as well as .
scl also is unusual or even unique in several respects .
it appears to be composed mainly or almost exclusively of an old , globular cluster- aged population ( e.g. da costa 1984 , hurley - keller et al . 1999 ,
monkiewicz et al . 1999 ,
dolphin 2002 ) . however , there are some blue stars brighter than the turnoff ( demers & battinelli 1998 ) and it may contain neutral h gas ( carignan et al .
1998 , bouchard et al . 2003 ) .
walcher et al .
( 2002 ) find evidence for tidal tails .
hurley - keller et al . ( 1999 ) , majewski et al . ( 1999 ) and harbeck et al . ( 2001 ) found a gradient in the morphology of the horizontal branch , with a much higher percentage of red hb stars in the inner regions than in the outer regions .
harbeck et al .
( 2001 ) found scl to have the most significant hb morphology gradient of any of their sample of 9 dsphs .
majewski et al . even suggested the possibility of a bimodal distribution based on their cmd .
however , tolstoy et al . ( 2001 ) found no indication for either a gradient or bimodality in their low resolution spectroscopic for a large sample of stars .
because of its importance , several groups independently began high resolution studies of scl stars .
after we began our study we became aware of the other groups .
the results of one of these groups have subsequently been published ( s03 ) and we have combined our results with theirs .
this allows for a substantial increase in sample size and coverage , allowing us to investigate any abundance trends with much greater confidence .
an additional aspect of a detailed analysis of scl s red giants is the internal evolution of the stars themselves .
while all highly evolved , metal - poor , low - mass red giants show evidence of extra - mixing beyond the canonical first dredge - up ( see references in , e.g. , weiss & charbonnel 2003 ) , the degree of mixing may depend on the initial stellar metallicity . in both field and globular cluster stars near the red giant tip , the very low @xmath15c/@xmath16c ratio , ranging from @xmath174 to 8 , can be unambiguously attributed to an in situ ( evolutionary ) mixing mechanism .
we can test the universality of this phenomenon by deriving the carbon isotopic ratios for our two most metal - rich stars . on the other hand ,
the o / fe , na / fe , and al / fe ratios vary greatly from star to star in globular clusters .
the abundance anomalies of these isotopes from higher p - burning cycles , which are not seen in field halo stars , seem to be mostly of primordial origin according to the preponderance of observational evidence ( e.g .. , gratton et al .
2001 ; grundhal et al .
2002 ; yong et al .
massive agb stars have been claimed to be the favorite candidates to have polluted the intracluster gas or the surface of cluster stars ( e.g. , cottrell & da costa 1981 ; ventura et al .
however fenner et al . (
2004 ) recently showed that the abundance patterns observed in a classical " globular cluster like ngc 6752 could not be matched by a model of chemical evolution incorporating self - consistently the detailed nucleosynthesis yields from agb stars . in particular , neither the o - na nor the mg - al anticorrelations could be reproduced , in agreement with the previous findings by denissenkov & herwig ( 2003 ) and herwig ( 2004 ) .
so the details of this primordial ( or pollution ) scenario still await clarification . by investigating the relative abundances of o , na and al we can see how the presence of these chemical variations depends on environment and probe the connection between dsphs and globular clusters . our paper is arranged as follows : in section 2 we present the observations and reductions and in 3 the details of the abundance analysis . in 4
we present the abundance results .
the heavy element star we discovered is discussed in detail in section 5 . in section 6
we summarize our major findings .
echelle spectra of four giants in scl were obtained on the nights of september 18 and 19 , 2000 with the uves instrument on the 8.2 m vlt ut2 telescope ( kueyen ) of the european southern observatory .
the target stars were selected from the study of schweitzer et al .
( 1995 ) as being amongst the brightest giant members ( with proper motion membership probabilities @xmath18 ) and covering the full color width near the tip of the giant branch .
this latter should reflect to first order as complete coverage of the full range as possible .
each star was observed for a total of four hours , divided into one - hour exposures .
the stars were observed simultaneously through the blue and red arms of uves using a dichroic beam splitter .
this yields complete coverage from @xmath19 in the red except for loss of a single order near the center where there is a gap between the two ccds , and complete coverage from @xmath20 in the blue .
the resolving power with a @xmath21 slit is about 22,000 in the red and 16,000 in the blue .
the seeing was generally @xmath22 .
spectra of hot , rapidly rotating stars were also obtained in order to divide out telluric absorption lines .
the data were sky subtracted , reduced to one - dimensional wavelength calibrated spectra , and then the individual spectra for each star were co - added , using the standard software packages available in iraf . typical s / n ratios for the final combined spectra are about 120 per pixel at 6700 and 65 per pixel at 4500 .
radial velocities of all 4 stars , given in table 1 , show that they are indeed members , as the mean radial velocity of scl stars is @xmath23 ( mateo 1998 ) . combining our four velocities with five velocities in s03
, we find a mean of + 110.0 km - s@xmath24 , with a dispersion ( standard deviation ) of 6.9 km s@xmath24 .
a small segment of spectrum is shown for a metal - poor star ( 195 , with [ fe / h]= -2.1 ) and for a more metal - rich star ( 1446 , with [ fe / h]= -1.2 ) in figure 1 .
the difference in the line strengths is obvious ; as the stars have rather similar effective temperatures and gravities which would lead to only very modest differences in line absorption for the same abundances , most of the differences in the observed line strengths are caused by abundance differences .
this is the most graphic evidence for a real abundance spread in this dsph .
one of the fundamental parameters needed in stellar abundance analyses is the effective temperature of the star in question .
the procedure in this study is to base effective temperatures on two broadband color ( v k and j
k ) calibrations of t@xmath25 .
table 1 lists the stars observed along with various apparent and absolute magnitudes and colors and the derived radial velocities .
the star designations , v - magnitudes and ( b v ) colors are taken from schweitzer et al . (
the two - micron all sky survey ( 2mass ) database , accessed via `` http://irsa.ipac.caltech.edu '' , is the source of the k - magnitudes and ( j k ) colors .
the 2mass magnitudes and colors have been transformed to the system defined by bessell & brett ( 1988 ) , as we use t@xmath25-calibrations from bessell , castelli & plez ( 1998 ) , who use the color system defined in bessell & brett ( 1988 ) .
the 2mass corrections are those defined by carpenter ( 2001 ) in his appendix a and are fairly small : a constant 0.04 magnitude offset in k , and a small color term that is about 0.03 magnitude in ( j k ) .
the v - magnitudes used to compute ( v k ) are corrected for reddening based on the ( b v ) color excess of @xmath26 ( mateo 1998 ) and a@xmath27= 3.3e(b v ) .
no absorption correction is applied to k , since the overall reddening to scl is quite small and @xmath28 .
in addition , in table 1 are the absolute k - magnitudes ( for a true distance modulus of @xmath29 - mateo 1998 ) , along with k - band bolometric corrections from bessell et al .
( 1998 ) and the subsequent absolute bolometric magnitudes and luminosities .
effective temperatures are derived for the program stars using the ( v k ) and ( j k ) colors from table 1 , along with calibrations discussed and defined in bessell et al .
these authors point out that ( v k ) versus t@xmath25 has almost no sensitivity to metallicity ( hereafter taken as [ fe / h ] ) so long as t@xmath25 is greater than @xmath174000k , while ( j k ) has only a small dependency ; their near independence from [ fe / h ] is why these two colors are used .
table 2 lists effective temperatures for each star as defined by ( v k ) and ( j k ) colors . with just the four program stars in question ,
there is no systematic offset between the two sets of t@xmath25 s , and their differences scatter around 100k with no systematic trend . for the final t@xmath25 to be used in the abundance analyses , we adopt the average of the two values and round this to the nearest 25k in defining the model atmosphere effective temperature ( shown in column 4 of table 2 ) .
other color effective temperature relations are available in the literature and we compare one other source ( mcwilliam 1990 ) to the calibrations used here . using mcwilliam s ( v k ) calibration and comparing it to the values of colors and t@xmath25 s in tables 1 and 2 , the mean difference ( in the sense of bessell et al .
( 1998 ) minus mcwilliam ) and standard deviation is found to be + 7@xmath3019k : very good agreement . using ( j
k ) , the mean and standard deviation are + 90@xmath3051k .
this comparison suggests that these various temperature scales for the types of red giants analyzed here are in good agreement with differences of less than about 100k . with an effective temperature scale defined by broadband colors ,
the remaining global stellar parameters of surface gravity ( parameterized as log g ) , microturbulent velocity ( @xmath31 ) , and overall metallicity ( defined by the fe abundance ) are set by the fe i and fe ii lines .
the spectroscopic analysis of the fe lines , as well as all of the other elements to be discussed , uses a recent version of the lte spectrum synthesis code moog , first described by sneden ( 1973 ) .
the model atmospheres adopted are those generated from a version of the marcs code as discussed by gustafsson et al .
the combination of lte analysis from moog using marcs model atmospheres has been used extensively in abundance analyses of k - giants , and yields accurate chemical abundances of many species .
recent examples of similar analyses of red giants includes ivans et al .
( 1999 , 2001 ) , ramirez et al .
( 2001 ) , and s01 and s03 .
the microturbulent velocity , at a given log g , is found by forcing all fe i lines to yield the same iron abundance , i.e. , with no significant slope of a(fe)+ 12.0 . ] versus reduced equivalent width ( log ( w/@xmath32 ) .
once the microturbulent velocity is defined , the surface gravity is tested for consistency by comparing the fe i and fe ii abundances , with ionization equilibrium demanding both neutral and singly ionized fe to yield the same abundances .
the now determined stellar parameters ( t@xmath25 , log g , and @xmath31 ) along with the fe i and fe ii lines are then used to derive the overall metallicity of the stellar atmosphere .
the entire process of defining log g , @xmath31 , and [ fe / h ] is iterated until a consistent set of stellar and model atmosphere parameters is found , and this atmosphere is finally used in the derivation of the other elemental abundances . when enforcing the ionization equilibrium of fe i and fe ii to derive surface gravity in metal - poor red giants , some care should be taken to investigate the possible influence of over - ionization on fe i , as discussed by thevenin & idiart ( 1999 ) .
data from three recent analyses of globular cluster giants can be used to partially address this question : ivans et al .
( 1999 ) for m4 , ramirez et al .
( 2001 ) for m71 , and ivans et al .
( 2001 ) for m5 .
in all these studies , `` evolutionary '' gravities are calculated from stellar model tracks ( with known masses ) coupled to the derived red - giant effective temperatures and luminosities .
iron abundances are then computed and can be compared between fe i and fe ii . from the three studies noted above , no significant effect
is seen over the metallicity range from [ fe / h]= -0.84 ( for m71 with @xmath33(fe i
fe ii)= + [email protected] ) , to [ fe / h]= -1.15 ( for m4 with @xmath33(fe i
fe ii)= [email protected] ) , and [ fe / h]= -1.21 ( for m5 with @xmath33(fe i
fe ii)= [email protected] ) . based on the above observational constraints ,
overionization may affect derived gravities by @xmath17 0.1 dex , and possibly lead to small over / underestimates of the iron abundance by @xmath17 0.1 dex . such a possibility will not , however , have a significant effect on the derived abundances and abundance trends to be discussed here . the derived effective temperatures , gravities , microturbulent velocities , and iron abundances are listed in table 2 .
the iron abundances are derived using the accurate sets of gf - values from martin , fuhr , & wiese ( 1988 ) , bard , kock , & kock ( 1991 ) , holweger et al .
( 1991 ) , and obrian et al .
it is worth noting that the absolute accuracy of these fe gf - values is now at the few percent level , and an analysis of solar fe i and fe ii lines yields photospheric iron abundances with a scatter of @xmath17 0.05 dex and essentially perfect agreement with the meteoritic abundance ( a(fe)= 7.50 - grevesse & sauval ( 1999 ) ) .
table 3 gives relevant parameters for all of our measured fe lines .
we will later combine our abundances to those derived by s03 for five other sculptor red giants in order to create a larger database .
abundances will be given as values of [ x / fe ] so we must check for any offsets in the two abundance scales caused by either gf - values or adopted solar abundances . in the case here for iron , we note first that s03 used a(fe)= 7.52 for the sun , whereas we adopt 7.50 ; to strictly compare our respective fe abundances , we should add + 0.02 dex to the s03 values to bring them onto our scale .
in addition , however , a comparison of gf values for fe lines reveals that for 15 lines in common , there is a mean offset of + 0.04 dex in log gf ( in the sense of us
s03 ) . based on this difference
( if it is indicative of a general trend for all fe lines ) , we should then subtract 0.04 dex from the s03 [ fe / h ] values to bring them onto our gf - scale .
the net result of considering the adopted solar fe and gf - value scales would be to shift by -0.02 dex the s03 values of [ fe / h ] to bring them into agreement with our scale .
this is such a small offset , well within the uncertainties of the gf - values themselves and even the solar fe abundance , that we consider such a difference to be insignificant and apply no corrections to the s03 values of [ fe / h ] : both studies are effectively on the same abundance scale . of the spectral species studied here in common with smith et al .
( 2000 ) , we have adopted the gf - values from that study , and their sources are discussed in detail in that paper .
these elements are o i , na i , mg i , al i , si i , ca i , sc ii , ti i , ti ii , fe i , fe ii , ni i , y i , y ii , zr i , zr ii , ba ii , la ii , and eu ii .
smith et al .
( 2000 ) analyzed both the sun and arcturus using this linelist and gf - values and derived expected abundances , indicating that these gf - values can be used to derive accurate abundances .
in addition , we have added the species mn i and zn i in this study , with the mn i gf - values taken from prochaska & mcwilliam ( 2000 ) .
neutral zinc gf - values were adjusted to yield a solar abundance of a(zn)=4.60 using a 1-d marcs model ; this resulted in log gf= -0.44 for the 4722 line ( in excellent agreement with the value of -0.39 from s03 ) , and log gf= -0.24 for the 4810 line ( again in excellent agreement with s03 who used -0.17 ) .
a comparison of the other elemental gf - values with the same lines used by s03 finds differences of less than 0.05 dex in log gf for all cases except al i. in the case of differences having less than 0.05 dex , no offsets will be applied to the s03 abundances when adding them to our dataset .
for al i the offset is + 0.26 dex ( in the sense of us
s03 ) , this difference was applied in order to combine our sculptor aluminium abundances with those from s03 .
there are also a few other points concerning gf - values that should be noted
. two ca i lines have differing log - gf values greater than 0.05 dex ; the 6439.08 gf - value used here is 0.08 dex larger than in shetrone et al .
( 2003 ) , but this is only marginally larger than 0.05 dex .
the gf - value for the 6161.30 line ( smith et al .
2000 ) is 0.24 dex larger than that adopted by shetrone et al . ; however the particular value used here , along with a marcs solar model , yields a solar calcium abundance of a(ca)=6.25 .
this is acceptably close to the recommended value of a(ca)=6.34 from lodders ( 2003 ) .
as calcium is represented by 8 lines in this study , and 9 lines from shetrone et al .
, with the other gf - values in close agreement , the differences discussed above will not affect significantly the average ca abundances .
the mg i lines used here at 8717.83 and 8736.04 were not in smith et al .
( 2000 ) and the gf - values here are taken from the kurucz ( 1991 ) compilation .
analysis of these lines in the solar flux spectrum results in respective magnesium abundances of a(mg)=7.51 and 7.54 , close to the lodders ( 2003 ) recommended value of 7.55 .
there are no lines in common between this study and that of shetrone et al .
( 2003 ) for ti i , ti ii , y i , and y ii , but later inspections of figure 6 ( for ti ) and figure 8 ( for y ) will find no significant differences in the respective behaviors of ti and y with metallicity between the two studies .
hyperfine splitting ( hfs ) was included for the species sc ii ( with the hfs data taken from prochaska & mcwilliam 2000 ) , mn i ( hfs data also taken from prochaska & mcwilliam 2000 ) , y i ( with hfs data taken from biehl 1976 ) , la ii ( with hfs data taken from lawler , bonvallet , & sneden 2001 ) , and eu ii ( with hfs data taken from biehl 1976 ) .
for those species with multiple isotopes , solar isotopic ratios were assumed .
table 4 provides the relevant parameters for all of our measured non - fe lines , as well as their equivalent widths in the sculptor red giants .
although we present the equivalent widths , it must be noted that all abundances were derived via spectrum synthesis .
the final abundances are given in table 5 , in the form of [ x / h ] values , as well as the adopted solar abundances in the form of a(x ) .
as discussed in section 3.1 , various comparisons between ( v - k ) and ( j - k ) temperature calibrations can reveal systematic differences of up to 90k , with a scatter of 50k , thus an expected uncertainty ( @xmath171@xmath34 ) of about 100k for t@xmath25 in red giants is a reasonable value .
in addition , the 1@xmath34 scatter set by the fe i lines in defining a mean iron abundance is about 0.15 to 0.20 dex ; this scatter is carried into the determination of the surface gravity from the fe ii lines , and leads to an uncertainty here of about 0.3 dex in log g. finally , the microturbulence is defined by using the fe i lines ( with the criterion of no trend in fe abundance with reduced equivalent width ) and the minimum scatter in the fe i abundances leads to an uncertainty in @xmath31 of about 0.3 km s@xmath24 .
the uncertainties of @xmath30100k in t@xmath25 , @xmath300.3 dex in log g , and @xmath300.3 km s@xmath24 represent approximate 1@xmath34 values for these fundamental stellar parameters .
all of these elemental species present different sensitivities in their derived abundances to the primary stellar parameters of t@xmath25 , log g , and @xmath31 .
table 6 quantifies these sensitivities for star 770 , which is near the middle of our sample in terms of effective temperature , gravity , and micorturbulence ; the other stars will exhibit very similar sensitivities to changes in stellar parmaeters .
the differences for each species are tabulated for a change of + 100k in t@xmath25 , + 0.3 in log g , and + 0.3 km - s@xmath24 in @xmath31 , with the final column showing the quadratic sum of these uncertainties .
this final value is a fair estimate of the uncertainty in the derived abundances caused by realisitic uncertainties in defining the fundamental stellar parameters .
we first combine our data with that of s03 obtained with the same telescope and instrument .
this gives us a total of 9 stars in scl , the second largest sample of high resolution abundances yet obtained for a dsph , surpassed only by several sagittarius studies , with a range in [ fe / h ] from 2.10 to 0.97 .
note that this substantially extends the range of s03 s sample , which covered 1.95 to 1.2 .
we also cover most of the known range in this galaxy , based both on the extreme colors of our sample in observed cmds and the large sample of ca - triplet abundances derived by tolstoy et al .
( 2001 ) for 37 stars .
other than 2 stars with of 2.2 to 2.3 , their next most star has @xmath35 and at the end their distribution stops at 1 except for a single star with 0.8 . in particular , our combined sample allows us to see abundance trends with more clearly . also note that our spectra are of significantly higher s / n than those of s03 s scl observations .
our mean @xmath36 ( standard error of the mean ) .
this compares very well with the mean of @xmath13 found by tolstoy et al .
( 2001 ) and the mean of 1.5 found by dolphin ( 2002 ) .
we do not find any indication of a gradient , although our sample is small and only covers a limited radial range , from 0.1 1.1 core radii .
tolstoy et al .
( 2001 ) have a much larger sample and radial extent and found no gradient .
sodium is produced in the ne - na cycle in which protons are captured by the ne isotopes accompanied by the necessary @xmath37-decays .
the stellar environment for the ne - na cycle is uncertain but it can occur at relatively low temperatures , near 30 million k , in evolved stable stars .
in addition na can be produced by carbon burning which requires temperatures that can be realized only in advanced stages of stellar evolution and in massive stars . in our nine scl stars
the mean [ na / fe ] ratio is @xmath38 , with no trend with .
this ratio differs from recent analyses of globular clusters in which an excess of na is usually seen . in m15 and m92 sneden , pilachowski and kraft ( 2000 )
find [ na / fe]=+0.2 on average . in m5 ivans
et al ( 2001 ) find [ na / fe]@xmath17 -0.2 in oxygen - rich stars , rising to + 0.4 in oxygen - poor stars . in m4 ivans et al .
( 1999 ) find [ na / fe]@xmath17 0.0 for stars that do not show evidence of a deficiency of oxygen .
clearly the na deficiency seen in scl differs from the situation in the globulars . in the halo field , fulbright ( 2002 ) found that [ na / fe ] scattered around 0.0 all the way down to [ fe / h]= 4.0 with some stars showing [ na / fe ] as large as + 0.5 between [ fe / h]= 2.0 to 3.5 and some scattering down to [ na / fe ] = 0.5 between [ fe / h]= 1.5 to 2.5 .
indeed the stars in his high velocity " bin have [ na / fe ] very similar to our sample .
even if a correction of + 0.2 is added to our [ na / fe ] values to compensate for potential non - lte effects ( e.g. tautvaisiene et al . 2004 ) , our na abundances are still @xmath39 dex lower than typical galactic stars of similar metallicity .
our oxygen abundances were derived from the single 6300 line of [ oi ] , while s03 used both this line ( mainly ) as well as the 6363 line when available ( 2 stars ) .
although generally weak and only a single line , we feel that our o abundances are well - determined via the spectrum synthesis technique .
a comparison of observed and synthetic spectra covering the [ o i ] line in star 1446 is shown in figure 2 to illustrate the quality of the spectra and corresponding synthetic matches . in figure 3
we show the correlation of [ o / fe ] with [ fe / h ] for both the sculptor giants ( 8 stars sampled , with 4 from this study and 4 from s03 ) , and a sample of galactic field stars from a number of studies ( noted in the figure caption ) .
the galactic studies shown in figure 3 include those that rely either on the [ o i ] 6300 line , or the infrared vibration - rotation lines from oh . at the metal - poor end , the [ o / fe ] value is similar to , albeit a bit lower in the mean than , that which is seen in metal - poor globular clusters and the halo field ( mcwilliam 1997 ) .
however , the ratio of o / fe decreases steadily and rapidly as increases above 1.5 , reaching [ o / fe]@xmath17 0.0 at [ fe / h]= 1.2 , and the most star at @xmath40 has a very low [ o / fe ] abundance of 0.3 .
this is distinctly different from the globulars and the halo and disk field where [ o / fe ] only begins to fall dramatically at [ fe / h]=1 and does not reach zero until [ fe / h ] is near zero .
the o abundance of star 982 is some 0.6 dex lower than the mean for the at this .
note that this trend is seen much more clearly here than in s03 due to the extended range , or for that matter from our data alone , which suggest a strong monotonic decline .
as noted in the introduction , it is very important to check for the existence of any na - o ( anti)correlation in order to probe the connection between dsphs , the galactic halo and globular clusters . in figure 4
we present [ na / fe ] vs. [ o / fe ] for the sculptor red giants along with the data for galactic field stars .
there is no trend in sculptor , although note that even the low - o star 982 , the heavy element star ( see section 5 ) , shows [ na / fe]= -0.2 .
where the anti - correlation is seen , it has often been ascribed to deep mixing within the star which has carried material to the stellar surface that had been processed by the on , nena and mgal cycles ( see dennisenkov and weiss 2001 and references therein ) .
however recent observational evidence and theoretical developments ( see charbonnel & palacios 2003 and references therein ) now point toward an alternative explanation .
namely , these anomalies may be due to stochastic enrichment by an earlier generation of stars followed by scattered incorporation into some , but not all , of the stars now seen in globular clusters ( cottrell & da costa 1981 ; dantona et al .
1983 ; jehin et al . 1998 ; parmentier et al . 1999 ) .
however the major source of pollution for gcs still remains to be determined .
indeed , based on current theories of intermediate mass stellar evolution and nucleosynthesis , it now appears that massive agbs , which seemed to be the most plausible candidates for this pollution , are not responsible for the observed globular cluster abundance anomalies ( denissenkov & herwig 2003 ; herwig 2004 ; fenner et al .
2004 ) . since we see neither the o / na nor the o / al anti - correlation in the sculptor stars it appears that neither of the above scenarios ( in situ extra - mixing of nena and mgal cycle material or pollution ) that induced the anomalous chemical patterns in globular clusters has occurred in this dwarf galaxy .
the anti - correlation is never seen in field stars of the galactic halo .
these facts tend to associate sculptor with field stars rather than with globular cluster stars .
we note , however , that mcwilliam et al .
( 2003 ) have found one star in sgr with a mild excess of [ na / o ] .
the other light odd element is al for which our fragmentary data ( we only derive al abundances for the two most stars ) shows a deficiency similar to that of na , while in globulars the [ al / fe ] value varies , reaching as much as + 0.6 in m4 in stars that show no evidence for the depletion of oxygen ( ivans et al .
1999 ) .
while the na / o ratios in scl do not provide evidence for deep mixing , the ratio of @xmath15c/@xmath16c in two stars shows that moderately deep mixing has indeed occurred . for our two most metal - rich stars it was possible to derive the carbon isotope ratios from the 8005 @xmath16cn feature . for star 1446
the derived ratio is 3 with a substantial uncertainty . for the heavy element star , 982 ,
the @xmath16cn feature is strong enough for an estimate of the uncertainty and we find a ratio of @xmath42 .
we show the fit for star 982 in figure 5 . these low ratios of @xmath15c/@xmath16c are almost exactly the cno equilibrium ratio and show that the vast majority of the material presently in the stellar atmosphere has been subject to proton capture at temperatures of at least 10@xmath43k .
low @xmath15c/@xmath16c ratios are the general rule for stars near the red giant tip in the field ( charbonnel , brown & wallerstein 1998 ; gratton et al .
2000 ) , and in galactic open ( gilroy 1989 ; gilroy & brown 1991 ) and globular clusters ( see charbonnel & do nascimento 1998 for early references ; smith et al . 2000 ; shetrone 2003 ) .
the same is true for rgb stars in the lmc ( smith et al .
2002 ) and in the smc ( hill et al .
our results thus confirm the universality of an extra - mixing mechanism which transports matter between the outer layers of the hydrogen burning shell and the convective envelope in all low - mass red giants , and which is still not part of the standard evolution theory .
this extra - mixing is independent of the stellar environment and metallicity , although it has been shown to depend on the initial stellar mass . for the purposes of this section
, we will include here as alpha elements mg , si , ca and ti . see s03 for a more thorough discussion of the various nucleosynthetic origins for the alpha elements .
silicon scatters about a mean near solar while magnesium , calcium , and titanium show interesting and similar trends albeit at different significance levels , as shown in figure 6 .
all three elements show trends generally similar to that of o , with solar or enhanced and relatively constant values for the stars with @xmath44 that are generally less than those of normal galactic field stars at similar , but the more stars have significantly lower that are generally much lower than those of galactic stars of the same .
the deficit with respect to galactic field stars is in fact true for si at all as well . in the case of mg ,
the lowest star has the most enhanced and the trend of decreasing over the full range is the most pronounced . the decrease in for the most stars is smallest for ti and indeed the difference between these and the more stars is not very significant .
[ ti / fe ] is nearly constant at about solar with only a small decrease to 0.2 for the three stars near 1 .
this observed behavior in the scl stars is different from the trends in the globulars and the halo where [ ti / fe ] is usually near + 0.3 over the range of [ fe / h ] from -2 to -1 ; though some metal - poor globulars show nearly the solar ratios ( lee and carney , 2002 ) .
in fact , models of type ii supernovae usually place ti as an iron - peak element rather than associate it with the alpha - elements ( arnett 1996 ) .
it appears that in scl ti follows snii models better than do most of the globulars and field stars of low metallicty .
but models comparing the relative yields of snii and ia ( e.g. lee and carney 2002 , fig .
9 , based on woosley and weaver 1995 models ) show that ti is _ the _ element most produced in snii s compared to snia s .
shetrone ( 2004 ) suggested that the light " ( o and mg ) and heavy " ( ca and ti ) elements may show differences in their behavior due to potential differences in their nucleosynthetic origins .
we find that the mean enhancements of mg and ca in scl ( 0.08 and 0.11 dex ) are very similar but o ( 0.22 dex ) is significantly enhanced with respect to ti ( -0.08 dex ) and thus there is no clear trend .
all of the elements from sc to zn are usually ascribed to the fe - peak though a few of the odd elements may be enhanced by small neutron - capture processes .
the relative abundances of sc , mn , cu , and zn are shown in figure 7 .
in galactic metal - poor stars sc follows fe very uniformly ( mcwilliam 1997 ) . in scl , between [ fe / h]=-2.1 and -1.5
, sc follows fe just as in the galaxy , although the mean [ sc / fe ] is slightly less than in the galaxy .
but the higher scl stars deviate significantly from their galactic counterparts : [ sc / fe ] begins to decrease at a of 1.5 and drops rapidly to about 0.5 by [ fe / h]=-1.0 , very reminiscent of the general behavior .
we know of no other object in which this phenomenon occurs . for cr we must rely on the data of s03 whose
cr / fe ratios for 5 stars lie close to -0.15 dex which is very similar to field stars in the halo ( mcwilliam 1997 , fig .
the mean [ mn / fe ] ratio is near -0.4 which is similar to that in halo field stars of the same metallicity interval .
however the [ mn / fe ] values for the largest and smallest deficiencies of fe suggest a small downward trend in [ mn / fe ] with [ fe / h ] . while the reality of this trend , which only depends on the two endpoints , is uncertain , especially when the error bars are taken seriously , the trend appears to be real . if so , this trend is contrary to the rise of mn with fe seen in the galactic halo , thick disk and bulge ( e.g. mcwilliam et al .
2003 ) . for co /
fe the 4 stars analysed by s03 also track iron as do the halo field stars with [ fe / h ] @xmath45 .
the same holds for the ni / fe ratio . for cu
the story is very different . in the 5 stars for which we have derived copper abundances , with [ fe / h ] between -1.2 and -1.8 , the values of [ cu / fe ] are very near -1.0 with a hint of a downward trend with , significantly different from the field halo stars and stars in @xmath1 cen , where it is close to -0.5 in the same interval of [ fe / h ] ( mcwilliam 1997 , cunha et al .
the field stars show a significant slope , reaching -0.8 dex in [ cu / fe ] versus [ fe / h ] at [ fe / h]=-2.5 .
mishenina et al .
( 2002 ) find a steady decrease in [ cu / fe ] with decreasing [ fe / h ] .
however , over the interval of [ fe / h]= 1.2 to 1.8 , their data are consistent with [ cu / fe]=0.5 . finally for zn
there appears to be no mean trend away from [ zn / fe]@xmath17 0.0 , as seen in the halo field stars , but it appears that there may be a bifurcation , with one group of scl stars with [ zn / fe]@xmath46 and another with [ zn / fe]@xmath47 .
elements heavier than zn are known to be produced by neutron capture .
the two neutron capture phenomena are the slow ( s - process ) capture sequence in which the time scale for beta - decay is shorter than the time scale between neutron captures and the rapid ( r - process ) capture sequence in which a flood of neutrons ( or a burst of nuclear reactions whose results mimic neutron captures ) drives the nuclei to extremely neutron - heavy isotopes which finally decay to the valley of stability .
the readily observable s - process species may be divided into the light ( ls ) group which consists of rb , sr , y , and zr ; and the heavy ( hs ) group which consists of ba , la and the light rare earths .
the only observable r - process element in our stars is eu .
the heavier r - process species have lines that are too weak to be measurable on our spectra . starting with the ls elements , either y , zr , or both are available in 8 stars of the combined data . ignoring for the moment the most star ( 982 ) , the mean ls ( using the average of y and zr when available ) is 0.26 with a large @xmath48 scatter of 0.4 dex and no trend .
this value is very low compared to galactic field stars ( e.g. fulbright 2002 ) .
as shown in figure 8 , star 982 is unique , standing far above all the other stars with [ y / fe]= 1.1 .
this is a heavy element star !
we discuss this star in detail in section 5 .
the [ hs / fe ] data ( taking the mean of ba and la ) scatter around a value of 0.1 with no trend , as shown in figure 9 ( omitting the heavy element star 982 which again is remarkable , as seen from this figure ) . with two exceptions ,
the scl stars mimic their counterparts in [ hs / fe ] .
[ eu / fe ] ( figure 10 ) appears to decrease from near + 0.7 at [ fe / h]@xmath49 to @xmath17 solar at [ fe / h]=1.2 , although the trend again is mainly determined by only two stars .
once again we omit the heavy element star 982 in which there is a huge excess of eu . with the exception of these three stars ,
the remainder are in good agreement with the mean for similar stars .
perhaps the best discriminator of the relative importance of s - process to r - process enhancement is the behavior of [ ba / eu ] as a function of . in figure 11
we present our scl results .
the long dashed line below represents the pure r - process ratio from arlandini et al .
( 1999 ) , while the long dashed line above represents the pure s - process ratio . in the galaxy , this ratio is @xmath50 constant at @xmath51 throughout the halo regime but begins to rise at @xmath52 and reaches a solar value near = 0.4 , significantly above the r - process line but well below the s - process value .
scl has a unique behavior in this diagram .
the most stars follow the . however , the stars more than = -1.5 follow an upward trend reaching to [ ba / eu]=+0.5 at = 1 , some 0.8 dex above the value .
note that the heavy element star 982 does not stand out in this diagram as being unusual but only extends the trend begun by its nearest companions in .
the rise in [ ba / eu ] for scl from figure 11 occurs near [ fe / h]= -1.5 , while in field stars no such rise is seen until [ fe / h]@xmath53 . in @xmath1 cen , however , there is a much steeper increase between [ fe / h]= -2.0 and -1.4 , as shown in figure 11 , plotted as the filled squares .
other s - process species show a similar rise in @xmath1 cen ( e.g. vanture , wallerstein , & brown 1994 , norris & da costa 1995 , smith et al .
2000 ) . in the galaxy ,
note that the metal - poor stars have an @xmath50 r - process ratio , which gradually increases towards the s - process value as [ fe / h ] increases ; this reflects the increasingly important contribution to the heavy elements from agb stars as the galaxy evolves chemically .
@xmath1 cen is known to be heavily influenced in its chemical evolution by agb stars and this is shown by the rapid increase ( in terms of an increase in [ fe / h ] ) to a pure s - process ratio in ba / eu as fe increases .
the s / r - process chemical evolution in scl appears to have been intermediate to that experienced by the milky way and @xmath1 cen .
however , note that johnson and bolte ( 2001 ) found that the interpretation of ba in this metallicity range is complicated .
galactic ba abundances from the 4554 line can show a rise in ba / eu occuring at very low metallicities ( around 2.0 ) , which is very unlikely to be due to s - process enrichments since they are not matched by la / eu enhancement .
this line is not used in our analysis nor that of s03 .
venn et al .
( 2004 ) showed that this ba / eu early rise is also seen in other dsph stars .
figure 12 compares a small portion of one of the orders from the spectrum of stars 1446 ( top ) and 982 ( bottom ) .
note that these stars have similar effective temperatures and fe abundances , as evidenced by the similarity in the strengths of the fei lines .
however , note the immense strength of lines due to the s - process elements zirconium and barium , as represented by zr i and ba ii , in the spectrum of star 982 .
the unusually large ratio of all species from y to eu relative to fe mark sc982 as a heavy element star .
such stars are extremely rare in our halo but several have been found now in dsphs ( s01 , s03 ) .
there are three types of heavy element stars .
lloyd evans ( 1983 ) suggested that the heavy element stars in @xmath1 cen were formed with their observed heavy - element excess .
many galactic heavy - element stars , referred to as intrinsic " , have generated their own excess heavies .
the best example of such objects are the s stars which contain technetium .
a third type of heavy - element star has received a dose of heavies from a now defunct companion .
they are referred to as extrinsic " , and are identified by the fact that they are spectroscopic binaries with periods near a year or somewhat greater .
we have searched for the tc i lines in the 4238 - 4297 region in scl 982 and have not found them . due to the heavy blending and modest s / n of the spectrum , this test is not definitive , but is indicative that we are not dealing with a recently self - polluted s or sc star .
we have no information on a possible variable radial velocity of 982 , but its observed velocity falls within the spread of the other stars . nevertheless we can derive some useful information about the star or stars that produced the heavy elements seen in sc982 .
a useful spectroscopic criterion is the hs / ls ratio with the ls species represented by y and zr and the hs represented by ba and la .
in addition we have measured the rb abundance which is sensitive to the neutron density during the neutron capture events that added to the heavy elements .
using our observed value of 0.6 for [ hs / ls ] and figures 17 and 18 of smith ( 1997 ) , we find a neutron exposure of tau = 1.1(mb@xmath54 ) and a log n(n ) = 8.6 ( @xmath55 ) .
in addition , the ratio of 0.6 for [ hs / ls ] combined with the metallicity of [ fe / h]=-1 places sc982 among the ch stars ( vanture 1992 ) though it does not appear to have the enhanced ch and c@xmath56 shown by ch stars . hence it is possible that the star that produced the heavies was a ch star .
one phenomenon seen in many red giants in globular clusters ( but not in field stars ) is a deficiency of oxygen combined with an excess of na , as discussed above .
the enhanced na / o ratio has been explained with proton captures by both @xmath57o and the nena cycle , either within the observed red giant or by agb stars that enriched the presently observed star . a significant enhancement of the na / o ratio requires a temperature near 30 x 10@xmath58k for the required proton captures to be effective on a reasonable timescale .
the abundances of star 982 as shown in table 5 indicate a low o / fe when compared to other sculptor red giants : [ o / fe]= -0.30 , while the mean for the other stars is + [email protected] .
the plot of [ na / fe ] versus [ o / fe ] shown in figure 4 shows no strong trend , although star 982 has the lowest [ o / fe ] and largest [ na / fe ] values .
in this paper we have combined our new vlt plus uves high resolution abundance data for 4 stars in the sculptor dwarf spheroidal galaxy with similar data obtained with the same instrument for 5 stars by shetrone et al .
this extends the range of [ fe / h ] covered from -2.1 to -0.97 and allows us to distinguish a number of interesting trends of various elemental abundances with fe that were either not visible or only hinted at in the more limited dataset of s03 .
the most important single fact that emerges is that from oxygen to manganese many elements show a relatively constant elemental ratio [ x / fe ] at the end and then declining rapidly for @xmath59 , or a steadily decreasing value of [ x / fe ] as [ fe / h ] rises from -2 to -1 .
the elements showing this behavior include o , mg , ca , ti , sc and mn ( while the ba / eu ratio increases with above = 1.5 ) .
it is unique to see the same pattern for all of these elements . in particular the ratios of [ o , mg , ca / fe ] near [ fe / h ] = -2 are similar to but slightly less than their values in the galactic halo at similar , but their decline to @xmath60 solar or less near [ fe / h ]
= -1.0 rather than at [ fe / h ] = 0.0 is unique .
[ sc / fe ] and [ ti / fe ] are near solar at [ fe / h ] = -2 and become substantially negative at [ fe / h ] = -1 .
one of our prime motivations for undertaking this study was to further test the hypothesis that the halo of our may have been accreted from dsph - like objects such as scl , as first proposed by searle and zinn ( 1978 ) .
our derived composition of the scl stars does not support the suggestion that the halo of our galaxy was formed from stars such as those now seen in scl .
this point has already been made by s01 , f02 , s03 and tolstoy et al .
we find that scl stars are significantly underabundant in [ /fe ] at all with respect to typical galactic field stars .
agb stars in scl were more important in the chemical evolution of scl than in the in causing the high s - process / r - process ratios ocurring in the most stars .
finally , we find a heavy element star , with very strong enhancement of s - process elements .
we thank paranal observatory for the excellent support received during our observing run , especially from t. szeifert and g. marconi .
we would like to gratefully acknowledge m. shetrone , e. tolstoy , v. hill , k. venn , a. kaufer and f. primas for allowing us to access their results prior to publication .
t. richtler made valuable comments on an earlier draft .
special thanks to the referee , k. venn , for a very helpful , thorough and constructive job which significantly improved this paper .
this work is supported in part by the national science foundation through ast99 - 87374 and ast03 - 07534 ( vvs ) .
the contributions by gg and gw were supported by the kennilworth fund of the new york community trust .
d.g . gratefully acknowledges support from the chilean _ centro de astrofsica _ fondap no .
d.g . also kindly recognizes the warm support and constant dedication of m.e.b .
thanks the french programme national galaxies and the swiss national science foundation for financial support .
arnett , w.,d .
1996 , supernovae and nucleosynthesis , princeton university press , princeton + arlandini , c. , kappeler , f. , wisshak , k. , gallino , r. , lugaro , m. , busso , m. , & stariero , o. 1999 , apj , 525 , 886 + baade , w. 1944 , apj , 100 , 137 + baade , w. , & swope , h. h. 1961 , aj , 66 , 300 + bard , a. , kock , a. , & kock , m. 1991 , a&a , 248 , 315 + bessell , m. s. , & brett , j. m. 1988 , pasp , 96 , 247 + bessell , m. s. , castelli , f. , & plez , b. 1998 , a&a , 333 , 231 + biehl , d. 1976 , ph.d .
thesis , univ .
kiel + bonifacio , p. , et al .
2000 , a&a , 359 , 663 + bonifacio , p. , & caffau , e. 2003 , a&a , 399 , 1183 + bonifacio , p. sbordone , l. , marconi , g. , pasquini , l. & hill , v. 2004 , a&a , 414 , 503 + bouchard , a. , carignan , c. , & mashchenko , s. 2003 , aj , 126 , 1295 + burris , d.l . ,
pilachowski , c.a . ,
armandroff , t.e . ,
sneden , c. , cowan , j.j . , roe , h. 2000 , apj , 544 , 302 + carignan , c. , beaulieu , s. , cote , s. , demers , s. , & mateo , m. 1998 , aj , 116 , 1690 + carretta , e. , gratton , r. , cohen , j. g. , beers , t. c. , christlieb , n. 2002 , aj , 124 , 481 + carpenter , j. m. 2001 , aj , 121 , 2851 + charbonnel , c. , brown , j.a . , wallerstein , g. , 1998 , a&a , 332 , 204 + charbonnel , c. , do nascimento , j. , 1998 , a&a , 336 , 915 + charbonnel , c. , & palacios , a. , 2003 , proceedings of the iau symposium 215 on _ stellar rotation _
, eds a.maeder & p.eenens + cole , a.a .
, smecker - hane , t.a . , gallagher , j.s .
2000 , aj , 120 , 1808 + cottrell , p.l .
, & da costa , g.s . , 1981 ,
apj , 245 , l79 + cunha , k. , smith , v.v . , lambert , d.l .
1998 , apj , 493 , 195 + cunha , k. , smith , v.v . ,
suntzeff , n. , b. , norris , j.e . ,
da costa , g.,s . , & plez , b. 2002 aj 124,379 + da costa , g.s .
1984 , apj , 285 , 483 + dantona , f. , gratton , r. , chieffi , a. , 1983 , mem.soc.astron.it . ,
54 , 173 + demers , s. , & battinelli , p. 1998 , aj , 115 , 154 + denisenkov , p.a .
, & herwig , f. , 2003 , apj , 590 , l99 + denisenkov , p.a . , & weiss , a. , 2001 , apj , 559 , l115 + dolphin , a.e .
2002 , mnras , 332 , 91 + edvardsson , b. , andersen , j. , gustafsson , b. , lambert , d.l . ,
nissen , p.e . , & tomkin , j. 1993 , a&a , 275 , 101 + eggen , o.j .
, lynden - bell , d. , & sandage , a. r. 1962 , apj , 136 , 748 + fenner , y. , campbell , s. , karakas , a.i . ,
lattanzio , j.c . ,
gibson , b.k .
, 2004 , mnras , accepted , astro - ph/0406360 + freeman , k. , & bland - hawthorn , j. 2002 , araa , 40 , 487 + fulbright , j.p .
2002 , aj , 123 , 404 ( f02 ) + gilroy , k.k .
, 1989 , apj , 347 , 835 + gilroy , k.k . ,
brown , j.a . , 1991 , 371 , 578 + gratton , r.g . ,
bonifacio , p. , bragaglia , a. , carretta , e. , et al .
, 2001 , a&a , 369 , 87 + gratton , r.g . ,
carretta , e. , caludi , r. , lucatello , s. , & barbieri , m. 2003a , a&a , 404 , 187 ( g03 ) + gratton , r.g .
& sneden , c. 1988 , a&a , 204 , 193 + gratton , r.g .
& sneden , c. 1991 , a&a , 241 , 541 + gratton , r.g .
& sneden , c. 1994 , a&a , 287 , 927 + gratton , r.g . ,
sneden , c. , carretta , e. , bragaglia , a. , 2000 , a&a , 354 , 169 + grebel , e.k .
, 1999 , in iau symp .
192 , the stellar content of local group galaxies , ed .
p. whitelock & r. cannon ( san francisco : asp ) , 17 + grevesse , n. , & sauval , a.j . 1999 ,
a&a , 347 , 348 + grundhal , f. , briley , m. , nissen , p.e . ,
feltzing , s. , 2002 , a&a 385 , l14 + gustaffson , b. , bell , r.a . , ericksson , k. , & nordlund , a. , 1975 , a&a , 42 , 407 + harbeck , d. , grebel , e.k . ,
holtzman , j. , guhathakurta , p. , brandner , w. , dolphin , a. , geisler , d. , sarajedini , a. , hurley - keller , d. , mateo , m. 2001 , aj , 122 , 3092 + herwig . , f. , 2004 , apj , 605 , 425 + hilker , m. , & richtler t. 2000 , a&a , 362 , 895 + hill , v. , barbuy , b. , spite , m. , 1997 , a&a , 323 , 461 + holweger , h. , bard , a. , kock , a. , & kock , m. 1991 , a&a , 249 , 545 + hughes , j. , & wallerstein , g. 2000 , aj , 119 , 1225 + hurley - keller , d. , mateo , m. , grebel , e. 1999 , apjl , 523 , 25 + ibata , r.a . , gilmore , g. , & irwin , m.j .
1994 , nature , 370 , 194 + ivans , i.i . ,
sneden , c. , kraft , r.,p . ,
suntzeff , n.,b . ,
smith , v.v . , johnson , j.a . , &
bolte , m. 2001 , apj , 554 , 888 + langer , e. & fulbright , j.p .
1999 aj 118,1273 + ivans , i.,i . , kraft , r.,p .
, sneden , c . , rich
, r. , shetrone , m. 2001 aj 122,1438 + jehin , e. , magain , p. , neuforge , c. , noels , a. , thoul , a.a .
, 1998 , a&a , 330 , l33 + johnson , j.a .
2002 , apjs , 139 , 219 + klypin , a.a . ,
kravtsov , a.v . , valenzuela , o. , & prada , f. 1999 , apj , 522 , 82 + kurucz , r.l .
1991 , cd - rom 23 ( cambridge : sao ) + lawler , j.e . ,
bonvallet , g. , & sneden , c. 2001 , apj , 556 , 452 + lee , j .- w . , & carney , b.w .
2002 , aj , 124 , 1511 + lloyd evans , t. 1983 , mnras , 204 , 975 + lodders , k. 2003 , apjl , 591 , 1220 + majewski , s.r . ,
siegel , m.h . ,
patterson , r.j . , rood , r.t .
1999 , apjl , 520 , 33 + martin , g.a .
, fuhr , j.r . , & wiese , w.l .
1988 , atomic transition probabilities : scandium through manganese ( new york : american chem .
soc . and aip ) + martin , n.f . ,
ibata , r.a . , bellazzini , m. , lewis , g.f . , & dehnen , w. 2004 , mnras , 348 , 12 + mateo , m. 1998 , araa , 36 , 435 + mcwilliam , a. 1990 , apjs , 74 , 1075 + mcwilliam , a. 1997 , araa , 35 , 503 + mcwilliam , a. , preston , g. w. , sneden , c. , & searle , l. 1995 , aj , 109 , 2757 + mcwilliam , a. , rich , r.m .
, smecker - hane , t.a .
, 2003 , apjl , 592 , 21 + melendez , j. , barbuy , b. , & spite , f. 2001 , apj , 556 , 858 + mishenina , t.,v . , kovtyukh , v.,v . ,
soubiran , c. , travaglio , c. , & moore , b. , ghigna , s. , lake , g. , quinn , t. , stadel , j. , & tozzi , p. 1999 , apj , 524 , 19 + busso , m. , 2002 a&a , 396 , 189 + monkiewicz , j. , et al . 1999 , pasp , 111 , 1392 + nissen , p.e . , & schuster , w.j .
1997 , a&a , 326 , 751 ( ns97 ) + nissen , p. e. , chen , y. q. , schuster , w. j. , zhao , g. 2000 , a&a , 353 , 722 + nissen , p.e . , primas , f. , asplund , m. , & lambert , d.l .
2002 , a&a , 390 , 235 + norris , j.e . , freeman , k.c . , & mighell , k.j .
1996 , apj , 462 , 241 + norris , j.e & da costa , g.s 1995 , apj , 447 , 680 + obrian , t.r . ,
wickliffe , m.e . ,
lawler , j.e . , whaling , w. , & brault , j.w .
1991 , j.opt.soc.am .
b , 8 , 1185 + parmentier , g. , jehin , e. , magain , p. , neuforge , c. , noels , a. , thoul , a.a . , 1999 ,
a&a 352 , 138 + prochaska , j.x . ,
naumov , s.o . , carney , b.w . , mcwilliam , a. , & wolfe , a.m. 2000 , aj , 120 , 2513 prochaska , j. , & mcwilliam , a. 2000 , apj , 537 , l57 + ramirez , s.v . ,
cohen , j.g . , buss , j. , briley , m.m .
2001 , aj , 122 , 1429 + reddy , b.e . , tomkin , j. , lambert , d.l .
, & allende prieto , c. 2003 , mnras , 340 , 304 + renzini , a. 1980 , mem . s.a.it . ,
51 , 749 + ryan , s.g . ,
norris , j.e . , & beers , t.c .
1996 , apj , 471 , 254 + schweitzer , a. e. , cudworth , k. m. , majewski , s. r. , & suntzeff , n. b. 1995 , aj , 110 , 2747 + searle , l. , & zinn , r. 1978 , apj , 225 , 357 + shapley , h. 1938 , nature , 142 , 715 + shapley , h. 1943 , galaxies , philadelphia : blakiston + shetrone , m. 2003 , apjl , 585 , 45 + shetrone , m. 2004 , origin and evolution of the elements , from the carnegie observatories centennial symposia . published by cambridge university press , carnegie observatories astrophysics series .
edited by a. mcwilliam and m. rauch , p. 220
+ shetrone , m. d. , bolte , m. , & stetson , p. b. 1998 , aj , 115 , 1888 + shetrone , m. , d. , ct , p. , & sargent , w. , l. , w. 2001 , apj , 548 , 592 ( s01 ) + shetrone , m. , venn , k. , tolstoy , e. , primas , f. , hill , v. , & kaufer , a. 2003 , aj , 125 , 684 ( s03 ) + smecker - hane , t.,a . ,
mcwilliam , a. , 2002 astro - ph/0205411 + smith , v.v .
1997 , rev .
phys . , 69 , 995 + smith , v.v . , cunha , k. , & king , j.r .
2001 , aj , 122 , 370 + smith , v.v . ,
hinkle , k.h . ,
cunha , k. , plez , b. , et al .
, 2002 , aj , 124 , 3241 + smith , v.v . , suntzeff , n.b . ,
cunha , k. , gallino , r. , busso , m. , lambert , d.l . , straniero , o. , 2000 , aj , 119 , 1239 + sneden , c. 1973 , apj , 184 , 839 + sneden , c. , & crocker , d.a .
1988 , apj , 335 , 406 + sneden , c. , gratton , r. g. , & crocker , d. a. 1991 , a&a , 246 , 354 + sneden , c. , pilachowski , c. , a , . & kraft , r. , p. 2000 , aj , 120 , 1014 + stephens , a. , & boesgaard , a.m. 2002 , aj , 123 , 1647 + suntzeff , n.b .
, & kraft , r.p .
1996 , aj , 111 , 1913 + tautvaisiene , g. , wallerstein , g. , geisler , d. , gonzalez , g. , charbonnel , c. 2004 , aj , 127 , 373 + thevenin , f. & idiart , t.p . 1999 , apj , 521 , 753 + tinsley , b.m .
1979 , apj , 229 , 1046 + tolstoy , e. , irwin , m.j . ,
cole , a.a . , pasquini , l. , gillmozzi , r. , & gallagher , j .
s. 2001 , mnras , 327 , 918 + tolstoy , e. , venn , k. , a. , shetrone , m. , primas , f. , hill , v. , kaufer , a. , & szeifert , t. 2003 , aj , 125 , 707 + unavane , m. , wyse , r.f.g . , & gilmore , g. 1996 , mnras , 278 , 727 + vanture , a. 1992 , aj , 104 , 1997 + vanture , a.d . , wallerstein , g. , & brown , j.a .
1994 , pasp , 106 , 835 + venn , k.a . , irwin , m. , shetrone , m.d . ,
tout , c.a . , hill , v. , tolstoy , e. 2004 , aj , 128 , 1177 + ventura , p. , dantona , f. , mazzitelli , i. , & gratton , r. 2001 , apj , 550 , l65 + walcher , j. , fried , j.w . ,
burkert , a. , & klessen , r.s .
2002 , astro - ph/0207467 + weiss , a . & charbonnel , c .
2003 , in proceedings of jd 04 at the xxiii iau general assembly , ed .
f. dantona and g. da costa , mem.soc.ast.it . , 75 , 347 + woolf , v.m . , tomkin , j. , & lambert , d.l .
1995 , apj , 453 , 660 + woosley , s.e . , & weaver , t.a .
1995 , apjs , 101 , 181 + yanny , b. , et al . , 2003 ,
apj , 588 , 824 + yong , d. , grundhal , f. , lambert , d.l . ,
nissen , p.e . , & shetrone , m. , 2003 , a&a , 402 , 985 + versus [ o / fe ] for the sculptor red giants ( large magenta filled circles - this paper , large magenta filled squares - s03 ) , along with results from galactic field stars ( small blue symbols ) . due to the large numbers of galactic stars ,
their symbols must be kept small , so the different symbols are not apparent , but these studies include edvardsson et al .
( 1993 - filled squares ) , nissen et al .
( 1997 - filled triangles ) , prochaska et al .
( 2000 - 6-pointed stars ) , or reddy et al .
( 2003 - filled circles ) . ,
width=529 ] , [ si / fe ] , [ ca / fe ] , and [ ti / fe ] versus [ fe / h ] for the sculptor red giants ( large magenta filled circles - this paper , large magenta filled squares - s03 ) and samples of galactic field stars ( small blue symbols ) . due to the large numbers of galactic stars , their symbols must be kept small , so the different symbols are not apparent , but these studies include gratton & sneden ( 1988 ) , edvardsson et al .
( 1993 ) , mcwilliam et al .
( 1995 ) , nissen et al .
( 1997 ) , prochaska et al .
( 2000 ) , carretta et al .
( 2002 ) , fulbright ( 2002 ) , johnson ( 2002 ) , and reddy et al .
( 2003 ) . , width=529 ] , [ mn / fe ] , [ cu / fe ] and [ zn / fe ] versus [ fe / h ] for the sculptor red giants ( large magenta filled circles - this paper , large magenta filled squares - s03 ) and samples of galactic field stars ( small blue symbols ) . due to the large number of galactic points , these symbols are kept small and the different symbols are not apparent , but these studies include sneden & crocker ( 1988 ) , sneden et al .
( 1991 ) , gratton & sneden ( 1991 ) , mcwilliam et al .
( 1995 ) , nissen et al .
( 2000 ) , mishenina et al .
( 2002 ) , johnson ( 2002 ) , and reddy et al .
, width=529 ] versus [ fe / h ] for the sculptor red giants ( large magenta filled circles - this paper , large magenta filled squares - s03 ) and samples of galactic field stars ( small blue symbols ) .
yttrium is used as a surrogate for the light s - process elements ( often the average of y and zr are used , but most of the galactic studies of metal - poor stars do not include zr ; the addition of zr to the sculptor stars would not change their positions significantly ) .
the galactic studies include gratton & sneden ( 1994 - filled triangles ) , fulbright ( 2002 - 6-pointed stars ) , johnson ( 2002 - 5-pointed stars ) , and reddy et al .
( 2003 - filled circles ) .
note the extreme [ y / fe ] enhancement in star 982 .
, width=529 ] versus [ fe / h ] , where hs " is the mean of the heavy s - process elements ba and la , for the sculptor red giants ( large magenta filled circles - this paper , large magenta filled squares - s03 ) and galactic field stars ( small blue symbols ) .
the galactic studies consist of gratton & sneden ( 1994 - filled triangles ) , fulbright ( 2002 - 6-pointed stars ) , and reddy et al .
( 2003 - filled circles ) .
note the extreme heavy s - process enhancement in star 982 .
, width=604 ] versus [ fe / h ] for the sculptor red giants ( large magenta filled circles - this paper , large magenta filled squares - s03 ) and samples of galactic field stars ( small blue symbols ) .
the galactic studies include gratton & sneden ( 1994 - filled triangles ) , woolf et al .
( 1995 - filled triangles ) , mcwilliam et al .
( 1995 - 4-pointed crosses ) , fulbright ( 2002 - filled squares ) , johnson ( 2002 - 6-pointed stars ) , and reddy et al .
( 2003 - filled circles ) .
note the extreme enhancement of star 982 .
, width=604 ] versus [ fe / h ] for the sculptor red giants ( large magenta filled circles - this paper , large magenta filled squares - s03 ) , galactic field stars ( small blue symbols ) and red giants from the peculiar globular cluster @xmath1 cen ( large red squares ) . the long dashed line below represents the pure r - process abundance ratio and the long dashed line above represents the pure s - process abundance ratio from arlandini et al .
the galactic studies include gratton & sneden ( 1994 - filled squares ) , mcwilliam et al .
( 1995 - filled squares ) , burris et al .
( 2000 - 6-pointed stars ) , fulbright ( 2002 - filled pentagons ) , johnson ( 2002 - filled hexagons ) , and reddy et al .
( 2003 - filled circles ) .
the points for @xmath1 cen are from smith et al .
, width=529 ] | we have used high - resolution , high signal - to - noise spectra obtained with the vlt and uves to determine abundances of 17 elements in 4 red giants in the sculptor dwarf spheroidal galaxy .
our [ fe / h ] values range from 2.10 to 0.97 , confirming previous findings of a large metallicity spread .
we have combined our data with similar data for five sculptor giants studied recently by shetrone et al .
to form one of the largest samples of high resolution abundances yet obtained for a dwarf spheroidal galaxy , covering essentially the full known metallicity range in this galaxy .
these properties allow us to establish trends of [ x / fe ] with [ fe / h ] for many elements , x. the trends are significantly different from the trends seen in galactic halo and globular cluster stars .
this conclusion is evident for most of the elements from oxygen to manganese .
we compare our sculptor sample to their most similar galactic counterparts and find substantial differences remain even with these stars .
the many discrepancies in the relationships between [ x / fe ] as seen in sculptor compared with galactic field stars indicates that our halo can not be made up in bulk of stars similar to those presently seen in dwarf spheroidal galaxies like sculptor , corroborating similar conclusions reached by shetrone et al . ,
fulbright and tolstoy et al .
these results have serious implications for the searle - zinn and hierarchical galaxy formation scenarios .
we also find that the most metal - rich star in our sample is a heavy element - rich star .
this star and the [ ba / eu ] trend we see indicates that agb stars must have played an important role in the evolution of the s - process elements in sculptor .
a very high percentage of such heavy element stars are now known in dwarf spheroidals compared to the halo , further mitigating against the formation of the halo from such objects . |
the spectrum of diffuse photons is expected to have a deep of more than two orders of magnitude at energies @xmath4 ev @xcite .
this deep is similar in nature to the well - known greisen - zatsepin - kuzmin ( gzk ) cutoff @xcite and is caused by electron pair production on the cosmic microwave background , @xmath5 .
the cross section of the latter process reaches its maximum of @xmath6 near the threshold at @xmath7 ev and decreases at higher energies ( see , e.g. , ref .
the attenuation length of photons in the region of the deep is of order 100 kpc , so the deep in the spectrum is a universal feature of models in which high energy photons have extragalactic origin .
indeed , the existence of the deep is confirmed by simulations in various models of uhe cr ( for a review see , e.g. , refs.@xcite ) . for instance , in the region of the deep the top - down models typically give the photon flux by means of the relation @xmath8 . ] of order @xmath9 ev@xmath10@xmath11s@xmath12sr@xmath12 , while at ultra - high energies , @xmath13 ev , the predicted flux is more than two orders of magnitude larger and reaches @xmath14 ev@xmath10@xmath11s@xmath12sr@xmath12 .
the spectrum of diffuse photons at energies above @xmath15 ev is known rather poorly . in the region of the deep
the bounds have been obtained by eas - top @xcite and casa - mia @xcite . at @xmath16
ev the bound is of order @xmath17 ev@xmath10@xmath11s@xmath12sr@xmath12 , about two orders of magnitude higher than has been predicted by top - down models . at ultra - high energies the photon flux can be as large as @xmath18 ev@xmath10@xmath11s@xmath12sr@xmath12
if the observed uhe cr events are interpreted as photons ( recent results from agasa @xcite suggest this possibility @xcite ) . while experimentally the existence of the deep in the photon spectrum is an open question ,
theoretically it is not solid either .
calculations of the spectrum cited above do not take into account the possibility that high energy photons can be generated in our galaxy by uhe electrons via synchrotron radiation in the galactic magnetic field . as we argue below , the account for synchrotron emission may substantially change the photon spectrum at @xmath19 ev filling the deep and bringing the expected photon flux close to the existing experimental limit .
the synchrotron mechanism requires large flux of uhe electrons to hit the galactic magnetic field .
it has been recently pointed out in ref .
@xcite that this condition is naturally satisfied in the halo models of uhe cr ( these models explain uhe cr by decays of heavy relic particles clustered in the galactic halo @xcite ) . due to the fragmentation process
, the decay products of the superheavy particles contain a large fraction of uhe electrons .
in this paper we show that uhe electrons which are necessary for the synchrotron mechanism to work can be of extragalactic origin , provided extragalactic magnetic fields are small .
we will see that , in fact , the large flux of uhe electrons is inherent in top - down models of uhe cr , so that the generation of high energy photons by the synchrotron mechanism is a generic prediction of top - down scenarios and is not specific to halo models of uhe cr .
the key observation is that uhe photons propagate in the extragalactic space via cascade process being converted to electrons and back with a small energy loss . as a result ,
the flux of uhe photons is necessarily accompanied by the flux of uhe electrons . at energies of order @xmath20 ev and in the absence of extragalactic magnetic fields
the electron flux is at least as large , or even much larger , than the photon one .
while uhe photons reach the earth and contribute to the observable flux of uhe cr , uhe electrons emit synchrotron radiation in the galactic magnetic field and transfer their energy to high energy photons .
as we will see below , the energy of produced photons lies in the region of the deep , while their flux is similar to that of uhe electrons ( and , thus , of uhe photons ) .
hence , in the absence of extragalactic magnetic fields the flux of uhe photons at the level of @xmath18 ev @xmath11s@xmath12sr@xmath12 implies the flux of synchrotron photons at the same level which fills the deep in the photon spectrum . since the large flux of uhe photons is one of the signatures of the top - down mechanisms of uhe cr , in the absence of extragalactic magnetic fields these models generically predict no deep in the spectrum of diffuse photons .
the mechanism we propose is sensitive to magnetic fields on distances up to @xmath21 mpc from our galaxy .
if no deep in the photon spectrum is observed and halo models are ruled out , the extragalactic magnetic field on this distances must be smaller than @xmath22 g. this is two orders of magnitude better than the existing bounds @xcite . inversely , if the deep is found and , at the same time , uhe cr have a large fraction of photons , the extragalactic magnetic field must be larger than @xmath23 g. the paper is organized as follows . in sect.2
we estimate the flux of uhe electrons given the flux of uhe photons and zero extragalactic magnetic field . in sect.3
we calculate the spectrum of synchrotron radiation in the galactic magnetic field for injected electrons of given energy . in sect.4
we estimate the effect of extragalactic magnetic fields .
sect.5 contains our conclusions .
our aim in this section is to show that in the energy range @xmath20 ev the flux of uhe photons is necessarily accompanied by a comparable or larger flux of uhe electrons , provided the extragalactic magnetic fields are absent .
the argument is based on the observation that at these energies the photon propagation is a cascade process ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) , i.e. , propagating photon is converted to an electron and back with small energy loss . as this process is random , one should expect certain ratio of photons and electrons far from the source .
the main reactions driving the cascade are @xmath0 pair production ( pp ) on the radio background , @xmath24 , double pair production ( dpp ) , @xmath25 , and the inverse compton scattering ( ics ) , @xmath26 @xcite . in the energy range of interest
double pair production dominates , so one should expect to find more electrons than photons .
a simple estimate can be obtained if one neglects secondary particles and energy losses . in this
( rather crude ) approximation pp and dpp lead to the conversion of photon to electron with the rates @xmath27 and @xmath28 , respectively , while ics converts electron back to photon with the rate @xmath29 .
the set of equations which describes propagation of photons and electrons reads @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the distance from the source , @xmath32 and @xmath33 are fractions of photons and electrons at the distance @xmath31 , respectively , and @xmath34 .
the solution to this system is @xmath35 where @xmath36 is an integration constant whose value is determined by the ratio @xmath37 at @xmath38 .
far from the source the value of this constant is irrelevant .
the observed fluxes @xmath39 are given by integrals over the space of @xmath40 multiplied by the particle injection rate . to estimate @xmath41 we note that the integrals are dominated by large distances where the ratio @xmath37 is constant ,
@xmath42 therefore , @xmath43 both @xmath44 and @xmath29 depend on energy . at @xmath45
ev one has @xmath46 mpc@xmath12 , @xmath47 mpc@xmath12 @xcite , and thus @xmath48 at higher energies the rate @xmath44 is dominated by dpp process and tends to a constant , @xmath49 mpc@xmath12 , while the rate @xmath29 rapidly falls off @xcite . at @xmath50 ev eq.([f / fnaive ] ) gives @xmath51 in a more accurate estimate one should take into account energy losses by leading particles and possible energy sharing in the leading @xmath0-pair in dpp . in this approximation
the result depends on the energy distribution of initial particles , as well as on the energy dependence of the rates @xmath27 , @xmath28 and @xmath29 .
we have performed such estimate by dividing energy interval @xmath52 ev into 10 energy bands and solving numerically the system of 20 coupled equations analogous to eqs.([ne - over - ng ] ) .
we have found that the corrections to eqs.([fe / fg22 ] ) and ( [ fe / fg23 ] ) are small and do not change our conclusions , unless the extragalactic magnetic filed is non - zero ( the latter case is considered in sect.4 ) .
consider now the synchrotron radiation of uhe electrons in the galactic magnetic field .
an ultra - relativistic particle of energy @xmath53 moving in the magnetic field @xmath54 emits radiation at the characteristic frequency @xcite @xmath55 the width of the frequency band is roughly @xmath56 . as a result of this process
, the particle looses energy at the rate @xmath57 both equations are written for the case of particle momentum normal to the direction of the magnetic field .
generalization to other cases is straightforward .
eq.([omega - sync ] ) implies that in the galactic magnetic field , @xmath58 g , electrons with energy @xmath59 ev radiate at the characteristic frequency @xmath60 ev .
this process is the source of high energy photons in the galactic halo models of uhe cr @xcite . since the galactic magnetic field
far from the galactic center is smaller , the extragalactic electrons which we consider in this paper should have higher energy in order to produce synchrotron radiation in the same frequency range
. for the quantitative analysis of the synchrotron emission by the extragalactic electrons consider an uhe electron moving in a varying magnetic field @xmath61 perpendicular to its velocity .
integration of eq.([energy - loss - eq ] ) gives @xmath62}\ ] ] where @xmath63 is the initial energy of the electron .
for definiteness , let us take the exponentially decaying magnetic field , @xmath64 ( note that we consider a particle propagating from @xmath65 ) .
this behavior is expected in some recent galactic magnetic field models @xcite for the field in the direction normal to the galactic disk .
the scale @xmath66 is of order 4 kpc . making use of eqs.([e = e[x ] ] ) and ( [ b ] ) one finds the relation between @xmath53 and @xmath54 at a given point of particle trajectory , @xmath67 this equation , together with eq.([omega - sync ] ) , determines the dominant radiation frequency as a function of particle energy , @xmath68 where @xmath69 this function is shown in fig.1 .
as can be seen from the picture , most part of the electron energy is emitted at frequencies close to @xmath70 according to eqs.([omega - sync ] ) and ( [ omegamax ] ) , at @xmath71 ev the electron looses most part of its energy in the region where the magnetic field is @xmath72 g , i.e. , at the distance @xmath73 kpc from the galactic disk for @xmath74 g. in the case of magnetic field not perpendicular to particle velocity , the spectrum of synchrotron photons is softer .
the same is true for the magnetic field which falls off slower than in eq.([b ] ) , as usually assumed for the galactic magnetic filed in the direction parallel to the galactic plane .
thus , one should expect angular dependence of photon spectrum with more energetic photons coming from the direction normal to the galactic plane , and softer spectrum from the directions in the galactic plane
. finally , let us estimate the flux of synchrotron photons assuming the flux of uhe photons which is typical for top - down scenarios , @xmath75 ev@xmath10@xmath11s@xmath12sr@xmath12 at energies @xmath76 ev .
eq.([fe / fg22 ] ) implies that , outside the galactic magnetic field , there is at least as large flux of uhe electrons which transfer their energy to high energy photons in the galactic magnetic field .
since the synchrotron spectrum has @xmath77 , the energy conservation implies that the flux of synchrotron photons is approximately the same as the flux of uhe electrons , which is larger by the factor @xmath41 than the flux of uhe photons .
as it was shown above , in the absence of extragalactic magnetic fields the observed flux of @xmath3 ev photons is proportional to the flux of uhe photons and the ratio @xmath78 at energies above @xmath79 ev .
the presence of large enough extragalactic magnetic field can significantly decrease this ratio . indeed ,
if @xmath80 conversion length , @xmath81 , is large compared to the energy loss length of the electron due to the synchrotron radiation in the extragalactic magnetic field , the flux of uhe electrons should be much smaller than the flux of uhe photons .
let us estimate the value of the extragalactic magnetic field at which the ratio @xmath82 at @xmath79 ev .
for this purpose note that the solution to eq.([energy - loss - eq ] ) in the constant magnetic field @xmath54 can be written in the form @xmath83 where @xmath84 is the distance passed by the electron while its energy decreases from @xmath63 to @xmath53 .
eq.([constfield ] ) implies that electrons with energy @xmath53 can only come from distances smaller than @xmath85 taking into account that the length @xmath86 of @xmath87 conversion is of order 50 mpc at @xmath71 ev @xcite one finds that the extragalactic magnetic field should be smaller than @xmath22 g at the distances @xmath88 mpc from our galaxy in order that the ratio @xmath41 to be comparable or larger than one . if the magnetic field at distances of order 50 mpc is noticeably larger than @xmath23 g , the ratio @xmath41 is much smaller than one and the flux of uhe electrons is not sufficient to fill the deep in photon spectrum by synchrotron mechanism ( for the discussion of present limits on the extragalactic magnetic field see , e.g. , ref .
@xcite ) .
it is worth noting that the mechanism we propose is not sensitive to magnetic fields at distances larger than @xmath89 mpc because this distance is sufficient for generation of a large fraction of electrons , @xmath82 .
the effect of distant magnetic fields is mere decreasing of the uhe photon flux , which is not important for our argument since we normalize uhe photon flux to the observed flux of uhe cr .
to summarize , we have shown that the expected deep in the photon spectrum at energies @xmath3 ev may be absent due to the synchrotron radiation of uhe cr in the galactic magnetic field .
the mechanism we propose involves extragalactic uhe electrons produced during cascade propagation of uhe photons and thus requires small extragalactic magnetic fields and large fraction of photons in uhe cr at energies @xmath20 ev .
the latter is the characteristic feature of all top - down models of uhe cr .
note , however , that our mechanism does not rely on any peculiarities of these models . when synchrotron radiation in the galactic magnetic field is taken into account ,
the top - down models predict the flux of @xmath3 ev photons which is close to the current experimental limits , provided that extragalactic magnetic fields are small .
thus , it is important to improve the sensitivity of the experiments in the energy range @xmath3 ev . the detection of the diffuse photon flux at the level of @xmath90 ev@xmath10@xmath11s@xmath12sr@xmath12 would strongly suggest that uhe cr are produced by a top - down mechanism .
moreover , this would imply that either the mechanism based on the halo model @xcite or the one proposed here works .
the two possibilities can be distinguished by measuring the angular anisotropy of uhe cr @xcite and of produced high energy photons @xcite .
additional signature of our mechanism is the dependence of the photon spectrum on the arrival direction as discussed in sect.3 . on the contrary , if the photon flux in the region of the deep is smaller than @xmath91 ev@xmath10@xmath11s@xmath12sr@xmath12 and , at the same time , uhe cr have a large fraction of photons , the extragalactic magnetic field must be larger than @xmath23 g.
the authors are indebted to d.s .
gorbunov , o.e .
kalashev , m.v .
libanov , v.a .
rubakov and d.v .
semikoz for useful discussions and comments .
the work of s.d . is supported in part by russian foundation for basic research under grant 99 - 02 - 18410 , intas grant 96 - 0457 within the research program of the international center for fundamental physics in moscow , and issep fellowship . 99 r.j .
could , g. schreder , phys .
* 16 * ( 1966 ) 252 ; + j.p .
jelley , phys .
* 16 * ( 1966 ) 479 .
k. greisen , phys .
* 16 * ( 1966 ) 748 ; + g.t .
zatsepin and v.a .
kuzmin , pisma zh .
* 4 * ( 1966 ) 144 ; s. lee , phys . rev . *
d58 * ( 1998 ) 043004 ; p. bhattacharjee , g. sigl , _ origin and propagation of extremely high energy cosmic rays _ , astro - ph/9811011 ; m. aglietta _
et al . _ ,
* 6 * ( 1996 ) 71 ; m.c .
et al . _ ,
phys . rev . lett.*79 * ( 1997 ) 1805 ; m. takeda _ et al .
* 81 * ( 1998 ) 1163 , astro - ph/9807193 .
m. teshima , talk presented at 10-th international school `` particles and cosmology '' , baksan , 1999 .
p. blasi , _ gamma rays from superheavy relic particles in the halo _ , astro - ph/9901390 ; v.a . kuzmin and v.a .
rubakov , phys . atom .
* 61 * ( 1998 ) 1028 ; v. berezinsky , m. kachelriess and a. vilenkin , phys .
* 79 * ( 1997 ) 4302 ; p.p .
kronberg , rep .
* 47 * ( 1994 ) 325 .
landau and e.m .
lifshits,``field theory '' , moscow , 1973 .
t. stanev , astrophys .
j. , * 479 * ( 1997 ) 290 .
d. ryu , h. kang , p.l .
biermann , a&a , * 335 * ( 1998 ) 19 , astro - ph/9803275 ; + t.a .
enlin , p.l .
biermann , p.p .
kronberg , and x.p .
wu ; astrophysical journal * 477 * ( 1997 ) 560 , astro - ph/9609190 ; s.l .
dubovsky , p.g .
tinyakov , pisma zh .
, * 68 * ( 1998 ) 99 . | we show that the deep expected in the diffuse photon spectrum above the threshold of @xmath0-pair production , i.e. , at energies @xmath1 ev , may be absent due to the synchrotron radiation by the electron component of the extragalactic ultra - high energy cosmic rays ( uhe cr ) in the galactic magnetic filed .
the mechanism we propose requires small ( @xmath2 g ) extragalactic magnetic fields and large fraction of photons in the uhe cr . for a typical photon flux expected in top - down scenarios of uhe cr
, the predicted flux in the region of the deep is close to the existing experimental limit .
the sensitivity of our mechanism to the extragalactic magnetic field may be used to improve existing bounds on the latter by two orders of magnitude .
# 1height#1 depth#1 width0pt * generation of @xmath3 ev photons by uhe cr in the galactic magnetic filed . * + s. l. dubovsky , p. g. tinyakov + |
brightest cluster galaxies ( bcgs ) are the most massive and most homogeneous class of galaxy observed in the universe .
their large stellar luminosities and unique position at the centres of galaxy clusters make them easily identified from cluster surveys and observed out to high redshift . occupying the dense regions in cluster cores , the formation of bcgs
can be explained by dynamical friction induced major merging ( white 1976 ; ostriker & hausman 1977 ) .
the same general picture subsequently emerges from simulations which show that bcgs could form through dissipationless merging of similar - mass systems ( e.g. dubinski , mihos & hernquist , 1999 ) .
more generally , work on elliptical galaxies from semi - analytic simulations indicates that they originate from an early period of rapid star formation and major merging at @xmath4 with subsequent mass assembly becoming dominated by non - dissipative ( dry ) minor merging ( e.g. khochfar & silk 2006 ) a conclusion which fits reasonably well with the `` downsizing '' behaviour results from deep optical / ir surveys ( e.g. cirasuolo et al .
2010 ) . since bcgs are formed in the first density peaks to collapse their evolution is easily followed in large @xmath5cdm cosmological simulations of structure formation .
based on the semi - analytic modelling of the dark matter millennium simulation , for example , de lucia & blaizot ( 2007 ) predict that bcgs have only @xmath6 of their stellar mass assembled by @xmath2 and should be undergoing many mergers between @xmath7 , approximately quadrupling in stellar mass over this time period .
the recent simulations of laporte et al .
( 2013 ) predict a somewhat smaller stellar mass growth for bcgs by both major and minor mergers , with mass growth of a factor of 1.9 during the time between @xmath8 and a further factor of 1.5 since @xmath9 .
observational studies of the merging rates in the centres of clusters concentrate on samples at low redshift , concluding that major mergers of bcgs are a rare occurrence and reporting a dominance of small companion galaxies close to the bcgs in cluster cores ( edwards & patton , 2012 ; liu et al . , 2009 ; mcintosh et al . 2008 ) . however , other authors point out that bcgs at low redshift continue to grow from major merging ( e.g. brough et al .
2011 ) . the close relationship between the complex intracluster environment and the central bcg is well established ( e.g. edge 1991 ; collins & mann 1998 ; brough et al .
2005 ; stott 2008 , 2012 ) . but
despite the obvious consequence of bcg growth in mass via the merging processes in the centres of clusters , observationally the problem remains a vexing issue .
the claim by aragn - salamanca , baugh & kauffmann ( 1998 ) of evolution in the stellar mass using the observed near - ir brightness of bcgs was shown to result from optical selection bias ( burke , collins & mann , 2000 ) .
subsequent work indicated little evolution of bcg stellar mass in both optically selected clusters out to @xmath10 ( whiley et al .
2008 ) and also for bcgs based on x - ray cluster selection reaching to @xmath11 ( collins et al .
2009 , stott et al .
the evolution measured for the bcgs in x - ray clusters as far back as @xmath2 is surprisingly small , with these systems already having of @xmath12 of their final mass and @xmath13 of their final scale - size ( stott et al .
2011 ) compared to their present day counterparts . on the other hand lidman
( 2012 ) claim to measure a stellar mass growth of a factor of 1.8 over the same epoch based on 12 bcgs from the spitzer - based sparcs survey .
this result is significantly different from the x - ray based clusters despite the substantial overlap in redshift of the samples , and while the sparcs bcg data are still a factor 1.5 heavier than the predicted masses of de lucia & blaizot ( 2007 ) they are in better agreement with the bcg growth rates from the most recent simulations ( laporte et al .
2013 ) .
independently of these considerations , it is becoming increasingly clear that to make any meaningful comparison between observed and predicted bcg evolution it is essential to take into account the stellar mass growth of the diffuse intracluster light ( icl ) which extends well beyond the stellar profile of the bcg in most cases but remains almost degenerate with the underlying surface brightness profile of the bcg in the inner @xmath14kpc . at low redshift both observations
( e.g. gonzalez , zaritsky & zabludoff , 2005 , 2007 ; zibetti et al . , 2005 ; toledo et al . , 2011 ) and simulations ( conroy et al . , 2007 )
find that the light from the icl and bcg combined contributes somewhere between @xmath15 of the total cluster starlight , with the individual icl contribution similar to or even dominating ( up to @xmath16 ) the contribution from the bcg .
furthermore the results of burke et al . (
2012 ) show that whatever may be happening to the bcg as a result of mergers , the icl component is built up relatively recently , increasing by as much as a factor 4 between @xmath3 and the present .
we return to this issue later in the paper . in this paper
we address the issue of bcg assembly using @xmath17 ` snapshots ' to estimate the instantaneous number of major and minor mergers onto bcgs from a sample of 14 high - redshift x - ray luminous clusters , and then compare our results to those of low redshift studies and simulations .
the structure of this paper is as follows : section [ data_s ] contains the details of the sample studied ; in section [ method_s ] the methods and corrections used are described ; in section [ results_s ] the numbers of bcg companions and the mass increases from their accretion are presented ; the results are discussed in section [ discussion ] and conclusions drawn in section [ conc_s ] . throughout this paper
we adopt a @xmath5cdm cosmology with @xmath18 = 70 km s@xmath19mpc@xmath19 , @xmath20 = 0.3 , @xmath21 = 0.7 .
we construct a sample of 14 x - ray selected galaxy clusters at @xmath0 , all of which have @xmath22-band imaging data from _
hst advanced camera for surveys ( acs ) _ or _ wide field planetary camera 2 ( wfpc2)_. the high spatial resolution of the @xmath17 enables bcg companions and galaxy separations to be resolved to a few kpc at @xmath3 .
the majority of the sample is drawn from that of stott et al .
( 2010 ) which are all x - ray selected clusters , and was supplemented with 2 additional x - ray luminous clusters in the same redshift range ( rcs j2319.9 + 0038 , gilbank et al . , 2008 ; and rx j1716.4 + 6708 , gioia et al . , 1999 ) with similar @xmath17 @xmath22-band data .
the clusters in the sample have images taken with either the f850lp or f814w filter , both of which correspond to observed frame @xmath22-band or rest frame @xmath23-band at the redshift of our sample .
the data are downloaded from the @xmath17 archive in pre - reduced form .
the details of the clusters in this sample are shown in table [ clusters ] and figure [ bcgs_50kpc ] shows the central 100kpc region surrounding all 14 clusters . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] [ mass_frac_tab ] edwards & patton ( 2012 ) study a sample of 91 bcgs at @xmath24 in clusters of masses @xmath25 with imaging in the @xmath26-band and carry out a similar analysis to that described here , counting companions within 30 and 50kpc apertures and using a control sample of ellipticals of similar brightness to estimate contamination . using similar dynamical friction arguments they calculate the dynamical merging timescales for the companions in the same manner as described here and conclude that for a 50 kpc aperture @xmath270.14 before background correction and @xmath28 after correcting .
these are somewhat smaller than our values reported here , namely @xmath291.14 and [email protected] respectively .
a comparison of the @xmath31 values is shown in figure [ ep_comp ] .
this figure highlights the excess of companion galaxies to bcgs at @xmath3 , with each mass ratio bin containing more than twice the number of companions compared to @xmath9 .
sample presented here is shown in black , the results of edwards & patton at @xmath32 are shown in red and the predictions from the simulations of laporte et al .
( 2013 ) at @xmath33 are shown in blue .
the magnitude gaps of -0.75 , -1.75 , -2.5 and -3.25 correspond to luminosity ratios of 1:2 , 1:5 , 1:10 and 1:20 respectively.,width=302 ] in a similar way to the results presented here , edwards & patton find there are a greater number of companions with larger luminosity ratios ( 20:1 ) than smaller luminosity ratios ( 2:1 ) at @xmath9 and in fact find companions of luminosity ratio of 2:1 or smaller to be rare .
this leads them to emphasise the role of minor merging in the build up bcgs since @xmath9 with an estimate that the masses of bcgs increase by @xmath3410% between @xmath9 and @xmath35 from the accretion of their companions .
other observational studies reach similar conclusions : liu et al ( 2009 ) examine 515 bcgs at @xmath36 and find @xmath37 for companions with luminosity ratios less than 1:4 and within 30 kpc of the bcg .
liu et al . also find 18/515 of their bcgs to be undergoing major mergers and suggest that bcgs should have increased their masses by 15% from major dry mergers since @xmath38 .
mcintosh et al . (
2008 ) study a sample of bcgs at @xmath39 and find only 38/845 to be undergoing major mergers ( @xmath40 ) .
they predict that massive haloes are growing by @xmath41 per gyr by major mergers . our high redshift sample on the other hand shows larger total luminosities for the 2:1 companions than the 20:1 sample , indicating that major merging is more important for the stellar mass buildup of high redshift bcgs than nearby bcgs . in summary , results from the literature
find a significantly lower number of bcg companion galaxies in low redshift clusters than are observed here for higher redshift systems .
of course the dynamical timescale argument in section [ timescale ] provides a plausible explanation for this behaviour ; table [ tf_tab ] indicates that all of the bcg companions within 50 kpc and with mass ratios less than 20:1 should have been accreted by the bcg in the 3.4 gyr between @xmath10 and @xmath9 and this is consistent with the relatively low numbers of companions found in the @xmath42 studies .
laporte et al . ( 2013 ) simulate the evolution of bcgs through their merging history using dark matter haloes initially extracted from the millennium simulation ( springel , 2005 ) and re - simulated using a zoom - in method developed by gao et al .
they populate the dark matter haloes with stellar particles which are distributed to match the scale - sizes observed for quiescent galaxies at @xmath33 and run their simulation from @xmath43 .
the number of companions at each luminosity ratio is compared with our data in figure [ ep_comp ] .
on average the predicted instantaneous merger rate over the mass ratios 1:12 ; 1:35 ; 1:10100 at @xmath33 are a factor 1.5 larger than our observations in the same ratio bins , however our sample has an upper limit of @xmath44 in redshift .
although we have no real observational constraint on how the merger rates change with time between @xmath45 and the uncertainties are large , it is noteworthy that the implied number of mergers during the cosmic time between @xmath46 is consistent with the major merger rate ( @xmath47gyr@xmath19 ) predicted for the most massive galaxies in @xmath48 simulations ( see hopkins et al . , 2010 ) .
turning to the bcg stellar mass growth , the laporte et al .
( 2013 ) simulations predict stellar mass growth factors of 1.5 ( @xmath49 ) ; 1.9 ( @xmath50 ) ; 2.6 ( @xmath51 ) .
their simulated cluster and bcg masses at @xmath3 are shown in comparison with those of the clusters and bcgs in our sample in figure [ mass_comp ] . from this figure
it can clearly be seen that there is good overlap between the simulations and our observed clusters , reinforcing a valid comparison between the samples .
their predicted mass increase of 1.9 between @xmath50 agrees well with the mass increase measured here under the reasonable assumption ( already demonstrated ) that all our companions merge by @xmath9 . however
a mass increase factor of 2.6 between @xmath52 is outside of the errors on the mass increase found here ( @xmath53 = 1.83 @xmath30 0.43 ) .
this appears to be a problem for the mass increase factor of 1.5 predicted for @xmath54 as the low redshift studies discussed in section [ comparison ] estimate the growth to be at the 10% level over a similar redshift range .
the results of laporte et al .
, however , show improved agreement with observations of bcg mass growth at larger redshift over the simulations of de lucia & blaizot ( 2007 ) , who predict an increase of @xmath55 times in mass for bcgs since @xmath3 .
however , it is clear from figure [ mass_comp ] that the problem for simulations of large bcg masses at high redshift is still apparent . the estimated number of mergers since @xmath3 has direct bearing on the question of whether bcgs have evolved in mass over the same period . as mentioned in the introduction , the mass growth of bcgs measured by some authors since @xmath3 is negligible , whereas others find significant evolution .
the growth factor via mergers of @xmath56 reported here is consistent with the stellar mass growth estimate of 1.8 for bcgs between @xmath57 reported by lidman et al .
( 2012 ) but somewhat contradictory to collins et al ( 2009 ) who find 90% of bcg stellar masses in place by @xmath58 , and stott et al ( 2010 ) who find bcgs at @xmath3 on average have 95% of the stellar mass of those measured locally ; both these studies use cluster a sample which largely overlaps with that used here .
if we believe the lower bcg mass growth estimates then it is necessary to ask whether accreted mass from companions ends up in the extended cd halos or as part of the icl surrounding the bcgs , rather than merging centrally onto the bcg itself .
burke et al . ( 2012 ) show that the icl contains @xmath344% of the total cluster light at @xmath3 , a fraction which increases to as much as 40% in clusters nearby ( rudick , mihos & mcbride 2006 , 2011 ; gonzalez et al . , 2007 ) .
furthermore burke et al .
( 2012 ) estimate that on average the icl contributes more ( observed frame ) @xmath59-band light than the combined stellar emission within a 50 kpc radius of their bcgs at @xmath2 ( see their table 3 ) ; providing strong evidence for substantial amounts of light at large radii .
laporte et al .
( 2013 ) do discuss the stripping of galaxies and the amount of mass from mergers which ends up in the diffuse component surrounding the bcg .
from their simulations they find between @xmath60 of the total merging mass ends up as a `` diffuse '' stripped component .
this suggests a scenario where the smallest companion galaxies , which have the longest merging timescales , have their stellar mass slowly stripped as a result of their slow spiral onto the bcg .
the drawn - out merger times means that there is ample opportunity for the stars in these small galaxies to be stripped and form the diffuse intracluster light .
however , the fraction of the stripped material estimated by laporte et al .
( 2013 ) is smaller than typical estimates of the icl fraction and there is not enough mass in the companions less than 1/20 of the bcg mass measured in this study ( but excluded from our analysis ) to account for the large icl fractions observed in nearby clusters ( e.g. , mihos et al . , 2005 ;
rudick et al . , 2006 ; gonzalez et al .
, 2005 ; 2007 ; krick et al . , 2006 ; 2007 ) .
in addition , the high resolution n - body simulations of conroy et al . ( 2007 ) and puchwien et al .
( 2010 ) predict that @xmath61 of the matter accreted onto bcgs from mergers should eventually end up distributed in icl in order to reproduce the distribution observed in nearby clusters .
furthermore , the simulations of murante et al .
( 2007 ) find that 50% of the light in the icl at the present day should have been formed through interactions of cluster galaxies with the bcg .
the simulations of the icl by rudick et al .
( 2011 ) predict a fairly steady buildup of the icl between @xmath62 ( see figure 4 of rudick et al . , 2011 ) ,
increasing to anything between @xmath63 of the total cluster light by today . therefore it may reasonably be expected that a smaller fraction of the accreted mass from companion galaxies than is predicted by laporte et al . and measured in this paper , contributes to the bcg mass growth , with the majority of accreted mass eventually residing in the icl . in this case , the bcg mass increase from accreted companions reduces from a factor 1.8 ( i.e. mass growth of 180% ) to more like @xmath64 ( i.e. mass growth of 50%90% ) , while the icl sees a many fold increase in its stellar content between @xmath7 .
more detailed simulations of the bcg + icl growth at @xmath3 would help to clarify these issues as would more observational work using homogeneously selected cluster samples in the redshift range between @xmath65 and at redshifts higher than @xmath66 . finally , one potential caveat to the bcg evolution work is that the mass estimation from observational measurement almost always assumes that light observed in near - ir wavebands traces stellar mass . in their simulation of bcg mass assembly ,
tonini et al .
( 2012 ) predict that the use of updated stellar population synthesis models with more detailed treatment of the agb component can provide reconciliation between the observed no - evolution results and predicted masses of bcgs from simulations . despite the large scatter in the predictions ,
this claim should be testable via the optical to near - ir colours of bcgs at @xmath67 .
in this paper we examine the numbers of mergers for 14 bcgs in the redshift range @xmath68 using @xmath17 images by counting the number of companions to bcgs within 50 kpc apertures to a consistent magnitude limit . based on these snapshot measurements , bcgs over this redshift range exhibit a wide range of merging activity with an average @xmath69 companions between luminosity or mass ratios 1:11:20 after background correction ; a number which is significantly larger than similar studies of bcgs at @xmath70 .
the calculated short merging timescales of the companion galaxies provides an explanation for the smaller number of companions at low redshift and suggests that the majority of the bcg companions at @xmath3 are accreted by @xmath9 .
we also estimate the mass growth of the bcgs resulting from the accretion of its companions .
we find that major and minor mergers contribute in about equal measure to the mass build of bcgs since @xmath3 .
the factor by which bcgs are estimated to grow in stellar mass from the accretion of their companions since @xmath3 is @xmath71 , which is close to the predictions of recent simulations of bcg merger history .
if material becomes stripped adding to the build up of the icl rather than merging onto to bcg over the same period then the real growth of bcgs from mergers could be substantially smaller .
we thank the anonymous referee for insightful comments which greatly improved this paper and an expeditious report .
we thank john stott for providing helpful discussions .
cac acknowledges stfc for financial support from grant st / h/002391/1 .
cb acknowledges an stfc quota studentship .
aragn - salamanca a. , baugh c.m .
kauffmann , g. , 1998 , mnras , 297 , 427 .
bertin e. , arnouts s. , 1996 , a&a , 117 .
binney j. , tremaine s. , 1987 , princeton university press , 747 p. brough s. , collins c.a . , burke d.j .
, lynam p.d . ,
mann r.g . , 2005 , mnras , 364 , 1354 .
brough s. , proctor r. , forbes d.a . ,
couch w.j .
, collins c.a . ,
burke d.j .
, mann r.g . , 2007 ,
mnras , 378,1507 .
brough s. , tran k .- v .
, sharp r.g . , von der linden a. , couch w.j . , 2011 , mnras , 414 , l80 .
burke d.j .
, collins c.a . ,
mann r.g . , 2000 , apj , 532 , l105 .
burke c. , collins c.a .
, stott j.p . , hilton m.j . , 2012 , mnras , 425 , 2058 .
capozzi c. , collins c.a .
, stott j.p . , hilton m. , 2012 , mnras , 419 , 2821 . cirasuolo m. , mclure r.j . ,
dunlop j.s . , almaini o. , foucaud s. , simpson c. , 2010 , mnras , 401 , 1166 .
collins c.a . ,
, 1998 , mnras , 297 , 128 .
collins c.a .
et al . , 2009 ,
nature , 458 , 7238 .
conroy c. et al .
, 2007 , apj , 668 , 2 . de lucia g. , blaizot j. , 2007 , mnras , 375 , 1 . dubinski j. , mihos j.c . , hernquist l. , 1999 , apj , 526 , 607
. edge a.c . , 1991 , mnras , 250 , 103 .
edwards l.o.v .
, patton d.r . , 2012 ,
mnras , 425,287 .
hopkins p.f . , croton d. , bundy k. , khochfar s. , van den bosch f. , somerville r.s . , wetzel a. , keres d. , et al . , 2010 , apj , 724,2
gao l. , navarro j. f. , frenk c. s. , jenkins a. , springel v. , white s. d. m. , 2012 , mnras , 425 , 2169 .
gerhard o. , kronawitter a. , sagkia r.p .
, bender r. , 2001 , aj , 121,1936 .
gilbank d.g . ,
, ellingson e. , hicks a.k .
gladders m.d . ,
barrientos l.f . , keeney b. , 2008 , apj letters , 677 , l89 .
gioia i.m .
, henry j.p . , mullis c.r . , ebeling h. , wolter a. , 1999 , aj , 117 , 2608 .
gladders m.d . ,
yee h.k.c . , 2000 ,
aj , 120 , 2148 .
gonzalez a.h . , zaritsky d. , zabludoff a.i . , 2005 ,
apj , 618 , 1 .
gonzalez a.h . , zaritsky d. , zabludoff a.i . , 2007 , apj , 666 , 1 .
hopkins p.f .
et al . , 2010 ,
apj , 724 , 915 .
khochfar s. , silk j. , 2006 , apj , 648 , l21 .
krick j.e . ,
bernstein r.a . ,
pimbblet k.a . , 2006 ,
apj , 131 , 168 krick j.e . ,
. , 2007 , apj , 134 , 466 .
krist j.e .
, hook r.n .
, stoehr f. , 2011 , spie conference series vol 8127 .
laporte c.f.p . ,
white s.d.m . , naab t. , gao l. , 2013 , mnras in press .
lidman c. et al .
, 2012 , mnras , 427 , 550 .
lidman c. , et al .
, 2013 , mnras , in press .
liu f.s . , mao s. , deng z.g . ,
wen z.l . , 2009 , mnras , 396 , 2003 .
loubser s.i . , sanchez - blazquez p. , 2012 , mnras , 425,841 .
mihos j.c .
, harding p. , feldmeier j. , morrison h. , 2005 , apj , 631 , 1 .
mcintosh d.h .. , guo y. , hertzberg j. , katz n. , mo h.j .
, van der bosch f.c . , yang x. , 2008 , mnras , 388 , 1537 .
murante g. , giovalli m. , gehrard o. , arnaboldi m. , borgani s. , dolag k. , 2007 , mnras , 377 , 2 .
ostiker j.p . , hausman m.a . , 1977 ,
apj . , 217 , l125 .
puchwein e. , springel v. , sijacki d. , dolag k. , 2010 , mnras , 406,2 .
rudick c. , mihos j.c . ,
mcbride c.k . , 2006 ,
apj , 648 , 2 .
rudick c. , mihos j.c . ,
mcbride c.k . , 2011 ,
apj , 732 , 48 .
springel v. , 2005 , mnras , 364,1105 .
stott j.p . ,
edge a.c . ,
smith g.p . ,
swinbank a.m. , ebeling h. , 2008 , mnras , 384 , 1502 .
stott j.p .
et al . , 2010 ,
apj , 718 , 1 .
stott j.p .
, collins c.a . ,
burke c. , hamilton - morris v. , smith g.p . , 2011 , mnras , 414 , 1 .
stott j.p .
et al . , 2012 ,
mnras , 422 , 2213 .
toledo , i. , melnick , j. , selman , f. , quintana , h. , giraud , e. , zelaya , p. 2011 , mn- ras , 414 , 602 tonini c. , bernyk m. , croton d. , maraston c. , thomas d. , 2012 , apj , 759,43 . van den bosch f.c . ,
lewis g.f . , lake g. , stadel j. , 1999 , apj , 515 , 50 .
van der marel r.p . , 1991 , mnras , 253 , 710 .
von der linden a. , best p.n .
, kauffmann g. , white s.d.m .
, 2007 , mnras , 379,867 .
van dokkum , p.g .
, van der marel r.p . , 2007 ,
apj , 655 , 30 .
whiley i.m . , et al . , 2008 , mnras , 387 , 3 .
white s.d.m .
, 1976 , mnras , 177 , 717 .
zibetti , s. , white , s.d.m . ,
schneider , d.p . , brinkmann , j. , 2005 , mnras , 358 , 949 . | hierarchical assembly within clusters of galaxies is tied directly to the evolution of the brightest cluster galaxies ( bcgs ) , which dominate the stellar light in the centres of rich clusters . in this paper
we investigate the number of mergers onto bcgs in 14 x - ray selected clusters over the redshift range @xmath0 using hst imaging data .
we find significant differences in the numbers of companion galaxies to bcgs between the clusters in our sample indicating that bcgs in similar mass clusters can have very different merging histories . within a 50 kpc radius around the bcgs
we find an average of @xmath1 companion galaxies with mass ratios ( companion : bcg ) between 1:1 and 1:20 .
the infalling companions show a 50/50 split between major ( 1:1 - 1:2 ) and minor ( 1:31:20 ) mergers . when compared to similar work using lower redshift clusters ,
these results demonstrate that both major and minor merging was more common in the past .
since the dynamical timescales for merging onto the bcg are relatively short compared with the look - back time to @xmath2 our results suggest that the bcg stellar mass may increase by as much as 1.8 times since @xmath3
. however the growth rate of bcgs will be substantially less if stripped material from nearby companions ends up in the diffuse intracluster light .
[ firstpage ] galaxies : clusters : general - galaxies : clusters : intracluster medium - galaxies : interactions - galaxies : evolution - galaxies : elliptical and lenticular , cd |
observations of thermal dust emission from galactic structures , such as starless cores , filaments , and bubbles in the interstellar medium ( ism ) , can provide key information on the initial conditions for star formation .
significant advances in the modelling of these structures have been made possible by the availability of submillimetre imaging data at multiple wavelengths , such as that provided by _
@xcite and various ground - based telescopes .
the data carry information on physical parameters such as the density and temperature structure of prestellar cores and their filamentary environments , as well as that of the turbulent medium from which those structures are believed to evolve .
the parameter estimation typically involves the fitting of modified blackbody models to the observed spectral energy distributions ( seds ) .
this may carried out on a pixel - by - pixel basis so as to produce maps of integrated column density and mean line - of - sight dust temperature ( sometimes referred to as _ column _ temperature ) . in the standard procedure
( see , for example , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , the images at all wavelengths are first smoothed to a common spatial resolution which , in the case of _ herschel _ data , means the resolution at the longest wavelength , i.e. , 500 @xmath1 m .
a variant of this technique @xcite uses spatial filtering to restore ( with the possible exception of the cooler structures ) the 250 @xmath1 m spatial resolution .
three physical assumptions underlying these procedures are : ( i ) the dust along a given line of sight has uniform temperature , ( ii ) the ratio of gas to dust is uniform , and ( iii ) the dust opacity law is constant and represented by a power - law , @xmath2 , as a function of wavelength , @xmath3 , with @xmath4 normally being taken as 2 .
the latter assumption may be relaxed by allowing @xmath4 to vary ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , although care must be exercised in order to avoid spurious correlations due to the degeneracy between dust temperature , @xmath5 , and @xmath4 @xcite .
since the structures of interest are , in general , not isothermal , assumption ( i ) is often a poor one .
this is particularly true of structures such as prestellar cores , which have large temperature gradients .
those gradients can have significant effects on parameter values estimated from sed fits .
for example , @xcite showed that line - of - sight temperature variations can lead to underestimates in mass .
also , @xcite found that the temperature variations result in poor fits of the peaks of seds to the models , and that temperature estimates based on simple sed fits can provide only upper limits to the coldest temperatures along the line - of - sight . if observational images are available at several ( at least three ) wavelengths , there is information contained in the data which allows us to constrain the distribution of temperature on the line of sight .
we accomplish this goal by using the set of observed images to produce an image cube consisting of a stack of 2d images of differential column - density , where each image in the stack represents the column - density at a different dust temperature .
this is an application of the more generic point process " algorithm @xcite , and we therefore refer to the new procedure as _ point process mapping _ , or ppmap .
a point process is defined as a random set of points in a suitably - defined state space .
it provides a conceptual framework for representing an astrophysical system as a collection of primitive `` objects , '' each of which is characterised by a set of parameters .
those parameters then constitute the axes of a
single - object state space " , so that the system itself is represented by a distribution of points in such a space . in the present context , the system may be a filament , bubble , core , or molecular cloud , and the constituent objects " are small building blocks , each of unit column - density and uniform temperature .
each such object is then characterised by three parameters : 2d position projected onto the plane of the sky @xmath6 , and dust temperature @xmath7 ; it can thus be represented as a point in a three - dimensional state space .
we divide the state space into a rectangular grid of @xmath8 cells corresponding to the total number of states ; the column - density distribution as a function of position and temperature is then defined by the set of occupation numbers of those cells , represented by vector @xmath9 which is referred to as the state " of the system .
we assume that the astrophysical structure is optically thin to the radiation emitted by dust at all observed wavelengths .
consequently the images are the superposition of the instrumental responses to all of the individual component objects , whose number is denoted by @xmath10 .
each object is defined to have unit column - density and a spatial profile corresponding to a circular gaussian whose full width at half maximum corresponds to 2 pixels in the positional grid .
the measurement model can then be expressed as : @xmath11 here , @xmath12 is the measurement vector whose @xmath13 component represents the pixel value at location @xmath14 in the observed image at wavelength @xmath15 ; @xmath16 is the measurement noise , assumed to be a gaussian random process with covariance @xmath17 ; @xmath18 is the system response matrix whose @xmath19 element expresses the response of the @xmath13 measurement to an object which occupies the @xmath20 cell in the state space , corresponding to spatial location @xmath21 and dust temperature @xmath22 ; it is given by @xmath23 here , @xmath24 is the convolution of the point spread function ( psf ) at wavelength @xmath3 with the profile of an individual object ; @xmath25 is a possible colour correction to the model fluxes due the finite bandwidth of the observations ; @xmath26 is the planck function ; @xmath27 is the solid angle subtended by the @xmath13 pixel and @xmath28 is the dust opacity law .
we could use any appropriate functional form for the latter , but for present purposes we adopt a simple power law with a constant index in the present case is motivated by the difficulty of constraining the opacity law with the limited coverage of long wavelengths in the _ herschel _ data set .
a future version of the algorithm will incorporate @xmath4 as a state variable and the observations will be supplemented by ground - based 850 @xmath1 m data . ] of @xmath29 , i.e. , @xmath30 eq . ( [ eq12 ] ) provides a reasonably good approximation ( to within @xmath31% ) when applied to observations of starless cores @xcite .
the reference opacity ( 0.1 @xmath32 g@xmath33 at 300 @xmath1 m ) is defined with respect to total mass ( dust plus gas ) .
although observationally determined , it is consistent with a gas to dust ratio of 100 @xcite .
the state vector , @xmath34 , is regarded as another random process ; its individual components , @xmath35 , are assumed to be statistically independent and binomially distributed _ a priori _
, i.e. @xmath36 here @xmath37 is the probability that any given cell is occupied when there is only one object present , i.e. @xmath38 . the _ a priori _ mean of @xmath35 is equal to the constant value @xmath39 for all @xmath40 , where @xmath41 and @xmath42 is the _ a priori _ expectation number of objects . for sufficiently large @xmath10
( in practice , @xmath43 ) , the demoivre - laplace theorem enables eq .
( [ eq2 ] ) to be approximated by a gaussian , such that : @xmath44 where @xmath45 . in either case , the _ a priori _ distribution of possible states is given by @xmath46 the goal of the procedure is to estimate @xmath34 given the data , @xmath12 .
the estimation is based on minimising the mean square error , so that the optimal estimate is then the _ a posteriori _ average value of @xmath34 , given by : @xmath47 here , @xmath48 is a 3-dimensional vector representing the coordinates @xmath49 of the @xmath20 cell in state space .
the conditional probability , @xmath50 , is given by bayes rule , @xmath51 where @xmath52 is given by ( [ eq3 ] ) , @xmath53 serves as a normalisation factor , @xmath54 and @xmath55 denotes the transpose .
we refer to @xmath56 as a density since it represents the average local density of occupied cells in the state space of position and temperature .
its estimation is a generic problem in statistical mechanics , and its solution has been discussed previously in connection with acoustical imaging @xcite , target tracking @xcite , and the detection of planets using interferometric data @xcite .
we use a stepwise approach in which we start by artificially increasing the measurement noise to the point at which the measurements contribute essentially no information ; the optimal solution is then simply the _ a priori _ mean density which is flat everywhere . we then gradually decrease the noise back down to the true value , updating @xmath56 at each step .
the process can be regarded as a time sequence of noisy measurements whose cumulative effect is to build the signal to noise ratio ( snr ) back up to the correct value .
the time " corresponds to a progress variable , @xmath57 , representing the degree of conditioning on the data , and its value increases from 0 to 1 during the estimation process . on this basis
we rewrite our measurement model as @xmath58 where @xmath59 represents the artificially increased measurement noise , assumed to be uncorrelated between time " samples , i.e. @xmath60 where @xmath61 is an appropriately scaled version of @xmath62 . the solution procedure is obtained from a hierarchy of integro - differential equations involving densities of all orders .
fortunately , the hierarchy can be truncated , to good approximation , at the first member .
we then obtain @xmath63 where @xmath64 is the conditioning factor , given by @xmath65 and @xmath66 represents a vector formed from the diagonal elements of @xmath67 .
the optimal @xmath68 , denoted @xmath69 , is obtained by numerically integrating eq .
( [ eq9 ] ) from @xmath70 to @xmath71 in steps of size @xmath72 , chosen to be small enough that the integrand changes approximately linearly between steps ; the initial condition is @xmath73 . the desired image cube of differential column - density is then obtained by mapping the set of @xmath74 back onto the 3d grid of coordinates @xmath49 .
we refer to the quantity @xmath39 as the _ a priori _ dilution ; it represents the degree to which the procedure is forced to represent the data with the least number of objects . in principle
, @xmath39 should be set at the smallest value for which the reduced chi squared , @xmath75 , is of order unity , where : @xmath76 and @xmath77 is the number of measurements , i.e. the total number of pixels at all wavelengths . in practice ,
values in the range 0.10.01 typically suffice .
provided @xmath39 ( or equivalently , @xmath42 ) has been appropriately chosen , the final number of representative objects ( equal to @xmath78 ) should correspond approximately to @xmath42 .
having obtained @xmath69 , the corresponding uncertainties may be obtained from the matrix of 2nd derivatives of @xmath79 with respect to the components of @xmath80 , using the procedure described by @xcite .
based on the gaussian approximation of eq .
( [ eq3a ] ) , making use of eqs .
( [ eq5 ] ) and ( [ eq6 ] ) , we construct a matrix , @xmath81 , as follows : @xmath82 where @xmath83 is the identity matrix of order @xmath8 .
the uncertainties in the @xmath74 values are then given by : @xmath84^{\frac{1}{2 } } \label{eq11b}\ ] ] the uncertainties become larger in localised regions of high source density , where the number of objects required to represent the astrophysical structure greatly exceeds the originally assumed @xmath42 . in such regions
a better approximation is provided by replacing @xmath39 in eq .
( [ eq11a ] ) with its _ a posteriori _ value , @xmath85 , given by : @xmath86 the above approach is motivated by two important considerations : + ( i ) direct maximisation of the _ a posteriori _ probability would involve searching a prohibitively large parameter space .
for example , if we characterise each of @xmath87 objects by @xmath88 parameters ( which in this case would be @xmath89 and differential column - density ) , we would need to search an @xmath90-dimensional space for the maximum probability ( or , equivalently , the minimum of a weighted chi squared function ) and this would be computationally intractible for any reasonable model size . by contrast , the procedure described above is guaranteed to reach the globally optimal solution in a limited number of steps without searching a multi - object parameter space .
+ ( ii ) the use of an occupation number formalism means that the computational burden does not increase with the number of objects .
our first test of ppmap was based on synthetic data for a @xmath91 prestellar core , modelled as a critical bonnor - ebert sphere with central density @xmath92 and radius @xmath93 , embedded in a cloud of visual absorption , @xmath94 , and located at a distance of @xmath95 .
the radial profile of dust temperature for this model , and the isophotal maps observable with _ herschel _ were computed using the phaethon radiative transfer code @xcite .
the model radial profiles of density and temperature are shown in fig .
[ fig1 ] . .
( b ) temperature , @xmath96$].,width=317 ] the model profiles were used to generate synthetic _ herschel _ images at the spire / pacs nominal wavelengths of @xmath97= 70,\,160,\,250,\,350\;{\rm and}\;500 $ ] , by calculating the intensity distribution on the plane of the sky , using the dust opacity law defined by eq .
( [ eq12 ] ) .
these intensity distributions were then convolved with the pacs and spire psfs for the appropriate wavelength bands @xcite and synthetic gaussian measurement noise is added , based on an assumed snr of 300 at all bands .
[ fig2 ] shows the result for @xmath98 . .
the width of the field of view is @xmath99 , corresponding to @xmath100 at the assumed distance of @xmath95.,width=226 ] before processing the synthetic images with ppmap , we first examine the results obtained by applying the standard procedure . in the latter ,
all the maps are smoothed to the resolution of the @xmath101 image , each pixel is then allocated a mean temperature on the basis of its sed , and finally this temperature is used to estimate the column - density of each pixel .
the results are shown in fig .
[ fig3 ] .
.,width=317 ] the synthetic images were used as input to ppmap , to produce estimates of the differential column - density in a stack of ten temperature planes corresponding to the following set of possible dust temperatures : @xmath96=7.0,\,8.0,\,9.0,\,10.0,\,11.1,\,12.4,\,14.0,\,16.2,\,19.6\ ; { \rm and}\ ; 25.0 $ ] .
the resulting differential column - density maps for the six temperature planes with significant values are shown in fig .
they have been expressed in units of @xmath102 k@xmath33 by dividing the estimated differential column - density in each temperature plane by the temperature interval itself .
[ fig5 ] shows a central slice through these images , together with the true ( model ) profiles for comparison . from the ppmap results we estimate that the total mass of the model prestellar core plus the cloud in which it is embedded is @xmath103 , which compares well with the true mass of @xmath104 .
likewise , the ppmap results give the integrated column - density along the line of sight through the centre of the model prestellar core to be @xmath105 , which compares well with the true value of @xmath106 . by comparison , the standard procedure ( i.e. smoothing all images to the lowest common resolution and assuming constant temperature along each line of sight ) gives a peak column - density of @xmath107 , i.e. too low by almost a factor of 2 .
we have also tested ppmap using synthetic data for a model turbulent cloud with fractal structure , i.e. , a nested , self - similar hierarchy of clumps within clumps , as described by @xcite .
we chose a model density distribution with total mass 1000 @xmath108 and determined its temperature structure via a radiative transfer calculation , assuming it to be bathed in an interstellar radiation field which gives rise to dust temperatures @xmath109 k in the centres of clumps and @xmath110 k at the cloud periphery .
herschel _ data were generated at the same five wavelengths as above , assuming the structure to be at a distance of 1 kpc .
as with the prestellar core model , the emergent intensity distribution was convolved with the _ herschel _ psfs , and gaussian noise added ( snr = 300 ) .
a set of 2d projections of the assumed 3d model density distribution is shown in the upper portions of figs .
[ fig6 ] and [ fig7 ] , which represent summations over selected temperature intervals and the total line - of - sight , respectively .
table 1 presents a summary of the results obtained in the testing of ppmap on synthetic data for both models , i.e. , the prestellar core and fractal turbulent cloud .
wherever possible it includes a comparison with results obtained using the standard techniques for column density mapping . some conclusions which can be drawn are : 1 . for both the prestellar core and fractal cloud , ppmap yielded peak column densities , total masses and minimum dust temperatures close to the true values , while conventional techniques of column density mapping gave underestimates for peak column density and total mass , and overestimates for the minimum temperature .
the apportioning of mass between the different temperature intervals was more accurate in the case of the prestellar core than for the fractal cloud , the median values of fractional error being 15% and 55% , respectively . [ cols="<,<,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] with regard to item ( i )
, the superior performance of ppmap can be attributed to the fact that it takes full account of line - of - sight temperature variations . regarding ( ii ) it is evident that , for both models , the mass errors for individual temperatures are much larger than the error in total mass , and this reflects the high degree of correlation between the errors . in all cases the mass errors are consistent with the expected uncertainties which , for the fractal cloud are @xmath111 at temperatures in the range 714 k , decreasing to @xmath112 at 25 k. as to the question of why the errors are significantly larger for the fractal cloud than for the prestellar core , the difference probably reflects the information content of the observations relative to the complexity of either model . in particular , table 1 shows that the prestellar core model has significant mass for only 6 temperatures , whereas the fractal cloud model has significant values for 10 temperatures .
the 5 observational wavelengths ( in conjunction with prior information ) are apparently sufficient to constrain the 6 temperatures of the prestellar core but insufficient to constrain the 10 temperatures of the fractal cloud . in the latter case
there is some degeneracy in the tradeoff of differential column density between neighbouring temperatures .
when understood in these terms , the difference between the estimated and true values of fractal cloud mass at different temperatures is not as alarming as the 55% error would suggest , since closer inspection shows that the only significant difference is that the peak of the distribution is pushed upwards by @xmath113 k. the use of more observational wavelengths would better constrain the distribution .
we have applied ppmap to _ herschel _ data for a region of active star formation in the galactic plane .
the region , part of the cma ob1 giant molecular cloud , was observed at wavelengths @xmath97 \simeq 70,\,160,\,250,\,350\;{\rm and}\;500 $ ] , as part of the hi - gal survey @xcite , and is described in detail by @xcite .
we have analysed a @xmath114 region centred on @xmath115= [ 224.\!\!^\circ 2717 , -0.\!\!^\circ8361]$ ] , which is dominated by a filamentary ridge at the western periphery of a prominent cavity .
colour corrections were not applied in this inversion , i.e. , we assumed @xmath116 .
this was because , for the dust temperatures under consideration , the deviations of the correction factors from unity are relatively small over most of the wavelength range ( @xmath117% for 160500 @xmath1 m ; * ? ? ? * ) .
even at 70 @xmath1 m , for which the correction is larger , it is still not significant compared to model errors since , in the field under study , essentially all of the 70 @xmath1 m emission is due to protostellar point sources which are not well modelled by optically thin dust .
colour corrections would , however , be necessary for other fields in which extended 70 @xmath1 m dust emission is present .
since the computational cost of ppmap scales approximately as the square of the number of image pixels , we reduced the computation time by analysing the region as a @xmath118 mosaic of partially overlapping @xmath119 fields .
the resulting maps of differential column - density are shown for six representative temperature ranges in fig .
[ fig8 ] ; the integrated column - density map , obtained by summing the differential column - density over all temperatures , is shown in fig .
[ fig9 ] . fig .
[ fig10 ] shows a plot of differential column density as a function of temperature , and includes the total mass at each temperature . .
the top panel shows the true distribution , and the bottom panel shows the estimated version obtained by summing the differential column density , obtained from ppmap , over all of the temperature intervals.,width=226 ] uncertainties in the differential column density estimates result from a combination of random and systematic effects .
the former are due to measurement noise and are well represented by eq .
( [ eq11b ] ) .
that equation , however , does not take into account the systematic errors associated with flux calibration .
the correlation of those errors between bands could , in principle , result in systematic effects in temperature estimation .
however , based on the results of @xcite who simulated such effects for the combination of pacs and spire data , we estimate that the effect of flux calibration errors ( including the correlated component ) contributes less than 1 k to our temperature uncertainties .
different structures are visible in the different temperature planes in fig .
these range from dense cores seen at @xmath96=9\;{\rm and}\;10 $ ] , to protostars seen at @xmath120 ; at the latter temperature , the contribution of the background interstellar medium has disappeared . at the estimated distance of @xmath121 @xcite ,
the cores are only marginally resolved and therefore they do not show the shell structure evident in our maps of the model prestellar core ( fig .
[ fig4 ] ) .
a shell structure is , however , evident in the filamentary envelope which shows a characteristic depression at @xmath122 k indicative of the lack of interior warm material .
the total mass of the filamentary complex within the analysed @xmath123 region , obtained by summing contributions from the pixels of the integrated column - density map of fig .
[ fig9 ] , is @xmath124 . the mean mass per unit length of the _ large structure _
( i.e. the structure filling the frame of fig . [ fig9 ] ) is then @xmath125 .
this is about two orders of magnitude larger than the maximum equilibrium value for an isothermal cylinder at @xmath126 , i.e. @xmath127 @xcite , which is consistent with the highly fragmented appearance of the large structure .
many local maxima are visible and the most prominent of these correspond to compact sources extracted by @xcite ; the locations of the extracted prestellar and protostellar cores are overplotted on fig .
[ fig9 ] .
the distribution of dust - derived column - density values for the larger ( @xmath128 ) field , which includes the filamentary complex , is presented as a histogram by @xcite ; it can be characterised as a log - normal distribution with a power - law tail , consistent with the effects of self - gravity on density fluctuations produced by interstellar turbulence @xcite .
the column - density distribution within the @xmath123 region under present study is shown by the black histogram in fig .
[ fig11 ] .
in contrast to the @xcite plot , no log - normal component is apparent ; the most prominent feature is a power - law - like variation at high column densities .
however , if instead of considering total column - density we sum the _ differential _ column - density over various separate temperature ranges , we obtain a somewhat different picture .
this is evident , for example , from the blue and red histograms in fig .
[ fig11 ] , which represent the column - density distributions of the warm ( @xmath129 k ) and cool ( @xmath130 k ) material , respectively . of these ,
the blue histogram is well fit by a log - normal , whose peak location ( @xmath131 ) and standard deviation of log column - density ( 0.28 ) closely match the log - normal component plotted by @xcite_the latter component , therefore , is still present _ , even though not apparent in the histogram of integrated column - density for the @xmath123 field .
the green histogram represents material at @xmath132 k. it appears that the material at this intermediate temperature dominates the flat portion of the total histogram below a column density of @xmath133 .
it is also the temperature range in which the differential column density reaches its peak , as shown by fig .
[ fig10 ] .
these results might be interpreted to mean that the warm gas ( log - normally distributed ) has retained the density structure produced by interstellar turbulence while the cool gas has collapsed into cores and comprises the high density tail of the histogram .
the reason that the log - normal ( turbulent ) component is much more prominent in the @xcite histogram is that the latter was derived from a much larger area of sky , over which the total contribution of the warm ism component was significantly larger than that of the more localised filamentary structure .
the material at intermediate temperatures ( @xmath134 k ) may be in a transitional stage of evolution , whereby self gravity has taken over , but the collapse has not yet terminated in a power - law distribution .
such a scenario is consistent with the simulations of @xcite .
we defer a more quantitative analysis of the distribution of differential column density to a forthcoming paper . in that regard
we expect that the decomposition of column densities into components at different temperatures will help in resolving some of the issues , currently being debated , in the interpretation of column density pdfs .
these include the question of whether the apparent power - law tail can be interpreted more fundamentally as a combination of log - normals @xcite , or whether the reverse is true , i.e. that the apparent log - normal components are actually combinations of power - laws with low - column - density turnovers @xcite .
the ppmap results demonstrate that there is considerably more information in multi - wavelength imaging data than simply the integrated column - density and the mean dust temperature .
even if only the integrated column - density is required , ppmap provides more accurate estimates of both peak column density and total mass than the standard analysis procedure .
the increased accuracy derives both from the ability to capture line - of - sight temperature variations , and from the improved spatial resolution that comes with not having to smooth observational data to the lowest common resolution .
the minimum temperature along the line of sight can also be obtained with much greater accuracy , and this is particularly important in the study of starless cores whereby the gas chemistry at core centre is strongly temperature dependent . moreover ,
ppmap - based estimates of column - density and temperature at the centre of a starless core are model- and geometry-_independent_. the multi - temperature maps of differential column - density can aid in the interpretation of more complex systems by distinguishing different physical components along the line of sight , as illustrated by our analysis of the filamentary structure in the cma ob1 cloud . in particular the image cubes served to bring out the log - normal component which was not at all apparent in the distribution of integrated column - density in the immediate vicinity of the filamentary complex .
our future work will include a more quantitative analysis of the functional forms of the pdfs of differential column density at different temperatures .
in particular we expect that the temperature decomposition will provide some insight into the issues currently being debated in connection with pdfs of molecular clouds .
an additional avenue that we will pursue is to add an additional variable to our state space , namely the index , @xmath4 , of the dust opacity law in order to provide information on the spatial variation of grain properties
. this will necessitate the inclusion of submillimetre data at longer wavelengths in order to break the well - known degeneracy between temperature and opacity .
although we have applied the point process algorithm to the problem of column density mapping of dusty galactic structures , the technique itself is far more generic , and can be applied to any system that can be represented as a set of points in a suitably defined parameter space , such that the instrumental response to each point contributes independently to the observations , i.e. , the measurement model obeys the superposition principle . in addition
the formalism is ideally suited to the study of dynamically evolving systems . to deal with the latter ,
it is necessary only to add a dynamic term of the form @xmath135 to eq .
( [ eq9 ] ) , where @xmath136 is the fokker - planck operator @xcite .
this would , for example , provide the ability to integrate on a moving object without knowing , in advance , how fast it is moving or in what direction .
the single - object state space would then include not only the @xmath6 source position , but two additional variables , @xmath137 and @xmath138 , representing the components of source velocity .
one important application might be the detection of near - earth asteroids , whereby ppmap has the potential to provide a significant increase in sensitivity . .
prestellar and protostellar cores extracted by @xcite are overplotted as red squares and blue circles , respectively .
the field of view is the same as for fig .
[ fig8].,width=317 ] k , @xmath132 k , and @xmath129 k , respectively .
the blue dotted line represents a log - normal function with standard deviation of log column - density equal to 0.28.,width=340 ]
ppmap is an algorithm designed to produce image cubes of differential column density as a function of angular position and dust temperature for dusty astrophysical structures associated with star formation .
the input data consist of a set of observational images at various wavelengths and the associated psfs .
all observational images are used at their native resolution and no smoothing is required . the performance has been evaluated using simulated _ herschel _ data at five wavelengths between 70 @xmath1 m and 500 @xmath1 m .
two representative cases were chosen , namely a model prestellar core ( embedded bonnor - ebert sphere ) and a spatially complex model of a fractal turbulent cloud , the dust temperatures being based on a radiative transfer model . in both cases the spatial structure at different temperatures was recovered well .
the apportioning of mass between different temperatures was accompished accurately for the prestellar core and reasonably well for the fractal cloud , except for a displacement in the distribution of estimated differential column density by @xmath113 k in the latter case .
the displacement reflects a limitation in the number of temperatures which can be constrained using observational data at five wavelengths .
the temperature resolution can be expected improve with the use of additional observational wavelengths .
comparison with column density maps produced by conventional techniques shows that ppmap can produce significantly more accurate estimates of peak column density , total mass , and minimum dust temperature within the particular structure .
application of ppmap to a filamentary complex observed during the hi - gal survey shows that the decomposition into different temperatures facilitates the separation of different physical components along the line of sight and has the potential to provide insight into the mechanisms associated with column density pdfs of molecular clouds .
we dedicate this paper to the memory of john m. richardson , a dear friend and former colleague of one of us ( kam ) , whose earlier development of point process algorithms provided the mathematical foundation of this work .
we also thank the referee for helpful comments .
this research is supported by the eu - funded vialactea network ( ref .
fp7-space-607380 ) . 99 bernard , j .- ph . , paradis , d. , marshall , d. j. et al .
2010 , a&a , 518 , l88 brunt , c. m. 2015 , mnras , 449 , 4465 elia , d. , molinari , s. , fukui , y. et al .
2013 , apj , 772 , 45 gordon , k. d. , roman - duval , j. , bot , c. et al .
2014 , apj , 797 , 85 griffin , m. j. , north , c. e. , amaral - rogers , a. et al .
2013 , mnras , 434 , 992 hacar , a. , tafalla , m. , kauffmann , j , & kovacs , a. 2013 , a&a 554 , 55 hildebrand , r. h. 1983 , qjras , 24 , 267 inutsuka , s. & miyama , s. m. 1997 , apj , 480 , 6811 kainulainen , j. , beuther , h. , henning , t. & plume , r. 2009 , a&a , 508 , l35 kelly , b. c. , shetty , r. , stutz , a. m. et al .
2012 , apj , 752 , 55 klessen , r. s. 2001 , apj , 556 , 837 lombardi , m. , alves , j. , & lada , c. j. 2015 , a&a , 576 , l1 malinen , j. , juvela , m. , collins , d. c. et al .
2011 , a&a 530 , a101 knyves , v. , andr , ph . , menshchikov , a. et al .
2010 , a&a , 518 , l106 kritsuk , a. g. , norman , m. l. & wagner , r. 2011 , apj , 727 , l20 marsh , k. a. , velusamy , t. & ware , b. 2006 , aj , 132 , 1789 molinari , s. , swinyard , b. , bally , j. , et al .
2010 , pasp , 122 , 314 palmeirim , p. , andr , ph . , kirk , j. et al .
2013 , a&a , 550 , a38 peretto , n. , fuller , g. a. , plume , r. et al .
2010 , a&a , 518 , 98 pilbratt , g. l. , riedinger , j. r. , passvogel , t. , et al .
2010 , a&a , 518 , l1 poglitsch , a. , waelkens , c. , geis , n. , et al .
2010 , a&a , 518 , l2 richardson , j. m. & marsh , k. a. 1987 , acoustical imaging , 16 , 615 richardson , j. m. & marsh , k. a. 1992 , in maximum entropy and bayesian methods , ed . c. r. smith et al .
( dordrecht : kluwer ) , 213 roy , a. , andr , ph . ,
palmeirim , p. et al .
2014 , a&a , 562 , a138 sadavoy , s. i. , di francesco , j. , jonhstone , d. 2013 , apj , 767 , 126 schneider , n. , andr , ph . , knyves , v. et al .
2013 , apj , 766 , l17 shetty , r. , kauffmann , j. , schnee , s. et al .
2009 , apj , 696 , 2234 stamatellos , d. & whitworth , a. p. 2003 , a&a , 407 , 941 veneziani , m. , piacentini , f. , noriega - crespo , a. et al .
2013 , apj , 772 , 56 walch , s. , whitworth , a. , bisbas , t. et al .
2011 , in computational star formation , proc .
270 , 323 ward , r. l. , wadsley , j. & sills , a. 2014 , mnras , 445 , 1575 whalen , a. d. , detection of signals in noise " ( new york : academic press ) | we present ppmap , a bayesian procedure that uses images of dust continuum emission at multiple wavelengths to produce resolution - enhanced image cubes of differential column - density as a function of dust temperature and position .
ppmap is based on the generic point process " formalism , whereby the system of interest ( in this case , a dusty astrophysical structure such as a filament or prestellar core ) is represented by a collection of points in a suitably defined state space .
it can be applied to a variety of observational data , such as _ herschel _ images , provided only that the image intensity is delivered by optically thin dust in thermal equilibrium .
ppmap takes full account of the instrumental point spread functions and does not require all images to be degraded to the same resolution .
we present the results of testing using simulated data for a prestellar core and a fractal turbulent cloud , and demonstrate its performance with real data from the hi - gal survey . specifically , we analyse observations of a large filamentary structure in the cma ob1 giant molecular cloud .
histograms of differential column - density indicate that the warm material ( @xmath0 k ) is distributed log - normally , consistent with turbulence , but the column - densities of the cooler material are distributed as a high density tail , consistent with the effects of self - gravity .
the results illustrate the potential of ppmap to aid in distinguishing between different physical components along the line of sight in star - forming clouds , and aid the interpretation of the associated pdfs of column density .
[ firstpage ] techniques : high angular resolution techniques : image processing methods : data analysis stars : formation submillimetre : ism ism : clouds . |
the authors acknowledge financial support from the agence nationale de la recherche ( anr ) through the @xmath32 ( anr-14-ce32 - 0019 ) and @xmath33 ( anr-2011-emma-0002 ) projects .
a. z. acknowledges financial support from the universit nice sophia antipolis .
f. k. acknolewdges financial support from the foundation simone et cino del duca ( institut de france).the authors would like to thank laurent labont , philippe bouyer , and baptiste battelier for technical support .
0 j. laurat , g. keller , j. a. oliveira - huguenin , c. fabre , t. coudreau , a. serafini , g. adesso , f. illuminati , j. opt .
b * 7 * , s577 ( 2005 ) .
m. bellini and a. zavatta , progr .
optics * 55 * , 41 ( 2010 ) .
u. l. andersen , g. leuchs , and c. silberhorn , laser & photon . rev . * 4 * , 337354 ( 2010 ) .
s. l. braunstein , p. van loock , rev .
phys . * 77 * , 513 ( 2005 ) . n. j. cerf , g. leuchs , e. s. polzik , quantum information with continuous variables of atoms and light , imperial college press ( 2010 ) .
d. gottesman and j. preskill , phys .
a * 63 * , 022309 ( 2001 ) . v. c. usenko and r. filip , new j. phys . * 13 * , 113007 ( 2011 ) .
t. eberle , v. handchen , j. duhme , t. franz , f. furrer , r. schnabel and r. f. werner , new j. phys .
* 15 * , 053049 ( 2013 ) .
l. s. madsen , v. c. usenko , m. lassen , r. filip , and u. l. andersen , nat .
commun . * 3 * , 1083 ( 2012 ) .
p. jouguet , s. kunz - jacques , a. leverrier , p. grangier , and e. diamanti , nat . photon . * 7 * , 378381 ( 2013 )
. h. takahashi , j. s. neergaard - nielsen , m. takeuchi , m. takeoka , k. hayasaka , a. furusawa , and m. sasaki , nat .
photon . * 4 * , 178 181 ( 2010 ) .
d. buono , g. nocerino , a. porzio , and s. solimeno , phys .
a * 86 * , 042308 ( 2012 ) .
s. n. filippov and m. ziman , phys .
rev . a * 90 * , 010301(r ) ( 2014 ) .
m. mehmet , s. ast , t. eberle , s. steinlechner , h. vahlbruch , and r. schnabel , opt .
express * 19 * , 25763 ( 2011 ) .
f. y. hou , l. yu , x. j. jiaa , y. h. zheng , c. d. xie , and k. c. peng , eur .
j. d * 62 * , 433437 ( 2011 ) .
j. zhao , x. m. guo , x.y .
wang , n. wang , y. m. li , k. c. peng , chin .
. lett . * 30 * , 060302 ( 2013 ) . c. baune , j. gniesmer , s. kocsis , c. e. vollmer , p. zell , j. fiurasek , and r. schnabel , e - print arxiv : 1510.00603 ( 2015 ) b. gouraud , d. maxein , a. nicolas , o. morin , and j. laurat , phys .
lett . * 114 * , 180503 ( 2015 ) .
s. tanzilli , a. martin , f. kaiser , m. p. de micheli , o. alibart , and d. b. ostrowsky , laser & photon . rev .
* 6 * , 115 ( 2012 ) .
g. s. kanter , p. kumar , r. v. roussev , j. kurz , k. r. parameswaran , and m. m. fejer , opt .
express * 10 * , 177 ( 2002 ) .
k. yoshino , t. aoki , and a. furusawa , appl .
lett . * 90 * , 041111 ( 2007 ) .
y. eto , t. tajima , y. zhang , and t. hirano , opt .
express * 16 * , 10650 ( 2008 ) .
l. a. ngah , o. alibart , l. labont , v. dauria , s. tanzilli , laser & photon . rev .
* 9 * , l1 ( 2015 ) .
c. weedbrook , s. pirandola , r. garcia - patron , n. j. cerf , t. c. ralph , j. h. shapiro , and s. lloyd , rev .
phys . * 84 * , 621 ( 2012 ) .
g. masada , k. miyata , a. politi , t. hashimoto , j. l. obrien and a. furusawa , nat .
* 9 * , 316 ( 2015 ) .
t. umeki , o. tadanaga , and m. asobe , ieee j. quantum electron .
* 46 * , 1206 ( 2010 ) .
f. kaiser , l. a. ngah , a. issautier , t. delord , d. aktas , v. dauria , m. p. de micheli , a. kastberg , l. labont , o. alibart , a. martin , s. tanzilli , opt .
comm . * 327 * , 716 ( 2014 )
. j. appel , d. hoffman , e. figueroa , and a. i. lvovsky , phys .
a * 75 * , 035802 ( 2007 ) .
s. ast , a. samblowski , m. mehmet , s. steinlechner , t. eberle , and r. schnabel , opt . lett .
* 37 * , 2367 ( 2012 ) .
j. roslund , r. m. de araujo , s. jiang , c. fabre , and n. treps , nat .
* 8 * , 109 ( 2013 ) .
t. hirano , k. kotani , t. ishibashi , s. okude , and t. kuwamoto , opt .
lett * 30 * , 1722 ( 2005 ) .
a. gerthoffer , c. guyot , w. qiu , a. ndao , m .-
bernal , n. courjal , opt . mater . * 38 * , 3741 ( 2014 ) . | we demonstrate , for the first time , the realization of an entirely guided - wave squeezing experiment at a telecom wavelength .
the state generation relies on waveguide non - linear optics technology while squeezing collection and transmission are implemented by using only telecom fibre components .
we observe up to @xmath0db of squeezing emitted at 1542 nm in cw pumping regime .
the compactness and stability of the experiment , compared to free - space configurations , represent a significant step towards achieving out - of - the - lab cv quantum communication , fully compatible with existing telecom fibre networks .
we believe that this work stands as a promising approach for real applications as well as for `` do - it - yourself '' experiments .
generation and manipulation of continuous variable ( cv ) non - classical states of light are the object of intense research due to their importance in both fundamental and applied physics @xcite . among others , a valuable feature of cv quantum resources is that they can be generated in a deterministic way at the output of non - linear optical media @xcite . moreover , cv entanglement is affected but never vanishes completely for any level of external loss @xcite . on these bases
, cv quantum optics has experienced an increasing interest for its application to quantum key distribution ( qkd ) @xcite , with many proposals based on both single - mode @xcite and two - mode squeezed light @xcite .
entanglement distillation and entanglement swapping schemes for long distance quantum communication have been demonstrated @xcite and systematic studies have been performed on the robustness of non - classicality against the communication channel losses @xcite .
+ a further step towards real - world applications of cv quantum communication has been done by generating squeezed light in the telecom c - band of wavelengths , where low - loss optical fibres and high performance standard components are available @xcite . in the perspective of implementing quantum networks that exploit optical fibres to connect distant atomic quantum memories ,
a quantum interface has recently been developed , converting squeezed light from telecom to visible wavelengths compatible with suitable atomic transitions @xcite . in the same spirit , a light - matter interface , coupling light guided in a tapered nanofibre to cold atoms , has been demonstrated @xcite .
+ in this framework , and in order to comply with further out - of - the - lab realizations of cv quantum optics , we demonstrate , for the first time , the feasibility of a full guided - wave approach for both the generation and measurement of squeezed light at a telecom wavelength .
+ in our scheme , single - mode squeezing at 1542 nm is generated by spontaneous parametric down conversion ( spdc ) in a periodically poled lithium niobate ridge - waveguide ( ppln / rw ) . at the output of the ppln / rw
, the non - classical beam is measured with a fibre homodyne detector .
this configuration allows implementing an extremely easy setup , entirely based on commercially available components , and fully compatible with existing fibre networks . on one hand ,
non - linear optics based on waveguide technology offers , compared to bulk implementations , better compactness and stability @xcite , as well as the possibility of efficient spdc in a single pass arrangement @xcite . on the other hand
, the use of off - the - shelf telecom fibre components permits the realization of a simple and plug - and - play setup that requires no alignment effort for spatial mode matching and that can be straightforwardly modified by connecting additional fibre components @xcite .
our approach , by first combining these two technologies and cv quantum optics , paves the way towards the realization of accessible and versatile experiments for cv quantum communication @xcite .
+ eventually , we note that the possibility of miniaturizing cv quantum technologies is at the center of recent investigations , in particular with the demonstration of a photonic chip for _ in situ _ operations on squeezing @xcite . compared to this work
, our paper follows a complementary vision by fully exploiting guided - wave optics for networking between remote quantum sources and nodes .
+ the experimental setup is presented in fig.[setup]-a .
a telecom continuous wave ( cw ) laser at 1542 nm ( _ toptica _ , dl pro , fibre coupled ) is amplified using an erbium doped fibre amplifier ( edfa , keopsys , cefa - c - hg ) and directed towards a 70:30 fibre beam splitter .
the less intense beam is used as the local oscillator ( lo ) for the homodyne detector .
the brighter beam is frequency doubled to 771 nm via second harmonic generation ( shg ) to be subsequently employed as pump field for the spdc process for the squeezing generation .
the shg stage is implemented employing a commercial periodically poled lithium niobate waveguide ( ppln / w , _ hc - photonics _ , efficiency of @xmath1 ) . at its output , frequency doubled light
is directly collected using a single mode fibre .
the beam at 771 nm then passes thought an in - line variable fibre attenuator and is directed towards the spdc stage .
type-0 spdc is obtained in a 4 cm - long commercial ppln / rw working at frequency degeneracy around 1542 nm ( _ nel _ , wh-0770 - 000-f - b - c ) .
we stress that this is , to our knowledge , the first time a ppln / rw is employed for a cv experiment .
the ridge waveguide structure offers a strong light confinement owing to a step index profile and guarantees high conversion efficiency over a large operation bandwidth of operation @xcite . by means of single - photon regime characterization , we estimate an spdc conversion efficiency of @xmath2 photon pairs / mw / ghz / s .
the spdc emission covers a continuous spectral bandwidth of 80 nm fwhm ( see fig.[setup]-b ) , corresponding to 10thz in the frequency domain .
we stress that , as no optical cavity is required to enhance the spdc process , this value represents directly the squeezing bandwidth @xcite .
the ppln / rw input and output facets are connected to polarization maintaining fibres ( pmfs ) , whose coupling with the ridge is optimized by the manufacturer thanks to micro - lenses .
for the input pump beam at 771 nm , we measured a fibre - to - waveguide transmission of @xmath3 . at the output of the ridge waveguide , single - mode squeezed light at 1542 nm
is collected with a measured coupling efficiency @xmath4 and it is directly available at the output of the pmf . to detect it , we send it to a fibre homodyne detector based on a 50:50 fibre beam splitter ( 50:50 f - bs ) followed by two ingaas photodiodes . in order to minimize fresnel reflection losses ,
the outputs of the 50:50 f - bs are spliced to ar - coated fibre optic patchcords .
the measured transmission of the signal path from the pmf output to the homodyne optical outputs is @xmath5 .
+ in addition to the compactness and stability of the setup , a major advantage of guided - wave optics lies in the achievement of a high degree of spatial mode matching between the lo and the signal without optical adjustment at the 50:50 f - bs inputs @xcite .
this huge benefit extremely simplifies the homodyne detector implementation ( see fig . [
setup]-a ) .
moreover , compared to the pulsed regime , cw pumping bypasses the difficulties of obtaining a lo matched with squeezed light in the temporal domain @xcite .
polarization matching is simply obtained by inserting a fibre polarization controller on the lo path .
a home - made fibre stretcher implements the lo phase scanning @xcite . at the 50:50 f - bs outputs , light
is directly sent to two ingaas photodiodes ( _ thorlabs _ , fga10 , without cap ) showing each @xmath6 quantum efficiency at 1542 nm .
the difference photocurrent , obtained by connecting the photodiodes to each other , is amplified by a low - noise home - made transimpedence amplifier with bandwidth of @xmath75mhz .
the noise power is measured for each quadrature phase by an electronic spectrum analyzer ( esa , _ hp _ , esa - l1500a ) set at zero - span around the analyzing frequency . as discussed in @xcite , the observed bandwidth of squeezed states produced by ppln / ws
is ultimately limited by that of the homodyne detection . in our experiment , we chose to work at 2mhz , where for a lo of 6.3mw , we observe a signal - to - noise ratio ( snr ) of 15.6db .
residual electronic noise associated with the detectors affects the measurement as an additional loss and can be taken into account by a factor @xmath8 @xcite .
note that squeezing at the telecommunication wavelength of 1550 nm can be detected over bandwidths of more than 2ghz , by means of ultra - fast detectors and electronics @xcite . in this context
, we recall that the exploitation of broadband squeezing is a key element for quantum channel multiplexing and high - speed quantum communication @xcite .
+ in the presence of losses , the variance of measured squeezed state quadratures , @xmath9 , can be written as @xcite : @xmath10 + 1-\eta , \label{quad}\ ] ] where @xmath11 is the overall detection efficiency . here , the values @xmath12=0 and @xmath12=@xmath13/2 correspond to anti - squeezing and squeezing , respectively . in equation ( [ quad ] ) , the squeezing parameter @xmath14 depends on the spdc pump power as @xmath15 , where @xmath16 is proportional to the crystal length and to the non - linear interaction strength .
+ fig.[sqvspower ] shows squeezing and anti - squeezing ( both in db ) as functions of the pump power at 771 nm .
each point corresponds to an average over several acquisitions with an error of @xmath17db .
data include the effect of imperfect ridge waveguide - to - fibre coupling , propagation losses in the waveguide and in the fibre components , non - unitary detection efficiency , and residual electronics noise .
pump powers reported on the graph are estimated with an error of @xmath18 and refer to inferred values at the ppln / rw input , taking into account the coupling and propagation losses at 771 nm .
different power levels are obtained with the variable attenuator at the shg output . as it can be seen , experimental data for both squeezing and anti - squeezing correctly follow the quadratic behavior predicted by the theory .
this shows , in particular , the absence of unwanted excess noise on anti - squeezed quadratures . by fitting the entire ensemble of data with equation ( [ quad ] ) , we obtain @xmath19mw@xmath20 and an overall detection efficiency @xmath21 .
a comparison of @xmath22 with our estimated detection efficiency , @xmath23 , gives for the propagation losses inside the ridge waveguide @xmath240.4db / cm , in agreement with typical reported values @xcite .
fig.[squeezing ] shows a typical squeezing curve obtained by scanning the phase of the local oscillator overtime .
it corresponds to the highest pump power ( 28mw ) coupled inside the ppln / rw and to a measured squeezing value of @xmath0db , with an anti squeezing of @xmath25db .
we stress that , by correcting the measured values for @xmath26 , we can infer the squeezing at the output of the waveguide to be @xmath7 - 3.3db , which is among the best values reported to date for cw - pumped squeezing @xcite .
a further improvement could be obtained by reducing the propagation losses inside the ppln / rw and by employing detectors with a higher @xmath27 at @xmath71550 nm .
the fabrication of low loss ridge waveguides is at the center of intense investigations with encouraging results leading to propagation losses lower than @xmath28db / cm @xcite . in parallel , detection efficiencies as high as @xmath29 at 1550 nm
have already been demonstrated on custom detectors @xcite .
eventually , the setup performances could be enhanced by improved pumping conditions .
these could be achieved , for example , by implementing another ppln / rw for the shg - stage . this way , higher optical powers at 771 nm could be achieved .
additionally , an improved fibre - to - waveguide coupling at the spdc stage would lead to a greater efficiency for the squeezing generation .
+ let us emphasize that for any application relying on entanglement as a quantum ressource , our setup can be easily modified so as to generate two - mode squeezing .
this can be achieved by mixing the output of two identical ppln / rws at a 50:50 f - bs plugged just before the homodyne detector .
the use of such a fibre component would automatically guarantee the mode - matching conditions for high - visibility quantum interference between the two squeezed states @xcite and will only introduce additional propagation loss typically of @xmath30db . by considering our measured best squeezing level of @xmath0db and based on the duan criterion for cv entanglement
, this would lead to a correlation variance of @xmath31 , which is well below the classical limit and in line with recent experiments showing the on - chip detection of einstein - podolsky - rosen entanglement @xcite .
+ in conclusion , based on advanced waveguide non - linear optics and telecom technology , we have implemented for the first time an entirely guided - wave optical setup allowing both the generation and the detection of single - mode squeezed light at a telecom wavelength .
we observe squeezing levels down to of @xmath0db .
our setup emploies plug - and - play components fully compatible with existing telecom fibre networks and requiring no alignment procedures for spatial mode matching .
these advantages guarantee an extreme reliability and make our approach a valuable candidate for real - world quantum communication based on continuous variable quantum optics . |
the investigation of optical pulses and of modulated periodical waves in wave guide structures as fibers and planar waveguides is connected with the additional requirements to the optical property of the materials .
one standard way for confinement the optical beams and pulses is by variation of the linear or nonlinear refractive index in plane , which is transverse to the propagation direction . in an isotropic
dispersive media the refractive index depends only on the frequency , the group velocity depends on the chromatic dispersion and the wave guide modes can not be introduced in linear regime of propagation .
to provide one correct analysis in this case we need to get in mind also the different spatial size of the optical pulses .
the longitudinal spatial size is determined from the time duration by the relations @xmath0 , where a typical value of the group index @xmath1 in transparency region of pure silica is ( @xmath2 ) .
for example , the typical transverse size of laser pulses is evaluated from @xmath3 @xmath4 to @xmath5 @xmath6 .
while for the longitudinal size of pulses or spatial period of modulated waves , there are mainly two possibilities : a. pulses from nanoseconds up to @xmath7 picoseconds . for such pulses @xmath8 and
their shape is more close to optical filaments .
b. pulses from few picoseconds to @xmath9 femtoseconds . in this case @xmath10 and the pulses look like as optical bullets .
when the transverse and longitudinal part are approximately equal ( case b ) , the ignoring of the second derivative in @xmath11 direction in amplitude equation is not possible .
the propagation of such type of short optical pulses in nonlinear media must be characterized , not only with the equal dimensions in @xmath12 , @xmath13 and @xmath11 direction , but also with non - stationary optical linear and nonlinear response of the media .
that is why we can expect , that the equations governing the propagation of such type of pulses , like optical bullets , are different from the well known paraxial approximated equations , which describe evolution of nanosecond and picosecond pulses @xcite .
another basic characteristic of the pulses is their polarization .
as it is well known , in the case of plane monochromatic wave , the electromagnetic field is polarized in the plane perpendicular to the direction of propagation . in this case
four stokes parameters , two amplitudes and two phases , connected with the transverse components of the electromagnetic field can be introduced @xcite .
this corresponds to su(2 ) symmetry of propagation of the monochromatic field .
the nanosecond and hundred picosecond optical pulses admit very little spectral bandwidth , and the polarization component in the propagation direction is small in respect to the transverse components . with good approximation
these pulses or modulated waves also can be investigated as polarized in @xmath14 plane .
their spatial form also is more close to the cw wave , as the longitudinal size is hundred times greater , than the transverse size .
in contrast to the case of long pulses , the few ps and femtosecond optical waves are with relatively equal size in @xmath15 direction and admit large spectral width . for them
such coherent su(2 ) tensor can not be introduced .
the experimental results show , that the electric field of sub - picosecond and femtosecond pulses , always contains also third longitudinal component . with the enlargement of the spectral width of the vector field
also the longitudinal component grows ( the component normal to the standard stokes coherent polarization plane ) .
recently carozzi et al .
have shown that for the wave packets higher class of symmetry - su(3 ) exists @xcite . using the presentation of gell - mann of su(3 ) , they prove that five independent parameters , three amplitudes and two phases , define the dynamics of propagation of the vector field .
this corresponds to a three - component vector field .
the above made analysis and the experimental results show that in the investigation of sub - picosecond and femtosecond pulses we must always have in mind the three - component vector character of the electromagnetic field .
an initial investigation of the propagation of the optical pulses was provided in the frame of spatiotemporal scalar evolution equation @xcite .
we found that vector generalization of such spatiotemporal model can be applied to optical pulses or to modulated periodical waves in uv region for dielectrics with strong dispersion .
starting from the maxwell equation for an isotropic , dispersive , nonlinear kerr - type media with no stationary response , we derive the next slowly varying vector amplitude equation @xcite : @xmath16 where @xmath17 , @xmath18 , @xmath19 and @xmath20 are the carrying wave number , group velocity , dispersion of the group velocity , and the nonlinear refractive index respectively . with @xmath21
we denote the slowly varying vector amplitude of the electrical field .
the equation ( [ a11 ] ) is written in second approximation to the linear dispersion and in first approximation to the nonlinear dispersion .
the kind of nonlinearity is connected with the fact , that in this paper , as in the previous one @xcite , we investigate only linearly polarized electrical field .
the dependance of the nonlinear polarization from different kinds of polarizations of the electrical field is discussed in the appendix 1 .
we will apply to the basic amplitude equation ( [ a11 ] ) the method of different and equal transverse and longitudinal spatial scales , as it is connected with the natural initial shape of the optical pulses .
this application is one simplification of the multi - scale method , introduced in the nonlinear optics in @xcite and also in the hydrodynamics @xcite .
applying a `` moving in time '' ( @xmath22 ) transformation to the vector amplitude equation ( [ a11 ] ) , we obtain : @xmath23 where @xmath24 .
the estimation of the influence of different terms in equation ( [ mt ] ) can be reached by writing it in dimensionless variables . to make one assessment of the difference between transverse and longitudinal dimension of the pulses we are introducing separately transverse @xmath25 and longitudinal @xmath26 constants . defining the rescaled variables : @xmath27 and constants : @xmath28 equation ( [ mt ] )
can be transformed in the following ( the primes and the seconds are not written for clarity ) : @xmath29 where @xmath30 and in the transparency region we use the approximation + @xmath31 . in the optical region
the wave vector is valued from @xmath32 to @xmath33 @xmath34 .
the typical value of the dispersion parameter in the transparency optical region of dielectrics is from @xmath35 @xmath36 up to @xmath37 @xmath36 in uv region @xcite
. the transfer sizes @xmath38 of laser generated optical pulses or modulated periodical in time waves are valued from @xmath39 to @xmath40 @xmath41 .
we will investigate laser pulses or modulated periodical waves with time duration or modulation period from few nanoseconds ( @xmath42 @xmath43 ) up to @xmath7 picoseconds ( @xmath44 @xmath43 ) in the transparency region of a nonlinear kerr type media .
the group velocity index in this case is about @xmath45 and using the relations @xmath46 @xmath41 , we find that the dimensionless parameter in front of second derivative in @xmath11 direction and cross - term is very small @xmath47 .
another important relation is that if slowly - varying amplitudes are used @xmath48 . for such typical values of the dispersion @xmath49 , wave vector @xmath17 , time duration @xmath50 and transverse dimension @xmath38 of the optical wave ,
the dimensionless parameter @xmath51 in front of the dispersion term in equation ( [ tp ] ) is very small @xmath52 .
here we study the cases with power near the critical for self - focusing @xmath53 .
these valuations give us possibility to estimate dimensionless constant in front of the different terms of normalized amplitude equation ( [ tp ] ) for the transparency optical region of a dispersive nonlinear kerr type media : @xmath54 neglecting the small terms in ( [ tp ] ) we obtain the next amplitude equation : @xmath55 as it can be expected , the dynamics of such kind of long optical pulses is governed by the well known paraxial approximation .
this equation was introduced initially for optical beam @xcite .
the fact , that with such type of nonlinear paraxial equation it is possible to investigate non - stationary processes is well known also @xcite .
it seems natural the dynamics of propagation of long pulses to be governed by the equation which describes dynamics of optical beam .
the paraxial approximation is applicable even when the relation between the longitudinal and the transverse part is of the order of ten ( @xmath56 ) .
the dimensionless coefficient in front of the term with second derivative in z direction and cross - term is of the order of square of @xmath57 ( @xmath58 ) , the term can be neglected and this leads again to the paraxial equation ( [ parax ] ) .
effects of self - steepening due to the first order of the nonlinear dispersion ( second term in equation ( [ tp ] ) ) is not possible as always @xmath59 .
different kind of generalization of equation ( [ parax ] ) in respect to nonlinearities @xcite and multi - component vector fields @xcite was performed .
it is important to point here that the second derivative in @xmath11 direction and the crossed term are neglected from the difference between transverse and longitudinal size ( @xmath60 ) , and not because the slowly varying amplitude is used .
when we investigate the optical pulses with equal transverse and longitudinal size @xmath61 , the second derivative in @xmath11 direction and cross term of the amplitude function are of the same order that the transverse laplassian , and these terms influence considerably on the dynamics of propagation . this important case we will investigate in the next section . when the power of the pulse is less than the critical for self - focusing @xmath62 the diffraction term dominates and the propagation of the optical pulses is governed by the next linear paraxial equation : @xmath63 in uv region of media with high density as liquids and dielectrics the dispersion @xmath49 increases considerably and can reach the values from @xmath64 @xmath36 .
the carrying wavenumber is valued from @xmath33 @xmath34 to @xmath65 @xmath34 and in this spectral region we can reach value with equal diffraction and dispersion length , which corresponds to @xmath66 .
we use for example bulk fused silica and calculate the linear refractive index from the sellmeier relations @xcite : @xmath67 with coefficients @xmath68 , wavelengths @xmath69 @xmath6 @xmath70 @xmath71 @xmath72 @xmath6 where @xmath73
. the choice of carrying wavelength for the optical packet at @xmath74 @xmath6 , ( @xmath75 @xmath76 ) is connected with the facts , that fused silica is still transparent on this wavelength and it can be reached easy way by fourth harmonics from nd yag laser on @xmath77 @xmath6 . considering the case of pulses or modulated waves with intensity near the critical for self - focusing @xmath78 , time duration @xmath79 @xmath80 and using the relations @xmath81 , the next values for laser characteristics and material constants are obtained : @xmath82 these parameters correspond to the next dimensionless constant : @xmath83 neglecting the small terms from the amplitude equation ( [ tp ] ) we obtain the next equation governing the propagation of optical pulses with different transfer and longitudinal size in uv region of dielectrics : @xmath84 the scalar variant of this spatiotemporal equation ( [ uv ] ) was introduced for first time by silberberg @xcite and attracts a growing interest . in the beginning this equation was suggested to discover the dynamics of so - called `` light bullets '' ( lb ) , i.e. optical pulses with relatively equal transfer and longitudinal size .
our investigation corrects this idea and finds that the equation ( [ uv ] ) governed the propagation of optical pulses with longitudinal size hundred times greater than the transfer one in uv region of dielectrics and liquids . in the case of optical waves with very small intensity
the nonlinear term can be neglected @xmath85 , and we obtain the linear version of the equation ( [ uv ] ) : @xmath86 let investigate the two component vector field polarizable in transverse @xmath14 plane . for long pulses , as they are more close to the cw regime , the longitudinal vector component is small and such approximation is possible .
we represent the optical vector field by two orthogonal components @xmath87 and the equation ( [ uv ] ) is transformed to the next nonlinear system of equations : @xmath88 in the linear case the ( [ sysuv ] ) is reduced to two equal scalar equations for @xmath89 and @xmath90 : @xmath91 where @xmath92 .
we rewrite the linear scalar equation ( [ lsuv ] ) in cylindrical coordinates : @xmath93 where @xmath94 and @xmath95 . the linear equation ( [ lc ] )
admits infinite number of exact analytical solutions of kind of : @xmath96\exp\left(i(\beta_1 z+\sqrt{2\alpha\delta^2}t)\right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath97\exp\left(i(\beta_1 z+\sqrt{2\alpha\delta^2}t)\right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath98 is one infinite number .
the solutions ( [ lsol ] ) , ( [ lsol1 ] ) admit modulation frequency @xmath99 and modulation wave vector @xmath100 in z direction .
the existence of such kind solutions for monochromatic light was observed for first time by nye and berry @xcite .
the solutions of kind ( [ lsol]),([lsol1 ] ) admit amplitude and phase singularities .
one elegant way to remove the amplitude singularities by using the combination of gaussian envelope and the solution ( [ lsol1 ] ) with @xmath101 was suggested for first time in @xcite for paraxial beam .
this method is applicable also to the linear equation ( [ lc ] ) and optical vortices in combined pulses with finite amplitudes can be found .
usually the localized solutions of the linear equations are not stable .
now we will turn to most interesting case ; exact solutions of the nonlinear system of equation ( [ sysuv ] ) .
again we rewrite the system ( [ sysuv ] ) in cylindrical variables : @xmath102 the nonlinear system of equations ( [ nlc ] ) admits another infinite number of exact vortex solutions of kind of : @xmath103 where @xmath104 is one infinite number .
one important consequence of these solutions is , that they are obtained as a balance not only between the diffraction and the nonlinearity , but mostly by the nonlinearity and the angular distribution .
that is why , we can expect one stable propagation of such vortices in z direction .
right away we can point here , that conditions for finiteness of the energy of the above solutions have been not found up to now .
the investigation of the propagation of optical pulses or modulated waves with equal transverse and longitudinal size @xmath106 is more convenient to provide in coordinate system moving with group velocity .
that is why we apply a galilean transformation to the basic vector amplitude equation ( @xmath107 , @xmath108 ) , as difference from the case of long pulses , where the `` moving in time '' transformation is more natural .
the equation ( [ a11 ] ) in this case is transformed to : @xmath109 where @xmath24 .
we use again the approximation @xmath31 . to estimate the influence of the different terms on the propagation dynamics we rewrite the equation ( [ a13 ] ) in dimensionless form . defining the rescaled variables : @xmath110 and constants : @xmath111 equation ( [ a13 ] )
can be transformed in the following ( the primes and the seconds are not written for clarity again ) : @xmath112 we point out , that the normalizing is with equal longitudinal and transverse dimensions @xmath113 . as it was pointed above , it is fulfilled usually for few picosecond and femtosecond pulses of a pulse with transverse size of @xmath114 millimeters to hundred micrometers .
dimensionless dispersion parameter @xmath116 in transparency region of dielectrics and gases usually is of the order of @xmath117 .
for example we calculate @xmath116 in the transparency region of pure silica on @xmath118 using the standard sellmeier expression for dependence of the dielectric constant from frequency , and the value really is of this order @xmath119 .
the constant @xmath120 has a value of @xmath121 ( @xmath122 ) if the slowly varying approximation is used . in this case , when we investigate the optical pulses with power near to the critical for self - focusing @xmath123 , @xmath124 , our vector amplitude equation ( [ eq13 ] ) can be transformed to the next evolution equation : @xmath125 the equation ( [ eq14 ] ) is one generalization of the well known paraxial equation ( [ parax ] ) in optical region for pulses with equal transverse and longitudinal size . the critical dimensionless parameter @xmath116 , which determines the relation between dispersion and diffraction in the normalized amplitude equation ( [ eq13 ] ) , as it was established in the previous paragraph , is very little in the optical region . in spite of this ,
the temporal effects are presented in the corresponding equation ( [ eq14 ] ) and for pulses with equal transverse and longitudinal size can not be neglected .
the situation in uv region is quite different . in this region
we can reach @xmath127 .
when we investigate optical pulses with power , near to the critical for self - focusing , the corresponding nonlinear dimensionless parameters admit values @xmath123 , @xmath128 .
than the equation ( [ eq13 ] ) is transformed to : @xmath129 if we compare the equations in optical ( [ eq14 ] ) and uv region ( [ uv1 ] ) , it is seen that in uv region we can take in mind in addition a negative second derivative in z direction of amplitude function and we multiply the temporal effects of second order by factor @xmath130 .
we use for example again bulk fused silica and calculate the linear refractive index @xmath131 from the sellmeier relations . the investigation is provided for the spectral region from wavelength @xmath74 @xmath6 to wavelength @xmath132 @xmath6 .
the group velocity @xmath133 , dispersion @xmath134 and the dimensionless parameter @xmath135 are calculated .
the typical characteristic of the laser pulse are @xmath136 @xmath43 , group velocity @xmath137 @xmath138 and @xmath139 @xmath41 . on figure
[ fig1 ] , figure [ fig2 ] are presented correspondingly the graphics of dispersion of the group velocity @xmath140 and dimensionless parameter @xmath141 . as it is seen from fig.2 , the dimensionless parameter @xmath116 ,
really can reach values equal to one in uv region for some dielectrics . in the uv region from @xmath142 nm
to @xmath143 nm for bulk fused silica.,width=491,height=321 ] within wavelengths from @xmath142 nm to @xmath143 nm for bulk fused silica .
the dispersion parameter reach a value @xmath144 in uv region.,width=491,height=321 ] now we come to the most interesting case in this investigation : the possibility that the temporal effects of second order can be neglected . as it can be traced out from basic amplitude equation ( [ a11 ] ) , and to see in the normalized equation ( [ eq13 ] ) , when @xmath146 , the dispersion effects of second order do not present in the corresponding amplitude equations and do not influence on the propagation dynamics .
recently in @xcite it was found that near the electronic resonances of gases and dielectrics and also near the langmuir frequency in cold plasma the dispersion is negative , the dispersion parameter arises rapidly and is of the order of @xmath145 .
again we investigate the propagation of optical pulses with power near the critical for self - focusing ( @xmath123 , @xmath128 ) . the amplitude equation ( [ eq13 ] ) in this case can be written in the next simple form of 3d+1 vector nonlinear schrdinger equation ( vnse ) : @xmath147 here we will study the possibility to obtain @xmath148 in the next three cases : 1 . near the isolated resonance of mercury vapor on @xmath149 .
2 . near the langmuir frequency in cold electron plasma .
3 . in deep
uv and r region for dielectrics , gazes and metals .
when @xmath150 the wave vector can be written as : @xmath151 calculating @xmath152 for dispersion relation of kind of ( [ eps ] ) , right away we obtain @xmath148 .
this gives us a confidence to look for such zones near the electronic resonances where @xmath153 .
near to some of the isolated electron resonances of metal vapors the dielectric constant can be expressed by @xcite : @xmath154 the investigation are provided for resonance frequency of mercury vapor on @xmath155 hz , oscillator strength @xmath156 , and natural ( i.e. radiative ) linewidth @xmath157 hz .
we use lorenz shape of the line , as we investigate the rarefied vapor and looking in zones outlying from resonance on distance more than @xmath158 , where the natural shape of the line dominated . in figure 3
it is shown the form of the dielectric constant for number density @xmath159 . in the figure 4
it is presented the dimensionless dispersion parameter @xmath116 . as it is well seen on the wing on the resonance on distance about @xmath158 we have spectral zone where @xmath160 .
right away it must be pointed that @xmath116 depends strongly on the number density n. the number density of the order of @xmath161 appears to be most suitable for large zones with @xmath162
. seems , for such number density the wing of the resonance in best way can be approximated with @xmath153 .
hz ( @xmath163 nm ) , and natural linewidth @xmath157 hz.,width=491,height=321 ] near to resonance frequency of mercury vapor on @xmath164 hz . on distance @xmath158
we find the spectral zone where @xmath165.,width=491,height=321 ] dielectric constant in the case of cold electron plasma is given by the expression @xcite : @xmath166 where @xmath167 is the plasma frequency and @xmath168 is the number of free electron particles per @xmath169 . here
we investigate a typical number which characterized the plasma density in generators used for nuclear fusion . in figure 5
is presented @xmath170 for frequencies higher and close to plasma frequency and number density @xmath171 @xmath169 .
the frequency is normalizing on spectral width of optical pulse @xmath172 hz , which corresponds to pulse with time duration @xmath173 seconds .
the corresponding to this dielectric constant dispersion parameter @xmath135 is presented in figure 6 . as it is seen from the graphics , the large spectral zone exists , more than twenty spectral widths from plasma frequency , where @xmath174 .
the transverse and longitudinal size such optical pulse valued from @xmath175 @xmath41 .
an important relation is pointed out with investigation of dependence of @xmath116 from time duration of the pulses and number density
. with decreasing the time and spatial duration of the pulses ( fs pulses ) and increasing the number density , this large spectral zone with @xmath174 keeps on . .
the frequency is normalizing on spectral width of the optical pulse @xmath172 hz.,width=491,height=321 ] near the plasma frequency .
large spectral sone with @xmath165 is established.,width=491,height=321 ] as it was established in @xcite , it is possible to find equal dispersion relation of the dielectric constant @xmath170 for different kind of materials , as dielectrics , gases , semiconductors , metals , when the carrying frequency of optical wave is much higher than the resonances of this media . in these cases
the localized energy of optical wave is much higher than the critical for ionization of the materials and the linear and nonlinear response is the same as in cold plasma . practically the electrons interact as free electrons on these frequencies .
it is not hard to find that in this region again we have the dispersion relation of dielectric constant of the kind of : @xmath176 the critical parameter which characterized the plasma frequency in these materials is the number density @xmath168 of the free electrons .
the typical number for semiconductors is @xmath177 and for metals is @xmath178 .
that is why , the application of this formula started from deep uv for light elements as h , li , e.c . and from r frequencies in heavy elements . for optical waves when @xmath179 , there are no difference between metals , semi - conductors , dielectrics and metals .
all of them are transparent for optical waves with carrying frequency @xmath180 .
again we can obtain , that near the corresponding plasma frequency of these materials , large frequency zone with negative dispersion parameter of order of @xmath181 exists , if the picosecond and femtosecond pulses are used .
for all of these three important cases the propagation of localized optical pulses is governed by the vector 3d+1 nonlinear schrdinger equation ( [ eq15 ] ) . the numerical experiment provided in @xcite
show a stable propagation of the vortex solutions .
the intensity picture of these multi - component solutions is truly symmetric and look like as stable fraunhofer distribution .
the internal structure of these vortices is presented by the spherical harmonics with integer number .
the solutions of the 3d+1 vector nonlinear schrdinger amplitude equation ( [ eq15 ] ) in a fixed basis are @xcite : @xmath182 @xmath183 @xmath184 where @xmath185 , @xmath186 and @xmath187 are the moving spherical variables of the independent variables @xmath188 .
the corresponding real solutions @xmath189 , are : @xmath190 @xmath191 @xmath192 it is important to point , that in @xcite conditions for finiteness of the energy of the solutions ( [ eq30])-([eq32 ] ) was found .
as it can be established , the averaged with one time period intensity field of these solutions admits total radial symmetry : @xmath193 thus , in one experiment the solution will look like as fraunhofer distribution .
figure 7 presents the surface @xmath194 of the solutions ( [ eq30])-([eq32 ] ) . ) of 3d+1 vector nonlinear schrdinger equation ( [ eq15]).,width=245,height=207 ] we can recognize the vortex structures of these solutions only if we see the field distribution and the intensity of one of the component , for example @xmath195 . on figure 8
we present the surface of one of the components @xmath196 , rewritten in cartesian coordinates : @xmath197 it is clearly seen , that the surface of our three dimensional solutions possess linear phase dislocations in space , which characterizes the vortex structures @xcite . of the averaged with one time period vortex solutions ( [ komp ] ) .
it is clearly seen linear phase dislocation for these solutions.,width=245,height=207 ] the intensity of this component @xmath198 , which is one @xmath199 distribution , is presented in figure 9 .
this picture is possible to see in one experiment , when an optical vortex of kind ( [ eq30])-([eq32 ] ) is passed trough the linear polarizer .
then the internal structure of these vortex solutions composed by spherical harmonics with @xmath200 distribution , will be seen .
our solutions ( [ eq30])-([eq32 ] ) admits total angular momentum @xmath201 and line phase singularities for the different components .
that is why , in spite of the fact that the intensity field is total symmetric , we recognize the internal vortex structures of these solutions . , which corresponds to @xmath202 distribution.,width=245,height=207 ]
in conclusion , we investigated the application of the nonlinear amplitude equation ( [ a11 ] ) , in different spectral zones , starting from the optical region , and extending up to the r region of dielectrics .
different generalizations of the paraxial equation are obtained , depending from the spectral zones , the material constants , and the initial shape of the pulses ( long pulses or optical bullets ) .
we find large spectral region near the plasma frequency in cold plasma for fs and few picosecond optical pulses , where the temporal effects of second order in the amplitude equations ( [ a11 ] ) can be neglected .
the same result is obtained also for spectral regions on the wings of the electron resonances in metal vapors . in the last case the conditions to obtain such effects depend strongly on the number density of the gases . in these spectral zones
the propagation of optical pulses is governed by the amplitude vector nonlinear schrdinger equation ( [ eq15 ] ) and , as it was predicted in @xcite , stable 3d optical vortices can be observed .
they look like as fraunhofer distribution in the space . after passing trough the linear polarizer
the vortex structures will be seen .
the vector theory presented in this paper can be extended also in respect to different kind of nonlinearities and polarizations of the optical field .
the electric field associated with linear or elliptically polarized optical wave can be written in the form let investigate the polarization dynamics of two initially linearly polarized components of the electrical field . then , there is no initial phase different between the components , and the complex amplitudes can be expressed as a product of two real amplitude functions with equal phases : @xmath207 , @xmath208 . calculating the relation between the linear polarized components in the same manner , as it was performed for plane wave @xcite , we obtain the same kind relation for the components of the electrical field : where @xmath210 and @xmath211 are real functions , not real constants as in the case of plane wave .
we investigate the propagation dynamics of optical pulses with arbitrary localized amplitudes .
the soliton case appear as partial case , when equal amount of nonlinear and linear phase shift are compensated , the initial phase different do not changed , and the linear polarization keeps on . for optical pulses with arbitrary amplitudes , as the media is isotropic , the diffraction and the dispersion add equal phases to the two components and they can be written generally in the form : where @xmath214 is the phase shift due to diffraction , @xmath215 is the phase shift due to dispersion , @xmath216 is the equal phase components for the both amplitudes , and @xmath217 , @xmath217 are the real part of solutions for the amplitudes on distance z in isotropic media . for arbitrary solutions of kind
( [ difdis1 ] ) , ( [ difdis2 ] ) the relation ( [ yar ] ) keeps on for the real part of the amplitudes .
it is following from the fact , that the diffraction and the dispersion effects do not change the initial linear polarization of the pulses ( do not yield linear birefringence in isotropic materials ) .
the nonlinear polarization @xmath218 in the case of isotropic medium is well known and can be written in the form @xcite : we point here , that the expression is valid not only for nonlinear nonresonant optical response , when @xmath222 , but also for nonlinearity near to some of the resonances , when @xmath223 . in the same way we can obtain
, that the components of the nonlinear polarization for one linear polarized vector in 3d space take forms : in the case of elliptically polarized light the relation ( [ yar ] ) take form : @xmath225 where @xmath226 is the different of the phase functions for the components of the vector field . since the diffraction and the dispersion add equal amount of phase shift to the different components in isotropic media , the phase different keeps on again .
if we substitute @xmath227 and @xmath228 with such phase difference in the expression for nonlinear polarization ( [ pnl ] ) , and take in mind that @xmath222 for case of nonresonant electronic nonlinearities , the next expression for the components can be found @xcite : the last terms in equations ( [ pnlx ] ) and ( [ pnly ] ) present degenerate four wave mixing process ( @xmath231 ) . since @xmath232 , this leads to periodically exchange of energy between the elliptically polarized components .
thus , such one exchange of energy can be observed in isotropic material as gases , metal vapors and crystals .
when the phase different vanish ( @xmath233 ) in the case of linearly polarized components , the amplitude functions admit again equal phases , and the nonlinear polarization ( [ pnlx ] ) and ( [ pnly ] ) can be transformed to the nonlinear polarization of linearly polarized components ( [ pnl1 ] ) and ( [ pnl2 ] ) .
this is one generalization of the results obtained for parametric solitons in @xmath234 media @xcite .
when there is no phase different between the components , the parametric therm appear as usual cross - phase term in the dispersion relations , and can be take in mind to determinate the right amplitude constants .
the polarization dynamics in materials which admit modal birefringece is more complicate . in single - mode fiber , where the linear birefgingent effect appear @xcite , additional polarization mode dispersion exists @xcite .
this lead to random birefringence in optical fibers and random phase different in the last parametric terms in ( [ pnlx ] ) and ( [ pnly ] ) .
our numerical experiment show that the parametric effects with random phases are not effective , and can be neglected .
one transitions to the manakov system with coefficients equal to one in front of the cross - terms @xcite is possible again for birefringent materials at elliptically angle @xmath235 between the main axes @xcite .
100 r.y.chiao , e.garmire and c.h.townes , phys .
13 , 479 ( 1964 ) .
v.i.talanov , pisma zh .
, 2 , 222 ( 1965 ) .
p.l.kelley , phys .
15 , 1005 ( 1965 ) .
m. born and e. wolf , _ principes of optics _ , 6th ( corr ) ed . , ( cambridge university press , cambridge , england , 1998 ) .
t. carozzi , r. karlsson , and j. bergman , phys .
e , 61 , 2024 ( 2000 ) .
s.a.akhmanov , a.p.sukhorukov , r.v .
khokhlov , zh .
50 , 474 ( 1966 ) .
s.a.akhmanov , a.p.sukhorukov , a.s.chirkin , zh . eksp
55 , 1430 ( 1968 ) .
a.c.newell , and j.v .
moloney , _ nonlinear optics _ , ( advanced topics in the interdisciplinary , mathematical sciences , addison - wesley , california , 1992 ) .
a.c.newell , j.a.whitehead , j. fluid .
mech . , 36 , 309 ( 1969 ) .
chirkin , ph.d .
thesis , moscow university , 1967 .
a.g.litvak , v.i.talanov , izv .
vuzov , radiophysics , 10 , 539 ( 1967 ) .
y.silberberg , opt.lett .
15 , 1282 ( 1990 ) .
a.b.blagoeva , s.g.dinev , a.a.dreisehuh , a.naidenov , + ieee j. quant .
electronic , qe-27 , 2060 ( 1991 ) .
j.f.nye , m.v .
berry , proc .
london , ser a - math .
sci 336 , 165 ( 1974 ) .
m. s. soskin , v. n. gorshkov , m. v. vasnetsov , j. t. malos , n. r. heckenberg , phys.rev .
a , 56 , 4064 ( 1997 ) .
l.m.kovachev , int .
j. of math . and math .
, 18 , 949 ( 2004 ) .
c.a.akhmanov , v.a.vysloukh , a.c.chirkin , _ optics of femtosecond laser pulses _ , ( nayka , moscow , 1988 ) .
yu.s.kivshar , and g.p.agrawal , _ optical solitons : from fiber to photonic cristals _ , ( academic press , san diego , 2003 ) .
a.desyatnikov , a.maimistov and b.malomed , phys .
e , 61 , 3107 ( 2000 ) .
l.torner,d.v.petrov , electron .
, 33 , 7 , 608 ( 1997 ) .
manakov , zh .
38 , 248 , ( 1974 ) .
a.s.desyatnikov , d.neshev , e.a.ostrovskaya , yu.s.kivshar , + g. mccarthy , w.krolikowski , and b.luther-davies , josa - b , 19 , 586 ( 2002 ) .
malitson , josa - b , 55 , 1205 ( 1965 ) .
r.w.boyd , _ nonlinear optics _ , ( acad.press inc . ,
v.i.karpman , _ nonlinear waves in dispersive media _ , ( nauka , moscow , 1973 ) .
l.d.landau and e.m.lifshitz , _ electrodynamics of continious media _ , ( nayka , moscow , 1978 ) .
a.yariv,_optical waves in crystals _ , ( john wiley and sons , inc , 1984 ) .
p.d.maker and r.w.terhune , physical review , 137 , 801 ( 1965 ) .
g.p.agrawal , _ nonliner fiber optics _ , ( academic press inc . , 2003 ) .
l.m.kovachev and v.n.serkin , izv .
nayk , physics , 53 , 1599 , ( 1989 ) .
i.p.kaminow , ieee j. quantum electronics , qe-17 , 15 ( 1981 ) .
j.yang , w.l.kath , c.r.menyuk , optics letters , 26 , 1472 ( 2001 ) .
c.r.menyuk,ieee j. quantum electronics , qe22 , 2674 ( 1989 ) . | we have investigated the nonlinear amplitude vector equation governing the evolution of optical pulses in optical and uv region .
we are normalizing this equation for the cases of different and equal transverse and longitudinal size of optical pulses or modulated optical waves , of week and strong dispersion .
this gives us the possibility to reduce the amplitude equation to different nonlinear evolution equations in the partial cases .
for some of these nonlinear equations exact vortex solutions are found .
conditions for experimental observations of these vortices are determined .
we have found large spectral zones on the wings of the electron resonances of metal vapors and also near to the plasma frequency where the amplitude equation can be reduced to 3d+1 vector nonlinear schrdinger equation .
pacs 42.81.dp;05.45.yv;42.65.tg |
dust is known to be ubiquitous in our galaxy , playing a crucial role in the heating , cooling and reprocessing of the interstellar medium ( ism ) .
it is therefore no surprise that dust exists within hii regions , and several studies have been aimed at revealing the distribution of dust within these ionized regions ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
hii regions are the result of the formation of early type ob stars , with their exact shape and size dependent on the surrounding environment and the balance between photoionization and recombination .
they provide us with an opportunity to investigate the star formation rate ( sfr ) within our own galaxy , and there has also been substantial work suggesting that hii regions play an important role in triggering star formation ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
given the importance of hii regions , it is essential to fully understand the physics and dynamics of these sources .
@xmath5{fig1a.pdf } & % \includegraphics[scale=0.65 , viewport=50 140 550 550]{fig1a.pdf } & \includegraphics[scale=0.2 , viewport=20 -400 550 50]{fig1b.pdf } \\ % \includegraphics[scale=0.2 , viewport=20 -400 550 50]{fig1b.pdf } \\ \end{array}$ ] in this analysis we focus solely on the hii region rcw175 .
rcw175 , located on the galactic plane at @xmath6 = 29.@xmath707 and @xmath8 = @xmath90.@xmath768 , was originally identified and catalogued by @xcite and was observed in emission with an h@xmath10 filter by @xcite .
rcw175 is actually just one component of the entire complex that will be discussed in this work .
as shown in figure [ fig:3_color_rcw175 ] , the complex consists of two separate components : g29.1 - 0.7 , a diffuse component to the east that is visible in h@xmath10 ( this is the component detected by @xcite and @xcite ) and g29.0 - 0.6 , a more compact component to the west that is heavily obscured by dust , and as a consequence , was not detectable in h@xmath10 emission . throughout this paper
we will use rcw175 to refer to the entire complex .
rcw175 is a particularly interesting hii region , as it has been observed to be a source of anomalous microwave emission ( ame ; @xcite ) .
ame is observed as an excess of emission with respect to the other galactic emission mechanisms at cm wavelengths , namely : thermal bremsstrahlung or free - free emission produced as a result of the interaction between the free electrons and ions in the ionized gas ; synchrotron emission originating from the acceleration of relativistic electrons in the galactic magnetic fields ; and thermal dust emission arising from the vibration of large dust grains .
ame is often attributed to electric dipole radiation arising from rapidly spinning small dust grains , each containing a dipole moment @xcite , and has been observed in other galactic hii regions @xcite along with a number of additional galactic environments such as molecular clouds @xcite , dark clouds @xcite and reflection nebulae @xcite . in this work
we attempt to provide a complete analysis of rcw175 in order to improve our understanding of both hii regions in general and also the ame .
the layout of the paper is as follows : section [ sec : data ] presents the data used in this work . in section [ sec : results_discussion ]
we describe the morphology of the region and compute the kinematic distance , the sfr and the dust mass .
we also produce a complete spectral energy distribution ( sed ) of the source and discuss the presence of ame , including its possible origin and excitation mechanism within the specific environment of rcw175 . finally , in section [ sec : summary ] we summarize our results and discuss our conclusions .
performing a thorough investigation of rcw175 requires data spanning a wide range of wavelengths .
however , given the angular size of rcw175 ( @xmath11 25 arcmin
see figure [ fig:3_color_rcw175 ] ) , we decided to only select data with an angular resolution @xmath12 15 arcmin to ensure the region was at least partially resolved .
all the data used in this analysis are described in sections [ subsec : ir_data ] , [ subsec : radio_data ] and [ subsec : spectral_data ] corresponding to infrared ( ir ) data , radio continuum data and radio spectral data , respectively . the _ infrared astronomical satellite _ ( _ iras _ ) data provide almost complete all - sky coverage at four bands centered at 12 , 25 , 60 and 100 @xmath13 m .
the improved reprocessing of the _ iras _ survey ( iris ; @xcite ) data represent a significant improvement over the original _ iras _ data in regards to absolute calibration , destriping and the removal of the zodiacal light .
the iris data have a typical gain uncertainty of @xmath14 15 @xmath15 and an angular resolution of @xmath14 4 arcmin . to mitigate the effect of the limited resolving power of the iris data , we also include higher angular resolution data from the more recent _
spitzer space telescope _ and _ herschel space observatory _ satellites . to trace the warm dust in rcw175 we used mid - ir observations from the _ spitzer _ glimpse @xcite and mipsgal @xcite legacy programmes .
both of these progammes involved mapping the inner galactic plane ( @xmath960@xmath16 @xmath17 @xmath6 @xmath17 60@xmath16 ) and when combined produce a wavelength coverage of 3.6 , 4.5 , 5.8 , 8.0 , 24 and 70 @xmath13 m . in this analysis
, we decided to use only the 8 @xmath13 m emission from the glimpse survey and the 24 @xmath13 m from the mipsgal survey .
the reasons for neglecting the three shortest wavelength irac bands is that the point source density increases significantly with the decrease in wavelength , and at these shorter wavelengths the spectrum can be contaminated by the presence of ionic and molecular lines , therefore making it substantially more difficult to accurately investigate extended emission .
we also ignored the mips 70 @xmath13 m observations , which suffer from responsivity variations , as there are now superior quality data obtained with _
herschel _ at the same wavelength ( see section [ subsubsec : herschel_data ] ) .
both the irac 8 @xmath13 m data , with an angular resolution of 2 arcsec , and the mips 24 @xmath13 m data , with an angular resolution of 6 arcsec , were reprocessed independently from the _ spitzer science centre _ pipeline .
first , an extended emission correction was applied to the 8 @xmath13 m data to ensure that the irac calibration , which is based on point sources , was effectively applied to the extended emission . secondly ,
both the 8 and 24 @xmath13 m data were corrected for the contribution of zodiacal light , which if not subtracted can result in an overestimate of the emission at these wavelengths by up to a factor of two .
both data sets were then subjected to source extraction , as the removal of the sources allows us to better investigate the diffuse emission .
the final step in the reprocessing was to perform an overlap correction to ensure a consistent background at each wavelength . given the data reprocessing , we assume a typical uncertainty of 10 @xmath15 for the extended emission in both the irac 8 @xmath13 m and the mips 24 @xmath13 m data . to complement the mid - ir _ spitzer _ observations , data from the _ herschel space observatory _
@xcite , observed as part of the hi - gal key programme @xcite , were also incorporated into this analysis .
hi - gal , like both glimpse and mipsgal , is a photometric survey of the inner galactic plane ( @xmath960@xmath16 @xmath17 @xmath6 @xmath17 60@xmath16 , the pacs @xcite and spire @xcite photometers at 70 , 160 , 250 , 350 and 500 @xmath13 m . these data , with an angular resolution between 6 arcsec at 70 @xmath13 m and 35 arcsec at 500 @xmath13 m , were reduced with the romagal pipeline as described by @xcite .
the absolute zero level was determined through the iris 60 @xmath13 m data for the pacs 70 @xmath13 m observations and the iris 100 @xmath13 m data for the other four bands , in a similar manner to that described in @xcite .
we assume a 20 @xmath15 uncertainty for the extended emission in the pacs and spire data .
the national radio astronomy observatory ( nrao ) very large array ( vla ) sky survey ( nvss ) data at 1.4 ghz @xcite represent the highest angular resolution ( 0.75 arcmin ) radio map of rcw175 .
however , the nvss data were observed with the vla interferometer in d and dnc configuration , and due to a lack of short spacings they are characterized by a lack of sensitivity on scales greater than @xmath11 15 arcmin .
this makes the nvss map useful to identify high resolution radio structures present in rcw175 , but it can not be used to determine the total flux density within the region .
given the limitation of the nvss data discussed above , data from both the 21 cm @xcite and 11 cm @xcite galactic plane surveys performed with the effelsberg 100 m telescope were used in this analysis .
the total power level of the 21 cm ( 1.4 ghz ) survey data ( @xmath93@xmath16 @xmath17 @xmath6 @xmath17 240@xmath16 , based on the stockert 21 cm survey @xcite and they are characterized by an angular resolution of 9.4 arcmin . due to the data reduction techniques used to process the 11 cm ( 2.7 ghz ) survey data ( @xmath92@xmath16 @xmath17 @xmath6 @xmath17 240@xmath16 , large - scale structure had to be added separately using low resolution ( @xmath14 19 arcmin ) stockert 11 cm data @xcite .
the final map has an angular resolution of 4.3 arcmin .
based on observations of radio sources , the temperature calibration accuracy is believed to be of the order of 10 @xmath15 for both the 21 and 11 cm data . to complement the effelsberg data
, we used the parkes 6 cm ( 5 ghz ) data that were obtained as part of the @xcite southern hemisphere galactic plane survey ( @xmath9170@xmath16 @xmath17 @xmath6 @xmath17 40@xmath16 , parkes 64 m telescope .
these data have an angular resolution of 4.1 arcmin and typical uncertainties are estimated to be 10 @xmath15 .
@xcite observed the galactic plane ( @xmath95@xmath16 @xmath17 @xmath6 @xmath17 56@xmath16 , 3 cm ( 10 ghz ) using the 45 m telescope at the nobeyama radio observatory .
these data have an angular resolution of 3 arcmin and we assume a typical uncertainty of @xmath14 10 @xmath15
. data observed simultaneously at 3.6 and 2.1 cm ( 8.35 and 14.35 ghz ) with the green bank 13.7 m telescope @xcite as part of the green bank galactic plane survey ( @xmath915@xmath16 @xmath17 @xmath6 @xmath17 255@xmath16 , included in this analysis .
these data have an angular resolution of 9.7 and 6.6 arcmin at 3.6 and 2.1 cm , respectively , and we assume a typical uncertainty of 10 @xmath15 . the cosmic background imager ( cbi ; @xcite ) was a 13-element interferometer that operated in the wavelength range 1.2 0.8 cm ( 26 36 ghz ) .
it was with the cbi that @xcite first detected the presence of an ame component in rcw175 .
although the cbi was an interferometer , the entire rcw175 complex was observed within a single cbi primary beam ( 28.2 arcmin ) and hence any flux loss on these scales should be negligible .
the cbi synthesized beam is 4.3 arcmin and we assume a conservative uncertainty of 5 @xmath15 for the cbi data . _ wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe _ ( _ wmap _ ) 7 yr total intensity sky maps
@xcite represent all - sky observations at 1.3 , 0.9 , 0.7 , 0.5 and 0.3 cm ( 23 , 33 , 41 , 61 and 94 ghz ) with an angular resolution of 52.8 , 39.6 , 30.6 , 21.0 and 13.2 arcmin , respectively .
however , given the angular resolution restrictions discussed previously , we use only the _ wmap _ 94 ghz data in this analysis . although the _ wmap _ data are calibrated using the cmb dipole , and hence are very accurately calibrated , due to beam errors and other systematics we assume a conservative 5 @xmath15 uncertainty . to complement all of the photometric data described in sections [ subsec : ir_data ] and [ subsec : radio_data ] we also utilize spectral data to help investigate the kinematics of rcw175 .
@xmath18{fig3a.pdf } & % \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 600]{fig3a.pdf } & \hspace{2.50 mm } \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 650]{fig3b.pdf } & % \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 600]{fig3b.pdf } & \hspace{2.50 mm } \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 650]{fig3c.pdf } & % \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 600]{fig3c.pdf } & \hspace{2.50 mm } \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 650]{fig3d.pdf } & % \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 600]{fig3d.pdf } & \hspace{2.50 mm } \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 650]{fig3e.pdf } \\ % \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 600]{fig3e.pdf } \\ \end{array}$ ] @xmath19{fig3f.pdf } & % \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 600]{fig3f.pdf } & \hspace{2.50
mm } \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 100 500 600]{fig3g.pdf } \\
% \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 600]{fig3g.pdf } \\ \end{array}$ ] @xmath20{fig4a.pdf } & \hspace{2.50 mm } \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 600]{fig4b.pdf } & \hspace{2.50 mm } \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 600]{fig4c.pdf } & \hspace{2.50 mm } \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 600]{fig4d.pdf } & \hspace{2.50
mm } \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 600]{fig4e.pdf } \\ \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 100 500 600]{fig4f.pdf } & %
\includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 600]{fig4f.pdf } & \hspace{2.50 mm } \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 100 500 600]{fig4g.pdf } & % \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 600]{fig4g.pdf } & \hspace{2.50 mm } \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 100 500 600]{fig4h.pdf } & % \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 600]{fig4h.pdf } & \hspace{2.50 mm } \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 100 500 600]{fig4i.pdf } & % \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 600]{fig4i.pdf } & \hspace{2.50 mm } \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 100 500 600]{fig4j.pdf } \\
% \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 600]{fig4j.pdf } \\ \end{array}$ ] @xmath21{fig5a.pdf } & % \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 500]{fig5a.pdf } & \hspace{2.50
mm } \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 100 500 580]{fig5b.pdf } & % \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 500]{fig5b.pdf } & \hspace{2.50 mm } \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 100 500 580]{fig5c.pdf } & % \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 500]{fig5c.pdf } & \hspace{2.50 mm } \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 100 500 580]{fig5d.pdf } & % \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 500]{fig5d.pdf } & \hspace{2.50 mm } \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 100 500 580]{fig5e.pdf } \\
% \includegraphics[scale=0.175 , viewport=20 10 500 500]{fig5e.pdf } \\ \end{array}$ ] the atomic hydrogen component of the ism is known to be widely distributed throughout the galaxy , and therefore , even though rcw175 is an hii region , we still wish to investigate the atomic hydrogen in the vicinity of the source .
hi data of rcw175 were obtained from the vla galactic plane survey @xcite .
these observations were performed as part of a hi and 21 cm continuum emission survey covering the longitude range 18@xmath16 @xmath17 @xmath6 @xmath17 67@xmath16 , with a latitude coverage from spacing information that is missing from the vla interferometric observations is obtained by additional observations with the green bank telescope .
the hi spectral line data have an angular resolution of 1 arcmin , a spectral resolution of 1.56 km s@xmath4 and an r.m.s .
noise of 2 k. co data is widely regarded as the most effective tracer of molecular hydrogen . with this in mind , we incorporate both @xmath22co and @xmath23co observations of rcw175 in this analysis .
the @xmath22co observations were performed as part of the massachusetts
stony brook galactic plane co survey @xcite .
these observations were performed at 2.6 mm ( 115.3 ghz ) and mapped the j=10 transition in the longitude range 8@xmath16 @xmath17 @xmath6 @xmath17 90@xmath16 and the latitude range have an angular resolution of @xmath14 3 arcmin , a spectral resolution of 1 km s@xmath4 and an r.m.s .
sensitivity of @xmath14 0.4 k. the @xmath23co data were obtained from the galactic ring survey @xcite .
mapping the j=10 transition ( 2.7 mm or 110.2 ghz ) , these observations cover the longitude range 18@xmath16 @xmath17 @xmath6 @xmath17 55.7@xmath16 , and the latitude range have an angular resolution of 46 arcsec , a spectral resolution of 0.21 km s@xmath4 and an r.m.s .
sensitivity of 0.13 k. the radio recombination line ( rrl ) data were produced by @xcite by combining the three rrls found within the 64 mhz bandwidth of the parkes zone of avoidance hi survey @xcite data .
the three rrls , h166@xmath10 , h167@xmath10 and h168@xmath10 , occur at a wavelength of 21.0 , 21.4 and 21.8 cm ( 1.42 , 1.40 and 1.37 ghz ) , respectively .
the rrl data have an angular resolution of 14.8 arcmin , a spectral resolution of 20 km s@xmath4 and an r.m.s .
sensitivity of @xmath14 0.003 k.
in figure [ fig:3_color_rcw175 ] we have identified the two separate components that make up rcw175 .
both of these components , g29.0 - 0.6 and g29.1 - 0.7 , appear shell - like : g29.1 - 0.7 is a larger , more diffuse component , @xmath14 8 arcmin across , while g29.0 - 0.6 is more compact and only @xmath14 4 arcmin across .
based on its shape , and using 20 and 90 cm vla continuum data in conjunction with _ midcourse space experiment _ ( _ msx _ ) 21 @xmath13 m data , @xcite tentatively classified g29.1 - 0.7 as a supernova remnant ( snr ) candidate .
however , using all the available data presented in this analysis , we identify g29.1 - 0.7 as an hii region , which is consistent with the recent analysis performed by @xcite .
figure [ fig : data ] displays maps of rcw175 from the radio all the way to the mid - ir .
although some of the radio maps lack the resolution to completely resolve both components , g29.0 - 0.6 is clearly the brighter component .
this is true at all wavelengths , including the ir data .
pacs and spire ir emission originating from g29.1 - 0.7 is restricted mainly to a dust filament located along the edge of the shell visible in the irac 8 @xmath13 m map , while g29.0 - 0.6 appears strongly in all the _ herschel _ bands .
although g29.0 - 0.6 is the dominant component , both components are visible at all the radio frequencies , indicating the presence of ionized gas in both of them . from figure [ fig:3_color_rcw175 ]
it is possible to see that the 24 @xmath13 m emission appears to originate within both the diffuse shell of g29.1 - 0.7 and the compact shell of g29.0 - 0.6 , while conversely the 8 @xmath13 m emission largely avoids these regions , with the bulk of the 8 @xmath13 m emission being concentrated around the edge of the shells in filamentary structures .
this concept has previously been observed in other hii regions ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , and is generally explained in terms of the classical scenario of the formation of hii regions : the ionized gas , produced by the ionizing ob star , expands into the surrounding environment due to pressure gradients .
this expansion sweeps up the gas and dust creating an interface between the ionized gas and the surrounding material where photons of lower energy dominate , known as a photodissociation region ( pdr ; ( see * ? ? ?
* ) for a complete review ) .
in this hypothesis , the dust within the shell is warm , and thought to consist of small grains , while the smaller and less durable dust grains and large molecules , such as the polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons ( pahs ) , may be destroyed by the harsh radiation field or swept up by the radiation pressure from the ionizing source .
since this scenario is consistent with what we observe in rcw175 , we infer that rcw175 actually consists of two separate hii regions .
in addition to the two - shell structure , also visible in figure [ fig:3_color_rcw175 ] is the location of the b1 ii type star , s65 - 4 , which appears to be towards the very centre of g29.1 - 0.7 .
s65 - 4 is part of a five star cluster identified by @xcite , and is the only ob star in the @xcite catalogue within the vicinity of rcw175 .
we , therefore , believe that s65 - 4 is the ionization source that produced the diffuse shell , g29.1 - 0.7 .
the lack of any known ob stars associated with g29.0 - 0.6 does not suggest that there are none present , but instead can probably be explained by the fact that this more compact component is much more heavily obscured by dust as can be seen by looking at the longer wavelength ir maps in figure [ fig : data ] .
having identified what we believe to be two individual hii regions within rcw175 , we use the available spectral data to determine the relationship between them . by looking at the @xmath22co and @xmath23co spectral data displayed in figures [ fig:12co_data ] and [ fig:13co_data ]
, we determined that both g29.0 - 0.6 and g29.1 - 0.7 appear at a similar velocity of @xmath11 50 km s@xmath4 .
in addition to both components appearing at the same velocity , they also appear to be spatially associated with each other , with the co emission in g29.1 - 0.7 restricted to the dust filament along the shell boundary and g29.0 - 0.6 being located at one end of this filament .
this association implies that both components are at a similar distance and are actually interacting with each other . in general
, we find that the co emission appears to spatially replicate the _ herschel _ pacs and spire data , which is not entirely unexpected as both are tracing the denser environments within rcw175 .
as has previously been mentioned , although the shell structure of g29.1 - 0.7 can be seen at 8 @xmath13 m , the longer wavelength pacs and spire emission is concentrated in a dust filament along the edge of the shell , but does not entirely enclose the shell . assuming the hii region formation hypothesis
, this implies that the ism is much more dense in the direction of the filament , while in the other direction , the surrounding ism provided less resistance to the radiation pressure and hence the swept up material formed a much lower density shell . from figure
[ fig : rrl_data ] it is possible to identify an rrl component associated with rcw175 . however , due to the coarse angular resolution of data , it is difficult to determine exactly where the emission is originating from within rcw175 .
the rrl data trace the ionized gas , therefore confirming its presence within the region .
in fact , @xcite detected rrl emission from both g29.1 - 0.7 and g29.0 - 0.6 , confirming that ionized gas is present in both components of rcw175 , hence reinforcing the idea that both g29.1 - 0.7 and g29.0 - 0.6 are hii regions . to further understand the morphology of rcw175 , we model the ir emission using a dust emission model . in the past few years , there have been substantial improvements of dust models , which have significantly increased our understanding of the ism dust properties .
one such model has been developed by @xcite and is called dustem .
dustem is a sophisticated model that allows the user to parameterize various physical dust quantities to compute the corresponding emission and extinction properties .
it has previously been used to characterize the dust properties in a variety of environments , such as regions of diffuse emission on the galactic plane @xcite , the star forming region the eagle nebula @xcite and the perseus molecular cloud @xcite . in this analysis
we use dustem in a similar manner as was used in the previous works , modeling the dust in rcw175 in terms of five dust populations : small carbonaceous dust grains , large carbonaceous dust grains , large silicate dust grains and neutral and ionized pahs .
we merge the neutral and ionized pahs into a single component of pahs , use the small carbonaceous dust grains as the very small grain ( vsg ) dust component and combine the large carbonaceous and silicate dust grains to form a big grain ( bg ) dust component .
since dustem itself does not contain a fitting routine , we used an updated version of the sed - fitting routine developed for the analysis performed on the perseus molecular cloud by @xcite .
this fitting routine is based on the idl routine mpfit @xcite and combines the dust emissivities computed by dustem with the instrumental bandpass filters , deriving an estimate of the flux that would be effectively observed at a given wavelength . for this analysis
we take advantage of the new _ herschel _ data with their superior angular resolution , and ignore the iris and _ wmap _ data . combining the _ herschel _ data with the irac 8 @xmath13 m data and the mips 24 @xmath13 m data , results in seven bands which provide a measure of the thermal dust emission across the entire ir spectrum . therefore
, combining dustem with these seven ir bands allows us to characterize the three dust grain populations of interest : pahs , vsgs and bgs . to do this , all seven ir maps were convolved to the common angular resolution of the spire 500 @xmath13 m map ( 35 arcsec ) and regridded onto a unified grid of 11.5 arcsec pixels . running dustem with our sed - fitting routine on a pixel - by - pixel basis
, we fit the seven ir data points by adjusting the abundance of the pahs and vsgs relative to the bgs ( @xmath24 and @xmath25 ) , the strength of the exciting radiation field ( erf ; @xmath26 ) , and the column density of hydrogen ( @xmath27 ) . in the previous work on the perseus molecular cloud ,
@xcite parameterized the radiation field by simply scaling the @xcite solar neighborhood radiation field , which is realistic given the lack of high - mass star formation in the cloud .
however , since there is clearly a source of ionization present in rcw175 , scaling the standard @xcite solar neighborhood field alone would not be a good approximation .
therefore , we decided to parameterize the erf by combining the @xcite radiation field with a 40,000 k blackbody , which is the typical temperature of an ob star , representing the source of ionization . to combine these two separate components of the erf , we normalized the 40,000 k blackbody to the @xcite radiation field between 6 and 13.6 ev ( see figure [ fig : isrf ] ) .
in addition , given the presence of dust in rcw175 , we implement an extinguishing of the radiation field .
the final parameterization of the erf is as follows : * @xmath26 @xmath17 1 @xmath28 use the @xcite radiation field extinguished by dust + * @xmath26 = 1 @xmath28 use the @xcite radiation field + * @xmath26 @xmath29 1 @xmath28 use the @xcite radiation field plus a 40,000 k blackbody @xmath30{fig6a.pdf } & % \includegraphics[scale=0.45 , viewport=50 0 500 300]{fig6a.pdf } & \includegraphics[scale=0.45 , viewport=50 20 500 350]{fig6b.pdf } \\
% \includegraphics[scale=0.45 , viewport=50 0 500 300]{fig6b.pdf } \\
\end{array}$ ] in figure [ fig : isrf ] it is possible to see the parameterization of the erf for the full range of values used in this analysis .
also displayed is the @xcite radiation field which represents the boundary between values of @xmath26 which are greater than , or less than , equal to 1 .
regarding our parameterization of the erf , from figure [ fig : isrf ] it is apparent that the dust extinction only affects the shorter wavelengths and that for values of @xmath26 @xmath31 2500 , the blackbody becomes totally dominant .
the result of running our sed - fitting routine and dustem on the rcw175 data was parameter maps of @xmath24 , @xmath25 , @xmath26 and @xmath27 .
an example of one of the fits obtained is displayed in figure [ fig : dustem_spectra ] .
this is the spectrum for a pixel within the centre of the shell of g29.1 - 0.7 and it shows the ir data , the best fitting values from our fitting routine and the three dust components required to reproduce the observed emission .
@xmath32{fig8a.pdf } & \includegraphics[scale=0.320,viewport=150 100 680 700]{fig8b.pdf } & \includegraphics[scale=0.320,viewport=150 100 680 700]{fig8c.pdf } \\
\end{array}$ ] @xmath33{fig8d.pdf } & \includegraphics[scale=0.320,viewport=100 100 680 700]{fig8e.pdf } \\
\end{array}$ ] in addition to producing the four parameter maps , dustem combines the optical and thermal properties of the grains with the given erf and calculates a temperature distribution for each size bin for each grain species .
these temperature distributions are computed taking into account the multi - photon absorption processes , based on the method described by @xcite .
therefore , to complement the parameter maps , we computed the median temperature of the bg size distribution , and used it as an estimate of the equilibrium temperature of the dust ( @xmath34 ) .
we emphasize that it is unphysical to compute a median temperature for the other dust components as these are stochastically heated and hence are not in thermal equilibrium with the erf .
this @xmath34 map , along with the four parameter maps , is displayed in figure [ fig : param_maps_contours ] .
these maps allow us to better understand the dust properties and environment within rcw175 .
looking at figure [ fig : param_maps_contours ] we find that the abundances of the pahs and vsgs relative to the bgs vary between @xmath11 0.5 1.5 and @xmath11 0.5 10 , respectively .
the maps also show that the vsgs are concentrated in the interior of both g29.1 - 0.7 and g29.0 - 0.6 , while the pahs are constrained to the edge of both components .
there is also a clear deficit of pahs within g29.1 - 0.7 .
as discussed in section [ subsec : morphology ] , this is consistent with the current hypothesis of hii region formation , with the pahs confined to the pdr and the warmer vsgs present inside the shell .
the strength of the erf map reveals a range of values from @xmath11 2 30 , with the highest values found towards g29.0 - 0.6 , implying that there is a significant source of excitation present .
this is again consistent with what we inferred from the radio and ir maps , and suggests that g29.0 - 0.6 is also an hii region . in g29.1 - 0.7 ,
the erf appears to be offset from the centre of the shell and concentrated toward the dust filament along the edge of the shell .
the column density map reveals that the highest densities ( @xmath11 1.5 @xmath1 10@xmath35 h @xmath36 ) are also found in the vicinity of g29.0 - 0.6 , implying that there are large quantities of dust present which we believe is the reason for a lack of observed ob stars associated with this component .
also observable is that the density is decreased toward the centre of the diffuse shell of g29.1 - 0.7 with values of @xmath11 5 @xmath1 10@xmath37 h @xmath36 .
the dust temperature map closely resembles the erf map , which is expected given the relationship between these two physical quantities , and shows that the dust temperature in rcw175 is in the range of 20
30 k , which is typical for hii regions .
this map also illustrates that the highest temperatures are found towards g29.0 - 0.6 .
having already identified that these two hii regions are associated with each other , and based on the fact that g29.0 - 0.6 is more compact , has a stronger erf , a higher dust temperature , and a higher column density , we believe that g29.0 - 0.6 is younger than the more evolved g29.1 - 0.7 , and hypothesize that it may even have formed as a result of the expansion of g29.1 - 0.7 into the surrounding ism . such triggered star formation is ubiquitous throughout the galaxy ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) essentially because the gravitational timescale of molecular gas is shorter than the typical lifetime of an o - type star .
@xcite identified three distinct triggering mechanisms : i ) direct compression of pre - existing density enhancements in a cloud ; ii ) accumulation of gas into a dense filament that collapses gravitationally into dense cores ( `` collect and collapse '' ) ; and iii ) cloud collisions .
given the environment of rcw175 and the significant differences in size , and hence age , it is unlikely that this was produced as the result of cloud collisions .
assuming that g29.1 - 0.7 formed first , then the expansion into the surrounding ism could have triggered the formation of g29.0 - 0.6 by either causing an existing density enhancement to collapse or by the collect and collapse method .
it is difficult to determine which method is more favorable , however , given that g29.0 - 0.6 is located at the edge of the shell of g29.1 - 0.7 , it is likely that triggering has occured .
this idea of triggered star formation will be developed further in section [ subsec : ysos ] .
previous estimates of the distance to rcw175 have been presented in the literature . using the rotation curve for the northern hemisphere given by @xcite with values of @xmath38 = 10 kpc and @xmath39 = 250 km s@xmath4
, @xcite found a kinematic distance of 3.5 kpc to rcw175 . assuming a value of the ratio of total to selective absorption @xmath40 = 3.0
, @xcite computed the reddening and distance to the ionizing b1 ii star in rcw175 using the intrinsic colors given by @xcite and the absolute magnitude
spectral type calibration of @xcite , and found a value of 3.6 kpc . with the spectral data described in section [ subsec : spectral_data ] now available , it is possible to update the distance estimates to rcw175 .
the first step in this process is to compute the mean velocity component associated with rcw175 for each of the spectral tracers . to do this
, we produced the mean spectrum within a 0.45 @xmath1 0.45 square degree region centred on rcw175 , and these spectra are displayed in figure [ fig : velocity_components ] .
based on the velocity measurements in the literature and by inspecting the individual data cubes ( as displayed in figures [ fig:12co_data ] , [ fig:13co_data ] and [ fig : rrl_data ] ) , it is clear that the velocity component associated with rcw175 occurs around @xmath11 50 km s@xmath4 .
the velocity component at @xmath11 50 km s@xmath4 in each of the @xmath22co , @xmath23co , hi and rrl spectra were simultaneously fitted with a gaussian and a linear baseline , resulting in a measure of the mean velocity component associated with rcw175 for each of the tracers .
these mean velocities , along with some measurements from the literature , are listed in table [ table : velocity_components ] .
l c c c c l h@xmath10 & 49.5 @xmath0 5.0 & 3.2 @xmath0 0.5 & 10.8 @xmath0 1.5 & 5.4 @xmath0 0.8 & @xcite + @xmath22co & 52.4 @xmath0 1.0 & 3.3 @xmath0 0.3 & 10.7 @xmath0 1.1 & 5.3 @xmath0 0.5 & @xcite + @xmath22co & 51.8 @xmath0 1.1 & 3.3 @xmath0 0.3 & 10.7 @xmath0 1.1 & 5.4 @xmath0 0.5 & this work + @xmath23co & 52.1 @xmath0 0.5 & 3.3 @xmath0 0.3 & 10.7 @xmath0 1.1 & 5.4 @xmath0 0.5 & this work + hi & 44.8 @xmath0 1.3 & 2.9 @xmath0 0.3 & 11.0 @xmath0 1.1 & 5.6 @xmath0 0.6 & this work + rrl &
47.7 @xmath0 20.0 & 3.1 @xmath0 1.3 & 10.9 @xmath0 4.7 & 5.5 @xmath0 2.4 & this work + [ table : velocity_components ] @xmath41{fig10a.pdf } & % \includegraphics[scale=0.35 , viewport=80 50 750 450]{fig10a.pdf } & \includegraphics[scale=0.35 , viewport=80 50 750 550]{fig10b.pdf } \\ % \includegraphics[scale=0.35 , viewport=80 50 750 450]{fig10b.pdf } \\ \end{array}$ ] from both the spectra displayed in figure [ fig : velocity_components ] and the measurements listed in table [ table : velocity_components ] , it is possible to see that the velocities of the molecular gas tracers ( @xmath22co and @xmath23co ) all have values which are larger than the values for the ionized gas tracers ( h@xmath10 and rrl ) .
this suggests that the molecular gas and the ionized gas may have become dissociated and that the ionized gas has ruptured and perhaps escaped the molecular gas .
this idea is consistent with what we observe when we look at rcw175 in the mid- to far - ir ( see figure [ fig : data ] ) , with only one side of the shell of g29.1 - 0.7 being visible as a filament like structure at the longer wavelengths .
this is the same structure that is visible in the co data cubes , implying that it consists of colder , denser dust that has been swept up by the radiation pressure within the centre of the shell .
the fact that this structure is not fully enclosing the ionized gas implies that the shell has become broken , allowing the ionized gas to leak out into the surrounding ism .
a similar conclusion can be drawn regarding the hi component , which has a lower velocity than both the molecular gas tracers and the ionized gas tracers .
a lack of hi associated directly with rcw175 is not surprising since this is an hii region .
the spectra in figure [ fig : velocity_components ] also highlight the clumpy nature of the co gas compared to the hi gas .
the hi gas is more smoothly distributed throughout the galaxy than the co , and this is evidenced by the @xmath22co and @xmath23co spectra containing much more structure than the hi spectra . to estimate the kinematic distance to rcw175
, we combined the computed velocity components with a galactic rotation curve .
we used the rotation curve models of @xcite , which holds for galactocentric distances less than 17 kpc making it adequate for use in this situation .
we adopted the @xcite linear rotation curve of the form @xmath42 where @xmath43 is the rotation velocity around the galactic centre of an object at a galactocentric distance , @xmath44 , @xmath39 and @xmath45 are the rotation velocity and angular velocity of the sun , respectively , and @xmath46 and @xmath47 are the fitting coefficients . for the adopted values of @xmath38
= 8.0 kpc and @xmath39 = 220 km s@xmath4 , @xcite found @xmath46 = 0.99334 , @xmath47 = 0.0030385 and @xmath45 = 27.5 km s@xmath4 .
we note that the rotation curves of @xcite are based on both hi @xcite and co @xcite measurements , with 150 and 104 data points , respectively .
the observations by @xcite targeted all 313 objects in the @xcite catalog and they found detections for 194 of these objects , including rcw175 .
this implies that rcw175 was therefore one of the data points used by @xcite to compute their rotation curve , using a distance of 3.5 @xmath0 1.2 kpc .
however , given that there were a total of 254 data points , the weight of any individual region is much less than 1 @xmath15 , and hence we feel confident in using this rotation curve to compute the kinematic distance to rcw175 . for sources with galactic radii less than that of the sun ( i.e. sources within the solar circle )
the estimated solar distance becomes degenerate as there are two solutions for every velocity , corresponding to a near distance , @xmath48 , and a far distance , @xmath49 .
this is known as the kinematic distance ambiguity .
the kinematic distances , @xmath48 and @xmath49 , and galactocentric distances , @xmath44 , for the data discussed in section [ subsec : spectral_data ] and for the values from the literature are tabulated in table [ table : velocity_components ] .
the distances obtained using the velocity measurements from the literature are more accurate then the corresponding previous estimates due to the updated rotation curve and updated values of @xmath38 and @xmath39 .
the kinematic distance ambiguity makes it difficult to determine whether @xmath48 or @xmath49 is the correct distance , however , based on the distance estimate of 3.6 kpc to the ionizing source s65 - 4 located at the centre of g29.1 - 0.7 @xcite , we select the near kinematic distance for this component .
since we have seen from the @xmath22co and @xmath23co data in figures [ fig:12co_data ] and [ fig:13co_data ] , that g29.1 - 0.7 and g29.0 - 0.6 are interacting , we believe that both components are situated at the near distance .
we note that @xcite placed g29.0 - 0.6 at the far distance .
however , they used two separate methods to break the ambiguity , with each method giving a different result : one placing it at the near distance and the other placing it at the far distance . given this uncertainty , we feel confident choosing the near distance for both components of rcw175 .
the adopted kinematic distances , @xmath50 , and galactocentric distances , @xmath44 , are plotted in figure [ fig : distances ] . by combining all the distance estimates
listed in table [ table : velocity_components ] , we compute the mean distance to rcw175 , @xmath50 = 3.2 @xmath0 0.2 kpc , and the mean galactocentric distance , @xmath44 = 5.4 @xmath0 0.3 kpc .
various works have attempted to use the sfr from individual hii regions ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and apply them to the entire galaxy to compute the galactic sfr .
such an analysis requires investigating multiple hii regions , which is beyond the scope of this work , but computing the sfr of rcw175 will be helpful to others estimating the galactic sfr .
@xcite developed a calibration to use monochromatic 24 @xmath13 m emission from extragalactic hii regions as a sfr indicator .
similar analyses have been performed by @xcite , @xcite and @xcite , each derived based on slightly different 24 @xmath13 m luminosity ranges .
@xcite estimated an intrinsic scatter of the order of 2 between these different calibrations .
recently , @xcite performed an analysis investigating various sfr determinations , and in doing so they extended the @xcite extragalactic mid - ir diagnostic to the galactic hii region m17 .
following their example , we use the extragalactic calibrations to compute the sfr in rcw175 . to estimate the 24 @xmath13 m luminosity we computed the flux density within rcw175 and converted this to a luminosity using @xmath51 where @xmath50 is the distance in m
, @xmath52 is the flux density in w m@xmath53 hz@xmath4 and @xmath54 is the frequency in hz . the flux density was derived using aperture photometry in a circular aperture centred on rcw175 with a radius of 12 arcmin .
an estimate of the background was obtained by computing the median value of all the pixels within an annulus , also centred on rcw175 , with an inner radius of 14 arcmin and an outer radius of 17.5 arcmin .
given that we compute a 24 @xmath13 m luminosity of the order of 1 @xmath1 10@xmath55 erg s@xmath4 for rcw175 , the calibrations established by @xcite and @xcite are the most applicable .
therefore , using the calibration of @xcite @xmath56 where @xmath57 is the 24 @xmath13 m luminosity in units of erg s@xmath4 , results in a sfr of ( 12.6 @xmath0 1.9 ) @xmath1 10@xmath2 m@xmath3 yr@xmath4 .
this result is consistent with the sfr computed using the @xcite calibration , which is ( 12.6 @xmath0 1.8 ) @xmath1 10@xmath2 m@xmath3 yr@xmath4 .
@xcite explored other methods of sfr determination , including the thermal radio continuum diagnostic . unlike the 24 @xmath13 m diagnostic , which uses dust emission as an indirect measure of the lyman continuum photon flux , @xmath58
, this method is based on the ionized gas .
the lyman continuum photon flux is the driving force of hii regions and the ionized gas can be observed at frequencies of a few ghz , due to the emission of thermal bremsstrahlung or free - free radiation ( as can be seen in figure [ fig : data ] ) .
@xcite adopted the following relationship between the sfr and the lyman continuum rate @xmath59 therefore to compute the sfr based on the thermal radio emission , we combined this relationship with the expression for @xmath58 derived by @xcite @xmath60 where @xmath61 + 1.5~\mathrm{ln } \left(\frac{t_{e}}{\mathrm{k}}\right ) \right\ } , \label{equ : a}\end{aligned}\ ] ] as defined by @xcite , and @xmath62 is the electron temperature .
having already obtained the mean galactocentric distance to rcw175 , we used the relationship between the galactocentric distance of hii regions and their electron temperature , empirically derived by @xcite based on a sample of 404 hii regions , to compute @xmath62 .
the expression from @xcite is @xmath63 where @xmath44 is in units of kpc .
this results in @xmath62 = 5861.6 @xmath0 189.5 k. throughout the rest of this analysis we adopt a value of @xmath62 = 5800 k. incorporating this value of @xmath62 into equation ( [ equ : nc ] ) and the flux density , @xmath64 , computed by integrating the flux in the parkes 5 ghz map ( using the same aperture as for the 24 @xmath13 m map ) we found that @xmath58 @xmath11 5 @xmath1 10@xmath65 photons s@xmath4 which , when substituted into equation ( [ equ : sfr_ff ] ) , results in a sfr @xmath14 3.6 @xmath1 10@xmath2 m@xmath3 yr@xmath4 .
this value is of the order 3
4 times smaller than the sfr computed from the mid - ir luminosity indicator .
this discrepancy can partially be explained in terms of the intrinsic uncertainties in the different diagnostics , which is of the order 2 3 , with an additional contribution arising from the fact that @xmath58 is an underestimate of the true lyman continuum rate .
equation ( [ equ : nc ] ) only computes the lyman continuum rate of the lyman photons that are ionizing the gas .
this is not the same as computing the lyman continuum rate of all the lyman photons emitted by the ionizing star , as some of the lyman photons are absorbed by dust before having the opportunity to ionize the gas . in light of this effect , we believe that the sfr of rcw175 is most accurately computed based on the 24 @xmath13 m emission .
c c c 24 & [ 24 ] < 7 & 65 + k@xmath66/24 & k@xmath66 < 14 and k@xmath66@xmath9[24 ] > 1 & 58 + & [ 8]@xmath9[24 ] > 0.5 and & + & ( ( [ 8]@xmath9[24 ] < 4 and [ 8 ] < 10 ) or ( [ 8]@xmath9[24 ] @xmath67 4 and [ 8 ] < 2.5@xmath1([8]@xmath9[24 ] ) ) ) & + & [ 4.5 ] < 6 and ( [ 4.5 ] @xmath67 6 and [ 4.5 ] @xmath68 11.5 and [ 4.5]@xmath9[8 ] > 0.4 ) & + & or ( [ 4.5 ] > 11.5 and [ 4.5 ] < 0.6944@xmath1([4.5]@xmath9[8])+11.22 ) & + 3.6/4.5/5.8/8 & [ 3.6]@xmath9[4.5 ] > 0.15 and [ 5.8]@xmath9[8 ] > 0.3 and [ 3.6 ] < 13.5 & 12 + [ table : ysoc_selection ] + as discussed by @xcite , and briefly in section [ subsec : dust_modeling ] , hii regions are known to play an important role in triggering star formation . having concluded that we believe that g29.0 - 0.6 was possibly triggered by the expansion of g29.1 - 0.7 into the surrounding ism , we would like to investigate if there is any ongoing triggering occurring within rcw175 . to do this
we looked at the location of candidate young stellar objects ( ysos ) in relation to the general morphology of rcw175 . to identify candidate ysos
we used the mipsgal point source catalogue ( shenoy et al . in prep . ) which contains all the mipsgal sources detected at 24 @xmath13 m .
since the coverage of the mipsgal survey is similar to that of the glimpse survey , the mipsgal catalogue has been band - merged with the glimpse sources .
the glimpse point source archive contains sources at all four irac bands ( 3.6 , 4.5 , 5.8 and 8 @xmath13 m ) that have been band - merged with sources in all three 2mass bands ( j , h and k@xmath66 ) .
the result is a band - merged source catalogue with sources detected at both near- and mid - ir wavelengths that is suitable to identify yso candidates . selecting only 24 @xmath13 m sources with a completeness and reliability of @xmath29 95 @xmath15
, we find 95 sources within a 0.45 degree square region centred on rcw175 .
we implemented the color - magnitude and color - color selection criteria of @xcite to identify yso candidates .
these criteria are listed in table [ table : ysoc_selection ] along with the corresponding number of sources in each selection , and are displayed visually in figure [ fig : ysoc_selection ] . combining these selection criteria resulted in a total of 6 yso candidates within the vicinity of rcw175 ,
all of which are listed in table [ table : ysoc ] .
c c c c 25 & 18:45:59.9 & @xmath93:49:12.0 & + 40 & 18:46:25.2 & @xmath93:48:09.1 & + 53 & 18:46:43.8 & @xmath93:44:35.3 & + 66 & 18:46:51.8 & @xmath93:41:59.5 & yso candidate @xcite + 67 & 18:47:06.8 & @xmath93:43:49.0 & + 73 & 18:46:31.4 & @xmath93:38:27.6 & + [ table : ysoc ] a simbad search within 6 arcsec ( the fwhm of the 24 @xmath13 m point response function ) of the yso candidate position reveals that 5 of the sources ( sources 25 , 40 , 53 , 67 and 73 ) have no simbad counterparts and one of the candidates ( source 66 ) has previously been identified as a possible yso candidate @xcite .
looking at the location of the 6 candidate ysos displayed in figure [ fig:3_color_rcw175 ] , two occur on the periphery of rcw175 ( sources 25 and 73 ) . sources 53 and 66 are located within the diffuse shell of g29.1 - 0.7 .
the location of these sources occur at both ends of a small filament of warm dust at either side of the ionizing source s65 - 4 .
source 67 and source 40 are found in the denser pdrs surrounding g29.1 - 0.7 and g29.0 - 0.6 , respectively .
given the lack of any distance estimate to these sources , it is difficult to confirm that these yso candidates are indeed associated with rcw175 , however , given the location is within the dense pdr , sources 40 and 67 are likely associated with rcw175 , and show that triggering may be occurring within this region .
to estimate the total dust mass associated with rcw175 , we use @xmath69 where @xmath70 is the flux density , @xmath50 is the distance to rcw175 , @xmath71 is the dust opacity and @xmath72 is the planck function . the dust opacity was computed using @xmath73 from @xcite , which is accurate for wavelengths between 20 700 @xmath13 m . since the cold , bgs contribute most of the dust mass , we evaluate equation ( [ equ : mass ] ) at a wavelength of 500 @xmath13 m . using the 500 @xmath13 m flux density and the equilibrium temperature of the cold dust component in rcw175 ( see section [ subsec : sed ] and table [ table : fluxes ] ) along with the distance , we compute a total dust mass of 215 @xmath0 53 m@xmath3 .
we also computed the dust mass using the 250 and 350 @xmath13 m data and found that the total dust masses were in agreement ( within the uncertainties ) with the one computed using the 500 @xmath13 m data .
having discussed the various intricacies of the morphology of rcw175 in the previous sections , we now want to look at the energy budget of the region . to do this we computed the flux density of the entire complex from the radio to the mid - ir , using the same method as was used to compute the 24 @xmath13 m flux density described in section [ subsec : sfr ] . unlike the dust modeling analysis performed with dustem in section [ subsec : dust_modeling ] , we are now looking at the entire region and so no longer restrict ourselves to using only the high resolution _
spitzer _ and _ herschel _ ir data .
therefore , we also incorporate the iris and _ wmap _ data , as well as all the radio data discussed in section [ subsec : radio_data ] .
as stated previously , we ignore the nvss data due to a lack of short spacings .
all the flux densities and the corresponding wavelengths are listed in table [ table : fluxes ] . both the calibration uncertainty and the flux density uncertainty from the aperture photometry , which is computed based on the r.m.s of the pixel values in the background , have been incorporated into the final uncertainties of the flux densities .
the values in table [ table : fluxes ] are plotted in figure [ fig : full_sed ] .
this sed is an updated version of the original sed presented by @xcite .
we have used more recent data where available ( e.g. effelsberg 1.4 ghz ) and we have substantially improved the constraint on the rayleigh - jeans tail of the thermal dust distribution given the inclusion of the _ herschel _ data .
it should also be noted that even though @xcite used gaussian fitting to compute the flux densities , while in this anlaysis we have used aperture photometry , the general consistency between both sets of data points is good .
the data between 2.7 and 12491.4 ghz , or 11 cm and 24 @xmath13 m , were simultaneously fitted with a power - law ( @xmath64 @xmath74 @xmath75 ) , a spinning dust model and two modified blackbody curves ( @xmath64 @xmath74 @xmath76 ) representing the free - free , ame and thermal dust emission , respectively .
these components will be discussed further in sections [ subsubsec : low_freq ] , [ subsubsec : thermal_dust ] and [ subsubsec : ame ] .
c c c c c 1.4 & effelsberg 100 m & @xcite & 9.4 & 3.2 @xmath0 0.5 + 2.7 & effelsberg 100 m & @xcite & 4.3 & 5.7 @xmath0 0.9 + 5 & parkes 64 m & @xcite & 4.1 & 4.0 @xmath0 0.8 + 8.35 & green bank 13.7 m & @xcite & 9.7 & 2.6 @xmath0 0.3 + 10 & nobeyama 45 m & @xcite & 3.0 & 2.6 @xmath0 0.4 + 14.35 & green bank 13.7 m & @xcite & 6.6 & 4.1 @xmath0 0.6 + 31 & cbi & @xcite & 4.3 & 6.0 @xmath0 0.3 + 94 & _ wmap _ & @xcite & 13.2 & 1.9 @xmath0 0.4 + 599.6 ( 500 @xmath13
m ) & _ herschel_/spire & @xcite & 0.6 & 649.0 @xmath0 134.0 + 856.5 ( 350 @xmath13 m ) & _ herschel_/spire & @xcite & 0.4 & 1580.0 @xmath0 322.0 + 1199.2 ( 250 @xmath13 m ) & _ herschel_/spire & @xcite & 0.3 & 4110.0 @xmath0 829.0 + 1873.7 ( 160 @xmath13 m ) & _ herschel_/pacs & @xcite & 0.2 & 9660.0 @xmath0 1940.0 + 2997.9 ( 100 @xmath13 m ) & iris & @xcite & 4.3 & 10300.0 @xmath0 1800.0 + 4282.7 ( 70 @xmath13 m ) & _ herschel_/pacs & @xcite & 0.1 & 9580.0 @xmath0 1920.0 + 4996.5
( 60 @xmath13 m ) & iris & @xcite & 4.0 & 6740.0 @xmath0 1050.0 + 11991.7 ( 25 @xmath13 m ) & iris & @xcite & 3.8 & 677.0 @xmath0 106.0 + 12491.4 ( 24 @xmath13 m ) & _ spitzer_/mips & @xcite & 0.1 & 581.0 @xmath0 58.1 + 24982.7 ( 12 @xmath13
m ) & iris & @xcite & 3.8 & 287.0 @xmath0 52.8 + 37474.1 ( 8 @xmath13 m ) & _ spitzer_/irac & @xcite & 0.03 & 483.0 @xmath0 48.3 + [ table : fluxes ] fitting the radio data in figure [ fig : full_sed ] with a single power - law resulted in a spectral index of , @xmath10 = @xmath90.3 @xmath0 0.1 .
this is steeper than the typical spectral index of @xmath11 @xmath90.1 expected for optically thin free - free emission at these frequencies @xcite , however it is consistent with the value of @xmath90.32 @xmath0 0.15 obtained previously by @xcite . to explain this steeper spectral index we believe that there must be some residual contamination from synchrotron emission in the low frequency radio maps which , given that synchrotron emission generally follows a power - law with a spectral index of @xmath11 @xmath90.7 , could be contributing to the steeper spectral index found in rcw175 . given that rcw175 is located on the galactic plane , there will be a contribution from the diffuse synchrotron emission .
additionally , a search in the @xcite catalogue of galactic supernova remnants reveals three nearby ( @xmath17 1 degree away ) supernova remnants , g29.7 - 0.3 ( kes 75 ) and g28.6 - 0.1 both @xmath11 0.7 degrees away and g29.6 + 0.1 @xmath11 0.9 degrees away , which may be causing synchrotron relativistic electrons to escape into the surrounding environments .
we therefore conclude that the low frequency emission in rcw 175 is arising from the free - free emission from the ionized gas and some small contribution from background residual synchrotron emission . to represent the thermal dust emission we used a modified blackbody curve , fitting for both the dust temperature , @xmath34 , and the dust emissivity spectral index , @xmath77 .
two curves were used to fit both the cold and warm dust components .
this is necessary since we are computing the sed for the entire region , and we know that the dust within the entire region is not emitting at a single temperature . in the dustem analysis , since we were fitting the sed on a pixel - by - pixel basis , we did not have this problem , and hence were able to restrict ourselves to using a single dust temperature .
the best fitting values for the cold dust are @xmath78 = 2.0 @xmath0 0.1 and @xmath79 = 22.9 @xmath0 5.8 k , while for the warm dust we find best fitting values of @xmath80 = 2.0 @xmath0 0.1 and @xmath81 = 52.7 @xmath0 20.5 k. these values of the cold and warm dust components are consistent with previous estimates of dust temperatures in hii regions ( e.g. * ? ? ?
it is also noticeable that by including the _ herschel _ data in our sed , the temperatures computed in this analysis are more accurate than the dust temperature estimated by @xcite who fitted a modified blackbody curve to the iris 100 and 60 @xmath13 m data , and obtained a temperature of 30.1 @xmath0 5.7 k. the excess of emission observed between @xmath11 10 60 ghz in the sed of rcw175 is a clear indication of the presence of ame .
the peaked nature of the ame spectrum is consistent with the current theoretical models of spinning dust @xcite , and therefore we modeled the ame as a spinning dust component . to do this we used the spinning dust code , spdust @xcite . for a given set of input parameters , spdust computes the emissivity of the spinning dust emission normalized by the hydrogen column density .
we used the updated version of spdust , which not only accounts for dust grains spinning about their axis of greatest inertia , it also accounts for grains spinning about their non principal axes .
since we have only two data points covering the critical frequency range , we decided not to fit for the individual spinning dust parameters within spdust .
instead , we adopted the idealized physical parameters for the various phases of the ism defined by @xcite ( warm ionized medium , warm neutral medium , cold neutral medium , molecular cloud , dark cloud , reflection nebula and pdr ) within spdust and fitted for the column density .
this simply involves scaling the amplitude of the spinning dust curve and has no effect on its shape or peak frequency .
we performed the fit using the parameters for each of the idealized environments and found that the warm ionized medium model resulted in the best fit to the data .
the spinning dust curve for the warm ionized medium fits the data extremely well , and from the fit we found that the column density required to produce the observed spinning dust emission is @xmath82 = ( 3.8 @xmath0 0.5 ) @xmath1 10@xmath37 h @xmath36 , which is consistent with the range of values of the total column density obtained from the dustem analysis ( section [ subsec : dust_modeling ] ) .
another method of confirming the strength of the ame is to compare to ame observed in other environments . to do this
, the @xmath11 30 ghz flux density is generally normalized by the 100 @xmath13 m flux density .
this quantity , often called the dust emissivity , was computed for rcw175 and we found a value of ( 5.8 @xmath0 1.1 ) @xmath1 10@xmath83 , which is consistent with the value computed by @xcite for the diffuse dust at intermediate latitudes .
these two results imply that the parameters we obtain for the ame in rcw175 are both physical and meaningful . to investigate the origin of the ame component observed in figure [ fig : full_sed ] we adopt the cbi 31 ghz map as a tracer of the ame .
this is a reasonable assumption given that the free - free and thermal dust components alone only predict a 31 ghz flux density of 1.7 jy compared to the measured value of 6.0 @xmath0 0.3 jy .
this is an excess of 4.3 jy implying that @xmath14 70 @xmath15 of the cbi emission is due to ame ( 14.3@xmath84 ) .
we note that this is a larger fraction of ame than was found by @xcite as they fixed the spectral index of the low frequency emission at a value of @xmath90.12 .
however , even if we fit a power - law component with a fixed spectral index of @xmath90.12 , we find that the fraction of ame is still @xmath14 60 @xmath15 ( 12.7@xmath84 ) . since we know that there is the possibility of ongoing star formation in rcw175 , we investigated the correlation between the ame and the location of the yso candidates identified in section [ subsec : ysos ] .
massive ysos form in ultra - compact hii ( uchii ) regions , which have densities @xmath31 10@xmath85 h @xmath86 and hence are optically thick . therefore ,
the free - free emission originating from the ionized gas is self - absorbed , which results in a turnover in the spectrum from @xmath10 = @xmath90.12 to @xmath10 @xmath14 2 .
the exact frequency of this turnover depends on the density of the uchii region , but can occur up to tens of ghz . of the 6 yso candidates identified within the vicinity of rcw175 , only one ( source 40 ) was located in g29.0 - 0.6 and this is situated @xmath14 1 arcmin from the peak of the ame .
the pointing accuracy of the cbi is @xmath14 0.5 arcmin @xcite , hence making it unlikely that the source of the excess emission in g29.0 - 0.6 is due to an uchii region .
similarly , none of the 6 yso candidates are associated with the peak of the ame in g29.1 - 0.7 , again suggesting that the ame in this region is not due to an uchii region .
having ruled out the possibility of the ame in rcw175 being due to self - absorbed free - free emission , we next want to investigate the connection between the ame and the dust properties . therefore , we compare the cbi 31 ghz map with the dust parameter maps discussed in section [ subsec : dust_modeling ] to identify which parameters , if any , correlate well with the ame . in figure
[ fig : param_maps_contours ] we display the dust parameter maps with the contours of the 31 ghz emission overlaid .
it is apparent that the 31 ghz emission is not strongly spatially correlated with the pah abundance .
the deficit of pahs within the shell of g29.1 - 0.7 is coincident with the ame observed in this component , while there appears to be a small collection of pahs present towards the ame originating from g29.0 - 0.6 .
looking at the vsg abundances relative to the 31 ghz emission we find that the vsgs are located in the interior of both g29.0 - 0.6 and g29.1 - 0.7 .
we find that only the vsgs in g29.0 - 0.6 are correlated with the 31ghz emission .
the vsgs present in g29.1 - 0.7 are centred on the location of the b1 ii star at the centre of the shell , which is clearly offset from the ame emission .
this suggests that the ame is not being produced by the vsgs , and is not directly associated with the source of ionization .
although the hydrogen column density is increased towards g29.0 - 0.6 , and decreased towards g29.1 - 0.7 , there is no apparent correlation with the ame .
however , the maps of the erf strength and @xmath34 appear to be very well correlated with the cbi emission . not only is the correlation present towards g29.0 - 0.6 , but it is also present towards g29.1 - 0.7 . as stated previously , within g29.1 - 0.7 , the erf is enhanced towards the dust filament along the edge of the shell , implying that the ionization front is not uniform in all directions . the correlation between the ame and the erf and the warmer dust implies that the ame is dependent on the strength of the erf , and suggests that it is the excitation of the erf that is producing the ame .
this result is consistent with the result found in the perseus molecular cloud , where the strength of the erf appeared to be enhanced in regions of ame @xcite , which therefore could be the result of electric dipole emission from spinning dust grains being spun up by photon grain interactions .
such photon grain interactions may also cause the grains to become dehydrogenated and as discussed by @xcite , this will have a strong effect on the electric dipole moment of the grain , which will also affect the spinning dust emissivity . the observed correlation between the ame and the erf in both rcw175 and the perseus molecular cloud is in agreement with the spinning dust theory , where , if all other parameters are fixed , the spinning dust emissivity increases with increasing erf strength ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
we also note that it is possible that a fraction of the excess emission could be due to magnetic dipole emission produced by thermal fluctuations in the magnetism of the grains @xcite . according to the theory
, the magnitude of the magnetic fluctuations depends on the magnetic properties of the grain material , and any strongly magnetic grain material will almost certainly contain fe .
indeed , recent results from @xcite have shown that in hii regions , at least @xmath11 40 @xmath15 of the fe atoms are embedded in dust grains , with this fraction increasing to @xmath11 97 @xmath15 in high metallicity , high density hii regions .
it is difficult to quantify the exact contribution originating from magnetic dipole emission , but one possible method to help distinguish between the two emission mechanisms would be to observe the polarization of the ame . electric dipole emission is predicted to be only slightly polarized ( a fractional polarization of < 1 @xmath15 above 30 ghz ; @xcite ) , while magnetic dipole emission from single domain magnetic grains is expected to be highly polarized ( a fractional polarization of up to @xmath11 40 @xmath15 ; @xcite ) .
no such observations of rcw175 have yet been performed , however , recent observations by @xcite have shown that the magnetic field strength towards galactic hii regions is similar to the typical magnetic field strength of the diffuse ism , implying that there is very little polarized emission in these environments .
this leads us to believe that the contribution of magnetic dipole emission from single domain magnetic grains in rcw175 is minimal .
however , we note that magnetic dipole emission arising from grains containing magnetic inclusions is expected to be relatively unpolarized ( a fractional polarization of < 1 @xmath15 ; @xcite ) , and as such , we can not completely rule out a contribution from magnetic dipole emission .
it is interesting that the ame in g29.1 - 0.7 is not spatially correlated with the surrounding pdr , where the pahs are concentrated , but is actually originating from a region just on the interior of the pdr . as we have shown in figure [ fig : param_maps_contours ] , this region has an enhanced erf compared to the rest of g29.1 - 0.7 .
recent work by @xcite have shown that in the orion bar pdr , there is a clear stratification present regarding the major gas ions .
they find that although the [ cii ] line at 158 @xmath13 m traces the dust in the pdr quite well , the [ nii ] line at 122 @xmath13 m is not spatially correlated with the dust , but actually originates closer to the ionizing source .
this is interesting as we appear to be finding a similar result with the ame in g29.1 - 0.7 not originating from the pdr , but rather originating closer to the ionization source .
in fact , @xcite investigated the effect of impulsive excitation due to individual ion
grain collisions , and found that these impulses result in a broadening of the spinning dust spectrum to higher frequencies and an increase in the spinning dust emissivity .
furthermore , a recent analysis by @xcite has shown that the spinning dust model is sensitive to the abundance of the major gas ions , with both the peak frequency and the spinning dust emissivity increasing with ion abundance .
this may be what we are observing here , explaining why the ame is not coincident with the pdr but is originating from a region closer to the source of ionization due to the stratification of the gas ions in the pdr .
further information regarding the distribution of the major gas ions within rcw175 is required to test this hypothesis but , to date , no such observations exist .
in this work we have performed a detailed analysis of the environment of rcw175 . for this purpose
, we used photometric data from 21 cm ( 1.4 ghz ) to the 8 @xmath13 m ( 3.75 thz ) in conjunction with hi , co and rrl spectral data . by looking at the photometric data , we found that rcw175 is not a single hii region , but consists , in fact , of two separate hii regions , g29.1 - 0.7 and g29.0 - 0.6 .
g29.1 - 0.7 is larger , more evolved , and most likely the older of the two regions ; while g29.0 - 0.6 is more compact , more dusty , and likely younger .
g29.1 - 0.7 contains the ionizing b1 ii star , s65 - 4 , at its centre , while g29.0 - 0.6 is characterized by the presence of filamentary pillars .
both components are clearly associated with each other , given the small spread in velocities , and we suggest that g29.0 - 0.6 may have been produced as a consequence of triggering from the expansion of g29.1 - 0.7 into the surrounding ism . using the dust model dustem
, we characterized the dust properties within the region and we found that there is a significant depletion of pahs within the larger , diffuse shell of g29.1 - 0.7 , and to a lesser extent within g29.0 - 0.6 .
we also found that the abundance of the vsgs is increased towards the interior of both g29.1 - 0.7 and g29.0 - 0.6 .
both these results are consistent with current theories on the formation of hii regions , with the pahs concentrated in the surrounding pdrs , while the warmer dust originates from within the centre of the shell .
recent work has hinted that the 24 @xmath13 m emission originating from within the hii region might not be due to vsgs , but to a population of very warm bgs , emitting thermally at 24 @xmath13 m ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
looking at the available spectral data we hypothesized that the ionized gas has become dissociated from the molecular gas , and we computed a distance of 3.2 @xmath0 0.2 kpc to rcw175 and a corresponding galactocentric distance of 5.4 @xmath0 0.3 kpc .
we used the 24 @xmath13 m emission to compute an estimate of the sfr for the region of ( 12.6 @xmath0 1.9 ) @xmath1 10@xmath2 m@xmath3 yr@xmath4 , and also identified 6 yso candidates in its vicinity .
additionally , we calculated that the total mass of dust in rcw175 is 215 @xmath0 53 m@xmath3 .
finally , we produced a complete sed from the radio to the mid - ir for the entire complex , and found a clear excess of emission at cm wavelengths .
this excess was well fitted with a spinning dust model using typical parameters for the warm ionized medium . by comparing the ame with the parameter maps produced by the dust modeling analysis
, we found that the ame is not spatially correlated with either the abundance of the pahs or vsgs , but is much more correlated with the strength of the erf and hence the dust temperature .
this is similar to the result observed for the ame in the perseus molecular cloud by @xcite , and hence we suggest that the erf is playing an important role in causing the dust grains to spin .
further investigation of the ame with respect to the location of the yso candidates rules out the possibility of the ame originating from an uchii region , and based on the fact that the ame in g29.1 - 0.7 originates from the interior of the pdr , we hypothesize that the ame is due to spinning dust , but that there is a significant contribution to the spinning dust model from the major gas ions . further studies like the current one need to be performed in order to fully understand if this connection between the ame and the erf is found throughout the galaxy or only occurs in certain environments , and further modeling will help us understand the role of the gas ions in the spinning dust models .
we thank the anonymous referee for providing useful comments that improved the content of this paper .
we thank mark calabretta and lister staveley - smith for help with the rrl data .
this work has been performed within the framework of a nasa / adp roses-2009 grant , no . 09-adp09 - 0059 .
cd acknowledges an stfc advanced fellowship and eu marie curie irg grant under the fp7 .
this work is based in part on observations made with the _ spitzer _ space telescope , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology under a contract with nasa .
this publication makes use of molecular line data from the boston university - fcrao galactic ring survey ( grs ) .
the grs is a joint project of boston university and five college radio astronomy observatory , funded by the national science foundation under grants ast-9800334 , ast-0098562 , ast-0100793 , ast-0228993 and ast-0507657 .
the national radio astronomy observatory is a facility of the national science foundation operated under cooperative agreement by associated universities , inc . | using infrared , radio continuum and spectral observations , we performed a detailed investigation of the hii region rcw175 .
we determined that rcw175 , which actually consists of two separate hii regions , g29.1 - 0.7 and g29.0 - 0.6 , is located at a distance of 3.2 @xmath0 0.2 kpc .
based on the observations we infer that the more compact g29.0 - 0.6 is less evolved than g29.1 - 0.7 and was possibly produced as a result of the expansion of g29.1 - 0.7 into the surrounding interstellar medium .
we compute a star formation rate for rcw175 of ( 12.6 @xmath0 1.9 ) @xmath1 10@xmath2 m@xmath3 yr@xmath4 , and identified 6 possible young stellar object candidates within its vicinity .
additionally , we estimate that rcw175 contains a total dust mass of 215 @xmath0 53 m@xmath3 .
rcw175 has previously been identified as a source of anomalous microwave emission ( ame ) , an excess of emission at cm wavelengths often attributed to electric dipole radiation from the smallest dust grains .
we find that the ame previously detected in rcw175 is not correlated with the smallest dust grains ( polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons or small carbonaceous dust grains ) , but rather with the exciting radiation field within the region .
this is a similar result to that found in the perseus molecular cloud , another region which harbors ame , suggesting that the radiation field may play a pivotal role in the production of this new galactic emission mechanism .
finally , we suggest that these observations may hint at the importance of understanding the role played by the major gas ions in spinning dust models . |
systems with correlated electrons display a rich variety of physical phenomena and properties : different types of magnetic ordering , ( high - tc ) superconductivity , ferroelectricity , spin - charge separation , formation of spatial inhomogeneities @xcite ( phase separation , stripes , local gap and incoherent pairing , charge and spin pseudogaps ) .
the realization of these properties in clusters and bulk depends on interaction strength @xmath1 , doping , temperature , the detailed type of crystal lattice and sign of coupling @xmath2 @xcite .
studies of perplexing physics of electron behavior in non - bipartite lattices encounter enormous difficulties .
exact solutions at finite temperatures exist only in a very few cases @xcite ; perturbation theory is usually inadequate while numerical methods have serious limitations , such as in the quantum monte - carlo method and its notorious sign problem . on the contrary
, one can get important insights from the exact solutions for small clusters ( molecules " ) .
for example , squares or cubes are the building blocks , or prototypes , of solids with bipartite lattices , whereas triangles , tetrahedrons , octahedrons without electron - hole symmetry may be regarded as primitive units of typical frustrated systems ( triangular , pyrochlore , perovskite ) .
exact studies of various cluster topologies can thus be very useful for understanding nanoparticles and respective bulk systems .
one can take a further step and consider an inhomogeneous bulk system as a collection of many such decoupled clusters , which do not interact directly , but form a system in thermodynamic equilibrium @xcite .
thus we consider a collection of such molecules " , not at fixed average number of electrons per each cluster , but as a grand canonical ensemble , for fixed chemical potential @xmath3 .
the electrons can be splintered apart by spin - charge separation due to level crossings driven by @xmath1 or temperature , so that the collective excitations of electron charge and spin of different symmetries can become quite independent and propagate incoherently .
we have found that local charge and spin density of states or corresponding susceptibilities can have different pseudogaps which is a sign of spin - charge separation . for large @xmath1 near half filling ,
holes prefer to be localized on separate clusters having mott - hubbard ( mh ) like charge pseudogaps @xcite and nagaoka ferromagnetism ( fm ) @xcite ; otherwise , spin density waves or spin liquids may be formed . at moderate @xmath1 , this approach leads to reconciliation of charge and spin degrees with redistribution of charge carriers or holes between square clusters . the latter ,
if present , can signal a tendency toward phase separation , or , if clusters prefer " to have two holes , it can be taken as a signature of pairing @xcite .
this , in turn , could imply imposed opposite spin pairing followed by condensation of charge and spin degrees into a bcs - like coherent state .
although this approach for large systems is only approximate , it nonetheless gives very important clues for understanding large systems whenever correlations are local .
we have developed this approach in refs .
@xcite and successfully applied to typical unfrustrated ( linked squares ) clusters .
our results are directly applicable to nanosystems which usually contain many clusters , rather well separated and isolated from each other but nevertheless being in thermodynamic equilibrium with the possibility of having inhomogeneities for different number of electrons per cluster .
interestingly , an ensemble of square clusters displays checkerboard " patterns , nanophase inhomogeneity , incoherent pairing and nucleation of pseudogaps @xcite . the purpose of this work is to further conduct similar extensive investigations in frustrated systems @xcite , exemplified by 4-site tetrahedrons and 5-site square pyramids .
as we shall see , certain features in various topologies are quite different and these predictions could be exploited in the nanoscience frontier by synthesizing clusters or nanomaterials with unique properties @xcite . and spin @xmath4 gaps versus @xmath1 in an ensemble of squares at @xmath5 and @xmath6 .
phase a : charge and spin pairing gaps of equal amplitude at @xmath7 describe bose condensation of electrons similar to bcs - like coherent pairing with a single energy gap .
phase b : mott - hubbard like insulator at @xmath8 leads to @xmath9 spin liquid behavior .
phase c : parallel ( triplet ) spin pairing ( @xmath10 ) at @xmath11 displays @xmath12 saturated ferromagnetism ( see sec . [ squares ] ) . ] and @xmath13 versus @xmath3 in grand canonical ensemble of tetrahedrons and fcs at @xmath14 , @xmath15 and @xmath16 .
mott - hubbard like ferromagnetism for @xmath17 at @xmath18 in tetrahedron occurs for @xmath19 , while absence of charge pseudogap near @xmath20 metallic state with spin rigidity manifests level crossing degeneracy related to pairing ( see inset ) . ] versus @xmath1 for one hole off half filling in tetrahedrons and fcs at @xmath6 . in tetrahedron
, @xmath21 at @xmath22 implies phase separation and coherent pairing with @xmath23 , while @xmath24 for @xmath12 at @xmath19 leads to a ferromagnetic insulator ( @xmath10 ) for all @xmath1 . in fcs , @xmath24 at @xmath25 for @xmath26 describes mott - hubbard like antiferromagnetism ( @xmath27 ) . ] versus @xmath1 at @xmath18 and @xmath15 in tetrahedron ( @xmath22 ) and deformed tetrahedral clusters ( @xmath28 and @xmath29 ) .
charge and spin pairing gaps of equal amplitude at @xmath22 imply coherent pairing , while @xmath30 and @xmath31 at @xmath32 correspond to an unsaturated ferromagnetic insulator for @xmath9 .
coherent pairing is retained in a narrow range near @xmath33 . ]
-@xmath3 phase diagram of tetrahedrons without electron - hole symmetry at optimally doped @xmath5 regime near @xmath34 at @xmath35 and @xmath22 illustrates the condensation of electron charge and onset of phase separation for charge degrees below @xmath36 .
the incoherent phase of preformed pairs with unpaired opposite spins exists above @xmath37 .
below @xmath38 , the paired spin and charge coexist in a coherent pairing phase .
the charge and spin susceptibility peaks , denoted by @xmath39 and @xmath40 , define pseudogaps calculated in the grand canonical ensemble , while @xmath41 and @xmath42 are evaluated in canonical ensemble . charge and
spin peaks reconcile at @xmath43 , while @xmath44 peak below @xmath38 signifies metallic ( charge ) liquid ( see inset for square cluster and ref .
@xcite ) . ] .ground state ( gs ) in various cluster geometries for one hole off half filling at large @xmath45 and @xmath26 having saturated ferromagnetism ( sf ) , unsaturated ferromagnetism ( uf ) , antiferromagnetism ( af ) or coherent pairing ( cp ) . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ]
exact diagonalization of the hubbard model ( hm ) @xmath46 and quantum statistical calculations of charge @xmath47 and spin @xmath48 susceptibilities , i.e. , _ fluctuations _ , in a grand canonical ensemble and pseudogaps @xmath49 and @xmath50 for canonical energies @xmath51 and
@xmath52 ( @xmath53 and @xmath54 being the total number of electrons and spin respectively ) yield valuable insights into quantum critical points and various phase transitions as shown in ref . @xcite . by monitoring the peaks in @xmath44 and @xmath55
one can identify charge / spin pseudogaps and relevant crossover temperatures ; nodes , sign and amplitude of pseudogaps determine energy level crossings , phase separation , electron pairing ranges , spin - charge separation and reconciliation regions .
[ squares ] for completeness and to facilitate the comparison with frustrated clusters , we first summarize the main results obtained earlier for small 2@xmath562 and 2@xmath564-sites bipartite clusters in refs .
the energies are measured in units @xmath57 in all results that follow .
[ fig : gap-4-site ] illustrates @xmath58 and @xmath59 in ensemble of 2@xmath562 square clusters at @xmath60 and @xmath61 .
vanishing of gaps indicates energy ( multiple ) level crossings and corresponding quantum critical points , @xmath62 and @xmath63 .
the negative gaps show phase separations for charge below @xmath64 and spin degrees above @xmath65 @xcite .
phase a : negative charge gap below @xmath62 displays electron pairing @xmath66 and charge phase separation into hole - rich ( charged ) metal and hole - poor ( neutral ) cluster configurations . in a grand canonical approach @xmath67 at @xmath7 corresponds to electron charge redistribution with opposite spin ( singlet ) pairing .
this picture for electron charge and spin gaps of equal amplitude @xmath68 of purely electronic nature at @xmath60 is similar to the bcs - like coherency in the attractive hm and will be called coherent pairing ( cp ) . in equilibrium , the spin singlet background ( @xmath69 ) stabilizes phase separation of paired electron charge in a quantum cp phase .
the unique gap @xmath70 at @xmath6 in fig .
[ fig : gap-4-site ] is consistent with the existence of a single quasiparticle energy gap in the bcs theory for @xmath71 @xcite .
positive spin gap in fig .
[ fig : gap-4-site ] at @xmath72 provides pairs rigidity in response to a magnetic field and temperature ( see sec
. [ diagram ] ) .
however , unlike in the bcs theory , the charge gap differs from spin gap as temperature increases .
this shows that coherent thermal excitations in the exact solution are not quasiparticle - like renormalized electrons , as in the bcs theory , but collective paired charge and coupled opposite spins .
the spin gap @xmath59 for excited @xmath12 configuration in fig .
[ fig : gap-4-site ] above @xmath62 is shown for canonical energies in a stable mh - like state , @xmath30 .
phase b : unsaturated ferromagnetism ( uf ) for unpaired @xmath9 with zero field @xmath55 peak for gapless @xmath73 projections and gapped @xmath27 for @xmath12 excitations at @xmath74 will be called a spin liquid .
phase c : negative @xmath10 at @xmath11 defines @xmath12 saturated ferromagnetism ( sf ) . localized holes at @xmath30 rule out possible nagaoka fm in a metallic phase @xcite .
field fluctuations lift @xmath75-degeneracy and lead to segregation of clusters into magnetic domains .
it appears that the ensemble of square clusters share common and important features with larger bipartite clusters in the ground state and at finite temperatures @xcite ( see sec .
[ diagram ] ) .
for example , in 2x4 ladders ( fig .
5 of ref .
@xcite ) , we have identified the existence of ( negative and positive ) oscillatory behavior in ( @xmath6 ) charge gaps as a function of @xmath1 .
similar to what was seen in square clusters at low temperatures , we observe level crossing degeneracies in charge and spin sectors in bipartite 2@xmath564 clusters at relatively small and large @xmath1 values , respectively .
thus the use of chemical potential and departure from zero temperature singularities in the canonical and grand canonical ensembles appear to be essential for understanding important physics related to the pseudogaps , phase separation , pairings and corresponding crossover temperatures . a full picture of coherent and incoherent pairing , electronic inhomogeneities and magnetism emerges only at finite , but rather low temperatures .
( if we set @xmath22 ev , the most of the interesting physics is seen to occur below a few hundred degrees k. ) the topology of the tetrahedron is equivalent to that of a square with next nearest neighbor coupling ( @xmath76 ) while the square pyramid of the octahedral structure in the htscs is related to face centered squares ( fcs ) . the average electron number @xmath77 and magnetization @xmath13 versus @xmath3 in fig .
[ fig : num_mag ] for @xmath15 shows contrasting behavior in pairing and magnetism at @xmath22 and @xmath19 for the tetrahedron at @xmath78 and fcs at @xmath79 .
different signs of @xmath2 in these topologies for one hole off half filling lead to dramatic changes in the electronic structure .
[ fig : gap ] illustrates the charge gaps at small and moderate @xmath1 .
tetrahedron at @xmath19 : sf with a negative spin gap in a mh - like phase exists for all @xmath1 .
tetrahedron at @xmath22 : metallic cp phase with charge and spin gaps of equal amplitudes similar to the bcs - like pairing , discussed for squares in sec .
[ squares ] , forms at all @xmath1 .
fcs at @xmath19 : mh - like insulator displays two consecutive crossovers at @xmath80 from ( @xmath81 ) antiferromagnetism ( af ) into ( @xmath82 ) uf and into ( @xmath83 ) sf above @xmath84 .
fcs at @xmath22 : mh - like insulator shows crossover at @xmath85 from ( @xmath81 ) af into ( @xmath82 ) uf . in triangles ,
sf and af are found to be stable for all @xmath86 at @xmath19 and @xmath22 respectively .
finally table [ nagaoka ] illustrates magnetic phases at large @xmath1 and @xmath6 .
for example , the squares and all frustrated clusters at @xmath19 exhibit stable sf ; tetrahedron and triangle at @xmath22 retain cp and af respectively ; uf for the @xmath82 state , separated by @xmath87 from @xmath81 , exists in fcs at @xmath22 .
[ fig : pyramid ] shows charge gap at two coupling values @xmath88 between the vertex and base atoms in the deformed tetrahedron .
vanishing of gap , driven by @xmath88 , manifests level crossings for @xmath28 , while @xmath32 and @xmath22 cases describe a single phase with avoided crossings .
[ diagram ] fig .
[ fig : ph4_6 ] illustrates a number of nanophases , defined in refs .
@xcite , for the tetrahedron similar to bipartite clusters .
the curve @xmath41 below @xmath36 signifies the onset of charge paired condensation . as temperature
is lowered below @xmath39 , a spin pseudogap is opened up first , as seen in nmr experiments @xcite , followed by the gradual disappearance of the spin excitations , consistent with the suppression of low - energy excitations in the htscs probed by stm @xcite .
the opposite spin cp phase with fully gapped collective excitations begins to form at @xmath89 .
the charge inhomogeneities @xcite of hole - rich and charge neutral _ spinodal _ regions between @xmath90 and @xmath91 are similar to those found in the squares and resemble important features seen in the htscs .
[ fig : ph4_6 ] shows the presence of bosonic modes below @xmath41 and @xmath38 for paired electron charge and opposite spin respectively .
this picture suggests condensation of electron charge and spin at various crossover temperatures while condensation in the bcs theory occurs at a single t@xmath0 value .
the temperature driven spin - charge separation above @xmath92 resembles an incoherent pairing ( ip ) phase seen in the htscs @xcite .
the charged pairs without spin rigidity above @xmath92 , instead of becoming superconducting , coexist in a nonuniform , charge degenerate ip state similar to a ferroelectric phase @xcite .
the unpaired weak moment , induced by a field above @xmath38 , agrees with the observation of competing dormant magnetic states in the htscs @xcite .
the coinciding @xmath55 and @xmath44 peaks at @xmath93 show full reconciliation of charge and spin degrees seen in the htscs above t@xmath0 . in the absence of electron - hole symmetry ,
the tetrahedral clusters near optimal doping @xmath94 undergo a transition with temperature from a cp phase into a mh - like phase .
it is clear that our exact results , discussed above , provide novel insight into level crossings , spin - charge separation , reconciliation and full bose condensation @xcite .
separate condensation of electron charge and spin degrees offers a new route for superconductivity , different from the bcs scenario .
the electronic instabilities found for various geometries , in a wide range of @xmath1 and temperatures , will be useful for the prediction of electron pairing , ferroelectricity @xcite and possible superconductivity in nanoparticles , doped cuprates , etc .
in contrast to the squares , exact solution for the tetrahedron exhibits coherent and incoherent pairings for all @xmath1 .
our findings at small , moderate and large @xmath1 carry a wealth of new information at finite temperatures in bipartite and frustrated nanostructures regarding phase separation , ferromagnetism and nagaoka instabilities in manganites / cmr materials .
these exact calculations illustrate important clues and exciting opportunities that could be utilized when synthesizing potentially high - tc superconducting and magnetic nanoclusters assembled in two and three dimensional geometries @xcite .
ultra - cold fermionic atoms in an optical lattice @xcite may also offer unprecedented opportunities to test these predictions .
we thank daniil khomskii , valery pokrovsky for helpful discussions and tun wang for valuable contributions .
this research was supported in part by u.s .
department of energy under contract no .
de - ac02 - 98ch10886
. 0 y. kohsaka _ et al_. , science * 315 * , 1380 ( 2007 )
. t. valla _ et al_. , science * 314 * , 1914 ( 2006 ) .
a. c. b@xmath95ia , r. laihob and e. l@xmath96hderantab , physica c*411 * , 107 ( 2004 ) . h. e. mohottala _ et al_. , nature materials * 5 * , 377 ( 2006 ) . k. k. gomes _ et al_. , nature * 447 * , 569 ( 2007 ) .
r. moro , s. yin , x. xu , and w. a. de heer , phys .
lett . * 93 * , 086803 ( 2004 ) ; x. xu , s. yin , r. moro , and w. a. de heer , * 95 * , 237209 ( 2005 ) .
y. nagaoka , phys .
rev . * 147 * , 392 ( 1966 ) .
s. belluci , m.cini , p. onorato , and e. perfetto , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 18 * , s2115 ( 2006 ) ; w - f .
tsai and s.a .
kivelson , phys .
rev . b*73 * , 214510 ( 2006 ) ; s.r .
white , s. chakravarty , m.p .
gelfand , and s.a .
kivelson , _ ibid _ b*45 * , 5062 ( 1992 ) ; r.m .
fye , m.j .
martins , and r.t .
scalettar , _ ibid _ * 42 * , r6809 ( 1990 ) ; n.e .
bickers , d.j .
scalapino , and r.t .
scalettar , int . j. mod
b*1 * , 687 ( 1987 ) .
h. shiba and p. a. pincus , phys .
rev . b*5 * , 1966 ( 1972 ) .
l. m. falicov and r. h. victora , phys .
rev . b*30 * , 1695 ( 1984 ) .
r. schumann , ann .
* 11 * , 49 ( 2002 ) ; * 17 * , 64 ( 2008 ) .
a. n. kocharian , g. w. fernando , k. palandage and j. w. davenport , j. magn .
magn . mater . *
300 * , 585 ( 2006 ) .
a. n. kocharian , g. w. fernando , k. palandage , and j. w. davenport , phys .
rev . b*74 * , 024511 ( 2006 ) .
a. n. kocharian , g. w. fernando , k. palandage , and j. w. davenport , phys .
a*364 * , 57 ( 2007 ) .
g. w. fernando , a. n. kocharian , k. palandage , tun wang , and j. w. davenport , phys .
rev . b*75 * , 085109 ( 2007 ) .
k. palandage , g. w. fernando , a. n. kocharian , and j. w. davenport , journal of computer - aided materials design * 14 * , 103 ( 2007 ) .
i. a. sergienko and s. h. curnoe , phys .
rev . b*70 * , 144522 ( 2004 ) .
s. y. wang , j. z. yu , h. mizuseki , q. sun , c. y. wang , and y. kawazoe , phys .
b*70 * , 165413 ( 2004 ) .
a. n. kocharian , g. w. fernando , k. palandage , and j. w. davenport , to be published ( 2008 ) .
r. friedberg , t. d. lee , and h. c. ren , phys .
b*50 * , 10190 ( 1994 ) . j. k. chin _ et al_. , nature * 443 * , 961 ( 2006 ) . | electron pairing and ferromagnetism in various cluster geometries are studied with emphasis on tetrahedron and square pyramid under variation of interaction strength , electron doping and temperature .
these exact calculations of charge and spin collective excitations and pseudogaps yield intriguing insights into level crossing degeneracies , phase separation and condensation .
criteria for spin - charge separation and reconciliation driven by interaction strength , next nearest coupling and temperature are found .
phase diagrams resemble a number of inhomogeneous , coherent and incoherent nanoscale phases seen recently in high t@xmath0 cuprates , manganites and cmr nanomaterials .
= 1.5 cm |
application of electric and magnetic fields has turned out to be extremely helpful for developing a detailed understanding of atoms , as the electronic level structure is modified by characteristic energy shifts and/or lifting multiple state degeneracies .
the latter is associated with the symmetry reduction from the so(3 ) group of all rotations down to u(1 ) for rotations about the field , caused by introduction of the preferential field direction in space .
typically , the separation between atomic levels belonging to different principal quantum numbers @xmath2 is so large that resonances between these states can hardly occur for the field strengths accessible in the laboratory .
this is different for rydberg atoms where the valence electron has been promoted into a level with high @xmath4 @xcite . in this range , for the hydrogen atom the levels of the stark ladder simply cross each other , when they come into resonance by application of an electric field .
by contrast , for many - electron atoms the excited electron experiences close to the nucleus a deviation from the @xmath5-coulomb potential due to the core electrons . the influence of this deviation is often comprised in the quantum defect , by which the rydberg formula for the excited electron binding energy is modified to @xmath6 , where @xmath7 is the rydberg energy and @xmath8 is the quantum defect for an electron with orbital angular momentum @xmath9 .
accordingly , the states within a particular shell show a splitting in zero field , and when an electric field is applied they may show avoided crossings when they approach each other .
excitons in semiconductors can be described as hydrogen - like complexes for which the crystal environment is captured by introducing effective carrier masses and the dielectric function , resulting in a renormalization of the rydberg energy , @xmath10 . like in atomic physics ,
electric and magnetic fields are essential tools for obtaining information about the details of the energy spectrum , determined also by the material parameters
. however , typically the exciton rydberg energy is quite small , so that the observable states are limited to small principal quantum numbers , for example , @xmath11 in the prototypical direct band gap semiconductor gaas .
moreover , when applying an external field it is challenging to separate the split states in energy because of their proximity , making a state identification complicated .
in addition , exciton ionization occurs already in relatively weak electric fields . here , cu@xmath0o has a somewhat unique position because of its remarkable crystal quality in combination with a large exciton rydberg energy of about @xmath1290 mev @xcite .
both features have allowed us to observe exciton states up to @xmath2 = 25 in high resolution laser absorption studies @xcite .
these states , even in absence of external fields , show a fine structure splitting that is related to the reduction from the continuous symmetry of atoms to the discrete o@xmath13 symmetry of the cubic crystal lattice @xcite .
the fine structure can be traced to the details of the band structure where band mixing effects lead to considerable deviations from a simple parabolic dispersion mostly for the holes @xcite . by analogy with atoms
, the resulting exciton level series can be approximately cast into an effective quantum defect model , even though we stress that the origin of the quantum defect is quite different @xcite . despite the sizable rydberg energy compared to other semiconductors ,
the splitting between different exciton states with @xmath14 is small enough , that application of feasible electric fields should allow one to bring states with different @xmath2 close to each other or even in resonance , without going to highly excited rydberg states . from the quantum defect analogy
a considerable state mixing and avoided crossings may occur between levels .
naively one may still expect that the absorption spectrum has the rather simple appearance of a stark ladder , as the optical parameters like the dielectric function are scalar quantities for a cubic crystal . here
we present the results of an extensive experimental study of the excitonic absorption spectrum for the states with low principal quantum numbers @xmath2 = 3 , 4 , and 5 in cu@xmath0o crystals in presence of an electric field applied along the light propagation axis .
by contrast to the simple expectations , we observe a rich fine structure of the spectra with intricate dependences on crystal orientation and light polarization .
this is because the electric field reduces the system symmetry further down to at least @xmath15 and thereby shuffles oscillator strength from the dominant @xmath16-excitons with @xmath17 to other angular momentum states , activating dipole - forbidden transitions @xcite .
additionally , the involvement of quadrupolar transitions leads to a high complexity of the spectra involving multiple lines whose presence in the spectra depends strongly on the polarization of the incident laser light relative to the crystal orientation .
our experimental findings are substantiated by detailed numerical calculations . for completeness
, we note that the cuprous oxide exciton level spectrum in electric field has been experimentally studied before , see the reviews @xcite .
however , in these studies the fine structure could not be resolved in that much detail , which may be related , for example , to the application of much higher fields in order to observe similar effects .
also a connection to previous microscopic calculations @xcite could not be established . here
the understanding of the exciton level structure is taken to an unprecedented level by providing studies with high spectral resolution .
the paper is organized as follows : in the next section we give the details of the experiment . in section [ sec : results ] we present the experimental results , while in section [ sec : theory ] the theoretical model for the excitons in electric field is described .
the comparison between theory and experiment is provided in section [ sec : disc ] .
in our absorption studies natural cuprous oxide crystal slabs of different orientations were studied : one sample ( sample 1 with a thickness of 50 @xmath18 m ) was cut and polished such that the [ 001 ] direction is along the crystal normal ; in the other case ( sample 2 with a thickness of 30 @xmath18 m ) the [ 110 ] direction is normal to the surface .
the samples were inserted in the liquid helium insert of an optical cryostat at @xmath19 = 1.3 k. the optical axis was chosen along the crystal normal .
excitation was done by using a broadband white light source the bandwidth of which was reduced to the wavelength range of interest by a double monochromator .
the polarization of the exciting light was chosen to be linear , so that for propagation of the beam along the [ 001 ] direction in sample 1 , the polarization vector @xmath20 was along [ 100 ] , equivalent to @xmath21[010 ] . for the sample 2 with the light propagating along the [ 110 ] direction ,
the two different independent light polarizations are @xmath22 $ ] and @xmath23 $ ] .
it is noteworthy that the @xmath22 $ ] and @xmath24 $ ] axes are not equivalent in the cubic @xmath25 point group , hence , it is not a priori obvious whether the transmission spectra are identical or not for these two polarization configurations .
after transmission through the crystal the light is dispersed by a double monochromator and detected by a si - charge coupled device camera .
the spectral resolution provided is less than 10 @xmath18ev .
as will be explained in further detail below , we were focussing in our experiments on the excitons with principal quantum number from @xmath2=3 to 5 . from previous experiments
@xcite we know that the spectral widths of these features exceed considerably the above spectral resolution .
therefore we decided that the white light absorption is sufficient to study the electric field induced modification of the exciton spectrum .
indeed , up to a principal quantum number of @xmath2 = 7 the spectra for laser and white light excitation coincide . for comparison and in depth studies we have also used a tunable single frequency dye laser with a photo - diode detection system , see sec .
[ sec : results ] for details . for application of the electric field
@xmath26 a special holder was fabricated , in which the samples were mounted strain - free .
the holder was designed such that the field could be applied along the optical axis ( longitudinal configuration , @xmath27 ) . by contrast , in previous experiments @xcite , only the transversal configuration with @xmath28 was studied .
the sample holder is shown in fig .
[ fig : sampleholder ] .
the crystal is mounted freely within a kapton - spacer of 75 @xmath18 m thickness that is placed between quartz plates with transparent electrodes of indium tin oxide ( ito ) evaporated on them .
the thickness of the electrodes was chosen to minimize interference signals in the transmission spectra .
we carefully checked that no measurable leakage current is flowing between the contacts .
we note that for recent fine structure studies of the exciton states this geometry was used to activate the @xmath29- and @xmath30-excitons ( @xmath31 and @xmath32 , respectively ) and extrapolate their energies towards zero electric field .
however , in these studies the level splitting by electric field was not assessed @xcite .
m ( * 3 * ) , sample ( * 4 * ) , free space filled with helium ( * 5 * ) . ] despite all these efforts , we note that we observe depolarization effects in the optical measurements when applying an electric field .
these effects may arise from charges on the crystal surfaces , charge redistribution among defects or optically injected carriers .
as time resolved measurements have shown , these effects can be minimized by cutting down the laser power to less than @xmath33w and pulsing the electric field .
these tools therefore were consequently applied in our studies . with these low laser powers
the effects of the electric field on the spectra were the same in laser excitation as well as in white light excitation .
in particular , we emphasize that the excitation densities are so low , that the formation of dressed states by simultaneous driving of two closely spaced exciton levels by a laser as demonstrated recently for rydberg excitons , see ref .
@xcite , is not relevant .
nevertheless , we find a difference in the electric field scale in the calculations and the scale in experiment determined as described above .
since the precise influence of these depolarization effects is hard to determine , we have rescaled the fields used in the calculations by a constant ( field - independent ) factor when comparing them with experiment .
the scaling factors are about 3 5 and do not vary systematically with studied sample , exciton principal quantum number etc .
most likely the variation of the scaling factors is related to the depolarization - causing charge distributions , which may vary upon thermal cycling of the crystal , for example .
still , we stress again that the elaborated design of the sample holder and the careful choice of experimental conditions have allowed the observation of field - induced effects at field strengths much smaller than in earlier studies .
we study the exciton states of the yellow exciton series in cuprous oxide , involving the topmost valence band and the lowest conduction band .
these bands are formed mainly from copper orbitals : the conduction band is of @xmath34-type character and the valence band is of @xmath35-type character , both with even parity .
optical transitions in electric - dipole approximation require an orbital angular momentum component change by unity , @xmath36 , which obviously can not be achieved in band - to - band transitions at the @xmath37 point , i.e. , the center of the brillouin zone .
the total angular momentum and resulting symmetry of the exciton are given by the product of electron and hole bloch amplitudes with the envelope function .
hence , in contrast to other semiconductors such as gaas or cdte , the dipole - transitions in cuprous oxide become possible due to a nonzero angular momentum of the envelope , namely by exciting excitons with a @xmath16-type envelope wavefunction @xcite . the spin - orbit interaction results in the complex coupling of the envelope and bloch functions angular momenta @xcite .
hence , one expects the exciton with a certain principal quantum number @xmath2 to consist of a multiplet comprising a large number of states .
the symmetry reduction from so(3 ) to @xmath25 by the cubic crystal environment , as compared to the isotropic model often used to describe excitons from the atom analogy , has been shown to activate higher exciton states with odd parity of the envelope : in a crystal angular momentum is strictly speaking no longer a good quantum number . as a result
, oscillator strength is shuffled from the dominant @xmath16-excitons to the @xmath38- or @xmath39-excitons which therefore become detectable in single photon absorption as demonstrated recently @xcite .
still , the oscillator strength of these features is comparatively small .
therefore we will use the angular momentum notation for the excitons at zero field , for reasons of simplicity and to facilitate the connection to previous results .
the effect of a static electric field is described by the hamiltonian @xcite @xmath40 acting on the exciton envelope functions , where @xmath41 is the coordinate of the relative electron - hole motion .
the electric field has odd parity with respect to the space inversion . as a result
, the electric field lifts the inversion symmetry of the cuprous oxide crystal .
if applied along the high symmetry crystallographic direction @xmath22 $ ] , the symmetry is reduced to the @xmath15 point symmetry group .
this will lead to an additional state mixing , by which the odd envelope @xmath16-excitons are mixed with the even @xmath29- and @xmath30-excitons in lowest order perturbation theory .
similarly , the @xmath38-excitons become mixed with the even envelope @xmath42-excitons ( as well as with @xmath30-excitons ) , provided the principal quantum number permits such high angular momentum states according to the limitation to @xmath43 . as a consequence of this state mixing , by application of the electric field not only a splitting of the lines observed already at zero field occurs , but also multiple additional lines are expected to emerge , resulting in a stark ladder . if applied along the [ 110 ] direction ( as in the sample 2 ) , the symmetry is even further reduced to @xmath44 point symmetry from which we expect a further enhancement of the effects of state mixing . to test these expectations and to set a reference for the subsequent white light studies , we recorded electric field series of the high energy side of the @xmath2 = 4 and 5 excitons using a tunable single frequency dye laser ( sirah matisse ds ) with a linewidth of about 5 nev @xcite .
the laser emission was stabilized by a noise eater ( tem messtechnik noiseeater ) in front of the sample with a suppression of intensity fluctuations by about a factor @xmath45 .
the transmitted laser light was detected by a photo - diode .
the corresponding spectra are shown in fig .
[ fig : fg - exc ] as water - fall plots . since , in general , the spectra are dominated by the @xmath16-excitons with an intensity at least two orders of magnitude larger than that of any other line ( see also the left hand side of fig . [ fig : comparison ] , giving the transmission for the excitons from @xmath2 = 5 to 7 )
, we have cut the @xmath16-excitons from the shown energy ranges and present only their high energy flanks for different applied voltages , in order to focus on the weaker lines from excitons with higher angular momenta .
the triplet of @xmath38-excitons activated by the mixing with the @xmath16-excitons due to the spin - orbit interaction and cubic symmetry effects are clearly observable starting from @xmath2=4 onwards .
previous calculations showed that four @xmath38-excitons should have finite oscillator strength , but two of them are almost degenerate @xcite .
application of the field lifts this degeneracy and leads also to activation of other states . in the @xmath2=4 spectra
we observe two more @xmath38-exciton states appearing whose character we conclude from the emergence in the same energy range as the triplet .
simultaneously one of the original @xmath38-exciton peaks remains prominent , while the other two become faint .
note that the linewidths of the additional exciton resonances are considerably broader than those of the original ones , and are similar to those of the @xmath16-excitons . on the high energy side
also another feature appears which we tentatively attribute to a @xmath30-exciton state , also with quite large linewidth .
-resonance and ( b ) the @xmath46-resonance for different applied voltages , recorded on sample 2 with light polarized along @xmath22 $ ] . for @xmath47
the @xmath38-excitons split into @xmath48 lines . for @xmath49
we observe two additional lines besides the @xmath38-states , which are identified as @xmath42-envelope excitons .
note the different scales at the energy axis .
the increase of optical density towards lower energies corresponds to the high energy flanks of the @xmath16-excitons .
] similar absorption lines with qualitatively the same appearance can be resolved for the multiplet related to the @xmath2 = 5 exciton .
note , however , that as expected from the larger polarizability of this exciton the equivalent splitting patterns appear at considerably smaller fields , roughly reduced by a factor of 2 illustrating strongly superlinear scaling of the polarizability with the principal quantum number @xcite .
also additional lines appear compared to the @xmath2=4 case . as increase of
the principal quantum number by unity also allows for a larger value of the maximum angular momentum @xmath50 by unity , we attribute these two lines to @xmath42-excitons with angular momentum @xmath9=4 .
note that for @xmath2 = 5 also a broad spectral feature shifting from higher to lower energies with increasing voltage appears on the high energy flank .
we attribute this line to the @xmath29-exciton from the @xmath51 multiplet .
irrespective of these details , the two electric field series confirm the expectations of a complex level splitting pattern which can not be explained within a simplified hydrogen - like model . to obtain better insight into the fine details of the spectra with all the faint lines and the strong field - induced changes , we have calculated the second derivative over the energy of every recorded spectrum and assembled them in a contour plot .
doing so , the huge differences in intensity between the different features are levelled and an easier comparison becomes possible .
this is shown in fig .
[ fig : comparison ] for the excitons with principal quantum numbers from @xmath49 to @xmath52 for three different cases , sample 1 with [ 001 ] orientation and [ 100 ] light polarization ( left contour plot ) and sample 2 with [ 110 ] orientation , in one case for [ 001 ] polarization ( mid ) and in the other case for @xmath53 $ ] polarization ( right ) , respectively . here
the studied energy range has been on purpose extended also to excitons with @xmath54 , in order to present a systematic phenomenology . for the quantitative comparison with theory
we will later on restrict to @xmath55 to @xmath48 , as for higher principal quantum numbers accurate calculations are challenging due to the huge size of the hilbert space involving multiple states , in particular , because of the vicinity of the states with different @xmath2 and necessity to account for ionization processes , which we did not include in our modeling . comparing the contour plots in fig .
[ fig : comparison ] , one finds the somewhat surprising result : in the cubic crystal of cuprous oxide the transmission spectra depend on the light propagation direction and light polarization .
the number of lines vary from panel to panel in fig .
[ fig : comparison ] and the spectra have the simplest appearance for @xmath56 $ ] and @xmath57 $ ] coming closest to the simple expectations of a stark ladder .
it is even more surprising that this particular light propagation direction corresponds to the lowest symmetry direction described by the @xmath44 point group . on the other hand ,
the spectra for the other two configurations from first sight appear rather similar , but deviate considerably from a stark fan .
in addition , we note that within the experimentally achievable fields exciton levels from multiplets of different principal quantum numbers can be brought into resonance , especially for the higher @xmath2 . in the right panel , within the experimental accuracy the levels cross each other , contributing to the rather simple appearance of the contour plot .
this crossing behavior changes for the configurations in the other two contour plots : here , in particular , on the high energy flank of a @xmath16-exciton anticrossings are observed , when the states with given @xmath2 ( moving to higher energies ) come into resonance with the states descending in energy from the exciton with the next higher principal quantum number . as mentioned above ,
the anticrossings are somewhat expected from the reduced symmetry in the crystal , effects of the spin - orbit interaction and the deviation of the coulomb interaction potential in the exciton from a pure @xmath5-form by the presence of the short - range part of the electron - hole interaction .
one also confirms that the field induced splitting between different states within a multiplet with a given @xmath2 becomes visible at the lower fields , the higher the principal quantum number .
in addition , the exciton lines split in more and more states with increasing @xmath2 as higher angular momenta become accessible .
in order to describe the experimental data and explain the dependence of the observed transmission spectra on the light propagation direction and the experimental geometry , in this section we present the model of the exciton stark effect in cu@xmath0o and address the optical selection rules for excitonic transitions in the presence of the electric field .
we consider the effect of the external electric field @xmath26 on the yellow exciton series formed of an electron with @xmath58 symmetry bloch amplitudes and a valence band hole with @xmath59 bloch function .
the complex valence band structure results in the admixture of the @xmath60 valence band to the @xmath59 band in the exciton @xcite . the admixture yields ( i ) the fine structure splitting of exciton multiplets with a given principle quantum number @xmath2 and ( ii ) the fine structure of states with a given orbital angular momentum @xmath9 @xcite . in accordance with eq .
the main effect of the external electric field is on the exciton envelope functions , hence , the band mixing effects can be included in the hydrogen - like model perturbatively @xcite .
therefore , we introduce the basis of the exciton states @xmath61 where @xmath41 is the position - vector of the relative electron - hole motion , @xmath62 , @xmath63 and @xmath64 are its polar and azimuthal angles , respectively , @xmath65 are the hydrogen - like radial functions , and @xmath66 are the spherical harmonics @xcite .
the factor @xmath67 is the product of the electron and hole bloch amplitudes with @xmath68 , being the spin components .
the effective exciton hamiltonian in cuprous oxide can be written as @xmath69 where @xmath70 takes into account only the orbital energies , @xmath71 is the spin - orbit coupling hamiltonian , @xmath72 describes the exchange interaction between the electron and the hole and @xmath73 comprises the effects of the cubic ( o@xmath13 point symmetry ) environment . in our calculations ,
the excitonic wavefunction is decomposed over the basis functions , and the hamiltonian @xmath74 , eq .
, is represented in matrix form .
the diagonalization of this matrix yields the exciton energies and wavefunctions which enable us to calculate the transmission spectra in the electric field .
the orbital hamiltonian is diagonal in the quantum numbers @xmath2 , @xmath9 , @xmath75 , @xmath76 and @xmath77 and its non - zero matrix elements read @xmath78 where the diagonal energies @xmath79 can be conveniently parametrized in terms of the exciton rydberg and the quantum defect : @xmath80 the spin - orbit coupling is dominant for the valence band states .
therefore it is sufficient to take into account the interaction of the hole spin and its orbital momentum only . in the spherical approximation the spin - orbit hamiltonian acting in the manifold of the states with
given @xmath2 and @xmath9 reads @xmath81 where @xmath82 are the corresponding spin - orbit coupling constants , @xmath83 is the hole spin operator with @xmath84 being the pauli matrices acting on the pair of hole bloch amplitudes @xmath85 and @xmath86 is the orbital angular momentum operator acting in the space of spherical harmonics , e.g. , @xmath87 .
the effective hamiltonian @xmath88 is quite similar to that of rydberg atoms @xcite .
it has spherical symmetry and allows for classification of the excitonic states by the atom - like nomenclature : the principle quantum number @xmath2 , the angular momentum @xmath9 , and the total momentum @xmath89 , where @xmath90 , its @xmath91-component @xmath92 and the electron spin component @xmath76 .
the eigenstates of @xmath93 are degenerate in @xmath92 and @xmath76 , their wavefunctions and energies read @xcite here @xmath95 are the clebsch - gordan coefficients . as a result , neglecting @xmath72 and @xmath73 one can denote the excitonic states as , e.g. , @xmath96 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 , @xmath99 , @xmath100 , etc . , by the principle quantum number @xmath2 , the symmetry of the envelope function ( @xmath29 for @xmath31 , @xmath16 for @xmath17 , etc . ) and the total angular momentum @xmath101 .
microscopically , the spin - orbit interaction results from the complex valence band structure , and particularly , from the mixing of the @xmath59 and @xmath60 bands @xcite .
by contrast , the contributions @xmath72 and @xmath73 are specific for excitons in semiconductors . @xmath72 describes the exchange interaction between the electron and the hole forming the exciton .
it can be decomposed in the long- and short - range parts @xcite .
the former is relatively weak for `` forbidden '' transitions and is disregarded here , see refs .
@xcite for details . in what follows
we consider only the short - range part of the exchange interaction , @xmath102 , where @xmath103 is the three - dimensional @xmath104-function .
this interaction is relevant for the @xmath29- and @xmath30-shell excitons : for the @xmath29-shell states the envelopes @xmath105 do not vanish at @xmath106 , and the @xmath30-shell states are strongly mixed with the @xmath34-shell states from the @xmath60 valence band , see ref .
@xcite for details . within the @xmath29- and @xmath30-
multiplets the exchange interaction is described by the constants @xmath107 and @xmath108 , respectively : @xmath109 with account for the contributions in eq .
the exciton states are split in accordance to the total angular momentum of the electron and the hole @xmath110 .
in particular , the @xmath34-shell states split into the paraexciton @xmath111 and the triplet orthoexciton @xmath112 , while the @xmath113-states split into states with @xmath114 and the @xmath115-states split into @xmath116 and @xmath117 multiplets .
we note , however , that the exchange interaction is most important for the @xmath113-states , while for the @xmath115- as well as for the @xmath38- , @xmath42- , etc .
excitons , the effects of the symmetry reduction due the cubic crystalline environment are important , see ref .
@xcite and below for details .
moreover , the exchange interaction mixes the @xmath29- and @xmath30-shell states with @xmath112 , as well as the @xmath35-shell multiplets with @xmath116 . for the following the mixing of the @xmath116 states
is disregarded and the mixing of the @xmath29-shell and @xmath30-shell states with @xmath112 is characterized by the parameters @xmath118 with @xmath119 being the @xmath91-component of the total angular momentum @xmath120 . the @xmath73 term reduces the symmetry of the problem from spherical to the o@xmath13 point group , resulting in mixing and splitting of the states with given total angular momentum .
we illustrate the role of these terms by the example of the @xmath115 excitonic states . in the @xmath25 point symmetry group
these states transform according to the reducible representation @xmath121 .
the crystalline splitting between these states is described by the effective hamiltonian @xmath122 where @xmath123 is the splitting between the @xmath60 quadruplet and the @xmath58 doublet , @xmath124 are the matrices of the angular momentum @xmath125 in the set of cubic axes .
similar invariants can be written for the @xmath38- , @xmath42- , etc .
microscopically , the origin of this splitting is the difference of the @xmath126 and @xmath127 luttinger parameters @xcite .
finally , the matrix elements of the electric field - induced perturbation , eq .
, are easily calculated making use of the general expressions for the matrix elements of the vector components in the basis of the @xmath66 @xcite and the integrals of the radial hydrogenic wavefunctions @xcite . in our calculations
we keep the momentum quantization axis parallel to the electric field ( @xmath128 $ ] for comparing with the experimental data on sample 1 and @xmath129 $ ] for comparing with the data on sample 2 ) . in order to calculate the transmission
spectra one needs to determine the exciton oscillator strengths .
we take into account both dipole transitions to @xmath16-shell excitonic states and quadrupolar transitions to @xmath29-shell states . to that end
we introduce the three orbital bloch amplitudes of the valence band @xmath130 , @xmath131 which transform , respectively , as @xmath132 , @xmath133 and @xmath132 in the @xmath25 point group , i.e. according to the @xmath134 irreducible representation .
the bloch amplitudes of the @xmath59 states in the electron representation can be written as [ g7 ] @xmath135 , @xmath136 are the spin - up and spin - down electron spinors ( i.e. , the basic functions of the @xmath58 irreducible representation ) and the set of cubic axes is used with @xmath137 $ ] , @xmath138 $ ] and @xmath139 $ ] .
the conduction band states are simply expressed via the @xmath140 bloch amplitude and spinors such as @xmath141 , @xmath142 .
it is convenient to parametrize the matrix elements of the optical transitions in terms of basic orbital matrix elements involving one bloch amplitude @xmath143 and one orbital envelope of the exciton .
particularly , for the @xmath16-shell excitonic states ( envelope @xmath144 , @xmath17 ) the matrix elements for the interband dipole transition can be recast as @xcite @xmath145 where @xmath146 is the dipole operator , @xmath30 is a material parameter @xcite , @xmath147 , @xmath148 , @xmath149 are the cartesian components , @xmath150 are the @xmath16-shell exciton envelopes transforming as the coordinate @xmath148 being a linear combination of functions with fixed @xmath2 and @xmath17 , and the symbol @xmath151 equals to @xmath152 if and only if all subscripts are different ( otherwise it is zero ) . for light propagating along the @xmath91-axis
the @xmath34-shell excitons are quadrupole - allowed in the @xmath153 and @xmath154 polarizations , and the matrix element of the transition reads @xmath155 where @xmath156 is the @xmath34-shell envelope , and @xmath157 is another parameter @xcite .
99ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty thomas f. gallagher , _ rydberg atoms _ ( cambridge university press , 2005 ) . @noop
* * , ( ) http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature13832 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.115.027402 [ * * , ( ) ]
link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.93.075203 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.93.195203 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1002/pssa.2210430102 [ * * , ( ) ] e. gross , `` optical spectrum of excitons in the crystal lattice , '' il nuovo cimento series * 10 * , 672 ( 1956 ) .
link:\doibase 10.1002/pssb.2220660140 [ * * , ( ) ] sylwia zieliska - raczyska , david ziemkiewicz , and gerard czajkowski , `` electro - optical properties of rydberg excitons , '' phys .
b * 94 * , 045205 ( 2016 ) m. amann , j. thewes , d. frhlich , and m. bayer , `` quantum chaos and breaking of all anti - unitary symmetries in rydberg excitons , '' nat .
, advance online publication: , 04 ( 2016 ) .
link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.23.2731 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.20.2251 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.91.107401 [ * * , ( ) ] f. schweiner , j. main , g. wunner , and c. uihlein , `` @xmath159-dependent exchange interaction of the @xmath160 orthoexciton in @xmath161 , '' phys .
b * 94 * , 115201 ( 2016 ) . note that in the supplemental information in ref .
@xcite the order of lines in the @xmath162-symbol , eq .
( 14 ) , is confused as remarked and corrected in ref .
@noop _ _ ( , , ) hans a. bethe , edwin e. salpeter , _ quantum mechanics of one - and two - electron atoms _ ( springer - verlag , 1957 ) . ,
solid state physics : supplement ( , ) a. g. zhilich , j. halpern , and b. p. zakharchenya , `` magnetoabsorption oscillations and the zeeman effect of excitons for forbidden interband transitions in @xmath163o crystals , '' phys
. rev . * 188 * , 1294 ( 1969 ) .
it can be derived in the @xmath164 perturbation theory taking into account the mixing with odd parity remote bands , e.g. , @xmath165 or @xmath166 and the dipole - allowed transitions between the remote and conduction / valence bands @xcite . | we have used high resolution transmission spectroscopy to study the exciton level spectrum in cu@xmath0o subject to a longitudinal external electric field , i.e. , in the geometry where the transmitted light is propagating along the field direction .
different experimental configurations given by the field orientation relative to the crystal and the light polarization have been explored .
we focus on the range of small principal quantum numbers @xmath1 .
the number of exciton states belonging to a particular principal quantum number increases with @xmath2 , leading to an enhanced complexity of the spectra .
still , in particular for @xmath3 a spectral separation of the different lines is feasible and identification as well as assignment of the dominant state character are possible .
we find a strong dependence of the spectra on the chosen light propagation direction and polarization configuration , reflecting the inadequacy of the hydrogen model for describing the excitons . with increasing the field excitonic states with different parity become mixed , leading to optical activation of states that are dark in zero field .
as compared with atoms , due to the reduced rydberg energy states with different @xmath2 can be brought into resonance in the accessible electric field strength range .
when this occurs , we observe mostly crossing of levels within the experimental accuracy showing that the electron and hole motion remains regular .
the observed features are well described by detailed calculations accounting for the spin - orbit coupling , the cubic anisotropy effects , and the symmetry - imposed optical selection rules . |
an experiment by mller _ et al _
@xcite at the institut laue - langevin ( ill ) is currently measuring spin - dependent effects in the thermal neutron capture process n+pd+ , [ polnp ] wherein , as indicated , both the incident neutron and the target proton are polarized . at threshold ,
the initial nuclear state is in either the @xmath9 or @xmath10 channel , where @xmath11 is the isospin .
the process ( [ polnp ] ) therefore receives contributions from the isovector m1 matrix element ( m1v ) between the initial @xmath12 ( @xmath13 ) and the final deuteron ( @xmath14 ) state , along with the isoscalar m1 matrix element ( ) and the isoscalar e2 ( ) matrix element between the initial @xmath15 ( @xmath14 ) and the final deuteron @xmath16 states .
contribution recently considered by chen , rupak and savage @xcite . ] since m1v is by far the largest amplitude ( see below ) , the spin - averaged cross section @xmath17 is totally dominated by m1v .
meanwhile , since the initial @xmath12 state has @xmath18 , the m1v can not yield spin - dependent effects , whereas and can .
this means that , as first noted by breit and rustgi@xcite , the spin - dependent observables in ( [ polnp ] ) are sensitive to small isoscalar matrix elements . to explain the significance of this feature in the context of nuclear effective field theory ( eft )
, we first give a brief discussion of the chiral filter hypothesis"@xcite . the chiral filter hypothesis based on current algebra
was proposed in 1978 prior to the advent of modern nuclear eft .
it dictates that corrections to the single - particle transitions in nuclei for the isovector m1 operator and the weak axial charge operator should be dominated by one - soft - pion - exchange two - body currents .
it was shown in @xcite that this dominance is naturally explained by chiral perturbation theory ; the soft - pion exchange diagrams are leading - order two - body diagrams in chiral counting . a thorough nuclear eft calculation of m1v carried out in @xcite gave a precise , parameter - free estimate of @xmath19 , which was in perfect agreement with the experimental value @xcite ; furthermore , it was confirmed that the major corrections to the one - body ( single - nucleon ) current in m1v indeed come from one - soft - pion - exchange . for the axial charge also ,
its large enhancement due to the soft - pion exchange two - body currents is by now well established @xcite .
thus , for the observables protected " by the chiral filter ( i.e. , observables essentially determined by leading chiral - order terms ) , nuclear eft has been highly successful .
the question now is whether we can profitably apply nuclear eft to observables unprotected " by the chiral filter . with leading chiral - order contributions vanishing , one must consider higher order diagrams , a task which can quickly become formidable .
the above - mentioned isoscalar matrix elements , m1s and e2s , are examples of the unprotected " observable .
as is well known , the one - body contribution of is highly suppressed due to the orthogonality between the initial @xmath15 and the final deuteron state .
the soft - pion exchange is also suppressed , there being no isoscalar @xmath20 vertex in the leading order chiral lagrangian , where @xmath21 is the external isoscalar field that couples to the baryonic current . due to this double suppression ,
the size of @xmath22 becomes even comparable ( see below ) to that of , which is a higher - order multipole and hence , in normal circumstances , can be ignored .
this situation suggests that we must go up to an unusually high chiral order before getting sensible estimates of the isoscalar matrix elements that govern the spin observables in ( [ polnp ] ) .
however , we show in this paper ( confirming the previous results reported in @xcite ) that nuclear eft allows us to make a systematic and reasonably reliable estimation of m1s and e2s . by the very nature of eft ,
an effective lagrangian involves , at each order of power counting , a certain number of parameters .
these parameters are in principle calculable from first principles for a given scale ( _ e.g. _ , lattice qcd @xcite ) but , in practice , they have to be fixed by experimental data .
once the parameters are so fixed , the lagrangian can then be used to make predictions for other processes governed by the same parameters .
however , it often happens that after fixing the parameters there is not much room left for prediction .
a major point of our work is to demonstrate that one can make a genuine eft prediction even for the highly suppressed m1s and e2s .
our _ bona fide _ prediction not biased by pre - existing numbers can be tested soon by the forthcoming results from the ill experiment @xcite .
adopting the convention of mller et al @xcite , we write the transition amplitude as _
d , ( , ) | t| _ np = ^_d m ( , ) _ np with ( , ) = [ amp ] where @xmath23 is the velocity of the projectile neutron , @xmath24 is the deuteron normalization factor @xmath25 , and @xmath26 ( @xmath27 ) denotes the spin wave function of the final deuteron ( initial @xmath0 ) state .
the emitted photon is characterized by the unit momentum vector @xmath28 , the energy @xmath29 and the helicity @xmath30 , and its polarization vector is denoted by @xmath31 .
the amplitudes , @xmath32 , @xmath22 and @xmath33 , represent the isovector m1 , isoscalar m1 and isoscalar e2 contributions , respectively .
these quantities are defined in such a manner that they all have the dimension of length , and the cross section for the unpolarized @xmath0 system takes the form _
unpol= ^2 + ^2 + ^2 .
[ xsection ] as we shall see below , the isoscalar terms ( @xmath34 and @xmath35 ) are strongly suppressed relative to @xmath36 approximately by a factor of @xmath37 so the unpolarized cross section is practically unaffected by the isoscalar terms . as mentioned , the isovector m1 amplitude was calculated @xcite very accurately up to @xmath38 relative to the single - particle operator .
the result expressed in terms of @xmath32 is : @xmath39 fm , which should be compared to the empirical value @xmath40 fm . in this paper , therefore , we will focus on the isoscalar amplitudes .
the isoscalar matrix elements are given by & & - _
d^j_z=1 | ^z | _ t^j_z=1 , + & & _
d^j_z=1 | q^33 | _ t^j_z=1[isoscalarme]with & = & 12 d^3 _ ( ) , + q^ij&= & d^3 ( 3 x^i x^j - ^ij ^2 ) j_^0 ( ) , [ muqdef]where @xmath41 is the em current .
the spin - triplet initial @xmath0 and the final deuteron wavefunctions , @xmath42 and @xmath43 , are given as | _
t , d^j_z _ 1 j_z _ 00 with the boundary conditions _
r u_d(r ) = a_s ^-_d r , _
r u_t(r ) = r - a_t , and _
r = _ d , _
r = 0 , where @xmath44 with @xmath45 the binding energy and @xmath46 the nucleon mass ; @xmath47 is the asymptotic @xmath48 ratio of the deuteron ; @xmath49 is the @xmath50 @xmath0 scattering length , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 ( @xmath53 ) is the spin ( isospin ) wavefunctions . as mentioned , the spin - dependent observables are sensitive to the isoscalar matrix elements .
let @xmath54 be the angular distribution of photons with helicity @xmath55 , where @xmath56 is the angle between @xmath28 ( direction of photon emission ) and a quantization axis of nucleon polarization .
for polarized neutrons with polarization @xmath57 incident on unpolarized protons , the photon circular polarization @xmath58 is defined by p_.[pgammadef ] at threshold , @xmath58 is given by p_= both protons and neutrons are polarized ( along a common quantization axis ) with polarizations @xmath59 and @xmath60 , respectively , the anisotropy @xmath61 is defined by _ & & , where @xmath62 is the angular distribution of total photon intensity ( regardless of their helicities ) . at threshold , we have _ & = & pp where pp_p_n .
we note that @xmath58 is linear in @xmath63 s in the leading order .
by contrast , unless @xmath64 , the anisotropy @xmath61 is quadratic in @xmath63 s and hence highly suppressed . for @xmath64 ( nearly perfect polarization )
, @xmath61 becomes @xmath65 in powers of @xmath63 s and can be of a substantial magnitude .
this feature suggests the possibility of obtaining two independent constraints on @xmath63 s , one from @xmath58 and the other from @xmath61 , which would allow extraction of the individual values of @xmath66 and @xmath67 .
there exist data on @xmath58 due to bazhenov _
et al . _
@xcite , and the ill experiment @xcite is expected to give information on @xmath61 .
our argument above is based on the strict threshold kinematics .
a few remarks are in order here .
when the velocity of the projectile neutron @xmath23 goes to zero , the cross section diverges as @xmath68 and consequently the matrix elements as @xmath69 .
however , the quantity that is actually measured in experiment is the yield , the flux times the cross section . since the flux is proportional to @xmath23 , @xmath70 near threshold is constant with good accuracy , and one measures the thermal average of this @xmath23-independent yield .
it is customary to translate the measured yield into the cross sections using a fixed velocity , @xmath71 m / s , which corresponds to the average neutron velocity at room temperature .
we adopt this convention throughout this paper , and we mean by at threshold " that we are neglecting any higher order corrections in @xmath23 .
chen et al.@xcite pointed out that at this velocity the isovector e1 matrix element ( we denote it by e1v ) connecting initial @xmath72 waves with the deuteron state can compete with m1s and e2s .
they calculated @xmath58 including the e1v contribution but the corresponding result for @xmath61 has not been reported .
the inclusion of e1v affects the asymmetry @xmath73 defined and calculated in @xcite .
however , for photons emitted in the @xmath74 direction , there is no contribution from e1v .
this means that @xmath58 , eq.([pgammadef ] ) , is not influenced at all by the e1v contribution .
meanwhile , according to @xcite , @xmath61 arising from e1v has a very different @xmath75 dependence from that arising from m1s and e2s . in principle , therefore , it should be possible to distinguish experimentally these two @xmath61 s of different origins . in the present work limited to the threshold kinematics , we do not discuss the contribution of e1v .
, while @xmath66 and @xmath67 are @xmath23-independent . ]
the chiral counting rules relevant to electroweak vertices in two - nucleon systems are well known by now ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) .
the chiral index @xmath76 of a given irreducible diagram is given by = 1 - 2 c + 2 l + _ i _ i , _ i = d_i + e_i + -2 , [ naive]where @xmath77 is the number of disjoint pieces ( @xmath78 for one - body currents and @xmath79 for two - body currents ) , and @xmath80 the number of loops ; @xmath81 , @xmath82 and @xmath83 are , respectively , the numbers of derivatives/@xmath84 s , external fields and nucleon lines at the @xmath85-th vertex . since chiral symmetry guarantees @xmath86 , eq.([naive ] ) implies that the one - body em current @xmath87 starts at @xmath88 while the two - body current @xmath89 starts at @xmath90 . as spelled out in @xcite
, there are additional suppression factors of either a kinematical or symmetry origin .
for instance , the space - part of the one - body current is suppressed by one power in @xmath91 relative to its time part .
the detailed counting rules for the two - body isoscalar em current are rather complicated and will be discussed later . at present , there are essentially two alternative " ways of power counting in setting up an effective field theory for two - nucleon systems .
one is the original weinberg scheme @xcite , in which the leading four - fermi contact interaction and a pion - exchange are treated on the same footing in calculating the irreducible " graphs for a potential that is to be iterated to all orders in the
reducible " channel . the power counting is done only for irreducible vertices .
the other is the power divergence subtraction " ( pds ) scheme @xcite , in which only the leading ( nonderivative ) four - fermi contact interaction is iterated to all orders , with the higher - order contact interactions and the pion exchange treated perturbatively . while the pds scheme is perhaps more systematic in power counting , we believe that the weinberg scheme is not only consistent with the strategy of eft but also , in the sense developed below , more flexible and predictive with possible errors due to potential inconsistency in power counting generically suppressed . in our work
we adopt the weinberg scheme . in this framework ,
the power counting for electroweak transition amplitudes simply reduces to chiral counting in the irreducible vertex for the current , as the current appears only once in the graphs .
we are then allowed to separate the current matrix element into the one - body ( single - particle ) and two - body ( exchange - current ) terms .
this framework has the advantage that it can be straightforwardly applied to n - body systems for @xmath92 .
iterating the irreducible vertex to all orders in the reducible channel is equivalent to solving the schrdinger equation with a corresponding potential .
this then suggests that we use , in calculating nuclear responses to slowly varying electroweak probes , those wave functions computed with so - called phenomenological realistic potentials " .
a prime example of these realistic potentials is the argonne @xmath93 potential @xcite ( called in short av18 ) .
thus in this approach , referred to as the _ hybrid approach _ , the one - body and two - body transition operators derived from eft are sandwiched between the initial and final two - nucleon wavefunctions distorted by a phenomenological n - n potential .
this procedure of mapping effective field theory to realistic wave functions has recently been justified by means of a cutoff regularization @xcite .
a similar argument in support of such a hybrid procedure has been presented by van kolck @xcite .
previously we adopted this scheme to study the unpolarized @xmath94 reaction for the thermal neutron .
the cross section for this process was computed to next - to - next - to - leading order ( nnlo ) in the above - described chiral counting scheme for the transition vertex @xcite , and with the use of the av18 wave functions .
the resulting theoretical cross section , @xmath95 , agrees very well with the experimental value @xmath96 fm @xcite ; @xmath97 consists of the leading 1-body contribution , @xmath98 , and the 2-body exchange - current contribution , which in conformity with the chiral filter is dominated by the soft one - pion exchange . as shown in @xcite ,
the single - particle matrix element has negligible uncertainty , and therefore the theoretical error is entirely attributable to the uncertainty in the exchange - current operator associated with the short - distance part of the interactions .
this short - range behavior is not fully controlled in the formulation of @xcite .
the short - distance part introduces a scale and renormalization - scheme dependence , and only those results that are not sensitive to this uncertainty can be trusted . in a framework that uses realistic wave functions ,
the short - distance scale is set by a ( momentum ) cutoff proportional to @xmath99 , where @xmath100 is the hard - core radius " that removes the part of the wave function for @xmath101 .
the net effect of this cutoff is that in addition to cutting the radial integrals in the coordinate space , it removes _ all _ zero - range terms in the current operator including zero - ranged counter terms .
after the four - fermion counter term is removed by the hard core , there are no more parameters in the theory .
this procedure , familiar to nuclear physicists , may be viewed as a form of exploiting the scheme dependence .
we shall refer to this procedure as the hard - core cutoff scheme ( hccs ) .
hccs can be justified for the process in question by using a ( momentum ) cutoff @xmath102 and showing that the counter - term contribution killed " by the hard core lies within that uncertainty range .
is related to the hard - core radius used in standard nuclear physics calculations . ]
the @xmath103 theoretical error assigned to @xmath97 above represents uncertainty in this cutoff procedure .
we will see below that , when the chiral filter does not apply , the removal of the zero - range counter terms by the simple hard - core cutoff may be much less reliable . either starting from the well - known em form factors of the nucleon , or carrying out an explicit chpt calculation that reproduces the form factors , we arrive at the following expressions for the one - body operators : _
1b(_1 , _ 2 ) & = & _ i=1,2 , + q^ab_1b(_1 , _ 2 ) & = & e _ i=1,2with u^ab_i 32 r_i^a ( _ i_i)^b + 32 r_i^a ( _ i_i)^b -^ab _ i ( _ i_i ) , where @xmath104 and @xmath105 . the matrix elements ( [ isoscalarme ] ) can then be obtained by a straightforward calculation .
for example , the leading order one - body matrix elements are given by _
1b^lo & = & - _ 0^dr , + _ 1b^lo & = & _ 0^dr r^2 .
as mentioned earlier , the one - body @xmath22 is suppressed by the orthogonality _ 0^dr = 0 .
[ ortho]using the av18 wavefunctions , the numerical results for the sum of the lo and nlo are given as _ 1b ( ) & = & ( -4.192 - 0.105 ) 10 ^ -3 = -4.29710 ^ -3 , + _ 1b ( ) & = & ( 1.401 - 0.007 ) 10 ^ -3 = 1.394 10 ^ -3 .
we see that the size of the one - body @xmath22 is about @xmath106 times smaller than m1v , a suppression which can be traced to the above - mentioned orthogonality and the smallness of @xmath107 as compared to @xmath108 .
generic diagrams for the two - body isoscalar current are depicted in fig . 1 .
all the propagators and the vertices therein should be understood as the renormalized quantities that include all the loops and counter term insertions to a given order .
the vertices with non - trivial renormalization are represented by big filled circles .
the one - loop graphs relevant to the filled circle in fig .
@xmath109 ( fig.@xmath110 ) are drawn in fig .
2 ( fig . 3 ) .
we now proceed to discuss in detail the counting rules for the two - body contributions . for easy reference
, we let stand for contributions of order @xmath111 relative to the leading one - body term . for the chiral - filter protected m1v , since the isovector @xmath112 vertex with @xmath113 enters at the blob of fig .
1@xmath114 , the leading correction appears at and the one - loops and the counter - terms appear at . for the isoscalar current , not protected by the chiral filter , the counting rules are quite different .
the @xmath20 coupling is highly suppressed by chiral symmetry , and its first non - vanishing term appears at _ i ( b^i nn ) 2 , _ i ( b^0 nn ) 3 .
the same suppression factors appear in the contact @xmath115 vertex . as a result ,
leading corrections for the @xmath22 are , which arise from a chiral lagrangian @xcite of the form _ 2 & = & - ^ ( _ _ - _ _ ) |b_v v _ i _ b_v + & - & i g_4 ( _ _ - _ _ ) |b_v [ s_v^ , s_v^ ] b_v |b_v b_v where @xmath116 is the nucleon field ; the definitions of the four - velocity @xmath117 , the spin - operator @xmath118 and the covariant pion - derivative @xmath119 can be found in @xcite .
although the second term contains an unknown constant @xmath120 , the first term is free from an additional parameter , for it is given by the wess - zumino term ( related to the adler - bell - jackiw anomaly ) the strength of which can be determined from the ksrf relation .
there is also a lagrangian consisting of @xmath121 corrections that we shall refer to as the fixed - term " lagrangian in which all the coefficents are uniquely determined @xcite , ^fixed = |b_v b_v [ fixed]where @xmath122 is the axial coupling constant and the ellipses denote terms irrelevant to our present study .
the chiral index of the first term is @xmath123 , while all the other terms have @xmath124 .
it is to be noted , however , that the @xmath123 term is proportional to the energy - transfer , by @xmath125 , where the subscript @xmath85 is the particle index . ] which is of order of @xmath126 .
consequently all the terms in eq.([fixed ] ) give contributions to the m1 operators .
there is no counter - term contribution to up to with which we are concerned .
the loop contributions enter at and are finite .
usually , counter - term contributions enter regardless of whether the loops are divergent or not at the same order as the loop contributions . in our case , however , there is no counter term contribution .
additional parameters characterizing the nuclear potential appear at the four - fermion vertex in fig .
3@xmath127 , through a lagrangian of the form _ 0 = -12 _ a c_a ( |b _ a b)^2 . here
s stand for non - derivative operators , and @xmath129 are constant coefficients . due to the fermi - dirac statistics , only two of the four possible @xmath129 are independent .
summing all the two - body contributions up to and fourier - transforming the resulting expressions into coordinate space , we obtain the following isoscalar m1 and e2 operators : _ 2b ( ) & = & + _ 1^fixed ( ) , [ mu2br ] + q^ij_2b ( ) & = & ( 3 r^i r^j - ^ij r^2 ) [ q2br]where @xmath130 and @xmath131 is the orbital angular momentum operator for the relative motion . we have separated the contribution from the fixed - term lagrangian ( [ fixed ] ) , _ 1^fixed ( ) & = & with ^i(x ) = ^ijk r^j x^l , where @xmath132 is either @xmath133 or @xmath134 ; @xmath135 and @xmath136 are yukawa functions , and @xmath137 is the momentum operator with the understanding that the derivatives act only on wavefunctions .
the @xmath138 s are given as c_1^t(r ) & = & ( 1 + + ) + _ 0 ^ 1 k_3(x ) , + c_3^t(r ) & = & m_^3 ( 1 + + ) - _ 0 ^ 1 k_3(x ) + & & + _ 0 ^ 1 , + c_5^v(r ) & = & _ 0 ^ 1 k_3(x ) [ c135]and _ 2(r ) & = & _ 1_2 - _ 0 ^ 1 k_3(x ) + v_1 ( ) + & + & \ { 3 _ 0 ^ 1 . + & & .
- ( 3 + 2 _ 1_2 ) _ 0 ^ 1 } , + c_4(r ) & = & m_^3 + _ 0 ^ 1 k_3(x ) + ( ) + & + & \ { 12 _ 0 ^ 1 - 3 _ 0 ^ 1 } + & & [ c24]where @xmath139 , @xmath140 and @xmath141 is the irregular modified bessel functions of order @xmath76 .
the coefficients @xmath142 s are defined by n_1 & = & _ 1_2 , + n_2 & = & _ 1_2 , + n_3 & = & ( 3 + 2 _ 1_2 ) , + n_wz & = & _ 1_2 , and @xmath143 and @xmath144 are two independent coefficients involving @xmath129 , v_1 & & - _ 1_2 + _ a ( _ 1^b _ 1^j c_a_a _ a _ 1^b_1^j
+ ( 1 2 ) ) , + ( _ 1 + _ 2)v_2 & & n_1 m_(_1+_2 ) + _ a ( _ 1^b _ 1^j \{c_a_a _ a,_1 } _ 1^b_1^j + ( 1 2 ) ) .
[ v1v2]in the above equations , the terms with @xmath120 and @xmath145 as well as the fixed - terms are due to contributions , while all the other terms come from contributions .
fortunately , the parameters @xmath144 can be absorbed into @xmath120 , can be renormalized to absorb some contribution , n_wz n_wz n_wz - n_1 .
[ nwz]unlike the @xmath120 case , however , this does not reduce the number of unknown parameters , since the value of @xmath146 is already known . ]
g_4 g_4 g_4 + n_wz + v_2 .
the @xmath143 term , which in naive counting is , is further suppressed and plays little role .
the reason is not hard to understand : @xmath143 appears only in @xmath147 , which is accompanied either by @xmath131 ( for ) or by @xmath148 ( for ) . as a consequence , the @xmath143 term contribution has the form ~v_1
d^3 r^n ^3 ( ) , [ v1term]where @xmath149 ( for m1s ) and @xmath150 ( for e2s ) , and eq.([v1term ] ) is obviously zero .
thus we are left with only one parameter @xmath151 . in the next section
we will show that we can fix @xmath151 by taking the magnetic moment of the deuteron as input .
this will enable us to make a totally parameter - free prediction for the ill experiment .
the two - body contribution to the , denoted by @xmath152 , can be expressed as _ 2b = _ 0^
dr f_t(r ) - g_4 d^3 ^(3 ) ( ) , [ naivemut]where @xmath153 consists of @xmath154 s [ see eqs.([c135 ] , [ c24 ] ) ] and the final and initial radial wavefunctions .
the first integral diverges since @xmath153 contains a piece which behaves like @xmath155 for @xmath156 .
if the hard - core cutoff scheme ( hccs ) defined earlier can be used , this divergence simply disappears , as the hard - core kills any contributions from @xmath157 ( @xmath100 = hard - core radius ) .
a hard - core would remove altogether the second integral in eq.([naivemut ] ) .
hccs was applied quite successfully to chiral - filter - protected quantities , e.g. , m1v @xcite . the numerical results in @xcite
exhibit only slight @xmath100-dependence , a feature that assures the predictivity of hccs . for processes not protected by the chiral - filter ,
however , there is no reason to believe that hccs continues to be satisfactory .
this is because two - body corrections for these processes come from short - ranged physics , " and therefore imposing a hard - core will throw out the main part of the relevant physics . for the process ( [ polnp ] )
this problem becomes even more serious because the strong suppression of the one - body @xmath22 in our case means that even small changes in the two - body contributions can have a significant influence on the total transition amplitude .
in particular , since we are calculating up to , it is not justifiable to neglect by fiat the @xmath151 term , which is . for systematic evaluation of the short - ranged contributions along with long - ranged contributions , a transparent method would be to impose a momentum cutoff @xmath158 in performing fourier transformation .
this scheme would allow us to include in a well - defined manner the contributions from @xmath159 , whereas they are simply thrown away in hccs .
technically , however , it is cumbersome to introduce a cutoff in fourier transformation .
fortunately , for our present purposes , we can use a convenient scheme equivalent to , but simpler than , the momentum cutoff method . for this scheme , we first note that , the large-@xmath160 contributions being scheme - independent , only the contributions @xmath161 involve scheme - dependence . secondly , while @xmath153 contains both the @xmath162-wave and @xmath163-wave radial functions , the terms involving the @xmath162-wave have higher powers of @xmath160 and hence receive only minor contributions from the small @xmath160 region .
then the only quantity that is sensitive to the renormalization scheme is the small-@xmath160 contribution of the term containing @xmath164 and @xmath165 . for small @xmath160 ,
however , these radial functions can be approximated as @xmath166 and @xmath167 . the small-@xmath160 contribution ( @xmath168 ) of the first integral of eq.([naivemut ] ) then can be written as _ 0^r_c
dr f_t u_d(0 ) u_t(0 ) a where @xmath169 is an @xmath100-dependent but wavefunction - independent constant .
this contribution can be absorbed into the redefintion of the parameter @xmath151 ; the resulting @xmath151 will become @xmath100-dependent . the net effect of this procedure
is to remove the @xmath157 contribution while retaining the @xmath100-dependent @xmath151 term .
operationally , we can achieve the same goal by replacing the delta function attached to @xmath151 with the delta - shell function , ^3 ( ) .
[ deltashell]for a given value of @xmath100 we can fix @xmath151 by fitting the deuteron magnetic moment .
we shall call this scheme the modified hard - core cutoff scheme ( mhccs ) . a regularization scheme similar to mhccs
has often been used in the literature ( see , for example , @xcite ) .
hereafter we drop the prime on @xmath151 for simplicity . in mhccs ,
eq.([naivemut ] ) is rewritten as _
2b & = & _ r_c^ dr f_t(r ) - g_4 _
2b^finite + _ 2b^zero .
[ mut]we determine @xmath120 through the renormalization condition for the deuteron magnetic moment , _
, 2b = _ r_c^ dr f_d(r ) + 2 m_n g_4 = _ d^exp - _ d_,1b , [ mud]g_4 = _ d , _ d_d^exp - _ d_,1b - _ d_,2b^finite for @xmath100 = 0.01 , 0.2 , 0.4 , 0.6 and 0.8 fm ,
we find @xmath170 0.024 , 0.020 , 0.022 , 0.023 and 0.023 ( in units of the nuclear magneton ) ; the corresponding values of @xmath120 are : @xmath171 5.06 , 2.24 , 0.73 , 0.31 and 0.20 . in table
[ t1 ] we give the renormalized @xmath22 and its breakdown into the various individual contributions , for different values of @xmath100 spanning a wide range , @xmath172 .
.[t1]individual contributions to in unit of @xmath173 .
@xmath174 is the sum of @xmath175 and @xmath176 , while @xmath175 is the sum of the contributions from the wz term , @xmath177 , and the fixed - term , " @xmath178 .
we also list the results in the hard - core cutoff scheme ( hccs ) ( without the @xmath120 contribution ) , @xmath179 , with @xmath180 .
the last row gives the total resulting from the mhccs regularization . [
cols=">,>,>,>,>,>",options="header " , ] we see that , while the finite part exhibits some @xmath100-dependence , the total @xmath22 is completely insensitive to the value of @xmath100 , owing to the renormalization to fit the magnetic moment of the deuteron .
our results can be summarized as = ( -2.850.01)10 ^ -3 , where the error bar stands for the @xmath100-dependence .
it is highly noteworthy that the @xmath100-independence holds even when @xmath120 changes by a factor of @xmath181 .
we also observe that the individual contributions coming from and are of the same order as the lo one - body contribution .
this feature can be traced to the afore - mentioned facts that the lo one - body contribution is suppressed by the orthogonality of the wavefunctions , and that the is suppressed due to the smallness of @xmath182 .
about half of the contributions are cancelled by the contributions . in obtaining the above numerical results
, we used the ksrf value , @xmath183 , for the @xmath184 coupling constant featuring in the wess - zumino term .
if instead we use a more conventional value , @xmath185 , then the resonance - exchange contribution decreases , leading to a larger cancellation between the loop contribution and the contributions .
even with the use of a unrealistically small value of the @xmath182 which would cause a complete cancellation among the 2-body terms , we have found @xmath186 ( for the entire range of @xmath172 ) , which differs only about 2 % from @xmath22 in table 1 .
we note that the mec contribution reduces the one - body contribution by about 30 % .
the two - body contribution to the @xmath33 turns out to be quite small , @xmath187 for the whole range of @xmath188 . combining the one - body and two - body contributions , we obtain = ( 1.40 0.01 ) 10 ^ -3 .
correspondingly , the two - body contribution to the deuteron quadrupole moment also is quite small , @xmath189 .
this means that the discrepancy between the experimental value ( @xmath190 ) and the one - body contribution ( @xmath191 ) can not be explained in terms of the two - body effects as calculated here .
we now discuss briefly the possibility of another renormalization scheme .
earlier , we invoked eq.([v1term ] ) to eliminate the contribution of the @xmath143 term .
however , if we use a non - zero value of @xmath100 , the delta - function gets smeared and therefore the @xmath143 term can have a finite contribution even though suppressed by powers of @xmath192 .
one then might wonder if there exists a possibility to renormalize the deuteron quadrupole moment @xmath193 as well as the magnetic moment by adjusting @xmath143 .
this is indeed possible , and we shall refer to this scheme as mhccs@xmath194 . since the extension of mhccs to mhccs@xmath194 is straightforward , we simply quote the results . for the range of @xmath195
, we find @xmath196 and @xmath197 .
thus mhccs@xmath194 and mhccs give very similar results .
we have found that , as far as the observables are concerned , the mhccs@xmath194 results exhibit even a higher degree of insensitivity to @xmath100 than those of mhccs .
meanwhile , the values of @xmath143 and @xmath120 in mhccs@xmath194 vary as @xmath198 and @xmath199 , when @xmath100 changes from 0.01 fm to 0.8 fm . while neither @xmath143 nor @xmath120 is an observable , the occurrence of these large coefficients , [ nwz ] ) , we can infer that the _ natural scales _ of the @xmath143 and @xmath120 are @xmath200 and @xmath201 , respectively .
] as well as the huge variation of @xmath143 with respect to @xmath100 is rather offending to the _ naturalness _ of the theory .
so we will not consider this scheme seriously . to illustrate the convergence of our chiral expansion
, we also present the results that are renormalized only up to . to this order
, there are no loops , and @xmath33 does not receive any two - particle contribution .
the results for @xmath22 again turn out to be very close to what we obtained in mhccs , exhibiting little @xmath100-dependence : for @xmath172 , = ( -2.84 0.01)10 ^ -3 .
the only isospin - violating " effect that features in the above consideration is the trivial fact that the two - nucleon system can emit both isovector and isoscalar photons .
we examine here whether any significant additional isospin - violating effects can arise due to higher - order electromagnetic ( em ) interactions , or isospin impurity in the two - nucleon system .
although in normal circumstances these effects give only minor corrections , they might be important in calculating highly suppressed amplitudes such as m1s and e2s .
it is particularly important to assess those isospin - violating effects in the dominant m1v which mock the isoscalar amplitude .
first , we argue that isospin violation in the initial- and final - state interactions can not influence the observables of our concern . to produce any spin - dependent effects
, the initial @xmath0 state must have @xmath202 , and hence , at threshold , should be a @xmath15 state .
if this state could be mixed with @xmath12 ( the only other available state at threshold ) , then the dominant m1v transition connecting @xmath12 and the deuteron would produce a rather significant correction to the genuine m1s . in the two - nucleon systems , however , the conservation of @xmath203 dictates that , even in the presence of isospin - violating interactions , there be no mixing between the @xmath12 and @xmath15 channels .
next , we need to examine radiative corrections to the m1 operator itself .
instead of considering all possible diagrams , we study here a typical diagram just to get a rough estimate .
one of the diagrams that give non - vanishing corrections is obtained from fig .
3@xmath204 by replacing the one - pion line in it with a photon line .
let @xmath205 be the ratio of the contribution of this radiative correction diagram to that of fig .
the em correction becomes more ( less ) important for lower ( higher ) momentum transfers .
when the momentum transfer is of order of @xmath84 , we find @xmath206 , where @xmath207 ( @xmath208 mev )
. applied to a specific case of @xmath22 , however , this ratio is enhanced by @xmath209 , as the isovector @xmath210 vertex can contribute to the isoscalar current due to the isospin breaking em interaction , and as a result the ratio of the em correction becomes @xmath211 .
thus the em correction might be substantial compared to the .
we remark , however , that , in mhccs ( and also in mhccs@xmath194 ) , this amount of correction would cause negligible changes in the final results . to conclude , we recapitulate our predictions in the mhccs scheme for the ratios of the relevant matrix elements and the polarization observables : & = & ( -0.490.01 ) 10 ^ -3 , + & = & ( 0.240.01 ) 10 ^ -3,[ourpred ] [ rme]and strictly at threshold p_&= & ( -1.04 0.01)10 ^ -3,[ppred ] + _ & = & 0.800.02 , [ etais]where the errors represent the variance among mhccs , mhccs@xmath194 and the mhccs
. the @xmath100-dependences are negligible .
the above values of @xmath58 and @xmath61 are for complete polarization ; that is , @xmath212 for @xmath58 and @xmath213 for @xmath61 .
as noted , @xmath61 decreases rapidly when @xmath75 becomes smaller ; for instance , @xmath214 and @xmath215 .
the results with hccs are rather different overlooked in the preliminary calculation reported there .
] , : & & = ( -0.980.03 ) 10 ^ -3 , + & & p_= ( -1.73 0.05)10 ^ -3,[hccs ] + & & _ = 0.530.01 , [ hccsres]where , this time , the errors reflect the @xmath100-dependence .
the @xmath33 remains the same as in eq.([rme ] ) .
the presently available experimental data for @xmath58 @xcite is : p_^exp = ( -1.5 0.3)10 ^ -3.[pexp ] although the prediction in the hccs , ( [ hccs ] ) , gives a @xmath58 closer to ( [ pexp ] ) , we regard our mhccs result ( [ ourpred ] ) to be more reliable .
the results of chen , rupak and savage @xcite for the ratios @xmath66 and @xmath67 computed in the pds counting scheme of @xcite are quite close to ours ( [ ourpred ] ) .
even with the rather generous error estimates in @xcite taken into account , this agreement is remarkable . while we believe that mhccs is more reliable than hccs
, we should note that the mhccs and hccs results for @xmath66 differ by a factor of @xmath216 . to be conservative
, we should take this difference as uncertainty in the treatment of the short - distance physics involved .
( @xmath67 does not distinguish the two hard - core cutoff schemes . )
this sort of uncertainty was implied in the chiral filter hypothesis of ref.@xcite .
it has been mentioned in various places that , when protected by the chiral filter , the hccs procedure yields quantitatively accurate results .
but the other side of the coin of the chiral filter suggests that the hccs procedure is likely to fail when unprotected by the chiral filter , as in the case of the isoscalar matrix elements at hand .
our results here indicate how to understand the possible demise of the much used hard - core cutoff procedure , a procedure which has long been a standard method in nuclear physics , in terms of an effective field theory regularization .
what comes out as a surprise from this work is that , despite the uncertainty due to the short - distance behavior , one can make a reasonably quantitative calculation of the observables that are _ not _ protected by the chiral filter mechanism .
we await with great eagerness the forthcoming results of the ill experiment , which will bring crucial information on this issue .
we would like to thank thomas m. mller for informing us of his experiment in progress and for useful discussions and martin savage for demonstrating to us the predictive power of the effective field theory approach he and his co - workers have developed .
we are grateful to c.w .
kim , director of kias , for the hospitality and encouragement at kias where this work was completed .
the work of kk was partially supported by the nsf grant no .
phys-9602000 , and that of dpm by the kosef through ctp of snu and by the korea ministry of education contract no .
98 - 2418 .
mller , private communication ; t.m .
mller , d. dubbers , p. hautle and o. zimmer , `` measurement of the @xmath217 anisotropy in the @xmath218-process , '' in the proceedings of the `` international workshop on particle physics with slow neutrons , '' ill , grenoble , france , 22 - 24 october , 1998 .
chen , g. rupak and m.j .
savage , suppressed amplitudes in @xmath219 , " nucl - th/9905002 . g. breit and m.l .
rustgi , nucl .
phys . a * 161 * ( 1971 ) 337 .
k. kubodera , j. delorme and m. rho , m. rho , .
park , d .-
min and m. rho , ; a.e .
cox , s.a.r .
wynchank and c.h .
collie , nucl .
phys . * 74 * ( 1965 ) 497 .
park , k. kubodera , d .-
min and m. rho , on making predictions with effective field theories in nuclear physics , " nucl - th/9904053 g.p .
lepage , talk given at the workshop on nuclear physics with effective field theories , " int , university of washington , february 25 - 26 , 1999 .
et al _ , s. weinberg , ; ; d.b .
kaplan , m. savage and m. wise , ; ; ; r.b .
wiringa , v.g.j .
stoks and r. schiavilla , t .- s .
park , k. kubodera , d .-
min and m. rho , ; u. van kolck , effective field theory of nuclear forces , " nucl - th/9902015 m. savage , k.a .
scaldeferri and m.b .
wise , nucl - th/9811029 n. fettes , u .- g .
meissner and s. steinberg , nucl .
a * 640 * ( 1998 ) 199 .
g. arfken , mathematical methods for physicists " , academic press , new york , 3rd ed .
kaplan and j.v .
steele , the long and short of nuclear effective field theory expansions , " nucl - th/9905027 , and references given therein . | previously , in an effective field theory formulated by us , we have carried out parameter - free calculations of a large number of low - energy two - nucleon properties .
an experiment at the institut laue - langevin is currently measuring spin - dependent effects in the polarized @xmath0 capture process @xmath1 at threshold . noting that spin - dependent observables for this reaction are sensitive to terms of chiral orders higher than hitherto studied , we extend our effective theory approach to this process and make _ parameter - free predictions _ on the spin - dependent observables .
-.7 in .25 in # 1 # 1| # 1 | # 1 # 1#2#3#4 # 1 * # 2 * ( # 4 ) # 3 . 0.4 cm effective field theory approach to 0.4 cm @xmath2 at threshold and mannque rho@xmath3 0.5 cm @xmath4 _ school of physics , korea institute for advanced study , seoul 130 - 012 , korea _
@xmath5 _ theory group , triumf , vancouver , b.c . ,
canada v6 t 2a3 _
@xmath6 _ department of physics and astronomy , university of south carolina + columbia , sc 29208 , usa + _
@xmath7 _ department of physics , seoul national university , seoul 151 - 742 , korea _
@xmath8 _ service de physique thorique , ce saclay , 91191 gif - sur - yvette , france _ 0.5 cm |
in ferromagnetic shape memory alloys like ni - mn - ga heusler alloys the high magnetocrystalline anisotropy fixes the magnetization along the easy magnetization axis of martensite variants @xcite .
this `` one - to - one correspondence '' between magnetic domains and the martensite variants allows to rearrange the crystallographic variants by applying a magnetic field @xcite .
hence , magnetic energy determines the evolution of the multivariant states in magnetic fields .
the martensitic microstructure can be described by adapting the phenomenological theory of magnetic domains @xcite .
a detailed understanding of this coupling between microstructure and magnetic domain structure can be achieved for suitably simple geometrical systems . here
, we develop a theory of multivariant stripes in thin plates . for these stripe structure
we derive analytical expressions for demagnetization energies and complete phase diagrams for equilibrium structures .
as a model we consider multivariant states in a layer of thickness @xmath0 with surface normal along @xmath3 and infinite extension in @xmath4 and @xmath5 direction .
commonly observed patterns include lamellar microstructures built from two coexisting single - variant states with oblique or straight interfaces , i.e. the angle between easy - magnetization axis and @xmath3 is equal to @xmath6 or @xmath7 , respectively ( fig .
1 a , b ) . the orientation of these interfaces with 90-degree magnetic walls are fixed by the crystallography of the twin - boundaries between the martensite variants .
within individual variants stripe domains with 180-degree magnetic domain walls can occur ( fig . 1 , c ) @xcite . the patterns in fig .
1 a , b on the one hand satisfy the elastic compatibility between the tetragonal variants and , on the other hand , comply with a common property of magnetic domains by avoiding uncompensated magnetostatic charges on the domain boundaries . here
, we assume that internal magnetic charges , that may arise at the twin - boundary @xcite , are absent or can be neglected as the period of 180-degree domain structures within variants remain small .
further , we assume that the uniaxial anisotropy is much stronger than the applied fields .
thus , deviations of the magnetization from the easy axis within the variants can be neglected . as sketched in fig .
1 a , the magnetization in the microsctructure with oblique twin interfaces can be reduced to a pattern with alternating magnetization @xmath8 perpendicular to the plate surface and an effective bias field @xmath9 . for the pattern with straight interfaces in fig . 1 b , the alternating magnetization @xmath10 , and the bias field is @xmath11 .
thus , the patterns in fig . 1 are reduced to models of stripe domains with alternating magnetization @xmath12 perpendicular to the surface and _ straight _ and _ oblique _ domain walls in a bias field @xmath13 .
the model with straight domain walls has been investigated in details for magnetic films ( see e. g. @xcite ) and the solutions for the micromagnetic problems can be applied directly for magnetic shape memory films . the model with oblique interfaces is the main subject of our investigations in this paper . ,
( b ) @xmath14 , and stripe domains within one variant ( c).,width=245 ] the reduced energy density @xmath15 ) for the oblique stripes can be written @xmath16 where @xmath17 , @xmath18 , and @xmath19 is the period of the domain structure , @xmath20 are the widths of domains polarized in the directions parallel ( + ) and antiparallel ( - ) to the field . the domain wall energy ( the first term in eq .
( [ energy1 ] ) includes the characteristic length @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the domain wall energy density which describes the balance between the domain wall and stray field energies .
the stray field energy @xmath23 is given by a function @xmath24 that includes an infinite sum , @xmath25 .
\label{stray2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the help of the integral transformation introduced in @xcite the infinite sum in eq .
( [ stray2 ] ) is transformed into integrals on the interval [ 0,1 ] .
then , the energy ( [ energy1 ] ) can be written @xmath26dt}+ \frac{p}{\pi}\frac{l_0}{l}-2hq\ , , \label{energy2}\ ] ] where @xmath27 , @xmath28 , @xmath29 , @xmath30 @xmath31^{-1 } \,\ , $ ] and @xmath32 .
for straight stripes ( @xmath33 ) the integral transformation of sum ( [ stray2 ] ) the following expression gives the system energy @xcite
\frac{p}{\pi}\frac{l_c}{l}\!-\!2hq\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] minimization of eqs .
( [ energy2 ] ) or ( [ energyst ] ) with respect to the internal parameters @xmath35 , @xmath36 gives the equilibrium values for the domain sizes ( @xmath37 , @xmath38 ) .
the difference @xmath39 between the system energy @xmath40 and that of the homogeneously magnetized layer , @xmath41 , can be written in the following form @xmath42 } \right]dt\ , , \label{deltaw}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath43 . the energy difference @xmath44 , eq .
( [ deltaw ] ) , is _ negative _ for all @xmath45 and @xmath46 , and reaches zero only for @xmath47 , @xmath48 ( fig .
[ energyprofiles ] ) .
similar relations are also true for straight stripes @xcite . for both types of systems ,
stripes with finite widths have _ always _ lower energy than a single variant state .
the stripes transform into a single variant state continuously by unlimited growth of the period @xmath49 . between stripe and single variant equilibrium states as function of the reduced inverse stripe period @xmath35 and for different values of the reduced difference @xmath36 between widths of up and down domains .
the equilibrium energy of the multidomain states is lower than that of the homogeneous state . , width=226 ] near the transition into the single variant state @xmath50 , and , thus , the function @xmath51 in eq .
( [ energy2 ] ) can be expanded with respect to the small parameter @xmath52 , and the energy ( [ energy2 ] ) can be evaluated in terms of elementary functions @xmath53 -2hq\ , , \label{energy3}\ ] ] where @xmath54 } -\upsilon ( u ) $ ] , @xmath55 , and @xmath56 . minimizing @xmath40 from eq .
( [ energy3 ] ) with respect to @xmath57 and @xmath36 yields equations for equilibrium values of @xmath35 , @xmath36 and @xmath57 @xmath58 where @xmath59^{-1 } , \label{u}\ ] ] @xmath60 .
\label{hcrit}\end{aligned}\ ] ] eqs .
( [ sol ] ) express the equilibrium values of @xmath35 and @xmath36 in parametrized form as functions of the applied field @xmath61 and the plate thickness @xmath0 .
according to eqs .
( [ sol ] ) the parameter @xmath62 from eq .
( [ hcrit ] ) defines the transition field into the saturated state ( @xmath47 , @xmath48 ) .
note that for @xmath63 the parameter @xmath57 transforms into @xmath64 .
this means that the transtion into the saturated state takes place by an infinite expansion of the domains with the magnetization parallel to the field , ( @xmath65 ) , while domains with the antiparallel magnetization ( @xmath38 ) keep a finite size . the transition line @xmath62 plotted as function of @xmath66 in fig .
[ trans ] separates the regions of multivariant and single variant states .
the equation @xmath67 defines the _ critical thickness _ @xmath68 .
for @xmath69 the oblique domains do not exist , while straight domains ( theoretically ) exist for any thickness @xcite ( fig .
[ trans ] ) .
and the reduced magnetic field @xmath70 perpendicular to the plate for oblique ( solid ) and straight ( dashed ) stripes
. the oblique domains do not exist below the critical thickness @xmath68 .
inset shows the functions @xmath71 close to the critical thickness .
, width=283 ] typical solutions for domain sizes ( @xmath72 ) are presented in fig .
[ solutions ] . at low fields ,
the domain sizes change only slowly .
exponential growth of the size @xmath37 for the domains with magnetization in field direction sets in close to the saturation field .
the minority domain size @xmath38 gradually decreases in the increasing magnetic field but remains finite at the transition field .
( upper set of curves ) @xmath73 ( lower set of curves ) as functions of the applied magnetic field for different layer thicknesses .
inset : dependence of the size for the minority domain on layer thickness at the transition .
, width=264 ] .
inset shows the `` universal '' character of the magnetization curves for large domains .
, width=8 ] the equilibrium magnetization curves in fig
. [ curve ] display different behavior of the magnetization reversal in `` thin '' ( @xmath74 ) and `` thick '' ( @xmath75 ) plates .
the former are characterized by low values of the saturation field @xmath76 and steep magnetization curves . in accordance with the phase theory
the latter have linear magnetization curves @xmath77 in a broad range of the applied field . in various aspects ,
we find that the solutions for the oblique stripes have a _ universal _ character that may be useful for analysis of experimental data . the solutions for @xmath36 in eq .
( [ sol ] ) give a universal magnetization curve for systems with large domains @xmath78 ( inset in fig . [ curve ] ) .
the solutions for the equilibrium values of @xmath35 @xmath79}dt = l_0/l $ ] at zero field ( @xmath80 ) yield a specific dependence of zero - field period @xmath81 on the layer thickness ( fig .
[ solutions0 ] ) . as a function of the plate thickness @xmath82 at zero field ( solid line ) in comparison with a correponding line ( dashed ) for straight stripes .
inset shows @xmath83 functions for a thin layer of ni@xmath84mn@xmath85ga@xmath86 investigated in ref .
@xcite corresponding to the straight stripe structure fig .
[ fig1 ] , b. the dashed curve is plotted for the averaged characteristic length @xmath87 , the solid line incorporates effects connected with the indicated variation of @xmath88 with @xmath0 .
, width=8 ] the equation for @xmath35 corresponding to the minimum value of @xmath81 , @xmath89= \int_0 ^ 1 t \arctan{\left [ \sin pt/\sinh pt\right]}dt $ ] , includes no material parameters and has the solution @xmath90 .
this yields @xmath91 , @xmath92 and the ratio @xmath93 .
corresponding values for straight domains are @xmath94 , @xmath95 , @xmath96 , @xmath97 @xcite .
the minority domain size , @xmath98 , at the transition field has a similar minimum ( inset in fig .
[ solutions ] ) .
the equation for @xmath99 @xmath100 has the solution @xmath101 , and yields the following values of the parameters in this point : @xmath102 , @xmath103 .
the point @xmath104 marks the transition region between a functional dependence @xmath105 characteristic for thick plates ( @xmath106 ) ( _ kittel _ law ) to a exponential growth of the period with a decreasing plate thickness , @xmath107@xcite in thin layers ( @xmath108 ) .
this transitional region has been reached in thin polycrystalline films of ni@xmath84mn@xmath85ga@xmath86 with easy - axes dominantly at 45-degree from the layer normal direction @xcite .
inset in fig .
[ solutions0 ] shows the calculated functions @xmath109 with material parameter @xmath88 adjusted to the experimental data of ref .
the present theory enables rigorous calculations of equilibrium structures in thin ferromagnetic martensite plates with two variants .
it is clear that real magnetization processes in magnetic shape - memory processes will generally be hysteretic .
however , the equilibrium states could be reached , e.g. , free - standing films or thin free single - crystal platelets with very mobile twin - boundaries .
the analytical expressions for the energy of a stripe system eqs .
( [ energy1])(energyst ) are applicable also for non - equilibrium states .
we find that oblique stripe structures are possible only above a certain critical thickness , while straight stripe structures have been known to exist for arbitrary dimensions of layers with perpendicular magnetic anisotropy .
the theoretical method can be extended to treat twinned martensite plates with other angle between easy magnetization and layer normal direction .
the authors are grateful to j. mccord , y. w. lai , v. neu , and r. schfer for helpful discussions .
n.s.k . , a.n.b .
thank h. eschrig for hospitality at ifw dresden .
we gratefully acknowledge support by deutsche forschungsgmeinschaft ( spp 1239 project a8 ) .
y. murakami et al . , appl .
. lett . * 82 * , 3695 ( 2003 ) .
y.ge , o.heczko , o.sderberg , and v.k .
lindroos , j.appl.phys . * 96 * , 2159 ( 2004 ) .
chernenko et al . , acta materialia * 54 * , 5461 ( 2006 ) .
y.w . lai et al . , appl .
. lett . * 90 * , 192504 ( 2007 ) .
a. n. bogdanov , d. a. yablonskii , fiz .
tela * 22 * , 680 ( 1980 ) [ sov .
phys . solid state * 22 * , 399 ( 1980 ) ] . | the evolution of multivariant patterns in thin plates of magnetic shape memory materials with an applied magnetic field was studied theoretically .
a geometrical domain - model is considered composed of straight stripe - like martensite variants with constant internal magnetization ( high anisotropy limit ) and magnetic domain wall orientation fixed by the twin boundaries . through
integral transforms of the demagnetization energy , the micromagnetic energy is cast into a form convenient for direct numerical evaluation and analytical calculations .
the equilibrium geometrical parameters of multivariant patterns with straight and oblique twin boundaries have been derived as functions of the applied field and the material parameters of a plate .
it is shown that the oblique multivariant states exist only in plates with thicknesses @xmath0 larger than a certain critical value @xmath1 . in samples with @xmath2
a magnetic - field - driven transformation occurs directly between single variant states . |
magnetic reconnection is a ubiquitous process where magnetic fields undergo topological rearrangement and which converts the magnetic energy into heat and various forms of plasma energy .
some of the key issues related with magnetic reconnection are : 1 .
how does fast magnetic reconnection occur and what determines the reconnection rate ?
two - dimensional magnetohydrodynamic ( mhd ) simulations of _ coronal _ magnetic reconnection show that the reconnection rate depends strongly on the resistivity model @xcite . in the case of uniform resistivity ,
the reconnection becomes steady sweet parker type , while in the case of anomalous resistivity , the reconnection tends to non - steady petschek type .
apart from the anomalous resistivity , the hall effect also plays an important role in facilitating the fast reconnection .
@xcite . it is however not clear whether the hall effect and anomalous resistivity operate and interact simultaneously in an astrophysical environment .
the anomalous resistivities required to explain the fast reconnection rate are @xmath0 localized ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) . in this case
, how can one reconcile the enormous gap between macroscopic scales ( e.g. solar flares @xmath1 km ) and microscopic scales required to explain the reconnection rate ?
3 . how does magnetic reconnection occur in partially ionized , highly _
the solar chromosphere is partially ionized and fully collsional .
anomalous resistivity appears in a collisionless plasma , but , because of the incredibly small scales with which it is associated , it is quite unlikely that it will play a role in the solar chromosphere . the importance of partially ionized plasma on magnetic reconnection in solar chromosphere is realized in some of the recent studies @xcite .
the multi - fluid mhd simulations of solar chromosphere have shown faster reconnection rates , compared to the single - fluid sweet parker prediction , and during the process of decoupling the recombination as well as the plasma outflow play a role in determining the reconnection rate @xcite .
the 2.5d mhd simulations of magnetic reconnection including the ambipolar diffusion and radiative cooling in the partially ionized solar chromosphere have been performed @xcite .
it has been found that fast magnetic reconnection develops as a consequence of the plasmoid instability and there is no need to invoke anomalous resistivity . in this paper
, we develop a non - linear model of magnetic reconnection in partially ionized plasma . recent observation of multiple plasma ejections in chromospheric anemone jets by @xcite has shown a strongly time - dependent as well as the intermittent nature of magnetic reconnection in the solar chromosphere . in this paper , we argue that as the magnetic reconnection in a sweet parker current sheet with a large aspect ratio goes through various regimes ( strongly coupled , intermediate and weakly coupled or decoupled ) in a partially ionized plasma and the reconnection will be plasmoid - induced , fast and fractal - like .
the solar chromosphere is a favorable site for magnetic reconnection to occur , since the ohmic resistivity is greatest in that region especially at the location of the temperature - minimum @xcite . in a partially ionized plasma ,
the collisions between electron - ion , electron - neutral and ion - neutral takes place .
the electron - ion and electron - neutral collisions produce an ohmic diffusion @xcite .
in addition to the ohmic diffusion , the hall drift and the ambipolar diffusion also appears in a partially ionized plasma . in the case of solar chromosphere , the hall effect can often be ignored @xcite .
the role of ambipolar diffusion has been studied analytically in the context of magnetic reconnection .
it has been found that in a sweet parker geometry , the ambipolar diffusion increases the reconnection rate @xcite .
some of the observations of magnetic field in the solar chromosphere suggest that reconnection can occur at speeds @xmath2 0.1 @xmath3 @xcite .
recent high - resolution observations of jets in the solar chromosphere show a strongly time - dependent and intermittent nature of magnetic reconnection in the solar chromosphere .
it was for the first time that @xcite , based on the observations of multiple plasma ejections in the chromospheric anemone jets , suggested that if a time - dependent and bursty reconnection occurs 10 times longer than the alfvn time scale , it can then naturally explain the observed intermittency of one to two minutes in the chromospheric jets .
as a result of the ambipolar diffusion , the dissipation of currents is increased manifold compared to the standard ohmic dissipation .
the ambipolar diffusion can also contribute in the chromospheric heating and therefore the ambipolar diffusion should be included in the non - linear mhd simulations of chromospheric heating @xcite .
it is known that in a partially ionized plasma , a current sheet undergoes thinning and enters a regime where the neutrals decouple from ions @xcite
. the strength of coupling between ion and neutrals in a partially ionized plasma can affect the reconnection rate and during the process of decoupling the reconnection rate could increase .
the alfvn speed in a decoupled regime is defined with respect to the ion mass density alone @xcite .
the multi - fluid mhd simulations show that , as a result of current sheet thinning and elongation , a critical lundquist number ( @xmath4 ) is reached in a partially ionized plasma and the plasmoid formation starts @xcite . during the current sheet thinning a stage is reached where the neutrals and ions decouple , and reconnection rate faster than the single - fluid sweet parker prediction is observed in such multi - fluid simulations . the ion and neutral outflows
are well coupled in the multi - fluid mhd simulations in the sense that the difference between ion and neutral outflow is negligible compared to the magnitude of the ion outflow .
the breakup of sweet parker current sheets with large aspect ratios and formation of plasmoids as a result of the tearing mode instability appears to be a generic feature of the reconnecting systems @xcite .
there are number of theoretical studies on tearing mode instability that show the dependence of the growth rate of the instability on the ion - neutral collisions @xcite , the flows @xcite , the hall drift @xcite , and the two - fluid effects @xcite . in this work ,
we focus on the role of ion - neutral collisions on tearing mode instability and fractal - like reconnection .
the growth rate ( @xmath5 ) of tearing mode instability depends upon the extent of coupling and partial ionization in a partially ionized plasma as @xcite @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the growth rate of tearing mode instability in a plasma where the alfvn time is defined with respect to ions and the diffusion time includes ohmic diffusivity , @xmath8 is the neutral - ion collision frequency , and @xmath9 , @xmath10 are the neutral and ion mass densities respectively . for @xmath11 , there exists a strongly coupled regime in a partially ionized gas .
apart from the strongly coupled regime , there exists an intermediate regime and a decoupled regime @xcite .
while deriving the dispersion relation in a partially ionized plasma [ i.e. equation ( 1 ) ] , the effect of shear flows is not included . in general , we expect that various regimes would arise during the current sheet thinning in the presence of multi - fluid physics , ionization , recombination and heating processes . in what follows ,
we discuss the strongly coupled , intermediate and decoupled regimes in context of the nonlinear instability and fractal nature of the magnetic reconnection .
equation ( [ eq1 ] ) in a strongly coupled regime reduces to @xmath12 where @xmath13 . lets consider the tearing mode instability in a sweet parker current - sheet width that has a thickness and length of @xmath14 and @xmath15 respectively , and @xmath16 in the subscript refers to the @xmath16th - level tearing
so , the next level tearing will be @xmath17 . for @xmath18
, @xmath19 corresponds to the initial width of the current sheet .
such a sweet parker current sheet becomes unstable to the secondary tearing if @xmath20 where the timescale @xmath21 refers to the the growth time of the tearing mode instability occurring at maximum rate and it is given by @xmath22 where @xmath23 is the alfvn speed determined by the ion density and @xmath3 is the alfvn speed determined by the total density as @xmath24 and @xmath25 .
it was shown by @xcite that by introducing @xmath3 , the form of growth rate of tearing mode instability becomes similar to @xcite , hereafter fkr .
equation ( [ eq4 ] ) can be simplified further to @xmath26 where @xmath27 .
the works by @xcite can be referred for theory of the secondary tearing in the sweet
parker current sheet .
remember here that @xmath28 gives the time in which the perturbation is carried out of the current sheet by the reconnection flow .
so , we get @xmath29 if the eq.([eq6 ] ) is satisfied during the strongly coupled regime , the secondary tearing of the sweet parker current sheet occurs , leading to the current sheet thinning in the nonlinear stage of the tearing mode instability . during this stage ,
the thickness of the sweet
parker current sheet is determined by the most unstable wavelength ( @xmath30 ) of the secondary tearing mode instability , i.e. , @xmath31 where @xmath32 .
the critical wavelength for the tearing mode instability is an important deciding parameter here ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the instability starts when the sweet parker current sheet becomes longer than the critical wavelength of tearing mode instability , given here by eq .
( [ eq7 ] ) .
the current sheet will continue to thin and when the current sheet thickness reaches @xmath33 further tertiary tearing instability occurs .
such subsequent tearing will occur again at a smaller scale .
it follows from eqs .
( [ eq6 ] ) and ( [ eq7 ] ) that @xmath34 or @xmath35 where @xmath36 it should be noted here that for @xmath37 , the eqs .
( [ eq9 ] ) to ( [ eq11 ] ) reduces to that of @xcite .
the fractal tearing in strongly coupled regime continues till the current sheet thickness reaches the microscopic scale of interest . with a different @xmath38 i.e. @xmath39 the eq.(9 )
can be rewritten as @xmath40 in the strongly coupled regime , we can estimate how many secondary tearings are required to reach a length scale of @xmath41 . here
@xmath3 is the bulk alfvn speed given by @xmath42 and @xmath8 is the neutral - ion collision frequency .
the ionization fraction is calculated from a photospheric - chromospheric model given in @xcite . in the model given in @xcite ,
a hydrostatic equilibrium is assumed and the number densities in the solar atmosphere is determined by solving the equations of radiative transfer and statistical equilibrium ( without local thermodynamic equilibrium ) . the ionization fraction and the collision frequencies are plotted as a function of height in the solar atmosphere ( figs .
the effect of non - equilibrium hydrogen ionization on the dynamical structure of the solar atmosphere and hydrogen line formation is studied in the 2d simulations of @xcite .
the simulations of @xcite show that the chromospheric populations of the hydrogen ( with principle quantum number = 2 level ) are coupled to the ion populations and the ionization fraction is also affected by the shock propagation in the solar chromosphere . the minimum ionization fraction ( @xmath43 ) in fig .
1a turns out to be smaller than the non - equilibrium hydrogen ionization case ( ionization fraction @xmath44 ) .
refer to @xcite for the further details on the calculation of the collision frequencies in the solar atmosphere .
the magnetic field strength in the solar atmosphere is calculated using a power - law dependence @xmath45 , where @xmath46 and @xmath47 are the magnetic field and the total mass density at the solar surface respectively .
figure 1c shows the variation of magnetic field strength as a function of height and its dependence on the surface magnetic field and @xmath48 .
the neutral - ion collision frequency can be calculated from @xmath49 .
the ion - neutral collision frequency ( @xmath50 ) is given by @xmath51 ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
here @xmath52
cm s@xmath53 is the ion - neutral collision cross - section , @xmath54 and @xmath55 .
the length scale @xmath41 is plotted as a function of height in the solar atmosphere ( fig .
for @xmath3 = 10 kms@xmath56 and @xmath57 s@xmath56 , this length scale is about @xmath58 cm or @xmath59 .
taking the typical solar chromospheric values , @xmath60 cm , @xmath61 cm , @xmath62 @xmath63 s@xmath64 , we find @xmath65 and a @xmath2 0.05 .
just one tearing takes the current sheet to @xmath66 .
we will see in the later sections that since @xmath67 is of the order of @xmath68 , the plasma will shift from strong to decouple regime through the intermediate state .
the time scale of n - th tearing ( @xmath21 ) in the strongly coupled regime is @xmath69 now , if we introduce @xmath70 as @xmath71 and @xmath72 , and @xmath73 , then the scaling relations similar to @xcite for @xmath74 , @xmath21 and @xmath75 .
the time ( @xmath76 ) taken from @xmath77 to @xmath21 for the solar chromospheric conditions becomes @xmath78 for @xmath79 , there exists an intermediate regime . the growth rate ( eq . [ eq1 ] ) of tearing mode instability
reduces to @xmath80 where @xmath50 is the ion - neutral collision frequency .
the sweet
parker current sheet becomes unstable to secondary tearing if @xmath81 here we use rather restrictive condition because on the large scales the plasma can be coupled .
the growth time of the tearing instability at maximum rate ( @xmath21 ) and it is given by @xmath82 in the intermediate regime , the time for the reconnection flow to carry the perturbation out of the current sheet is @xmath83 , we get @xmath84 the most unstable wavelength of the secondary tearing instability is given by @xmath85 while deriving eq.(27 ) , @xmath86 is taken . as the current sheet thickness arrives at @xmath87 further tertiary tearing occurs .
it follows from eqs .
( 20 ) and ( 21 ) that @xmath88 or @xmath89 where @xmath90 and @xmath91 the eqs .
( 23 ) and ( 24 ) are new equations in terms of scalings and they are fundamentally different from @xcite .
the eq.(23 ) further leads to @xmath92 where @xmath93 for the current sheet thinning in the intermediate regime , we can estimate how many secondary tearings would be required to reach to a scale where the reconnection approaches a decoupling scale .
the length scale of the decoupling is given by @xmath94 substituting the typical numbers in the solar chromosphere , @xmath95 for @xmath23 = 300 kms@xmath56 and @xmath96 s@xmath56 , @xmath97 = 300 cm .
the alfvn velocity w.r.t .
ions could be 10 times higher and then the @xmath98 cm ( about 10@xmath99 ) .
if we use @xmath100 from eq.(24 ) and calculate @xmath101 then we get @xmath102 .
the variation of ( @xmath103 ) is plotted as a function of height in the solar atmosphere ( fig .
2b ) . taking the typical solar chromospheric values , @xmath60 cm , @xmath61 cm , @xmath62 @xmath63 s@xmath64 , we find @xmath65 and a @xmath2 0.09 . since @xmath14 should be smaller than the typical decoupling scale ( @xmath97 ) , we have @xmath104 or @xmath105 this inequality gives that in about four secondary tearings ( @xmath106 ) , the @xmath14 approaches 10@xmath99 .
the time scale of n - th tearing is @xmath107 where @xmath108 eqs .
( 33 ) and ( 34 ) lead to @xmath109 where @xmath110 , and @xmath111 and @xmath112 , we find @xmath113 thus we obtain @xmath114 for @xmath115 .
it follows from this equation that @xmath116 using eq .
( 38 ) , we can get the total time @xmath76 as @xmath117 now the @xmath76 can be calculated taking the typical solar chromospheric conditions and @xmath118 cm which is of the order of @xmath41 .
we get @xmath119 for @xmath60 cm , we get @xmath120 .
it is important to note that the time - scale @xmath70 appearing in eq .
( 40 ) is given by eq .
( 34 ) . at this stage
the current sheet width as reached to a stage where @xmath121 . in the decoupled regime ( @xmath122 ) , the eq . ( 1 ) reduces to @xmath123 .
the scaling relations derived by @xcite can be used by taking the alfvn speed w.r.t ions i.e. @xmath124 or @xmath125 where @xmath126 then eq . ( 41 ) leads to @xmath127 for the typical solar chromospheric values mentioned earlier , this gives @xmath128 @xmath2 0.15 .
after ten secondary tearings , the current sheet width reaches to a scale where @xmath129 . taking @xmath70 as @xmath130 and using the scaling relation for @xmath21 from @xcite , we get @xmath76 as @xmath131
+ figure [ fig3 ] shows the width of the current sheet normalised by the length of the current sheet at the n - th level of tearing for two different assumptions for the decoupling length scale using different models for the magnetic field and different heights in the solar atmosphere . for panels ( a ) and ( c ) we assume that the decoupling length scale is determined by @xmath132 and for panels ( b ) and
( d ) we take @xmath133 . the key difference between these two
is the second has smaller decoupling lengths , which makes it harder to tear down to the decoupling length scale . for the case shown in panels ( a ) and ( c )
, the decoupling length scale is sufficiently large that for both cases under study the decoupling length scale is reached .
this happens in under 5 tearings for all cases shown here .
however , it is only the case with the strongest magnetic field where the system reaches down to the kinetic scales . for the case shown in panels ( b ) and ( d ) , the decoupling length scale is much smaller so that in only the case with the strongest magnetic field where the decoupling length scale is reached .
this happens in on the 12th - tearing , after which the system approaches the kinetic scales . in all cases
it is very interesting to note that for the lower ion alfvn velocities ( implying either higher ionisation fraction or a lower magnetic field strength ) the fast reconnection regime is not achieved .
it is possible to determine if a system can reach the the kinetic scale purely by assessing the asymptotic limit of eq .
( [ eq44 ] ) , i.e. : @xmath134 therefore , to reach the kinetic scales found at @xmath135 , we require @xmath136 or a lundquist number of @xmath137 . for the resistivity and current sheet length used in the paper we require an ion alfvn velocity of @xmath138cms@xmath56 and @xmath62@xmath63s@xmath56 .
this naturally places a strong constraint on the particular chromospheric conditions where fast reconnection can occur , with the general implication that a strong magnetic field is a necessary requirement to achieve this .
it is also important to note the importance of the factor @xmath139 found in a ( see eq .
[ a_eq ] ) plays an important role in this limit , i.e. the factor is equal to @xmath140 . in other works ,
e.g. @xcite , this factor is taken as @xmath141 which would result in a factor of @xmath142 reduction in the limit given by equation [ limit ] .
in this analysis , we have assumed that the initial current sheet width is given by the sweet parker scaling . however , when we consider ion - neutral drift , it is possible that the current sheet will undergo thinning as a result of the neutrals leaving the current sheet before reconnection takes place .
in fact , this drift velocity in the current sheet was estimated to be approximately @xmath143 kms@xmath56 by @xcite .
there are a number of simple ways with which the new current sheet width can be estimated , and we provide a few of these here . at first
we try to find out the width of the current sheet at the point where the ambipolar diffusion balances the ohmic diffusion .
this is given by the following equation : @xmath144 for some distance from the centre of the current sheet ( @xmath145 ) .
@xcite showed that the magnetic field takes the distribution of @xmath146 , therefore we have : @xmath147 implying that @xmath148 this new current sheet width @xmath145 can be seen as analogous to the new current sheet width found for the kippenhahn - schlter prominence model by @xcite .
another possibility is that there exists a weak guide field component in the centre of the current sheet . in this case
the ambipolar diffusion squeezes the current sheet until this guide field becomes strong enough to support it , this was numerically investigated by @xcite . in this case we are looking for a balance between the external magnetic field ( @xmath149 ) and the guide field after it has undergone compression to @xmath150 . through flux conservation , the original guide field ( @xmath151 ) roughly relates to ( @xmath150 ) in the following way : @xmath152 where @xmath153 is the original width of the current sheet .
as we need the point were @xmath154 we get : @xmath155 this estimate can be seen as consistent with the thinning found in the numerical experiments as shown in figure 12 of @xcite .
it is interesting to note that the nature of the equation for the current sheet width at the n - th tearing ( eqs .
13 , 27 and 44 ) implies that we do not have to be overly concerned about the initial width of the current sheet from the point of view of whether or not we can have fast reconnection . as eq .
33 , in the limit of @xmath156 , becomes @xmath157 , which is independent of the initial current sheet width . to state this simply , reaching the decoupling length scale is independent of the initial current sheet width .
it does , however , play a role in determining how many levels of tearing are necessary to reach this width , and so may be important for speeding up the process of reaching the decoupling length scale .
the multi - fluid , two - dimensional mhd simulation in a harris type current sheet shows fast reconnection and plasmoid formation in the solar chromosphere @xcite .
it is noticed in the simulations that as a result of current sheet thinning and elongation , the plasmoid instability in the mhd simulation starts when the aspect ratio (= @xmath158 ) approaches 200 and the @xmath159 @xcite .
@xcite also noticed that for sufficiently long current sheets the tearing mode becomes unstable despite of the stabilizing effect of the inhomogeneous flow . in an intermediate regime in partially ionized plasma , the maximum growth rate of tearing mode instability is given by eq .
this relation is based upon the fkr - theory but gets modified due to the ion - neutral collisions .
the sweet
parker current sheet becomes unstable to tearing mode when @xmath160 from eq.(18 ) , we get @xmath161 the eq . ( 53 ) can be re - written as @xmath162 and that further reduces to @xmath163 where @xmath164 and @xmath165 is the aspect ratio of the sweet
parker current sheet given by @xmath166 .
the sweet
parker reconnection rate ( @xmath167 ) is given by @xmath168 .
this along with eq .
( 54 ) gives @xmath169 for the secondary tearing to occur the critical aspect ratio should be @xmath170 this gives @xmath171 if we consider @xmath172 cm , @xmath96 s@xmath56 , @xmath62 @xmath63 s@xmath64 . the current - sheet width used in eq .
( 57 ) is considered in the intermediate regime . since @xmath173 , the value of @xmath4 @xmath174 it should be noted that the @xmath4 obtained here
is similar to the value reported in multi - fluid mhd simulations .
there are even higher values of @xmath165 that are reported in the simulations of @xcite . while noticing that the @xmath4 depends upon the prandtl number as well @xcite it is important to mention here that if we take slightly different values of @xmath175 @xmath63 s@xmath64 and @xmath176 s@xmath56 and keep the current sheet width unchanged in eq .
( 57 ) , we get @xmath177 and @xmath178 .
the magnetic reconnection , as it proceeds from a coupled regime to a decoupled regime , undergoes rapid changes in the tearing mode time scale .
once the tearing mode instability develops , the plasmoids are formed .
the role of two - dimensional flows on the current sheet and plasmoid formation is studied by @xcite .
the maximum growth rate of tearing mode in @xcite scales with lundquist number as @xmath179 where @xmath180 , and the corresponding wave number scales as @xmath181 .
it should be noted here that the scalings based on fkr theory ( without including effect of shear flow ) on sweet
parker current sheet leads to the scaling laws that are consistent with @xcite , so a simple application of @xcite would provide correct answer to the problem .
the formation of plasmoids and its ejection from the long and thin current sheet lead to a nonlinear instability and fractal like reconnection . the current sheet thickness ( @xmath182 )
is shown in the n - th secondary tearing for the intermediate and the decoupled regimes .
the relevant time scales of fractal tearing are also calculated for an intermediate coupling and decoupled case in partially ionized plasma .
the tearing mode time scale ( @xmath70 ) could lie between 10 s - 150 s ( c.f . * ? ? ?
this gives @xmath183 between 6 s - 90 s in the decoupled regime .
it is clear that although the main energy release is explained by the fast reconnection , the plasmoid induced instability and fractal tearing can produce a very thin current sheet in a partially ionized plasma .
the shift in the regimes from strongly coupled to weakly coupled is one of the important component in the fast magnetic reconnection in partially ionized plasma . as a result of
the plasmoid mediated processes in a partially ionized plasma , there could be few more regimes that will bring the scale down to ion - skin depth or ion - larmor radius due to the hall or kinetic effects ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
as is clear from figure [ fig3 ] , it is not necessarily the case that reconnection occurring in a partially ionized plasma will reach the kinetic scale .
in fact , we have been able to estimate the required lundquist number ( based on the ion alfvn velocity ) for kinetic scales to be reached as @xmath184 , i.e. this is the @xmath185 required to allow the tearing instability to still be important down to kinetic scales . when it is possible to reach these small scales due to multiple tearings , the reconnection has to pass through three distinct regimes : the coupled regime , the intermediate regime and the decoupled regime .
as the decoupling of the alfvn waves happens before the decoupling of the instability , it can be expected that the reconnection dynamics undergoes multiple transitions .
it is worth noting that there is another scale that we have not considered here , the hall lengthscale , which is related to the lengthscale at which ions become demagnetised .
we plan to investigate how the inclusion of hall physics influences the cascade we describe in a future work .
the passage through reconnection regimes will be characterised by the development of the decoupling of the neutrals from the reconnection dynamics , first by decoupling from the plasma then the plasma decoupling from the neutrals .
this does not mean that that these neutrals are never to feel the ions again , on the contrary the ions will recouple to the neutrals and even then later the neutrals will recouple to the plasma as the reconnected plasma is ejected from the current sheet and starts an inverse cascade , partially through plasmoid merger , to connect to the global reconnection dynamics .
this coupling process will allow for very short periods of time , protons and electrons to reach very high temperatures ( @xmath186 ) before they collisionally lose their heat to the neutrals .
it is possible that high frequency observations of chromospheric reconnection would reveal the presence of high energy thermal emission ( potentially in @xmath5-rays ) at the reconnection site . in this paper , we have presented a mechanism for reaching kinetic scales through reconnection in a partially ionized plasma . the interesting problem that we have addressed here is important to the basic physics of magnetic reconnection in the solar chromosphere , and could potentially be applied in other partially ionized , astrophysical plasmas .
however , there is still one question that we must address : is significant flux reconnected at small scales ? this is a point of great interest as if only a small amount of flux is being reconnected quickly , it is unlikely that the global reconnection rate would greatly differ . to discuss this
, we use the results from two studies performed on the plasmoid instability in a fully ionized plasma .
@xcite gives the distribution of the frequency of plasmoids with a given flux as @xmath187 and @xcite gives @xmath188 .
for the former , this implies that the total flux reconnected at any scale should be the same as any other scale , the latter implies that the reconnected flux is dominated by small scales with a @xmath189 distribution .
therefore , this leads us to believe that significant flux is reconnected at small scales , allowing the cascade to collisionless reconnection that our model describes to present a significant increase in the reconnection rate .
ah is supported by his stfc ernest rutherford fellowship grant number st / l00397x/1 , and for part of this work by the grant - in - aid for young scientists ( b , 25800108 ) .
part of this work was performed during a visit by kaps to kyoto university , during this visit kaps was supported by the grant - in - aid for young scientists ( b , 25800108 ) .
the authors would also like to thank the anonymous referee for their helpful and insightful comments .
arber t.d . ,
botha , g.j.j . , & brady , c.s .
2009 , , 705 , 1183 baalrud , s. d. , bhattacharjee , a. , huang , y .- m . , & germaschewski , k. 2011 , physics of plasmas , 18 , 092108 biskamp , d. 1986 , physics of fluids , 29 , 1520 biskamp , d. 1992 , nonlinear magnetohydrodynamics , cambridge monographs on plasma physics , cambridge univ .
press brandenburg , a. & zweibel , e. g. 1994 , , 431 , 689 cassak , p. a. , shay , m. a. & drake , j. f. 2005 , , 95 , 235002 cassak , p.a . ,
drake , j.f . & shay , m.a .
2007 , physics of plasmas , 14 , 054502 cowling , t.g . 1956 , , 116 , 114 cox , a.n .
2000 , allen s astrophysical quantities , fourth edition , springer , new york daughton , w. , roytershteyn , v. , albright , b. j. , et al .
2009 , physical review letters , 103 , 065004 dere , k.p .
1996 , , 472 , 864 drake , j. f. , shay , m. a. , & swisdak , m. 2008 , physics of plasmas , 15 , 042306 furth , h.p .
, killeen , j. & rosenbluth , m.n .
1963 , physics of fluids , 6 , 459 hillier , a. , shibata , k. , & isobe , h. 2010 , , 62 , 1231 huang , y .- m . ,
& bhattacharjee , a. 2012 , , 109 , 265002 khodachenko , m. l. , arber , t. d. , rucker , h. o. , & hanslmeier , a. 2004 , , 422 , 1073 khomenko , e. & collados , m. 2012 , , 747 , 87 krishan , v. 2009 , , 400 , 2200 leake , j. e. , lukin , v. s. , linton , m. g. , & meier , e. t. 2012 , , 760 , 109 leake , j. e. , lukin , v. s. & linton , m. g. 2013 , physics of plasmas , 20 , 061202 leenaarts , j. , carlsson , m. , hansteen , v. , & rutten , r. j. 2007 , , 473 , 625 loureiro , n. f. , schekochihin , a. a. & cowley , s. c. 2007 , physics of plasmas , 14 , 100703 loureiro , n. f. , samtaney , r. , schekochihin , a. a. , & uzdensky , d. a. 2012 , physics of plasmas , 19 , 042303 loureiro , n. f. , schekochihin , a. a. , & uzdensky , d. a. 2013 , , 87 , 013102 malyshkin , l.m . & zweibel , e.g. 2011 , , 739 , 72 mirnov , v.v . , hegna , c.c . & prager , s.c .
2004 , physics of plasmas , 11 , 4468 nishizuka , n. , nakamura , t. , kawate , t. , singh , k. a. p. , & shibata , k. 2011 , , 731 , 43 ni , l. , yang , z & wang , h. 2007 , , 312 , 139 ni , l. , kliem , b. , lin , j. , & wu , n. 2015 , , 799 , 79 ofman , l. , chen , x. l. , morrison , p. j. , & steinolfson , r. s. 1991 , physics of fluids b , 3 , 1364 ieroset , m. et al .
2001 , nature , 412 , 414 piddington , j.h . 1954 , , 114 , 651 ren , y. , yamada , m. , ji , h. , et al .
2008 , physics of plasmas , 15 , 082113 samtaney , r. , loureiro , n. f. , uzdensky , d. a. , schekochihin , a. a. , & cowley , s. c. 2009 , physical review letters , 103 , 105004 shepherd , l.s . & cassak , p.a .
2010 , , 105 , 015004 shibata , k. & tanuma , s. 2001 , ep&s , 53 , 473 singh , k. a. p. & krishan , v. 2010 , new astronomy , 15 , 119 singh , k. a. p. & subramanian , p. 2007
, , 243 , 163 singh , k. a. p. , shibata , k. , nishizuka , n. , & isobe , h. 2011 , physics of plasmas , 18 , 111210 singh , k. a. p. , isobe , h. , nishida , k. , & shibata , k. 2012 , , 760 , 28 sonnerup , b.u.o .
& sakai , j .- i .
1981 , eos trans .
union , 62 , 353 sturrock , p. a. 1994 , plasma physics , an introduction to the theory of astrophysical , geophysical and laboratory plasmas , isbn 0521448107 , cambridge university press , 1994 . , sturrock , p.a .
1999 , , 521 , 451 tanuma , s. , yokoyama , t. , kudoh , t. , & shibata , k. 2001 , , 551 , 312 uzdensky , d. a. , loureiro , n. f. , & schekochihin , a. a. 2010 , , 105 , 235002 vishniac , e. t. & lazarian , a. 1999 , , 511 , 193 yokoyama , t. & shibata , k. 1994 , , 436 , l197 zweibel , e.g. 1989 , , 340 , 550 zweibel , e. g. , lawrence , e. , yoo , j. , et al . 2011 , physics of plasmas , 18 , 111211 | the recent observations of @xcite have shown multiple plasma ejections and the intermittent nature of magnetic reconnection in the solar chromosphere , highlighting the need for fast reconnection to occur in highly collisional plasma . however ,
the physical process through which fast magnetic reconnection occurs in partially ionized plasma , like the solar chromosphere , is still poorly understood .
it has been shown that for sufficiently high magnetic reynolds numbers , sweet
parker current sheets can become unstable leading to tearing mode instability and plasmoid formation , but when dealing with a partially ionized plasma the strength of coupling between the ions and neutrals plays a fundamental role in determining the dynamics of the system .
we propose that as the reconnecting current sheet thins and the tearing instability develops , plasmoid formation passes through strongly , intermediately , and weakly coupled ( or decoupled ) regimes , with the time scale for the tearing mode instability depending on the frictional coupling between ions and neutrals .
we present calculations for the relevant time scales for fractal tearing in all three regimes .
we show that as a result of the tearing mode instability and the subsequent non - linear instability due to the plasmoid - dominated reconnection , the sweet parker current sheet tends to have a fractal - like structure , and when the chromospheric magnetic field is sufficiently strong the tearing instability can reach down to kinetic scales , which are hypothesized to be necessary for fast reconnection . |
in january 2016 , a crocheter on the social networking site ravelry @xcite posted images of a coin purse she had made as a christmas present , and started a discussion thread asking readers of a particular forum if they could help her identify the name of its 3d shape ( hereafter termed _ the shape _ ) .
the purse , shown in figure [ purse ] , had been constructed following a pattern @xcite by making a flat oval , and attaching a zipper to its edge in such a way that when the zipper closed , the purse was not folded over exactly in half onto itself ( flat ) , but sat up , enclosing an intriguingly - shaped volume .
the crocheter had read the german version @xcite of an ian stewart column on the sphericon @xcite , and believed that the shape might be sort - of - but - not - quite a sphericon . however , the paper templates for making one s own sphericons that she had seen @xcite have curved edges only , which her oval did not . in fact _
oval _ is rather loose a term , and broadly means _
egg - like_. the purse in question had been constructed from a _ stadium _ , the 2d shape made from a rectangle and two semi - circles , as shown in figure [ stad ] .
over the next few weeks , various ravelry members , including the author of this paper , joined in on - line discussion and brain - storming about the shape .
more than 500 of ravelry s ( admittedly 6 million ) members read at least part of the thread ( before , as threads do , it wandered off to shapes more generally ) .
patterns for objects with similar construction were pointed out @xcite . as well as the sphericon family ,
d - forms @xcite were mentioned .
so , was the shape one of these , and if so , which was it ?
this seemingly simple question , prompted by a hand - made christmas gift , has triggered this survey and investigation of sphericons and d - forms .
the main conclulsions of this investigation are to be found in section [ concl ] .
the sphericon has been described as ` [ a ] solid ... not as widely known as it should be ' @xcite , and conversations with mathematical colleagues , and presentations about this work , have shown this to be so .
thus , an introduction to the history , properties and generalisations of sphericons , and of d - forms , make up the next two sections of the paper .
the classification of the shape is then clear .
the paper concludes with some more general results , summarised in table [ classify ] , and includes templates for the surfaces required to make several particular generalised sphericons by d - forming , thereby stitching ( literally ) a connection between the sphericon family and d - forms .
\(a ) at ( 0,0 ) ; ( b ) at ( 0,2 * 1.5 cm ) ; ( c ) at ( 4.71cm,0 ) ; ( d ) at ( 4.71cm,2 * 1.5 cm ) ; ( a ) node[above ] @xmath1 ( c ) ; ( c ) arc [ start angle=-90 , end angle=90 , radius=1.5 cm ] ( b ) arc [ start angle=90 , end angle=270 , radius=1.5 cm ] ; ( a )
node[left ] @xmath2 ( b ) ; ( c )
node[right , pos=0.75 ] @xmath3 ( d ) ; at ( @xmath4 ) ;
the sphericon , at least as a mathematical object , came to public attention in stewart s mathematical recreations column @xcite in 1999 .
colin roberts , a joiner who had enjoyed geometry at school , sent stewart his creation , after seeing him on television . the column was written shortly after this .
roberts had first made a sphericon from mahogany some thirty years earlier in 1967 @xcite .
independently , in the early 1980s , an israeli designer david hirsch submitted a patent application for ` meander motion ' toys constructed on the same principles @xcite .
roberts motivation , however , lay in producing a one - surfaced object , with no hole ( unlike the well - known mbius strip ) .
the sphericon can be constructed from a pair of identical cones of apex angle 90 degrees joined at their bases ( a _ bicone _ ) . cut the bicone in half through the two apices so as to reveal its square cross - section , twist one half through 90 degrees , and then ` glue ' the square faces together again , as shown in figure [ cut ] .
especially when made of grained wood , it is a beautiful object .
it has a single , sinuous surface @xcite , and two disjoint curved edges , set at right angles ; see figure [ sphericon ] .
the surface has the property that if one traces a finger along the middle of it , one comes back to the starting point @xcite .
( rather inaccurately from the point of view of mathematical terminology , this has been called a ` continuous ' surface @xcite ; we will avoid that term . ) the two curved edges each end in vertices ( four in total ) . the sphericon rolls in an amusing manner , what stewart terms ` a controlled wiggle ' @xcite , the meander motion of hirsch s toys @xcite .
a _ sphere _ will roll in a straight line , and a _ cone _ rolls in a circle . the sphericon changes direction as the parts of its surface come into contact with the surface it is rolling on , but on average the motion is in a line .
hence the name _
sphericon_. sphericons are one of the intriguing solids that can be assembled , and their rolling behaviour predicted , at momath in new york @xcite .
the sphericon featured next in the monthly feature column of the american mathematical society @xcite .
the sphericon was used as an interesting examplar of how edges and apices have to be treated carefully , in order to calculate the total gaussian curvature of the figure to be the expected @xmath5 .
phillips introduced the _
hexasphericon _ and found connections between such higher order sphericons ( to be introduced below ) and his work on mazes @xcite .
some particular closed space curves were found to lie on the sphericon surface @xcite , and an explicit hybrid function form ( in cartesian coordinates ) is given .
perhaps not surprisingly , given its origins , wood - turners began experimenting with the sphericon .
a special join , called a paper join , enables the cutting - open process to be done without damage .
the bicone can be replaced by any solid of revolution with appropriate cross - section symmetry .
some makers introduced different profiles ( producing what they termed _ femispheres _ ) or non - convex cross - sections ( the _ streptohedrons _ ) @xcite .
other makers @xcite generated some of the convex geometric objects that are classified as the series of @xmath6-icons @xcite .
sphericons have been made of ceramic , glass , plastic ( 3d printing ) and as metal sculptures , as well as of wood .
think of the bicone as the solid of revolution of a square about its diagonal ( as in the image ( a ) of figure [ cut ] ) .
now replace the square by any other @xmath6-vertex regular convex polygon , and use one of the symmetry axes to generate a solid of revolution @xcite .
when @xmath6 is odd , this axis will run through one vertex and one straight edge of the polygon .
when @xmath6 is even , the polygonal cross - section can be rotated about an axis through two opposite vertices or through the midpoints of two opposing edges . for @xmath7 ,
different ` @xmath6-icons ' can be produced by more than one rotation ( in the cut - rotate - reglue process ) , due to the rotational symmetries of the cross - section ; these may be completely different or may come in right- and left - hand pairs .
a full classification of the family of solids requires one to specify @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the rotation ( in radians ) between cutting and regluing , termed the twist @xcite .
two special cases will now be considered : * the dual sphericon * rotating a square about an axis through the midpoints of opposite edges results in a cylinder of equal height and diameter . applying the cutting and rotating process ,
an object with _ two surfaces _ and _ one closed edge _ is produced , as illustrated in figure [ dual ] .
this object is dual to the original sphericon in a particular sense ; the sphericon has _ two disjoint edges _ ending in vertices and _ one surface _ that can be traced as described above .
springett @xcite described this object , which wood - turners term _ side - cut _ , as being ` rather unexciting ' . in the cutting process
, four semicircles are produced , which are then joined smoothly to the sides of the cylinder .
the paper template for this object consists of not one stadium , but two .
the dual sphericon is a possible two - sided die . indeed , such dice and various @xmath10-icons
are available from various 3d printing artists .
\(a ) at ( 60pt,7.5pt ) ; ( b ) at ( 108.5pt,40pt ) ; ( c1 ) at ( 64pt,63.75pt ) ; ( c2 ) at ( 50pt,63.25pt ) ; ( d ) at ( 9pt,100pt ) ; ( e ) at ( 65pt,143pt ) ; ( f ) at ( 108.5pt,130pt ) ; ( g ) at ( 65pt,110pt ) ; ( h ) at ( 9pt,50pt ) ; ( f ) ( b ) ; ( d ) ( h ) ; ( a ) .. controls ( @xmath11 ) and ( @xmath12 ) .. ( b ) ; ( b ) .. controls ( @xmath13 ) and ( @xmath14 ) .. ( c1 ) .. controls ( @xmath15 ) and ( @xmath16 ) .. ( c2 ) .. controls ( @xmath17 ) and ( @xmath18 ) .. ( d ) ; ( d ) .. controls ( @xmath19 ) and ( @xmath20 ) .. ( e ) .. controls ( @xmath21 ) and ( @xmath22 ) .. ( f ) .. controls ( @xmath23 ) and ( @xmath24 ) .. ( g ) .. controls ( @xmath25 ) and ( @xmath26 ) .. ( h ) .. controls ( @xmath27 ) and ( @xmath28 ) .. ( a ) ; * the trisphericon * a _ single _ cone may be created as the solid of revolution of an equilateral triangle , the @xmath29 case .
it can be cut to produce a triangular cross - section .
when one half is rotated through 120 degrees and the form reglued , a solid with one curved surface , one -shaped edge and 2 vertices is produced ; see figure [ trisph ] . in the sense described above
, this object is self - dual .
following a similar argument to stewart @xcite we can establish what the paper template for this object is ( figure [ temp ] ) .
this object has also been called the ` kleines sphericon ' @xcite , the ` conicon ' @xcite or the ` equilaticon ' @xcite . while ` one - sided dice ' based on the mbius band are available to purchase , trisphericons are even better candidates for this title , as they have the desirable feature of having no hole .
\(a ) at ( 0,0 ) ; ( b ) at ( 0,2 * 1.5 cm ) ; ( c ) at ( 2 * 1.5cm,2 * 1.5 cm ) ; ( d ) at ( 2 * 1.5cm,4 * 1.5 cm ) ; ( a )
node[left ] @xmath2 ( b ) ; ( b )
node[above ] @xmath2 ( c ) ; ( c )
node[right ] @xmath2 ( d ) ; ( a ) ( c ) ; ( b ) ( d ) ; ( d ) arc [ start angle=90 , end angle=180 , radius=2 * 1.5 cm ] arc [ start angle=90 , end angle=270 , radius=1.5 cm ] arc [ start angle=270 , end angle=360 , radius=2 * 1.5 cm ] arc [ start angle=-90 , end angle=90 , radius=1.5 cm ] ; ( @xmath30 ) + + ( 0.2 * 1.5cm,0 ) + + ( 0,0.2 * 1.5 cm ) ; ( @xmath31 ) + + ( 0,0.2 * 1.5 cm ) + + ( 0.2 * 1.5cm,0 ) ; more generally , the @xmath6-icons can always be considered as formed by cutting , twisting and reglueing a solid made of @xmath32 sections of cones ( possibly including a cone with apex at infinity , a cylinder ) .
the @xmath6-icons for odd @xmath6 are self - dual and the @xmath6-icons for even @xmath6 have dual forms , generated by the two different symmetry axes @xcite . when it is pertinent to specify the twist @xmath9 used in construction , the notation @xmath0-icon will be used .
stadia may be present in the dual @xmath6-icons , as we can see from the four semicircles created in the cutting process .
new features arise as @xmath6 increases , such as surfaces enclosing other surfaces @xcite think of a velodrome , with the sloped surface around the centre . it is worthwhile , at this point , if you have resisted the temptation so far , to make a sphericon from paper or light card using templates such as those of pppe @xcite .
( indeed , the crocheter mentioned in the introduction had done exactly this with her family , which is why she was familiar with them . ) of course , you will not have a solid sphericon ; you will have the surface and will manipulate and tape it to enclose a volume shaped like the solids .
the d - form entered mathematics in a similar way to the sphericon but this time from design .
they are 3d objects formed when the boundaries of two 2d shapes of equal perimeter length are joined .
the british designer and inventor tony wills says they came to him in a dream , as a way of expanding his working vocabulary of forms @xcite .
wills has used d - forms in street architecture ( benches , bins , bollards ) @xcite .
the constituent 2d shapes need to be made of a material that does not stretch or shear ; a typical cushion is not a d - form !
two circles can not produce a ( non - trivial ) d - form , but two identical offset ellipses do , as seen in figure [ ms ] .
the cross - section of the object produced using two ellipses with their major axes set at right angles looks like the letter capital .
( d is for dream , for the shape of this cross - section and also for developable surfaces @xcite . )
as the shapes are joined , they inform each other as to how their joined boundary should curve in space .
wills observed that choosing different points on the boundaries of the 2d shapes to start the seam between them changes the resulting d - form @xcite .
he investigated joining the boundary of a circle to that of a square ( i.e. not a smooth boundary ) producing an object he termed a squaricle , and also used non - convex shapes .
baseball construction @xcite is an example of d - forming that long pre - dates wills ; two flat pieces of leather have been designed ( by trial and error initially ) to be joined in such a way that their seam lies on a sphere .
the initial 3d form is not spherical the leather is subsequently stretched over a hard spherical core .
d - forms are piece - wise _ developable surfaces _ , in that they can be cut open and each piece flattened , without creasing , to be planar @xcite , although they have been described thus far as being formed by the reverse process .
developable surfaces have the advantage for designers , artists and builders that they can be constructed from rolled sheet metal ; even ships and airplanes are made this way @xcite .
d - forms have been observed to have much in common with various sculptural works @xcite .
predicting in advance what the d - form will look like , and hence what 2d shapes to use , is not easy , though computational methods ( based on meshes ) have been developed @xcite .
a recent paper @xcite describes software used ( in the education of architecture students ) to match the perimeter length of different planar shapes , scaling them to be isoperimetric , in order that they can be used to create d - forms . as with the sphericon , making a paper model , right now , will help you understand how d - forms evolve in front of you and how beautiful they can be .
you can use a template @xcite or you can easily cut your own using a double layer of paper .
d - forms were introduced to the mathematical world by wills and sharp before their publications @xcite .
questions @xcite regarding their creasing , and whether or not a d - form is always the convex hull of a space curve , were posed in 2001 and addressed in 2007 , with the boundaries of the 2d shapes restricted to being convex @xcite .
demaine and orourke also introduced the concept of a _ pita - form _
a pita - form is defined to be the 3d shape obtained by glueing ( or zipping ) the boundary of a _ single _ convex 2d shape to itself .
demaine returned to the open questions surrounding d - forms with a different co - author in 2010 @xcite .
they established that both d - forms and pita - forms are the convex hull of their seams , that d - forms are always crease - free away from the seam , but that a pita - form may have at most one crease , between the two endpoints of its seam .
( of course , ` crease ' has to be defined a bit more carefully ( in terms of differentiability properties ) than by simply looking at a paper model , as this initially led to the proposition that pita - forms also might never have creases @xcite . )
also introduced were _
seam forms _ , a natural generalization to more flat ( convex ) pieces than two .
( it may be pertinent to mention one more concept introduced by demaine and collaborators , that of _ zipper unfolding _ of a polyhedron @xcite , to prevent confusion . in this case , the surface being zipped is deliberately folded , marking it into the polygons that constitute the faces of the polyhedron . )
as mentioned in the introduction , both sphericons and d - forms were suggested as describing the shape ( figure [ purse ] ) , formed from a crocheted stadium , lined so that there is some rigidity to the surface and no shearing or stretching , before the zipper is added .
the astute reader will by now have realised that , simply , it is a pita - form , made from a stadium . this author has experimented with making various pita - forms from crocheted stadia , varying the ratio between the rectangle s height and the radius of the semi - circles , and with different starting points for the seam ( figure [ pita ] ) .
tips for making your own from fibre are given in appendix a. but does the shape belong on the sphericon family tree also ? as should have become clear from section [ solid ] , any @xmath6-icon s surface is subject to symmetry , side length and angle constraints prescribed by its construction from a regular 3d object .
what if one steps back from these origins , and hence from these constraints ?
could not the stadium ( figure [ stad ] ) be regarded as the outcome of relaxing conditions which led to figure [ temp ] ? just as the two shapes in figure [ hex ] are hexagons , one regular and one irregular , the shape , with its one surface and one -shaped seam between two distinct endpoints , could be termed an ` irregular trisphericon ' , to coin a phrase .
iin 0, ... ,5 ( i ) at ( i60:1.5 ) ; iin 0, ... ,5 let 1=int(mod(i+1,6 ) ) in ( i ) ( 1 ) ; ( 0,0 ) + +
( 35:1.5 ) + + ( 65:1 ) + + ( 120:1 ) + + ( 200:2 ) + + ( 250:0.75 ) cycle ; to put this around the other way , the [ regular ] trisphericon is a pita - form , formed from a particular 2d shape ( figure [ temp ] ) which is _ not _ convex .
moving on further from the original question about the shape that motivated this investigation , what of other relationships between the sphericon family , and pita- and d - forms ?
a kinship is foreshadowed in the works of the turkish artist ilhan koman .
consider the piece called _ rolling lady _ which dates from 1983 @xcite .
it consists of two bicones ( four developable surfaces ) interlocked at right angles in such a way as to roll . at its elegant heart
lie two perpendicular circles , just as two perpendicular edges , circle sectors , are a striking feature of the sphericon .
( in this article , the connection of the sphericon to the rollers and wobblers of @xcite , and to the oloid , has not been explored , being somewhat tangential to the identification question under consideration . )
let s look at the shape that did not much interest springett , the dual sphericon ( figure [ dual ] ) .
again , the astute reader has probably pre - empted the statement that this is precisely a d - form obtained from two stadia , with @xmath33 , and attached to one another symmetrically .
this inspired the crocheted piece _ d - based _ shown in figure [ ball ] .
d - forms made using stadia seem not to have been mentioned or visualised prior to 2007 @xcite .
authors moved directly from dismissing the circle to trying out the ellipse .
perhaps this springs from the fact that the cone is probably the most well - known developable surface @xcite , so that conic sections seemed a natural constituent for d - forms ( despite the fact that there is no formula for the perimeter of an ellipse , and matching perimeter length is the name of the game in making d - forms @xcite ) .
of course , a stadium has a perimeter that can be calculated as precisely as one might wish : @xmath34 .
two identical stadia can always be joined to form a d - form , but this will only be a dual sphericon if the midpoints of the semicircles on one stadium are joined to the midpoints of the straight sides of the other , and if @xmath35 . when @xmath36 , and the attachment is midpoint - to - midpoint , the elongated object is stable on one of its four semi - circular faces .
such a d - form makes an excellent four - sided die .
in fact , it is arguably nicer than the one based on the tetrahedron , which has a point , not a face , in the air ! when @xmath37 , and the attachment is symmetric , the object is stable only when it rests on the centre - line of one or other of its two curved surfaces .
if tilted slightly from this position , it will rock back .
hollow mock - ups of these two d - forms can be seen in figure [ stable ] .
a perfectly constructed dual sphericon has stability properties that transition between these two cases . tilting the dual sphericon
when it is sitting on the centre - line of one of its two curved surfaces does not raise or lower the centre of gravity , so that this is a position of neutral equilibrium ; it rolls , until it sits flat on one of its two semicircular faces .
it is interesting to classify which @xmath0-icons , over and above the trisphericon and the dual sphericon , are d - forms and pita - forms ( in the sense of permitting the convexity condition on the constituent surfaces to be relaxed ) .
the information needed to perform this classification is available , though using unconventional mathematical nomenclature , and at least one error , in early studies at un - maintained web sites @xcite .
it is collected and corrected in table [ classify ] . in interpreting this table ,
the values of @xmath38 are restricted to @xmath39 for @xmath6 odd , and to @xmath40 for @xmath6 even , limiting the forms to those which are unique ( up to chirality ) .
[ classify ] an @xmath0-icon will be a pita - form if it has one surface and one edge that runs between two distinct endpoints ; it will be a @xmath41-form if it has two surfaces and one closed edge . from this we can conclude : * when @xmath6 is odd , and co - prime to @xmath38 , the @xmath0-icon is a generalised pita - form .
( this includes the trisphericon . the first values for which this does not apply are @xmath42 . ) * when @xmath6 is even , and the @xmath0-icon has been generated using the midpoint - to - midpoint symmetry axis , it will be a d - form , if @xmath43 and @xmath38 are co - prime .
( this includes the dual sphericon .
it also , for example , includes all 5 possible @xmath44 forms . ) by way of illustration , figure [ hexasphericon ] shows a wooden version of the dual hexasphericon ( @xmath45 , @xmath46 ) ; the two semicircular ends that are visible are from the same surface .
when a regular hexagon ( side length @xmath3 ) is rotated to form a solid of revolution ( about the midpoints of a pair of opposite straight edges ) , its vertices trace out three circles .
two of these have radius @xmath3 , and the other has radius @xmath2 , the distance between opposite vertices in a regular hexagon , by elementary geometry ( see figure [ hex ] ) .
each of these circles is cut in half , relocated in space and then joined to half of another circle , when the cut - rotate - reglue process is carried out .
apart from the circular ends , the other parts of the dual hexasphericon s surface are pieces of cones , and each is formed ( developed ) from a quarter of an annulus .
thus each of the two surfaces that form the dual hexasphericon by d - forming is of the shape shown in figure [ hextemp ] .
( 0,0 ) arc [ start angle=0 , end angle = 90 , radius=2 ] ; ( 0,0 ) arc [ start angle=0 , end angle=-180 , radius=0.5 ] ; ( -1,0 ) arc [ start angle = 0 , end angle = 90 , radius = 1 ] ; ( -2,1 ) arc [ start angle = -90 , end angle = -180 , radius = 2 ] ; ( -2,2 ) arc [ start angle = -90 , end angle = -180 , radius = 1 ] ; ( -3,3 ) arc [ start angle = 0 , end angle = 180 , radius = 0.5 ] ; ( -1.5,0.5 ) ( -1.29,0.707 ) ; ( 0,0 ) ( -1,0 ) ; ( -3,3 ) ( -4,3 ) ; ( -2,1 ) ( -2,2 ) ; for the octasphericon ( @xmath47 , @xmath46 ) a similar geometric argument shows that each of its constituent surfaces is made up of a rectangle , two semi - circles and two sectors ( opening angle @xmath48 ) from an annulus .
the inner arc of the annulus sector has the same length as the semi - circles ( @xmath49 ) , and the length of the outer arc and of the rectangle side is @xmath50 .
the template is shown in figure [ dualoct ] .
( 3.8,0 ) ; ( 0,1 )
( 3.8,1 ) ; ( 3.8,1 ) arc [ start angle=90 , end angle = -37.3 , radius = 1.71 ] ; ( 3.8,0 ) arc [ start angle=90 , end angle = -37.3 , radius = 0.71 ] ; ( 0,0 ) arc [ start angle = -90 , end angle = -217.3 , radius = 1.71 ] ; ( 0,1 ) arc [ start angle = -90 , end angle= -217.3 , radius = 0.71 ] ; ( -0.56 , 2.14 ) arc [ start angle = -37.3 , end angle = 142.7 , radius = 0.5 ] ; ( 4.36 , -1.14 ) arc [ start angle = -217.3 , end angle = -37.3 , radius = 0.5 ] ; for @xmath51 , there are two possible @xmath52-icons .
their two constituent surfaces are each bounded by 2 semicircles , 2 arcs of length @xmath49 and @xmath53 , and four of length @xmath54 .
the order in which they connect to each other is different for @xmath46 and @xmath55 . in the static representation of words and diagrams ,
it is not easy to appreciate the features of these forms .
as well as making some of their own , readers are encouraged to enjoy some remarkable on - line animations of them ( for numerous higher values of @xmath6 and @xmath38 ) @xcite .
as far as can be judged from the published literature , these instructions for creating the ` piece - wise circular ' surfaces of the dual @xmath0-icons by d - forming have not been explicitly stated previously , though presentations on sphericons and d - forms have been made at the same conference @xcite ! this may be because of the very different geography of their birthplaces , in the realm of solids and of surfaces respectively .
it seems to have taken crochet fibre to link them .
i wish to acknowledge the contributors to the thread _ how would you call this shape ? _ in the woolly thoughts forum of ravelry , in particular annagret , bevbh , irishlacenet , madeleines , soyloquesoy and woolhelmina , for their inspiration of this piece , and for pooling their collective wisdom about fibre arts and mathematics .
thanks also to jane pitkethly for creating four of the line drawings and to the fibre artists who permitted photos of their work to be used .
particular thanks to the estate of the late steve mathias for giving permission for photos of his wood - turning to be used , and to craig kaplan for figure 3 .
the perceptive comments of editor and associate editor have also improved this paper significantly , and i thank them . 12 , ravelry website ; available at http://www.ravelry.com/about .
t. akgn , a. koman and e. akleman , _ developable sculptural forms of ilhan koman _ , in _ bridges london : mathematics , music , art , architecture , culture _ ,
london , uk , 48 august 2006 , the bridges organization , pp .
343 - 350 .
available at http://archive.bridgesmathart.org/2006/bridges2006-343.html . l.c .
bardos , _ d - forms _ website ; available at http://www.cutoutfoldup.com/1602-d-forms.php . cherry berry crochet , _ coins purse or sewing necessaire crochet pattern _ ; available at + http://www.ravelry.com/patterns/library/coins-purse-or-sewing-necessaire-crochet-pattern . c. belden , _ sphericon _ ; + available at http://www.hypersurf.com/ charlie2/turning / streptohedrons / sphericon / sphericon.html p. bourke , _ dforms _ website ; available at http://paulbourke.net / geometry / dform/. f. brown , _ zippy strip _ ; available at http://www.ravelry.com/patterns/library/zippy-strip . e.d .
demaine , m.l .
demaine , a. lubiw , a. sharlo and j.l .
shallit , _ zipper unfoldings of polyhedral complexes _ in _ proceedings of the 22nd canadian conference on computational geometry ( cccg 2010 ) _ , winnipeg , manitoba , canada , 9 - 11 august 2010 , pp .
219 - 222 ; + images available at http://gallery.bridgesmathart.org/exhibitions/2011-bridges-conference/alubiw e.d .
demaine and j. orourke , _ geometric folding algorithms _ , cambridge university press , cambridge , 2007 .
demaine and g. n. price , _ generalized d - forms have no spurious creases _ , discrete comput geom 43 ( 2010 ) , pp . 179 - 186 . c. engelhardt , and c. ucke , _ zwei - scheiben - roller _ , mathematisch - naturwissenschaftlicher unterricht 48 ( 1995 ) , pp .
259 - 263 .
m. fessenden , _ please play with your math : new musuem opens in new york city _ , scientific american , december 19 , 2012 .
available at : http://blogs.scientificamerican.com / observations / please - play - with - your - math - new - museum - opens - in - new - york - city/. d. henderson and d. taimina , _ crocheting the hyperbolic plane _ , the mathematical intelligencer 23 ( 2001 ) , pp .
. gnen , e. akleman and v. srinivasan , _ modeling d - forms _ , in _ bridges donostia : mathematics , music , art , architecture , culture _ , san sebastian , spain , 24 27 july 2007 , the bridges organization , pp .
209 - 216 .
available at http://archive.bridgesmathart.org/2007/bridges2007-209.html . d.h .
hirsch , _ patent no .
59720 : a device for generating a meander motion _
( 1980 ) ; available at https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/file:patent59720-claims.pdf and + https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/file:patent59720-drawings.pdf .
r. kaufman , _ the @xmath6-icon study _ website ; available at http://www.interocitors.com/polyhedra/ c. kimberling and p. j. c. moses , _ closed space curves made from circles on polyhedra _ , journal for geometry and graphics 15 ( 2011 ) , pp .
i. koman , _ rolling lady _ ( 1983 ) .
image available at http://www.koman.org/work/work_1983rollinglady.html r.r .
orduo , n .
winard , s. bierwagen , d .
shell , n. kegar , a. borhani and e. akleman , _ a mathematical approach to obtain isoperimetric shapes for d - form construction _ , in _ proceedings of bridges 2016 : mathematics , music , art , architecture , education , culture _ , jyvskyl , finland , 913 august 2016 , the bridges organization , pp . 277 - 284 .
available at http://archive.bridgesmathart.org/2016/bridges2016-277.pdf h.m .
osinga and b. krauskopf , _ crocheting the lorentz manifold _ , the mathematical intelligencer 26 , ( 2004 ) , pp .
a. phillips , _ the differential geometry of the sphericon _
, feature column of the american mathematical society , october 1999 .
available at http://www.ams.org/samplings/feature-column/fcarc-sphericon1 a. phillips , _ meander mazes on polysphericons _ , in _ the visual mind ii _ , m. emmer ( ed . ) , mit press , cambridge , ma , 2005 and http://www.ams.org/samplings/feature-column/fcarc-octo-cretan . c. pppe and i. stewart ,
_ der kegel mit dem dreh _ , spektrum der wissenschaft 7 ( 2000 ) , pp .
114 - 116 .
+ available at http://www.spektrum.de/magazin/der-kegel-mit-dem-dreh/826587 + and http://www.wissenschaft-online.de/spektrum/themen/sphericon-text.html h. pottmann and j. wallner , _ computational line geometry _
, springer - verlag , berlin , 2001 .
p. roberts , _ the sphericon _ ; + available at http://web.archive.org/web/20141219072120/http://www.pjroberts.com/sphericon/ j. sharp , _ d - forms and developable surfaces _ , in _ renaissance banff : mathematics , music , art , culture _ , banff , alberta , canada , 31 july3 august 2005 , the bridges organization , pp .
available at http://archive.bridgesmathart.org/2005/bridges2005-121.html .
j. sharp , _ d - forms : surprising new 3-d forms from flat curved shapes _ ,
tarquin publications , hertfordshire , uk , 2009 .
d. springett , _ streptohedrons ( twisted polygons ) _ , in _ bridges london : mathematics , music , art , architecture , culture _ ,
london , uk , 48 august 2006 , the bridges organization , pp . 285292 .
available at http://archive.bridgesmathart.org/2006/bridges2006-285.html .
d. springett , _ woodturning full circle _ , sussex , uk , guild of master craftsmen publications , 2008 .
website ; available at http://www.mathias.org / steve / sphericons/. i. stewart , _ cone with a twist _
281(1999 ) , pp.116 - 117 . r.b .
thompson , _ designing a baseball cover _ , coll .
j. 29 ( 1998 ) , pp.48 - 61 .
weisstein , _ sphericon _ , mathworld a wolfram web resource . + available at http://mathworld.wolfram.com/sphericon.html .
t. wills , _ d - forms : 3d forms from two 2d sheets _ , in _ bridges london : mathematics , music , art , architecture , culture _ ,
london , uk , 48 august 2006 , the bridges organization , pp .
503 - 510 .
t. wills , _ d - form street furniture _ website ; available at http://www.wills - watson.co.uk / portfolio - item / d - form - street - furniture/.
to crochet a stadium is not as daunting a task as making the lorentz manifold @xcite or even a hyperbolic plane @xcite . to make a dual sphericon , you will need to crochet two identical pieces . to make a pita - form , you need only one .
you will need yarn , a crochet hook , a sewing needle and scissors ( only to cut threads , not to cut the surface ! ) .
any ( free or purchased ) non - lacy pattern for an ` oval ' will suffice .
this could be a pattern for a rug or table mat . `
oval ' is used in craft forums ( and daily conversation ) for just about anything which is not symmetric enough to be a circle and not angular enough to be a rectangle , and even for 3d forms , so check to see that it is actually going to produce a stadium ( figure [ stad ] ) .
if you are familiar with both knitting and crochet , you will realise that to produce a stadium , crochet is easiest .
this is related to the reason that crochet is more natural for producing hyperbolic surfaces @xcite ; because one works with a stitch at a time on the hook , and can control stitch height , different types of shapes can be made in crochet from those made with knitting .
i have chosen to make my models so far using plarn ( plastic yarn , made by recycling shopping bags ) which produces quite a stiff fabric even for treble ( uk ) stitches .
using acrylic yarn and a smaller - than - usual hook to produce a dense fabric in double ( uk ) crochet would also work @xcite . if you decide to stuff your models , use just enough stuffing that they do not collapse , but not so much as to distort them .
my models are quite small , but larger models will probably need stuffing .
another method to get around the inherent stretchiness and floppiness of most knitted or crocheted fabric , and the shaping disadvantages of knitting , is to use felted knitted fabric , cut to shape , as seen in figure [ ms ] .
i closed my models by overstitching , pulling only tight enough to close the seam , again to avoid distortion . for
the dual sphericon , begin by joining the midpoint of a semicircle on one stadium to the midpoint of the straight side of the other , and then join stitch by stitch , until the two pieces are joined . for the pita - form
, you can pick any starting point ( apart from the exact midpoints ) for your seam .
it s fun to make several , using different starting points . to control the size of the rectangular part of your stadium , vary the length of the starting chain .
the diameter of the semi - circular parts depends on the stitch height ( double or treble ) and the number of rounds completed ; you will need to make a gauge swatch if you want stadia of precise measurements .
it might be fun to use @xmath56 interesting pita - forms are obtained for @xmath58 such as those created using the pattern _ zippy strip _ @xcite . in this case , the stadium continues to wrap around itself , with the seam forming a helix in space ( rather than just an ) .
again , the starting point of the seam will determine the final outcome .
some makers describe a flattish purse ( figure [ zippy ] ) , while others obtain something more ` pyramidal ' . in making one myself
, i observed that remarkable feature of d - forms , that they continue to develop right up until they are closed .
this development is captured in figure [ contort ] . | sphericons and d - forms are 3d objects created and described by artists , which have separately received attention in the mathematical literature in the last 15 or so years .
the attempt to classify a seamed , crocheted form geometrically led to the observation , which appears not to have been previously made explicit , that these objects are related .
general results concerning @xmath0-icons and seam- , d- and pita - forms are given .
instructions to crochet such forms are provided in the appendix .
sphericon , d - form , pita - form , developable surface , crochet 51m04 ; 97m80 |
the two @xmath3 meson factories babar and belle , which have already started operation , open an exciting new era in studying physics of @xmath3 mesons .
both factories have already presented thrilling results on cp violation @xcite .
the physics program of the b factories contain two main directions : detailed study of cp violation in @xmath4 decays and precise measurement of rare flavor changing neutral current ( fcnc ) processes .
it is well known that fcnc processes are very sensitive to the new physics beyond the standard model ( sm ) .
so , main goal of the investigations undergoing at @xmath3 factories is to find inconsistencies within the sm , in particular find indications for new physics in the flavor and cp violating sector @xcite .
new physics effects can appear in rare @xmath3 meson decays in two different ways , either through new contributions to the wilson coefficients existing in the sm or through the new structures in the effective hamiltonian which are absent in the sm .
rare @xmath3 meson decays induced by @xmath5 transition has been extensively studied in framework of the sm and its various extensions @xcite@xcite .
one of the efficient ways in establishing new physics beyond the sm is the measurement of the lepton polarization @xcite@xcite .
all previous studies for the lepton polarization have been limited to sm and its minimal extensions , except the works @xcite . in @xcite
the analysis of the @xmath6 lepton polarization for the inclusive @xmath7 decay was presented in a model independent way and in @xcite lepton polarizations are investigated using the most general model independent hamiltonian for the @xmath8 decay . the aim of this work is studying lepton polarizations in the exclusive @xmath9 decay using the general form of the effective hamiltonian including all possible form of interactions . here
we will study @xmath10 and @xmath6 leptonic modes because of the following two reasons .
firstly , the electron polarization is hard to measure experimentally , and secondly , it is well known that in the sm the normal @xmath11 and transversal @xmath12 polarizations are both proportional to the lepton mass and hence their measurements might be possible especially in the @xmath13 channel .
the work is organized as follows . in section 2 , using a general form of four fermi interaction we derive the general expressions for the longitudinal , transversal and normal polarizations of leptons . in section 3
we investigate the sensitivity of the above mentioned polarizations to the new wilson coefficients . at the end of this section
we also present our conclusion .
in this section we compute the lepton polarization asymmetries , using the most general , model independent form of the effective hamiltonian .
the effective hamiltonian for the @xmath14 transition in terms of twelve model independent four fermi interactions can be written in the following form : [ matel ] h_eff & = & v_tsv_tb^\ { c_sl & & + c_ll^tot |s_l _
b_l |_l ^_l + c_lr^tot |s_l _
b_l |_r ^_r + c_rl |s_r _
b_r |_l ^_l + & & + c_rr |s_r _ b_r |_r ^_r + c_lrlr |s_l b_r |_l _ r + c_rllr |s_r b_l |_l _
r + & & + c_lrrl |s_l b_r |_r _
l + c_rlrl |s_r b_l |_r _
l+ c_t |s _ b |^ + & & + i c_te^ |s _ b | _ } , where the chiral projection operators @xmath15 and @xmath16 in ( [ matel ] ) are defined as l = , r = , and @xmath17 are the coefficients of the four fermi interactions and @xmath18 is the momentum transfer .
note that among twelve wilson coefficients several already exist in the sm .
the coefficients @xmath19 and @xmath20 correspond to @xmath21 and @xmath22 in the sm , respectively .
the next four terms in eq .
( [ matel ] ) are the vector type interactions with coefficients @xmath23 , @xmath24 , @xmath25 and @xmath26 .
two of these vector interactions containing @xmath23 and @xmath24 do exist in the sm as well in the form @xmath27 and @xmath28 .
therefore we can say that @xmath23 and @xmath24 describe the sum of the contributions from sm and the new physics and they can be written as c_ll^tot & = & c_9^eff - c_10 + c_ll , + c_lr^tot & = & c_9^eff + c_10 + c_lr , the terms with coefficients @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 and @xmath32 describe the scalar type interactions .
the last two terms with the coefficients @xmath33 and @xmath34 , obviously , describe the tensor type interactions .
exclusive @xmath2 decay is described by the matrix element of effective hamiltonian over @xmath3 and @xmath35 meson states , which can be parametrized in terms of form factors .
it follows from eq .
( [ matel ] ) that in order to calculate the amplitude of the @xmath2 decay , the following matrix elements are needed [ roll ] & & k|s _ b b , + & & k |s i _ q^b b , + & & k |s b b , + & & k |s _ b b .
these matrix elements are defined as follows : [ ilk ] k(p_k ) |s _ b b(p_b ) = f_+ + f_0 q _ , with @xmath36 , [ ucc ]
k(p_k ) |s _ b b(p_b ) = -i , the matrix elements @xmath37 and @xmath38 can be calculated by contracting both sides of eqs .
( [ ilk ] ) and ( [ ucc ] ) with @xmath39 , and using equation of motion we get [ uc ] k(p_k ) |s b b(p_b ) & = & f_0 , + [ iki ] k(p_k ) |s i _ q^b
b(p_b ) & = & . taking into account eqs .
( [ matel][uc ] ) , the matrix element of the @xmath2 decay can be written as [ had ] m(bk ^+^- ) & = & v_tb v_ts^\ { |^ + & + & |^_5 + |q + |_5 n + & + & 4 |^ ( - i g ) + & + & 4 |^ _ h } .
the auxiliary functions above are defined as [ as ] a & = & ( c_ll^tot + c_lr^tot + c_rl + c_rr ) f_+ + 2 ( c_br+c_sl ) , + b & = & ( c_ll^tot + c_lr^tot+ c_rl + c_rr ) f_- - 2 ( c_br+c_sl ) ( m_b^2-m_k^2 ) , + c & = & ( c_lr^tot + c_rr - c_ll^tot - c_rl ) f_+ , + d & = & ( c_lr^tot + c_rr - c_ll^tot - c_rl ) f_- , + q & = & f_0 ( c_lrlr + c_rllr+c_lrrl + c_rlrl ) , + n & = & f_0 ( c_lrlr + c_rllr - c_lrrl - c_rlrl ) , + g & = & f_t , + h & = & f_t , where f_- = ( f_0-f_+ ) .
it follows immediately from eq .
( [ had ] ) that the difference from the sm is due to the last four terms only , namely , scalar and tensor type interactions .
( [ had ] ) we next calculate the final lepton polarizations for the @xmath2 decay . for this purpose
we define the following orthogonal unit vectors , @xmath40 in the rest frame of @xmath0 and @xmath41 in the rest frame of @xmath1 , for the polarization of the leptons along the longitudinal ( @xmath15 ) , transversal ( @xmath42 ) and normal ( @xmath43 ) directions : [ pol ] s_l^- & & ( 0,_l^- ) = 0 , , + s_n^- & & ( 0,_n^- ) = 0 , , + s_t^- & & ( 0,_t^- ) = 0 , _
n^- _ l^- , + s_l^+ & & ( 0,_l^+ ) = 0 , , + s_n^+ & & ( 0,_n^+ ) = 0 , , + s_t^+ & & ( 0,_t^+ ) = 0 , _ n^+ _ l^+ , where @xmath44 and @xmath45 are the three momenta of @xmath46 and @xmath35 meson in the center of mass ( cm ) frame of the @xmath47 system , respectively . the longitudinal unit vectors @xmath48 and @xmath49
are boosted to cm frame of @xmath47 by lorentz transformation , [ bs ] s^-_l , cm & = & , , + s^+_l , cm & = & , - , while vectors @xmath50 and @xmath51 are not changed by boost . the differential decay rate of the @xmath2 decay for any spin direction @xmath52 of the @xmath53 , where @xmath52 is the unit vector in the @xmath53 rest frame , can be written as [ ddr ] = _ 0 , where @xmath54 corresponds to the unpolarized differential decay rate , and @xmath55 , @xmath11 and @xmath12 represent the longitudinal , normal and transversal polarizations , respectively .
the expression for the unpolarized differential decay rate in eq .
( [ ddr ] ) is [ unp ] _ 0 = v_tb v_ts^^2 ^1/2(1,r , s ) v , where @xmath56 , @xmath57 , @xmath58 and @xmath59 is the lepton velocity .
the explicit form of @xmath60 is [ del ] & = & -128 m_b^4 m_(a g^ ) + 32 m_b^2 m_^2 ( 1-r ) ( c d^ ) + 16 m_b^2 m_(1-r ) ( c n^ ) + & + & 16 m_b^2 m_^2 s d ^2 + 4 m_b^2 s n ^2 + 16 m_b^2 m_s ( d n^ ) + m_b^6 s v^2 h ^2 + & + & 4 m_b^2 sv^2 q ^2 + m_b^4 s(3-v^2)a ^2 + m_b^6s ( 3-v^2)g ^2 + & + & m_b^4 s \{2 - ( 1-v^2)}c ^2 .
the polarizations @xmath55 , @xmath11 and @xmath12 are defined as : p_i^()(q^2 ) = , where @xmath61 represents the charged lepton @xmath53 polarization asymmetry for @xmath62 , i.e. , @xmath55 and @xmath12 are the longitudinal and transversal asymmetries in the decay plane , respectively , and @xmath11 is the normal component to both of them . with respect to the direction of the lepton polarization ,
@xmath55 and @xmath12 are @xmath63odd , @xmath42even , while @xmath11 is @xmath63even , @xmath42odd and @xmath64odd .
calculations lead to the following results for the longitudinal , transversal and normal polarization of the @xmath53 : [ plm ] + & & - 4 m_(1-r ) ( c q^ ) + m_b^4 s ( g h^ ) - 4 m_s ( d q^ ) - 2 ( n q^ ) } , + + [ ptm ] + & & 4 m _ ( a d^ ) 64 m_^2 ( d g^ ) 2 ( a n^ ) 32 m _ ( g n^ ) + 2 v^2 ( c q^ ) } , + + [ pnm ] . from these expressions we can make the following conclusion . contributions coming from the sm to @xmath65 and @xmath66 are exactly the same but with the opposite sign
. however contributions coming from new interactions to @xmath65 and @xmath66 can have same or opposite sign .
this can be useful in looking for new physics . from eq .
( [ ptm ] ) we observe that at zero lepton mass limit , contributions coming from scalar interactions survive .
similarly terms coming from scalar and tensor interactions survive in the massless lepton limit for @xmath67
. therefore , experimentally measured value of @xmath68 for the @xmath69 can give a very promising hint in looking new physics beyond sm .
about normal polarization we can comment as follows .
one can see from eq .
( [ pnm ] ) the difference between @xmath70 and @xmath71 ( for which sm predicts @xmath72 ) is again due to the existence of the scalar and tensor interactions .
incidentally , w e should note that a similar situation takes place for the lepton polarizations in the @xmath8 decay @xcite .
it follows from this discussion that a measurement of the lepton polarization of each lepton and combined analysis of lepton and antilepton polarizations @xmath73 , @xmath74 and @xmath75 can give very useful information to constraint or to discover new physics beyond sm , which are all zero in the sm in the limit of massless leptons .
therefore if in experiments nonzero value of the above mentioned combined lepton asymmetries were observed , this can be considered as an discovery of the new physics beyond sm .
first of all we introduce the values of the input parameters used in the present work : @xmath76 , @xmath77 , @xmath78 , @xmath79 , @xmath80 .
it is well known that the wilson coefficient @xmath81 receives short as well as long distance contributions coming from the real @xmath82 intermediate states , i.e. , with the @xmath83 family , but in this work we consider only short distance contributions .
experimental data on @xmath84 fixes only the modulo of @xmath85 . for this reason throughout our analysis we have considered both possibilities , i.e. , @xmath86 , where the upper sign corresponds to the sm prediction . for the values of the form factors , we have used the results of @xcite ( see also @xcite ) .
the @xmath87 dependence of the form factors can be represented in terms of three parameters as [ fit ] f(s ) = f(0 ) exp(c_1 s + c_2 s^2 + c_3 s^3 ) , where the values of parameters @xmath88 , @xmath89 , @xmath90 and @xmath91 for the @xmath92 decay are listed in table 1 .
@xmath93 from the expressions of the lepton polarizations we see that they all depend on @xmath87 and the new wilson coefficients
. it may be experimentally difficult to study the dependence of the the polarizations of each lepton on both quantities .
therefore we eliminate the dependence of the lepton polarizations on @xmath87 , by performing integration over @xmath87 in the allowed kinematical region , so that the lepton polarizations are averaged .
the averaged lepton polarizations are defined as [ av ] p_i = .
we present our results in a series figures . note that in all figures we presented the value of @xmath85 is chosen to have its sm value , i.e. , @xmath94
( 1 ) and ( 2 ) depict the dependence of the averaged longitudinal polarization @xmath95 of @xmath0 and the combination @xmath96 on new wilson coefficients , at @xmath94 for @xmath69 decay . from these figures
we see that @xmath95 is sensitive to the existence of all new interactions except to vector and scalar interactions with coefficients @xmath97 , @xmath25 and @xmath30 , @xmath29 , respectively , while the combined average @xmath96 is sensitive to scalar type interactions only .
it is interesting that contributions from @xmath30 , @xmath29 ( @xmath31 , @xmath32 ) to the combined asymmetry is always negative ( positive )
. therefore determination of the sign of @xmath98 can be useful in discriminating the type of the interaction . from fig .
( 2 ) we see that @xmath99 at @xmath100 , which confirms the sm result as expected . for the other choice of @xmath85 , i.e. , @xmath101 the situation is similar to the previous case , but the magnitude of @xmath96 is smaller . figs .
( 3 ) and ( 4 ) are the same as figs.(1 ) and ( 2 ) but for the @xmath102 decay . in this case
the difference of the dependence of the longitudinal polarization @xmath95 on new wilson coefficients from the muon case is as follows : in the muon case @xmath103 is negative for all values of the new wilson coefficients while for the tau case @xmath95 can receive both values , for example for @xmath104 , @xmath95 is positive , and for @xmath105 , @xmath95 is negative .
it is obvious from fig .
( 4 ) that if the values of the new wilson coefficients @xmath31 , @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath32 and @xmath34 are negative ( positive ) , @xmath96 is negative ( positive ) .
absolutely similar situation takes place for @xmath106 . for these reasons determination of the sign and of course magnitude of @xmath107 can give promising information about new physics .
( 5 ) and ( 6 ) the dependence of the average transversal polarization @xmath108 and the combination @xmath109 on the new wilson coefficients are presented for the @xmath69 decay , respectively .
we observe from fig .
( 5 ) that the average transversal polarization is strongly dependent only on @xmath31 and @xmath32 and quite weakly to remaining wilson coefficients .
it is also interesting to note that for the negative ( positive ) values of these scalar coefficients @xmath108 is negative ( positive ) . for the @xmath109 case
, there appears strong dependence on all four scalar interactions with coefficients @xmath110 .
the behavior of this combined average transversal polarization is identical for the coefficients @xmath111 and @xmath112 in pairs , so that four lines responsible for these interactions appear only to be two .
moreover @xmath109 is negative ( positive ) for the negative ( positive ) values of the new wilson coefficients @xmath31 and @xmath32 and positive ( negative ) for the coefficients @xmath29 and @xmath30 .
remembering that in sm , in massless lepton case @xmath113 and @xmath114 . therefore determination of the signs and magnitudes of @xmath108 and @xmath109 can give quite a useful information about the existence of new physics .
for the choice of @xmath101 , apart from the minor differences in their magnitudes , the behaviors of @xmath108 and @xmath109 are similar as in the previous case . as is obvious from figs .
( 7 ) and ( 8) , @xmath108 and @xmath115 show stronger dependence only on @xmath33 for the @xmath102 decay . again
@xmath108 and @xmath109 change sign at @xmath116 .
as has already been noted , determination of the sign and magnitude of @xmath108 and @xmath109 are useful hints in looking for new physics .
note that for simplicity all new wilson coefficients in this work are assumed to be real . under this condition @xmath117 and @xmath118 have non - vanishing values coming from the imaginary part of sm , i.e. , from @xmath81 . from figs .
( 9 ) and ( 10 ) we see that @xmath117 and @xmath118 are strongly dependent on all scalar type interactions for the @xmath69 decay .
similar behavior takes place for the @xmath102 decay as well .
the change in sign and magnitude of both @xmath117 and @xmath118 that are observed in these figures is an indication of the fact that an experimental verification of them can give unambiguous information about new physics . in the present work
we analyze the possibility of pinning down new physics beyond sm by studying lepton polarizations only .
it follows from eq .
( [ unp ] ) that the branching ratio of the @xmath2 decay depends also on the new wilson coefficients and hence we expect that it can give information about new physics . in this connection there follows the question : can one establish new physics by studying the lepton polarizations only ?
in other words , are there regions of the new wilson coefficients @xmath17 in which the value of the branching ratio coincides with that of the sm prediction , but the lepton polarizations would not ? in order to answer this question , we present in figs .
( 11)(14 ) the dependence of the branching ratio on the average and combined average polarizations of the leptons .
in these figures the value of the branching ratio ranges between the values @xmath119 .
these figures depict that there indeed exist such regions of @xmath17 in which the value of the branching ratio does agree with the sm result , while the lepton polarizations differ from the sm prediction .
it follows from the pair of figs .
( 3 ) , ( 11 ) ; ( 7 ) , ( 13 ) and ( 8) , ( 14 ) , that if @xmath33 lies in the region @xmath120 , the above mentioned condition , i.e. , mismatch of the polarizations in the standard model and the new physics , is fulfilled . on the other hand one can immediately see from fig .
( 12 ) that such a region for the combined average longitudinal lepton polarization does not exist and hence it is not suitable in search of new physics
. note that in all figures intersection point of all curves correspond to the sm case .
this analysis allows us to conclude that there exists certain regions of new wilson coefficients for which study of the lepton polarization itself can give promising information about new physics . finally , a few words about the detectibilty of the lepton polarization asymmetries at @xmath3 factories or future hadron colliders , are in order . as an estimation ,
we choose the averaged values of the longitudinal polarization of muon and transversal and normal polarizations of the @xmath6 lepton , which are approximately close to the sm prediction , i.e. , @xmath121 , @xmath122 and @xmath123 .
experimentally , to measure an asymmetry @xmath124 of a decay with the branching ratio @xmath3 at the @xmath125 level , the required number of events is given by the formula @xmath126 .
it follows from this expression that to observe the lepton polarizations @xmath127 , @xmath128 and @xmath129 in @xmath102 decay at @xmath130 level , the expected number of events are @xmath131 , respectively . on the other hand ,
the number of @xmath132 pairs that is expected to be produced at @xmath3 factories is about @xmath133 .
a comparison of these numbers allows us to conclude that while measurement of the normal polarization of the @xmath6 lepton is impossible , measurements of the longitudinal polarization of muon and transversal polarization of @xmath6 lepton could be accessible at @xmath3 factories .
99 b. aubert _
et al . _ , babar collaboration , preprint : hep ex/0102030 ( 2001 ) ; + a. abashian _
et al . _ ,
belle collaboration , preprint : hep ex/0102018 ( 2001 ) .
y. grossman , preprint : hep - ph/0012216 ( 2000 ) .
t. goto , y. okada , y. shimizu and m. tanaka , _ phys .
_ * d55 * ( 1997 ) 4273 ; + t. goto , y. okada , y. shimizu and m. tanaka , _ phys .
rev . _ * d58*(1998 ) 094006 .
j. l. hewett and j. d. wells , _ phys .
_ * d55 * ( 1997 ) 5549 .
y. grossman , z. ligeti and e. nardi , _ phys .
_ * d55 * ( 1997 ) 2768 .
t. g. rizzo , _ phys .
* d58 * ( 1998 ) 114014 .
e. lunghi , a. masiero , i. scimemi and l. silvestini , _ nucl .
phys . _ * b568 * ( 2000 ) 120 .
hou , r. s. willey and a. soni , _ phys .
* 58 * ( 1987 ) 1608 .
n. g. deshpande and j. trampetic , _ phys .
* 60 * ( 1988 ) 2583 . c. s. lim , t. morozumi and a. i. sanda , _ phys .
_ * b218 * ( 1989 ) 343 .
b. grinstein , m. j. savage and m. b. wise , _ nucl .
phys . _ * b319 * ( 1989 ) 271 .
w. jaus and d. wyler , _ phys .
* d41 * ( 1990 ) 3405 .
p. j. odonnell and h. k. tung , _ phys .
* d43 * ( 1991 ) 2067 .
a. ali , t. mannel and t. morozumi , _ phys .
* b273 * ( 1991 ) 505 . c. greub , a. ioannissian and d. wyler , _ phys .
lett . _ * b346 * ( 1995 ) 145 .
g. burdman , _ phys .
rev . _ * d52 * ( 1995 ) 6400 .
a. j. buras and m. mnz , _ phys .
rev . _ * d52 * ( 1995 ) 186 .
n. g. deshpande , x. -g .
he and j. trampetic , _ phys .
lett . _ * b367 * ( 1996 ) 362 .
t. m. aliev , m. savci , _ phys .
_ * b452 * ( 1999 ) 318 ; + t. m. aliev , a. zpineci , h. koru and m. savci , _ phys .
_ * b410 * ( 1997 ) 216 ; + t. m. aliev , c. s. kim and y. g. kim , _ phys .
rev . _ * d62 * ( 2000 ) 014026 .
y. g. kim , p. ko and j. s. lee , _ nucl .
phys . _ * b544 * ( 1999 ) 64 .
j. l. hewett , _ phys .
_ * d53 * ( 1996 ) 4964 .
f. krger and l. m. sehgal , _ phys .
* b380 * ( 1996 ) 199 .
s. fukae , c. s. kim and t. yoshikawa , _ phys .
_ * d61 * ( 2000 ) 074015 .
t. m. aliev , m. savci , _ phys .
_ * b481 * ( 2000 ) 275 .
shu yan , chao shang huang , liao wei , shou hua zhu , + _ phys .
_ * d62 * ( 2000 ) 094023 . t. m. aliev , k. akmak , m. savci , preprint : hep ph/0009133 ( 2000 ) .
a. ali , p. ball , l. t. handoko and g. hiller , _ phys .
rev . _ * d61 * ( 2000 ) 074024 .
t. m. aliev , a. zpineci , m. savci , h. koru , _ phys .
lett . _ * b400 * ( 1997 ) 194 . v. m. belyaev , a. khodjamirian , r. rckl , _ z. phys . _
* c60 * ( 1993 ) 349 .
p. ball , _ jhep _ * 9809 * ( 1998 ) 005 .
* fig . ( 1 ) * the dependence of the average longitudinal polarization asymmetry @xmath95 of muon on the new wilson coefficients .
+ + * fig .
( 2 ) * the dependence of the combined average longitudinal polarization asymmetry @xmath107 of @xmath0 and @xmath1 on the new wilson coefficients for the @xmath134 decay .
+ + * fig .
( 3 ) * the same as in fig . ( 1 ) , but for the @xmath135 decay .
+ + * fig .
( 4 ) * the same as in fig . ( 2 ) , but for the @xmath135 decay .
+ + * fig .
( 5 ) * the same as in fig . ( 1 ) , but for the average transversal polarization asymmetry @xmath108 of muon .
+ + * fig .
( 6 ) * the same as in fig .
( 2 ) , but for the transversal polarization asymmetry @xmath136 .
+ + * fig .
( 7 ) * the same as in fig .
( 5 ) , but for the @xmath135 decay .
+ + * fig .
( 8) * the same as in fig .
( 6 ) , but for the @xmath135 decay . + + * fig . ( 9 ) * the dependence of the average normal asymmetry @xmath117 of muon on the new wilson coefficients .
+ + * fig .
( 10 ) * the dependence of the combined average normal polarization asymmetry @xmath137 on the new wilson coefficients for the @xmath134 decay .
+ + * fig .
( 11 ) * parametric plot of the correlation between the integrated branching ratio @xmath138 ( in units of @xmath139 ) and the average longitudinal lepton polarization asymmetry @xmath103 as function of the new wilson coefficients as indicated in the figure , for the @xmath135 decay . + + * fig .
( 12 ) * the same as in the fig . ( 11 ) , but for the combined average longitudinal lepton polarization asymmetry @xmath140 . + + * fig .
( 13 ) * the same as in fig .
( 11 ) , but for the average transversal lepton polarization asymmetry @xmath141 . + + * fig .
( 14 ) * the same as in the fig .
( 13 ) , but for the combined average transversal lepton polarization asymmetry @xmath142 . | using the general , model independent form of the effective hamiltonian , the general expressions of the longitudinal , normal and transversal polarization asymmetries for @xmath0 and @xmath1 and combinations of them for the exclusive @xmath2 decay are found .
the sensitivity of lepton polarizations and their combinations on new wilson coefficients are studied .
it is found that there exist regions of wilson coefficients for which the branching ratio coincides with the standard model result while the lepton polarizations differ substantially from the standard model prediction .
hence , studying lepton polarization in these regions of new wilson coefficients can serve as a promising tool for establishing new physics beyond the standard model .
16.3 true cm 23.0 true cm -0.8 true in 0.00 true in plus 1000pt minus 1000pt # 1 pacs numbers : 12.60.i , 13.20.v , 13.25.hw |
a small , but growing , number of galactic globular clusters exhibit a star - to - star variation in the relative abundances of the heavy elements .
@xmath0 centauri is the most well - known member of this group with its stars spanning a range in metallicity = @xmath6 from [ fe / h ] @xmath3 @xmath22.0 to [ fe / h ] @xmath3 @xmath20.5 ; for certain elements , the abundance ratios with respect to iron , [ x / fe ] , exhibit considerable variations with metallicity ( e.g. , @xcite ) . as the most massive galactic globular cluster and in light of its complex chemical enrichment history , @xmath0 cen is regarded to be the core of a disrupted dwarf galaxy ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
m54 is the second most massive galactic globular cluster .
it displays a key characteristic shared by @xmath0 centauri but absent in the majority of clusters , namely , a metallicity dispersion @xcite , albeit of smaller amplitude than that found in @xmath0 centauri . that m54 is the nuclear star cluster of the sagittarius dwarf spheroidal galaxy lends further support to the hypothesis that massive globular clusters with metallicity variations may be the nuclei of disrupted dwarf galaxies ( although @xcite argue that the nucleus of sgr likely formed independently of m54 ) . when considering the ensemble of globular clusters with unusual chemical abundance ratios cen and m54 , the other clusters include m15 @xcite , ngc 362 @xcite , ngc 1851 @xcite , ngc 2419 @xcite , ngc 3201 @xcite , ngc 5824 @xcite , ngc 6656 @xcite , ngc 7089 @xcite and terzan 5 @xcite ] ( dispersions in metallicity and/or neutron - capture elements ) , it is clear that these objects are preferentially the more luminous , and therefore the more massive , clusters .
@xcite considered globular clusters with an extended horizontal branch ( i.e. , a horizontal branch with extremely blue stars ) which likely signifies the presence of he abundance variations @xcite .
they argued that not only are clusters with an extended horizontal branch preferentially more massive , but also when considered together the clusters have different kinematics from other groupings of the galactic globular cluster population .
the sample of clusters with extended horizontal branches include @xmath0 cen , m54 and m22 , all of which exhibit metallicity variations .
@xcite showed that such clusters had kinematics consistent with accretion and thus likely have a different origin to the bulk of the cluster population .
the identification of additional globular clusters with peculiar chemical abundance patterns ( e.g. , star - to - star variations in metallicity ) would advance our understanding of the range and relative frequency of the abundance spread phenomenon in the galactic globular cluster system .
additionally , quantifying the number of accreted systems has important consequences for understanding the formation and evolution of our galaxy @xcite .
to this end , the most obvious objects to study are the most massive globular clusters with extended horizontal branches .
m62 ( ngc 6266 ) is the ninth most luminous cluster @xcite and has an extended blue horizontal branch . in the f439w @xmath2 f555w versus f555w colour magnitude diagram presented by @xcite ,
the horizontal branch extends down in luminosity to the main sequence turn - off .
the extended horizontal branch is also readily identified in dereddened @xmath7 versus @xmath8 and @xmath7 versus @xmath9 diagrams @xcite .
m62 ranks fifth in the number of millisecond pulsars @xcite , and there may be a connection between multiple stellar populations and the numbers of millisecond pulsars @xcite .
@xcite find that m62 could contain the most rr - lyrae of any galactic globular cluster and is a typical oosterhoff type i system .
this cluster lies in the vicinity of the bulge , although proper - motion measurements indicate that it probably belongs to the thick disk @xcite .
m62 is highly reddened , @xmath10 ) = 0.47 @xcite , and it is severely affected by differential reddening , @xmath11 @xmath12 0.25 @xcite .
the goal of the present paper is to conduct a detailed chemical abundance analysis of m62 based on high - resolution , high signal - to - noise ratio spectra . to our knowledge
this is the first such analysis of this cluster and this work therefore represents an essential step towards completing the census and characterisation of the galaxy s most massive globular clusters .
six targets were selected from @xcite ( see table [ tab : param ] ) .
all were high probability members based on the published radial velocities and were observed with the high dispersion spectrograph ( hds , @xcite ) on the subaru telescope on 2013 july 17 .
the exposure times ranged from 16 to 40 minutes per program star .
we used the stdyb setting and the 08 slit which resulted in a wavelength coverage from @xmath124100 to @xmath126800at a spectral resolution of @xmath13 .
there were approximately four pixels per resolution element .
spectra of a telluric standard ( hd 163955 ) and a radial velocity standard ( hd 182572 ) were also taken during this observing run .
two additional targets were selected from strmgren photometry obtained by j.a - g and observed using the mike spectrograph @xcite at the magellan - ii telescope on 2012 june 26 .
the exposure times were 1 hour for each star .
the 07 slit was employed providing a spectral resolution of @xmath14 = 35,000 ( blue ccd ) and @xmath14 = 27,000 ( red ccd ) with a wavelength coverage from @xmath123800 to @xmath129000 .
there were approximately four pixels per resolution element .
a telluric standard ( hd 170642 ) was also observed . in figure
[ fig : cmd ] , we show the locations of our targets in @xmath15 colour - magnitude diagrams ( cmd ) .
the photometry is from @xcite and 2mass @xcite .
colour - magnitude diagrams for m62 from @xcite ( left panels ) and 2mass @xcite ( right panels ; taking only objects within a radius of 3.5 and `` aaa '' photometric quality flags ) .
the aqua star represents the radial velocity non - member , star a195 , and the red circle represents star a124 , the possible non - member based on chemical abundances .
all other program stars are shown as grey circles . in the left panels
, the solid line represents the mean rgb ridge line from @xcite . ]
@lccrrrrcccccc@ name & ra 2000 & dec .
2000 & @xmath16 & @xmath17 & @xmath18 & rv & @xmath19rv & @xmath20 & @xmath21 & @xmath22 & [ m / h ] & [ fe / h ] + & & & & & & ( km s@xmath23 ) & ( km s@xmath23 ) & ( k ) & ( cm s@xmath24 ) & ( km s@xmath23 ) & dex & dex + ( 1 ) & ( 2 ) & ( 3 ) & ( 4 ) & ( 5 ) & ( 6 ) & ( 7 ) & ( 8) & ( 9 ) & ( 10 ) & ( 11 ) & ( 12 ) & ( 13 ) + + a5 & 17 01 16.21 & @xmath230 03 31.81 & 9.782 & 8.847 & 8.583 & @xmath275.0 & 0.2 & 3950 & 0.50 & 1.79 & @xmath21.10 & @xmath21.12 + a7 & 17 01 17.50 & @xmath230 03 20.60 & 9.602 & 8.608 & 8.389 & @xmath289.3 & 0.5 & 3925 & 0.20 & 1.89 & @xmath21.10 & @xmath21.15 + a14 & 17 01 17.29 & @xmath230 03 58.69 & 11.476 & 10.710 & 10.529 & @xmath254.2 & 0.2 & 4400 & 1.40 & 1.53 & @xmath21.10 & @xmath21.10 + a27 & 17 01 25.19 & @xmath230 04 09.85 & 11.779 & 11.124 & 10.989 & @xmath269.9 & 0.4 & 4625 & 1.50 & 1.76 & @xmath21.20 & @xmath21.24 + a124 & 17 01 00.28 & @xmath230 07 38.28 & 11.449 & 10.756 & 10.536 & @xmath268.2 & 0.3 & 4450 & 1.00 & 1.64 & @xmath21.20 & @xmath21.19 + a195 & 17 01 12.63 & @xmath230 03 40.78 & 11.988 & 11.318 & 11.157 & @xmath20.1 & 0.4 & & & & & + + c53 & 17 01 15.20 & @xmath230 08 36.50 & 10.101 & 9.246 & & @xmath273.6 & 0.2 & 4450 & 1.40 & 1.78 & @xmath21.10 & @xmath21.11 + d10 & 17 01 16.80 & @xmath230 08 18.00 & 10.125 & 9.145 & & @xmath259.0 & 0.2 & 4175 & 0.90 & 1.90 & @xmath21.10 & @xmath21.15 + the subaru spectra were reduced using iraf .
the magellan spectra were reduced using a combination of iraf and the mtools package . in both cases ,
the approach was similar to that described in @xcite . in figure
[ fig : spec ] , we plot a region of the spectra for the program stars .
the telluric standards were used to correct regions affected by telluric absorption .
star a195 had a signal - to - noise ratio s / n = 40 per pixel near 6000 . excluding this star , the s / n ranged from s / n = 65 per pixel ( stars a14 and a27 ) to s / n = 110 per pixel ( star d10 ) . /@xmath21/[fe
/ h ] ) are included .
the red spectrum is star a124 , a possible non - member based on the chemical abundances . ] for the program stars observed with subaru , heliocentric radial velocities were measured by cross - correlating each star against the radial velocity standard , hd 182572 , for which we adopted a valueudry / std / stdnew.dat ] of @xmath2100.35 km s@xmath23 . for the program stars observed with magellan , the radial velocities were determined by measuring the positions of a large number ( several hundred ) of atomic absorption features .
the radial velocities are presented in table [ tab : param ] and we note that star a195 is not a radial velocity member .
equivalent widths ( ew ) were measured using routines in iraf and daospec @xcite .
we note that every line measured using daospec was also measured , and visually inspected , using iraf .
for all stars , there was good agreement between the two sets of measurements ; for a given star , the average difference in ews between iraf and daospec was 0.1 m with a dispersion of 3 m .
the line list and ew measurements ( average of iraf and daospec ) are presented in table [ tab : ew ] .
[ cols="^,^,^,>,>,>,>,>,>,>,>,^ " , ] it is now well established that every globular cluster exhibits star - to - star abundance variations for c , n , o , f , na , mg and al ( e.g. , see reviews by @xcite ) .
these abundance variations are believed to have been produced via hydrogen - burning at high temperature in asymptotic giant branch ( agb ) stars , fast - rotating massive stars and/or massive binaries ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
@xcite and @xcite found that the abundance dispersions for the light elements correlate with various physical parameters .
in particular , they noted that the interquartile range ( iqr ) for [ o / fe ] , [ na / fe ] , [ o / na ] and [ mg / al ] exhibits a correlation with the absolute luminosity , i.e. , total mass . within our modest sample , assuming for the purposes of this exercise that the [ o / fe ] limits are detections , we find iqr[o / na ] = 1.11 and iqr[mg / al ] = 0.89 . with @xmath1 = @xmath29.18 @xcite , the iqr values for m62 are consistent with those of other luminous clusters . in figure
[ fig : m62m4m5 ] we plot [ x / fe ] versus atomic number for m62 , m4 and m5 .
regarding the @xmath5-process elements , zr , ba and la have ratios of [ x / fe ] @xmath3 + 0.4 .
such values differ from the majority of field halo stars of similar metallicity and from the comparable metallicity globular cluster m5 . on the other hand ,
these abundance ratios in m62 are comparable ( but not identical ) to m4 , a cluster believed to have formed from gas enriched in @xmath5-process material .
it is intriguing that both m4 and m62 are inner disk globular clusters of similar metallicity .
enhancements in the @xmath5-process elements are also seen in the globular clusters @xmath0 cen and m22 ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) . for elements
other than zr , ba and la , the abundance pattern in m62 more closely resembles that of m5 rather than m4 . at the metallicity of these clusters ,
published neutron - capture element abundances in inner disk and bulge stars are limited .
the @xcite comparison field stars in figure [ fig : field ] are solar neighbourhood objects . since the pioneering work by @xcite on chemical abundances in the bulge , the handful of papers presenting neutron - capture element abundances at or below [ fe / h ] = @xmath21.0 in the inner disk or bulge include @xcite and @xcite .
although their sample sizes are modest , some stars are enriched with material produced by @xmath5-process nucleosynthesis . among the bulge and inner disk globular clusters with [ fe / h ] @xmath25 @xmath21.0 , ngc 6522 exhibits enhancements in the @xmath5-process elements @xcite while hp-1
@xcite and ngc 6558 @xcite do not .
the abundances of rb and pb offer important diagnostics regarding the nature of the @xmath5-process . due to a branching point at @xmath26kr along the @xmath5-process path ,
the rb / zr ratio is sensitive to the neutron density at the site of the @xmath5-process . at high neutron density
, the [ rb / zr ] ratio is expected to be a factor of @xmath1210 larger than at low neutron density @xcite , although the yields depend on details in the models and nuclear reaction rates @xcite .
indeed , large rb abundances have been observed in massive agb stars @xcite .
pb and bi are the last stable nuclei along the @xmath5-process path .
if the total neutron exposure , or neutron supply per seed nuclei , is sufficiently high , large overabundances of these elements are predicted ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , and have been observed ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
as already noted , measurements of rb and pb were only possible for the two program stars observed at the magellan telescope . in figure
[ fig : rb ] we show observed and synthetic spectra near the 7800 rbi feature .
we measure values of [ rb / fe ] = + 0.09 and + 0.13 for stars c53 and d10 , respectively .
as can be seen in figure [ fig : m62m4m5 ] , those values fall closer to m5 ( [ rb / fe ] = 0.00 ) than to m4 ( [ rb / fe ] = + 0.39 ; @xcite ) . @xcite measured [ rb / fe ] in three globular clusters ( ngc 6752 , ngc 1904 and 47 tuc ) and found constant values in each cluster at the [ rb / fe ] @xmath3 0.0 level .
the [ rb / zr ] ratios are @xmath20.04 and @xmath20.05 for stars c53 and d10 , respectively , when the zr abundances are shifted on the @xcite scale as described in @xcite . the [ rb / zr ] ratios in m62 lie below those of m4 and m5 , [ rb / zr ] = + 0.17 and + 0.08 , respectively , but above the @xmath0 cen values @xcite . in summary ,
the low [ rb / fe ] and [ rb / zr ] ratios in m62 offer no support for a weak @xmath5-process contribution ( i.e. , the @xmath5-process in massive stars from the @xmath27ne(@xmath28,@xmath29)@xmath30 mg reaction ) from which the high neutron density would result in considerably higher [ rb / fe ] and [ rb / zr ] ratios than observed
. we will revisit the [ rb / zr ] ratio in the context of fast - rotating massive stars later in this subsection . the sr abundance in m62
, @xmath31[sr / fe]@xmath32 = @xmath20.39 , appears to be unusually low compared to the neighbouring elements , @xmath31[rb / fe]@xmath32 = + 0.11 and @xmath31[y / fe]@xmath32 = + 0.16 .
since our analysis only considered one line , sri 4607.33 , we regard the low sr abundance with some caution .
indeed , other studies that consider the 4607.33 sri line in globular cluster giants find [ sr / fe ] ratios that are lower than for the neighbouring elements [ rb / fe ] , [ y / fe ] and [ zr / fe ] ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* yong et al .
2014 , in preparation ) .
@xcite investigated non - lte corrections for the 4607.33 sr line , and for @xmath20/@xmath21/[fe / h ] = 4400/2.2/@xmath21.2 , the correction is 0.29 dex .
the magnitude and sign of this correction would help to reconcile the sr abundances with those of rb and y. in figure [ fig : m62m4m5 ] we adjust the sr abundance accordingly . in figure
[ fig : pb ] , we plot observed and synthetic spectra near the 4058 pbi feature .
we measure values of [ pb / fe ] @xmath330.09 and [ pb / fe ] = @xmath20.20 for stars c53 and d10 , respectively . for comparison , the average values in m4 and m5 are [ pb / fe ] = + 0.30 and @xmath20.35 , respectively @xcite .
thus , the m62 values for [ pb / fe ] lie closer to m5 than to m4 ( see figure [ fig : m62m4m5 ] ) .
@xcite argue that the pb / eu ratio offers a good diagnostic of the presence of @xmath5-process enriched material . for m62 ,
the pb to eu ratios are at the same level as the ( more metal - poor ) `` @xmath4-process standard stars '' in @xcite . from table [ tab : abun2 ] , all element ratios [ eu / x ] ( for x = la and heavier elements ) are consistent , within @xmath120.2 dex , with the scaled - solar @xmath4-process distribution @xcite , see figure [ fig : eux ] .
( note that while we refer to @xmath5-process and @xmath4-process elements according to their origin in solar system material , those definitions may be incorrect in m62 , e.g. , la and ce in this cluster are likely produced primarily through the @xmath4-process . ) regarding the lighter elements , the first to deviate from the @xmath4-process signature is ba : while the solar @xmath4-process value is [ eu / ba]@xmath34 @xmath12 0.9 dex , m62 exhibits a ratio of @xmath12 0.2 dex . in the same way ,
all elements lighter than ba depart from the solar system @xmath4-process signature . for x = rb to pb .
the dashed red line represents the scaled - solar @xmath4-process distribution @xcite .
( for sr , we apply a non - lte correction of 0.29 dex , see section 4.2 for details . )
] the neutron - capture element abundance ratios of the m62 stars are not consistent with @xmath5-process nucleosynthesis occurring in agb stars of low metallicity .
low - mass agb stars of @xmath35 are the main site of the @xmath5-process in the galaxy and typically produce [ hs / ls ] refers to the heavy @xmath5-process elements ( ba , la , etc . ) and @xmath36 refers to the light @xmath5-process elements ( y , zr , etc . ) . ]
@xmath37 , [ pb / hs ] @xmath38 dex and [ rb / zr ] @xmath39 at [ fe / h ] @xmath40 ( e.g. , @xcite ; fishlock et al .
2014 , in preparation ) .
this is a direct consequence of the operation of the @xmath41c(@xmath28,@xmath29)@xmath42o reaction which is the dominant neutron source for @xmath35 ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
for intermediate - mass agb stars the @xmath27ne(@xmath28,@xmath29)@xmath30 mg reaction is the neutron source and operates during convective thermal pulses .
the abundance pattern produced in those stars should be dominated by lighter @xmath5-process elements ( y , rb , sr , zr ) @xcite . at [ fe / h ]
@xmath40 , typical abundances in stars @xmath43 are [ hs / ls ] @xmath44 , [ pb / hs ] @xmath45 , and [ rb / zr ] @xmath46 dex ( fishlock et al .
2014 , in preparation ) .
fast - rotating massive stars ( which we hereafter refer to interchangeably as `` spin stars '' ) can produce a large amount of @xmath5-process products at low metallicity , where the dominant neutron source is @xmath27ne(@xmath28,@xmath29)@xmath30 mg in the convective he - burning core and in the subsequent convective c - burning shell @xcite . in these stars , @xmath27ne is primary , i.e. , it is not directly produced from the initial cno abundances as in non - rotating massive stars ( see for instance the weak @xmath5-process in massive stars at solar metallicity , e.g. , @xcite ) .
the faster the star rotates , the more primary @xmath27ne can be made available in the he core .
the most abundant elements from the @xmath5-process in spin stars are sr , y and zr while production for heavier elements up to ba strongly depends on the rotation speed and on nuclear uncertainties , e.g. , on the @xmath28-capture rates on @xmath27ne @xcite and on the @xmath28-capture rates on @xmath47o ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
the @xmath5-process in massive stars can not produce elements beyond the ba neutron - magic peak ( n = 82 ) due to basic properties of @xmath27ne as a neutron source ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
spin stars have been suggested as the source of the light element abundance variations in globular clusters @xcite .
recall that in figure [ fig : ncap ] there was no significant correlation between the abundances of na and the neutron - capture elements .
thus , there is no obvious connection between the star - to - star na abundance variation and the enhancement in y , zr and ba abundances in this cluster .
@xcite explored the impact of changing the amount of primary @xmath27ne available to make neutrons , from 1 percent ( in mass fraction ) to 0.2 percent , for a 25 m@xmath48 model at [ fe / h ] = @xmath23 .
the result of this change was an increase in the [ zr / ba ] ratio from @xmath20.18 to 0.67 .
as expected , eu is not efficiently produced by the @xmath5-process regardless of the initial abundance of @xmath27ne .
m62 stars exhibits an average [ eu / ba ] = + 0.2 , and this value lies between the @xmath5-process abundance signature of spin stars and the @xmath4-process .
this intermediate value may be a consequence of the combination of the @xmath4-process ( which makes eu and some ba ) and the @xmath5-process in spin stars ( producing ba and only a small amount of eu ) .
m62 exhibits [ rb / zr ] and [ rb / y ] ratios of @xmath490.4 and @xmath490.1 , respectively . in the models considered by @xcite , reducing the initial @xmath27ne abundance from 1 per cent ( in mass fraction ) to 0.2 percent increases the [ rb / zr ] ratio from @xmath20.86 to @xmath20.57 , and the [ rb / y ] ratio from @xmath20.86 to @xmath20.75 .
the predicted [ rb / zr ] ratio is slightly lower than the observations .
those predictions were based on a 25 m@xmath48 spin star model .
it would be of great interest to explore a larger range of initial masses in order to quantify the final core - collapse supernova yields for the elements from rb to zr .
on the other hand , it is difficult to reconcile the average [ rb / y ] observed in m62 with spin star nucleosynthesis .
y is efficiently produced at high neutron densities from sr .
the dispersion in the [ y / fe ] ratio is consistent with the measurement uncertainties , although there is a hint that the [ y / fe ] ratios cluster around two values , @xmath120.1 and @xmath120.4 .
the abundance enhancement at y and zr is a key feature of the lighter element primary process ( lepp ) exhibited by some halo stars at lower metallicities , [ fe / h ] @xmath50 @xmath22 ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
while the astrophysical site of the lepp is not clearly understood , a number of scenarios have been proposed , including explosive nucleosynthesis triggered by neutrino - winds in core - collapse supernovae ( e.g. , @xcite ) and the @xmath5-process in fast - rotating massive stars ( e.g. , @xcite ) . while the aforementioned lepp explosive scenarios can not efficiently contribute to elements up to the ba peak
, the @xmath5-process in spin stars may potentially produce them . to summarise , while the abundance ratios for the elements y , zr and ba may be consistent with the @xmath5-process in spin stars , the high [ rb / y ] ratio is difficult to explain .
spin - star models at metallicities closer to that of m62 and for a larger range of initial masses would be needed to perform a consistent chemical evolution study , and test the spin stars scenario for this cluster . in this context , it has been reported that ngc 6522 , a bulge globular cluster , has enhanced sr and y abundances consistent with spin star nucleosynthesis @xcite . in that study ,
the abundances were derived from the sri6503.99 and yii 6613.73 lines . as noted in their paper ,
the sriline is weak .
we suspect that this yii line is blended with the fei6613.82 line @xcite , and this fe line has a lower excitation potential and @xmath51 value of 1.011 ev and @xmath25.587 , respectively ( vienna atomic line database , @xcite )
. it would therefore be interesting to re - examine the sr and y abundances in ngc 6522 using additional lines to confirm the sr and y enhancements in that cluster .
our analysis reveals no evidence for an intrinsic metallicity dispersion in m62 .
as noted in the introduction , the globular clusters with metallicity dispersions are preferentially the more luminous objects and tend to have extended horizontal branches
. some , and perhaps all , of these clusters may be the nuclei of accreted dwarf galaxies . based on our results
, m62 is a massive globular cluster with an extended horizontal branch that does not harbour a metallicity dispersion .
star a124 has lower ratios of the neutron - capture elements when compared to the other program stars .
although a124 has stellar parameters and a radial velocity consistent with cluster membership , the besanon model @xcite predicts that some field contamination is likely , @xmath124% .
the simplest explanation is that a124 is a field star .
the o and na abundances for a124 lie at the lower end of the distribution defined by the cluster stars and are similar to field stars .
proper - motion and/or parallax measurements will test this hypothesis .
nevertheless , future studies may reveal additional stars in m62 with a range of neutron - capture element abundances .
if m62 really hosts two populations of stars , of equal size , with distinct neutron - capture element abundances , then the probability of observing six out of seven program stars from a single population is 6% .
in this paper we present a chemical abundance analysis of seven bright giants in m62 , a luminous globular cluster with an extended horizontal branch .
we find no evidence for a metallicity dispersion , as seen in other luminous globular clusters with similar horizontal branch morphology .
we find star - to - star abundance variations and correlations for o , na and al and the amplitudes of those variations are comparable to those found in the most massive globular clusters .
the elements zr , ba and la exhibit enhancements , [ x / fe ] @xmath12 + 0.4 , compared to field stars at the same metallicity .
the lack of a significant correlation between the abundances of na and the neutron - capture elements would suggest that the light element variations and enhancement in y , zr and ba are produced in different processes and/or sites . for the elements heavier than la , the abundances are consistent with the scaled - solar @xmath4-process distribution .
on the other hand , y , zr and ba are clearly enhanced when compared to the scaled - solar @xmath4-process distribution .
the abundance pattern for these elements is incompatible with the s - process in agb stars or in non - rotating massive stars . on the other hand , while the abundance distribution for these elements could be produced by fast - rotating massive stars , the high [ rb / y ] ratios that we measure do not match existing frms model predictions .
one star has neutron - capture element abundance ratios that are distinct from the remaining stars .
while this is likely a field halo star , the identification of additional stars in the vicinity of m62 with similar abundance patterns would be of great interest .
studies of other luminous globular clusters are necessary to complete the census and characterisation of the most luminous clusters in the milky way .
we thank christian johnson for helpful discussions .
d.y , a.a.b , g.d.c , a.i.k and j.e.n gratefully acknowledge support from the australian research council ( grants dp0984924 , fs110200016 , ft110100475 and dp120101237 ) . j.a .-
g acknowledges support by the chilean ministry for the economy , development , and tourism s programa iniciativa cientfica milenio through grant p07 - 021-f , awarded to the milky way millennium nucleus ; by proyecto fondecyt postdoctoral 3130552 ; by proyecto fondecyt regular 1110326 ; and by proyecto basal pfb-06/2007 .
m.p acknowledges support from the ambizione grant of the snsf ( switzerland ) and eurogenesis ( masche ) .
funding for the stellar astrophysics centre is provided by the danish national research foundation .
the research is supported by the asterisk project ( asteroseismic investigations with song and kepler ) funded by the european research council ( grant agreement no . : 267864 ) . ,
t. , yee , j. c. , feltzing , s. , johnson , j. a. , gould , a. , cohen , j. g. , asplund , m. , melndez , j. , lucatello , s. , han , c. , thompson , i. , gal - yam , a. , udalski , a. , bennett , d. p. , bond , i. a. , kohei , w. , sumi , t. , suzuki , d. , suzuki , k. , takino , s. , tristram , p. , yamai , n. , & yonehara , a. 2013 , , 549 , a147 , r. , shectman , s. a. , gunnels , s. m. , mochnacki , s. , & athey , a. e. 2003 , in society of photo - optical instrumentation engineers ( spie ) conference series , vol .
4841 , society of photo - optical instrumentation engineers ( spie ) conference series , ed .
m. iye & a. f. m. moorwood , 16941704 , a. , beard , m. , grres , j. , couder , m. , deboer , r. , falahat , s. , gray , r. t. , kontos , a. , kratz , k .-
l . , leblanc , p. j. , li , q. , obrien , s. , zkan , n. , pignatari , m. , sonnabend , k. , talwar , r. , tan , w. , uberseder , e. , & wiescher , m. 2013 , , 87 , 045805 , a. , aparicio , a. , piotto , g. , rosenberg , a. , chaboyer , b. , sarajedini , a. , siegel , m. , anderson , j. , bedin , l. r. , dotter , a. , hempel , m. , king , i. , majewski , s. , milone , a. p. , paust , n. , & reid , i. n. 2009 , , 694 , 1498 , a. f. , sneden , c. , kraft , r. p. , wallerstein , g. , norris , j. e. , da costa , g. , milone , a. p. , ivans , i. i. , gonzalez , g. , fulbright , j. p. , hilker , m. , piotto , g. , zoccali , m. , & stetson , p. b. 2011 , , 532 , a8 , m. f. , cutri , r. m. , stiening , r. , weinberg , m. d. , schneider , s. , carpenter , j. m. , beichman , c. , capps , r. , chester , t. , elias , j. , huchra , j. , liebert , j. , lonsdale , c. , monet , d. g. , price , s. , seitzer , p. , jarrett , t. , kirkpatrick , j. d. , gizis , j. e. , howard , e. , evans , t. , fowler , j. , fullmer , l. , hurt , r. , light , r. , kopan , e. l. , marsh , k. a. , mccallon , h. l. , tam , r. , van dyk , s. , & wheelock , s. 2006 , , 131 , 1163 | with the exception of terzan 5 , all the galactic globular clusters that possess significant metallicity spreads , such as @xmath0 cen and m22 , are preferentially the more luminous clusters with extended horizontal branches . here
we present radial velocities and chemical abundances for seven bright giants in the globular cluster m62 , a previously little - studied cluster .
with @xmath1 = @xmath29.18 , m62 is the ninth most luminous galactic globular cluster and has an extended horizontal branch . within our sample ,
we find ( i ) no evidence for a dispersion in metallicity , [ fe / h ] , beyond the measurement uncertainties , ( ii ) star - to - star abundance variations for c , o , na and al with the usual correlations between these elements as seen in other globular clusters , and ( iii ) a global enrichment for the elements zr , ba and la at the level [ x / fe ] @xmath3 + 0.4 dex . for elements heavier than la , the abundance ratios are consistent with the scaled - solar @xmath4-process distribution .
below la , the abundances are anomalous when compared to the scaled - solar @xmath5-process or @xmath4-process distributions . for these elements ,
the abundance signature in m62 is in agreement with predictions of the @xmath5-process from fast - rotating massive stars , although the high [ rb / y ] ratio we measure may be a challenge to this scenario .
[ firstpage ] stars : abundances galaxy : abundances globular clusters : individual : ngc 6266 |
data from tidal stream debris is a valuable resource for constraining galactic structure . in the last decade ,
several streams , with both globular cluster and dwarf galaxy progenitors , have been discovered in the milky way @xcite , as well as in nearby galaxies @xcite . by examining the density , kinematics , distribution , and structure of various tidal streams surrounding the milky way , a clearer picture of how our halo was built
can be developed @xcite .
in addition , stellar streams can be used as probes of the galactic gravitational potential , and thus constrains the shape of the dark matter halo @xcite .
@xcite , hereafter gd , announced the detection of a @xmath0 cold stellar stream in the galactic halo ( the stream itself we refer to henceforth as gd-1 , following gd ) , using stellar density counts extracted from the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ; york et al .
this stream is extremely narrow , less than @xmath5 degrees in width , which is less than 50 pc at their measured distances of 7.3 to 9.1 kpc from the sun .
gd therefore concluded that the progenitor was a globular cluster , but the progenitor remains unidentified and could be completely disrupted . in this work
, we utilize newly available sloan extension for galactic understanding and exploration ( segue ; see yanny et al .
2009 ) spectroscopy of stars identified along the stream , that are available in the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) data release 7 ( dr7 ) , to constrain the orbit of the stream and search for possible progenitors .
the sdss imaging survey @xcite has made it possible to detect faint milky way halo streams from the spatial distribution of stars because it provides very accurate multicolor photometry for millions of galactic stars .
even with the well - calibrated sdss photometry @xcite , gd separated the faint structure from the background of milky way halo and disk stars only with careful filtering and smoothing techniques @xcite . to characterize the stream in more detail and to compute an orbit , we reanalyze the imaging data , supplemented through dr7 , and then add to it all newly available spectroscopic observations of gd-1 stream stars available in sdss dr7 . using the analysis of gd as a guide
, stars were selected from the sdss dr7 @xcite footprint from a rough color - magnitude box restricted to blue f turnoff and upper main sequence stars at distances of 7 to 20 kpc from the sun ( taking into account that the turnoff spans more than a magnitude of absolute magnitudes ) : @xmath6 .
magnitudes with @xmath7 subscript indicate those which have been corrected for reddening using the @xcite maps as implemented in sdss ( dr7 ) .
all sdss stars in the dr7 north galactic cap footprint which are in this color - magnitude box were selected and plotted in an ( @xmath8 ) stellar density diagram with pixels @xmath9 on a side .
examination of this diagram by eye showed that gd-1 stream stood out weakly from the background , with enough contrast so that the location of several fiducial points along the stream in ( @xmath8 ) could be mapped .
low - order polynomials were then fit to the positions of these points .
the lowest order best fit was of third order : @xmath10 by comparison with likely identified spectroscopic stream members we later verified that this polynomial matches the stream position within about @xmath11 for @xmath12 , and within about @xmath13 for @xmath14 and @xmath15 .
next , 147,537 stars within @xmath16 of this polynomial fit ( a conservative width is used to increase the signal to noise , it is not necessary to identify every star ) were selected from @xmath17 .
they represent the ` on - stream ' data set . for a control sample ( ` off - stream ' ) , 158,147 stars were selected within @xmath18 degrees of a curve offset by 5 degrees in @xmath19 from the ` on - stream ' data over a similar @xmath20 range . a hess diagram in ( @xmath21 ) of the difference between the on and off stream data @xcite
was generated and the results are shown in figure 1 .
figure 1 shows a clear faint turnoff around @xmath22 and upper main sequence descending to @xmath23 .
other features in figure 1 include an imperfectly subtracted thick disk residual at @xmath24 from @xmath25 and a residual from nearby m dwarfs at @xmath26 and @xmath27 .
the stars below the turnoff are concentrated in a relatively narrow band of color and magnitude , as expected for a stream localized in distance from the sun .
since the stream varies in distance from 7 to about 10 kpc for the stars in this figure , the actual width of the main sequence is substantially narrower than demonstrated here .
the blue turnoff of @xmath28 suggests a lower metallicity or younger age than that of the spheroid , which has a turnoff of @xmath29 and @xmath30 \sim -1.6 $ ] .
we superimpose with black dots in figure 1 a fiducial sequence from the cluster m92 .
the m92 sequence was calculated by starting with the fiducial sequence in undereddened @xmath31 from @xcite , converting it to @xmath32 using e(b - v ) of 0.02 and a distance to m92 of 8.2 kpc , as tabulated by @xcite , and then shifting it to the approximate distance to the gd-1 stream , which is approximately 9 kpc over this range of ra ( distance modulus @xmath33 ) .
this low - metallicity cluster , with @xmath30 = -2.3 $ ] @xcite , fits the main sequence and the turnoff reasonably well .
we do not see the giant branch or the horizontal branch ( which should be at @xmath34 ) in this figure , but given the faintness of the stream that is not unexpected .
we now refine the rough color - magnitude box used to detect the stream in equatorial coordinates .
the refined box is selected to allow for a stream which changes distance by @xmath35 over @xmath36 .
the box is defined as the union of three selection regions heavily outlined in figure 1 : a ) @xmath37 ( turn off ) b ) @xmath38 ( lower turn off ) and c ) @xmath39 ( upper main sequence ) .
all stars with images in the sdss dr7 northern galactic cap region which meet these criteria ( and have @xmath40 to exclude quasars ) , are selected and plotted in @xmath41 in the upper panel of figure 2 .
the gd-1 stream is faintly visible , running in an arc from about @xmath42 through @xmath43 , then down to @xmath44 where it crosses in front of the sagittarius stream , and then it is not clearly visible as it is lost in monoceros and other galactic halo stars near @xmath45
. the lower panel of figure 2 presents the same data in a galactic polar projection .
the gd-1 stream is clearly visible .
there are several features in the density of stars along the stream of unknown origin
. they could be the remains of a nearly dissolved progenitor , the result of interactions between the stream and the potential of the milky way s disk and halo , or unassociated spheroid substructure .
the kinematics of the stream , detailed below , reveal that it is on a retrograde orbit moving through the sequence of points in the order just described for the upper panel of figure 2 .
numerous other dwarf galaxies , streams and halo overdensities are present in figure 2 ; these will not be discussed further here . the segue survey @xcite , which is one of three surveys carried out as part of sdss - ii , obtained spectra of approximately 240,000 milky way stars toward @xmath46 sightlines that each covered seven square degrees of the sky , with an emphasis on obtaining spectra of fainter halo stars . while most of segue s 200 observing tiles were randomly distributed across the sdss imaging footprint , a few were placed on streams of known interest , including the gd-1 stream .
all segue spectra were processed through the standard sdss spectroscopic reduction pipelines @xcite , from which radial velocities accurate to about @xmath47 for objects at @xmath48 were determined .
in addition , the stellar spectra were processed through the segue stellar parameter pipeline ( sspp ) @xcite in order to obtain abundance ( [ fe / h ] ) , surface gravity ( log g ) , and other atmospheric parameter estimates .
we select from the sdss - ii / segue dr7 database all measured parameters of the @xmath49 spectra of stars within @xmath50 of the gd-1 stream described by eq .
1 . we further refined the selection to exclude objects far away from the fiducial m92 curve of figure 1 by requiring that they meet these color magnitude cuts : @xmath51 or @xmath52 or @xmath53 or @xmath54 or @xmath55 or @xmath56 .
the region bounded by these cuts is outlined with a light line in figure 1 .
most of the 4568 remaining spectra are concentrated in @xmath57 diameter patches centered on segue tiles , but some are part of the sdss - i and sdss - ii legacy surveys .
these latter surveys targeted nearly the entire sdss footprint spectroscopically , but with few and limited signal - to - noise on stellar targets ( since the sdss legacy survey primarily targets galaxy and quasar candidates ) .
we show in figure 3 the line - of - sight , galactic standard of rest velocities , @xmath58 , for each star in the sample , as a function of galactic longitude .
we calculate @xmath58 using : @xmath59 , where rv is the heliocentric radial velocity in @xmath60 and @xmath61 are the standard , sun - centered galactic coordinates of each star . a sine curve with amplitude 110 @xmath60 traces an approximate locus of nearby disk stars co - rotating with the sun .
spheroid stars occupy a broad range of @xmath62 centered at @xmath63 .
seven regions of interest are marked along the bottom of figure 3 , indicating areas with segue plates , where stars identified with the gd-1 stream will be selected .
the positions of these seven regions on the sky in equatorial coordinates are also indicated with circles and numbered in the upper panel of figure 2 .
regions 5 and 6 were specially targeted by segue with a tile directly on locations along the gd-1 stream . from examination of figure 3
, it appears that there is an excess of stars off the rotating disk locus at @xmath64 in regions 5 and 6 . to confirm that these are in fact gd-1 stream stars
, we isolate the stars in regions 5 and 6 and plot their velocity histogram in figure 4 .
the distribution in figure 4 is overlayed with gaussians for the thick disk ( dispersion of @xmath65 and an offset of @xmath66 ) , and inner halo ( dispersion of @xmath67 ) .
a significant peak is detected at @xmath68 which we associate with the gd-1 stream member stars .
we next examine the metallicity distribution of stars in this velocity peak in order to estimate the elemental abundance of the gd-1 stream . later in the paper
we will show that the individual @xmath62 velocities in regions 5 and 6 are @xmath69 and @xmath70 km s@xmath71 , respectively , so we chose a peak " velocity range of @xmath72 km s@xmath71 .
figure 5 shows the sspp abundance estimates for all stars with good metallicity estimates ( for a good estimate a turnoff star generally needs to be brighter than about @xmath73 ) .
errors on individual stars @xmath30 $ ] are approximately 0.3 dex for spectral type f objects with @xmath74 .
the histogram for all abundances of stars in regions 5 and 6 are plotted with a light line ( 1311 stars ) , those for stars in the velocity peak of figure 4 are indicated with a heavy line ( 115 stars ) .
the stars with velocities of the gd-1 stream are heavily biased towards lower metallicity stars , compared with those of the thick disk ( @xmath30 \sim -0.7 $ ] ) , or inner halo ( @xmath30 \sim -1.6 $ ] ) .
we estimate from figure 4 that about 30 stars in the spectroscopic dataset are from the gd-1 stream . to see the metallicitydistribution of the stars in the gd-1 stream
, we subtract a scaled version of the histogram with the light line from the histogram with the heavy line .
the scaling factor is ( 115 - 30)/(1311 - 30 ) . since the stars in the velocity selected region contain a smaller fraction of thick disk stars , the subtracted histogram is oversubtracted at high metallcities , and likely undersubtracted at spheroid metallcitites .
the mean of the stars in the shaded region is [ fe / h]=-1.9 , but the real metallicity of the stream is probably somewhat lower than this .
bins with negative counts do not appear in figure 5 .
we now return to the sample of stars in figure 3 , and select only those of very low metallicity ( @xmath75 < -1.65 $ ] ) in order to isolate stream members from the thick disk and halo field star populations . the low metallicity spectra with positions , colors , and magnitudes that make them candidates for gd-1 stream members
are shown in figure 6 .
several velocity peaks are now clearly separated from the disk and spheroid .
we now examine stars in each of the seven regions numbered in figure 6 and determine their observational properties .
we estimated the distance to the gd-1 stream at the positions of each of the seven regions that it overlaps using a matched filter algorithm .
we first generated the hess diagram from sdss dr7 data from a region about @xmath76 wide in ra and 1@xmath77 wide in dec in the vicinity of each plate , centered on the polynomial fit to the gd-1 stream .
then the hess diagram of the background was generated from two regions of sky with the same angular extent on the sky , but offset 1.5@xmath77 higher and 1.5@xmath77 lower in declination . the background hess diagram ( divided by two to correct for the difference in sky area )
was subtracted from the corresponding hess diagram on the gd-1 stream .
the subtracted hess diagrams are shown in figure 7 .
since the gd-1 stream is of quite low metallicity , we selected the globular cluster m92 ( [ fe / h]@xmath78 ) to compare with the observations .
we then constructed a m92 filter hess diagram with the similar method to @xcite .
we first broaden the m92 fiducial sequence from @xcite with the sdss photometric errors .
because we do not have a luminosity function for m92 stars , we used the luminosity function of m13 , estimated from sdss survey counts vs. magnitude for stars away from the core of m13 , to create the hess diagram .
as before , we assume the distance to m92 is 8.2 kpc .
the m92 filter was shifted from -0.5 to 1.5 magnitudes in r in steps of 0.05 mag . for each shift ,
we cross - correlated the m92 filter with the subtracted hess diagram : @xmath79\cdot f(g - r , r+{\delta}r)\ ] ] and estimated the error of cross - correlation function as : @xmath80\cdot f^2(g - r , r+{\delta}r)\}^{0.5}.\ ] ] in the above equations , o and b represent the hess diagrams of orbit and background segments , respectively .
f is the value of m92 filter .
then we define the maximum position , @xmath81 , of the cross - correlation function to be the actual distance modulus to the stream . near the maximum
, we can estimate the cross - correlation function by the taylor expansion : @xmath82 the second term in the right equals zero , since the first derivative is zero at maximum .
we use the above taylor expansion , using only the lowest order non - zero terms , to estimate the error in the cross - correlation function : @xmath83 since @xmath84 , @xmath85 the distance and corresponding error of each of the seven points along the stream with segue spectra are listed in table 1 .
figure 8 shows the same data as figure 7 , but overplotted with the m92 fiducial sequence shifted to the best estimated distance for each sky position .
figure 9 shows velocity histograms of low metallicity stars from figure 6 within @xmath86 of each selected region .
a gaussian velocity histogram , representing a halo distribution with @xmath87 and are normalized so that the area under the curve equals the number of stars in the histogram , is also shown .
the region number is indicated in the upper right corner of each panel , and the velocity of the peak most likely associated with the gd-1 stream is also indicated .
we list below some details of each region s selection , including the sdss / segue plates on which most of the objects were detected . in each region with a clear stream detection ,
the velocity and velocity dispersion for the gd-1 stream were computed using an iterative method that used only stars within one standard deviation of the mean velocity .
we computed the mean and standard deviation of the stars near the velocity peak .
then , we selected stars that were within one standard deviation of the mean and re - computed the mean and standard deviation
. the standard deviation calculated this way is an underestimate , since we have removed the tails of the distribution .
we corrected the standard deviation assuming gaussian tails .
this process was repeated until the computed mean and standard deviation matched the mean and standard deviation used to select the stars in the stream .
table 2 lists 48 high confidence gd-1 stream members .
the sample includes the stars in figure 6 ( which are selected based on angular distance from the gd-1 stream , photometric color and magnitude , and metallicity ) which have galactic longitude within two degrees of the seven plate centers , have velocities near the measured or expected velocities for the gd-1 stream , and which have proper motions that are consistent with our gd-1 stream model ( presented in 7 ) .
the velocity cuts for each of the seven regions are : 1 ) @xmath88 , 2 ) @xmath89 , 3 ) @xmath90 , 4 ) @xmath91 , 5 ) @xmath92 , 6 ) @xmath93 , and 7 ) @xmath94 .
the proper motions expected for each of the seven regions are listed in table 1 .
the stars in table 2 are within two sigma of the expected proper motions , where one sigma is 3 mas / yr in each of @xmath95 and @xmath96 .
table 2 includes each objects sdss - id number , coordinates , magnitude , colors , velocity , estimated metallicity , surface gravity and proper motion .
the proper motions ( @xmath97 ) listed here are from the usno - b / sdss catalog of @xcite , as extracted from the dr7 database s ` propermotions ' table .
errors on an individual @xmath98 star s measurement are about @xmath99 on each coordinate .
regions 4 , 5 , and 6 were specifically targeted by segue with plates along the gd-1 stream .
these regions , along with region 1 , targeted by the sdss legacy survey , constitute the 4 regions along the stream with spectroscopy used to fit a model orbit for gd-1 .
_ region 4 , plates 2889 and 2914 : _ the gd-1 stars are well sampled in this plate pair ; there is a clearly detected peak of ( primarily ) f turnoff stars at @xmath100 km s@xmath71 with @xmath101 km s@xmath71 , in the magnitude range @xmath102 .
the metallicity of stars in the velocity peak is about @xmath30 \sim -2.2 $ ] .
there are two bhbs in this sample near @xmath103 , corresponding to a distance of 7.2 kpc @xcite .
the distance to this region derived in section 3 from the turnoff photometry is @xmath104kpc , in good agreement with the bhb magnitudes .
the velocities of the two bhbs are -6 and -3 @xmath60 , in excellent agreement with the average of the turnoff star velocities , as are the metallicities ( [ fe / h ] = -2.0 and -2.1 , respectively ) .
_ region 5 , plates 2557 and 2567 : _ the plate spans the full width of the gd-1 stream .
there is a strong peak in the velocity distribution .
this peak has @xmath105 with @xmath106 km s@xmath71 .
the average @xmath107 magnitude in this range is @xmath73 , which is consistent with the distance estimation from color magnitude turnoff fitting .
the metallicity distribution of f turn - off stars in the peak shows that [ fe / h ] of this stream is about -2.05 .
the distance to this piece of the stream is @xmath108 .
_ region 6 , plates 2390 and 2410 : _ a strong and narrow peak is detected in figure 9 , at @xmath109 , @xmath110 km s@xmath71 and @xmath111 .
[ fe / h ] distributions show the metallicity peaks at about -2.05 , which is consistent with the [ fe / h ] peak find in plate 2567 and slightly higher than plate 2914 , this indicates that they are from the same stream .
a distance estimate puts stars in this region of the stream at @xmath112 from the sun .
_ region 1 , plate 1154 : _ this is a special sdss legacy plate , rather than a segue plate , but since it is at low galactic latitude it does have a large number of stellar candidates .
its important gd-1 stream candidate stars cluster at velocity @xmath113 , with @xmath114 km s@xmath71 , and ( lower s / n ) metallicity [ fe / h ] @xmath115 , which anchors the stream orbit away from regions 4,5 and 6 . with larger errors ,
the distance to this stream here is @xmath116 .
there is a second peak ( 3 stars ) at @xmath117 .
we discount this second peak as being associated with gd-1 , since two of its three members have [ fe / h ] = -1.8 , significantly higher than the average for other stream peak members .
this secondary peak could be related to the anti - center stream noted by @xcite , as the radial velocity of these stars is @xmath118 , is close to their value for acs - c ( see lower panel of figure 1 and figure 2 of that work ) .
the following 3 regions were not involved in the model fit ( see below ) , but as there are segue spectra available here along the orbit defined by the imaging arc defined in equation 1 , we examine these segue plates for possible stream members . _
region 2 , plates 1760 , 2433 , 2667 and 2671 : _ this plate pair was targeted by segue as it contains the open solar - metallicity cluster m67 .
the sagittarius stream also passes near by , along with the anti - center stream . by chance
, the gd-1 stream arc appears to pass within 1.3@xmath77 of the plate center , and several very low metallicity turnoff stars are detected with average @xmath119 .
the distance to the stream is @xmath120 .
_ region 3 , plates 2304 and 2319 : _ several stars with metallicity have velocities in a broad excess near @xmath121 , however there is not a significant candidate peak here .
a peak at @xmath122 has stars with @xmath123 >
\sim -1.8 $ ] , and is not a viable stream maximum . the distance from section 3 is estimated at @xmath124 .
_ region 7 , plate 2539 and 2547 : _ this plate pair is on the fitted arc of equation 1 , but the stream becomes too tenuous to be defined . we do not see a velocity peak here , but following the trend in the peaks of points 1 - 6 there may be two or three stars ( above background ) at @xmath125 , with the correct metallicity and proper motion to be associated with gd-1 .
we do not place as strong a confidence in the gd-1 membership of stars in this peak as the other 6 regions . a very uncertain distance estimate to the stream here ,
is about @xmath126 from the sun .
orbit fits , which were not fit to data in region 7 , confirm that this is the correct velocity to be looking for stream stars , but that the distance is somewhat underestimated .
we note that the estimated distances to individual regions are in very good agreement with those quoted by @xcite , indicating that the results are somewhat robust to details of the method and potential parameters .
the observed properties of the stars in the seven gd-1 stream candidate regions are summarized in table 1 , where we list region number ( @xmath127 ) ; equatorial coordinates , @xmath41 ; the corresponding galactic coordinates ( @xmath128 ) with errors ( we use @xmath19 to denote a measured error , to distinguish it from the intrinsic dispersion , which we denote with the symbol @xmath129 ) ; the average galactocentric standard of rest velocity and heliocentric radial velocity with an error , and the velocity dispersion . the velocity mean and dispersion were calculated as described in 3 .
the tabulated intrinsic dispersions are upper limits to the actual velocity dispersion of the stream ; since they are similar in size to the velocity errors for each individual spectrum , the measurement is consistent with an intrinsic velocity distribution of zero .
the error in the mean is the velocity dispersion divided by the square root of the number of stars used to compute it .
regions 2 , 3 , and 7 do not have clear , narrow peaks in the velocity distributions and therefore were not used to fit the orbit , though figure 6 shows there are excess stars at about the right velocities .
table 1 lists the computed galactic @xmath130 positions ( with respect to a right handed coordinate system with the sun at ( -8,0,0 ) kpc ) for each stream region and a distance to the stream at that region , again with errors . for the four regions numbered 1,4,5 and 6 , the velocity and position accuracies are highly significant , and there is high confidence of the gd-1 stream membership of stars highlighted in the corresponding boxes of figure 6 .
figure 10 highlights this confidence by showing a color - magnitude diagram of all high - confidence spectroscopic gd-1 stream candidates in regions 1 - 7 , shifted to a standard distance of 9 kpc based on the photometric hess diagram fitting .
these objects are also proper motion selected , in that only objects within @xmath131 of the proper motion of the best fit model are kept . superimposed over the spectral candidates
is the m92 fiducial sequence of @xcite shifted to a distance modulus of @xmath33 , identical to that used in figure 1 .
distances to the other regions were estimated as described in section 3 .
we now calculate our best metallicity estimate for gd-1 by selecting only the 48 stars with spectra in figure 10 .
we note that these stars were pre - cut on metallicity at an earlier stage ( figure 6 ) to have @xmath132 < -1.65 $ ] . a histogram with bins similar to the measurement error
yields a gd-1 stream metallicity of [ fe / h]@xmath133 dex with a dispersion of @xmath134 dex ( essentially the measurement error ) .
in addition to these statistical errors , there may be systematic errors in the metallicity determinations from sdss dr7 of @xmath135 dex @xcite .
we now use the data listed in table 1 to fit an orbit for the stream , assuming a fixed galactic potential .
@xcite postulated the progenitor of this stream is a globular cluster because it has a narrow width in the sky .
as a cluster orbits the galaxy , stars farther from the progenitor will depart from the orbit due to dynamical friction and scattering of the stream stars . because the progenitor is presumed to be a compact object with a few km s@xmath71 velocity dispersion , it is reasonable to assume that the stars in the tidal stream lie approximately on the orbit of the globular cluster @xcite .
dwarf galaxies , on the other hand , will experience larger spatial dispersions because they have larger dispersions in their energies . therefore , in this paper , we fit the orbit to the positions and velocities of the stars in the tidal stream .
the galactic potential model used in this work follows directly from @xcite .
we use a 3 component potential - disk , bulge , and halo , of the form given in equations ( [ disk ] ) , ( [ bulge ] ) , and ( [ halo ] ) .
@xmath136 @xmath137 @xmath138 in these potentials , @xmath139 and @xmath140 , where @xmath141 are galactocentric cartesian coordinates .
we adopt the sun - galactic center distance so that @xmath142 .
the symbol @xmath143 is the cylindrical radius from the center of the galaxy , whereas @xmath144 refers to the sun - centered distance to an arbitrary point along the stream . in these potentials ,
@xmath145 and @xmath146 are the masses of the disk and bulge , respectively .
the spatial extent of the potentials are determined by @xmath147 , the disk scale length , @xmath148 the disk scale height , @xmath149 the bulge scale radius , and @xmath150 the dark matter halo scale length .
additionally , @xmath151 describes the dark matter halo dispersion speed ( which is related to the total dark matter halo mass ) , and @xmath152 represents the dark matter halo flattening in the @xmath153 direction .
we found that the parameters of the galactic potential were not well constrained by the path of the tidal stream , so these parameters ( table [ parameters ] ) were held constant , with the same values used by @xcite . in this work
, we will fit four orbital parameters , given in table [ fitpars ] .
@xmath154 are the distance ( from the sun ) to , and velocities of , region 5 . given a galactic potential , these parameters fully specify the gc orbit .
we then evolve the test particle forward and backward from the starting location , using the @xmath155 and @xmath156 tools in the nemo stellar dynamics toolbox @xcite .
we convert the resulting orbit into @xmath61 and perform the goodness of fit calculation .
to find reasonable initial values for these parameters , we imagine placing a test particle in region 5 at @xmath157 kpc ) . we then construct a vector between the @xmath158 and @xmath159 points .
this gives us the direction of the total velocity , because we are assuming the orbit passes through both of these points .
the principle initial values for the parameters in region 5 are @xmath154 = ( 8.0 kpc , -94 km / s , -285 km / s , -104 km / s ) . in practice
we start searching for the best parameters in a range of values near these approximate values for the orbital parameters .
the parameter selection ranges are given in table [ fitpars ] . in order to find the best - fit orbit to the data given in table 1 ,
it is necessary to define a goodness - of - fit metric , and search the relevant parameters for the minimum value of this metric .
the metric for an orbit of this type involves three important factors : the orbit passing through the plate locations in the sky , having the proper velocities at these locations , and having the correct distances . in order to consider all of these factors , we define three chi - squared values , one for each of the relevant variables , and simply sum them to create the total goodness of fit metric . specifically , @xmath160 @xmath161 @xmath162 @xmath163 where @xmath164 , @xmath127 being the number of data points , and @xmath165 being the number of parameters . to calculate these @xmath166 values
, we calculate a model orbit using the selected parameters .
we search the orbit for the @xmath167 values from the plates , and use the associated values of @xmath148 , @xmath62 , and @xmath144 to compute @xmath166 .
we now optimize the orbital parameters so that @xmath166 is minimized . to do this
, we choose an initial set of parameters , calculate an orbit using the nemo stellar dynamics toolbox @xcite , and calculate @xmath166 .
we then use a gradient descent method to adjust the parameters to new values , generate a new orbit , and recalculate @xmath166 .
this process is continued until the true minimum value of @xmath166 is found , and the associated parameters describe the best fit orbit .
let the vector @xmath168 describe the parameters .
for each @xmath169 there is an associated @xmath170 .
we choose an initial set of parameters @xmath171 , and find @xmath172 .
we then iterate the parameters by equation ( [ gradientdescent ] ) .
@xmath173 we calculate the gradient using a finite difference method , shown in equation ( [ finitedifference ] ) . @xmath174 different values of @xmath175 are used because the parameters are on different scales , it would not be appropriate to use the same step size for them all .
the step sizes for the parameters are given in table [ fitpars ] .
@xmath176 is a variable - learning parameter .
it initially begins at @xmath177 , and if the new value of @xmath178 is smaller than the old , then @xmath176 is multiplied by @xmath179 , if not , it is multiplied by @xmath180 .
the purpose of this is to ensure if a minimum is being found , then it is found faster than with a constant - learning parameter .
we also multiply it by the associated @xmath175 value to make the step size appropriate for the parameter being considered .
the uncertainties of the best - fit parameters can be estimated from the shape of the @xmath166 surface at its minimum . to do this ,
we follow the method outlined by @xcite .
we construct a matrix @xmath181 of second partial derivatives of the @xmath166 surface , evaluated at the minimum found by the gradient descent . the error estimate for the @xmath182 parameter
is @xmath183 .
the @xmath181 matrix is defined as @xmath184 the matrix @xmath185 is the hessian matrix , whose elements are given by @xmath186
we select five initial sets of parameters by randomly choosing values within the ranges given in table [ fitpars ] .
we perform the gradient descent to reach the best fit parameters .
we then estimate the parameter errors using the hessian method outlined above .
the best - fit parameters and their errors are @xmath187 .
the chi - squared of this fit is 2.07 .
the negative velocities indicate a retrograde orbit .
the perigalacticon for this orbit is located @xmath188 kpc from the galactic center at @xmath189 , near region 6 .
the space velocity of stars in the model at this position is 276 @xmath60 .
the apogalacticon is at @xmath190 kpc from the galactic center , toward @xmath191 , though we do not observe this direction on the sky .
all errors are @xmath192 .
these orbital parameters are fairly insensitive to the choices of parameters in the galactic potential . in particular , they are good estimates of the orbital parameters for a wide range of @xmath152 and @xmath150 .
to investigate whether we could determine anything about the shape of the dark matter halo from this tidal tail , we performed parameter sweeps on @xmath152 and @xmath150 while keeping the kinematic parameters constant ( figure 11 ) .
we see that very low flattenings are inconsistent with the data , but a wide range of @xmath152 and @xmath150 are allowed .
the potential assumed in fitting the orbit is a standard logarithmic flat - rotation curve dark matter halo plus a stellar disk .
since the gd-1 stream approaches within 15 kpc of the galactic center , the effects of the massive disk are felt by the orbit , and increasing the relative mass of the disk vs. the halo can mimic the effects of a flattened halo . at perigalacticon ,
the disk exerts twice as much gravitational force as the halo . given this , it is not surprising that the stream orbit depends minimally on the halo parameters .
more models and constraints , from this and other streams , are clearly needed to constrain the shape of the dark matter halo .
the upper panel of figure 12 shows the orbit in @xmath61 with the stream locations shown .
the model prediction is in very good agreement with the experimental observations .
the middle and lower panels of figure 11 show the orbit in @xmath167 versus @xmath58 and @xmath167 versus distance from the sun .
we also see good agreement with the experimental observation .
figure 13 shows the orbit projected into the three planes of galactic coordinates @xmath141 .
we deduce an orbital eccentricity @xmath193 ( one sigma error ) and an inclination to the galactic plane of @xmath194 .
arrows show the relative direction of the stream s retrograde motion compared to the milky way .
the final columns of table 1 show the predicted proper motions ( @xmath97 ) for stars in the stream at each region 1 - 7 based on the distances in table 1 .
these predictions may be compared with actual observed proper motions for stream star candidates in table 2 at each region . in general
the agreement is quite good for regions 2 - 6 , given proper motion errors of @xmath195 in each coordinate .
spectral candidates more than @xmath196 away were excluded from figure 10 , dropping about 20% of the candidates , leaving a generally good fit to a shifted m92 fiducial sequence for these regions .
region 7 had fewer good proper motion matches , and it is possible that we are not seeing gd-1 stream candidates here .
figure 14 shows the photometrically chosen stars with proper motions available near regions 1,4,5 and 6 , along with an equivalent set of field stars ( chosen 5 degrees away ) for comparison .
there s a clear excess of ` on - stream ' stars in the lower right quadrant of each region on - stream these are likely stream members .
the estimated tangential velocities ( relative to the sun ) are given .
to search for a possible progenitor , we selected all milky way globular clusters from @xcite that had metallicities in the range @xmath197[fe / h]@xmath198
. only seven of these globular clusters ( terzan 8 , arp2 , ngc 6809 , ngc 6749 , ngc 6341 , ngc 6681 , and ngc 6752 ) are within @xmath76 of the gd-1 orbit .
additionally , we considered ngc 2298 , which is @xmath199 from the orbit , and has a metallicity of @xmath30 = -1.85 $ ] .
we compared the positions and velocities of these globular clusters with an orbital path that extends all the way around the milky way . to create a stream of
this length would require a globular cluster to orbit the milky way for on the order of gigayears , with the length depending on the concentration of the progenitor , as well as the shape and location of the progenitor s orbit .
of the eight globular clusters , ngc 6809 , ngc 6749 , and ngc 6752 are ruled out because their distances are more than a factor of two different from the distance to the orbit .
the remaining five clusters had radial velocities that are inconsistent with the predicted orbit by more than 50 km / s . we therefore conclude that the milky way globular cluster catalog published by @xcite does not contain the progenitor of this stream .
we use spectroscopic kinematic and abundance information to isolate stars in the gd-1 stream , and use the positions and velocities of those stars to derive orbital parameters for its orbit .
the gd-1 stream is moving very rapidly on a retrograde orbit around the milky way . in the region of the orbit which is detected
, it has a distance of about 7 - 11 kpc from the sun .
the stream s orbit takes it to apogalactic distances of @xmath200 kpc , and it has a perigalacticon of @xmath201 kpc , implying an eccentricity of @xmath202 .
the inclination to the galactic plane is about @xmath203 .
the metallicity of the stream is [ fe / h]@xmath204 plus systematic errors of a few tenths dex .
none of the known globular clusters in the milky way have positions , radial velocities , and metallicities that are consistent with being the progenitor of the gd-1 stream .
the consistency between the proper motions of these stream candidates and our best fit model gives us further confidence that we have identified stream members and that our model accurately represents the path on the sky of the stream stars .
while we claim only consistency here between the proper motion data and our model , we note that more detailed fits to the proper motion ( in addition to the radial velocities ) for such nearby streams can be a crucial tool in constraining the halo potential shape and other parameters .
we acknowledge a careful reading and several important suggestions from the anonymous referee which significantly improved the observational analysis section of this paper . b.a.w and h.j.n .
acknowledge support from the national science foundation , grant ast 06 - 06618 .
we gratefully acknowledge peter teuben for many useful nemo discussions and lee newberg for assisting us with calculating the measurement errors .
we also acknowledge useful discussion with linda sparke regarding streams in potentials . z.h.t .
acknowledges support from the national natural science foundation of china under grant no .
has received partial support for this work from grants phy 02 - 16783 and phy 08 - 22648 : physics frontiers center / joint institute for nuclear astrophysics ( jina ) , awarded by the u.s . national science foundation .
funding for the sdss and sdss - ii has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national science foundation , the u.s .
department of energy , the national aeronautics and space administration , the japanese monbukagakusho , the max planck society , and the higher education funding council for england .
the sdss web site is http://www.sdss.org/. the sdss is managed by the astrophysical research consortium for the participating institutions .
the participating institutions are the american museum of natural history , astrophysical institute potsdam , university of basel , cambridge university , case western reserve university , university of chicago , drexel university , fermilab , the institute for advanced study , the japan participation group , johns hopkins university , the joint institute for nuclear astrophysics , the kavli institute for particle astrophysics and cosmology , the korean scientist group , the chinese academy of sciences ( lamost ) , los alamos national laboratory , the max - planck - institute for astronomy ( mpia ) , the max - planck - institute for astrophysics ( mpa ) , new mexico state university , ohio state university , university of pittsburgh , university of portsmouth , princeton university , the united states naval observatory , and the university of washington .
abazajian , k. et al . , 2009 ,
apjs , submitted , arxiv:0812.0649 adelman - mccarthy , j.k . , ageros , m.a . ,
allam , s.s .
et al . , 2008 , apjs , 175 , 297 allende prieto , c. et al .
2008 aj , 136 , 2070 . an , d. , johnson , j.a . ,
clem , j. l. , et al .
, 2008 , apjs , in press , arxiv:0808.0001 bellazzini , m. , ferraro , f. , and ibata , r. 2002 , aj , 125 , 188b belokurov , v. , et al .
2007 , , 658 , 337 bullock , j. s. , & johnston , k. v. 2005 apj 635 , 931 chapman , s. c. et al .
2008 , mnras , submitted , arxiv:0808.0755 clem , j. l. , vanden berg , d. a. , & stetson , p. b. 2008 aj 135 , 682 cole , nathan , et al .
2008 , , 683 , 750 duffau , s. , zinn , r. , vivas , a. k. , carraro , g. , mendez , r. a. , winnick , r. , & gallart , c. 2006 , , 636 , l97 fellhauer , m. , belokurov , v. , evans , w. et al .
2006 , , 651 , 167 ferguson , a. m. n. , johnson , r. a. , faria , d. c. , irwin , m. j. , ibata , r. a. , johnston , k. v. , lewis , g. f. , & tanvir , n. r. 2005 , , 622 , l109 fukugita , m. , ichikawa , t. , gunn , j.e . , doi , m. , shimasaku , k. , and schneider , d.p .
1996 , aj , 111 , 1748 grillmair , c. j. & dionatos , o. 2006 , , 643 , l17 ( gd ) grillmair , c. j. 2006 , , 645 , l37 grillmair , c. j. , & johnson , r. 2006 , , 639 , l17 grillmair , c. j. 2006 , , 651 , l29 grillmair , c. j. , carlin , j. l. & majewski , s. r. 2008 , , 689 , l117 grillmair , c. j. arxiv:0811.3965 , apj , in press .
gunn , j.e .
, et al . 1998 , aj , 116 , 3040 gunn , j.e .
2006 , aj , 131 , 2332 harris , w. e. 1996 , , 112 , 1487 helmi , a. , 2004 , , 610 , l97 hogg , d. w. , finkbeiner , d.p . ,
schlegel , d.j . , and gunn , j.e .
2001 , aj , 122 , 2129 ibata , r. a. , gilmore , g. , and irwin , m.j .
1995 , mnras , 277 , 781 ibata , r. , irwin , m. , ferguson , a. m. n. , lewis , g. f. , tanvir , n. 2001 nature 412 , 49 ibata , r. , lewis , g. f. , irwin , m. , totten , e. , and quinn , t. 2001 , , 551 , 294 ivezic , z. , et al . 2004 , an , 325 , 583 law , david r. , johnston , kathryn v. , and majewkski , steven r. 2005 , , 619 , 807 lee , y. s. , et al . 2008a , , 136 , 2022 lee , y. s. , et al . 2008b , , 136 , 2050 leon , s. , meylan , g. , and combes , f. 2000 , aap , 359 , 907 majewski , steven r. , skrutskie , m. f. , weinberg , martin d. , ostheimer , james c. 2003 , , 549 , l199 martinez - delgado et al .
2001 , , 549 , l199 martinez - delgado et al .
2008 , , submitted , arxiv:0801.4657 martinez - delgado , d. , gabany , r. j. , pennarrubia , j. , rix , h .- w . , majewski , s. r. , trujillo , i. , & pohlen , m. , in `` highlights of spanish astrophysics v '' , proceedings of the viii scientific meeting of the spanish astronomical society ( sea ) , springer , arxiv:0812.3219 munn , j. a. et al .
2004 aj 127 , 3034 newberg , h.j . , yanny , b. , et al .
2002 , apj , 569 , 245 newberg , h.j . ,
yanny , b. , cole , n. , et al . , 2007,apj , 668 , 221 odenkirchen , m. , et al .
2001 , , 548 , l165 odenkirchen , m. , et al .
2003 , aj , 126 , 2385 pier , j.r . ,
munn , j.a .
, hindsley , r.b . ,
hennessy , g.s .
, kent , s.m . ,
lupton , r.h . , and ivezic , z. 2003 , aj , 125 , 1559 rockosi , c.m . , odenkirchen , m . ,
grebel , e.k .
et.al.,2002,aj 124 , 349 schlegel , d.j . , finkbeiner , d.p .
, & davis , m. 1998 , apj , 500 , 525 sirko , e. et al . 2004 aj 127 , 899 smith , j.a . , et al .
2002 , aj , 123 , 2121 stoughton , c. , et al .
2002 , aj , 123 , 485 teuben , p.j .
the stellar dynamics toolbox nemo , in : astronomical data analysis software and systems iv , ed .
r. shaw , h.e .
payne and j.j.e .
( 1995 ) , pasp conf series 77 , p398 .
tucker , d. , et al .
2006 , an , 327 , 821 vivas , a. k. et al .
2001 , , 554 , l33 yanny , b. , newberg , h. j. , et al .
2000 , , 540 , 825 yanny , b. , rockosi , c. , newberg , h. , knapp , g. et al .
2009 aj , submitted .
york , d.g .
2000 , , 120 , 1579 rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr 1&126.58&-0.22&224.47&0.5&20.88&0.5&108&259&5&11&-14.86&-6.72&3.66&10.4&1.2&7.0&-6.4 + 2&131.92&11.17&215.93&0.2&30.83&0.2&69&188 & & & -12.51&-3.27&3.32 & 6.5&0.6&8.6&-7.4 + 3&138.65&22.29&206.03&0.2&40.89&0.2 & & & & & -12.75&-2.31&4.57&7.0&0.4&10.0&-7.3 + 4&144.25&30.09&197.00&0.2&47.54&0.2&-7&39&1&3.9&-12.83&-1.47&5.52&7.5&0.3&10.9&-6.5 + 5&157.92&44.19&172.30&0.2&57.24&0.2&-71&-88&2&5.3&-12.30&0.58&6.74&8.0&0.5&11.8&-2.4 + 6&163.69&48.32&161.95&0.2&59.02&0.2&-87&-124&2&9.2&-12.30&1.41&7.54&8.8&0.8&11.5&-0.6 + 7&217.50&57.51&99.95&1.0&55.00&1.0 & & & & & -8.98&5.6&8.08&9.9&1.2&4.1&5.2 + rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr 1154 - 53083 - 266&1&125.683891&-0.439561&113.4&7.4&264.7&19.107&0.909&0.275&-1.89&0.08&3.46&0.25&3.5&-4.3 + 1154 - 53083 - 145&1&126.577150&-0.439386&97.8&7.8&249.4&19.102&0.904&0.180&-2.14&0.07&3.62&0.23&12.9&-10.5 + 1154 - 53083 - 155&1&126.645407&-0.340477&109.0&3.6&260.3&18.117&0.935&0.275&-2.06&0.04&3.30&0.22&11.6&-3.9 + 1760 - 53086 - 339&2&131.406984&9.770413&65.8&14.5&186.9&18.389&0.909&0.227&-2.18&0.11&4.05&0.29&9.4&-8.4 + 2671 - 54141 - 432&2&132.157853&11.135851&77.3&6.0&193.9&18.780&0.841&0.406&-2.24&0.04&3.54&0.22&10.0&-5.2 + 2667 - 54142 - 427&2&132.367656&11.325495&70.5&4.0&186.5&17.433&0.987&0.420&-2.17&0.02&2.77&0.24&6.7&-7.4 + 2667 - 54142 - 604&2&133.073392&12.266884&62.3&2.5&175.1&15.859&1.159&0.486&-2.08&0.03&2.22&0.15&8.4&-6.1 + 2319 - 53763 - 347&3&138.399875&22.413022&38.1&11.6&114.5&19.451&0.843&0.243&-2.24&0.22&3.80&0.09&13.2&-7.7 + 2319 - 53763 - 358&3&138.450751&22.434572&40.4&4.7&116.7&17.996&0.865&0.259&-1.93&0.02&3.90&0.10&12.5&-9.7 + 2319 - 53763 - 387&3&138.669378&22.559736&48.9&11.8&124.7&19.603&0.874&0.385&-2.07&0.07&3.68&0.30&12.1&-7.9 + 2889 - 54530 - 311&4&142.787815&29.461085&-0.9&4.2&47.8&17.454&0.972&0.417&-1.98&0.04&3.23&0.28&10.7&-9.4 + 2914 - 54533 - 297&4&142.978804&29.136307&-3.0&3.9&46.9&18.139&0.925&0.189&-2.09&0.04&3.94&0.16&8.8&-9.3 + 2889 - 54530 - 240&4&143.339524&29.620398&-6.2&4.7&41.7&17.933&0.883&0.256&-2.14&0.03&3.63&0.17&9.6&-6.7 + 2889 - 54530 - 204&4&143.424098&29.036453&-3.6&5.1&46.5&17.822&0.872&0.271&-2.21&0.05&3.28&0.20&6.7&-4.5 + 2889 - 54530 - 215&4&143.453188&29.120632&-3.4&1.7&46.4&14.981&1.194&-0.237&-2.09&0.11&3.20&0.17&9.5&-10.9 + 2889 - 54530 - 238&4&143.552948&29.477508&-4.3&4.6&44.1&17.843&0.888&0.293&-2.21&0.01&3.60&0.18&8.4&-9.1 + 2889 - 54530 - 225&4&143.597836&29.802697&-6.1&1.7&41.0&14.845&1.196&-0.102&-1.98&0.06&3.34&0.09&13.7&-11.1 + 2914 - 54533 - 171&4&143.718962&29.874100&-3.6&8.0&43.2&19.432&0.747&0.285&-2.26&0.08&3.33&0.56&15.4&-8.7 + 2914 - 54533 - 458&4&144.107345&30.737924&-9.8&4.8&33.6&18.716&0.779&0.216&-2.26&0.05&4.41&0.10&13.1&-6.5 + 2914 - 54533 - 453&4&144.120941&30.947724&-1.4&4.4&41.2&17.955&0.827&0.220&-2.10&0.02&3.79&0.28&14.3&-6.3 + 2914 - 54533 - 509&4&144.275720&30.280468&-4.4&3.9&40.6&18.292&0.909&0.187&-2.25&0.01&3.46&0.31&9.5&-12.2 + 2914 - 54533 - 515&4&144.487234&30.410401&-4.7&3.6&39.8&18.247&0.855&0.232&-1.82&0.04&3.72&0.15&10.5&-1.6 + 2914 - 54533 - 540&4&144.561728&30.968385&-1.9&11.0&40.4&20.190&0.854&0.344&-1.95&0.10&3.46&0.21&12.6&-3.8 + 2567 - 54179 - 396&5&157.181542&44.514349&-67.9&6.8&-85.0&18.745&0.841&0.254&-2.08&0.04&3.78&0.19&13.9&1.8 + 2567 - 54179 - 246&5&157.565788&43.643316&-73.0&6.0&-87.1&18.630&0.934&0.167&-2.23&0.01&3.71&0.18&12.9&-0.9 + 2567 - 54179 - 238&5&157.691771&43.797748&-71.9&12.7&-86.7&19.546&0.908&0.206&-2.21&0.02&3.27&0.16&10.1&-5.6 + 2567 - 54179 - 189&5&157.817344&43.923322&-70.1&11.9&-85.5&19.761&0.772&0.342&-1.88&0.07&4.23&0.36&9.0&3.5 + 2567 - 54179 - 211&5&157.889540&43.500286&-65.2&10.0&-79.0&19.309&0.901&0.205&-1.89&0.15&3.74&0.07&9.2&-0.3 + 2567 - 54179 - 212&5&158.051293&43.644022&-67.6&5.2&-82.1&18.349&0.839&0.208&-1.90&0.07&3.67&0.26&9.7&-0.2 + 2567 - 54179 - 170&5&158.137638&44.086320&-58.2&9.8&-74.4&19.112&0.863&0.201&-2.04&0.06&3.64&0.17&14.4&-1.7 + 2567 - 54179 - 491&5&158.437074&44.466389&-69.2&9.1&-87.1&18.242&0.880&0.209&-2.02&0.09&3.95&0.16&8.9&-1.9 + 2567 - 54179 - 511&5&158.700621&44.530392&-68.9&4.4&-87.2&18.083&0.954&0.237&-2.22&0.01&3.18&0.25&12.1&1.3 + 2557 - 54178 - 498&5&158.747249&44.686776&-74.2&3.9&-93.2&16.794&1.048&0.476&-2.12&0.02&2.60&0.27&13.5&2.7 + 2410 - 54087 - 297&6&162.371533&47.207633&-87.0&6.9&-118.3&18.893&0.885&0.255&-2.26&0.02&3.46&0.20&15.4&-1.3 + 2410 - 54087 - 236&6&162.451620&48.002695&-85.2&4.2&-119.5&18.305&0.896&0.250&-1.71&0.04&3.51&0.21&8.6&4.8 + 2410 - 54087 - 288&6&162.547222&46.990942&-88.0&12.2&-118.7&19.344&0.893&0.164&-2.08&0.08&3.78&0.14&9.6&-3.8 + 2390 - 54094 - 256&6&162.557763&47.251097&-95.0&2.6&-126.6&16.945&1.048&0.036&-1.83&0.00&3.89&0.19&16.1&-1.5 + 2410 - 54087 - 380&6&162.743760&48.903984&-85.3&5.1&-123.1&18.632&0.840&0.269&-1.80&0.07&3.81&0.05&12.7&-1.6 + 2410 - 54087 - 173&6&163.799206&47.813588&-88.8&7.1&-123.6&18.828&0.845&0.200&-2.06&0.07&3.86&0.30&8.9&-1.8 + 2410 - 54087 - 539&6&164.064054&49.034036&-92.2&8.2&-131.6&19.293&0.925&0.169&-1.68&0.11&3.10&0.30&8.1&-1.7 + 2410 - 54087 - 501&6&164.334475&48.472850&-81.1&7.8&-118.8&19.401&0.925&0.202&-1.76&0.08&3.80&0.28&7.3&0.0 + 2410 - 54087 - 504&6&164.371325&48.224481&-90.6&8.8&-127.4&19.409&0.841&0.208&-1.75&0.07&4.30&0.14&11.3&-0.6 + 2390 - 54094 - 565&6&164.616981&49.202693&-81.1&2.0&-121.6&16.919&1.105&0.487&-1.86&0.01&2.93&0.19&6.9&3.7 + 2390 - 54094 - 615&6&165.199453&48.669262&-92.4&3.9&-131.5&17.895&0.896&0.385&-2.24&0.02&3.81&0.16&11.8&-1.7 + 2410 - 54087 - 637&6&165.381730&48.671045&-87.1&6.2&-126.4&18.928&0.887&0.206&-2.29&0.05&3.84&0.12&7.8&-0.2 + 2539 - 53918 - 406&7&217.430060&59.067783&-163.8&3.0&-297.5&15.805&1.226&-0.133&-2.11&0.03&3.29&0.12&5.9&3.7 + 2539 - 53918 - 070&7&219.681591&57.897316&-148.9&10.7&-283.7&17.970&0.862&0.199&-2.15&0.02&3.73&0.04&2.5&10.8 + 2539 - 53918 - 596&7&219.898491&58.258368&-157.6&5.5&-293.3&17.035&1.197&-0.167&-2.10&0.26&2.92&0.43&1.0&2.9 + cc @xmath20 & @xmath205 + @xmath145 & @xmath206 + @xmath146 & @xmath207 + @xmath147 & @xmath208
kpc + @xmath148 & @xmath209 kpc + @xmath149 & @xmath210 kpc + @xmath151 & @xmath211 km / s + @xmath152 & 1.0 + @xmath150 & 12 kpc + [ parameters ] cccc @xmath212 & sun - centered distance of region 5 & 0.1 kpc & 5 : 13 kpc + @xmath213 & x velocity of region 5 & 1 km / s & -130 : -60 km / s + @xmath214 & y velocity of region 5 & 1 km / s & -320 : -230 km / s + @xmath215 & z velocity of region 5 & 1 km / s & -80 : -120 km / s + [ fitpars ] | we use velocity and metallicity information from sdss and segue stellar spectroscopy to fit an orbit to the narrow @xmath0 stellar stream of grillmair and dionatos .
the stars in the stream have a retrograde orbit with eccentricity @xmath1 ( perigalacticon of 14.4 kpc and apogalacticon of 28.7 kpc ) and inclination approximately @xmath2 . in the region of the orbit which is detected
, it has a distance of about 7 to 11 kpc from the sun . assuming a standard disk plus bulge and logarithmic halo potential for the milky way stars plus dark matter , the stream stars are moving with a large space velocity of approximately @xmath3 at perigalacticon . using this stream alone , we are unable to determine if the dark matter halo is oblate or prolate .
the metallicity of the stream is [ fe / h ] @xmath4
. observed proper motions for individual stream members above the main sequence turnoff are consistent with the derived orbit .
none of the known globular clusters in the milky way have positions , radial velocities , and metallicities that are consistent with being the progenitor of the gd-1 stream . |
magnetoelectric ( me ) effects in multiferroic ( mf ) or ferromagnetic ( metallic ) films have brought remarkable interest since promising technological applications in spintronics and ultrafast electric field control on magnetic data storage are seen as imminent@xcite,@xcite .
characterization of the relative strength for the me coupling can be obtained by implementing terahertz spectroscopy in rare earth manganites of the type rmno@xmath2 ( r = tb , gd , dy , eu : y ) @xcite,@xcite,@xcite,@xcite demonstrating that the generated electromagnons ( mixed spin - waves and photon states ) represent , among others , the signature of the me effect for an approximate range of frequencies between 10 @xmath3 and 40 @xmath3 at temperatures where antiferromagnetic resonance modes ( afmr ) coexist , or more recently , the key mechanism for controllable magnetochromism in ba@xmath4mg@xmath4fe@xmath5o@xmath6 hexaferrites @xcite . the magnetoelectric effect emerges when a magnetic field @xmath7 can induce a polarization vector @xmath8 at zero applied electric field ( @xmath9 ) .
likewise , the magnetization of the substance @xmath10 can be generated for an electric field @xmath11 with @xmath12 .
the minimal coupling for describing the thermodynamic potential associated with this effect is given by @xmath13 , where @xmath14 is an unsymmetrical magnetoelectric tensor , whose components depend on the magnetic symmetry class@xcite . the primary origin for the me coupling is commonly associated with the dzyaloshinskii - moriya relativistic exchange - interaction @xcite,@xcite which is appropriate for the description of asymmetric spin wave dispersion on double layer fe - films@xcite as well as for those materials where weak ferromagnetism emerges , namely the ilmenite fetio@xmath2 , tbmno@xmath2 , eu@xmath15y@xmath16mno@xmath2 ( @xmath17 at @xmath18 k@xcite ) or the widely studied pyroelectric ferromagnet bamnf@xmath1 @xcite . weak ferromagnetism on this compound is generated by canting effects between antiferromagnetic sub - lattices , leading to a spontaneous polarization @xmath8 perpendicular to the resulting magnetization @xmath10@xcite .
considerations in the symmetry change of the static polarization and magnetization fields have brought interesting unconventional optical phenomena labeled as non - reciprocal dichroism associated with the sign reversal of @xmath19 , recently reported in the perovskite eu@xmath20y@xmath21mno@xmath22 , with magnetoelectric activity for photon energies around 0.8 mev ( sub thz regime ) in the cycloidal phase at 4 k@xcite .
intense activity in the last decade has also been dedicated to achieve possible optical and photonic band gap control via surface plasmon ( sp ) propagation in periodic arrays@xcite , since modern lithographic techniques allow to design functional objects with almost any desirable geometrical pattern at a sub - wavelength scale@xcite .
plasmon localization and its coupling with incident light depend on the dielectric properties of the metal in conjunction of its surrounding environment , enlightening an alternative route for engineering highly efficient sp photonic devices via externally applied fields , rare earth doping or electron charge transference from the modified metal@xcite . in this communication
, we study an electrodynamic - based model for estimating the optical response generated by the contact between a material exhibiting weak ferromagnetism in contact with a 2d metallic film .
it is found that a specific strength of the me interaction might couple with localized charge - sheet modes for electron carrier densities about @xmath23 @xmath24 and incident frequencies around 18 @xmath3 , leading to a change in the reflectance from the metallic film . applied magnetic field effects on relative reflective
are discussed in section iii .
localized charge - sheet modes in a 2d conducting medium in the framework of drude approximation is obtained from the nakayama result @xcite,@xcite,@xcite : @xmath25 where @xmath26 corresponds to the quasiwavevector in the @xmath27 direction , @xmath28 is defined as @xmath29 and @xmath30 denotes the electron density concentration in a two dimensional space .
@xmath31 is related with the wavevector along @xmath32-direction through @xmath33 , ( @xmath34 ) .
the term @xmath35 represents the relative dielectric function value for @xmath36-th medium , with @xmath37 for vacuum . in the range of wavelengths behind the far infrared radiation ( @xmath38 mm ) , the dielectric function approaches to the well recognized lyddane - sachs - teller ( lst ) relationship : @xmath39 , where @xmath40 corresponds to the dielectric permittivity of the medium @xmath41 and @xmath42 represents the longitudinal ( transverse)-optical phonon frequency . for numerical purposes ,
we have set @xmath43 , which coincides with the relationship for the @xmath44-axis normal phonon modes in bamnf@xmath1 .
the permittivity @xmath40 is a functional depending on mechanical strain deformations and polarization field depletion in the proximities between the multiferroic slab and metal film@xcite , and is taken as constant for zero applied ( electric ) field and fixed temperature .
formula ( [ nakay ] ) is derived by solving the complete set of maxwell equations with normal ( tm wave ) incidence for @xmath45 , and boundary conditions on the plane @xmath46 with the _ ansatz _ for propagating fields @xmath47 in the region @xmath46 .
magnetoelectric effects are taken into consideration throughout the transverse susceptibility @xmath48 and the electric displacement vector @xmath49 is written into the constitutive equation like @xmath50 . after inserting the additional term @xmath51 $ ] , the expression ( [ nakay ] ) shall be modified under @xmath52 . in the plane
@xmath46 , and in agreement with the geometrical configuration shown in figure ( [ r0 ] ) , the non - zero surface current density component is defined as @xmath53 , where @xmath54 corresponds to the @xmath55-element of the generalized conductivity tensor@xcite , and @xmath56 is the electrical field propagating on the @xmath32 direction .
[ fig1 ] the generic expression for the transverse susceptibility @xmath48 is obtained from first principles by minimizing the free - energy density functional @xmath57 , which contains the two sublattice magnetizations , the polarization as well as external fields .
it can be summarized as : @xmath58 $ ] , where @xmath59 is a coupling parameter which is an involved function of the canting angle between two adjacent ( antiferromagnetic ) sublattices , the spontaneous magnetization @xmath10 and the polarization vector @xmath8 , as well as the parameters @xmath60 .
factor @xmath61 is defined in terms of the characteristic magnetoelectric frequency @xmath62 as @xmath63 , given in units of mm@xmath64 all throughout this paper@xcite , in concordance with the spectral weight intrinsically associated with the fitting procedure for the transmittance spectra via lorentzian model in various multiferroic species , namely rmn@xmath65o@xmath66(r : y , tb ) , tbmno@xmath22 or lumno@xmath2@xcite , and its dependence with the externally applied magnetic field has been neglected for small canting angles ( see for instance eqs .
( 38 ) and ( 47 ) in reference [ 14 ] .
two main poles are clearly identified for @xmath48 : the optical antiferromagnetic resonance mode ( afmr ) @xmath67 and the soft - phonon along @xmath10 with resonance frequency @xmath68 , with @xmath69 .
classical plasmon excitations in low 2d carrier electron density are experimentally detected and theoretically estimated for wavevectors @xmath70 @xmath3 and energies @xmath71 mev@xcite , @xcite,@xcite , therefore the condition @xmath72 remains valid in the range of interest , and the dispersion relationship for the coupled magnetoelectric plasma mode is obtained by solving the modified equation ( [ nakay ] ) : @xmath73,\ ] ] with @xmath74 , @xmath75 and @xmath76 . for @xmath77 , i.e. , no magnetoelectric effects taken under consideration , we reproduce the expression for the localized plasmon mode @xcite : @xmath78 where ( @xmath79 ) sign in equation ( [ cuasiwv ] ) has been selected .
complex index of refraction @xmath80 is directly estimated from the wavenumber @xcite @xmath81 @xmath82 .
the lowest - order reflectance coefficient @xmath83 for normal incidence is defined as @xmath84 and its numerical profile discussed on the next section .
@xmath80 can be considered as the _ effective _ index of refraction for the composite 2d metallic foil in contact with a multiferroic ( ferroelectric ) system under normal incidence of a electromagnetic wave oscillating in the thz regime . applied magnetic field @xmath85 along @xmath86-direction enters into the formalism by taking symmetry considerations upon the dependence of the electrical conductivity as a function of @xmath85 under the transformation @xmath87 , with @xmath88 .
expression ( [ cuasiwv ] ) may be reconstructed as : @xmath89 @xmath90,\ ] ] with @xmath91 . the classical localized magnetoplasmon mode ( [ qy ] )
is rewritten for @xmath92 and under @xmath93 like@xcite : @xmath94 in similarity with the result ( [ qy ] ) . in this particular case
the antireflective condition ( @xmath95 ) depends on the external magnetic field intensity @xmath96 , which leads to a quadratic correlation @xmath97 for @xmath98 . for an arbitrary orientation of @xmath0 , equation ( [ nakay ] ) shall be modified on its right side accordingly @xmath99 , where @xmath100 is a function of the directors @xmath101@xcite .
optical reflectivity response for this structure might also be verified by adapting the rouard method@xcite,@xcite : @xmath102 where @xmath103 corresponds to the internal reflectivity between media labeled @xmath104 ( @xmath36 ) and @xmath105 is the phase difference on the second medium with thickness @xmath106 , defined as @xmath107 .
the index of refraction @xmath108 is a function of the components for the conductivity tensor @xmath109 $ ] depending on the incoming electromagnetic field polarization . in this particular case , it is calculated as : @xmath110 while @xmath55 is explicitly given by @xmath111 where @xmath112 represents the electronic plasma frequency for the _ bulk _ system , which is related to @xmath113 through @xmath114 where @xmath115 being the volumetric electron density concentration .
reference values for plasma frequencies were taken as @xmath116 hz and @xmath117 hz for gold ( au ) in the framework of the drude model fitting@xcite .
factors @xmath103 in formula ( [ rou ] ) are given explicitly by @xmath118 , and @xmath119 , with @xmath120 .
indeces of refraction are directly obtained by reconstructing the set of maxwell equations on each material media . in the general case , taking into account the me effect in the formalism by inserting the tensor @xmath121 $ ] , the propagating electric field @xmath11 must satisfy : @xmath122\mathbf{e}\right)_{m - mf}\\ \nonumber + \omega^{2}\mu_{0}\mathbf{d}_{m - mf}+4\pi\omega\nabla\times\left(\left[\chi\right]\mathbf{e}\right)_{m - mf},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath123 $ ] is the conductivity tensor , and @xmath49 previously defined as the electric displacement vector , and subscript @xmath124 indicates the region where fields propagation are evaluated , namely the metal ( m ) or multiferroic ( mf ) slab .
figure ( [ r1 ] ) exhibits the zero field reflectance response as a function of the 2d electronic carrier concentration @xmath30 , for different wavelengths and the magneto - electric coupling parameter @xmath61 fixed at @xmath125 mm@xmath64 , the dielectric permittivity values have been taken as @xmath126 and @xmath127 for the pyroelectric ferromagnet bamnf@xmath1 , which correspond to the values measured along its @xmath128 and @xmath44 crystallographic axes , respectively .
dotted curves ( a ) and ( b ) are set as reference for @xmath92 .
comparative results are shown for rouard s method ( rm ) and the modified nakayama ( n ) expression ( eq . [ nakay ] ) , indicating the change in the reflectivity spectra under the me effect and different values for the dielectric constant @xmath129 .
the reflectance response increases from @xmath130 ( @xmath131 ) to @xmath132 ( @xmath133 ) for electronic densities lower than @xmath134 @xmath24 , while it augments monotonically to @xmath135 for electronic concentrations greater than @xmath136 @xmath24 regardless of the value of @xmath61 , in the framework of the rm approach .
one of the discrepancies with the nakayama results is due to the difference between the 2d intrinsic plasma frequency @xmath113 and those associated with the plasma frequency in the _ bulk _ system @xmath137 .
variation in the electronic carrier density in the former case has been simulated by inserting the thickness film dependence @xmath106 on @xmath137 , providing good agreement for @xmath138 nm ( @xmath139 @xmath24 ) as proven in fig.([comp ] ) .
minima of reflectivity obtained from eq .
( [ cuasiwv ] ) , are located at @xmath140 , or @xmath141 , indicating that the critical wavelength for _ bare _ plasmon excitations is larger as the electronic concentration decreases .
afmr mode lies in the range thz range , with @xmath142 thz , while the transverse phonon frequency is taken as 7.53 thz for the bamnf@xmath1 compound@xcite .
metallic behavior predominates for concentrations higher than @xmath143 @xmath24 and smaller than @xmath144 @xmath24 and selected wavelengths between 0.5 mm and 0.6 mm .
resonant plasmon modes ( i.e. , collective electronic excitations under me interaction ) are important for carrier densities around @xmath145 @xmath24 , where radiative absorption or antireflective phenomena become strong and the reflectance spectrum is therefore significantly modified by diminishing the percentage of absorbed radiation only when the external frequency approaches the characteristic mode @xmath67 , and @xmath146 .
figure ( [ r2 ] ) depicts the shifting of the minimum of reflectance in the @xmath147 plane for the nakayama approach .
the me effect becomes relevant by decreasing the _ critical _ carrier density @xmath148 as @xmath61 increases , and it remains essentially unmodified for those frequencies away from the afmr characteristic mode as indicated in line ( d ) . dotted vertical line is tagged at @xmath133 mm@xmath64 as a eye guide for identifying the critical density change as the incident wavelength varies around @xmath149 .
critical density @xmath150 shall be understood as the electron carrier concentration which maximizes antireflective effects for the composite metal / multiferroic system .
figure ( [ bparallel0 ] ) shows the reflectance response under applied magnetic field with magnitude @xmath151 t for different directions on the @xmath152 plane .
afmr resonance at @xmath153 is not essentially affected by the orientation of the external field , but it becomes sensitive with the azimuthal angle for frequencies between the edge of the thz range and the microwave ( shf ) band .
highly reflective effects are more intense for external magnetic fields which are applied in the opposite direction with respect to the weak ferromagnetic state @xmath10 , favoring the metallic behavior for long wavelengths and shielding the resulting me interaction . _ in - plane _ applied field @xmath0 effects on the reflectance as a function of carrier density @xmath30 are illustrated in fig .
( [ bparallel ] ) .
@xmath154 tends to increase for @xmath0 parallel to @xmath155-axis and decreases for @xmath0 along @xmath156 axis .
curve ( b ) for null @xmath0 overlaps the outcome of @xmath157 at @xmath158 t , @xmath159 and @xmath160 ( i.e. , parallel to @xmath32 axis ) , indicating no substantial variation in the optical reflectance for applied fields in the same direction of the plasmonic wavevector @xmath161 for carrier densities smaller than @xmath162 @xmath24 . equation ( [ max ] ) has also been treated by implementing finite element method ( fem ) and standard boundary conditions for @xmath49 and @xmath163\mathbf{e}$ ] fields in order to calculate the reflectance response as a function of incident wavelengths .
comparative results on the calculated response of the reflectance are shown in figures ( [ comp ] ) and ( [ 3cc ] ) . under nakayama
s formalism , the metallic medium is treated as a 2d system , while rouard and fem methods converge with the first one for a film thickness around @xmath138 nm , which roughly corresponds to an electronic carrier density of 147.42 @xmath24 after calculating the correlation between two intrinsic plasma frequencies @xmath137 and @xmath113 .
iso - reflective lines for @xmath164@xcite close to @xmath153 and the externally applied magnetic field ( in @xmath86 direction ) are shown in figure ( [ control ] ) .
projected lines preserve symmetrical distribution under magnetic field inversion nearby @xmath165 although strong fluctuations and a sign flip on @xmath166 are present for wavelengths slightly different from @xmath165 and magnetic fields greater than @xmath167 t , indicating that interacting me and plasmonic activity might increase the reflectance outcome from systems with low electronic density and without applied field .
we have developed a model for studying the magnetoelectric interactions on 2d plasmonic modes in the thz range for a metal / multiferroic composite device .
the multiferroic medium exhibits weak ferromagnetism and the metallic behavior enters into the formalism in the framework of the classical drude - lorentz model .
relative reflectance response for normal incidence is numerically calculated for a particular me coupling strength @xmath61 and wavelengths near to the optical antiferromagnetic resonance frequency @xmath168 by using three different approaches : nakayama s formalism , rouard s method and finite elements ( fem ) .
characteristic soft phonon and afmr frequencies were taken for the pyroelectric ferromagnet bamnf@xmath1 , showing that a particular condition for reflectivity might be adjustable by varying the intensity of the applied field , its orientability , film thickness or incident frequency of radiation , mainly in a range @xmath169 .
spectra of reflectance demonstrate that the magnetoelectric interaction predominates for metallic film thicknesses smaller than 25 nm in the thz regime , while for thicker films ( 50 - 100 nm ) the optical outcomes are not significantly affected by this interaction ; instead , total reflectance from the film is observed along a wide range of frequencies up to the cut - off bulk value @xmath170 phz , in which reflectivity decays abruptly to zero and exhibits oscillatory behavior for greater frequencies .
the chosen value of @xmath112 is into the typical order of magnitude for good conductors like gold , silver or copper , despite that the calculations and comparison with the strictly 2d system were made just for the first one .
there is not a clear signature of the plasmonic cut - off for intermediate film thicknesses ( 25 - 50 nm ) and the reflectivity curve does not breach abruptly as for wider ones ; rather , it reaches its maximum value in a broad interval of @xmath171 hz , suggesting a variation of the effective dielectric response associated with the metal under me interaction .
further analysis shall be proposed for other metals or semiconducting materials , since optical control experiments on the thz range have recently been achieved on gaas wafers via stimulated photocarriers generated by interband light absorption .
the resulting reflectivity spectrum is tuned from antireflective ( @xmath172 ) to high reflective ( @xmath173 ) limits under controlled power illumination@xcite,@xcite .
although all numerical simulations were conducted for @xmath174 , ( @xmath175 being taken as @xmath176 and @xmath177 in the range of interest ) , simultaneous electric field control @xmath178 on optical properties for the composite device might also be achieved under the dielectric function dependence for a multiferroic material @xmath179 $ ] , the polarization @xmath180 and temperature , issue that shall be addressed in future investigations .
h.v . wants to thank computing accessibility at pom group .
c. v .- h .
acknowledges financial support provided by dima , _ direccin de investigacin sede manizales _ , universidad nacional de colombia . h.v .
declares no competing financial interest .
00 c - g duan , j. p. velev , r. f. sabirianov , z. zhu , j. chu , s. s. jaswal and e. y. tsymbal , phys .
* 101 * , 137201 ( 2008 ) .
l. gerhard , t. k. yamada , t. balashov , a. f. takcs , r. j. h. wesselink , m. dne , m. fechner , s. ostanin , a. ernst , i. mertig and w. wulfhekel , nature nanotechnology * 5 * , 792 ( 2010 ) .
doi:10.1038/nnano.2010.214 a. pimenov , a. m. shuvaev , a. a. mukhin and a. loidl , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 20 * , 434209 ( 2008 ) .
d. talbayev , s. a. trugman , a. v. balatsky , t. kimura , a. j. taylor and r. d. averitt , physical review letters * 101 * , 097603 ( 2008 ) .
h. n@xmath181mec , f. kadlec , p. ku@xmath182el , l. duvillaret and j .- l .
coutaz , optics communications * 260 * , 175 ( 2006 ) .
a. pimenov , a. a. mukhin , v. yu ivanov , v. d. travkin , a. m. balbashov and a. loidl , nature physics * 2 * , 97 - 100 ( 2006 ) .
n. kida and y. yokura , journal of magnetism and magnetic materials * 324 * , 3512 ( 2012 ) .
l. d. landau , e. m. lifshitz and l. p. pitaevskii , _ electrodynamics of continuous media _ , 2nd ed .
, ch.*v * , butterworth - heinemann ( 2006 ) .
h. katsura , n. nagaosa and a. v. balatsky , physical review letters * 95 * , 057205 ( 2005 ) .
h. katsura , a. v. balatsky and n. nagaosa , physical review letters * 98 * , 027203 ( 2007 ) .
zakeri , y. zhang , j. prokop , t .- h .
chuang , n. sakr , w. x. tang and j. kirschner , physical review letters * 104 * , 137203 ( 2010 ) .
a. a. mukhin , v. yu ivanov , v. d. travkin , a. s. prokhorov , a. a. volkov , a. v. pimenov , a. m. shuvaev and a. loidl , phys .- usp * 52 * , 851 ( 2009 ) .
doi : 10.3367/ufne.0179.200908j.0904 j. f. scott , rep .
prog . phys . *
42 * , 1055 ( 1979 )
. v. gunawan and r. l. stamp , j. phys .
: condensed matter * 23 * , 105901 ( 2011 ) .
y. takahashi , r. shimano , y. kaneko , h. murukawa and y. tokura , nature physics * 8 * , 121 ( 2012 ) , doi:10.1038/nphys2161 w. l. barnes , a. dereux and t. w. ebbensen , nature * 424 * , 824 ( 2003 ) .
s. li , m. jadidi , t. e. murphy and g. kumar , optical express * 21 * no . 6 , 7041 ( 2013 ) . h. j. freund , surface science * 601 * , 1438 ( 2007 ) .
m. nakayama j. phys .
soc . jpn.*36 * , 393 ( 1974 ) . m. cottam and d. r. tilley , _ introduction to surface and superlattice excitations _ , cambridge university press ( 1989 ) .
j. m. pitarke , v. m. silkin , e. v. chulkov and p. m. echenique , rep .
. phys . * 70 * , 1 - 87 ( 2007 ) .
s. zhong , s. alpay , v , nagarajan , j. mater . res .
* 21 * ( 6 ) ( 2006 ) 1600 .
j. slyom , _ fundamentals of the physics of solids _ , vol .
ii , springer - verlag ( 2009 ) .
d. r. tilley and j. f. scott , physical review b * 25 * , 3251 ( 1982 ) .
k. l. livesey and r. l. stamps , physical review b * 81 * , 094405 ( 2010 ) . j .-
rivera , eur .
j. b. * 71 * , 299 ( 2009 ) .
a. b. sushkov , r. valds aguilar , s. park , s - w .
cheong and h. d. drew , physical review letters * 98 * , 027202 ( 2007 ) .
e. h. hwang and s. das sarma , physical review b * 64 * , 165409 ( 2001 ) .
i. a. nechaev , v. m. silkin and e. v. chulkov , journal of experimental and theoretical physics * 112 * , issue 1 , pp 134 - 139 ( 2011 ) .
f. kanjouri , a. h. esmailian and m. molayem , eur .
j. b * 79 * , 429 ( 2011 ) .
g. r. fowles , _ introduction to modern optics _ , second edition , dover ( 1989 ) ; j. b. marion and m. a. heald , _ classical electromagnetic radiation _ , second edition , chapter * 6 * , academic press ( 1980 ) .
@xmath183 , with @xmath184 , @xmath185 and @xmath186 , @xmath187 and @xmath188 .
p. lecaruyer , e. maillart , m. canva and j. rolland , applied optics * 45 * , 8419 ( 2006 ) .
o. s. heavens , _ optical properties of thin solid films _ , chapter * 4 * , dover publications ( 1991 ) .
e. j. zeman and g. c. schatz , j. phys .
91(3 ) , 634 - 643 ( 1987 ) .
j. barna , journal of magnetism and magnetic materials * 62 * , 381 ( 1986 ) .
m. a. eriksson , a. pinczuk , b. s. dennis , c. f. hirjibehedin , s. h. simon , l. n. pfeiffer , k.w .
west , physica e * 6 * , 165 ( 2000 ) .
j. d. e. mcintyre and d. e. aspnes , surface science * 24 * , 417 ( 1970 ) .
l. fekete , j. y. hlinka , f. kadlec , p. ku@xmath182el and p. mounaix , optical letters , * 30 * , no .
15 , 1992 ( 2005 ) .
_ recent developments in terahertz optoelectronics
_ , edited by jean - louis coutaz , comptes rendus physique , * 9 * , issue 2 , pages 127 - 284 ( 2008 ) . | the rle of the magnetoelectric effect upon optical reflectivity is studied by adapting an electrodynamic - based model for a system composed by a 2d metallic film in contact with an extended multiferroic material exhibiting weak ferromagnetism .
the well - known _ nakayama s _ boundary condition is reformulated by taking into account the magnetoelectric coupling as well as an externally applied magnetic field @xmath0 in an arbitrary direction . it is found that the reflectance shows strong fluctuations for incident radiation close to the characteristic antiferromagnetic resonance frequency associated with the multiferroic material in the thz regime . these results were verified for a 10 nm metallic foil by using a finite element method ( fem ) and the rouard s approach , for a wide range of wavelengths ( 0.1 - 5 mm ) , showing good agreement with respect to nakayama s outcome , for the particular material bamnf@xmath1 .
+ + _ keywords : _ multiferroics , magnetoelectric effect , surface plasmon , reflectance . |
this paper completes the proof that the pairs of graphs as in fig .
[ graph ] are not realized as ( dual ) principal graphs of any subfactor for @xmath0 .
these graphs are a part of the list of graphs given by haagerup in 1991 in @xcite as candidates which might be realized as ( dual ) principal graphs of subfactors .
bisch proved that a subfactor with ( dual ) principal graph ( 4 ) in @xcite does _ not _ exist @xcite by checking the inconsistency of fusion rules on the graph .
haagerup and the first author proved that two pairs of graphs : the case @xmath1 of ( 2 ) ( see figure [ graph ] ) as well as the case ( 3 ) in @xcite , are realized as ( dual ) principal graphs of subfactors , and that such subfactors are unique respectively ( @xcite ) .
the remaining problem was whether the graphs for the case @xmath2 of ( 2 ) as in figure [ graph ] would be realized as ( dual ) principal graphs of subfactors .
haagerup proved that the obstruction , as found for the case ( 4 ) by bisch , does not exist on any of the pairs of the graphs in ( 2 ) .
moreover , he proved that a unique biunitary connection exists for each pair of the graphs ( @xcite ) .
for the case @xmath3 , it was numerically checked by ikeda that the biunitary connection should be flat ( @xcite ) . in 2005 ,
etingof , nikshych , and ostrik showed in ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 8.51 ) , that the index of a subfactor has to be a cyclotomic integer , namely an algebraic integer that lies in a cyclotomic field .
the result is essentially based on the result by a. coste and t.gannon in @xcite , that shows that the entries of the @xmath4-matrix of a modular tensor category are in some cyclotomic field .
this implies that if the square of the perron - frobenius eigenvalue ( pfev ) of a graph is not a cyclotomic integer , the graph can not be the ( dual ) principal graph of a subfactor . utilizing this new fact ,
the first author proved that the graphs in figure [ graph ] are not ( dual ) principal graphs for @xmath5 for @xmath6 by showing that for each @xmath6 , the galois group of the minimal polynomial @xmath7 of the square @xmath8 of pfev of each graph is not abelian : it is actually a symmetric group . by the kronecker - weber theorem ( @xcite ) , this implies that the @xmath8 s for @xmath9 in said range , are not cyclotomic integers .
the first author also checked that for the case @xmath10 , @xmath11 is a cyclotomic integer .
kondo s result in @xcite , that implies that the galois group of an irreducible polynomial with square - free discriminant should be symmetric , played an essential role there . in this paper
we prove , by further utilizing algebraic number theory , that none of the graphs in figure [ graph ] can be realized a ( dual ) principal graph for @xmath12 .
we prove that the @xmath8 s for @xmath12 are not only not cyclotomic integers , but actually the field extension @xmath13 over @xmath14 is not even a galois extension : notice that if @xmath13 was contained in some cyclotomic field , the extension @xmath15 is necessarily galois , since it corresponds to a subgroup of an abelian group , which is automatically a normal subgroup .
the first author would like to thank t. banica for valuable discussions , especially for bringing @xcite to attention , which contained a change of variable used in
[ irred ] , and d. bisch , v. jones and y. kawahigashi for pointing out the result in @xcite .
m.a . also thanks rims for hospitality during the visit in may 2007 , that made this collaboration possible .
in the following , we list some theorems in algebraic number theory necessary for later discussion . most of them are directly cited from references .
we give all the proofs for the statements for which we could not find a reference .
[ unit ] let @xmath16 is an algebraic integer such that all the conjugates have the complex absolute value equal to one . then @xmath16 is a root of unity . *
* + let @xmath17 be the number of the conjugates of @xmath16 . for any @xmath18 , there is @xmath19 such that @xmath20 let @xmath21 , where the product is taken over all conjugates @xmath22 s of @xmath16 .
then @xmath23 therefore we may choose @xmath19 so that @xmath24 is arbitrarily close to @xmath25 .
on the other hand , @xmath26 is also an algebraic integer , and its conjugates are given by @xmath27 s .
therefore they are roots of an irreducible monic polynomial in @xmath28 $ ] , thus @xmath29 .
this means @xmath30 , i.e. @xmath31 for some @xmath22
. then all the conjugates of @xmath32 are also @xmath25 , this implies @xmath33 .
thus @xmath16 is a root of unity .
+ + the rest of this section is devoted to a brief explanation of hilbert s theory on ramification of ideals , which plays a key role in our argument , and to listing the theorems we use .
let @xmath34 be a finite extension of @xmath14 , namely a field generated by finitely many algebraic numbers .
we denote by @xmath35 _ the ring of integers of k _ , namely the set of algebraic integers contained in @xmath34 .
for example , @xmath36 let @xmath37 be a prime number .
it generates a prime ideal @xmath38 in @xmath39 .
now , consider the ideal @xmath40 , generated by @xmath37 in @xmath35 .
this is not generally a prime ideal . since @xmath35 is a _
dedekind domain _
( @xcite , 3.1 ) , it factorizes into a product of prime ideals uniquely : @xmath41 where @xmath42 s are distinct prime ideals of @xmath35 .
it is easy to see that @xmath43 for all @xmath44 .
we call @xmath45 _ the ramification index of @xmath42_. for a prime ideal @xmath46 of @xmath35 , @xmath47 is a field .
consider the composition of the maps @xmath48 then ker@xmath49 .
thus @xmath50 induces a field extension @xmath51 .
we call @xmath52=:h({\mathfrak p})$ ] _ the degree of @xmath46 over @xmath9
. _ the ramification theory concerns the factorization described above , for a given prime @xmath37 and a field extension @xmath34 .
there is the following beautiful theorem .
( dedekind , @xcite , theorem 4.33 ) let @xmath53 be an algebraic integer , @xmath54 , and @xmath55 $ ] be the minimal polynomial of @xmath53 .
let @xmath37 be a prime number that does not factor @xmath56 , where @xmath57 is the discriminant of @xmath58 , @xmath59 is the discriminant of @xmath34 , and let @xmath60 .
suppose the factorization of @xmath58 mod @xmath37 is given by @xmath61 where @xmath62 s are irreducible polynomials in @xmath63 $ ] .
then we have @xmath64 where @xmath42 s are distinct prime ideals of @xmath35 , and @xmath65 .
here we do not give definitions for the discriminant of a polynomial nor the discriminant of a field .
in fact we do not want to deal with the discriminants , thus we need to modify this theorem for our use . we will also combine it with the following nice theorem : ( @xcite , theorem 4.6 ) suppose @xmath66 is a galois extension of degree @xmath17 . then for a prime @xmath37 we have @xmath67 where @xmath42 s are distinct prime ideals of @xmath35 , and @xmath68 for all @xmath44 for some @xmath69 , and we have @xmath70 we obtain the following theorem for our use .
[ factorpoly ] let @xmath53 be an algebraic integer , @xmath54 , and @xmath55 $ ] be the minimal polynomial of @xmath53 with degree @xmath17 .
suppose that @xmath66 is galois .
let @xmath37 be a prime number , and @xmath71 .
let @xmath72 , @xmath58 , and @xmath73 be integers such that @xmath67 where @xmath42 s are distinct prime ideals of @xmath35 , and @xmath68 for all @xmath74 then @xmath75 factorizes mod @xmath37 as follows : @xmath76 where @xmath77 $ ] with @xmath78 for all @xmath44 and each @xmath79 is of the form @xmath80 , where @xmath81 $ ] is irreducible .
* proof . *
+ let @xmath82 and @xmath83 note that for @xmath84 , @xmath85 is a prime ideal , and it coincides with some @xmath86 , since @xmath87 for each @xmath42 we define @xmath88 then @xmath89 is a subgroup of @xmath90 .
consider the following surjection @xmath91 let @xmath92 .
this is a normal subgroup of @xmath89 , and we have @xmath93 and @xmath94 are called _ decomposition group _ and _ inertia group _ of @xmath42 respectively , see @xcite , p263 . ] for each @xmath44 , let @xmath95 to be so that @xmath96 .
then we obtain a coset decomposition @xmath97 observe that @xmath98 thus @xmath99 note also that @xmath100 and @xmath101=h$ ] for all @xmath44 , thus we have @xmath102 as well . noting that @xmath103 , we get @xmath104 in @xmath105 $ ] we have @xmath106 let @xmath107 $ ] . since @xmath89 preserves @xmath42 , we have @xmath108 , where @xmath109 and @xmath110 is the image of @xmath111 in @xmath112 noting @xmath113 , we have @xmath114 note that @xmath115 $ ] , and @xmath116 thus @xmath117 $ ] as well . the polynomial @xmath118 s may or may not be irreducible in @xmath63 $ ] .
let @xmath119 since @xmath120 is abelian , @xmath121 is a normal subgroup of @xmath120 .
thus we have @xmath122 where @xmath123 since @xmath124 runs through all the conjugates of @xmath110 , @xmath125 is the minimal polynomial of @xmath110 and @xmath126 $ ] .
now , since @xmath127 mod @xmath42 @xmath128 $ ] , we have @xmath129 mod @xmath37 .
altogether we have desired factorization of @xmath75 mod @xmath37 , @xmath130 where for each @xmath44 @xmath131 , @xmath132 , and @xmath133 is irreducible .
let @xmath8 be the square of pfev of the graph @xmath134 in fig .
[ graph ] . in @xcite the adjacency matrix @xmath135 of @xmath134 was given , which is of the size @xmath136 .
the characteristic polynomial of the matrix @xmath137 divided by @xmath138 , which is denoted by @xmath139 , satisfies the following recursive formula @xmath140 and thus computed as follows : @xmath141 where @xmath142 , @xmath143 , @xmath144 , and @xmath145 .
the largest root of @xmath146 is @xmath8 . in this section
we prove the following theorem conjectured in @xcite .
[ irred ] let @xmath147 then @xmath148 is irreducible for any @xmath9 , thus it is the minimal polynomial of @xmath8 .
one immediately sees that the polynomials @xmath139 s are ugly : indeed @xmath149 and so on .
it is hard to see any pattern as @xmath9 varies .
however , by the change of variable used in @xcite , we obtain better polynomials .
we define @xmath150 the polynomials @xmath151 s satisfy the recursive formula @xmath152 thus we obtain @xmath153 for any @xmath154 .
our goal is to prove the following theorem , which is stronger than theorem [ irred ] .
[ irredq ] for each @xmath155 , let @xmath156 then @xmath157 is irreducible .
[ roots ] let @xmath158 . *
then there exists unique @xmath159 such that @xmath160 ( @xmath161 ( 1) there exists unique @xmath162 such that @xmath163 . ) * if @xmath164 is a root of @xmath151 , then @xmath165 , or @xmath166 .
this , together with proposition [ unit ] , implies the following : [ factorize ] suppose @xmath151 factorizes into the product of irreducible polynomials as follows : @xmath167 and suppose @xmath168 .
then @xmath169 , and for @xmath170 , all the roots of @xmath171 are roots of unity .
* proof of proposition [ roots ] . *
+ ( 1 ) : notice that @xmath172 , @xmath173 , thus there exist a root @xmath174 of @xmath151 in @xmath175 .
we show that it is unique .
it suffices to show that @xmath176 on @xmath175 . for @xmath177 , @xmath178 , so @xmath179 . since @xmath180 on @xmath181 , @xmath182 holds in @xmath175 . for general @xmath9 ,
since @xmath183 we have @xmath184 it is easily checked that @xmath185 in @xmath175 .
thus @xmath186 in @xmath175 .
( 1) is immediate from the fact that @xmath187 .
+ + ( 2 ) : notice that @xmath188 for @xmath189 therefore @xmath190 for @xmath191 , which implies that @xmath192 has no non - positive real root .
thus the only real roots of @xmath192 are @xmath174 and @xmath193 . on the other hand , recall
that the matrix @xmath137 is symmetric , thus all the eigenvalues are real .
therefore all the roots of @xmath194 are real . if @xmath195 is a root of @xmath192 , @xmath196 is a root of @xmath194 , which is real , and @xmath195 is a root of @xmath197 .
this implies that @xmath195 is real or @xmath198 .
+ + * proof of theorem [ irredq ] . *
+ for @xmath199 mod @xmath200 , we show that @xmath192 is irreducible . from cor .
[ factorize ] , it suffices to show that @xmath192 has no root which is a root of unity .
let @xmath201 note that the roots of @xmath202 are the roots of @xmath192 except for @xmath203 : it is easy to check that they are not roots of @xmath192 .
thus it suffices to show that @xmath202 has no root which is a root of unity except for those .
let @xmath204 , where @xmath205 , and suppose @xmath206 .
notice that @xmath207 thus @xmath208 @xmath209 @xmath210 or @xmath211 notice that @xmath212 therefore , @xmath213 where @xmath214 .
thus we need to show that there is no @xmath215 satisfying the equation except for @xmath216 and @xmath25 .
similarly , for @xmath217 , we need to show that the only roots of @xmath202 which are roots of unity are the roots of @xmath218 .
so we need to show that there is no @xmath215 satisfying the equation except for @xmath219 in addition .
+ + suppose there is @xmath220 satisfying , where @xmath221 , @xmath222 , and @xmath223 .
[ nx ] for @xmath224 , @xmath225 satisfies .
* + let @xmath34 be the splitting field of @xmath202 and @xmath226 . by the assumption @xmath227 , thus @xmath228 .
observe @xmath229 , where the action of @xmath230 is given by + @xmath231 , @xmath232 . take @xmath233 such that @xmath234 , then @xmath235 , thus @xmath236 is a root of @xmath202 as well , thus @xmath237 satisfies .
+ + therefore , without loss of generality we choose @xmath238 so that @xmath239 will be the minimum among the choices of @xmath238 , which implies that @xmath240 is the maximum .
we may choose so that @xmath241 , thus @xmath242 .
more specifically , we choose @xmath243 @xmath244 in particular , for @xmath245 , @xmath246 . * proof . *
+ let @xmath247 , and @xmath248 then @xmath249 [ upperbound - d ] @xmath250 we prove this lemma later on . using
this lemma will give an upperbound of @xmath53 .
for @xmath251 , we have @xmath252 note that the last term is fixed . since @xmath253 , there are at most three solutions to @xmath254 . therefore we obtain @xmath255 . noting that @xmath256 , @xmath53 needs to be odd .
thus we get @xmath257 or @xmath200 .
@xmath258 is possible only if @xmath259 .
+ + * proof of lemma [ upperbound - d ] . *
+ there is a natural group homomorphism @xmath260 observe that @xmath261 .
thus @xmath262 there is a formula for computing @xmath263 ( @xcite ) : for @xmath264 , where @xmath265 s are distinct primes , we have @xmath266 applying this formula to @xmath267 we obtain @xmath268 .
+ + we return to the proof for theorem [ irredq ] .
+ + * case 1 * : @xmath245 . in this case
let @xmath270 to be so that @xmath271 . since @xmath272 , @xmath270 satisfies . then @xmath273 so that @xmath274 the graphs of @xmath275 and @xmath276 is given in fig .
[ f(x)|x| ] .
[ f(x)|x| ] for @xmath277 , since @xmath278 or @xmath279 .
it is easy to check that @xmath280 for @xmath281 , and @xmath282 for @xmath283 .
since @xmath75 is an odd function , we have @xmath284 for @xmath285 .
since @xmath286 , we have no other range of @xmath287 satisfying @xmath284 .
this , together with , implies @xmath288 .
we shall find the maximum of @xmath75 in @xmath285 .
@xmath289 thus the critical points are given by @xmath290 .
one may easily check that this gives local maxima for @xmath291 , with the value @xmath292 thus @xmath293 for @xmath285 . from , we have @xmath294 recall that @xmath238 was given explicitly for each @xmath19 .
we now examine each case .
* @xmath295 : @xmath296 .
since @xmath297 for all @xmath298 , we have @xmath299 for all the odd integer @xmath298 .
* @xmath300 : @xmath301 .
* @xmath302 : @xmath303 . *
@xmath304 : @xmath305 we have @xmath306 for all @xmath307 , @xmath308 . * @xmath309 : @xmath310 .
we have @xmath311 for all @xmath312 , @xmath313 .
we need to check that @xmath314 is not a solution for . since @xmath315 , @xmath316 thus @xmath317
on the other hand , @xmath318 therefore , the only rational solutions for in @xmath319 are @xmath216 .
thus the polynomial @xmath192 is irreducible in this case .
+ + * case 2 * : @xmath320 . in this case
@xmath53 can be either @xmath321 or @xmath200 .
note that @xmath322 .
for the case @xmath257 , @xmath19 can not be divisible by @xmath200 .
the proof proceeds exactly the same as for case 1 , except that we do not have to worry about @xmath302 at the end . for @xmath258
, we have @xmath323 from lemma [ upperbound - d ]
. note that for @xmath324 , @xmath325 is a solution for , by lemma [ nx ] .
thus @xmath326 since distinct values of @xmath251 give distinct values for @xmath327 , @xmath323 implies that @xmath328 has at least two solutions , and they are in the range of @xmath329 where @xmath330 .
taking @xmath331 , we have @xmath332 . noting that @xmath333
, we examine each @xmath334 . *
@xmath295 : @xmath335 * @xmath302 : @xmath336 * @xmath337 : @xmath338 thus for odd @xmath339 , @xmath340 .
* @xmath341 : @xmath342 thus for @xmath343 , @xmath344 * @xmath345 : @xmath346 thus for @xmath347 , @xmath344 we check if the surviving values @xmath348 would give solutions to . for @xmath349 , @xmath350 since @xmath351 . on the other hand , @xmath352 thus @xmath353 and @xmath354 are solutions . for @xmath314 , noting that @xmath355 , @xmath322 , @xmath356 is undefined . on the other hand @xmath357 ,
thus fails .
altogether , for @xmath320 , the only solutions for are @xmath358 and @xmath359 this complete the proof of theorem [ irredq ] , and thus that of theorem [ irred ] .
in this section we show that @xmath8 s are not cyclotomic integers for @xmath360 , which implies that the graphs @xmath134 in fig .
[ graph ] are not principal graphs for subfactors for @xmath360 , which was conjectured in @xcite . *
* + let @xmath373 for the rest of this section .
suppose @xmath370 was a galois extension .
it coincides with the splitting field of the minimal polynomial @xmath374 of @xmath362 .
we use theorem [ factorpoly ] to derive a contradiction .
first we look for a suitable prime number .
the following is obtained by easy computations using the recursive formula .
note that the condition @xmath377 is obviously redundant , and that @xmath379
. + + * proof .
* + claim [ zero ] implies that @xmath380 , @xmath381 .
thus , in the setting of theorem [ factorpoly ] we have @xmath382 , therefore @xmath383 factorizes into a product of linear terms .
+ in the following , we find a suitable prime @xmath37 to derive a contradiction to the above proposition .
* proof . *
+ consider the fourth derivative of @xmath386 : @xmath387 let @xmath376 , @xmath384 .
then @xmath388 thus , for @xmath195 in an algebraic closure of @xmath389 , @xmath390 only if @xmath391 .
note that @xmath392 is not a root of @xmath202 .
this implies that the multiplicities of roots of @xmath393 can not be more than four , nor can the multiplicities of the roots of @xmath394 .
recall that @xmath395 .
there is a one to one correspondence between factors @xmath396 . therefore @xmath385
+ + in the following , there is a slight difference in arguments for @xmath397 and @xmath398 .
we deal with each case one by one .
+ * case 1 * : @xmath399 is not a prime , nor a power of @xmath200 . + by the assumption , there is a prime number @xmath400 that divides @xmath399 . since @xmath401 , @xmath399 is divisible by some number larger or equal to @xmath402 , thus @xmath403 , where by @xmath404 for @xmath405 we denote the largest integer dominated by @xmath406 .
suppose that @xmath370 is galois . by proposition [ factor ] and lemma [ multi ] , and that @xmath407 , we need at least @xmath408 distinct elements in @xmath389 , where by @xmath409 for @xmath405 we denote the smallest integer dominating @xmath406 .
however , @xmath410 , thus @xmath411 , thus we have a contradiction .
the remaining cases are when @xmath399 is prime or a power of @xmath200 .
+ + * case 2 * : @xmath412 .
let @xmath413 .
suppose @xmath370 is galois .
from proposition [ factor ] we have @xmath414 where @xmath415
thus @xmath416 note that @xmath417 is irreducible @xmath418 . since @xmath419 , @xmath420 thus @xmath421 . on the other hand
@xmath422 so @xmath423 . however , we get @xmath424 by the following computation . @xmath425
thus @xmath426 therefore we need @xmath427 .
thus @xmath370 can not be galois for @xmath428 , where @xmath399 is a power of @xmath200 .
+ + * case 3 * : @xmath399 is a prime @xmath429 .
let @xmath430 , and assume that @xmath370 is galois . from proposition [ factor
] we have @xmath431 where @xmath432 thus @xmath433 we postpone the proof of this lemma to the end of this subsection . if @xmath174 is a root of @xmath192 , it is a root of @xmath436 for some @xmath437 ; thus @xmath438 . therefore if @xmath439 and @xmath440 is irreducible , @xmath441 or @xmath442 any linear factor of @xmath192 divides @xmath443 or @xmath444 as well .
* proof . *
+ ( 1 ) from the euclidean algorithm one obtains @xmath448 since @xmath449 we are done .
likewise , one obtains that @xmath450 and the right hand side divides @xmath451 .
+ + since @xmath452 , @xmath453 divides @xmath454 only if @xmath455 . using the same computation as in the case for @xmath456 , we have @xmath457 , and @xmath458 , and @xmath459 .
( note that @xmath200 is invertible in @xmath460 . )
thus we have @xmath461 and all the terms @xmath440 appearing here are irreducible in @xmath462 $ ] .
since they can not divide @xmath443 which is a product of linear terms , they must divide @xmath444 , therefore @xmath451 . since @xmath463
, we have @xmath464 if @xmath465 since lemma [ multi ] works for @xmath466 , we still have @xmath467 therefore we have @xmath468 , thus @xmath469 . since @xmath470 by assumption , the conclusion of proposition [ factor ] fails for all @xmath151 s except possibly for @xmath471 . for @xmath471
one may directly verify that @xmath472 , thus proposition [ factor ] fails in this case as well .
+ * proof of lemma [ fermat ] . *
+ ( @xmath473 ) suppose @xmath474 .
then @xmath174 is a root of @xmath475 . since @xmath476
, we have @xmath477 .
thus @xmath478 is also a root of @xmath475 , and hence is equal to @xmath174 or @xmath479 .
+ ( @xmath480 ) suppose @xmath481 .
then @xmath482 as well , and @xmath483
. then @xmath484 .
therefore @xmath485 is a root of @xmath486 ; thus it is in @xmath460 .
we still use proposition [ factor ] and derive a contradiction , in essentially the same way as in the previous section . note that @xmath399 can not be be divisible by @xmath200 in this case
. therefore we deal with two cases : whether @xmath399 is a prime or not .
note that @xmath192 is not irreducible in this case : instead , @xmath488 is irreducible and it corresponds to the minimal polynomial @xmath374 .
+ + case 1 : @xmath399 is not a prime .
+ we take a prime @xmath37 so that @xmath376 .
we have @xmath403 as explained in the proof in [ knequiv2 ] .
since @xmath489 , we need at least @xmath490 distinct elements in @xmath389 in order for @xmath491 to be galois by proposition [ factor ] .
however , we still have an inequality @xmath492 ; therefore there are nt sufficiently many distinct elements in @xmath389 .
+ + case 2 : @xmath399 is a prime .
+ let @xmath430 .
the proof is exactly the same as the previous section , except for a slight difference at the very end .
we have @xmath493 ; thus we get the same inequality @xmath469 . however , by assumption @xmath373 and @xmath494 .
haagerup , u. ( 1994 ) .
principal graphs of subfactors in the index range @xmath499 . in
_ subfactors proceedings of the taniguchi symposium , katata _ , ( ed .
h. araki , et al . ) , world scientific , 138 .
ocneanu , a. ( 1988 ) .
quantized group , string algebras and galois theory for algebras .
_ operator algebras and applications , vol . 2 ( warwick , 1987 ) _ , ( ed .
d. e. evans and m. takesaki ) , london mathematical society lecture note series vol .
136 , cambridge university press , 119172 .
sunder , v. s. and vijayarajan , a. k. ( 1993 ) . on the non - occurrence of the coxeter graphs
@xmath502 , @xmath503 , @xmath504 as principal graphs of an inclusion of ii@xmath497 factors
. _ pacific journal of mathematics _ * 161 * , 185200 . | we show that any graph , in the sequence given by haagerup in 1991 as that of candidates of principal graphs of subfactors , is not realized as a principal graph except for the smallest two .
this settles the remaining case of a previous work of the first author . |
the canonical edwards - anderson ( ea ) model ising spin glasses ( isgs ) in dimension @xmath11 have been the subject of very many numerical studies .
there is now consensus supported by analytic arguments that the two archetype models , the isgs on square lattices with near neighbor interactions having distributions which are either gaussian or bimodal ( @xmath0 ) , have zero temperature transitions @xcite . for the gaussian case , where the interaction distribution is continuous and the ground state is unique
, there is now also general consensus concerning the low temperature thermodynamic limit ( thl ) behavior and exponents . in the bimodal case
there is an `` effectively continuous energy level distribution '' regime coming down from high temperatures and ending with a crossover at a size dependent temperature @xmath2 to a ground state dominated regime @xcite .
interpretations differ considerably concerning the critical exponents for the bimodal interaction case
. we will give a new analysis of accurate numerical monte carlo data up to size @xmath12 on the bimodal system in the thl and up to @xmath13 on the gaussian system .
we use the temperature @xmath14 or the inverse temperature @xmath15 when it is convenient .
we first discuss discuss the specific heat using data from the simulations and independent data down to low temperatures and large sizes from refs .
@xcite and @xcite .
then we analyse the simulation data for other observables to obtain reliable and accurate estimates for the critical exponents of the thl regime , using both the conventional scaling variable @xmath14 and a novel scaling variable compatible with the generic scaling approach for isgs introduced in @xcite , adapted to a situation where @xmath16 .
we find that the gaussian model and the bimodal model in the thl are not in the same universality class .
the @xmath5d gaussian model is relatively clear - cut . because @xmath17 and the interaction distribution is continuous , there is a unique ground state ( for each sample ) and the low temperature excitation distribution has no gap .
the fact that the ground state is unique necessarily implies that for all @xmath3 , as @xmath18 , @xmath19 and the reduced susceptibility @xmath20 . with @xmath14
chosen as the critical scaling variable , the standard thermodynamic limit low temperature critical expressions are @xmath21 and @xmath22 because the critical exponent @xmath4 is strictly zero .
the critical behavior of both the observables at low temperature is governed by the single exponent @xmath23 , which is related to the stiffness exponent through @xmath24 .
accurate zero temperature domain wall stiffness measurements to large sizes @xcite show that @xmath25 , i.e. @xmath26 . in the @xmath5d bimodal case the situation is complicated by two factors .
first , the ground state is not unique but is massively degenerate ; the zero - temperature entropy per spin is @xmath27 @xcite .
secondly , the distribution of excited state energy levels is not continuous but increases by steps of @xmath28 ; in particular there is an energy gap @xmath28 between the ground state and the first excited state .
one can write @xcite the `` nave '' leading low temperature finite size specific heat expression @xmath29 where @xmath30 , @xmath31 are the sample - averaged entropies of the first excited state and the ground state . setting @xmath32 a crossover temperature can then be defined by @xcite @xmath33 which separates the critical behavior in the low temperature ground state dominated regime ( with @xmath34 ) and a @xmath35 regime where the whole ensemble of higher energy states dominate the thermodynamics @xcite . an explicit phenomenological expression for @xmath2 derived from eq .
5 of ref .
@xcite , which is consistent with the raw data points @xcite for @xmath36 is @xmath37 a much simpler droplet - based expression from @xcite is @xmath38 .
@xmath2 decreases with increasing @xmath3 because the degeneracy of the excited states increases faster with @xmath3 than that of the ground state .
we will assume @xcite that in the @xmath35 thl regime the data can be analysed in the same way as if the energy level distribution were continuous .
with this assumption the @xmath35 regime will have `` effectively continuous '' energy level distribution critical exponents with an effective ordering temperature @xmath39 still zero .
the ground state dominated regime at @xmath40 is a finite size effect which disappears in the infinite @xmath3 limit .
a non - zero @xmath4 is to be expected _ a priori _ for a system with a strong ground state degeneracy , unless each individual ground state is isolated in phase space which is not the case @xcite in the bimodal isg . a droplet analysis of ground state measurements on large sized samples @xcite
show that @xmath41 , broadly consistent with a number of finite temperature simulation estimates @xcite .
however it has been claimed that in the @xmath35 regime the bimodal isg can be considered to be effectively in the same universality class as the gaussian isg @xcite , meaning that the effective exponents are again @xmath42 and @xmath26 . in view of the basic definition of @xmath4 in terms of the short range limit of the spin - spin correlation function
@xmath43 $ ] , this claim is rather surprising .
a major difficulty in establishing the limiting @xmath44 $ ] behavior for isgs in dimension @xmath5 @xcite consists in finding an appropriate and reliable extrapolation procedure from simulation data necessarily restricted in size and in temperature because of the need to achieve good thermal equilibration at large sizes .
this is a problem that we will address .
the simulations were performed using the houdayer cluster method @xcite in combination with the exchange monte carlo @xcite method . in the cluster step
we first pick a random site @xmath45 and compute its overlap @xmath46 , where @xmath47 and @xmath48 denote the spin for two different replicas .
we then build an equal-@xmath49 cluster along the nearest neighbor interactions and flip all cluster spins in both replicas .
we used four replicas which turned out to be remarkably efficacious . on each iteration
the replicas are paired at random , then , for each pair , a cluster update is performed , and the usual heat - bath spin update and exchange . for all systems we used @xmath50 .
the number of temperatures were more than 250 for the smallest systems starting at @xmath51 . with increasing system size the number of temperatures
was decreased and @xmath52 increased . for the largest system ( bimodal @xmath53 with @xmath12 )
@xmath54 temperatures were used with @xmath55 .
the exchange rate was always at least @xmath56 for all systems and temperatures .
the systems were deemed equilibrated when the average @xmath57 for the systems at @xmath58 appeared stable between runs .
the number of equilibration steps increased with system size , for the bimodal @xmath12 this took about @xmath59 steps .
after equilibration , at least @xmath60 measurements were made for each sample for all sizes , taking place after every cluster - sweep - exchange step .
the usual observables were registered , the energy @xmath61 , the correlation length @xmath62 , the spin overlap moments @xmath63 , @xmath64 . correlations @xmath65 between the energy and some observables @xmath66 were also registered .
thermodynamic derivatives could then be evaluated through the usual @xmath67 .
error estimates of observables and derivatives were done with the bootstrap method .
sizes studied were @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 , @xmath71 , @xmath72 , @xmath73 , @xmath74 , @xmath75 , @xmath76 , @xmath77 , @xmath78 for bimodal interactions , and up to @xmath13 for the gaussian interactions , with @xmath79 samples ( @xmath53-interactions ) for all sizes .
the size dependence of the ground state energy per spin @xmath80 for the 2d gaussian isg has been shown @xcite to follow the simple critical finite size scaling rule @xmath81 with a @xmath82 consistent with the estimate from ground state domain wall stiffness measurements @xcite .
standard scaling arguments @xcite would suggest that the low temperature specific heat should behave as @xmath83 but because of the continuous interaction distribution , in addition to critical excitations there are always single spin excitations .
these lead to a term @xmath84 which dominates the gaussian low temperature specific heat as noted by ref . @xcite .
specific heat data for the bimodal model were calculated through the present simulations ; data extending to a much lower temperature range and larger sizes have already been measured using the sophisticated pfaffian arithmetic technique by lukic _
@xcite and by thomas _
@xcite , and we are very grateful to be able to quote these results _ in extenso_. the data for the two models are shown , see fig . [ fig1 ] and fig .
[ fig2 ] , in the form of plots of the derivative @xmath85 against @xmath86 .
this non - conventional form of plot happens to be particularly instructive .
a low temperature limit @xmath87 appears as a straight line through the origin with slope @xmath88 , while a low temperature limit of the `` nave '' bimodal ground state dominated form eq . appears as a straight line with intercept @xmath89 and slope @xmath90 .
the gaussian data are almost independent of @xmath3 for the whole temperature range .
physically this occurs because the specific heat in isgs is predominately a near neighbor effect .
the curve tends to a slope @xmath91 corresponding to @xmath92 in the low @xmath14 limit , in agreement with the conclusion of ref .
@xcite . for the bimodal model
there is first a high temperature and/or high @xmath3 envelope curve corresponding to the effectively continuous @xmath93 regime . in this regime
finite size effects are very weak : the specific heat is almost independent of @xmath3 as in the gaussian .
the curves for the two models are of similar form but are not identical . in the large @xmath3 , low @xmath14 limit of this envelope curve , the bimodal data as shown in fig .
[ fig2 ] indicate @xmath94 in agreement with the conclusions drawn in ref .
@xcite based on droplet excitation arguments . for each @xmath3 the data curve peels off the large @xmath3 envelope curve below an @xmath3-dependent temperature which can be identified with the start of the effectively continuous to ground state dominated regime crossover centered at @xmath2 .
finally for each @xmath3 in the low temperature range @xmath95 the specific heat links up to the `` nave '' limit of eq . .
( it should be noted that because of the logarithmic derivative , temperature independent @xmath3-dependent factors do not show up in this plot ) .
the crossover can be seen to be gentle for small @xmath3 , becoming sharp for large @xmath3 . defining @xmath2 as the location of the maximum positive slope on this plot ,
the crossover temperatures can be clearly identified and are consistent with @xmath96 .
an anomalous limit of the form @xmath97 which has been proposed by some authors @xcite following ref .
@xcite is inconsistent with the data in fig .
[ fig2 ] for all @xmath3 and @xmath14 ( see also @xcite ) .
an intermediate @xmath3 regime where @xmath98 as proposed in ref .
@xcite or @xmath99 as proposed in ref .
@xcite appear to be valid only for a limited range of @xmath14 and @xmath3 .
for isgs with non - zero critical temperatures finite size scaling analyses at and close to the critical temperature are used to estimate critical exponents . for the @xmath5d bimodal isg , because of the crossover to the ground state dominated regime this approach is ruled out and the critical exponents must be estimated using the entirely different strategy of thl measurements . the standard renormalization group theory ( rgt ) scaling variable for models with non - zero ordering temperatures is @xmath100 .
this obviously can not be used when @xmath101 ; by convention the scaling variable used in the literature for @xmath5d isgs is the un - normalized temperature @xmath14 .
this is only a convention ; it is perfectly legitimate to use other conventions .
thus , when considering the canonical @xmath102d ising ferromagnet , baxter @xcite remarks `` when @xmath101 it is more sensible to replace @xmath103 by @xmath104 '' .
( in fact for the particular @xmath102d model scaling without corrections over the entire temperature range follows if a related scaling variable @xmath105 is chosen @xcite ) .
below we will introduce another scaling variable appropriate for isgs with @xmath106 , but for the moment we follow this traditional @xmath107 @xmath5d isg convention .
the critical exponents are defined through the leading thl expressions for the reduced susceptibility and the second moment correlation length within this convention : @xmath108 and @xmath109 in the limit @xmath110 .
for all data which fulfil the condition ( either in the bimodal and gaussian models ) @xmath111 with @xmath112 , observables such as @xmath113 and @xmath114 depend on @xmath14 but not on @xmath3 , and so correspond to the thl infinite size values @xmath115 and @xmath116 .
the thl condition defines implicitly a crossover temperature @xmath117 .
it turns out that in the bimodal @xmath5d isg the thl limit temperature @xmath117 is always higher than the corresponding crossover temperature to the ground state dominated regime @xmath2 defined above , so the thl data are always well in the effectively continuous regime .
the thl data extrapolation to @xmath118 corresponds to estimates for the critical exponents in the successive limits @xmath119 $ ] so in the effectively continuous energy level regime , to be distinguished from the exponents defined taking the successive limits @xmath120 $ ] which would correspond to the `` finite size '' ground state dominated regime .
there have been many previous studies having the aim of estimating the critical exponents and in particular @xmath4 for the bimodal model .
mcmillan already in 1983 estimated @xmath121 from @xmath122 correlation data on one @xmath123 sample well in the effectively continuous regime @xcite .
katzgraber and lee @xcite estimated @xmath124 from @xmath113 data .
et al _ @xcite show a plot of @xmath125 against @xmath126 after an extrapolation to infinite @xmath3 using the technique of ref .
they state `` fits of this curve lead to values of @xmath4 that are very small , between @xmath127 and @xmath128 , strongly suggestive of @xmath42 '' . however , this type of extrapolation to infinite @xmath3 is delicate , particularly in the bimodal @xmath5d case .
in addition , the data displayed by @xcite on a @xmath129 plot extending over five decades on the @xmath130 axis are hard to fit with precision . katzgraber _
et al _ @xcite show a plot of @xmath131 which in principle is equivalent to the ref .
@xcite plot but which provides a display much more sensitive to the value of @xmath4 ; they state cautiously `` for all system sizes and temperatures studied @xmath132 is always greater than @xmath133 , although an extrapolation to @xmath42 can not be ruled out '' , so that the possibility of the bimodal and gaussian isgs being in the same universality class `` can not be reliably proven '' . in refs . @xcite it is claimed that the gaussian and bimodal models are in the same universality class , which is surprising as `` the data are not sufficiently precise to provide a precise determination of @xmath4 , being consistent with a small value @xmath134 , including @xmath42 '' .
all the estimates quoted so far can be considered to concern the effectively continuous regime . at zero or low temperatures ,
so in the ground state dominated regime , different sophisticated algorithms lead to the estimates @xmath135 @xcite , and to @xmath136 @xcite . in fig .
[ fig3 ] and fig .
[ fig4 ] , we show plots of @xmath137 against @xmath138 for the gaussian and bimodal models .
these are _ raw _ data points having the high statistical precision of the present measurements . with the conventional definition of the critical exponents through @xmath139 and @xmath140 in the thl regime low-@xmath14 limit ,
the limiting slope @xmath141 at criticality as @xmath142 is by definition equal to @xmath143 . for the gaussian model
the observed tendency of the slope is consistent with the limit of @xmath144 which must be the case for this nondegenerate ground state model . for the bimodal model the observed @xmath145 in the thl regime is not tending to @xmath5 but to a constant limit of @xmath146 .
slight overshoots for each @xmath3 in both systems can be ascribed to @xmath113 and @xmath114 not reaching the thl condition at quite the same temperature .
as stated above , very similar observations were made in ref .
@xcite for the bimodal model .
the present results thus confirm unambiguously that for the bimodal isg in the effectively continuous regime @xmath4 is not zero but is @xmath147 .
thus the bimodal isg in the effectively continuous thl regime and the gaussian isg are not in the same universality class .
it has been shown that in dimension @xmath148 also , gaussian and bimodal isgs are not in the same universality class @xcite , so the breakdown of universality in isgs appears to be general .
estimating the exponents @xmath23 or @xmath149 is more difficult than for the exponent @xmath4 . as we have noted above , the standard rgt convention for models with finite temperature ordering
is to use the scaling variable @xmath150 , which obviously can not be applied to models with @xmath151 , and for @xmath5d isgs the preferred convention in the literature has been to use the un - normalized scaling variable @xmath107 . in practice this is inefficient as the extrapolations towards the @xmath152 limit in order to estimate the values for the critical exponents are very ambiguous .
for instance , when presenting @xmath14-scaled susceptibility data for sizes up to @xmath12 katzgraber _ et al _ @xcite state `` the [ susceptibility ] data for the bimodal case can be extrapolated to any arbitrary value including @xmath153 '' .
we will introduce a novel scaling variable suitable for the @xmath5d isgs , applying the same principles as for isgs at higher dimensions @xcite , adapted to @xmath154 ordering : for spin glasses the relevant interaction strength parameter is not @xmath155 but is @xmath156 , so the natural dimensionless parameter is @xmath157 ( or alternatively @xmath158 for bimodal isgs ) . with the standard normalisation @xmath159 the natural inverse `` temperature '' in isgs
is @xmath160 , not @xmath15 .
this was recognized immediately after the edwards - anderson model was introduced , in high temperature series expansion ( htse ) analyses for isgs including @xmath5d models @xcite , but has since been overlooked in most simulation analyses .
it is convenient to choose a scaling variable @xmath161 defined in such a way that @xmath162 at criticality and @xmath163 at infinite temperature . with an isg ordering at a finite inverse temperature @xmath164 , @xmath165 is an appropriate choice @xcite .
when @xmath166 as in the @xmath5d isg case , @xmath167 has been used @xcite , but here we will prefer @xmath168 as it turns out to be efficient and the limits are easy to relate to those of the @xmath14 scaling convention . with non - zero @xmath39 the effective exponents at criticality do not depend on the choice of scaling variable ; this is not the case when @xmath169 , but a simple dictionary is given below relating the limiting derivatives for @xmath170 scaling to the exponents for the conventional @xmath14 scaling . the thl htse darboux @xcite format for observables @xmath171 is @xmath172 with @xmath173 in isgs @xcite .
the htse isg susceptibility @xmath174 is naturally in this format , so for isg models with @xmath175 the thl susceptibility can be scaled in the wegner @xcite form @xmath176\ ] ] because the correlation function second moment @xmath177 htse is of the form ( see ref .
@xcite for the ising ferromagnet ) @xmath178 and the second moment correlation length is defined through @xmath179 with @xmath180 the number of nearest neighbors , for consistency the appropriate correlation length variable for isg scaling is @xmath181 rather than @xmath182 ( whether @xmath183 is zero or not ) .
this point has been spelt out in ref .
@xcite .
examples of applications of the scaling rules outlined here to other specific models ( both ferromagnets and isgs ) have been given elsewhere .
a general discussion of ferromagnets and spin glasses is given in ref .
@xcite , analyses of @xmath184d ising , xy and heisenberg ferromagnets in ref .
@xcite , the @xmath5d ising ferromagnet is analysed in ref .
@xcite , @xmath184d ising ferromagnets in @xcite , high dimension ising ferromagnets in ref .
@xcite , and the @xmath5d villain fully frustrated model in ref .
@xcite .
the scaling of the binder cumulant @xmath185 is discussed in the appendix . the @xmath5d simulation data analysis and the extrapolations below
are based on the derivatives @xmath186 in the thl regime where these derivatives are independent of @xmath3 and so equal to the infinite size derivatives .
an advantage of the @xmath5d models is that in contrast to @xmath187 for the models with non - zero @xmath183 , for the @xmath5d isgs with @xmath188 there is no uncertainty in the definition of @xmath189 related to an uncertainty in the value of the ordering temperature .
once the @xmath190 limits for the various derivatives have been estimated by extrapolation of the thl data for finite @xmath3 , there is a simple dictionary for translating into terms of the conventional @xmath14 scaling critical exponents @xmath23 and @xmath4 defined above : [ derivs ] @xmath191
the four derivatives of eq . are shown in figs .
[ fig5 ] to [ fig12 ] .
in contrast to the derivatives in which @xmath14 is used as the scaling variable , each derivative can be extrapolated in a fairly unambiguous manner to criticality , and always has an exact finite value at infinite temperature @xmath192 .
the exact infinite temperature limits from the general high temperature scaling expansion expressions @xcite applied to scaling with @xmath170 are ( when @xmath193 ) : [ exact ] @xmath194 the extrapolation method is outlined in appendix ii . with @xmath144 and assuming @xmath195 @xcite , the predicted gaussian critical limits ( when @xmath196 ) for the derivatives are [ gderivs ] @xmath197 from the fitted thl data extrapolations ( see appendix ii ) the estimated gaussian critical limit values are @xmath198 , @xmath199 , @xmath200 , @xmath201 respectively .
these values are fully consistent with the list above , validating the approach and the extrapolation procedure that we have used . for the bimodal data , the extrapolated thl limits ( when @xmath196 ) from the figures ( see appendix ii ) give estimates [ jderivs ] @xmath202 these are all significantly different from the gaussian values , confirming non - universality . when translated into the @xmath14 scaling convention , the 2d bimodal critical exponents from these measurements are @xmath203 and @xmath204 ( so @xmath205 .
not only is the thl bimodal exponent @xmath4 different from the gaussian value but the @xmath23 value is different also .
simulation data are presented for the gaussian and bimodal interaction distribution ising spin glasses in dimension two , which are known to order only at zero temperature . in order to facilitate extrapolations to zero temperature ,
a temperature scaling variable @xmath206 is introduced in addition to the traditional @xmath5d isg scaling variable @xmath107 .
the gaussian simulation data are completely consistent with the well established critical behavior for this model , with exponents @xmath1 and @xmath207 @xcite .
the bimodal specific heat simulation data supplemented by data from lukic _ et al _ @xcite and from thomas _ et al _ @xcite show clear crossovers from an effectively continuous energy level thermodynamic limit regime to a finite size ground state dominated regime at size dependent temperatures @xmath208 ( see ref .
@xcite ) .
the extrapolated thl simulation results tend to critical limits which correspond consistently to @xmath209 and @xmath204 , clearly different from the gaussian values .
this demonstrates that the standard universality rules do not hold for @xmath5d isg models . in dimension
@xmath148 also bimodal and gaussian isgs have been shown not to be in the same universality class either @xcite , strongly suggesting a lack of universality for isgs in each dimension ( presumably up to the upper critical dimension ) . against @xmath14 .
sizes @xmath210 , @xmath75 , @xmath74 , @xmath73 , @xmath72 , @xmath71 top to bottom in the dip .
curve : extrapolation.,width=288 ] [ fig1 ] against @xmath14 .
full points : simulation data @xmath211 , @xmath75 , @xmath73 , @xmath71 , @xmath70 ( black , green , red , pink , cyan ) top to bottom .
open points : pfaffian data ; red polygons @xmath212 , blue right triangles @xmath213 , black left triangles @xmath12 , brown diamonds @xmath13 ( all data from ref .
@xcite ) , green down triangles @xmath214 , red up triangles @xmath215 , pink circles @xmath216 , all data fom ref .
dashed diagonal red line @xmath217 , green diagonal line @xmath218.,width=288 ] [ fig2 ] against @xmath219 for @xmath210 , @xmath75 , @xmath74 , @xmath73 left to right . in this and all
following figures both gaussian and bimodal , the color coding is : black , pink , red , blue , green , brown , cyan , olive for @xmath220 , @xmath77 , @xmath76 , @xmath75 , @xmath74 , @xmath73 , @xmath72 , @xmath71.,width=288 ] [ fig3 ] against @xmath219 for @xmath220 , @xmath77 , @xmath76 , @xmath75 , @xmath74 , @xmath73 left to right .
same color coding as in fig .
[ fig3].,width=288 ] [ fig4 ] against @xmath170 .
sizes @xmath210 , @xmath75 , @xmath74 , @xmath73 , @xmath72 left to right .
same color coding as in fig .
[ fig3 ] . dashed line : extrapolation .
red arrow : exact infinite temperature value .
blue arrow : gaussian critical value.,width=288 ] [ fig5 ] against @xmath170 .
sizes @xmath220 , @xmath77 , @xmath76 , @xmath75 , @xmath74 , @xmath73 , @xmath72 left to right .
same color coding as in fig .
[ fig3 ] . dashed line : extrapolation .
red arrow : exact infinite temperature value .
, width=288 ] [ fig6 ] against @xmath170 .
sizes @xmath210 , @xmath75 , @xmath74 , @xmath73 left to right .
same color coding as in fig .
[ fig3 ] . dashed line : extrapolation .
red arrow : exact infinite temperature value . blue arrow : gaussian critical value.,width=288 ] [ fig7 ] against @xmath170 .
sizes @xmath220 , @xmath77 , @xmath76 , @xmath75 , @xmath74 , @xmath73 , @xmath72 left to right .
same color coding as in fig .
[ fig3 ] . dashed line : extrapolation .
red arrow : exact infinite temperature value .
, width=288 ] [ fig8 ] against @xmath170 , where @xmath221 is the binder cumulant .
@xmath222 , @xmath75 , @xmath74 , @xmath73 left to right .
same color coding as in fig .
line : extrapolation .
blue arrow : gaussian critical value .
, width=288 ] [ fig9 ] against @xmath170 , where @xmath221 is the binder cumulant .
sizes @xmath223 , @xmath77 , @xmath76 , @xmath75 , @xmath74 , @xmath73 left to right .
same color coding as in fig .
[ fig3 ] . line :
, width=288 ] [ fig10 ] against @xmath170 .
sizes @xmath210 , @xmath75 , @xmath74 , @xmath73 left to right .
same color coding as in fig .
[ fig3 ] . dashed line : extrapolation .
red arrow : exact infinite temperature value .
blue arrow : gaussian critical value.,width=288 ] [ fig11 ] against @xmath170 .
sizes @xmath220 , @xmath77 , @xmath76 , @xmath75 , @xmath74 , @xmath73 , @xmath72 left to right .
same color coding as in fig .
[ fig3 ] . dashed line : extrapolation .
red arrow : exact infinite temperature value .
, width=288 ] [ fig12 ] against @xmath170 .
sizes @xmath222 , @xmath75 , @xmath74 , @xmath73 , @xmath72 , @xmath71 top to bottom .
same color coding as in fig .
@xmath221 is the binder cumulant .
line slope @xmath224 .
, width=288 ] [ fig13 ] against @xmath170 .
sizes @xmath223 , @xmath77 , @xmath76 , @xmath75 , @xmath74 , @xmath73 , @xmath72 , @xmath71 top to bottom .
same color coding as in fig .
@xmath221 is the binder cumulant .
line slope @xmath225 .
, width=288 ] [ fig14 ]
the ferromagnetic binder cumulant has been extensively exploited in the fss limit regime very close to criticality for its properties as a dimensionless observable .
in addition its thl properties can also be studied . in ising ferromagnets , the critical exponent for the second field derivative of the susceptibility @xmath226 ( also called the non - linear susceptibility ) , is @xcite @xmath227 the non - linear susceptibility @xmath226 is directly related to the binder cumulant , @xcite eq . 10.2 , through @xmath228 as @xmath229 scales with the critical exponent @xmath230 , the normalized binder cumulant @xmath231 scales with the thl regime critical exponent @xmath232 . in any @xmath233 ising system
the infinite temperature ( independent spin ) limit for the binder cumulant is @xmath234 where @xmath235 is the number of spins ; @xmath236 for a hypercubic lattice .
so @xmath231 has an infinite temperature limit which is strictly @xmath102 , and a large @xmath3 critical limit ( with corrections as for the other observables ) : @xmath237 exactly the same argument can be transposed to isgs ( see ref .
@xcite for @xmath226 in isgs ) . in the particular case of a @xmath5d isg model with @xmath170 scaling ,
the critical value for the derivative @xmath238 of the binder cumulant thl data extrapolated to @xmath239 is @xmath240 where @xmath23 is once again the correlation length critical exponent in the @xmath14 scaling convention .
the binder cumulant data plotted in the eq .
form are shown for the two models in figs .
[ fig13 ] and [ fig14 ] .
the thl envelope curves can be seen by inspection .
the derivatives of these curves have already been shown in figs .
[ fig9 ] and [ fig10 ] .
it has been suggested that if two models have the same function when @xmath241 is plotted against @xmath242 , it is a proof of universality .
however , because both @xmath243 and @xmath62 are controlled by just the same exponent @xmath23 this is questionable .
as the data sets do not extend to infinite size , to estimate the critical @xmath239 limit values from the thl derivative data in figs .
[ fig5 ] to [ fig12 ] , an extrapolation must be made .
there is no definitive method to extrapolate so as to be sure to obtain exact values of the critical exponents , though data to still larger sizes would make the task easier .
the most economical choice for extrapolation is to assume that the thl derivative data continue to evolve smoothly and regularly when an extrapolation is made towards @xmath239 through the smaller @xmath170 region where no thl data are for the moment available . to do this , for each derivative observable @xmath145 with @xmath244
we collect together the thl data points for all the sizes @xmath3 up to @xmath245 and make standard polynomial fits with @xmath184 or @xmath148 terms @xmath246 or @xmath247 ( in fits with larger numbers of terms the fit parameter values become unstable ) . assuming that each polynomial fit curve extended to @xmath248 is a good approximation to the true behavior , each @xmath249 is an estimate for the critical limit value .
the @xmath249 values for @xmath184 or @xmath148 parameter fits turn out to be similar . in figs .
[ fig15 ] , [ fig16 ] , [ fig17 ] and [ fig18 ] the data and fits are shown for @xmath250 , @xmath251 and @xmath252 and @xmath253 for both gaussian and bimodal models . the fits are automatic , so this procedure is objective and we assume that it is optimal for the available data .
all the gaussian extrapolated critical values estimated in this way are close to those expected assuming the published exponents , @xmath42 and @xmath207 @xcite .
this implies that the estimated bimodal critical values are also close to the true critical limits .
we are very grateful to olivier martin and to alan middleton who generously allow us access to the specific heat data of ref .
@xcite and of ref .
@xcite respectively .
we would like to thank alex hartmann for very helpful suggestions .
the computations were performed on resources provided by the swedish national infrastructure for computing ( snic ) at the high performance computing center north ( hpc2n ) and chalmers centre for computational science and engineering ( c3se ) .
99 a. k. hartmann and a. p.
young , phys .
b * 64 * , 18404 ( 2001 ) .
m. ohzeki and h. nishimori , j. phys .
a : math . theor . * 42 * , 332001 ( 2009 ) .
t. jrg , j. lukic , e. marinari , o. c. martin , phys .
* 96 * , 237205 ( 2006 ) .
j. lukic , a. galluccio , e. marinari , o. c. martin and g. rinaldi , phys .
92 * , 117202 ( 2004 ) . c. k. thomas , d. a. huse , and a. a. middleton , phys .
lett . * 107 * , 047203 ( 2011 ) . i. a. campbell , k. hukushima , and h. takayama , phys .
* 97 * , 117202 ( 2006 ) .
h. rieger , l. santen , u. blasum , m. diehl , m. jnger , and g. rinaldi , j. phys .
a * 29 * , 3939 ( 1996 ) ; * 30 * , 8795(e ) ( 1997 ) .
a. c. carter , a. j. bray , and m. a. moore , phys .
lett . * 88 * , 077201 ( 2002 ) . c. amoruso , e. marinari , o. c. martin , and a. pagnani , phys .
lett . * 91 * , 087201 ( 2003 ) .
j. houdayer and a. k. hartmann , phys .
b * 70 * , 014418 ( 2004 )
. a. k. hartmann , a. j. bray , a. c. carter , m. a. moore , and a. p. young , phys .
b * 66 * , 224401 ( 2002 ) j. poulter and j. a. blackman , phys . rev .
b * 72 * , 104422 ( 2005 ) . k. t. creighton and a. a. middleton phys . rev .
b * 77 * , 144418 ( 2008 ) . h. g. katzgraber , lik wee lee , and i. a. campbell , phys . rev .
b * 75 * , 014412 ( 2007 ) .
r. fisch , j. stat .
phys . * 128 * , 1113 ( 2007 ) .
a. k. hartmann , phys .
b * 77 * , 144418 ( 2008 )
. w. l. mcmillan , phys .
b * 28 * , 5216 ( 1983 ) .
j. houdayer , eur .
j. b * 22 * , 479 ( 2001 )
. h. g. katzgraber and lik wee lee , phys .
b * 71 * , 134404 ( 2005 ) .
k. hukushima and k. nemoto , j. phys .
japan * 65 * , 1604 ( 1996 ) .
i. a. campbell , a. k. hartmann and h. g. katzgraber , phys .
b * 70 * 054429 ( 2004 ) .
wang , phys .
e * 72 * , 036706 ( 2005 ) .
wang and r. h. swendsen , phys .
b * 38 * , 4840 ( 1988 ) . l. saul and m. kardar , phys .
e * 48 * , r3221 ( 1993 ) .
w. atisattapong and j. poulter , new journal of physics * 10 * 09312 ( 2008 ) .
r. j. baxter `` exactly solved models in statistical mechanics '' academic press ( london ) ( 1982 ) .
h. g. katzgraber , i. a. campbell , and a. k. hartmann , phys .
b * 78 * , 184409 ( 2008 ) . i. a. campbell and p. h. lundow , phys . rev .
b * 83 * , 014411 ( 2011 ) .
s. caracciolo _
et al . _ ,
lett . * 74 * , 2969 ( 1995 ) .
m. palassini and s. caracciolo , phys .
lett . * 82 * , 5128 ( 1999 ) .
m. baity - jesi _ et al .
b * 88 * , 224416 ( 2013 ) .
f. parisen toldin , a. pelissetto , and e. vicari , phys .
e * 82 * , 021106 ( 2010 ) .
f. parisen toldin , a. pelissetto , and e. vicari , phys .
e * 84 * , 051116 ( 2011 ) .
p. h. lundow and i. a. campbell , phys .
e * 91 * , 042121 ( 2015 ) , physica a * 434 * , 181 ( 2015 ) .
r. r. p. singh and s. chakraverty , phys .
b * 36 * , 559 ( 1987 )
. l. klein , j. adler , a. aharony , a. b. harris and y. meir , phys .
b * 43 * , 11249 ( 1991 ) .
d. daboul , i. chang , and a. aharony , eur .
j. b * 41 * , 231 ( 2004 ) .
j. g. darboux , j. math .
pures appl . * 4 * , 377 ( 1878 ) . f. j. wegner , phys . rev .
b * 5 * , 4529 ( 1972 ) .
p. butera and m. comi , phys .
b * 65 * , 144431 ( 2002 )
. i. a. campbell , k. hukushima , and h. takayama , phys .
b * 76 * , 134421 ( 2007 ) . i. a. campbell and p. butera , phys . rev .
b * 78 * , 024435 ( 2008 ) .
p. h. lundow and i. a. campbell , phys .
b * 83 * , 184408 ( 2011 ) .
b. berche , c. chatelain , c. dhall , r. kenna , r. low , and j. c. walter , j. stat .
p11010 ( 2008 ) .
v. privman , p. c. hohenberg and a. aharony , `` universal critical - point amplitude relations '' , in `` phase transitions and critical phenomena '' ( academic , ny , 1991 ) , eds . c. domb and j.l .
lebowitz , * 14 * , 1 . | a new analysis is given of numerical simulation data on the archetype square lattice ising spin glasses ( isg ) with a bimodal ( @xmath0 ) and gaussian interaction distributions .
it is well established that the ordering temperature of both models is zero .
the gaussian has a non - degenerate ground state so exponent @xmath1 and it has a continuous distribution of energy levels . for the bimodal model , above a size - dependent cross - over temperature @xmath2
there is a regime of effectively continuous energy levels ; below @xmath2 there is a distinct regime dominated by the highly degenerate ground state plus an energy gap to the excited states .
@xmath2 tends to zero at very large @xmath3 leaving only the effectively continuous regime in the thermodynamic limit .
we show that in this regime the critical exponent @xmath4 is not zero , so the effectively continuous regime @xmath5d bimodal isg is not in the same universality class as the @xmath5d gaussian isg .
the simulation data on both models are analyzed using a scaling variable @xmath6 suitable for zero temperature transition isgs , together with appropriate scaling expressions .
accurate simulation estimates can be obtained for the temperature dependence of the thermodynamic limit reduced susceptibility @xmath7 and second moment correlation length @xmath8 over the entire range of temperature from zero to infinity . the gaussian critical exponent from the simulations @xmath9 is in full agreement with
the well established value from the literature .
the bimodal exponent from the thermodynamic limit regime analysis is @xmath10 , once again different from the gaussian value . |
for a sub - markovian process @xmath0 on a locally compact set @xmath1 endowed with a non - negative radon measure @xmath2 , _ spectral radius _
@xmath3 is defined as the infimum over all those @xmath4 for which the resolvent function @xmath5 is @xmath2-integrable on compact subsets of @xmath1 for every compact set @xmath6 . under some general assumptions ,
the quantity @xmath3 can be described in several ways : * for an irreducible discrete time markov chain @xmath7 on a countable set @xmath1 , @xmath8 is a common radius of convergence of the series @xmath9 where @xmath10 are the transition probabilities of @xmath7 ( see seneta @xcite and vere - jones @xcite ) . *
@xmath11 where the supremum is taken over all compact subsets @xmath12 and @xmath13 is the sub - markovian semi - group associated to @xmath0 .
* @xmath3 is the infimum over all @xmath4 for which there is a positive measurable function @xmath14 which is @xmath2-integrable on compact subsets of @xmath1 and such that @xmath15 for all @xmath16 .
a function @xmath14 satisfying the inequality @xmath17 is usually called @xmath18-superharmonic .
a dual description of @xmath3 can be given by using @xmath18-superharmonic radon measures on @xmath1 ( see seneta @xcite , stroock @xcite and vere - jones @xcite for example ) .
* when the sub - markovian semi - group @xmath19 is generated by a symmetric linear operator @xmath20 in @xmath21 , the value @xmath22 is the bottom of the @xmath23-spectrum of @xmath20 ( see stroock @xcite and also limingwu @xcite for a similar result for discrete time markov chains ) . *
@xmath24 where the supremum is taken over all compact subsets @xmath25 and for every compact set @xmath26 , @xmath27 denotes the first exit time from the set @xmath26 ( see stroock @xcite ) .
the last description of the quantity @xmath3 shows that @xmath3 provides the rate at which the process @xmath0 leaves compact sets .
this quantity is of interest for transient markov processes , because it shows how fast the process goes to infinity . because of the first property , the value @xmath28 is usually called _ convergence parameter _ of @xmath0 . in the present paper ,
woess s terminology is used : we call the quantity @xmath3 spectral radius of the process @xmath0 , see woess s book @xcite .
while this terminology may be misleading ( in a non - symmetrical case , the correspondence between the value @xmath3 and operator properties of @xmath13 is more intricate , see vere - jones @xcite ) , it stresses the importance of the correspondence between the value @xmath3 and the spectral radius in @xmath21 of a symmetric case .
the value @xmath3 is clearly sensitive to changing the transition probabilities on compacts .
the quantity @xmath29 is defined as the infimum of @xmath3 over all such changes : @xmath30 @xmath31 denotes here spectral radius of the sub - markovian process @xmath0 killed on the set @xmath26 and the infimum is taken over all compact subsets @xmath25 .
for symmetric markov processes , by perssons principle ( see grillo @xcite for symmetric diffusions and liming wu @xcite for symmetric markov chains ) , the quantity @xmath29 is related to the @xmath23-essential spectral radius of the corresponding markov semi - group .
it is of interest for recurrent markov processes : given a compact set @xmath25 , let @xmath32 denote the first hitting time of @xmath26 , then under some general assumptions , the number @xmath29 equals the infimum over all those @xmath4 for which the function @xmath33 is @xmath2-integrable on compact subsets of @xmath34 ( see proposition [ pr3 - 3 ] below ) .
the quantity @xmath29 provides therefore the rate at which the process returns to compacts . for some positive recurrent countable markov chains
, the quantity @xmath29 gives an accurate bound to the rate of convergence to equilibrium : malyshev and spieksma @xcite have shown that this is the best geometric convergence rate when the transitions of the markov chain are changed on a finite subset of @xmath1 . for more details concerning a relationship between the quantity @xmath29 and the rate of convergence to equilibrium
see liming wu @xcite ) .
unfortunately , in practice , outside of some particular examples , an explicit representation of @xmath29 is very difficult to obtain . in the present paper
, we consider a markov process @xmath0 on @xmath35 for which the family of rescaled processes @xmath36)$ ] satisfies sample path large deviation principle with a good rate function @xmath37}$ ] .
the quantities @xmath3 and @xmath29 are represented in terms of the rate function : we show that @xmath38}(\phi ) \quad \text { and } \quad \log r^*_e = - \inf_{\substack{\phi(0)=\phi(1 ) , \\
\phi(t)\not= 0 , \ ; \forall \ ; 0<t<1 } } i_{[0,1]}(\phi)\ ] ] where the first infimum is taken over all continuous functions @xmath39 with @xmath40 and the second infimum is taken over all continuous functions @xmath39 with @xmath40 such that @xmath41 for all @xmath42 .
the first result in this domain was obtained by malyshev and spieksma @xcite for discrete time partially homogeneous random walks in @xmath43 and in @xmath44 .
unfortunately , their proofs use particular properties of the processes and it is not usually possible to extend them to a more general situation ( see section [ sec1 ] for more details ) .
our results are motivated by applications to reflected diffusions considered by varadhan and williams @xcite and jump markov processes describing stochastic networks . for these processes , the sample paths large deviation principle has been established and an explicit representation of the corresponding rate function has been obtained ( see @xcite for example ) while the essential spectral radius @xmath29 has not been identified .
an example of jackson networks illustrates our results . using relation ( [ e1-i ] )
we obtain an explicit representation of the quantities @xmath3 and @xmath29 for two - dimensional jackson networks . in the forthcoming paper
, we apply our results for reflected diffusions in @xmath45 .
we consider a strong markov process @xmath0 on @xmath46 whose sample paths are right continuous with left limits .
the set @xmath1 is endowed by a non - negative radon measure @xmath2 .
we assume that the set @xmath1 is closed and unbounded and that @xmath47 for every open non - empty subset @xmath48 . given a closed set @xmath49 , @xmath50 denotes the hitting time of @xmath51 : @xmath52 by convention @xmath53 .
it is assumed that for every real bounded measurable function @xmath54 on @xmath1 , the mapping @xmath55 is @xmath56-measurable from @xmath57 to @xmath58 . * spectral radius * @xmath3 is the infimum of all those @xmath4 for which the resolvent function @xmath59 is @xmath2-integrable on compact subsets of @xmath1 for every compact subset @xmath6 . * essential spectral radius * @xmath60 is the infimum of all those @xmath4 for which there is a compact set @xmath25 such that the truncated resolvent function @xmath61 is @xmath2-integrable on compact subsets of @xmath34 for every compact subset @xmath62 . the markov process @xmath0 is assumed to satisfy the following large deviation conditions
. * assumption ( a ) : large deviations .
* _ let @xmath63 be the set of all possible limits @xmath64 with @xmath65 , and let @xmath66,{\cal e})$ ] denote the skorohod space of all functions @xmath39 from @xmath67 $ ] to @xmath63 which are right continuous and have left limits .
we assume that _ * @xmath68 and the set @xmath69 is convex ; * for every @xmath70 , the family of rescaled processes @xmath71)\stackrel{\text{def.}}{= } ( x(at)/a , \ ; t\in[0,t])\ ] ] satisfies sample path large deviation principle in @xmath66,{\cal e})$ ] with a good rate functions @xmath72}$ ] ( see section [ sec4 ] for a precise definition ) ; * the rate function @xmath72}$ ] has an integral form : there is a local rate function @xmath73 such that @xmath74}(\phi ) = \int_0^t l(\phi(t),\dot\phi(t ) ) \,dt\ ] ] if the function @xmath75\to { \cal e}$ ] is absolutely continuous , and @xmath37}(\phi ) = + \infty$ ] otherwise .
* there are two convex functions @xmath76 and @xmath77 on @xmath35 such that * * @xmath78 for all @xmath79 and for all @xmath80 , * * the function @xmath77 is finite in a neighborhood of zero * * and @xmath81 for @xmath82 and @xmath16 , we denote by @xmath83 the infimum of the rate function @xmath84}(\phi)$ ] over all continuous functions @xmath85 \to { \cal e}$ ] with @xmath86 and @xmath87 , @xmath88 denotes the infimum of @xmath84}(\phi)$ ] over all continuous functions @xmath85 \to { \cal e}$ ] for which @xmath86 , @xmath87 and the set @xmath89~ : \phi(s)=0 \}$ ] has lebesgue measure zero , @xmath90 denotes the infimum of @xmath84}(\phi)$ ] over all continuous functions @xmath85 \to { \cal e}$ ] such that @xmath86 , @xmath87 and @xmath91 for all @xmath92 .
@xmath93 denotes the constant function @xmath94 .
the quantities @xmath95 and @xmath96 are defined by @xmath97 using classical large deviation techniques we obtain the following result .
[ th1 ] under the hypotheses ( a ) , for any @xmath82 , @xmath98}(\ol{0 } ) ~=~ - \limsup_{t\to + \infty } i(t , x , y)/t ~=~ - \inf_{\phi(0)=\phi(1 ) } i_{[0,1]}(\phi)\ ] ] where the infimum is taken over all continuous functions @xmath75\to { \cal e}$ ] with @xmath40 .
our main technical result is the following theorem .
[ th2 ] under the hypotheses ( a ) , for any @xmath82 , @xmath99}(\phi ) \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the infimum is taken over all continuous functions @xmath75\to { \cal e}$ ] with @xmath40 such that @xmath41 for all @xmath42 .
theorem [ th2 ] extends the result obtained earlier by malyshev and spieksma @xcite for discrete time homogeneous random walks in @xmath43 and in @xmath44 .
the main difficulty consists here in the proof of the upper bound @xmath100 . to get this inequality , one has to analyze the behavior of the rescaled processes @xmath101 in a neighborhood of infinity where truncations on compact sets are not sufficient . in a such situation
, freidlin - wentzel method can not be applied .
the proof of the upper bound @xmath100 proposed by malyshev and spieksma in @xcite uses particular properties of the processes : they considered discrete time random walks with uniformly bounded jumps for which the sets @xmath102 are compact and bounded uniformly in @xmath103 . for continuous time markov processes , the sets @xmath104 are usually not bounded .
moreover , their method required that for any @xmath105 there exist @xmath106 and @xmath107 such that for all @xmath108 , @xmath109 uniformly in @xmath110 on the set of all @xmath110 for which the quantity @xmath111 is finite .
such an uniform convergence is very difficult to check in practice and is sometimes wrong : this implies the uniform continuity of the mapping @xmath112}(\phi).\ ] ] for the standard brownian motion in @xmath58 , this infimum is achieved by the function @xmath113 and equals @xmath114 .
the function @xmath114 is not uniformly continuous on @xmath115 . in our paper
, we prove the inequality @xmath100 by using a method of statistical physics called cluster expansions , see for example malyshev and minlos @xcite or rivasseau @xcite . in the present setting
, this method consists in bounding the quantity @xmath116 by a limit of a sum of the terms indexed by geometrical objects called clusters where the number of terms can be estimated and for each term , a large deviation technique with an appropriate scaling can be applied .
the main steps of our proof can be summarized as follows . _
proof of the inequality _ @xmath117 for @xmath118 large enough .
@xmath119 denotes here the conditional probability given that @xmath120 ( or equivalently @xmath121 ) .
if the order of the limits in @xmath122 and @xmath123 could be reversed , a large deviation upper bound would give directly a good estimate of the right hand side of this inequality .
unfortunately , such an inversion of the limits seems very difficult to prove : for this one should be able to perform large deviation estimates simultaneously for all @xmath123 large enough with the same large deviation parameter @xmath122 large enough .
an alternative approach consists in sub - dividing the interval @xmath67 $ ] on smaller disjoint intervals @xmath124 $ ] is such a way that for every of these intervals , the desired large deviation estimates can be performed with the same parameter @xmath122 large enough . for this
we use the following preliminary results .
_ 2 . some preliminary results and constructions .
_ let @xmath125 denote the infimum of the rate function @xmath84}(\phi)$ ] over all @xmath126\to{\cal e}$ ] such that @xmath86 , @xmath87 and @xmath127 using the upper large deviation bound we show that for given @xmath128 and @xmath118 there exists a finite set @xmath129 and there are strictly positive real numbers @xmath130 and @xmath131 such that @xmath132 and for any @xmath133 , for all @xmath134 , and for any @xmath135 satisfying the inequality @xmath136 , the following inequalities hold @xmath137 } |z_a(s)| \geq n \ ; \mbox { and } \ ; z_a(1)\in b\bigl(y,\delta(x , y)\bigr)\right ) & \leq - a m_n(1,x , y ) + a\eps\end{aligned}\ ] ] when @xmath138 , and @xmath139 } |z_a(s)| \geq n \ ; \mbox { and } \ ; z_a(1 ) \in b\bigl(y,\delta(x ,
y)\bigr ) \right ) \leq - a i^*_0 n/\eps\ ] ] when @xmath140 .
here and throughout , @xmath141 denotes the open ball centered at @xmath103 and having radius @xmath142 .
_ 3 . change of scale_. using the above estimates and the identity @xmath143 we conclude that for any @xmath133 , for all @xmath144 , @xmath145 and @xmath146 , and for any @xmath147 , the following inequalities hold @xmath148 } |z_a(s)| \geq nt \ ; \mbox { and } \ ; z_a(t)\in t b\bigl(y,\delta(x , y)\bigr)\right ) \\ \leq - a m_n(t , tx , ty ) + at\eps\end{gathered}\ ] ] when @xmath149 , and @xmath150 } |z_a(s)| \geq n t\ ; \mbox { and } \ ; z_a(t ) \in t b\bigl(y,\delta(x , y)\bigr ) \right ) \leq - a t i^*_0 n/\eps\ ] ] otherwise .
these inequalities hold simultaneously for all @xmath133 and @xmath151 when @xmath152 .
such a change of scale is a key point of our proof .
cluster expansion_. for given @xmath105 , @xmath118 and @xmath123 , and for every function @xmath153,{\cal e})$ ] with @xmath154 for all @xmath155 and such that @xmath156 and @xmath157 , we define a partition @xmath158 and a sequence @xmath159 , as follows . *
if @xmath160 we let @xmath161 and we choose @xmath162 such that @xmath163 and @xmath164 . *
otherwise , we divide the interval @xmath67 $ ] in two intervals @xmath165 $ ] and @xmath166 $ ] and we restart our construction for the restriction of @xmath39 on each of them .
this algorithm terminates because @xmath167 for all @xmath155 .
the resulting sequence @xmath168 is called @xmath169- cluster corresponding to @xmath39 ( see section [ sec6 ] for a more careful definition of @xmath169- cluster ) . in statistical physics , the notion of cluster is usually associated with a connected graph . in our context , the cluster @xmath170 is connected in the following sense : @xmath171 for every @xmath172 . for each cluster @xmath173 we consider the quantity @xmath174 where the supremum is taken over all @xmath175 . using inequality ( [ e3 - 1 ] ) we obtain @xmath176 where the summation is taken over all clusters @xmath177 @xmath178 for which the sets @xmath179 and @xmath180 are non - empty .
cluster estimates_. we show that for given @xmath181 , @xmath118 and @xmath182 , there are at most @xmath183 clusters .
for every cluster @xmath177 @xmath178 we obtain a good estimate of the quantity @xmath184 by using the inequalities ( [ e4 - 1 ] ) , ( [ e5 - 1 ] ) with @xmath185 , @xmath186 and @xmath187 for every @xmath188 ( see lemma [ lem6 - 6 ] below ) and we deduce from them the desired inequality @xmath100 .
our paper is organized as follows .
section [ secii ] is devoted to general properties of the quantities @xmath3 and @xmath29 .
in section [ sec4 ] , the definition and some useful properties of sample path large deviations are recalled and different representations of the quantities @xmath95 and @xmath96 are derived .
section [ sec5 ] is devoted to the proof of theorem [ th1 ] .
theorem [ th2 ] is proved in section [ sec6 ] . in section [ sec7 ]
we apply our results to calculate the quantities @xmath3 and @xmath29 for two dimensional jackson networks . to simplify the notations , we consider continuous time markov processes . for discrete time markov processes our results
can be extended in a straightforward way .
in this section , we recall general properties of the quantities @xmath3 and @xmath29 . for @xmath4 and for a real bounded measurable function @xmath54 on @xmath1 , the resolvent function is defined by @xmath189 where @xmath190 denotes markov semi - group corresponding to the process @xmath0 : @xmath191 recall that by definition , @xmath3 is the infimum of all those @xmath4 for which the function @xmath192 is @xmath2-integrable on compact subsets of @xmath1 for every compact set @xmath193 .
it is clear moreover that @xmath3 is the infimum of all those @xmath4 for which the function @xmath194 is @xmath2-integrable on compact subsets of @xmath1 for every non - negative continuous function @xmath54 having a compact support .
the following property of the quantity @xmath3 immediately follows from the definition .
[ pr0 - 2 ] @xmath195 where the supremum @xmath196 is taken over all compact subsets @xmath197 .
moreover , if for a compact set @xmath193 , there exists a compact set @xmath198 and there are real numbers @xmath16 and @xmath181 such that @xmath199 for all @xmath92 , then for any compact subset @xmath6 , @xmath200 indeed , relation ( [ e1 - 2 ] ) holds because by fubini s theorem @xmath201 suppose moreover that for a compact set @xmath193 there are real numbers @xmath16 and @xmath181 and a compact set @xmath198 such that @xmath202 for all @xmath92 and for all @xmath203 . then for any increasing sequence of real positive numbers @xmath204 with @xmath205 , the following inequalities hold @xmath206 the last inequality shows that for @xmath207 , @xmath208 whenever @xmath209 and consequently , inequality ( [ e3 - 2 ] ) is verified
the following proposition shows that for a large class of markov processes , the quantity @xmath3 can be represented in terms of @xmath18-superharmonic functions .
a measurable function @xmath210 is called @xmath18-superharmonic with @xmath4 if the inequality @xmath15 holds for all @xmath211 .
we say that a function @xmath14 is locally @xmath2-integrable on @xmath1 if it is @xmath2-integrable on the compact subsets of @xmath1 .
[ pr1 - 2 ] suppose that there exists a non - negative continuous function @xmath212 on @xmath1 having a compact support such that for every @xmath16 the function @xmath213 is continuous on @xmath1 and for every @xmath214 there exists @xmath16 such that @xmath215 .
then @xmath3 is the infimum of all those @xmath4 for which there exists a non - negative locally @xmath2-integrable @xmath18-superharmonic function @xmath14 with @xmath216 for every compact subset @xmath6 .
indeed , for @xmath217 , the function @xmath218 is non - negative locally @xmath2-integrable and @xmath18-superharmonic .
moreover , the sample paths of the markov process @xmath0 being right continuous , the mapping @xmath219 is right continuous and hence , under the hypotheses of our proposition , @xmath220 for every @xmath214 . finally , by fatou
s lemma , the function @xmath218 is lower semi - continuous on @xmath1 and consequently , for any compact set @xmath6 , @xmath221 conversely , suppose that for @xmath4 there exists a non - negative locally @xmath2-integrable @xmath18-superharmonic function @xmath14 such that @xmath216 for every compact subset @xmath6 .
then for every compact set @xmath6 , and for any @xmath16 and @xmath207 , @xmath222 > from this it follows that for any @xmath223 , the function @xmath224 is locally @xmath2-integrable and consequently , @xmath225 .
proposition [ pr1 - 2 ] is therefore verified .
recall that by definition , the quantity @xmath29 is the infimum over all those @xmath4 for which there is a compact set @xmath25 , such that the the truncated resolvent function @xmath226 is @xmath2-integrable on the compact subsets of @xmath34 for every compact set @xmath62 .
[ pr0 - 3 ] @xmath227 where the infimum is taken over all compact subsets @xmath25 and the supremum is taken over all compact subsets @xmath228 .
suppose moreover that for any compact subset @xmath25 there are compact sets @xmath229 and there is a real number @xmath16 such that @xmath230 then @xmath231 where the infimum @xmath232 is taken over all compact subsets @xmath25 and the supremum is taken over all compact subsets @xmath233 .
indeed , let @xmath31 be the infimum over all those @xmath4 for which the function ( [ e1 - 3 ] ) is @xmath2-integrable on the compact subsets of @xmath34 for every compact set @xmath233 .
using the same arguments as for the proof of proposition [ pr0 - 2 ] we obtain that for every compact set @xmath25 , @xmath234 and moreover , for compact subsets @xmath228 , @xmath235 if there are a compact set @xmath236 and a real numbers @xmath16 such that @xmath237 using relation @xmath238 , this proves proposition [ pr0 - 3 ] .
the next proposition describes the quantity @xmath29 in terms of lyapunov functions which are superharmonic outside of compact sets .
a measurable function @xmath210 is called @xmath18-superharmonic outside of a compact set @xmath25 with @xmath4 if the inequality @xmath239 holds for all @xmath240 and for all @xmath211 .
[ pr1 - 3 ] suppose that there exists an increasing sequence of open relatively compact sets @xmath241 such that @xmath242 and let for every @xmath243 there exist a non - negative continuous function @xmath244 on @xmath1 having a compact support in @xmath245 such that for every @xmath16 the function @xmath246 is continuous on @xmath245 and for every @xmath247 there exists @xmath16 such that @xmath248 then @xmath29 is the infimum of all those @xmath4 for which there exists a compact set @xmath25 and a non - negative locally @xmath2-integrable @xmath18-superharmonic outside of @xmath26 function @xmath14 with @xmath216 for every compact subset @xmath233 .
given a compact subset @xmath25 , let @xmath31 be the infimum over all those @xmath4 for which the function ( [ e1 - 3 ] ) is @xmath2-integrable on the compact subsets of @xmath34 for every compact set @xmath233 , and let @xmath249 be the infimum of all those @xmath4 for which there exists a non - negative locally @xmath2-integrable @xmath18-superharmonic outside of @xmath26 function @xmath14 with @xmath216 for every compact subset @xmath233 .
the same arguments as in the proof of proposition [ pr1 - 2 ] show that for @xmath250 , @xmath251 for every @xmath243 .
the quantities @xmath31 and @xmath249 being decreasing with respect to @xmath26 , this implies that @xmath252 where the last infimum is taken over all compact subsets @xmath25 .
proposition [ pr1 - 3 ] is therefore proved .
let @xmath253 denote the infimum over all those @xmath4 for which there is a compact set @xmath25 such that the function @xmath254 is @xmath2-integrable on the compact subsets of @xmath34 .
the following proposition represents the number @xmath253 in terms of lyapunov functions .
[ pr2 - 3 ] @xmath253 is the infimum of all those @xmath4 for which there exists a compact set @xmath25 and a non - negative locally @xmath2-integrable @xmath18-superharmonic outside of @xmath26 function @xmath14 with @xmath255 .
suppose that for @xmath256 , there is a non - negative @xmath257-superharmonic outside of @xmath26 function @xmath14 which is @xmath2-integrable on the compact subsets of @xmath34 and such that @xmath255 .
then for any @xmath16 , and for any @xmath240 , @xmath258 for any @xmath259 , the function ( [ e4 - 3 ] ) is therefore @xmath2-integrable on the compact subsets of @xmath34 and consequently , @xmath260 .
the function ( [ e4 - 3 ] ) being @xmath18-superharmonic outside of @xmath26 , this proves proposition [ pr2 - 3 ] .
the next proposition shows that for a large class of recurrent markov processes , the quantities @xmath29 and @xmath261 are equal .
[ pr3 - 3 ] suppose that the hypotheses of proposition [ pr1 - 3 ] are satisfied and let for every @xmath262 , and @xmath263 , @xmath264-almost surely for every @xmath265
. then @xmath266 .
if for @xmath4 there is a compact set @xmath25 such that the function ( [ e4 - 3 ] ) is @xmath2-integrable on the compact subsets of @xmath34 , then for every compact set @xmath6 , the function ( [ e1 - 3 ] ) is @xmath2-integrable on the compact subsets of @xmath34 and therefore , @xmath267 .
let us prove that @xmath268 .
because of proposition [ pr2 - 3 ] , it is sufficient to show that for any @xmath269 there is @xmath243 and a non - negative @xmath18-superharmonic outside of @xmath270 function @xmath14 which is @xmath2-integrable on the compact subsets of @xmath271 and such that @xmath272 . it is sufficient moreover to consider the case when @xmath273 because for @xmath274 , the function @xmath275 is @xmath18-superharmonic . given a compact subset @xmath25 , let @xmath31 be the infimum over all those @xmath4 for which the function ( [ e1 - 3 ] ) is @xmath2-integrable on the compact subsets of @xmath34 for every compact set @xmath233 .
the quantity @xmath31 being decreasing with respect to @xmath26 , @xmath276 given @xmath277 let us choose @xmath278 such that @xmath279 and let @xmath280 be such that @xmath281 . under the hypotheses of proposition
[ pr1 - 3 ] the function @xmath282 is @xmath2-integrable on the compact subsets of @xmath283 and @xmath18-superharmonic outside of @xmath284 .
moreover the same arguments as for the proof of proposition [ pr1 - 2 ] show that for any compact subset @xmath285 , there is @xmath286 such that @xmath287 consider a compact set @xmath288 . using strong markov property , we obtain @xmath289 the last equality holds here because under the hypotheses of our proposition , for all @xmath290 , @xmath264-almost surely @xmath291 .
the function @xmath14 being @xmath2-integrable on the compact subsets of @xmath271 and @xmath18-superharmonic outside of @xmath292 the last relation shows that @xmath293 .
letting finally @xmath294 we conclude that @xmath295 .
the equality @xmath296 is therefore proved .
let @xmath66,\r^d)$ ] denote the set of all right continuous with left limits functions from @xmath67 $ ] to @xmath35 endowed with skorohod metric @xmath297 . recall that skorohod metric @xmath298 is defined as the infimum of those positive @xmath299 for which there exists a strictly increasing continuous mapping @xmath300 from @xmath67 $ ] onto itself satisfying inequalities @xmath301 where the metric is induced by the euclidean norm @xmath302 on @xmath35 .
the space @xmath66,\r^d)$ ] endowed with skorohod
metric is complete . a sequence @xmath303,\r^d)$ ]
converges to a limit @xmath153,\r^d)$ ] in the skorohod metric if and only if there exist strictly increasing continuous mappings @xmath304\to [ 0,t]$ ] such that @xmath305 , @xmath306 , @xmath307 as @xmath308 uniformly in @xmath309 $ ] and @xmath310 as @xmath308 uniformly in @xmath311 $ ] .
when @xmath39 is continuous on @xmath67 $ ] , skorohod convergence @xmath312 implies uniform convergence . for non - continuous @xmath39
, skorohod convergence @xmath312 implies @xmath313 , @xmath314 and @xmath315 for continuity points @xmath309 $ ] of @xmath39 . for more details about skorohod metric , we refer the reader to billingsley @xcite .
we consider a markov process @xmath0 on @xmath316 .
the trajectories of the markov process @xmath317 are assumed to be almost surely right continuous and to have left limits .
\1 ) a mapping @xmath72}:~d([0,t],\r^d)\to [ 0,+\infty]$ ] is a _ good rate function _ on @xmath66,\r^d)$ ] if for any @xmath318 and for any compact set @xmath319 , the set @xmath320,\r^d ) : ~\phi(0)\in v \ ; \mbox { and } \ ; i_{[0,t]}(\varphi ) \leq
c \}\ ] ] is compact in @xmath66,\r^d)$ ] .
according to this definition , a good rate function is lower semi - continuous .
\2 ) the family of scaled markov processes @xmath71)\stackrel{\text{def.}}{= } ( x(at)/a , \ ; t\in[0,t])\ ] ] is said to satisfy _ sample path large deviation principle _ in @xmath66 , \r^d)$ ] with a rate function @xmath72}$ ] if for any @xmath321 @xmath322}(\phi),\ ] ] for every open set @xmath323,\r^d)$ ] , and @xmath324}(\phi).\ ] ] for every closed set @xmath325,\r^d)$ ] .
@xmath326 denotes here and throughout a conditional probability given that @xmath327 ( or equivalently @xmath328 ) , the infimum at the left hand side of the inequality ( [ e - lb-4 ] ) and the supremum at the left hand side of the inequality ( [ e - ub-4 ] ) are taken over all @xmath329 satisfying the inequality @xmath330 .
we refer to sample path large deviation principle as spld principle
. inequalities ( [ e - lb-4 ] ) and ( [ e - ub-4 ] ) are referred as lower and upper spld bounds respectively .
the following statement is a consequence of contraction principle ( see dembo and zeitouni @xcite ) and the identity @xmath331 .
[ pr1 - 4 ] suppose that the family of scaled processes @xmath332 satisfies spld principle in @xmath333,\r^d)$ ] with a good rate functions @xmath37}$ ] .
then for any @xmath70 , this family of processes satisfies spld principle in @xmath66,\r^d)$ ] with the good rate functions @xmath334}(\phi ) = t i_{[0,1]}(g_t\phi)\ ] ] where @xmath335 denotes a mapping from @xmath66,\r^d)$ ] to @xmath333,\r^d)$ ] defined by @xmath336.\ ] ] when the spld principle holds , the corresponding rate function is unique and hence , under the hypotheses ( a ) , relation ( [ e1 - 4 ] ) is satisfied . a good rate function
satisfies moreover the following properties .
[ lem1 - 4 ] for any closed set @xmath337,\r^d)$ ] , the mapping @xmath338}(\phi)\ ] ] is lower semi - continuous on @xmath339 . indeed , for any @xmath318 and for any compact set @xmath340 , @xmath341}(\phi ) \leq c \ } = \\
\bigcap_n \xi(k_n)\ ] ] where @xmath342}(\phi ) \leq c + 1/n \}$ ] and the mapping @xmath343,\r^d)\to\r^2 $ ] is defined by @xmath344 .
the sets @xmath292 being compact and the mapping @xmath345 being continuous , the sets @xmath346 are compact .
this proves that the set is also compact and consequently , the mapping is lower semi - continuous . throughout this section , @xmath72}$ ]
denotes a good rate function on @xmath66,\r^d)$ ] satisfying assumption ( a ) and relation ( [ e1 - 4 ] ) .
recall that @xmath63 denotes the set of all possible limits @xmath64 with @xmath65 .
according to assumption ( a ) , * the set @xmath69 is convex and non - empty ; * the rate function @xmath72}$ ] has an integral form : there is a local rate function @xmath73 such that @xmath74}(\phi ) = \int_0^t l(\phi(t),\dot\phi(t ) ) \ , dt\ ] ] if the function @xmath75\to { \cal e}$ ] is absolutely continuous , and @xmath37}(\phi ) = + \infty$ ] otherwise .
* there is a convex function @xmath77 on @xmath35 that is finite in a neighborhood of zero and such that @xmath347 for all @xmath79 and for all @xmath80 . here and throughout , for @xmath82 and @xmath16
, @xmath83 denotes the infimum of the rate function @xmath84}(\phi)$ ] over all continuous functions @xmath85\to{\cal e}$ ] with @xmath86 and @xmath87 , @xmath90 denotes the infimum of the rate function @xmath84}(\phi)$ ] over all continuous functions @xmath85\to{\cal e}$ ] such that @xmath86 , @xmath87 and @xmath91 for all @xmath3480,t[$ ] , and @xmath88 is the infimum of the rate function @xmath84}(\phi)$ ] over all those @xmath85\to{\cal e}$ ] for which @xmath86 , @xmath87 and the set @xmath349 : \phi(s)=0\}$ ] has lebesgue measure zero . by definition , @xmath350 * remark 1*. because of relation ( [ e1 - 4 ] ) , for any @xmath82 and @xmath16 , @xmath351 and @xmath352 * remark 2*. the integral representation of the rate function implies that for any @xmath153,\r^d)$ ] and @xmath353 , @xmath354}(\phi ) = i_{[0,t]}(\phi ) + i_{[t , t]}(\phi)\ ] ] where @xmath355}(\phi ) = i_{[0,t - t]}(\phi(t+\cdot))$ ] . from this it follows that for any @xmath356 , @xmath357 moreover , for @xmath358 , @xmath359 * remark 3*. since the function @xmath77 is convex and finite in a neighborhood of zero , there are @xmath360 and @xmath361 such that @xmath362 for all @xmath80 with @xmath363 . hence , for @xmath364 with @xmath82
such that @xmath365 , @xmath366}(\phi ) ~\leq~ l_2(y - x ) \leq c.\ ] ] using relations ( [ e1 - 4p ] ) and ( [ e2 - 4p ] ) this implies that @xmath367 for all @xmath82 and for all @xmath368 .
using relations ( [ e2 - 4p ] ) and ( [ e3 - 4p ] ) we obtain the following statement .
[ lem2 - 4 ] for any continuous function @xmath369\to { \cal e}$ ] with @xmath370 , @xmath371}(\phi ) \geq i_{[0,t]}(\ol{0})\ ] ] and @xmath372}(\phi ) \geq
i_0(1,0,0 ) \ , \mes\{t\in[0,t]:\phi(t)\not=0\}\ ] ] where @xmath373:\phi(t)\not=0\}$ ] denotes lebesgue measure of the set @xmath374:\phi(t)\not=0\}$ ] .
indeed , given a continuous function @xmath369\to { \cal e}$ ] with @xmath375 , consider a sequence of functions @xmath376\to
{ \cal e}$ ] defined by @xmath377 for all @xmath378 $ ] and for all @xmath379 .
it is clear that @xmath380 as @xmath308 uniformly on @xmath67 $ ] .
the rate function @xmath72}(\cdot)$ ] being lower semi - continuous , this implies that @xmath381}(\phi_n ) \geq i_{[0,t]}(\ol{0})\ ] ] because uniform convergence implies skorohod convergence .
relations ( [ e1 - 4 ] ) and ( [ e3 - 4p ] ) show that @xmath72}(\phi_n ) = n i_{[0,t / n]}(\phi_n ) = i_{[0,t]}(\phi)$ ] and hence , the last inequality proves relation ( [ e5 - 4p ] ) .
furthermore , for such a function @xmath39 , the set @xmath3820,t[:\phi(t)\not=0\}$ ] is a union of countable family of open disjoint intervals @xmath383t_i , t'_i [ \subset [ 0,t]$ ] , @xmath384 . using relation ( [ e3 - 4p ] )
we obtain @xmath74}(\phi ) \geq
\sum_i i_{[t_i , t'_i]}(\phi ) \geq \sum_i i_0(t'_i - t_i,0,0 ) = i_0(1,0,0 ) \sum_i ( t'_i - t_i)\ ] ] where the second relation holds because for every @xmath385 , @xmath386 and @xmath387 for all @xmath388t_i , t'_i[$ ] , and the third relation follows from relation ( [ e1 - 4 ] ) .
the last relation proves inequality ( [ e6 - 4p ] ) .
the following proposition gives several equivalent representations of @xmath95 and @xmath96 .
[ prop1 - 4 ] 1 ) for any @xmath82 and @xmath70 , @xmath389}(\ol{0 } ) ~=~ \limsup_{t\to + \infty } i(t , x , y)/t ~=~ \inf_{\phi(0)=\phi(t ) } i_{[0,t]}(\phi)/t\ ] ] where the infimum is taken over all continuous functions @xmath369\to { \cal e}$ ] with @xmath390 , and @xmath391}(\phi)/t \label{e8 - 4p}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the infimum is taken over all continuous functions @xmath369\to { \cal e}$ ] with @xmath390 such that @xmath41 for all @xmath353 .
the equalities @xmath392}(\ol{0})$ ] and @xmath393 hold because of lemma [ lem1 - 4 ] .
furthermore , relation ( [ e4 - 4p ] ) and the inequality @xmath394 show that the limits @xmath395 and @xmath396 do not depend on @xmath397 . since by ( [ e1 - 4p ] ) , @xmath398
, we conclude that for any @xmath397 @xmath399 moreover , relation ( [ e3 - 4p ] ) shows that @xmath400 for all @xmath401 , @xmath70 and @xmath243 and consequently , @xmath402 the last relation combined with the inequality @xmath403}(\phi)/t\ ] ] proves that @xmath404}(\phi)/t.\ ] ] relation ( [ e7 - 4p ] ) is therefore proved .
the same arguments show that for all @xmath401 and @xmath70 @xmath405}(\phi)/t\ ] ] where the infimum is taken over all continuous functions @xmath369\to{\cal e}$ ] with @xmath390 for which the set @xmath406 has lebesgue measure zero , that the limits @xmath407 , @xmath408 and @xmath409 do not depend on @xmath410 and that for every @xmath70 , @xmath4110,t [ } } i_{[0,t]}(\phi)/t , \quad i=1,2.\end{aligned}\ ] ] hence , to complete the proof of relation ( [ e8 - 4p ] ) it is sufficient to show that the infimum at the right hand side of the above relation does not exceed @xmath412 , or equivalently that @xmath413}(\phi ) \geq \inf_{x\not=0 } i_0(t , x , x).\ ] ] for any continuous function @xmath414\to{\cal e}$ ] with @xmath415 and @xmath41 for all @xmath3880,t[$ ] .
for such a function @xmath39 , for every @xmath416 there is a function @xmath417\to { \cal e}$ ] with @xmath418 , @xmath419 and @xmath420 such that @xmath421 for all @xmath422 $ ] and @xmath423}(\psi_\delta ) \leq
ct_\delta$ ] ( see remark 3 ) . define the function @xmath424 by setting @xmath425 for @xmath426 $ ] and @xmath427 for @xmath428 $ ] .
then , using relation ( [ e3 - 4p ] ) , we get @xmath429}(\phi_\delta ) = i_{[0,t_\delta]}(\psi_\delta ) + i_{[\delta , t -\delta]}(\phi ) \leq
ct_\delta + i_{[0,t]}(\phi)\ ] ] and using relation ( [ e2 - 4p ] ) it follows that @xmath430}(\phi_\delta ) & \geq i_0(t - 2\delta + t_\delta,\phi(\delta),\phi(\delta ) ) \\ & \geq \inf_{x\not=0 } i_0(t - 2\delta + t_\delta , x , x ) = \frac{1}{t}(t - 2\delta + t_\delta ) \inf_{x\not=0 } i_0(t , x , x).\end{aligned}\ ] ] this proves that @xmath74}(\phi ) \geq \frac{1}{t}(t - 2\delta + t_\delta ) \inf_{x\not=0 } i_0(t , x , x ) - ct_\delta.\ ] ] letting at the last inequality @xmath431 we obtain relation ( [ e8 - 4pp ] ) .
recall that @xmath83 denotes the infimum of the rate functions @xmath84}(\phi)$ ] over all continuous functions @xmath85\to{\cal e}$ ] , with @xmath86 and @xmath87 . by proposition [ prop1 - 4 ] , @xmath432}(\ol{0 } )
~=~ \limsup_{t\to + \infty } i(t , x , y)/t ~=~ \inf_{\phi(0)=\phi(t ) } i_{[0,t]}(\phi)/t\ ] ] where the infimum is taken over all continuous functions @xmath369\to { \cal e}$ ] with @xmath390 .
to complete the proof of theorem [ th1 ] it is sufficient therefore to show that @xmath433 . to prove the upper bound @xmath434 we use proposition [ pr0 - 2 ] and the spld upper bound .
the spld upper bound implies that for all compact sets @xmath435 , @xmath436}(\phi ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the infimum is taken over all continuous functions @xmath437\to { \cal e}$ ] with @xmath438 and @xmath439 .
the right hand side of the last inequality equals @xmath440 the mapping @xmath441 being lower semi - continuous ( see lemma [ lem1 - 4 ] ) , using proposition [ pr0 - 2 ] we conclude that @xmath442 inequality ( [ e1 - 5 ] ) is therefore proved . to prove the lower bound @xmath443 we use relation ( [ e3 - 2 ] ) of proposition [ pr0 - 2 ] and the spld lower bound .
the hypotheses of proposition [ pr0 - 2 ] are satisfied for every compact set @xmath193 with @xmath444 and @xmath445 for @xmath446 and for @xmath447 large enough because @xmath448 if @xmath449 , and because by the spld lower bound , @xmath450}(\phi ) \\ & \geq~ - i_{[0,1]}(\ol{0 } ) ~\geq - l_2(0 ) ~ > -\infty .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] using relation ( [ e3 - 2 ] ) with @xmath451 and letting @xmath452 , we obtain @xmath453 hence , by markov property , @xmath454 furthermore , spld lower bound proves that for any @xmath455 and for any @xmath321 , there exist @xmath456 and @xmath457 such that for all @xmath458 and for all @xmath459 satisfying inequality @xmath460 , @xmath461}(\phi ) - \sigma \\ & \geq -\inf_{y : |y| < \eps } i(1,x , y ) - \sigma ~\geq~ - i(1,x,0 ) - \sigma .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] recall that @xmath462 and consequently , @xmath463 .
the set @xmath464 being compact , there are @xmath465 such that @xmath466 for @xmath467 , we obtain therefore @xmath468 the last relation combined with inequality ( [ e2 - 5 ] ) proves that @xmath469 finally , relations ( [ e1 - 4p ] ) and ( [ e3 - 4p ] ) show that for any @xmath42 , @xmath470 and consequently , for @xmath471 , using inequality ( [ e4 - 4p ] ) it follows that @xmath472 letting at the last inequality @xmath473 , we conclude @xmath474 .
the inequality @xmath475 combined with ( [ e1 - 5 ] ) proves that @xmath476 .
recall that for @xmath477 and @xmath16 , @xmath88 denotes the infimum of @xmath84}(\phi)$ ] over all continuous functions @xmath478\to{\cal e}$ ] with @xmath86 , @xmath87 for which the set @xmath89~ : \phi(s)=0 \}$ ] has lebesgue measure zero .
@xmath90 denotes the infimum of @xmath84}(\phi)$ ] over all continuous functions @xmath478\to{\cal e}$ ] such that @xmath86 , @xmath87 and @xmath91 for all @xmath92 . by proposition [ prop1 - 4 ] , @xmath479}(\phi)/t \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the infimum is taken over all continuous functions @xmath369\to { \cal e}$ ] with @xmath390 such that @xmath41 for all @xmath353 .
to prove theorem [ th2 ] it is sufficient therefore to show that @xmath480 .
the proof of this inequality uses relation ( [ e3 - 3 ] ) of proposition [ pr0 - 3 ] and spld lower bound .
we begin our proof with the following lemma .
[ lem1 - 6p ] under the hypotheses ( a ) , for any compact subset @xmath482 , for any @xmath483 , and for any @xmath484 such that @xmath485 , the inequality @xmath486 holds with @xmath487 and @xmath488 for all @xmath447 large enough .
let @xmath483 , @xmath144 and @xmath484 be such that @xmath489 .
for a compact subset @xmath25 are is @xmath490 such that for @xmath491 , @xmath492 . for @xmath487 and @xmath488 , @xmath493 for all @xmath491 .
moreover because of spld lower bound and assumption @xmath494 , @xmath495}(\phi ) \\ & \geq~ -l_2(0 ) ~>~ -\infty \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath496 .
the last inequality shows that for any @xmath128 small enough , there is @xmath497 such that for every @xmath498 , the right hand side of inequality ( [ e2 - 6 ] ) is strictly positive and hence , inequality ( [ e1 - 6 ] ) holds .
because of lemma [ lem1 - 6p ] and proposition [ pr0 - 3 ] , relation ( [ e3 - 3 ] ) holds for any compact set @xmath25 with @xmath499 for any @xmath500 and for all @xmath447 large enough . using this relation together with markov property we obtain @xmath501 } |z_a(s)| >
\sigma\right ) \\ \geq&~ \liminf_{a\to + \infty } \lim_{n\to \infty }
\inf_{y : |y - x| \leq \eps } \frac{1}{ant } \log \p_{ay } \left(\max_{k\leq n } |z_a(kt)-x| < \eps , \inf_{s\in[0,nt ] } |z_a(s)| > \sigma\right ) \\ \geq&~ \liminf_{a\to \infty } \inf_{y : |y - x| \leq \eps}\frac{1}{at } \log \p_{ay } \left(|z_a(t)-x| < \eps , \ ; \inf_{s\in[0,t ] } |z_a(s)| > \sigma \right)\end{aligned}\ ] ] for any @xmath70 . the last inequality combined with the spld lower bound ,
the same arguments as in the proof of theorem [ th1 ] ( see the proof of inequality ( [ e2 - 5 ] ) ) and relation ( [ e3 - 4p ] ) show that for any @xmath502 , @xmath503 where @xmath504 denotes the infimum of the rate function @xmath84}(\phi)$ ] over all those @xmath505,{\cal e})$ ] for which @xmath506 , @xmath507 and @xmath508 for all @xmath509 $ ] .
moreover , letting @xmath510 we get @xmath511 for all @xmath512 $ ] and consequently , by assumption ( a ) , @xmath513}(\phi_y ) ~=~ \int_0 ^ 1 l(\phi_y(t ) , \dot\phi_y(t ) ) \ , dt ~\leq~ l_2(y - x).\ ] ] using this relation for the right hand side of inequality ( [ e3 - 6 ] ) and letting @xmath514 we obtain @xmath515 the function @xmath77 being finite in a neighborhood of zero , this implies that @xmath516 the last inequality combined with relation ( [ e0 - 6 ] ) proves that @xmath517 . to prove this relation we use proposition [ pr0 - 3 ] and the spld upper bound .
because of proposition [ pr0 - 3 ] , for any @xmath118 , @xmath518 to estimate the right hand side of this inequality , we use cluster expansion method and spld upper bound . before to introduce the notion of clusters , we consider the following preliminary results . for @xmath82 and @xmath16 ,
let @xmath125 denote the infimum of the rate function @xmath84}(\phi)$ ] aver all functions @xmath519,{\cal e})$ ] such that @xmath86 , @xmath87 and @xmath520 [ lem2 - 6 ] for @xmath82 and @xmath118 , @xmath521 } \leq \ ; - m_n(1,x , y).\end{gathered}\ ] ] using spld upper bound it follows that for any @xmath397 and for any @xmath522 , @xmath523 } & \ ; \leq \lim_{\delta\to 0}\limsup_{a\to\infty } \sup_{z\in b(x,\delta ) } \ ; \frac{1}{a}\log\p_{az}\bigl(\sup_{s\in [ 0,1 ] } |z_a(s)|\geq n \ ; \mbox { and } \ ; z_a(1)\in\ol{b}(y,\sigma)\bigr ) \\ & \ ; \leq - \inf_{y'\in\ol{b}(y,\sigma ) } m_n(1,x , y').\end{aligned}\ ] ] by lemma [ lem1 - 4 ] , the mapping @xmath524 is lower semi - continuous and hence , letting at the last relation @xmath514 we get inequality ( [ e3 - 7 ] ) . by lemma [
lem2 - 6 ] , for any @xmath105 , @xmath118 and @xmath82 , there exist @xmath525 and @xmath526 such that for any @xmath527 and for any @xmath528 satisfying the inequality @xmath136 , the following inequalities hold .
@xmath137 } |z_a(s)| \geq n \ ; \mbox { and } \ ; z_a(1)\in b\bigl(y,\delta(x , y)\bigr)\right ) & \leq - a m_n(1,x , y ) + a\eps\end{aligned}\ ] ] when @xmath138 , and @xmath139 } |z_a(s)| \geq n \ ; \mbox { and } \ ; z_a(1 ) \in b\bigl(y,\delta(x , y)\bigr ) \right ) \leq - a i^*_0 n/\eps\ ] ] when @xmath140 .
moreover , the real number @xmath134 at the above inequalities can be replaced by @xmath529 with @xmath530 and @xmath531 .
using relation @xmath532 this implies the following statement .
[ lem3 - 6 ] for any @xmath181 and @xmath118 , there are strictly positive functions @xmath533 and @xmath534 on @xmath535 such that for any @xmath82 , @xmath536 , @xmath537 and @xmath528 satisfying the inequality @xmath538 , the following inequalities hold @xmath539 } |z_a(s)| \geq n t \ ; \mbox { and } \ ; z_a(t)\in t b\bigl(y , \delta(x , y)\bigr)\right ) \\ \leq - a t m_n(1,x , y ) + at\eps\end{gathered}\ ] ] when @xmath138 , and @xmath540 } |z_a(s)| \geq n t \ ; \mbox { and } \ ; z_a(t ) \in t b\bigl(y , \delta(x , y)\bigr ) \right ) \leq - a t i^*_0 n/\eps\ ] ] otherwise .
we are ready now to introduce the notion of cluster . for a given @xmath128
, we choose @xmath541 large enough so that @xmath542}(\phi ) > i^*_0/\eps\ ] ] for any function @xmath519,{\cal e})$ ] for which there are @xmath543 such that @xmath544 .
such a choice is possible because under the hypotheses ( a ) , for any absolutely continuous function @xmath75 \to { \cal e}$ ] for which there are @xmath543 such that @xmath544 @xmath545}(\phi ) & \geq~ \int_{s_1}^{s_2 } l(\phi(s),\dot\phi(s ) ) ds ~\geq~ \int_{s_1}^{s_2 } l_1(\dot\phi(s ) ) ds \\ & \geq~ ( s_2-s_1 ) l_1\bigl((\phi(s_2 ) - \phi(s_1))/(s_2-s_1)\bigr ) ~\geq~ n \inf_{v : |v| \geq n }
l_1(v)/|v| ~\to~ + \infty \end{aligned}\ ] ] when @xmath546 . given @xmath105 and @xmath541 ,
let @xmath533 and @xmath534 be the positive functions on @xmath547 satisfying lemma [ lem3 - 6 ] . without any restriction of generality we will suppose that for any @xmath82 ,
@xmath548 the set @xmath549 being compact there exists a finite subset @xmath550 such that @xmath551 for a function @xmath552,{\cal e})$ ] such that @xmath154 for all @xmath553 and @xmath554 , @xmath555 , we define a partition @xmath556 and a sequence @xmath557 by induction : * we choose @xmath162 such that @xmath558 and @xmath559 , and we let @xmath161 if @xmath560 * otherwise , we divide the interval @xmath561 $ ] in two intervals @xmath562 $ ] and @xmath563 $ ] and we restart our construction for the restriction of @xmath39 on each of them .
this algorithm terminates because @xmath564 for all @xmath565 $ ] .
the resulting sequence @xmath566 is called _
@xmath567- cluster corresponding to the function @xmath39_. remark that for such a sequence , @xmath568 for every @xmath569 and @xmath570 for all @xmath188 .
moreover , for @xmath571 and @xmath572 and for a natural number @xmath573 such that @xmath574 , by construction , @xmath575 for all @xmath576 . a sequence @xmath173 is called _
@xmath577- cluster _
if * @xmath578 and @xmath570 for all @xmath188 ; * @xmath575 for all @xmath576 ; * the set @xmath579 is non - empty for every @xmath569 . for a given @xmath169- cluster @xmath173 ,
we denote by @xmath580 the set of all functions @xmath581\to{\cal e}$ ] such that @xmath582 .
the quantity @xmath583 is defined by @xmath584 where the supremum is taken over all @xmath214 such that @xmath585 . remark that by construction , @xmath586 where the sum is taken over all @xmath577-clusters @xmath177 @xmath178 for which the sets @xmath179 and @xmath180 are non - empty . to estimate the right hand side of the inequality ( [ e7 - 7 ] ) ( and hence also the right hand side of the inequality ( [ e1 - 7 ] ) ) we estimate the number of @xmath577-clusters and for each @xmath577-cluster @xmath587 we estimate the quantity @xmath184 .
this is a subject of the following lemmas .
[ lem4 - 6 ] for any @xmath182 , there are at most @xmath588 @xmath589-clusters , where @xmath590 denotes the number of points of the set @xmath591 .
indeed , let @xmath592 .
then there are at most @xmath593 possible choices for a sequence of natural numbers @xmath594 and for any @xmath595 there are at most @xmath596 . to estimate the quantities @xmath184 we use assumption ( a ) and lemma [ lem3 - 6 ] .
recall that under the hypotheses ( a ) , the rate function @xmath72}$ ] has an integral form : there is a local rate function @xmath73 such that @xmath74}(\phi ) = \int_0^t l(\phi(t),\dot\phi(t ) ) \ , dt\ ] ] if the function @xmath75\to { \cal e}$ ] is absolutely continuous , and @xmath37}(\phi ) = + \infty$ ] otherwise .
moreover , there is a finite in a neighborhood of zero convex function @xmath597 such that @xmath347 for all @xmath79 and for all @xmath80 .
the function @xmath77 being convex and finite in a neighborhood of zero , there are real numbers @xmath361 and @xmath318 such that @xmath598 [ lem6 - 6 ] for any @xmath599 , for any @xmath600 and for any @xmath577-cluster @xmath601 for which the sets @xmath179 and @xmath180 are non - empty , the following inequality holds @xmath602 using lemma [ lem3 - 6 ] and markov property , it follows that for any real number @xmath600 , for any @xmath182 and for any @xmath577-cluster @xmath603 , @xmath604 where @xmath605 denotes the sum over all @xmath188 for which @xmath606 and @xmath607 is the sum over all those @xmath188 for which @xmath608 . if @xmath609 because of relation ( [ e10 - 7 ] ) , @xmath610 and hence , inequality ( [ e9 - 7 ] ) holds .
furthermore , let us consider for every @xmath611 , for which @xmath612 , a continuous function @xmath613 \to { \cal e}$ ] with @xmath614 , @xmath615 and @xmath616 , such that @xmath617}(\phi_i ) = m_n(1 , x_i , y_i).\ ] ] such a function exists because the set of all continuous functions @xmath75 \to { \cal e}$ ] with @xmath618 , @xmath619 and @xmath620 is closed in @xmath333,{\cal e})$ ] , and because the level sets @xmath621}(\phi ) \leq c\}$ ] are compact ( see the definition of a good rate function in section [ sec4 ] ) .
let @xmath622 be the set of all those @xmath172 for which the set @xmath623 is empty and @xmath612 .
because of relation ( [ e2 - 7 ] ) , @xmath624 for all @xmath625 .
when @xmath626 , using inequality ( [ e10 - 7 ] ) we get @xmath627 and hence , inequality ( [ e9 - 7 ] ) holds . to prove our lemma
, it is sufficient now to verify inequality ( [ e9 - 7 ] ) in the case when @xmath628 for this , we construct an absolutely continuous function @xmath629\to{\cal e}$ ] with @xmath630 for which the lebesgue measure of the set @xmath631 : \phi(s ) \not= 0\}$ ] is greater than @xmath632 and @xmath633}(\phi ) ~\leq~ { \textstyle \sum ' } ( t_i - t_{i-1 } ) m_n(1 , x_i , y_i ) + 2t\eps c / c + 2(bn + t\eps)c / c.\ ] ] : we let @xmath634 and @xmath635 for every @xmath188 and we define @xmath636 by setting @xmath637 and @xmath638 for all for @xmath576 , where @xmath639 , @xmath640 and @xmath641 for @xmath642 , and by letting @xmath643 if @xmath606 and @xmath644 otherwise .
the function @xmath645\to { \cal e}$ ] is defined then in the following way : for @xmath646 $ ] , @xmath188 , we let @xmath647 then for every @xmath648 , @xmath649 and @xmath650 . for @xmath651 $ ] , @xmath576 , we let @xmath652 where @xmath653 .
the resulting function @xmath39 is absolutely continuous on @xmath654 $ ] and @xmath655 .
moreover , by construction , @xmath41 for all @xmath656 $ ] . using relations ( [ e12 - 7 ] ) this implies that @xmath657 the last inequality combined with lemma [ lem2 - 4 ] and proposition [ prop1 - 4 ] show that @xmath658}(\phi ) \geq t ( 1 - 2\eps ) i^*_0.\ ] ] _ proof of inequality ( [ e13 - 7 ] ) _ : relations ( [ e1 - 4 ] ) and ( [ e11 - 7 ] ) imply that @xmath659}(\phi ) = ( t_i - t_{i-1})i_{[0,1]}(\phi_i ) = ( t_i - t_{i-1 } ) m_n(1,x_i , y_i)\ ] ] for all @xmath188 for which @xmath660 . when @xmath608 , using assumption ( a ) and inequality ( [ e8 - 7 ] ) we obtain @xmath661}(\phi ) \leq ( t'_i - t''_{i-1 } ) l_2\bigl((y_i - x_i)c/2n\bigr ) \leq 2n c ( t_i - t_{i-1})/c.\ ] ] because of assumption ( a ) , @xmath662}(\phi ) \leq ( t''_i - t'_i ) l_2\bigl((\hat{x}_{i+1 } - \hat{y}_i)/\delta_i\bigr)\ ] ] for all @xmath576 . moreover , for @xmath663 , @xmath664 where the first inequality holds because by definition of @xmath577-cluster , the set @xmath665 is non - empty and the second inequality follows from relation ( [ e6 - 7 ] )
similarly , for @xmath666 , @xmath667 and for @xmath668 , @xmath669 because under the hypotheses of our lemma , the sets @xmath179 and @xmath180 are non - empty . using inequality ( [ e8 - 7 ] ) this implies that @xmath670 and consequently , @xmath662}(\phi ) ~\leq~ ( t''_i - t'_i ) c ~=~ \delta_i c\ ] ] for every @xmath576 .
the last inequality , relations ( [ e12 - 7 ] ) , ( [ e16 - 7 ] ) , ( [ e17 - 7 ] ) and the equality @xmath671 show that @xmath672}(\phi ) & = \sum_{i=1}^n i_{[t''_{i-1},t'_i]}(\phi ) + \sum_{i=0}^n i_{[t'_i , t''_i]}(\phi ) \\ & \leq { \textstyle \sum ' } ( t_i - t_{i-1})m_n(1,x_i , y_i ) + 2n c { \textstyle \sum '' } ( t_i - t_{i-1})/c + \sum_{i=0}^n\delta_i c \\
& \leq { \textstyle \sum ' } ( t_i - t_{i-1})m_n(1,x_i , y_i ) + 2tc\eps + 2(b
n + t\eps ) c / c.\end{aligned}\ ] ] relation ( [ e13 - 7 ] ) is therefore verified .
we are ready now to complete the proof of lemma [ lem6 - 6 ] : relations ( [ e10 - 7 ] ) , ( [ e13 - 7 ] ) and ( [ e15 - 7 ] ) imply that @xmath673}(\phi ) + 2t\eps c / c + 2(bn + t\eps)c / c + \eps { \textstyle \sum ' } ( t_i - t_{i-1 } ) \\ & \leq - t(1 - 2\eps )
i^*_0 + 4t\eps c / c + 2bn c / c + t\eps . \end{aligned}\ ] ] the last inequality proves relation ( [ e9 - 7 ] ) .
let us complete now the proof of the inequality @xmath674
. inequalities ( [ e1 - 7 ] ) and ( [ e7 - 7 ] ) prove that @xmath675 the sum is taken here over all @xmath577-clusters @xmath177 @xmath178 for which the sets @xmath179 and @xmath180 are non - empty . using lemma [ lem4 - 6 ] and lemma [ lem6 - 6 ] we obtain therefore @xmath676 letting finally @xmath677 we conclude that @xmath678 .
in this section , we apply our results to jackson networks .
let us recall the definition and some well - known results concerning jackson network .
this is a network with @xmath679 queues . for @xmath680 ,
the arrivals and the service times at the @xmath385-th queue are poisson with parameters @xmath681 and @xmath682 respectively .
all the poisson processes are independent .
when the customer finish its service at queue @xmath385 , it goes to the queue @xmath683 with probability @xmath684 . the residual quantity @xmath685 is the probability that the customer leaves definitely the network .
we assume that @xmath686 for all @xmath680 .
let @xmath687 denote the length of the queue i at time @xmath688 , @xmath680 .
then @xmath689 is a continuous time markov chain on @xmath690 with generator @xmath691 where @xmath692 @xmath693 is the @xmath385-th unit vector .
we set @xmath694 and @xmath695 for all @xmath696 , the matrix @xmath697 is then stochastic . *
the spectral radius of the matrix @xmath698 is strictly less than unity , * for any @xmath699 , there exists @xmath243 and @xmath700 such that @xmath701 where @xmath702 denotes the @xmath703-time transition probability of a markov chain with @xmath704 states associated to the stochastic matrix @xmath705 .
the markov process @xmath0 is then irreducible .
the system of traffic equations @xmath706 has the unique solution @xmath707 ( see @xcite ) .
the markov process @xmath0 is recurrent if and only if @xmath708 for all @xmath680 , and it is ergodic ( positive recurrent ) if and only if @xmath709 for all @xmath680 .
recall that _
spectral radius _ of the process @xmath0 is defined by @xmath710 when the process @xmath0 is recurrent we have obviously @xmath711 . for a transient markov process
, spectral radius @xmath3 shows how fast the process goes to infinity . _ essential spectral radius _
@xmath29 is defined as the infimum over all those @xmath4 for which there is a finite set @xmath712 such that @xmath713 where @xmath32 denotes the first time when the process @xmath0 hits the set @xmath26 .
when the markov process @xmath0 is recurrent the quantity @xmath29 is the infimum over all those @xmath4 for which there is a finite set @xmath712 such that @xmath714 the hypotheses of proposition [ pr3 - 3 ] are satisfied here because the markov process @xmath0 has uniformly bounded jumps .
the markov process @xmath0 satisfies the hypotheses ( a ) : the family of scaled markov processes @xmath715)\stackrel{\text{def.}}{= } ( x(at)/a , \ ; t\in[0,t])$ ] satisfies sample path large deviation principle ( see @xcite ) with a good rate function having an integral form : @xmath74}(\phi ) = \int_0^t l(\phi(t),\dot{\phi}(t ) ) \ , dt\ ] ] for every absolutely continuous function @xmath414\to\r_+^d$ ] , and @xmath72}(\phi ) = + \infty$ ] otherwise .
the local rate function @xmath716 can be represented in several ways , see @xcite : for @xmath717 and @xmath718 with @xmath719 for @xmath720 and @xmath721 for @xmath722 , @xmath723 for all @xmath80 .
@xmath724 denotes here the usual scalar product in @xmath35 , @xmath725 @xmath726 and @xmath727 is the set of those all @xmath728 for which @xmath729 the hypotheses @xmath494 are satisfied with @xmath730 and @xmath731 under assumption ( j ) , the convex conjugate @xmath732 of the function @xmath733 is finite everywhere on @xmath35 ( see @xcite , lemma 10.1 ) , and for every @xmath734 , @xmath735 which implies that @xmath736 [ cor1 - 7 ] under the hypotheses ( j ) , @xmath737}(\phi)\ ] ] where the infimum is taken over all continuous functions @xmath75\to \r_+^d$ ] with @xmath40 and @xmath738}(\phi)\ ] ] where the infimum is taken over all continuous functions @xmath75\to \r_+^d$ ] with @xmath40 such that @xmath41 for all @xmath42 . indeed , for any continuous function @xmath75\to \r_+$ ] with @xmath40 and @xmath41 for all @xmath42 , @xmath742}(\phi ) = \int_0 ^ 1 r^*(\dot\phi(t ) )
\ , dt ~\geq~ r^*(0 ) = -\inf_{\alpha\in\r } r(\alpha)\ ] ] because the convex conjugate @xmath732 of the function @xmath733 is convex . for a constant function @xmath496 with @xmath743 , @xmath742}(\phi )
= r^*(0 ) = -\inf_{\alpha\in\r } r(\alpha).\ ] ] this proves that the right hand side of relation ( [ e3-j ] ) equals @xmath744 and hence , @xmath741 .
recall that @xmath755 is the set of all @xmath756 with @xmath757 , and @xmath758 is the set of all @xmath756 with @xmath759 . for given @xmath747 and @xmath748 satisfying the inequalities @xmath760 and @xmath761 , let @xmath762 .
then for @xmath763 with @xmath764 and @xmath765 we have @xmath766 furthermore , for @xmath767 , denote @xmath768 .
the inequality @xmath769 implies that @xmath770 and therefore , for @xmath764 and @xmath771 we obtain @xmath772 and @xmath773 the right hand side of the last inequality tends to @xmath774 as @xmath775 because @xmath753 , and hence , for any @xmath128 there is @xmath776 such that for @xmath777 and @xmath778 , @xmath779 the same arguments show that for any @xmath128 there is @xmath780 such that for @xmath781 and @xmath782 , @xmath783 the last inequality combined with relations ( [ e8-j ] ) and ( [ e9-j ] ) shows that @xmath784 for all @xmath763 with @xmath785 .
this implies that for all @xmath786 and @xmath787 with @xmath788 , @xmath789 where @xmath790 denotes the first time when the process @xmath0 hits the set @xmath791 .
using proposition [ pr1 - 3 ] we conclude that @xmath792 and letting @xmath677 we obtain inequality ( [ e7-j ] ) .
let @xmath803 denote the boundary of the set @xmath804 .
straightforward calculations show that for @xmath805 , @xmath806 the minimum of the function @xmath752 on the boundary @xmath807 is achieved at the point @xmath808 with @xmath809 and equals @xmath810 the minimum of the function @xmath752 on the boundary @xmath811 is achieved at the point @xmath812 with @xmath813 and equals @xmath814 without any restriction of generality we will suppose that @xmath815 which implies that @xmath816 hence , to prove the equality @xmath817 it is sufficient to show that @xmath818 . for this , we consider the set @xmath819 and we notice that @xmath820 because @xmath821 and @xmath822 , @xmath823 while for all @xmath824 , @xmath825 and @xmath826 . since @xmath827 this implies that @xmath828 for all @xmath42 because the set @xmath829 is convex .
the function @xmath752 being strictly convex , the inequality @xmath830 implies that @xmath831 for all @xmath832 .
the set @xmath833 being connected we conclude that @xmath834 because the boundary of the set @xmath755 has no intersection with @xmath833 .
this proves that the point @xmath835 achieves the infimum of the function @xmath752 on @xmath755 and consequently , @xmath818 .
relation ( [ e11-j ] ) is therefore proved .
notice furthermore that @xmath836 where the first inequality follows from the inequality @xmath815 and the second inequality holds because @xmath837 . when @xmath838 we obtain therefore @xmath839 and hence , relation ( [ e10-j ] ) holds .
suppose now that @xmath849 ( see figure 1 ) , then @xmath850 because otherwise , @xmath851 .
for @xmath852 with @xmath853 and @xmath854 , we have @xmath855 which implies that @xmath856 .
moreover , using the inequality @xmath857 we obtain @xmath858 where the last inequality holds because @xmath859 and @xmath860 this proves that @xmath861 and consequently , relation ( [ e10-j ] ) holds .
* proof of proposition [ prop2-j]*. relation ( [ e2-j ] ) imply that @xmath862}(\phi)\ ] ] where the infimum is taken over all continuous functions @xmath437\to \r^2_+$ ] with @xmath40 . because of relation ( [ e3-j ] ) , @xmath863}(\phi)\ ] ] where the infimum is taken over all those continuous functions @xmath437\to \r^2_+$ ] for which @xmath40 and @xmath387 for all @xmath42 .
when the markov process @xmath0 is non - ergodic , theorem 2 of ignatiouk @xcite proves that @xmath864}(\phi ) , i_{[0,1]}(\psi)\}\ ] ] where @xmath865 and @xmath866 for all @xmath512 $ ] . using relations ( [ e12-j ] ) and ( [ e13-j ] )
this implies that @xmath867}(\phi ) , i_{[0,1]}(\psi)\ } \ , \leq \ , \log r^*_e \leq \log r^*.\ ] ] and consequently , relation ( [ e5-j ] ) holds .
suppose now that the markov process @xmath0 is ergodic .
then using lemma [ lem1-j ] and lemma [ lem2-j ] it follows that @xmath868}(\phi ) , i_{[0,1]}(\psi)\}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] the last relation combined with inequality ( [ e13-j ] ) proves relation ( [ e4-j ] ) . | the essential spectral radius of a sub - markovian process is defined as the infimum of the spectral radiuses of all local perturbations of the process . when the family of rescaled processes satisfies sample path large deviation principle , the spectral radius and the essential spectral radius are expressed in terms of the rate function .
the paper is motivated by applications to reflected diffusions and jump markov processes describing stochastic networks for which the sample path large deviation principle has been established and the rate function has been identified while essential spectral radius has not been calculated . |
empirically the literature reports several behaviors for the income and wealth distributions in different countries .
a century ago , the italian social economist pareto suggested a power - law @xcite distribution in the high - income range , namely , in terms of cumulative distribution : @xmath0 , with @xmath1 being the pareto index @xcite . on the other hand montroll
@xcite suggested a lognormal distribution with power law tail for the usa personal income .
more recently , wealth and income distributions in the usa and in the united kingdom have been described by an exponential distribution with power law high - end tails @xcite . whereas , the japanese personal income distribution appears to follow lognormal distributions also with power law tails @xcite . in some recent papers zipfs law
has also been proposed @xcite . in this paper
we add to the above empirical investigations an analysis of the income distribution in australia ( figure [ f.income ] ) .
> from the theoretical side , it has been shown that pure multiplicative stochastic ( msp ) processes can explain the lognormal income distribution but they fail to explain the power law tails @xcite .
power law tails can be obtained extending msp processes by including -for instance- additive noise and boundary constraints @xcite .
these models explain well the emergence of power law distributions , but they are incomplete , neglecting interactions between agents . hence , msps with interacting agents connected through a network have been developed @xcite .
these models retrieve power law tails with exponents @xmath1 which are related to the network properties . in this paper
, we show that distributions with power law tails can emerge also from additive stochastic processes with interacting agents . in this case , we show that the network of connections among agents plays a crucial role .
indeed , the resulting wealth distribution is shaped directly by the degree distribution of the network .
the original purpose of the present work was not to construct any realistic model for the wealth distribution .
our aim was simply to demonstrate the possibility to obtain ` fat ' tails also without the use of multiplicative stochastic processes .
rather surprising we find out that the results from such an additive process are in good qualitative agreement with the empirical data for the income distribution in australia . [
cols="^,^ " , ]
we have shown that a mechanism of wealth exchange with additive gaussian noise can produce distributions with power - law tails when the network which connects the agents is of a scale - free type . although the original purpose of this work was not to produce a realistic model for the wealth evolution
, we find a good qualitative agreement between the empirical data and the theoretical prediction .
more realistic models will be proposed in future works by introducing also multiplicative stochastic terms and a dynamical evolution in the network connectivity .
t. di matteo wishes to thank the research school of social sciences , anu , for providing the abs data .
this work was partially founded by the arc discovery project : dp0344004 .
we acknowledge the stac supercomputer time grant at apac national facility . | we investigate the wealth evolution in a system of agents that exchange wealth through a disordered network in presence of an additive stochastic gaussian noise .
we show that the resulting wealth distribution is shaped by the degree distribution of the underlying network and in particular we verify that scale free networks generate distributions with power - law tails in the high - income region .
numerical simulations of wealth exchanges performed on two different kind of networks show the inner relation between the wealth distribution and the network properties and confirm the agreement with a self - consistent solution .
we show that empirical data for the income distribution in australia are qualitatively well described by our theoretical predictions .
[ 1999/12/01 v1.4c il nuovo cimento ] |
during the early stages of the 19967 outburst of the microquasar gro j165540 , _ hst _ , _ rxte _ and _ cgro _ light curves reveal an enigmatic behaviour , shown in fig .
[ longlcfig ] . over a period of about 3 months , during which optical and uv fluxes declined steadily , the x - ray brightness of the object _ increased_. the hard x - ray rise in particular appears almost _ anti - correlated _ with the optical / uv decline ;
this is difficult to reconcile with models in which the optical / uv flux is produced by reprocessing in an irradiated accretion disc , e.g. king & ritter ( 1998 ) , for which the optical flux is expected to track x - ray behaviour .
nonetheless , comparison of optical and x - ray light curves reveals correlated variability ; echo mapping suggests that this is due to the disc being significantly irradiated , contrary to what the long term light curves would suggest .
our _ hst _ data set spans 1996 may 14 to july 22 , comprising five separate observations , during four of which the _ rxte_/pca also observed the source .
each observation resulted in a series of spectra ( spanning most or all of the 13009000 range ) obtained with time resolution of 23s
. we will examine the evidence which these data provide for reprocessed x - rays being an important source of optical flux and suggest one way to reconcile this evidence with the apparently contradictory longer term behaviour .
the hard x - ray vs.optical/uv anti - correlation may arise naturally from this interpretation .
[ longlcfig ]
our _ hst / rxte _ data from june 8 ( photometric phase 0.4 ) shows correlated short - term variability ( on timescales of seconds to minutes ) , with the x - ray variations leading the optical by 1020 seconds . the combined interpolation cross correlation function is shown in fig . [ icffig ] .
we interpret this correlation as due to reprocessing of a variable x - ray flux into optical / uv emission and hence perform echo mapping of the reprocessing region ( hynes et al.1998a . )
the observed lags are too short to be consistent with reprocessing on the companion star ( at this orbital phase causality requires a minimum lag of @xmath0s from the companion ) but are of the size expected for echoes from the accretion disc .
we therefore conclude that x - rays are being reprocessed into optical / uv photons in the disc .
we estimate that to produce the amplitude of variability observed by _ hst _ , at least 1520% of the optical flux must be generated in this way .
in hynes et al . ( 1998b ) we considered models for the optical / uv continuum spectral evolution , shown in fig .
[ continuumfig ] .
the far - uv spectrum ( @xmath1 ) resembles the canonical @xmath2 accretion disc spectrum .
we suggested two interpretations for the spectrum at lower energies ( @xmath3 ) : thermal emission from the accretion disc , and non - thermal synchrotron emission from a compact , self - absorbed source .
we will focus here on the former model . in this interpretation
, we are seeing optically thick thermal emission from an object with a temperature fixed around 910000k , shrinking in area . allowing for the contribution from the bright f - type companion star ,
the area required is just about consistent with a shrinking hot region of an accretion disc .
the temperatures needed are consistent with gas just in the hot state of the disc instability model ( cannizzo , chen & livio 1995 . )
the shrinking area may thus be a signature of the long postulated cooling wave of this model . with this interpretation , there remains one important question to be addressed : what is responsible for the heating of the disc ?
the spectrum that is seen is not purely the @xmath2 form expected for an approximately steady - state , viscously heated accretion disc , and instead is closer to the shape predicted for an irradiated disc ( vrtilek et al .
1990 ) , suggesting that it may be x - ray heating which is keeping the disc in the hot state .
so far , we have compressed our data in wavelength to produce light curves and in time to examine spectra .
we will now seek a compromise between spectral and temporal resolution , characterising the spectrum of the variability observed .
this is only possible using very course wavelength binning , as our signal - to - noise ratio is low , and hence only a continuum variability spectrum can be estimated .
it is immediately clear , however , that the variability spectrum is bluer than the mean spectrum , i.e. , there is a higher percentage variability in the uv than at red wavelengths .
this variability spectrum can be simply characterised as a blue power - law ( @xmath4 ) ; this is a similar slope to that of the power - law component seen in the far - uv , and may indicate that this is the variable component of the spectrum .
an alternative explanation , however , is that a the blue variability spectrum is due to reprocessing of x - ray variability .
the x - rays change the temperature of the disc and hence we would expect the spectrum to be the _ derivative _ of a black - body ; the rate of change of the disc spectrum with respect to temperature
. our variability spectrum can be fit by the derivative of a 10000k black - body , a comparable temperature to that deduced from fitting the mean spectrum . at present
we can not discriminate between these possibilities , but we anticipate that analysis of the remaining data segments will further constrain the interpretation .
we have now accumulated several pieces of evidence which suggest significant reprocessing of x - rays by the accretion disc : reprocessing is seen directly through echo - mapping ; the shape of the continuum optical / uv spectrum is similar to that expected for an irradiated disc ; and the variability spectrum is consistent with the derivative of the mean spectrum with respect to temperature .
it is natural to ask whether the overall light curves could be reproduced by any irradiation dominated model for the disc .
the most promising approach seems to be the following , hinging on the x - ray spectral state evolution , from an initially soft , mainly thermal spectrum towards the canonical two - component form ( soft black - body plus hard power - law ) .
the power - law component is widely believed to be formed by comptonisation of soft photons , so this change is suggestive of an increasing optical depth of comptonising material ( a similar scenario , but in reverse , was considered by mineshige ( 1994 ) for x - ray nova muscae ) .
if this material takes the form of a corona above the surface of the disc , then it will affect x - ray irradiation as follows .
initially , soft x - rays will have a clear path to the outer disc and irradiation will be efficient .
as the comptonising corona thickens , the comptonised hard x - ray flux will increase , while x - rays moving parallel to the disc will be increasingly attenuated , shielding the outer disc and hence reducing the efficiency of irradiation .
this decrease in efficiency dominates over the increase in x - ray flux and so the reprocessed optical flux declines , even though the x - rays are increasing . the observed anti - correlation thus emerges .
this model is not without difficulties ; it requires the edge of the disc to become partly shielded from x - rays , while our line of sight to the x - ray source remains unobscured .
since this is a high inclination system , however , our line of sight does not lie very far above the disc edge , and so some fine tuning of the shielding is required .
we would also predict that irradiation should be strongest on our first observation , may 14 , and that we should thus see strong echoes then .
in fact we see no optical / uv x - ray correlations in the may 14 data .
an alternative which therefore remains appealing is that the optical energy budget is dominated by viscous heating , rather than by irradiation ; in this case , the reprocessing that is seen is merely a perturbation to this , albeit a relatively large one , and does not drive the long - term optical evolution .
neither of these explanations for the behaviour of gro j165540 during 1996 that have been suggested here can readily be rejected , and both have difficulties and features to commend them .
detailed modelling may be needed to rule one , or even both , of them out .
there are clearly many questions remaining to be answered concerning this outburst and this work continues .
many thanks to my collaborators on this work , co - authors on hynes et al .
( 1998a , b ) , and especially to my supervisor , carole haswell , for endless constructive advice and encouragement .
considerably less progress would have been made on this project without the many stimulating discussions i have had with other workers in the field too numerous to list here .
i am supported by a pparc research studentship .
support for this work was provided by nasa through grant number go-6017 - 01 - 94a from stsci , which is operated by aura , under nasa contract nas5 - 26555 and also through contract nas5 - 32490 for the _ rxte _ project .
this work made use of the _ rxte _ and _ cgro _ science centers at nasa / gsfc and the nasa ads service .
thanks also to all at stsci for technical support .
hunstead & campbell - wilson 1996 cannizzo j. k. , chen w. , livio m. , 1995 , apj , 454 , 880 hunstead , r. , campbell - wilson , d. 1996 , iauc 6410 hynes r.i . , obrien k. , horne k. , chen w. , haswell c.a . , 1998a , mnras , accepted ( astro - ph/980638 ) hynes r.i . , haswell c.a . ,
shrader c.r .
, chen w. , horne k. , harlaftis e.t . , obrien k. , hellier , c. , fender r.p . , 1998b , mnras , accepted ( astro - ph/9803145 ) king a. r. , ritter h. , 1998 , mnras , 293 , l42 mineshige s. , 1994 , apj , 431 , l99 seaton m. j. , 1979 , mnras , 187 , 73p vrtilek , s.d . ,
raymond , j.c . ,
garcia , m.r .
, verbunt , f. , hasinger , g. , krster , m. 1990 , a&a , 235 , 162 | we examine the results of a coordinated _ hst__rxte__cgro _ campaign to study the microquasar gro j165540 during its 19967 outburst , focusing on interpretation of the overall anti - correlation seen between optical and x - ray fluxes during the early months of the outburst .
our tools include echo - mapping , optical / uv continuum spectral modelling and analysis of spectral variability .
we conclude by suggesting one possible interpretation for the anti - correlation . |
the gurevich - pitaevskii ( gp ) special universal solution of the korteweg - de vries ( kdv ) equation @xmath0 was introduced in @xcite in connection with the problem of description of collisionless shock waves ( sagdeev showed in @xcite that such waves are of oscillating character ) .
the behaviour of the gp special solution for @xmath1 and @xmath2 is determined in the main from the cubic canonical equation of the cusp catastrophe @xmath3 the gp solution to the kdv equation is one of the most interesting special functions of the modern nonlinear mathematical physics . in @xcite it is shown that in problems of dispersion hydrodynamics ( in particular , in problems of plasma theory ) the gp special solution appears near the points of overturning of simple waves . from the results of @xcite , @xcite ,
@xcite one actually sees that the same universal special function appears near the points of overturning of the generic state solutions to diverse dispersion perturbations of the equations of one - dimensional motion of ideal incompressible liquid @xmath4 here , @xmath5 is the density of the liquid , @xmath6 the velocity and @xmath7 , where @xmath8 is the speed of sound and @xmath9 the pressure . in particular , this is the case for solutions of the shallow water equations @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the free boundary , @xmath12 the potential of bottom velocity and @xmath13 the acceleration of gravity .
the right - hand sides can actually be written as complete series in powers of the parameter @xmath14 by the procedure given for instance in ( * ? ? ?
* ch . 1 , 4 ) ( and not only as the so - called second approximations , as stated in @xcite ) . in the 1990s
there were discovered surprising connections of the gp special solutions with some problems of quantum gravity . in @xcite
this solution was showed to simultaneously satisfy the fourth order ordinary differential equation @xmath15 which had been studied for @xmath16 in @xcite and @xcite in connection with evaluating nonperturbative string effects in two - dimensional quantum gravity ( the equation ( [ eq.ode ] ) belongs to a class of massive string equations ) . in @xcite the solution of @xmath17 with asymptotics @xmath18{x}$ ] as @xmath19 was treated numerically in connection with problems of quantum gravity .
one can show that this solution @xmath20 is also equivalent to the gp special solution of ( [ eq.kdv ] ) for @xmath21 ( but not for @xmath22 ) .
dubrovin showed in @xcite and @xcite directly by means of the theory of approximate symmetries @xcite that it is the solution of ( [ eq.ode ] ) with asymptotics ( [ eq.assembly ] ) that appears near the points of wave overturning for the very diverse singular dispersion perturbations of the equations of one - dimensional hydrodynamics .
the results of numerical simulations presented in @xcite demonstrate rather strikingly that the gp special solution of the kdv equation possesses a domain of undamped oscillations for @xmath23 large enough .
the authors of @xcite did not conjecture any relation of their paper to the gp special solution and raised the problem of describing this domain of oscillations .
meanwhile gurevich and pitaevskii @xcite had used successfully the self - similar solutions of the averaged whitham equations @xcite to solve the problem .
the self - similar solutions in question were constructed in explicit form by potemin @xcite .
however , the problem on the leading term of asymptotics of the gp special solution in the domain of whitham oscillations has been open up to now .
one not simple question still unanswered has been that on the phase shift . our purpose is to show how it is possible to construct the leading term of the gp special solution in the zone of oscillations without using any averaging methods . to this end
we derive certain algebraic equations for the slowly varying amplitude and the leading term of the phase , which are actually equivalent to those of @xcite .
moreover , we determine the phase shift of the solution in the oscillation zone .
our approach may also be of use for the study of undamped oscillations of other common solutions to integrable partial and ordinary differential equations which are of importance in physics .
in particular , it applies to two universal solutions of the kdv equation treated in the recent article @xcite .
almost one problem in the approach is some awkwardness of analytical calculations .
however , invoking modern programs for symbol calculations ( in this paper we use maple ) often allows one to get rid of such problems without particular difficulties .
consider the solution of the kdv equation that , for @xmath24 and @xmath25 , is determined in the main from the cubic equation ( [ eq.assembly ] ) .
it is known that for this solution for positive @xmath23 there is a domain where dissipationless shock waves appear .
we are aimed at constructing asymptotics of the solution in this domain , when @xmath26 . following familiar techniques
, we change the variables by @xmath27 then equations ( [ eq.kdv ] ) and ( [ eq.ode ] ) take the form @xmath28 we now look for a solution @xmath29 of the system in the form of asymptotic series @xmath30 where @xmath31 , @xmath32 and @xmath33 are @xmath34-periodic in the fast variable @xmath35 .
this latter is assumed to be of the form @xmath36 where by @xmath37 is meant precisely the phase shift . for the unknown function
@xmath31 we get the nonlinear system @xmath38 while the systems for @xmath32 @xmath39 and for @xmath33 @xmath40 proves to be linear . here ,
@xmath41 and @xmath42 are explicit functions depending on @xmath43 and @xmath31 , and @xmath44 and @xmath45 are explicit functions depending on @xmath43 and @xmath31 , @xmath32 , i.e. , the right - hand sides are explicit functions depending on @xmath43 and on the preceding corrections .
we write @xmath46 for short . from the compatibility condition of the equations for @xmath31 we obtain a first order equation @xmath47 from the compatibility condition of the equations for @xmath32 we derive a nonlinear equation @xmath48 for the unknown function @xmath49 .
( in section [ s.roetsf ] we show that this equation agrees with results obtained earlier . )
when requiring the compatibility of the equations for @xmath33 , we deduce that the function @xmath50 should satisfy , together with ( [ eq.u0 ] ) , a nonlinear ordinary differential equation in the variable @xmath43 of the form @xmath51 here , @xmath52 and @xmath53 are polynomials in @xmath31 of degrees @xmath54 and @xmath55 , respectively , with coefficients depending on @xmath43 and @xmath56 .
the function @xmath57 is given by @xmath58 where @xmath59 note that ( [ eq.u2 ] ) is a hamiltonian equation with hamiltonian quadratic relative to the impulse , i.e. @xmath60 where @xmath61 , @xmath62 and @xmath63 are functions of @xmath43 and @xmath31 .
we proceed to study equations ( [ eq.u0])-([eq.u2 ] ) .
equation ( [ eq.u0 ] ) is autonomous in the fast variable @xmath35 , hence the arbitrary constant of the general solution is contained in the phase shift which we take into account in the variable @xmath37 .
the general solution of this equation is sought in the form @xmath64 where @xmath65 is the elliptic function of jacobi and @xmath12 , @xmath66 , @xmath67 and @xmath68 are to be defined .
on substituting @xmath31 into equation ( [ eq.u0 ] ) and equating the coefficients of different powers of the jacobi function to zero we get the system of algebraic equations @xmath69 from the assumption on the @xmath34-periodicity of @xmath31 it follows that @xmath70 where @xmath71 is the complete elliptic integral of first kind
. the system of equations ( [ eq.q , r ] ) , ( [ eq.u1 ] ) , ( [ eq.algebraic ] ) and ( [ eq.periodicity ] ) obtained in this way is overdetermined .
it consists of 6 algebraic equations and 2 differential equations for the unknowns @xmath72 , @xmath73 , @xmath56 , @xmath12 , @xmath66 , @xmath67 and @xmath68 .
our next concern will be to show that one can find all slowly varying unknowns without solving the differential equations .
the unknowns @xmath72 , @xmath73 , @xmath56 , @xmath66 and @xmath67 can be determined immediately from this system through @xmath12 , @xmath68 and @xmath43 .
more precisely , @xmath74 on substituting these expressions into ( [ eq.algebraic ] ) we arrive at one algebraic equation @xmath75 for @xmath12 and @xmath68 . differentiating this equality in @xmath43 and substituting the resulting expression along with ( [ eq.f , q , r , b , c ] ) into ( [ eq.q , r ] ) and ( [ eq.u1 ] ) , we obtain 3 equations containing @xmath76 and @xmath77 .
on eliminating these derivatives , we get another algebraic equation for @xmath12 and @xmath68 which contains the quotient of two complete elliptic integrals @xmath78 using ( [ eq.a , k ] ) to eliminate the highest power of @xmath43 from the latter equation we bring it to the form @xmath79 when eliminating the variable @xmath12 from ( [ eq.a , k ] ) and ( [ eq.k , a ] ) , one finds @xmath68 as an implicit function of @xmath43 .
the other functions can be expressed explicitly through @xmath68 .
this method allows one to get the explicit formulas of @xcite without using averaging procedure .
the domain of @xmath43 in which oscillations are possible is determined from the condition that @xmath80 $ ] . to the point @xmath81 there corresponds leading wave front set @xmath82 and to the point @xmath83 there corresponds trailing wave front set @xmath84 .
the second ordinary differential equation of ( [ eq.fcov ] ) enables us also to determine the phase shift @xmath37 of the solution . for this purpose
we make use of equation ( [ eq.u2 ] ) .
note that @xmath31 is an even function of @xmath35 , hence @xmath85 is odd and @xmath86 , @xmath87 are even in @xmath35 . multiplying ( [ eq.u2 ] ) by @xmath88 , integrating in @xmath35 over the whole period @xmath89 and taking into account that the mean value of an odd periodic function over the whole period vanishes
, we get the equation @xmath90 in order to choose a concrete solution to ( [ eq.shift ] ) , one has to use the asymptotics of the solution for @xmath91 .
such an asymptotics is given in @xcite and it shows in particular that the solution does not contain @xmath92 . in our case
we get @xmath93 from the asymptotics of @xmath94 it follows that a solution of ( [ eq.shift ] ) contains terms of the form @xmath95 which are not permitted by @xcite .
hence , this solution enters into the linear combination of solutions with coefficient @xmath96 , and so @xmath97 is constant .
the hypothesis on the constancy of the phase shift @xmath37 has been formulated in @xcite . however , in @xcite it was based solely on the asymptotics given there .
it is clear that _ a priori _ one might not exclude the situation where the phase shift fails to be constant but tends exponentially fast to a constant as @xmath91 . from ( [ eq.shift ] ) and the asymptotics of @xmath98 for @xmath91 we see that such is not the case , and so @xmath37 proves to be constant . to evaluate the constant @xmath99 we invoke a numerical simulation .
namely , we compare a numerical solution with the solution constructed by using asymptotic formulas .
corresponding to @xmath100 . , width=483 ] corresponding to @xmath101 and root of equation @xmath102.,width=483 ] for @xmath101.,width=408 ] to this end
we have written a special program .
the results of numerical simulations are presented in figures [ f.0 ] [ f.2 ] . in figures
[ f.0]-[f.1 ] one can observe numerical solutions for function @xmath103 for negative and positive value @xmath23 .
it can be shown that function @xmath103 for negative value @xmath23 practically councide with the root of the equation @xmath104 . in figure [ f.2 ]
the difference between these solutions is shown .
both figures correspond to @xmath101 .
the constant @xmath99 has proved to be equal to @xmath105 .
the difference between two solutions is a multiple of @xmath106 which agrees with the order of the first correction in formula ( [ eq.asymptotic ] ) .
we believe that the constant @xmath99 just amounts to @xmath107 and the small difference is caused by a computation error .
figure [ f.2 ] makes it evident that the error increases for @xmath43 close to @xmath108 and @xmath109 .
this manifests the nonuniform character of the constructed asymptotic formula in the entire domain of the variable @xmath43 . in neighbourhoods of
the leading and trailing wave front sets one should construct other asymptotic formulas which can be made consistent with asymptotic expansion ( [ eq.asymptotic ] ) , as it is described in @xcite .
to start with , we bring the equations obtained in @xcite to a simpler form .
these are @xmath110 for @xmath111 , where @xmath112 and @xmath113 with @xmath114 .
obviously , one can eliminate two variables from three equations .
on eliminating @xmath43 and @xmath115 we get an equation for @xmath116 , @xmath117 and @xmath118 , which does not contain @xmath43 and @xmath115 .
namely , @xmath119 we now eliminate either of the variables @xmath43 and @xmath115 in the equations and use ( [ eq.first ] ) to eliminate all powers of @xmath116 greater than the first one .
then we get two more equations @xmath120 the system of equations ( [ eq.q , r ] ) , ( [ eq.algebraic ] ) and ( [ eq.periodicity ] ) is equivalent to the system of averaged equations ( [ eq.first ] ) and ( [ eq.second ] ) which was obtained in @xcite by whitham s method . to prove this
, we pass in the system of the equation for @xmath67 in ( [ eq.f , q , r , b , c ] ) and equations ( [ eq.a , k ] ) , ( [ eq.k , a ] ) to whitham s variables @xmath121 , @xmath122 and @xmath123 by @xmath124 on eliminating @xmath43 and @xmath115 from the obtained equations we arrive precisely at ( [ eq.first ] ) . on eliminating either of @xmath43 and @xmath115 and all powers of @xmath116 greater than the first one , we get ( [ eq.second ] ) , as desired .
it should be noted that the value of the phase shift @xmath99 derived from the numerical simulation contradicts @xcite . from the results of the paper
it follows that the function @xmath37 tends to @xmath125 , as @xmath91 .
but there is an arithmetical error in formula ( 17)@xcite and in formula ( 21)@xcite . the right calculation with using monodromic date from @xcite showed that @xmath126 tends to @xmath107 , and so @xmath127 * acknowledgements * the authors are greatly indepted to v. adler for first numerical experiments in this problem .
the derivation of equation ( [ eq.u1 ] ) without using the averaging method is due to our colleague v. kudashev .
the research of the first author was supported by the dfg grant ta 289/4 - 1 and by the program for supporting young scientists , grant mk-2812.2010.1 .
the first and second authors were also supported by the rfbr 09 - 01 - 92436 , 10 - 01 - 91222 . | we get the leading term of the gurevich - pitaevskii special solution of the kdv equation in the oscillation zone without using averaging methods . nondissipative shock wave , cusp catastrophe |
stripes have been an area of active study in the high - temperature superconductivity research .
they are modulations of charge and spin densities , and can be static or dynamic . in 1995 ,
tranquada and coworkers@xcite observed the coexistence of superconducting and stripe domain order for the material la@xmath0nd@xmath1sr@xmath2cuo@xmath3 at around doping @xmath4 .
the stripes are one - dimensional objects on a two - dimensional plane , and they have been called `` self - organized one dimensionality.''@xcite search for stripes in the hubbard and @xmath5 models has been intense and is still going strong ( see ref . for a review of some experimental results and theoretical considerations ) .
> from the theory side , there are basically two roads .
one approach is using microscopic models such as the hubbard and @xmath5 models to study numerically stripe formation and phase separation .
dmrg appears to be the best tool in such studies and has been applied to the @xmath5 model in refs . .
another approach to stripes is to use effective field theories , treating stripes as macroscopic objects ( macrosopic in the sense of many - particle collective motion ) .
for example in ref . , zaanen considered stripes as `` a gas of elastic quantum strings in @xmath6 dimensions . ''
the microscopic , numerical approach can be used to understand the mechanism for stripe formation and to derive macroscopic parameters such as stripe - stripe interaction energy and stripe stiffness , but it is limited by computational power .
the macroscopic approach on the other hand takes these macroscopic parameters as an input and can obtain results relevant to experiments , but it can explain less about mechanism
. we will follow the microscopic route which enables us to obtain macroscopic parameters from diagonalization data . in this paper , we study stripes in a strongly - interacting model of spinless fermions and hardcore bosons on the square latttice .
the hamiltonian is @xmath7 with periodic boundary conditions .
we study both the spinless fermion and the hardcore boson versions of the model . @xmath8 and @xmath9 are the spinless fermion or hardcore boson creation and annihilation operators at site @xmath10 , @xmath11 the number operator , @xmath12 the nearest - neighbor hopping amplitude , and @xmath13 the nearest - neighbor interaction . at the each site
there can be at the most one particle .
furthermore , we study the strong - correlation limit of the model and take @xmath14 , i.e. , infinite nearest - neighbor repulsion .
the spinless fermion and hardcore boson model with infinite nearest - neighbor repulsion involves a significant reduction of the hilbert space as compared to the hubbard model .
the hubbard model on the @xmath15 lattice at half - filling , with 8 spin - up and 8 spin - down electrons has @xmath16 states in the largest matrix block , after reduction by particle conservation , translation , and the symmetries of the square.@xcite in our model with infinite @xmath13 , after using particle conservation and translation symmetry ( but not point group symmetry ) , the largest matrix for the @xmath17 system has @xmath18 states ( for 11 particles ) .
we can therefore compute for all fillings the @xmath17 system whereas for the hubbard model @xmath15 is basically the limit .
this also means that at certain limits we can obtain results that are difficult to obtain in the hubbard model , for example , we can exactly diagonalize a system of two length-8 stripes on the @xmath19 lattice .
this is one of the two papers that we are publishing to systematically study the phase diagram of the spinless fermion and hardcore boson model on the square lattice with infinite nearest - neighbor repulsion . in the other paper , @xcite we study the dilute limit of this model eq .
( [ eq - ham ] ) , focusing on the problem of a few particles , and that limit is dominated by two - body interactions . in the present paper ,
we study the near - half - filled limit of our model , where stripes are natural objects . with infinite nearest - neighbor repulsion , the maximum filling fraction ( particle per site ) for our model is 1/2 , for both spinless fermions and hardcore bosons . at exactly half - filling ,
the particles form a checkerboard configuration that can not move . adding a single hole to it can not produce motion either because the hole is confined by neighboring particles .
a natural way to add holes to this system is to align them in a row going across the system , as indicated in fig .
[ fig - hole ] .
we call this row of holes a stripe and it is the subject of study in this paper . for many systems with certain aspect ratios ( e.g. , the @xmath20 lattice depicted in fig . [ fig - hole ] )
, the stripe state is the one with the smallest number of holes and nonzero energy .
here we have an interesting kind of physics of extended , fluctuating , quantum mechanical objects , that are results of collective motions of many particles .
spinless models related to the present one have been invoked occasionally in the literature @xcite but usually in the context of a specific question about spinfull models : it was recognized that a spinless model would capture the same physics with fewer complications .
the only systematic work on phase diagram of spinless fermions is by uhrig .
@xcite however , the method is expansion around infinite dimensionality ; this will have special difficulty with arrays of domain walls , since wall fluctuations and the attendant kinetic energy are strongly suppressed in high dimensions .
the falicov - kimball model is an alternate way to simplify the hubbard model , which is also commonly presented in a spinless form , @xcite and develops stripe - like incommensurate patterns .
@xcite however , this model includes a second immobile ( classical ) species of electron , so its stripes can not have quantum fluctuations .
@xcite no known electron system realizes our model , even approximately .
a `` half - metallic '' ferromagnet @xcite meaning that for one spin state , the conduction band is all filled or all empty realizes a spinless model for the other spin state .
however in the best - known half - metals , the manganites , @xcite the formation of inhomogeneities is dominated by lattice distortions and orbital degeneracies ( not to mention static pinning disorder ) , so that quantum - fluctuating defects find no role in current theories of manganites .
( the same may be true for the verwey transition in magnetite , @xcite which was modeled previously with spinless electrons @xcite . )
conceivably the spinless model could be realized in an array of semiconductor quantum dots in a magnetic field .
@xcite the most plausible realization of the boson version of our model would be an adsorbed gas of @xmath21he on a substrate with square symmetry .
( the same model
but on a triangular lattice has been introduced independently to model @xmath21he on nanotube @xcite ) .
the fermion case could similarly be realized , in principle , by spin - polarized @xmath22he , however it would be difficult to achieve a degree of polarization sufficient to neglect the minority spin state .
this paper appears to be the first using exact diagonalization ( as opposed to dmrg ) to investigate the properties of interacting stripes with a microscopic hamiltonian .
@xcite in real fermion systems , stripes ( antiphase domain walls containing holes ) have been a prominent object of experimental study in the high-@xmath23 cuprates .
@xcite stripe - based mechanisms have been proposed for high - temperature superconductivity , @xcite but the prevalent current opinion is that stripes compete with superconductivity .
@xcite nevertheless , stripes are obviously clues to how the charge and spin degrees of freedom interact with each other , which is important in a majority of the high-@xmath23 theories .
stripes are modeled theoretically and numerically using the same hubbard model ( or its variations ) which were already accepted as models of homogeneous phases .
it is still unsettled whether stripes are stabilized in this model , which omits long - range and even nearest - neighbor coulomb repulsion .
the most explicit calculations are by density - matrix renormalization group ( dmrg ) , adapted to two - dimensional systems formed into strips .
@xcite the results favor stripes with 1/2 holes per unit length , as found in experiments ; however , those simulations are strongly influenced by the ( necessary ) open boundary conditions on two sides .
what relation can our spinless model have to these spinfull models ?
firstly , at the intermediate scales appropriate to a stripe array , the spinfull and spinless systems are modeled in very similar ways : stripes are mutually repelling , quantum - fluctuating strings .
this level is appropriate to studies of the anisotropic transport expected in a ( non - superconducting ) stripe array , as well as the stripe interactions , as has been emphasized by zaanen .
@xcite in the spinfull models , only a little has been done to explicitly relate the macroscopic parameters to the underlying microscopic model .
@xcite in our model and unlike any spinfull model exact diagonalization can address phenomena such as the effective mass and interactions of carriers on a stripe , long - wavelength stripe fluctuations , stripe - stripe repulsion , or the transfer of carriers from one stripe to the next .
thus , not only analytically but numerically , one can go quite far in extracting such parameters for our model . secondly , if spinfull stripes are stabilized at all ( in the absence of long - range repulsion ) , it is by kinetic energy in the same fashion that our stripes are stabilized . in either case ,
a fermion belonging to one domain hops transverse to the stripe , and ( since the stripe is also an antiphase domain wall ) still finds itself correctly placed in the order of the new domain . in our model
, that order is the `` checkerboard '' pattern , which is enforced by the nearest - neighbor repulsion @xmath13 . from this viewpoint
, @xmath13 is analogous to the antiferromagnetic coupling @xmath24 in the @xmath12-@xmath24 model .
( our @xmath25 limit then corresponds to the case @xmath26 , which is the unphysical regime of the @xmath12-@xmath24 model . )
an even more precise correspondence would be to stripes in the @xmath12-@xmath27 model : @xcite in that system ( as in ours ) the undoped , ordered state breaks a discrete ( ising - type ) symmetry , and hence is practically inert , supporting no gapless goldstone ( spinwave ) excitations : only the stripe itself has low - energy excitations .
if the ordered state had a continuous symmetry , as in the hubbard or @xmath12-@xmath24 models , spin - wave modes can mediate a @xmath28 attraction @xcite between stripes ( where @xmath29 is the stripe separation ) .
if short - distance kinetic energy were to favor a stripe array , the long - range force mediated by continuous spins implies phase separation in the limit of very small doping .
@xcite our stripes with an occupation of 0.5 hole per unit length are insulating and correspond to insulating stripes of 1 hole per unit length in the @xmath12-@xmath24 model ( the factor of two reflects the density of the ordered background state ) , as implied in the original ideas @xcite about stripe stabilization from a strong - coupling viewpoint .
this paper is organized as follows .
first ( in sec
. [ sec - diagstripe ] ) we describe briefly our exact diagonalization code for studying the near - half - filled limit of our model .
we use translation symmetry to block diagonalize the hamiltonian matrix .
a graph viewpoint motivates a method of building the basis states from a starting configuration and explains the relation between boson and fermion energy spectra . next ( sec . [ sec - onestripe ] )
we study the problem of a single stripe . here
particles can only move in one direction , effectively reducing the 2d problem to a 1d one .
this one - stripe problem maps exactly to a spin-1/2 chain , which is exactly solvable using bethe ansatz . using the single - stripe energy dispersion relation along the direction perpendicular to the stripe , we obtain stripe effective mass for motion in that direction . in the next two sections , we study the problem of one or two holes on a stripe .
( for the one - hole case , the bosons and fermions have the same energy spectrum . )
we determine the dispersion relationship ( energy gap and effective mass ) for one hole moving on a stripe , and study the binding of two holes .
it is informative to study the finite - size dependence of the energy on the lattice dimensions in both directions : in particular , it decays exponentially as a function of the lattice size perpendicular to the stripe , which we explain quantitatively in terms of the stripe tunneling through a barrier between two potential wells .
one of the motivations for studying our model is our interest in a simple model of interacting stripes . in sec .
[ sec - twoandmore ] we have exactly diagonalized systems with two , three , and four stripes , and find that the stripes repel .
the interaction energies scale as the inverse square of the stripe spacing , which ( like the above - mentioned tunneling ) follows from the one - dimensional nature of the stripe s transverse motion in our systems .
finally ( sec .
[ sec - stripearray ] ) we discuss the stability of an array of stripes by fitting the diagonalization results in the intermediate filling limit and using a maxwell construction .
our interest is whether at the intermediate - filling limit we have the stripe - array case or a phase - separated case with hole - rich regions and particle rich - regions .
the conclusion is , interestingly , that the boson stripe - array is not stable and the fermion stripe - array is very close to the stability limit and is possibly stable . our earlier publication , ref .
, contains some of the results of this paper in a condensed form , with a focus on the stability of the stripe - array .
the present paper contains more systematic and more updated results and a substantial number of important new results on , for example , boson and fermion statistics , stripe effective mass and stripe - stripe interaction .
in this section , we describe our exact diagonalization code .
we begin by describing the conventions for labeling basis states , which are crucial to keep track of sign factors in the fermion case .
then we introduce a geometrical way to view the basis states as nodes on a graph , and apply this to classify the conditions under which the boson and fermion problems have the same . on the left and @xmath30 on the right .
site numbers are shown , following the numbering convention , upward and rightward . ]
each basis state with @xmath31 particles corresponds 1-to-1 to a _ configuration _ , which is array of the @xmath31 occupied site numbers @xmath32 .
any configuration with two nearest neighbors occupied is excluded because of the infinite @xmath13 in the hamiltonian eq .
( [ eq - ham ] ) .
periodic boundary conditions are specified by two lattice vectors @xmath33 and @xmath34 ( which will be called _ boundary vectors _ in the following ) , such that for any lattice vector @xmath35 we have @xmath36 , where @xmath37 and @xmath38 are two integers .
the configuration by itself is insufficient to define the basis ket , since we need to specify its sign or phase factor . to fix the fermion sign
, we must establish an arbitrary ordering of sites and always configurations in this order .
then we denote the basis state @xmath39 , the site ordering convention used in this paper is to start with site 0 at the lower left corner and move upward along a lattice column until we encounter the cell boundaries defined by the boundary vectors @xmath33 and @xmath34 , then shift rightward and repeating in the next column , progressing until all sites have been numbered . fig .
[ fig-2lattice ] shows two example systems : @xmath40 and @xmath30 . in this basis
the hamiltonian eq .
( [ eq - ham ] ) acts as @xmath41 where @xmath42 denotes the set of states created by hopping one particle in @xmath43 to an allowed nearest - neighbor site . for bosons @xmath44 always and for fermions @xmath45 .
and the matrix element is @xmath46 if @xmath47 and 0 , otherwise .
we use lattice translation symmetry to block diagonalize the hamiltonian matrix @xmath48 . the eigenstates that we use
are the bloch states@xcite @xmath49 in this expression @xmath50 is a reciprocal lattice vector ( one of @xmath51 , where @xmath51 is the number of sites ) , @xmath52 is a lattice vector ( the order of @xmath53 in the sum is not important ) , @xmath54 is translation by @xmath52 , and @xmath55 is a normalization factor .
the original basis states @xmath43 are divided by translation into classes and any two states in the same class give the same bloch state with an overall phase factor .
a representative is chosen from each class and is used consistently to build the bloch states .
for a state @xmath43 we denote its representative @xmath56 , and the hamiltonian matrix is block diagonal in the sense that @xmath57 when @xmath58 .
the matrix @xmath59 is diagonalized for each @xmath60 vector using the well - known lanczos method .
it is helpful conceptually to represent specific cases of our hamiltonian by the _ state graph _ , in an abstract ( or high - dimensional ) space , such that each node corresponds to a basis state , and two nodes are joined by an edge of the graph if and only if the two states differ by one particle hop .
( as used in sec . [ sec - graphhop ] , our many - body hamiltonian is almost equivalent to a single particle hopping on the state graph . )
the best - known precedent of this approach s trugman s study of one - hole and two - hole hopping in the @xmath12@xmath27 model @xcite .
two states are _ connected _ if one state can be changed to another by a succession of hops . for states near half filling , our @xmath61 constraint forbids many hop moves , so the graph is sparse and can possess interesting topological properties relevant to our spectrum .
we remarked ( fig .
[ fig - hole ] ) that an isolated hole is unable to hop ; larger finite `` droplets '' of holes are still immobile , though they may gain kinetic energy from internal fluctuations .
specifically , @xcite if one draws a rectangle with edges at @xmath62 to the lattice around the droplet , so as to enclose every site which deviates from the checkerboard order , then ( with the @xmath61 constraint ) sites outside this rectangle can never be affected by fluctuations of the droplet . due to the droplets , the state graph ( representing all states with @xmath31 particles ) may be broken up into many disconnected components , states which can not access each other by allowed hops .
this happens if both boundary vectors are even vectors , so that the system cell would support half filling with a perfect checkerboard order . for slightly less than half filling ,
the _ typical _ basis state consists of scattered immobile droplets of the kind just described .
each component corresponds to a different way to assign the holes to droplets , or merely a shifted way of placing the same droplets .
each sort of droplet has its characteristic energy levels @xcite and the system energies are the sum , just like a system of noninteracting atoms , each having its independent excited levels . when the state graph is disconnected , the hilbert space is correspondingly blocked into components which are not connected by matrix elements .
this is beyond the blocking according to translational symmetry , which remains true . in systems with even - even boundary conditions
, we are not mainly interested in the configurations with droplets , but in those with two stripes .
@xcite since these are disconnected from the rest of the hilbert space , it speeds up the the diagonalization by a large factor if it is limited to the stripe - configuration subblock of the hamiltonian matrix .
the only way to separate out this subblock is to generate basis states iteratively from a starting configuration which has two stripes .
what of the case of even - odd or ( equivalently ) odd - odd boundary conditions ?
these force _ one _ stripe ( possibly with additional holes , or possibly more stripes ) . in every such case ( excluding @xmath63 with odd @xmath64 )
, the stripe can fluctuate and absorb any droplets , so we believe the hilbert space is fully connected , and the diagonalization is not speeded up .
nevertheless , for every case near half - filling , we enumerated the basis from a starting configuration , as ( we believe ) this is the fastest way to do so .
systematically enumerating all possible fillings by brute force would take more time than the diagonalization itself , since almost every brute - force trial configuration gets ruled out by the @xmath61 constraint . however , at low fillings ( which we study in ref . )
the brute - force enumeration is used . in that case , if we generated from a starting configuration , there would be too many alternate routes to reach a given state .
hence much time would be wasted in searches to check whether each newly reached state was already on the basis state list .
below we outline the algorithm for building the basis states and the hamiltonian matrix . .
applying all allowed hoppings to @xmath65 ( the level 0 state ) gives the states @xmath37 , @xmath38 , @xmath66 , ... applying hoppings to @xmath37 ( a level 1 state ) gives level 2 states @xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 , ... the basis state list is then @xmath65 , @xmath37 , @xmath38 , @xmath66 , ... , @xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 , ... , @xmath70 , @xmath71 , ... , @xmath72 , @xmath73 , ... note that when applying hoppings to a state , only add states not already on the list .
we call this graph of states connected by hopping the _ state graph_. ] to build basis states without using translation symmetry from a starting state @xmath65 , we follow the following steps . 1 .
apply hopping to @xmath65 and obtain states @xmath37 , @xmath38 , @xmath66 , ... see fig [ fig - tree ] .
form the basis state list @xmath65 , @xmath37 , @xmath38 , @xmath66 , ... that are numbered 0 , 1 , 2 , 3 , ... and record the hamiltonian matrix elements @xmath74 , @xmath75 , @xmath76 , ... 2 .
apply hoppings to the next state on the basis state list that has not been applied hopping to . here from @xmath37 we get @xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 ... add these to the basis state list to form @xmath65 , @xmath37 , @xmath38 , @xmath66 , ... ,
@xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 , ...
( note we should not add states that are already on the list . for example , applying hoppings to @xmath37 will certainly give @xmath65 back again . do not include this state in level 2 states . when computing hermitian matrix elements we only need @xmath77 for @xmath78 . )
if @xmath67 is the @xmath79-th element on the list , record the matrix elements @xmath80 , @xmath81 , @xmath82 , ... 3 .
repeat the previous step until all the states on the list have been applied hopping to and no new states are created .
we finish with a basis state list @xmath65 , @xmath37 , @xmath38 , @xmath66 , ... , @xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 , ... , @xmath70 , @xmath71 , ... , @xmath72 , @xmath73 , ... and we have stored the hamiltonian matrix elements . when building basis states with translation symmetry , as in eq .
( [ eq - bloch ] ) , the procedure is like the above , except we apply hopping to representative states of each class of translation related states and also store the representatives of the resulting states . in this paper
we study both the boson and the fermion versions of our model eq . ( [ eq - ham ] ) , and one question that we often ask is when bosons and fermions have the same spectrum . in this section ,
we introduce a graph - based way to study the relationship between the boson and fermion spectra . using eq .
( [ eq - hn ] ) , we know that if @xmath83 is a state that can be obtained from the state @xmath84 by one nearest - neighbor hop , then we have @xmath85 where the subscripts @xmath86 and @xmath87 denote the fermion and boson matrix elements respectively and we have used the fact that @xmath88 for bosons . if we can write @xmath89 i.e. , @xmath90 as a product of a function @xmath91 that depends on one state only , then eq . ( [ eq - hbf ] )
can be written as a matrix equation , @xmath92 where @xmath93 . because @xmath94 , it is a similarity transformation , and then the eigenvalues of @xmath95 are identical to that of @xmath96 . indeed ,
this is a much stronger condition than having identical eigenenergy spectra : the _ eigenstates _ are also identical ( modulo a sign ) , so e.g. an operator which depends on the basis state has the same expectation in the boson and fermion cases . on the other hand ,
if the function @xmath91 can not be defined , the boson and fermion hamiltonians are not equivalent
. we can relate eq .
( [ eq - sab ] ) to the loops which occur in virtually every state graph with the help of fig .
[ fig - sab ] . here
@xmath90 is defined on the arrow pointing from @xmath84 to @xmath83 , whereas the function @xmath97 is defined on the node @xmath84 of the graph . ,
that is defined for each state , from a reference state 0 and the step wise hopping sign function @xmath90 , that is defined on the arrow pointing from @xmath84 to @xmath83 .
define @xmath98 .
if the function @xmath99 is well - defined , i.e. , all paths leading from 0 to @xmath83 give the same sign , then the boson and fermion spectra are identical . ]
[ fig - sab ] suggests a natural way to construct @xmath97 .
first we choose a reference point .
this should not matter and the one we choose is the starting state of the exact diagonalization program , say @xmath100 .
we set @xmath101 .
then if one hop takes @xmath84 to @xmath83 , define @xmath98 .
this is certainly correct if eq .
( [ eq - sab ] ) is true ; but if the state graph has a loop , two different paths lead to the same state @xmath83 from 0 , and @xmath99 can be well defined only if they produce the same sign .
the answer is different for different state graphs ( or disconnected subgraphs of the state graph ) , so it depends on the system dimensions and filling .
we can check numerically whether the function @xmath97 is well defined at the same time as we are building the basis set by applying hopping , i.e. constructing the state graph in the form of a tree ( fig .
[ fig - tree ] ) .
we store a sign for each state , starting with @xmath102 for state @xmath65 in fig .
[ fig - tree ] .
as we expand the tree , we compute the sign for the next level of states .
whenever we come to a state that is already on the list , we test whether the sign we produce following the current path equals that already stored for that state . depending whether the sign always agrees or sometimes disagrees , we know the fermion and boson problems are or are not equivalent .
this method is the basis for statements later in the paper on boson and fermion spectra ( sec .
[ sec-1stripebosefermi ] and sec .
[ sec-2andmorebosefermi ] , and briefly in secs .
[ sec - onehole ] and [ sec - twoholes ] ) ; it is not necessary to compute all the eigenvalues .
the boson - fermion equivalence condition can be re - stated in a way that is independent of the site ordering convention at the start of sec .
[ sec - diagstripe ] .
say each particle is originally numbered @xmath103 and retains its number when it hops .
then @xmath104 is simply the sign of the permutation which changes the string of particles ( when they are listed according to the site order ) .
the function @xmath97 is well - defined if and only if the product of @xmath104 around any closed loop of the state graph is unity ; in other words , if and only if any sequence of hops that restores the original configuration induces an even permutation of the particles .
when just two particles can be exchanged ( an odd permutation ) , as is obviously possible at low fillings , the fermion and boson spectra are obviously different .
it was first observed by mila , in a model very similar to ours , that the creation of stripes is more favorable than of isolated holes , as a way to dope the system below half filling .
@xcite we shall finally address more rigorously the phase stability of the stripe ( sec .
[ sec - stripearray ] ) , but in this section we will study the eigenstates of a single stripe in the system . in fig .
[ fig - stripe ] we show a @xmath105 and @xmath106 system with 12 particles .
a stripe of length four is formed along the @xmath107 direction .
the only four possible nearest - neighbor hops of the leftmost state are indicated with arrows and the resulting four states are shown on the right .
note that with a single stripe , the particles can only hop in the @xmath108 direction .
it is not possible for them to move in any fashion in the @xmath107 direction . system . for the leftmost state ,
the four possible hops are labeled and the resulting configurations are shown on the right .
the corresponding spin chain configurations are shown below ( see sec .
[ sec - maptospin ] ) . ]
we also consider tilted boundaries @xmath109 , which force a tilt of @xmath87 steps to the stripe because the site @xmath110 is identified with @xmath111 . in fig .
[ fig - tilted ] , the @xmath112 and @xmath113 systems are shown . note
because each stripe step is at 45 degree angle , an even ( odd ) horizontal length of the stripe @xmath114 must produce an even ( odd ) number of total vertical steps @xmath87 .
thus @xmath115 is always even . for a general @xmath109 system with @xmath116 odd , the single - stripe states have @xmath117 particles .
note also that for the tilted stripes , vertical hopping is again the only allowed motion of the particles .
diagonal stripes are observed in la@xmath118nio@xmath3,@xcite and they are an interesting topic in the @xmath5 model.@xcite however , in our model with @xmath61 , no hopping is possible away from a @xmath62 edge of any domain .
thus a diagonal stripe has no kinetic energy ( unless there are additional holes , as discussed in sec .
[ sec - holekink ] ) and is disfavored . and the @xmath113 systems .
the boundary conditions force a tilt of the stripe .
the corresponding spin - chains have total @xmath119 equal to @xmath120 and @xmath121 respectively ( see sec [ sec - maptospin ] ) . ]
[ sec - graphhop ] we find from diagonalization that for one - stripe systems with rectangular boundaries , the boson and fermion spectra are identical and are symmetric about zero . for a stripe in systems with tilted boundaries
, there are complications . for the @xmath122 system , with @xmath79 and @xmath53 integers ,
the spectrum is not symmetric about zero . in this case , with @xmath53 odd , the fermion spectrum is still identical to the boson spectrum , but for @xmath53 even , the fermion energies are the boson ones with a minus sign ( and because the spectrum is no longer symmetric about zero , the fermion energies are not the same as the boson energies ) . for the @xmath123 system ,
the boson and fermion spectra are identical and symmetric about zero .
all these numerical findings can be explained in terms of the state graph , extending sec .
[ sec - statistics ] .
we must characterize the permutations induced by a sequence of particle hops which return to the same basis configuration .
this is quite easy in the single stripe state , since ( as already commented on fig .
[ fig - stripe ] and fig .
[ fig - tilted ] ) , particles move in the @xmath108 direction only .
our discussion includes all @xmath124 systems ( which are tilted boundaries if @xmath125 ) . in these cases ,
particles are confined to the same column , and the net permutation is a product of permutations in each column . consider the total particle permutation induced when the system returns to the starting state by a loop on the state graph .
@xcite if in this process the stripe as a whole makes no net movement across the @xmath108 boundaries , then in each column the particles undo their hops and the net permutation is the identity .
thus , the only nontrivial loops are those in which the stripe crosses the @xmath108 boundary . indeed , since each hop moves the stripe locally by @xmath126 , the stripe must cross it must cross the boundary _
twice_. the particles in each column have returned to the original positions with a cyclic permutation in each column , which has the sign @xmath127 therefore the sign of the system s permutation is @xmath128 which ( since @xmath115 is even ) reduces to @xmath129 : the fermion and boson spectra differ if and only if this phase is @xmath130 , i.e. only when @xmath87 is odd _ and _ @xmath131 .
the @xmath132 symmetry of the single - stripe spectrum also falls out from visualizing the hamiltonian as a single particle hopping on the state graph ( with amplitude @xmath133 for every graph edge ) , and recalling the spectrum depends only on the attributes of closed loops .
we can always change our convention for the phase factors of the basis states , which is equivalent to a `` gauge transformation '' on the nodes of the state graph .
whenever a state graph is _ bipartite _ , meaning every closed loop on it has an even number of edges , it is well - defined to divide the basis states into `` even '' and `` odd '' classes .
if we change the phase factor by @xmath130 for every `` odd '' basis state , every edge ( every @xmath134 factor ) picks up a factor @xmath130 . by gauge equivalence
, the new hamiltonian matrix has the same spectrum . yet on the other hand , it is manifestly the same as the old matrix with @xmath135 , so it has the sign - reversed spectrum ; this proves the @xmath132 symmetry .
now , the nontrivial loops in the state - graph are those that pass the stripe twice across the @xmath108 boundary ; this motion requires @xmath136 hops .
thus , the state - graph is bipartite and the spectrum has @xmath132 symmetry , if and only if @xmath51 is even .
if @xmath51 is odd , the gauge - invariant effect of reversing @xmath135 is to change the net product of @xmath134 around every nontrivial loop by a factor @xmath130 .
but we showed that switching fermi and bose statistics creates the same sign : hence the fermion spectrum is the inverse of the boson spectrum , as observed . in figs .
[ fig - stripe ] and [ fig - tilted ] , we have indicated a natural map from any configuration @xmath137 of the stripe to a state of a spin chain of length @xmath114 . ( recall that `` configuration '' was defined in sec .
[ sec - basis ] as a pattern of occupied sites ; the map from the quantum states of the stripe is more subtle on account of phase factors , which are confronted later in this subsection . ) here it is obvious the spin length is one - half , for each stripe step , @xmath138 , can take only two values.@xcite the up step of the stripe is mapped to an up spin and the down step to a down spin . for example , the leftmost configuration in fig .
[ fig - stripe ] maps to a spin state @xmath139 .
this mapping was first noted by mila @xcite , who used it ( as we do here ) to evaluate the exact ground state energy of a stripe . note that when the periodic boundary conditions are rectangular , the stripe satisfies @xmath140 . in the corresponding states of the spin chain ,
the total @xmath141 spin component is zero . for tilted boundaries ,
the map to the spin - chain works exactly as before , the only difference being that the resulting spin configurations have @xmath142 .
the stripe - to - spin - chain map is not one - to - one , for translation in the @xmath108 direction of a single - stripe state gives the same spin - chain state ( with a possible fermion sign ) .
a rather analogous situation ( but one dimension higher ) appears in the two - dimensional quantum dimer model ( qdm ) .
@xcite in the qdm , every dimer configuration corresponded with a surface @xmath143 , uniquely except for an arbitrary shift of @xmath141 , just as our spin ( or 1d fermion ) chain corresponds to a stripe @xmath137 here .
there were two kinds of low energy excitations of the qdm : ripplon modes of the `` surface '' , and transverse motion ( or tunneling ) of the `` surface '' through a periodic boundary condition .
these correspond , respectively , to our ripplon modes labeled by @xmath144 ( see sec .
[ sec - stripeexcite ] and also sec .
[ sec - onehole ] ) and to our @xmath108-translation modes labeled by @xmath145 ( see eq .
( [ eq - mexcite ] ) ) .
the analogy is imperfect in that , in the qdm , the dimer configuration is `` real '' and the surface is an abstract mapping of it , whereas here the spin chain is the abstract mapping and the stripe is `` real . '' to determine the hamiltonian in spin language , consider that each allowed particle hop takes the stripe either from up - step / down - step to down - step / up - step or from down - step / up - step to up - step / down - step .
they correspond to the nearest - neighbor spin flips @xmath146 to @xmath147 and @xmath147 to @xmath146 respectively .
since the matrix element of @xmath148 is @xmath149 between states differing by a hop , this must also be the matrix element of @xmath150 between states differing by a spin flip .
thus the equivalent spin hamiltonian is @xmath151 which is the so - called spin-1/2 xx chain and is well - studied and exactly solvable .
@xcite lifted to act on hilbert space , the map should take the mathematical form @xmath152 where @xmath43 is a stripe state and @xmath153 is a spin state .
correspondingly , the equivalent spin hamiltonian should satisfy @xmath154 where @xmath148 is the spinless fermion or hardcore boson hamiltonian , eq .
( [ eq - ham ] ) , and @xmath43 is any single - stripe state . however , in the fermion case these equations are inconsistent with an arbitrary site - ordering scheme , for eq .
( [ eq - sssmap ] ) did not take the sign factors into account .
for many boundary conditions , there is _ no _ way to define a unique function , on account of the large loops in the state graph illustrated in fig .
[ fig - sab ] .
that is , particles can be hopped successively ( corresponding to a walk on the state graph ) such that @xmath43 returns to the state @xmath155 .
this gauge - like phase is familiar from the spinor coherent states ( where each spin direction is mapped to a spin-1/2 ket ) , in which case a @xmath156 rotation induces a @xmath130 phase shift .
this is handled most transparently after a further mapping of the spin chain to a fermion chain ( sec .
[ sec-1dfermion ] , below ) . in that representation
, the phase factor can be associated with the hopping of a one - dimensional fermion across the periodic boundary , and it will be implemented by adding an artificial flux that pierces the ring formed by the chain with periodic boundary conditions ( sec .
[ sec-1stripephase ] ) .
the many - to - one nature of the map ( because @xmath157 translation of the stripe produces the same spin state ) is easier to handle .
let us choose a rectangular system , adopt the site - ordering conventions of sec .
[ sec - basis ] , and provisionally assume there is no gauge - like phase ambiguity .
we ask that if @xmath158 translates a state in the @xmath108 direction by @xmath159 , then @xmath160 . one way to recover
the notion of a unique map is to form fourier states like eq .
( [ eq - bloch ] ) , but only in the @xmath108 direction : @xmath161 the normalization factor here is always @xmath162 because the @xmath116 translations in the sum can not produce two identical states .
from group theory we know @xmath163 if @xmath164 , so states with different @xmath145 belong to disconnected blocks . in each block with a given @xmath145 ,
there is a one - to - one correspondence @xmath165 . using eq .
( [ eq - hn ] ) , because @xmath148 commutes with translation @xmath158 , it is easy to show that @xmath166 for @xmath167 , we then have @xmath168 but if we translate @xmath169 by @xmath159 so we have @xmath170 , where @xmath91 is the fermion sign from translating the state @xmath169 by @xmath159 , then the translation state @xmath171 . then we have , @xmath172 eqs . ( [ eq - hpn ] ) and ( [ eq - hpn ] ) tell us that choosing @xmath173 rather than @xmath169 , the matrix element @xmath174 has an extra sign @xmath91 and an extra phase factor @xmath175 .
however , in the spin - chain language , we have , @xmath176 , because @xmath177 .
this means that we should have @xmath178 for all @xmath159 .
choose @xmath179 , then , as we have shown in sec .
[ sec-1stripebosefermi ] , every fermion hop in the one - stripe case produces a @xmath180 sign,@xcite thus we have @xmath181 , and at the same time , every @xmath108 translation gives @xmath182 .
in addition , if we choose @xmath183 , then we have , @xmath184 for any @xmath185 and @xmath43 in their respective translation classes .
in summary , for @xmath183 and @xmath186 , we map the fourier transformed single - stripe state @xmath187 to the spin - chain state @xmath188 , then we have an identity of matrix elements @xmath189 , and thus eq .
( [ eq - hammap ] ) is satisfied . for general @xmath190 or @xmath191 ,
this map involves additional phase factors which will be discussed in sec .
[ sec-1stripephase ] using a further map to one - dimensional fermions that we will describe in sec .
[ sec-1dfermion ] .
we have checked that the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the spin chain system match those of the spinless fermion and hardcore boson problems , using a spin diagonalization program developed for another project .
@xcite it is possible , in turn , to map each configuration of `` spins '' to that of a one - dimensional ( 1d ) lattice gas of particles : every @xmath192 becomes an occupied site , every @xmath193 becomes a vacant one .
the total number of `` up '' steps , i.e. fermions , is @xmath194 if the boundary vector along the stripe is @xmath195 .
the @xmath196 hop of a real particle on the square lattice ( implying a @xmath197 fluctuation of the stripe ) , translates to a spin exchange @xmath198 in the xx chain , and finally to a + @xmath107 hop of a 1d particle .
as is well - known , @xcite in one dimension hardcore particles may always be treated as fermions : if there is no path for them to exchange , then the statistics has no physical meaning .
one can describe the system as one - dimensional spinless fermions which are _ noninteracting _ , as the fermi statistics is already sufficient to keep two particles from occupying the same site .
the explicit relation of the stripe path @xmath199 to the 1d spin and fermion representations is @xmath200 where @xmath201 .
the effective one - dimensional hamiltonian is @xmath202 thus the dispersion is @xmath203 where @xmath204 is the one - dimensional wavevector .
we can construct exactly the ground state by filling the lowest - energy plane - wave states , up to the one - dimensional fermi vector @xmath205 ( @xmath206 for an untilted stripe ) ; here @xmath207 is the density of one - dimensional fermions , corresponding to a stripe slope @xmath208 .
all excited states correspond exactly to other ways of occupying the 1d fermion states .
if a stripe is coarse - grained as a quantum - fluctuating string , then it can be approximated using a harmonic hamiltonian , @xmath209\\ & = & \sum _ q { 1\over 2 } \left [ \frac{p_q^2}{\rhostar } + k q^2 { y_q^2}\right ] . \label{eq - string } \end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath210 is the effective mass density per unit length of the stripe , and the stiffness @xmath211 is analogous to a string tension .
the long - wave excitations of such a `` string '' are the quantized capillary waves known as _ ripplons _ , which have dispersion @xmath212 and @xmath204 is the one - dimensional wavevector .
on the other hand , in the microscopic representation by 1d - fermions , the fundamental excitation is evidently a particle or hole , which corresponds to a mobile _ kink _ of the stripe .
the ripplon is thus a composite excitation , a kink - antikink bound state . in the equivalent language of the spin-1/2 xx model ,
the ripplon maps to a magnon ( hydrodynamic mode ) , while the kink maps to a spinon .
the fractionalization of the spin-1 magnon into two spin-1/2 spinons is a familiar fact , as this system is a special case of a luttinger liquid .
@xcite we can use the fermi sea representation to extract the parameters in eq .
( [ eq - string ] ) . as noted above
, the 1d fermi wavevector is @xmath213 and by eq .
( [ eq-1deq ] ) the total energy is @xmath214 , where this notation means the sum over occupied 1d fermion states . equating the energy density due to small tilts to @xmath215 , we obtain @xmath216 .
next , the ripplon velocity is the same velocity as the fermi velocity , @xmath217 .
( this is a standard fact of one - dimensional fermi seas . ) with eq .
( [ eq - ripplon ] ) , that implies @xmath218 the 1d fermi sea representation also allows the exact computation of stripe fluctuations as a function of @xmath107 .
it is straightforward to show ( after rewriting in terms of wave operators ) that at half filling , @xmath219 we also know from eq .
( [ eq - deltay ] ) that @xmath220 this and eq .
( [ eq - stripecorr ] ) give that @xmath221 ^ 2 \rangle & = & r+ \frac{8}{\pi^2 } \sumodd \left ( \frac{1}{r } - \frac{r}{r^2 } \right)\\ & \approx & { \rm const } + \frac{4}{\pi^2 } \ln r \label{eq - stripefluc } \end{aligned}\ ] ] not surprisingly , the same result can be derived via the zero - point intensities of the harmonic ripplon modes , of eqs .
( [ eq - string ] ) and ( [ eq - ripplon ] ) .
( [ eq - stripefluc ] ) means that , due to the anticorrelations evident in eq .
( [ eq - stripecorr ] ) , the transverse deviations of the stripe grow slowly with length .
thus , if it moves transversely over larger distances , the stripe can often be approximated as a single rigid object .
this approximation will be invoked in several sections to explain how energy splittings depend on the system size @xmath116 in the transverse direction .
the mappings described in sec . [ sec-1dfermion ] are less trivial than they appeared , due to two related facts .
the first fact is that the mapping of stripe to spins ( or to 1d particles ) is many - to - one , as already noted in sec .
[ sec - maptospin ] .
the second fact is that the statistics of 1d hardcore particles is not quite as irrelevant as suggested in sec .
[ sec-1dfermion ] : they _ can _ be permuted by moving them in the @xmath107 direction through the periodic boundary conditions .
as is well known , this induces additional phase factors in a finite system .
consider , for example , a sequence of @xmath197 hops along a stripe , such that exactly one particle hops in each column .
the net effect on the real particle configuration is to translate the stripe by ( 0,2 ) ; in the fermion case , a sign factor @xmath222 is also picked up , where @xmath223 is the number of columns in which the real particle hop crossed the cell boundary , and eq . ( [ eq - sigmacol ] ) is the fermion sign picked up from the resulting rearrangement of creation operators among sites in a column .
( note that , here and for the rest of this discussion , we limit consideration to lattices in which the second boundary vector is @xmath224 . )
meanwhile , the same sequence of real particle hops maps to a cyclic permutation of the 1d particles in the @xmath225 direction exactly one @xmath225 hop occurs on every bond along the chain .
if the wavevector of our eigenstate is taken as @xmath226 , the stripe configuration shifted by @xmath227 ought to have an amplitude in the wavefunction @xmath228 times the amplitude of the original configuration . in a 1d fermion system
, however , the actual phase factor is @xmath229 , i.e. the number of fermions that are cyclically permuted .
we can account for all the phase factors by modifying the one - dimensional chain so that a particle hopping around its periodic boundary condition picks up a phase @xmath230 in other words by inserting a flux @xmath231 into the ring , @xcite where @xmath232 is sufficient to account for the two phases mentioned above , in the boson case ; in the fermion case , the an additional term @xmath233 is needed .
@xcite finally it is equivalent , modulo @xmath156 , to replace @xmath114 by @xmath234 in the last term : @xmath235_{\rm fermions } , \label{eq - phi1stripe}\ ] ] where the last term is included only in the fermion case , and even then it is zero in a rectangular system .
[ notice that @xmath116 is always odd when the boundary vector is @xmath236 transverse to the stripe , and the other boundary vector @xmath195 must be even . ]
it follows that the allowed 1d wavevectors are @xmath237 , where @xmath79 is any integer .
we get @xmath238 when the number @xmath239 of 1d fermions is odd and @xmath240 when @xmath239 is even ; either way , the 1d fermions occupied in the ground state are placed symmetrically about @xmath241 . in any eigenstate , the real wavevector component is @xmath242 , thus @xmath243 for the stripe ground state in any rectangular system .
it is not hard to compute @xmath214 to obtain the ( exact ) total ground state energy @xmath244 which implies the stripe energy is @xmath245 per unit length in the thermodynamic limit .
@xcite all our numerical results for stripe states agree with eq .
( [ eq - stripee0 ] ) ( see table [ t - excite ] ) .
when , as mentioned in sec .
[ sec - stripeexcite ] , we model the stripe direction as a free particle moving in one dimension , it is useful to know its effective mass @xmath246 .
the minimum - energy state of a single stripe with @xmath247 consists of rigid motion in that direction , so for small @xmath145 we expect @xmath248 in the 1d fermion representation , this state is constructed by shifting the ground state fermi sea by a wavevector @xmath249 , as follows from the first term in the phase shift eq .
( [ eq - phi1stripe ] ) . from this one obtains @xmath250 @xmath251 combining that with eqs .
( [ eq - stripee0 ] ) and ( [ eq - mstripe ] ) , one obtains @xmath252 for a long stripe , eq .
( [ eq - mstripelx ] ) implies an effective mass density @xmath253 in agreement with eq .
( [ eq - rhostar ] ) . to obtain the effective mass @xmath246 from exact diagonalization data , we use the smallest @xmath254 with a large @xmath255 .
( [ eq - mstripe ] ) gives the following expression to extract @xmath246 numerically , @xmath256 the results are shown in table [ t - excite ] ; they agree perfectly with eq .
( [ eq - mstripelx ] ) . .
stripe effective mass @xmath246 [ eq . ( [ eq - mexcite ] ) ] using single - stripe excited state energies with @xmath257 , with @xmath255 . [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ t - stable ] in table [ t - stable ] , we have also included calculations for the five smallest and five largest lattices in fig .
[ fig - fit ] separately .
we find that @xmath258 for both boson and fermion increases with increasing lattice size .
for the boson case , this means that for large lattices , the stripe - array is not stable against phase separation ( @xmath259 ) . for the fermion case ,
the result is stable ( @xmath260 ) for the lattices that we have studied , but @xmath258 is very close to the stability limit 1.273 .
the fermion stripe - array is possibly stable . in our earlier publication , ref .
, we used the same polynomial fitting function , eq .
( [ eq - fit ] ) , but we fixed @xmath261 , corresponding to the energy of an noninteracting particle , and our systems there went from 20 sites ( @xmath262 ) to 36 sites ( @xmath263 ) .
the analysis in this section and the results in table [ t - stable ] are obtained using the three - parameter ( @xmath264 ) fit for bigger lattices , from 25 sites ( @xmath265 ) to 42 sites ( @xmath20 ) . the conclusion in ref .
was @xmath266 for fermions , and @xmath267 for bosons .
simulated the boson case of our model eq .
( [ eq - ham ] ) , using quantum monte carlo , but with @xmath268 .
their phase diagram , fig .
11 of ref . , shows a first - order phase transition between the @xmath269 solid [ i.e. the checkerboard phase ] and a superfluid [ the hole - rich phase with @xmath270 .
our results correspond to a single point @xmath271 on their plot ; however , their phase boundary approaches that point with a slope @xcite @xmath272 , i.e. at @xmath273 in the @xmath25 limit , or @xmath274 in a related simulation . @xcite .
this is much _ larger _ than our result @xmath275 .
that is puzzling , since it would imply either that the liquid state ( with density @xmath276 ) has much lower energy than we found , or else that a state exists at @xmath277 ( in these finite systems ) having much lower energy than the stripe states we studied . the evidence in ref
. for phase separation rests on histograms such as their fig .
10 which exhibits ( for @xmath278 in an @xmath279 system ) a bimodal probability distribution for the density @xmath65 , in a grand canonical ensemble , with peaks at @xmath280 ( the checkerboard state ) and @xmath281 , the latter being interpreted as a liquid state . for our @xmath61 model ,
a similar plot at low temperature would show peaks at @xmath280 and at @xmath282 .
the latter peak represents a two - stripe state with 8 holes .
its energy is @xmath283 @xmath284 ( using eq .
( [ eq - stripee0 ] ) , and neglecting the stripe - stripe interaction in light of fig .
[ fig - phi ] ) .
our point is that examination of the most probable configurations is needed in order to judge whether the coexisting state contains stripes or liquid droplets .
indeed , the discrete coexistence between @xmath280 and @xmath282 is an artifact of the periodic boundary conditions in the thermodynamic limit , within the stripe - array phase , density @xmath65 varies continuously with the chemical potential .
in this paper we studied systematically a two dimensional model of strongly - interacting spinless fermions and hardcore bosons on the square lattice eq .
( [ eq - ham ] ) near the half - filled limit .
we considered an extended , quantum - fluctuating object that is natural in our model at the dense limit the stripe . after introducing our model ( sec .
[ sec - intro ] ) and our diagonalization program ( sec .
[ sec - diagstripe ] ) , we made a detailed study of the problems of a single stripe ( sec .
[ sec - onestripe ] ) , up to two holes on a stripe ( secs .
[ sec - onehole ] and [ sec - twoholes ] ) , stripe - stripe interaction of two , three , and four stripes ( sec .
[ sec - twoandmore ] ) , and finally the stability of an array of stripes ( sec .
[ sec - stripearray ] ) .
our theoretical studies were aided with substantial amount of results obtained from exact diagonalization .
as is well - known , quantum systems in two dimensions are much more difficult to study than those in one dimension . because of the presence of strong repulsion , at the dense limit of our model , motion is severely limited .
we showed that for the problems of a single stripe , holes on a stripe and a few stripes , analytical results can be obtained by mapping the two - dimensional problems to one - dimensioinal ones , which can in turn be studied using the analytical tools available in one dimension .
we showed in great detail the intricacies of each map , including for example , the many - to - one problem , the resulting phase factors , and the role of boson and fermion statistics .
another theme in this paper is the comparison between the boson and fermion problems . at the center of this comparison
is the state graph introduced in sec .
[ sec - diagstripe ] which describes graphically the relationship among the basis states . for the problems of a single stripe , holes on a stripe , and a few stripes , we investigated the effect of particle statistics on eigenenergy , with the help of the state graph and our computer program . and for the problem of stripe - array stability
, we obtain from diagonalization results an interesting conclusion that the boson stripe - array is not stable and the fermion stripe - array is very close to the stability limit and is possibly stable . this paper taken as a whole is an attempt to understand stripes as macroscopic objects arising from microscopic components ( the spinless fermion and hardcore boson particles in our model ) .
the underlying physics is the quantum mechanics of the component particles that is described by a many - particle schrodinger equation ( which we solve by exact diagonalization ) .
stripes can perhaps be called an _ emergent phenomenon _ and are results of collective motions of many microscopic particles ( the original particles or holes ) .
they can perhaps be considered in the same fashion as phonons arising from collective lattice vibrations . and
like phonons , the stripes in our problem have a life of their own , and we have tried , in this paper , to understand the new physics they bring .
this paper is one of the first using exact diagonalization to study stripes .
this is possible because of the significant hilbert space reduction afforded by our model eq .
( [ eq - ham ] ) , spinless fermions and hardcore bosons with infinite nearest - neighbor repulsion .
we believe that this is one of the simplest microscopic lattice model with which to study stripes from the underlying particle dynamics . and
as we commented in our other paper on the dilute limit of this model,@xcite this model deserves to be better known and better studied .
there are a number of directions in which the work of this paper might be extended .
for example , our code handles quite arbitrary periodic boundary conditions , not necessarily rectangular or square .
our key use of this feature was to accurately measure the equation of state for the strongly interacting liquid at density @xmath276 , as used in sec .
[ sec - stability ] to decide the stripe - array stability . by including a wide variety of differently shaped fermion systems in fig .
[ fig - fit ] ( top plot ) , in effect we average out the `` noise '' ( which is due to fermion shell effects @xcite ) .
an alternative way to do the same thing , which we have not implemented in the present work , would be to impose a phase factor across the boundary conditions and average over all phases .
@xcite a boundary condition could be used to investigate the 90@xmath285 bend of a stripe , which was discussed in sec .
[ sec - stripe90 ] .
these would force a diagonal stripe , as in fig .
[ fig-45hole ] , but additional holes would be added to the stripe which are expected to condense and form a segment at right angles . that geometry would permit estimation of the energy cost of the @xmath286 bend .
this study has focused entirely on eigenenergies ; since our diagonalizations provide the wavefunctions too , we could have computed a variety of informative expectations , such as correlation functions .
we did make qualitative observations using snapshots of the high - weighted configurations . in our diagonalizations with two or more stripes ( sec .
[ sec-3and4stripe ] ) , which started from a state with stripes all merged , the highest - weight state in the ground state eigenvector has stripes far apart from each other , and nearly equally spaced , as expected from the one - dimensional approximate wavefunctions of sec .
[ sec - twoandmore ] .
calculation of the probability distribution for the stripe separation would provide a quantitative test of those wavefunctions .
similar calculations would give a more direct check of the exponential decay of the hole probability as a function of its distance from a stripe , as predicted in sec .
[ sec - doublewell2 ] ; and would immediately reveal the attractive or repulsive tendency of two holes on a stripe ( sec .
[ sec - stripe90 ] ) .
we studied the case of _ one _ stripe with _ two _ holes ; the case of _ two _ stripes with _
one _ hole is also worth investigating .
the finite - size dependence of the extra energy due to the hole would shed light on the processes by which the hole is transferred between stripes when they touch .
such processes are critical to the transport properties of the stripe array , as considered in refs . in the spinfull case .
up to here , we discussed further kinds of measurements which could be made on the same model system ; variations are also possible of the model itself .
the most obvious of these is to treat @xmath268 .
a large but finite @xmath13 may be handled in the spirit of the @xmath12-@xmath24 : the same highly restricted basis states ( which facilitated our diagonalizations ) are retained , but new hopping terms along [ 2,0 ] and [ 1,1 ] type vectors appear , with amplitudes @xmath287 , wherever the intervening site would be forbidden by the nearest - neighbor exclusion .
it is not obvious whether this tends to stabilize or to destabilize the stripe array .
the inclusion of another form of correlated hopping ( ref . , fig .
3(c ) ) can certainly stabilize or destabilize the stripe array depending on its sign .
@xcite finally , the same code is adaptable , almost without modifications , to the triangular lattice . that may model @xmath22he or @xmath21he atoms adsorbed on graphite or on carbon nanotubes , @xcite which implement a periodic boundary condition in one direction .
we acknowledge support by the national science foundation under grant dmr-9981744 .
we thank g. g. batrouni for helpful discussions .
we find the number of basis states @xmath288 is maximum for fillings @xmath289 , close to the filling @xmath290 at which , in the thermodynamic limit , ( see sec . [ sec - stability ] ) a hole - rich liquid coexists with the half - filled state or the ( nearly - half - filled ) stripe array state .
this count may be estimated by adapting pauling s trick for the ice model entropy @xcite .
the number of ways merely to distribute @xmath31 particles over @xmath51 sites , uncontrained , is @xmath291 implying the usual entropy @xmath292 as @xmath293 ; this must be corrected to account for the constraint of no nearest neighbors .
one chosen particle has a probability @xmath294 to be free of nearest neighbors .
if we pretend this event is independent as each particle on ( say ) the even lattice is chosen in turn , then the @xmath295 power of this probability is the chance for the whole configuration to be valid .
the net entropy is estimated as @xmath296 ; this attains its maximum @xmath297 around @xmath298 . implying the leading dependence @xmath299 for the @xmath61 spinless case , compared to @xmath300 in the hubbard model case .
in fact , for a @xmath17 lattice , the block with @xmath301 particles has the largest ( translation - reduced ) matrix dimension , @xmath302 .
let @xmath303 be the number of basis states ( per @xmath50 vector ) in a configuration with @xmath304 stripes and @xmath223 holes on it .
this grows exponentially with @xmath114 but comparatively slowly with @xmath116 , so we can handle quite large @xmath116 , and moderately large @xmath114 . the number of states with two stripes may be estimated by placing them independently the correction from disallowing overlaps is subdominant .
that is the square of the one - stripe count , multiplied by @xmath308 for the possible vectors offsetting one stripe relative to the other , i.e. @xmath309 .
@xmath310 . for one stripe with one hole ,
the basis states were counted for @xmath311 and @xmath312 .
empirically , @xmath313 exactly , where @xmath314 , @xmath315 , @xmath316 , @xmath317 ; for @xmath106 , this appears to follow with @xmath318 , @xmath319 , @xmath320 .
the linear increase with @xmath116 is due to the states with the hole away from the stripe . for a stripe with two holes , eq .
( [ eq - count11 ] ) gets multiplied by an additional factor @xmath308 , for the possible offset of the second hole relative to the first .
empirically , @xmath321 ( valid for @xmath322 ) ; this is inferred from @xmath323 . for @xmath106
, we found roughly @xmath324 , for @xmath114 up to 13 .
j. m. tranquada , d. j. buttrey , v. sachan , and j. e. lorenzo , phys .
lett . * 73 * , 1003 ( 1994 ) ; j. m. tranquada , b. j. sternlieb , j. d. axe , y. nakamura , and s. uchida , nature * 375 * , 561 ( 1995 ) .
j. zaanen , science * 286 * , 251 ( 1999 ) .
g. s. uhrig and r. vlaming , phys .
71 * , 271 ( 1993 ) ; g. s. uhrig and r. vlaming , physica b * 206 & 207 * , 694 ( 1995 ) .
j. k. freericks , phys . rev .
b 47 , 9263 ( 1993 ) .
r. lemanski , j.k .
freericks , and g. banach , preprint ( cond - mat/0204503 ) .
the system ba@xmath325k@xmath2bio@xmath326 is argued to have stripes of that sort , by i. b. bischofs , p. b. allen , v. n. kostur , and r. bhargava , preprint ( cond - mat/0203486 ) . r. a. de groot , f. m. mueller , p. g. van engen , and k. h. j. buschow , phys .
lett . * 50 * , 2024 ( 1983 ) ; v. yu .
irkhin and m. i. katsnelson , physics - uspekhi * 37 * , 659 ( 1994 ) [ usp .
nauk * 164 * , 705 - 24 ( 1994 ) ] .
j. r. cullen and e. callen , phys .
* 26 * , 236 - 8 ( 1971 ) . j .-
h . park , e. vescovo , h .- j .
kim , c. kwon , r. ramesh , and t. venkatesan , nature * 392 * , 794 ( 1998 ) .
h. seo , m. ogata , and h. fukuyama , phys .
b 65 , 085107 ( 2002 ) .
see , e.g. , e. manousakis , preprint ( cond - mat/0201142 ) .
d. green and c. chamon , phy .
* 85 * , 4128 ( 2000 ) . ref . did investigate the tendency , as a function of @xmath327 , for four holes to line up [ stripe - like correlation ] in the typical configurations found in exact diagonalizations of the @xmath12-@xmath24 model on up to 20 sites .
j. zaanen , m. l. horbach , and w. van saarloos , phys .
b * 53 * , 8671 ( 1996 ) .
h. eskes , r. grimberg , w. van saarloos , and j. zaanen , phys .
b * 54 * , r724 - 7 ( 1996 ) ; h. eskes , o. y. osman , r. grimberg , w. van saarloos , and j. zaanen , phys .
b * 58 * , 6963 ( 1998 ) .
l. p. pryadko , s. kivelson , and d. w. hone , phys .
lett . * 80 * , 5651 ( 1998 ) ; l. p.
pryadko , s. a. kivelson , v. j. emery , y. b. bazaliy , and e. a. demler , phys .
b * 60 * , 7541 ( 1999 ) .
this phase separation is between the half - filled phase and a stripe - array ( still near half - filling ) with a particular spacing @xmath29 .
it is _ not _ the phase separation , involving a hole - rich phase , that we ( or ref . )
have been concerned with .
( note in ref .
the roles of long- and short - range forces are reversed from ref .
, as to which kind produces phase - separation and which produces a stripe array . )
one should also note that ref . models stripes as fixed .
its conclusion is not guaranteed for the case , closer to the cuprates , that the frequency scale of stripe fluctuations , @xmath328 , exceeds that of spin waves , @xmath329 . in the case
@xmath332 , as in fig .
[ fig - stripe ] , a simpler argument is possible , which depends only on the numbering convention of sec .
[ sec - diagstripe ] .
a fermion sign can be introduced by a hop only when a hop takes a particle across the @xmath108 boundary , so the ordering of the @xmath333 particles in its column undergoes a cyclic permutation with sign @xmath334 as defined in eq .
( [ eq - sigmacol ] ) .
this is unity when @xmath335 so in eq .
( [ eq - hn ] ) @xmath44 for every matrix element , i.e. the boson and fermion hamiltonians are identical . p. a. houle , n. g. zhang , and c. l. henley , phys .
b * 60 * , 15179 ( 1999 ) .
the code used in this reference can diagonalize arbitrary spin systems for both the full hamiltonian matrix and the cyclic permutation symmetry - reduced problem .
this description has glossed over the complications that our one - dimensional wavefunctions are manifestly multi - valued .
we must imagine that the many - body wavefunction of the 1d system jumps to another `` riemann sheet '' every time a 1d fermion hops across the boundaries .
this is familiar from the theory of anyons .
the last term here does not yield the @xmath336 factor described above , but it is gauge - equivalent to that .
it gives the correct factor for the @xmath116 iterated shifts by @xmath227 required to return to the original stripe configuration , which is @xmath337 recall @xmath116 must be odd . for @xmath338 and @xmath339 systems
the boson and fermion energies are the same . for @xmath340
this is not true , and here we plot the boson energies . note that this does not invalidate the result ( that boson and fermion one - hole - with - a - stripe problems have the same energy spectra ) checked in sec .
[ sec - onehole ] because it was for rectangular systems .
this is analogous to the reason that , in the hubbard model , a hole moving in a half - filled background suppresses spin deviations ( y. nagaoka , phys . rev . *
147 * , 392 ( 1966 ) . )
snapshots of the high - weight configurations in the ground - state wavefunction do commonly show the hole combined with an up - step as in fig .
[ fig-45hole ] , but we did not study this quantitatively .
this is not true for systems with @xmath114 close to @xmath116 .
for example , for @xmath263 with @xmath341 , the lowest boson energy is @xmath342 and the fermion energy is @xmath343 .
there we do not necessarily have two parallel stripes .
alternatively , the same two - stripe problem can be solved using relative coordinates ( center - of - mass frame ) .
it appears as one particle with reduced mass @xmath344 confined to a box @xmath345 .
the energy is @xmath346 , which agrees with eq .
( [ eq - box ] ) .
so strictly speaking , we should write something like @xmath347 to emphasize @xmath348 s dependence on @xmath114 and the boson and fermion statistics , but when we do not explicitly study these dependencies , we neglect them in @xmath348 .
p. visscher , phys .
b * 10 * , 943 ( 1974 ) .
v. j. emery , s. a. kivelson , and h. q. lin , phys .
64 * , 475 ( 1990 ) ; phys .
b * 42 * , 6523 ( 1990 ) .
these are square lattices @xmath349 with @xmath350 and @xmath351 , and rectangular lattices @xmath352 , @xmath353 , and @xmath20 .
f. hbert , g. g. batrouni , r. t. scalettar , g. schmid , m. troyer , and a. dornreich , phys .
b 65 , 014513 . note that `` striped '' , as used in this paper , has a meaning quite distinct from our stripes .
g. g. batrouni , private communication . | we consider a hubbard - like model of strongly - interacting spinless fermions and hardcore bosons on a square lattice , such that nearest neighbor occupation is forbidden .
stripes ( lines of holes across the lattice forming antiphase walls between ordered domains ) are a favorable way to dope this system below half - filling . the problem of a single stripe can be mapped to a spin-1/2 chain , which allows understanding of its elementary excitations and calculation of the stripe s effective mass for transverse vibrations . using lanczos exact diagonalization
, we investigate the excitation gap and dispersion of a hole on a stripe , and the interaction of two holes .
we also study the interaction of two , three , and four stripes , finding that they repel , and the interaction energy decays with stripe separation as if they are hardcore particles moving in one ( transverse ) direction .
to determine the stability of an array of stripes against phase separation into particle - rich phase and hole - rich liquid , we evaluate the liquid s equation of state , finding the stripe - array is not stable for bosons but is possibly stable for fermions . |
the @xcite and @xcite _ chandra _ surveys of the nuclear bulgerevealed a large population of weak , hard point - like x - ray sources that could account for up to 10% of the previously observed `` diffuse '' x - ray emission from the nuclear bulge .
numerous studies have tried to characterise these newly discovered x - ray sources of the nuclear bulge surveys based on their x - ray properties .
@xcite suggest that a large fraction may be wind - accreting neutron stars with high mass companions . @xcite and
@xcite propose that they could be white dwarfs accreting from main sequence counterparts ( cataclysmic variables , polars and intermediate polars ) . @xcite and
@xcite believe them to be neutron stars with low mass companions and @xcite have speculated that they could be isolated neutron stars and black holes accreting from the interstellar medium .
however , the weak nature of the sources means that positive identification of the majority of the sources is impossible based solely on the x - ray data .
identification of the stellar counterparts to these x - ray sources we will allow the differentiation between these possibilities .
as shown in @xcite , to identify candidate counterparts to x - ray sources in the nuclear bulge , very high resolutions imaging is required to avoid issues of confusion due to the high stellar density of the region .
in addition to that , the extremely high , variable extinction towards the nuclear bulge requires these observations to be performed in the near - infrared or longer wavelengths .
previously , only the denis and 2mass surveys had observed the nuclear bulge entirely in the near - infrared , however as will be shown , their depth and resolution is insufficient for the purposes of identifying the counterparts to the majority of the nuclear bulgex - ray sources .
the ( united kingdom infrared deep sky survey - galactic plane survey ) ukidss - gps is one of the five near infrared public legacy surveys that are being undertaken by the ukidss consortium , using the wide field camera on the united kingdom infrared telescope @xcite .
surveying the northern galactic plane and the nuclear bulge in @xmath1 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 bands , integration times of 80s , 80s and 40s respectively achieve median 5-@xmath4 depths of @xmath5 , @xmath6 and @xmath7 ( vega system ) for the most recent data release 2 ( dr2 ; * ? ? ?
the resolution of the ukidss - gps observations are 0.2 , an order of magnitude better than the 2mass survey , with a similar positional accuracy of @xmath8 . in the nuclear bulge
, the crowding of this extremely dense stellar region coupled with the high level of intervening extinction reduces the completion limit of the survey to @xmath9 , @xmath10 and @xmath11 with detection limits of @xmath12 , @xmath13 and @xmath14 . despite this
, the @xmath15 region shown in figure [ f : nbimage ] contains @xmath16 point sources . as
such it is the first survey covering the entire nuclear bulge to have the resolution and depth to allow the identification of candidate counterparts to the majority of the nuclear bulge x - ray sources .
we used the topcat program to identify candidate counterparts to the x - ray sources .
we used a larger @xmath17 positional error for the ukidss - gps nuclear bulge source positions , than the stated accuracy of @xmath18 , to account for the confusion in the nuclear bulge caused by the very high stellar density .
the `` out - of - the - box '' _ chandra_positional error is @xmath19 , though this can be considerably larger ( up to @xmath20 ) in some cases due to image distortion in the outer regions of the _ chandra _ array and/or to the very low s / n of the faintest sources detected . for the purpose of this study , we discarded all x - ray sources for which the x - ray positional errors were greater than @xmath21 radius ; for error circles greater than this size , the number of candidate counterparts is sufficiently high ( 5 - 30 stars ) to render meaningless any attempt at astrometric matching between the near - infrared and x - ray catalogs .
we used the @xmath17 positional error for the ukidss - gps source positions , along with the derived positional errors from the @xcite and @xcite x - ray source catalogues to set a maximum separation of @xmath22 between and x - ray source and a star that can be considered a match .
[ cols="^ , > , > , > , > , > " , ] [ t : ncounterparts ] of the 4256 x - ray sources in the @xcite catalogues , 3963 x - ray sources have positional errors of less than @xmath21 . from these , we found 3076 candidate counterparts to 1963 of the x - ray sources .
there are 1368 x - ray sources with only one candidate counterpart , 341 with two candidate counterparts , 151 with three and 103 with 4 or more candidate counterparts .
table [ t : ncounterparts ] gives a breakdown of the numbers of counterparts for x - ray sources with error circles of @xmath23 , @xmath24 and @xmath25 .
as can be seen , for x - ray sources with positional errors of @xmath26 , the majority of these have only one candidate counterpart , whereas those with @xmath24 errors have a slightly larger proportion with 2 candidate counterparts . as might be expected , it is the sources with the larger error circles , @xmath25 , which have a much larger proportion with multiple candidate counterparts .
figure [ f : xrscolmag ] shows colour magnitude diagrams ( cmds ) of the candidate counterparts compared to a representative sample of nuclear bulge stars from the ukidss - gps dr2 catalogue . from the diagrams it can be seen that the x - ray sources follow the general trend of the overall stellar distribution but with some differences to their specific distribution .
for instance , the cmds containing @xmath1-band data reveal a high proportion of the candidate counterparts to be in the local , main - sequence arm of the cmds .
the majority of the remaining candidate counterparts in all three cmds are consistent with red giants at a galactic centre distance with variable levels of extinction ( see poster contribution by gosling et al . for details of the nuclear bulgeextinction ) .
figure [ f : xrscolmag ] also demonstrates the increase in candidate counterparts that occurs when sources with photometry in the @xmath2 and @xmath3-band is compared to those for which there is photometry in all 3 or @xmath1 and @xmath2-bands .
there is a large amount of extinction towards the nuclear bulge ( see additional poster contribution of gosling et al . for further details ) , this extinction has a greater effect on shorter wavelengths and so is most likely to obscure a source in the @xmath1 band .
this is also apparent in the increase in sources being predominately those with large values of @xmath27 indicating high levels of extinction .
identifying the candidate counterparts to the nuclear bulge x - ray sources is only the first step in understanding this population . to better understand them
, it will be necessary to identify the true companion to each of the x - ray sources where possible . in order to do this ,
we intend to search for accretion signatures in the candidate counterparts .
we are undertaking a narrow - band brackett-@xmath28 ( br-@xmath28 , a known accretion signature ) imaging survey of the nuclear bulge to identify sources with br-@xmath28excess , and will also follow - up the candidate counterparts with near - infraredmulti - object spectroscopy using the flamingos-2 instrument soon to be commissioned on gemini south .
we will also compare our catalogue of candidate counterparts to the _ spitzer _ catalogue of point sources of @xcite to increase our wavelength coverage of these sources and to identify those with spectra indicating that they are likely to be in accreting or x - ray emitting systems .
we have presented an initial matching of the source positions of the _ chandra _ nuclear bulge surveys of @xcite and @xcite to the new ukidss - gps near - infrared survey of the nuclear bulge . in doing so ,
we have identified candidate counterparts to @xmath29 of the x - ray sources in this extremely crowded and heavily extincted region .
we show that these candidate counterparts are consistent with the overall stellar distribution of observations towards the nuclear bulge although the relative proportions of the populations are different .
candidate counterparts that are observed in the @xmath1-band have a higher tendency to be foreground sources and those observed only in the @xmath2 and @xmath3-bands are more likely to be nuclear bulge sources .
this is most likely to be an effect of the high levels of extremely spatially variable extinction ( see additional poster contribution by gosling et al . for further details ) towards the nuclear bulge .
further observations including narrow - band br-@xmath28 imaging and near - infraredspectroscopy using the flamingos-2 instrument as well as comparison to other datasets such as the _ spitzer _ observations of the nuclear bulge will be used to better identify the true companions to these x - ray sources and so gain an understanding as to the nature of the nuclear bulge x - ray source population . | we present an initial matching of the source positions of the _ chandra _ nuclear bulge x - ray sources to the new ukidss - gps near - infrared survey of the nuclear bulge .
this task is made difficult by the extremely crowded nature of the region , despite this , we find candidate counterparts to @xmath0 of the x - ray sources . we show that detection in the @xmath1-band for a candidate counterpart to an x - ray source preferentially selects those candidate counterparts in the foreground whereas candidate counterparts with only detections in the @xmath2 and @xmath3-bands are more likely to be nuclear bulge sources .
we discuss the planned follow - up for these candidate counterparts . |
despite the great success of the standard model ( sm ) , the mechanism for electroweak symmetry breaking remains to be tested in experiments .
there are many reasons to believe there is physics beyond the sm . in particular , the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm ) is one of the best motived theories where it is possible to describe the cold dark matter in the universe and where the unification of the gauge couplings is achieved . in low energy supersymmetry
it is assumed that the susy breaking scale is at tev following the naturalness criterion .
recently , arkani - hamed and dimopoulos @xcite , have noticed that gauge coupling unification can be achieved in a supersymmetric model where all scalars , except for one higgs doublet , are very heavy .
most of the unpleasant aspects of low energy supersymmetry , such as excessive flavour and cp violation , very fast dimension 5 proton decay , and tight constraints on the higgs mass , are eliminated . at the same time , there is a candidate to describe the cold dark matter in the universe .
several phenomenological studies in this scenario , now called split supersymmetry , have been performed @xcite .
it is expected that the higgs boson will be discovered in the next generation of collider experiments .
therefore , one of the main issues in higgs boson physics is the identification of observable useful to distinguish between the sm higgs @xmath1 and the lightest higgs in possible extensions of the sm .
there are several studies devoted to this very important issue in the context of the mssm @xcite . as we mention before we hope at future collider experiments we will discover at least a neutral particle with spin zero , the higgs boson , and the lightest supersymmetric particles , the neutralinos and charginos .
since in split supersymmetry the interactions of the lightest higgs boson with the sm fermions are the same as the interactions of the sm higgs , through the decays into two sm fermions it is not possible to make the identification of the higgs .
therefore we have to use the decays at one loop , where the effect of virtual particles present in split susy is relevant . in this letter
we investigate this issue and we argue that the way to address it is studying the decays of the higgs boson into two photons . we show several numerical examples where it is possible to appreciate large differences between the decay rates in the sm and in split supersymmetry .
in order to identify the higgs boson at future colliders the predictions of all its decay rates have to match with their measurements . this is the case of sm higgs boson @xmath1 or the lightest higgs boson @xmath2 of the supersymmetric extension of the standard model .
it is particularly difficult to distinguish between the sm higgs boson and the mssm lightest higgs boson in the decoupling limit @xcite .
this is precisely what happens in split supersymmetry , where all scalars are very heavy except for one higgs doublet and for the neutralinos and charginos which are all light .
therefore , in split supersymmetry we expect that at future colliders the lightest higgs boson will be discovered together with charginos and neutralinos . however , their discovery is not enough to claim that the observed higgs corresponds to the split susy light higgs , since we have to measure its couplings with a good precision . in the context of the mssm
there are studies about the possibility to distinguish between different higgses through the couplings @xmath3 @xcite , @xmath4 @xcite and @xmath5 @xcite .
also the quantity @xmath6 has been studied extensively @xcite . in this letter
we study the possibility to identify the light higgs in split supersymmetry @xcite .
since in this case all sfermions and higgs bosons , except for the lightest one , are very heavy it is not possible to use the quantity @xmath7 nor the coupling @xmath3 .
the @xmath8 and @xmath9 couplings are equal at tree level in the sm and in split susy .
there are not differences at one - loop , since all squarks or sleptons in the loops are very heavy . in the case of @xmath3 coupling , this is a one - loop induced coupling with quark contributions being common to both the sm and split - susy , and with the difference being the squark contributions , which are negligible .
the two other possibilities are to use the couplings @xmath4 and @xmath5 .
however , it is not possible to use the first one since we know that the @xmath10 is very small and it will be very difficult to determine it with a very good precision @xcite .
therefore we concentrate on the possibility to use the coupling @xmath5 for our study .
the decay @xmath11 can be observed at the lhc but with an error larger than @xmath12 @xcite . at electron - positron colliders
there is the additional possibility of photon - photon collisions , where the rate @xmath13 can be measured with a @xmath14 precision @xcite .
this combined with a measurement of @xmath15 with a @xmath16 @xcite , gives a determination of @xmath17 with a @xmath18 error .
the decay rate @xmath19 is given by @xcite : @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the fine structure constant , @xmath22 is the @xmath23 gauge coupling constant , @xmath24 is the @xmath25 boson mass , and @xmath26 is the higgs boson mass .
there is an amplitude @xmath27 for each charged particle inside the loop , and depends on a loop function @xmath28 whose form varies according to the spin of the particle in the loop . in split
supersymmetry the relevant contributions are : @xmath29 where @xmath30 , @xmath31 , @xmath32 are the amplitudes for the contributions with @xmath25 bosons , fermions , and charginos inside the loop , respectively .
the parameter @xmath33 , where @xmath34 is the mass of the particle inside the loop , and @xmath26 is the higgs mass .
@xmath35 for quarks and squarks , while @xmath36 for leptons and sleptons , and @xmath37 is the electric charge of the fermion @xmath38 .
the couplings of the lightest higgs to the internal particles are given by : @xmath39 @xmath40 with @xmath41 and @xmath42 .
the matrices @xmath43 and @xmath44 are the matrices which diagonalize the chargino mass matrix .
the loop functions @xmath45 , @xmath46 and @xmath47 can be found in @xcite . in split
supersymmetry , the higgs couplings to fermions and @xmath25 bosons are sm - like , giving contributions which are equal in both models .
therefore , the chargino contribution will determinate the difference between the decays into two photons in the sm and split susy .
in order to quantify the difference between the decay rate of the sm higgs and the lightest higgs into two photons in split supersymmetry we define the following quantity : @xmath48 we calculate this quantity using the above formulas for different values of the relevant parameters , which are the higgs mass , the higgsino mass parameter @xmath49 , the @xmath23 gaugino mass @xmath50 , and @xmath51 . we take @xmath52 gev and consider it as an independent parameter . notice
that in the case of split supersymmetry , since we accept the fine - tuning and we integrate out all superheavy scalars , the higgs mass basically does not change when we vary the rest of the parameters .
the loops corrections with charginos and neutralinos are not very important , see for example @xcite . in figure [ dmu ] we see how this quantity changes as a function of the parameter @xmath49 , for given values of @xmath50 and @xmath53 .
note that it is possible to achieve differences up to @xmath54 when the chargino contribution is large .
as this difference is achieved , the branching ratio of the decay into two photons is of the order of @xmath55 .
we impose the experimental bound @xmath56 gev , which limits the curves at low values of @xmath49 .
as the magnitude of the parameter @xmath49 increases the chargino masses increase also , the heavier faster than the lightest . in general
, larger chargino masses produce smaller contributions to @xmath11 and thus the parameter @xmath57 decreases . for a similar reason ,
curves defined by larger values of the gaugino mass @xmath50 have smaller @xmath57 .
these curves are defined by @xmath58 gev ( red crosses ) , @xmath59 gev ( blue x s ) , and @xmath60 gev ( green circles ) .
two different values of @xmath51 are considered in this figure , @xmath61 and 50 with the smaller value giving larger @xmath57 .
another interesting point to notice in this figure is the correlation between the sign of @xmath49 ( actually , the sign of @xmath62 since we work with @xmath63 ) and the sign of @xmath57 . in fig .
[ dm2 ] we show the variation of @xmath57 as a function of @xmath50 for @xmath61 and @xmath64 , 250 , and 350 gev .
it is clear that when @xmath50 is increased our quantity decreases since the chargino contributions are less important , due to their larger mass .
the three curves are limited at low @xmath50 by the experimental lower bound on the chargino mass described before . at the other extreme ( @xmath65 gev ) the light chargino mass is given by 133 , 213 , and 262 gev for @xmath64 , 250 , and 350 gev , respectively . despite these large chargino masses , @xmath57 remains above 1% in the whole parameter space shown in the figure . in fig .
[ dtb ] we have the dependence of @xmath57 on @xmath51 , and plot three curves with increasing values of @xmath49 and @xmath50 , as indicated in the figure . in all cases
@xmath57 decreases with @xmath51 from several percent at low values to less than 1 - 2% at large values .
the decay rate for @xmath11 in the mssm with the higgs sector in the decoupling limit was studied in @xcite .
it was found that contributions from the stop sector are larger when the left - right mixing is large , and that contributions from charginos decrease with @xmath51 . at small @xmath51 chargino and
stop contributions have opposite signs and a cancellation could occurs .
of course , this cancellation does not happens in split supersymmetry , obtaining larger decay rates @xmath0 . in general , smaller decay rates are obtained at large values of @xmath51 : chargino contributions are small in both the mssm and split susy , with the stop contribution adding to the @xmath25 contribution in the mssm .
larger decay rates are found in the mssm at high @xmath51 when the sbottom loops are also important .
we hope that the results presented in this section will be useful to understand the possibility to distinguish between the sm higgs boson and the lightest higgs boson in split susy .
in split supersymmetry the light higgs boson couplings to sm particles are identical to the couplings of the sm higgs boson .
we point out that a way to distinguish between them is through the decay into two photons .
we show several numerical examples where we appreciate large differences of several percent between the predictions for @xmath0 in the two models , making possible the discrimination at future photon - photon colliders .
once the higgs boson and the charginos are discovered at the next generation of collider experiments , the well defined predictions for the higgs decay into two photons will constitute an important cross check to identify the light higgs boson in split susy .
h. e. haber , nucl .
* 116 * ( 2003 ) 291 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0212010 ] .
m. dubinin , h. j. schreiber and a. vologdin , eur .
j. c * 30 * ( 2003 ) 337 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0302250 ] .
m. carena and h. e. haber , prog .
* 50 * ( 2003 )
63 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0208209 ] . z. bern , l. j. dixon and c. schmidt , phys .
d * 66 * ( 2002 ) 074018 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0206194 ] .
l. s. group _ et al .
_ , arxiv : hep - ph/0410364 .
d. asner , b. grzadkowski , j. f. gunion , h. e. logan , v. martin , m. schmitt and m. m. velasco , arxiv : hep - ph/0208219 .
d. asner _
et al . _ ,
j. c * 28 * ( 2003 ) 27 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0111056 ] .
s. soldner - rembold and g. jikia , nucl .
instrum .
meth . a * 472 * ( 2001 ) 133 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0101056 ]
. j. f. gunion , h. e. haber and r. van kooten , arxiv : hep - ph/0301023 .
j. f. gunion et al , higgs hunter s guide . | we investigate the possibility to distinguish between the standard model higgs boson and the lightest higgs boson in split supersymmetry .
we point out that the best way to distinguish between these two higgs bosons is through the decay into two photons .
it is shown that there are large differences of several percent between the predictions for @xmath0 in the two models , making possible the discrimination at future photon - photon colliders .
once the charginos are discovered at the next generation of collider experiments , the well defined predictions for the higgs decay into two photons will become a cross check to identify the light higgs boson in split supersymmetry . |
the general concern of this paper is the dynamics of solid bodies in a fluid flow .
this dynamics is relevant to many natural and industrial processes , like blood flows , sprays , or design of micro swimmers .
a main problem to understand this dynamics is to compute the drag exerted by the flow on the bodies . from the mathematical point of view ,
a natural approach to this problem is to use the euler or navier - stokes equations to model the flow .
however , this generates serious difficulties .
a famous one is _
dalembert s paradox _
, related to the euler equation : in an incompressible and inviscid potential flow , a solid body undergoes no drag @xcite .
but the navier - stokes equations also raise modeling issues .
let us consider for instance a single solid moving in a viscous fluid .
we denote by @xmath1 , @xmath2 the solid and fluid domains at time @xmath3 , and @xmath4 the total domain .
we assume that the fluid is governed by the navier - stokes equations .
we denote @xmath5 and @xmath6 its velocity and internal pressure , @xmath7 its density , @xmath8 its viscosity .
thus : @xmath9 with @xmath10 the gravitational force . in parallel to the fluid modeling , we write the conservation of linear and angular momentum for the body . denoting @xmath11 the position of the center of mass , @xmath12 its velocity , and @xmath13 the angular velocity at time @xmath3
, these conservation laws read @xmath14 following standard notations , @xmath15 and @xmath16 are the density and mass of the solid ( independent of @xmath3 and @xmath17 ) , @xmath18 is the newtonian tensor of the fluid : @xmath19 and @xmath20 is the inertia matrix of the solid : @xmath21 the vector @xmath22 is the unit normal vector pointing inside the solid @xmath23 .
note that the velocity @xmath24 at each point @xmath17 of the solid reads @xmath25 to close the system , one usually imposes no - slip conditions , both at the fluid - solid interface and the cavity boundary : @xmath26 and one specifies the initial data : the initial position of the solid @xmath27 , @xmath28 one could believe that system -- is a good model for the interaction between a solid and a viscous fluid . far from it : in the case of a sphere falling over a flat wall @xmath29 it predicts that no collision is possible between the solid and the wall !
this no - collision paradox has been known from specialists since the 1960 s , after articles by cox and brenner and cooley and oneill in the context of stokes equations . since then , the no - collision paradox has been confirmed at the level of the navier - stokes equations ( see @xcite , and the preliminary result in ) .
of course , such a result is unrealistic , as it goes against archimedes principle .
it suggests that the navier - stokes equations are not relevant to collisional and post - collisional descriptions .
hence , many physicists have tried to find an explanation for the paradox .
_ we shall focus here on one possible explanation , namely the no - slip condition_. the idea is that , when the distance between the solids gets very small ( below the micrometer ) , the no - slip condition is no longer accurate , and must be replaced by a navier condition : @xmath30 in other words , only the normal component of the relative velocity of the fluid is zero , to ensure impermeability .
the tangential ones are non - zero , and proportional to the stress constraint , with constant slip lengths @xmath31 . for a recent discussion of the navier condition , notably in the context of microfluidics
, we refer to @xcite .
see also the seminal paper @xcite .
let us point out that the navier - condition is sometimes used as a wall law , to describe the averaged effect of rough hydrophobic surfaces @xcite .
the effect of slip conditions on collision was investigated recently by the authors in article @xcite .
more precisely , this article is devoted to a simplified model , in which * the navier - stokes equations are replaced by the steady stokes ones ( quasi - static regime ) . *
the domain @xmath32 is a half - space , the solid @xmath33 is a sphere . in this context , denoting @xmath34 the distance between @xmath23 and the plane @xmath35 , it is shown that the dynamics obeys the reduced ode @xmath36 where the drag term @xmath37 satisfies @xmath38 as @xmath39 .
this is in sharp contrast with the case of no - slip conditions , for which @xmath40 .
in particular , it allows for collisions in finite time .
we refer to @xcite for all details and other results in the context of rough boundaries .
hence , paper @xcite provides a resolution of the paradox : one can _ a priori _ keep the navier - stokes equations , up to considering the navier boundary conditions .
nevertheless , the analysis in @xcite is limited to simple configurations and to stokes flows . in the context of the full 3d navier - stokes system
, more complicated behaviors may occur .
for instance , smooth solutions may exhibit singularities prior to any collision . to describe the qualitative features of the collision ,
_ one needs to consider weak solutions_. the theory of weak solutions is well understood in the case of no - slip conditions and many references will be given in the next section .
_ however , the existence of weak solutions with navier conditions has been so far an open question , due to serious additional mathematical difficulties . to address
this question is the purpose of the present paper_. broadly , we shall build weak solutions for system -- , up to collision between the solid and the cavity @xmath32 .
the paper is organized as follows .
section [ results ] contains the statement of our main result : we give a definition of weak solutions , and state the existence of such solutions as long as no contact occurs .
we explain the main difficulties in proving their existence , in comparison to the results available for no - slip conditions .
we conclude section [ results ] by an outline of our proof , to be carried out in sections [ transport ] to [ convergence ] .
more precisely : * section [ transport ] is devoted to an auxiliary nonlinear transport equation , which is crucial to our approximation procedure .
* section [ approx ] is dedicated to the construction of solutions for well - chosen approximations of the navier - stokes / solid dynamics .
* section [ convergence ] describes the limit procedure , from the approximate to the exact system .
the aim of this paragraph is to define a weak formulation and weak solutions for system -- , that is in the case of slip conditions of navier type .
we remind that in the case of no - slip conditions , the theory of weak solutions has been successfully achieved over the last ten years , first up to collision ( see ) and then globally in time ( see in the 2d case , @xcite in the 3d case ) .
let us also mention the alternative approach in @xcite , and the recent result @xcite on the uniqueness of 2d weak solutions up to collision . as usual
, in order to derive a weak formulation , the starting point is formal multiplication by appropriate test functions .
these test functions must of course look like the solution itself .
notably , they must be rigid vector fields in the solid domain @xmath33 .
this forces the space of test functions to depend on the solution itself : it is a classical difficulty , already recognized in the no - slip case .
_ a key feature of the slip conditions is that these test functions , and also the solution , will be moreover discontinuous across the fluid / solid interface .
_ indeed , the first line of ensures the continuity of the normal component , but the tangential ones may have a jump .
it is a strong difference with regards to boundary conditions , and it will generate many difficulties throughout the paper .
we first introduce some notation for the classical spaces of solenoidal vector fields .
let @xmath41 be a lipschitz domain .
we set @xmath42 we remind that elements @xmath43 of @xmath44 satisfy @xmath45 in @xmath46 .
we also introduce the finite dimensional space of rigid vector fields in @xmath47 : @xmath48 finally , we define for any @xmath49 the space @xmath50 of test functions over @xmath51 : @xmath52 ; l^2_\sigma(\omega ) ) , \ : \mbox{there exists } \ : \varphi_f \in { \cal d}([0,t ) ; { \cal d}_\sigma(\overline{\omega } ) ) , \ : \varphi_s \in { \cal d}([0,t ) ; { \cal r } ) \\ \mbox { such that } \ : \varphi(t,\cdot ) = \varphi_f(t,\cdot ) \ : \mbox { on } f(t ) , \ :
\varphi(t,\cdot ) = \varphi_s(t,\cdot ) \ : \mbox { on } s(t ) , \ : \mbox { for all } \ : t \in [ 0,t ] \bigr\}.\end{gathered}\ ] ] let us point out once again that this space of test functions depends on the solution itself through the domains @xmath23 and @xmath53 .
let us also notice that the constraint @xmath54 encodes in a weak form the continuity of the normal component at @xmath55 : @xmath56 multiplying by @xmath57 , integrating over @xmath53 , and integrating by parts , we obtain ( formally ) @xmath58 where the normal vectors @xmath59 , in the integrals at the right - hand side , point resp .
outside @xmath32 and inside @xmath23 .
using : @xmath60 eventually , one can use to write differently the last integral : tedious but straightforward manipulations yield @xmath61 combining the previous identities and integrating from @xmath62 to @xmath63 entails @xmath64 equation is a global weak formulation of the momentum equations and , taking the slip conditions into account .
setting @xmath65 in the above formal computations yields that , for all @xmath66 : $ ] @xmath67 this goes together with the conservation of mass , that amounts to the transport of @xmath33 by the rigid vector field @xmath68 .
it reads @xmath69 or in a weak form : for all @xmath70 , @xmath71 pondering on these formal manipulations , we can now introduce our definition of a weak solution on @xmath51 .
_ we fix once for all the positive constants @xmath72_. let @xmath32 and @xmath73 two lipschitz bounded domains of @xmath47 .
let @xmath74 , @xmath75 such that @xmath76 a weak solution of -- on @xmath51 ( associated to the initial data @xmath27 , @xmath77 and @xmath78 ) is a couple @xmath79 satisfying * @xmath80 is a bounded domain of @xmath47 for all @xmath81 , such that @xmath82 * @xmath43 belongs to the space @xmath83 \bigr\},\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath84 for all @xmath85 . * equation is satisfied for all @xmath57 . * equation is satisfied for all @xmath86 . * equation is satisfied for almost every @xmath87 let us conclude this paragraph by a few comments on this definition of weak solutions : 1 . as @xmath88 ,
the integrals over @xmath23 in are integrable with respect to time : namely , @xmath89 belong to @xmath90 .
actually , by the method of characteristics , as @xmath91 ( rigid velocity field ) , it is easily seen that @xmath92 for an isometric propagator @xmath93 which is lipschitz continuous in time , smooth in space .
it follows that all integrals in equation make sense .
for instance , as @xmath55 is lipschitz for all @xmath3 and fields @xmath94 have at least @xmath95 regularity , the surface integral @xmath96 can be defined for almost every @xmath3 in the trace sense .
moreover , it defines an element of @xmath90 .
this can be seen through the change of variable @xmath97 : the surface integral turns into @xmath98 where @xmath99 and where @xmath100^{-1 } \ , \nu(y ) \|_2
\det({{\nabla}}\phi_{t,0}(y ) ) \ : ( = 1)\ ] ] is the tangential jacobian ( see ( * ? ? ? * lemme 5.4.1 ) for details ) .
this clearly defines an element of @xmath90 .
2 . equations and involve fields @xmath101 , @xmath102 defined over @xmath32 and such that @xmath103 however , a closer look at equations and shows that they only involve @xmath104 in particular , they only depend on @xmath43 and @xmath105 , not on the choice of the extended fields @xmath101 and @xmath106 .
the condition @xmath107 implies that @xmath108 all terms being again understood in the trace sense .
it is easy to see that equation , that is the transport equation @xmath109 can be written @xmath110 and implies @xmath111 ( remind that @xmath112 ) . more generally , one can replace @xmath43 by any @xmath113 satisfying @xmath114 where the last equality holds in the space @xmath115 ( see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 3.2.2 ) ) .
note that equations and should be replaced by @xmath116 in the case of inhomogeneous solid and fluid , with variable density functions @xmath117 and @xmath118 .
see @xcite in the case of no - slip conditions .
extension of the present work ( on a single rigid and homogeneous solid in a homogeneous fluid ) to more general configurations will be the matter of a forthcoming paper .
noticing that @xmath119 it is tempting to write under the condensed form @xmath120 where @xmath121 , coupled with the global transport equation @xmath122 this kind of global formulation , reminiscent of the inhomogeneous navier - stokes equations , is used in the construction of weak solutions with dirichlet boundary conditions : _ cf _ .
_ however , it is not valid here _ : due to the discontinuity of the tangential components of @xmath43 and @xmath105 , neither @xmath123 nor @xmath124 and @xmath125 belong to @xmath126 . for instance , @xmath127 where @xmath128 is the dirac mass along the solid boundary @xmath129 .
this is why we keep the formulation , distinguishing between the solid and the fluid part .
6 . the definition of a weak solution that we consider can not be satisfactory after collision .
indeed , we do not specify any rebound law .
moreover , in the case of dirichlet conditions at the fluid - solid interface , explicit examples show that the analogue of our weak solution is not unique @xcite .
our result is the following * ( existence of weak solutions up to collision ) * [ theorem_existence ] let @xmath32 and @xmath130 two @xmath131 bounded domains of @xmath47 .
let @xmath74 , @xmath75 such that @xmath132 there exists @xmath49 and a weak solution of -- on @xmath51 ( associated to the initial data @xmath27 , @xmath77 and @xmath78 ) .
moreover , such weak solution exists up to collision , that is @xmath133 the rest of the paper will be devoted to the proof of the theorem .
briefly , there are two main difficulties compared to the case of dirichlet conditions : * the lack of a unified formulation such as . * the lack of a uniform @xmath0 bound on solutions @xmath43 .
these difficulties appear both in the construction of approximate solutions , and in the convergence process .
indeed , the approximation of fluid - solid systems is usually adressed by relaxing the solid constraint , through a penalization term . in this way , one is left with approximate systems that are close to density dependent navier - stokes equations .
roughly , they read @xmath134 in the case of no slip conditions , in which a global formulation of type - already holds , to build such approximation is quite natural .
but in the case of navier conditions , this is not easy .
once an approximate sequence of solutions @xmath135 has been derived , dirichlet conditions allow for uniform @xmath0 bounds on @xmath136 .
this simplifies a lot of convergence arguments , notably with regards to the transport equation @xmath137 to which the classical diperna - lions theory applies straightforwardly @xcite .
also , it helps to provide strong convergence of @xmath136 in @xmath138 . in short
, the lack of bound on @xmath139 ( due to the penalization term ) can be overcome by considering the fields @xmath140 , where @xmath141 is the orthogonal projection in @xmath142 over the fields that are rigid in a @xmath143-neighborhood of @xmath23 .
one can show that @xmath140 has good equicontinuity properties uniformly in @xmath143 and @xmath144 . in the case of navier boundary conditions
, no uniform bound is available in @xmath0 .
this forces us to use more the structure of the solution @xmath43 , in particular the @xmath0 bounds on the fluid and solid domains separately .
this is also a source of trouble for the construction of approximate solutions , as one must find an approximation scheme in which such structure is not too much broken .
let us describe here briefly the main lines of our proof .
let @xmath145 as in theorem [ theorem_existence ] , and @xmath146 the keypoint is to consider approximate problems of the following type : _ find @xmath147 such that _ a ) : : @xmath148 is a bounded lipschitz domain for all @xmath66 $ ] , such that @xmath149 ; l^p(\omega ) ) , \ : \forall \ , p < + \infty\ ] ] b ) : : @xmath150 c ) : : for all @xmath151 s.t .
@xmath152 : @xmath153 d ) : : @xmath154 in above lines , * @xmath155 is the total density function . * @xmath156 is an inhomogeneous viscosity coefficient .
* @xmath157 is the orthogonal projection in @xmath158 over rigid fields .
this means that : @xmath159 * eventually , @xmath160 is a field that satisfies @xmath161 for some @xmath143 fixed and arbitrary in @xmath162 .
moreover , @xmath163 will be chosen so that it is close to @xmath164 outside @xmath165 ( in @xmath166 topology ) . in this way
, it will asymptotically coincide with the limit @xmath43 of @xmath164 .
further details on the definition of @xmath163 will be provided in due course .
let us make a few comments on such approximate problems : 1 .
they rely on the use of the fields @xmath167 , that were already introduced in @xcite in the context of dirichlet conditions .
these fields appear both : + \i ) in the transport equation for @xmath168 . they will allow for a good control of the trajectories of the approximate solid bodies @xmath165 .
+ \ii ) in the penalization term @xmath169 . formally , as @xmath144 goes to infinity , this term will allow to recover the rigid constraint inside the solid .
2 . note that _ a contrario _ to the large penalization term , the viscosity term @xmath170 vanishes asymptotically in the solid part .
hence , there will be no uniform bound in @xmath142 for @xmath164 , as expected ( see the discussion in paragraph [ mainresult ] ) .
a specificity of these approximate problems is that the transport equation * d ) * is nonlinear in @xmath168 for a given @xmath164 .
indeed , @xmath171 depends on @xmath168 ( _ cf _ the formula in section [ transport ] ) .
the whole section [ transport ] is dedicated to this auxiliary nonlinear transport equation , which is a keystone of the approximation procedure .
once the solution @xmath168 of * d ) * is found and seen as a functional of @xmath164 , equation * c ) * can be written as @xmath172 for some functional @xmath173 from @xmath174 into itself . in short
, we shall solve this equation by a galerkin procedure : we shall look for an approximate solution @xmath175 where @xmath176 is an orthonormal basis of @xmath177 .
we shall solve approximate equations @xmath178 by schauder s theorem and pass to the limit with respect to @xmath179 .
this process is explained in section [ approx ] .
note that the field @xmath163 satisfies @xmath180 in particular , one can write @xmath181 this will allow to obtain energy estimates in a standard way , in the spirit of the approximate systems used for dirichlet conditions .
the price to pay is the necessary control of @xmath182 , which will exhibit strong gradients near @xmath183 as @xmath184 .
moreover , a similar `` boundary layer behaviour '' will be involved in the approximation of discontinuous test functions @xmath57 by continuous test functions @xmath185 ( involved in * c ) * ) .
the whole convergence process will be analyzed in section [ convergence ] .
let @xmath49 , @xmath107 .
this section is devoted to the equation @xmath186 where @xmath187 is defined by the following formula @xmath188 where the center of mass , total mass and inertia tensor of the solid are defined by @xmath189 and @xmath190 if @xmath191 with @xmath23 a subdomain of @xmath32 , @xmath192 is the orthogonal projection in @xmath193 over rigid vector fields , see @xcite .
we start with the regular case , that is when @xmath194 ; { \cal d}_\sigma(\overline{\omega}))$ ]
. this case will be useful for galerkin approximations of * a)-d)*. * ( well - posedness ) * [ transportwp ] let @xmath195 ; { \cal d}_\sigma(\overline{\omega})).$ ] \i ) there is a unique solution @xmath196 ; l^p({{\mathbb r}}^3))$ ] @xmath197 of @xmath198 + ii ) moreover @xmath199 for all @xmath3 , with @xmath23 a lipschitz bounded domain .
more precisely , @xmath200 for the isometric propagator @xmath93 associated to @xmath187 : @xmath201 ^ 2 ; c^\infty_{loc}({{\mathbb r}}^3))$ ] .
_ we can suppose @xmath202 ; { \cal d}_\sigma(\mathbb r^3))$ ] with no loss of generality .
assume for a moment that we have found a solution @xmath203 of .
then , we can see as a linear transport equation , with given transport @xmath204 ; \ : { \cal r})$ ] . by the method of characteristics
, we get easily @xmath205 where @xmath93 is the isometric propagator defined by @xmath206 now , we use in the expression for @xmath187 .
we obtain : @xmath207 where @xmath208 and @xmath209 in particular , denoting @xmath210 the finite dimensional manifold of affine isometries , we deduce from and that @xmath211 \mapsto { \rm isom}({{\mathbb r}}^3)$ ] satisfies an ordinary differential equation , of the type @xmath212 for a time - dependent vector field @xmath213 over @xmath214 .
namely , @xmath215 is defined by the same formula as in , replacing everywhere @xmath216 by @xmath217 .
conversely , if we manage to show existence of and uniqueness of a @xmath218 solution of over @xmath219 $ ] , then formula will define the unique solution @xmath203 of the nonlinear equation , proving theorem [ transportwp ] .
hence , it only remains to study the well - posedness of .
we can identify @xmath214 with @xmath220 , and identify all tangent spaces with @xmath221 . by the cauchy - lipschitz theorem
, there is existence and uniqueness of a @xmath218 maximal solution if @xmath213 is continuous in @xmath222 , locally lipschitz in @xmath217 .
considering the expression of @xmath213 , see , this follows from [ lem_m * ] let @xmath223 ; { c}^{\infty}_{loc}({{\mathbb r}}^3))$ ] .
then , the function @xmath224 \times { \rm isom}({{\mathbb r}}^3 ) \mapsto { { \mathbb r } } , \quad { \cal m}(t,\phi ) = \int_{s^0 } 1_{\omega}(\phi(y ) ) v(t , \phi(y ) ) dy\ ] ] is continuous in @xmath225 , and uniformly lipschitz in @xmath217 over @xmath219 $ ] .
_ proof of the lemma .
_ the continuity is obvious .
then , for two affine isometries @xmath217 and @xmath226 , we write @xmath227 clearly , @xmath228 , \\
|x| \le \|(\phi,\phi')\|_{\infty } } } \hspace{-.5cm}| { { \partial}}_x v(t , x)| \ : \int_{s_0 } | \phi(y ) - \phi'(y)| dy \ :
\le \ : c_{\phi,\phi ' } || \phi - \phi'||_{\infty}.\ ] ] as regards @xmath229 , we write @xmath230 , \\ |x| \leq \|\phi'\|_{\infty } } } \hspace{-.2 cm } |v(t , x)| \ : \int_{{{\mathbb r}}^3 } \left| 1_{\omega}(\phi(y ) ) - 1_{\omega}(\phi'(y ) ) \right| \ , dy \ : \le \ : c_{\phi ' } \ , \int_{{{\mathbb r}}^3 } \left| 1_{\omega}(\phi(y ) ) - 1_{\omega}(\phi'(y ) ) \right| \ , dy\ ] ] for each @xmath231 , the integrand is non - zero if and only if @xmath232 and @xmath233 or vice - versa . as @xmath234 ,
this is only possible if @xmath235 and @xmath236 are in a @xmath237-neighborhood ( say @xmath238 ) of @xmath35 .
hence , @xmath239 this concludes the proof of the lemma .
last step is to prove that the maximal solution is defined over the whole interval @xmath219 $ ] . from -
, one can write @xmath240 where @xmath241 is defined in and @xmath242 is an orthogonal matrix .
in particular , the only way that the maximal solution is not global on @xmath219 $ ] is through a blow - up of @xmath243 .
but , again , from , @xmath244 which prevents any blow - up .
this ends the proof of the theorem . *
( strong sequential continuity ) * [ strongcontinuity ] assume that @xmath245 ; { \cal d}_\sigma(\overline{\omega})).\ ] ] then with obvious notations , one has @xmath246 ; l^p_{{}loc}({{\mathbb r}}^3 ) ) \ : ( p < \infty),\ ] ] as well as @xmath247 ; c^\infty_{loc}({{\mathbb r}}^3 ) ) , \quad \phi^n \rightarrow \phi \quad \mbox { strongly in } \ : c^1([0,t]^2 ; c^\infty_{loc}({{\mathbb r}}^3)).\ ] ] _ proof of the proposition . _ as @xmath164 converges in @xmath248;{\cal d}_{\sigma}(\overline{\omega})),$ ] we have that @xmath167 is bounded in @xmath249 similarly @xmath168 is bounded in @xmath250 furthermore , up to a subsequence that we do not relabel , @xmath167 converges weakly- * in @xmath251 to some @xmath252 and @xmath253 converges strongly in @xmath254 applying di perna - lions theory , we obtain that @xmath168 converges weakly- * in @xmath255 and strongly in @xmath248;l^p_{loc}(\omega))$ ] for all finite @xmath256 .
its limit @xmath257 , satisfies : @xmath258 using the convergence of both @xmath168 and @xmath164 in equation , we obtain that @xmath259 , where @xmath260 is defined similarly to @xmath187 , replacing @xmath203 by @xmath257 .
moreover , the convergence of @xmath261 holds in @xmath248 ; c^\infty_{loc}({{\mathbb r}}^3)).$ ] consequently , @xmath262 is the unique solution of so that @xmath263 and @xmath264 , and all the sequence converges . to derive the convergence of the propagators @xmath265 from the convergence of the vector fields @xmath167
is then standard , and we omit it for brevity . * ( weak sequential continuity ) * [ weakcontinuity ] let @xmath266 be a bounded sequence in @xmath267 , satisfying @xmath268 then , up to a subsequence , one has @xmath269 @xmath270 ; l^p_{loc}({{\mathbb r}}^3 ) ) \ : ( p < \infty),\ ] ] with @xmath271 a solution of @xmath272 moreover , @xmath203 satisfies condition ii ) of proposition [ transportwp ] , and the following additional convergences hold : @xmath273 \phi^n \rightarrow \phi \quad & \mbox { weakly * in } & \ : w^{1,\infty}((0,t)^2 ; c^\infty_{loc}({{\mathbb r}}^3 ) ) \quad \mbox { strongly in } \ : c([0,t]^2 ; c^\infty_{loc}({{\mathbb r}}^3))\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] _ proof . _
the proof follows the same scheme as the previous one .
we only sketch the arguments .
first , up to the extraction of a subsequence , we obtain that @xmath269 then , as before , we obtain that @xmath274 is bounded in @xmath275 .
this yields that @xmath276 ( still up to a subsequence ) .
we then deduce applying di perna - lions theory that , up to the extraction of a subsequence , @xmath168 converges strongly in @xmath277 ; l^p_{loc}({{\mathbb r}}^3))$ ] to some @xmath203 , which in turn implies that @xmath278 and that @xmath279 is a solution to our tranport equation .
eventually , uniform bounds on @xmath265 and @xmath280 ( which imply weak- * convergence of a subsequence in @xmath281 ) follow easily .
this section is devoted to the resolution of approximate fluid - solid systems .
these approximate systems were introduced in paragraph [ strategy ] , _ cf _ * a)-d)*. the previous section has focused on the transport equation * d)*. it remains to examine * c)*. at first , we explain a little how the field @xmath163 connecting @xmath167 to @xmath282 is defined . the detailed definition of @xmath163 will be achieved in section [ convergence ] .
we first remind a classical result on the equation @xmath283 , taken from ( * ? ? ?
* exercise iii.3.5 ) : [ bogovski ] let @xmath41 be a bounded lipschitz domain .
let @xmath284 and @xmath285 satisfying the compatibility condition @xmath286 then there exists a solution @xmath287 of @xmath288 with @xmath289 the previous proposition yields easily [ lemmamollified ] * ( extension of solenoidal vector fields ) * there exists a continuous linear operator @xmath290 satisfying @xmath291 on @xmath32 .
moreover , for all open subset @xmath292 , @xmath293 * ( connection of solenoidal vector fields ) * [ coroconnection ] for all @xmath294 , there exists a continuous linear operator @xmath295\ ] ] such that @xmath296 \ : = \ : u_s \quad \mbox { in } \ : s_0 , \\ & v^\delta[u , u_s ] \ : = \ : u \quad \mbox { outside a $ \delta$ neighborhood of } \ : s_0
. \end{aligned}\ ] ] from there , we have the following [ constructionvn ] for all @xmath294 , there exists a continuous mapping @xmath297\ ] ] such that @xmath298(t , \cdot ) \ : = \ : u_s(t , \cdot ) \quad \mbox { in } \ : s(t ) , \\ & v^\delta[u , u_s](t , \cdot ) \ : = \ : u(t , \cdot ) \quad \mbox { outside a $ \delta$ neighborhood of } \ : s(t ) , \ : t \in [ 0,t ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where , as usual , @xmath299 and @xmath300 is the isometric propagator associated to @xmath68 .
moreover , @xmath301 can be chosen so that @xmath302 \|^2_{l^2(0,t ; h^1(\mathbb r^3 ) ) } \
: \le \ : { \cal c } \ , \int_0^t \left ( \| u(t,\cdot ) \|^2_{h^1({{\mathbb
r}}^3\setminus \overline{s(t ) } ) } \ : + \ : \| u_s(t,\cdot ) \|^2_{l^2(s(t ) ) } \right ) \ , dt,\ ] ] where @xmath303 depends on @xmath143 and @xmath63 .
the proposition can be deduced from corollary [ coroconnection ] using lagrangian coordinates .
namely , we introduce @xmath304 and @xmath213 through the relations @xmath305 clearly , for all @xmath3 , @xmath306 and @xmath307 define elements of @xmath308 and @xmath309 respectively . using corollary [ coroconnection ] , we define @xmath310 $ ] through the relation @xmath311\left(t,\phi_{t,0}(y)\right ) \ : = \ : d\phi_{t,0}\vert_{y}\left(v^\delta[u(t,\cdot),u_s(t,\cdot)](y ) \right).\ ] ] it fulfills all requirements , which ends the proof .
back to system * c ) * , the idea is to define @xmath312 .\ ] ] clearly , for any time @xmath313 such that @xmath314,\ ] ] @xmath315 will belong to @xmath316 and will satisfy @xmath317 let us stress that there is still some latitude left in the construction of @xmath163 , through the choice of the operator @xmath318 in corollary [ coroconnection ] . as will be shown in section [ convergence ] , this operator can be chosen depending on @xmath144 ( @xmath319 ) so that @xmath163 is close to @xmath164 outside @xmath165 ( in @xmath166 topology ) .
however , this additional property will not be needed until section [ convergence ] .
last remark : the resolution of * a)-d ) * , and the whole construction of weak solutions , will be first performed on a small time interval @xmath219 $ ] , for a time @xmath63 that is uniform in @xmath144 .
existence of weak solutions up to collision will follow from a continuation argument , to be explained at the end of section [ convergence ] .
as pointed out in paragraph [ strategy ] , the resolution of * a)-d ) * is carried out through a galerkin scheme .
let @xmath320 being both an orthonormal basis of @xmath177 and a basis of @xmath142 , with elements in @xmath321 .
the aim of this paragraph is to find for all @xmath322 and some @xmath49 a couple @xmath323 satisfying a ) : : @xmath324 is a bounded lipschitz domain for all @xmath66 $ ] , such that @xmath325 ; l^p(\omega ) ) \ : ( p < \infty)\ ] ] b ) : : @xmath326)^n.$ ] c ) : : for all @xmath327 @xmath328
d ) : : @xmath329 in above lines , similarly to the original problem : * @xmath330 is the total density function . *
@xmath331 is an inhomogeneous viscosity coefficient .
* @xmath332 is defined by , adding the upperscript @xmath179 everywhere . *
eventually , @xmath333 $ ] , see paragraph [ mollified ] .
_ note that all quantities above depend on @xmath144 , notably through the penalization term and the viscosity coefficient .
but we omit @xmath144 from the notations to lighten writings . _ also ,
note that @xmath334 can be seen as an element of @xmath335 , as the @xmath336 are defined globally .
in particular , @xmath333 $ ] is well - defined .
the main result of this paragraph is [ theogalerkin ] there is @xmath49 , @xmath337 , such that for all @xmath338 , * a)-d ) * has at least one solution such that @xmath339 . to prove theorem [ theogalerkin ]
, we shall express our galerkin problem as a fixed point problem , and will apply schauder s theorem to it .
thus , we want to identify @xmath334 as the fixed point of an application @xmath340 defined on @xmath341 ; \ : \mbox{span}(e_1,\dots , e_n ) ) , \quad \| u \|_{l^\infty(0,t ; l^2(\omega ) ) } \le r \right\}$ ] .
we proceed as follows .
let @xmath342 .
* _ step 1 .
_ let @xmath203 be the solution of @xmath343 given by proposition [ transportwp ] .
we know that @xmath191 with @xmath23 a bounded lipschitz domain , @xmath66 $ ] .
we define accordingly : @xmath344.\ ] ] * _ step 2 . _
we consider the following ode , with unknown @xmath345 \mapsto \mbox { span}(e_1,\dots , e_n)$ ] : @xmath346 in which @xmath347 , @xmath348 and @xmath349 are defined by @xmath350 we have identified here the function @xmath351 with its coefficients in the basis @xmath352 .
note that the function @xmath353 defined in step 1 has a positive lower bound , so that @xmath354 in the sense of symmetric matrices , whatever the value of @xmath203 . also , the continuity of @xmath355 and @xmath356 over @xmath219 $ ] is easy and will be proved below .
in particular , equation has a unique solution @xmath357 ; \ : \mbox{span}(e_1,\dots , e_n)).\ ] ] in this way , we can associate to each @xmath358 some field @xmath359 ; \ : \mbox{span}(e_1,\dots , e_n)).\ ] ] the whole point is to prove [ propgalerkin ] there exists @xmath49 , @xmath337 , uniform in @xmath144 and @xmath179 , such that @xmath360 is a well - defined mapping from @xmath361 to itself , continuous and compact . before proving this proposition ,
let us show how it implies theorem [ theogalerkin ] . by schauder s theorem , it yields the existence of a fixed point @xmath362 of @xmath360 .
let @xmath363 be the corresponding solution of the transport equation on @xmath219 \times { { \mathbb r}}^3 $ ] . as will be clear from the proof , the time @xmath63 of the proposition satisfies @xmath364,\ ] ] for some @xmath143 fixed and arbitrary in @xmath365 .
hence , * a ) * is satisfied , and @xmath366 $ ] satisfies @xmath367 , as well as @xmath368 ( see remark 4 after the definition of weak solutions , and remark 5 , paragraph [ strategy ] ) . finally , we notice that ode is equivalent to : for all @xmath327 @xmath369 combining this equation with the previous one on @xmath370 leads to * c)*. note that condition @xmath367 is needed for the convective term to vanish through integration by parts . .
we first prove that @xmath360 is well - defined from @xmath361 to @xmath248 ; \ : \mbox{span}(e_1,\dots , e_n))$ ] for any @xmath63 and @xmath337 .
the only thing to check is the continuity of matrices @xmath355 and @xmath356 in with respect to time , which will guarantee the existence of a solution to the linear ode . as @xmath203 belongs to @xmath248 ;
l^p(\omega))$ ] for all finite @xmath256 , so does @xmath353 , and @xmath355 is clearly continuous .
as regards @xmath356 , the only difficult terms are @xmath371 we remind that the propagator @xmath372 associated to @xmath187 satisfies @xmath373 ^ 2 ; \ , c^\infty_{loc}({{\mathbb r}}^3)\right)\ ] ] hence , a look at the construction of @xmath301 , _ cf _ corollary [ coroconnection ] and proposition [ constructionvn ] ( see also lemma [ lemmaw ] in the appendix [ app_lemmawn ] ) , yields @xmath374 ; h^1_\sigma({{\mathbb r}}^3)).\ ] ] it implies that @xmath375 is continuous .
as regards @xmath376 , we change variables to go back to a fixed domain .
we set @xmath97 to obtain @xmath377 where @xmath378 and where @xmath379 is the tangential jacobian .
see ( * ? ? ?
* lemme 5.4.1 ) for details .
as @xmath380 is continuous in @xmath3 and smooth in @xmath17 , we obtain that @xmath381 is continuous . . here
, we need to restrict to small @xmath63 .
more precisely , we fix @xmath382 , and consider a time @xmath63 such that @xmath383 _ let us prove that such time @xmath63 does exist and can be chosen uniformly with respect to @xmath179 and @xmath144 . _ for all @xmath358 , we write @xmath384 with @xmath217 the propagator associated to the rigid field @xmath385 defined in .
it is enough that @xmath386 } | { { \partial}}_t \phi_{t,0}(t , y ) |
< \frac{\mbox{dist}(s_0 , { { \partial}}\omega ) - 2 \delta}{t } , \quad t \in [ 0,t ] , \quad y \in s_0.\ ] ] we find @xmath387 using that the propagator is isometric . moreover , classical calculations yield @xmath388 we can then use the inequality @xmath389 where for instance @xmath390 eventually , any @xmath391 will satisfy .
let now @xmath43 be arbitrary in @xmath361 .
thanks to , we have that @xmath392 $ ] satisfies @xmath393 , and @xmath394 mutiplying by @xmath395 , integrating in time , and combining with the last transport equation , we obtain the energy estimate @xmath396 as @xmath397 , we deduce easily that @xmath398 for @xmath399 large enough . hence , @xmath173 sends @xmath361 to itself . for any @xmath400 , we get from equation : @xmath401 integrating with respect to time , we obtain @xmath386 } \left ( |\tilde\alpha(t)| + |\frac{d}{dt}\tilde\alpha(t)| \right ) \ : \le \ : c'\ ] ] ( where the constant at the r.h.s .
may depend on @xmath179 or @xmath144 ) .
in other words , @xmath402 ; \ : \mbox{span}(e_1,\dots , e_n ) ) } \ : \le \ : c''\ ] ] which provides compactness in @xmath361 by ascoli s theorem .
let @xmath403 a sequence in @xmath361 , such that @xmath404 in @xmath361 ( that is uniformly over @xmath219 $ ] ) .
we want to show that @xmath405 in @xmath361 .
first , we note that , as @xmath406 is a finite - dimensional subspace of @xmath407 we have that @xmath408 converges to @xmath43 in @xmath248 ; \mathcal{d}_{\sigma}(\bar{\omega})).$ ] then , we use proposition [ strongcontinuity ] . with obvious notations , @xmath409 ; l^p_{loc}({{\mathbb r}}^3 ) ) \ : ( p < \infty),\ ] ] as well as @xmath410 from there , and the construction of @xmath301 ( corollary [ coroconnection ] , proposition [ constructionvn ] , lemma [ lemmawn ] in appendix [ app_lemmawn ] ) , it is easy to see that @xmath411 ; h^1_{\sigma}({{\mathbb r}}^3)).\ ] ] by slightly adapting the arguments of step 1 , one can then show that the matrices in satisfy @xmath412).\ ] ] from classical results for ode s , it follows that @xmath413 ; \ : \mbox{span}(e_1,\dots , e_n)).\ ] ] for the sake of brevity , we leave the details to the reader . in the previous paragraph , we have built for each @xmath414 a solution @xmath415 ( denoted @xmath334 for brevity ) of * a)-d)*. it is defined on @xmath219 $ ] for some time @xmath63 uniform in @xmath338 , satisfying . the next step is to let @xmath179 go to infinity , to recover a solution @xmath164 of * a)-d)*. we remind the uniform energy estimate ( see ) @xmath416 it yields that @xmath417 the bound in @xmath0 follows from the @xmath418 bound on @xmath419 and korn s inequality , see @xcite .
from there , we will be able to show strong convergence both in the transport equation * d ) * and in the momentum equation * c)*. as regards the transport equation , we rely on proposition [ weakcontinuity ] .
up to a subsequence , one has @xmath420 for some @xmath421 , and it follows from this proposition that @xmath422 ; l^p_{loc}({{\mathbb r}}^3 ) ) \ : ( p < \infty),\ ] ] as well as @xmath423 \phi^n \rightarrow \phi \quad & \mbox { weakly * in } & \ : w^{1,\infty}((0,t)^2 ; c^\infty_{loc}({{\mathbb r}}^3))\ , , \quad \mbox { strongly in } \ : c([0,t ] ; c^\infty_{loc}({{\mathbb r}}^3))\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] up to another extraction .
we stress again that all limits depend on @xmath144 .
it remains to study the convergence of equation * c)*. therefore , we fix the test function : we take @xmath424 for some fixed @xmath425 .
the point is to obtain as @xmath426 the limit equation * c ) * , still with @xmath427 .
but as @xmath425 is arbitrary , and as @xmath320 is a basis of @xmath142 , standard density arguments will allow to extend the formulation to general test functions . at first
, we need to prove that , @xmath428 \vert_{\omega } \quad \mbox { in } \ : l^2(0,t;h^1_\sigma(\omega)).\ ] ] it is enough to prove that @xmath429 \ : \rightarrow \ : \hat{v } \ : : = \ : v^{\delta}[e_\omega u , p_s u]\ ] ] weakly in @xmath430 . in view of corollary [ coroconnection ] and proposition [ constructionvn ] ,
it is an easy consequence of lemma [ lemmawn ] .
we are now ready to handle the asymptotics of * c ) * ( with @xmath431 ) .
as before , for the sake of brevity , we focus on the two most difficult terms , those which involve @xmath432 as regards @xmath433 , once again we change variables to go back to a fixed domain .
we obtain @xmath434 where @xmath435 and where @xmath436 let @xmath437 , resp .
@xmath438 to which we associate @xmath439 , resp .
@xmath440 through the change of coordinates : @xmath441 from the weak convergence of @xmath334 , we deduce that @xmath442 converges weakly in @xmath443 given the strong convergence of @xmath444 in @xmath248;l^p(\omega))$ ] we also have that @xmath445 converges strongly to @xmath446 in @xmath447 . furthermore , as @xmath448 is an isometric mapping for all @xmath179 , we get that : @xmath449 where , because of lemma [ lemmawn ] : @xmath450 with obvious notations .
this yields corresponding weak and strong convergences of the traces of these functions on @xmath451 having in mind that @xmath452 for all @xmath179 , and going back to the moving domain , we obtain easily that @xmath453 converges weakly in @xmath90 to : @xmath454 we finally turn to the convergence of @xmath455 for which we will need some compactness on @xmath456 therefore , we introduce some notations : we denote by @xmath457 the orthogonal projection from @xmath126 onto @xmath458 respectively @xmath459 the orthogonal projection from @xmath126 onto @xmath460 .
we also remind that our strong , resp .
weak , convergence results on @xmath370 , resp .
@xmath334 imply that .
@xmath461 in particular , we have for any fixed @xmath462 : @xmath463 moreover , equation * c ) * can be written : for all @xmath464 , @xmath465^*\right)\ ] ] where @xmath466^*)\right)$ ] is defined by the duality relation : @xmath467 we remind that for @xmath468^*$ ] , @xmath459 is defined by duality : @xmath469 . from the above expression for @xmath470 and
the various bounds already obtained , it is easily seen that for any fixed @xmath462 , @xmath471 is bounded ( in @xmath179 ) in @xmath472^*)$ ] .
hence , the same conclusion applies to @xmath473 . combining with
, it follows that for any fixed @xmath462 , @xmath474^ * ) \ : \mbox{as } \ :
n \to \infty.\ ] ] now , we note that , for arbitrary @xmath462 and @xmath475 and a.a .
@xmath476 there holds @xmath477^ * } & = & \sup_{\|\varphi\|_{[h^1_{\sigma}(\omega ) ] } = 1 } \int_{\omega } \left(p(\rho^n u^n(t ) ) - p_k ( \rho^n u^n)(t)]\right ) \varphi\\ & = & \sup_{\|\varphi\|_{[h^1_{\sigma}(\omega ) ] } = 1 } \int_{\omega } \rho^n u^n(t ) ( \varphi - p_k \varphi ) \\ & \leq & \left [ \sup_{\|\varphi\|_{[h^1_{\sigma}(\omega ) ] } = 1 } \|\varphi - p_k \varphi\|_{l^2(\omega ) } \right ] \|\rho^n u^n\|_{l^\infty l^2(\omega)}\,,\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] by a standard argument based on rellich lemma , one shows that @xmath478 as @xmath479 . with the uniform bound on @xmath480 in @xmath481 , we can conclude that @xmath482^ * ) , \quad \mbox { as $ k \rightarrow + \infty$ , uniformly in $ n$.}\ ] ] of course , with a similar but simpler estimate , we also have @xmath483^ * ) , \quad \mbox { as $ k \rightarrow + \infty$.}\ ] ] combining , and , we obtain finally that : @xmath484 converges to @xmath485 strongly in @xmath486^*).$ ] combining this strong convergence with the weak convergence of @xmath487 in @xmath488 we might apply the method of p.l .
lions @xcite with the duality bracket @xmath489^*-h^1_{\sigma}(\omega ) $ ] to prove that @xmath490 converges to @xmath491 strongly in @xmath138 .
finally , we rewrite : @xmath492 where : * @xmath490 converges to @xmath491 strongly in @xmath138 * @xmath493 converges to @xmath494 strongly in @xmath495 * @xmath496 converges to @xmath497 weakly in @xmath498 ( thanks to the imbedding @xmath499 ) . combining these statements
, we get that @xmath500 converges to @xmath501 ( with obvious notations ) weakly in @xmath502 such convergences result yield that @xmath503 satisfy * c ) * for test functions @xmath105 of the form @xmath504 with @xmath505 and @xmath506 via a classical density argument , the convergence extends to all @xmath507 such that @xmath152 .
we end this section by proving that the approximate solution @xmath503 satisfies the further estimate : @xmath508 for almost all @xmath66.$ ] for simplicity we drop exponent @xmath144 in what follows .
first , we note that the solutions @xmath509 of the galerkin scheme satisfy uniformly in @xmath179 and that , up to the extraction of a subsequence @xmath510 converges to @xmath511 in @xmath512 hence , we may pass to the limit in for almost all @xmath66\,.$ ] on the other hand , there holds : * by construction of the galerkin scheme , @xmath513 in @xmath126 so that : @xmath514 * given the strong convergence of @xmath487 in @xmath138 : @xmath515 * given the weak convergence of @xmath334 in @xmath516 and the strong convergence of @xmath517 in @xmath248;l^p(\omega))$ ] we get that @xmath518 converges weakly to @xmath519 in @xmath520 in particular , in the weak limit , there holds : @xmath521 with similar arguments , we obtain : @xmath522 * finally , we pass to the limit in the boundary terms .
first , we introduce @xmath523 and @xmath524 associated to the extension @xmath525 $ ] and the rigid vector field @xmath526 respectively , computed through the change of variable @xmath527 as previously , we have : @xmath528 because of the weak convergence of @xmath334 and @xmath529 in @xmath530 we have that @xmath523 and @xmath531 converge also weakly in @xmath532 ( see lemma [ lemmawn ] ) . hence , we have also weak convergence of the traces on @xmath533 the lower semi - continuity of the @xmath418-norm on @xmath534 yields : @xmath535 similar weak - convergence and semi - continuity arguments yield also : @xmath536 this ends the proof of .
in the previous section , we have obtained the existence of solutions @xmath164 of approximate fluid - solid systems , namely satisfying * a)*-*d)*. these solutions @xmath164 are defined on some ( uniform in @xmath144 ) time interval @xmath537 such that @xmath538 we must now study the asymptotics of @xmath164 as @xmath144 goes to infinity , and recover a weak solution at the limit . in what follows , we will often make use of the notation @xmath539 for @xmath41 an open set and @xmath540 .
the density @xmath541 clearly satisfies the uniform bound @xmath542 combining and yields that @xmath543 for some constant @xmath544 depending only on @xmath545 , @xmath546 and @xmath547 .
in particular , up to a subsequence , the first inequality gives @xmath548 we can then pass to the limit of the transport equation * d ) * , using proposition [ weakcontinuity ] .
the following convergence holds up to a subsequence : @xmath270 ; l^p_{loc}({{\mathbb r}}^3 ) ) \ : ( p < \infty),\ ] ] with @xmath549 for an isometric propagator @xmath550 .
moreover , one has @xmath551 in particular , one recovers the transport equation setting @xmath552 .
now , we can combine the second inequality in , that yields @xmath553 with the strong ( resp .
weak ) convergence of @xmath168 ( resp .
@xmath164 and @xmath167 ) .
as @xmath144 goes to infinity , we derive easily : @xmath554 finally , the last inequality in and korn s inequality imply that @xmath555 we then introduce continuous extension operators @xmath556 in the spirit of corollary [ lemmamollified ] . as long as the @xmath557 are @xmath558 away from @xmath35 ,
it is standard to construct these extension operators in such a way that @xmath559.\ ] ] hence , if we set @xmath560 , we have that @xmath561 from the @xmath562 bound , we can assume up to another extraction that @xmath563 from above equality and from the strong convergence of @xmath168 , we then get : @xmath564 eventually , considering relations and , we get that the limit @xmath43 of @xmath164 belongs to @xmath565 . hence , back to the definition of a weak solution , it only remains to show that the momentum equation is satisfied by @xmath566 .
prior to the analysis of the momentum equation , we must establish some refined estimates on the _ connecting velocity _ @xmath163 .
we remind that @xmath163 was defined in lagrangian like coordinates , see paragraph [ mollified ] .
more precisely , @xmath567 \right),\ ] ] where @xmath568 and @xmath569 $ ] is some linear operator connecting @xmath570 to @xmath571 over a band of width @xmath143 outside @xmath27 : see corollary [ coroconnection ] .
we shall here specify our choice for the operator @xmath318 . actually
, we shall make it depend on @xmath572 ( @xmath319 ) , in order for the following additional assumption to be satisfied : @xmath573 - u \|_{l^p((s_0)_\delta \setminus s_0 ) } \le c_{\delta , p } \left ( \| ( u - u_s ) \cdot \nu
\|_{l^p({{\partial}}s_0 ) } + n^{1/6 - 1/p } \| ( u , u_s)\|_{h^1((s_0)_\delta \setminus s_0 ) } \right),\\ \quad \forall \,2 \le p \le 6 .
\end{gathered}\ ] ] we postpone the construction of such operator @xmath574 to the end of the paragraph .
back to @xmath163 , the additional assumption implies easily that for all @xmath575 , @xmath576 but we know that @xmath577 where the last bound comes from the second inequality in .
we emphasize here that , as the @xmath557 s are all isometric to one another , the constant @xmath544 does not depend on @xmath578 .
interpolation with the similar other bound @xmath579 & \:\le\ : & c \displaystyle{\int_0^t } \left ( \| u^n \|_{h^1(f^n(t))}^2 \ : + \ : \| u^n \|^2_{l^2(s^n(t ) ) } \right ) \ , dt \ : \le \ : c \end{array}\label{unn2 } \end{gathered}\ ] ] yields that @xmath580 eventually , we get that @xmath581 this will be much important in the treatment of the nonlinear terms .
we conclude this paragraph with the construction of the operator @xmath574 satisfying .
we take @xmath582 in @xmath583 .
up to an extension of @xmath213 , there is no loss of generality assuming that @xmath584 .
we shall construct a field @xmath238 such that @xmath585 = 0 , @xmath586 therefore , we introduce a system of orthogonal curvilinear coordinates @xmath587 in a tubular neighborhood of @xmath588 : @xmath589 are coordinates along the surface @xmath588 , whereas @xmath590 denotes a transverse coordinate . in particular , @xmath591 .
we set @xmath592 the associated orthonormal vectors , with scale factors @xmath593 .
we remind that @xmath594 for a scalar function @xmath595 , whereas @xmath596 for any field @xmath597 .
we then set @xmath598 \ ,
e_z ) \ ] ] for a smooth truncation function @xmath599 $ ] equal to @xmath600 in a neighborhood of @xmath62 . clearly , for all @xmath601 , and @xmath602 , @xmath603 also , @xmath604 satisfies . but
it is not divergence - free : formula yields @xmath605 e_z ) \ ] ] so that for all @xmath606 , @xmath607 to obtain a divergence - free field , we note that both @xmath304 and @xmath213 have zero flux through @xmath534 and ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 3.1 ) : there exists a field @xmath608 such that @xmath609 and for all @xmath6101,2]$ ] , @xmath611 in particular , by sobolev imbedding , one has for all @xmath612 @xmath613 finally , the field @xmath614 fulfills our requirements .
we construct a field @xmath615 such that @xmath616 = 0 , @xmath617 \
, \nu , \quad \mbox { and } \ : w\vert_{{{\partial}}(s_0)_\delta } = 0.\ ] ] in the same spirit as in the first step , we take @xmath618 \ , e_z\ ] ] where @xmath619 is again a truncation function : @xmath620 near @xmath62 , and @xmath621 outside @xmath622 $ ] .
a rapid computation shows that @xmath623 by proposition [ bogovski ] , there exists a field @xmath624 such that @xmath625 and @xmath626 in particular , by sobolev imbedding , one has for all @xmath601 @xmath627 finally , the field @xmath628 fulfills our requirements .
eventually , we set @xmath629 \ : & = \ : u \ : \mbox { outside } \ : ( s_0)_\delta , \\ v^\delta[u , u_s ] \ : & = \ : v - w \ : \mbox { in } \ : ( s_0)_\delta \setminus s_0 , \\ v^\delta[u ,
u_s ] \ : & = u_s \ : \mbox { in } \ : s_0 .
\end{aligned } \right.\ ] ] combining , , and leads to .
the weak formulation of the momentum equation involves discontinuous test functions @xmath57 : @xmath630 with @xmath631 on the contrary , the approximate momentum equation * c ) * involves continuous ( or at least @xmath0 ) test functions .
hence , we will have to approach @xmath632 by a sequence @xmath633 in @xmath634 . due to the discontinuity of the limit
, the @xmath635 s will exhibit strong gradients near @xmath636 .
precise estimates are needed , that are the purpose of [ approximatetest ] let @xmath637 .
there exists a sequence @xmath638 in @xmath639 , of the form @xmath640 that satisfies * @xmath641 ; l^p(\omega ) ) } = o(n^{-\alpha / p})$ ] for all @xmath642 $ ] . * @xmath643 ; l^6(\omega))$ ] . * @xmath644 ; h^1(\omega ) ) } = o(n^{\alpha/2})$ ] .
* @xmath645 . *
@xmath646 . .
the point is to build a good approximation @xmath647 of @xmath648 over the solid domain .
broadly , we want @xmath649 and @xmath650 therefore , we proceed as for @xmath163 , by using lagrangian coordinates : we define @xmath651 and @xmath652 through the formulas @xmath653 and the goal is to define properly some @xmath654 , related to @xmath647 by the formula @xmath655 _ note that @xmath651 and @xmath652 depend on @xmath144 through the propagator @xmath265 , but we omit it from our notations . _ the only thing we have to keep in mind is that the bounds on @xmath265 guarantee that @xmath651 and @xmath652 are uniformly bounded in @xmath656 for all @xmath657 thanks to the change of coordinates , the problem is now in the fixed domain @xmath27 .
roughly , we want to build @xmath654 in such a way that @xmath658 and @xmath659 note that time is only a parameter in the system .
the construction of @xmath654 follows the one of @xmath238 , performed in the previous paragraph , step 1 .
we take @xmath654 under the form @xmath660 the first term has the explicit form @xmath661 \ , e_z \right).\ ] ] again , @xmath619 is a smooth truncation function near @xmath62 , and @xmath590 is a coordinate transverse to the boundary : @xmath591 .
it is easily seen that @xmath662 satisfies the right boundary condition at @xmath588 .
moreover , @xmath663 but it is not divergence - free . by applying formula
, we get @xmath664 \ , e_z \right)\right).\ ] ] in particular ,
@xmath665 is uniformly bounded in @xmath666 by proposition [ bogovski ] , there exists some field @xmath667 satisfying @xmath668 and @xmath669 in particular , @xmath670 back to the moving domain ( in variable @xmath17 ) , one can combine the estimates -- with the uniform bound on @xmath265 in @xmath671 .
from there , one can deduce the estimates of the proposition .
for the sake of brevity , we only treat the two last items .
namely , we write @xmath672 where the last inequality involves and . this bound implies in turn that @xmath673 the products at the r.h.s .
are then easily handled using the strong convergence of @xmath168 ( and the weak convergence of @xmath167 ) .
we obtain @xmath674 as expected .
this concludes the proof of the proposition .
we now have all the elements to study the asymptotics of the approximate momentum equation * c)*. given an arbitrary @xmath57 , we consider an approximate sequence @xmath638 as in proposition [ approximatetest ] .
we shall take @xmath185 as a test function in * c ) * , and let @xmath144 tend to infinity , so as to recover .
we shall rely on the fields @xmath675 and @xmath5 introduced in paragraph [ aprioribounds ] .
we remind that @xmath676 to lighten notations , we shall write @xmath677 , @xmath678 . we remind that these rigid fields satisfy @xmath679 in this paragraph , we consider the asymptotics of all terms but the convection one . *
we write the diffusion term as : @xmath680 from the strong convergence of @xmath168 to @xmath203 in @xmath248 ; l^p(\omega))$ ] , and the weak convergence of @xmath675 to @xmath5 in @xmath562 , we deduce @xmath681 as regards @xmath682 , we use the bounds @xmath683 established in the previous paragraphs .
they imply @xmath684 if we choose @xmath685 , then @xmath682 goes to zero as @xmath144 goes to infinity , and finally @xmath686 * the boundary term at @xmath35 reads @xmath687 by the weak convergence of @xmath675 in @xmath688 .
* we deal with the boundary term at @xmath183 as in the galerkin approximation .
we introduce @xmath689 @xmath690 and capital letters to denote velocity fields when seen through the change of variable .
we then have , as in the computation for the galerkin method : @xmath691 where we used that @xmath692 we note here that @xmath185 converges to @xmath105 in @xmath248;l^6(\omega))$ ] so that combining with the strong convergence of @xmath168 it yields that @xmath693 converges to @xmath694 in @xmath695 through the change of variable , lemma [ lemmawn ] yields that : @xmath696 then , we combine the respective convergences of @xmath697 with lemma [ lemmawn ] yielding , with obvious notations : @xmath698 we apply these convergences together with the continuity of traces on @xmath699 and go back to the moving geometry , to obtain finally : @xmath700 * to treat the penalization term we use the bounds @xmath701 ; l^6(\omega ) ) } = o(n^{-\alpha/2})\ ] ] established in the previous paragraph .
we also remind that @xmath648 , as a rigid vector field , satisfies @xmath702 .
from there , @xmath703 if we choose @xmath704 ( which is compatible with the former constraint @xmath705 ) , the penalization term vanishes as @xmath184 . to show that @xmath707 is a weak solution over @xmath537
, we still have to pass to the limit in the convection term @xmath708 to compute this limit , we first prove [ prop_strongcvgce ] up to the extraction of a subsequence , @xmath706 converges to @xmath43 in @xmath512 this result is obtained applying the method introduced in the reference ( see also @xcite for the 3d case ) .
we first introduce some notations . given @xmath709 and @xmath33 a bounded connected subset @xmath710 , we denote @xmath711 \ : = \ : \mbox { the closure of } \ : \ { v \in h^1_{\sigma}(\omega ) \ : \text { such that } v_{|_{s } } \in \mathcal{r}\ } \ , \ : \text{in } \ : h^s(\omega).\ ] ] as @xmath712 $ ] is a closed subspace of @xmath713 we denote @xmath714 $ ] the orthogonal projector from @xmath713 onto this subspace . given @xmath715 we recall that @xmath716 $ ] is a dense subspace of @xmath717\,,$ ] and that the imbbeding @xmath716 \subset \mathcal{r}^{s}[s]$ ] is compact .
if @xmath718 we shall drop exponent @xmath719 .
we emphasize that in the case @xmath720 the projector @xmath721 $ ] does not coincide with the @xmath722 introduced in .
our first step is the following approximation lemma : [ lemvhbar ] let @xmath723 . *
the sequence @xmath724 is uniformly bounded in @xmath725 .
moreover , there is @xmath726 such that for all @xmath727 , @xmath728 \ , u^n(t,\cdot)\|^2_{h^s(\omega ) } \ : \leq \ : c \left(h^{{\varepsilon}}\ , + \ , n^{-{{\varepsilon } } } \right).\ ] ] * one has @xmath729 .
moreover , there exists @xmath730 such that for all @xmath727 , @xmath731 \ , u(t,\cdot)\|^2_{h^s(\omega)}\text{d$t$ } \ : \leq \ : c h^{{\varepsilon}},\ ] ] where , in both cases , the constant @xmath544 depends only on initial data .
_ proof of the lemma .
_ we only prove the first item of the lemma , the second one being simpler .
it relies on the construction of a suitable approximation @xmath732 of @xmath164 , rigid in a @xmath733-neighborhood of @xmath165 .
this approximation will satisfy the following properties : * @xmath734 is bounded in @xmath725 for @xmath719 small enough * @xmath735 in @xmath736 and @xmath737 outside @xmath738 for a.a .
@xmath476 . + note that it implies @xmath739 $ ] for a.a .
@xmath476 . * for @xmath733 sufficiently small and for a.a
@xmath740 there holds @xmath741 before giving further details on the construction of @xmath732 we explain how the previous properties imply lemma [ eq_hbarun ] .
by interpolation of and , we obtain @xmath742 we square the inequalities in and integrate from @xmath62 to @xmath63 . using with the uniform bounds , we end up with @xmath743 moreover , @xmath744 using , we get @xmath745 combining this last inequality with the first inequality in yields @xmath746
as regards the @xmath747 norm , @xmath748 , we use the second inequality in to write @xmath749 finally , we have @xmath750 we end up with @xmath751 one last interpolation between and shows that for all @xmath752 and @xmath726 , @xmath753 as @xmath754 belongs to @xmath755 $ ] for all @xmath3 , by definition of the projection , the same inequality holds replacing @xmath732 by @xmath756 $ ] , as expected .
we still have to achieve the construction of @xmath757 .
it follows the construction of @xmath163 , _ cf _ paragraph [ aprioriboundsv ] .
it is actually simpler , because we only look for a @xmath732 with @xmath747 regularity for small @xmath719 .
in particular , jump on the tangential part at @xmath758 and @xmath759 will be allowed . as before
, we go back to lagrangian coordinates : we look for a @xmath732 under the form @xmath760 also , we define @xmath761 and @xmath762 through @xmath763 in this way , we are back to a static problem . _ for brevity , we shall omit temporarily the time dependence in our notations_. the point is to build a field @xmath764 satisfying @xmath765 and suitable estimates .
therefore , we follow paragraph [ aprioriboundsv ]
. we parametrize @xmath766 by curvilinear coordinates @xmath587 , @xmath590 being the distance at @xmath534 .
hence , @xmath767 then , we introduce @xmath768 \ , e_z ) \ ] ] and the solution @xmath769 of @xmath770 v^n_{h,2 } & = & 0 & \text { on $ \partial ( s_0)_{\delta}$ and $ \partial ( s_0)_{h}$ } \end{array } \right.\ ] ] computations similar to those of paragraph [ aprioriboundsv ] yield : @xmath771 let us emphasize that the constant @xmath544 in the last inequality can be chosen uniformly in @xmath733 , see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem iii.3.1 ) .
it follows by interpolation that @xmath772 finally , we build some @xmath773 where @xmath774 is the unique solution of : @xmath775 we recall that @xmath776 on @xmath777 by standard elliptic regularity results , there exists a constant @xmath544 independent of @xmath733 such that : @xmath778 by interpolation , we get @xmath779 now , we write @xmath780 eventually , we set @xmath781 . we stress that the normal component of @xmath782 is continuous across @xmath783 and @xmath784 . hence , for any @xmath785 , the @xmath747 norm of @xmath764 over the whole domain is controlled by the sum of the @xmath747 norms over @xmath786 , @xmath787 and @xmath788 , where @xmath789 is a shorthand for @xmath790 .
it follows from this remark and the previous inequalities that : for all @xmath791 @xmath792 also , one has @xmath793 back to the moving domain , and accouting for time dependence , we obtain . the second step in the treatment of the nonlinear terms
is a control of the hausdorff distance between @xmath557 and @xmath794 for close times @xmath795 $ ] .
this is the purpose of [ lemmahausdorff ] let @xmath796 .
i ) : : there exists @xmath797 such that for all @xmath798 , @xmath799.\ ] ] ii ) : : there exists @xmath540 such that for all @xmath800 $ ] , for all @xmath801 \cap [ 0,t]$ ] @xmath802 note that condition and point i ) of the lemma ( applied with @xmath803 ) imply that @xmath804 , \quad \mbox { for some fixed } \ : \delta > 0.\ ] ] _ proof of the lemma_. we first treat * i ) * , focusing on the first inclusion ( the other one is proved in the same way ) . to this end , we recall that the associated sequence of characteristic functions @xmath805 converges to @xmath203 in @xmath248 ; l^1(\omega)).$ ] this implies that @xmath386 } |s^n(t ) \ : \triangle \ : s(t)| = \sup_{t \in [ 0,t ] } \|\chi_s^n(t,\cdot ) - \chi_s(t,\cdot)\|_{l^1(\omega ) } \to 0 \text { when $ n \to \infty$}\,,\ ] ] where we denoted @xmath806 the symmetric difference of subsets of @xmath807 let us now take @xmath808 and assume _ a contrario _ that there exists a sequence of times @xmath809 $ ] and of integers @xmath810 going to infinity such that @xmath811 as @xmath812 is isometric to @xmath27 , which satisfies : @xmath813 there exists for all @xmath462 a ball @xmath814 with radius @xmath815 such that @xmath816 so that @xmath386 } |s^{n_k}(t ) \ : \triangle \ : s(t)| \geq \dfrac{4\pi |r'|^3}{3}\,,\ ] ] which yields a contradiction
. consequently , there exists @xmath817 such that , for all @xmath818 @xmath819 .\ ] ] the second item * ii ) * is obtained in the same way .
let @xmath820 and assume for instance that the first inclusion does not hold .
arguing as previously , we are able to construct two sequences @xmath821 and @xmath822 converging both to @xmath800 $ ] and such that @xmath823 contains a ball of fixed radius . once again
, this contradicts the continuity in @xmath824 of @xmath203 at @xmath825 thanks to the previous lemmas , we can conclude the proof of proposition [ prop_strongcvgce ] , following very closely . at first
, very minor adaptation of the proof of yields : _ for @xmath826 there exists @xmath827 , such that , for all @xmath828 : @xmath829 u^n = \int_0^{t } \int_{\omega } \rho u \cdot p^{s}[(s(t))_h ] u.\ ] ] _ we remind that the main idea behind this limit is the following : thanks to lemma [ lemmahausdorff ] , for any field @xmath830 , the projected field @xmath831(\xi)$ ] is rigid in a neighborhood of @xmath557 for @xmath144 large enough .
hence , if one uses @xmath831(\xi)$ ] as a test function in the momentum equation , the boundary term at @xmath832 and the penalization term vanish : roughly , one recovers a uniform bound on @xmath833 ( \rho^n u^n)$ ] in a sobolev space of negative index , and from there compactness . for all details , see .
then , one establishes that @xmath834
@xmath835 the idea is to write @xmath836(u^n ) - \int_0^{t } \int_{\omega } \rho u \cdot p^{s}[(s(t))_h](u ) \right ) \\ & \quad + \int_0^t \int_\omega \rho^n u^n \cdot ( u^n - p^s[s(t)_h ] u^n ) dt \ : + \ : \int_0^t \int_\omega \rho u \cdot ( p^s[s(t)_h ] u - u ) dt\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first term at the r.h.s .
is controlled using , whereas the last two are treated thanks to lemma [ prop_strongcvgce ] : note that @xmath837 for @xmath144 large enough by lemma [ lemmahausdorff ] , so that @xmath838 \ , u^n(t,\cdot)\|^2_{h^s(\omega)}\ : & \le \ : \int_0^t \|u^n(t,\cdot ) - p^s[(s^n(t))_{2h } ] \ , u^n(t,\cdot)\|^2_{h^s(\omega ) } \\ & \ : \leq \ : c \left(h^{{\varepsilon}}\ , + \ , n^{-{{\varepsilon } } } \right ) .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] the final step of the proof consists in showing that @xmath839 which yields the strong compactness of @xmath164 ( @xmath353 having positive lower and upper bounds ) .
the idea here is to write @xmath840 the first term at the r.h.s .
goes to zero by . for the second one
, we use that @xmath841 strongly in @xmath842;l^p(\omega))$ ] for all finite @xmath256 and that @xmath843 is uniformly bounded in @xmath844 for some @xmath845 , thanks to the uniform @xmath747 bound on @xmath164 .
again , we refer to for all details .
thanks to the strong convergence of proposition [ prop_strongcvgce ] , we are now able to split @xmath846 in a suitable way .
let us first remind that @xmath163 is identically equal to @xmath847 inside @xmath165 , whereas @xmath185 is identically equal to @xmath848 outside @xmath165 .
this allows us to decompose the convection term as follows : @xmath849 the convergence of @xmath850 is clear : @xmath851 the convergence of @xmath852 follows from the fourth item in proposition [ approximatetest ] , which clearly implies that @xmath853 using the strong convergence of @xmath854 to @xmath855 in @xmath856 , it is then easily shown that @xmath857 now , we write the second term at the r.h.s . as @xmath858 as @xmath648 is a rigid vector field .
it remains to study @xmath859 .
we know from paragraph [ aprioriboundsv ] that @xmath860 it follows that @xmath861 in this last identity we collect the strong convergences of @xmath164 to @xmath43 in @xmath138 and of @xmath168 to @xmath619 in @xmath862;l^{15}(\omega)),$ ] together with the uniform regularity of @xmath863 in @xmath864 ( see lemma [ lemvhbar ] ) , which yields that @xmath865 are uniformly bounded in @xmath866 we obtain then : @xmath867 this concludes our proof .
we pass to the weak limit in and prove that the solution @xmath868 satisfies the further energy estimate .
first , we note that implies @xmath869 for all @xmath870 as we have convergence of @xmath871 in @xmath872 we can pass to the weak limit in this inequality for almost all @xmath66.$ ] as @xmath23 remains far from @xmath873 we treat boundary terms in a similar way as in paragraph [ sec_nrjin ] . the only term which requires a new treatment is : @xmath874 for this term
, we note that , because of lemma [ lemmahausdorff ] , there holds for arbitrary @xmath808 and @xmath144 sufficiently large : @xmath875 if we let @xmath144 go to infinity , and then @xmath733 go to @xmath62 , we obtain : @xmath876 for almost all @xmath66.$ ] hence , passing to the limit in yields .
our solutions are limited in time to avoid collision .
namely , the only shortcoming of our construction is that it requires the distance between @xmath23 and @xmath873 to be larger than a fixed positive distance @xmath143 through time .
however , as long as we are given an initial data @xmath877 and an initial position @xmath27 such that @xmath878 we are able to construct a small time @xmath63 depending only on the inital position of @xmath27 in @xmath32 and the @xmath418 norm of @xmath546 such that the solution exists and satisfies this property on @xmath219.$ ] as our solutions satisfy also energy estimate we might reproduce the arguments of ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 2.2 ) to concatenate solutions in time and prove existence of at least one weak solution until collision time . 99 g. barnocky and r. h. davis . the influence of pressure - dependent density and viscosity on the elastohydrodynamic collision and rebound of two spheres . , 209:501519 , 1989 . achieving large slip with superhydrophobic surfaces : scaling laws for generic geometries 19 , 123601 ( 2007 ) . c. bost , g .- h .
cottet , and e. maitre .
convergence analysis of a penalization method for the three - dimensional motion of a rigid body in an incompressible viscous fluid .
, 48(4):13131337 , 2010 .
h. brenner et r. g. cox . the resistance to a particle of arbitrary shape in translational motion at small reynolds numbers .
( 1963 ) , 561595 . m. cooley and m. oneill . on the slow motion generated in a viscous fluid by the approach of a sphere to a plane wall or stationary sphere .
, 16:3749 , 1969 .
r. h. davis , j. serayssol , and e. hinch .
the elastohydrodynamic collision of two spheres .
, 163:045302 , 2006 .
r. h. davis , y. zhao , k. p. galvin , and h. j. wilson .
solid - solid contacts due to surface roughness and their effects on suspension behaviour . , 361(1806):871894 , 2003 .
b. desjardins et m. j. esteban , existence of weak solutions for the motion of rigid bodies in a viscous fluid .
( 1999 ) , 5971 .
r. j. diperna et p .-
l . lions .
ordinary differential equations , transport theory and sobolev spaces .
( 1989 ) , 511547 .
e. feireisl . on the motion of rigid bodies in a viscous incompressible fluid . ,
* 3 * ( 2003 ) , 419441 .
g. p. galdi . .
springer monographs in mathematics .
springer , new york , second edition , 2011 . steady - state problems .
m. hillairet et d. grard - varet .
regularity issues in fluid structure interaction , * 195 * ( 2010 ) , 375407 .
d. grard - varet and m. hillairet .
computation of the drag force on a sphere close to a wall .
the roughness issue . , to appear o. glass and f. sueur .
uniqueness results for weak solutions of two - dimensional fluid - solid systems .
arxiv:1203.2894v1 , march 2012 .
a. henrot and m. pierre variation et optimisation de formes .
une analyse gomtrique ( french ) [ shape variation and optimization .
a geometric analysis ] mathmatiques @xmath879 applications 48 , springer , berlin , 2005 .
m. hillairet .
lack of collision between solid bodies in a 2d incompressible viscous flow .
, * 32 * ( 2007 ) , 13451371 .
m. hillairet et t. takahashi .
collisions in 3d fluid structure interaction problems , * 40 * ( 2009 ) , 24512477 .
l. hocking . the effect of slip on the motion of a sphere close to a wall and of two adjacent sheres .
, 7:207221 , 1973 .
microfluidics : the no - slip boundary condition , c. tropea , a. yarin , j. f. foss ( eds . ) , springer , 2007 .
l . lions . , volume 3 of _ oxford lecture series in mathematics and its applications_. the clarendon press oxford university press , new york , 1996 .
incompressible models , oxford science publications .
c. marchioro and r. pulvirenti . mathematical theory of incompressible nonviscous fluids , applied mathematical sciences vol .
96 , 1994 . on korn s second inequality
. 15 ( 1981 ) , 237348 .
san martn , v. starovoitov , et m. tucsnak .
global weak solutions for the two - dimensional motion of several rigid bodies in an incompressible viscous fluid .
, * 161 * ( 2002 ) , 113147 , 2002 . j. smart and d. leighton .
measurement of the hydrodynamic surface roughness of noncolloidal spheres .
, 1:5260 , 1989 .
v. n. starovoitov .
behavior of a rigid body in an incompressible viscous fluid near a boundary .
in _ free boundary problems ( trento , 2002 ) _ , volume 147 of _ internat . ser .
_ , 313327 .
birkhuser , basel , 2004 . v. n. starovoitov
. nonuniqueness of a solution to the problem on motion of a rigid body in a viscous incompressible fluid . , 130(4):48934898 , 2005 .
g. stokes . on the theories of internal friction of fluids in motion and of the equilibrium and motion of elastic solids , _
_ , * 8 * ( 1845 ) , 287 - 319 .
t. takahashi .
analysis of strong solutions for the equations modeling the motion of a rigid - fluid system in a bounded domain . , * 8 * ( 2003):14991532 .
o. vinogradova and g. yakubov .
surface roughness and hydrodynamic boundary conditions . , 73:479487 , 1986 .
in this appendix , we study the influence of isometric transformations on weak and strong convergence of sequences .
first , we prove : [ lemmawn ] let @xmath890 \times \mathbb r^3 $ ] such that @xmath891 for all @xmath66.$ ] we assume that @xmath892 converges to @xmath217 in @xmath248;c^{\infty}_{loc}(\mathbb r^3)).$ ] given a sequence @xmath893 we define : @xmath894 then , with obvious notations : * if @xmath895 converges to @xmath896 strongly ( resp . weakly ) in @xmath897 then @xmath898 converges to @xmath615 strongly ( resp . weakly ) in @xmath899 * if @xmath895 converges to @xmath896 in @xmath248 ; h^1(\mathbb r^3))$ ] then @xmath898 converges to @xmath615 in @xmath248;h^1(\mathbb r^3)).$ ] * the same assertions hold true replacing @xmath887 by @xmath900 .
_ we point out that @xmath901 and @xmath902 satisfy symmetric relations : @xmath903^{-1}(x)\right)\ : = \ : d[\phi^n_{t}]^{-1}\vert_{x } \ , w^n(t , x),\ ] ] so that fields @xmath904 and @xmath905 , resp . @xmath615 and @xmath896 can be switched in this lemma .
_ proof of lemma [ lemmawn]_. we first remind that @xmath906 is an affine isometry , so that ( for all @xmath907 ) @xmath908^{-1 } \ , m \ , d\phi^n_{t}\vert_{y}\big| = |m| , \quad \forall ( x , y ) \in { { \mathbb r}}^3 \times \mathbb r^3 , \quad \forall m \in m_3({{\mathbb r}}).\ ] ] the same relations hold for @xmath217 instead of @xmath892 . _ strong convergence .
_ we focus on convergence in @xmath248 ; h^1(\mathbb r^3))$ ] , the strong convergence in @xmath909 being treated in the same way .
first , we note that our previous lemma yields : @xmath910;h^1(\mathbb r^3 ) ) \ :
\mbox { for any } n , \quad w \in c([0,t];h^1(\mathbb r^3)).\ ] ] then , we write @xmath911 ; l^2({{\mathbb r}}^3 ) ) } \ : \le \ : \sup_{t } i_1^n(t ) \ : + \sup_{t } \ : i_2^n(t ) \ : + \sup_{t } \ : i_3^n(t)\ ] ] where @xmath912^{-1 } \vert_y \ , w(t , [ \phi_{t}]^{-1 } \circ \phi^n_{t}(y ) ) \right|^2 dy , \ ] ] @xmath913^{-1}\circ d\phi_{t}\vert_y \ , w(t , [ \phi_{t}]^{-1 } \circ \phi^n_{t}(y ) ) - w(t,[\phi_{t}]^{-1 } \circ \phi^n_{t}(y ) ) \right|^2 dy,\ ] ] and @xmath914^{-1 } \circ \phi^n_{t}(y ) ) - w(t , y ) \right|^2 dy .\ ] ] using , we have easily @xmath915 which tends uniformly to @xmath62 when @xmath916 by assumption .
we then get @xmath917^{-1 } \circ \phi^n_{t}(y ) ) \right|^2 dy \\ \ : & \le \ : \sup_{t , y } \left| d\phi^n_{0,t}\circ d\phi_{t,0 } - i_d \right|^2 \| w \|_{c([0,t];h^1(\mathbb r^3 ) ) } \rightarrow 0 .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , the continuity of @xmath615 with values in @xmath918 implies that : @xmath919 can be made arbitrary small uniformly in time , taking @xmath355 sufficiently large .
so , we apply the local convergence of @xmath892 to @xmath217 to obtain that , for @xmath179 sufficiently large , there holds : @xmath920^{-1 } \circ \phi^n_{t}(y ) ) |^2 dy\right)^{1/2 } \ : + \ : \left ( \int_{|y| \ge a } | w(t , y ) |^2 dy \right)^{1/2 } \\ & + \ : \left ( \int_{|y| < a } \left| w(t,[\phi_{t}]^{-1 } \circ \phi^n_{t}(y ) ) - w(t , y ) \right|^2 dy \right)^{1/2 } \\ & \le \ : 2 \left ( \int_0^t \int_{|y| \ge a/2 } | w(t,(y ) ) |^2 \right)^{1/2 } + \ :
\left ( \int_{|y| < a } \left| w(t,[\phi_{t}]^{-1 } \circ \phi^n_{t}(y ) ) - w(t , y ) \right|^2 dy \right)^{1/2 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] the first term at the r.h.s . is independent of @xmath179 and goes to zero as @xmath355 goes to infinity .
moreover , for fixed @xmath355 , @xmath921^{-1 } \circ \phi^n_{t}(y)$ ] converges to @xmath231 uniformly in @xmath219 \times \ { |y| \le a \}$ ] .
hence , for fixed @xmath355 , the second term at the r.h.s .
converges to zero as @xmath179 goes to infinity ( continuity of translations in @xmath418 ) uniformly in @xmath3 .
we conclude that @xmath922 goes to zero , so that @xmath902 converges to @xmath615 in @xmath248 ; l^2({{\mathbb r}}^3))$ ] .
the convergence of @xmath923 to @xmath924 follows the same lines , which yields the result . .
again , we only prove the convergence on @xmath807 the convergence in @xmath900 is similar .
we assume here that @xmath895 converges to @xmath896 in @xmath925 weak .
given @xmath926 there holds : @xmath927^{-1}\vert_x \right)^{-1 } \chi(t,[\phi^n_{t}]^{-1}(x ) ) \ : dt \ : dy\ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we applied again that @xmath928 is a linear isometry .
because of the strong convergence of @xmath892 in @xmath248 ; c^1_{loc}(\mathbb r^3))$ ] there holds : @xmath929^{-1}\vert_x \right)^{-1 } \chi(t,[\phi^n_{t}]^{-1}(x ) ) \to \left(d[\phi_{t}]^{-1}\vert_x \right)^{-1 } \chi(t,[\phi_{t}]^{-1}(x))\text { strongly in $ l^{2}((0,t ) \times \mathbb r^3)$}\ ] ] so that with the weak convergence of @xmath901 we obtain : @xmath930 similar arguments yield also that : @xmath931 which ends the proof . | we study in this paper the movement of a rigid solid inside an incompressible navier - stokes flow , within a bounded domain .
we consider the case where slip is allowed at the fluid / solid interface , through a navier condition .
taking into account slip at the interface is very natural within this model , as classical no - slip conditions lead to unrealistic collisional behavior between the solid and the domain boundary .
we prove for this model existence of weak solutions of leray type , up to collision , in three dimensions .
the key point is that , due to the slip condition , the velocity field is discontinuous across the fluid / solid interface .
this prevents from obtaining global @xmath0 bounds on the velocity , which makes many aspects of the theory of weak solutions for dirichlet conditions inappropriate . |
the mechanical properties of bulk metallic glasses , such as high strength and low ductility , are both of fundamental scientific interest and technological importance @xcite .
it is now well recognized that the plastic deformation of metallic glasses below their glass transition temperature involves irreversible rearrangements of small clusters of atoms @xcite .
the plastic flow of amorphous materials in response to applied shear stress can be described using the shear transformation zone model , which takes into account the density and internal state of the localized zones @xcite . in recent years
, various deformation mechanisms including elementary plastic events and shear band formation were studied at different length and time scales using atomistic simulations and finite element modeling @xcite .
notably , the energy landscape analysis had shown that a large strain cycle rejuvenates the glass by increasing the potential energy , while a small strain cycle overages the glass by moving the system to deeper energy minima @xcite .
however , many essential features of the deformation process in strained amorphous systems including a correlation between localized plastic events and distribution of avalanches are not fully understood .
0.05 in the effect of inertia on steadily sheared disordered solids in the athermal quasistatic limit was examined in two and three dimensions using molecular dynamics simulations @xcite .
it was found that the distribution of avalanche sizes obeys a power - law decay over about three orders of magnitude in drops of the potential energy density and shear stress , and the volume of plastically deformed regions is proportional to the energy dissipated in an avalanche @xcite . in the underdamped regime
, the system can be carried over successive energy barriers to progressively lower minima leading to large avalanches , while in the overdamped case , avalanches are smaller and they typically consist of several disconnected regions oriented along diagonal lines @xcite .
it was also shown that at finite strain rates and zero temperature , the correlation between local plastic events remains relevant , and the avalanche size scales as the inverse square root of strain rate in two dimensions @xcite .
0.05 in in the last few years , a number of studies investigated oscillatory shear response of amorphous materials using atomistic simulations @xcite , continuum modeling @xcite , and experimental measurements @xcite .
it was found that below a certain strain amplitude , the disordered systems gradually evolve into dissipative limit cycles and particle rearrangements remain reversible , thus retaining memory of the initial conditions @xcite . the number of back and forth cycles required to reach steady state increases as the critical strain amplitude is approached from below @xcite .
surprisingly , it was shown that the cyclic deformation is accompanied by plastic rearrangements of atoms that are reversed by the end of each cycle @xcite . with further increasing strain amplitude ,
particle displacements become irreversible leading to a diffusive behavior and structural relaxation @xcite .
0.05 in the elastic response of a two - dimensional amorphous solid to a localized shear transformation was recently studied via molecular dynamics simulations in different damping regimes @xcite . in this process
, about twenty atoms within a circular inclusion were instantaneously sheared in a quiescent system and the time evolution of the displacement field was measured .
it was demonstrated that the stationary solution for the disorder - averaged displacement field has a quadrupolar symmetry and it agrees well with the predictions of the continuum elasticity theory @xcite . it was further observed that the transient regime is strongly dependent on the damping dynamics and the time dependence of the displacement field obtained from molecular dynamics simulations agrees with the continuum solution in the overdamped case at large times @xcite . the numerical analysis based on the finite element method that takes into account microscopic viscosity and the local elastic constants showed that the temporal evolution of the disorder - averaged displacement field is similar to the propagation of the elastic signal in a uniform medium @xcite .
0.05 in in the previous study @xcite , molecular dynamics simulations were carried out to investigate the influence of a local shear transformation on plastic deformation of a three - dimensional model glass .
the shear transformation was introduced in a quiescent system via a spherical inclusion that was gradually strained into an ellipsoid and then converted back into the sphere during a finite time interval .
it was demonstrated that at strain amplitudes above a few percent , the structural relaxation of the material involved localized plastic events that were identified using the cage detection algorithm @xcite .
the spatial distribution of clusters of cage jumps and their radial density profiles were studied for various damping conditions and durations of the shear event .
interestingly , it was found that the density profiles of cage jumps are well described by a universal function multiplied by a factor that depends on the friction coefficient and the shear transformation time scale @xcite .
it remained unclear , however , how this factor varies with the strain amplitude and whether it can be expressed as a function of a single variable .
0.05 in in this paper , the plastic response of the amorphous material to a reversible shear transformation is examined over a wide range of damping conditions and oscillation time scales .
the analysis of the density profiles of cage jumps presented in the previous study @xcite is extended further to describe the effect of strain amplitude on the profile shape and the dependence of the density maximum on the friction coefficient and oscillation period . in particular , it is demonstrated that , at sufficiently slow transformation rates , the peak value of the density profiles is a function of the ratio of the friction coefficient and the time scale of the shear transformation and that it strongly depends on the strain amplitude .
0.05 in the rest of the paper is structured as follows .
the details of molecular dynamics simulation model are described in the next section .
the analysis of the radial density profiles of cage jumps as a function of the time scale of the shear event , friction coefficient , and the strain amplitude is presented in sec.[sec : results ] .
the conclusions are provided in the final section .
the simulated system consists of @xmath0 particles confined in a three - dimensional cell as shown in fig.[fig : snapshot_system ] .
we used a standard model of a glass - forming lennard - jones ( lj ) binary mixture introduced by kob and andersen @xcite . in this model ,
any two particles @xmath1 interact through the lennard - jones ( lj ) potential @xmath2 , \label{eq : lj_ka}\ ] ] with the parameters @xmath3 , @xmath4 , @xmath5 , @xmath6 , @xmath7 , and @xmath8 @xcite .
the lj potential is truncated at the cutoff radius @xmath9 @xcite .
the units of length , mass and energy are chosen @xmath10 , @xmath11 , and @xmath12 , and , consequently , the unit of time is defined @xmath13 .
the simulations were performed at a constant density @xmath14 and the linear size of the cubic box is @xmath15 .
periodic boundary conditions were applied along the @xmath16 , @xmath17 , and @xmath18 directions .
0.05 in the motion of particles is governed by the classical langevin dynamics .
for example , the equation of motion in the @xmath16 direction for the @xmath19-th particle of mass @xmath20 is given by @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the friction coefficient and @xmath23 is a random force with zero mean and variance @xmath24 determined by the fluctuation - dissipation theorem @xcite . the langevin temperature is fixed @xmath25 , where @xmath26 is the boltzmann constant
. the equations of motion were integrated numerically using the fifth - order gear predictor - corrector algorithm @xcite with a time step @xmath27 .
different realizations of disorder were prepared by quenching the system from the temperature @xmath28 , which is well above @xmath29
@xcite , to the final temperature @xmath25 with the rate of @xmath30 .
0.05 in we next describe the deformation protocol for the reversible shear transformation .
the inclusion atoms were identified within a sphere of radius @xmath31 , which is located at the center of the simulation cell ( see fig.[fig : snapshot_system ] ) .
the average number of atoms in the inclusion is about @xmath32 .
first , the positions of the inclusion atoms were kept fixed while the system was aged for about @xmath33 at the temperature @xmath34 .
the spherical inclusion was gradually strained into an ellipsoid and then converted back into the sphere during the time interval @xmath35 .
note that the major axis of the ellipsoid was oriented along one of the diagonals of the simulation box , and the volume of the inclusion was kept constant during the transformation . in our study , the shear strain is defined as the ratio of the ellipsoid semi - major axis to the sphere radius @xmath31 .
the variation of stain as a function of time from zero to @xmath35 is described by the following equation @xmath36 where @xmath37 is the strain amplitude and @xmath35 is the time scale of the shear event .
after the shear transformation , the positions of inclusion atoms were kept fixed at their original positions and the system was allowed to equilibrate for the additional time interval @xmath38 .
this time interval is larger than the damping time @xmath39 for the smallest value of the friction coefficient @xmath40 considered in the present study .
several test simulations were performed when the system was equilibrated for a larger time interval of @xmath41 after the shear transformation in order to verify that the results remain unchanged .
finally , the average atom positions were computed before and after the shear transformation and then analyzed in @xmath42 independent samples .
at mechanical equilibrium , the atomic structure of the model glass shows no long - range order while each atom remains trapped in a cage composed of its neighbors during the time scale of the computer simulation at the studied temperature .
the plastic deformation of the amorphous material was induced by a reversible shear transformation of a spherical inclusion and studied at different damping conditions and time scales of the shear event . in our setup , the inclusion atoms were displaced to form an ellipsoid with the major axis parallel to the @xmath43 direction ( see fig.[fig : snapshot_system ] ) in order to reduce the effect of periodic boundary conditions . it was observed that at sufficiently small strain amplitudes ( below a few percent ) , the system response is elastic and all atoms return to their cages after the shear transformation @xcite .
0.05 in in the present study , the analysis of particle positions was performed in the plastic regime when the strain amplitude was varied in the range @xmath44 .
we find that at smaller values of @xmath37 , an accurate analysis of particle displacements requires averaging over larger number of independent systems , while at larger strain amplitudes , the relative distance between inclusion atoms becomes comparable to the molecular diameter , thus creating voids at the surface of the inclusion during the shear transformation process .
irreversible rearrangements of atoms in the material triggered by the shear transformation were identified using the cage detection algorithm @xcite .
visual inspection of snapshots of the simulated system revealed that cage jumps tend to aggregate into relatively compact clusters , which are predominantly located near the inclusion where the deformation of the material during the shear transformation is larger @xcite .
0.05 in it was shown in the previous study @xcite that the clusters of cage jumps are approximately power - law distributed with an exponent that depends on the strain amplitude .
in general , it is expected that the density of cage jumps will decay away from the center of the inclusion because the maximum local strain in the material during the reversible shear transformation decreases as a function of the radial distance . for example , the displacement and strain fields were calculated analytically for a spherical inclusion that was strained into an ellipsoid in a two - dimensional plane , while the third direction reminded neutral @xcite .
it was shown that in a stationary regime , the strain field has a quadrupolar symmetry and it decays as @xmath45 from the center of the inclusion in three dimensions @xcite .
0.05 in averaged density profiles of cage jumps as a function of the radial distance from the center of the inclusion are plotted in fig.[fig : den_var_time ] for the strain amplitude @xmath46 in the regime of intermediate damping @xmath47 .
several important features are evident .
first , the density of cage jumps is reduced within about two atomic diameters from the surface of the inclusion .
this effect originates from the reversible motion of the inclusion atoms that effectively form a part of a cage for the neighboring atoms of the material , thus reducing the probability of their irreversible displacements @xcite .
second , the density profiles exhibit a maximum at @xmath48 and then decay with further increasing radial distance .
it was previously shown that the rate of decay for @xmath49 correlates well with the local deformation of the material , which was estimated from the relative displacement of neighboring particles after the spherical inclusion was irreversibly strained into an ellipsoid @xcite .
0.05 in in general , we find that the average density of cage jumps increases with increasing time scale of the shear transformation ( e.g. , see fig.[fig : den_var_time ] ) . at small values of @xmath50 and @xmath51 ,
the time scale of the shear event is comparable with the time it takes for sound waves to propagate across the system , and thus the probability of formation of large clusters is reduced .
in contrast , when @xmath52 , the shear stress from the deforming inclusion can induce larger clusters of cage jumps , which in turn might trigger other irreversible events in the system .
in addition , as the damping rate decreases , the effect of inertia becomes more important , leading to larger avalanches during the shear transformation process , and , as a result , larger density of cage jumps .
this trend was also identified in sheared disordered solids in the athermal quasistatic limit by examining the critical scaling of avalanches at different damping rates @xcite .
0.05 in it was further noticed in the previous study @xcite that the density profiles of cage jumps for different values of @xmath35 and @xmath22 can be made to collapse onto a master curve if @xmath53 is divided by a scaling factor . in fig.[fig : density_prof_univ ] , we plot the average density profiles normalized by the corresponding density peak @xmath54 for different values of @xmath22 and strain amplitudes @xmath55 , @xmath56 and @xmath57 .
it is evident that for each value of the strain amplitude , the rescaled density profiles @xmath58 collapse on the master curves .
note that the data in fig.[fig : density_prof_univ ] for the two lower values @xmath55 and @xmath56 are shifted for clarity .
it can be seen that the location of the maximum of @xmath58 and the slope of decay for @xmath49 depend of the strain amplitude .
the deviation from the @xmath45 dependence , which describes the decay of the local strain away from an elliptical inclusion @xcite , for larger strain amplitudes @xmath46 and @xmath57 might be due to the finite system size .
remember that at @xmath59 some atoms interact with their neighbors via periodic boundary conditions but the local strain is in general not the same across periodic boundaries during the shear transformation .
0.05 in in our study , the maximum of the density profiles of cage jumps @xmath54 was estimated in a wide range of parameter values , i.e. , @xmath60 and @xmath61 .
figure[fig : contour_plot ] shows a contour plot of the density peaks @xmath54 as a function of the friction coefficient and the shear transformation time scale for the strain amplitude @xmath46 .
it can be seen that the density landscape is quite complex , but the trends are clear .
namely , at small @xmath35 in the overdamped regime , the deformation of material during the shear transformation is minimal , and thus the density of cage jumps is relatively small . in the opposite limit ,
when the shear transformation is very slow and the system dynamics is underdamped , the deformation of material is largest , facilitating the formation of large clusters , and the density of cage jumps saturates to a maximum value of about @xmath62 ( see fig.[fig : contour_plot ] ) .
0.05 in it can be further observed that the contour lines in fig.[fig : contour_plot ] approximately follow a linear dependence between the friction coefficient and the time scale of the shear event ( see the straight line with unit slope in fig.[fig : contour_plot ] ) .
this correlation holds over the whole range of parameters @xmath22 and @xmath35 , except for the data points within the dashed region in fig.[fig : contour_plot ] .
this , in turn , implies that the ratio @xmath63 computed along a contour level will correspond to the same value of the density peak .
therefore , it is expected that the data reported outside of the dashed region in fig.[fig : contour_plot ] can be collapsed onto a master curve if replotted as a function of @xmath63 .
another argument for using @xmath63 is that the time dependence of the continuum displacement field after an instantaneous shear transformation in the overdamped regime is roughly proportional to the factor @xmath64 , where @xmath65 is the shear modulus @xcite .
therefore , it follows that the local displacement field , which can trigger an irreversible rearrangement of atoms at a distance @xmath66 from an inclusion , depends on the ratio @xmath67 .
0.05 in the density peaks of cage jumps are first plotted in fig.[fig : rhomax_all ] as a function of the ratio @xmath63 for the strain amplitudes @xmath55 , @xmath56 and @xmath57 and the same range of parameter values as in fig.[fig : contour_plot ] .
the collapse of the data on three distinct master curves is satisfactory ; however , the data are somewhat scattered at intermediate values of @xmath63 .
as anticipated , the scattered data in fig.[fig : rhomax_all ] were evaluated for the parameters @xmath22 and @xmath35 within the dashed region in fig.[fig : contour_plot ] . without these data points ,
the dependence of the density peaks on the ratio @xmath63 is shown in fig.[fig : rhomax_collapse ] .
it is evident that for @xmath68 , the density peak saturates to a constant value that corresponds to the largest plastic deformation for each strain amplitude .
in contrast , with increasing @xmath63 , the density peak gradually crosses over to a power - law decay as a function of @xmath63 . in this regime
, the density of cage jumps is reduced due to either small time scale @xmath35 or large friction coefficient .
0.05 in it is apparent that the shape of the curves shown in fig.[fig : rhomax_collapse ] is very similar , suggesting that they might be different by a factor that depends on the strain amplitude .
indeed , we found that when the density peaks for each strain amplitude are divided by @xmath69 , the data collapse onto a single master curve ( see fig.[fig : rhomax_eps5 ] ) .
the resulting master curve extends over about five orders of magnitude in @xmath63 .
notice that the slope of the decay at @xmath70 depends slightly on the strain amplitude .
the existence of the plateau in fig.[fig : rhomax_eps5 ] implies that the largest value of @xmath54 can be obtained in the limiting case of a very slow shear transformation for any damping conditions , i.e. , when @xmath71 .
the significance of the value @xmath72 for the exponent is at present not clear .
we note , however , that the exponent was estimated based only on three data points for @xmath37 and the critical value of the strain amplitude that marks the onset of irreversible deformation was not determined in our study .
the relatively strong dependence of @xmath54 on the strain amplitude might be due the quadrupolar symmetry of the strain field that can trigger increasingly large clusters of cage jumps around the inclusion upon increasing strain amplitude .
in this paper , we have examined the structural relaxation in a three - dimensional amorphous material induced by a reversible shear transformation using molecular dynamics simulations .
the material was deformed by straining a spherical inclusion into an ellipsoid of the same volume and then converting it back into the sphere .
we found that at sufficiently large strain amplitude of the shear transformation , some particles undergo irreversible displacements that were identified using the cage detection algorithm .
the density profiles of cage jumps exhibit a distinct maximum near the surface of the inclusion followed by a power - law decay as a function of the radial distance . at a given strain amplitude ,
the density profiles are self - similar when scaled by the density maximum , which in turn depends on the damping rate and duration of the shear transformation .
moreover , it was demonstrated that the data for the peak value of the density profiles can be collapsed onto a master curve when plotted as a function of the ratio of the friction coefficient and the oscillation period .
overall , these findings indicate that the density of cage jumps around the inclusion becomes larger in the cases of weakly damped dynamics or slow shear transformation .
financial support from the national science foundation ( cbet-1033662 ) is gratefully acknowledged .
computational work in support of this research was performed at michigan state university s high performance computing facility and the ohio supercomputer center . , @xmath56 , and @xmath57 and the shear transformation time scale @xmath80 .
for each strain amplitude , the friction coefficient is @xmath81 ( solid black curve ) , @xmath82 ( dashed blue curve ) , @xmath83 ( dash - dotted red curve ) , and @xmath74 ( solid green curve ) .
the data for @xmath55 and @xmath56 are displaced vertically for clarity .
the straight solid and dashed lines indicate slopes @xmath84 and @xmath85 respectively . ] ( in units of @xmath86 ) as a function of the friction coefficient @xmath22 and the time scale of the shear event @xmath35 for the strain amplitude @xmath46 .
the contour levels are specified in the legend .
open square symbols indicate individual data points . the straight line with unit slope is shown as a reference .
the data points within the dashed region were excluded in the analysis of @xmath87 presented in figs.[fig : rhomax_collapse ] and [ fig : rhomax_eps5 ] ( see text for details ) . ] as a function of the ratio @xmath63 for the strain amplitudes @xmath55 ( @xmath88 ) , @xmath56 ( @xmath89 ) , and @xmath57 ( @xmath90 ) . the friction coefficient and the time scale of the shear event vary in the ranges @xmath60 and @xmath91 , respectively .
error bars are about the size of the symbols . ] as a function of the ratio @xmath63 for the strain amplitudes @xmath55 ( @xmath88 ) , @xmath56 ( @xmath89 ) , and @xmath57 ( @xmath90 ) .
the same data as in fig.[fig : rhomax_all ] except for @xmath92 and @xmath93 ( i.e. , except for the data points within the dashed region shown in fig.[fig : contour_plot ] ) . ] | molecular dynamics simulations are performed to investigate the plastic response of a model glass to a local shear transformation in a quiescent system .
the deformation of the material is induced by a spherical inclusion that is gradually strained into an ellipsoid of the same volume and then reverted back into the sphere .
we show that the number of cage - breaking events increases with increasing strain amplitude of the shear transformation .
the results of numerical simulations indicate that the density of cage jumps is larger in the cases of weak damping or slow shear transformation .
remarkably , we also found that , for a given strain amplitude , the peak value of the density profiles is a function of the ratio of the damping coefficient and the time scale of the shear transformation . |
the sudbury neutrino observatory is a second generation water cerenkov detector using 1000 tonnes of heavy water , d@xmath1o , as detection medium .
sno was designed to address the problem of the deficit of solar neutrinos by having sensitivity to all flavours of neutrinos and not just to @xmath2 , allowing for a model independent test of the oscillation explanation of the observed deficit .
such sensitivity can be achievable because energetic neutrinos can interact in the d@xmath1o of sno via three different reactions .
electron neutrinos may interact via the charged current ( cc ) reaction .
all non - sterile neutrinos may also interact via neutral current ( nc ) and via elastic scattering ( es ) ( smaller cross section ) .
the main objective of sno is to measure the ratio of nc / cc events . in its first year of
operation sno is concentrating on the measurement of the cc reaction rate while in a following phase , after the addition of mgcl@xmath1 salt to enhance the nc signal , it will also perform a precise measurement of the nc rate .
it is clear that a cross - section - normalized and acceptance - corrected ratio higher than 1 would strongly indicate the oscillation of @xmath2 into @xmath3 and/or @xmath4 . on the other hand a deficit on both cc and
nc leading to a normalized nc / cc ratio @xmath5 , can only be made compatible with the oscillation hypothesis if @xmath2 oscillates in to a sterile neutrino .
most of the studies of the potential of sno have been performed in the framework of oscillations between two neutrino states where @xmath2 oscillates into either an active , @xmath6 , or a sterile , @xmath7 , neutrino channel . on the other hand ,
once the possibility of a sterile neutrino is considered , these two scenarios are only limiting cases of the most general mixing structure @xcite which permits simultaneous @xmath7 and @xmath6 oscillations .
we consider those four
neutrino schemes favoured by considering together with the solar neutrino data , the results of the two additional evidences pointing out towards the existence of neutrino masses and mixing : the atmospheric neutrino data and the lsnd results .
we concentrate on two sno measurements : the first expected result on the cc ratio and the expected to be most sensitive , the ratio of nc / cc . the measurement of other observables , such as the recoil energy spectrum of the cc events and the zenith angular dependence can provide important information to distinguish between the different allowed regions for @xmath2active oscillations but they are not expected to be very sensitive as discriminatory between the active and sterile oscillations .
the results presented in this section have been obtained for the oscillation parameters in the presently allowed regions to the solar neutrino problem in the two neutrino schemes .
the results of the global fit to the data ( ref .
@xcite ) include ( i ) the sk data after 1117 days of operation ( total number of events and day and night energy spectra ) , ( ii ) gallex , gno and sage data , ( iii ) the homestake data .
we used the 90% and 99% cl regions found from the global minimum .
the fit includes the latest standard solar model fluxes , bp00 model @xcite .
for details on the statistical analysis applied to the different observable we refer to ref .
@xcite .
the total number of events in the cc reaction at sno is calculated with the @xmath8d cc cross section computed from the corresponding differential cross sections @xcite folded with the finite energy resolution function of the detector and integrated over the electron recoil energy . for definiteness , we adopted the most optimistic total energy threshold @xmath9 .
the total number of events in the nc reaction at sno is obtained using the @xmath8d nc cross section from @xcite . in order to cancel out all energy independent efficiencies and normalizations
we will use the ratio @xmath10}}$ ] where @xmath11 is the predicted number of events in the case of no oscillations .
the equivalent expression for the nc ratio @xmath12}}$ ] out of those ratios one can compute the double ratio @xmath13 [ nc]/[cc ] for which the largest sources of uncertainties cancel out @xcite . as it was shown in ref .
@xcite , the ratio between the nc and cc reaction cross sections is extremely stable against any variations of the inputs of the calculations .
the expected total uncertainties for the [ cc ] ratio and the [ nc]/[cc ] ratio are 6.7 % and 3.6 % respectively assuming 5000 cc events and 1219 nc events @xcite .
-1 cm in fig .
[ 2fsno ] we show the predicted [ cc ] and [ nc]/[cc ] ratios for the allowed regions in the two flavour analysis .
the dots correspond to the local best fit points and the error bars show the range of predictions for the points inside the 90 and 99 % cl allowed regions .
the mapping of the regions onto these bars can be easily understood from the behaviour of the probability for the different solutions : + ( a ) for oscillations into active neutrinos the [ nc]/[cc ] ratio is simply the inverse of the [ cc ] prediction .
therefore : in the sma region smaller mixing angles are mapped onto higher ( lower ) values of [ cc ] ( [ nc]/[cc ] ) ratio .
one may notice that the prediction for the [ cc ] rate for the global best fit point ( 0.60 ) is larger than the measured rate at super kamiokande .
this is due to the nearly flat spectrum at super kamiokande which implies that the best fit point in the global analysis corresponds to a smaller mixing angle than the best fit point for the analysis of rates only ; in the lma region , the lower @xmath14 and @xmath15 values are mapped onto higher ( lower ) [ nc]/[cc ] ( [ cc ] ) ratios and viceversa ; in the low region the higher ( lower ) [ nc]/[cc ] ( [ cc ] ) ratio occurs for smaller @xmath15 and higher @xmath14 .
\(b ) for the sterile case , the best fit point in sma occurs at lower @xmath14 than in the active case and this produces a higher prediction for the [ cc ] ratio ( 0.76 ) .
the [ nc]/[cc ] ratio takes an almost constant value very close to one ( 0.98 in the best fit point ) , since both numerator and denominator are proportional to @xmath16 .
it is smaller than one because for the sma solution the probability increases with energy in the range of detection at sno and the threshold for the nc reaction is below the one for the cc one .
what we see from these results is that while the data on [ cc ] can give a hint towards large or small mixing solutions , it will be hard to distinguish active from sterile oscillations on the only bases of this measurement .
this is not the case for the [ nc]/[cc ] ratio where both scenarios appear nicely separated .
it is not hard to foresee from these results that from the [ nc]/[cc ] measurement sno will be able to constraint the additional mixings in the four neutrino scenario which describe the admixture of active and sterile oscillations .
this is the main point in this paper .
together with the results from the solar neutrino experiments we have two more evidences pointing out towards the existence of neutrino masses and mixing : the atmospheric neutrino data and the lsnd results .
all these experimental results can be accommodated in a single neutrino oscillation framework only if there are at least three different scales of neutrino mass - squared differences .
the simplest case of three independent mass - squared differences requires the existence of a light sterile neutrino , _
i.e. _ one whose interaction with standard model particles is much weaker than the sm weak interaction , so it does not affect the invisible z decay width , precisely measured at lep .
there are six possible four neutrino schemes that can accomodate all these evidences .
they can be divided in two classes : 3 + 1 and 2 + 2 . in the 3 + 1 schemes
there is a group of three neutrino masses separated from an isolated mass by a gap of the order of 1ev which gives the mass - squared difference responsible for the short - baseline oscillations observed in the lsnd experiment . in 2 + 2 schemes
there are two pairs of close masses separated by the lsnd gap .
3 + 1 schemes are disfavoured by experimental data with respect to the 2 + 2 schemes but they are still marginally allowed . as discussed in ref .
@xcite , for any of these four neutrino schemes , either 2 + 2 or 3 + 1 , only four mixing angles are relevant in the study of solar neutrino oscillations @xcite .
the survival of solar @xmath2 s mainly depends on the mixing angle @xmath17 , whereas the mixing angles @xmath18 and @xmath19 determine the relative amount of transitions into sterile @xmath20 or active @xmath21 , this last one being a combination of @xmath3 and @xmath4 controlled by the mixing angle @xmath22 .
@xmath3 and @xmath4 can not be distinguished in solar neutrino experiments , because their matter potential and their interaction in the detectors are equal , due only to nc weak interactions . as a consequence
the active / sterile ratio and the survival probability for solar neutrino oscillations do not depend on the mixing angle @xmath23 , and depend on the mixing angles @xmath18 @xmath19 only through the combination @xmath24 .
for further details see ref .
@xcite . in the general case of simultaneous @xmath7 and @xmath6 oscillations
the corresponding probabilities are given by @xcite @xmath25 where @xmath26 takes the standard two neutrino oscillation form for @xmath27 and @xmath28 but computed with the modified matter potential @xmath29 .
thus the analysis of the solar neutrino data in the four neutrino mixing schemes is equivalent to the two neutrino analysis but taking into account that the parameter space is now three
dimensional @xmath30 .
we want to stress that , although originally this derivation was performed in the framework of the 2 + 2 schemes @xcite , it is equally valid for the 3 + 1 ones @xcite . the allowed regions in the three parameter space for the global combination of observables are shown in ref .
the global minimum used in the construction of the regions lays in the lma region and for pure @xmath2active oscillations , @xmath31 .
the sma region is always a valid solution for any value of @xmath32 at 95% cl ( [email protected] allowed at 90% cl ) . on the other hand , the lma and low
qvo solutions disappear for increasing values of the mixing @xmath32 ( 0.72 and 0.76 at 99% cl , respectively ) .
in this section , we present the predictions for the cc ratio and for the nc / cc ratio in the four neutrino scenario previously described .
this scenario contains as limiting cases the pure @xmath2active and @xmath2sterile neutrino oscillations . in figs .
[ 4fsno_sma]@xmath34[4fsno_low ] we show the results for the predicted [ cc ] ratio and [ nc]/[cc ] ratio for the different allowed regions ( sma , lma , low - qvo ) at 90 and 99 % cl as a function of @xmath32 .
the general behaviour of the dependence of the predicted ratios with @xmath32 can be easily understood using the following simplified expressions : @xmath35 } & \sim & p_{\nu_e\to\nu_e } \ ; , \label{cc}\\ \frac{\mbox{\rm [ nc ] } } { \mbox{\rm [ cc ] } } & \sim & \frac{1 - c^2_{23 } c^2_{24}(1 - p_{\nu_e\to\nu_e})}{p_{\nu_e\to\nu_e}}\;. \label{nccc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] from eq . ( [ cc ] ) ,
the only dependence of [ cc ] on @xmath32 is due to the modification of the matter potential entering in the evolution equation and it is very weak .
the dependence of the allowed range of the [ cc ] ratio with @xmath32 displayed in the figures arises mainly from the variation of the size of the allowed regions . alternatively following eq .
( [ nccc ] ) we find a stronger linear dependence of [ nc]/[cc ] on @xmath32 with slope @xmath36[cc ] and intercept @xmath37[cc ] .
this simple description is able to reproduce the main features of our numerical calculations as can be seen in the figures
. figs .
[ 4fsno_sma]@xmath34[4fsno_low ] contain the main quantitative result of our analysis in the four neutrino mixing scenario . from each of them
it is possible to infer the allowed range of the active sterile admixture , @xmath32 , compatible , within the expected uncertainty , with a given sno measurement of the ratios .
also , comparing the allowed ranges for the different solutions one can study the potential of these measurements as discriminatory among the three presently allowed regions .
of course , both issues are not independent as we have no `` a priory '' knowledge of which is the right solution and both must be discussed simultaneously . in order to do
so we pass to describe and compare in detail the predictions in the different regions .
the results for the sma solution are shown in fig .
[ 4fsno_sma].a and [ 4fsno_sma].b for [ cc ] and [ nc]/[cc ] ratios respectively .
first we notice that we find a small region allowed at 90 % cl only for a non vanishing admixture of active and sterile oscillations as mentioned before . in this region
[ cc]@xmath380.650.73 and [ nc]/[cc]@xmath38 1.31.4 . the predictions at 99% range from [ cc]@xmath38 0.40.9 ( [ nc]/[cc]@xmath381.12.5 ) for pure @xmath2active scenario to to [ cc]@xmath38 0.590.85 ( [ nc]/[cc]@xmath380.960.98 ) for pure @xmath2sterile oscillations .
thus if sno observes a ratio [ cc]@xmath390.58 the value of @xmath32 can be constrained to be smaller than 1 disfavouring pure @xmath2sterile oscillations . on the contrary a measurement of [ cc]@xmath400.68 will immediately hint towards the sma solution but will not provide any information on the active sterile admixture .
also , one must notice , that such value , although allowed by the present global statistical analysis at 99 % cl , will imply a strong disagreement with the total rate event rate observed at super kamiokande . as seen in fig .
[ 4fsno_sma].b the [ nc]/[cc ] ratio is more sensitive to the active sterile admixture . to guide the eye , in the figures for the [ nc]/[cc ] ratio
we plot a dotted line for the prediction in the case of no oscillation [ nc]/[cc]=1 . for any of the solutions , the allowed range for
this ratio shows as general behaviour a decreasing with @xmath32 due to two effects : @xmath41 the allowed regions become smaller and @xmath42 the prediction decreases when more sterile neutrino is involved in the oscillations as described in eq .
( [ nccc ] ) .
the measurement of higher values of this ratio will favour the four neutrino scenario with larger component of @xmath2active oscillations . on the other hand a measurement of [ nc]/[cc]@xmath43 ,
will push the oscillation hypothesis towards the pure @xmath2sterile oscillation scenario .
this case will be harder to differentiate from the non oscillation scenario .
we find that with the expected sensitivity the parameter @xmath32 is constrained to be above 0.44 at 99% cl and that the pure @xmath2active oscillations in the sma region are compatible with [ nc]/[cc]= 1 only at @xmath44 .
the predictions for oscillation parameters in the lma region are shown in figs .
[ 4fsno_lma].a and [ 4fsno_lma].b for [ cc ] and [ nc]/[cc ] ratios respectively .
the predictions at 99% vary in the range [ cc]@xmath38 0.180.62 and [ nc]/[cc]@xmath38 1.45.6 .
the first thing we notice by comparing fig .
[ 4fsno_lma].a with fig .
[ 4fsno_sma].a and fig .
[ 4fsno_low].a is that the most discriminatory scenario for the [ cc ] rate results if sno finds a small value [ cc]@xmath45 . this would significantly hint towards the lma solution to the solar neutrino problem and towards and @xmath2active oscillation scenario .
first , it is well separated from the predictions for the sma and low regions .
second , it will include as a bonus a small but measurable day night asymmetry .
and third it will constrain the @xmath32 to a small value ( @xmath46 ) . on the contrary
the less discriminatory scenario will be a measurement 0.4@xmath39[cc]@xmath390.6 where the prediction would be compatible with both sma and low - qvo solutions and no improvement on our knowledge of the four neutrino schemes is possible .
the [ nc]/[cc ] ratio can definitively improve the discrimination between the different scenarios provided its measurement lays in the upper range .
for instance a measurement of [ nc]/[cc]@xmath38 4 ( @xmath47 0.7 at @xmath48 ) will be conclusive for selecting lma as the solution to the snp and will imply and upper bound on @xmath49 . the predictions for the low
qvo region lay between the ones for sma and lma as displayed in fig .
[ 4fsno_low ] and therefore they are more difficult to discriminate . the predictions at 99% vary in the range [ cc]@xmath38 0.30.68 and [ nc]/[cc]@xmath38 1.23.4 . as a consequence
we see that a low [ cc ] ratio but still within the 99% cl range allowed for this region , 0.3@xmath39[cc]@xmath390.4 , will constrain significantly the @xmath32 parameter compatible with this solution but it will not be distinguishable from the lma solution unless the measured [ cc]@xmath390.3 . as mentioned above , the [ nc]/[cc ] ratio will be able to differentiate the lma and low - qvo solutions if not in the range [ 1.5,3 ] .
one should also notice that for the upper part of this range a positive measurement of the day
night asymmetry and the zenith dependence will point towards the higher @xmath50 of the low region as the solution . 99 d. dooling
_ et al._,phys . rev .
* d61 * , 073011 ( 2000 ) . c. giunti _ et al._,phys
. rev . * d62 * , 013005 ( 2000 ) . m. c. gonzalez - garcia , these proceedings .
j. n. bahcall _ et al._,astro - ph/0010346 .
gonzalez - garcia _ et al .
_ , hep - ph/0011245 . s. nakamura _ et al .
_ , nucl - th/0009012
. j. n. bahcall _ et al._,phys .
* d62 * 093004 ( 2000 ) . c. giunti and m. laveder , hep - ph/0010009 . | we discuss the potential of the sudbury neutrino observatory ( sno ) to constraint the four neutrino mixing schemes favoured by the results of all neutrino oscillations experiments .
our results show that some information on the value of @xmath0 can be obtained by the first sno measurement of the cc ratio , while considerable improvement on the knowledge of this mixing will be achievable after the measurement of the nc / cc ratio . |
complex organic molecules ( coms ) have a key role among the many molecules so far detected in space : since they follow the same chemical rules of carbon - based chemistry , which terrestrial life is based on , they may give us an insight into the universality of life .
of course , large biotic molecules are not detectable in space , certainly not via ( sub)millimeter observations .
however , to determine whether pre - biotic molecules may form in space , we first need to understand the basic mechanisms that form smaller coms . there is an extensive literature on the subject and still much debate on how coms may form in space ( e.g. herbst & van dishoeck 2009 ; caselli & ceccarelli 2012 ; bergin 2013 ) .
two basic processes are , in principle , possible : coms may form on the grain surfaces or in gas phase .
it is possible and even probable that the two processes are both important in different conditions for different molecules .
acetaldehyde ( ch@xmath0cho ) has been detected in a large range of interstellar conditions and with different abundances , namely in hot cores ( blake et al .
1986 ) , hot corinos ( cazaux et al . 2003 ) , cold envelopes ( jaber et al . 2014 ) , galactic center clouds ( requena - torres et al . 2006 ) and pre - stellar cores ( berg et al .
grain surface models predict that ch@xmath0cho is one of the simplest coms and can be formed either by the combination of two radicals on the grain surface , ch@xmath0 and hco , which become mobile when the grain temperature reaches @xmath230 k ( garrods & herbst 2006 ) , or by irradiation of iced ch@xmath5 , co@xmath6 and other iced species ( bennett et al . 2005 ) .
for the former route , the two radicals are predicted to be formed either because of the photolysis of more complex molecules on the grain mantles or , more simply , because of the partial hydrogenation of simple biatomic molecules on the grain mantles ( taquet et al .
conversely , gas phase models claim that acetaldehyde is easily formed by the oxidation of hydrocarbons , which are produced by the hydrogenation of carbon chain on the grain mantles ( charnley et al .
1992 , 2004 ) .
finally , a further possible mechanism involving formation in the very high density gas - phase immediately after ice mantles are sublimated has been proposed by rawlings et al .
( 2013 ) . in general
, it is very difficult to distinguish which of these three mechanisms are at work and , consequently , their relative importance .
the chemically rich shocked region l1157-b1 offers a unique possibility to test these theories , as it is a place where the dust is not heated by the protostar , but some of the grain mantles are sputtered / injected in the gas phase because of the passage of a shock ( see e.g. fontani et al .
the l1157-mm protostar ( @xmath7 = 250 pc ) drives a chemically rich outflow ( bachiller et al .
2001 ) , associated with molecular clumpy cavities ( gueth et al .
1996 ) , created by episodic events in a precessing jet . located at the apex of the more recent cavity , the bright bow shock called b1 has a kinematical age of 2000 years .
this shock spot has been the target of several studies ( e.g. the large programs herschel / chess ( chemical herschel surveys of star forming regions ; ceccarelli et al .
2010 ; and iram-30m / asai ( astrochemical survey at iram ) . in this letter
we report high spatial resolution observations of acetaldehyde , with the aim to constrain and quantify the contribution of gas phase chemistry to the ch@xmath0cho formation .
l1157-b1 was observed with the iram plateau de bure ( pdb ) 6-element array in april may 2013 using both the c and d configurations , with 21176 m baselines , filtering out structures @xmath8 20@xmath9 , and providing an angular resolution of 2@xmath105 @xmath3 2@xmath103 ( pa = 90@xmath11 ) .
the primary hpbw is @xmath12 .
the observed ch@xmath0cho lines ( see table 1 ) at @xmath2 134136 ghz were detected using the widex backend which covers a 4 ghz spectral window at a 2 mhz ( @xmath2 4.4 km s@xmath13 ) spectral resolution .
the system temperature was 100200 k in all tracks , and the amount of precipitable water vapor was generally @xmath2 5 mm .
calibration was carried out following standard procedures , using gildas - clic .
calibration was performed on 3c279 ( bandpass ) , 1926 + 611 , and 1928 + 738 ( phase and amplitude ) .
the absolute flux scale was set by observing mwc349 ( @xmath14 jy at 134 ghz ) .
the typical rms noise in the 2 mhz channels was @xmath2 0.7 mjy beam@xmath13 .
acetaldehyde emission has been clearly ( s / n @xmath8 10 ) detected towards l1157b1 .
1 shows the map of the ch@xmath0cho(7@xmath156@xmath16 ) e and a lines integrated emission . in order to verify whether the present ch@xmath0cho image is altered by filtering of large - scale emission
, we produced the ch@xmath0cho(7@xmath156@xmath16 ) e+a spectrum summing the emission measured at pdbi in a circle of diameter equal to the half - power beam width ( hpbw ) of the iram-30 m telescope ( 17@xmath9 ) .
we evaluated the missing flux by comparing such emission with the spectrum directly measured with the single - dish ( from the asai spectral survey , lefloch et al .
, in preparation ) . as already found for hdco by fontani et al .
( 2014 ) , with the pdbi we recover more than 80% of the flux , indicating that both tracers do not have significant extended structures .
the spatial distribution reported in fig .
1 shows that ch@xmath0cho is mainly associated with two regions : ( i ) the eastern b0-b1 cavity opened by the precessing jet ( called ` e - wall ' , see fig . 1 in fontani et al .
2014 ) , and ( ii ) the arch - like structure composed by the b1a - e - f - b clumps identified by ch@xmath0cn ( called ` arch ' ) . the red , turquoise , and magenta polygons shown in fig
. 1 sketch out these two regions , intersecting at the position of the b1a clump .
note that b1a is in turn located where the precessing jet is expected to impact the cavity producing a dissociative j - shock ( traced by high velocity sio , h@xmath6o , [ feii ] , [ oi ] , and high - j co emission : e.g. gueth et al .
1998 , benedettini et al . 2012 ) .
figure 2 shows the ch@xmath0cho line spectrum observed with the 3.6 ghz widex bandwidth towards the brightest clump , b1a . up
to six lines ( @xmath1 = 2635 k , see table 1 ) are detected with a s / n @xmath17 3 . using the gildas weeds package ( maret et al .
2011 ) and assuming optically thin emission and lte conditions , we produced the synthetic spectrum ( red line in fig .
2 ) that best fits the observed one .
note that the ch@xmath0cho lines are blue - shifted , by 2 km s@xmath13 , with respect to the cloud systemic velocity ( + 2.6 km s@xmath13 : bachiller & perz gutirrez 1997 ) , and have linewidths of 8 km s@xmath13 .
similarly , we extracted the ch@xmath0cho line spectrum towards the three b1 zones , ` e - wall ' , ` arch ' , and ` head ' , shown in fig .
1 . table 2 reports the measured peak velocities , intensities ( in @xmath18 scale ) , fwhm linewidths , and integrated intensities , for each of the three zones .
.list of ch@xmath0cho transitions detected towards l1157-b1 [ cols="<,^,^,^,^ " , ] @xmath19 from the jet propulsion laboratory database ( pickett et al .
+ lccccccc & & & & & & & + & & & & & & & + & & & & & & & + + 7@xmath156@xmath16 e & 30(3 ) & + 0.4(0.4 ) & 8.2(1.0 ) & 264(28 ) & & & + [ -1ex ] & & & & & 5.0(0.3)9.2(0.5 ) & 1.7(0.1)11.0(0.6 ) & 1.9(0.2)0.9(0.1 ) + [ -1.1ex ] 7@xmath156@xmath16 a & 29(3 ) & + 0.5(0.5 ) & 8.6(1.3 ) & 263(31 ) & & & + + 7@xmath156@xmath16 e & 71(7 ) & 0.9(0.3 ) & 9.2(0.8 ) & 748(54 ) & & & + [ -1ex ] & & & & & 15.9(0.1)29.4(0.1 ) & 0.6(0.1)4.2(0.1 ) & 7.6(1.1)3.7(0.5 ) + [ -1.1ex ] 7@xmath156@xmath16 a & 76(7 ) & 0.2(0.9 ) & 8.0(0.5 ) & 608(42 ) & & & + + 7@xmath156@xmath16 e & 14(3 ) & + 0.9(0.5 ) & 8.0(1.1 ) & 81(13 ) & & & + [ -1ex ] & & & & & 1.7(0.3)3.1(0.5 ) & 0.2(0.1)0.7(0.1 ) & @xmath8 1.5 + [ -1.1ex ] 7@xmath156@xmath16 a & 13(3 ) & + 0.9(0.6 ) & 5.2(1.6 ) & 81(13 ) & & & + @xmath19 the errors are the gaussian fit uncertainties .
the spectral resolution is 4.4 km s@xmath13 . @xmath20
derived using the ( 7@xmath216@xmath16 ) e and a emissions .
figure 1 compares the ch@xmath0cho distribution with that of hdco ( fontani et al . 2014 ) , showing an excellent agreement , with weak or no emission at the head of the bow b1 structure ( called ` head ' ) .
the acetaldehyde emission is concentrated towards the ` e - wall ' and ` arch ' zones , namely the part of b1 associated with the most recent shocked material , as probed by the hdco emission .
this is further supported by the fact that the brightest acetaldehyde emission comes where also ch@xmath0oh , another dust mantle product , and ch@xmath0cn , a 6-atoms com , emission peak ( codella et al .
2009 , benedettini et al .
2013 ) . finally , the ch@xmath0cho observed emission is also confined in the low - velocity range ( @xmath22 @xmath2 8 km s@xmath13 ) of the l1157-b1 outflow , which is dominated by the extended b1 bow - cavity , according to lefloch et al .
( 2012 ) and busquet et al .
( 2014 ) . in summary ,
similarly to hdco , ch@xmath0cho traces the extended interface between the shock and the ambient gas , which is chemically enriched by the sputtering of the dust mantles . to derive the column density
, we used the lte populated and optically thin assumption and best fitted the six detected lines of tables 12 . towards the b1a peak ,
we find @xmath23 = 9 @xmath3 10@xmath24 @xmath25 , and a rotational temperature of @xmath26 = 15 k , in agreement with the value derived for the molecular cavity from single - dish co and hdco measurements ( 1070 k ; lefloch et al .
2012 , codella et al .
assuming rotational temperatures between 10 and 70 k ( table 2 ) we derived a column density of 530 @xmath3 10@xmath27 @xmath25 in the ` e - wall ' and ` arch ' regions , and @xmath2 23 10@xmath27 @xmath25 in the ` head ' .
the size of the regions ( at 3@xmath28 level ) is 9@xmath9 ( ` e - wall ' ) , 7@xmath9 ( ` arch ' ) , and 8@xmath9 ( ` head ' ) .
an estimate of the ch@xmath0cho abundance can be derived using the the co column density @xmath29 10@xmath30 @xmath25 derived by lefloch et al .
( 2012 ) on a 20@xmath9 scale .
we derived @xmath23 using the ch@xmath0cho spectrum extracted on the same scale and assuming 1070 k. we find @xmath23 @xmath2 0.91.6 @xmath3 10@xmath24 @xmath25 , which implies a high abundance , @xmath31 @xmath29 23 @xmath3 10@xmath4 , similar to what has been measured in hot - corinos ( @xmath29 26 @xmath3 10@xmath4 , cazaux et al .
2003 ) , and larger than that measured in prestellar cores ( @xmath2 10@xmath32 , vastel et al . 2014 ) and towards high - mass star forming regions ( @xmath2 10@xmath3210@xmath33 , cazaux et al . 2003
; charnley 2004 ) .
the ratio between @xmath23 and the column density of hdco , i.e. a molecule which in l1157-b1 is predominantly released by grain mantles ( fontani et al . 2014 ) , is higher ( even if we consider the uncertainties , see table 2 ) in the ` arch ' with respect to the ` e - wall ' by a factor @xmath2 28 .
assuming the same grain mantle composition and release mechanism , this difference suggests that , in the ` arch ' , a significative fraction of the observed ch@xmath0cho is formed in the gas phase . in the gas phase , the injection from grain mantles of ethane ( c@xmath6h@xmath34 ) is expected to drive first c@xmath6h@xmath35 and successively acetaldehyde ( e.g. charnley 2004 ; vasyunin & herbst 2013 ) : the overlap between the hdco ( fontani et al . 2014 ) and ch@xmath0cho emitting regions supports this scenario .
we can , therefore , use the measured ch@xmath0cho abundance to constrain the quantity of c@xmath6h@xmath35 that has to be present in the gas phase in order to produce the observed quantity of ch@xmath0cho . to this end , we use the chemical code astrochem , a pseudo time dependent model that follows the evolution of a gas cloud with a fixed temperature and density considering a network of chemical reactions in the gas phase . we followed the same 2-steps procedure adopted in podio et al .
( 2014 ) and mendoza et al .
( 2014 ) , to first compute the steady - state abundances in the cloud ( i.e. t@xmath36=10 k , n@xmath37=10@xmath38 @xmath39 , @xmath40=3 10@xmath41 s@xmath13 ) ; and then we follow the gas evolution over 2000 yr at the shocked conditions ( i.e. t@xmath36=70 k and n@xmath37=10@xmath42 @xmath39 ) . to estimate the influence of a possibly larger gas t@xmath36 during the passage of the shock , we also run cases with temperatures up to 1000 k. we adopt the osu chemical network and assume visual extinction of a@xmath43 = 10 mag and grain size of 0.1 @xmath44 m .
we assume that the abundances of ocs and co@xmath6 are also enhanced by the passage of the shock , namely their abundance in step 2 is @xmath45 = 6 10@xmath46 and @xmath47 = 6 10@xmath48 .
similarly , we assume that the abundance of methanol in step 2 is 2 10@xmath48 , in agreement with the most recent determination in l1157-b1 by mendoza et al .
( 2014 ) . finally , we varied the c@xmath6h@xmath35 abundance from 2 @xmath3 10@xmath49 to 2 @xmath3 10@xmath46 .
as expected , the predicted steady - state abundance of acetaldehyde in the cloud is very low ( 1.5 10@xmath50 ) .
however , once c@xmath6h@xmath35 is in the gas phase , it rapidly reacts with oxygen forming abundant acetaldehyde on timescale shorter than 100 years ( fig .
3 ) . the ch@xmath0cho abundance reaches the observed value , @xmath29 23 @xmath3 10@xmath4 , at the shock age ( 2000 years ) , for c@xmath6h@xmath35 @xmath2 26 @xmath3 10@xmath49 .
note that we obtain the same result if the gas temperature is @xmath51 k , and a 30% higher value at 1000 k. figure 3 shows also that the ch@xmath0cho / ch@xmath0oh abundance ratio is expected to drop between 10@xmath52 yr and 10@xmath38 yr . a different age could , therefore , justify the slightly smaller ch@xmath0cho / ch@xmath0oh ratio observed towards the ` head ' region .
we have shown that acetaldehyde is abundant , @xmath31 @xmath29 23 @xmath3 10@xmath4 , in the gas associated with the passage of a shock and enriched by iced species sputtered from grain mantles and injected into the gas phase .
the measured acetaldehyde abundance could be consistent with the scenario of oxydation of gaseous hydrocarbons formed in a previous phase and released by the grain mantles .
however , the abundance of the c@xmath6h@xmath35 required to reproduce the measured ch@xmath0cho is very high , @xmath2 26 @xmath3 10@xmath49 , namely less than 0.6% the elemental gaseous carbon .
there are no observations of c@xmath6h@xmath35 , hence it is impossible to compare with direct estimates of the abundance of this molecule .
however , it has been argued that large quantities of frozen methane , of a few % of iced mantle water , is found around the l1527-mm protostar , where the detection of ch@xmath0d ( sakai et al . 2012 ) indicates @xmath53 @xmath29 0.41.5 @xmath3 @xmath54 .
this large abundance has been attributed to a low density of the pre - collapse core from which l1527-mm originated ( aikawa et al .
interestingly , the analysis of the deuteration of water , methanol and formaldehyde in l1157-b1 led codella et al .
( 2012 ) to conclude that also the mantles of l1157-b1 were formed in relatively low density ( @xmath2 10@xmath52 @xmath39 ) conditions .
to conclude , in the specific case of l1157-b1 , gas phase reactions can produce the observed quantity of acetaldehyde only if a large fraction of carbon , of the order of 0.1% , is locked into iced hydrocarbons .
further observations of the hydrocarbons abundance in l1557-b1 are needed to confirm or dismiss our hypothesis .
the authors are grateful to p. caselli for instructive comments and suggestions , as well as to the iram staff for its help in the calibration of the pdbi data .
this research has received funding from the european commission seventh framework programme ( fp/2007 - 2013 , n. 283393 , radionet3 ) , the prin inaf 2012 jedi , and the italian ministero dellistruzione , universit e ricerca through the grant progetti premiali 2012 ialma .
lp has received funding from the european union seventh framework programme ( fp7/2007 - 2013 , n. 267251 ) .
cc and bl acknowledge the financial support from the french space agency cnes , and rb from spanish mineco ( fis2012 - 32096 ) .
aikawa y. , wakelam v. , garrod r.t .
, & herbst e. 2008 , apj 674 , 993 bachiller r. , & perz gutirrez m. 1997 , apj 487 , l93 benedettini , m. , busquet , b. , lefloch , b. , et al .
2012 , a&a 539 , l3 bennett c.j . , osamira y. , lebar m.d . , & kaiser r.i . 2005 ,
apj 634 , 968 bergin , e.a .
2013 , xvii special courses at the national observatory of rio de janeiro .
aip conference proceedings , arxiv:1309.4729 blake g.a . ,
masson c.r . ,
phillips t.g . , &
sutton e.c .
1986 , apjs 60 , 357 busquet g. , lefloch b. , benedettini , m. , et al .
2014 , a&a 561 , 120 benedettini , m. , viti , s. , codella , c. , et al .
2013 , mnras 436 , 179 caselli , p. & ceccarelli , c. 2012 , a&arv , 20 , 56 cazaux s. , tielens a.g.g.m .
, ceccarelli c. , et al .
2003 , apj 593 , l51 ceccarelli c. , bacmann a. , boogert a. , et al .
2010 , a&a 521 , l22 charnley s.b . , 2004 ,
space res .
33 , 23 charnley s.b .
, tielens a.g.g.m . ,
& millar t.j .
1992 , apj 399 , l71 codella c. , benedettini m. , beltrn m.t . , et al .
2009 , a&a 507 , l25 codella c. , ceccarelli c. , lefloch b. , et al .
2012 , apj , 757 , l9 fontani f. , codella c. , ceccarelli c. , et al .
2014 , apj 788 , l43 garrod r.t .
, & herbst e. 2006 , a&a 457 , 927 garrod r.t . , wakelam v. , & herbst e. 2007 , a&a 467 , 1103 garrod r.t . , weaver s.l.w . , & herbst e. 2008 , apj 682 , 283 garrod r.t . , vasyunin a.i .
, semenov d.a . ,
wiebe d.s . ,
& henning th .
2009 , apj 700 , l43 gueth f. , guilloteau s. , & bachiller r. 1996 , a&a 307 , 891 gueth f. , guilloteau s. , & bachiller r. 1998 , a&a 333 , 287 herbst e. , & van dishoeck e.f .
2009 , ara&a 47 , 427 jaber a.a .
, ceccarelli c. , kahane c. , & caux e. 2014 , apj 791 , 29 lefloch b. , cabrit s. , busquet g. , et al .
2012 , apj , 757 , l25 maret s. , hily - blant p. , pety j. , et al . ,
a&a 526 , a47 berg k.i . ,
bottinelli s. , jrgensen j.k . , van dishoeck e.f .
2010 , apj 716 , 825 occhiogrosso a. , vasyunin a. , herbst e. , et al .
2014 , a&a 564 , 123 pickett h.m .
, poynter r.l . ,
cohen e.a . ,
1998 , j. quant .
spectrosc . &
rad . transfer 60 , 883 podio l. , lefloch b. , ceccarelli c. , codella c. , & bachiller r. 2014 , a&a 565 , 64 requena - torres m.a . ; martn - pintado j. , rodrguez - franco a. , et al .
2006 , a&a 455 , 971 rawlings j.m.c .
, williams d.a .
, viti s. , & cecchi - pestellini c. 2013 , mnras 430 , 264 sakai n. , shirley y.l . , sakai t. , et al .
2012 , apj 758 , l4 taquet , v. , ceccarelli , c. , & kahane , c. 2012 , apj 784 , l3 vastel c. , ceccarelli c. , lefloch b. , & bachiller r. 2014 , apj 795 , l2 vasyunin a.i . , & herbst e. 2013 , apj 769 , 34 | the formation of complex organic molecules ( coms ) in protostellar environments is a hotly debated topic . in particular , the relative importance of the gas phase processes as compared to a direct formation of coms on the dust grain surfaces is so far unknown .
we report here the first high - resolution images of acetaldehyde ( ch@xmath0cho ) emission towards the chemically rich protostellar shock l1157-b1 , obtained at 2 mm with the iram plateau de bure interferometer .
six blueshifted ch@xmath0cho lines with @xmath1 = 26 - 35 k have been detected .
the acetaldehyde spatial distribution follows the young ( @xmath2 2000 yr ) outflow cavity produced by the impact of the jet with the ambient medium , indicating that this com is closely associated with the region enriched by iced species evaporated from dust mantles and released into the gas phase .
a high ch@xmath0cho relative abundance , 23 @xmath3 10@xmath4 , is inferred , similarly to what found in hot - corinos .
astrochemical modelling indicates that gas phase reactions can produce the observed quantity of acetaldehyde only if a large fraction of carbon , of the order of 0.1% , is locked into iced hydrocarbons .
[ firstpage ] molecular data stars : formation radio lines : ism submillimetre : ism ism : molecules |
open magnetic systems for plasma confinement have a number of potential advantages when considered as a basis for fusion reactors with various thermonuclear applications starting from neutron sources with a thermonuclear gain factor @xmath3 @xcite and ending with power plants with @xmath4 @xcite .
in addition to simplicity of their design , the advantages of open systems are proven capability of high-@xmath5 plasma confinement ( @xmath5 is a ratio between the plasma and magnetic field pressures ) , relatively low wall loading by plasma heat and radiation , and possibility of direct conversion of plasma `` exhaust '' to electricity . the hot ion component with energy optimal for fusion applications is commonly sustained in such systems by injection of high - power neutral beams ( nbi ) .
in turn , the electron plasma component is heated due to relaxation of nbi driven energetic ions .
electrons with their superior mobility are carrying most of the heat flux , which goes mainly along the magnetic field lines and hits the end plates outside the magnetic mirrors .
due to direct contact with cold wall the electron temperature ( @xmath6 ) ends up essentially lower than the mean energy of fast ions .
an energy confinement time of fast ions in plasma with relatively cold electrons is determined by the electron - ion coulomb collisions , @xmath7 . for this reason ,
the electron temperature is the main factor limiting the confinement time of fast ions and thus the power efficiency of a beam - driven fusion reactor based on a magnetic mirror .
widely believed estimation based on classical ( spitzer ) electron thermal conductivity shows that the heat flux along the magnetic field lines is proportional to @xmath8 @xcite , which closes the door on any possible thermonuclear application of a mirror trap due to a poor quality of energy confinement .
this simplified view is widely spread over the fusion community .
that in combination to many experiments which never demonstrated the electron temperature higher than 280 ev @xcite , led to a judgment that the very concept of a thermonuclear reactor based on a magnetic mirror has hit a dead end .
this results in a relatively weak research activity in this field . however , there are many complex and not yet sufficiently investigated processes in a region with expanding magnetic field lines behind the magnetic mirrors which lead to a significant suppression of the longitudinal electron heat flux @xcite
. low - temperature experiments also suggest the inconsistency of the above mentioned simplified view @xcite .
this alone lets us to consider the magnetic mirror concept as a productive approach to a fusion reactor .
having said that , a direct experimental demonstration of the electron temperature much higher than that predicted by the spitzer heat conductivity might become the strongest argument in favor of mirror trap perspectives .
a more practical goal is to achieve a temperature required for a magnetic - mirror - based source of fusion neutrons for material testing , subcritical fission reactors and nuclear waste processing based on fusion driven burning of minor actinides . according to @xcite ,
the electron temperature of @xmath9ev is enough to fit all mentioned applications . in this letter
we report the latest experimental results , which in our opinion let us practically achieve these ambitious goals .
experiments were performed on the gdt ( gas dynamic trap ) facility in budker institute .
plasma was supported by 5mw nbi heating and 0.7mw electron cyclotron resonance heating ( ecrh ) . in a series of successive shots with combined heating
we have reached an average electron temperature of @xmath0ev with plasma density being @xmath10m@xmath11 ; moreover , in several shots we have registered the electron temperature close to 1 kev .
the gdt is large - scale axially symmetric magnetic mirror device with 7-m - long central cell and two expander cells attached to it from both ends .
ratio between maximal and minimal confining magnetic field on the trap axis ( the mirror ratio ) is 35 .
the device is distinguished with a fairly good confinement that allows to reach local plasma @xmath5 up to @xmath12% .
design , physics of plasma confinement and main goals of this machine are described in @xcite ; here we mention only key issues that made the reported results possible
. important feature of the setup is that the plasma facing collectors are placed sufficiently far from the magnetic mirrors in a region with expanded magnetic field lines .
plasma expansion before end plates essentially reduces the electron heat transfer along the magnetic field far below the spitzer value @xcite .
the main heating system consists of eight nbis providing 5 mw of total injected power .
recently the gdt has been upgraded with the additional electron cyclotron resonance heating ( ecrh ) system operated at 54.5 ghz with total power 0.7 mw @xcite .
an evident attractive feature of the ecrh is that power is directly deposited into the electron component resulting in comparable powerflux to those transmitted to electrons from the slowing - down of nbi - born fast ions ( @xmath13mw ) .
note , that although ecrh techniques are well developed for toroidal fusion devices and small open traps , none of the existing schemes is suitable for the gdt conditions .
thus we have developed a new scheme of the ecrh at the fundamental harmonic of the extraordinary plasma mode . in this scheme the microwave beam is launched obliquely into the plasma at a specific angle and position such that it is effectively trapped by an inhomogeneous plasma `` waveguide '' , and after several crossings of the plasma axis the beam finally reaches the cyclotron resonance surface and dissipates @xcite .
presently available power supply provides the required for the ecrh magnetic field only at one end of the machine , which would limit the experiment to one of two available heating beams ( with power about 0.4mw ) .
experiments in such conditions resulted in the on - axis electron temperature of @xmath14ev @xcite . in this letter
we report the experiment in which we adopt another strategy .
the confining magnetic field is reshaped such that it is increased in the both ecrh regions located near the trap ends and is lowered everywhere else .
this allows exploiting both microwave beams and boosting the injected ecrh power to 0.7mw .
another important feature of new magnetic geometry is the possibility to tune the magnetic field inside the ecrh region .
however the whole magnetic field in the device is decreased ( e.g. from 0.35 to 0.27 t in the central solenoid and proportionally in magnetic mirrors ) what results in some degradation of plasma confinement properties . in particular , without ecrh the on - axis electron temperature is only @xmath15ev depending on plasma density while for the standard magnetic configuration this temperature is 250 ev with plasma density @xmath16m@xmath11 @xcite .
another issue to be addressed is the magneto - hydro - dinamic ( mhd ) stability of bulk plasma , which in case of the gdt is inherently unstable . to stabilize discharge
we employ the novel vortex confinement technique @xcite .
in short , we apply a biasing potential to the plasma edge to induce a radial electric field inside the plasma column ; then @xmath17-drift results in differential rotation of peripheral plasma which suppresses the radial transport caused by the flute mhd modes .
potential gap between plasma core and periphery should be about @xmath6 in order to provide an optimal confinement .
this condition is easily violated when ecrh results in fast rise of electron temperature . thus to stabilize plasma we boost the bias potential by applying additional voltage to the vortex confinement electrodes during the ecrh phase .
electron temperature and density profiles are measured in the central plane by thomson scattering diagnostics based on 1@xmath18 m laser .
the experiment is performed in deuterium plasma .
a typical shot is presented in fig.[fig1 ] .
the discharge is initiated by a plasma gun that injects primary plasma along the trap axis from 0.5 to 4.5 ms .
plasma heating starts at 3.7 ms with 5mw nbi , then after 2.4 ms an additional 0.7mw ecrh is switched - on .
total discharge duration is about 9 ms while the ecrh phase lasts 2.5 ms .
one can see that ecrh may result in rapid degradation of plasma confinement steady heating is switched to a full - scale instability leading to the loss of the entire plasma which is indicated by all diagnostics ( most clearly by the diamagnetic loops ) .
nevertheless , the discharge may be stabilized by appling an additional biasing voltage ( @xmath19v ) to the plasma limiter during the ecrh phase . as seen from diamagnetic signals , the additional voltage stabilizes plasma , but
the instability is not entirely suppressed .
the latter is most clearly pronounced in time resolved measurements of the on - axis electron temperature shown in fig.[fig1](a ) .
though the diamagnetic signal is maintained at the same level or even grows , the peaked temperature profile can not be supported during the whole ecrh pulse .
nevertheless , the duration of stable microwave heating has been increased up to 0.6 ms what results in the record electron temperature registered at the gdt to date .
even though the mhd activity is still present , it no longer leads to the dramatic loss of the entire plasma and tends to become less destructive with the increase of the limiter potential jump .
( a ) evolution of the on - axis electron temperature during the ecr heating measured using thomson scattering system .
( b ) evolution of the diamagnetic signal ( mostly contributed by the hot ions ) and the bias potential used for plasma stabilization during combined 5mw nbi and 0.7mw ecrh discharges with ( navy lines online ) and without ( red lines online ) additional voltage on the limiter at the gdt facility .
, width=321 ] electron energy spectrum measured by thomson scattering on the axis of gdt and averaged over 7 consecutive shots .
fit of these data suggests the maxwellian electron distribution function with the electron temperature of @xmath0ev and density @xmath20m@xmath11 .
the same data for one of shots with electron temperature above 900ev is shown in the insert .
, width=321 ] in fig.[fig2 ] we present thomson scattering data for the on - axis electron temperature .
this plot is obtained by averaging over a series of several sequential shots .
the scattered spectrum proves that the electron velocity distribution remained maxwellian ( represented by a straight line in the plot ) with the average electron temperature of @xmath21ev .
it should be noted that in few shots the measured electron temperature exceeds 900ev .
plasma density is about @xmath10m@xmath11 for all shots .
presented series of shots has been obtained in most favorable conditions for the electron heating found experimentally . in total
there are more than 200 successful shots with the on - axis electron above 300ev that have been registered during the reported campaign ; their distribution over the measured temperature is presented in table [ tab ] .
.[tab ] distribution of high - temperature shots in experiments with reduced magnetic field and 700kw ecrh . [ cols="^,^ " , ] in fig.[fig3 ] we show the typical radial profiles of the electron temperature and plasma density measured by the thomson scattering in the central solenoid ( before the ecrh and in 0.6 ms after the ecrh start up ) .
the peaked temperature profile suggests that the microwave power is deposited inside the central region with characteristic radius @xmath22 cm leaving the peripheral plasma intact .
this is in contradiction both to the initial theorecical work @xcite and the low - power experiment @xcite in which the microwave power is spread through the whole plasma cross - section rather than focused in a narrow region around the machine axis .
however , this may be explained by combination of two factors .
first , for the new plasma configuration the ray - tracing indeed predicts that ecrh power deposition has a gap in the core plasma : 30% of total injected power is deposited in a narrow and well localised region close to the plasma axis with @xmath23 cm , 40% of power goes to the peripheral plasma with @xmath24 cm , and the rest power is lost ( not absorbed ) .
another reason for temperature peaking is a reduced central magnetic field in new configuration that results in poor confinement at the plasma periphery as compared to the standard configuration .
it should be stressed , however , that in spite of reduced confining properties of the machine , the power balance indicates that the core plasma is traped in the gas - dynamic regime @xcite .
indeed , assuming that electron energy is lost due to plasma streaming with the ion - acoustic velocity @xmath25 along the magnetic field lines , one can estimate the power density required to support a stationary discharge with a given electron temperature as @xmath26 .
previously this scaling has been proven experimentally for discharges without ecrh @xcite .
then we can compare two discharges , before and during the stable ecrh stage , assuming that only temperature and power are varying , @xmath27 where @xmath28kw is nbi power deposited into electrons without ecrh , and @xmath29kw is the total ecrh and nbi power after the ecrh is switched on .
both powers are calculated by ray - tracing and fast ion slowing down codes for the core plasma region limited by @xmath30 cm ( for plasma profiles shown in fig.[fig3 ] ) .
this simple estimate gives about threefold increase in the electron temperature what is in good agreement with our measurements .
note that the classical heat flux for electrons with a temperature of 500ev corresponds to power losses of few gws , therefore the spitzer thermal conductivity along magnetic field lines is suppressed in our experiment .
radial profiles of the electron temperature and density in the central section of the gdt facility .
our diagnostics resolves one radial point per shot , thus these profiles were obtained as sum over series of identical shots .
to improve reproducibility we use a scenario with a peak electron temperature slightly lower than that indicated in fig.[fig2].,width=321 ] summarizing our experience in ecrh supported discharge at the gdt facility we may conclude that reaching of high electron temperature in an open trap with dense plasma results in degradation of plasma mhd stability .
this problem is manageable but eventually we will have to find some compromise between high temperature and stability in practical applications .
in the present report we aim to demonstrate the highest possible ( in a quasi - stationary discharge ) electron temperature with available resources . to make it possible we focus the microwave power deposition on the plasma axis reaching very high local power density ( up to 20kw/@xmath31 compared to @xmath32kw/@xmath31 typical of purely nbi heating ) .
moreover , ray - tracing calculations reveal a positive feedback : temperature increase results in the better absorbtion and , therefore , the stronger peaking of a temperature profile .
we find that our theoretical understanding of resonant plasma heating has been proven experimentally , thus the proposed novel ecrh scheme works quite robust .
so we are quite confident on straightforward continuation of the experiment by expanding our technical limitations .
returning to the standard magnetic configuration with 0.35 t in the trap center solenoid and further increase of vortex potential will improve overall plasma stability and confinement , what hopefully will allow to operate the ecrh as a routine tool at the gdt device .
the practical goal is to obtain more broad temperature profiles with high electron energy content .
the reported increase of the electron temperature along with previous experiments , which demonstrated plasma confinement with beta as high as 60% , provide a firm basis for extrapolating the gas dynamic trap concept to a fusion relevant applications .
the authors are grateful to prof.m.thumm for his valuable advises concerning physical and technical aspects of ecr heating and to dr.a.anikeev , dr.o.smolyakova , dr.v.malygin and v.orlov for their support and assistance .
we thank all the gdt team participated in the experiment .
we also appreciate encouragement and interest from profs.a.ivanov , a.arzhannikov , d.ryutov , a.molvik and t.s.simonen
. the work is supported by the russian scientific foundation ( pr .
14 - 12 - 01007 ) . 99 f.h.coengsen , t.a.casper , d.l.correll , c.c.damm , a.h.futch , b.glogan , a.w.molvik and c.e.walter , j. fusion energ .
* 8 * , 237 ( 1989 ) p.a.bagryansky , a.a.ivanov , e.p.kruglyakov a.m.kudryavtsev , yu.a.tsidulko , a.v.andriyash , a.l.lukin and yu.n.zouev , fusion eng . des . * 70*(13 ) , ( 2004 ) l.j.perkins , b.g.logan , r.b.campbell , r.s.devoto , d.t.blackfield and b.h.johnson , fusion technol . *
8 * , 685 ( 1985 ) a.beklemishev _ et al .
_ , fusion sci . technol . *
63*(1 t ) , 46 ( 2013 ) l.spitzer , jr .
, _ physics of fully ionized gases , 2d ed . _
( new york : interscience , 1962 ) .
t.c.simonen and r.horton , nucl .
fusion * 29 * , 1373 ( 1989 ) i.k.konkashbaev , i.s.landman and f.r.ulinich , zh . exp .
. fiz . * 74*(3 ) , 956 ( 1978 ) a.v.anikeev , p.a.bagryansky , g.i.kuznetsov and n.v.stupishin , plasma physics reports * 25*(10 ) , 775 ( 1999 ) a.a.ivanov and v.v.prikhodko , plasma phys .
fusion * 55 * , 063001 ( 2013 ) p.a.bagryansky _ et al .
_ , fusion sci . technol . *
63*(1 t ) , 40 ( 2013 ) a.g.shalashov , e.d.gospodchikov , o.b.smolyakova , p.a.bagryansky , v.i.malygin and m.thumm , phys .
plasmas * 19 * , 052503 ( 2012 ) p.a.bagryansky , yu.v.kovalenko , v.ya.savkin , a.l.solomakhin and d.v.yakovlev , nucl .
fusion * 54 * , 082001 ( 2014 ) t.c.simonen , a.anikeev , p.bagryansky , a.beklemishev , a.ivanov , a.lizunov , v.v.maximov , v.prikhodko and yu.tsidulko , j. fusion energ .
* 29 * , 558 ( 2010 ) a.d.beklemishev , p.a.bagryansky , m.s.chaschin and e.i.soldatkina , fusion sci
. technol . * 57 * , 351 ( 2010 ) v.v.mirnov and d.d.ryutov , sov .
* 5 * , 279 ( 1979 ) | we demonstrate plasma discharges with extremely high temperature of bulk electrons at the large axially symmetric magnetic mirror device gdt ( budker institute , novosibirsk ) . according to thomson scattering measurements , the on - axis electron temperature averaged over several sequential shots
is @xmath0ev with peak values exceeding 900ev in few shots .
this corresponds to at least threefold increase as compared to previous experiments both at the gdt and at other comparable machines , thus demonstrating the maximum quasi - stationary ( @xmath1ms ) electron temperature achieved in open traps .
the breakthrough is made possible with application of sophisticated electron cyclotron resonance heating in addition to standard heating by neutral beams .
the reported increase of the electron temperature along with previous experiments , which demonstrated high - density plasma confinement with @xmath2% , provide a firm basis for extrapolating to fusion relevant applications of open magnetic systems . |
in the last few years high resolution x ray spectroscopy has made progress in the exploration of the circumnuclear environment of radio loud ( rl ) agns .
studies performed on obscured rl sources ( grandi et al .
2007 hereafter g07 ; sambruna et al . 2007 ; reeves et al .
2010 hereafter r10 ; piconcelli et al .
2008 ; torresi et al . 2009
; evans et al . 2010 ) revealed photoionized emitting
line gas as responsible for the soft excess , similarly to radio quiet ( rq ) seyfert 2 galaxies . if absorption and emission are processes occurring in the same plasma , as suggested for seyfert galaxies ( kinkhabwala et al .
2002 ) , it is natural to assume that warm absorbers ( wa ) , characterizing at least 50@xmath10 of seyfert 1 spectra , should be present also in unobscured broad line radio galaxies ( blrg ) . with the term warm absorber we intend ionized outflowing gas in our line of sight that produces narrow absorption lines of several elements from c to fe in the soft x ray spectrum . generally , these structures are blueshifted with moderate velocities , v@xmath17100 - 1000 km s@xmath2 ( kaastra et al .
2000 ; kaspi et al . 2002 ; crenshaw et al . 2003 ) , but can reach also v@xmath1810@xmath19 km s@xmath2 ( pounds et al .
2003 ; reeves et al .
2003 , 2010 ; braito et al .
2011 ) when the wind originates directly from the disk .
the detection of was in blrgs was expected to be more difficult than in seyfert 1s , because of the jet .
if it is closer to the line of sight , the doppler boosted , non thermal radiation could mask the absorption features .
+ hints of was have been observed in the past in a handful of rl sources : 3c 382 and 3c 390.3 with _ asca _ ( reynolds 1997 ) ; 3c 351 with _ rosat
_ pspc ( nicastro et al . 1999 ) ; 4c+74.26 with the _ xmm newton _ epic cameras ( ballantyne 2005 ) . + the presence of absorption features in rl agns was confirmed by the high resolution x ray analysis of 3c 382 ( torresi et al .
2010 ; reeves et al . 2009 ) . successively r10 reported the presence of a warm absorber also in 3c 445 .
since the gas has non negligible outflowing velocities , it could contribute in transferring momentum to the environment in addition to the jet .
however to what extent is the wind importance in the energetic budget of powerful rl agns is still an open question . in order to shed some light on this issue , we collect high resolution data from literature and explore the _ xmm newton _ reflection grating spectrometer ( rgs ) archive .
the main goal is to enlarge the sample of rl sources with clear detection of warm absorbers . finally , we attempt a rl / rq comparison of the ionization and kinematic properties of the x ray absorbing gas .
+ the paper is organized as follows : in section 2 the very small sample of blrgs considered throughout the work is described ; the rgs spectral analysis performed on 3c 390.3 and 3c 120 together with the results are reported in section 3 . in section 4
we discuss the physical and energetical properties of blrg was and attempt a first comparison between rl and rq outflows .
the main results of this work are summarized in section 5 .
the cosmological values h@xmath20=71 km s@xmath2 mpc@xmath2 , @xmath21=0.27 , @xmath22=0.73 ( komatsu et al .
2009 ) are assumed throughout .
the sample of blrgs consists of four sources : 3c 390.3 , 3c 120 , 3c 382 and 3c 445 .
the main properties of each object are reported in table 1 , where the redshifts , the jet inclination angles , the black hole masses , the ionizing luminosities between 11000 ry , and the radio luminosities at 151 mhz are listed .
l c c c c c + & z & _ i _ & logm@xmath23@xmath24 & logl@xmath25@xmath26 & logl@xmath27@xmath28 + & & ( degrees ) & ( m@xmath29 ) & ( erg s@xmath2 ) & ( w hz@xmath2 sr@xmath2 ) + _ 3c 445 _ & 0.05623 & @xmath3060@xmath31 & 8.33 & 44.47 & 25.23 + _ 3c 390.3 _ & 0.0561 & 3035@xmath32 & 8.55 & 44.85 & 25.53 + _ 3c 382 _ & 0.0579 & 3545@xmath32 & 9.06 & 45.27 & 25.17 + _ 3c 120 _ & 0.033 & @xmath3021@xmath33 & 7.74 & 44.96 & 25.04 + + + + + + + + + + + + + + 3c 390.3 ( z=0.0561 ; hewitt & burbidge 1991 ) is a classical double lobed frii radio galaxy ( pearson & readhead 1988 ) .
it is one of the closest radio sources whose core exhibits superluminal motion in the pc scale jet ( alef et al .
1996 ) . from the apparent velocity of 3.5c and the core dominance , giovannini et al .
( 2001 ) estimated the jet inclination angle @xmath34 with @xmath350.960.99.=v / c is the bulk velocity in units of the speed of light ( urry @xmath36 padovani 1995 ) . ]
double peaked emission lines characterize the optical and uv spectra of the source ( eracleous & halpern 1994 ; zheng 1996 ; wamsteker et al .
1997 ) , while the uv bump is weak or even absent ( wamsteker et al .
3c 390.3 is known to be variable in the x ray band , with variations in both soft and hard band on a timescale of weeks to months ( leighly & obrien 1997 ; gliozzi et al .
all previous x ray telescopes observed this source . while in the hard x ray band there is a general agreement on the presence of an iron line and reflection hump ( grandi et al .
1999 ; sambruna et al .
2009 ) , the modeling of the soft x
ray band is controversial .
_ einstein _ ( kruper et al . 1990 ) and _ bepposax _ ( grandi et al .
1999 ) required an excess of column density .
_ exosat _ claimed the presence of a soft excess ( ghosh & sondararajaperumal 1991 ) while reynolds ( 1997 ) found hints of warm absorption in the _ asca _ data , successively confirmed by the detection of an absorption edge at 0.65 kev ( sambruna et al .
recently sambruna et al .
( 2009 ) observed an emission line in the rgs spectrum associated with ovii forbidden line possibly produced in the nlr .
3c 120 ( z=0.033 ; burbidge 1967 ) is classified as an fri exhibiting a one sided jet ( seielstad et al .
1979 ; walker et al . 1987
; harris et al . 2004 ) .
the apparent transverse velocity of the jet @xmath37=5.3c , as obtained by the vlba observation ( lister et al .
2009 ) , implies an upper limit on the inclination angle of 21@xmath38 .
the optical spectrum of 3c 120 is typical of seyfert 1 galaxies , with strong and broad emission lines , quite unusual for fri radio sources .
reverberation mapping constrains the black hole mass to be 5.5@xmath39@xmath4010@xmath41 m@xmath29 ( peterson et al .
2004 ) . at uv wavelengths ,
3c 120 has a typical agn spectrum with a strong blue bump and strong emission lines signature of a standard optically
thick geometrically thin accretion disk ( maraschi et al . 1991 ) .
the hard x ray spectrum is characterized by a slightly broadened iron line ( ew@xmath17100 ev ) at 6.4 kev , a weak ionized line at 6.9 kev ( yaqoob & padmanabhan 2004 ; kataoka et al .
2007 ) and compton reflection @xmath42/2@[email protected] ( eracleous et al . 2000 ; zdziarski & grandi 2001 ; gliozzi et al . 2003 ; ballantyne et al . 2004 ) .
the soft x ray band of 3c 120 has been observed by the grating instruments onboard _ chandra _ and _ xmm
newton_. in the _ chandra _ high energy transmission gratings ( hetg ) spectrum an oviii ly@xmath44 absorption line , blueshifted by @xmath17 -5500 km s@xmath2 , was observed ( mckernan et al .
this feature was not revealed in the _ xmm newton_/rgs observation ( ogle et al .
2005 ) , that on the contrary shows a slightly redshifted oviii ly@xmath44 emission structure . 3c 382 ( z=0.0579 ; marzke et al .
1996 ) is a frii lobe - dominated radio galaxy showing a long jet ( 1.68 from the core ) and two radio lobes , with a total extension of 3 ( black et al .
1992 ) . in the optical uv and x ray regimes
there are hints of no strong jet contamination .
the optical spectrum shows broad lines ( fwzi@xmath1825,000 km s@xmath2 ) which are variable on a timescale of months to years .
yee and oke ( 1981 ) suggested the presence of the uv bump from the accretion disk . in the x
ray band 3c 382 is a bright source ( f@xmath45 3@xmath4010@xmath46 erg @xmath6 s@xmath2 ) .
it can be well fitted with a single power law between 210 kev , but shows a strong excess at lower energies ( prieto 2000 ; grandi et al .
2001 ) . in part
this is probably related to an extended emission ( 0.22.4 kev ) revealed by _
rosat / hri _ and _ chandra _ ( prieto 2000 ; gliozzi et al .
the presence of a slow highly ionized outflow in this source was attested by torresi et al .
( 2010 ) using _ xmm
newton_/rgs data , and confirmed by the _ chandra_/hetg spectrum ( reeves et al . 2009 ) .
3c 445 ( z=0.05623 ) is a powerful frii radio galaxy , classified as a blrg because of its broad and intense balmer lines in the optical spectrum . near
ir observations show a substantial reddening of e@xmath47=1 mag and the radio to ir sed indicates a predominance of dust emission with a negligible contribution of synchrotron photons .
the existence of absorbing material is also supported by x
ray data showing a strong depletion of the continuum photons below a few kev .
r10 suggests that the nuclear view could be obscured by an outflowing and clumpy accretion disk wind with high column density ( n@xmath410@xmath48 @xmath6 ) and velocity ( v=10@xmath19 km s@xmath2 ) . in spite of its optical classification ,
3c 445 seems more similar to seyfert 2s than seyfert 1s ( g07 ; sambruna et al .
2007 ) . in agreement with that ,
the soft x
ray excess can be fitted with a mix of emission lines and scattered continuum produced by photoionized gas ( g07 ; r10 ) .
indeed , the presence of the wa in this source was deduced by the detection of a high energy absorption feature around 7 kev . + since was
have been already ascertained in 3c 382 and 3c 445 , here we re analyze the rgs data of 3c 390.3 and 3c 120 .
3c 390.3 was observed by _ xmm newton_/rgs ( den herder et al .
2001 ) on 2004 october 89 for a total exposure of 50 ks and on october 17 for 20 ks .
+ 3c 120 was pointed twice , on 2002 september 6 for 12 ks and on 2003 august 26 for 130 ks . in this paper
we consider only the second and longer observation . +
the rgs1 and rgs2 spectra were extracted using the sas ( v. 9.0.0 ) task _ rgsproc _ , which combines the event lists from all rgs ccd , produces source and background spectra using a region spatially offset from that containing the source , and generates response matrices .
the resulting spectra were analyzed using the fitting package spex ( v.2.0 ) ( kaastra , mewe and nieuwenhuijzen 1996 ) .
the galactic absorption was modeled with the spex hot component . for all spectral models
solar elemental abundances were adopted ( anders & grevesse 1989 ) . for each source
the proper line of sight galactic column density was considered , n@xmath12=3.5@xmath4010@xmath5 @xmath6 and n@xmath12=1.1@xmath4010@xmath49 @xmath6 for 3c 390.3 and 3c 120 , respectively ( kalberla et al . 2005 ) .
the absorption / emission features were searched for following two steps : 1 . a phenomenological approach , consisting in the inspection of the ( data model / error ) residuals after having fitted the continuum ; 2 .
a physical approach , fitting the absorption features with the _ xabs _ model in spex . _ xabs _ calculates the transmission through a gas layer .
free parameters in this model are the outflow velocity ( @xmath50 ) , the total hydrogen column density ( @xmath51 ) and the ionization parameter @xmath13.=@xmath52 , _
l _ is the 1 - 1000 rydberg ( ry ) source ionizing luminosity ( corresponding to 13.6 ev13.6 kev ) , _
n@xmath53 _ is the electron density of the gas and _ r _ is the distance of the gas from the central source . ] in the model the column densities of different ions are linked through an ionization balance , which is precalculated using cloudy ( ferland et al . 1998 ) .
the ionization balance is dependent on the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) of the source .
the uv / x ray seds for both 3c 120 and 3c 390.3 were constructed using both the epic
pn ( strder et al . 2001 ) and the optical monitor ( om ; mason et al .
2001 ) and are shown in fig . 1 . for 3c 390.3
we considered only the longest observation performed on oct .
the data were reduced using the sas ( v. 9.0.0 ) with standard procedures . the light curve over 10 kev was extracted to check high background periods .
the source and the background spectra were extracted from circular regions of 35@xmath54 radius .
backgrounds were taken from a region within the same ccd of the targets and not contaminated by the sources .
the response matrices were created using the sas commands rmfgen and arfgen .
events outside the 0.410 kev band were discarded in the pn spectra of both sources ( guainazzi 2010 ) .
we produced a rough representation of the continuum using a simple absorbed power law for 3c 390.3 ( @xmath551.8 ) and a broken power law ( @xmath56 , @xmath57 with a break at 2.5 kev ) for 3c 120 .
for the purpose of constructing the sed , both continua were then unabsorbed , to obtain the true ionizing x ray flux . for the optical / uv part of the sed we used the om measurements for both
3c 120 ( v and uvw1 filters ) and 3c 390.3 ( u , uvw1 , uvm2 and uvw2 filters ) .
the photometric analysis was performed using the standard procedure within the _ xmm newton _ sas ( v. 9.0.0 ) .
the optical fluxes have been dereddened using the extinction curves of cardelli et al .
( 1989 ) , knowing the optical extinction @xmath58 .
this has been calculated following bohlin et al .
( 1978 ) formula : @xmath59@xmath6 ( for @xmath60 ) .
the low energy tail of the sed ( infra red to radio ) was taken as described in the standard sed used in cloudy ( mathews & ferland 1987 ) . at first the continuum of both observations
was modeled with a power law ( @xmath61 ) plus a neutral absorber ( @xmath62 ) in addition to the galactic one ( c / d.o.f.=583/406 ) .
although during the second pointing ( oct .
17 ) the source flux was about 14@xmath10 lower , the spectral parameters are completely consistent
. a careful inspection of the residuals revealed photon deficits in the regions of nex ( 12.134 ) , fexx ( 12.864 ) , oviii ly@xmath44 ( 18.969 ) and nvi ( 24.898 ) .
an example of absorbed structures is shown in fig . 2 .
in order to confirm the wa detection and constrain physical properties of the wa , the _ xabs _ component was added to the continuum model . the column density of the ionized absorber n@xmath63 , the ionization parameter @xmath13 and the velocity of the gas were let free to vary . the velocity dispersion between different blend components is fixed to the default value v=100 km s@xmath2 .
the covering fraction parameter ( f@xmath64 ) is fixed to the default value equal to 1 .
the fit improves with the addition of the warm absorber with respect to the power law alone , i.e. @xmath65c=18 and 11 for a decrease by 3 in the number of degrees of freedom , corresponding to a significance @xmath1899.6@xmath10 and @xmath1797@xmath10 , for the longest and shortest observations , respectively ( see table 2 and fig . 3 ) .
+ although one phase absorption model well describes the data , we also tested a stratified gas possibility .
actually , the inclusion of a second absorber , with a higher ionization parameter ( log@xmath66 erg cm s@xmath2 ) and column density ( @xmath67 @xmath6 ) seems to better reproduce the shape of the most prominent features .
however , the statistical improvement of the fit is not significant
. finally , we note positive residuals around 23.5 ( observed frame ) in both data sets ( fig . 4 ) .
in agreement with sambruna et al .
( 2009 ) , a narrow gaussian component at the theoretical wavelength of the ovii forbidden line ( table 3 ) is a good parametrization of this emission feature .
l c c c c c c + obs . &
@xmath68 & n@xmath12 & n@xmath63 & log@xmath13 & v & @xmath65c + & & ( 10@xmath5@xmath6 ) & ( 10@xmath5@xmath6 ) & ( erg cm
s@xmath2 ) & ( km s@xmath2 ) & + oct . 8 & [email protected] & [email protected] & 5.5@xmath70 & 2.08@xmath71 & @xmath72600 & 18 + oct .
17 & [email protected] & [email protected] & 3.7@xmath73 & 1.98@xmath74 & @xmath721000 & 11 + l c c c c c + obs . & line & @xmath75 & flux & fwhm & @xmath65c + & & ( ) & ( 10@xmath76 ph @xmath6
s@xmath2 ) & ( ) + oct .
8 & ovii(f ) & 22.101 & 0.56@xmath77 & 0.51@xmath78 & 13 + oct .
17 & ovii(f ) & 22.101 & 0.64@xmath79 & 0.33@xmath80 & 17 + the soft x
ray continuum of 3c 120 is very complex .
an rgs fit with a simple power law absorbed by two neutral absorbers is not a satisfying representation of the data ( c / d.o.f.=803/328 ) .
the spectral shape of the continuum seems to be curved , as suggested by negative residuals around 2326 that is the region where oi edge is expected .
we exclude that this spectral bending can be attributed to a warm absorber .
indeed the _ xabs _ model is not statistically required by the data and left the residuals invariant . following ogle et al .
( 2005 ) , the oxygen abundance of the second absorber was allowed to vary .
the fit greatly improves ( c / d.o.f.=562/327 ) and the oxygen abundance drops to a@[email protected] .
however an inspection of the residuals still reveals emission features in the range 1720 ( fig .
these structures can be fitted with two gaussian lines at the wavelength corresponding to the rest frame positions of fexvii and oviii ly@xmath44 ( see table 4 ) , providing a further improvement of the fit ( c / d.o.f.=449/323 ) . to ascertain the nature of the emitting line gas we tested both collisional ( i ) and photoionized ( ii ) scenarios .
+ ( i ) a single temperature collisional model , cie ( collisional ionization equilibrium ) in spex , was applied instead of two single lines . a thermal component with kt=0.37@xmath82 kev
can not completely take into account the emission features , infact residuals around the fexvii are still present .
a second cie component gives a poor fit c / d.o.f.=520/323 , while a better modeling is provided by a non equilibrium ionization jump model ( neij ) in spex ( c / d.o.f.=498/323 ) .
however , even in this case , there are still positive residuals .
+ ( ii ) if the emitting line gas has a photoionized origin , the emission line at 16.892 could be radiative recombination continuum ( rrc ) from ovii slightly redshifted with respect to the rest frame of the galaxy ( v@xmath17 + 2000 km s@xmath2 ) .
we tested this hypothesis fitting this feature with the rrc model in spex .
since rrcs are narrow and prominent structures in photoionized plasmas , we assumed a typical electron temperature of kt=3 ev .
we fit the rrc emission measure of ovii as a free parameter , however the fit is still not satisfying ( c / d.o.f.=517/324 ) .
we conclude that our proposed models can not reproduce the data better than a single temperature gas plus a gaussian line , c / d.o.f.=440/323 ( see table 4 ) , leaving the exact nature of the emitting line gas still uncertain .
however we exclude that one , or two , plasma components in collisional ionization equilibrium , or even in non
equilibrium , are sufficient to reproduce the soft excess in 3c 120 .
l c c + & model 1 & model 2 + @xmath68 & [email protected] & [email protected] + n@xmath83 & 8.8@xmath84 & [email protected] + a@xmath81 & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath75( ) & 16.892 &
16.892 + flux@xmath26 & 0.66@xmath85 & 0.38@xmath86 + fwhm( ) & 0.27@xmath87 & 0.13@xmath88 + @xmath75( ) & 18.969 &
+ flux@xmath24 & 0.18@xmath89 &
+ fwhm( ) & 0.13@xmath90 &
+ kt(kev ) & & 0.37@xmath82 + + + +
table 5 lists , for each source , column density , ionization parameter , outflow velocity and minimum and maximum radii derived for the was of the studied blrgs . for 3c 390.3
we consider the parameters obtained from the oct .
8 observation for which the fit improvement due to the inclusion of a warm absorber is more significant . for 3c 445 ,
the soft emitting gas properties , derived by r10 , are also listed . in order to establish the location of the emitting / absorbing region , the measured distances of the broad line region ( blr ) and the torus
are also reported .
+ the minimum distance of the wa ( r@xmath91 ) from the central engine is measured from : @xmath92 where m is the black hole mass and assuming that the outflow must have a speed ( v@xmath93 ) greater than or equal to the escape velocity .
+ the maximum distance ( r@xmath94 ) can be estimated assuming that most of the mass of the absorber is concentrated in a thin layer @xmath65r where @xmath65r / r@xmath301 .
the column density is a function of the density of the material n(r ) at ionization parameter @xmath13 , of its volume filling factor ( here assumed equal to 1 ) and of @xmath65r : @xmath95 this combined with the expression of the ionization parameter gives @xmath96 therefore if @xmath65r / r@xmath301 @xmath97 the blr and torus radii are calculated following the prescriptions of ghisellini & tavecchio ( 2008 ) , that simply assume that typical distances scale as the square root of the ionizing disk luminosity : @xmath98 @xmath99 table 5 suggests two immediate considerations : + ( i ) depending on the line of sight , different features are revealed ( see also table 1 ) .
the absorption lines due to photoionization and photoexcitation processes are preferentially observed in sources seen at small _
( i.e. 3c 382 and 3c 390.3 ) . on the contrary ,
the emission lines produced by the inverse processes are dominant in 3c 445 , the only source with seyfert 2 characteristics ( and presumably with the larger jet inclination angle ) .
we note that no wa could be detected in 3c 120 , the blrg in the sample with the smallest inclination angle ( _ _ i__@xmath7221@xmath38 ) and the only one with a @xmath100ray counterpart ( abdo et al .
however this source is quite complex .
indeed the detection of x ray emission lines is at odds with the idea that the jet dominates the soft x
ray emission ; + ( ii ) the location of the ionized outflow is not unique . in 3c 445
the wa was suggested by the detection of a strong edge around 7 kev . the deduced high velocity ( v@xmath93@xmath1710@xmath19 km s@xmath2 ) , high column density ( n@xmath12@xmath1810@xmath48 @xmath6 ) and low ionization parameter ( log@xmath13=1.4 erg cm s@xmath2 ) of the wind indicate a probable origin in the disk ( r10 ) .
on the contrary , in 3c 382 and 3c 390.3 , the absorption features , signatures of an ionized outflow , were found in the soft part of the grating spectra .
the gas has different physical parameters and probably a different origin .
indeed the column densities and ionization parameters vary in the range n@xmath12@xmath10110@xmath102 @xmath6 and log@xmath13=23 erg cm s@xmath2 .
moreover the slower velocities , v@xmath93@xmath1710@xmath103 km s@xmath2 , constrain the location of such gas between the torus and the nlr , favoring the torus wind scenario ( krolik & kriss 2001 ; blustin et al .
2005 hereafter b05 ) .
+ warm absorber energetics are summarized in table 6 .
the mass accretion rate @xmath8 ( l@xmath104l@xmath105=@xmath106c@xmath1 ) was calculated for @xmath107=0.1 . + the mass outflow rate estimates how much mass is carried out of the agn through the wind , and can be expressed as ( b05 ) : @xmath108 we set the solid angle of the outflow @xmath42=2.1 , using the information that @xmath1733@xmath10 of the radio galaxies belonging to the 3cr sample with [email protected] are blrgs ( buttiglione et al .
2009 ) , and assuming that at least 50@xmath10 of the objects possess an outflow as in seyfert 1s .
the volume filling factor c@xmath109 , being unknown , was kept equal to 1 , equivalent to assume an upper limit on @xmath7 .
+ the kinetic energy is the power released in the circumnuclear environment through the outflow and is expressed by : @xmath110 where v@xmath93 is the blueshift velocity measured for the warm absorber .
p@xmath11 is calculated according to the formula of shankar et al .
( 2008 ) adapted from willott et al .
( 1999 ) : @xmath111 l@xmath112 is the observed radio luminosity in units of 10@xmath113 w hz@xmath2 sr@xmath2 at 151 mhz . the factor _
f _ accounts for systematic underestimates of the true jet power .
the average value @xmath72f@xmath18=15 ( hardcastle et al . 2007 ) supports the picture of `` _ _ heavy _
_ '' jets with a dominant protonic component .
+ looking at table 6 , it appears immediately evident that the kinetic luminosity related to slow outflows is always a negligible fraction ( @xmath1141@xmath10 ) of both bolometric luminosity and jet kinetic power and that the radiative power is generally larger than the kinetic one .
shankar et al . (
2008 ) proposed to directly link the kinetic power of the ejecting material ( jets , winds ) to the rest mass energy of the accreting matter .
if this is the case , p@xmath11 can also be expressed in terms of accretion energy : p@xmath11=@xmath115c@xmath1 ( we do not take into account the wind , as its energetic contribution is not important ) .
then , the ratio between p@xmath11 and l@xmath116 directly expresses @xmath117 .
this efficiency ratio is generally @xmath118 , suggesting that accretion power could be preferentially channeled in radiation rather than in jet kinetic power ( at least in these sources ) . assuming @xmath107 equal to 0.1 ( typical value of standard accretion disks ) , @xmath119 ranges between 0.010.06 .
however if accretion disk winds are energetically important ( see section 4.3 ) the kinetic ( jet + wind ) power could compete with the radiative power .
here we compare the x ray properties of blrgs studied in this work with a sample of type 1 rq agns ( seyfert 1s , nls1s , qsos ) having a good modeling of the wa .
we chose the sample already studied by b05 with the addition of the seyfert 1.2 ic4329a taken from mckernan et al .
( 2007 ) . among the sources exhibiting signatures of warm absorption as reported by mckernan et al .
, ic4329a is the only one not in common with b05 .
very recently , a possible detection of a fast outflow in mr2251178 has been proposed by gofford et al .
( 2011 ) on the basis of _ suzaku _ data . for this source , belonging to the b05 sample , we however prefer to consider only the wa physical parameters derived by the _ xmm newton_/rgs analysis ( kaspi et al . 2004 , b05 ) . for the sake of consistency , when a source has a multi phase outflow , only the higher phase , similar to blrgs ( log@xmath13=2 - 2.9 erg cm s@xmath2 ) , is considered .
it is important to note that , in this case , the estimated mass outflow rates refer only to the higher phases , neglecting the contribute of mass outflow rates related to lower ionization parameters .
+ however , even considering the averaged warm absorber parameters the final result does not change .
the mass outflow rates and the related kinetic powers of rq objects in table 4 of b05 are rescaled to a volume filling factor equal to 1 in order to match our assumption .
we keep the small ( and of no consequence ) difference between the solid angle of blrgs ( @xmath42=2.1 ) and seyferts / qsos ( @xmath42=1.6 ) , both estimated on the basis of similar considerations .
fixing c@xmath120=1 , the rq mass outflow rates are obviously shifted to larger values . + as shown in fig .
6 ( _ upper panel _ ) , all the sources have large ( and implausible ) mass outflow rates exceeding the mass accretion rates even more than one order of magnitude implying , also for rl sources , a non uniform distribution of the photoionized gas .
we can deduce a blrg volume filling factor as small as @xmath170.01 , simply assuming that the same amount of matter is accreted and ejected as wind from the nuclear region ( i.e. @xmath121 with @xmath107=0.1 ) .
+ in both rl and rq agns , the kinetic energy associated to the slow winds is negligible with respect to the radiative luminosity , even considering a uniform gas distribution ( c@xmath120=1 ) ( fig .
6 _ lower panel _ ) .
there are only three sources , pg 1211 + 143 , pg 0844 + 349 and 3c 445 , for which @xmath122(@xmath123l@xmath105 ) . in these objects
the winds have velocities of several thousands km s@xmath2 , in spite of the presence / absence of a powerful jet , and are probably directly connected to the accretion disk ( pounds et al . 2003a , b ) .
these disk winds are extremely energetic , unless they have small covering factors and/or are transient phenomena . indeed ,
in blrgs persistent disk outflows covering large solid angles could even compete with the jets in trasferring momentum to the circumnuclear environment .
+ in order to further investigate the role of the relativistic jet , we explore a possible correlation between the mass outflow rate and the radio loudness parameter ( r ) .
we adopt a radio loudness : @xmath124\ ] ] as proposed by terashima & wilson ( 2003 ) . for rq agns ,
we use the 210 kev x
ray luminosities as measured by bianchi et al .
( 2009 ) , while we refer to torresi et al .
( 2010 ) and to this paper for the x ray luminosities of 3c 382 and 3c 390.3 , respectively .
+ the 5 ghz luminosities of rl and rq sources are taken from kellermann et al .
( 1969 ) and from ulvestad et al .
( 1984 ) , respectively . for rq objects , when the luminosity at 5 ghz is not available , we extrapolate it from the 1.4 ghz luminosity as reported in the nrao / vla sky survey catalogue ( nvss ; condon et al .
1998 ) by assuming @xmath44=0 ( nagar , wilson & falcke 2001 ) .
we notice that different assumptions on the radio spectral slope do not affect the radio loudness estimation . indeed even using @xmath44=0.8 , given the dispersion of spectral indexes for agns ( kukula et al .
1998 ) , the estimated r values are completely consistent with those obtained for @xmath44=0 .
+ we consider blrgs and type 1 agns having slow outflows ( v@xmath93=10@xmath103 km s@xmath2 ) and similar phases .
disk winds are not taken into account here because we have only three sources . in fig .
7 the mass outflow rates of both rl and rq agns are plotted as a function of the radio loudness .
this plot suggests a possible difference between the two classes .
indeed the average @xmath7 value of rq objects is @xmath174 m@xmath29 yr@xmath2 , much lower than that of blrgs that is around 25 m@xmath29 yr@xmath2 .
+ when the spearman @xmath125 test and the generalized kendall @xmath126 test in the astronomy survival analysis ( asurv ) package ( feigelson et al . 1985 ; isobe et al . 1986 ; lavalley et al . 1992 ) are applied to data , a possible positive correlation between @xmath7 and r is suggested .
the resulting significance is @xmath127=0.05 and @xmath128=0.02 , respectively .
the correlation is assumed to be significant if equal or below 0.05 .
this trend could simply reflect differences in the gas distribution , tending to preferentially clump when the system is less perturbed by the jet , given the dependence of @xmath7 on the volume filling factor .
alternatively , if the geometry of the gas is similar in both rq and rl objects , the observed correlation would indicate that larger amount of mass escapes from the nuclear region when the jet production mechanism is more efficient .
we notice that the ionization parameter , the outflow velocity and the ionizing luminosity are not correlated with r ( significance of correlation 0.4 , 0.8 and 0.2 , respectively , according to the generalized kendall @xmath126 test ) .
l c c c c c c c + & log n@xmath129 & log @xmath13 & v@xmath93 & r@xmath91 & r@xmath94 & r@xmath130 & r@xmath131 + & ( @xmath6 ) & ( erg cm s@xmath2 ) & ( km s@xmath2 ) & ( pc ) & ( pc ) & ( pc ) & ( pc ) + _ 3c 445 _ ( em ) & 22.0 & 3 ; 1.8 & + 150@xmath24;-430@xmath26 & - & @xmath720.01@xmath28 ; @xmath170.1@xmath31 & 0.02 & 0.45 + _ 3c 445 _ ( wa ) & 23.3 & 1.4 & -10@xmath19 & 0.01 & - & - & - + _ 3c 390.3 _ ( wa ) & 20.7 & 2.08 & @xmath72 - 600 & @xmath1329 & @xmath30450 & 0.03 & 0.7 + _ 3c 382 _ ( wa ) & 22.5 & 2.69 & -1000 & @xmath13210 & @xmath3044 & 0.05 & 1.5 + _ 3c 120 _ & - & - & - & -&- & 0.03 & 0.8 + + + + + + + l c c c c c c + & log@xmath7 & log@xmath9 & log l@xmath133 & @xmath8 & log p@xmath11 & @xmath134 + & ( m@xmath29 yr@xmath2 ) & ( erg s@xmath2 ) & ( erg s@xmath2 ) & ( m@xmath29 yr@xmath2 ) & ( erg s@xmath2 ) & + _ 3c 445 _ & 2.90 c@xmath109 & 46.4 & 45.10 & 0.2@xmath26 & 44.88 & 0.06 + _ 3c 390.3 _ & 1.40 c@xmath109 & 41.66 & 45.65 & 0.77 & 45.12 & 0.03 + _ 3c 382 _ & 1.41 c@xmath109 & 41.91 & 45.84 & 1.2 & 44.81 & 0.01 + _
3c 120 _ & - & - & 45.34 & 0.37 & 44.71 & 0.02 + + + + +
in this work we report the detection of a warm absorber in the blrg 3c 390.3 .
this is the third outflow observed after 3c 382 and 3c 445 . on the contrary 3c 120
, the blrg with the smallest jet inclination angle ( _ _ i__@xmath13521@xmath38 ) shows a complex soft x
ray spectrum only modified by a structured galactic cold gas , without signatures of warm ionized absorption .
+ we discuss the physical and energetical properties of the warm absorbers found in three blrgs , 3c 390.3 , 3c 382 and 3c 445 : * depending on the outflow velocities the absorbing gas has different locations : the nlr / torus for slower outflows ( 3c 390.3 and 3c 382 ) , and the accretion disk for 3c 445 .
interestingly , these winds have been detected in different spectral regions , i.e. the nlr / torus winds in the soft x
ray band ( 0.32 kev ) , while the accretion disk wind above 6 kev ( r10 ) ; * the mass outflow rate ( @xmath7 ) of the absorbers is higher than the mass accretion rate ( @xmath8 ) , implying that we are overestimating the volume filling factor c@xmath109 , here assumed equal to 1 but probably much less than 1 ; * even considering upper limits on @xmath7 , the kinetic luminosity associated with the slow outflows is always lower than the accretion luminosity and the jet kinetic power .
aware of the scarcity of rl sources with was , we attempt a first comparison with a sample of type 1 rq agns : * fixing c@xmath109=1 , the mass outflow rates have implausibly large values in both rl and rq agns , suggesting a clumpy gas configuration in all agns independently of their radio power ; * in both seyferts / qsos and blrgs , the kinetic luminosity related to slow outflows is always negligible with respect to the accretion luminosity ( and the jet kinetic power for rl agns ) ; * fast accretion disk winds are observed in agns , independently of the rl or rq classification ( fig .
the associated kinetic energies appear to be huge ( @xmath136 l@xmath105 ) ( unless these fast outflows have small covering factors and/or are transient phenomena ) ; * although the rl and rq wa properties are very similar ( at least at zeroth order ) , the mass outflow rate ( @xmath7 ) and the radio loudness parameter ( r ) seem to be correlated ( fig .
7 ) indicating a possible effect of a strong radio source on the outflowing winds .
considering that @xmath7 depends on the covering factor , this result could simply indicate a different gas distribution in rl and rq sources , with the wa being clumpier in absence of a strong radio source .
alternatively , if the gas distribution is the same , the correlation could suggest that powerful jets favor the escape of more massive ( but not necessarily more energetic ) winds .
the anonymous referee is gratefully acknowledged for thoughtful comments on the manuscript .
we warmly thank jelle kaastra for accurate and constructive comments and suggestions .
we thank kazushi iwasawa for valuable and useful discussions .
et is grateful to adriano de rosa for providing constant technical assistance . _
xmm newton _ is an esa science mission with instruments and contributions directly funded by esa member states and nasa .
et acknowledges the support of the italian space agency ( contract asi / inaf i/009/10/0 and asi / glast i/017/07/0 ) . | we review the soft x ray properties of 3c 390.3 , 3c 120 , 3c 382 and 3c 445 , the only broad line radio galaxies ( blrg ) for which good quality gratings data are currently available .
the _ xmm newton_/rgs data of 3c 390.3 and 3c 120 were re analyzed searching for warm absorbers , already discovered in 3c 382 and 3c 445 .
we confirm the absence of ionized absorption features in 3c 120 , but find signatures of outflowing gas ( v@xmath0 10@xmath1 km s@xmath2 ) in 3c 390.3 .
its warm absorber ( log@xmath3 2 erg cm s@xmath2 , n@xmath4 10@xmath5 @xmath6 ) , similar to that observed in 3c 382 , is probably placed in the narrow line regions .
its gas content is slower and less dense than the accretion disk wind discovered in 3c 445 . independently from the location of the warm gas , the outflowing masses ( @xmath7 ) of blrgs are significantly ( but improbably ) predominant with respect to the accretion masses ( @xmath8 ) , suggesting a clumpy configuration of the warm absorber .
however , even assuming overestimated values of @xmath7 , the kinetic luminosity of the outflow ( @xmath9 ) is well below 1@xmath10 of the kinetic power of the jet ( p@xmath11 ) .
thus , the jet remains the major driver of the radio loud agn feedback at least on pc scale and beyond .
the warm absorber parameters ( n@xmath12 , @xmath13 ) of blrgs span similar range of values of type 1 radio quiet agns
. however , when the mass outflow rate of blrgs and seyfert 1s is plotted as a function of the radio loudness , r = log [ @xmath14 l@xmath15/l@xmath16 $ ] , the mass outflow rate seems to increase with radio power .
galaxies : active x - rays : galaxies galaxies : general galaxies : radio galaxies techniques : spectroscopic |
the critical phenomena , typical of many body systems , have attracted remarkable scientific interest since a long time .
the monte carlo ( mc ) stochastic techniques @xcite serve to estimate thermodynamic averages from samples of the configuration space .
many advanced simulation approaches are rooted in elementary updates of metropolis algorithm @xcite , which generates a markovian chain of spin configurations .
most of the efforts try to improve mc method within the critical region .
the efficiency of mc method have been increased by the development of sampling and data processing techniques .
the reweighting technique applied anew to classical statistical systems @xcite enables to perform a random sampling for one distribution function , and to calculate quantities of interest for similar distributions . to be more concrete ,
let us assume that a sample of @xmath0 configurations ( @xmath1 ) of quantity @xmath2 have been accumulated for a fixed temperature @xmath3 .
the samples @xmath4 are used to construct a continuous temperature @xmath5 dependence of a single histogram approximation @xmath6 of the canonical thermodynamic average @xmath7 .
the interpolation called `` _ reweighting on the fly _ '' @xcite is based on the formula @xmath8 } { \displaystyle \sum_{q=1}^{n } \exp \left [ \frac{e_q}{t_t}\left(1 - \frac{t_t}{t } \right ) \right]}\ , , \label{reweight1}\ ] ] where @xmath9 is the energy ( in boltzmann constant units ) of configuration @xmath10 .
because of the finite length of the mc run , eq .
( [ reweight1 ] ) provides reliable results only for a relatively narrow range of @xmath5 values around @xmath3 .
when @xmath5 differs too much from @xmath3 , it causes an increase of the statistical errors and may lead to unreliable results .
the reliable range of @xmath5 values also decreases as the system size increases @xcite . a qualitative study in ref .
has shown that reweighting causes a systematic shift in the height and the location of the specific heat peak , which depends on the relative position of @xmath3 and @xmath5 .
it turns out that the shift decreases as @xmath11 only for @xmath0 much larger than the number of degrees of freedom .
systematic errors , eventually affected by sampling autocorrelations , may also take place at finite @xmath0 . the first quantitative study of the statistical errors in reweighted data @xcite has demonstrated that theoretical calculation of the error is both difficult and time consuming so it may not be justified for all studies . in this paper
we present rather general iterative treatment based on the single histogram reweighting which implicitly takes into account both the systematic errors of reweighting and the statistical errors to generate stochastic fluctuations near a critical point .
a well known systematic error , present in the histogram method , is an overestimation ( underestimation ) of @xmath12 when @xmath13 ( @xmath14 ) , respectively @xcite .
this fact and the general idea of feedback regulation @xcite are used to construct an iterative algorithm .
the aim of the suggested method is to estimate the critical temperature or other parameters of interest , as well as to perform an analysis and partial elimination of their errors .
the method combines single reweighting , linear filtering and an iterative treatment .
the incorporation of iterations is inspired by a general class of probabilistic models @xcite .
the iterations generate data that are further analyzed in terms of a suggested autoregressive moving average ( arma ) model .
the single - spin flip metropolis algorithm is applied here in order to obtain averages for moderate lattice sizes .
the cluster methods are not used due to the efficiency reasons discussed in ref . .
the efficiency of the algorithm should also be increased by hybrid schemes @xcite . however , because of many side effects that can show up , a separate study of hybrid schemes is needed .
the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ general_scheme ] the iterative self - organized algorithm is suggested . in sec .
[ sec : model ] the autoregressive phenomenological model of the stochastic iterative search process is proposed and the corresponding relations for second - order statistics are derived . the model is used to parametrize mc data obtained for ferromagnetic 2d ising spin models on @xmath15 square lattices ( see sec .
[ sec : details ] ) .
we start by defining a process where temperature is driven by some response function .
the stochastic process can be formally described by the second - order recursive formula @xmath16 it generates sequence @xmath17 .
the stochastic function @xmath18 , which provides a _ preliminary histogrammatic _
estimate @xmath19 of unknown critical temperature @xmath20 , is defined implicitly by @xmath21 the key point of the reweighting is to localize the extremal value of the response function @xmath22 evaluated for @xmath0 mc samples .
commonly , the response function can be defined by the first and second moments of energy or magnetization , respectively .
the role of filtering , defined by the plasticity parameter @xmath23 in eq .
( [ adap1 ] ) , is to weaken fluctuations @xcite of the @xmath19 sequence .
let us assume the invariant probability distribution function ( pdf ) of the form @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the kronecker s symbol and @xmath26 is the arithmetic average ( which differs from standard thermodynamic average @xmath27 ) . from now on @xmath20
is associated with pseudocritical temperature @xmath28 of the specific heat . for gaussian - like @xmath29
we suppose @xmath30 as mentioned above , the specific heat can be estimated within a histogram reweighting approach using the fluctuation - dissipation relation @xmath31 at the thermodynamic limit @xmath32 , the iterative process becomes deterministic and tends to an unique fixed point @xmath33 . for finite @xmath0 ,
a convergence criterion have to be formulated in a pure statistical sense .
the variance @xmath34 has been chosen as a suitable measure that reflects the convergence .
the iterative process , described by eqs .
( [ eqrecur1 ] ) , ( [ adap1 ] ) , ( [ objec1 ] ) supplemented by eq .
( [ objec2 ] ) , consists of nonlinear and stochastic rules . as an auxiliary tool of analysis , let us introduce a phenomenological model to parameterize the simulated statistics . within the model , the explicit form of the stochastic function [ see eq .
( [ eqrecur1 ] ) ] is @xmath35 where an additive noise @xmath36 describes uncertainty .
the convergence rate towards @xmath20 is determined by the parameter @xmath37 , which contains information of the systematic reweighting error . from eqs .
( [ eqrecur1 ] ) , ( [ adap1 ] ) and eq .
( [ model_alg ] ) follows that @xmath38 where the noise term is controlled by the coefficient @xmath23 .
the model discussed here can be considered as an application of arma(1,1 ) model @xcite .
the solution of eq .
( [ model_2 ] ) can be written simply as @xmath39 where @xmath40 .
the above formula , written for any @xmath36 dependence , is general . at this point ,
let us consider the statistical properties of gaussian noise for @xmath36 specified by @xmath41 where @xmath42 . within the limit of a second order statistics in @xmath3 , from eq .
( [ solutt1 ] ) and eq .
( [ firstxi1 ] ) , follows @xmath43 therefore , the stationary regime is defined by the invariance @xmath44 , which stays in agreement with eq .
( [ tavel1 ] ) . if the solution given by eq .
( [ solutt1 ] ) is substituted into eq .
( [ disp1 ] ) , one obtains @xmath45 which is equivalent to the recursion @xmath46 .
terms proportional to @xmath47 describe a _
transient regime _ of the initial temperature @xmath48 , which the system forgets exponentially fast .
terms @xmath49 and @xmath50 are deterministic and stochastic contribution to @xmath51 , respectively .
the variance @xmath51 remains finite for @xmath52 if @xmath53 , that is if @xmath54 . the transient regime can be characterized by @xmath55 whereas , to obtain the stationary regime , one needs to calculate @xmath56 it results that @xmath57 diverges at @xmath58 or equivalently @xmath59 .
the characteristic transient time , @xmath60 follows from its definition @xmath61 .
the transient time has a singularity for @xmath62 and @xmath63 . in this
limit the model describes immediate convergence ( @xmath64 ) and variance @xmath65 . a singular parametric line , @xmath66 , splits region @xmath53 into alternating ( @xmath67 ) and unidirectional convergence ( @xmath68 ) of @xmath3 near @xmath20 . regarding the convergence properties , it is useful to introduce @xmath69 as the value of the _ highest initial convergence rate _ , defined by the condition @xmath70 .
this yields @xmath71 for this extremal value is @xmath72 .
finally , we introduce some supplementary remarks about the limit of the vanishing error . clearly , for @xmath73 we assume @xmath74 . the consequence of eqs .
( [ eq : var_infty ] ) and ( [ time_ch ] ) is @xmath75 , that implies @xmath76 .
unfortunately , because of @xmath77 this can not be attained in practice .
in order to explore the proposed model by numerical simulation , we chose the 2d ising model with the metropolis algorithm as testing ground .
most of the data are accumulated on square lattices of linear dimension @xmath78 and periodic boundary conditions .
the methodology is expected to be quite general and of straightforward application for both discrete and continuous systems .
every iteration step @xmath79 of algorithm , based on eq .
( [ eqrecur1 ] ) and eq .
( [ adap1 ] ) , consists of the following main blocks ( i)-(iv ) : _ equilibration _ that includes @xmath80 mcss ( monte carlo steps per spin ) for constant @xmath3 .
_ accumulation _ of @xmath0 pairs @xmath81 into histograms . in order to reduce autocorrelations ,
successive samples are separated by one mcss .
_ localization _ of the maximum @xmath82 by a gradient algorithm .
recall , that @xmath22 is computed from eq .
( [ reweight1 ] ) and eq .
( [ objec2 ] ) for @xmath12 and @xmath83 .
_ prediction _ of next @xmath84 using the filtering given by eq .
( [ adap1 ] ) .
[ initconv1 ] illustrates the properties of _ transient regimes _ , which are affected by the choice of @xmath48 and @xmath23 .
the @xmath23-dependences of @xmath85 are presented in fig .
[ fig : var_1](a ) .
one may see that the agreement of the simulated data with eq .
( [ eq : var_1 ] ) is quite satisfactory .
typical values of the parameters determined by the fit are gathered in table [ tab : par ] . for @xmath86 , we observe that @xmath87 , which is in agreement with our expectations . the insert of fig .
[ fig : var_1](b ) illustrates the dependence of @xmath88 with the special cases @xmath89 and @xmath90 , which clearly coincide with eq .
( [ eq : eta_m ] ) .
additional numerical study reveals the discrepancy for @xmath91 , that is caused by a non - trivial decrease of @xmath37 by decreasing @xmath48 ( @xmath92 ) .
the @xmath0-dependence depicted in fig .
[ fig : var_1](b ) is constructed for an initial value @xmath93 .
there is a certain @xmath0 value for which @xmath94 and iterations cross from alternating to unidirectional convergence . in other words ,
statistical errors compensate systematic ones . in agreement with ref .
, we have verified statistical errors of mc averages to be proportional to @xmath95 , which implies @xmath96 .
actually , the fit provides @xmath97 .
if the number of iterations is much larger than @xmath98 , the initial conditions are forgotten and thus invariant pdf s of temperature variable are formed ( see inset in fig .
[ fig : var_infty ] ) .
the calculation of @xmath99 ( @xmath100 ) is controlled by @xmath23 .
we have verified @xmath101 for the _ stationary regime_. the error increases monotonically with @xmath23 for a given @xmath0 as in fig .
[ fig : var_infty ] .
we have compared the simulation and analytical @xmath23-dependences of @xmath57 for @xmath102 and @xmath37 , given in table [ tab : par ] , and those determined by a fit of eq .
( [ eq : var_infty ] ) for @xmath103 .
the comparison reveals a discrepancy of the @xmath102 parameter determination .
the @xmath102 parameter , determined by the fit of eq .
( [ eq : var_infty ] ) to numerical data , increases its value about @xmath104 .
a further extension of the model , e.g. taking into account a weak colored noise , should eliminate this distinction . according to eq .
( [ tavel1 ] ) , the mean values of invariant pdf s ( see inset in fig . [
fig : var_infty ] ) were used to estimate @xmath105 .
the method is straightforward applied for @xmath106 .
subsequently , the values @xmath28 are interpolated by the finite size formula @xmath107 .
this yields to estimate the thermal coefficient @xmath108 and the critical temperature as @xmath109 .
the last estimation stays in a satisfactory agreement with exact value @xmath110^{-1}=0.56729 $ ] .
the problem of critical indices can be handled effectively in the frame of a two - lattice iterative algorithm , too @xcite . in that case , the objective function given by eq .
( [ objec1 ] ) has to be written in terms of the binder cumulant , @xmath111 , we considered , as an example , the exponent @xmath112 of the correlation length @xmath113}{\ln\left(l_1/l_2\right ) } \ , .
\label{eq : nu}\ ] ] within the proposed algorithm , we generated a sequence of estimates ( for each iteration step separately ) of the critical exponent for the lattice pair @xmath114 .
considering the peak of nonsymmetric pdf of @xmath115 we determined @xmath116 with a relative error of @xmath117 .
an iterative process that is useful around the critical point and includes metropolis single spin - flip algorithm , single - histogram reweighting and linear filtering is studied numerically .
the properties of this iterative algorithm are studied for the 2d ising ferromagnetic model on a square lattice .
the total errors in the estimate of pseudocritical temperature are obtained .
we demonstrated how the accuracy can be affected by @xmath23 .
however , one should be careful with an extremely small @xmath23 to avoid an enormous increase of transient time .
our analysis demonstrates that it is insufficient to use several reweighting trials to estimate total errors .
the most interesting iterations are of this kind that compensate the systematic errors introduced by the histogram reweighting approach . despite of the success of the linearized model , which allows interpretation of numerical data , further improvement of the proposed methodology
is still expected .
for instance , one should take into account non - linear corrections in eq .
( [ model_2 ] ) and/or the colored noise ( that is , with autocorrelations of error terms ) in eq .
( [ eq : whitenoise ] ) .
we believe that nontrivial dependences of @xmath37 and @xmath118 ( see e.g. inset of fig .
[ fig : var_1](b ) ) could be further explained considering microscopic expression for the density of states @xcite .
the authors would like to thank the slovak grant agency vega ( grant no .
1/2009/05 ) and the agency apvt-51 - 052702 and the internal grant of the faculty of sciences of afrik university vvgs 2003 for financial support .
the authors express their thanks to unknown referee for valuable corrections and suggestions
. 00 k. binder , d.w .
heermann , _ monte carlo simulation in statistical physics _
( springer , berlin , 1998 ) .
n. metropolis , a.w .
rosenbluth , m.n .
rosenbluth , a.h .
teller , _ j. chem
. phys . _ * 21 * , 1087 ( 1953 ) . z.w .
salsburg , j.d .
jacobson , w. fickett , w.w .
wood , _ j. chem .
_ * 30 * , 65 ( 1959 ) ; + a.m. ferrenberg , r.h .
swendsen , _ phys .
lett . _ * 61 * , 2635 ( 1988 ) .
a.m. ferrenberg , r.h .
swendsen , _ phys .
lett . _ * 63 * , 1195 ( 1989 ) .
a.m. ferrenberg , d.p .
landau , r.h .
swendsen , _ phys .
e _ * 51 * , 5092 ( 1995 ) .
a.m. ferrenberg , d.p .
landau , _ phys .
b _ * 44 * , 5081 ( 1991 ) . d.p .
landau , _ journ .
mater . _ * 200 * , 231 ( 1999 ) .
mnger , m.a .
novotny , _ phys .
b _ * 43 * , 5773 ( 1991 ) .
kadanoff , _ physics today _ ( march 1991 ) , p. 9 .
h. robbins , s. munroe , _ ann .
* 22 * , 400 ( 1951 ) .
n. ito , g.a .
kohring , _ int .
c _ * 5 * , 1 ( 1994 ) .
plascak , a.m. ferenberg , d.p .
landau , _ phys .
e _ * 65 * , 066702 ( 2002 ) .
principe , n.r .
euliano , w.c .
lefebvre , _ neural and adaptive systems : fundamentals through simulations _ ( john wiley & sons , inc .
brockwell , r.a .
davis , _ introduction to time series and forecasting _
( springer , new york , 1996 ) .
d. horvth , m. gmitra , z. kuscsik , _ czech .
j. phys . _
* 54 * , 921 ( 2004 ) ; + d. horvth , m. gmitra , _ int . j. mod .
c _ * 15 * , 1269 ( 2004 ) .
beale , _ phys .
lett . _ * 76 * , 78 ( 1997 ) . | we present iterative monte carlo algorithm for which the temperature variable is attracted by a critical point .
the algorithm combines techniques of single histogram reweighting and linear filtering .
the 2d ising model of ferromagnet is studied numerically as an illustration . in that case , the iterations uncovered stationary regime with invariant probability distribution function of temperature which is peaked nearly the pseudocritical temperature of specific heat . the sequence of generated temperatures is analyzed in terms of stochastic autoregressive model .
the error of histogram reweighting can be better understood within the suggested model .
the presented model yields a simple relation , connecting variance of pseudocritical temperature and parameter of linear filtering . |
[ [ section ] ] higher energy gains , reduced energy spread , smaller emittance and better stability of laser- plasma accelerated electrons@xcite are critical issues to address for future development and applications of compact particle accelerators and radiation sources@xcite .
plasma density perturbation as a means of controlling electron acceleration@xcite and electron injection@xcite in laser - generated plasma wakefield is an active research topic .
radial density gradients can modify the structure of wakefields and influence the process of injection by wavebreaking through a dependence of the plasma wavelength on the transverse co - ordinate@xcite .
injection of electrons into a narrow phase space region of the wakefield is necessary for generating accelerated electron bunches with good quality in terms of energy spread and divergence .
decreasing density profile along the laser propagation direction can lead to controlled injection of electrons and is expected to generate electron bunches with better beam quality in comparison to self - injection in a homogeneous plasma by reducing the threshold of injection within a narrow phase region of the wakefield@xcite .
[ [ section-1 ] ] injection in a longitudinally inhomogeneous plasma can offer the flexibility of a simpler experimental configuration and less stringent spatio - temporal synchronisation requirements as compared to other controlled injection techniques based on secondary laser pulses in orthogonal@xcite and counterpropagating@xcite geometries or with external magnetic - fields@xcite .
recently electrons injected in the density gradient at the exit of a gas- jet@xcite have been post - accelerated in a capillary - discharge based secondary accelerating stage@xcite .
the original proposal for density - gradient injection was based on density scale lengths greater than the plasma wavelength@xcite .
steep gradients in density , with scale lengths shorter than the plasma wavelength , can also lead to electron injection@xcite .
such sharp density gradients have been experimentally generated by shock - fronts created with a knife - edge obstructing the flow from the gas - jet nozzle and used to improve the quality of accelerated electrons@xcite .
[ [ section-2 ] ] recent experimental studies@xcite validated the use of plasma perturbation in the form of a density - depleted channel for injecting electrons@xcite into the wakefield of a pump beam propagating across the channel walls . in this article
, we report on results extending that experiment by changing the position of the plasma channel along the laser wakefield axis .
the density depleted channel was created with a machining laser beam that propagates orthogonal to the pump beam . by changing the plasma channel position ,
the injection location was varied and thereby the subsequent accelerating distance .
this method allowed for inducing controlled electron injection and generating quasi - monoenergetic electron beams with a fine control of their energy .
the variation of electron energy with acceleration length in our modified configuration compared to previous experiments@xcite , was similarly used to estimate the accelerating field strength . it was observed that a threshold plasma length prior to depletion region was necessary for density - gradient injection to be effective whereas the final electron beam parameters such as energy - spread , divergence and charge were independent of injection location .
[ [ section-3 ] ] the experiments were performed at the laboratoire doptique applique with the @xmath5 tw , @xmath5 fs , @xmath6 hz , @xmath7 @xmath8 m , ti : sapphire salle - jaune " laser system@xcite .
the pump and machining beams , propagating orthogonal to each other , are focused onto a supersonic helium gas - jet ejected from a @xmath9 mm diameter conic nozzle@xcite . the density profile as characterised by michelson interferometry
has a plateau of length @xmath10 mm with @xmath11 @xmath8 m density gradients at the edges@xcite .
the pump beam with an energy of approximately @xmath12 j is focused by a @xmath13 cm focal length spherical mirror ( f@xmath14 ) and the machining beam with an energy of @xmath15 mj is focused by a cylindrical lens system , with a tunable time - delay between the two beams .
the fwhm spot size of the pump beam was estimated to be @xmath16 @xmath8 m @xmath17 @xmath18 @xmath8 m with a peak - intensity of approximately @xmath19 @xmath17 @xmath20 w/@xmath21(normalised vector potential @xmath22 @xmath23 @xmath24 ) .
the cylindrical focusing system for the machining beam consists of two cylindrical lenses ( focal lengths of @xmath25 mm and @xmath26 mm ) , placed in series such that it generates a line focus of tunable length ( fwhm @xmath27 @xmath15-@xmath28 @xmath8 m ) by varying the separation between the two lenses .
the line focus of the machining beam is oriented in a direction orthogonal to the plane defined by the pump and machining beam axis , whereas the transverse width ( fwhm spot- size @xmath23 @xmath5 @xmath8 m ) of the line is aligned along the pump pulse propagation direction .
the peak- intensity in the line focus estimated to be around @xmath29 @xmath17 @xmath30 w/@xmath21 ( @xmath22 @xmath23 @xmath31 ) .
the schematic experimental setup consisting of the machining and pump beam along with a probe beam ( picked off from the pump beam ) for nomarski plasma interferometry@xcite is shown in fig .
[ fig : schematic : setup ] . .
accelerated electrons from the gas - jet are dispersed by the magnet and detected by a lanex phosphor screen.,width=321 ] [ [ section-4 ] ] the machining laser pulse ionizes the gas - jet and creates a hot plasma localized in the line focal volume that hydrodynamically expands into the surrounding neutral gas .
this leads to the formation of a density depleted channel with an inner lower density region surrounded by an expanding higher plasma density channel wall@xcite .
therefore the pump beam sees a longitudinal density- gradient at the edges of the channel as it propagates in a direction perpendicular to the machining beam .
the density depletion at the focus of the machining beam creates the axial density gradient ( for the pump beam ) that induces injection of electrons into the wakefield generated by pump pulse . a schematic picture of the experimental target configuration with the preformed density - depletion region is shown in fig .
[ fig : schematic : tgtconfig ] .
the position of the density depleted channel and thereby the length ( @xmath32 ) of the interaction distance following the injection position was tuned by the laterally scanning the machining focus ( along the pump beam axis ) with a motorised mirror ( m@xmath33 ) placed after cylindrical lens system and before the final focus .
the aspect ratio of the line focus with an approximate length of @xmath28 @xmath8 m ( fwhm ) in the vertical direction ( @xmath34-axis ) and a spot size of @xmath5 @xmath8 m ( fwhm ) along the pump pulse propagation direction ensures that the strongest density gradient as seen by the plasma wakefield of the pump pulse is predominantly longitudinal ( @xmath35 - axis ) . ) and after ( @xmath36 ) the density depleted zone was varied by laterally scanning the machining focus ( mf - scan ) along the pump beam axis.,width=321 ] [ [ section-5 ] ] in our experiments , the time delay between the pump and the machining laser pulse was fixed at @xmath37 ns following earlier experiments@xcite where the timing had been optimized to obtain the strongest density gradients .
nomarski interferometry allowed us to measure precisely ( @xmath38 @xmath39 @xmath8 m ) the axial location of the density depletion from the position of the distortion in the interferogram fringes ( fig .
[ fig : interferogram ] ) arising due to the presence of the density channel in the path of the probe beam .
the axial width of the depletion zone estimated from the dimensions of the distorted region was approximately @xmath15-@xmath28 @xmath8 m .
however it was not possible to retrieve the longitudinal density profile in the distorted region from the interferometers due to the large phase shift caused by the machined plasma .
the plasma wavelength in our experiments is estimated to be approximately @xmath40-@xmath41 @xmath8 m corresponding to densities of @xmath42 @xmath20 @xmath43 . since our conditions are similar to that in ref .
@xmath18 , the density - gradient scale length is likewise expected to be similar ( @xmath44 m ) and therefore the change in longitudinal density can be considered as gradual compared to plasma wavelength . as is evident from the integrity of the curved fringes throughout the gas - jet in the left side of the interferogram ( z @xmath45 @xmath46 mm )
, the density - depletion or injection zone in the path of the pump beam does not appear to disrupt its subsequent propagation and self - guiding .
the pump pulse appears to be guided for lengths greater than @xmath47 m ( rayleigh range for a gaussian focal spot size of @xmath48 @xmath8 m ) both before and after the depletion zone . controlled injection of electrons into the plasma wakefield
occurs in the density- gradients of the density - depleted region and acceleration in the subsequent homogeneous plasma .
[ [ section-6 ] ] the energy of the accelerated electron bunch exiting the gas - jet was measured with a magnetic spectrometer consisting of @xmath49 tesla , @xmath6 cm magnet and a lanex phosphor screen imaged onto a @xmath48-bit ccd camera .
the spectrometer energy resolution was @xmath50 at @xmath15 mev .
the electron energy spectrum and absolute charge is obtained by post - processing the recorded data taking into account the calibration of the diagnostic@xcite .
[ [ section-7 ] ] in our experiments , electrons are trapped and accelerated by the strong electric fields of the nonlinear plasma wave ( plasma bubble)@xcite excited by the intense and ultrashort pump laser pulse propagating in the gas - jet . depending on specific plasma conditions , injection into the bubble can occur either by self - trapping or by controlled injection due to the preformed density - perturbation .
the acceleration of electrons occurs in the matched plasma bubble regime of resonant laser wakefield acceleration @xcite(pulse length @xmath51 plasma wavelength/2 ) wherein the laser focal spot size is comparable to the bubble radius which is approximately of the order of half a plasma wavelength@xcite . in order to differentiate between self - injection and density - gradient injection ,
electron spectrum was first recorded with only the pump beam focused onto the gas - jet .
the density was reduced to minimize self - injection as much as possible without complete reduction of the detected charge . in these conditions ( electron densities of about @xmath52 - @xmath53 @xmath17 @xmath54 @xmath43 ) ,
self- injection occurs occasionally , resulting in the production of a poor quality electron beam with a broadband electron energy distribution .
the lanex image and the corresponding electron spectrum for one such target shot are shown in fig .
[ fig : filename_pumponlyspectra ] .
the spectrum of the self - injected electrons is consistently characterized by a large energy spread , low - energy dark current and considerable fluctuations in the spectral profile with high backround level on consecutive shots .
the mean value of maximum electron energy ( defined as cut - off edge in the logarithm of the spectral profile ) was around @xmath55 mev .
@xmath17 @xmath54 @xmath43.,title="fig:",width=359,height=60 ] @xmath17 @xmath54 @xmath43.,title="fig:",width=321,height=207 ] ) of the machining focus .
@xmath56 = ( a ) @xmath57 mm ( b ) @xmath58 mm ( c ) @xmath59 mm ( d ) @xmath37 mm ( e ) @xmath60 mm ( f ) @xmath61 mm from the entrance of the gas - jet.,width=321 ] the electron signal in the high - energy tail ( @xmath62 mev ) of the spectrum ( fig .
[ fig : filename_pumponlyspectra ] ) is due to the high background level . for plasma densities much below the self - injection threshold
, there were no distinct electron peaks with significant charge and the detected electron distribution was very close to the background level .
the presence or absence of density - depleted region under these conditions did not have any significant effect on the electron spectrum because the densities are too low to excite a wakefield of sufficient amplitude that can trap and accelerate electrons .
self - injection at low densities would require laser system with greater power . at higher densities ( @xmath27 @xmath52 - @xmath53 @xmath17 @xmath20 @xmath43 )
, there is an increased probability of intermittent self - trapping of electrons with a poor accelerated beam quality .
however for the same experimental conditions , firing the machining beam resulted in significant improvement of electron spectrum .
the effect of the depletion region , in the form of localized electron injection at the density - gradients , dominates over any occasional self - injection .
in contrast to the case of self - injection in a homogeneous plasma , the presence of the preformed density perturbation , leads to the acceleration of electrons with low energy spread , indicating the benefits of controlled injection for a fixed laser power .
[ [ section-8 ] ] the axial location of the depletion region was varied by translating the position of the machining focus from the entrance to the exit of the gas - jet along the direction of the pump laser - axis .
electron spectrum data was recorded by scanning the location of the depletion region in steps of approximately @xmath31 mm and keeping all other experimental conditions unchanged .
electron beam images on the lanex screen , obtained on selected shots for the scanned axial locations ( @xmath56 ) of the machining focus in the range of @xmath57 mm to @xmath61 mm , are shown in fig .
[ fig : spectrastack ] . by changing the location of the density depletion and thereby the subsequent plasma interaction length ,
the final energy of the accelerated electrons is observed to be tunable .
the spectra at different longitudinal locations ( @xmath56 ) of the machining focus are shown in fig.[fig : bsdspectrum ] .
the relative energy spread ( @xmath63 ) of the quasi - monoenergetic peaks is around @xmath64 , limited by electron spectrometer in these few selected shots .
moreover the peak signal level in the density - gradient injected spectrum is approximately ten times higher than in the case of the self - injected electron spectrum .
the improvement in electron beam quality with the machining beam highlights the advantages of controlled injection over uncontrolled self - injection , besides offering the flexibilty of tuning the electron energy with a single gas - jet in this particular experimental geometry . ) of around @xmath64
obtained by density - gradient injection for three different axial location ( z@xmath65 ) of the machining focus .
z@xmath66 ( a ) @xmath61 mm ( b ) @xmath60 mm ( c ) @xmath67 mm from the entrance of the gas - jet .
the injected charge is ( a ) @xmath68 pc ( b ) @xmath69 pc ( c ) @xmath60 pc and the plasma density is approximately @xmath53 @xmath17 @xmath54 @xmath43.,width=321 ] [ [ section-9 ] ] quasi - monoenergetic electrons were not detected when the depletion region was placed closer to the entrance in the first - half of the gas - jet , indicating that there is a threshold pump - pulse propagation distance after which the electrons begin to get injected in the longitudinal gradients of the depletion zone .
the threshold length for our experimental conditions in the case of density - gradient injection was found to be approximately @xmath46 mm from the entrance of the gas - jet .
initially the focussed pump laser pulse has intensity ( @xmath70 ) and parameters ( spot size @xmath27 @xmath48 @xmath8 m , pulse length @xmath27 @xmath71 @xmath8 m ) that are far from the matched , plasma bubble regime of resonant laser wakefield acceleration . for the matched regime at our plasma densities
, the pump spot size has to be approximately equal to the bubble radius ( @xmath72 @xmath73 @xmath8 m ) .
therefore a long interaction distance is needed for the laser pulse to be sufficiently compressed transversally and longitudinally in order to drive a suitable nonlinear plasma wave for trapping electrons . through an interplay of self - focusing , pulse - shortening and self- steepening , the spot size and
the temporal duration of the pump laser pulse evolves to reach the matched regime after propagating for a certain axial distance from the focal position@xcite .
quasi - static wake simulations@xcite reveal that for a pump laser focus location in the range of [ @xmath74 @xmath8 m on the edge of the gas - jet , the initial normalized laser amplitude ( @xmath22 ) of @xmath24 increases to a maximum value ( @xmath75 ) of about @xmath76 after a propagation distance of approximately @xmath77/@xmath78 mm , close to the experimentally observed threshold length .
the increased laser amplitude is due to initial focal spot size and pulse duration compressing to approximately @xmath79 m and @xmath80 fs respectively .
though the exact values of the final laser parameters can change with the initial focus location , they are approximately close to the matched regime and favours the generation of a plasma bubble that can trap electrons as it traverses the density - depleted region . when the depletion region was placed closer to the exit of the gas - jet , quasi - monoenergetic electrons
were observed with lower peak energy compared to the case when focused at the center . for propagation lengths ( @xmath81 ) in the range of @xmath46 mm to @xmath58 mm ,
the spectrum had greater instability compared to case of lengths greater than @xmath58 mm presumably due to conditions being close to the matched regime or thresholds of electron injection .
for the data set obtained with the machining beam , the probability of injection for which a quasi - monoenergetic electron distribution has been measured was approximately @xmath82 . in the other @xmath82 of case , no electrons were observed or when they were measured exhibited a broad energy distribution with a lower total charge . the shot to shot stability
could be improved in the future by tuning the delay between the pump and the machining pulse ( or the machining laser energy ) .
the probability of injection could also be improved by better control over laser conditions that were perhaps sub - optimal during this particular experiment .
[ [ section-10 ] ] in fig .
[ fig : energylength ] , the final electron energy is plotted as a function of the density - depletion position @xmath81 .
the data points are the mean of accumulated data from multiple shots and the straight line is a fit over the data corresponding to the @xmath81 in the range @xmath59 mm to @xmath83 mm . since the axial location of machining focus ( @xmath81 ) determines the plasma interaction length ( @xmath36 ) following the depletion region ( see fig .
[ fig : schematic : tgtconfig ] ) , the maximum possible acceleration length ( @xmath84 ) in a @xmath9 mm gas - jet approximately equals @xmath85 mm .
note that for our experimental conditions , the net acceleration length is less than the maximum possible value since the density - gradient injection is effective only for @xmath86 @xmath46 mm .
the linear region in the graph ( fig .
[ fig : energylength ] ) quantifies the tunability of electron energy with acceleration length . the final electron energy on an average varied from @xmath1 mev to @xmath0 mev for an acceleration length varying from @xmath87 mm to @xmath88 mm equivalent to an acceleration gradient of @xmath15 gev / m .
this value is similar to that measured recently in colliding pulse injection@xcite but lower than that expected from theory@xcite .
the scaling law predicts an acceleration gradient ( @xmath89 ) of approximately @xmath90 gev / m for our parameters , which is greater than the experimental measurement by a factor of @xmath91 .
this could be probably due to a decrease of the laser intensity in the second half of the gas jet or the deformation of the bubble resulting from laser pulse evolution that reduces the electron energy gain .
the acceleration length ( @xmath84 ) in our case is limited to about @xmath69 mm . for machining focus locations ( @xmath81 ) prior to @xmath59 mm
, there appears to be a trends towards saturation of the mean electron energy . in this region , the spectrum is unstable with larger fluctuations in peak energy compared to the linear region . in some shots multiple
peaked spectrum with energies as high as @xmath92 mev in the highest energy peak , whereas in certain shots single peaks with much lower energies were observed .
this could be due to @xmath93 evolution during laser propagation and the possibility of occurrence of multiple bunch injection on the density - gradient .
the energy spectrum data was also analysed by plotting the maximum cut- off energy and a similar trend was observed with a slightly greater slope in the linear region .
mev to @xmath0 mev by varying the location of the machining focus in the range of @xmath59 mm to @xmath83 mm from the entrance of the gas - jet .
dots are the mean of accumulated data from multiple shots and error bars are the standard error of the mean.,width=321,height=207 ] [ [ section-11 ] ] finally the variation of various electron beam parameters such as relative energy spread , divergence and charge within the peaks of the spectrum were analysed as a function of the axial location of the machining focus ( fig .
[ fig : parameters ] ) .
the divergence , injected charge and relative energy spread is relatively constant across the acceleration length with approximate mean values ( @xmath38 std .
error ) of @xmath94 mrad , @xmath4 pc and @xmath2 respectively .
error ) of @xmath3 mrad , @xmath4 pc and @xmath2 respectively .
dots are the mean of accumulated data from multiple shots and error bars are the standard error of the mean.,width=321,height=226 ]
in summary , quasi - mononenergetic electrons were generated by using the longitudinal density gradients of a plasma density perturbation to induce controlled injection of electrons into the plasma wakefield .
the density perturbation in the form of a density depleted plasma channel was created by a secondary machining beam .
final energy of the accelerated electrons was tuned from a maximum of @xmath1 mev to @xmath0 mev by varying the axial position of the density perturbation and thereby the injection location and the subsequent plasma interaction length . a threshold plasma length
prior to depletion region was required for density - gradient injection to be effective whereas the final electron beam parameters such as energy - spread , divergence and charge were observed to be independent of the injection location .
controlled injection in a longitudinally inhomogeneous plasma appears better than self - injection in a homogeneous plasma in terms of final electron - beam quality for the same experimental conditions and offers the flexibility of tuning the electron energy with a single gas - jet . in future , accurate measurements of the density profile in the density - gradient injection scheme will allow for benchmarking numerical simulations to optimize the experimental parameters needed for generating high - quality electron beams .
we thank j.p . goddet and a. tafzi for the operation of the laser system .
we acknowledge the support of the european research council for funding the paris erc project ( contract no .
226424 ) , ec fp7 laserlab- europe / laptech ( contract no .
228334 ) and eu access to research infrastructures programme project laserlab - europe ii .
geddes , k. nakamura , g.r .
plateau , c. toth , e. cormier - michel , e. esarey , c.b .
schroeder , j.r .
cary , and w.p .
plasma - density - gradient injection of low absolute - momentum - spread electron bunches .
, 100(21):215004 , 2008 .
gonsalves , k. nakamura , c. lin , d. panasenko , s. shiraishi , t. sokollik , c. benedetti , c.b .
schroeder , c.g.r geddes , j. van tilborg , et al .
tunable laser plasma accelerator based on longitudinal density tailoring . ,
2011 .
k. koyama , a. yamazaki , a. maekawa , m. uesaka , t. hosokai , m. miyashita , s. masuda , and e. miura .
laser - plasma electron accelerator for all - optical inverse compton x - ray source .
, 608(1):s51s53 , 2009 .
k. schmid , a. buck , c.m.s .
sears , j.m mikhailova , r. tautz , d. herrmann , m. geissler , f. krausz , and l. veisz . density - transition based electron injector for laser driven wakefield accelerators .
, 13(9):091301 , 2010 .
j. faure , c. rechatin , o. lundh , l. ammoura , and v. malka .
injection and acceleration of quasimonoenergetic relativistic electron beams using density gradients at the edges of a plasma channel .
, 17:083107 , 2010 .
n. hafz , h.j .
lee , j.u .
kim , g.h .
kim , h. suk , and j. lee .
femtosecond x - ray generation via the thomson scattering of a terawatt laser from electron bunches produced from the lwfa utilizing a plasma density transition .
, 31(6):13881394 , 2003 .
hsieh , c .- m .
huang , c .-
chang , y .- c .
ho , y .- s .
chen , j .- y .
lin , j. wang , and s .- y .
tomography of injection and acceleration of monoenergetic electrons in a laser - wakefield accelerator .
, 96:095001 , 2006 .
m. pittman , s. ferr , j.p .
rousseau , l. notebaert , j.p .
chambaret , and g. chriaux . design and characterization of a near - diffraction - limited femtosecond 100-tw 10-hz high - intensity laser system .
, 74(6):529535 , 2002 .
y. glinec , j. faure , a. guemnie - tafo , v. malka , h. monard , j.p .
larbre , v. de waele , j.l .
marignier , and m. mostafavi . absolute calibration for a broad range single shot electron spectrometer .
, 77:103301 , 2006 .
v. malka , s. fritzler , e. lefebvre , m. m. aleonard , f. burgy , j. p. chambaret , j. f. chemin , k. krushelnick , g. malka , s. p. d. mangles , z. najmudin , m. pittman , j. p. rousseau , j. n. scheurer , b. walton , and a. e. dangor .
electron acceleration by a wake field forced by an intense ultrashort laser pulse .
, 298(5598):15961600 , 2002 .
mangles , c.d .
murphy , z. najmudin , a.g.r .
thomas , j.l .
collier , a.e .
dangor , e.j .
divall , p.s .
foster , j.g .
gallacher , c.j .
hooker , et al .
monoenergetic beams of relativistic electrons from intense laser plasma interactions . , 431(7008):535538 , 2004 .
j. faure , y. glinec , a. pukhov , s. kiselev , s. gordienko , e. lefebvre , j.p .
rousseau , f. burgy , and v. malka . a laser plasma accelerator producing monoenergetic electron beams . , 431(7008):541544 , 2004 .
w. lu , m. tzoufras , c. joshi , f. s. tsung , w. b. mori , j. vieira , r. a. fonseca , and l. o. silva .
generating multi - gev electron bunches using single stage laser wakefield acceleration in a 3d nonlinear regime .
, 10:061301 , 2007 . a. g. r. thomas , z. najmudin , s. p.
d. mangles , c. d. murphy , a. e. dangor , c. kamperidis , k. l. lancaster , w. b. mori , p. a. norreys , w. rozmus , and k. krushelnick . effect of laser - focusing conditions on propagation and monoenergetic electron production in laser - wakefield accelerators . , 98:095004 , 2007 . | a density perturbation produced in an underdense plasma was used to improve the quality of electron bunches produced in the laser - plasma wakefield acceleration scheme .
quasi - monoenergetic electrons were generated by controlled injection in the longitudinal density gradients of the density perturbation . by tuning the position of the density perturbation along the laser propagation axis , a fine control of the electron energy from a mean value of @xmath0 mev to @xmath1 mev has been demonstrated with a relative energy - spread of @xmath2 , divergence of @xmath3 mrad and charge of @xmath4 pc . |
the discovery of a resonance at the lhc @xcite that is compatible with the standard - model ( sm ) higgs boson @xcite marked a milestone in particle physics .
the existence of the higgs boson is inherently related to the mechanism of spontaneous symmetry breaking @xcite while preserving the full gauge symmetry and the renormalizability of the sm @xcite .
its mass , the last missing parameter of the sm , has been measured to be ( @xmath0 ) gev @xcite .
the existence of the higgs boson allows the sm particles to be weakly interacting up to high - energy scales without violating the unitarity bounds of scattering amplitudes @xcite .
this , however , is only possible for particular higgs - boson couplings to all other particles so that with the knowledge of the higgs - boson mass all its properties are uniquely fixed .
the massive gauge bosons and fermions acquire mass through their interaction with the higgs field that develops a finite vacuum expectation value in its ground state thus hiding the still unbroken electroweak gauge symmetry .
the minimal model requires the introduction of one weak isospin doublet of the higgs field and leads after spontaneous symmetry breaking to the existence of one scalar higgs boson , while non - minimal higgs sectors predict in general more than one higgs boson . within the sm with one higgs
doublet the higgs mass is constrained by consistency conditions as the absence of a landau pole for the higgs self - coupling up to high energy scales and the stability of the electroweak ground state @xcite .
if the sm is required to fulfill these conditions for energy scales up to the scale of grand unified theories ( guts ) of @xmath1 gev the higgs mass is constrained between 129 gev and about 190 gev @xcite .
the last condition of vacuum stability can be relaxed by demanding the life - time of the ground state to be larger than the age of our universe @xcite .
this reduces the lower bound on the higgs mass to about 110 gev @xcite .
the measured value of the higgs mass indicates that our universe is unstable with a large lifetime far beyond the age of the universe .
if the sm is extended to the gut scale , radiative corrections to the higgs - boson mass tend to push the higgs mass towards the gut scale , if it couples to particles of that mass order . in order to obtain the higgs mass at the electroweak
scale the counter term has to be fine - tuned to cancel these large corrections thus establishing a very unnatural situation that requires a solution .
this is known as the hierarchy problem @xcite .
possible solutions are the introduction of supersymmetry ( susy ) @xcite , a collective symmetry between sm particles and heavier partners as in little higgs theories @xcite or an effective reduction of the planck and gut scales as in extra - dimension models at the tev scale @xcite .
sm higgs bosons are dominantly produced via the loop - induced gluon - fusion process @xmath2 with top quarks providing the leading loop contribution @xcite .
other production processes as vector - boson fusion @xmath3 @xcite , higgs - strahlung @xmath4 @xcite and higgs radiation off top quarks @xmath5 @xcite are suppressed by more than one order of magnitude . while the dominant gluon - fusion process allows for the detection of the higgs boson in the rare decay modes into @xmath6 , four charged leptons and @xmath7-boson pairs , other decay modes are only detectable in the subleading production modes as e.g. the main higgs - boson decay into bottom quarks in
strongly boosted higgs - strahlung @xcite or the higgs - boson decay into @xmath8-leptons in the vector - boson - fusion process @xcite .
supersymmetric extensions of the sm are motivated by providing a possible solution to the hierarchy problem if the supersymmetric particles appear at the few - tev scale @xcite .
supersymmetry connects fermionic and bosonic degrees of freedom and thus links internal and external symmetries @xcite .
it is the last possible symmetry - type of @xmath9-matrix theories , i.e. the last possible extension of the poincar algebra .
the minimal supersymmetric extension of the sm ( mssm ) predicts the weinberg angle in striking agreement with experimental measurements if embedded in a gut @xcite .
moreover , it allows to generate electroweak symmetry breaking radiatively @xcite and yields a candidate for dark matter if @xmath10-parity is conserved @xcite which renders the lightest supersymmetric particle stable .
finally it increases the proton lifetime beyond experimental bounds in the context of supersymmetric guts @xcite .
the mssm requires the introduction of two isospin doublets of higgs fields in order to maintain the analyticity of the superpotential and the anomaly - freedom with respect to the gauge symmetries @xcite .
moreover , two higgs doublets are needed for the generation of the up- and down - type fermion masses .
the higgs sector is a two - higgs - doublet model ( 2hdm ) sector of type ii .
the mass eigenstates consist of a light ( @xmath11 ) and heavy ( @xmath12 ) scalar , a pseudoscalar ( @xmath13 ) and two charged ( @xmath14 ) states .
the self - interactions of the higgs fields are entirely fixed in terms of the electroweak gauge couplings so that the self - couplings are constrained to small values .
this leads to an upper bound on the light scalar higgs mass that has to be smaller than the @xmath15-boson mass @xmath16 at leading order ( lo ) .
this is , however , broken by radiative corrections , which are dominated by top - quark - induced contributions @xcite .
the parameter @xmath17 , defined as the ratio of the two vacuum expectation values of the scalar higgs fields , will in general be assumed to be in the range @xmath18 , where @xmath19 denotes the top ( bottom ) mass , consistent with the assumption that the mssm is the low - energy limit of a supergravity model @xcite and to avoid non - perturbative phenomena .
if the soft susy - breaking parameters do not contain any complex phases the input parameters of the mssm higgs sector at lo are generally chosen to be the mass @xmath20 of the pseudoscalar higgs boson and @xmath17 .
all other masses and the mixing angle @xmath21 between the scalar cp - even higgs states can be derived from these basic parameters ( and the top mass and susy parameters , which enter through radiative corrections ) .
the radiative corrections can be approximated by the parameter @xmath22 , which grows with the fourth power of the top quark mass and logarithmically with the stop masses @xmath23 , supplemented by terms originating from soft susy - breaking parameters , i.e. the trilinear coupling @xmath24 , the higgsino mass @xmath25 and the third - generation squark mass @xmath26 with @xmath27 , @xmath28 where @xmath29 denotes the fermi constant and @xmath30 the @xmath31 top mass at the scale @xmath26 .
these corrections are positive and reach a maximum ( related to @xmath32 ) for @xmath33 .
they increase the squared mass of the light neutral higgs boson @xmath11 to @xmath34 in this approximation , the upper bound on @xmath35 is shifted from the tree level value @xmath16 up to @xmath36 145 gev .
the mass of the lightest scalar state @xmath11 is given by @xmath37 \label{eq : hmass}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the masses of the heavy neutral and charged higgs bosons are determined by the sum rules ( valid for this approximation ) , @xmath38 the effective mixing parameter @xmath21 between the cp - even scalar higgs states can be derived as @xmath39 the radiative corrections to the mssm higgs sector have been calculated up to the two - loop level in the effective potential approximation and in the diagrammatic approach @xcite .
the leading corrections are also known at the three - loop level within the effective potential approach @xcite .
the corrections beyond next - to - leading order ( nlo ) are dominated by the qcd corrections to the top - quark - induced contributions .
they decrease the upper bound on the light scalar higgs mass @xmath35 by about 10 gev to @xmath40 gev , while leaving a residual uncertainty of @xmath41 gev on the light scalar higgs mass . in the context of increasing lower mass bounds for the supersymmetric particles ,
a resummation of large logarithms related to the susy - particle masses has been performed for the calculation of the mssm higgs - boson masses @xcite . for large susy - particle masses
this resummation may lead to effects of the order of 5 gev ( or larger for small values of @xmath42 ) on the light scalar higgs mass .
the calculation of the radiative corrections has also been extended to the effective trilinear and quartic self - interactions of the mssm higgs bosons that are consistently defined at vanishing external momenta .
the nlo corrections at @xmath43 and @xmath44 are available since a long time @xcite , where @xmath45 and @xmath46 . in the leading approximation in terms of the parameter
@xmath22 the trilinear couplings of the neutral higgs bosons are given up to @xmath43 by @xcite @xmath47 which have been normalized to @xmath48 .
similar but more involved expressions can be obtained for the quartic higgs self - couplings .
some time ago the nlo corrections to the higgs self - couplings have been extended by the next - to - next - to - leading order ( nnlo ) corrections of @xmath49 @xcite , where @xmath50 denotes the strong coupling constant .
the radiative corrections are large in general , while the nnlo part is of moderate size but reduces the theoretical uncertainties significantly to the few per - cent level .
the couplings of the neutral higgs bosons to fermions and gauge bosons depend on the angles @xmath21 and @xmath51 .
normalized to the sm higgs couplings , they are listed in table [ tb : hcoup ] .
the pseudoscalar particle @xmath13 does not couple to gauge bosons at tree level , and its couplings to down ( up)-type fermions are ( inversely ) proportional to @xmath17 .
.[tb : hcoup ] _ mssm higgs couplings to up- and down - type fermions and gauge bosons ( @xmath52 ) relative to the corresponding sm couplings . _ [ cols="<,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the final results for the mssm higgs branching ratios have been obtained with the public codes feynhiggs @xcite and hdecay @xcite using the sm input parameters of the previous section .
[ fig : mssmnbr ] shows the neutral higgs branching ratios for two values of @xmath42 within the @xmath53 benchmark scenario @xcite that is defined as @xmath54 the kinks visible in these plots are due to the opening of new decay modes according to the sm and susy - particle masses of the final - state particles .
[ fig : mssmcbr ] displays the corresponding charged higgs branching ratios within the @xmath53 benchmark scenario @xcite for two values of @xmath42 .
the related uncertainties are not shown in the plots .
( 150,640)(0,0 ) ( -270,370.0 ) ( -20,370.0 ) ( -270,170.0 ) ( -20,170.0 ) ( -270,-30.0 ) ( -20,-30.0 ) ( 150,240)(0,0 ) ( -180,-20.0 ) ( 70,-20.0 )
the gluon - fusion mechanism @xcite @xmath55 dominates higgs - boson production at the lhc in the entire relevant higgs mass range .
the gluon coupling to the higgs boson in the sm is mediated by triangular top- and bottom - quark loops , see fig .
[ fg : gghlodia ] .
since the yukawa coupling of the higgs particle grows with the quark mass , the form factor reaches a constant value for large loop quark masses .
if the masses of heavier quarks beyond the third generation are fully generated by the higgs mechanism , these particles would add the same amount to the form factor as the top quark in the asymptotic heavy quark limit .
thus gluon fusion can serve as a counter of the number of heavy quarks , the masses of which are generated by the conventional higgs mechanism . on the other hand within the three - generation sm gluon fusion will allow to measure the top quark yukawa coupling .
this , however , requires a precise knowledge of the cross section within the sm with three generations of quarks .
( 180,100)(0,0 ) ( 0,20)(50,20)-35 ( 0,80)(50,80)35 ( 50,20)(50,80 ) ( 50,80)(100,50 ) ( 100,50)(50,20 ) ( 100,50)(150,50)5 ( 155,46)@xmath12 ( 25,46)@xmath56 ( -15,18)@xmath57 ( -15,78)@xmath57 + the partonic cross section can be derived from the gluonic width of the higgs boson at lowest order @xcite , @xmath58 with the scaling variables defined as @xmath59 , @xmath60 .
the variable @xmath61 denotes the partonic c.m .
energy squared and @xmath62 the renormalization scale .
the amplitudes @xmath63 are given in eq .
( [ eq : ftau ] ) . in the narrow - width approximation the hadronic cross section can be cast into the form @xcite @xmath64 with the gluon luminosity @xmath65 at the factorization scale @xmath66 , and the scaling variable is defined , in analogy to the drell yan process , as @xmath67 , with @xmath68 specifying the total hadronic c.m .
energy squared .
the bottom - quark contributions interfere destructively with the top loop and decrease the cross section by about 10% at lo .
( 450,100)(-10,0 ) ( 0,20)(30,20)-33 ( 0,80)(30,80)33 ( 30,20)(60,20)-33 ( 30,80)(60,80)33 ( 30,20)(30,80)35 ( 60,20)(60,80 ) ( 60,80)(90,50 ) ( 90,50)(60,20 ) ( 90,50)(120,50)5 ( 125,46)@xmath12 ( 65,46)@xmath56 ( -10,18)@xmath57 ( -10,78)@xmath57 ( 15,48)@xmath57 ( 180,100)(210,100)33 ( 210,100)(270,100)36 ( 180,0)(210,0)-33 ( 210,100)(210,60)34 ( 210,0)(210,60 ) ( 210,60)(240,30 ) ( 240,30)(210,0 ) ( 240,30)(270,30)5 ( 275,26)@xmath12 ( 215,26)@xmath56 ( 165,-2)@xmath57 ( 165,98)@xmath57 ( 195,78)@xmath57 ( 275,98)@xmath57 ( 330,100)(360,100 ) ( 360,100)(420,100 ) ( 330,0)(360,0)-33 ( 360,100)(360,60)34 ( 360,0)(360,60 ) ( 360,60)(390,30 ) ( 390,30)(360,0 ) ( 390,30)(420,30)5 ( 425,26)@xmath12 ( 365,26)@xmath56 ( 315,-2)@xmath57 ( 315,98)@xmath69 ( 425,98)@xmath69 ( 345,78)@xmath57 + [ [ qcd - corrections . ] ] qcd corrections .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + in the past the ( two - loop ) nlo qcd corrections to the gluon - fusion cross section , fig .
[ fg : gghqcddia ] , have been calculated including the full mass dependences @xcite .
they consist of virtual corrections to the basic @xmath2 process and real corrections due to the associated production of the higgs boson with massless partons , @xmath70 these subprocesses contribute to the higgs production at @xmath71 .
the virtual corrections rescale the lowest - order fusion cross section with a coefficient depending only on the ratios of the higgs and quark masses .
gluon radiation leads to two - parton final states with invariant energy @xmath72 in the @xmath73 and @xmath74 channels at nlo .
in general the hadronic cross section can be split into seven parts @xcite , @xmath75 \tau_{h } \frac{d{\cal l}^{gg}}{d\tau_{h } } + \delta \sigma_{gg } + \delta \sigma_{gq } + \delta \sigma_{q\bar{q } } + \delta \sigma_{qq } + \delta \sigma_{qq'}\ ] ] where the finite parts of virtual corrections @xmath76 and the real corrections @xmath77 , @xmath78 and @xmath79 ( same - flavour quark - antiquark initial states ) start to contribute at nlo , while @xmath80 ( same - flavour quark - quark and antiquark - antiquark initial states ) and @xmath81 ( different - flavour quark and antiquark initial states ) appear for the first time at nnlo .
the renormalization scale @xmath62 of @xmath50 and the factorization scale @xmath66 of the parton densities are fixed properly , in general at @xmath82 .
the quark - loop mass has been identified with the pole mass @xmath83 , while the qcd coupling @xmath50 and the parton density functions are defined in the @xmath31 scheme with five active flavours .
we define the nlo @xmath84 factor as the ratio @xmath85 the nlo corrections are positive and large , increasing the gluon - fusion cross section at the lhc by about 6090% .
the qcd corrections to the bottom - quark contributions are significantly smaller if the bottom mass is used in terms of the pole mass or the @xmath31 mass at the scale of the bottom mass .
this choice is motivated by the numerical cancellation of squared and single logarithms of the relative qcd corrections at nlo @xcite .
this feature modifies the destructive bottom - quark contribution to a reduction of the cross section by about @xmath86 at nlo . comparing the exact mass - dependent results with the expressions in the heavy - quark limit
, it turns out that this asymptotic @xmath84 factor provides an excellent approximation even for higgs masses above the top - decay threshold .
we explicitly define the approximation by @xmath87 where we neglect the @xmath88 quark contribution in @xmath89 , while the leading order cross section @xmath90 includes the full @xmath91 quark mass dependence .
the comparison with the full massive nlo result is presented in fig .
[ fg : gghapprox ] .
the solid line corresponds to the exact cross section and the broken line to the approximate one . for higgs masses below @xmath36 1 tev ,
the deviations of the asymptotic approximation from the full nlo result are less than 15% , whereas for @xmath92 gev they amount to @xmath93 , if the full lo cross section is multiplied by the approximate k - factor .
this property of the nlo corrections suggests this to be true also at higher orders , since it is a consequence of the dominating soft and collinear gluon effects in the qcd corrections . within the heavy top - quark limit
the nnlo @xcite and n@xmath94lo @xcite qcd corrections have been calculated .
the nnlo contributions increase the production cross section by about 20% beyond nlo , while the n@xmath94lo corrections range at the level of a few per - cent .
these results indicate that the gluon - fusion cross section is under theoretical control despite the large size of the nlo corrections .
this is further corroborated by the results obtained by a soft and collinear gluon resummation on top of the n@xmath94lo result .
this resummation has been performed at the nnll level @xcite and the n@xmath94ll level @xcite in the heavy top - quark limit .
quite recently also finite top - mass effects have been included in the resummation framework @xcite at the nll order , where they are known exactly .
resummation effects beyond n@xmath94lo yield only a per - cent increase of the cross section for the central scale choice . however , they yield an approximation of effects beyond n@xmath94lo and contribute to a sophisticated estimate of the residual uncertainties . [ [ electroweak - corrections . ] ] electroweak corrections .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the electroweak corrections to the gluon - fusion cross section have been computed approximately first .
the leading top mass corrections of @xmath95 coincide with the corrections to the gluonic decay mode of eq .
( [ eq : hggelw ] ) and are thus small @xcite .
this calculation has been refined by the determination of the nlo electroweak corrections due to light - fermion loops @xcite and finally by the full numerical integration of the exact nlo corrections to the top- and @xmath96-induced electroweak corrections @xcite .
the electroweak corrections coincide with the ones to the @xmath97 decay .
the nlo electroweak corrections have been extended by a calculation of the mixed qcd - electroweak corrections in the limit @xmath98 @xcite which can be attributed to the corrections of the effective @xmath99 coupling .
however , it is unclear how reliable this approximation is in practice . due to the dominance of soft and collinear gluon effects
the bulk of the electroweak corrections will factorize from the pure qcd corrections . in the following the electroweak corrections
will be combined with the qcd corrections in factorized form .
[ [ total - cross - section . ] ] total cross section .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + theoretical uncertainties in the prediction of the higgs cross section originate from three major sources , the dependence of the cross section on the parton densities , the unknown corrections beyond n@xmath94lo and the parametric uncertainties originating from the input value of the strong coupling @xmath50 and to a lesser extent of the top and bottom quark masses .
the missing quark - mass effects beyond nlo have been estimated as less than 1% by an explicit large top - mass expansion of the nnlo corrections beyond the heavy top - quark limit @xcite .
the total uncertainty of the prediction for the total gluon - fusion cross sections has been estimated as 4% and can dominantly be traced back to the renormalization- and factorization - scale dependence as well as the pdf+@xmath50 uncertainties @xcite .
the renormalization- and factorization - scale dependence is depicted in fig .
[ fg : gghscale ] for the known perturbative orders in the heavy top - quark limit . a significant reduction from @xmath100 to
the few - per - cent level is visible from lo to n@xmath94lo .
the results for the cross section are contained in the public codes higlu @xcite up to nnlo , sushi @xcite up to n@xmath94lo as well as ihix @xcite up to n@xmath94lo .
[ [ transverse - momentum - distribution . ] ] transverse - momentum distribution .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + apart from the total cross section also distributions are relevant for analyzing the higgs properties .
of particular interest in this context is the transverse - momentum distribution of the higgs boson that arises due to the additional radiation of gluons .
the lo contributions are part of the real corrections to the gluon - fusion cross section at nlo .
the first results were obtained a long time ago @xcite that include the full quark - mass dependence at lo .
the nlo qcd corrections were calculated in the heavy top - quark limit @xcite that is expected to be reliable up to @xmath101-values below the @xmath102 threshold as can be inferred from a large top - mass expansion @xcite . recently
a more rigorous inclusion of finite top - mass effects at nlo has been studied by using exact results partially @xcite .
these calculations are extended by the recent derivation of the nnlo qcd corrections in the heavy - top limit @xcite .
these predictions have been matched to a soft - gluon resummed expression that provides a regular prediction for small values of @xmath101 thus removing the spurious singularities in @xmath103 in fixed - order expressions @xcite .
the consistent matching between the resummed and fixed order expressions has been performed at nnll+nnlo level @xcite . in addition
finite quark - mass effects have been included in the resummed expressions at nll+nlo , too @xcite .
the latter step requires to use different matching scales for the pure top - induced contributions and those that involve bottom loops . during the last years
the full nlo expressions have been implemented in the powheg box @xcite providing in this way a reliable nlo event generator @xcite .
a second matching to parton showers has been performed by combining sushi @xcite and the mc@nlo @xcite framework in the code amcsushi @xcite at nlo accuracy , too .
the gluon - fusion mechanism @xcite @xmath104 dominates the neutral mssm higgs boson production at the lhc in the phenomenologically relevant higgs mass ranges for small and moderate values of @xmath17 . only for large @xmath17
can the associated @xmath105 production channel develop a larger cross section due to the enhanced higgs couplings to bottom quarks @xcite .
analogous to the gluonic decay modes , the gluon coupling to the neutral higgs bosons in the mssm is built up by loops involving top and bottom quarks as well as squarks , see fig .
[ fg : mssmgghlodia ] .
( 180,100)(0,0 ) ( 0,20)(50,20)-35 ( 0,80)(50,80)35 ( 50,20)(50,80 ) ( 50,80)(100,50 ) ( 100,50)(50,20 ) ( 100,50)(150,50)5 ( 155,46)@xmath106 ( 20,46)@xmath107 ( -15,18)@xmath57 ( -15,78)@xmath57 + the partonic cross sections can be obtained from the gluonic widths of the higgs bosons at lowest order @xcite : @xmath108 where the scaling variables are defined as @xmath109 , @xmath110 , and @xmath61 denotes the partonic c.m . energy squared .
the amplitudes @xmath111 are defined in eqs .
( [ eq : mssmhgg ] , [ eq : mssmagg ] ) , and the mssm couplings @xmath112 can be found in tables [ tb : hcoup ] and [ tb : hsqcoup ] . in the narrow - width approximation the hadronic cross sections are given by @xmath113 with the gluon luminosity defined in eq .
( [ eq : gglum ] ) and the scaling variables @xmath114 where @xmath68 specifies the total hadronic c.m .
energy squared . for small @xmath17
the top loop contribution is dominant , while for large values of @xmath17 the bottom quark contribution is strongly enhanced .
if the squark masses are less than @xmath115 gev , their contribution is significant , and for squark masses beyond @xmath116 gev they can safely be neglected @xcite .
[ [ qcd - corrections.-1 ] ] qcd corrections .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + in the past the full two - loop qcd corrections to the quark and squark loops of the gluon - fusion cross section were calculated @xcite .
in complete analogy to the sm case they consist of virtual corrections to the basic @xmath117 process and real corrections due to the associated production of the higgs bosons with massless partons .
thus the contributions to the final result for the hadronic cross section can in complete analogy to the sm case be classified as @xmath118 \tau_\phi \frac{d{\cal l}^{gg}}{d\tau_\phi } + \delta\sigma^\phi_{gg } + \delta\sigma^\phi_{gq } + \delta\sigma^\phi_{q\bar{q } } + \delta\sigma^\phi_{qq } + \delta\sigma^\phi_{qq ' } \label{eq : mssmgghqcd5}\ ] ] where @xmath119 and @xmath120 start to contribute at nnlo .
the analytic nlo expressions for arbitrary higgs boson and quark masses are rather involved and can be found in @xcite . as in the sm case
the ( s)quark - loop masses have been identified with the pole masses @xmath121 , while the qcd coupling and pdfs of the proton are defined in the @xmath122 scheme with five active flavours .
the axial @xmath123 coupling can be regularized in the t hooft veltman scheme @xcite or its extension by larin @xcite , which preserves the chiral symmetry in the massless quark limit by the addition of supplementary counter terms and fulfills the non - renormalization theorem @xcite of the abj anomaly @xcite at vanishing momentum transfer .
the same result can also be obtained with the scheme of ref .
@xcite that gives up the cyclicity of the traces involving clifford matrices .
similar to the sm the leading terms in the heavy - quark limit provide a reliable approximation for small @xmath17 up to higgs masses of @xmath124 tev with a maximal deviation of @xmath125 for @xmath126 $ \sim$}}~}5 $ ] in the intermediate mass range .
the squark contributions in the heavy - squark limit coincide with the heavy - quark case apart from the mismatch related to the effective lagrangians of eqs .
( [ eq : leff ] , [ eq : leffsq ] ) . the genuine susy
qcd corrections are the same as for the gluonic decay width as discussed in section [ sc : hgg ] .
they are moderate for small values of @xmath42 @xcite , but can be large for large @xmath42 due to the contribution of the @xmath127 terms and a sizeable remainder beyond these approximate contributions @xcite . in the opposite limit , where the higgs mass is much larger than the quark mass ,
the analytic results coincide with the sm expressions for both the scalar and pseudoscalar higgs particles up to nlo at which the results for small quark masses are known @xcite .
this coincidence reflects the restoration of the chiral symmetry in the massless quark limit .
the leading logarithmic structure is the same as in the sm case , see eq .
( [ eq : hgglog ] ) .
the non - abelian part of these logarithms has not been resummed so that the uncertainties for large values of @xmath42 are sizeable due to the dominance of the bottom - quark loops involving the large logarithms .
the qcd corrections are positive and large , increasing the mssm higgs production cross sections at the lhc by up to about 100% .
the effect of the pure squark loops ( without gluino exchange ) on the scalar higgs @xmath84 factors is of moderate size and lead to a maximal modification by about 10% .
squark mass effects on top of the lo ones can amount to @xmath128 for large higgs masses @xcite .
for the top - loop contributions alone the n@xmath94lo corrections can be used consistently .
susy - electroweak corrections are unknown so far .
[ [ transverse - momentum - distribution.-1 ] ] transverse - momentum distribution .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the results of the powheg implementation of the full lo matrix elements for the transverse - momentum distribution of ref .
@xcite and amcsushi @xcite can also be used for the mssm , since they also include variable top and bottom yukawa couplings .
the code of ref .
@xcite includes squark - loop contributions in addition .
a rigorous comparison between the powheg implementation and analytical resummation approaches @xcite as well as amcsushi has been performed @xcite .
this comparison addressed in particular different approaches for the setting of the resummation scale of the bottom - loop contributions . in scenarios where the top loops provide the dominant contribution
the differences between the codes are in the range of up to about 50% , while for scenarios with bottom - loop dominance they are larger and can reach 100% @xcite .
these differences will only be reduced by calculating the nlo corrections to the transverse - momentum distribution including the full mass dependence .
( 120,110)(0,0 ) ( 0,0)(50,0 ) ( 50,0)(100,0 ) ( 0,100)(50,100 ) ( 50,100)(100,100 ) ( 50,0)(50,50)35 ( 50,50)(50,100)35 ( 50,50)(100,50)5 ( 105,46)@xmath12 ( -15,-2)@xmath69 ( -15,98)@xmath69 ( 55,21)@xmath96 ( 55,71)@xmath96 + at the lhc the second important higgs production channel is the vector - boson - fusion ( vbf ) mechanism ( see fig . [
fg : vvhlodia ] ) @xcite . for
intermediate higgs masses the vector - boson - fusion cross section is about one order of magnitude smaller than the gluon - fusion one .
the cross section can be approximated by the @xmath130-channel diagrams of the type shown in fig .
[ fg : vvhlodia ] within @xmath131 accuracy , i.e. without any colour - cross talk between the quark lines , while interference effects for identical quark flavours and @xmath68-channel contributions are at the per - cent level after subtracting the corresponding higgs - strahlung component from the @xmath68-channel contributions @xcite . within the structure - function approach the leading order partonic vector - boson - fusion cross section @xcite can be cast into the form ( @xmath132 ) :
@xmath133 ^ 2 [ q_2 ^ 2-m_v^2]^2 } \nonumber \\ & & \left\ { f_1(x_1,\mu_f^2 ) f_1(x_2,\mu_f^2 ) \left [ 2+\frac{(q_1 q_2)^2}{q_1 ^ 2q_2 ^ 2 } \right ] \right .
\nonumber \\ & & + \frac{f_1(x_1,\mu_f^2)f_2(x_2,\mu_f^2)}{p_2q_2 } \left[\frac{(p_2q_2)^2}{q_2 ^ 2}- m_p^2+\frac{1}{q_1 ^ 2}\left(p_2q_1-\frac{p_2q_2}{q_2 ^ 2}q_1q_2\right)^2 \right ] \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{f_2(x_1,\mu_f^2)f_1(x_2,\mu_f^2)}{p_1q_1 } \left[\frac{(p_1q_1)^2}{q_1 ^ 2}- m_p^2+\frac{1}{q_2 ^
2}\left(p_1q_2-\frac{p_1q_1}{q_1 ^ 2}q_1q_2\right)^2 \right ] \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{f_2(x_1,\mu_f^2)f_2(x_2,\mu_f^2)}{(p_1q_1)(p_2q_2 ) } \left[p_1p_2 - \frac{(p_1q_1)(p_2q_1)}{q_1 ^ 2 } - \frac{(p_2q_2)(p_1q_2)}{q_2 ^ 2 } \right .
\nonumber \\ & & \left .
\hspace*{4.5cm}+\frac{(p_1q_1)(p_2q_2)(q_1q_2)}{q_1 ^ 2q_2 ^ 2 } \right]^2 \nonumber \\ & & \left .
+ \frac{f_3(x_1,\mu_f^2)f_3(x_2,\mu_f^2)}{2(p_1q_1)(p_2q_2 ) } \left [ ( p_1p_2)(q_1q_2 ) - ( p_1q_2)(p_2q_1 ) \right ] \right\ } dx_1 dx_2 \frac{dp\!s_3}{\hat s } \label{eq : vvhlo}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath134 denotes the three - particle phase space of the final - state particles , @xmath135 the proton mass , @xmath136 the proton momenta and @xmath137 the momenta of the virtual vector bosons @xmath138 . the functions @xmath139 are the usual structure functions from deep - inelastic scattering processes at the factorization scale @xmath66 : @xmath140 \nonumber \\
f_2(x,\mu_f^2 ) & = & 2x \sum_q ( v_q^2+a_q^2 ) [ q(x,\mu_f^2 ) + \bar q(x,\mu_f^2 ) ] \nonumber \\
f_3(x,\mu_f^2 ) & = & 4 \sum_q v_qa_q [ -q(x,\mu_f^2 ) + \bar q(x,\mu_f^2 ) ] \label{eq : stfu}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath141 are the ( axial ) vector couplings of the quarks @xmath69 to the vector bosons @xmath142 : @xmath143 for @xmath144 and @xmath145 , @xmath146 for @xmath147 .
@xmath148 is the third weak isospin component and @xmath149 the electric charge of the quark @xmath69 . in the past
the nlo qcd corrections have been calculated first within the structure function approach @xcite . since ,
at lowest order , the proton remnants are color singlets , no color will be exchanged between the first and the second incoming ( outgoing ) quark line and hence the qcd corrections only consist of the well - known corrections to the structure functions @xmath139 . the final result for the nlo qcd - corrected cross section leads to the replacements @xmath150 \right .
\nonumber \\ & & \left [ -\frac{3}{4 } p_{qq}(z ) \log \frac{\mu_f^2z}{q^2 } + ( 1+z^2 ) { \cal d}_1(z ) - \frac{3}{2 } { \cal d}_0(z ) \right . \nonumber \\ & & \left .
\hspace*{6 cm } + 3 - \left ( \frac{9}{2 } + \frac{\pi^2}{3 } \right ) \delta(1-z ) \right ] \nonumber \\ & & \left .
+ \frac{1}{4 } g(y,\mu_f^2 ) \left [ -2 p_{qg}(z ) \log \frac{\mu_f^2z}{q^2(1-z ) } + 4z(1-z ) - 1 \right ] \right\ } \\ \delta f_2(x,\mu_f^2,q^2 )
& = & 2x\frac{\alpha_s(\mu_r)}{\pi}\sum_q ( v_q^2+a_q^2 ) \int_x^1 \frac{dy}{y } \left\ { \frac{2}{3 } [ q(y,\mu_f^2 ) + \bar q(y,\mu_f^2 ) ] \right . \nonumber \\ & & \left [ -\frac{3}{4 } p_{qq}(z ) \log \frac{\mu_f^2z}{q^2 } + ( 1+z^2 ) { \cal d}_1(z ) - \frac{3}{2 } { \cal d}_0(z ) \right .
\nonumber \\ & & \left .
\hspace*{3.0 cm } + 3 + 2z - \left ( \frac{9}{2 } + \frac{\pi^2}{3 } \right ) \delta(1-z ) \right ] \nonumber \\ & & \left .
+ \frac{1}{4 } g(y,\mu_f^2 ) \left [ -2p_{qg}(z ) \log \frac{\mu_f^2z}{q^2(1-z ) } + 8z(1-z ) - 1 \right ] \right\ } \\
\delta f_3(x,\mu_f^2,q^2 ) & = & \frac{\alpha_s(\mu_r)}{\pi } \sum_q 4 v_q a_q \int_x^1 \frac{dy}{y } \left\ { \frac{2}{3 } [ -q(y,\mu_f^2 ) + \bar q(y,\mu_f^2 ) ] \right .
\nonumber \\ & & \left [ -\frac{3}{4 } p_{qq}(z ) \log \frac{\mu_f^2z}{q^2 } + ( 1+z^2 ) { \cal d}_1(z ) - \frac{3}{2 } { \cal d}_0(z ) \right .
\nonumber \\ & & \left .
\left . \hspace*{3 cm }
+ 2 + z - \left ( \frac{9}{2 } + \frac{\pi^2}{3 } \right ) \delta(1-z ) \right ] \right\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath151 and the functions @xmath152 denote the altarelli
parisi splitting functions , which are given by @xcite @xmath153 the plus distributions are defined as @xmath154 the physical scale @xmath155 is given by @xmath156 for @xmath157 . these expressions have to be inserted in eq .
( [ eq : vvhlo ] ) and the full result expanded up to nlo .
the typical renormalization and factorization scales are fixed by the vector - boson momentum transfer @xmath158 .
the size of the qcd corrections amounts to about 10% and is thus small @xcite as can be inferred from fig .
[ fg : vbfcorr ] that displays the individual corrections to the cross section @xcite .
these results have been extended by the calculation of the full nlo qcd corrections including interference contributions between the @xmath159-channels thus confirming the smallness of the additional contributions at nlo , too @xcite .
the nlo electroweak corrections reduce the cross section by about 10% @xcite so that there is a significant interplay between the qcd and electroweak corrections , if the latter are defined in the @xmath29-scheme , see fig .
[ fg : vbfcorr ] . for a reliable prediction of the vector - boson - fusion cross section
both corrections have to be taken into account .
the nlo qcd and electroweak corrections are also known exclusively and have been implemented in the public monte carlo programs hawk @xcite and vbfnlo @xcite .
the full nlo results can also be generated with the mg5_amc@nlo framework @xcite and are available within the powheg box @xcite so that a full matching to parton showers can be used .
the nnlo qcd corrections have been obtained in the structure - function approach giving rise to a per - cent effect on the total cross section @xcite , see fig .
[ fg : vbfcorr ] .
these are implemented in the public codes vbf@nnlo @xcite and provbf @xcite with the latter providing exclusive results .
up to nnlo non - factorizing contributions have been shown to be small @xcite .
the theoretical calculations have been extended to n@xmath94lo very recently @xcite .
the n@xmath94lo corrections are tiny , but reduce the theoretical uncertainties significantly .
( 150,280)(0,0 ) ( -170,-10.0 ) ( 100,-10.0 ) ( 120,120)(0,0 ) ( 0,0)(50,0 ) ( 50,0)(100,0 ) ( 0,100)(50,100 ) ( 50,100)(100,100 ) ( 50,0)(50,50)35 ( 50,50)(50,100)35 ( 50,50)(100,50)5 ( 105,46)@xmath160 ( -15,-2)@xmath69 ( -15,98)@xmath69 ( 55,21)@xmath96 ( 55,71)@xmath96 + due to the absence of vector boson couplings to pseudoscalar higgs particles @xmath13 , only the scalar higgs bosons @xmath160 can be produced via the vector - boson - fusion mechanism at tree level ( see fig .
[ fg : mssmvvhlodia ] ) .
however , these processes are suppressed with respect to the sm cross section due to the mssm couplings ( @xmath161 ) , @xmath162 it turns out that the vector - boson - fusion mechanism is less relevant in the mssm , because for large heavy scalar higgs masses @xmath163 , the mssm couplings @xmath164 are very small apart from the decoupling regime where the light scalar higgs boson becomes sm - like .
the relative pure qcd corrections are the same as for the sm higgs particle , i.e. @xmath165 @xcite .
the genuine susy qcd corrections amount to less than a per cent and are thus small @xcite . some years ago the susy
electroweak corrections have been determined @xcite .
being moderate in size in general they can modify the vbf cross section by @xmath165 .
( 160,120)(0,-10 ) ( 0,100)(50,50 ) ( 50,50)(0,0 ) ( 50,50)(100,50)35 ( 100,50)(150,100)36 ( 100,50)(150,0)5 ( 155,-4)@xmath12 ( -15,-2)@xmath167 ( -15,98)@xmath69 ( 65,65)@xmath96 ( 155,96)@xmath96 + the higgs - strahlung mechanism @xmath168 ( see fig . [
fg : vhvlodia ] ) is important in the intermediate higgs mass range due to the possibility to tag the associated vector boson and to reconstruct the @xmath169 decay for strongly boosted higgs bosons by using jet - substructure techniques @xcite .
its cross section is about one to two orders of magnitude smaller than the gluon - fusion cross section for the relevant higgs mass range .
the partonic cross section can be expressed at lowest - order as @xcite @xmath170 where @xmath171 denotes the usual two - body phase - space factor and @xmath141 are the ( axial ) vector couplings of the quarks @xmath69 to the vector bosons @xmath142 , which have been defined after eq .
( [ eq : stfu ] ) . at leading order the partonic c.m .
energy squared @xmath172 coincides with the invariant mass @xmath173 of the higgs vector - boson pair squared , @xmath174 .
the hadronic cross section can be obtained from convolving eq .
( [ eq : vhvpart ] ) with the corresponding @xmath175-luminosity , @xmath176 with @xmath177 and @xmath68 the total hadronic c.m .
energy squared and @xmath178\ ] ] the nlo qcd corrections are identical to the corresponding corrections to the drell yan process @xcite .
the natural scale of the process is given by the invariant mass of the higgs vector - boson pair in the final state , @xmath158 .
the nlo qcd corrections increase the total cross section by about 30% and are thus moderate @xcite , see fig .
[ fg : vhcorr ] . some time ago the nnlo qcd corrections
have been determined @xcite . for the @xmath179 final state
there is a sizeable contribution from the loop - induced @xmath180 process , see fig .
[ fg : ggzhdia ] .
it contributes @xmath128 to the total cross section as can be inferred from fig .
[ fg : vhcorr ] , while the rest of the nnlo corrections amounts to about 5% .
recently the nlo qcd corrections to @xmath180 have been calculated in the heavy - top - quark limit @xcite .
they increase this contribution significantly .
the calculation of the qcd corrections has been supplemented by the full nlo electroweak corrections @xcite . within the @xmath29-scheme
they decrease the cross section by about 10% and are thus of the same relevance as the nnlo qcd corrections , see fig .
[ fg : vhcorr ] . the nlo qcd and electroweak corrections
are implemented in the public program hawk @xcite including leptonic decays of the final - state vector boson .
the nnlo qcd corrections are implemented in the public codes hvnnlo @xcite that includes final - state higgs decays into leptons and bottom quarks , mcfm @xcite , vhnnlo @xcite , vh@nnlo @xcite and nnlops @xcite .
the nlo results have been matched to parton showers within the powheg box @xcite and the mg5_amc@nlo framework @xcite .
( 150,280)(0,0 ) ( -170,-10.0 ) ( 100,-10.0 ) ( 180,90)(40,0 ) ( 0,20)(50,20)-35 ( 0,80)(50,80)35 ( 50,20)(50,80 ) ( 50,80)(100,50 ) ( 100,50)(50,20 ) ( 100,50)(150,50)35 ( 150,50)(200,80)35 ( 150,50)(200,20)5 ( 205,76)@xmath15 ( 205,16)@xmath12 ( 25,46)@xmath56 ( -15,18)@xmath57 ( -15,78)@xmath57 ( 180,90)(-40,0 ) ( 0,20)(50,20)-35 ( 0,80)(50,80)35 ( 50,20)(50,80 ) ( 50,80)(100,80 ) ( 100,80)(100,20 ) ( 100,20)(50,20 ) ( 100,80)(150,80)35 ( 100,20)(150,20)5 ( 155,76)@xmath15 ( 155,16)@xmath12 ( 25,46)@xmath56 ( -15,18)@xmath57 ( -15,78)@xmath57 + ( 160,120)(0,-10 ) ( 0,100)(50,50 ) ( 50,50)(0,0 ) ( 50,50)(100,50)35 ( 100,50)(150,100)36 ( 100,50)(150,0)5 ( 155,-4)@xmath160 ( -15,-2)@xmath167 ( -15,98)@xmath69 ( 65,65)@xmath96 ( 155,96)@xmath96 + for the same reasons as in the vector - boson - fusion mechanism case , the higgs - strahlung off @xmath96 bosons , @xmath181 ( see fig .
[ fg : mssmvhvlodia ] ) , is smaller for the scalar mssm higgs particles @xmath160 than for the sm higgs boson apart from the decoupling regime for the light scalar @xmath11 .
the cross sections can be easily related to the sm cross sections , @xmath182 which is true up to nnlo qcd apart from the loop - induced @xmath183 process that involves the large top yukawa coupling in addition to the @xmath184 coupling , see fig .
[ fg : ggzhdia ] .
pseudoscalar couplings to intermediate vector bosons are absent so that pseudoscalar higgs particles can not be produced at tree level in this channel .
the relative qcd corrections are the same as in the sm case and thus of moderate size @xcite in general up to nnlo .
only the contamination from @xmath183 will be weighted differently due to the top yukawa coupling factor .
its contribution ranges at about 20% .
the genuine susy
qcd corrections are small @xcite , while the genuine susy - electroweak corrections are unknown so far .
( 360,120)(0,-10 ) ( 0,100)(50,50 ) ( 50,50)(0,0 ) ( 50,50)(100,50)35 ( 100,50)(125,75 ) ( 125,75)(150,100 ) ( 150,0)(100,50 ) ( 125,75)(150,50)5 ( 155,46)@xmath12 ( -15,98)@xmath69 ( -15,-2)@xmath167 ( 65,65)@xmath57 ( 155,98)@xmath130 ( 155,-2)@xmath185 ( 250,0)(300,0)35 ( 250,100)(300,100)35 ( 350,0)(300,0 ) ( 300,0)(300,50 ) ( 300,50)(300,100 ) ( 300,100)(350,100 ) ( 300,50)(350,50)5 ( 355,46)@xmath12 ( 235,98)@xmath57 ( 235,-2)@xmath57 ( 355,98)@xmath130 ( 355,-2)@xmath185 + [ [ tbar - th - production . ] ] @xmath186 production .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + in the intermediate higgs mass range the cross section of the associated production of the higgs boson with a @xmath102 pair is smaller than those of the higgs - strahlung processes @xcite , but of significant size , since it allows to tag the additional @xmath102 pair and the higgs boson decays @xmath169 , @xmath187 as well as the rare photonic decay mode @xmath188 on the long time run .
this process is generated by gluon
gluon and @xmath175 initial states at leading order ( see fig . [
fg : httlodia ] ) . at the lhc the gluon
gluon channel is dominant due to the enhanced gluon structure function analogous to the gluon - fusion mechanism .
the nlo qcd corrections to @xmath186 production have been calculated and result in a moderate increase of the cross section by @xmath128 @xcite .
the origin of this moderate size is the strong phase - space suppression of the massive three - particle threshold so that soft and collinear threshold effects are strongly diminished .
the main parts of the qcd corrections originate from regions significantly above the production threshold and can be approximated by a fragmentation approach involving first producing a @xmath102 pair supplemented by the @xmath189 fragmentation in the high - energy limit @xcite . although this provides a bad approximation for the magnitude of the cross section itself it leads to a reasonable estimate of the relative qcd corrections @xcite .
the full nlo results have recently been implemented in the powheg box @xcite , matched to sherpa @xcite and generated within the mg5_amc@nlo framework @xcite thus offering nlo event generators matched to parton showers .
the nlo result has recently been improved by a soft and collinear gluon resummation based on the scet approach starting from the boosted final - state particle triplet @xcite leading to a further increase of the cross section by 5 - 10% .
the residual scale dependence is reduced to the level of @xmath190 .
recently the electroweak corrections have been calculated for @xmath186 production @xcite .
they range a the per - cent level and are thus small .
moreover , off - shell top - quark effects have been determined at nlo in qcd @xcite with leptonic top - quark decays and turn out to be small for the inclusive @xmath186 cross section .
however , they play a role in certain regions of phase space and are thus of relevance for distributions . [ [ bbar - bh - production . ] ] @xmath191 production .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + higgs bremsstrahlung off bottom quarks does not play a significant role for the sm higgs boson , but yields an important constraint on the bottom yukawa coupling .
its total cross section is of similar size as the @xmath186 production cross section .
the results of @xmath186 production can be taken over for @xmath191 production .
however , they have to be transformed to the four - flavour - scheme ( 4fs ) in order to avoid artificial large logarithms initiated by the bottom mass in the combination of the virtual and real corrections at nlo . in this way
finite bottom - mass effects can be taken into account consistently .
the nlo qcd corrections are positive and large .
there is a decrease by about 10% due to top - yukawa induced contributions at nlo corresponding to the diagrams of fig .
[ fg : bbhyt ] @xcite .
( 180,120)(40,-10 ) ( 0,0)(50,0)-35 ( 0,80)(50,80)35 ( 50,80)(80,80)33 ( 50,80)(50,60)32 ( 80,80)(100,100 ) ( 100,60)(80,80 ) ( 50,0)(50,60 ) ( 50,60)(100,30 ) ( 100,30)(50,0 ) ( 100,30)(150,30)5 ( 155,26)@xmath12 ( 105,96)@xmath88 ( 105,56)@xmath192 ( 40,36)@xmath130 ( -15,-2)@xmath57 ( -15,78)@xmath57 ( 180,120)(-40,-10 ) ( 0,20)(50,20)-35 ( 0,80)(50,80)35 ( 50,20)(50,80 ) ( 50,80)(100,80 ) ( 100,80)(100,20 ) ( 100,20)(50,20 ) ( 100,80)(130,80)33 ( 130,80)(150,100 ) ( 150,60)(130,80 ) ( 100,20)(150,20)5 ( 155,16)@xmath12 ( 155,96)@xmath88 ( 155,56)@xmath192 ( 40,46)@xmath130 ( -15,18)@xmath57 ( -15,78)@xmath57 + however , the @xmath101-integration of the final - state bottom quarks generates potentially large logarithmic contributions as part of the 4fs result , @xmath193 where the effective bottom densities are given by @xmath194 with a scale @xmath155 significantly smaller than the higgs boson mass as can be inferred from the @xmath101 distribution of the bottom quark in the final state @xcite .
the logarithmic contributions contained in @xmath195 can be resummed by the dlglap evolution @xcite of the initial - state bottom pdfs .
this requires to treat the bottom quark as a massless active flavour , i.e. to introduce the 5fs with bottom densities of the proton .
( 100,110)(-20,0 ) ( 0,100)(50,50 ) ( 50,50)(0,0 ) ( 50,50)(100,50)5 ( 105,46)@xmath12 ( -15,98)@xmath88 ( -15,-2)@xmath192 + the 5fs - calculation starts from the process @xmath196 at lo , see fig . [ fg : bb2hdia ] , yielding the lo cross section @xmath197 with the variable @xmath198 involving the hadronic c.m .
energy squared @xmath68 and the parton luminosity @xmath199\ ] ] the 5fs relies on three approximations at lo , i.e. neglecting bottom - mass and off - shell effects and the transverse momenta of the initial - state bottom quarks .
the last two conditions are resolved by adding the higher - order qcd corrections so that only the inclusion of bottom mass effects is not possible in the 5fs framework . in the small - mass limit
the 4fs- and 5fs - calculations have to approach each other at higher orders so that the comparison of both schemes yields an estimate of missing higher - order corrections . using the running @xmath31 bottom mass @xmath200 the nlo qcd corrections to @xmath196
have been calculated @xcite , @xmath201 with @xmath202 , the coefficient functions @xmath203 + 1-z \right\ } \nonumber \\
\omega_{bg}(z ) & = & -\frac{1}{2 } p_{qg}(z ) \log \left ( \frac{\mu_f^2}{(1-z)^2 \tau s } \right ) - \frac{1}{8}(1-z)(3 - 7z)\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the parton luminosity @xmath204\ ] ] the calculation of the qcd corrections to @xmath196 has been extended to nnlo @xcite .
the qcd corrections decrease the cross section by about 30% for the central scale choice equal to the higgs mass . at nnlo
the @xmath205-initiated diagrams of the 4fs ( see fig . [
fg : httlodia ] ) contribute for the first time so that the kinematics of the spectator bottom quarks is restored . for a better comparison of both schemes
a general analysis of the logarithms related to the @xmath101-integrated bottom quarks has been performed with the result that the proper factorization scale to be chosen for the bottom densities is significantly smaller than the higgs boson mass within the 5fs @xcite .
this analysis has been extended to all orders for the logarithmic terms and confirms the smaller effective factorization scale in the 5fs @xcite .
this decreases the 5fs result and makes it agree better with the nlo 4fs result . in order to combine both calculations within the 4fs and 5fs
one has to avoid double counting of common contributions according to eq .
( [ eq : beff ] ) .
this has been done empirically in the past by using the santander matching @xcite @xmath206 where the chosen weight @xmath207 pays attention to the fact that the common terms of both calculations are logarithmic .
[ fg : bbhcomp ] shows the comparison of the nlo 4fs result with the nnlo 5fs and santander - matched cross section as a function of the higgs mass .
this empirically matched result has been improved by two different procedures of a consistent matching of the 4fs and 5fs , one dubbed fonll @xcite and the other nlo+nnll@xmath208+ybyt @xcite .
both approaches reexpress the quantities of one scheme in terms of the other one and use suitably modified sets of the pdf4lhc15 parton density functions that treat the particular region at the input scale of the size of the bottom mass consistent with the matching procedures @xcite .
the perturbative counting within both approaches is different so that a comparison of both approaches is motivated to obtain an idea of their differences .
both results are shown together with the santander - matched result in fig .
[ fg : bbhmatch ] as a function of the higgs mass .
both consistent matching procedures agree well within their respective uncertainties and come out slightly higher than the cross sections obtained by santander matching by about 20% .
both consistently matched results indicate a tendency towards the original 5fs calculation for larger higgs boson masses .
[ [ th - production . ] ] @xmath209 production .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + ( 100,100)(100,0 ) ( 0,80)(50,80 ) ( 0,20)(50,20)35 ( 50,80)(100,110 ) ( 50,80)(50,50)33 ( 50,20)(50,50 ) ( 100,20)(50,20 ) ( 50,50)(100,50 ) ( 100,50)(150,20 ) ( 100,50)(150,80)5 ( -60,48)@xmath210 ( 155,76)@xmath12 ( 155,18)@xmath130 ( -15,78)@xmath69 ( -15,18)@xmath57 ( 105,108)@xmath211 ( 55,65)@xmath7 ( 75,55)@xmath130 ( 105,18)@xmath192 ( 100,100)(-30,0 ) ( 0,80)(50,80 ) ( 0,20)(50,20)35 ( 50,80)(100,110 ) ( 50,80)(50,40)34 ( 50,20)(50,40 ) ( 100,20)(50,20 ) ( 50,40)(100,40 ) ( 50,60)(100,60)5 ( 105,56)@xmath12 ( 105,38)@xmath130 ( -15,78)@xmath69 ( -15,18)@xmath57 ( 105,108)@xmath211 ( 55,65)@xmath7 ( 105,18)@xmath192 + ( 100,100)(100,0 ) ( 0,80)(50,80 ) ( 0,20)(50,20 ) ( 50,80)(100,80 ) ( 50,80)(50,20)35 ( 50,20)(100,20 ) ( 100,20)(150,0 ) ( 100,20)(150,40)5 ( -60,48)@xmath212 ( 155,36)@xmath12 ( 155,-2)@xmath130 ( -15,78)@xmath69 ( -15,18)@xmath88 ( 105,78)@xmath211 ( 55,46)@xmath7 ( 75,25)@xmath130 ( 100,100)(-30,0 ) ( 0,80)(50,80 ) ( 0,20)(50,20 ) ( 50,80)(100,80 ) ( 50,80)(50,20)35 ( 50,20)(100,20 ) ( 50,50)(100,50)5 ( 105,46)@xmath12 ( 105,18)@xmath130 ( -15,78)@xmath69 ( -15,18)@xmath88 ( 105,78)@xmath211 ( 55,61)@xmath7 + ( 100,120)(100,0 ) ( 0,80)(50,50 ) ( 50,50)(0,20 ) ( 50,50)(100,50)35 ( 150,80)(100,50 ) ( 100,50)(125,35 ) ( 125,35)(150,20 ) ( 125,35)(150,50)5 ( -60,48)@xmath213 ( 155,46)@xmath12 ( 155,18)@xmath130 ( -15,78)@xmath69 ( -15,18)@xmath167 ( 155,78)@xmath192 ( 70,60)@xmath7 ( 100,100)(-30,0 ) ( 0,80)(50,50 ) ( 50,50)(0,20 ) ( 50,50)(100,50)35 ( 100,50)(150,80)5 ( 100,50)(125,35)33 ( 125,35)(150,20 ) ( 150,50)(125,35 ) ( 155,76)@xmath12 ( 155,18)@xmath130 ( -15,78)@xmath69 ( -15,18)@xmath167 ( 155,48)@xmath192 ( 70,60)@xmath7 + single - top quark production in association with a higgs boson proceeds in two different generic ways at lo , the dominant @xmath130-channel contribution and the subleading @xmath68-channel one , see fig .
[ fg : thdia ] .
it allows to test the sign of the top yukawa coupling , since there are interference effects between the higgs - boson couplings to top quarks and @xmath7 bosons .
the @xmath130-channel suffers from the same problem as @xmath191 production , i.e. there is the alternative to treat it within the 4fs or 5fs the latter starting with bottom densities of the proton the dglap evolution of which resum potentially large logarithms arising in the 4fs . within the 5fs
there is no interference between the @xmath130- and @xmath68-channel contributions up to nlo .
the full nlo calculation has been performed by means of the mg5_amc@nlo framework @xcite .
the qcd corrections to the @xmath130-channel contribution are small , i.e. @xmath165 , and of a similar size as the difference between the 4fs and 5fs at nlo . in order to reduce the difference between the 4fs and 5fs the central scale choice
has been reduced to @xmath214 for the @xmath130-channel contributions , while the @xmath68-channel uses a central scale twice as large @xcite .
the theoretical uncertainties , estimated from the scale dependence and the difference between both schemes , range at the level of 515% @xcite . including the pdf+@xmath50 uncertainties the total uncertainty can be estimated to be in the same ball park .
[ [ tbar - tbbar - b - phi - production . ] ] @xmath215 production .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + ( 360,120)(0,-10 ) ( 0,100)(50,50 ) ( 50,50)(0,0 ) ( 50,50)(100,50)35 ( 100,50)(125,75 ) ( 125,75)(150,100 ) ( 150,0)(100,50 ) ( 125,75)(150,50)5 ( 155,46)@xmath106 ( -15,98)@xmath69 ( -15,-2)@xmath167 ( 65,65)@xmath57 ( 155,98)@xmath216 ( 155,-2)@xmath217 ( 250,0)(300,0)35 ( 250,100)(300,100)35 ( 350,0)(300,0 ) ( 300,0)(300,50 ) ( 300,50)(300,100 ) ( 300,100)(350,100 ) ( 300,50)(350,50)5 ( 355,46)@xmath106 ( 235,98)@xmath57 ( 235,-2)@xmath57 ( 355,98)@xmath216 ( 355,-2)@xmath217 + the scalar higgs cross sections for higgs bremsstrahlung off heavy quarks @xmath155 can simply be related to the sm case at lo : @xmath218 this relation is also valid at nlo apart from diagrams involving closed top / bottom loops coupling to the higgs bosons , see fig .
[ fg : bbhyt ] .
the lo expressions for the pseudoscalar higgs boson @xcite are similarly involved as the scalar case and will not be presented here .
the top quark coupling to mssm higgs bosons is suppressed with respect to the sm for @xmath219 .
therefore higgs bremsstrahlung off top quarks @xmath220 is less important for mssm higgs particles . on
the other hand higgs bremsstrahlung off bottom quarks @xmath221 will be the dominant higgs production channel for large @xmath17 due to the strongly enhanced bottom quark yukawa couplings @xcite .
the qcd corrections for the scalar higgs bosons can be inferred from the sm cross section by eq .
( [ eq : tthmssm ] ) but with the properly rescaled diagrams of fig .
[ fg : bbhyt ] .
the nlo qcd corrections to pseudoscalar @xmath222 production have been calculated in ref .
@xcite yielding a slightly larger but moderate increase of the cross section .
the full susy - qcd corrections have been calculated quite recently for @xmath223 production @xcite and for @xmath224 production in the 4fs @xcite and the 5fs @xcite .
being of moderate size for small values of @xmath42 , i.e. similar to the pure qcd corrections , they can be large for @xmath224 production due to the @xmath127 corrections to the bottom yukawa couplings .
however , the remainder after absorbing the leading terms in the effective resummed yukawa couplings turns out to be small @xcite .
the susy - electroweak corrections are known for @xmath225 production within the 5fs @xcite .
the latter can be well approximated by the radiatively improved higgs masses and couplings and the electroweak @xmath127 terms for large values of @xmath42 .
[ [ charged - higgs - production . ] ] charged higgs production .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + ( 130,110)(300,0 ) ( 250,0)(300,0)35 ( 250,100)(300,100)35 ( 350,0)(300,0 ) ( 300,0)(300,50 ) ( 300,50)(300,100 ) ( 300,100)(350,100 ) ( 300,50)(350,50)5 ( 355,46)@xmath226 ( 235,98)@xmath57 ( 235,-2)@xmath57 ( 355,98)@xmath130 ( 355,-2)@xmath192 ( 295,-30)_(a ) _ ( 130,110)(-20,0 ) ( 0,100)(50,50 ) ( 50,50)(0,0 ) ( 50,50)(100,50)35 ( 100,50)(150,100)5 ( 100,50)(150,0)5 ( 155,96)@xmath227 ( 155,-4)@xmath226 ( -15,-2)@xmath167 ( -15,98)@xmath69 ( 60,60)@xmath228 ( 75,-30)_(b ) _ + ( 130,110)(70,0 ) ( 10,20)(50,20)-34 ( 10,80)(50,80)34 ( 50,20)(50,80 ) ( 50,80)(90,80 ) ( 90,80)(90,20 ) ( 90,20)(50,20 ) ( 90,80)(130,80)5 ( 90,20)(130,20)5 ( 0,18)@xmath57 ( 0,78)@xmath57 ( 55,85)@xmath229 ( 135,76)@xmath227 ( 135,16)@xmath226 ( 60,-10)_(c ) _ ( 130,110)(-30,0 ) ( 10,20)(50,20)-34 ( 10,80)(50,80)34 ( 50,20)(50,80 ) ( 50,80)(90,80 ) ( 90,80)(90,20 ) ( 90,20)(50,20 ) ( 90,80)(130,80)34 ( 90,20)(130,20)5 ( 0,18)@xmath57 ( 0,78)@xmath57 ( 55,85)@xmath229 ( 135,76)@xmath230 ( 135,16)@xmath226 ( 60,-10)_(d ) _ + ( 130,110)(50,0 ) ( 0,80)(50,80 ) ( 50,80)(50,20 ) ( 50,20)(0,20 ) ( 50,80)(100,80)5 ( 50,20)(100,20)5 ( 105,76)@xmath226 ( 105,16)@xmath227 ( -15,78)@xmath88 ( -15,18)@xmath192 ( 55,48)@xmath130 ( 45,-10)_(e ) _ ( 130,110)(-50,0 ) ( 0,80)(50,80 ) ( 50,80)(50,20 ) ( 50,20)(0,20 ) ( 50,20)(100,20)36 ( 50,80)(100,80)5 ( 105,76)@xmath226 ( 105,16)@xmath230 ( -15,78)@xmath88 ( -15,18)@xmath192 ( 55,48)@xmath130 ( 45,-10)_(f ) _ + ( 130,120)(10,0 ) ( 0,100)(50,100 ) ( 50,100)(100,100 ) ( 0,0)(50,0 ) ( 50,0)(100,0 ) ( 50,100)(50,70)33 ( 50,30)(50,0)33 ( 50,70)(100,70)5 ( 50,30)(100,30)5 ( 50,70)(50,30)5 ( 55,83)@xmath231 ( 55,13)@xmath231 ( 105,66)@xmath226 ( 105,26)@xmath227 ( 105,98)@xmath69 ( 105,-2)@xmath69 ( -15,98)@xmath69 ( -15,-2)@xmath69 ( 45,-20)_(g ) _ + charged higgs bosons are dominantly produced at the lhc in association with top quarks @xmath232 and the charge - conjugated process , see fig .
[ fg : hcpro]a . for charged higgs - boson masses
@xmath233 the dominant contribution to this process factorizes into @xmath102 pair production with the subsequent ( anti)top decay into a charged higgs and ( anti)bottom quark .
this region is then suitably described by the qcd- and electroweak - corrected @xmath102 production cross section @xcite multiplied with the radiatively corrected branching ratio of the top decays @xcite . however , for larger charged higgs masses the top decays are kinematically closed and charged higgs bosons are produced in terms of the full process of fig .
[ fg : hcpro]a . for the inclusive rate
the final - state bottom quark gives rise to the options to calculate this process in the 4fs or the 5fs , where the latter starts from the process @xmath234 and the charge - conjugated process and thus uses bottom pdfs of the proton .
both calculations have been performed up to nlo qcd resulting in moderate scale dependences @xcite . while the 5fs is available exclusively for all distributions involving the top quark and charged higgs boson , the 4fs allows to determine distributions involving the bottom quark in the final state in addition .
both calculations have been combined by means of the santander matching of eq .
( [ eq : santander ] ) @xcite with the weight @xmath235 . for small values of @xmath42 the genuine susy - qcd corrections
are of moderate size @xcite , while for large @xmath42 they are completely dominated by @xmath127-terms with a small remainder .
thus for the compilation of the charged - higgs production cross section the effective bottom yukawa coupling @xmath236 ( combined with the top yukawa coupling factor @xmath237 ) has been used that can be translated into an effective @xmath42 value @xcite .
the result for the continuum production cross section without susy - qcd corrections is shown in fig .
[ fg : proch ] for two charged higgs masses as a function of @xmath42 .
the qcd corrections enhance the 4fs cross section by about 60% @xcite , while they are moderate for the 5fs @xcite .
( 150,180)(0,0 ) ( -300,-90.0 ) ( -40,-90.0 ) an open problem for a long time has been the treatment of the intermediate region between resonant top quark decays and the continuum contribution for large charged higgs masses .
this has been solved recently by a full nlo calculation in the 4fs within the complex - mass scheme for the intermediate top quarks @xcite .
the nlo qcd corrections turn out to be large in this mass regime , too , while the results nicely interpolate between the low- and high - mass regimes as can be inferred from fig .
[ fg : prochint ] .
( 150,350)(0,0 ) ( -90,-80.0 ) the second important charged higgs production process is charged higgs pair production in a drell yan type process ( see fig . [
fg : hcpro]b ) @xcite @xmath238 which is mediated by @xmath68-channel photon and @xmath15-boson exchange .
the nlo qcd corrections can be taken from the drell yan process and are of moderate size as in the case of the neutral higgs - strahlung process discussed before @xcite . the genuine susy
qcd corrections , mediated by virtual gluino and squark exchange in the initial state , are small @xcite . charged higgs pairs can also be produced from @xmath205 initial states by the loop - mediated process @xcite ( see fig . [
fg : hcpro]c ) @xmath239 where the dominant contributions emerge from top and bottom quark loops as well as stop and sbottom loops , if the squark masses are light enough .
the nlo corrections to this process are unknown .
this cross section is of similar size as the bottom - initiated process @xcite ( see fig . [
fg : hcpro]e ) @xmath240 which relies on the approximations required by the introduction of the bottom densities as discussed before and is known at nlo @xcite .
qcd corrections are of significant size due to the @xmath127 terms related to the bottom yukawa coupling .
the pure qcd corrections and the genuine susy
qcd corrections can be of opposite sign . charged higgs bosons can be produced in association with a @xmath7 boson @xcite ( see fig . [
fg : hcpro]d ) @xmath241 which is generated by top - bottom quark loops and stop - sbottom loops , if the squark masses are small enough .
this process is known at lo only .
the same final state also arises from the process @xcite ( see fig . [
fg : hcpro]f ) @xmath242 which is based on the approximations of the 5fs .
the qcd corrections have been calculated and turn out to be of moderate size @xcite .
finally , charged higgs - boson pairs can be produced in vector - boson - fusion @xcite ( see fig . [
fg : hcpro]g ) @xmath243 the lo cross section is independent of @xmath42 and can be sizeable within the mssm .
however , the calculation of ref .
@xcite is not consistent with the parton picture , since small quark masses have been introduced for the accompanying quarks in order to regulate the collinear divergences of photon - exchange contributions . for a more reliable prediction qed - mass factorization
has to be performed already at lo . -90
-90 all higgs boson production cross sections have been updated with the known higher - order corrections and the most recent parton density functions , i.e. the pdf4lhc15 sets @xcite , where nlo densities have been used consistently for nlo predictions and nnlo densities for nnlo predictions . using the same values of the input parameters as for the branching ratios discussed in section [ sc : br ] and their uncertainties
a rigorous analysis has been performed to derive a sophisticated prediction of the central cross section values and their uncertainties .
the results are shown in fig .
[ fg : hprodcxn ] as a function of the higgs mass for 13 and 14 tev c.m .
energy at the lhc .
the size of the coloured bands represents the individual sums of the theoretical and parametric uncertainties .
all production cross sections with results beyond nlo in qcd exhibit a small residual uncertainty in the few - per - cent range . only the cross sections for @xmath186 , @xmath244 and @xmath209 production
develop larger uncertainties due to the problems discussed in the previous sections .
the theoretical and parametric uncertainties of each production process have been added in quadrature .
the gluon - fusion cross sections can be predicted with a total ( gaussian ) uncertainty of about 5% , the vector - boson - fusion and @xmath245 higgs - strahlung channels with less than 3% uncertainty and the @xmath179 higgs - strahlung channel with about 4% uncertainty due to the novel loop contributions from @xmath180 as discussed in section [ sc : higgsstrahlung ] .
the uncertainties of @xmath186 production amount to about @xmath246 , for @xmath68- and @xmath130-channel @xmath209 production to about @xmath247 and for @xmath191 production to about @xmath248 . fig .
[ fg : hcxnen ] shows the energy dependence of the higgs production cross sections for a higgs mass @xmath92 gev .
it is visible that all cross sections develop a similar rising slope apart from @xmath186 and @xmath209 that grow stronger due to the larger phase - space suppression for smaller energies .
-90 an analogous update of the production cross sections as for the sm case has been made also for the mssm higgs - boson production cross sections .
the public code sushi @xcite has been used as the preferred choice since this includes the full nlo qcd corrections to the gluon - fusion cross section and the nnlo qcd corrections in the heavy top - quark limit for the top - loop contributionslo qcd corrections have been included in sushi @xcite . ] .
moreover , electroweak corrections originating from light - fermion loops @xcite are taken into account in this program .
for the @xmath249 production cross section sushi contains the nnlo qcd - corrected 5fs - cross section that agrees with the 4fs results within about 20% for the adopted scale choices
susy - qcd corrections are included in the heavy susy - particle limit for the gluon - fusion process and in the @xmath127 approximation for @xmath250 production .
the compiled cross sections within the @xmath53 scenario @xcite are shown in fig .
[ fig : mssmcxn ] for two values of @xmath42 .
the left plot exhibits the dominance of the gluon - fusion process for smaller values of @xmath42 and the right one the dominance of @xmath224 production for large values of @xmath42 .
uncertainties have not been added to these results , but have been analyzed in detail in ref .
@xcite .
( 150,240)(0,0 ) ( -280,-20.0 ) ( -30,-20.0 ) ( 100,100)(100,0 ) ( 0,80)(50,80)35 ( 0,20)(50,20)35 ( 50,20)(50,80 ) ( 50,80)(100,80 ) ( 100,80)(100,20 ) ( 100,20)(50,20 ) ( 100,80)(150,80)5 ( 100,20)(150,20)5 ( -60,48)@xmath210 ( 155,76)@xmath12 ( 155,16)@xmath12 ( -15,78)@xmath57 ( -15,18)@xmath57 ( 30,48)@xmath56 ( 100,100)(-20,0 ) ( 0,80)(50,80)35 ( 0,20)(50,20)35 ( 50,20)(50,80 ) ( 50,80)(100,50 ) ( 100,50)(50,20 ) ( 100,50)(150,50)5 ( 150,50)(200,80)5 ( 150,50)(200,20)5 ( 205,76)@xmath12 ( 205,16)@xmath12 ( -15,78)@xmath57 ( -15,18)@xmath57 ( 30,48)@xmath56 ( 146,46 ) ( 146,60 ) + ( 100,100)(100,0 ) ( 0,80)(50,80 ) ( 50,80)(100,80 ) ( 0,20)(50,20 ) ( 50,20)(100,20 ) ( 50,80)(50,20)35 ( 48,60)(100,60)5 ( 52,40)(100,40)5 ( -60,48)@xmath212 ( 105,78)@xmath69 ( 105,18)@xmath69 ( 105,56)@xmath12 ( 105,36)@xmath12 ( -15,78)@xmath69 ( -15,18)@xmath69 ( 20,48)@xmath96 ( 100,100)(-20,0 ) ( 0,80)(50,80 ) ( 50,80)(100,80 ) ( 0,20)(50,20 ) ( 50,20)(100,20 ) ( 50,80)(50,20)35 ( 50,50)(100,50)5 ( 100,50)(150,80)5 ( 100,50)(150,20)5 ( 105,78)@xmath69 ( 105,18)@xmath69 ( 155,76)@xmath12 ( 155,16)@xmath12 ( -15,78)@xmath69 ( -15,18)@xmath69 ( 20,63)@xmath96 ( 96,46 ) ( 96,60 ) + ( 100,100)(100,0 ) ( 0,80)(50,50 ) ( 50,50)(0,20 ) ( 50,50)(100,50)35 ( 100,50)(150,80)35 ( 100,50)(150,20)5 ( 120,60)(150,42)5 ( -60,48)@xmath213 ( 155,78)@xmath96 ( 155,38)@xmath12 ( 155,16)@xmath12 ( -15,78)@xmath69 ( -15,18)@xmath167 ( 60,60)@xmath96 ( 100,100)(-20,0 ) ( 0,80)(50,50 ) ( 50,50)(0,20 ) ( 50,50)(100,50)35 ( 100,50)(150,80)35 ( 100,50)(125,35)5 ( 125,35)(150,20)5 ( 125,35)(150,50)5 ( 155,78)@xmath96 ( 155,46)@xmath12 ( 155,16)@xmath12 ( -15,78)@xmath69 ( -15,18)@xmath167 ( 60,60)@xmath96 ( 121,31 ) ( 121,45 ) + ( 100,100)(100,0 ) ( 0,80)(50,80)35 ( 0,20)(50,20)35 ( 50,20)(50,80 ) ( 50,80)(100,80 ) ( 100,80)(100,50 ) ( 100,50)(100,20 ) ( 100,20)(50,20 ) ( 100,80)(150,80)35 ( 100,50)(150,50)5 ( 100,20)(150,20)5 ( 155,76)@xmath15 ( 155,46)@xmath12 ( 155,16)@xmath12 ( -15,78)@xmath57 ( -15,18)@xmath57 ( 30,48)@xmath56 ( 100,100)(-20,0 ) ( 0,80)(50,80)35 ( 0,20)(50,20)35 ( 50,20)(50,80 ) ( 50,80)(100,80 ) ( 100,80)(100,20 ) ( 100,20)(50,20 ) ( 100,80)(150,80)35 ( 100,20)(150,20)5 ( 125,20)(150,35)5 ( 155,76)@xmath15 ( 155,31)@xmath12 ( 155,16)@xmath12 ( -15,78)@xmath57 ( -15,18)@xmath57 ( 30,48)@xmath56 ( 121,16 ) ( 121,30 ) + ( 100,100)(100,0 ) ( 0,80)(50,80)35 ( 0,20)(50,20)35 ( 50,20)(50,40 ) ( 50,40)(50,60 ) ( 50,60)(50,80 ) ( 50,80)(100,80 ) ( 100,20)(50,20 ) ( 50,60)(100,60)5 ( 50,40)(100,40)5 ( -60,48)@xmath251 ( 105,78)@xmath130 ( 105,18)@xmath185 ( 105,56)@xmath12 ( 105,36)@xmath12 ( -15,78)@xmath57 ( -15,18)@xmath57 ( 100,100)(-20,0 ) ( 0,80)(50,80)35 ( 0,20)(50,20)35 ( 50,20)(50,50 ) ( 50,50)(50,80 ) ( 50,80)(100,80 ) ( 100,20)(50,20 ) ( 50,50)(100,50)5 ( 100,50)(150,80)5 ( 100,50)(150,20)5 ( 105,78)@xmath130 ( 105,18)@xmath185 ( 155,76)@xmath12 ( 155,16)@xmath12 ( -15,78)@xmath57 ( -15,18)@xmath57 ( 96,46 ) ( 96,60 ) + higgs - boson pair production is the first process that allows to obtain direct access to the trilinear self - coupling of the higgs boson and paves the way to the higgs potential at the origin of electroweak symmetry breaking .
higgs boson pairs are dominantly produced in the gluon - fusion process and to a lesser extent in vector - boson fusion , double higgs - strahlung and double higgs bremsstrahlung off top quarks , see fig .
[ fg : hhdia ] .
the production cross sections are shown as a function of the collider energy for a higgs mass @xmath92 gev in fig .
[ fg : hhcxns ] .
gluon fusion dominates the production of higgs - boson pairs by more than an order of magnitude , while the production modes roughly follow the pattern of single - higgs boson production .
since the diagrams involving the trilinear higgs coupling are only a subset for each process the sensitivity to the trilinear higgs coupling is reduced compared to the size of the individual cross sections .
the sensitivities of the individual production cross sections to the trilinear higgs coupling are shown in fig .
[ fg : hhcxns ] .
the locations of the minima of the cross sections in terms of the value of @xmath252 are different for the production mechanisms @xcite .
[ [ gluon - fusion . ] ] gluon fusion .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + the gluon - fusion process is mediated by top- and to a lesser extent bottom - quark loops .
there are box- and triangle contributions at lo , see fig .
[ fg : hhdia]a .
the box contributions are dominant with a destructive interference to the triangle diagrams @xcite .
the sensitivity to the trilinear higgs coupling follows the rough behaviour @xmath253 so that the uncertainties of the production cross section is immediately translated to the uncertainties of the extraction of the trilinear self - coupling . in the past
the nlo qcd corrections have been determined in the limit of heavy top quarks @xcite .
similar to the single higgs case they increase the cross section by up to 100% .
due to the fact that the invariant mass of the final - state higgs - boson pair is much larger than in the single - higgs case the heavy top - quark limit is expected to work less reliable in the higgs - pair case .
the first attempt to estimate finite top - mass effects at nlo was by means of a systematic heavy - top expansion of the inclusive cross section @xcite that gave an estimate of about 10% for the finite top - mass effects beyond lo .
the second attempt kept the virtual corrections in the heavy - top limit but included the real corrections exactly @xcite .
this resulted in a 10%-decrease of the nlo cross section .
very recently the full nlo calculation has been completed by numerical methods implying a decrease of the total cross section by about 14% at the lhc for a c.m .
energy of 13 tev @xcite so that the heavy - top limit works still reasonably well for the total cross section . for large invariant higgs - pair masses
the finite mass effects can reach a level of 20% .
the nlo result has been extended by the nnlo qcd corrections in the heavy top - quark limit that lead to a rise of the total cross section by about 20% @xcite . within a heavy top - quark expansion
nnlo top mass effects have been estimated to be at the 5%-level @xcite . finally a nnll soft and collinear gluon resummation has been added which adds a contribution of 5 - 10% beyond nnlo @xcite . including the most up - to - date theoretical status for the prediction of the total cross section the theoretical uncertainties due to the scale dependence
is reduced to about 5% . together with the pdf+@xmath50 uncertainties one obtains a total uncertainty of about 10% for the total cross section at the lhc @xcite .
recently a public code has been constructed for fully exclusive higgs - boson pair production via gluon fusion including nnlo qcd corrections at parton level @xcite .
[ [ vector - boson - fusion . ] ] vector - boson fusion .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + higgs - boson pair production via vector - boson fusion is dominated by @xmath130-channel contributions as in the single - higgs case , see fig .
[ fg : hhdia]b .
the nlo qcd corrections can be taken from deep inelastic lepton - nucleon scattering analogous to single - higgs production @xcite .
they increase the cross section by about 10% . within the same approach the nnlo qcd corrections
have been obtained @xcite .
they range at the per - cent level
. the residual theoretical and parametric uncertainties amount to about 3 - 4% at the lhc @xcite .
[ [ double - higgs - strahlung . ] ] double higgs - strahlung .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + double higgs - strahlung proceeds along the same lines as single - higgs - strahlung , i.e. the higgs boson pair is produced in association with a @xmath7 or @xmath15 boson , see fig .
[ fg : hhdia]c .
the nlo and nnlo qcd corrections can be taken over from the corresponding calculation for the drell yan process , since the final state is only weakly interacting @xcite .
the only difference to the drell yan process emerges from the additional loop - mediated @xmath254 process , see fig .
[ fg : hhdia]c .
this has been added to the nnlo qcd corrections .
the qcd corrections increase the production cross sections by about 30% , while the @xmath255 adds another 2030% to @xmath256 production @xcite .
the residual theoretical uncertainties range at the 3%-level for @xmath257 production and at the level of 4% for @xmath256 production @xcite . a fully differential calculation for @xmath257 final states
has recently been completed @xcite .
[ [ double - higgs - bremsstrahlung - off - top - quarks . ] ] double higgs bremsstrahlung off top quarks .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + higgs - boson pair production in association with top quarks is generated by analogous diagrams to the single - higgs case , see fig .
[ fg : hhdia]d @xcite .
the nlo qcd corrections have been calculated recently with the mg5_amc@nlo tool @xcite .
they modify the total cross section by about 20% and reduce the scale dependence to a level of less than 5% . the total theoretical and parametric uncertainties for this production process amount to about @xmath258 at the lhc with c.m .
energies of 13 and 14 tev @xcite .
( 100,100)(-30,-5 ) ( 0,100)(50,100)36 ( 0,0)(50,0)36 ( 50,100)(100,50 ) ( 100,50)(50,0 ) ( 50,0)(50,100 ) ( 100,50)(150,50)5 ( 150,50)(200,100)5 ( 150,50)(200,0)5 ( 165,76)@xmath259 ( 165,-5)@xmath260 ( 90,50)@xmath261 ( -15,-3)@xmath57 ( -15,78)@xmath57 ( 20,38)@xmath56 ( 100,100)(-150,-5 ) ( 0,100)(50,100)36 ( 0,0)(50,0)36 ( 50,100)(140,100 ) ( 140,100)(140,0 ) ( 140,0)(50,0 ) ( 50,0)(50,100 ) ( 140,100)(190,100)5 ( 140,0)(190,0)5 ( 165,76)@xmath259 ( 165,-5)@xmath260 ( -15,-3)@xmath57 ( -15,78)@xmath57 ( 20,38)@xmath56 in the mssm there are several possible neutral higgs - pair final states .
the gluon - fusion mechanism yields @xmath262 final states that emerge from analogous diagrams as in the sm - higgs case . in the mixed scalar - pseudoscalar channel , i.e. @xmath263
, off - shell @xmath15-boson exchange contributes to the @xmath68-channel diagrams , too , see fig .
[ fg : ggha ] .
however , these final states are dominates by drell - yan production mechanisms , see fig .
[ fg : hady ] .
since the qcd corrections to mssm higgs pair production via gluon fusion are only known in the heavy - top - quark limit so far , reliable nlo predictions of the corresponding cross sections are only possible for small values of @xmath42 where the top loops provide the dominant contributions and for not too large external higgs masses .
the qcd corrections are large and positive , increasing the cross sections by up to 100% @xcite .
the mssm cross sections for the gluon - fusion processes range below 10 fb in all regions where none of the higgs bosons involved in the @xmath68-channel becomes resonant .
however , for small values of @xmath42 and below the @xmath102-threshold there are sizeable regions where the heavy scalar higgs boson can become resonant and decays into @xmath264 final states , @xmath265 . in these regions
the cross sections become large , since the dominant piece factorizes into the single heavy - scalar higgs production cross section and the branching ratio of the @xmath266 decay @xcite .
mixed scalar - pseudoscalar higgs boson production is dominated by the drell yan process @xmath267 .
the qcd corrections can be translated from the corresponding drell yan process and are of moderate size @xcite .
the cross sections for these processes can reach the level of about 100 fb . ( 160,100)(0,0 ) ( 0,80)(50,50 ) ( 50,50)(0,20 ) ( 50,50)(100,50)35 ( 100,50)(150,80)5 ( 100,50)(150,20)5 ( 155,16)@xmath160 ( -15,18)@xmath167 ( -15,78)@xmath69 ( 70,60)@xmath15 ( 155,76)@xmath13 +
in this review the decay widths and branching ratios of sm and mssm higgs bosons have been discussed .
all relevant higher order corrections , which are dominated by qcd corrections , have been summarized according to the present state of the art . at the lhc
the sm higgs particle is produced predominantly by gluon fusion @xmath2 , followed by vector - boson fusion @xmath268 ( @xmath52 ) and , to a lesser extent , higgs - strahlung off vector bosons , @xmath269 , and top quarks , @xmath270 .
the cross sections of these production channels have been described including all known qcd and electroweak corrections , which are important in particular for the dominant gluon - fusion mechanism . in the mssm
the neutral higgs bosons will mainly be produced via gluon fusion @xmath117 .
however , through the enhanced @xmath88 quark couplings , higgs bremsstrahlung off @xmath88 quarks , @xmath271 , will dominate for large @xmath42 .
all other higgs production mechanisms , i.e. vector - boson fusion and higgs - strahlung off vector bosons or @xmath102 pairs , will be less important than in the sm .
g. aad _ et al . _ [ atlas collaboration ] , phys .
* b716 * ( 2012 ) 1 ; s. chatrchyan _ et al . _
[ cms collaboration ] , phys .
lett . * b716 * ( 2012 ) 30
. g. aad _ et al . _ [ atlas and cms collaborations ] , jhep * 1608 * ( 2016 ) 045 .
p. w. higgs , phys .
* 12 * ( 1964 ) 132 , phys .
* 13 * ( 1964 ) 508 and phys .
* 145 * ( 1966 ) 1156 ; f. englert and r. brout , phys .
* 13 * ( 1964 ) 321 ; g. s. guralnik , c. r. hagen and t. w. kibble , phys .
* 13 * ( 1964 ) 585 ; t. w. b. kibble , phys .
* 155 * ( 1967 ) 1554 .
g. t hooft , nucl .
b * 35 * ( 1971 ) 167 ; g. t hooft and m. j. g. veltman , nucl .
b * 44 * ( 1972 ) 189 . c. h. llewellyn smith , phys .
lett . * 46b * ( 1973 ) 233 ; j. m. cornwall , d. n. levin and g. tiktopoulos , phys .
d * 10 * ( 1974 ) 1145 erratum : [ phys .
d * 11 * ( 1975 ) 972 ] ; b. w. lee , c. quigg and h. b. thacker , phys .
* 38 * ( 1977 ) 883 and phys .
d * 16 * ( 1977 ) 1519 .
n. cabibbo , l. maiani , g. parisi and r. petronzio , nucl .
b * 158 * ( 1979 ) 295 ; m. s. chanowitz , m. a. furman and i. hinchliffe , phys . lett . * 78b * ( 1978 ) 285 ; r. a. flores and m. sher , phys . rev .
d * 27 * ( 1983 ) 1679 ; m. lindner , z. phys .
c * 31 * ( 1986 ) 295 ; a. hasenfratz , k. jansen , c. b. lang , t. neuhaus and h. yoneyama , phys .
b * 199 * ( 1987 ) 531 ; j. kuti , l. lin and y. shen , phys .
* 61 * ( 1988 ) 678 ; m. lscher and p. weisz , nucl .
b * 318 * ( 1989 ) 705 ; m. sher , phys .
* 179 * ( 1989 ) 273 and phys .
b * 317 * ( 1993 ) 159 addendum : [ phys .
b * 331 * ( 1994 ) 448 ] ; g. altarelli and g. isidori , phys .
b * 337 * ( 1994 ) 141 ; j. a. casas , j. r. espinosa and m. quiros , phys .
b * 342 * ( 1995 ) 171 .
g. degrassi , s. di vita , j. elias - miro , j. r. espinosa , g. f. giudice , g. isidori and a. strumia , jhep * 1208 * ( 2012 ) 098 ; d. buttazzo , g. degrassi , p. p. giardino , g. f. giudice , f. sala , a. salvio and a. strumia , jhep * 1312 * ( 2013 ) 089 . j. r. espinosa and m. quiros , phys .
b * 353 * ( 1995 ) 257 .
e. gildener and s. weinberg , phys .
d * 13 * ( 1976 ) 3333 ; s. weinberg , phys .
d * 13 * ( 1976 ) 974 and phys .
d * 19 * ( 1979 ) 1277 ; l. susskind , phys . rev .
d * 20 * ( 1979 ) 2619 .
y. a. golfand and e. p. likhtman , jetp lett .
* 13 * ( 1971 ) 323 [ pisma zh . eksp .
* 13 * ( 1971 ) 452 ] ; d. v. volkov and v. p. akulov , phys .
lett . *
46b * ( 1973 ) 109 ; j. wess and b. zumino , nucl .
b * 70 * ( 1974 ) 39 . for reviews on supersymmetric theories , see p. fayet and s. ferrara , phys .
* 32 * ( 1977 ) 249 ; h. p. nilles , phys . rept .
* 110 * ( 1984 ) 1 ; r. barbieri , riv .
nuovo cim .
* 11n4 * ( 1988 ) 1 ; h. e. haber and g. l. kane , phys .
* 117 * ( 1985 ) 75 .
n. arkani - hamed , a. g. cohen and h. georgi , phys .
b * 513 * ( 2001 ) 232 ; n. arkani - hamed , a. g. cohen , t. gregoire and j. g. wacker , jhep * 0208 * ( 2002 ) 020 ; n. arkani - hamed , a. g. cohen , e. katz , a. e. nelson , t. gregoire and j. g. wacker , jhep * 0208 * ( 2002 ) 021 .
n. arkani - hamed , s. dimopoulos and g. r. dvali , phys .
b * 429 * ( 1998 ) 263 ; i. antoniadis , n. arkani - hamed , s. dimopoulos and g. r. dvali , phys .
b * 436 * ( 1998 ) 257 ; l. randall and r. sundrum , phys .
* 83 * ( 1999 ) 3370 and phys .
* 83 * ( 1999 ) 4690 .
h. m. georgi , s. l. glashow , m. e. machacek and d. v. nanopoulos , phys .
* 40 * ( 1978 ) 692 .
r. n. cahn and s. dawson , phys .
* 136b * ( 1984 ) 196 erratum : [ phys .
* 138b * ( 1984 ) 464 ] ; k. i. hikasa , phys .
lett . * 164b * ( 1985 ) 385 erratum : [ phys .
b * 195 * ( 1987 ) 623 ] ; g. altarelli , b. mele and f. pitolli , nucl .
b * 287 * ( 1987 ) 205 .
s. l. glashow , d. v. nanopoulos and a. yildiz , phys .
d * 18 * ( 1978 ) 1724 ; z. kunszt , z. trocsanyi and w. j. stirling , phys .
b * 271 * ( 1991 ) 247 .
r. raitio and w.w .
wada , phys .
* d19 * ( 1979 ) 941 ; j. n. ng and p. zakarauskas , phys .
rev . * d29 * ( 1984 ) 876 ; z. kunszt , nucl .
* b247 * ( 1984 ) 339 ; j. f. gunion , phys .
lett . * b261 * ( 1991 ) 510517 ; w. j. marciano and f. e. paige , phys .
* 66 * ( 1991 ) 24332435
. j. m. butterworth , a. r. davison , m. rubin and g. p. salam , phys .
* 100 * ( 2008 ) 242001 .
d. l. rainwater , d. zeppenfeld and k. hagiwara , phys .
d * 59 * ( 1998 ) 014037 ; t. plehn , d. l. rainwater and d. zeppenfeld , phys .
b * 454 * ( 1999 ) 297 .
e. witten , phys .
lett . *
105b * ( 1981 ) 267 .
s. dimopoulos , s. raby and f. wilczek , phys .
d * 24 * ( 1981 ) 1681 ; l. e. ibanez and g. g. ross , phys .
* 105b * ( 1981 ) 439 . l. e. ibanez and g. g. ross , phys .
* 110b * ( 1982 ) 215 .
h. goldberg , phys .
* 50 * ( 1983 ) 1419 erratum : [ phys .
* 103 * ( 2009 ) 099905 ] ; j. r. ellis , j. s. hagelin , d. v. nanopoulos , k. a. olive and m. srednicki , nucl .
b * 238 * ( 1984 ) 453 .
s. dimopoulos and h. georgi , nucl .
b * 193 * ( 1981 ) 150 .
p. fayet , nucl .
b * 90 * ( 1975 ) 104 , phys . lett .
b * 64 * ( 1976 ) 159 and phys .
b * 69 * ( 1977 ) 489 ; n. sakai , z. phys .
c * 11 * ( 1981 ) 153 ; k. inoue , a. kakuto , h. komatsu and s. takeshita , prog .
theor . phys .
* 67 * ( 1982 ) 1889 , prog
. theor .
* 68 * ( 1982 ) 927 [ erratum - ibid .
* 70 * ( 1983 ) 330 ] and prog .
* 71 * ( 1984 ) 413 .
see e.g. g. degrassi , s. heinemeyer , w. hollik , p. slavich and g. weiglein , eur .
j. * c28 * ( 2003 ) 133 .
f. zwirner , in * saariselkae 1991 , proceedings , physics and experiments with linear colliders , vol . 1 * 309 - 351 and cern geneva - th .
6357 [ hep - ph/9203204 ] .
s. p. martin , phys .
* d75 * ( 2007 ) 055005 ; r. v. harlander , p. kant , l. mihaila and m. steinhauser , phys .
* 100 * ( 2008 ) 191602 , erratum _ ibid .
_ * 101 * ( 2008 ) 039901 .
p. draper , g. lee and c. e. m. wagner , phys .
d * 89 * ( 2014 ) no.5 , 055023 ; e. bagnaschi , g. f. giudice , p. slavich and a. strumia , jhep * 1409 * ( 2014 ) 092 ; k. cheung , r. huo , j. s. lee and y. l. sming tsai , jhep * 1504 * ( 2015 ) 151 ; j. pardo vega and g. villadoro , jhep * 1507 * ( 2015 ) 159 ; g. lee and c. e. m. wagner , phys
. rev .
d * 92 * ( 2015 ) no.7 , 075032 ; h. bahl and w. hollik , eur .
j. c * 76 * ( 2016 ) no.9 , 499 .
barger , m.s .
berger , a.l .
stange and r.j.n .
phillips , phys .
rev . * d45 * ( 1992 ) 4128 ; w. hollik and s. pearanda , eur .
j. * c23 * ( 2002 ) 163 ; a. dobado , m.j .
herrero , w. hollik and s. pearanda , phys .
* d66 * ( 2002 ) 095016 .
m. brucherseifer , r. gavin and m. spira , phys .
d * 90 * ( 2014 ) no.11 , 117701 ; m. brucherseifer , phd thesis , eth zrich , 2012 .
l. j. hall , r. rattazzi and u. sarid , phys .
d * 50 * , 7048 ( 1994 ) ; r. hempfling , phys .
d * 49 * , 6168 ( 1994 ) ; m. carena , m. olechowski , s. pokorski and c. e. m. wagner , nucl .
b * 426 * ( 1994 ) 269 ; d. m. pierce , j. a. bagger , k. t. matchev and r .- j .
zhang , nucl .
b * 491 * , 3 ( 1997 ) ; j. guasch , w. hollik and s. pearanda , phys .
b * 515 * ( 2001 ) 367 ; g. dambrosio , g. f. giudice , g. isidori and a. strumia , nucl .
b * 645 * , 155 ( 2002 ) ; a. j. buras , p. h. chankowski , j. rosiek and l. slawianowska , nucl .
b * 659 * , 3 ( 2003 ) ; v. barger , h. e. logan and g. shaughnessy , phys .
d * 79 * , 115018 ( 2009 ) ; n. d. christensen , t. han and s. su , phys .
d * 85 * , 115018 ( 2012 ) .
m. s. carena , d. garcia , u. nierste and c. e. m. wagner , nucl .
b * 577 * , 88 ( 2000 ) .
j. guasch , p. hfliger and m. spira , phys .
d * 68 * , 115001 ( 2003 ) .
d. noth and m. spira , phys .
* 101 * , 181801 ( 2008 ) and jhep * 1106 * , 084 ( 2011 ) .
l. mihaila and c. reisser , jhep * 1008 * , 021 ( 2010 ) ; a. crivellin and c. greub , phys .
d * 87 * ( 2013 ) 015013 erratum : [ phys .
d * 87 * ( 2013 ) 079901 ] .
b. a. kniehl , phys .
* 240 * ( 1994 ) 211 ; a. djouadi , phys .
* 457 * ( 2008 ) 1 and phys .
* 459 * ( 2008 ) 1 ; s. dittmaier and m. schumacher , prog .
phys . * 70 * ( 2013 ) 1 ; j. baglio , a. djouadi and j. quevillon , rept .
* 79 * ( 2016 ) no.11 , 116201 .
m. spira , fortsch .
* 46 * ( 1998 ) 203 .
j. r. ellis , m. k. gaillard and d. v. nanopoulos , nucl .
b * 106 * ( 1976 ) 292 .
l. resnick , m. k. sundaresan and p. j. s. watson , phys .
d * 8 * ( 1973 ) 172 .
e. braaten and j. p. leveille , phys .
d * 22 * ( 1980 ) 715 ; n. sakai , phys .
d * 22 * ( 1980 ) 2220 ; t. inami and t. kubota , nucl .
b * 179 * ( 1981 ) 171 ; m. drees and k. i. hikasa , phys .
b * 240 * ( 1990 ) 455 erratum : [ phys .
b * 262 * ( 1991 ) 497 ] and phys .
d * 41 * ( 1990 ) 1547 .
s. g. gorishnii , a. l. kataev and s. a. larin , sov .
j. nucl .
* 40 * ( 1984 ) 329 [ yad .
* 40 * ( 1984 ) 517 ] ; s. g. gorishnii , a. l. kataev , s. a. larin and l. r. surguladze , mod .
a * 5 * ( 1990 ) 2703 and phys . rev .
d * 43 * ( 1991 ) 1633 ; a. l. kataev and v. t. kim , mod .
lett . a * 9 * ( 1994 ) 1309 ; l. r. surguladze , phys .
b * 341 * ( 1994 ) 60 ; k. g. chetyrkin , phys .
b * 390 * ( 1997 ) 309 ; k. melnikov , phys .
d * 53 * ( 1996 ) 5020
. k. g. chetyrkin and a. kwiatkowski , nucl .
b * 461 * ( 1996 ) 3 ; s. a. larin , t. van ritbergen and j. a. m. vermaseren , phys .
b * 362 * ( 1995 ) 134 .
j. fleischer and f. jegerlehner , phys .
d * 23 * ( 1981 ) 2001 .
d. y. bardin , b. m. vilensky and p. k. khristova , sov .
j. nucl .
* 53 * ( 1991 )
152 [ yad . fiz .
* 53 * ( 1991 ) 240 ] ; a. dabelstein and w. hollik , z. phys .
c * 53 * ( 1992 ) 507 ; b. a. kniehl , nucl .
b * 376 * ( 1992 ) 3 .
a. djouadi , d. haidt , b. a. kniehl , p. m. zerwas and b. mele , in * munich / annecy / hamburg 1991 , proceedings , @xmath272 collisions at 500 gev , pt .
a * 11 - 30 .
b. a. kniehl and m. spira , nucl .
b * 432 * ( 1994 ) 39 ; a. kwiatkowski and m. steinhauser , phys .
b * 338 * ( 1994 ) 66 erratum : [ phys . lett .
b * 342 * ( 1995 ) 455 ] .
k. g. chetyrkin , b. a. kniehl and m. steinhauser , phys .
* 78 * ( 1997 ) 594 .
l. mihaila , b. schmidt and m. steinhauser , phys .
b * 751 * ( 2015 ) 442 .
d. de florian _ et al .
_ [ lhc higgs cross section working group collaboration ] , arxiv:1610.07922 [ hep - ph ] . c. s. li and r. j. oakes , phys .
d * 43 * ( 1991 ) 855 ; a. mendez and a. pomarol , phys .
b * 252 * ( 1990 ) 461 .
a. djouadi and p. gambino , phys .
d * 51 * ( 1995 ) 218 erratum : [ phys .
d * 53 * ( 1996 ) 4111 ] .
a. djouadi , j. kalinowski and m. spira , comput .
commun .
* 108 * ( 1998 ) 56 ; a. djouadi , m. m. mhlleitner and m. spira , acta phys .
b * 38 * ( 2007 ) 635 .
a. dabelstein , nucl .
b * 456 * ( 1995 ) 25 ; r. a. jimenez and j. sola , phys .
b * 389 * ( 1996 ) 53 ; j. a. coarasa perez , r. a. jimenez and j. sola , phys .
b * 389 * ( 1996 ) 312 .
a. djouadi , j. kalinowski and p. m. zerwas , z. phys .
c * 70 * ( 1996 ) 435 ; s. moretti and w. j. stirling , phys .
b * 347 * ( 1995 ) 291 erratum : [ phys .
b * 366 * ( 1996 ) 451 ] .
b. a. kniehl , nucl .
b * 352 * ( 1991 ) 1 ; d. y. bardin , p. k. khristova and b. m. vilensky , sov .
j. nucl .
* 54 * ( 1991 )
833 [ yad . fiz .
* 54 * ( 1991 ) 1366 ] .
b. a. kniehl and m. spira , z. phys .
c * 69 * ( 1995 ) 77 .
b. a. kniehl and m. spira , nucl .
b * 443 * ( 1995 ) 37 .
b. a. kniehl and m. steinhauser , phys .
b * 365 * ( 1996 ) 297 and nucl .
b * 454 * ( 1995 ) 485 .
t. g. rizzo , phys .
d * 22 * ( 1980 ) 722 ; w. y. keung and w. j. marciano , phys . rev .
d * 30 * ( 1984 ) 248 .
r. n. cahn , rept .
* 52 * ( 1989 ) 389 .
a. bredenstein , a. denner , s. dittmaier and m. m. weber , phys .
d * 74 * ( 2006 ) 013004 and jhep * 0702 * ( 2007 ) 080 .
s. boselli , c. m. carloni calame , g. montagna , o. nicrosini and f. piccinini , jhep * 1506 * ( 2015 ) 023 .
a. denner , s. heinemeyer , i. puljak , d. rebuzzi and m. spira , eur .
j. c * 71 * ( 2011 ) 1753 .
s. heinemeyer _ et al . _ [ lhc higgs cross section working group collaboration ] , arxiv:1307.1347 [ hep - ph ] . w. hollik and j. h. zhang , arxiv:1011.6537 [ hep - ph ] and phys .
d * 84 * ( 2011 ) 055022 .
m. spira , a. djouadi , d. graudenz and p. m. zerwas , nucl .
b * 453 * ( 1995 ) 17 .
t. inami , t. kubota and y. okada , z. phys .
c * 18 * ( 1983 ) 69 .
a. djouadi , m. spira and p. m. zerwas , phys .
b * 264 * ( 1991 ) 440 .
k. g. chetyrkin , b. a. kniehl and m. steinhauser , phys .
* 79 * ( 1997 ) 353 .
p. a. baikov and k. g. chetyrkin , phys .
* 97 * ( 2006 ) 061803 . m. a. shifman , a. i. vainshtein , m. b. voloshin and v. i. zakharov , sov . j. nucl
. phys . * 30 * ( 1979 ) 711 [ yad
. fiz . * 30 * ( 1979 ) 1368 ] .
m. spira , jhep * 1610 * ( 2016 ) 026 .
k. g. chetyrkin , b. a. kniehl and m. steinhauser , nucl .
b * 510 * ( 1998 ) 61 .
w. bernreuther and w. wetzel , nucl .
b * 197 * ( 1982 ) 228 erratum : [ nucl .
b * 513 * ( 1998 ) 758 ] ; s. a. larin , t. van ritbergen and j. a. m. vermaseren , nucl .
b * 438 * ( 1995 ) 278 ; y. schrder and m. steinhauser , jhep * 0601 * ( 2006 ) 051 ; k. g. chetyrkin , j. h. khn and c. sturm , nucl .
b * 744 * ( 2006 ) 121 .
b. a. kniehl and a. v. kotikov , phys .
b * 642 * ( 2006 ) 68 ; r. n. lee and i. s. terekhov , jhep * 1101 * ( 2011 ) 068 ; b. a. kniehl , a. v. kotikov , a. i. onishchenko and o. l. veretin , phys .
* 97 * ( 2006 ) 042001 ; k. chetyrkin , p. baikov and j. khn , pos ll * 2016 * ( 2016 ) 010 .
a. djouadi and p. gambino , phys .
* 73 * ( 1994 ) 2528 ; k. g. chetyrkin , b. a. kniehl and m. steinhauser , nucl .
b * 490 * ( 1997 ) 19 .
u. aglietti , r. bonciani , g. degrassi and a. vicini , phys .
b * 595 * ( 2004 ) 432 and hep - ph/0610033 ; g. degrassi and f. maltoni , phys .
b * 600 * ( 2004 ) 255 .
s. actis , g. passarino , c. sturm and s. uccirati , phys .
b * 670 * ( 2008 ) 12 ; s. actis , g. passarino , c. sturm and s. uccirati , nucl .
b * 811 * ( 2009 ) 182 .
s. dawson , a. djouadi and m. spira , phys .
* 77 * ( 1996 ) 16 .
j. f. gunion , h. e. haber , g. l. kane and s. dawson , front .
* 80 * ( 2000 ) 1 . m. mhlleitner and m. spira , nucl .
b * 790 * ( 2008 ) 1 ; r. bonciani , g. degrassi and a. vicini , jhep * 0711 * ( 2007 ) 095 . s. gori and i. low , jhep * 1309 * ( 2013 ) 151 . m. mhlleitner , h. rzehak and m. spira , jhep * 0904 * ( 2009 ) 023 . h. e. haber and g. l. kane , phys .
* 117 * ( 1985 ) 75 .
g. t hooft and m. j. g. veltman , nucl .
b * 44 * ( 1972 ) 189 ; p. breitenlohner and d. maison , commun .
* 52 * ( 1977 ) 11 .
s. a. larin , phys .
b * 303 * ( 1993 ) 113 .
m. spira , a. djouadi , d. graudenz and p. m. zerwas , phys .
b * 318 * ( 1993 ) 347 .
j. g. krner , d. kreimer and k. schilcher , z. phys .
c * 54 * ( 1992 ) 503 ; d. kreimer , hep - ph/9401354 . k. melnikov , m. spira and o. i. yakovlev , z. phys .
c * 64 * ( 1994 ) 401 .
k. g. chetyrkin , b. a. kniehl , m. steinhauser and w. a. bardeen , nucl .
b * 535 * ( 1998 ) 3 .
s. l. adler , phys .
* 177 * ( 1969 ) 2426 ; j. s. bell and r. jackiw , nuovo cim .
a * 60 * ( 1969 ) 47 .
d. g. sutherland , nucl .
b * 2 * ( 1967 ) 433 ; m. j. g. veltman , proc .
a * 301 * ( 1967 ) 107 .
s. l. adler and w. a. bardeen , phys .
* 182 * ( 1969 ) 1517 .
j. brod , f. fugel and b. a. kniehl , phys .
d * 78 * ( 2008 ) 011303 and nucl .
b * 807 * ( 2009 ) 188 .
v. v. sudakov , sov .
jetp * 3 * ( 1956 ) 65 [ zh .
fiz . * 30 * ( 1956 ) 87 ] . m. i. kotsky and o. i. yakovlev , phys .
b * 418 * ( 1998 ) 335 ; r. akhoury , h. wang and o. i. yakovlev , phys .
d * 64 * ( 2001 ) 113008 .
r. v. harlander and m. steinhauser , phys .
b * 574 * ( 2003 ) 258 and jhep * 0409 * ( 2004 ) 066 ; g. degrassi and p. slavich , nucl .
b * 805 * ( 2008 ) 267 ; g. degrassi , s. di vita and p. slavich , eur .
j. c * 72 * ( 2012 ) 2032 .
r. v. harlander and f. hofmann , jhep * 0603 * ( 2006 ) 050 ; r. v. harlander , f. hofmann and h. mantler , jhep * 1102 * ( 2011 ) 055 ; g. degrassi , s. di vita and p. slavich , jhep * 1108 * ( 2011 ) 128 . g. degrassi and p. slavich , jhep * 1011 * ( 2010 ) 044 . c. anastasiou , s. beerli and a. daleo , phys .
* 100 * ( 2008 ) 241806 .
m. mhlleitner , h. rzehak and m. spira , pos radcor * 2009 * ( 2010 ) 043 and desy - proc-2010 - 01 .
m. carena , s. heinemeyer , c. e. m. wagner and g. weiglein , eur .
j. c * 26 * ( 2003 ) 601 .
zheng and d.d .
wu , phys .
d * 42 * ( 1990 ) 3760 ; a. djouadi , m. spira , j. j. van der bij and p. m. zerwas , phys .
b * 257 * ( 1991 ) 187 ; s. dawson and r. p. kauffman , phys .
d * 47 * ( 1993 ) 1264 ; a. djouadi , m. spira and p. m. zerwas , phys .
b * 311 * ( 1993 ) 255 ; k. melnikov and o. i. yakovlev , phys .
b * 312 * ( 1993 ) 179 ; m. inoue , r. najima , t. oka and j. saito , mod .
lett . a * 9 * ( 1994 ) 1189 ; j. fleischer , o. v. tarasov and v. o. tarasov , phys .
b * 584 * ( 2004 ) 294 .
r. harlander and p. kant , jhep * 0512 * ( 2005 ) 015 ; c. anastasiou , s. beerli , s. bucherer , a. daleo and z. kunszt , jhep * 0701 * ( 2007 ) 082 ; u. aglietti , r. bonciani , g. degrassi and a. vicini , jhep * 0701 * ( 2007 ) 021 . m. steinhauser , in * tegernsee 1996 , the higgs puzzle * 177 - 185 [ hep - ph/9612395 ] . c. sturm , eur .
j. c * 74 * ( 2014 ) 8 , 2978 .
p. maierhfer and p. marquard , phys .
b * 721 * ( 2013 ) 131 .
a. djouadi , p. gambino and b. a. kniehl , nucl .
b * 523 * ( 1998 ) 17 ; g. degrassi and f. maltoni , nucl .
b * 724 * ( 2005 ) 183 ; g. passarino , c. sturm and s. uccirati , phys .
b * 655 * ( 2007 ) 298 ; s. actis , g. passarino , c. sturm and s. uccirati , nucl .
b * 811 * ( 2009 ) 182 .
a. djouadi , v. driesen , w. hollik and j. i. illana , eur .
j. c * 1 * ( 1998 ) 149 .
r. n. cahn , m. s. chanowitz and n. fleishon , phys .
lett . * 82b * ( 1979 ) 113 ; l. bergstrm and g. hulth , nucl .
b * 259 * ( 1985 ) 137 erratum : [ nucl .
b * 276 * ( 1986 ) 744 ] .
m. spira , a. djouadi and p. m. zerwas , phys .
b * 276 * ( 1992 ) 350 .
r. bonciani , v. del duca , h. frellesvig , j. m. henn , f. moriello and v. a. smirnov , jhep * 1508 * ( 2015 ) 108 ; t. gehrmann , s. guns and d. kara , jhep * 1509 * ( 2015 ) 038 .
a. abbasabadi , d. bowser - chao , d. a. dicus and w. w. repko , phys .
d * 55 * ( 1997 ) 5647 ; a. abbasabadi and w. w. repko , jhep * 0608 * ( 2006 ) 048 and phys .
d * 71 * ( 2005 ) 017304 ; d. a. dicus and w. w. repko , phys .
d * 87 * ( 2013 ) no.7 , 077301 ; l. b. chen , c. f. qiao and r. l. zhu , phys .
b * 726 * ( 2013 ) 306 ; g. passarino , phys .
b * 727 * ( 2013 ) 424 .
y. sun , h. r. chang and d. n. gao , jhep * 1305 * ( 2013 ) 061 .
g. gamberini , g. f. giudice and g. ridolfi , nucl .
b * 292 * ( 1987 ) 237 .
a. brignole and f. zwirner , phys .
b * 299 * ( 1993 ) 72 ; s. heinemeyer and w. hollik , nucl .
b * 474 * ( 1996 ) 32 ; k. e. williams and g. weiglein , phys .
b * 660 * ( 2008 ) 217 ; k. e. williams , h. rzehak and g. weiglein , eur .
j. c * 71 * ( 2011 ) 1669 ; m. krause , m. mhlleitner , r. santos and h. ziesche , arxiv:1609.04185 [ hep - ph ] . s. heinemeyer , w. hollik and g. weiglein , comput . phys .
commun .
* 124 * ( 2000 ) 76 ; t. hahn , s. heinemeyer , w. hollik , h. rzehak and g. weiglein , comput .
commun .
* 180 * ( 2009 ) 1426 .
j. baglio , r. grber , m. mhlleitner , d. t. nhung , h. rzehak , m. spira , j. streicher and k. walz , comput .
commun .
* 185 * ( 2014 ) no.12 , 3372 .
a. g. akeroyd , a. arhrib and e. m. naimi , eur .
j. c * 12 * ( 2000 ) 451 erratum : [ eur .
j. c * 14 * ( 2000 ) 371 ] and eur .
j. c * 20 * ( 2001 ) 51 ; m. krause , r. lorenz , m. mhlleitner , r. santos and h. ziesche , jhep * 1609 * ( 2016 ) 143 .
a. djouadi , j. kalinowski , p. ohmann and p. m. zerwas , z. phys .
c * 74 * ( 1997 ) 93 .
a. bartl , h. eberl , k. hidaka , t. kon , w. majerotto and y. yamada , phys .
* b402 * ( 1997 ) 303 ; a. arhrib , a. djouadi , w. hollik and c. jnger , phys .
* d57 * ( 1998 ) 5860 .
e. accomando , g. chachamis , f. fugel , m. spira and m. walser , phys .
d * 85 * ( 2012 ) 015004 .
h. eberl , k. hidaka , s. kraml , w. majerotto and y. yamada , phys .
d62 * ( 2000 ) 055006 .
w. frisch , h. eberl and h. hlucha , comput .
phys . commun .
* 182 * ( 2011 ) 2219 . c. weber , k. kovarik , h. eberl and w. majerotto , nucl .
phys . * b776 * ( 2007 ) 138 .
a. djouadi , p. janot , j. kalinowski and p. m. zerwas , phys .
b * 376 * ( 1996 ) 220 .
r. y. zhang , w. g. ma , l. h. wan and y. jiang , phys .
d * 65 * ( 2002 ) 075018 ; h. eberl , w. majerotto and y. yamada , phys .
b * 597 * ( 2004 ) 275 ; t. ibrahim , phys .
d * 76 * ( 2007 ) 075012 and phys .
d * 77 * ( 2008 ) 065028 ; a. bharucha , a. fowler , g. moortgat - pick and g. weiglein , jhep * 1305 * ( 2013 ) 053 ; a. c. fowler and g. weiglein , jhep * 1001 * ( 2010 ) 108 ; s. heinemeyer and c. schappacher , eur .
j. c * 75 * ( 2015 ) no.5 , 230 .
e. gross , g. wolf and b. a. kniehl , z. phys .
c * 63 * ( 1994 ) 417 erratum : [ z. phys .
c * 66 * ( 1995 ) 321 ] ; a. djouadi , m. spira and p. m. zerwas , z. phys .
c * 70 * ( 1996 ) 427 .
l. g. almeida , s. j. lee , s. pokorski and j. d. wells , phys .
d * 89 * ( 2014 ) no.3 , 033006 ; g. p.
lepage , p. b. mackenzie and m. e. peskin , arxiv:1404.0319 [ hep - ph ] .
n. gray , d. j. broadhurst , w. grafe and k. schilcher , z. phys .
c * 48 * ( 1990 ) 673 ; k. g. chetyrkin and m. steinhauser , phys .
* 83 * ( 1999 ) 4001 ; k. g. chetyrkin and m. steinhauser , nucl .
b * 573 * ( 2000 ) 617 ; k. melnikov and t. v. ritbergen , phys .
b * 482 * ( 2000 ) 99 ; p. marquard , a. v. smirnov , v. a. smirnov and m. steinhauser , phys .
* 114 * ( 2015 ) no.14 , 142002 ; a. l. kataev and v. s. molokoedov , arxiv:1511.06898 [ hep - ph ] .
c. w. bauer , z. ligeti , m. luke , a. v. manohar and m. trott , phys .
d * 70 * ( 2004 ) 094017 .
k. a. olive _ et al . _
[ particle data group collaboration ] , chin .
c * 38 * ( 2014 ) 090001 .
m. carena , s. heinemeyer , o. stal , c. e. m. wagner and g. weiglein , eur .
j. c * 73 * ( 2013 ) no.9 , 2552 .
s. dawson , nucl .
b * 359 * ( 1991 ) 283 .
d. graudenz , m. spira and p. m. zerwas , phys .
* 70 * ( 1993 ) 1372 ; c. anastasiou , s. bucherer and z. kunszt , jhep * 0910 * ( 2009 ) 068
. m. spira , ph .
d. thesis , rwth aachen , 1992 .
j. butterworth _ et al .
_ , j. phys .
g * 43 * ( 2016 ) 023001 .
s. catani , d. de florian and m. grazzini , jhep * 0105 * ( 2001 ) 025 ; r. v. harlander and w. b. kilgore , phys .
d * 64 * ( 2001 ) 013015 and phys .
* 88 * ( 2002 ) 201801 ; c. anastasiou and k. melnikov , nucl . phys .
b * 646 * ( 2002 ) 220 ; v. ravindran , j. smith and w. l. van neerven , nucl .
b * 665 * ( 2003 ) 325 ; s. marzani , r. d. ball , v. del duca , s. forte and a. vicini , nucl .
b * 800 * ( 2008 ) 127 .
t. gehrmann , m. jaquier , e. w. n. glover and a. koukoutsakis , jhep * 1202 * ( 2012 ) 056 ; c. anastasiou , c. duhr , f. dulat and b. mistlberger , jhep * 1307 * ( 2013 ) 003 ; c. anastasiou , c. duhr , f. dulat , f. herzog and b. mistlberger , jhep * 1312 * ( 2013 ) 088 ; w. b. kilgore , phys .
d * 89 * ( 2014 ) 7 , 073008 ; y. li , a. von manteuffel , r. m. schabinger and h. x. zhu , phys .
d * 90 * ( 2014 ) 5 , 053006 ; c. anastasiou , c. duhr , f. dulat , e. furlan , t. gehrmann , f. herzog and b. mistlberger , jhep * 1503 * ( 2015 ) 091 ; c. anastasiou , c. duhr , f. dulat , f. herzog and b. mistlberger , phys . rev .
* 114 * ( 2015 ) 21 , 212001 . c. anastasiou , c. duhr , f. dulat , e. furlan , t. gehrmann , f. herzog , a. lazopoulos and b. mistlberger , jhep * 1605 * ( 2016 ) 058 . m. krmer , e. laenen and m. spira , nucl .
b * 511 * ( 1998 ) 523 ; s. catani , d. de florian , m. grazzini and p. nason , jhep * 0307 * ( 2003 ) 028 ; s. moch and a. vogt , phys .
b * 631 * ( 2005 ) 48 ; v. ravindran , nucl .
b * 746 * ( 2006 ) 58 and nucl .
b * 752 * ( 2006 ) 173 ; a. idilbi , x. d. ji , j. p. ma and f. yuan , phys .
d * 73 * ( 2006 ) 077501 ; v. ahrens , t. becher , m. neubert and l. l. yang , eur .
j. c * 62 * ( 2009 ) 333 ; d. de florian and m. grazzini , phys .
b * 674 * ( 2009 ) 291 .
d. de florian , j. mazzitelli , s. moch and a. vogt , jhep * 1410 * ( 2014 ) 176 ; m. bonvini and l. rottoli , phys .
d * 91 * ( 2015 ) 5 , 051301 .
s. catani , l. cieri , d. de florian , g. ferrera and m. grazzini , nucl .
b * 888 * ( 2014 ) 75 .
d. de florian and m. grazzini , phys .
b * 718 * ( 2012 ) 117 ; m. bonvini and s. marzani , jhep * 1409 * ( 2014 ) 007 ; t. schmidt and m. spira , phys . rev .
d * 93 * ( 2016 ) no.1 , 014022 ; m. bonvini , s. marzani , c. muselli and l. rottoli , jhep * 1608 * ( 2016 ) 105 . c. anastasiou , r. boughezal and f. petriello , jhep * 0904 * ( 2009 ) 003 .
r. v. harlander and k. j. ozeren , phys .
b * 679 * ( 2009 ) 467 and jhep * 0911 * ( 2009 ) 088 ; a. pak , m. rogal and m. steinhauser , phys .
b * 679 * ( 2009 ) 473 and jhep * 1002 * ( 2010 ) 025 .
m. spira , hep - ph/9510347 and nucl .
instrum .
a * 389 * ( 1997 ) 357 .
r. v. harlander , s. liebler and h. mantler , comput .
commun .
* 184 * ( 2013 ) 1605 and arxiv:1605.03190 [ hep - ph ] . c. anastasiou , s. buehler , f. herzog and a. lazopoulos , jhep * 1112 * ( 2011 ) 058 .
r. k. ellis , i. hinchliffe , m. soldate and j. j. van der bij , nucl .
b * 297 * ( 1988 ) 221 ; u. baur and e. w. n. glover , nucl .
b * 339 * ( 1990 ) 38 . c. r. schmidt , phys .
b * 413 * ( 1997 ) 391 ; d. de florian , m. grazzini and z. kunszt , phys .
* 82 * ( 1999 ) 5209 ; c. j. glosser and c. r. schmidt , jhep * 0212 * ( 2002 ) 016 ; v. ravindran , j. smith and w. l. van neerven , nucl .
b * 634 * ( 2002 ) 247 .
r. v. harlander , t. neumann , k. j. ozeren and m. wiesemann , jhep * 1208 * ( 2012 ) 139 ; t. neumann and m. wiesemann , jhep * 1411 * ( 2014 ) 150 . t. neumann and c. williams , arxiv:1609.00367 [ hep - ph ] .
r. boughezal , f. caola , k. melnikov , f. petriello and m. schulze , jhep * 1306 * ( 2013 ) 072 and phys .
* 115 * ( 2015 ) no.8 , 082003 ; x. chen , t. gehrmann , e. w. n. glover and m. jaquier , phys .
b * 740 * ( 2015 ) 147 ; x. chen , j. cruz - martinez , t. gehrmann , e. w. n. glover and m. jaquier , jhep * 1610 * ( 2016 ) 066 .
y. l. dokshitzer , d. diakonov and s. i. troian , phys .
* 58 * ( 1980 ) 269 ; g. parisi and r. petronzio , nucl .
b * 154 * ( 1979 ) 427 ; j. c. collins , d. e. soper and g. f. sterman , nucl .
b * 250 * ( 1985 ) 199 ; s. catani and m. grazzini , nucl .
b * 845 * ( 2011 ) 297 .
g. bozzi , s. catani , d. de florian and m. grazzini , nucl .
b * 737 * ( 2006 ) 73 ; h. mantler and m. wiesemann , eur .
j. c * 73 * ( 2013 ) no.6 , 2467 ; m. grazzini and h. sargsyan , jhep * 1309 * ( 2013 ) 129 ; r. v. harlander , h. mantler and m. wiesemann , jhep * 1411 * ( 2014 ) 116 ; f. caola , s. forte , s. marzani , c. muselli and g. vita , jhep * 1608 * ( 2016 ) 150 .
e. bagnaschi , r. v. harlander , h. mantler , a. vicini and m. wiesemann , jhep * 1601 * ( 2016 ) 090 .
s. frixione , p. nason and c. oleari , jhep * 0711 * ( 2007 ) 070 ; s. alioli , p. nason , c. oleari and e. re , jhep * 1006 * ( 2010 ) 043 .
e. bagnaschi , g. degrassi , p. slavich and a. vicini , jhep * 1202 * ( 2012 ) 088 .
j. alwall , m. herquet , f. maltoni , o. mattelaer and t. stelzer , jhep * 1106 * ( 2011 ) 128 ; j. alwall _ et al .
_ , jhep * 1407 * ( 2014 ) 079 . h. mantler and m. wiesemann , eur . phys .
j. c * 75 * ( 2015 ) no.6 , 257 .
d. a. dicus and s. willenbrock , phys .
d * 39 * ( 1989 ) 751 .
t. han , g. valencia and s. willenbrock , phys .
* 69 * ( 1992 ) 3274 .
t. figy , c. oleari and d. zeppenfeld , phys .
d * 68 * ( 2003 ) 073005 ; t. figy and d. zeppenfeld , phys .
b * 591 * ( 2004 ) 297 ; e. l. berger and j. m. campbell , phys .
d * 70 * ( 2004 ) 073011 .
v. n. gribov and l. n. lipatov , sov .
j. nucl .
phys . * 15 * ( 1972 ) 438 [ yad
. fiz . * 15 * ( 1972 ) 781 ] ; g. altarelli and g. parisi , nucl .
b * 126 * ( 1977 ) 298 ; y. l. dokshitzer , sov .
jetp * 46 * ( 1977 ) 641 [ zh .
* 73 * ( 1977 ) 1216 ] .
m. ciccolini , a. denner and s. dittmaier , phys .
* 99 * ( 2007 ) 161803 and phys .
d * 77 * ( 2008 ) 013002 .
a. denner , s. dittmaier , s. kallweit and a. mck , comput .
commun .
* 195 * ( 2015 ) 161 .
k. arnold _ et al .
_ , comput .
commun .
* 180 * ( 2009 ) 1661 , k. arnold _ et al .
_ , arxiv:1107.4038 [ hep - ph ] and arxiv:1207.4975 [ hep - ph ] ; j. baglio _ et al .
_ , arxiv:1404.3940 [ hep - ph ] .
p. bolzoni , f. maltoni , s. o. moch and m. zaro , phys .
* 105 * ( 2010 ) 011801 and phys .
d * 85 * ( 2012 ) 035002 .
m. cacciari , f. a. dreyer , a. karlberg , g. p. salam and g. zanderighi , phys .
* 115 * ( 2015 ) no.8 , 082002 .
r. v. harlander , j. vollinga and m. m. weber , phys .
d * 77 * , 053010 ( 2008 ) ; j. r. andersen , t. binoth , g. heinrich and j. m. smillie , jhep * 0802 * ( 2008 ) 057 ; a. bredenstein , k. hagiwara and b. jger , phys . rev .
d * 77 * ( 2008 ) 073004 .
f. a. dreyer and a. karlberg , phys .
* 117 * ( 2016 ) no.7 , 072001 .
a. djouadi and m. spira , phys .
d * 62 * ( 2000 ) 014004 .
w. hollik , t. plehn , m. rauch and h. rzehak , phys .
* 102 * ( 2009 ) 091802 ; t. figy , s. palmer and g. weiglein , jhep * 1202 * ( 2012 ) 105
. m. h. seymour , z. phys .
c * 62 * ( 1994 ) 127 .
t. han and s. willenbrock , phys .
b * 273 * ( 1991 ) 167 .
o. brein , a. djouadi and r. harlander , phys .
b * 579 * ( 2004 ) 149 .
l. altenkamp , s. dittmaier , r. v. harlander , h. rzehak and t. j. e. zirke , jhep * 1302 * ( 2013 ) 078 ; a. hasselhuhn , t. luthe and m. steinhauser , arxiv:1611.05881 [ hep - ph ] . m. l. ciccolini , s. dittmaier and m. krmer , phys .
d * 68 * ( 2003 ) 073003 ; a. denner , s. dittmaier , s. kallweit and a. mck , jhep * 1203 * ( 2012 ) 075 .
g. ferrera , m. grazzini and f. tramontano , jhep * 1404 * ( 2014 ) 039 and phys .
b * 740 * ( 2015 ) 51 .
j. m. campbell , r. k. ellis and c. williams , jhep * 1606 * ( 2016 ) 179 .
o. brein , r. v. harlander and t. j. e. zirke , comput .
commun .
* 184 * ( 2013 ) 998 ; r. v. harlander , s. liebler and t. zirke , jhep * 1402 * ( 2014 ) 023 .
w. astill , w. bizon , e. re and g. zanderighi , jhep * 1606 * ( 2016 ) 154 .
w. beenakker et al . , phys .
* 87 * ( 2001 ) 201805 .
w. beenakker et al . , nucl .
* b653 * ( 2003 ) 151203 ; l. reina and s. dawson , phys . rev .
* 87 * ( 2001 ) 201804 ; s. dawson , l. h. orr , l. reina , and d. wackeroth , phys .
* d67 * ( 2003 ) 071503 .
r. frederix , s. frixione , v. hirschi , f. maltoni , r. pittau and p. torrielli , phys .
b * 701 * ( 2011 ) 427 .
s. dawson and l. reina , phys .
d * 57 * , 5851 ( 1998 ) ; e. braaten and h. zhang , phys .
d * 93 * ( 2016 ) no.5 , 053014 .
m. v. garzelli , a. kardos , c. g. papadopoulos and z. trocsanyi , europhys .
* 96 * ( 2011 ) 11001 ; h. b. hartanto , b. jger , l. reina and d. wackeroth , phys . rev .
d * 91 * ( 2015 ) no.9 , 094003 .
f. cascioli , s. hche , f. krauss , p. maierhfer , s. pozzorini and f. siegert , jhep * 1401 * ( 2014 ) 046 .
a. kulesza , l. motyka , t. stebel and v. theeuwes , jhep * 1603 * ( 2016 ) 065 .
a. broggio , a. ferroglia , b. d. pecjak , a. signer and l. l. yang , jhep * 1603 * ( 2016 ) 124 ; a. broggio , a. ferroglia , b. d. pecjak and l. l. yang , arxiv:1611.00049 [ hep - ph ] . y. zhang , w. g. ma , r. y. zhang , c. chen and l. guo , phys .
b * 738 * ( 2014 ) 1 ; s. frixione , v. hirschi , d. pagani , h. s. shao and m. zaro , jhep * 1409 * ( 2014 ) 065 and jhep * 1506 * ( 2015 ) 184 .
a. denner and r. feger , jhep * 1511 * ( 2015 ) 209 .
s. dittmaier , m. krmer and m. spira , phys .
d * 70 * ( 2004 ) 074010 ; s. dawson , c. b. jackson , l. reina and d. wackeroth , phys .
d * 69 * ( 2004 ) 074027 ; m. wiesemann , r. frederix , s. frixione , v. hirschi , f. maltoni and p. torrielli , jhep * 1502 * ( 2015 ) 132 .
d. l. rainwater , m. spira and d. zeppenfeld , hep - ph/0203187 ; m. spira , hep - ph/0211145 ; f. maltoni , z. sullivan and s. willenbrock , phys .
d * 67 * ( 2003 ) 093005 ; e. boos and t. plehn , phys . rev .
d * 69 * ( 2004 ) 094005 ; j. m. campbell _ et al .
_ , hep - ph/0405302 .
d. dicus , t. stelzer , z. sullivan and s. willenbrock , phys .
d * 59 * ( 1999 ) 094016 ; c. balazs , h. j. he and c. p. yuan , phys . rev .
d * 60 * ( 1999 ) 114001 .
r. v. harlander and w. b. kilgore , phys .
d * 68 * ( 2003 ) 013001 .
f. maltoni , g. ridolfi and m. ubiali , jhep * 1207 * ( 2012 ) 022 erratum : [ jhep * 1304 * ( 2013 ) 095 ] ; m. lim , f. maltoni , g. ridolfi and m. ubiali , jhep * 1609 * ( 2016 ) 132 .
r. harlander , m. krmer and m. schumacher , arxiv:1112.3478 [ hep - ph ] .
s. forte , d. napoletano and m. ubiali , phys . lett .
b * 751 * ( 2015 ) 331 and phys .
b * 763 * ( 2016 ) 190 m. bonvini , a. s. papanastasiou and f. j. tackmann , jhep * 1511 * ( 2015 ) 196 and jhep * 1610 * ( 2016 ) 053 .
f. demartin , f. maltoni , k. mawatari and m. zaro , eur .
j. c * 75 * ( 2015 ) no.6 , 267 .
s. dittmaier , p. hfliger , m. krmer , m. spira and m. walser , phys .
d * 90 * ( 2014 ) no.3 , 035010 .
wu , w. g. ma , h. s. hou , r. y. zhang , l. han and y. jiang , phys .
b * 618 * ( 2005 ) 209 .
s. dawson , c. b. jackson and p. jaiswal , phys .
d * 83 * ( 2011 ) 115007 .
s. dittmaier , m. krmer , a. mck and t. schlter , jhep * 0703 * ( 2007 ) 114 .
p. nason , s. dawson and r. k. ellis , nucl .
b * 303 * ( 1988 ) 607 and nucl .
b * 327 * ( 1989 ) 49 erratum : [ nucl .
b * 335 * ( 1990 ) 260 ] ; w. beenakker , h. kuijf , w. l. van neerven and j. smith , phys .
d * 40 * ( 1989 ) 54 ; w. beenakker , w. l. van neerven , r. meng , g. a. schuler and j. smith , nucl .
b * 351 * ( 1991 ) 507 ; m. czakon , a. mitov and s. moch , nucl .
b * 798 * ( 2008 ) 210 ; p. brnreuther , m. czakon and a. mitov , phys .
* 109 * ( 2012 ) 132001 ; m. czakon and a. mitov , jhep * 1212 * ( 2012 ) 054 and jhep * 1301 * ( 2013 ) 080 ; m. czakon , p. fiedler and a. mitov , phys . rev
. lett .
* 110 * ( 2013 ) 252004 ; m. czakon , p. fiedler , d. heymes and a. mitov , jhep * 1605 * ( 2016 ) 034 .
w. beenakker , a. denner , w. hollik , r. mertig , t. sack and d. wackeroth , nucl .
b * 411 * ( 1994 ) 343 .
m. jezabek and j. h. khn , nucl .
b * 314 * ( 1989 ) 1 ; c. s. li , r. j. oakes and t. c. yuan , phys .
d * 43 * ( 1991 ) 3759 ; a. czarnecki and s. davidson , phys .
d * 48 * ( 1993 ) 4183 ; j. m. campbell , r. k. ellis and f. tramontano , phys . rev .
d * 70 * ( 2004 ) 094012 ; a. czarnecki and k. melnikov , nucl .
b * 544 * ( 1999 ) 520 ; k. g. chetyrkin , r. harlander , t. seidensticker and m. steinhauser , phys . rev .
d * 60 * ( 1999 ) 114015 ; i. r. blokland , a. czarnecki , m. slusarczyk and f. tkachov , phys . rev .
* 93 * ( 2004 ) 062001 ; i. r. blokland , a. czarnecki , m. slusarczyk and f. tkachov , phys . rev .
d * 71 * ( 2005 ) 054004 erratum : [ phys .
d * 79 * ( 2009 ) 019901 ] ; a. czarnecki , j. g. krner and j. h. piclum , phys .
d * 81 * ( 2010 ) 111503 ; j. gao , c. s. li and h. x. zhu , phys .
* 110 * ( 2013 ) no.4 , 042001 ; m. brucherseifer , f. caola and k. melnikov , jhep * 1304 * ( 2013 ) 059 .
a. denner and t. sack , nucl .
b * 358 * ( 1991 ) 46 ; g. eilam , r. r. mendel , r. migneron and a. soni , phys .
* 66 * ( 1991 ) 3105 ; t. kuruma , z. phys .
c * 57 * ( 1993 ) 551 .
w. peng , m. wen - gan , z. ren - you , j. yi , h. liang and g. lei , phys .
d * 73 * ( 2006 ) 015012 erratum : [ phys .
d * 80 * ( 2009 ) 059901 ] ; s. dittmaier , m. krmer , m. spira and m. walser , phys .
d * 83 * ( 2011 ) 055005 .
g. p. gao , g. r. lu , z. h. xiong and j. m. yang , phys .
d * 66 * ( 2002 ) 015007 ; s. h. zhu , phys .
d * 67 * ( 2003 ) 075006 ; t. plehn , phys .
d * 67 * ( 2003 ) 014018 ; e. l. berger , t. han , j. jiang and t. plehn , phys .
d * 71 * ( 2005 ) 115012 ; n. kidonakis , pos hep * 2005 * ( 2006 ) 336 .
m. flechl , r. klees , m. krmer , m. spira and m. ubiali , phys .
d * 91 * ( 2015 ) no.7 , 075015 . c. degrande , r. frederix , v. hirschi , m. ubiali , m. wiesemann and m. zaro , arxiv:1607.05291 [ hep - ph ] . k. d. lane , econf c * 8206282 * ( 1982 ) 222 ; e. eichten , i. hinchliffe , k. d. lane and c. quigg , rev .
* 56 * ( 1984 ) 579 addendum : [ rev .
* 58 * ( 1986 ) 1065 ] ; n. g. deshpande , x. tata and d. a. dicus , phys .
d * 29 * ( 1984 ) 1527 .
r. foot , h. lew and g. c. joshi , phys .
d * 37 * ( 1988 ) 3161 ; s. willenbrock , phys .
* d35 * ( 1987 ) 173 ; a. krause , t. plehn , m. spira and p.m. zerwas , nucl .
* b519 * ( 1998 ) 85 ; y. jiang , l. han , w.g .
ma , z.h .
yu and m. han , j. phys . * g23 * ( 1997 ) 385 [ erratum - ibid .
* g23 * ( 1997 ) 1151 ] ; y. jiang , w. g. ma , l. han , m. han and z. h. yu , j. phys .
g * 24 * ( 1998 ) 83 ; o. brein and w. hollik , eur .
j. * c13 * ( 2000 ) 175 .
barrientos bendezu and b.a .
kniehl , nucl .
* b568 * ( 2000 ) 305 . h. hong - sheng , m. wen - gan , z. ren - you , j. yi , h. liang and x. li - rong , phys .
* d71 * ( 2005 ) 075014 ; a. alves and t. plehn , phys .
d * 71 * ( 2005 ) 115014 .
barrientos bendezu and b.a .
kniehl , phys .
* d59 * ( 1999 ) 015009 ; o. brein , w. hollik and s. kanemura , phys .
* d63 * ( 2001 ) 095001 .
barrientos bendezu and b.a .
kniehl , phys .
d * 63 * ( 2001 ) 015009 .
dicus , j.l .
hewett , c. kao and t.g .
rizzo , phys .
d * 40 * ( 1989 ) 787 .
w. hollik and s.h .
zhu , phys .
* d65 * ( 2002 ) 075015 ; j. zhao , c.s .
li and q. li , phys .
* d72 * ( 2005 ) 114008 .
s. moretti , j. phys .
g * 28 * ( 2002 ) 2567 .
e. bagnaschi , r. v. harlander , s. liebler , h. mantler , p. slavich and a. vicini , jhep * 1406 * ( 2014 ) 167 .
g. degrassi , p. p. giardino , f. maltoni and d. pagani , arxiv:1607.04251 [ hep - ph ] .
j. baglio , a. djouadi , r. grber , m. m. mhlleitner , j. quevillon and m. spira , jhep * 1304 * ( 2013 ) 151 .
j. baglio , a. djouadi and j. quevillon , rept .
* 79 * ( 2016 ) no.11 , 116201 .
e. w. n. glover and j. j. van der bij , nucl .
b * 309 * ( 1988 ) 282 ; t. plehn , m. spira and p. m. zerwas , nucl .
b * 479 * ( 1996 ) 46 erratum : [ nucl .
b * 531 * ( 1998 ) 655 ] .
s. dawson , s. dittmaier and m. spira , phys .
d * 58 * ( 1998 ) 115012 .
j. grigo , j. hoff , k. melnikov and m. steinhauser , nucl .
b * 875 * ( 2013 ) 1 .
r. frederix , s. frixione , v. hirschi , f. maltoni , o. mattelaer , p. torrielli , e. vryonidou and m. zaro , phys .
b * 732 * ( 2014 ) 142 ; f. maltoni , e. vryonidou and m. zaro , jhep * 1411 * ( 2014 ) 079
. g. degrassi , p. p. giardino and r. grber , eur .
j. c * 76 * ( 2016 ) no.7 , 411 ; s. borowka , n. greiner , g. heinrich , s. p. jones , m. kerner , j. schlenk , u. schubert and t. zirke , phys . rev .
* 117 * ( 2016 ) no.1 , 012001 erratum : [ phys .
* 117 * ( 2016 ) no.7 , 079901 ] ; s. borowka , n. greiner , g. heinrich , s. p. jones , m. kerner , j. schlenk and t. zirke , jhep * 1610 * ( 2016 ) 107 .
d. de florian and j. mazzitelli , phys .
b * 724 * ( 2013 ) 306 and phys .
* 111 * ( 2013 ) 201801 ; j. grigo , k. melnikov and m. steinhauser , nucl .
b * 888 * ( 2014 ) 17 .
j. grigo , j. hoff and m. steinhauser , nucl .
b * 900 * ( 2015 ) 412 .
d. y. shao , c. s. li , h. t. li and j. wang , jhep * 1307 * ( 2013 ) 169 ; d. de florian and j. mazzitelli , jhep * 1509 * ( 2015 ) 053 .
d. de florian , m. grazzini , c. hanga , s. kallweit , j. m. lindert , p. maierhfer , j. mazzitelli and d. rathlev , jhep * 1609 * ( 2016 ) 151
. l. s. ling , r. y. zhang , w. g. ma , l. guo , w. h. li and x. z. li , phys .
d * 89 * ( 2014 ) no.7 , 073001 .
h. t. li and j. wang , arxiv:1607.06382 [ hep - ph ] .
m. moretti , s. moretti , f. piccinini , r. pittau and a. d. polosa , jhep * 0502 * ( 2005 ) 024 . | higgs physics at hadron colliders as the lhc is reviewed within the standard model ( sm ) and its minimal supersymmetric extension ( mssm ) by summarizing the present state - of - the - art of theoretical predictions for the production cross sections and decay rates . |
dilute polymer solutions exhibit physical behaviours that distinguish them from ordinary newtonian fluids .
even a small polymer concentration can considerably change the large - scale behaviour of the flow by enhancing viscosity and reducing the turbulent drag .
a comprehensive understanding of hydrodynamical properties of polymer solutions is still lacking despite the large number of industrial applications ( e.g. sreenivasan and white 2000 ) . a starting point for the theoretical description of dilute polymer solutions is the dynamics of isolated polymer molecules .
the knowledge of how a single molecule is deformed by the velocity gradient allows the development of constitutive models that in turn can be used to calculate the large scale flow .
the stationary dynamics of a single , isolated polymer has received much attention to date ( see larson 2005 , shaqfeh 2005 , for a review ) . on the contrary , less is known about non - equilibrium dynamics of isolated polymers in flow . since rouse ( 1953 ) and zimm s ( 1956 ) seminal works , experimental , numerical , and theoretical studies focused on the internal relaxation dynamics of a polymer floating in a solvent under the influence of brownian fluctuations .
the two model situations considered were : ( a ) a polymer suspended in solution and pulled at the ends ( quake _ et al .
_ 1997 , hatfield and quake 1999 ) ; ( b ) a tethered polymer submitted to a uniform flow and freely relaxing after cessation of the flow ( perkins _ et al .
_ 1994 , brochard - wyart 1995 , manneville _
_ 1996 , rzehak and zimmermann 2002 ) .
the above studies did not take into account the interaction between the polymer and an external flow .
hernndez cifre and garca de la torre ( 1999 ) note that rouse and zimm s theories may not provide the adequate time scale for coil
stretch processes in flow on the basis of brownian dynamics simulations . here
, we investigate how an elongational flow influences polymer relaxation dynamics .
we determine the time scale associated with polymer deformation _ in the flow _ and show a significant deviation from rouse and zimm s predictions in the vicinity of the coil
stretch transition .
our analysis is based on an eigenvalue problem for the confluent heun equation , and constitutes a new physical application of this latter equation .
polymer dynamics is extremely rich already in simple deterministic flows , such as elongational flows ( perkins _ et al .
_ 1997 , smith and chu 1998 ) , shear flows ( smith _ et al .
_ 1999 , celani _ et al .
_ 2005b , puliafito and turitsyn 2005 , gerashchenko and steinberg 2006 ) or combinations of the two ( hur _ et al .
_ 2002 , babcock _ et al .
the velocity gradient of a non - uniform flow stretches the polymer , while entropic forces attempt to restore the polymer into the coiled equilibrium shape . in other words ,
the configuration of the polymer results from the counterbalance between the entropic forces and the hydrodynamic drag .
here we consider an elongational flow , which is defined by a constant velocity gradient @xmath0 .
this flow is particularly effective in stretching polymers far from their equilibrium configuration .
a transition to the stretched state of the polymer occurs as the velocity gradient exceeds the critical value @xmath1 , where @xmath2 is the time associated with the slowest relaxation mode of the polymer in thermal equilibrium with the surrounding medium . for @xmath3 polymers
stay in the coiled equilibrium configuration ; for @xmath4 they become fully extended .
this phenomenon is known as the coil
stretch transition ( de gennes 1974 ) . rouse ( 1953 ) computed @xmath2 as a function of the number of monomers in the polymer assuming the polymer could be described as a beads - and - springs chain with hookean interactions .
zimm ( 1956 ) refined rouse s prediction by taking into account hydrodynamic interactions between segments of the chain .
the study of polymer dynamics has benefited from a class of mesoscopic models that are based on a coarse - grained treatment of the polymer molecule .
one of the simplest is the elastic dumbbell model , which only takes into account the slowest oscillation mode of the molecule ( bird _ et al .
_ 1987 ) . notwithstanding this crude simplification
, the dumbbell model captures the main aspects of polymer dynamics in elongational flows , such as the coil
stretch transition ( perkins _ et al .
_ 1997 ) and finite - time conformation hysteresis ( schroeder _ et al .
_ 2003 , schroeder _
we examine how the probability density function ( pdf ) of the extension of a dumbbell - like molecule approaches its stationary form .
we compute the typical time it takes for the initial pdf to attain its steady - state form and show that , in the proximity of the coil
stretch transition , this time is exceedingly long compared to @xmath2 .
a similar behaviour is encountered in white - in - time isotropic random flows ( celani _ et al .
_ 2005a , martins afonso and vincenzi 2005 ) ; however , for an elongational flow the amplification of the transient relaxation time is much stronger .
the problem is solved within the framework of the fokker
planck equation for the pdf of the extension of the polymer .
the computation of the transient relaxation time is recast as a central two - point connection problem ( ctcp ) for a singly confluent heun equation .
the heun equation is the general fuchsian differential equation with four regular singularities .
its singly confluent form , also known as the generalised spheroidal wave equation , results from the merging of two regular singularities into one irregular singularity of poincar rank @xmath5 ( see slavyanov 1995 , for a review ) .
a ctcp is an eigenvalue problem for an ordinary differential equation where : ( a ) at both endpoints of the interval of definition is located a singularity of the equation ; ( b ) the solutions are required to have a specified asymptotic behaviour while approaching the two singularities from inside .
contrary to the hypergeometric equation , an explicit formula for the ctcp is not known for the heun family of equations .
the eigenvalues can be determined only as solutions of transcendental equations involving continued fractions .
well - known applications of the confluent heun equation are the electronic spectra of the hydrogen - molecule ion in the born - oppenheimer approximation ( jaff 1934 ) and the teukolsky equation describing small perturbations to the kerr geometry in black hole theory ( leaver 1985 ) . for a comprehensive introduction to physical applications of the heun equations we refer the reader to the book by slavyanov and lay ( 2000 ) .
the rest of this paper is organised as follows .
the dumbbell model is introduced in section [ sec : dumbbell ] .
the computation of the transient relaxation time and the related ctcp for the confluent heun equation are presented in section [ sec : stationary ] .
section [ sec : conclusions ] is devoted to conclusions .
when one is interested in the statistics of polymer extension the dynamics of a polymer molecule can be described , to a first approximation , in terms of its slowest oscillation mode . in this case
, the molecule can be modelled as an elastic dumbbell , i.e. as two beads connected by a spring .
the beads represent the ends of the molecule and the spring models entropic forces .
the separation between the beads measures the extension of the polymer . when introduced into a non - uniform flow the molecule experiences collisions with fluid particles and
becomes stretched under the action of the velocity gradient . in the simplest case ,
the drag force is assumed to be proportional to the velocity of the polymer relative to the fluid and thermal agitation is modelled by brownian motion . in most applications
the extension of the polymer remains smaller than the dissipative scale of the carrier flow , and therefore the velocity field can be assumed to be linear .
the separation vector of the ends of the polymer , @xmath6 , is then a stochastic process evolving according to the three - dimensional stochastic ordinary differential equation . ]
( e.g. bird _
1987 ) @xmath7 where @xmath8 , @xmath9 is the equilibrium mean - square separation of the ends of the molecule , and @xmath10 denotes the three - dimensional standard brownian motion .
the function @xmath11 determines the entropic force .
we consider the finitely extensible nonlinear elastic ( fene ) dumbbell model with @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the maximum extension of the molecule .
the force diverges as the molecular extension approaches @xmath13 ; thus the extension of the molecule will be finite and smaller than @xmath13 .
the fene model is appropriate for synthetic polymers such as polyacrylamide and polyethyleneoxide ; biological macromolecules such as dna and polyeptides are better described by the worm - like chain model ( e.g. larson 2005 ) . in elongational - flow experiments ,
the flexibility parameter @xmath14 usually ranges from @xmath15 to @xmath16 ( larson 2005 , shaqfeh 2005 ) .
the fene model neglects hydrodynamic interactions between the segments of the polymer .
inclusion of hydrodynamic interactions makes the coil
stretch transition sharper , but do not change the transition qualitatively ( e.g. wiest _ et al .
_ 1989 , hernndez cifre and garca de la torre 1998 , 1999 ) .
furthermore , the dumbbell model without hydrodynamic interactions accurately reproduces the extension
strain curve observed in experiments ( perkins _ et al .
the accuracy of the model can be ascribed to the cancellation between the effect of the distribution of drag forces along the chain and the effect of the increase in effective drag coefficient with polymer extension ( larson _ et al .
_ 1997 ) . neglecting hydrodynamic interactions has the benefits of providing analytical results .
a steady planar elongational flow is characterised by one direction of stretch , one direction of compression , and one neutral direction .
the velocity gradient is constant along the directions both of the extensional and compressional axes : @xmath17 , @xmath18 .
when a polymer is immersed in that flow the first component of the separation vector rapidly becomes much greater than the other components : @xmath19 and @xmath20 .
the extension of the molecule , therefore , is approximatively @xmath21 , and @xmath22 can be replaced by @xmath23 .. therefore , the results henceforth presented are unchanged for this flow . ]
according to this approximation , the first component of gives a one - dimensional stochastic differential equation for the extension of the dumbbell : @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the one - dimensional brownian motion .
for the sake of notational simplicity , we introduce the rescaled separation vector @xmath26 .
the pdf of @xmath27 , @xmath28 with @xmath29 $ ] , satisfies the one - dimensional fokker planck equation associated with ( e.g. stratonovich 1963 ) @xmath30 + \frac{1}{2b}\,\frac{\partial^2 \psi}{\partial q^2 } , \end{array}\ ] ] where @xmath31 , @xmath32 , and @xmath33 .
the dimensionless number _ wi _ is known as the weissenberg number and measures the level of polymer stretching . for @xmath34 polymers
are in the coiled state ; for @xmath35 polymers are fully extended .
the critical value @xmath36 marks the coil
stretch transition in elongational flows ( de gennes 1974 ) .
strictly speaking , the approximation leading to and holds true when the polymer is sufficiently stretched , i.e. only for @xmath37 .
equation , indeed , does not yield a good approximation of @xmath28 at low @xmath38 .
however , we shall see at the end of this section that it is appropriate to investigate polymer relaxation dynamics in terms of and also below the coil - stretch transition .
the fokker - planck equation is solved with reflecting boundary conditions , that is the probability current @xmath39 is assumed to vanish at the endpoints of the interval of definition : @xmath40 @xmath41 ( stratonovich 1963 ) . under these conditions , the stationary distribution of the extension , @xmath42 , can be derived by simple integration ( bird _ et al .
_ 1987 ) : @xmath43 where @xmath44\ ] ] and @xmath45 and @xmath46 denote the euler gamma function and the confluent hypergeometric function , respectively ( e.g. erdlyi _ et al .
large extensions become more and more probable with increasing _ wi _ in accordance with experiments ( perkins _ et al .
note however that , at low _ wi _ , equation does not constitutes a good description of the pdf of small extensions due to the approximation behind .
the time behaviour of the system depends on the form of the spectrum of the operator @xmath47 with reflecting boundary conditions : @xmath48 where @xmath49 denotes the probability current associated with the eigenfunction @xmath50 . under conditions , @xmath47 is non - positive defined and symmetric with respect to the scalar product with weighting function @xmath51 .
its eigenvalues @xmath52 are therefore real and non - negative , @xmath53 being associated with the long - time solution @xmath54 ( stratonovich 1963 ) .
if @xmath47 has a countable spectrum @xmath55 with @xmath56 , then is the characteristic time needed for @xmath28 to attain its long - time form @xmath57 when the initial condition @xmath58 is taken far from equilibrium ( schenzle and brand 1979 ) .
we note that while @xmath2 is the relaxation time of the polymer _ in the absence of flow _ , @xmath59 characterises polymer relaxation dynamics _ in the flow_. to compute @xmath59 , we need to solve the eigenvalue problem , . by making the substitutions @xmath60 , @xmath61
, we can rewrite ( [ eq : spectrum ] ) in the form @xmath62 where @xmath63 , @xmath64 , @xmath65 , @xmath66 , @xmath67 , and @xmath68 .
the above equation is a singly confluent heun equation in the non - symmetrical canonical form ( decarreau _ et al .
_ 1978a , decarreau _ et al .
_ 1978b , slavyanov 1995)$ ] , would lead to a second - order linear differential equation with two irregular singularities of poincar rank 1 and 3 , respectively . the fene model in a @xmath69-correlated random flow can be solved in terms of a general heun equation ( martins afonso and vincenzi 2005 ) . ] .
equation ( [ eq : che ] ) has two regular singularities at @xmath70 and @xmath71 and an irregular singularity of poincar rank 1 at @xmath72 .
the characteristic exponents at @xmath70 are 0 and @xmath73 ; at @xmath71 , they are 0 and @xmath74 .
we neglect the case of @xmath75 integer and odd since it does not have physical relevance .
consequently , there are no logarithmic solutions and , for @xmath76 , @xmath77 can be written as @xmath78 with @xmath79 , @xmath80 complex constants and @xmath81 , @xmath82 analytic functions of @xmath83 ( equivalently of @xmath84 ) such that @xmath85 and @xmath86 .
similarly , for @xmath87 , @xmath77 takes the form @xmath88 with @xmath89 , @xmath90 complex constants and @xmath91 , @xmath92 analytic functions of @xmath83 such that @xmath93 and @xmath94 .
it is easily seen that boundary conditions ( [ eq : bc ] ) can be matched only by those solutions of ( [ eq : che ] ) that belong to the exponent 0 both in @xmath70 and @xmath71 ( that is both @xmath80 and @xmath90 have to be zero ) since it does not have physical relevance . ] . the eigenvalue problem defined by
( [ eq : spectrum ] ) and ( [ eq : bc ] ) is therefore mapped into a ctcp on @xmath95 $ ] for the confluent heun equation ( [ eq : che ] ) . to compute the eigenvalues @xmath52
, we adapt the procedure exploited by svartholm ( 1939 ) and erdlyi ( 1942 , 1944 ) to ( [ eq : che ] ) ( see also slavyanov 1995 , slavyanov and lay 2000 ) .
we then expand @xmath96 in series of jacobi polynomials having the required characteristic exponent at @xmath70 and @xmath71 : @xmath97 with @xmath98 and @xmath99 .
the function @xmath100 denotes the gauss hypergeometric function ; @xmath101 are the jacobi polynomials of parameters @xmath102 and @xmath103 and degree @xmath104 ( e.g. erdlyi _ et al .
_ 1953 ) . the conditions for the convergence of will determine the spectrum of @xmath47 .
by defining the operators @xmath105,\\ \mathscr d_2w_\mu :=- z(z-1)w'_\mu,\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can rewrite ( [ eq : che ] ) in the form @xmath106 where @xmath107 , @xmath108/2 $ ] , @xmath109 .
the polynomials @xmath110 satisfy the differential relations ( erdlyi _ et al .
_ 1953 ) @xmath111 and @xmath112 with @xmath113 \widetilde{c}_n=-\frac{n(n+\omega)(n+\delta-1)}{(2n+\omega)(2n+\omega-1)}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in addition , the following recurrence relation holds ( erdlyi _ et al .
_ 1953 ) : @xmath114 with coefficients @xmath115 \widehat{c}_n=-\frac{n(n+\delta-1)}{(2n+\omega-1)(2n+\omega)}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] inserting expansion ( [ eq : expansion ] ) in ( [ eq : che_2 ] ) and exploiting relations ( [ eq : pol_1 ] ) , ( [ eq : pol_2 ] ) , ( [ eq : pol_3 ] ) yield the following three - term recurrence relation for @xmath116 : @xmath117 where the coefficients @xmath118 depend on @xmath52 through @xmath119 and @xmath120 . the asymptotic behaviour of @xmath121 and @xmath122 is given by @xmath123 according to the perron - kreuser theorem ( e.g. gautschi 1967 , wimp 1984 ) , implies that the recurrence relation ( [ eq:3 ] ) has two linearly independent solutions @xmath124 and @xmath125 such that @xmath126 the above sequences have the property : @xmath127 ; hence @xmath128 is what is called a minimal solution of .
every other solution non proportional to @xmath128 is asymptotically proportional to @xmath129 , and therefore diverges with increasing @xmath104 .
therefore , we can already say that can converge only if the sequence @xmath130 is a minimal solution of .
the second limit in implies that @xmath131{|c^-_n|}=0 $ ] .
this condition ensures that , if the coefficients @xmath132 form a minimal solution of , then expansion convergences absolutely to an analytic function in the whole complex plane ( szeg 1939 , p. 252 ) .
nonetheless , it is also required that @xmath133 for @xmath134 , that is the sequence @xmath130 is subject to initial conditions and .
equation is trivially satisfied since @xmath135 , and so does for @xmath53 .
( this is in accordance with the fact that @xmath54 exists for all @xmath136 and @xmath75 . ) however , for @xmath137 , equation fixes the ratio @xmath138 .
this latter requirement is not satisfied by whatever @xmath52 , and therefore select the spectrum of @xmath47 . to summarise , the spectrum of @xmath47 is the set of those @xmath52 such that @xmath139 is a minimal solution of satisfying @xmath140 . from pincherle s theorem ( e.g. gautschi 1967 , p. 31 ) , this conclusion is equivalent to stating that the eigenvalues @xmath52 are the solutions of @xmath141 the latter represents a transcendental equation for the relaxation spectrum associated with the fokker - planck equation .
the reciprocal of the smallest nonzero solution is @xmath142 .
we calculated @xmath59 numerically by means of the modified miller algorithm ( wimp 1984 , pp .
the behaviour of @xmath59 as a function of _ wi _ is reported in fig .
[ fig ] .
rescaled relaxation time @xmath142 as a function of the weissenberg number _ wi _ for @xmath143 ; the inset shows the comparison with the small-_wi _ behaviour @xmath144 ( dashed line ) . , scaledwidth=60.0% ] for very small @xmath136 the influence of the external flow is negligible and @xmath59 is approximately equal to @xmath2 . with increasing @xmath136 the ratio
@xmath142 starts growing as @xmath145 .
this behaviour can be deduced by replacing the spring force with a hookean force , @xmath146 , and computing the relaxation of the moments of @xmath147 .
for a fixed @xmath75 , the rescaled relaxation time reaches a sharp maximum @xmath148 in the neighbourhood of the coil
stretch transition ( @xmath149 ) ; the value of @xmath148 increases linearly with @xmath150 ( fig .
[ fig:2 ] ) . with increasing @xmath75 , @xmath59 attains its maximum value @xmath148 closer and closer to @xmath151 and the width of the peak decreases ( fig .
[ fig:2 ] ) . vs. the square root of the flexibility parameter @xmath14 : @xmath152 increases as @xmath153 with @xmath154 and @xmath155 ; ( _ b _ ) behaviour of @xmath156 as a function of @xmath150 , where @xmath156 is the weissenberg number at which the relaxation time attains its maximum value @xmath148 ; ( _ c _ ) relaxation time vs. _ wi _ for different @xmath75 , rescaled to make the maximum values coincide.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=32.5% ] vs. the square root of the flexibility parameter @xmath14 : @xmath152 increases as @xmath153 with @xmath154 and @xmath155 ; ( _ b _ ) behaviour of @xmath156 as a function of @xmath150 , where @xmath156 is the weissenberg number at which the relaxation time attains its maximum value @xmath148 ; ( _ c _ ) relaxation time vs. _ wi _ for different @xmath75 , rescaled to make the maximum values coincide.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=35.0% ] + vs. the square root of the flexibility parameter @xmath14 : @xmath152 increases as @xmath153 with @xmath154 and @xmath155 ; ( _ b _ ) behaviour of @xmath156 as a function of @xmath150 , where @xmath156 is the weissenberg number at which the relaxation time attains its maximum value @xmath148 ; ( _ c _ ) relaxation time vs. _ wi _ for different @xmath75 , rescaled to make the maximum values coincide.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=62.0% ] for large @xmath136 the relaxation time is fixed by the time scale of the flow @xmath157 , and therefore @xmath142 decreases as @xmath158 .
the computation of @xmath59 shows that , near the coil
stretch transition , the typical time scale involved in polymer relaxation dynamics is strongly different from @xmath2 .
the time associated with the fundamental oscillation mode is not representative of polymer temporal dynamics in flow .
these results confirm the behaviour encountered in isotropic @xmath69-correlated gaussian flows ( celani _ et al .
_ 2005a , martins afonso and vincenzi 2005 ) , but here the enhancement of @xmath59 is stronger since the elongational flow is more efficient in deforming polymers . in brownian dynamics simulations and experiments the relaxation time of @xmath28 can be measured from the decay of the moments of the extension to their steady - state value . to observe @xmath59
, one has to make sure that the initial condition @xmath58 is not orthogonal to the first eigenfunction of @xmath47 , that is @xmath159 in , with respect to the scalar product with weighting function @xmath57 .
figure [ fig : eigen ] shows the shape of @xmath159 for different @xmath136 .
an initial pdf concentrated either at a coiled or a stretched extension @xmath160 ( formally @xmath161 ) has projection onto @xmath159 equal to @xmath162 by construction ( e.g. stratonovich 1963 ) .
the initial condition with all the polymers having the same extension @xmath160 is therefore not orthogonal to @xmath159 if @xmath163 ; all the moments will thus tend to their stationary value with a typical time scale @xmath59 .
associated with the smallest nonzero eigenvalue @xmath164 ( @xmath143 ) .
the eigenfunctions have been computed numerically by means of the iteration
variation method ( morse and feshbach 1953).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=47.0% ] associated with the smallest nonzero eigenvalue @xmath164 ( @xmath143 ) .
the eigenfunctions have been computed numerically by means of the iteration
variation method ( morse and feshbach 1953).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.8% ] we now show that it is accurate to compute @xmath59 by means of also for @xmath165 . at low @xmath136 , the entropic force can be modelled as a hookean force , i.e. @xmath166 in . the vector equation therefore reduces to a set of three decoupled stochastic differential equations for @xmath167 , @xmath168 , @xmath169 .
hence we have @xmath170 , where @xmath171 is the pdf of the vector @xmath172 and @xmath173 is the pdf of the @xmath174-th component of @xmath172 .
the relaxation time of @xmath171 is thus the longest of the relaxation times of @xmath175 , @xmath176 , and @xmath177 given that all the @xmath173 have a non - trivial long - time limit .
it is easy to check that at low _ wi _ the relaxation time of @xmath175 is @xmath178 , while @xmath179 and @xmath180 ( with obvious notation ) .
the function @xmath171 therefore has the same relaxation time as @xmath175 .
now we note that @xmath28 and @xmath171 have the same long - time behaviour since @xmath181 .
we thus come to the following conclusion : the relaxation times of @xmath28 and @xmath175 coincide at low _ wi _ and @xmath175 satisfies .
this fact explains why yields an accurate computation of @xmath59 also below the coil
stretch transition .
we have investigated the relaxation dynamics of an isolated polymer in an external flow .
previous studies focused on the relaxation of a polymer in a solvent driven only by brownian motion .
those studies determined the time @xmath2 associated with the slowest oscillation mode of the molecule in the absence of external flow .
we have considered an elongational flow and derived a transcendental equation for the relaxation spectrum associated with the time evolution of the pdf of polymer extension .
the problem of computing this spectrum has been recast as a central two - point connection problem for a confluent heun equation .
the heun equation results from the separation of the time variable in the fokker
planck equation for the pdf of the extension .
our analysis shows that an external elongational flow strongly influences polymer relaxation dynamics .
the longest relaxation time associated with the evolution of the pdf of the extension provides an estimation of the time scale of polymer deformation . near the coil
stretch transition , this time is significantly greater than @xmath2 ( already one order of magnitude greater for short molecules ) .
the physical reason is the large number of polymer configurations close to the coil stretch transition . at intermediate weissenberg numbers polymer conformation results from a critical competition between the entropic force and the velocity gradient .
therefore , around the transition , coiled and stretched polymer coexist in the flow , and this makes the relaxation to the equilibrium pdf particularly long .
it is worth noticing that the amplification of the relaxation time is stronger when hydrodynamic interactions are taken into account ; this behaviour is intimately related to the finite - time conformation hysteresis observed in elongational flows ( celani _ et al .
_ 2006 ) .
the authors are grateful to a. celani , c. doering , m. martins afonso , a. puliafito , and b. rajaratnam for useful suggestions .
this work has been partially supported by the european union under the contract hprn - ct-2002 - 0030 `` fluid mechanical stirring and mixing : the lagrangian approach '' . * babcock h p , teixeira r e , hur j s , shaqfeh e s and chu s 2003 _ macromolecules _ * 36 * 45448 * bird r b , hassager o , armstrong r c and curtiss c f 1987 _ dynamics of polymeric liquids , fluid mechanics _
vol 2 ( new york : wiley ) * brochard - wyart f 1995 _ europhys
. lett . _ * 30 * 38792 * celani a , musacchio s and vincenzi d 2005a _ j. stat .
phys . _ * 118 * 53154 * celani a , puliafito a and turitsyn k 2005b _ europhys .
lett . _ * 70 * 46470 * celani a , puliafito a and vincenzi d 2006 _ phys .
lett . _ * 97 * 118301 * davoudi j and schumacher j 2006 _ phys
. fluids _ * 18 * 025103 * decarreau a , dumont - lepage m - cl , maroni p , robert a and ronveaux a 1978a _ ann . soc .
bruxelles _ * 92 * 5378 * decarreau a , maroni p , robert a 1978b _ ann . soc .
bruxelles _ * 92 * 15189 * erdlyi a 1942 _ duke math . j. _ * 9 * 4858 * erdlyi a 1944 _ q. j. math . _ * 15 * 629 * erdlyi , magnus w , oberhettinger f and tricomi f g 1953 _ higher transcendental functions _ ( new york : mcgraw - hill ) * gautschi w 1967 _ siam rev . _
* 9 * 2482 * de gennes p g 1974 _ j. chem .
_ * 60 * 503042 * gerashchenko s and steinberg v 2006 _ phys .
* 96 * 038304 * hatfield j w and quake s r 1999 _ phys . rev .
lett . _ * 82 * 354851 * hernndez cifre j g and garca de la torre j 1998 _ j. non - cryst .
solids _ * 235 - 237 * 71722 * hernndez cifre j g and garca de la torre j 1999 _ j. rheol . _ * 43 * 33958 * hur j s , shaqfeh e s , babcock h p and chu s 2002 _ phys .
_ e * 66 * 011915 * jaff g 1933 _ z. phys .
_ * 87 * 53544 * larson r g , perkins t t , smith d e and chu s _ phys . rev .
_ e * 55 * 17947 * larson r g 2005 _ j. rheol . _
* 49 * 170 * leaver e w 1985 _ proc .
. london _ a * 402 * 28598 * manneville
s , cluzel ph , viovy j - l , chatenay d and caron f 1996 _ europhys .
_ * 36 * 4138 * martins afonso m and vincenzi d 2005 _ j. fluid mech .
_ * 540 * 99108 * morse p m and feshbach h 1953 _ methods of theoretical physics _
( new york : mcgraw hill ) * perkins t t , quake s r , smith d e and chu s 1994 _ science _ * 264 * 822 * perkins t t , smith d e and chu s 1997 _ science _ * 276 * 201621 * puliafito a and turitsyn k 2005 _ physica _ d * 211 * 922 * quake s r , babcock h and chu s 1997 _ nature _ * 388 * 1514 * rouse p e 1953 _ j. chem .
* 21 * 127280 * rzehak r and zimmermann w 2002 _ europhys .
lett . _ * 59 * 77985 * schenzle a and brand h 1979 _ phys . rev .
_ a * 20 * 162847 * schroeder c m , babcock h p , shaqfeh e s g and chu s 2003 _ science _ * 301 * 15159 * schroeder c m , shaqfeh e s g and chu s 2004 _ macromolecules _ * 37 * 924256 * shaqfeh e s g 2005 _ j. non - newton . fluid mech . _ * 130 * 128 * slavyanov s yu 1995 _ confluent heun equation _ , in _ heun s differential equations _
ed a. ronveaux ( new york : oxford university press ) * slavyanov s yu and lay w 2000 _ special functions , a unified theory based on singularities _
( new york : oxford university press ) * smith d e and chu s 1998 _ science _ * 281 * , 133540 * smith d e , babcock h p and chu s 1999 _ science _ * 283 * 17247 * sreenivasan k r and white c m 2000 _ j. fluid mech . _ * 409 * 14964
* stratonovich r l 1963 _ topics in the theory of random noise _ ( new york : gordon and breach science publishers ) * svartholm n 1939 _ math .
ann . _ * 116 * 41321 * szeg g 1939 _ orthogonal polynomials _ ( providence , ri : american mathematical society ) * wiest j l , wedgewood l and bird r b 1989 _ j. chem . phys .
_ * 90 * 58794 * wimp j 1984 _ computation with recurrence relations _
( pitman publishing inc . ) * zimm b h 1956 _ j. chem .
* 24 * 26978 | we investigate the non - equilibrium dynamics of an isolated polymer in a stationary elongational flow .
we compute the relaxation time to the steady - state configuration as a function of the weissenberg number .
a strong increase of the relaxation time is found around the coil
stretch transition , which is attributed to the large number of polymer configurations .
the relaxation dynamics of the polymer is solved analytically in terms of a central two - point connection problem for the singly confluent heun equation . _
j. phys . a : math . gen .
_ * 39 * , 1069110701 ( 2006 ) |
modern astronomy pays close attention to the physics and evolution of triple and multiple stars .
the stability of orbits in such systems , see , e.g. @xcite , the influence of additional bodies on the central binary , and the dynamical evolution of orbits in multiple systems , see , e.g. @xcite are particularly interesting .
some important astrophysical phenomena can be associated with the evolution and dynamical interactions of triple stars .
type ia supernovae may originate in triples due to the evolution of the central binary under the influence of a third star @xcite or due to the dynamical interaction and subsequent direct collision of white dwarfs in triple systems @xcite .
the giant eruption of eta carinae in 19th century could be the result of a merger of a massive close binary , triggered by the gravitational interaction with a massive tertiary companion , which is the current member of the binary @xcite .
investigations of multiplicity of stars are important for understanding of star formation processes , see , e.g. , @xcite .
this makes searches for multiplicity in binary systems of high importance .
according to the general catalogue of variable stars @xcite , the orbital period of cvboo is @xmath3 d and the spectral type of its primary component is g0 .
cvboo was found as an eclipsing binary by @xcite , and it was studied by many observers during several decades using photographic , visual , pmt ( photomultiplier tube ) , and ccd ( charge - coupled device ) methods . in a detailed study of cv boo , @xcite presented the results of @xmath4-band photometric studies and spectroscopic radial velocity ( rv ) measurements of cv boo . using their own data and information from literature , @xcite determined the masses , radii and effective temperatures of the primary and secondary components to be @xmath5m@xmath6 , @xmath7r@xmath6 and @xmath8k , and @xmath9m@xmath6 , @xmath10r@xmath6 and @xmath11k , respectively .
@xcite found that cv boo has a light curve variability with a period shorter than the orbital period .
they connected this variability with the axial rotation of a spotted component ( or both components ) which rotates faster than the synchronous rate .
@xcite noted that this fact disagrees with predictions from the tidal evolution theory according to which both companions should be synchronized .
also , they came to the conclusion that both components are near the end of the main sequence stage and that the primary component even probably entered into the shell hydrogen burning stage . @xcite estimated the age of the system as @xmath12 myr , and concluded that the radii of the companion stars in cv boo are about @xmath13 larger than what is expected from stellar evolutionary models . @xcite also claimed that cv boo has a stable orbital period , based on available 98 primary and 50 secondary minima .
nevertheless , the existence of a large number of high precision ccd photometry obtained since 2008 allows us to search for an additional companion in cv boo .
.moments of light minima for cv boo obtained from our observations . here `` hjd '' is the heliocentric julian date , `` min '' is the minimum type ( `` i '' is the primary minimum , `` ii '' is the secondary minimum ) , @xmath14 is the difference between observed values of moments of minima and values calculated using ephemeris ( [ eph ] ) , @xmath15 is the difference between observed values of moments of minima and values calculated using equation ( [ ephlong ] ) . [ cols="^,^,^,^ " , ] cv boo was observed with the 50 cm amt-1 telescope with the apogee alta - u16 m 4kx4k ccd camera at the maidanak observatory of the ulugh beg astronomical institute ( uzbek academy of sciences ) during 41 nights in spring summer of 2014 .
we obtained more than 32500 images in the bessell _ r _ filter with exposures ranging from 8 to 20 s , with a typical exposure of 10 s. continuos monitoring time intervals were 5 - 7 hours per night .
bias and dark frames with appropriate exposures were made every night before and after observations .
flat field frames were recorded for the twilight sky .
to process the data we use the aperture photometry method with a specific program .
the optimum aperture corresponds to the minimum of the standard deviation for differential magnitudes .
we used 2mass j15270686 + 3659270 and 2mass j15272880 + 3647225 as the reference stars .
the aperture was constant during each night and did nt change significantly from night to night .
precision values for a single exposure were in the range @xmath16 for different nights .
standard dark and flat field corrections were made .
original fits files were converted to text files containing the cv boo brightness with respect to the reference stars depending on the heliocentric julian date ( hjd ) .
light curves of cv boo were created on the basis of these data .
figure [ fig1 ] plots a sample light curve of cv boo . in order to achieve the highest possible precision of minima moments we use only the best light curves with both branches around the light curve minimum .
according to @xcite at least one of the stars in cv boo can be spotted .
such spots can influence the symmetry of minima branches .
we assumed that positions of spots did nt change during our observations .
this assumption is valid because we studied the asymmetry of branches for our observational points and found that it is almost constant .
also , we note that asymmetry of the branches is about an order of magnitude less than the double amplitude of a light effect that is found in the present study .
the duration of a minimum of a light curve of cv boo is @xmath17 of its orbital period . to calculate moments of minima of a light curve we used a part of a minima with a duration 0.05 of the orbital period .
it is equal to @xmath18 of the minimum depth and @xmath19 of the minimum duration .
we calculate moments of minima in free searches by solving the light curves using fixed set of geometrical parameters of the system .
a specific program designed to calculate orbital elements is used , see @xcite for more details , also see @xcite for a similar approach .
we adopted the following parameters of the binary system : radii of the components of @xmath20 and @xmath21 ( in units of the semi - major axis of the system ) , the inclination angle @xmath22 , the zero eccentricity of the central binary orbit , the luminosities of the components @xmath23 and @xmath24 ( in units of the system luminosity ) , and the limb darkening coefficient @xmath25 .
this set of parameters is similar to parameters obtained by @xcite .
the list our moments of minima is presented in table [ minima ] .
as a first step in our study , we used all moments of minima ( we collected observational points from @xcite , and use our results from table [ minima ] ) and the linear ephemeris obtained by @xcite : @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the number of orbital periods since the initial epoch .
the moments of the secondary minima are @xmath28 , where @xmath29 d is the orbital period of cv boo . at this stage , we calculate @xmath30 as the difference between the observational moments of minima and values calculated using equation ( [ eph ] ) .
to analyse deviations of moments of minima as a function of time , we used the weighted least squares method because measurements of different authors have different errors . for three groups of observations ( `` photographic '' , `` visual '' , and `` pmt / ccd '' ) we take weights to be equal to the inverse standard deviations in these groups .
polinomial time regressions ( with the power in the range from 0 to 3 ) are checked using two criteria : student t - criterion ( the significance level 0.95 ) , the hypothesis of the zero mean , and @xmath31 criterion ( the significance level 0.05 for two intervals ; only two intervals were used , because observations have different precision ) , the hypothesis of the equiprobable sign deviations is used .
hypothesises of 0 and 1 powers are declined , for the 3 power the regression matrix is almost degenerate , therefore deviations of moments of minima can be described by a quadratic dependence on time . a graphical presentation of this result can be found in the figure [ fig2 ] . as a result
we give the next ephemeris for cv boo : @xmath32 where @xmath33 , @xmath34 d , and @xmath35 d. we estimate the significance of our results using a statistical method by @xcite and calculate the value @xmath36 where @xmath37 is the standard deviation that corresponds to the values of @xmath30 calculated using equation ( [ eph ] ) and @xmath38 is the standard deviation that is corrected with the theoretical curve from equation ( [ ephlong ] ) .
the less @xmath39 means the better coincidence of a theoretical result with observations . for moments of minima derived from photographic plates
, one has @xmath40 , @xmath41 , @xmath42 . for visual moments of minima : @xmath43 , @xmath44 , @xmath45 . for moments of minima obtained from the ccd and pmt observations : @xmath46 , @xmath47 , @xmath48 . for all points
: @xmath49 , @xmath50 , @xmath51 .
so , we can conclude that equation ( [ ephlong ] ) describes the whole observations better than the linear ephemeris in equation ( [ eph ] ) , therefore the cv boo orbital period is changing on a long time scale . at the same time , the existing data do nt allow us to determine the physical nature of this change .
we analyse 14 moments of minima obtained during our observations in 2014 and find that these data probably contain a periodical variation ( period @xmath0 d ) due to the light time effect ( see figure [ fig3 - 1 ] ) .
also , we collected published ccd and pmt times of cv boo light minima since hjd 2452321 in addition to our data .
these modern ccd and pmt moments of minima have comparatively low scatter and can be suitable to find a relatively low amplitude variation of the orbital period .
we calculate @xmath52 as the difference between the observational moments of minima and the values calculated using equation ( [ ephlong ] ) .
to derive orbital parameters of a multiple system we solve its light equation ( see equation 3 in @xcite , also see @xcite for a more detailed description of this method ) by an iterative method of differential corrections . for our 14 moments of minima from table [ minima ]
we obtain the following orbital parameters for the third body : the orbital period of @xmath53 d , the amplitude of the light equation is @xmath54 s , @xmath55 , @xmath56 au , where @xmath57 is the semi - major axis of the orbit of the cv boo binary star s center of mass around the center of mass of the whole system and @xmath58 is the angle between the third body s orbital plane and the plane of the sky , initial epoch of the third companion is @xmath59 , the longitude of the pericenter is @xmath60 for the orbit of the center of mass of the close binary that revolves around the center of mass of the triple system . the result is shown in figure [ fig3 - 1 ] , here @xmath61 , @xmath62 , and @xmath63 . for all ccd and pmt moments of minima after hjd 2452321 taken from the @xcite and from table [ minima ]
we obtain the following set of light equation parameters : @xmath64 d , @xmath65 s , @xmath55 , @xmath66 au , @xmath67 , @xmath68 .
the result is shown in the figure [ fig3 - 2 ] , here @xmath69 , @xmath70 , and @xmath71 . among the moments of minima after hjd 2452321 we take 88 moments of minima as `` good '' , 16 moments of minima as `` bad '' . the reasons to define the moments of minima as `` bad '' and `` good '' points are the following .
the moments of minima might be calculated differently by different observers even for the same minimum .
also , the spot activity of the companions can distort the light curves of the system and can lead to differences in calculations of moments of minima .
a particular point is assumed to be `` bad '' if its standard deviation exceeds @xmath72 value from the short period curve in figure [ fig3 - 2 ] .
our 14 points form an uniform group , we used the same method to find all minima moments , light curves with both branches , and spots did nt evolve during our observations , therefore the result based on them is reliable .
if we use the linear ephemeris for all points after hjd 2452321 instead of equation ( [ ephlong ] ) , the parameters of the light equation slightly differs , but the light equation exists .
the difference between @xmath14 calculated for the theoretical curve in figure [ fig2 ] for hjd 2452321 and for hjd of the most recent observations ( hjd 2456800 - 2456900 ) is @xmath73 s , the order of magnitude of this value is the same as the order of magnitude of the light equation suggested here . at the same time
, we should note that during this period of time the secular orbital period change is practically a smooth function that can be represented as a parabolic function with equation [ ephlong ] or as a sinusoidal function with the period @xmath74 years .
the period of the light effect found in the present study is @xmath0 d and so it can be found , because there are about 60 orbital cycles of the suggested tertiary body between hjd 2452321 and hjd 2456900 . during our observations
the influence of the secular orbital period change is definitely negligible .
the mass function of the suggested tertiary companion is @xmath75 , see , e. g. , @xcite , equation ( 5 ) .
this value yields the lower limit of the mass of this body of @xmath76 .
we found a periodical variation of the cv boo orbital period on a time scale of @xmath0 d. this variation can be explained by the light time effect caused by the gravitational influence of a third star with a mass of @xmath77 in an eccentric orbit with @xmath2 . according to figure 1 in @xcite the third companion is in a chaotic zone or ( if the real orbit of the suggested tertiary companion is significantly wider than its projection ) almost in a chaotic zone ( the values of parameters for the mentioned figure are @xmath78 , @xmath79 , where @xmath80 and @xmath81 are the masses of the primary and the secondary components respectively , @xmath82 is the pericentric distance of the tertiary companion , @xmath83 is the semi - major axis of the central binary s orbit ) .
so the system is very interesting to test numerical calculations of dynamical evolution . according to @xcite , the fraction of solar type spectroscopic binaries with tertiary components reaches 96% for binaries with the orbital period less than 3 d.
our investigation is in a good agreement with this result .
the disagreement between the axial rotation of stars in cv boo and predictions from tidal evolution theory noted by @xcite ( at least one of the components rotates faster than the synchronous rate ) can probably be explained by a resonance suggested by @xcite , see the last paragraph of section 3 .
this fact serves as an indirect evidence in favour of the existence of a tertiary companion in cv boo and the influence of this tertiary companion on the central binary .
the physical nature of the secular variation of the cv boo orbital period ca nt be clarified with the existing data , so that additional photometric and spectroscopic observations are needed to shed light on this question .
it can probably be explained by one of the following mechanisms : ( i ) the re - synchronization of the axial rotation of one of the companions ( or both companions ) with orbital rotation of the binary that was disturbed by a third body , ( ii ) the light time effect caused by the gravitational influence of an additional body with a very long orbital period ( about several decades ) , ( iii ) the magnetic mechanism @xcite that changes the quadrupole gravitational momentum of the stars in the system by possible strong gravitational disturbances of the orbits in this system , and ( iv ) the slow mass transfer in the system .
it is possible that rv studies by @xcite and by @xcite have missed the proposed tertiary companion with the orbital period @xmath0 d because of the following reasons .
a rough estimate of the orbital velocity of the center of masses of the binary system around the center of masses of the whole system ( with the third body s orbital parameters given above ) gives @xmath84 km s@xmath85 during the very short periastron passage , the radial velocity is @xmath86 km s@xmath85 , during the apastron passage the orbital velocity becomes @xmath87 km s@xmath85 , the radial velocity is @xmath88 km s@xmath85 .
these quantitative estimates are valid for @xmath89 calculated for 88 points .
orbital velocities of the components of the central binary are about 300 km s@xmath85 and their radial velocities range from several tens to more than a hundred of km s@xmath85 .
the orbit of the suggested tertiary companion is an ellipse , therefore most of the time the orbital velocity of the binary should be much less than during the third companion s periastron passage .
the radial projection of the orbital velocity can be only less than the orbital velocity and in some positions within the orbit it can be almost zero . only a few radial velocity measurements were made near the periastron passage of the suggested body .
therefore the presence of this body could be missed in previous spectral studies .
an accurate rv study during several months can prove or reject the existence of the candidate tertiary companion found in this work . in case of @xmath90 for 14 moments of minima obtained from our observations the radial velocities around the periaston and
apastron passages are much less than values above , therefore this motion could be missed even easier than in the case of @xmath89 for 88 moments of minima ( our+literature ) .
a close binary system similar to cv boo can be a progenitor of a binary system that consists of two carbon - oxygen white dwarfs , therefore it can be a progenitor of a typeia supernova in a triple scenario @xcite , in this scenario the total mass of colliding white dwarfs can be less than the chandrasekhar limit .
cv boo itself will most likely merge during further evolution in common envelope stage . to estimate its probable fate we used the web version of the `` scenario machine '' @xcite . for the masses of the stars equal to the masses of cv boo components and the semi - major axis in the range @xmath91 and the common envelope efficiency in the range
@xmath92 we obtain different paths of evolution of this binary .
the influence of the tertiary companion can change cv boo s evolutionary final state : ( a ) a single white dwarf after merge during common envelope evolution ( this is the most probable way of the evolution of this binary ) , ( b ) a binary white dwarf , ( c ) a binary white dwarf , its components collide under the influence of the tertiary companion .
the third body is required for the case ( c ) , whereas cases ( a ) and ( b ) can be realized both in the presence of the tertiary companion and without it . | a short period eclipsing binary star cv boo is tested for the possible existence of additional bodies in the system with a help of the light equation method .
we use data on the moments of minima from the literature as well as from our observations during 2014 may
july .
a variation of the cv boo s orbital period is found with a period of @xmath0 d. this variation can be explained by the influence of a third star with a mass of @xmath1 in an eccentric orbit with @xmath2 . a possibility that the orbital period changes on long time scales is discussed .
the suggested tertiary companion is near the chaotic zone around the central binary , so cv boo represents an interesting example to test its dynamical evolution .
a list of 14 minima moments of the binary obtained from our observations is presented . |
despite the tendency of social actors to become more similar to each other through their local interactions @xcite , global polarization , i.e. , the existence of stable multicultural regimes , is a ubiquitous phenomenon in human society @xcite .
this issue has been addressed by somewhat idealized agent - based simulations of human behavior producing highly nontrivial insights on the nature of the collective behavior that results from the homogenizing local interactions ( see @xcite for a recent review ) . in this line ,
a particularly successful model is axelrod s model for the dissemination of culture or social influence @xcite . in axelrod s model ,
the agents are placed at the sites of a square lattice of size @xmath3 and can interact with their nearest neighbors only .
the culture of an agent is represented by a string of @xmath4 cultural features , where each feature can adopt a certain number @xmath5 of distinct traits .
the interaction between any two neighboring agents takes place with probability proportional to the number of traits they have in common .
although the result of such interaction is the increase of the similarity between the two agents , as one of them modifies a previously distinct trait to match that of its partner , the model exhibits global polarization @xcite .
the key ingredient for the existence of stable globally polarized states in axelrod s model is the rule that prohibits the interaction between agents which do not have any cultural trait in common .
relaxation of this rule so as to permit interactions regardless of the similarity between agents leads to one of the @xmath6 distinct absorbing homogeneous configurations @xcite .
in addition , introduction of external noise so that traits can change at random with some small probability @xcite , as well as the increase of the connectivity of the agents @xcite , destabilizes the polarized state also .
although axelrod s model enjoyed great popularity among the statistical physics community due mainly to the existence of a non - equilibrium phase transition @xcite that separates the globally homogeneous from the globally polarized regimes @xcite , the vulnerability of the polarized absorbing configurations was considered a major drawback to explaining robust collective social behavior . in this vein ,
parisi et al .
@xcite have proposed a lattice version of the classic frequency bias mechanism for cultural or opinion change @xcite , which assumes that the number of people holding an opinion is the key factor for an agent to adopt that opinion , i.e. , people have a tendency to espouse cultural traits that are more common in their social environment .
actually , almost any model of cultural transmission admits that the probability that an individual acquires a cultural variant depends on the frequency of that variant in the population .
the frequency - dependent bias mechanism requires , however , that the individual be _ disproportionately _ likely to acquire the more common variant @xcite .
more to the point , in the model of parisi et al .
the culture of an agent is specified by a binary string of length @xmath4 ( so @xmath7 ) and each bit of that string takes the value which is more common among its neighbors @xcite .
since the model can be immediately recognized as @xmath4 independent majority - vote models @xcite , we found the claim by those authors that such model exhibits a polarized regime most intriguing . in order to check whether the multicultural absorbing configurations reported by parisi et al . were not artifacts of the small lattice size used in their study ( @xmath8 ) , in this paper we present a detailed analysis of the effects of the finite size of the lattice by considering square lattices of linear size up to @xmath9 .
in addition , we set @xmath10 to stress the identification with the well - known majority vote model of statistical physics . hence the agents or sites of the lattices are modeled by ising spins .
our findings indicate that the polarized regime is indeed stable in the thermodynamic limit @xmath11 and that the element accountable for this stability is the procedure used to calculate the majority , which includes the site to be updated ( target site ) in addition to its nearest neighbors . for sites in the bulk of the lattice ,
this procedure essentially specifies the criterion of update in case of a tie , i.e. , in case there is no majority among the neighbors . in this case , the majority - vote variant used by parisi et al . leaves the state of the agent untouched , whereas the most common variant used in the literature sets that state at random with probability @xmath12 @xcite .
it should be noted , however , that the criterion used by parisi et al .
is actually the original definition of the majority - vote model as introduced in refs .
it is surprising that such ( apparently ) minor implementation detail produces nontrivial consequences in the thermodynamic limit , which can actually be confirmed analytically using a mean - field approach that takes into account the correlation between nearest neighbors the pair approximation @xcite .
however , the addition of a thermal - like noise such that the individuals may take a stance opposed to the majority opinion with some small probability destabilizes the globally polarized regime leading to one of the two low - temperature homogeneous steady states of the ising model @xcite . in that sense
we disagree with the claim by parisi et al . that their variant of the majority - vote model is more robust than axelrod s model to the effect of this type of noise .
the rest of this paper is organized as follows . in sect .
[ sec : model ] we describe the variant of the majority - vote model proposed by parisi et al . , which henceforth we refer to as the extended majority - vote model since its key ingredient is the stretching of the neighborhood to include the target site @xcite . in sect .
[ sec : mf ] we present the mean - field approach to this model using the single - site and pair approximations @xcite . in sect .
[ sec : res ] we use extensive monte carlo simulations to investigate several properties of the absorbing configurations such as the average number of opinion domains or clusters , the size of the largest cluster and the distribution of cluster sizes , giving emphasis to their dependences on the lattice size . in that section
also we discuss the vulnerability of the heterogeneous opinion regime against a thermal - like noise , which allows the individuals to disagree with the majority opinion . finally , in sect .
[ sec : conc ] we present our concluding remarks .
the agents are fixed at the sites of a square lattice of size @xmath3 with open boundary conditions ( i.e. , agents at the corners interact with two neighbors , agents at the sides with three , and agents in the bulk with four nearest neighbors ) .
the initial configuration is random : the opinion of each agent is set by a random digit @xmath13 or @xmath14 with equal probability . at each time
we pick a target agent at random and then verify which is the more frequent opinion ( @xmath14 or @xmath13 ) among its extended neighborhood , which includes the target agent itself .
the opinion of the target agent is then changed to match the corresponding majority value .
we note that there are no ties for agents in the bulk or at the corners of the square lattice since in these cases the extended neighborhood comprises @xmath15 and @xmath16 sites , respectively .
however , agents at the sides of the lattice have an extended neighborhood of @xmath17 sites ( i.e. , @xmath16 neighbors plus the target agent ) and so in case of a tie , the opinion of the target agent remains unchanged .
of course , in the limit of large lattices the contribution of these boundary sites will be negligible .
this procedure is repeated until the system is frozen in an absorbing configuration .
although the majority - vote rule or , more generally , the frequency bias mechanism for opinion change @xcite is a homogenizing assumption by which the agents become more similar to each other , the above - described model does seem to exhibit global polarization , i.e. , heterogeneous absorbing configurations @xcite . since the study of ref .
@xcite was based on a small lattice of linear size @xmath18 a more careful analysis is necessary to confirm whether this conclusion holds in the thermodynamic limit as well .
it is interesting to note that for the more popular variant of the majority - vote model , in which the state of the target site is not included in the majority reckoning , and ties are decided by choosing the opinion of the target agent at random with probability @xmath12 , the only absorbing states in the thermodynamic limit are the two homogeneous configurations . for finite lattices , however , we find heterogeneous absorbing configurations characterized by stripes that sweep the entire lattice . in sect .
[ sec : res ] we carry out a finite size scaling analysis of the extended majority - vote rule aiming at understanding the nature of the opinion domains that fragment the absorbing configurations .
in this section we offer an analytical approximation to the extended majority - vote model introduced by parisi et al @xcite .
the state of the agent at site @xmath19 of the square lattice is represented by the binary variable @xmath20 and so the configuration of the entire lattice comprising @xmath21 sites is denoted by @xmath22 .
the master equation that governs the time evolution of the probability distribution @xmath23 is given by @xmath24\ ] ] where @xmath25 and @xmath26 is the transition rate between configurations @xmath27 and @xmath28 @xcite .
for the extended majority - vote model we have @xmath29 - \eta_i \right |\ ] ] where the notation @xmath30 stands for the sum over the 4 nearest neighbors of site @xmath19 and @xmath31 if @xmath32 and @xmath13 otherwise .
we are interested in determining the fraction of agents holding opinion @xmath14 or , equivalently , the fraction of sites in state @xmath14 , which we denote by @xmath33 .
since all sites are equivalent we have @xmath34 and this mean value is given by the equation @xmath35 with @xmath36 as usual .
to carry out this average we need to make approximations . in what follows we study in detail two such approximation schemes , namely , the single - site approximation and the pair approximation . this the simplest mean - field scheme which assumes that the sites are independent random variables so that eq .
( [ r0 ] ) becomes @xmath37 - 1 \right | \nonumber \\
& & + \left ( 1 - \rho \right ) \sum_{n=0}^4 b_n^4 \left ( \rho \right ) \theta \left [ n - 3 \right ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath38 is the binomial distribution @xmath39 carrying out the sums explicitly and rearranging the terms yield @xmath40 this equation , which is invariant to the change @xmath41 , has three fixed points , namely , @xmath42 , @xmath43 and @xmath44 .
the first two fixed points are stable and the third one is unstable .
this means that in the single - site approximation the only stable configurations are the homogeneous ones .
finally , we note that @xmath33 contains the same information as the single - site probability distribution @xmath45 .
in fact , @xmath46 and @xmath47 . in this scheme
we assume that nearest neighbors sites are statistically dependent random variables so that , in addition to the single - site probability distribution @xmath45 , we need to compute the pair probability distribution @xmath48 as well .
of particular importance for the subsequent calculations is the conditional probability distribution @xmath49 which is given simply by the ratio between the pair and the single - site probability distributions .
for the sake of concreteness , let us denote the states of the 4 neighbors of site @xmath19 by @xmath50 and @xmath51 .
these are independent random variables in the pair approximation since they are not nearest neighbors in the square lattice , so the sum @xmath52 that appears in the argument of the theta functions is a sum of independent variables . with these notations
we can rewrite eq .
( [ r0 ] ) as @xmath53 where we have carried out the sum over @xmath54 explicitly .
the assumption that @xmath55 are statistically independent random variables allows to write @xmath56 and finally obtain @xmath57 \left | \theta \left [ n - 2 \right ] - 1 \right | \nonumber \\ & & + \left ( 1 - \rho \right ) \sum_{n=0}^4 b_n^4 \left [ p_{1 \mid 1 } \left ( 1 \mid 0 \right ) \right ] \theta \left [ n - 3 \right ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] which is identical to eq .
( [ r1a ] ) except for the arguments of the binomial distributions . using the notation @xmath58 we write @xmath59 so that eq .
( [ r2b ] ) involves only two unknowns , @xmath33 and @xmath60 . carrying out the summations explicitly so as to eliminate the theta functions yields @xmath61 \nonumber \\ & & + \left ( 1 - \rho \right ) \left [ b_3 ^ 4 \left ( \frac{\rho-\phi}{1-\rho } \right ) + b_4 ^ 4 \left ( \frac{\rho - \phi}{1-\rho } \right ) \right ] .\end{aligned}\ ] ] we note that this equation reduces to eq .
( [ r1b ] ) in the case the neighboring sites are assumed independent , i.e. , @xmath62 .
next , our task is to determine an equation for @xmath63 where @xmath64 labels one of the four nearest neighboring sites of @xmath19 .
we have @xmath65 carrying out the average over @xmath66 and @xmath67 ( say @xmath68 ) explicitly yields @xmath69
\left | \theta \left [ m - 1 \right ] - 1 \right | \nonumber \\ & & + 2 \left ( 1 - \rho \right ) p_{1 \mid 1 } \left ( 1 \mid 0 \right ) \sum_{m=0}^3 b_m^3 \left [ p_{1 \mid 1 } \left ( 1 \mid 0 \right ) \right ] \theta \left [ m - 2 \right ] \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] which can be written more compactly as @xmath70 . \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] equations ( [ r2c ] ) and ( [ r2e ] ) determine completely the time evolution of @xmath33 and @xmath60 and so they are our final equations for the pair approximation of the extended majority - vote model .
figure [ fig:1 ] , which shows the time evolution of the density of sites in state @xmath14 , confirms that eq .
( [ r2e ] ) is indeed invariant to the change @xmath71 .
most surprisingly , this figure uncovers an unexpected dependence on the choice of the ( random ) initial condition @xmath72 and @xmath73 : indeed in the range @xmath74 , where @xmath75 , the equilibrium solution @xmath76 is a smooth function of @xmath72 , i.e. , there is a continuum of fixed points .
accordingly , fig . [ fig:2 ] shows the fixed point solutions of eqs .
( [ r2c ] ) and ( [ r2e ] ) for the usual situation in which the states of the sites of the initial configuration are set @xmath14 with probability @xmath72 and @xmath13 with probability @xmath77 . for this setting
we have @xmath73 . the mathematical explanation for the odd dynamical behavior exhibited in figs .
[ fig:1 ] and [ fig:2 ] is that the dynamic evolution is such that @xmath78 for @xmath79 , a condition that solves the two equations ( [ r2c ] ) and ( [ r2e ] ) at equilibrium ( i.e. , @xmath80 ) simultaneously and so leaves one of the unknowns free to take any arbitrary value set by the dynamics or the initial conditions .
the physical reason is that there are in fact many absorbing configurations very close to the random initial configurations and a few lattice updates ( typically 10 ) is sufficient to freeze the dynamics ( see fig .
[ fig:3 ] ) .
in fact , the comparison with the results of the monte carlo simulations exhibited in fig .
[ fig:2 ] shows a good qualitative agreement between the pair approximation and the simulation results .
finally , we note that the pair approximation for the variant of the majority - vote model in which ties are decided by flipping the state of the target site with probability @xmath12 yields the anticipated result that the only stable fixed points are @xmath81 and @xmath82 , whose basins of attraction depend on whether @xmath72 is less or greater than @xmath12 .
in this section we first demonstrate that the heterogeneous absorbing configurations of the extended majority - vote model do persist in the thermodynamic limit and then we proceed with the characterization of the opinion domains ( clusters ) that fragment those configurations .
figure [ fig:3 ] illustrates one such a configuration for @xmath83 .
we recall that a cluster is simply a connected , bounded lattice region wherein the agents share the same opinion .
we focus on a few relevant statistical quantities to characterize the cluster organization , namely , the average number of clusters @xmath84 , the average size of the largest cluster @xmath85 , and the distribution of cluster sizes @xmath86 .
we must evaluate these quantities for different lattice sizes ( typically we use @xmath87 samples for each @xmath0 ) and then take an appropriate extrapolation procedure to infinite lattices ( @xmath88 ) . to simulate efficiently the extended majority - vote model for large lattices
we first make a list of the active agents .
an active agent is an agent whose opinion differs from the most frequent opinion among its extended neighborhood .
clearly , only active agents can change their opinions and so it is more efficient to select the target agent randomly from the list of active agents rather than from the entire lattice . in the case that the opinion of the target agent is modified by the majority - vote rule , we need to re - examine the active / inactive status of the target agent as well as of all its neighbors so as to update the list of active agents .
the dynamics is frozen when the list of active agents is empty .
the implementation of a similar procedure allowed the simulation of axelrod s model for very large lattices and the clarification of several issues regarding the stability of the heterogeneous absorbing configurations of that model @xcite .
we begin our analysis by presenting the dependence of the average number of clusters @xmath89 on the lattice area @xmath1 in fig .
[ fig:4 ] .
the increase of @xmath89 with increasing @xmath1 is the evidence that confirms that the extended majority - vote model exhibits heterogeneous absorbing configurations in the thermodynamic limit , @xmath11 .
more to the point , we find @xmath90 for the purpose of comparison , for frozen random configurations in which the @xmath1 sites are set to @xmath14 or @xmath13 with the same probability this ratio yields @xmath91 ( and so the average number of clusters scales linearly with the lattice area too ) .
we note that the reciprocal of the ratio given in eq .
( [ a_f1 ] ) is the average size of the clusters : @xmath92 for the extended majority - vote model and @xmath93 for random configurations .
although the mean size of a typical cluster is finite , there may be clusters whose sizes can become arbitrarily large as the lattice size increases . to investigate this point we show in fig .
[ fig:5 ] the average size of the largest cluster @xmath85 as function of the lattice area . as in the case of @xmath84 , the asymptotic scaling is revealed only for large lattices ( @xmath94 ) and it indicates that @xmath85 increases with @xmath95 for large @xmath0 . in the thermodynamic limit the relevant quantity is then @xmath96 we found that @xmath85 scales with @xmath95 for random configurations also , though the ratio @xmath97 is considerably smaller than the ratio given in eq .
( [ b_f1 ] ) .
it is interesting to note that the standard deviation @xmath98^{1/2 } $ ] tends to the constant value @xmath99 in the thermodynamic limit .
this amounts to a large but finite variance and so in order to satisfy the tchebycheff inequality the set of clusters whose size grows like @xmath2 must have measure zero in that limit .
since the probability that a randomly chosen site belongs to one such a cluster vanishes like @xmath100 , the measure of the set of diverging clusters will be vanishingly small if its cardinality is finite , i.e. , if only a finite number of clusters have sizes scaling with @xmath101 .
up to now we found no qualitative differences between the statistical properties of the clusters produced by the extended majority - vote rule or by assigning randomly the digits @xmath14 and @xmath13 to the sites of the square lattice .
in fact , for both types of configurations the quantities @xmath89 and @xmath102 exhibit the same scaling behavior with the lattice area @xmath1 .
however , a more detailed view of the cluster organization is given by the distribution @xmath86 of cluster sizes @xmath103 , which is shown in fig .
[ fig:6 ] for different lattice sizes .
the data seems to be remarkably well fitted by the power - law distribution @xmath104 for over more than three decades .
in addition , the figure indicates that the region where the power - law fitting holds increases with increasing @xmath0 .
this power - law distribution , however , is not compatible with our previous findings of finite values for the mean and variance of @xmath86 , since the distribution @xmath104 has infinite mean and variance . to answer this conundrum , in fig .
[ fig:7 ] we plot the same data using a semi - logarithmic scale instead of the log - log scale of fig .
[ fig:6 ] .
the results show that for large lattice sizes the distribution @xmath86 is in fact exponential , the power - law behavior being valid only in an intermediate range of cluster sizes .
the results for the larger lattice @xmath105 ( though not the results for the smaller lattices @xmath106 and @xmath107 ) show that the exponential distribution is not a mere cut - off inherent to the finitude of the lattices used in the simulations , as manifested by the straight - line appearance of @xmath86 revealed by the semi - log graph in the regime of large clusters . for the sake of comparison , in fig .
[ fig:8 ] we show the distribution of cluster sizes for frozen random configurations which can be well - described by the exponential distribution @xmath108 for large @xmath103 .
the puzzling power - law behavior found for intermediate values of @xmath103 in the extended majority - vote model is missing in this case . finally , it is interesting to note that , for any absorbing configuration of the extended majority - vote model , clusters of size @xmath14 are prohibited , clusters of sizes @xmath109 and @xmath16 are allowed at the sides of the square lattice only , and the only cluster of size @xmath17 allowed in the bulk of the lattice is that in which the four sites surrounding a unit cell are in the same state .
in fact , this elementary square cluster is the only structure capable to propagate through the lattice , i.e. , whenever a stable cluster is formed one such elementary square is formed .
a word is in order about the robustness of the heterogeneous absorbing configurations to the effect of noise , which allows the agents to oppose the opinion of the majority with some small probability .
more pointedly , after applying the update rule for each agent , which may or may not result in the change of its opinion , we flip its opinion with probability @xmath110 $ ] @xcite .
since in this case there are no absorbing configurations the notion of active sites is useless and so we implement the dynamics by picking lattice sites at random with the same probability
. then the unit of time ( a monte carlo step ) corresponds to the update of @xmath1 randomly chosen sites . for @xmath111 we present in fig .
[ fig:9 ] the time evolution of the fraction of sites in state @xmath14 , which we denote by @xmath33 as in sect .
[ sec : mf ] , for different values of the noise parameter @xmath112 but for the same initial configuration .
this figure , which exhibits the evolution of a single sample , shows the vulnerability of the heterogeneous absorbing configurations against a vanishingly amount of thermal noise if one gives enough time for thermalization .
for the small values of @xmath112 considered , the steady - state is close to one of the two homogeneous configurations , with all individuals exhibiting opinion @xmath13 or opinion @xmath14 .
the specific outcome is a stochastic process which depends on the choice of the initial configuration as well as on the sequence of random numbers used in the update rule .
this paper is motivated by the claim that the extended majority - vote model , for which the target site counts in the reckoning of the majority , exhibits a nontrivial multicultural regime , i.e. , heterogeneous absorbing configurations @xcite . from the perspective of the statistical physics
, we find this claim most intriguing , as we expect the model to behave similarly to the majority - vote models commonly considered in the physics literature , which are basically ising models with zero - temperature glauber kinetics @xcite , and so exhibit only two homogeneous absorbing configurations in the thermodynamic limit .
our first impression was that the heterogeneous absorbing configurations were artifacts of the small lattice size ( @xmath18 ) used or of some ` non - physical ' elements of the original model such as the nearest and next - nearest neighbors interactions ( moore neighborhood ) and the parallel update of the sites @xcite .
accordingly , we have modified the original model proposed by parisi et al . by introducing the usual nearest neighbors interactions ( von neumann neighborhood ) and the random sequential update of sites .
a careful finite size scaling analysis of a few relevant measures that characterize the absorbing configurations shows that the heterogeneous absorbing configurations not only persist in the thermodynamic limit but produce a tricky distribution of cluster sizes @xmath86 that decays as a power law @xmath104 for clusters of intermediate size @xmath103 and as an exponential for very large clusters sizes ( see figs .
[ fig:6 ] and [ fig:7 ] ) .
essentially , the reason for this somewhat unexpected outcome is the criterion of update in case of a tie for a site in the bulk of the lattice : the site remains unchanged rather than flipping to another state with probability @xmath12 as usually done in statistical mechanics models @xcite .
what is remarkable is that the existence of these heterogeneous absorbing configurations for the extended majority - vote model , as well as their absence in the more usual variants of that model , can actually be predicted analytically using the pair approximation : the multiple - clusters regime is signaled by the presence of an infinity of attractive fixed points of the mean - field equations .
we found that the statistical properties ( e.g. , average number of clusters , mean size of the largest cluster and the asymptotic distribution of cluster sizes ) of the clusters that break up the absorbing configurations ( see fig . [ fig:3 ] ) are qualitatively identical to those of random configurations .
this could also be inferred by the very short convergence times ( see dashed line in fig .
[ fig:9 ] ) which indicate that the absorbing configurations are very close to the initial random configurations , since a few lattice updates suffice to reach them .
we are not aware of any similar study of the statistical properties of the heterogeneous configurations of axelrod s model , so we can not compare the cluster organization of these two models .
our findings , which corroborate the results of parisi et al .
@xcite , shows that the extended majority - vote model does exhibit a ` multicultural ' regime , despite the fact that the update rule biases the agents to become more similar to each other .
a similar conclusion holds for axelrod s model as well @xcite , except that in axelrod s model the similarity is a prerequisite for interactions - the ` birds of a feather flock together ' hypothesis which states that individuals who are similar to each other are more likely to interact and then become even more similar @xcite .
( a similar assumption has been used to model the interspecies interactions in spin - glass like model ecosystem @xcite . )
the majority - vote model is considerably simpler and converges to the absorbing configurations much faster than axelrod s .
however , the ( short ) inventory of advantages stops here : in disagreement with the claim of parisi et al .
@xcite we found that the absorbing configurations of the extended majority - vote model are vulnerable to the noisy effect of flipping the opinions of the agents with some small probability .
it is well - known that this type of noise destabilizes the heterogeneous configurations of axelrod s model too @xcite .
of course , the extended majority - vote model lacks the main appealing feature of axelrod s model , namely , the existence of a non - equilibrium phase transition that separates the homogeneous and the polarized regimes in the thermodynamic limit . in that sense
it would be interesting to find out how a similar transition could be induced in the zero - temperature majority - vote model . | the existence of juxtaposed regions of distinct cultures in spite of the fact that people s beliefs have a tendency to become more similar to each other s as the individuals interact repeatedly is a puzzling phenomenon in the social sciences .
here we study an extreme version of the frequency - dependent bias model of social influence in which an individual adopts the opinion shared by the majority of the members of its extended neighborhood , which includes the individual itself .
this is a variant of the majority - vote model in which the individual retains its opinion in case there is a tie among the neighbors opinions .
we assume that the individuals are fixed in the sites of a square lattice of linear size @xmath0 and that they interact with their nearest neighbors only . within a mean - field framework
, we derive the equations of motion for the density of individuals adopting a particular opinion in the single - site and pair approximations .
although the single - site approximation predicts a single opinion domain that takes over the entire lattice , the pair approximation yields a qualitatively correct picture with the coexistence of different opinion domains and a strong dependence on the initial conditions .
extensive monte carlo simulations indicate the existence of a rich distribution of opinion domains or clusters , the number of which grows with @xmath1 whereas the size of the largest cluster grows with @xmath2 .
the analysis of the sizes of the opinion domains shows that they obey a power - law distribution for not too large sizes but that they are exponentially distributed in the limit of very large clusters .
in addition , similarly to other well - known social influence model axelrod s model we found that these opinion domains are unstable to the effect of a thermal - like noise . |
recent literature reports on many studies about the structural and dynamical properties of water confined in different environments .
@xcite the interest on this subject arises mainly from evidence of the relevance of the water - substrate interaction in determining either stability and enzymatic activity of proteins or swelling of clay minerals . in this respect
it is also important to elucidate to what extent water itself is significantly perturbed from its bulk behavior , when confined within a porous material , and in particular how far from the interface does the perturbation propagate through the liquid and whether it depends on the nature of the interaction ( hydrophilic or hydrophobic ) .
all the experimental studies of the dynamics of water molecules confined in different substrates agree in suggesting a slowing down of the translational single molecule motion @xcite compared to the bulk liquid phase , while the same kind of agreement is not found in the interpretation of structural data .
@xcite most neutron diffraction studies are indeed interpreted in terms of more extensive hydrogen bonding than in bulk water , at least in the water layers closer to the interface and below room temperature @xcite , contrarily to what found in a recent study performed by some of us .
@xcite as a matter of fact this study differs from previous ones in two relevant aspects : first , only in this case hydrogen / deuterium substitution in the neutron diffraction experiment was exploited , thus allowing the estimate of three site - site radial distribution functions ; second , full account of the excluded volume effects on the radial distribution functions was attempted for the first time .
although the limitations of the experimental technique do not allow to draw definitive and quantitative conclusions , nevertheless it was apparent from this study that water confined in porous vycor glass is still hydrogen bonded , but the bond network is strongly distorted even at room temperature .
the above mentioned experimental limitations are due to the presence of contributions to the measured cross section due to the cross correlations between water atoms and vycor atoms , which can not be isolated from the water - water correlations in the neutron diffraction experiment . as a consequence in the experiment
only three composite site - site distribution functions are accessible through the isotopic substitution , namely @xmath2 , @xmath3 , and @xmath4 , where the subscript @xmath5 stays for all hydrogen atoms in the sample ( either water hydrogens or protons bonded to the pore surface ) and @xmath6 labels all non substituted atoms ( i.e. water oxygens or vycor atoms ) .
@xcite information about the relative arrangement of water atoms may then be masked by the cross correlation terms : to extract this information from the experiment the hypothesis that the microscopic structure of confined water does not change upon changing the hydration state was proposed .
@xcite molecular dynamics ( md ) simulations on the contrary do not suffer from such limitations , as individual atomic species may be labelled and the corresponding distribution functions calculated , thus providing an useful test of the entire data analysis procedure .
to our knowledge , only a few md studies on the modifications of water structure and/or dynamics in the presence of a substrate interaction have been so far performed @xcite , for both hydrophobic or hydrophilic interactions .
all these studies indicate that water perturbations are both short ranged and relatively mild in magnitude
. however the investigated geometries may hardly be comparable with the extended and fractal - like network of thin cylindrical pores offered by vycor glass . since the nature of the substrate - water interaction along with the geometrical characteristics of the confinement may influence the structure of interstitial water@xcite , we present here a md simulation of tip4p water , confined in a cylindrical pore built inside a sio@xmath7 glass .
to model the cylindrical cavity of a porous glass , like corning vycor glass @xcite , we follow the method proposed by brodka and zerda @xcite in the simulation of liquid acetone in silica pores . a vitreous silica ( sio@xmath7 ) of 192 atoms is obtained by performing a md simulation with the empirical potential model of feuston and garofolini .
@xcite starting from a cristobalite crystalline structure @xcite , the system is melted at @xmath8 and then quenched to room temperature with the method described in ref . and .
since we need a cylindrical cavity of @xmath0 of diameter , which corresponds to the average size of the vycor glass pores , the small glass cell is repeated five times along the three directions in order to get a cubic cell of approximately @xmath9 atoms with a box lenght of @xmath10 .
we create a cavity inside the glass by removing the atoms lying within a distance @xmath11 from the @xmath12-axis .
then we remove from the cavity surface also the silicon atoms bonded to less than four oxygens .
this procedure leaves on the pore surface a number of _ non bridging _ oxygens ( nbo ) , i.e. oxygen atoms bonded to only one silicon , and is a reasonable replica of the industrial preparation of the sample .
@xcite surface oxygens bonded to two silicon atoms will be in the following referred to as _ bridging _ oxygens ( bo ) .
this nomenclature is in agreement with previous literature .
@xcite since in the experiment the nbo were saturated with protons prior to hydration , we attach extra hydrogen atoms to the nbo found on our simulation cell surface .
the surface hydrogens are placed at the equilibrium distance ( @xmath13 ) from a nbo with a si - o - h angle of @xmath14 .
we notice that the procedure described above generates a cavity with a rough surface , with geometry and size similar to the average ones in the real porous vycor glass .
the actual volume of the cavity , @xmath15 , generated inside our simulation box is indeed unknown and only roughly approximated to a lower value by the volume of a cylinder of radius @xmath11 . in the simulation
we use the model tip4p
@xcite for water .
water molecules interact with the substrate atoms with a potential modeled according to ref . , where different lennard - jones ( lj ) parameters and fractional charges are assumed for bo and nbo .
silicon and surface hydrogen atoms interact only via coulombic forces with the charged water sites .
lj parameters and fractional charges for the @xmath1 sites and tip4p water are given in table 1 .
the cross lj parameters are calculated with the usual lorentz - berthelot rules . during the simulation the substrate atoms and the surface hydrogens do not move .
periodic boundary conditions are applied only along the axis of the cylinder ( @xmath12-direction ) .
all the pair interactions are truncated at a cutoff radius of @xmath16 and reaction field corrections are applied . @xcite the number of particles to use is determined by the density of the confined water at full hydration in the neutron diffraction experiment @xcite ,
i.e. @xmath17 corresponding to @xmath18 molecules .
the simulation starts with the centers of the molecules placed in a fcc lattice , where the occupied nodes are randomly chosen .
the size of the lattice is such that it is contained in the cylindrical pore .
the origin of the coordinates is assumed in the middle of the cylinder axis .
the initial velocities are chosen randomly with a distribution consistent with the required temperature .
the equation of motions are solved with the popular quaternion - leapfrog algorithm due to fincham .
@xcite confined water is melted at @xmath19 and then equilibrated at @xmath20 .
initially a very small time step of @xmath21 is used then it is slowly increased .
we find that for time steps larger than @xmath22 we need a too frequent rescaling of the temperature , so the final runs are done with a time step of @xmath23 .
the calculation of the forces during the simulation is performed with a neighbour list built by using a cell method @xcite , thus allowing the simulation to be run on an alpha station .
the calculation of the site - site radial distribution functions of confined water is motivated by the possibility of comparing with the experimental results recently obtained with the use of the isotopic substitution technique in neutron diffraction experiments .
@xcite on the other hand the site - site distribution functions can be easily calculated from computer simulation , when periodic boundary conditions are applied in all three directions , but in our case , where the system is confined in a cylindrical box one must carefully take care of the excluded volume effects , as discussed recently by ref . and . as a matter of fact the radial distribution functions obtained either experimentally or by simulation for a confined liquid can not readily compare with those of the corresponding bulk , due to the existence of regions , where the liquid is not allowed . in this case
indeed the radial distribution function of a system of non interacting particles , the so called _ uniform fluid _ , is not equal to unity at all @xmath24 values , but approaches its asymptotic value with a profile which depends on the size and shape of the confining volume . as a consequence
the site - site distribution functions of the interacting liquid , which are defined with respect to that of the uniform fluid , do not lay on a flat profile and the amplitude of their oscillations may also show a trivial @xmath24-dependence .
@xcite our md results could directly compare with the experimental data of ref . only if the simulation box was topologically identical to the real vycor glass sample and if the site - site distribution functions of tip4p water were correctly reproducing those of real bulk water .
since both conditions are only approximately matched , we will perform the corrections for the excluded volume effects on our md calculated site - site distribution functions , to compare the corrected ones with those of tip4p bulk water .
the aim of this comparison will be to test whether we observe the same qualitative modifications with respect to bulk water observed in ref . .
from the configurations obtained in the molecular dynamics simulation one can calculate for each site of type @xmath25 , placed in the origin of the reference frame , the number of sites of type @xmath26 lying inside a spherical shell @xmath27 of thickness @xmath28 at distance @xmath24 from the origin and obtain the average number of site pairs @xmath29 .
following the usual recipes @xcite , regardless of the confinement inside an almost cylindrical volume , the computer simulated distribution function is then calculated as @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the number of @xmath26 sites .
the results obtained for the @xmath32 functions are shown in figs .
1a - 1c .
they are compared with the same functions obtained in a simulation , where water is purely confined in the cylindrical pore without any interaction with the substrate atoms .
the large difference between the intensity of the first peaks of the two oxygen - oxygen @xmath33 functions indicates that switching on the interaction with the substrate atoms is equivalent to enhance the confinement effects .
the same trend is observed for the other functions and particularly in the oxygen - hydrogen @xmath34 one , where the so called hydrogen bond peak at @xmath35 is strongly enhanced .
however , as we will see below , this is not an evidence of an increase of the number of hydrogen bonds in the confined system , but a trivial effect of the geometrical confinement .
@xcite from the figs .
1a - 1c it is clear that in the limit of large @xmath24 all three site - site correlation functions of confined water go below the exact limit of unity .
this is a finite size effect due to the absence of periodic boundary conditions along the @xmath36 and @xmath37 directions .
as already stated the site - site correlation functions ( [ defgmd ] ) calculated in the computer simulation represent the fluctuations of the density with respect to a _ uniform _ density profile , which is not a constant as in non confined systems .
thus to obtain the corrected site - site distribution functions of water inside the pore @xmath38 to be compared with those of the corresponding bulk liquid , we calculate , following ref . and
: @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the _ pair correlation function _ of the confined uniform fluid . at variance with the experiment , in the present computer simulation
, water is confined in a single pore , thus neglecting the correlation between water molecules residing in different pores , nevertheless the molecular dynamics results can be corrected using the same basic results of ref . and .
in particular the function @xmath40 can be obtained from the fourier transform of the form factor of a cylinder .
@xcite moreover to evaluate eq .
( [ gwwdef ] ) one has to take into account that the function @xmath32 is not known behind @xmath41 and its asymptotic behaviour is not reliable , a problem already considered in the experiment where the @xmath42 limit of the structure factors are not available .
@xcite before commenting the md results after correction for excluded volume effects , and comparing these with bulk water results , it is useful to remind the qualitative differences between bulk and confined water evidenced in ref . .
the water - water distribution function for the oxygen atoms of confined water @xmath43 has the first peak at @xmath44 as in the bulk , although sharper and less intense , while the second peak is shifted towards @xmath45 .
only minor differences are apparent in the distribution function of water oxygens and water+vycor hydrogens , @xmath46 , with respect to the @xmath47 of bulk water .
in particular the h - bond peak has almost the same intensity in both liquids , although in the confined case it is sharper , and some excess intensity is visible between the two main peaks .
the hydrogen - hydrogen distribution function of water sites , @xmath48 , shows on the contrary a dramatic increase of the first peak at @xmath49 , while the second one is almost completely washed out .
all these results suggest that confined water is still h - bonded , nevertheless the orientational correlations between neighbouring water molecules are strongly influenced by the confinement , resulting in a highly distorted network of bonds .
as far as the water - vycor cross distribution functions are concerned , only the distribution functions of water oxygens and vycor atoms ( regardless of any distinction between oxygen and silicon ) , @xmath50 , and that of vycor atoms and water hydrogens , @xmath51 , were extracted from the experiment .
the first one shows an intense peak at @xmath44 , followed by a second peak at @xmath52 ; the second one shows modulations , with very low intensity at @xmath53 and @xmath45 . in fig .
2a - 2c we show the results obtained with a procedure similar to the one adopted in ref . , in order to perform the corrections for the excluded volume effects . due to the approximations involved in the derivation ,
our functions are not reliable below the minimum approach distances , evidenced in fig .
2a - 2c by the arrows .
the site - site correlation functions of the bulk tip4p water at the density @xmath54 are also shown in the same figures : although this density does not correspond to a physical state for bulk water at ambient conditions , nevertheless we prefer this state as a reference , to avoid confusion of density effects with those due to confinement . the oxygen - oxygen site - site distribution function ( fig .
2a ) shows a first peak , which is lower in amplitude and sharper than in bulk water , in agreement with the experiment .
moreover there is an evident increase of intensity in the region between @xmath55 : an indication of a distortion of the hydrogen bond network found also in the experiment .
@xcite as far as the @xmath56 function is concerned , we notice a dramatic change of the amplitude of the second peak and of the first minimum , in comparison with bulk water , while only minor modifications of the h - bond peak seem to occur .
this results suggest that while the average number of h - bonds , as measured by the integral under the first peak , does not sensibly change , the orientational order of neighbouring water molecules is strongly distorted in the confined geometry .
the comparison with the experiment is not straightforward in this case , since neutrons can not distinguish between water protons and protons bonded to nbo .
nevertheless we notice that also the experimental data do not evidence enhancements of the amplitude of the h - bond peak and that the disagreement found with our simulation as far as the amplitude of the second peak is concerned may , at least partly , be due to the protons on the cavity surface , contributing with a broad peak between @xmath57 and @xmath58 ( see fig .
3a ) . moreover in fig .
2b we notice that the peak around @xmath59 , i.e. where the surface hydrogen contribution is already very low according to fig .
3a , is in agreement with the experimental results .
the @xmath48 function ( fig .
2c ) confirms the strong distortion of the orientational order , since the amplitudes of both first and second peaks decrease and the first minimum shifts towards lower @xmath24 values . on the other hand
this is the distribution function with the worst agreement with the experiment .
such disagreement may be ascribed to the potential model or to the approximation made in ref . to extract the water - water contribution from the measured structure factors ( i.e. weak dependence on the hydration state ) .
the site - site distribution functions of the substrate atoms with respect to the water atoms can be obtained along the same procedure described for the @xmath60 using eq .
( [ gwwdef ] ) , with the appropriate substrate - water uniform fluid function @xmath61 .
since the substrate atoms are confined in a region between the cylinder surface and the surface of the total simulation cell of lenght @xmath62 , we assume that @xmath61 is the fourier transform of the difference between the form factor of the cylinder of diameter @xmath62 and the form factor of the internal cylinder with the diameter @xmath63 . in fig .
3b we show the results for @xmath64 and @xmath65 .
the behaviour of this functions agrees with the experiment , particularly the positions of the first peak in both functions are located close to the experimental results . in conclusion
our simulation agrees with the experiment at a qualitative level : both techniques suggest indeed that the h - bond network is strongly distorted in confined water , although this does not necessarily imply strong enhancement or depression of the h - bond peak .
in order to gain a better insight into the microscopic structure of the confined water , we perform a careful analysis of the configurations obtained in molecular dynamics .
we divide the cylindrical pore in ten concentric radial shells , the @xmath66 shell being defined by @xmath67 where @xmath68 .
first of all we look at the average density in each shell . from fig . 4 we see that the density profile is not constant along the @xmath69 coordinate , and that it takes a value similar to that of bulk water at ambient conditions in the first layer , i.e. the one closer to the center of the cylinder .
the density slowly decreases going towards the cylinder surface and abruptely increases at layer n. @xmath70 , close to the substrate surface .
the last layer ( n. @xmath71 ) is in the volume excluded by the lj repulsion .
it is interesting to compare this result with the calculation performed with the substrate - water interaction switched off . in this latter case
the density is essentially constant up to layer n. @xmath72 and decreases in the last two layers .
the effect of the interaction is thus to attract few water molecules , mainly from layers @xmath73 and @xmath72 , to the surface , as shown by the density increase at layer n.@xmath70 .
the disturbance , brought into the density profile by the presence of an interacting surface , seems to extend up to no more than @xmath74 from the surface itself .
moreover we notice that the potential model used here , gives a modest hydrophilic effect , in comparison with ref . ; this may also depend on the geometrical simmetry of the interface , as already apparent from ref . .
at all layers , except the @xmath71-th , the density is higher than its average value of @xmath17 , due to the size of the lj diameters .
this qualitatively explains why experimentally one finds for confined water a lower average density than for bulk water .
@xcite on the other hand this finding needs a deeper investigation , because it may be dependent on both the potential model and the simulation technique adopted . in particular one should investigate whether in a nve simulation the system tries to build up a kind of bulk phase at contact with the confined phase , due to the simultaneous constraints of a constant number of particles and a constant volume .
different computer simulation methods , where one allows the system to change density during the simulation @xcite , could help to clarify this point . in fig .
5 we report the average number of hb in each shell ( solid line ) , as calculated according to a geometrical definition .
@xcite we consider two water molecules as being hydrogen bonded if their o - o separation is less than @xmath75 , their closest o - h separation is less than @xmath49 and the @xmath76 angle @xmath77 is less than @xmath78 . as seen from fig .
5 the number of hb almost monotonically decreases approaching the interface ; in particular in the layer n. @xmath70 , where the density is highest , the number of hb goes below its density - weighted average value ( dotted line in the figure ) .
when the substrate - water interaction is turned off the number of hb is essentially constant up to the @xmath70-th layer and decreases , as also the density does , in the last two layers .
the comparison of the two profiles in fig .
5 reveals that the pure geometrical confinement is responsible for the reduction of the number of hb at the interface ; switching on the interaction does not sensibly modify this number , although the density at layer n.@xmath70 increases .
conversely , in the layers closer to the center of the pore , where the density reaches that of ambient water , even the number of hb approaches the values typical of bulk water at ambient conditions .
the reduction of the number of hb in the intermediate layers seems also to be a density effect .
6a and 6b report the distributions of hb and the distribution of @xmath79 respectively .
the histograms of fig .
6a broaden and shift towards zero , approaching the pore surface , and also the distribution of @xmath79 markedly broadens for layer @xmath70 , compared with layers @xmath80 and @xmath81 . the pattern of hb in the @xmath70-th layer is severely disordered due to the orientational constraints , brought by the presence of a confinement .
we notice that the results found for the internal layers can not be distinguished from those for the bulk and the disturbance brought by the confinement in an interacting substrate extends up to @xmath74 from the interface .
we have also calculated the number of hb between the water molecules , located in layers @xmath70 and @xmath71 , and the hydrogens and oxygen atoms belonging to the cavity surface .
this analysis , although biased by the low statistics , indicates that the number of such bonds is very low in the present simulation .
the results obtained by md simulation of tip4p water confined in a cylindrical @xmath1 pore have been compared with those of the simulation of the same liquid after switching off the interaction with the substrate atoms and with those of the corresponding bulk liquid .
the first comparison indicates that the absence of periodic boundary conditions and the cylindrical simmetry of the confining volume are by themselves able to induce a significant distortion of the orientational order of water molecules , although leaving the density profile almost flat behind the shell closest to the interface . indeed switching on the interaction with the substrate produces only an enhancement of the modulations of the distribution functions at short distances , without emergence of any new feature .
moreover when the interaction with the substrate is switched on , the competition between water - water and water - substrate interaction produces a minimum in the density profile at intermediate distances from the cavity surface on one side and the condensation of a _ water drop _ in the middle of the pore .
this effect , although quite reasonable , may depend on the model and on the simulation technique and , as already stated , deserves a deeper investigation .
the observed phenomenon is accompained by the occurence of a dishomogeneous distribution of the h - bonds throughout the pore .
while the water drop in the middle of the pore seems to have almost the same distribution of h - bonds as its bulk liquid , the average number of bonds decreases going towards the interface and its distribution becomes broader .
it is noticeable that even in the shell closest to the interface , when the density reaches its maximum value , the average number of h - bonds is much lower than everywhere else .
this suggests that the main effect of the confinement is to disturb the orientational arrangement of molecules to such an extent that a continuous network of bonds is not favoured up to distances from the interface of the order of @xmath74 approximately .
as far as the intermolecular structure of water is concerned , the site - site distribution functions give only an average picture of the system .
for this reason the h - bond peak of the @xmath82 function is not dramatically different from that of bulk tip4p water , nevertheless it is clearly apparent from the comparison of all the three site - site distribution functions in fig .
2 with their counterpart for the bulk liquid that the h - bond network is strongly distorted and that a number of interstitial ( i.e. non h - bonded ) neighbouring molecules must be present .
this result is in qualitative agreement with the experimental findings of ref . , although the distortion of the h - h correlation in that case seems more dramatic .
however we must bear in mind that on one side md results are model dependent and on the other side the experimental results were obtained assuming a weak hydration dependence of the partial structure factors , an hypothesis which deserves confirmation . as a matter of fact this md study will continue to understand how the water structure depends on the hydration level . a further comment on the potential model is mandatory .
this model for the water - substrate interaction seems to be weakly hydrophilic . as a matter of fact the density in the water layer closest to the substrate increases only by the @xmath83
this may be due to the balance between the lj repulsive interaction and the coulombic forces , as suggested also by the low number of bonds between water oxygens and protons bonded to nbo .
s. h. chen , and m. c. bellissent - funel , hydrogen bond networks , edited by m. c. bellissent - funel and j. c. dore , nato asi series
c : mathematical and physical science , * 435 * , 337 ( kluwer academic publishers , 1994 ) .
p. j. rossky , hydrogen bond networks , edited by m. c. bellissent - funel and j .c .
dore , nato asi series c : mathematical and physical science , * 435 * , 337 ( kluwer academic publishers , 1994 ) , and references therein .
lldddddd & & @xmath84 & @xmath85 & q & x & y & z + & site & @xmath86 & ( k ) & @xmath87 & @xmath86 & @xmath86 & @xmath86 + water&o & 3.154 & 78.0 & 0.0 & 0.0 & -0.06556 & 0.0 + & h & 0.0 & 0.0 & 0.52 & 0.75695&0.52032&0.0 + & h & 0.0 & 0.0 & 0.52 & -0.75695&0.52032&0.0 + & x & 0.0 & 0.0 & -1.04 & 0.0 & 0.0844 & 0.0 + silica & si&0.0 & 0.0 & 1.283 & & & + & bo&2.70 & 230.0 & -0.629 & & & + & nbo&3.00 & 230.0 & -0.533 & & & + & hs & 0.0 & 0.0 & 0.206 & & & + * figure 1 * - computer simulated site - site distribution functions , calculated according to eq . 1 .
solid line represents distribution functions obtained by considering water confined in a interacting silica cavity ; dashed line represents distribution functions of water confined in the same cavity but without any interaction with the substrate atoms . * a ) * oxygen - oxygen distribution function .
* b ) * oxygen - hydrogen distribution function .
* c ) * hydrogen - hydrogen distribution function .
* figure 2 * - computer simulated distribution functions , calculated according to eq .
( 2 ) , for confined water ( solid lines ) .
these functions have been corrected taking into account excluded volume effects , as explained in the text , and are compared with results obtained for bulk tip4p water ( dashed lines ) . due to the approximations involved in the derivation ( see text ) the corrected functions are not reliable below the minimum approach distances , indicated by the arrow . *
a ) * oxygen - oxygen distribution function .
* b ) * oxygen - hydrogen distribution function .
* c ) * hydrogen - hydrogen distribution function .
* figure 4 * - layer analysis of the density profile of confined water as a function of distance from the center of the pore , calculated with the substrate - water interaction turned on ( solid line ) and off ( dashed line ) .
* figure 5 * - layer analysis of the number of hydrogen bonds ( @xmath92 ) as a function of distance from the center of the pore , calculated with the substrate - water interaction turned on ( solid line ) and off ( dashed line ) .
the orizontal dotted line represents the density - weighted average value of @xmath92 for confined water with the substrate - water interaction turned on . | a molecular dynamics simulation of water confined in a silica pore is performed in order to compare it with recent experimental results on water confined in porous vycor glass at room temperature .
a cylindrical pore of @xmath0 is created inside a vitreous @xmath1 cell , obtained by computer simulation .
the resulting cavity offers to water a rough hydrophilic surface and its geometry and size are similar to those of a typical pore in porous vycor glass .
the site - site distribution functions of water inside the pore are evaluated and compared with bulk water results .
we find that the modifications of the site - site distribution functions , induced by confinement , are in qualitative agreement with the recent neutron diffraction experiment , confirming that the disturbance to the microscopic structure of water mainly concerns orientational arrangement of neighbouring molecules .
a layer analysis of md results indicates that , while the geometrical constraint gives an almost constant density profile up to the layers closest to the interface , with an uniform average number of hydrogen bonds ( hb ) , the hydrophilic interaction produces the wetting of the pore surface at the expenses of the adjacent water layers .
moreover the orientational disorder togheter with a reduction of the average number of hb persists in the layers close to the interface , while water molecules cluster in the middle of the pore at a density and with a coordination similar to bulk water . |
since the discovery of gamma - ray burst ( grb ) afterglows in the late 90 s @xcite , these energetic phenomena have been targets of observational efforts at essentially all electromagnetic wavelengths .
the wealth of available information put severe constraints on the various families of interpretative scenarios , showing an unexpected richness and complexity of possible behaviors @xcite .
the first observations at mev - gev energies , with the energetic gamma - ray experiment telescope ( egret ) on - board the compton gamma - ray observatory ( cgro ) @xcite , showed that the observations in the high energy ( he : 1 mev-30 gev ) and in the very high energy range ( vhe : 30 gev - 30 tev ) can be powerful diagnostic tools for the emission processes and physical conditions of grbs . the launch of _ fermi _
@xcite , with its large area telescope ( lat ) @xcite , showed that , at least for the brightest events , gev emission from grbs is a relatively common phenomenon @xcite confirming that our comprehension of grb physics is still unsatisfactory . in this context
, multiple efforts have been performed in grbs observations by the new generation of ground - based imaging atmospheric cherenkov telescopes ( iacts ) , such as magic , hess or veritas . in all cases
only upper limits have been derived .
the two most limiting factors are the heavily attenuation of the vhe signal by pair - production due to the interactions with the lower energetic photons of the extragalactic background light ( ebl ) @xcite and the delay of the observations . within this scenario , magic has the advantage , compared to other iacts , in its low energy sensitivity and pointing speed @xcite . throughout the paper
the convention @xmath1 has been adopted in cgs units .
grb090102 was detected and located by the _
swift _ satellite @xcite on january 02 , 2009 at 02:55:45 ut @xcite .
the prompt light curve is structured in four partially overlapping peaks for a total @xmath2 of @xmath3 s. since the burst was also detected by _
konus wind _
@xcite and _ integral _
@xcite , it has been possible to obtain a very good reconstruction of the prompt emission spectral parameters . the time - averaged spectrum can be modeled with the classical band function @xcite with peak energy @xmath4 kev and a total fluence in the 20 kev - 2 mev range of @xmath5 erg @xmath6 @xcite .
early optical follow - up measurements were performed by many groups like tarot @xcite at @xmath7 + 40.8 s , the rem robotic telescope at @xmath7 + 53 s @xcite and grond telescope @xcite at @xmath7 + 2.5 h. the optical light - curve , monitored from several tens of seconds to slightly more than a day from the @xmath7 , shows a steep - to - shallow behavior with a break at about 1ks . before the break ,
the optical flux decay index is @xmath8 while the index became @xmath9 after the break , steeper and flatter respectively , when compared to the simultaneous x - ray emission .
optical spectroscopy was rapidly carried out by the not telescope @xcite deriving a redshift of z=1.547 , which allows to compute an isotropic energy value of @xmath10 erg and a rest frame peak energy of @xmath11=1149@xmath12 kev in good agreement with the amati relation .
a detailed discussion of the follow up observations for this burst can be found in @xcite .
the magic telescope located at roque de los muchachos ( 28.75@xmath13n , 17.89@xmath13w , la palma , canary islands ) performed a follow - up measurement of grb090102 starting the observation at the position provided by _ swift _
( ra : 08h 33 m 02s ; dec : 33@xmath13 05 29 ) at 03:14:52 ut at @xmath14 s. data presented in this paper have been taken before november 2009 , when magic was operating as a single telescope .
first data runs were taken at very low zenith angles from 5@xmath13 reaching 52@xmath13 at the end of datataking at 06:54:01 ut after 13149 s of observation .
magic upper limits above 80 gev have already been published for this grb @xcite while results and scientific discussion about a successive dedicated analysis focused in the low energy band @xcite will be presented here . to ensure the lowest energy threshold , only data taken with zenith distance @xmath15 25@xmath13 ,
corresponding to the first 5919 s of observation ( data sub - sample up to 04:53:32 ut ) has been taken into account during this analysis .
together with the magic-1 sum trigger system @xcite , it yields an analysis threshold around 30 gev evaluated using mc simulations . in order to accurately estimate the background from hadronic atmospheric showers , an off data sample has been taken one night later with the telescope pointing close to the burst location and in the same observational conditions and instrument setup . in spite of the excellent magic low energy analysis threshold , no significant
excess of gamma - ray photons has been detected from a position consistent with grb090102 .
differential upper limits with 95@xmath16 cl were evaluated .
telescope efficiency was evaluated with a 30@xmath16 estimation of systematic uncertainties .
however , the excellent low energy threshold for ground - based observations with cherenkov telescopes makes these observations particularly interesting in spite of the high redshift of grb090102 .
.magic - i 95@xmath16 confidence level upper limits for the afterglow emission of grb090102 .
the values correspond to the first 5919 s of observation from 03:14:52 ut to 04:53:32 ut for a zenith distance ranging between 5@xmath13 and 25@xmath13 . [ cols="^,^,^ " , ]
in the so - called standard scenario , known as the fireball model @xcite , grb dynamics during the prompt phase are governed by relativistic collisions between shells of plasma emitted by a central engine ( internal shocks ) .
similarly , the emission during the afterglow is thought to be connected to the shocks between these ejecta with the external medium ( external shocks ) . in both cases , the observed photons
are radiation from particles accelerated to ultrarelativistic energies by successive collisions with magnetized medium ( fermi mechanism ) . even if the details of the acceleration process are not firmly known , several non - thermal mechanisms
have been suggested to be sources of vhe photons .
possible processes comprise both leptonic ( e.g. electron synchrotron , synchrotron self compton - ssc ) and hadronic models ( e.g. proton synchrotron ) @xcite . in the most plausible scenario ,
electron synchrotron radiation is the dominant process in the low energy regime ( @xmath15 mev ) while ssc emission overwhelm other processes in the vhe range . as first approximation
, a broken power - law can be used in modeling the expected emission .
the relevant break energies of the spectrum will be the minimum injection @xmath17 and the cooling @xmath18 .
the first one refers to emission frequency of the bulk of the electrons population while the cooling frequency identifies where electrons effectively cool .
both are strongly dependent on the microphysical parameters used to describe the fireball and for the ssc are ( following @xcite ) : @xmath19\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath20\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath21 the medium particle density , @xmath22 is the energy per unit solid angle , @xmath23 the time delay after the grb onset ( in hours ) and @xmath24 is the source redshift .
the slope of the electron energy distribution ( @xmath25 ) can be evaluated using the optical spectral index light - curve @xcite and has been found to be @xmath26 in good agreement with numerical simulations which suggest a value of @xmath25 ranging between 2.2 - 2.3 @xcite . on the contrary , we can only constrain the values for the micro - physical parameters @xmath27 , the fraction of total energy going to electrons , and @xmath28 , the fraction of total energy going to magnetic fields . assuming that the optical light curve time break @xcite is less then the start time of the shallow decay phase ( @xmath29 s ) , we obtain @xmath30 and @xmath31 which only barely fix the @xmath28 , @xmath27 values .
we thus assume @xmath32 and @xmath33 which correspond to typical values for the late afterglow @xcite
. + gamma ray absorption by pair production with extragalactic background light ( ebl ) limits the iacts capability in detecting sources at redshift @xmath341 .
we adopted the model in @xcite to evaluate the ebl absorption .
the ebl intensity evaluated using this model matches the minimum level allowed by galaxy counts , which leads to the highest transparency of the universe to vhe @xmath35-rays .
this is indeed an optimistic yet realistic scenario for grbs studies in the vhe regime . as a matter of fact
, we have obtained a value for the optical depth @xmath36 of @xmath37 at about 40 gev .
this gives an attenuation of the flux at the same energy of the order of @xmath38 , a value that does not significantly compromise the detection capability of magic .
we have used the above derived equations in order to predict the expected emission in the magic energy range . from numerical results
it is evident that , for both the chosen parameters and at the magic observation time , leptonic components are usually the dominant mechanisms from the low ( electron synchrotron emission ) to the very high energy ( ssc ) .
magic observations ( @xmath0 40 gev ) were carried out in the sed region where @xmath39f@xmath40 so that it is possible to evaluate the expected ssc emission : @xmath41 which gives ( for our first energy bin and taking into account the ebl absorption ) @xmath42(40 gev)@xmath43 erg @xmath6 s@xmath44 .
this result is below of about one order of magnitude ( in the first energy bins ) to the reported upper limits .
however , a change in the microphysical fireball values can influence the vhe emission giving scenarios with substantially higher flux .
we also explored the possibility of a strong and prevalent proton synchrotron component in the gev range .
the cooling frequency for protons can in fact easily reach the gev regime since @xmath45 .
however , the required energy budget ( @xmath46 erg ) and medium density ( @xmath47 @xmath48 ) needed to match the expected low energy flux with observed data is rather incompatible with the measured total energy release .
this makes the possibility to observe the hadronic emission component with the magic telescope unrealistic , at least for a canonical fireball .
other hadronic - induced emissions such as @xmath49 decay @xcite can have a non negligible effect with new features in the spectrum in a higher energies range .
moreover , at these energies , @xmath50 , implying that lowering the temporal delay of the observations can make the expected emission higher by one order of magnitude .
our estimates show that magic follow - up observations within few hundreds of seconds from the t@xmath51 would have the potential to detect this source .
this demonstrates both the capabilities of the system and the necessity of a fast - response observations .
although we could not yet set firm constraints on the main theoretical scenarios , our results show the interesting perspectives for an afterglow detection in very high energy domain .
this energy range will have very high impact on the understanding of the grb phenomena and the unique opportunity of having simultaneous follow - up with _ fermi_/lat and the magic telescope will have an important role in constraining different emission mechanisms and the space parameters . +
the above results will be discussed in a forthcoming dedicated publication together with the fermi / lat data .
we would like to thank the instituto de astrofisica de canarias for the excellent working conditions at the observatorio del roque de los muchachos in la palma .
the support of the german bmbf and mpg , the italian infn and spanish micinn is gratefully acknowledged .
this work was also supported by eth research grant th 34/043 , by the polish mniszw grant n n203 390834 , and by the yip of the helmholtz gemeinschaft .
+ 9 costa , e. et al . , 1997 ,
nature , 387 , 783 gehrels , n. , ramirez - ruiz , e. , fox , d.b .
, 2009 , a&a , 47 , 567 hurley , k. et al . , 1994 ,
nature 372 , 652 band , d. l. , axelsson , m. , baldini , l. , et al .
, 2009 , apj , 701 , 1673 atwood , w. b. et al . , 2009 , apj , 697 , 1071 granot , j. et al . , 2010 , arxiv/1003.2452 nikishov , a. i. , 1962 , sov .
jetp , 14 , 393 garczarczyk , m. et al .
, 2009 , arxiv/0907.1001 gehrels , n. et al . , 2004 ,
apj , 611 , 1005 mangano , v. et al . , 2009a , gcn 8762 golenetskii , s. et al . , 2009 ,
gcn 8776 mangano v. et al . ,
2009 , gcn report 192.1 band , d. et al . , 1993 ,
apj , 413 , 281 klotz , a. et al . , 2009 , gcn 8761 covino , s. et al . , 2009 ,
gcn 8763 afonso , p. et al . , 2009 , gcn 8771 de ugarte postigo a. et al . , 2009 ,
gcn 8766 gendre , b. et al . , 2010 , mnras , 405 , 2372 gaug , m. et al . , 2009 ,
gcn 8816 gaug , m. et al . , 2009 , proceeding of the 31st icrc albert , j. et al .
, ( magic collaboration ) 2008 , sci , 322 , 5905 pacz@xmath52skj , b. , 1986 , apj , 308 , l43 zhang , b. , meszaros , p. 2001 , apj 559 , 110 vietri , m. , 2003 , apj , 591 , 954 melandri , a. , et al . , 2010 , apj , 723 , 1331 yost , s.a . ,
harrison , f.a . ,
sari , r. , frail , d.a .
, 2003 , apj , 597 , 459 domnguez , a. et al .
, 2011 , mnras , 410 , 2556d bttcher , m. , dermer , c.d . , 1998 ,
apj , 499 , 131 | hints for a gev component in the emission from grbs are known since the egret observations during the 90s and they have been recently confirmed by the data of the fermi satellite .
these results have , however , shown that a fully satisfactory interpretative framework of the grb phenomena is still lacking .
the magic telescope opens the possibility to extend the measurement of grbs in the several tens up to hundreds of gev energy range . from the theoretical point of view
, both leptonic and hadronic processes have been suggested to explain the possible gev / tev counterpart of grbs .
observations with ground - based telescopes of very high energy photons ( e@xmath030 gev ) from these sources are going to play a key role in discriminating among the different proposed emission mechanisms which are barely distinguishable at lower energies .
magic telescope observations of the grb090102 ( z=1.547 ) field from 03:14:52 ut to 06:54:01 ut are analyzed to derive upper limits to the gev / tev emission .
we compare these results to the expected emissions evaluated for different processes in the framework of the standard fireball model .
the results we obtained are compatible with the expected emission but can not yet set further constraints on the theoretical scenario .
however , the difficulty in modeling the low energy data for this event makes it difficult to fix in an unambiguous way the physical parameters which describe the fireball .
nonetheless , the magic telescope , thanks to its low energy threshold and fast repositioning , is opening for the first time the possibility to fill the energy gap between space - based gamma detectors and the ground - based measurements .
this will makes possible grbs multiwavelength studies in the very high energy domain . |
it is widely acknowledged that theoretical research and applications development evolve at different speeds , driven by different aims .
research theory investigates new problems and new ideas , taking its time to study different solutions that tackle problems from different points of view .
it often happens that while deeply studying one of these solutions , new ideas or entirely new problems emerge , opening the way to entirely new ( sub)theories . the development of applications , instead , is much more oriented towards effective solutions .
moreover , the choice between different solutions is often dictated by technology constraints or market constraints such as cost - effectiveness and rapid productivity .
the ( relative ) low speed and the wide scope of the theory often result in a ( relative ) lack of integration of results .
the theoretical outcomes of research are so abundant that their integration and assimilation is quite hard .
nevertheless , incorporating different results under a unifying or coherent view , both formally and epistemologically , would be of great help for the progress of the knowledge .
on the other hand , the speedy development of application solutions tends to miss the opportunities offered by theoretical results that have been already established but not yet fully applied .
while the percolation of theoretical results into applications intrinsically requires some time , it is helpful to remind taking a look from theory towards applications and from applications to theory every so often . this paper
is then written in this spirit .
we examine the history of popular programming languages to expose how concurrency has been incorporated into the mainstream programming .
this excursus is not meant to be a survey of concurrent languages ; it would be very incomplete in that sense .
we aim instead at identifying a number of historical landmarks and crucial concepts that shaped the development of programming languages .
moreover , rather than fully describing these major points , we focus on their connection under an evolutionary perspective , using the biological theory of evolution as an instructive metaphor .
we then borrow the evolutionary talking from biology , using it as an explanatory tool to more deeply reflect on some concepts and to stimulate the development of meta - knowledge about the history of programming languages .
[ [ structure - of - the - paper ] ] structure of the paper + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + in section 2 we start our excursus of the history of popular programming languages from an evolutionary perspective .
we first examine the general development process , and we then deep into some language , trying to uncover evolutionary lineages related to specific programming traits . in section 3
we consider concurrency abstractions : we put forward three different concurrency models used in mainstream programming , emphasizing the fact that they correspond to three different levels of explanation .
the evolutionary excursus is then completed in section 4 with a discussion of the impact of the clouds and big data technologies in programming languages . in section 5
we discuss the role of the theoretical research in the evolutionary scenario , putting forward its ability of promoting and testing language mutations .
we conclude in section 6 with final comments .
the research about programming languages can be described in many different ways .
an interesting approach is looking at languages in a timeline perspective , trying to grasp the evolutionary process that guided ( or that unfolded behind ) the fortune of mainstream programming languages .
it has been suggested ( e.g.,@xcite ) that information technology innovations occur mainly through the combination of previous technologies .
even living structures are the result of a widespread reuse and combination of available elements , but in biology established solutions are seldom replaced , while the introduction of new simple technological elements can completely reset the path of future technologies .
another key feature of technological evolution is that it is mainly guided by planned designs , that have no equivalent with natural evolution : technology designers seek optimality criteria in terms of correctness , efficiency , cost and speed , and they outline new goals and expectations .
nevertheless , long - term trends and the diversification effects of contingencies , also due to social and economical factors , can only be captured a posteriori .
we then give here a very incomplete and extremely partial outline of what could be called the modern history of mainstream programming languages .
if we try the exercise of listing major languages in a total , time - based ordering , we observe that even a very rough ordering requires to choose a non - trivial criterion . should we list languages according to when they have been invented or according to when they became popular ?
interestingly , such a question exposes the gap between why a language has been invented and why it became popular .
for instance objective - c was designed long before the advent of mobile devices but its popularity greatly depends on the boost in the proliferation of apps for apple mobile tools ( see the objective - c s tiobe index in @xcite ) .
a fair solution to the ordering problem is then not to linearize the languages , but the major evolutionary leaps that marked the area , as depicted in figure [ fig : timelinep ] . with the introduction of languages such as fortran , lisp , cobol and
algol around 1950s-1960s we can start talking about modern languages , that rely on primitives such as ` if ` , ` goto ` , ` continue ` to add structure to the code . around 1970s-1980s the advent of languages like c , simula , smalltalk , ml and prolog marks the rise of modern programming _ paradigms _ , such as imperative programming , functional programming , logic programming and object - orientation .
the case of object - oriented programming ( oop ) is particularly instructive . in its well known paper
`` the free lunch is over ''
@xcite , herb sutter recalls that even if oop dates back in 1960s , object - orientation did nt become the dominant paradigm until the 1990s .
he also observes that the shift appeared _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ `` when the industry was driven by requirements to write larger and larger systems and oop s strengths in abstraction and dependency management _ made it a necessity _ for achieving large - scale software development that is economical , reliable , and repeatable '' .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ correspondingly , the killer application for oop and its modularity , encapsulation and code reuse principles , has been recognized to be the development of guis ( graphical user interfaces ) .
the key observation here is that the object - oriented model , well studied in academia , became pervasive in applications and mainstream programming only when driven by critical industry requirements .
similar evolutionary leaps in the history of programming languages can be traced also in recent years .
more precisely , we can identify a number of _ catalysts _ that powered significant changes in mainstream programming .
first of all , the advent of the internet ( and its appeal to the market ) shifted the programming language goals from efficiency to portability and security .
this is the scenario where java came into the arena , and the jvm brought to the fore the concept of virtual machine bytecode , already used , e.g. , in ml and smalltalk .
but the growth of the web had an impact also on the popularity of other languages : the so - called scripting languages , such as php , javascript , python , ruby , which are well suited to the development of short programs to be embedded into web pages and web servers .
notice however that , besides web technologies , these languages are often the favorite choice of many general - purpose programmers because of their high - level , declarative programming model which enhances productivity and fast prototyping .
it is worth remarking here that the success of these dynamic languages as general - purpose languages also comes as a reaction to the heavy and verbose type discipline imposed by strongly typed languages such as java or c#. another landmark in the history of programming languages , which is directly related to the topic of this paper , is the popularity of concurrent programming , whose catalyst is the fact that new , efficient hardware can only be somehow parallel .
moore s law , establishing that cpu performance doubles approximately every two years , is still valid only because performance gains can nowadays be achieved in fundamentally different ways : by means of cpu hyperthreading ( i.e. many threads in a single cpu ) and multicore ( many cpus on one chip ) .
however , in order to benefit from such a new hardware , applications must be concurrent .
for the sake of clarity , we observe that parallel and concurrent computing are different concepts , even if they are often used ( also in this article ) as synonyms .
they both refer to computations where more than one thread of control can make progress at the same time .
parallel computing stresses on the fact that many computations are actually carried out simultaneously by means of parallel hardware , such as multi - core computers or clusters .
concurrent computation generally refers to tasks that may be executed in parallel either effectively , on a parallel hardware , or virtually , by interleaving the execution steps of each thread on a sequential hardware .
moreover , in the context of programming languages , parallel tasks are generally sets of independent activities that are simultaneously active , while concurrent programs focus on the coordination of the interactions and communications between different tasks .
as in the case of oop , concurrent programming has been known since 1960s ( e.g. , it is a core aspect of any operating system ) , but it became widespread and mainstream essentially only because of the inexorability of parallel hardware .
the greatest cost of concurrency , that also limited its accessibility , is that ( correct ) concurrent programming is really hard and refactoring sequential code to add concurrency is even harder .
concurrency is so hard partly because of intrinsic reasons , such as dealing with nondeterminism , but also because of accidental reasons , like improper programming models .
as illustrated in figure [ fig : concgap ] , concurrent programming involves two phases . first the design of a concurrent algorithm or a concurrent software architecture , then its translation into a concurrent code .
the feasibility of such a translation clearly depends on the design choices of the target programming language .
many concurrency models have been studied , offering a range of solutions at very different abstraction levels .
single instruction multiple data ( simd ) architectures such as general purpose - gpus are tailored to specific parallel hardware devices , and efficient lock - free programming techniques require a precise account of the processor s memory model . at the other
extreme stays the actor model , which fosters declarative programming and integrates well with oop .
different concurrency models lead to different concurrent languages , e.g. , java , mpi , erlang , cuda , that entail very different programming styles , each one with merits and shortcomings .
in particular , an effective high - level concurrent programming model is still lacking .
such a deficiency can be rephrased in other terms : the quest for satisfactory , high - level concurrency abstractions is still open .
we will further examine this point in section [ sec : concabs ] , but before diving into concurrency , we now make our look at mainstream programming more concrete by applying the evolutionary explanation to specific language traits .
after having discussed how large - scale industrial software , the internet and the popularity of parallel hardware had a pivotal role in the development of mainstream programming , we now shift the point of view and we move within some language , trying to uncover specific evolutionary processes .
rather than looking at the history of a single language , we focus on how some key programming features evolved in time , in the same spirit of the biological study of the evolution of specific traits , like the wings , the eye or the thumb , across different species . in the realm of programming languages ,
a suitable definition of heritable traits to be used for studying a sort of programming language phylogeny is far from being clear .
we then consider here the general notion of _ programming abstractions _ as the semantic traits that we can trace back in the history of programming languages .
in particular , we discuss some object - oriented abstraction , the type discipline and the integration of functional programming with other paradigms .
[ [ object - oriented - languages ] ] object oriented languages + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + if we consider the object model used by ools , we can identify a tight `` evolutionary lineage '' starting from c++ , passing through java and ending in scala .
for instance , the enforcing of encapsulation has progressively increased along this lineage : c++ s friend functions violating encapsulation disappeared in java , and scala adopted the uniform access principle ( which dates back to the eiffel language ) , that is , object s fields and methods are accessed through the same notation , preventing the disclosure of any implementation details .
moreover , research and practice about multiple inheritance conducted from c++ s superclass diamonds with virtual inheritance , through java s single inheritance and multiple interfaces , up to scala s mixins .
this lineage also illustrates another trend in mainstream , general - purpose , languages : the programming style becomes more declarative and high - level , while implementation and efficiency issues are progressively moved under the hood by increasing the complexity of the runtime .
a simple example is memory management : java s automatic garbage collector takes fine - grained memory handling away from the programmer s control .
additionally , java s distinction between the primitive type ` int ` and the class type ` integer ` disappeared in scala .
primitive types exist in java because they allow for an efficient memory implementation that avoids the overhead of class representation ; scala s solution ( inherited from smalltalk ) keeps a uniform object - oriented model in the language , that only has the ` int ` class type , and delegates to the compiler ( and the jvm ) the implementation of the ` int ` class type as java s efficient ` int ` type .
[ [ typed - languages ] ] typed languages + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the rise and fall of types in mainstream programming is well represented in another evolutionary lineage of languages : the path from c++ , to java , to python / javascript , up to scala . in this case
the object - oriented type system of c++ ( among other aspects ) proved to be a valid support for early finding `` message - not - understood '' errors typical of oop .
then java pushed ahead types to a strong typing discipline , at the cost of becoming verbose and possibly cumbersome . as a reaction , untyped languages like python or javascript attracted programmers more interested in concise , easier to read and faster to write programming .
ancient philosophers teach that `` virtue stands in the middle '' , indeed recent solutions are a compromise between the two extremes : statically typed languages such as scala or apple s swift @xcite dramatically reduced type verbosity by improving the compiler s ability to infer types . at the same time , statically typed versions of untyped languages have been proposed , e.g. , microsoft s typescript @xcite for javascript and mypy @xcite for python .
[ [ functional - programming ] ] functional programming + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + another interesting example to be looked at in an evolutionary perspective is the case of functional programming . for
a long time programming by means of immutable data and higher - order functions had been confined to languages that have never become mainstream .
pure functional programming has its merits , but sometimes the imperative style is more natural and much easier to reason about .
c # is possibly the first mainstream language that clearly marks the integration of oop and fp into a multiparadigm language as a design goal .
however , the full integration of these two paradigms is better achieved in scala , whose default variables are immutable and a function is nothing else than an instance , i.e. an object , of the class ( implementing the trait ) ` function ` .
it is important to remark here that scala borrowed many of its features from previous languages , from smalltalk s uniform object model , to ocaml , ohaskell and plt - scheme design choices .
we just intend to highlight here which abstractions have been recently brought to the fore as a result of an instance of the recombination process mentioned at the beginning of this section . to conclude , it is mandatory to observe that the recent standards c++11 and java8 both extended the language with lambda - expressions , that is with higher - order functions . besides encouraging a more declarative programming style ,
as illustrated in the example below , functional programming has been proved to leverage parallel programming over data structures , which brings us back to our main topic .
consider a list of people from which we want to find the age of the oldest male .
let s focus on the java language , even if this is not restrictive . in what we could call the original java style ,
we would write something like the following code : .... person [ ] people = ... int maxage=-1 ; for(int i=0 ; i < people.length ; i++ ) if(people[i].getgender()==male & & people[i].getage()>maxage ) maxage = people[i].getage ( ) ; .... this iteration corresponds to a pure imperative programming style .
a pure object - oriented style would rather use an ` iterator ` over a ` collection ` , rephrasing the pattern as follows : .... collection < person > people = ... iterator < person > it = people.iterator ( ) ; int maxage=-1 ; while(it.hasnext ( ) ) { person p = it.next ( ) ; if(p.getgender()==male & & p.getage()>maxage ) maxage = p.getage ( ) ; } .... since java5 we can rephrase the iteration in a more abstract style , using the foreach construct : .... collection < person > people = ... int maxage=-1 ; for(person p : people ) if(p.getgender()==male & & p.getage()>maxage ) maxage = p.getage ( ) ; .... this style is more abstract in the sense that the iteration variable is not just an index ( or an iterator , which is a sort of pointer ) , but the current element under examination .
we have also abstracted away iteration details like the size of the collection and the iteration increment step . with java8 iteration
can be even more abstract , focusing on _ what _ we want to do , without going into _ how _ to do it , thanks to higher - order methods : .... collection < person > people = ... int maxage= people.stream().filter(p - > p.getgender()==male ) .maptoint(p - > p.getage ( ) ) .max ( ) ; .... in this code the data structure ( ` collection ` ) is used to produce a stream of elements that proceed through a pipeline of aggregate operations .
also notice that these operations correspond to the _ map - reduce _ functional programing pattern , where the ` maptoint ` method is the _ transformer _ and ` max ` is the _
combiner_. this new iteration style is a real advantage when the code heavily handles large data structures , since it is easily parallelizable by relying on ` parallelstream`s rather than sequential ` stream`s . indeed , in presence of parallel streams the java runtime partitions the stream into multiple substreams and let the aggregate operations to process these substreams in parallel by minimizing the synchronizations required by the concurrent computation .
anyway , it is interesting to observe such a drift toward a more declarative , high - level , programming style .
after having looked at how programming abstractions evolved in other areas , in this section we go back to concurrency .
as we said above , a number of different concurrency models have been proposed .
we recall here three models mainstream programming has been attracted by : the shared memory model , the message passing model , and the gp - gpu concurrency model . however , before discussing the three models , we emphasize the fact that they correspond to three different _ levels of explanation _ ( with reference to @xcite )
. an epistemological account of this aspect is clearly out of scope , we just observe that tackling concurrent programming and finding suitable primitives is much harder than , say , functional programming , since concurrency affects many levels : the hardware , the operating system , the language runtime , the language syntax , and the logical level of algorithms . here a quote from robin milner s turing lecture @xcite is particularly fitting : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ `` i reject the idea that there can be a unique conceptual model , or one preferred formalism , for all aspects of something as large as concurrent computation [ ... ] we need many levels of explanation : many different languages , calculi , and theories for the different specialisms '' , and also `` many levels of explanations are indispensable . indeed the entities at a higher level will certainly be of greater variety than those lower down '' .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ [ [ shared - memory - model ] ] shared memory model + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + in programming language terms , the shared memory model is represented by java - like threads : dynamically activated concurrent flows of computation that communicate by means of synchronization on a shared state .
this model , relying on mutable shared state , is well - suited to imperative programming .
moreover , it is a very natural model for _ data - centric _ , centralized algorithms and centralized systems where different software components operate on shared data .
however , protecting the shared state with appropriate synchronization mechanisms has been shown to be very difficult .
java - like locks and conditions ( that are also available in c # and c++11 ) are error - prone and unscalable .
errors like data races , deadlocks , priority inversion can be very subtle , and extensive testing is difficult because of nondeterminism and the fact that locks are not compositional . [ [ message - passing - model ] ] message passing model + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + when the application has a distributed nature and is _ communication - centric _ , shared - state is extremely error - prone . in this case
the message passing model is much more valuable : the state is no longer shared but it is dispatched as a message .
therefore , data races are avoided by construction and deadlocks are infrequent .
message passing typically allows for a more declarative programming style and more easily scales to a distributed system , possibly at the cost of high communication and coordination overheads . notice that this model endorses immutable data and programming techniques that use effects locally , selectively or minimally , that is , functional programming .
but there are not just functional languages that provide support for message passing : for instance the mpi standard is implemented in languages such as fortran , c and java .
the c - based google s language go offers message passing in a channel - based style . anyway , whenever the underlying paradigm is imperative , mutable variables are not immune to subtle race conditions .
an interesting integration of the message passing model with the object - oriented paradigm is represented by the actor model @xcite .
an actor , like an object , has an identity and reacts to messages in a single - threaded way in the same spirit of method invocations
. moreover , encapsulation , modularization , the clear distinction between interface and implementation are key notions also in the design of actor systems .
interestingly enough , the following quote from a. key talking about ool in 1998 fully applies also to actors : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ `` the key in making great and growable systems is much more to design how its modules communicate rather than what their internal properties and behaviours should be '' @xcite .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ notice that this is not an accident since the actor model has been proposed in the same years when languages with concurrent objects were studied ( e.g.@xcite ) .
today , the actor model is distinctive of erlang , a purely functional language with concurrency primitives that has been developed in the 1990s but whose popularity has grown in the 2000s due to the demand for concurrent services . nowadays erlang is used in a number of significant industrial projects such as facebook chat , github , whatsapp .
the actor model is also one of the successful features of scala , which is adopted for instance by coursera , linkedin , ebay , essentially because it provides a type safe language with scalable concurrency primitives on top of the jvm , which is a mature technology platform . in
is interesting to observe that , differently from erlang , in the case of scala the original actor - based constructs are not primitive in the language , but they are defined as a regular api whose implementation emerges as an effective example , in the spirit of the quest depicted in section [ sec : quest ] , of how scala s object - oriented and functional abstractions productively interoperate @xcite .
another approach that is getting increasing attention in the realm of communication - centric computing is _ protocol - based computing_. in this view , programming a concurrent ( and distributed ) system entails the design of a precise communication protocol involving a , possibly dynamic , set of interacting parties . using the terminology of service - oriented programming ,
if a service is represented as a sequence , or more generally as a graph , of messages to be sent / received , then an application can be viewed as service orchestration . however , web service technology and languages ( e.g. , jolie @xcite ) are just an example of what can be called protocol - centric programming .
another example is offered by the scribble language @xcite and the other outcomes of the rich theory of behavioural types and session types that are percolating at the level of programming languages .
[ [ general - purpose - gpu - programming ] ] general purpose - gpu programming + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + over the years the graphics processing unit ( gpu ) and its massively parallel architecture proved to be convenient also for general purpose usage , particularly for some class of algorithms and applications where large amount of data need to be parallely processed .
physics simulations , ray tracing , bioinformatics , evolutionary computation , machine learning , oil exploration , scientific image processing , linear algebra , statistics , 3d reconstruction , bitcoins mining and even stock options pricing , and many more fields and disciplines can benefit from this architecture .
gpus use the `` single instruction , multiple data''(simd ) architecture , in which multiple processors execute the same instructions on different pieces of data .
this allows the control flow computation to be shared amongst processors , so that more of the hardware is devoted to instruction execution .
however , given this architecture , gp - gpu programming requires a specific algorithmic thinking and a corresponding programming model . in 2006
nvidia launched cuda , a parallel computing platform on gpus comprising a programming model and an extension to the c programming language .
however , in the cuda programming model it is fundamental to precisely know the underlying architecture and its consequences on the performance of programs .
it is essential to be aware of how ( sets of ) threads are mapped onto the hardware , how they are executed and scheduled , and to know the peculiarities of memory access patterns .
therefore cuda brings about an extremely low - level programming , which allows c / c++ programmers to significantly fine - tune the applications performance , at the price of sacrificing high - level abstraction . the recent explosion of interest in gp - gpu , both from the research community and the industry is changing the situation .
in particular , efforts are made to unify host and device programming .
on the hardware side , the memories of the cpu and gpu are physically distinct but cuda 6 very recently ( @xcite ) provided a unified managed memory that is accessible to both the cpu and gpu , and thus avoids the need of explicitly programming the migration of data from the cpu to the gpu and back
. moreover , support for object handling , dynamic allocation and disposal of memory is rapidly growing . on the software side , many projects develop high - level programming models for gp - gpu , such as openacc for c / c++ , copperhead for python , the nova statically - typed functional language , and x10 heterogeneous compiler .
this field is clearly not yet mature , but the integration of the gpu concurrency model with high - level programming is just a matter of time .
we can trace an evolutionary lineage also locally to shared memory abstractions .
the original java threading model provides a class ` thread ` whose instances are associated to ( possibly dynamically ) created jvm threads . to spawn a new thread
the programmer must create a new object of type ` thread ` that encapsulates the code to be executed in parallel , and then call the method ` start ( ) ` on such an object .
however , requesting and obtaining the exclusive control of a jvm thread is costly in terms of performance .
novel solutions enforce a clear distinction between _ logical threads _ , that is , the activities to be concurrently executed , a.k.a .
tasks , and the _ executors _ , which are pools of ( jvm ) thread workers . in particular , the link between the task to be executed and the thread actually executing it is taken away from the programmer s control and it is devolved to an efficient work - stealing scheduling algorithm implemented by the runtime .
the difference between the lightweight threads spawned in the program and the pool of executors available in the runtime is particularly marked in the x10 language . in this language ,
a block of code to be executed in parallel is simply defined by the statement ` async{ ... code ... } ` .
the ` finish { ... } ` statement instructs the control to wait for the termination of all the concurrent code that might have been asynchronously spawned within the ` finish ` block . in other terms , x10 concurrency primitives provide a very simple ( but effective ) fork / join model that abstracts away the management of thread workers . similar ( but less straightforward ) solutions are available in recent java releases , together with a number of classes that allow the programmer to customize the pool of runtime executors . to conclude
, we observe the evolution of another distinctive feature of the java threading model : the use of locks and conditions . as we discussed above , correctly using primitives like ` synchronized , wait ( ) , notify ( ) ` is very difficult .
hence java concurrency library encapsulates a correct usage of these primitives into ready - to - be - used higher level abstractions such as atomic values , barriers , synchronized data structures .
however , x10 completely dismissed java s low level , error - prone building blocks , in favor of higher - level primitives such as ` atomic { ... } ` and ` when(condition ) { ... } ` , directly taken from software transactional memories .
in this section we complete the overview of the programming languages timeline that we started in section [ sec : quest ] .
in particular , we discuss a couple of more recent driving forces that are powering other significant changes in mainstream programming , as illustrated in figure [ fig : timelineii ] .
besides multicores and gpus , which drive concurrent programming , another important achievement of modern technology is cloud computing , which is acting as a catalyst for _ distributed programming_. also in this case , distributed systems are well - established , together with a number of successful programming solutions like sockets , rpcs ( remote procedure call ) , rmi ( remote method invocation ) , the grid , soa ( service oriented architecture ) .
however , the key change here is that the popularity of cloud resources shifted the business applications model from a centralized service provider accessed in client - server model , to the so - called software as a service ( saas ) model , where applications are deployed on heterogeneous platforms , from mobile devices up to cloud based clusters , running thousands of multicore processors .
such a model requires ad hoc solutions to productively deal with scalability issues , hardware heterogeneity , fault tolerance , security and privacy .
these requirements demand new architectural and system - level solutions , but also well - suited programming models can clearly offer a strong support . in this context , _ reactive programming _ is attracting a growing appeal .
the reactive manifesto @xcite precisely distills the distinctive features of reactive applications : they must be ready to react to events , react to load , react to failures , and react to users .
reactivity to events : : entails an event - driven programming model that , instead of issuing a command that
_ asks for a change _
, reacts to an event that indicates that something _
has changed_. such a model endorses all kinds of asynchronous operations : non blocking operations and decoupling event generation from event processing result in higher performance and scalability . as an example , _ futures _ are an asynchronous concurrency abstraction that has come to light in many recent mainstream languages . reactivity to load : : means the ability to scale up / down to deal with addition / removal of cpus on a node , and to scale out / in to deal with addition / removal of server nodes .
scalability , or elasticity , requires loose coupling between component behaviour and its location ( i.e. , location transparency ) .
it also requires to minimize shared mutable state and explicitly focuses on components communication .
reactivity to failures : : asks for programming styles that enforce application resilience , in order to quickly recover from software failures , hardware failures , and communication failures .
for instance , minimization of interdipendencies between components , encapsulation and hierarchic supervision lead to software components that are better isolated and monitored .
reactivity to user interaction : : addresses application responsiveness .
this aspect champions asynchronous and event - driven approaches and technologies that push data towards consumers when available rather than polling , such as push - servers @xcite or websockets @xcite which push events to browser and mobile applications .
this scenario will act as the environment operating a selection over the features of actual programming languages .
many of the features described in the previous sections clearly have to do with some of the items above , but cloud computing and reactive programming bring about a new shuffle of old issues and new problems . hence new `` language mutations
'' will appear to adapt to these new requirements . by reaching the end of our timeline , we find the current challenge we are facing in computer science : dealing with the huge amount of data that are collected by smart devices and pervasive computing .
big data applications require high - performance and data - parallel processing at a greater order of magnitude .
interestingly , reactive programming can be convenient here with its view of data in terms of streams of data rather than a collection / warehouse of data .
however , analytic computations on big data are proving to be the killer application for _ high performance computing _ ( hpc ) , that is , the programming model designed for scale - out computation on massively parallel hardwdare .
this paradigm is targeted not only to cloud infrastructures , but also to high - performance computing on supercomputers with massive numbers of processors . to exemplify ,
let s consider the x10 programming language , an open - source language developed at ibm research @xcite , whose design recombines earlier programming abstraction into a new mix in order to fit the hpc requirements .
x10 is designed around the _ place _ abstraction , which represents a virtual computational node that can be mapped onto a computer node in the cluster , or onto a processor or a core in a supercomputer .
according to the hpc model , a single program runs on a collection of places , it can create global data structures spanning multiple places , and it can spawn tasks at remote places and detect their termination . at the same time , a significant design feature is that x10 is an object - oriented , high - level programming language : its syntax is reminiscent of java - like and scala - like abstractions , and a powerful and expressive type system enforces static checks and promotes the programming - by - contracts methodology in terms of constrained dependent types .
notice that tackling high performance computing by means of high - level programming abstractions enhances productivity and integration with mainstream programming .
however , it also implies that considerable efforts must be put in place at the runtime environment level : raising the abstraction level of the source program must indeed be balanced out by an efficient executable with significant performance on heterogeneous hardware .
indeed , in the case of x10 , the source code compiles either to java code , or to c++ code or also to cuda code .
moreover , the resilient runtime supports executions that are tolerant of place failures .
x10 is then well - suited to write code running on 100 to 10.000 multicore nodes , that is up to 50 millions of cores .
as far as concurrency is concerned , high performance computing requires specific abstractions that allow the program to capture the logic of big data applications without explicitly dealing with distribution and parallelism issues . once again , the quest for good abstractions that allow both a more declarative code and an efficient implementation is crucial also in hpc , where the gap between the logic of the application and the execution infrastructure is particularly large .
a couple of so - called big data application frameworks are proving to be successful : the _ map - reduce _ model and the _ bulk synchronous parallel _ model .
the map - reduce model , implemented for instance by google s mapreduce , apache hadoop and apache spark , is a model inspired by map and reduce combinators from the functional programming , through which many real world tasks can be expressed ( e.g. , sorting and searching tasks @xcite ) .
the bulk synchronous parallel ( bsp ) model , implemented for instance by google s pregel [ 11 ] and apache giraph , has recently gained great interest because of its ability to process graphs of enormous size , such as social or location graphs , by deeply exploiting the work distribution on several machines ( e.g. @xcite ) .
it is worth observing that these two models could be classified as _
concurrency patterns _ , in that , similarly to classical object - oriented design patterns , they compose basic ( concurrent ) abstractions into strategic solutions . this observation illustrates how hpc entails an abstraction level , hence also a level of explanation , that is higher than that of concurrent programming , that will lead to the forthcoming landmark in the timeline .
the timeline we have described so far lists the catalysts that powered significant changes in mainstream programming .
this list also bears out the co - evolution of programming languages and hardware technology , which incidentally is evocative of the co - evolution of the human language and the brain .
however , in the history of programming languages there is another important co - evolving lineage , that corresponds to the advances of the theoretical research .
it is not worth here to distinguish what theoretical results affected mainstream programming ad what application solutions powered theoretical work .
such a distinction would require a precise historical reconstruction , and it is not essential to acknowledge that both areas have been mutually influenced , thus co - evolved .
let us rather recall another quote from robin milner s turing lecture @xcite talking about the semantic ingredients of concurrent computation : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ `` i believe that the right ideas to explain concurrent computing will only come from a dialectic between models from logic and mathematics and a proper distillation of a practical experience [ ... ] on the one hand , the purity and simplicity exemplified by the calculus of functions and , on the other hand , some very concrete ideas about concurrency and interaction suggested by programming and the realities of communication '' .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the role of the theory in the evolution of programming languages is then essential for the _ dialectic method _ devised by robin milner . in his lecture
he aimed at distilling the basic semantic elements of concurrent interaction , but the same holds also in general for programming primitives : suitable programming abstractions come from a dialectic between the experimental tests conducted by practical programming , and the deep mathematical tests conducted by the theoretical approach .
observe that these two kinds of tests are often conducted at different times , with practical programming occasionally picking out some theoretical result tested much earlier in a possibly slightly different context .
the formal languages studied by the theoreticians are indeed well suited to test new abstractions and new mix of abstractions in a concise and expressive model . in other terms , they allow for experimentation in a controlled environment . for instance , notions like asynchrony , locality , scope extrusion , futures , mobility , security , timing , probability and many other have been studied by many process calculi both in isolation and in combination .
this kind of research is a definite contribution to what we called the quest for good abstractions . in evolutionary terms
, we could say that theoretical research tests and promotes language mutations , not necessarily driven by the actual environment or the short - term future .
additionally , when working in a formal framework it is easier to distinguish the different abstraction levels involved in a given issue .
hence it is easier to first pick out just a single level to develop specific solutions , and then to study the integration of separate approaches into a distinct model , explicitly targeted at the combination of the different abstraction levels .
a nice example of combination of different abstraction levels are the works of abadi , fournet et gonthier about the translation of communication on secure channels into encrypted communication on public channels @xcite . in these works the high level primitives for secure communication in a pi - calculus - like language
are mapped into a lower - level , spi - calculus - like , language that includes cryptographic primitives .
the correctness theorem for such a translation implies that one can reason about the security of programs in the high - level language without mentioning the subtle cryptographic protocols used in their lower - level implementation . as a final example of productive mix of abstractions resulted from the dialectic method described above
, we recall the recent process of integration of functional programming into object - oriented and concurrent programming languages . an interesting way of looking at such a process is observing that this integration is actually fostered by understanding the notion of _ function _ as an abstraction that represents a _ behavior _ , which can be passed around and composed .
moreover , while imperative programming involves thinking in terms of _ time _ , functional programming rather focuses on _ space _ , where basic functions / behaviors are composed by need as building blocks , and the execution advances by transforming immutable values instead of stepwise modifications of mutable state ( @xcite ) .
the spatial view of functional programming can smoothly fit oop s ability of structuring software systems . on the other hand , designing a concurrent system in terms of space rather than time is easier and it allows one to better deal with the intrinsic nondeterminism . as a result , after fifty years of functional programming , the distinctive traits of those languages shine in new languages essentially because they leverage concurrency .
an evolutionary biologist would call such a functional shift an example of exaptation @xcite .
to conclude our excursus we point up some final comment .
first we remark that in the realm of natural languages we know that writing in a language involves thinking in that language .
the same holds also for programming languages : each language entails a specific programming style , and we know that _ what _ is being said ( or coded ) is shaped and influenced by _ how _ is being said ( or coded ) .
and the same also holds for formal models and theoretical frameworks .
it is then important to remind that there is no best model / language , but there might be a best suited model / language for a given situation .
that is why occasionally changing the working model / language might be beneficial .
moreover , modern software systems distinctive of innovative internet - driven companies such as google , facebook , linkedin , are actually written using a mix of languages , creating a sort of ecosystem of programming languages that interoperate at different abstraction levels . as a consequence ,
a productive mix of models together with interoperable primitives is vital .
a final comment is devoted to our evolutionary look at the modern history of programming languages . in this paper
we essentially used the evolutionary talking as a metaphor .
however , a thorough discussion about to what extent darwin s theory of evolution can be applied to programming languages would be very insightful .
indeed , it would be quite interesting to answer questions like what are language mutations and is there a struggle for life in the language arena ?
are different concurrency models / abstractions an example of mutations over which the market ( or the marketing strategies ) will do its selection action ? will only those languages that are equipped with higher plasticity either in their design choices or in their marketing strategies survive ?
it is not an accident that oracle embarked on a deep change of the java platform , both in the language , the jvm and the programming style , to leverage java8 s lambda expressions @xcite ; how else could we call such a change if not a form of adaptation ? | in this paper we examine how concurrency has been embodied in mainstream programming languages . in particular , we rely on the evolutionary talking borrowed from biology to discuss major historical landmarks and crucial concepts that shaped the development of programming languages .
we examine the general development process , occasionally deepening into some language , trying to uncover evolutionary lineages related to specific programming traits .
we mainly focus on concurrency , discussing the different abstraction levels involved in present - day concurrent programming and emphasizing the fact that they correspond to different levels of explanation .
we then comment on the role of theoretical research on the quest for suitable programming abstractions , recalling the importance of changing the working framework and the way of looking every so often .
this paper is not meant to be a survey of modern mainstream programming languages : it would be very incomplete in that sense .
it aims instead at pointing out a number of remarks and connect them under an evolutionary perspective , in order to grasp a unifying , but not simplistic , view of the programming languages development process . |
within the past few years the number of known brown dwarfs has increased dramatically , with both the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ; * ? ? ? * ) and two micron all - sky survey ( 2mass ; * ? ? ?
* ) accounting for the bulk of the discoveries .
these objects have been identified based on broad - band photometry with follow - up optical and near - infrared spectroscopy .
the integrated data from these investigations has yielded important information about the variation of the chemical composition and of the effects of condensates in brown dwarfs in term of their spectral types ( e. g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
spectroscopic observations in the mid - infrared yield important additional information @xcite , but due to the very low infrared brightness of these objects and the effects of the earth s atmospheric absorption these measurements have been difficult or impossible from ground - based observatories . with the launch of the spitzer space telescope @xcite and the onboard infrared spectrograph ( irs ; * ? ? ?
* ) on 2003 august 25 , we now have an observatory with sufficient sensitivity to undertake these studies .
accordingly , the science team of the irs has organized a comprehensive observational program of m , l , and t dwarfs , covering the range from the earliest m dwarfs to the latest t dwarfs .
we present here the first results from this program : observations of the m3.5 star gj 1001a ( lhs 102a ) , the l8 dwarf denis - p j0255@xmath04700 ( hereafter j0255@xmath04700 ) , and the t1/t6 binary system @xmath1 indi ba / bb .
the three objects described here were observed with the irs instrument on the spitzer space telescope as part of one of the major irs science team guaranteed time observing programs .
the irs is capable of low - and moderate - resolution spectroscopy , with only data from the low - resolution modules being reported here .
each of the irs low - resolution modules is fed by two long slits , one used for first order and the second used for second order .
the irs low - resolution modules have slit lengths of 546 and 1513 for both orders in the short - low ( sl ) and long - low ( ll ) modules , respectively .
the spectral resolution of the sl module as determined by the slit width is @xmath2 = 0.06 for second order and @xmath2 = 0.12 for first order .
the spectral resolution of the ll module as determined by the slit width is @xmath2 = 0.17 for second order and @xmath2 = 0.32 for first order .
the slit widths of both of the irs low - resolution modules are nyquist sampled by the pixel pitch of their infrared arrays .
@xcite describe the design , performance , and operation of the irs in more detail .
table 1 provides a summary of the observations reported here .
as all of these objects have relatively large proper motions , the irs blue peakup array was used to locate the current positions of these objects and to reposition them into the irs slits with an estimated radial uncertainty of approximately 04 , ( 1@xmath3 ) .
each object was observed at two locations in each of the irs low - resolution slits , with the positions located at approximately the 1/3 and 2/3 positions along the long axis of the slits .
the standard irs data reduction pipeline version s9.1 at the spitzer science center processed the data .
stellar standards were also observed to calibrate the spectra and remove any spectral artifacts which may have survived the processing ; the results reported here were corrected with the a dwarf standard star @xmath4 umi .
the zodiacal and galactic backgrounds were subtracted before the spectral extractions using observations when the target was located in the alternate slit .
finally , the spectra were extracted from the sky - subtracted two - dimensional array images using an early version of the smart irs data - reduction software package being developed at cornell university @xcite .
figure 1 shows the resulting irs low - resolution spectra for the three objects reported here . at this early stage in the spitzer mission ,
our estimated uncertainty in the absolute photometry is @xmath5 , but the uncertainty in the spectral shape is much less than this .
the caption for figure 1 gives the uncertainties in the spectral shapes which were estimated from a combination of the measured noise in the individual reads of the pixels in the detector arrays and the variation between the spectra extracted from the observations at the two slit positions .
these uncertainties therefore incorporate some measure of the residual systematic uncertainties and spectral flat - fielding errors .
uncertainties in the absolute flux calibration were estimated in different ways for the three objects and are described below .
lll gj 1001a & 2003 december 16 & 4190464 + + & sl2 480 seconds + & sl1 480 seconds + & ll2 480 seconds + & ll1 960 seconds + + denis - p j0255@xmath04700 & 2004 january 7 & 4192000 + + & sl2 480 seconds + & sl1 480 seconds + & ll2 480 seconds + & ll1 960 seconds + + @xmath1 indi ba / bb & 2003 september 26 & 6625792 + + & sl2 56 seconds + & sl1 56 seconds + 4700 , and the @xmath1 indi ba / bb system . the fluxes for @xmath1 indi ba / bb have been divided by a factor of 10 for clarity .
the average 1@xmath3 errors in the data points are as follows : for gj 1001a , 2.60 mjy from 5.3 to 14.1 and 1.61 mjy from 14.1 to 35.0 ; for j0255@xmath04700 they are 0.73 mjy from 5.3 to 14.1 and 1.00 mjy from 14.1 to 35.0 ; for the @xmath1 indi ba / bb system they are 2.26 mjy from 5.3 to 15.3 .,height=432 ] 4700 , and the @xmath1 indi ba / bb system compared with model spectra .
the fluxes for @xmath1 indi ba / bb have been divided by a factor of 10 for clarity .
the observed data are denoted by the solid black lines while the model spectra are in the thicker blue lines .
the various model parameters for each of the spectra are given in the text .
the most noticeable h@xmath6o , ch@xmath7 , and nh@xmath8 bands are marked , although weaker h@xmath6o absorption extends from the blue edge of the figure to 7.0 , and nh@xmath8 absorption in @xmath1 indi ba / bb extends from 8.5 to the red edge of the figure . in the case of gj 1001a
the entire displayed spectrum is dominated by water absorption , while in j0255@xmath04700 water is dominant longward of 9 . in a t1 ( the brightest component of @xmath1 indi b ) ,
nh@xmath8 is present but not strong enough to be visible in the 1215 region , so that longward of 12 the spectral morphology is still primarily due to water absorption .
the strong 7.8 absorption band from ch@xmath7 is evident in both of the cooler objects.,height=432 ]
as the atmospheres of brown dwarfs cool with time , their spectral signatures reflect a progression of changes in their atmospheric chemical equilibrium and condensate structure .
the three dwarfs discussed here provide snapshots of this progression . in an m dwarf such as gj 1001a , the elements o , c , and
n are predominantly found in @xmath9o , co , and @xmath10 and the atmosphere is too warm for condensation of solids ( @xcite ) .
as the effective temperature ( @xmath11 ) falls , a variety of condensates form in the atmosphere , most notably iron and silicates .
these condensates are not expected to be well - mixed through the atmosphere , but rather be found in relatively thin , discrete cloud layers overlying the condensation level ( @xcite ) . as the @xmath11 falls to that of a late l dwarf , such as j0255@xmath04700 ,
the cloud layer is optically thick and affects either directly ( as a major opacity source ) or indirectly ( by altering the atmospheric temperature / pressure profile ) all spectral regions .
the exact spectral signature of the cloud depends both on its vertical thickness and the particle size distribution of the condensates .
in addition as the atmosphere cools chemical equilibrium begins to favor first @xmath12 over co and then @xmath13 over @xmath10 ( @xcite ) .
the strong mid - infrared bands of these molecules begin to challenge the domination of water opacity , at least in some spectral regions , by the late l s . by the early to
mid t dwarfs , such as the @xmath1 indi pair , the condensate cloud is forming quite deep in the atmosphere . in the relatively clear , cool atmosphere above the cloud
, chemical equilibrium begins to strongly favor @xmath12 and @xmath13 and their spectral features , along with particularly strong bands of water , grow in prominence ( @xcite ) .
figure 1 shows the resulting pronounced changes in the mid - infrared spectral morphology between the three objects .
the spectra and comparisons with synthetic spectra are considered for each of the objects in turn .
gj 1001a is classified as an m3.5 v star @xcite and is part of a binary system with the l5 dwarf gj 1001b @xcite .
the distance between the primary and secondary is large enough ( 18 ) that there is no contamination of the primary s spectrum by stray light from the secondary . using optical and near - infrared spectra , leggett et al .
( 2002 ) find a best fit to this object with @xmath11 = 3200 k and @xmath14 using a mixing length parameter of 2 in the ames - dusty models of allard et al .
figure 2 compares this same model , smoothed to a spectral resolution of @xmath15 , with the irs data .
the 6.5 feature seen in the irs spectrum also appears in the model and arises from h@xmath16o opacity . for the object gj 1001a
the near - infrared observations @xcite can be used with the model and the resulting predicted photometric flux compared with our observations .
although the shape of the model spectrum is an excellent match to the irs data , the model fluxes derived from the near - infrared observations had to be scaled by a factor of 0.87 to fit the observed data .
the near - infrared flux levels are consistent with the @xmath11 and radius derived from the luminosity if the dwarf is older than 0.15 gyr @xcite .
j0255@xmath04700 is classified optically as an l8 dwarf .
unfortunately the trigonometric parallax distance of this object has not been measured .
considerable structure can be seen in the irs spectrum and to interpret these results we have compared the irs data with the model described by @xcite and saumon et al .
( 2003 ) , with t@xmath17 = 1400 k , @xmath18 in figure 2 . in this model
atmospheric condensate clouds are treated as described by @xcite with a sedimentation efficiency parameter @xmath19 .
the model has been normalized to match the observed flux in the 8.6 9.0 region .
models that include condensate sedimentation in the chemical equilibrium but ignore cloud opacity require unrealistically high t@xmath17 to acceptably fit the data and these are not shown here .
we judge the excellent agreement of the cloudy model to the j0255@xmath04700 data as further evidence for finite - thickness silicate and iron clouds in the observable atmospheres of late l dwarfs .
as can be seen in the figure the correlation between the model spectrum and the irs data is excellent , although there is a slight discrepancy between the data and model predictions in the h@xmath6o feature at 5.5 6.5 .
in addition there is a broad shallow dip in the irs data compared with the model between 9 and 11 that may be due to a silicate cloud feature .
the irs spectrum shows the first detection of the 7.8 ch@xmath7 band in a brown dwarf .
@xmath12 was detected at 3.3 in l dwarfs by @xcite and since the @xmath20 band is of comparable strength to the @xmath21 fundamental , it is not surprising to find this mid - infrared signature of atmospheric methane in an l dwarf . models with ( @xcite ) and without ( @xcite ) dust opacity also anticipated this feature in the l dwarf t@xmath17 range along with the water features noted above .
methane absorption is even more obvious in the spectrum of the @xmath1 indi b system discussed below .
@xcite used oscir at gemini south to image j0255@xmath04700 in the @xmath22-band ( @xmath23 13.4 ) and three narrowband filters centered at 8.8 , 10.3 and 11.7 .
flux density detections were obtained in the @xmath22 and 8.8 bands , with upper limits for the 10.3 and 11.7 bands . despite the estimated 25% uncertainty in our absolute flux calibration
, the irs spectrum can not be scaled to match both their @xmath22-band and their 8.8 flux density measurements .
@xcite note that the @xmath22-band flux density is a factor of 2 to 3 greater than the narrowband values and discuss possible causes of this discrepancy .
our data can rule out two of their suggestions - the presence of peculiar emission or absorption lines .
figures 1 and 2 show that there are no strong emission features in the @xmath22 bandpass and also that the narrow bandpasses do not fall in regions of strong absorption . while it is difficult to reconcile all of the creech - eakman et al .
photometry with our irs spectrum , our data can be brought into approximate agreement with the three narrowband measurements if the spectrum is scaled to the lower limit of the 8.8 @xmath24 m oscir detection .
this may indicate that the @xmath22-band measurement is in error .
the @xmath1 indi ba and bb system consists of a t1 and t6 dwarf separated by 0732 @xcite .
the irs does not have the spatial resolution to separate the two objects so the measured spectrum is a composite of the two individual spectra . in this object
we find the first evidence for nh@xmath8 absorption in the spectrum between 10 and 11 , although its presence in very cool brown dwarf atmospheres has been expected for some time @xcite .
@xcite reported a weak detection of nh@xmath8 in the near infrared spectrum of the t6 dwarf gl 229b but this is the first strong detection of nh@xmath8 in a brown dwarf . with the lower t@xmath17 for the components of this binary system the condensate clouds
are predicted to be below the photosphere and thus have a less pronounced effect on the composite spectrum than they do on the l8 dwarf s spectrum .
a composite model spectrum provides an excellent match to the irs data and was obtained as follows . as with the model for j0255@xmath04700 we used the model described by @xcite and saumon et al .
( 2003 ) . from the estimates of @xmath25 for each component @xcite and the estimated age of @xmath1 indi a ( 0.82 gyr ; * ? ? ?
* ) , we use our brown dwarf cooling calculations @xcite to obtain ( @xmath11 , log @xmath26 , @xmath27 ) = ( 1250 k , 5.13 , 0.094 ) , ( 840 k , 4.89 , 0.100 ) for the t1 and the t6 dwarfs , respectively . selecting the closest cloudless synthetic spectra in our grid of models ( 1200 k , 5.0 ) and ( 800 k , 5.0 ) which are within the uncertainties of those parameters , and using the above radii and the trigonometric parallax of @xmath1 indi a @xcite , the absolute flux at the earth of the t dwarf binary was obtained .
note that in figure 2 , the composite model spectrum has not been normalized to the irs data , so that in this case the predicted flux agrees with the irs data to within the data errors .
\(1 ) we have taken advantage of the unprecedented sensitivity of the infrared spectrograph instrument on the spitzer space telescope to observe two brown dwarfs .
these are the first spectra in this wavelength range ever reported for this type of object .
the spectrum of an m dwarf is also reported here , providing a contrast between objects with masses above and below the hydrogen - burning minimum mass .
\(2 ) the observed mid - infrared spectral morphologies of these three objects vary strongly with their spectral classes , reflecting the changes in gas chemistry driven by the temperature of their atmospheres .
\(3 ) model comparisons with the observed spectra of all three objects show good agreement , with only a few minor deviations .
models with cloud opacities do a better job of reproducing the data from j0255@xmath04700 than do models without clouds .
\(4 ) we report here the first positive detection of the 7.8 methane band .
we also report the first unambiguous detection of nh@xmath8 in a brown dwarf atmosphere .
we are pleased to thank the entire team of dedicated scientists , engineers , and managers that contributed to the development of the spitzer observatory and the irs instrument .
in particular , we would like to especially thank larry simmons and david gallagher of jpl , and john troeltzsch , marty huisjen , and john marriott of ball aerospace for their leadership in this endeavor .
this work is based on observations made with the spitzer space telescope , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology under nasa contract 1407 .
support for this work was provided by nasa s office of space science .
t. roellig and m. marley would like to acknowledge the support of the nasa office of space sciences .
d. saumon s work at lanl is supported by the united states department of energy under contract w-7405-eng-36 .
m. cushing is supported by a spitzer fellowship . | we present the first mid - infrared spectra of brown dwarfs , together with observations of a low - mass star .
our targets are the m3.5 dwarf gj 1001a , the l8 dwarf denis - p j0255@xmath04700 , and the t1/t6 binary system @xmath1 indi ba / bb . as expected , the mid - infrared spectral morphology of these objects changes rapidly with spectral class due to the changes in atmospheric chemistry resulting from their differing effective temperatures and atmospheric structures . by taking advantage of the unprecedented sensitivity of the infrared spectrograph on the spitzer space telescope
we have detected the 7.8 methane and 10 ammonia bands for the first time in brown dwarf spectra . |
growing attention has recently been paid to the model buildings based on the scenario of extra dimensions compactified with tev scale @xcite .
along such a scenario the top quark condensate ( top - mode standard model : tmsm ) @xcite was reconsidered by several authors @xcite in the versions with compactified extra dimensions , where the ad hoc four - fermion couplings in the original tmsm may be replaced by the strong attractive forces due to kaluza - klein ( kk ) modes of the bulk standard model ( sm ) gauge bosons . in particular , arkani - hamed , cheng , dobrescu and hall ( acdh ) @xcite proposed a version of the tmsm where the third generation quarks / leptons as well as the sm gauge bosons are put in the bulk , while other generations in the brane . in a series of papers
@xcite we investigated the full gauge dynamics ( _ without four - fermion interactions _ ) in the bulk , based on the ladder schwinger - dyson ( sd ) equation .
we further studied @xcite phenomenological implications on the acdh scenario and found that @xmath6 ( four extra dimensions ) will be a viable case which predicts a correct top mass , @xmath7 gev , and a characteristic higgs mass , @xmath8 gev , from the requirement that only the top can condense ( `` topped mac '' or tmac requirement ) . actually , the most prominent feature of the gauge theories with extra dimensions is that the theories become strongly coupled , with the coupling growing by the power running in the ultraviolet region beyond the compactification scale .
let us take a class of @xmath2 gauge theories with massless @xmath3 flavors .
it was pointed out @xcite ( see also @xcite ) that the bulk gauge coupling of such gauge theories can have a ( nontrivial ) ultraviolet fixed point ( uvfp ) within the truncated kk effective theory @xcite .
although existence of such a uvfp is somewhat subtle in the lattice studies @xcite and other nonperturbative approach @xcite , unless it is an artifact of the truncated kk effective theory , it implies existence of a renormalizable interacting gauge theory even in dimensions higher than four .
it is in sharp contrast to the conventional view ( based on the perturbation ) that higher dimensional gauge theories are nonrenormalizable and trivial .
once we assume that such a nontrivial uvfp does exist beyond the truncated kk effective theory , the theory behaves near the uvfp as a _ walking gauge theory _ @xcite having a large anomalous dimension
@xmath9 @xcite . in the four - dimensional case , as was pointed out by bardeen et al .
@xcite , the four - fermion interaction becomes a marginal operator due to the large anomalous dimension , @xmath10 , of the walking gauge theory , and hence can be mixed with the gauge interaction .
then _ the phase structure of the walking gauge theories should be analyzed in a larger parameter space including the four - fermion interactions as well as the gauge interactions_. the gauged nambu - jona - lasinio ( njl ) model , a model of gauge theory plus four - fermion interaction , was first studied by bardeen , leung and love @xcite within the ladder sd equation for the fixed gauge coupling in four dimensions .
the critical line of the four - dimensional model for the fixed gauge coupling was discovered by kondo , mino and yamawaki @xcite and independently by appelquist , soldate , takeuchi and wijewardhana @xcite . since
then the model has been offering many interesting applications for physics of dynamical symmetry breaking , such as the walking technicolor @xcite , the strong etc technicolor @xcite / topcolor - assisted technicolor @xcite , and the tmsm @xcite or topcolor @xcite , etc .
( see for reviews refs .
@xcite ) .
the characteristic dynamical feature of the four - dimensional gauged njl model is the large anomalous dimension @xcite , @xmath11 , for the fixed ( walking ) gauge coupling , and the finiteness of all ( renormalized ) couplings at composite level as well as induced yukawa coupling of the fermion to the composite bosons in the continuum limit ( infinite cutoff limit ) .
this implies the ( nonperturbative ) `` renormalizability '' or `` nontriviality '' of the model , as was pointed out in ref.@xcite for the ( `` moderately '' ) walking gauge coupling , with @xmath12 , where @xmath13 and @xmath14 .
the parameter @xmath15 measures the speed of running of the running gauge coupling @xcite : @xmath16 is the normal running as in the qcd , while @xmath17 is the walking coupling and @xmath18 corresponds to the fixed ( `` standing '' limit of the walking ) gauge coupling .
combined with the asymptotic freedom , @xmath12 reads @xmath5 . ] , and was subsequently shown more systematically for the fixed ( walking ) gauge coupling ( @xmath19 ) in ref .
@xcite as well as for the moderately walking one in ref.@xcite . for the fixed gauge coupling ,
such a phenomenon takes place along the whole critical line except for the pure njl point ( without gauge coupling and `` @xmath20 '' ) where the above couplings vanish logarithmically in the continuum limit and hence the theory becomes nonrenormalizable or trivial .
inclusion of four - fermion interactions into the gauge theories has not been done so far in the context of the extra dimension scenario .
the analysis of the phase structure of the gauged njl model with extra dimensions for such walking gauge theories may be useful not only for the tmsm but for other strong coupling theories such as the bulk technicolor , various composite models , etc .. in this paper we investigate phase structure of the gauged njl model in the @xmath0-dimensional bulk , based on the improved ladder sd equation for the bulk fermion propagator , assuming that the ( dimensionless ) bulk running gauge coupling is given by the truncated kk effective theory and hence almost fixed at the nontrivial uvfp in a wide energy range above the compactified energy scale .
as far as the cutoff energy @xmath21 is large , the effect of the compactified scale is negligible and the sd equation is well approximated by that with the fixed coupling @xcite .
thus we take the gauge coupling be fixed at the value of uvfp for simplicity . here
we should stress that our results in this paper crucially depend on the existence of such a uvfp . by solving the sd equation
we find the critical line in the two - dimensional parameter space ( @xmath22,@xmath23 ) of the coupling strength @xmath22 ( essentially the squared gauge coupling fixed at the uvfp value ) and the ( dimensionless ) four - fermion coupling @xmath23 : @xmath24 which exists only for @xmath25 , where @xmath26 is the critical coupling strength of the pure gauge theory without four - fermion interaction @xcite .
the critical line separating the spontaneously broken phase ( with nonzero dynamical mass @xmath27 of the fermion ) and the unbroken one ( with zero dynamical mass ) resembles that in the four - dimensional gauged njl model with fixed gauge coupling @xcite except for the prefactor @xmath28 instead of @xmath29 .
note , however , that we actually consider in this paper a class of @xmath2 gauge theories ( with @xmath3 flavors ) which are asymptotically free having a trivial uvfp in four dimensions , @xmath30 , but do have the nontrivial one in higher dimensions , @xmath31 whose value is uniquely determined once the model parameters such as @xmath32 and @xmath3 are specified . each point on the above critical line thus corresponds to a single gauged njl model with a different gauge theory with different @xmath33 .
we can not freely adjust its value .
we further discuss the phase structure of the model , following the manner in the four - dimensional case @xcite .
we find that the decay constant @xmath34 of the composite nambu - goldstone ( ng ) boson @xmath35 becomes finite in the continuum limit ( @xmath36 ) , if @xmath32 and @xmath3 are arranged so as to satisfy the condition @xmath37 where @xmath38 is given by @xmath39 we may call @xmath40 as a `` marginal triviality ( mt ) '' point , where the decay constant @xmath34 of the composite ng boson @xmath35 diverges logarithmically , @xmath41 , in the continuum limit @xmath36 and hence resembles the pure njl point ( zero gauge coupling ) in the four - dimensional case .
then in the nontrivial window we find a surprising result that even in higher dimensions the four - fermion theory _ in the presence of gauge interactions _ becomes `` renormalizable '' and `` nontrivial '' in the sense that the induced ( renormalized ) yukawa coupling of the fermion to the ng boson and the ( renormalized ) couplings among @xmath35 and composite scalar @xmath42 all remain finite in the continuum limit ( @xmath36 ) .
this is analogous to the renormalizability and nontriviality of the four - dimensional case @xcite except that the mt point in four - dimensional case corresponds to the pure njl point , @xmath43 for @xmath44 .
we demonstrate these facts by explicit computation of @xmath34 , the yukawa vertex @xmath45 , the scalar propagator @xmath46 , and the effective potential @xmath47 . here
we should emphasize one distinct feature of the inclusion of the four - fermion interaction into the gauge theory in the bulk with compactified extra dimensions : in the case of pure gauge theories ( without four - fermion interactions ) , the `` nontrivial '' theory defined at the critical point @xmath26 is only formal , since the gauge coupling @xmath22 at the uvfp is not a continuous parameter but a discrete one depending on @xmath32 and @xmath3 and hence can not be fine - tuned arbitrarily close to the critical value @xcite .
it means that even if we assume existence of the uvfp , _ the pure gauge theory in higher dimensions can only be renormalizable in a formal sense_. thus there is no finite theory for pure gauge theories .
on the other hand , in the gauged njl model we do have a continuous parameter , the four - fermion coupling @xmath23 , and hence _ the nontrivial theory can be defined by fine - tuning @xmath23 arbitrarily close to the criticality of the four - fermion coupling _ at the critical line eq .
( [ criticalline1 ] ) .
note that for @xmath48 where no criticality of the four - fermion coupling exists , there is no finite theory even in the gauged njl model . for the theories in the nontrivial window , @xmath49
, we perform explicitly the renormalization of the effective potential in a way similar to the four - dimensional case given in ref.@xcite .
the renormalized four - fermion coupling @xmath50 also has a uvfp @xmath51 .
we then find that the theory has a large anomalous dimension at the uvfp @xmath52 : @xmath53 which takes the same form as that of the four - dimensional model @xcite when @xmath54 in the prefactor is set to be @xmath55 .
since @xmath56 , the dynamical dimension of the four - fermion interaction , @xmath57 $ ] , reads @xmath58 for @xmath59 , and such an operator is a relevant operator similarly to the four - dimensional gauged njl model @xcite .
thus , as we were motivated by the four - dimensional case , we conclude that _ the phase structure of the gauge theory with extra dimensions which behaves as a walking theory should also be studied with inclusion of the four - fermion interaction_. as expected , in the renormalized effective potential there exist interactions of @xmath60 and @xmath61 for @xmath62 ( nontriviality ) , which are _ conformal invariant_. the renormalizability / nontriviality implies a remarkable fact that the physics prediction is _ cutoff insensitive _ , notwithstanding the ultraviolet dominance of the dynamics of both the walking gauge and the four - fermion interactions strongly coupled in the ultraviolet region , which may be useful for model buildings .
we further study rg flows of each theory in the nontrivial window governed by a uvfp @xmath63 corresponding to a set of @xmath64 ( each point lying on the critical line @xmath65 ) .
then we find that our renormalization is consistently performed even off the uvfp . for @xmath66 , on the other hand , we find that the gauged njl model becomes trivial and nonrenormalizable in spite of the fact that we can fine - tune the four - fermion coupling to make finite the dynamical mass of the fermion .
the `` renormalized effective potential '' actually has no interaction terms of @xmath60 and @xmath61 .
this renormalization would lead to the `` anomalous dimension '' @xmath67 and @xmath68 for @xmath69 .
however , our renormalization is incomplete for @xmath69 : there exists another marginal operator @xmath70 whose dynamical dimension is given by dim(@xmath71 ( marginal operator ! ) in our renormalization scheme .
we further discuss in sec .
[ summary ] the formal limit @xmath44 , in which @xmath72 and @xmath73 and hence the uvfp s for both regions of the nontrivial window @xmath74 and trivial region @xmath75 shrink to a single point of the pure njl point . nonetheless , the nontrivial window for @xmath4 coincides with the condition of the renormalizability / nontriviality of the four - dimensional gauged njl model with ( moderately ) walking gauge coupling characterized by @xmath12 @xcite , which is clearly distinguished from @xmath76 corresponding to the trivial region @xmath75 .
thus the nontrivial window is not a peculiarity of the extra dimensions but actually exists already in the four - dimensional gauged njl model in a rather sophisticated manner .
the paper is organized as follows : in sec .
[ sec2 ] we give our model setting , lagrangian and the running gauge coupling constant within the truncated kk effective theory . in sec .
[ sec3 ] we study phase structure of the model , based on the simplest approximation , the bifurcation technique @xcite , to the sd equation .
we find the critical line , and calculate simplified scaling relation , scalar boson propagator and the decay constant @xmath34 of the ng boson @xmath35 .
we also find the mt point where @xmath77 diverges logarithmically in the continuum limit . in sec .
[ sec - moreabout ] we incorporate subleading terms in the asymptotic region by more involved approximations than the bifurcation , `` linearized approximation '' @xcite and `` power expansion method '' @xcite .
the sub - dominant term is required for the effective potential . in sec .
[ eff_pot ] we calculate the effective potential . in sec .
[ sec - rg ] we discuss the renormalization making finite the induced yukawa coupling , the effective potential and the scalar boson propagator .
we give detailed discussions on the rg flow in the nontrivial window .
[ summary ] is devoted to summary and discussion : in particular we discuss the @xmath4 limit . in appendix
[ app1 ] , we give another detailed calculations of the composite scalar propagator . appendix [ sec - appendix2 ] and [ sec - appendix3 ] are for details of the `` linearized approximation '' and `` power expansion method '' , respectively .
appendix [ app - d ] is for more discussions on the nonrenormalizability of the region @xmath78 .
let us start with the renormalization group properties of the gauge interaction in the @xmath79 dimensional bulk .
extra @xmath80 spatial dimensions are assumed to be compactified at scale @xmath81 .
the negative mass dimension of the bulk gauge coupling implies strong interaction at high energy .
thus the higher loop effects somehow need to be taken into account .
the task , however , immediately meets serious trouble with the nonrenormalizability of the bulk gauge theory @xmath82 .
we therefore _ define _ the bulk gauge theory by using the `` truncated kaluza - klein ( kk ) '' effective theory @xcite , which allows us to calculate the loop effects within 4d effective field theory .
a remarkable feature of the truncated kk effective theory is the existence of the non - trivial ultraviolet fixed point ( uvfp ) at least for its @xmath83 coupling @xcite .
we briefly review the properties of the renormalization group equation ( rge ) in this model . after the decomposition of the bulk gauge field into its kk - modes , the running of the four - dimensional gauge coupling @xmath84 can be described by the rge , @xmath85 where we assumed the renormalization scale @xmath86 is sufficiently larger than the compactification scale @xmath81 , @xmath87 .
the rge coefficient @xmath88 is given by @xmath89 for @xmath2 gauge theory with @xmath3 bulk fermions .
@xmath90 stands for the number of kk modes below the renormalization scale @xmath86 .
we use an approximation @xmath91 the factor @xmath92 in eq .
( [ nkk_app ] ) arises from the orbifold compactification on @xmath93 .
( see refs .
@xcite . ) the four - dimensional gauge coupling @xmath94 can be matched with the _ dimensionful _ bulk gauge coupling @xmath95 , @xmath96 it is convenient to define the _ dimensionless _ bulk gauge coupling @xmath97 , @xmath98 and thus @xmath99 combining eqs .
( [ rge - ed1 ] ) , ( [ nkk_app ] ) , and ( [ hat - g ] ) , we obtain rge for @xmath97 @xcite @xmath100 with @xmath101 being the loop factor of naive dimensional analysis ( nda ) in @xmath54 dimensions , @xmath102 the rge ( [ rge_ed3 ] ) leads to a uvfp @xmath103 @xcite , @xmath104 for @xmath105 .
so far we have shown the uvfp only within the truncated kk effective theory at one - loop level .
does such a uvfp really exist beyond the approximation we adopted ?
this question is , of course , a highly non - perturbative problem @xcite and extremely difficult to be answered . instead of solving this difficult problem , in this paper
, we simply assume the existence of the uvfp and address a hopefully easier but still quite exciting question : how does the bulk gauge theory behave with such a uvfp ?
such a theory should possess an approximate conformal invariance and was shown to have a large anomalous dimension @xmath106 @xcite .
the situation has a strong resemblance to the four - dimensional walking gauge theories @xcite , in which the gauge coupling is assumed to be on the nontrivial uvfp and the fermion bilinear operator @xmath107 acquires a large anomalous dimension @xmath108 .
it is known that the nambu - jona - lasinio ( njl ) type four - fermion interaction becomes relevant in such a walking gauge dynamics .
the walking gauge theory was then analyzed in an extended coupling space including the njl type four - fermion interaction ( gauged njl model ) @xcite .
this resemblance motivates us to study the gauged njl model with extra dimensions . in this paper
, we therefore focus on the dynamical chiral symmetry breaking ( d@xmath109sb ) in the gauged njl model with extra dimensions .
the lagrangian of the gauged njl model with extra dimensions is given by @xmath110 \nonumber \\ & & - \frac{1}{2}{\mbox{tr}}\left(f_{mn } f^{mn}\right ) , \label{gnjl1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath111 and @xmath112 is the chirality matrix in @xmath54 dimensions , @xmath113 @xmath114 the pauli matrices , and @xmath115 the four - fermion coupling .
the gauge group is @xmath2 and @xmath116 denotes the field strength .
the gauge coupling is assumed to be on the uvfp . for simplicity , we take the number of flavor as @xmath117 , i.e. , @xmath118 in the flavor space . the number of dimensions @xmath54 is assumed to be even , @xmath119 , so as to introduce chiral fermions in the bulk .
extra @xmath120 spatial dimensions are compactified at a tev - scale @xmath81 .
it is convenient to rewrite the lagrangian eq .
( [ gnjl1 ] ) by using auxiliary fields @xmath42 , @xmath121 , @xmath122 in order to see the equivalence of eq .
( [ gnjl1 ] ) and eq .
( [ gnjl2 ] ) , we just need to eliminate the auxiliary fields @xmath42 and @xmath121 through their euler equations @xmath123 in eq .
( [ gnjl2 ] ) . the vacuum expectation value ( vev ) of @xmath42 @xmath124 is proportional to the chiral condensate in the chiral limit @xmath125 .
note that the model with @xmath125 possesses global @xmath126 chiral symmetry , @xmath127 the bare mass term @xmath128 will be taken to be zero in the analysis of the d@xmath109sb in this paper .
we express the bulk fermion propagator as @xmath129.\ ] ] nonvanishing @xmath130 implies d@xmath109sb , which can be investigated through the ( improved ) ladder schwinger - dyson ( sd ) equation .
we need to take into account the running of the bulk gauge coupling in the sd equation . in the sd equation
there are three different momenta , ( euclidean ) square of which are @xmath131 , @xmath132 and @xmath133 for the external and the loop momenta of the fermion and the gauge boson momentum , respectively .
hence there exist various ways to incorporate the running effects .
the simplest one @xcite is to take @xmath134 , which has been widely used for four - dimensional models in landau gauge where the sd equation dictates @xmath135 , so that it is consistent with the vector ward - takahashi ( wt ) identity . in the case of extra dimensions we also used this in ref .
. however , this is not consistent with the chiral wt identity @xcite , and hence we adopt as in ref .
@xcite an ansatz of ref.@xcite , namely the gauge boson momentum is identified as the renormalization scale of the gauge coupling strength , @xmath136 where @xmath97 is the dimensionless bulk gauge coupling .
we assume here that the dimensionless bulk gauge coupling is on its uvfp , @xmath137 .
the assumption is justified in case that the cutoff @xmath21 is very large and the uvfp really exists .
the sd equation is then given by @xmath138^{d/2 - 1 } } \nonumber \\[3 mm ] & & \qquad \times \left(\frac{(d-1)(d-4)}{d}+\xi\right ) , \label{eq : sdeq_a } \\[3 mm ] b(x ) & = & \sigma + ( d-1+\xi)\kappa_d \int_0^{\lambda^2}\!\!\ ! dy \frac{y^{d/2 - 1}b(y)}{a^2(y ) y + b^2(y ) } \nonumber \\ & & \qquad \times \frac{1}{[\max(x , y)]^{d/2 - 1 } } , \label{eq : sdeq_b}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have introduced ultraviolet cutoff @xmath21 and the gauge fixing parameter is denoted as @xmath139 .
@xmath140 is defined by @xmath141 we denote the gauge coupling strength by @xmath22 , @xmath142 with @xmath143 being the quadratic casimir of the fundamental representation , @xmath144 it is understood that @xmath42 stands for the vev of the auxiliary field @xmath145 in eq .
( [ eq : sdeq_b ] ) .
hereafter , we will adopt this shorthand notation without discriminating the auxiliary fields ( @xmath42 , @xmath35 ) from their vevs ( @xmath145 , @xmath146 ) . when @xmath147 and hence @xmath148 , the sd equations eqs .
( [ eq : sdeq_a ] ) and ( [ eq : sdeq_b ] ) are reduced to those of the bulk gauge theory without four - fermion interactions in a form given in @xcite .
we choose the gauge fixing parameter @xmath139 as @xcite @xmath149 with this choice of gauge fixing parameter , the fermion wave function factor becomes trivial , i.e. , @xmath150 and @xmath151 .
the sd equation then reads @xmath152^{d/2 - 1}}. \label{imp_ladder_sd}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the vev of @xmath42 is given by eq .
( [ eq : vev_sigma0 ] ) .
we thus obtain @xmath153 where we defined the _ dimensionless _ four - fermion coupling constant @xmath23 as @xmath154 and used @xmath155 the sd equation ( [ imp_ladder_sd ] ) for the mass function is equivalent to the differential equation @xmath156 & & \quad \quad + \frac{2(d-1)(d-2)}{d } \kappa_d \frac{x \sigma(x)}{x+\sigma^2 } = 0 , \label{sde_diff } \end{aligned}\ ] ] with the infrared boundary condition ( irbc ) @xmath157 and the ultraviolet boundary condition ( uvbc ) @xmath158 \sigma(x ) \bigg|_{x = \lambda^2 } = ( d/2 - 1)\sigma .
\label{uv - bc}\ ] ] the derivative of eq .
( [ imp_ladder_sd ] ) at the cutoff scale @xmath159 is given by @xmath160 from eq .
( [ eq : vev_sigma ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : derivative_sigma ] ) we see @xmath161 the uvbc then reads @xmath162 \sigma(x ) \bigg|_{x = \lambda^2 } \nonumber \\[3 mm ] = ( d/2 - 1)m_0 .
\qquad \label{uv - bc2 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath163 , the sd equation reduces to the gap equation of the pure njl model .
see the appendix of ref .
@xcite for the analysis of the @xmath164 dimensional pure njl model .
even if we start with the chiral limit @xmath165 , we expect the dynamical chiral symmetry breaking @xmath166 takes place if the njl coupling exceeds certain critical value . in order to fully analyze the behavior of the dynamical chiral phase transition in this model , we need to solve the nonlinear sd equation eq .
( [ imp_ladder_sd ] ) as it stands .
such a task turns out to be almost impossible within analytical methods , however . instead of solving the nonlinear sd equation ,
here we first adopt the bifurcation technique @xcite , restricting the solution much smaller than the cutoff scale @xmath167 .
the bifurcation technique is justified at least for the determination of the critical coupling and the leading asymptotic behavior of the mass function @xmath168 . in this section ,
we employ the bifurcation technique for the sake of simplicity to avoid unnecessarily complicated expressions in discussing the decay constant , effective yukawa coupling , and the propagator of the composite scalar , which are determined only through the dominant term of @xmath168 . on the other hand ,
the sub - dominant term is relevant to the scaling relation and the lowest interaction term of the effective potential .
the bifurcation method , however , does not always lead to the correct sub - dominant term . thus we will perform more sophisticated analysis later in section [ sec - moreabout ] to determine the sub - dominant term of @xmath168 . in the bifurcation technique , the @xmath169 terms in the denominators of eq .
( [ imp_ladder_sd ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : vev_sigma ] ) are replaced by an infrared cutoff @xmath170 @xmath171^{d/2 - 1 } } , \label{eq : integ_eq}\ ] ] with @xmath172 we also assume @xmath173 and @xmath174 . the integral equation eq .
( [ eq : integ_eq ] ) is equivalent with a set of the _ linear _ differential equation @xmath175 & & \qquad \quad + \frac{2(d-1)(d-2)}{d } \kappa_d \sigma(x ) = 0 , \label{eq : diff_eq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and boundary conditions @xmath176 and @xmath177 \sigma(x ) \bigg|_{x = \lambda^2 } = 0 .
\label{eq : uv - bc}\ ] ] the solution of eq .
( [ eq : diff_eq ] ) behaves differently for @xmath178 and for @xmath48 . here
critical value @xmath26 is obtained as @xcite @xmath179 for the sub - critical @xmath180 , the solution of eq .
( [ eq : diff_eq ] ) is given by a power - damping form , @xmath181 where @xmath182 and @xmath183 are real constants .
we also define @xmath184 and @xmath185 as @xmath186 and @xmath187 respectively . for the super - critical @xmath48 ,
on the other hand , the solution starts to oscillate , @xmath188 with @xmath189 being a complex constant .
the parameter @xmath190 and the angle @xmath191 are defined as @xmath192 and @xmath193 respectively .
let us first discuss the case with @xmath178 .
the irbc eq .
( [ eq : ir - bc ] ) leads to @xmath194 if we normalize the mass function such as @xmath195 , we can determine concretely @xmath182 and @xmath183 .
it is convenient to rewrite the uvbc eq .
( [ eq : uv - bc ] ) in the following form , @xmath196 \sigma(x ) \right|_{x=\lambda^2 } = 0 .
\label{eq : uv - bc2}\ ] ] combining eq .
( [ eq : bifurc1 ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : uv - bc2 ] ) , we obtain @xmath197 eq . ( [ eq : ir - bc2 ] ) then leads to the scaling relation ) is not correct near the pure njl limit .
actually , it fails to reproduce the scaling behavior of the @xmath54(@xmath198 ) dimensional pure njl model @xcite in the @xmath199 limit .
see section [ sec - moreabout ] for more detailed analysis of the scaling behavior . ]
@xmath200 the nontrivial solution @xmath201 exists only when the njl coupling exceeds the critical line , @xmath202 see figure [ fig : critical_line ] for the phase diagram in the @xmath22-@xmath23 plane .
note that the negative sign in eq .
( [ eq : ir - bc2 ] ) is essentially important .
if the sign of @xmath183 were identical to @xmath182 , we would not obtain positive value in eq .
( [ eq : scaling0 ] ) for @xmath203 , indicating the instability of the vacuum . we will be back to this problem later in sec .
[ eff_pot ] . from eq .
( [ eq : bifurc1 ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : ir - bc2 ] ) , we also obtain the asymptotic form of the nontrivial solution ,
@xmath204 we next consider the condensate @xmath42 , which can be calculated from eq .
( [ uv - bc ] ) .
we obtain @xmath205 neglecting the sub - dominant term . the asymptotic solution eq .
( [ eq : asymp_sol ] ) can be written in terms of @xmath42 , @xmath206 the mass function @xmath207 is thus proportional to the order parameter @xmath42 .
we will use eq .
( [ eq : asymp_sol2 ] ) later in sec .
[ sec - yukawa ] to calculate the yukawa vertex of the composite scalar field @xmath42 .
we next turn to the case with @xmath48 . from the irbc eq .
( [ eq : ir - bc ] ) we find @xmath208 on the other hand , the uvbc eq .
( [ eq : uv - bc ] ) gives @xmath209 with @xmath210 being given by @xmath211 we note that nontrivial solution @xmath201 exists in eq .
( [ eq : uv - bc3 ] ) , irrespective of the size of the njl coupling .
this could be easily understood in an analytical manner by looking at the region @xmath212 , where we can use an approximation @xmath213 eq .
( [ eq : uv - bc3 ] ) then leads to a scaling relation ( zero - node solution ) @xmath214 for @xmath215 we find @xmath216 $ ] .
we next consider the continuum limit ( @xmath217 ) in the present model . as we stated before ,
we simply admit the existence of the uvfp in the gauge coupling strength in the present analysis .
one might thus think that we should be able to obtain a finite theory even in the @xmath217 limit thanks to the uvfp .
this is a non - trivial problem , however , in the d@xmath109sb vacuum . as we see in eq .
( [ eq : scaling1 ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : scaling2 ] ) , the dynamical mass of the fermion ( @xmath170 ) is proportional to the cutoff @xmath21 and thus diverges in the @xmath217 limit if both @xmath23 and @xmath22 are fixed . in other words , in order to keep @xmath170 finite , the njl coupling @xmath23 needs to approach its critical value eq .
( [ eq : g_crit ] ) in the @xmath217 limit .
this procedure , known as the wilsonian renormalization , allows us to define the continuum limit of the gauged njl model .
hereafter we use the word `` renormalization '' in this sense .
recall that the d@xmath109sb always takes place regardless the njl coupling @xmath23 for @xmath48 .
there does not exist critical njl coupling with this @xmath22 .
what does happen in the continuum limit for @xmath48 then ? instead of @xmath23 , one may think about tuning @xmath22 to its critical value @xmath26 .
this procedure can not be done , however , since @xmath22 is essentially given by the uvfp of the gauge coupling strength in eq .
( [ eq : def_kappad ] ) .
the value of @xmath22 should be fixed once the discrete model parameters such as @xmath32 and @xmath3 are determined .
we thus conclude that there is no finite continuum limit for @xmath48 at least within the ladder approximation .
we probably need to introduce other higher dimensional interactions in order to define the continuum limit with @xmath48 .
we also note that @xmath218 can not be achieved for @xmath219 within the approximations we used .
it happens @xmath220 , for instance , for @xmath221 and @xmath222 .
] we thus concentrate upon the @xmath178 case hereafter .
there appear massless nambu - goldstone ( ng ) fields in the d@xmath109sb vacuum .
the interaction of the ng field is then described by the low energy theorem and its decay constant . in this subsection
, we estimate the size of the decay constant by using an approximation proposed by pagels and stokar ( ps ) @xcite . the decay constant can be written solely in terms of the mass function @xmath207 within the ps approximation . we know that the ps approximation works reasonably well in the d@xmath109sb of four - dimensional qcd .
the @xmath54-dimensional generalization of the ps formula is given by @xmath223 where @xmath34 denotes the decay constant in @xmath54 dimensions @xmath224 the four - dimensional decay constant @xmath225 is obtained through the matching condition @xmath226 it is straightforward to estimate the decay constant by using the asymptotic behavior of the mass function eq .
( [ eq : asymp_sol ] ) , @xmath227 note that @xmath34 diverges in the @xmath217 limit for @xmath228 the condition eq .
( [ eq : mtcondition1 ] ) can be rewritten in terms of @xmath22 , @xmath229 with the marginal triviality ( mt ) point @xmath40 being defined as @xmath230 the ng field interaction is suppressed by @xmath231 according to the low energy theorem . for @xmath232
the ng field is therefore decoupled from the rest of system and becomes trivial in the continuum limit ( @xmath217 ) .
on the other hand , surprisingly enough , the decay constant @xmath34 remains finite for @xmath233 even in the continuum limit @xmath217 .
once the condition eq .
( [ eq : mtcondition3 ] ) is satisfied , the ng field enjoys non - trivial interactions in the `` renormalized '' theory of the higher dimensional gauged njl model .
the mt point @xmath40 is indicated by a cross in the phase diagram figure [ fig : critical_line ] . at this point
the decay constant @xmath34 diverges as @xmath41 , while @xmath234 for @xmath235 .
in @xmath44 we find @xmath43 , namely the mt point coincides with the pure njl point , where it is well - known @xmath77 diverges logarithmically . on the other hand , in the @xmath236 limit @xmath237 , and hence the region of the finite @xmath34 is squeezed out .
in addition to the ng bosons , a composite scalar boson also appears in the spectrum of the njl type models . as we will show later , the auxiliary scalar field @xmath42 of eq .
( [ gnjl2 ] ) actually acquires non - trivial propagator at the loop level . in this subsection
, we adopt a simple method proposed by appelquist , terning , and wijewardhana ( atw ) @xcite to calculate roughly the properties of the composite scalar .
we also describe more sophisticated method based on ref .
@xcite in appendix a. these results qualitatively agree with each other .
the auxiliary field @xmath42 propagator at @xmath238 is given by @xmath239 \nonumber \\ & & + \mbox{constant } , \label{eq : aux_prop}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath240 is the yukawa type vertex of the auxiliary field , and @xmath241 and @xmath242 are the @xmath243 and @xmath42 momenta , respectively . the basic difficulty in the calculation of eq .
( [ eq : aux_prop ] ) arises from our lack of knowledge of @xmath240 . in appendix a , we calculate analytically @xmath240 with certain approximations . as for the effective yukawa vertex at @xmath244 ,
on the other hand , we easily find @xmath245 where we used eq .
( [ eq : asymp_sol2 ] ) . for the relation between @xmath207 and @xmath45 , see , e.g. , ref .
@xcite .
atw showed that eq .
( [ eq : aux_prop ] ) can be approximated by @xmath246 \nonumber \\ & & + \mbox{constant } , \label{eq : aux_prop2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] within reasonable assumptions .
note that eq .
( [ eq : aux_prop2 ] ) contains yukawa vertex only at @xmath244 , @xmath247 and we are thus able to use eq .
( [ yukawa ] ) in the evaluation of the @xmath42 propagator .
after the wick rotation and performing the angular integrals , we obtain @xmath248 , \nonumber\\ & & \hspace*{-0.5 cm } = 2^{d/2 } n_c n_f { \omega_{\rm nda}}\int_0^{\lambda^2}\!\!\!\ ! dy \
, y^{d/2 - 2 } \gamma_s^2(y ) k ( x , y ) , \label{sigma_prop}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we defined @xmath249 the kernel @xmath250 is given by @xmath251 for even dimensions we obtain @xmath252 where @xmath253 is defined as @xmath254 and @xmath255 .
substituting eq .
( [ yukawa ] ) for eq .
( [ sigma_prop ] ) , we obtain the composite scalar propagator for @xmath256 ( @xmath257 ) : @xmath258 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath259 and @xmath260 at the marginal triviality point @xmath261 ( @xmath262 ) , we find @xmath263 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath264 and @xmath265 we next consider the @xmath217 limit .
it is convenient to renormalize the auxiliary field @xmath42 @xmath266 in such a limit .
we define the renormalization constant @xmath267 so as to keep the renormalized propagator finite , @xmath268 { \displaystyle \left(\dfrac{\lambda}{\mu}\right)^{2(\nu-1 ) } \ln\left ( \dfrac{\lambda^2}{\mu^2 } \right ) , } & { \displaystyle ( \kappa_d = \kappa_d^{\rm mt } ) , } \\[3ex ] { \displaystyle \left(\dfrac{\lambda}{\mu}\right)^{2(\nu-1 ) } , } & { \displaystyle ( 0 < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm mt } ) . } \end{array } \right .
\label{eq : z_wav}\ ] ] the renormalized propagator is then given by @xmath269 & & \left\ { \begin{array}{l@{\quad}c } { \displaystyle c_{\nu\omega } \mu^{2\nu } \left(\dfrac{x}{\mu^2}\right)^{\nu\omega } , } & { \displaystyle ( \kappa_d^{\rm mt } < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm crit } ) , } \\[3ex ] { \displaystyle c_{0 } \mu^{2\nu } \left(\dfrac{x}{\mu^2}\right ) , } & { \displaystyle ( \kappa_d = \kappa_d^{\rm mt } ) , } \\[3ex ] { \displaystyle c_{\ell=1 } \mu^{2\nu } \left(\dfrac{x}{\mu^2}\right ) , } & { \displaystyle ( 0 < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm mt } ) , } \end{array } \right . \nonumber\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the @xmath217 limit . what does happen for the yukawa type vertex ,
then ? from eq .
( [ yukawa ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : z_wav ] ) we obtain @xmath270 & & \left\ { \begin{array}{l@{\quad}c } { \displaystyle \frac{2}{1+\omega } \left(\frac{-q^2}{\mu^2}\right)^{-\frac{\nu}{2}(1-\omega)}. } & { \displaystyle ( \kappa_d^{\rm mt } < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm crit}),\quad } \\[4ex ] { \displaystyle 0 } & { \displaystyle ( 0
< \kappa_d \le \kappa_d^{\rm mt } ) , } \end{array } \right . \nonumber \\ \label{eq : ren_yukawa } \end{aligned}\ ] ] in the @xmath217 limit . we note that the composite scalar thus decouples from the rest of the system for @xmath271 in the continuum limit . on the other hand , for @xmath272 , the composite scalar interacts with fermions in a non - trivial manner through the yukawa vertex eq .
( [ eq : ren_yukawa ] ) .
these behaviors are consistent with our analysis of the ng field ( decay constant ) in the previous subsection .
for the determination of the precise scaling behavior around the critical line , it is not enough to know the dominant asymptotic behavior of mass function eq .
( [ eq : asymp_sol ] ) .
actually , lacking the sub - dominant term , the bifurcation method does not reproduce exactly the same scaling relation ( gap equation ) as that of the pure njl model in the vanishing gauge coupling limit even in four dimensions @xcite .
we also need information of sub - dominant terms .
the sub - dominant terms are also required in the calculation of the effective potential .
unfortunately , the bifurcation technique is not enough for such a purpose . in this section
, we evaluate the sub - dominant terms first in the well - known linearized sd equation , and next in the power expansion method .
it is known that the linearized approximation works well in four dimensions . by using the linearized ansatz
, we can solve analytically the ladder sd equation .
we obtain the coefficient of the sub - dominant term as well as its exponent .
the power expansion method reflects the correct asymptotic behavior of the nonlinear sd equation .
however , we can determine only the exponent of the sub - dominant term in the method .
the coefficient of the sub - dominant term is left as an unknown parameter . in a certain region of the gauge coupling
, it turns out that the exponent of the sub - dominant term is different depending on the methods .
we thus describe both results .
we first consider the linearized sd equation @xcite , in which the @xmath169 term in the denominator is replaced by a constant @xmath273 .
this approximation works well in the determination of the dominant asymptotic solution at @xmath274 .
it is also known that the scaling behavior determined from the linearized sd equation closely approximates to the numerical results of the non - linear sd equation in the case of the four - dimensional gauged njl model .
the linearized sd equation is given by @xmath275^{d/2 - 1 } } , \label{eq : linearized_sd } \\
\sigma & = & m_0 + \frac{g}{\lambda^{d-2 } } \int_0^{\lambda^2 } dx x^{d/2 - 1 } \dfrac{\sigma(x)}{x + \sigma_0 ^ 2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] and a subsidiary condition , @xmath276 the integral equation eq . ( [ eq : linearized_sd ] ) is equivalently rewritten in terms of a set of differential equation and boundary conditions ,
@xmath277 @xmath278 \sigma(x ) \bigg|_{x = \lambda^2 } & = & \nu \sigma , \quad \label{eq : uv - bc2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath184 and @xmath185 are defined in eq .
( [ eq : nudef ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : omegadef ] ) . the uvbc eq .
( [ eq : uv - bc2 ] ) can also be expressed as @xmath279 \sigma(x ) \bigg|_{x = \lambda^2 } = \nu m_0 .
\quad \label{eq : uv - bc3}\ ] ] note that the differential equation ( [ eq : sddifflinear ] ) possesses three regular singular points at @xmath280 .
the solution is then expressed by using the gauss hypergeometric functions .
it is now easy to find the solution of eq .
( [ eq : sddifflinear ] ) satisfying the subsidiary condition eq .
( [ eq : subsidiary ] ) and the irbc eq .
( [ eq : ir - bc2 ] ) , @xmath281 where @xmath282 is the gauss hypergeometric function @xmath283 with @xmath284 , @xmath285 , @xmath286 being defined in eq .
( [ eq : hyperdef ] ) .
we assumed here @xmath178 and hence a real and positive @xmath185 . the uvbc eq .
( [ eq : uv - bc3 ] ) determines @xmath170 and thus the scaling relation .
we need to know the behavior of the mass function eq .
( [ eq : solution_in_hypergeo ] ) in the ultraviolet region @xmath287 .
for such a purpose , it is convenient to use a well - known formula @xcite , @xmath288 combining eq .
( [ eq : hypergeo_def ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : hypergeo_formula ] ) , we expand the solution eq .
( [ eq : solution_in_hypergeo ] ) for @xmath274 , @xmath289 with @xmath290 and @xmath291 being given by @xmath292 the @xmath182 term in eq .
( [ eq : linearized_sd_asymptotic ] ) gives the leading contribution to the mass function @xmath168 in the asymptotic region @xmath287 for @xmath178 .
the next - to - leading contribution , on the other hand , comes from @xmath293 or @xmath183 , depending on the value of @xmath22 .
for @xmath74 @xmath183 term gives the next - to - leading contribution , while @xmath293 term becomes the next - to - leading for @xmath294 . at @xmath295
the power of @xmath293 and @xmath183 terms goes same in the expression of eq .
( [ eq : linearized_sd_asymptotic ] ) .
although the coefficients @xmath296 and @xmath297 diverge at @xmath295 , i.e. , @xmath261 , they cancel out each other , so that the logarithmic term appears , @xmath298 in order to determine the scaling relation near the critical line , we compare the leading ( @xmath182 ) and the next - to - leading ( @xmath183 or @xmath182 depending on @xmath22 ) terms in the uvbc eq .
( [ eq : uv - bc3 ] ) . for @xmath125 , we find @xmath299 for @xmath74 , and @xmath300 for @xmath301 , where we used @xmath302 .
note here that the signs of @xmath182 and @xmath183 ( @xmath293 ) are opposite to each other for @xmath303 ( @xmath294 ) .
we thus find @xmath304 { \displaystyle \sqrt { 1 - \dfrac{g^{\rm crit}}{g } } } , & { \displaystyle ( 0 \leq \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm mt } ) . } \end{array } \right .
\label{gapeq - linear}\ ] ] note here that eq .
( [ gapeq - linear ] ) in @xmath199 limit agrees with the scaling relation obtained in the @xmath54(@xmath198 ) dimensional pure njl model @xcite .
the chiral condensate is calculated from eq .
( [ uv - bc ] ) , @xmath305 for @xmath74 , and @xmath306 for @xmath307 .
further details of our analysis on the linearized sd equation are given in appendix [ sec - appendix2 ] .
we next try to investigate the sub - dominant asymptotic solution directly from the non - linear sd equation eq .
( [ imp_ladder_sd ] ) without using the linearizing ansatz of the previous subsection .
@xcite the non - linear differential equation eq .
( [ sde_diff ] ) and the boundary conditions eqs .
( [ ir - bc ] ) and ( [ uv - bc ] ) can be rewritten as @xmath308 \sigma(x ) \right|_{x=\lambda^2 } = \nu m_0 .
\label{eq : pe_uvbc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath309 the last term in the non - linear differential equation eq .
( [ eq : pe_diff ] ) can be expanded as @xmath310 eq .
( [ eq : pe_expansion1 ] ) allows us formally to expand the solution @xmath207 of eq .
( [ eq : pe_diff ] ) , @xmath311 where @xmath312 is the solution of a homogeneous linear differential equation @xmath313 \sigma_1(x ) = 0 , \label{eq : pe_diff1}\ ] ] while @xmath314 is the inhomogeneous part of the solution of @xmath315 \sigma_2(x ) \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad = \dfrac{\nu^2(1-\omega^2)}{4}\dfrac{\sigma_1 ^ 3(x)}{x}. \label{eq : pe_diff2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the higher terms in the expansion eq .
( [ eq : pe_expansion2 ] ) are given in a similar manner to eq .
( [ eq : pe_diff2 ] ) just by replacing the r.h.s . to @xmath316 , @xmath317 , @xmath318 , @xmath319 , @xmath320 . what does the expansion eq .
( [ eq : pe_expansion2 ] ) mean then ?
the solution of eq .
( [ eq : pe_diff1 ] ) is given by @xmath321 with @xmath170 being a constant with a mass dimension .
we thus obtain @xmath322 with @xmath323 , @xmath324 , @xmath325 , @xmath326 .
note that the exponent of the power damping of @xmath314 is steeper than that of @xmath312 for @xmath287 .
it is also obvious that the higher terms in the expansion eq .
( [ eq : pe_expansion2 ] ) falls quicker even than @xmath314 for @xmath274 . the expansion eq .
( [ eq : pe_expansion2 ] ) can therefore be understood as an `` power expansion '' in this sense .
since we are interested only in the dominant term ( @xmath182 ) and in the sub - dominant term ( @xmath183 or @xmath293 depending on @xmath22 ) , we restrict our analysis to these three terms .
the power damping behavior of @xmath182 and @xmath183 terms agree with those in the linearized sd equation .
we note , however , the exponent of the power damping of the @xmath293 term differs from the the result of the linearized sd equation .
actually , the @xmath293 term becomes sub - dominant for @xmath327 , @xmath328 \kappa_d^{\rm crit}.\ ] ] we also note @xmath329 for @xmath82 .
we first consider the case @xmath330 , where the @xmath183 term gives the sub - dominant contribution . since the power expansion can not be adopted in the infrared region , we are not able to use the irbc eq .
( [ eq : pe_irbc ] ) to determine the coefficient @xmath182 and @xmath183 .
if we assume that @xmath183 possesses opposite sign to @xmath182 , we find a scaling relation similar to eq .
( [ eq : lin_scaling1 ] ) . for @xmath331 , on the other hand , the r.h.s . of eq .
( [ eq : lin_scaling1 ] ) becomes negative .
( [ eq : lin_scaling1 ] ) thus can not be understood as a scaling relation .
this problem may be related with the vacuum instability which will be discussed in sec.[eff_pot ] .
hereafter we assume the result in the linearized sd equation , @xmath332 , remains to be valid even in the power expansion method for @xmath333 .
we next turn to the @xmath327 case , where the @xmath293 term gives the sub - dominant contribution . from eq .
( [ eq : pe_diff2 ] ) , we find @xmath334 and thus @xmath335 .
the scaling relation is then given by @xmath336 with this @xmath22 , where we used @xmath302 .
we thus find @xmath337 { \displaystyle \left ( 1 - \dfrac{g^{\rm crit}}{g } \right)^{\frac{1}{2\nu(1-\omega)+2 } } } , & { \displaystyle ( 0 \leq \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm pe } ) . }
\end{array } \right .
\label{gapeq - pow}\ ] ] as in the linearized approximation , the coefficient @xmath293 in eq .
( [ eq : c2c1 ] ) diverges at @xmath338 , i.e , @xmath339 .
this implies that the logarithmic term appears at the point .
we can easily confirm that @xmath314 given by @xmath340 satisfies eq .
( [ eq : pe_diff2 ] ) .
the chiral condensation is calculated from eq .
( [ uv - bc ] ) , @xmath341 for @xmath342 , while @xmath343 for @xmath344 .
we here outline our method to calculate the effective potential @xmath345 in the gauged njl model .
see refs .
@xcite for details . for simplicity
we assume @xmath346 in this analysis .
it is easy to restore the @xmath121 degree of freedom by using the chiral symmetry , i.e. , @xmath347 .
we start with the partition function @xmath348 $ ] , @xmath349 \equiv \frac{1}{i } \ln \int [ d\psi d\bar\psi ] [ { \rm gauge } ] \exp \left ( i\int d^d x ( { \cal l } + j \sigma ) \right ) , \label{eq : defwj}\ ] ] with @xmath350 being the lagrangian of the auxiliary field description of the gauged njl model eq .
( [ gnjl2 ] ) . for a constant external field @xmath351
, the partition function can be written as @xmath349 = \int d^d x w(j).\ ] ] we note @xmath352 with @xmath42 in the r.h.s . being understood as the vev of @xmath42 . solving @xmath351 as a function of @xmath42 in eq .
( [ eq : wj ] ) , we define the effective potential @xmath345 , @xmath353 and thus obtain @xmath354 we next describe how we calculate @xmath351 in terms of @xmath42 . looking at eq .
( [ gnjl2 ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : defwj ] ) , we find the effect of constant @xmath351 can be taken into account by replacing the bare mass @xmath128 , @xmath355 in the sd equation . from eq .
( [ sigma ] ) we obtain @xmath356 the derivative at the cutoff @xmath357 can be calculated from the uvbc eq .
( [ uv - bc ] ) , @xmath358,\ ] ] which leads to a compact expression for @xmath351 , @xmath359 .
\label{eq : expressionj}\ ] ] we thus obtain the effective potential @xmath345 in terms of @xmath42 and @xmath360 : @xmath361 & & -\frac{1}{g}\frac{m_0 \sigma}{\lambda^2}+\frac{1}{2 g } \dfrac{\sigma^2}{\lambda^2 } \nonumber \\[3 mm ] & & + \frac{4}{\nu(1-\omega^2)}\frac{1}{\lambda^2 } \int d\sigma \ , [ \sigma-\sigma(\lambda^2 ) ]
. \label{pot_gen}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the pure njl limit @xmath163 ,
i.e. , @xmath362 , we should return to eq .
( [ imp_ladder_sd ] ) . plugging with @xmath363 and eqs .
( [ eq : vev_sigma ] ) , ( [ eq : replace ] ) , we easily find @xmath364 & & \hspace*{-6 mm } = -\frac{1}{g}\frac{m_0 \sigma}{\lambda^2}+\frac{1}{2 g } \dfrac{\sigma^2}{\lambda^2 } -\frac{1}{\lambda^2 } \int d\sigma \
, \int_0 ^ 1 dz \frac{z^{\nu}\,\sigma}{z+\frac{\sigma^2}{\lambda^2 } } , \nonumber \\[3 mm ] & & \hspace*{-6 mm } = -\frac{1}{g}\frac{m_0 \sigma}{\lambda^2 } + \frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{1}{g}-\frac{1}{\nu}\right ) \dfrac{\sigma^2}{\lambda^2 } + \frac{1}{4(\nu-1 ) } \dfrac{\sigma^4}{\lambda^4 } \nonumber \\[3 mm ] & & \hspace*{-6 mm } \qquad + { \cal o}\left(\frac{\sigma^6}{\lambda^6}\right ) , \qquad ( \kappa_d=0 ) .
\label{pot_njl}\end{aligned}\ ] ] since the sub - dominant term of @xmath360 with nonvanishing gauge coupling depends on the approximations , we calculate @xmath345 separately . in the calculation of the effective potential @xmath345 , we need to express @xmath360 in term of @xmath42 .
let us start with the solution of the linearized sd equation for @xmath333 .
combining eq .
( [ eq : linearized_sigma1 ] ) with @xmath365 we obtain @xmath366 we are now able to calculate the effective potential from eq .
( [ eq : localpot1 ] ) , eq .
( [ eq : expressionj ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : sigma_at_lambda1 ] ) , @xmath367 & & -\frac{1}{g}\frac{m_0 \sigma}{\lambda^2}+\frac{1}{2 } \left(\frac{1}{g}-\frac{1}{g^{\rm crit}}\right ) \dfrac{\sigma^2}{\lambda^2 } \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad + a_1 \left(\frac{\sigma}{\lambda } \right)^{2+\frac{2\nu\omega}{\nu(1-\omega)+1 } } + \cdots , \label{eq : linearized_pot1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath368 . here
the coefficient @xmath369 is defined as @xmath370 it is straightforward to perform similar analysis for @xmath371 .
we obtain @xmath372 & & -\frac{1}{g}\frac{m_0 \sigma}{\lambda^2}+\frac{1}{2 } \left(\frac{1}{g}-\frac{1}{g^{\rm crit}}\right ) \dfrac{\sigma^2}{\lambda^2 } \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad\quad + a_2 \left(\frac{\sigma}{\lambda}\right)^{2+\frac{2}{\nu(1-\omega)+1 } } + \cdots , \label{eq : linearized_pot2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath373 .
the coefficient @xmath374 is defined as @xmath375 the calculation at @xmath262 is a little bit involved , since we need to take account of both @xmath183 and @xmath293 . by using formulas given in appendix [ sec - appendix2 ] ,
we obtain @xmath372 & & -\frac{1}{g}\frac{m_0 \sigma}{\lambda^2}+\frac{1}{2 } \left(\frac{1}{g}-\frac{1}{g^{\rm crit}}\right ) \dfrac{\sigma^2}{\lambda^2 } \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad\quad + a'_2 \left(\frac{\sigma}{\lambda } \right)^{2+\frac{2}{\nu } } \ln \left(\frac{\lambda}{\sigma}\right ) + \cdots , \label{eq : linearized_pot3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath262 and the coefficient @xmath376 is given by @xmath377 using eqs .
( [ eq : c_n ] ) and ( [ eq : d_n ] ) , we find the coefficients @xmath369 , @xmath374 and @xmath376 are all positive definite in the linearized sd equation .
the potential is therefore stabilized for large value of @xmath42 even if we truncate the potential and neglect @xmath378 terms in eqs .
( [ eq : linearized_pot1 ] ) , ( [ eq : linearized_pot2 ] ) and ( [ eq : linearized_pot3 ] ) .
the effective potential @xmath345 can also be calculated in the power expansion method .
we should keep it in mind , however , that the coefficients @xmath182 and @xmath183 can not be determined with the power expansion method , unlike the calculation in the linearized sd equation .
we here summarize our results of the effective potential in the power expansion method : @xmath379 & & -\frac{1}{g}\frac{m_0 \sigma}{\lambda^2}+\frac{1}{2 } \left(\frac{1}{g}-\frac{1}{g^{\rm crit}}\right ) \dfrac{\sigma^2}{\lambda^2 } \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad + \tilde a_1 \left(\frac{\sigma}{\lambda } \right)^{2+\frac{2\nu\omega}{\nu(1-\omega)+1 } } + \cdots , \label{eff - pot - pow1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath380 , and @xmath379 & & -\frac{1}{g}\frac{m_0 \sigma}{\lambda^2}+\frac{1}{2 } \left(\frac{1}{g}-\frac{1}{g^{\rm crit}}\right ) \dfrac{\sigma^2}{\lambda^2 } \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad + \tilde a_2 \ , \frac{\sigma^4}{\lambda^4}+\cdots , \label{eff_pot_pw2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath381 , and @xmath379 & & -\frac{1}{g}\frac{m_0 \sigma}{\lambda^2}+\frac{1}{2 } \left(\frac{1}{g}-\frac{1}{g^{\rm crit}}\right ) \dfrac{\sigma^2}{\lambda^2 } \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad + \tilde a'_2 \ , \frac{\sigma^4}{\lambda^4 } \ln \left(\frac{\lambda}{\sigma}\right)+\cdots , \label{eff_pot_pw3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath338 .
the coefficients @xmath382 , @xmath383 and @xmath384 are defined by @xmath385 respectively .
we emphasize here , due to the lack of our knowledge of @xmath182 and @xmath183 , the coefficient @xmath386 can not be calculated in the power expansion method . on the other hand , we find @xmath387 for @xmath388 , independently of @xmath182 .
we comment that the exponent of the lowest interaction term ( @xmath386 term ) in eq .
( [ eq : linearized_pot1 ] ) is the same as that of @xmath369 in eq .
( [ eff - pot - pow1 ] ) . in passing
, the bifurcation solution also leads to the same exponent of the lowest interaction term .
thus the lowest interaction term in the effective potential is insensitive to the approximations of the sd equation for @xmath74 .
note that @xmath389 . on the other hand , for @xmath390 ,
the exponent of the lowest interaction term is different depending on the approximations .
in sec . [ sec3 ] we found `` renormalizability '' or `` nontriviality '' in the sense that the decay constant @xmath34 and the renormalized yukawa coupling @xmath391 become finite in the continuum limit for @xmath74 .
here we further study the renormalization and discuss the renormalization group ( rg ) flow , based on the effective potential derived in sec .
[ eff_pot ] .
the renormalization of the effective potential is performed in a way similar to the four - dimensional gauged njl model @xcite .
this method is applicable not only in the broken phase , but also in the symmetric phase .
note that we already renormalized the @xmath42 field in eq .
( [ eq : z_wav ] ) so that its kinetic term is kept finite . for @xmath74
we require the bare parameters ( @xmath128 and @xmath23 ) in the effective potential to depend on the cutoff ( @xmath392 and @xmath393 ) such that @xmath394 and @xmath395 the effective potential is thus kept finite even in the continuum limit @xmath396 ( wilsonian renormalization ) .
we define the renormalized parameters @xmath397 as @xmath398 and @xmath399 with @xmath86 being the renormalization scale . the effective potential eq .
( [ eq : linearized_pot1 ] ) ( linearizing approximation ) is thus renormalized as @xmath400 & & -\frac{1}{g_r}\frac{m_r \sigma_r}{\mu^2}+\frac{1}{2 } \left(\frac{1}{g_r}-\frac{1}{g^{\rm crit}}\right ) \dfrac{\sigma_r^2}{\mu^2 } \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\quad + a_1 \left(\frac{\sigma_r}{\mu } \right)^{2+\frac{2\nu\omega}{\nu(1-\omega)+1 } } , \label{eq : renormalized_pot1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath368 , and similarly is eq .
( [ eff - pot - pow1 ] ) ( power expansion method ) .
note that the `` @xmath378 '' terms in eqs .
( [ eq : linearized_pot1 ] ) and ( [ eff - pot - pow1 ] ) are decoupled in the @xmath217 limit .
the @xmath42 field has non - trivial self - interaction in the renormalized effective potential .
recall that @xmath401 .
the potential is therefore stabilized and the vev of @xmath60 remains finite for @xmath402 .
we emphasize that the form of the renormalized effective potential @xmath403 does not depend on the approximations , although the coefficient of the interaction term does . from eqs .
( [ ren_m1 ] ) and ( [ ren_g1 ] ) we obtain the beta function of the dimensionless four - fermion coupling @xmath50 , @xmath404 and the anomalous dimension of the fermion mass @xmath405 , @xmath406 , \label{beta - m1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath74 .
they take the same form as those in the four - dimensional gauged njl model with fixed gauge coupling @xcite up to the factor @xmath407 ( @xmath4 ) .
we note the beta function of the njl coupling possesses a uvfp @xmath408 . at the fixed point of @xmath50
the anomalous dimension @xmath405 reads @xmath409 let us turn to the region @xmath235 . in this region
the decay constant @xmath34 diverges as we mentioned .
it is thus expected that the same renormalization procedure as in the region @xmath74 will break down .
in fact , if we formally performed such a renormalization , we would get the renormalized effective potential would take the same form as eq .
( [ eq : renormalized_pot2 ] ) . although the definition of @xmath50 and @xmath410 in eqs .
( [ ren_m2 ] ) and ( [ ren_g2 ] ) should be modified by logarithmic factors , the beta function and the anomalous dimension are unchanged from eqs .
( [ beta - g2 ] ) and ( [ beta - m2 ] ) . if one took the limit @xmath411 of the expression in eq .
( [ eq : renormalized_pot1 ] ) , one would find the pole in the coefficient @xmath369 .
this pole actually is logarithmic divergence @xmath412 when the sub - sub - leading term is properly incorporated in the limit @xmath396 as in the pure njl limit of the four - dimensional gauged njl model @xcite .
after the renormalization of the @xmath42 field eq .
( [ eq : z_wav ] ) , we find the interaction term vanishes in @xmath403 , consistently with eq .
( [ eq : renormalized_pot2 ] ) . ]
@xmath400 & & -\frac{1}{g_r}\frac{m_r \sigma_r}{\mu^2}+\frac{1}{2 } \left(\frac{1}{g_r}-\frac{1}{g^{\rm crit}}\right ) \dfrac{\sigma_r^2}{\mu^2 } , \label{eq : renormalized_pot2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we defined @xmath410 and @xmath50 as @xmath413 and @xmath414 this renormalization would imply the beta function and the anomalous dimension : @xmath415 and @xmath416 the anomalous dimension @xmath405 would read @xmath417 at the uvfp of @xmath50 . however , the self - interaction term in @xmath403 eq .
( [ eq : renormalized_pot2 ] ) disappears at @xmath396 in our renormalization procedure both in the linearized approximation and in the power expansion method .
thus the renormalized potential is not stabilized for @xmath402 and hence the renormalization breaks down .
the yukawa interaction does also vanish and hence interactions of @xmath42 and @xmath35 are all trivial .
let us next consider the dynamical dimension of composite operators . within the ladder approximation adopted in this paper ,
various composite operators have the dynamical dimensions , @xmath418 with @xmath419 using eqs .
( [ ano - fp1 ] ) and ( [ ano - fp2 ] ) , we find @xmath420 d-2 , & ( 0 \leq \kappa_d \leq \kappa_d^{\rm mt } ) , \end{array}\right.\ ] ] @xmath421 2d-4 , & ( 0 \leq \kappa_d \leq \kappa_d^{\rm mt } ) , \end{array}\right.\ ] ] @xmath422 & & \left\{\begin{array}{l@{\qquad}c } d+2 - 2\nu\omega , & ( \kappa_d^{\rm mt } < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm crit } ) , \\[3 mm ] d , & ( 0 \leq \kappa_d \leq \kappa_d^{\rm mt } ) .
\nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] the four - fermion operator @xmath423 is relevant in the whole region @xmath424 , which justifies the inclusion of the four - fermion interaction in the study of the phase structure of walking gauge theories . for the region @xmath425 both operators @xmath426 and @xmath70 are irrelevant , i.e. , dim(@xmath426 ) @xmath427 and dim(@xmath428 ) @xmath427 .
this is consistent with our renormalization procedure without introducing such operators .
on the other hand , for @xmath78 , the kinetic operator @xmath70 becomes marginal , dim(@xmath428 ) @xmath429 , while the eight - fermion operator @xmath426 is irrelevant , dim(@xmath426 ) @xmath427 .
this is another symptom of breakdown of our renormalization in this region .
we may need to incorporate the marginal operator @xmath70 as a counter term , which is similar to the situation in the four - dimensional pure njl model where both @xmath430 and @xmath426 are marginal @xcite .
we comment on further symptom of breakdown of our renormalization procedure for @xmath78 .
if we renormalized consistently the effective action in this region , we would expect the renormalization of @xmath107 as @xmath431 note that @xmath432 , while eq .
( [ chi - cond ] ) yields @xmath433 where we used the asymptotic behavior of the dominant solution in eq .
( [ eq : asymp_sol ] ) .
thus eq .
( [ psi - r ] ) diverges as @xmath434 .
this can be understood by noting @xmath435 , the vev of which is divergent due to the lack of the interaction term as stabilizer in @xmath403 eq .
( [ eq : renormalized_pot2 ] ) .
this reflects necessity of other operators such as the kinetic operator @xmath70 as counter terms .
see appendix [ app - d ] for further details .
we depict our results mentioned above in fig .
[ phase - r ] and tables [ tab1][tab3 ] of the nontrivial window : it could arise from the ambiguity of the estimate of @xmath26 in the improved ladder sd equation with different momentum identification for the running gauge coupling @xcite . although , as we mentioned in sect.[sec3 ] , our momentum identification eq .
( [ imp_ladder ] ) with nonlocal gauge fixing has much advantage over the simplest one @xcite , @xmath436 , with landau gauge fixing , one might use the latter . then one could get somewhat smaller values:@xcite @xmath437 , @xmath438 , and @xmath439 , compared with those in the present paper ,
@xmath440 $ ] .
this would shift the nontrivial window for a fixed @xmath32 to a somewhat smaller @xmath3 region .
for example , the model with @xmath441 would enter the nontrivial window . ] : * the region @xmath48 _ no finite continuum theory . _
+ as we discussed in sec .
[ sec3 ] , the gauge coupling strength on the uvfp @xmath22 is not a continuous parameter , so that @xmath22 can not be fine - tuned arbitrarily close to @xmath26 to make the dynamical mass finite in the continuum limit ( @xmath396 ) .
for example , models with @xmath442 fall into this category .
* the region @xmath74 _ nontrivial window . _ + the dynamical mass can be made finite by fine - tuning of the four - fermion coupling . once the dynamical mass is made finite ,
the decay constant of the ng boson is also finite and so is the yukawa coupling of the ng boson .
the self - interaction of @xmath60 and the yukawa interaction remain nontrivial .
we also note that the self - interaction of @xmath60 is conformal symmetric .
the renormalized four - fermion coupling @xmath50 has a uvfp @xmath51 and the anomalous dimension @xmath405 is very large , @xmath443 .
for example , models with @xmath444 fall into this category .
the nontrivial window gets closed , @xmath237 , when @xmath445 .
* the region @xmath78 _ trivial or nonrenormalizable . _
+ even if we made the dynamical mass finite by fine - tuning the four - fermion coupling , the decay constant does diverge in the continuum limit .
the self - interaction of @xmath60 and the yukawa interaction vanish and are trivial .
the renormalized effective potential is not stabilized for @xmath402 . without introducing additional operators other than the four - fermion operator
, the theory can not be renormalized . for example , models with @xmath446 fall into this category .
note that @xmath40 is reduced to the pure njl point in the four - dimensional njl model , @xmath43 , in the limit @xmath44 .
so far we focused our discussions on the theory with the gauge coupling exactly on the uvfp @xmath447 .
each point on the critical line @xmath65 describes a different theory ( different @xmath33 ) . now that we have shown existence of the nontrivial window
, we shall study the rg flows of @xmath448 of a particular theory specified by one point on the critical line . in order to obtain the rg flows in the vicinity of the uvfp @xmath449
, we define variations @xmath450 and @xmath451 as @xmath452 it is enough to study linearized rges @xcite @xmath453 \delta g_r \end{array } \right ) = { \cal m } \left ( \begin{array}{@{}c@ { } } \delta \hat g^2 \\[2 mm ] \delta g_r \end{array } \right),\ ] ] with @xmath454 neglecting higher order terms of @xmath450 and @xmath451 .
the diagonal components are obtained from eqs .
( [ rge_ed3 ] ) and ( [ beta - g1 ] ) .
the off - diagonal one @xmath455 is a constant to be determined later .
the eigenvalues @xmath456 @xmath457 and eigenvectors @xmath458 are defined as @xmath459 we obtain @xmath460 and @xmath461 @xmath462 we here note @xmath463 since @xmath464 for @xmath465 ( @xmath466 ) in the nontrivial window ( @xmath467 ) . in order to estimate @xmath455 , we need to determine the effective potential off the uvfp , @xmath468 , which can be obtained by solving the sd equation .
instead of doing this , here we simply replace the uvfp value @xmath469 in eq .
( [ ren_g1 ] ) with the running bulk gauge coupling @xmath470 : @xmath471 with @xmath472 differentiating eq .
( [ ren_g3 ] ) with respect to @xmath473 , we obtain a rough estimate of @xmath455 as @xmath474 the eigenvector @xmath475 is then parallel to the tangent of the critical line @xmath65 .
once we choose the model , ( @xmath33 ) , the uvfp value @xmath476 is fixed and so is the critical value of the four - fermion coupling @xmath65 .
rg flows for a typical @xmath477 are depicted in fig .
[ rgflow ] in the vicinity of the point @xmath478 . from eq .
( [ lam1-lam2 ] ) we can see a gross feature of rg flows independently of the value of @xmath455 : the rg flows approach this point as increasing @xmath86 more rapidly in the direction of @xmath479 than that of @xmath480 .
there are four regions ( i , ii , iii and iv ) which are separated by two lines @xmath481 ( parallel to @xmath479 ) and @xmath482 ( parallel to @xmath480 ) .
the d@xmath109sb takes place in the regions i and ii . the line @xmath481 coincides with the tangent of the critical line . while the chiral symmetry is unbroken in the region iii , the region iv is not precisely the symmetric phase : although the njl coupling in the region iv is not strong enough for the d@xmath109sb , the gauge coupling strength grows strong in the infrared there .
we thus expect d@xmath109sb also in the region iv , with a fermion dynamical mass being of order @xmath483 @xmath484 @xcite which is a scale parameter of this gauge theory analogously to @xmath485 . as the border between region ii and iv is not a phase boundary in the exact sense but has a similar feature in the sense that the dynamical mass grows rapidly from @xmath483 ( instead of @xmath486 ) to @xmath21 as we cross the line from region iv to ii .
a similar phenomenon also takes place in the four - dimensional gauged njl model with the qcd - like gauge coupling . ] note that the theory is controlled by the uvfp @xmath487 , where the composite fields @xmath42 and @xmath35 enjoy nontrivial interactions .
thus the theory in the nontrivial window is consistently renormalized even off the uvfp @xmath468 .
we have discussed phase structure of the @xmath54-dimensional gauged njl model with compactified extra @xmath488 dimensions on the tev scale , based on the improved ladder sd equation with the running gauge coupling given by the truncated kk effective theory . such a running ( dimensionless ) gauge coupling has a nontrivial uv fixed point ( uvfp ) and the theory behaves as a four - fermion theory coupled to a walking gauge theory with the gauge coupling almost constant near the value of the uvfp in a wide energy region above the compactification scale .
the central assumption of this paper was that the existence of the uvfp is not an artifact of the kk effective theory and may have some reality in a more elaborate nonperturbative approach . solving the sd equation in the bulk by setting the gauge coupling at the value of the uvfp as a reasonable approximation
, we found the critical line similar to that of the four - dimensional gauged njl model : @xmath489 with @xmath490 , which takes the same form as that of the four - dimensional one with a fixed gauge coupling for @xmath491 in the prefactor . in spite of the formal resemblance to the four - dimensional case , however , the uvfp value @xmath22 , given by eq .
( [ eq : def_kappad ] ) with eqs .
( [ bprime ] ) and ( [ uv - fp ] ) , is determined as a function of @xmath32 and @xmath3 and hence is not a free parameter but is a fixed quantity once we specify the model . here
we should emphasize the following : in the pure gauge theories with extra dimensions the `` nontrivial '' theory defined at the critical point is only formal , since @xmath22 can not be fine - tuned arbitrarily close to the critical value @xcite .
the dynamical mass can not be made finite in the continuum limit @xmath492 .
then , even if we assume the existence of the uvfp beyond the truncated kk effective theory , the renormalizability of higher dimensional gauge theories with @xmath64 such that @xmath48 ( region ( a ) in fig .
[ phase - r ] ) is only formal .
see , for example , the tmac analysis of the @xmath6 top mode standard model with extra dimension @xcite . ] . on the other hand
, we do have a continuous parameter , the four - fermion coupling @xmath23 , in the gauged njl model and hence the nontrivial theory can be defined by fine - tuning @xmath23 arbitrarily close to the critical line .
thus the inclusion of the four - fermion interactions may provide an interesting new possibility for higher dimensional gauge theories which were long considered nonrenormalizable and trivial theories based on the perturbation .
remarkably enough , we in fact found the nontrivial window ( region ( b ) in fig .
[ phase - r ] ) for @xmath64 such that @xmath493 @xmath494 where the four - fermion theory in the presence of walking gauge interactions becomes `` nontrivial '' and `` renormalizable '' , similarly to the four - dimensional gauged njl model , in the sense that the decay constant @xmath34 and couplings of composite @xmath35 and @xmath42 as well as the induced yukawa coupling of the fermion ( with mass @xmath495 ) to those composites remain finite in the continuum limit @xmath36 .
we explicitly performed renormalization of the kinetic term of the composite bosons and the effective potential .
the renormalized four - fermion coupling has a uvfp at @xmath51 , where the theory has a large anomalous dimension @xmath496 the renormalized effective potential indeed has nontrivial interactions which are _ conformal invariant _ , thanks to the large anomalous dimension .
it is rather surprising that even in higher dimensions the four - fermion operators become relevant thanks to the large anomalous dimension , @xmath497 .
in fact , the dynamical dimension of @xmath498 operator is relevant , dim(@xmath498 ) @xmath499 . on the other hand ,
the @xmath426 operator and the kinetic term @xmath70 are irrelevant , dim(@xmath426 ) @xmath500 , and dim(@xmath501 .
thus the theory can be renormalized without operators other than @xmath498 .
we further gave the rg flow off the uvfp in fig .
[ rgflow ] which is consistent with our renormalization performed on the uvfp . on the other hand , for @xmath64 such that @xmath78 ( region ( c ) in fig .
[ phase - r ] ) , the decay constant @xmath34 diverges even if we fine - tune the four - fermion coupling close to the critical value @xmath65 to make finite the dynamical mass of the fermion . at the mt point
@xmath262 the divergence of @xmath77 is logarithmic , @xmath41 , which is similar to the situation at the pure njl point of the four - dimensional case .
the mt point is reduced to the pure njl point @xmath502 for @xmath491 . without introducing other operators such as @xmath426 , @xmath503 , etc .
, the renormalization breaks down in the region ( c ) at this point it is worthwhile mentioning the formal limit @xmath44 of the nontrivial window .
it was shown @xcite that the four - dimensional gauged njl model becomes renormalizable and nontrivial , when the one - loop gauge coupling runs as specified by : @xmath504 where @xmath15 measures the running speed of the coupling @xcite:@xmath17 is the walking theory and @xmath505 corresponds to the non - running ( standing limit of walking coupling ) case with vanishing beta function .
the condition eq .
( [ moderate walking ] ) was first obtained @xcite by evaluating the @xmath77 , taking account of the _ logarithmic corrections _ to the asymptotic behavior of the mass function @xcite : @xmath506 instead of eq .
( [ eq : asymp_sol ] ) , and then in the rg group analysis in the language of the equivalent gauged yukawa model @xcite and also in the nonperturbative rg equation@xcite . here
we show that the formal limit of @xmath4 of the nontrivial window in this paper coincides with that characterized by precisely the same condition as eq .
( [ moderate walking ] ) , now _ without logarithmic corrections _ which were rather delicate factors in the previous arguments in the four - dimensional model .
instead we consider @xmath507 with @xmath508 in the spirit of @xmath509 expansion @xcite .
the nontrivial window is defined by @xmath510 which reads @xmath511 on the other hand , from eqs .
( [ uv - fp ] ) and ( [ eq : def_kappad ] ) we have @xmath512 then we obtain eq .
( [ moderate walking ] ) , @xmath513 .
the nontrivial window in the formal limit @xmath514 thus coincides with the condition of the renormalizability / nontriviality of the four - dimensional gauged njl models , namely those coupled to the ( moderately ) walking gauge theory with @xmath12 . combining the condition of asymptotic freedom @xmath515 and @xmath12
, we thus have theories within the nontrivial window in @xmath4 : @xmath516 see table [ tab4 ] for the theories satisfying eq .
( [ nt4 ] ) ( or eq . ( [ moderate walking ] ) ) . on the other hand , the trivial region ( c ) ( @xmath517 ) coincides with the condition of the triviality / nonrenormalizability , @xmath518 , in the @xmath4 limit .
thus in the @xmath519 limit where @xmath72 and @xmath73 ( for @xmath520 ) depending upon the dimension @xmath521 in such a way that @xmath522 , one could have a limit arriving at the four - dimensional gauged njl model with fixed ( standing ) gauge coupling @xmath523 : @xmath524 . ] , the uvfp s for both regions ( c ) ( @xmath517 ) and ( b ) ( @xmath525 ) in the phase diagram of fig .
[ phase - r ] shrink to a single point of the pure njl point and hence the distinction among them is not obviously visible compared with the case with extra dimensions . in other words , the renormalizability / nontriviality of the four - dimensional gauged njl model with @xmath12 gauge theories @xcite is a four - dimensional manifestation of the nontrivial window , in sharp contrast to the theory with @xmath518 .
thus _ the nontrivial window is not a peculiarity nor an artifact of the extra dimensions but is rather a universal feature of the gauged njl model_. the rg flows of the nontrivial window in this limit are only in regions ii and iv of fig .
[ rgflow ] and are similar to fig .
[ rgflow ] but with a crucial difference : since @xmath526 in this limit , the flows first approach @xmath481 instead of @xmath482 and then converge toward the pure njl point ( fig . [ rgflow - d4 ] ) .
this is actually consistent with the gross feature obtained in the four - dimensional model .
@xcite in conclusion , we have shown that the four - fermion theories in @xmath82 dimensions are renormalizable and nontrivial , _ when coupled to @xmath54-dimensional walking gauge theories _ , with the parameters @xmath64 being in the nontrivial window , which we assumed have a nontrivial ultraviolet fixed point as given by the truncated kk effective theory .
the fact that the four - fermion theory in dimensions @xmath527 , _ lower than 4 _ , is renormalizable and nontrivial has been known for long time since wilson @xcite ( for a proof on the @xmath528 theory , see ref.@xcite ) and was also known for the arbitrary @xmath529 dimensions @xcite .
further in @xmath55 it was known @xcite that the four - fermion theory when coupled with certain walking gauge theories is renormalizable and nontrivial .
here we have shown for the first time that the four - fermion theory in @xmath82 , _ higher than 4 _ , also shares the same feature when coupled to walking gauge theories characterized by the nontrivial window .
this renormalizability / nontriviality is not just a formal matter , but implies _ cutoff insensitivity _ of the physics prediction , which may be useful for model buildings even with a finite cutoff .
this is rather surprising , since the theory is dominated by the dynamics in the ultraviolet region where both the gauge and the four - fermion interactions become strongly coupled .
explicit model buildings based on this observation were in fact attempted for the four - dimensional case ( `` top mode walking guts '' ) @xcite .
the phase structure of the gauged njl model in the bulk with compactified extra dimensions may be useful for model buildings such as the top mode standard model , bulk technicolor , etc .. for instance , the @xmath530 standard model gauge interactions are not enough to trigger the top quark condensate @xcite , while the gauged njl model can do work due to the additional attractive interactions as in the case of the original top mode standard model .
although introduction of such an ad hoc four - fermion interaction may be less attractive than the scenario without it , the kk modes of the top quark still naturally reduce the top quark mass prediction of the original model as was emphasized in ref.@xcite .
since the electroweak symmetry breaking is still a central mystery of the modern particle theory , it would be useful to consider all possible dynamical scenarios before the lhc will take off .
the gauged njl model with extra dimensions may become one of the dormant volcano to give an explosion into rich tev physics .
the work is supported in part by the jsps grant - in - aid for the scientific research ( b)(2 ) 14340072 ( k.y . and m.t . ) , ( c)(2 ) 16540226 ( m.t . ) and by kra pbrg 2002 - 070-c00022 ( m.h . ) .
we have calculated the auxiliary field propagator in sec .
[ sec - yukawa ] by using the resummation technique @xcite .
we may take yet another choice proposed in ref .
@xcite in which we obtain the scalar propagator as the lowest order of the chebyshev expansion . while the resummation technique is operative in a weak gauge coupling region , the chebyshev expansion method is valid in the whole region . in four dimensions the results of the chebyshev expansion method are similar to those of the resummation technique .
@xcite we here demonstrate that the wave function renormalization constant for the auxiliary field agrees with the result of the resummation technique shown in eq .
( [ eq : z_wav ] ) even in extra dimensions .
the composite scalar propagator is written in terms of the vacuum polarization function @xmath531 for the composite scalar : @xmath532 where the vacuum polarization function is given by @xmath533 , \label{sde_scalvac}\ ] ] with @xmath534 being the bethe - salpeter ( bs ) amplitude for the scalar . neglecting the explicit breaking of the @xmath54 dimensional lorentz symmetry owing to the compactification
, we can decompose generally the bs amplitude @xmath534 into four lorentz scalar functions @xmath535 @xmath536 , @xmath537 & & + ( \fsl p+\fsl q ) f_3(p+q , p)+\fsl p f_4(p+q , p ) , \label{bs}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath242 and @xmath241 denote momenta of the fermion and the scalar bound state , respectively .
although one might suspect that more structure functions are needed in @xmath164 dimensions , other terms are zero or reduced into the above four , because the bs amplitude includes only two momenta .
we analyze the scalar propagator and the bs equation in the symmetric phase , i.e. , @xmath538 we then obtain the vacuum polarization function as @xmath539 on the other hand , the bs equation under the ladder approximation is @xmath540 s(k+q ) { \chi_{\rm s}}(k+q , k ) s(k)[-it^a\gamma^n ] g^2_{(4+\delta)d}d_{mn}(p - k ) , \label{bs_eq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath541 is the identity matrix and @xmath542 is the propagator of the gauge boson . in the symmetric phase the bs equation
is obviously decomposed into two simultaneous equations for @xmath543 and for @xmath544 . since the structure functions @xmath545 and @xmath546 do not contribute to @xmath531 as shown in eq .
( [ pis ] ) , we neglect the two hereafter .
the bs equations for @xmath547 and @xmath548 are given by @xmath549^{d/2 - 1 } } f_1(k+q , k ) \nonumber \\ & & + 2 ( d-1+\xi ) c_f g_*^2 \int \frac{d^d k}{i(2\pi)^d } \frac{(k \cdot q)^2-k^2 q^2}{k^2\,(k+q)^2\,[-(p - k)^2]^{d/2 - 1 } } f_2(k+q , k ) , \label{bs_eq1 } \\
f_2 ( p+q , p ) & = & \frac{c_f g_*^2}{2[(p \cdot q)^2-p^2 q^2 ] } \int \frac{d^d k}{i(2\pi)^d } \frac{\xi ( p , q , k)}{k^2\,(k+q)^2\,[-(p - k)^2]^{d/2 - 1 } } f_1(k+q , k ) \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{c_f g_*^2}{(p \cdot q)^2-p^2 q^2 } \int \frac{d^d k}{i(2\pi)^d } \frac{-k \cdot ( k+q ) \ , \xi(p , q , k)}{k^2\,(k+q)^2\,[-(p - k)^2]^{d/2 - 1 } } f_2(k+q , k ) \label{bs_eq2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath550 \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{2(1-\xi)}{-(p - k)^2}\left\ { -q^2[k \cdot ( p - k)]\,[p \cdot ( p - k ) ] -[q \cdot ( k - p)]\,[p^2(q \cdot k)-k^2(p \cdot q)]\right\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the bulk gauge coupling was replaced as in eq .
( [ imp_ladder ] ) with @xmath551 .
the gauge fixing parameter @xmath139 should be taken as @xmath552 for consistency with the ladder approximation .
let us expand @xmath547 , @xmath548 , and the integral kernels of @xmath531 and the bs equations by series of gegenbauer polynomials , which is generalization of the chebyshev polynomials . at this stage the bs equations ( [ bs_eq1 ] ) and ( [ bs_eq2 ] )
depend on three angles @xmath553 defined by @xmath554 as well as an infinite chain of harmonics @xmath555 and @xmath556 for expansion of the gegenbauer polynomials @xmath557 , where @xmath558 and @xmath559 so that it is quite difficult to solve analytically the equations .
we here note that only the bs equation for the harmonics @xmath560 contains an inhomogeneous term ( the constant unity ) , because the gegenbauer polynomials satisfy @xmath561 with @xmath562 ^ 2},\ ] ] and @xmath563 the inhomogeneous term certainly gives main contributions to the bs equations .
hence we assume that the bs equation for @xmath560 is well approximated by the closed form of @xmath560 , neglecting the effects of @xmath564 and @xmath565 . the harmonics @xmath564 and @xmath565
are iteratively determined after @xmath560 is computed .
we then obtain the bs equation for @xmath560 as @xmath566 where @xmath567 , @xmath568 , @xmath569 , and @xmath570 with @xmath571 \lefteqn { \hspace*{-7 mm } b_0(s , u ) \equiv } \nonumber \\ & & \hspace*{-3 mm } \frac{1}{w_0}\int_0^\pi d\beta \sin^{2\nu}\beta \ , \frac{c_0^\nu(\cos\beta)}{[(p_e - k_e)^2]^{\frac{d}{2}-1 } } .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can easily perform the angular integrations and find @xmath572 & & \qquad \left .
+ 1 \phantom{\big|}\right ] , \\[2 mm ] b_0(s , u ) & = & \frac{1}{[\max(s , u)]^{\frac{d}{2}-1 } } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] the vacuum polarization function is written in terms of @xmath560 as @xmath573 noting that the integral of r.h.s . in the zeroth order bs equation ( [ zeroth_bs_eq ] ) at @xmath574 is just same as in eq .
( [ vacpol3 ] ) , we can rewrite the composite scalar propagator without the integral as follows : @xmath575,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we divided the zeroth order harmonics @xmath560 into two parts of the ir and uv regions ,
@xmath576 the bs amplitude in zero momentum transfer , i.e. , the effective yukawa coupling @xmath45 , is also obtained through @xmath577 , @xmath578 let us solve the zeroth order bs equation ( [ zeroth_bs_eq ] ) which is equivalent to a set of the second order differential equation , @xmath579 and the irbc @xmath580 and the uvbc @xmath581 with @xmath582 we now replace the hypergeometric function in @xmath583 by unity , i.e. , @xmath584 .
\label{app_a0}\ ] ] we confirm later on that the approximation works well in @xmath530 . within the approximation the differential equations for the uv and ir parts are @xmath585 and @xmath586 respectively , where we used @xmath587 we can solve analytically eqs .
( [ bs_eq_uv ] ) and ( [ bs_eq_ir ] ) and find @xmath588 , \label{fuv}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the uv part , and @xmath589 , \label{fir}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the ir part , where @xmath590 , @xmath591 and @xmath592 represent the bessel functions of first and second kind , and modified one , respectively . for @xmath261 we should use the modified bessel function of the third kind , @xmath593 , instead of @xmath594 .
the irbc ( [ bs - irbc ] ) leads to @xmath595 other coefficients @xmath596 , and @xmath597 are obtained from the uvbc ( [ bs - uvbc ] ) and smoothness conditions for @xmath598 at @xmath599 , @xmath600 and @xmath601 as follows : @xmath602 c_2 & = & c_1\left(\frac{t}{\lambda^2},-\omega\right),\\ c_3 & = & \eta^{-1}\left(\frac{t}{\lambda^2},\omega\right ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we defined @xmath603 , \label{zdef } \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath604 , \label{gammaeq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath605 .
\label{geq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the prime @xmath606 denotes @xmath607 .
we also note the relation @xmath608 the bs amplitude is thus given by @xmath609 .
\label{fuv2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the effective yukawa coupling @xmath45 is also obtained as @xmath610 which agrees with eq .
( [ yukawa ] ) calculated through the resummation technique . in the case of @xmath530
, we can solve the bs equation without using the approximation for @xmath611 represented in eq .
( [ app_a0 ] ) .
the bs equations for @xmath612 and @xmath577 are @xmath613 & & + \frac{\tilde{\kappa}_6}{6 } \left(\frac{4}{st}-\frac{1}{t^2}\right ) f_{\rm ir}(s , t)=0 , \label{bs_eq2_ir } \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath614 & & + \frac{\tilde{\kappa}_6}{2s^2 } \left(2-\frac{4t}{3s}+\frac{t^2}{3s^2}\right ) f_{\rm uv}(s , t)=0 , \label{bs_eq2_uv}\end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively . noting that eq .
( [ bs_eq2_uv ] ) is rewritten as @xmath615 with @xmath616 , we obtain the solutions @xmath617 where @xmath618 and @xmath619 denote the confluent hypergeometric function and its @xmath620 function , respectively , we here defined @xmath621 we can confirm that @xmath577 is real , i.e. , @xmath622 , by using the kummer s transformation @xmath623 .
the irbc ( [ bs - irbc ] ) leads to @xmath624 owing to the behavior of the confluent hypergeometric @xmath620 function around zero @xmath625 other coefficients @xmath626 and @xmath627 are obtained by using the uvbc ( [ bs - uvbc ] ) and continuous conditions ( [ cont])([contdiff ] ) .
we show the difference between the solutions with or without the approximation ( [ app_a0 ] ) .
( see figs .
[ fig2 ] and [ fig3 ] . )
the approximation works well within a few % .
we expect that the approximation is also valid in @xmath628 .
we now determine the wave function renormalization constant for the auxiliary field @xmath42 .
we expand the function @xmath629 in eq .
( [ fuv2 ] ) over @xmath630 . depending on the values of @xmath631 ,
three expressions are obtained : @xmath632,\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath633 , and @xmath634 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath635 , and @xmath636 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath637 , where we defined @xmath638 @xmath639 and @xmath640 for @xmath261 we also used the behavior of the bessel function @xmath641 around @xmath642 , @xmath643 although we have calculated in the symmetric phase so far , we expect that the momentum dependence of @xmath644 is unchanged even in the broken phase , as long as neglecting effects of the mass term .
we thus obtain the wave function renormalization constant for @xmath42 as @xmath645 { \displaystyle z_\sigma^{-1}=\left(\frac{\lambda}{\mu}\right)^{2(\nu-1 ) } \ln \left(\frac{\lambda^2}{\mu^2}\right ) } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle \omega = \frac{1}{\nu } } \\[5 mm ] { \displaystyle z_\sigma^{-1}=\left(\frac{\lambda}{\mu}\right)^{2(\nu-1 ) } } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle \frac{1}{\nu } < \omega \leq 1 } \end{array } \right.\ ] ] with @xmath646 the results are consistent with the analysis of the resummation technique in sec .
[ sec - yukawa ] .
in this appendix , we summarize our results on the linearized sd equation including the cases with @xmath647 and @xmath262 .
we obtain the asymptotic behavior of the mass function as follows : @xmath648 { \displaystyle \frac{\gamma(d/2)}{\gamma(\nu/2)\gamma(1+\nu/2 ) } \left(\frac{x}{\sigma_0 ^ 2}\right)^{-\frac{\nu}{2 } } \left(\ln \frac{x}{\sigma_0 ^ 2}+h_0\right ) , } & \mbox{for } & \kappa_d = \kappa_d^{\rm crit } , \\[5 mm ] { \displaystyle c_1 \left(\frac{x}{\sigma_0 ^ 2}\right)^{-\frac{\nu}{2}(1-\omega ) } + d_1 \left(\frac{x}{\sigma_0 ^ 2}\right)^{-\frac{\nu}{2}(1+\omega ) } , } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle \kappa_d^{\rm mt } < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm crit } , } \\[5 mm ] { \displaystyle c_1 \left(\frac{x}{\sigma_0 ^ 2}\right)^{-\frac{1}{2}(\nu-1 ) } \left(1-\frac{1}{4}(\nu^2 - 1)\frac{\sigma_0 ^ 2}{x } \ln \frac{x}{\sigma_0 ^ 2}\right ) , } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle \kappa_d = \kappa_d^{\rm mt } , } \\[5 mm ] { \displaystyle c_1 \left(\frac{x}{\sigma_0 ^ 2}\right)^{-\frac{\nu}{2}(1-\omega ) } + c_2 \left(\frac{x}{\sigma_0 ^ 2}\right)^{-\frac{\nu}{2}(1-\omega)-1 } , } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle 0 < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm mt } , } \\[5 mm ] 1 , & \mbox{for } & \kappa_d = 0 , \end{array}\right . \label{sol_linear}\ ] ] where @xmath649 @xmath650 and @xmath651 in eq .
( [ h0 ] ) , @xmath652 is the euler s constant , @xmath653 . substituting eq .
( [ sol_linear ] ) for the uvbc ( [ uv - bc2 ] ) with @xmath125 , we obtain the gap equation @xmath654 { \displaystyle \ln \frac{\sigma_0 ^ 2}{\lambda^2}=h_0+\frac{2}{\nu}- \frac{\frac{16}{\nu^2}}{\frac{4}{\nu}-\frac{1}{g } } , } & \mbox{for } & \kappa_d = \kappa_d^{\rm crit } , \\[7 mm ] { \displaystyle \frac{g^{\rm crit}}{g}=1+\frac{4\omega d_1}{1-\omega^2 } \frac{\left(\dfrac{\sigma_0}{\lambda}\right)^{2\nu\omega } } { c_1+\frac{1-\omega}{1+\omega}d_1 \left(\dfrac{\sigma_0}{\lambda}\right)^{2\nu\omega } } , } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle \kappa_d^{\rm mt } < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm crit } , } \\[12 mm ] { \displaystyle \frac{g^{\rm crit}}{g}=1-\nu g^{\rm crit}\left ( 1-\frac{(\nu-1)^2}{4\nu}\frac{1}{g}\right ) \frac{\sigma_0 ^ 2}{\lambda^2 } \ln \frac{\lambda^2}{\sigma_0 ^ 2 } , } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle \kappa_d = \kappa_d^{\rm mt } , } \\[7 mm ] { \displaystyle \frac{g^{\rm crit}}{g}=1+\frac{4c_2}{\nu(1-\omega^2 ) } \frac{\frac{\sigma_0 ^ 2}{\lambda^2 } } { c_1 + \left(1-\frac{2}{\nu(1+\omega)}\right)c_2 \frac{\sigma_0 ^ 2}{\lambda^2 } } , } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle 0 < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm mt } , } \\[7 mm ] { \displaystyle \frac{g^{\rm crit}}{g } = 1-\frac{\nu}{\nu-1 } \frac{\sigma_0 ^ 2}{\lambda^2 } , } & \mbox{for } & \kappa_d = 0 . \end{array}\right.\ ] ] with @xmath655 the scaling relation is then found as @xmath656 { \displaystyle \exp\left(\frac{h_0}{2}+\frac{1}{\nu}\right ) \exp\left(-\frac{\frac{8}{\nu^2}}{\frac{4}{\nu}-\frac{1}{g}}\right ) } & \mbox{for } & \kappa_d = \kappa_d^{\rm crit } , \\[5 mm ] { \displaystyle \left[\,\frac{c_1}{-d_1}\frac{1-\omega^2}{4\omega } \left(1-\frac{g^{\rm crit}}{g}\right)\,\right]^{\frac{1}{2\nu\omega } } } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle \kappa_d^{\rm mt } < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm crit } , } \\[5 mm ] { \displaystyle \sqrt{\left(\omega-\frac{1}{\nu}\right ) \left(1-\frac{g^{\rm crit}}{g}\right ) } } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle 0 \leq \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm mt } , } \end{array}\right.\ ] ] where we used @xmath302 . for @xmath262
the scaling relation can not be written by elementary functions : @xmath657 the chiral condensation is calculated from eq .
( [ uv - bc ] ) : @xmath658 { \displaystyle \frac{\gamma(d/2)}{\gamma(\nu/2)\gamma(1+\nu/2 ) } \left(\dfrac{\sigma_0}{\lambda}\right)^{\nu } \left(\ln \dfrac{\lambda\;}{\sigma_0}+\frac{h_0}{2}+\frac{1}{\nu}\right ) , } & \mbox{for } & \kappa_d = \kappa_d^{\rm crit } , \\[5 mm ] { \displaystyle \frac{(1+\omega)}{2 } c_1 \left(\dfrac{\sigma_0}{\lambda}\right)^{\nu ( 1-\omega ) } + \frac{(1-\omega)}{2 } d_1 \left(\frac{\sigma_0}{\lambda}\right)^{\nu ( 1+\omega ) } , } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle \kappa_d^{\rm mt } < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm crit } , } \\[5 mm ] { \displaystyle \frac{(1+\nu)}{2\nu } c_1 \left(\dfrac{\sigma_0}{\lambda}\right)^{\nu-1 } \left[1-\frac{1}{4}(\nu^2 - 1)\frac{\sigma_0 ^ 2}{\lambda^2 } \ln \frac{\lambda^2}{\sigma_0 ^ 2}\right ] , } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle \kappa_d = \kappa_d^{\rm mt } , } \\[5 mm ] { \displaystyle \frac{(1+\omega)}{2 } c_1 \left(\dfrac{\sigma_0}{\lambda}\right)^{\nu ( 1-\omega ) } + \left(\frac{1+\omega}{2}-\frac{1}{\nu}\right ) c_2 \left(\dfrac{\sigma_0}{\lambda}\right)^{\nu ( 1-\omega)+2 } , } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle 0 < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm mt } , } \\[5 mm ] 1 , & \mbox{for } & \kappa_d = 0 . \end{array}\right . \label{sig_linear}\ ] ] eq .
( [ sig_linear ] ) reads @xmath659 { \displaystyle \frac{2}{1+\omega } \sigma + \frac{2\omega}{1+\omega}d_1 \lambda \left(\frac{2c_1^{-1}}{1+\omega } \frac{\sigma}{\lambda}\right)^{1 + \frac{2\nu\omega}{\nu(1-\omega)+1 } } , } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle \kappa_d^{\rm mt } < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm crit } , } \\[5 mm ] { \displaystyle \frac{2\nu}{1+\nu } \sigma -\frac{\nu-1}{\nu } c_1 \lambda \left(\frac{2\nu c_1^{-1}}{1+\nu } \frac{\sigma}{\lambda}\right)^{1+\frac{2}{\nu } } \ln \frac{\lambda}{\sigma } , } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle \kappa_d = \kappa_d^{\rm mt } , } \\[5 mm ] { \displaystyle \frac{2}{1+\omega}\sigma + \frac{2}{\nu(1+\omega ) } c_2 \lambda \left(\frac{2c_1^{-1}}{1+\omega } \frac{\sigma}{\lambda}\right)^{1 + \frac{2}{\nu(1-\omega)+1 } } , } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle 0 < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm mt } , } \\[5 mm ] { \displaystyle \sigma } & \mbox{for } & \kappa_d = 0 . \end{array}\right . \label{m_lin}\ ] ] for @xmath48 we do not obtain a handy formula .
we summarize results on the power expansion solution for @xmath178 .
the asymptotic behavior of the mass function is given by @xmath660 { \displaystyle c_1 \left ( \dfrac{x}{\sigma_0 ^ 2 } \right)^{-\frac{1}{4}(\nu-1 ) } -\frac{(\nu-1)(3\nu+1)}{8(\nu+1)}\,c_1 ^ 3 \left(\dfrac{x}{\sigma_0 ^ 2}\right)^{-\frac{3\nu+1}{4 } } \ln \frac{x}{\sigma_0 ^ 2 } , } & \mbox{for } & \kappa_d = \kappa_d^{\rm pe } , \\[5 mm ] { \displaystyle c_1 \left ( \dfrac{x}{\sigma_0 ^ 2 } \right)^{-\frac{1}{2}\nu(1-\omega ) } + c_2 \left ( \dfrac{x}{\sigma_0 ^ 2 } \right)^{-\frac{3}{2}\nu(1-\omega)-1 } } & \mbox{for } & 0 < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm pe } , \end{array}\right .
\label{sol_pow}\ ] ] with @xmath661 where @xmath182 and @xmath183 can not be determined in the power expansion method . substituting eq .
( [ sol_pow ] ) for the uvbc ( [ uv - bc2 ] ) with @xmath125 , we obtain the gap equation @xmath662 { \displaystyle \frac{g^{\rm crit}}{g}=1-\frac{2\nu^2 c_1 ^ 2 g^{\rm crit}}{\nu+1}\left ( 1-\frac{(\nu-1)^2}{16\nu^2 g}\right ) \left(\frac{\sigma_0}{\lambda}\right)^{\nu+1 } \ln \frac{\lambda^2}{\sigma_0 ^ 2 } , } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle \kappa_d = \kappa_d^{\rm pe } , } \\[7 mm ] { \displaystyle \frac{g^{\rm crit}}{g}=1+\frac{4(\nu+1-\nu\omega)c_2}{\nu(1-\omega^2 ) } \dfrac{\left(\dfrac{\sigma_0}{\lambda}\right)^{2\nu(1-\omega)+2 } } { c_1 + \frac{\nu(3\omega-1)-2}{\nu(1+\omega)}c_2 \left(\dfrac{\sigma_0}{\lambda}\right)^{2\nu(1-\omega)+2 } } , } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle 0 < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm pe}. } \end{array}\right.\ ] ] the scaling relation is then found as @xmath663^{\frac{1}{2\nu\omega } } } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle \kappa_d^{\rm pe } < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm crit } , } \\[7 mm ] { \displaystyle \left[\,\dfrac{2\nu\omega-\nu-1}{\nu c_1 ^ 2 } \left(1-\frac{g^{\rm crit}}{g}\right ) \,\right]^{\frac{1}{2\nu(1-\omega)+2 } } } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle 0 < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm pe } , } \end{array}\right.\ ] ] where we used @xmath302 . for @xmath664
the scaling relation can not be written by elementary functions : @xmath665 the chiral condensation is calculated from eq .
( [ uv - bc ] ) : @xmath666 { \displaystyle \frac{(3\nu+1)}{4\nu } c_1
\left(\dfrac{\sigma_0}{\lambda}\right)^{\frac{\nu-1}{2 } } -\frac{(\nu-1)^2 ( 3\nu+1)}{32\nu(\nu+1 ) } c_1 ^ 3 \left(\dfrac{\sigma_0}{\lambda}\right)^{\frac{3\nu+1}{2 } } \ln \frac{\lambda^2}{\sigma_0 ^ 2 } , } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle \kappa_d = \kappa_d^{\rm pe } , } \\[5 mm ] { \displaystyle \frac{(1+\omega)}{2 } c_1 \left(\dfrac{\sigma_0}{\lambda}\right)^{\nu ( 1-\omega ) } + \left(\frac{3\omega-1}{2}-\frac{1}{\nu}\right ) c_2 \left(\dfrac{\sigma_0}{\lambda}\right)^{3\nu ( 1-\omega)+3 } , } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle 0 < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm pe}. } \end{array}\right .
\label{sig_pow}\ ] ] eq .
( [ sig_pow ] ) reads @xmath667 { \displaystyle \frac{4\nu}{3\nu+1}\sigma -\frac{\nu-1}{\nu+1}\,\lambda \left(\frac{4\nu}{3\nu+1}\frac{\sigma}{\lambda}\right)^3 \ln \frac{\lambda}{\sigma } , } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle \kappa_d = \kappa_d^{\rm pe } , } \\[5 mm ] { \displaystyle \frac{2}{1+\omega}\sigma -\frac{\nu(1-\omega)}{2(2\nu\omega-\nu-1)}\ , \lambda\ , \left(\frac{2}{1+\omega}\frac{\sigma}{\lambda}\right)^3 , } & \mbox{for } & { \displaystyle 0 < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm pe}. } \end{array}\right . \label{m_pow}\ ] ] these formulae are useful for calculation of the effective potential .
in sec . [ sec - rg ] , we studied the renormalization of the effective potential , keeping the kinetic term of the auxiliary field finite
. it should be so in the viewpoint of renormalization of the effective action .
for @xmath78 , however , the theory can not get into the `` broken phase '' @xmath402 , because the `` renormalized '' potential ( [ eq : renormalized_pot2 ] ) becomes unbounded from below . in this appendix , we attempt another procedure in which the vev of @xmath60 remains finite independently of the value of @xmath22 .
for such a purpose we may admit to incorporate any required operators . can be found a necessary and sufficient operator set ? before details , we jump to conclusions : it depends on approximation methods of the ladder sd equation .
the dynamical mass should be finite , so that eq .
( [ uv - bc ] ) yields the wave function renormalization constant of @xmath42 as @xmath668 for the whole region .
( compare eq .
( [ z - sig ] ) with eq .
( [ eq : z_wav ] ) . ) by using eq .
( [ z - sig ] ) , we obtain the renormalized yukawa vertex @xmath669 in the continuum limit @xmath217 .
( see also eq .
( [ eq : ren_yukawa ] ) . ) on the other hand , the `` renormalized '' propagator of @xmath42 behaves as @xmath670 for @xmath671 and @xmath672 for @xmath295 .
thus the kinetic term of @xmath42 diverges in the continuum limit @xmath396 for @xmath78 .
we need to add the operator @xmath70 in the effective action in order to absorb the divergence . moreover , the decay constant is also divergent in the region , so that the interactions of the ng boson vanishes in @xmath396 .
the scaling relation for @xmath671 is given by @xmath673 ( see eq .
( [ gapeq - linear ] ) . ) the four - fermion coupling @xmath23 is thus renormalized as @xmath674 so as to make the dynamical mass @xmath170 finite .
this is the very same as eq .
( [ ren_g2 ] ) .
the bare effective potential has been already obtained in eq .
( [ eq : linearized_pot2 ] ) .
we rewrite eq .
( [ eq : linearized_pot2 ] ) in terms of @xmath60 and @xmath50 : @xmath675 .
\nonumber \\ \label{bare_pot1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we renormalize the bare mass term , i.e. , the first line of eq .
( [ bare_pot1 ] ) as follows : @xmath676 which is the same as eq .
( [ ren_m1 ] ) .
the beta function and anomalous dimensions are then found , @xmath677 and @xmath678 respectively . at the uvfp of @xmath50
the anomalous dimension is @xmath679 .
therefore the mismatch of the @xmath21 dependence between @xmath128 and @xmath680 is resolved .
( see also eq .
( [ chi - cond2 ] ) . )
troublesome are the @xmath681 term and interaction term ( @xmath374 term ) in eq .
( [ bare_pot1 ] ) .
the divergence still remains after the `` renormalization '' of the four - fermion term .
in addition , the operator having the fractional power of @xmath682 is required .
the scaling relation is given by @xmath683 { \displaystyle \lambda\ , \left ( 1 - \dfrac{g^{\rm crit}}{g } \right)^{\frac{1}{2\nu(1-\omega)+2 } } } , & { \displaystyle ( 0 < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm pe } ) . }
\end{array } \right.\ ] ] ( see eq .
( [ gapeq - pow ] ) . ) in order to keep @xmath170 finite , we renormalize the gap equation , @xmath684 for @xmath380 and @xmath685 for @xmath344 . by rewriting the bare effective potential in eqs .
( [ eff - pot - pow1 ] ) and ( [ eff_pot_pw2 ] ) in terms of @xmath60 and @xmath50 , we obtain @xmath686 , \nonumber \\ \label{bare_pot2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath380 , and @xmath687 , \nonumber \\ \label{bare_pot3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath344 .
the bare mass term is then renormalized @xmath676 for @xmath688 .
the beta function and anomalous dimensions are and @xmath690 , & ( \kappa_d^{\rm pe } < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm crit } ) \\[3 mm ] 3\nu\omega-\nu-2 + 2 [ \nu(1-\omega)+1 ] \dfrac{g_r}{g^{\rm crit } } , & ( 0 < \kappa_d < \kappa_d^{\rm pe } ) \end{array}\right . \end{aligned}\ ] ] after the renormalization , the effective potential for @xmath380 has no divergent term . for @xmath344 , on the other hand , the four - fermion ( @xmath681 ) and eight - fermion ( @xmath692 ) terms diverge in the continuum limit . therefore the corresponding counter terms are required .
in passing , the bifurcation solution leads to the same results as above ones for @xmath380 in the whole region .
thus only the counter term of the auxiliary field propagator is needed in the nonrenormalizable region @xmath78 .
i. antoniadis , phys .
* b 246 * , 377 ( 1990 ) .
k. r. dienes , e. dudas , and t. gherghetta , phys .
b436 * , 55 ( 1998 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/9803466 ] ; nucl .
b537 * , 47 ( 1999 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/9806292 ] . v. a. miransky , m. tanabashi , and k. yamawaki , phys . lett .
* b221 * , 177 ( 1989 ) ; mod .
phys . lett . * a4 * , 1043 ( 1989 ) .
y. nambu , enrico fermi institute report no .
89 - 08 , 1989 ( unpublished ) ; in _ proceedings of the 1989 workshop on dynamical symmetry breaking _ , edited by t. muta and k. yamawaki ( nagoya university , nagoya , japan , 1990 ) .
w. j. marciano , phys .
* 62 * , 2793 ( 1989 ) .
w. a. bardeen , c. t. hill , and m. lindner , phys
* d41 * , 1647 ( 1990 ) .
b. a. dobrescu , phys . lett .
* b 461 * , 99 ( 1999 ) ; hep - ph/9903407 .
h. cheng , b. a. dobrescu , and c. t. hill , nucl . phys . *
b 589 * , 249 ( 2000 ) . n.
arkani - hamed , h .- c .
cheng , b. a. dobrescu , and l. j. hall , phys . rev . *
d62 * , 096006 ( 2000 ) .
m. hashimoto , m. tanabashi , and k. yamawaki , phys .
rev . * d64 * , 056003 ( 2001 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0010260 ] .
v. gusynin , m. hashimoto , m. tanabashi , and k. yamawaki , phys . rev .
* d65 * , 116008 ( 2002 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0201106 ]
. m. hashimoto , m. tanabashi , and k. yamawaki , phys .
rev . * d69 * , 076004 ( 2004 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0311165 ] .
k. agashe , jhep * 0105 * , 017 ( 2001 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0012182 ] .
d. i. kazakov , jhep * 0303 * , 020 ( 2003 ) , [ arxiv : hep - th/0209100 ] . k. r. dienes , e. dudas , and t. gherghetta , phys .
91 * , 061601 ( 2003 ) , [ arxiv : hep - th/0210294 ] .
s. ejiri , j. kubo , and m. murata , phys . rev . *
d62 * , 105025 ( 2000 ) .
h. kawai , m. nio , and y. okamoto , prog .
* 88 * , 341 ( 1992 ) .
k. farakos , p. de forcrand , c. p. korthals altes , m. laine , and m. vettorazzo , nucl . phys . *
b655 * , 170 ( 2003 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0207343 ] .
h. gies , phys . rev . *
d68 * , 085015 ( 2003 ) , [ arxiv : hep - th/0305208 ] .
b. holdom , phys . lett . *
b150 * , 301 ( 1985 ) .
k. yamawaki , m. bando , and k. matumoto , phys .
. lett . * 56 * , 1335 ( 1986 ) ; m.
bando , t. morozumi , h. so , and k. yamawaki , phys .
lett . * 59 * , 389 ( 1987 ) .
t. akiba , and t. yanagida , phys .
b169 * , 432 ( 1986 ) .
t. appelquist , d. karabali , and l.c.r .
wijewardhana , phys .
lett . * 57 * , 957 ( 1986 ) ; t. appelquist , and l. c. r. wijewardhana , phys . rev . *
d36 * , 568 ( 1987 ) .
w. a. bardeen , c. n. leung , and s. t. love , phys .
lett . * 56 * , 1230 ( 1986 ) ; c. n. leung , s. t. love , and w. a. bardeen , nucl .
b273 * , 649 ( 1986 ) .
kondo , h. mino , and k. yamawaki , phys .
* d39 * , 2430 ( 1989 ) ; k. yamawaki , in _ proc .
johns hopkins workshop on current problems in particle theory 12 , baltimore , june 8 - 10 , 1988 _ , edited by g. domokos and s. kovesi - domokos ( world scientific pub .
co. , singapore 1988 ) .
t. appelquist , m. soldate , t. takeuchi , and l. c. r. wijewardhana , in _ proc .
johns hopkins workshop on current problems in particle theory 12 , baltimore , june 8 - 10 , 1988 _ , edited by g. domokos and s. kovesi - domokos ( world scientific pub .
co. , singapore 1988 ) .
v. a. miransky , and k. yamawaki , mod .
* a4 * , 129 ( 1989 ) .
t. appelquist , t. takeuchi , m. einhorn , and l. c. r. wijewardhana , phys . lett . *
220b * , 223 ( 1989 ) . c. t. hill , phys .
* b 345 * , 483 ( 1995 ) ; k. lane , and e. eichten , phys . lett .
* b 352 * , 382 ( 1995 ) ; k. lane , phys .
* b 433 * , 96 ( 1998 ) . c. t. hill , phys .
lett . * 266 b * , 419 ( 1991 ) .
v. a. miransky , _ dynamical symmetry breaking in quantum field theories _ ( world scientific pub .
co. , singapore 1993 ) .
k. yamawaki , in _ proceedings of 14th symposium on theoretical physics `` dynamical symmetry breaking and effective field theory '' _ , cheju island , korea , july 21 - 26 , 1995 , ed .
j. e. kim ( minumsa pub .
co. , korea , 1996 ) p.43 - 86 , [ arxiv : hep - ph/9603293 ] .
c. t. hill , and e. h. simmons , phys .
* 381 * , 235 ( 2003 ) , [ erratum _ ibid . _
* 390 * , 553 ( 2004 ) ] , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0203079 ] .
kondo , s. shuto , and k.yamawaki , mod .
. lett . * a6 * , 3385 ( 1991 ) .
n. v. krasnikov , mod .
* a8 * , 797 ( 1993 ) .
kondo , m. tanabashi , and k. yamawaki , prog .
. phys . * 89 * , 1249 ( 1993 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/9212208 ] .
see also k .-
kondo , m. tanabashi , and k. yamawaki , dpnu-91 - 20/chiba - ep-53 ( 1991 ) , mod .
a8 * , 2859 ( 1993 ) .
m. harada , y. kikukawa , t. kugo , and h. nakano , prog .
. phys . * 92 * , 1161 ( 1994 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/9407398 ] .
k. i. kubota , and h. terao , prog .
. phys . * 102 * , 1163 ( 1999 ) , [ arxiv : hep - th/9908062 ] .
a. a. andrianov , v. a. andrianov , p. giacconi , and r. soldati , jhep * 0307 * , 063 ( 2003 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0305271 ] .
h. abe , h. miguchi , and t. muta , mod .
a15 * , 445 ( 2000 ) , [ arxiv : hep - ph/0002212 ] ; h. abe , t. inagaki , and t. muta , hep - ph/0104002 .
i. fomin , v. p. gusynin , v. a. miransky , and yu . a. sitenko , riv .
nuovo cim .
* 6 * , no . 5 , 1 ( 1983 ) . w. a. bardeen , and s. t. love , phys
. rev . * d45 * , 4672 ( 1992 ) .
d. atkinson , j. math .
* 28 * 2494 ( 1987 ) .
v. a. miransky , sov .
38 * , 280 ( 1983 ) ; k. higashijima , phys . rev . * d29 * , 1228 ( 1984 ) . t. kugo , and m. g. mitchard , phys . lett . * b282 * , 162 ( 1992 ) .
h. pagels , and s. stokar , phys .
rev . * d20 * , 2947 ( 1979 ) .
t. appelquist , j. terning , and l. c. r. wijewardhana , phys . rev . *
d44 * , 871 ( 1991 ) .
v. p. gusynin , and m. reenders , phys . rev . * d57 * , 6356 ( 1998 ) , [ arxiv : hep - th/9712123 ] . v. p.
gusynin , v. a. kushnir , and v. a. miransky , phys . rev .
* d39 * , 2355 ( 1989 ) , [ erratum _ ibid_. * d41 * , 3279 ( 1990 ) ] .
t. nonoyama , t.b .
suzuki , and k. yamawaki , prog .
81 * 1238 ( 1989 ) .
h. bateman , and a. erdelyi , _ higher transcendental functions _ ,
vol . 1 , mcgraw - hill , new york ( 1953 ) .
v. a. miransky , and k. yamawaki , phys . rev .
* d55 * ( 1997 ) 5051 ; _ ibid . _ * d56 * , 3768 ( 1997 ) .
v. a. miransky , int .
phys . * a 8 * , 135 ( 1993 ) .
k. g. wilson , and j. b. kogut , phys .
* 12 * , 75 ( 1974 ) .
k. g. wilson , phys . rev . *
d7 * ( 1973 ) 2911
. k. i. aoki , k. morikawa , j. i. sumi , h. terao , and m. tomoyose , prog .
. phys . * 102 * , 1151 ( 1999 ) , [ arxiv : hep - th/9908042 ] .
b. rosenstein , b. j. warr , and s. h. park , phys .
* 205 * 59 ( 1991 ) .
y. kikukawa and k. yamawaki , phys .
b234 * , 497 ( 1990 ) .
s. hands , a. kocic and j. b. kogut , annals phys . *
224 * , 29 ( 1993 ) , [ arxiv : hep - lat/9208022 ] .
i. inukai , m. tanabashi and k. yamawaki , in _ proceedings of 1996 international workshop on perspectives of strong coupling gauge theories ( scgt 96 ) _ , nagoya , japan , 13 - 16 nov .
1996 , edited by j. nishimura and k. yamawaki ( world scientific pub . ,
singapore , 1997 ) 44 - 53 , [ arxiv : hep - ph/9706346 ] . | we investigate phase structure of the @xmath0-dimensional gauged nambu - jona - lasinio ( njl ) model with @xmath1 extra dimensions compactified on tev scale , based on the improved ladder schwinger - dyson ( sd ) equation in the bulk .
we assume that the bulk ( dimensionless ) running gauge coupling in the sd equation for the @xmath2 gauge theory with @xmath3 massless flavors is given by the truncated kaluza - klein effective theory and hence has a nontrivial ultraviolet fixed point ( uvfp ) , resulting in the walking coupling .
we find the critical line in the parameter space of two couplings , the gauge coupling ( value fixed at the uvfp ) and the ( dimensionless ) four - fermion coupling , which is similar to that of the gauged njl model with fixed ( walking ) gauge coupling in four dimensions .
it is shown that _ in the presence of such walking gauge interactions _ the four - fermion interactions become `` nontrivial '' and `` renormalizable '' even in higher dimensions , similarly to the four - dimensional gauged njl model .
such a renormalizability / nontriviality holds only in the restricted region of the critical line ( `` nontrivial window '' ) with the gauge coupling larger than a _
non - vanishing _
value ( `` marginal triviality ( mt ) '' point ) , in contrast to the four - dimensional case where such a renormalizability holds for all regions of the critical line except for the pure njl point ( without gauge coupling ) . in the nontrivial window
the renormalized effective potential yields a nontrivial interaction which is conformal invariant .
the existence of the nontrivial window implies `` cutoff insensitivity '' of the physics prediction in spite of the ultraviolet dominance of the dynamics . in the formal limit @xmath4 , the nontrivial window shrinks to the pure njl point but with a nontrivial condition which coincides with the known condition of the renormalizability / nontriviality of the four - dimensional gauged njl model , @xmath5 |
gamma ray bursts ( grbs ) are interesting highly energetic phenomena for which there is still no definitive explanation on the originating mechanism ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . regarding the initial event that triggers a grb , the combination of the observed short variability timescales and huge radiated energies points towards cataclysmic events leading to the formation of a stellar compact object with mass @xmath0 and radius @xmath1 releasing a gravitational energy @xmath2 erg .
specifically , according to their time duration , grbs can be classified as @xmath3 ( lgrbs ) if the duration of the gamma - ray signal is larger than 2 s and short ( sgrbs ) in other cases @xcite , although the boundary is not sharply delimited ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
there are several pieces of evidence in favour of an association of lgrbs with massive stars , especially the facts that they occur in star - forming regions @xcite and that supernovae have been found in association with a few of them ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
this leads to the _ collapsar _ model @xcite where a lgrb is associated with the gravitational collapse of a massive , wolf - rayet , star leading to the formation of an accreting stellar - mass black hole ( bh ) .
an alternative scenario where the central engine formed after the gravitational collapse is a young , rapidly rotating ( ms period ) neutron star ( ns ) has also been considered by @xcite , @xcite and @xcite . on the other hand ,
the identification of the progenitors of sgrbs is more uncertain @xcite .
this is partially due to the fact that the detection of sgrb afterglows is technically more difficult , and therefore rarer , than for lgrbs .
so far there is only a handful of detected afterglows , since the first detection in 2005 @xcite .
sgrbs can occur in all types of galaxies , either of a star - forming type or not @xcite .
this is consistent with the most popular scenario , that is the merger of a ns+ns or ns+bh binary system . as a main motivation for the present contribution and due to the current uncertainties on the origin of ( especially short ) grbs ,
it is worth investigating other possible classes of cataclysmic events where astrophysical stellar compact objects are involved .
we will focus on nss .
a ns can be partially characterized by a set of static observables , namely mass , @xmath4 , and radius , @xmath5 .
the structure of a ns has been discussed thoroughly in the past ( for a review see e.g. * ? ? ?
it can be briefly described by a dense _ core _ , where matter is in the form of a liquid of nucleons ( or additional particles including strangeness ) , and a _ crust _ where matter undergoes a liquid - solid transition into a clusterized myriad of nuclei @xcite . in more detail , the so - called neutron drip ( nd ) line signals the boundary between the outer and inner crust where neutrons start to leak out from nuclei .
the mass in the crust is small ( up to a few percent ) as compared to the whole ns and therefore it could be accelerated , if ejected by large energies , to large velocities or even high lorentz factors .
the equation of state ( eos ) that governs the description of matter in the inside of nss is currently poorly known .
whether matter remains in the form of baryons or deconfined quarks is a matter of debate .
the problem of the internal constituents in a ns has been thoroughly and periodically revisited from the early 1930 s when landau predicted the existence of such objects @xcite from the basis of the existence of neutral hadronic particles . from the discovery of the neutron by chadwick in 1932 to 1984 when it was hypothesized @xcite that a more stable type of matter could be possible ( formed by roughly equal quantities of @xmath6 quarks , arising from weak decay of regular @xmath7 matter present in nucleonic matter made of protons and neutrons ) a wide variety of possible nuclear configurations has been proposed . in this latter quark system case ,
for example , recent attention has been devoted to lattice calculations showing the possibility of the existence of the @xmath8dibaryon , with @xmath9 quark content @xcite and experimental input from the lhc is expected on the formation of a quark - gluon plasma .
a stable type of extended strange matter would allow the existence of stars even more compact than nss , i.e. hybrid or pure quark stars ( qss ) @xcite .
the transition from a nucleonic type of matter to a quark phase is presently not well understood . from the theoretical point of view , some work has been done @xcite on the possibility of quark bubble nucleation in a cold system , where the temperature is well approximated by @xmath10 . as this mechanism
is not efficient enough , this process may seem unlikely to occur .
another series of works have been developed by ouyed and collaborators which propose the quark - nova model in which a massive ns converts explosively to a quark star @xcite .
the transition is obtained mostly via a central density increase due to spin - down or accretion forming a conversion front that propagates toward the surface .
the outcome is ejection of the ns s outermost layers at relativistic speeds . alternatively ,
as we explain in this work , additional _ external _ agents may be able to produce thermal excitations in these dense degenerate matter systems . from indications concerning astrophysical and cosmological backgrounds
we know that dark matter ( dm ) is distributed inhomogeneously in the universe and , additionally , could be gravitationally accreted onto individual massive astrophysical objects .
one of the most popular dark matter candidates is considered to be a majorana - type weakly interacting particle ( wimp ) , although other asymmetric dark matter candidates could exist as well @xcite . from the experimental point of view
, current direct and indirect detection experiments try to constrain its properties .
for example , direct detection earth - based experiments dama @xcite , cogent @xcite , cresst and lately coupp @xcite seem to point towards a light particle in the @xmath11 @xmath12 mass range ( although this is in tension with other null searches ) while there has been a lot of interest in indirect detection of new excesses of extra photon components from the galactic center that could be due to annihilation of a @xmath13 @xmath12 particle @xcite , albeit so far at only the @xmath14 level of significance .
dm passing through astrophysical massive objects is expected to scatter off their constituent nuclei , lose energy , and become trapped by their gravitational field .
multiple scatterings cause dm to sink towards the center and afterwards , assuming that it may self - annihilate , a series of end products are available .
based on the previous arguments , a set of current experiments try to find evidence for this process in the sun , earth @xcite or even more compact - sized objects such as nss @xcite .
recently , new ideas on the possibility that quark bubbles may be formed by spark seeding in the inner cores of dense nss have been proposed by @xcite .
sparks would be generated in a sort of _ trojan horse _ mechanism by self - annihilation of dark matter particles gravitationally accreted by nss gathering in their internal cores . as estimated
, this would allow release energies of up to about one order of magnitude higher than the quark binding energies in the present baryons @xcite .
this mechanism then could lead to the conversion of nss into qss if the transition to quark matter phase is macroscopic . in this way the matter component in the form of dm would not only influence cosmological observables , but even ns dynamics @xcite .
similar arguments have been claimed in the solar seismology observables @xcite .
we investigate in the present paper whether this type of _ non - repeating _ cataclysmic event could produce sgrbs and what could be a possible specific signature .
after a short summary of the scenario in [ sect : scenario ] , in [ sect : energetics ] we compare the energy released by sgrbs with the energetics of the progenitor model that we propose and in
[ sect : rate ] we discuss the short grb event rate in light of this scenario as compared to observed rates , as well as the natural delay time between the regular ns phase and qs formation and how this mechanism may affect the properties of the host galaxies of short grbs . in [ sect : engine ] we present and analyze the ejecta and crust masses that could be expelled due to the ns@xmath15qs conversion and we present the details of the resulting central engine model . in [ sect : grb ] we attempt to discuss the expected temporal ( [ sect : duration ] ) and spectral ( [ sect : spectrum ] ) properties of the prompt gamma - ray emission and the afterglow . in
[ sect : gw ] we discuss our results and possible genuine additional signals and gravitational wave emission that could finally lead to a clear identification as compared with the short grb scenario involving binary mergers . finally in
[ sect : conclusions ] we give a brief summary of our conclusions and suggestions on how to proceed in further work .
there has been some previous work where dm accretion in astrophysical objects has been considered @xcite . as a summary , we start in this section by motivating the scenario where the emission of a sgrb may occur . in our previous work
@xcite the possibility of spark seeding in ns as a result of dm accretion was proposed .
we found a relationship between the mass of the dm particle , @xmath16 , and the binding energy of the lump of quark matter or strangelet formed , @xmath17 as calculated from the mit bag model @xcite .
@xmath18 where @xmath19 is the baryonic number density and @xmath20 and @xmath21 are the chemical potential and mass of the quark of @xmath22type in the light sector , @xmath23 .
@xmath24 is the bag constant .
the channels available to the @xmath25 annihilation are , so far , not known and this uncertainty is phenomenologically parametrized into the fraction @xmath26 . inside the ns
, it is believed that dm scatters one or more times and thermalizes according to a boltzmann distribution .
the thermal radius is given by @xmath27 this radius is , in general , time - dependent since evolution proceeds for central temperatures @xmath28 and baryonic mass densities @xmath29 .
dm at high density may self - annihilate to channels involving photons , leptons and light @xmath30 pairs @xcite . due to the fact that either a light or heavy self - annihilating particle in the @xmath31 mass - range may release a spark of energy able to liberate the constituent quark content of the baryons forming the very dense matter in the core of these objects , a pure nucleonic ns
could then be considered a metastable state of compact stars .
note that a self - annihilating @xmath32 @xmath12 particle as recently suggested in the context of direct detection experiments would , in particular , fit into this scenario .
the annihilation power is then given as @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the dm mass density and @xmath35 is the thermally averaged annihilation cross section . if the spark seeding is able to form quark lumps or strangelets , most likely off - center , inside a volume @xmath36 they could individually grow or coalesce from a stable minimum mass number , so far poorly known , @xmath37 , according to previous estimates @xcite . in this way a _ burning front _ may proceed if particular thermodynamical conditions are fulfilled .
if the burning is partial , the final configuration object would be hybrid , constitued by an inner quark matter phase and an outer nucleonic phase .
however , if the burning is complete the resultant object would be formed by a pure quark phase . in both cases the final configuration in the mass - radius phase space @xmath38 , as computed from different eos using a variety of many - body effective theories @xcite , is a smaller , slightly lighter , more compact object than the initial one characterized by @xmath39 . in figure [
fig : mr ] we show a qualitative scheme , inspired from the work by @xcite , of how the transition would produce a more compact object .
the transition point , and therefore the initial configuration mass , would be influenced by the presence of spark seeding by self - annihilating dm in this model .
in such a ns @xmath15 qs transition , part of the outer crust of the initial ns can be expelled , and possibly accelerated to relativistic speed , which may lead to a transient episode of high - energy emission . in the following ,
we discuss a possible association of some grbs with such events .
we focus on sgrbs for several reasons : * the energetics of bright long grbs may be a challenge for this scenario , whereas typical energies of short grbs are in a much better agreement ( see [ sect : energetics ] ) ; * a delay of at least @xmath40 yr is expected between the formation of a ns and the transition to a qs , which is too long for long grbs as supernovae within a few days have been found in association with some of these events . on the other hand
, the scenario naturally leads to a broad distribution of the delay @xmath41 , allowing long delays that are necessary to explain the properties of the afterglows and host galaxies of short grbs ( see [ sect : rate ] ) ; * the scenario naturally leads to short ( or very short ) timescales for the gamma - ray emission , pointing towards short or ultra - short grbs ( see [ sect : duration ] ) .
since 2005 and the first accurate localization of a sgrb @xcite , the redshift of an increasing number of short grbs has been measured , confirming their cosmological origin and leading to a large dispersion in the isotropic equivalent energy released in gamma - rays , @xmath42 erg @xcite .
this energy is emitted by a relativistic outflow which is probably beamed within an opening angle @xmath43 so that the true energy release is @xmath44 , where the beaming factor is defined as @xmath45 unfortunately , the opening angle @xmath43 can not be easily measured in grbs .
it can be estimated if a _ jet break _ is identified in the late afterglow @xcite .
it is only in very rare cases that a precise constraint on @xmath43 is obtained , such as @xmath46 in grb 051221a @xcite , and even in such cases , it remains partially model - dependent .
the distribution of @xmath47 for sgrbs is therefore unknown @xcite .
highly beamed sgrbs with @xmath48 would lead to @xmath49 whereas larger opening angles of about @xmath50 give @xmath51 .
this will remain as a major source of uncertainty in what follows . in sgrbs ,
the isotropic equivalent energy @xmath52 is released in gamma - rays on a very short time scale ( @xmath53 s ) and observed well above 1 mev ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
then , the gamma - ray emission must be produced from relativistic ejecta to avoid the _ compactness problem _ : this provides a constrain on the minimum value of the lorentz factor for the emission region to be optically thin for @xmath54 annihilation @xcite .
the analysis of a few pre-_fermi _ short bursts @xcite leads to @xmath55 from this @xmath54 opacity constraint @xcite . when a sgrb is detected up to the gev range by _
fermi_-lat , stricter constraints are obtained , such as @xmath56 in grb 090510 @xcite .
+ let us compare these constraints on the energetics and the relativistic nature of the emitting material in sgrbs with the predictions of the scenario described in the previous section .
if there is a transition triggered from the inside @xcite , namely due to dm self - annihilation in the central core of a ns ( @xmath4 , @xmath5 ) then the final configuration may lead to a more compact object with partially deconfined quark content .
the energy gap to this new configuration ( @xmath57 , @xmath58 ) will release approximately ( here we assume @xmath59 for the sake of comparison ) , @xmath60 note that the internal energy due to the matter equation of state has been estimated to be of the order of @xmath61 @xcite , therefore this estimate is correct up to a numerical factor that somewhat depends on the eos .
the energy @xmath62 liberated in a ns@xmath15qs transition can be compared with the energy @xmath63 released in the gravitational collapse leading to the formation of a ns ( standard core - collapse supernova ) .
we define this ratio ( in the approximation @xmath64 ) as @xmath65.the calculation is made assuming a transition of a hadronic type star with a combined eos model including additional hyperons @xcite to a hybrid star with a quark content described by the mit bag model
. two relativistic non - linear walecka - type eos models of glendenning - moszkowsky @xcite are tested , namely , gm1 ( blue curve ) and gm3 ( red curve ) usually used to describe the hadronic phase .
the typical compressibility values @xmath66 for the gm1 model are stiffer than for the gm3 model .
note that in this scenario of hybrid stars the maximum mass for the hybrid object must be somewhat lower than in the case of the pure hadronic star .
although both of them predict maximum hadronic stars masses somewhat on the low side with @xmath67 , ( as compared to recent measurements reporting masses of about @xmath68 @xcite ) , they can be considered illustrative to show a general trend of the typical original configurations before transitioning to hybrid or pure qss . in this figure
the value of some nuclear parameters such as the s - quark mass has been taken to be @xmath69 and the strong coupling constant @xmath70 .
surface tension is @xmath71 .
no curvature energy has been considered .
in this situation the initial configuration masses and radii are not the same , since they depend on the value of the @xmath24 bag constant in the mit model .
following @xcite we consider that the transition takes place between a configuration in the initial hadronic star with gravitational mass @xmath72 and with some baryonic mass @xmath73 and that of a final hybrid object ( computed with the hybrid eos ) with the same baryonic mass , @xmath74 , since that charge is conserved .
@xmath75 and @xmath76 are the energy density and baryonic mass density for the baryonic object .
physically , the transition occurs due to the fact that as the density or central pressure exceeds a threshold value , it is energetically allowed that , at the transition point , bubbles of quark matter form .
this is due to the lowering of the chemical potential in the system as more degrees of freedom are available .
these lumps of quark matter can grow very rapidly , driving a burning front and the original hadronic star will be converted into a hybrid star or quark star . in the mechanism involving self - annihilating dm this
energy released could be considered as _ sparks _ that would coalescence or ignite the medium and allow quark deconfinement out of the baryons present ( this is b - dependent and therefore , eos dependent in our model ) . if we further include corrections due to slightly different masses for the initial and final configurations we have @xmath77 .
we typically find @xmath78 , which illustrates that the transition mechanism discussed here indeed belongs to the class of the most energetic phenomena in the universe . the efficiency @xmath79 is plotted in fig [ fig : eos ] as a function of the bag constant @xmath80 .
it shows that the efficiency @xmath79 is higher as the bag constant @xmath24 grows , pointing to heavier dm particles in order to ignite the nucleation of quark matter lumps but well in the conservative range shown in fig . 2 in @xcite .
further work is needed to clarify the role of the eos in the efficiency of the transition since the possible existence of a burning front able to fully convert the ns into a qs and proceed towards higher radii is a crucial point .
numerically , using typical values @xmath81 , @xmath82 and @xmath83 results in @xmath84 . in the ns@xmath15qs transition
most of the energy @xmath62 will be radiated as neutrinos and photons , as showed by detailed calculations @xcite . additionally gravitational radiation
should also be emitted ( see [ sect : gw ] ) .
we assume now that a small fraction , @xmath85 , of this energy may be injected into the outer crust which is then ejected and becomes relativistic .
the kinetic energy of the expelled crust is @xmath86 if acceleration is complete .
the isotropic equivalent energy that could be radiated as gamma - rays by such an ejecta can be estimated by @xmath87 where @xmath88 is the efficiency of gamma - ray energy extraction from the ejecta and could range from @xmath89 for the extraction of kinetic energy by internal shocks @xcite to @xmath90 for photospheric emission ( see e.g * ? ? ? * ) or magnetic reconnection @xcite .
as discussed below , relativistic motion of the ejecta is favored by a small ejected mass , @xmath91 , which corresponds typically to the outer crust .
the crust is defined as the region where the density drops below nuclear saturation density ( nsd ) at @xmath92 @xmath93 , and the outer crust is limited by the neutron drip ( nd ) at @xmath94 ( see [ sect : engine ] ) .
then , the value @xmath95 used in eq .
[ eq : egammiso ] would correspond for instance to a situation where 1% of @xmath62 is injected in the crust and 10% of this energy is injected preferentially in the outer crust , so that @xmath96 . as there is large uncertainty in this estimate
we use a safe approximation below the @xmath97 quoted in other detailed calculations @xcite .
this estimate of @xmath52 is in reasonable agreement with observations of sgrbs : the ns@xmath15qs conversion scenario investigated here can reproduce measured energies in sgrbs for @xmath98 .
+ regarding the relativistic nature of the ejecta , the maximum lorentz factor , @xmath99 , that can be reached depends on the expelled fraction or ejected mass , @xmath100 , of the crust .
the maximum lorentz factor can be deduced from the estimate of @xmath101 above , and from the ejected mass @xmath100 as : @xmath102 again , it seems that lorentz factors above @xmath103 , in agreement with the observational constraints described above , can be reached as long as the ejected mass remains low ( @xmath104 ) and the fraction of the energy injected in the outer crust is not too small ( @xmath105 ) .
even ultra - high relativistic ejecta with @xmath106 could in principle be produced , if the ejected mass is really small .
this could be the scenario where the _
crust is expelled .
+ we conclude that the dm self - annihilation triggered ns@xmath15qs scenario can , in principle , release enough energy to power a sgrb , and that the ejected crust can reach high lorentz factors , which is necessary to emit gamma - rays .
this is however strongly dependent on the two parameters @xmath85 and @xmath100 which are very difficult to predict accurately at this stage .
this will be briefly discussed in
[ sect : engine ] .
assuming that the transition of a ns to a qs triggered by the self annihilation of accreted dm in the core can inject enough energy into relativistic ejecta to produce a sgrb , it is worth comparing the observed rate of these phenomena with the predicted rate of ns@xmath15qs conversions . the local rate per unit volume of sgrbs , @xmath107 ,
can be estimated from their observed rate and distribution of flux using a population model ( luminosity function , comoving rate , etc ) , as has been done by @xcite , @xcite , who obtain @xmath108 the lower limit corresponds to a comoving sgrb rate that follows the cosmic star formation rate with a long delay , and the upper limit to a constant comoving rate .
unfortunately , the unknown distribution of the beaming factor and its average @xmath109 is again a major source of uncertainty in this estimate .
+ in the scenario presented is this work , the local rate of ns formation , estimated as the local rate of type ii supernovae , gives an _ upper limit _ for the rate of ns @xmath15 qs conversions .
it is of the order of @xcite @xmath110 then the ratio of the former two rates is @xmath111 from these estimates only , one can conclude that ns @xmath15 qs transition can be much more frequent than sgrbs , depending on the fraction of ns that will experience such a transition . if all sgrbs are due to ns @xmath15 qs conversions , the low ratio obtained in eq .
[ eq : ratesnii ] could be ( i ) either due to the fact that only a fraction of ns @xmath15 qs transitions lead to short grbs ; ( ii ) or be related to the fact that only a small fraction of ns are converted into qs .
having only a small fraction of ns converting to a qs is expected if the delay @xmath41 between the formation of a ns and its conversion to a qs is usually long , e.g. @xmath112 several gyr . for a broad probability distribution @xmath113 of the delay @xmath41 , with a high mean value @xmath114 of the order of the hubble time ,
most conversions would not have occured yet , resulting in a low ratio @xmath115 , the observed short grbs being produced by the conversions with the shortest delays . in addition , such a distribution of @xmath113 would make the scenario in good agreement with the properties of short grb afterglows and host galaxies : contrary to the case of lgrbs which are always observed in central regions of star forming galaxies @xcite , sgrbs can occur at any place ( sometimes at the periphery or outside ) in any type of galaxy @xcite .
this indicates a delay between the end of the life of the massive progenitor star and the production of the short grb .
it is already a well known fact that most nss are born with a natal velocity kick @xmath116 that can be as large at @xmath117 km / s @xcite .
therefore , with high values of @xmath41 , not only any correlation with star formation is lost , but the ns can travel a distance @xmath118 and most likely experience the conversion to a qs far from the galactic central regions , or even outside the galaxy . in the scenario presented here a lower limit on @xmath41
can be obtained from the physics of the transition , which is triggered by self - annihilation of accreted dm from the galactic halo . in our galaxy
the dm density distribution can be taken to be of a type @xcite @xmath119}\ ] ] with parameters @xmath120 , @xmath121 , and @xmath122 so that at the solar neighbourhood the keplerian velocity is @xmath123 km / s and the local dm density is @xmath124 .
dm from this halo can be accreted by gravitational capture @xcite at a rate at peak of ns distribution @xcite of@xmath125 but off - peak , at about solar circle it may be reduced somewhat . in this estimate , we assume a wimp - nucleon ( spin independent ) cross section @xmath126 @xcite .
once the steady state , resulting from competing processes of annihilation and accretion , has been reached , the elapsed time is @xmath127 where @xmath128 is the volume of the star .
typically , if we assume a light @xmath32 @xmath12 dm particle , as direct detections experiments seem to preliminary suggest , we obtain @xmath129 yr . for a velocity ( temperature ) dependent cross section and heavier dm particles @xmath130 @xmath12 , this delay can be longer , @xmath131 yr @xcite . from the condition that the transition should likely occur after reaching the steady state , we get a lower limit on the delay @xmath41 , @xmath132 notice that this delay is already much too large to allow to consider producing lgrbs with ns @xmath15 qs conversions , as an associated sn is sometimes found in association with such events within a few days @xcite . on the other hand , it is too small to have sgrbs uncorrelated with star formation , which is required by the observed diversity of sgrb host galaxies and afterglow locations @xcite .
we conclude that @xmath41 is related to the microphysical processes happening in the burning of the ns .
this , in turn , depends on the ability of the compact object ( mainly related to the eos ) and environment conditions to accrete dm and , therefore , can not be simply predicted and should present some spread and extend up to a large value @xmath133 that can be constrained by observations . in our galaxy , there are hundreds of confirmed nss , with measured radii and masses @xcite . on the other hand , the subsample of confirmed nss with an estimate of the age
is very small , due to the difficulty of the age determination , based on cooling theory @xcite .
it seems that nss with an age of at least @xmath134 myr are identified @xcite which would put a lower limit on the maximum value of the delay @xmath41 , @xmath135 such delays , as shown by eq .
[ eq : distance ] , lead to travelled distance of the order of 10 kpc or more , reaching the outskirts of a galaxy but are still too small to de - correlate from the star formation activity .
one can not of course exclude that much older nss are present in the sample of confirmed nss , which would increase @xmath136 up to 100 my or more .
nevertheless , a detailed comparison with the properties of sgrb host would require the knowledge of the distribution @xmath113 , which seems yet out of reach .
another possible approach to constrain the rate of ns@xmath15qs transitions in the scenario proposed here is to focus on the kinematics of observed pulsars .
the pulsar tangential velocity data can be fitted with a bimodal distribution peaked around @xmath137 km / s and an upper @xmath138 km / s @xcite .
the high velocity pulsars with @xmath139 roughly account for the 10@xmath140 of the pulsar population .
the first peak in the distribution is believed to be due to the kick velocity given to the ns when it is formed in a core collapse supernova .
it has been suggested by @xcite that the second higher velocity peak could be due to a _
second _ kick when the ns@xmath15qs conversion takes place . in previous work @xcite
, it was shown that dm seeding in nss may form a stable and long - lived strange quark matter ( sqm ) lump that could induce a partial ns conversion into a hybrid sqm star .
this event may produce , as a consequence , an effect on the kinematics with a birth kick and rotation as a result of the partial burning of the ns @xcite able to produce up to @xmath141 km / s and relative changes in the angular velocity of @xmath142 as a result of the off - center mechanism driving the transition .
other mechanisms quoted in the literature rely on some kind of asymetry @xcite in the front progress . from this interpretation of the observed pulsar velocity distribution , @xmath143
could be taken as an upper limit for the frequency of the ns@xmath15qs transitions , leading to an upper limit for the ns@xmath15qs rate which is more constraining than in eq .
[ eq : ratesnii ] , i.e. @xmath144 since this rate remains higher than the sgrb rate , at this stage the only possibility in this scenario is to to assume that only a fraction @xmath145 of ns @xmath15 qs transitions produce a short grb , leading to @xmath146 this additional factor @xmath147 can be related to internal processes , such as the capacity of the burning front to proceed to the crust ( see [ sect : engine ] ) .
note that the value of the efficiency @xmath148 has been obtained here assuming that all short grbs are produced by ns @xmath15 qs transitions .
however , we will show below ( [ sect : duration ] ) that this scenario naturally leads to short grb durations @xmath149 s , so that only very short grbs are good candidates for counterparts of these ns @xmath15 qs transitions .
then , it reduces in principle even more the value of @xmath147 . on the other hand , observations of afterglows of ultra - short grbs ,
identifications of their host galaxy and measurements of their distance are extremely rare so that their intrinsic rate is unknown .
the distribution of the duration of batse bursts show that @xmath150 of the short bursts have a duration below 100 ms @xcite .
this factor can not however be directly applied to the estimate of the intrinsic rate given by eq .
[ eq : ratesgrb ] . indeed
, this population of very short bursts may very well be a separate group with different properties : they are usually made of a single short and hard spike with possible substructure on a timescale of a few 10 @xmath151s @xcite .
the analysis ( @xmath152 and @xmath153 diagram ) of the distribution of very short bursts observed by batse and konus gives some evidence for a local origin @xcite . this is however a bit contradictory with more recent results obtained by _ swift _ : 10 very short bursts with a duration of less 100 ms have been detected by swift until june 2012 .
all of these show indeed a single short duration hard spike in the bat . in many cases ,
the afterglow has not been identified or is very weak at the limit of the detection ( grb 050925 , grb 051105a , grb 070209 , grb 070810b , grb 070923 , grb 090417a , grb 100628a , grb 120305a ) .
there are however two very short bursts where the afterglow has been well detected and localized and where there is a good candidate for the host galaxy . in both cases , the host candidate is an early type galaxy and the afterglow shows a large offset of a few 10 kpc : grb 050509b seems to be associated to an elliptical galaxy at @xmath154 with an offset of 35 - 55 kpc @xcite ; grb 090515 is probably associated to an early type galaxy at @xmath155 with a large offset of 75 kpc @xcite .
these two examples indicate a population at cosmological distance which is uncorrelated to star formation , in agreement with the discussion above .
the sample is however much too small to allow for a determination of the intrinsic rate of very short grbs and an estimate of @xmath147 .
in this section , we model the basis of the central engine mechanism of the internal burning front that will induce a resultant outflow with several relativistically moving emitting regions .
this discussion is based on a series of works @xcite .
nuclear processes involving quark deconfinement in the hadronic phase may happen if the @xmath156 @xmath12 dm particle candidate self - annihilates liberating @xmath157 photons and other light particle pair products .
the corresponding lump of strange quark matter ( @xmath6 matter ) evolves towards the formation of a fireball that may cause stress and tension on the base of the inner crust of a ns .
since there are only a few preliminar simulations @xcite developed so far on the full process of energy transport from the inner deconfined regions to outer regions through a burning front there is not much information where this front may stop or whether it fully proceeds to the outer crust . in these simulations
the ns burning condition is dynamically analyzed showing the possibility that a hybrid star may form if the conversion front is not able to proceed as _
burning_. however , a full detailed treatment has not hitherto been performed .
+ in previous work @xcite , it was found that the seeding is most likely a non central process , and therefore , geometrically , the burning front progression may not be a radially symmetric dynamical process ( see fig . 2 in @xcite ) .
the possibility of a beamed ejection of the outer crust arises then from the anisotropy in the progression of the burning front .
this has been somewhat explored in the work of @xcite where they discuss the possibility of preferred ejection of a fireball through the polar caps . in the present work ,
we discuss the constraints on the ejected mass as a result of the ns@xmath15qs conversion .
similar to what may happen in the heavy ion collision events in large colliders , a fireball may be formed and grow rapidly . then , a pure nucleonic eos of matter , would no longer be valid as nucleon quark content may be deconfined .
since the newer eos is softened , later evolution may lead to the fact that the original hydrostatic structure is not longer energetically possible and re - adjustement of the object to favor lower radii and masses and then to build up tension in the crust tending to eject it and break it up .
the crust mainly corresponds to matter where the density is below the nsd .
therefore for lower densities a myriad of nuclei with mass number @xmath158 populate this phase .
since the particular distribution of nuclei depend on the competition of short - range hadronic interaction and long range coulomb interaction a set of irregular shapes different from the spherical one can arise , forming what is known as the _ pasta phase_. as a result , low density matter in the crust of nss is mostly neutron - rich due to the deleptonization caused by neutrino escape in the first stages of cooling .
its isospin content is closer to that of neutron matter than to regular nuclei where proton and neutron content are balanced @xmath159 . from the @xmath160fe iron content
usually assumed in the lower density region in the crust , there is a series of neutron - rich nuclei going through heavier @xmath161ni , @xmath162ge , @xmath163sr and after this the nd transition takes place , signaling the inner crust of the ns . in the inner crust , surrounding these non - uniform pasta structures , a neutron gas is filling the system , as has been directly simulated in previous work @xcite .
fragmented emission of ejecta is therefore possible since the stress in the base of the crust from a burning front may liberate the most abundant structures and the rest of lower @xmath158 nuclei .
the gradient of composition ( heavy @xmath15 light ) should also produce some variability during the crust ejection , all regions of the crust being not necessarily ejected with the same lorentz factor .
an additional source of uncertainty is related to the fraction of the initial energy release associated to the transition in the core which will be injected into gamma - ray photons , and the associated photo - disintegration of heavy nuclei .
an efficient photo - disintegration would lead to a modified chemical composition biased towards light elements , and would enrich the medium by free neutrons that can be an additional source of energy ( neutron decay ) and internal dissipation in the ejecta ( see [ sect : duration ] ) . in order to size the importance of this ejection , we plot in fig .
[ fig3 ] the crust mass @xmath164 as a function of the stellar radius .
these data are obtained integrating the tov @xcite equations for eight representative different eos @xcite up to the core .
we compute the mass of the crust by integrating above a critical density , either the neutron drip density @xmath165 @xmath166 to estimate the mass of the outer ( solid ) crust only , or the nuclear saturation density @xmath167 @xmath168 ( where crust - core boundary sets in ) to estimate the mass of the entire crust .
we find that the condition @xmath169 needed for the relativistic motion ( [ sect : energetics ] ) can be fulfilled if only the outer crust is ejected ( @xmath170 ) , whereas it becomes much more difficult if the whole crust is expelled ( @xmath171 ) .
the details of the physics of the propagation of the burning front and the associated energy deposition are required to estimate precisely the fraction of the crust which is ejected .
if this fraction varies from a ns@xmath15qs transition to another , this would naturally lead to @xmath172 as discussed in the previous section .
in this section we discuss some expected properties for sgrbs produced in the scenario proposed in this work .
we focus on the identification of distinct features related to the specific central engine that could help in distinguishing this mechanism from others proposed in the literature .
let us assume that the ejected outer crust has a mass @xmath173 , an initial energy @xmath174 and a width @xmath175 , where @xmath176 is the light crossing time ( @xmath177 ) .
the maximum final lorentz factor that can be reached in the ejection is @xmath178 due to the large physical uncertainties regarding the energy deposition in the crust and the following ejection , we do not attempt here a detailed calculation of the relativistic ejection ( see e.g. * ? ? ? * for a self - similar solution of the propagation of a strong shock wave within the ns and the following shock breakout ) .
for a thermal acceleration , the saturation to this value of the lorentz factor will occur at radius @xmath179 assuming an initial radius @xmath180 km for the ejection .
the ejecta will become transparent for its own radiation at the photospheric radius @xmath181 where we take the thomson opacity @xmath182 .
here we assume @xmath183 free electron per nucleon in the expanding gas , whereas the dynamical chemical composition discussed in the previous section may lead to lower values .
this does not affect too much the discussion as the dependence goes moderately as @xmath184 .
this expression of @xmath185 is valid for @xmath186 .
the radius @xmath187 is defined below and is of the order of a few @xmath188 cm so that the condition is always true for the typical parameters considered here .
the estimates of @xmath189 and @xmath185 are based on standard fireball theory for grbs ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) and are only rough estimates for the scenario considered here as the physics of the ejection of the crust is much more complex .
we should bear in mind that the ejecta composition @xcite and fragmentation may affect both the dynamics ( @xmath189 ) and the interaction with radiation ( @xmath185 ) @xcite .
therefore , if the energy is not deposited in an homogeneous way in the expelled crust , the final lorentz factor in the ejecta may not be uniform .
in addition , fragmentation of the crust during its ejection will also lead to some variability in the ejecta .
if variations of @xmath190 are present on length scales @xmath191 , this will induce collisions ( internal shocks ) that will dissipate energy at a typical radius @xmath187 given by @xmath192 clearly , this possible internal dissipation will always occur well below the photosphere , and , depending on the value of the lorentz factor , even before the acceleration is complete .
most of the dissipated energy should contribute again to the acceleration and the internal shock phase will only tend to smooth out the initial internal variability , without contributing to the emission
. the ejecta will expand freely initially , but will eventually be decelerated by the external medium . however , due to the expected delay between the formation of the ns and the ns @xmath15 qs transition , this external medium can correspond to the periphery of the host galaxy or even the surrounding intergalactic medium , i.e. have a low density .
we assume a uniform medium with a number density @xmath193 .
then the deceleration will start at radius @xmath194 @xmath195 is the proton mass . from these different estimates ,
we find for the proposed scenario that @xmath196 this would naturally lead to two episodes of emission , a single spike emitted at the photosphere followed by an afterglow starting at late time due to the high value of @xmath197 .
the duration of the prompt spike should be fixed by the intrinsic curvature of the emitting region and its lateral extension , which gives @xmath198 except if the ejection is highly beamed , the minimum is usually given by the first term .
nevertheless , this estimate clearly points out towards short ( @xmath199 s ) and even probably very short ( @xmath200 ms , see figure [ fig : grbnsqs ] ) grbs without any strong variability ( one main single spike ) . due to the low external density
, the afterglow should rise slowly and reach a maximum around @xmath201 , i.e. a few 10 ms to a few hours after the grb , depending on the external density .
in addition , the combination of a low external density and a moderate energy will naturally lead to a weak afterglow .
note that if free neutrons are present in the ejecta , due to efficient photo - disintegration ( see [ sect : engine ] ) , these neutrons will decay at a typical radius @xmath202 , fixed by the mean lifetime @xmath203 , which could lead to an early additional signature at @xmath204 ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
vs efficiency of the energy injection in the crust @xmath85 , the following constraints are plotted : ( 1 ) lines of constant lorentz factor are plotted in blue for @xmath205 ( non relativistic limit ) , @xmath206 , @xmath207 and @xmath208 .
the limit @xmath209 obtained from the compactness argument ( see [ sect : energetics ] is plotted in thick line and the forbidden region is shaded ; ( 2 ) the limit where the radius of the internal dissipation @xmath187 is equal to the radius of the photosphere is plotted in red ( most of the parameter space is well below this line , i.e. @xmath210 ) ; the limit where the observed duration of the prompt emission of photospheric origin is equal to 100 ms ( 1 s ) is plotted in magenta solid ( dashed ) line ; the limit where the observed peak energy of the photospheric emission is 100 kev is plotted in green ; the limit where the isotropic equivalent gamma - ray energy emitted by the photosphere is equal to @xmath211 is plotted in black . the effect of the redshift of the source on the duration and the spectrum are not included . other parameters
are @xmath212 ( i.e. the width of the outer crust is 300 m ) and @xmath213 ( i.e. the ejecta is beamed within @xmath214 ) .
as can be observed , a large fraction of the parameter space ( top - left region ) corresponds to ultra - relativistic outflows ( @xmath215 ) producing a very short ( @xmath216 ms ) but bright ( @xmath217 ) spike of hard ( @xmath218 kev ) photons , i.e. a very short grb . ]
if most of the gamma - rays are produced at the photosphere , one should expect a thermal ( quasi - planckian ) spectrum , possibly modified at high energy by comptonization @xcite .
the peak energy of the observed spectrum will then be located at @xmath219 , where @xmath220 is the temperature of the photosphere .
it can be computed assuming an adiabatic radial expansion from the ejection to the photosphere : @xmath221 the efficiency of the photospheric emission can also be deduced from the adiabatic evolution and equals @xmath222 .
this leads to a better estimate of the isotropic equivalent energy radiated in gamma - rays , @xmath223 that stands on the lower values for grbs .
of course , there is still a large uncertainty due to the unknown factors @xmath47 , @xmath224 and @xmath100 .
however , these two estimates confirm the capacity to produce bright and hard spikes of gamma - rays in the considered scenario , as illustrated in figure [ fig : grbnsqs ] where all the constraints on the prompt gamma - ray emission expected in the ns @xmath15 qs conversion scenario are summarized
. another possible signature of the scenario would be the presence of spectral features and lines associated to the specific chemical composition ( heavy elements ) of the ejected material .
following the work by @xcite where @xmath225 were considered , the spectrum could be influenced below the mev range .
in addition to the expected short duration burst of @xmath226-rays and x - rays and to the afterglow , it is likely that a multi - messenger approach must be followed to spot this progenitor scenario for sgrbs .
the emission of gravitational waves by the merger of ns+ns or ns+bh binary is the most promising source for detectors such as virgo and ligo and their advanced versions @xcite , or the einstein telescope @xcite .
the predicted emission during the three main stages of the merger has been extensively studied in the literature ( see * ? ? ? * for a review ) . in the inspiral stage ,
the signal is very well known up to the last stable orbit .
then , the emission during the merger is more uncertain and must be modeled using supercomputer simulations which provide information about the gravitational waveform @xcite ( see the recent simulations by @xcite which compute the evolution of the merger up to black hole formation , including or not magnetic fields , realistic eos , etc . ) .
the final ringdown stage is also very well known as the inspiral .
therefore , the detection of gravitational waves in association with a sgrb would undoubtedly prove if the progenitor is a merger or not . with a horizon of @xmath227 mpc for ns+ns mergers and @xmath228 mpc for ns+bh mergers
, there may be merger detections with advanced virgo , ligo@xcite ( 0.4 to 400 mergers / yr for ns+ns , a slightly smaller rate for ns+bh , @xcite ) .
however , the simultaneous detection with a sgrb if the merger scenario is correct is more uncertain , both for theoretical ( beaming of the gamma - ray emission ) and instrumental ( localization of sgrbs ) reasons .
the gravitational wave signature of the scenario studied here is not as well known as for compact binary mergers .
it is expected that a change in the moment of inertia is caused by deformations in the ns@xmath15qs transition .
some preliminary estimates of the transient gravitational wave signal from an explosive quark - hadron phase transition have been done @xcite .
it could in principle be detected out to 20 mpc with advanced virgo / ligo , which makes unfortunately the probability of detection with an associated sgrb quite low , even if the intrinsic rate of very short grbs is quite uncertain ( see [ sect : rate ] ) .
the strategy for the detection of gravitational waves associated to a grb is to combine searches , already having identified typical patterns in temporal and directional coincidence with sgrbs that had sufficient gravitational - wave data available , although it is a very challenging task @xcite .
an additional signal that may be used to discriminate between progenitor models for sgrbs is the neutrino emission .
the specific signal expected from ns+ns mergers has been studied using supercomputer simulations ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) . in this work and within the present scenario we do not attempt to describe such a neutrino emission since it crucially depends on the central engine details .
however , it should be expected a neutrino flux originating from hadronic reactions happening in the central engine ( conversion in the nucleon burning front of quark deconfinement and strangeness production ) or in the ejecta ( photo - meson interactions between shock - accelerated protons / nuclei and gamma - ray photons ) .
in addition , if produced neutrons do not interact they will decay being accompanied by anti - neutrinos .
emission of prompt muon neutrino fluxes have been performed in some grb general scenarios @xcite and seem to be testable as recent preliminary estimated sensitivities for ice cube 86-strings quote values of @xmath229 .
additionally , experiments as amanda - ii and icecube have the capability @xcite of detecting anisotropies from the emission @xcite of neutrinos from gamma ray induced air showers .
therefore , as motivated , the discovery of high energy neutrinos in correlation with a sgrb and gw signal would help disentangling the current scenario .
in this work we discuss the possibility that a ns@xmath15qs transition may be a central engine model for short ( @xmath230 1 s ) or more probably very short ( @xmath216 ms ) grbs .
this is an alternative to the popular ns+ns or ns+bh merger scenario for sgrbs .
note that this scenario is known to be compatible with observations of sgrbs but has not been proved yet , and that in addition , there are a few observations suggesting that very short bursts could be a separate population .
we suggest that these very short bursts could be produced by the ejection and acceleration to relativistic speed of the ( outer ) crust of the ns during the conversion to a qs .
we find that * the isotropic equivalent gamma - ray energy @xmath231 can be accounted for , assuming that @xmath232 of the gravitational energy released by the transition is injected in the outer crust with , however , a large uncertainty due to the unknown beaming factor of the ejection ; * high lorentz factors , necessary for the emission of @xmath226-rays on short time - scales ( compactness problem ) , can be reached , as long as the mass of the expelled crust is less than @xmath233 ; this is attainable for the outer crust in ns models . *
the rate of very short grbs can probably be reproduced , assuming that only a fraction of transitions lead to a grb and that there is on average a large delay between the formation of the ns and the conversion into a qs .
such a delay is expected due to the fact that the transition is triggered by self - annihilation of dm , which needs first to be accreted in the core of the ns .
such delays would then naturally at least partially suppress the correlation between star formation and very short grbs , which should be observed in any type of galaxy with a large offset ( at the present time , there are only two host galaxies of very short grbs which have been possibly identified , both being early - type , and the offset is a few 10 kpc in both cases ) ; * the prompt gamma - ray emission should be mainly produced at the photosphere , without a strong variability which should be washed out by internal dissipation at much smaller radii . * for a large fraction of the parameter space , a hard ( @xmath234 kev ) and short ( duration @xmath230 100 ms ) spike of gamma - rays is expected , in general agreement with observations of very short grbs ; * the afterglow should rise slowly and be rather weak , due to a low density of the external medium
. a possible additional signature can be expected at early time if the ejected material initially contains free neutrons . *
fragmentation of the ejecta arises naturally in this model since non - uniform nuclei arranged in lattice or even pasta phases are present in the low density matter .
* spectral features of heavy nuclei relativistically accelerated are expected below @xmath235 mev . to summarize , possible _ signatures _ compared to the binary ( ns , bh ) merger scenario are the shortness of the prompt gamma - ray emission , with possibly a thermal spectrum and spectral features due to the heavy composition , the associated gw emission , and possibly the properties of the host galaxies and the distribution of the afterglow position in the host , this latter signature being however difficult to characterize due to the uncertainties on the typical delay between the ns formation and the transition to a qs . clearly , a multi - wavelength / multi - messenger approach is needed to reach a firm conclusion .
we thank the micinn ( spain ) multidark , fis-2009 - 07238 , fis2011 - 14759-e and fis2012 - 30926 projects and the esf - funded compstar project for partial financial support .
we acknowledge useful discussions with i. bombaci , j. horvath , k. kotera , r. ouyed and c. providencia .
m. a. p. g. would like to thank the iap for its kind hospitality . | we present a mechanism based on internal self - annihilation of dark matter accreted from the galactic halo in the inner regions of neutron stars that may trigger the full or partial conversion into a quark star .
we explain how this effect may induce a gamma ray burst that could be classified as short , according to the usual definition based on time duration of the prompt gamma - ray emission .
this mechanism differs in many aspects from the most discussed scenario associating short gamma - ray bursts with compact object binary mergers .
we list possible observational signatures that should help to distinguish between these two possible classes of progenitors
. short gamma ray burst , dark matter , neutron star , quark star . |
silicates are an important component of interstellar and circumstellar dust .
many galactic sources show broad emission or absorption features at 10 and 18 @xmath0 m due to the si
o stretching and o si o bending vibrations of silicate bonds . because of the width of these features , these silicates must have an amorphous structure .
these broad amorphous silicate features have also been observed in a variety of extragalactic environments , including seyfert galaxies ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , quasars @xcite , luminous and ultra - luminous infrared galaxies @xcite and a sample of mid - infrared detected , optically invisible , high - luminosity galaxies with redshifts of 1.7 @xmath3 z @xmath3 2.8 @xcite . in recent years , observational evidence for the presence of _ crystalline _ silicates in various astrophysical environments has also emerged . in particular ,
infrared spectra have revealed that silicates in circumstellar environments often contain a significant crystalline fraction around both pre - main - sequence stars ( t - tauri stars and herbig aebe stars ) and post - main - sequence stars ( asymptotic giant branch ( agb ) stars , post - agb stars , planetary nebulae , luminous blue variables ( lbvs ) , red super giants ( rsgs ) and post - rsgs ) ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
? * ; * ? ? ?
these crystalline silicates are invariably magnesium rich ( e.g. , pyroxene ( mgsio@xmath4 ) and forsterite ( mg@xmath1sio@xmath2 ) .
crystalline silicates are also known to be ubiquitous in the solar system , including primitive objects such as comets ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
because crystallization is inhibited by high - energy barriers , the origin and evolution of the crystalline silicate fraction in interstellar and circumstellar media has the potential to provide direct evidence of energetic processing of grains .
silicates play an especially large role in shaping the mid - infrared spectral appearance of ultra - luminous infrared galaxies ( ulirgs ; l@xmath510@xmath6l@xmath7 ) .
ulirgs are thought to represent the final stage in the merging process of gas - rich spirals , where the interaction has driven gas and dust towards the remnant nucleus , fueling a massive starburst and a nascent active galactic nucleus ( agn ) . here , we present evidence for the presence of _ crystalline _ silicates as part of the deep silicate absorption features observed towards a sample of twelve heavily obscured ulirgs .
we are obtaining mid - infrared spectroscopy for a sample of 110 ulirgs , as part of the guaranteed time observation ( gto ) ulirg program of the infrared spectrograph ( irs)@xcite on the spitzer space telescope @xcite .
seventy seven of these spectra have been analyzed so far .
the twelve ulirg spectra presented in this paper were selected based upon the strength of spectral structure indicative of crystalline silicate absorption bands at 16 and 23@xmath0 m .
table [ tab1 ] lists the basic properties of these targets , along with their observation dates and on - source integration times .
the observations were made with the short - low ( sl ) and long - low ( ll ) modules of the _ irs_. the spectra were extracted from the flatfielded images provided by the spitzer science center ( pipeline version s11.0.2 ) .
the images were background - subtracted by differencing the two sl apertures and for ll , by differencing the two nod positions .
spectra were then extracted and calibrated using the _ irs _ standard star hr6348 for sl and the stars hr6348 , hd166780 , and hd173511 for ll @xcite .
small wavelength corrections were made to compensate for known offsets in the s11 processed data .
after extraction the orders were stitched to ll order 1 , requiring order - to - order scaling adjustments of typically 510% .
the largest adjustment was made for arp220 to match sl order 1 and ll order 2 , which required sl1 to be scaled up by 21% . in the final step
, the 537@xmath0 m spectra were scaled to match the observed _ irs _ blue or red peak - up flux . for those sources lacking a ( useful ) peak - up flux ,
the spectra were scaled down by 10% , the average scaling factor of the other spectra . in some spectra , most notably in iras205514250 , residual fringing , which is due to subpixel pointing errors
, appears in ll order 1 ( between 20 and 30@xmath0 m ) .
lccccc target & aor key & date observed & int .
time & redshift & d@xmath8 + & & & min .
& & mpc + 001837111 & 7556352 & 14 nov .
2003 & 15 & 0.327 & 1700 + 003971312 & 4963584 & 04 jan .
2004 & 14 & 0.262 & 1320 + 011992307 & 4964864 & 18 jul .
2004 & 14 & 0.156 & 737 + 063017934 & 4970240 & 11 aug .
2004 & 12 & 0.156 & 700 + 063616217 & 4970496 & 11 aug .
2004 & 14 & 0.160 & 760 + 08572 + 3915 & 4972032 & 15 apr .
2004 & 6 & 0.0584 & 258 + 15250 + 3609 & 4983040 & 4 mar .
2004 & 7 & 0.0554 & 244 + arp220 & 4983808 & 29 feb .
2004 & 5 & 0.0181 & 78 + 17068 + 4027 & 4986112 & 16 apr .
2004 & 14 & 0.179 & 858 + 18443 + 7433 & 4987904 & 5 mar .
2004 & 14 & 0.135 & 627 + 205514250 & 4990208 & 14 may 2004 & 4 & 0.0427 & 186 + 23129 + 2548 & 4991488 & 17 dec . 2003
& 23 & 0.179 & 858 +
the top panel of figure[fig1 ] shows the average _ irs _ low - resolution spectrum for our sample , obtained after scaling the spectra to s@xmath9=1jy at 15@xmath0 m .
the average spectrum is dominated by broad absorption features at 10 and 18@xmath0 m , which we attribute to absorption by amorphous silicates .
the spectrum further shows weaker absorption features due to water ice ( 6.0@xmath0 m ) and hydrocarbons ( 6.90 and 7.25@xmath0 m ) .
pah emission features can be seen at low contrast at 6.2 , 7.7 , and 11.2@xmath0 m .
the features are especially weak in the spectrum of irasf001837111 @xcite and absent in the spectrum of iras08572 + 3915 ( figure[fig1 ] , lower panel ) .
our spectra further show a few emission lines , most notably the h@xmath1s(3 ) line at 9.66@xmath0 m , the [ neii ] line at 12.81@xmath0 m and the h@xmath1s(1 ) line at 17.0@xmath0 m .
these will be discussed elsewhere @xcite . upon close inspection
, the spectra also reveal evidence for weak and narrow absorption features near 16 , 19 and 23 @xmath0 m , independent of the redshift of the source .
emission and absorption features at these wavelengths are also know in galactic sources with strong silicate features and have been attributed to the presence of crystalline silicates . in order to investigate the presence of a crystalline component to the silicate absorption features in our sample , we infer the silicate optical depth spectrum by dividing out a local continuum from our _ irs _ spectra .
we define the local continuum as a three point spline interpolation of continuum points at 5.6@xmath0 m ( 0.1@xmath0 m shortward of the wavelength range affected by the 6.0@xmath0 m water ice absorption feature ) , 7.1@xmath0 m ( in between the two hydrocarbon absorption bands at 6.90 and 7.25@xmath0 m ) , and the red cut - off of irs ll order 1 ( ranging from 29 to 36@xmath0 m , depending on the redshift of the source ) . for sources without discernable 7.7@xmath0 m pah emission ( e.g. iras08572 + 3915 and irasf001837111 )
, we replace the 7.1@xmath0 m pivot by the continuum at 7.98.0@xmath0 m .
the resulting spline interpolated local continuum is illustrated for iras08572 + 3915 in the lower panel of figure[fig1 ] .
the effect of small changes in the adopted local continuum on the resulting silicate profile is illustrated by the shaded areas around the spline - interpolated continuum in the lower panel of figure[fig1 ] and on the resulting silicate profile in the third panel of figure[fig2 ] .
the resulting optical depth profiles for the twelve sources in our sample have apparent 10@xmath0 m optical depths ranging from 2.1 for iras17068 + 4027 to 4.2 for iras08572 + 3915 , with a mean value of 2.5 ( see figure[fig3 ] and table[tab2 ] ) . in order to derive the characteristics of these narrow features we have to account for the amorphous silicate features which dominate the absorption structure in this wavelength range .
we have compared the general profile of the 10 and 18@xmath0 m amorphous silicate featues in these ulirgs with those in a sample of galactic background sources @xcite . however , because of the uncertainties in the placement of the continuum for these galactic sources , the derived interstellar 10 and @xmath10 m amorphous silicate features show differences in their relative strengths , and in the level of absorption between them
. since fitting the ulirg data with a composite galactic spectrum would therefore introduce spurious artifacts , we have elected to represent the broad amorphous silicate features in the ulirg and galactic spectra with spline fits .
deviations from these fits in the ulirg spectra , significantly larger than those seen among the galactic sources , would then argue strongly for a crystalline component .
we have tested this procedure on the high signal - to - noise spectrum of the galactic center source gcs3 , and on laboratory absorption spectra of amorphous silicates .
the residuals from the spline fits to these spectra are very small ( @xmath36% ) , validating our analysis to that level .
the method is demonstrated in the top panel of figure[fig2 ] for laboratory spectra of amorphous olivines and pyroxenes @xcite .
the spline fit traces the amorphous profile to better than 2% of the local optical depth , except for the 16@xmath0 m range , where the spline deviates by up to 6% .
the resulting small artifacts are shown at the top of the panel .
we also tested our method on the optical depth profile as seen towards the galactic background source gcs3 @xcite , depicted in the second panel of figure[fig2 ] .
the silicates along this line of sight are thought to be @xmath1199% amorphous in composition @xcite .
in contrast to the laboratory profiles , the fit residuals for the gcs3 spectrum are dominated by spectral noise rather than fitting artifacts .
the third panel of figure[fig2 ] shows the fit to the silicate profile of the ulirg iras08572 + 3915 .
the red curve smoothly fits the maximum depth of the broad 18@xmath0 m feature , while ignoring the strong , narrow substructure around 11 , 16 , 19 and 23@xmath0 m . after subtracting the spline - interpolated amorphous component from the optical depth spectrum ,
the features at 11 , 16 , 19 and 23@xmath0 m show up in the fit residual spectrum , clearly above the levels expected for artifacts introduced by the fitting procedure . in the lower panel of figure[fig2 ]
we compare these residuals to known spectra of circumstellar and laboratory crystalline silicates .
the adopted spline fits to the amorphous silicate profiles for the twelve ulirgs in our sample are overplotted in red in figure[fig3 ] , while the residual optical depth spectra are presented in figure[fig4 ] .
the individual spectra in the latter figure are truncated at -0.1 optical depth in order not to be dominated by spurious optical depth structure introduced by emission features of 11.3@xmath0 m pah and 12.8@xmath0 m [ ne ii ] .
these common features aside , the twelve spectra clearly show absorption structure at 16 , 19 and 23@xmath0 m that can not be attributed to observational artifacts ( i.e. fringing , flux calibration ) or imperfections in the spline fit to the amorphous component .
a few sources ( e.g. iras063017934 , iras23129 + 2548 ) further show a weak feature at 2728@xmath0 m and only one source , iras08572 + 3915 , a strong feature at 11@xmath0 m ( see also figure[fig2 ] )
. the latter feature may also be present in the other spectra , but its detection is complicated by the presence of emission from 10.51@xmath0 m [ s iv ] and 11.3@xmath0 m pah in the same wavelength range ( see figure[fig4 ] ) .
further note the presence of absorption bands of gas phase c@xmath1h@xmath1 and hcn at 13.7 and 14.05@xmath0 m in the spectra of several of our ulirgs , most notably iras15250 + 3609 and iras23129 + 2548 .
these bands are otherwise seen in dense , warm molecular clouds surrounding massive galactic protostars @xcite . in figure[fig5 ]
we show the average residual optical depth spectrum for our twelve sources and compare it to the observed crystalline silicate opacity profile of the young star is tau @xcite and the calculated opacity profile of forsterite @xcite .
the relative strengths of the absorption bands in the ulirg spectra are different from those of the comparison profiles . in the ulirg spectra ,
the features get progressively weaker towards longer wavelength , whereas no such trend exists for the comparison profiles ( see also figures [ fig2 ] and [ fig5 ] ) . a possible explanation for this trend could be dilution of the crystalline absorption spectrum by cold dust emission from a less obscured cooler component , either the other nucleus or the circumnuclear environment .
nevertheless , the similarities between the ulirg profile and the comparison profiles in peak position and width are striking .
we therefore conclude that the features observed at 11 , 16 , 19 , 23 and 28@xmath0 m in the ulirg spectra are indeed caused by the presence of crystalline silicates in their nuclear medium .
the peak position of the 16@xmath0 m band , in particular , is sensitive to the mg / fe ratio of olivines @xcite .
the peak position of this band observed in the ulirg spectra ( 16.1@xmath0 m ) falls close to the laboratory measured position of forsterite , the mg - rich end member of the olivines ( mg@xmath1sio@xmath2 ; 16.3@xmath0 m ; * ? ? ? * ) and much to the blue of the peak position in fayalite , the iron - rich end member of the olivines ( fe@xmath1sio@xmath2 ; 17.7@xmath0 m ; * ? ? ? * ) .
hence , in line with other observations of crystalline silicates in space , extragalactic olivines appear to be extremely mg - rich and fe - poor .
lcccc target & @xmath12(peak ) & @xmath13(peak ) & @xmath13(peak)/@xmath12(peak ) &
n@xmath14/n@xmath15 + 001837111 & 3.0 & 0.22 & 0.073 & 0.11 + 003971312 & 3.2 & 0.28 & 0.088 & 0.13 + 011992307 & 3.6 & 0.21 & 0.060 & 0.09 + 063017934 & 3.4 & 0.35 & 0.10 & 0.15 + 063616217 & 2.9 & 0.15 & 0.051 & 0.08 + 08572 + 3915 & 4.2 & 0.22 & 0.053 & 0.08 + 15250 + 3609 & 3.6 & 0.20 & 0.056 & 0.08 + arp220 & 3.3 & 0.16 & 0.048 & 0.07 + 17068 + 4027 & 2.1 & 0.17 & 0.082 & 0.12 + 18443 + 7433 & 3.2 & 0.25 & 0.078 & 0.12 + 205514250 & 2.9 & 0.18 & 0.062 & 0.09 + 23129 + 2548 & 3.2 & 0.25 & 0.078 & 0.12 + we infer the fraction of crystalline silicates in our sample from the peak optical depths of the 10@xmath0 m amorphous and the 16@xmath0 m crystalline silicate absorption bands using @xmath16 where @xmath17 and @xmath18 are the mass column densities of the amorphous and crystalline silicates . adopting @xmath19(peak )
= 2.4@xmath2010@xmath21 @xmath22/g as the peak mass absorption coefficient for amorphous silicates @xcite and @xmath23(peak ) = 1.6@xmath2010@xmath21 @xmath22/g as the peak mass absorption coefficient for forsterite @xcite , we find crystalline - to - amorphous silicate mass column density ratios ranging from 0.07 to 0.15 , with a median value of 0.11 ( see table[tab2 ] ) .
it should be understood that these numbers are upper limits , since foreground emission and radiative transfer effects within the optically thick 10@xmath0 m silicate band may cause the apparent optical depth of the 10@xmath0 m silicate feature to be a lower limit to the true optical depth .
our findings should be contrasted to the upper limit of crystalline silicates in the general ism of the milky way of @xmath31% @xcite and the crystalline - to - amorphous ratios of up to 0.75 observed in circumstellar environments @xcite .
given the broad range in infered crystalline - to - amorphous silicate ratios in our sample , we have investigated the existence of correlations with the apparent 10@xmath0 m optical depth , the iras r(60,100 ) color , the 5.5@xmath0m to23@xmath0
m rest frame spectral slope and the 6.2@xmath0 m pah equivalent width , but found no significant trends .
the fraction of crystallinity within this sample can therefore , at present , not be linked to the infrared spectral appearance .
we have detected crystalline substructure in the silicate absorption features towards twelve strongly obscured ulirg nuclei .
this is the first detection of crystalline silicates in any source outside the local group .
space - based and ground - based observations have revealed the presence of infrared emission features of crystalline silicates around young stellar objects and evolved stars @xcite .
comets also often show evidence for crystalline silicates in their spectra @xcite .
in contrast , while stellar sources of silicate dust inject at least 5% of their silicates in crystalline form , the galactic _ interstellar _ silicate feature is exceedingly smooth , and there is no evidence for a crystalline absorption component in the galactic ism .
this translates into an upper limit on the crystalline fraction in the galactic interstellar medium of 1% @xcite .
this difference in crystallinity between silicates injected and silicates in the ism implies a rapid transformation of crystalline silicates into amorphous silicates in the interstellar medium ( @xmath24yr ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
this transformation has been attributed to energetic processing of the dust by heavy cosmic ray ions @xcite or to ion bombardment in high velocity ( v@xmath111000km / s ) shocks @xcite .
in particular , based upon laboratory experiments and estimated cosmic ray fluxes in our galaxy , the timescale for amorphization is estimated to be only 70 million years @xcite , considerably shorter than the timescale at which ( crystalline ) silicates are injected into the galactic ism ( 4 billion years ; * ? ? ? * ) these same processes injection of crystalline silicates from stars and cosmic ray and shock amorphization will play a role in the interstellar media of these ulirgs as well .
possible explanations for the much higher crystalline silicate fraction in these ulirgs as compared to the milky way include a higher fraction of crystalline silicates injected and/or a delay in the interstellar amorphization rate .
in particular , ulirgs are characterized by a high rate of star formation driven by merging events .
in contrast to the local ism , the enrichment of the dusty interstellar medium will be dominated by the rapidly evolving massive stars and the contribution by the more numerous low - mass stars will lag on the timescale associated with the ulirg - merger event ( @xmath25 yr ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) .
evidence for the presence of a large population of evolved massive stars in ulirg nuclei exists for the nearest ulirg , arp220 @xcite .
spectroscopic studies of sources in our galaxy have revealed that massive stars are prominent sources of crystalline silicates during the supergiant phase . in particular , the more extreme examples of this class , such as afgl4106 , nmlcyg and irc+10420 , have crystalline silicate fractions of the order of 0.15 @xcite .
likewise , crystalline silicates have been observed in the ejecta of some lbvs , such as r71 and agcar @xcite .
this episodic mass - loss phase dominates the dust injection by the most massive stars ( m@xmath1150m@xmath7 ) in the galaxy . finally , it is currently unknown how much crystalline silicate dust is injected by supernovae .
indeed it is unknown how much dust is injected by sne .
however , it is conceivable that the sne resulting from this starburst also inject a large fraction of their freshly condensed dust in the form of crystalline silicates .
hence , a starburst may rapidly increase the crystalline silicate fraction in the nuclear region .
of course , the high supernova rate in a starburst will drive strong shock waves into the local environment , which will sputter the dust , returning the atoms from the solid to the gas phase @xcite .
however , likely , the destruction rate of crystalline and amorphous silicates are similar and hence , to first order , this will not affect the crystalline - to - amorphous fraction . more importantly
, supernovae are thought to be the dominant source of cosmic rays and this may increase the rate at which crystalline silicates are transformed into amorphous silicates .
however , cosmic rays freshly accelerated in the supernova remnants may leak away to the rest of the galaxy on a timescale of @xmath2610@xmath27 yr @xcite , limiting the rate of this solid - state conversion in the starburst environment .
thus , the crystalline - to - amorphous conversion time - scale may actually be quite similar to the value calculated for the local milky way ( 70 million years ; * ? ? ?
we expect that over time , as the merging event ages and the starburst intensity decreases , the fraction of crystalline silicates will decrease on a similar time - scale .
thus , we attribute the high fraction of crystalline silicates in these ulirgs as compared to others to the relative ` youth ' of these systems ; e.g. , the amorphitization process may lag the merger - triggered , star - formation - driven dust injection process .
all 17 ulirgs with @xmath28(10@xmath0m)@xmath112.9 in our ulirg sample of 77 galaxies show crystalline silicate structure in their irs spectra . at lower silicate optical depth
, the number of clear detections falls sharply . above @xmath28(10@xmath0m)=2 , 18 out of 23
ulirgs definitely show the 16@xmath0 m crystalline feature . above @xmath28(10@xmath0m)=1 ,
this is 20 out of 46 and for the entire ulirg sample only 21 out of 77 .
we note that a complete analysis of this fraction is hampered by possible radiative transfer effects in the silicate features ( as evidenced by the strong variation in the ratio of 10to18@xmath0 m peak optical depths ) , the presence of 1618@xmath0 m uir emission in some sources with non - negligible pah emission @xcite and by the challenge to detect weak 16@xmath0 m absorption features at low contrast and low signal - to - noise .
nevertheless , it is clear that crystalline silicates are a common component of the nuclear interstellar medium during the strongly obscured evolutionary phase of the ulirg phenomena .
crystalline silicates can also be a sign of high - temperature grain processing . in a ulirg , both a central agn and hot , young stars are potential sources of high - energy photons capable of heating the dust in the ism .
x - ray and far uv photons from a central agn will produce a hot , inner region . however , an agn as the source of grain processing in our ulirg sample is problematic for two reasons .
first , interferometric 10@xmath0 m spectra of the seyfert-2 nucleus of ngc1068 do not show any indication for crystalline silicates in its inner warm 2pc region @xcite .
second , the crystalline silicates are seen in absorption in our spectra , implying that they are located in the cooler , outer regions . this would require a large scale mechanism to transport the inner toroid material outwards and distribute it over the surrounding medium . the extended nature of a starburst does not require such a mechanism and therefore seems a more likely source of processed material than a central source .
crystalline silicates are also a characteristic of the circumstellar planetary disks surrounding young stellar objects such as herbig aebe stars and t - tauri stars . again , in order to be seen in absorption , this material will have to be transported outwards into the surrounding cold medium , presumably through jets and winds @xcite
. there is , however , no indication in galactic sources for such large scale transport of crystalline silicates . on the contrary , for herbig
aebe stars the emission features of crystalline silicates are strongly concentrated towards the inner 2au of the disks ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
hence , we deem high - temperature crystallization of existing amorphous silicate grains unlikely as the source of the high crystalline silicate fraction in ulirgs .
in this work , we report the discovery of crystalline substructure at 11 , 16 , 19 , 23 and 28@xmath0 m in the amorphous silicate features towards twelve deeply obscured ulirg nuclei .
these features indicate the presence of the mineral forsterite ( mg@xmath1sio@xmath2 ) .
previously , crystalline silicates have only been observed in circumstellar environments .
we infer the fraction of crystalline silicates in our sample from the peak optical depths of the 10@xmath0 m amorphous and the 16@xmath0 m crystalline bands and find a crystalline - to - amorphous ratio ranging from 0.07 to 0.15 , with a median value of 0.11 .
these numbers are likely upper limits , since foreground emission and radiative transfer effects will cause the apparent 10@xmath0 m silicate optical depth to be a lower limit to the true optical depth .
the crystalline - to - amorphous ratio in our twelve deeply obscured ulirgs is 715 times larger than the upper limit for this ratio in the interstellar medium of the milky way .
this suggest that the timescale for injection of crystalline silicates into the ism is short in a merger - driven starburst environment ( eg .
, as compared to the total time to dissipate the gas ) , pointing towards evolved massive stars ( red supergiants , lbvs and type ii supernovae ) as prominent sources of crystalline silicates .
furthermore , the timescale for amorphitization of crystalline silicates , which is known to be fairly rapid in the ism of the milky way ( @xmath2610@xmath29 yr ) , is at most of similar order in starburst environments .
we expect that over time , as the merging event ages and the starburst decreases in intensity , the fraction of crystalline silicates will decrease rapidly .
thus , we attribute the high fraction of crystalline silicates in these ulirgs , as compared to others , to the relative ` youth ' of these systems .
finally , other galaxy types may also exhibit crystalline silicate features far above the upper limits set for the crystalline silicate fraction in the ism of our galaxy ( @xmath31% ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the possible detection of a 23@xmath0 m crystalline emission feature in the quasar pg1351 + 640 , reported by @xcite , may be a signpost of more detections to come .
the authors wish to thank elise furlan , bill forrest , patrick morris , els peeters for discussions , and frank molster and sacha hony for sharing their iso sws data .
support for this work was provided by nasa through contract number 1257184 issued by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology under nasa contract 1407 .
hwws was supported under this contract through the spitzer space telescope fellowship program . | silicates are an important component of interstellar dust and the structure of these grains amorphous versus crystalline is sensitive to the local physical conditions .
we have studied the infrared spectra of a sample of ultra - luminous infrared galaxies . here , we report the discovery of weak , narrow absorption features at 11 , 16 , 19 , 23 , and 28@xmath0 m , characteristic of crystalline silicates , superimposed on the broad absorption bands at 10 and 18@xmath0 m due to amorphous silicates in a subset of this sample .
these features betray the presence of forsterite ( mg@xmath1sio@xmath2 ) , the magnesium - rich end member of the olivines .
previously , crystalline silicates have only been observed in circumstellar environments .
the derived fraction of forsterite to amorphous silicates is typically 0.1 in these ulirgs .
this is much larger than the upper limit for this ratio in the interstellar medium of the milky way , 0.01 .
these results suggest that the timescale for injection of crystalline silicates into the ism is short in a merger - driven starburst environment ( e.g. , as compared to the total time to dissipate the gas ) , pointing towards massive stars as a prominent source of crystalline silicates .
furthermore , amorphization due to cosmic rays , which is thought to be of prime importance for the local ism , lags in vigorous starburst environments . |
there is growing interest in type ib / c supernovae ( sne ) following the discovery of a subclass that display very broad - lined spectra , indicating the existence of ejecta expanding with velocity @xmath9 .
models of the optical spectra and the light curves ( lcs ) of this high - velocity subclass , also called hypernovae ( hne , e.g. , @xcite ) , have concluded that these are the explosions of massive c+o stars , producing up to 10 times the kinetic energy of normal core - collapse sne ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
it is unclear why some hne are apparently associated with grbs , i.e. , sn 1998bw and grb 980425 , @xcite , sn 2003dh and grb 030329 @xcite , and sn 2003lw and grb 031203 @xcite , while others are not .
the type ic sn 2002ap , discovered in m74 @xcite , is one of the nearest sne in recent years .
its host galaxy has a distance modulus of only @xmath10 ( @xcite ; see also @xcite for the latest review ) .
@xcite measured the total extinction toward the sn with a high - resolution spectrum and concluded that @xmath11 .
we adopt these values in this paper .
early - time optical spectroscopy and photometry was published by @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and others .
most authors emphasized the spectral similarity to the broad - lined sn 1998bw and sn 1997ef .
the early - time light curve ( lc ) , was much broader than that of the normal type ic sn 1994i , but was significantly fainter than that of sn 1998bw and peaked earlier .
@xcite ( hereafter paper i ) presented early - time near - infrared ( nir ) and optical photometry , obtained with the magnum telescope . using the @xmath12 photometry
, they built a well - sampled @xmath1 bolometric lc for sn 2002ap .
nir photometry has also been reported by @xcite and @xcite .
@xcite described the evolution of nir spectra , which were dominated by lines of intermediate - mass elements ( see also @xcite ) .
@xcite modelled the early - time optical spectra and bolometric lc using 1-d codes .
they concluded that sn 2002ap was the energetic explosion of a c+o star , having evolved from a star of 20 - 25 @xmath2 on the main sequence , and that it ejected @xmath5 2.5 @xmath2 material with a kinetic energy of @xmath5 @xmath13 ergs , including @xmath5 0.07 @xmath2 @xmath14ni .
this places sn 2002ap at the low - mass low - energy end of hypernovae .
they also constrained the explosion date to mjd 52300.0 @xmath15 0.5 days .
we use the explosion date as the reference point for any sn epoch in this paper . based on observed limits in pre - discovery images
, @xcite argued that the progenitor was either a single w - r star of main - sequence mass @xmath16 or more likely part of an interacting binary .
sn 2002ap was also monitored in the radio @xcite , x - rays @xcite , and uv @xcite .
@xcite estimated quite a small energy in any relativistic material from the faintness of the radio .
they addressed the material with velocities larger than the shock velocity ( @xmath17 ) .
therefore , their results do not contradict the high energy obtained in the 1-d model for the bulk sn ejecta by @xcite , whose ejecta velocity distribution has a cut - off at 70,000 km s@xmath18 . as a possible confirmation of this result , the shock velocity derived by @xcite from models of the radio and x - ray observations was also @xmath5 70,000 km s@xmath18 .
sn 2002ap was not apparently associated with a grb @xcite .
however , @xcite discovered a polarized spectrum component that resembled the total flux spectrum but redshifted by @xmath19 ( see also @xcite ) .
they proposed that this component is due to scattering from jet material .
@xcite further suggested that the jet may be too baryon - contaminated to trigger a grb and that it was expanding almost freely and hence was radio quiet .
@xcite reproduced a bump in the lc of the xrf 030723 afterglow with a sn 2002ap - like lc .
sn 2002ap was monitored into the late nebular phase . @xcite
published optical photometry covering from 2002 june to december and spectroscopy continuing to 2003 february .
the spectra show unusually strong and sharp - peaked [ ] and ] emission lines ( see also @xcite ) .
late - time spectroscopy was also obtained by other observers ( y. qiu ; k. kawabata ; s. b. pandey ; private communications ) , and late - time photometry by @xcite and @xcite .
it is also important to have intensive late - time nir observations of type ib / c sne .
as demonstrated in the case of sn 1998bw @xcite , the nir contribution to the total flux is quite large , in particular at late times .
late - time nir observations may also reveal molecule and dust formation , if any exists ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
however , few type ib / c sne have been observed at late phases in the nir . for sn 2002ap ,
the only late - time nir observation published so far is a spectrum taken in 2002 august @xcite . in this paper
, we report on @xmath0 imaging photometry obtained for sn 2002ap between 2002 june 12 and 2003 august 29 , completing the 1.5 years follow - up project with the magnum telescope ( see also paper i ) . we describe the observations and data reduction and
present our multicolor lcs in 2 .
an @xmath1 bolometric lc is then constructed using the photometry . in 3 , we discuss the bolometric lc , analyze the evolution of the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) , compare the late - time nir lcs with those of other type ib / c sne , and present 1-d models for the bolometric lc .
optical ( johnson - cousins @xmath20 ) and nir ( @xmath21 ) imaging photometry of sn 2002ap ( @xmath22 , @xmath23 ) was carried out using the magnum 2 m telescope at the summit of haleakala on the island of maui , hawaii @xcite .
the multicolor imaging photometer mounted at the bent - cassegrain focus has an site @xmath24 pixel ccd with a scale of @xmath25pixel@xmath18 , for which the light is effectively received in a field of view of @xmath26 pixel ccd or @xmath27 , and also has an sbrc @xmath28 pixel insb with a scale of @xmath29pixel@xmath18 yielding a field of view of @xmath30 .
a dichroic beam splitter enables simultaneous imaging through optical ( @xmath31 ) and nir ( @xmath32 ) filters @xcite .
the observations were scheduled by the magnum scheduler @xcite , except for the solar conjunction from march to june in 2003 .
telescope dithering was performed with 6 or 10-arcsec steps primary for @xmath21 .
the typical exposure time for one step was 190 sec for @xmath33 , 95 sec for @xmath34 , 65 sec for each of @xmath35 , 60 sec for @xmath36 and 30 sec for each of @xmath37 .
as sn 2002ap faded , the number of dithering steps was increased from 6 to 12 .
the typical seeing size of the stellar image was 1.0 - 1.6 arcsec in @xmath34 and 0.85 - 1.4 arcsec in @xmath38 .
dome - flat images for @xmath0 and nir dark images were obtained at the end of each night .
image reduction was performed using our package of iraf - based automated reduction software ( magred ) , which includes the standard corrections for bias and flat field frames . for more details
see paper i. two reference stars , a and b , were observed in the same frame of sn 2002ap for differential photometry .
one reference star ( a , @xmath39 , @xmath40 ) was used for @xmath20 as in paper i. the other reference star ( b , @xmath41 , @xmath42 ) was used for @xmath21 . in order to calibrate the magnitude of star b , nir standard stars @xcite were also observed , whenever possible , either before or after the observation of sn 2002ap .
the median magnitudes and the number of calibrations for star b in the insb frame are @xmath43 , @xmath44 , and @xmath45 .
a variability check was made for stars a and b by increasing the total exposure time in proportion as sn 2002ap faded .
figure 1 shows the difference between their @xmath20 magnitudes after 2003 july , when the optical flux of star b became detectable .
( it was not possible to make the same plot in the nir because star a was usually outside or on the edge of the insb detector . )
the error bars estimated from photon statistics are in good agreement with the dispersion of the data points , so that it is not necessary to regard stars a and b as variable .
simple aperture photometry was used throughout , and the aperture magnitude of sn 2002ap was obtained as the magnitude difference between sn 2002ap and star a or b. an aperture size of 6.9 arcsec was adopted for all images , which minimizes the dispersion of the differential photometry .
however , special care was taken for reliable magnitude determination of sn 2002ap , given the presence of a faint background object within a distance of about 1 arcsec .
this object became distinguishable from sn 2002ap , when sn 2002ap became sufficiently faint after solar conjunction in 2003 . in 2003
december , sn 2002ap faded compared to the background object , and it was easy to resolve sn 2002ap and the object separately .
then , using the iraf daophot package , the psf magnitude of the object was measured several times when the seeing was relatively good .
this way , the psf magnitude of the object was determined as @xmath46 , @xmath47 , @xmath48 , @xmath49 , @xmath50 , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 .
these fluxes were subtracted from each aperture photometry of sn 2002ap .
moreover , reference star b in nir photometry has a faint nearby star which is about 4 mag fainter .
photometry was performed on the images where this faint nearby star was subtracted using iraf daophot package .
the @xmath0 data taken over 42 nights from june 12 , 2002 to aug 29 , 2003 are tabulated in table 1 .
the uncertainty in each magnitude was derived combining in quadrature the magnitude dispersion from the frames obtained during the same night and the magnitude error of reference star a for @xmath20 , or b for @xmath21 .
a small error of 0.01 mag was added in quadrature for the @xmath20 magnitudes , taking into account the non - linearity correction error between sn 2002ap and reference star a. another 0.01mag error caused by the seeing effect , arising from the profile difference between sn 2002ap and the reference star a , was also added .
the absolute calibration error and the subtracted flux uncertainty of the background object were taken into account when evaluating the total photometry error .
no color - term correction was applied to the magnitudes of sn 2002ap in the nebular phase , because strong line emissions and large color difference with respect to the main sequence star make this correction particularly difficult , as demonstrated by @xcite .
we show the magnum @xmath12 lcs in figure 2 ( _ filled circles _ ) , combining the late - time data in table 1 and the early - time data of paper i. for comparison , we also show the @xmath31 photometry of @xcite ( @xmath53 days ; _ crosses _ ) , that of @xcite ( @xmath54 days ; _ open circles _ ) , and the early - time @xmath21 photometry of @xcite ( @xmath55 days ; _ open circles _ ) .
obviously , our lcs have the largest time span .
they are unique also in that both the early and late phase were well covered in nir , the first time for any sn ib / c .
to guide the eye , we made b - spline fits ( _ solid lines _ ) to the data , excluding the pandey and foley late - time ones .
it is clear from the figure that the decline of the late - time lc slowed down after september 2002 in several bands .
we derived the decline rates and the date when the decline rate changed in each band by @xmath56-fitting the late - time magnum data using a broken line ( see table 2 ) . before the change , which took place between about day 210 and 250 , the decline rate was similar in all bands , i.e. , about @xmath57 mag / day .
the change is most profound in the nir , as the @xmath36 and @xmath4 lcs flattened from 0.018 mag / day to 0.012 and 0.008 mag / day , respectively .
it is small for most optical bands , although the @xmath34 lc did flatten from 0.021 to 0.014 mag / day . as a result ,
the nir contribution to the total flux increased significantly going to very late times .
this will be discussed further in the next section .
most of our late - time data agree well with the @xcite ones , although their @xmath33 magnitudes are 0.1 - 0.2 mag brighter than ours after day 280 and their @xmath58 magnitudes 0.1 - 0.25 mag brighter after day 160 .
the @xcite late - time data are 0.1 - 0.15 mag brighter than ours in the @xmath33 band , 0.2 - 0.4 mag brighter in the @xmath34 band , and 0.1 - 0.2 mag fainter in the @xmath58 band .
those differences can be partly explained by measurement uncertainties inherent to practical broadband photometry of sne ( e.g. , see @xcite ) , since these objects have time - evolving and line - dominated spectra of non - stellar nature .
our late - time @xmath20 lcs can differ from the those of @xcite and @xcite by as much as 0.3 mag . however , their data were less well sampled than ours .
the late - time evolution of the optical colors , @xmath59 , @xmath60 , and @xmath61 , is very different between sn 2002ap and sn 1998bw , as shown in figure 3 . in particular ,
@xmath60 of sn 2002ap between day 140 and 330 is about 0.3 - 0.6 mag larger and @xmath59 between day 200 and 340 about 0.3 mag smaller than in sn 1998bw .
this can be easily understood within the context of spectroscopy . in the nebular phase ,
the spectra of both sne were dominated by [ ] @xmath626300,6364 in the @xmath63 band , [ ] multiplets in the @xmath34 and @xmath33 bands , and ] @xmath644571 in the @xmath33 band , while ] @xmath627291,7324 may also contribute to the @xmath63 and @xmath58 photometry and the nir triplet to the @xmath58 photometry depending on the actual filter cut - off . as discussed by @xcite ,
sn 2002ap has the strongest [ ] @xmath626300,6364 and ] @xmath644571 nebular emissions of any sn published .
however , its [ ] multiplets are much weaker than in sn 1998bw , a consequence of much less @xmath14ni ejected by sn 2002ap . between day 390 and 520 , @xmath60 and @xmath61 dropped and @xmath59 rose rapidly .
this may indicate a flux shift from emissions of intermediate - mass elements to [ ] multiplets .
unfortunately , no observed spectra have so far been obtained for type ib / c sne at such late times .
we built the @xmath1 bolometric lc integrating the @xmath0 broadband flux ( see paper i for details ) .
a reddening of @xmath65 was corrected for @xcite , and a distance modulus of 29.5 was adopted ( but see @xcite ) .
the lc is shown in figure 4 , extending that in paper i to @xmath66 days since explosion .
it consists of three independent data sets , which agree with one another .
most of the data ( _ filled circles _ ) , tabulated in table 3 ( _ late time _ ) and paper i ( _ early time _ ) , were made from the magnum photometry .
we interpolated and extrapolated the observations to estimate the the @xmath38 magnitudes between day 280 and 340 and the @xmath36 and @xmath58 magnitudes at day 520 . for epochs
@xmath67 days , the observations of @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite were used for interpolation .
bolometric magnitudes at day 407 and 578 ( _ triangles _ ) were converted from @xmath4 magnitudes using approximate bolometric corrections .
the other two data sets were based on the @xcite ( _ open circles _ ) and @xcite ( _ crosses _ ) optical photometry , respectively , which was combined with the @xcite and our @xmath21 photometry .
the bolometric lc at late time has a shape similar to that of sn 1998bw ( figure 4 ; _ squares _ ) , another hypernova , although the latter was much brighter .
the sn 1998bw lc in figure 4 is shifted down by 1.75 mag to match the peak magnitude of sn 2002ap .
both lcs show a similar late - time slowing - down . for sn 2002ap ,
the decline rate changed from @xmath68 mag / day between day 130 and 230 to @xmath69 mag / day between day 270 and 580 .
for sn 1998bw , the decline rate was @xmath70 mag / day between day 70 and 220 and @xmath69 mag / day between day 320 and 540 .
for comparison , the late - time bolometric lc of another hypernova , sn 1997ef , followed the decay rate of @xmath14co , i.e. , @xmath71 mag / day @xcite . on the other hand , sn 2002ap reached its light maximum @xmath72 days earlier than sn 1998bw did , although their peak widths are actually comparable ( figure 4 ; _ inset _ ) .
we show the sed of sn 2002ap at 5 typical late epochs in figure 5 , where the monochromatic fluxes converted from the magnum @xmath0 photometry are connected using spline - fitting curves .
the observed upper limits of the @xmath38-band flux at day 393 and 520 are marked by _
arrows_. zero flux was assumed at both the the blue edge of the @xmath33 band and the red edge of the @xmath38 band .
we used such seds to obtain the @xmath1 bolometric magnitudes .
the seds are dominated by the flux in the @xmath63 and @xmath58 bands before about day 340 - 390 , which was mainly due to strong [ ] , ] , and emissions @xcite .
the @xmath33 bump at the three intermediate epochs reflects the contribution of ] @xmath644571 .
after about day 340 - 390 , the @xmath34 flux , attributed to [ ] multiplets , increased relative to that in other optical bands , while the @xmath58-band - dominated emissions died away .
the nir flux contribution rose rapidly after @xmath5 day 300 ( figure 6 ) .
this can been seen in figure 5 as a big @xmath4 bump in the sed and also in figure 2 as a significant flattening of the @xmath4 and @xmath36 lcs .
to explain this , we examined the synthesized nir spectra of the models that reproduce the late - time optical spectra of sn 2002ap ( p. a. mazzali et al .
2005 , in preparation ) .
the most likely candidates are the strong [ ] 1.646 @xmath6 m and 1.608 @xmath6 m lines , while the 1.099 @xmath6 m line may account for the concurrent @xmath36-band flux increase .
the lines were already developed in the day @xmath5 200 nir spectrum of @xcite , although they were still not as strong as a 1.5 @xmath6 m feature , possibly emission .
we note in passing that the appearance of the co first - overtone band in that spectrum suggested by those authors seems to coincide with the @xmath38-band lc steepening seen in figure 2 .
the late - time @xmath4-band spectra of sn 1983n , taken by @xcite and of very low resolution , showed a strong 1.65 @xmath6 m feature , which was explained by those authors as [ ] lines but was soon , together with an adjacent feature , re - identified as [ ] lines by @xcite .
these [ ] nir features can also be found in the synthetic late - time spectra of type ib sne computed by @xcite . in figure 7
we compare the late - time @xmath21 lcs of sn 2002ap with those of other type ib / c sne ( see table 4 ) .
sn 1998bw and sn 1984l were 1.52.5 mag brighter than all other sne , indicating a large mass of @xmath14ni ejected .
the nir lcs of sn 1984l were relatively slow , as was its late - time optical lc which was modelled using very massive ejecta but with normal kinetic energy @xcite .
the few points of sn 1998bw , when shifted down by 1.8 mag ( @xmath36 ) , 1.5 mag ( @xmath4 ) , and 1.7 mag ( @xmath38 ) , respectively , fall on the lcs of sn 2002ap .
the lcs of sn 1983n have later and broader peaks than those of sn 2002ap , but they become similar between in the @xmath36-band and @xmath4-band day @xmath5 200 and 350 . on the other hand , the @xmath21 data of sn 1983i and 1982r seem to bridge the lc gap in sn 2002ap data between day 50 and day 140 ( solar conjunction ) .
figure 7 contradicts the picture that sne 1983i , 1983n , and 1984l have similar @xmath21 lcs @xcite .
type ib / c sne were first established as a new class by those authors , who showed that these sne have similar @xmath21 lcs which are different from those of type ia sne [ and also by @xcite through an analysis of the optical spectra ] .
they artificially shifted the data of sn 1983i and sn 1984l in both phase and brightness in order to match the nir lcs of sn 1983n .
their sn 1983i data were assigned epochs 20 days later than ours , and sn 1984l 14 days earlier .
our epoch estimates are more reasonable because we based them on optical lcs and spectra which are better observed and understood than the nir data .
inspecting by eye the only published spectrum of sn 1983i @xcite , we noticed that it resembles those of sn 2002ap between 2002 february 16 and 22 @xcite .
the similarity can be seen not only in the overall shape and strongest line features , but also in relatively weak ones , like those near @xmath73 , @xmath74 , and @xmath75 .
the spectrum was taken on 1983 may 17 , 5 days after discovery .
we estimate the epoch of that spectrum as @xmath76 days since explosion , through this comparison , and hence derive an explosion date of 1983 april 25 .
the lcs of sn 1983i seem to match those of sn 2002ap not only in the nir ( figure 7 ) but also in the optical ( figure 8) , if our estimates of the explosion date and the distance modulus are correct .
we adopt 31.0 as the distance modulus to the host galaxy of sn 1983i , ngc 4051 in the ursa major cluster @xcite .
this value is also close to the average of the distance modulus of the ursa major cluster ( 31.4 , @xcite ) , and that corresponding to its radial velocity corrected for the local group infall onto virgo ( 30.5 , leda ; @xcite ) the late - time bolometric lc of sn 2002ap declines more slowly than that of the 1-dimensional ( 1-d ) model of @xcite that best reproduced the early - time spectra and lc ( see figure 9 ; _ dotted line _ ) .
this is expected , since the lc follows that of sn 1998bw closely in terms of the decline rate , as shown in figure 4 .
the best - fitting 1-d model for the early - time spectra and lc of sn 1998bw also fails to explain its late - time spectrum and lc @xcite . to mimic the outcome of 2-dimensional jet - induced explosion calculations @xcite , which applies to sn 1998bw and
may also apply to sn 2002ap , @xcite introduced a dense core . that core absorbs @xmath77-rays efficiently at late time . using this structure ,
the slow lc decline of hypernovae was reproduced by those authors using a monte - carlo radiative transfer code but with simplified physics .
we tested the dense - core scenario on sn 2002ap using our sophisticated 1-d sn radiation hydrodynamical and @xmath77-ray transfer code @xcite .
the best - fitting model ( _ solid line _ ) has @xmath78 ejecta below 3,000 km s@xmath18 , compared with 0.1 @xmath2 in the model without a dense core , and @xmath79 low - velocity @xmath14ni . compared with @xcite , who modelled only the early - time observations , the total ejecta mass has increased from 2.5 @xmath2 to 3 @xmath2 , but with little change in the total @xmath14ni mass ( 0.08 @xmath2 ) and the kinetic energy ( @xmath80 ergs ) .
a dense ejecta core is also required in 1-d late - time spectrum models ( p. a. mazzali et al .
2006 , in preparation ) in order to explain the observed sharp line cores of [ ] and ] @xcite .
a dense core can not be formed in 1-d explosion simulations for hypernovae @xcite , but it is a natural product of 2-d jet - induced explosions @xcite .
this strongly indicates asymmetry in the sn 2002ap explosion , an intrinsic feature also shared by other hypernovae .
evidence of asymmetry in sn 2002ap can also be found in spectropolarimetry @xcite , which shows an intrinsic continuum polarization varying around 0.5% , corresponding to an asphericity of @xmath5 10% for the bulk of the ejecta .
we thank s. b. pandey , e. nishihara , and r. j. foley for the electronic files of their photometric data .
this work has been supported in part by the grant - in - aid for scientific research ( 16540229 , 17030005 , & 17033002 for kn ) and the 21st century coe program ( quest ) from the jsps and mext in japan , and by the national science foundation under grant no .
phy99 - 07949 .
gerardy , c. l. , fesen , r. a. , marion , g. h. , hflich , p. , wheeler , j. c. , nomoto , k. , & motohara , k. 2004 , in cosmic explosions in three dimensions , ed .
p. hflich , p. kumer , & j. c. wheeler ( cambridge : cambridge univ . press ) , 57 llcccccccc jun 12.61 & 52437.61 & & 16.15@xmath81 & & & & & 14.98@xmath82 & clear jun 13.60 & 52438.60 & 16.75@xmath83 & & & & & 14.93@xmath84 & & clear jun 14.60 & 52439.60 & & & 15.43@xmath85 & & 15.75@xmath83 & & & clear jun 16.60 & 52441.60 & & & & 15.10@xmath85 & & & & clear jun 18.60 & 52443.60 & & & & 15.14@xmath85 & & 15.01@xmath84 & & clear jul 3.56 & 52458.56 & 17.07@xmath84 & & 15.70@xmath85 & & 16.17@xmath82 & & 15.49@xmath86 & thin cloud jul 5.60 & 52460.60 & & & 15.72@xmath85 & & & & & thin cloud jul 6.55 & 52461.55 & & & 15.74@xmath85 & & & & 15.53@xmath87 & cloudy jul 19.56 & 52474.56 & & & 15.94@xmath85 & & & & & clear jul 22.56 & 52477.56 & & & 15.98@xmath85 & & & & & clear jul 23.51 & 52478.51 & 17.42@xmath83 & 17.00@xmath85 & 16.01@xmath85 & 15.75@xmath85 & 16.51@xmath83 & 15.74@xmath86 & 15.84@xmath86 & clear aug 7.47 & 52493.47 & 17.71@xmath82 & 17.36@xmath85 & 16.28@xmath85 & 16.04@xmath85 & 16.81@xmath82 & 16.00@xmath88 & 16.03@xmath89 & thin cloud aug 11.59 & 52497.59 & & & 16.34@xmath85 & & 16.80@xmath82 & & & thin cloud aug 17.61 & 52503.61 & & 17.59@xmath85 & & & & 16.14@xmath86 & & thin cloud aug 18.44 & 52504.44 & & & 16.45@xmath85 & 16.24@xmath85 & 17.05@xmath82 & & & clear aug 22.54 & 52508.54 & & 17.64@xmath83 & 16.51@xmath85 & 16.29@xmath85 & 16.87@xmath82 & 16.22@xmath88 & & cloudy sep 2.44 & 52519.44 & 18.16@xmath84 & 17.89@xmath85 & & & & 16.36@xmath88 & 16.74@xmath87 & clear sep 3.61 & 52520.61 & & 17.90@xmath85 & & & & 16.43@xmath88 & & thin cloud sep 5.59 & 52522.59 & & & 16.73@xmath85 & 16.54@xmath85 & 17.22@xmath82 & & & thin cloud sep 7.61 & 52524.61 & & 18.02@xmath85 & & & & 16.56@xmath88 & & cloudy sep 8.41 & 52525.41 & 18.25@xmath84 & & 16.77@xmath85 & & 17.41@xmath88 & & 16.98@xmath90 & cloudy sep 16.54 & 52533.54 & 18.41@xmath84 & 18.15@xmath85 & 16.91@xmath85 & 16.73@xmath85 & 17.42@xmath82 & 16.57@xmath86 & 17.07@xmath91 & clear oct 27.52 & 52574.52 & 19.12@xmath91 & 18.86@xmath83 & 17.59@xmath83 & 17.41@xmath83 & 17.93@xmath88 & 17.08@xmath87 & 18.24@xmath92 & clear oct 30.45 & 52577.45 & 19.11@xmath89 & 18.92@xmath82 & 17.61@xmath85 & 17.46@xmath82 & 17.88@xmath86 & 17.09@xmath87 & 17.96@xmath93 & thin cloud nov 23.22 & 52601.22 & 19.49@xmath90 & 19.31@xmath84 & 17.99@xmath83 & 17.94@xmath82 & & 17.21@xmath88 & & clear dec 1.39 & 52609.39 & 19.67@xmath94 & 19.40@xmath84 & 18.12@xmath83 & 18.06@xmath82 & & 17.29@xmath88 & & clear dec 9.35 & 52617.35 & 19.75@xmath94 & 19.58@xmath86 & 18.26@xmath83 & 18.19@xmath82 & & 17.32@xmath88 & & clear dec 18.37 & 52626.37 & 19.91@xmath93 & 19.66@xmath89 & 18.38@xmath82 & 18.34@xmath84 & 18.55@xmath87 & & & clear dec 30.37 & 52638.37 & 20.03@xmath95 & 19.85@xmath87 & 18.62@xmath83 & 18.47@xmath86 & & 17.38@xmath87 & & clear feb 11.22 & 52681.22 & & & & & & & @xmath96 19.7 & clear feb 23.22 & 52693.22 & 20.99@xmath97 & & & & & & & clear feb 24.23 & 52694.23 & & 20.49@xmath98 & & & & & & clear feb 25.23 & 52695.23 & & & 19.60@xmath86 & & & & & clear feb 26.23 & 52696.23 & & & & 19.50@xmath99 & & & & clear mar 11.21 & 52709.21 & & & & & & 17.89@xmath90 & & clear mar 12.22 & 52710.22 & & & & & 19.16@xmath100 & & & clear jun 27.62 & 52817.62 & & & 21.26@xmath100 & & & & & clear jul 3.60 & 52823.60 & 22.80@xmath101 & & & & & & & clear jul 5.60 & 52825.60 & & 21.75@xmath102 & & & & 18.80@xmath103 & & clear aug 15.49 & 52866.49 & & & & @xmath96 21.5 & & & & thin cloud aug 28.50 & 52879.50 & & & & & @xmath96 21.2 & 19.83@xmath104 & & clear aug 29.50 & 52880.50 & & & & & & & @xmath96 19.9 & clear lccc 52438.5 & 136.5 & [email protected] & 23% 52458.5 & 156.5 & [email protected] & 22% 52478.5 & 176.5 & [email protected] & 22% 52493.5 & 191.5 & [email protected] & 22% 52504.0 & 202.0 & [email protected] & 21% 52508.5 & 206.5 & [email protected] & 23% 52521.0 & 219.0 & [email protected] & 21% 52525.0 & 223.0 & [email protected] & 21% 52533.5 & 231.5 & [email protected] & 22% 52574.5 & 272.5 & [email protected] & 23% 52577.5 & 275.5 & [email protected] & 24% 52601.0 & 299.0 & [email protected] & 25% 52609.5 & 307.5 & [email protected] & 26% 52617.5 & 315.5 & [email protected] & 26% 52626.5 & 324.5 & [email protected] & 29% 52638.5 & 336.5 & [email protected] & 29% 52695.0 & 393.0 & -9.47@xmath116 & 39% 52709.0 & 407.0 & -9.3@xmath15 0.2 & 52822.0 & 520.0 & -8.06@xmath117 & 54% 52879.5 & 577.5 & -6.8@xmath15 0.5 & cccccc spectroscopic type & ib / c & ic & ib & ib & ic , hypernova distance modulus & 31.2 & 31.0 & 28.25 & 31.5 & 32.76 extinction @xmath118 & 0.5 & 0.04 & 0.2 & 0.09 & [email protected] explosion date ( ut ) & 1982 september 28 & 1983 april 25 & 1983 july 1 & 1984 august 5 & 1998 april 25.9 | late - time @xmath0 photometry of the peculiar type ic sn 2002ap , taken between 2002 june 12 and 2003 august 29 with the magnum telescope , is presented .
the light curve decline rate is derived in each band and the color evolution is studied through comparison with nebular spectra and with sn 1998bw . using the photometry , the @xmath1 bolometric light curve is built , extending from before light maximum to day 580 after explosion .
the light curve has a late - time shape strikingly similar to that of the hypernova sn 1998bw .
the decline rate changes from 0.018 mag / day between day 130 and 230 to 0.014 mag / day between day 270 and 580 . to reproduce the late - time light curve
, a dense core must be added to the 1-d hypernova model that best fits the early - time observations , bringing the ejecta mass from 2.5 @xmath2 to 3 @xmath2 without much change in the kinetic energy , which is @xmath3 ergs .
this is similar to the case of other hypernovae and suggests asymmetry . a large @xmath4-band bump developed in the spectral energy distribution after @xmath5 day 300 , probably caused by strong [ si i ] 1.646@xmath6 m and 1.608@xmath6 m emissions .
the near - infrared flux contribution increased simultaneously from @xmath7 to @xmath8 at day 580 .
the near - infrared light curves were compared with those of other type ib / c supernovae , among which sn 1983i seems similar to sn 2002ap both in the near - infrared and in the optical . |
recent progress in cosmology is largely stimulated by precise measurements of the universe .
the redshift survey of galaxies is one of the most important methods in distinguishing cosmological models .
the baryon acoustic oscillations ( baos ) in the early universe @xcite , which were first detected in the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) anisotropy power spectrum @xcite , were also detected in the large - scale structure probed by redshift surveys @xcite .
the expansion history and curvature of the universe can be geometrically measured by galaxy clustering in redshift space @xcite , and the bao signature in the large - scale structure yields a standard ruler @xcite for this purpose .
therefore , accurately measuring the bao scales in a statistical quantity such as the power spectrum or correlation function of galaxies , one can constrain the structure of the universe , such as the nature of dark energy @xcite . to utilize the baos as a standard ruler in the universe ,
a theoretically precise description of the baos is of the utmost importance .
the physics of the baos at sufficiently large redshift is well described by linear theory .
only the amplitude of the spatial pattern of clustering is increased , and the characteristic scale of the baos is unaltered in this regime
. however , the nonlinear dynamics play an important role in a redshift range where we can measure the large - scale structure . even though the bao scales @xmath0 are large , the nonlinearity deforms the bao pattern in the power spectrum and correlation function @xcite .
nonlinear deformations of the power spectrum are described by the standard perturbation theory ( spt ) @xcite of higher orders as long as the density fluctuations on bao scales are still in the linear regime at sufficiently large redshift @xcite .
the last condition is not necessarily satisfied by realistic surveys .
moreover , when the cold dark matter ( cdm ) is present , the higher - order spt does not give any sensible prediction for the correlation function because unphysical behavior in small wavelength limit prevents fourier transform from converging .
recently , several other approaches beyond the framework of spt have been proposed @xcite . among others ,
scoccimarro s reformulation of fluid equations using the propagator , the vertex , and a source @xcite provides a way to use standard tools of field theory , yielding the renormalized perturbation theory ( rpt ) @xcite , the large-@xmath1 expansions @xcite , the renormalization group approach @xcite , and the closure theory @xcite in the context of gravitational instability theory . in these newly developed approaches ,
the standard perturbative expansion is reorganized and partially resummed in various ways .
it is still difficult to exactly calculate the power spectrum by these approaches , and different levels of approximations and ansatz are employed .
the predictions of the power spectrum calculated by the 2-loop rpt and renormalization group method are shown to agree with measurements of the @xmath1-body simulations on bao scales even at low redshift where the 1-loop spt breaks down @xcite .
it is still nontrivial why these approaches work well despite their approximate treatments and use of ansatz .
so far the predictions of the above nonlinear theories , such as spt , rpt , and their variants , have been confined in real space . since the large - scale structure is actually measured in redshift space , it is mandatory to make predictions in redshift space for applying the nonlinear theories to realworld observations .
the redshift - space distortion effects in the linear regime are analytically given by first - order spt ( i.e. , linear theory ) @xcite .
however , investigations of nonlinear redshift - space distortions by higher - order spt are quite limited in literature @xcite , apart from numerical simulations and nonlinear modelings @xcite . in this paper
, we consider resummations of the perturbative expansion by a different approach from rpt and its variants .
instead of relying on scoccimarro s reformulation , we start from a lagrangian picture of density perturbations .
why do we have to add yet another approach even though there are already enough ?
there are a number of reasons .
first , our approach is simpler than other resummation methods . while it is straightforward to calculate the power spectrum in our approach , other resummation techniques are so complicated that approximate treatments and/or ansatz are necessary in deriving the final power spectrum .
second , as a result of that , our analytic expression of the resulting power spectrum is no more complicated than the spt expression , and numerical evaluations are fast performed .
third , and most importantly , our approach is capable of evaluating the nonlinear power spectrum _ in redshift space _
, which is beyond the scope of other resummation methods in literature .
fourth , unlike in spt , the power spectrum in our approach can be fourier transformed to predict the nonlinear effects in the correlation function .
an important ingredient of our approach is the perturbation theory in lagrangian space , which is known as the lagrangian perturbation theory ( lpt ) @xcite .
the first - order lpt corresponds to the classic zeldovich approximation @xcite .
since the observable power spectrum is given in eulerian space , predicting the power spectrum by lpt is not a trivial task .
we define a method of calculating the power spectrum from the lpt , partially expanding the lagrangian variables in eulerian space .
the resulting expression contains an infinite series of spt terms ; that is , the spt terms are automatically resummed in our formulation . the underlying motivation of this formulation is shared with rpt .
readers are recommended to go through an excellent introduction in ref .
@xcite using the zeldovich approximation , which equally applies to our formulation since our formalism and rpt become equivalent in a case of zeldovich approximation . the rest of this paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ sec : resum ] , our basic formalism is described . a brief review of lpt is also included . in sec .
[ sec : realspace ] , analytic results of the power spectrum and correlation function in real space are presented and compared with simulation results in the literature . the corresponding results in redshift space
are derived in sec .
[ sec : redshiftspace ] .
the conclusions are given in sec .
[ sec : concl ] .
in a lagrangian picture , a fundamental variable to represent perturbations is a displacement field @xmath2 , which maps a fluid element from initial lagrangian coordinates @xmath3 to the eulerian coordinates @xmath4 at a time @xmath5 : @xmath6 we will drop the argument @xmath5 in the following for notational simplicity , and readers should keep in mind that the dynamical variables always depend on time . assuming the initial density field is sufficiently uniform
, the eulerian density field @xmath7 satisfies the continuity relation , @xmath8 , where @xmath9 is the mean density in comoving coordinates .
this relation is equivalent to the following equation : @xmath10 - 1 , \label{eq:1 - 2}\ ] ] where @xmath11 is the density contrast . the power spectrum @xmath12 is defined by a relation @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the fourier transform of the density contrast .
the power spectrum in real space depends only on the magnitude of the wave vector , @xmath15 . in redshift space , however , a directional dependence emerges . using eqs .
( [ eq:1 - 2])([eq:1 - 4 ] ) , the power spectrum can be expressed by a displacement field as @xcite @xmath16 } \right\rangle - 1 \right ) , \label{eq:1 - 5}\ ] ] where @xmath17 .
because of the homogeneity , the ensemble average in the integrand of the right - hand side ( rhs ) only depends on the separation @xmath3 . the expression of eq .
( [ eq:1 - 5 ] ) is a general relation between the power spectrum and displacement fields .
we use the cumulant expansion theorem @xcite @xmath18 , \label{eq:1 - 6}\ ] ] in eq .
( [ eq:1 - 5 ] ) , where @xmath19 denotes a cumulant of a random variable @xmath20 @xcite . in the resulting equation
, we have a following quantity : @xmath21 \right\}^n \right\rangle_{\rm c } \nonumber\\ & \quad = [ 1 + ( -1)^n ] \left\langle[\bm{k}\cdot\psi(\bm{0})]^n\right\rangle_{\rm c } \nonumber\\ & \quad + \sum_{j=1}^{n-1 } ( -1)^{n - j } \left(\begin{array}{c}n\\j\end{array}\right ) \left\langle [ \bm{k}\cdot\psi(\bm{q}_1)]^j [ \bm{k}\cdot\psi(\bm{q}_2)]^{n - j } \right\rangle_{\rm c } , \label{eq:1 - 7}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the binomial theorem is applied . in this equation , only @xmath22 cases are survived , because @xmath23 for parity symmetry .
accordingly , we obtain a general expression , @xmath24 \int d^3q\ , e^{-i\bm{k}\cdot\bm{q } } \nonumber\\ & \qquad\quad \times \left\ { \exp\left [ \sum_{n=2}^\infty \frac{k_{i_1}\cdots k_{i_n}}{n ! } b^{(n)}_{i_1 \cdots i_n}(\bm{q } ) \right ] - 1 \right\ } , \label{eq:1 - 8}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where summation over repeated indices is assumed as usual , and @xmath25 are defined . in the rhs of eq .
( [ eq:1 - 9b ] ) , all the @xmath1 indices are symmetrized over . the quantity @xmath26 of eq .
( [ eq:1 - 9a ] ) is given by a cumulant of a displacement vector at a single position .
the quantity @xmath27 of eq .
( [ eq:1 - 9b ] ) is given by cumulants among two displacement vectors which are separated by a lagrangian distance @xmath28 .
correlations among components of separated displacement vectors are expected to be small when the separations are large . when we are interested in clustering on large scales , the magnitude of wave vector @xmath29 is small , and large separations of @xmath28 in eq .
( [ eq:1 - 5 ] ) efficiently contribute to the integral .
therefore , we expect the cumulants of @xmath27 are smaller than the cumulants of @xmath26 on large scales . with the above consideration , we propose to _ expand only the @xmath27 terms in eq .
( [ eq:1 - 8 ] ) as small quantities and keep the @xmath26 terms in the exponent_. if the @xmath26 terms are expanded as well , this equation turns out to give equivalent results of spt , which is formulated in eulerian space , as shown below .
therefore , the exponential prefactor contains infinitely higher - order perturbations in terms of spt .
thus our method provides a way to resum the infinite series of perturbations in the spt .
this point is our first key technique of this paper .
the second technique is to evaluate the cumulants of the displacement field by the lpt , which is addressed in the following . before that
, it is convenient to represent the cumulants of the displacement field in fourier space . to evaluate eq .
( [ eq:1 - 8 ] ) , it is useful to define the polyspectra @xmath30 of the displacement field by @xmath31 where @xmath32 is the fourier transform of the displacement field .
the relation @xmath33 is always satisfied because of the translational invariance . for @xmath34 ,
we employ a notation , @xmath35 , for simplicity .
the factors @xmath36 in the rhs of eq .
( [ eq:1 - 10 ] ) are there to ensure that the polyspectra @xmath37 are real numbers .
in fact , one easily finds the complex conjugate satisfies @xmath38 which is an equivalent condition that the polyspectra are real numbers , @xmath39 .
it is also important to note the polyspectra of the displacement field satisfy a parity relation , @xmath40 which is explicitly shown by eqs .
( [ eq:1 - 10 ] ) and ( [ eq:1 - 11 ] ) . using the polyspectra defined above , eqs .
( [ eq:1 - 9a ] ) and ( [ eq:1 - 9b ] ) reduce to @xmath41 for a newtonian pressureless self - gravitating fluid embedded in an expanding universe , the displacement field is governed by the equation of motion , @xmath42 , \label{eq:1 - 16}\ ] ] where @xmath43 is the time - dependent hubble parameter , and @xmath44 is a derivative with respect to the eulerian coordinate , @xmath45 .
the gravitational potential @xmath46 is determined by the poisson equation , @xmath47 where the density contrast is related to the displacement field by eq .
( [ eq:1 - 2 ] ) or , equivalently , @xmath48
\right\}^{-1 } -1 .
\label{eq:1 - 18}\ ] ] we use the lpt @xcite to evaluate the polyspectra of the displacement field . in lpt , the displacement field is expanded by a perturbative series : @xmath49 where @xmath50 has the order of @xmath51 , which is considered a small quantity ( properly speaking , dimensionless quantity @xmath52 is considered to be small ) .
it is quite common in the lpt that the velocity field is assumed to be irrotational , @xmath53 this condition is compatible with the dynamical eq .
( [ eq:1 - 16 ] ) and restricts one to considering a subclass of general solutions .
the main motivation of this restriction is that the vortical motions linearly decay in eulerian perturbation theory @xcite and thus are negligible in the quasilinear regime .
we assume this condition throughout this paper . the longitudinal part of eq .
( [ eq:1 - 16 ] ) is an independent equation to be solved perturbatively in lpt ; the same is true for eqs .
( [ eq:1 - 17 ] ) , ( [ eq:1 - 18 ] ) , and ( [ eq:1 - 20 ] ) .
each perturbative term of the displacement field in fourier space is generally represented as @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the linear density contrast at the present time @xmath56 , @xmath57 is a linear growth rate normalized by @xmath58 .
the imaginary unit is there to ensure that the perturbative kernels @xmath59 are real vectors .
this is straightforward to show by considering the parity transformation of both sides of eq .
( [ eq:1 - 21 ] ) .
the perturbative kernels do not depend on time in an einstein de sitter model .
in general cosmology , they weakly depend on time and cosmological parameters @xcite .
it is still a good approximation that the perturbative kernels in arbitrary cosmology are replaced by those in the einstein
de sitter model @xcite .
we adopt this approximation throughout this paper for simplicity , although including such dependence is straightforward .
the perturbative kernels in lpt up to third order are given by @xcite @xmath60 \label{eq:1 - 22b}\\ & \bm{l}^{\rm ( 3a)}(\bm{p}_1,\bm{p}_2,\bm{p}_3 ) \nonumber\\ & \quad = \frac57 \frac{\bm{k}}{k^2 } \left[1 - \left(\frac{\bm{p}_1 \cdot \bm{p}_2}{p_1 p_2}\right)^2\right ] \left\{1 - \left[\frac{(\bm{p}_1 + \bm{p}_2 ) \cdot \bm{p}_3 } { |\bm{p}_1 + \bm{p}_2| p_3}\right]^2\right\ } \nonumber\\ & \qquad - \frac13 \frac{\bm{k}}{k^2 } \left [ 1 - 3\left(\frac{\bm{p}_1 \cdot \bm{p}_2}{p_1 p_2}\right)^2 \right .
\nonumber\\ & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad \left .
+ \ , 2 \frac{(\bm{p}_1 \cdot \bm{p}_2)(\bm{p}_2 \cdot \bm{p}_3 ) ( \bm{p}_3 \cdot \bm{p}_1)}{p_1 ^ 2 p_2 ^ 2 p_3 ^ 2 } \right ] \nonumber\\ & \qquad + \bm{k}\times \bm{t}(\bm{p}_1,\bm{p}_2,\bm{p}_3 ) , \label{eq:1 - 22c}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath61 for @xmath59 , and a vector @xmath62 represents a transverse part whose expression is not needed in the following application .
it is useful to symmetrize the kernel @xmath63 in terms of their arguments : @xmath64 .
\label{eq:1 - 23}\ ] ] the polyspectra of the displacement field in lpt can be evaluated in almost the same way as in the case of density fields in eulerian perturbation theory .
substituting eqs .
( [ eq:1 - 11 ] ) , ( [ eq:1 - 19 ] ) , and ( [ eq:1 - 21 ] ) into eq .
( [ eq:1 - 10 ] ) , the perturbative expansion of the polyspectra is calculated .
we assume the initial density field is a random gaussian field , in which case the cumulants of the linear density field are completely expressible by a linear power spectrum , @xmath65 . up to second order in @xmath66
, we obtain @xmath67 where we define quantities @xmath68 , @xmath69 by @xmath70 which are explicitly given by using lpt kernels as @xmath71 and @xmath72 the polyspectra of order four or higher do not contribute up to second order in @xmath66 . in random gaussian fields , it can generally be shown that @xmath1-polyspectrum has the order @xmath73 in @xmath66 , for the connectedness of the cumulants . in spt ,
diagrammatic techniques prove to be quite useful @xcite . similarly , we find diagrammatic representations of the above quantities of eqs .
( [ eq:1 - 25a])([eq:1 - 26 ] ) , which are given in fig .
[ fig : polydiag ] .
diagrammatic representations of @xmath74 ( a ) , @xmath75 ( b ) , @xmath76 ( c ) , and @xmath77 ( d ) . ] at this point , eq . ( [ eq:1 - 8 ] ) is expanded by lpt by using eqs .
( [ eq:1 - 14a ] ) , ( [ eq:1 - 14b ] ) , and ( [ eq:1 - 25a])([eq:1 - 26 ] ) .
as promised , only quantities @xmath27 are expanded from the exponent in eq .
( [ eq:1 - 8 ] ) and keep @xmath26 in the exponent .
the result is @xmath78 \nonumber\\ & \times \biggl\ { k_i k_j \left [ c^{(11)}_{ij}(\bm{k } ) + c^{(22)}_{ij}(\bm{k } ) + c^{(13)}_{ij}(\bm{k } ) + c^{(31)}_{ij}(\bm{k } ) \right ] \nonumber\\ & \qquad + k_i k_j k_k \int \frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3 } \left [ c^{(112)}_{ijk}(\bm{k},-\bm{p},\bm{p}-\bm{k } ) \right .
\nonumber\\ & \qquad\quad \left .
+ \ , c^{(121)}_{ijk}(\bm{k},-\bm{p},\bm{p}-\bm{k } ) + c^{(211)}_{ijk}(\bm{k},-\bm{p},\bm{p}-\bm{k } ) \right ] \nonumber\\ & \qquad + \frac12 k_i k_j k_k k_l \int \frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3 } c^{(11)}_{ij}(\bm{p } ) c^{(11)}_{kl}(\bm{k}-\bm{p } ) \biggr\}. \label{eq:1 - 27}\end{aligned}\ ] ] except for the linear - theory contribution , @xmath79 , all the polyspectra in the above terms are accompanied by integrations over wave vectors .
accordingly , these terms correspond to the 1-loop diagrams in fig . [
fig : psdiag ] . diagrams for our resummed power spectrum of eq .
( [ eq:1 - 27 ] ) . ]
the bubble diagram ( a ) of fig .
[ fig : psdiag ] corresponds to the exponent of the first factor .
the tree diagram ( b ) corresponds to the linear contribution @xmath80 , and loop diagrams ( c)(e ) correspond to @xmath81 , @xmath82 , and @xmath83 , respectively .
the loop diagrams ( f)(h ) correspond to integrals of @xmath84 , @xmath85 , and @xmath86 , respectively .
the last loop diagram i ) corresponds to the last integral in eq .
( [ eq:1 - 27 ] ) .
the expansion of eq .
( [ eq:1 - 27 ] ) is therefore a loop expansion , and all the 1-loop diagrams are exhausted in this equation . in the exponent of the prefactor
, we could consider the higher - order terms such as integrals of @xmath81 , @xmath82 .
these terms correspond to the 2-loop diagrams of fig .
[ fig : twobubble ] . two - loop bubble diagrams ( see text ) . ] although those terms are second order in @xmath66 , their contributions to the total power spectrum are third order since they are multiplied by first- or higher - order terms in eq .
( [ eq:1 - 27 ] ) .
therefore , we do not include these 2-loop contributions and truncate all the multiloop contributions .
it is straightforward to calculate eq .
( [ eq:1 - 27 ] ) using the expression of the polyspectra of the displacement field , eqs .
( [ eq:1 - 25a])([eq:1 - 26 ] ) , and perturbation kernels , eqs .
( [ eq:1 - 22a])([eq:1 - 23 ] ) .
contractions with spatial indices in eq .
( [ eq:1 - 27 ] ) can be taken before evaluating the momentum integrations .
the transverse part in the third - order kernel , eq .
( [ eq:1 - 22c ] ) , vanishes in course of calculation , because of the inner product with vector @xmath87 . as a result ,
the calculation is quite similar to that in spt , where some of the angular integrations can be analytically done @xcite .
the result is @xmath88 \nonumber\\ & \times \biggl\ { p_{\rm l}(k ) + \frac{1}{98 } \frac{k^3}{4\pi^2 } \int_0^\infty dr p_{\rm l}(kr ) \int_{-1}^1 dx p_{\rm l}[k\,(1 + r^2 - 2rx)^{1/2 } ] \frac{(3r + 7x - 10rx^2)^2}{(1 + r^2 - 2rx)^2 } \nonumber\\ & \qquad\qquad + \frac{1}{252 } \frac{k^3}{4\pi^2 } p_{\rm l}(k ) \int_0^\infty dr p_{\rm l}(kr ) \left[\frac{12}{r^2 } + 10 + 100 r^2 - 42 r^4 + \frac{3}{r^3}(r^2 - 1)^3 ( 7r^2 + 2 ) \ln\left|\frac{1+r}{1-r}\right| \right ] \biggr\}. \label{eq:2 - 1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] comparing this result with that of 1-loop spt @xcite , one immediately notices the similarity of the equations .
the only differences are the existence of the exponential prefactor and the number @xmath89 of the second term in the last square bracket , which is @xmath90 in spt instead .
thus , eq . ( [ eq:2 - 1 ] ) is equivalently represented as @xmath91 \nonumber\\ & \quad \times \left [ p_{\rm l}(k ) + p_{\rm spt}^{\mbox{\scriptsize 1-loop}}(k ) + \frac{k^2}{6\pi^2 } p_{\rm l}(k ) \int dp\ , p_{\rm l}(p ) \right ] , \label{eq:2 - 1 - 1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath92 is a pure 1-loop contribution ( without a linear contribution ) to the power spectrum in spt .
it is obvious from this expression that expanding the exponential prefactor exactly reproduces the spt result at the 1-loop level .
the exponential prefactor contains information from an infinite series of higher - order perturbations in terms of spt . in terms of diagrams of spt @xcite ,
the exponential prefactor comes from the diagrams in which two points are connected by a single internal line with @xmath66 but vertices are dressed by loops .
however , those diagrams are not completely resummed , and parts of the resulting terms are resummed .
therefore , the resummation of this paper corresponds to a partial vertex renormalization in terms of the spt . on the other hand
, the resulting expression has a certain similarity with rpt @xcite , because of the exponential prefactor .
in fact , a square root of this factor coincides with the nonlinear propagator in a large-@xmath29 limit of rpt . in its formulation ,
the nonlinear power spectrum is divided into two parts .
the first part is linearly dependent on the initial power spectrum with a coefficient given by the square of the propagator .
the second part corresponds to contributions from mode couplings among different scales .
rpt uses loop expansions to evaluate the mode - coupling contributions .
our expression has a similar structure , although the methods are quite different .
one possible reason for this similarity is that the rpt propagator in the zeldovich approximation exactly coincides with the square root of the exponential prefactor of eq .
( [ eq:2 - 1 ] ) above . in the zeldovich approximation ,
only @xmath80 is present for cumulants of the displacement field . as a result ,
loop corrections come only from diagrams of type i ) in fig .
[ fig : psdiag ] and its multiloop extensions ( @xmath93-loop diagrams with @xmath94 internal lines connected to the two external vertices ) , in which the vertex renormalization can not appear . as a result , rpt and
our approach turn out to be equivalent in the zeldovich approximation ( see the introduction of ref .
@xcite ) .
having an exponential damping factor , the power spectrum in our approximations does not have power at large wave numbers .
this behavior is not physical in the fully nonlinear regime , since the nonlinear evolution enhances the power spectrum on small scales .
our approximations only apply to the quasilinear regime on large scales .
an advantage of this property is that the integration of the power spectrum is stable so that other statistical quantities may be obtained , such as the correlation function , on quasilinear scales .
on the other hand , our approximations for the power spectrum itself fail when the exponential damping factor is efficient .
it is useful to have an estimate for the validity range of wave numbers in our approximations .
since the damping scale is given by @xmath95^{-1/2 } , \label{eq:2 - 1 - 2}\ ] ] a possible criterion for the validity range is @xmath96 , where @xmath97 should be determined according to the required accuracy .
we will see below that @xmath98 corresponds to the accuracy within a few percent , compared to the @xmath1-body simulations . throughout the rest of this paper
, we consider @xmath99 as the validity range in our approximations . in fig .
[ fig : logps ] , the power spectra of our result , and those of linear theory and 1-loop spt , are compared .
comparison of power spectra by different approximations at redshifts @xmath100 ( from upper to lower lines ) .
_ black ( solid ) line _ : this work ; _ red ( dotted ) line _ : linear theory ; _ green ( dashed ) line _ : 1-loop spt .
two nonlinear scales @xmath101 , @xmath102 in each redshift are indicated by arrows . ]
the linear power spectrum @xmath66 is calculated from the output of cmbfast @xcite at @xmath103 .
we adopt a cosmological model with parameters @xmath104 , @xmath105 , @xmath106 , @xmath107 , @xmath108 and @xmath109 .
the damping scale @xmath101 and the claimed validity scale @xmath102 are indicated in the figure .
it is clearly seen that our power spectra are expnentially damped on small scales @xmath110 . in this log - log plot , differences among the three approximations in our claimed validity range @xmath99 are hardly seen .
our approach is advantageous when a very accurate estimation on large scales is crucial .
the determination of the bao scale really requires such accuracy . in fig .
[ fig : realpsbao ] , detailed features in nonlinear power spectra are shown on bao scales . to enhance the baryon oscillations , each power spectrum is divided by a smoothed , no - wiggle linear power spectrum @xmath111 @xcite .
the same cosmological parameters are assumed as in fig .
[ fig : logps ] .
the validity ranges are indicated in the figure .
there are differences among three approximations in our validity ranges . in fig .
[ fig : psse ] , our result of the power spectrum in real space is compared with the @xmath1-body simulations of ref . @xcite using the same parameters as seo and eisenstein s .
comparison of the power spectra to the @xmath1-body simulations of ref .
@xcite in real space at redshifts @xmath112 , @xmath113 , and @xmath114 from top to bottom , respectively .
_ open circles _ : @xmath1-body simulations ; _ black ( solid ) line _
: this work ; _ red ( dotted ) line _ : linear theory ; _ green ( dashed ) line _
: 1-loop spt .
only nonlinear deviations from the linear growth is measured in @xmath1-body simulations to reduce cosmic variances .
estimates of validity range , @xmath99 are indicated by arrows . in the @xmath115 sample ,
the range where contributions from the nave shot noise exceed @xmath116 is also indicated , althogh the true shot noise could be smaller because of the regularity of particle positions at such a large redshift in the simulation . ] in this case , @xmath117 and other cosmological parameters are the same as above . the linear power spectrum is calculated from the output of cmbfast at @xmath118 to match the input power spectrum of the simulations .
since the no - wiggle power spectrum @xmath111 matches to the power spectrum at @xmath103 , the baseline is slightly larger than unity , because of nongravitational effects in the transfer function . to reduce the effects of cosmic variance in @xmath1-body simulations
, we calculate the differences ( in logarithmic scales ) between the output power spectra and linearly evolved initial power spectra at @xmath118 , both measured in simulations .
the resulting differences are added to the linear theory prediction in the figure . in this way ,
initial deviations of the power spectrum from the theoretical power spectrum are subtracted ( similar presentations are seen in ref .
the actual output power spectrum of simulations is noisier than that in the figure especially on larger scales . as described in ref .
@xcite , the savitzky - golay filtering is applied when the power spectrum in each @xmath1-body sample is evaluated .
the shot noise is not corrected for the @xmath1-body samples , since the initial positions of particles are on regular grids , and the nave shot noise @xmath119 , where @xmath120 is the number density of particles , does not apply at a large redshift in the simulation @xcite .
it is not obvious how to correct for the shot noise in such a situation .
the samples with @xmath112 and @xmath121 are hardly affected by the shot noise because the signal amplitudes are large , but contributions from the nave shot noise in the @xmath115 sample are over @xmath116 for @xmath122 .
therefore , the @xmath115 sample could be more or less affected by nontrivial shot noise in that range , although that is smaller than the nave shot noise . in all cases of the three redshifts @xmath112 , @xmath113 , @xmath114 , the ranges where our results and simulations agree are broader than those of 1-loop spt .
overall , the 1-loop spt overestimates the power spectrum on relatively small scales , while our result is always better on the same scales .
for example , the height of the peak at @xmath123 of the @xmath112 sample is explained by our work , while the 1-loop spt overestimates the height . in a range @xmath124@xmath125 of the @xmath121 sample ,
@xmath1-body data are ( accidentally ) closer to the linear theory rather than the 1-loop spt .
this tendency is also explained by our work . in the @xmath115 sample ,
our result matches the @xmath1-body result in the range @xmath126 , while linear theory and 1-loop spt do not ( under the condition that the nontrivial shot noise is negligible as noticed above ) .
the simulations and our results agree within a few percent in our claimed validity range , @xmath99 .
the correlation function @xmath127 is given by a fourier transform of the power spectrum .
after angular integrations , they are related by @xmath128 where @xmath129 is the spherical bessel function of zeroth order . in the 1-loop spt
, the power spectrum badly behaves on small scales to perform this integral .
the 1-loop contribution to the power spectrum in spt consists of two terms , @xmath130 .
each term asymptotically behaves as @xcite @xmath131 and the net power spectrum is much smaller in magnitude than each term . on mildly small scales ,
the residuals also behave as @xmath132 for a cdm - like power spectrum
. therefore , the power spectrum on small scales contributes to the integral in eq .
( [ eq:2 - 2 ] ) even if the separation @xmath133 is large . in a small - scale limit , @xmath134 ,
the leading contributions of the two terms are exactly canceled out , and the net contribution behaves as @xcite @xmath135 for a cdm - like power spectrum , @xmath136 , and the integral in eq .
( [ eq:2 - 2 - 2 ] ) diverges . as a result
, one can not evaluate the correlation function by the 1-loop spt , because the integral of eq .
( [ eq:2 - 2 ] ) does not converge .
this divergence obviously reflects the fact that the 1-loop spt is invalid on small scales .
since the correlation function is an observable quantity , this is an undesirable property in spt .
such a problem does not occur in our expression of eq .
( [ eq:2 - 1 ] ) : the power spectrum is exponentially suppressed in the small - scale limit .
this behavior is not physical on sufficiently small scales , since our expression is applicable only to the weakly nonlinear regime .
however , small - scale behavior in the power spectrum should not be relevant to the correlation function on large scales , since dominant contributions of the power spectrum to the correlation function of eq .
( [ eq:2 - 2 ] ) come from scales @xmath137 for a cdm - like power spectrum . since the exponential prefactor in eq .
( [ eq:2 - 1 ] ) acts as a gaussian damping function , the resulting correlation function has a form of convolution by a gaussian smoothing function .
this smoothing effect by nonlinearity is already known , which smears the bao peak in the correlation function @xcite .
the physical origin of this nonlinear smearing is the random motion of mass elements , because the dominant contribution of this smearing factor comes from @xmath138 ) .
it is worth noting that this nonlinear smearing effect is not captured by linear theory and higher - order spt . in fig .
[ fig : realxibao ] , the nonlinear correlation function is plotted on bao scales . the same cosmological parameters as in fig .
[ fig : realpsbao ] are adopted .
nonlinear smearing effects on the baryon acoustic peak are described by our theory . in fig .
[ fig : realxibao ] , gaussian - filtered linear theory is overplotted .
the filtering length is given by the one that the exponential prefactor in eq .
( [ eq:2 - 1 ] ) implies : @xmath139^{1/2}.
\label{eq:2 - 3}\ ] ] this simple model approximately explains the nonlinear smearing effects . in detail , this simple model overestimates the small - scale clustering and height of the trough , and underestimates the peak height . in fig .
[ fig : xise ] , our result of the correlation function in real space at @xmath112 is compared with the @xmath1-body simulations of refs .
@xcite using the same parameters as used in these references .
comparison of the correlation functions to the @xmath1-body simulations of refs .
@xcite in real space .
_ open circles _ : @xmath1-body results ; _ black ( solid ) line _ : this work ; _ red ( dotted ) line _ : linear theory .
only nonlinear deviations from the linear growth are measured in @xmath1-body simulations to reduce finiteness effects . ] as in the case of the power spectrum , we compute differences ( in linear scales ) between the output correlation function and the linearly evolved initial correlation function at @xmath118 in the simulation , and the resulting differences are added to the linear - theory prediction in the figure . if we directly plot the measured correlation function , the amplitudes on @xmath140@xmath141 and @xmath142@xmath143 are slightly ( about @xmath144 ) larger .
this tendency is already seen even in the initial correlation function at @xmath118 , which can be identified to the finiteness effect of the simulations .
therefore , we only measure the nonlinear deviations from the linear theory in the simulation .
the agreement between the simulation and our result is quite good .
there is not any fitting parameter at all . in the corresponding power spectrum , the @xmath112 plot in fig .
[ fig : psse ] , the difference between our result and that of 1-loop spt may seem to be small . in the correlation function , however , the difference is really big , since the 1-loop spt can not predict the correlation function , while our result explains the nonlinear effects on bao scales very precisely .
our approach above can be extensible to the calculation in redshift space . in redshift surveys ,
the position of each galaxy is measured by the redshift . in a completely homogeneous universe ,
the comoving distance
redshift relation is given by a standard formula for the friedmann - lematre universe : @xmath145 where @xmath146 is the time - dependent hubble parameter .
in reality , however , the universe is locally inhomogeneous , and the comoving distance to a galaxy of redshift @xmath147 is not exactly given by eq .
( [ eq:3 - 1 ] ) . for the galaxy redshifts ,
the leading source of the deviation is the doppler shift caused by the peculiar velocities of the galaxy .
the observed redshift @xmath148 with the effect of the peculiar velocity can be calculated by solving the geodesic equation .
the comoving distance in redshift space is defined by @xmath149 , where , in the rhs , the redshift - distance relation of eq .
( [ eq:3 - 1 ] ) is adopted even though we live in an inhomogeneous universe . when the peculiar velocities are nonrelativistic , the comoving distance in real space , @xmath150 , and that in redshift space @xmath151 is related by @xmath152 @xcite , where @xmath153 is a line - of - sight component of the peculiar velocity @xmath154 .
throughout this paper , we work in `` distant - observer '' or `` plane - parallel '' approximation , where the line - of - sight direction is fixed in space and denoted by @xmath155 .
we ignore the contribution from the peculiar velocity of the observer , which does not contribute to the following calculation of the power spectrum .
when the curvature scale of the universe is much larger than clustering scales we are interested in , we can safely use local cartesian coordinates in the volume of galaxy surveys .
thus the relation between the position in real space @xmath4 and that in redshift space @xmath156 is given by @xmath157 where @xmath158 . therefore , using eq .
( [ eq:1 - 1 ] ) , the displacement field in redshift space is given by @xmath159 a similar equation has been applied to the analysis of the zeldovich approximation @xcite . in the time - independent approximation to the perturbative kernels , @xmath160 , and therefore , the time derivative of the displacement field is simply @xmath161 where @xmath162 is the logarithmic derivative of the linear growth rate .
thus , the displacement field of each perturbation order in redshift space is given by @xmath163 which is just a linear mapping of the displacement vector of each order .
this linear transformation is characterized by a redshift - space distortion tensor @xmath164 for @xmath93th order perturbations , defined by @xmath165 with which eq .
( [ eq:3 - 5 ] ) reduces to @xmath166 , or in a vector notation , @xmath167 .
therefore , the perturbative kernels in redshift space are given simply by @xmath168 thus , our calculation in real space can be simply generalized to that in redshift space by using the redshift - space perturbative kernels in eqs .
( [ eq:1 - 25a])([eq:1 - 26 ] ) , while the form of eq .
( [ eq:1 - 27 ] ) is unchanged in redshift space , provided that the cumulants of the displacement field are evaluated in redshift space .
the mappings of the order - by - order cumulants are quite simple : @xmath169 the calculation of eq .
( [ eq:1 - 27 ] ) in redshift space is more complicated than in real space , since the anisotropy is introduced by the redshift - space distortion tensors . accordingly , the momentum integrations should be evaluated before taking inner products with the vector @xmath87 . in redshift space , however , the cumulants @xmath68 and @xmath170 in eq .
( [ eq:1 - 27 ] ) should be replaced by redshift - space counterparts , @xmath171 and @xmath172 of eqs .
( [ eq:3 - 8a ] ) and ( [ eq:3 - 8b ] ) . since the redshift distortion tensors
@xmath164 are anisotropic , the integrands do not reduce to scalar functions .
therefore we need to explicitly evaluate integrals of tensors .
the results are given in appendix [ app : inttens ] , eqs .
( [ eq : a-4a])([eq : a-4c ] ) and ( [ eq : a-6a])([eq : a-6c ] ) . using those equations , it is straightforward to obtain an expression of the power spectrum @xmath173 in redshift space .
there are many terms in the result , which are arranged as @xmath174 a \right\ } \nonumber\\ & \qquad\qquad \times \left [ ( 1 + f\mu^2)^2 p_{\rm l}(k ) + \sum_{n , m } \mu^{2n } f^m e_{nm}(k ) \right ] , \label{eq:3 - 9}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath175 is the direction cosine of the wave vector @xmath87 with respect to the line of sight , @xmath176 and @xmath177 and all the other @xmath178 which are not listed above are zero .
the functions @xmath179 and @xmath180 are given by eqs .
( [ eq : a-1a])([eq : a-3b ] ) in appendix [ app : inttens ] . as in the case of real space
, the spt result should be reproduced by expanding the exponential prefactor in eq .
( [ eq:3 - 9 ] ) . a formal expression for the 1-loop power spectrum in redshift space @xcite contains 3-dimensional integrations
. further reduction of the expression is possible and necessary to compare with our result . in appendix [ app : redpsspt ] , we derive a reduced expression for the power spectrum of 1-loop spt in redshift space , which itself is a new result . finally , the following relation , which is similar to eq . ( [ eq:2 - 1 - 1 ] ) , is confirmed : @xmath174 a \right\ } \nonumber\\ & \quad \times \left\ { ( 1 + f\mu^2)^2 p_{\rm l}(k ) + p_{\rm sspt}^{\mbox{\scriptsize 1-loop}}(\bm{k } ) \right .
\nonumber\\ & \qquad\quad \left .
+ \ , ( 1 + f\mu^2)^2[1 + f(f+2)\mu^2 ] k^2 p_{\rm l}(k ) a \right\ } , \label{eq:3 - 12}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath181 is the 1-loop contribution to the redshift - space power spectrum in spt given in appendix [ app : redpsspt ] . therefore , when the exponential prefactor is expanded , eq .
( [ eq:3 - 9 ] ) reduces to the result of spt .
the linear term in eq .
( [ eq:3 - 9 ] ) corresponds to the kaiser formula @xcite of the linear perturbation theory .
the appearance of the exponential suppression prefactor is characteristic in our formalism .
this factor reflects the nonlinear smearing effect of the velocity field along the lines of sight @xcite , such as the fingers - of - god effect by large - scale random motions . the linear theory and higher - order spt
do not have such a suppression factor along the lines of sight .
this form of the suppression factor exactly matches a phenomenological model of the redshift - space power spectrum on large scales @xcite , which is given by ( after correcting obvious typos ) @xmath182 ( 1 + f\mu^2)^2 p_{\rm l}(\bm{k } ) , \label{eq:3 - 13}\ ] ] where @xmath183 and @xmath184 are wave vector components across and along the line of sight , and @xmath185 and @xmath186 are modeled by @xmath187 the length parameter @xmath188 characterizes the scale of radial displacements . when all the 1-loop contributions of our eq .
( [ eq:3 - 9 ] ) are omitted , the model of eq .
( [ eq:3 - 13 ] ) is `` derived '' if we identify @xmath189 , where @xmath190 is a linear - theory value of @xmath191 at @xmath103 . in ref .
@xcite , the parameter @xmath188 is measured from the @xmath1-body simulation of eisenstein , seo , and white , and a value @xmath192 is obtained for @xmath141 separations in their cosmology ( we convert their quoted value according to different conventions of the growth factor ) . using the same set of cosmological parameters as theirs , we find @xmath193 .
the corresponding prediction from our formalism is @xmath194 , which is very close to their measured value .
there is another simple model of the nonlinear power spectrum in redshift space @xcite , which is given by @xmath195 , \label{eq:3 - 15}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath196 is the same as our @xmath191 of eq .
( [ eq:3 - 10 ] ) , and @xmath197 , @xmath198 , @xmath199 are ( cross ) power spectra of density and velocity fields , calculated from nonlinear 1-loop spt .
even though the density and velocity ( cross ) correlations are taken into account , this model is no longer a result of exact 1-loop perturbation theory ( see appendix [ app : redpsspt ] ) .
this simple model explains @xmath1-body data to some extent but predicts a slightly larger power spectrum than @xmath1-body data on small scales @xcite .
this model has a similar structure to our result but lacks many terms .
the spherical average of eq .
( [ eq:3 - 9 ] ) is calculated by using the following integral : @xmath200 , \label{eq:3 - 20}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath201 is the lower incomplete gamma function , and @xmath202 is the error function normalized by @xmath203 . in fig .
[ fig : redpsbao ] , the spherically averaged nonlinear power spectrum in redshift space is plotted on bao scales .
the same cosmological parameters as in fig .
[ fig : logps ] are adopted .
each power spectrum is normalized by a no - wiggle power spectrum @xcite in real space . according to the kaiser effect ,
the amplitude is larger in higher redshifts . in the same plot , the simple model of eq .
( [ eq:3 - 15 ] ) is overplotted .
both linear theory and 1-loop spt are larger than our result and the simple model , since the former two do not have a suppression factor which corresponds to nonlinear smearing effects along the lines of sight in redshift space .
the validity ranges @xmath99 are indicated in the figure , where @xmath101 is given by eq .
( [ eq:2 - 1 - 2 ] ) . in fig .
[ fig : pssered ] , a comparison of the power spectrum in redshift space between our results and the @xmath1-body simulations of ref . @xcite is presented .
comparison of the power spectra to the @xmath1-body simulations of ref .
@xcite in redshift space at redshifts @xmath112 , @xmath113 , and @xmath114 from top to bottom , respectively .
_ open circles _ :
@xmath1-body simulations ; _ black ( solid ) line _ : this work ; _ red ( dotted ) line _ : linear theory ; _ green ( dashed ) line _ : 1-loop spt ; _ blue ( long dashed ) line _ : a simple model of redshift - space power spectrum @xcite .
only nonlinear deviations from the linear growth are measured in @xmath1-body simulations to reduce cosmic variances .
estimates of validity range , @xmath99 are indicated by arrows . in the @xmath115 sample , the range where contributions from the nave shot noise exceed @xmath116 is also indicated . ] as in real space , our results are better than 1-loop spt results .
the 1-loop spt overestimates the power spectrum much worse in redshift space . on smaller scales , the simple model of eq .
( [ eq:3 - 15 ] ) and the linear theory seems to be good descriptions at a particular redshift . however , that is just a coincidence because they do not describe the simulations at different redshifts .
the shot noise is not corrected for the @xmath1-body simulation , and the @xmath1-body sample of @xmath115 might be affected by the shot noise on small scales .
the range where the nave shot noise is over @xmath116 is indicated in the figure .
since the particle positions in redshift space are more randomly distributed than in real space , the true shot noise might be larger than that in real space .
overall , our results describe the @xmath1-body results well at all redshifts .
the correlation function @xmath204 in redshift space is given by @xmath205 when we consider the spherically averaged correlation function , the relation of eq .
( [ eq:2 - 2 ] ) is applicable with the spherically averaged power spectrum . in fig .
[ fig : redxibao ] , the spherically averaged nonlinear correlation function in redshift space is plotted on bao scales . the same cosmological parameters as in fig . [
fig : realpsbao ] are adopted .
since the effect of the suppression factor is larger in redshift space , the nonlinear smearing effects on the baryon peak are larger than in real space ( cf .
[ fig : realxibao ] ) .
this is because the nonlinear redshift - space distortions additionally smear the clustering along the line of sight . as in fig .
[ fig : realxibao ] , gaussian - filtered linear theory is overplotted , which approximately explains the nonlinear smearing effects . in fig .
[ fig : xisered ] , our result of the correlation function in redshift space at @xmath112 is compared with the @xmath1-body simulations of refs .
@xcite using the same parameter as used in these references .
comparison of the correlation functions to the @xmath1-body simulations of refs .
@xcite in redshift space .
_ open circles _ : @xmath1-body results ; _ black ( solid ) line _ : this work ; _ red ( dotted ) line _ : linear theory .
only nonlinear deviations from the linear growth are measured in @xmath1-body simulations to reduce finiteness effects . ]
the agreement is quite good also in redshift space , and our result explains the nonlinear effects on bao scales very precisely even in redshift space .
in this paper , we have formulated a new resummation method of the cosmological perturbation theory , starting from the lagrangian description of perturbations .
the infinite series of perturbations in spt is naturally contained in the exponential prefactor in our formalism , and expanding the exponential factor reproduces the spt .
we have presented 1-loop results of our formalism in this paper .
our method is particularly useful for studying nonlinear effects on bao scales and always provides a better description of the @xmath1-body results than spt on large scales .
nonlinear corrections to the correlation function can be calculated by our formalism .
this is a great advantage over spt , since higher - order spt can not predict the correlation function .
our 1-loop results are comparable to the 1-loop results of the rpt @xcite . in the rpt
, it is shown that taking into account the 2-loop effects enlarges the applicable range toward small scales in the power spectrum . since our formalism and rpt
have common features in the resulting equations , we expect that 2-loop extensions of our calculation similarly enlarge the applicable range of scales in the power spectrum .
the description of the bao peak in the correlation function seems already sufficient by our 1-loop calculation .
it is an important and original outcome that our formalism gives an analytical description of nonlinear effects in redshift space .
the large - scale structure is measured by redshift surveys of astronomical objects , such as galaxies , quasars , lyman - alpha absorbers , 21 cm emission , etc . however
, nonlinear corrections to the power spectrum and correlation function in redshift space by perturbation theory have not been sufficiently studied so far .
our formalism and results presented in this paper are unprecedented in this respect and are crucial steps toward applying the bao measurements in redshift surveys to constraining the nature of dark energy , the curvature of the universe , etc .
considering the biasing effects in galaxy clustering is beyond the scope of this paper .
a simple prescription of the biasing is to replace @xmath206 in our equations , where @xmath207 is the linear bias parameter .
however , nonlinearity and nonlocality of biasing might not be negligible even on bao scales @xcite . incorporating the nonlinear and nonlocal biasing into our formalism
will be addressed in future work .
i wish to thank h .-
seo and d. j. eisenstein for providing table forms of their figures in refs .
@xcite and a. taruya and n. yoshida for discussion .
i acknowledge support from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science , and technology , grant - in - aid for scientific research ( c ) , 18540260 , 2006 , and grant - in - aid for scientific research on priority areas no .
467 `` probing the dark energy through an extremely wide and deep survey with subaru telescope . ''
this work is supported in part by jsps ( japan society for promotion of science ) core - to - core program `` international research network for dark energy . ''
in this appendix , we present results of integrating cumulants of the displacement field , which appear in eq . ( [ eq:1 - 27 ] ) .
although we do not need to evaluate the integrations as tensors in real space , we do need to do that in redshift space . to present the results , it is convenient to define the following integrals : @xmath208\ , \frac{\tilde{q}_n(r , x)}{(1 + r^2 - 2rx)^2 } , \label{eq : a-1a}\\ & r_n(k ) = \frac{1}{48 } p_{\rm
l}(k ) \frac{k^3}{4\pi^2 } \int_0^\infty dr\ , p_{\rm l}(kr)\,\tilde{r}_n(r ) , \label{eq : a-1b}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath209 and @xmath210 the following expressions are directly obtained by substituting eqs .
( [ eq:1 - 22a])([eq:1 - 23 ] ) into eqs .
( [ eq:1 - 25a])([eq:1 - 25c ] ) : @xmath211 in deriving eq .
( [ eq : a-4c ] ) , the transverse part of eq . ( [ eq:1 - 22c ] ) vanishes , because the rotational covariance implies @xmath212 where @xmath213 is a scalar function .
the remaining integrals are obtained by using the rotational covariance .
for example , when the integrand is given by @xmath214 times a scalar function of @xmath87 and @xmath215 , integration over @xmath215 should result in a form @xmath216 .
the coefficients @xmath20 and @xmath217 can be obtained by contracting the original expression with @xmath218 and @xmath219 , and so forth .
after these kinds of manipulations , we obtain @xmath220 where the spatial indices are symmetrized over in eq .
( [ eq : a-6c ] ) .
if we substitute those expressions of eqs .
( [ eq : a-4a])([eq : a-4c ] ) and ( [ eq : a-6a])([eq : a-6c ] ) into eq . ( [ eq:1 - 27 ] ) , the real - space result of eq .
( [ eq:2 - 1 ] ) is reproduced .
in this appendix , the nonlinear power spectrum in redshift space is calculated by 1-loop spt . a formal expression found in the literature @xcite
is given by 3-dimensional integrals , which are reduced to lower dimensional integrals below .
it is suggested that the 1-loop calculation of the power spectrum in redshift space by spt does not give satisfactory results , because spt in redshift space breaks down at larger scales than in real space @xcite . in this paper , we do not recommend the extensive use of the 1-loop spt in redshift space .
however , it is still useful to calculate the nonlinear corrections by spt in redshift space for the following reasons : first , the 1-loop corrections indicate when the linear theory is applicable and when nonlinear effects become important in redshift space .
second , the 1-loop spt gives the asymptotic behavior of nonlinear corrections in the @xmath221 limit , which should be compared with any nonlinear theory of redshift - space distortions on large scales .
the comoving real - space position @xmath4 and the comoving redshift - space position @xmath156 are related by eq .
( [ eq:3 - 2 ] ) , or @xmath222 the density field in real space @xmath7 and that in redshift space @xmath223 are related by conservation relation : @xmath224 therefore , the density contrast in redshift space is given by @xmath225j^{-1 } - 1 , \label{eq : b-3}\ ] ] where @xmath226 is the jacobian of the mapping from real space to redshift space .
one can easily calculate the fourier transform of eq .
( [ eq : b-3 ] ) : @xmath227 , \label{eq : b-4}\ ] ] where @xmath228 .
this relation is applicable even in the fully nonlinear regime . in fourier space , @xmath229 .
following the route of spt , the density contrast and the peculiar velocity , which are absent in an homogeneous universe , are expanded in perturbative series : @xmath230 where @xmath231 corresponds to the velocity divergence . in the spt , only growing - mode solutions in each order are retained , and the peculiar velocity field is consistently assumed to be irrotational .
thus , the velocity field is fully characterized by the velocity divergence @xcite . in fourier space ,
each perturbative term is given by @xmath232 the perturbative kernels @xmath233 and @xmath234 do not depend on time in an einstein de sitter model .
they weakly depend on time and cosmological parameters in general cosmology , but it is still a good approximation that the perturbative kernels are replaced by those in the einstein de sitter model even in arbitrary cosmology @xcite . the explicit form of the perturbation kernels is given in refs .
@xcite . expanding the peculiar velocity field in eq .
( [ eq : b-4 ] ) , and applying the perturbative expansions of eqs .
( [ eq : b-5a ] ) and ( [ eq : b-5b ] ) , we obtain the perturbative series for the redshift - space density field : @xmath235 where the perturbative kernels in redshift space @xmath236 are given by @xmath237 up to third order , where @xmath238 , @xmath239 , and @xmath240 etc
. the expression of @xmath241 should be symmetrized over its arguments when necessary .
these kernels are equivalent to those derived in ref .
@xcite , while the derivation and apparent expressions here are somewhat different from those of scoccimarro , couchman , and frieman .
when the linear bias @xmath207 is present , the perturbative kernels for density fluctuations of galaxies are given by replacing @xmath206 in the above kernels .
when the bias is modeled by a nonlinear and local one , it is straightforward to include that by a method of ref .
@xcite .
given the perturbative kernels , the nonlinear power spectrum in redshift space is calculated in a similar way to that in real space @xcite .
the power spectrum @xmath242 in redshift space is defined by @xmath243 note that the power spectrum in redshift space is no longer isotropic .
the perturbative expansion of the power spectrum up to second order in the linear power spectrum ( i.e. , fourth order in @xmath244 ) is given by @xmath245 , \label{eq : b-10}\ ] ] where @xmath246 is the contribution from @xmath247 , @xmath248 is from @xmath249 , and @xmath250 is from @xmath251 .
the first quantity is the linear ( or tree - level ) power spectrum , and the last two quantities are 1-loop corrections , which are given by @xmath252 ^ 2 p_0(k ) , \label{eq : b-11a}\\ & p_{\rm s22}(\bm{k } ) = 2 \int \frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3 } \left [ s^{\rm s}_2(\bm{p},\bm{k}-\bm{p } ) \right]^2 p_0(p )
p_0(|\bm{k}-\bm{p}| ) , \label{eq : b-11b}\\ & p_{\rm s13}(\bm{k } ) = 6 s_1(\bm{k } ) p_0(k ) \int \frac{d^3p}{(2\pi)^3 } s^{\rm s}_3(\bm{k},\bm{p},-\bm{p } ) p_0(p ) , \label{eq : b-11c}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath253 is a symmetrized kernel obtained from @xmath236 .
the first - order power spectrum is given by @xmath254 which is the kaiser formula @xcite in linear perturbation theory .
integration over the azimuthal angle can be analytically performed in eqs .
( [ eq : b-11b ] ) and ( [ eq : b-11c ] ) , and further integration over the polar angle in eq .
( [ eq : b-11c ] ) is also possible .
terms which contain the line - of - sight components of the wave vector can be evaluated by using the rotational covariance as described in appendix [ app : inttens ] .
after a lengthy but straightforward calculation , the final results are given by @xmath255 \frac{a_{nm}(r , x)}{(1 + r^2 - 2rx)^2 } , \label{eq : b-13a}\\ & p_{\rm s13}(\bm{k } ) = ( 1 + f \mu^2 ) p_0(k ) \nonumber\\ & \qquad \times \sum_{n , m } \mu^{2n } f^m \frac{k^3}{4\pi^2 } \int_0^\infty dr p_0(kr ) b_{nm}(r ) \label{eq : b-13b}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where non - vanishing components of @xmath256 and @xmath257 are @xmath258 , \label{eq : b-14d}\\ & a_{23 } = \frac{1}{14 } ( 1 - x^2)(7 - 42rx - 6r^2 + 48 r^2 x^2 ) , \label{eq : b-14e}\\ & a_{24 } = \frac{3}{16 } r^2 ( 1 - x^2)^2 , \label{eq : b-14f}\\ & a_{33 } = \frac{1}{14 } ( -7 + 35x^2 + 54rx - 110rx^3 \nonumber\\ & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad + 6r^2 - 66r^2x^2 + 88r^2x^4 ) , \label{eq : b-14g}\\ & a_{34 } = \frac18 ( 1 - x^2)(2 - 3r^2 - 12rx + 15r^2x^2 ) , \label{eq : b-14h}\\ & a_{44 } = \frac{1}{16 } ( -4 + 12x^2 + 3 r^2 + 24rx \nonumber\\ & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad - 30r^2x^2 - 40rx^3 + 35r^2x^4 ) , \label{eq : b-14i}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath259 , \label{eq : b-15a}\\ & b_{11 } = 3 b_{00 } , \label{eq : b-15b}\\ & b_{12 } = \frac{1}{168 } \left [ \frac{18}{r^2 } - 178 - 66 r^2 + 18 r^4 \right . \nonumber\\ & \qquad\qquad\qquad \left . - \frac{9}{r^3 } ( r^2 - 1)^4 \ln\left|\frac{1+r}{1-r}\right| \right ] , \label{eq : b-15c}\\ & b_{22 } = \frac{1}{168 } \left [ \frac{18}{r^2 } - 218 + 126 r^2 - 54 r^4 \right . \nonumber\\ & \qquad\qquad\quad \left . + \frac{9}{r^3 } ( r^2 - 1)^3(3r^2 + 1 ) \ln\left|\frac{1+r}{1-r}\right| \right ] , \label{eq : b-15d}\\ & b_{23 } = - \frac23.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in a limit @xmath260 , only @xmath261 terms survive , and the previous results of the 1-loop power spectrum in real space @xcite are recovered . p. j. e. peebles and j. t. yu , , 815 ( 1970 ) ; r. a. sunyaev and y. b. zeldovich , astrophys .
space sci.*7 * , 3 ( 1970 ) ; j. r. bond and g. efstathiou , astrophys . j. letters , * 285 * , l45 ( 1984 ) ; j. r. bond and g. efstathiou , mon . not .
r. astron .
, * 226 * , 655 ( 1987 ) ; j. a. holtzman , astrophys
. j. suppl .
ser . , * 71 * , 1 ( 1989 ) .
a. d. miller et al . , astrophys .
j. letters , * 524 * , l1 ( 1999 ) ; p. de bernardis et al .
, , * 404 * , 955 ( 2000 ) ; s. hanany et al .
, astrophys .
j. letters , 545 , l5 ( 2000 ) ; c. l. bennett et al . , astrophys
. j. suppl .
* 148 * , 1 ( 2003 ) .
d. j. eisenstein et al .
, , 560 ( 2005 ) ; s. cole et al .
, mon . not .
r. astron .
soc . , * 362 * , 505 ( 2005 ) ; m. tegmark et al .
, , 123507 ( 2006 ) ; g. htsi , astron .
, * 449 * , 891 ( 2006 ) ; w. percival et al . , , 51 ( 2007 ) ;
n. padmanabhan et al .
mon . not .
r. astron .
soc . , 378 , 852 ( 2007 ) . w. hu and z. haiman , , * 68 * , 063004 ( 2003 ) ; c. blake and k. glazebrook , , * 594 * , 665 ( 2003 ) ; h .- j .
seo and d. j. eisenstein , , * 598 * , 720 ( 2003 ) ; e. v. linder , , * 68 * , 083504 ( 2003 ) ; t. matsubara , , * 615 * , 573 ( 2004 ) ; l. amendola , c. quercellini , and e. giallongo , mon . not .
r. astron .
* 357 * , 429 ( 2005 ) ; c. blake and s. bridle , mon . not .
r. astron .
* 363 * , 1329 ( 2005 ) ; k. glazebrook and c. blake , , * 631 * , 1 ( 2005 ) ; d. dolney , b. jain , and m. takada , mon . not .
r. astron .
, * 366 * , 884 ( 2006 ) ; h .- j .
seo and d. j. eisenstein , , * 665 * , 14 ( 2007 ) .
r. angulo , c. m. baugh , c. s. frenk , r. g. bower , a. jenkins , & s. l. morris , mon . not .
r. astron .
* 362 * , l25 ( 2005 ) ; j. guzik , g. bernstein , and r. e. smith , mon . not
r. astron .
soc . , * 375 * , 1329 ( 2007 ) ; z. ma , , * 665 * , 887 ( 2007 ) ; r. e. smith , r. scoccimarro , and r. k. sheth , , * 75 * , 063512 ( 2007 ) ; r. e. smith , r. scoccimarro , and r. k. sheth , , * 77 * , 043525 ( 2008 ) . m. white , astroparticle physics , * 24 * , 334 ( 2005 ) ; a. e. schulz and m. white , astroparticle physics , * 25 * , 172 ( 2006 ) ; e. huff , a. e. schulz , m. white , d. j. schlegel , and m. s. warren , astroparticle physics , * 26 * , 351 ( 2007 ) ; t. nishimichi , et al . ,
japan , * 59 * , 1049 ( 2007 ) .
s. matarrese and m. pietroni , mod .
a , * 23 * , 25 ( 2008 ) ; s. matarrese and m. pietroni , j. cosmol .
phys . , 0706 ( 2007 ) 026 ; k. izumi and j. soda , , 083517 ( 2007 ) ; o. j. rosten , j. cosmol .
, 01 ( 2008 ) 029 .
t. buchert , astron .
, * 223 * , 9 ( 1989 ) ; f. moutarde , j .- m .
alimi , f. r. bouchet , r. pellat , and a. ramani , , * 382 * , 377 ( 1991 ) ; t. buchert , mon . not .
r. astron .
soc . , * 254 * , 729 ( 1992 ) ; t. buchert and j. ehlers , mon . not .
r. astron .
soc . , * 264 * , 375 ( 1993 ) ; t. buchert , mon . not .
r. astron .
soc . , * 267 * , 811 ( 1994 ) ; e. hivon , f. r. bouchet , s. colombi and r. juszkiewicz , astron . astrophys .
, * 298 * , 643 ( 1995 ) ; j. ehlers and t. buchert , general relativity and gravitation , * 29 * , 733 ( 1997 ) ; t. tatekawa , recent res .
. astrophys .
* 2 * 1 ( 2005 ) ( arxiv : astro - ph/0412025 ) . j. r. bond and h. m. p.
couchman , in _ proceedings of the 2nd canadian conference on general relativity and relativistic astrophysics _ ( world scientific , singapore , 1988 ) , p. 385 ; a. n. taylor , in _ cosmic velocity fields , proceedings of the 9th iap astrophysics meeting , institut dastrophysique , paris , july 12 - 17 , 1993 _ ( editions frontieres , gif - sur - yvette , 1993 ) , p. 585 ; a. n. taylor and a. j. s. hamilton , mon . not .
r. astron .
* 282 * , 767 ( 1996 ) . | we develop a new approach to study the nonlinear evolution in the large - scale structure of the universe both in real space and in redshift space , extending the standard perturbation theory of gravitational instability .
infinite series of terms in standard eulerian perturbation theory are resummed as a result of our starting from a lagrangian description of perturbations .
delicate nonlinear effects on scales of the baryon acoustic oscillations are more accurately described by our method than the standard one .
our approach differs from other resummation techniques recently proposed , such as the renormalized perturbation theory , etc .
, in that we use simple techniques and thus resulting equations are undemanding to evaluate , and in that our approach is capable of quantifying the nonlinear effects in redshift space .
the power spectrum and correlation function of our approach are in good agreement with numerical simulations in literature on scales of baryon acoustic oscillations .
especially , nonlinear effects on the baryon acoustic peak of the correlation function are accurately described both in real space and in redshift space .
our approach provides a unique opportunity to analytically investigate the nonlinear effects on baryon acoustic scales in observable redshift space , which is requisite in constraining the nature of dark energy , the curvature of the universe , etc .
, by redshift surveys . |
it is widely accepted that triplet pairing between constituent spin-1/2 fermions gives rise to superfluid phases in liquid @xmath0he at millikelvin temperatures and in the neutronic component of the quantum fluid interior of a neutron star at temperatures in the hundred kev range and below . in both cases ,
the density is so high that the familiar singlet s - wave gap is quenched by the dominant effect of the short - range repulsion in that channel . instead
, pairing is favored in a channel with an odd orbital momentum @xmath5 , and therefore in the triplet spin state .
the pairing mechanisms active in these two examples produce interesting distinctions between them . in superfluid @xmath0he , pairing is triggered by spin fluctuations @xcite , and the b - state ( or b - phase ) with total angular momentum @xmath6 occupies most of the superfluid phase diagram .
however , the spin - fluctuation mechanism induces relatively tiny energy splittings between states with different @xmath7 values .
consequently , very close to the critical temperature @xmath8 there exists a phase transition from the b - phase to the a - phase , which involves a combination of @xmath9 and @xmath10 pairing channels .
the situation in neutron matter is rather different . referring to the experimental data on the energy dependence of the @xmath11 scattering phase shifts @xcite
, one may infer that central forces between a neutron pair are quite weak , and that pairing must be due predominantly to the spin - orbit force .
based on empirical analyses of spin - orbit splitting in finite nuclei , the latter force is expected to be insensitive to polarization and correlation effects .
the spin - orbit pairing mechanism implies that the spin @xmath12 and orbital momentum @xmath13 of the pair cease to be conserved separately , and pairing in the @xmath10 channel dominates @xcite . in both fermi quantum liquids ,
the effective in - medium interaction contains a component that mixes two - body states with orbital angular momenta @xmath14 .
specifically , pairing channels with @xmath5 and @xmath15 are coupled by the magnetic dipole force in the case of liquid @xmath0he and by the tensor force arising from pion exchange , in neutron matter .
however , the effect is of minuscule importance in the @xmath0he problem , since the magnetic dipole component is smaller in magnitude than the dominant central part of the interaction by a factor @xmath16 @xcite .
by contrast , the magnitude of the dominant spin - orbit force in neutron matter is only a few times larger than the tensor component , so the effects of the latter can not be neglected .
( more specifically , the parameter measuring the strength of the tensor force relative to the spin - orbit force varies around @xmath17 in the density interval @xmath18 @xcite if in - vacuum interaction constants are adopted , @xmath19 being the saturation density of symmetrical nuclear matter . )
moreover , pion exchange is responsible for the most powerful fluctuations in neutron matter .
accordingly , it is imperative to give careful attention to + @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 channel coupling in the quantitative description of pairing in neutron matter . reliable prediction of the phase diagram of triplet pairing over an extensive temperature range has proven to be extraordinarily difficult .
the traditional tool for elucidation of the phase diagram in liquid @xmath0he and other systems manifesting superfluidity or superconductivity has been the ginzburg - landau functional approach .
but since ginzburg - landau theory is valid only near the critical temperature , it has little relevance to neutron stars , which cool down to temperatures one or two orders of magnitude below @xmath8 by a thousand years after their birth in a supernova event .
there is of course the alternative of brute - force iterative solution of the gap equation , which has been widely used in quantitative studies of singlet s - wave pairing @xcite .
however , this strategy is generally afflicted with slow convergence and uncertain accuracy both for s - wave interactions containing strong short - range repulsions and for pairing in higher angular momentum states , where one must deal with a multitude of coupled nonlinear singular integral equations . the limitations of standard iterative approaches become particularly serious when one seeks to construct the superfluid phase diagram of the system , which is sensitive to tiny energy splittings between the different solutions of the bcs pairing problem .
explication of the complete superfluid phase diagram of neutron matter has two facets .
first , one must identify and characterize the set of admissible solutions of the bcs gap equations arising in the @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 pairing problem , i.e. , one must find the `` spectrum of solutions . ''
second , one must determine the relative stability of the different solutions under variation of density , temperature , and other relevant parameters , so as to uncover the possible phase transitions and map out the actual phase diagram .
the purpose of this paper is to present a detailed account of the substantial progress that has been made on the first of these tasks through application of the separation method developed in ref .
@xcite for robust and accurate solution of bcs gap equations .
( the reader may consult ref .
@xcite for a comprehensive review of the separation approach . )
many of the results obtained here have been exposed in condensed form in earlier works @xcite ; it is our intent here to offer a more complete justification of these findings , and to provide an enhanced understanding of their wider implications . in the separation method ,
the bcs system is recast so as to isolate the major , logarithmically divergent contributions to the pairing effect and treat them separately from the remaining features of the problem , which are very insensitive to the presence of the gap and its particular value .
this method , which in essence reduces the problem to solution of system of algebraic equations , is equally reliable and precise in the limiting regimes @xmath20 and @xmath21 , as well as in between . in concrete calculations
, we may accommodate and exploit the fact , based on the experimental @xmath22-scattering phases @xcite , that the central components of the in - vacuum @xmath11 interaction nearly compensate each other .
assume _ quite plausibly that this feature is maintained by the _ effective _ @xmath11 interaction within neutron matter .
we furthermore assume with less confidence that the smallness of the parameter characterizing the importance of the tensor force relative to the spin - orbit force is maintained in dense neutron matter .
it must be acknowledged that medium modification may be more significant in the case of the tensor force than it is for the spin - orbit component , especially in the vicinity of the phase transition leading to pion condensation @xcite .
investigation of this issue calls for a concerted effort and will be pursued elsewhere .
the current study of the @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 model is exhaustive in its assembly of the set of solutions whose structural expression involves only real numbers .
the implementation of this program requires no numerical computations ; remarkably , everything can be done analytically . in principle , the same method can be readily applied to the determination of complex solutions . however , this more complicated problem inevitably entails some computer work .
the paper is organized as follows : in sec . 2 ,
the coupled - channel bcs formalism is stated , the separation method is applied to the gap equations , and further analysis establishes the explicit equations of an incisive perturbative treatment of the @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 pairing model . in sec . 3 ,
the parametric degeneracy inherent in the unperturbed @xmath0p@xmath1 problem is lifted , and all real solutions of the perturbed model are found .
section 4 furnishes a convenient and succinct catalog of these solutions .
finally , sec . 5
is devoted to a discussion of potential vulnerabilities of our approach to the @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 problem in neutron matter , as well as informative connections with aspects of triplet pairing in liquid @xmath0he .
fixing the spin and isospin of the pairing state at @xmath23 and @xmath24 ( triplet - triplet ) , we start with the partial - wave decomposition @xmath25 of the @xmath26 gap matrix in terms of the spin - angle matrices @xmath27 and the multi - channel bcs gap equations @xmath28 that embrace the formal problem to be solved @xcite .
the latter equations contain the spin trace @xmath29\ ] ] and the interaction matrix elements @xmath30 appearing in the partial - wave expansion @xmath31 of the block of feynman diagrams irreducible in the particle - particle channel .
the quasiparticle energy @xmath32^{1\over 2 } \label{qen}\end{aligned}\ ] ] is assembled from the single - particle spectrum @xmath33 of the normal fermi liquid , measured relative to the chemical potential @xmath34 and often parametrized with an effective mass @xmath35 , together with the gap components @xmath36 .
we note that @xmath37 takes on an angular dependence by virtue of the spin trace @xmath38 , which in principle greatly complicates the task of solving the system ( [ bc ] ) .
however , this angular dependence only comes into play near the fermi surface ; hence it can be ignored in those integral contributions to the r.h.s . of eq .
( [ bc ] ) in which the region around the fermi surface is suppressed @xcite . consequently , in practice the gap equations approximately decouple in the variables @xmath39 , @xmath40 , and @xmath41 , by virtue of the orthogonality property @xmath42 treatment of the exact , coupled equations ( [ bc ] ) is therefore not as difficult as it appears at first sight ( though still not at all trivial ) . the angle dependence of the function @xmath43 makes it awkward to speak of _ the _ energy gap .
therefore it is conventional to introduce the quantity @xmath44^{1/2 } \label{egap}\ ] ] as a representative measure of the pairing gap in the quasiparticle spectrum , where the overbar signifies an angle average .
as we have argued in the introduction , the spin - orbit component of the neutron - neutron interaction exerts a strong influence on pair formation in dense neutron matter , favoring the condensation of pairs in the @xmath0p@xmath1 state . accepting this widely held view , the simplifying feature just revealed implies that contributions to triplet pairing from nondiagonal terms with @xmath45 or @xmath46 on the r.h.s . of eq .
( 1 ) can be evaluated within perturbation theory .
defining @xmath47 , the relevant coupling parameter is @xmath48 .
the evaluation is carried out in terms of the set of `` principal '' gap amplitudes @xmath49 , with @xmath50 running from @xmath51 to 2 .
a further simplification ensues from time - reversal invariance , which implies that only three of these five quantities can be independent , say @xmath49 with @xmath52 . focusing on the nondiagonal contributions to the r.h.s . of eq .
( 1 ) , we observe that two of them are of leading significance .
the first contains the integral of the product @xmath53 , and the second contains the integral of the product @xmath54 . restricting attention to these contributions , we arrive at the @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 pairing problem , which has been studied both analytically and numerically in earlier work @xcite .
the list of participating states appears to be exhausted upon addition of the @xmath0p@xmath55 and @xmath0p@xmath56 pairing channels , which are deemed to be of lesser importance ; their role will be examined later in this paper .
adopting the @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 pairing model as circumscribed above , the bcs system ( [ bc ] ) takes the explicit form @xmath57 which will now be subjected to analysis and solution . in writing the r.h.s . of this equation ,
we have replaced the quasiparticle energy @xmath58 by + @xmath59^{1/2}$ ] , where @xmath60 is the gap function of the much - studied @xmath0p@xmath1 pairing model in which the tensor coupling between @xmath61 and @xmath22 states is ignored .
the substitution @xmath62 in the integrals on the right is justified by the small relative size of the quantities @xmath63 , @xmath64 , and @xmath65 .
a conspicuous feature of the @xmath0p@xmath1 pairing model is the high parametric degeneracy of the spectrum of its solutions .
this property has been investigated in detail in refs .
@xcite in terms of the two ratios @xmath66 and @xmath67 .
the degeneracy is reflected in the existence of a set of curves @xmath68 in the plane @xmath69 , upon which all the bcs equations of the @xmath0p@xmath1 problem are satisfied . as we shall see , this degeneracy is essentially lifted in the @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 pairing model where @xmath70 . a finite set of points @xmath69 , depending somehow on the @xmath71 value , replaces the set of solution curves @xmath68 of the @xmath0p@xmath1 model .
it is the objective of this article to identify the different solutions of the system ( [ bc1 ] ) and to establish their structure in the realistic case of small @xmath71 .
the analysis is aided by the fact that the parameters @xmath72 and @xmath73 are _ continuous functions _ of the coupling constant @xmath71 .
this property implies that the number of solutions of the @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 pairing problem as well as their structure remains the same no matter how small @xmath71 is .
consequently , implementation of our program reduces to determination of the functions @xmath74 and @xmath75 at @xmath76 , i.e. , @xmath77 and @xmath78 .
it then becomes apparent that the quasiparticle energy @xmath79 may be replaced by @xmath80 on the left - hand - sides of eqs .
( [ bc1 ] ) as well as on the right , since taking into account the difference @xmath79 and @xmath80 within ( [ bc1 ] ) can not , by itself , lift the parametric degeneracy .
this conclusion is confirmed in the numerical calculations we have performed .
the nondiagonal integrals on the r.h.s . of eqs .
( [ bc1 ] ) are rapidly convergent , with the overwhelming contributions coming from momenta adjacent to the fermi surface .
this feature greatly expedites application of the perturbation strategy . for @xmath37 significantly in excess of the energy gap @xmath81 of eq .
( [ egap ] ) , the energies @xmath37 and @xmath82 are coincident to high precision , such that the angular integration in eq .
( [ bc1 ] ) yields a null result .
thus , when treating the nondiagonal contributions it is sufficient to know the minor gap components @xmath83 at the point @xmath84 , which may be efficiently evaluated in terms of the coefficients @xmath85 ( with @xmath52 ) . in this process
, we retain , on the r.h.s . of the last of eqs .
( [ bc1 ] ) , only the dominant contribution containing a large logarithmic factor @xmath86 , where @xmath87 is the fermi energy .
this factor is angle - independent ; therefore the respective angular integral is freely evaluated , giving rise to the simple connection @xmath88 in obtaining this relation we have employed the equality @xmath89 , which holds when one keeps only logarithmic contributions .
analogous linear relations are obtained for the other minor components @xmath90 of the gap function ( notably @xmath91 and @xmath92 ) .
insertion of the result ( [ prop1 ] ) into the first of eqs .
( [ bc1 ] ) leads to the closed system of equations @xmath93
@xmath94\nonumber\\ & \times & { \tanh \left(e_0({\bf p}_1 ) / 2t\right)\over 2 e_0({\bf p}_1 ) } \delta_1^{2m_1}(p_1 ) p^2_1 dp_1d{\bf n}_1 \label{bcf}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for finding the set of three gap functions @xmath95 with @xmath96 .
at this point we invoke the separation method and assert the decomposition @xcite @xmath97 of the gap component into a `` universal '' shape factor @xmath98 that is _ independent _ of the magnetic quantum number @xmath50 and a numerical coefficient @xmath99 that embodies the dependence on @xmath50 .
the function @xmath98 , normalized by @xmath100 , is the solution of a _ linear _ integral equation . as argued in refs .
@xcite , this decomposition holds to high accuracy in the problem domain under consideration .
accordingly , our problem reduces to the determination of the three key coefficients @xmath99 , which obey a set of coupled algebraic equations obtained by setting @xmath84 in eqs .
( [ bcf ] ) . with @xmath101 , 1 , and 2
, these equations read @xmath102 k_0({\bf n})d{\bf
n } \ , , \label{cutr}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath103 , and @xmath104 it should be remarked that the integral ( [ ko ] ) contains a constant coming from regions lying far from the fermi surface , but this constant does not contribute to the angular integration on the r.h.s . of eq .
( [ cutr ] ) . in the present work
, the search for solutions will be confined to those with real coefficients @xmath99 .
the structure of the phases having complex coefficients @xmath99 can be explored and established along the same lines , although the calculations become much more cumbersome . to streamline the task of finding solutions , it is helpful to rewrite eqs .
( [ cutr ] ) in terms of the ratios @xmath105 and @xmath106 .
this step ensures coincidence between the left - hand sides of these equations and their counterparts in the model of pure @xmath0p@xmath1 pairing solved in ref.@xcite .
substitution of the explicit form of @xmath107 into eqs .
( [ cutr ] ) , followed by straightforward algebra , gives a system of three equations @xmath108 & = & \eta v_f r_2\ , , \nonumber \\
\lambda_1 + v_f\left[-(\lambda_2 + 1)j_1+\lambda_1(j_0 + 4j_5 + 2j_3)/4\right ] & = & \eta v_f r_1\ , , \nonumber\\ 1 + v_f\left[-(\lambda_2 j_3+\lambda_1 j_1)/3 + j_5\right ] & = & \eta v_f r_0 \ , , \label{sprl}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for these ratios and the gap value @xmath81 .
here , as before @xcite , @xmath109 with @xmath110 , @xmath111 , @xmath112 , and + @xmath113 and @xmath114 , @xmath115 , and @xmath116 . among the integrals @xmath117 ( @xmath118 ) , only @xmath119 contains a singular principal term going like @xmath120 .
all the other @xmath117 converge close to the fermi surface , where @xmath121^{1/2}$ ] with @xmath122 } \biggl [ 1 + 3\cos^2\theta+\lambda^2_2\sin^2\theta+ { \lambda^2_1\over 2}(1+\cos^2\theta ) \nonumber \\ & \quad&~ -2\lambda_1(1+\lambda_2)\cos\theta\sin\theta\cos\varphi + { 1\over 2}(\lambda^2_1 - 4\lambda_2)\sin^2\theta\cos2\phi \biggr ] \ , .
\label{do}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in terms of the coefficients @xmath123 , the right - hand sides of eqs .
( [ sprl ] ) read @xmath124 where @xmath125 k_0({\bf n})d{\bf
n } \ , \nonumber \\
s_{m1 } & = & \int \left [ s^{2m21}_{31}({\bf n})+s^{2m21}_{13}({\bf n } ) -s^{2m2,-1}_{31}({\bf n})-s^{2m2,-1}_{13}({\bf n } ) \right ] k_0({\bf n})d{\bf n } \ , \nonumber \\
s_{m0 } & = & \int \left [ s^{2m20}_{31}({\bf n})+s^{2m20}_{13}({\bf n})\right ] k_0({\bf n})d{\bf n } \ . \label{intr}\end{aligned}\ ] ]
equations ( [ sprl ] ) have three familiar _ one - component _ solutions with definite magnetic quantum numbers @xmath101 , 1 , and 2 . to uncover the structure and the spectrum of the _ multicomponent _ , mixed-@xmath50 solutions of the perturbed problem , a two - step transformation is applied to the system ( [ sprl ] ) .
the integral @xmath119 introduces the gap value @xmath81 into the description , but it is irrelevant to the phase structure . as a first step , we combine eqs .
( [ sprl ] ) so as to eliminate terms involving @xmath119 from the first pair and , at the same time , reduce the number of the @xmath117 integrals in each equation to two .
the resulting equations are @xmath126 & = & \eta b_1 \ , , \nonumber \\ ( \lambda_2 + 1 ) [ ( \lambda_1 ^ 2 - 4\lambda_2)j_1 + \lambda_1(\lambda_2 + 1)j_3 ] & = & \eta b_2 \ , \label{spp2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath127 two cases are to be distinguished .
the first corresponds to @xmath128 , a particular solution of the pure @xmath0p@xmath1 pairing problem @xcite . in this case , the left - hand sides of eqs .
( [ spp2 ] ) vanish identically , and hence so must their right - hand sides , leading to the single restriction @xmath129 as will be seen , this condition is satisfied at _ any _ @xmath105 .
therefore the particular solution @xmath128 found in the pure @xmath0p@xmath1 problem survives intact when the @xmath0f@xmath1 coupling is switched on .
let us now assume @xmath130 and proceed to the second step .
following ref .
@xcite , we perform a rotation @xmath131 with the objective of removing the integral @xmath41 from eqs .
( [ spp2 ] ) . to this end , the parameter @xmath132 is taken as a root of the quadratic equation @xmath133 the integrals @xmath117 transform according to @xmath134 substitution of the transformed integrals into eqs .
( [ spp2 ] ) yields @xmath135&=&\eta b_1 \ , , \nonumber \\ (
\lambda_2 + 1)[a_1j_0+a_2j_3]&=&-2 \eta b_2 \ , , \label{eqaa}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath136 ( some details of this step are provided in refs .
@xcite . )
the left - hand members of the two equations ( [ eqaa ] ) are seen to be identical .
in fact , the universalities of pure @xmath0p@xmath1 pairing revealed in ref . @xcite stem from this key property .
the solutions of the restricted problem derived from eqs .
( [ eqaa ] ) at @xmath137 fall into two groups composed of states that are degenerate in energy .
this remarkable feature is independent of temperature , density , and details of the in - medium interaction .
there is an upper ( i.e. , higher - energy ) group consisting of states whose angle - dependent order parameters have nodes and a lower group without nodes ( cf . ref .
in addition to the energy degeneracies , the multicomponent pairing solutions , which obey the relation @xmath138 manifest a parametric degeneracy with respect to the coefficient ratios @xmath105 and @xmath106 , as they in general define _ curves _ rather than _ points _ in the @xmath69 plane . among solutions of the @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 pairing model there exist some for which @xmath139 and @xmath140 in eq .
( [ eqaa ] ) vanish simultaneously at a certain set of parameters @xmath105 and @xmath106 satisfying eq .
( [ specc ] ) .
indeed , consider the set of values @xmath141 which determine two - component solutions of the pure @xmath0p@xmath1 pairing problem @xcite . in these cases , it may be observed from eqs .
( [ bi ] ) and ( [ rhsr ] ) that @xmath142 where @xmath143 and @xmath144 are defined by eq .
( [ intr ] ) . as seen from eq .
( [ do ] ) , the quantities @xmath145 and @xmath146 are even functions of @xmath147 @xcite , while both @xmath148 and @xmath149 appear to be linear in @xmath147 ( for details , refer to the appendix ) . as a result , both the matrix elements @xmath143 and @xmath144 vanish identically when the integration over @xmath150 is performed .
hence both of the quantities @xmath139 and @xmath140 turn out to be zero , and we find that eq .
( 31 ) defines a discrete set of valid two - component solutions for the + @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 pairing problem as well as for the pure @xmath0p@xmath1 case .
no other two - component solutions of the former problem have been found in numerical calculations . continuing our exploration ,
suppose that @xmath139 and @xmath140 do not vanish .
equating the right - hand members of eqs .
( [ eqaa ] ) in the @xmath151 limit , we then obtain an _ additional _ relation between the parameters @xmath77 and @xmath78 similar to ( [ rel1 ] ) , namely @xmath152 the quantities @xmath153 being defined by eq .
( [ rhsr ] ) . inserting the explicit expressions for the @xmath153
, this auxiliary condition can be recast as @xmath154 where @xmath155 and the quantities @xmath156 are given in the appendix .
substituting for the @xmath156 , we obtain @xmath157 \nonumber \\ & \quad&~ + 70\left[(\lambda_2 - 3)(\lambda_2 + 3)+2\lambda_1 ^ 2 \right ] xz^3 \nonumber \\ & \quad&~ + 70\left[2\lambda_2(\lambda_2 - 3)-2\lambda_1 ^ 2 \right ] x^3z -96 ( \lambda_2 - 3)(\lambda_2 + 1)xz \ , .
\label{psi12}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the relation ( [ g12 ] ) supplements the spectral condition ( [ specc ] ) . as a direct consequence , the strong parametric degeneracy inherent in pure @xmath0p@xmath1 pairing
is lifted in the case of @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 pairing . with the exception of the straight - line solution @xmath158 noted above
, the solutions of the problem are now represented by a set of _ isolated _ points in the @xmath69 plane .
the system formed by eqs .
( [ specc ] ) and ( [ rela ] ) is amenable to analytic solution .
we begin the search for solutions of eq .
( [ g12 ] ) with the particular solution ( @xmath105 , @xmath128 ) of the pure @xmath0p@xmath1 pairing problem . in this case ,
@xmath159 while , as seen from ( [ do ] ) , the gap function @xmath160 depends only on the single variable @xmath161 : @xmath162 since the integrals @xmath163 both vanish , the integral @xmath164 also vanishes at any @xmath105 .
accordingly , the degenerate solution @xmath128 of the uncoupled @xmath0p@xmath1 pairing problem survives when the @xmath0f@xmath1 channel is involved . in search of other solutions
, we again make use of the transformation ( [ rot ] ) , applying it now to the whole integrand of eq .
( [ g12 ] ) . as found in ref .
@xcite , the gap function @xmath165 reduces to a function of the single variable @xmath166 under such a transformation ; hence the same property holds for the factor @xmath167 in eq .
( [ g12 ] ) , which is defined as a functional of @xmath165 by eq .
( [ ko ] ) . to ascertain how the factor @xmath168 is transformed , let us write down the results of the transformation for simple terms entering this function . in implementing the transformation
we omit odd - power terms @xmath169 and @xmath170 , which do not contribute to the integral ( [ g12 ] ) .
one obtains @xmath171 after inserting these relations into the formula ( [ psi12 ] ) for @xmath168 , simple algebra yields @xmath172\,,\ ] ] where @xmath173 \zeta^3 \nonumber \\ & \quad&~+ 3\lambda_1 ( \lambda_2 - 3 ) \zeta^2 + \left[2\lambda_2(\lambda_2 - 3)-2\lambda_1 ^ 2\right ] \zeta -2\lambda_1\lambda_2 \biggr\ } \,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath174\zeta^3 + 3\lambda_1 ( \lambda_2 - 3 ) \zeta^2 \nonumber \\ & \quad&~- [ ( \lambda_2 - 3)(\lambda_2 + 3)+2\lambda_1 ^ 2 ] \zeta + \lambda_1(\lambda_2 + 3)\biggr\ } \,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath175 \,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath176 ( \zeta-\zeta^3 ) \nonumber\\ & \quad&~+ \left[2\lambda_2(\lambda_2 - 3 ) - 2\lambda_1 ^ 2\right](\zeta^3-\zeta ) \biggr\ } \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] these results can be simplified slightly by employing the connection + @xmath177 , and one finally arrives at @xmath178 \,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath179\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath180 the auxiliary integrals @xmath181 and @xmath182 are helpful in completing the evaluation of @xmath183 by integration over the new variables .
the integrals @xmath184 , @xmath185 , and @xmath186 are related by @xmath187 using these connections , one can easily verify that integration of the combinations @xmath188 and @xmath189 over @xmath169 gives zero .
it follows then that if we make the following replacements @xmath190 in eq .
( [ psi12 ] ) , the new function @xmath191 t^4 \nonumber \\ & \quad&~ - \left [ 6u(\lambda_1,\lambda_2 ) + 12 v(\lambda_1,\lambda_2 ) -4w(\lambda_1,\lambda_2)\right ] t^2 \nonumber \\ & \quad&~ + 3 u(\lambda_1,\lambda_2 ) + 4v(\lambda_1,\lambda_2 ) \bigr\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] will guarantee the same result as given by @xmath168 upon integration of eq .
( [ g12 ] ) .
for this integral to vanish identically , with the function @xmath192 regarded as arbitrary , the coefficients of all powers of @xmath166 in the function @xmath193 must be zero : @xmath194 this system reduces to the chain of equations @xmath195 where @xmath105 and @xmath106 are to satisfy the relation ( [ specc ] ) .
it can be proved that to determine all solutions of this set it is sufficient to solve the equation @xmath196 which has the explicit form @xmath197 and then to verify that the other equalities in ( [ chain ] ) hold for these solutions . to solve eq .
( [ expl ] ) , consider the first branch of eq .
( [ specc ] ) , @xmath198 for which @xmath199 then eq . ( [ expl ] )
is recast to @xmath200 one root of this equation is obviously @xmath201 , which corresponds to @xmath202 .
another pair of roots is given by @xmath203 yielding respectively @xmath204 now consider the second branch of eq .
( [ specc ] ) , @xmath205 with @xmath206 in this case , eq .
( [ expl ] ) becomes @xmath207 its roots are @xmath208 and @xmath209 insertion of these solutions into other ( [ chain ] ) results in a chain of identities , as required .
the set of solutions of the @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 pairing problem revealed by the above analysis is depicted in fig . 1 and cataloged in table 1 .
figure 1 refers to the multicomponent solutions and represents them by their coordinates @xmath69 in the two - dimensional parameter space .
only the right half of the @xmath210 plane is plotted , because the pairing energies are independent of the sign of @xmath105 .
the most important message of this figure is that ( with the exception previously noted ) the solution curves that represent parametrically degenerate solutions of the @xmath0p@xmath1 problem shrink to discrete points as the degeneracy is lifted by the perturbation that admixes the @xmath0f@xmath1 channel . [
cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] the solutions ( which correspond to pairing states and ultimately to superfluid phases ) divide into two categories : those whose order parameters contain nodes and those whose order parameters are nodeless .
it is convenient to identify the nodal states with the symbol @xmath211 and the nodeless states with the symbol @xmath212 .
first there are the three well - known `` one - component '' solutions , belonging to magnetic quantum numbers @xmath213 , @xmath214 , and @xmath101 , respectively .
in addition , we have established the existence of ten multicomponent solutions that mix states with different values of @xmath215 .
these are comprised of five nodeless solutions and five exhibiting nodes .
the five nodeless multicomponent solutions @xmath216 include : * two two - component solutions denoted @xmath217 , which are _ identical _ to the `` particular '' solutions found in the pure @xmath0p@xmath1 case having @xmath218 and @xmath219 . * three three - component solutions associated with the branch ( [ branch1 ] ) of eq .
( [ specc ] ) .
two of these , denoted @xmath220 and @xmath221 , derive respectively from the upper root of the pair ( [ rts1 ] ) and the root @xmath201 . the third , named @xmath222 , derives from the lower root of the pair ( [ rts1 ] ) . the five nodal solutions @xmath223 consist of : * two two - component solutions @xmath224 that are identical to the `` particular '' solutions found in the pure @xmath0p@xmath1 problem having @xmath225 and @xmath226 . * three three - component solutions associated with the branch ( [ branch2 ] ) of eq .
( [ specc ] ) .
the solutions @xmath227 and @xmath228 derive respectively from the lower and upper roots of the pair ( [ rts2 ] ) , while @xmath229 derives from the root @xmath201 . appealing to continuity in the parameter @xmath71
, it may be expected that the general features of the spectrum of solutions delineated by the perturbative analysis will persist even when @xmath71 is not especially small .
in the present article , we have employed the separation method of ref .
@xcite to derive , from the system of nonlinear bcs integral equations for the components @xmath230 of the gap function , a set of nonlinear algebraic equations for the coefficients specifying the angular structure of the superfluid states of interest . based on this stratagem
, we have been able to find all the real solutions of the @xmath231@xmath232 pairing problem in the regime of vanishingly small @xmath71 .
their salient feature is a remarkable independence of the temperature @xmath233 and of any details of the interaction @xmath234 . in principle
, the full collection of complex solutions can also be obtained along the same lines , but the calculations become much more cumbersome . it must be noted that the status of the @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 pairing model , in which contributions from @xmath0p@xmath235p@xmath55 or @xmath0p@xmath235p@xmath56 transitions are assumed to be unimportant , is somewhat vulnerable . this assumption should be a safe one in the low - density regions of a neutron star . however , it may not hold in the denser core region , where ( i ) the cancellation between different contributions to the + p - wave central component of the scattering amplitude becomes questionable and ( ii ) the amplification of the tensor force due to the pion - exchange renormalization @xcite becomes pronounced
. these effects , which increase with density , may overwhelm the spin - orbit component in the effective pairing interaction , whose strength depends only mildly on density .
the @xmath0p@xmath55 pairing channel would then take command and give rise to a superfluid state analogous to the b - state of liquid @xmath0he . in the less challenging situation
where @xmath0p@xmath235p@xmath55 transitions can be described within perturbation theory , their effects reduce to a renormalization of the matrix elements @xmath236 , which acquire an additional term of the form @xmath237 an analogous modification occurs when contributions from @xmath0p@xmath235p@xmath56 transitions are taken into account perturbatively . in short , the introduction of new transitions among two - body states results in the mixing of components having different values of total angular momentum @xmath7 .
this effect depends very strongly on the proximity to the critical temperature @xmath8 .
it is well known that in the immediate vicinity of @xmath8 , all the bcs equations decouple ; hence the various phases that appear may be classified according to the quantum number @xmath7 .
these considerations apply as well to superfluid @xmath0he .
the magnetic dipole interaction between the @xmath0he atoms which is responsible for such a phase separation close to @xmath8 triggers the planar state with @xmath9 @xcite .
this result is unaffected by strong - coupling corrections .
let us now turn to a more detailed analysis of the impact of transitions between pairing states .
we start with the two - component solutions ( [ two ] ) , namely @xmath238 , and recall that in the @xmath231@xmath232 model , both of the quantities @xmath239 and @xmath240 , which behave as @xmath241 , vanish identically .
as will now be argued , this property holds in an extended version that allows for transitions between states with different @xmath7 values . upon setting @xmath218 in the equations ( [ bi ] ) and ( [ rhsr ] ) determining @xmath139 and @xmath140 , there apparently remains a single term containing @xmath242 .
but upon closer inspection of the integrands in ( [ corr ] ) , this term is also found to vanish . according to eq .
( [ ko ] ) , @xmath243 is an even function of @xmath147 independently of @xmath106 , while @xmath244 , the explicit form of which is given in the appendix , is an odd function of @xmath147 .
nullification of the respective integrals therefore occurs upon integration over @xmath150 .
consequently , the equality @xmath245 applies even when the transitions @xmath0p@xmath235p@xmath56 are incorporated into the description .
it follows that the spectrum ( [ two ] ) of the two - component solutions of the @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 pairing model endures upon inclusion of the @xmath0p@xmath235p@xmath55 and @xmath0p@xmath235p@xmath56 transitions .
the opposite situation is encountered when one considers the particular solution of the @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 pairing model defined by the straight line @xmath128 .
the single point @xmath246 of this line does survive as a solution of the pairing problem , but the other points do not . to confirm this assertion
, we first observe that in eq .
( [ rel1 ] ) , contributions from the corrected values of @xmath247 and @xmath248 are proportional to @xmath105 and hence vanish provided @xmath218 ; further , as seen from eq .
( [ rhsr ] ) , the corrected value of @xmath241 is zero , since contributions from the terms of eq .
( [ corr ] ) vanish at @xmath218 . to reveal other viable points on the straight line , one looks for the zeroes of the terms in the l.h.s . of eq
( [ rel1 ] ) introduced by @xmath249 and @xmath250 transitions .
direct calculation shows that the term corresponding to the @xmath250 transition vanishes identically on the line @xmath128 , while that for the @xmath249 transition is proportional to @xmath251 , where the integral @xmath252 is given by eq .
( [ intk ] ) .
it can be checked that this expression has no new zeroes on the straight line @xmath128 in addition to the point @xmath218 .
close inspection reveals that the revised locations of the other solutions found above depend on the matrix elements of the interaction @xmath234 ; if the ratio @xmath253 is small then the shifts from the old positions are also small .
naturally it is of interest to trace the trajectories of solutions as this ratio is varied , thereby exploring the phenomenon of triplet pairing in the continuum of cases from that of dense neutron matter to that of superfluid @xmath0he .
this investigation will be a subject of future work .
our method is to be compared with ginzburg - landau ( gl ) theory , which is generally regarded as the standard technique for mapping the spectrum of the phases of systems with triplet pairing . in the gl method ,
the search for diverse phases is based on the construction of a suitable free energy functional up to terms of fourth ( or even sixth ) power in the gap value @xmath254 .
this approach allows one to simultaneously evaluate the splitting between the different phases and efficiently determine the phase diagram .
another advantage of the gl procedure resides in the facility of including strong - coupling corrections @xcite arising from the dependence of the effective interaction @xmath234 on the gap value , an effect that becomes important close to the critical temperature @xmath8 .
unfortunately , the gl method fails when the temperature @xmath233 is significantly different from @xmath8 .
its application to the phase - spectrum problem makes a sense only if the phase structure of superfluid neutron matter is independent of @xmath233 .
however , special conditions must be met for this to be true in the face of the explicit appearance of the factor @xmath255 in the set of bcs equations , and the explication of these conditions is impossible within the gl approach itself .
our method is free of these shortcomings .
it is equally reliable close to @xmath8 and at @xmath256 .
moreover , the incorporation of strong - coupling corrections reduces to the insertion of new terms in @xmath234 that depend on @xmath254 itself ; if this dependence is appropriately specified , no further hurdles must be overcome to fully elucidate the triplet superfluid phase diagram . in a sequel to this paper , we shall report the findings of a quantitative treatment of the transitions between the phases arising in the @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 model and construct the corresponding superfluid phase diagram of dense neutron matter .
this task requires significant numerical effort beyond the analytic developments of the present work .
0.5 cm * acknowledgements * 0.5 cm this research was supported in part by the u. s. national science foundation under grant no .
phy-0140316 , by the mcdonnell center for the space sciences at washington university , and by grant no .
00 - 15 - 96590 from the russian foundation for basic research ( vak and mvz ) .
jwc also acknowledges support received from fundao luso - americana para o desenvolvimento ( flad ) and from fundao para a cincia e a technologia ( fct ) for his participation in madeira math encounters xxiii at the university of madiera , where some of this work was done .
he thanks professor ludwig streit and his colleagues for the generous hospitality extended by the centro de cincias mathemticas .
to find analytic solutions of the system ( [ bc ] ) , explicit formulas for the set of matrix elements @xmath257 @xmath258 are needed , where the @xmath259 are associated legendre polynomials .
lengthy algebra involving @xmath260- and @xmath261-symbols yields @xmath262 further calculations are conveniently carried out in terms of the harmonic variables @xmath115 , @xmath116 , and @xmath114 , which satisfy @xmath272 .
one has @xmath273 accounting for these relations , one finds @xmath274 we may now evaluate the combinations @xmath275 entering eq .
( [ psi12 ] ) : @xmath276 + 2\lambda_1(16xz-35xz^3 ) \bigr\ } \ , , \label{rr0}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath277 \nonumber \\ & \quad&~ + 7\lambda_1(z^2+x^2 - 10x^2z^2 ) \bigr\ } \ , , \label{rr1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath278\nonumber\\ & \quad&~ + 2\lambda_1(48xz-35xz^3 - 70x^3z ) \bigr\ } \ , .
\label{rr2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] substitution of eq .
( [ sss ] ) into eqs .
( [ rr0])-([rr2 ] ) leads to the results @xmath279 + 2\lambda_1(16xz-35xz^3 ) \bigr\ } \,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath280 \nonumber \\ & \quad&~ + 7\lambda_1(z^2+x^2 - 10x^2z^2 ) \bigr\ } \,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath281\nonumber\\ & \quad&~ + 2\lambda_1 ( 48xz-35xz^3 - 70 x^3z)\bigr\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] 99 d. vollhardt and p. wlfle , _ the superfluid phases of helium 3 _ ( taylor & francis , london , 1990 ) .
r. a. arndt , c. h. oh , i. i. strakovsky , r. l. workman , and f. dohrmann , phys .
c * 56 * ( 1997 ) 3005 .
m. hoffberg , a. e. glassgold , r. w. richardson , m. ruderman , phys .
. lett .
* 24 * ( 1970 ) 775 .
t. takatsuka and r. tamagaki , prog .
* 46 * ( 1971 ) 114 .
t. takatsuka , prog .
* 48 * ( 1972 ) 1517 .
l. amundsen and e. stgaard , nucl .
* a442 * ( 1985 ) 163 . prog .
* 112 * ( 1993 ) 27 .
v. a. khodel , v. v. khodel , and j. w. clark , phys .
* 81 * , ( 1998 ) 3828 .
v. v. khodel , v. a. khodel , and j. w. clark , nucl .
* a679 * ( 2001 ) 827 .
r. b. wiringa , v. g. j. stoks , and r. schiavilla , phys .
c * 51 * ( 1995 ) 38 .
j. m. c. chen , j. w. clark , r. d. dav , and v. a. khodel , nucl .
* a555 * ( 1993 ) 59 .
v. a. khodel , v. v. khodel , and j. w. clark , nucl .
* a598 * ( 1996 ) 390 .
v. a. khodel , phys . at .
* 64 * ( 2001 ) 393 .
v. a. khodel , j. w. clark , and m. v. zverev , phys .
* 87 * ( 2001 ) 031103 .
a. b. migdal , rev .
phys . * 50 * ( 1978 ) 107 .
a. akmal , v. r. pandharipande , and d. g. ravenhall , phys .
c * 58 * ( 1998 ) 1804 .
m. baldo , .
elgary , l. engvik , m. hjorth - jensen , and h .- j .
schulze , phys .
c * 58 * ( 1998 ) 1921 .
r. w. richardson , phys .
d * 5 * ( 1972 ) 1883 .
j. a. sauls and j. w. serene , phys .
d * 17 * ( 1978 ) 1524 .
g. barton and m. a. moore , j. phys .
c : solid state phys .
* 7 * ( 1974 ) 2989 . | the @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 pairing model is generally considered to provide an adequate description of the superfluid states of neutron matter at densities some 2 - 3 times that of saturated symmetrical nuclear matter .
the problem of solving the system of bcs gap equations expressing the @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 model is attacked with the aid of the separation approach .
this method , developed originally for quantitative study of s - wave pairing in the presence of strong short - range repulsions , serves effectively to reduce the coupled , singular , nonlinear bcs integral equations to a set of coupled algebraic equations . for the first time , sufficient precision becomes accessible to resolve small energy splittings between the different pairing states . adopting a perturbative strategy , we are able to identify and characterize the full repertoire of real solutions of the @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 pairing model , in the limiting regime of small tensor - coupling strength . the p
f channel coupling is seen to lift the striking parametric degeneracies revealed by a earlier separation treatment of the pure , uncoupled @xmath0p@xmath1 pairing problem . remarkably , incisive and robust results are obtained solely on the basis of analytic arguments . unlike the traditional ginzburg - landau approach ,
the analysis is not restricted to the immediate vicinity of the critical temperature , but is equally reliable at zero temperature .
interesting connections and contrasts are drawn between triplet pairing in dense neutron matter and triplet pairing in liquid @xmath0he . * @xmath0p@xmath1@xmath0f@xmath1 pairing in dense neutron matter : + the spectrum of solutions * 1 cm m. v. zverev@xmath2 , j. w. clark@xmath3 , and v. a. khodel@xmath4 1 cm _
@xmath2russian research center kurchatov institute , + moscow , 123182 , russia + @xmath3mcdonnell center for the space sciences and department of physics , + washington university , st .
louis , mo 63130 - 4899 _ 0.5 cm ' '' '' 0.5 cm 0.5 cm ' '' '' 0.5 cm |
recent successful measurements of ortho positronium ( ps ) scattering cross sections by h@xmath2 , n@xmath2 , he , ne , ar , c@xmath3h@xmath4 , and c@xmath5h@xmath6 @xcite have spurred renewed theoretical activity in this subject @xcite . of these , the ps - he system is of special interest as it is the simplest system in which there are experimental results for total cross section @xcite and pickoff quenching rate @xcite . the experimental results for partial and differential cross sections for this system should be available soon @xcite .
a complete understanding of this system is necessary before a venture to more complex targets .
the pioneering calculations in this system using the static exchange approximation were performed by barker and bransden @xcite and by fraser and kraidy @xcite .
there have also been r - matrix @xcite , close - coupling ( cc ) @xcite and model - potential @xcite calculations for ps - he scattering .
more recently , there has been successful calculation of ps scattering by h @xcite , he @xcite , ne @xcite , ar @xcite , and h@xmath2 @xcite using a regularized model exchange potential in a coupled - channel formulation . however , there is considerable discrepancy among the different theoretical ps - he cross sections at zero energy which we discuss below .
the static - exchange calculation by sarkar and ghosh @xcite , and by blackwood _
@xcite yielded @xmath7 ( at 0.068 ev ) , and @xmath8 ( at 0 ev ) , respectively , for the elastic cross section .
the inclusion of more states of ps in the cc @xcite and r - matrix @xcite calculations does not change these results substantially .
the pioneering static - exchange calculations by barker and bransden @xcite yielded 13.04 @xmath9 and by fraser @xcite yielded @xmath10 for zero - energy ps - he cross section .
these results are in good agreement with each other . however , the model potential calculation by drachman and houston @xcite yielded @xmath11 and by this author @xcite yielded @xmath12 for the zero - energy ps - he cross section .
so there is considerable discrepancy in the results of different theoretical calculation of low - energy ps - he elastic scattering . on the experimental front
, there have been conflicting results for the low - energy ps - he elastic cross section by nagashima _
@xcite , who measured a cross section of @xmath13 at 0.15 ev , by coleman _
@xcite , who reported @xmath14 at 0 ev , by canter _
@xcite , who found @xmath15 at 0 ev , and by skalsey _
@xcite , who measured @xmath16 at 0.9 ev .
it is unlikely that these findings could be consistent with each other .
the results for the total cross section of ps scattering obtained from the coupled - channel calculation employing the model potential @xcite are in agreement with experiments of refs .
@xcite at low energies . for ps
- he , this model , while agrees @xcite with the experimental total cross sections @xcite in the energy range 0 to 70 ev , reproduces @xcite successfully the experimental pickoff quenching rate @xcite .
all other calculations could not reproduce the general trend of cross sections of ps - he scattering in the energy range 0 to 70 ev and yielded a much too small quenching rate at thermal energies @xcite . however , the very low - energy elastic cross sections of the model - potential calculation @xcite are at variance with the experiments of refs .
@xcite . pointing at the discrepancy above among different theoretical and experimental studies , blackwood _
_ @xcite called for a `` fully fledged calculation '' to resolve the situation . here
we present a variational basis - set calculational scheme for low - energy ps - he scattering in s wave below the lowest ps - excitation threshold at 5.1 ev . using this method
we report numerical result for the scattering length of ps - he using a one parameter uncorrelated he ground - state wave function @xcite .
we present the formulation for the variational basis - set calculation in sec .
ii , the numerical result for ps - he scattering length in sec .
iii and a summary in sec .
because of the existence of three identical fermions ( electrons ) in the ps - he system , one needs to antisymmetrize the full wave function .
the position vectors of the electrons @xmath17 @xmath18 of ps , and @xmath19 and @xmath20 of he @xmath17 and positron ( @xmath21 ) measured with respect to ( w.r.t . ) the massive alpha particle at the origin are shown in fig .
1 . in this configuration
the wave function for elastic scattering in the electronic doublet state of ps - he is taken as @xmath22 where @xmath23 is the incident ps momentum and @xmath24,\end{aligned}\ ] ] represents the doublet wave function of ps - he and where @xmath25 denotes spin up state and @xmath26 down and @xmath27 denotes the ps wave function of electron 1 .
the he ground state wave function @xmath28 and the scattering function @xmath29 are symmetric under the exchange of electrons 2 and 3 .
the spin function @xmath30 is antisymmetric under the same exchange .
the full antisymmetrization operator for the three electrons is @xmath31 where @xmath32 is an operator for exchange in both space and spin of electrons @xmath33 and @xmath34 . as the scattering wave function ( [ wf ] ) above
is already antisymmetrized with respect to electrons 2 and 3 , the operator @xmath35 in the antisymmetrizer is redundant and the relevant antisymmetrizer in this case is @xmath36 .
hence , the fully antisymmetric state @xmath37 of ps - he scattering is given by @xmath38 the projection of the schrdinger equation on the doublet state @xmath39 is @xmath40 with @xmath41 the full ps - he hamiltonian . the incident ps energy @xmath42 ev . using the identities @xmath43 and @xmath44 @xmath45
, we see that the two terms on the right - hand side of eq .
( [ yyt ] ) give equivalent contribution which are combined in eq .
( [ xxt ] ) which is rewritten as @xmath46 hence after the spin projection to the doublet state the effective antisymmetrizer to be used on state ( [ wf ] ) is @xmath47 .
we shall use this antisymmetrizer in the following and supress the spin functions .
the full ps - he hamiltonian @xmath41 can be broken in the convenient form as follows : @xmath48 where @xmath49 includes the full kinetic energy and intracluster interaction of he and ps for the arrangement shown in fig .
1 and @xmath50 is the sum of the intercluster interaction between he and ps in the same configuration : @xmath51.\ ] ] we employ the position vectors @xmath52 , @xmath53 , @xmath54 , @xmath55 , @xmath56 .
the fully antisymmetric state satisfies the lippmann - schwinger equation @xcite @xmath57 where the channel green s function is given by @xmath58 and the incident wave @xmath59 satisfies @xmath60 we are using atomic units ( au ) in which @xmath61 , where @xmath62 ( @xmath63 ) is the electronic charge ( mass ) and @xmath64 the bohr radius .
the properly symmetrized transition matrix for elastic scattering is defined by @xmath65 @xcite .
a basis - set calculational scheme for the transition matrix can be obtained from the following expression @xcite @xmath66 using eq .
( [ 2x ] ) , it can be verified that eq .
( [ 61 ] ) is an identity if exact scattering wave functions @xmath67 are used .
if approximate wave functions are used , expression ( [ 61 ] ) is stationary w.r.t .
small variations of @xmath68 but not of @xmath69 .
this one - sided variational property emerges because of the lack of symmetry of the formulation in the presence of explicit antisymmetrization operator @xmath70 .
however , this variational property can be used to formulate a basis - set calculational scheme with the following trial functions @xcite @xmath71 where the suffix @xmath72 denotes trial and @xmath73 are the basis functions . substituting eq .
( [ 62 ] ) into eq .
( [ 61 ] ) and using this variational property w.r.t .
@xmath74 we obtain @xcite @xmath75 @xmath76g_1{\cal a } _ 1 v_1 | f_n \rangle}.\ ] ] using the variational form ( [ 63 ] ) and definition @xmath77 we obtain the following basis - set calculational scheme for the transition matrix @xmath78 ) and ( [ 4 ] ) are also valid in partial - wave form . in the present s - wave calculation ,
the basis functions are taken in the following form @xmath79 where @xmath80 and @xmath81 are nonlinear variational parameters .
the ground - state wave function of the he atom is taken to be @xmath82 with @xmath83 and @xmath84 @xcite and @xmath85 represent the ps(1s ) wave function . for elastic scattering
the direct born amplitude is zero and the exchange correlation dominates scattering . to be consistent with this , the direct terms in the form factors @xmath86 and @xmath87 are zero with the above choice of correlations in the basis functions via @xmath88 and @xmath81 .
this property follows as the above function is invariant w.r.t . the interchange of @xmath21 and @xmath89 whereas the remaining part of the integrand in the direct terms changes sign under this transformation . in ps
- he elastic scattering the electron 2 of he is the active electron undergoing exchange with the electron 1 of ps whereas the electron 3 of he is a passive spectator . in this calculation
we include in eq .
( [ 8 ] ) correlation between electrons 1 and 2 .
consequently , we deal with integrals in three vector variables @xmath90 and @xmath21 .
if we also include correlation involving electron 3 we shall have to deal with integration in four vector variables , which is beyond the scope of the present study . however , we believe that a meaningful calculation can be performed only with correlation between the active electrons 1 and 2 . hence , to avoid complication we ignore correlation involving electron 3 , which is expected to lead to correction over the present study . in s wave at zero energy , @xmath91 in eq .
( [ 8 ] ) ; also , @xmath92 .
the useful matrix elements of the present approach are explicitly written as @xcite @xmath93 f_n({\bf
r}_2,{\bf r}_3,\rho_1,{\bf s}_1 ) d{\bf r}_2 d{\bf r}_3 d{\rho_1 } d{\bf s}_1,\\ & = & - \frac{1}{2\pi}\int \varphi({\bf r}_1 ) \eta({\rho}_2)\frac{\sin(ps_2)}{ps_2 } [ { \cal v}_1 ] g_n({\bf r}_2,\rho_1,{\bf s}_1 ) d{\bf r}_2 d{\rho_1 } d{\bf s}_1,\\ \label{52 } \langle f_m|{\cal a}_1v_1|\phi^1_p \rangle & = & - \frac{1}{2\pi}\int g_m({\bf r}_1 , \rho_2,{\bf s}_2 ) [ { \cal v}_1 ] \varphi({\bf r}_2)\eta({\rho}_1)\frac{\sin(ps_1)}{ps_1 } d{\bf r}_2 d{\rho_1 } d{\bf s}_1,\\ \label{53 } \langle f_m|{\cal a}_1v_1|f_n\rangle & = & - \frac{1}{4\pi}\int g_m ( { \bf r}_1 , \rho_2,{\bf s}_2 ) [ { \cal v}_1 ] g_n({\bf r}_2 , \rho_1,{\bf s}_1 ) d{\bf r}_2 d{\rho_1 } d{\bf s}_1,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath94 , \quad \quad h(x)= \frac{1}{x}+\frac{\exp(-2\lambda x)}{x } + \lambda \exp(-2\lambda x),\ ] ] @xmath95 where the so called off - shell term @xmath96 has been neglected for numerical simplification in this calculation .
this term is expected to contribute to refinement over the present calculation . in this convention
the on - shell t - matrix element at zero energy is the scattering length : @xmath97 all the matrix elements above can be evaluated by a method presented in ref .
. we describe it in the following for @xmath98 of eq .
( [ 7 ] ) . by a transformation of variables from @xmath99
to @xmath100 with jacobian @xmath101 and separating the radial and angular integrations , the form factor ( [ 7 ] ) is given by @xmath102 d\hat s_1 d\hat s_2 d\hat x , \label{13}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath103 , @xmath104 , @xmath105 and @xmath106 .
recalling that @xmath107 , @xmath108 , @xmath109 , we employ the following expansions of the exponentials in eq .
( [ 13 ] ) @xmath110 @xmath111 @xmath112 @xmath113 @xmath114 where the @xmath115 s are the usual spherical harmonics . using eqs .
( [ 5x ] ) @xmath17 ( [ 9x ] ) in eq .
( [ 13 ] ) we get @xmath116.\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the @xmath117-sum is truncated at @xmath118 .
this procedure avoids complicated angular integrations involving @xmath119 , @xmath120 and @xmath21 .
the matrix element takes a simple form requiring straightforward numerical computation of certain radial integrals only .
the functions @xmath121 , @xmath122 , @xmath123 etc .
are easily calculated using eqs .
( [ 5x ] ) @xmath17 ( [ 9x ] ) : @xmath124 where @xmath125 is the usual legendre polynomial and @xmath126 is the cosine of the angle between @xmath127 and @xmath21 . the integrals ( [ 52 ] ) and ( [ 53 ] ) can be evaluated similarly .
for example @xmath128,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath129 , @xmath130 , @xmath131 , @xmath132 and @xmath133 .
we tested the convergence of the integrals by varying the number of integration points in the @xmath134 , @xmath135 and @xmath136 integrals in eqs .
( [ 8z ] ) and ( [ 8zx ] ) and the @xmath126 integral in eq .
( [ 8xz ] ) .
the @xmath134 integration was relatively easy and 20 gauss - legendre quadrature points appropriately distributed between 0 and 16 were enough for convergence .
in the evaluation of integrals of type ( [ 8xz ] ) 40 gauss - legendre quadrature points were sufficient for adequate convergence .
the convergence in the numerical integration over @xmath135 and @xmath136 was achieved with 300 gauss - legendre quadrature points between 0 and 12 . the maximum value of @xmath117 in the sum in eqs .
( [ 8z ] ) and ( [ 8zx ] ) , @xmath137 , is taken to be 7 which is sufficient for obtaining the convergence with the partial - wave expansions ( [ 5x ] ) @xmath17 ( [ 9x ] ) .
we find that a judicial choice of the parameters in eq .
( [ 8 ] ) is needed for convergence .
the present method does not provide a bound on the result .
consequently , the method could lead to a wrong scattering length if an inappropriate ( incomplete ) basis set is chosen .
after some experimentation we find that for good convergence the nonlinear parameters @xmath138 and @xmath139 should be taken to have both positive and negative values and @xmath140 should have progressively increasing values till about 1.5 .
if no care is taken in choosing the parameters a large number of functions could be necessary for obtaining convergence .
the results reported in this work are obtained with the following parameters for the functions @xmath141 : @xmath142 @xmath143 @xmath144 @xmath145 @xmath146 @xmath147 @xmath148 @xmath149 @xmath150 @xmath151 @xmath152
@xmath153 @xmath154 @xmath155 by employing a suitably chosen set of the parameters we have kept the number of functions to a minimum . .4 cm table i : ps - he scattering length in au for different @xmath137 and @xmath156 . .2 cm & @xmath157 & @xmath158 & @xmath159&@xmath160 & @xmath161 & @xmath162 + 1&2.056 & 1.867&1.782 & 1.721&1.681 & 1.655 & 1.638 + 3&2.418 & @xmath163&28.016 & 4.151&3.061 & 2.839 & 2.933 + 5&@xmath164 & 1.563 & 1.234&1.128&1.135 & 1.168 & 1.190 + 6&0.712 & 0.982&0.782 & 0.637&0.650 & 0.769 & 0.878 + 7&3.372 & 0.983 & 0.792 & 0.694&0.727 & 0.824 & 0.910 + 8&@xmath165 & 1.124 & 0.944&0.877&0.907 & 0.971 & 1.023 + 9&6.283 & 0.976 & 0.832&0.801&0.841 & 0.897 & 0.943 + 10&1.332 & 1.123 & 0.941 & 0.897&0.929 & 0.981 & 1.023 + 11&1.225 & 1.112 & 0.945&0.886&0.909 & 0.963 & 1.011 + 12&0.756 & 1.468 & 0.995&0.918&0.931 & 0.964 & 0.977 + 13&1.229 & 1.197&1.008 & 0.944 & 0.970 & 1.028 & 1.022 + 14 & 1.061 & 1.249 & 1.060&0.980&0.983 & 1.026 & 1.019 + 0.4 cm in table
i we show the convergence pattern of the present calculation w.r.t . the number of partial waves @xmath137 and basis functions @xmath156 used in the calculation .
the convergence is satisfactory considering that we are dealing with a complicated five - body problem .
however , as the present calculation does not produce a bound on the result , the convergence is not monotonic with increasing @xmath156 .
the final result of the present calculation is that for @xmath166 and @xmath162 : @xmath167 au . although it is difficult to provide a quantitative measure of convergence , from the fluctuation of this result for large @xmath156 and @xmath137 we believe the error in our result to be less than 10@xmath168 , so that the final ps - he scattering length is taken as @xmath169 au .
the results for large @xmath156 and @xmath137 reported in table i all lie in this domain .
the maximum number of functions ( @xmath166 ) used in this calculation is also pretty small , compared to those used in different kohn - type variational calculations for electron - hydrogen ( @xmath170 ) @xcite , positron - hydrogen ( @xmath171)@xcite , and positron - helium ( @xmath172 ) @xcite scattering . because of the explicit appearance of the green s function , the present basis - set approach is similar to the schwinger variational method . using the schwinger method ,
convergent results for electron - hydrogen @xcite and positron - hydrogen @xcite scattering have been obtained with a relatively small basis set ( @xmath173 ) .
these suggest a more rapid convergence in these problems with a schwinger - type method .
to summarize , we have formulated a basis - set calculational scheme for s - wave ps - he elastic scattering below the lowest inelastic threshold using a variational expression for the transition matrix .
we illustrate the method numerically by calculating the scattering length in the electronic doublet state : @xmath174 au .
this corresponds to a zero - energy cross section of @xmath175 in reasonable agreement with a model calculation by this author ( @xmath176 ) @xcite and the experiment of skalsey _ et al . _
[ @xmath177 at 0.9 ev ] @xcite .
this calculation as well as our previous studies of ps - he scattering using a model exchange potential @xcite possibly consolidate the experimental result of skalsey _ et al .
_ however , these low - energy ps - he elastic scattering cross sections are in disagreement with other experiments by nagashima _
[ @xmath178 at 0.15 ev ] @xcite , by canter _
( @xmath179 ) @xcite , and by coleman _ et al . _
( @xmath180 ) @xcite , as well as with conventional static - exchange calculations of refs .
@xcite ( @xmath181 ) and a model potential calculation of ref .
@xcite ( @xmath182 ) . as the effective interaction for elastic scattering between ps and he is repulsive in nature , a smaller scattering length as obtained in this study and in refs .
@xcite would imply a weaker effective ps - he interaction .
this would allow the ps atom to come closer to he and would lead @xcite to a large pickoff quenching rate and a large @xmath183 @xmath184 in agreement with experiment @xcite .
the conventional close - coupling @xcite , r - matrix @xcite and static - exchange @xcite models yielded a much too large scattering length corresponding to a stronger repulsion between ps and he .
consequently , these models led to a much too small @xmath183 @xmath185 @xcite in disagreement with experiment @xcite .
this is addressed in detail in ref .
@xcite where we established a correlation between the different scattering lengths and the corresponding @xmath183 .
this correlation suggests that a small ps - he scattering length as in this work is consistent with the large experimental @xmath183 .
although we have used a simple wave function for he in this complex five - body calculation we do not believe that the use of a more refined he wave function would substantially change our findings and conclusions . however , independent calculations and accurate experiments at low energies are welcome for a satisfactory resolution of this controversy .
the work is supported in part by the conselho nacional de desenvolvimento - cientfico e tecnolgico , fundao de amparo pesquisa do estado de so paulo , and financiadora de estudos e projetos of brazil .
p. g. coleman , s. rayner , f. m. jacobsen , m. charlton , and r. n. west , j. phys .
b * 27 * , 981 ( 1994 ) .
a. j. garner , a. zen , and g. laricchia , nucl .
instrum . &
methods phys .
b * 143 * , 155 ( 1998 ) ; p. k. biswas , _ ibid . _ * 171 * , 135 ( 2000 ) .
s. k. adhikari and i. h. sloan , phys .
c * 11 * , 1133 ( 1975 ) ; nucl . phys . * a241 * , 429 ( 1975 ) ; s. k. adhikari , phys . rev .
c * 10 * , 1623 ( 1974 ) ; _ variational principles and the numerical solution of scattering problems _ , ( john - wiley , new york , 1998 ) .
figure number 1 .
different position vectors for the ps - he system w.r.t . the massive alpha particle at the origin in arrangement 1 with electrons 2 and 3 forming he and 1 forming ps .
the arrows on the electrons indicate the orientations of spin @xmath17 up and down . | we present a variational basis - set calculational scheme for elastic scattering of positronium atom by helium atom in s wave and apply it to the calculation of the scattering length .
highly correlated trial functions with appropriate symmetry are used in this calculation .
we report numerical result for the scattering length in atomic unit : @xmath0 .
this corresponds to a zero - energy elastic cross section of @xmath1 .
* pacs number(s ) : 34.90.+q , 36.10.dr * = 1.5 true cm = -.6 true cm |
the discovery of topological insulator @xcite has generated strong activities in the condensed matter and high - energy physics communities .
a prominent property of a topological insulator is the existence of gapless surface states in the form of a dirac hamiltonian with momentum and spin directions locked with each other @xcite .
there have been many interesting theoretical predictions , e.g. @xcite , based on the current - spin coupling of this surface hamiltonian .
if the fermi energy is within the bulk gap , it is easy to expect that some physical quantities or phenomena , such as the landau - level spectrum in a perpendicular field @xcite , transport phenomena involving the surface states @xcite , or the rkky interactions @xcite between spins on the surface , can be evaluated from an effective surface hamiltonian . on the other hand
, one may question if some physical quantities do not just rely on effective surface models @xcite .
the response induced by an external magnetic field is one of the interesting topics with above ambiguity .
generally , this perturbation to a system has an effective zeeman field term , a vector potential term , and further contributions @xcite . in this paper , we focus on the surface current response to a static zeeman or exchange field .
we examine if the surface hamiltonian is sufficient to determine this response .
we also can relate the current @xmath0 to the orbital magnetization @xmath1 by @xmath2 @xcite , where @xmath3 is the position .
orbital magnetization is an interesting quantity .
even when the maximally localized wannier functions are used , this magnetization , besides a term ( local circulation " in @xcite or self - rotation " in @xcite ) which can be interpreted in the same way as rotational motion of electrons in isolated atoms , contains a contribution ( itinerant circulation " in @xcite ) which describes the electronic motion at the edge of the sample . despite the existence of such a current near the sample boundary , it has been shown that the total orbital magnetization is independent of the details at the boundary for an insulator with zero chern number @xcite . with the presence of topological surface states for chern insulators ,
this independence becomes even less obvious .
nevertheless , bianco and resta @xcite provided a real - space expression of orbital magnetization for any two - dimensional insulator with finite chern number , and demonstrated that the formula is independent of boundary conditions for a large sample . on the other hand , chen and
lee @xcite argued that , for a system composed of two insulators with opposite chern numbers , the orbital magnetization should be independent of the details at the boundaries .
they also demonstrated , by numerical calculations , that the orbital magnetization is insensitive to local perturbed potentials near the edge in a chern insulator , and it is also unchanged with magnetic moments at the edges , which gap out the edge states , in spin hall insulator .
therefore , it is interesting to verify if this bulk property still applies for a three - dimensional topological insulator , where there are topologically required surface states with the low energy physics described by two - dimensional dirac fermions . in an earlier work ,
one of us @xcite analyzed the surface current of a topological insulator generated by an in - plane static zeeman field via perturbation theory , employing an effective hamiltonian that is valid only for small bulk momentum @xmath4 .
he showed that there is a cancelation between the contribution from redistribution of particles ( pauli ) and that from virtual transitions ( van - vleck ) between the surface states .
in particular , due to this cancelation , the current response is independent of the chemical potential when it falls within the bulk gap .
furthermore , it is found that the bulk scattering states also provides a significant contribution of opposite sign to that of the surface states . as a result of this cancelation
, the total surface current has no dramatic change when the system changes from a trivial to a topological insulator . in this paper , to account more carefully contributions from states of all momenta , we calculate the current response to a static external zeeman field , employing a lattice model . using exact diagonalization , we examine the contributions from both the surface and the scattering states . to gain more physical insights
, we shall consider in some detail the contributions from states with small momenta parallel to the surface and compare these results with those obtained analytically in @xcite .
the cancelation between the pauli and the van - vleck contributions for the surface states , and the van - vleck contributions from the surface versus the bulk states , will be examined more carefully .
we compare the current responses between topological insulators and normal insulators . for the topological insulator
, we demonstrate the independence of the response on the chemical potential ( so long as it is within the bulk gap ) , even though the occupation of the surface states depends on it .
we shall also show that , due to compensation between the surface and scattering states contributions , the total current response is independent of surface magnetic moments which gaps out the surface states .
we shall also discuss effects of different types of external fields on different surfaces .
we consider anisotropic topological insulators and examine the origin of the anisotropy in the current response .
some technical difficulties we encounter in using the exact diagonalization to evaluate the pauli contributions and the contributions near the dirac point are mentioned .
this paper is outlined as follows . in sec .
[ model ] , we describe the theoretical model being used .
the numerical results for the current in response to an in - plane external field are provided in sec .
[ current - y ] .
we compare the results obtained here with the analytic study of @xcite .
we also study the effects of chemical potential , anisotropy , and surface magnetic moments . in sec .
[ field - type ] , cases with different types of external fields acting on different surfaces are discussed .
[ conclusion ] is the conclusion .
an effective model for a topological insulator , for example bi@xmath5se@xmath6 , at small momentum @xmath4 is of the form @xcite h = m_x+v_zk_z_y - v(k_xs_y - k_ys_x)_z .
[ hb - linear ] here @xmath7 and @xmath8 are the pauli matrices acting on spin and orbital subspaces , respectively .
@xmath9 , @xmath10 and @xmath11 are material parameters . @xmath10 and @xmath11 are set to be positive . the parity operator is taken as @xmath12 . to include the contribution from finite momenta , we extend the hamiltonian eq .
( [ hb - linear ] ) to the following form : h = m(k)_x+v_z(k_z)_y - v((k_x)s_y-(k_y)s_x)_z , [ hb ] where @xmath13 . for convenience , we set the lattice constant ( @xmath14 ) equal to one .
@xmath15 and @xmath16 are also material parameters and limited to be positive .
@xmath17 specifies a trivial phase .
the condition to be in the topological insulator depends on both @xmath9 , @xmath15 and @xmath18 .
we shall focus on the topological non - trivial phase within the following region , -2\{c , c_z}<m<0 .
[ hb - sscondition ] here for simplicity , we have written down a form that is appropriate for a crystal of tetragonal @xmath19 symmetry instead of the @xmath20 symmetry for the real bi@xmath21se@xmath22 family .
we make this simplication because the relevant issues of the current response in this paper is whether the contribution is from the surface states or from the scattering states , hence our main conclusions are independent of the lattice symmetry and the specific parameters of the materials
. we shall start from lattice model to take account of effects of boundaries .
the corresponding real - space hamiltonian for a simple cubic lattice is lll h(r ) & = & ( m+2c+c_z)_ra^+_r_xa_r + & + & _ r [ a^+_r(-_x+is_y_z)a_r+x + & & + a^+_r(-_x - is_x_z)a_r+y + & & + a^+_r(-_x - i_y)a_r+z + h.c . ] , [ hb - lattice ] where @xmath23 and @xmath24 are fermion creation and annihilation operator , respectively , at site r. to calculate the surface current , for example , on the top surface with the normal along @xmath25 direction , we shall apply an open boundary condition to the @xmath26 direction and periodic boundary conditions to the @xmath27 and @xmath28 directions . in this case , we get an effective hamiltonian on an one - dimensional chain along the @xmath26 direction with two good quantum numbers , the in - plane momentum components @xmath29 and @xmath30 .
we get the energy spectra from the exact diagonalization . for the topological trivial phase , the spectra consist simply of scattering states , related to the bulk plane - wave states found in a system without boundaries and occupying the same energy range .
for the topological non - trivial phase , there are also mid - gap surface states .
these midgap states form a dirac cone for the top ( @xmath25 ) surface and another for the bottom ( @xmath31 ) surface .
the energy dispersion of the surface states is given by @xmath32 , which can be related to zero energy states of its corresponding supersymmetric hamiltonian .
@xcite the condition to have surface states is @xmath33 , where @xmath34 . combining the condition @xmath35 for the side surface in @xmath36 direction , where @xmath37 , we shall set @xmath9 within eq .
( [ hb - sscondition ] ) for simplification .
note that low energy dispersion at half - filling is described by massless dirac fermions . for a given in - plane momentum ,
the decay length of the surface state is @xmath38 in the z direction , which reduced to @xmath39 as @xmath40 and @xmath41 . in this paper
, we shall focus on the case with the thickness much larger than @xmath42 so that the coupling between the surface states on different surfaces can be ignored .
when applying an in - plane zeeman field @xmath43 to a system with spin - orbit coupling , one can expect redistribution of particles around the fermi surface because these states have spin - momentum locking and the energy levels become lower or higher as the spin prefers to be along or against the external field .
therefore there is a contribution to the current in the transversal direction of the field .
this is the pauli contribution of the current response .
however , the zeeman field also modifies the wavefunctions .
the modification will trigger off virtual transitions between occupied and empty states @xcite .
this is the van - vleck contribution of the current response . as mentioned in ref .
@xcite , the virtual transition between the surface states is not enough to get a physical answer for the current response to an external field , since the result depends on the momentum cut - off employed .
a proper evaluation of the van - vleck contribution must consider virtual transitions from any occupied state to any empty state .
here we use exact diagonalization to evaluate all the states and the current they carry .
the operator for current density along the @xmath27 direction is given by j_x(z,_)=h(z,_)/k_x , where @xmath44 is the hamiltonian after partial fourier transformation as described below eq .
( [ hb - lattice ] ) .
therefore , for the model eq .
( [ hb ] ) , this is given by @xmath45 .
we obtain the eigenstates with finite external field @xmath43 by exact diagonalization as mentioned before , and evaluate the expectation value of this current operator .
for the external perturbation to create the surface current , we use @xmath46 where @xmath47 is also a material parameter and would be absorbed in the definition for @xmath48 for simplicity .
the most general perturbation by an external zeeman field @xmath43 has two types @xcite , with and without an additional @xmath12 coefficient in the above expression .
we shall see that the term with @xmath12 contributes no current response to @xmath43 on the top surface .
however , it becomes necessary for other cases .
we have more discussion about this point in sec .
[ field - type ] .
we shall consider systems with a uniform @xmath43 at first , and discuss the effects of non - uniform @xmath43 in sec .
[ non - u ] . for a uniform @xmath48 , the current deep in the bulk vanishes , since eq .
( [ hb - lattice ] ) for the bulk has inversion symmetry .
the current flows only near the surface .
the surface ( number ) current on the top surface can then be evaluated by i_top^x=_b.z .
_ zj_x(z , _ ) , [ itop ] where @xmath49 is the momentum parallel to the surface .
the surface current for the bottom surface is from similar formula but the sum @xmath26 is over the bottom half .
although we could have studied general responses , we shall confine ourselves to the linear case where physical pictures can be accessed more easily .
we therefore present our results in the form of a linear response coefficient defined by = i_top^x/ b_y .
[ kappa ] first of all , we shall show that the current response to @xmath50 is independent of the chemical potential , provided that it is within the bulk gap . in this subsection
, the chemical potential independence is verified from numerical results . combining with other studies below
, we shall also give a physical argument why this response is independent of the chemical potential before the end of sec .
[ smm ] . .
( a ) total contributions .
( b ) contributions from the bulk scattering states .
( c ) contributions from the surface states . @xmath51 .
@xmath52 s are the same for different @xmath53 s .
a sharp change of @xmath54 around the fermi energy is corresponding to the pauli contribution .
we limit the chemical potential to be @xmath55 , where @xmath56 in these plots .
the magenta dash line is linear fitting around small k for the case with @xmath57 .
, width=566 ] in order to make the physics more transparent , we shall first compare the results from numerical calculations with those from analytic works @xcite by studying the response of the states with small @xmath49 .
we do this by limiting the domain in eq .
( [ itop ] ) to @xmath58 : _ b.z .
2_0^k_rdk _ , where @xmath59 is the magnitude of the in - plane momenta .
we divide the total current response ( @xmath60 ) into two contributions , one from the surface states ( denoted by @xmath54 ) and one from the bulk bands ( denoted by @xmath52 ) .
the results are shown in fig .
[ kappa - kr ] .
we limit the chemical potential to be @xmath61 , so that the system has no scattering states around the fermi energy .
figure [ kappa - kr](b ) shows that @xmath52 is independent of @xmath53 , though it is finite .
this independence is in accordance with @xcite , where it was concluded that there is no contribution to the current via virtual transitions from the valence band to the surface states and from the surface states to the conduction band .
that is , @xmath62 arises entirely from virtual transitions between the valence and conduction bands .
@xmath54 are shown in fig .
[ kappa - kr](c ) . for @xmath63
, there is no pauli contribution due to the vanishing of density of states , and @xmath64 is entirely due to virtual transitions from occupied to empty surface states .
the magnitude of @xmath64 increases with @xmath65 when more surface states are included , as shown by the dashed line ( our actual numerical calculation gives the yellow dots with some small deviations from this line near small @xmath65 .
this is related to a technical issue which will be discussed in sec .
[ tech ] ) . for finite @xmath53 s ,
@xmath54 becomes zero when @xmath66 is less than the fermi momentum @xmath67 .
this reflects the absence of virtual transitions between the surface states when @xmath68 due to the pauli exclusion principle , since at a given momentum @xmath49 with @xmath69 , both the surface states with @xmath70 are occupied . around @xmath71 ,
the response has a sharp change , which is mainly from redistribution of particles by the external field .
this represents the pauli contribution .
the finite width of the change in @xmath64 in fig .
[ kappa - kr ] is due both to the fact that the fermi surface is not a regular circle and the finite the resolution of the points that we have used .
this pauli contribution complements exactly the missing van - vleck contributions ( compared to @xmath63 ) from surface states with @xmath72 .
@xmath64 becomes independent of @xmath53 when @xmath73 .
@xmath74 is given in fig .
[ kappa - kr](a ) . at these small momenta
, @xmath54 is main contribution to @xmath60 , while @xmath52 is a smaller contribution of opposite sign .
however , as shown in fig .
[ kappa - aniso ] , @xmath52 shows non - monotonic behavior and has comparable amplitude to that of @xmath54 for some cases .
the comparison between fig .
[ kappa - kr ] and fig .
[ kappa - aniso ] for isotropic case also shows that @xmath52 versus @xmath54 differ more ( less ) for increasing ( decreasing ) @xmath75 .
the numerical results for small @xmath66 discussed above is consistent with the analytic results in @xcite .
the current response is insensitive to the occupancy of the surface states , which infers it is a quantity related to the bulk properties .
numerical results also show that @xmath60 for the bottom surface has equal amount but opposite sign to the top surface .
this is related to the charge conservation .
we shall provide an argument in sec .
[ smm ] why this current must be independent of the chemical potential .
, we can consider our system as a collection of two - dimensional systems , one for each @xmath76 ( for a magnetic field along @xmath28 ) . in our case ,
each of these two - dimensional systems has zero chern number ( at finite @xmath48 , as can most easily be seen by considering the surface state spectra ) . on the other hand ,
the derivative of the orbital magnetic moment with respect to the chemical potential is proportional to the chern number for a general two - dimensional system @xcite .
hence this derivative must also vanish for our three - dimensional system . ]
s to @xmath43 on the top surface .
( a ) fixed @xmath15 and varying @xmath16 .
( b ) fixed @xmath16 and varying @xmath15 .
total current responses on the side surface are found to be the same as those on the top surface .
, width=377 ] the total surface current responses are dependent on the material parameters , i.e. @xmath9 , @xmath15 , @xmath16 , @xmath10 and @xmath11 .
we like to show more about this point .
for convenience , we set @xmath77 and @xmath40 .
because of the independence of @xmath60 on the chemical potential , we shall study the systems with @xmath57 . for a system with @xmath78 ,
it means the anisotropy between in - plane and out - of - plane . in fig .
[ kappa - m ] , we show that the system has different current responses and anisotropic effects between topological and normal insulators . in the normal phase , non - zero current from only the scattering states
is slightly modified as changing the material parameters .
as @xmath15 or @xmath16 become larger , the responses are larger .
when @xmath9 changes from positive to negative values , the response continually grows up into the topological phase . instead of weak dependence and monotonic increasing for the current response of normal insulator , it shows different dependence on @xmath15 and @xmath16 in the topological phase .
figure [ kappa - aniso ] shows more details about the anisotropic effects .
note that the external field is set to be so small that the surface states are well separated from the bulk bands for all momenta .
in the normal phase , the current response is only from the scattering states and enhanced for larger @xmath15 or @xmath16 , as shown in the middle row of fig .
[ kappa - aniso ] .
the amplitude of the response is monotonic increasing as a function of @xmath66 for small momenta .
for the topological phase , the dependence is more complicated .
first , we focus on @xmath54 in the bottom row of fig .
[ kappa - aniso ] . before saturation
, the slopes of @xmath54 are the same for all cases , which related to the independence of @xmath15 for the van - vleck contribution .
@xcite we also find that total @xmath54 is weakly changed as modifying @xmath16 , but strongly dependent on @xmath15 .
this might be related to the fact that the size of surface cone becomes smaller as @xmath15 is larger . however , the results of @xmath60 ( top row of fig .
[ kappa - aniso ] ) show that it is still dependent on @xmath16 , which mainly related to @xmath52 ( middle row of fig .
[ kappa - aniso ] ) .
@xmath52 shows an opposite contribution for those momenta with the surface states .
once the surface states merge into bulk bands , @xmath52 is changing in a way similar to that of normal insulator .
we note that @xmath60 increases smoothly as crossing the transition , which infers that @xmath52 compensates the missing of the midgap states at larger momenta .
basically , the momentum region to have surface cones is a bulk property .
in addition , @xmath60 is independent of the chemical potential as @xmath61 .
therefore , the current response to an external field can not be described only from effective surface hamiltonian .
three cases with different material parameters are shown in different columns .
top row is for total current response , middle row for the contribution from scattering states and the bottom for that from surface states .
black full lines are for topological non - trivial phase and red dash lines for trivial phase . , width=377 ] before further discussions , we like to mention some technical problems we encounter when calculating the current by the exact diagonalization , and how they are overcome .
the first is the difficulty to calculate the contribution with momenta near the dirac point as @xmath57 .
due to finite size effect , two surfaces couple to each other and result in a gap , inversely exponentially proportional to the size of the sample , to the ideal dirac cones .
this causes a sudden jump for the current as the energy scale of the external field is larger than this gap . the corresponding current response will reflect size effects and this is already beyond the linear response , which is not the concern in this paper . from a physical point of view
, the density of state approaches zero at the dirac point , and so the pauli contribution should vanish . in the numerical calculations ,
we either subtract out the spurious contributions to the current ( when larger fields were used in the exact diagonalization ) , or slightly shift the momentum to avoid the ambiguity .
another problem is the difficulty to count the pauli contribution for cases with @xmath79 .
finite grid makes the evaluation of redistribution of particles difficult .
we can overcome this problem by applying twist boundary conditions and averaging over different cases .
this method is equivalent to including more lattice momentum points .
the twist boundary condition can also be applied to estimate the contribution around the dirac point .
-resolved current response for the top and side surface .
the current has the same value for different surfaces for each @xmath30 .
@xmath80 , @xmath81 , @xmath82 .
, width=377 ] now , we study the current response on different surfaces
. we shall focus on the @xmath83 surface as a side surface ( _ i.e. _ surface normal pointing from the sample to its outside along @xmath84 ) . the current @xmath85 generated by @xmath43 on this side surface is along the @xmath31 direction and calculated from a formula analogous to eq .
( [ itop ] ) with @xmath27 and @xmath26 interchanged . in this case
, we apply an open boundary condition along the @xmath27 direction and periodic boundary conditions in the @xmath28 and @xmath26 direction . though the calculations in this subsection is done for a film geometry which is different from those in the last ( sec .
[ p - v ] ) , our calculations show that the current response is identical for the same given parameters @xmath15 and @xmath18 ( fig .
[ kappa - m ] ) .
this is expected , since for a sample with finite size in both @xmath27 and @xmath26 directions , we must have a ( number ) current circulating counterclockwise along the @xmath28 direction .
the currents on different surfaces must be equal , which is inevitable due to the charge conservation .
even more we find , as shown in fig .
[ kappa - ky ] , the current is conserved for each @xmath30 .
( @xmath86 is defined as by eq .
( [ kappa ] ) but with the numerator replaced by @xmath87 or @xmath88 , which are in turn given by a formula similar to eq .
( [ itop ] ) except there is no integration over @xmath76 . )
it is easy to get this conclusion for @xmath89 , because the system reduces to a two - dimensional quantum spin - hall system . for finite @xmath76
, one has a tight - binding model for a fictitious two - dimensional system with time - reversal - symmetry breaking terms .
however , the currents must still be the same for different surfaces again due to the charge conservation .
our results give a numerical demonstration that current for each momentum @xmath30 is conserved .
this conclusion applies to the cases with surface magnetic moments , which is discussed further in the next subsection .
figure [ kappa - ky ] also shows that the current response is mainly from small @xmath30 and decays as increasing @xmath90 .
we note that @xmath86 is a smooth function in @xmath76 , even though surface states exist only for @xmath91 below some maximum value ( where the surface states merge into the bulk states ) .
the sum of the surface and scattering states contributions give rise to smooth @xmath76 dependence .
the current responses of the side surface for the cases with different @xmath9 and anisotropy are also the same as those of the top surface for each given @xmath30 .
the resulting @xmath60 s are the same between different surfaces , as mentioned in the caption of fig .
[ kappa - m ] .
however , the dependence of the current response on @xmath66 is different .
numerical results for small momenta show that @xmath60 on the side surface is weakly enhanced by increasing @xmath16 and strongly suppressed by increasing @xmath15 .
this might be explained by the shrink of the momentum region to have the surface states and the change of slopes of the surface cones .
however , this momentum region is related to bulk properties of a topological insulator by material parameters , as discussed in the last subsection .
in addition , anisotropic effects of the current response to @xmath92 on side surfaces are not simply explained by the modification of the surface cones .
we have more discussion about this point in sec .
[ field - type ] .
even with the independence of the chemical potential , one may question if the current changes dramatically when the surface states are gapped out , for example in the presence of an extra term in the hamiltonian proportional to @xmath93 , representing local moments , at the top surface . for clearer explanation , we shall focus on the isotropic case ( @xmath94 ) and
study the current response to @xmath43 on the top surface .
the responses to other fields on different surfaces can be found by a mapping discussed in the next section . before calculation
, it is helpful to apply some simple arguments to find out what we should expect . consider surface magnetic moments put just on the top layer . if the size of the system is large enough in the @xmath26 direction , the surface current for the bottom would not be affected .
our numerical study has verified this point for all considered cases of this paper . using charge conservation ,
the current at the top surface can not change either .
( this point may be clearer if one considers a sample with finite ( but both large ) sizes in both the x and z directions , since , as mentioned in the last section , we must have a circulating current ) .
hence , the current at the top surface can not be affected by the surface magnetic moment , even though a gap may appear .
( the same conclusion can be reached by consider the currents at the side surfaces . )
we shall verify this below by explicit calculations . .
( a ) the robustness of the current to local magnetic moments for each @xmath30 . the contributions from the scattering and the surface states are shown in ( b ) and ( c ) .
same symbols are used for all panels .
the blue dash line in ( c ) is linear fitting around small @xmath95 for the case without surface magnetic moment and with @xmath57 .
, width=566 ] to include local magnetic moments at the surface , we add an additional term h_m=*h_1(*r)*s to the hamiltonian , where @xmath97 is an position dependent exchange field .
( this is not the most general form ( see sec .
[ field - type ] below ) but is sufficient for our considerations here ) .
we first consider an @xmath97 to produce a gap on the surface states .
for this we use @xmath98 with @xmath99 uniform and finite only on the top layer of our system .
( the gap generated is however smaller than @xmath100 by a factor from the overlap between the surface state wavefunction with the first layer ) .
numerical results of the current responses for various values of @xmath99 are shown in fig .
[ kappa - mi ] .
figure [ kappa - mi](a ) shows that the total current response is unchanged : in fact , the @xmath30-resolved current is also independent of @xmath99 .
( note that while fig .
[ kappa - ky ] presents the current conservation between different surfaces , fig .
[ kappa - mi](a ) shows the robustness of the current to surface magnetic moments . ) * * * the above however does not imply that the current contribution from each in - plane momentum unaffected by @xmath99 .
we show the @xmath66 dependence at small momenta in fig .
[ kappa - mi](b - c ) .
first , let us focus on @xmath101 . with finite @xmath99 ,
@xmath64 is suppressed .
this can be easily understood by considering the modifications to the surface state spectrum when a gap is opened up . on the other hand ,
@xmath62 also decreases , and in fact can even change sign at small @xmath65 .
these changes compensate each other exactly when integrated over all momenta , giving a response independent of @xmath99 .
figure [ kappa - mi ] also contains a comparison between @xmath101 and @xmath102 at a finite @xmath99 . as in sec .
[ p - v ] , @xmath64 vanishes exactly for @xmath65 below the fermi momentum , implying once more that the van vleck contributions involving virtual transitions between the surface and bulk bands vanish even in the present case , even though the boundary condition at the surface becomes different from that of sec .
[ p - v ] since now there is a finite @xmath99 at the surface .
when @xmath65 is increased beyond the fermi momentum , the pauli contribution again compensates exactly the missing surface - to - surface van vleck contribution , as in sec .
[ p - v ] . from the physical argument given in the beginning of this subsection ( or the direct evaluations above ) , the independence of the current on the chemical potential in sec .
[ p - v ] is then no surprise .
consider again a given sample with magnetic moments on the top surface , gapping out the surface states .
the current at the top surface should be independent of @xmath53 if @xmath53 is within the created gap . by charge conservation , the same must then be true also for the `` pristine '' bottom surface .
one can consider the large @xmath99 limit where the surface states disappear entirely for the top surface and conclude that the total current at the bottom ( and hence for all surfaces ) must also be independent of @xmath53 .
the same arguments can be applied to the side surfaces when considering a sample with finite ( but large ) extent in both @xmath27 and @xmath26 directions . in this case
we must have circulating current of equal magnitudes near both the @xmath27 and @xmath26 surfaces when the magnetic field is along the y direction at all @xmath53 s within the gap and independent of whether the surface states on one particular surface is destroyed or not . .
( a ) total current response for the system with external field for all sites ( black full circle ) , for all except the top layers ( green cross ) , and just for the top layers ( red empty diamond ) . the corresponding contributions from the scattering and the surface states for momenta up to @xmath65 are shown in ( b ) and ( c ) , respectively .
( d ) position dependence of current response with different mass to @xmath43 just on the top layer .
@xmath96 for ( a)-(c ) . ,
width=566 ] this robustness of the current response to a time - reversal - broken term also applies to other situations .
we shall discuss two special cases , both related to distributed external fields .
the first is an artificial case with an external field on all sites except the top layer .
the results are shown in fig .
[ kappa - mi2](a - c ) by lines with crosses .
this case can also be considered a system with surface magnetic moment with @xmath103 finite only on the top layer and along the @xmath104 direction with an magnitude equal to that of the external zeeman field @xmath48 .
therefore , it is instructive to compare this case with sec .
[ smm ] . comparing fig .
[ kappa - mi2](b - c ) with fig .
[ kappa - mi](b - c ) , we indeed find similar dependence of the responses on @xmath66 . at small @xmath65
, @xmath64 is suppressed , but @xmath62 also decreases , which in fact can also change sign near small @xmath65 .
their sum @xmath60 at small @xmath65 is smaller , but the loss at small momenta is complemented by the contribution from large momenta , which mainly from the scattering states . after summing over all states , the total current is not affected as shown in fig .
[ kappa - mi2](a ) .
the second case is a system with @xmath43 just on the top surface . because one layer is very small as comparing to the size of the bulk
, we can expect no total surface current ( since the current at the bottom surface is necessarily zero ) .
indeed as shown in fig .
[ kappa - mi2](a ) , we obtain vanished @xmath60 after summing over all states .
however , when @xmath105 is summed only up to a finite range @xmath65 , it is in general finite .
@xmath64 at finite @xmath65 is similar to the uniform @xmath48 case , being always negative but smaller .
it is somewhat difficult to separate clearly the surface versus bulk states when @xmath65 becomes comparable to the @xmath105 where these states merge into each other , but our calculation shows that @xmath64 seems to vanish when summing over all surface states .
we understand this as follows .
we note that at the parallel momentum where a surface merges with the bulk states , the decaying length of the surface state diverges , and therefore a finite localized magnetic moment at the surface will result only in a vanishing perturbation .
the vanishing of the current from the surface states can then be understood as due to the fact that now the surface state spectra simply shifts in momentum space with their end points fixed .
( note that this shift in momentum is therefore @xmath4 dependent and is different from that from a uniform gauge field ) . from fig .
[ kappa - mi2 ] , @xmath62 within @xmath65 is also in general finite . in particular
, it acquires a negative value near the momentum where the surface states merge into the bulk , though the total @xmath60 integrated over all momenta again vanishes .
since we are evaluating the linear response , we can see from fig .
[ kappa - mi2 ] that the response for a uniform @xmath48 is just the sum of the responses for the two non - uniform @xmath48 cases discussed above , as it should be .
we have also checked that , for a finite @xmath53 , there is no response for @xmath65 smaller than the fermi momentum ( as in fig .
[ kappa - kr](c ) and [ kappa - mi](c ) ) , suggesting again that there are no van - vleck contributions due to surface to bulk virtual transitions for our non - uniform @xmath48 s .
figure [ kappa - mi2](d ) shows the position dependence of the total current response for the case where @xmath48 is localized at the surface . there is a sharp ( lattice - scale ) feature near the surface
this is followed by a slower feature of opposite sign decaying into the bulk , with an @xmath9-dependent decaying length ( around @xmath106 for @xmath56 and @xmath107 for @xmath108 . )
this pattern then is roughly a current loop around the localized external field @xmath48 . for a thick sample ,
there is thus no net current on the bottom surface .
when comparing the current responses to external fields with different directions , we should take more care about the form of the perturbation hamiltonian .
actually , eq . ( [ hb ] ) or eq .
( [ hb - lattice ] ) already implied the anisotropy of topological insulator between the @xmath26 and in - plane directions .
for this system , indeed the current response to @xmath43 is from @xmath50 .
if the applied field is along the @xmath26 direction , however , the current response of a side surface is not simply from @xmath109 with some coefficient . in this section
, we shall have more discussion on this point . we can limit possible terms in the hamiltonian by symmetry arguments .
since an external magnetic field is a pseudo - vector which also breaks the time - reversal symmetry , the allowed terms in the hamiltonian describing the effects of a magnetic field can be @xcite h_b = -*b_1**s - * b_2**s_x , [ h - mi ] where @xmath110 and @xmath111 are external magnetic fields scaled with appropriate directional dependent @xmath112-factors .
we shall call the term in eq .
( [ h - mi ] ) without parity operator @xmath113 and the other @xmath114 . * * * * * * .[table ] current response of a topological insulator and reaction of its surface states to different types of external field on different surfaces .
sh@xmath115 : surface cone shift in @xmath116 direction .
sl : slope reduced for all momentum .
sl@xmath117 : slope reduced except along @xmath118 .
sl@xmath119 : slope reduced except along @xmath89 . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ] our numerical calculations show that , for the top surface , current can be generated from @xmath120 and @xmath121 by @xmath122 and @xmath123 , respectively . on the other hand ,
non - zero current response on the x - side surfaces is from @xmath121 and @xmath124 by @xmath123 and @xmath125 , respectively .
these conclusions agreed with those of @xcite which analyzes only states with small momenta . the responses might be possibly be understood by considering the reaction of the surface states to the external fields , which is summarized in table [ table ] .
therefore , it might be reasonable to expect that the system has a current response as the surface cone is shifted by external fields .
for example , the component @xmath123 shifts the surface cone in @xmath126 direction and creates a contribution of the number current in @xmath83 direction if the perturbed hamiltonian is @xmath50 .
also , @xmath123 shifts the surface cone in @xmath127 direction for @xmath36 surface .
therefore @xmath50 will create a surface current along @xmath25 direction on the x - side surface , as discussed before .
those denoted by gap or reduced slope have no current response .
for example , another possible term from @xmath43 is @xmath128 , which excite no current on both the top and side surfaces . even though for the total physical response one must consider both the surface and bulk states , it turns out that the above criteria can decide whether there is or is not a finite response to a particular external perturbation . as a comparison , we like to demonstrate anisotropic effects of the current responses to @xmath92 on side surfaces .
the maximum momentum region to have surface states within the constraint eq .
( [ hb - sscondition ] ) is similar to an ellipse as @xmath78 .
the radius of this region in the @xmath129 direction is set to be @xmath130 and that in the @xmath30 direction @xmath131 . from our numerical calculation
, we find that , for systems with fixed @xmath15 , @xmath130 is shorter while @xmath16 is larger .
for systems with fixed @xmath16 , increasing @xmath15 will decrease @xmath131 .
the parameter change helps to understand the current response of systems with these material parameters . the first and third columns of fig .
[ kappa - aniso - side ] show that @xmath60 decreases as @xmath16 becomes larger .
this might be explained by the shrink of @xmath130 , which supposed to reduce @xmath54 .
@xmath54 no longer contributes to @xmath60 when @xmath66 is larger than some critical value , but the curve of @xmath60 smoothly increases as crossing the transition .
@xmath52 compensates the loss in the region without those midgap states . on the other hand , the first two columns of fig .
[ kappa - aniso - side ] show that @xmath60 becomes larger when @xmath15 is larger .
one might relate this increasing to sharper slope of the surface cone in @xmath30 .
however , the shrink of @xmath131 would make the surface states have less region to contribute @xmath54 .
the same reduction occurs for @xmath52 .
after summation , @xmath60 still smoothly increases as including more contribution from larger momenta .
the current responses on a side surface can not be simply explained from the study of the surface states . besides
, the momentum region to have surface states is determined by the material parameters , which are used to describe the bulk properties .
it is necessary to consider both the surface and the scattering states in current responses . on a side surface .
the arrangement of these plots is the same as that illustrated in fig .
[ kappa - aniso ] except the external field is along the @xmath26 direction .
, width=377 ]
in conclusion , we studied the current response of a topological insulator to a static zeeman field using an exact diagonalization to a lattice model .
the effects of current responses to different types of external fields on different surfaces are discussed .
we find no change in the surface current by changing the occupancy of the surface states or applying a time - reversal symmetry - breaking terms near the boundary .
these only affect the individual contributions to the current , such as pauli versus van - vleck , or surface versus bulk states , but not the total .
this suggests that there is a kind of sum - rule for this response , though we have not yet been able to derive it analytically .
our results support the conclusion that magnetization is a bulk property , independent of the details at the boundaries of the sample , even for topological insulators .
this work is supported by the ministry of science and education of taiwan under grant number most- 101 - 2112-m-001 -021 -my3 . | we study the magnetoelectric coupling at the surface of a topological insulator .
we are in particular interested in the surface current induced by a static zeeman / exchange field .
this surface current can be related to the orbital magnetization of the system . for an insulator with zero chern number ,
the orbital magnetization is independent of the details at the boundary . with the appearance of surface states in the topological insulator , it is not immediately obvious if the response is not affected by the conditions at the surface .
we investigate this question using exact diagonalization to a lattice model . by applying a time - reversal symmetry - breaking term near the boundary , no matter
if the surface states are gapped out , we still find no change in the surface current .
this arises from cancelations between pauli and van - vleck contributions between surface and bulk scattering states .
we also show that the surface current response is independent of the chemical potential when it is within the bulk gap .
our results are consistent with the claim that orbital magnetization is a bulk property .
_ keywords _ : topological insulator , current response , orbital magnetization |
embedding a quantum well ( qw ) inside a semiconductor microcavity results in the formation of the so - called microcavity polaritons ; a coherent superpositon of the cavity mode and an exciton , when the cavity is tuned to an excitonic transition in the qw . over the last 15 years
, these bosonic quasiparticles were shown to have many nice properties for studying quantum optics and many - body physics in integrated photonic structures .
for example , their photonic component allows for a direct observation of the polaritons and a large coherence length , while the matter component is responsible for polariton interactions .
bose - einstein condensation of polaritons and their superfluid properties have been investigated in detail both experimentally and theoretically @xcite .
the presence of charges inside the quantum well that could interact with the polaritons , has been put aside until recently . from the theoretical side ,
the mixed electronic - polaritonic system was proposed to reach superconductivity at higher temperatures , possibly even room temperature , thanks to a strongly attractive electron - electron interaction mediated by the polaritons @xcite .
a pioneering experiment with high density modulation doping was performed by gabbay _
@xcite , where it is shown that strong light - matter coupling is possible , even though neither an excitonic nor a trionic state could be resolved .
recently , in the experiments by smolka et al .
@xcite polariton formation was observed over a range of electron densities , both with and without a magnetic field . for what concerns the effect of the electron gas on the polaritons , various contributions both from the experimental @xcite and theoretical @xcite side
have been made .
those works considered the electron - polariton scattering physics , but it was assumed that the polariton quasiparticle itself was not affected by the electron gas .
the optical excitation of an electron gas ( metal or doped semiconductor ) is an important problem in many - body physics that was introduced by mahan @xcite and to which nozires , de dominicis @xcite and anderson @xcite made seminal contributions .
nowadays , the fermi edge singularity is still an active topic of research that has recently attracted the attention of the community working on ultracold atomic gases @xcite .
the role of the electrons on the properties of the exciton - polariton itself for a highly doped quantum well has been investigated in refs . .
in our previous work@xcite , we have discussed the single particle exciton - polariton properties , properly taking into account the many - body physics involving the anderson orthogonality catastrophe ( aoc ) and fermi edge singularity ( fes ) .
unfortunately , an exact evaluation of the optical response was only possible for negligible electron - electron interactions . in the low density regime ,
where trion correlations dominate , this makes it a poor approximation . in the case of a low density electron gas , trion - polaritons
have been observed and discussed theoretically @xcite .
a theoretical model for trion - polaritons , that takes into account the aoc and fes , is however still missing .
it is the purpose of this paper to fill this gap .
we will focus on the linear properties of trion - polaritons , deferring the study of polariton - polariton interactions to a future work .
this paper is organized as follows : in section [ sec : one ] the notations used in this article are introduced and we set up our model and show how to calculate the optical response of the two - dimensional electron gas .
section [ sec : tp ] presents some linear polariton properties such as the polariton energies , lineshapes . in the same section
we calculate the spatial distribution of electrons in the lower polariton state .
the last section [ conclusionandoutlook ] gives a summary and outlook .
the system under consideration is a quantum well containing a non - interacting two dimensional electron gas ( 2deg ) , placed inside a planar microcavity . for the sake of simplicity
we consider a spin polarized 2deg ( the generalization of our results for an unpolarized electron gas is straightforward ) .
when a photon impinges onto an empty qw , an interband electron - hole pair can be created and forms a bound electron - hole pair , the exciton . in the presence of a 2deg ,
the exciton will interact with the electrons , with the possibility of forming a trionic bound state , where the valence band hole is bound to two electrons .
typically , the trion binding energy is much weaker than the exciton binding energy .
therefore , the trion can be approximated as an electron that is bound to an exciton through an effective electron - exciton potential @xmath0 .
this approximation reduces the trion physics from a three - body to a two - body problem . within this approximation
, it becomes feasible to treat the interaction of the exciton with all the electrons in the 2deg .
provided that the electron - electron interactions can be neglected and the exciton mass tends to infinity , the formalism of combescot and nozires @xcite yields an exact description of the optical response properties .
we will restrict in this paper to these approximations and leave the inclusion of electron - electron interactions for future work .
we thus start from the following hamiltonian : @xmath1 with @xmath2 here , @xmath3 describes the matter degrees of freedom of the quantum well . because the exciton ( created by @xmath4 ) is assumed to have infinite mass , it is sufficient to consider a single exciton mode that is localized in real space with energy @xmath5 .
the kinetic energy for the electrons , created with @xmath6 , is given by @xmath7 ( units are @xmath8 ) .
the last term in @xmath3 describes the electron scattering by the exciton .
in particular we will use an attractive exciton - electron potential @xmath9 , for which it is known that in two dimensions this always results in the presence of a bound state with energy @xmath10 .
furthermore , we restrict ourselves to the spheric symmetric @xmath11 angular momentum channel . the coupling of the qw to the photon field is treated semiclassically as @xmath12 here @xmath13 is the coupling constant between the optical mode in the cavity and the exciton center - off - mass at zero in - plane momentum @xmath14 .
the amplitude @xmath15 represents a coherent drive by an external laser field . in order to calculate the optical response function of the qw , we start from the free 2deg and treat the light - matter coupling term as a perturbation to the system .
the optical response @xmath16 of the qw is then given by linear response theory as @xcite @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the time - ordering operator , and @xmath19 is the unperturbed fermi sea ( a slater determinant built with plane waves @xmath20 ) . using the heisenberg picture for the time dependence of the operators we can write it as @xmath21 the second line expresses that the time evolution of the electrons after the injection of the exciton is governed by the modified hamiltonian @xmath22 , for which @xmath19 is no longer an eigenstate .
the overlap with the unperturbed fermi sea will therefore become time - dependent , and in particular for long times it will decay as a powerlaw .
the value @xmath23 is the ground state energy of @xmath19 .
the expectation value can be straightforwardly computed numerically@xcite as @xmath24 .
\label{eq : gtdet}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath25 is the fermi - dirac distribution .
the matrix @xmath26 is given by @xmath27 where one has @xmath28 . finally the 2deg absorption is given by @xmath29
it has been shown@xcite that in the limit @xmath30 the function @xmath16 is given as a sum of two powerlaws , @xmath31 with @xmath32 some constants .
the powerlaw decay is a manifestation of the so - called anderson orthogonality catastrophe@xcite which states that the ground state of the system with and without the scattering potential ( due to the exciton ) are orthogonal to each other .
the powers @xmath33 can be related to the scattering phase shift at the fermi level of the conduction electrons scattering off the potential : @xmath34 the phase shifts satisfy @xmath35 $ ] , making @xmath36 $ ] .
furthermore , since the laplace transform of the separate terms in is given by @xmath37=\frac{|c|\gamma(1-\alpha)e^{-i\frac{\pi\alpha}{2}}}{(\omega-\omega+i\eta^+)^{1-\alpha } } , \label{eq : splaplace}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath38 the gamma function , it follows that the absorption spectrum contains two singularities , the so - called fermi edge singularities .
the positions of the singularities in frequency domain ( ` thresholds ' ) is given by@xcite @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the energy difference between the system s ground state before and after the quench . here
, the single particle energies @xmath41 are obtained by diagonalizing @xmath42 .
let us now be more specific about the choice for the exciton - electron potential : in the remaining part of this paper we work with an attractive yukawa potential @xmath43 with @xmath44 numerical constants .
the thresholds and the corresponding powerlaw exponents in real time domain for the above choice of @xmath45 are depicted in fig .
[ fig : exponentsthresholds ] as a function of fermi energy .
because the scattering potential is attractive , the spectrum @xmath46 contains a bound state with energy @xmath10 , corresponding to the state in which an electron is bound to the exciton , i.e. a trion .
the trion binding energy is thus given by the amount of energy needed to dissociate the trion into an exciton and an electron . in the following
, the binding energy will be used as an energy scale . at zero density
, the lowest threshold corresponds to the trion and the upper threshold is given by the exciton energy . for sake of simplicity , in the following we will call the lowest threshold the trion , and the highest threshold the exciton for all densities .
still at zero density , we find that the powerlaw exponent in time domain corresponding to the trion ( @xmath47 ) is exactly one , while the exciton exponent @xmath48 is zero . from eq .
we then immediately see that the exciton corresponds to a delta function in absorption while the trion is completely flat in frequency domain . for increasing electron density , the trion exponent gets larger than the excitonic exponent , the crossover being for the fermi energy comparable to the trion binding energy .
the latter means that the trion tends to get more delta - function like in absorption for increasing 2deg density , while the exciton gets flattened out .
this behaviour has been numerically verified to hold for several short - range potentials .
in particular , we also checked it for the more realistic @xmath49 exciton - electron potential .
the two thresholds are getting more separated for increasing fermi energy .
this would correspond to an increase of the trion binding energy for higher electron densities .
this seems unphysical and should be attributed to the neglect of electron - electron interactions . as a function of fermi energy .
b ) powerlaw exponents @xmath33 as a function of fermi energy .
both exponents are seen to be smaller than one , corresponding to two singularities in the absorption spectrum . for fermi energies larger or comparable to the trion binding energy , the trion exponent ( blue open circles )
starts getting smaller than the exciton exponent ( red squares ) . ]
note that , in order for our model ( the exciton as elementary boson ) to be valid we must avoid very high electron densities .
specifically , we are restricted to densities satisfying @xmath50 .
this means that the electron interparticle distance should always be larger than the exciton bohr radius . only in this situation
it is not possible for the electrons to see the internal structure of the exciton .
typically , in gaas qw s it holds that @xmath51 , so in order for our model to stay valid we must have approximately @xmath52 .
this explains the horizontal range on the figure [ fig : exponentsthresholds ] . for the yukawa potential mentioned earlier ,
we have numerically computed the response function @xmath16 in the time domain up to times for which the asymptotic regime , eq . , sets in . in figs .
[ fig : tsandls](a - c ) the modulus of the response function is plotted for increasing 2deg density from top to bottom .
note the double logaritmic scale to evidence the powerlaw nature of the decay .
solid lines correspond to the numerical simulation while the dashed ( dotted ) line correponds to the powerlaw decay using the trion ( exciton ) exponent from fig .
[ fig : exponentsthresholds](b ) . to obtain the absorption
, we numerically performed the laplace transform of the time series using an appropriate damping term to avoid manifestations of the gibbs phenomenon . on a double logaritmic scale for increasing fermi energy .
the dashed ( dotted ) lines depict the powerlaw decay using the exponents @xmath47 ( @xmath48 ) from eq . .
( d - f ) absorption spectra obtained after performing the laplace transform of the time series .
spectral weight is shifted from the exciton singularity at low densities towards the trion threshold at higher densities . ]
the corresponding absorption spectra are seen in figs .
[ fig : tsandls](d - f ) .
all spectra are shifted with respect to the trion threshold @xmath53 .
the spectral lines are seen to have an asymmetric lineshape with a powerlaw tail at the high frequency side of the threshold .
this is of course due to the powerlaw exponent in eq . .
only for the real time exponent being exactly zero , the lineshape becomes a symmetric lorentzian . in theory
, the absorption on the left hand side of the trion singularity should be identically zero .
due to the numerical damping , this sudden step is slightly rounded .
furthermore , for increasing fermi energy we see that the distance between the two thresholds indeed increases , as mentioned before .
the trion is seen to get narrower again for higher densities ( the corresponding real time exponent goes to zero for high densities , see fig .
[ fig : exponentsthresholds]b ) .
experimentally many effects such as electron - electron interactions , finite temperature , will nevertheless broaden the spectral line . to quantify which of both singularities is most dominant in the spectrum
, we define the oscillator strength as the integral of the absorption spectrum around each singularity .
the boundary between the two thresholds is taken as the frequency where the absorption has its minimal value in between .
since from the definition we have @xmath54 , each oscillator strength is less than 1 . fig . [
fig : os ] shows the oscillator strength as a function of fermi energy . at zero density
all spectral weight is in the exciton ( red squares ) , that is a delta function .
this is indeed the only transition that is possible in our model , since at least one electron is needed to form a trion . for increasing fermi energy ,
oscillator strength is transferred from the exciton towards the trion ( blue circles ) .
both singularities have equal oscillator strength when the fermi energy is comparable to the trion binding energy .
for very high 2deg densities most oscillator is gathered in the trion .
this is consistent with the spectral lines in figs .
[ fig : tsandls](d - f ) where the exciton is seen to be dominant at low densities , while the trion starts dominating for high electron densities@xcite . because of the simple form of eq .
, it is straightforward to investigate finite temperature effects on the spectral lineshapes . in the fig .
[ fig : lsfinitetemp]a we show the time evolution of @xmath16 for a fixed fermi energy @xmath55 , and for several temperatures @xmath56 . for finite temperature ,
the time series are always seen to coincide with the zero temperature result for short times .
however , deviations from the @xmath57 start showing up at the time proportional to the inverse temperature , i.e. @xmath58 . for long times the finite temperature series decay exponentially to zero ( not visible on the double logaritmic plot ) .
figure [ fig : lsfinitetemp]b depicts the corresponding absorption spectra . for @xmath57
we have the same lineshape as in fig .
[ fig : tsandls]e . for increasing temperature , the spectral line shapes become broadened and tend to get more lorentzian .
as expected , increasing the temperature too much , causes the two thresholds to merge . for a fixed density @xmath55 and for several temperatures @xmath59 .
for finite @xmath60 , the response function exponentially decays , with a decay time set by the inverse temperature .
b ) absorption spectra obtained by laplace transformation of the time series .
finite temperature causes a broadening of the absorption peaks and makes them more symmetric , i .. e lorentzian . ]
we can now turn on the light - matter interaction between the cavity photon and the charged quantum well . in particular ,
we are intrested in the linear properties of the coupled light - matter system , i.e. we do not consider photon - photon interactions .
the main quantity of intrest is the photon spectral function , given by @xmath61 here @xmath62 is the cavity mode energy and @xmath63 the laplace transform of eq . .
the microcavity is assumed to be lossless and we only consider a single photon mode at normal incidence . from now on , we restrict our attention to the trion in the 2deg absorption spectra at zero temperature .
in particular , as the trion energy shifts with increasing electron density ( see fig .
[ fig : exponentsthresholds]a ) , we can put the photon into resonance with the trion for every density .
the resulting lower polariton energy @xmath64 is seen in figs .
[ fig : rabismall]a , [ fig : rabilarge]a for two different values of the light - matter coupling , i.e. @xmath65 vs @xmath66 . in both cases , we see a monotonic increase in the trion - polariton ` rabi splitting ' as a function of fermi energy .
this can be attributed to the gain of trion oscillator strength as the fermi energy increases . for low electron density
, the increase of the trion oscillator strength can be simply understood in terms of an increased trion - photon overlap @xcite . in recent experiments@xcite ,
a _ decrease _ of the rabi splitting was however observed for higher electron density .
introducing hole recoil and electron - electron interactions could solve this discrepancy . in the subfigures ( 1 - 3 )
the polariton lineshapes ( red solid ) are depicted for some fixed fermi energies , the values being indicated by the black dashed lines in the large figures . for comparison , the 2deg absorption has also been depicted in blue dashed lines . for small light - matter coupling , the exciton does not influence the cavity mode .
the lower polariton now truly corresponds to the trion - polariton as being a superposition of trion and photon . note that in principle the lower polariton should have zero linewidth , but for visibility we gave it some small value .
the other polariton modes intrinsically possess a finite linewidth due to the finite absorption of the 2deg at the corresponding polariton energies . for larger light - matter coupling ,
the photon starts admixing with the exciton resulting in a non - zero quasiparticle shift at the lowest electron density under consideration .
we also see a clearly visible polariton mode above the exciton threshold . furthermore , in fig .
[ fig : rabilarge](2 ) the middle polariton is seen to have an asymmetric lineshape with a large tail towards the low frequencies .
this feature stems from the interplay between the two skewed lineshapes from both the trion and exciton and the fact that they both contribute equally to the polariton formation because of their oscillator strengths being the same at the corresponding fermi energy .
one of the attractive features of microcavity polaritons is their strong optical nonlinearity , allowing the creation of an interacting polariton quantum ` fluid ' .
a feshbach resonance mechanism for enhancing the polariton interactions @xcite has recently been investigated@xcite .
unfortunately , in the current state of the art microcavities , the single photon nonlinearities are too weak in order to enter the photon blockade regime .
it has been recently suggested that the electrons in the qw could enhance interactions between the polaritons @xcite . in the previous part of the paper ,
we have shown the lower trion - polariton to be the good quasi particle for a highly doped qw embedded in a planar microcavity . because the matter component of the polaritons is responsible for the interactions , it is instructive to investigate the spatial structure of the trion - polariton . in particular
, we will calculate the electron density in the lower polariton state through the electron - exciton density correlation function : @xmath67 with @xmath68 the density operator at position @xmath69 .
because the exciton is assumed to be infinitely heavy , we can place it in the origin without loss of generality . since we only consider s - wave scattering , the meaning of the spatial coordinate @xmath70 is the relative radial distance from the electrons to the exciton center - of - mass .
we start again from the unperturbed fermi sea and consider the hamiltonian @xmath71 given by eq . as a small perturbation to the 2deg . using kubo s response theory
, we find that the lowest order contribution to the above correlation function is of second order in the perturbation , i.e. proportional to @xmath72 .
it is given by @xmath73\ , \hat{\psi}^\dagger_x(0,\tau)|\textrm{fs}\rangle+\textrm{h.c.}\nonumber \\ & = & |ga_l|^2\sum_{n , m}\phi_n(r)\phi^*_m(r)\int_{-\infty}^\infty d\omega\ , g_{nm}(\omega)\frac{1}{\omega-(\omega_l-\bar{\varepsilon}_n)}\frac{1}{\omega-(\omega_l-\bar{\varepsilon}_m)}. \label{eq : xedens}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , we adiabatically turned on the laser in order to find the stationary state of the electron density under the continous wave excitation ( see details in the appendix ) .
the wave functions @xmath74 are the single particle eigenstates of the hamiltonian @xmath42 in position space , satisfying @xmath75 . the matrix @xmath76 is given as @xmath77 the expectation value in the above equation looks similar to eq . and
it can again be calculated numerically @xcite .
this means that our results on the electron density properly take into account the anderson orthogonality catastrophe and the fermi edge singularity physics .
the expectation value should be calculated in the lower polariton state . in the resulting expression eq .
the polariton shows up through the laser frequency @xmath78 .
in particular , we consider resonant continous wave excitation , thus with the frequency of the laser resonant with the lower polariton energy @xmath64 .
note that @xmath64 is a free parameter in this calculation , but its actual value has been calculated in the previous part of this paper , see figs . [
fig : rabismall]a , [ fig : rabilarge]a.the exciton density in the lower polariton state can be calculated analogously .
it is found to be @xmath79 where the absorption @xmath80 is given in eq . .
the electron density along the radial direction and in the lower polariton state is shown in fig .
[ fig : g2 ] for several fermi energies and polariton energies .
the trion bohr radius @xmath81 is taken as the lengthscale corresponding to the bound state @xmath82 with energy @xmath83 . ) as a function of radial distance to the exciton center - of - mass . at large distances ,
the density stays unperturbed as the correlation function always asymptotically goes to @xmath84 . for a high density 2deg
the electron density does not depend too much on the rabi frequency because the electrons screen the exciton on a time scale of the inverse fermi energy . for smaller fermi energy ,
a low rabi frequency still allows the electrons to screen the exciton . for higher rabi frequency
, the electrons do not have enough time to react onto the presence of the exciton so that the electron density is unperturbed . ] for the lowest fermi energy , a small rabi frequency ( blue solid lines ) , defined as the energy difference between the lower polariton and the trion threshold @xmath53 , is seen to increase the electron density at short distances from the exciton .
this can be understood as follows : when the photon is annihilated and an exciton is created , the fermi sea is shaken up due to the appearance of the exciton .
for small rabi frequency , it takes longer time for the exciton to be reconverted into a photon .
this means that there is a longer time for the electrons in the fermi sea to adjust themselves to the presence of the exciton : a screening cloud of electrons is able to build up near the exciton .
the reason for the increase of electron density is the attractive exciton - electron potential , i.e. the presence of the bound state . for larger rabi frequency
, there will be much less time for the electrons to reorganize ; as soon as they start readjusting , the exciton has already dissapeared and turned into a photon .
this is seen by the green dashed - dotted line where the exciton density tends to flatten . for large fermi energies ( comparable to or larger than the trion binding energy )
, the electron density does not depend too much on the rabi frequency .
we argue that the time it takes for the individual electrons to adjust to the presence of the scattering potential , is proportional to the inverse fermi energy .
the larger the fermi energy , the less time it takes to reorganize the electrons at the fermi level and the system will always be able to build up a screening cloud .
nevertheless , the absolute value of @xmath85 decreases for increasing fermi energy , simply because there is less time to screen the exciton . in all cases , the electron density oscillates and the envelope decays as @xmath86 at large distances , corresponding to the friedel oscillations . from the above
, we see that there should be a frequency window in which the trion gets screened on a length scale comparable to the bare trion bohr radius , making it a truly localized , electrically charged particle , while still ensuring strong coupling .
the rabi frequency should be small enough such that there is time for the electrons to form for the trion , by binding to the exciton .
since the formation time typically goes as @xmath87 , one should maintain @xmath88 .
on the other hand , one should avoid running into the weak coupling regime by taking the rabi frequency too small .
we have set up an effective model describing the formation of trion - polaritons in a microcavity embedding a doped quantum well .
taking into account important many - body effects such as the anderson orthogonality catastrophe and fermi edge singularity , we were able to qualitatively describe the 2deg absorption , the crossover of oscillator strength from exciton to trion and the polariton lineshapes .
the role of finite temperature has been discussed as well . finally , we calculated the electron density profile in the lower polariton state and concluded that for a specific range of rabi frequencies , the trion - polariton behaves as an electrically charged localized particle .
a major simplification in our model was the neglect of electron - electron interactions . including this physics would probably solve the decreasing linewidth of the trion for increasing electron density .
also , the binding energy of the trion then becomes a function of fermi energy instead of being a fixed parameter .
most importantly , a self - consistent treatment of electron - electron interactions in the calculation of the electron density profile is needed to see whether a charge build - up near the exciton is still possible .
we are greatful to ata imamoglu , cristiano ciuti , charles grenier and dries sels for stimulating discussions .
this work was financially supported by the ua - lp program .
99 i. carusotto , and c. ciuti , rev .
phys . * 85 * , 299 - 366 ( 2013 ) .
f. p. laussy , a. v. kavokin , and i. a. shelykh , phys .
lett . * 104 * , 106402 ( 2010 ) .
a. gabbay , y. preezant , e. cohen , b. m. ashkinadze , and l. n. pfeiffer , phys .
. lett . * 99 * , 157402 ( 2007 ) .
s. smolka , w. wuester , f. haupt , s. faelt , w. wegscheider , and a. imamoglu , science * 346 * , 6207 ( 2014 ) .
p. g. lagoudakis , m. d. martin , j. j. baumberg , a. qarry , e. cohen , and l. n. pfeiffer , phys .
lett . * 90 * , 206401 ( 2003 ) .
m. perrin , p. senellart , a. lematre , and j. bloch , phys .
b * 72 * , 075340 ( 2005 ) .
a. das , b. xiao , s. bhowmick , and p. bhattacharya , applied physics letters * 101 * , 131112 ( 2012 ) .
g. malpuech , a. kavokin , a. di carlo , and j. j. baumberg , phys .
b * 65 * , 153310 ( 2002 ) . g. d. mahan , phys . rev . * 153 * , 882 ( 1967 ) .
p. nozires , and c.t
. de dominicis , phys . rev . *
178 * , 1097 ( 1969 ) .
p. anderson , phys .
rev . lett . * 18 * , 1049 ( 1967 ) .
m. knap , a. shashi , y. nishida , a. imambekov , d. a. abanin , and e. demler , phys .
x * 2 * , 041020 ( 2012 ) .
g. refael , and e. demler , phys .
b * 77 * , 144511 ( 2008 ) .
a. schirotzek , c. h. wu , a. sommer , and m. w. zwierlein , phys . rev . lett . * 102 * , 230402 ( 2009 ) . n. s. averkiev , and m. m. glazov , phys .
b * 76 * , 045320 ( 2007 )
. n. s. averkiev , m. m. glazov , and m. m. voronov , solid .
comm . * 152 * , 395 ( 2012 ) .
m. baeten , and m. wouters , phys .
b , * 89 * , 245301 ( 2014 ) .
r. rapaport , r. harel , e. cohen , arza ron , e. linder , and l. n. pfeiffer , phys .
* 84 * , 1607 ( 2000 ) .
d. bajoni , m. perrin , p. senellart , a. lematre , b. sermage , and j. bloch , phys .
b * 73 * , 205344 ( 2006 ) .
m. combescot , and p. nozi ` eres , le journal de physique , * 32 * , 913 ( 1971 )
. n. dambrumenil , and b. muzykantskii , phys .
b * 71 * , 045326 ( 2005 ) .
m. vladimirova , s. cronenberger , d. scalbert , k. v. kavokin , a. miard , a. lematre , j. bloch , d. solnyshkov , g. malpuech , and a. v. kavokin , phys .
b * 82 * , 075301 , ( 2010 )
. n. takemura , s. trebaol , m. wouters , m. t. portella - oberli and b. deveaud , nat .
* 10 * , 500 ( 2014 ) .
in this appendix we derive , using kubo s reponse theory , the expression for the electron - exciton density correlation function.starting from the unperturbed fermi sea and treating the hamiltonian as a perturbation to the system , we need to go second order in this perturbation to have a first non - zero contribution to the density - density correlation function . using standard kubo response theory we find where the remaining expectation values need to be calculated in the unperturbed state.we perform the calculation in two dimensions .
restriction to the spheric symmetric states comes down to using the proper hankel transform pairs . using the interaction picture for the time evolution of the operators we obtain @xmath90 where @xmath42 is the hamiltonian governing the dynamics of the electrons in presence of the exciton scattering potential and @xmath91 is the ground state energy of the fermi sea without the exciton.using the fourier transform for the system enclosed in a box of area @xmath92 , we obtain @xmath93 where the plane wave creation operators satisfy @xmath94 .
the time evolution of the operators is governed by the hamiltonian in presence of the exciton : @xmath95 the eigenstates are no longer plane waves and we therefore make a unitary transformation from the plane wave basis to the basis of eigenstates of @xmath96 , we call them scattering states .
the latter are characterized by their principal quantum number @xmath97 and the angular momentum @xmath98 , because the scattering potential under consideration is spheric symmetric .
this gives latexmath:[\[\begin{aligned } & & \frac{1}{s}\sum_{\mathbf{k , q}}e^{i\left ( \mathbf{k - q}\right ) \mathbf{r}% } \,\langle \textrm{fs}|e^{-i\bar hs}c_{\mathbf{k}}^{\dagger } \left ( t\right ) c_{% \mathbf{q}}\left ( t\right ) \,e^{i\bar h\tau } |\textrm{fs}\rangle \\ & = & \frac{1}{s}\sum_{\mathbf{k , q}}e^{i\left
( \mathbf{k - q}\right ) \mathbf{r}% } \,\sum_{n , m=0}^{\infty } \sum_{l , p=-\infty } ^{\infty } \langle \mathbf{q}% where in the third line we introduced the unit operator .
the initial state @xmath19 is built with plane waves but the operator @xmath102 destroys a scattering state .
we therefore make again a transformation from scattering states to plane wave states , finally yielding @xmath103 the sum over @xmath104 defines the wave function in position space . writing @xmath105 , the eigenstates of the hamiltonian @xmath96 in plane wave basis , we define @xmath106 and we have @xmath107 here , we introduced shorthand notation for the double sum over @xmath108 ( dropping the angular momentum indices in order not to overload the notation ) : @xmath109 this expression is exactly the one from eq . in the paper . the above expectation value should be plugged into equation .
this gives @xmath110 the hermitian conjugate term can be shown to be the same as interchanging @xmath111 and @xmath112 , yielding @xmath113 where now we can both have @xmath114 and @xmath115 .
introducing the fourier transformation of @xmath116 , we can now easily do the integration over @xmath117 .
furthermore , in order to obtain the stationary state under the continous excitation , we add a small exponential term , meaning we slowly ( for example , as compared to the lifetime of the cavity mode ) turn on the laser .
if we then take @xmath118 , this will eliminate all transient behaviour , originating from the initial time @xmath119 .
in other words , we do not want our result to depend on @xmath119.so , introducing the fourier transform for a function @xmath120 , @xmath121we obtain , by adiabatically turning on the laser ( only focus on the time integrals ) @xmath122the last line follows from straightforward integration and taking the proper limits . restoring the double sum over @xmath123 , we obtain equation in the article
. the exciton density can be calculated completely analogously . | we theoretically investigate the trion - polariton and the effects of a two - dimensional electron gas on its single particle properties .
focussing on the trion and exciton transitions , we set up an effective model and calculate the optical absorption of the quantum well containing the 2deg . including the light - matter coupling
, we compute the rabi splitting and polariton lineshapes as a function of 2deg density .
the role of finite temperature is investigated .
the spatial extent of the trion - polariton is also calculated .
we find a substantial charge build - up at short distances as long as the rabi frequency does not exceed the trion binding energy .
all our calculations take into account the fermi - edge singularity and the anderson orthogonality catastrophe . |
in the quest to understand when galaxies formed their stars and assembled their mass , two complementary observational techniques can be employed : direct observations of galaxies at different redshifts , and reconstruction of the previous galaxy history from fossil records at a given epoch .
the main advantage of the first method is that measuring the current star formation is less uncertain than estimating the past history , especially in galaxies in which the light of young stars outshines the older population , in particular at high redshift ( papovich et al .
2001 ; zibetti et al . 2009 ; conroy 2013 ) . on the other hand ,
the second method has the benefit of tracing the evolution of each individual galaxy , without having to infer histories in a statistical sense with the problems involved in the identification of progenitors and descendants .
both methods heavily rely on spectrophotometric modeling , to calibrate the star formation rate ( sfr ) indicators and derive the star formation histories ( sfhs ) , and are affected by the choice of the initial mass function ( imf ) . on a cosmic scale ,
the collection of the star formation rate density ( sfrd ) measurements at different cosmic times ( from z=8 to 0 ) give us an indication on the summa of the sfh of the universe .
( madau et al . 1996 ; lilly et al .
1996 ; hopkins & beacom 2006 ; karim et al .
2011 ( radio ) ; burgarella et al . 2013
( fir+uv ) ; sobral et al .
2013 ( h - alpha ) ; bouwens et al .
2014 ( uv ) ; madau & dickinson 2014 ) .
it has emerged that the sfrd of the cosmos peaks at @xmath4 , following a rise after the big bang and before falling by a factor about 10 to the current value .
this picture is now well established , though large uncertainties still exist at high redshifts .
the sfrd(z ) has important implications for the reionization of the universe , the cosmic chemical evolution , the transformation of gas into stars and the build - up of stellar mass .
ideally , however , one would want to go beyond the description of cosmic global history , and trace galaxy evolution on a galaxy - by - galaxy basis to understand the physical processes driving it . in this respect ,
great progress has been made by surveys at different redshifts that have established the existence of a strong dependence of galaxy histories on galaxy stellar mass .
on average , more massive galaxies have formed their stars and completed their star formation activity at higher z than less massive galaxies ( the so called downsizing effect , cowie et al .
1996 ; gavazzi et al . 2006 ; de lucia et al . 2007 ;
snchez - blzquez et al .
the existence of relations between star formation rate and galaxy stellar mass ( sfr - mass ) and specific star formation rate and mass ( ssfr = sfr / mass ) have been established from z=0 out to @xmath1 ( brinchmann et al . 2004 ; salim et al .
2007 ; noeske et al . 2007 ;
daddi et al .
2007 ; rodighiero et al . 2011
; whitaker et al . 2012 ; sobral et al . 2014 ; speagle et al . 2014 ) , and many other galaxy properties have been found to be strongly correlated with galaxy mass .
furthermore , a number of works have pointed out that galaxy properties are even more strongly correlated with a combination of galaxy mass and galaxy `` size '' , arguing for velocity dispersion ( franx et al .
2008 ; bernardi et al .
2003 ; smith et al . 2009
; wake et al .
2012 ) or galaxy surface mass density ( brinchmann et al . 2004
; kauffmann et al . 2006 ) as principal drivers .
the exact origin of these trends is still unknown , but evidence has accumulated for a dependence of galaxy stellar population ages on galaxy sizes at fixed mass ( poggianti et al .
2013 ; van der wel et al . 2009
; cappellari et al . 2012 ) , suggesting that also galaxy structure , and not just stellar mass , is relevant . in a recent paper , omand et al .
( 2014 ) argue that the observed correlation of the quenched fraction with @xmath5 is related to the dominance of the bulge component with respect to the disk , suggesting it might ultimately be linked with galaxy morphology ( see also driver et al .
even the ssfr - mass relation might be due to the increase of the bulge mass fractions with galaxy stellar mass , as the ratio of sfr and stellar mass of the galaxy disk is virtually independent of total stellar mass ( abramson et al .
2014 ) .
on the other hand , galaxy stellar population properties have been known to vary strongly with galaxy environment ( spitzer & baade 1951 ; oemler 1974 ; davis & geller 1976 ; dressler 1980 ) .
galaxy clusters have seen an evolution in their blue galaxy fractions that is even stronger than in the field , and the evolution from blue star - forming to red passive takes place sooner in dense environments and massive haloes ( poggianti et al .
2006 ; wilman et al . 2005 ; cooper et al . 2006 ; cucciati et al .
2006 ; iovino et al .
whether this environmental dependence is simply due to different galaxy mass distributions and/or morphological distributions with environment , or it reflects a stellar history that differs with environment at a given mass , is still a matter of debate ( thomas et al .
2005,2010 ; baldry et al .
2006 ; peng et al .
2010 , 2012 ; poggianti et al .
2013 ) . on a global scale , the evolution of the sfrd in different environments at low redshift is not yet known , though the evolution of the blue galaxy fractions suggests a steeper decline in clusters than in the field ( kodama & bower 2001 ) . the contribution of haloes of different masses to the sfrd(z ) has been recently quantified by popesso et al .
( 2014a , b ) , who argue that the process of structure formation , and the associated quenching processes , play an important role in the drop of the sfrd(z ) since @xmath6 .
overall , several lines of evidence suggest that both galaxy mass and environment play a role , with environment being more relevant for lower mass galaxies , at least as far as quenching is concerned ( haines et al . 2007 ; cooper et al . 2010 ;
pasquali et al . 2010 ; peng et al . 2010 , 2012 ; mcgee et al . 2011 ; sobral et al . 2011 ; muzzin et al . 2012 ; smith et al . 2012 ; wetzel et al . 2012
; lin et al . 2014 ; la barbera et al . 2014 ; vulcani et al . 2015 ) . however , while it is well established that the relative incidence of star - forming and passive galaxies changes with environment , it is still debated whether environment matters for the whole galaxy stellar history , or it only causes it to end leading to quenching at some point . turning to the reconstruction of galaxy sfhs from fossil records , this reaches high levels of precision in galaxies with resolved stellar populations , such as our milky way and the local group . going to more distant galaxies , it has to rely on the interpretation of the galaxy integrated spectrum , and is limited by our capability to discriminate between stars of different ages from the spectrum they emit .
spectrophotometric models capable of extracting sfhs from integrated spectra have been built by a number of groups : heavens et al .
( 2000 ; moped ) , cid - fernandes et al .
( 2004 ; starlight ) , ocvirk et al .
( 2006a , b ; stecmap ) , fritz et al .
( 2007 ; now called sinopsis ) , macarthur et al . 2009 , koleva et al . ( 2009 ; ulyss ) , tojeiro et al . ( 2007 ; vespa ) and others ( see sedfitting.org/sed08 ) .
they have been applied to reconstruct the sfh of galaxies in large surveys ( e.g. panter et al .
2007 and tojeiro et al .
2009 on sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) ; fritz et al .
2011 on wings ) , and to study these histories for galaxy subsets of special interest ( e.g. tojeiro et al . 2013 ; vulcani et al . 2015 ) .
two studies in particular ( heavens et al . 2004 ; panter et al . 2007 )
derived the cosmic sfh from sdss spectra , and were successful in reproducing the sfrd(z ) and the downsizing effect . in this work
we make use of a non - parametric spectrophotometric model to derive the past history of star formation in five broad bins of age from integrated spectra of galaxies in clusters and the field and , within the field , in groups and lower mass haloes .
searching for the origin of the overall decline observed in the sfrd(z ) since @xmath3 , we also consider present - day star - forming galaxies separately from the rest , and quantify the relative role of their decline in star formation and that of galaxies that have been quenched .
our goal is to shed light on the history of galaxies of different masses and morphologies , and isolate any residual environmental trend .
we stress that we look for sfh trends with galaxy parameters _ today _ , that is as a function of the mass , morphology and environment that galaxies have at low redshift , when the spectra we use to derive their past stellar history are taken .
the outline of the paper is as follows : in sect .
2 we describe the datasets used , and in sect .
3 the methods for assigning galaxy morphology and the spectrophotometric model used for galaxy stellar masses and sfhs . sect .
4 presents our results : in 4.1 the sfrd of the field sample is compared with recent observational measurements at different redshifts ; in 4.2 we study the sfrd in different environments ; in 4.3 we analyze the sfh of star - forming galaxies both in the field and in clusters , in 4.4 the contribution of galaxies of different mass and morphological type to the total sfrd , and in 4.5 we present a global picture which considers the mean sfh of galaxies in different environments , with the same stellar mass but different morphology . finally , we summarize our findings in sect . 5 .
the imf adopted is a salpeter one in the mass range 0.1 - 100 @xmath7 ( salpeter 1955 ) , and the cosmological constants assumed are @xmath8=0.3 , @xmath9=0.7 , @xmath10 .
the _ padova millennium galaxy and group catalogue _ ( calvi , poggianti & vulcani , 2011 ) is a database built on the basis of the millennium galaxy catalogue ( mgc ) , a deep and wide b - imaging survey along an equatorial strip of @xmath11 38 @xmath12 obtained with the isaac newton telescope ( int ) .
the final catalogue is restricted to galaxies brighter than @xmath13 with a spectroscopic redshift in the range @xmath14 , taken from the mgcz catalogue , the spectroscopic extension of the mgc , that has a 96@xmath15 spectroscopic completeness at these magnitudes ( driver et al . , 2005 ) .
most of the mgcz spectra of our sample come from the sdss ( abazajian et al .
2003 , @xmath16 resolution ) and the remaining ones from the 2df galaxy redshift survey ( 2dfgrs ) ( colless et al . 2001 ) and the 2df follow - up obtained by the mgc team ( driver et al .
2005 ) , with a 2df resolution of @xmath17 fwhm .
the fibre diameters are 3 for the sdss and 2.16 for the 2df setup , corresponding to the inner 1.3 to 6 kpc of the galaxies .
the pm2gc galaxy stellar mass completeness limit was computed as the mass of the reddest @xmath18 galaxy ( b - v = 0.9 ) at our redshift upper limit ( z = 0.1 ) , and it is equal to @xmath19 .
the comoving volume of the pm2gc survey is 361424 @xmath20 .
the image quality and the spectroscopic completeness of the pm2gc are superior to sdss , and these qualities result in more robust morphological classifications and better sampling of dense regions . in particular , the mgc is based on int data ( 2.5 m telescope ) obtained with a median seeing of 1.3 `` and at least 750s of exposure , with a pixel scale of 0.333''/pixel , while the sdss ( again , 2.5 m telescope ) has a median seeing of 1.5 `` in g ( the closest band to the pm2gc ) , an exposure time of 54.1s and 0.396''/pixel . as for spectroscopic completeneness , 14% of all pm2gc galaxies do not have an sdss spectrum , and the sdss incompleteness is particularly severe in dense regions such as groups .
moreover , the pm2gc data is very comparable in quality to our cluster sample ( wings ) and the two samples have been analyzed in a homogenous way with the same tools .
the characterization of the environment of the galaxies was conducted by means of a _ friends - of - friends _ ( fof ) algorithm .
the methods and the presentation of the catalogues are described in calvi et al .
briefly , a catalogue of 176 groups of galaxies with at least three members was built in the redshift range @xmath21 , containing 43@xmath15 of the total _ general field _
population at these redshifts .
the mean redshift and velocity dispersion @xmath22 of the groups are respectively 0.0823 and 192 @xmath23 .
88@xmath15 of the selected groups are composed by less than 10 members , and 63@xmath15 by less than 5 members .
galaxies were assigned to a group if they were within 3 @xmath22 from the group redshift and 1.5 r@xmath24 from the group geometrical center .
we define as @xmath25 the radius of the sphere inside which the mean density is a factor 200 @xmath26 the critical density of the universe at that redshift .
this parameter gives an approximation of the virial radius of a cluster or group and for our structures it is computed from the velocity dispersions using the formula ( finn et al . , 2005 ) : @xmath27 with @xmath28 the group velocity dispersion and @xmath29 its mean redshift .
galaxies that do not satisfy the group membership criteria have been placed either in the catalogue of single field galaxies , that comprises the isolated galaxies , or in the catalogue of binary field galaxies , which comprises the systems with two galaxies within 1500 km / s and 0.5 h@xmath30 mpc .
finally , galaxies that were part of the trial groups in the fof procedure but did not fulfill the final group membership criteria are treated separately as `` mixed sample '' .
all galaxies in the environments described above are collected in the `` general field '' sample pm2gc .
the number of galaxies in each sub - environment and in the general field sample are shown in table [ pm2_subenv ] .
.list of the number of galaxies in different environments in the pm2gc sample . [ cols="^,^",options="header " , ] globally , the decline in sfh gets progressively steeper going from lower to higher mass haloes .
the exact shape of such decline seems to vary with the halo mass .
in fact , the sfr ranking order at the highest redshift respects the halo mass ranking , while at @xmath31 the ranking of @xmath32 groups and @xmath33 clusters is not respected .
galaxies in haloes of mass @xmath34 show a very flat and well separated sfh compared to all other masses . yet
, they still display a sfr at @xmath1 significantly higher than at any other redshift , a feature common to haloes of all masses . to conclude , the slope of the decline of the sfrd strongly changes with environment .
this is clearly visible with both of our definitions of environment . in sect .
4.5 we will analyze in detail the origin of this effect .
, in the bottom panel all samples are normalized to the pm2gc low - z value , indicated by the black solid triangle . ]
= 14 and from the wings cluster sample for more massive halos .
the sfrs are normalized so to coincide in the lowest redshift bin , as indicated by the large black filled circle .
the halo mass ranges considered are shown in the legend . ]
the sfh throughout the cosmic time in a given environment includes a large number of galaxies and at each epoch is the result of star formation processes taking place in galaxies that are still actively forming stars .
the decline of the sfrd from the past to the present age is in principle the cumulative result of declining star formation in galaxies that are still star - forming today ( i.e. at the redshift they are observed in the pm2gc or wings ) together with the increase in the number of galaxies that at some point have stopped forming stars , i.e. have been quenched .
the study of the sfh of today s star - forming galaxies aims to disentangle these two effects . in the following ,
we consider as currently star - forming those galaxies whose ssfr at the time they are observed ( i.e. z = 0.03 - 0.11 ) is above a fixed threshold . for computing the ssfr ,
the current sfr is taken to be the average during the last 20 myr as obtained from the model . in figure [ ssfrmass_rel ]
we report the ssfr - mass relation from low redshift measurements of sfr and galaxy stellar masses .
the black dots in the figure are the pm2gc field galaxy sample values ( z = 0.03 - 0.11 ) , the green dotted line is the fit from the star forming sequence from salim et al .
( 2007 ) ( z @xmath35 0.1 ) , the blue solid line is the same quantity as given in lara - lopez et al . (
2013 ) ( z up to @xmath35 0.36 ) and the blue dashed lines are located at one sigma with respect to the blue solid one .
the threshold separating star - forming from passive galaxies is chosen on the basis of this ssfr - mass relation and is taken to be equal to ssfr @xmath36 ( see fig .
[ ssfrmass_rel ] ) .
this criterion selects 2094 star - forming galaxies in the field and 612 in clusters .
figure [ sfingmass ] shows the mean sfh per star - forming galaxy in different galaxy mass bins , obtained dividing the sum of all sfrs by the number of galaxies . the global decline in the cosmic star formation
is not only due to an increasing fraction of galaxies becoming quenched at lower redshifts , but also to the decrease with time of the average sfr of today s star - forming galaxies .
the trend depends on galaxy mass , as shown in fig .
[ sfingmass ] : it is steeper in high - mass galaxies than in low - mass ones , both in the field and in clusters . in clusters ,
the sfr drop between the oldest and the second oldest time intervals is much more pronounced than in the field for all galaxy masses , in agreement with the fact that star formation in cluster galaxies occurred very early on .
figure [ interpolazione ] shows the redshift dependence of the ratio between the total sfr of all galaxies at any given redshift and the total sfr at the same redshift of galaxies that are still forming stars today , for pm2gc ( full circles ) and wings ( empty triangles ) separately . the fractional contribution to the total sfr at any redshift of galaxies that are now quenched
is equal to ( 1 - 1/y ) , with y being the y axis - value in fig .
[ interpolazione ] .
there is one extra redshift bin in this figure , because the first time interval of 600 myr was splitted into 20 myr and 580 myr , to isolate the present - day value according to our definition of star forming galaxies .
the first point plotted in the figure represents the ratio between the sfr of today s star forming galaxies and the current measured sfr , and by definition
it has a value equal to one .
the resulting values have been interpolated using a least squares method and the resulting interpolation lines are : @xmath37 where y is the y axis - value in fig .
[ interpolazione ] .
a good correlation for pm2gc galaxies is found , with the interpolation line reproducing well within the error bars the temporal behaviour of the ratio . for wings
not all the points follow a linear correlation within the error bars , even if the general trend is decreasing as in the field .
this figure illustrates that the star formation process at high z was mainly due to galaxies which today are not active anymore .
in fact , @xmath38 of the sfr in the field and @xmath39 in clusters at @xmath1 originated in galaxies that are not forming stars today . at @xmath40 , these factors are @xmath41 in the field and @xmath42 in clusters .
moreover , in clusters the interpolation line is almost three times steeper than in the field , meaning that the contribution of quenching to the sfrd(z ) decline is much more significant in clusters than in the field . .
error bars have been computed from the errors relative to sfrs in both the complete and star - forming samples using error propagation . ] in this section we focus on the comparison between clusters and field taking into consideration the contribution to the sfrd(z ) of galaxies of different mass and morphology .
recall that stellar masses and morphologies refer to galaxies as they appear at low redshift , when we observe them .
their morphological type at higher z , at the moment they possessed the sfrs we infer , might have been different , due to the well known morphological evolution taking place both in clusters and in the field ( e.g. dressler et al .
1997 ; oesch et al .
2010 ; vulcani et al . 2011 ) . figure [ pm2wings_morpho ] shows that the contribution to the sfrd(z ) depends on the morphological type and , considering a given type , on the environment .. agns classified as early - type in the pm2gc sample are 28 and their contribution to the z=0 early - type sfrd is @xmath43 .
the number of early type agns contaminating wings galaxies is only 3 : in the present epoch they contribute to the early - type sfrd only for @xmath44 . ]
the main contribution to the sfrd in the field sample ( left panel in the figure ) is given by today s late - type galaxies ( marked with blue circles ) , which dominate at all redshifts .
compared to the total values estimated for the pm2gc , the sfrd of late - types is @xmath45 of the total at the present epoch and @xmath46 at the highest z. the relative contribution of different morphological types to the total star formation varies with time : ( today s ) early - type galaxies , which are composed mainly of old and red stars , gave a larger contribution to the sfrd at earlier epochs , while today they contribute only for 30 @xmath15 of the total sfrd .
s0s and ellipticals have quite similar values at every epoch , with ellipticals slightly dominating at all redshifts except the lowest bin . in principle ,
the analysis just performed depends on both the stellar history of each type and the morphological distribution of galaxies within each environment , i.e. the number of galaxies populating each type . in our field sample 59% of all galaxies
are late - types , 21% are s0s and 19% are ellipticals . at z = 0 on average
the star formation activity in a late - type galaxy is 1.5 times higher than in an elliptical and 1.6 times than in an s0 , which is expected given that early - type galaxies today are on average more passive than late - types .
in contrast with the field , early - type galaxies dominate the total sfrd in clusters at all epochs , except in the lowest redshift bin . the difference in the fractional contribution of late- and early - types ,
however , is much smaller than in the field : in clusters , 40 @xmath15 of the total today sfrd is due to late - types , only slightly higher than the 32 @xmath15 and 28 @xmath15 of s0s and ellipticals , respectively .
this picture reverses going back in time : between 0.1 @xmath47 z @xmath47 1 , today s lenticular galaxies produce the majority of stars , and finally at the highest z ellipticals dominate .
the scenario just described is influenced by the significantly different distribution of morphologies in cluster galaxies compared with that in the field : in clusters 28% of all galaxies are ellipticals , 44% are s0s and 27% are late - type .
overall , the trends in clusters and in the field are clearly very different as far as the relative roles of each type are concerned .
we now divide galaxies into mass bins , according to the completeness limits of the two surveys : m @xmath48 for pm2gc and m @xmath49 for wings . in figure [ pm2wings_mass ] the field and
the cluster sfrds are divided into respectively three and four mass bins .
qualitatively , the global sfrd in both environments is dominated by galaxies with @xmath50 . going into more details , in the field
, galaxies with masses m @xmath51 give the main contribution to the total sfrd for z @xmath52 0.35 , while in the two lowest redshift intervals galaxies with masses @xmath53 prevail .
low - mass galaxies ( blue circles ) have lower sfrd than the intermediate mass galaxies , but still higher than the most massive galaxies for z @xmath47 0.1 .
the trends plotted in the left panel of figure [ pm2wings_mass ] are influenced again by both the size of the subsamples and the average sfrs of galaxies of different masses . to compare the average sfr of a typical galaxy of a certain mass
it is useful to divide the sfr by the number of galaxies populating the considered mass bin . today
, on average , galaxies in different mass bins ( including passive ones ) form roughly the same amount of stars , and intermediate - mass galaxies dominate the global sfrd in the field just because they are more numerous .
on the contrary , at higher z , the hierarchy established in the total sfrd is very pronounced : the sfr per unit galaxy of m @xmath51 galaxies on average is @xmath54 5 times higher than that of intermediate - mass galaxies and about 13 times the one of the low mass systems .
the right panel of figure [ pm2wings_mass ] refers to wings cluster galaxies .
galaxies with the lowest mass always give the smallest contribution to the total sfrd at any redshift , while the intermediate and high - mass galaxies have similar sfrd values until z @xmath54 2 , and at higher z the most massive ones prevail .
analysing again the mean sfrd per galaxy within a certain range in mass it turns out that today the sfrd of the average low - mass galaxy becomes roughly equal to that of intermediate - mass ones , while high - mass galaxies have values higher of a factor @xmath54 2.3 .
going to higher redshifts , the ratio of the average sfrd of high - mass and intermediate - mass ( low - mass ) galaxies becomes greater , reaching a value of @xmath54 6 ( 16 ) at the highest redshift .
an important phenomenon strictly connected with masses is downsizing : galaxies with higher masses are characterized by shorter and earlier star formation on average , while lower mass galaxies have longer star formation timescales .
the variation of the sfh of galaxies according to their stellar mass is evident comparing the slopes of the hypothetical curve connecting points of the same color and shape ( red , green and blue ) in fig .
[ pm2wings_mass ] .
in particular , as an estimate of the process , we can calculate the ratio between the value of sfr in the first and in the last redshift intervals and analyse its variation as a function of mass .
this ratio is @xmath54 3 for low - mass galaxies , @xmath54 6 for intermediate mass ones and @xmath54 26 for high mass galaxies in the field .
the same ratios in wings galaxies are the following : @xmath54 13 for low masses , @xmath54 36 for intermediate ones and @xmath54 94 for the highest masses .
the numbers listed above demonstrate that the downsizing phenomenon acts in the field as well as in clusters , but in the latter it is stronger .
even galaxies of the same mass are characterised by different timescales and sfhs depending on their environment .
the average decline of the star formation process in galaxies of a given mass is less steep in the field than in clusters .
cluster galaxies form the bulk of their stars at earlier epochs with average high - z sfrd values per galaxy systematically higher than those of the field at any given galaxy stellar mass today , as we will see in more details in the next section .
the last sequence of plots in figure [ massm123 ] aims to answer the following questions : on average , do galaxies of different morphological types but same masses have different histories ? do galaxies of the same mass and morphological type have different histories depending on the environment ? we divide galaxies according to their morphological type , mass bin and environment . to avoid any possible residual mass dependence in each mass bin , we first verified whether galaxies in each given mass bin and given morphological type had the same mass distribution in both environments , performing a kolmogorov smirnov test ( ks ) .
the ks test found significantly different mass distributions only in three cases ( elliptical galaxies in the lowest mass bin and lenticular galaxies both in the lowest and in the highest mass bins , plots not shown ) .
for these , we constructed ad hoc samples of randomly selected wings galaxies that matched the pm2gc mass distribution . moreover , for this plot , we limit the m3 bin to @xmath55 , to have a similar upper mass limit for spirals , ellipticals and s0s in each environment . fig .
[ massm123 ] presents the sfh of galaxies in each mass bin , matched in mass when necessary , for different environments and morphologies .
the total sfr is divided by the number of galaxies of each subsample , in order to derive the mean history of a galaxy of a given type , mass and environment .
environments are plotted in figures with different symbols ( full circles , squares and triangles for field galaxies and empty circles , squares and triangles for cluster galaxies ) and colours follow the same legend of the morphological analysis in figure [ pm2wings_morpho ] .
figure [ massm123 ] highlights that , perhaps surprisingly , in a given environment , galaxies of the same mass but different morphologies share the same history of star formation , except for the lowest redshift bin .
in fact , the average sfr of late - type , s0 and elliptical galaxies of a given mass is similar within the errors at all redshifts , except at @xmath56 when late - type galaxies have a systematically higher value than early - type galaxies .
there is , instead , a different sfh in clusters and field for galaxies of a given mass and morphological type : all types in clusters have a higher sfr at @xmath1 and a lower sfr at lower redshifts , than field galaxies .
comparing now the different mass bins , the downsizing in star formation is again visible ( the slope of the sfh gets steeper at higher masses ) .
the range of sfr at the lowest redshift is similar for galaxies of all masses , while it varies greatly at the highest z ( see sect . [ subsec_morphomass_plots ] ) . from the analysis of these plots ,
it is possible to establish a general hierarchy in the properties of galaxies which mostly influence the star formation process .
galaxy mass is clearly an important factor in determining the sfr slope with time , in all environments .
however , it is not the only factor , as cluster galaxies of a given mass have a steeper decline of sf with time . for each mass , the highest average sfr at @xmath1
is found for cluster galaxies , and does not depend on morphology .
morphology , in contrast , has little influence on the sfh .
the only morphological dependence is at the present epoch when , on average , a late - type galaxy forms more stars than an early - type galaxy of the same mass .
these results seem to suggest that the stellar history of a galaxy depends mainly on its mass _ and _ environment , and is almost independent of its present - day morphology . finally , computing from fig .
[ massm123 ] the ratio of the average sfr in the highest and lowest redshift bins for galaxies of the same mass and morphology and comparing it for different environments , we obtain cluster - to - field ratios typically ranging from 4 to 7 , with an average of 5 .
thus , the much steeper sfrd decline in clusters compared to the field ( ratio=40/7=5.7 ) discussed in [ subsec_environ_plots ] can be explained by the steeper history of cluster galaxies compared to the field , at fixed galaxy mass and morphology .
we conclude that the different slope in the sfrd(z ) of clusters and field is not driven by variations of the galaxy mass or morphological distributions with environment , but by the fact that galaxy stellar histories vary with galaxy location at each given mass and morphology .
having derived the sfh of galaxies in clusters ( wings ) and the field ( pm2gc ) , we have investigated the sfrd evolution with redshift as a function of environment , the histories of galaxies that are still forming stars at the time they are observed , and the role of galaxy masses , morphologies and environment in driving the differences of the sfrd(z ) with environment .
we have found that : 1 .
the pm2gc cumulative sfrd agrees quite well with the sfrd observed at different redshifts ( figure [ pm2gc_md14 ] ) .
the only discrepancy is seen at the highest z ( z @xmath57 2 ) where the pm2gc sfrd is a factor @xmath58 lower than the integral of the md14 best - fit function over the same redshift interval .
the sfrd changes with environment ( figure [ pm2wings_subsets ] ) and in particular two effects contribute simultaneously to the cluster - field differences in the sfrd : the different density of the two environments , which changes the normalization of the sfrds at all epochs , and the intrinsic differences of the histories within the environments , which change the slope of the sfrd .
the cluster sfrd decline is much steeper than in the field , and there is a progressive steepening going from single to binaries to groups and clusters , as well as going from lower mass to higher mass haloes .
the decline of the sfrd(z ) is due to two factors : the decline of the sfh of star forming galaxies and the quenching rate of galaxies as a function of redshift ( figure [ sfingmass ] ) .
we have quantified the relative importance of the two processes ( figure [ interpolazione ] ) : the star formation process at high z was mainly due to galaxies which today are not active anymore , and this is true in particular for clusters .
more than 50 % of the sfr in the field and more than 75 % in clusters at z @xmath57 2 originated in galaxies that are not currently forming stars . at z @xmath11 1 these factors are 42 % in the field and 73 % in clusters .
galaxies of different morphological types but same mass and environment have on average remarkably similar sfrs at all epochs except at the lowest redshift , suggesting that the current morphological type is linked with the current morphology but is largely non - influent for the past sfh .
the average sfh of a galaxy depends on galaxy stellar mass and , at fixed mass , on galaxy environment .
the different slope of the decline in the sfrd(z ) in clusters and field is due to the fact that galaxies of given mass and morphology form their stars sooner in clusters than in the field .
these results point to an accelerated formation in high mass haloes compared to low mass ones even for galaxies that will end up having the same galaxy mass today .
we acknowledge the anonymous referee for her / his careful report , important suggestions and comments which helped us improving our work .
we thank joe liske , simon driver and the whole mgc team for making easily accessible a great data set .
we are grateful to the rest of the wings team for help and useful discussions .
vg and bmp acknowledge financial support from the istituto nazionale di astrofisica through a phd cycle 30th grant .
bv was supported by the world premier international research center initiative ( wpi ) , mext , japan and by the kakenhi grant - in - aid for young scientists ( b)(26870140 ) from the japan society for the promotion of science ( jsps ) . 99 abazajian k. , et al . , 2003 , aj , 126 , 2081 abramson l. e. , gladders m. d. , dressler a. , oemler a. , poggianti b. , vulcani b. , 2014 , arxiv , arxiv:1411.1431 allen j. t. , et al . , 2015 , mnras , 446 , 1567 baldry i. k. , balogh m. l. , bower r. g. , glazebrook k. , nichol r. c. , bamford s. p. , budavari t. , 2006 , mnras , 373 , 469 bernardi m. , et al . , 2003 , aj , 125 , 1849 bertelli g. , bressan a. , chiosi c. , fagotto f. , nasi e. , 1994 , a&as , 106 , 275 bothwell m. s. , et al . , 2011 , mnras , 415 , 1815 bouwens r. j. , et al . , 2012 ,
apj , 752 , l5 bouwens r. j. , et al .
, 2012 , apj , 754 , 83 bouwens r. j. , et al . , 2014 , apj , 795 , 126 bressan a. , granato g. l. , silva l. , 1998 , a&a , 332 , 135 brinchmann j. , charlot s. , white s. d. m. , tremonti c. , kauffmann g. , heckman t. , brinkmann j. , 2004 , mnras , 351 , 1151 bundy k. , et al . , 2015 , apj , 798 , 7 burgarella d. , et al .
, 2013 , a&a , 554 , aa70 calvi r. , poggianti b. m. , vulcani b. , 2011 , mnras , 416 , 727 calvi r. , poggianti b. m. , fasano g. , vulcani b. , 2012 , mnras , 419 , l14 calvi r. , poggianti b. m. , vulcani b. , fasano g. , 2013 , mnras , 432 , 3141 cappellari m. , et al . , 2012 ,
nature , 484 , 485 cardelli j. a. , clayton g. c. , mathis j. s. , 1989 , apj , 345 , 245 cava a. , et al . , 2009 , a&a , 495 , 707 cid fernandes r. , gu q. , melnick j. , terlevich e. , terlevich r. , kunth d. , rodrigues lacerda r. , joguet b. , 2004 , mnras , 355 , 273 cid fernandes r. , et al .
, 2013 , a&a , 557 , a86 colless m. , et al . , 2001 ,
mnras , 328 , 1039 conroy c. , 2013 , ara&a , 51 , 393 cooper m. c. , et al . , 2006 , mnras , 370 , 198 cooper m. c. , et al . , 2010 , mnras , 409 , 337 cowie l. l. , songaila a. , hu e. m. , cohen j. g. , 1996 , aj , 112 , 839 cucciati o. , et al . , 2006 , a&a , 458 , 39 cucciati o. , et al . , 2012 , a&a , 539 , aa31 daddi e. , et al . , 2007 , apj , 670 , 156 dahlen t. , mobasher b. , dickinson m. , ferguson h. c. , giavalisco m. , kretchmer c. , ravindranath s. , 2007 , apj , 654 , 172 davis m. , geller m. j. , 1976 , apj , 208 , 13 de lucia g. , et al . , 2007 , mnras , 374 , 809 de lucia g. , blaizot , j. , 2007 , mnras , 375 , 214 dressler a. , et al . , 1997 , apj , 490 , 577 dressler a. , 1980 , apj , 236 , 351 driver s. p. , liske j. , cross n. j. g. , de propris r. , allen p. d. , 2005 , mnras , 360 , 81 driver s. p. , robotham a. s. g. , bland - hawthorn j. , brown m. , hopkins a. , liske j. , phillipps s. , wilkins s. , 2013 , mnras , 430 , 2622 ebeling h. , voges w. , bohringer h. , edge a. c. , huchra j. p. , briel u. g. , 1996 , mnras , 281 , 799 ebeling h. , edge a. c. , bohringer h. , allen s. w. , crawford c. s. , fabian a. c. , voges w. , huchra j. p. , 1998 ,
mnras , 301 , 881 ebeling h. , edge a. c. , allen s. w. , crawford c. s. , fabian a. c. , huchra j. p. , 2000 , mnras , 318 , 333 fasano g. , et al . , 2006 , a&a , 445 , 805 fasano g. , vanzella e. , wings team , 2007 , aspc , 374 , 495 fasano g. , et al . , 2012 , mnras , 420 , 926 ferland g. j. , 1996 , hazy , a brief introduction to cloudy , univ .
kentucky phys .
rep finn r. a. , et al . , 2005 , apj , 630 , 206 franx m. , van dokkum p. g. , schreiber n. m. f. , wuyts s. , labb i. , toft s. , 2008 , apj , 688 , 770 fritz j. , et al . , 2007 , a&a , 470 , 137 fritz j. , et al . , 2011 ,
a&a , 526 , aa45 fritz j. , et al . , 2014 , a&a , 566 , aa32 gavazzi g. , boselli a. , cortese l. , arosio i. , gallazzi a. , pedotti p. , carrasco l. , 2006 , a&a , 446 , 839 gonzlez delgado r. m. , et al . , 2014 , a&a , 562 , a47 gruppioni c. , et al . , 2013 , mnras , 432 , 23 haines c. p. , gargiulo a. , la barbera f. , mercurio a. , merluzzi p. , busarello g. , 2007 , mnras , 381 , 7 hao c .- n . , kennicutt r. c. , johnson b. d. , calzetti d. , dale d. a. , moustakas j. , 2011 , apj , 741 , 124 heavens a. f. , jimenez r. , lahav o. , 2000 , mnras , 317 , 965 heavens a. , panter b. , jimenez r. , dunlop j. , 2004 , nature , 428 , 625 hopkins a. m. , beacom j. f. , 2006 , apj , 651 , 142 iovino a. , et al . , 2010 , a&a , 509 , aa40 jacoby g. h. , hunter d. a. , christian c. a. , 1984 , apjs , 56 , 257 karim a. , et al . , 2011 , apj , 730 , 61 kauffmann g. , heckman t. m. , de lucia g. , brinchmann j. , charlot s. , tremonti c. , white s. d. m. , brinkmann j. , 2006 , mnras , 367 , 1394 kodama t. , bower r. g. , 2001 , mnras , 321 , 18 koleva m. , prugniel p. , bouchard a. , wu y. , 2009 , a&a , 501 , 1269 la barbera f. , pasquali a. , ferreras i. , gallazzi a. , de carvalho r. r. , de la rosa i. g. , 2014 , mnras , 445 , 1977 lara - lpez m. a. , et al . , 2013 , mnras , 434 , 451 lilly s. j. , le fevre o. , hammer f. , crampton d. , 1996 , apj , 460 , l1 lin l. , et al . , 2014 , apj , 782 , 33 macarthur l. a. , gonzlez j. j. , courteau s. , 2009 , mnras , 395 , 28 madau p. , ferguson h. c. , dickinson m. e. , giavalisco m. , steidel c. c. , fruchter a. , 1996 , mnras , 283 , 1388 madau p. , dickinson m. , 2014 , ara&a , 52 , 415 magnelli b. , elbaz d. , chary r. r. , dickinson m. , le borgne d. , frayer d. t. , willmer c. n. a. , 2011 , a&a , 528 , aa35 magnelli b. , et al . , 2013 , a&a , 553 , aa132 marziani p. , donofrio m. , bettoni d. , fasano g. , fritz j. , poggianti b. m. , cava a. , 2013 , an , 334 , 412 mcgee s. l. , balogh m. l. , wilman d. j. , bower r. g. , mulchaey j. s. , parker l. c. , oemler a. , 2011 , mnras , 413 , 996 muzzin a. , et al .
, 2012 , apj , 746 , 188 noeske k. g. , et al .
, 2007 , apj , 660 , l43 ocvirk p. , pichon c. , lanon a. , thibaut e. , 2006 , mnras , 365 , 46 ocvirk p. , pichon c. , lanon a. , thibaut e. , 2006 , mnras , 365 , 74 oemler a. , jr .
, 1974 , apj , 194 , 1 oesch p. a. , et al . , 2010 , apj , 714 , l47 omand c. m. b. , balogh m. l. , poggianti b. m. , 2014 , mnras , 440 , 843 panter b. , jimenez r. , heavens a. f. , charlot s. , 2007 , mnras , 378 , 1550 papovich c. , dickinson m. , ferguson h. c. , 2001 , apj , 559 , 620 pasquali a. , gallazzi a. , fontanot f. , van den bosch f. c. , de lucia g. , mo h. j. , yang x. , 2010 , mnras , 407 , 937 peng y .- j .
, et al . , 2010 ,
apj , 721 , 193 peng y .- j . , lilly s. j. , renzini a. , carollo m. , 2012 , apj , 757 , 4 poggianti b. m. , bressan a. , franceschini a. , 2001 , apj , 550 , 195 poggianti b. m. , et al . , 2006 , apj , 642 , 188 poggianti b. m. , et al .
, 2013 , apj , 762 , 77 popesso p. , et al . , 2014 ,
arxiv , arxiv:1407.8214 popesso p. , et al . , 2014 ,
arxiv , arxiv:1407.8231 reddy n. a. , steidel c. c. , 2009 , apj , 692 , 778 robotham a. s. g. , driver s. p. , 2011
, mnras , 413 , 2570 rodighiero g. , et al . , 2011 , apj , 739 , l40 salim s. , et al . , 2007 , apjs , 173 , 267 salpeter e. e. , 1955 , apj , 121 , 161 snchez s. f. , et al . , 2012 , a&a , 538 , a8 snchez - blzquez p. , et al . , 2006 , mnras , 371 , 703 snchez - blzquez p. , et al . , 2009 , a&a , 499 , 47 sanders d. b. , mazzarella j. m. , kim d .- c . ,
surace j. a. , soifer b. t. , 2003 , aj , 126 , 1607 schenker m. a. , et al . , 2013 ,
apj , 768 , 196 schiminovich d. , et al . , 2005 , apj , 619 , l47 smith r. j. , lucey j. r. , hudson m. j. , 2009 , mnras , 400 , 1690 smith r. j. , lucey j. r. , price j. , hudson m. j. , phillipps s. , 2012 , mnras , 419 , 3167 sobral d. , best p. n. , smail i. , geach j. e. , cirasuolo m. , garn t. , dalton g. b. , 2011 , mnras , 411 , 675 sobral d. , smail i. , best p. n. , geach j. e. , matsuda y. , stott j. p. , cirasuolo m. , kurk j. , 2013 , mnras , 428 , 1128 sobral d. , best p. n. , smail i. , mobasher b. , stott j. , nisbet d. , 2014 , mnras , 437 , 3516 speagle j. s. , steinhardt c. l. , capak p. l. , silverman j. d. , 2014 , apjs , 214 , 15 spitzer l. , jr .
, baade w. , 1951 , apj , 113 , 413 springel v. , et al . , 2005 , natur , 435 , 629 takeuchi t. t. , yoshikawa k. , ishii t. t. , 2003 , apj , 587 , l89 thomas d. , maraston c. , bender r. , mendes de oliveira c. , 2005 , apj , 621 , 673 thomas d. , maraston c. , schawinski k. , sarzi m. , silk j. , 2010 , mnras , 404 , 1775 tojeiro r. , heavens a. f. , jimenez r. , panter b. , 2007 , mnras , 381 , 1252 tojeiro r. , wilkins s. , heavens a. f. , panter b. , jimenez r. , 2009 , apjs , 185 , 1 tojeiro r. , et al .
, 2013 , mnras , 432 , 359 van der wel a. , bell e. f. , van den bosch f. c. , gallazzi a. , rix h .- w . , 2009 , apj , 698 , 1232 varela j. , et al . , 2009 , a&a , 497 , 667 vulcani b. , et al . , 2011 , mnras , 413 , 921 vulcani b. , de lucia g. , poggianti b. m. , bundy k. , more s. , calvi r. , 2014 , apj , 788 , 57 vulcani b. , poggianti b. m. , fritz j. , fasano g. , moretti a. , calvi r. , paccagnella a. , 2015 , apj , 798
, 52 wake d. a. , van dokkum p. g. , franx m. , 2012 , apj , 751 , l44 wetzel a. r. , tinker j. l. , conroy c. , 2012 , mnras , 424 , 232 whitaker k. e. , van dokkum p. g. , brammer g. , franx m. , 2012 , apj , 754 , l29 wilman d. j. , et al . , 2005 , mnras , 358 , 88 wyder t. k. , et al .
, 2005 , apj , 619 , l15 wuyts s. , et al . , 2012 ,
apj , 753 , 114 yang x. , mo h. j. , van den bosch f. c. , pasquali a. , li c. , barden m. , 2007 , apj , 671 , 153 yang x. , mo h. j. , van den bosch f. c. , 2008 , apj , 676 , 248 zibetti s. , charlot s. , rix h .- w . , 2009 , mnras , 400 , 1181 | we analyze the star formation history ( sfh ) of galaxies as a function of present - day environment , galaxy stellar mass and morphology .
the sfh is derived by means of a non - parametric spectrophotometric model applied to individual galaxies at @xmath0 in the wide - field nearby galaxy - cluster survey ( wings ) clusters and the padova millennium galaxy and group catalogue ( pm2gc ) field .
the field reconstructed evolution of the star formation rate density ( sfrd ) follows the values observed at each redshift , except at @xmath1 where our estimate is @xmath2 higher than the high - z observed value .
the slope of the sfrd decline with time gets progressively steeper going from low mass to high mass haloes .
the decrease of the sfrd since @xmath3 is due to 1 ) quenching 50% of the sfrd in the field and 75% in clusters at @xmath1 originated in galaxies that are passive today and 2 ) the fact that the average sfr of today s star - forming galaxies has decreased with time .
we quantify the contribution to the sfrd(z ) of galaxies of today s different masses and morphologies .
the current morphology correlates with the current star formation activity but is irrelevant for the past stellar history .
the average sfh depends on galaxy mass , but galaxies of a given mass have different histories depending on their environment .
we conclude that the variation of the sfrd(z ) with environment is not driven by different distributions of galaxy masses and morphologies in clusters and field , and must be due to an accelerated formation in high mass haloes compared to low mass ones even for galaxies that will end up having the same galaxy mass today .
[ firstpage ] galaxies : clusters : general galaxies : evolution galaxies : formation galaxies : star formation . |
the large magellanic cloud ( lmc ) is one of our closest neighbor galaxies at a distance of @xmath0 .
the sagitarrius dwarf is closer at @xmath1 , but its contrast with respect to the milky way foreground stars is so low that it was discovered only about a decade ago .
the lmc is therefore the closest , big , easily observable galaxy from our vantage point in the milky way . as such
, it has become a benchmark for studies on various topics .
it is of fundamental importance for studies of stellar populations and the interstellar medium ( ism ) , it is being used to study the presence of dark objects in the galactic halo through microlensing ( e.g. , alcock et al .
2000a ) , and it plays a key role in determinations of the cosmological distance scale ( e.g. , freedman et al .
for all these applications it is important to have an understanding of the structure and kinematics of the lmc .
this is the topic of the present review . for information on other aspects of the lmc
, the reader is referred to the book by westerlund ( 1997 ) .
the book by van den bergh ( 2000 ) discusses more generally how the properties of the lmc compare to those of other galaxies in the local group .
the small magellanic cloud ( smc ) at a distance of @xmath2 is a little further from us than the lmc , and is about 5 times less massive .
its structure is more irregular than that of the lmc , and it is less well studied and understood .
recent studies of smc structure and kinematics include the work by hatzidimitriou et al .
( 1997 ) , udalski et al .
( 1998 ) , stanimirovic et al .
( 1999 , 2004 ) , kunkel , demers & irwin ( 2000 ) , cioni , habing & israel ( 2000b ) , zaritsky et al .
( 2000 , 2002 ) , crowl et al .
( 2001 ) and maragoudaki et al .
however , our overall understanding of smc structure and kinematics has not evolved much since the reviews by westerlund and van den bergh .
the present review is therefore restricted to the lmc .
the lmc consists of an outer body that appears elliptical in projection on the sky , with a pronounced , off - center bar .
the appearance in the optical wavelength regime is dominated by the bar , regions of strong star formation , and patchy dust absorption .
the lmc is generally considered an irregular galaxy as a result of these characteristics .
it is in fact the prototype of the class of galaxies called `` magellanic irregulars '' ( de vaucouleurs & freeman 1973 ) .
detailed studies of the morphological characteristics of the lmc have been performed using many different tracers , including optically detected starlight ( bothun & thompson 1988 ; schmidt - kaler & gochermann 1992 ) , stellar clusters ( lynga & westerlund 1963 ; kontizas et al .
1990 ) , planetary nebulae ( meatheringham et al .
1988 ) and non - thermal radio emission ( alvarez , aparici & may 1987 ) .
recent progress has come primarily from studies of stars on the red giant branch ( rgb ) and asymptotic giant branch ( agb ) and from studies of hi gas .
= 0.6 recently , two important near - ir surveys have become available for studies of the magellanic clouds , the two micron all sky survey ( 2mass ; e.g. , skrutskie 1998 ) and the deep near - infrared southern sky survey ( denis ; e.g. , epchtein et al .
cross - correlations of the data from these surveys and from other catalogs are now available as well ( delmotte et al
. 2002 ) .
the surveys are perfect for a study of lmc morphology and structure .
near - ir data is quite insensitive to dust absorption , which is a major complicating factor in optical studies ( zaritsky , harris & thompson 1997 ; zaritsky 1999 ; udalski et al .
2000 ; alcock et al .
the surveys have superb statistics with of the order of a million stars .
also , the observational strategy with three near - ir bands ( @xmath3 , @xmath4 and @xmath5 in the 2mass survey ; @xmath6 , @xmath3 and @xmath5 in the denis survey ) allows clear separation of different stellar populations .
in particular , the data are ideal for studies of evolved rgb and agb stars , which emit much of their light in the near - ir .
this is important for studies of lmc structure , because these intermediate - age and old stars are more likely to trace the underlying mass distribution of the lmc disk than younger populations that dominate the light in optical images .
figure [ f : cmds ] shows the @xmath7 color - magnitude diagram ( cmd ) for the lmc region of the sky .
several finger - like features are visible , each due to different stellar populations in the lmc or in the foreground ( nikolaev & weinberg 2000 ; cioni et al . 2000a ; marigo , girardi & chiosi 2003 ) .
the lmc features of primary interest in the present context are indicated in the figure , namely the red giant branch ( rgb ) , the tip of the rgb ( trgb ) , the oxygen - rich agb stars , and the carbon - rich agb stars ( `` carbon stars '' ) .
van der marel ( 2001 ) used the color cut shown in the figure to extract a sample from the 2mass and denis datasets that is dominated by rgb and agb stars .
these stars were used to make the number - density map of the lmc shown in figure [ f : maps ] .
kontizas et al .
( 2001 ) showed the distribution on the sky of @xmath8 carbon stars identified by eye from optical objective prism plates .
their map does not show all the rich detail visible in figure [ f : maps ] , but it is otherwise in good agreement with it .
= 0.6 the near - ir map of the lmc is surprisingly smooth .
the morphology is much less irregular than it is for the the younger stellar populations that dominate the optical light .
apart from the central bar there is a hint of some spiral structure , as discussed previously by , e.g. , de vaucouleurs & freeman ( 1973 ) .
however , the spiral features all have very low contrast with respect to their surroundings , and there is certainly no well organized spiral pattern in the lmc .
quantitative analysis can be performed on the basis of ellipse fits to the number density contours .
this yields a surface number density profile that can be fit reasonably well fit by an exponential with a scale length of @xmath9 ( @xmath10 ) .
the radial profiles of the ellipticity @xmath11 ( defined as @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the axial ratio ) and the major axis position angle @xmath14 both show pronounced variations as function of distance from the lmc center , due to the presence of the central bar .
however , at radii @xmath15 the contour shapes converge to an approximately constant position angle @xmath16 and ellipticity @xmath17 .
= 0.6 to study the distribution of hi in the lmc on small scales requires many pointings to cover the lmc at high angular resolution .
kim et al . ( 1998 ) used the australia telescope compact array ( atca ) to obtain a map that is sensitive on scales of 15@xmath18 . on these scales ,
the morphology is dominated by hi filaments with numerous shells and holes .
the turbulent and fractal nature of the ism on these scales is the result of dynamical feedback into the ism from star formation processes . in the context of the present review we are more interested in the large scale distribution of hi gas
this issue has been studied for decades , including work by mcgee & milton ( 1966 ) , rohlfs et al .
( 1984 ) and luks & rohlfs ( 1992 ) .
most recently , staveley - smith et al .
( 2003 ) obtained the map shown in figure [ f : himap ] , using a multibeam survey with the parkes telescope .
this map is sensitive to spatial structure in the range @xmath19 to @xmath20 .
the hi distribution is very patchy ( see also kim et al .
2003 , who combined the data of kim et al .
[ 1998 ] and staveley - smith et al .
[ 2003 ] into a single map that is sensitive to structures on all scales down to @xmath21 ) .
the hi in the lmc is not centrally concentrated and the brightest areas are several degrees from the center .
the overall distribution is approximately circular and there is no sign of a bar .
all of these characteristics are strikingly different from the stellar distribution shown in figure [ f : maps ] .
figure [ f : hioverlay ] shows contours of the hi distribution on a somewhat larger scale , from the hipass data presented in putman et al .
( 2003 ) , overlaid on the lmc near - ir star count map from figure [ f : maps ] .
this comparison suggests that collisionless tracers such as rgb and agb stars are best suited to study the structure and mass distribution of the lmc disk , whereas hi gas may be better suited to study the effects of tidal interactions .
the stream of gas towards the right of figure [ f : hioverlay ] is the start of the magellanic bridge towards the smc , which provides one of the many pieces of evidence for strong tidal interactions between the lmc , the milky way and the smc .
figure [ f : stream ] shows a wide - area hi map of the magallanic system .
the most prominent feature is the magellanic stream , a @xmath22 wide filament with @xmath23 of neutral hydrogen that spans more than @xmath24 across the sky ( e.g. , westerlund 1997 ; putman et al .
it consists of gas that trails the magellanic clouds as they orbit the milky way .
a less prominent leading gas component was recently discovered as well ( lu et al .
1998 ; putman et al .
1998 ) , the start of which is seen at the left in figure [ f : stream ] .
= many detailed theoretical models have been constructed for the magellanic stream ( e.g. , murai & fujimoto 1980 ; lin & lynden - bell 1982 ; shuter 1992 ; liu 1992 ; heller & rohlfs 1994 ; gardiner , sawa & fujimoto 1994 ; moore & davis 1994 ; lin , jones & klemola 1995 ; gardiner & noguchi 1996 ; yoshizawa & noguchi 2003 ; mastropietro et al .
2004 ; conners et al .
models in which tidal stripping is the dominating process have been particularly successful .
the most sophisticated recent calculations in this class are those by yoshizawa & noguchi ( 2003 ) and conners et al .
( 2004 ) , both of which build on earlier work by gardiner & noguchi ( 1996 ) . in these models
the lmc and smc form a gravitationally bound system that orbits the milky way .
the magellanic stream and the leading arm represent material that was stripped from the smc @xmath25 ago .
this was the time of the previous perigalactic passage , which coincided with a close encounter between the clouds .
the models successfully reproduce many properties of the magellanic stream , including its position , morphology , width variation , and the velocity profile along the stream .
the models also explain the presence of the leading arm , and why it is less prominent than the trailing stream .
given the successes of tidal models , it has always been surprising that no population of stars associated with the stream has ever been found ( e.g. , irwin 1991 ; guhathakurta & reitzel 1998 ; majewski et al .
2003 ) . in a tidal model where the stripping is dominated by gravity
, one might naively expect that both stars and gas are stripped equally .
however , galaxies generally have hi gas disks that are more extended than the stellar distribution .
since material is preferentially stripped from the outskirts of a galaxy , this can explain why there may not be any stars associated with the stream ( yoshizawa & noguchi 2003 ) .
alternatively , it has been argued that the lack of stars in the stream may point to important contributions from other physical processes than tidal effects . for example ,
moore & davis ( 1994 ) and mastropietro et al .
( 2004 ) suggest that the stream consists of material which was ram - pressure stripped from the lmc during its last passage through a hot ( @xmath26 k ) ionized halo component of the milky way .
another alternative was proposed by heller & rohlfs ( 1994 ) , who suggested that hydrodynamical forces ( rather than gravitational / tidal forces ) during a recent lmc - smc interaction are responsible for the existence of the stream .
models of the magellanic stream have traditionally used the properties of the stream to estimate the orbit of the lmc , rather than to base the calculations on estimates of the lmc proper motion .
an important characteristic of the orbit is the present - day tangential velocity in galactocentric coordinates , for which values have been inferred that include @xmath27 ( lin & lynden - bell 1982 ) , @xmath28 ( shuter 1992 ) , @xmath29 ( heller & rohlfs 1994 ) , @xmath30 ( murai & fujimoto 1980 ) , @xmath31 ( liu 1992 ) and @xmath32 ( gardiner et al .
1994 ; gardiner & noguchi 1996 ) , respectively .
proper motion measurements have improved significantly over time , and it is now known that @xmath33 ( as discussed in detail in section [ s : orbit ] ) . this is consistent with the lower range of the values predicted by models for the stream .
the data are most consistent with the models of gardiner & noguchi ( 1996 ) and their follow - ups , which also provide some of the best fits to many other properties of the magellanic stream .
the observational error on @xmath34 is almost small enough to start ruling out some of the other models .
it is possible that future proper motion measurements may yield a much more accurate determination of the lmc orbit .
models of the magellanic stream then hold the promise of providing important constraints on the mass , shape , and radial density profile of the milky way s dark halo ( e.g. , lin et al .
to understand the tidal interactions in the magellanic system it is important to know the orbit of the lmc around the milky way .
this requires knowledge of all three of the velocity components of the lmc center of mass .
the line - of - sight velocity can be accurately determined from the doppler velocities of tracers ( see section [ s : kinematics ] ) . by contrast
, determination of the velocity in the plane of the sky is much more difficult . for the lmc ,
proper motion determinations are available from the following sources : kroupa et al .
( 1994 ) , using stars from the ppm catalogue ; jones , klemola & lin ( 1994 ) , using photographic plates with a 14 year epoch span ; kroupa & bastian ( 1997 ) , using hipparcos data ; drake et al .
( 2002 ) , using data from the macho project ; and anguita , loyola & pedreros ( 2000 ) and pedreros , anguita & maza ( 2002 ) , using ccd frames with an 11 year epoch span .
some of the measurements pertain to fields in the outer parts in the lmc disk , and require corrections for the orientation and rotation of the lmc disk .
the measurements are all more - or - less consistent with each other to within the error bars .
the exception to this is the anguita et al .
result , which almost certainly suffers from an unidentified systematic error .
when this latter result is ignored , the weighted average of the remaining measurements yields proper motions towards the west and north of ( van der marel et al .
2002 ) @xmath35 transformation of the proper motion to a space velocity in @xmath36 requires knowledge of the lmc distance @xmath37 .
many techniques have been used over the years to estimate the lmc distance , but unfortunately , there continue to be systematic differences between the results from different techniques that far exceed the formal errors .
it is beyond the scope of the present review to address this topic in detail . instead
, the reader is refered to the recent reviews by , e.g. , westerlund ( 1997 ) , gibson et al .
( 2000 ) , freedman et al .
( 2001 ) and alves ( 2004b ) .
freedman et al .
adopt a distance modulus @xmath38 on the basis of a review of all published work .
this corresponds to @xmath39 . at this distance ,
a proper motion of @xmath40 corresponds to @xmath41 and 1 degree on the sky corresponds to @xmath42 .
combination of the distance and proper motion of the lmc yields velocities @xmath43 and @xmath44 towards the west and north , respectively , with errors of @xmath45 in each direction .
this can be combined with the observed line - of - sight velocity , @xmath46 ( see section [ ss : carbonstars ] ) , to obtain the three - dimensional motion of the lmc with respect to the milky way .
it is usual to adopt a cartesian coordinate system @xmath47 , with the origin at the galactic center , the @xmath48-axis pointing towards the galactic north pole , the @xmath49-axis pointing in the direction from the sun to the galactic center , and the @xmath50-axis pointing in the direction of the sun s galactic rotation .
the observed lmc velocities must be corrected for the reflex motion of the sun , which is easily done with use of standard estimates for the position and velocity of the sun with respect to the galactic center .
the @xmath47 position of the lmc is then found to be ( van der marel et al .
2002 ) @xmath51 and its three - dimensional space velocity is @xmath52 this corresponds to a distance of @xmath53 from the galactic center , and a total velocity of @xmath54 in the galactocentric rest frame .
the motion has a radial component of @xmath55 pointing away from the galactic center , and a tangential component of @xmath56 .
the proper motion of the smc is known only with errors of @xmath57 in each coordinate ( kroupa & bastian 1997 ) , which is five times less accurate than for the lmc . however , to within these errors the smc is known to have a galactocentric velocity vector that agrees with that of the lmc .
the combination of a small but positive radial velocity and a tangential velocity that exceeds the circular velocity of the milky way halo implies that the lmc must be just past pericenter in its orbit .
the calculation of an actual orbit requires knowledge of the three - dimensional shape and the radial profile of the gravitational potential of the milky way dark halo .
gardiner et al . ( 1994 ) and gardiner & noguchi ( 1996 ) calculated orbits in a spherical milky way halo potential with a rotation curve that stays flat at @xmath58 out to a galactocentric distance of at least @xmath59 . such a potential is consistent with our present understanding of the milky way dark halo ( kochanek 1996 ; wilkinson & evans 1999 ; ibata et al .
the calculations properly take into account that the lmc and smc orbit each other while their center of mass orbits the milky way .
however , since the lmc is more massive than the smc , its motion is not too different from that of the lmc - smc center of mass . for an assumed present - day lmc velocity @xmath60 consistent with that given in equation ( [ lmcvelres ] ) the apocenter to pericenter ratio is inferred to be @xmath61 .
the perigalactic distance is @xmath62 and the orbital period around the milky way is @xmath25 .
the kinematical properties of the lmc provide important clues to its structure .
observations have therefore been obtained for many tracers .
the kinematics of gas in the lmc have been studied primarily using hi ( e.g. , rohlfs et al .
1984 ; luks & rohlfs 1992 ; kim et al . 1998 ) .
discrete lmc tracers which have been studied kinematically include star clusters ( freeman , illingworth & oemler 1983 ; schommer et al .
1992 ) , planetary nebulae ( meatheringham et al .
1988 ) , hii regions and supergiants ( feitzinger , schmidt - kaler & isserstedt 1977 ) , and carbon stars ( kunkel et al . 1997b ; graff et al .
2000 ; alves & nelson 2000 ; van der marel et al .
a common result from all these studies is that the line - of - sight velocity dispersion of the tracers is generally at least a factor @xmath63 smaller than their rotation velocity .
this implies that the lmc is kinematically cold , and must therefore to lowest approximation be a disk system . to understand the kinematics of an lmc tracer population it is necessary to have a general model for the line - of - sight velocity field that can be fit to the data .
all studies thus far have been based on the assumption that the mean streaming ( i.e. , the rotation ) in the disk plane can be approximated to be circular .
however , even with this simplifying assumption it is not straightforward to model the kinematics of the lmc , because it is so near to us .
its main body spans more than @xmath64 on the sky and one therefore can not make the usual approximation that `` the sky is flat '' over the area of the galaxy .
spherical trigonometry must be used , which yields the general expression ( van der marel et al .
2002 ) : @xmath65 with @xmath66^{1/2 } } } } .\ ] ] in this equation , @xmath67 is the observed component of the velocity along the line of sight .
the quantities @xmath68 identify the position on the sky : @xmath69 is the angular distance from the center and @xmath70 is the position angle with respect to the center ( measured from north over east ) .
the kinematical center is at the center of mass ( cm ) of the galaxy .
the quantities @xmath71 describe the velocity of the cm in an inertial frame in which the sun is at rest : @xmath72 is the systemic velocity along the line of sight , @xmath73 is the transverse velocity , and @xmath74 is the position angle of the transverse velocity on the sky .
the angles @xmath75 describe the direction from which the plane of the galaxy is viewed : @xmath76 is the inclination angle ( @xmath77 for a face - on disk ) , and @xmath78 is the position angle of the line of nodes , as illustrated in figure [ f : drawviewang ] . the line - of - nodes is the intersection of the galaxy plane and the sky plane .
the velocity @xmath79 is the rotation velocity at cylindrical radius @xmath80 in the disk plane .
@xmath37 is the distance to the cm , and @xmath81 is a geometrical factor .
the quantity @xmath82 is the ` spin sign ' that determines in which of the two possible directions the disk rotates .
= 0.6 the first term in equation ( [ vfield ] ) corresponds to the internal rotation of the lmc .
the second term is the part of the line - of - sight velocity of the cm that is seen along the line of sight , and the third term is the part of the transverse velocity of the cm that is seen along the line of sight . for a galaxy that spans a small area on the sky ( very small @xmath69 ) ,
the second term is simply @xmath72 and the third term is zero .
however , the lmc does not have a small angular extent and the inclusion of the third term is particularly important .
it corresponds to a solid - body rotation component .
given the lmc transverse velocity implied by equation ( [ weightb ] ) , it rises to an amplitude of @xmath83 at @xmath84 , which significantly exceeds the amplitude of the intrinsic rotation contribution ( first term of eq .
[ [ vfield ] ] ) at that radius .
the fourth term in equation ( [ vfield ] ) describes the line - of - sight component due to changes in the inclination of the disk with time , as are expected due to precession and nutation of the lmc disk plane as it orbits the milky way ( weinberg 2000 ) .
this term also corresponds to a solid - body rotation component .
the general expression in equation ( [ vfield ] ) appears complicated , but it is possible to gain some intuitive insight by considering some special cases . along the line of nodes one
has that @xmath85 and @xmath86 , so that @xmath87 .\ ] ] here it has been defined that @xmath88 .
the quantity @xmath89 is the component of the transverse velocity vector in the plane of the sky that lies along the line of nodes ; similarly , @xmath90 is the component perpendicular to the line of nodes .
perpendicular to the line of nodes one has that @xmath91 and @xmath92 , and therefore @xmath93 here it has been defined that @xmath94 .
this implies that perpendicular to the line of nodes @xmath95 is linearly proportional to @xmath96 .
by contrast , along the line of nodes this is true only if @xmath79 is a linear function of @xmath80 .
this is not expected to be the case , because galaxies do not generally have solid - body rotation curves ; disk galaxies tend to have flat rotation curves , at least outside the very center .
this implies that , at least in principle , both the position angle @xmath78 of the line of nodes and the quantity @xmath97 are uniquely determined by the observed velocity field : @xmath78 is the angle along which the observed @xmath95 are best fit by a linear proportionality with @xmath96 , and @xmath97 is the proportionality constant .
= 0.8 among the discrete tracers in the lmc that have been studied kinematically , carbon stars have yielded some of the largest and most useful datasets in recent years .
van der marel et al .
( 2002 ) fitted the general velocity field expression in equation ( [ vfield ] ) to the data for 1041 carbon stars , obtained from the work of kunkel et al .
( 1997a ) and hardy , schommer & suntzeff ( unpublished ) .
the combined dataset samples both the inner and the outer parts of the lmc , although with a discontinuous distribution in radius and position angle . figure [ f : fit ] shows the data , with the best model fit overplotted .
overall , the model provides a good fit to the data .
= 0.6 as discussed in section [ ss : generalexp ] , the line - of - nodes position angle is uniquely determined by the data ; the model yields @xmath98 .
the lmc inclination can not be determined kinematically , but it is known reasonably well from other considerations ( see section [ s : viewing ] ) . with both viewing angles and the lmc proper motion known , the rotation curve @xmath79 follows from equation ( [ vlosalong ] ) .
the result is shown in figure [ f : rotcurve ] .
the inferred rotation curve @xmath79 rises linearly in the central region and is roughly flat at @xmath99 for @xmath100 .
the negative value at the innermost radius @xmath101 has limited significance ; it is probably affected by the sparse coverage of the data at these radii ( see figure [ f : fit ] ) , as well as potential non - circular streaming motions in the region of the bar .
the error bars on @xmath79 in figure [ f : rotcurve ] reflect the random errors due to the sampling of the data . however , there are also contributions from the errors in the line - of - nodes position angle @xmath78 , the lmc proper motion and the inclination @xmath76
. in particular , @xmath79 scales as @xmath102 ; and if the component @xmath103 of the transverse velocity vector along the line of nodes is larger than given in equation ( [ weightb ] ) , then @xmath79 will go up .
when all uncertainties are properly accounted for , the amplitude of the flat part of the rotation curve and its formal error become @xmath104 .
when asymmetric drift is corrected for , the circular velocity in the disk plane can be calculated to be @xmath105 .
the implied total mass of the lmc inside the last measured data point is therefore @xmath106 .
by contrast , the total stellar mass of the lmc disk is @xmath107 and the mass of the neutral gas in the lmc is @xmath108 ( kim et al .
the combined mass of the visible material in the lmc is therefore insufficient to explain the dynamically inferred mass .
the lmc must therefore be embedded in a dark halo .
this is consistent with the fact that the observed rotation curve amplitude is relatively flat as a function of radius .
the lmc tidal radius can be calculated to be @xmath109 , which corresponds to an angle on the sky of @xmath110 .
the uncertainty in the tidal radius is due primarily to our ignorance of how far the lmc dark halo extends .
either way , the tidal radius extends beyond the region for which most observations of the main body of the lmc are available .
however , it should be kept in mind that the tidal radius marks the position beyond which material becomes unbound .
the structure of a galaxy can be altered well inside of this radius ( weinberg 2000 ) . as discussed in section [ ss : generalexp ] , the line - of - sight velocity field constrains the value of @xmath111 .
the carbon stars yield @xmath112 . given our knowledge of the proper motion and distance of the lmc ( see section [ s : orbit ] ) this implies that @xmath113 .
the lmc is the first galaxy for which it has been possible to measure @xmath114 .
the @xmath115-body simulations by weinberg ( 2000 ) show that the tidal torques from the milky way are expected to induce precession and nutation in the symmetry axis of the lmc disk plane .
although a detailed data - model comparison is not possible at the present time , it is comforting to note that the observed @xmath114 is of the same order as the rate of change of the disk orientation seen in the simulations .
hi gas provides another powerful method to study the kinematics of the lmc .
high quality data is available from , e.g. , kim et al .
unfortunately , the kinematical analysis presented by kim et al . was not as general as that discussed above for carbon stars .
they did not leave @xmath97 as a free parameter in the fit .
instead , they corrected their data at the outset for the transverse motion of the lmc using the proper motion measured by jones et al .
( 1994 ) , @xmath116 , and assumed that @xmath117 .
this fixes @xmath118 , which is inconsistent with the value inferred from the carbon star velocity field .
kim et al . obtained a kinematic line of nodes that is both twisting with radius and inconsistent with the value determined from the carbon stars .
in addition , they inferred a rotation curve for which the amplitude exceeds that in figure [ f : rotcurve ] by @xmath119 .
it is likely that these results are affected by the imposed value of @xmath97 .
a more general analysis of the hi kinematics is therefore desirable , but unfortunately , is not currently available .
the same limitations apply to many of the other published studies of lmc tracer kinematics cited at the start of section [ s : kinematics ] .
independent of how the data are analyzed , it is likely that collisionless tracers provide a more appropriate means to study the structure of the lmc using equilibrium models than does hi gas .
the dynamical center of the carbon star velocity field is found to be consistent ( to within the @xmath120 per - coordinate errors ) with both the center of the bar and the center of the outer stellar contours .
however , it has long been known that the center of the hi rotation velocity field does not coincide with the center of the bar , and it also does nt coincide with the center of the outer contours of the stellar distribution .
it is offset from both by @xmath121 .
this indicates that the hi gas may not be in equilibrium in the the gravitational potential .
added evidence for this comes from the fact that the lmc and the smc are enshrouded in a common hi envelope , and that they are connected by a bridge of hi gas ( see figure [ f : stream ] ) .
even at small radii the lmc gas disk appears to be subject to tidal disturbances ( see figure [ f : hioverlay ] ) that may well affect the velocity field .
a disk that is intrinsically circular will appear elliptical in projection on the sky .
the viewing angles of the disk ( see figure [ f : drawviewang ] ) are then easily determined : the inclination is @xmath122 , where @xmath11 is the apparent ellipticity on the sky , and the line - of - nodes position angle @xmath78 is equal to the major axis position angle @xmath123 of the projected body .
the viewing angles of the lmc have often been estimated under this assumption , using the projected contours for many different types of tracers ( de vaucouleurs & freeman 1973 ; bothun & thompson 1988 ; schmidt - kaler & gochermann 1992 ; weinberg & nikolaev 2001 ; lynga & westerlund 1963 ; kontizas et al .
1990 ; feitzinger et al . 1977
; kim et al . 1998 ; alvarez et al . 1987 ) .
however , it now appears that this was incorrect .
the kinematics of carbon stars imply @xmath98 ( see section [ ss : carbonstars ] ) , whereas the near - ir morphology of the lmc implies @xmath16 ( see section [ s : morphology ] ) .
the result that @xmath124 implies that the lmc can not be intrinsically circular .
the value of @xmath14 is quite robust ; studies of other tracers have yielded very similar results , although often with larger error bars .
the result that @xmath125 therefore hinges primarily on our confidence in the inferred value of @xmath78 .
there have been other kinematical studies of the line of nodes , in addition to that described in section [ ss : carbonstars ] .
these have generally yielded values of @xmath78 that are both larger and twisting with radius ( e.g. , kim et al .
1998 ; alves & nelson 2000 ) . however , the accuracy of these results is suspect because of the important simplifying assumptions that were made in the analyses ( see section [ ss : hikin ] ) .
no allowance was made for a potential solid - body rotation component in the velocity field due to precession and nutation of the lmc disk , which is both predicted theoretically ( weinberg 2000 ) and implied observationally by the carbon star data ( see section [ ss : carbonstars ] ) .
arguably the most robust way to determine the lmc viewing angles is to use geometrical considerations , rather than kinematical ones . for an inclined disk
, one side will be closer to us than the other .
tracers on that one side will appear brighter than similar tracers on the other side .
this method does not rely on absolute distances or magnitudes , which are notoriously difficult to estimate , but only on relative distances or magnitudes .
to lowest order , the difference in magnitude between a tracer at the galaxy center and a similar tracer at a position @xmath68 in the disk ( as defined in section [ ss : generalexp ] ) is @xmath126 where the angular distance @xmath69 is expressed in degrees .
the constant in the equation is @xmath127 magnitudes .
hence , when following a circle on the sky around the galaxy center one expects a sinusoidal variation in the magnitudes of tracers .
the amplitude and phase of the variation yield estimates of the viewing angles @xmath75 .
= 0.5 van der marel & cioni ( 2001 ) used a polar grid on the sky to divide the lmc area into several rings , each consisting of a number of azimuthal segments .
the data from the denis and 2mass surveys were used for each segment to construct near - ir cmds similar to that shown in figure [ f : cmds ] . for each segment the modal magnitude ( magnitude where the luminosity function peaks ) was determined for carbon - rich agb stars selected by color , as had been suggested by weinberg & nikolaev ( 2001 ) . figure [ f : banddep ]
shows the inferred variation in magnitude as function of position angle @xmath70 for the radial range @xmath128 .
the expected sinusoidal variations are confidently detected .
the top panel shows the results for stars selected from the denis survey with the color selection criterion @xmath129 .
the bottom panel shows the results from the 2mass survey with the same color selection .
the same sinusoidal variations are seen , indicating that there are no relative calibration problems between the surveys .
also , the same variations are seen in the @xmath6 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 and @xmath5 bands , which implies that the results are not influenced significantly by dust absorption .
the middle panel shows the variations in the trgb magnitudes as a function of position angle , from the denis data .
rgb stars show the same variations as the agb stars , suggesting that the results are not influenced significantly by potential peculiarities associated with either of these stellar populations .
the observed variations can therefore be confidently interpreted as a purely geometrical effect .
the implied viewing angles are @xmath130 and @xmath131 .
the @xmath78 value thus inferred geometrically is entirely consistent with the value inferred kinematically ( see section [ ss : carbonstars ] ) . moreover , there is an observed drift in the center of the lmc isophotes at large radii which is consistent with both estimates , when interpreted as a result of viewing perspective ( van der marel 2001 ) .
the aforementioned analyses are sensitive primarily to the structure of the outer parts of the lmc .
several other studies of the viewing angles have focused mostly on the region of the bar , which samples only the central few degrees .
many of these studies have been based on cepheids .
their period - luminosity relation allows calculation of the distance to each individual cepheid from a light curve .
the relative distances of the cepheids in the sample can then be analyzed in similar fashion as discussed above to yield the lmc viewing angles .
cepheid studies in the 1980s did nt have many stars to work with .
caldwell & coulson ( 1986 ) analyzed optical data for 73 cepheids and obtained @xmath132 and @xmath133 .
laney & stobie ( 1986 ) obtained @xmath134 and @xmath135 from 14 cepheids , and welch et al .
( 1987 ) obtained @xmath136 and @xmath137 from 23 cepheids , both using near - ir data .
the early cepheid studies have now all been superseded by the work of nikolaev et al .
they analyzed a sample of more than 2000 cepheids with lightcurves from macho data .
through use of photometry in five different bands , including optical macho data and near - ir 2mass data , each star could be individually corrected for dust extinction . from a planar fit to the data they obtained @xmath138 and @xmath139 .
other recent work has used the magnitude of the red clump to analyze the relative distances of different parts of the lmc .
olsen & salyk ( 2002 ) obtained @xmath140 and @xmath141 , also from an analysis that was restricted mostly to the the inner parts of the lmc .
there is one caveat associated with all viewing angle results for the central few degrees of the lmc .
namely , it appears that the stars in this region are not distributed symmetrically around a single well - defined plane , as discussed in detail in section [ ss : nonplanar ] . in the present context
we are mainly concerned with the influence of this on the inferred viewing angles .
olsen & salyk ( 2002 ) perform their viewing angle fit by ignoring fields south - west of the bar , which do not seem to agree with the planar solution implied by their remaining fields .
by contrast , nikolaev et al . (
2004 ) fit all the stars in their sample , independent of whether or not they appear to be part of the main disk plane
. clearly , the @xmath75 results of olsen & salyk and nikolaev et al . are the best - fitting parameters of well - posed problems . however , it is somewhat unclear whether they can be assumed to be unbiased estimates of the actual lmc viewing angles . for
a proper understanding of this issue one would need to have both an empirical and a dynamical understanding of the nature of the extra - planar structures in the central region of the lmc .
only then is it possible to decide whether the concept of a single disk plane is at all meaningful in this region , and which data should be included or excluded in determining its parameters .
this is probably not an issue for the outer parts of the lmc , given that the agb star results of van der marel & cioni ( 2001 ) provide no evidence for extra - planar structures at radii @xmath142 . in summary
, all studies agree that @xmath76 is in the range @xmath143@xmath144 . at large radii
, @xmath78 appears to be in the range @xmath145@xmath146 .
by contrast , at small radii all studies indicate that @xmath78 is in the range @xmath147@xmath148 .
as mentioned , it is possible that the results at small radii are systematically in error due to the presence of out - of - plane structures .
alternatively , it is quite well possible that there are true radial variations in the lmc viewing angles due to warps and twists of the disk plane .
many authors have suggested this as a plausible interpretation of various features seen in lmc datasets ( van der marel & cioni 2001 ; olsen & salyk 2002 ; subramaniam 2003 ; nikolaev et al .
moreover , numerical simulations have shown that milky way tidal effects can drive strong warps in the lmc disk plane ( mastropietro et al .
the inferred lmc viewing angles can be used to deproject the observed morphology that is seen in projection on the sky ( van der marel 2001 ) .
this yields an in - plane ellipticity @xmath11 in the range @xmath149@xmath150 , depending somewhat on the adopted viewing angles ; e.g. , the nikolaev et al .
( 2004 ) angles give @xmath151 and the van der marel & cioni ( 2001 ) angles give @xmath152 .
the conclusion that the lmc is elongated is in itself not surprising .
the dark matter halos predicted by cosmological simulations are generally triaxial ( e.g. , dubinski & carlberg 1991 ) , and the gravitational potential in the equatorial plane of such halos does not have circular symmetry .
so it is generally expected that disk galaxies are elongated rather than circular .
furthermore , it is possible to construct self - consistent dynamical models for elliptical disks ( e.g. , teuben 1987 ) .
what is surprising is that the lmc ellipticity is fairly large .
studies of the apparent axis ratio distribution of spiral galaxy disks ( binney & de vaucouleurs 1981 ; lambas , maddox & loveday 1992 ) of the structure of individual spiral galaxies ( rix & zaritsky 1995 ; schoenmakers , franx & de zeeuw 1997 ; kornreich , haynes & lovelace 1998 ; andersen et al .
2001 ) and of the scatter in the tully - fisher relation ( franx & de zeeuw 1992 ) indicate that the average ( deprojected ) ellipticity of spiral galaxies is only 510% .
so while spiral galaxies are generally elongated , their elongation is usually smaller than inferred here for the lmc .
of course , galaxies of type sm and i m are ( by definition ) more irregular and lopsided than spirals .
so it is not a priori clear whether or not the lmc is atypically elongated for its hubble type .
it is interesting to ask what may be the cause of the large in - plane ellipticity of the lmc .
the prime candidate is distortion by the milky way tidal field .
the present - day tidal force on the lmc by the milky way exceeds that from the smc .
moreover , the milky way tidal field is responsible for other well - known features of the magellanic system , such as the magellanic stream ( see section [ s : stream ] ) .
n - body simulations have shown that the structure of the lmc can be altered significantly by the milky way tidal force ( weinberg 2000 ) and the simulations of mastropietro et al .
( 2004 ) indeed predict a considerable in - plane elongation for the lmc . also , the lmc elongation in projection on the sky points approximately towards the galacic center and is perpendicular to the magellanic stream ( van der marel 2001 ) , as predicted naturally by simulations of tidal effects ( mastropietro et al .
however , a very detailed data - model comparison is not possible at the present time . that would require accurate knowledge of the past history as a function of time of the lmc orbit , of the disk - plane orientation due to precession and nutation , and of the lmc - smc distance .
such knowledge is not available at the present time .
a consequence of the ellipticity of the lmc disk is that one can not expect the streamlines of tracers in the disk to be perfectly circular , by contrast to what has been assumed in all kinematical studies to date .
the effect of this is probably not large , because the gravitational potential of a mass distribution is always rounder than the mass distribution itself .
one effect of ellipticity is an apparent offset between the kinematical line of nodes and the true line of nodes ( schoenmakers , franx & de zeeuw 1997 ) .
this effect is presently not at observable levels , given that kinematical analysis of carbon stars ( see section [ s : kinematics ] ) yields a line - of - nodes position angle @xmath78 that is in adequate agreement with geometrical determinations ( see section [ s : viewing ] ) .
however , it should be kept in mind that , as the sophistication of the studies of lmc kinematics increases , it might become necessary to account for the effect of non - circularity on the observed kinematics .
the scale height of the lmc disk can be estimated from the observed line - of - sight velocity dispersion @xmath153 . for carbon stars , the scatter of the velocity measurements around the best - fitting rotating disk model ( figure [ f : fit ] )
yields @xmath154 .
the ratio of rotation velocity to velocity dispersion is therefore @xmath155 . for comparison
, the thin disk of the milky way has @xmath156 and its thick disk has @xmath157 .
in a relative sense one might therefore expect the lmc disk to be similar , but somewhat thicker than the milky way thick disk .
weinberg ( 2000 ) argued from @xmath115-body simulations that such considerable thickness could be the result of milky way tidal effects on the lmc .
the radial profile of the velocity dispersion contains information on the lmc scale height as function of radius .
the carbon star velocity dispersion is close to constant as function of radius , and this is not what is expected for a disk with a constant scale height . to fit this behavior
one must assume that the scale height increases with radius in the disk ( alves & nelson 2000 ) .
this can arise naturally as a result of tidal forces from the milky way , which become relatively more important ( compared to the lmc self - gravity ) as one moves to larger radii .
alves & nelson considered an isothermal disk with a vertical density profile proportional to @xmath158 , where @xmath159 can vary with disk radius .
application to the carbon star data of van der marel et al .
( 2002 ) yields @xmath160 at the lmc center , rising to @xmath161 at a radius of @xmath162 .
the lmc carbon stars are part of the intermediate - age population which is believed to be fairly representative for the bulk of the mass in the lmc . in this sense , the results inferred for the carbon star population are believed to be characteristic for the lmc as a whole . however , it is certainly not true that all populations have the same kinematics . as in the milky way ,
younger populations have a smaller velocity dispersion ( and hence a smaller scale height ) than older populations .
a summary of measurements for various populations is given by gyuk , dalal & griest ( 2000 ) .
the youngest populations ( e.g. , supergiants , hii regions , hi gas ) have dispersions of only @xmath163 .
old long - period variables have dispersions @xmath164 ( bessell , freeman & wood 1986 ) and so do the oldest star clusters ( freeman et al .
1983 ; schommer et al .
these values are considerably below the lmc circular velocity ( see section [ ss : carbonstars ] ) .
this has generally been interpreted to mean that the lmc does not have an old pressure supported halo similar to that of the milky way . the first possible evidence for the presence of a pressure supported halo was presented recently by minniti et al .
they measured a dispersion @xmath165 for a sample of 43 rr lyrae stars within @xmath166 from the lmc center .
this value is consistent with what would be expected for a pressure supported halo in equilibrium in the gravitational potential implied by the circular velocity ( alves 2004a ) .
the rr lyrae stars make up @xmath63% of the visible mass of the lmc , similar to the value for the milky way halo .
however , it is surprising that the surface density distribution of the lmc rr lyrae stars is well fit by an exponential with the same scale length as inferred for other tracers known to reside in the disk ( alves 2004a ) .
this is very different from the situation for the milky way halo , where rr lyrae stars follow a power - law density profile .
this suggests that maybe the rr lyrae stars in the lmc did form in the disk , instead of in a halo . in this scenario
they might simply have attained their large dispersions by a combination of disk heating and milky way tidal forces ( weinberg 2000 ) . to discriminate between halo and disk origins
it will be important to determine whether the velocity field of the rr lyrae stars has a rotation component .
this will require observations at larger galactocentric distances.=-2 one of the most important reasons for seeking to understand the vertical structure of the lmc is to understand the results from microlensing surveys .
the observed microlensing optical depth towards the lmc is @xmath167 with an additional 2030% of systematic error ( alcock et al .
it has generally been found that equilibrium models for the lmc do not predict enough lmc self - lensing events to account for the observed optical depth ( gyuk , dalal & griest 2000 ; jetzer , mancini & scarpetta 2002 ) .
for the most favored set of lmc model parameters in the gyuk et al . study the predicted self - lensing optical depth is @xmath168 , a factor of @xmath169 less than the observed value . to account for the lenses it is therefore necessary to assume that some @xmath170% of the milky way dark halo is made up of lenses of mass @xmath171@xmath172 ( alcock et al .
however , it is a mystery what the composition of this lensing component could be . a large population of old white dwarfs has been suggested , but this interpretation is not without problems ( e.g. , fields , freese , & graff 2000 ; flynn , holopainen , & holmberg 2003 ) .
it is therefore worthwhile to investigate whether the models that have been used to estimate the lmc self - lensing might have been oversimplified .
this is particularly important since there is evidence from the observed microlensing events themselves that many of the lenses may reside in the lmc ( sahu 2003 ) .
to lowest order , the self - lensing optical depth in simple disk models of the lmc depends exclusively on the observed velocity dispersion and not separately on either the galaxy mass or scale height ( gould 1995 ) .
one way to increase the self - lensing predicted by lmc models is therefore to assume that a much larger fraction of the lmc mass resides in high velocity dispersion populations than has previously been believed .
salati et al .
( 1999 ) showed that the observed optical depth can be reproduced if one assumes that 70% of the mass in the lmc disk consists of objects with @xmath153 ranging from @xmath173 to @xmath174 .
however , this would seem difficult to explain on the basis of present data .
although rr lyrae stars have now been observed to have a high velocity dispersion , these old stars make up only 2% of the visible mass .
so their influence on self - lensing predictions is negligible . a better way to account for
the observed optical depth might be to assume that the vertical structure of the lmc is more complicated than for normal disk galaxies .
the self - lensing optical depth might then have been considerably underestimated.=-2 one way to explain the observed microlensing optical depth is to assume that there might be stellar populations outside of the main lmc disk plane .
for example , there might be a population of stars in front of or behind the lmc that was pulled from the magellanic clouds due to milky way tidal forces ( zhao 1998 ) or there might be a non - virialized shroud of stars at considerable distances above the lmc plane due to milky way tidal heating ( weinberg 2000 ; evans & kerins 2000 ) . if microlensing source stars belong to such populations , then this would yield observable signatures in their characteristics .
in particular , if microlensing source stars are behind the lmc , then they should be systematically fainter ( zhao , graff & guhathakurta 2000 ) and redder ( zhao 1999 , 2000 ) than lmc disk stars .
hst / wfpc2 cmds of fields surrounding microlensing events show no evidence for this , although the statistics are insufficient to rule out specific models with strong confidence ( alcock et al .
other tests of the spatial distribution and properties of the lmc microlensing events also do not ( yet ) discriminate strongly between different models for the location and nature of either the lenses or the sources ( alcock et al .
2000a ; gyuk , dalal & griest 2000 ; jetzer , mancini & scarpetta 2002 ) .
this is primarily because only 1317 lmc microlensing events are known .
so to assess whether the lmc has out - of - plane structures it is best to focus on other types of tracers that might yield better statistics .
zaritsky & lin ( 1997 ) studied the optical cmd of a field @xmath175 north - west of the lmc center and found a vertical extension at the bright end of the red clump .
they suggested that this feature is due to stars 15@xmath176 above the lmc disk .
however , this interpretation has been challenged for many different reasons ( e.g. , bennett 1998 ; gould 1998 , 1999 ) .
most seriously , beaulieu & sackett ( 1998 ) pointed out that a vertical red clump ( vrc ) extension is naturally expected from stellar evolution due to young helium core burning stars .
the same feature is seen in the fornax and sextans a dwarfs ( gallart 1998 ) .
it remains somewhat open to discussion whether the number of stars in the lmc vrc is larger than expected given our understanding of the lmc star formation history , so a foreground population is not strictly ruled out ( zaritsky et al .
however , it certainly does nt appear to be a favored interpretation of the data . also , the kinematics of the vrc stars is indistinguishable from that of lmc red clump stars ( ibata , lewis & beaulieu 1998 ) .
more recently , zhao et al .
( 2003 ) performed a detailed radial velocity survey of 1300 stars of various types within @xmath177 from the lmc center .
they found no evidence for stars with kinematics that differ significantly from that of the main lmc disk .
this rules out a significant foreground or background population of stars that reside in a tidal stream that is seen superposed onto the lmc by chance ( zhao 1999 ) .
any foreground or background population must be physically associated with the lmc , and share its kinematics .
sub - populations within the lmc with subtly different kinematics have been suggested ( graff et al .
2000 ) , but only at low statistical significance .
other arguments for stars at large distances from the lmc disk also have not been convincing .
kunkel et al . (
1997b ) argued on the basis of carbon star velocities that the lmc has a polar ring .
however , the carbon star velocity field shown in figure [ f : fit ] seems to be well fit by a single rotation disk model .
it is possible that the kunkel et al .
study was affected by the use of an lmc transverse velocity value of only @xmath178 , which is considerably below the value indicated by presently available proper motion data ( @xmath179 ; see section [ s : orbit ] ) .
weinberg & nikolaev ( 2001 ) found a tail of relatively faint stars in luminosity functions of agb stars selected by @xmath180 color from 2mass data .
they suggested that this is not due to dust extinction but might indicate stars behind the lmc . on the other hand ,
the distribution of these stars on the sky ( van der marel , unpublished ) bears a strong resemblance to the far infrared iras map of lmc dust emission ( schwering 1989 ) .
this casts doubt on the interpretation that the brightnesses of these stars have not been affected by dust .
weinberg & nikolaev ( 2001 ) also found a slightly non - gaussian tail in their agb star luminosity functions towards brighter magnitudes .
however , this need not indicate stars in the foreground , given that there is no a priori reason why the agb star luminosity function would have to be gaussian . in another study ,
alcock et al .
( 1997 ) found no evidence for unexpected numbers of rr lyrae stars at distances beyond @xmath181 from the lmc disk plane .
the studies discussed in sections [ s : kinematics ] and [ s : viewing ] indicate that the overall structure of the lmc is that of a ( thick ) disk . from section [ ss : foreback ]
it follows that there is no strong evidence for unexpected material far from the disk plane .
however , this does not mean that there may not be non - planar structures in the disk itself .
for example , it was already discussed in section [ s : viewing ] that there might be warps and twists in the disk plane .
early evidence for non - planar material came from hi observations .
one of the most prominent optical features of the lmc is the star forming 30 doradus complex , located just north of the eastern tip of the bar .
this region is a very strong source of uv radiation , yet the hi gas disk of the lmc does not show a void in this part of the sky .
this indicates that the 30 doradus complex can not be in the plane of the lmc disk , but must be at least @xmath182@xmath183 away from it ( luks & rohlfs 1992 ) .
hi channel maps show that there is a separate hi component , called the `` l - component '' , that is distinct from the main lmc disk .
it has lower line - of - sight velocities than the main disk by @xmath184@xmath185 , contains some 19% of the hi gas in the lmc , and does not extend beyond @xmath186@xmath187 from the lmc center ( luks & rohlfs 1992 ) .
absorption studies indicate that this component is behind the lmc disk ( dickey et al .
the 30 doradus complex is spatially located at the center of the l - component .
it is probably directly associated with it , given that the l - component shows a hole of hi emission at the 30 doradus position as expected from ionization .
these results suggest that in the central few degrees of the lmc an important fraction of the gas and stars may not reside in the main disk .
= 0.6 it has now proven possible to test some of these ideas more directly by using large stellar databases .
section [ s : viewing ] already mentioned the study of more than 2000 cepheids by nikolaev et al .
they obtained accurate reddening - corrected ( relative ) distances to each of the cepheids .
the distance residuals with respect to the best - fitting plane do not follow a random gaussian distribution .
instead they show considerable structure , as shown in figure [ f : cepheids ] .
the two - dimensional distribution of the residuals on the sky was interpreted as a result of two effects , namely a symmetric warp in the disk , and the fact that the bar is located @xmath188 in front of the main disk .
interestingly , an offset between the lmc bar and disk had previously been suggested by zhao & evans ( 2000 ) as an explanation for the observed lmc microlensing optical depth .
if the disk and the bar of the lmc are not dynamically connected , then this may also explain why in projection the lmc bar appears offset from the center of the outer isophotes .
the variation of the reddening - corrected red clump magnitude over the face of the lmc has also been used to study vertical structures in the lmc disk .
olsen & salyk observed 50 randomly selected fields in the central @xmath189 of the lmc at ctio .
they found that fields between @xmath186@xmath189 south - west of the lmc center are @xmath190 mag brighter than expected from the best plane fit .
they interpreted this to indicate that stars in these fields lie some @xmath191 above the lmc disk , and argued for warps and twists in the lmc disk plane .
subramaniam ( 2003 ) used red clump magnitudes determined from stars in the ogle database to address the same issue .
this yielded a map of the red clump magnitude along the length and width of the lmc bar .
this map shows considerable structure and clearly can not be fit as a single plane .
subramaniam ( 2004 ) suggested that the residuals can be interpreted as the result of a misaligned secondary bar inside the primary bar .
eclipsing binaries have also provided interesting information on this subject .
these binaries can be modeled in detail to yield a fairly accurate distance .
the distances of sources studied so far seem to indicate a slightly lower lmc distance modulus of @xmath192 ( ribas et al .
2002 ) than has been inferred from other tracers ( see section [ s : orbit ] ) . however , it is possible to obtain somewhat higher values with a slightly different analysis ( groenewegen & salaris 2001 ; clausen et al .
2003 ) so this is no great cause for concern ( alves 2004b ) .
what is interesting though is that four eclipsing binaries analyzed by the same team with the same method show a considerable spread in distance .
this has been interpreted to mean than one of the binaries lies @xmath193 behind the lmc disk plane ( ribas et al .
2002 ) and that another one lies @xmath194 in front of it ( fitzpatrick et al .
2003 ) .
the above studies indicate that there is considerable and complicated vertical structure in the central few degrees of the lmc disk . however , this is a rapidly developing field , and many important questions remain open . in particular , it is unclear whether the features reported in the various studies are actually the same or not .
qualitative comparison is not straightforward .
different authors study different areas of the lmc , they plot residuals with respect to different planes , and they present their results in figures that plot different types of quantities . however ,
cursory inspection of the various papers shows very few features that are obviously in common between the studies .
quantitative comparison is therefore needed . direct comparison to the results for the outer parts of the lmc , where there is little evidence for extra - planar structures ( van der marel & cioni 2001 ) , is also important .
if discrepancies emerge from such comparisons , then this can mean two things .
either some studies are in error ( e.g. , due to use of inaccurate dust corrections , or by incorrect interpretation of stellar evolutionary variations as distance variations ) or different tracers do not trace the same structure .
the latter might well the case .
cepheids are young stars with ages less than a few times @xmath195 years whereas stars on the rgb and agb are typically older than 1 gyr .
since the structure of the lmc and its gaseous component vary with time as a result of tidal interactions with the milky way and the smc , one would nt necessarily expect stars formed at different epochs to trace identical structures .
another open question is what the physical and dynamical interpretation is of the extra - planar structures that are being detected .
many authors have used the term `` warp '' .
however , the residuals that have been reported do not much resemble the smoothly varying residuals that are expected from a single plane with a global warp .
the structures appear to be both different and more complicated than a single warp .
if a decomposition into different components is attempted , then such a decomposition must use entities that can be understood dynamically ( disk , bar , bulge , warp , etc . ) and that make sense in the context of the overall evolutionary history of the magellanic system .
components with holes or sharp edges ( e.g. , subramaniam 2004 ) are not particularly realistic from a dynamical viewpoint .
phase mixing of stellar orbits quickly removes such sharp discontinuities .
also , if the vertical structures detected in the inner region of the lmc disk are due to components that are not connected to the main disk plane , then why does the projected image of the lmc ( e.g. , figure [ f : maps ] ) look so smooth ? and why is there so little evidence from stellar kinematics for components with decoupled kinematics ( e.g. , figure [ f : fit ] ; zhao et al .
2003 ) ? clearly , many questions remain to be answered before we can come to a full understanding of the vertical structure of the lmc .
the structure and kinematics of the lmc continue to be active areas of research .
as outlined in this review , much progress has been made recently .
improved datasets have played a key role in this , most notably the advent of large stellar datasets of magnitudes in many bands , lightcurves , and line - of - sight kinematics , and also the availability of sensitive hi observations over large areas . as a result
we now have a fairly good understanding of the lmc morphology and kinematics .
the proper motion of the lmc is reasonably well measured and the global properties of the lmc orbit around the milky way are understood .
the angles that determine how we view the lmc are now known much more accurately than before and this has led to the realization that the lmc is quite elliptical in its disk plane .
we are starting to delineate the vertical structure of the lmc and are finding complexities that were not previously expected . despite the excellent progress
, many questions on lmc structure still remain open . why is the bar offset from the center of the outer isophotes of the lmc ?
why is the dynamical center of the hi offset from the center of the bar , from the center of the outer isophotes , and from the dynamical center of the carbon stars
? why do studies of the inner and outer regions of the lmc yield differences in line - of - nodes position angle of up to @xmath143 ?
does the lmc have a pressure supported halo ?
are there populations of stars at large distances from the lmc plane ?
what is the origin and dynamical nature of the non - planar structures detected in the inner regions of the lmc ?
do different tracers outline the same non - planar structures ?
it might be necessary to answer all of these open questions before we can convince ourselves that the optical depth for lmc self - lensing has been correctly estimated .
this seems to be the most critical step in establishing whether or not the milky way halo contains hitherto unknown compact lensing objects ( machos ) .
the open questions about lmc structure are important also in their own right .
the tidal interaction between the magellanic clouds and the milky way provides one of our best laboratories for studying the processes of tidal disruption and hierarchical merging by which all galaxies are believed to grow
. a better understanding of lmc structure may also provide new insight into the origin of the magellanic stream , which continues to be debated . and with improved proper motion measurements of the magellanic clouds ,
the stream may become a unique tool to constrain the shape and radial density distribution of the milky way halo at radii inaccessible using other tracers .
skrutskie , m. 1998 , in the impact of near - infrared sky surveys on galactic and extragalactic astronomy , proc . of the 3rd euroconference on near - infrared surveys , n. epchtein . ,
ed . , astrophysics and space science library , vol .
230 , 11 ( dordrecht : kluwer ) | i review our understanding of the structure and kinematics of the large magellanic cloud ( lmc ) , with a particular focus on recent results .
this is an important topic , given the status of the lmc as a benchmark for studies of microlensing , tidal interactions , stellar populations , and the extragalactic distance scale .
i address the observed morphology and kinematics of the lmc ; the angles under which we view the lmc disk ; its in - plane and vertical structure ; the lmc self - lensing contribution to the total microlensing optical depth ; the lmc orbit around the milky way ; and the origin and interpretation of the magellanic stream .
our understanding of these topics is evolving rapidly , in particular due to the many large photometric and kinematic datasets that have become available in the last few years .
it has now been established that : the lmc is considerably elongated in its disk plane ; the lmc disk is thicker than previously believed ; the lmc disk may have warps and twists ; the lmc may have a pressure - supported halo ; the inner regions of the lmc show unexpected complexities in their vertical structure ; and precession and nutation of the lmc disk plane contribute measurably to the observed line - of - sight velocity field
. however , many open questions remain and more work is needed before we can expect to converge on a fully coherent structural , dynamical and evolutionary picture that explains all observed features of the lmc . |
the mechanical status of granular matter is presently one of the most open and debated issues @xcite .
this state of matter exhibits many unusual mechanical and rheological properties such as stress induced organization at the microscopic @xcite or at the mesoscopic @xcite level which may yield macroscopic effects such as stress induced anisotropy @xcite .
this issue sets fundamental questions relevant to the understanding of many other systems exhibiting jamming such as dense colloids or more generally soft glassy materials @xcite . for practical applications ,
the quasistatic rheology of granular assemblies is described using a phenomenological approach , based on an elasto - plastic modelling of stress - strain relations @xcite .
so far , there is no consensus on how to express correctly the macroscopic constitutive relations solely out of microscopic considerations and under various boundary conditions or loading histories .
this very basic issue was illustrated in a recent debate on how to understand the stress distribution below a sand pile and especially how to account for the dependence on preparation protocols @xcite .
a new mechanical approach was proposed based on the concept of fragile matter @xcite and force chains propagation modelling @xcite .
but recent experiments have dismissed this approach and evidenced results more consistent with the traditional framework of general elasticity @xcite . in this paper
we focus on the predictions for stresses measurements at the bottom for an elastic material confined in a rigid cylinder .
when the column is filled with granular material it corresponds to the classical janssen s problem @xcite .
recently , this issue has received a lot of attention either experimentally @xcite or numerically @xcite , the confined material being either pushed or pulled down .
surprisingly , so far to our knowledge , there are very few systematic comparison or even direct relation with the outcome of standard elasticity in the same situation of confinement .
note that experimentally , it was found that essentially elastic materials like gels , may display a janssen stress saturation effects that could well predict the onset of self - collapsing under gravity @xcite . in a recent paper @xcite , evesque and
de gennes proposed a model for the slow filling of an elastic medium modelling a granular packing .
as the material is poured in the column , displacements of the material at the bottom are induced by the weight of the new material added so that it mobilizes friction forces . within the assumption of a minimal anchorage length
, it leads to partial and inhomogeneous mobilization of friction at the walls : friction is fully mobilized at the bottom , and partially in the upper part of the column .
a janssen like pressure profile can be derived in the case where the saturation length @xmath0 is high compared to the column radius @xmath1 ; this last condition is actually restrictive and inappropriate for usual experimental cases @xcite .
we propose to study in detail the elastic predictions and to compare them to the janssen model and to experimental results for a granular material in _ the same situation _
i.e. when the material is at the coulomb threshold _ everywhere _ at the walls .
the main comparison features with the experimental results have already been presented in @xcite ; here , we detail much more the elastic predictions . two kinds of situations are considered .
first , the mass at the bottom of the column is measured as a function of the material filling mass .
second , similar measurements are produced with an overweight on the top of the material .
we recently performed the corresponding experiments for a granular material @xcite and it was shown that one could obtain quite reproducible data provided a good control of the packing fraction homogeneity and a polarization of all the friction forces at the walls in the upwards direction .
our measurements confirmed , for the first time , the general validity of janssen s saturation curve .
they also evidenced an overshoot effect of spectacular amplitude induced by a top mass equal to the saturation mass .
these experimental results are actually strong tests for any theory of granular matter .
we first summarize our recent experimental results @xcite and compare them to the janssen model predictions . in @xcite , a slightly polydisperse assembly of 1.5 mm glass beads was poured at controlled packing fraction in steel columns of various friction coefficient , and of diameter varying between 38 mm and 80 mm .
the aim of the experimental procedure is to achieve the coulomb threshold everywhere at the walls when the apparent mass @xmath2 is measured ; see @xcite for details on the procedure .
the apparent mass @xmath2 measured at the bottom of the column was plotted as a function of the filling mass @xmath3 of the material .
the typical results obtained when @xmath3 is varied are shown on fig .
the apparent mass @xmath2 saturates exponentially with @xmath3 .
when an overweight equal to the saturation mass @xmath4 is added on top of the granular material , @xmath2 increases with @xmath3 , up to a maximum @xmath5 , which is about @xmath6 higher than @xmath4 , then decreases slowly towards the saturation mass @xmath4 .
the simple model which captures the physics of this saturation phenomenon was provided in 1895 by janssen @xcite .
this model is based on the equilibrium of a granular slice taken at the onset of sliding everywhere at the walls ; we attempted to realize as best as possible this last condition in our experiment @xcite . in cylindrical coordinates with origin at the top surface and the cylinder axis being the @xmath7 axis , the relation , at the slipping onset , between the shear stress @xmath8 and the horizontal stress @xmath9 at the walls is @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the coulomb static friction coefficient between the grains and the walls .
it results in a relation between the filling mass @xmath3 and the apparent mass at the bottom @xmath2 of the form : @xmath12 with @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the mass density of the granular material , and @xmath15 is the janssen parameter rendering the average horizontal redirection of vertical stresses : @xmath16 from a mechanical point of view , a major simplification of this model comes from the assumption that the redirection parameter @xmath15 would stay constant along the vertical direction .
but on the other hand , it provides a clear and simple physical explanation for the existence of an effective screening length @xmath0 @xmath17 above which the mass weighted at the bottom saturates . in @xcite ,
several saturation profiles were measured for various packing fractions , columns sizes and friction coefficients between the grains and the walls .
when the apparent mass rescaled by the saturation mass is plotted as a function of the filling mass also rescaled by the saturation mass , we obtain a _
universal rescaling _ of all data on a curve which is precisely the one predicted by janssen ( fig .
[ fig1 ] ) : @xmath18 , with @xmath19 .
the rescaling with radius @xmath1 and friction coefficient @xmath11 was also checked , and good agreement with the janssen model rescaling was found .
the janssen constant @xmath15 was found to depend on packing fraction @xmath20 and an effective relation was derived : @xmath21 .
on the other hand , when a top mass equal to the saturation mass is added on the top of the granular material , the apparent mass @xmath2 displays a maximum @xmath5 @xmath6 higher than @xmath4 , whereas the janssen model predicts @xmath22 whatever the filling mass @xmath3 is .
therefore , this overshoot goes beyond the possibilities of janssen s model which seems adapted to a unique configuration . in the next section
, we study in detail the predictions of isotropic homogeneous elasticity .
we first recall the general framework of homogeneous isotropic elasticity , and then predict the behavior of an elastic material confined in a column .
the elastic theory gives , in the limit of small deformations , a linear relation between the stress tensor components @xmath23 and the strain tensor components @xmath24 .
for an isotropic elastic material , we get @xmath25 where e is the young modulus , and @xmath26 the poisson ratio which takes its value between @xmath27 and @xmath28 in 3d , and between -1 and 1 in 2d . in a uniaxial homogeneous compression experiment ( fig .
[ fig2 ] ) , where @xmath29 is imposed everywhere , the other stress tensor components being null , we get @xmath30 everywhere and @xmath31 which signifies that the material expands in the transverse direction.the young modulus @xmath32 is thus characteristic of the material s stiffness ; a cylinder of length @xmath33 and section @xmath34 has stiffness @xmath35 in the axial direction .
the poisson ratio is linked to the material compressibility : the volume variation is : @xmath36 .
therefore , an incompressible material has poisson ratio @xmath28 in 3d ( 1 in 2d ) .
if we now confine an elastic medium of young modulus @xmath32 and poisson ratio @xmath26 , in a rigid cylinder of radius @xmath1 , no more radial displacement at the walls is allowed : @xmath37 .
stresses and displacements can actually be calculated in the _ limit of high depths @xmath7 _ under the assumption that they then should be independent of @xmath7 .
the boundary conditions we impose are the coulomb condition everywhere at the walls @xmath38 and infinitely rigid walls i.e. @xmath39 .
the stress tensor components are then @xmath40 and the asymptotic displacements are @xmath41 this can be checked by injecting this solution in the stress - strain relation ( [ stressstrain ] ) and internal equilibrium relation @xmath42 thus , we obtain a janssen s like redirection phenomenon due to a poisson s ratio effect with a local janssen s parameter @xmath43 , being for large depths : @xmath44 at 2d , we obtain the same saturation and stress redirection phenomena with @xmath45 . for a free elastic medium ,
the poisson ratio effect is a transverse dilatation ; for a confined elastic material , the poisson ratio effect is a transverse redirection of stresses ( fig .
[ fig2 ] ) . in the following
, @xmath46 will design the elastic stress redirection constant , whereas @xmath15 is devoted to design the stress redirection constant in the janssen framework . in this section
, we obtained the asymptotic values of stresses and displacements . for the vertical stress ,
the limit is similar to the janssen asymptotic vertical stress if one identifies @xmath15 an @xmath46 .
but we can not say anything from this calculation about the whole pressure profile .
we thus need to perform numerical computation . in the next section
, we present the numerical methods we employed to simulate janssen experiments for an elastic column .
two different methods were employed : we first computed the stresses in 2d with a spring lattice .
we also computed the stresses in 3d , using finite element method thanks to cast3 m @xcite .
the 2d computations are performed in order to provide elastic predictions for a direct comparison with 2d simulations of granular materials . in order to avoid any confusion ,
let us recall that we are not trying here to give a microscopic model for a granular material , but we use a discrete system behaving like an effective elastic medium in the continuous limit in order to perform simple numerical simulations . however , this system can describe the most simple of granular materials : a 2d hexagonal piling of frictionless disks ( with non - hertzian contacts so that contact elasticity is linear ) .
note also that systems of springs have been recently studied by goldenberg and goldhirsch @xcite ; they showed that large forces inhomogeneities ( i.e. like forces chains ) can be found at the discrete scale in these systems , which are elastic in the continuous limit .
in order to simulate a 2d elastic medium , we put point masses @xmath47 on an hexagonal lattice of link size @xmath48 ( fig .
[ fig3 ] ) .
every particle is linked to her 6 neighbors with identical springs of stiffness @xmath49 and length @xmath48 at rest .
therefore , the potential interaction energy between particles placed at @xmath50 and @xmath51 ( such that @xmath52 ) at rest , submitted to infinitesimal displacements @xmath53 and @xmath54 , is : @xmath55 by varying the stiffness @xmath49 , we can only vary the young modulus @xmath32 of the effective elastic medium . as we also need to vary the poisson ratio @xmath56 , an elastic torsion potential between neighbor springs separated by angle @xmath57 ( fig .
[ fig4 ] ) is added : @xmath58 this potential tries to maintain an angle @xmath59 between 2 neighbors springs if @xmath60 .
thus the limit @xmath61 corresponds to a contractive medium of poisson ratio -1 , whereas the limit @xmath62 corresponds to a incompressible medium .
an elementary area @xmath63 can be associated to each particle .
the surface energy @xmath64 then reads : @xmath65 if we consider the continuum limit of this system , the displacement of a particle located at @xmath51 is : @xmath66 the surface potential energy can be easily computed at second order in @xmath67 , and one obtains : @xmath68 for an elastic medium , stress - strain linearity reads @xmath69 there are _ a priori _ 9 independent parameters in @xmath70 ( but only 2 if it is an isotropic elastic medium ) .
the surface energy then reads @xmath71 if we identify this energy to the one we obtained for the spring lattice , we see that our system , in the continuous limit , is an isotropic elastic medium of young modulus e and poisson ratio @xmath26 : @xmath72 in order to solve the equilibrium problem of the lattice , we need to express the internal forces
. they can be deduced from the surface energy ( [ omega ] ) : to the usual elastic forces due to compression ( or decompression ) of springs , add forces which tends to drive the triangles angles to their equilibrium value ( if @xmath60 ) or out of the @xmath59 value ( if @xmath73 ) .
the force on a , due to the out of equilibrium angles of triangle abc ( fig .
[ fig4 ] ) reads : @xmath74 where @xmath75 is the rotation matrix of angle @xmath57 . for the numerical computation
, we impose the balance of forces ( gravity , elastic forces , torsion forces ) everywhere . at the bottom
, we impose a null vertical displacement ( rigid bottom ) , and either a perfectly stick ( i.e. nullity of horizontal displacement ) or perfectly slip ( i.e. nullity of horizontal projection of forces ) bottom . at the walls , we impose a null horizontal displacement ( rigid wall ) , and we impose the coulomb condition : the forces projected vertically are proportional to the forces projected horizontally with proportionality factor @xmath11 . on top of the material ,
the forces projected horizontally are null ( perfectly slip overweight ) , and the overweight is simulated by imposing the same vertical displacement for each particle on top ( stiff overweight ) , which is close to the experimental situation .
we thus obtain a linear system on the point displacements .
we can vary stiffness @xmath49 and @xmath76 in order to simulate elastic mediums of different young modulus and poisson ratio .
note that for varying @xmath26 between 0 and 1 , we need to vary @xmath76 between @xmath77 and @xmath78 .
we also vary the friction at the walls @xmath11 . in order to get the whole stress saturation curve ,
finite element numerical simulations @xcite were performed .
the column is modelled as an isotropic elastic medium .
we vary the friction at the walls @xmath11 , the young modulus @xmath32 and the poisson ratio @xmath26 .
we imposed a rigid ( nullity of vertical displacements ) , either perfectly stick ( nullity of horizontal displacements ) or perfectly slip ( nullity of horizontal stresses ) bottom .
we found no appreciable difference between these two previous cases .
the condition @xmath79 is imposed everywhere at the walls .
the cylinder is modelled as a steel elastic medium .
we verified that in all the simulations performed , there is no traction in the elastic medium , so that this can actually be a model for a granular material .
for the simulations performed without overweight , the top surface is set free ( no stress ) ; the overweight is modelled as a perfectly slip ( no horizontal stress ) brass elastic medium . in order to impose the coulomb condition at the walls
, we first set @xmath80 at each point of the mesh at the walls ; we then obtain in these conditions the value @xmath81 exerted by the elastic medium on the walls .
we then iterate in order to obtain @xmath82 where @xmath11 is the friction coefficient at the walls : the vertical force imposed at step ( i+1 ) is : @xmath83 we choose @xmath84 .
this procedure ensures convergence towards the coulomb condition : if at step ( i ) the coulomb condition @xmath85 is fulfilled , then at step ( i+1 ) : @xmath86 .
this boundary condition is the same as the one at step ( i ) : this yields @xmath87 , and thus @xmath88 .
note that in these simulations we imposed the coulomb condition everywhere at the walls .
this allows comparison with the janssen model in the same situation .
but , regarding the experimental results @xcite , i ) nothing really insures that our piling preparation is strictly isotropic and ii ) in spite of the careful procedure , we are never absolutely sure that all the friction forces at the wall are actually mobilized upwards
. moreover , the modelling of the contacts may seem rudimentary , as elasticity of contact should be included . in these simulations
, imposing dynamical friction at the walls or the static coulomb threshold is actually the same : the material obeys the same equilibrium equations ( if we consider a steady sliding at the walls ) , and the same condition at the walls , with just a change in the name ( and the experimental value ) of the friction coefficient .
in this section , we present the results obtained from numerical computations at 2d and 3d . in the following ,
we vary mainly the friction coefficient , and the poisson ratio .
the 2d simulations are in arbitrary units .
the 3d simulations were all performed , if no contrary mention , for an isotropic elastic medium of mass density @xmath89 ( which corresponds to an assembly of glass beads of packing fraction @xmath90 ) , of young modulus 100 mpa , in a steel cylinder of radius @xmath91 cm , poisson ratio 0.3 , young modulus 210 gpa , and thickness 3 mm .
these data , which correspond to the display used in @xcite , will not be specified anymore in the following .
simulations will also be performed in order to study the influence of the variation of the cylinder radius and the young modulus of the elastic medium .
we first perform simulations similar to the original janssen experiment : we plot the weight at the bottom as a function of the weight of elastic material in the column ( fig .
[ fig5 ] ) . ; the friction at the walls is @xmath92 .
the data are fitted by a janssen curve of coefficient @xmath93 ( line ) .
the janssen curve for @xmath15 corresponding to the elastic stress redirection constant @xmath94 is also displayed ( dotted line).,width=302 ] we see on fig .
[ fig5 ] , for friction coefficient @xmath92 and poisson ratio @xmath95 , that the apparent mass @xmath2 saturates exponentially with the filling mass .
the data are perfectly fitted by the janssen model for these parameters ( fig .
[ fig5 ] ) , but the janssen coefficient @xmath15 extracted from the fit is @xmath96 higher than the elastic stress redirection constant @xmath97 .
this is _ a priori _ unexpected as the elastic saturation pressure and the janssen one should be identical with @xmath98 . in order to understand this feature
, we study the whole mean vertical pressure profile in the same column ( fig .
[ fig6 ] ) .
( squares ) ; the friction at the walls is @xmath92 .
depth @xmath99 cm corresponds to the top of the column .
depth @xmath100 cm corresponds to the bottom .
we display the integral of vertical stresses @xmath101 at height @xmath7 .
the data are compared to a janssen curve of coefficient @xmath102 corresponding to the elastic stress redirection constant ( dotted line).,width=302 ] regarding mean vertical pressure , we see that the asymptotic value is now the expected theoretical asymptotic value , and the janssen curve with @xmath98 gives a good though not perfect fit of the profile
. the pressure saturates at high depths but decreases suddenly near the bottom ; this is actually the value on the bottom we measure in a janssen experiment .
this feature explains why the saturation mass is lower than the expected one on fig .
the reason for this change of pressure near the bottom is that the asymptotic vertical displacement is parabolic whereas the bottom is rigid and imposes a flat displacement .
it is thus important to note that the usual janssen experiment , in which one measure is made for one given height , is not equivalent to measuring a pressure profile , and results in a lower saturation stress ( i.e. higher janssen s constant @xmath15 ) than the pressure profile . for more clarity on this last point ,
we illustrate this difference on fig .
[ fig7 ] . for 3d simulations of an elastic material .
we plot @xmath103 vs. @xmath104 for @xmath105 ( squares ) , @xmath106 ( open circles ) , @xmath107 ( triangles ) , @xmath95 ( open down triangles ) and @xmath108 ( stars ) ; the friction at the walls is @xmath92.,width=302 ] extracted form 2d ( squares ) and 3d ( triangles ) simulations for various poisson ratios . in the 2d simulations ,
the friction at the walls is @xmath109 ; in the 3d simulations , the friction at the walls is @xmath92 .
@xmath15 is plotted vs. the elastic stress redirection constant @xmath45 in 2d , @xmath110 in 3d.,width=302 ] in the following , we study the rescaling law of simulated janssen experiments with friction coefficient @xmath11 at the walls and the poisson ratio @xmath26 .
the data are compared to the janssen model predictions by plotting @xmath111 for different @xmath11 and @xmath26 ( since @xmath112 and @xmath113 ) . on fig .
[ fig8 ] , we study the rescaling with the poisson ratio @xmath26 for 3d simulations .
the rescaling law is rather good , the differences may not be observable experimentally . on fig .
[ fig9 ] we plot the janssen coefficient @xmath15 extracted from the fit of data in 2d and 3d versus the elastic stress redirection constants @xmath46 ( @xmath26 in 2d , @xmath114 in 3d ) .
we observe that for a given friction coefficient , @xmath15 hardly depends on @xmath26 in 2d : @xmath15 variation is @xmath115 for @xmath46 varying from @xmath116 to @xmath117 . in 3d , @xmath118 increases roughly linearly with @xmath46 for @xmath46 varying from @xmath119 to @xmath120 ; however , k variation is less than 10% in this range .
we remark that @xmath121 : we explained it in the preceding section as a consequence of the presence of the rigid bottom . at the walls for 2d simulations of an elastic material .
we plot @xmath122 vs. @xmath123 for @xmath124 ( squares ) , @xmath125 ( open circles ) , @xmath126 ( triangles ) and @xmath109 ( open down triangles ) ; the poisson ratio is @xmath127.,width=302 ] at the walls for 3d simulations of an elastic material .
we plot @xmath128 vs. @xmath129 for @xmath130 ( open down triangles ) @xmath131 ( triangles ) , @xmath92 ( open circles ) and @xmath126 ( squares ) ; the poisson ratio is @xmath95.,width=302 ] on fig .
[ fig10 ] and fig .
[ fig11 ] , we study the rescaling with the friction coefficient @xmath11 at the walls respectively for 2d and 3d simulations . we now see that the proposed rescaling law is not good : the saturation is more abrupt as the friction coefficient is higher . extracted form 2d ( squares ) and 3d ( triangles ) simulations for various friction coefficient @xmath11 . in the 2d simulations , the poisson ratio is @xmath127 ; in the 2d simulations , the poisson ratio is @xmath95 .
@xmath15 is rescaled by the elastic stress redirection constant @xmath132 in 2d , @xmath133 in 3d.,width=302 ] on fig .
[ fig12 ] we plot the janssen coefficient @xmath15 extracted from the saturation mass value in 2d and 3d versus @xmath11 .
we now observe that the janssen constant ( and thus the saturation mass ) depends strongly on the friction coefficient at the walls : @xmath15 increase is @xmath134 in 2d for @xmath11 varying between @xmath135 and @xmath136 , and @xmath6 in 3d for @xmath11 varying from @xmath135 to @xmath137 .
@xmath15 depends roughly quadratically on @xmath11 .
moreover , the janssen constant seems to tend towards the elastic stress redirection constant @xmath46 when @xmath11 goes to 0 . in order to understand these features , we plot on fig .
[ fig13 ] the mean vertical pressure @xmath101 versus the depth , and its rescaling with @xmath11 . vs. depth @xmath7 , for elastic materials of poisson ratio @xmath95 , and friction at the walls @xmath131 ( triangles ) , @xmath92 ( open circles ) , et @xmath126 ( squares ) .
we plot @xmath138 vs. @xmath139 where @xmath140 is the theoretical saturation value for @xmath101 .
@xmath141 corresponds to the top of the material .
we also plot the janssen model prediction with @xmath142 ( line).,width=302 ] we see that , regarding the pressure profile , the janssen rescaling law is correct for the asymptotic value , but the profiles are slightly different : for low friction at the walls @xmath143 , the profile is perfectly fitted by the janssen law ; for higher friction , the profile is sharper and saturates abruptly . the differences for simulated janssen experiments observed on fig .
[ fig11 ] are now identified as a consequence of the presence of a rigid bottom : we actually see on fig .
[ fig13 ] that the decrease of pressure near the bottom is more important when the friction is higher i.e. the saturation mass is lower ( and the effective janssen constant is higher ) .
we now understand all these features : the parabolic part of asymptotic displacements is negligible for low friction ; in this case , the flat displacement imposed by the rigid bottom matches the asymptotic displacement , and the pressure at the bottom is the saturation pressure : we thus obtain @xmath98 . as the friction is increased ( and the material leans on the walls ) , the parabolic part of asymptotic displacement becomes more important and the influence of the rigid bottom is to decrease pressure ; we thus observe an increase in the effective janssen constant @xmath15 with @xmath11 . in the janssen picture ,
the janssen coefficient @xmath15 and the friction at the walls @xmath11 are not independent parameters : the relevant parameter is @xmath144 .
as regards the saturation mass @xmath4 , it remains true in elasticity , and we see on fig .
[ fig14 ] that @xmath144 , extracted from the saturation mass value , is a function of @xmath145 alone ( i.e. data on fig .
[ fig9 ] and [ fig12 ] can be replotted on a single universal curve ) ; we find a quadratic dependence of @xmath144 on @xmath145 : @xmath146 .
this explains the dependence found before on @xmath26 at fixed @xmath11 or on @xmath11 at fixed @xmath26 .
extracted form 3d ( triangles ) simulations for various friction coefficient @xmath11 at constant @xmath95 ( empty triangles ) and various poisson ratios @xmath26 at constant @xmath92 ( squares ) ; see fig .
[ fig8 ] and [ fig11 ] for @xmath26 and @xmath11 values .
the dotted line is the @xmath147 line ; the line is a polynomial fit with @xmath148.,width=302 ] however , it is not true anymore for the whole janssen profile : we see on fig .
[ fig15 ] that there is not a universal curve @xmath18 : if most data may be fit by the janssen curve ( with @xmath19 , it is not true anymore for high ( i.e. low @xmath4 values ) ; the data for high values of @xmath144 ( = 0.65 here ) fall above the janssen curve .
however , for most experimental conditions , @xmath144 is not as high , and this effect will not be observable . vs. @xmath149 for 3d simulations for various values of @xmath26 and @xmath11 ; the triangles are for @xmath95 and @xmath126.,width=302 ] on fig . [ fig16 ] , the young modulus is varied .
mpa ( squares ) , @xmath150 mpa ( open triangles ) et @xmath151 gpa ( circles ) , of poisson ratio @xmath152 , in a steel column of radius @xmath91 cm ; the friction coefficient at the walls is @xmath92 .
, width=302 ] we observe that the results are independent of the young modulus @xmath32 value , as long as it is less than 500 mpa ; we see on fig .
[ fig16 ] that the curves obtained for the simulation of a janssen experiment for @xmath153 mpa and @xmath150 mpa can be perfectly superposed . for higher @xmath32 ,
the weighted mass is higher and does not seem to saturate anymore ; as an example , for @xmath151 gpa on fig .
[ fig16 ] , @xmath2 seems to increase indefinitely .
note that this young modulus effect is present only because we take into account the walls elasticity ; for rigid walls and bottom , there would not be any dependence on @xmath32 .
the values of @xmath32 presented here have a meaning only for a particular cylinder ( same @xmath32 and same thickness ) . in this section ,
we present simulations of a janssen experiment , when an overweight corresponding to the saturation mass is added on top of the material . on fig .
[ fig17 ] and [ fig18 ] , we plot the apparent mass @xmath2 versus the filling mass @xmath3 , rescaled by the saturation mass @xmath4 , respectively in 2d and 3d , for various poisson ratio . : 0.33 ( open stars ) , 0.40 ( diamonds ) , 0.48 ( open down triangles ) , 0.57 ( triangles ) , 0.67 ( open circles ) and 0.78 ( squares ) .
the friction coefficient at the walls is @xmath109 .
the data are scaled with the saturation mass obtained in a simulation without overweight.,width=302 ] ( triangles ) , @xmath154 ( circles ) et @xmath95 ( squares ) .
the friction coefficient at the walls is @xmath92 .
the data are scaled with the saturation mass obtained in a simulation without overweight.,width=302 ] we now observe that , contrary to the simulations without any overweight , the results depend strongly on @xmath26 , i.e. on the elastic stress redirection constant @xmath46 .
the curves all have the same form : @xmath2 increases with @xmath3 , up to a maximum @xmath5 , then decreases slowly towards the saturation mass @xmath4 . the relative maximum @xmath155 increase with @xmath26 , and takes its value for higher @xmath149 .
the proposed rescaling law , similar to the janssen one , is not correct .
we did not find any rescaling law ; we thus keep our rescaling as a practical representation of data . on fig .
[ fig19 ] et [ fig20 ] , we plot the apparent mass @xmath2 versus the filling mass @xmath3 , rescaled by the saturation mass @xmath4 , respectively in 2d and 3d , for various friction coefficients at the walls . :
0.2 ( squares),0.3 ( open circles ) ) , 0.4 ( triangles ) , 0.5 ( open down triangles ) , 0.6 ( diamonds ) , 0.7 ( open left triangles ) , 0.8 ( right triangles ) , 0.9 ( open hexagons ) and 1.0 ( stars ) .
the poisson ratio is @xmath156 .
the data are scaled with the saturation mass obtained in a simulation without overweight.,width=302 ] ( triangles ) , @xmath92 ( squares ) and @xmath126 ( circles ) .
the poisson ratio is @xmath95 .
he data are scaled with the saturation mass obtained in a simulation without overweight.,width=302 ] we observe that the relative maximum of the apparent mass @xmath155 increases with the friction coefficient at the walls , and takes its value for higher @xmath149 .
this result leads to an apparent paradox .
as actually the maximum @xmath5 increases when @xmath4 decreases ( i.e. when @xmath11 and @xmath26 increase ) , we observe that _ the more the weight of the grains is screened by the walls , the less the weight of the overload is screened _
! we will propose an interpretation in the following .
we can wonder if all these results remain true for the profile .
these features could be due only to the presence of a bottom . on fig .
[ fig21 ] , we plot the mean pressure profile when an overweight of mass equal to the saturation mass obtained in the simulation of a janssen experiment is added on top of the material . vs. depth @xmath7 , for elastic materials of friction coefficient at the walls @xmath92 , and poisson ratios @xmath106 ( squares ) and @xmath95 ( circles ) , when an overweight equal to the saturation mass is added on top of the material .
we plot @xmath138 vs. @xmath157 where @xmath158 is the theoretical saturation value for @xmath101 .
@xmath141 corresponds to the top of the material.,width=302 ] we observe the same features as for the simulation of a janssen experiment . in order to go one step further ,
we now add an overweight which imposes on top of the material a mean pressure equal to the saturation pressure ; the results are presented on fig .
[ fig22 ] . vs. depth @xmath7 , for elastic materials of friction coefficient at the walls @xmath92 , and poisson ratios @xmath106 ( squares ) and @xmath95 ( circles ) , when an overweight equal to the saturation value @xmath159 of @xmath101 .
we plot @xmath138 vs. @xmath160 where @xmath158 is the theoretical saturation value for @xmath101 .
@xmath141 corresponds to the top of the material.,width=302 ] once again , we observe the same features as for the simulation of a janssen experiment .
the janssen rescaling law is still incorrect , and the overshoot effect is more important for higher poisson ratio and friction coefficient .
moreover , on the profile the amplitude of the maximum is more important : for friction coefficient @xmath92 and poisson ratio @xmath95 , we find that the maximum force on the profile is @xmath161 times the saturation force @xmath159 , whereas the maximum weighted mass is @xmath162 times the saturation mass @xmath4 . of the column .
we plot @xmath163 vs. @xmath164 for @xmath165 cm ( squares ) et @xmath91 cm ( line ) , for an elastic material of poisson ratio @xmath95 and friction coefficient at the walls @xmath92.,width=302 ] we finally verify the rescaling with the radius column for simulations with and without any overweight .
this rescaling is perfect for both simulations ( fig .
[ fig23 ] ) for the extreme radius employed in @xcite ( @xmath165 cm et @xmath91 cm ) . to summarize , several features are experimentally observable if the isotropic elastic theory is valid .
in a janssen experiment with free top surface , for a same material , the janssen constant @xmath15 , deduced from the measured saturation mass @xmath4 , must be higher for higher friction coefficient at the walls . in an experiment with @xmath4 overweight on top of the material
, the apparent mass @xmath2 must increase strongly with the filling mass @xmath3 , and then decrease slowly towards the saturation mass @xmath4 .
the observed maximum @xmath5 must increase with friction at the walls and with janssen coefficient @xmath15 ( measured in a janssen experiment with free top surface ) .
the saturation mass @xmath4 deduced from the pressure profile must be higher than the one measured at the bottom , and a strong decrease in the pressure must be observed near the bottom .
this kind of feature would not be observed for a hyperbolic theory such as osl @xcite .
moreover , for experiments with an overweight on top of the material , the maximum of @xmath2 will be higher on the pressure profile . in this section ,
we compare the elastic theory predictions to the experimental results obtained in @xcite .
the main features have already been presented in @xcite the janssen experiment data are perfectly fitted by the janssen model .
therefore , they are also perfectly fitted by the elastic theory : we indeed showed in sec .
[ nooverweight ] that for weak friction at the wall ( @xmath166 as in the experiment ) the janssen model and elastic theory predictions can not be discerned.we also showed in sec . [ nooverweightvaryfriction ] that when the friction coefficient is increased , the elastic theory predict a sharper initial increase of @xmath2 with @xmath3 and an more abrupt saturation .
however , this can not be observed experimentally for the small range of friction coefficient used in @xcite ( from 0.22 to 0.28 ) . in order to test this last prediction
, it would be necessary to work with higher friction at the walls ( @xmath167 ) .
note that for high packing fractions ( @xmath168 ) , we obtained janssen coefficients higher than 1 ( @xmath169 ) : this can not be obtained in the isotropic elastic theory , as @xmath170 .
we saw that @xmath46 is less than @xmath15 ( fig .
[ fig9 ] , [ fig12 ] ) , due to presence of a rigid bottom , but for small friction at the walls , this can not explain high @xmath15 values : we deduce from fig .
[ fig12 ] that for @xmath171 , @xmath15 must be less than 1.03 ; for @xmath126 , @xmath15 could be as high as 1.2.we will see in sec .
[ anisotropy ] how to obtain higher @xmath15 values in the context of anisotropic elasticity .
it was observed in @xcite that for different preparations , characterized by different packing fractions , the saturation mass @xmath4 is lower for higher packing fraction .
although there may be structural differences between the pilings other than the packing fraction , this can be interpreted as increase of the janssen coefficient @xmath15 with packing fraction .
thus , in the context of isotropic elasticity , this leads to an effective increase of the poisson ratio @xmath26 with packing fraction . in @xcite , an effective relation between packing fraction @xmath20 and poisson ratio @xmath26
was derived : @xmath172 with a precision of @xmath173 .
note that the largest packing fraction @xmath168 would give a poisson ratio @xmath174 marginally larger than the limit value of @xmath28 , as commented above .
the elastic theory gives qualitatively the same behavior as the experimental results ( see fig .
[ fig24 ] ) : the apparent mass @xmath2 increases with the filling mass @xmath3 , up to a maximum @xmath5 , then decreases slowly towards the saturation mass @xmath4 .
furthermore , all the features predicted by elasticity can be observed : @xmath175 rescaling , @xmath155 increase with friction at the walls , and @xmath155 increase with packing fraction ( experiment ) or poisson ratio ( theory ) .
note that @xmath155 increases with packing fraction and poisson ratio are equivalent because of the effective increase of poisson ratio with packing fraction deduced from the classical janssen experiment . however , there is no quantitative agreement between isotropic elasticity predictions and experiments .
[ fig24 ] ) .
the elastic curve is very similar to the experimental one , but the experimentally observed maxima are 30 to 40 times larger . vs. filling mass @xmath3 , rescaled by the saturation mass @xmath176 , for loose packing in medium - rough columns of 3 diameters ( 38 mm ( squares ) , 56 mm ( circles ) , 80 mm ( triangles ) ) with an overweight equal to @xmath4 ; the dotted line is the hydrostatic curve .
b : simulation of the experiment of fig .
[ fig24]a , for an elastic medium characterized by the same saturation mass ( poisson ratio @xmath177 ) and the same friction at the walls ( @xmath131 ) .
inset : maximum mass @xmath5 rescaled by saturation mass @xmath4 vs. static coefficient of friction at the walls @xmath11 , in experiments made on loose ( squares ) and dense ( circles ) packing in 38 mm diameter columns , and in simulations for elastic media of poisson ratios @xmath95 ( open squares ) and @xmath108 ( open circles ) ; the left vertical scale is used for the experimental data , the right vertical scale is used for the simulation data.,width=302 ] interestingly , we find in the elastic case the same qualitative phenomenology as in the experiment i.e. the computed values of the overshoot @xmath178 rescaled by the saturation mass @xmath4 increases both with the friction at the walls and the poisson coefficient ( i.e. with the effective janssen s parameter ) .
this features reads as a paradox : _ the more the weight of the grains is screened by the walls , the less the weight of the overload is screened _ , but we can now try to understand it at least qualitatively .
if we impose on the top surface of an elastic medium the asymptotic values for displacements and stresses ( see eq .
( [ stressasympt ] ) , ( [ depasympt ] ) ) , these values then extend to the rest of the column .
thus , with such an overweight , a flat pressure profile along depth z @xmath179 is obtained as in janssen s theory .
actually , with the overload , the displacement imposed experimentally on the surface is almost constant : @xmath180 since the overweight is much more rigid than the material . then , as the asymptotic displacement is parabolic , we must have a transition regime , which is at the origin of the overshoot effect .
there are two limits in which this transition can disappear , i.e. when the poisson coefficient @xmath56 or when friction at the walls @xmath11 are decreased to zero .
then the parabolic part of the asymptotic displacements ( eq .
( [ depasympt ] ) ) becomes negligible and therefore , the imposed displacement on the surface is close to the asymptotic value .
this results in a decrease of the overshoot amplitude .
basically , we thus recover in the elastic case , the same paradox as the experimental situation .
we now understand it as a consequence of the boundary condition imposed experimentally by the overweight i.e. an almost constant displacement on the surface
. it would be interesting to put overweights of different young modulus on top of a granular material in order to see if the overshoot amplitude decreases when the overweight young modulus is decreased .
in this section , we study the elastic theory predictions for the force needed to push an elastic material upwards at constant velocity in a column , and compare it to recent experimental observations @xcite in the case of a slowly driven granular material .
the main features of this analysis have been presented in @xcite . for a vertically pushed granular assembly @xcite at constant velocity ,
the resistance force @xmath181 increases very rapidly with the packing s height @xmath182(see fig .
[ fig25 ] ) . of the packing scaled by the column diameter @xmath183 , for 1.58 mm steel beads , of packing fraction 62.5% , in a 36 mm duralumin column , for @xmath184 ( filled squares ) and @xmath185 ( open circles ) .
the line and the dotted line are fits by eq .
( [ jansseninv ] ) .
the dashed line is the hydrostatic curve.,width=302 ] following the standard janssen screening picture , this strong resistance to motion is due to the leaning of the granular material on the walls ( eq .
( [ redirection ] ) ) in association with solid friction at the side walls . at the walls ,
we suppose a sliding of the granular material at a velocity @xmath186 ( the driving velocity ) ; the shearing stress is then @xmath187 where @xmath188 is the dynamic coefficient of friction between the beads and the cylinder s wall at a velocity @xmath186 . the force @xmath181 exerted by the grains on the piston can be derived from equilibrium equations for all slices ,
thus we obtain : @xmath189 where @xmath190 is the mass density of the granular material , @xmath1 is the cylinder radius and @xmath191 the acceleration of gravity .
the length @xmath192 is the effective screening length .
we see on fig .
[ fig25 ] that the data are well fitted by eq .
( [ jansseninv ] ) .
we obtain @xmath193 at @xmath194 and @xmath195 at @xmath196 . in order to get the isotropic homogeneous elasticity prediction for the pushing experiment
, we perform a series of numerical simulations using finite element method @xcite . the condition @xmath197 is now imposed everywhere at the walls ( for the pulling situation , we impose @xmath198 ) .
the cylinder is modelled as a duralumin elastic medium .
as long as the young modulus @xmath32 of the elastic medium is less than @xmath199 mpa , which is usually the case for granular media , we find no dependence of the results on @xmath32 .
we find no appreciable difference between the elastic prediction ( fig . [ fig26 ] ) and the curve given by eq .
( [ jansseninv ] ) with @xmath98 .
therefore , regarding the dependence of the stationary state force @xmath181 on the height of beads , our system can not be distinguished from an elastic medium . and young modulus @xmath200 mpa in a duralumin cylinder of radius @xmath201 cm , with coefficient of friction @xmath202 at the walls , to the curve obtained with eq .
( [ jansseninv ] ) with janssen coefficient @xmath203 ( line).,width=302 ] as a check of consistency , we performed the following dynamical experiment in @xcite .
first , the granular column is pushed upwards in order to mobilize the friction forces downwards and far enough to reach the steady state compacity . starting from this situation , the friction forces at the walls are reversed by moving the piston downwards at a constant velocity @xmath204 , until a stationary regime is attained .
note that this stationary regime is characterized by the same compacity @xmath205 as in the pushing situation . in fig .
[ fig27 ] the pushing force @xmath181 is measured for different packing heights @xmath182 .
the fit of experimental results with eq .
( [ janssen ] ) gives @xmath206 which is @xmath207 larger than @xmath208 extracted from the pushing experiment .
this difference , though small , can be observed out of uncertainties , and is systematic .
it can not be due to a slight change in compacity @xmath209 as from relation @xmath210 , we would expect a 2% variation in compacity between the pushing and the pulling experiment , which would be observed ; we actually measured @xmath211 . according to janssen s picture
, this would imply that vertical stress redirection is more efficient in the downward pulling situation .
we believe this is a clear evidence of a granular structuring effects but its also shows that this effect is not dominant : it affects only @xmath207 of the average mechanical parameter @xmath15 .
note that finite element simulations show that the presence of a rigid bottom implies that the effective janssen s parameter @xmath212 extracted from janssen s rescaling for the pulling situation is higher than @xmath46 , whereas for the pushing @xmath213 ( as can be seen on fig .
[ fig26 ] : the fit of the elastic curve with @xmath98 is good ) . actually , if we adjust the elastic predictions for pushing and pulling experiments with an elastic material of poisson coefficient @xmath95 , eq .
( [ jansseninv ] ) yields a janssen s constant @xmath212 for the pushing which is about @xmath214 lower than @xmath212 for the pulling .
this is qualitatively ( though not quantitatively ) in agreement with the experimental results .
therefore isotropic elasticity can be a good framework only if we neglect the existence of bulk restructuring effects inducing differences in the effective poisson coefficient of the material between the pulling and the pushing .
note that in this case , an isotropic modelling of the granular material is somehow questionable .
we have seen in the preceding sections that isotropic elasticity reproduces qualitatively all the features observed in the experiments performed on granular materials .
however , some problems remain : a janssen constant @xmath15 of order 1.2 was observed experimentally @xcite whereas elasticity can not provide janssen constants higher than 1.03 with the same experimental parameters ( i.e. @xmath215 ) ; moreover , the amplitude of the overshoot predicted by elasticity is 20 times lower than the one observed experimentally .
that is why we study here the predictions of the simplest extension of isotropic elasticity : transversely isotropic elasticity .
the stress - strain relations are now : @xmath216 following the same calculation steps as in sec .
[ elastheory ] , one can show that , in the limit of high depths @xmath7 , confinement imposes : @xmath217 i.e. we recover in the anisotropic case a janssen - like relation between stresses , with a stress redirection constant @xmath218 the constraints on the elastic parameters are now @xmath219 we can see the consequences on @xmath220 through an example .
if @xmath221 , then the constraint is @xmath222 which leads to @xmath223 . by adjusting the modulus @xmath224 and @xmath225
, one can give any value to @xmath220 which is not bounded anymore by a maximum value of 1 ( the isotropic case ) .
this means that the experimental values found in @xcite for dense packing , i.e. a janssen constant @xmath226 , which could not be reached by the isotropic elastic theory , can be understood in the framework of anisotropic elasticity .
note however , that we have now 5 independent parameters instead of 2 .
the problem is now that there are several ways to give @xmath15 a value by adjusting independently ( while satisfying the constraints ) 4 parameters @xmath227 , @xmath228 , @xmath224 , and @xmath225 ; another independent parameter is @xmath229 , which may affect the janssen profile shape ; thus one has to find a physical justification for choosing these values .
we tried to vary independently most parameters while keeping @xmath15 and @xmath11 constant in order to see if for a given @xmath4 , there is a way to obtain the giant overshoot we observe experimentally . several tries are compared with the isotropic case on fig .
[ fig28 ] .
as far as we could see , there is only a rather small influence of anisotropy on the overshoot amplitude : the deviation from the isotropic value is at the most 15% for reasonable values of the modulus .
nevertheless , there are some general tendencies : the higher the shear modulus @xmath229 , the smaller the overshoot amplitude is ; the higher @xmath227 , the higher the amplitude is , whatever the stiffer direction may be . however , the effect is far from sufficient to reproduce experimental results . vs. filling mass @xmath3 , rescaled by the saturation mass @xmath4 , for various transversely isotropic elastic media characterized by the same saturation mass @xmath4 .
squares : @xmath230 mpa , @xmath231 mpa , @xmath232 ( isotropic medium ) .
open circles : @xmath233 mpa , @xmath231 mpa , @xmath232 .
triangles : @xmath234 mpa , @xmath231 mpa , @xmath232 . open down triangles : @xmath230 mpa , @xmath235 mpa , @xmath236 mpa , @xmath237 .
diamonds : @xmath230 mpa , @xmath235 mpa , @xmath236 mpa , @xmath238 , @xmath239 .
open left triangles : @xmath230 mpa , @xmath235 mpa , @xmath236 mpa , @xmath240 , @xmath241 .
right triangles : @xmath230 mpa , @xmath242 mpa , @xmath243 mpa , @xmath244 , @xmath245 .
open stars : @xmath230 mpa , @xmath242 mpa , @xmath243 mpa , @xmath246 , @xmath247 . in all these simulations ,
the friction at the walls is @xmath131.,width=302 ] in order to account for the height of the experimentally observed overshoot , we propose a toy model based on the idea of stress - induced anisotropy .
it is possible that the overweight induces locally a change in the structure .
we would expect an increase of the number of contacts i.e. of the young modulus @xmath225 in the vertical direction , if the granular material can be modelled as an effective elastic medium . from the relation @xmath248
, we then expect the janssen coefficient to be lower near the overweight than in the bulk .
let the janssen constant be @xmath249 near the overweight , down to a depth @xmath250 , and @xmath251 for any depth @xmath252 .
the saturation mass , which is the overweight mass , was measured with an homogeneous material of janssen constant @xmath253 and is thus @xmath254 .
then , it underestimates the saturation mass @xmath255 of the material layer near the overweight : the measured mass @xmath2 then first increases with the filling mass @xmath3 and would naturally tend to a higher value @xmath256 .
but for a depth @xmath250 the material s structure is no more affected by the overweight and is now characterized by a janssen constant @xmath253 : the mass imposed on the material 2 by the material 1 is then higher than its saturation mass @xmath257 , and the measured mass @xmath2 has to decrease with the filling mass @xmath3 in order to reach its saturation value @xmath257 .
this simple idea can be easily formalized for an ideal janssen material .
the equilibrium equation on the vertical stress @xmath258 in material @xmath259 characterized by janssen constant @xmath260 reads @xmath261 in the material 1 , for @xmath262 , we solve this equation for the mass @xmath263 weighted at depth @xmath7 , with the boundary condition @xmath264 and get @xmath265 in the material 2 , for @xmath266 we solve this equation with the boundary condition @xmath267 and get @xmath268 these equations can be rewritten using @xmath269 and @xmath270 as variables : @xmath271 the two independent variables one can adjust are @xmath272 ( which is the janssen constant ratio @xmath273 ) , and the ratio @xmath274 where @xmath275 is the janssen screening length in the medium 2 . on a @xmath276 plot ,
the parameter @xmath277 is the x - axis value @xmath278 at which the weighted mass starts to decrease .
the slope at the origin is @xmath279 .
typically ( see fig .
[ fig29 ] and fig .
[ fig30 ] ) , the experimental slopes are of order 0.5 ( it would be 1 for an hydrostatic pressure ) , i.e. the janssen coefficient @xmath249 has to be about 2 times @xmath253 ; in the anisotropic elasticity framework , it would mean that the young modulus in the vertical direction is doubled by the overweight .
the order of the extension @xmath277 of the induced anisotropy is of order 0.4 .
the experimental data for dense and loose packing are compared on fig .
[ fig29 ] and fig .
[ fig30 ] with the model .
it appears to reproduce correctly the data ; however , the parameters can not be determined accurately as they are obtained from the very beginning of the data ( the slope at the origin and the x - axis value of the maximum ) which can not be measured with a high precision .
therefore , the parameters presented in these figures are just given as examples . vs. filling mass @xmath3 , rescaled by the saturation mass @xmath4 , for dense packing in medium - rough columns of 3 diameters ( 38 mm ( squares ) , 56 mm ( circles ) , 80 mm ( triangles ) ) with an overweight equal to @xmath4 .
the data are compared with our inhomogeneous janssen model with @xmath280 , and @xmath281.,width=302 ] vs. filling mass @xmath3 , rescaled by the saturation mass @xmath4 , for loose packing in medium - rough columns of 3 diameters ( 38 mm ( squares ) , 56 mm ( circles ) , 80 mm ( triangles ) ) with an overweight equal to @xmath4 .
the data are compared with our inhomogeneous janssen model with @xmath282 , and @xmath283 .
, width=302 ]
in conclusion , we performed an extensive study of the janssen s column problem .
it is a mixture of numerical studies both in 2d and in 3d , in the case of frictional boundaries .
the aim was to test thoroughly the classical and celebrated janssen s analysis in the context of an effective homogeneous elastic material and provide some meaning to the effective janssen s constant of stress redirection at it can be obtained experimentally .
note that here we do not make any assumption on a plastic threshold in the bulk as it is usually considered to provide bounds on the janssen s constant ( active and passive limits ) .
also this analysis was performed in the context of an extensive experimental work where preparation was varied and were special care about friction at the wall was taken to be able to establish a precise comparison with theoretical modelling .
interestingly , we find that the janssen s approach is fully valid in the limit of low friction coefficients between the grains and the wall ( up to a moderate value of 0.5 ) .
it means that an exponential saturation curve of the average normal stress at the bottom is an excellent approximation , which defines precisely an effective janssen s constant solely dependent on the poisson ratio .
we also derive ion the limit of an infinite column a value for an elastic janssen s constant ( @xmath284 in 2d and @xmath285 in 3d ) .
for a finite size column , the presence of a bottom diminish the average vertical stress such as to yield an effective janssen s constant if the bottom normal stress is measured with a value directly related to the elastic constant @xmath46 .
therefore , in this context experiment data can be matched with isotropic elasticity if the packing fraction representing the preparation can be associated with an effective poisson ratio . consequently , there is a need to provide a more strained test to the isotropic elastic theory .
this was done experimentally by imposing on the top of the column an overweight equal to the saturation stress @xcite and here we propose the same test in the same conditions for an elastic material .
the numerical simulations show that stresses at the bottom also exhibits an overshoot when the column depth is increased .
the relative value of the overshoot is at most 7% .
we propose a scaling relation of the overshoot amplitude when the wall fiction is varied .
this result contrasts with a janssen s analysis where a flat profile should be observed .
this overshoot effect is related to the deformation of the elastic medium below the overweight which sets a length where the deformation profile is not parabolic any more as in the rest ( more like a flat profile as it is imposed by the overweight boundary condition ) .
but at the quantitative level , the overshoot effect found experimentally has an amplitude about 20 to 30 times larger !
this lack of quantitative agreement opens new questions on the modification on the influence of the medium due to the overload .
this is the reason why we push further the investigation in the context of anisotropic elasticity .
we consider an orthotropic elastic medium with the main stiff direction along the vertical . in this case
the effective janssen s redirection coefficient can be changed according to the stiffness ratio but the overshoot test does not produce an overshoot value significantly larger than the isotropic situation .
finally , we propose a qualitative model based on an extension of the janssen s approach where we assume that the overload has changed the medium within a given depth such as to yield a smaller janssen s constant .
this would be consistent with the onset of strain induced anisotropy producing a stiffer medium in the vertical direction .
the agreement of this simple model ( with two fitting parameters ) is satisfactory but more importantly it raises interesting questions and calls for new experimental work . in this frame of mind
it would be very interesting to see differences of the stress saturation curve for two media prepared i ) with a regular rain like pouring as before and ii ) a rain like deposition process but where an overweight is imposed above each deposition step ( a deposition step being of a height much smaller than the final height ) . in this case
the stress induced texture changes could provide a rational explanation to the extension of the janssen s model that fits correctly the overweight experiments . | we compute the stresses in an elastic medium confined in a vertical column , when the material is at the coulomb threshold everywhere at the walls .
simulations are performed in 2 dimensions using a spring lattice , and in 3 dimensions , using finite element method .
the results are compared to the janssen model and to experimental results for a granular material . the necessity to consider elastic anisotropy to render qualitatively the experimental findings
is discussed . |
antiprotonic atoms are a specific tool to study the strong interaction and the nucleon density in the nuclear periphery .
the strong interaction potential leads to widths and energy shifts of antiproton - atomic levels compared to the purely electromagnetic interaction .
the measurement of these widths and shifts gives information on the strength of the interaction , which is often expressed by an effective scattering length in the optical potential model @xcite , and on the nucleon density in the region where the annihilation takes place .
in contrast to other methods which are sensitive to the charge distribution and usually probe the whole nucleus with the nuclear periphery giving only a small contribution , antiprotons are sensitive to the matter density at the nuclear periphery ( they probe the nucleon density at distances about 2 fm larger than the half - denstity charge radius ) . by investigating different isotopes of one element , the effect of additional nucleons can be deduced .
the major part of the effect comes from the higher nucleon density in the nuclear periphery of isotopes with more neutrons @xcite .
possibly isospin effects on the effective antiproton - nucleon scattering - length may also exist . before our studies data of antiprotonic atoms had been collected for several elements @xcite .
however , with a few exceptions , these were mainly light isotopes ( @xmath5 ) and a number of them was investigated using natural targets under difficult antiprotonic beam conditions .
the aim of the ps209 collaboration was to measure with antiprotons from lear at cern a large variety of elements and isotopes in order to provide a set of data for a new combined analysis @xcite to determine the nucleon density in the nuclear periphery .
this analysis is expected to yield knowledge about the neutron density in the annihilation region and better knowledge of the antiproton - nucleus interaction , e.g. about a density or isospin dependence of the effective scattering length @xcite .
the results of the ps209 experiment were already reported in a number of conferences , see e.g. @xcite . in particular the last reference presents a comprehensive table of level widths and shifts determined in 34 monoisotopic or isotopically separated targets ranging from @xmath6 to @xmath7 . in ref .
@xcite these data were analyzed under the assumption of a two parameter fermi ( 2pf ) distribution of peripheral protons and neutrons .
a linear relationship of the difference between the neutron and proton root mean square radii ( rms ) @xmath8 and the asymmetry parameter @xmath9 was established ( where @xmath10 and @xmath11 are neutron , atomic and mass numbers , respectively ) . besides conference communications some more detailed reports on the evaluations of ps209 results
were already published @xcite or are in preparation . in this publication results for tin and cadmium isotopes are presented .
the isotopes @xmath12 , @xmath13 , @xmath14 , @xmath15 , @xmath16 and @xmath17 have been investigated . for four of these nuclei also
the neutron - to - proton density ratio in the nuclear periphery could be measured using the radiochemical method @xcite .
the principle of the method employed is described in ref . .
the antiprotons are captured into a high antiprotonic - atom orbit .
they cascade down towards levels with lower principal quantum number @xmath18 by the emission of auger electrons and x - rays . in states with low @xmath18
the orbit of the antiproton comes close to the nucleus and the interaction with the nucleus becomes large .
the resulting shifts and widths of the levels were partly evaluated and interpreted as explained in the next sections .
the strong interaction width can be measured directly ( via analysis of the line shape ) if it is of the order of magnitude of the instrumental resolution ( about 1 kev ) . for many isotopes
this is the case for the lowest visible transition .
the energy of the transitions may be measured with an accuracy of about 10 ev .
thus strong - interaction energy shifts which are larger than this value may be determined . for those levels ,
for which the strong interaction width is of the order of the electromagnetic width ( due to x- and auger transitions ) , the strong interaction width was deduced from the intensity balance of the x - ray transitions feeding and depopulating the respective level @xcite . in the case of non - circular transitions
the feeding transitions can not be observed experimentally , as they are hidden by the much stronger intensities of the circular transitions . in these cases
the feeding intensities can be taken from cascade calculations if the cascade is sufficiently well known @xcite .
the experiment was performed with the antiproton beam provided by lear of cern . the setup ( cf .
[ setup ] ) is similar to that described in ref . .
due to the small initial momentum of the antiprotons of 106 mev/@xmath19 the scintillation - counter telescope , consisting of an anticounter s1 and a counter s2 , was placed inside a chamber ( with aluminum windows of thickness 12 @xmath20 m ) filled with helium .
this was necessary to avoid large an energy straggling and degradation for the low energy ( 6.0 mev ) antiprotons in air .
after passing the chamber window the antiprotons were stopped inside the target .
the properties of the different targets are listed in table [ targets ] .
the x - rays emitted during the antiproton cascade were measured with three ge detectors ( two coaxial detectors with an active diameter of 49 mm and a length of 50 mm and one planar detector with diameter 36 mm and thickness 14 mm ) with a resolution ( fwhm ) of about 1 kev at 200 kev gamma ray energy .
the detectors were placed at distances of about 50 cm from the target at angles of 13@xmath21 , 35@xmath21 and 49@xmath21 respectively towards the beam axis .
the detector - target distance was adjusted in the way to obtain a good signal - to - noise ratio and simultaneously decrease the background produced by pions from the annihilation processes , which would obscure the x - ray lines and would have damaged the detectors .
this also allowed to avoid summing effects .
the x - rays were measured in coincidence with the antiproton signal in a time window which was extended up to 500 ns after the antiproton signal from the telescope counter . the stability and efficiency of the detectors and the data acquisition system was checked by on - line and off - line measurements with calibration sources .
the x - ray spectrum from the target @xmath17 , as taken with detector 1 , is shown in fig .
[ sn124spec ] .
the upper right part shows the part of the spectrum with the last visible transition @xmath22 .
those lines in the spectra which are not significantly broadened by strong interaction were fitted with gaussian functions .
their relative intensities are given in table [ cd_int ] and table [ sn_int ] for the cd and sn istopes , respectively .
for the fit of the transition @xmath22 two lorentzians convoluted with gaussians were used .
the strong - interaction energy shifts were deduced from the measured energies of these transitions .
the energy shift is the difference between the energy calculated with a purely electromagnetic potential @xcite and the measured transition energy .
the widths of the levels @xmath23 were determined from the measured intensity balance .
small corrections for parallel transitions and for unobserved transitions from higher levels were taken from the calculated cascade @xcite .
for the determination of the width of the level ( 9,7 ) all intensities of the feeding transitions were taken from the results of the cascade calculations .
the radiative and auger widths ( obtainded according to ref .
@xcite ) which were used for these calculations are summarized in table [ cd_rad_aug ] for cadmium and in table [ sn_rad_aug ] for tin .
tables [ cd_gam_sh ] and [ sn_gam_sh ] give the measured widths and shifts for the cadmium and tin isotopes , respectively .
the variation of these observables due to the different number of protons and neutrons from @xmath12 to @xmath17 is clearly visible .
the widths for @xmath17 are roughly twice as large as those for @xmath12 .
the shifts turn from attractive or compatible with zero for @xmath12 to repulsive for @xmath17 .
the only observable which does not follow rather smooth systematics is the upper level @xmath24 width of @xmath12 . for all other nuclei presented in these tables
the lower to upper level widths ratio is @xmath25 , whereas the same ratio is only about 50 in case of @xmath12 .
this effect is due to e2 resonance @xcite which in cd nuclei mixes the @xmath26 and the @xmath27 states .
the difference between the energies of nuclear @xmath28 state and the corresponding antiprotonic - atom transition is 65 kev and 184 kev in @xmath12 and @xmath13 , respectively .
as the electric quadrupole moment is not very different for both nuclei @xcite , the increase of the upper level width due to the mixing is more significant in @xmath12 than in @xmath13 .
this qualitatively explains the observed effect . to be more quantitative , the width of the @xmath26 level in cd nuclei should be known .
this width was estimated by an extrapolation to @xmath29 of the systematics presented in @xcite for lower z nuclei .
the extrapolated value is @xmath30 kev .
this leads to the e2 induced width of @xmath31 ev and @xmath32 ev in @xmath12 and @xmath13 , respectively .
the @xmath33 and @xmath34 components of the upper level widths , corrected for the e2 effect , are also given in table [ cd_gam_sh ] .
the summary of the results ( measured values ) for @xmath12 is shown in fig .
the region of tin isotopes with a closed @xmath35 proton shell constitutes one of the favorable parts of the nuclear chart for experimental and theoretical nuclear - structure studies . during our investigation on antiprotonic atoms in this region we measured , besides the results reported in this paper , the level widths and shifts in even te isotopes ( @xmath36 ) @xcite .
in addition , using the radiochemical method @xcite , we have determined the neutron halo factor , a quantity reflecting the composition of the outer nuclear periphery in @xmath37 , @xmath38 @xcite and in @xmath39 @xcite . in the present discussion
we will concentrate on the first two elements . in our recent publication @xcite
we have presented in detail our approach to determine the peripheral neutron distribution and differences between the neutron and proton mean square radii @xmath8 using observables gathered from antiprotonic atoms under the assumption of a two - parameter fermi ( 2pf ) neutron and proton distribution : @xmath40 , where @xmath19 is the half density radius , @xmath41 the diffuseness parameter ( related to the surface thickness @xmath42 by @xmath43 ) and @xmath44 is a normalization factor .
this approach is summarized below .
assuming identical annihilation probabilities on neutrons and protons the radiochemical experiment determines the halo factor , which is close to the normalized neutron to proton density ratio ( @xmath45 ) at a radial distance @xmath46 fm larger than the half density charge radius . comparing the halo factor with the neutron to proton density ratio deduced from @xmath8 determined in other experiments
one can conclude that for neutron rich nuclei it is mostly the neutron diffuseness which increases and not the half density radius @xcite .
although this conclusion was based on the very simple 2pf model of the nuclear periphery it is corroborated by much more sophisticated hartree fock bogoliubov ( hfb ) calculations .
this is illustrated in figs .
[ hfb_2pf ] and [ hfb_2pf_rorat ] , where the proton and neutron density distributions for @xmath17 are compared for both models .
the hfb calculations were performed using skp force @xcite , giving @xmath8 value equal to 0.16 fm .
as the calculated proton ( @xmath47 ) and neutron ( @xmath48 ) half - density radii are almost identical , this rms difference is mainly due to the difference in the proton and neutron surface diffuseness .
the fitted 2pf distributions with the hfb @xmath48 , @xmath47 and @xmath8 values closely approximate the hfb distributions . in the peripheral region from 6.5 fm to 8.5 fm , e.g , the 2pf neutron distribution differs by less than 20% from that derived from hfb calculations .
a similar result was obtained for other investigated nuclei .
the antiprotonic x - rays are analyzed using an optical potential with the antiproton - nucleon scattering length of the form @xmath49 fm , as proposed for point - like nucleons in ref .
the method allows to study the nuclear density at a radial distances about 1 fm closer to the nuclear center than those examined in the radiochemical experiment .
the peripheral bare proton densities in form of 2pf distributions are obtained @xcite from the experiments sensitive to the nuclear charge : electron scattering @xcite or muonic x - rays @xcite .
the differences between experimental level widths and shifts and those calculated with parameters of the proton distributions are attributed to the neutron contributions to these observables .
based on the analysis and the comparison described above , the half density radii of the proton and neutron distributions are assumed to be equal , @xmath50 .
the neutron diffuseness is considered as a free parameter , adjusted to agree best with the experimental lower and upper level widths ( the lower level shifts were not taken to the fits , see comments below ) .
table [ dtpar ] illustrates this procedure for the cd and sn nuclei . for the sn nuclei the 2pf charge distribution determined using data from muonic atoms or from electron scattering differ significantly . only the electron scattering data lead to @xmath8 values compatible with the systematics gathered for other nuclei @xcite and with previous experiments @xcite .
therefore these data were retained for further analysis . in fig .
[ gam_sh_rys ] the widths and shifts , calculated with density distributions from this table and the scattering lengths given above are compared with corresponding experimental values .
it is evident that the potential used is able to reproduce simultaneously the lower and upper level widths for cd and sn nuclei whereas one has some problems with the level shifts ( only for @xmath15 , @xmath16 and @xmath17 the measured shifts are reproduced within the experimental errors ) .
the analysis of the x - ray data as presented in table [ dtpar ] allows to determine the normalized neutron to proton density ratio @xmath51 as a function of the radial distance at the periphery of the investigated nuclei .
as indicated above , the radiochemical experiment can be considered as giving the same ratio at a radial distance in the far periphery .
figure [ rorat_prc ] compares the results of these two experiments together with the normalized neutron to proton density ratio obtained from the hartree - fock - bogoliubov ( hfb ) calculations . for the sake of illustration
the comparison is extended to some other nuclei not discussed in detail in the present publication . for heavy cd and sn nuclei two experimental approaches are consistent within the experimental errors .
they are also in fair agreement with hfb calculations ( a similar result is obtained for 15 other investigated nuclei , partly shown in fig . [ rorat_prc ] ) .
as already mentioned in our previous paper @xcite the situation is quite different for the lightest members of the cd and sn chains . for these nuclei
the analysis of the x - ray data gives densities consistent with the hfb model with skyrme interaction as well as with recent calculations with gogny force @xcite .
the radiochemical experiment , however , seems to indicate a proton - rich nuclear periphery .
we encountered a similar problem for the two lightest members of the ru and sm isotopic chains . in ref .
@xcite the role of a quasi - bound @xmath52 ( @xmath53 ) state in nuclei with weakly bound protons was indicated as an explanation of this puzzle .
( for @xmath12 and @xmath14 the corresponding proton separation energies are 7354 kev and 7559 kev , respectively ) .
the formation of such a state would favor the annihilation on protons in comparison with those on neutrons and lead to a much smaller halo factor than really expected from the peripheral neutron and proton densities .
this explanation , although opening new research areas , would indicate that our radiochemical method is not as universal as we believed previously .
the x - ray data , combined with proton distributions deduced from electron scattering experiments ( sn nuclei ) and muonic atoms ( cd nuclei ) allowed to determine the differences @xmath8 between neutron and proton rms radii .
the results are presented in table [ dtpar ] and fig .
[ drdelta ] . they are compared with other experiments as well as with the hfb model in ref .
the @xmath8 values in figure [ drdelta ] for the @xmath13 result differ from these in ref .
@xcite as the correction for e2 was done and the level shift was excluded from the fit .
the @xmath12 results are presented for the first time .
antiprotonic x - rays were measured in two even cd and four even sn nuclei . the strong interaction level widths and shifts were determined .
the observed isotopic effects are attributed , at least to a large extent , to the increase of the difference between the neutron and proton rms radii with increasing neutron number .
the interpretation of the collected data was done using a simple two parameter fermi ( 2pf ) model to describe the peripheral proton and neutron distribution .
it was verified that these simple distributions approximate rather well ( within 20% ) the distributions obtained from the hfb model in the region where the antiproton annihilation probability is significant .
the parameters of the proton distributions were obtained from literature , where 2pf charge distributions were determined from muonic - atoms or electron - scattering experiments . for neutron rich nuclei
the peripheral neutron distributions deduced from the antiprotonic x - ray data are in good agreement with ealier radiochemical experiments .
this is , however , not the case for the lightest members of the investigated cd and sn isotope chains . in these nuclei
the radiochemical data indicate enhanced peripheral proton density in comparison with the neutron density .
such a result is in contradiction with the x - ray data as well as with hfb model calculations .
it may be explained by the formation of a quasi - bound @xmath54p states in nuclei with weakly bound protons .
we thank the lear team for providing the intense , high - quality antiproton beam and dr .
anna stolarz of the heavy ion laboratory in warsaw and katharina nacke and dr .
peter maier - komor of the technical university munich for the target preparation .
financial support by the polish state committee for scientific research as well as the accelerator laboratory of the university and the technical university of munich is acknowledged .
this work was also supported by deutsche forshungsgemeinschaft .
28 natexlab#1#1bibnamefont # 1#1bibfnamefont # 1#1citenamefont # 1#1url # 1`#1`urlprefix[2]#2 [ 2][]#2 , * * , ( ) .
, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , * * , ( ) .
, , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , , , , , * * , ( ) .
, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . ,
* * , ( ) .
, , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , ,
, * * , ( ) . , , ,
* * , ( ) .
, , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
* * , ( ) . , , , *
.target properties : thickness @xmath55 , enrichment @xmath41 , number of antiprotons used , and on - line calibration sources . [
cols="^,^,^,^,<",options="header " , ] c|l|l|l|l|r|r|r|l|l|l|l|r|r|r & & + isotope & @xmath56&@xmath57&@xmath58&@xmath59&@xmath60&@xmath61 & @xmath8 & @xmath56&@xmath57&@xmath58&@xmath59&@xmath60&@xmath61 & @xmath8 + @xmath0cd & 5.2875 & 2.30 & 5.329 & 2.000 & @xmath62 0.43@xmath63 & 0.2 & 0.15@xmath64 & & & & & & & + @xmath1cd & 5.4164 & 2.30 & 5.457 & 2.000 & @xmath62 0.45@xmath65 & 0.2 & [email protected] & 5.42 & 2.34 & 5.461 & 2.043 & 0.39@xmath67 & 0.2 & 0.13@xmath68 + @xmath2sn & 5.3714 & 2.30 & 5.412 & 1.995 & [email protected] & 0.8 & [email protected] & 5.375 & 2.416 & 5.416 & 2.184 & [email protected] & 0.8 & [email protected] + @xmath1sn & 5.417 & 2.30 & 5.458 & 1.995 & [email protected] & 0.3 & [email protected] & 5.358 & 2.420 & 5.399 & 2.135 & [email protected] & 0.3 & [email protected] + @xmath3sn & 5.459 & 2.30 & 5.499 & 1.995 & [email protected] & 0.7 & [email protected] & 5.315 & 2.530 & 5.356 & 2.263 & [email protected] & 0.9 & [email protected] + @xmath4sn & 5.491 & 2.30 & 5.531 & 1.995 & [email protected] & 0.9 & [email protected] & 5.490 & 2.347 & 5.530 & 2.052 & [email protected] & 0.9 & [email protected] + + + + + + + [ dtpar ]
anticounter , and s@xmath69 counter of the telescope.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] .
the 2pf distributions were fitted to hfb model curves ( half density radii @xmath71 fm and the difference between neutron and proton rms radii , @xmath72 fm ) .
the obtained 2pf diffuseness parameters are @xmath73 fm and @xmath74 fm.,scaledwidth=90.0% ] .
open circles and dotted lines : cadmium isotopes ( upper level widths corrected for the e2 effect ) , full circles and solid lines : tin isotopes .
the lines are calculated using the optical potential for point - like nucleons @xcite with the surface parameters given in table [ dtpar ] ( see also text ) .
positive level shift corresponds to repulsive interaction.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] ) deduced from strong - interaction level widths and shifts ( solid lines with indicated statistical errors ) and charge distributions given in ref .
@xcite ( sn nuclei ) and ref .
@xcite ( other nuclei ) .
they are compared with @xmath76 measured in the radiochemical experiments ( marked with crosses at a radial distance corresponding to the most probable annihilation site ) and with hfb model calculations ( dashed lines).,scaledwidth=80.0% ] between the rms radii of the neutron and proton distribution as deduced from the antiprotonic atom x - ray data , as a function of @xmath77 .
the full line is the same as in fig . 4 of ref . | the x - ray cascade from antiprotonic atoms was studied for @xmath0cd , @xmath1cd , @xmath2sn , @xmath1sn , @xmath3sn , and @xmath4sn . widths and shifts of the levels due to
strong interaction were deduced .
isotopic effects in the cd and sn isotopes are clearly seen .
the results are used to investigate the nucleon density in the nuclear periphery .
the deduced neutron distributions are compared with the results of the previously introduced radiochemical method and with hfb calculations . |
optical bright emission lines have been used for many years as the main source of information to derive physical properties and chemical abundances both in nearby and distant galaxies .
these optical emission - lines are excited by the uv radiation emitted by young massive stars in the gas clouds surrounding on - going star - formation complexes in galaxies .
the total metallicity ( @xmath2 ) of the gas - phase is one of the most relevant pieces of information that can be extracted . in particular
, the regime of low metallicity is particularly important in the context of unevolved / young objects resembling the first protogalaxies and or star - formation in the high redshift universe .
the most accurate method to derive @xmath2 using the bright collisionally excited emission - lines is the determination of the total oxygen abundance assuming , e.g. , that the different metals are present in solar proportion .
in addition , the nebular oxygen abundance inferred from emission lines is not the total o since part of the o may be depleted into dust grains .
however , this depletion is negligible small in our galaxies as discussed at the end of section [ sec : physical_porperties ] .
therefore in this paper we use the term oxygen abundance even though we measure nebular oxygen abundance . ] ; o / h based on measuring the electron temperature , the so - called @xmath3 method .
@xmath3 can be derived from the ratio of lines with different excitation potential ; the most widely used is the ratio of oxygen lines , [ oiii]@xmath44363/([oiii]@xmath5 [ oiii]@xmath6 ) .
then , the ionic abundances of the most abundant oxygen ions is obtained from the ratio of their brightest emission - lines to a hydrogen balmer line , i.e. , [ oii]@xmath43727/h@xmath7 for o@xmath8 and [ oiii]@xmath45007/h@xmath7 for o@xmath9 ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . unfortunately , the @xmath3 method is often useless at large redshifts due to the faintness of the weak auroral lines and/or because the wavelength coverage does not include the emission - lines required to derive of the observation electron temperature or ionic abundances . in those cases , other methods based only on the brightest available
emission - lines are used instead .
one of the most popular ones is based on the ratio between [ nii]@xmath46584 and h@xmath10 , the so - called n2 parameter ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
this parameter involves emission lines close in wavelength so it is almost independent of reddening or flux calibration uncertainties .
n2 presents a linear relation with log(o / h ) , within a range of metallicity including extremely metal poor ( xmp ) galaxies ; see , e.g. , . ] .
moreover , n2 allows measuring o / h in high redshift objects , because the required [ nii ] emission - line appears in many high - z surveys focused on the detection of h@xmath10 in near - ir bands .
other methods widely used to derive o / h based on strong collisional emission lines have revealed to be quite inefficient in the range of xmps .
for instance , the r23 parameter @xcite has a bi - valuated behaviour with o / h in high redshift objects , and o3n2 can not be used for oxygen abundance 12+log(o / h)@xmath118 .
this paper is focused on the empirical o / h estimate using the n2 index in metal - poor galaxies .
we wanted to take advantage of the comprehensive sample of metal - poor galaxies compiled by @xcite to improve the significance of the calibrations o / h versus n2 obtained so far . to our surprise
, we found that the scatter of the relationship o / h versus n2 increases when improving the statistics , and reveals that the ratio [ nii]@xmath46583 to h@xmath10 seems to be independent of metallicity at low oxygen abundance ( 12+log(o / h)@xmath117.6 , which corresponds to a metallicity @xmath12 ) .
this result casts doubts on the metallicities of high - redshift metal - poor objects based on n2 , but indicates that n2 can be used to set an upper limit to the true metallicity of the targets .
this paper describes the problem , the solution , and explains how the behaviour of n2 can be understood using photoionization models .
the paper is organized as follows .
first , we describe the sample of 46 xmp galaxies ( section [ sec : sample ] ) used to calibrate the n2-based empirical metallicity estimate .
the @xmath3 method we use to determine physical properties and chemical abundances is presented in section [ sec : physical_porperties ] .
the @xmath3 method is employed to determine the chemical abundances of the sample of xmps in section [ sec : metallicity ] . in order to identify the sources of scatter in the n2 calibration at low metallicities ,
photoionization models are analyzed in section [ sec : models ] .
the sources of the observed scatter are identified in section [ sec : results_empiric ] .
a summary with conclusions and follow - up work is provided in section [ sec : discussion ] .
in order to calibrate the index n2 in the very low - z range , we need a large sample of low - z targets with their o / h homogeneously determined via the direct method .
we start off from the metal - poor galaxy sample compiled by @xcite , which included all galaxies with metallicity one tenth or less of the solar value found to the date of publication .
the total sample includes 140 xmps . among them , 79 have spectra in sdss / dr7 , which is the spectral database used in the calibration .
nearby galaxies with spectra in sdss ( objects with @xmath13 ) have [ oii]@xmath43727 out of the observed spectral range , thus the determination of the @xmath14 by the direct method , i.e. , using [ oii]@xmath43727 , is not possible .
a slight modification of the direct method allows to calculate the value of @xmath14 from the intensities of the auroral lines [ oii]@xmath157320,7330 @xcite and was explored .
it is important , however , to bear in mind that the application of the auroral line method is restricted to spectra with sufficiently high signal - to - noise ratio @xcite . because of this , we select galaxies with s / n @xmath16 3 in [ oii]@xmath47320
. only 31 of the 79 metal - poor galaxies with sdss spectra fulfill the required s / n criterion .
we added 15 galaxies to the sample taking into account the similarity between n and o ionization structures . with
n / o obtained using the n2s2 index @xcite and @xmath17 inferred through the functional form by @xcite , it is possible to estimate @xmath14 when [ oii ] lines are unavailable . in summary
, we have 46 xmp galaxies with their metallicities determined in a homogeneous and consistent way , which is the main sample employed in this paper .
in order to put our work into context , we also randomly select and analyze a control sample of 65 starburst galaxies , having intermediate metallicities ( @xmath18 ) .
we first select those emission line galaxies in sdss / dr7 which were not classified as metal - poor galaxies by @xcite .
then , we discarded agns using the bpt diagram @xcite .
finally , we divided the range of n2 roughly corresponding to @xmath18 in 65 equal intervals , and then one galaxy was randomly selected per interval .
the emission - line fluxes of the spectra of the 46 xmps and the 65 galaxies in the control sample are measured using our own idl procedure to better control the errors and their propagation .
basically , the procedure works as the task splot in iraf . in the case of an isolated line or two blended unresolved lines
, they are measured integrating between two points given by the position of the local continuum identified by eye . if two lines are blended , but they can be resolved , we use a multiple gaussian fit to estimate individual fluxes .
the statistical error associated with the observed emission lines is calculated using the expression @xmath19^{1/2}$ ] @xcite , where @xmath20 is the error in the observed line flux , @xmath21 corresponds to the noise in the continuum near the measured emission line , @xmath22 is the number of pixels used in the measurement of the line flux , @xmath23 is the line equivalent width , and @xmath24 is the wavelength dispersion . all line fluxes were corrected for reddening using the same procedures as in @xcite .
the reddening coefficient in h@xmath25 , @xmath26 , was calculated assuming the extinction law of @xcite for the galaxy and performing a least - squares fit to the difference between the theoretical and observed balmer decrement .
the corrected emission line flux of a line with wavelength @xmath27 , @xmath28 , is given by @xmath29 where @xmath30 stands for the measured emission line flux , and @xmath31 is the extinction law at the corresponding wavelength . with the reddening corrected fluxes ,
we determine the physical conditions of the ionized gas , electron temperature and electron density included . electron temperature and electron density determinations are based on the five - level statistical equilibrium atom approximation in the task temden of iraf @xcite .
electron density is derived from the ratio [ sii]@xmath46717/[sii]@xmath46731 , and in objects without this ratio , a density of 100 @xmath32 is assumed , typical in this kind of galaxies ( e.g. * ? ? ?
the electron temperature of [ oiii ] is derived using the ratio ( [ oiii]@xmath44959+[oiii]@xmath45007)/[oiii]@xmath44363 ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) . as we mentioned in sec .
[ sec : sample ] , [ oii]@xmath43727 is often out of the wavelength range in the sdss spectra of our galaxies , thus the electron temperature of [ oii ] is calculated using the model relation between t([oii ] ) and t([oiii ] ) worked out by @xcite .
furthermore , in the 15 cases without @xmath14 , we need the electron temperature of [ nii ] to calculate @xmath17 . t[nii ] ) can be derived from the emission - line ratio ( [ nii]@xmath46584 + [ nii]@xmath46548)/[nii]@xmath45755 in 8 objects .
the remaining 7 cases use an independent relation between t([nii ] ) and t([oiii ] ) worked out by @xcite .
this particular study uses oxygen abundance to trace the metallicity , therefore , we have not calculated the abundance of other elements .
the measures calculates the total oxygen abundance relative to hydrogen using , @xmath33 the ionic abundances of @xmath34 and @xmath35 are obtained employing the expressions given by @xcite , which consider the lines [ oiii]@xmath04959 and [ oiii]@xmath05007 for @xmath35 , and [ oii]@xmath367320,7330 for @xmath34 .
o@xmath37 does not need to be included since its abundance is negligibly small in hii regions ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . for those galaxies without a direct determination of the ionic abundance @xmath14 , considering the similarity of ionization structures of n and o , it is possible to assume , @xmath38 with n / o obtained using the n2s2 index by @xcite , and @xmath17 , calculated employing the approximation by @xcite , it is possible to determine @xmath14 through the expression , @xmath39 errors in chemical abundances and physical properties are estimated in a montecarlo simulation .
the line fluxes involved in determining the physical conditions and chemical abundances are randomly modified 500 times according to their observed errors , and the abundances are computed for each one of these realizations .
the error for the abundance is the standard deviation among all the values thus obtained .
the noise added to the observed fluxes is assumed to be gaussian .
these error bars do not include systematic errors , which may be non - negligible .
for instante , even xmp galaxias , where the dust is almost absent ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , may have 20represent an artificial drop of metallicity of 0.08dex .
similar error results from ignoring temperature inhomogenities ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
the oxygen nebular metallicity computed for the metal - poor sample is compared with n2 in fig . [
fig : results_metalpoor ] .
the first important result is that , most of the galaxies have metallicities one tenth or less of the solar value .
therefore , the oxygen abundance obtained using the direct method confirms that most galaxies selected as low - metallicity galaxies in @xcite are , indeed , xmps .
in addition , the observed oxygen abundance presents a tendency to be constant with n2 for the metal - poor galaxies , i.e. , metallicities have similar values for a broad range of [ nii]@xmath40/h@xmath10 ( fig .
[ fig : results_metalpoor ] ) .
this is discouraging if one tries to use n2 as proxy for metallicity at low metallicity . as we argue below , n2-based metallicity estimates by (
* pp04 ) calibrate the n2 index versus o / h relationship in the range @xmath41 ( see fig .
[ fig : results_metalpoor ] ) .
the data set used by pp04 presents a discontinuity in metallicity in the region of xmp galaxies .
figure [ fig : results_allsample ] shows our metal - poor galaxy sample together with the control sample .
there is no jump in the low metallicity range .
then , we conclude that the apparent discontinuity in pp04 is due to the small number of data points they had available .
the present sample makes use of a more recent and larger database and , the oxygen abundance versus n2 shows a continuous trend even in the low metallicity range .
the scatter of the relationship @xmath42 vs n2 is very large ( fig .
[ fig : results_allsample ] ) .
this scatter is also present in other samples like the one used by @xcite and the more recent sample analyzed by @xcite .
we initially attempted to calibrate the n2 index in the low metallicity range , but we gave up due to the scatter of the observed points .
however , n2 can be safely used to set an upper limit to the true metallicity in the low metallicity range .
the third - order polynomial calibration from pp04 suffices for this objective ( see the fit inserted in fig .
[ fig : results_allsample ] ) , namely , @xmath43 when @xmath44 .
equation [ eq : poli3_pp04 ] grants that a xmp galaxy according to n2 is a truly xmp galaxy .
in order to understand the source of scatter in figs . [
fig : results_metalpoor ] and [ fig : results_allsample ] , we developed a set of photoionization models using cloudy ( v.10 ; * ? ? ? * ) , covering the physical condition expected for the observed objects .
the photoionization models assume a spherically symmetric hii region , with the ionized emitting gas taken to have a constant density of 50 @xmath32 .
we also tried models with constant gas pressure , but they do not significantly modify the emission line ratios with respect to constant density models , and so this assumption does not bias the conclusions of the modeling .
the models have plane - parallel geometry .
the gas is ionized by a coeval cluster of massive stars , with the spectral energy distribution ( sed ) obtained using starburst99 synthetic stellar atmospheres @xcite .
the age of the cluster is 1 myr .
we use an initial mass function ( imf ) with exponents 1.3 and 2.3 at low and high masses , respectively .
boundaries for the imf are 0.1 and 100 @xmath45 , and the exponent changes at 0.5 @xmath45 .
models use padova agb stellar tracks with metallicities z=0.004 and z=0.0004 , the latter being the lowest available metallicity . assuming solar composition , z=0.0004 @xmath46 12+log(o / h)=7.16 and z=0.004 @xmath46 12+log(o / h)=8.16 , which corresponds to the range of oxygen abundance found in our targets .
.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] the available metallicities are too coarse for the intended modeling . therefore , for intermediate metallicity , we interpolate the two extreme spectra , one with @xmath47 and the other with @xmath48 . if @xmath49 then the spectrum corresponding to metallicity z , @xmath50 , is @xmath51 with @xmath52 and , @xmath53 .
it is also assumed that the gas has the same metallicity as the ionizing stars .
the other ionic abundances are set in solar proportions , except in the case of nitrogen , where we explore different values of n / o . our galaxies are expected to have @xmath54 @xcite . to measure
n / o one would ideally like to have [ oii]@xmath43727 , but , as it is explained in sec .
[ sec : sample ] , the line is often outside the observed spectral range . in this case
we use n2s2 index to obtain an approximate value of n / o @xcite .
[ fig : n_o ] shows the result for our sample . from the figure we see that the metal - poor galaxies have typically @xmath55 .
taking into account this fact , we compute two sets of models with @xmath56 and @xmath57 . each one is built for a number of ionization parameters @xmath58 and for a number of oxygen abundances @xmath59 .
the range of @xmath60 corresponds to the ionization degree shown by the type of object studied here ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
all in all , we have 154 photoionization models which allow us to predict n2 of a function of 12+log(o / h ) under a large number of circumstances . when looking for a metallicity indicator based on bright emission lines such as n2 , one would ideally like to find combinations of lines whose fluxes depend only on chemical abundances .
this is difficult because the emission line fluxes are controlled by other physical parameters as well . in the case of n2 , the ionization parameter ( u ) , i.e. , ratio between the number of ionizing photons and density of hydrogen atoms , is the parameter cause most of the intrinsic variations @xcite . in order to understand and identify the relationship between
the scatter observed in fig .
[ fig : results_metalpoor ] and the ionization parameter , we employ the photoionization models described in sec .
[ sec : models ] .
[ oiii]/h@xmath7=[oiii]@xmath63 weakly depends on metallicity in a non - trivial way , although it is mainly sensitive to the ionization parameter at sub - solar metallicity ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
we use the observed [ oiii]/h@xmath7 together with the models to estimate u in individual galaxies .
metallicity and n / o are known .
thereby , we plot [ oiii]/h@xmath7 versus n2 for the models and the galaxies , and we assign to each galaxy the nearest value of u. the results are shown in fig .
[ fig : n2_sepu ] , which contains oxygen abundance versus n2 with different colors representing different ionization parameters .
this plot is quite revealing , because it indicates that the scatter observed in fig .
[ fig : results_metalpoor ] can be explained by the galaxies having different degree of ionization . as fig .
[ fig : n2_sepu ] shows , given an oxygen abundance , n2 decreases with increasing ionization parameter .
the degree of ionization of a galaxy changes with its evolutionary state ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
the observed equivalent width of h@xmath7 ( ew(h@xmath7 ) ) indicates the age of the ionizing cluster ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , although it also depends on the underlying stellar component of the galaxies that provides most of the photons in continuum wavelengths .
@xcite showed that the underlying population contribution is less than 10% in a sample of hii galaxies similar to our targets .
therefore , we can use @xmath64 as a qualitative estimate of the evolutionary state of our xmp sample .
we computed ew(h@xmath7 ) for our galaxies , and the maximum of the distribution is at ew(h@xmath7)@xmath65100 .
galaxies in two different age ranges are shown in fig .
[ fig : n2_sepewhb ] ; the red filled circles correspond to ew(h@xmath7)@xmath11100 whereas the galaxies with ew(h@xmath7)@xmath66100 are shown as black filled circles .
lower ew(h@xmath7)s correspond to younger galaxies . comparing fig .
[ fig : n2_sepu ] and [ fig : n2_sepewhb ] , we can see that the galaxies with low ionization parameter are the most evolved ones .
these results indicate that part of the dispersion showed in fig .
[ fig : results_metalpoor ] is related to the evolutionary state of the galaxies through the ionization parameter u. as coded in the inset .
there is a clear trend for smaller n2 to have lower u. the relationship is not one - to - one , though.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] ) @xmath11100 , whereas black filled circles stand for galaxies with ew(h@xmath7)@xmath66100.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] the dependence of the scatter in fig .
[ fig : results_metalpoor ] on n / o was also explored . since n2 uses n line to measure o abundance , ti most depend on n / o .
as one can hinted at differences in fig .
[ fig : n2_sepno ] , another source of scatter seems to be in the n / o ratio .
the figure separates galaxies with log ( n / o)@xmath67 - 1.5 ( red filled circles ) and galaxies with log ( n / o)@xmath68 - 1.5 ( blue filled circles ) .
contrarily to what is expected for low - metallicity galaxies evolving as a closedbox system , n / o is not constant .
figure [ fig : n_o ] shows n / o for our metal - poor galaxies .
the vast majority have log ( n / o)@xmath69 - 1.6 , which is the value expected for metal - poor galaxies .
this plateau is though to begin at @xmath70 ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , and the actual value of @xmath71 may depend on the type of galaxy ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
there are galaxies with an excess of n / o in fig .
[ fig : n_o ] .
those are the ones with low metallicity but large n2 in fig .
[ fig : n2_sepewhb ] possible reasons for this excess could be , extra production of primary nitrogen , coming from low - metallicity intermediate - mass stars or wolf - rayet stars , or a combination of inflows of metal - poor gas and outflows of enriched gas @xcite .
nitrogen enhancements in similar galaxies have also been reported by .
-1.5 , whereas blue filled circles represent galaxies with log(n / o)@xmath68 - 1.5.,scaledwidth=50.0% ]
our initial aim was improving the calibration used in the literature to infer oxygen abundance from n2 for low - metallicity galaxies .
in particular , we compare n2 and metallicity determined using the direct method in the set of xmp galaxies worked out by @xcite .
the first result is that the oxygen abundances obtained using the direct method confirm that galaxies classified as low - metallicity galaxies in @xcite are , indeed , metal - poor .
the second result is more discouraging though .
the observed oxygen abundance presents a tendency to be constant with n2 making it difficult to work out any calibration at low metallicity .
instead , we argue that the calibration o / h vs n2 by pp04 can be used at low metallicity to set an upper limit to the true metallicity ( see eq . [
eq : poli3_pp04 ] ) .
o / h vs n2 presents a very large scatter ( see fig .
[ fig : results_metalpoor ] ) .
cloudy photoionization models allowed us to understand the scatter .
we found that n2 decreases with the ionization parameter for a given oxygen abundance . considering that the degree of ionization is related to the evolutionary state of the starburst ionizing the medium , we analyze the state of evolution using the equivalent width of h@xmath7 .
this analysis indicates that part of the dispersion observed is indeed due to the evolutionary state of the galaxies .
in addition , we found that part of the scatter is also due to an excess of n / o in some of the metal - poor galaxies .
an excess could be due to an extra production of primary nitrogen galaxies , or other processes including inflows of metal - poor gas ( sec .
[ sec : results_empiric ] ) . in short , we find the commonly used metallicity estimate based on n2 to be uncertain at low - metallicities .
fortunately , it is possible to use the n2 calibration to set an upper limit to the abundance in metal - poor galaxies .
we are thankful to elena terlevich , roberto terlevich and jose vlchez for insightful comments and discussions .
abml thanks the hospitality of the iaa during her visit .
epm thanks also to projects pex2011-fqm7058 and tic114 _ galaxias y cosmologa _ of the junta de andaluca ( spain ) " this work has been funded by the spanish micin project _ estallidos _ , aya 2010 - 21887-c04 - 04 .
we are members of the consolider - ingenio 2010 program , grant micinn csd2006 - 00070 : first science with gtc .
funding for the sdss and sdss - ii has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national science foundation , the u.s .
department of energy , the national aeronautics and space administration , the japanese monbukagakusho , the max planck society , and the higher education funding council for england .
the sdss is managed by the astrophysical research consortium for the participating institutions ( for details , see the sdss web site at http://www.sdss.org/ ) . ,
g. , prantzos , n. , meynet , g. , et al .
2012 , in eas publications series , vol .
54 , eas publications series , ed .
g. stasiska , n. prantzos , g. meynet , s. simn - daz , c. chiappini , m. dessauges - zavadsky , c. charbonnel , h .-
ludwig , c. mendoza , n. grevesse , m. arnould , b. barbuy , y. lebreton , a. decourchelle , v. hill , p. ferrando , g. hbrard , f. durret , m. katsuma , & c. j. zeippen , 363 | the n2 index ( [ nii]@xmath06584/h@xmath1 ) is used to determine emission line galaxy metallicities at all redshifts , including high redshift , where galaxies tend to be metal - poor .
the initial aim of the work was to improve the calibrations used to infer oxygen abundance from n2 employing updated low - metallicity galaxy databases .
we compare n2 and the metallicity determined using the direct method for the set of extremely metal - poor galaxies compiled by @xcite .
to our surprise , the oxygen abundance presents a tendency to be constant with n2 , with a very large scatter .
consequently , we find that the existing n2 calibrators overstimate the oxygen abundance for most low metallicity galaxies , and then they can be used only to set upper limits to the true metallicity in low - metallicity galaxies . an explicit expression for this limit
is given .
in addition , we try to explain the observed scatter using photoionization models .
it is mostly due to the different evolutionary state of the hii regions producing the emission lines , but it also arises due to differences of n / o among the galaxies . |
the periodic modulation of stress wave existing in periodic composites results in exotic dynamic response .
the phononic band - structure@xcite induced by the periodic modulation of stress waves has close similarities with areas like electronic band theory@xcite and photonics@xcite .
the rich wave - physics resulting from the periodic modulations offers potential for novel applications such as refractive acoustic devices@xcite , ultrasound tunneling@xcite , waveguiding@xcite , reversed doppler effect@xcite , sound focusing@xcite , hypersonic control@xcite , negative refraction@xcite , gradient - index refraction@xcite , etc .
the first step in realizing these applications is to calculate the phononic band - structure . additionally , some research areas such as phononic band - structure optimization@xcite and inverse problems in dynamic homogenization@xcite depend heavily on the speed , efficiency , accuracy and versatility of the band - structure calculating algorithm . there
exist several techniques by which band - structures of photonic and phononic composites can be calculated .
the plane wave expansion method ( pwe)@xcite is easy to implement but converges slowly when material properties show large contrast .
the multiple scattering method@xcite can precisely predict the band structure , but is subject to geometry limitations . the finite element method
( fem)@xcite is derived from variational principles and it is widely used for computing phononic bandstructures of various geometries .
hussein and hulbert@xcite have presented a mixed finite element approach based on the variation of displacement and strain field , which shares the same mathematical background ( hu - washizu variational theorem ) as the methods presented in this paper .
some other methods are the finite difference time domain method ( fdtd)@xcite and secondary expansions such as the reduced bloch mode expansion@xcite method , etc .
convergence rates of three variational principles , the displacement rayleigh quotient , where the displacement field is varied , the stress rayleigh quotient , where the stress field is varied , and the mixed quotient@xcite , where both the displacement and stress fields are varied , are considered in this paper . in addition , we also compare the convergence rates of the variational methods with the most popular band structure algorithms ( pwe and displacement based fem ) .
the mixed quotient was proposed by nemat - nasser@xcite in 1972 , which was derived from the works of hellinger@xcite , prange@xcite , reissner@xcite , hu@xcite , washizu@xcite .
nemat - nasser@xcite showed that when compliance is constant , the mixed quotient reduces to the displacement rayleigh quotient and when density is constant , the mixed quotient reduces to the stress rayleigh quotient .
babuska and osborn@xcite related the convergence behavior of the three variational principles to the smoothness of the compliance and density functions and showed that the mixed quotient , in general , converges faster than the other two methods .
due to its excellent accuracy and efficiency , the mixed variation principle has been recently applied to the study of wave refraction in periodic elastic composites@xcite . in this paper ,
the three variational principles which solve the phononic eigenvalue problems are presented in section [ stateproblem ] .
the algorithms derived from the variational principles are suitable for applications to arbitrary unit cells .
we present the detailed formulation of the eigenvalue problems and their convergence behavior under different compliance and density distribution for 1-d and 2-d periodic composites . in our calculation
we consider the effects of different function continuity and differentiability conditions of compliance and density on the convergence rates of the three formulations .
phononic computations seek to evaluate the essential properties of sound / stress waves traveling in periodic structures .
these properties include the phononic band - structure evaluated along the boundary of the irreducible brillouin zone ( ibz ) of 1- , 2- , and 3-d composites , their equi - frequency contours , and the associated density of states . however , all these properties emerge from the solution of the fundamental eigenvalue problem which is associated with the elastodynamics of periodic structures . in the following subsections
we define the essential properties of the periodic domain under consideration , eigenvalue problem associated with wave propagation in this periodic domain , and the variational methods which can be employed for its solution . in the following treatment repeated latin indices mean summation , whereas , repeated greek indices do not .
consider a general 3-dimensional periodic composite .
the unit cell of the periodic composite is denoted by @xmath0 and is characterized by 3 base vectors @xmath1 , @xmath2 .
any point within the unit cell can be uniquely specified by the vector @xmath3 where @xmath4 .
the same point can also be specified in the orthogonal basis as @xmath5 .
the reciprocal base vectors of the unit cell are given by : @xmath6 such that @xmath7 .
( [ fvectors ] ) shows the schematic of a 2-d unit cell , indicating the unit cell basis vectors , the reciprocal basis vectors and the orthogonal basis vectors .
the composite is characterized by a spatially varying stiffness tensor , @xmath8 , and density , @xmath9 , which satisfy the following periodicity conditions : @xmath10 where @xmath11 @xmath12 are integers . ) , reciprocal basis vectors ( @xmath13 ) , and the orthogonal vectors ( @xmath14 ) are shown . ] for wave propagation in such a periodic composite the wave vector is given as @xmath15 where @xmath16 . for harmonic elastodynamic problems
the equation of motion at any point @xmath17 in @xmath0 is given by @xmath18 where @xmath19 , and @xmath20,\mathbf{u}\exp\left[-i\omega t\right]$ ] are the space and time dependent stress tensor and displacement vector respectively .
the stress tensor is related to the strain tensor through the elasticity tensor , @xmath21 , and the strain tensor is related to the displacement vector through the kinematic relation , @xmath22 . due to the periodicity of the composite the traction and displacement at any point @xmath17
are related to the corresponding traction and displacement at another point , separated from the first by a unit cell , through bloch relations .
these relations serve as the homogeneous boundary conditions on @xmath23 .
if the bloch wave vector is @xmath24 then these boundary conditions are given by : @xmath25;\quad t_j(\mathbf{x}+\mathbf{h}^i)=-t_j(\mathbf{x})\exp\left[i\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{h}^i\right ] , \quad \mathbf{x}\in\partial\omega\ ] ] where @xmath26 are the components of the traction vector and @xmath27 is the exterior normal vector on @xmath23 .
the @xmath28 ( or @xmath29 ) pairs which satisfy the equation of motion along with the bloch boundary conditions constitute the solution to the phononic eigenvalue problem . the most straightforward way of finding a variational solution to the above problem is through the rayleigh quotient method .
this constitutes expressing the equation of motion in terms of displacement through the use of the constitutive and kinematic relations : @xmath30_{,k}=-\lambda\rho u_j\ ] ] it can be shown that the displacement field which satisfies the above equation of motion along with the bloch boundary conditions minimizes the following functional ( displacement rayleigh quotient ) : @xmath31 the inner product is given by : @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the complex conjugate of @xmath34 .
the solutions to the phononic eigenvalue problem are calculated by finding the infimum of @xmath35 .
an analogous single variable quotient can be derived by expressing the governing equation in terms of the stress field : @xmath36_{,k}+\lambda d_{jkmn}\sigma_{mn}=0\ ] ] where @xmath37 and @xmath38 .
the above form leads the following functional ( stress rayleigh quotient ) : @xmath39 which must be minimized to find the eigenvalue solutions of the phononic problem .
yet another variational formulation can be derived by considering a modified form of the governing equation : @xmath40 the above form admits variations on both the displacement and the stress fields and leads to faster convergence of the eigenvalue solution .
the solution to ( [ equationofmotionmix ] ) that satisfies the bloch boundary conditions renders the following functional stationary ( mixed quotient ) : @xmath41 the three variational methods above can be derived from hu - washizu variational theorem , which includes all the equations for the linear theory of elasticity ( without inertial forces ) .
the detailed derivation is presented in @xcite and the quotient formulations have been explicitly given in @xcite .
the minimization problems mentioned in the previous section can be tackled by expanding the displacement and stress fields using chosen test functions to satisfy the boundary conditions and continuity conditions . :
@xmath42 the test functions are appropriately chosen to be orthogonal in the sense that @xmath43 is proportional to @xmath44 , @xmath45 being the kronecker delta . substituting from ( [ approximation])@xmath46 to ( [ dispr ] ) and setting the derivative of @xmath35 with respect to the unknown coefficients , @xmath47 , equal to zero , we arrive at the following system of linear homogeneous equations : @xmath48_{,k}+\lambda_u\rho\bar{u}_j , f^{\theta\eta\xi}\rangle=0\nonumber\\ j , k , m , n=1,2,3\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the general 3-dimensional case , if trigonometric expansion terms are used and @xmath49 vary from @xmath50 to @xmath51 then ( [ equationshomogeneousdispr ] ) represents @xmath52 linear homogeneous equations in the @xmath52 unknown displacement coefficients .
this eigenvalue problem can be cast into the following generalized matrix form : @xmath53 where @xmath54 and @xmath55 are @xmath56 matrices and @xmath57 is the eigenvector consisting of the displacement coefficients used in the expansion .
similar sets of eigenvalue equations can be derived for the stress rayleigh quotient and the mixed quotient . for the stress rayleigh quotient the equations
are : @xmath58_{,k}+\lambda_\sigma d_{jkmn}\bar{\sigma}_{mn},f^{\theta\eta\xi}\rangle=0\nonumber\\ j , k , m , n=1,2,3\end{aligned}\ ] ] which have been derived by substituting from ( [ approximation])@xmath59 to ( [ sigmar ] ) and setting the derivative of @xmath60 with respect to the unknown coefficients , @xmath61 , equal to zero .
taking into account the symmetry of the stress tensor the above represent @xmath62 linear homogeneous equations in the @xmath62 unknown stress coefficients , when trigonometric expansion terms are used .
this eigenvalue problem can be cast into the following matrix form : @xmath63 where @xmath64 and @xmath65 are @xmath66 matrices and @xmath67 is the eigenvector consisting of the stress coefficients used in the expansion .
it is clear , therefore , that the matrices characterizing the stress rayleigh eigenvalue problem are 4 times bigger than the ones characterizing the displacement rayleigh quotient .
the eigenvalue problem resulting from the mixed - quotient can be derived by substituting from ( [ approximation ] ) to ( [ mixedvariational ] ) and setting the derivative of @xmath68 with respect to the unknown displacement and stress coefficients equal to zero .
taking into account the symmetry of the stress tensor we arrive at the following @xmath69 linear homogeneous equations in the @xmath69 unknown displacement and stress coefficients , when trigonometric expansion terms are used : @xmath70 these equations can be written in the following equivalent matrix form : @xmath71 matrices @xmath72 contain the integrals of the various functions appearing in ( [ equationshomogeneous ] ) .
the above system of equations can be recast into the following form : @xmath73 to approximate the stress and displacement fields in ( [ approximation ] ) , we use test functions of the following form : @xmath74)\right]\ ] ] where @xmath75 .
one way for the displacement and stress field to satisfy the boundary conditions , ( [ boundaryconditions ] ) , is to choose the test functions which satisfy the boundary conditions themselves . to show that these test functions satisfy the boundary conditions we note that @xmath76 and , therefore : @xmath77)\right]\exp\left[i(\mathbf{k}\cdot(\mathbf{h}^j\delta_{jk}))\right]\exp\left[i(2\pi[\alpha\delta_{1k}+\beta\delta_{2k}+\gamma\delta_{3k}])\right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath78 are integers the last term equals unity and we have @xmath79\ ] ] showing that test functions satisfy the boundary conditions . to show orthogonality we note that @xmath80)\right ] \exp\left[-i(\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{x}+2\pi[\theta h_1+\eta h_2+\xi h_3])\right]d\omega\\ = \int_\omega \exp\left[i(2\pi[(\alpha-\theta )
h_1+(\beta-\eta ) h_2+(\gamma-\xi ) h_3])\right]d\omega\propto\delta_{\alpha\theta}\delta_{\beta\eta}\delta_{\gamma\xi}\end{aligned}\ ] ] showing the orthogonality of the test functions .
we are primarily interested in studying the convergence rates of the three variational schemes with respect to the number of trigonometric terms used in the expansion @xmath81 .
furthermore , it is of interest to investigate the convergence behaviors of the three variational principles under different compliance and density variations .
nemat - nasser et al.@xcite in 1975 proved that the mixed quotient , in general , converges faster than the other quotients .
babuska and osborn@xcite presented in 1978 their theoretical analysis on the convergence rates of the three quotients , and related them to the function spaces of the density and compliance functions .
they showed that when compliance , @xmath82 , is rough and density , @xmath83 , is smooth , the stress rayleigh quotient converges faster than the displacement rayleigh quotient , however , when density is rough and compliance is smooth , the displacement rayleigh quotient formulation results in faster convergence rates . in both situations
the mixed quotient converges faster than the other two . in the following sections we explicitly calculate the convergence rate of the three quotients under different density and compliance variation .
it can be shown that the error of any formulation considered here is bounded by the following inequality : @xmath84 where @xmath85 is the eigenvalue approximated by @xmath51 trigonometric terms .
we omit the proof of the above inequality , ( [ errorboundm ] ) , and for details refer to babuska and osborn@xcite . since @xmath19 and @xmath86 , frequency , @xmath87 , should also be bounded by the above relation .
we define the relative error as @xmath88 and let @xmath89 .
taking natural @xmath90 on ( [ errorboundm ] ) , we have @xmath91 where @xmath92 is the relative error when @xmath93 and @xmath94 is the relative convergence rate . by plotting @xmath95 as a function of @xmath96 we can extract the convergence rates of the different variational methods . according to nemat - nasser et al.@xcite
, the mixed quotient ( [ mixedvariational ] ) reduces to stress rayleigh quotient ( [ sigmar ] ) under constant density and to the displacement rayleigh quotient under constant compliance .
we expect that the mix quotient converges as fast as the stress rayleigh quotient in the former case and converges at the same rate as the displacement rayleigh quotient in the latter case .
the effect can be explained through the matrix form of the quotients .
for instance , recasting ( [ equationshomogeneousmatrix ] ) into the following form : @xmath97 comparing to ( [ eigenvaluematrixstressr ] ) , we need to show that @xmath98 when density is constant ( since @xmath99 ) .
the matrix form of the mixed quotient formulation has the following coefficients : @xmath100=i2\pi q_k^{\theta\eta\xi}\int_\omega \exp\left[i2\pi(q_l^{\alpha\beta\gamma}-q_l^{\theta\eta\xi})x_l\right]d\omega\\ \nonumber[\mathbf{h}]^*=-i2\pi q_n^{\alpha\beta\gamma}\int_\omega \exp\left[i2\pi(q_l^{\alpha\beta\gamma}-q_l^{\theta\eta\xi})x_l\right]d\omega\\ \nonumber[\mathbf{\omega}]=\int_\omega \rho(x_1,x_2,x_3)\exp\left[i2\pi(q_l^{\alpha\beta\gamma}-q_l^{\theta\eta\xi})x_l\right]d\omega\\ \left[\mathbf{\phi}\right]=\int_\omega d_{jkmn}(x_1,x_2,x_3)\exp\left[i2\pi(q_l^{\alpha\beta\gamma}-q_l^{\theta\eta\xi})x_l\right]d\omega , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath101 .
the matrix form of the stress rayleigh quotient formulation has the following coefficients : @xmath102=-4\pi^2 q_n^{\alpha\beta\gamma}q_k^{\theta\eta\xi}\int_\omega \bar{\rho}(x_1,x_2,x_3)\exp\left[i2\pi(q_l^{\alpha\beta\gamma}-q_l^{\theta\eta\xi})x_l\right]d\omega\\ \left[\mathbf{d}\right]=\int_\omega d_{jkmn}(x_1,x_2,x_3)\exp\left[i2\pi(q_l^{\alpha\beta\gamma}-q_l^{\theta\eta\xi})x_l\right]d\omega . \end{aligned}\ ] ] when @xmath83 is constant , we have @xmath103d\omega$ ] , which is equal to ( [ coefficients3dstressr])@xmath46 .
similarly , we can show that @xmath104 , when compliance is constant . in this case , the coefficients for displacement rayleigh quotient formulation are : @xmath105=\int_\omega \rho(x_1,x_2,x_3)\exp\left[i2\pi(q_l^{\alpha\beta\gamma}-q_l^{\theta\eta\xi})x_l\right]d\omega\\ \left[\mathbf{c}\right]=-4\pi^2 q_n^{\alpha\beta\gamma}q_k^{\theta\eta\xi}\int_\omega c_{jkmn}(x_1,x_2,x_3)\exp\left[i2\pi(q_l^{\alpha\beta\gamma}-q_l^{\theta\eta\xi})x_l\right]d\omega , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath106 is the material stiffness tensor satisfying @xmath107 . in summary , for the cases when either density or compliance is constant , the mixed quotient results in the same matrices as the stress rayleigh quotient and the displacement rayleigh quotient respectively .
there is only one possible bravais lattice in 1-dimension with a unit cell vector whose length equals the length of the unit cell itself ( fig . [ 1-dfvectors ] ) . without any loss of generality
we take the direction of this vector to be the same as @xmath108 .
if the length of the unit cell is @xmath109 , then we have @xmath110 .
the reciprocal vector is given by @xmath111 .
the wave - vector of a bloch wave traveling in this composite is specified as @xmath112 . to completely characterize the band - structure of the unit cell
it is sufficient to evaluate the dispersion relation in the irreducible brillouin zone ( @xmath113 ) . , reciprocal basis vector ( @xmath114 ) , and the orthogonal vector ( @xmath108 ) are shown . ] for plane longitudinal wave propagating in the @xmath108 direction the only displacement component of interest is @xmath115 and the only relevant stress component is @xmath116 ( for plane shear waves traveling in @xmath108 direction the quantities of interest are @xmath117 and @xmath118 ) .
the equation of motion and the constitutive law are : @xmath119 where @xmath120 is the spatially varying young s modulus .
the exact dispersion relation for 1-d longitudinal wave propagation in a periodic layered composite has been given by rytov@xcite , @xmath121 where @xmath122 is the thickness , @xmath123 is the density , and @xmath124 is the longitudinal wave velocity of the @xmath125th layer @xmath126 in a unit cell .
we can solve for the corresponding wave number @xmath24 by providing a range of frequency , @xmath127 , using ( [ rytov ] ) .
the displacement and stress fields are approximated by 1-d trigonometric functions : @xmath128,\quad \bar{\sigma}_{11}=\sum_{\alpha =- m}^ms^{\alpha}_{11}\exp\left[i(\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{x}+2\pi\alpha h_1)\right]\ ] ] which can be further simplified to : @xmath129,\quad \bar{\sigma}_{11}=\sum_{\alpha =- m}^ms^{\alpha}_{11}\exp\left[i2\pi(q_1+\alpha)x_1/a\right],\ ] ] where @xmath109 is the periodicity length .
for the displacement rayleigh quotient the eigenvalue problem is : @xmath130_{,1}+\lambda_u\rho\bar{u}_1,f^\theta\rangle=0\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath131 .
the above are transformed to the matrix form of ( [ eigenvaluematrixdispr ] ) with the following column vector : @xmath132 the associated coefficient matrices have the following elements : @xmath133_{ij}=\frac{-4\pi^2(q_1+i - m-1)(q_1+j - m-1)}{a^2}\int_0^ae(x_1)\exp\left[i2\pi(i - j)x_1/a\right]dx_1\\ \nonumber[\boldsymbol{\rho}]_{ij}=\int_0^a\rho(x_1)\exp\left[i2\pi(i - j)x_1/a\right]dx_1\\ i , j=1,2, ... (2m+1)\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the stress rayleigh quotient the eigenvalue problem is : @xmath134_{,1}+\lambda_\sigma d\bar{\sigma}_{11},f^{\theta}\rangle=0\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath131 and @xmath135 .
the above are transformed to the matrix form of ( [ eigenvaluematrixstressr ] ) with the following column vector : @xmath136 the associated coefficient matrices have the following elements : @xmath137_{ij}=\int_0^ad(x_1)\exp\left[i2\pi(i - j)x_1/a\right]dx_1\\ \nonumber[\boldsymbol{\bar{\rho}}]_{ij}=\frac{-4\pi^2(q_1+i - m-1)(q_1+j - m-1)}{a^2}\int_0^a\bar{\rho}(x_1)\exp\left[i2\pi(i - j)x_1/a\right]dx_1\\ i , j=1,2, ... (2m+1 ) .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the mixed - quotient the eigenvalue problem is : @xmath138 where @xmath131 .
the above are transformed to the matrix form of ( [ equationshomogeneousmatrix ] ) with column vectors ( [ dispclmnvec ] ) and ( [ stressclmnvec ] ) .
the associated coefficient matrices have the following elements : @xmath139_{ij}=\frac{i2\pi(q_1+i - m-1)}{a}\int_0^a\exp\left[i2\pi(i - j)x_1/a\right]dx_1\\ \nonumber[\mathbf{\omega}]_{ij}=\int_0^a\rho(x_1)\exp\left[i2\pi(i - j)x_1/a\right]dx_1\\ \nonumber[\mathbf{\phi}]_{ij}=\int_0^ad(x_1)\exp\left[i2\pi(i - j)x_1/a\right]dx_1\\ \nonumber\left[\mathbf{h}\right]^*_{ij}=\frac{-i2\pi(q_1+j - m-1)}{a}\int_0^a\exp\left[i2\pi(i - j)x_1/a \right]dx_1\\ i , j=1,2, ... (2m+1 ) .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] now the eigenvalue problems can be solved for the frequencies @xmath127 which correspond to an assumed value of @xmath140 . the exact solution for wave propagation in 1-d for a 2-phase periodic composite was first given in ( [ rytov ] ) .
here we present a comparison of the results from the displacement rayleigh quotient , stress rayleigh quotient , and mixed quotient formulations with the exact rytov solution .
we have not employed numerical integration in the following results because for the 1-d case the integrals in ( [ coefficients1ddispr ] ) , ( [ coefficients1dstressr ] ) and ( [ coefficients1dmixedq ] ) can be calculated exactly .
the composite under consideration is a 2-phase layered composite consisting of the following 2 phases : 1 .
phase 1 : @xmath141 2 .
phase 2 : @xmath142 fig .
( [ comparewithexact ] ) shows the comparison of the results from the displacement rayleigh quotient , stress rayleigh quotient and mixed quotient formulations with the rytov solution for the first five branches .
the results are calculated for @xmath143 at a total of 99 points .
the variational results are shown for @xmath144 for each variational scheme . .
] it is clear from fig .
( [ comparewithexact ] ) that the mixed quotient and the stress rayleigh quotient capture the first 3 branches very well . in general , more trigonometric expansion terms are required for higher accuracy in higher branches and the accuracy of all three quotients worsens as we consider higher branches . for the 4th and 5th branches , the stress rayleigh quotient gives better approximation than the mixed quotient , however it shows slower convergence ( table [ errorcexact ] ) .
.the average convergence rates , @xmath94 , and the initial errors , @xmath92 , approximated using the results from @xmath145 to @xmath146 for the first five branches . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ]
we have presented comparative convergence studies of three variational principles used for solving elastodynamic eigenvalue problems .
the formulations of three fundamental principles presented in this paper can be easily applied to 1- , 2- , and 3-d periodic composites .
the convergence behavior is seen to be related to the continuity and differentiability of the material property variations .
smoothly varying material properties in a unit cell result in higher convergence rates for all three quotients . comparing the three methods ,
mixed quotient generally shows larger convergence rates for the different considered cases .
although generally showing superior effectiveness in convergence , mixed quotient is as fast as displacement or stress rayleigh quotient when either compliance or density is constant respectively .
the relative errors produced by the mixed quotient for a given @xmath51 can be smaller by as much as @xmath147 , when compared to those produced by the displacement or stress rayleigh quotients using trigonometric terms . in the comparisons between mixed quotient and two other methods , fem and pwe , we find that the mixed quotient , in general , has larger convergence rates .
this research has been conducted under ucsd / onr w91crb-10 - 1 - 0006 award to the illinois institute of technology ( darpa afosr grant rdecom w91crb-101 - 0006 to the university of california , san diego ) .
10 url # 1`#1`urlprefixhref # 1#2#2 # 1#1 f. cervera , l. sanchis , j. sanchez - perez , r. martinez - sala , c. rubio , f. meseguer , c. lopez , d. caballero , j. snchez - dehesa , refractive acoustic devices for airborne sound , physical review letters 88 ( 2 ) ( 2001 ) 23902 .
a. khelif , a. choujaa , b. djafari - rouhani , m. wilm , s. ballandras , v. laude , trapping and guiding of acoustic waves by defect modes in a full - band - gap ultrasonic crystal , physical review b 68 ( 21 ) ( 2003 ) 214301 .
o. sigmund , j. s. jensen , systematic design of phononic band gap materials and structures by topology optimization , philosophical transactions of the royal society of london .
series a : mathematical , physical and engineering sciences 361 ( 1806 ) ( 2003 ) 10011019 . c. j. rupp , a. evgrafov , k. maute , m. l. dunn , design of phononic materials / structures for surface wave devices using topology optimization , structural and multidisciplinary optimization 34 ( 2 ) ( 2007 ) 111121 .
hladky - hennion , j .-
decarpigny , analysis of the scattering of a plane acoustic wave by a doubly periodic structure using the finite element method : application to alberich anechoic coatings , the journal of the acoustical society of america 90 ( 6 ) ( 1991 ) 33563367 . s. nemat - nasser , anti - plane shear waves in periodic elastic composites : band structure and anomalous wave refraction , proceedings of the royal society of london a : mathematical , physical and engineering sciences 471 ( 2180 ) .
c. geuzaine , j .- f .
remacle , gmsh : a 3-d finite element mesh generator with built - in pre - and post - processing facilities , international journal for numerical methods in engineering 79 ( 11 ) ( 2009 ) 13091331 .
j. vasseur , p. deymier , b. chenni , b. djafari - rouhani , l. dobrzynski , d. prevost , experimental and theoretical evidence for the existence of absolute acoustic band gaps in two - dimensional solid phononic crystals , physical review letters 86 ( 14 ) ( 2001 ) 30123015 . | three fundamental variational principles used for solving elastodynamic eigenvalue problems are studied within the context of elastic wave propagation in periodic composites ( phononics ) .
we study the convergence of the eigenvalue problems resulting from the displacement rayleigh quotient , the stress rayleigh quotient and the mixed quotient .
the convergence rates of the three quotients are found to be related to the continuity and differentiability of the density and compliance variation over the unit cell . in general
, the mixed quotient converges faster than both the displacement rayleigh and the stress rayleigh quotients , however , there exist special cases where either the displacement rayleigh or the stress rayleigh quotient shows the exact same convergence as the mixed - method .
we show that all methods converge faster for smoother material property variations , but when density variation is rough , the difference between the mixed quotient and stress rayleigh quotient is higher and similarly , when compliance variation is rough , the difference between the mixed quotient and displacement rayleigh quotient is higher . since eigenvalue problems such as those considered in this paper tend to be highly computationally intensive , it is expected that these results will lead to fast and efficient algorithms in the areas of phononics and photonics .
phononics , variational methods , bandstructure |
the nuclear symmetry energy plays an important role in the properties of nuclei and neutron stars @xcite . to a good approximantion
, it can be written as @xmath0 where @xmath1 , is the isospin asymmetry ; @xmath2 , @xmath3 , are the neutron , proton densities , and @xmath4 describes the density dependence of the symmetry energy .
theoretical predictions for @xmath4 from microscopic nucleon - nucleon interactions show large uncertainties , especially in the region of suprasaturation density @xcite . constraining
the density dependence of the symmetry energy has become one of the main goals in nuclear physics and has stimulated many theoretical and experimental studies @xcite .
heavy ion collisions ( hic ) with asymmetric nuclei provide a unique opportunity for laboratory studies of the density dependence of the symmetry energy because a large range of densities can be momentarily achieved during hics . in theoretical studies with transport models , the isospin ratio observables which are constructed from the isospin contents of emitted nucleons or fragments , such as y(n)/y(p ) and dr(n / p ) for emitted nucleons@xcite
, isospin transport ratios @xmath5 constructed from the isospin asymmetry of projectile residues ( or emitted resource)@xcite , and @xmath6 , constructed from the yields of lcp between the mid - rapidity and projectile region@xcite , have been prove to be primarily sensitive to the density dependence of the symmetry energy . by comparing the theoretical predictions to the experimental data , the sought - after constraints can be obtained .
one frequently utilized transport models to describe the heavy ion collisions is the boltzmann - uehling - uhlenbeck ( buu ) equation , which provides an approximate wigner transform of the one - body density matrix as its solution@xcite .
@xmath7-[f_{1'}f_{2'}(1-f)(1-f_{2})]\nonumber\\ & & \times ( 2\pi)^3\delta^{3}(\mathbf{p}+\mathbf{p}_2-\mathbf{p}_{1'}-\mathbf{p}_{2'})\ } \label{buueq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the l.h.s .
of this equation is the total differential of @xmath8 with respect to the time assuming a potential @xmath9 .
usually a skyrme - parametrization of the real part of the g - matrix or skyrme - like energy density functional are employed as the nucleonic potential which describe the influence of the different isospin asymmetric nuclear equation of state ( asy - eos ) .
stochastic extensions of these mean - field based approaches have been introduced ( see @xcite and references therein ) .
for instance , in the so - called stochastic mean field ( smf ) @xcite model fluctuations are injected in coordinate space by agitating the spacial density profile . the r.h.s .
( [ buueq ] ) contains a boltzmann collision integral which describes the influence of binary hard - core collisions and are realized by the test particles .
another frequently utilized approaches , known as the molecular dynamics model ( qmd)that represent the individual nucleons as gaussian `` wave - packet '' with mean values that move in according the ehrenfest theorem ; i.e. hamilton s equations@xcite .
@xmath10 the expectation of the total hamiltonian @xmath11 is obtained from the real part of the g - matrix or the skyrme energy density functional , and it describes the influence of the different asy - eos .
the collision part in the qmd models are handled as same as the way in buu type models but it is for nucleons rather than the test particles . in this work ,
we choose to simulate nuclear collisions with the code imqmd05 developed at the china institute of atomic energy ( ciae ) , details of this code are described in ref .
@xcite , for studying several isospin ratio observables , such as dr(n / p ) , isospin transport ratios @xmath5 , @xmath6 ratios for the yields of lcp between the mid - rapidity and projectile region and their relations to the fragmentation mechanism . for brevity
, we limit our discussion here to the parameterization of the symmetry energy used in our calculations , which is of the form @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the nucleon mass and the symmetry coefficient @xmath14 . using this particular parameterization , the symmetry energy at subsaturation densities increases with decreasing @xmath15 , while the opposite is true for supranormal densities . in general , the eos is labeled as stiff - asy for @xmath16 , and as soft - asy for @xmath17 .
finally , we also give a brief discussion the recent comparisons between the imqmd05 and smf calculations for further understanding the theoretical issue in the describing the reaction mechanism at low - intermediate energy heavy ion collisions .
isospin ratios which are constructed from the isospin contents of fragments , such as @xmath18 ( or named as n / p ratio ) , dr(n / p ) from neutron - rich and neutron - poor systems , isospin transport ratios @xmath5 and @xmath19(@xmath20)/@xmath21([email protected] ) , are sensitive to the density dependence of symmetry energy . in this section
, we will check their sensitivities to the density dependence of symmetry energy and try to get the information of symmetry energy from them .
the neutron to proton ratio @xmath23 of pre - equilibrium emitted neutron over proton spectra was considered as a sensitive observable to the density dependence of symmetry energy@xcite , because it has a straightforward link to the symmetry energy . in order to reduce the sensitivity to uncertainties in the neutron detection efficiencies and sensitivity to relative uncertainties in energy calibrations of neutrons and protons , the double ratio @xmath24 had been measured by famiano and compared with the transport model prediction@xcite .
we performed calculations of collisions at an impact parameter of @xmath25 at an incident energy of @xmath26 per nucleon for two systems : @xmath27 and @xmath28 with imqmd05 to study the @xmath29 ratio for emitted nucleons@xcite .
the shaded regions in the left panel of fig.[fig - dr ] show the range , determined by uncertainties in the simulations , of predicted double ratios @xmath30 of the nucleons emitted between @xmath31 and @xmath32 in the center of mass frame as a function of the center of mass nucleon energy , for @xmath33 and @xmath34 .
the double ratios @xmath29 are higher for the eos with the weaker symmetry energy density dependence @xmath33 than that for @xmath35 because the nucleons mainly emit from the lower density region at intermediate energy hics .
compare to the data on @xmath29 for emitted nucleons(solid stars ) , the general trend of data @xmath29 are qualitatively reproduced and the data seem to be closer to the calculation employing the eos with @xmath36 .
the right panel of fig.[fig - dr ] show the coalescence - invariant double ratio .
the coalescence - invariant double ratios are constructed by including all neutrons and protons emitted at a given velocity , regardless of whether they are emitted free or within a cluster .
the data are shown as open stars and the calculation results are shown as shaded region . here
, the measurement and simulation results illustrate that the fragments with @xmath37 mainly contribute to the low energy spectra and do not affect the high - energy @xmath29 data very much .
( color online ) ( left ) dr(n / p ) ratios for emitted free nucleons and ( right ) coalescent - invariant @xmath29 from the imqmd simulations are plotted as shadow region.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] in order to constrain the range of @xmath38 from the @xmath29 data that had been published , a series calculations for two systems , @xmath27 and @xmath28 , have been performed by varying @xmath39 and @xmath34@xcite . since the emitted nucleons are mainly from the subnormal densities at this energies , the n / p ratios of emitted nucleons are associated with the values of symmetry energy at subnormal density .
therefor , the @xmath29 ratio should increase with decreasing @xmath38 .
however , in the limit of very small @xmath40 , the finite system completely disintegrates and the @xmath29 ratio decrease and approaches the limit of reaction system , @xmath41 . as a consequence of these two competing effects ,
the double ratio values peak around the @xmath42 . despite the large experiment uncertainties for higher energy data , those comparisons definitely rule out very soft ( @xmath43 ) and very stiff ( @xmath35 ) density dependence of symmetry energy .
the @xmath44 analysis suggest that within a @xmath45 uncertainty , parameters of @xmath38 fall in the range of @xmath46 for the @xmath47 . when the projectile and target nuclei come into contact , there can be exchange of nucleons between them . if the neutron to proton ratios of the projectile and target differ greatly , the net nucleon flux can cause a diffusion of the asymmetry @xmath48 reducing the difference between the asymmetries of two nuclei .
this isospin diffusion process , which depends on the magnitude of the symmetry energy , affects the isospin asymmetry of the projectile and target residues in peripheral hics . the isospin transport ratio @xmath5 has been introduced @xcite to quantify the isospin diffusion effects , @xmath49 where x is an isospin observable and the subscripts @xmath50 and @xmath51 represent the neutron rich and neutron - poor nuclei . in this work ,
we use @xmath50 and @xmath51 to denote the projectile ( first index ) and target ( second index ) combination . where @xmath52 , and @xmath53 .
we obtain the value of @xmath54 by comparing three reaction systems , @xmath55 , @xmath56 and @xmath57 ( or @xmath58 ) .
construction of the transport ratio minimize the influence of other effects besides isospin diffusion effects on the fragment yields , such as preequilibrium emission and secondary decay , by rescaling the observable x for the asymmetric a+b system by its values for the neutron - rich and neutron - deficient symmetric systems , which do not experience isospin diffusion .
based on eq .
( [ ridef ] ) , one expects @xmath59 in the absence of isospin diffusion and @xmath60 if isospin equilibrium is achieved .
( [ ridef ] ) also dictates that two different observables , @xmath61 , will give the same results if they are linearly related . in one experiment ,
@xmath61 was taken as the isoscaling parameter , @xmath62 , obtained from the yield of the light particles near the projectile rapidity@xcite , to measure the isospin diffusion ability in heavy ion collisions . in transport models
@xcite , the isospin asymmetry @xmath48 of the projectile residues ( emitting source ) has been used to compute @xmath63 because it is linearly related to the isoscaling parameters @xmath62@xcite .
we analyze the amount of isospin diffusion with imqmd05 by constructing a tracer from the isospin asymmetry of all emitted nucleons ( n ) and fragments ( frag ) , including the heavy residue if it exists , with velocity cut @xmath64 ( nearly identical results are obtained with higher velocity cut @xmath65 ) .
this represents the full projectile - like emitting source , and should be comparable to what has been measured in experiments .
fig.2 shows the results of isospin transport ratios @xmath66 ( upright triangles ) as a function of the impact parameter for a soft symmetry case ( @xmath67 , open symbols ) and a stiff symmetry case ( @xmath68 , closed symbols ) . @xmath5
obtained with soft - symmetry case is smaller than those obtained with stiff - symmetry potential case .
this is consistent with the expectation that higher symmetry energy at subnormal density leads to larger isospin diffusion effects ( smaller @xmath5 values ) .
, open symbols ) and a stiff symmetry case ( @xmath68 , closed symbols ) .
upright triangle symbols are for the tracer defined by the isospin asymmetry of all fragments and unbound nucleons with velocity cut ( @xmath64 ) , @xmath69 .
circles are for the tracer defined by the heaviest fragment with @xmath70 in projectile region , @xmath71.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] @xmath5 depends weakly on impact parameter over a range extending from central ( @xmath72 ) to mid peripheral(@xmath73 ) collisions .
interestingly , the isospin equilibrium and global thermal equilibrium are not reached even for central collisions .
our results show , that neither the effective interaction is sufficiently strong nor the collisions are sufficiently frequent ( most of them are pauli suppressed ) to mix the projectile and target nucleons completely .
these two effects prevent the combined system from attaining isospin equilibrium even in central collisions . with impact parameter increasing for @xmath74 , the overlap region and thus the number of nucleons transferred from projectile and target decreases , causing the @xmath5 values to increase . in peripheral collisions ,
most often , a large residue remains .
if it decouples from the full emitting source before it equilibrates , it may experience a different amount of diffusion than the full emitting source examined by @xmath69 . to examine this
, we constructed a tracer using the isospin asymmetry of the heaviest fragments with charge @xmath75 in the projectile region .
this tracer is mainly relevant to peripheral collisions as the central collisions are dominated by multifragmentation and very few large projectile fragments survive .
the dependence of @xmath76 for impact parameter @xmath77 is shown as open and closed circles in fig .
the isospin transport ratios constructed from the different isospin tracers have different values especially in the case of @xmath67 .
stronger isospin equilibration ( smaller @xmath5 values ) is observed in the isospin transport ratios @xmath66 constructed from nucleons and fragments than @xmath76 constructed from the heaviest fragments with @xmath70 .
since isospin diffusion mainly occurs through the low - density neck region , and the system breaks up before isospin equilibrium , the asymmetry of the projectile and target residues do not achieve equilibrium and , larger @xmath78 values result .
in contrast , there is more mixing of nucleons from the target and projectile in the neck region due to the isospin diffusion .
consequently , rupture of the neutron - rich neck is predicted to result in the production of neutron - rich fragments at mid rapidity .
since fragments are formed at all rapidities , we can examine the rapidity dependence of @xmath5 to obtain more information about the reaction dynamics .
3 shows @xmath5 as a function of the scaled rapidity @xmath79 .
the symbols in the leftmost panel are experimental data obtained in ref .
@xcite for three centrality gates .
this transport ratio was generated using the isospin tracer @xmath80 where @xmath81 is the yield ratio of the mirror nuclei , @xmath82 and @xmath83 @xcite .
as expected the values of @xmath5 obtained from peripheral collisions ( solid stars ) are larger than those obtained in central collisions ( open stars ) . for comparison ,
the imqmd05 calculations of @xmath66 are plotted as lines in the middle and right panels for a range of impact parameters .
the middle panel contains the results from the soft symmetry potential ( @xmath67 ) while the right panel shows the results from the stiff symmetry potential ( @xmath68 ) .
the impact parameter trends and magnitude of the data are more similar to the results of the calculations from soft symmetry potentials ( @xmath67 ) for peripheral collisions .
we have performed the @xmath44 analysis for both observables , @xmath5 and @xmath84 , for constraining the density dependence of symmetry energy .
using the same 2@xmath85 criterion , the analysis brackets the regions @xmath86 is obtained .
it is consistent with previous analysis on dr(n / p ) .
however , the experimental trend of @xmath5 gated on the most central collisions ( open stars ) is not reproduced by the calculations .
the experimental data indicate more equilibration for central collisions near mid rapidity while the transport model indicates more transparency .
the equilibration in the e / a = 50mev data may be the result of the impact parameter determination from charged particle multiplicity wherein the most central collisions are assumed to be the ones with highest charge particle multiplicity . for the most central events , a gate on the highest multiplicity , may select events in which more nucleon - nucleon collisions occur rather than a strict selection on the most central impact parameters . as a function of rapidity for three centrality gates [ 16 ] .
( middle panel ) the calculated results of @xmath66 as a function of rapidity for @xmath87 for @xmath67 and ( right panel ) @xmath68.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] the yield ratios , @xmath6 , for lcps between the projectile region and mid - rapidity region , are defined as @xmath88 where @xmath89 is the reduced rapidity . it reflect the isospin migration ability and have been measured by _ kohley.et.al . _ for @xmath90 , @xmath91 , @xmath92 at the beam energy of 35 mev / nucleon for middle peripheral collisions @xcite .
the data show a clear preference for emission around the mid - rapidity region for more neutron - rich lcps resulting from the isospin migration mechanism through the neck region between the projectile and target@xcite .
theoretical study by smf model@xcite demonstrates that @xmath6 is sensitive to the density dependence of symmetry energy .
the experimental trends are reproduced by smf model . however , there are largest discrepancies on the reduced rapidity distribution for the yields of proton and @xmath93 , and also on their values of @xmath6 as mentioned in reference@xcite .
the discrepancies were thought to be related to the statistical decay of qp at later stages of the reaction @xcite . in the points of reaction dynamics ,
the different fragmentation mechanism in the transport models simulations also lead to different behaviors of the rapidity distribution for lcps besides the effects from secondary decay .
thus , it is instructive to study the rapidity distribution of lcp with imqmd05 . in fig.[ref - fig.3](a ) , we present the multiplicity distribution for fragments with @xmath94 for @xmath90 at @xmath95=35 mev / nucleon and impact parameter b=4fm and @xmath68 .
we find that * half * of events belongs to multi - fragmentation process which are defined by multiplicity for fragments with charge @xmath96 , i.e.,@xmath97 .
the rest are the binary ( @xmath98 ) and ternary ( @xmath99 ) fragmentation events .
it suggests that the binary , ternary fragmentation and multi - fragmentation coexist around 35mev / nucleon . in fig.[ref - fig.3 ] ( b ) and ( c ) , we plot the reduced rapidity distribution for the yields of @xmath93 and @xmath100 obtained with three kinds of fragmentation process , binary ( square symbols ) , ternary ( circle symbols ) and multi - fragmentation ( triangle symbols ) which are selected by @xmath101 and @xmath102 .
the yields of @xmath93 and @xmath100 in fig.[ref - fig.3 ] are normalized to per event .
it is clear that the binary events produce more @xmath93 and @xmath100 at mid - rapidity relative to that produce in multi - fragmentation events . for @xmath68 case , the yield of @xmath93 at @xmath103 obtained with binary fragmentation events is 35% larger than that with multi - fragmentation events . for neutron - rich lcp , for example
, the yield of @xmath100 at @xmath103 obtained in binary fragmentation events is 70% larger than that in multi - fragmentation events due to isospin migration .
( color online ) ( a ) the multiplicity distribution for fragments with @xmath94 ( @xmath104 ) .
( b ) is the reduced rapidity ( @xmath105 ) distribution for the yield of @xmath93 with binary ( square symbols ) , ternary ( circle symbols ) and multi - fragmentation ( triangle symbols ) process .
( c ) is for @xmath100 .
all of those results are for @xmath90 at e=35 mev / u for b=4fm and @xmath68 . ]
fig.[ref - fig.4 ] shows the calculated results for the rapidity distribution of light charged particles _
, _ d _ , _ t _ , @xmath106 , @xmath107 and @xmath108 for @xmath109 at b=4fm with 100,000 events .
the distributions are normalized with the yield at @xmath103 for comparing with data in ref @xcite to understand the fragmentation mechanism , because the fragmentation mechanism mainly determine the shape of the rapidity distribution for lcp .
the open circles are for @xmath67 and solid symbols are for @xmath68 .
the data are taken from the ref @xcite and plotted as stars .
both our calculations and data show that the width of distribution decreases with the mass of lcps increasing . for the rapidity distributions of @xmath110 and @xmath93 ,
the width of distribution for @xmath110 is smaller than that for @xmath93 due to the isospin migration . by comparing the simulated results to the data , the imqmd05 calculations with stiffer symmetry energy
can well reproduce the data at forward rapidity region ( @xmath111 ) for all _ p _ , _ d _ , _ t _ , @xmath93 , @xmath112 and @xmath100 .
for the backward rapidity region ( @xmath113 ) , there are obvious differences between the results from imqmd05 calculations and the data because the efficiency for detection of lcps at the backward @xcite are not included in this imqmd05 calculations . in order to constrain the symmetry energy by the rapidity distribution of lcps
, we further calculate @xmath114 in a series of @xmath115 . in fig.[ref - fig.5 ] , we present the results of @xmath6 as a function of the az of emitted particles for three reaction systems @xmath91 , @xmath92 and @xmath90 at b=4fm .
the open symbols are the results for @xmath116 and @xmath34 .
the solid stars are the data from @xcite .
since the isospin migration occurs in the neutron - rich neck region , the @xmath6 shows an increasing trend with the values of isospin asymmetry of lcps increasing for the same element .
the more neutron - rich the lcps is , the larger the @xmath6 is .
furthermore , the calculated results show the values of @xmath6 for neutron - rich isotopes are sensitive to the density dependence of symmetry energy .
the calculations with stiffer symmetry energy predict larger values of @xmath6 due to the stronger isospin migration effects .
this conclusion is as same as the results obtained with smf model @xcite . as shown in fig.[ref - fig.5 ] , the imqmd05 calculations with stiffer symmetry energy ( @xmath117 ) can reasonably reproduce the data of @xmath6 as a function of az for @xmath91 .
but our calculations underestimate the @xmath6 values of neutron - rich light charged particles , such as @xmath100 , for the neutron - rich reaction systems @xmath92 and @xmath90 .
it could come from the lacking of fine structure effects of neutron - rich elements ( such as neutron - skin , stability of lighter neutron - rich elements ) , and the impact parameter smearing effects in the transport model simulations .
even though our calculations can reproduce the @xmath6 data for @xmath118 , the definitely constraints on the symmetry energy with the data of @xmath6 can not be obtained before we fix the problems on the theoretical predictions of @xmath6 for neutron - rich reaction system .
( color online)@xmath114 values as a function of the charge times mass ( za ) for _ p _ ( za=1 ) , _ d _ ( za=2 ) , _ t _ ( za=3 ) , @xmath93 ( za=6 ) , @xmath112 ( za=8 ) , @xmath100 ( za=12 ) .
the open symbols are the results obtained with imqmd05 for @xmath116 and @xmath34 .
the solid stars are the data from @xcite . ] up to date , there are several constraints on the symmetry energy with isospin sensitive observables , dr(n / p ) raitos , isospin transport ratios @xmath5 and @xmath6 ratios , by adopting different type of transport models , such as qmd type and buu type@xcite . there are overlap between the results of symmetry energy from different approaches , but they are different in detail .
thus , further understanding the issues in the qmd type and buu type would be crucial in theoretical studies for improving the constraints on the symmetry energy . at the code level ,
both buu and qmd models propagate particles classically under the influence of a mean field potential , which is calculated self - consistently the positions and momenta of the particles , and allow scattering by nucleon - nucleon collisions due to the residual interaction . the pauli principle in both approaches
is enforced by application of pauli blocking factors .
these similarities in implementation have lead to similarities in predictions for many collision observables @xcite .
there are also significant differences in these approaches . in the buu equations ,
each nucleon is represented by 200 - 1000 test particels that generate the mean field and suffer the collisions . in qmd , there is one test particle per nucleon .
a - body correlations and cluster formation are not native to the original buu approach ; which is supposed to provide the wigner transform of the one body density matrix . on the other hand ,
many - body correlations and fluctuations can arise from the a - body dynamics of qmd approach .
such a - body correlations are suppressed in buu approach , but correlations can arise in both approaches from the amplification of mean field instabilities in spinodal region @xcite .
collision algorithms in the qmd approach modify the momenta of individual nucleons , while in buu approach , only the momenta of test particles are modified . depending on the details of the in - medium cross sections that are implemented
, the blocking of collisions can also be more restrictive for qmd than for buu , leading to fewer collisions and therefore a greater transparency .
fragments can be formed in qmd approaches due to the a - body correlations and these correlations are mapped onto the asymptotic final fragments by a minimum spanning tree algorithm .
serval different methods have been developed to allow buu codes to calculate cluster production . in the stochastic mean field ( smf )
approach ( one of the buu type model ) , the time evolution of the one - body phase - space distribution @xmath8 is governed by the nuclear mean - field , two - body scattering , and a fluctuating ( stochastic ) term which causes the fragmentation @xcite . since there are typically more than 100 test particles per nucleon , collision induced fluctuations are smaller in buu than in qmd possibly suppressing the fragment formation rates . as an example , we present the results of average charge number for @xmath119 as a function of rapidity obtained with imqmd05 and smf models for @xmath120 at @xmath121 and b=6 , 8fm in fig.[ref - zhangsmf ] .
the solid lines are the results from imqmd05 , and dashed lines are from smf calculations@xcite .
squares are for b=6fm , and circles are for b=8fm .
the results obtained with qmd simulations show that the average charge number of @xmath119 increase with rapidity increasing before @xmath122 in the forward region in the qmd simulations , and two peaks appear around the projectile and target rapidity region , respectively . in the smf simulations
, the peak appears at mid - rapidity besides two peaks around projectile and target rapidity .
it clearly shown that the strict pauli blocking in the qmd models simulations leads to a greater transparency than that in the smf type simulations .
the larger fluctuation in the qmd models lead to more fragments and light particles emitted than that from smf predictions . as results ,
the fragments distributed over the whole rapidity region and heavier fragment is , larger velocity is . in smf calculations ,
the fragmentation process is less effective due to the reduced amplitude of fluctuations and many - body correlations .
this enhances the appearance of binary and ternary processes in semi - peripheral heavy ion reactions , according to the prominent role of the mean - field dynamics . as a consequence ,
the intermediate mass fragments tend to distribute at mid - rapidity .
it also lead that the the average charge number of @xmath119 have a peak around mid - rapidity and narrower rapidity distribution of lighter clusters than the results from qmd models .
( color online ) the average charge number for @xmath119 as a function of rapidity for @xmath120 at b=6,8fm with @xmath68 .
the solid lines are the results from imqmd05 , and dashed lines are from smf.,scaledwidth=35.0% ]
in summary , we have investigated the influences of the density dependence of the symmetry energy on several different isospin ratio observables , such as dr(n / p ) ratio , isospin transport ratios @xmath5 , the rapidity dependence of isospin transport ratio @xmath84 and @xmath6 raitos ( the yield ratios of lcp between the mid - rapidity and projectile region ) with imqmd05 .
the study shows that these isospin ratio observables are sensitive to the density dependence of symmetry energy .
this conclusion is similar to conclusions reached using buu approaches in the range of symmetry energies studied here . by comparing the calculated results to data , the very soft ( @xmath123 ) and very stiff symmetry energy ( @xmath68 ) are ruled out .
cluster formation is important for intermediate energy heavy ion collisions , and it modifies the spectral double ratios at @xmath124 .
we also tested different tracers by constructing corresponding isospin transport ratios for them using different symmetry energies . for weakly density dependent symmetry energies ( small @xmath15 ) with large symmetry energies at sub - saturation densities , the values of @xmath5 for the residue tracer @xmath125 are larger than those extracted from the entire emitting source , i.e. , @xmath69 .
the difference between these two tracers can be examined experimentally as a new probe of the symmetry energy and reaction mechanism . by studying reaction systems @xmath91 , @xmath92 and @xmath90 at the beam energy of 35 mev per nucleon and b=4fm within the framework of imqmd05
, we find that half of events belongs to the multi - fragmentation mechanism , and half of them is of binary and ternary fragmentation events .
the binary and ternary events produce more light charged particles at middle rapidity , and the multi - fragmentation events broaden the reduced rapidity distribution for the yields of lcps .
both the data and our calculations illustrate that the reaction systems seems more transparency and more fragments , light particles emitted . as results , the data of the reduced rapidity distribution for the yields of lcps and @xmath114 as a function of az for @xmath109 can be well reproduced by the imqmd05 calculations . for neutron rich reaction systems @xmath92 and @xmath90 ,
our calculations underestimate the @xmath6 values of neutron - rich light charged particles , such as @xmath100 , it could be cause by the lacking of fine structure effects for lighter elements in the transport models , and the impact parameter smearing effects .
this work has been supported by the chinese national science foundation under grants 11075215 , 10979023 , 10875031 , 11005022,11005155 , 10235030 , and the national basic research program of china no .
we wish to acknowledge the support of the national science foundation grants no . phy-0606007 .
9 j. lattimer and m. prakash , ap .
j. 550 , 426 ( 2001 ) .
j. lattimer and m. prakash , science 304 , 536 ( 2001 ) .
a. steiner et al . , phys .
411 , 325 ( 2005 ) .
a. l. watts and t. e. strohmayer , ap .
j. 637 , l117 ( 2006 ) .
d. g. yakovlev and c. j. pethick , annu .
42 , 169 ( 2004 ) .
b. a. brown , phys .
c 43 , r1513 ( 1991 ) .
b. li et al . , phys .
rep 464 , 113 ( 2008 ) .
p. danielewicz , r. lacey , and w. g.lynch , science 298 , 1592 ( 2006 ) . c. fuch and h. wolter , eur .
j. a 30 , 5 ( 2006 ) .
u. garg , nucl .
phys . a 731 , 3 ( 2004 ) .
h. s. xu et al . , phys .
85 , 716 ( 2000 ) .
m. b. tsang et al . , phys .
86 , 5023 ( 2001 ) .
d. v. shetty et al . , phys .
c 70 , 011601 ( 2004 ) .
m. b. tsang et al . , phys .
92 , 062701 ( 2004 ) .
chen , c. m. ko , and b .- a .
li , phys .
94 , 032701 ( 2005 ) . q. li et al . , phys .
c 72 , 034613 ( 2005 ) .
q. li et al . , phys .
c 73 , 051601 ( 2006 ) .
t. x. liu et al . , phys .
c 76 , 034603 ( 2007 ) .
b .- a . li and l .- w .
chen , phys .
c 72 , 064611 ( 2005 ) .
m. a. famiano et al .
97 , 052701 ( 2006 ) .
b. li , c. ko , and z. ren , phys .
78 , 1644 ( 1997 ) .
b. li , l. w. chen , g. c. yong , and w. zuo , phys .
b 634 , 378 ( 2006 ) .
b. li , phys . rev
85 , 4221 ( 2000 ) .
b. li , nucl .
phys . a 734 , 539c ( 2004 ) .
g. yong , b. li , and l. chen , phys .
c 73 , 034603 ( 2006 ) .
m. b. tsang , y. zhang , p. danielewicz , m. famiano , z. li , w. g. lynch , and a. w. steiner , phys .
102 , 122701 ( 2009 ) .
b. giordano et al .
c 81 , 044611 ( 2010 ) .
p. napolitani et al . , phys . rev .
c. 81 , 044619 ( 2010 ) .
y. zhang and z. li , phys .
c 71 , 024604 ( 2005 ) .
y. zhang , p. danielewicz , m. famiano , z. li , w. g. lynch , and m. b. tsang , phys .
b 664 , 145 ( 2008 ) .
yingxun zhang , d.d.s.coupland , p.danielewicz , et.al . , phys.rev.c85 , 024602(2012 ) .
z. kohley , l.w .
may , s. wuenschel , et.al . ,
phys.rev.c83 , 044601(2011 ) .
bertsch , s. das gupta , phys.rep .
4 , 189(1988 ) .
p.chomaz , m.colonna , j.randrup , phys.rep .
389 , 263 ( 2004 ) .
v. baran et .
al , nucl .
phys . a 703 , 603 ( 2002 ) .
j. aichelin , a. rosenhauer , g. peilert , h. stocker , and w. greiner , phys .
58 , 1926 ( 1987 ) .
y. zhang and z. li , phys . rev .
c 74 , 014602 ( 2006 ) .
y. zhang , z. li , and p. danielewicz , phys .
c 75 , 034615 ( 2007 ) .
a. ono , p. danielewicz , w. a. friedman , w. g. lynch , and m. b. tsang , phys .
c 68 , 051601(r ) ( 2003 ) .
l. w. chen , c. m. ko , b. a. li , phys .
c 72 , 064309 ( 2005 ) .
m. colonna et al . , nucl .
a 642 , 449 ( 1998 ) .
j.aichelin , c.hartnack , a. bohnet , zhuxia li , g.peilert , h.stocker and w. greiner , phys.lett .
b 224 , 34(1989 ) . | within the framework of imqmd05 , we study several isospin sensitive observables , such as dr(n / p ) ratios , isospin transport ratio ( isospin diffusion ) , yield ratios for lcps between the projectile region and mid - rapidity region for the reaction systems ni+ni , zn+zn , sn+sn at low - intermediate energies .
our results show that those observables are sensitive to the density dependence of symmetry energy , and also depend on the cluster formation mechanism . by comparing these calculations to the data ,
the information of the symmetry energy and reaction mechanism is obtained . |
recent advances of micro - sensor fabrication technology allow for producing cheap and small sensor nodes with wireless communication capabilities . consequently , wireless sensor networks ( wsns ) become an economically sound solution to wide range of applications such as environmental and wildlife habitat monitoring , target tracking for defense purposes , and health care @xcite .
typical wsn consists of large number of sensor nodes deployed in an area of interest to collect specific information about the surrounding environment .
the need for large number of sensor nodes in wsns while being cost - effective constraints the industry standards to produce battery - powered sensor nodes with simple hardware . as a result of the limited energy and processing capabilities of sensor nodes ,
the collected information has to be sent to a fusion center ( fc ) for centralized processing .
one important application of wsns is the distributed estimation of scalar parameters ( see , e.g. , @xcite , and references therein ) . in such application ,
sensor nodes transmit their observations over a multiple access channel ( mac ) to the fc .
the received signal is distorted by the channel fading and the additive noise .
the fc is required to reconstruct the source parameter with minimum mean - square error ( mse ) .
depending on the available information about the source statistics , different estimators can be used to achieve the mse criterion .
the performance of the best linear unbiased estimation ( blue ) @xcite , minimum mean squared error ( mmse ) estimator @xcite , and maximum likelihood estimator ( mle ) @xcite are studied in literature .
both orthogonal mac @xcite and coherent mac @xcite are considered in the distributed estimation problem .
assuming gaussian source signal and noise , amplify - and - forward schemes significantly outperform the traditional source - channel coding for both multiple access channels @xcite .
optimal power allocation for sensor nodes under different constraints is addressed in @xcite .
asymptotic behavior of the distortion is also studied in @xcite .
the mse performance for the coherent mac asymptotically approaches to zero as the number of sensors increases to infinity .
however , this is not the case for the orthogonal mac where the mse reaches a finite non - zero value as the number of sensor nodes increases @xcite .
diversity order of estimation distortion is introduced in @xcite and shown to be given by the number of sensors . in most wsn applications ,
the source parameter is a physical quantity like temperature , pressure , humidity , sound , ... etc .
therefore , the sensor node observations are correlated where the correlation coefficient is exponentially decaying with distance . in literature , simple signal models were usually assumed .
for example , unity correlated observations are assumed in @xcite , where sensor nodes measure a noisy version of the source signal .
the correlation between the observations and the source signal ( denoted hereafter as the source - node correlation ) is considered in @xcite .
however , in this model the correlation between observations ( denoted hereafter as the inter - node correlation ) is determined by the source - node correlation as we will show later . considering a correlation model with inter - node correlation that determined by the distance between sensor nodes
is a more realistic assumption @xcite . in this paper , we study the distributed estimation of a scalar parameter where sensor nodes transmit their observations to the fc over a coherent mac . the observations are spatially correlated and corrupted by noise . moreover , the communication channel is subject to fading and additive white gaussian noise ( awgn ) .
the fc uses the received signal to estimate the source parameter using lmmse estimator . the distance - based correlation model of @xcite
is used in this paper to characterize the source - node correlation and the inter - node correlation .
the effect of the distance - based correlation on the estimation performance is demonstrated and compared with the case of unity correlated observations .
the outage probability is adopted as the performance measure .
a new closed - form expression for the outage probability in terms of quadratic forms is introduced .
it is shown that less correlated observations degrade the performance .
hereafter , small letters , bold small letters , and bold capital letters will designate scalars , vectors , and matrices , respectively .
if @xmath0 is a matrix , then @xmath1 , @xmath2 , and @xmath3 denote the hermitian , the transpose , and the eigenvalues of @xmath0 , respectively .
we define @xmath4 to be a diagonal matrix formed from vector @xmath5 .
the function @xmath6 returns the same value for the positive values and zero for the negative values and the function @xmath7 returns the maximum value . ' '' '' @xmath8
consider a wsn consisting of @xmath9 sensor nodes and a fc as shown in fig . 1 .
sensor nodes are required to observe a scalar parameter modeled by a zero - mean complex gaussian random variable @xmath10 .
the signals measured by individual sensor nodes can be described as @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the @xmath13th sensor node observation and @xmath14 is the observation noise .
the signals @xmath15 and @xmath16 , are modeled as zero - mean joint gaussian random variables , i.e. @xmath17 , @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is the source - node correlation coefficient between @xmath15 and @xmath12 .
moreover , sensor node observations @xmath16 , are correlated to each other , i.e. @xmath20 , where @xmath21 is the inter - node correlation coefficient between @xmath12 and @xmath22 .
the correlation coefficients are non - negative and decrease monotonically with distance . using the power exponential model presented in @xcite , @xmath19 and @xmath21 are functions of @xmath23 and @xmath24 , respectively , according to the relation @xmath25 where @xmath23 is the distance between the event source and the @xmath13th node , @xmath24 is distance between sensor @xmath13 and @xmath26 , @xmath27 , and @xmath28 and @xmath29 are the model parameters , where @xmath28 normalizes the distance and @xmath29 controls the correlation decay rate . let us define the matrix @xmath30 as the cross - node correlation matrix with @xmath21 is the element at the @xmath13th row and @xmath26th column . assuming random sensor node locations , @xmath30 will be a full - rank matrix , and therefore this model will be referred to as _ full - rank _ correlation model .
the aforementioned model for the correlation coefficients @xmath31 and @xmath21 is more generalized than the one used in @xcite where the signal is given as @xmath32 , and thus @xmath33 in this case .
this results in _ unity _ correlated source and observations , i.e. @xmath34 and @xmath35 , @xmath36 . also , the signal model used in @xcite is @xmath37 which corresponds to @xmath38 in eq .
( [ eq : observatiomodel ] ) and results in the special case @xmath39 where @xmath40 and @xmath41 .
let us define the vector @xmath42^{t}$ ] , then the cross - node correlation matrix for the later case is given by @xmath43 which is a rank one matrix and thus will be referred to as _ rank - one _ correlation model . in the rest of the paper , we will compare between the three correlation models .
for the amplify - and - forward scheme , the transmitted signal from the @xmath13th sensor node is given by @xmath44 , where @xmath45 is the amplification factor . here
, the transmit power for each node is @xmath46 .
assume that the channel state information ( csi ) is available at the fc .
then , the coherent combining of the transmitted signals received at the fc is @xmath47 where @xmath48 is the communication noise @xmath49 and @xmath50 is the rayleigh fading for the @xmath13th node @xmath51 .
given the signal and channel statistics , the lmmse estimate @xmath52 can be expressed as @xmath53 and the corresponding distortion becomes @xmath54 the normalized distortion @xmath55 is then given by eq .
( [ normdes ] ) ( shown at the bottom of the next page ) .
this expression is the generalization of the equivalent one given in ( * ? ? ?
2 ) for the unity correlated source and observations . the first term in the numerator and the first term of the denominator in eq . ( [ normdes ] )
are the result of the inter - node correlation .
in this section , the special cases of unity correlation and rank - one model are compared to full - rank model . for simplicity ,
the channel fading is neglected , i.e. @xmath56 , and equal power allocation ( epa ) is assumed , i.e. @xmath57 , where @xmath58 is the total transmit power for all sensor nodes .
accordingly , the normalized distortion expression for the full - rank model reduces to @xmath59 considering the signal model in ( * ? ? ?
* eq . 10 ) , which results in the special case @xmath60 ( rank - one model ) , the corresponding normalized distortion is given by @xmath61 finally , for unity correlated source and observations , i.e. @xmath34 and @xmath62 , the normalized distortion expression reduces to @xmath63 which is equivalent to the expression in ( * ? ? ?
* eq . 2 ) . comparing the aforementioned expressions
, it is apparent that @xmath64 and @xmath65 as the number of sensor nodes goes to infinity .
however , @xmath66 does not vanish under the same condition .
the effect of correlation on the distortion when the number of sensor nodes increases is depicted in fig . 2 .
( [ asymptoticd1 ] ) , ( [ asymptoticd2 ] ) , and ( [ asymptoticd3 ] ) are averaged over 1000 random realization of sensor node locations and plotted for increasing @xmath9 . here
, the observation signal - to - noise ratio ( snr ) is defined as @xmath67 = 20 db and the communication snr as @xmath68 = 20 db , where @xmath69 .
the correlation model has @xmath28 = 250 and @xmath29 = 1 .
the total transmit power of all sensor nodes is @xmath58 = 10 db ( normalized to @xmath70 ) .
as expected , the distortion for the unity correlated case tends to zero as @xmath9 increases .
the same behavior is noticed for the rank - one model , however with slightly higher distortion in this case .
conversely , the distortion for full - rank model exhibit a floor behavior at a non - zero distortion ( @xmath71 0.182 ) .
therefore , correlation between observations should be taken into consideration when designing distributed estimation schemes because weak correlation degrades its performance .
the normalized distortion in eq .
( [ normdes ] ) depends on the channel fading , correlation coefficients , channel and measurement noise power , and amplification factors .
given the distance - based correlation model , the correlation coefficients will be invariable for specific network geometry . therefore , with fixed power allocation and noise power ,
the channel fading is the only determining factor for the fluctuation in the estimation distortion . in many applications ,
the interest is to characterize the maximum distortion rather than the average distortion . in such situations ,
the outage probability is used as a performance measure where the outage refers to the event at which a desired performance level can not be satisfied . here
, the outage probability is defined as the probability that the normalized distortion exceeds a certain value @xmath72 , @xmath73 to find a closed - form expression for the outage probability , we first express the distortion in vector form .
let us define the vectors @xmath74^{t}$ ] , @xmath75^{t}$ ] , and @xmath76 and @xmath77 as defined previously .
it follows that @xmath78 , where @xmath79 and @xmath80 .
similarly , @xmath81 , where @xmath82 . also , @xmath83 , where @xmath84 and @xmath85 .
then the normalized distortion can be expressed in terms of indefinite quadratic forms as @xmath86 where @xmath87 and @xmath88 .
accordingly , the outage probability takes the form @xmath89 where @xmath90 . using the results of @xcite
, the outage probability @xmath91 can be expressed as @xmath92 where @xmath93 , are the eigenvalues of the matrix @xmath94 and @xmath95 is the heaviside unit - step function .
this expression can be simplified if @xmath96 is substituted by its component matrices , @xmath97 where the last approximation results from considering that @xmath98 .
recall that the matrix @xmath99 is the outer product of the vector @xmath100 by itself , hence it is of rank one and positive semidefinite .
moreover , @xmath101 is also positive semidefinite matrix .
therefore , @xmath96 has only one non - negative eigenvalue and all other eigenvalues can simply canceled off in ( [ outagepreqn1 ] ) because of the unit - step function .
finally , the expression of outage probability simplifies to @xmath102 where @xmath103 is the only non - negative eigenvalue of @xmath94 . using weyl s inequality @xcite
, this eigenvalue can be lower bounded by @xmath104 where @xmath105 and @xmath106 are the largest eigenvalues of the matrices @xmath99 and @xmath101 , respectively .
the outage probability depends on the eigenvalues of @xmath107 ( exact expression ) or the eigenvalues of @xmath99 and @xmath101 ( lower bound ) .
assume equal power allocation , one has @xmath108 where @xmath109 is the factor reflecting the effect of the correlation on the largest eigenvalue and it depends on the geometry of the wsn . considering that the term @xmath110 is constant for specific network setting
, the factor @xmath111 will be referred to as the normalized eigenvalue .
the outage probability in this case is expressed as @xmath112 clearly , the outage probability is a monotonically decreasing function of @xmath111 and thus related to the signal and observations correlation .
in this section , the analytic results are confirmed by numerical simulations . consider a wsn that consists of @xmath9 = 10 sensor nodes randomly located in a square area with side length of @xmath113 m. it is required to estimate a source parameter located @xmath114 m away from the center of the sensor nodes .
the settings of fig . 2 are assumed for all the following simulations unless otherwise stated .
moreover , the channel fading has variance @xmath115 .
all simulation results are averaged over 1000 independent runs .
3 shows the outage probability vs. the normalized distortion .
the analytic expressions are plotted with solid , dashed , and dotted lines and the simulations are plotted with circle , diamond , and plus marks . the closed - form expression is shown to be in perfect match with the simulation results and the accuracy of the closed - form approximation of the outage probability is verified .
the correlation clearly affects the outage performance where more outage occurs for both distance - based correlation models .
note that for the full - rank model , @xmath116 for @xmath117 with values less than @xmath71 0.182 ( i.e. the distortion is always larger than this value ) which agrees with the results of fig . 2 .
4 compares between the exact expression for the largest eigenvalue ( normalized by @xmath118 ) and its approximation in eq .
( 17 ) for different source locations .
the source distance to the center of the square area is set to 50 m , 30 m , and 0 m. note that @xmath119 is upper bounded by @xmath118 since @xmath120 recall that the outage probability is a monotonically decreasing function of @xmath121 and situations with larger eigenvalue corresponds to a better outage performance ( i.e. lower outage probability ) . from the figure , we conclude that observing farther source reduces the largest eigenvalue and thus increases the outage probability .
in this paper , distributed estimation of a scalar parameter in wsns is considered .
correlated source signal and observations are assumed and the effect of correlation is investigated . a closed - form expression for the outage probability
is derived to link between the correlation and the outage performance .
it is shown that higher distortion levels occurs with higher probability when assuming correlated observations as compared to unity correlated ones .
moreover , the distortion does not vanish when increasing the number of sensor nodes indefinitely for the distance - based correlation .
s. cui , j. j. xiao , a. j. goldsmith , z. q. luo , and h. v. poor , `` estimation diversity and energy efficiency in distributed sensing , '' _ ieee trans .
, _ vol .
55 , no . 9 , pp .
46834695 , sep .
2007 .
x. wang and c. yang .
`` decentralized estimation over orthogonal multiple - access fading channels in wireless sensor networks optimal and suboptimal estimators , '' _ eurasip journal on advances in sig .
proc . , _ vol .
2011 , no . 1 , dec
. 2011 .
i. bahceci and a. khandani , `` linear estimation of correlated data in wireless sensor networks with optimum power allocation and analog modulation , '' _ ieee trans . on commun .
, _ vol . 56 , no . 7 , pp . 11461156 , jul . 2008
. m. h. chaudhary and l. vandendorpe , `` power constrained linear estimation in wireless sensor networks with correlated data and digital modulation , '' _ ieee trans . on sig .
, _ vol .
60 , no . 2 , pp . 570584 ,
m. gastpar and m. vetterli , `` source - channel communication in sensor networks , '' in _ proc .
2nd international conference on information processing in sensor networks ( ipsn03 ) , _ palo alto , ca , usa , pp . 162177 , dec . 2003 .
t. al - murad , m. ghogho , and a. swami , `` effects of fading and spatial correlation on node selection for estimation in wireless sensor networks , '' in _ proc .
ieee eleventh international workshop on sig .
advances in wireless communications ( spawc10 ) _ , marrakech , morocco , jun . 2010 .
a. s. leong , s. dey , g. n. nair , and p. sharma , `` power allocation for outage minimization in state estimation over fading channels , '' _ ieee trans .
, _ vol .
59 , no . 7 , pp . 33823397 , jul . 2011
. t. y. al - naffouri and b. hassibi , `` on the distribution of indefinite quadratic forms in gaussian random variables , '' in _ proc .
ieee international symposium on information theory ( isit09 ) , _ seoul , korea , pp . 17441748 , jul .
rajendra bhatia , _ matrix analysis _ , graduate texts in mathematics , springer - verlag , new york , 1997 . | we address the distributed estimation of an unknown scalar parameter in wireless sensor networks ( wsns ) .
sensor nodes transmit their noisy observations over multiple access channel to a fusion center ( fc ) that reconstructs the source parameter .
the received signal is corrupted by noise and channel fading , so that the fc objective is to minimize the mean - square error ( mse ) of the estimate . in this paper , we assume sensor node observations to be correlated with the source signal and correlated with each other as well
. the correlation coefficient between two observations is exponentially decaying with the distance separation .
the effect of the distance - based correlation on the estimation quality is demonstrated and compared with the case of unity correlated observations .
moreover , a closed - form expression for the outage probability is derived and its dependency on the correlation coefficients is investigated .
numerical simulations are provided to verify our analytic results . |
anais project aims at the study of the annual modulation signal attributed to galactic dark matter particles@xcite using 250 kg nai(tl ) at the canfranc underground laboratory ( lsc ) , in spain .
the dama experiment , at the laboratori nazionali del gran sasso , in italy , reported first evidence of the presence of an annual modulation in the detection rate compatible with that expected for a dark matter signal , just in the region below 6kevee ( electron equivalent energy ) with a high statistical significance@xcite .
this signal was further confirmed by the libra experiment , using 250 kg of more radiopure nai(tl ) detectors@xcite . using the same target than dama / libra experiment makes possible for anais to confirm such a result in a model independent way . to achieve this goal
, anais detectors should be as good ( or better ) as ( than ) those of dama / libra in terms of energy threshold and radioactive background below 10kevee : energy threshold below 2kevee and background at 1 - 2counts / kev / kg / day .
after the operation of several prototypes at the lsc@xcite , the main challenge for anais is the achievement of the required low background level , being contaminations in the bulk of the crystal still dominant in the background .
however , backgrounds at low , medium and high energy are quite well understood , as shown with anais-0 prototype@xcite and some other interesting results , as very slow scintillation in nai(tl)@xcite or an anomalous fast event population attributable to quartz scintillation@xcite have been obtained . in the following ,
we will report on the main results derived from the anais-25 prototypes concerning background level and analysis of the dominant contributions ( section[sec : bck ] ) , light collection efficiency and energy threshold ( section[sec : yield ] ) . before
, we will briefly describe the experimental setup ( section[sec : setup ] ) and , finally , prospects for the building of anais-250 will be revised ( section[sec : prospects ] ) .
the anais-25 set - up consists of two cylindrical 12.5 kg mass nai(tl ) crystals grown by alpha spectra ( as ) @xcite using ultra - pure nai powder ( below 90ppb potassium at 95% c.l . according to hp ge spectrometry results at the lsc ) .
detectors were manufactured by as in their ultra - low background assembly laboratory .
the university of zaragoza ( uz ) group collaborated with as in the detector design , material selection and protocols for cleaning materials and tools .
ofhc copper was used for the encapsulation with two synthetic quartz windows allowing the coupling of the photomultiplier tubes ( pmts ) in a second step at the lsc clean room .
an aluminized mylar window allows to calibrate at low energy both detectors ( see figure [ fig : anais-25module ] ) .
two units of r12669sel2 and two units of r11065sel hamamatsu pmts were coupled to modules anais-25:d0 and d1 , respectively and the detectors were installed at lsc to start immediately the data taking inside a shielding consisting of : 10 cm archaeological lead , 20 cm low activity lead , pvc box tightly closed and continuously flushed with boil - off nitrogen gas , and active plastic scintillator vetoes placed on top of the shielding .
the main goal of the anais-25 set - up was to determine the potassium content of the as crystals . for that , the study of the coincidences between the two modules was used and a result for the @xmath0k activity of [email protected] / kg ( equivalent to [email protected] natural potassium ) was derived @xcite . as is improving the nai powder purification procedures in order to get down to the 20ppb potassium goal .
we show in figures[fig : bkgle ] and [ fig : bkghe ] the background at low and high energy , respectively , for anais-25:d0 module . in the latter ,
only gamma events are shown .
similar background is obtained for anais-25:d1 module , although slightly lower at medium and high energy because of the pmts used in the latter ( ham .
r11065sel model ) , which have better radiopurity .
cosmogenically activated isotopes contribution can be clearly identified in the first months of measurement underground@xcite .
contaminations in the nai crystal bulk , as well as those from pmts and other detector components determined by hpge spectrometry have been included in the simulation using gant4 package and following a similar approach to that presented in@xcite . in particular , in the crystal bulk have been simulated @xmath0k@xmath2i , and the isotopes from the @xmath3u and @xmath4th chains identified as explained below ; in the case of @xmath5pb , it has been assumed that all the contamination required to explain the total alpha rate measured is found in the crystal bulk ( see discussion below ) .
cosmogenic isotopes have not been included in the simulation , whose results are shown in figures [ fig : bkgle ] and [ fig : bkghe ] . pulse shape analysis ( psa ) allows to powerfully discriminate the alpha origin energy depositions in the bulk and , hence , to identify and quantify the presence of different isotopes from the @xmath3u and @xmath4th chains .
anais-25 modules showed a total alpha rate : 3.15mbq / kg , further beyond the radiopurity goals of anais experiment and the corresponding energy spectrum does not show typical features from natural chains .
efforts to understand the origin of the contamination are still ongoing , but some progress in this direction can be reported : the activities of some of the alpha - decaying isotopes of the natural chains present in anais-25 modules have been identified through the @xmath6 and bi - po coincidences and are given in table[tab : chains ] ; it should be noticed the reduced activity in these isotopes compared to the level measured in previous prototype anais-0 .
because of that , it is difficult to explain the alpha rate observed in anais-25 without strongly breaking equilibrium in at least one of the natural chains : the most plausible hypothesis is assuming @xmath5po as responsible of most of the alpha rate observed in anais-25 set - up , not being possible to discard by now neither bulk , nor superficial contamination , nor even a combination of both .
@xmath5po should have entered into the purification / growing / building process through progenitor @xmath7rn , which having a very short lifetime would have very fast decayed , implanting @xmath5pb in the powder or crystal .
our low energy spectrum shows clearly the presence of @xmath5pb decay , being the observed events rate compatible with expectations for a bulk contamination at the level required to explain the whole alpha rate measured ( see figure[fig : bkgle ] ) .
we have confirmed this point by measuring at the lsc a new crystal , 1 kg mass , grown by as and sent without encapsulation to uz .
it was encapsulated and coupled to two pmts at the uz and installed for measuring at the lsc in a reduced shielding near anais-25 , having as only goal the determination of the alpha contamination . in this case ,
secular equilibrium had not yet been reached and a clear increase in the alpha rate compatible with the half - life of @xmath5po can be observed in figure[fig : alpharate ] . having the timing information of the procedures followed , mainly purification , handling , and growing , the origin of the contamination can be traced back . as has modified , according to this information , its procedures to reduce the @xmath5pb content in the next crystals produced .
total light collected per unit of energy deposited in the nai(tl ) crystal has been calculated with the mean pulse area which corresponds to 22.6kev events from a @xmath8cd source and the mean pulse area of single photoelectrons , identified in pulses with a few number of them and averaged to build the single electron response ( s.e.r . ) .
corresponding efficiencies derived for anais-0 prototype , similar in shape to dama / libra crystals , using the same pmts than anais-25 modules , are also shown in table[tab : yield ] for comparison . a remarkable improvement in light collection efficiency in the as modules can be reported , pointing at the possibility of further reduction of the anais threshold , demonstrated to be at 2kevee level in the anais-0 prototype@xcite .
while crystal radiopurity goal is being achieved , the rest of experimental requirements for anais experiment have been or are being tested at lsc . summarizing the present status : * light collection efficiency features and other related parameters of the anais-25 modules have proven to be excellent ( see previous section ) : remarkable optical quality of the crystals plus high efficient hamamatsu pmts contribute to this point .
* very strong tools to discriminate scintillation events steming from the nai(tl ) bulk crystal from other kind of spurious events , having mainly the origin in the pmts , have been developed .
these two features make us confident to lower anais threshold beyond the 2kevee already achieved with previous prototypes , because total light collection efficiency more than doubled ( see table[tab : yield ] ) . at the same time , the improved energy resolution observed at very low energy in anais-25 modules helps to reduce the possible interference of the @xmath0k contribution in the dark matter analysis . *
the lsc experimental space for anais is ready for the mounting : shielding materials are stored underground ; 40 units of the hamamatsu pmt model chosen for anais have been ordered , and 15 units have been already screened for radiopurity at the lsc hp ge test bench ; plastic scintillators vetoes are being tested ; and electronic chain and acquisition software have been fully commissioned and tested with the two modules set - up anais-25 . * a successful background model has been developed for anais-0 prototype@xcite and is being applied to anais-25 ( some of the preliminary results have been shown in section[sec : bck ] ) . * a full simulation of anais-250 set - up consisting of 20 modules 12.5 kg mass each , cylindrical in shape , and installed in a 4x5 configuration , is ongoing ( see figure[fig : anais250 ] ) .
one of the first results under analysis is the capability of rejecting @xmath0k events as a function of different experimental parameters : copper encapsulation thickness , modules separation , modules total size , number of modules , etc .
this work has been supported by the spanish ministerio de economa y competitividad and the european regional development fund ( mineco - feder ) ( fpa2011 - 23749 ) , the consolider - ingenio 2010 programme under grants multidark csd2009- 00064 and cpan csd2007 - 00042 , and the gobierno de aragn ( group in nuclear and astroparticle physics , araid foundation and c. cuesta predoctoral grant ) .
p.villar is supported by the mineco subprograma de formacin de personal investigador .
we also acknowledge lsc and gifna staff for their support .
k. freese , _ et al .
mod . phys . * 85 * , 1561 ( 2013 ) .
r. bernabei , _ et al .
nuovo cim . a * 112 * , 545 ( 1999 ) .
+ r. bernabei , _ et al .
b * 450 * , 448 ( 1999 ) .
r. bernabei , _ et al .
inst . meth .
a * 592 * , 297 ( 2008 ) .
+ r. bernabei , _ et al .
_ , eur . phys .
j. c * 56 * , 333 ( 2008 ) .
+ r. bernabei , _ et al .
j. c * 67 * , 39 ( 2010 ) .
+ r. bernabei , _ et al .
a * 692 * , 120 ( 2012 ) .
+ r. bernabei , _ et al .
j. c * 73 * , 2648 ( 2013 ) .
j. amar , _ et al .
_ , j. phys .
ser . * 375 * 012026 ( 2012 ) .
s. cebrin , _ et al .
_ , astrop . phys . * 37 * , 60 ( 2012 ) .
j. amar , _ et al .
. instr . & meth .
a * 742 * , 187 ( 2014 ) , arxiv:1308:3478 . c. cuesta , _ et al . _ , opt . mat . * 36 * , 316 ( 2013 ) .
j. amar , _ et al .
_ , accepted for publication in optical materials arxiv:1401.3118v2 .
alpha spectra inc .
, grand junction , colorado , us .
http://www.alphaspectra.com/ c. cuesta , _ et al .
_ , accepted for publication in int .
phys . a , arxiv:1403.3580 . c. cuesta , _ et al .
_ , in preparation . | the anais ( annual modulation with nai(tl ) scintillators ) experiment aims at the confirmation of the dama / libra signal using the same target and technique at the canfranc underground laboratory ( lsc ) .
250 kg of ultra pure nai(tl ) crystals will be used as target , divided into 20 modules , 12.5 kg mass each , and coupled to two high efficiency photomultiplier tubes from hamamatsu .
the anais-25 set - up at the lsc consists of two prototypes , amounting 25 kg nai(tl ) , grown from a powder having a potassium level under the limit of our analytical techniques , and installed in a convenient shielding at the lsc .
the background has been carefully analyzed and main results will be summarized in this paper , focusing on the alpha contamination identified in the prototypes and the related background contributions .
status of fulfillment of anais experimental goals and prospects for the building of anais-250 experiment will be also revised .
dark matter search , sodium iodide , annual modulation , scintillation 29.40.mc , 29.40.wk , 95.35.+d |
in order to develop and maintain tissues , cells in multicellular organisms have to interact with each other and the extracellular matrix ( ecm ) . cellular communication proceeds mainly through specific interactions provided by receptor - ligand binding . in solution , gradients in ligand concentration encode spatial information .
for example , morphogen gradients guide cell differentiation @xcite , and gradients of chemoattractants or chemorepellants direct cell motility ( _ chemotaxis _ ) @xcite . for cells adhering to each other or to the ecm
, physical properties of the environment like topography and mechanics provide additional information supplementing specific biochemical cues .
in particular , cells in their natural environment typically orient along fiber bundles of the ecm , a principle termed _ contact guidance _ @xcite . in general , cells preferentially orient along directions with minimal curvature @xcite .
while contact guidance provides only a bidirectional cue for cell migration , unidirectional cues result from spatial gradients in adhesiveness ( _ haptotaxis _ ) @xcite , substrate rigidity ( _ durotaxis _ ) @xcite and substrate tension ( _ tensotaxis _ ) @xcite .
tissue cells like fibroblasts in the connective tissue constantly remodel their structural environment by degrading old and secreting new ecm .
moreover they can exert forces large enough to actively reorganize the ecm after it has been laid down @xcite .
hence , cells not only respond to the physical properties of their environment , but also actively modulate them .
this results in indirect , matrix - mediated interactions between cells . in particular
, cell traction - induced reorganization of collagen fibers can mediate a mechanical interaction between cells via contact guidance @xcite . in the same vein
, elastic interactions between cells can result from stress and strain in the ecm induced by cell traction . during recent years
, the sophisticated use of elastic substrates has proven that cells indeed respond to purely elastic features in their environment , including rigidity , rigidity gradients and prestrain @xcite .
it now appears that many cell types , including fibroblasts , smooth muscle cells , and endothelial cells ( but not neutrophils or neurons ) , respond to the mechanical properties of their environment with a common preference for large effective stiffness @xcite . here
the term _ effective stiffness _ comprises both rigidity of and tensile strain in the environment , which can be actively sensed by cells via mechanotransductory processes at cell - matrix adhesions @xcite .
these mechanical cues play an important role in a variety of physiological processes , including development , tissue maintenance , angiogenesis , myotube fusion , wound healing and metastasis @xcite .
in particular , if coupled to cell division , stress and strain become major determinants of tissue morphogenesis @xcite . in general ,
tissue function arises from the close relationship between cell behaviour in and material properties of the ecm @xcite .
we have argued before that elastic interactions contribute to the way single cells position and orient themselves in compliant environments @xcite .
however , it has not been discussed in detail before how this individual behaviour translates into collective behaviour of cell ensembles in compliant environments . in a recent short report
we have shown that elastically interacting cells assemble into strings of cells which then leads to screening of the cellular traction patterns @xcite .
although this effect in principle suppresses macroscopic order , we have also found that macroscopic order can exist at high cell density , with an interesting competition between string- and ring - like structures as a function of the poisson ratio of the surrounding material . in our recent report
, this effect has been especially analyzed for ordered ( lattice ) arrangements of cells , which can be decomposed into strings .
since cellular systems are intrinsically noisy , in this paper we focus on stochastic effects using extensive monte carlo simulations , which allow to predict collective effects in the presence of noise . in the following ,
we mainly consider the case of cells adhering to the top of a soft elastic substrate , because this setup might be the easiest way to experimentally verify our theoretical predictions .
commonly used materials for elastic substrates are polyacrylamide or polydimethylsiloxane , which can be described by linear isotropic elasticity theory .
since we are interested in the interactions mediated by an elastic environment , we only consider situations without cell - cell contact , which experimentally could trigger different cellular responses to mechanical signals .
therefore in our theoretical work we first fix cell positions and then relax cellular orientations using standard monte carlo techniques .
experimentally , this might be done by using microcontact printing , thus restricting cells to adhesive islands , or by using non - motile cell lines , which adhere at random positions and then do not move . by freezing in cell positions , we are also able to control cell density . for the position geometry , we consider ordered ( lattice ) arrangements , random perturbations around ordered positions and arrangements which are completely random .
we calculate structural phase diagrams as a function of of elastic moduli , cell density , noise and cell position geometry using monte carlo simulations .
we then briefly investigate collective elastic effects in three dimensional elastic environments and finally discuss our results in the context of wound healing .
in order to sense the mechanical properties of their environment , tissue cells pull on it with actomyosin contractility . in many cases ,
this contractile mechanical activity is directed along the long axis of the cell body , especially when confronted with a mechanically anisotropic environment .
the mechanical action of such an anisotropic force pattern can be modeled as an anisotropic force contraction dipole @xmath0 , where the unit vector @xmath1 specifies cell orientation .
in contrast to electric dipoles in electrostatics , which are vectors , force dipoles in elasticity theory are tensors of rank two .
@xmath2 specifies the dipole strength , which typically has @xmath3 j , corresponding to two opposing forces @xmath4 nn separated by a distance @xmath5 @xmath6 m @xcite .
we will consider cells with anisotropic force patterns only and assume that the magnitude @xmath2 is constant for all cells .
a mechanically active cell generates an elastic strain field @xmath7 , which again is a tensor of rank two .
the strain induced by @xmath2 can be calculated from the elastic green tensor @xmath8 which describes the deformation of the medium at @xmath9 caused by a point force at @xmath10 . in general
@xmath11 depends on material properties and boundary conditions . for translationally invariant situations , one has @xmath12 .
elastic interactions between two cells result if the mechanical activity @xmath13 of one cell responds to the elastic field @xmath14 induced by another cell . in the framework of a general field theory elastic interaction
can then be represented by a coupling of @xmath14 and @xmath13 .
since cells are active and moreover often show a regulated response , the exact form of the coupling between @xmath13 and @xmath14 can not be predicted from first principles . in a first order approximation
we may assume that @xmath13 and @xmath14 are linearly coupled .
for mechanically active cells like fibroblasts , experimental observations suggest that indeed they adopt positions and orientations in such a way as to effectively minimize the scalar quantity @xmath15 @xcite . for tensile strain , this implies that contractile cells actively align with the external field . because they pull against the external stretch , cells reduce displacement . for fibroblast - like cells ,
this behaviour might have evolved in the context of wound healing , when cell traction is required to close wounds .
a biophysical interpretation of the origin of the extremum principle regarding @xmath16 is to note that @xmath16 has dimensions of energy .
physically @xmath16 can be interpreted as an extra energy contribution to the deformation energy required to build up a force dipole in the presence of strain @xmath14 @xcite . using the analogy of a harmonic spring
the basic idea can be explained easily : for a given spring constant @xmath17 , it takes the work @xmath18 to build up the force @xmath19
. therefore larger stiffness @xmath17 corresponds to smaller work @xmath16 required to reach the force @xmath19 . in this way
@xmath16 may be interpreted as the inverse of an effective stiffness of the environment and the extremum principle in @xmath16 corresponds to the experimental observation that cell - matrix contacts grow stronger in a stiff environment , thus eventually determining cell orientation . using this extremum principle ,
we have been able before to unify many diverse observations which have been reported for the organization of single cells on elastic substrates and in physiological hydrogels @xcite .
for example , it predicts that single cells prefer to align in parallel and perpendicular to free and clamped surfaces of finite sized samples , respectively .
it is however important to note that the cellular response to the actively sensed effective stiffness of the environment is very different from the cellular response to cyclic external stretch with a 1 hz frequency , which is relevant for the physiology of lung tissue and the cardiovascular system . in this case , many cell types tend to orient away from the direction of stretch @xcite , possibly to avoid the recurrent deformation of their cytoskeleton . for two cells , the above reasoning leads to the following effective interaction potential @xcite @xmath20 where we consider only situations with translational invariance .
the optimal cell configuration is described by the minimum of @xmath16 in regard to cell positioning and orientation . since in general @xmath21 scales as @xmath22 , where @xmath23 is distance and
@xmath24 an elastic modulus , @xmath16 scales as @xmath25 and has units of energy . since in a linear material
the cellular strain fields superimpose , the functional that describes elastic interactions of a system of @xmath26 cells reads : @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the interaction between two cells @xmath29 and @xmath30 as described in .
the factor @xmath31 is required to avoid double counting and the factor @xmath32 for _ per cell _ normalization .
the optimal structure is given by the configuration which minimizes as a function of all cellular orientations and positions and we may refer to this structure as the _ ground state _ , in analogy to interacting passive particles in physical systems . in the presence of noise any system will deviate from its optimal state . in the cellular systems discussed here , noise results both from intracellular processes ( like the intrinsic stochasticity of gene expression and signal transduction ) and from heterogeneities in the material properties of the environment . in order to introduce a stochastic element into the structure formation process
, we perform monte carlo simulations using the standard metropolis algorithm to generate typical configurations in the presence of noise @xcite .
this implies the use of an gibbs ensemble , which in our case is the simplest choice given that we do not know the exact details of the cellular decision making process ( in information theory , the gibbs ensemble arises from maximizing the measure for disorder ( _ shannon entropy _ ) under the constraint of a prescribed average energy ) .
starting from an arbitrary configuration , a cell is selected at random and its orientation randomly varied .
the new configuration is always accepted when it decreases @xmath16 .
otherwise it is accepted with the probability @xmath33 , where @xmath34 is the boltzmann constant and @xmath35 is temperature . in our context
@xmath36 represents a measure for the degree of stochasticity involved in cellular decision making .
other studies on modelling cellular structure formation have used the same concept before and found an effective value of @xmath37 j @xcite . since this quantity comprises all molecular interactions between a cell and its environment , it is six orders of magnitudes larger than thermal energy . in our case
, the competition between elastic and stochastic effects can be characterized by the reduced temperature @xmath38 which measures the relative importance of noise with respect to the average elastic interaction strength . here
@xmath39 is the average distance between two cells which is related to the averaged cell density by @xmath40 in two dimensions ( 2d ) and by @xmath41 in three dimensions ( 3d ) .
as we will see below , typical values in our simulations range from @xmath42 to @xmath43 . using @xmath44 j , @xmath45 kpa , @xmath46 m and a typical value @xmath47
, we obtain @xmath48 j. therefore our choice for the noise level is exactly in the same range as the earlier estimates @xcite . as the effective temperature is decreased towards cero , @xmath49 , @xmath16 decreases and the ground states become increasingly favorable .
this process is known as _ simulated annealing _ and is often used to identify optimal structures @xcite . in the vicinity of an optimal structure , almost all monte carlo moves are rejected .
in contrast , when @xmath50 , every monte carlo move is accepted and the structures get disordered .
one monte carlo sweep corresponds to @xmath26 such monte carlo moves .
after thermal equilibration ( typically about @xmath51 monte carlo sweeps ) , the metropolis algorithm samples the important configurations typical for a given temperature @xmath52 .
one can then calculate statistical properties of structures at defined noise level by averaging the quantity of interest over many configurations generated by the metropolis algorithm . to study stochastic effects using our monte carlo simulations we typically consider @xmath53 dipoles .
in order to minimize the effects of boundaries and finite size , we apply periodic boundary conditions ( pbcs ) , such that each dipole has the same number of next neighbors and experiences the same local geometry .
we implement pbcs using the minimal image convention , i.e. we only consider the interactions of the dipole with its @xmath54 nearest ( image ) dipoles @xcite .
note that in the two - dimensional situation of cells on top of an elastic half space , the @xmath55 interaction effectively constitutes a _ short - ranged _ potential , because its area integral does not diverge with system size ( @xmath56 where @xmath57 is system size ) .
thus , boundary effects are expected to play only a minor role in this case and the minimal image convention is a good approximation .
we now make some additional assumptions which will simplify our subsequent calculations and which will allow for a direct comparison of our theoretical calculations with appropriate experiments .
first , we assume that the environment can be described by isotropic linear elasticity theory , which is a reasonable assumption for the synthetic substrates like the ones made from polyacrylamide or polydimethylsiloxane commonly used to study mechanical effects in cell culture @xcite .
thus there are two elastic constants : the young modulus @xmath24 describes the rigidity of the material and the poisson ratio @xmath58 the relative importance of compression and shear .
in particular we mainly consider the situation of cells adhering to the top surface of a thick elastic film .
such a situation can be theoretically represented by an elastic half - space geometry with dipolar orientations constrained to the x - y - plane .
therefore the young modulus @xmath24 and the poisson ratio @xmath58 are 3d quantities .
the maximal value for @xmath58 is @xmath31 , e.g. for strongly hydrated polymer gels .
if such a material is tensed in one direction , the shear mode is excited and it contracts in the perpendicular directions ( _ poisson effect _ ) . for common materials ,
the minimal value for the poisson ratio is @xmath59 , e.g. in dehydrated fibrous polymer gels .
then the volume mode prevails and uniaxial tension does not translate into lateral contraction . for cells exerting tangential forces on top of an elastic substrate one can use the boussinesq green function of an elastic halfspace @xcite to specify to @xcite : @xmath60 where @xmath23 is the distance between cells and the cellular orientations @xmath61 , @xmath62 and @xmath63
are defined via the scalar products @xmath64 , @xmath65 and @xmath66 .
@xmath67 is given by @xmath68 where @xmath69 and @xmath70 .
secondly , because here we focus on elastic effects , we want to avoid cell - cell contacts , which are known to change the mechanical state of adhering cells @xcite .
therefore we attribute an exclusion disc of radius @xmath71 to each cell .
moreover in most of our simulations cell positions are frozen and only orientational degrees of freedom are considered .
experimentally , this situation might be achieved by using non - motile cell lines or appropriate drugs to suppress cell motility .
alternatively , one might use microcontact printing to prepare well - defined adhesive islands constraining cell positions .
finally , while the focus of our paper is on structure formation on planar synthetic substrates to allow a direct comparison of theory and experiment , we also briefly consider cells in a three - dimensional ( 3d ) environment .
for computational simplicity we keep the assumption of linear isotropic . for cells embedded in an infinite 3d isotropic elastic environment
, the interaction law stays the same as , but with different constants @xmath72 and @xmath73 which now follow from the kelvin solution for the full elastic space @xcite . in 3d ,
the elastic interactions are truly long - ranged , in the sense that now the volume integral over the elastic interaction diverges with system size ( @xmath74 where @xmath57 is system size ) , thus boundary effects become more important .
we first consider structure formation in the presence of noise when cells adopt regular positions on an infinite square ( s ) and hexagonal ( h ) lattice . in general
we find a strong dependence of structure formation on lattice geometry , poisson ratio @xmath58 and noise level @xmath52 .
in particular our simulations show an interesting competition between _ string - like _ and _ ring - like _ structures at low noise levels , which we have also found before in a detailed analysis of optimal structures @xcite . for the square lattice low noise structures
are always string - like .
the lattice geometry favors the formation of strings directed along one of the principal lattice vectors @xmath75 or @xmath76 for all @xmath58 .
the limit @xmath77 shows structural degeneracy , that is , additional structures , e.g. parallel strings aligned along @xmath78 , become equally favored as parallel ( 1,0)-string structure .
enhanced structural degeneracy of string - like structures in the limit of vanishing poisson ratio occurs also on the hexagonal lattice .
most interestingly , however , on the hexagonal lattice string- and ring - like structures exchange stability as a function of poisson ratio . for @xmath79
the poisson effect favors ring - like structures over strings , with rings composed of four dipoles each rotated by 90 degrees relatively to its neighbor . on both lattice types the orientational order imposed by elastic interactions
is gradually destroyed with increasing noise levels .
when elastic interactions dominate , dipoles typically fluctuate weakly around their optimal orientations forming long - ranged ordered structures . at intermediate noise levels ,
long - ranged order is decreased , but there are still ordered domains which locally adjust to elastic signals . as noise increased further ,
domain size decreases and local fluctuations become stronger , eventually giving eventually rise to completely random dipole arrangements .
the loss of long - ranged order with increased noise can be quantified by calculating the temperature behavior of appropriate order parameters . for string - like structures
all dipoles point along a common direction @xmath80 .
a suitable parameter to quantify the degree of global alignment therefore seems to be the angle @xmath81 between dipole orientation @xmath1 and @xmath80 , where @xmath82 .
note that force dipoles have a bipolar symmetry and thus dipole orientations @xmath1 and @xmath83 are equivalent .
thus , the average @xmath84 .
however , the average @xmath85 becomes one when all dipoles point along @xmath80 , while for an isotropic structure @xmath86 .
thus , we define an alignment order parameter @xmath87 as @xmath88 which is non - zero only for globally aligned structures and zero otherwise . from our monte carlo simulations
we compute @xmath87 as a function of @xmath52 and poisson ratio for both lattice types .
as shown in a , on the square lattice a globally aligned structure @xmath89 always develops regardless of poisson ratio when the noise level becomes sufficiently low .
the transition temperature @xmath90 from a state without into a state with long - ranged orientation correlations , i.e. where @xmath91 for the first time , decreases approximately linearly with @xmath58 .
this might be attributed to the general enhancement of elastic interactions with increasing poisson ratio @xmath92 . in b
we show how the probability distribution to find a dipole with a given orientation @xmath81 evolves with increasing noise levels . at low @xmath52
almost all dipoles point along @xmath93 and the orientation distribution is strongly peaked ; with increasing @xmath52 the distribution broadens and finally for @xmath94 all orientations are - on a global scale - equally likely ( circle ) .
in contrast to the square lattice , where long - ranged order always implies alignment , the type of long - ranged order developed on a hexagonal lattice depends on poisson ratio .
c shows that an aligned structure develops only for @xmath95 .
interestingly , in this case the relation between the transition temperature @xmath90 and poisson ratio is also reversed compared to the square lattice : @xmath90 stays roughly constant for @xmath96 and then drops quickly around @xmath97 .
moreover , towards @xmath98 the transition seems to become more discontinuous and in our simulations @xmath87 suddenly jumps from a low to a large value , indicating bistability and a first order phase transition .
the @xmath90 scaling with @xmath58 might be explained by simultaneous overall decrease in elastic signal strength with decreasing @xmath58 within strings compensated by an increase in lateral string - string coupling favoring global alignment at small @xmath58 . for larger poisson ratio ( @xmath99 )
we find @xmath100 at all temperatures . at low @xmath101 a macroscopic isotropic long - ranged ring - like order exists build up by small rings composed of four dipoles oriented at 90 degrees with respect to each other .
that is , at @xmath102 there are two equally large subpopulations of dipoles oriented at 90 degrees with respect to each other .
this corresponds to the two peaks in the radial orientation distribution shown in d @xmath103 . for @xmath104 the transition temperature into the ordered ring - like structure @xmath90
is slightly larger than @xmath105 and significantly lower than @xmath106 observed for the string structures on the square lattice at equal dipole densities . in [ fig : ordered_square ] and [ fig : ordered_hex ] we summarize our results for ordered structures in the form of @xmath107 phase diagrams for square and hexagonal lattices , respectively .
we have included representative snapshots of typical dipole configurations at noise levels well below @xmath90 in the globally ordered state , approximately at the phase transition @xmath90 and well above @xmath90 in the disordered phase for @xmath108 and @xmath104 , respectively .
it is important to note that despite the loss of _ global _ order at elevated noise levels @xmath109 , elastic interactions still _ locally _ manifest themselves in characteristic domain formation .
for example , at @xmath110 elastic interactions still cause local order on a square lattice and one finds short string - like domains preferentially oriented along the principal lattice vectors . on incompressible substrates ( @xmath111 )
we furthermore often observe cooperative excitations and the formation of ring - like domains .
this may reflect the competition between ring- and string - like domains which is modulated by the poisson ratio .
in fact , as we have shown before , at @xmath104 ring - like structures are only slightly disfavoured with respect to the string - like structures @xcite . nevertheless , it may seem surprising that ring - like domains are excited so easily already at very low @xmath52 even before coexistence of the equally favorable ( 1,0 ) and ( 0,1 ) domains occurs ( see snapshot at @xmath112 ) .
the reason is probably a large domain interface penalty for two ( 1,0 ) and ( 0,1 ) string domains compared to the interface penalty of a string and an adjacent ring - domain . for the hexagonal lattice local structural characteristics of elastic interactions under noise are again string - like domains preferentially oriented along directions specified by lattice geometry . for large @xmath58 ,
a characteristic signature for elastic interactions is the formation of 4-cell - ring or ladder - domains with cells having approximately perpendicular orientations with respect to each other .
thus , although experimentally noise might be too strong to allow for global ordering , elastic interactions might be still detected by their local signatures of characteristic domain formation .
experimentally cells may not adopt perfect lattice positions , in particular when adhesive islands are used which are large compared to cell size in order to minimize the effects of island shape on cellular force distribution @xcite .
we therefore investigate the effect of positional fluctuations at low thermal noise intensities . for this purpose
we randomly displace the dipole positions within a circle of radius @xmath23 around the lattice positions before relaxing the orientations .
the degree of positional disorder can be quantified by the ratio @xmath113 of the radius with respect to the lattice constant @xmath39 . in the following we focus on the square lattice and @xmath104 , since synthetic polymer gels typically have @xmath114 . for this value of the poisson ratio ,
predicts a lattice geometry dependent transition from a string - like structure on a square lattice to a ring - like structure on the hexagonal lattice .
however , rings are thermally excited easily on the square lattice .
hence the string - like structure might also be easily destabilized under positional disorder . in
we show monte carlo snapshots at a low reduced temperature ( @xmath115 ) for @xmath116 .
the simulations show that a 10@xmath117 deviation from the lattice positions has only a minor effect on orientational ordering . for @xmath118 , string - like as well as ring - like domains form and long - ranged orientational
order disappears . as for thermal noise
, ring - domains typically localize to interfaces between string - like domains with perpendicular orientations . with increasing @xmath67 domains shrink and structures appear increasingly disordered
. thus , moderate deviations from the square lattice positions are not sufficient to destabilize string - like structures with respect to ring - like structures on incompressible substrates . possibly because under uniform positional noise dipoles still find themselves in a local fourfold coordination with other dipoles ( that is , each dipole has typically for next neighbors as on the square lattice ) , string domains are stabilized .
we conclude that positional disorder affects structure formation in a similar way as increasing the temperature @xmath52 on a perfect lattice . on a homogeneous substrate ,
non - motile cells usually adhere more or less at random positions .
therefore we next study typical structures on elastic substrates with completely randomized but fixed positions as described above .
cellular structure formation on elastic substrates is now governed mainly by three control parameters , namely reduced temperature @xmath52 , poisson ratio @xmath58 and cell density . since in our model each cell is characterized by an exclusion radius @xmath71 , we introduce a reduced density @xmath119 which is a dimensionless variable describing the ratio of the area occupied by @xmath26 circular disks of radius @xmath71 to the area of the ( simulation ) box with length @xmath57 .
shows typical snapshots of structures at @xmath115 for cells on an elastic substrate with @xmath120 ( top bottom ) for @xmath121 ( left right ) . at low densities cells
predominantly optimize locally the interaction between them by forming short strings with no long - range correlation between string - like clusters .
we attribute this finding to the strong tendency of dipoles to form strings and the strong elastic screening of string - string interactions @xcite .
this results in rather robust pattern formation that does not differ qualitatively as the poisson ratio is varied , see a. one expects that these patterns represent typical cellular structures formed by strongly interacting cells when cells in dilute concentrations are suspended on an elastic substrate and adhere at random positions ( @xmath122 ) .
with increasing @xmath123 the respective structures at low noise intensity show a strong dependence on the poisson ratio @xmath58 . for incompressible substrates ( @xmath111 )
we find isotropic ring - like structures , see ( ivc ) . with decreasing poisson ratio
string - like patterns emerge . for @xmath124
we find coexistence of string - like and ring - like domains , compare ( iiic ) . for substrates with poisson ratio below @xmath125 string - like structures dominate at intermediate densities . with increasing density strings
start to interact and domains of aligned parallel strings form which increase in size with increasing @xmath123 , see ( iib , iic ) .
highly compressible substrates ( @xmath126 ) favor cell alignment along a common direction at high cell densities and in ( ic ) we find a globally aligned structure . here
, the rotational symmetry of the structure is spontaneously broken along an arbitrary direction in space despite lacking long - ranged positional order . in this respect
we may speak of a nematic structure in analogy to nematic phases formed by liquid crystals which are characterized by orientational order but positional disorder . as before one can quantify the development of anisosotropic long - ranged order with the order parameter @xmath87 defined in . in contrast to the lattice structures where preferred string direction @xmath80 was determined by lattice geometry , the orientation of the director @xmath80 on homogeneous substrates is arbitrary .
this is taken into account by defining a two - dimensional analog of the nematic order parameter @xmath87 used in the theory of liquid crystals @xcite .
we first introduce the ordering matrix @xmath127 , where @xmath128 is the orientation vector of the @xmath63th particle and the sum runs over all particles in the simulation box .
the largest eigenvalue @xmath129 of the symmetric ordering matrix @xmath130 corresponds then to the order parameter @xmath131 . as before @xmath87 measures the degree of orientational order with respect to the current director @xmath80 , which is the corresponding eigenvector to the maximal eigenvalue .
@xmath132 implies nematic and @xmath100 isotropic structures .
since we freeze in positions , we first thermally average @xmath87 for a fixed configuration of the dipole positions and subsequently average over at least 20 random position configurations obtained for the same @xmath123 . in
we show the quantitative effects of the reduced density @xmath123 , poisson ratio @xmath58 and reduced temperature @xmath52 on nematic ordering . at constant temperature @xmath115
a nematic structure forms beyond a critical density @xmath133 and below a critical value of the poisson ratio , see a. the degree of structural alignment increases with increasing @xmath123 and approaches @xmath134 toward the maximal @xmath135 , which is the maximal packing density achieved for disks arranged on a hexagonal lattice . for @xmath99
no nematic ordering @xmath100 occurs at any density @xmath123 or temperature @xmath52 , because ordered structures are ring - like .
in addition to the density - dependent ordering transition , the nematic structure is also destabilized by increased noise . in b
we plot @xmath87 for @xmath136 at different values of the reduced temperature @xmath52 .
the critical density @xmath137 to obtain a nematic structure increases with @xmath52 and @xmath138 for any any @xmath123 when @xmath52 exceeds a critical @xmath139 , which corresponds approximately to @xmath90 measured on the hexagonal lattice . in c
we show the phase diagram in the @xmath58-@xmath123-plane for @xmath115 .
diamonds mark @xmath140 , squares @xmath141 and the dashed line denotes our estimate for the isoline @xmath142 .
we find three different phases : a high - density anisotropic string - like structure , a high - density isotropic ring - like structure and a low density disordered structure .
the general features of this phase diagram are very similar to the thermal phase diagram for hexagonal lattices shown in but with the role of @xmath52 and ( inverse ) density @xmath123 exchanged .
note , that at @xmath135 dipoles in fact adopt hexagonal lattice positions , because disks must order into a hexagonal lattice due to the non - overlap constraint .
thus , reducing the density from @xmath135 in our model is in some sense equivalent to introducing position fluctuations around hexagonal lattice positions ( see above ) , which qualitatively has similar consequences as raising the effective temperature .
these results also show the importance of local position geometry and dipole coordination . at high @xmath123 dipoles have six next neighbors and all interactions are equal in magnitude . because elastic interactions are strongly anisotropic and dependent on poisson ratio , non - trivial structure formation as a function of local dipole coordination and poisson ratio results .
decreasing @xmath123 the number of next neighbors decreases and at low @xmath123 dipoles typically only have one or two next neighbors , which favors dipole alignment and string formation . due to screening of the traction patterns in a string , adjacent strings hardly interact and we obtain a largely disordered structure even at low @xmath52 . in our calculations the degree of position correlation is controlled by @xmath123 , which therefore plays a similar role as lattice geometry before .
in contrast to relative density effects described by @xmath123 , absolute density effects can be subsumed into the effective temperature @xmath52 , see .
this is due to the fact that by _ increasing _ cell density the screening efficiency of string - string interactions also _ increases_. the only way to overcome screening and introduce lateral coupling between dipoles is to insure that dipole - dipole distances within a string and the distance to an adjacent string are comparable . increased dipole coordination , however , is controlled by @xmath123 rather than by @xmath143 .
we note that the order - disorder transition with @xmath123 might also represent a _
spin - glass transition_. such transitions are common for magnets , where spins represent magnetic moments . in magnets global ordering of spins can result in a ferromagnetic state , where all spins point along a common direction and a macroscopic magnetic field builds up .
anti - ferromagnetic order results when spins are globally ordered but with equal numbers of up and down spins , such that no macroscopic polarization builds up .
a spin - glass transition occurs when e.g. due to disordered positions of spins no ferro- or anti - ferromagnetic order develops even at low temperatures . in analogy ,
dipoles in our model represent spins .
the aligned structure therefore might be called a _ ferroelastic phase _ , because a macroscopically anisotropic polarization stress develops spontaneously . in analogy
, the ring - like structure might be called an _ antiferroelastic phase _ , because the macroscopic stress exerted by the dipoles remains isotropic . when @xmath144 , no global order develops even in the limit @xmath145 ; instead
, many equally favorable states exist . because we do not allow dipoles to adjust positions
, they can not relax into an ordered ferro- or anti - ferroelastic state .
thus , the disordered low temperature phase might also represent a spin glass .
there is an interesting difference between thermally disordered states and density disordered states at low t. in both cases , dipoles can be aligned by application of an external field .
the former might be called a _ paraelastic phase _ because it relaxes into the unpolarized disordered state after the external field is switched off with a single time - scale @xmath146 .
in contrast , the later might represent a spin - glass state and relaxation into the disordered state can not be described by a single power law .
in fact a characteristic feature of spin glasses is a fast relaxation to a remanent polarization and then a slow relaxation into the unpolarized state , which may exceed experimental timescales .
although cell behaviour in 3d is not the focus of this paper , we now spell out a few predictions resulting from our model in this case .
calculations for cells positioned on a simple cubic lattice suggest that in incompressible environments ( @xmath147 ) the optimal structure is effectively isotropic with a hedgehog - like unit cell , where all dipoles at the corners point to the cube s center , see a , while for @xmath136 spontaneous symmetry breaking along a principal lattice lattice vector occurs , see b. this indicates that similar transitions between ring - like and string - like structures as a function of poisson ratio @xmath58 exist in 3d as they do in 2d .
string - like structures might also be favored by anisotropies in the effective mechanical properties of the environment .
for example , fiber alignment or external strain fields might cause cell alignment with the external perturbation , which could be further stabilized by elastic interactions between cells . in c
we show a corresponding snapshot of a monte carlo simulation with @xmath148 cells modeled as hard spheres with an elastic dipole moment at their center .
here we allowed for both orientational and positional degrees of freedom ( @xmath149 ) , where the position dependence of @xmath16 from is used for additional monte carlo moves .
moreover we applied a homogeneous strain field along the @xmath150-direction .
cells respond by an alignment with the external field and the formation of strings as has been observed experimentally @xcite . without external field but with mobile cells
we typically observe formation of `` networks '' of cells at low temperature and intermediate densities and disconnected uncorrelated strings at elevated noise levels and low densities , respectively . in general
, we expect that the low to intermediate density regime of a three 3d phase diagram for mobile elastically interacting force dipoles will resemble the phase behavior of electric dipolar fluids @xcite . in both systems string formation dominates and
string - string interactions are screened in the same way @xcite . at high dipole
densities our lattice calculations in 3d suggest that phase transitions as a function of poisson ratio may occur and we find evidence that again a low poisson ratio of the material tends to favor global cell alignment .
in finite 3d environments the geometry and boundary condition of the sample may also affect structure formation .
the presence of a boundary modifies the direct elastic interaction between cells by boundary induced strain fields , which , depending on boundary condition , introduce either attractive or repulsive contributions to the elastic interaction plus a direct interaction term with the boundary @xcite .
an instructive example for the competition between the direct interaction of a cell with the boundary and cellular interactions is the elastic half space with a clamped boundary .
when cells are located close to the boundary , the direct interaction with a clamped boundary favors cellular orientations pointing toward the surface @xcite .
on the other hand , interactions between cells favor the formation of strings and thus parallel orientations .
our calculations suggest that the transition between these two configurations is a function of the ratio @xmath151 , where @xmath152 is the distance to the boundary and @xmath39 is the distance between cells , and the number of interacting cells @xmath26 . above a critical value @xmath153 the direct interaction with the boundary dominates and cells
are expected to point toward the surface . for @xmath154 orientations in parallel to the clamped surface are favored when sufficiently many cells are present , @xmath155 . in d
we plot @xmath156 as a function of @xmath63 .
thus , collective effects may alter preferred cell organization close to clamped boundaries .
in contrast for a free surface the direct interaction with boundary favors parallel alignment , which is further stabilized by collective elastic effects between cells .
this may explain the robust parallel alignment of cells with respect to free surfaces which has been observed experimentally @xcite .
using a simple mathematical model and extensive monte carlo simulations , we have analyzed structure formation due to elastic effects for fibroblast - like cells with anisotropic force patterns .
our model predicts in a quantitative way how structure formation is controlled on soft elastic substrates by the poisson ratio @xmath58 , the reduced cell density @xmath123 , the relative strength of elastic interactions with respect to noise ( represented by the reduced temperature @xmath52 ) and the geometry of cell positioning .
up to intermediate cell densities , we predict the formation of uncorrelated strings of cells ( paraelastic phase ) .
this finding can be explained by noting that the cellular traction patterns in strings screen each other , as we have demonstrated before by an analytical calculation @xcite .
for high cell densities , we find an interesting competition between isotropic ring - like and anisotropic string - like structures .
the string - like ( ferroelastic ) phase is reminiscent of the nematic phase for liquid crystals . in contrast
, the nematic order parameter vanishes in the ring - like ( anti - ferroelastic ) phase , because local ordering principles preclude nematic order on the macroscopic scale .
the poisson ratio @xmath58 allows to switch between these phases .
it strongly affects cellular structure formation due to the non - trivial way in which stress and strain propagates in the elastic environment .
the antiferroelastic phase is expected to occur on synthetic elastic substrates made from e.g. polyacrylamide or polydimethylsiloxane , which are characterized by @xmath157 . in order to obtain the nematic phase , new kinds of polymer gels for cell culture are needed , with considerable lower values for the poisson ratio ( namely below @xmath158 ) .
one possible route might be the design of biocompatible polymer gels with large meshsizes but little hydration , thus avoiding the incompressibility effect of bound water . as it is an open issue
on which time and length scales cells sense the mechanical properties of their environment @xcite , design and testing of new materials is crucial for progress in this field . like the poisson ratio , also
the other determinants of cellular structure formation are in principle accessible experimentally .
the young modulus @xmath24 directly affects the reduced temperature and can easily be varied in experiments .
nevertheless it does not appear to be a reasonable control variable for experiments , mainly because the predicted structure formation might be expected to take place only in a small range of @xmath24-values , namely the ones corresponding to physiological rigidities ( around kpa ) .
other control parameters of interest are cellular contractility ( which affects @xmath52 through the force dipole moment @xmath2 and which might be varied for example by administering lpa , which stimulates rho - mediated contractility ) and the average distance @xmath39 between cells (
although , in order for the force dipole approximation to remain valid , the typical distance between cells should not be smaller than the typical cell length ) .
the most important experimental control parameter next to the poisson ratio @xmath58 might be the geometry of cell positioning , which can be controlled with patterning techniques ( including microcontact printing in two dimensions ) .
elastic effects are likely to contribute to large scale tissue organization and to the structure - function relationship of tissues .
our results indicate that for sparsely populated tissues , elastic interactions , despite their long - ranged character , might have only a rather local effect .
this is a result of the local tendency for cells to align into strings combined with the resulting screening of elastic fields . in this regime
the system remains macroscopically disordered over a wide range of variations in material properties and cell density , effectively making the composite material of matrix and cells robust against perturbations .
it is well known that the sparsely populated connective tissue is a rather disordered structure .
our simulations suggest that without macroscopic external fields elastic interactions between cells favor isotropic disordered structures . in this case
the average stress in the tissue resulting from cells is isotropic , that is @xmath159 , where @xmath143 is the cell density .
the situation changes when an external field is applied ( e.g. resulting from a wound ) .
then highly aligned structures may prevail . in this
case cells orient their mechanical activity in such a way that the average cellular stress in the medium @xmath160 becomes anisotropic in response to homogeneous uniaxial stress , that is , the cellular stress is directed opposite to the externally applied stress ( e.g. as to close the wound ) .
it is an interesting question what happens after the external alignment field has decreased to zero .
our calculations suggest that elastic interactions may stabilize an aligned structure even in the absence of external fields . in particular , disordered tissues ( like the connective tissue )
may become aligned due to an external field . due to elastic interactions the transition from the aligned state back into the normal disordered state upon switching off the external field could be dramatically slowed down , in analogy to similar effects observed in magnetic spin glasses .
this could have implications for wound healing and scar formation .
polarization also occurs spontaneously in our model .
interestingly , this state reminds of the disease state called _ contracture _ , when certain tissues ( like skin or muscle ) start to tighten up , eventually preventing movement of body parts .
it is an interesting speculation whether the mechanical properties of extracellular matrices are altered by ( diseased ) cells in such a way as to effectively induce variations in the poisson ratio , which could trigger transitions between ferro- and anti - ferroelastic states . in order to investigate this point in more detail
, our model should be extended to include viscoelastic and plastic effects as well as fiber degrees of freedom .
mechanotaxis also plays an important role for _ dynamic _ rearrangement of groups of cells in tissues , including development , wound healing , capillary sprouting and tumor growth .
the work presented here builds on experimental observations which suggest that cells migrate toward high strain areas and orient their mechanical activity in such a way as to pull back in response to external tensile strain .
such tensile strain is certainly present e.g. close to wounded areas or tumors .
future studies will show in which sense our model can be adapted to these more specific situations .
the current study shows in a general way that many interesting structure formation processes arise from mechanical effects in communities of mechanosensitive cells and therefore might help not only to understand the corresponding physiological situations , but also to program new tissue functions by guiding the design of novel material with appropriate mechanical properties .
we thank phil allen , sam safran , assi zemel and thomas pfeifer for helpful discussions . this work was supported by the german research foundation ( dfg ) through the emmy noether program as well as by the center for modelling and simulation in the biosciences ( bioms ) at heidelberg .
engler aj , griffin ma , sen s , bonnemann cg , sweeney hl , discher de .
myotubes differentiate optimally on substrates with tissue - like stiffness : pathological implications for soft or stiff microenvironments .
j cell biol 2004;166:877887 , 2004 .
yeung t , georges pc , flanagan la , marg b , ortiz m , funaki m , zahir n , ming w , weaver v , janmey pa .
effects of substrate stiffness on cell morphology , cytoskeletal structure , and adhesion .
cell motil cytoskel 2005;60:2434 .
wong jy , leach jb , brown xq .
balance of chemistry , topography and mechanics at the cell - biomaterial interface : issues and challenges for assessing the role of substrate mechanics on cell response . surface sci 2004;570:119133 .
balaban nq , schwarz us , riveline d , goichberg p , tzur g , sabanay i , mahalu d , safran sa , bershadsky a , addadi l , geiger b. force and focal adhesion assembly : a close relationship studied using elastic micropatterned substrates .
nat cell biol 2001;3:466472 .
riveline d , zamir e , balaban nq , schwarz us , ishizaki t , narumiya s , kam z , geiger b , bershadsky ad .
focal contacts as mechanosensors : externally applied local mechanical force induces growth of focal contacts by an mdia1-dependent and rock - independent mechanism . j cell biol 2001;153:11751185 .
schwarz us , balaban nq , riveline d , bershadsky a , geiger b , safran sa .
calculation of forces at focal adhesions from elastic substrate data : the effect of localized force and the need for regularization .
biophys j 2002;83:13801394 .
parker kk , brock al , brangwynne c , mannix rj , wang n , ostuni e , geisse na , adams jc , whitesides gm , ingber de . directional control of lamellipodia extension by constraining cell shape and orienting cell tractional forces .
faseb j 2002;16:11951204 .
bell e , ivarsson b , merrill c. production of a tissue - like structure by contraction of collagen lattices by human - fibroblasts of different proliferative potential invitro .
proc natl acad sci usa 1979;76:12741278 .
figure 1 : effect of noise on global alignment order .
( a ) the order parameter @xmath87 for alignment on a square lattice as a function of noise @xmath52 for poisson ratio @xmath161 ( from left to right ) . for low noise ,
aligned structures develop for all values of the poisson ratio .
( b ) the radial distribution of the dipolar orientations on a square lattice with @xmath162 for poisson ratio @xmath147 .
the two peaks correspond to an aligned structure with bipolar symmetry below @xmath163 .
( c ) on a hexagonal lattice , @xmath138 for @xmath164 and @xmath165 for @xmath166 from left to right . at low noise ,
aligned structures are unstable for large values of the poisson ratio .
( d ) the radial distribution function on a hexagonal lattice with @xmath167 for poisson ratio @xmath147 .
the four peaks correspond to a ring - like structure below @xmath168 .
+ + figure 2 : schematic phase diagram as a function of noise level @xmath169 and poisson ratio @xmath58 for the square lattice . for illustration
, typical monte carlo snapshots are added .
both decreasing @xmath169 or increasing @xmath58 favors the ordered string - like phase . for @xmath108
, the dipoles typically weakly fluctuate around the string - like ground state . for @xmath104 ,
the dominant fluctuations around the optimal state are ring - like .
+ + figure 3 : schematic phase diagram as a function of noise level @xmath169 and poisson ratio @xmath58 for the hexagonal lattice . for illustration
, typical monte carlo snapshots are added .
ordered phases are favored by decreasing @xmath169 , but the ordered phases are string- and ring - like for small and large values of @xmath58 , respectively .
+ + figure 4 : snapshots of monte carlo simulations at reduced temperature @xmath115 for cellular force dipoles randomly displaced from an ideal square lattice for @xmath170 from left to right for @xmath104 ( a - c ) and @xmath136 ( d - f ) , respectively . increased positional disorder @xmath67 destroys long - ranged orientational order in a similar way as an increase in @xmath52 on a perfect lattice .
+ + figure 5 : snapshots of monte carlo simulations at reduced temperature @xmath115 for @xmath171 cellular force dipoles at random , but fixed positions on an elastic substrate with @xmath172 , respectively ( top - bottom ) .
the reduced area density increases from left to right as @xmath173 , respectively , while the average cell density @xmath174 remains constant .
+ + figure 6 : averaged nematic order parameter @xmath87 as a function of model parameters .
( a ) simulation results for @xmath175 ( left - right ) and @xmath164 ( bottom ) , respectively .
thus nematic ordering occurs only on compressible substrates and above a critical density .
( b ) simulation results for @xmath136 at @xmath176 ( top - bottom ) .
thus nematic ordering disappears above a certain noise level .
( c ) phase diagram for @xmath115 for dipoles on elastic substrates obtained by monte carlo simulations .
all points below diamonds have @xmath177 and all points above squares yield @xmath178 . the long dashed line is our estimate for the isoline with @xmath179 .
the horizontal dashed line marks the maximal @xmath123 possible for a hexagonal lattice .
+ + figure 7 : collective effects in 3d elastic media .
( a , b ) the optimal structure in a cubic lattice depends on the poisson ratio @xmath58 . in incompressible media ( @xmath147 )
the isotropic hedgehog structure is most favorable ( a ) while in highly compressible media ( @xmath59 ) elastic interactions favor aligned structures ( b ) .
( c ) cells in external strain fields form strings running along the direction of stretch due to interactions with external strain and elastic cell - cell interactions .
( d ) collective effects can modify preferred cell organization close to a clamped boundary , which for single cells is perpendicular . for small intercellular distances ( @xmath180 ) and sufficiently many cells in a string ( @xmath181 ) ,
the parallel orientation becomes more favorable . | compliant environments can mediate interactions between mechanically active cells like fibroblasts . starting with a phenomenological model for the behaviour of single cells
, we use extensive monte carlo simulations to predict non - trivial structure formation for cell communities on soft elastic substrates as a function of elastic moduli , cell density , noise and cell position geometry . in general
, we find a disordered structure as well as ordered string - like and ring - like structures .
the transition between ordered and disordered structures is controlled both by cell density and noise level , while the transition between string- and ring - like ordered structures is controlled by the poisson ratio .
similar effects are observed in three dimensions .
our results suggest that in regard to elastic effects , healthy connective tissue usually is in a macroscopically disordered state , but can be switched to a macroscopically ordered state by appropriate parameter variations , in a way that is reminiscent of wound contraction or diseased states like contracture .
keywords : cell - matrix adhesion , mechanotransduction , tissue organization , elastic interactions |
it is a common knowledge that the impact of a measuring device onto the object - under - test should be minimized if working with signal sources of essentially quantum nature .
this is a general problem of non - disturbing quantum measurements . for electronic detecting facilities , especially amplifiers ,
this means minimizing the energy , of noise or other origin , irradiated backwards to the object - under - test .
the effect is a so called `` back action '' , the phenomenon causing uncontrolled destruction of a quantum state of the object , e.g. , the qubit decoherencing , etc . @xcite .
the back action is detected and requires a quantitative description in a wide frequency band , orders of magnitude wider than the amplifier operation frequency band .
therefore , the `` equivalent noise temperature '' ( @xmath0 ) determined for a relatively narrow operation frequency band of the amplifier ( receiver ) is an inadequate term here .
instead , one should say about wide - spectrum brightness temperature of the amplifier and its active elements , at both the input and output `` terminals '' .
the amplifiers intended for ultra - low temperature applications ( to amplify the signals from quantum detectors , single electron transistors and variety of other quantum structures ) are typically based on the field - effect transistors . among them
, a class of hemt is distinguished , the field - effect transistors with high electron mobility .
hemts feature a very wide operational frequency band while field - induced as opposed to thermally - generated current - carrier electrons ( two - dimensional electron gas , 2deg ) in the channel principally enable the transistor functionality down to the absolute zero temperature . owing these advantages of the hemts they are widely used in ultra - sensitive readout amplifiers@xcite for quantum devices signals .
consequently , the quantitative description of the back action as applied to hemts is a hot issue .
thermal noise is generated in the hemt input ( gate - source ) terminals due to power dissipation in the input circuit of the transistor .
the dissipative losses come mainly from the gate metallization resistance , the under - gate channel resistance and the source resistance .
the corresponding irradiation ( for perfect matching , or zero input reflection coefficient ) is characterized by the gate temperature @xmath1 which is close to the physical temperature of the transistor crystal lattice @xmath2 .
cooling down to the cryogenic temperatures is an effective method to suppress the thermal irradiation .
if an ultra - deep cooling is supposed , it should be accompanied by a considerable decrease ( down to a few microwatts and less ) in the transistor consumed / dissipated power to avoid excessive joule overheating of its active area .
the situation with overheating becomes more severe because of low thermal conductivity of the heterostructures @xcite .
the low cooling capacity of the ultra - low - temperature cryorefrigerators , especially below 100 mk , also strongly limits the hemt dissipated power .
provided if the heat sink is effective , the input - circuit - generated thermal noise is reduced sufficiently and can be neglected regarding the back action .
the `` hot '' electrons irradiation from the gate - drain channel region , being another cause of the back action , also contributes substantially to @xmath0 .
a high effective electron temperature @xmath3 ( drain temperature ) exceeding the lattice temperature by two orders of magnitude is inherent for this mechanism .
the irradiation of the 2deg in gate - drain part of the channel goes backward to the input via intrinsic drain - gate capacitance of the transistor .
the excitation of the waveguide modes by the output circuit in the conductive cavity ( where the amplifier is placed and often the signal source ) is an additional way .
the effect of @xmath3 can be roughly estimated using the reverse transmission gain ( @xmath4 ) from the transistor s - matrix .
typically , @xmath4 is about -20 ... -30 db at 1 ghz frequency
. the @xmath4 rises almost linearly with frequency so the effect of @xmath3 can prevail over @xmath5 . if the amplifier has a high input impedance ( @xmath4 is defined for 50-@xmath6 network ) , then the reverse transmission increases stimulating the search for the ways of @xmath3 reduction .
the @xmath3 and @xmath5 are used to calculate basic noise characteristics of a transistor , namely , the minimal noise temperature , the optimal source impedance and the noise conductivity @xcite .
the both @xmath3 and @xmath5 figures are extracted from a series of the noise measurements by solving the inverse problem @xcite on the basis of the electrophysical transistor model which is inevitably limited to certain frequency band and temperature range .
integrally , the extraction procedure is sophisticated and ambiguous . in the context of the back - action problem
, the characteristics of the existing energy flows disturbing the quantum object should be found .
the temperature is a natural quantifier of the chaotic ( noise ) irradiation .
so , the task is rather to measure directly the brightness temperature than to solve the inverse problem on extraction of @xmath3 , @xmath5 or other similar noise invariants @xcite .
first , to measure @xmath7 instrumentally , the contribution of the amplified noise of the input circuit to the integral output noise irradiation of the transistor should be excluded . referring to the modern transistors with cut - off frequencies of tens and more gigahertz ,
such an elimination is hard enough because of stability problem .
moreover , it becomes much more complicated under the deep - cooling conditions .
however , the ultra - low power consumption of the transistor associated with deep - cooled amplifiers results in decrease in the cut - off frequency by two orders of magnitude while the stability factor exceeds the unity . consequently , the stability is not further an issue , and the direct instrumental measurement of @xmath7 become possible . in this work
we propose a simple method to measure directly the brightness temperature of the 2deg in a hemt channel .
the results of the measurements are discussed and the recommendations on the choice of the hemt dc regime are formulated concerning the back action phenomenon .
the simplified diagram of the experimental setup is shown in fig.[fig01 ] .
the essence of the technique are by - turn measurement and subsequent comparison of the powers of the two signals .
the first one is produced by the output circuit of the transistor - under - test ( q1 ) , the second one is the reference , taken from a variable resistor r whose temperature is equal to the ambient temperature . during the calibration procedure ,
the resistance r is set equal to the differential resistance of the channel in a specified point of the transistor static characteristics .
the measurement cycle is described below in more detail .
the transistor gate is ac - shorted to the source by c1 to exclude the amplified input circuit noise from the net output signal .
the self inductance of the capacitor c1 ( smd 0603 , 330 pf ) along with the inductance of the q1 gate terminal does not exceed 3 nh .
the associated reactance at a mean frequency ( 50 mhz ) of the operational range is inductive and not greater than 4@xmath8 and the capacitive reactance of the gate - source of more than 3@xmath9 k@xmath6 . under these conditions ,
only the noise component representing the source resistance noise is amplified by the transistor adding to @xmath7 .
this resistance does not exceed 3@xmath10 for practically all low - power hemts .
taking into account that the transistor voltage gain does not exceed 5 under the microcurrent dc regime , it is easy to show that the contribution of the source noise in the output signal is less than 1% . the transistor q1 and the variable resistor r
are placed close to the instrumental amplifier to minimize the shunt capacitance . a three - stage hemt ( avago atf35143 ) high input impedance ( 100@xmath9 k@xmath6 ) , low - noise cooled amplifier ( hilna in fig.[fig01 ] )
is used as the instrumental amplifier .
the hilna gain is about 40 db , the operational frequency band is 20 to 100 mhz .
the integral noise temperatures of the hilna are [email protected] k and [email protected] k at the source resistance of 10@xmath8 and 1000@xmath8 , respectively , and the ambient temperature @xmath12k .
the amplifier circuitry is similar to the earlier reported devices @xcite .
the measuring circuit is a low - q parallel tank consisted of the resistor r and hemt channel resistance , the capacitance of the wires , pads and hilna input ( totally 5 pf ) and the inductance l ( 3@xmath13h ) .
a linear amplifier ( la ) with a band - pass filter ( 40 ... 80 mhz ) is placed next to the hilna . the specified frequency band ( namely , the lower edge )
is chosen in order to exclude the @xmath14 noise of q1 .
the output signal level is measured by a square - meter voltmeter ( smv ) within an accuracy of better than 1% .
the multisection filters are put into the supply circuits ( not shown in fig.[fig01 ] ) and the test unit is electromagnetically shielded .
the measurement errors are 0.1% and 1.5% for the dc voltages and currents , correspondingly .
the measuring cycle is a three - stage one .
first , the resistor r is set to zero resistance , and the static characteristics of the transistor are measured .
the drain - source resistance @xmath15 is calculated from the data obtained as a function of @xmath16 and @xmath17 .
the smv readouts are taken for each calculated @xmath18 . according to the measurement procedure and nyquist theorem ,
the smv voltage , which is proportional to the output signal power , can be written as : @xmath19 where @xmath20 is the mean square of the measured output voltage at a specified drain - source resistance @xmath18 , @xmath21 is the mean square of the measured output voltage at @xmath22 = 0 ( see below ) , @xmath23 is the boltzmann constant , @xmath24 is the brightness temperature of the noise irradiation of the transistor channel , @xmath25 and @xmath26 are the total gain and effective pass band of the measuring system , correspondingly , at the specified @xmath18 .
the second stage is a calibration .
the transistor is zero - biased and maximally opened ( @xmath27 ) .
the channel resistance @xmath18 is minimal ( @xmath28=8@xmath111 @xmath6 for atf36077 ) and fully linear .
the noise generated by @xmath18 is purely thermal ( white ) .
it adds to the noise of the calibration resistor r with resistance @xmath22 .
the calibration includes tuning the calibration resistor r in the range of 0 ... 670 @xmath6 while the smv readout is synchronously taken . in a manner similar to ( [ 1
] ) , we write the equation for the smv output signal : @xmath29 where @xmath30 is the mean square of the measured output voltage at a specified resistance @xmath22 of the calibration resistor r ( exactly , @xmath31 ) , @xmath32 is the physical temperature of the calibration resistor r , @xmath33 and @xmath34 are the total gain and the effective pass band of the measuring system , correspondingly , at the specified @xmath22 .
finally , an expression for @xmath24 can be derived from ( [ 1 ] ) and ( [ 2 ] ) taking @xmath35 , @xmath36 .
these equalities are valid if the experimental values are taken from the data array with the selection rule @xmath37 .
then we obtain : @xmath38 to simplify the measurement and calculation procedures , a few assumptions were made when writing ( [ 1])-([3 ] ) .
\(i ) @xmath39=const is assumed , i.e. the noise temperature of the instrumental amplifier ( hilna ) does not depend on the source resistance .
actually , it varies ( see above ) although always staying below the temperature to measure , @xmath24 .
\(ii ) @xmath39 is supposed to be measured at @xmath22=0 .
in fact , the minimal value @xmath40 8 @xmath6 ( for atf36077 ) .
\(iii ) it is believed that the dc channel resistance @xmath18 is equal to the ac one , at the measurement frequency ( 40 - 60 mhz ) . in reality , the ac channel resistance is less by a few percent .
all the assumptions made are not too rough , and the systematic absolute error ( see section iii ) does not exceed 2 k. nevertheless , it should be taken into account when @xmath24 is about several kelvins .
when the measured @xmath24 is of some tens kelvins ( the most important and interesting range ) , the error is determined by the accuracy of the instrumental measurement being , by our estimate , of about 10% of the measured value . to the authors opinion ,
this error is acceptable in the context of this work .
additionally , the following should be clarified here .
the drain temperature @xmath3 , as a parameter in the two - temperature pospeshalski noise model @xcite , actually represents the effective temperature of the 2deg in the saturated region ( roughly , the gate - drain region ) of the hemt channel .
meanwhile , the expression ( [ 3 ] ) that we obtained for @xmath24 represents an averaged 2deg temperature throughout the whole channel including the source - gate part with its temperature which is always close to @xmath2 .
it is the 2deg temperature that we designate by @xmath24 .
it is measured directly and has a clear physical sense .
however , @xmath3 and @xmath24 do not differ too much since the resistance of the source - gate region is about 1/100 of the total channel resistance .
the measurement of @xmath24 can , in principle , be done without the calibration resistor , using the transistor noise instead at @xmath16 = 0 , @xmath41 = 0 . however , in practice this requires an extra ( negative ) bias voltage which could cause , for some transistors , the gate leakage noise to emerge .
the pseudomorphic hemt avago atf36077 was chosen as a test object .
we believe this transistor is a good representative of low - power hemts .
additionally , as our practice show , atf36077 has a very low gate leakage current and a high mechanical stability during multiple thermal cycling .
the atf36077 static characteristics show no hysteresis .
all said above makes atf36077 a suitable object for testing the proposed measurement method . the bias voltage and ,
correspondingly , the maximal drain current were chosen so that the transistor dissipated power @xmath42 would not exceed @xmath43w .
the larger @xmath42 values are beyond the subject of this work .
also , at @xmath44w the transistor - under - test should be carefully monitored for a parasitic oscillation to emerge which is provoked by the gate grounding . the consumption current of the hilna is a suitable indicator of the parasitic oscillations .
the measurements were taken at 4.2 k , 78 k and 290 k when developing the technique .
the results of the measurements at 4.2 k are reported below .
fig.[fig02 ] demonstrates the static characteristics and the electron temperature for atf36077 .
let us start with these data to estimate the measurement error . to do this
, we note that the measured @xmath24 is assumed to be equal to @xmath32 when @xmath16 = 0 , @xmath45 = 0 .
it is quite reasonable from the physical point of view .
then the difference between @xmath24 and @xmath32 in the origin of the static characteristic branch ( @xmath16=0 ) can serve as a measure of the absolute error .
the data show that the systematic error does not exceed 2 k. let us take conventionally @xmath46 db as a measure of the back action .
also , we define the criterion of the acceptable irradiation in the direction of the signal source : the temperature of such an irradiation must not be higher than @xmath47 , that is @xmath48 .
bearing in mind these definitions , a recommendation useful in designing the amplifiers with reduced back action can be derived from fig.[fig02 ] .
namely , the maximal acceptable value of @xmath16 is 150 mv for hemt operating at @xmath49 k. fig.[fig03 ] shows the electron temperature @xmath24 as a function of the drain current @xmath41 at fixed drain - source voltages @xmath16 .
it is clearly seen that @xmath50 plot tends to a saturation and , there is no increase of the electron temperature with the current anyway .
this witnesses for a negligible contribution of the channel diffusion noise induced onto the gate .
therefore , the gate is `` well - grounded '' while the operation frequency and the circuit design are adequate .
the @xmath24 as a function of @xmath16 at fixed drain currents is plotted in fig.[fig04 ] .
it should be noted at once that the doubled electron temperature ( @xmath51 ) is observed at the voltages much higher than expected threshold values ( of order of 1 mv ) approximately following from the condition @xmath52 .
the effect could evidence for the ballistic ( collision - free ) electron transport at corresponding parts of the static characteristics .
a distinctive bend of the curve taken at the drain current of 100 @xmath53a may be associated with the threshold of the optical phonon scattering mechanism activation ( approximately 30 ev for the a3b5 semiconductors ) .
the corresponding dc regime ( @xmath54ma , @xmath55mv ) can be recommended for the first - stage transistors in the amplifiers with minimized back action intended to function at subkelvin temperatures .
the hemt ability of working at ultra - low supply voltages in the unsaturated region of the static characteristics was reported earlier in @xcite .
the absence of the `` bend '' in the plots corresponding to the drain currents 20 and 50 @xmath53a is most likely due to the expansion of the under - gate depletion region towards the source .
this effect probably causes the paradoxical rise of @xmath24 with decreasing the channel current ( fig.[fig04 ] ) as well . the above estimates and the plots analysis is rather qualitative .
they aimed , in the context of this work , to the demonstration of reasonability of the measurement of the electron temperature in studying electrophysical processes in hemts and finding the optimal regimes from the point of view of the back action problem . to estimate the back action at low frequencies where @xmath14 noise predominates , it is necessary to measure the amplifier noise temperature with the standard procedure @xcite .
a technique is suggested in this paper for the direct measurement of the brightness temperature of the 2deg in a hemt . the technical simplicity and clear physical sense of the measurement results makes the proposed method a convenient tool for further studies of the delicate electrophysical processes such as the ballistic electron transport and diffusion , the 2deg properties and so on .
grounding on the results of the 2deg brightness temperature measurements , the recommendations are put for choosing the hemt dc regimes which are the best concerning the back action .
it is found that the optimal hemt operation points to minimize the back action lie in the unsaturated area of the static characteristics that possibly corresponds to the electron ballistic transit .
m. grajcar , a. izmalkov , e. ilichev , th .
wagner , n. oukhanski , u. huebner , t. may , i. zhilyaev , h.e .
hoenig , ya.s .
greenberg , v.i .
shnyrkov , d. born , w. krech , h .-
meyer , a. maasen van den brink , and m.h.s .
amin , phys .
b , 69 , 060501 ( 2004 ) . | a technically simple and physically clear method is suggested for the direct measurement of brightness temperature of two - dimensional electron gas ( 2deg ) in the channel of a high electron mobility transistor ( hemt ) .
the usage of the method was demonstrated with the pseudomorphic hemt as a specimen .
the optimal hemt dc regime , from the point of view of the `` back action '' problem , was found to belong to the unsaturated area of the static characteristics possibly corresponding to the ballistic electron transport mode .
the proposed method is believed to be a convenient tool to explore the ballistic transport , electron diffusion , 2deg properties and other electrophysical processes in the heterostructures . |
susy is perhaps the most promising candidate for physics beyond the standard model ; it also provides a good test of detector performance .
the atlas @xcite and cms @xcite collaborations at the cern large hadron collider ( lhc ) have therefore devoted a lot of effort to studying susy signatures and measurements .
this talk provides an overview of that work with emphasis on new results since the overviews in ref . and .
the susy cross section at the lhc is dominated by the associated strong production of gluinos and squarks .
if @xmath0 parity is conserved , these decay into the lightest susy particle @xmath1 , which escapes the detector , plus quarks , gluons , and perhaps other standard model particles . thus , susy provides signatures containing at least jets and large missing transverse energy @xmath2 .
the lhc should be able to observe these signals for @xmath3 and @xmath4 masses up to about @xmath5 with only @xmath6 of integrated luminosity .
the challenge at the lhc is not to discover tev - scale susy ( assuming it exists ) but to make precision measurements of masses and other quantities .
since the decay products of each susy particle contain an invisible @xmath1 , no mass peaks can be reconstructed directly .
instead , masses must be inferred @xcite from kinematic endpoints and other properties of the events .
developing methods to do this has been a main emphasis of the studies to date .
typically , events are simulated for a particular susy model and for the standard model backgrounds using a parton shower monte carlo program such as herwig @xcite , isajet @xcite , or pythia @xcite , the detector response is simulated using a fast parameterization , cuts are made to give a good signal / background , and various kinematic distributions are reconstructed .
a number of examples are presented below .
since @xmath3 and @xmath4 are strongly produced , their cross sections are comparable to qcd at the same @xmath7 .
if @xmath0 parity is conserved , their decays produce distinctive events with large @xmath2 .
a typical analysis requires at least four jets with @xmath8 and @xmath9 and plots as a measure of @xmath7 the quantity @xmath10 for large @xmath11 the standard model background is typically 10% of the signal .
the reach is thus limited mainly by the @xmath3 and @xmath4 production cross sections and hence masses .
this reach is shown for the minimal sugra model in fig .
[ catania18 ] .
note that the sensitivity for one month at 10% of design luminosity is about @xmath12 . of course it will take more than one month to understand the detectors , but nevertheless one might hope for an interesting talk at susy08 .
squark and gluino decays typically involve one or more intermediate charginos or neutralinos , giving rise to multi - lepton signatures as well as ones involving jets .
the reach for such signatures is shown in figure [ d_denegri_1266c ] .
the emergence of the susy signal from the standard model background is illustrated for a typical case in figure [ tovey02 ] .
also shown is the correlation between the peak of the @xmath11 distribution and @xmath13 obviously , however , any such inclusive correlation is model dependent . while the reach plots in figure [ catania18 ] apply only to msugra , similar reach in gluino and squark masses should apply to any model in which they decay into an invisible and relatively light @xmath1 .
some models are easier .
for example , gmsb models with prompt @xmath14 or @xmath15 decays provide additional photon or lepton handles to suppress standard model backgrounds .
gmsb models with a quasi - stable @xmath16 provide a penetrating charged particle with @xmath17 that is well measured by the muon detectors .
amsb models give few single leptons but larger @xmath2 .
if @xmath0 parity is violated via @xmath18 or @xmath19 , there are again additional leptons .
perhaps the most difficult case is @xmath0-violation via @xmath20 , giving multiple jets but no @xmath21 jets .
the background is poorly known , but it seems likely that one must rely on leptonic cascade decays . in general , however , discovery of gluinos and squarks with masses of order @xmath22 appears straightforward .
masses of @xmath23 are of course much more difficult and would probably need a luminosity upgrade .
if @xmath0 parity is conserved , then the @xmath1 is invisible and there are no mass peaks .
nevertheless , kinematic endpoints allow one to determine mass combinations .
the simplest example is the decay for the dilepton signature , events are selected to have two leptons with ( typically ) @xmath24 and @xmath25 in addition to multiple hard jets and large @xmath2 .
then the dominant standard model background is @xmath26 .
the background from @xmath26 or from any other standard model source involving two independent decays cancels in the combination @xmath27 .
the same is true for two independent chargino decays in msugra , and it is likely to be true in any susy model that avoids @xmath28 and other low - energy constraints . an opposite - sign , same - flavor dilepton signature can arise from a 2-body cascade decay @xmath29 , from a 3-body @xmath30 decay , or from a decay via a @xmath31 .
all three cases are illustrated in figure [ blois ] .
they are clearly distinguished by shape .
such endpoints are observable over a significant fraction of the msugra parameter space , as illustrated in figure [ cmsll ] . in particular ,
a large part of the msugra parameter space with acceptable cold dark matter has light sleptons and hence enhanced @xmath32 decays .
when a longer decay chain can be identified , more combinations of masses can be measured .
for example , at msugra point 5 , the dominant source of dileptons is @xmath33 . the gluino is heavier than the squarks , and
the hardest jets generally come from the squarks .
in such a case , one can form an @xmath34 endpoint and two @xmath35 endpoints in addition to the @xmath32 one @xcite .
in addition , if a lower limit on the @xmath32 mass is imposed , there is also an @xmath36 threshold .
all of these distributions after experimental selections are shown in figure [ camb5new ] .
the endpoints and thresholds can all be expressed in terms of the masses involved using elementary kinematics , and they provide enough constraints to determine the masses .
the results taking estimated errors into account for the @xmath1 and @xmath37 masses are shown in figure [ camb15 ] for two models with similar masses .
all the masses involved are determined quite accurately as functions of @xmath38 ; in particular the two models can be easily distinguished .
the @xmath1 mass is determined to about 10% through its effect on the kinematics even though it is invisible .
an alternative approach is to reconstruct @xmath39 momentum assuming that the @xmath1 mass is known and using @xmath40 while this is exact only for a 3-body @xmath41 at the endpoint , it can be used as an approximation elsewhere .
an analysis for sugra point b ( @xmath42 , @xmath43 , @xmath44 , @xmath45 , @xmath46 ) using this method looks for @xmath47 .
the dilepton distribution after cuts and the reconstructed @xmath48 distribution using @xmath49 are shown in figure [ tricomi ] .
a second @xmath21 can be added to reconstruct the gluino mass ; see ref . .
if the decay @xmath51 is kinematically allowed , it often has a substantial branching ratio .
the decay @xmath50 can be reconstructed by selecting events with multiple jets plus large @xmath2 and plotting the mass of pairs of jets tagged as @xmath21 s .
the reach for this signature in msugra , shown in figure [ cmshbb ] , covers a substantial fraction of parameter space
. it might well be the discovery mode for the light susy higgs .
if @xmath50 can be reconstructed , it can then be combined with jets to determine other masses . in figure [ p5_mbbj ] for example ,
the @xmath52 was combined with each of the two hardest jets in the event ; the smaller of these masses should be less than the @xmath53 endpoint .
this measurement is less precise than those involving leptons , but it may be useful if the leptonic branching ratios are small .
susy events can be much more complex than those for the cases discussed above .
an example is the `` focus point '' region : in msugra as @xmath54 becomes large for fixed values of the other parameters , @xmath55 and radiative electroweak symmetry breaking fails . near this boundary
, the @xmath1 is dominantly higgsino , leading to acceptable values of cold dark matter @xcite .
the exact location of the focus point region is very sensitive to details of the susy spectrum calculation @xcite , but such a region surely exists . in one calculation
@xcite the msugra point @xmath56 , @xmath57 , @xmath44 , @xmath45 , @xmath46 is close to the @xmath58 focus point boundary . since the squarks are heavy , susy production is dominated by @xmath59 pairs .
the largest @xmath3 branching ratios are calculated @xcite to be @xmath60 .
these decays give events with 1216 jets and leptons !
the methods described previously suffice to find such signals .
many of the basic starting points discussed previously also work ; see for example figure [ c1500mll ] . but sorting out the combinatorial background in such complex events is quite difficult and has not yet been solved .
@xmath0-parity violation with @xmath61 , and especially @xmath62 is another example of a susy model with very complex signatures . in such models
the signal has very high jet multiplicity nominally six jets just from the @xmath1 decays few or no @xmath21 jets that might be used to reduce the combinatorial background , and small @xmath2 .
the qcd background for such events is not well known ; the 1-loop qcd corrections to the production of 6 - 10 jets seem unlikely to be calculated even by the end of lhc running .
estimates based on qcd shower monte carlo programs suggest that the backgrounds are comparable to the signals , but this is at best a rough estimate . for such scenarios , therefore , it is probably necessary to rely on susy cascade decays , e.g. , @xmath63 , to provide additional handles to suppress the qcd background .
one example that has been studied uses such decays with branching ratios taken from msugra point 5 . even though there are no missing particles , reconstruction is difficult because the jets from the @xmath1 are soft and the mass resolution is only @xmath64 . define the mass combinations @xmath65 ; then the jet resolution largely cancels for @xmath66 , as can be seen in figure [ camb6a ] . the distributions in figure [ camrviol ] show reasonable distributions in these variables .
these are just two examples of susy scenarios giving complex signatures .
such scenarios are certainly possible , and much more work is needed to develop analysis strategies to deal with them .
the initial motivation for studying @xmath67 signatures came from the fact that for large regions of msugra parameter space with @xmath68 the only two - body decay modes are @xmath69 and @xmath70 .
then these modes have branching ratios close to 100% , and all ssuy decays involve @xmath67 s .
such scenarios are disfavored because they tend to give contributions to @xmath71 much larger than observed .
low - energy tests of the standard model seem to require that the first two generations of squarks and sleptons be nearly degenerate .
this degeneracy is not understood in general but does occur in msugra . even in msugra , however , the third generation of squarks and sleptons is split by renormalization group and left - right mixing effects .
thus , study of the third generation is likely to be essential for understanding susy .
because of technical constraints , the atlas and cms vertex detectors do not have sufficient resolution to identify @xmath67 decays cleanly .
hence , leptonic @xmath67 decays can not be distinguished from prompt leptons , and @xmath67 s can only be identified using narrow , one - prong jets , for which there is substantial qcd background . as can be seen from figure [ tdr9 - 31 ] ,
the typical jet rejection is a factor of about 100 for a @xmath67 efficiency of 50% . for msugra with @xmath72 , @xmath44 , @xmath73
, the only 2-body decays of light gauginos are @xmath74 and @xmath75 .
these decays therefore dominate .
since there is @xmath2 both from @xmath76 s and from @xmath1 s , the @xmath67 distributions can only be inferred from their hadronic decay products . instead of a sharp @xmath77 edge at @xmath78 , one would observe the distribution shown in figure [ p6subtracted ] .
the visible @xmath67 momentum depends both on the momentum and on the polarization of the parent @xmath67 .
the decay @xmath79 is maximally sensitive to the polarization while high - mass decays are rather insensitive to it .
a study of the separation of different decay modes has been carried out using a full geant - based simulation of @xmath67 s from susy events in the atlas detector .
the visible @xmath67 mass is reconstructed by combining charged tracks and electromagnetic calorimeter cells , exploiting the fine granularity of the calorimeter .
the reconstructed masses , figure [ mtaunew ] , show a good separation of @xmath80 decays and some difference between @xmath81 and @xmath82 decays .
the same figure indicates the sensitivity of the @xmath77 mass distribution to a reversal of helicities .
in gmsb models the lightest susy particle is the light gravitino @xmath83 .
the phenomenology depends on nature and lifetime of the next lightest particle ( nlsp ) , which can be either the @xmath1 or a @xmath16 .
decays into @xmath83 lead to more distinctive events and to longer decay chains , such as @xmath84 , that can be used to determine susy masses @xcite .
the lifetime for the nlsp to decay to a @xmath83 is unknown and is an important parameter of the model .
short @xmath14 lifetimes can be measured by selecting dalitz decays and using the vertex detector . for @xmath85
the signature is occasional photons that do no point to the primary vertex .
the atlas electromagnetic calorimeter was designed to measure photon angles with @xmath86 to improve the @xmath87 mass resolution .
it also has good time resolution , @xmath88 .
both can be exploited to detect long - lived @xmath14 decays with good efficiency , as seen in figurereftdr20 - 65 .
if no signal is seen , an upper limit of order @xmath89 could be established @xcite .
a long - lived slepton nlsp would give tracks with @xmath17 through the calorimeter and muon system .
these can be well identified by using the muon system as a time of flight system , as can be seen in figure [ cmsmstau ] @xcite .
the lifetime can be estimated by counting the number of events with zero , one , and two such tracks , as is also shown in figure [ cmsmstau ] .
it should also be possible to determine the lifetime by looking for kinks in the central tracker , but developing the needed pattern recognition algorithm is non - trivial and has not yet been attempted .
if susy exists with masses below about @xmath22 , it seems likely that the atlas and cms detectors should find evidence for it shortly after the lhc begins operation .
only a limited number of susy models and cases have been investigated so far , and in all cases the answer has been known .
these studies seem sufficient , however , to sketch the broad outlines of an initial program of susy measurements ( assuming that @xmath0 parity is conserved ) : 1 .
search for an excess of multijet + @xmath2 events over standard model predictions , which of course must be checked against other measurements . 2 .
if such an excess is found , select a sample of susy with simple cuts such as those described above .
look for special features such as @xmath90 s or long - lived @xmath16 s in these events .
look for @xmath91 , @xmath32 , @xmath92 , @xmath21 jets , hadronic @xmath67 decays , etc .
try simple endpoint - type analyses such as those described above .
there is of course much more information available , including cross sections , branching ratios , and other kinematic distributions .
ultimately one will want to use the first measurements to guide further analyses incorporating all the information . this program will need the full power of the lhc and its detectors .
i. hinchliffe and f. e. paige , in _ proc . of the aps / dpf / dpb summer study on the future of particle physics ( snowmass 2001 ) _ ed .
n. graf , snowmass-2001-e401 _ prepared for aps / dpf / dpb summer study on the future of particle physics ( snowmass 2001 ) , snowmass , colorado , 30 jun - 21 jul 2001_. i. hinchliffe and f. e. paige , in _ proc . of the aps / dpf / dpb summer study on the future of particle physics ( snowmass 2001 ) _ ed .
n. graf , snowmass-2001-e402 _ prepared for aps / dpf / dpb summer study on the future of particle physics ( snowmass 2001 ) , snowmass , colorado , 30 jun - 21 jul 2001_. | the atlas and cms collaborations at the cern large hadron collider ( lhc ) have devoted considerable effort to the study of susy signatures and measurements .
this talk provides an overview of what can be learned at the lhc if tev - scale susy exists .
= cmss10 scaled 1 by -6.5 in by 2 by -by -8.9 in by 2 by - to 0pt --to 8.9 in = 6.5 in brookhaven national laboratory ' '' '' ' '' '' to ' '' '' ' '' '' * susy signatures at lhc * .5 in * frank e. paige * _ physics department _
_ brookhaven national laboratory _ _ upton , ny 11973 usa _
.75 in abstract the atlas and cms collaborations at the cern large hadron collider ( lhc ) have devoted considerable effort to the study of susy signatures and measurements .
this talk provides an overview of what can be learned at the lhc if tev - scale susy exists .
invited talk at the _
susy02 : the 10th international conference on supersymmetry and unification of fundamental interactions _ ( june 1723 , 2002 , desy , hamburg ) . this manuscript has been authored under contract number de - ac02 - 98ch10886 with the u.s .
department of energy .
accordingly , the u.s .
government retains a non - exclusive , royalty - free license to publish or reproduce the published form of this contribution , or allow others to do so , for u.s .
government purposes . * susy signatures at lhc * * frank e. paige * _ brookhaven national laboratory , upton , ny 11973 usa _ |
cooperative behavior often provides a strong benefit for populations . but why are cooperators not undermined by non - cooperative individuals which take the benefit but save the costs for its provision @xcite ? for higher developed organisms , there are several ways to escape this _ dilemma of cooperation _ : for individuals , which are capable to recognize other individuals , memorizing previous interactions and controlling their handling accordingly , reciprocity , and punishment can promote cooperation @xcite .
however , those mechanisms can not act in organisms of modest complexity like microbes or during the early course of life where memory and recognition were mostly lacking . in such scenarios ,
cooperation might prevail due to the structure of the population @xcite ; this idea has been studied both theoretically and experimentally in the context of kin- , group- and multilevel selection @xcite .
if cooperators more likely interact with other cooperators ( positive assortment ) , they keep most of their benefit for themselves and are less exploited by non - cooperators .
however , due to the costs of cooperation , a fitness disadvantage compared to non - cooperators is still present : positive assortment supports cooperation but is not necessarily sufficient to ensure its maintenance .
crucially , positive assortment can only act if cooperation is already established in the population such that cooperative individuals can successfully assort .
thus , the question remains how cooperation can emerge _ starting with a single cooperating mutant_. in this manuscript , we address this issue for a generic situation of microbial populations .
cooperative microbes typically produce public goods whose synthesis is metabolically costly @xcite .
for example , consider the proteobacteria _ pseudomonas aeruginosa _ and siderophore production : when iron is lacking in the environment , cooperative strains produce iron - scavenging molecules ( siderophores ) @xcite .
released into the environment these molecules can efficiently bind single iron molecules and the resulting complex can then be taken up by surrounding bacteria .
microbial populations are highly structured : several colonies form one population @xcite .
new colonies arise due to migration into new habitats or more actively due to controlled life - cycles triggered by environmental factors .
for example , studies of _ p. aeruginosa _
@xcite confirm that typical life - cycles pass through different steps with regularly occurring dispersal events ensued by the formation of new colonies . as the initial colony sizes are typically small , such dispersal events coincide with population bottlenecks .
emulating the dynamical colony formation , microbial cooperation has been studied experimentally by employing a life - cycle where new colonies are regularly formed from old ones @xcite .
these experiments and theoretical work @xcite show that such a restructuring mechanism can cause an increase in the level of cooperation . based on these observations ,
we here theoretically investigate if such a restructuring scenario can not only maintain cooperation , but also allows for the evolution of cooperation from a single mutant . assuming a constant population size , the onset of traits from a single mutant and its fixation
have been studied in the frameworks of population genetics and evolutionary game theory @xcite .
however the consequences of ecological factors such as population growth and population restructuring remain unclear @xcite . to tackle this question for the microbial scenario introduced before , we consider a life - cycle model , consisting of three steps @xcite ,
see fig .
[ fig : cartoon ] : and free - riders [ red ] in an initially well - mixed population are randomly subdivided into groups of average size @xmath4 .
the groups then evolve separately following two main rules .
first , groups with a higher fraction of cooperators grow faster as more public good is present in those populations .
second , in each group cooperators reproduce slower as free - riders as they do not have to provide the public good ; for detail see main text .
after a certain time @xmath5 all groups are merged and the cycle restarts . ]
\(i ) in the _ group - formation step _ , a population consisting of cooperators ( @xmath6 ) and non - cooperating _ free - riders _ ( @xmath7 ) is randomly assorted into different groups ( colonies ) .
( ii ) in the ensuing _ group - evolution step _ , each group evolves separately according to generic growth laws of microbes .
( iii ) in the _ group - merging step _
, colonies are merged to one population again .
consecutively , the cycle starts anew with the next group - formation step .
the synchronous reformation of groups via merging all individuals into a single population follows recent experiments @xcite and is obviously a simplification of natural colony formation .
however , it captures the essence of regular occurring bottlenecks , namely rearranging colonies which have an initially small population size .
furthermore , as it comprises a worst - case scenario for cooperation , it is suited to study the possible onset of cooperation in microbial populations starting with a single cooperative mutant .
starting with a well - mixed population with a fraction @xmath8 of cooperators , @xmath9 groups ( colonies ) are formed during the group - formation step .
successively , each group @xmath10 is assigned @xmath11 randomly chosen individuals of the well - mixed population ; group sizes @xmath12 are poisson - distributed with mean @xmath4 .
the random assortment leads to a statistical variation in the initial fraction of cooperators , @xmath13 . approximately , it is of the order @xmath14 .
we investigate this unbiased random assortment of groups as it does not assume individuals to be distinguishable by the sorting mechanism and again constitutes a worst - case scenario for cooperators .
after assortment into groups , each group @xmath10 evolves and grows separately . the dynamics within groups is given by a stochastic process based on birth and death events which are characterized by the corresponding per capita birth rates @xmath15 and death rates @xmath16 , where @xmath17 denotes the trait of the individual in group @xmath10 @xcite .
the birth rates of individuals depend on two factors , namely the trait of the individual and the composition of the colony the individual is living in .
first , cooperators reproduce slower than free - riders in each colony as they have metabolic costs due to the production of the public good , @xmath18 .
second , as more cooperative groups produce more public good , individuals in colonies containing a higher fraction of cooperators are better off , @xmath19 for @xmath20 .
the death rates incorporate the effect of limited resources and , therefore , increase with an increasing population size , @xmath21 for @xmath22 . for specificity , we assume the following birth and death rates which fulfill all conditions stated above : @xmath23 where @xmath24 is the kronecker delta defined by @xmath25 and @xmath26 . while @xmath27 sets the growth advantage of cooperators on the colony level , the parameter @xmath28 measures the metabolic costs of cooperation . the growth rate @xmath29 is assumed to be fixed setting the time - scale of growth .
the here assumed functional form of the growth rates reproduces the generically observed growth dynamics of microbial populations @xcite : small colonies grow exponentially and their size is bounded by a maximal colony size which here scales with @xmath30 .
a more detailed description of the dynamics including a discussion of the deterministic equations can be found in refs .
furthermore , in @xcite the specific form of the rates is justified by successful comparisons with experiments by chuang et al .
note also that the qualitative results presented in this manuscript do not depend on the specific functional forms of the growth rates , but only on the rather generic conditions of population bottlenecks followed by growth .
after a _ regrouping time _ @xmath5 the separated groups are merged again into one well - mixed population with a then changed global population size @xmath31 , and a fraction of cooperators which is given by the weighted average , @xmath32 the cycle then starts anew with the new fraction of cooperators , @xmath33 .
although the fraction of cooperators within each group is expected to decrease during group - evolution , an increase in the global fraction of cooperators is possible in principle : the disadvantage of cooperation within each group can be overcome by changing weights , @xmath34 , in the total population . to achieve this
there must be a sufficiently high positive correlation between group size and cooperator fraction @xcite .
such an increase of cooperation is an example of simpson s paradox @xcite . for the random assortment of groups considered here , two mechanisms promoting cooperation
can be distinguished as previously studied @xcite .
first , for very small population bottlenecks , purely cooperative colonies might be formed where there is no conflict with free - riders ( _ group - fixation mechanism _ ) .
second , more cooperative groups grow comparably fast and thereby compensate for the selection advantage of free - riders ( _ group - growth mechanism _ ) . as those mechanisms are crucial for the understanding of our results concerning single mutants spreading in the population , we first repeat some arguments from ref .
@xcite and additionally introduce analytic calculations and a study of the key parameters to support them .
the second part of this article is devoted to the main question of the paper namely whether a single cooperative mutant which can not rely on benefits provided by other cooperators has the chance to spread in the population .
in the following we analyze both mechanisms in detail , starting with the group - fixation mechanism . for long separate evolution of groups , @xmath35 ,
all groups reach a stationary state : they consist of either cooperators or free - riders only with a group sizes of @xmath36 and @xmath30 , respectively .
the global fraction of cooperators is then @xmath37 @xmath38 denotes the probability for a group to consist of only cooperators after assortment . in first order ,
only initially purely cooperative groups contribute to @xmath38 while all mixed groups are taken over by free - riders , such that @xmath39 if @xmath40 exceeds the initial fraction of cooperators , @xmath8 , the group - fixation mechanism is strong enough to overcome the advantage of free - riders .
as @xmath38 increases with the initial fraction of cooperators , there is an unstable fixed point @xmath41 , implicitly defined by @xmath42 in eq . :
for initial fractions , @xmath8 , above @xmath41 , a purely cooperative population is reached after several regrouping events .
in contrast , when starting below , @xmath43 , cooperators become extinct in the population . this bistable behavior
is illustrated in fig .
[ fig : phases ] where depending on the initial value @xmath8 the global fraction of cooperators is shown after a large regrouping time @xmath44 .
in contrast to the group - fixation mechanism , the group - growth mechanism acts for small times , where groups strongly grow . as cooperation enhances the growth speed of colonies , more cooperative groups have a larger weight in the average even though @xmath45 holds in each group .
depending on the parameters , this positive effect is able to compensate for the selection disadvantage of cooperators .
this can be quantified performing a van kampen expansion of the master equation , see supplementary information .
for binomial distributed groups , the change in the fraction of cooperators at time @xmath46 is given by , @xmath47x(1-x ) \ , .\ ] ] the first term accounts for the selection advantage of free - riders for the growth advantage of more cooperative groups while the second one reflects the growth advantage of more cooperative groups .
the initial change , @xmath48 , is larger if @xmath8 is small meaning that higher selection disadvantages can be overcome . under regrouping after time @xmath5 , the group - growth mechanisms results in a stable fixed point @xmath49 . as the group - growth mechanisms relies only on variance in group composition , but not on the existence of purely cooperative groups , it acts for much stronger population bottlenecks , @xmath4 , than the group - fixation mechanism does .
however , as it is caused by population growth it can only act for short regrouping times @xmath5 .
repeated regrouping corresponds to an iterative map .
the underlying dynamics ( group formation and group evolution ) result in an effective drift : @xmath50 .
depending on the strength of both mechanisms , and thus @xmath4 and @xmath5 , five distinct fixed point scenarios can be distinguished ; examples for the corresponding stability plots ( @xmath51 ) are shown in fig .
[ fig : phases ] . besides the discussed _
bistable _ [ only group - fixation ] and _ stable coexistence scenario _ [ only group - growth ] , there can be a _
bistable coexistence scenario _ [ group - growth and fixation mechanism ] .
in addition , there are the _ scenarios of only cooperation _ and _ only defection _ , where the sole stable fixed points are @xmath52 or @xmath53 , respectively . and
@xmath5 five different scenarios with different fixed point behaviors arise . for each scenario , we show an exemplary drift diagram on the right , where the change in the fraction of cooperators after one life - cycle is shown depending on the initial fraction of cooperators , @xmath54 .
dots correspond to simulation results of the transition points and the lines are guides to the eye to separate the different scenarios : pure cooperation with a stable fixed point at 1 , _
i.e. _ for a purely cooperative population ( @xmath55 , @xmath56 ) , coexistence with a stable fixed point at @xmath57 ( @xmath58 , @xmath59 ) , bistability with an unstable fixed point at @xmath57 ( @xmath60 , @xmath44 ) , bistable coexistence where both an stable and an unstable fixed point are present ( @xmath55 , @xmath61 ) and only free - riders .
the black square corresponds to the parameters studied in fig .
[ fig : traj ] ( @xmath62 ) .
other parameters are @xmath63 , @xmath64 , and @xmath65 .
[ fig : phases ] ] to this point we have seen that the internal dynamics on the intra - group level result in an effective drift for the iterative map , which can support cooperation .
we now want to examine whether this drift allows for the evolution of cooperation . in other words , we investigate if a single cooperative mutant can survive and spread in a free - riding population . in fig .
[ fig : traj ] we show two exemplary trajectories for the time evolution of the fraction of cooperators . the parameters @xmath66 and @xmath60 corresponds to the coexistence regime in fig .
[ fig : phases ] ( black square ) .
the simulations are performed by placing a single cooperative mutant in one of the @xmath67 groups ; this corresponds to an average initial fraction of cooperators of @xmath68 . in fig .
[ fig : traj ] * a * , a coexistence trajectory is shown while in fig .
[ fig : traj ] * b * cooperators go extinct at the fifth regrouping event ( @xmath69 )
. there are strong differences between these trajectories and the ones known from non - linear dynamics models without an iterative map which are commonly used to analyze coexistence scenarios : due to the dynamics during group - evolution , the fraction of cooperators does not only fluctuate slightly at the fixed point , but oscillates around it .
the reason is the interplay of the group - growth mechanism with the ensuing decline in the fraction of cooperators due to the selection disadvantage of cooperators in each group : after each regrouping event , the group growth mechanism causes an increase in the level of cooperators .
later on , when population growth slows down as groups are already close to their carrying capacity , the group - growth mechanism is not effective anymore .
thus , the fraction of cooperators declines due to their growth disadvantage within each group .
this dynamic pattern is then repeated in each life - cycle causing the oscillatory behavior .
but not only oscillations increase the variability , also demographic fluctuations are particularly strong .
the reason is that small variations in the fraction of cooperators are exponentially amplified during group growth .
therefore , for large times ( @xmath70 in fig . [
fig : traj ] * a * ) when the steady state is already reached the exact position of the maxima and minima in each life - cycle substantially varies between different regrouping events . in addition , also the regrouping mechanism increases the randomness , _
i.e _ due to the stochastic reformation of groups the fraction of cooperators can change during this process . in the inset of fig .
[ fig : traj ] * a * the first eight regrouping steps are magnified .
for instance during the second ( @xmath71 ) and fourth ( @xmath72 ) regrouping events a substantial drop in the fraction of cooperators is present , while for other regrouping events it is hardly changed .
this analysis already shows , that the question whether a single mutant can survive is much less trivial than suggested by the phase diagram [ fig .
[ fig : phases ] ] : mutants have to overcome two hampering factors which diminish the positive drift of the iterative map .
first , in each group free - riders are favored over cooperators due to the costs to produce the public goods @xmath28 : during group - evolution , the fraction of cooperators declines in each initially mixed group . thus if group - evolution was not interrupted by the formation of new groups
, cooperators would die out in those mixed groups .
therefore , in all parameter regimes ( including the ones with a stable cooperation fixed point ) the fixation probability of a free - rider is higher than the one of a cooperator during group - evolution .
second , even if cooperators have survived group - evolution , it is not assured that they survive regrouping as this process follows a random distribution . especially for small fractions of cooperators ,
cooperators die out more likely than free - riders during regrouping . taken together ,
it is not obvious whether the advantages of cooperators are sufficient to enable the evolution of cooperation from a single mutant . and @xmath60 , correspond to a point in the coexistence regime indicated by the black square in fig .
[ fig : phases ] . in panel
* a * a coexistence trajectory is shown , while panel * b * shows extinction of cooperators . for small times ( zoom in inset panel *
a * , and panel * b * ) cooperators have to survive a highly stochastic process : cooperators start with only one mutant , the population is subject to exponential growth which amplifies fluctuations , and regrouping events add an additional level of stochasticity .
in addition , also for larger times the trajectory oscillates around the fixed point ( for a detailed explanation see main text ) and is therefore prone to extinction .
[ fig : traj ] ] in the following we study this issue by analyzing the _ fixation probability _ @xmath73 , and the _ survival probability _ @xmath74 .
@xmath75 denotes the probability that a single cooperative mutant will take over the entire population , whereas @xmath76 is the probability that free - riders have not fixated yet in the population .
both probabilities are time - dependent , but reach quasi - stationary values under repeated regrouping , see supplementary information .
again starting with one cooperator , we performed stochastic simulations of the population dynamics , each realization with @xmath77 regrouping events . in fig .
[ fig : evol_prob ] , the probabilities @xmath74 ( panel * a * ) and @xmath73 ( panel * b * ) depending on @xmath4 are shown for different regrouping times @xmath5 . due to the life - cycle dynamics
the fixation behavior here is more intricate than for standard evolutionary dynamics . in those standard models ,
it is the population size only that determines the weight of fluctuations with respect to the deterministic drift @xcite . in the limit of large population sizes fluctuations become irrelevant and a stable fixed point is reached with absolute certainty . in contrast , for our life - cycle model , the stability diagram and the deterministic drift themselves depend on the initial population size @xmath4 : cooperators are less favored for higher values of @xmath4 . , and their fixation probability , @xmath73 , are shown after @xmath78 regrouping events .
interestingly both probabilities are fairly large over a large parameter regime .
different colors correspond to different regrouping times : @xmath79 , @xmath67 , number of realizations @xmath80 .
other parameters : @xmath63 , @xmath64 , @xmath65 .
black lines are calculated with our analytic approximation , eq . for @xmath81 ( solid ) and @xmath82 (
] for small @xmath4 , the regime of pure cooperation with a stable fixed point at @xmath52 is present , cf .
[ fig : phases ] . in accordance with that both fixation and survival probability are equal and fairly large . with increasing initial population sizes @xmath4 the strength of the group - growth mechanism is reduced and we observe a decline in the survival and fixation probabilities .
this decline is faster for larger regrouping times since cooperators stay longer in the evolution step and the thereby created selection disadvantage , @xmath83 , accumulates during the time interval @xmath84 $ ] .
further increasing initial groups sizes cause a steep drop in the fixation probability .
the reason is that upon increasing @xmath4 one is leaving the regime of pure cooperation , cf .
[ fig : phases ] red line .
hence , the fixation probability of cooperators dramatically declines . while the so far discussed fixation probabilities only depend quantitatively on the regrouping time @xmath5 , the survival probabilities are also qualitatively influenced by this parameter . for small @xmath5 ,
the system is in the coexistence regime which implies that cooperators neither fully take over the population nor die out easily .
thus the survival probability shows only a slow decay with @xmath4 in this regime .
in contrast , for larger regrouping times , the dynamics becomes unstable . because the dynamics start with a single cooperative mutant , the group - fixation mechanism is not efficient as it is unlikely that the threshold above which cooperators are favored is reached .
therefore , the survival probability declines rapidly with increasing @xmath4 .
let us finally discuss how the survival probabilities can be understood , based on analytic arguments . to this end ,
we approximate the dynamics by considering the first life - cycle only , _ i.e. _ the first group - evolution steps and the ensuing formation of new colonies .
as most extinction events of cooperators happen at the beginning , this approximation captures the extinction dynamics qualitatively correctly , see supplementary information .
the success of a cooperator crucially depends on the size of the group it is living in . for larger groups it has to compete with more free - riders and its survival chances are diminished .
as the group sizes are poisson - distributed , the probability that a cooperator emerges in a group of size @xmath85 is given by @xmath86 .
the probability that cooperators survive the first regrouping step is the probability that not all @xmath87 newly formed groups are purely free - riding . for a realization with a fraction of @xmath88 cooperators before regrouping , this probability is given by @xmath89 .
taken together this leads to the overall survival probability @xmath90 where @xmath91 denotes an average over all possible realizations . for large regrouping times
, cooperators die out in all initially mixed groups , _
i.e. _ @xmath92 for @xmath93 .
thus , the survival probability simplifies to @xmath94 , which is in perfect agreement with our simulation results ; see fig [ fig : evol_prob ] ( dashed black line ) . for smaller @xmath5 ,
the group - growth mechanism is dominant , and cooperators also survive in initially mixed groups leading to even higher values of the survival probabilities . for @xmath81 ,
where the group - growth mechanism results in a stable fixed point , we compare the approximation with the simulated survival probabilities and find good agreement ; cf .
fig [ fig : evol_prob ] ( solid black line ) . .
in panel * b * the impact of varying selection disadvantages is investigated for @xmath63 and @xmath60 . in panel * c * the survival probability for different values of @xmath27 scaling the growth advantage mediated by the public good is shown . even for small values of @xmath27
the group - growth mechanism is effective and support the onset of cooperation .
if not varied , @xmath60 and @xmath65 .
other parameters are as in fig .
[ fig : robust ] ] to further support the idea that ecological factors can explain the onset of cooperation , we study the robustness of our findings against changes of the model parameters .
in particular we vary @xmath27 scaling the benefit of the public good , and @xmath28 measuring the metabolic costs due to the production of a public good . in fig .
[ fig : robust ] , we show the survival probabilities for different regrouping times and @xmath60 depending on @xmath28 ( panel * b * ) and @xmath27 ( panel * c * ) . interestingly , already for comparably small values of @xmath27 the positive impact of a public good on the population size notably supports cooperation and thereby increases the survival probability .
in contrast increasing costs @xmath28 decrease the survival chances , but the benefits of cooperation are strong enough to compensate for selection disadvantages of up to 20@xmath95 .
in addition , we also demonstrate that our results do not depend on the assumption that the regrouping time is fixed . in fig .
[ fig : robust ] * a * , survival probabilities are shown for regrouping times exponentially distributed with @xmath96 according to @xmath97 $ ] .
again , the survival probabilities are fairly large and our conclusion that a simple life - cycle supports cooperators strong enough to overcome their selection disadvantages is not changed .
all in all , we therefore conclude that our results are robust against changes in the details of the parameters and model assumptions and thereby constitute a possible mechanisms enabling the onset of cooperation .
in this article , we studied the impact of ecological factors like population growth and population bottlenecks on the evolutionary dynamics of cooperating individuals .
our main findings can be subdivided into two blocks : first we analyzed the evolutionary dynamics acting on cooperators already abundant in a population , second we studied the survival chances of single mutants emerging in a purely non - cooperating environment . in the first part , we were employing our recently introduced model @xcite to study how a restructuring mechanism combined with typical growth conditions influences the evolutionary dynamics of public good producing bacteria .
depending on the inoculation size @xmath4 and the regrouping time @xmath5 , regimes of stable cooperation , coexistence between cooperators and free - riders and bistability emerge .
those regimes arise over a broad parameter regime even though the worst case scenarios for cooperators are assumed whenever model assumptions have to be made .
therefore , we believe that the mechanisms still apply in more realistic evolutionary scenarios where for example reassortment is not completely random or public goods are not equally distributed between all individuals @xcite . other studies focussing on different aspects of the interplay between evolution and ecological factors support our findings : for instance , the impact of exponential growth following bottlenecks in infinite populations was shown to support cooperators @xcite . in ref .
@xcite the competition between groups sharing a bounded global populations size and thereby competing for resources was investigated , while in ref .
@xcite the impact of mutations on the beneficial effects of population growth for groups starting with only one individual was studied .
in addition , also the frequency of ecological disturbance and resource supply plays a crucial role for the resulting level of cooperation @xcite .
furthermore , beneficial effects for cooperators were also found when reassortment is not random but environmental driven @xcite .
all studies emphasize the important role of ecological factors for understanding cooperation .
in contrast to the mentioned studies , we focussed on a description of bacterial growth , starting with an exponential growth phase reaching a carrying capacity later on .
the different growth regimes ( exponential growth and stationary state ) influence the evolutionary dynamics differently : both related mechanisms ( group - growth and group - fixation ) favor cooperators , but as confirmed by analytic arguments presented above , the strength of the group - growth mechanisms increases with small @xmath8 while the strength of group - fixation mechanism decreases .
therefore , both mechanisms can be associated with two different fixed point scenarios ( stable and unstable ) .
we present a full parameter study of the ensuing regimes of cooperation ( fully cooperative , coexistence , bistability , bistable coexistence and purely free - riding ) for both key parameters , @xmath4 and @xmath5 . in the second part of our paper we focussed on the question whether those beneficial mechanisms can also explain the onset of cooperation from a single mutant .
similar questions were extensively studied for evolutionary dynamics without regrouping where the factors influencing fixation probabilities for neutral , beneficial and deleterious mutations were investigated carefully , see e.g. @xcite
. however , the non - iterative map caused by regrouping makes a new study essential as it alters many aspects of the evolutionary dynamics . here
, we demonstrate that ecological factors increase the survival and fixation probabilities of cooperators substantially . in particular
, the group - growth mechanism allows for the robust establishment of cooperation as it does not rely on a threshold fraction of cooperators to act effectively .
remarkably , the probability for a single mutant to succeed decreases only slowly with increasing @xmath4 , and growth thus allows the onset of cooperation without the requirement of extremely narrow population bottlenecks . due to the robustness against parameter changes and the worst case assumptions employed ,
our model provides a proof of principle that ecological factors might explain the onset of cooperative behavior .
once cooperation is established in a population , more advanced mechanisms , which rely on cooperators already present in a population , like kin discrimination or other active forms of positive assortment , may evolve to further stabilize cooperative behavior , see _ e.g. _ @xcite .
we thank jan - timm kuhr for discussion . financial support by the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft through the priority program
phenotypic heterogeneity and sociobiology of bacterial populations " ( fr850/11 - 1 ) and the nano initiative munich ( nim ) is gratefully acknowledged .
calculations . 10 w. d. hamilton , `` the genetical evolution of social behaviour . i+ii , '' _ j.theor .
_ , vol . 7 , p. 1 , 1964 .
j. maynard smith , _ evolution and the theory of games_. cambridge : cambridge university press , 1982 .
s. okasha , _ evolution and the levels of selection_. oxford : oxford university press , 2006 .
m. a. nowak , `` five rules for the evolution of cooperation , '' _ science _
314 , p. 1560
, 2006 .
s. wright , `` evolution in mendelian populations , '' _ genetics _ ,
16 , pp . 97159 , 1931 .
a. traulsen and m. a. nowak , `` evolution of cooperation by multilevel selection , '' _ proc .
u. s. a. _ , vol .
103 , no .
29 , pp . 1095210955 , 2006 .
j. a. fletcher and m. doebeli , `` a simple and general explanation for the evolution of altruism , '' _ proc r soc lond b _ , vol .
276 , pp . 1319 , 2009 .
a. traulsen , `` mathematics of kin- and group - selection : formally equivalent ? , '' _ evolution _ , vol .
64 , pp . 316323 , 2009 .
t. julou , t. mora , l. guillon , v. croquette , i. j. schalk , d. bensimon , and n. desprat , `` cell - cell contacts confine public goods diffusion inside pseudomonas aeruginosa clonal microcolonies . , '' _ proceedings of the national academy of sciences _ , 2013 .
w. d. hamilton , `` the evolution of altruistic behavior , '' _ am .
_ , vol .
97 , pp . 35456 , 1963 .
j. maynard smith , `` group selection and kin selection , '' _ nature _ , vol . 4924 , p. 1145
, 1964 .
d. s. wilson , `` a theory of group selection , '' _ proc .
usa _ , vol .
72 , no . 1 , p. 143
, 1975 .
m. j. wade , `` an experimental study of group selection , '' _ evolution _ , vol .
31 , no . 1 ,
pp . 134153 , 1977 .
m. j. wade , `` a critical review of the models of group selection , '' _ the quarterly review of biology _ , vol .
53 , no . 2 , pp .
101114 , 1978 .
m. j. wade , `` group selection versus individual selection : an experimental analysis , '' _ evolution _ , vol .
36 , no . 2 , pp .
271282 , 1982 .
d. s. wilson , `` the group selection controversy : history and current stauts , '' _ ann rev ecol syst _ ,
14 , pp . 159186 , 1983 . c. j. goodnight , `` the influence of environmental variation on group and individual selection in a cress , '' _ evolution _ , vol
39 , no . 3 , pp .
545558 , 1985 .
e. sober and d. s. wilson , _ unto others : the evolution and psychology of unselfish behavior_. national academy press , washington , 1999 . j. fletcher and m. zwick , `` strong altruism can evolve in randomly formed groups , '' _
_ , vol . 228 , pp
303313 , jan 2004 .
t. killingback , j. bieri , and t. flatt , `` evolution in group - structured populations can resolve the tragedy of the commons , '' _ proc .
b _ , vol .
273 , p. 1477
, 2006 .
l. lehmann , l. keller , s. west , and d. roze , `` group selection and kin selection : two concepts but one process , '' _ proc .
u. s. a. _ , vol .
104 , no . 16 , pp .
67366739 , 2007 . j. a. fletcher and m. zwick , `` the evolution of altruism : game theory in multilevel selection and inclusive fitness , '' _ j. theor
_ , vol . 245 , pp
. 2636 , mar 2007 .
s. a. west , a. s. griffin , and a. gardner , `` social semantics : how useful has group selection been ?
_ j. evol .
_ , vol . 21 , pp . 374385 , nov 2007 . c. hauert and l. imhof ,
`` evolutionary games in deme structured , finite populations , '' _ j theo biol _ , vol .
299 , p. 106
, 2011 .
g. j. velicer , `` social strife in the microbial world , '' _ trends microbiol .
_ , vol . 11 , no . 7 , p. 330
, 2003 .
kreft and s. bonhoeffer , `` the evolution of groups of cooperating bacteria and the growth rate versus yield trade - off , '' _ microbiol . _ ,
151 , no . 3 , pp .
637641 , 2005 .
m. a. brockhurst , `` population bottlenecks promote cooperation in bacterial biofilms , '' _ plos one _ , vol . 2 , p. e634 , jan 2007 .
a. gardner and k. r. foster , _ the evolution and ecology of cooperation - history and concepts_. springer - verlag , 2008 .
j. gore , h. youk , and a. van oudenaarden , `` snowdrift game dynamics and facultative cheating in yeast , '' _ nature _ , vol .
459 , p. 253
, 2009 .
o. hallatschek , `` noise driven evolutionary waves , '' _ plos comput biol _ , vol
. 7 , p. e1002005 , 03 2011 .
a. buckling , f. harrison , m. vos , m. a. brockhurst , a. gardner , s. a. west , and a. griffin , `` siderophore - mediated cooperation and virulence in pseudomonas aeruginosa , '' _ fems microbiol .
_ , vol .
62 , no . 2 , p. 135
, 2007 .
s. p. diggle , a. s. griffin , g. s. campbell , and s. a. west , `` cooperation and conflict in quorum - sensing bacterial populations , '' _ nature _ , vol .
450 , pp . 411414 , 2007 .
l. hall - stoodley , j. w. costerton , and p. stoodley , `` bacterial biofilms : from the natural envrionment to infectious diseases , '' _ nat .
_ , vol . 2 , pp .
95108 , 2004 .
s. a. west , a. s. griffin , a. gardner , and s. p. diggle , `` social evolution theory for microorganisms , '' _ nat .
_ , vol . 4 , no . 8 , p. 597
, 2006 .
p. stoodley , k. sauer , d. g. davies , and j. w. costerton , `` biofilms as complex differentiated communities , '' _ ann .
_ , vol .
56 , pp . 187209 , 2002 .
a. s. griffin , s. a. west , and a. buckling , `` cooperation and competition in pathogenic bacteria , '' _ nature _ , vol .
430 , p. 1024
, 2004 .
j. s. chuang , o. rivoire , and s. leibler , `` simpson s paradox in a synthetic microbial system , '' _ science _
323 , pp . 272275 , 2009 .
j. s. chuang , o. rivoire , and s. leibler , `` cooperation and hamilton s rule in a simple synthetic microbial system , '' _ molec .
_ , vol . 6 , p. 398
, 2010 .
j. cremer , a. melbinger , and e. frey , `` growth dynamics and the evolution of cooperation in microbial populations , '' _ scientific reports _ , vol . 2 , p. 281
, 2012 .
t. garcia and s. de monte , `` group formation and the evolution of sociality , '' _ evolution _ , vol .
67 , no . 1 ,
pp . 131141 , 2013 .
m. kimura , _ the neutral theory of molecular evolution_. cambridge : cambridge university press , 1983 .
m. a. nowak , a. sasaki , c. taylor , and d. fudenberg , `` emergence of cooperation and evolutionary stability in finite populations , '' _ nature _ , vol .
428 , pp . 646650 , 2004 .
c. taylor , d. fudenberg , a. sasaki , and m. a. nowak , `` evolutionary game dynamics in finite populations , '' _ bull . math .
_ , vol .
66 , no . 6 , pp .
16211644 , 2004 .
a. traulsen , j. c. claussen , and c. hauert , `` coevolutionary dynamics : from finite to infinite populations , '' _ phys .
_ , vol .
95 , p. 238701
, 2005 .
a. traulsen , m. a. nowak , and j. m. pacheco , `` stochastic dynamics of invasion and fixation , '' _ phys .
74 , no . 1 , p. 011909
, 2006 .
l. a. imhof and m. a. nowak , `` evolutionary game dynamics in a wright - fisher process , '' _ journal of mathematical biolology _ , vol . 52 , pp . 667681 , 2006 .
t. antal and i. scheuring , `` fixation of strategies for an evolutionary game in finite populations , '' _ bull .
_ , vol . 68 , p. 1923 , 2006 .
j. cremer , t. reichenbach , and e. frey , `` the edge of neutral evolution in social dilemmas , '' _ new j. phys .
_ , vol . 11 , p. 093029
, 2009 .
t. l. parson , c. quince , and j. b. plotkin , `` some consequences of demographic stochasticity in population genetics , '' _ genetics _ , vol .
185 , pp . 13451354 , 2010 .
a. melbinger , j. cremer , and e. frey , `` evolutionary dynamics in growing populations , '' _ phys . rev
_ , vol . 105 , p. 178101
, 2010 .
j. cremer , a. melbinger , and e. frey , `` evolutionary and population dynamics : a coupled approach , '' _ phys .
e _ , vol .
84 , p. 051921
, 2011 .
j. monod , `` the growth of bacterial cultures , '' _ annu .
_ , vol . 3 , pp .
371394 , 1949 .
g. r. price , `` selection and covariance , '' _ nature _ , vol .
227 , p. 520
, 1970 .
m. a. brockhurst , a. buckling , and a. gardner , `` cooperation peaks at intermediate disturbance , '' _ curr .
_ , vol . 17 , no . 761 , 2007 . m. a. brockhurst , m. g. j. l. habets , b. libberton , a. buckling , and a. gardner , `` ecological drivers of the evolution of public - goods cooperation in bacteria , '' _ ecology _ , vol . 91 , no . 2 , pp .
334340 , 2010 .
j. w. pepper and b. smuts , `` a mechanism for the evolution of altruism among nonkin : positive assortment through environmental feedback , '' _ am .
_ , vol . 160 , no . 2 ,
20513 , 2002 . j. w. pepper , `` simple models of assortment through environmental feedback , '' _ artif . life _ , vol . 13 , no . 1 , pp .
19 , 2007 .
g. ichinose and t. arita , `` the role of migration and founder effect for the evolution of cooperation in a multilevel selection context , '' _ ecological modelling _
210 , no . 3 , pp . 221 230 , 2008 .
w. j. ewens , _ mathematical population genetics_. springer , 2nd .
m. kimura and t. ohta , `` the average number of generations until fixation of a mutant gene in a finite population , '' _ genetics _
61 , pp . 763771 , 1969 .
t. ohta , `` slightly deleterious mutant substitutions in evolution , '' _ nature _ , vol . 246 , p. 96
, 1973 .
d. queller , `` does population viscosity promote kin selection , '' _ trends ecol evol _ , vol . 7 , p. 322
, 1992 .
m. travisano and g. j. velicer , `` strategies of microbial cheater cotrol , '' _ trends microbiol . _ ,
12 , no . 2 , pp . 7277 , 2004 .
e. ostrowski , m. katoh , g. shaulsky , d. queller , and j. e. strassmann , `` kin discrimination increases with genetic distance in a social amoeba , '' _ plos biol .
_ , vol . 6 , no . 11 , p. e287 , 2008 .
r. kmmerli , a. s. griffin , s. a. west , a. buckling , and f. harrison , `` viscous medium promotes cooperation in the pathogenic bacterium pseudomonas aeruginosa , '' _ proc biol sci _
276 , p. 3531
, 2009 .
g. j. velicer and m. vos , `` sociobiology of the myxobacteria , '' _ annu .
_ , vol .
63 , pp .
599623 , 2009 .
* supporting information * in this supplementary material , we show how van kampen s system size expansion can be used to derive the initial slope of the fraction of cooperators , eq .
( 4 ) main text .
in addition , we present data which confirms the validity of eq .
( 4 ) and approximations made for the calculations shown in the main text .
as already described in the main text , the group growth mechanism is a fluctuation driven effect . to describe it
, we perform an omega expansion @xcite of the master equation ( me ) defined by the birth and death rates eqs .
( 1 ) ( main text ) .
the results obtained in this section hold for a fixed initial group size , where the random assortment only influences the composition but not the number of individual of a colony . in most of our simulations ( all except fig .
s1 ) , we use poisson distributed group sizes and fluctuations in the initial composition of a group are additionally enhanced by variation in group - size , see main text .
this full solution can be calculated by weighting the result for fixed colony sizes by a poisson distribution with mean , @xmath4 .
but as the important parameter dependences are already present when considering only binomial distributed groups and the expression are less lengthy , we focus on this simpler case in the following .
before we start with the calculations , we also want to make another comment .
normally , the condition for successfully performing the omega expansion , is a stable deterministic attractor .
however , here we do not want to analyze the resulting fokker - planck equation in detail , but only use it to determine an estimate of the strength of the group - growth mechanism at @xmath98 ( if the mechanism is not strong enough to overcome the selection pressure at the very beginning , it will also not happen later as fluctuations become smaller with increasing time ) .
therefore , the strict assumption of a stable fixed point can be relaxed , which leads to good results as we demonstrate at the end of this section .
the me describing the evolutionary dynamics is given by , @xmath99p(\!n_c\!,\!n_f\ ! ) , \label{eq : me}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath100 is the probability to find a group containing @xmath101 cooperators and @xmath102 free - riders .
the ladder operators @xmath103 are defined by @xmath104 .
now , within the van kampen system size expansion , the stochastic variables , @xmath101 and @xmath102 , are substituted by a linear combination of functions describing their rescaled means , @xmath105 and @xmath106 , and new stochastic variables , @xmath107 and @xmath108 , accounting for fluctuations , @xmath109 in this expressions fluctuations are already weighted according the well - known square root dependence on the population size @xcite which scales with the carrying capacity @xmath30 . employing eqs . in eq . and
expanding the resulting expression in the carrying capacity @xmath30 leads to the mean - field equations for @xmath105 and @xmath106 in order @xmath110 and a fokker - planck equation ( fpe ) for @xmath111 in higher orders . as the fpe is lengthy and does not contributed to the understanding of our calculation ,
we do no write it down explicitly here . in table
[ table ] , we summarize all changes arising with the substitution and the expansions which are used to transform the me to a fpe equation .
.[table]table summarizing the substitutions and expansions which are employed to transform the me into a fokker - planck equation .
the stochastic variable @xmath112 represents the fluctuations @xmath113 .
the means are either given by @xmath114 or @xmath115 and @xmath116 . [
cols="^,^",options="header " , ] and @xmath4 . the black line corresponds to the condition , .
the other parameters are @xmath117 and @xmath64.[fig : condition ] ] , when starting with a single mutant .
change occurs only during the first regrouping events .
lines show @xmath118 for different initial group sizes @xmath4 and fixed regrouping time @xmath81.[fig : time_course ] ] next , we analyze the mean values and second moments of the fluctuations
. they can be calculated by multiplying the fpe with the respective fluctuation variable and integrating over both , @xmath119 with @xmath120 . at time @xmath46 , the means of the fluctuations vanish according to the initial conditions @xmath121 .
thus the time evolution of the means is determined by only the second moments and given by , @xmath122 , \nonumber \\
\langle \dot \mu \rangle = & -\!\frac{rp(1+s)}{m_0\sqrt{k}}\left[(1\!-\!x_0)^2\langle\xi^2_0\rangle\!-\!2x_0(1\!-\!x_0)\langle\xi\mu_0\rangle\!+\!x_0 ^ 2\langle\mu_0 ^ 2\rangle\right ] , \nonumber\\ \label{eq : first } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we used @xmath123 and @xmath124 .
as the composition of each group is drawn from a binomial distribution , the variance of this distribution sets the initial condition for the second fluctuation moments , @xmath125 . employing this in eq
. leads to , @xmath126 the reason for the different signs of both differential equations is that the global growth rate @xmath127 is positively correlated with the fraction of cooperators @xmath88 while it is negatively correlated with the fraction of free - riders , @xmath128 .
hence , cooperators are favored by fluctuations . to compare the strength of this fluctuation driven mechanism with the deterministic selection disadvantage
, we analyze the average fraction of cooperators . to first order in @xmath129 , it is given by , @xmath130 differentiating this expression , neglecting higher order of @xmath83 and @xmath129 , and using eqs .
leads to , @xmath131 to confirm the validity of this calculation , we determine the parameter regime , in which the positive second term can overcome the selection disadvantage caused by cooperators @xmath132 .
this condition holds if , @xmath133 in fig .
[ fig : condition ] , we compare this condition to simulation data , for varying @xmath83 and @xmath4 .
we use the cooperation time , the time until the fraction of cooperators drops under its initial value , as a measure .
if the cooperation time is zero , the advantage due to fluctuations is not large enough to overcome the selection disadvantage , while for finite values of the cooperation time , the group - growth mechanism is sufficient to compensate for slower growth of cooperators . as shown in fig .
[ fig : condition ] , eq .
is in agreement with the position where the cooperation time vanishes .
note that the analytical solution derived before gives a lower bound for the the fluctuation driven enhancement of cooperation : we only take into account the initial fluctuations given by a binomial distribution .
in addition , demographic fluctuations further enhance cooperation , explaining the systematic shift in fig . s1 .
in fig . 3 in the main text , we show the extinction probabilities after 100 regrouping steps . here , we want to confirm that after this time , already a quasi stationary state is reached . in fig .
[ fig : time_course ] , the time evolution of the survival probability of cooperators is shown for exemplary parameters .
the data clearly shows that , as already mentioned in the body of this paper , the first regrouping steps mainly determine the fate of the population .
if a single cooperative mutant survives those first grouping events , its extinction probability almost vanishes . besides validating that
after @xmath134 regrouping steps already a quasi steady state is reached , the presented data also justifies our analytical approach to estimate survival probabilities based only on the first regrouping event . | cooperative behavior is widespread in nature , even though cooperating individuals always run the risk to be exploited by free - riders .
population structure effectively promotes cooperation given that a threshold in the level of cooperation was already reached .
however , the question how cooperation can emerge from a single mutant , which can not rely on a benefit provided by other cooperators , is still puzzling . here
, we investigate this question for a well - defined but generic situation based on typical life - cycles of microbial populations where individuals regularly form new colonies followed by growth phases .
we analyze two evolutionary mechanisms favoring cooperative behavior and study their strength depending on the inoculation size and the length of a life - cycle . in particular , we find that population bottlenecks followed by exponential growth phases strongly increase the survival and fixation probabilities of a single cooperator in a free - riding population . * the emergence of cooperation from a single mutant during microbial life - cycles * + + anna melbinger@xmath0 , jonas cremer@xmath1 , erwin frey@xmath2 + + * 1 * arnold sommerfeld center for theoretical physics and center for nanoscience , department of physics , ludwig - maximilians - universitt mnchen , germany + * 2 * department of physics , ucsd , 9500 gilman drive , la jolla , ca , usa + @xmath3 e - mail : [email protected] |
it is fair to say that the two - dimensional ising model has a very particular historical importance in statistical mechanics .
this model of ferromagnetism has been the first natural model where the existence of a phase transition , a property common to many statistical mechanics models , has been proved , in peierls 1936 work @xcite . in a series of seminal papers ( particularly @xcite ) ,
onsager computed several macroscopic quantities associated with this model .
since then , the ising model has attracted a lot of attention , and it has probably been one of the most studied models , giving birth to an extensive literature , both mathematical and physical .
a few decades later , in 1969 , fortuin and kasteleyn introduced a dependent percolation model , for which the probability of a configuration is weighted by the number of clusters ( connected components ) that it contains .
this percolation representation turned out to be extremely powerful to study the ising model , and by now it has become known as the _ random - cluster _ model , or the _ fortuin - kasteleyn percolation _ _ fk percolation _ for short .
recall that on a finite graph @xmath0 , the fk percolation process with parameters @xmath1 is obtained by assigning to each configuration @xmath2 a probability proportional to @xmath3 where @xmath4 , @xmath5 , and @xmath6 denote respectively the number of open edges , closed edges , and connected components in @xmath2 .
the definition of the model also involves the use of _ boundary conditions _ , encoding connections taking place outside @xmath0 .
the boundary conditions can be seen as a set of additionnal edges between sites on the outer boundary , and they will play a central role in this article . the precise setup that we consider in this paper is presented in section 2 . for the specific value @xmath7 , the fk percolation provides a _ geometric representation _ of the ising model _ via _ the _ edwards - sokal coupling _ @xcite . for this reason ,
we restrict ourselves here to this value @xmath7 , and we call this model the _ fk ising model_. we also stick to the square lattice @xmath8 or subgraphs of it though our arguments could possibly be carried out in the more general context of isoradial graphs , as in @xcite . note that our results are stated for the fk representation , but that the edwards - sokal coupling then allows one to translate them into results for the ising model itself .
for instance , 2-point connection probabilities for the fk ising model correspond via this coupling to 2-spin correlation functions for the ising model . for the value @xmath7 and @xmath8 as an underlying graph ,
the model features a phase transition in the infinite - volume limit at the critical and self - dual point @xmath9 : for @xmath10 , there is a.s . no infinite open cluster , while for @xmath11 , there is a.s . a unique one .
these two regimes , known as sub - critical and super - critical , have totally different macroscopic behaviors . between them
lies a very interesting and rich regime , the critical regime , corresponding to the value @xmath12 .
its behavior is intimately related to the behavior of the model through its phase transition , as indicated in particular by the scaling theory . in this paper , we prove lower and upper bounds for crossing probabilities in rectangles of bounded aspect ratio . these bounds are uniform in the size of the rectangles and in the boundary conditions , and they are analogues for the fk ising model to the celebrated russo - seymour - welsh bounds for percolation @xcite .
formally , we consider _ rectangles _ @xmath13 on the square lattice , @xmath14 for @xmath15 , and translations of it here and in the following , @xmath16 denotes the integer interval between the two ( real ) end - points , _ i.e. _ the interval @xmath17 \cap \mathbb{z}^2 $ ] .
we denote by @xmath18 the event that there exists a _ vertical crossing _ in @xmath13 , a path from the bottom side @xmath19 to the top side @xmath20 which consists only of open edges .
our main result is the following : [ rsw ] let @xmath21 .
there exist two constants @xmath22 ( depending only on @xmath23 and @xmath24 ) such that for any rectangle @xmath13 with side lengths @xmath25 and @xmath26 ( _ i.e. _ with aspect ratio bounded away from @xmath27 and @xmath28 by @xmath23 and @xmath24 ) , one has @xmath29 for _ any _ boundary conditions @xmath30 , where @xmath31 denotes the fk measure on @xmath13 with parameters @xmath32 and boundary conditions @xmath30 .
these bounds are in some sense a first glimpse of scale invariance .
it was widely believed in the physics literature that the fk ising model at criticality , _
i.e. _ for @xmath12 , should possess a strong property of conformal invariance in the scaling limit @xcite .
a precise mathematical meaning was recently established by smirnov in a groundbreaking paper @xcite .
one of the main tools there is the so - called _ preholomorphic fermionic observable _ , a complex observable that allows one to make appear harmonicity on the discrete level .
this property can then be used to take continuum limits and describe the scaling limits so - obtained .
our proof mostly relies on smirnov s observable .
more precisely , it is based on precise estimates on connection probabilities for boundary vertices , that allow us to use a second - moment method on the number of pairs of connected sites . for that
, we use smirnov s observable to reveal some harmonicity on the discrete level , which enables us to express macroscopic quantities such as connection probabilities in terms of discrete harmonic measures . note in addition that other recent works @xcite also suggest that this complex observable is a relevant way to look at fk percolation , both for @xmath7 and for other values of @xmath33 .
we would like to stress that our argument is intended to be self - contained and that it stays completely in a discrete setting , using essentially elementary combinatorial tools : in particular , we do not make use of any continuum limits @xcite .
crossing bounds turned out to be instrumental to study the percolation model at and near its phase transition for instance to derive the _ scaling relations _
@xcite , that link the main macroscopic observables , such as the density of the infinite cluster and the characteristic length .
these bounds are also useful to study variations of percolation , in particular for models exhibiting a self - organized critical behavior .
we thus expect theorem [ rsw ] to be of particular interest to study the fk ising model at and near criticality .
this theorem allows us to derive easily several noteworthy results . among the consequences that we state ,
let us mention the celebrated fact that there is no magnetization at criticality for the ising model , first established by onsager in @xcite , tightness results for the interfaces coming from the aizenman - burchard technology , and the value @xmath34 of the one - arm half - plane exponent that describes the asymptotic probability of large - distance connections starting from a boundary point , and also the decay of boundary magnetization in the ising model .
it should also be instrumental to prove the existence of critical exponents , in particular of the _ arm exponents_. theorem [ rsw ] appears to be a very useful tool , enabling to transfer properties of the scaling limit objects back to the discrete models .
connections between discrete models and their continuum counterparts usually involve decorrelation of different scales , and thus use spatial independence between regions which are far enough from each other . in the random cluster model
, one usually addresses the lack of spatial independence by successive conditionings , using repeatedly the spatial ( or domain ) markov property of fk percolation , by which what happens outside a given domain can be encoded by appropriate boundary conditions . for this reason
, proving bounds that are _ uniform in the boundary conditions _ seems to be very important .
we would also like to mention that other proofs of russo - seymour - welsh - type bounds have already been proposed . in @xcite ,
chelkak and smirnov give a direct and elegant argument to explicitly compute the crossing probabilities in the scaling limit , but their argument only applies for some specific boundary conditions ( alternatively wired and free on the four sides ) . in @xcite ,
camia and newman also propose to obtain rsw as a corollary of a recently announced result : the convergence of the full collection of interfaces for the ising model @xcite to the conformal loop ensemble cle(3 ) .
the interpretation of cle(3 ) in terms of the brownian loop soup @xcite is also used . however , to the author s knowledge , the proofs of these two results are quite involved , and moreover , the reasoning proposed only applies for boundary conditions `` in the bulk '' , that correspond to the infinite - volume limit . in these two cases , uniformity with respect to the boundary conditions is not addressed , and there does not seem to be an easy argument to avoid this difficulty . while weaker forms might be sufficient for some applications
, it seems however that this stronger form is needed in many important cases , and that it considerably shortens several existing arguments .
the paper is organized as follows . in section 2
, we first remind the reader of the basic features of the fk percolation , as well as properties of smirnov s fermionic observable . in section 3
, we compare the observable to harmonic measures , and we establish some estimates on these harmonic measures .
these estimates are instrumental in the proof of theorem [ rsw ] , which we perform in section 4 .
finally , section 5 is devoted to presenting the consequences that we mentioned .
in order to remain as self - contained as possible , we recall some basic features of the random - cluster models . some of these properties , like the fortuin - kasteleyn - ginibre ( fkg ) inequality , are common to many statistical mechanics models .
the reader can consult the reference book @xcite for more details , and proofs of the results stated . the random - cluster ( or _ fk percolation _
) measure can be defined on any finite graph , but here we only consider finite subgraphs @xmath0 of the square lattice @xmath35 .
we denote by @xmath36 the boundary of such a subgraph @xmath0 , that is , the vertices having _ less than four adjacent edges _ notice that this definition is non standard .
a _ configuration _
@xmath2 is a random subgraph given by the vertices of @xmath0 , together with some subset of edges between them .
an edge of @xmath0 is called _ open _ if it belongs to @xmath2 , and _ closed _ otherwise . two sites
@xmath37 and @xmath38 are said to be _ connected _ if there is an _
open path _ a path composed of open edges only connecting them , which is denoted by @xmath39 .
similarly , two sets of vertices @xmath40 and @xmath41 are said to be connected if there exist two sites @xmath42 and @xmath43 such that @xmath44 , and we use the notation @xmath45 .
we also abbreviate @xmath46 as @xmath47 .
sites can be grouped into ( maximal ) connected components , usually called _
contrary to usual independent percolation , the edges in the fk percolation model are dependent of each other , a fact which makes the notion of _ boundary conditions _ important .
formally , a set @xmath30 of boundary conditions is a set of `` abstract '' edges , each connecting two boundary vertices , that encodes how these vertices are connected outside @xmath0 .
we denote by @xmath48 the graph obtained by adding the new edges in @xmath30 to the configuration @xmath2 .
we are now in a position to define the fk percolation measure itself , for any parameters @xmath49 $ ] and @xmath50 . denoting by @xmath4 ( resp .
@xmath5 ) the number of open ( resp . closed ) edges of @xmath2 , and by @xmath51 the number of connected components in @xmath48 , the fk percolation process on @xmath0 with parameters @xmath52 , @xmath33 and boundary conditions @xmath30 is obtained by taking @xmath53 as a probability for any configuration @xmath2 on @xmath0 , where @xmath54 is an appropriate normalizing constant , called the _ partition function_. among all the possible boundary conditions , two of them play a particular role . on the one hand ,
the _ free _ boundary conditions correspond to the case when there are no extra edges connecting boundary vertices , we denote by @xmath55 the corresponding measure . on the other hand , the _ wired _
boundary conditions correspond to the case when all the boundary vertices are pair - wise connected , and the corresponding measure is denoted by @xmath56 .
the different edges of an fk percolation model being highly dependent , what happens in a given domain depends on the configuration outside the domain
. however , the fk percolation model possesses a very convenient property known as the _ domain markov property _ , which usually makes it possible to obtain some spatial independence .
this property is really instrumental in all our proofs .
consider a graph @xmath0 , with @xmath57 its set of vertices .
for a subset @xmath58 , consider the graph @xmath59 having @xmath60 as a set of vertices , and the edges of @xmath0 connecting sites of @xmath60 as a set of edges .
then for any boundary conditions @xmath61 , @xmath62 conditioned to match some configuration @xmath2 outside @xmath0 is equal to @xmath63 , where @xmath30 is the set of connections inherited from @xmath2 . in other words , one can encode , using appropriate boundary conditions @xmath30 , the influence of the configuration outside @xmath0 . the random - cluster model with parameters
@xmath49 $ ] and @xmath64 on a finite graph @xmath0 has the _ strong positive association property_. more precisely , it satisfies the so - called holley criterion , a fact which has two important consequences .
a first consequence is the well - known _ fkg inequality _
@xmath65 for any pair of _ increasing _ events @xmath66 , @xmath67 ( increasing events are defined in the usual way @xcite ) and any boundary conditions @xmath30 .
this correlation inequality is fundamental to study fk percolation , for instance to combine several increasing events such as the existence of crossings in various rectangles .
a second property implied by the strong positive association is the following monotonicity between boundary conditions , which is particularly useful when combined with the domain markov property .
for any boundary conditions @xmath68 ( all the connections present in @xmath61 belong to @xmath30 as well ) , we have @xmath69 for any increasing event @xmath66 that depends only on @xmath0 .
we say that @xmath62 is stochastically dominated by @xmath70 ( denoted by @xmath71 ) .
in particular , this property directly implies that the free and wired boundary conditions are extremal in the sense of stochastic ordering : for any set of boundary conditions @xmath30 , one has @xmath72 an infinite - volume measure can be constructed as the increasing limit of fk percolation measures on the nested sequence of graphs @xmath73 with free boundary conditions .
for any fixed @xmath50 , classical arguments then show that there must exist a critical point @xmath74 such that for any @xmath75 , there is almost surely no infinite cluster of sites , while for @xmath76 , there is almost surely one ( see @xcite for example ) . in two dimensions , an fk measure on a subgraph @xmath0 of @xmath8 with free boundary conditions can be associated with a dual measure in a natural way , as we explain now .
the dual graph @xmath77 is obtained by putting a vertex at the center of each face of @xmath8 having an edge in @xmath0 .
the edges are connecting any two adjacent vertices for which the corresponding faces are separated by an edge of @xmath0 .
the fk percolation model @xmath78 is then dual to the measure @xmath79 , where @xmath80 satisfies @xmath81 one then expects the critical point @xmath82 to be the self - dual point @xmath83 for which @xmath84 , whose value can easily be derived : @xmath85 for the value @xmath7 of the parameter , the fk percolation model is related to the ising model .
more precisely , if starting from an fk percolation sample , one assigns uniformly at random a spin @xmath86 or @xmath87 to each cluster as a whole ( sites in the same cluster get the same spin ) , independently , we get simply a sample of the ising model .
this coupling is called the _ edwards - sokal coupling _ @xcite . in this case , the fk percolation model is now well - understood .
the value @xmath88 is implied by the computation by kaufman and onsager @xcite of the partition function of the ising model , and an alternative proof has been proposed recently by beffara , duminil - copin and smirnov @xcite . moreover , in @xcite , smirnov proved conformal invariance of this model at the self - dual point @xmath89 . in the following ,
we restrict ourselves to the fk percolation model with parameters @xmath7 and @xmath90 ( so that we forget the dependence on @xmath52 and @xmath33 ) , which is also known as the _ critical fk ising model _
we often call it the fk ising model for short .
in this part , we recall discrete analyticity and discrete harmonicity results for the fk ising model , established by smirnov in @xcite .
these results are crucial in our proofs since they will allow us to compare connection probabilities to harmonic measures .
_ recall that from now , @xmath7 and @xmath91_. let @xmath92 be a _
finite _ subgraph of the primal lattice @xmath8 such that @xmath93 is a self - avoiding polygon where @xmath94 is the set of edges between boundary sites .
hence , @xmath95 , the connected component of @xmath96 containing the graph , is a bounded and simply connected domain .
consider two sites @xmath97 and @xmath98 of the boundary of @xmath92 .
they determine two arcs of @xmath99 , @xmath100 and @xmath101 , obtained by following @xmath94 in the counterclockwise direction from @xmath97 to @xmath98 , and conversely .
we consider a random cluster measure with free boundary conditions on @xmath100 , and wired boundary conditions on @xmath101 .
these boundary conditions are called the _ dobrushin boundary conditions _ on @xmath102 , @xmath100 is called the _
free _ arc and @xmath101 the _ wired arc_.
we denote by @xmath103 the associated random cluster measure with parameters @xmath7 and @xmath91 .
this measure has a very nice representation on the so - called medial graph of @xmath92 , which we define now .
we first define the _ medial lattice _ associated with the square lattice @xmath8 . in order to do that , consider together @xmath8 with its dual @xmath104 , and declare _ black _ the sites of the primal lattice @xmath8 , and _ white _ the sites of the dual lattice @xmath104 .
we then introduce the graph obtained by replacing every site by a colored diamond , as on figure [ fig : medial_lattice ] .
we obtain in this way a rotated copy of the square lattice ( scaled by a factor @xmath105 ) , denoted by @xmath106 .
the sites of the primal ( resp .
dual ) lattice are thus associated with the black ( resp .
white ) faces : we use extensively in the proof this correspondence between sites of the primal and of the dual lattices , and faces of the medial lattice .
for instance , we say that two black diamonds are connected if the corresponding sites of the primal lattice are connected .
a domain @xmath92 with dobrushin boundary conditions : the vertices of the primal graph are black , the vertices of the dual graph @xmath107 are white , and between them lies the medial lattice @xmath108.,width=321 ] we construct the _ medial graph _
@xmath108 of @xmath102 by considering the diamonds intersecting @xmath95 , together with the white diamonds touching the free arc @xmath101 ( see figure [ fig : medial_lattice ] ) .
these white diamonds form the _ free arc _ of @xmath108 , the black diamonds corresponding to sites of the wired arc of @xmath92 form the _ wired arc _ of @xmath108 .
the corners of diamonds _ not belonging _ to the two arcs of @xmath108 define the _ vertices _ of @xmath108 .
the _ edges _ are the edges of @xmath106 between two vertices .
we adopt the following convenient convention : the two edges @xmath109 and @xmath110 of @xmath106 ( resp .
adjacent to @xmath97 and @xmath98 ) that `` separate '' the free and the wired arcs of @xmath108 are considered as edges of @xmath108 .
the two definitions of arcs ( for @xmath92 and @xmath108 ) are quite similar .
nevertheless , the free arc of @xmath92 is composed of sites of @xmath8 while the free arc of @xmath108 is composed of white diamonds of @xmath108 .
moreover , vertices of @xmath108 possess two adjacent edges if they are `` on the boundary '' ( except next to @xmath97 and @xmath98 ) , and four otherwise .
for any fk percolation configuration in @xmath92 , the interfaces between the primal clusters and the dual clusters ( if we follow the edges of the medial lattice ) form a family of loops , together with one path from @xmath109 to @xmath110 , called the _ exploration path _ , as shown on figure [ fig : loop_configuration ] .
a simple rearrangement of ( [ def_fk ] ) shows that the probability of such a configuration is proportional to @xmath111 taking into account the fact that @xmath7 and @xmath112 .
in addition to this , we put an orientation on the medial graph : we orient the edges of each black face in such a way that the arrows are in counter - clockwise order
. it naturally gives an orientation to the loops , so that we are now working with a model of oriented curves on the medial lattice .
if we consider a dobrushin domain @xmath102 , the slit domain created by `` removing '' the @xmath113 first steps of the exploration path is again a dobrushin domain .
more precisely , consider the new arc @xmath114 composed of @xmath93 , together with the sites of @xmath92 adjacent to the exploration path .
we can define a new domain by removing all the sites of @xmath92 which are not in the same connected component of @xmath115 as @xmath98 : we obtain a new dobrushin domain @xmath116,\gamma(t),b)$ ] , where , with a slight abuse of notation , @xmath117 is used to denote the site of the primal lattice adjacent to the medial edge @xmath117 .
the exploration path @xmath118 is the interface between the primal open cluster connected to the wired arc and the dual open cluster connected to the free arc , so that , conditionally on @xmath118 , the law of the fk ising model in the new domain is exactly @xmath119,\gamma(t),b}$ ] .
this observation will be instrumental in our proof .
an fk percolation configuration in the dobrushin domain @xmath102 , together with the corresponding interfaces on the medial lattice : the loops in grey , and the exploration path @xmath118 from @xmath109 to @xmath110 in black.,width=302 ] let @xmath120 be a dobrushin domain and @xmath121 the exploration path from @xmath109 to @xmath110 .
the _ winding _ @xmath122 of a curve @xmath123 between two edges @xmath124 and @xmath125 of the medial lattice is the total rotation ( in radians ) that the curve makes from the center of the edge @xmath124 to the center of the edge @xmath125 .
the _ fermionic observable _ @xmath60 can now be defined by the formula @xcite @xmath126,\ ] ] for any edge @xmath127 of the medial lattice @xmath108 .
the constant @xmath128 appearing in front of the winding is called the _ spin _
( see @xcite ) .
the quantity @xmath129 is a complexified version of the probability that @xmath127 belongs to the exploration path ( note that it is defined on the medial graph @xmath108 ) .
the complex weight makes the link between @xmath60 and probabilistic properties less explicit .
nevertheless , as we will see , the winding term can be controlled close to the boundary .
the observable @xmath60 also satisfies the following local relation , from which propositions [ definitionh ] and [ subsupharm ] follow .
[ cauchy - riemann ] for any vertex @xmath130 of the medial lattice @xmath131 with _ four adjacent edges _ in @xmath108 , the relation @xmath132 is satisfied , where @xmath133 , @xmath134 , @xmath135 and @xmath136 are the four edges at @xmath130 indexed in clockwise order , as on figure [ fig : cauchy_riemann ] . the discrete relation at a vertex @xmath130.,width=113 ] we refer to @xcite or @xcite for the proof of this result .
the key ingredient is a bijection between configurations that contribute to the values of @xmath60 at the vertices around @xmath130 .
note that for other values of @xmath33 , one can still define the fermionic observable in a way similar to eq.([observable_f ] ) : for an appropriate value @xmath137 of the spin , the previous relation eq.([eq : cauchy_riemann ] ) still holds ( see @xcite , @xcite , or @xcite ) .
due to the specific value of the spin @xmath128 , corresponding to the value @xmath7 , the complex argument modulo @xmath139 of the fermionic observable @xmath60 follows from its definition eq.([observable_f ] ) .
for instance , if the edge @xmath127 points in the same direction as the starting edge @xmath109 , then the winding is a multiple of @xmath140 , so that the term @xmath141 is equal to @xmath142 , and @xmath129 is purely real .
the same reasoning can be applied to any edge to show that it belongs to the line @xmath143 , @xmath144 or @xmath145 depending on its direction .
contrary to lemma [ cauchy - riemann ] , this property is very specific to the fk ising model . for a vertex @xmath130 with _ four _ adjacent edges , keeping the same notations as in the previous subsection , @xmath146 and @xmath147 are always orthogonal ( for the scalar product between complex numbers @xmath148 ) , as well as @xmath149 and @xmath150 , so that eq.([eq : cauchy_riemann ] ) can be rewritten as @xmath151 consider now a vertex @xmath130 with _ two _ adjacent edges of @xmath108 , and denote by @xmath152 the `` entering '' edge , and @xmath153 the `` exiting '' edge .
such a vertex must be on the boundary of the domain , and @xmath152 belongs to @xmath121 if and only if @xmath153 belongs to @xmath121 indeed , by construction , the curve entering through @xmath152 must leave through @xmath153 . moreover , the windings of the curve @xmath154 and @xmath155 are constant since @xmath121 can not wind around these edges . from these two facts ,
we deduce : @xmath156 ) and ( [ relationh2 ] ) , one can easily prove the following proposition .
[ definitionh]there exists a _ unique function _ @xmath138 defined on the faces of @xmath131 by the relation @xmath157 for any two neighboring faces @xmath67 and @xmath158 , respectively black and white , separated by the edge @xmath127 , and by fixing the value @xmath159 on the black face corresponding to @xmath97 .
moreover , @xmath138 is then automatically equal to @xmath159 on the black diamonds of the wired arc , and equal to @xmath27 on the white diamonds of the free arc .
this function @xmath138 is a discrete analogue of the antiderivative of @xmath160 , as explained in remark 3.7 of @xcite .
let us denote by @xmath161 and @xmath162 the restrictions of @xmath138 respectively to the black faces and to the white faces .
for a black site of @xmath92 not on the boundary , we can consider the usual _ discrete laplacian _
( on the graph @xmath92 ) at this site : it is the average on the four nearest black neighbors , minus the value at the site itself .
a similar definition holds for white sites of the graph @xmath107 . the result below , proved in @xcite , is a key step to prove convergence of the observable as one scales the domain but we will not discuss this question here .
its proof relies on an elementary yet quite lengthy computation .
[ subsupharm ] the function @xmath161 ( resp .
@xmath162 ) is _ subharmonic _ ( resp . _ superharmonic _ ) inside the domain for the discrete laplacian . since we know that @xmath138 is equal to @xmath159 ( resp .
@xmath27 ) on the black diamonds of the wired arc ( resp .
the white diamonds of the free arc ) , the previous proposition can be seen as an approximate dirichlet problem for the function @xmath138 . in the next section , we make this statement rigorous by comparing @xmath138 to harmonic functions corresponding to the same boundary problems ( on the set of black faces , or on the set of white ones ) .
in this section , we obtain a comparison result for the boundary values of the fermionic observable @xmath60 introduced in the previous section in terms of discrete harmonic measures .
it will be used to obtain all the quantitative estimates on the observable that we need for the proof of theorem [ rsw ] . as in the previous section ,
let @xmath163 be a discrete dobrushin domain , with free boundary conditions on the counterclockwise arc from @xmath97 to @xmath98 and wired boundary conditions on the counterclockwise arc from @xmath98 to @xmath97 . for our estimates , we first extend the medial graph of our discrete domain by adding two extra layers of faces : one layer of white diamonds adjacent to the black diamonds of the sites of the wired arc , and one layer of black diamonds adjacent to the white diamonds of the free arc .
we denote by @xmath164 this extended domain .
note that one faces a small technicality when adding a new layer of diamonds : some of these additional diamonds can overlap diamonds that were already here . for instance , if the domain has a slit , the free and the wired arc are adjacent along this slit , and the extra layer on the wired arc ( resp .
free arc ) overlaps the free arc ( resp . wired arc ) .
as we will see , @xmath161 is equal to @xmath159 on the wired arc , and to @xmath27 on the additional layer along the free arc . one
should thus remember in the following that the added diamonds are considered as different from the original ones it will always be clear from the context which diamonds we are considering .
for any given black face @xmath67 , let us define @xmath165 to be the continuous - time random walk on the black faces of @xmath164 starting at @xmath67 , that jumps with rate @xmath159 on adjacent black faces , _ except _ for the black faces on the extra layer of black diamonds adjacent to the free arc onto which it jumps with rate @xmath166 .
similarly , we denote by @xmath167 the continuous - time random walk on the white faces of @xmath164 starting at a white face @xmath158 that jumps with rate @xmath159 on adjacent white faces , _ except _ for adjacent white faces on the extra layer of white diamonds adjacent to the wired arc onto which it jumps with the same rate @xmath168 as previously . for a black face @xmath67
, we denote by @xmath169 the probability that the random walk @xmath170 hits the wired arc from @xmath98 to @xmath97 before hitting the extra layer adjacent to the free arc .
similarly , for @xmath158 a white face , we denote by @xmath171 the probability that the random walk @xmath172 hits the additional layer adjacent to the wired arc before hitting the free arc .
note that there is no extra difficulty in defining these quantities for infinite discrete domains as well .
we have the following result : [ uniform comparability ] let @xmath163 be a discrete dobrushin domain . for any medial edge @xmath127 adjacent to a boundary edge of the free arc ,
if we denote by @xmath173 the black face that it borders and by @xmath174 any closest white face that is _ not _ on the free arc , we have @xmath175 by construction of the function @xmath138 , we have @xmath176 and @xmath177 , where @xmath178 is the medial edge between @xmath67 and @xmath158 : it is therefore sufficient to show that @xmath179 and @xmath180 .
we only prove that @xmath181 , since the other case can be handled in the same way . for this , we use a variation of a trick introduced in @xcite and extend the function @xmath138 to the extra layer of black diamonds added as explained above by setting @xmath138 to be equal to @xmath27 there .
it is then sufficient to show that the restriction @xmath161 of @xmath138 to the black diamonds of @xmath164 is subharmonic for the laplacian that is the generator of the random walk @xmath182 , since it has the same boundary values as @xmath183 . inside the domain , this is given by proposition [ subsupharm ] , since there the laplacian is the usual discrete laplacian ( associated with it is just a simple random walk ) .
the only thing to check is when a face involved in the computation of the laplacian belongs to one of the extra layers . for the sake of simplicity , we study the case when only one face belongs to these extra layers .
we extend @xmath131 by adding two extra layers of medial faces , and extend the functions @xmath161 and @xmath162 there .
here is represented the extension along the free arc.,width=188 ] denote by @xmath184 , @xmath185 , @xmath186 and @xmath187 the black faces adjacent to @xmath67 , and assume that @xmath187 is on the extra layer ( see figure [ fig : comparison ] ) .
the discrete laplacian of @xmath182 at face @xmath67 is denoted by @xmath188 .
we claim that @xmath189+\frac{2\sqrt{2}}{6 + 5\sqrt{2}}h_{\bullet}(b_s)-h_{\bullet}(b)\geq 0.\]]for that , let us denote by @xmath190 the four medial edges at the bottom vertex @xmath130 between @xmath67 and @xmath187 , in clockwise order , with @xmath133 and @xmath134 along @xmath67 , and @xmath135 and @xmath136 along @xmath187 ( see figure [ fig : comparison ] ) note that @xmath135 and @xmath136 are not edges of @xmath108 , but of @xmath106 .
we extend @xmath60 to @xmath135 and @xmath136 by requiring @xmath147 and @xmath146 to be orthogonal , as well as @xmath150 and @xmath149 , and @xmath191 to hold true .
this defines these two values uniquely : indeed , as noted before , we know that @xmath192 on the boundary ( since @xmath193 and @xmath194 are fixed , with @xmath195 , and the curve can not go through one of these edges without going through the other one ) , which implies , after a small calculation , that @xmath196 if we denote by @xmath197 the function defined by @xmath198 on @xmath67 , @xmath184 , @xmath185 and @xmath186 , and by @xmath199 then @xmath197 satisfies the same relation eq.([def_h ] ) ( definition of @xmath138 ) for @xmath135 and @xmath136 , as inside the domain . since the fermionic observable @xmath60 verifies the same local equations ,
the computation performed in the appendix c of @xcite is valid , proposition [ subsupharm ] applies at @xmath67 , and we deduce @xmath200-\tilde{h}_{\bullet}(b)\geq 0.\ ] ] using the definition of @xmath197 , this inequality can be rewritten as @xmath201-\frac{6 + 5\sqrt{2}}{4(2+\sqrt{2})}h_{\bullet}(b)\geq 0.\ ] ] now using that @xmath202 , we get the claim , eq.([modified_laplacian ] ) . in the previous subsection
, we gave a comparison principle between the values of @xmath138 near the boundary , and the harmonic measures associated with two ( almost simple ) random walks , on the two lattices composed of the black faces and of the white faces respectively .
in this subsection , we give estimates for these two harmonic measures in different domains needed for the proof of theorem [ rsw ] .
we start by giving a lower bound which is useful in the proof of the 1-point estimate .
[ 2 points estimate ] for @xmath203 and @xmath204 , let @xmath205 be the graph @xmath206 then there exists @xmath207 such that for any @xmath208 , @xmath209 in the dobrushin domain @xmath210 ( see figure [ fig : example ] ) , for all @xmath211 and @xmath212 such that @xmath213 ( _ i.e. _ far enough from the corners ) , @xmath214 being any of the two white faces that are both adjacent to @xmath37 and not on the free arc .
this proposition follows from standard results on simple random walks ( the local central limit theorem and gambler s ruin type estimates ) . for the sake of conciseness
, we do not provide a detailed proof .
estimate of lemma [ 2 points estimate ] : the dashed line corresponds to the free arc.,width=226 ] in the remaining of the section , we consider _ only _ dobrushin domains @xmath102 that _ contain the origin _ on the free arc , and are _ subsets _ of the medial lattice @xmath215 , where @xmath216 denotes the upper half plane in this case , we say that _
@xmath92 is a dobrushin @xmath217-domain_. for the following estimates on harmonic measures , the dobrushin domains that we consider can also be infinite .
we are interested in the harmonic measure of the wired arc seen from a given point : without loss of generality , we can assume that this point is just the origin .
let @xmath218 be the corresponding black diamond of the medial lattice , and @xmath219 be an adjacent white diamond which is not on the free arc .
we first prove a lower bound on the harmonic measure .
for that , we introduce , for @xmath220 and @xmath221 , the segments @xmath222 [ lower_bound ] there exists a constant @xmath223 such that for any dobrushin @xmath217-domain @xmath102 , we have @xmath224 provided that , in @xmath92 , the segment @xmath225 disconnects from the origin the intersection of the free arc with the upper half - plane ( see figure [ fig : comparison_lower_bound ] ) . we know that @xmath225 disconnects the origin from the part of the free arc that lies in the upper half - plane ,
let us thus consider the connected component of @xmath226 that contains the origin . in this new domain @xmath227 ,
if we put free boundary conditions along @xmath225 , the harmonic measure of the wired arc is smaller than the harmonic measure of the wired arc in the original domain @xmath92 . on the other hand ,
the harmonic measure of the wired arc in @xmath227 is larger than the harmonic measure of the wired arc in the slit domain @xmath228 , which has respectively wired and free boundary conditions to the left and to the right of @xmath229 ( see figure [ fig : comparison_lower_bound ] ) . estimating this harmonic measure is straightforward , using the same arguments as before .
the two domains involved in the proof of lemma [ lower_bound].,width=453 ] we now derive upper bounds on the harmonic functions .
we will need two estimates of different types .
the first one takes into account the distance between the origin and the wired arc , while the second one requires the existence of a segment @xmath230 disconnecting the wired arc from the origin ( still inside the domain ) .
[ upper_bound ] there exist constants @xmath231 such that for any dobrushin @xmath217-domain @xmath102 , a. [ upperbounddistance ] if @xmath232 denotes the distance between the origin and the wired arc , @xmath233 b. [ upperboundarc ] and if the segment @xmath230 disconnects the wired arc from the origin inside @xmath92 , @xmath234 let us first consider item ( [ upperbounddistance ] ) . for @xmath235 , define the dobrushin domain @xmath236 where @xmath237 is the set of sites in @xmath217 at a graph distance at most @xmath238 from the origin ( see figure [ fig : upper_bound ] ) .
the harmonic measure of the wired arc in @xmath102 is smaller than the harmonic measure of the wired arc in this new domain @xmath237 , and , as before , this harmonic measure is easy to estimate .
let us now turn to item ( [ upperboundarc ] ) . since @xmath230 disconnects the wired arc from the origin , the harmonic measure of the wired arc is smaller than the harmonic measure of @xmath230 inside @xmath92 , and this harmonic measure is smaller than it is in the domain @xmath239 with wired boundary conditions on the left side of @xmath230 right side if @xmath240 ( see figure [ fig : upper_bound ] ) . once again , the estimates are easy to perform in this domain . the two different upper bounds ( [ upperbounddistance ] ) and ( [ upperboundarc ] ) of lemma [ upper_bound].,width=453 ]
we now prove our main result , theorem [ rsw ] . the main step is to prove the uniform lower bound for rectangles of bounded aspect ratio with free boundary conditions .
we then use monotonicity to compare boundary conditions and obtain the desired result . in the case of free boundary conditions ,
the proof relies on a second moment estimate on the number @xmath241 of pairs of vertices @xmath242 , on the top and bottom sides of the rectangle respectively , that are connected by an open path .
the organization of this section follows the second - moment estimate strategy . in proposition
[ probability that one point belongs to gamma ] , we first prove a lower bound on the probability for one site on the bottom side of a rectangle to be connected to a site on the top side .
this estimate gives a lower bound on the expectation of @xmath241 .
then , proposition [ probability that two points belong to gamma ] provides an upper bound on the probability that two points on the bottom side of a rectangle are connected to the top side .
this proposition is the core of the proof , and it provides the right bound for the second moment of @xmath241 .
it allows us to conclude the section by using the second moment estimate method , thus proving theorem [ rsw ] . in this section ,
we use two main tools : the domain markov property , and probability estimates for connections between the wired arc and sites on the free arc .
we first explain how the previous estimates on harmonic measures can be used to derive estimates on connection probabilities : the following lemma is instrumental in our proof .
[ interpretation h ] let @xmath102 be a dobrushin domain .
for any site @xmath37 on the free arc of @xmath92 , we have @xmath243 where @xmath244 is the black face corresponding to @xmath37 , and @xmath214 is any closest white face that is not on the free arc .
since @xmath37 is on the free boundary of @xmath92 , there exists a white diamond on the free arc of @xmath108 which is adjacent to @xmath244 : we denote by @xmath127 the edge between these diamonds . as noted before , since the edge @xmath127 is along the free arc , the winding @xmath245 of the exploration path @xmath118 at @xmath127 is constant , and depends only on the direction of @xmath127 .
this implies that @xmath246 in addition , @xmath127 belongs to @xmath118 if and only if @xmath37 is connected to the wired arc , which implies that @xmath247 is exactly equal to @xmath248 .
proposition [ uniform comparability ] thus implies the claim . with this lemma at our disposal , we can prove the different estimates . throughout the proof , we use the notation @xmath249 for constants that depend neither on @xmath25 nor on sites
@xmath37 , @xmath38 or on boundary conditions .
when they do not depend on @xmath250 , we denote them by @xmath251 ( it is the case for the upper bounds ) .
recall the definition of @xmath205 : @xmath252 let @xmath253 ( resp .
@xmath254 ) be the _ top side _ @xmath255 ( resp .
_ bottom side _
@xmath256 ) of the rectangle @xmath205 .
we begin with a lower bound on connection probabilities .
[ probability that one point belongs to gamma ] let @xmath203 , there exists a constant @xmath257 such that for any @xmath208 , @xmath258 for all @xmath259 , @xmath260 , satisfying @xmath261 .
the probability that @xmath37 and @xmath262 are connected in the rectangle with free boundary conditions can be written as the probability that @xmath37 is connected to the wired arc in @xmath263 ( where the wired arc consists of a single vertex ) .
the previous lemma , together with the estimate of lemma [ 2 points estimate ] , concludes the proof .
we now study the probability that two boundary points on the bottom edge of @xmath205 are connected to the top edge .
[ probability that two points belong to gamma ] there exists a constant @xmath264 ( uniform in @xmath265 ) such that for any rectangle @xmath205 and any two points @xmath266 on the bottom side @xmath254 , @xmath267 where @xmath268 and @xmath269 denote respectively the top - left and top - right corners of the rectangle @xmath205 . the proof is based on the following lemma , which is a strong form of the so - called half - plane one - arm probability estimate ( see section [ one_arm_exponent ] for a further discussion of this result ) . for @xmath37 on the bottom side of @xmath205 and @xmath270 ,
we denote by @xmath271 the box centered at @xmath37 with diameter @xmath272 for the _ graph distance_. we can now state the lemma needed : [ upper bound for tk ] there exists a constant @xmath273 ( uniform in @xmath25 , @xmath250 and the choice of @xmath37 ) such that for all @xmath274 , @xmath275 the dobrushin domain @xmath276 , together with the exploration path up to time @xmath113.,width=226 ] consider @xmath277 , and the box @xmath205 with one point @xmath278 .
eq.([strong_one_arm ] ) becomes trivial if @xmath279 , so we can assume that @xmath280 . for any choice of @xmath281 , the monotonicity between boundary conditions eq.([extremality ] ) implies that the probability that @xmath271 is connected to the wired arc @xmath253 in @xmath282 is smaller than the probability that @xmath271 is connected to the wired arc in the dobrushin domain @xmath283 , where @xmath284 and @xmath285 are the bottom - left and bottom - right corners of @xmath286 . from now on ,
we replace @xmath250 by @xmath287 , and we work in the new domain @xmath276 . notice that @xmath288 is then included in @xmath205 and that the right - most site of @xmath288 is at a distance at least @xmath25 from the wired arc .
we denote by @xmath113 the hitting time for the exploration path naturally para - metrized by the number of steps of the subset of the medial lattice composed of the edges adjacent to @xmath271 ; we set @xmath289 if the exploration path never reaches this set , so that @xmath37 is connected to @xmath288 if and only if @xmath290 .
let @xmath124 be the right - most site of the box @xmath271 .
consider now the event @xmath291 . by conditioning on the curve up to time @xmath113 ( and on the event @xmath292 ) , we obtain @xmath293)\big]\\ & = { \mathbb{e}}_{r_n^{\beta},c_n , d_n}\big[\mathbb{i}_{t<\infty}{\mathbb{p}}_{r_n^{\beta}\setminus { \gamma}[0,t],{\gamma}(t),d_n}(z\leadsto \text{wired arc})\big],\end{aligned}\]]where in the second inequality , we have used the domain markov property , and also the fact that it is sufficient for @xmath124 to be connected to the wired arc in the new domain ( since it is then automatically connected to the wired arc of the original domain ) . on the one hand ,
since @xmath124 is at a distance at least @xmath25 from the wired arc ( thanks to the new choice of @xmath250 ) , we can combine proposition [ uniform comparability ] and lemma [ interpretation h ] with item ( [ upperbounddistance ] ) of lemma [ upper_bound ] to obtain @xmath294 on the other hand , if @xmath117 can be written as @xmath295 , with @xmath296 , then the arc @xmath297 disconnects the free arc from @xmath124 in the domain @xmath298 $ ] , while if @xmath299 , with @xmath300 , then the arc @xmath297 still disconnects the free arc from @xmath124 . using once again proposition [ uniform comparability ] and lemma [ interpretation h ] , this time with lemma [ lower_bound ]
, we obtain that a.s . @xmath301
this estimate being uniform in the realization of @xmath302 $ ] , we obtain @xmath303 which implies the desired claim eq.([strong_one_arm ] ) .
this picture presents the different steps in the proof of proposition [ probability that two points belong to gamma ] : we first ( 1 ) condition on @xmath304 $ ] and use the uniform estimate ( [ upperbounddistance ] ) of lemma [ upper_bound ] , then ( 2 ) condition on @xmath305 $ ] and use the estimate ( [ upperboundarc ] ) of lemma [ upper_bound ] , in order to ( 3 ) conclude with lemma [ upper bound for tk].,width=453 ] let us take two sites @xmath37 and @xmath38 on @xmath254 .
as in the previous proof , the larger the @xmath250 , the larger the corresponding probability , we can thus assume that @xmath250 has been chosen in such a way that there are no boundary effects . in order to prove the estimate , we express the event considered in terms of the exploration path @xmath121 .
if @xmath37 and @xmath38 are connected to the wired arc , @xmath121 must go through two boundary edges which are adjacent to @xmath37 and @xmath38 , that we denote by @xmath306 and @xmath307 .
notice that @xmath306 has to be discovered by @xmath121 before @xmath307 is .
we now define @xmath308 to be the hitting time of @xmath306 , and @xmath309 to be the hitting time of the set of edges adjacent to the ball @xmath310 , for @xmath311 . if the exploration path does not cross this ball before hitting @xmath306 , we set @xmath312 . with these definitions , the probability that
@xmath306 and @xmath307 are both on @xmath121 can be expressed as @xmath313\right.)\big ] , \label{estimation part 1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the second equality is obtained by conditioning on the exploration path up to time @xmath308 .
recall that @xmath307 belongs to @xmath118 if and only if @xmath38 is connected to the wired arc .
moreover , @xmath38 is at a distance at least @xmath314 from the wired arc in @xmath315 $ ] ( since @xmath316 ) .
hence , the domain markov property and item ( [ upperbounddistance ] ) of lemma [ upper_bound ] give that a.s . @xmath317\right.)={\mathbb{p}}_{r_n^{\beta}\setminus { \gamma}[0,t_x],x , b_n}(y\leadsto\text{wired arc})\leq \frac{c_3}{\sqrt{2^k}}.\ ] ] by plugging this uniform estimate into ( [ estimation part 1 ] ) , and removing the condition on @xmath316 , we obtain @xmath318\right.)\big],\end{aligned}\]]where we conditioned on the path up to time @xmath319 .
now , @xmath306 belongs to @xmath118 if and only if @xmath37 is connected to the wired arc , and in addition , the vertical segment connecting @xmath320 to @xmath321 , of length at most @xmath322 , disconnects the wired arc from @xmath37 in the domain @xmath323 $ ] .
applying the domain markov property and item ( [ upperboundarc ] ) of lemma [ upper_bound ] , we deduce that a.s . @xmath324\right.)&={\mathbb{p}}_{r_n^{\beta}\setminus { \gamma}[0,t_{k+1}],{\gamma}(t_{k+1}),b_n}(x\leadsto\text{wired arc})\leq c_4\frac{\sqrt{2^{k+1}}}{|x - y|}.\end{aligned}\]]making use of this uniform bound , we obtain @xmath325 using also lemma [ upper bound for tk ] for the second inequality .
we are now in a position to prove our main result .
let @xmath203 and @xmath326 , and also @xmath205 defined as previously . * step 1 : lower bound for free boundary conditions . *
let @xmath327 be the number of connected pairs @xmath242 , with @xmath278 , and @xmath328 .
the expected value of this quantity is equal to @xmath329=\sum_{\substack{u\in \partial_+r_n^{\beta}\\ x\in \partial_-r_n^{\beta}}}{\mathbb{p}}_{r_n^{\beta}}^0(x \leadsto u).\ ] ] proposition [ probability that one point belongs to gamma ] directly provides the following lower bound on the expectation by summing on the @xmath330 pairs of points @xmath242 far enough from the corners , _
i.e. _ satisfying the condition of the proposition : @xmath329\geq c_6(\beta)n\ ] ] for some @xmath331 . on the other hand , if @xmath37 and @xmath262 ( resp .
@xmath38 and @xmath130 ) are pair - wise connected , then they are also connected to the horizontal line @xmath332 which is ( vertically ) at the middle of @xmath205 .
moreover , the domain markov property implies that the probability in @xmath205 with free boundary conditions that @xmath37 and @xmath38 are connected to this line is smaller than the probability of this event in the rectangle of half height with wired boundary conditions on the top side . in the following ,
we assume without loss of generality that @xmath25 is even and we set @xmath333 , so that the previous rectangle is @xmath334 , and we define @xmath335 and @xmath336 as before . using the fkg inequality , and also the symmetry of the lattice , we get @xmath337where @xmath338 and @xmath339 are the projections on the real axis of @xmath262 and @xmath130 . summing the bound provided by proposition [ probability that two points belong to gamma ] on all sites @xmath340 and @xmath341 , we obtain @xmath342\leq c_7 m^2\leq c_7n^2\ ] ] for some constant @xmath343 . now , by the cauchy - schwarz inequality , @xmath344 \geq \frac{{\mathbb{e}}_{r_n^{\beta}}^0[n_n]^2}{{\mathbb{e}}_{r_n^{\beta}}^0[n_n^2]}\geq c_6(\beta)^2/c_7,\ ] ] since @xmath345 = { \mathbb{e}}_{r_n^{\beta}}^0[n_n \mathbb{i}_{n_n>0}]$ ] .
we have thus reached the claim .
* step 2 : lower and upper bounds for general boundary conditions . * using the ordering between boundary conditions eq.([extremality ] ) , the lower bound that we have just proved for free boundary conditions actually implies the lower bound for any boundary conditions @xmath30 . for the upper bound , consider a rectangle @xmath13 with dimensions @xmath346 with @xmath347 and with boundary conditions @xmath30 .
using once again eq.([extremality ] ) , it is sufficient to address the case of wired boundary conditions , and in this case , the probability that there exists a dual crossing from the left side to the right side is at least @xmath348 , since the dual model has free boundary conditions .
we deduce , using the self - duality property , that @xmath349 where we use the notation @xmath350 for the existence of a horizontal dual crossing , and @xmath351 is as usual the dual graph of @xmath13 ( note that we have implicitly used the invariance by @xmath352-rotations ) .
this concludes the proof of theorem [ rsw ] .
theorem [ rsw ] can also be applied to the ising model , using the edwards - sokal coupling . however , we have to be a little careful since not all boundary conditions can `` go through this coupling '' .
consider the ising model with @xmath353 or free boundary conditions in a rectangle @xmath13 with dimensions @xmath25 and @xmath354 .
there exists a constant @xmath355 such that @xmath356 where @xmath357 denotes the existence of a vertical @xmath353 crossing .
we could state this result for more general boundary conditions , for instance @xmath353 on one arc and free on the other arc .
the corresponding result for @xmath358 boundary conditions is actually not expected to hold : one can notice for example that in any given smooth domain , a cle(3 ) process the object describing the scaling limit of cluster interfaces
does not touch the boundary .
we start by stating an easy consequence of theorem [ rsw ] .
we consider the box @xmath359 , its boundary being denoted as usual by @xmath360 .
we also introduce @xmath361 the annulus @xmath362 of radius @xmath363 centered on the origin , and we denote by @xmath364 the event that there exists an open circuit surrounding @xmath365 in this annulus .
[ circuits ] for every @xmath366 , there exists a constant @xmath355 such that for all @xmath25 and @xmath367 , with @xmath368 , @xmath369 this follows from theorem [ rsw ] applied in the four rectangles @xmath370 , @xmath371 , @xmath372 and @xmath373 . indeed ,
if there exists a crossing in each of these rectangles in the `` hard '' direction , one can construct from them a circuit in @xmath361 . now , consider any of these rectangles , @xmath374 for instance .
its aspect ratio is bounded by @xmath375 , so that theorem [ rsw ] implies that there is a horizontal crossing with probability at least @xmath376 combined with the fkg inequality , this allows us to conclude : the desired probability is at least @xmath377 .
[ zero - magnetization ] for @xmath378 , there exists a unique infinite - volume measure @xmath379 . for this measure
, there is almost surely no infinite open cluster .
moreover , there exist constants @xmath380 such that for all @xmath221 , @xmath381 this result implies in particular that @xmath382 , in other words that there is no magnetization at @xmath378 .
this result also applies to the ising model : the magnetization at the origin decays at least as a power law .
we would like to mention that an alternative proof of the fact that there is no spontaneous magnetization at criticality can be found in @xcite . also , we actually know from onsager s work @xcite that the connection probability follows a power law as @xmath383 , described by the one - arm plane exponent @xmath384
. it should be possible to prove the existence and the value of this exponent using conformal invariance , as well as the arm exponents for a larger number of arms .
more precisely , one would need to consider the probability of crossing an annulus a certain ( fixed ) number of times in the scaling limit , and analyze the asymptotic behavior of this probability as the modulus tends to @xmath28 .
theorem [ rsw ] then implies the so - called quasi - multiplicativity property , which allows one to deduce , using concentric annuli , the existence and the value of the arm exponents for the discrete model .
we first note that it is classical that the non - existence of infinite clusters implies uniqueness of the infinite - volume measure : it is thus sufficient to prove equation eq.([up ] ) .
we consider the annuli @xmath385 for @xmath386 , and @xmath387 the event that there is a dual circuit in @xmath388 .
we know from corollary [ circuits ] that there exists a constant @xmath389 such that @xmath390 for all @xmath386 . by successive conditionings
, we then obtain @xmath391 and the desired result follows .
note that together with sharp threshold arguments developed by graham and grimmett @xcite , these crossing estimates also provide a geometric proof that the critical point is @xmath392 ( which then gives the critical temperature of the ising model , thanks to the edwards - sokal coupling ) .
theorem [ rsw ] can be used to apply the technology developed by aizenman and burchard @xcite , to prove regularity of the collection of interfaces , which implies tightness using a variant of the arzel - ascoli theorem .
this compactness property for the set of interfaces is important to construct the scaling limits of discrete interfaces , once we have a way to identify their limit uniquely ( using for instance the so - called martingale technique , detailed in @xcite ) . here
, the fermionic observable provides a conformally invariant martingale , and its convergence to a holomorphic function has been proved in @xcite , leading to the following important theorem : [ convergence to sle(16/3 ) ] for any dobrushin domain @xmath120 , with discrete approximations @xmath393 , the @xmath394-law of the exploration path @xmath395 from @xmath396 to @xmath397 converges weakly to the law of a chordal _ sle(16/3 ) _ path in @xmath398 , from @xmath97 to @xmath98 .
we briefly explain how one can use the crossing bounds to obtain the compactness of the interfaces .
note that this result has also been proved , in a different way , in @xcite and in the forthcoming article @xcite . as usual ,
curves are defined as continuous functions from @xmath399 $ ] into a bounded domain @xmath92 more precisely , as equivalence classes up to strictly increasing reparametrization .
the _ curve distance _ is then just the distance induced by the norm of uniform convergence .
let @xmath400 be the annulus @xmath401 .
we denote by @xmath402 the event that there are @xmath403 crossings of the curve from @xmath404 to @xmath405 .
[ aizenman - burchard ] let @xmath398 be a compact domain and denote by @xmath406 the law of a random curve @xmath407 with short - distance cut - off @xmath408 .
if for any @xmath409 , there exists @xmath410 and @xmath411 such that for all @xmath412 and @xmath413 , @xmath414 and @xmath415 , then the curves @xmath416 are precompact for the weak convergence associated with the curve distance . this theorem can be applied to the family @xmath417 of exploration paths defined in theorem [ convergence to sle(16/3 ) ] , using the following argument .
if @xmath402 holds , then there are @xmath272 open paths , alternating with @xmath272 dual paths , connecting the inner boundary of the annulus to its outer boundary .
moreover , one can decompose the annulus @xmath400 into roughly @xmath418 annuli of the form @xmath419 , so that it is actually sufficient to prove that @xmath420 for some constant @xmath421 .
since the paths are alternating , one can deduce that there are @xmath272 open paths , each one being surrounded by two dual paths .
hence , using successive conditionings and the domain markov property , the probability for each of them is smaller than the probability that there is a crossing in the annulus , which is less than some constant @xmath421 by corollary [ circuits ] ( note that this reasoning also holds on the boundary ) .
hence , theorem [ aizenman - burchard ] implies that the family @xmath422 is precompact for the weak convergence . as a by - product of our proofs , in particular of the estimates of section [ comp - harm - mes ]
, one can also obtain the value of the critical exponent for the boundary magnetization in the ising model , near a free boundary arc ( assuming it is smooth ) , and the corresponding one - arm half - plane exponent for the fk ising model .
let us first consider the one - point magnetization @xmath423 $ ] for the ising model at criticality in a discrete domain @xmath163 with free boundary conditions on the counterclockwise arc @xmath100 and @xmath353 boundary conditions on the other arc @xmath101 . there exist positive constants @xmath424 and @xmath425 such that for any discrete domain @xmath163 with @xmath426 and @xmath427 ( @xmath221 ) , containing the rectangle @xmath428 and such that its boundary contains the lower arc @xmath429 , we have @xmath430 \leq c_2 n^{-1/2},\ ] ] uniformly in @xmath25
. the magnetization at the origin can be expressed , in the corresponding fk representation , as the probability that the origin is connected to the wired counterclockwise arc @xmath101 .
this probability can now be estimated exactly as in section [ section_proof ] : it is equal to the probability that the fk interface passes through @xmath27 ( since the origin is on the free boundary of @xmath398 ) , which is itself the modulus of the fermionic observable on @xmath163 evaluated at @xmath27 .
now , it suffices to use proposition [ uniform comparability ] to compare this to the two harmonic measures , and then estimates similar to the estimates in lemmas [ lower_bound ] and [ upper_bound ] .
this result can be equivalently stated for the one - arm half - plane probability for fk percolation : consider the rectangle @xmath428 .
there exist positive constants @xmath424 and @xmath425 such that for any boundary conditions @xmath30 such that the lower arc @xmath431 is free , one has @xmath432 uniformly over all @xmath25 .
we get the upper bound using monotonicity and the previous proposition , since @xmath353 boundary conditions in the ising model correspond to wired boundary conditions in the corresponding fk representation . for the lower bound , by theorem [ rsw ] and the fkg inequality
, we can enforce the existence of a crossing in the half - annulus @xmath433 that disconnects 0 from @xmath434 to the price of a constant independent of @xmath30 .
using monotonicity and fkg , the probability that @xmath27 is connected by an open path to this crossing ( conditionally on its existence ) is larger than the probability that @xmath27 is connected to the boundary with wired boundary conditions , without conditioning .
hence , the lower bound of the previous proposition gives the desired result .
note that contrary to the power laws established using _ sle _ , there are no potential logarithmic corrections here as is the case with the `` universal '' arm exponents for percolation ( corresponding to 2 and 3 arms in the half - plane , and 5 arms in the plane ) .
furthermore , one can follow the same standard reasoning as for percolation , based on the rsw lower bound , to prove that the two- and three - arm half - plane exponents , with alternating `` types '' ( primal or dual ) , have values @xmath159 and @xmath435 respectively . since the work of onsager @xcite , it is well - known that for the ising model at criticality , the magnetization at the middle of a square of side length @xmath436 with @xmath353 boundary conditions decays like @xmath437 .
it is then tempting to say that the correlation of two spins at distance @xmath367 in the plane ( in the infinite - volume limit , say ) decays like @xmath438 , and this is indeed what happens . to the knowledge of the authors , there is no straightforward generalization of onsager s work that allows to derive this without difficult computations .
however , this result can be made rigorous very easily with the help of theorem [ rsw ] .
we give here only a result for two - point correlation functions , but exponents for @xmath25-spin correlations , for instance , can be obtained using exactly the same method .
let us first interpret onsager s result in terms of the fk representation .
let @xmath439 be the square @xmath440 with arbitrary boundary conditions @xmath30 .
then there exist two constants @xmath424 and @xmath425 ( independent of @xmath367 and @xmath30 ) such that we have @xmath441 onsager s result gives the result with wired boundary conditions ( since it is derived in terms of the ising model with @xmath353 boundary conditions ) , so by monotonicity it gives the upper bound .
using theorem [ rsw ] , we can obtain a lower bound independent of the boundary conditions by enforcing the existence of a circuit in the annulus @xmath442 , and using the fkg inequality .
for that , we just need to lower the constant , using monotonicity : the connection probability conditionally on the fact that there is a wired annulus around the origin is larger than the connection probability with @xmath353 boundary conditions on @xmath443
. we can now give the result for two - point correlation functions in the infinite - volume ising model .
consider the ising model on @xmath444 at critical temperature .
there exist two positive constants @xmath445 and @xmath446 such that we have @xmath447 \leq c_2 |x - y|^{-1/4},\ ] ] where for any @xmath448 , we denote by @xmath449 and @xmath450 the spins at @xmath37 and @xmath38 .
the 2-spin correlation @xmath451 $ ] can be expressed , in the corresponding fk representation , as the probability of the event @xmath452 .
let now @xmath367 be the integer part of @xmath453 .
the upper bound is easy and does not rely on theorem [ rsw ] : the event that @xmath37 is connected to @xmath38 implies that @xmath37 is connected to @xmath454 and that @xmath38 is connected to @xmath455 . using the domain markov property , these two events are independent conditionally on the states on the boundaries of the boxes . using the previous lemma
, we get the upper bound .
let us turn now to the lower bound .
we can enforce the existence of a connected `` @xmath456 '' in the discrete domain @xmath457 \setminus \left [ ( x + b_{m})\cup ( y + b_{m } ) \right]\ ] ] that surrounds both @xmath37 and @xmath38 and separates them : this costs only a positive constant @xmath458 , independent of @xmath367 , using theorem [ rsw ] in well - chosen rectangles and the fkg inequality .
using once again the fkg inequality , we get that @xmath459 and combined with the previous lemma , this yields the desired result .
this research was initiated during a semester spent by p.n . at universit de genve , and p.n .
would like to thank the mathematics department there for its hospitality , in particular stanislav smirnov .
p.n.s visit was made possible by the nsf grant oise-07 - 30136 .
s research was supported by the marie - curie grant s16472 .
this research was also supported in part by the swiss fns .
are also particularly thankful to stanislav smirnov for his constant support during their phd .
finally , the three authors enjoyed fruitful and stimulating discussions with many people , and they are particularly grateful to vincent beffara , dimitri chelkak , geoffrey grimmett , charles newman , stanislav smirnov , yvan velenik and wendelin werner . | we prove russo - seymour - welsh - type uniform bounds on crossing probabilities for the fk ising model at criticality , independent of the boundary conditions .
our proof relies mainly on smirnov s fermionic observable for the fk ising model , which allows us to get precise estimates on boundary connection probabilities .
it remains purely discrete , in particular we do not make use of any continuum limit , and it can be used to derive directly several noteworthy results some new and some not among which the fact that there is no spontaneous magnetization at criticality , tightness properties for the interfaces , and the existence of several critical exponents , in particular the half - plane one - arm exponent . |
the motivation for this project is to design a novel optical system for quasi - real time alignment of tracker detector elements used in high energy physics ( hep ) experiments .
fox - murphy _ et.al .
_ from oxford university reported their design of a frequency scanned interferometer ( fsi ) for precise alignment of the atlas inner detector @xcite .
given the demonstrated need for improvements in detector performance , we plan to design and prototype an enhanced fsi system to be used for the alignment of tracker elements in the next generation of electron - positron linear collider detectors .
current plans for future detectors require a spatial resolution for signals from a tracker detector , such as a silicon microstrip or silicon drift detector , to be approximately 7 - 10 @xmath0@xcite . to achieve this required spatial resolution
, the measurement precision of absolute distance changes of tracker elements in one dimension should be on the order of 1 @xmath0 .
simultaneous measurements from hundreds of interferometers will be used to determine the 3-dimensional positions of the tracker elements . in this paper , we describe ongoing r&d in frequency scanned interferometry ( fsi ) to be applied to alignment monitoring of a detector s charged particle tracking system , in addition to its beam pipe and final - focus quadrupole magnets .
the university of michigan group has constructed several demonstration fsis with the laser light transported by air or single - mode optical fiber , using single - fiber and dual - laser scanning techniques , and dual - laser with dual - channel for initial feasibility studies .
absolute distance was determined by counting the interference fringes produced while scanning the laser frequency .
the main goal of the demonstration systems was to determine the potential accuracy of absolute distance measurements that could be achieved under both controlled and realistic conditions .
secondary goals included estimating the effects of vibrations and studying error sources crucial to the absolute distance accuracy .
two multiple - distance - measurement analysis techniques were developed to improve distance precision and to extract the amplitude and frequency of vibrations . under laboratory conditions , a measurement precision of @xmath1 50 nm
was achieved for absolute distances ranging from 0.1 meters to 0.7 meters by using the first multiple - distance - measurement technique .
the second analysis technique has the capability to measure vibration frequencies ranging from 0.1 hz to 100 hz with amplitude as small as a few nanometers , without a _ priori _ knowledge@xcite .
the multiple - distance - measurement analysis techniques are well suited for reducing vibration effects and uncertainties from fringe & frequency determination , but do not handle well the drift errors , such as from thermal effects .
we describe a dual - laser system intended to reduce the drift errors and show some results under realistic conditions .
the dual - channel fsi is used to make sanity checks of the displacement of the detector simultaneously .
dual lasers with oppositely scanned frequency directions permit cancellation of many systematic errors , making the alignment robust against vibrations and environmental disturbances .
we also report on progress using a dual - channel dual - laser fsi with prototype .
under realistic environmental conditions , a precision of about 0.2 - 0.3 microns was achieved for a distance of about 57 cm for the prototype .
the intensity @xmath2 of any two - beam interferometer can be expressed as @xmath3 , where @xmath4 and @xmath5 are the intensities of the two combined beams , and @xmath6 and @xmath7 are the phases . assuming the optical path lengths of the two beams are @xmath8 and @xmath9 , the phase difference is @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is the optical frequency of the light , and c is the speed of light . for a fixed path interferometer , as the frequency of the laser
is continuously scanned , the optical beams will constructively and destructively interfere , causing `` fringes '' .
the number of fringes @xmath12 is @xmath13 , where @xmath14 is the optical path difference between the two beams , and @xmath15 is the scanned frequency range .
the optical path difference ( opd for absolute distance between beamsplitter and retroreflector ) can be determined by counting interference fringes while scanning the laser frequency .
schematic of an optical fiber fsi system.,width=302 ] if small vibration and drift errors @xmath16 occur during the laser scanning , then @xmath17 , @xmath18/2\pi = d_{true}\delta\nu / c + [ \epsilon(t)\nu(t)/c - \epsilon(t0)\nu(t0)/c]$ ] , assuming @xmath19 , @xmath20 , @xmath21 , the measured distance can be written as , @xmath22
a schematic of the fsi system with a pair of optical fibers is shown in figure [ fsi ] the light source is a new focus velocity 6308 tunable laser ( 665.1 nm @xmath23 675.2 nm ) . a high - finesse ( @xmath24 ) thorlabs sa200 f - p is used to measure the frequency range scanned by the laser .
the free spectral range ( fsr ) of two adjacent f - p peaks is 1.5 ghz , which corresponds to 0.002 nm .
a faraday isolator was used to reject light reflected back into the lasing cavity .
the laser beam was coupled into a single - mode optical fiber with a fiber coupler .
data acquisition is based on a national instruments daq card capable of simultaneously sampling 8 channels at a rate of 250 ks / s / ch with a precision of 12-bits .
omega thermistors with a tolerance of 0.02 k and a precision of 0.01 @xmath25 are used to monitor temperature .
the apparatus is supported on a damped newport optical table . in order to reduce air flow and temperature fluctuations ,
a transparent plastic box was constructed on top of the optical table .
pvc pipes were installed to shield the volume of air surrounding the laser beam . inside the pvc pipes ,
the typical standard deviation of 20 temperature measurements was about @xmath26 .
temperature fluctuations were suppressed by a factor of approximately 100 by employing the plastic box and pvc pipes .
detectors for hep experiments must usually be operated remotely for safety reasons because of intensive radiation , high voltage or strong magnetic fields .
in addition , precise tracking elements are typically surrounded by other detector components , making access difficult . for practical hep application of fsi , optical fibers for light delivery and return
are therefore necessary .
the beam intensity coupled into the return optical fiber is very weak , requiring ultra - sensitive photodetectors for detection . considering the limited laser beam intensity used here and the need to split into many beams to serve a set of interferometers , it is vital to increase the geometrical efficiency . to this end
, a collimator is attached to the optical fiber , the density of the outgoing beam from the optical fiber is increased significantly .
the return beams are received by another optical fiber and amplified by a si femtowatt photoreceiver with a gain of @xmath27 .
for a fsi system , drifts and vibrations occurring along the optical path during the scan will be magnified by a factor of @xmath28 , where @xmath11 is the average optical frequency of the laser beam and @xmath29 is the scanned frequency range . for the full scan of our laser , @xmath30 .
small vibrations and drift errors that have negligible effects for many optical applications may have a significant impact on a fsi system . a single - frequency vibration may be expressed as @xmath31 , where @xmath32 , @xmath33 and @xmath34 are the amplitude , frequency and phase of the vibration , respectively . if @xmath35 is the start time of the scan , eq .
[ eq : rdist ] can be re - written as @xmath36/c \label{eq : rdist}\end{aligned}\ ] ] if we approximate @xmath37 , the measured optical path difference @xmath38 may be expressed as @xmath39 \times \sin[\pi f_{vib}(t+t_0)+\phi_{vib } ] \label{eq : rdist_vib}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath40 is the true optical path difference in the absence of vibrations .
if the path - averaged refractive index of ambient air @xmath41 is known , the measured distance is @xmath42 .
if the measurement window size @xmath43 is fixed and the window used to measure a set of @xmath44 is sequentially shifted , the effects of the vibration will be evident .
we use a set of distance measurements in one scan by successively shifting the fixed - length measurement window one f - p peak forward each time .
the arithmetic average of all measured @xmath44 values in one scan is taken to be the measured distance of the scan ( although more sophisticated fitting methods can be used to extract the central value ) . for a large number of distance measurements @xmath45
, the vibration effects can be greatly suppressed .
of course , statistical uncertainties from fringe and frequency determination , dominant in our current system , can also be reduced with multiple scans .
averaging multiple measurements in one scan , however , provides similar precision improvement to averaging distance measurements from independent scans , and is faster , more efficient , and less susceptible to systematic errors from drift . in this way
, we can improve the distance accuracy dramatically if there are no significant drift errors during one scan , caused , for example , by temperature variation .
this multiple - distance - measurement technique is called slip measurement window with fixed size , shown in figure [ multi_dist ] .
however , there is a trade off in that the thermal drift error is increased with the increase of @xmath45 because of the larger magnification factor @xmath46 for a smaller measurement window size .
the schematic of two multiple - distance - measurement techniques .
the interference fringes from the femtowatt photoreceiver and the scanning frequency peaks from the fabry - perot interferometer(f - p ) for the optical fiber fsi system recorded simultaneously by daq card are shown in black and red , respectively .
the free spectral range(fsr ) of two adjacent f - p peaks ( 1.5 ghz ) provides a calibration of the scanned frequency range.,width=415 ] in order to extract the amplitude and frequency of the vibration , another multiple - distance - measurement technique called slip measurement window with fixed start point is used , as shown in figure [ multi_dist ] . in eq .
[ eq : rdist_vib ] , if @xmath35 is fixed , the measurement window size is enlarged one f - p peak for each shift , an oscillation of a set of measured @xmath44 values indicates the amplitude and frequency of vibration .
this technique is not suitable for distance measurement because there always exists an initial bias term , from @xmath35 , which can not be determined accurately in our current system .
the typical measurement residual versus the distance measurement number in one scan using the above technique is shown in figure [ rdist](a ) , where the scanning rate was 0.5 nm / s and the sampling rate was 125 ks / s .
measured distances minus their average value for 10 sequential scans are plotted versus number of measurements ( @xmath45 ) per scan in figure [ rdist](b ) .
the standard deviations ( rms ) of distance measurements for 10 sequential scans are plotted versus number of measurements ( @xmath45 ) per scan in figure [ rdist](c ) .
it can be seen that the distance errors decrease with an increase of @xmath45 .
the rms of measured distances for 10 sequential scans is 1.6 @xmath0 if there is only one distance measurement per scan ( @xmath47 ) .
if @xmath48 and the average value of 1200 distance measurements in each scan is considered as the final measured distance of the scan , the rms of the final measured distances for 10 scans is 41 nm for the distance of 449828.965 @xmath0 , the relative distance measurement precision is 91 ppb .
distance measurement residual spreads versus number of distance measurement @xmath45 ( a ) for one typical scan , ( b ) for 10 sequential scans , ( c ) is the standard deviation of distance measurements for 10 sequential scans versus @xmath45
. the frequency and amplitude of the controlled vibration source are 1 hz and 9.5 nanometers , ( d ) magnification factor versus number of distance measurements , ( e ) distance measurement residual versus number of distance measurements , ( f ) corrected measurement residual versus number of distance measurements.,title="fig:",width=245 ] distance measurement residual spreads versus number of distance measurement @xmath45 ( a ) for one typical scan , ( b ) for 10 sequential scans , ( c ) is the standard deviation of distance measurements for 10 sequential scans versus @xmath45 .
the frequency and amplitude of the controlled vibration source are 1 hz and 9.5 nanometers , ( d ) magnification factor versus number of distance measurements , ( e ) distance measurement residual versus number of distance measurements , ( f ) corrected measurement residual versus number of distance measurements.,title="fig:",width=264 ] the standard deviation ( rms ) of measured distances for 10 sequential scans is approximately 1.5 @xmath0 if there is only one distance measurement per scan for closed box data . by using the multiple - distance - measurement technique , the distance measurement precisions for various closed box data with distances ranging from 10 cm to 70 cm collected are improved significantly ; precisions of approximately 50 nanometers are demonstrated under laboratory conditions , as shown in table 1 .
all measured precisions listed in table [ tab : dist_single_laser ] are the rms s of measured distances for 10 sequential scans .
two fsi demonstration systems , air fsi and optical fiber fsi , were constructed for extensive tests of multiple - distance - measurement technique , air fsi means fsi with the laser beam transported entirely in the ambient atmosphere , optical fiber fsi represents fsi with the laser beam delivered to the interferometer and received back by single - mode optical fibers .
.[tab : dist_single_laser ] distance measurement precisions for various setups using the multiple - distance - measurement technique . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ]
one possible silicon tracker alignment system is shown in figure [ sid_alignment ] for a generic tracker .
the top left plot shows lines of sight for alignment in the r - z plane of the tracker barrel , the top right plot for alignment in x - y plane of the tracker barrel , the bottom plot for alignment in the tracker forward region .
red lines / dots show the point - to - point distances need to be measured using fsis .
there are 752 point - to - point distance measurements in total for the alignment system .
more studies are needed to optimize the distance measurements grid .
et.al._ , `` frequency scanning interferometry in atlas : remote , multiple , simultaneous and precise distance measurements in a hostile environment '' , meas . sci .
technol.15 ( 11 ) : 2175 - 2187 ( 2004 ) hai - jun yang _
et.al._ , `` high - precision absolute distance measurement using dual - laser frequency scanned interferometry under realistic conditions '' , nucl .
instrum . & meth .
a575 ( 2007 ) 395 - 401 .
[ physics/0609187 ] | in this paper , we report high - precision absolute distance and vibration measurements performed with frequency scanned interferometry .
absolute distance was determined by counting the interference fringes produced while scanning the laser frequency .
high - finesse fabry - perot interferometers were used to determine frequency changes during scanning .
a dual - laser scanning technique was used to cancel drift errors to improve the absolute distance measurement precision . a new dual - channel fsi demonstration system is also presented which is an interim stage toward practical application of multi - channel distance measurement . under realistic conditions ,
a precision of 0.3 microns was achieved for an absolute distance of 0.57 meters .
a possible optical alignment system for a silicon tracker is also presented . |
the standard model of cosmology suggests that the total energy density of the universe is presently dominated by the densities of two components : the _ dark matter _
component , which is a pressureless matter fluid having an attractive behaviour , and the _ dark energy _ , whose main properties are a negative pressure and a nearly constant energy density today , which evoke the idea of vacuum energy .
the nature of both components remains unknown , and in the near future we can hope that the large hadron collider ( lhc ) will be able to provide hints on the nature of dark matter . in spite of the mysteries of the dark components ,
it is generally considered that dark matter can be modeled as a system of collisionless particles , whereas the most usual models of dark energy are the scalar field based quintessence models .
however , many difficulties in usual dark energy and dark matter models still question the cosmological standard model bases , leaving room for other models to be investigated . in this paper
, we consider a unifying model in which the dark matter and dark energy components can be considered as two different aspects of a same component , the _
dark fluid_. we will first review how such a unifying model can be constrained by the cosmological observations .
then we will consider a dark fluid model based on a complex scalar field , and we will discuss the question of the choice of the scalar field potential .
during last years , cosmological observations have greatly improved in precision and in number . whereas their analyses are generally performed within the standard model of cosmology , considering distinctly dark matter and dark energy ,
they can be reinterpreted to determine constraints on the dark fluid model .
a first analysis of the cosmological constraints has been performed in ( arbey , 2005 ) . with new data becoming available , and in particular with the new 5-year wmap constraints ( komatsu et al . , 2008 )
, a reanalysis is performed in ( arbey , 2008 ) .
we will present here some of the most interesting results .
+ first we define as usual @xmath0 as the ratio of the density of the dark fluid over the critical density , and @xmath1 as the ratio of the pressure of the dark fluid over its density . + according to ( arbey , 2008 ) recent observations of supernov of type ia impose the following constraints on the dark fluid : @xmath2 where @xmath1 is written in function of the expansion factor : @xmath3 with @xmath4 .
the result on @xmath5 is particularly interesting , as it reveals that @xmath6 , which is a property that has to be satisfied to enable a description of the dark fluid by a scalar field .
+ + structure formation is also a very interesting way to contrain cosmological models .
however , no stringent constraints can be determined without performing a precise analysis of a specific dark fluid model .
we have nevertheless shown that a dark fluid should have an equation of state respecting @xmath7 at the time of structure formation .
+ + the data on the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) have been greatly improved with the new wmap 5-year data . if only the cmb data are considered , a large variety of dark fluid models would still be permitted .
we can however consider that a dark fluid model is more realistic if the fluid behaves today like a dark energy with a negative pressure , but was behaving mainly like matter at the recombination time .
we refer to ( arbey , 2008 ) for a more thourough analysis of the cmb constraints .
+ + constraints can also be derived considering primordial nucleosynthesis ( bbn ) models . under the assumption that the universe is dominated by radiation at bbn time
, we expect the dark fluid density to be small in comparison to the radiation density , in order to prevent the expansion rate to be strongly modified at this period , since it would lead to a modification in the abundance of the elements .
if we assume that the dark fluid behaviour does not change violently during bbn , it means that the equation of state of this fluid during the bbn period has to be @xmath8 , or that its density was completely negligible before bbn + + taken separately , these constraints does not seem very severe , but in a complete dark fluid scenario , all of them must be respected simultaneously , and when requiring that the dark fluid should also be able to explain dark matter at local scales , they become very restrictive . + we will now consider a dark fluid model based on a complex scalar field and confront it with the observational constraints .
modelling a dark fluid is not an easy task , as such a model should be able to describe simultaneously dark matter and dark energy properties . in the literature ,
only a few dark fluids have been investigated , the most well - known being the chaplygin gas ( see kamenshchik et al . , 2001 , bilic et al . , 2002 and r. bean et al . , 2003 ) .
in this paper , i consider a particular model using a scalar field , which was first introduced in ( arbey , 2006 ) . + + dark energy shares with vacuum energy the property of having a negative pressure and a quasi - constant energy density . therefore , a standard scalar field is often referred as a good pretendant for dark energy , and models of dark energy based on scalar fields are generally referred as quintessence scalar fields ( peebles et al . , 1988 ) .
an important question in these models is the choice of the potential of the scalar field , as it completely determines the behaviour of the field throughout the expansion of the universe .
many potentials have already been investigated , and some of them , such as the decreasing exponential potential , have been already excluded by the cosmological data .
however , it is still unclear how to choose the potential , and the main idea is to try to use potentials which can originate from physics motivated theories .
+ + the same problem appears when trying to build a dark fluid model , but the potential choice is now more constrained , as the scalar field has to behave like matter at local scale to account for observations in galaxies and clusters , and like dark energy at cosmological scales . the studies in ( arbey et al . , 2001/2002/2003
) have already shown that it is possible to describe dark matter in galaxies and at cosmological scales using a complex scalar field , provided the field has a mass term in the potential .
we have shown in particular that with a model based on a complex scalar field @xmath9 with an internal rotation @xmath10 and based on the lagrangian density : @xmath11 associated to a quadratic potential @xmath12 , the extended rotation curves of spiral galaxies can be reproduced , as can be seen for example in fig . [ gal ] .
to retain this dark matter behaviour , we will consider dark fluids demonstrating a @xmath13 behaviour in their potentials .
+ + scalar fields have shown a great polyvalence , as they can lead to either a dark energy behaviour , or a matter behaviour .
therefore , it is quite natural to model a dark fluid using also a scalar field .
however , an important question remains : how can the behaviour of the dark fluid be similar to dark matter at local scales and similar to dark energy at cosmological scales .
remarking that the density of dark fluid at cosmological scales today is of the order of the critical density , i.e. @xmath14 , and that the average matter density in galaxies is of the order @xmath15 , an answer can arise : the dark fluid needs to be inhomogeneous .
+ + in ( arbey , 2006 ) , the dark fluid model using the potential @xmath16 was investigated .
it is formed with a quadratic term giving a mass to the field , and mostly responsible for the dark matter behaviour , and a decreasing exponential part , which can find an origin in some high energy theories and which can recall quintessence potentials , responsible for the dark energy behaviour . in the regions of spacetime where the scalar field density is large enough , for example around galaxies or in the early universe , the quadratic part of the potential would dominate , and where the density is small , the second part of the potential dominates , leading to a repulsive vacuum energy - like behaviour .
then , such a potential leads to a universe highly inhomogeneous today .
+ it was also shown that such a potential can lead to the cosmological behaviour illustrated in fig .
[ cosmo ] , which is consistent with the observations , provided the different parameters are chosen adequately .
to fix the parameters , we consider three scales : the mass @xmath17 is fixed by galaxy scales , confronting the model predictions to galaxy rotation curves ; the @xmath18 parameters is fixed in order for the field to behave mostly as dark matter at typical cluster scales ; and @xmath19 is chosen in order for the field to be consistent with the cosmological observations revealing a dark energy behaviour .
we have then @xmath20 ev , @xmath21 and @xmath22 . with this choice of parameters
, we have shown that the scalar field dark fluid model is able to reproduce galaxy rotation curves , to condensate at cluster scales , and to have today a negative pressure at cosmological scales .
+ + the question of the choice of the potential remains crucial .
we would like it to be physics motivated , and to originate if possible from high energy theories .
to investigate the behaviour of the scalar field from the quantum physics point of view , we used in ( arbey & mahmoudi , 2007 ) an effective quantum field theory approach to determine how quantum fluctuations would affects the potential of eq .
( [ potential ] ) . we have shown in this way that such a potential would be modified by quantum fluctuations , especially if we expect it to be somehow non - minimally coupled to matter fields .
this result can be understood in two different manners : either such a potential is not resistant to quantum fluctuation and is not viable from the quantum theory point of view , or it is an effective potential which already includes the quantum corrections . in both points of view
, the choice of the potential is uncertain . in this context ,
a new interesting potential is currently under investigation : @xmath23 it has the advantage of finding roots in brane theories , and yet no big difference in behaviour is expected from the one determined by the potential of eq .
( [ potential ] ) .
the standard model of cosmology assumes the existence of two unknown dark components , dark matter and dark energy .
we have seen that it is possible to replace both components with a unique component , the dark fluid , and to remain consistent with the cosmological data .
the properties of the dark fluid are already severely constrained because of its dual dark energy / dark matter properties , but it is nevertheless possible to model it with a simple and usual complex scalar field . the main question of the model is the choice of the scalar field potential , but an adequate choice can lead to a fluid explaning at the same time the dark matter observations at local scales , and the dark energy behaviour at cosmological scales .
the relations between such a model and quantum theories are however not obvious , and still need to be worked out . however , to conclude , the dark fluid models are viable alternatives to the standard cosmological model , and need to be further investigated . | the standard model of cosmology suggests the existence of two components , `` dark matter '' and `` dark energy '' , which determine the fate of the universe .
their nature is still under investigation , and no direct proof of their existences has emerged yet . there exist alternative models which reinterpret the cosmological observations , for example by replacing the dark energy / dark matter hypothesis by the existence of a unique dark component , the _ dark fluid _ , which is able to mimic the behaviour of both components . after a quick review of the cosmological constraints on this unifying dark fluid , we will present a model of dark fluid based on a complex scalar field and discuss the problem of the choice of the potential . |
our interest in and the eventual development of the pbm goes back many years to the early nineteen eighties .
van hove s work@xcite in the early eighties considered the bubbles as small droplets of quark - gluon plasma ( qgp ) assumed to be produced in ultra - relativistic collisions of hadrons and/or nuclei .
his work recognized that experimental detectors only see what is emitted in the final state at kinetic freezeout .
therefore final state predictions of his string model work on plasma bubbles or any other theory required specific convincing predictions that are observable in the final state which can be measured by experiment .
his work predicted that the final state rapidity distribution dn / dy of hadrons would exhibit isolated maxima of width @xmath4 ( single bubble ) or rapidity bumps of a few units ( due to those cases producing a few bubbles ) .
these rapidity regions would also contain traditional signals of qgp formation .
even this early work by van hove needed his bubbles near the surface of the final state fireball in order to experimentally measure the particles emitted in the final state at kinetic freezeout .
we and other searched for these van hove bubbles , but no one ever found any significant evidence for them .
our next paper@xcite was our final attempt to make a theoretical treatment of the single bubble case ( similar to the van hove case ) which could be experimentally verified .
it is possible that with enough statistics one in principle could find single to a few bubble events .
we developed a number of event generators which could possibly provide evidence for striking signals resulting from these bubbles .
one should note that in that paper we had included in sec .
11 mathematical expressions describing how charged pions are effected by strong color electric and color magnetic fields which are present and parallel in a cp - odd bubble of metastable vacuum .
this section was motivated by the work of kharzeev and pisarski@xcite .
for example eq . 3 - 4 of the section
show the boosts of the @xmath5 and the @xmath6 we estimated .
thus in 2000 we were already interested in and were investigating and publishing predictions for this phenomenon .
when we considered the rhic quantum interference data in 2000@xcite it became clear that the fireball surface was rapidly moving outward .
this implied a very large phase space region covered by the fireball , and also implied that it would be very unlikely for there to be only one isolated bubble ( small source size ) with a large amount of energy sitting on the surface .
it seemed more likely that there would be many bubbles or gluonic hot spots around the expanding surface .
this led to a paper@xcite which was our earlier version of ref.@xcite . in that paper
we concluded that the behavior of the hanbury - brown and twiss ( hbt ) measurements@xcite should be interpreted as evidence of a substructure of bubbles located on the surface of the final state fireball in the central rapidity region at kinetic freezeout .
the hbt radii were decreasing almost linearly with transverse momentum and implying to us a source size of @xmath72 fm radii bubbles were on the surface and could be selected for if we considered transverse momenta above 0.8 gev / c .
these momenta would allow sufficient resolution to resolve individual bubbles of @xmath72 fm radii .
we further concluded that these hbt quantum interference observations were likely due to phase space focusing of the bubbles pushed by the expanding fireball .
thus the hbt measurements of source size extrapolated to transverse momenta above 0.8 gev / c were images of the bubbles .
the hbt correlation has the property of focusing these images on top of each other for a ring of bubbles transverse to and centered on the beam forming an average hbt radius .
thus our model was a ring of bubbles sitting on the freezeout surface with average size @xmath72 fm radius perpendicular to the beam at mid - rapidity .
the phase space focusing would also lead to angular correlations between particles emitted by the bubbles and be observable .
1 shows the geometry of the bubbles . for the background particles that account for particles in addition to the bubble particles we used unquenched hijing@xcite with its jets removed .
we assumed that most of the jets were eliminated from the central events because of the strong jet quenching observed at rhic@xcite .
we investigated the feasibility of using charged - particle - pair correlations as a function of angles which should be observable due to the phase space focusing of the particles coming from individual bubbles .
at that point we fully expected that these correlations would be observable in the star detector@xcite at rhic if one analyzed central au au collisions .
correlation analyses are powerful tools in detecting substructures .
historically substructures have played an important role in advancing our understanding of strong ( non perturbative ) interactions .
our earlier paper explained the general characteristics of the angular correlation data , and was also consistent with hbt measurements in a qualitative manner .
this motivated us to develop a reasonably quantitative model , the parton bubble model@xcite which is discussed in the following .
in this publication@xcite we developed a qcd inspired parton bubble model ( pbm ) for central ( impact parameter near zero ) high energy heavy ion collisions at rhic .
the pbm is based on a substructure consisting of a single ring of a dozen adjoining 2-fm - radius bubbles ( gluonic hot spots ) transverse to the collider beam direction , centered on the beam , and located at or near mid - rapidity .
the at or near mid - rapidity refers to the boost invariant region that exist in the rhic heavy ion collisions which spans 2 - 4 units of rapidity .
because of this spread in @xmath8 , we will use the relative spread of particles in @xmath8 ( @xmath9 ) in order to capture the angular correlations along the beam axis .
the ring resides on the fireball blast wave surface ( see fig .
1 ) . we assumed these bubbles are likely the final state result of quark - gluon - plasma ( qgp ) formation since the energy densities produced experimentally are greater than those estimated as necessary for formation of a quark - gluon - plasma .
thus this is the geometry for the final state kinetic freezeout of the qgp bubbles on the surface of the expanding fireball treated in a blast wave model .
the average behavior of emitted final state particles coming from the surface bubbles at kinetic freezeout is given by the ring of twelve bubbles formed by energy density fluctuations near the surface of the expanding fireball of the blast wave .
one should note that the blast wave surface is moving at its maximum velocity at freezeout ( 3c/4 ) . for central events each of the twelve bubbles have 3 - 4 partons per bubble each at a fixed @xmath10 for a given bubble .
this number of partons was determined from correlation data analyzed by the star experiment@xcite .
the transverse momentum ( @xmath2 ) distribution of the charged particles is similar to pqcd but has a suppression at high @xmath2 like the data .
the bubble ring radius of our model was estimated by blast wave , hbt and other general considerations to be approximately 8 fm .
the bubbles emit correlated charged particles at final - state kinetic freezeout where we select a @xmath2 range ( 0.8 gev / c @xmath1 @xmath2 @xmath1 4.0 gev / c ) in order to increase signal to background .
the 0.8 gev / c @xmath2 cut increases the resolution to allow resolving individual bubbles which have a radius of @xmath72 fm .
this space momentum correlation of the blast wave provides us with a strong angular correlation signal .
pythia fragmentation functions@xcite were used for the bubbles fragmentation that generate the final state particles emitted from the bubbles . a single parton using pythia forms a jet with the parton having a fixed @xmath8 and @xmath10 ( see fig .
the 3 - 4 partons in the bubble which shower using pythia all have a different @xmath8 value but all have the same @xmath10 ( see fig .
the pbm explained the high precision au au central ( 0 - 10% ) collisions at @xmath11 200 gev@xcite ( the highest rhic energy ) .
we utilize a two particle correlation function in the two dimensional ( 2-d ) space of @xmath12 vs @xmath9 . the azimuthal angle @xmath10 of a particle is defined by the angle of the particle with respect to the vertical axis which is perpendicular to the beam axis and is measured in a clock - wise direction about the beam .
@xmath12 is the difference , @xmath13 - @xmath14 , of the @xmath10 angle of a pair of particles ( 1 and 2 ) .
the pseudo - rapidity @xmath8 of a particle is measured along one of the beam directions .
@xmath9 is the difference , @xmath15 - @xmath16 , of the @xmath8 values of a pair of particles ( 1 and 2 ) .
the two dimensional ( 2-d ) total correlation function is defined as : @xmath17 where s(@xmath18 ) is the number of pairs at the corresponding values of @xmath18 coming from the same event , after we have summed over all the events .
m(@xmath18 ) is the number of pairs at the corresponding values of @xmath18 coming from the mixed events , after we have summed over all our created mixed events .
a mixed event pair has each of the two particles chosen from a different event .
we make on the order of ten times the number of mixed events as real events .
we rescale the number of pairs in the mixed events to be equal to the number of pairs in the real events .
this procedure implies a binning in order to deal with finite statistics . to enhance comparison we use the same binning in our simulations as is used by the star high precision experimental analyses@xcite .
the division by m(@xmath18 ) for experimental data essentially removes or drastically reduces acceptance and instrumental effects . if the mixed pair distribution was the same as the real pair distribution c(@xmath18 )
would be one for all values of the binned @xmath18 . in the correlations used in this paper we select particles independent of its charge .
the correlation of this type is called a charge independent ( ci ) correlation .
this difference correlation function has the defined property that it only depends on the differences of the azimuthal angle ( @xmath12 ) and the beam angle ( @xmath9 ) for the two particle pair .
thus the two dimensional difference correlation distribution for each bubble which is part of c(@xmath18 ) is similar for each of our 12 bubbles and will image on top of each other .
the pbm fit to the angular correlation data was reasonably quantitative to within a few percent ( see fig . 4 and fig .
5 ) ) .
the correlation functions we employed ( like the hbt correlation functions ) have the property that for the difference in angles ( difference of momentum for hbt ) these correlations will image all 12 bubbles on top of each other .
this leads to average observed angles of approximately @xmath19 in @xmath12 , @xmath20 in @xmath9 , originating from a source size of about @xmath72 fm radius which is consistent with the hbt correlation .
thus the pbm generates @xmath12 vs @xmath9 charged - particle - pair correlations for charged particles with @xmath2 in the range 0.8 gev / c to 4.0 gev / c as displayed in fig . 4 and fig .
we show the ci correlation in fig .
5 a reasonably quantitative successful comparison with data .
it should be noted that the spread in @xmath9 of the bubble is determined by the longitudinal momentum distribution of the 3 - 4 partons that make up the bubble .
this distribution which is quassian in nature was adjusted to the observed @xmath9 width of correlation data analyzed by the star experiment@xcite .
furthermore the model results were consistent with the hanbury - brown and twiss ( hbt ) observations@xcite that the observed source radii determined by quantum statistical interference were reducing by a considerable factor with increasing transverse momentum ( @xmath2 ) .
the hbt radii are interpreted to reduce from @xmath76 fm at @xmath2 @xmath70.2 gev / c to @xmath72 fm at @xmath2 @xmath71 gev / c for our @xmath2 range .
the generally accepted explanation for this behavior is that as @xmath2 increases radial flow increasingly focused the viewed region of the final state into smaller volumes .
if just one small hbt size bubble were emitting all the correlated particles , this phenomena would lead to large spikes of particles emitted at one limited @xmath10 angular region in individual events .
this is definitely not observed in the au au or other collision data at rhic .
therefore , a distributed ring of small sources around the beam as assumed in the pbm is necessary to explain both the hbt results@xcite and the correlation data@xcite .
the particles emitted from the same bubble are virtually uncorrelated to particles emitted from any other bubble except for momentum conservation requirements .
an away side peak in the total correlation is built up from momentum conservation between the bubbles .
the pbm was also recently extended to pbme@xcite which is identical to the pbm for central collisions ( 0 - 5% ) . for centralities running from 30 - 80% jet quenching
is not strong enough to make jets negligible therefore , a jet component was added which was based on hijing calculations .
this jet component accounts for more of the correlation as one moves toward peripheral bins , and explains all of it for the most peripheral collisions .
the pbme explained in a reasonably quantitative manner ( within a few percent ) the behavior of the recent quantitative experimental analysis of charge pair correlations as a function of centrality@xcite .
this further strengthened the substantial evidence for bubble substructure .
the agreement of the pbm and the pbme surface emission models with experimental analyses strongly implied that at kinetic freezeout the fireball was dense and opaque in the central region and most centralities ( except the peripheral region ) in the intermediate transverse momentum region ( 0.8 @xmath1 @xmath2 @xmath1 4.0
gev / c ) .
thus we conclude that the observed correlated particles are both formed and emitted from or near the surface of the fireball . in the peripheral region
the path to the surface is always small .
the ci correlation used in fig . 4 and the pbm@xcite is also defined as the sum of two charged - particle - pair correlations .
they are the unlike - sign charge pairs ( us ) and the like - sign charge pairs ( ls ) .
this charge independent correlation ( ci ) is defined as the correlation made up of charged - particle - pairs independent of what the sign is , which is the average of the us plus the ls correlations .
thus ci = ( us + ls)/2 .
therefore the ci is the total charge pair correlation observed in the experimental detection system within its acceptance .
the ci was generated for @xmath0 = 200 gev central ( 0 - 5% ) au au collisions in the @xmath2 range 0.8 gev / c to 4.0 gev / c at rhic .
when the ci was compared to the corresponding experimental analyses@xcite a reasonably quantitative agreement within a few percent of the observed ci was attained .
see ref.@xcite sec .
4.2 , ref.@xcite sec .
v , and ref.@xcite sec .
vi b. this analysis and our previous work@xcite was done without using a jet trigger .
in fact jet production in the central region was negligible due to strong jet quenching@xcite .
as one can see in fig .
4 the central ci correlation of @xmath12 on the near side ( @xmath12 @xmath1 @xmath21 ) , is sharp and approximately jetlike at all @xmath9 .
in contrast the @xmath9 dependence is relatively flat . in the central production
the average observed angles are approximately @xmath19 in @xmath12 and @xmath20 in @xmath9 .
it is of interest to note that the sharp jetlike collimation in @xmath12 persists at all centralities ( 0 - 80% ) .
the elongation in @xmath9 persists in the 0 - 30% centrality range and then decreases with decreasing centrality becoming jetlike in the peripheral bins .
these characteristics are in reasonable quantitative agreement with the fits of the pbm and the pbme to experimental data analyses@xcite .
the difference of the us and ls correlations is defined as the charge dependent ( cd ) correlation ( cd = us - ls ) .
the 2-d experimental cd correlation for centralities ( 0 - 80% ) has a jetlike shape which is consistent with pythia jets ( vacuum fragmentation ) for all centralities .
this clearly implies that both particle hadronization and emission occur from the fireball surface region as explained in ref.@xcite sec .
a glasma flux tube model ( gftm)@xcite that had been developed considers that the wavefunctions of the incoming projectiles , form sheets of color glass condensates ( cgc)@xcite that at high energies collide , interact , and evolve into high intensity color electric and magnetic fields .
this collection of primordial fields is the glasma@xcite , and initially it is composed of only rapidity independent longitudinal color electric and magnetic fields .
an essential feature of the glasma is that the fields are localized in the transverse space of the collision zone with a size of 1/@xmath22 .
@xmath22 is the saturation momentum of partons in the nuclear wavefunction .
these longitudinal color electric and magnetic fields generate topological chern - simons charge@xcite which becomes a source for particle production .
the transverse space is filled with flux tubes of large longitudinal extent but small transverse size @xmath7@xmath23 .
particle production from a flux tube is a poisson process , since the flux tube is a coherent state .
as the partons emitted from these flux tubes locally equilibrate , transverse flow builds due to the radial flow of the blast wave@xcite .
the flux tubes that are near the surface of the fireball get the largest radial flow and are emitted from the surface . as in the parton bubble model these partons shower and the higher @xmath2 particles escape the surface and do not interact .
these flux tubes are in the present paper considered strongly connected to the bubbles of the pbm .
the method used to connect the pbm and the gftm is described and discussed in the next section v. @xmath22 is around 1 gev / c thus the transverse size of the flux tube is about 1/4 fm .
the flux tubes near the surface are initially at a radius @xmath75 fm .
the @xmath10 angle wedge of the flux tube is @xmath71/20 radians or @xmath7@xmath24 .
thus the flux tube initially has a narrow range in @xmath10 .
the large width in the @xmath9 correlation which in the pbm depended on the large spread in @xmath9 of the bubble partons results from the independent longitudinal color electric and magnetic fields that created the glasma flux tubes .
how much of these longitudinal color electric and magnetic fields are still present in the surface flux tubes when they have been pushed by the blast wave will be a speculation of this paper for measuring strong cp violation ? it has been noted that significant features of the pbm that generated final state correlations which fit the experimentally observed correlation data@xcite are similar to those predicted by the gftm@xcite .
therefore in the immediately following section we assume a direct connection of the pbm and the gtm , give reasons to justify it , and then discuss its consequences , predictions and successes .
the successes of the pbm have strongly implied that the final state surface region bubbles of the pbm represent a significant substructure . in this subsection
we show that the characteristics of our pbm originally developed to fit the precision star au au correlation data in a manner consistent with the hbt data ; implies that the bubble substructure we originally used to fit these previous data is closely related to the gftm .
a natural way to connect the pbm bubbles to the gftm flux tubes is to assume that the final state at kinetic freezeout of a flux tube is a pbm final state bubble .
thus the initial transverse size of a flux tube @xmath71/4 fm has expanded to the size of @xmath72 fm at kinetic freezeout . with this assumption
we find consistency with the theoretical expectations of the gftm .
we can generate and explain the triggered ridge phenomenon and data ( see sec .
vi ) , thus implying the ridge is connected to the bubble substructure . we can predict and obtain very strong evidence for the color electric field of the glasma from comparing our multi - particle charged particle correlation predictions , and existing experimental correlation publications ( see sec .
vii ) . we have also predicted correlations which can be used to search for evidence for the glasma color magnetic field ( sec .
of course an obvious question that arises is that since a flux tube is an isolated system does a pbm bubble , that we assume is the final state of a flux tube at kinetic freezeout , also act as an isolated system when emitting the final state particles ?
the near side correlations signals since the original pbm@xcite have always come virtually entirely from particles emitted from the same bubble .
thus each bubble has always acted as an isolated system similar to the behavior of a flux tube .
in heavy ion collisions at rhic there has been observed a phenomenon called the ridge which has many different explanations@xcite .
the ridge is a long range charged particle correlation in @xmath9 ( very flat ) , while the @xmath12 correlation is approximately jet - like ( a narrow gaussian ) .
there also appears with the ridge a jet - like charged - particle - pair correlation which is symmetric in @xmath9 and @xmath12 such that the peak on the jet - like correlation is at @xmath9 = 0 and @xmath12 = 0 .
the @xmath12 correlation of the jet and the ridge are approximately the same and smoothly blend into each other .
the ridge correlation is generated when one triggers on an intermediate @xmath2 range charged particle and then forms pairs between that trigger particle and each of all other intermediate charged particles with a smaller @xmath2 down to some lower limit .
the first case we will study in this paper is a trigger charged particle between 3.0 to 4.0 gev / c correlated with all other charged particles which have a @xmath2 between 1.1 gev / c to 3.0 gev / c . in this paper
we will investigate whether the pbm can account for the ridge once we add a jet trigger to our pbm generator@xcite . however
this trigger will also select jets which previously could be neglected because there was such strong quenching@xcite of jets in central collisions .
a jet trigger had not been used in the pbm comparison to all previous data .
we use hijing@xcite merely to determine the expected number of jets to add for our added jet trigger .
these jet particles were added to our pbm generator .
thus our pbm generator now had hijing generated background particles , bubbles of the pbm and added jet particles from hijing .
we have already shown that our final state particles come from hadrons at or near the fireball surface .
we reduce the number of jets by 80% which corresponds to the estimate that only the parton interactions on or near the surface are not quenched away , and thus at kinetic freezeout form and emit hadrons which enter the detector .
this 80% reduction is consistent with single @xmath25 suppression observed in ref.@xcite .
we find for the reduced hijing jets that 4% of the au au central events ( 0 - 5% ) centrality at @xmath11 200 have a charged particle with a @xmath2 between 3.0 and 4.0 gev / c with at least one other charged particle with its @xmath2 greater than 1.1 gev / c coming from the same jet .
the addition of the jets to the pbm generator provides the appropriate particles which are picked up by the trigger in order to form a narrow @xmath9 correlation signal at 0 which is also a narrow signal in @xmath12 at 0 ( fig .
this narrow jet signal is present in the data and is what remains of jets after 80% are quenched away .
we then form two - charged - particle correlations between one - charged - particle with a @xmath2 between 3.0 to 4.0 gev / c and another charged particle whose @xmath2 is greater than 1.1 gev / c .
the results of these correlations are shown in fig .
6 is the ci correlation for the 0 - 5% centrality bin with the just above stated @xmath2 selections on charge pairs .
since we know in our monte carlo which particles are emitted from bubbles and thus form the ridge , we can predict the shape of the ridge for the above @xmath2 cut by plotting only the correlation formed from pairs of particles that are emitted by the same bubble ( see fig .
the charge pair correlations are virtually all emitted from the same bubble .
those charge pair correlations formed from particles originating from different bubbles are small contributors which mainly have some effect on the away side correlation .
7 is the ridge signal which is the piece of the ci correlation for the 0 - 5% centrality of fig .
6 , after removing all other pairs except the pairs emitted from the same bubble .
a very important aspect of the gftm is the boost that the flux tubes get from the radial flow of the blast wave .
this boost is the same all along the flux tube and only depends on how far away from the center axis of the blast wave the flux tube is . in the pbm
the partons in the bubble received a boost in @xmath2 from the radial flow field in the blast wave ; that after final state fragmentation of the bubbles gave the generated particles a consistent @xmath2 spectrum with the data . since the boost from the blast wave depended on the position of the bubble in the radial flow field , there should be a correlation between partons @xmath2 within a bubble .
if one redistributed the partons with their @xmath2 boosts uniformly among the bubbles , the over all results for the generated correlations without a trigger would be unchanged .
one should note none of our prior work ( i.e.pbm@xcite or pbme@xcite ) contained a trigger .
we have only added a trigger here to treat the `` triggered ridge '' which obviously requires it . in our treatment of the gftm ( sec .
vii ) we have removed the trigger . once we require a trigger demanding higher @xmath2 particles , we start picking out bubbles which have more radial flow ( harder particles ) . thus correlated particles which pass our @xmath2 selection and trigger come almost entirely from the harder bubbles with more radial flow , while the softer bubbles which were subject to less radial flow mainly generate low enough @xmath2 particles that become background particles or are lost to the correlation analysis due to @xmath2 selection .
figure 6 shows the result of our trigger and @xmath2 selection .
if one redistributed the partons with their @xmath2 radial flow boost among all the bubbles , then all bubbles become equal and there is no longer soft and hard bubbles . with this change
we can generate bubble events .
we find that both the non - triggered correlation and the @xmath12 correlation are virtually unchanged in the region less than about @xmath26 ( see fig .
it seems that we move from the situation where we have a few bubbles with a lot of correlated particles above our @xmath2 cut to a lot of bubbles that have few correlated particles above our cuts .
however there is a difference in the triggered correlation s away side or @xmath12 near the @xmath27 peak . in ref.@xcite
we discuss this away side effect and attributed this peak to momentum conservation .
this is however not the whole story .
the away side peak is generated by the geometry of the bubble ring which requires that for every bubble there is another bubble nearly @xmath27 away that is emitting particles .
these symmetry requirements on the geometry contribute more to the away side peak especially for the case without a trigger or redistributed random partons .
this geometry effect is what causes the away side correlation of elliptic flow in a peripheral heavy ion collision .
in such a collision there is a higher energy density aligned with the reaction plane .
on one side of the reaction plane there are more particles produced because of increased energy density , and because of the geometry of the situation . on the other side of the reaction plane
there are also more particles produced for the same reasons .
thus there is a correlation between particles that are near each other on one side of the reaction plane and a correlation between particles that are on both sides of the reaction plane .
momentum conservation requires particle communication by bouncing into each other , while geometry has no such communication .
the right hand does not need to know what the left hand is doing .
however , if physics symmetry makes them do the same thing then they can show a correlation .
the away side peak depends on the fragmentation of the away side bubble . for the triggered case where
there is a hard bubble with a strong correlation of parton @xmath2 inside the bubble ( gftm like ) , we will have more correlated particles adding to the signal on the near side . on the other hand
the away side bubble will be on average a softer bubble which will have a lot less particles passing the @xmath2 cuts and thus have a smaller signal .
if we consider the case of a random parton @xmath2 bubble the particles passing the @xmath2 cuts should be very similar on the near and the away side .
8 we compare the two correlations generated by the correlated and the random cases .
we compare the @xmath12 correlation for the two cases ( solid is correlated and open is random)for each of the five @xmath9 bins which cover the entire @xmath9 range ( 0.0 to 1.5 ) . the vertical correlation scale is not offset and is correct for the largest @xmath9 bin , 1.2 @xmath28 1.5 , which is the lowest bin on the figure .
as one proceeds upwards to the next @xmath9 bin the correlation is offset by + 0.05 .
this is added to the correlation of each subsequent @xmath9 bin .
the smallest @xmath9 bin on top of fig .
8 has a + 0.2 offset .
a solid straight horizontal line shows the offset for each @xmath9 bin .
each solid straight horizontal line is at 1.0 in correlation strength .
we see that the away side correlation in the @xmath12 region greater than about @xmath26 is larger for the random case .
particles which come from bubbles that satisfy the trigger ( 3.0 @xmath1 @xmath2 @xmath1 4.0
gev / c ) are harder and have a different @xmath2 distribution compared to the case without trigger requirements . in a given
triggered event if one could select particles that come from the bubble or ridge , one would find that the @xmath2 spectrum is harder than the average @xmath2 spectrum . in fig .
9 we show how one can by trigger choose particles that are rich with ridge particles .
we consider a typical trigger particle and the associated regions in the available experimental @xmath10 and @xmath8 ranges .
the ridge particles we consider are separated from the trigger particle by 0.7 in @xmath8 .
this is done to eliminate particles coming from jet production that could also be associated with the trigger particle .
the bulk of the ridge particles lie within @xmath29 of the @xmath10 of the trigger particle .
the width of the @xmath10 spread is @xmath12 = @xmath30 .
therefore on a trigger by trigger basis we accumulate particles from the ridge region ( see fig .
9 ) and form a @xmath2 spectrum of charged particles .
we then form a ratio of the @xmath2 spectrum for the ridge region particles divided by the @xmath2 spectrum for all particles in central au au events .
this ratio is highly dependent on our ridge cut area .
we can virtually remove this dependency by normalizing the two @xmath2 spectra to have the same counts for the 2.0 gev / c bin .
figure 10 is this ratio which can be considered a correlation of particles as a function of @xmath2 in the ridge region compared to particles from the event in general . in fig .
10 we form this ratio or correlation for the bubbles which have a correlated @xmath2 among the partons ( gftm like ) .
we also show the correlation for bubbles which have a random @xmath2 distribution among partons in the bubble . for the random case the @xmath2 spectrum does not differ much from the average @xmath2 spectrum while there is a big difference for the flux tube like case .
this correlation could be easily measured in the rhic data
. triggered angular correlation data showing the ridge was presented at quark matter 2006@xcite .
figure 11 shows the experimental @xmath12 vs. @xmath9 ci correlation for the 0 - 10% central au au collisions at @xmath11 200 gev ; requiring one trigger particle @xmath2 between 3 and 4 gev / c and an associated particle @xmath2 above 2.0 gev / c .
the yield is corrected for the finite @xmath9 pair acceptance . for the pbm generator
, we then form a two - charged - particle correlation between one charged particle with a @xmath2 between 3.0 to 4.0 gev / c and another charged particle whose @xmath2 is greater than 2.0 gev / c .
the results of this correlation is shown in fig .
figure 11 shows the corrected pair yield determined in the central data whereas fig .
12 shows the correlation function generated by the pbm which does not depend on the number of events analyzed .
we can compare the two figures , if we realize that the away side ridge has around 420,000 pairs in fig .
11 while in fig .
12 the away side ridge has a correlation of around 0.995 . if we multiply the correlation scale of fig .
12 by 422,111 in order to achieve the number of pairs seen in fig .
11 , the away side ridge would be at 420,000 and the peak would be at 465,000 . this would make a good agreement between the two figures . the correlation formed by the ridge particles is generated almost entirely by particles emitted by the same bubble .
we have shown in all our publications that the same side correlation signals are almost entirely formed by particles coming from the same bubble .
thus we can predict the shape and the yield of the ridge for the above @xmath2 trigger selection and lower cut , by plotting only the correlation coming from pairs of particles that are emitted by the same bubble ( see fig . 13 ) .
in ref.@xcite it was assumed that the ridge yield was flat across the acceptance while in fig .
13 we see that this is not the case .
therefore our ridge yield is approximately 35% larger than estimated in ref.@xcite .
finally we can plot the jet yield that we had put into our monte carlo .
we used hijing@xcite to determine the number of expected jets , and then reduced the number of jets by 80% .
this assumes that only the parton interactions on or near the surface that form hadrons at kinetic freezeout are not quenched away and thus enter the detector .
this 80% reduction is consistent with single @xmath25 suppression observed in ref.@xcite .
this jet yield is plotted in fig .
14 where we subtracted contributions from the bubbles and the background particles from fig . 11 .
the strong cp problem remains one of the most outstanding puzzles of the standard model .
even though several possible solutions have been put forward it is not clear why cp invariance is respected by the strong interaction .
it was shown however through a theorem by vafa - witten@xcite that the true ground state of qcd can not break cp .
the part of the qcd lagrangian that breaks cp is related to the gluon - gluon interaction term @xmath3 .
the part of @xmath3 related to cp violations can be separated into a separate term which then can be varied by multiplying this term by a parameter called @xmath31 . for the true qcd ground state @xmath31 = 0 ( vafa - witten theorem ) . in the vicinity of the deconfined qcd vacuum
metastable domains@xcite @xmath31 non - zero could exist and not contradict the vafa - witten theorem since these are not the qcd ground state .
the metastable domains cp phenomenon would manifest itself in specific correlations of pion momenta@xcite .
the glasma flux tube model ( gftm)@xcite considers the wavefunctions of the incoming projectiles , form sheets of cgc@xcite at high energies that collide , interact , and evolve into high intensity color electric and magnetic fields .
this collection of primordial fields is the glasma@xcite .
initially the glasma is composed of only rapidity independent longitudinal ( along the beam axis ) color electric and magnetic fields .
these longitudinal color electric and magnetic fields generate topological chern - simons charge@xcite through the @xmath3 term and becomes a source of cp violation .
how much of these longitudinal color electric and magnetic fields are still present in the surface flux tubes when they have been pushed by the blast wave is a speculation of this paper for measuring strong cp violation ?
the color electric field which points along the flux tube axis causes an up quark to be accelerated in one direction along the beam axis , while the anti - up quark is accelerated in the other direction .
so when a pair of quarks and anti - quarks are formed they separate along the beam axis leading to a separated @xmath5 @xmath6 pair along this axis .
the color magnetic field which also points along the flux tube axis ( which is parallel to the beam axis ) causes an up quark to rotate around the flux tube axis in one direction , while the anti - up quark is rotated in the other direction .
so when a pair of quarks and anti - quarks are formed they will pickup or lose transverse momentum after the bubble is boosted radial outwards due to radial flow of the blast wave .
these changes in @xmath2 will be transmitted to the @xmath5 @xmath6 pairs .
_ it is important to note that the cp violating asymmetries in @xmath5 and @xmath6 momenta arise through the witten - wess - zumino@xcite _ term .
the quarks and anti quarks which , later form the @xmath5 and @xmath6 , directly respond to the color electric and color magnetic fields and receive their boosts at the quark and anti quark level before they are pions . these boosts are transmitted to the pions at hadronization .
thus no external magnetic field is required in the methodology followed in this paper .
the following references demonstrate this:@xcite . _ _ to represent the color electric field effect we assume as the first step for the results being shown in this paper ; that we generate bubbles which have an added boost of 100 mev / c to the quarks in the longitudinal momentum which represents the color electric effect .
the @xmath5 and the @xmath6 which form a pair are boosted in opposite directions along the beam axis . in a given bubble
all the boosts are the same but vary in direction from bubble to bubble . for the color magnetic field effect
, we give 100 mev / c boosts to the transverse momentum in an opposite way to the @xmath5 and the @xmath6 which form a pair .
for each pair on one side of a bubble one of the charged pions boost is increased and the other is decreased .
while on the other side of the bubble the pion for which the boost was increased is now decreased and the pion which was decreased is now increased by the 100 mev / c .
all pairs for a given bubble are treated in the same way however each bubble is random on the sign of the pion which is chosen to be boosted on a given side .
this addition to our model is used in the simulations of the following subsections . above we saw
that pairs of positive and negative pions should show a charge separation along the beam axis due to a boost in longitudinal momentum caused by the color electric field .
a measure of this separation should be a difference in the pseudorapidity ( @xmath9 ) of the opposite sign pairs .
this @xmath9 measure has a well defined sign since we defined this difference measuring from the @xmath6 to the @xmath5 . in order to form a correlation we must pick two pairs for comparison .
the pairs have to come from the same bubble ( a final state of an expanded flux tube ) since we have shown by investigating the events generated by the model that pairs originating from different bubbles will not show this correlation
. therefore we require the @xmath5 and the @xmath6 differ by @xmath29 or less in @xmath10 .
let us call the first pair @xmath32 .
the next pair ( @xmath33 having the same @xmath10 requirement ) has to also lie inside the same bubble to show this correlation .
thus we require that there is only @xmath34 between the average @xmath10 of the pairs .
this implies that at most in @xmath10 no two pions from a given bubble can differ by more than @xmath19 . in fig .
15 we show two pairs which would fall into the above cuts . @xmath32 and @xmath33 are positive in fig .
however if we would interchange the @xmath5 and @xmath6 on either pair the value of its @xmath9 would change sign .
finally the mean value shown on fig .
15 is the mid - point between the @xmath5 and the @xmath6 where one really uses the vector sum of the @xmath5 and the @xmath6 which moves this point toward the harder pion . considering the above cuts we defined a correlation function where we combine pairs each having a @xmath9 .
our variable is related to the sum of the absolute values of the individual @xmath9 s ( @xmath35 ) .
we assign a sign to this sum such that if the sign of the individual @xmath9 s are the same it is a plus sign , while if they are different it is a minus sign . for the flux tube
the color electric field extends over a large pseudorapidity range therefore let us consider the separation of pairs @xmath36 greater than 0.9 . for the numerator of the correlation function
we consider all combinations of unique pairs ( sign ( @xmath35 ) ) from a given central au au event divided by a mixed event denominator created from pairs in different events .
we determine the rescale of the mixed event denominator by considering the number of pairs of pairs for the case @xmath37 lying between @xmath38 and @xmath39 for events and mixed events so that the overall ratio of this sample numerator to denominator is 1 . by picking @xmath38 @xmath1 @xmath37 @xmath1 @xmath39
we make sure we are not choosing pairs from the same bubble . for a simpler notation let ( sign ( @xmath35 ) )
= @xmath40 which varies from -4 to + 4 since we have an over all @xmath8 acceptance -1 to + 1 ( for the star tpc detector for which we calculated ) . the value being near @xmath41 4 can happen when one has a hard pion with @xmath2 of 4 gev / c ( upper cut ) at @xmath8 = 1 with a soft pion @xmath2 of 0.8 gev / c ( lower cut ) at @xmath8 = -1 combined with another pair ; a hard pion with @xmath2 of 4 gev / c at @xmath8 = -1 with a soft pion with @xmath2 of 0.8 gev / c at @xmath8 = 1 . in fig .
we show the correlation function of opposite sign charge - particle - pairs paired and binned by the variable @xmath40 with a cut @xmath36 greater than 0.9 between the vector sums of the two pairs .
the events are generated by the pbm@xcite and are charged particles of 0.8 @xmath1 @xmath2 @xmath1 4.0 gev / c , and @xmath42 @xmath1 1 , from au au collisions at @xmath11 200 gev .
since we select pairs of pairs which are near each other in @xmath10 they all together pick up the bubble correlation and thus these pairs of pairs over all show about a 4% correlation . in the 1.0 @xmath1 @xmath40
@xmath1 2.0 region the correlation is 0.5% larger than the -2.0 @xmath1 @xmath40 @xmath1 -1.0 region .
this means there are more pairs of pairs aligned in the same direction compared to pairs of pairs not aligned .
this alignment is what is predicted by the color electric field effect presented above .
in fact if one has plus minus pairs all aligned in the same direction and spread across a pseudorapidity range , locally at any place in the pseudorapidity range one would observe an increase of unlike sign charge pairs compared to like sign charge pairs . at small @xmath9 unlike sign charge pairs are much larger than like sign charge pairs in both the pbm and the data which agree .
10 , 11 , and 14 of ref.@xcite .
figure 11 of ref.@xcite compares the total correlation for unlike - sign charge pairs and like - sign charge pairs in the precision star central production experiment for au au central collisions ( 0 - 10% centrality ) at @xmath0=200 gev , in the transverse momentum range 0.8 @xmath1 @xmath2 @xmath1 2.0 gev / c@xcite .
the unlike - sign charge pairs are clearly larger in the region near @xmath12 = @xmath9 = 0.0 .
the increased correlation of the unlike - sign pairs is 0.8% @xmath41 0.002% .
figure 10 of ref.@xcite shows that the pbm fit to these data gives the same results .
figure 14 of ref.@xcite shows that the cd = unlike - sign charge pairs minus like - sign charge pairs is positive for the experimental analysis .
therefore the unlike - sign charge pairs are considerably larger than the like - sign charge pairs .
in fact this effect is so large and the alignment is so great that when one adds the unlike and like sign charge pairs correlations together there is still a dip at small @xmath9 and @xmath12 see fig .
4 and fig . 7 of the present paper .
the statistical significance of this dip in the two high precision experiments done independently from different data sets gathered 2 years apart@xcite is huge .
it would require a fluctuation of @xmath43 to remove the dip .
this dip is also not due to any systematic error since both of the just cited precision experiments carefully investigated that possibility ; and found no evidence to challenge the reality of this dip .
this highly significant dip ( @xmath7@xmath43 ) means that like - sign pairs are removed as one approaches the region @xmath9 = @xmath12 = 0.0 at a rate much larger than regular jet fragmentation . jet fragmentation does not have a dip in its ci correlation
thus this is very strong evidence for the predicted effect of the color electric field . after considering the color electric effect we turn to the color magnetic effect which causes up quarks to rotate around the flux tube axis in one direction , while the anti - up quarks rotate in the other direction .
so when a pair of quarks and anti - quarks are formed they will pickup or lose transverse momentum .
these changes in @xmath2 will be transmitted to the @xmath5 and @xmath6 pairs .
_ it was previously shown in sec .
vii a that the cp violating asymmetries in the @xmath5 and the @xmath6 momenta arise through the witten - wess - zumino term .
the quarks and anti quarks which , later form the @xmath5 and the @xmath6 , directly respond to the color electric and color magnetic fields and receive their boosts at the quark and anti quark level before they hadronize into pions . these boosts are transmitted to the @xmath5 and the @xmath6 .
_ in order to observe these differential @xmath2 changes one must select pairs on one side of the bubble in @xmath10 and compare to other pairs on the other side of the same bubble which would lie around @xmath30 to @xmath44 away in @xmath10 .
we defined a pair as a plus particle and minus particle with an opening angle ( @xmath31 ) of @xmath45 or less .
we are also interested in pairs that are directly on the other side of the bubble .
we require they are near in pseudorapidity ( @xmath9 @xmath1 0.2 ) .
the above requirements constrain the four charged particles comprising both pairs to be contained in the same bubble and be close to being directly on opposite sides of the bubble ( a final state expanded flux tube ) . the difference in @xmath2 changes due to and
predicted by the color magnetic effect should give the @xmath5 on one side of the bubble an increased @xmath2 and a decreased @xmath2 on the other side , while for the @xmath6 it will be the other way around .
this will lead to an anti - alignment between pairs . in fig .
17 we show two pairs which would fall into the above cuts .
both pairs are at the limit of the opening angle cut @xmath46 and @xmath47 equal @xmath45 .
the @xmath2 of the plus particle for pair number 1 is 1.14 gev / c , while the minus particle is 1.39 gev / c .
thus @xmath48 is equal to -0.25 gev / c .
the @xmath2 of the plus particle for pair number 2 is 1.31 gev / c , the minus particle is 0.91 gev / c and @xmath49 is equal to 0.40 gev / c .
finally the mean value shown on fig .
17 is the mid - point between the @xmath5 and the @xmath6 where one really uses the vector sum of the @xmath5 and the @xmath6 which moves this point toward the harder pion . considering the above cuts we defined a correlation function where we combine pairs each having a @xmath50 .
our variable is related to the sum of the absolute values of the individual @xmath50 s ( @xmath51 ) .
we assign a sign to this sum such that if the sign of the individual @xmath50 s are the same it is a plus sign , while if they are different it is a minus sign . for the flux tube
the color magnetic field extends over a large pseudorapidity range where quarks and anti - quarks rotate around the flux tube axis , therefore we want to sample pairs at the different sides of the tube making a separation in @xmath10 ( @xmath12 ) between @xmath30 to @xmath44 .
we are interested in sampling the pairs on the other side so we require the separation in @xmath8 ( @xmath9 ) be 0.2 or less . for the numerator of the correlation function
we consider all combinations of unique pairs ( sign ( @xmath51 ) ) from a given central au au event divided by a mixed event denominator created from pairs in different events .
we determine the rescale of the mixed event denominator by considering the number of pairs of pairs for the case @xmath36 lying between 1.2 and 1.5 plus any value of @xmath37 for events and mixed events so that the overall ratio of this sample numerator to denominator is 1 . by picking this @xmath9 bin for all @xmath37
we have around the same pair count as the signal cut with the @xmath12 correlation of the bubbles being washed out . for a simpler notation let ( sign ( @xmath51 ) )
= @xmath52 which we plot in the range from -4 to + 4 since we have an over all @xmath2 range 0.8 to 4.0 gev / c .
thus the maximum magnitude of @xmath50 s is 3.2 gev / c which makes @xmath52 have a range of @xmath416.4 .
however the larger values near these range limits occur very rarely . in fig .
18 we show the correlation function of opposite sign charged - particle - pairs paired and binned by the variable @xmath52 with a cut @xmath36 less than 0.2 between the vector sums of the two pairs , and with @xmath30 @xmath1 @xmath37 @xmath1 @xmath44 .
the events are generated by the pbm@xcite and are charged particles of 0.8 @xmath1 @xmath2 @xmath1 4.0 gev / c , with @xmath42 @xmath53 1 , from au au collisions at @xmath11 200 gev .
since we select pairs of pairs which are near each other in @xmath10 ( @xmath30 to @xmath44 ) they all together pick up the bubble correlation and thus these pairs of pairs over all show about a 0.4% correlation . in the -4.0 @xmath1 @xmath52 @xmath1 -1.0 region
the correlation increases from 0.4% to 1% , while in the 1.0 @xmath1 @xmath52 @xmath1 4.0 region the correlation decreases from 0.4% to -0.2% .
this means the pairs of pairs are anti - aligned at a higher rate than aligned .
this anti - alignment is what is predicted by the color magnetic field effect presented above .
in fact the anti - alignment increases with @xmath2 as the ratio bubble particle to background increases .
however these predicted color magnetic effects have not been searched for yet and therefore there is no experimental evidence for them .
experimental investigations of star tpc detector charged particle correlations provide a method of obtaining experimental confirmation of the anti - alignment caused by the color magnetic field .
in this article we summarize the assumptions made and the reasoning that led to the development and construction of our parton bubble model ( pbm)@xcite , which successfully explained the charge - particle - pair correlations in the central ( 0 - 10% centrality ) @xmath11 200 gev au au data@xcite .
the pbm is also consistent with the au au central collision hbt results .
this is presented and discussed in sec .
4 of ref.@xcite and sec .
i and ii of this paper . in sec .
iii we discussed extending our model , which was a central collision model , to be able to treat the geomery of bubble production for 0 - 80% collision centralities ( pbme@xcite ) such as measured and analyzed in rhic data@xcite .
the bubbles represent a significant substructure of gluonic hot spots formed on the surface of a dense opaque fireball at kinetic freezeout .
the origins of these hot spots come from a direct connection between our parton bubble model ( pbm@xcite ) and the glasma flux tube model ( gftm)@xcite ) . in the gftm
a flux tube is formed right after the initial collision of the au au system .
this flux tube extends over many units of pseudorapidity ( @xmath9 ) .
a blast wave gives the tubes near the surface transverse flow in the same way it gave flow to the bubbles in the pbm .
this means the transverse momentum ( @xmath2 ) distribution of the flux tube is directly translated to the @xmath2 spectrum . in the pbm
this flux tube is approximated by a sum of partons which are distributed over this same large @xmath9 region .
initially the transverse space is filled with flux tubes of large longitudinal extent but small transverse size @xmath7@xmath23 .
the flux tubes that are near the surface of the fireball get the largest radial flow and are emitted from the surface . as in the parton bubble model these partons shower and the higher @xmath2 particles escape the surface and do not interact .
@xmath22 is around 1 gev / c thus the size of the flux tube is about 1/4 fm initially .
the flux tubes near the surface are initially at a radius @xmath75 fm .
the @xmath10 angle wedge of the flux tube @xmath7 1/20 radians or @xmath7@xmath24 . in sec . v
( also see sec .
iv ) we connect the gftm to the pbm : by assuming the bubbles are the final state of a flux tube at kinetic freezeout , and discussing evidence for this connection which is further developed in sec . vi and sec .
vii . with the connection of the pbm to the gftm two new predictions become possible for our pbm .
the first is related to the fact that the blast wave radial flow given to the flux tube depends on where the tube is initially in the transverse plane of the colliding au au system .
the tube gets the same radial boost all along its longitudinal length .
this means that there is correlated @xmath2 among the partons of the bubble . in this paper
we consider predictions we can make in regard to interesting topics and comparisons with relevant data which exist by utilizing the parton bubble model ( pbm@xcite ) , and its features related to the glasma flux tube model ( gftm)@xcite ) .
topic 1 : the ridge is treated in sec .
topic 2 : strong cp violation ( chern - simons topological charge ) is treated in sec .
we show in sec .
vi that if we trigger on particles with 3 to 4 gev / c and correlate this trigger particle with an other charged particle of greater than 1.1 gev / c , the pbm can produce a phenomenon very similar to the ridge@xcite .
( see figs .
we then selected charged particles inside the ridge and predicted the correlation that one should observe when compared to the average charged particles of the central au au collisions at @xmath0 = 200 gev@xcite . in sec .
vi d ( comparison to data ) : triggered experimental angular correlations showing the ridge were presented at quark matter 2006@xcite .
figure 7 shows the experimental @xmath12 vs. @xmath9 ci correlation for 0 - 10% central au au collisions at @xmath0 = 200 ; requiring one trigger particle @xmath2 between 3 to 4 gev / c and an associated particle @xmath2 above 2.0 gev / c .
the yield is corrected for the finite @xmath9 pair acceptance . for the pbm generator
, we then form a two charged particle correlation between one charged particle with a @xmath2 between 3.0 to 4.0 gev / c and another charged particle whose @xmath2 is greater than 2.0 gev / c .
these are the same trigger conditions as in ref.@xcite which is shown in fig . 11 , that shows the corrected pair yield in the central data .
12 shows the correlation function generated by the pbm which does not depend on the number of events analyzed .
the two figures were shown to be in reasonable agreement when compared as explained previously in sec .
vi d. in fig .
13 we show the ridge signal predicted by the pbm for very similar data but with 0 - 5% centrality .
figure 14 shows the extraction of the jet signal .
explanations are given in the text .
the second prediction is a development of a predictive pionic measure of the strong cp violation .
the gftm flux tubes are made up of longitudinal color electric and magnetic fields which generate topological chern - simons charge@xcite through the @xmath3 term that becomes a source of cp violation .
the color electric field which points along the flux tube axis causes an up quark to be accelerated in one direction along the beam axis , while the anti - up quark is accelerated in the other direction .
so when a pair of quarks and anti - quarks are formed they separate along the beam axis leading to a separated @xmath5 and @xmath6 pair along this axis . the color magnetic field which also points along the flux tube axis ( which is parallel to the beam axis ) causes an up quark to rotate around the flux tube axis in one direction , while the anti - up quark rotates in the other direction .
so when a pair of quarks and anti - quarks are formed they will pickup or lose transverse momentum .
these changes in @xmath2 will be transmitted to the @xmath5 and @xmath6 pairs .
the above pionic measures of strong cp violation are used to form correlation functions based on four particles composed of two pairs which are opposite sign charge - particle - pairs that are paired and binned .
these four particle correlations accumulate from bubble to bubble by particles that are pushed or pulled ( by the color electric field ) and rotated ( by the color magnetic field ) in a right or left handed direction .
the longitudinal color electric field predicts aligned pairs in a pseudorapidity or @xmath9 measure .
the longitudinal color magnetic field predicts anti - aligned pairs in a transverse momentum or @xmath50 measure .
the observations of these correlations would be a strong confirmation of this theory .
the much larger unlike - sign pairs than like - sign pairs in the pbm and the data ; and the strong dip of the ci correlation at small @xmath9 ( see fig . 4 and sec .
vii c for full details ) shows very strong evidence supporting the color electric alignment prediction in the @xmath0 = 200 gev central au au collision data analyses at rhic@xcite .
this highly significant dip ( @xmath7@xmath43 ) means that like - sign pairs are removed as one approaches the region
@xmath9 = @xmath12 = 0.0 .
thus this is very strong evidence for the predicted effect of the color electric field .
the color magnetic anti - aligned pairs in the transverse momentum prediction , treated in sec .
vii d as of now has not been observed or looked for .
however our predicted specific four charged particle correlations can be used to search for experimental evidence for the color magnetic fields .
our success in demonstrating strong experimental evidence for the expected color electric field effects from previously published data suggests that the unique detailed correlations we have presented for searching for evidence for the predicted color magnetic field effects should be urgently investigated .
if we are lucky and the predicted color magnetic effects can be confirmed experimentally we would have strong evidence for the following : \1 ) cp is violated in the strong interaction in isolated local space time regions where topological charge@xcite is generated .
\2 ) the glasma flux tube model ( gftm ) which was evolved from the color glass condensate ( cgc ) would be found to be consistent with a very significant experimental check .
\3 ) the parton bubble model event generator ( pbm ) is clearly closely connected to the gftm .
the bubble substructure strongly supported by the pbm is likely due to the final state of the flux tube at kinetic freezeout .
this research was supported by the u.s .
department of energy under contract no .
de - ac02 - 98ch10886 .
the author thank william love for valuable discussion and assistance in production of figures .
finally this manuscript is in memory of my fellow collaborator prof .
sam lindenbaum which help form many of the ideas of bubbles in heavy ion collisions .
99 l. van hove , z. phys .
c 27 , 135 ( 1985 ) .
lindenbaum , r.s .
longacre , j. phys .
g 26 , 937 ( 2000 ) .
d. kharzeev , r.d .
pisarski , phys . rev .
d 61 , 111901 ( 2000 ) . c. adler _ et al .
87 , 082301 ( 2001 ) .
lindenbaum , r.s .
longacre m. kramer , eur .
j. c. 30 , 241 ( 2003 ) .
lindenbaum , r.s .
longacre , eur .
j. c. 49 , 767 - 782 ( 2007 ) .
j. adams _ et al .
_ , phys . rev .
c. 71 , 044906 ( 2005 ) , s.s .
adler _ et al .
_ , phys rev .
93 , 152302 ( 2004 ) . x.n .
wang and m. gyulassy , phys .
d 44 , 3501 ( 1991 ) .
k. adcox _ et al .
88 , 022301 ( 2001 ) .
nucl . instrum .
meth . a 499,(2003 ) , c. adler et al . , 433 - 436 , k.h . ackermann et al.(star collaboration ) , 624 - 632 , m. anderson et al . , 659 - 678 , f.s . bieser et al . , 766 - 777
. t. sjostrand , m. van zijil , phys . rev .
d 36 , 2019 ( 1987 ) .
j. adams _ et al .
c 75 , 034901 ( 2007 ) .
lindenbaum and r.s .
longacre , phys . rev .
c 78 , 054904 ( 2008 ) .
abelev _ et al .
_ , arxiv:0806.0513[nucl - ex ]
. j. adams _ et al .
91 , 172302 ( 2003 ) .
a. adare _ et al .
lett . 101 , 232301 ( 2008 ) .
a. dumitru , f. gelis , l. mclerran and r. venugopalan , nucl .
a 810 , 91 ( 2008 ) .
l. mclerran and r. venugopalan , phys . rev .
d 49 , 2233 ( 1994 ) ; phys .
d 49 , 3352 ( 1994 ) ; phys .
d 50 , 2225 ( 1994 ) .
t. lappi and l. mclerran , nucl .
phys . a 772 , 200 ( 2006 ) .
f. gelis and r. venugopalan , acta phys .
b 37 , 3253 ( 2006 ) .
d. kharzeev , a. krasnitz and r. venugopalan , phys . lett .
b 545 , 298 ( 2002 ) .
s. gavin , l. mclerran and g. moschelli , eur .
j. c. 62 , 277 - 280 ( 2009 ) .
n. armesto , c. salgado , u.a .
wiedemann , phys rev .
93 , 242301 ( 2004 ) .
p. romatschke , phys .
c. 75 , 014901 ( 2007 ) .
e. shuryak , phys .
rev . c. 76 , 047901
a. dumitru , y. nara , b. schenke , m. strickland , phys .
c 78 , 024909 ( 2008 ) .
pantuev , arxiv:0710.1882[hep - ph ] .
r. mizukawa , t. hirano , m. isse , y. nara , a. ohnishi , j. phys .
g 35 , 104083 ( 2008 ) .
wong , phys .
rev . c. 78 , 064905 ( 2008 ) .. r.c .
hwa , arxiv:0708.1508[nucl - th ] .
j. putschke , j. phys .
34 , s679 ( 2007 ) . c. vafa , e. witten , phys .
53 , 535 ( 1984 ) , nucl .
b 234 , 173 ( 1984 ) .
d. kharzeev , r.d .
pisarski , m.h.g .
tytgat , phys .
81 , 512 ( 1998 ) . c. vafa , e. witten , nucl . phys .
b 233 , 422 ( 1983 ) . j. wess , and b. zumino , phys . lett .
37b , 95 ( 1971 ) l.e .
finch _ et al .
c 65 , 014908 ( 2001 ) . | in an earlier paper we developed a parton bubble model ( pbm ) for rhic , high - energy heavy - ion collisions . pbm was based on a substructure of a ring of localized bubbles ( gluonic hot spots ) which initially contain 3 - 4 partons composed of almost entirely gluons .
the bubble ring was perpendicular to the collider beam direction , centered on the beam , at midrapidity , and located on the expanding fireball surface of au au central collisions ( 0 - 10% ) at @xmath0=200 gev .
the bubbles emitted correlated particles at kinetic freezeout , leading to a lumpy fireball surface . for a selection of charged particles ( 0.8 gev / c
@xmath1 @xmath2 @xmath1 4.0 gev / c ) , the pbm reasonably quantitatively ( within a few percent ) explained high precision rhic experimental correlation analyses in a manner which was consistent with the small observed hbt source size in this transverse momentum range .
we demonstrated that surface emission from a distributed set of surface sources ( as in the pbm ) was necessary to obtain this consistency . in this paper
we give a review of the above comparison to central au au collisions .
the bubble formation can be associated with gluonic objects predicted by a glasma flux tube model ( gftm ) that formed longitudinal flux tubes in the transverse plane of two colliding sheets of color glass condensate ( cgc ) , which pass through one another .
these sheets create boost invariant flux tubes of longitudinal color electric and magnetic fields .
a blast wave gives the tubes near the surface transverse flow in the same way it gave transverse flow to the bubbles in the pbm . in this paper
we also consider the equivalent characteristics of the pbm and gftm and connect the two models .
in the gftm the longitudinal color electric and magnetic fields have a non - zero topological charge density @xmath3 .
these fields cause a local strong cp violation which effects charged particle production coming from quarks and anti - quarks created in the tube or bubble .
# 1#2#3#4#1 * # 2 * , # 3 ( # 4 ) |
in a markovian model for an equity market with mean rates of return @xmath0 and covariance rates @xmath1 , @xmath2 , for its asset capitalizations @xmath3 at time @xmath4 , what is the highest return on investment [ as in ( [ maxretinv ] ) below ] that can be achieved relative to the market on a given time
horizon @xmath5 $ ] , using nonanticipative investment strategies ?
what are the weights assigned to the different assets by such an investment strategy that accomplishes this ? answers : under suitable conditions , @xmath6 and @xmath7,\ ] ] respectively . here
$ ] is the smallest nonnegative solution of the linear parabolic partial differential inequality @xmath9 subject to the initial condition @xmath10 , for the linear operator @xmath11 with @xmath12 , @xmath13 and @xmath14 .
furthermore , @xmath15 is the probability that the @xmath16-valued diffusion process @xmath17 with infinitesimal generator @xmath18 as above and @xmath19 does not hit the boundary of the orthant @xmath20 by time @xmath21 .
we note that the answers involve only the covariance structure of the market , not the actual rates of return ; the only role these latter play is to ensure that the diffusion @xmath22 lives in @xmath23 .
arbitrage relative to the market exists on @xmath5 $ ] , iff @xmath24 ; this is deeply related to the importance of _ strict local martingales _ in the present context , and amounts to failure of uniqueness for the cauchy problem @xmath25 sufficient conditions for such failure of uniqueness are provided .
consider an `` auxiliary market '' with capitalizations @xmath26 as above .
the probabilistic significance of the change of drift inherent in the definition of the operator @xmath18 , from @xmath27 for @xmath28 to @xmath29 for @xmath30 , is that it corresponds to a change of probability measure which makes the weights @xmath31 , of the auxiliary market portfolio martingales .
its financial significance is that it bestows to the auxiliary market portfolio @xmath32 the so - called _ numraire property _ : any strategy s relative performance in the market with capitalizations @xmath30 is a supermartingale , so this market can not be outperformed .
this change need not come from a girsanov - type ( absolutely continuous ) transformation ; rather it corresponds to , and represents , the _ exit measure _ of fllmer ( @xcite ) for an appropriate supermartingale .
sections [ sec2 ] and [ sec3 ] set up the model , whereas section [ sec4 ] introduces the notion and offers examples of relative arbitrage ; section [ sec5 ] makes the connection with strict local martingales . section [ sec6 ] formulates the problem , and section [ sec7 ] offers some preliminary results , actually in some modest generality ( including non - markovian cases ) . section [ sec8 ] sets up the markovian model ; the results are presented in earnest in sections [ sec9][sec11 ] , section [ sec12 ] discusses a couple of examples in detail and a few open questions are raised in section [ sec13 ] .
_ related literature _ : the questions raised in this study are related to the work of delbaen and schachermayer ( @xcite ) .
they bear an even closer connection with issues raised in the finance literature under the general rubric of `` bubbles '' [ see definition 5 and theorem 1 in ruf ( @xcite ) for the precise connection ] .
the literature on this topic is large , so let us mention the papers by loewenstein and willard ( @xcite ) , pal and protter ( @xcite ) and , most significantly , heston , loewenstein and willard ( @xcite ) , as the closest in spirit to our approach here .
we note the recent preprint by hugonnier ( @xcite ) , which demonstrates that arbitrage opportunities can arise in equilibrium models ; this preprint , and heston , loewenstein and willard ( @xcite ) , can be consulted for an up - to - date survey of the literature on this subject and for some explicit computations of trading strategies that lead to arbitrage .
the need to consider state - price - density processes that are only local ( as opposed to true ) martingales has also been noticed in the context of `` stochastic volatility '' models [ e.g. , sin ( @xcite ) , wong and heyde ( @xcite ) ] and of pricing with long maturities [ e.g. , hulley and platen ( @xcite ) ] .
we consider a model consisting of a money - market @xmath33 , @xmath34 and of @xmath35 stocks with capitalizations , @xmath36 for @xmath37 . these are defined on a probability space @xmath38 and
are driven by the brownian motion @xmath39 whose @xmath40 independent components are the model s `` factors .
'' we shall assume throughout that the interest rate process of the money - market is @xmath41 , identically equal to zero ; and that the vector - valued process @xmath42 of capitalizations , the vector - valued process @xmath43 of _ mean rates of return _ for the various stocks and the @xmath44-matrix - valued process @xmath45 of _ volatilities _ are all progressively measurable with respect to a right - continuous filtration @xmath46 which represents the `` flow of information '' in the market with @xmath47 , @xmath48 .
let @xmath49 be the _ covariance process _ of the stocks in the market , and impose for @xmath50-a.e .
@xmath51 the condition @xmath52 under this condition the processes @xmath53 can be expressed as @xmath54 . in this
setting , the brownian motion @xmath55 need not be adapted to the `` observations '' filtration @xmath56 .
it _ is _ adapted , though , to the @xmath50-augmentation @xmath57 of the filtration @xmath58 , provided that @xmath59 and that the matrix - valued process @xmath60 is invertible as in assumption [ assumptionb ] below .
consider now a _ small investor _ who decides , at each time @xmath4 , which proportion @xmath61 of current wealth @xmath62 to invest in the @xmath63th stock , @xmath64 ; the proportion @xmath65 gets invested in the money market .
thus , the wealth @xmath66 for an initial capital @xmath67 and an investment strategy @xmath68 satisfies the initial condition @xmath69 and @xmath70\\[-8pt ] & = & \pi'(t ) [ \beta(t)\ , d t + \sigma(t)\ , d w ( t ) ] .\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] we shall call _ investment strategy _ a @xmath71-progressively measurable process @xmath72,@xmath73 which satisfies for @xmath74-a.e . @xmath75 the analogue @xmath76 of ( [ 1.2 ] )
. the collection of investment strategies will be denoted by @xmath77 . a strategy @xmath78 with @xmath79 for all @xmath80 will be called _
portfolio_. a portfolio never invests in the money market and never borrows from it .
we shall say that a process @xmath81 is _ bounded _ , if for it there exists a real constant @xmath82 such that @xmath83 holds for all @xmath84 .
we shall call _ long - only portfolio _ one that satisfies @xmath85 , that is , never sells any stock short .
clearly , a long - only portfolio is also bounded .
corresponding to an investment strategy @xmath86 and initial capital @xmath87 , the associated wealth process , that is , the solution of ( [ 1.8 ] ) , is @xmath88 the strategy @xmath89 invests only in the money market at all times ; it results in @xmath90 , that is , in hoarding the initial wealth under the mattress .
an important long - only portfolio is the market portfolio ; this invests in all stocks in proportion to their relative weights , @xmath91 clearly @xmath92 , and the resulting vector process @xmath93,@xmath94 of market weights takes values in the positive simplex @xmath95 of @xmath96 .
an application of it s rule gives , after some computation , the dynamics of this process as @xmath97,\qquad i = 1,\ldots , n .\ ] ] here @xmath98 is the matrix with entries @xmath99 , @xmath100 the @xmath63th unit vector in @xmath101 and the vector @xmath102 has @xmath103
the following notion was introduced in fernholz ( @xcite ) : given a real number @xmath104 and any two investment strategies @xmath86 and @xmath105 , we call @xmath106 an _ arbitrage relative to _ @xmath107 over @xmath108 $ ] , if @xmath109 we call such relative arbitrage _ strong _ if @xmath110 . arbitrage ( resp . , strong arbitrage )
relative to @xmath111 that invests only in the money market , is called just that , without the qualifier `` relative . '' here
are some examples taken from the survey fernholz and karatzas ( @xcite ) , especially sections 7 and 8 , remark 11.4 , examples 11.1 and 11.2 .
suppose first that @xmath112 holds almost surely for some constant @xmath113 .
then the long - only portfolio @xmath114 , @xmath115 is , for sufficiently large @xmath116 , a strong arbitrage relative to the market portfolio @xmath117 over any time
horizon @xmath108 $ ] with @xmath118 .
another condition guaranteeing the existence of strong arbitrage relative to the market is that there exists a real constant @xmath119 with @xmath120{\mu_1 ( t ) \cdots\mu_n ( t ) } \biggl [ \sum_{i=1}^n \alpha_{ii } ( t)- { 1 \over n } \sum_{i=1}^n \sum_{j=1}^n \alpha_{ij } ( t ) \biggr ] \ge h \qquad \forall\,0 \le t < \infty\ ] ] a.s .
then for @xmath121 sufficiently large , the long - only portfolio @xmath122 , @xmath123 , @xmath124 , is strong arbitrage relative to the market over any @xmath108 $ ] with @xmath125 .
[ remark1 ] suppose that all the eigenvalues of the covariance matrix - valued process @xmath126 are bounded away from both zero and infinity , uniformly on @xmath127 , and that ( [ intvol ] ) holds .
then , for any given constant @xmath128 , the long - only portfolio @xmath129 , @xmath130 , leads again to strong arbitrage relative to the market portfolio over sufficiently long time
it is also of great interest that appropriate modifications of the portfolio @xmath131 yield such arbitrage over _ any _ time
horizon @xmath108 $ ] .
we shall assume from now on that there exists a _ market price of risk _
@xmath132 , an @xmath133-progressively measurable process that satisfies @xmath134\\[-8pt ] & \displaystyle\mathbb{p } \biggl ( \int_0^t \|\vartheta(t , \omega ) \|^2 \,d t <
\infty,\,\forall\ , t \in(0,\infty ) \biggr ) = 1.&\nonumber % \end{aligned}\ ] ] the existence of a market - price - of - risk process @xmath135 allows us to introduce an associated exponential local martingale , @xmath136 this process is also a supermartingale ; it is a martingale , if and only if @xmath137 holds for all @xmath138 . for the purposes of this work it is important to allow such exponential processes to be strict local martingales
; that is , not to exclude the possibility @xmath139 for some @xmath138 . from ( [ z ] ) and ( [ 1.8 ] ) , now written in the form @xmath140 on the strength of ( [ th ] ) , the product rule of it
s calculus shows that @xmath141 is a positive local martingale and a supermartingale , for every @xmath142 .
if @xmath143 is invertible , we can take @xmath144 as market price of risk in ( [ th ] ) .
if @xmath145 holds we can select @xmath146 and get @xmath147 from ( [ 1.10 ] ) ; there is then no arbitrage relative to the market because @xmath148 _ is a supermartingale for all _ @xmath149 ; thus @xmath150\le1 $ ] , a conclusion at odds with ( [ ao ] ) .
suppose the covariance process @xmath126 isbounded , and ( [ ao ] ) holds for two bounded portfolios @xmath151 and @xmath105 .
then , for _ any _ market - price - of - risk process @xmath135 as in ( [ th ] ) , the positive local martingales @xmath152 and @xmath153 of ( [ z ] ) , ( [ 1.10 ] ) are strict : @xmath154 < v $ ] , @xmath155 [ fernholz and karatzas ( @xcite ) , section 6 ] . in particular , if the matrix @xmath126 is bounded , and ( [ ao ] ) holds for some bounded portfolio @xmath86 and for the market portfolio @xmath156 ( these assumptions are satisfied , e.g. , under the conditions in remark [ remark1 ] ) , then @xmath157 < x(0 ) , \nonumber\\[-8pt]\\[-8pt ] & & \mathbb{e } [ z(t ) x_i(t ) ] < x_i(0),\qquad i=1,\ldots , n
.\nonumber % \end{aligned}\ ] ]
the possibility of strong arbitrage relative to the market , defined and exemplified in section [ sec4 ] , raises an obvious question : _ what is the best possible arbitrage of this kind _ ?
one way to cast this question is as follows : on a given time
horizon @xmath5 $ ] , what is the _
smallest _ relative amount , @xmath158 of initial capital , starting with which one can match or exceed at time @xmath21 the market capitalization @xmath159 ? clearly , @xmath160 ; and for @xmath161 , no strategy starting with initial capital @xmath162 can outperform the market almost surely , over the horizon @xmath5 $ ] .
that is , for every @xmath163 and @xmath161 , we have @xmath164 < 1 $ ] . we shall impose from now on the following structural assumptions on the filtration @xmath165 , the `` flow of information '' in the market . [ assumptiona ] every local martingale of the filtration @xmath133 can be represented as a stochastic integral , with respect to the driving brownian motion @xmath166 in ( [ 1.1 ] ) , of some @xmath167-progressively measurable integrand .
[ assumptionb ] we have @xmath59 , and @xmath168 is invertible , @xmath169 $ ] . under these two assumptions , general results about hedging in so - called complete markets [ e.g. , karatzas and shreve ( @xcite ) , fernholz and karatzas ( @xcite ) , section 10 or ruf ( @xcite ) ] based on martingale representation results , show that the quantity of ( [ c.3 ] ) given as @xmath170 / x(0 ) ; \qquad\mbox{that } v^ { \mathfrak{u } ( t ) x(0 ) , \widehat{\pi } } ( t ) = x(t)\ ] ] holds a.s . for some @xmath171 ; and that @xmath172 gives the highest return , @xmath173 on investment , that one can achieve relative to the market over @xmath5 $ ] .
arbitrage relative to the market is possible on @xmath5 $ ] , if and only if @xmath174 .
the result in ( [ c.5 ] ) provides no information about the strategy @xmath175 that implements this `` best possible '' arbitrage , apart from ascertaining its existence . in section [ sec8 ] we shall specialize the model of ( [ 1.1 ] ) to a markovian context and describe @xmath175 in terms of partial differential equations ( section [ sec11 ] ) .
we shall also characterize the quantity @xmath176 in terms of the smallest solution to a parabolic partial differential inequality , and as the probability of nonabsorption by time @xmath177 for a suitable diffusion ( theorems [ theorem1 ] , [ theorem2 ] ) .
assumption [ assumptiona ] holds when @xmath56 is ( the augmentation of ) @xmath178 , the filtration generated by the brownian motion @xmath55 ; as well as when assumption [ assumptionb ] holds , the @xmath179 are all progressively measurable with respect to @xmath180 , @xmath181 , and @xmath182 [ jacod ( @xcite ) ] .
the positive local martingale @xmath183 , whose expectation appears in ( [ c.5 ] ) , can be expressed as @xmath184 for @xmath185 .
here we have solved equation ( [ 1.10 ] ) for @xmath186 and set @xmath187 whence @xmath188 from ( [ th ] ) ; we thus re - cast ( [ 1.1 ] ) as @xmath189 .\ ] ] on the other hand , we note from ( [ c.7.aa ] ) , ( [ c.8 ] ) that the reciprocal of the exponential local martingale @xmath190 can be expressed as @xmath191 similarly , the reciprocal of the local martingale @xmath192 is @xmath193 where @xmath194 and @xmath195 . comparing ( [ c.7.bb ] ) and ( [ c.7.bba ] ) , we observe that @xmath196 and cast the dynamics of ( [ 2.2 ] ) and ( [ 2.4 ] ) for the market portfolio @xmath197 as @xmath198 if @xmath199 , that is , @xmath200 is a martingale on @xmath5 $ ] , no arbitrage relative to the market is possible on this time
horizon ; the `` reference '' measure @xmath201 / x(0 ) , \qquad a\in \mathcal{f } ( t),\ ] ] is a probability , that is , @xmath202 ; and under @xmath203 , the process @xmath204 , in ( [ c.8 ] ) is a brownian motion by the girsanov theorem , so from ( [ 2.2.a ] ) the market weights @xmath205 are martingales . we shall characterize next @xmath176 in terms of the _ fllmer exit measure _ , of a `` generalized martingale measure '' and of a measure @xmath206 with respect to which @xmath207 is locally absolutely continuous [ equations ( [ c.6a ] ) , ( [ c.6b ] ) ] and which plays , to a considerable extent , the rle of @xmath203 when @xmath208 fails to be a @xmath50-martingale .
the processes of ( [ c.7.aa])([c.7.bba ] ) are important in this effort .
we shall assume in this section that the process @xmath209 of ( [ z ] ) is adapted to @xmath210 and that this filtration is , in turn , the right - continuous version @xmath211 of a _ standard system _ @xmath212 : to wit , each @xmath213 is isomorphic to the borel @xmath214-algebra of some polish space , and for any decreasing sequence @xmath215 such that @xmath216 is an atom of @xmath217 , for some increasing sequence @xmath218 , we have @xmath219 . the canonical example is the space @xmath220 of right - continuous paths @xmath221 , where @xmath222 is an additional `` absorbing point '' ; paths stay at @xmath222 once they get there , that is , after @xmath223 , and are continuous on @xmath224 .
if @xmath225 , then @xmath226 is a standard system [ see fllmer ( @xcite ) , the appendix ] . under these conditions
, we can associate to the @xmath227-local martingale @xmath228 a positive measure @xmath229 on the predictable @xmath230-algebra of @xmath231 \times\omega$ ] , @xmath232 \times a \bigr ) : = \mathbb{e } [ z(t ) x(t ) 1_a ] / x(0 ) , \qquad a \in\mathcal{f } ( t ) , t \in[0 , \infty ) , \ ] ] by invoking an extension result [ parthasarathy ( @xcite ) , theorem v.4.1 , whence the assumptions on the nature of the probability space ] .
this is the `` exit measure '' of the supermartingale @xmath208 , introduced by fllmer ( @xcite , @xcite ) [ see also delbaen and schachermayer ( @xcite ) , fllmer and gundel ( @xcite ) ] .
fllmer ( @xcite ) obtained a characterization of the ( process - theoretic ) properties of supermartingales , such as @xmath233 here , in terms of the properties of @xmath234 .
it follows from his work that @xmath200 is a : @xmath235 _ martingale _ , if and only if @xmath229 in concentrated on @xmath236 ; @xmath235 _ potential _ [ i.e. , @xmath237 , if and only if @xmath229 in concentrated on @xmath238 . from theorem 4 in delbaen and schachermayer ( @xcite ) and theorem 1 and
lemma 4 of pal and protter ( @xcite ) , the process @xmath239 of ( [ c.7.bb ] ) is a continuous martingale under some probability measure @xmath206 on the filtered space @xmath240 as above .
the measure @xmath207 is locally absolutely continuous with respect to @xmath206 , with @xmath241 on each @xmath242 ; and the process @xmath243 of ( [ c.8 ] ) is @xmath244-brownian motion [ cf .
ruf ( @xcite ) , section 5 ] .
thus , from ( [ 2.2.a ] ) _ the weights @xmath245 are martingales _ and satisfy @xmath246 a.e .
, under @xmath206 .
we consider the first time the process @xmath239 hits the origin , @xmath247 ( infinite , if the set is empty ) .
we have @xmath248 , but @xmath249 can be positive , so @xmath206 may not be absolutely continuous with respect to @xmath207 ; whereas , @xmath250-a.e . on @xmath251 , we have @xmath252 , @xmath253 and @xmath254 . intuitively , the role of the absorbing state @xmath222 is to account for events that have zero @xmath50-measure , but positive @xmath255-measure .
we also introduce the first times the processes @xmath256 and @xmath257 hit the origin , @xmath258 [ proposition1 ] the quantity of ( [ c.3 ] ) can be represented as @xmath259 \times\omega \bigr ) = \mathbb{q } ( \mathcal{t } >
t ) .\ ] ] suppose @xmath260 and that all capitalizations @xmath261 are real - valued @xmath255-a.e .
then we also have the @xmath255-a.e .
representations @xmath262 where @xmath263 .
this event has @xmath264-measure equal to zero , if for some real constant @xmath265 we have @xmath266 we note @xmath267 \times a ) = \mathbb { e}^\mathbb{p } ( \lambda^{-1 } ( t ) 1 _ { a \cap\ { \mathcal{t } > t \ } } ) = \mathbb{e}^\mathbb{q } ( \lambda(t ) \cdot\lambda^{-1 } ( t ) 1 _ { a \cap\ { \mathcal{t } > t \ } } ) = \mathbb{q } ( a \cap\ { \mathcal{t } > t \ } ) $ ] , @xmath268 . with @xmath269 ,
we get ( [ c.6a ] ) . for @xmath270 ,
this gives @xmath271 : all the weights @xmath272 are strictly positive [ equivalently , all @xmath273 take values in @xmath274 on @xmath275 , @xmath255-a.e .
recall @xmath276 , @xmath277 from ( [ c.7.bb ] ) , ( [ c.7.bba ] ) ; this gives@xmath278 on @xmath279 , and the first equation in ( [ c.6aa ] ) . on the event @xmath280 , for some @xmath281 we shall have @xmath282 , thus also @xmath283 and the second equation in ( [ c.6aa ] ) .
on the other hand , we have seen that @xmath284 , @xmath285 holds @xmath255-a.e .
on @xmath286 , so this equation is valid on @xmath287 . finally , from ( [ c.9 ] ) , ( [ c.7.bb ] ) : @xmath288 , @xmath289 for @xmath255-a.e .
. then ( [ c.6w ] ) implies @xmath291 , and @xmath292 gives @xmath293 , thus @xmath294 .
equation ( [ c.6a ] ) can be thought of as a `` generalized wald identity '' [ cf .
problem 3.5.7 in karatzas and shreve ( @xcite ) ] . in section [ sec93 ]
we shall obtain a characterization of the type ( [ c.6a ] ) in a markovian context , in terms of properties of an auxiliary diffusion and with the help of an appropriate partial differential equation .
this will enable us to describe the investment strategy that realizes the optimal arbitrage .
in a similar vein , there exists on the filtered space @xmath240 a probability measure @xmath295 under which @xmath296 is a martingale , and @xmath297 on each @xmath298 , whereas @xmath299 of ( [ v ] ) is @xmath300-brownian motion . under @xmath295 ,
the processes @xmath301 , @xmath302 are nonnegative local ( and super-)martingales , @xmath303 .
this justifies the appellation `` generalized martingale measure '' for @xmath304 .
defining @xmath305 , we have @xmath306 and @xmath152 _ is a strict @xmath50-local martingale if and only if @xmath307 _ [ a potential , if and only if @xmath308 ; and the expression of ( [ c.3 ] ) , ( [ c.5 ] ) is @xmath309 .\ ] ] this last expression takes the form @xmath310 $ ] when @xmath311 is a @xmath312-martingale ; from ( [ v ] ) , this will be the case under the novikov condition @xmath313 < \infty$ ] . moreover , @xmath314 ( no arbitrage relative to the market is possible on @xmath5 $ ] ) , if and only if : @xmath311 _ is a @xmath312-martingale , and @xmath315 holds @xmath316-a.e . _
we shall assume from now on that @xmath317 and that the processes @xmath318 , @xmath319 , @xmath320 in ( [ 1.1 ] ) are of the form @xmath321 here @xmath322 is the vector of capitalizations at time @xmath323 , and @xmath324 , @xmath325 are continuous functions .
we shall denote by @xmath326 and @xmath327 the vector and matrix , respectively , of these local rate - of - return and local volatility functions . with this setup ,
the vector process @xmath328 of capitalizations becomes a diffusion , with values in @xmath23 and dynamics @xmath329 where for @xmath330 we set @xmath331 , @xmath332 this diffusion @xmath28 has infinitesimal generator @xmath333 [ assumptionc ] for every @xmath334 , the matrix @xmath335 is invertible ; the system ( [ d.2 ] ) has a unique - in - distribution weak solution , with @xmath336 and values in @xmath23 ; and for @xmath337 , the following analogue of ( [ 1.2 ] ) , ( [ th ] ) holds for each @xmath338 : @xmath339 it follows from this assumption that the brownian motion @xmath340 is adapted to the augmentation of the filtration @xmath341 , and that @xmath342 is a market - price of risk process as postulated in ( [ th ] )
. the following conditions from bass and perkins ( @xcite ) , in particular their theorem 1.2 and corollary 1.3 , are sufficient for the existence of a weak solution for ( [ d.2 ] ) which is unique in distribution : the functions @xmath343 , @xmath344 of ( [ d.3 ] ) can be extended by continuity on all of @xmath345 ; @xmath346 and @xmath347 are hlder continuous on compact subsets of @xmath20 ; and we have @xmath348\\[-8pt ] \| \mathfrak{b } ( \mathbf{x})\| + \| \mathfrak{s } ( \mathbf{x})\| & \le & c ( 1 + \|\mathbf{x } \| ) \qquad \forall\,\mathbf{x } \in[0,\infty)^n,\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath349 for @xmath350 , @xmath351 , where @xmath352 is the boundary of @xmath20 .
[ remark2 ] the diffusion @xmath353 of ( [ d.2 ] ) takes values in @xmath354 , if and only if the diffusion @xmath355 , with dynamics @xmath356 and @xmath357 , takes values in @xmath354 . thus , any conditions guaranteeing the existence of a nonexplosive solution to the sdes of ( [ xi ] ) for all times , such as linear growth for @xmath358 and @xmath359 , also ensure that @xmath360 takes values in @xmath354 .
alternatively , one may invoke results of friedman ( @xcite ) , section 9.4 and chapter 11 , to obtain conditions on @xmath361 under which the diffusion @xmath360 of ( [ d.2 ] ) never attains any of the faces @xmath362 of @xmath363 .
in particular , if these functions can be extended by continuity on all of @xmath345 ; the @xmath364 are continuously differentiable ; the matrix @xmath365 degenerates on the faces of the orthant ; and the so - called _ fichera drifts _
@xmath366 are nonnegative on @xmath367 , for each @xmath37 ; then @xmath353 takes values in @xmath368 [ see friedman ( @xcite ) , theorem 9.4.1 and corollary 9.4.2 ] . [ assumptiond ] there exists @xmath369 of class @xmath370 , such that @xmath371 in light of assumption [ assumptionc ] , this new requirement amounts essentially to postulating that the vector field @xmath372 be conservative ; it is imposed here for technical reasons ( cf .
discussion in remark [ remark3 ] ) . under it ,
the generator of ( [ d.4 ] ) becomes @xmath373 $ ] , and we have @xmath374 _ throughout the remainder , assumptions [ assumptionb ] , [ assumptionc ] , [ assumptiond ] will be in force , and @xmath375 ; this is a natural choice , and consistent with assumption [ assumptiona ] . _
the uniqueness in distribution posited in assumption [ assumptionc ] implies that @xmath28 is strongly markovian ; we shall denote by @xmath377 the distribution of this process started at @xmath378 .
our objective now is to study @xmath379 / ( x_1 + \cdots+ x_n ) , \ ] ] the quantity of ( [ c.3 ] ) , ( [ c.5 ] ) in this diffusion context .
we start by observing that with @xmath380 as in assumption [ assumptiond ] and the notation of ( [ d.4 ] ) and ( [ d.7.a ] ) , it s rule gives @xmath381 , and the exponential local martingale @xmath152 of ( [ z ] ) becomes @xmath382 in particular , @xmath152 is @xmath383-adapted .
we are setting here @xmath384 , \\
\label{d.11 } g(\mathbf{x } ) & : = & e^ { - h(\mathbf{x } ) } \sum_{i=1}^n x_i , \qquad g(t , \mathbf{x } ) : = \mathbb{e}^{\mathbb{p}^{\mathbf{x } } } \bigl [ g ( \mathfrak{x}(t ) ) e^ { - \int_0^t k ( \mathfrak{x}(t ) ) \,dt } \bigr ] .\end{aligned}\ ] ] with this notation , the function of ( [ d.10.a ] ) becomes @xmath385 . a bit more generally , these considerations coupled with the markov property of @xmath28lead for any @xmath386 to the a.s .
\over x(t ) z(t ) } = { g(t - t , \mathbf{y } ) \over g(\mathbf{y } ) } \bigg| _ { \mathbf{\mathbf{y } } = \mathfrak{x } ( t ) } = u \bigl(t - t,\mathfrak{x } ( t ) \bigr ) .\ ] ] the following assumption [ assumptione ] will also be imposed from now onward .
_ it amounts to assuming that the function @xmath388 of is of class @xmath389 . _
note that ( [ d.12.a ] ) is satisfied , at least in the support of @xmath390 , thanks to the assumption @xmath391 and to the @xmath392-martingale property of the process @xmath393 .
[ assumptione ] the function @xmath394 in ( [ d.11 ] ) takes values in @xmath395 , is continuous on @xmath396 , of class @xmath389 on @xmath397 , and solves @xmath398 this cauchy problem is exactly the one arising in classical feynman kac theory [ see , for instance , friedman ( @xcite ) , sections 5.6 , 6.5 , karatzas and shreve ( @xcite ) , section 5.7 and janson and tysk ( @xcite ) ] . from theorem 1 and the remark following it in heath and schweizer ( @xcite ) , assumption [ assumptione ] holds if : the functions @xmath399 , @xmath400 of ( [ d.3 ] ) are continuously differentiable on @xmath395 and satisfy the growth condition in ( [ bp ] ) ; the functions @xmath401 of ( [ d.3 ] ) satisfy the nondegeneracy condition ( [ nondeg ] ) below ; the function @xmath402 in ( [ d.11 ] ) is hlder continuous , uniformly on compact subsets of @xmath23 ; the continuous function @xmath403 of ( [ d.10 ] ) is bounded from below ; and the function @xmath404 in ( [ d.11 ] ) is real - valued and continuous on @xmath405 . this latter requirement is satisfied , for instance , if the functions @xmath406 in ( [ xi ] ) obey linear growth conditions , and the function @xmath407 has polynomial growth [ see karatzas and shreve ( @xcite ) , problem 5.3.15 , as well as heath and schweizer ( @xcite ) , lemma 2 ( and the paragraph preceding it ) ]
. sustained computation shows then that the cauchy problem of ( [ d.12.a ] ) , ( [ d.12.b ] ) for @xmath408 , leads to a corresponding cauchy problem for @xmath409 , namely @xmath410 for @xmath411 ; and @xmath412 for @xmath413 . rather than including the computations which lead from ( [ d.12.a ] ) to equation ( [ e.1 ] ) , we present here a rather simple , informal argument that we shall find useful also in the next subsection , in a more formal setting .
we start by casting ( [ c.7.aa ] ) as @xmath414 where , by analogy with ( [ c.8 ] ) , we have set @xmath415 on the other hand , assuming that @xmath416 of ( [ d.10.a ] ) is of class @xmath389 , we obtain from it^ o s rule and with @xmath417 , @xmath418 , @xmath419 the product rule of the stochastic calculus applied to the process @xmath420\ ] ] of ( [ d.12 ] ) , leads then to @xmath421 \,d w_k ( t ) .\end{aligned}\ ] ] we have set @xmath422 where the last equality is checked easily from ( [ d.4 ] ) and ( [ d.7.a ] ) .
but the process @xmath423 of ( [ d.15 ] ) is a martingale , so the term @xmath424 should vanish , and @xmath425 \,dw_k ( t ) .\ ] ] in other words , the function @xmath426 $ ] of ( [ d.10 ] ) must satisfy the parabolic partial differential equation ( [ e.1 ] ) , as postulated earlier .
[ remark3 ] this informal derivation suggests that it may be possible to dispense with assumptions [ assumptiond ] , [ assumptione ] altogether , if it can be shown from first principles that the function @xmath427 of ( [ d.10.a ] ) is of class @xmath389 on @xmath428 . indeed , under suitable conditions
, one can rely on techniques from the malliavin calculus and the hrmander hypollipticity theorem [ nualart ( @xcite ) , pages 99124 ] to show that the @xmath429-dimensional vector @xmath430 with @xmath431 and @xmath432 has an infinitely differentiable probability density function , for any given @xmath338 .
this provides the requisite smoothness for the function @xmath433.\ ] ] the conditions needed for this approach to work are strong ; they include the infinite differentiability of the functions @xmath434 , @xmath435 , @xmath436 , as well as additional algebraic conditions which , in the present context , are somewhat opaque and not very easy to state or verify . for these reasons
we have opted for sticking with assumptions [ assumptiond ] , [ assumptione ] ; these are satisfied in the examples of section [ sec12 ] , are easy to test and allow us to represent fllmer s exit measure via ( [ e.6.u ] ) , ( [ e.6.v ] ) without involving stochastic integrals . equation ( [ e.1 ] )
is determined _ entirely _ from the volatility structure of model ( [ 1.1 ] ) .
furthermore , the cauchy problem of ( [ e.1 ] ) , @xmath437 , admits the trivial solution @xmath438 ; thus , the existence of arbitrage relative to the market portfolio over a finite time
horizon @xmath5 $ ] is tantamount to _ failure of uniqueness _ for the cauchy problem of ( [ e.1 ] ) , @xmath439 over the strip @xmath5\times(0 , \infty)^n $ ] .
[ remark4 ] assume there exists some @xmath113 such that the continuous functions @xmath440 satisfy either of the conditions @xmath441 & \ge & h ( x_1 + \cdots+ x_n)\end{aligned}\ ] ] for all @xmath413 [ we have just re - written ( [ intvol ] ) and ( [ ew ] ) in the present context ] .
then from the results reviewed in section [ sec4 ] we deduce that , for all @xmath442 under ( [ e.2.a ] ) , and for all @xmath443 under ( [ e.2.abc ] ) , we have @xmath444 .
in particular , under either ( [ e.2.a ] ) or ( [ e.2.abc ] ) , _ uniqueness fails for the cauchy problem of _ ( [ e.1 ] ) , @xmath445 . whenever uniqueness fails for this problem , it is important to know how to pick the `` right '' solution from among all possible solutions , the one which gives the quantity of ( [ d.10.a ] ) .
the next result addresses this issue ; it implies that @xmath446 in ( [ d.11 ] ) is the _
smallest nonnegative _ , continuous function , of class @xmath447 , which satisfies @xmath448 and ( [ d.12.b ] ) [ cf . karatzas and shreve ( @xcite ) , exercise 4.4.7 for a similar situation ] .
[ theorem1 ] the function @xmath449 $ ] of ( [ d.10.a ] ) is the continuous function , of class @xmath389 on @xmath397 , that satisfies @xmath450 and ( [ e.3 ] ) .
consider any continuous function @xmath451 which is of class @xmath389 on @xmath452 , and satisfies ( [ e.3 ] ) and @xmath453 on @xmath454 ; we shall denote by @xmath455 the collection of all such functions .
we introduce @xmath456 , @xmath457 as in ( [ d.15 ] ) . repeating verbatim the arguments in section [ sec91 ] , we use ( [ e.3 ] ) to conclude that the nonnegative process @xmath458 is a local supermartingale .
thus @xmath458 is bona - fide supermartingale , @xmath459 holds for every @xmath460 , and @xmath461 follows from ( [ d.10.a ] ) .
[ proposition2 ] assume that the continuous functions @xmath462 of ( [ d.3 ] ) satisfy the following nondegeneracy condition : _ for every compact subset @xmath463 of @xmath464 , there exists a number @xmath465 such that _ @xmath466 then , if @xmath467 holds for some @xmath468 , we have @xmath469 let us work first under the stronger assumption @xmath470 for some @xmath468 .
for every @xmath471 , we consider the set @xmath472 and define @xmath473 ( with @xmath474 if the set is empty ) .
assumption ( [ e.3.u ] ) amounts to @xmath475 , and the claim ( [ e.3.v ] ) to @xmath474 ; we shall prove this claim by contradiction .
suppose @xmath476 ; then @xmath477 for any given @xmath478 , and some @xmath479 .
for _ any _ given @xmath480 , consider an open , connected set @xmath481 which contains both @xmath482 and @xmath483 , and whose closure @xmath484 is a compact subset of @xmath464 ; in particular , we have @xmath485 .
the function @xmath409 attains its maximum value over the cylindrical domain @xmath486 at the point @xmath487 , which lies in the interior of this domain . by assumption then , the operator @xmath488 of ( [ e.3.a ] ) with @xmath489 is uniformly parabolic with bounded , continuous coefficients on @xmath490 , so from the maximum principle for parabolic operators [ friedman ( @xcite ) , chapter 6 ] , @xmath491 now let us recall the @xmath492-a.s .
equality @xmath493 = u ( t - t,\mathfrak{x } ( t ) ) \cdot x(t ) z(t ) $ ] from ( [ d.12 ] ) ; we apply it with @xmath494 , @xmath495 , then take expectations with respect to the probability measure @xmath377 , and use ( [ e.3.g ] ) along with ( [ d.10.a ] ) , to obtain for every @xmath496 $ ] , @xmath497 \over x_1 + \cdots+ x_n } = { \mathbb{e}^{\mathbb{p}^{\mathbf{x } } } [ x(t ) z(t ) ] \over x_1 + \cdots+ x_n}= u(t,\mathbf{x})=1 , \qquad \forall\ , \mathbf{x } \in(0,\infty)^n.\ ] ] but since @xmath498 , this contradicts the definition of @xmath499 .
now we revert to ( [ e.3.u1 ] ) ; as j. ruf ( private communication ) observes , yet another application of the maximum principle , as above , leads to ( [ e.3.u ] ) . under the nondegeneracy condition ( [ nondeg ] ) , and with either ( [ e.2.a ] ) or ( [ e.2.abc ] ) , inequality ( [ e.3.v ] ) holds . that is , arbitrage with respect to the market exists then over time
horizon @xmath108 $ ] with @xmath138 .
let us consider now the diffusion process @xmath500 with infinitesimal generator @xmath501 as in ( [ e.3.a ] ) , ( [ e.3.b ] ) and dynamics @xmath502 [ assumptionf ] the system of sdes ( [ e.4 ] ) admits a unique - in - distribution weak solution with values in @xmath503
. this will be the case , for instance , if the drift functions @xmath504 of ( [ e.3.b ] ) can be extended by continuity on all of @xmath345 and satisfy the bass and perkins ( @xcite ) conditions preceding , following and including ( [ bp ] ) .
the resulting process @xmath505 is then markovian , and we shall denote by @xmath506 its distribution with @xmath507 . unlike the original process @xmath28 , which takes values in @xmath23 , this new process @xmath30 is only guaranteed to take values in the nonnegative orthant @xmath508 . in particular , with @xmath413 the first hitting time @xmath509 of the boundary @xmath363 of @xmath345 may be finite with positive @xmath510-probability .
our next result shows that this possibility amounts to the existence of arbitrage relative to the market , and to the lack of uniqueness for the cauchy problem of ( [ e.1 ] ) and @xmath511 .
[ theorem2 ] with the above notation and assumptions , including ( [ nondeg ] ) , the function @xmath426 $ ] of ( [ d.10.a ] ) admits the representation @xmath512 , \qquad ( t,\mathbf{x } ) \in(0 , \infty ) \times(0 , \infty ) ^n .\ ] ] the function on the right - hand side of ( [ e.6 ] ) is space time harmonic for the diffusion @xmath513 on @xmath514 , so it solves equation ( [ e.1 ] ) there [ cf .
janson and tysk ( @xcite ) , theorem 2.7 ] . consider any function @xmath515 in the collection @xmath455 of theorem [ theorem1 ] ; then @xmath516 is a nonnegative local ( thus a true ) @xmath517-supermartingale , and we deduce @xmath518 = \mathbb{q}^{\mathbf{x } } ( \mathfrak{t } > t ) , \nonumber\\ \eqntext{(t,\mathbf{x } ) \in(0 , \infty ) \times ( 0 , \infty)^n.}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the claim follows now from the proof of theorem [ theorem1 ] . under the assumptions of theorem [ theorem2 ] , for any given @xmath413
the @xmath519-supermartingale @xmath200 is under @xmath520 a : @xmath235 martingale , if and only if @xmath521 ; @xmath235 potential [ i.e. , @xmath522 , iff @xmath523 ; @xmath235 strict local ( and super-)martingale on any time
horizon @xmath5 $ ] with @xmath338 , if and only if @xmath524 .
we represent by analogy with ( [ c.6a ] ) the exit measure @xmath525 of the supermartingale @xmath208 with initial configuration @xmath526 , in the form @xmath527 \times\omega\bigr ) = u(t,\mathbf{x } ) = \mathbb{q}^{\mathbf{x } } [ \mathfrak{t}>t ] , \ ] ] and from ( [ d.9])([d.12 ] ) we have for @xmath528 , @xmath529 \times a \bigr)\nonumber\\[-8pt]\\[-8pt ] & & \qquad= \mathbb{e}^{\mathbb{p}^{\mathbf{x } } } \biggl [ { g ( \mathfrak{x}(t ) ) \over g(\mathbf{x } ) } 1_a \bigl ( \mathbb{q}^{\mathbf{z } } [ \mathfrak{t}>t - t ] \bigr ) \big|_{\mathbf{z } = \mathfrak{x}(t)}\ , e^ { - \int_0^t k ( \mathfrak{x}(s ) ) \,ds } \biggr].\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] when @xmath413 and the quantity of ( [ e.6 ] ) is equal to one , the @xmath510-distribution of the process @xmath530 in ( [ e.4 ] ) is the same as the @xmath531-distribution of the original stock - price process @xmath532 ; this follows by comparing ( [ e.4 ] ) and ( [ e.3.b ] ) with ( [ c.9 ] ) , and denoting by @xmath533 the probability measure @xmath203 of ( [ c.9.a ] ) with @xmath534 .
we have in this spirit the following result , by analogy with remark [ remark2 ] . [ proposition3 ] under the assumptions of theorem [ theorem2 ] , suppose that the functions @xmath364 are continuously differentiable on @xmath354 ; that the matrix @xmath535 degenerates on @xmath536 ; and that the analogues of ( [ fichera ] ) , the fichera drifts @xmath537 for the process @xmath538 of ( [ e.4 ] ) , can be extended by continuity on @xmath539 .
if @xmath540 holds on each face @xmath541 , @xmath542 of the orthant , then we have @xmath543 in ( [ e.6 ] ) , and no arbitrage with respect to the market portfolio exists on any time horizon .
if , on the other hand , we have @xmath544 on each face @xmath541 of the orthant , then @xmath545 in ( [ e.6 ] ) and arbitrage with respect to the market portfolio exists , on every time horizon @xmath546 $ ] with @xmath547 . in light of theorem [ theorem2 ] , the first claim follows from theorem 9.4.1 , corollary 9.4.2 of friedman ( @xcite ) , and the second is a consequence of the support theorem for diffusions [ ikeda and watanabe ( @xcite ) , section vi.8 ] .
[ remark5 ] ( i ) the `` relative weights '' @xmath548 , @xmath549 have dynamics similar to ( [ 2.2.a ] ) , @xmath550 they are thus @xmath551-martingales with values in @xmath552 $ ] ( cf .
section [ sec61 ] ) ; so , when any one of them hits either boundary point of the unit interval , it gets absorbed there . in terms of them , the first hitting time of ( [ e.5 ] ) can be expressed as in ( [ c.6aa ] ) , @xmath553 , where @xmath554 .
\(ii ) the measure @xmath555 corresponds to a _ change of drift _ , from @xmath556 in ( [ d.2 ] ) to @xmath557 in ( [ e.3.b ] ) , ( [ e.4 ] ) ; this ensures that , under @xmath558 , the components of the new , `` fictitious '' market portfolio @xmath559 are martingales , that @xmath559 has the numraire property , and thus that @xmath559 can not be outperformed .
let us assume now the form @xmath560 for the functions of ( [ d.1 ] ) , with @xmath561 and suitable continuous functions @xmath562 , @xmath563 on @xmath564 . for @xmath565 , we set @xmath566 . in words , we consider instantaneous growth rates and volatilities that depend at time @xmath4 only on the current configuration @xmath567 of relative market weights , so the process @xmath568 of ( [ 2.2 ] )
is now a diffusion with values in the positive simplex @xmath564 and @xmath569 , \qquad i = 1,\ldots , n , \hspace*{-36pt}\ ] ] with @xmath570 @xmath571 in this setup , the function of ( [ d.10.a ] ) can be expressed in the form @xmath572 , in terms of a function @xmath573 $ ] that satisfies the initial condition @xmath574 and the equation @xmath575 which appears on page 56 of fernholz ( @xcite ) and can be derived from ( [ e.1 ] ) . on the other hand , by analogy with theorem [ theorem2 ] and ( [ nus ] ) ,
the quantity @xmath576 is the probability that the process @xmath577 with @xmath578 and dynamics ( [ g.7 ] ) below , does not hit the boundary of the nonnegative simplex @xmath579^n | \sum_{i=1}^n m_i = 1 \ } $ ] before @xmath580 : @xmath581
let us substitute now the expressions of ( [ d.13 ] ) into ( [ e.0 ] ) , to obtain the dynamics of the martingale @xmath582 in ( [ d.15 ] ) , with @xmath583 , @xmath584 thus we can identify the `` replicating strategy '' @xmath585 of ( [ c.5 ] ) as @xmath586 and its value as @xmath587 , @xmath185 . [ remark6 ] in the special case of a markovian model ( [ g.2 ] ) for the market weights of @xmath588 , expression ( [ f.6 ] ) takes the form @xmath589 of a `` functionally - generated portfolio '' in the terminology of fernholz ( @xcite ) , page 56 ; whereas the value is @xmath590 , @xmath185 . in this case
we have @xmath591 : the strategy that implements the best possible arbitrage relative to the equity market never borrows or lends .
we discuss in this section two illustrative examples .
additional examples , in which the investment strategy @xmath592 of ( [ f.6 ] ) that realizes the optimal arbitrage can be computed in closed form in dimension @xmath593 , can be found in ruf ( @xcite ) .
for the first of these examples , take @xmath594 , @xmath595 and @xmath596 in ( [ 1.1 ] ) where the process @xmath597 satisfies @xmath598 and @xmath599 .
this is a bessel process in dimension three the radial part of a brownian motion started at unit distance from the origin and takes values in @xmath395 .
we have then @xmath600 , @xmath601 for @xmath602 in ( [ th ] ) and ( [ z ] ) , so @xmath200 is very clearly a martingale .
however , @xmath152 is the prototypical example of a _ strict _ local martingale we have @xmath155 for every @xmath338 [ e.g. , karatzas and shreve ( @xcite ) , exercise 3.36 , page 168 ] .
this example is taken from karatzas and kardaras [ ( @xcite ) , page 469 ] , where an arbitrage with respect to the money - market is constructed in closed form .
it illustrates that it is possible for @xmath152 to be a strict local martingale and @xmath200 to be a martingale ; in other words , the second and third inequalities in ( [ ao.b ] ) fail , while the first stands . here
we have @xmath603 , @xmath604 and @xmath605 , @xmath606 , @xmath607 in ( [ d.10 ] ) , ( [ d.11 ] ) , thus @xmath608 for all @xmath609 , @xmath610 .
arbitrage relative to @xmath611 does not exist here , despite the existence of arbitrage relative to the money market and the fact that @xmath152 is a strict local martingale .
note that @xmath612 in ( [ e.3.b ] ) , so the diffusion of ( [ e.4 ] ) is again a bessel process in dimension three , @xmath613 , @xmath614 .
this process never hits the origin , so the probability in ( [ e.6 ] ) is equal to one , for all @xmath615 .
our second example is the model of `` stabilization by volatility '' introduced in fernholz and karatzas ( @xcite ) and studied further by goia ( @xcite ) . with @xmath616 ,
@xmath617 $ ] this posits @xmath618\\[-8pt ] \sigma_{i k } ( t ) & = & \delta_{i k } ( \mu_i ( t ) ) ^{-1/2 } ; \qquad 1 \le i , k \le n , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] that is , rates of return and volatilities which are large for the small stocks and small for the large stocks .
the conditions of bass and perkins ( @xcite ) hold for the resulting system of sdes in the notation of ( [ 2.1 ] ) with @xmath619 , @xmath620 the unique - in - distribution solution of ( [ d.8 * ] ) is expressed in terms of independent bessel processes @xmath621 in dimension @xmath622 with @xmath623 and @xmath624 . in particular
, @xmath28 takes values in @xmath625 ; for more details on these lamperti - like descriptions and their implications , see fernholz and karatzas ( @xcite ) and goia ( @xcite ) .
condition ( [ d.7 ] ) is satisfied in this example , so assumption [ assumptionc ] also holds . for the model of ( [ d.8*a ] )
, we have @xmath626 , @xmath627 for @xmath628
. the assumptions of theorem [ theorem2 ] and of propositions [ proposition1 ] and [ proposition3 ] are all satisfied here , as are ( [ c.6w ] ) and ( [ d.6 ] ) with @xmath629 and @xmath630 .
this function @xmath631 is nonnegative , since we have assumed @xmath632 , whereas @xmath633 . in particular , with @xmath634 we get @xmath635\ ] ] [ see goia ( @xcite ) and pal ( @xcite ) for a computation of the joint density of @xmath636 which leads then to an explicit computation of @xmath637 in ( [ e.u ] ) above , and shows that this function is indeed of class @xmath638 .
with @xmath639 one computes @xmath640 , therefore @xmath641 as well as @xmath642 for @xmath37 .
both representations in ( [ c.6aa ] ) hold for the first hitting time of ( [ ttau ] ) in this case ; whereas @xmath643 as in ( [ ttau])([c.6b ] ) , since @xmath644 .
both ( [ e.2.a ] ) and ( [ e.2.abc ] ) hold for the example of ( [ d.8*a ] ) with @xmath645 , the first as equality ; from the corollary to proposition [ proposition2 ] and remark [ remark3 ] , ( [ e.3.v ] ) holds .
we recover the result of banner and fernholz ( @xcite ) on the existence of arbitrage relative to market of ( [ d.8*a ] ) over _ arbitrary _ time horizons . the diffusion process @xmath646 of ( [ e.4 ] )
takes now the form @xmath647 the conditions of bass and perkins ( @xcite ) are satisfied again , though one should compare the `` weak drift '' @xmath648 in ( [ d.8 * * ] ) , which vanishes for , with the `` strong drift '' @xmath649 for the the original diffusion @xmath28 in ( [ d.8 * ] ) , which is strictly positive on @xmath650 .
the corresponding fichera drifts in ( [ ficheratoo ] ) , ( [ fichera ] ) are given by @xmath651 , @xmath652 , and @xmath653 hold on @xmath654 ; from remark [ remark2 ] we verify again that the diffusion @xmath655 of ( [ d.8 * ] ) takes values in @xmath656 .
in contrast , the new diffusion @xmath30 of ( [ d.8 * * ] ) lives in @xmath657 , and hits the boundary @xmath363 of this nonnegative orthant with positive probability @xmath658 = 1 - u(t,\mathbf{x } ) $ ] for every @xmath338 .
the positive @xmath519-supermartingale @xmath200 is a @xmath519-potential , for every @xmath659 . in this case , the three inequalities of ( [ ao.b ] ) hold for every @xmath338 : _ the local martingales @xmath152 , @xmath200 and @xmath660 , @xmath302 are all strict .
_ the model ( [ d.8*a ] ) can be cast in the form ( [ g.2 ] ) for the relative market weights , as a _ multivariate jacobi diffusion process _ with dynamics @xmath661 , or @xmath662 with appropriate brownian motions @xmath663 .
thus , each component @xmath664 is also a diffusion on the unit interval @xmath665 with local drift @xmath666 and local variance @xmath667 of wright fisher type .
goia ( @xcite ) studies in detail this multivariate diffusion @xmath668 based on an extension of the warren and yor ( @xcite ) , gouriroux and jasiak ( @xcite ) study of skew - products involving bessel and jacobi processes . from ( [ d.8 * * ] )
, @xmath669 satisfies the stochastic equation @xmath670 $ ] , where @xmath671 is brownian motion ; thus @xmath672 a geometric brownian motion with drift , under @xmath673 .
the process @xmath674 of ( [ g.7 ] ) is related to the auxiliary diffusion @xmath513 of ( [ d.8 * * ] ) via @xmath675 .
the dynamics of these @xmath676 s are easy to describe in the manner of ( [ nus ] ) , namely , @xmath677 , or in the notation of ( [ g.9 ] ) : @xmath678 .
then the feller test [ e.g. , karatzas and shreve ( @xcite ) , pages 348350 ] ensures that each @xmath676 hits one of the endpoints of @xmath679 in finite expected time .
thus , all but one of the @xmath680 s eventually get absorbed at zero ; from that time @xmath681 [ with @xmath682 onward , the only surviving nonzero component @xmath672 behaves like geometric brownian motion with drift ; in particular , @xmath683 never hits the origin .
what conditions , if any , on the markovian covariance structure of section [ sec8 ] will guarantee that @xmath175 of ( [ f.6 ] ) never borrows from the money - market , that is , @xmath684 ? that it is a portfolio , i.e. , that @xmath685 holds ?
( see remark [ remark6 ] for a partial answer . ) or better , that @xmath686 of ( [ f.6 ] ) is a long - only portfolio , meaning that both this condition and @xmath687 hold ? can an iterative method be constructed which converges to the minimal solution of the parabolic differential inequality ( [ e.3 ] ) , @xmath445 and is numerically implementable [ possibly as in ekstrm , von sydow and tysk ( @xcite ) ] ?
how about a monte carlo scheme that computes the quantity @xmath688 of ( [ e.6 ] ) by generating the paths of the diffusion process @xmath30 , then simulating the probability @xmath689 $ ] that @xmath30 does not hit the boundary of the nonnegative orthant by time @xmath690 , when started at @xmath691 ?
how does @xmath692 behave as @xmath693 ?
if it decreases to zero , then at what rate ?
in the context of proposition [ proposition1 ] , and under the probability measure @xmath250 of section [ sec71 ] , the processes @xmath694 are real - valued ( do not explode ) if and only if their sum @xmath695 as in ( [ 2.1 ] ) is real - valued .
now it is fairly straightforward to check from ( [ c.9 ] ) that this sum satisfies the equation @xmath696 , \ ] ] where the continuous , @xmath255-local martingale @xmath697 and its quadratic variation process @xmath698 are given , respectively , as @xmath699 thus by the dambis
schwarz result [ e.g. , karatzas and shreve ( @xcite ) , theorem 3.4.6 ] , for some real - valued @xmath255-brownian motion @xmath700 we have @xmath701 it is fairly clear form this representation that a sufficient condition for the total capitalization process @xmath695 to be real - valued , @xmath255-a.e .
, is that this should hold for the quadratic variation process
@xmath702 : @xmath703 in the volatility - stabilized model of section [ sec121 ] we have @xmath704 and thus @xmath705 , so this condition is clearly satisfied .
we wish to thank g. itkovi , n. sesum , e. r. fernholz , a. banner , v. papathanakos , t. ichiba and most notably j. ruf for several helpful discussions .
we are grateful to m. srbu , m. soner , f. delbaen , w. schachermayer , j. hugonnier , j. teichmann and c. kardaras for their comments .
we are also deeply indebted to the referees and associate editor for their meticulous readings , and for suggestions that improved this paper greatly . | in a markovian model for a financial market , we characterize the best arbitrage with respect to the market portfolio that can be achieved using nonanticipative investment strategies , in terms of the smallest positive solution to a parabolic partial differential inequality ; this is determined entirely on the basis of the covariance structure of the model .
the solution is intimately related to properties of strict local martingales and is used to generate the investment strategy which realizes the best possible arbitrage .
some extensions to non - markovian situations are also presented . and . . |
the current cutting - edge technology has developed seeking the realization of quantum information and quantum computation .
for such realization , the mathematical modeling of the system of some quantum devices will play an important role .
one of the candidates for qubit is electron spin , that is , the so - called _ electron - spin qubit _ or the _ spintronic qubit _ , from the point of the view of spintronics @xcite .
it is remarkable that the transportation of a single electron as a qubit has been demonstrated experimentally @xcite as well as the spin - conserved transport tunneling through a junction was experimentally demonstrated in organic spintronics @xcite . in addition , the spin - flip and the phase - shift was demonstrated in the experiment for the spin state of an electron - hole pair in a semiconductor quantum dot @xcite , while the spin alignment was studied in the process of the spin - transport in organic spintronics @xcite .
the experimental development makes us hopeful that an integrated circuit for qubit and a quantum network are really demonstrated in future .
this paper deals with the dirac particle living in the configuration space consisting of the two quantum wires and a junction for the spintronic qubit .
although we actually have to determine a concrete physical object for the junction , we regard the junction as a black box so that it has mathematical arbitrariness .
we regard the wires as the union of the intervals , @xmath1 , @xmath2 , for mathematical simplicity .
namely , the segment @xmath3 $ ] with length @xmath4 plays a role of the junction .
many physicists have investigated the individual boundary condition of the wave functions of the dirac particle for the corresponding self - adjoint extension of the dirac operator in the case of the point interaction ( i.e. , @xmath5 ) @xcite . meanwhile , the dirac operator consists of the combination of the dirac matrices and the momentum operator of electron .
the boundary conditions of the self - adjoint extensions of the momentum operators have been studied by mathematicians @xcite .
we note that there is a general theory in mathematics , called boundary triple , to handle the boundary condition , and the theory has still been developed @xcite . in refs.@xcite
the appearance of a phase factor was proved for the schrdinger particle under the same mathematical set - up as ours . for our dirac particle , in the case where @xmath5 , benvegn and dabrowski showed that a phase factor appears in their four - parameter family ( see eq.(15 ) of ref.@xcite ) .
in addition , they showed how the boundary condition affects the spin .
the description of boundary condition by the individual one - parameter families have been studied in refs.@xcite ( also see eqs.(17 ) and ( 18 ) of ref.@xcite ) .
we will go ahead and make an in - depth research for the dirac particle .
thus , we employ the minimal dirac operator for the hamiltonian . in this paper , we follow the machinery in refs.@xcite based on the von neumann s theory @xcite , in which all the self - adjoint extensions of our minimal dirac operator are parameterized by @xmath6 , where @xmath7 is unitary group of degree @xmath8 .
we prove that all the boundary conditions of wave functions of our dirac particle are completely classified into the two types ( see corollary [ cor : theo-2 ] ) .
one of them is the type that states the wave functions do not pass through the junction , and described by two parameters , @xmath9 with @xmath10 , concerned with the reflections at @xmath11 and at @xmath12 , respectively .
the other is the type that states the wave functions do pass through the junction , and described by benvegn and dabrowski s four - parameter family ( see theorem [ theo:1 ] , theorem [ theo:2 ] , and proposition [ prop:06 ] ) .
we give our concrete formulae showing the one - to - one correspondence between the boundary conditions of wave functions of our dirac particle and the self - adjoint extensions of the minimal dirac operator ( see theorem [ theo:2 ] , and propositions [ prop:03 ] , [ prop : inverse ] , [ prop:06 ] ) .
our formulae states that benvegn and dabrowski s four - parameter family can be characterized by three parameters , @xmath13 with @xmath14 , concerned with the reflection , penetration , and phase factor , respectively ( see corollary [ cor : bd->3 ] ) . to obtain our formulae
, we invent our representation of @xmath7 in proposition [ prop:03 ] .
we then realize that all the boundary conditions are independent of @xmath4 , the length of the junction , which is different from the case for the schrdinger operator @xcite . through our mathematical toy model
we propose a mathematically fundamental idea for a tunnel - junction device in the light of the industry of quantum engineering .
we always assume that every hilbert space @xmath15 that we handle in this paper is separable .
we denote by @xmath16 the inner product of the hilbert space @xmath15 , where we suppose that the right hand side of the inner product @xmath16 is linear .
we here prepare some notations and notions using in operator theory .
let @xmath17 denote the set of all ( linear ) operators acting in @xmath15 .
we always omit the word of ` linear ' from the notion of linear operator because we consider only linear operators in this paper .
so , when we write , @xmath18 , it means that @xmath19 is an operator acting in the hilbert space @xmath15 . that is , there is a subspace @xmath20 so that @xmath19 is a linear map from @xmath21 to @xmath15 .
we call @xmath21 the _ domain _ of the operator @xmath19 .
we say that an operator @xmath22 is an _ extension _ of the operator @xmath23 , provided that @xmath24 and @xmath25 for every @xmath26 . we denote it as @xmath27 or @xmath28 .
the operator equation is defined in the following : an operator @xmath23 is _ equal _ to an operator @xmath22 if and only if @xmath29 and @xmath25 for every @xmath30 . in particular ,
the operator equation , @xmath31 , is equivalent to the conditions , @xmath27 and @xmath32 . for every operator @xmath23 and subspace @xmath33 with @xmath34 , the operator @xmath35 is defined by @xmath36 and @xmath37 for every @xmath38 .
we call @xmath39 the _ restriction _ of the operator @xmath19 on the subspace @xmath40 . in particular , the equation , @xmath41 , holds for operators @xmath42 with @xmath27 .
let @xmath43 or @xmath44 denote the identity operator on @xmath15 , i.e. , @xmath45 for every @xmath46 .
an operator @xmath23 is said to be _ closed _ when the graph @xmath47 of the operator @xmath19 is closed in @xmath48 , where @xmath49 . in other words , if @xmath50 and @xmath51 in @xmath15 as @xmath52 , then @xmath26 and @xmath53 .
we say that an operator @xmath54 is _ densely defined _ when its domain @xmath21 is dense in @xmath15 .
let an operator @xmath23 be densely defined .
we define a subspace @xmath55 of @xmath15 by @xmath56 we note @xmath57 is uniquely determined then .
the _ adjoint operator _
@xmath58 of @xmath19 is defined by @xmath59 and @xmath60 .
it is well known that @xmath58 is closed and @xmath61 .
a densely defined operator @xmath23 is _ symmetric _ when the condition , @xmath62 , holds .
we say that a densely defined operator @xmath23 is _ self - adjoint _ if and only if the operator equation , @xmath63 , holds .
we emphasize that self - adjointness requires @xmath64 , while symmetry requires @xmath65 only .
let @xmath66 be closed symmetric .
an operator @xmath23 is _ self - adjoint extension _ of @xmath67 , provided that the condition , @xmath68 , holds and the operator @xmath19 is self - adjoint . for every closed symmetric operator @xmath69
, we respectively define _ deficiency subspaces _ @xmath70 and @xmath71 by @xmath72 , and moreover ,
_ deficiency indices _ @xmath73 and @xmath74 by @xmath75 .
namely , @xmath76 are the eigenspaces of @xmath77 , respectively , corresponding to the eigenvalues @xmath78 , and @xmath79 are their individual dimensions . a _ unitary operator _
@xmath80 from a hilbert space @xmath81 to a hilbert space @xmath82 is defined as follows : @xmath80 is a surjective linear map from the hilbert space @xmath81 to the hilbert space @xmath82 , and it satisfies the relation , @xmath83 for every @xmath84 . our argument developed in this paper is based on the following proposition : [ prop : von - neumann ] ( von neumann @xcite ) : let @xmath69 be closed symmetric . 1 . if @xmath85 , then @xmath86 has self - adjoint extensions .
2 . there is a one - to - one correspondence between self - adjoint extensions @xmath19 of @xmath67 and unitary operators @xmath87 so that the correspondence is given by the following : for every unitary operator @xmath88 , the corresponding self - adjoint extension @xmath89 is defined by @xmath90 and then its operation is @xmath91 .
conversely , for every self - adjoint extension @xmath19 of @xmath67 , there is the corresponding unitary operator @xmath92 so that @xmath93 .
let us now suppose that @xmath94 .
fix individual complete orthonormal systems , @xmath95 , of the deficiency subspaces @xmath76 .
we identify unitary operators from @xmath70 to @xmath71 with @xmath96 unitary matrices making the correspondence by @xmath97 , @xmath98 .
so , we often identify the unitary operator @xmath80 with the unitary matrix @xmath99 , and write @xmath100 in the case @xmath101 , where @xmath102 denotes the unitary group of degree @xmath103 .
we say @xmath80 is _ diagonal _ if @xmath104 with @xmath105 .
otherwise , we say @xmath80 is _ non - diagonal_. we here introduce some notations concerning function spaces that we use in this paper .
let @xmath106 be an open set of the @xmath0-dimensional euclidean space @xmath107 , i.e. , @xmath108 .
we respectively define function spaces , @xmath109 , @xmath110 , and @xmath111 as follows : @xmath112 where the integral is the lebesgue integral . @xmath113 here @xmath114 denotes the closure of the set @xmath106 in @xmath107 .
we note that the differential @xmath115 of the absolutely continuous function @xmath116 exists for almost every @xmath117 .
@xmath118 here @xmath119 is the boundary of the set @xmath106 . in the case
where @xmath120 ( resp .
@xmath121 ) is in the set @xmath106 , the boundary condition in the function space @xmath122 means that @xmath123 ( resp .
@xmath124 ) .
in this section we define some @xmath0-dimensional dirac operators .
first up , we define the configuration space in which the dirac particle lives . for every @xmath125 , we set two intervals @xmath126 and @xmath127 by @xmath128 and @xmath129 .
we often call @xmath126 and @xmath127 the _ left island _ and the _ right island _ , respectively .
we set our configuration space @xmath130 by @xmath131 .
we define two spaces of functions on our configuration space @xmath130 as : @xmath132 where @xmath133 denotes the algebraic tensor product .
the function spaces @xmath134 and @xmath135 are dense in @xmath136 , where @xmath137 denotes the tensor product of hilbert spaces . we , however , note the following .
the sobolev spaces respectively corresponding to @xmath134 and @xmath135 have their own sobolev - space structures different from each other because of the junction @xmath138 $ ] for @xmath2 , which implies existence of uncountably many self - adjoint extensions of the minimal dirac operator defined below . for the quantization of a relativistic particle on the @xmath0-dimensional configuration space @xmath130 , we seek a representation of ` energy @xmath139 ' with matrices @xmath140 and @xmath141 satisfying @xmath142 and @xmath143 for the probability interpretation of the wave function of electron . here
@xmath144 is the momentum operator and @xmath145 is the mass of electron .
then , we have candidates of the representation : @xmath146 or @xmath147 , and @xmath148 , where @xmath149 are the pauli ( spin ) matrices : @xmath150 we employ @xmath151 as @xmath140 throughout this paper .
( minimal dirac operator ) : let @xmath152 be the mass of electron . the @xmath0-dimensional dirac operator @xmath153 is defined by @xmath154 where the momentum operator @xmath144 is given by @xmath155 .
we call the operator @xmath156 the _ minimal dirac operator_. the following proposition comes from the well - known facts on the momentum operator @xmath144 and its adjoint operator @xmath157 : [ prop : adjoint - operator ] the minimal dirac operator @xmath158 is closed symmetric .
its adjoint operator @xmath159 is given by @xmath160 where @xmath161 .
since the operation of the adjoint operator @xmath162 is the same as that of the minimal dirac operator @xmath156 though their domains are different from each other , we make the following definition : ( maximal dirac operator ) : we call the adjoint operator @xmath162 the _ maximal dirac operator_. similarly , since the restriction of the adjoint operator @xmath162 on every subspace @xmath163 with the condition , @xmath164 , has the same operation as that of the minimal dirac operator @xmath156 , we name them in the following : for every subspace @xmath163 with the condition , @xmath164 , we call the restriction @xmath165 the _ dirac operator _ in this paper .
set constants @xmath166 and @xmath167 by @xmath168 and @xmath169 , respectively .
we define functions @xmath170 and @xmath171 by @xmath172 and functions @xmath173 and @xmath174 by @xmath175 here @xmath176 and @xmath177 are respectively the characteristic functions on the closure @xmath178 of the left island and the closure @xmath179 of the right island . as proved in [ subsec : proof - deficiency - indices ] ,
we can compute the deficiency indices of the minimal dirac operator @xmath156 in the following : [ prop : deficiency - indices ] the deficiency indices of the minimal dirac operator are @xmath180 and therefore the minimal dirac operator @xmath156 has self - adjoint extensions . then
, the deficiency subspaces are given by @xmath181 by propositions [ prop : von - neumann ] and [ prop : deficiency - indices ] we can represent every self - adjoint extension of the minimal dirac operator by an element of @xmath7 .
we denote by @xmath182 the self - adjoint extension of the minimal dirac operator @xmath156 corresponding to @xmath6 .
then , proposition [ prop : von - neumann ] says that the domain @xmath183 of the self - adjoint extension @xmath182 is @xmath184 since @xmath185 for @xmath186 , the unitary operator @xmath6 includes the information about how the electron reflects at the boundary and how it passes through the junction .
so , our problem is to derive the boundary condition form the information that @xmath80 has .
we determine the entries @xmath187 of @xmath188 as follows : @xmath189 the von neumann theory says that the unitary operator @xmath80 maps the eigenfunction @xmath190 living in the left island ( resp .
@xmath191 living in the right island ) to the eigenfunction @xmath192 ( resp .
@xmath193 ) staying in the same island with the probability @xmath194 ( resp .
@xmath195 ) and the eigenfunction @xmath193 ( resp .
@xmath192 ) coming from the opposite island with the probability @xmath196 ( resp .
@xmath197 ) .
we denote by @xmath198 the set of all extended real numbers : @xmath199 .
for every two parameters @xmath200 , we introduce a boundary condition by @xmath201 we introduce a class of four parameters @xmath202 in the following : @xmath203 for every @xmath204 in the class ( [ cl - alpha ] ) , we define the _ boundary matrix _ @xmath205 by @xmath206 we note that our vector @xmath140 is equivalent to the benvegn and dabrowski s four - parameter family given in eq.(15 ) of ref.@xcite ( see proposition [ prop:06 ] below ) . for every wave function @xmath207 , we respectively set the wave function @xmath208 with _ up - spin _ and the wave function @xmath209 with _ down - spin _ by @xmath210 because of the unitarily equivalence , @xmath211 , we often identify @xmath136 with @xmath212 , and then , we represent @xmath213 as @xmath214 conforming with this representation , we often use the representation : @xmath215 then , the boundary matrix @xmath216 gives a boundary condition : @xmath217 as proven in
[ proof - theo-1 ] , the dirac operators with the following two types of boundary conditions are self - adjoint extensions of the minimal dirac operator : [ theo:1 ] 1
. give a subspace @xmath218 by @xmath219 for every @xmath220 .
then , the dirac operator @xmath221 defined as the restriction of the maximal dirac operator @xmath162 on @xmath218 , i.e. , @xmath222 , is a self - adjoint extension of the minimal dirac operator @xmath156 .
2 . give a subspace @xmath223 by @xmath224 for every vector @xmath140 in the class ( [ cl - alpha ] ) .
then , the dirac operator @xmath225 defined as the restriction of the maximal dirac operator @xmath162 on @xmath223 , i.e. , @xmath226 , is a self - adjoint extension of the minimal dirac operator @xmath156 . before stating our second theorem
, we introduce a device for the representation of @xmath7 . in general
, the so - called homomorphism theorem tells us that @xmath227 for each @xmath228 , where @xmath229 is the special unitary group of degree @xmath103 . in this paper
we seek another representation of the unitary group @xmath7 making good use of the degree , @xmath230 , that we handle now .
the following proposition will be proved in
[ subsec : proof - prop-03 ] : [ prop:03 ] the unitary group @xmath7 has the following representation : @xmath231 here @xmath232 is defined by @xmath233 for the hamilton quaternion field @xmath234 consisting of @xmath235 matrices . remark : _ for arbitrary coefficients , @xmath236 , the wave function _
@xmath237 _ is in the domain @xmath223 , where @xmath238 , and @xmath239 were defined in eqs.([eq:+eigenfunctions ] ) and ( [ eq :- eigenfunctions ] ) .
taking @xmath240 as the coefficient @xmath241 ( resp .
@xmath242 ) in the case where @xmath80 is non - diagonal , we have @xmath243 ( resp .
@xmath244 ) .
we set @xmath245 for @xmath246 , where @xmath247 is the branch of the complex square root with the cut along the non - negative real axis @xmath248 .
the function @xmath249 is analytic in @xmath250 $ ] , @xmath251 for @xmath252 , and @xmath253 for @xmath254 @xcite .
then , since @xmath255 and @xmath256 , we have @xmath257 and @xmath258 .
thus , the entry @xmath259 is concerned with the reflection , and the entry @xmath260 with the penetration .
_ now our second theorem is the following : [ theo:2 ] 1 .
every diagonal @xmath6 has the following representation : there are complex numbers @xmath9 so that @xmath261 then , for arbitrarily fixed @xmath262 and @xmath263 satisfying @xmath10 , a necessary and sufficient condition for @xmath264 is given by determining the vector @xmath220 with the formulae : 1 . for @xmath265 , @xmath266 , where @xmath267 .
2 . for @xmath268 , @xmath269 .
3 . for @xmath270 , @xmath271 , where @xmath272 .
4 . for @xmath273 , @xmath274 .
2 . let @xmath166 be a constant defined by @xmath275 .
every non - diagonal @xmath276 has the following representation : there are complex numbers @xmath277 so that @xmath278 then , for arbitrarily fixed @xmath259 , @xmath260 , and @xmath279 satisfying @xmath280 and @xmath281 , a necessary and sufficient condition for @xmath282 is given by determining the vector @xmath283 with the formulae : @xmath284 the proof of this theorem will appear in [ subsec : proof - theo-2 ] .
since proposition [ prop : von - neumann ] says that unitary operators @xmath6 determine all the self - adjoint extensions of the minimal dirac operator , theorem [ theo:2 ] gives the complete classification with the boundary conditions : [ cor : theo-2 ] the boundary conditions of all the self - adjoint extensions of the minimal dirac operator @xmath156 can be classified under either one of the boundary conditions , ( [ bc - rho ] ) and ( [ bc - alpha ] ) .
theorem [ theo:2 ] gives the formulae showing how to construct the two parameters @xmath285 ( resp .
the four parameters @xmath286 ) describing the boundary condition from the parameters , @xmath287 ( resp .
@xmath288 ) , describing the unitary operator @xmath6 appearing in von neumann s theory .
we give the formulae conversely showing how to construct the parameters describing the unitary operator @xmath6 from the parameter family describing the boundary condition .
since theorem [ theo:2 ] i ) gives the one - to - one correspondence between the boundary condition ( [ bc - rho ] ) and the parameters @xmath287 actually , we immediately have 1 . @xmath289 $ ] if @xmath290 , 2 .
@xmath268 if @xmath291 , 3 .
@xmath292 $ ] if @xmath293 , 4 .
@xmath273 if @xmath294 .
the formulae for the other case are obtained using propositions [ prop:03 ] and [ prop:06 ] : [ prop : inverse ] for every boundary matrix @xmath216 with @xmath283 in the class ( [ cl - alpha ] ) , the corresponding non - diagonal @xmath295 is determined as : @xmath296 where @xmath297 , @xmath298 and @xmath299 is determined by following proposition [ prop:06 ] as @xmath300 , @xmath301 , and @xmath302 , @xmath303 .
we will prove this proposition in [ subsection : prop - inverse ] .
the following proposition says that our @xmath283 in the class ( [ cl - alpha ] ) is equivalent to benvegn and dabrowski s four - parameter family , which shows how a phase factor appears in the boundary matrix : [ prop:06 ] let @xmath304 be the set of all boundary matrices @xmath216 for vectors
@xmath286 in the class ( [ cl - alpha ] )
. then , @xmath305 or @xmath306 .
so , set @xmath307 , and @xmath308 as @xmath309 if @xmath305 , and @xmath310 if @xmath311
. then , @xmath304 has the following representation : @xmath312 remark : _ the benvegn and dabrowski s four - parameter family , consisting of @xmath313 and @xmath314 , as in eq.(15 ) of ref.@xcite is given by the correspondence , @xmath315 , @xmath316 , and @xmath317 .
_ _ meanwhile , in the case of the schrdinger particle living in our configuration space @xmath130 , the boundary matrix @xmath216 making the boundary condition , @xmath318 has the four parameters satisfying @xmath319 and @xmath320 , and moreover , the set @xmath304 has the following representation : @xmath321 for more details , see proposition 2.6 of ref.@xcite . _
thus , proposition [ prop:06 ] , together with eqs.([eq : tjf1 ] ) , says that the benvegn and dabrowski s four - parameter family can actually characterized by three parameters coming from von neumann s theory : [ cor : bd->3 ] the benvegn and dabrowski s four - parameter family , consisting of @xmath313 and @xmath314 , is characterized by three parameters , @xmath277 with @xmath14 and @xmath322 .
in this section , we propose a mathematical idea for a tunnel - junction device for spintronic qubit . of course ,
since we derive mathematically - theoretical possible mechanism from our simple toy model , we are not sure that the idea can be experimentally demonstrated .
even this toy model , however , tells us that we have to mind the effect of a phase coming from the boundary .
we can see such an effect in the andreev(-like ) effects in more realistic cases refs.@xcite .
conversely , we may use the phase effect for a device .
we are interested in the unit of a quantum device , consisting of a junction and two quantum wires such as in fig.[fig : unit ] from the point of the view of quantum engineering .
the combination of these units makes a quantum network .
the junction is for controlling the information of qubit .
the wires play a role of transporting the information .
we suppose that the energy of our unit has the hamiltonian , @xmath323 , where @xmath324 is the hamiltonian for the single electron living in the two wires , @xmath325 the hamiltonian for the electron in the junction consisting of a physical object such as a quantum dot , and @xmath326 describes the interaction between the wires and the junction .
the hamiltonians @xmath324 and @xmath325 should be observables in physics , and therefore , self - adjoint operators in mathematics then .
we actually have to determine a concrete physical object for the junction to complete and realize our unit in the quantum engineering .
but , in this paper , we regarded the junction as a black box so that the junction has mathematical , physical arbitrariness .
thus , we handled the hamiltonian @xmath324 only , but we adopted proper boundary condition between the two wires and the junction instead of considering the hamiltonian @xmath325 and the interaction @xmath326 so that the hamiltonian @xmath324 becomes observable , i.e. , self - adjoint .
the self - adjointness of the hamiltonian @xmath324 is mathematically determined by a boundary condition of the wave functions on which the hamiltonian @xmath324 acts .
in addition to this , the boundary condition is uniquely determined by the quality and the shape of the boundary of a material of the wires in real physics .
thus , the wave functions have to satisfy the unit s own specific boundary condition to become the residents of the unit , otherwise they are ejected .
our one - to - one correspondence formulae show how the benvegn and dabrowski s four - parameter family are concretely determined .
their four - parameter family shows how the phase factor appears and how the electron spin is affected at the boundary .
since von neumann s theory gives the form of the wave functions , we can grasp how they pass through the junction . on the other hand , the boundary which is not characterized by the benvegn and dabrowski
s four - parameter family is the case where the wave functions never infiltrate the junction , which is characterized by the two parameters .
as is well known , this case is also important , for instance , to demonstrate the aharonov - bohm effect experimentally @xcite .
thus , through our observation along with benvegn and dabrowski s result , we understood that , for the wave functions which pass through the junction , the boundary condition has its own relation between the phase factor and the electron spin .
the results may suggest a mathematical possibility of making a device for switching the channel of qubit . there is a case of the two units in fig.[fig : units ] :
the unit0 accepts the wave functions with the boundary condition bc0 only , and refuses the wave functions with another boundary condition . on the other hand
, the unit1 welcomes the wave functions with the boundary condition bc1 different from bc0 , though it rejects the wave functions with the boundary condition bc0 .
for instance , as shown in eqs.([eq : spin - flip ] ) and ( [ eq : no - spin - flip ] ) below , we can use unit0 for the channel without spin - flip and unit1 for the channel with spin - flip as well as we can use the units for channels for the phase - shifted qubit .
thus , regarding unit0 and unit1 as a qubit , our switching device in fig.[fig : units ] may play a role of _ quantum state transfer _ from spintronic qubit . here
we should remember the experimental demonstration of the flying qubit @xcite , which is realized by the presence of an electron in either channel of the wire of an aharonov - bohm ring .
theorem [ theo:2 ] shows the correspondence : @xmath327 theorem [ theo:2 ] assures us that _ there is no boundary condition which makes a self - adjoint extension but conditions , ( [ bc - rho ] ) and ( [ bc - alpha])_. these two conditions make the broad difference : the solitariness in the boundary condition ( [ bc - rho ] ) , @xmath328 and @xmath329 both of boundary conditions in the left island and the right one are independent of each other , which says that _ there is no interchange between the wave functions living in the left island @xmath330 and those living in the right island @xmath331 _ because the information of the wave functions never infiltrates the junction . in addition , _ no special phase factor but @xmath332 appears in this boundary condition then_. on the other hand , according to eq.(15 ) of ref.@xcite described by the benvegn and dabrowski s four - parameter family with the representation proposition [ prop:06 ] , the boundary condition ( [ bc - alpha ] ) shows _ how the wave functions living in the left island and the those living in the right island make interchange between each other _ , and _ how the electron spin is affected by the phase factor at the boundaries _ : @xmath333 for some @xmath334 , @xmath335 , with @xmath336 .
the wave function ( [ eq : wias-1 ] ) determines four parameters @xmath337 through eq.([eq : tjf1 ] ) .
if @xmath334 , @xmath338 , satisfy @xmath339 and @xmath340 , we obtain the boundary condition so that the _ spin - flip _ with the _ phase factor _ @xmath341 for an arbitrary @xmath342 takes place , that is , the up - spin and the down - spin interchange with each other : @xmath343 meanwhile , if @xmath334 , @xmath338 , satisfy @xmath344 and @xmath345 , we obtain the boundary condition so that the phase factor @xmath346 appears for an arbitrary @xmath342 but the spin - flip does not take place : @xmath347 in fig.[fig : units ] , for instance , let us employ eq.([eq : no - spin - flip ] ) with @xmath348 and @xmath349 for unit0 , and eq.([eq : spin - flip ] ) with @xmath350 and @xmath351 for unit1 , respectively .
we set the pauli - x gate in the disc of junctions .
then , the residence of the wave functions living in unit0 is switched to unit1 after the pauli - x gate operation .
that is , we have a spin - based switching device for qubit .
thus , there is a possibility that we can use this switching device for quantum state transfer from spintronic qubit regarding unit0 and unit1 as qubit . in the same way , if we employ eq.([eq : no - spin - flip ] ) with @xmath348 and @xmath352 for unit1 instead , we can make a phase - based switching device for qubit .
this means that we may control the qubit consisting of unit0 and unit1 through the phase factor @xmath299 .
we note that both the spin - flip gate operation and the phase - shift gate operation had been demonstrated in the experiment for the spin state of an electron - hole pair in a semiconductor quantum dot @xcite .
we will give individual proofs of our main results .
we now prove proposition [ prop : deficiency - indices ] .
let @xmath353 be in the deficiency subspace @xmath354 , i.e. , @xmath355 or @xmath356 . then , since @xmath357 , proposition [ prop : adjoint - operator ] gives us the following differential equation : @xmath358 we note that @xmath359 .
so , according to the general theory of differential equation , every solution @xmath360 of eq.([eq : proof-5 - 1 - 1 ] ) in @xmath134 is respectively written as @xmath361 it follows from this representation that @xmath362 because the functions @xmath363 and @xmath364 mutually intersect orthogonally in the hilbert space @xmath365 .
the existence of self - adjoint extensions follows from proposition [ prop : von - neumann ] . to prove theorem [ theo:1 ] we prepare the following lemma here .
[ lem:02 ] 1 .
let @xmath366 be arbitrary complex numbers
. 1 . for every @xmath367 with @xmath368 ,
there is a wave function @xmath369 so that @xmath370 and @xmath371 .
2 . for every @xmath367 with @xmath372 and @xmath269 ,
there is a wave function @xmath369 so that @xmath370 and @xmath373 .
3 . for every @xmath367 with @xmath274 and @xmath374 ,
there is a wave function @xmath369 so that @xmath371 and @xmath375 .
4 . for every @xmath367 with @xmath376
, there is a wave function @xmath369 so that @xmath373 and @xmath375 .
2 . for arbitrary vector @xmath377
, there is a wave function @xmath378 so that @xmath379 .
we embed the function spaces @xmath380 and @xmath381 in the function space @xmath134 in the following : for every @xmath382 , we expand the function @xmath360 as @xmath383 for @xmath384 and regard the function @xmath360 as the function on @xmath385 .
we employ the same expansion for functions in @xmath381 .
\i ) it is not so difficult to show this part .
let @xmath386 be in @xmath387 .
fix an arbitrary function @xmath388 with @xmath389 , and take it . for an arbitrary number @xmath390
we define functions @xmath391 by @xmath392 .
similarly , take a function @xmath393 with @xmath394 .
for an arbitrary number @xmath395 we define functions @xmath396 by @xmath397 . in the case where @xmath368 , define a function @xmath398 by @xmath399 . in the case
where @xmath372 and @xmath269 , define a function @xmath398 by @xmath400 . in the case
where @xmath274 and @xmath374 , define a function @xmath401 by @xmath402 . in the case where @xmath376 , define a function @xmath398 by @xmath403 .
then , we obtain our desired wave function @xmath360 .
\ii ) take functions @xmath404 and @xmath405 with @xmath406 , @xmath407 , @xmath408 , and @xmath409 . for arbitrary vector @xmath377
we define functions @xmath410 and @xmath411 by @xmath412 and @xmath413 , respectively .
define the function @xmath414 by @xmath415 .
then , we reach the function @xmath414 satisfying @xmath416 with @xmath417 . in the same way , we can obtain a function @xmath418 satisfying @xmath419 with @xmath420 . therefore , defining the function @xmath360 by @xmath421 , this function is our desired one .
@xmath422 + we here prove theorem [ theo:1 ] . using integration by parts , for every @xmath423 we have the following equation : @xmath424 \i ) we prove our statement in the case where @xmath425 only .
it is clear that @xmath426 .
first up , we show @xmath427 .
since @xmath428 , eq.([eq : theo-1 - 1 ] ) leads to the equation , @xmath429 for every @xmath430 .
this means that @xmath221 is symmetric , i.e. , @xmath427 .
next , we show @xmath431 . based on lemma [ lem:02 ] ( i-1 ) , for arbitrary vector @xmath377
, we employ the wave function @xmath432 so that @xmath433 and @xmath434 . using the definition of the adjoint operator , the fact that @xmath435 , and eq.([eq : theo-1 - 1 ] ) , we have the equation , @xmath436 for every @xmath437 . because the complex numbers @xmath438 and @xmath439 were arbitrarily , we have the equations : @xmath440 and @xmath441 for every @xmath437 .
these conditions say that @xmath442 , namely , @xmath443 and thus @xmath444 .
therefore , we have showed that the dirac operator @xmath221 is a self - adjoint extension of the minimal dirac operator : @xmath445 . in the same way
, we can prove our statement for the case where @xmath446 or @xmath447 with the help of lemma [ lem:02 ] ( i-2)(i-4 ) .
\ii ) let us fix an arbitrary vector @xmath283 in the class ( [ cl - alpha ] ) .
it is clear that @xmath448 . by eq.([eq : theo-1 - 1 ] ) together with the fact that @xmath449 , we have the equation , @xmath450 for every @xmath451 .
this means that @xmath225 is symmetric , i.e. , @xmath452 .
based on lemma [ lem:02 ] ii ) , for arbitrary vector @xmath377 , we employ the wave function @xmath453 so that @xmath454 . using the definition of the adjoint operator , the fact that @xmath455 , and eq.([eq : theo-1 - 1 ] ) , we have the equation , @xmath456 for every @xmath457 . because the complex numbers @xmath438 and @xmath439 were arbitrarily , we have the equations : @xmath458 and @xmath459 for every @xmath457 .
we here note that the immediate computation leads to the entries of the inverse boundary matrix as @xmath460 since @xmath461 satisfies the conditions of the class ( [ cl - alpha ] ) .
hence it follows that @xmath462 , namely , @xmath463 and thus @xmath464 .
therefore , we have showed that the dirac operator @xmath225 is a self - adjoint extension of the minimal dirac operator : @xmath465 .
first up , we rewrite @xmath466 in terms of the electron spin , that is , in terms of the hamilton quaternion field spanned by the pauli spin matrices : [ lem:03 ] the special unitary group @xmath466 has the following representation : @xmath467 in this proof we use the following representation . introducing the argument @xmath468 of each entry @xmath469 of the matrix @xmath470 ,
we represent @xmath80 as @xmath471 let us handle an arbitrary @xmath6 for a while .
the unitarity of @xmath80 leads to the equations : @xmath472 comparing the diagonal entries in the first row and the first column of both sides of eq.([eq : unitary - eq02 ] ) , we have the equality : @xmath473 in addition , we similarly have the equality , @xmath474 , by eq.([eq : unitary - eq01 ] ) .
thus , it follows from these two equalities that @xmath475 in the same way , using the equalities , @xmath474 and @xmath476 , we reach the equality : @xmath477 comparing the off - diagonal entries in the first row and the second column of both sides of in eq.([eq : unitary - eq01 ] ) , and using eqs.([eq:5 - 3 - 2 ] ) and ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 3 ] ) , we have the equation , @xmath478 multiplying the both sides of this by @xmath479 , we have @xmath480 thus , we have derived the conditions ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 1 ] ) , ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 2 ] ) , ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 3 ] ) , and ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 4 ] ) from the condition @xmath6 .
conversely , it is easy to check that eqs.([eq:5 - 3 - 1 ] ) , ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 2 ] ) , ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 3 ] ) , and ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 4 ] ) bring us to the condition @xmath6 .
consequently , the condition @xmath6 is equivalent to the conditions ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 1 ] ) , ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 2 ] ) , ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 3 ] ) , and ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 4 ] ) : @xmath481 let us consider the case where @xmath482 from now on .
then , we have an extra condition : @xmath483 combining eq.([eq : unitary - eq03 ] ) with eqs.([eq:5 - 3 - 1])([eq:5 - 3 - 3 ] ) leads to the equations , @xmath484 which implies that @xmath485 assume that @xmath486 now . then , eq.([eq:5 - 3 - 4 ] ) brings us to the equation : @xmath487 eqs.([eq:5 - 3 - 5 ] ) and ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 6 ] ) say that @xmath488 here .
then , the above equation leads to the relation , @xmath489 .
this is a contradiction .
thus , by the reductio ad absurdum , we know that @xmath490 and therefore @xmath491 by eq.([eq:5 - 3 - 6 ] ) . on the other hand , assume that @xmath492 .
then , we have the condition , @xmath493 or @xmath494 , by eq.([eq:5 - 3 - 1 ] ) . in the case where @xmath493 , since we have the equality @xmath495 , the equation @xmath490 comes up from eq.([eq:5 - 3 - 5 ] ) . in the case
@xmath494 , similarly , the equation @xmath491 is derived from eq.([eq:5 - 3 - 5 ] ) .
these arguments make us realize that @xmath496 in this way , we succeeded in showing that the condition @xmath482 implies the conditions ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 1 ] ) , ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 2 ] ) , ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 3 ] ) , ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 4 ] ) , and the extra condition ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 7 ] ) . we here show that adding the condition ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 7 ] ) to the conditions ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 1 ] ) , ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 2 ] ) , ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 3 ] ) , and ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 4 ] ) completes a necessary and sufficient condition so that @xmath482 . in the case where @xmath486
, we have the equations , @xmath497 , since @xmath490 and @xmath491 by the condition ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 7 ] ) . in the case
@xmath492 , if @xmath495 ( resp .
@xmath498 ) , then we have the equality , @xmath499 ( resp .
@xmath500 ) by eq.([eq:5 - 3 - 1 ] ) .
thus , we reach the computation , @xmath501 ( resp .
@xmath502 ) by the condition ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 7 ] ) . therefore , the condition , @xmath482 , is equivalent to the conditions , ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 1 ] ) , ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 2 ] ) , ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 3 ] ) , ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 4 ] ) , and ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 7 ] ) : @xmath503 based on this equivalence ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 8 ] ) , set our desired complex numbers as @xmath504 and @xmath505 , respectively
. then , we have @xmath506 if @xmath495 , and @xmath507 if @xmath494 , by ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 2 ] ) and ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 7 ] ) .
we have @xmath508 if @xmath498 , and @xmath509 if @xmath493 , by ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 3 ] ) and ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 7 ] ) .
thus , we obtain the statement of our lemma .
@xmath422 + now we prove proposition [ prop:03 ] .
we use the matrix representation ( [ eq : representation - matrix ] ) again . in the case
where @xmath510 , through the equivalence ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 8 ] ) , multiplying the both sides of eq.([eq:5 - 3 - 4 ] ) by @xmath511 gives us the expression @xmath512 .
thus , we can compute the determinant of @xmath80 as @xmath513 here we used eq.([eq:5 - 3 - 1 ] ) of the equivalence ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 8 ] ) , and the equality @xmath514 .
thus , we realize that @xmath515 . define our desired complex numbers as @xmath516 , @xmath517 , and @xmath518 , respectively .
then , lemma [ lem:03 ] gives the representation : @xmath519 on the other hand , in the case @xmath520 , we can compute the determinant of @xmath80 as @xmath521 since we have the value of @xmath522 as @xmath523 by eq.([eq:5 - 3 - 1 ] ) of the equivalence ( [ eq:5 - 3 - 8 ] ) .
thus , we realize that @xmath524 .
based on lemma [ lem:03 ] , define our desired complex numbers as @xmath525 , @xmath526 , and @xmath527 , respectively .
then , we reach the conclusion , @xmath528 these are the construction of the representation in our proposition . before proving theorem [ theo:2 ]
, we make a small remark : for every @xmath529 , there are @xmath238 and @xmath236 so that @xmath530 by propositions [ prop : von - neumann ] and [ prop : deficiency - indices ] together with eq.([eq : solution ] ) .
we prove theorem [ theo:2 ] i ) here .
let us suppose that @xmath80 is diagonal . in this case
, it is clear that there are complex numbers @xmath9 so that latexmath:[\[u= \left ( \begin{array}{cc } \gamma_{l } & 0 \\ 0 & \gamma_{r } \end{array } \right),\quad operator @xmath80 on @xmath532 is determined by @xmath533 and @xmath534 . by eq.([eq : hu ] ) , we can represent the boundary value @xmath535 as @xmath536 and the boundary value @xmath537 as @xmath538 we set @xmath539 as @xmath540 , and so , we have @xmath541 . here
@xmath166 was given as @xmath297 , and thus , @xmath542 and @xmath543 .
we compare the boundary values @xmath544 and
@xmath545 : in the case where @xmath546 , we have @xmath547 the value of @xmath548 runs over the whole @xmath107 when the angular @xmath549 runs over @xmath550 , and then , the correspondence @xmath551 makes the one - to - one correspondence . on the other hand , in the case
where @xmath552 , we have @xmath553 and @xmath554 .
similarly , compare the boundary values @xmath555 and @xmath556 : in the case where @xmath557 , we have @xmath558 the correspondence @xmath559 makes the one - to - one correspondence . in the case where @xmath273 , we have @xmath560 and @xmath561 . therefore , we realize that the condition , @xmath562 , is equivalent to the correspondence : @xmath563 for @xmath564 and @xmath565 for @xmath268 , and @xmath566 for @xmath557 and @xmath567 for @xmath273 , which gives our desired correspondence .
we prove theorem [ theo:2 ] ii ) now .
first up , proposition [ prop:03 ] gives the representation of @xmath80 : there are complex numbers @xmath277 so that @xmath568 here the fact , @xmath322 , comes from the assumption that @xmath80 is non - diagonal .
thus , the operation of @xmath80 on @xmath532 is determined by @xmath569 and @xmath570 .
using eq.([eq : hu ] ) , we can compute individual boundary values @xmath535 and @xmath537 as @xmath571 and @xmath572 we remember that @xmath573 and @xmath574 , and then , @xmath575 thus , noting @xmath576 , we can compute the following inverse matrix : @xmath577 thus , define a @xmath235 matrix @xmath578 by @xmath579 then , we have @xmath580 thus , we reach the boundary condition : @xmath581 for every @xmath582 .
we set @xmath583 as @xmath584 , @xmath585 , and then , we have @xmath586
. then , @xmath587 and @xmath588 are real numbers , and @xmath589 and @xmath590 are purely imaginary numbers , which implies the relations : @xmath591 , @xmath592 , @xmath593 , and @xmath594 .
so , we have confirmed the first part of conditions of the class ( [ cl - alpha ] ) .
we check the last two conditions of the class ( [ cl - alpha ] ) : the immediate computation easily bring us to @xmath595 using @xmath596 .
we here note that @xmath597 , @xmath598 , which implies @xmath599 .
thus , we have @xmath600 .
therefore , we can conclude from the above argument that the vector @xmath601 is in the class ( [ cl - alpha ] ) , and then , @xmath602 .
therefore , the condition , @xmath603 , is equivalent to the correspondence @xmath604 .
we accomplished the proof of the part ii ) .
we denote by @xmath605 the set on the right hand side of our desired representation .
it is evident that @xmath606 .
so , the only thing we have to do is that we show @xmath607 . for every @xmath608 ,
set @xmath609 as @xmath610 .
since the vector @xmath140 is in the class ( [ cl - alpha ] ) , @xmath611 , @xmath612 , @xmath613 , and @xmath614 are purely imaginary numbers .
moreover , the last condition of the class ( [ cl - alpha ] ) says that @xmath615 .
that is , @xmath616 is a real number .
thus , it follows from the last condition , that @xmath617 is also a real number , and @xmath305 or @xmath306 . in the case where @xmath618 ,
setting @xmath619 , and @xmath308 as @xmath620 , @xmath621 , @xmath622 , @xmath623 , and @xmath624 , we immediately obtain the representation of @xmath216 in @xmath605 . in the case
@xmath311 , we only have to set @xmath619 , and @xmath308 by @xmath625 , @xmath626 , @xmath627 , @xmath628 , and @xmath629 , respectively , and then , we reach our desired fact @xmath630 . thus , the two cases imply that @xmath607 .
therefore , we can conclude the proof of the equality , @xmath631 .
we prove proposition [ prop : inverse ] here .
first up , it immediately follows from the definition of @xmath259 , @xmath260 , and @xmath632 that @xmath596 .
we here remark that this equation gives us the equation , @xmath633 .
\label{eq : inv-1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] next , we show @xmath634 . it is easy to check the equations , @xmath635 by proposition [ prop:06 ] . by using these equations together with @xmath636 we have @xmath637 \\ & { = } & \textrm{right hand side of ( \ref{eq : inv-1})}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , we have @xmath634 , and then , we reach @xmath638 thus , what we have to show is that every @xmath529 satisfies the boundary condition ( [ bc - alpha ] ) .
insert the boundary values @xmath639 and @xmath640 with expressions , @xmath641 into the boundary conditions , @xmath642 then , by using the arbitrariness of the coefficients @xmath242 and @xmath241 in @xmath183 and noting the fact @xmath576 , we can show that the condition @xmath643 is equivalent to the system of the following system of equations : @xmath644 then , we can show that our @xmath645 is a solution of this system of equations : noting @xmath646 and @xmath336 , we have @xmath647 .
thus , we realize that our @xmath648 satisfy ( [ eq : inverse-2 ] ) as @xmath649 \\ & { = } & \gamma_{3}^{*}(-\alpha_{1}+\mu\alpha_{2}).\end{aligned}\ ] ] using @xmath650 and @xmath651 , we can show that our @xmath648 satisfy ( [ eq : inverse-3 ] ) as @xmath652 combining @xmath651 and @xmath336 , we have @xmath653 . using this equation and @xmath650 , we can show that our @xmath648 satisfy ( [ eq : inverse-4 ] ) as @xmath654 \\ & { = } & \gamma_{3}^{*}(-\alpha_{3}+\mu\alpha_{4 } ) .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] using @xmath650 and @xmath646 , we know that our @xmath648 satisfy ( [ eq : inverse-5 ] ) as @xmath655 therefore , consequently , we can complete the proof of our proposition .
we have proved that all the boundary conditions of wave functions of our dirac particle are completely classified into the two types . for the case where the electron s wave functions do not pass through the junction
, their boundary condition can be described by two parameters , @xmath9 with @xmath10 , determined by von neumann s theory . in the case where the wave functions do pass through the junction
, the boundary condition is described by benvegn and dabrowski s four - parameter family , and then , their four parameters can actually be described by three parameters , @xmath13 with @xmath14 and @xmath322 , determined by von neumann s theory .
these results stem from our one - to - one correspondence formulae , eqs.([eq : tjf1 ] ) and ( [ eq : tjf2 ] ) with propositions [ prop:03 ] and [ prop:06 ] .
let us make small two remarks at the tail end of this paper . using our method
, we can completely classify the boundary conditions of all self - adjoint extensions of the minimal schrdinger operator , too @xcite . in the dirac operator s case
, there is no effect of the length of junction in the boundary condition .
however , in the schrdinger operator s case we can find it in the boundary condition .
we have not understand any strictly physical reason why the schrdinger particle feels the length @xmath4 of the junction , but the dirac particle does not .
we conjecture that the speed of the particle is concerned with the reason .
one of the authors ( m.h . ) acknowledges the financial support from jsps , grant - in - aid for scientific research ( c ) 23540204 .
he also expresses special thanks to kae nemoto and yutaka shikano for the useful discussions with them .
a. b. giroday , a. j. bennett , m. a. pooley , r. m. stevenson , n. skld , r. b. patel , i. farrer , d. a. ritchie , and a. j. shields , _ all - electrical coherent control of the exciton states in a single quantum dot _ , phys .
b , * 82 * ( 2010 ) , 241301 .
s. hermelin , s. takada , m. yamamoto , s. tarucha , a. d. wieck , l. saminadayar , c. buerle , and t. meunier , _ electrons surfing on a sound wave as a platform for quantum optics with flying electrons _ ,
nature , * 477 * ( 2011 ) , 435 . m. n. leuenberger , m. e. flatt , and d. d. awschalom , _ teleportation of electronic many - qubit states encoded in the electron spin of quantum dots via single photons _
, phys . rev .
lett . , * 94 * ( 2005 ) , 107401 . _
r. p. g. mcneil , m. kataoka , c. j. b. ford , c. h. w. barnes , d. anderson , g. a. c. jones , i. farrer , and d. a. ritchie _ , _ on - demand single - electron transfer between distant quantum dots _ , nature , * 477 * ( 2011 ) , 439 .
n. osakabe , t. matsuda , t. kawasaki , j. endo , a. tonomura , s. yano , and h. yamada , _ experimental confirmation of aharonov - bohm effect using a toroidal magnetic field confined by a superconductor _ , phys .
rev . a , * 34 * ( 1986 ) , 815
. t. s. santos , j. s. lee , p. migdal , i. c. lekshmi , b. satpati , and j. s. moodera , _ room - temperature tunnel magnetoresistance and spin - polarized tunneling through an organic semiconductor barrier _ , phys .
lett . , * 98 * ( 2007 ) , 016601 .
j. j. h. m. schoonus , p. g. e. lumens , w. wagemans , j. t. kohlhepp , p. a. bobbert , h. j. m. swagten , and b. koopmans , _ magnetoresistance in hybrid organic spin valves at the onset of multiple - step tunneling _ , phys .
lett . , * 103 * ( 2009 ) , 146601 . a. tokuno , m. oshikawa , and e. demler , _ dynamics of one - dimensional bose liquids : andreev - like reflection at y - junctions and the absence of the aharonov - bohm effect _ ,
, * 100 * ( 2008 ) , 140402 .
x. zhang , s. mizukami , t. kubota , q. ma , m. oogane , h. naganuma , y. ando , and t. miyazaki , _ observation of a large spin - dependent transport length in organic spin valves at room temperature _ , nature communications , * 4 * ( 2013 ) , 1392 . | we consider the dirac particle living in the @xmath0-dimensional configuration space with a junction for a spintronic qubit . we give concrete formulae explicitly showing the one - to - one correspondence between every self - adjoint extension of the minimal dirac operator and the boundary condition of the wave functions of the dirac particle .
we then show that the boundary conditions are classified into two types : one of them is characterized by two parameters and the other is by three parameters .
then , we show that benvegn and dabrowski s four - parameter family can actually be characterized by three parameters , concerned with the reflection , penetration , and phase factor . |
the flavor content of the nucleon sea provides an important test for models of nucleon structure .
a flavor symmetric sea leads to the gottfried sum rule @xmath6 @xcite , whereas any deviation from this value is an indication of the @xmath7 asymmetry of the nucleon sea .
the first clear evidence of a violation of the gottfried sum rule came from the new muon collaboration ( nmc ) @xcite , which was later confirmed by drell - yan experiments @xcite and a measurement of semi - inclusive deep - inelastic scattering @xcite .
all experiments show evidence that there are more @xmath4 quarks in the proton than there are @xmath5 quarks .
the experimental results and theoretical ideas on the flavor asymmetric sea are summarized in several review articles @xcite . in the constituent quark model ( cqm ) , the proton is described in terms of a @xmath8 valence - quark configuration . therefore , a violation of the gottfried sum rule implies the existence of higher fock components ( such as @xmath9 configurations ) in the proton wave function .
additional indications for the importance of multiquark components are provided by parity - violating electron scattering experiments , which have shown evidence for a nonvanishing strange quark contribution , albeit small , to the charge and magnetization distributions of the proton @xcite , and by cqm studies of baryon spectroscopy @xcite .
whereas most models ( see _ e.g. _ @xcite ) reproduce the mass spectrum of baryon resonances reasonably well , they show very similar deviations for other properties , such as for example the electromagnetic and strong decay widths of @xmath10 and @xmath11 , the spin - orbit splitting of @xmath12 and @xmath13 , the low @xmath14 behavior of transition form factors , and the large @xmath15 decay widths of @xmath16 , @xmath17 and @xmath18 .
all of these results point towards the need to include exotic degrees of freedom ( _ i.e. _ other than @xmath19 ) , such as multiquark @xmath20 or gluonic @xmath21 configurations . as an illustration
we show in fig .
[ d13 ] the transverse electromagnetic transition form factors of the @xmath22 resonance for different cqms .
the problem of missing strength at low @xmath14 can be attributed to the lack of explicit quark - antiquark degrees of freedom , which become more important in the outer region of the nucleon .
theoretically , the role of @xmath23 configurations in the nucleon wave function was studied in an application to the electromagnetic form factors @xcite .
mesonic contributions to the spin and flavor structure of the nucleon are reviewed in @xcite . in another , cqm based , approach the importance of @xmath2 pairs in the proton was studied in a flux - tube breaking model based on valence - quark plus glue dominance to which @xmath2 pairs are added in perturbation @xcite .
the pair - creation mechanism is inserted at the quark level and the one - loop diagrams are calculated by summing over a complete set of intermediate baryon - meson states @xmath24 ( see fig .
[ fig:1 ] ) . for consistency with the ozi - rule and to retain the success of the cqm in hadron spectroscopy
, it was found necessary to sum over a complete set of intermediate states , including both pseudoscalar and vector mesons , rather than just a few low - lying states @xcite . in order to address the violation of the gottfried sum rule
, we first generalize the model of @xcite to include @xmath0 and @xmath1 loops as well .
the formalism of the ensuing unquenched quark model is reviewed briefly before discussing an application to the flavor asymmetry of the nucleon sea .
in the flux - tube model for hadrons , the quark potential model arises from an adiabatic approximation to the gluonic degrees of freedom embodied in the flux tube @xcite .
the role of quark - antiquark pairs in meson spectroscopy was studied in a flux - tube breaking model @xcite in which the @xmath3 pair is created with the @xmath25 quantum numbers of the vacuum .
subsequently , it was shown by geiger and isgur @xcite that a _ miraculous _ set of cancellations between apparently uncorrelated sets of intermediate states occurs in such a way that they compensate each other and do not destroy the good cqm results for the mesons .
in particular , the ozi hierarchy is preserved and there is a near immunity of the long - range confining potential , since the change in the linear potential due to the creation of quark - antiquark pairs in the string can be reabsorbed into a new strength of the linear potential , _
i.e. _ in a new string tension . as a result ,
the net effect of the mass shifts from pair creation is smaller than the naive expectation of the order of the strong decay widths .
however , it is necessary to sum over large towers of intermediate states to see that the spectrum of the mesons , after unquenching and renormalizing , is only weakly perturbed .
an important conclusion is that no simple truncation of the set of meson loops is able to reproduce such results @xcite .
the extension of the flux - tube breaking model to baryons requires a proper treatment of the permutation symmetry between identical quarks . as a first step ,
geiger and isgur investigated the importance of @xmath2 loops in the proton by taking into account the contribution of the six different diagrams of fig .
[ diagrams ] with @xmath26 and @xmath27 , and by using harmonic oscillator wave functions for the baryons and mesons @xcite . in the conclusions ,
the authors emphasized that , in order to investigate the origin of the violation of the gottfried sum rule and the spin crisis of the proton , it is necessary to extend their calculation to include @xmath0 and @xmath1 loops as well . in this contribution , we take up this challenge and present a generalization of the formalism of @xcite in which quark - antiquark contributions can be studied * for any initial baryon resonance , * for any flavor of the quark - antiquark pair , and * for any model of baryons and mesons .
these extensions were made possible by two developments : the solution of the problem of the permutation symmetry between identical quarks by means of group - theoretical techniques , and the construction of an algorithm to generate a complete set of intermediate states for any model of baryons and mesons . while the first improvement allows the evaluation of the contribution of quark - antiquark pairs for any initial baryon @xmath28 ( ground state or resonance ) and for any flavor of the @xmath3 pair ( not only @xmath29 , but also @xmath30 and @xmath31 ) , the second one permits the carry out the sum over intermediate states up to saturation for any model of baryons and mesons , as long as their wave functions are expressed in the basis of harmonic oscillator wave functions .
the ensuing unquenched quark model is based on an adiabatic treatment of the flux - tube dynamics to which @xmath3 pairs with vacuum quantum numbers are added as a perturbation @xcite
. the pair - creation mechanism is inserted at the quark level and the one - loop diagrams are calculated by summing over a complete set of intermediate states . under these assumptions , to leading order in pair creation , the baryon wave function is given by @xmath32 ~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath33 denotes the initial baryon and @xmath34 and @xmath35 the intermediate baryon and meson , @xmath36 and @xmath37 represent the relative radial momentum and orbital angular momentum of @xmath34 and @xmath35 , and @xmath38 is the total angular momentum @xmath39 . the operator @xmath40 represents the quark - antiquark pair - creation operator with the @xmath25 quantum numbers of the vacuum @xcite @xmath41^{(0 ) } b_i^{\dagger}(\vec{p}_i ) \ , d_j^{\dagger}(\vec{p}_j ) ~. \end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath42 and @xmath43 are the creation operators for a quark and antiquark with momenta @xmath44 and @xmath45 , respectively .
the quark pair is characterized by a color singlet wave function @xmath46 , a flavor singlet wave function @xmath47 and a spin triplet wave function @xmath48 with spin @xmath49 .
the solid harmonic @xmath50 indicates that the quark and antiquark are in a relative @xmath51 wave .
since the operator @xmath40 creates a pair of constituent quarks , a gaussian quark - antiquark creation vertex function was introduced by which the pair is created as a finite object with an effective size , rather than as a pointlike object . in momentum space it is given by @xmath52 the width has been determined from meson decays to be approximately @xmath53 fm @xcite .
here we take the average value , @xmath54 fm .
finally , the dimensionless constant @xmath55 is the intrinsic pair creation strength which has been determined from strong decays of baryons as @xmath56 @xcite .
the strong coupling vertex @xmath57 was derived in explicit form in the harmonic oscillator basis @xcite . in the present calculations , we use harmonic oscillator wave functions
in which there is a single oscillator parameter for the baryons and another one for the mesons which , following @xcite , are taken to be @xmath58 gev @xcite and @xmath59 ( gev ) @xcite , respectively . in general , matrix elements of an observable @xmath60 can be expressed as @xmath61 where the first term denotes the contribution from the valence quarks @xmath62 and the second term that from the @xmath3 pairs @xmath63 we developed an algorithm based upon group - theoretical techniques to generate a complete set of intermediate states of good permutational symmetry , which makes it possible to perform the sum over intermediate states up to saturation , and not just for the first few shells as in @xcite .
not only does this have a significant impact on the numerical result , but it is necessary for consistency with the ozi - rule and the success of cqms in hadron spectroscopy .
the first clear evidence for the flavor asymmetry of the nucleon sea was provided by nmc at cern @xcite .
the flavor asymmetry is related to the gottfried integral for the difference of the proton and neutron electromagnetic structure functions @xmath64
\nonumber\\ & = & \frac{1}{3 } \left [ 1 - 2(n_{\bar{d}}-n_{\bar{u } } ) \right ] ~.\end{aligned}\ ] ] under the assumption of a flavor symmetric sea @xmath65 one obtains the gottfried sum rule @xmath6 .
the final nmc value is @xmath66 at @xmath67 ( gev / c)@xmath68 for the gottfried integral over the range @xmath69 @xcite , which implies a flavor asymmetric sea .
the violation of the gottfried sum rule has been confirmed by other experimental collaborations @xcite .
table [ tab:1 ] shows that the experimental values of the gottfried integral are consistent with each other within the quoted uncertainties , even though the experiments were performed at very different scales , as reflected in the average @xmath14 values .
theoretically , it was shown that in the framework of the cloudy bag model the coupling of the proton to the pion cloud provides a mechanism to produce a flavor asymmetry due to the dominance of @xmath70 among the virtual configurations @xcite . in the unquenched quark model
, the flavor asymmetry can be calculated from the difference of the number of @xmath4 and @xmath5 sea quarks in the proton @xmath71 even in absence of explicit information on the ( anti)quark distribution functions , the integrated value can be obtained directly from eq .
( [ asym ] ) .
the effect of the quark - antiquark pairs on the gottfried integral is a reduction of about one third with respect to the gottfried sum rule , corresponding to an excess of @xmath4 over @xmath5 quarks in the proton which is in qualitative agreement with the nmc result .
an explicit calculation with harmonic oscillator wave functions for the baryons and mesons in which the sum over intermediate states includes four oscillator shells , shows a proton asymmetry @xmath72 which corresponds to @xmath73 , in remarkable agreement with the experimental value .
it is important to note that in this calculation the parameters were taken from the literature @xcite , and that no attempt was made to optimize their values . due to isospin symmetry
, the neutron has a similar excess of @xmath5 over @xmath4 quarks @xmath74 .
lccc experiment & @xmath75 & @xmath76 range & @xmath77 + nmc & @xmath78 & @xmath79 & @xmath66 + hermes & @xmath80 & @xmath81 & @xmath82 + e866/nusea & @xmath83 & @xmath84 & @xmath85 +
in this contribution , we discussed the importance of quark - antiquark pairs in baryon spectroscopy . to this end
, we developed an unquenched quark model for baryons in which the contributions from @xmath0 , @xmath1 and @xmath2 loops are taken into account in a systematic way .
the present model is an extension of the flux - tube breaking model of geiger and isgur @xcite , and is valid for any initial baryon resonance , any flavor of the quark - antiquark pair and any model of baryons and mesons .
the model was applied to the flavor asymmetry of the nucleon sea . in a first calculation with harmonic oscillator wave functions for both baryons and mesons in which the parameters were taken from the literature @xcite
, it was shown that the inclusion of @xmath3 pairs leads automatically to an excess of @xmath4 over @xmath5 quarks in the proton .
the value that we obtained for the violation of the gottfried sum rule is in amazing agreement with the experimental data .
we emphasize that no attempt was made to optimize the parameters in the calculations .
the first applications of the unquenched quark model to the flavor asymmetry of the nucleon sea and the proton spin @xcite are very promising and encouraging .
we believe that the inclusion of the effects of quark - antiquark pairs in a general and consistent way may provide a major improvement to the constituent quark model , which increases considerably its range and applicability . in future work
, the present unquenched quark model will be applied systematically to several problems in light baryon spectroscopy , such as the electromagnetic and strong couplings , the elastic and transition form factors of baryon resonances , their sea quark content and their flavor decomposition @xcite .
this work was supported in part by papiit - unam , mexico ( grant in113808 ) and in part by i.n.f.n . ,
italy .
s. capstick and n. isgur , phys .
d * 34 * , 2809 ( 1986 ) ; + r. bijker , f. iachello and a. leviatan , ann .
( n.y . ) * 236 * , 69 ( 1994 ) ; _ ibid . _
* 284 * , 89 ( 2000 ) ; phys .
d * 55 * , 2862 ( 1997 ) ; + m. ferraris , m.m .
giannini , m. pizzo , e. santopinto and l. tiator , phys .
b * 364 * , 231 ( 1995 ) ; + m. aiello , m. ferraris , m.m .
giannini , m. pizzo and e. santopinto , phys .
b * 387 * , 215 ( 1996 ) .
glozman and d.o .
riska , phys . rep . * 268 * , 263 ( 1996 ) ; + l.ya .
glozman , w. plessas , k. varga and r.f .
wagenbrunn , phys .
d * 58 * , 094030 ( 1998 ) ; + u. lring , k. kretzschmar , b.ch .
metsch , h.r .
petry , eur .
j. a * 10 * , 309 ( 2001 ) ; + u. lring , b.ch .
metsch , h.r .
petry , eur .
j. a * 10 * , 447 ( 2001 ) . | the flavor asymmetry of the nucleon sea is discussed in an unquenched quark model for baryons in which the effects of quark - antiquark pairs ( @xmath0 , @xmath1 and @xmath2 ) are taken into account in an explicit form .
the inclusion of @xmath3 pairs leads automatically to an excess of @xmath4 over @xmath5 quarks in the proton , in ageement with experimental data .
keywords : protons and neutrons , quark models , flavor symmetries , gottfried sum rule se discute la asimetra de sabor del nuclen en una extensin del modelo de cuarks en que se toman en cuento de manera explcita los efectos de creacin de pares cuark - anticuark ( @xmath0 , @xmath1 y @xmath2 ) .
la inclusin de los pares @xmath3 lleva inmediatamente a un exceso de cuarks @xmath4 sobre @xmath5 en el protn , de acuerdo con los datos experimentales .
descriptores : protones y neutrones , modelos de cuarks , simetra de sabor , regla de suma de gottfried |
in the current literature of complex systems , aging is frequently reported as a phenomenon observed in spin glasses and other disordered systems , rather than in biological systems @xcite , though some works have been devoted to biological aging of populations @xcite .
relevant contributions have been brought presenting this phenomenon from a general perspective , revealing that temporal autocorrelation functions in the bak - sneppen model display aging behavior similar to glassy systems@xcite . to our knowledge
those papers give , up to now , the more relevant contribution to the relation between soc and aging .
up to our knowledge , a detailed study of individual aging from the viewpoint of self - organized critical systems has not yet been performed .
it is well known that biological aging manifests itself in an individual as the slowing down of many processes as , _
e.g_. , slower growing of tumors and manifestation of senescence in the slowing down of reflex behavior . due to its characteristics ,
relaxation phenomena in complex systems are good candidates to the study of aging .
about 150 years ago , weber and gauss carried out a simple experiment demonstrating that relaxation in complex systems is not exponential .
investigating the contraction of a silk thread they found that it does not contract so quickly but it relaxes slowly following a power law @xmath1 .
this behavior is not particular of mechanical relaxation , it has been also observed in experiments of magnetic relaxation in spin glasses and high critical temperature superconductors , transient current measurements in amorphous semiconductors , dielectric relaxation , and more @xcite . in relaxation dynamics
, aging means that the properties of a system depends on its age @xcite .
for instance , consider a glass quenched at time @xmath2 below its glass transition temperature under an external stress . at time @xmath3 the stress is released .
if the system were near equilibrium , then its response measured at certain time @xmath4 will be a function of the difference @xmath5 and , therefore , normalized responses taken at different initial times @xmath6 will collapse in a single curve .
however , this is not the behavior in glass materials , and , as was pointed above , in live beings .
aging is a consequence of the nonequilibrium dynamics and may be considered as a characteristic of the dynamics of complex systems far from equilibrium . in the following sections we demonstrate that these manifestations of individual aging are present in sandpile avalanches modeled with a bethe lattice , particularly , the process of relaxation .
contrary to @xcite , we do not consider deterministic toppling ( like that present in the bak - sneppen model ) but a probabilistic one , and avalanches are not regarded as infinite , as is @xcite , but the finite size of the system ( sandpile ) is explicitly included .
sandpiles seem to be simplest systems which lead to complex behavior and are a paradigm for the study of all phenomena manifested in complex systems out of equilibrium , like relaxation under external perturbations .
they have been taken as the paradigm of self - organization since the introduction of these ideas by bak , tang , and wiesenfeld @xcite .
the evolution of a sandpile under an external perturbation has been extensively studied experimentally @xcite , theoretically @xcite , and by computer simulations @xcite . in general , those works analyze the sandpile dynamics close to the critical state , i.e. , close to the critical angle . if a sandpile is subjected to an external perturbation , like , _
e.g. _ , small amplitude vibrations , large amplitude grain motions are rare events but from time to time , a grain may jump from its quasiequilibrium position .
if a surface grain jumps , it will fall through the slope of the pile until it collides with another sand grains down the slope . after this collision
the initial grain may be trapped with those grains or some of them may fall through the slope . if the last possibility happens then each grain surviving the collision will fall through the slope as the initial grain did .
this image of an avalanche as an initial object that consecutively drags another resembles a branching process for which the bethe lattice representation seems to be natural @xcite .
the representation of the avalanche dynamics as a bethe lattice is a mean field approach to the problem .
it neglects correlations between branches .
notwithstanding , if the pile angle is below is critical value the avalanches will be rare events and , in case of occurrence , will be very sparse .
thus , such an approximation will be acceptable for analyzing the long time relaxation of the pile angle below its critical value , which is the subject of this paper .
away from the critical point the mean field approximation works quite well .
let us represent the avalanche as a cascade in the bethe lattice as follows .
firstly , we start with a single node , which could represent in this case a grain . in a further step @xmath7
will emerge with probability @xmath8 , depending on the pile angle @xmath9 .
this operation of generation of @xmath7 identical particles starting from one is repeated in the next step to each node of the new group , and so on . if the percolation process overcomes a given length ( that of the border of the pile ) those nodes beyond the limit constitute the avalanche .
if it does not , there would be no avalanche since the cascade was stopped before reaching the base of the pile ( frustrated avalanche ) . by avalanche size
we take the number of nodes , of the corresponding bethe lattice , in the last step . after an avalanche the sandpile _
autoorganizes itself _ with the new number of grains ( i.e. , a new slope is calculated with the remaining grains ) .
the occurrence of avalanches will carry as consequence a decrease in the number of grains in the pile and , therefore , a decrease of @xmath10 . each time an avalanche occurs
, the occurrence of a new avalanche is less probable .
thus , to characterize this feedback mechanism a relation between @xmath11 and the number of grains in the pile @xmath12 is needed .
the drag probability @xmath8 is a function of the slope
. its value is determined by the competition of two contrary forces : the gravity , which conspires against the stability of the slope , and the friction which favors the slope stability .
since the slope forms an angle @xmath9 with the horizontal plane the component of the gravity force in the slope direction will be larger with the increase of this angle , varying from zero to a maximum value when @xmath9 goes from zero to @xmath13 .
therefore it is plausible to assume that the contribution of the gravity and , therefore , the tendency of falling down the slope is proportional to @xmath14 . on the contrary , the resistance to this tendency given by the static friction decreases with decreasing the pile angle , varying from a maximum value to zero when @xmath9 goes from zero to @xmath13 .
hence , it is also plausible to assume that the resistance to the falling down is proportional to @xmath15 .
thus the slope dependence of @xmath16 can be expressed through the ratio of both tendencies @xmath17 .
based on this hypothesis we may propose the exponential relation @xmath18 where @xmath19 is a parameter determined by the gravitational field , the friction , and vibration intensity .
notice that @xmath20 and @xmath21 .
this selection for @xmath8 can not be regarded as a sophisticated trick or something imposed _
ad hoc _ to the model in order to obtain the desired results , since it can be verified that _ any _ function satisfying the very general conditions already stated is adequate to our model .
incidentally , it must be said that this reveals the robustness of the model .
on the other hand , the number of grains in a pile with slope angle @xmath9 is given by @xmath22 where @xmath23 is a geometrical factor and @xmath24 is the ration between a characteristic size of the pile base @xmath25 and sand grain @xmath26 . combining equations ( [ eq:1 ] ) and ( [ eq:2 ] )
it is obtained @xmath27 where @xmath28 .
thus equation [ eq:1 ] relates the dragging probability with the number of grains in the pile .
the parameter @xmath29 should not depend on the size of the system .
it must be a function of parameters describing the vibrations , amplitude @xmath30 and frequency @xmath31 , and of the gravitational field acceleration @xmath32 . the only nondimensional combination of these magnitudes is given by the ratio between the vibration acceleration @xmath33 and @xmath32 and , therefore , @xmath34 .
this conclusion , obtained from dimensional analysis , is corroborated by experiments on sandpiles under vibrations @xcite which show that the ratio @xmath35 is the relevant parameter .
for a given value of @xmath29 and @xmath36 , there is a critical number of grains in the pile @xmath37 .
this value can be found recalling that in the bethe lattice the critical value of @xmath16 for percolation exists is @xmath38 , resulting @xmath39 in a static sandpile ( i.e. , no vibrations ) this value corresponds with the number of grains in the pile at the angle of repose @xcite .
another magnitude of interest is the penetration length , the number of steps @xmath40 in the bethe lattice for an avalanche to take place .
this magnitude must be proportional to the length of the pile slope and , therefore , should be given by the expression @xmath41 notice that the possible existence of a geometrical factor in equation [ eq:4a ] may be absorbed in @xmath36 , redefining @xmath23 in equation [ eq:2 ] .
moreover , the relation between @xmath42 and @xmath12 may be easily obtained using equation [ eq:2 ] .
equations [ eq:3 ] and [ eq:4a ] relate the parameters of the pile with those of its bethe lattice representation .
they were obtained here in a different way than that proposed by zaperi _
et al _ @xcite .
other dependencies between the dragging probability and the number of grains in the sandpile may be proposed .
notwithstanding , as it is discussed below , the precise form of this functional dependence is not relevant .
the numerical experiment of relaxation is performed as follows .
we start with a certain number of @xmath12 . in a first step , we test if an avalanche takes place using the bethe lattice representation .
if it does , then we simulate the process and then recalculate the value of @xmath43 by simply substracting the size of the avalanche to @xmath12 and using equation [ eq:3 ] .
the size of the avalanche is the number of nodes generated in the bethe lattice which surpass the size of the pile whose measure is given by ( [ eq:4a ] ) .
then this step is repeated again and again , whereas avalanche sizes and times are registered . if avalanches are considered as instantaneous the number of steps is a measure of time .
this approximation is valid for low vibration intensities . in this
case grain jumps which trigger avalanches are rare events and , therefore , the time between two successive grain jumps will be much larger than the duration of avalanches .
to describe the behavior of our system , we define the relaxation function @xmath44 of the sandpile as : @xmath45 where we include the time dependence of the number of grains in the sandpile .
@xmath6 is the waiting time ,
i.e. , the instant at which we begin the counting of the number of grains since the start of the relaxation .
( avalanche ) , as in @xcite .
the existence of aging in our model is illustrated in figure 1 .
we have plotted the normalized relaxation @xmath46 at different ages ( steps ) of the system ( simulation ) by taking as initial time @xmath47 for @xmath48 and @xmath49 . as it can be seen
the relaxation becomes slower with increasing the age of the system , in agreement with experiments in structural and spin glasses @xcite ( and , unfortunately , with human life ) .
the system exhibits a delay in the relaxation , after which the relaxation function decreases as a power law ( long time tail ) with an exponent @xmath50 thus , since the angle relaxation becomes slower with the age of the pile then it will never reach an equilibrium angle and , therefore , properties like translational invariance and the fluctuation dissipation theorem do not hold @xcite .
associated with these slow relaxation dynamics and aging phenomena we expect to observe a wide distribution of time between avalanches . as time increases the time between two consecutive avalanches @xmath51 becomes larger , because after an avalanche the occurrence of a new avalanche becomes smaller .
therefore , it is expected that the mean time between avalanches diverges as @xmath52 .
hence , the distribution of time between avalanches @xmath53 should satisfy the asymptotic behavior for large @xmath54 @xmath55 with @xmath56 .
this hypothesis is confirmed in our simulations .
figure 2 shows the distribution of time between avalanches for @xmath57 and @xmath49 .
it is approximately constant for small values and then it decays following a power law in more than two decades .
the plateau at small values of @xmath51 is associated to the rapid decay observed at short times while the tail for large @xmath51 should be related to the long time tail . here
we observe that @xmath58 thus , there should be some connection between the distribution of time between avalanches and the long time relaxation .
finally we want to mention that these simulations were also carried out assuming other functional dependences between the dragging probability and the number of grains in the pile @xmath43 . in all cases the results where qualitatively similar to those presented here using equation [ eq:3 ] , reflecting
that the precise dependence is not relevant .
a sandpile model for aging was presented revealing that this phenomenon is manifested in relaxation of sandpile avalanches . biological systems and
individuals show similar behavior .
phenomena related to some kind of relaxation in live beings deserve more quantitative research .
the introduction of a bethe lattice representation for the avalanches and a feedback mechanism describes quite well the principal features of the relaxation in sandpiles under low intensity vibrations .
the proposed representation leads to long time tails relaxation , aging and lvy ( fractal ) distributions of time constants , which are characteristic properties of the dynamics of complex systems out of equilibrium .
this work was partially supported by the _ alma mater _
prize , given by the university of havana , and the direccin general de investigacin cientfica y tcnica dgicyt , spain , ministerio de educacin y cultura . | aging in complex systems is studied @xmath0 the sandpile model .
relaxation of avalanches in sandpiles is observed to depend on the time elapsed since the beginning of the relaxation .
lvy behavior is observed in the distribution of characteristic times . in this way ,
aging and self - organized criticality appear to be closely related . |
fmi acknowledges the support by conacyt ( mexico ) grant no . 34668-e .
w. wang , f.m . izrailev and g. casati ,
phys . rev . *
e 57 * , 323 ( 1998 ) ; f. borgonovi , i. guarneri and f.m .
izrailev , phys . rev . * e 57 * , 5291 ( 1998 ) ; l. meza - montes , f.m .
izrailev , and s.e .
ulloa , phys .
. sol . * 220 * , 721 ( 2000 ) ; g.a.luna-acosta , j.a.mndes-bermdez , and f.m.izrailev , phys .
a. , * 274 * , 192 ( 2000 ) ; l. benet , f.m .
izrailev , t.h .
seligman and a. suarez moreno , phys .
a. * 277 * , 87 ( 2000 ) . | a novel approach is suggested for the statistical description of quantum systems of interacting particles .
the key point of this approach is that a typical eigenstate in the energy representation ( shape of eigenstates , se ) has a well defined classical analog which can be easily obtained from the classical equations of motion .
therefore , the occupation numbers for single - particle states can be represented as a convolution of the classical se with the quantum occupation number operator for non - interacting particles .
the latter takes into account the wavefunctions symmetry and depends on the unperturbed energy spectrum only . as a result ,
the distribution of occupation numbers @xmath0 can be numerically found for a very large number of interacting particles . using the model of interacting spins
we demonstrate that this approach gives a correct description of @xmath0 even in a deep quantum region with few single - particle orbitals .
2 in many physical systems such as complex atoms , heavy nuclei and interacting spins , highly excited eigenstates in the unpertured many - particles basis can be treated as a chaotic superposition of a very large number of components , for a relatively strong interaction among particles ( see , e.g. @xcite ) .
this fact has been used in @xcite in order to develop a statistical description of closed systems with a finite number of fermi - particles . in particular
, it was analytically shown that for a strong enough interaction , a smooth dependence of occupation numbers on the energy occurs , which is related to global properties of chaotic eigenstates . as is known , the direct numerical computation of excited eigenstates is strongly restricted due to a very large number of many - particles states , which grows extremely fast with the number of particles . however , the mean values of occupation numbers turn out to depend on the average shape of chaotic eigenstates in the unperturbed basis , not on exact , specific values of their components @xcite . in this letter
we develop a novel approach to quantum systems with chaotic behaviour in the classical limit .
this approach takes into account both the chaotic properties of the classical system , and the specific features of the unperturbed single - particle spectrum . as a result
, one can avoid diagonalization of hamiltonian matrices of a huge size which may be practically unfeasible .
this kind of approach can be applied to generic hamiltonian systems with two - body interaction of the type : @xmath1 here @xmath2 describes @xmath3 _ non - interacting _ particles with @xmath4 as single - particle hamiltonians , and @xmath5 stands for a long - range two - body interaction between the particles . in what follows , we assume that the single - particle spectrum is determined by a finite number @xmath6 of single - particles energies @xmath7 , @xmath8 ; however , the approach is valid for more generic systems with an infinite spectrum .
the unperturbed hamiltonian @xmath2 determines the many - particle states @xmath9 ( with @xmath10 , @xmath11 as creation - annihilation operators ) , that form the basis in which the exact eigenstates of @xmath12 are represented . as usual , we assume that the basis is ordered according to increasing unperturbed energy values @xmath13 .
the distribution of occupation numbers ( don ) for single - particle states is defined by the relation , @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the occupation number operator giving the occupation numbers @xmath16 equal to @xmath17 or @xmath18 for fermi - particles , and to @xmath19 for bose - particles .
these numbers @xmath20 indicate how many particles in a many - particle _ basis _ state @xmath21 , occupy a particular single - particle state @xmath22 . correspondingly
, the occupation numbers @xmath23 give the probability that one of @xmath3 particles in a many - particle _ exact _ state with the _ total _ energy @xmath24 , occupies a particular single - particle state @xmath22 .
the total number @xmath25 of many - body states equals @xmath26 for fermi and @xmath27 for bose - particles .
one should note that while in the above expression for the don , the eigenfunctions @xmath28 depend on the total hamiltonian @xmath12 , the term @xmath20 depends on the unperturbed spectrum only .
this fact is crucial for our semiquantal approach . due to the chaotic structure of exact eigenstates
, one can make an average of the don over a small energy window @xmath29 around the fixed value @xmath24 .
this averaging procedure is similar to that used in the conventional statistical mechanics developed for systems with a finite number of particles in contact with a heat bath , or for isolated systems of an _ infinite _ number of _ non - interacting _ particles .
expression ( [ nqu ] ) for the mean values @xmath23 can be considerably simplified by introducing the so - called _ shape of eigenfunctions _ , se ,
( envelope of eigenstates in energy representation ) .
the form of the se has been studied in details both in the model with random two - body interaction @xcite , and in dynamical models of interacting particles @xcite .
the introduction of the average quantity se ( thus neglecting correlations between different components @xmath28 ) represents the key point of our approach .
we assume that the unperturbed many - body energy spectrum has an intrinsic degeneracy .
this situation is typical for spin systems , and is more complicated in comparison with those studied before @xcite .
below we show how this difficulty can be overcome .
let us redefine the state @xmath30 by means of a indexes pair @xmath31 , where @xmath32 labels the `` unperturbed energy '' @xmath33 of the many - body state , while @xmath34 labels its degeneracy @xmath35 .
if there are @xmath36 different `` unperturbed '' energies , one can write , @xmath37 , therefore , one has , @xmath38 according to standard definition@xcite , the se is given by : @xmath39 by substituting @xmath40 with @xmath41 as an average over @xmath42 , we obtain an approximate expression for the don in terms of the se , @xmath43 needless to say , if an unperturbed spectrum has no degeneracy , eq.([crus ] ) can be written in a similar way by taking an average over a small window of energy around @xmath33 .
as one can see , expression ( [ crus ] ) depends on two terms of different nature .
the first one , @xmath44 , refers to the unperturbed many - particle spectrum and reflects the specific properties of a single - particle spectrum , as well as quantum features related to fermi - dirac or bose - einstein statistics .
in contrast , the second term , @xmath45 , refers to global properties of eigenstates and describes _ interaction _ effects .
therefore , the basic idea of our semiquantal " approach is to substitute the latter term ( se ) by its classical analog which can be easily found from classical equations of motion .
classical analogs of the se have been studied in different models , see , for example , @xcite ) . in practice
, one has to derive the distribution @xmath46 for the probability to find the unperturbed energy @xmath47 for @xmath2 , given the conserved total energy @xmath24 .
this can be obtained by generating many different initial classical configurations on the energy surface @xmath48 or sampling the @xmath49 values generated by one single trajectory onto the energy surface and computing the correspondent distribution of @xmath50 @xcite .
the two procedures have been found to give the same results in the chaotic region@xcite . in order to facilitate the comparison with the quantum se , in our numerical simulations the bin size of @xmath47
equals the energy distance between neighbour values of @xmath33 . in the same way
one can define the classical distribution of occupation numbers , @xmath51 ( see also @xcite ) . for the quantum - classical comparison ,
the bin size of @xmath52 is taken to be equal to the spacing between close single - particle energy levels @xmath7 .
let us stress that in this semiquantal approach ( sa ) it is possible to study specific systems of , let us say , @xmath53 interacting particles occupying @xmath54 single - particle levels .
surely , one expect this approach to be valid for highly excited chaotic states in a deep semiclassical region .
however , by direct numerical simulations we have found that the sa gives correct results even for energy values close to the ground state .
the model that we have studied , consists of @xmath3 3-d interacting spins placed in a magnetic field @xmath55 directed along the @xmath56-axis . in order to have a proper many - body operator one should require a coupling between _ all spins _ ( not only between neighbors ) .
the hamiltonian thus reads , @xmath57 using the well known relations @xmath58 , one can write , @xmath59 + & \\
+ \frac{1}{4}(j_x - j_y ) \sum\limits_{i=1}^{n-1 } \sum\limits_{j = i+1}^{n } [ s_i^+ s_j^+ + s_i^- s_j^- ] + & \\ \frac{1}{4 } ( j_x+j_y ) \sum\limits_{i=1}^{n-1 } \sum\limits_{j = i+1}^{n } [ s_i^+ s_j^- + s_i^- s_j^+ ] \label{h00 } \end{array}\ ] ] in the mean field approximation , we put @xmath60 .
the interaction can be further simplified by the particular choice @xmath61 .
thus , our hamiltonian @xmath62 has the following form , @xmath63 .
\label{h0}\ ] ] for simplicity , the @xmath3 classical constants of motion @xmath64 have been set to 1 , therefore , the only free classical parameters are the total conserved energy @xmath24 and the interaction @xmath65 .
the classical model has been studied in @xcite and it was numerically found to be chaotic and exponentially unstable in a wide energy range .
more precisely , in order to have strong chaos , one needs the interaction @xmath65 between particles to be strong enough .
a convenient choice is to take the interaction strength @xmath66 .
one should stress that this situation is the most difficult for theoretical studies , see discussion in @xcite .
quantization follows the standard rules , which gives , @xmath67 and @xmath68 with @xmath69 .
the action of creation and annihilation operators is defined by : @xmath70 where @xmath71 are the non - symmetrized states ( first quantization states ) .
there are @xmath72 single - particle energy levels @xmath73 with @xmath74 .
therefore , the unperturbed many - particle energy spectrum consists of a number of degenerate levels with the spacing equal to @xmath75 .
note , that both the ground state @xmath76 and the upper level @xmath77 are non - degenerate .
the classical limit is recovered when spins are allowed to have any possible orientation , that is @xmath78 , and @xmath79 .
the choice we have done ( @xmath61 ) allows to reduce the dimension of the hilbert space by , approximately , one half .
this happens because the operator @xmath5 in ( [ h0 ] ) connects only those unperturbed many - body states that are separated by the spacing @xmath80 . in what follows
, we consider the subset of the many - body states containing the ground state . from these states
we construct the completely symmetrized states @xmath81 ) , in the second quantization , can be written as : @xmath82 with @xmath83 here @xmath84 , with @xmath85 and @xmath86 the creation - annihilation operators satisfying the standard relation @xmath87= \delta_{hk}$ ] .
as to the coefficients @xmath88 , @xmath89 , they have quite complicated expressions ; however , they can be easily computed numerically .
the procedure we have used in our numerical simulations consists of the following steps : a ) compute the classical values @xmath90 , and @xmath91 as described above ; b ) compute the quantum values @xmath90 and @xmath91 by diagonalization of the total hamiltonian ( [ cal0 ] ) ; c ) compute @xmath90 and @xmath91 by using the semiquantal approximation according to expression ( [ crus ] ) .
the results for the don are summarized in fig.[n4 ] . for the convenience of comparison , symbols refer to the quantum and sa results , while the classical data are presented as hystograms , .
note , that each particle can have energy within the interval @xmath92 $ ] . in order to make the quantum - classical comparison as close as possible
, we took the classical bin size equal to @xmath75 .
all distributions have been normalized in such a way that @xmath93 . in cases (
a ) and ( b ) we choose the same energy , close to the ground state and two different @xmath94 values . in ( c ) and
( d ) instead , we choose a higher energy value .
the latter case ( ( c ) and ( d ) ) should describe a situation more classical than the former ( higher energy should correspond to higher temperature ) .
one can see that , while classical and quantum data only disagree in the _ deep _ quantum region ( a ) ( energy close to the ground state and small @xmath94 ( _ big _
@xmath75 ) ) , there is a very nice correspondence between quantum and sa data in all cases ( including region ( a ) ) .
this nice correspondence is far from trivial since sa does not take into account quantum correlations inside exact eigenstates , together with possible correlations between the two terms , @xmath95 and @xmath96 in expression ( [ nquan ] ) , both expected to be strong in the deep quantum region .
it is very interesting to explore the occurence of the bose - einstein ( be ) distribution in our model .
a similar problem has been studied in detail for the model of two - body random interaction @xcite where the conditions for the appearence of fermi - dirac distribution have been found for few interacting fermi - particles . by assuming , a priori , the validity of the be - distribution @xmath97^{-1}$ ] in our closed system
, one can find the temperature " @xmath98 and the chemical potential " @xmath99 via the standard relations , @xmath100 here @xmath101 is the numerically computed energy obtained from the single - particle quantum distribution ( see details in @xcite ) , and @xmath3 is the number of particles . notice that , due to interaction , @xmath102 .
the comparison between be and sa distributions are shown in fig.2 .
as one can see , even for relatively small @xmath103 , the distribution @xmath90 can be closely approximated by be - distribution .
this confirms the expectation that a strong enough interaction between particles can play the role of an internal heat bath @xcite .
therefore , the standard quantum distributions can be used , with a corresponding renormalization of the energy @xmath101 ( see details in @xcite ) .
thus in our model there is no need to increase further the number of particles , since even for @xmath103 a remarkable agreement with be distribution has been found .
we would like to stress that an exact quantum treatment of the last example calls for a diagonalization of a huge matrix of size @xmath104 , while , with the semiquantal approach , all computations required few minutes on a standard portable pc . in conclusion , we suggest an effective semiquantal approach to closed systems of interacting particles , based on the chaotic structure of eigenstates . in this approach
, the computation of the distribution of occupation numbers can be easily performed by making use of the classical analog of the shape of eigenstates in the unperturbed many - particle basis .
we demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach using the model of 3-d spins with anisotropic ising interaction .
the data show that semiquantal computations give results which are very close to the exact ones . |
a new theoretical concept which , once formulated , naturally emerges in many related contexts , deserves further study .
even more so , if it makes us view well - established theories in a novel way , and meaningfully points beyond standard theory .
area metrics , we argue in this paper , are such an emerging notion in fundamental physics .
an area metric may be defined as a fourth rank tensor field which allows to assign a measure to two - dimensional tangent areas , in close analogy to the way a metric assigns a measure to tangent vectors . in more than three dimensions ,
area metric geometry is a true generalization of metric geometry ; although every metric induces an area metric , not every area metric comes from an underlying metric .
the mathematical constructions , and physical conclusions , of the present paper are then based on a single principle : _ spacetime is an area metric manifold .
_ we will be concerned with justifying this rather bold idea by a detailed construction of the geometry of area metric manifolds , followed by providing an appropriate theory of gravity , which finally culminates in an application of our ideas to cosmology . in the highly symmetric cosmological area metric spacetimes , we can compare our results easily to those of einstein gravity .
we obtain the interesting result that the simplest type of area metric cosmology , namely a universe filled with non - interacting string matter , may be solved exactly and is able to explain the observed @xcite very small late - time acceleration of our universe , see the figure on page , without introducing any notion of dark energy , nor by invoking fine - tuning arguments .
it may come as a surprise , but standard physical theory itself predicts the departure from metric to true area metric manifolds .
more precisely , the quantization of classical theories based on metric geometry generates , in a number of interesting cases , area metric geometries : back - reacting photons in quantum electrodynamics effectively propagate in an area metric background @xcite ; the massless states of quantum string theory give rise to the neveu - schwarz two - form potential and dilaton besides the graviton , producing a generalized geometry which may be neatly absorbed into an area metric @xcite ; the low energy action for d - branes @xcite is a true area metric volume integral @xcite ; canonical quantization of gravity la ashtekar @xcite naturally leads to an area operator @xcite , such that the classical limit of the underlying spin network structure is also likely a generic area metric manifold , rather than a metric one .
the emerging picture is that area metric manifolds are generalized geometries . in the case of string theory
, one may even reverse the argument by observing that the geometry of an area metric background forces one to consider strings rather than point particles @xcite . in the present paper
this plays a role in our discussion of fluids in area cosmology ; fluids on area metric spacetime can not consist of particles , but must feature strings as the minimal mechanical objects , which leads us to develop the notion of a string fluid .
generalized geometries begin to play an increasingly important role also in mainstream string theory , despite the fact that one initial starting point for its formulation is a metric target space manifold .
non - geometric backgrounds in string theory , meaning backgrounds that do not admit a metric geometry , for instance emerge in flux compactifications on which one acts with t - dualities or in mirror symmetry @xcite .
they also appear in compactifications with duality twists , which in some cases have been shown to be equivalent to asymmetric orbifolds @xcite .
generalized geometries built to understand these situations have been originally proposed by hitchin @xcite and , the t - fold idea , by hull @xcite .
these have found a number of applications @xcite , one recent example discusses the stabilization of all moduli through fluxes in a specific non - geometric background @xcite .
maybe the most striking example of a classical theory , where area metrics play a natural role , is gauge theory in general , and maxwell electrodynamics in particular .
given that electrodynamics is the historical birth place of the concept of a spacetime metric , this is certainly noteworthy .
it is known that electrodynamics may be formulated on any @xmath0-dimensional smooth manifold without even introducing the concept of a metric @xcite .
the idea of this so - called pre - metric approach goes back to a paper by peres @xcite , and is based on the observation that charges , and in certain situations , magnetic flux lines can be counted , which is nicely explained in @xcite .
hence one may define the notions of a field strength two - form @xmath1 and an electromagnetic induction @xmath2-form @xmath3 .
the equations of vacuum electrodynamics are then given by @xmath4 and @xmath5 .
the induction two - tensor @xmath6 dual to @xmath3 must be related to the field strength @xmath1 by some constitutive relation in order to close the system of equations . while peres originally took this to be a definition of the metric , hehl et al .
@xcite generalized this to an arbitrary linear relation @xmath7 described by a tensor @xmath8 of fourth rank , and investigated which conditions imply light propagation along a lorentzian lightcone .
such general relations between the field strength and the induction are known from the description of electrodynamics in continuous media ; the lensing of light rays in some materials can not be described by geodesics in a metric background .
it is therefore not too daring to suspect that gravitational lensing may be equally rich , which amounts to the assumption that spacetime is an area metric manifold our central assumption in this paper . of course
, neither the most extensive list of known phenomena , nor the most suggestive hints for generalizations alone will be able to justify our proposal to consider spacetime an area metric manifold .
however , the area metric gravity theory developed in this paper seems a particularly worthwile testbed for our hypothesis ; this is not least due to the fact that we do not introduce any new parameter into the theory . in this sense , it is not a deformation of einstein - hilbert gravity ( as every alternative action based on metric geometry necessarily is ) , but rather an extension in which the metric ricci scalar is replaced by its area metric analogue .
the prediction of an accelerated expansion of our universe at late times , without any additional assumptions or scales being put in by hand , should count as a promising indication in favour of the idea of area metric spacetime .
this paper is divided into two largely self - contained parts .
part one ( sections 17 ) develops the foundations of area metric geometry in detail .
its practical results , however , are concisely summarized in the first section of part two ( sections 8 - 14 ) where the area metric version of einstein - hilbert gravity is formulated in general , and then applied to area metric cosmology .
a more detailed outline of the individual sections of the paper is given at the beginning of each of the two parts .
we conclude the paper with a discussion of our results and point out future directions .
appendix [ conventions ] lists our conventions , while appendices [ appvary ] and [ qsimplification ] respectively derive the general equations of motion of four - dimensional area metric gravity , and those simplified for the almost metric case .
this first purely mathematical part of the paper may be skipped at first reading .
its practically relevant results are concisely summarized at the beginning of part two , so that the reader mainly interested in the application of area metric geometry to gravity and cosmology may fast - forward to the second part , and come back later to the in - depth treatment of area metric geometry presented here .
the precise definition of area metrics , densities and volume forms is given in section [ manifolds ] , before the non - linear structure of the space of oriented areas is briefly discussed in section [ sec_areabundles ] .
the ensuing construction of area metric geometry is canonical in the sense that it does not rely on additional structure beyond area metric data @xcite . a central issue , namely the extraction of some effective metric from an area metric , is resolved in three steps : identification of the fresnel tensor associated with an area metric in section [ gauge ] , construction of a family of pre - metrics from the fresnel tensor in section [ normal ] , and finally selection of a unique , non - degenerate member of that family in section [ sec_effmetric ] . the aside on area metric symmetries in section
[ sec_killing ] prepares our discussion of cosmology later on . from a practical point of view
, the most important result of this first part of the paper is the construction of area metric curvature tensors which are downward compatible to their metric counterparts , in section [ curvature ] .
knowing how to measure lengths and angles , one knows how to measure areas .
more precisely , if @xmath9 is a metric manifold , one may define the tensor @xmath10 that measures the squared area of a parallelogram spanned by vectors @xmath11 as @xmath12 .
we will call @xmath13 the area metric induced from the metric @xmath14 . the basic idea of area metric geometry
consists in promoting area metrics to a structure in their own right , independent of whether there is some underlying metric or not . to achieve this generalization , we simply introduce the area metric by keeping some of the salient algebraic properties of the metric - induced area metrics ( [ cg ] ) .
formally , we define an area metric manifold @xmath15 as a smooth @xmath0-dimensional manifold @xmath16 equipped with a fourth - rank covariant tensor field @xmath17 that satisfies the following symmetry and invertibility properties at each point of the manifold : 1 .
@xmath18 for all vector fields @xmath19 in @xmath20 , 2 .
@xmath21 for all vector fields @xmath19 in @xmath20 , 3 .
@xmath22 , defined as @xmath23 by continuation , is invertible .
here @xmath24 denotes the space of all contravariant antisymmetric tensors of rank two ; for our conventions concerning components of @xmath25 tensors see appendix [ conventions ] .
we will see at the end of section [ gauge ] that in three dimensions every area metric is metric - induced ; from four dimensions onwards , however , there exist area metrics that can not be induced from any metric .
in addition to the symmetries _ ( i ) _ and _ ( ii ) _ which we included in our definition , a metric - induced area metric ( [ cg ] ) features a third symmetry , namely cyclicity : @xmath26 we emphasize that we do not impose cyclicity as a property of generic area metrics .
in fact , we will see shortly that non - cyclicity plays a central role in two related problems : in the extraction of metric information from an area metric and in the construction of area metric compatible connections .
the price to pay for non - cylicity is that the area metric tensor @xmath17 is algebraically reducible .
more precisely , any area metric decomposes uniquely into a cyclic area metric and a four - form , which are both irreducible .
it will turn out to be advantageous for technical reasons to consider such a decomposition for the inverse area metric , @xmath27}\,.\ ] ] in this context note that the cyclic components @xmath28 and the four - form components @xmath1 of the inverse area metric generically mix under inversion ; in other words , the cyclic part of the inverse area metric is not simply the inverse of the cyclic part of the area metric . an area metric @xmath17 naturally gives rise to the scalar density @xmath29 of weight @xmath30 , where the capitalized determinant @xmath31 is understood to be taken over the square matrix of dimension @xmath32 representing the map @xmath33 .
the correct transformation behaviour under diffeomorphisms is easily seen by direct calculation , noting that for any square matrix @xmath34 of dimension @xmath0 we have @xmath35}{}_{b_2 } = ( \det t^a{}_b)^{d-1}\,,\ ] ] where the determinant @xmath36 denotes the standard determinant .
hence any area metric manifold is naturally equipped with a volume form @xmath37 , whose components in some basis are given by @xmath38 where @xmath39 is the levi - civita tensor density normalized such that @xmath40 .
now that we have given a precise definition of area metric manifolds , we should mention some relations to the mathematical literature .
the idea to base geometry on some measure of area goes back to work by cartan @xcite , and has been generalized under the name of ` areal spaces ' , see @xcite and references therein , to geometries based on reparametrization - invariant integrals , i.e. , to any given volume measure .
although these geometries are more general than our physically motivated area measure , this does not mean that we will simply reproduce , or specialize , known mathematics in this paper . in fact , it is precisely our tensorial approach that allows us , in a novel way , to construct an effective metric and connections on the embedding bundle of areas .
moreover the physical motivation behind our construction leads to a successful application to gravity theory .
at first sight , it seems that an area metric assigns a measure to parallelograms .
but actually , an area metric @xmath17 assigns equal area measure to any two co - planar parallelograms @xmath11 and @xmath41 in @xmath42 that are related by an @xmath43 basis transformation . to see this ,
let @xmath44 and @xmath45 with @xmath46 ; then @xmath47 the equivalence class of all parallelograms that are @xmath48-related to some representative parallelogram @xmath11 is algebraically neatly realized as the wedge product @xmath49 , since @xmath50 the quotient space of all parallelograms by this @xmath48 identification will be denoted by @xmath51 , and its elements are the oriented areas over @xmath52 .
similarly , we denote the bundle of oriented areas over @xmath16 by @xmath53 .
whereas parallelograms constitute a vector space @xmath54 , the oriented areas @xmath51 at some point @xmath55 can not carry a vector space structure . to see this
note the following : while @xmath49 clearly is an element of the vector space @xmath24 , a generic vector @xmath56 decomposes into a finite sum of such wedge - products , rather than being a single wedge - product .
a useful necessary and sufficient criterion for @xmath57 to be a simple wedge product , and hence an oriented area , is @xmath58 in which case @xmath57 is called simple .
thus the space of oriented areas @xmath51 is a subset of the vector space @xmath24 defined by the vanishing of the four - tensor @xmath59 .
since this condition is quadratic in @xmath57 , the set @xmath51 is recognized as an affine variety in @xmath24 .
hence the bundle @xmath53 fails to be a vector bundle .
while this does not prevent the construction of a connection , from some connection on the underlying principal bundle , it is not possible to define a covariant derivative on @xmath53 .
but it is possible to define a covariant derivative on the vector bundle @xmath25 , into which @xmath53 is embedded , and we will do so in section [ curvature ] . when discussing strings and string fluids in section [ sec_sfluids ] , we will also need to address integrability issues , i.e. , under which circumstances a distribution of oriented areas is tangent to some underlying two - surface .
the physical postulate put forward in this paper is that physical spacetime is an area metric manifold @xmath15 , rather than a metric manifold .
this immediately prompts the question of whether a generic area metric may give rise to some effective metric on the manifold @xmath16 .
the latter will play a significant role in the construction of an area metric curvature scalar which is downward compatible to the metric ricci scalar , in section [ curvature ] . with the aim of constructing an effective metric in mind
, it turns out to be extraordinarily instructive to probe the geometric structure of an area metric manifold by abelian gauge theory . in particular
this allows us to study wave propagation , which in the geometric - optical limit gives insight into the geometry of rays . in the metric - induced case ,
the ray surfaces reduce to the familiar null cones . in our more general
setting , the fresnel tensor describes the geometry of rays , and its derivation presents the first step towards the extraction of metric information from the underlying area metric manifold , which will be completed in sections [ normal ] and [ sec_effmetric ] .
consider the following action for a one - form potential @xmath60 with field strength @xmath61 on an area metric manifold of dimension @xmath62 : @xmath63 the equations of motion , derived by variation with respect to @xmath60 , are simply given by the bianchi identity @xmath4 and by @xmath5 in terms of the dual electromagnetic induction @xmath3 , which is a @xmath2-form on @xmath16 with components @xmath64 to obtain geometric information from these equations , we study the geometric - optical limit . in this limit
one considers waves as propagating discontinuities in the derivatives of the fields @xmath1 and of the electromagnetic induction @xmath2-form @xmath3 along a wavefront surface described by the level lines of some scalar function @xmath65 on @xmath16 .
the rays of the wavefront are then given by the gradient @xmath66 .
extending an insightful argument of hehl , obukhov and rubilar @xcite , where a detailed derivation may be found , to arbitrary dimension @xmath0 , we find that the wavefront gradients must obey the fresnel equation @xmath67 where @xmath68 is the totally symmetric tensor density of weight @xmath69 given by @xmath70 with @xmath28 being the cyclic part of the inverse area metric @xmath71 as in ( [ c+f ] ) . as explained in appendix [ conventions ] we use the convention that the summation over numbered _
anti_-symmetric indices is ordered , i.e. , @xmath72 and similarly for the @xmath73 .
it is a remarkable fact that , in the geometric - optical limit , the propagation of wave fronts is determined entirely in terms of the cyclic part of the inverse area metric , due to ( [ dense ] )
. it will be convenient to cast the information encoded in the density @xmath68 into the form of a tensor @xmath74 . in order to not introduce non - cyclic information into this tensor
, we are led to de - densitize @xmath68 according to @xmath75 note that the determinant factor presents the required scalar density of weight @xmath76 because @xmath28 is a contravariant tensor .
the tensor @xmath74 describing the ray surfaces will be called the fresnel tensor induced from the area metric @xmath17 . in order to illustrate the geometric role of the fresnel tensor @xmath74 in a familiar setting , consider the action ( [ edaction ] ) on a lorentzian manifold @xmath9 , on which , for the time being , the area measure is simply induced from the metric @xmath14 by virtue of ( [ cg ] ) .
a more subtle discussion of metric - induced measures will follow in section [ sec_effmetric ] . in this case
the action reduces to the standard form @xmath77 .
moreover , a direct calculation shows that the fresnel tensor simplifies to @xmath78 so that the fresnel equation ( [ fresnel ] ) takes the factorized form @xmath79 this result is of course equivalent to the standard null condition for light rays propagating on a metric manifold .
the insight to be drawn from this comparison is the fact that , a priori , it is not a metric that describes the propagation of rays ( not even in the metric case ) , but rather the fresnel tensor @xmath74 ( which however happens to factorize neatly to the form ( [ factoredfresnel ] ) in the case of a metric background ) .
hence , it is useful to make a conceptual difference between the background structure ( metric or area metric ) employed to define one - form dynamics on the one hand , and the structure that describes that theory in the geometric - optical limit ( the fresnel tensor ) on the other hand , although we are used to think of these structures as synonymous in the metric case .
there is an important corollary from the above findings , of which we will make essential use in section [ sec_killing ] . for an area metric in three dimensions ,
the ( totally symmetric ) fresnel tensor @xmath80 is of second rank , and with some amount of algebra , one checks that @xmath80 is invertible .
furthermore , @xmath81 induces the area metric we started with , by expression ( [ cg ] ) .
hence , in three dimensions , every area metric is induced from some metric .
this is no longer the case in more than three dimensions .
as a second step towards the extraction of an effective metric from the area metric , we identify in this section a family @xmath82 of pre - metrics on @xmath16 which are induced by an area metric via the fresnel tensor .
if the area metric data distinguish a non - degenerate member of that family ( in a way we will explain below ) , the area metric manifold will be called normal . in other words ,
normal area metrics allow for the extraction of a metric .
probing an area metric manifold of arbitrary dimension by abelian gauge theory , we found that wave propagation in the geometric - optical limit is described by the fresnel tensor ( [ fresnel ] ) , not by a metric .
we may use the totally symmetric fresnel tensor to define a symmetric bilinear form on a subbundle of the cotangent bundle @xmath83 ( with bundle projection @xmath84 ) by the following construction , which in similar form finds application in finslerian geometry @xcite .
we choose local coordinates @xmath85 on @xmath86 which induce local coordinates @xmath87 on @xmath88 , by virtue of @xmath89 .
then we define the characteristic function @xmath90 on that portion @xmath91 of the cotangent bundle where @xmath92 takes real values .
thus @xmath93 is a level set of the function on the total bundle space defined by the imaginary part of @xmath92 , and hence defines a subbundle of @xmath83 , with @xmath94 . for any @xmath95 ,
the function @xmath96 is homogeneous of degree two in @xmath97 , i.e. , @xmath98 . from the characteristic function
we may now define a symmetric tensor field @xmath99 by differentiating @xmath92 twice with respect to the fibre coordinate @xmath100 this is indeed a tensor under diffeomorphisms of @xmath16 since they do not depend on the fibre coordinates @xmath97 .
it is quickly verified that @xmath101 so that the bilinear form @xmath92 only depends on the direction of @xmath97 in the fibre , not on its ` length ' .
this scaling behaviour of @xmath99 is consistent with the scaling of the characteristic function @xmath92 .
a simple and fruitful way of looking at this construction is to think of an area metric as giving rise to a family @xmath82 of symmetric contravariant tensors on @xmath16 with components @xmath102 parametrized by sections @xmath103 .
viewing the characteristic function @xmath92 as a generalized norm squared on cotangent vectors @xmath97 , the symmetric covariant tensors @xmath82 present linearizations of this norm around the chosen section @xmath104 .
we emphasize again the fact that only the cyclic part @xmath28 of the inverse area metric @xmath71 contributed to the fresnel tensor @xmath74 , and hence to the construction of the symmetric tensors @xmath105 . an important class of area metric manifolds are those for which one may construct a particular section @xmath106 alone from the data of the area metric tensor @xmath17
, such that @xmath107 is non - degenerate on all of @xmath16 .
then @xmath108 will be called a normal area metric manifold .
we will see that normality of an area metric is an inevitable requirement for the construction of area metric curvature tensors that are downward compatible to their metric counterparts .
but it is not a big restriction .
we will show in the next section that one - forms @xmath104 can always be constructed from the area metric , albeit not always uniquely .
also , @xmath109 is an open condition so that normality is the rule not the exception . in particular
, we will show that area metrics induced from riemannian metrics are always normal . for lorentzian metrics in even dimensions , we find that the construction of a normal area metric interestingly requires that the lorentzian metric should describe a stably causal spacetime .
the signature of a normal area metric manifold @xmath108 is defined as the signature @xmath110 of the metric @xmath111 constructed from @xmath17 and @xmath112 . with this definition , we may define the totally antisymmetric tensor density @xmath113 to be normalized such that @xmath114 .
this in turn induces the contravariant tensor @xmath115 with components @xmath116 it is necessary to distinguish the tensors @xmath117 and @xmath115 , because their components are in general not related by lowering and raising of indices with the area metric and inverse area metric , respectively . with these definitions , we obtain for the contraction over @xmath118 indices the useful identity @xmath119}_{\,\,\,b_1 \dots b_{d - k}}\,.\ ] ]
we now complete the construction of an effective metric from a generic area metric manifold @xmath15 without specifying additional data . from our findings in sections [ gauge ] and [ normal ] , we know that the extraction of a metric from area metric data amounts to the construction of a section @xmath104 of the subbundle @xmath91 , as defined by reality of the characteristic function ( [ character ] ) , such that @xmath120 is normal
. then the inverse of the tensor @xmath82 as defined in ( [ hsigma1 ] ) provides the desired metric . in order to achieve downward compatibility with metric geometry
, we further require that for metric - induced area metrics the inducing metric @xmath14 is recovered up to a sign ( more can not be expected since the metric - induced area metrics are quadratic expressions ) .
this requirement will lead to a modification of the induction formula ( [ cg ] ) for lorentzian metrics .
the fresnel tensor for a metric - induced area metric ( [ cg ] ) takes the simple form ( [ metricfresnel ] ) .
then the characteristic function ( [ character ] ) is given by @xmath121 in both cases this is real on the entire cotangent bundle , so that @xmath122 .
now , however , appears a crucial difference between metric manifolds of different signatures .
first consider the case of a riemannian metric @xmath14 where @xmath123 independent of the dimension . in this case
all members of the family @xmath105 of metrics coincide , and are given , for an arbitrary section @xmath104 , by @xmath124 this means that any choice of section @xmath125 recovers the inducing riemannian metric @xmath14 from the area metric @xmath126 , including the zero section that does not even require area metric data .
thus @xmath127 is normal if @xmath14 is a riemannian metric .
the same conclusion holds if @xmath14 is an odd - dimensional lorentzian metric . but now let @xmath14 be an even - dimensional lorentzian metric
. then the family @xmath82 of metrics is given by @xmath128 in contrast to the riemannian case , it is now not possible to choose the zero - section in order to recover the inducing lorentzian metric .
this means we must obtain a non - trivial section from the area metric in order to be downwards compatible to the metric - induced case .
otherwise the construction would fail for the even - dimensional lorentzian case .
we first observe that the required section @xmath104 can not be constructed alone from the cyclic part @xmath28 of the inverse area metric .
this is because the only one - forms obtainable from @xmath28 are of the form @xmath129 where @xmath130 and @xmath131 are a finite set of non - negative integers and @xmath132 and @xmath133 .
now for an area metric that is metric - induced according to ( [ cg ] ) , we have @xmath134 and @xmath135 , so that both @xmath28 and its inverse are cylic ( which , we recall , does not hold for generic area metrics ) . then it is easily verified that all of the one - forms ( [ candidateone ] ) vanish .
thus we are compelled to conclude that information from the area metric beyond the cyclic part @xmath28 is needed for the definition of a non - trivial section @xmath104 .
we hence turn to the four - form part of the inverse area metric as a potential carrier of this information .
this fits nicely together with the observation that @xmath136 is defined entirely in terms of the cyclic part of the inverse area metric .
so the four - form part will exclusively contribute to the construction of the section @xmath104 which replaces @xmath97 , while the cyclic part exclusively contributes to the definition of the bilinear symmetric tensor @xmath136 .
for an area metric manifold of dimension @xmath137 , we may schematically decompose the inverse area metric as @xmath138 so that the information in the four - form part is succinctly encoded in a @xmath139-form @xmath140 .
now four - dimensional area metric manifolds are distinguished since , in this dimension , the construction of a one - form from the four - form part of @xmath71 is unique .
the only possible choice is @xmath141 any rescaling of this choice , even by a function , is without effect because of relation ( [ deg0 ] ) . due to the symmetries of @xmath71 and @xmath115 , it is also not possible to construct further non - vanishing one - forms from @xmath142 .
already in five dimensions , there are several possibilities , @xmath143 in even higher dimensions , the number of possibilities further proliferates .
so in four dimensions only may one speak of _ the _ normal area metric manifold @xmath120 constructed from an area metric manifold .
( at least , unless one could formulate further meaningful criteria to construct , also in higher dimensions , a natural section @xmath112 to single out the effective metric from the family @xmath82 of contravariant tensors . ) from now on , we will therefore restrict attention to the four - dimensional case , which of course also is the one of immediate physical interest .
a four - dimensional normal area metric manifold will henceforth be denoted @xmath144 where @xmath145 is the unique metric constructed from the area metric @xmath17 .
generically , the metric @xmath146 of course only encodes part of the information contained in the area metric .
other than in dimension three , the area measure @xmath147 re - induced from the effective metric generically does not agree with the measure determined by @xmath17 .
the above constructions play out nicely for area metric manifolds induced by stably causal spacetimes @xmath9 in four dimensions . for the latter
, there always exists a global time function @xmath148 on @xmath16 such that @xmath142 is everywhere @xmath14-timelike @xcite .
hence after a choice of global time function @xmath148 has been made , the latter may be encoded directly into the totally antisymmetric part of the inverse area metric : @xmath149 due to our mainly plus signature convention , the inducing lorentzian metric may be recovered , using ( [ zzz ] ) and ( [ lorentzh ] ) , as @xmath150 .
so downward compatibility is maintained .
from now on , we will denote the inverse area metric ( [ stablycausallift ] ) induced by some lorentzian metric @xmath14 and a suitable scalar field @xmath148 always by @xmath151 .
inverting this one finds the relation @xmath152 this is the closest a normal area metric may come to a lorentzian metric , and presents an important class of area spacetimes which can be easily compared to standard metric spacetime , see section [ solar ] . in the following section , we will see that cosmological symmetries , for instance , enforce this special , almost metric , form of an area metric .
at this point it is useful to study isometries of area metric manifolds .
this will provide us with more evidence for the natural role non - cyclic area metrics play and prepare our discussion of area metric cosmology .
a diffeomorphism @xmath153 is called an area metric isometry if it preserves the area metric in the sense that for all smooth vector fields @xmath154 on @xmath16 and all @xmath55 , we have @xmath155 where @xmath156 denotes the push - forward with respect to @xmath92 . as in the metric case , it is useful to consider the generators of isometries , i.e. , killing vector fields @xmath157 . clearly , @xmath157 is a killing vector field for an area metric manifold @xmath15 if @xmath158 .
this condition implies that the killing vectors of a given area metric manifold , together with the standard commutator , constitute a lie algebra .
it is reassuring to verify that for a metric - induced area metric manifold , @xmath157 is a killing vector of @xmath159 if and only if @xmath157 is a killing vector of @xmath9 .
this is indeed the case : the implication @xmath160 is evident .
conversely , assume @xmath161 . in particular , for any pair of @xmath14-orthogonal vectors
@xmath162 , we have @xmath163 now consider a @xmath14-orthonormal basis @xmath164 , @xmath165 of @xmath166 . for any three distinct vectors @xmath167 in such a basis
, the relation above implies @xmath168 this set of equations is homogeneous and non - degenerate with respect to @xmath169 , @xmath170 , and @xmath171 , so that it admits as the unique solution @xmath172 . to complete the proof , note that we then also have @xmath173 so that @xmath174 .
it follows that @xmath175 for all @xmath176 ; in other words , @xmath177 .
it is also worthwhile to note that , in the case @xmath178 , the theorem easily extends to @xmath179 .
equipped with the definition of killing vectors , we can now discuss physically relevant applications .
in particular , we will be able to construct the analogue of a friedmann - lematre - robertson - walker ( flrw ) cosmology for an area metric background .
we will discover that a cosmological area metric in @xmath180 is precisely of the form ( [ stablycausallift ] ) , with the cyclic part being induced by a standard flrw metric , and with the scalar field providing an additional degree of freedom in comparison to metric geometry .
first recall that , given a lie group action @xmath181 on some smooth manifold @xmath16 , it is useful to define the following notions @xcite .
the orbit of some point @xmath55 is the submanifold @xmath182 .
the isotropy group @xmath183 at some point @xmath55 is that subgroup of @xmath17 whose action leaves @xmath97 invariant .
a submanifold @xmath184 of dimension @xmath185 is said to be _ homogeneous _ if there is a transitive action of some lie group @xmath17 on @xmath184 , i.e. if @xmath186 for all @xmath187 .
it is said to be _ spherically symmetric _ around a point @xmath97 if the isotropy group of @xmath97 is @xmath188 , and the relative orbit of any other point @xmath189 around @xmath97 is topologically equivalent to an @xmath190-sphere . in complete analogy with the standard , rigorous definition of a ( spatially ) homogeneous and isotropic manifold in lorentzian geometry
, we can now define area metric cosmology , i.e. , flrw area metric manifolds , as follows : @xmath15 is a @xmath0-dimensional flrw area metric manifold if and only if it can be suitably sliced in @xmath191-dimensional hypersurfaces , which are homogeneous and spherically symmetric around each point . additionally , the hypersurfaces must be spacelike , in the sense that the restriction of the area metric to them must be positive definite .
in the four - dimensional case , on which we will focus , the general form of the area metric compatible with these requirements can be easily determined .
first of all , we note that the area metric on the slices must be metric - induced , since the slices are three - dimensional ( compare the corollary at the end of section [ gauge ] ) .
the inducing metric @xmath192 must describe three - dimensional maximally symmetric riemannian manifolds with line element @xmath193 for normalized curvature @xmath194 , in the usual system of coordinates @xmath195 . for the restriction of the area metric to the slices of constant @xmath196
we then obtain the expression @xmath197 for some function @xmath198 .
moreover , on each of the spacelike slices , @xmath199 behaves as a three - dimensional metric with respect to the entire group of isometries .
therefore , introducing some function @xmath200 , we have @xmath201 finally , explicitly solving killing conditions for the remaining components of the area metric , one finds for the remaining non - vanishing components the form @xmath202 for some function @xmath203 . employing a suitable rescaling of the time
coordinate and redefining the free functions @xmath204 , it is easy to verify that an flrw area metric takes the form @xmath205 , see ( [ stablycausallift ] ) , where @xmath206 is the standard flrw metric , so that @xmath207 and @xmath208 only depends on time .
inverting @xmath205 and redefining the scalar field , also the inverse area metric decomposes into the form @xmath209 thus in comparison with the standard metric case , flrw area metric manifolds in @xmath180 feature a time - dependent scalar degree of freedom @xmath210 additional to those of the metric , which happens to be encoded in the totally antisymmetric part of the ( inverse ) area metric . if non - vanishing , the section @xmath211 will be @xmath212-timelike , and thus render the flrw area metric normal , as discussed at the end of the previous section .
consequences of this feature for the dynamics of such cosmological models will be discussed in sections [ sec_cosmology ] and [ sec_exact ] .
our aim in this section is the construction of an area metric compatible connection and area metric curvature , which are downward compatible to their metric counterparts . as discussed in @xcite
, we principally need a connection on the non - vector bundle of area spaces @xmath53 embedded in @xmath25 . in order to keep technicalities to a minimum
, we will determine this connection in terms of a covariant derivative @xmath213 on the vector bundle @xmath25 .
consider a four - dimensional normal area metric manifold @xmath214 , where @xmath146 is the unique metric constructed from @xmath17 , as explained in section [ sec_effmetric ] .
the metric @xmath146 immediately gives rise to the torsion - free levi - civita connection @xmath215 , which of course lifts to the @xmath25-bundle in the standard way .
while @xmath215 provides a covariant derivative on @xmath25 and is downward compatible , it is not of direct relevance for the area metric manifold @xmath15 . on the one hand
, it does not contain all the information contained in the area metric , which follows from a simple counting of the number of independent components of the effective metric that defines @xmath215 . on the other hand
, @xmath215 does not obey the important geometric property that the area metric should be covariantly constant : @xmath216 in general .
but covariant constancy of the area metric ensures , for instance , that the simplicity condition ( [ simple ] ) of a section @xmath57 of @xmath25 is not violated by parallel transport ; in other words , areas are preserved under parallel transport @xcite . but
most importantly , we require area metric compatibility because it allows us to determine a unique connection as follows .
first note that an arbitrary connection @xmath213 on @xmath25 , including the area metric compatible one we are seeking , differs at most by some tensor @xmath157 from the lift of the levi - civita connection , i.e. , @xmath217 or , in coordinates , @xmath218 . in order to uniquely determine an area metric - compatible connection @xmath213
, we need to constrain the class of @xmath25-connections we are looking for . to this end note
that for an arbitrary connection on the bundle @xmath25 over a normal area metric manifold @xmath144 , we may define the tensor @xmath219 for any vector @xmath220 and sections @xmath221 of @xmath25 .
we call @xmath222 the relative torsion of the @xmath25-connection @xmath213 with respect to @xmath144
. the virtue of having such a tensor is that one may formulate a consistent condition on a generic @xmath25 connection by requiring @xmath222 to vanish identically .
this requirement corresponds to the symmetry condition @xmath223 on the components of the tensor @xmath157 defined in ( [ xdef ] ) , where indices have been lowered using the area metric @xmath17 .
vanishing relative torsion and area metric compatibility together , @xmath224 then uniquely determine the tensor @xmath157 : using the first requirement @xmath225 gives @xmath226 while the second requirement @xmath227 allows us to equate this to @xmath228
. then @xmath157 must be of the form @xmath229 this result can also be obtained in the coordinate - free language of pre - connections introduced in @xcite
. then the relative torsion - free , area metric compatible @xmath25-connection is given by @xmath230,\cdot)\,,\ ] ] with the symmetric and antisymmetric pre - connections @xmath231 & = & g(\nabla_z^{lc}\omega,\sigma ) - g(\omega,\nabla_z^{lc}\sigma)\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively . here the symmetric pre - connection is determined by @xmath225 alone , while the antisymmetric pre - connection then is determined by @xmath227 .
note that while in @xcite a metric @xmath14 was assumed to be given as data in addition to an area metric in order to construct a connection , the significant advance of this paper consists in having constructed the metric @xmath146 in a unique manner from the area metric data alone .
hence we have now achieved the construction of a true area metric connection , without additional data .
the identification of this unique connection @xmath213 associated with a normal four - dimensional area metric manifold @xmath15 now allows for the definition of the area metric curvature in standard fashion @xmath232}\omega\,,\ ] ] whose components can be calculated to be @xmath233}{}_{b_2]ij}+\left(\nabla^{lc}_i x^{a_1a_2}{}_{b_1b_2j}+x^{a_1a_2}{}_{f_1f_2i}x^{f_1f_2}{}_{b_1b_2j}-(i\leftrightarrow j)\right),\ ] ] where @xmath234 is the curvature of the levi - civita connection @xmath215 obtained from @xmath146 . natural contraction over indices 1 and 2 with indices 3 and 5 yields
the area metric ricci tensor @xmath235 another second rank tensor is defined by @xmath236 } = \mathcal{r}_g{}^{pq}{}_{pqij}\,.\ ] ] due to its antisymmetry , however , there is no contraction to a non - zero scalar of first order in @xmath184 ; the lowest order scalar one may build from @xmath237 is @xmath238 .
this invariant is therefore of no interest to area metric gravity , as its inclusion in an action would drive the derivative order of the equations of motion automatically beyond two .
so the unique area metric curvature scalar of linear order in @xmath239 , is the area metric ricci scalar @xmath240 in the case of an area metric @xmath13 induced from a riemannian metric we have @xmath241 from ( [ xx ] ) .
hence it is immediately clear that the area metric ricci tensor and ricci scalar reduce to their metric counterparts while the tensor @xmath184 vanishes .
the lorentzian case is less obvious ; recall that inducing a normal area metric from a lorentzian metric requires the addition of a scalar @xmath148 whose gradient @xmath142 is a globally non - null one - form field ; according to ( [ stablycausallift ] ) the area metric is @xmath242 .
it may now be checked , however , that also in this case all of the above curvature tensors reduce to their metric counterparts , and that @xmath184 vanishes identically .
this proves the required downward compatibility to metric geometry .
we will use the curvature invariant @xmath243 in the following second part of the paper for the construction of an area metric gravity theory .
the discussion of area metric gravity in this second part is self - contained , since the relevant results of area metric geometry developed in part one are concisely summarized in the following section [ synopsis ] .
the general formalism of area metric gravity and its coupling to matter is developed in section [ gravtheory ] , followed by a comparison of almost metric vacuum solutions to standard general relativity in section [ solar ] .
fluids on area metric spacetimes are necessarily string fluids , as is explained in sections [ pfluids ] and [ sec_sfluids ] . building on these preliminaries , we apply area metric geometry to cosmology in section [ sec_cosmology ] , and find the exact solution for a homogeneous and isotropic area metric universe filled with string dust in section [ sec_exact ] .
this leads to the prediction that area metric cosmology may explain , without dark energy or fine - tuning , the small late - time acceleration of our universe .
in this brief section , we give a practical guide to the construction of area metric curvature in _ four _ dimensions . for derivations and details of the construction in coordinate - free fashion , see part one of this paper .
a lorentzian area metric on a smooth four - dimensional manifold @xmath16 is a covariant tensor @xmath244[cd ] } = g_{[cd][ab]}\,,\ ] ] whose inverse is defined as the contravariant tensor @xmath245 satisfying @xmath246}_d\,.\ ] ] considering ordered pairs of indices @xmath247 , one may write an area metric in four dimensions in petrov notation , i.e. , as a @xmath248 matrix @xmath249 with @xmath162 taking values in the set @xmath250 , [ 02 ] , [ 03 ] , [ 12 ] , [ 13 ] , [ 23]\}$ ] . defining @xmath251 as the determinant taken over the matrix @xmath249 , one may define covariant and contravariant area metric volume tensors @xmath252 where the totally antisymmetric tensor densities @xmath39 are normalized so that @xmath253 and @xmath254 , respectively . the inverse area
metric uniquely decomposes as @xmath255 i.e. , into a cyclic part @xmath256}=0 $ ] and a totally antisymmetric part , which in four dimensions amounts to the specification of a function @xmath148 on @xmath16 .
the definition of @xmath257 is that of @xmath37 , with @xmath28 replaced by @xmath17 . a normal area metric allows to extract a unique effective metric @xmath258 from the area metric data . in case
the area metric is almost metric , i.e. , @xmath259 for some metric @xmath14 , the effective metric @xmath146 recovers the inducing metric @xmath14 up to a sign , which validates the present construction independent of its deeper geometric meaning discussed in part one of this paper .
finally , the area metric curvature tensor is given by @xmath260}{}_{[b_1b_2][ij ] } = 4\delta^{[a_1}_{[b_1}r^{a_2]}{}_{b_2]ij}+\big(\nabla^{lc}_i x^{a_1a_2}{}_{b_1b_2j}+\frac{1}{2}x^{a_1a_2}{}_{pqi}x^{pq}{}_{b_1b_2j}-(i\leftrightarrow j)\big),\ ] ] where @xmath234 and @xmath215 are the riemann tensor and the levi - civita connection of the effective metric @xmath146 , and the non - metricity tensor @xmath157 is defined by @xmath261}{}_{[b_1b_2]f}\,.\ ] ] the area metric curvature tensor , as well as the associated area metric ricci tensor @xmath262 and area metric ricci scalar @xmath263 , reduce to their metric counterparts for almost metric area metrics .
these correspondences ensure in particular that area metric geometry is downward compatible to metric geometry , which is therefore contained as a special case .
area metric geometry allows us to devise a gravity theory different from einstein s without modifying the form of the einstein - hilbert action ; the latter is just re - interpreted as an action for an area metric manifold , with all metric quantities being replaced by their area metric counterparts .
we restrict our study of the area metric version of the einstein - hilbert action to four dimensions , as only there the standard metric version enjoys its truly special status due to lovelock s theorem @xcite .
thus we adopt the following action for four - dimensional normal area metric spacetimes @xmath15 : @xmath264 from which the equations of motion are derived by variation with respect to the ( inverse ) area metric @xmath17 .
the gravitational constant @xmath265 is not yet determined at this stage .
the quantity @xmath266 represents the matter lagrangian scalar density , which in many cases is simply @xmath267 in terms of a scalar lagrangian @xmath268 .
the diffeomorphism invariance of the action immediately implies an area metric bianchi identity for the gravitational part of the action , and the conservation law for the area metric energy - momentum tensor @xmath34 . in order to study the latter , consider a diffeomorphism on @xmath16 generated by a vector field @xmath269 .
the induced variation of the inverse area metric may be expressed covariantly as a lie derivative , @xmath270pcd}+2 \nabla^{lc}_p \xi^{[c}g^{d]pab}\,,\ ] ] where the second equality uses the levi - civita connection of the effective metric .
requiring invariance of the matter action under this variation by setting @xmath271 , i.e. , @xmath272 , and performing some partial integration , we are led to the conservation equation @xmath273}_i\right)=0\,.\ ] ] for the fourth rank tensor @xmath274 we call this tensor @xmath34 the generalized energy - momentum tensor of matter on an area metric manifold
. since it is derived by variation with respect to the inverse area metric , it has the symmetries of the area metric .
in particular it may contain a totally antisymmetric part in the decomposition under the local frame group .
computationally performing the variation of the gravitational part of the action is rather involved ; it is given in full detail in appendix [ appvary ] . from the reducibility of the inverse area metric @xmath17 into a cyclic and totally antisymmetric part , however , it is clear that in four dimensions the equations of motion for generic area metrics can be separated accordingly .
so if the tensor @xmath275 denotes the variation of the gravitational part of the action ( [ totalaction ] ) with respect to the inverse area metric @xmath71 , i.e. , @xmath276 then , using equation ( [ varg ] ) , we may decompose the total variation into those terms arising from the gravitational part @xmath277,\ ] ] and into those from the matter part @xmath278.\ ] ] taking care to impose the symmetries of @xmath279 on the expressions in brackets that are contracted with it , we may thus define the cyclic contributions @xmath280 and @xmath281 , and the scalar contributions @xmath282 and @xmath283 of the gravitational tensor @xmath284 and the energy - momentum tensor @xmath34 to the equations of motion . in terms of these quantities ,
whose explicit form is derived in appendix [ appvary ] , the full equations of motion for area metric gravity take the form [ generalform ] @xmath285 of course , these field equations are far too complex to be exactly solved in general , and one has to content oneself with studying exact solutions for highly symmetric spacetimes . for area
metric cosmology we will start this program below . as an example for the general theory outlined above , consider the theory of electrodynamics defined by the action ( [ edaction ] ) .
variation of this action with respect to the inverse area metric yields the generalized energy momentum tensor @xmath286 as an aside we note here that @xmath180 is special because it is only in this dimension that we have @xmath287 for arbitrary electromagnetic fields .
we may now substitute the expression for @xmath34 into the conservation equation above .
the coupling of the area metric background and the gauge theory is then only consistent if this equation is satisfied .
this is in fact to be expected since the energy momentum tensor was derived from a diffeomorphism invariant action . in order to see explicitly that this is indeed the case , we rewrite the resulting conservation condition for electrodynamics in the form @xmath288}+\frac{1}{2}f_{di}\left(\nabla^{tm}_c+\frac{1}{2(d-1)}x_c\right)\left(g^{cdab}f_{ab}\right )
= 0\,.\ ] ] all covariant derivatives in this expression may be replaced with partial derivatives by using the definition of the dual electromagnetic induction @xmath2-form , see ( [ induction ] ) . in this way
we obtain @xmath289}+\frac{1}{2}(-1)^d f_{i_d i}\omega_g^{i_1\dots i_d}\partial_{[i_1}h_{i_2\dots i_{d-1}]}=0\,.\ ] ] so the equations of motion of area metric electrodynamics , namely the bianchi identity @xmath4 , and @xmath5 imply energy conservation , rendering the matter coupling consistent .
a question of immediate interest is of course how standard einstein gravity fits into the more general area metric framework , given its huge phenomenological success especially regarding observations within our solar system .
more precisely , we would like to know under which circumstances there exist solutions of ( [ generalform ] ) where the inverse area metric is of almost metric form @xmath290 , see ( [ stablycausallift ] ) , which is the closest one may get to the standard lorentzian case .
( recall from section [ sec_effmetric ] that the field @xmath148 is needed in order to render the area metric induced from a lorentzian metric normal . ) interestingly , area metrics with cosmological symmetries are of almost metric form , as we found in section [ sec_killing ] .
thus the results of the present section will be useful in our discussion of area metric cosmology in the following sections [ pfluids][sec_exact ] .
the main aim here , however , is to study the conditions under which area metric gravity reduces to einstein gravity . in doing so
, it is important to withstand the temptation to discuss the reduction of ( [ totalaction ] ) to the almost metric case at the level of the action
. this can not be meaningful a priori , because variation with respect to @xmath17 sweeps out more variations than variations with respect to a metric and a scalar field can do @xcite .
if one simply inserted the ansatz @xmath291 into the total action , this would reduce the gravitational part to its standard metric analogue , up to a @xmath148-dependent conformal factor .
but we will now show that this does not correspond to what generically happens at the level of the full equations of motion including matter .
so we insert the almost metric form @xmath291 into the full equations of motion , which , as shown in technical detail in appendix [ qsimplification ] , neatly factorizes the cyclic contribution @xmath280 of the gravitational variation as @xmath292b ] } + s_{[c[a}g_{b]d]}\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] for some symmetric tensor @xmath293 . if the cyclic contribution @xmath281 of the energy - momentum tensor to the equations of motion is generated in like fashion from some symmetric second rank tensor , then the field equations are equivalent to [ vacuumgg ] @xmath294 where we define @xmath295 , @xmath296 and @xmath297 .
when we discuss cosmological solutions below , we will have to make sure that @xmath298 does not leave its allowed range @xmath299 we will see that this can be understood as a consistency constraint on the initial conditions .
it is thus clear that for there to be an almost metric solution at all , the cyclic part of the energy - momentum tensor at hand needs to factorize in the same fashion as ( [ factorized ] ) . in vacuo
, this is of course trivially the case .
it is also reassuring that the vacuum system with @xmath300 is causally well - behaved : in order to see this , we will now perform suitable field redefinitions , and thus reveal that this system is conformally equivalent to einstein - hilbert gravity minimally coupled to a massless scalar field .
first , using the trace of the first equation we may replace the system by a simpler one : @xmath301 now a conformal transformation of the metric and a simple redefinition of the scalar field according to @xmath302 shows that the vacuum equations of motion for an area metric of the almost metric form @xmath291 are conformally equivalent to the system @xmath303 these are precisely einstein s equations for @xmath304 coupled to a massless scalar field @xmath305 , and thus we know that also the original , conformally related theory is causal .
we emphasize again that the above equations are only valid for almost metric area metrics in vacuo .
this very special case , however , allows for a most important conclusion : any vacuum solution @xmath9 of einstein - hilbert gravity is a vacuum solution of area metric gravity ( setting either @xmath306 , or @xmath307 with appropriate conditions on the derivatives , see ( [ vacuumgg ] ) ) . upon the inclusion of matter however , it is no longer true that metric solutions of einstein - hilbert gravity lift to solutions of area metric gravity .
for instance , the area metric energy - momentum tensor ( [ edt ] ) for electrodynamics does not take the factorized form ( [ factorized ] ) for the almost metric ansatz @xmath291 , simply because the first term does not even contain a metric .
thus , not only can electrodynamics live on a non - metric area metric spacetime , but also in general electrodynamics backreacts in such a way as to generate a non - metric area metric spacetime !
this can only be avoided by restricting the admissible geometries ( and thus the variation ) to a standard metric one . in other words , while standard einstein - hilbert solutions are of course stationary points of the einstein - hilbert action , they may fail to be stationary within the wider spectrum of area metric manifolds , in the presence of matter whose energy momentum tensor does not factorize .
thus it is the fact that we vary with respect to the area metric which causes the potential departure from einstein - hilbert gravity in the presence of matter , while the vacuum solutions of standard general relativity are also vacuum solutions of area metric gravity .
in general relativity perfect fluids present an effective device to discuss the gravitational effects of fundamental matter averaged over large scales . especially in order to obtain calculationally manageable cosmological models ,
the description of matter as an ubiquitous fluid is necessary . in this section
we will introduce fluid matter on area metric spacetimes as the most general form of energy momentum consistent with area metric cosmology .
this discussion paves our way towards a first comparison between area metric cosmology and einstein cosmology .
the general form of the energy momentum four - tensor is restricted by the killing symmetries of a given area metric spacetime @xmath15 .
consider a diffeomorphism of @xmath16 generated by a vector field @xmath269 , and the resulting change @xmath308 of the variation of the gravitational action with respect to @xmath71 .
there are two ways to express this quantity .
the first simply is the lie derivative of the four - tensor @xmath284 along @xmath269 , i.e. , @xmath309 .
the second uses the fact that @xmath284 is completely determined by the area metric @xmath17 ; schematically it follows that @xmath310 .
hence if @xmath157 is a killing symmetry of @xmath17 , i.e. , if @xmath311 , then we conclude @xmath312 the general form of the area metric gravity equations of motion , including matter , is @xmath313 the lie derivative of the left hand side along any killing symmetry @xmath157 of the area metric @xmath17 vanishes , hence consistency requires that the energy momentum tensor should also satisfy @xmath314 for each of the background s killing symmetries .
in other words , consistent energy momentum tensors inherit the symmetries of the background .
this conclusion is analogous to the one used in standard general relativity to restrict the class of admitted sources in a spacetime with specified symmetry properties .
we may repeat our discussion of section [ sec_killing ] to impose the symmetries of an flrw area metric cosmology on the four - tensor @xmath34 . recall that @xmath71 is defined in terms of the standard flrw metric @xmath14 and a time - dependent scalar @xmath148 , and that we have a distinguished time variable @xmath315 .
one then finds the components of @xmath34 to be proportional to those of the area metric up to time - dependent functions .
we choose the following parametrization , [ fluidenergy ] @xmath316 where the three functions @xmath317 and @xmath184 describe the local macroscopic properties of the fluid .
below , we will match these functions with the usual notions of density and pressure for a fluid . but
first note that like in the metric case , the fluid energy momentum tensor is not obtained from some lagrangian , and so the conservation law ( [ conservation ] ) is not automatically ensured .
we have to impose the energy - momentum conservation condition on the tensor @xmath34 , which , using the hubble function @xmath318 , leads to the equation of motion of the fluid , @xmath319 before we turn to our main application of fluid matter , which will be to area metric cosmology , we will introduce in the next section the notion of string fluids which allows us to give a covariant interpretation to fluid matter on area metric spacetimes .
area metric spacetimes @xmath15 do not provide a measure of length which would be required to formulate dynamics for the worldlines of point particles .
but they do provide a measure of area , and so one may regard string worldsheets as the minimal dynamical , and hence fundamental , objects on area metric manifolds @xcite .
it is therefore reasonable to expect that any collection of matter fields averaged over large scales should have an approximate description in terms of a fluid made out of strings ; this is in complete analogy to standard general relativity where perfect ( point particle ) fluids are used for this purpose .
our aim in this section is twofold : first we will formulate a simple energy momentum four - tensor for a string fluid on an arbitrary area metric spacetime , and give a geometric interpretation for the consistency conditions arising from the energy conservation equation ( [ conservation ] ) .
second , we will rewrite the general energy momentum tensor consistent with area metric cosmology covariantly in terms of a string fluid ; any collection of averaged matter fields in cosmology can thus be understood as a continuous distribution of string worldsheets .
we recall a few basic facts about classical strings on @xmath15 from @xcite .
string worldsheets are tangent surfaces to an integrable distribution of areas @xmath320 in @xmath53 .
thus they satisfy the simplicity condtion ( [ simple ] ) and the frobenius integrability criterion : the commutator of @xmath321 and @xmath322 lies within the plane spanned by @xmath323 . in components
this is equivalent to @xmath324}=0\,.\ ] ] string dynamics follow from the stationarity of the worldsheet area integral , i.e. , from @xmath325 .
the equality follows from the simplicity of @xmath57 , if we explicitly decompose the area metric as @xmath326 into the cyclic algebraic curvature tensor @xmath327 and a four form @xmath328 in analogy to ( [ c+f ] ) .
it has been shown in @xcite that the string equation of motion takes a very simple form after fixing the worldsheet reparametrization invariance to constant squared area @xmath329 .
the stationarity , or minimal surface , condition then simply becomes @xmath330(\omega\wedge z)=0\ ] ] for any vector @xmath220 .
only the cyclic part of the area metric contributes to this equation .
the energy momentum four - tensor of a string fluid should be expressible in terms of the area metric and the area distribution @xmath57 .
we now write down the simplest two terms that obey the required symmetries of an area metric .
one of these will then be shown to represent fluids composed of non - interacting strings ; the other term is an example for a simple interaction .
define @xmath331 in terms of two functions @xmath332 and @xmath333 . in order to demonstrate the geometric meaning of these terms we analyse the energy momentum conservation condition . as argued in the preceding section
this condition is not automatically satisfied , but nevertheless has to be imposed for consistent matter coupling .
we substitute ( [ sfluid ] ) into ( [ conservation ] ) ; the resulting equation can be rewritten as follows : @xmath334ab}\omega^{ab}\right ) -4 g_{diab}\omega^{ab}\left(\nabla^{lc}_c+\frac{1}{6}x_c\right)\left((\tilde\rho+\tilde p ) \omega^{cd}\right)+8\partial_i\tilde p\\\ ] ] observe that the totally antisymmetric part of the area metric in the first term does not contribute .
this is a consequence of the simplicity ( [ simple ] ) and the integrability ( [ integrability ] ) of @xmath57 .
hence we may replace @xmath17 in the first term by its cyclic part @xmath327 .
due to the antisymmetrization in this term we may also replace the covariant derivatives by partials .
let us discuss the case @xmath335 first .
the first term then is recognizable as the stationarity condition ( [ stationarity ] ) : the local string worlsheets in the string fluid are stationary , as is classical string motion .
the vanishing of the remaining second term in the string fluid conservation equation is implied by a generalized continuity equation @xmath336 where the right hand side represents the divergence of a densitized current . in form - language
the continuity equation is equivalent to @xmath337=0 $ ] for the two - form @xmath338 .
the geometrical picture for this equation is as follows .
choose any compact four - volume @xmath339 with boundary @xmath340 , and any hypersurface defined by @xmath341 with gradient @xmath342 .
the projection on the hypersurface of the flow of the string fluid through @xmath343 is @xmath344\wedge d\psi\,.\ ] ] this vanishes if the volume @xmath339 lies entirely within the domain of the string fluid ; then its inflow and outflow through the boundary @xmath340 are precisely equal , independent of the choice of projection on @xmath342 .
thus the string fluid energy momentum tensor ( [ sfluid ] ) is amenable to a simple analysis for @xmath335 : energy momentum conservation is valid provided that the string fluid obeys both the stationarity equation and a generalized current conservation , or continuity , equation . while the worldsheet minimal surfaces of this situation correspond to zero mean curvature form @xmath345 , switching on a non - constant pressure @xmath346 means prescribing the local mean curvature by the projection of the gradient field @xmath347 into the surfaces
non - zero @xmath333 ( even a constant one ) also deforms the continuity equation .
the term proportional to @xmath333 hence represents a certain class of interactions between the strings that form the string fluid .
finally , we remark that constant @xmath348 ( with @xmath349 ) generates precisely the same terms that one would obtain by adding an area metric cosmological constant to the gravitational action @xmath350 , in perfect analogy with the metric case .
we now approach our second aim , and part , of this section : the covariant rewriting of the most general energy momentum tensor consistent with area metric cosmology , see the preceding section , in terms of a string fluid .
recall that area metric cosmologies are of the almost metric type , featuring the flrw metric @xmath14 and an additional time - dependent scalar @xmath148 .
string fluid matter in cosmology is tightly constrained ; consistency with isotropy forbids a one - component string fluid , since the local string worldsheets then would distinguish a preferred spatial direction .
we therefore must resort to a string fluid with three components @xmath351 , with three @xmath14-spacelike vectors @xmath352 that may isotropically fill out the spatial sections in a four - dimensional cosmology . due to the distinguished cosmological time variable , @xmath315 , the fluid energy momentum tensor ( [ fluidenergy ] ) has components proportional to the @xmath353 , @xmath354 and @xmath355 projections of the area metric , respectively .
these can be defined covariantly using the three - component string fluid . using the decomposition ( [ gdec ] )
we first define a projection ( which is an endomorphism on @xmath25 ) to the purely spatial indices @xmath356 $ ] by writing @xmath357}_{cd}+q^{ab}{}_{cd}\,,\qquad
q^{ab}{}_{cd}=\sum_i \omega^{ab}_i g^c_{cdi_1i_2}\omega^{i_1i_2}_i\,.\ ] ] to guarantee the right - action of this operator is a projection we need to satisfy @xmath358 , which is easily achieved by the requirement @xmath359 which relates the three components of the string fluid . for later convenience
we solve this by considering @xmath360 and @xmath361 vielbeins of the three - dimensional metric @xmath362 : then we have the useful relation @xmath363 . the second projection we need
is the one to the mixed indices @xmath364 $ ] .
it is simply given by the right - action of @xmath365 for which of course @xmath366 .
there is one further way to covariantize the purely spatial components @xmath367 of the area metric .
consider the operator @xmath368 since the @xmath369 all contain the preferred time vector @xmath370 , we have @xmath371 , and hence @xmath372 .
so @xmath373 is not a projection ; it rather maps tensors with mixed indices @xmath364 $ ] to tensors with purely spatial indices .
in terms of the three - component string fluid we hence rewrite the fluid energy momentum as a sum of projections of the area metric to its different components , weighted each by time - dependent functions : @xmath374.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we do not display two further non - vanishing terms involving @xmath375 and @xmath376 since they simply result in shifts of the functions @xmath377 and @xmath378 . making use of the schematic relation @xmath379=-g^4(\cdot,\cdot)$ ] which follows from the fact that we have chosen the @xmath380 as vielbeins of @xmath362 , we may rewrite the energy momentum tensor as @xmath381 note that we have four functions @xmath382 here , although three functions @xmath383 as in ( [ fluidenergy ] ) should be sufficient . without loss of generality we can in fact fix @xmath384 .
if we do so , and calculate the components @xmath385 , @xmath386 and @xmath387 , comparison to ( [ fluidenergy ] ) gives the invertible relation @xmath388 to conclude , the three - component string fluid tensor with @xmath384 is a covariant way to rewrite the general source tensor for all types of matter averaged over large scales in an area metric cosmology as @xmath389 the energy momentum conservation equation follows from ( [ fleq ] ) and ( [ invrel ] ) , using for later convenience the redefinition @xmath390 , and the hubble function , as @xmath391 a special case of the general expression ( [ gensfluid ] ) is the string fluid representing the sum of three components of non - interacting strings , see ( [ sfluid ] ) , which we will call string dust . from our previous discussion we read off the characteristic relations @xmath392 we will use string dust in our discussion of the late universe , where interactions presumably are neglibible .
as a first application of the dynamical area metric manifold theory developed so far , we derive in this section the equations of area metric cosmology , with the aim to compare our theory to einstein s general relativity . from our discussion of killing symmetries we know that cosmological area metrics are of the almost metric type , fully characterized by just two fields : the flrw metric @xmath14 and a time - dependent scalar field @xmath148 . thus we can use the simplified equations of motion ( [ vacuumgg ] ) discussed in section [ solar ] .
these are of the general form @xmath393 we perform a time space split by writing @xmath315 , where greek indices denote spatial coordinates .
the characteristic property of the flrw metric , which obeys @xmath394 , also implies @xmath395 . employing the definition @xmath396 , and similarly for the spatial components of the cosmological ricci tensor , @xmath397
, we explicitly obtain the following expressions for the non - vanishing components @xmath398 and @xmath399 : [ eqgrav ] @xmath400 where @xmath318 is used .
the expression for @xmath282 is given by equation ( [ phiva ] ) .
we now consider the matter contribution to the gravitational equations of motion .
as argued above the most general form of matter in area metric cosmology is given by a string fluid energy momentum tensor of the form ( [ gensfluid ] ) . from the timelike normalizations
@xmath401 we immediately find the string fluid contribution to the scalar equation which simply reads @xmath402 the four - tensor contribution @xmath403 is more involved . since @xmath404 here , this projection to an algebraic curvature tensor is @xmath405 where the indices on @xmath369 are lowered with the metric @xmath14 .
importantly there are no non - vanishing components @xmath406 .
this is guaranteed by our construction and again shows consistency with the area metric cosmology background .
we proceed to calculate the non - vanishing components of @xmath281 , which again uses the convenient form of the @xmath407 as vielbeins of @xmath362 .
the results are @xmath408 it is easy to see that @xmath281 is induced by a symmetric two - tensor in the same way as is @xmath280 in ( [ factorized ] ) .
we now extract the components of @xmath296 ; writing @xmath409 this gives @xmath410 according to ( [ eqform ] ) , we finally combine our results for the gravitational contributions ( [ eqgrav ] ) and our results for the matter contributions ( [ eqmatt ] ) to the general equations of area metric cosmology coupled to any type of matter . the latter is described in a parametrization by a three - component string fluid .
we find the simple @xmath148-equation @xmath411 calculating the trace of @xmath412 and using ( [ req ] ) , we deduce a standard scalar field equation for @xmath298 , @xmath413 with potential @xmath414 finally , using both ( [ req ] ) and ( [ phieq ] ) to simplify ( [ eqform ] ) , we explicitly obtain the time - time and spatial components of the ricci tensor [ graveqs ] @xmath415 we may now easily compare our equations to those of einstein gravity , i.e. , to @xmath416 , coupled to a perfect fluid with standard energy momentum @xmath417 . performing
the time space split these equations are @xmath418 thus our string fluid gives rise to a perfect fluid with equation of state parameter @xmath419 before we analyze this effective behaviour further we have to perform a final consistency check .
since the string fluid energy momentum four - tensor was not derived , by variation with respect to the inverse area metric , from an action , we have to ensure that the energy momentum conservation equation ( [ constring ] ) is satisfied .
only then is the coupling of the string fluid to the gravitational equations consistent . to see why this is true , we start from the time - component of the contracted bianchi identity @xmath420 which is the standard fluid equation of motion @xmath421 . in our string fluid variables
we thus have @xmath422 we expand the derivative of the term @xmath423 ; then we replace @xmath424 by using the identity @xmath425 which holds for any flrw cosmology , and @xmath426 by employing the equation of motion of @xmath298 .
up to a sign , this precisely yields the energy momentum conservation condition ( [ constring ] ) .
our cosmological three - component string fluid thus is consistent without any further restrictions on the functions @xmath427 and @xmath377 .
let us turn to a closer inspection of the effective equation of state parameter @xmath428 .
we obtain the following results which are generic for any string fluid , and thus for any type of matter in area metric cosmology ( in string fluid parametrization ) . in the limit @xmath429
we obtain the parameter @xmath430 of an effective radiation fluid .
note that this limit is exactly realized by the vacuum which , in particular , obeys @xmath431 .
thus the vacuum cosmology in area metric geometry is equivalent to einstein cosmology filled with a radiation fluid . in the limit @xmath432
we obtain the parameter @xmath433 describing a universe with zero acceleration @xmath434 .
consider now the condition @xmath435 for an accelerating universe ; it is satisfied if either @xmath436 or @xmath437 . for values of @xmath438 close to the simple pole in @xmath428 at @xmath439 , we may obtain any value of @xmath428 , both positive or negative .
so string fluids in principle should be able to describe any physical universe .
moreover , the diverging effective equation of state parameter @xmath440 close to the pole is a temptation to speculate on a possible explanation for the inflationary phase of the universe .
whether this can be realized , however , requires a careful analysis and solutions of the equations . in the next section
we will explicitly analyze the important case of the late universe , which is characterized by non - interacting matter .
we will show that area metric cosmology provides a natural explanation for the observed acceleration of our universe .
in this section we exactly solve the equations of area metric cosmology filled with non - interacting matter , which we describe by string dust .
this is the simplest scenario to which we can apply our theory .
moreover , it should describe the late universe , where matter on average has spread out so much that interactions are no longer important .
the defining relations for string dust have been discussed in ( [ sdust ] ) .
we employ these and collect the complete set of equations of motion .
the scalar equation of motion follows from ( [ potphi ] ) as @xmath441 we also have the gravitational equations ( [ graveqs ] ) which , in the string dust case , read [ gequ ] @xmath442 in the non - vacuum case where @xmath443 , an equivalent system is obtained by replacing one of the three equations above by the simpler continuity equation which follows from ( [ constring ] ) , i.e. , @xmath444 and we will , in fact , replace the scalar equation of motion . dividing the first of the gravitational equations ( [ gequ ] ) by @xmath3 we deduce @xmath445 for constant @xmath446 .
so @xmath298 is determined by the scale factor . the continuity equation is easily integrated , and yields @xmath332 in terms of the scale factor and a constant @xmath447 .
explicitly we find @xmath448 the remaining equation we have to solve in order to obtain the string dust solution follows from the second gravitational equation in ( [ gequ ] ) : @xmath449 we are interested in the effective equation of state parameter for the perfect fluid that is created by area metric cosmology in addition to einstein cosmology . hence we rewrite the defining relations for the parameters @xmath450 and @xmath438 in ( [ statepar ] ) using the above equations .
this yields @xmath451 for @xmath452 .
hence the definition of the parameter @xmath428 results in @xmath453 we conclude that once we have a solution of ( [ aeq ] ) for the scale factor @xmath454 , the whole system of equations is integrated , and provides @xmath332 , @xmath298 and @xmath428 .
equation ( [ aeq ] ) is exactly solved by the scale factor @xmath455 for integration constants @xmath456 and @xmath457 .
the parameter @xmath269 is defined as above . for the sake of completeness , we will now discuss three possible cases @xmath458 , @xmath459 and @xmath460 , assuming @xmath461 ( the discussion for @xmath462 is very similar but does not contain consistent @xmath463 cosmologies ) .
however , it is evident that the only relevant case for our model of late time cosmology is @xmath460 , since @xmath458 requires fine - tuning , and @xmath459 evolves towards a contracting universe , against the assumed predominance of the string dust component . [
[ i - case - xi0 . ] ] ( i ) case @xmath458 .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + this case with @xmath464 can only be realized by positively curved @xmath465 cosmologies ; this fixes @xmath447 which is not generic .
we also need positive @xmath466 and @xmath467 for a real solution .
we find @xmath468 so that the effective equation of state parameter follows from ( [ parst ] ) as @xmath469 it is not difficult to show that @xmath470 for all @xmath471 . in the limit @xmath472
we find @xmath473 .
consistency requires @xmath474 , see the discussion for ( [ constraint ] ) . since @xmath475 one can show consistency for @xmath476 and large @xmath477 .
so this case of a string dust filled area metric cosmology describes an open , eternally decelerating , universe with initial singularity , for which the acceleration tends to zero for late times , see figure [ figure1 ] .
[ [ ii - case - xi0 . ] ] ( ii ) case @xmath459 .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the solution for the scale factor holds for positive @xmath466 and is the upper half of an ellipsoid , defined for @xmath478 .
we deduce @xmath479 , but this leads to an inconsistency .
for late times , i.e. , for @xmath480 , the derivative @xmath481 diverges , and hence @xmath298 so that @xmath474 can not be satisfied .
therefore this closed universe is not a valid solution . [ [ iii - case - xi0 . ] ] ( iii ) case @xmath460 .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + this case will turn out to be the most interesting .
it has @xmath482 , and so it can be realized by negatively curved @xmath483 and flat @xmath463 cosmologies without further restrictions .
it can also be realized by @xmath465 cosmologies , but this requires a matter density @xmath484 . again
@xmath479 so that the effective equation of state parameter takes the form @xmath485 but here , for @xmath460 , we have to discuss two subcases depending on the sign of the integration constant @xmath456 . if @xmath466 then the solution is defined for @xmath486 .
if @xmath487 then the solution is defined for all @xmath196 . for both signs of @xmath456 we obtain the late time limit of @xmath473 .
we can also check consistency for late times @xmath488 . if @xmath489 this limit ensures @xmath490 .
the solution with @xmath466 corresponds to an open , eternally decelerating , universe with initial singularity , for which the acceleration tends to zero for late times .
the solution for @xmath487 describes an open , eternally _ accelerating _ , universe without singularities that passes a minimal radius @xmath491 and has a late - time acceleration tending to zero , see figure [ figure1 ] .
it is worthwhile to note that the sign of @xmath456 is , in principle , deducible from evaluation of the hubble parameter and of the density @xmath332 at present time , since @xmath492 . in the case of a flat universe , for example ,
acceleration ( @xmath487 ) is obtained if @xmath493 ( note , however , that the precise value of @xmath265 has still to be fixed , e.g. , from comparison with solar system experiments . ) _ the solid curves in this sketch show the area metric cosmologies filled with string dust . from bottom to top
these are the cases @xmath458 , @xmath460 with @xmath466 , and @xmath459 with @xmath487 .
the dashed curve depicts the inconsistent case @xmath459 .
the top curve is an important new result from area geometry ( and can not be obtained as a dust - filled einstein cosmology ) : late - time acceleration that tends to zero for @xmath472._,width=288 ] we conclude that non - interacting string dust matter in area metric cosmology is equivalent to einstein cosmology filled with a perfect fluid , but , importantly , it provides a more interesting phenomenology than does an einstein universe filled with standard pressure - free dust .
first , area metric cosmology predicts an open late universe , since the closed cosmology is inconsistent .
second , and most strikingly , area metric cosmology may naturally explain , for all @xmath463 and @xmath494 cosmologies , the late - time acceleration of the universe !
this explanation neither invokes fundamentally unexplained concepts such as a cosmological constant or other forms of dark energy , nor does it invoke fine - tuning since the acceleration automatically tends to small values at late time ; these results become consequences of area geometry applied to the very simplest scenario , cosmology .
this paper is based on the hypothesis that spacetime is an area metric manifold , which presents a true generalization of metric geometry in dimensions greater than three . by constructing a rigid extension of general relativity to area metric geometry , which can explain the acceleration of the late universe without additional assumptions , we have shown that this idea can be taken to surprisingly interesting conclusions .
the physically immediately relevant case of a four - dimensional area metric manifold is distinguished , since we have shown that the area metric geometry on three - dimensional submanifolds is equivalent to some metric geometry .
this reconciles the idea of an area metric spacetime with the phenomenological fact that we can measure lengths and angles in our individual spatial sections .
paying tribute to the phenomenal success of the metric description of spacetime in general relativity , we have constructed curvature invariants that are downward compatible to their metric counterparts .
crucial for this achievement was the extraction of an effective spacetime metric from the fundamental area metric data .
the availability of an area metric curvature scalar , which reduces to the metric ricci tensor precisely for a metric - induced area metric , in particular allows us to read the einstein - hilbert action as dynamics for an area metric .
remarkably , the equations of motion , derived by variation with respect to the area metric , are of second differential order .
this circumvention of lovelock s theorem @xcite ( which for metric manifolds asserts that standard general relativity is the only geometric gravity theory with second order equations ) underlines one remarkable aspect of this modification of general relativity .
another distinguished feature is that the area metric extension of einstein gravity is rigid , in the sense that it does not use an undetermined deformation ( length ) scale to add derivative or curvature corrections to the einstein - hilbert action , see e.g. @xcite , nor does it simply add additional fields propagating on a given background metric , as do scalar tensor theories , see e.g. @xcite .
we saw that the theory is downward compatible to general relativity in vacuo : every vacuum solution of einstein s equations also solves the vacuum equations of area metric gravity . upon the inclusion of matter ,
however , solutions of einstein - hilbert gravity no longer induce solutions of area metric gravity .
a case in point is the area metric einstein - maxwell theory , which is only consistent for true area metric backgrounds . in other words , not only can electromagnetic fields propagate on an area metric background , but their backreaction requires a deviation from a purely metric spacetime .
the simplest departure from standard metric theory occurs for area metrics of almost metric type , which are determined by a metric and a single scalar .
we have shown that the vacuum equations of area metric gravity for this situation are causally well - behaved ; conformal transformation and field redefinition demonstrates their equivalence to einstein gravity coupled to a free scalar field .
it should be noted , however , that the equations arising from area metric gravity have to be interpreted without these transformations , since they are not available in the generic , not almost metric , case .
the scalar field in the almost metric setting therefore must not be regarded as a field on a metric background , but is itself part of the area metric geometry .
the consequences of this mechanism become most apparent in cosmology , which is of the almost metric type , where the scalar in fact behaves as an effective radiation fluid , unlike a standard scalar field .
an area metric structure of spacetime implies that strings , not point particles , are the minimal mechanical objects one may discuss @xcite .
an important consequence of this fact is that the notion of a fluid in cosmology has to be built on an integrable distribution of local worldsheets , rather than on a velocity field for worldlines .
we have discussed string fluids arising in this way , and shown that they covariantly describe any collection of matter fields consistent with area metric cosmology .
so string fluids can be seen as matter averaged over large scales .
we find a remarkable correspondence between , on the one hand , area metric cosmology coupled to the most general consistent string fluid , and , on the other hand , einstein cosmology coupled to a standard perfect fluid .
the energy density and pressure of this effective perfect fluid are given in terms of four functions : the scalar and three parameters of the string fluid .
this implies an enormous freedom in the effective equation of state parameter which may , in principle , take any real value . for
the late universe one may assume that matter has spread out so much that interactions are no longer important .
we have derived exact solutions for area metric cosmology filled with string dust , i.e. , with non - interacting string fluids .
while they show some similarity to the solutions of a dust - filled einstein universe , a remarkable feature emerges that can not be realized in general relativity : independent of the spatial curvature , area metric cosmology explains the observed small late - time acceleration of our universe @xcite .
this effect is a consequence of area geometry ; it does not invoke a cosmological constant nor additional quintessence fields , see e.g. @xcite .
neither does this result depend on fine - tuning , since one of the nice features is that the acceleration automatically tends to zero with time .
so the idea of spacetime as an area metric manifold can be taken very far indeed , has a common conceptual basis in the structure of string and gauge theory , and provides a very encouraging first cosmological prediction , too .
but , as can be expected from any novel theoretical framework , a number of open ends remains to be addressed .
the most pressing one from a phenomenological point of view is whether area metric gravity passes solar system tests .
this question is certainly solvable , but complicated by the fact that a spherically symmetric area metric is generically not almost metric , but contains one further scalar degree of freedom .
while we have shown that every vacuum solution of einstein gravity , i.e. , in particular the schwarzschild solution , induces a vacuum solution of area metric gravity , it is not clear whether this vacuum solution consistently extends to a solution with matter having learnt that the inclusion of matter may require deviations from metric geometry . in the metric case life is simpler because of birkhoff s theorem .
another such physical issue is the discussion of fermions , which might be introduced by their dirac algebra with respect to the effective metric . on the mathematical side , a precise understanding of the degrees of freedom united in the area
metric is needed .
this includes in particular the connection to string theory , where true area metrics emerge as combinations of a metric and a two - form potential .
this problem is likely related to the question of possible relations between area metric geometry and generalized geometries emerging in string theory , such as generalized complex geometry @xcite or t - folds @xcite .
if one ventures to consider an area metric spacetime structure as a geometrization of the string idea , which we feel is structurally quite natural , one ultimately has to find out how to quantize strings on an area metric background ; given that the trace anomaly in quantized string theory is determined essentially by the two - dimensional worldsheet curvature @xcite and that the area metric curvature vanishes in two - dimensions , one may for instance speculate that a successful string quantization based on area metric geometry modifies the standard no - ghost theorems @xcite .
a detailed investigation of these issues is of course needed , and remains the subject of future work .
in this appendix we lay down our conventions for the coordinate representations of objects and operations .
let @xmath16 be a @xmath0-dimensional smooth manifold and @xmath495 a basis of @xmath20 .
this basis canonically induces the basis @xmath496 of @xmath497 which is of dimension @xmath498 .
any section @xmath57 of @xmath497 can be expanded in this basis in the following form , @xmath499 which defines the components of @xmath57 .
note that we adhere to the convention that sums over numbered indices @xmath500 , _ only _ on totally _
anti_-symmetric objects , are ordered sums over @xmath501 . as an immediate consequence of this convention we find the components of exterior products of sections @xmath502 and @xmath503 : @xmath504}\,.\ ] ] a basis @xmath505 of @xmath83 induces the canonical basis @xmath506 of @xmath507 which is dual to ( [ basis1 ] ) if @xmath505 is dual to @xmath495 , in which case @xmath508}_{b_k]}\,,\ ] ] where the right hand side are precisely the components of the identity on @xmath497 .
we also define contraction symbols for @xmath509 and @xmath510 : @xmath511 for k - forms @xmath512 we define the exterior derivative such that @xmath513}\epsilon^{a_1}\wedge\dots\wedge\epsilon^{a_{k+1}}\,.\ ] ]
this appendix contains full technical detail of the derivation of the equations of motion of area metric gravity in four dimensions .
these are obtained from variation , with respect to the inverse area metric , of the action @xmath350 proposed in ( [ totalaction ] ) in section [ gravtheory ] .
this action contains , through the area metric curvature tensor ( [ areacurv ] ) , covariant derivatives of the @xmath157-tensors , which we remove by partial integration . for this purpose note that covariant derivatives involving the tangent bundle connection @xmath215 integrated over the area manifold are no longer surface terms , since the area metric is not covariantly constant under this connection .
instead the following formula holds for partial integration : @xmath514 where @xmath515 . using this result
we obtain the four - dimensional action in the alternative form @xmath516 which is classically equivalent to the original action on manifolds without boundary . as a shorthand
we have used the definition @xmath517 in contracting the @xmath157-tensors , where deltas with multiple indices simply denote products of single deltas , e.g. @xmath518 .
we proceed to vary the action ( [ varyac ] ) with respect to the area metric , which is determined by its decomposition into the irreducible algebraic curvature tensor @xmath28 and the scalar @xmath148 as in ( [ scheme ] ) .
the calculation is not difficult , but rather long , and will be presented in several steps .
we begin with a variation with respect to the effective metric @xmath146 , which of course still depends both on @xmath28 , via the fresnel tensor , and on @xmath148 via the chosen natural section @xmath142 of the cotangent bundle .
the dependence on the effective metric in all covariant derivatives @xmath215 , also in the tensors @xmath157 , has to be taken account .
variation of the levi - civita connection and of the corresponding riemann curvature tensor with respect to a given metric are standard .
we explicitly provide these variations with respect to the inverse metric .
then , for connection and curvature [ h1 ] @xmath519 where we use another notational shorthand , @xmath520 the same remark as above applies for deltas with multiple indices .
the variation of the @xmath157-tensor with respect to the effective metric follows as @xmath521}_{t|j]}\right)\nabla^{lc}_x\delta g_g^{\alpha\beta}\,.\label{h3}\ ] ] employing these relations and performing all necessary partial integrations one hence obtains the expression @xmath522}_{t|j ] } \right)\right ) \nonumber\\ & & { } - \frac{1}{6}\left(\delta^{xw}_{\alpha\beta}-g_g^{xw}g_{g\,\alpha\beta}\right)\left(\nabla^{lc}_xx_w+\frac{1}{6}x_xx_w\right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] our second step is the variation of the action with respect to all explicitly occurring area metrics ; these appear in the volume form , and also in the @xmath157-tensors .
explicitly we have @xmath523 application of these two identities finally yields the expression @xmath524 in order to obtain the full variation of the action , we last but not least have to consider the dependence of the effective metric and of the area metric itself on the irreducible parts @xmath28 and @xmath148 of the area metric , and then to combine all terms . for the area metric
we find @xmath525 the expressions for the effective metric are more elaborate . in our mainly plus signature convention these are given by @xmath526 and @xmath527 where the characteristic function @xmath92 evaluated on the section @xmath142 , see ( [ character ] ) , appears .
we also use the abbreviations @xmath528 , @xmath529 and @xmath530 .
the final result for the combined terms resulting from the total variation of the action @xmath531 may now be written in the simple form @xmath532 note that in reaching this result another partial integration has to be performed on the terms arising from the variation @xmath533 . the final result for @xmath282
is then given by the expression @xmath534 the almost final result for @xmath280 is given by the following expression @xmath535 which , however , does not yet have the correct symmetry structure : @xmath536 to obtain the correct @xmath280 note that this term must have the symmetries of an algebraic curvature tensor since these symmetries are imposed by its contraction with @xmath537 in equation ( [ result ] ) . to correct procedure
thus is to project onto this irreducible representation by removing the totally antisymmetric part : @xmath538 the positive sign between both terms is a consequence of the lorentzian signature .
finally , we arrive at the vacuum gravity equations for four - dimensional area metric manifolds .
vanishing variation @xmath539 with respect to the inverse area metric implies the following two equations , corresponding to its cyclic and totally antisymmetric parts , respectively : @xmath540
in section [ solar ] we have discussed almost metric area metrics @xmath291 , which are determined by a metric and scalar field , as those closest to standard lorentzian manifolds . for this rather simple case
occurs a significant simplification of the four - dimensional equations of motion that have been derived in detail in the preceding section .
we will now present this simplification in some more detail as a basis for our discussion of area metric cosmology in the main text . essentially because of the simple form ( [ metricfresnel ] ) of the fresnel tensor in the almost metric case , we find that the inner bracket in the @xmath148-variation , see @xmath282 in ( [ vphi ] ) , is identically zero , and hence its derivative is .
hence @xmath541 in vacuo this expression must vanish by equation ( [ vac ] ) , which simply requires that @xmath542 should be an algebraic curvature tensor . a similarly drastic simplification occurs for the variation with respect to @xmath28 .
we expand all terms that multiply @xmath543 in equation ( [ vcalmost ] ) , while at the same time imposing the algebraic curvature tensor symmetries on the indices @xmath355 .
this results in @xmath544\beta}+\frac{1}{2}\delta^{(ab)}_{\alpha[\gamma}g_{g\,\delta]\beta}\,.\ ] ] the simplified form of the @xmath28-equation then follows as @xmath545\beta}+\frac{1}{2}v_{g_g\,[\alpha[\gamma}g_{g\,\delta]\beta]}\nonumber\\ & & { } + \frac{1}{12}\phi k^\phi g_{g\,\alpha[\gamma}g_{g\,\delta]\beta}+v_{g\,\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}+\frac{1}{24}k^\phi\omega_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the antisymmetrization in the second term is supposed to act only on the index pairs @xmath356 $ ] and @xmath546 $ ] .
this equation indeed has the symmetries of an algebraic curvature tensor ; this is ensured by the addition of the last term which removes the totally antisymmetric part of @xmath542 .
the inverse @xmath547 of @xmath151 has already been displayed in ( [ invlift ] ) .
this expression immediately enables us to calculate the @xmath157-tensor as @xmath548}_{cd}\right).\ ] ] we now have all the information needed to further simplify the above expressions for @xmath282 and @xmath280 in the almost metric case . for the @xmath148-variation
we simply find @xmath549 the @xmath28-variation @xmath280 which is a rank four tensor turns out to conform to a very particular structure .
it is in fact induced from a symmetric rank two tensor @xmath293 as shown in equation ( [ factorized ] ) , where @xmath550 our main application of these expressions in this paper is to area metric cosmology .
+ d. n. spergel _ et al . _
[ wmap collaboration ] , astrophys .
j. suppl .
* 148 * ( 2003 ) 175 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0302209 ] .
r. a. knop _ et al . _ [ supernova cosmology project collaboration ] , astrophys .
j. * 598 * ( 2003 ) 102 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0309368 ] . i. t. drummond and s. j. hathrell , phys .
d * 22 * ( 1980 ) 343 .
f. p. schuller and m. n. r. wohlfarth , jhep * 0602 * , 059 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0511157 ] .
e. s. fradkin and a. a. tseytlin , phys .
b * 163 * ( 1985 ) 123 .
a. abouelsaood , c. g. callan , c. r. nappi and s. a. yost , nucl .
b * 280 * ( 1987 ) 599 .
e. bergshoeff , e. sezgin , c. n. pope and p. k. townsend , phys .
* 188b * ( 1987 ) 70 .
r. g. leigh , mod .
lett . a * 4 * , 2767 ( 1989 ) .
a. ashtekar , phys .
lett . * 57 * , 2244 ( 1986 ) . c. rovelli and l. smolin , nucl .
b * 331 * , 80 ( 1990 ) . c. rovelli and l. smolin , nucl .
b * 442 * , 593 ( 1995 ) [ erratum - ibid .
b * 456 * , 753 ( 1995 ) ] [ arxiv : gr - qc/9411005 ] .
f. p. schuller and m. n. r. wohlfarth , nucl . phys .
b * 747 * , 398 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0508170 ] .
s. kachru , m. b. schulz , p. k. tripathy and s. p. trivedi , jhep * 0303 * ( 2003 ) 061 [ arxiv : hep - th/0211182 ] .
s. hellerman , j. mcgreevy and b. williams , jhep * 0401 * ( 2004 ) 024 [ arxiv : hep - th/0208174 ] .
s. gurrieri , j. louis , a. micu and d. waldram , nucl .
b * 654 * ( 2003 ) 61 [ arxiv : hep - th/0211102 ] .
s. fidanza , r. minasian and a. tomasiello , commun .
* 254 * ( 2005 ) 401 [ arxiv : hep - th/0311122 ] .
a. dabholkar and c. hull , jhep * 0309 * ( 2003 ) 054 [ arxiv : hep - th/0210209 ] .
c. m. hull and a. catal - ozer , jhep * 0310 * ( 2003 ) 034 [ arxiv : hep - th/0308133 ] .
a. flournoy , b. wecht and b. williams , nucl .
b * 706 * ( 2005 ) 127 [ arxiv : hep - th/0404217 ] .
n. hitchin , quart . j. math .
oxford ser .
* 54 * ( 2003 ) 281 [ arxiv : math.dg/0209099 ] .
m. gualtieri , _ generalized complex geometry _
, oxford university dphil thesis , [ arxiv : math.dg/0401221 ] . c. m. hull , jhep * 0510 * ( 2005 ) 065 [ arxiv : hep - th/0406102 ] .
a. dabholkar and c. hull , jhep * 0605 * ( 2006 ) 009 [ arxiv : hep - th/0512005 ] .
m. grana , r. minasian , m. petrini and a. tomasiello , jhep * 0408 * ( 2004 ) 046 [ arxiv : hep - th/0406137 ] .
m. grana , j. louis and d. waldram , arxiv : hep - th/0505264 .
p. koerber , jhep * 0508 * ( 2005 ) 099 [ arxiv : hep - th/0506154 ] .
r. zucchini , jhep * 0503 * ( 2005 ) 022 [ arxiv : hep - th/0501062 ] .
m. zabzine , arxiv : hep - th/0605148 .
r. a. reid - edwards , arxiv : hep - th/0610263 .
grange and s. schafer - nameki , arxiv : hep - th/0609084 .
k. becker , m. becker , c. vafa and j. walcher , arxiv : hep - th/0611001 . c. lammerzahl and f. w. hehl , phys .
d * 70 * ( 2004 ) 105022 [ arxiv : gr - qc/0409072 ] .
f. w. hehl and y. n. obukhov , found .
* 35 * ( 2005 ) 2007 [ arxiv : physics/0404101 ] .
f. w. hehl , yu . n. obukhov , g. f. rubilar and m. blagojevic , phys .
lett . a * 347 * ( 2005 ) 14 [ arxiv : gr - qc/0506042 ] .
a. peres , ann .
* 19 * ( 1962 ) 279 .
this continues the canonical approach of @xcite , whereas an example of additional structure is provided by multi - metric backgrounds interpreted as an area metric @xcite .
m. abate and g. patrizio , _ finsler metrics a global approach _ , lecture notes in mathematics * 1591 * , springer , berlin 1994 .
e. cartan , _ les espaces mtriques fonds sur la notion daire _ , hermann , paris 1933 .
w. barthel , math .
annalen * 137 * ( 1959 ) 42 .
f. brickell , can .
j. math .
* 90 * ( 1968 ) 540 .
e. t. davies , aequ . math .
* 7 * ( 1972 ) 173 .
e. t. davies , atti accad .
linzei * 53 * ( 1973 ) 389 . l. tamssy , rep .
* 36 * ( 1995 ) 453 .
c. j. isham , _ modern differential geometry for physicists _ , world scientific lecture notes * 61 * , world scientific , singapore 1999 .
j. k. beem , p. ehrlich and k. easley , _ global lorentzian geometry _ , 2nd ed .
, marcel dekker , new york 1996 .
d. lovelock , j. math .
* 12 * ( 1971 ) 498 .
d. lovelock , j. math .
* 13 * ( 1972 ) 874 .
r. s. palais , comm .
math.physics * 69 * ( 1979 ) 19 .
d. n. vollick , phys .
d * 68 * ( 2003 ) 063510 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0306630 ] .
s. m. carroll , a. de felice , v. duvvuri , d. a. easson , m. trodden and m. s. turner , phys .
d * 71 * ( 2005 ) 063513 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0410031 ] .
f. p. schuller and m. n. r. wohlfarth , nucl .
b * 698 * ( 2004 ) 319 [ arxiv : hep - th/0403056 ] .
f. p. schuller and m. n. r. wohlfarth , phys .
b * 612 * ( 2005 ) 93 [ arxiv : gr - qc/0411076 ] .
s. nojiri and s. d. odintsov , arxiv : hep - th/0610164 .
r. punzi , f. p. schuller and m. n. r. wohlfarth , arxiv : gr - qc/0605017 . n. bartolo and m. pietroni , phys .
d * 61 * ( 2000 ) 023518 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9908521 ] .
a. a. coley , gen .
* 31 * ( 1999 ) 1295 [ arxiv : astro - ph/9910395 ] .
g. esposito - farese and d. polarski , phys .
d * 63 * ( 2001 ) 063504 [ arxiv : gr - qc/0009034 ] . w. graf , arxiv : gr - qc/0602054 . s. m. carroll , phys . rev . lett . * 81 * ( 1998 ) 3067 [ arxiv : astro - ph/9806099 ] .
i. zlatev , l. m. wang and p. j. steinhardt , phys .
* 82 * ( 1999 ) 896 [ arxiv : astro - ph/9807002 ] .
s. hellerman , n. kaloper and l. susskind , jhep * 0106 * ( 2001 ) 003 [ arxiv : hep - th/0104180 ] .
a. m. polyakov , phys .
b * 103 * ( 1981 ) 207 .
p. goddard , j. goldstone , c. rebbi and c. b. thorn , nucl .
b * 56*(1973 ) 109 .
a. m. polyakov , phys .
b * 103 * ( 1981 ) 211 . | area metric manifolds emerge as effective classical backgrounds in quantum string theory and quantum gauge theory , and present a true generalization of metric geometry . here , we consider area metric manifolds in their own right , and develop in detail the foundations of area metric differential geometry . based on the construction of an area metric curvature scalar , which reduces in the metric - induced case to the ricci scalar ,
we re - interpret the einstein - hilbert action as dynamics for an area metric spacetime .
in contrast to modifications of general relativity based on metric geometry , no continuous deformation scale needs to be introduced ; the extension to area geometry is purely structural and thus rigid .
we present an intriguing prediction of area metric gravity : without dark energy or fine - tuning , the late universe exhibits a small acceleration . |
let @xmath1 be a knot in the @xmath2-sphere @xmath3
. then we denote by @xmath4 the @xmath2-manifold obtained by @xmath5-surgery on @xmath1 , i.e. , by attaching a solid torus to @xmath6int@xmath7 in such a way that @xmath5 bounds a meridian disk of the filling solid torus . using the preferred meridian - longitude pair of @xmath8 ,
we parametrize slopes @xmath5 of @xmath1 by @xmath9 ; then we also write @xmath10 for @xmath11 .
we begin by recalling berge s @xcite construction , an explicit construction which yields several infinite families of knots each admitting a lens space dehn surgery .
let @xmath1 be a knot contained in a genus two heegaard surface @xmath12 for @xmath3 , i.e. , @xmath13 , where @xmath14 and @xmath15 denote genus two handlebodies .
suppose that @xmath1 is nontrivial and that the manifolds @xmath16 and @xmath17 are both solid tori , where @xmath16 ( resp .
@xmath17 ) is obtained by attaching a @xmath18-handle to @xmath14 ( resp .
@xmath15 ) along @xmath1 . the isotopy class in @xmath19 of the curve(s ) in @xmath20 is called the _ surface slope _ of @xmath1 with respect to @xmath12 . then by performing dehn surgery on @xmath1 along the surface slope @xmath5
, we obtain a @xmath2-manifold @xmath21 , which is a lens space .
it can not be @xmath22 by @xcite , nor @xmath3 by @xcite .
this construction is called _
berge s construction _ or the _ primitive / primitive construction _ and such a knot @xmath1 is said to be _ primitive / primitive _ with respect to @xmath12
. in @xcite berge suggested the following .
see also @xcite .
[ berge ] if @xmath11 is a lens space , then this surgery arises from berge s construction .
dean @xcite , @xcite made a natural modification to berge s construction ; suppose that @xmath1 is as before except that @xmath17 is now a seifert fiber space over the disk with two exceptional fibers .
then for the surface slope @xmath5 , @xmath11 is a seifert fiber space over @xmath23 with at most three exceptional fibers or a connected sum of two lens spaces . if @xmath1 is hyperbolic , then the cabling conjecture @xcite states that the latter can not occur .
this construction is called _
dean s construction _ or the _ primitive / seifert - fibered construction _ and such a knot @xmath1 is said to be _ primitive / seifert - fibered _ with respect to @xmath12 .
the notion of primitive / seifert - fibered construction has been slightly generalized by allowing the possibility that @xmath17 is a seifert fiber space over the mbius band with one exceptional fiber @xcite , @xcite . in the following ,
we use the term primitive / seifert - fibered construction ( or knot ) in this generalized sense .
in analogy with conjecture [ berge ] , dean @xcite and gordon @xcite asked : [ dean ] if @xmath11 is a seifert fiber space other than a lens space , then does this surgery arise from a primitive / seifert - fibered construction ?
many examples of seifert fibered surgeries ( see , for example , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and @xcite ) have been constructed using the montesinos trick ( @xcite , @xcite ) .
recently , in @xcite , eudave - muoz has shown that all known examples of seifert fibered surgeries constructed by the montesinos trick can be explained by dean s construction .
furthermore , seifert fibered surgeries on twisted torus knots in @xcite can also be explained by such constructions @xcite .
on the other hand , in the present note we demonstrate the following which answers the question above in the negative .
a knot @xmath1 is _ strongly invertible _ if there is an orientation preserving involution of @xmath3 which leaves @xmath1 invariant and reverses an orientation of @xmath1 ; primitive / seifert - fibered knots are shown to be strongly invertible .
[ non - p / s ] there is an infinite family of non - strongly invertible knots each of which admits a seifert fibered surgery with none of these surgeries arising from the primitive / seifert - fibered construction .
for example , the @xmath0-pretzel knot belongs to the family .
very recently hyung - jong song has observed that the 1-surgery of the @xmath24-pretzel knot is a seifert fibered surgery , but does not arise from the primitive / seifert - fibered construction .
in contrast with our examples , the @xmath24-pretzel knot is strongly invertible ; but it has cyclic period @xmath18 and tunnel number greater than one like ours . in his thesis @xcite , the first author observed that the @xmath25-pretzel knot has a small seifert fibered surgery by experiments via weeks computer program snappea .
this observation is the starting point of our study .
* acknowledgements * the first author wishes to thank steven boyer and jinha jun for helpful conversations .
we would like to thank the referee for careful reading and useful comments .
we shall say that a seifert fiber space is of _ type _
@xmath26 if it has a seifert fibration over @xmath23 with three exceptional fibers of indices @xmath27 and @xmath28 @xmath29 .
* example 1 .
* let @xmath30 be the two component link of figure [ fig : fig1 ] .
here @xmath1 is the montesinos knot given by the triple of rational tangles @xmath31 , which is often called the @xmath25-pretzel knot .
( we adopt bleiler s convention @xcite on the parametrization of rational tangles . )
let @xmath32 ( @xmath33 is possibly zero ) be the knot obtained from @xmath1 by performing @xmath34-surgery on @xmath35 .
equivalently , @xmath32 is obtained by doing @xmath33-twisting along @xmath35 .
then @xmath32 enjoys the following properties . 1 .
@xmath32 is a hyperbolic knot , 2 .
@xmath32 has cyclic period @xmath18 , but is not strongly invertible , 3 .
the tunnel number of @xmath32 is @xmath18 , and 4 .
@xmath36 is a seifert fiber space of type @xmath37 . before verifying properties ( 1)(4 )
we observe that @xmath38 is the family of theorem [ non - p / s ] .
_ proof of theorem _ [ non - p / s ] .
properties ( 2 ) and ( 4 ) show that @xmath32 is not strongly invertible and admits a seifert fibered surgery .
assume for a contradiction that @xmath32 is primitive / seifert - fibered ; then @xmath39 is a solid torus for an unknotted genus @xmath18 handlebody @xmath14 with @xmath40 .
first we show that @xmath32 has tunnel number @xmath41 following @xcite .
by @xcite , there is a homeomorphism of the genus two handlebody @xmath14 after which @xmath32 appears as in figure [ fig : fig2 ] . after pushing @xmath32 into @xmath14 ,
take an arc @xmath42 as in figure [ fig : fig2 ]
. then @xmath43 is the product of a surface and an interval .
thus @xmath44 is a genus two handlebody , so the knot @xmath32 has tunnel number @xmath41 .
this then implies that @xmath32 is strongly invertible by ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 5 ) , a contradiction .
hence the seifert fibered surgery does not come from the primitive / seifert - fibered construction .
@xmath45(theorem [ non - p / s ] ) [ period2 ] @xmath32 has cyclic period @xmath18 .
_ as shown in figure [ fig : fig3 ] , let @xmath46 be the @xmath47-rotation about @xmath48 such that @xmath49 and @xmath50 .
the axis @xmath48 is disjoint from @xmath1 and intersects @xmath35 in exactly two points . hence , @xmath51int@xmath52 extends to an involution @xmath53 of @xmath54 about an axis @xmath55 such that @xmath56 and @xmath57 .
it follows that @xmath32 has cyclic period 2 .
@xmath45(claim [ period2 ] ) [ seifert ] @xmath58 is a seifert fiber space of type @xmath37 .
_ let @xmath59 denote the manifold obtained by performing a surgery on the link @xmath30 with surgery slopes @xmath41 for @xmath1 and @xmath34 for @xmath35 .
we will show that @xmath59 is a seifert fiber space of type @xmath37 . to prove this we form the quotient by the involution @xmath60 to obtain the factor knot @xmath61 , the branched knot @xmath62 which is the image of @xmath48 , and the arc @xmath63 which is the image of @xmath35 and connects two points in @xmath62 ( figure [ fig : fig4 ] ) . as shown in figure [ fig : fig4 ] , the factor knot @xmath61 is unknotted in @xmath64 . note that @xmath41-surgery on @xmath1 corresponds to @xmath65-surgery on the factor knot @xmath61 which is equivalent to @xmath66-twisting along @xmath61 because @xmath61 is unknotted ; see figure [ fig : fig6 ] .
we denote the image of @xmath62 after @xmath66-twisting along @xmath61 by @xmath67 .
note also that by the montesinos trick ( @xcite , @xcite ) , @xmath34-surgery on @xmath35 corresponds to @xmath34-untangle surgery ( i.e. , a replacement of a @xmath68-untangle by a @xmath34-untangle ) on @xmath67 along @xmath63 as indicated in figure [ fig : fig8 ] . in order to correctly perform the untangle surgery , we keep track of the framing .
this can be done by indicating a band @xmath69 whose core is @xmath63 ; see figure [ fig : fig4 ] .
( for simplicity , we indicate the band @xmath69 in only two places : just after taking the quotient by the involution @xmath70 , and just before performing the untangle surgery . ) by an isotopy as in figures [ fig : fig6 ] and [ fig : fig7 ] , we see that @xmath67 is the montesinos knot given by the triple of rational tangles @xmath71 . denote the result of @xmath34-untangle surgery on @xmath67 by @xmath72 ( figure [ fig : fig8 ] ) .
then @xmath72 is the montesinos knot given by the triple of rational tangles @xmath73 , and the branched covering space @xmath59 of @xmath3 branched along @xmath72 is a seifert fiber space of type @xmath74 .
since the linking number of @xmath1 and @xmath35 is zero , the @xmath41-slope of @xmath1 corresponds to the @xmath41-slope of @xmath32 , and hence @xmath75 .
it follows that @xmath58 is a seifert fiber space of type @xmath74 as required .
@xmath45(claim [ seifert ] ) . ] . ] . ]
[ hyperbolic ] @xmath32 is a hyperbolic knot .
_ the knot @xmath1 bounds an obvious seifert surface @xmath76 of genus one .
since @xmath35 can be isotoped off @xmath76 , after doing @xmath33-twisting along @xmath35 @xmath76 becomes a seifert surface for @xmath32 . by claim [ seifert ]
, @xmath32 is a nontrivial knot and thus @xmath77 , the genus of @xmath32 , is equal to one .
assume for a contradiction that @xmath32 is a satellite knot .
then since @xmath36 is atoroidal , @xmath32 has a companion solid torus @xmath78 whose core is a simple knot @xmath79 such that @xmath32 is a @xmath80 or @xmath41-bridge braid in @xmath78 ( ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 2.2(1 ) ) ) . from schubert s formula @xcite ( (
* proposition 2.10 ) ) we have @xmath81 , where @xmath82 denotes the winding number of @xmath32 in @xmath78 . since @xmath83 and @xmath84 , we have @xmath85 , a contradiction . if @xmath32 is a torus knot , then since the genus is one , @xmath32 is a @xmath86-torus knot @xmath87 .
however @xmath88 ( resp .
@xmath89 ) is a seifert fiber space of type @xmath90 ( resp .
@xmath91 ) , contradicting claim [ seifert ] .
it follows that @xmath32 is a hyperbolic knot .
@xmath45(claim [ hyperbolic ] ) [ non - invertible ] @xmath32 is not strongly invertible .
_ recall that @xmath32 has cyclic period @xmath18 and that @xmath58 is a seifert fiber space of type @xmath74 ( claim [ seifert ] ) .
since @xmath92 and @xmath93 , if @xmath32 is strongly invertible , then by ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1.7(1 ) ) , @xmath32 is a torus knot or a cable of a torus knot .
this contradicts @xmath32 being hyperbolic ( claim [ hyperbolic ] ) .
therefore @xmath32 is not strongly invertible . @xmath45(claim
[ non - invertible ] ) [ tunnel number ] the tunnel number of @xmath32 is two . _
proof_. let @xmath14 be a handlebody in @xmath3 which is obtained by thickening the obvious genus one seifert surface for @xmath1 .
then @xmath94 is a genus 2 heegaard surface for @xmath3 which contains @xmath1 .
since @xmath35 is a core of a handlebody @xmath14 , @xmath14 remains a handlebody after @xmath34-surgery on @xmath35 .
it follows that @xmath32 is embedded in a genus 2 heegaard surface @xmath12 .
then , by ( * ? ? ?
* fact on p.138 ) the tunnel number of @xmath32 is less than or equal to @xmath18 . on the other hand , since a tunnel number one knot is strongly invertible ( ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 5 ) ) , claim [ non - invertible ] implies that the tunnel number of @xmath32 is two .
@xmath45(claim [ tunnel number ] ) * example 2 .
* the second example is a variant of example 1 .
let us consider the trivial knot @xmath95 of figure [ fig : fig9 ] below , instead of @xmath35 of figure [ fig : fig1 ] .
let @xmath96 be the knot obtained from @xmath1 by doing @xmath33-twisting along @xmath95 .
then the argument in the proof of claim [ seifert ] shows that @xmath97 is a seifert fiber space of type @xmath98 ; see figures [ fig : fig10][fig : fig13 ] .
the arguments in the proofs of claims [ period2 ] , [ hyperbolic ] , [ non - invertible ] and [ tunnel number ] show that the @xmath96 also enjoy the same properties as in example 1 , and that the seifert fibered surgeries do not come from the primitive / seifert - fibered construction . .
] . ] .
in @xcite it has been conjectured that if @xmath10 is a seifert fiber space , then it admits a seifert fibration such that one of its fibers is unknotted in @xmath99the original@xmath100 @xmath3 . for our knots
@xmath32 ( resp .
@xmath96 ) , the trivial knot @xmath101 which is the dual of @xmath35 ( i.e. , the core knot of @xmath34-filling along @xmath35 ) ( resp . @xmath102 which is the dual of @xmath95 ) becomes an exceptional fiber of index @xmath103 in @xmath36 ( resp .
an exceptional fiber of index @xmath104 in @xmath97 ) .
thus the dehn surgeries described in examples 1 and 2 satisfy the conjecture .
( song s example mentioned in the introduction also satisfies the conjecture . )
we also mention a geometric aspect of seifert fibered surgeries on hyperbolic knots . it was observed in ( * ? ? ?
* section 7 ) that short closed geodesics in hyperbolic knot complements are often unknotted in @xmath3 and become seifert fibers in the resulting seifert fiber spaces after dehn surgery .
an experiment via weeks computer program snappea @xcite suggests the table below , where @xmath1 is the @xmath25-pretzel knot , and @xmath35 , @xmath95 are trivial knots described in figures 1 and 9 .
recall that @xmath105 is a seifert fiber space of type @xmath106 .
we conclude this paper with some questions .
although the knots given in examples 1 and 2 can not be primitive / seifert - fibered for any genus two heegaard surface , they are still embedded in a genus two heegaard surface for @xmath3 .
we would like to ask : m. eudave - muoz ; non - hyperbolic manifolds obtained by dehn surgery on a hyperbolic knot , in : studies in advanced mathematics vol . * 2 * , part 1 , ( ed .
w. kazez ) , 1997 , amer .
soc . and international press , pp . 3561 .
d. gabai ; foliations and the topology of 3-manifolds iii , j. diff .
* 26 * ( 1987 ) , 479536 .
f. gonzlez - acua and h. short ; knot surgery and primeness , math .
* 99 * ( 1986 ) , 89102 . | we construct two infinite families of knots each of which admits a seifert fibered surgery with none of these surgeries coming from dean s primitive / seifert - fibered construction .
this disproves a conjecture that all seifert fibered surgeries arise from dean s primitive / seifert - fibered construction .
the @xmath0-pretzel knot belongs to both of the infinite families . |
although finite - temperature field theory provides the natural framework to describe thermodynamic properties and phase transitions in plasmas involving gauge fields , its perturbative realization faces dreadful obstacles produced by severe infrared divergences in the gauge sector @xcite . in the case of quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) at finite temperature @xmath5 , where the theory is defined in @xmath11 and the compact direction in @xmath12 lies along the euclidean time with period @xmath4 , one can say that the domain of validity of the _ naive _ , plain perturbation expansion is tremendously restricted @xcite ( see also refs .
@xcite ) . along the years , this difficulty stimulated the development of techniques that reorganize the perturbative series , improving significantly the weak - coupling expansion ( for reviews , see refs .
@xcite ) . in particular
, one can build an effective theory by using the separation of scales provided by @xmath5 , @xmath13 , and @xmath14 , which is known as dimensionally reduced effective theory , or electrostatic qcd ( eqcd ) @xcite .
the pressure , for instance , is currently known up to @xmath15 at high temperatures and at most moderate chemical potentials @xmath16 @xcite .
alternatively , one can resort to the hard thermal loop ( htl ) framework @xcite ( see ref .
@xcite for recent results ) .
nevertheless , at order @xmath17 in the gauge coupling of a non - abelian gauge theory at finite temperature , it is well known that perturbation theory breaks down due to infrared divergences in the magnetic sector , the notorious linde problem @xcite .
therefore , to implement eqcd one is then obliged to match the coefficients of the order @xmath17 to computations in lattice qcd in three dimensions @xcite .
the compactification brought about by the finite temperature framework is the key ingredient responsible for the linde problem since the static large distance behavior of the gauge theory at high @xmath5 is the same as in 3-dimensional gauge theory , which confines at the scale @xmath18 . on the other hand , at zero temperature and finite density the fermi sea does not produce dimensional reduction and this infrared problem is absent @xcite .
therefore , it is interesting to investigate how the linde problem may be affected when thermal yang - mills theory is subjected to an additional compactification along a spatial direction 4-dimensional thermal gauge theories defined in compact spaces , such as @xmath19 , have been studied in @xcite . ] . in this note
we investigate the case of a pure glue @xmath0 plasma on a torus given by @xmath20 , with @xmath7 being the length of the compactified spatial direction . by construction , this system is symmetric under the mapping @xmath21 and @xmath22 , which we denominate _ radius exchange symmetry_. a double trace deformation @xcite of this theory in the limit of large number of colors was used in @xcite to understand the interplay between the color electric and magnetic sectors in the deconfinement phase transition @xcite . here
we show that in this theory linde s problem is much more severe and any perturbative calculation breaks down already at order @xmath9 due to the presence of a non - perturbative scale @xmath10 .
therefore , observables in this theory ( such as the pressure or screening masses ) can only be computed non - perturbatively even when the gauge coupling is arbitrarily small .
this paper is organized as follows . in section [ oldlinde ]
we summarize the main aspects behind linde s original argument . in section [ newlinde ]
we discuss the relevant properties of the perturbative yang - mills plasma on @xmath20 and the different regimes of the theory including the full breakdown of perturbation theory in this context . in section [ conclusion ]
we present our final remarks and outlook .
in his seminal 1980 paper @xcite , linde argued that the perturbative study of yang - mills theory defined in @xmath23 is extremely problematic due to severe infrared divergences .
notably , perturbation theory for the pressure breaks down at order @xmath24 . for completeness
, we briefly review linde s argument in the sequel .
+ let us consider the contribution to the pressure from the @xmath25-loop diagram depicted in fig .
[ fig : linde_diagram ] .
the leading infrared ( ir ) behavior comes from taking the matsubara zero mode for every line ; all other modes act as effective ir regulators . for the argument , it is sufficient to estimate its contribution to the pressure using a simple power counting strategy @xcite . in this spirit
, we can neglect its tensorial structure and write this zero mode contribution schematically in the form @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the gluon 4-momentum and @xmath28 is the matsubara frequency .
the origin of each factor is easy to trace : vertices contribute with @xmath29 , lines with a propagator @xmath30 , and loops with an integral . in order to estimate the contribution from this diagram
, we take @xmath5 as an ultraviolet cutoff since it would naturally arise if we were to sum over all matsubara frequencies due to the presence of statistical factors .
also , as the diagrams are potentially ir divergent , one can not take arbitrarily soft modes into account ; we only integrate over momentum above a lower threshold @xmath31 .
the diagrams are ir regular for @xmath32 and divergent for @xmath33 .
namely , the dominant behavior for different values of @xmath34 are @xcite [ eq : linde_result ] @xmath35 in perturbation theory , the coupling @xmath36 and the scale @xmath5 provide a natural hierarchy of energy scales : @xmath37 . using such hierarchy as a guideline
, one can push @xmath31 deeper and deeper towards the ir region .
. shows that when @xmath31 reaches @xmath38 all diagrams with @xmath39 contribute at @xmath24 .
in other words , perturbation theory breaks down since infinitely many diagrams have to be considered at a finite order , even if @xmath36 is taken to be arbitrarily small .
the reasoning above ignores the possibility of screening masses being dynamically generated and , as a matter of fact , they are present in thermal yang - mills theory @xcite . in this context , a screening mass would work as a natural ir regulator , essentially playing the role of @xmath31 in eq . .
in the color electric sector , ir modes are screened as @xmath40 . on the other hand , from eq .
one can see that a color magnetic mass @xmath41 makes all loops @xmath42 contribute to @xmath24 , which is interpreted as the breakdown of the perturbative expansion .
this is the so - called linde problem of thermal yang - mills theory .
now we consider pure glue @xmath0 yang - mills theory on @xmath20 .
we define our coordinates as @xmath43 where @xmath44 corresponds to @xmath45 and @xmath46 $ ] and @xmath47 $ ] parametrize the torus .
we note that the partition function is periodic in @xmath48 _ and _ @xmath49 and all observables in this theory should be invariant under radius exchange symmetry , i.e. , @xmath50 .
the fourier decomposition of the yang - mills field is given by @xmath51 and , due to the presence of two compact dimensions , this system can be formally seen as kaluza - klein like tower of two - dimensional yang - mills theories coupled to two adjoint scalars for each one of the winding modes on the torus .
we denote @xmath52 and @xmath53 , where @xmath54 and @xmath55 represent these two adjoint scalars .
as discussed in @xcite , this theory has global @xmath56 center symmetry and two order parameters given by the wilson lines on the torus .
one may consider the behavior of this theory in certain limits of the energy scales @xmath5 and @xmath8 : * @xmath57 ( dimensional reduction ) : the adjoint scalars acquire a large mass and decouple from the low - energy effective theory , which becomes the exactly solvable two - dimensional yang - mills theory for the massless gluons along the two non - compact directions @xcite ; * @xmath58 , @xmath8 finite ( or @xmath59 , @xmath5 finite ) : one of the compact dimensions unwinds and the low - energy effective theory becomes three - dimensional yang - mills theory coupled to an adjoint scalar of mass @xmath60 ( or @xmath61 ) .
these scenarios are illustrated in fig .
[ diagrama ] . when @xmath59 , @xmath62 the two - point function of the color field tensor @xmath63 with components along the non - compact directions exhibits the usual screening for large spatial separations while when @xmath64 this correlator becomes non - propagating as in 2-dimensional yang - mills theory @xcite
. now we can address linde s problem in yang - mills theory on @xmath20 .
as before , we estimate in a power counting scheme the dominant ir contribution of the linde diagrams , shown in fig .
[ fig : linde_diagram ] . in the present case
there is not one but two compactified dimensions and , thus , in order to get the leading ir contribution we must take the zero modes associated with each circle for every line in the loop diagram .
the equivalent of eq .
is then @xmath65 as in section [ oldlinde ] , if we were to sum over all modes a natural uv cutoff would arise .
such a hard scale is given as a function of the two energy scales related to the two compact directions , which we denote by @xmath66 .
its exact dependence on @xmath8 and @xmath5 is not important for our argument though it must satisfy the radius exchange symmetry , @xmath67 .
once again , due to the potential ir divergences of the linde diagrams , we only integrate over modes above a certain ir scale @xmath31 .
the dominant ir behavior for different values of @xmath34 can be readily estimated : [ eq : linde_result_torus ] @xmath68 as the problem now has two typical scales , one can no longer build a unique hierarchy of energy scales with the aid of the coupling constant .
in fact , there are infinitely many hierarchies at our disposal , one for each possible combination of @xmath8 and @xmath5 with the proper dimension . nevertheless , for scales where @xmath69 , all linde diagrams with 3 or more loops contribute at @xmath9 , which indicates the breakdown of perturbation theory .
thus , the presence of a second compactified dimension renders the linde problem in gauge theories even more severe .
the fact that ir fluctuations have become stronger should be expected given the compact character of the space and the presence of an additional zero mode in the torus in comparison to the usual case of ym in @xmath11 . also , we note that the zero modes in the compact directions , though constant , have non - trivial commutators .
a thorough discussion about these modes is , however , beyond the scope of the present note . in the dimensional reduction limit ,
i.e. , @xmath57 , the system becomes effectively yang - mills theory in two dimensions @xcite . in this case , one can write the partition function purely in terms of the field strengths @xmath70 ( bianchi s constraint is trivial in two dimensions ) @xcite , with a simple quadratic action @xmath71 whose field strengths fluctuate on the plane independently from one another . the pressure of this system can be solved exactly @xcite and it contains a term that goes as @xmath71 and , thus , it can not be simply expanded in perturbative powers of @xmath36 at weak coupling .
we believe this may be the root behind the failure of naive perturbation theory at order @xmath72 found here for yang - mills theory on @xmath20 .
we note that 2-dimensional yang - mills theory would also appear as a limit of the original 4-dimensional theory if the torus would be replaced by any compact surface with genus one , though the explicit construction of the linde problem in this case is beyond the scope of this paper .
perturbative expansions at finite temperature are plagued with ir divergences whenever massless bosonic fields are present @xcite .
this situation is even more problematic in the case of thermal yang - mills theory since the linde problem essentially makes naive perturbation theory meaningless beyond @xmath24 . thermal field theories , in the imaginary - time formalism ,
are set in an euclidean space - time with a compact time direction . in this context
, all thermal effects are ultimately encoded in the structure of the underlying space - time ( e.g. , @xmath11 ) . in order to better understand the role played by compactification in ir problems of non - abelian gauge theories
, we included a second compact dimension and analyzed the behavior of yang - mills theory , providing an extension of linde s argument for the case where the compact part of space - time is the torus @xmath73 .
our study shows that the linde problem in this case becomes much more severe , as it already emerges at @xmath9 for the pressure .
this indicates that the perturbative expansion in yang - mills theory on @xmath20 faces important limitations since the lowest order correction to any physical observable will necessarily have a non - perturbative contribution even at arbitrarily small coupling .
however , this system could be readily studied on the lattice and it would be interesting to investigate the phase diagram of this theory , depicted in fig .
[ diagrama ] .
one could compute on the lattice the glueball correlator and see its behavior changing from the well - known description in terms of screening masses when @xmath74 to the finite @xmath75 scenario addressed in this paper .
finally , it would be interesting to see if the breakdown of perturbation theory induced by ir divergences in yang - mills theory indeed has a topological character .
one could check if other compact surfaces with genus one ( which are then topologically equivalent to the torus considered here ) produce the same qualitative results for the pressure .
while we can not rigorously prove it at this time , we conjecture that this is going to be the case because the dimensional reduction argument discussed here , which leads to 2-dimensional yang - mills theory , should also hold .
additionally , compactifications of yang - mills theory on @xmath76 , where @xmath77 is a compact surface with genus @xmath78 , may yet reveal other features that are not present in the simple torus example considered here .
the authors are indebted to r. d. pisarski and a. vuorinen for useful comments .
j. n. thanks a. dumitru for discussions .
this work was supported by capes , cnpq , faperj , and fapesp .
m. le bellac , _ thermal field theory _
( cambridge university press , 2000 ) ; j. i. kapusta and c. gale , _ finite - temperature field theory : principles and applications _
( cambridge university press , 2006 ) ; m. laine , a. vuorinen , _ basics of thermal field theory _ , lecture notes in physics ( springer international publishing switzerland , 2016 ) .
b. a. freedman and l. d. mclerran , phys .
d * 16 * , 1169 ( 1977 ) .
e. v. shuryak , sov .
jetp * 47 * , 212 ( 1978 ) [ zh . eksp
. teor .
fiz . * 74 * , 408 ( 1978 ) ] .
p. arnold and c. x. zhai , phys .
d * 50 * , 7603 ( 1994 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9408276 ] .
p. arnold and c. x. zhai , phys .
d * 51 * , 1906 ( 1995 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9410360 ] .
r. parwani and h. singh , phys .
d * 51 * , 4518 ( 1995 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9411065 ]
. k. kajantie , m. laine and y. schroder , phys .
d * 65 * , 045008 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0109100 ] .
e. braaten and a. nieto , phys .
lett . * 76 * , 1417 ( 1996 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9508406 ] .
e. braaten , nucl .
a * 702 * , 13 ( 2002 ) .
j. p. blaizot and e. iancu , phys .
rept . * 359 * , 355 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0101103 ] .
u. kraemmer and a. rebhan , rept .
phys . * 67 * , 351 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0310337 ] .
j. o. andersen and m. strickland , annals phys .
* 317 * , 281 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0404164 ] .
t. appelquist and r. d. pisarski , phys .
d * 23 * , 2305 ( 1981 ) .
k. kajantie , m. laine , k. rummukainen and m. e. shaposhnikov , nucl .
b * 458 * , 90 ( 1996 ) [ hep - ph/9508379 ] .
e. braaten and a. nieto , phys .
d * 51 * , 6990 ( 1995 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9501375 ] .
k. kajantie , m. laine , k. rummukainen and y. schroder , phys .
d * 67 * , 105008 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0211321 ] .
a. vuorinen , phys .
d * 68 * , 054017 ( 2003 ) [ hep - ph/0305183 ] .
a. hietanen , k. kajantie , m. laine , k. rummukainen and y. schroder , phys .
d * 79 * , 045018 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0811.4664 [ hep - lat ] ] .
e. braaten and r. d. pisarski , nucl .
b * 337 * , 569 ( 1990 ) .
e. braaten and r. d. pisarski , nucl . phys .
b * 339 * , 310 ( 1990 ) .
e. braaten and r. d. pisarski , phys .
d * 45 * , no .
6 , r1827 ( 1992 ) .
n. haque , a. bandyopadhyay , j. o. andersen , m. g. mustafa , m. strickland and n. su , jhep * 1405 * , 027 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1402.6907 [ hep - ph ] ] .
a. kurkela and a. vuorinen , phys .
lett . * 117 * , no . 4 , 042501 ( 2016 ) [ arxiv:1603.00750 [ hep - ph ] ] .
a. d. linde , phys .
b * 96 * , 289 ( 1980 ) .
d. j. gross , r. d. pisarski and l. g. yaffe , rev .
* 53 * , 43 ( 1981 ) .
a. hietanen , k. kajantie , m. laine , k. rummukainen and y. schroder , jhep * 0501 * , 013 ( 2005 ) [ hep - lat/0412008 ] .
a. hietanen and a. kurkela , jhep * 0611 * , 060 ( 2006 ) [ hep - lat/0609015 ] .
f. di renzo , m. laine , v. miccio , y. schroder and c. torrero , jhep * 0607 * , 026 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0605042 ] .
r. d. pisarski and d. h. rischke , phys .
lett . * 83 * , 37 ( 1999 ) [ nucl - th/9811104 ] .
d. t. son , phys . rev .
d * 59 * , 094019 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9812287 ] .
o. aharony , j. marsano , s. minwalla , k. papadodimas and m. van raamsdonk , adv .
* 8 * , 603 ( 2004 ) [ hep - th/0310285 ] .
r. d. pisarski , phys .
d * 74 * , 121703 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0608242 ] .
d. simic and m. unsal , phys .
d * 85 * , 105027 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1010.5515 [ hep - th ] ] .
j. liao and e. shuryak , phys .
c * 75 * , 054907 ( 2007 ) [ hep - ph/0611131 ] .
m. n. chernodub and v. i. zakharov , phys .
* 98 * , 082002 ( 2007 ) [ hep - ph/0611228 ] .
d. j. gross and e. witten , phys .
d * 21 * , 446 ( 1980 ) .
m. b. halpern , phys .
d * 19 * , 517 ( 1979 ) . | we investigate the perturbative expansion in @xmath0 yang - mills theory compactified on @xmath1 where the compact space is a torus @xmath2 , with @xmath3 being a thermal circle with period @xmath4 ( @xmath5 is the temperature ) while @xmath6 is a circle with length @xmath7 where @xmath8 is an energy scale .
a linde - type analysis indicates that perturbative calculations for the pressure in this theory break down already at order @xmath9 due to the presence of a non - perturbative scale @xmath10 .
we conjecture that a similar result should hold if the torus is replaced by any compact surface of genus one . |
the cauchy problem for the korteweg de vries ( kdv ) equation @xmath1 in the zero - dispersion limit has been widely studied .
the physical interest in this limit is due to the fact that it describes the phenomenon of shock waves in dissipationsless dispersive media .
dispersive shock waves are characterized by the appearance of rapid modulated oscillations .
gurevich and pitevskii @xcite suggested that these oscillations could be modeled by the solution of the one - phase whitham equations @xcite .
the multiphase or @xmath2-phase whitham equations were derived by flaschka , forest and mc laughlin @xcite .
lax and levermore @xcite rigorously showed that the multiphase whitham equations appear in the zero dispersion limit of the cauchy problem for the kdv equation with asymptotically reflectionless initial data . later venakides @xcite considered a wider class of initial data .
lax and levermore developed their theory in the frame of the zero - dispersion asymptotics for the solution of the inverse scattering problem of kdv .
they showed that the principal term of the relevant asymptotics is given by the @xmath2-phase solution @xcite of the kdv equation with the wave parameters depending on the functions @xmath3 which satisfy the @xmath2-phase whitham equations : @xmath4 for @xmath5 the speeds @xmath6 , @xmath7 , depend through @xmath8 on complete hyperelliptic integrals of genus @xmath2 .
for @xmath9 we define @xmath10 and the zero - phase whitham equation reads @xmath11 and can be integrated by the method of characteristics .
the formal integrability of equations ( [ whithamg ] ) for @xmath5 was obtained by tsarev @xcite using the geometric - hamiltonian structure @xcite of the whitham equations .
namely he proved that if the functions @xmath12 , @xmath13 , solve the linear over - determined system of equations @xmath14,\quad i , j=1,2,\dots,2g+1,\;\;i\neq j,\ ] ] where @xmath15 , are the speeds in ( [ whithamg ] ) , then the solution @xmath16 of the so called hodograph transformation @xmath17 satisfies equations ( [ whithamg ] ) .
conversely , any solution @xmath18 of ( [ whithamg ] ) can be obtained in this way in the neighborhood of @xmath19 at which @xmath20 s are not vanishing .
the general solution of the tsarev equations was obtained in @xcite,@xcite,@xcite for monotonically increasing initial data .
the key step introduced in @xcite,@xcite was to reduce the solution of the tsarev system to the solution of linear - overdetermined systems of euler - poisson darboux type for some functions @xmath21 , @xmath22 , namely @xmath23 in this paper we show that these functions play a role in the lax - levermore maximization problem .
we study the small dispersion limit of kdv for monotonically increasing analytic initial data bounded at infinity .
we use a different approach to the small dispersion limit obtained in @xcite by deift , venakides and zhou .
these authors first used the formulation of the cauchy problem for kdv as a riemann - hilbert ( rh ) problem @xcite ( see also @xcite ) .
then , for computing the small @xmath24-asymptotics , they used the steepest descent method for oscillatory riemann - hilbert problems introduced in @xcite .
their procedure leads to a scalar rh problem for a certain phase function @xmath0 that turns out to be equivalent to the solution of the leading order variational problem in the lax - levermore theory .
furthermore they reduce the initial value problem for the whitham equations to solving a set of algebraic equations constrained by algebraic inequalities .
existence and uniqueness of the initial value problem for the whitham equations follows from the existence and uniqueness of the solution of the variational problem in the lax - levermore theory .
the rh problem for the scalar function @xmath0 is well defined even for smooth initial data .
we show that , for smooth monotonically increasing initial data bounded at infinity , the function @xmath0 and the lax - levermore maximizer can be expressed as the solution of a linear overdetermined system of euler - poisson - darboux type . in the same way , the set of algebraic equations obtained through the deift , venakides and zhou approach can be expressed as the solution of a set of linear overdetermined systems of equations of euler - poisson darboux type .
we also show that this set of algebraic equations is equivalent to the set of algebraic equations defined by the hodograph transformation ( [ ch00 ] ) .
the advantage of this representation is clear when one tries to construct effectively the solution of the set of algebraic equations constrained by the algebraic inequalities .
it is simpler to evaluate space derivatives and to estimate the sign of the quantities in the inequalities .
indeed this representation was used in @xcite,@xcite to give an upper bound to the genus of the solution of the whitham equations .
this paper is organized as follows .
section 2 contains the definitions of the abelian differentials on riemann surface and the meromorphic analogue of the cauchy kernel . in section 3
we review the riemann - hilbert steepest descent method for the zero dispersion kdv equation with monotonically increasing initial data .
we determine the scalar function @xmath0 associated to the rh problem and all its properties in section 4 .
we show that the set of algebraic equations that we call moment conditions and normalization conditions are equivalent to the set of algebraic equations defined by the hodograph transformation . in section 5
we show that the hodograph transformation obtained in sec 4 is equivalent to the classical one provided in @xcite and @xcite .
we then show that the moment conditions , the normalization conditions and the lax - levermore maximizer can be expressed in terms of solutions of linear overdetermined systems of euler - poisson - darboux type .
we also derive in a simple way the equations which determine the phase transitions .
finally in section 6 we summarize the main results and draw our conclusions .
let @xmath25 be the hyperelliptic riemann surface of genus @xmath26 .
we shall use the standard representation of @xmath27 as a two - sheeted covering of @xmath28 with cuts along the intervals @xmath29,\quad k=1,\dots , g+1,\quad u_{2g+2}=-\infty\,.\ ] ] we choose the basis @xmath30 of the homology group @xmath31 so that @xmath32 lies fully on the upper sheet and encircles clockwise the interval @xmath33 $ ] , @xmath34 , while @xmath35 emerges on the upper sheet on the cut @xmath33 $ ] , passes anti - clockwise to the lower sheet trough the cut @xmath36 $ ] and returns to the initial point through the lower sheet .
the one - forms that are analytic on the closed riemann surface @xmath27 except for a finite number of points are called abelian differentials .
we define on @xmath27 the following differentials @xcite : \1 ) the canonical basis of holomorphic one - forms or abelian differentials of the first kind @xmath37 : @xmath38 the constants @xmath39 are uniquely determined by the normalization conditions @xmath40 we remark that an holomorphic differential having all its @xmath41-periods equal to zero is identically zero @xcite .
\2 ) the set @xmath42 , @xmath43 , @xmath26 , of abelian differentials of the second kind with a pole of order @xmath44 at infinity , with asymptotic behavior @xmath45d\lb \quad \mbox{for large}\;\ ; \lb\ ] ] and normalized by the condition @xmath46 we use the notation @xmath47 in literature the differentials @xmath48 and @xmath49 are called quasi - momentum and quasi - energy respectively @xcite .
the explicit formula for the differentials @xmath50 , @xmath43 , is given by the expression [ b6 ] ^g_k()=d , p^g_k ( ) = ^g+k+a^k_1 ^g+k-1+a^k_2 ^g+k-2 +a^k_g+k , where the coefficients @xmath51 , @xmath52 , @xmath53 are uniquely determined by ( [ sigma ] ) and ( [ norm2 ] ) .
\3 ) the abelian differential of the third kind @xmath54 with first order poles at the points @xmath55 and @xmath56 with residues @xmath57 respectively .
its periods are normalized by the relation @xmath58 in the following we mainly use the normalized differential @xmath59 which has simple poles at the points @xmath60 with residue @xmath57 respectively .
the differential @xmath59 is explicitly given by the expression @xmath61 where @xmath62 , @xmath63 , is the normalized basis of holomorphic differentials . by construction
@xmath64 the differential @xmath59 can also be written in the form @xmath65 where @xmath66 @xmath59 as a function of @xmath67 , is an abelian integral .
the periods of this integral are obtained from the relations @xcite @xmath68=0,\quad \int_{\beta_j}d_z[\dozr]= 4\pi i \phi_k(\lb)\,,\quad j=1,\dots g\,.\ ] ] the differential @xmath59 satisfies the property @xcite @xmath69 in the following we will use the single value restriction of @xmath59 determined by the conditions @xmath70 and by choosing @xmath71 to be analytic off the cuts ( [ cut ] ) and real positive @xmath72 .
we will still denote this single value restriction with @xmath59 .
we remark that @xmath59 is a meromorphic analogue of the cauchy kernel on the riemann surface @xmath27 @xcite .
the next proposition is also important for our subsequent considerations .
@xcite [ propog ] the abelian differentials of the second kind @xmath73 , @xmath74 , defined in ( [ sigma ] ) satisfy the relations @xmath75=-\dfrac{1}{2k+1}d_{\lb}{\operatornamewithlimits{res}_{z=\infty}}\left [ \dorz\,z^{k+\frac{1}{2}}\right]\,,\ ] ] where @xmath59 has been defined in ( [ ck ] ) , @xmath76 is the normalized abelian differential of the third kind with simple poles at the points @xmath77 with residue @xmath57 respectively and @xmath78 denotes differentiation with respect to @xmath79 .
following @xcite we reformulate the inverse scattering for the kdv equation as a rh problem . we consider monotonically increasing analytic initial data @xmath80 bounded at infinity . for convenience
we assume @xmath81 we suppose @xmath82 for all finite @xmath83 and @xmath84 .
let @xmath85 , be the reflection coefficient from the left of the schdinger equation @xmath86 .
define the matrix @xcite , @xcite ( , ) = \ { lcl & _ 1 , & 1 , . where @xmath87 and @xmath88 .
the goal is to find a row vector valued function @xmath89 analytic for complex @xmath79 off the real axis , satisfying the jump and asymptotic conditions @xmath90 where @xmath91 . the rh problem of finding the matrix @xmath92 given @xmath93 has a unique solution in the space @xmath94 .
the solution of the cauchy problem ( [ kdv ] ) is given by @xmath95 where @xmath96 see again ( @xcite , @xcite ) .
in this paper we study the cauchy problem ( [ kdv ] ) in the limit @xmath97 , the so called zero - dispersion limit of the kdv equation .
we use the wkb approximation with one turning point to calculate the reflection coefficient @xcite @xmath98}(\lb)\\ \rho(\lb)&\simeq \lb^{\frac{1}{2}}x(\lb)-\int_{-\infty}^{x(\lb ) } [ \lb^{\frac{1}{2}}-(\lb - u_0(x))^{\frac{1}{2}}]dx,\\ \end{split}\ ] ] where the quantity @xmath99 is defined by the relation @xmath100 . as usual @xmath101}(\lb)$ ] denotes the characteristic function of the interval @xmath102 $ ] . from the above considerations the jump matrix reduces to the identity matrix for @xmath103 and our rh problem
is reduced to the interval @xmath104 $ ] .
the quantity @xmath105 can be expressed also in the form @xmath106 where @xmath107 is the inverse function of the initial data @xmath80 . in the following we identify @xmath108 with its wkb approximation . following the procedure in @xcite ,
we introduce a change of the dependent variable @xmath109 @xmath110 where the scalar function @xmath111 is analytic in @xmath79 off the line @xmath104 $ ] and satisfies @xmath112 , for @xmath113 and @xmath114 as @xmath115 . from ( [ g ] ) and ( [ u(x ) ] )
we obtain @xmath116 where @xmath117 and @xmath118 .
the rh problem in the new variable becomes @xmath119 , @xmath120 , where @xmath121 and @xmath122 . for computing the small @xmath24 asymptotics we follow the technique in @xcite .
the interval @xmath123 is partitioned into finitely many intervals @xmath124 , @xmath125 and @xmath126 , @xmath26 . using the steepest descent method @xcite,@xcite
, the jump matrix @xmath127 can be reduced to one of the two forms with exponentially small errors as @xmath128 , lll & a0 ) & 0&-ie^-ih/ + -ie^ih/&0 + _ j=1^g+1i_j , + & & + & b0 ) & 1&0 + 0&1 + , ( 0,1)\_j=1^g+1i_j .
+ the function @xmath0 satisfies the following conditions : @xmath129 where @xmath130 is some constant of integration ; 0.3 cm @xmath131 the remaining rh problem is the following [ rh1 ] lcl m_+&=&m_-_1 , ( - , 0 ) , + & & + m_+&=&-i m_-_1 e^-i_3_j/ , _
j=1^g+1i_j , + where @xmath132 . to complete the solution of the initial value problem ( [ kdv ] ) we have to determine the phase function @xmath0 , the intervals @xmath133 , @xmath134 , the values @xmath130 .
once all these steps have been made , we have to solve the rh problem ( [ rh1 ] ) , so that the solution of the initial value problem ( [ kdv ] ) can be expressed by @xcite , @xcite @xmath135 where @xmath136 has been defined in ( [ b6 ] ) and @xmath137 .
the theta function is defined by @xmath138 where @xmath139 is the period matrix of the holomorphic differentials ( [ holo ] ) , namely @xmath140 , @xmath141 .
we observe that for each fix @xmath143 and @xmath144 the function @xmath145 satisfies the following rh problem @xmath146 where @xmath147 .
we call the intervals @xmath133 bands , while the intervals @xmath148 , @xmath149 , @xmath150 , are called gaps .
we add the requirement that @xmath151 it follows that @xmath152 are continuous functions for @xmath120 .
we recall that the condition @xmath153 for large @xmath79 , implies @xmath154 we observe that the condition ( [ rhg2 ] ) implies the following normalization condition @xmath155 where @xmath32 is any clockwise close loop around the cut @xmath133 . when the loops @xmath32 collapse to the interval @xmath133 described twice , the conditions ( [ normalization ] ) become @xmath156 the solution of the rh problem ( [ rhg0 ] ) that satisfies ( [ c1 ] ) is given by the integral @xcite @xmath157 where @xmath158 we choose @xmath159 to be analytic off the intervals @xmath160\cup{\mathcal{l}}_g $ ] , real and positive for @xmath161 and we denote @xmath162 the boundary value from above the cut @xmath160\cup{\mathcal{l}}_g $ ] . in order for ( [ g1 ] ) to satisfy ( [ c2 ] )
we must impose the following moment conditions @xmath163 furthermore we must impose the normalization conditions ( [ normalization ] ) .
we observe that ( [ normalization ] ) and ( [ moment ] ) represent a system of @xmath164 algebraic equations which , in principle , determines the end - points @xmath165 of the intervals @xmath133 , @xmath134 .
for @xmath9 the moment condition reduces to the form @xmath166 which is the solution of the zero - phase equation ( [ zeroph ] ) .
we observe that @xmath167 and @xmath168 therefore because of the assumption of the continuity of @xmath169 on @xmath170 , the following relation must be satisfied @xmath171 where @xmath172 for @xmath173 odd and @xmath174 for @xmath173 even .
we consider analytic initial data or smooth initial data in @xmath170 that satisfies ( [ const ] ) , so that the function @xmath175 is hlder continuous in subsets of @xmath170 , namely @xmath176 where the constant @xmath177 , @xmath178 , and @xmath179 is some open subset of @xmath170 .
@xcite [ mu ] if the function @xmath175 is hlder continuous near and at @xmath180 , @xmath13 , then @xmath181 where @xmath172 for @xmath173 odd and @xmath174 for @xmath173 even .
the above lemma guarantees the consistency of the assumptions ( [ c1 ] ) and ( [ c11 ] ) .
these considerations suggests to build a second solution @xmath182 of the rh problem ( [ rhg0 ] ) requiring that @xmath183 satisfies ( [ c2 ] ) and ( [ c3 ] ) while we impose the continuity ( [ c1 ] ) as constraint .
the solution @xmath183 is given by the expression @xmath184 the polynomial @xmath185 has degree @xmath186 and its coefficients are uniquely determined from ( [ c3 ] ) or ( [ normalization ] ) .
it is easy to verify that @xmath187 where @xmath62 , @xmath188 is the basis of holomorphic differential defined in ( [ holo ] ) .
the function @xmath183 satisfies the conditions ( [ c2 ] ) and ( [ c3 ] ) .
the continuity on the function @xmath183 is obtained imposing that the end points @xmath189 evolve according to the equations @xmath190 the next theorem establishes the equivalence between the two different solutions @xmath145 and @xmath183 of the rh ( [ rhg0 ] ) .
[ equiv ] the function function @xmath183 and the set of algebraic equations ( [ zerog ] ) is equivalent to the function @xmath145 and the set of algebraic equations ( [ moment ] ) and ( [ normalization ] ) . the equivalence is established for any @xmath191 initial data satisfying ( [ const ] ) . * proof*:we write @xmath183 in the form @xmath192 using the identity @xmath193 we obtain @xmath194 where the @xmath195 s are the symmetric function in the variables @xmath196 , namely @xmath197 , @xmath198 , @xmath199 and so on . using ( [ switch ] ) we can rewrite ( [ o1 ] ) in the form @xmath200 imposing ( [ zerog ] ) , we can see that the first term in ( [ o2 ] ) is automatically zero at the branch points by lemma [ mu ] .
therefore , using ( [ o2 ] ) , the equations ( [ zerog ] ) imply @xmath201\right|_{\lb = u_i}=0 , \end{split}\ ] ] for @xmath202 the above quantity is a polynomial in the @xmath79 variable of degree @xmath203 that must have @xmath164 zeros , therefore it is identically zero . from the coefficients of degree @xmath2 to @xmath203
we get the moments conditions ( [ moment ] ) . for the coefficients of degree @xmath109
, @xmath204 we get the relations @xmath205 using ( [ snorm ] ) the above relation simplifies to the form @xmath206 because the matrix @xmath207 , @xmath208 , @xmath204 is invertible , the relation ( [ a3 ] ) is equivalent to @xmath209 which coincides with the normalization conditions ( [ normalization ] )
. therefore on the solution of ( [ moment ] ) and ( [ normalization ] ) the function @xmath183 reads @xmath210 @xmath211 in the same way we can prove that @xmath145 , the moment conditions ( [ moment ] ) and the normalization conditions ( [ normalization ] ) are equivalent to @xmath183 and the equations ( [ zerog ] ) .
we remark that the equivalence between the two solutions does not depend on the fact that the problem has a priori a unique solution as follows from the lax - levermore theory but it derives only on the structure of the rh problem for the scalar function @xmath0 .
we observe that using @xmath212 , the meromorphic analogue of the cauchy kernel defined in ( [ ck ] ) , we can write @xmath213 in the form @xmath214 where @xmath215 and @xmath216 here and below the integrals in the @xmath67 variable are taken on the upper side of @xmath217 . using the above representation
we compute the constants @xmath218 defined in ( [ rhg1 ] ) @xmath219 integrating by parts the above identity and using ( [ dozl ] ) and ( [ periods ] ) we obtain @xmath220 from the above it follows that @xmath221 . the following theorem due to krichever @xcite connects the solution of the set of algebraic equations ( [ moment ] ) and ( [ normalization ] ) or ( [ zerog ] ) , to a solution of the whitham equations .
@xcite let us suppose that the @xmath180 s depend on @xmath143 and @xmath144 in such a way that the conditions ( [ zerog ] ) are fulfilled .
then @xmath222 , @xmath223 , satisfies the whitham equations @xmath224 where @xmath225 and the differentials @xmath226 and @xmath227 have been defined in ( [ dpt ] ) .
we remark that from proposition ( [ propog ] ) the following identity is easily verified @xmath228 where @xmath48 and @xmath49 have been defined in ( [ dp ] ) .
the second expression of the @xmath229 s in ( [ vi ] ) is the classical formula for the speeds of the whitham equations obtained in @xcite .
we can write the algebraic equations ( [ zerog ] ) in the form of the so called hodograph transformation introduced by tsarev @xcite : @xmath230 where @xmath231 and @xmath232 has been defined in ( [ omp ] ) . as a consequence of theorem [ equiv ] , the set of algebraic equations ( [ moment ] ) and ( [ normalization ] ) is equivalent to the hodograph transformation ( [ ch0 ] ) . in the next section
we will show that the @xmath233 s defined in ( [ twi ] ) coincide with the classical formulas provided in @xcite or @xcite .
we first define the cauchy problem for the whitham equations .
the initial value problem consists of the following .
we consider the evolution on the @xmath234 plane of the initial curve @xmath235 according to the zero - phase equation ( [ zeroph ] ) .
the solution @xmath236 of ( [ zeroph ] ) , with the initial data @xmath80 , is given by the characteristic equation @xmath237 where @xmath107 is the inverse function of the initial data @xmath80 .
the solution @xmath236 in ( [ zp ] ) is globally well defined only for @xmath238 , where @xmath239 $ ] is the time of gradient catastrophe of ( [ zp ] ) . near the point of gradient catastrophe and for a short time @xmath240 ,
the evolving curve is given by a multivalued function with three branches @xmath241 , which evolve according to the one - phase whitham equations .
outside the multivalued region the solution is given by the zero - phase solution @xmath236 defined in ( [ zp ] ) .
on the phase transition boundary the zero - phase solution and the one - phase solution are attached @xmath242-smoothly .
since the whitham equations are hyperbolic @xcite , other points of gradient catastrophe can appear in the branches @xmath241 themselves or in @xmath236 . in general , for @xmath240 ,
the evolving curve is given by a multivalued function with and odd number of branches @xmath243 , @xmath26 .
these branches evolve according to the @xmath2-phase whitham equations .
the @xmath2-phase solutions for _ different @xmath2 _ must be glued together in order to produce a @xmath242-smooth curve in the @xmath244 plane evolving smoothly with @xmath144 .
the initial value problem of the whitham equations is to determine , for almost all @xmath245 and @xmath143 , the phase @xmath246 and the corresponding branches @xmath243 from the initial data @xmath247 .
the solution of the whitham equations for a given @xmath2 is obtained by the so called hodograph transformation introduced by tsarev @xcite .
[ tsarevt ] if @xmath248 , @xmath52 , solves the linear over - determined system @xmath249,\quad i , j=1,2,\dots,2g+1,\;\;i\neq j,\ ] ] then the solution @xmath250 of the hodograph transformation @xmath251 satisfies system ( [ whithamg ] ) .
conversely , any solution @xmath252 of ( [ whithamg ] ) can be obtained in this way in a neighborhood @xmath19 where the @xmath20 s are not vanishing .. to guarantee that the @xmath253phase solutions for different @xmath2 are attached continuously , the following natural boundary conditions must be imposed on @xmath254 , @xmath13 , @xmath5 . when @xmath255 , @xmath256 , @xmath257 and for @xmath258 [ b2 ] w_i^g(u_1, ,u_l , u_l,
,u_2g+1)= w_i^g-1(u_1, ,_l,_l, ,u_2g+1 ) .
the superscript @xmath2 and @xmath186 in the @xmath259 s specify the corresponding genus and the hat denotes the variable that have been dropped . when @xmath260 and @xmath261 we have that [ b3 ] lll & w_1(u_1,u_3,u_3)=f(u_1 ) + & w_2(u_1,u_3,u_3)=w_3(u_1,u_3,u_3 ) , where @xmath262 is the initial data .
similar conditions hold true when @xmath263 , namely [ b4 ] lll & w_3(u_1,u_1,u_3)=f(u_3 ) + & w_1(u_1,u_1,u_3)=w_2(u_1,u_1,u_3 ) .
we remark that the @xmath229 s satisfy the boundary conditions ( [ b1]-[b2 ] ) and for @xmath260 we have @xmath264 the solution of the boundary value problem ( [ tsarev ] ) , ( [ b1]-[b4 ] ) has been obtained in @xcite for any smooth monotonically increasing initial data .
@xcite [ theot1 ] let be @xmath262 the inverse function of the smooth initial data @xmath265 . if the function @xmath266 , @xmath267 , is the symmetric solution of the linear over - determined system [ qk ] \
{ lll 2(u_i - u_j)= - , ij , i , j=1 , , 2g+1,g>0 & & + & & + q_k(_2g+1)=f_k(u ) & & + & & + f_k(u)= u^-k+ ( u^g - f^(k-1)(u ) ) , & & . with the ordering @xmath268
, then @xmath248 , @xmath223 , defined by @xmath269,\ ] ] solves the boundary value problem ( [ tsarev ] ) , ( [ b1]-[b4 ] ) .
conversely every solution of ( [ tsarev ] ) , ( [ b1]-[b4 ] ) can be obtained in this way . in ( [ wi ] ) the polynomials @xmath270 s have been defined in ( [ b6 ] ) and the @xmath271 s are the coefficient of the expansion for @xmath272 of @xmath273 the existence and uniqueness of the solution of the boundary value problem ( [ qk ] ) has been proved in @xcite .
@xcite the solution of the boundary value problem ( [ qk ] ) is unique , symmetric with respect to the variables @xmath274 and reads @xmath275 where @xmath276 and @xmath277 the functions @xmath278 and the solutions @xmath279 , @xmath63 , of the boundary value problem ( [ qk ] ) satisfy the following relations : [ relations ] cll _
u f_k(u)&=&f_k+1(u)+u _ u f_k+1(u),k=1 , , g-1,g>0 , + & & + _ u_iq_k()&=&q_k+1()+u_i _ u_i q_k+1 ( ) i=1. ,2g+1,k=1, ,g-1g>0 .
@xcite [ theot2 ] the solution of the whitham equations described by ( [ ch ] ) where the @xmath248 s are given by ( [ wi ] ) is @xmath242-smooth on the phase transition boundaries .
the next theorem shows the equivalence between the hodograph transformation defined in ( [ ch0 ] ) and the one define in ( [ ch ] ) [ wiequiv ] for any smooth monotonically increasing initial data satisfying ( [ const ] ) , the following identity is satisfied @xmath280 where the @xmath233 s are defined in ( [ twi ] ) and the @xmath248 s are defined in ( [ wi ] ) . therefore combining theorem [ equiv ] and and theorem [ wiequiv ]
, we deduce that the hodograph transformation ( [ ch ] ) is equivalent to the set of algebraic equations ( [ moment ] ) and ( [ normalization ] ) .
the next theorem shows that the hodograph transformation ( [ ch ] ) can be written in a nice algebraic form .
this is the first step to transform the moment conditions ( [ moment ] ) and the normalization conditions ( [ normalization ] ) into a combination of solutions of linear - overdetermined systems of euler - poisson - darboux type .
[ hodoalge ] for @xmath5 the hodograph transformation ( [ ch ] ) where the @xmath248 s are defined in ( [ wi ] ) is equivalent to the following set of @xmath164 algebraic equations @xmath281 @xmath282 where the function @xmath283 is given by the relation @xmath284 the function @xmath285 satisfies the linear overdetermined system of euler - poisson - darboux type [ bpsi ] \ { lll & & ^g(;)- ^g(;)=2(u_i - u_j ) ^g(;),ij , i , j=1, 2g+1 + & & ^g(;)-2 ^g(;)=2(-u_j ) ^g(;),j=1, 2g+1 + & & ^g(;)=
f^(g ) ( ) . where @xmath286 is the @xmath2th derivative of the smooth monotonically increasing initial data @xmath262 .
the above boundary value problem can be integrate in the form @xmath287 where @xmath288 and the @xmath289 s have been defined in ( [ crho ] ) . the solution obtained is symmetric with respect to the variables @xmath189 .
a similar formula can be obtained for @xmath290 . in the next section
we identify the system ( [ zero1 ] ) with the moment conditions ( [ moment ] ) and system ( [ zero2 ] ) with the normalization condition ( [ normalization ] ) .
0.5 cm * proof of theorem [ wiequiv]*. we show that the @xmath233 s defined in ( [ twi ] ) satisfy the tsarev system ( [ tsarev ] ) and the boundary conditions ( [ b1]-[b4 ] )
. therfore by theorem [ theot1 ] , we obtain @xmath291 .
we follow the steps in @xcite,@xcite .
the quantities @xmath292 , @xmath293 , are well defined .
indeed let us write @xmath294 and @xmath232 in the form @xmath295 and @xmath296 where @xmath297\,\ ] ] and the @xmath298 s have been defined in ( [ n ] ) . here and below all the integrals
are taken on the upper side of @xmath217 .
then @xmath299\ , . \end{split}\ ] ] next we show that the @xmath300 s satisfy the tsarev system ( [ tsarev ] ) .
the differentials @xmath301 and @xmath302 are normalized abelian differentials of the second kind with a pole at @xmath303 of second order .
because of ( [ twi ] ) the differential @xmath304 is holomorphic and @xmath305 that follows from ( [ norm ] ) .
therefore @xmath306 because it is a holomorphic differential having all the @xmath41-periods equal to zero . from ( [ omdp ] )
we obtain @xmath307 we use the above identity to evaluate @xmath308 . from ( [ twi1 ] ) and ( [ pr ] ) we obtain @xmath309 which shows that @xmath310 in particular the above argument also applied to @xmath311 , @xmath294 and @xmath229
therefore we also have @xmath312 which when combined with ( [ ttt ] ) proves the tsarev relation for the @xmath300 s .
next we show that the functions @xmath313 , @xmath13 , satisfy the boundary conditions ( [ b1]-[b4 ] ) . in the following we use the superscript @xmath2 to denote the corresponding genus of the quantities
we are referring to .
we need to consider the behavior of the abelian differential @xmath212 when two branch points become coincident . for the purpose let be @xmath314 , @xmath315 where @xmath316 .
the differential @xmath317 has the following expansion for @xmath318 when @xmath319 is odd @xcite @xmath320 where @xmath321 is the normalized abelian differential of the third kind having first order poles at the points @xmath322 with residue @xmath57 respectively and it is defined on the riemann surface @xmath323 the differential @xmath324 has poles at @xmath325 of order at most @xmath326 and zero residue . in formula ( [ dolead ] ) the quantity @xmath327 . when @xmath319 is even @xmath212 has the following expansion @xcite for @xmath318 @xmath328 the above expansion contains also terms of order @xmath329 . using ( [ dolead ] ) and ( [ dotrail ] ) we can get the expansion of the differentials @xmath232 and @xmath226 when @xmath314 and @xmath315 , @xmath330 . let be @xmath331 the contour from @xmath332 to @xmath333 on the upper sheet of @xmath27 .
when @xmath319 is odd @xmath334 where @xmath335\cup\dots\cup [ u_{l+3},u_{l+2}]\cup[u_{l-1},u_{l-2}]\cup\dots\cup[u_2,u_1]\ ] ] is the corresponding contour defined on the riemann surface @xmath336 of genus @xmath186 . from ( [ dolead ] ) we obtain the expansion of @xmath337 as @xmath318 , namely @xmath338 where @xmath339 when @xmath319 is even @xmath340 where @xmath335\cup\dots\cup [ u_{l+4},u_{l+3}]\cup[u_{l+2},u_{l-1}]\cup[u_{l-2},u_{l-3}]\cup\dots\cup[u_2,u_1]\ ] ] and from ( [ dotrail ] ) we obtain the expansion of @xmath232 @xmath341 the same expansions applies to @xmath226 , therefore combining ( [ omlead ] ) and ( [ omtrail ] ) we obtain @xmath342}= \left.\dfrac{{\omega}^{g-1}(\lb)}{d\tilde{p}^{g-1}(\lb)}\right|_{\lb = u_i},\quad i\neq l , l+1,\;i=1,\dots 2g+1.\ ] ] from the above identity it is clear that the boundary conditions ( [ b2 ] ) are satisfied . in order to evaluate ( [ za ] ) at the points @xmath343
, we need to do some extra work .
let us defined the quantity @xmath344 when @xmath314 and @xmath315 , @xmath319 odd , using ( [ omlead ] ) we obtain @xmath345 where now @xmath324 is a polynomial in @xmath79 . using ( [ dolead ] )
we obtain the following expansion of the second term in the above equation @xmath346 therefore @xmath347 where @xmath348 . combining ( [ chi0 ] ) and ( [ chi1 ] ) we obtain @xmath349 in the same way we can get the expansion for @xmath350 , namely @xmath351 which , when combined with ( [ chilead ] ) gives @xmath352 where @xmath353 . using ( [ omtrail ] )
we obtain the following expansion of @xmath354 when @xmath355 and @xmath315 , @xmath319 even , @xmath356 from the above and ( [ chi1 ] ) we can evaluate @xmath357 and @xmath358 combining the above two expansions we obtain @xmath359 the relations ( [ as1 ] ) and ( [ as2 ] ) show that the boundary conditions ( [ b1 ] ) are satisfied . from ( [ za ] )
we obtain @xmath360 which shows that the boundary condition ( [ b3 ] ) is satisfied .
analogous considerations can be done for proving ( [ b4 ] ) .
theorem [ wiequiv ] is then proved.@xmath211 0.3 cm * proof of theorem [ hodoalge]*. following the steps in @xcite we consider the polynomial @xmath361 where @xmath362 and @xmath363 , @xmath5 , is given by the expression @xmath364 with the polynomials @xmath365 , @xmath366 , defined in ( [ b6 ] ) and the functions @xmath279 , @xmath367 , defined in ( [ qk ] )
. then the hodograph transformation ( [ ch ] ) is equivalent , for @xmath5 , to the equation @xmath368 the proof of the above proposition is obtained observing that the @xmath248 s defined in ( [ wi ] ) are given by the ratio @xmath369 , @xmath13 , where @xmath363 is the polynomial defined in ( [ r2 g ] ) .
hence we can write the hodograph transformation ( [ ch ] ) in the form @xmath370_{\lb = u_i}=0 , \quad i=1,\dots,2g+1 . \;\;\ ] ] for @xmath5 , @xmath371 is a polynomial of degree @xmath203 and because of ( [ sol3 ] ) it must have at least @xmath164 real zeros .
therefore it is identically zero . putting equal to zero the first @xmath372 coefficients of the polynomial @xmath373 and using repeatedly the identity ( [ relations ] )
we obtain ( [ zero1 ] ) .
putting to zero the coefficients of @xmath373 of degree @xmath374 to degree @xmath186 is equivalent to the equations @xmath375 indeed when ( [ zero1 ] ) is satisfied , the differential @xmath376 is an holomorphic differential and by ( [ zero22 ] ) it has all its alpha - periods equal to zero .
therefore it is identically zero .
hence the last @xmath2 equations reads @xmath377 in the third equality of ( [ ppp ] ) we have used the fact that @xmath378 because of the normalization conditions ( [ norm2 ] ) . the function @xmath285 defined in ( [ psi ] ) satisfies the relations @xmath379 using ( [ psir ] ) we can rewrite the last term in ( [ ppp ] ) in the form @xmath380 where the last equality has been obtained integrating by parts . using the definition of @xmath290 in ( [ phi ] )
we rewrite the above relation in the form @xmath381 which is equivalent to ( [ zero2 ] ) .
@xmath211 in this section we show that the set of algebraic equations described by the moment conditions ( [ moment ] ) and the normalization conditions ( [ normalization ] ) can be written in terms of solutions of linear overdetermined system of euler - poisson - darboux type introduced in @xcite .
[ algequiv ] for any monotonically increasing analytic initial data satisfying ( [ const ] ) , the set of algebraic equations defined by the moment conditions ( [ moment ] ) is equivalent , for @xmath5 , to ( [ zero1 ] ) ; the set of algebraic equations defined by the normalization conditions ( [ normalization ] ) is equivalent , for @xmath5 , to ( [ zero2 ] ) , namely @xmath383 * proof*:we first consider the moment conditions . since @xmath384 we have @xmath385 for analytic initial data we can deform the integrals @xmath386 where @xmath387 is a close loop around the interval @xmath388 passing through zero and the @xmath389 are close loops around the intervals @xmath133 and within the domain of analyticity of the initial data .
we can deform the contours @xmath390 to a single contour @xmath391 where the contours @xmath392 are the closed contours plotted in the figure below . 0.2 cm the integrals
@xmath393 therefore @xmath394 from the right hand side of ( [ iib ] ) it is straightforward to verify that the integrals @xmath395 , @xmath43 , are symmetric with respect to the variables @xmath396 and satisfy the linear overdetermined system of euler - poisson - darboux type defined in ( [ qk ] ) with the initial data @xmath397 } = \partial_uf_{g - k}(u)-kf_{g - k+1}(u ) , \quad k=0,\dots , g-1,\\ & \left.\dfrac{2}{\pi i } \int_{{\mathcal{l}}_g}\dfrac{\rho^{\prime}(z)z^g}{y^+(z)}dz\right|_{[u_1=u_2=\dots = u_{2g+1}=u]}=2u\partial_uf_1(u)+f_1(u ) , \end{split}\ ] ] where the functions @xmath278 , @xmath367 , have been defined in ( [ qk ] ) . because of the uniqueness of the solution of the boundary value problem ( [ qk ] ) the first @xmath372 equations in ( [ ealgequiv ] ) are satisfied . as regarding the normalization conditions ( [ normalization ] ) we have the following identity for @xmath398 , @xmath149 @xmath399 where the function @xmath290 has been defined in ( [ phi ] ) and @xmath400 is equal to one for @xmath9 and zero otherwise .
the last identity in ( [ phi0 ] ) has been obtained performing computations similar to the ones in ( [ iii ] ) .
therefore @xmath401 and theorem [ algequiv ] in then proved .
@xmath211 the relations ( [ ealgequiv ] ) are satisfied for smooth initial data .
* proof*:the proof is obtained combining theorems [ equiv ] , [ wiequiv ] , [ hodoalge ] and [ algequiv ] .
@xmath211 0.1 cm in the following we write the variational conditions in ( [ rhg1 ] ) and ( [ rhg2 ] ) in terms of the function @xmath290 defined in ( [ phi ] ) .
the variational conditions ( [ rhg1 ] ) and ( [ rhg2 ] ) can be written in the form @xmath402 and @xmath403 where the function @xmath290 has been defined in ( [ phi ] ) and @xmath400 is equal to @xmath404 for @xmath9 and zero otherwise .
* proof*:we first prove ( [ rhg11 ] ) . from ( [ phi0 ] ) and
lemma [ mu ] we obtain @xmath405 which coincides with ( [ rhg11 ] ) .
as regarding ( [ lax0 ] ) we have @xmath406 where @xmath400 is equal to one for @xmath9 and zero otherwise . in order to express the integral @xmath407 as the solution of a linear overdetermined system of euler - poisson - darboux type ,
let us consider the function @xmath408 which satisfies ( [ qk ] ) with initial data @xmath409 then @xmath410 the derivation of the above identity is straightforward .
next we consider the first identity in ( [ ealgequiv ] ) for the function @xmath411 .
let us suppose @xmath412 , for @xmath413 , @xmath150 , let us define the interval @xmath414 and @xmath415 .
the function @xmath416 is analytic in the complement of @xmath160\cup{\mathcal{l}}_g\cup i$ ] and positive for @xmath417 .
@xmath418 denotes the boundary value from above .
then by ( [ ealgequiv ] ) we have @xmath419 the limit @xmath420 of the left hand side of the above identity has been obtained in ( [ philimit ] ) .
here we derive the limit of the right hand side .
let us define @xmath421 . then @xmath422 combining the previous three relations we obtain @xmath423 combining ( [ gh ] ) and ( [ phigap ] ) the variational condition ( [ lax0 ] ) can be easily obtained .
we observe that the function @xmath424 must be nonzero at the branch points .
this is obvious for g=0 . indeed
@xmath425 . for @xmath5
the derivatives @xmath426 are given by the expression @xcite @xmath427 where @xmath428 has been defined in ( [ b6 ] ) . from the above expression it is obvious that the @xmath426 s are nonsingular if @xmath429 , @xmath13 .
we derive the equations which determine a change of genus of the solution of the hodograph transformation ( [ ch ] ) or the set of algebraic equations ( [ moment ] ) and ( [ normalization ] ) .
we observe that a transition necessarily occurs when one of the two conditions ( [ rhg11 ] ) or ( [ lax0 ] ) fail to be satisfied .
if the conditions ( [ rhg11 ] ) fail to be satisfied at some point @xmath430 in the bands @xmath431 , it follows that @xmath432 indeed @xmath430 must be a stationary point of the integral @xmath433 .
when we can solve the above system together with the moment conditions ( [ moment ] ) and the normalization conditions ( [ normalization ] ) for some @xmath245 , we obtain a point @xmath434 , @xmath435 and @xmath436 of the boundary between the @xmath2-phase solution and the @xmath437phase solution . in the same way
if the conditions ( [ lax0 ] ) fail to be satisfied at some point @xmath430 in the gaps @xmath438 , it follows that @xmath439 the above system describes the point of phase transition when a new band is opening .
systems ( [ trail ] ) and ( [ lead ] ) have been obtained in @xcite studying directly the hodograph transformation ( [ ch ] ) . following the steps in @xcite we construct the maximizer of the lax - levermore - venakides functional @xcite,@xcite .
let us make the change of variable @xmath440 , taking the upper complex half plane onto @xmath441 $ ] .
the function @xmath142 transforms to @xmath442 .
the function @xmath443 is analytic off the real @xmath444 axis .
we extend the definition of @xmath443 onto the lower complex @xmath444-plane by the relation @xmath445 .
the rh problem for the function @xmath443 is @xmath446 and @xmath447 . on the real axis
we define the function @xmath448 to be equal to zero outside the interval @xmath449 $ ] , while on the interval @xmath450 @xmath451.\ ] ] the function @xmath448 is the unique maximizer of the functional @xcite,@xcite @xmath452,\quad \psi\in l^1([0,1]),\;\psi\leq 0,\ ] ] where @xmath453 @xmath454 the maximization problem is attacked analytically by solving the variational conditions @xmath455 namely if @xmath456 satisfies ( [ lax1 ] ) , then @xmath457 @xcite . in @xcite
it is shown that the variational conditions ( [ lax1 ] ) transform to ( [ rhg1 ] ) and ( [ rhg2 ] ) .
the benefit of the variational formulation is that , due to the convexity of the maximization problem , the uniqueness of @xmath458 and hence of @xmath0 is guaranteed .
furthermore for each fixed @xmath143 and @xmath144 the support of the maximizer in uniquely defined .
an important consequence of this result is the following .
for almost all @xmath143 and @xmath459 the solution @xmath243 of the hodograph transformation ( [ ch ] ) @xmath460 which satisfies the constraints ( [ rhg1 ] ) and ( [ rhg2 ] ) or , equivalently , ( [ rhg11 ] ) and ( [ lax0 ] ) , exists for some @xmath26 and it is unique . as a final result
we write the lax - levermore - venakides maximizer as the solution of a linear overdetermined system of euler - poisson - darboux type . for @xmath5 the maximizer @xmath448 in ( [ lax ] )
can be written in the form @xmath461 \cup_{j=1}^g[\b_{2j},\b_{2j+1}],\ ; \end{split}\ ] ] @xmath462 @xmath463 and the function @xmath464 has been defined in ( [ phi ] ) .
we observe that the condition ( [ lax0 ] ) implies @xmath465 for @xmath466 and vice - versa .
the proof of the theorem follows directly from ( [ lax0 ] ) and ( [ lax ] ) .
all the information on the initial data of the lax - levermore maximizer is contained in the the function @xmath290 . in @xcite,@xcite an upper bound to the genus of the solution of the whitham equations was provided .
we selected initial data such that the maximum number of real zeros of the function @xmath424 is @xmath467 for @xmath468 where @xmath469 is the supposed upper bound of the genus .
then we showed that , in such a situation , phase transitions from solutions of genus @xmath470 to solutions of genus @xmath471 do not occur .
the proof of the theorem is obtained only studying the whitham equations and the hodograph transformation ( [ ch ] ) . in this new representation of the lax - levermore - venakides maximizer , the above result has an easy interpretation .
namely it gives an upper bound to number of intervals where the function @xmath472 is positive for @xmath468 .
in this paper we have studied the cauchy problem for the kdv equation with small dispersion and with monotonically increasing initial data .
we have used the formulation of the cauchy problem for kdv as a riemann - hilbert ( rh ) problem @xcite .
the small @xmath24-asymptotics is obtained using the steepest descent method for oscillatory riemann - hilbert problems introduced in @xcite .
analyticity of the initial data is essential for this step . in this paper
we have shown that , for smooth monotonically increasing initial data bounded at infinity , the set of algebraic equations obtained through the deift , venakides and zhou approach can be expressed as the solution of a linear overdetermined systems of equations of euler - poisson - darboux type .
we have also shown that this set of algebraic equation is equivalent to the set of algebraic equations defined by the hodograph transformation ( [ ch ] ) .
the uniqueness of the lax - levermore maximization problems guarantees the uniqueness of the solution of the cauchy problem for the whitham equations . as a final result
we have shown that the lax - levermore maximizer can also be expressed as a solution of a linear overdetermined system of euler - poisson - darboux type . | we study the cauchy problem for the korteweg de vries ( kdv ) equation with small dispersion and with monotonically increasing initial data using the riemann - hilbert ( rh ) approach .
the solution of the cauchy problem , in the zero dispersion limit , is obtained using the steepest descent method for oscillatory riemann - hilbert problems . the asymptotic solution is completely described by a scalar function @xmath0 that satisfies a scalar rh problem and a set of algebraic equations constrained by algebraic inequalities .
the scalar function @xmath0 is equivalent to the solution of the lax - levermore maximization problem .
the solution of the set of algebraic equations satisfies the whitham equations .
we show that the scalar function @xmath0 and the lax - levermore maximizer can be expressed as the solution of a linear overdetermined system of equations of euler - poisson - darboux type .
we also show that the set of algebraic equations and algebraic inequalities can be expressed in terms of solutions of a different set of linear overdetermined systems of equations of euler - poisson - darboux type .
furthermore we show that the set of algebraic equations is equivalent to the classical solution of the whitham equations expressed by the hodograph transformation . |
quantum correlations allow one to perform many communicational and computational tasks with efficiency unattainable using classical devices and they are at the heart of all considerations in quantum information theory . on the other hand the quantum correlations are very sensitive to any disturbances and easily suffer degradation .
any operation performed on a quantum correlated system can result in decreasing entanglement .
one of the most important feature of information encoded in the quantum systems is that while classical informations can be copied exactly , quantum information can not be cloned with perfect accuracy .
more precisely , it is not possible to obtain a perfect copy of an arbitrary , unknown quantum state using unitary transformations .
this so - called no - cloning theorem recognized by wootters and zurek @xcite follows directly from the linearity of quantum mechanics .
a quantum cloning machine designed to perfect cloning of a given finite set of orthogonal states is used in a proof of this theorem .
the orthogonal states are cloned perfectly using this quantum cloning machine , but clones of all other states contain errors .
this cloning machine is a special example of state - dependent cloners , which in general case produce approximate clones of the chosen non - orthogonal states @xcite .
independent cloning machines producing clones , whose quality is independent of input states , form another class of the cloners .
buek and hillary first showed how the no cloning theorem can be bypassed @xcite .
they also proposed construction of a network , consisting of quantum gates , realizing the idea of an universal cloning machine @xcite . this network clones any quantum state of a qubit equally well , where the figure of merit is the local fidelity , i.e. an overlap between the states of the input and the output qubits .
these results were extended later to cases where @xmath0dimensional systems , for @xmath1 , are cloned and to cases where more than two clones are obtained in the cloning process @xcite .
quantum cloning is considered in quantum cryptography as a useful tool allowing a partial break in security of some quantum cryptography protocols @xcite .
recently galvo and hardy have shown that quantum cloning can be also applied to improve the performance of some quantum computation tasks @xcite .
preservation of the quantum correlations is specially important in this case because the computational power of quantum computers is based on the use of highly correlated quantum systems .
cloning can be considered as a method of enhancement of the efficiency of the quantum computers only if it allows one to produce clones which are not only similar to the cloned systems , but in the first place , if it preserve the entanglement of the states .
the article has the following structure .
we begin with short characterization of the three kinds of deterministic cloning machines .
next , we recall a definition of the entanglement of formation , which is used to measure the quantum correlations and finally , in the main part of the article , we present results of calculations of the entanglement of formation for the clones obtained using the cloning machines considered and we compare the efficiency of these cloners with regards to the preservation of the quantum correlations .
first we consider the wootters - zurek cloning machine . originally wootters and zurek considered cloning of qubits , i.e. states belonging to a two - dimensional hilbert space .
we want to study the cloning of the correlated systems , so we need to extend the wootters - zurek results .
we propose an extended version of the wootters - zurek cloning machine adapted to a task of cloning the entangled states of the two qubit systems .
we choose a basis of bell states as the set of states which are perfectly cloned : @xmath2 and @xmath3 .
the cloning process is defined by a transformation relation on the states @xmath4 : @xmath5 and the cloning machine is in an initial state @xmath6 .
after the transformation both pairs are in the cloned state @xmath7 , and the cloning machine is in the final state @xmath8 depending upon the initial state of the input pair of the qubits .
we consider not too much restrictive assumption that the states @xmath9 of the cloner are orthogonal , i.e. @xmath10 .
an arbitrary pure superposition of the basis states @xmath11 transforms as follows : @xmath12 a reduced density operator of any clone reads : @xmath13\right]\\ \nonumber & = & \sum^4_{i=1}\alpha^2_i|\varphi_i\rangle \langle\varphi_i|,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where for simplicity we have taken the probability amplitudes , @xmath14 , real . the fidelity of the clones @xmath15 .
we see that in agreement with the scheme of this cloning machine , the basis states are cloned perfectly and the clones of all other states contain some errors .
this is illustrated by changes of the fidelity , which is less than one for these states .
the minimal fidelity @xmath16 and it is less than the fidelity attained in a procedure for the estimation of states using an optimal measurement , which can be regarded as a classical counterpart of the quantum cloning @xcite . the mean fidelity of such classical cloning @xmath17 .
eight product states of a form @xmath18 , where @xmath19 , are cloned the worst .
these states are fortunately least interesting from our point of view .
the wootters - zurek cloning machine clones some states very badly .
however it has one big advantage : the quantum correlation of some kind of states are completely preserved in the cloning .
next under consideration is the best known and most widely studied , the state - independent symmetric optimal quantum cloning machine @xcite .
the cloning transformation is a shrinking type transformation , which can be formally expressed in the form : @xmath20 , where the shrinking factor @xmath21 , @xmath22 is a density matrix of the ideal clone of the input state and @xmath23 is the number of clones produced @xcite .
all clones are in this same final state described by the density matrix @xmath24 .
we restrict our investigations to a case when only two clones are produced due to , first , it being the generic case , and second , for more clones the entanglement of each of them rapidly decreases with the number of clones @xcite .
it is not possible to obtain arbitrarily many entangled clones of the input state even if the cloned pair of the qubits is at the beginning of the cloning process in the maximally entangled state .
the clones are entangled if at most five copies are produced .
more copies will already be in states with no quantum correlation @xcite . at the end of the survey on the classes of the deterministic quantum cloning machines
we turn our attention on the class of asymmetric state - independent cloning machines @xcite . in this case
the states of the clones are different .
they are described by density matrices obtained as a result of action similar to before , i.e. shrinking type transformations .
however now the scaling factors can be different : @xmath25 where , as previously , we have restricted the considerations to the case of two clones , i.e. @xmath26 . the parameters @xmath27 are connected by a relation : @xmath28 which define a range of allowed values of them . in extremal cases
the asymmetric cloning transformation degenerates : when @xmath29 and @xmath30 the states of the qubits do not change at all , and when @xmath31 and @xmath32 the states of the qubits swap ; and actually these transformations should not be called the cloning . when both shrinking parameters are equal to @xmath33 the symmetric cloning machine is reproduced .
the non - locality of the quantum state can manifest itself in many different ways .
the best known and one which has been tested in many experiments is a violation of the bell inequality @xcite .
however , the violation of the bell inequality is not wholly satisfactory measure of the quantum correlations .
there are other quantities which have been developed as measures of the quantum non - locality @xcite . in the case of a pair of correlated qubits ,
one such measure is the entanglement of formation @xcite .
this quantity is much more sensitive to the degree of quantum correlations than the bell inequality and what is also very important is that a finite , compact analytical formula for it is known .
the entanglement of formation @xmath34 $ ] is defined in the following way @xcite : @xmath35={\mathcal e}(c(\hat{\rho})),\ ] ] where @xmath36 @xmath37 and @xmath38 is so - called concurrence of the two - qubit state @xmath39 given by expression : @xmath40 the @xmath41 s in these expressions are the square roots of eigenvalues , in decreasing order , of a non - hermitian matrix @xmath42 , and @xmath43 we use the entanglement of formation to investigate preservation of the quantum correlations in the cloning process .
we compare the three above - described cloning machines used to produce the clones of the non - local system consisting of two qubits formed in the entangled pure state .
any of the bell states can be chosen : @xmath44 determines the amount of entanglement in the state , @xmath45 and for simplicity both @xmath46 and @xmath47 are taken as real .
we decide to use the state @xmath48 .
the states of the clones at the output of the cloning machines considered are described by the following density matrices
wootters - zurek cloning machine ( wzcm ) @xmath49 @xmath50.\ ] ] 2 .
symmetric universal cloning machine ( scm ) @xcite @xmath51 @xmath52 3 .
asymmetric universal cloning machine ( acm ) @xcite
@xmath53 @xmath54 we calculate the entanglement of formation of the output states of the cloning machines described above . in figure [ fig1 ] we show the entanglement of formation of the clones of the states @xmath55 obtained as the result of cloning using the symmetric universal cloning machine and the wootters - zurek cloning machine .
the clones produced by the scm distinctly lose the entanglement , not only the value of entanglement for them is strongly reduced but also some states , which , at the beginning had less entanglement , but have now lost all of it .
the degree of reduction depends upon how much entanglement the state had before the cloning and is maximally equal to a factor @xmath56 for the singlet state @xmath57 .
the entanglement of the clones obtained in cloning by the wzcm is equal to the entanglement of the initial states which were cloned .
the prize for entanglement preservation , which must be paid in this case , is dependence of the fidelity upon the input state of the cloning transformation . .
] an analysis of the asymmetric cloning machine is more complex because two additional parameters characterizing the cloning transformation are presented in this case . in order to describe a mean amount of the entanglement falling to the clones we define an average entanglement per clone : @xmath58.\ ] ] in figure [ fig2 ] we show the average entanglement @xmath59 of the clones of the singlet state @xmath60 for values of the scaling parameters @xmath61 and @xmath62 belonging to the region given by eq .
the maximum of the average entanglement is attained for two degenerate cases , when the state of the cloned pair of qubits does not change or when the cloned pair and the blanc pair swap states .
we exclude these two cases from our analysis because cloning actually do not happen in them .
we see that the average entanglement is largest for values @xmath61 and @xmath62 , which lie on a curve bordering the region containing allowed values of the parameters @xmath27 from a side of larger values of @xmath63 , the curve described by the equation : @xmath64 and attains minimum on the curve which borders the region considered from the opposite side , the curve given by the equation @xmath65 . using acm as a function of the shrinking parameters @xmath61 and @xmath62 . ]
we concentrate our attention on these values of the parameters @xmath27 , which correspond to largest values of the average entanglement . in figure [ fig3 ] the average entanglement @xmath59 of the clones of the singlet state for parameters
@xmath61 and @xmath66 is presented .
a dashed line corresponding to the value of the entanglement of the clones obtained using the symmetric cloning machine is used as a reference .
it turn out that the asymmetric cloning machine can , on average , be evidently better at cloning the entangled states than the symmetric cloning machine , which produces identical but less entangled clones .
the acm allows one to preserve in both clones more entanglement at the cost of a non - uniform distribution of its between the produced clones .
the minimal value of the average entanglement is obtained for @xmath67 , which is precisely the value of the shrinking parameter of the scm . using acm for the shrinking parameters @xmath61 and @xmath68 as a function of the parameter @xmath61 .
the dashed line shows the entanglement of formation of the clones obtained using scm . ]
so far we have studied the average entanglement of the clones of the singlet state .
it is the most representative quantity because the singlet state is maximally entangled state . to complete the considerations concerning the asymmetric cloning machine we show in figure [ fig4 ] the average entanglement @xmath69 for the clones of states @xmath48 for the scaling parameters
@xmath70 lying on the curve corresponding to maximal values of the average entanglement .
produced using acm calculated for scaling parameters @xmath70 as a function of the parameters @xmath46 and @xmath61 . ]
we see that also for states other than the singlet state the acm is more efficient in preserving of the entanglement .
the maximum of the average entanglement is obviously attained for the singlet state and for this state the dependence upon the shrinking parameters is most evident . for other input states
the average entanglement is already less sensitive to changes of the parameter @xmath61 .
comparison of the cloning machines using the entanglement of formation calculated for the clones of the states @xmath48 , presented above , informs us how many of the quantum correlations survive the cloning when the given state is cloned .
we would like also to know , which of the considered cloning machines is better , more efficient , preserve more entanglement on average , when the cloned states are chosen arbitrarily . in order to analyse quantitatively such a quantity
we define a new parameter : a mean entanglement of a family of the states , calculated as the average of the entanglement of formation over the whole ensemble of the input states : @xmath71\ , d\alpha , \\
\overline{e}_{acm}(s_1,s_2 ) & = & \int^{1}_{0 } e^{\,(av)}_{acm}(\alpha|s_1,s_2)\ , d\alpha,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where an index @xmath72 , @xmath73 , specifies the kind of cloning transformation . in the case of the asymmetric cloning machine
the mean entanglement still is a function of the scaling parameters @xmath27 . in the both remaining cases the mean
entanglement is just a number characterizing the global ability of these cloning machines to preserve the quantum correlations in the cloning process .
the mean entanglement of formation for the wzcm and the scm are , respectively , @xmath74 and @xmath75 . in figure [ fig5 ]
we show the mean entanglement of the clones obtained using the acm for the shrinking parameters @xmath70 . .
] we see that the mean entanglement of formation is larger when the acm produces more asymmetric clones and tends to a minimal value for the scaling parameters corresponding to the scm .
the mean entanglement is largest for the wzcm , the result of the cloning process using the acm is much poorer and the mean entanglement of the clones obtained using the scm is already very small and close to zero .
to summarize , in this article we have investigated how the entanglement of formation of the pairs of qubits changes in the cloning process .
we have analysed three kinds of the cloners : the modified version of the state - dependent wootters - zurek cloning machine designed to produce perfect clones of the bell states , the universal symmetric cloning machine producing similar clones and the state - independent asymmetric cloning machine producing clones which are different .
we have computed and compared the entanglement of formation of the clones of the entangled pure states .
we have shown that the entanglement degrades very distinctly in the case of the scm .
the clones produced using the acm are much more entangled , however the entanglement is non - uniformly distributed among the clones .
also , more entanglement is preserved on average in the case of the acm , when mean value of the entanglement per clone is analysed . in the case of the wzcm
the whole entanglement of the cloned systems survive .
we have also defined the new quantity , the mean entanglement calculated as the mean over the whole ensemble of the cloned states , the quantity , which characterizes the cloning machines globally .
the mean entanglement seems to be large enough for the wzcm to hope that such a cloner can be useful in practical applications , but the fidelity of the clones produced is rather poor in this case . in both remaining cases the mean
entanglement is much smaller .
we conclude that the quantum cloning machines can be used to produce the clones of entangled states , however the entanglement of the clones is reduced .
the most entangled are clones obtained using the cloning machine , which is specially designed to preserve the entanglement , but which is rather poor as the cloner .
conversely , the universal cloning machine clones states quite well , but the clones obtained are almost completely devoid of entanglement . the results obtained seems to suggest that the quantum cloning can not actually be used to improve the performance of the quantum computation tasks due to the drastic reduction of the entanglement in the cloning process .
00 w. k. wootters and w. h. zurek , 1982 , _ nature ( london ) _ , * 299 * , 802 .
m. hillery and v. buek , 1997 , _ phys .
a _ , * 56 * , 1212 .
d. bru , 1998 , _ phys .
a _ , * 57 * , 2368 .
a. chefles and s. m. barnett , 1999 , _ phys . rev .
a _ , * 60 * , 136 . v. buek and m. hillery , 1996 , _ phys
a _ , * 54 * , 1844 .
v. buek , s. l. braunstein , m. hillery , and d. bru , 1997 , _ phys .
a _ , * 56 * , 3446 .
r. f. werner , 1998 , _ phys .
rev a _ , * 58 * , 1827 .
v. buek and m. hillery , 1998 , _ phys .
_ , * 81 * , 5003 . m. keyl and r. f. werner , 1999 , _ j. math .
_ , * 40 * , 3283 .
e. f. galvo and l. hardy , 2000 , _ phys .
a _ , * 62 * , 022301 .
r. derka , v. buzek , and a. k. ekert , 1998 , _ phys .
_ , * 80 * , 1571 .
p. masiak and p. l. knight , 2001 , _ fortschr .
_ , * 49 * , 1001 . n. j. ceft , 1998 , _ acta phys .
_ , * 48 * , 115 .
a. aspect , p. grangier , and g. roger , 1981 , _
phys.rev.lett._ , * 47 * , 460 .
a. aspect , p. grangier , and g. roger , 1982 , _
phys.rev.lett._ , * 49 * , 91 .
v. vedral , m. b. plenio , m. a. rippin , and p. l. knight , 1997 , _ phys .
_ , * 78 * , 2275 .
v. vedral , m. b. plenio , k. jacobs , and p. l. knight , 1997 , _ phys .
a _ , * 56 * , 4452 .
s. hill and w. k. wootters , 1997 , _ phys .
_ , * 78 * , 5022 .
w. k. wootters , 1998 , _ phys .
_ , * 80 * , 2245 . | recently galvo and hardy have shown that quantum cloning can improve the performance of some quantum computation tasks .
however such performance enhancement is possible only if quantum correlations survive the cloning process .
we investigate preservation of the quantum correlations in the process of non local cloning of entangled pairs of two level systems .
we consider different kinds of quantum cloning machines and compare their effectiveness in the cloning of non maximally entangled pure states .
a mean entanglement is introduced in order to obtain a quantitative evaluation of an average efficiency for the different cloning machines .
we show that a reduction of the quantum correlations is significant and it strongly depends upon the kind of cloning machine used .
losses of the entanglement are largest in the case of the universal quantum cloning machine .
generally , in all cases considered the losses of the entanglement are so drastic that the method of enhancement for the performance of the quantum computation using the quantum cloning seems to be questionable . |
there has been a great deal of interest in studying collective dynamics of two - dimensional ( 2d ) strongly coupled coulomb systems ( sccss ) in the presence of an external magnetic field @xcite .
early studies were mainly concerned with the 2d electron gas and/or liquid systems , and were largely motivated by their potential applications in the semiconductor industry , e.g. , for metal - oxide - semiconductor ( mos ) structures @xcite .
recently , interests have turned to a slightly different system , i.e. , the so - called strongly coupled complex ( dusty ) plasmas ( scdps ) @xcite .
complex ( dusty ) plasma is a suspension of micron - sized charged dust particles in a weakly ionized plasma with electrons , ions , and neutral atoms or molecules @xcite .
therein , dust particles acquire a few thousand electron charges by absorbing surrounding electrons and ions , and consequently interact with each other via a dynamically screened coulomb potential @xcite while undergoing brownian motion due primarily to frequent collisions with the neutral molecules .
when the interaction potential energy between charged dust particles significantly exceeds their kinetic energy , they become strongly coupled and can form ordered structures comprising liquid and solid states . since the motion of charged dust particles in complex ( dusty ) plasmas can be directly observed in real time by using a video camera , such systems have been generally regarded as a promising model system to study many phenomena occurring in solids , liquids and other sccss at the kinetic level .
the 2d scdp has become particularly favorable in recent laboratory experiments , probably because complications due to the ion - wake effect @xcite can be avoided in 2d systems , and thus the interaction between dust particles can be well approximated by the debye - hckel / yukawa potential @xcite , @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the charge on each particle , @xmath2 is the inter - particle distance , and @xmath3 is the screening length . such a system can be fully characterized in equilibrium by the screening parameter , @xmath4 , and the coulomb coupling strength , @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is the temperature of the system and @xmath7 is the wigner - seitz radius , given by @xmath8 with @xmath9 being the areal density of particles . of great interest in 2d
dusty plasmas are their collective and dynamical properties , such as the longitudinal and transverse wave modes , which have been studied extensively over the past decade in experiments @xcite , theories @xcite , and numerical simulations @xcite ( see , in particular , ref .
@xcite for a review of recent developments ) .
in particular , there has been a growing interest recently in studying the collective dynamics of scdps in an external magnetic field @xcite . however , most of those studies were theoretical .
for example , uchida _
_ et al.__@xcite derived a wave dispersion relation for a 2d yukawa lattice in a perpendicular magnetic field based on the harmonic approximation ( ha ) and compared it with the results obtained through a molecular dynamics ( md ) simulation in a perfect triangular lattice .
et al.__@xcite studied the propagation of mach waves in a 2d magnetized yukawa system based on the random - phase approximation ( rpa ) , where the effect of strong coupling was neglected .
that work was subsequently extended to include the effect of strong coupling @xcite by adopting the quasilocalized charge approximation ( qlca ) @xcite .
moreover , sun _
@xcite examined the influence of an external magnetic field on a dust lattice wave in a plasma crystal .
very recently , farokhi _ et al . _
@xcite derived analytically a wave dispersion relation in a 2d hexagonal yukawa lattice in an external magnetic field with arbitrary direction .
although many theoretical proposals have arisen from the above listed studies @xcite and experimentlists have also attempted to study the dynamics of magnetized dusty plasmas @xcite , exploring these proposals in the laboratory does not seem to be feasible yet due to many technical constraints @xcite .
in this situation , it is desirable to perform numerical experiments that can validate the existing theories and that can serve as a guide for future laboratory experiments .
other than the above - mentioned md simulation by uchida _ _ et al.__@xcite , we have found only two related md simulations in open literature : one studying static structures of 2d magnetized dusty plasmas by liu _ _
et al.__@xcite , and the other studying collective modes in a coulomb system ( 2d strongly correlated electrons ) by ranganathan and johnson @xcite . given that , to the best of our knowledge , there are no computer simulations studying collective modes in magnetized yukawa systems that cover both the liquid and solid states , we perform the numerical experiments here to fill the gap . first , we obtain thermally excited phonon spectra from direct simulations of 2d yukawa systems in a perpendicular magnetic field .
the resulting dispersion relations are then compared with those derived in the above mentioned analytical theories for different values of the screening parameter and the coulomb coupling strength .
the rest of the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
ii , we provide details of our simulations of 2d yukawa solids and liquids with perpendicular magnetic field . in sec .
iii , analytical formulas are given for dispersion relations in the rpa , qlca and ha , and compared with simulations .
a discussion of the results is given in sec .
iv , followed by a brief conclusion in sec . v.
our simulation is performed by using the brownian dynamics ( bd ) method @xcite , in which we assume that numerous and frequent collisions with the neutral - gas molecules give rise to a brownian motion of each dust particle in the plasma .
these collisions give rise to the well - known epstein drag , which is quantified by the friction coefficient , or damping rate @xmath10 .
we therefore need to introduce one additional parameter , the damping coefficient @xmath11 , where @xmath12^{1/2}$ ] is the nominal dusty plasma frequency , enabling us to fully characterize the system @xcite . in our work
, @xmath13 particles are simulated in a square with periodic boundary conditions .
charged dust particles interact with each other via pairwise yukawa potentials , while undergoing brownian motions .
the simulation follows the trajectory of each dust particle by numerically integrating and solving the corresponding langevin equation and its integral @xcite , @xmath14 where , as usual , @xmath15 and @xmath16 are the velocity and position of a dust particle , respectively , and @xmath17 is the systematic ( deterministic ) force coming from interactions with all other dust particles in the system .
furthermore , @xmath18 is the external magnetic field , @xmath19 is the speed of light in vacuum , and @xmath20 is brownian acceleration , respectively . note that the friction coefficient @xmath10 and the brownian acceleration @xmath20 represent complementing effects of the same sub - scale phenomenon : numerous collisions of a brownian particle with the neutral - gas molecules in the system .
while the former represents an average effect of these collisions , the latter represents fluctuations due to the discreteness of collisions and is generally assumed to be well represented by delta - correlated gaussian white noise . the friction coefficient and the brownian acceleration
are both related to the medium temperature through a fluctuation - dissipation theorem .
we adopt here a gear - like predictor - corrector method for our bd simulations , which was used successfully in simulating the shock wave propagation @xcite , the heat conduction @xcite , and diffusion processes in scdps @xcite .
detailed algorithms and procedures for performing these integrations can be found in ref .
the advantages of using the bd method are as follows .
first , it brings the simulation closer to real dusty plasma experiments by taking into account both the brownian motion and the damping effect in a self - consistent manner .
second , it simplifies the simulation as no external thermostat is needed .
initially , charged dust particles are randomly placed in the square .
the system comes to an equilibrium after a period proportional to @xmath21 , typically around @xmath22 , except under conditions with extremely strong coupling and large magnetic field , in which case relaxation of the system becomes extremely slow .
one would expect a faster relaxation of the system ( and therefore a faster simulation ) at higher damping rates .
however , we choose here @xmath23 to minimize the damping effect on collective modes , thus allowing us to concentrate on the effects of the magnetic field .
we note that the effect of neutral - gas damping on collective modes in unmagnetized sdcps has been discussed in detail elsewhere @xcite .
wave spectra are determined from the current - current correlation functions .
we follow the definition given in ref.@xcite , in which the current density of the system is @xmath24 \label{eq_current_density_t},\ ] ] while its fourier transform is given by @xmath25 where @xmath26 and @xmath27 are the position and velocity of the @xmath28th particle at time @xmath29 , respectively , and the index @xmath30 labels cartesian components @xmath31 and @xmath32 . assuming that waves propagate along the @xmath31 direction , i.e. , @xmath33 , one obtains the current - current correlation functions @xmath34 for the directions parallel and perpendicular to the wave propagation direction , respectively .
one recalls that , without the magnetic field , these functions correspond to the longitudinal and transverse modes @xcite , respectively .
here the superscript @xmath35 denotes the complex conjugate while the angular bracket denotes the ensemble average .
the wave spectra are then given by the fourier transforms of the corresponding current - current correlations @xcite
, @xmath36 in simulations , eqs .
( [ eq_spectra ] ) are evaluated by using a discrete fourier transform in a period of @xmath37 .
a general expression for the dispersion relation , @xmath38 , in a magnetized 2d many - body system can be determined by solving the following equation for @xmath39 @xcite , @xmath40 where @xmath41 is the 2d unit matrix , and @xmath42 .
note that the matrix @xmath43\ ] ] accounts for the presence of an external magnetic field , with @xmath44 being the gyrofrequency of dust particles . note that , although we have neglected damping in eq .
( [ eq_m ] ) , it can easily be recovered by replacing @xmath45 with @xmath46 .
the matrix @xmath47 contains details of interactions between dust particles and its form depends on the specific theory used . for convenience ,
we introduce here a new parameter @xmath48 . for typical laboratory dusty plasma parameters ( @xmath49 @xmath50 , @xmath51 ev
, @xmath52 ev , the radius of dust particles @xmath53 m , @xmath54 g , @xmath55 e and @xmath56 @xmath57 ) , one has @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath60 and @xmath61 for @xmath62 , @xmath63 , @xmath64 , and @xmath65 tesla , respectively . in the rpa
, one obtains @xcite @xmath66 where @xmath67 is the 2d fourier transform of the yukawa potential @xcite . the dispersion relation in the rpa
can then be obtained by substituting eq .
( [ eq_m_rpa ] ) into eq .
( [ eq_m ] ) @xcite as @xmath68 where @xmath69 .
it is clear that the mode given in eq.([eq_wk_rpa ] ) is a hybrid cyclotron - plasmon mode in 2d resulting from a superposition of the cyclotron oscillations due to the magnetic field and a 2d dust - acoustic wave .
it corresponds to the so - called magnetoplasmon mode in pure coulomb systems @xcite , and is reduced to the usual 2d dust - acoustic mode when @xmath70 @xcite .
more details of the derivation above can be found in ref .
@xcite .
and @xmath71 directions with @xmath72 , @xmath73 and @xmath74 .
dashed lines are the dispersion relations determined by the rpa and qlca.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] ( solid lines with filled circles ) and @xmath71 ( solid lines with filled squares ) directions at several fixed wavenumbers with @xmath72 , @xmath73 and @xmath74.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] and @xmath71 directions ) for @xmath72 , @xmath73 and @xmath74 .
dashed lines are the dispersion relations determined by the rpa and the qlca.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] in the qlca , one has @xcite @xmath75 the second term , @xmath76 $ ] ( with @xmath77 and @xmath78 ) , is the @xmath79 dynamical matrix of the qlca @xcite , which takes into account the short - range inter - particle correlations that are missing in the rpa . by neglecting this term
, we immediately recover the rpa result given in eq .
( [ eq_m_rpa ] ) . for the qlca @xcite , the wave dispersion relation has two branches : the _ high_-frequency branch @xmath80 and the _ low_-frequency branch @xmath81 , which are given by @xmath82 \nonumber \\ & \pm & \frac{1}{2}\sqrt{[d_{l}(q)+d_{t}(q)+\omega^{2}_{0}(q)+\omega^2_{c}]^2 + 4\omega^{2}_{c}d_{t}(q ) } , \label{eq_wk_qlca}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath83 and @xmath84 are the projections of @xmath85 on the longitudinal and transverse directions , respectively .
one recognizes that the high - frequency branch is actually the magnetoplasmon mode with corrections due to particle - particle correlations , while the low - frequency branch is identified as the magnetoshear mode , which is maintained by the strong particle - particle correlations . when @xmath70 , eqs .
( [ eq_wk_qlca ] ) yield the longitudinal and transverse modes of the qlca in unmagnetized 2d yukawa liquids , respectively @xcite .
it should be noted that the presence of the magnetic field does not alter the general scenario of the longitudinal and transverse modes at @xmath86 , although it strongly modifies the dispersion relation .
namely , one sees that both @xmath83 and @xmath84 appear in both the high- and low - frequency branches as a result of the interplay between the particle - particle correlations and the external magnetic field .
in addition , let us mention that the magnetic field has no effect on the static structure of a system in equilibrium .
therefore , expressions for @xmath87 and @xmath88 are exactly the same as those obtained without the magnetic field @xcite .
in the ha , it is assumed that the charged dust particles form a perfect triangular lattice in 2d and are located at the points of that lattice while performing thermal oscillations around their equilibrium positions . in this case
, one needs to adopt an another strategy to obtain the interaction matrix and the dispersion relation .
one finds @xcite @xmath89\equiv [ m_{\mu\nu}(\mathbf{q } ) ] , \label{eq_m_ha}\ ] ] where again @xmath77 and @xmath78 , and the summation over @xmath28 includes all points on the triangular lattice @xcite .
the resulting dispersion relations correspond to the so - called magnetophonon modes @xcite , and are quite similar to those of the qlca .
there are two branches , given by @xmath90 \nonumber \\
& \pm & \frac{1}{2}\sqrt{[m_{xx}+m_{yy}+\omega^2_{c}]^2 + 4(m^{2}_{xy}-m_{xx}m_{yy } ) } , \label{eq_wk_ha}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath91 is determined by eq .
( [ eq_m_ha ] ) .
the wave propagation depends on the polarization angle @xmath92 , and the corresponding dispersion relations are periodic functions of @xmath92 with a period of @xmath93 due to the hexagonal symmetry @xcite .
the angular dependence arises because the system is now anisotropic at short wavelengths .
and @xmath71 directions ) for @xmath72 , @xmath73 and @xmath94 .
dashed lines are the dispersion relations determined by the rpa and the qlca.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] and @xmath71 directions ) for @xmath72 , @xmath73 and @xmath95 .
dashed lines are the dispersion relations determined by the rpa and the qlca.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] and @xmath71 directions ) for @xmath72 , @xmath73 and @xmath96 .
dashed lines are the dispersion relations determined by the rpa and the qlca.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] and @xmath71 directions ) for @xmath72 , @xmath73 and @xmath96 .
solid lines are the angle - dependent dispersion relations determined by the ha , with light - gray ( yellow ) for the high - frequency branch and dark - gray ( red ) for the low - frequency branch , respectively.,scaledwidth=80.0% ]
as a typical example , we show in fig .
[ fig_b05_k1g200_0 ] the simulation wave spectra in both the longitudinal ( @xmath97 ) and transverse ( @xmath71 ) directions for @xmath72 , @xmath73 and @xmath74 , along with the dispersion relations from the rpa and qlca theories .
the results clearly show that the high- and low - frequency branches co - exist in both the longitudinal and transverse directions .
the high - frequency magnetoplasmon modes @xcite exhibit typical oscillations that originate from the short - range order in strongly coupled systems @xcite , whereas their long wavelength limits approach the cyclotron - plasmon oscillation frequency .
however , the two branches of modes are not isotropic because the wave spectra appear to be different in the @xmath97 and @xmath71 directions .
this is shown particularly clearly in the low - frequency branches .
for example , there is a gap at long wavelengths of the low - frequency branch in the @xmath97 direction , and a gap around the first trough of oscillations in the @xmath71 direction .
this indicates that coupling between the longitudinal and transverse modes strongly depends on both the wavenumber and frequency @xcite . a more detailed analysis of the frequency dependence of this coupling is shown in fig .
[ fig_b05_k1g200_a ] for several wavenumbers , where one can see that the amount of energy in the low- and high - frequency branches is redistributed between the two directions of wave propagation in a complementary manner .
for example , when analyzing long wavelengths , one finds more energy in the low - frequency branch for the transverse direction than for the longitudinal direction , while there is more energy in the high - frequency branch for the longitudinal direction than for the transverse direction .
the roles of the transverse and longitudinal directions can be reversed at other wavelengths , as shown in fig .
[ fig_b05_k1g200_a ] for @xmath98 .
we have observed in our simulations that such an effect occurs for any value of the coupling strength , and is more pronounced for higher @xmath99s .
we note that a similar effect was observed previously in the md simulation of a perfect triangular lattice @xcite . in the following
, we shall simply add the wave spectra obtained in both directions to achieve a more complete picture of both the high- and low - frequency branches .
this is done in fig .
[ fig_b05_k1g200 ] using the data from fig.[fig_b05_k1g200_0 ] , where both branches now show similar oscillatory structures .
one observes that the qlca captures the dispersion of the high - frequency wave spectra very well in a reasonably large range of wavelengths , whereas the rpa displays noticeable discrepancy with our simulations except in the long wavelength limit .
for the low - frequency branch , the agreement between the qlca and simulations is less satisfactory , although the qlca seems to give the correct trend in the oscillatory structures of the spectra .
we first examine how collective dynamics depends on the state of the system .
figures [ fig_b05_k1g10 ] , [ fig_b05_k1g100 ] , and [ fig_b05_k1g1000_eqlca ] show the wave spectra for a high temperature liquid with @xmath94 , a cool liquid with @xmath95 , and a crystalline state with @xmath96 , respectively , where @xmath73 and @xmath72 are kept fixed in all three figures .
one sees from fig .
[ fig_b05_k1g10 ] that , at @xmath94 , both the high- and low - frequency modes are heavily damped at short wavelengths , say @xmath100 , and there are essentially no collective modes beyond @xmath101 .
one would attribute this to landau damping and viscous / collisional damping .
the qlca dispersion relation again agrees reasonably well with our simulations for the high - frequency branch , in the region where the peak in the spectra is distinguishable , while the agreement between the qlca and our simulations is poorer for the low - frequency branch .
there may be several reasons for this . on one hand , since the low - frequency mode is always heavily damped in the simulations , the corresponding wave spectra spread out in the @xmath102 plane , and it is difficult to isolate their peak positions . on the other hand , it is well known that most of the damping effects , such as landau damping and diffusional damping , are not included in the qlca @xcite .
this can be related to the inability of the qlca to predict the long wavelength cutoff in the shear mode , which is clearly seen in the low - frequency branch in fig .
[ fig_b05_k1g10 ] .
as expected , the damping effect becomes much weaker with increasing @xmath103 or , equivalently , with decreasing temperature .
when @xmath95 , one observes from fig .
[ fig_b05_k1g100 ] that the wave spectra are largely extended in the short wavelength direction , and so is the region of agreement between the qlca and the simulations for the high - frequency branch . however , the discrepancy between the qlca and the simulations for the low - frequency branch is still significant .
a substantial improvement is observed only in fig .
[ fig_b05_k1g1000_eqlca ] at @xmath96 , for which the long wavelength cutoff in the low - frequency branch disappears and oscillatory structures are quite distinguishable in both branches .
a good agreement between the qlca and simulations is found in both branches , particularly in the first brillouin zone . for shorter wavelengths ,
some fine structures appear in the spectra due to the angular dependence of the wave dispersion , and the qlca dispersion can only give a correct tendency of the oscillations .
the task of resolving full angular dependence of the wave dispersion lies beyond the capability of the qlca , but this issue can be tackled by the ha , as shown next .
and @xmath71 directions ) for @xmath104 , @xmath73 and @xmath96 .
dashed lines are the dispersion relations determined by the rpa and the qlca .
solid lines are the angle - dependent dispersion relations determined by the ha , with light - gray ( yellow ) for the high - frequency branch and dark - gray ( red ) for the low - frequency branch , respectively.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] figure [ fig_b05_k1g1000_ha ] displays the same spectra as shown in fig . [ fig_b05_k1g1000_eqlca ] , but comparisons are made with the dispersion results from the ha .
there are two groups of dispersions from the ha , corresponding to the high- and low - frequency modes , respectively , and in each group ten different curves that cover the period of @xmath93 evenly are shown .
one sees that the structure of the wave spectra is well overlapped by the ha dispersion curves , indicating a good agreement between the ha and our simulation . by comparing the results of the ha and those of the qlca in fig .
[ fig_b05_k1g1000_eqlca ] , one concludes that the qlca gives a kind of angle - averaged dispersion .
and @xmath71 directions ) for @xmath105 , @xmath73 and @xmath96 .
solid lines are the angle - dependent dispersion relations determined by the ha , with light - gray ( yellow ) for the high - frequency branch and dark - gray ( red ) for the low - frequency branch , respectively.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] and @xmath71 directions ) for @xmath72 , @xmath106 and @xmath96 . dashed lines are the dispersion relations determined by the rpa and the qlca.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] next , we analyze the dependence of wave spectra on the intensity of the external magnetic field . figure [ fig_b03_k1g1000 ] shows wave spectra for @xmath104 ( with other parameters being the same as those in fig .
[ fig_b05_k1g1000_ha ] ) , together with the dispersions from both the qlca and the ha . comparing with fig .
[ fig_b05_k1g1000_ha ] , one sees from fig.[fig_b03_k1g1000 ] that the oscillations in the wave spectra are greatly enhanced in this case , and fine structures due to the angular dependence in the wave propagation direction are enriched . as before
, the agreement with the qlca is clearly shown for both branches , roughly within the first brillouin zone . on the other hand
, one sees that the ha captures the fine structures in the wave spectra very well .
the fact that the wave spectra in the high - frequency branch exhibit a gap in certain directions of propagation at the wavelengths @xmath107 can be rationalized as follows . since our simulation of the crystal lattice unavoidably has defects and contains distinct domains with different orientations , the measured wave spectra are expected to exhibit some preference to certain angles of propagation based on the dominant crystal orientation .
one can roughly estimate such an effect by comparing the spectral distributions with the ha dispersion relations , as illustrated in fig.[fig_b03_k1g1000 ] . on the other hand ,
both the oscillations and fine structures in the wave spectra are suppressed for stronger magnetic fields , as shown in fig .
[ fig_b10_k1g1000 ] for @xmath105 , along with the dispersions from the ha .
one sees in that figure that the high - frequency branch is raised above @xmath108 and its width is greatly reduced , as is the width of the low - frequency branch , when the magnetic field increases .
and @xmath71 directions ) for @xmath72 , @xmath109 and @xmath96 .
dashed lines are the dispersion relations determined by the rpa and the qlca.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] finally , we examine the effect of screening on the wave spectra .
figures [ fig_b05_k2g1000 ] , [ fig_b05_k3g1000 ] , and fig.[fig_b05_k1g1000_eqlca ] compare the wave spectra for screening parameters @xmath106 , 3 and 1 , respectively , with @xmath96 and @xmath72 kept fixed . the dispersion relations from the rpa and qlca are also shown for comparison .
it is seen that , with increasing @xmath110 , the oscillatory structures in the spectra gradually flatten out , so that the dispersions become almost featureless when @xmath111 . at the same time , the width of the low - frequency branch decreases continuously with increasing @xmath110 and , for @xmath111 , the spectra become very blurry due to heavy damping .
in this paper , we have used the brownian dynamics simulation to generate wave spectra of 2d strongly coupled dusty plasmas in an external magnetic field . we have examined how these spectra are affected by the coupling strength in such systems and by the intensity of the magnetic field . in particular , we have compared the dispersion relations resulting from the simulation wave spectra with those obtained from several analytical theories , including the random - phase approximation , quasi - localized charge approximation and the harmonic approximation .
two branches of collective modes are generally observed in our simulation : the high - frequency magnetoplasmon and the low - frequency magnetoshear modes .
the rpa can only reproduce the high - frequency branch , i.e. , the magnetoplasmon mode , and it gives a good approximation only in the long wavelength limit , but remains robust for increasing coupling strengths , even up to the crystalline state .
the qlca can reproduce both of the above modes , and it shows a particularly good agreement with the simulation in the high - frequency branch for wide ranges of coupling strengths , screening parameters and magnetic field magnitudes . however , the agreement between the qlca dispersion relations and the simulation spectra is generally poor in the low - frequency branch , particularly in a high - temperature liquid state , probably because landau and diffusional damping are neglected in the qlca .
the situation becomes better in a crystalline state where a good agreement between the qlca and the simulation is found in the low - frequency branch within the entire first brillouin zone .
however , the qlca can not capture fine structures in the wave spectra due to angular - dependence of the wave propagation in the crystalline state .
in this case , it is found that the ha can give a very good description of the collective dispersions observed in the simulation .
our simulations show that the wave spectra exhibit profiles at fixed wavenumbers that have variable widths in the frequency domain .
these widths generally correspond to various dissipation mechanisms that give rise to damping of the collective dynamics in strongly coupled systems .
we note that we have deliberately chosen a very weak collisional damping on the neutral - gas molecules in order to reveal the effects of the magnetic field and other parameters . while comparisons of the observed widths can not be made with the above analytical theories , we have found some general trends in our simulations . the strongest effect on the frequency widths of wave spectra was found to come from the coupling strength , with the widths strongly increasing with increasing temperature of the system .
this is similar to the observations in unmagnetized sdcps @xcite . with regards to the intensity of the magnetic field ,
the spectra were found to be narrower at higher magnetic fields , whereas lower magnetic fields are accompanied by broad , fine structures in the spectra reflecting a strong anisotropy in the direction of propagation .
these structures are generally very well captured by the families of dispersion relations coming from the ha .
finally , we have found that increasing the screening parameter gives rise to narrower and flatter wave spectra , with the low - frequency branch reduced to a heavily - damped mode akin to low - frequency noise .
clearly , more theoretical work is necessary to fully understand the dissipation mechanisms in strongly - coupled dusty plasmas in the presence of a magnetic field .
99 k. w. chiu and j. j. quinn , phys .
b * 9 * , 4724 ( 1974 ) . h. fukuyama , solid state commun . * 17 * , 1323 ( 1975 ) . l. bonsall and a. a. maradudin , phys
b * 15 * , 1959 ( 1977 ) .
r. cte and a. h. macdonald , phys .
b * 44 * , 8759 ( 1991 ) . k. i. golden , g. kalman , and ph .
wyns , phys .
b * 48 * , 8882 ( 1993 ) .
s. ranganathan , r. e. johnson , and c. e. woodward , phys .
40 * , 673 ( 2002 ) .
s. ranganathan , and r. e. johnson , phys .
b * 71 * , 035339 ( 2005 ) .
p. k. shukla and a. a. mamun , _ introduction to dusty plasma physics _
( institute of physics , bristol , 2002 ) .
p. k. shukla and b. eliasson , rev .
phys . * 81 * , 25 ( 2009 ) .
m. lampe , g. joyce , and g. ganguli , phys .
plasmas * 7 * , 3851 ( 2000 ) ; ieee trans .
plasma sci .
* 33 * , 57 ( 2005 )
. m. nambu , s. v. vladimirov , and p. k. shukla , phys .
a * 203 * , 40 ( 1995 ) .
p. k. shukla and n. n. rao , phys .
plasmas * 3 * , 1770 ( 1996 ) .
u. konopka , g. e. morfill , and l. ratke , phys .
* 84 * , 891 ( 2000 ) .
d. s. lemons , m. s. murillo , w. daughton , and d. winske , phys .
plasmas * 7 * , 2306 ( 2000 ) .
a. homann , a. melzer , s. peters , and a. piel , phys .
e * 56 * , 7138 ( 1997 ) .
a. homann , a. melzer , s. peters , r. madani , and a. piel , phys .
a * 242 * , 173 ( 1998 ) .
s. nunomura , j. goree , s. hu , x. g. wang , a. bhattacharjee , and k. avinash , phys .
89 , 035001 ( 2002 ) .
s. zhdanov , s. nunomura , d. samsonov , and g. morfill , phys .
e * 68 * , 035401(r ) ( 2003 ) .
s. nunomura , s. zhdanov , d. samsonov , and g. morfill , phys .
* 94 * , 045001 ( 2005 ) .
v. nosenko , j. goree , and a. piel , phys .
* 97 * , 115001 ( 2006 ) .
d. dubin , phys .
plasmas * 7 * , 3895 ( 2000 ) .
x. g. wang , a. bhattacharjee , and s. hu , phys .
86 * , 2569 ( 2001 ) .
m. s. murillo and d. o. gericke , j. phys .
a : math . gen . * 36 * , 6273 ( 2003 ) g. j. kalman , p. hartmann , z. donk , and m. rosenberg , phys .
lett . * 92 * , 065001 ( 2004 ) .
a. piel and j. goree , phys .
plasmas * 13 * , 104510 ( 2006 ) .
t. sullivan , g. j. kalman , s. kyrkos , p. bakshi , m. rosenberg and z. donk , j. phys .
a : math . gen . * 39 * , 4607 ( 2006 ) .
z. donk , g. j. kalman , and p. hartmann , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 20 * , 413101 ( 2008 ) .
l. j. hou , z. l. mikovi , alexander piel and m. s. murillo , phys .
e * 79 * , 046412
. g. uchida , u. konopka , and g. morfill , phys .
rev . lett . * 93 * , 155002 ( 2004 ) .
k. jiang , l. j. hou , x. xu , and y. n. wang , new . j. phys . * 9 * , 57 ( 2007 ) . k. jiang , y. h. song , and y. n. wang , phys .
plasmas * 14 * , 103708 ( 2007 ) .
x. x. sun , c. h. wang , x. g. wang , chin .
* 24 * , 771 ( 2007 ) .
b. farokhi , m. shahmansouri and p. k. shukla , phys .
plasmas * 16 * , 063704 ( 2009 ) .
i. pilch , a. piel , t. trottenberg , and m. e. koepke , phys .
plasmas * 14 * , 123704 ( 2007 ) ; i. pilch , t. reichstein , and a. piel , phys .
plasmas * 15 * , 103706 ( 2008 ) .
s. f. liu , x. wang , b. l. hu , l. wang and y. h. liu , j. phys . a : math .
* 38 * , 3057 ( 2005 ) .
m. p. allen and d. j. tildesley , _ computer simulation of liquids _
( oxford university press , new york , 1989 ) , chapter 9 . l. j. hou , and z. l. mikovi , a. piel and p. k. shukla , phys .
plasmas * 16 * , 053705 ( 2009 ) .
v. e. fortov , o. s. vaulina , o. f. petrov , v. i. molotkov , a. m. lipaev , v. m. torchinsky , h. m. thomas , g. e. morfill , s. a. khrapak , yu .
p. semenov , a. i. ivanov , s. k. krikalev , a. yu .
kalery , s. v. zaletin and yu .
p. gidzenko , phys .
lett . * 90 * , 245005 ( 2003 ) .
d. s. lemons and d. l. kaufman , ieee trans .
plasma sci .
* 27 * , 1288 ( 1999 ) .
d. s. lemons , _ an introduction to stochastic processes in physics _ ( the johns hopkins university press , baltimore , 2002 ) , chapters 6 - 10 .
k. jiang , l. j. hou , y. n. wang , and z. l. mikovi , phys .
e * 73 * , 016404 ( 2006 ) .
l. j. hou , and a. piel , phys .
plasmas * 15 * , 073707 ( 2008 ) .
l. j. hou , and a. piel , j. phys .
a : math . theor . * 42 * , 214025 ( 2009 ) .
l. j. hou , a. piel and p. k. shukla , phys .
lett . * 102 * , 085002 ( 2009 ) .
j. p. boon and s. yip . _ molecular hydrodynamics _
( dover , new york , 1991 ) , chapter 2 . k. i. golden , and g. j. kalman , phys .
plasmas * 7 * , 14 ( 2000 ) . m. rosenberg and g. kalman , phys .
e * 56 * , 7166 ( 1997 ) .
g. kalman , m. rosenberg , and h. e. dewitt , phys .
* 84 * , 6030 ( 2000 ) | thermally excited phonon spectra of 2d yukawa solids and liquids in the presence of an external magnetic field are studied using computer simulations .
special attention is paid to the variation of wave spectra in terms of several key parameters , such as the strength of coupling , the screening parameter , and the intensity of the magnetic field .
in addition , comparisons are made with several analytical theories , including random - phase approximation , quasi - localized charge approximation , and harmonic approximation , and the validity of those theories is discussed in the present context . |
Subsets and Splits