id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01620v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01620v2 | MAGDi: Structured Distillation of Multi-Agent Interaction Graphs Improves Reasoning in Smaller Language Models | 2024-02-02T18:35:14 | 2024-06-07T18:13:16 | Justin Chih-Yao Chen, Swarnadeep Saha, Elias Stengel-Eskin, Mohit Bansal | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-agent interactions between Large Language Model (LLM) agents have shown
major improvements on diverse reasoning tasks. However, these involve long
generations from multiple models across several rounds, making them expensive.
Moreover, these multi-agent approaches fail to provide a final, single model
for efficient inference. To address this, we introduce MAGDi, a new method for
structured distillation of the reasoning interactions between multiple LLMs
into smaller LMs. MAGDi teaches smaller models by representing multi-agent
interactions as graphs, augmenting a base student model with a graph encoder,
and distilling knowledge using three objective functions: next-token
prediction, a contrastive loss between correct and incorrect reasoning, and a
graph-based objective to model the interaction structure. Experiments on seven
widely used commonsense and math reasoning benchmarks show that MAGDi improves
the reasoning capabilities of smaller models, outperforming several methods
that distill from a single teacher and multiple teachers. Moreover, MAGDi also
demonstrates an order of magnitude higher efficiency over its teachers. We
conduct extensive analyses to show that MAGDi (1) enhances the generalizability
to out-of-domain tasks, (2) scales positively with the size and strength of the
base student model, and (3) obtains larger improvements (via our multi-teacher
training) when applying self-consistency -- an inference technique that relies
on model diversity. | [
-0.41584545373916626,
-0.771215558052063,
0.6343732476234436,
0.09115277230739594,
0.06589144468307495,
0.3715629577636719,
-0.25301593542099,
0.005833333823829889,
0.04520746320486069,
0.1246938556432724,
-0.34697777032852173,
-0.38950538635253906,
-0.5416169166564941,
0.23764082789421082,
-0.21469666063785553,
0.7251152992248535,
0.19534876942634583,
0.32529741525650024,
-0.5536026954650879,
0.057046934962272644,
-0.16169095039367676,
-0.47951793670654297,
-0.49046409130096436,
-0.8523550629615784,
0.5406289100646973,
0.48814845085144043,
0.717267632484436,
0.36586207151412964,
0.3932487666606903,
0.43958309292793274,
-0.1970052272081375,
0.97240149974823,
-0.5554637312889099,
0.100674107670784,
-0.4428803324699402,
-0.31421101093292236,
-0.5820726156234741,
0.15265853703022003,
0.6466086506843567,
1.0292998552322388,
-0.13159382343292236,
-0.11627797782421112,
0.16095587611198425,
0.7975088357925415,
-0.8448450565338135,
0.26297178864479065,
-0.43320232629776,
-0.15573590993881226,
0.20896877348423004,
0.08366638422012329,
-0.8334086537361145,
-0.20544099807739258,
-0.05175312981009483,
-0.6084203720092773,
0.017718641087412834,
-0.2479841560125351,
0.669698178768158,
0.38648131489753723,
-0.7590572834014893,
-0.25032395124435425,
-0.7243272662162781,
0.5966137647628784,
-0.4459543228149414,
0.37126442790031433,
0.37722039222717285,
0.3331149220466614,
-0.4600234627723694,
-1.024570107460022,
-0.6806736588478088,
0.03277328982949257,
-0.20662161707878113,
-0.0333421565592289,
-0.3328850269317627,
0.15340173244476318,
0.21789845824241638,
0.14686086773872375,
-0.09033732116222382,
-0.2258892059326172,
-0.518551766872406,
-0.002989702858030796,
0.7090697288513184,
0.026423366740345955,
0.09700299799442291,
-0.0018278772477060556,
-0.140487939119339,
-0.13191717863082886,
-0.6924143433570862,
-0.10179433971643448,
0.3822747766971588,
0.3861764669418335,
0.22303429245948792,
0.62739497423172,
-0.1436179131269455,
0.6744709014892578,
0.3248343765735626,
-0.5269641280174255,
0.3440859317779541,
-0.531005859375,
-0.25289660692214966,
-0.16378840804100037,
0.6627650260925293,
0.2086290419101715,
0.4714736044406891,
-0.11193925887346268,
0.1672678142786026,
-0.05473748967051506,
-0.09156322479248047,
-1.1064742803573608,
-0.6317571997642517,
0.013370614498853683,
-0.20465582609176636,
-0.18523672223091125,
-0.006162455305457115,
-0.5371797680854797,
-0.5089694261550903,
-0.3794970214366913,
0.22638754546642303,
-0.546558141708374,
-0.3101414442062378,
0.19384479522705078,
-0.3631901443004608,
-0.22728882730007172,
0.45206037163734436,
-0.7849970459938049,
0.4014054238796234,
0.679848313331604,
0.888973593711853,
0.06332552433013916,
-0.6984217762947083,
-0.7936432957649231,
0.3777294158935547,
-0.37927931547164917,
0.8359113335609436,
-0.8143856525421143,
-0.5128530859947205,
-0.5227809548377991,
-0.15916095674037933,
-0.3146856129169464,
-0.4125346839427948,
0.1813037246465683,
-0.15394505858421326,
0.025809472426772118,
-0.2950481176376343,
-0.5458000302314758,
-0.16149704158306122,
0.319937139749527,
-0.6670124530792236,
0.8660746812820435,
0.047136642038822174,
-0.6423556804656982,
0.31435272097587585,
-0.7356316447257996,
-0.3141597509384155,
-0.21658693253993988,
0.05110830068588257,
-0.37051889300346375,
-0.03297922760248184,
0.455035924911499,
0.26567867398262024,
-0.1650860756635666,
0.2548275291919708,
-0.4996573030948639,
-0.398639440536499,
0.11595671623945236,
-0.3276899755001068,
0.7212828993797302,
0.3480105698108673,
0.15073944628238678,
0.09399192035198212,
-0.5958276987075806,
0.08532819151878357,
0.0959741622209549,
-0.09662927687168121,
-0.5518503785133362,
0.12639294564723969,
-0.6769112348556519,
0.07796736806631088,
0.07623180747032166,
-0.2460959106683731,
0.6156682968139648,
-0.36849623918533325,
0.6989062428474426,
0.6372132897377014,
-0.011219772510230541,
0.8726043105125427,
-0.10230284184217453,
0.25491228699684143,
0.15724192559719086,
0.13297328352928162,
-0.08734196424484253,
-0.46076712012290955,
-0.5846726298332214,
-0.8680689334869385,
0.4050121307373047,
0.1530763804912567,
-0.9201192855834961,
0.028348518535494804,
-0.20254802703857422,
-0.6335800290107727,
-0.4807729721069336,
0.23043346405029297,
0.33341866731643677,
0.46950748562812805,
0.3266531229019165,
0.07213322818279266,
-0.30708831548690796,
-0.5899514555931091,
0.03572332113981247,
-0.18165846168994904,
0.19656643271446228,
0.05407676473259926,
0.6471943855285645,
-0.30548056960105896,
1.1396210193634033,
-0.707645058631897,
-0.18327797949314117,
-0.43535134196281433,
0.07979966700077057,
0.10452517867088318,
0.24021661281585693,
0.7535189986228943,
-0.6489482522010803,
-0.7732577323913574,
0.01174772996455431,
-0.480370432138443,
-0.13341273367404938,
0.07866595685482025,
-0.4480718672275543,
-0.18254898488521576,
0.28512170910835266,
-0.5888673663139343,
0.32880333065986633,
0.35925641655921936,
-0.4437974691390991,
0.35145726799964905,
-0.3799428641796112,
0.23891322314739227,
-1.0093786716461182,
-0.3463497459888458,
-0.2582757771015167,
-0.2794908881187439,
-0.7345572113990784,
-0.06393220275640488,
-0.07295947521924973,
0.02810022421181202,
-0.26189833879470825,
0.5461467504501343,
-0.6541767120361328,
-0.016293255612254143,
-0.45687270164489746,
0.2832326591014862,
0.6676056385040283,
0.40788888931274414,
-0.16497628390789032,
0.9740337133407593,
0.5949731469154358,
-0.30683571100234985,
0.5040282011032104,
0.30466172099113464,
-0.01159153413027525,
0.6696415543556213,
-0.6583845615386963,
0.24553744494915009,
-0.21966522932052612,
0.27520984411239624,
-0.9556205868721008,
0.08373433351516724,
0.24218158423900604,
-0.3939363658428192,
0.12582625448703766,
-0.38732150197029114,
-0.5730387568473816,
-0.31081458926200867,
-0.20459400117397308,
0.2914077937602997,
0.15043531358242035,
-0.7554459571838379,
1.064191460609436,
0.2039792239665985,
0.11749647557735443,
-0.6600229740142822,
-0.503902792930603,
-0.08810662478208542,
-0.11080507934093475,
-0.6761531829833984,
-0.08052235841751099,
-0.15345361828804016,
-0.6654192805290222,
0.2072991281747818,
-0.10437717288732529,
-0.43480855226516724,
0.3513413965702057,
0.22062024474143982,
0.2015969306230545,
0.10503558814525604,
0.48499688506126404,
0.42751169204711914,
0.0030939059797674417,
-0.055700406432151794,
-0.1745794415473938,
0.542159378528595,
-0.41623109579086304,
-0.6532262563705444,
-0.2053719013929367,
0.38777679204940796,
0.5134971141815186,
-0.44043147563934326,
0.9667103886604309,
0.34546709060668945,
-0.19630271196365356,
-0.4617665410041809,
-0.12796010076999664,
-0.24922537803649902,
-0.5020104050636292,
0.32289624214172363,
-0.9094957709312439,
-0.5555466413497925,
0.2718176245689392,
-0.4294511675834656,
-0.0878196731209755,
0.3290356993675232,
0.470899760723114,
0.10646478086709976,
1.266196846961975,
0.441601037979126,
0.19779334962368011,
0.32371222972869873,
-0.6004886031150818,
0.3599735498428345,
-0.5574875473976135,
-0.4448433518409729,
-0.3760084807872772,
-0.29147201776504517,
-0.1067318245768547,
-0.5963619351387024,
0.30732688307762146,
0.36926698684692383,
-0.3055524230003357,
0.07469819486141205,
-0.696554958820343,
0.9364661574363708,
0.5570110082626343,
0.03178596496582031,
0.6456855535507202,
-0.030426425859332085,
-0.07249129563570023,
0.17572025954723358,
-0.7492302656173706,
-0.5340604782104492,
1.106337070465088,
0.0645696371793747,
0.885278046131134,
0.2698846459388733,
0.9546734690666199,
0.2984972894191742,
0.476855605840683,
-0.6464636921882629,
0.4722099304199219,
-0.01314342301338911,
-0.4632892906665802,
-0.35565054416656494,
-0.5549006462097168,
-0.8115261793136597,
0.8328087329864502,
-0.20560693740844727,
-0.5336487889289856,
0.43100085854530334,
0.07008036226034164,
-0.08706460893154144,
0.30746087431907654,
-1.3526122570037842,
0.7938978672027588,
0.08029960840940475,
-0.2985434830188751,
-0.13544374704360962,
-0.3465556204319,
0.41342225670814514,
-0.06507840007543564,
0.2436840832233429,
-0.39384061098098755,
0.25757071375846863,
0.2707953453063965,
-0.8486346006393433,
0.7913927435874939,
-0.0779094472527504,
-0.0563853494822979,
0.6307607889175415,
0.06232626363635063,
0.6351190209388733,
0.07855959981679916,
-0.26193860173225403,
0.0688251405954361,
0.18919257819652557,
-0.4178236722946167,
-0.9806792736053467,
0.5794867873191833,
-0.8637993335723877,
-0.6240370273590088,
-0.3284669518470764,
-0.8751713037490845,
-0.024970345199108124,
0.21927471458911896,
-0.15088121592998505,
0.39126646518707275,
0.062415529042482376,
-0.018549835309386253,
0.25787553191185,
0.4898579716682434,
0.21456608176231384,
0.4369620084762573,
-0.2506884038448334,
-0.3733747601509094,
0.8577800393104553,
0.16989466547966003,
0.48159059882164,
0.0051853167824447155,
0.20904476940631866,
-0.24023079872131348,
-0.16317328810691833,
-0.24485771358013153,
0.33918026089668274,
-1.0449284315109253,
-0.25595176219940186,
-0.5773205161094666,
-0.2252012938261032,
-0.5380022525787354,
-0.23469038307666779,
-0.5268985629081726,
-0.530042290687561,
-0.33435124158859253,
-0.1846168041229248,
0.3124030828475952,
0.6354677081108093,
-0.37993165850639343,
0.25983747839927673,
-0.479815810918808,
0.20913468301296234,
0.48847538232803345,
-0.1368819922208786,
-0.0023027663119137287,
-0.20488791167736053,
-0.14124736189842224,
0.38542336225509644,
-0.31436336040496826,
-1.020198941230774,
0.3699110448360443,
0.6233372092247009,
0.5312679409980774,
0.5539889931678772,
0.28858423233032227,
0.9010668992996216,
-0.6770700216293335,
0.3067193627357483,
0.2810712456703186,
-1.1680277585983276,
0.43175196647644043,
0.22777575254440308,
0.0524260550737381,
0.39288267493247986,
0.22040650248527527,
-0.17693378031253815,
-0.474954217672348,
-0.3574373722076416,
-0.4852953851222992,
0.5403739213943481,
0.11566144973039627,
-0.03320199251174927,
-0.2952159643173218,
0.2422969937324524,
-0.01906644180417061,
0.23360982537269592,
-0.4569629728794098,
-0.4424402713775635,
-0.397598534822464,
-0.17832449078559875,
-0.0498926118016243,
-0.19016370177268982,
-0.49202799797058105,
-0.6154037714004517,
0.565367579460144,
-0.4243496060371399,
-0.005823810119181871,
0.1576376110315323,
-0.1790838986635208,
0.21855317056179047,
0.23807016015052795,
0.37827154994010925,
0.9085754752159119,
0.06740700453519821,
0.6126677989959717,
0.3640645742416382,
-0.29726865887641907,
0.3679468035697937,
0.2723870873451233,
0.08880924433469772,
-0.04088814929127693,
0.3462766110897064,
0.6562423706054688,
-0.14874203503131866,
-0.598394513130188,
0.5542446374893188,
0.01815161667764187,
-0.32278919219970703,
0.08637017756700516,
0.21877624094486237,
0.2768571972846985,
0.9111312031745911,
0.2610522210597992,
-0.06876454502344131,
0.2544865608215332,
-0.5370332598686218,
0.1432557851076126,
0.4403817355632782,
0.04735986888408661,
-0.15195737779140472,
0.5599040389060974,
0.19128811359405518,
-0.10454858839511871,
0.5834444761276245,
-0.5818226933479309,
-0.37799519300460815,
0.6520650386810303,
0.6200905442237854,
0.5094181299209595,
-0.1926831603050232,
0.6102967262268066,
0.3026188910007477,
0.15009139478206635,
-0.1070639118552208,
0.07987972348928452,
-0.1791362464427948,
-0.87762051820755,
-0.7391665577888489,
-0.23564456403255463,
-0.7179062366485596,
-0.43702226877212524,
-0.4024295508861542,
0.10247363895177841,
-0.18816296756267548,
-0.2547564208507538,
0.2709195911884308,
0.2071106731891632,
-0.20546719431877136,
-0.2504749596118927,
0.03659484535455704,
0.5473181009292603,
-0.8731151819229126,
1.0695419311523438,
0.6186227798461914,
-0.4404282867908478,
-0.9374374747276306,
-0.39537689089775085,
-0.10616892576217651,
-0.5487123131752014,
0.8856412172317505,
0.05472945421934128,
-0.37787768244743347,
0.02834792248904705,
-0.606774091720581,
-0.7523276209831238,
1.137765884399414,
0.638055145740509,
-0.5196956396102905,
-0.09100095927715302,
-0.025442328304052353,
0.4441410005092621,
-0.5232991576194763,
0.3975217342376709,
0.670414924621582,
0.4749346375465393,
0.5184595584869385,
-0.7993385195732117,
-0.08092138171195984,
-0.25816336274147034,
-0.2452169954776764,
0.32690632343292236,
-0.5918139815330505,
1.0693942308425903,
-0.6730968952178955,
-0.26631686091423035,
-0.2288668304681778,
0.8345661759376526,
0.3746866285800934,
0.5612194538116455,
0.44379347562789917,
0.46739113330841064,
1.2231779098510742,
-0.2165205478668213,
0.7735509276390076,
-0.2049119770526886,
0.647510826587677,
1.3648697137832642,
-0.4914729595184326,
0.3941348195075989,
0.47616881132125854,
-0.1631721407175064,
0.6510917544364929,
0.28781938552856445,
-0.1896389126777649,
0.659168541431427,
0.07952344417572021,
-0.29918399453163147,
-0.5457262992858887,
-0.0767074003815651,
-0.38323137164115906,
0.3161848783493042,
0.20689859986305237,
-0.04939931631088257,
-0.47407448291778564,
0.2302369326353073,
0.13565342128276825,
0.32923009991645813,
-0.2770906388759613,
0.5841093063354492,
-0.03416480869054794,
-0.4947512745857239,
0.5455827116966248,
-0.0975906029343605,
0.189787358045578,
-0.25978460907936096,
-0.207816481590271,
-0.2812974154949188,
0.382551372051239,
-0.2036103457212448,
-0.5941958427429199,
0.2926814556121826,
-0.183528333902359,
-0.3829360902309418,
-0.10632120072841644,
0.73410964012146,
-0.8204843401908875,
-0.522210419178009,
0.1797770857810974,
0.7375447750091553,
0.269376277923584,
-0.027865232899785042,
-0.5078220367431641,
-0.11297880858182907,
-0.18573491275310516,
-0.153554767370224,
0.13611088693141937,
0.7043402194976807,
0.0018420397536829114,
0.8445178270339966,
0.630510687828064,
0.01765557751059532,
0.004509542603045702,
0.3144059181213379,
1.3204773664474487,
-0.08501125872135162,
-0.1490638107061386,
-1.0884610414505005,
0.30302953720092773,
-0.3795397877693176,
0.12876546382904053,
0.8870163559913635,
0.4909180998802185,
0.6196103692054749,
0.16686122119426727,
0.36941996216773987,
0.12230418622493744,
0.24317415058612823,
-0.3092111647129059,
0.5378117561340332,
-0.5227032899856567,
0.1798158884048462,
-0.1837945282459259,
-0.9244733452796936,
-0.027689091861248016,
0.7225503325462341,
-0.5255431532859802,
-0.007754363119602203,
0.7846384048461914,
0.5379021167755127,
-0.037483617663383484,
-0.2972588837146759,
0.3332388997077942,
0.057134635746479034,
0.5039156675338745,
0.5699788928031921,
0.8423252105712891,
-0.1403266191482544,
0.7022019624710083,
-0.36166268587112427,
0.000017028678485075943,
0.08230311423540115,
-0.6284513473510742,
-1.3666592836380005,
-0.4595395028591156,
-0.3942030966281891,
-0.3564803898334503,
0.10389456897974014,
0.960361659526825,
0.7275294065475464,
-0.40337425470352173,
0.03976721689105034,
0.08425410091876984,
0.7281628847122192,
-0.3949718773365021,
-0.1980341076850891,
0.3990207314491272,
-0.4186742305755615,
-1.3149408102035522,
0.5786634683609009,
0.21645218133926392,
-0.09354013949632645,
-0.16187839210033417,
-0.4063939154148102,
-0.274726927280426,
0.43049705028533936,
0.7206065058708191,
0.03750456124544144,
-0.4862152636051178,
-0.26472216844558716,
-0.1595371663570404,
-0.1462399810552597,
0.06588605046272278,
0.5827038288116455,
-0.6688042283058167,
0.5882877707481384,
0.5450071096420288,
0.20282641053199768,
0.6265897750854492,
0.20402978360652924,
0.37238165736198425,
-0.7561721801757812,
0.44706204533576965,
-0.1332637220621109,
0.46478933095932007,
0.14711333811283112,
-0.08084342628717422,
0.7253856062889099,
0.35056671500205994,
-0.4538491666316986,
-1.0693674087524414,
0.2514081299304962,
-0.5830701589584351,
-0.6205493807792664,
1.1147667169570923,
-0.39949825406074524,
-0.1818895787000656,
0.00929528009146452,
-0.2555411159992218,
0.17665788531303406,
-0.3522840440273285,
0.5094012022018433,
0.7535566687583923,
-0.0688260942697525,
-0.19943630695343018,
0.010546550154685974,
0.23936757445335388,
-0.0031195837073028088,
-0.8844172954559326,
-0.12338952720165253,
0.7260828614234924,
0.23000499606132507,
0.23037618398666382,
0.658828854560852,
0.1775190830230713,
0.07738277316093445,
0.21716536581516266,
0.08608270436525345,
-0.7469256520271301,
-0.7457895278930664,
0.22009995579719543,
0.3196004033088684,
-0.03024166449904442,
-0.18517112731933594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01619v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01619v1 | KB-Plugin: A Plug-and-play Framework for Large Language Models to Induce Programs over Low-resourced Knowledge Bases | 2024-02-02T18:32:24 | 2024-02-02T18:32:24 | Jiajie Zhang, Shulin Cao, Linmei Hu, Ling Feng, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Program induction (PI) has become a promising paradigm for using knowledge
bases (KBs) to help large language models (LLMs) answer complex
knowledge-intensive questions. Nonetheless, PI typically relies on a large
number of parallel question-program pairs to make the LLM aware of the schema
of the given KB, and is thus challenging for many low-resourced KBs that lack
annotated data. To this end, we propose KB-Plugin, a plug-and-play framework
that enables LLMs to induce programs over any low-resourced KB. Firstly,
KB-Plugin adopts self-supervised learning to encode the detailed schema
information of a given KB into a pluggable module, namely schema plugin.
Secondly, KB-Plugin utilizes abundant annotated data from a rich-resourced KB
to train another pluggable module, namely PI plugin, which can help the LLM
extract question-relevant schema information from the schema plugin of any KB
and utilize this information to induce programs over this KB. Experiments on
five heterogeneous KBQA datasets show that KB-Plugin achieves better or
comparable performance with 25$\times$ smaller backbone LLM compared to SoTA PI
methods for low-resourced KBs, and even approaches the performance of
supervised methods. Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/THU-KEG/KB-Plugin. | [
-0.27822649478912354,
-0.7019582986831665,
0.7016566395759583,
0.5239206552505493,
0.025968706235289574,
0.09758292883634567,
-0.5922063589096069,
-0.07669178396463394,
0.3410886526107788,
0.5861194729804993,
-0.5180599093437195,
-0.5726203322410583,
-0.25314053893089294,
-0.0020879243966192007,
-0.3241404891014099,
0.6099646091461182,
0.20261943340301514,
0.041196051985025406,
-0.47606122493743896,
0.2579576075077057,
-0.5462253093719482,
-0.1940760612487793,
-0.1328275352716446,
-0.2874123454093933,
0.43596434593200684,
0.7069926261901855,
0.46881553530693054,
0.4661366641521454,
0.28498321771621704,
0.21886791288852692,
0.20398342609405518,
0.31843191385269165,
-0.532723605632782,
0.12769880890846252,
-0.126071959733963,
-0.725227415561676,
-0.23495209217071533,
-0.072106271982193,
0.39230743050575256,
0.8384892344474792,
-0.021385733038187027,
0.15079449117183685,
-0.14486806094646454,
0.5596276521682739,
-0.8276880383491516,
0.5119366645812988,
-0.7558427453041077,
0.06215309351682663,
-0.14201758801937103,
-0.2887676954269409,
-0.7343066930770874,
-0.2803823947906494,
-0.054192449897527695,
-0.8274111747741699,
0.10017950087785721,
0.24918703734874725,
0.4900388717651367,
0.13581378757953644,
-0.3472045660018921,
-0.3121240437030792,
-0.7891910076141357,
0.5988274812698364,
-0.7872855067253113,
0.286969393491745,
0.2527385354042053,
0.27012306451797485,
-0.6469197869300842,
-0.5667458772659302,
-0.7334822416305542,
-0.3594047725200653,
-0.49500179290771484,
0.06095493212342262,
0.25785166025161743,
0.08011498302221298,
0.6013194918632507,
0.44654083251953125,
-0.6417173147201538,
0.15568678081035614,
-0.4727165400981903,
-0.1832171231508255,
0.34136632084846497,
0.21280330419540405,
0.23554784059524536,
-0.34627804160118103,
0.01654619537293911,
0.2414785623550415,
-1.0175598859786987,
-0.13455437123775482,
0.23016352951526642,
0.5410508513450623,
-0.05325282737612724,
0.7316414713859558,
-0.42242857813835144,
0.8568240404129028,
0.18167568743228912,
-0.21349424123764038,
0.21595320105552673,
0.041534289717674255,
-0.2855917513370514,
0.35787057876586914,
0.8953611254692078,
-0.016593292355537415,
0.10812535136938095,
-0.4638260006904602,
-0.10146719217300415,
0.18003533780574799,
0.16032437980175018,
-0.8756514191627502,
-0.5494157075881958,
0.2206922024488449,
-0.24424585700035095,
-0.6186850666999817,
-0.1245250329375267,
-0.7651567459106445,
-0.5012936592102051,
-0.3074393570423126,
0.5680279731750488,
-0.4891416132450104,
-0.3325560688972473,
0.017476143315434456,
0.04291040822863579,
0.31468796730041504,
0.14337772130966187,
-1.076101303100586,
0.20041796565055847,
0.675731360912323,
0.8732622265815735,
-0.33212485909461975,
-0.2945759892463684,
-0.6911576390266418,
0.3883278965950012,
-0.44559091329574585,
0.7240057587623596,
-0.5923904776573181,
-0.3182602524757385,
0.21544015407562256,
0.2596503496170044,
-0.0023219361901283264,
-0.5813730955123901,
-0.12822797894477844,
-0.8774717450141907,
0.31015658378601074,
-0.5039607882499695,
-0.8445268869400024,
0.13713769614696503,
0.07069013267755508,
-0.7101333141326904,
1.0554066896438599,
0.498176246881485,
-0.8242952227592468,
0.4837591350078583,
-0.9834638833999634,
-0.6489008665084839,
0.17382901906967163,
-0.4893452227115631,
-0.18062996864318848,
0.07228708267211914,
0.23660346865653992,
0.6162500977516174,
-0.20182664692401886,
0.20901517570018768,
-0.3826337158679962,
-0.5080359578132629,
-0.026579633355140686,
0.10120521485805511,
1.039306640625,
0.08300713449716568,
-0.2063545286655426,
-0.06022052466869354,
-0.6791597604751587,
-0.026605701074004173,
0.22321492433547974,
-0.5386966466903687,
-0.29784095287323,
-0.4539695084095001,
-0.3678394854068756,
0.35370612144470215,
0.027070708572864532,
-0.5722204446792603,
0.64170902967453,
-0.5979965329170227,
0.3812647759914398,
0.5063803791999817,
-0.004297839477658272,
0.8415074944496155,
0.08230471611022949,
0.7106667757034302,
0.07369764149188995,
-0.1048019602894783,
-0.42834150791168213,
-0.39237120747566223,
-0.7981864213943481,
-0.44440004229545593,
0.367093950510025,
0.5770684480667114,
-0.8438627123832703,
0.4867582321166992,
-0.2556667625904083,
-0.5569095611572266,
-0.5211524367332458,
0.3512609004974365,
0.12948162853717804,
0.6040083169937134,
0.3035947382450104,
-0.1030513271689415,
-0.37690576910972595,
-0.7929242849349976,
-0.10436216741800308,
-0.13560175895690918,
-0.17638683319091797,
0.5914798378944397,
0.3350943922996521,
0.0098186656832695,
0.9269067049026489,
-0.630791425704956,
-0.10273031145334244,
-0.27524757385253906,
0.1914145052433014,
0.34279879927635193,
0.5337489247322083,
0.3889930546283722,
-0.3776155114173889,
-0.7178876996040344,
-0.05138050764799118,
-0.7951051592826843,
-0.4180424213409424,
-0.23780664801597595,
-0.46228477358818054,
0.17936497926712036,
0.6571472883224487,
-1.0198333263397217,
0.11819539219141006,
0.4192821681499481,
-0.27626124024391174,
0.9819064736366272,
0.0979505330324173,
0.2163112759590149,
-0.9507001638412476,
0.22951626777648926,
-0.5830543041229248,
-0.21028602123260498,
-0.6005756258964539,
-0.1469581127166748,
0.34474703669548035,
-0.1766834408044815,
-0.4605701267719269,
0.23742328584194183,
-0.29294028878211975,
-0.3519420027732849,
-0.1107083261013031,
0.00366610218770802,
0.2276117503643036,
0.45328599214553833,
-0.15760387480258942,
1.0351253747940063,
0.7100797891616821,
-0.6303513050079346,
0.6795617938041687,
0.29643675684928894,
-0.5366432666778564,
0.15274064242839813,
-0.11732487380504608,
-0.004934896714985371,
-0.1434779167175293,
0.12055693566799164,
-0.7195125222206116,
-0.5142397880554199,
0.2500338852405548,
-0.25587397813796997,
0.6345352530479431,
-0.4283677935600281,
-0.7299008369445801,
-0.3238466680049896,
0.034429166465997696,
0.21183623373508453,
0.5115900039672852,
-0.700620174407959,
0.7037577629089355,
0.07462098449468613,
-0.10745220631361008,
-0.37649866938591003,
-0.5313094854354858,
-0.05983287841081619,
-0.13980917632579803,
-0.43680649995803833,
0.33287784457206726,
0.07883918285369873,
0.025582116097211838,
0.16533209383487701,
0.19256018102169037,
0.0636056661605835,
-0.0962178185582161,
0.31962448358535767,
0.4102300703525543,
-0.48395198583602905,
0.5575094223022461,
0.2991679906845093,
-0.08394638448953629,
0.20683005452156067,
-0.6719269752502441,
0.681751549243927,
-0.12921883165836334,
-0.6675070524215698,
-0.1035342589020729,
0.25473329424858093,
0.7077950835227966,
-0.27294906973838806,
0.8492255210876465,
0.5957103371620178,
-0.03483671694993973,
-0.23000937700271606,
-0.720962643623352,
-0.3834051191806793,
-0.4976777732372284,
0.3738127052783966,
-0.2477552741765976,
-1.1778196096420288,
0.21278685331344604,
-0.6833853721618652,
-0.14502818882465363,
0.19497492909431458,
0.8301272988319397,
-0.16947151720523834,
0.7390835285186768,
0.7027009129524231,
-0.3906514346599579,
0.3049510717391968,
-0.3678998053073883,
0.4136222004890442,
-0.44987860321998596,
-0.16364450752735138,
-0.13464930653572083,
-0.18850605189800262,
-0.5511904954910278,
-0.4858419597148895,
0.26834291219711304,
0.20866526663303375,
-0.10110751539468765,
0.29761093854904175,
-0.41397401690483093,
0.6577586531639099,
0.6805537343025208,
-0.0924571231007576,
0.18344901502132416,
0.03830055147409439,
-0.3536553382873535,
0.15455637872219086,
-1.1179269552230835,
-0.1363281011581421,
1.2793598175048828,
0.029476748779416084,
0.6853838562965393,
-0.23726078867912292,
0.7841123342514038,
0.34441399574279785,
0.42877137660980225,
-0.8365045785903931,
0.5154300332069397,
0.18743062019348145,
-0.7042359709739685,
-0.4597821533679962,
-0.3207077980041504,
-0.4454161524772644,
-0.15569348633289337,
-0.366834431886673,
-0.6988611817359924,
0.1911672055721283,
0.5287296772003174,
-0.49708423018455505,
0.21666955947875977,
-0.8798378705978394,
1.0330121517181396,
-0.08140411972999573,
-0.42143166065216064,
-0.2409236878156662,
-0.431930273771286,
0.7508787512779236,
-0.20163090527057648,
0.08633016049861908,
0.0038739931769669056,
0.334501177072525,
0.5122973918914795,
-0.3746117651462555,
0.6398966908454895,
-0.4533173441886902,
0.08632645010948181,
0.3680694103240967,
0.48508426547050476,
0.715616762638092,
0.04576127976179123,
0.07251960039138794,
-0.0905030146241188,
-0.044750481843948364,
-0.4532206952571869,
-0.8475179076194763,
0.9877814650535583,
-0.47231802344322205,
-0.622036874294281,
0.029066240414977074,
-0.7152082920074463,
-0.40516409277915955,
0.2642614245414734,
0.20081926882266998,
0.2060128003358841,
0.27557456493377686,
0.14816468954086304,
0.8053232431411743,
-0.44964736700057983,
0.025889355689287186,
0.47599735856056213,
-0.5650906562805176,
-0.11681828647851944,
0.8416114449501038,
0.048409830778837204,
0.4241986572742462,
0.31028613448143005,
0.24457283318042755,
0.07376167923212051,
-0.024513335898518562,
-0.48174354434013367,
0.2109350860118866,
-0.5650008916854858,
-0.3813498020172119,
-0.8402042388916016,
-0.2069116085767746,
-0.4601125121116638,
-0.2888045608997345,
-0.47535815834999084,
-0.6789030432701111,
0.04683797433972359,
-0.23550136387348175,
0.6686525344848633,
0.5123808979988098,
-0.09685561060905457,
0.6097286343574524,
-0.4673788249492645,
0.2081521898508072,
0.45654499530792236,
0.5357489585876465,
-0.023695865646004677,
-0.35649752616882324,
-0.6365986466407776,
-0.3760186731815338,
-0.09617336094379425,
-0.8063458204269409,
0.18379031121730804,
0.13930891454219818,
0.29297733306884766,
0.5879303216934204,
0.15471436083316803,
0.5575871467590332,
-0.681826651096344,
0.6363652944564819,
0.09711551666259766,
-0.5898163318634033,
0.6224046945571899,
-0.311635285615921,
0.1743994504213333,
0.3921965956687927,
0.5796627998352051,
-0.43708309531211853,
-0.5682713389396667,
-0.36935439705848694,
-0.7848532795906067,
0.9220184087753296,
0.04643432796001434,
0.0464177206158638,
0.019870616495609283,
0.3974044919013977,
0.2775247395038605,
0.38315510749816895,
-0.6569697260856628,
-0.10438202321529388,
-0.2809576988220215,
-0.16123569011688232,
0.2938380539417267,
-0.4212839603424072,
-0.05190810188651085,
-0.170099139213562,
0.8620687127113342,
-0.15665368735790253,
0.40334928035736084,
-0.04731832072138786,
-0.32433387637138367,
-0.18683922290802002,
0.23951174318790436,
0.13391144573688507,
0.5452892184257507,
-0.2202390432357788,
0.2850159704685211,
0.2505684494972229,
-0.2216436117887497,
-0.04543759301304817,
-0.02240683324635029,
-0.2793180048465729,
-0.07346925884485245,
0.46299201250076294,
0.47154390811920166,
0.17470058798789978,
-0.635338306427002,
0.5856064558029175,
0.09987404942512512,
0.0067594279535114765,
-0.06895133852958679,
0.22697503864765167,
0.4605638384819031,
0.27597835659980774,
-0.07787986844778061,
-0.32677674293518066,
0.0945354774594307,
-0.21781450510025024,
0.07247906178236008,
0.4260105490684509,
-0.09531666338443756,
-0.13124333322048187,
0.366034597158432,
0.015728171914815903,
-0.25248464941978455,
0.6974000334739685,
-0.5837366580963135,
-0.5822570323944092,
0.2391977161169052,
0.815140962600708,
0.5236244797706604,
-0.10754483193159103,
0.11590933799743652,
0.3685109615325928,
0.27733927965164185,
0.23023498058319092,
0.36736151576042175,
-0.2833414375782013,
-0.5908470749855042,
-0.9199547171592712,
-0.6113113760948181,
-0.1496421843767166,
0.5749281048774719,
-0.3560968339443207,
0.39156094193458557,
-0.3062017560005188,
0.1230049729347229,
-0.02600484900176525,
-0.1860702484846115,
-0.8442546725273132,
-0.2161615490913391,
0.02549867518246174,
1.2131643295288086,
-1.3329994678497314,
0.8819929361343384,
0.5991312265396118,
-0.3713752031326294,
-0.8818654417991638,
-0.1411592811346054,
-0.16673247516155243,
-0.5814915895462036,
0.8547476530075073,
0.22236289083957672,
0.11413035541772842,
0.1013617217540741,
-0.6500059366226196,
-0.7404587268829346,
1.0651121139526367,
0.35121816396713257,
-0.4881274998188019,
-0.0891193225979805,
0.48583951592445374,
0.12497441470623016,
-0.44170081615448,
-0.12006881088018417,
0.706471860408783,
0.337867796421051,
-0.22510741651058197,
-0.6955010890960693,
0.16529761254787445,
-0.03063134104013443,
-0.1262328028678894,
0.03634883090853691,
-0.4056050777435303,
0.46717146039009094,
-0.13085192441940308,
0.2260718047618866,
-0.23279328644275665,
0.6700793504714966,
0.3471255600452423,
0.06502583622932434,
0.6032041311264038,
0.42643120884895325,
0.5470073819160461,
0.13351547718048096,
0.5742722153663635,
-0.7829573154449463,
0.1714983880519867,
1.0647127628326416,
-0.2816294729709625,
0.424949586391449,
0.7060847878456116,
-0.2957359552383423,
0.6126863360404968,
0.195185124874115,
-0.14116054773330688,
0.7053093314170837,
0.2856404185295105,
-0.44720780849456787,
-0.5044671297073364,
-0.023925822228193283,
-0.17423434555530548,
0.4361177086830139,
0.5879585146903992,
-0.3133127689361572,
-0.10692790895700455,
0.08077394217252731,
-0.07177677005529404,
-0.07654039561748505,
-0.09862334281206131,
0.6796910166740417,
0.043680235743522644,
-0.629410445690155,
0.18508411943912506,
-0.04384559765458107,
0.30807268619537354,
-0.7088331580162048,
-0.20246663689613342,
-0.186039000749588,
-0.14860332012176514,
-0.29805824160575867,
-0.3784520626068115,
0.09107040613889694,
-0.12847661972045898,
-0.35227376222610474,
0.19540706276893616,
1.2500797510147095,
-0.4551655054092407,
-0.5605546832084656,
0.18399247527122498,
0.5841698050498962,
0.09864748269319534,
-0.0314653217792511,
-0.20709766447544098,
-0.15109579265117645,
-0.25415849685668945,
-0.38633015751838684,
0.3296945095062256,
0.8203139901161194,
0.096564881503582,
0.69761723279953,
0.760380744934082,
0.36679747700691223,
0.1926611065864563,
0.053805116564035416,
1.216262936592102,
-0.4482493996620178,
-0.5366625785827637,
-0.7378215789794922,
0.4089414179325104,
-0.19694913923740387,
0.3533041477203369,
0.7331755757331848,
0.8398351073265076,
0.7297657132148743,
-0.490846186876297,
1.005235195159912,
-0.4388786554336548,
0.5406015515327454,
-0.497576504945755,
0.7640036940574646,
-0.25180941820144653,
0.2855694890022278,
-0.186150923371315,
-0.7324854135513306,
-0.2014813870191574,
0.5613492727279663,
-0.48707208037376404,
-0.14725616574287415,
0.48948168754577637,
1.2057963609695435,
-0.3486449122428894,
-0.007245169952511787,
0.4181736409664154,
0.3914143145084381,
0.26044321060180664,
0.3562583029270172,
0.8908560872077942,
0.07434810698032379,
0.5926663279533386,
-0.6024484038352966,
-0.4303002953529358,
-0.4623321294784546,
-0.9656234979629517,
-1.0615063905715942,
-0.36268293857574463,
-0.14295722544193268,
-0.5126213431358337,
-0.024975502863526344,
1.2762322425842285,
0.9030610918998718,
-1.1100096702575684,
-0.08624586462974548,
-0.25104185938835144,
0.1536918729543686,
-0.003336553229019046,
-0.2958204746246338,
0.5757504105567932,
-0.7887008786201477,
-0.2361239194869995,
0.5345106720924377,
0.4921228885650635,
-0.4233826696872711,
-0.6352760791778564,
-0.02631279267370701,
-0.08709388226270676,
-0.144365593791008,
0.781597375869751,
0.25131723284721375,
-0.4964105486869812,
-0.12326263636350632,
0.08567841351032257,
-0.011107505299150944,
-0.12066212296485901,
1.0884981155395508,
-1.2201206684112549,
0.5079776644706726,
0.24349445104599,
0.8336480259895325,
0.45449763536453247,
-0.42725253105163574,
0.552114725112915,
-0.9503351449966431,
0.1266191601753235,
0.11873096227645874,
0.2908690571784973,
0.13035108149051666,
-0.625251054763794,
0.3446948826313019,
0.2793291509151459,
-0.6178560853004456,
-0.8424501419067383,
0.4488684833049774,
-0.6086887121200562,
-0.0694318562746048,
1.1527533531188965,
-0.2589992582798004,
-0.3023718297481537,
-0.08714310079813004,
-0.08287325501441956,
0.2536032795906067,
-0.2682223916053772,
1.0786234140396118,
0.6298391222953796,
-0.23148785531520844,
0.094608835875988,
-0.7269974946975708,
0.7212523818016052,
0.060127705335617065,
-0.6630244255065918,
0.45118436217308044,
0.4206973612308502,
0.30236387252807617,
0.21332798898220062,
0.6815091967582703,
-0.04893529787659645,
0.3372196555137634,
-0.04314093291759491,
0.18578362464904785,
-0.43776819109916687,
-0.395068883895874,
0.028680521994829178,
-0.017265334725379944,
0.1905994713306427,
0.028050348162651062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01618v1 | Style Vectors for Steering Generative Large Language Model | 2024-02-02T18:31:15 | 2024-02-02T18:31:15 | Kai Konen, Sophie Jentzsch, Diaoulé Diallo, Peer Schütt, Oliver Bensch, Roxanne El Baff, Dominik Opitz, Tobias Hecking | cs.CL | cs.CL | This research explores strategies for steering the output of large language
models (LLMs) towards specific styles, such as sentiment, emotion, or writing
style, by adding style vectors to the activations of hidden layers during text
generation. We show that style vectors can be simply computed from recorded
layer activations for input texts in a specific style in contrast to more
complex training-based approaches. Through a series of experiments, we
demonstrate the effectiveness of activation engineering using such style
vectors to influence the style of generated text in a nuanced and
parameterisable way, distinguishing it from prompt engineering. The presented
research constitutes a significant step towards developing more adaptive and
effective AI-empowered interactive systems. | [
-0.360874742269516,
-0.768410861492157,
0.49099546670913696,
0.7067731618881226,
-0.10613224655389786,
0.29340219497680664,
-0.45650580525398254,
-0.09115622937679291,
0.24335645139217377,
0.3413747251033783,
-0.6480824947357178,
-0.5532441139221191,
-0.5299655795097351,
0.04149491339921951,
-0.52386075258255,
0.8301364779472351,
-0.29942718148231506,
0.02430667169392109,
-0.15522535145282745,
0.06670086830854416,
-0.3720310628414154,
-0.7990679740905762,
-0.7988278269767761,
-0.5522394180297852,
0.6967789530754089,
0.3963068723678589,
0.6346426010131836,
0.2566138803958893,
0.20755423605442047,
0.42109212279319763,
-0.19689546525478363,
0.1449030488729477,
-0.5486032366752625,
0.5209691524505615,
0.003789679380133748,
-0.30028021335601807,
-0.621568500995636,
0.06141059473156929,
0.48216164112091064,
0.3239116072654724,
0.12365259975194931,
-0.14057791233062744,
0.40294793248176575,
0.7344154715538025,
-0.5142021775245667,
0.1902366727590561,
-0.3400842249393463,
0.21257668733596802,
-0.0751686841249466,
-0.6957606673240662,
-0.7722949385643005,
-0.09202253818511963,
-0.045776769518852234,
-0.49014905095100403,
-0.24158594012260437,
0.051531754434108734,
0.6252536177635193,
0.08338428288698196,
-0.3696679174900055,
-0.3949808180332184,
-1.0654102563858032,
0.9686654806137085,
-0.51441490650177,
0.35721251368522644,
0.07230553776025772,
0.05416754260659218,
-0.11884824931621552,
-0.5813807249069214,
-0.6486815810203552,
-0.2612447440624237,
0.04828574135899544,
0.2931104600429535,
-0.07739391922950745,
0.07490365207195282,
0.24688926339149475,
-0.02966631017625332,
-0.21955536305904388,
0.527187168598175,
-0.031353581696748734,
0.0543118417263031,
0.892738938331604,
0.0780818834900856,
0.5947810411453247,
-0.1676889806985855,
-0.460233211517334,
-0.2878890037536621,
-0.890870988368988,
0.010350617580115795,
0.5002068877220154,
0.2168274223804474,
-0.3520549237728119,
0.5941575765609741,
-0.19008971750736237,
0.41845574975013733,
0.2033226191997528,
-0.16575030982494354,
0.37407004833221436,
-0.19392669200897217,
-0.2778083086013794,
0.1980784833431244,
0.9543920755386353,
0.360276997089386,
0.28565898537635803,
-0.11019715666770935,
-0.5591374635696411,
-0.1875213086605072,
0.5726948380470276,
-0.7214168310165405,
0.06888966262340546,
0.20758186280727386,
-0.43671274185180664,
-0.6415508985519409,
-0.19715078175067902,
-0.8278048634529114,
-0.5462286472320557,
-0.6464300751686096,
0.39495381712913513,
-0.49262845516204834,
-0.3648073375225067,
-0.16792744398117065,
-0.22814489901065826,
0.743590772151947,
0.3332553505897522,
-1.0136692523956299,
-0.2851828336715698,
0.7613473534584045,
0.6802883744239807,
-0.444368451833725,
-0.036559127271175385,
-0.3170122802257538,
0.07341167330741882,
-0.729473352432251,
0.5539067387580872,
-0.7780390381813049,
-0.5487674474716187,
0.33316734433174133,
-0.19634899497032166,
0.08236426115036011,
-0.28301018476486206,
0.6394110918045044,
-0.7864936590194702,
0.08644554764032364,
-0.255790114402771,
-0.30694490671157837,
-0.07329454272985458,
-0.02067304588854313,
-0.5620998740196228,
1.0674304962158203,
0.03939230740070343,
-0.5384381413459778,
0.21227425336837769,
-0.6853696703910828,
-0.6010453104972839,
0.08365046977996826,
-0.36788517236709595,
-0.4493367075920105,
0.15380768477916718,
0.275434285402298,
0.8313069343566895,
0.04590248316526413,
0.1445508897304535,
-0.20908525586128235,
-0.20609967410564423,
0.3894273340702057,
-0.3585990071296692,
0.5961391925811768,
0.153363436460495,
-0.4622907340526581,
0.7396383285522461,
-0.783735454082489,
-0.11402712762355804,
0.2653675079345703,
-0.4256724417209625,
-0.3772278428077698,
0.08409414440393448,
0.21483996510505676,
0.20915119349956512,
0.10368906706571579,
-0.2605742812156677,
0.2531910836696625,
-0.18007338047027588,
0.38847294449806213,
0.954491913318634,
-0.0051265074871480465,
0.8264340758323669,
-0.3367718756198883,
0.9184508323669434,
-0.19345548748970032,
-0.18579401075839996,
-0.08981828391551971,
-0.3418450653553009,
-1.019758939743042,
-0.3474934697151184,
-0.04487525299191475,
0.482544869184494,
-1.182481050491333,
0.46231791377067566,
-0.14362475275993347,
-0.5028566718101501,
-0.4049918055534363,
0.410274863243103,
0.2110808789730072,
0.37251654267311096,
0.18132367730140686,
-0.06589023768901825,
-0.4820334017276764,
-0.6902008652687073,
-0.03173710033297539,
-0.04390379786491394,
-0.03550267219543457,
0.18069414794445038,
0.14729303121566772,
-0.1713101863861084,
0.7348726391792297,
-0.16215714812278748,
0.13399361073970795,
-0.7726012468338013,
0.5015032291412354,
-0.22912505269050598,
0.5238355398178101,
0.8720706105232239,
-0.8147920966148376,
-0.40845048427581787,
0.006874582264572382,
-0.8241360187530518,
-0.36386704444885254,
-0.39791059494018555,
-0.46181926131248474,
0.3626866340637207,
1.1321215629577637,
-0.4836369454860687,
0.25047776103019714,
0.6908183693885803,
-0.17578643560409546,
0.43730002641677856,
0.14400531351566315,
0.149400532245636,
-1.0826001167297363,
-0.12679073214530945,
0.25129836797714233,
-0.023555083200335503,
-0.9520745277404785,
0.10027391463518143,
0.05468345806002617,
-0.13695302605628967,
-0.4714494049549103,
0.5727230906486511,
-0.6220503449440002,
0.07481947541236877,
-0.28931906819343567,
0.027843572199344635,
0.23252974450588226,
0.6456515192985535,
0.09342537075281143,
0.7499961853027344,
0.37858492136001587,
-0.5861653089523315,
0.5679730176925659,
0.15503568947315216,
-0.544721782207489,
0.7202951312065125,
-0.6826715469360352,
0.3132609724998474,
-0.387565016746521,
-0.01256784237921238,
-1.207257866859436,
-0.11941436678171158,
0.04500763490796089,
-0.2898058295249939,
0.8499507308006287,
0.00544242188334465,
-0.340383917093277,
-0.13647207617759705,
-0.40149393677711487,
0.17817659676074982,
0.7852548360824585,
-0.5223810076713562,
0.9480527639389038,
0.11109323799610138,
-0.5557360053062439,
-0.3319476842880249,
-0.600412130355835,
0.1281164139509201,
-0.47527313232421875,
-0.6211391687393188,
0.47459766268730164,
-0.102065809071064,
-0.3623500466346741,
-0.274899959564209,
0.33724936842918396,
0.3119261860847473,
0.3037944734096527,
0.455546498298645,
0.3839089274406433,
-0.3889547884464264,
0.07498186081647873,
0.29255643486976624,
0.1841011345386505,
0.2300356775522232,
-0.03464330732822418,
0.9953649640083313,
0.3106483221054077,
-0.3956538140773773,
-0.5304694175720215,
0.3832053542137146,
0.7489757537841797,
-0.5480775833129883,
0.7598673105239868,
0.7276919484138489,
0.12844423949718475,
-0.6167095899581909,
-0.20267494022846222,
-0.05652996525168419,
-0.5880820155143738,
0.538417637348175,
-0.2620776295661926,
-0.7213924527168274,
0.3082646429538727,
-0.18643489480018616,
0.153883695602417,
0.4052586555480957,
0.8903753757476807,
-0.19891053438186646,
1.2939397096633911,
0.8546513319015503,
-0.14546096324920654,
1.0104618072509766,
-0.19888049364089966,
0.15434059500694275,
-0.8927363753318787,
-0.2944604754447937,
-0.45789802074432373,
-0.7065192461013794,
-0.5916956067085266,
-0.38173386454582214,
0.47343701124191284,
0.1881493180990219,
-0.3329852819442749,
-0.13223734498023987,
-0.3532954752445221,
0.03168367221951485,
0.7018418908119202,
0.04650525003671646,
-0.03856855630874634,
0.2567059397697449,
-0.14946825802326202,
0.2494661509990692,
-0.6871163249015808,
-0.5339856147766113,
0.957421064376831,
0.5078967213630676,
1.0185810327529907,
0.08518781512975693,
0.732385516166687,
0.08314934372901917,
0.5157414078712463,
-1.1081823110580444,
0.5916754007339478,
0.030700284987688065,
-0.17109861969947815,
-0.4302234351634979,
-0.08918379992246628,
-0.6498712301254272,
-0.16085052490234375,
-0.5200186967849731,
-0.45869341492652893,
0.20093512535095215,
0.06897854804992676,
-0.2535576820373535,
0.07977975159883499,
-0.7938060164451599,
0.5178343653678894,
-0.2190791219472885,
-0.306826651096344,
-0.05071486160159111,
-0.1894873082637787,
0.10624060779809952,
-0.05553992837667465,
-0.005089235492050648,
0.07809431105852127,
-0.1406610757112503,
0.8009047508239746,
-0.2711920440196991,
1.1311430931091309,
0.14292745292186737,
-0.42723551392555237,
0.3844558000564575,
0.19436147809028625,
0.6546356081962585,
-0.4598018527030945,
-0.2297857105731964,
-0.13458865880966187,
-0.742299497127533,
-0.1749914586544037,
-0.767134964466095,
0.8326045274734497,
-0.9014815092086792,
-0.6288795471191406,
-0.0727110505104065,
-0.5927742123603821,
-0.38143390417099,
0.03182998299598694,
0.21577785909175873,
0.5826787948608398,
-0.22261308133602142,
0.19117020070552826,
0.737969160079956,
-0.5056224465370178,
0.7584638595581055,
0.21653951704502106,
-0.35283294320106506,
-0.17641276121139526,
0.9045644402503967,
0.019191909581422806,
0.5501554012298584,
0.3971835672855377,
0.1145024448633194,
-0.05008115991950035,
-0.5068708658218384,
-0.7172022461891174,
-0.04368128627538681,
-0.7708218097686768,
-0.02565743401646614,
-0.6373654007911682,
-0.5241585969924927,
-0.4441673755645752,
-0.5341493487358093,
-0.1857127994298935,
-0.3389953374862671,
-0.5969275832176208,
-0.26698899269104004,
0.6658576726913452,
1.0294007062911987,
0.3877243399620056,
0.49554696679115295,
-0.48979440331459045,
0.12689422070980072,
0.40021243691444397,
0.2300441861152649,
0.20025651156902313,
-0.5635270476341248,
0.07326497882604599,
-0.2866303622722626,
-0.344388484954834,
-0.9429045915603638,
0.4814033508300781,
0.07977065443992615,
0.500149130821228,
0.5181987285614014,
-0.14850962162017822,
0.16407805681228638,
-0.6049966812133789,
0.8239571452140808,
0.19297660887241364,
-0.8662050366401672,
0.39565542340278625,
-0.33329543471336365,
0.2880149483680725,
-0.0505555123090744,
0.7507646083831787,
-0.6230071187019348,
-0.3672410845756531,
-0.3934124708175659,
-0.9474363327026367,
0.48061686754226685,
-0.09104494005441666,
0.5689080953598022,
0.14059440791606903,
0.4013192057609558,
-0.20830942690372467,
0.23552922904491425,
-0.35944506525993347,
-0.3601197898387909,
-0.3413601815700531,
-0.45983266830444336,
-0.047965943813323975,
-0.5950731635093689,
-0.12262151390314102,
0.003179823746904731,
0.7619615793228149,
-0.23261886835098267,
0.34303492307662964,
-0.10029741376638412,
0.19418442249298096,
-0.0830095186829567,
0.4637065529823303,
0.6586222052574158,
0.515723705291748,
0.2606240212917328,
0.07912637293338776,
-0.178870290517807,
-0.33979690074920654,
0.12082289159297943,
-0.1516006588935852,
-0.5717729330062866,
-0.09965807944536209,
0.532911479473114,
1.106682538986206,
0.1694934368133545,
-0.21229399740695953,
0.43090879917144775,
0.22695699334144592,
-0.07005762308835983,
-0.06160033866763115,
0.26784029603004456,
0.2600739896297455,
0.21000368893146515,
0.1823495328426361,
-0.25339195132255554,
-0.15873652696609497,
-0.6165099740028381,
-0.06067003309726715,
0.7032827138900757,
-0.6439659595489502,
-0.3413941264152527,
0.6230432391166687,
0.6434251666069031,
-0.3340909481048584,
0.41379547119140625,
-0.14640077948570251,
-0.6530823707580566,
0.5681107640266418,
0.5858604311943054,
1.0892589092254639,
-0.3626575171947479,
0.28875812888145447,
0.036735519766807556,
0.17506715655326843,
0.0762101337313652,
0.4563603699207306,
0.20336231589317322,
-0.9271523952484131,
-0.6840294003486633,
-0.8314101099967957,
-0.30314838886260986,
0.22538895905017853,
-0.4818386435508728,
0.5161947011947632,
-0.6228352785110474,
-0.09225666522979736,
0.15945523977279663,
-0.6341352462768555,
-0.6470869779586792,
0.133930504322052,
0.45929646492004395,
0.861216127872467,
-0.9296088218688965,
0.6071169376373291,
0.8576121926307678,
-0.39745330810546875,
-0.8929561972618103,
-0.022908251732587814,
0.16309484839439392,
-0.9844669699668884,
1.0394953489303589,
-0.14916066825389862,
-0.20182615518569946,
-0.026741178706288338,
-0.9623414278030396,
-0.7715888619422913,
0.9919462203979492,
0.08839534968137741,
-0.5692125558853149,
-0.06150339916348457,
-0.06188957020640373,
0.5369285941123962,
-0.5139055848121643,
0.0624236986041069,
0.37380170822143555,
0.34476208686828613,
0.32198357582092285,
-0.6452819108963013,
-0.03434404730796814,
-0.33450987935066223,
0.35031136870384216,
0.10748469084501266,
-0.6487652659416199,
0.6084634065628052,
0.12739898264408112,
-0.27186429500579834,
0.08791916072368622,
1.2099956274032593,
0.0075084371492266655,
-0.016094429418444633,
0.3431920111179352,
0.25185051560401917,
0.521239161491394,
-0.04020223766565323,
1.1739599704742432,
-0.5282124280929565,
-0.10310609638690948,
0.7862302660942078,
-0.1716046780347824,
0.8431666493415833,
0.4329492747783661,
0.12319941073656082,
0.8180639743804932,
0.1774550825357437,
0.21610158681869507,
0.2932721674442291,
0.20760220289230347,
-0.44178324937820435,
-0.2554779350757599,
-0.3005009591579437,
-0.16583411395549774,
0.5659166574478149,
0.38503777980804443,
-0.6230174899101257,
0.26446205377578735,
0.17345941066741943,
0.39454060792922974,
0.13526347279548645,
-0.5115349888801575,
0.8456705808639526,
0.1422918289899826,
-0.5873756408691406,
0.4008806347846985,
0.1319272518157959,
0.765019416809082,
-0.6815344095230103,
-0.11030230671167374,
-0.1772429347038269,
-0.09546234458684921,
-0.18373624980449677,
-0.9195087552070618,
-0.15065398812294006,
0.027745144441723824,
-0.06499283015727997,
-0.6938669085502625,
0.7990655899047852,
-0.4348028600215912,
-0.6898537278175354,
0.1694565862417221,
0.3519057333469391,
-0.36496850848197937,
0.06377842277288437,
-0.4337918162345886,
0.48461905121803284,
-0.08758871257305145,
-0.7132748365402222,
0.2690587639808655,
0.7492337226867676,
-0.15804512798786163,
0.6863967776298523,
0.4951651692390442,
0.09883115440607071,
0.08947417140007019,
0.3419091999530792,
1.0125645399093628,
-0.5454769730567932,
-0.3786690831184387,
-0.9006452560424805,
0.512620747089386,
-0.043550048023462296,
-0.15465837717056274,
0.774165153503418,
0.07559683918952942,
0.5993514657020569,
-0.043718185275793076,
0.9472547173500061,
0.060440436005592346,
0.10395710170269012,
-0.7979106307029724,
0.860095739364624,
-0.3548470437526703,
0.1548883467912674,
-0.49363088607788086,
-0.8415952920913696,
-0.07732145488262177,
0.43008261919021606,
-0.2751982510089874,
0.31622713804244995,
0.3034682869911194,
0.7204291224479675,
0.14833953976631165,
-0.027399804443120956,
0.18243412673473358,
0.43752604722976685,
0.480008602142334,
0.24192588031291962,
1.0264514684677124,
0.1270972639322281,
0.07304034382104874,
-0.3159734308719635,
-0.4154056906700134,
-0.2510126531124115,
-1.1848315000534058,
-1.010449767112732,
-0.5446112155914307,
-0.34379109740257263,
-0.537055492401123,
-0.24221515655517578,
1.0731227397918701,
0.5964533090591431,
-0.6907157897949219,
-0.16886700689792633,
0.23057788610458374,
0.0885707288980484,
-0.09170705825090408,
-0.20871172845363617,
0.2800930440425873,
-0.4884520471096039,
-0.9193673133850098,
0.5114253163337708,
0.43714439868927,
0.2216198593378067,
-0.7167867422103882,
-0.06470298767089844,
0.08372809737920761,
0.3127278983592987,
1.0785967111587524,
0.11306817829608917,
-0.42367100715637207,
-0.3558090031147003,
-0.0761590376496315,
-0.34548670053482056,
0.012601641938090324,
1.0327054262161255,
-0.5509954690933228,
0.2404768168926239,
0.7549222111701965,
0.7489768266677856,
0.08683227747678757,
0.04332321882247925,
0.804344117641449,
-0.9416625499725342,
0.17193931341171265,
0.045660555362701416,
0.24847914278507233,
0.5020986199378967,
-0.3596442937850952,
0.11319365352392197,
-0.004912225063890219,
-0.377668172121048,
-0.4433583915233612,
0.28792035579681396,
-0.944344162940979,
-0.09686148911714554,
1.6459633111953735,
0.1402466595172882,
-0.3084156811237335,
0.22416789829730988,
-0.394193172454834,
0.2061685025691986,
-0.32342252135276794,
0.4311659634113312,
0.671700119972229,
-0.283670574426651,
-0.12205139547586441,
-0.5014262795448303,
0.8237107992172241,
0.40704965591430664,
-0.7093431353569031,
0.04159437119960785,
0.4538361728191376,
-0.04778190702199936,
0.2721066474914551,
0.3529963493347168,
0.005058488342911005,
-0.11257550865411758,
-0.34804433584213257,
0.3246520161628723,
-0.01856788992881775,
-0.5110234022140503,
-0.40344759821891785,
0.2207881063222885,
0.3282310962677002,
0.13693486154079437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01613v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01613v1 | Nomic Embed: Training a Reproducible Long Context Text Embedder | 2024-02-02T18:23:18 | 2024-02-02T18:23:18 | Zach Nussbaum, John X. Morris, Brandon Duderstadt, Andriy Mulyar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This technical report describes the training of nomic-embed-text-v1, the
first fully reproducible, open-source, open-weights, open-data, 8192 context
length English text embedding model that outperforms both OpenAI Ada-002 and
OpenAI text-embedding-3-small on short and long-context tasks. We release the
training code and model weights under an Apache 2 license. In contrast with
other open-source models, we release a training data loader with 235 million
curated text pairs that allows for the full replication of nomic-embed-text-v1.
You can find code and data to replicate the model at
https://github.com/nomic-ai/contrastors | [
-0.20064671337604523,
-0.5615439414978027,
0.6605629324913025,
0.23583358526229858,
-0.3418782949447632,
-0.46357980370521545,
-0.029629655182361603,
-0.42703792452812195,
0.3735969662666321,
0.6627112030982971,
-0.27407416701316833,
-0.6129847764968872,
-0.4690890312194824,
-0.006249330472201109,
-0.6305340528488159,
1.1338554620742798,
-0.4009949862957001,
0.3712305724620819,
-0.6346007585525513,
-0.5981098413467407,
-0.14931321144104004,
-0.4784751832485199,
-0.35786768794059753,
-0.17828819155693054,
0.4566453695297241,
0.6189473271369934,
0.4571037292480469,
0.7420884966850281,
0.6210482120513916,
0.12290715426206589,
0.08683020621538162,
-0.40899035334587097,
-0.7016744017601013,
-0.0234063807874918,
-0.01851414330303669,
-0.26848816871643066,
-0.5710843205451965,
0.12935751676559448,
0.7669060826301575,
0.31321418285369873,
0.08540868759155273,
0.23619771003723145,
0.03897502273321152,
0.3539797365665436,
-0.6344385743141174,
-0.10521366447210312,
-0.28914326429367065,
0.07241875678300858,
-0.2592855989933014,
-0.1906558722257614,
-0.6099324226379395,
-0.34675124287605286,
0.29205361008644104,
-0.7397368550300598,
0.029991483315825462,
-0.016735410317778587,
0.6727351546287537,
0.356505423784256,
-0.5488337278366089,
-0.23777702450752258,
-0.5842013359069824,
1.0488684177398682,
-0.6938472390174866,
0.3094223439693451,
0.36718809604644775,
0.43994951248168945,
0.21318230032920837,
-0.7695351243019104,
-0.5352832674980164,
-0.28346967697143555,
0.021095041185617447,
-0.1487116515636444,
0.04316505044698715,
-0.09286393225193024,
-0.02071913331747055,
0.4436061978340149,
-0.6112632155418396,
0.11209540069103241,
-0.5163598656654358,
0.2103108912706375,
0.4684915840625763,
0.04215717688202858,
0.2532011866569519,
0.13771335780620575,
-0.820911169052124,
0.036323029547929764,
-0.6850080490112305,
-0.5002207159996033,
0.07687698304653168,
-0.024354664608836174,
-0.6160196661949158,
0.6228135228157043,
-0.21986398100852966,
0.48768895864486694,
-0.2617168724536896,
0.004263519775122404,
0.6045100092887878,
-0.3617926836013794,
-0.5319446921348572,
0.34491851925849915,
0.7280319333076477,
0.3005819022655487,
0.04123314842581749,
-0.2361936718225479,
-0.28244492411613464,
-0.030504586175084114,
0.35534974932670593,
-1.1207218170166016,
0.001318776630796492,
0.197425976395607,
-0.42160117626190186,
-0.32117679715156555,
0.14197924733161926,
-0.6632660627365112,
-0.21950030326843262,
-0.11274443566799164,
0.7026823163032532,
-0.5873594284057617,
-0.21913351118564606,
0.039939362555742264,
-0.2295064479112625,
0.47042855620384216,
0.35050421953201294,
-0.5499224066734314,
0.32800355553627014,
0.5581533908843994,
1.2165671586990356,
-0.005700224544852972,
-0.33351558446884155,
-0.4117814302444458,
-0.06315597146749496,
-0.22021247446537018,
0.5397465229034424,
-0.5085484981536865,
-0.43206968903541565,
0.047779060900211334,
0.160799041390419,
0.10398648679256439,
-0.20304830372333527,
0.6677618026733398,
-0.4254992604255676,
0.4124757647514343,
0.20659352838993073,
-0.8222874402999878,
-0.07805837690830231,
0.20324228703975677,
-0.8888523578643799,
0.8663448095321655,
0.310881644487381,
-0.8907783627510071,
0.2700082063674927,
-0.9933643937110901,
-0.14543631672859192,
-0.07065925747156143,
-0.11616653949022293,
-0.596304714679718,
0.041981492191553116,
-0.07071192562580109,
0.28189316391944885,
-0.18513493239879608,
-0.1565125733613968,
-0.42388561367988586,
-0.5325235724449158,
-0.019618600606918335,
-0.274324893951416,
0.857218861579895,
0.12524297833442688,
-0.25612109899520874,
0.2915862798690796,
-0.7462136745452881,
-0.2017073780298233,
0.49169814586639404,
-0.21978192031383514,
-0.46392759680747986,
-0.10266449302434921,
0.24937455356121063,
0.09386594593524933,
0.478654682636261,
-1.138992190361023,
0.16257286071777344,
-0.17020608484745026,
0.5024840235710144,
0.583286464214325,
-0.1358066201210022,
0.5399936437606812,
-0.5725566744804382,
0.4049774706363678,
0.06779838353395462,
0.2109304815530777,
-0.4949093759059906,
-0.47129347920417786,
-0.5472188591957092,
-0.41205716133117676,
0.3963140845298767,
0.4247186481952667,
-0.733709454536438,
0.16030940413475037,
-0.5614985227584839,
-0.6606889367103577,
-0.8753193616867065,
0.19742032885551453,
0.6245195865631104,
0.47212135791778564,
0.5045300126075745,
-0.10697658360004425,
-0.40719807147979736,
-0.9650804400444031,
0.052958693355321884,
0.40025854110717773,
-0.1417321413755417,
0.202517569065094,
0.8502312302589417,
-0.31500670313835144,
0.8432807922363281,
-0.38105520606040955,
-0.5358244180679321,
-0.14707885682582855,
0.15240894258022308,
-0.10662633925676346,
0.6139039397239685,
0.9101646542549133,
-0.4480894207954407,
-0.6135008931159973,
0.05502024292945862,
-0.9671363830566406,
0.252124160528183,
0.24430692195892334,
-0.09618963301181793,
0.44069889187812805,
0.5377148389816284,
-0.12447023391723633,
0.5568872094154358,
0.9669910073280334,
-0.26101040840148926,
0.06097886711359024,
-0.446368545293808,
0.07119958847761154,
-1.281494140625,
0.2925427258014679,
0.10805968940258026,
-0.4295535087585449,
-0.5768893361091614,
0.2144375890493393,
0.19880923628807068,
-0.16499395668506622,
-0.7108576893806458,
0.6733602285385132,
-0.3197782337665558,
0.099631667137146,
-0.1920069009065628,
0.3681555390357971,
-0.14148706197738647,
0.417946457862854,
-0.029386499896645546,
0.8505446314811707,
0.5377938747406006,
-0.5448048114776611,
0.035836584866046906,
0.3991847038269043,
-0.5897525548934937,
0.5400945544242859,
-1.0209921598434448,
0.370068222284317,
-0.34692972898483276,
0.1677199751138687,
-1.0014151334762573,
-0.2603636384010315,
0.24835315346717834,
-0.48833131790161133,
0.08130446821451187,
-0.08468466252088547,
-0.48034608364105225,
-0.12590686976909637,
-0.627578854560852,
0.7130518555641174,
0.5320225358009338,
-0.7349935173988342,
0.02993270568549633,
0.35976260900497437,
0.04736912623047829,
-0.359285444021225,
-1.0141915082931519,
-0.2944179177284241,
0.22470475733280182,
-0.4125862121582031,
0.4069960415363312,
-0.15166530013084412,
0.048038020730018616,
0.2920228838920593,
-0.08643589913845062,
-0.34045347571372986,
0.14814254641532898,
0.47686949372291565,
0.13845933973789215,
-0.4565395414829254,
0.07676929235458374,
0.11056865006685257,
-0.25637900829315186,
-0.12935863435268402,
-0.17230413854122162,
0.4031626880168915,
0.02690165303647518,
-0.43821656703948975,
-0.7141963243484497,
0.3981549143791199,
0.6269968748092651,
-0.24414362013339996,
1.095199465751648,
0.3174374997615814,
-0.43127310276031494,
-0.03466343134641647,
-0.17469730973243713,
0.21782153844833374,
-0.438759982585907,
0.2568841576576233,
-0.1140000969171524,
-1.0325804948806763,
0.01783672161400318,
0.04361496493220329,
0.24995684623718262,
0.46729961037635803,
0.14125798642635345,
0.053963158279657364,
1.1046804189682007,
0.7711517214775085,
-0.05569083243608475,
0.7221497297286987,
-0.2080724686384201,
-0.0959310531616211,
-0.7185479998588562,
-0.3435431718826294,
-0.49364349246025085,
-0.38558074831962585,
-0.35157689452171326,
-0.44023361802101135,
0.24640490114688873,
0.12899340689182281,
-0.4457375109195709,
0.182377427816391,
-0.540748655796051,
0.6372182369232178,
0.6374431848526001,
0.30795997381210327,
0.09501993656158447,
0.06511151790618896,
0.18822655081748962,
0.17128252983093262,
-0.26511213183403015,
-0.6981083750724792,
1.4865795373916626,
0.4190930724143982,
0.6921876072883606,
0.13021641969680786,
0.851605236530304,
0.3879872262477875,
0.3655783236026764,
-0.6668787002563477,
0.24643023312091827,
-0.2593108117580414,
-0.5502296686172485,
-0.3921560049057007,
-0.21335084736347198,
-0.995331346988678,
-0.26700925827026367,
-0.13763666152954102,
-0.38552743196487427,
-0.15963156521320343,
0.032474029809236526,
0.025959210470318794,
0.5054070949554443,
-0.5039593577384949,
1.0809330940246582,
-0.04912334680557251,
-0.004458981100469828,
-0.20205362141132355,
-0.6063007116317749,
0.19428621232509613,
-0.07449005544185638,
-0.019134582951664925,
0.13484816253185272,
-0.2808734178543091,
0.9248167872428894,
-0.3543279469013214,
0.6819359064102173,
-0.38488370180130005,
0.05650358647108078,
0.19717487692832947,
-0.025875462219119072,
0.22428934276103973,
-0.05924109369516373,
-0.1297621726989746,
0.37990641593933105,
0.06277191638946533,
-0.7952675819396973,
-0.32847487926483154,
0.9058681130409241,
-1.1006742715835571,
-0.30887752771377563,
-0.3134550452232361,
0.16202320158481598,
0.2970343828201294,
0.3798087537288666,
0.27549484372138977,
0.5134226083755493,
-0.6319652199745178,
0.7362447381019592,
0.8857718706130981,
-0.1888737827539444,
0.44544708728790283,
0.3491141200065613,
-0.22462600469589233,
-0.7421538233757019,
0.8704004883766174,
-0.017050346359610558,
0.31020262837409973,
0.543093204498291,
-0.045520931482315063,
0.12735626101493835,
-0.44650840759277344,
-0.4413909614086151,
0.13750788569450378,
-0.5165926814079285,
-0.20023642480373383,
-0.7700590491294861,
-0.4077295958995819,
-0.2586577832698822,
-0.3400484323501587,
-0.4524131417274475,
-0.38198283314704895,
-0.44434258341789246,
-0.3136427700519562,
0.5209252834320068,
1.390724539756775,
0.26253992319107056,
0.7010118365287781,
-0.6555644273757935,
0.2614764869213104,
0.019046317785978317,
0.7724976539611816,
-0.11008784174919128,
-0.38946419954299927,
-0.5971581935882568,
0.1451905071735382,
-0.35566246509552,
-0.8088223934173584,
0.3310356140136719,
0.061697494238615036,
0.5366296768188477,
0.47267773747444153,
-0.16204755008220673,
0.16972491145133972,
-0.43494293093681335,
1.1209580898284912,
0.30324724316596985,
-1.0108340978622437,
0.6798706650733948,
-0.17959509789943695,
0.37646934390068054,
0.6036226749420166,
0.7750322222709656,
-0.19328023493289948,
-0.09922035038471222,
-0.28674474358558655,
-0.8190076351165771,
0.8791103959083557,
0.12141261994838715,
0.21719631552696228,
-0.13959699869155884,
0.2978915572166443,
0.43866050243377686,
0.16880646347999573,
-0.6006790995597839,
-0.382442444562912,
-0.6371161937713623,
-0.3364187180995941,
-0.2601439654827118,
-0.5634657740592957,
-0.04931493476033211,
-0.205718994140625,
0.6005817651748657,
-0.04704485833644867,
0.5849199891090393,
0.5198327898979187,
-0.46376872062683105,
0.03432582691311836,
0.2185572236776352,
0.8041432499885559,
0.4240550100803375,
-0.47791779041290283,
-0.13428910076618195,
0.03372696414589882,
-0.5322542190551758,
0.008653821423649788,
-0.05671868473291397,
-0.07612796872854233,
0.07493425160646439,
0.24452590942382812,
0.9708243608474731,
0.45335307717323303,
-0.6613369584083557,
0.9579584002494812,
-0.2147124856710434,
-0.532392144203186,
-0.5869189500808716,
-0.20099462568759918,
-0.21852242946624756,
0.010123152285814285,
0.0993766337633133,
-0.18599364161491394,
0.07404926419258118,
-0.3763499855995178,
0.3486228287220001,
0.20061592757701874,
-0.7625752091407776,
-0.31504347920417786,
0.9135905504226685,
0.25882020592689514,
-0.3045383393764496,
0.6758599281311035,
-0.2178221195936203,
-0.17122919857501984,
0.5654395818710327,
0.6234263777732849,
1.0674320459365845,
-0.23306891322135925,
0.17419202625751495,
0.3130875825881958,
0.12204824388027191,
-0.11892404407262802,
0.42810681462287903,
0.0038577020168304443,
-0.24691537022590637,
-0.09507113695144653,
-0.4421085715293884,
-0.5369954109191895,
-0.04892280325293541,
-0.8640959858894348,
0.49543872475624084,
-0.7799941301345825,
0.0612025111913681,
-0.055368874222040176,
-0.10668175667524338,
-0.7744261026382446,
0.11614864319562912,
0.2051643431186676,
1.3640496730804443,
-0.5499555468559265,
1.1667561531066895,
0.7876644730567932,
-0.5808232426643372,
-0.0758693590760231,
-0.05895712599158287,
-0.20327211916446686,
-0.7500416040420532,
0.3068446218967438,
0.5010697841644287,
0.019127024337649345,
0.007753957062959671,
-0.9232872724533081,
-0.8598155379295349,
1.5673044919967651,
0.3865611255168915,
-0.4051415026187897,
-0.008376479148864746,
-0.0068504163064062595,
0.49766016006469727,
-0.5574841499328613,
0.4093700349330902,
0.2207345813512802,
0.13910400867462158,
-0.11636939644813538,
-1.0072740316390991,
-0.03744420036673546,
-0.38007503747940063,
-0.18255791068077087,
0.3486032783985138,
-0.7503294348716736,
0.8967481851577759,
-0.07604232430458069,
-0.26874658465385437,
0.6408666372299194,
0.6339334845542908,
-0.12282637506723404,
0.4894424378871918,
0.18144914507865906,
0.7899147272109985,
0.5724708437919617,
0.131365567445755,
1.333561897277832,
-0.6141570806503296,
0.3652399778366089,
1.3556653261184692,
-0.1927708238363266,
1.2489300966262817,
0.35258248448371887,
0.2874293625354767,
0.85447096824646,
0.28092440962791443,
-0.02479507215321064,
0.697022020816803,
-0.07455985248088837,
-0.15709999203681946,
0.10354296118021011,
-0.22523266077041626,
-0.562209963798523,
0.23478929698467255,
0.09776130318641663,
-0.759544312953949,
-0.1877351552248001,
0.0851622074842453,
0.17482933402061462,
-0.1111140325665474,
-0.28331899642944336,
0.9080294370651245,
0.031938906759023666,
-0.2460235357284546,
0.5266502499580383,
0.016401486471295357,
0.7355260252952576,
-0.7165383100509644,
-0.11378829926252365,
-0.10208400338888168,
0.23152872920036316,
-0.09090150147676468,
-0.8528221845626831,
0.41641807556152344,
0.03395242244005203,
-0.20370987057685852,
-0.1917545348405838,
0.32540228962898254,
-0.26730433106422424,
-0.14871302247047424,
0.5980795621871948,
0.24728940427303314,
0.07616762816905975,
-0.006251983344554901,
-0.2861730456352234,
-0.08061888068914413,
-0.2763814926147461,
-0.29781031608581543,
0.5487168431282043,
0.36307623982429504,
0.20890739560127258,
0.5571138858795166,
0.35429149866104126,
-0.3986920118331909,
-0.043988414108753204,
-0.19069676101207733,
0.8564951419830322,
-0.9163180589675903,
-0.43990495800971985,
-0.7693162560462952,
0.5487139225006104,
-0.12043622136116028,
-0.4748949706554413,
0.766417384147644,
0.7796385884284973,
0.9991376399993896,
-0.1314578354358673,
0.8308631777763367,
0.10084196925163269,
0.27655157446861267,
-0.2623821198940277,
0.7252557277679443,
-0.9454867839813232,
-0.2339136153459549,
0.04237684607505798,
-0.6207347512245178,
-0.20264996588230133,
0.25374850630760193,
-0.11363228410482407,
-0.19732780754566193,
0.7151556015014648,
0.4274345338344574,
-0.15456312894821167,
0.28086766600608826,
0.3314375877380371,
0.27846893668174744,
0.14291226863861084,
0.6132909655570984,
0.31619375944137573,
-0.6414801478385925,
0.6910049915313721,
-0.2623957097530365,
-0.4810153543949127,
-0.3415870666503906,
-0.8484632968902588,
-1.0635840892791748,
-0.47328847646713257,
-0.23099185526371002,
-0.2874094247817993,
0.003945230972021818,
0.98252934217453,
0.6979138851165771,
-0.9596665501594543,
-0.05786027014255524,
-0.032392606139183044,
0.04098421335220337,
0.0503302626311779,
-0.22723358869552612,
0.15267972648143768,
-0.16996748745441437,
-0.7136338949203491,
0.4020928144454956,
0.32668331265449524,
0.3399086892604828,
-0.38977453112602234,
-0.2418542057275772,
-0.13847090303897858,
0.3819514811038971,
0.5563119053840637,
0.2354857325553894,
-0.3534754514694214,
-0.2681439220905304,
-0.14991073310375214,
-0.4128482937812805,
0.3538541793823242,
0.6128599047660828,
-0.7539244890213013,
0.46385154128074646,
0.6217415928840637,
0.6507053375244141,
0.38640663027763367,
-0.37133780121803284,
0.5601891279220581,
-0.7877422571182251,
0.2845563590526581,
-0.018563371151685715,
0.46563929319381714,
0.13050849735736847,
-0.146822988986969,
0.5897549986839294,
-0.00849093310534954,
-0.7183096408843994,
-0.8969953656196594,
0.009277412667870522,
-1.160074234008789,
-0.2567295432090759,
0.9459320902824402,
-0.3938554525375366,
-0.47230157256126404,
0.2531245946884155,
-0.2824225127696991,
0.3022402822971344,
-0.4580470323562622,
0.40475696325302124,
0.3033164143562317,
0.2502351999282837,
0.0513782761991024,
-0.6416671276092529,
0.32888931035995483,
0.0761844664812088,
-0.7162124514579773,
-0.39047971367836,
0.19049760699272156,
0.4273602366447449,
0.2075980305671692,
0.4862935245037079,
-0.25376662611961365,
0.2051520198583603,
0.38299229741096497,
0.1161232516169548,
-0.25251832604408264,
-0.4802883267402649,
-0.6484969258308411,
0.27906957268714905,
0.05268959328532219,
-0.59428471326828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01828v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01828v1 | Retrieval Augmented End-to-End Spoken Dialog Models | 2024-02-02T18:23:09 | 2024-02-02T18:23:09 | Mingqiu Wang, Izhak Shafran, Hagen Soltau, Wei Han, Yuan Cao, Dian Yu, Laurent El Shafey | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | We recently developed SLM, a joint speech and language model, which fuses a
pretrained foundational speech model and a large language model (LLM), while
preserving the in-context learning capability intrinsic to the pretrained LLM.
In this paper, we apply SLM to speech dialog applications where the dialog
states are inferred directly from the audio signal.
Task-oriented dialogs often contain domain-specific entities, i.e.,
restaurants, hotels, train stations, and city names, which are difficult to
recognize, however, critical for the downstream applications. Inspired by the
RAG (retrieval-augmented generation) paradigm, we propose a retrieval augmented
SLM (ReSLM) that overcomes this weakness. We first train a speech retriever to
retrieve text entities mentioned in the audio. The retrieved entities are then
added as text inputs to the underlying SLM to bias model predictions. We
evaluated ReSLM on speech MultiWoz task (DSTC-11 challenge), and found that
this retrieval augmentation boosts model performance, achieving joint goal
accuracy (38.6% vs 32.7%), slot error rate (20.6% vs 24.8%) and ASR word error
rate (5.5% vs 6.7%). While demonstrated on dialog state tracking, our approach
is broadly applicable to other speech tasks requiring contextual information or
domain-specific entities, such as contextual ASR with biasing capability. | [
-0.21884964406490326,
-0.8020785450935364,
0.5617119073867798,
-0.2879355549812317,
-0.2055048644542694,
0.38092073798179626,
-0.32950472831726074,
-0.4643840491771698,
0.2509039342403412,
0.9009516835212708,
-0.4527830481529236,
-0.2946469485759735,
-0.3616220951080322,
0.07108381390571594,
-0.4001910388469696,
0.9173137545585632,
0.1522778421640396,
0.17839030921459198,
-0.45981070399284363,
-0.16306327283382416,
-0.6288957595825195,
-0.8251110911369324,
-0.689946711063385,
-0.48900020122528076,
0.2039436250925064,
-0.03269999846816063,
0.3832499384880066,
0.21922916173934937,
0.08630022406578064,
0.29390451312065125,
-0.392578125,
0.5229212045669556,
-0.49522367119789124,
0.3831295073032379,
-0.17716027796268463,
-0.3669675290584564,
-0.4021991491317749,
-0.04146512970328331,
0.631510317325592,
0.6855415105819702,
-0.28376832604408264,
0.20953181385993958,
-0.06213965639472008,
0.5568045377731323,
-0.5066689252853394,
0.11542613059282303,
-0.8790839910507202,
-0.1448420286178589,
-0.012919717468321323,
-0.5424053072929382,
-0.6054990291595459,
-0.10472826659679413,
0.43265441060066223,
-0.5605262517929077,
0.06880434602499008,
0.2974398136138916,
0.7699418067932129,
0.3597811758518219,
-0.5196974277496338,
-0.5604926943778992,
-0.6999770998954773,
0.8793483972549438,
-0.7744188904762268,
0.762514591217041,
0.5579311847686768,
0.21712854504585266,
-0.17326602339744568,
-0.7148282527923584,
-0.44178879261016846,
-0.4556715786457062,
-0.06108453497290611,
0.12259819358587265,
-0.10746363550424576,
0.2910151481628418,
0.3983708918094635,
0.300978422164917,
-0.3828141689300537,
-0.3524779677391052,
-0.19913984835147858,
-0.31948766112327576,
0.32704997062683105,
0.15219520032405853,
0.3765106201171875,
-0.09309469163417816,
-0.4841255247592926,
0.27891358733177185,
-0.6188488602638245,
0.004705766215920448,
0.07429493218660355,
0.6720678210258484,
0.13488666713237762,
0.45076143741607666,
-0.0880606472492218,
1.0192276239395142,
0.20151560008525848,
-0.34043681621551514,
0.3914952874183655,
-0.4132331311702728,
-0.20650999248027802,
0.31859979033470154,
0.22711443901062012,
0.05053497478365898,
-0.07930251210927963,
-0.31319189071655273,
-0.49074700474739075,
-0.20619651675224304,
0.3126956820487976,
-0.41759753227233887,
0.13987496495246887,
-0.04947291314601898,
-0.17699173092842102,
0.12359912693500519,
-0.4601193070411682,
-0.36470702290534973,
-0.2565460801124573,
-0.693710446357727,
0.5778857469558716,
-0.3485942482948303,
-0.21122314035892487,
-0.18450984358787537,
-0.024901757016777992,
0.2240407019853592,
0.43273767828941345,
-0.586037814617157,
0.29590022563934326,
0.6754273772239685,
0.7275634407997131,
-0.11514302343130112,
0.12658557295799255,
-0.9161013960838318,
0.34732040762901306,
-0.27518340945243835,
0.6328783631324768,
-0.8164161443710327,
-0.5716102719306946,
-0.06411506980657578,
-0.006578658241778612,
-0.1795337051153183,
-0.6536729335784912,
0.6103344559669495,
-0.7013110518455505,
0.2467418909072876,
-0.20367243885993958,
-0.6928262710571289,
-0.2869434952735901,
0.170265793800354,
-0.49644508957862854,
1.0750036239624023,
0.09650979191064835,
-0.48176002502441406,
0.12965601682662964,
-0.3789750635623932,
-0.4428319036960602,
0.15446390211582184,
-0.29929861426353455,
-0.2241617888212204,
0.31363359093666077,
0.21060821413993835,
0.016215691342949867,
-0.4280898869037628,
0.38775867223739624,
0.06385736912488937,
-0.46564769744873047,
0.08199261128902435,
-0.474148154258728,
0.5472666025161743,
0.1724071502685547,
-0.0006281795795075595,
0.12949949502944946,
-0.6120384931564331,
0.0036674311850219965,
-0.18350471556186676,
-0.4437219202518463,
-0.5444394946098328,
-0.05124564468860626,
0.03940688073635101,
0.12493698298931122,
0.35048767924308777,
-0.6562018990516663,
-0.1462814211845398,
-0.37707650661468506,
0.3131626844406128,
0.587644636631012,
-0.06518259644508362,
0.5264350771903992,
-0.2035902738571167,
0.46642181277275085,
-0.029699087142944336,
-0.3723730444908142,
-0.41438716650009155,
-0.30484503507614136,
-0.6508268713951111,
-0.2613847851753235,
0.3248880207538605,
0.6442146301269531,
-1.0297811031341553,
0.3177359402179718,
-0.18496309220790863,
-0.11588932573795319,
-0.7055771350860596,
-0.1267937868833542,
0.5832128524780273,
1.0025982856750488,
0.25623366236686707,
-0.143727108836174,
-0.75175940990448,
-0.6937877535820007,
-0.33258551359176636,
-0.1307568997144699,
-0.03718584403395653,
0.7281815409660339,
0.10605951398611069,
-0.1645258516073227,
1.0988916158676147,
-0.2818702459335327,
-0.4314866065979004,
-0.4235783517360687,
-0.059009816497564316,
0.2850901782512665,
0.29576730728149414,
0.20033299922943115,
-0.8891801834106445,
-0.5693312287330627,
-0.06950364261865616,
-0.5153008103370667,
-0.18969273567199707,
-0.00528163043782115,
0.04122770577669144,
0.3068431317806244,
0.3131391406059265,
-0.6109086275100708,
0.4097079336643219,
0.3348676264286041,
-0.26198020577430725,
0.5376778244972229,
-0.20645025372505188,
0.20250670611858368,
-1.0190846920013428,
-0.02595846727490425,
-0.0180647075176239,
-0.630096435546875,
-1.033654808998108,
-0.1948300004005432,
-0.19298067688941956,
-0.4887748658657074,
-0.3990137577056885,
0.6785842776298523,
-0.5420211553573608,
-0.46368175745010376,
-0.5366109609603882,
0.35850852727890015,
0.14276427030563354,
0.6786056160926819,
0.26509591937065125,
1.2242099046707153,
0.47769472002983093,
-0.5316652059555054,
0.18047700822353363,
0.25308963656425476,
-0.30320438742637634,
0.5329095125198364,
-0.5747669339179993,
0.4731399118900299,
-0.3540545701980591,
0.4161134362220764,
-0.945732593536377,
0.099279023706913,
-0.07063599675893784,
-0.6125597357749939,
0.46672481298446655,
-0.17890870571136475,
-0.28128674626350403,
0.0664437860250473,
0.17037174105644226,
0.30169397592544556,
0.4753231108188629,
-0.6585226655006409,
1.0604337453842163,
0.695521891117096,
-0.14316749572753906,
-0.4992062449455261,
-0.3725513219833374,
0.07902980595827103,
-0.1649037003517151,
-0.37238481640815735,
0.3249952495098114,
-0.025492703542113304,
-0.02590510994195938,
-0.16223184764385223,
-0.3758407533168793,
-0.046556632965803146,
-0.26608431339263916,
0.24842090904712677,
0.3518317639827728,
0.06852205842733383,
0.09290247410535812,
-0.30766525864601135,
-0.16513873636722565,
-0.18086287379264832,
-0.24179565906524658,
0.6452910304069519,
-0.1045788899064064,
-0.268150269985199,
-0.4146525263786316,
0.40438562631607056,
0.4735153615474701,
-0.30573490262031555,
0.4352518916130066,
0.6367408633232117,
-0.5493457913398743,
0.09460785984992981,
-0.8092103600502014,
-0.21207444369792938,
-0.44316861033439636,
0.4930460751056671,
-0.5323694348335266,
-1.1013988256454468,
0.5433489084243774,
-0.2062542736530304,
0.0637412816286087,
-0.008090359158813953,
0.3380663990974426,
-0.11005497723817825,
1.052173137664795,
0.3804568350315094,
-0.1181306540966034,
0.6039808988571167,
-0.10132495313882828,
0.32500162720680237,
-1.3905549049377441,
-0.2513265907764435,
-0.3607177138328552,
0.04951420798897743,
-0.2400323450565338,
-0.6133249402046204,
0.6140649318695068,
0.19830285012722015,
-0.02949833869934082,
0.4821530282497406,
-0.36082032322883606,
0.14656168222427368,
0.6381626129150391,
0.20393645763397217,
0.494373083114624,
0.17371568083763123,
-0.05748164653778076,
-0.16156448423862457,
-0.6019138097763062,
-0.33933547139167786,
0.7595663666725159,
0.315909743309021,
0.6337676644325256,
0.0701829120516777,
0.6164463758468628,
0.4716477692127228,
0.11866620928049088,
-0.7203134298324585,
0.6308904886245728,
-0.22642794251441956,
-0.5919268131256104,
-0.3490411639213562,
-0.567990779876709,
-0.6599512100219727,
0.41204553842544556,
-0.06550762057304382,
-0.9186539053916931,
0.04489300772547722,
0.2169879972934723,
-0.3435300290584564,
0.20271404087543488,
-0.5588474869728088,
0.30469250679016113,
-0.1478186845779419,
-0.2717718183994293,
-0.2506762742996216,
-0.428908109664917,
0.10017664730548859,
-0.008632266893982887,
0.13485799729824066,
-0.3510092496871948,
0.03400726243853569,
0.6974808573722839,
-0.26633185148239136,
0.6307265162467957,
-0.35369664430618286,
-0.057694852352142334,
0.5704489350318909,
-0.11417971551418304,
0.7615639567375183,
-0.013885666616261005,
-0.19705474376678467,
0.07730322331190109,
-0.11295595020055771,
-0.057491499930620193,
-0.7910005450248718,
0.6768366694450378,
-0.5373174548149109,
-0.7708207964897156,
-0.25106605887413025,
-0.6847593188285828,
-0.45163723826408386,
0.11092983186244965,
-0.03167662024497986,
1.0126383304595947,
0.19944611191749573,
0.08880198001861572,
0.7623050212860107,
-0.26950740814208984,
0.2830609679222107,
0.8007188439369202,
-0.27123868465423584,
-0.46552520990371704,
1.1260004043579102,
0.06822280585765839,
0.47560200095176697,
0.3964731991291046,
-0.05491751432418823,
-0.66707444190979,
-0.4826448857784271,
-0.4914521276950836,
0.04694836586713791,
-0.5950011610984802,
-0.2950533330440521,
-0.6364830732345581,
-0.326275110244751,
-0.4117944836616516,
0.022063203155994415,
-0.41396406292915344,
-0.3585449755191803,
-0.3549887537956238,
0.04999027028679848,
0.31105509400367737,
0.42493095993995667,
0.08774196356534958,
0.21518844366073608,
-0.7363372445106506,
0.42818281054496765,
0.214255690574646,
0.2684943377971649,
0.0082405311986804,
-0.9524966478347778,
-0.2169378399848938,
0.35604777932167053,
-0.020334111526608467,
-0.7741120457649231,
0.511183500289917,
0.2848266363143921,
0.7026292085647583,
-0.0582633875310421,
0.06860309839248657,
0.9188804030418396,
-0.713047981262207,
0.7581236362457275,
0.32885023951530457,
-0.8549795746803284,
0.5689235925674438,
-0.24734719097614288,
0.41766199469566345,
0.5418906211853027,
0.016274461522698402,
-0.6695671081542969,
-0.2035875767469406,
-0.35835736989974976,
-0.842987060546875,
0.701561450958252,
0.06616122275590897,
0.12764936685562134,
-0.051530689001083374,
0.386534720659256,
-0.18787218630313873,
0.30600544810295105,
-0.372674822807312,
-0.2682878375053406,
0.09592549502849579,
0.016385864466428757,
0.13353396952152252,
-0.3938649296760559,
-0.04506681486964226,
-0.11160150915384293,
0.8504419326782227,
-0.08490034937858582,
0.3128267824649811,
0.4254451096057892,
-0.2888313829898834,
-0.078980952501297,
0.3978390395641327,
0.5664263367652893,
0.7389059662818909,
-0.3524816930294037,
-0.03884908929467201,
0.4193136394023895,
-0.29303303360939026,
0.13838233053684235,
0.09112424403429031,
-0.2067139744758606,
0.30772897601127625,
0.12802629172801971,
1.0891244411468506,
0.3493838608264923,
-0.9988679885864258,
0.2500987648963928,
0.040739756077528,
0.19607143104076385,
-0.5585821270942688,
-0.17276205122470856,
-0.10610625892877579,
0.3371855318546295,
0.6630509495735168,
-0.03279135376214981,
0.4478740096092224,
-0.6331351399421692,
0.43551868200302124,
0.5855950713157654,
-0.7030821442604065,
-0.18484973907470703,
0.5973576307296753,
0.3038496971130371,
-0.5492979884147644,
0.5544251799583435,
-0.24315527081489563,
-0.6784877777099609,
0.3228133022785187,
0.8754311800003052,
0.8289886116981506,
-0.19748637080192566,
-0.10498256236314774,
0.24091936647891998,
-0.09056342393159866,
0.08672109991312027,
0.2745634615421295,
-0.2514299154281616,
-0.6783440113067627,
-0.6095935106277466,
-0.7256693840026855,
-0.3641473054885864,
0.10745147615671158,
-0.7730219960212708,
0.10304540395736694,
-0.01812508888542652,
-0.5014634132385254,
-0.30147287249565125,
0.05037347599864006,
-0.4554300308227539,
0.15043774247169495,
0.37784337997436523,
0.7741047739982605,
-0.36946311593055725,
0.8258708119392395,
0.7118447422981262,
-0.13443931937217712,
-0.6517269015312195,
-0.23052716255187988,
0.032995689660310745,
-0.8104725480079651,
0.5892730355262756,
0.06161617115139961,
-0.3116696774959564,
0.08225662261247635,
-0.19149044156074524,
-1.1399320363998413,
1.068195104598999,
0.2580729126930237,
-0.7920500040054321,
-0.4249002933502197,
0.02621438540518284,
0.4601663649082184,
-0.5523526072502136,
0.4021357595920563,
0.6166700720787048,
0.013948067091405392,
0.3667050898075104,
-1.3135675191879272,
-0.13556377589702606,
-0.0364457443356514,
0.28194084763526917,
0.3020188808441162,
-0.4926813542842865,
0.5245038866996765,
-0.2263370305299759,
-0.32946816086769104,
-0.01041138544678688,
0.8498438000679016,
0.6414163112640381,
0.5194174647331238,
0.711227536201477,
0.58570396900177,
0.6089010834693909,
-0.04722009599208832,
0.7537187933921814,
-0.4542962312698364,
0.30529043078422546,
1.5991727113723755,
-0.4301733672618866,
0.8264080286026001,
0.4783188998699188,
-0.002787108765915036,
0.1296597272157669,
0.3970066010951996,
0.47649601101875305,
0.8377812504768372,
0.08557289838790894,
-0.6167223453521729,
-0.19286905229091644,
-0.7508940696716309,
-0.29584723711013794,
0.4700475335121155,
0.6630969047546387,
-0.1718413233757019,
-0.19395925104618073,
0.24789977073669434,
-0.11829879134893417,
0.11964651197195053,
-0.47384941577911377,
0.9418536424636841,
0.23534569144248962,
-0.5918604731559753,
0.5214657187461853,
-0.33327677845954895,
0.5862352848052979,
-0.4845605194568634,
-0.3364116847515106,
0.1063341423869133,
-0.07275497913360596,
-0.07225789874792099,
-0.46277308464050293,
0.28285691142082214,
-0.018183903768658638,
-0.24707598984241486,
-0.31816211342811584,
0.9806022047996521,
-0.8963398933410645,
-0.24108101427555084,
0.2688719928264618,
0.42569440603256226,
0.19729654490947723,
0.01894356869161129,
-0.5877324342727661,
0.24262049794197083,
0.22854480147361755,
-0.14077524840831757,
0.2710222899913788,
0.012814810499548912,
0.12129868566989899,
0.71916663646698,
0.652349591255188,
0.1324814409017563,
0.11139535903930664,
0.34612011909484863,
0.8005573153495789,
-0.5108703374862671,
-0.5046099424362183,
-0.42654600739479065,
0.35682177543640137,
-0.046446822583675385,
0.05499008670449257,
0.5872633457183838,
0.7136403918266296,
0.7485071420669556,
0.18880662322044373,
0.7643637657165527,
0.02308846451342106,
1.1287853717803955,
-0.4712200462818146,
0.438381552696228,
-0.43022772669792175,
0.44913965463638306,
-0.05573679506778717,
-0.8308560848236084,
0.2840215265750885,
0.4738747775554657,
-0.30659976601600647,
0.037728674709796906,
0.15377189218997955,
0.732816219329834,
0.250749409198761,
0.05405184254050255,
0.6306291222572327,
-0.041862502694129944,
0.37155526876449585,
0.43357542157173157,
0.7763195037841797,
-0.37257635593414307,
0.3371398150920868,
-0.11534900963306427,
-0.10145842283964157,
-0.09786069393157959,
-0.45103660225868225,
-0.818143904209137,
-0.8167589902877808,
-0.1810309737920761,
-0.3359352648258209,
0.3031281530857086,
1.0724821090698242,
0.8162291049957275,
-0.6131941080093384,
-0.22326628863811493,
0.2560679018497467,
-0.07873456925153732,
0.06603216379880905,
-0.2596645951271057,
0.23395800590515137,
-0.4913853704929352,
-0.83592689037323,
0.8170459866523743,
0.30217495560646057,
-0.12618054449558258,
-0.10485853999853134,
-0.1335311084985733,
-0.35894346237182617,
0.10251013189554214,
0.7617193460464478,
0.17721474170684814,
-1.0357428789138794,
-0.3474084138870239,
-0.0394548699259758,
0.061613503843545914,
-0.0367615669965744,
0.9053043127059937,
-1.0246154069900513,
0.7617517709732056,
0.2689444124698639,
0.8020555973052979,
0.5887917876243591,
0.23264378309249878,
0.7161586284637451,
-0.9059169292449951,
0.14188505709171295,
0.3963078260421753,
0.3628862500190735,
0.43389806151390076,
-0.3732019066810608,
0.4756098687648773,
0.07410486042499542,
-0.5766575932502747,
-0.9774088859558105,
0.19515100121498108,
-0.8750616312026978,
0.07822319120168686,
0.974366307258606,
-0.15063777565956116,
-0.02377963624894619,
-0.22293947637081146,
-0.23429548740386963,
0.4204791188240051,
-0.6660376191139221,
0.4204092025756836,
0.4335033893585205,
-0.31326788663864136,
-0.309373676776886,
-0.8445905447006226,
0.5769175887107849,
0.41861477494239807,
-0.5634796619415283,
0.13106027245521545,
0.44087889790534973,
0.160164475440979,
0.28966647386550903,
0.811150312423706,
-0.019275793805718422,
0.15737731754779816,
-0.2378312647342682,
-0.1878747195005417,
-0.17424289882183075,
-0.3201727569103241,
-0.3190288841724396,
-0.17445626854896545,
-0.14394277334213257,
-0.23330919444561005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01826v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01826v1 | Leveraging Large Language Models for Analyzing Blood Pressure Variations Across Biological Sex from Scientific Literature | 2024-02-02T18:15:51 | 2024-02-02T18:15:51 | Yuting Guo, Seyedeh Somayyeh Mousavi, Reza Sameni, Abeed Sarker | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Hypertension, defined as blood pressure (BP) that is above normal, holds
paramount significance in the realm of public health, as it serves as a
critical precursor to various cardiovascular diseases (CVDs) and significantly
contributes to elevated mortality rates worldwide. However, many existing BP
measurement technologies and standards might be biased because they do not
consider clinical outcomes, comorbidities, or demographic factors, making them
inconclusive for diagnostic purposes. There is limited data-driven research
focused on studying the variance in BP measurements across these variables. In
this work, we employed GPT-35-turbo, a large language model (LLM), to
automatically extract the mean and standard deviation values of BP for both
males and females from a dataset comprising 25 million abstracts sourced from
PubMed. 993 article abstracts met our predefined inclusion criteria (i.e.,
presence of references to blood pressure, units of blood pressure such as mmHg,
and mention of biological sex). Based on the automatically-extracted
information from these articles, we conducted an analysis of the variations of
BP values across biological sex. Our results showed the viability of utilizing
LLMs to study the BP variations across different demographic factors. | [
-0.3507987856864929,
-0.7107356786727905,
0.5867961645126343,
0.36247003078460693,
-0.42964625358581543,
-0.28494787216186523,
-0.055851858109235764,
-0.6696237325668335,
0.2693503201007843,
0.29863694310188293,
-0.34797173738479614,
-0.5935102105140686,
-0.8098565936088562,
0.5816585421562195,
0.0708845853805542,
1.1057347059249878,
-0.22726142406463623,
0.3746405243873596,
-0.11274199187755585,
0.2147795855998993,
-0.13589009642601013,
-0.5457711815834045,
0.12467898428440094,
-0.23160114884376526,
0.7934401631355286,
-0.0687880590558052,
0.75058513879776,
0.86048424243927,
0.8333067893981934,
0.0662696436047554,
-0.3814391791820526,
0.20640450716018677,
-0.4492906630039215,
0.036678653210401535,
-0.03382072225213051,
0.059904683381319046,
-0.6008500456809998,
-0.12430581450462341,
1.0636513233184814,
0.8954709768295288,
0.11484507471323013,
0.5171453356742859,
0.34973299503326416,
0.8022589683532715,
-0.6023945212364197,
0.4505669176578522,
-0.01965208910405636,
-0.08062770962715149,
-0.48429107666015625,
-0.4684767425060272,
0.02400609850883484,
-0.3635239601135254,
0.6548630595207214,
-0.1263328194618225,
0.42789456248283386,
0.06016843393445015,
0.8461970686912537,
0.1913435459136963,
-0.7218855023384094,
-0.07312136143445969,
-0.9834707975387573,
0.5776434540748596,
-0.7018818259239197,
0.6655383110046387,
0.2594519853591919,
-0.1422688066959381,
-0.3080039620399475,
-0.09219349920749664,
-0.23018309473991394,
-0.16305242478847504,
-0.24018844962120056,
-0.3418181538581848,
-0.367554247379303,
-0.111749567091465,
0.07415498048067093,
0.26428908109664917,
-0.6708242893218994,
-0.24208344519138336,
-0.5255371332168579,
0.06662772595882416,
0.43105548620224,
0.20137648284435272,
0.4358488619327545,
-0.3459300696849823,
-0.3714790940284729,
-0.04128042981028557,
-0.6211000680923462,
0.10034456104040146,
0.4934770464897156,
0.8149890303611755,
-0.3864274322986603,
0.40212807059288025,
0.16863663494586945,
0.5879008173942566,
-0.29590269923210144,
-0.05088981240987778,
0.44457459449768066,
-0.24317264556884766,
-0.20984983444213867,
-0.09592919051647186,
0.8307529091835022,
0.2634230852127075,
-0.00530132744461298,
-0.07348361611366272,
0.059793177992105484,
-0.13712471723556519,
0.11610990762710571,
-1.0856456756591797,
0.01549623068422079,
0.08488670736551285,
-0.4052741825580597,
-0.14358243346214294,
-0.024340208619832993,
-1.1176645755767822,
-0.5566915273666382,
-0.3673471510410309,
-0.10572165995836258,
-0.2553108036518097,
-0.599222719669342,
-0.07141510397195816,
-0.36310163140296936,
0.15462540090084076,
0.03348995000123978,
-1.0528188943862915,
0.38575854897499084,
0.6702950596809387,
0.9367031455039978,
-0.4874553084373474,
-0.11221571266651154,
0.12318862974643707,
0.05561142787337303,
-0.3551086485385895,
0.5628296732902527,
-0.4403854012489319,
-0.6811150908470154,
-0.032432831823825836,
-0.031208660453557968,
-0.11005101352930069,
-0.39793166518211365,
0.6152470111846924,
-0.06226152181625366,
-0.1647920310497284,
-0.37033146619796753,
-0.5563071966171265,
0.2841317057609558,
0.09459072351455688,
-0.4348675012588501,
0.9055255651473999,
-0.16905200481414795,
-0.9426351189613342,
0.2703237533569336,
-0.255170613527298,
-0.2909359633922577,
0.15410597622394562,
-0.5583462119102478,
-0.6533157229423523,
0.12939980626106262,
0.39782118797302246,
0.4288475215435028,
-0.7455825209617615,
0.4842650294303894,
-0.39651983976364136,
-0.1681205779314041,
0.29792433977127075,
-0.4225872755050659,
0.39630886912345886,
-0.24999263882637024,
-0.07355448603630066,
0.2281958907842636,
-0.5303090214729309,
-0.21285954117774963,
0.025521142408251762,
0.08999915421009064,
-0.5281617641448975,
0.23111779987812042,
0.26277631521224976,
0.0018306601559743285,
0.13034376502037048,
-0.9601377844810486,
0.16714701056480408,
-0.2597979009151459,
0.2547414302825928,
0.6061396598815918,
0.3284112513065338,
-0.1081283912062645,
-0.4053104817867279,
0.3525153696537018,
-0.35710427165031433,
0.27216386795043945,
0.47726795077323914,
-0.6143127083778381,
-0.061910439282655716,
-0.7476846575737,
0.2553671598434448,
0.351421594619751,
-0.12372078001499176,
0.48039019107818604,
-0.6501109600067139,
-0.8176674246788025,
-0.45441824197769165,
0.0764087662100792,
0.2964233458042145,
0.3351985514163971,
0.31100568175315857,
-0.025070857256650925,
-0.40264734625816345,
-1.009353518486023,
-0.22896794974803925,
-0.5774482488632202,
-0.1717364490032196,
0.4368385970592499,
0.6266849637031555,
-0.23452110588550568,
0.5693872570991516,
-0.9046517014503479,
-0.21818935871124268,
-0.13186457753181458,
0.5256919264793396,
0.16282927989959717,
0.6690111756324768,
0.4026316702365875,
-0.63773113489151,
-0.04994439706206322,
-0.24737906455993652,
-0.6225879788398743,
-0.45898348093032837,
0.2998223602771759,
-0.638665497303009,
-0.10616699606180191,
0.29861578345298767,
-0.32687655091285706,
0.6096758842468262,
0.7584126591682434,
-0.3572569191455841,
0.974297821521759,
-0.4199952781200409,
-0.004970491863787174,
-0.6683725118637085,
0.1861737072467804,
0.4596787393093109,
0.09685753285884857,
-0.6304693222045898,
0.06915119290351868,
0.16210168600082397,
-0.1948392540216446,
-0.18850600719451904,
0.5037814378738403,
-0.4174920916557312,
0.01381566934287548,
-0.5458990931510925,
-0.6797236204147339,
-0.30899354815483093,
0.464451402425766,
0.41679611802101135,
0.30158859491348267,
0.32330769300460815,
-0.4629288911819458,
-0.03230265900492668,
0.15776243805885315,
-0.09685886651277542,
0.23429138958454132,
-0.9987025260925293,
-0.01622413843870163,
-0.2194688320159912,
0.4462791085243225,
-1.0486336946487427,
-0.36861541867256165,
-0.038756463676691055,
-0.5091702938079834,
-0.04299044981598854,
-0.5121472477912903,
-0.5692322254180908,
-0.23931628465652466,
-0.31574180722236633,
0.2587957978248596,
0.5423469543457031,
-0.09112804383039474,
0.5224741101264954,
0.574542224407196,
-0.5813760161399841,
-0.1291659027338028,
-0.24338911473751068,
-0.31060728430747986,
-0.03503943607211113,
-0.6061561703681946,
0.31745949387550354,
-0.0751490592956543,
-0.22732548415660858,
-0.16896867752075195,
-0.33452966809272766,
-0.3044099509716034,
-0.40397170186042786,
0.6970031261444092,
0.9266164302825928,
0.09452236443758011,
0.5442427396774292,
-0.01569860428571701,
0.10201869159936905,
0.32789966464042664,
0.04434330761432648,
0.4140898585319519,
-0.2919730246067047,
-0.1603671908378601,
-0.3055754005908966,
0.7220645546913147,
0.6667359471321106,
-0.2787839472293854,
0.8003926277160645,
0.4487966299057007,
-0.5456616878509521,
0.10584105551242828,
-0.1328614354133606,
-0.2911375164985657,
-0.34361469745635986,
0.34028202295303345,
-0.10079571604728699,
-0.8126119375228882,
0.29347795248031616,
0.03296613320708275,
0.2711317539215088,
0.09523160755634308,
0.6901834011077881,
-0.21005237102508545,
1.0304099321365356,
0.9088861346244812,
0.034372396767139435,
0.22737650573253632,
0.322704941034317,
0.03539614751935005,
-0.7015230059623718,
0.029756179079413414,
-0.7203772664070129,
-0.4289490580558777,
-1.1049821376800537,
-0.3381035625934601,
0.8030230402946472,
-0.3803959786891937,
-0.4352502226829529,
-0.1952318549156189,
-0.36845558881759644,
0.349092572927475,
0.2486886978149414,
0.539737343788147,
0.21781127154827118,
0.0023644790053367615,
-0.1270480453968048,
-0.3864976465702057,
-0.20497678220272064,
-0.51130610704422,
1.23493492603302,
0.5071544647216797,
0.5796031355857849,
0.33630484342575073,
0.38131093978881836,
0.26917922496795654,
0.5209158658981323,
-0.4362300634384155,
0.4297032356262207,
-0.24042049050331116,
-1.0523537397384644,
-0.3896417021751404,
-0.7682456970214844,
-1.0448417663574219,
0.17850695550441742,
-0.4315798580646515,
-0.7794434428215027,
0.35026636719703674,
0.22031879425048828,
-0.3194890320301056,
0.3887999653816223,
-0.3337790071964264,
0.6340633034706116,
-0.034439973533153534,
-0.5435863733291626,
0.30457016825675964,
-0.8145583271980286,
0.3971027731895447,
-0.07703668624162674,
0.1521320343017578,
-0.7247204184532166,
-0.18165622651576996,
0.6480426788330078,
-0.24246333539485931,
0.9366673231124878,
0.1614697426557541,
-0.13687826693058014,
-0.36336004734039307,
0.05737219378352165,
0.03104470856487751,
0.0021919775754213333,
-0.022946875542402267,
0.5729320645332336,
0.12988674640655518,
-0.7124729752540588,
-0.33448272943496704,
0.7167288661003113,
-1.163896083831787,
-0.4471457600593567,
-0.7561318278312683,
-0.882290780544281,
-0.1605551391839981,
0.017774999141693115,
0.14298586547374725,
0.5397413372993469,
-0.13561438024044037,
-0.014108427800238132,
0.3272126019001007,
-0.2766593396663666,
0.16209018230438232,
0.5444513559341431,
-0.02879762463271618,
-0.3656664788722992,
0.4815022647380829,
-0.08927669376134872,
0.4364207684993744,
0.297183632850647,
0.8361517786979675,
-0.35015928745269775,
-0.3430898189544678,
-0.49673521518707275,
0.6491091251373291,
-0.24811169505119324,
0.29357147216796875,
-0.47763311862945557,
-0.18865013122558594,
-0.5197071433067322,
0.09971641004085541,
-0.23676614463329315,
0.3352961242198944,
0.09058096259832382,
-0.1570131480693817,
0.29611772298812866,
0.30904966592788696,
0.2751375734806061,
0.007418923545628786,
-1.045701503753662,
0.3859117925167084,
0.31966277956962585,
0.1956517994403839,
-0.24005351960659027,
-0.3881990909576416,
0.2780018150806427,
-0.34505516290664673,
-0.09432719647884369,
-1.2813037633895874,
0.8360171914100647,
0.19496314227581024,
0.265639990568161,
0.06352919340133667,
0.13849195837974548,
0.5699799656867981,
-0.6005712747573853,
0.5054482221603394,
0.03051145002245903,
-0.802943229675293,
0.4443501830101013,
-0.659390389919281,
0.4085765480995178,
0.29765674471855164,
0.9691079258918762,
-0.5382067561149597,
-0.2954952120780945,
-0.295049250125885,
-1.0440922975540161,
0.08213800191879272,
0.6705973744392395,
-0.04977687820792198,
0.17226360738277435,
0.3238171935081482,
0.35766223073005676,
0.2895103991031647,
-0.6332778930664062,
-0.4541369676589966,
0.39651551842689514,
-0.16966673731803894,
-0.12817217409610748,
0.070670947432518,
-0.19752509891986847,
-0.6718534231185913,
0.5532532930374146,
0.00031681597465649247,
0.4385077953338623,
0.556965708732605,
0.08658360689878464,
-0.3028011620044708,
0.6693174839019775,
0.41807782649993896,
0.7658945918083191,
-0.7082313895225525,
0.5018603801727295,
-0.2193036526441574,
-0.9040587544441223,
0.2776736915111542,
0.6480542421340942,
-0.36312809586524963,
0.16535507142543793,
0.3844563663005829,
0.6268123388290405,
0.035196442157030106,
-0.7106413841247559,
0.211745023727417,
-0.1289510875940323,
-0.232400581240654,
-0.11655459553003311,
-0.29600876569747925,
0.027274038642644882,
-0.03527601808309555,
0.4326319694519043,
0.00730496272444725,
-0.13476864993572235,
-0.38081660866737366,
0.04371435567736626,
-0.06148868426680565,
-0.4256076216697693,
-0.34005916118621826,
0.4436085820198059,
0.48376500606536865,
-0.059059180319309235,
0.3380309045314789,
-0.1277592033147812,
-0.14685139060020447,
0.5050861239433289,
0.40089598298072815,
0.6459083557128906,
-0.015475600957870483,
0.03369535505771637,
0.4836830496788025,
0.5421741008758545,
0.17456746101379395,
0.49760881066322327,
0.5698729753494263,
-0.5643529891967773,
-0.5914190411567688,
-0.7484651207923889,
-0.578886866569519,
0.2772907316684723,
-0.5358629822731018,
0.28465166687965393,
-0.4031623303890228,
-0.3679611384868622,
0.6513714790344238,
-0.10569057613611221,
-0.41051965951919556,
0.006523539777845144,
0.5616057515144348,
0.5085768103599548,
-1.1316304206848145,
0.6649344563484192,
0.8240576386451721,
-0.10117208957672119,
-0.5931680798530579,
0.3555094003677368,
0.35936519503593445,
-0.2738436460494995,
0.5943014025688171,
0.12341511249542236,
-0.07177292555570602,
-0.3296239972114563,
-0.6641899943351746,
-0.6308506727218628,
0.46598532795906067,
0.31671515107154846,
-0.48720893263816833,
-0.13755352795124054,
0.6401599645614624,
0.853573203086853,
-0.18514752388000488,
0.38038361072540283,
0.5064648985862732,
0.2962205410003662,
-0.20065638422966003,
-1.0720998048782349,
0.09951942414045334,
-0.6097577214241028,
-0.023474881425499916,
0.7056422233581543,
-0.4491772949695587,
1.152239203453064,
-0.005194491241127253,
0.2725379467010498,
-0.13469363749027252,
0.5661188960075378,
0.6388825178146362,
0.12593954801559448,
0.6434308290481567,
0.07691685110330582,
0.4781617820262909,
-0.046947356313467026,
1.0306371450424194,
-0.17950791120529175,
0.24791958928108215,
0.863706111907959,
-0.35742390155792236,
1.0436067581176758,
0.504510223865509,
-0.3249587118625641,
0.39937326312065125,
0.48961541056632996,
0.17095880210399628,
0.01764516346156597,
0.4951308071613312,
-0.4175206422805786,
-0.44323286414146423,
-0.2863405644893646,
-0.5126401782035828,
0.40254899859428406,
0.5167274475097656,
-0.5168824195861816,
-0.3147604167461395,
-0.2971566319465637,
0.13981716334819794,
-0.12381622195243835,
-0.17136715352535248,
0.25901827216148376,
0.05432239547371864,
-0.4398494362831116,
0.7160710096359253,
-0.053208693861961365,
0.5798475742340088,
-0.8890548348426819,
0.006401395425200462,
-0.058112360537052155,
0.22042079269886017,
-0.022011345252394676,
-0.5931338667869568,
0.15621891617774963,
0.38853737711906433,
-0.2155066877603531,
-0.16033121943473816,
0.8338146209716797,
-0.46359264850616455,
-0.7827652096748352,
0.1704578846693039,
0.7149231433868408,
0.21865962445735931,
-0.17332695424556732,
-0.33613887429237366,
0.01198515109717846,
-0.18435050547122955,
0.17419938743114471,
0.31838473677635193,
0.05001319572329521,
-0.08939387649297714,
0.5619543194770813,
0.8529739379882812,
0.7672202587127686,
-0.22630976140499115,
-0.022037427872419357,
0.5379003286361694,
-0.5501558780670166,
-0.6407404541969299,
-1.138903260231018,
-0.05337052419781685,
-0.2252626121044159,
-0.8178220391273499,
0.7485394477844238,
0.29187169671058655,
0.3871958255767822,
-0.07713966071605682,
0.6388055682182312,
0.2939586937427521,
0.7043467164039612,
0.057220619171857834,
0.48907530307769775,
-0.4171869158744812,
0.16693080961704254,
-0.7090639472007751,
-0.836168110370636,
-0.35977041721343994,
0.10306888073682785,
-0.5261179804801941,
-0.3409833610057831,
0.7877620458602905,
0.4022942781448364,
-0.011981094256043434,
0.2283184826374054,
-0.08379660546779633,
-0.0828218013048172,
0.5781668424606323,
0.5154399275779724,
0.5765500068664551,
0.03591839224100113,
0.5915986895561218,
-0.17243929207324982,
-0.38072553277015686,
-0.1877545565366745,
-0.9443672895431519,
-0.7768869400024414,
-0.14845936000347137,
-0.46378496289253235,
-0.007464414928108454,
0.33111631870269775,
1.170209288597107,
0.8872299790382385,
-0.45970359444618225,
-0.427495539188385,
0.1024739220738411,
-0.1416185349225998,
-0.5371367931365967,
-0.09708543866872787,
0.5385477542877197,
0.26734644174575806,
-0.6782141327857971,
-0.2716973125934601,
0.21309316158294678,
0.45421621203422546,
-0.4113965928554535,
0.2642759382724762,
-0.11343821883201599,
0.26302769780158997,
0.02231687493622303,
0.27152302861213684,
-0.3503125011920929,
-0.06026533618569374,
0.04489210993051529,
-0.32889747619628906,
0.05017832666635513,
0.8423923850059509,
-0.2121119201183319,
0.18014229834079742,
0.9467412829399109,
0.48882219195365906,
0.11981294304132462,
-0.048575710505247116,
0.9413661360740662,
-1.092222809791565,
0.10161326825618744,
0.2514215409755707,
0.3430311679840088,
0.49461817741394043,
-0.322115957736969,
0.2940608561038971,
0.4423670172691345,
-0.7017369866371155,
-0.7716507911682129,
0.07026732712984085,
-0.8808099627494812,
-0.3534930348396301,
1.3524771928787231,
-0.014965652488172054,
-0.29588595032691956,
-0.1928996443748474,
-0.1454051434993744,
0.2863806486129761,
-0.6996825337409973,
0.890625536441803,
0.9465500116348267,
-0.38314101099967957,
0.26590004563331604,
-1.124125361442566,
0.5598035454750061,
0.429485946893692,
-1.032834768295288,
0.3139137923717499,
0.25786158442497253,
0.23090776801109314,
-0.01131795346736908,
0.18896837532520294,
-0.295043408870697,
0.10465937107801437,
-0.2729414105415344,
0.05950560048222542,
0.20525091886520386,
-0.04200195148587227,
-0.12115925550460815,
0.08531753718852997,
-0.43045616149902344,
-0.14744679629802704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01592v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01592v1 | Towards Sustainable Workplace Mental Health: A Novel Approach to Early Intervention and Support | 2024-02-02T17:35:49 | 2024-02-02T17:35:49 | David W. Vinson, Mihael Arcan, David-Paul Niland, Fionn Delahunty | cs.CL | cs.CL | Employee well-being is a critical concern in the contemporary workplace, as
highlighted by the American Psychological Association's 2021 report, indicating
that 71% of employees experience stress or tension. This stress contributes
significantly to workplace attrition and absenteeism, with 61% of attrition and
16% of sick days attributed to poor mental health. A major challenge for
employers is that employees often remain unaware of their mental health issues
until they reach a crisis point, resulting in limited utilization of corporate
well-being benefits. This research addresses this challenge by presenting a
groundbreaking stress detection algorithm that provides real-time support
preemptively. Leveraging automated chatbot technology, the algorithm
objectively measures mental health levels by analyzing chat conversations,
offering personalized treatment suggestions in real-time based on linguistic
biomarkers. The study explores the feasibility of integrating these innovations
into practical learning applications within real-world contexts and introduces
a chatbot-style system integrated into the broader employee experience
platform. This platform, encompassing various features, aims to enhance overall
employee well-being, detect stress in real time, and proactively engage with
individuals to improve support effectiveness, demonstrating a 22% increase when
assistance is provided early. Overall, the study emphasizes the importance of
fostering a supportive workplace environment for employees' mental health. | [
-0.40310949087142944,
-0.9964720606803894,
0.6098101139068604,
0.3126979172229767,
-0.27633458375930786,
0.265237033367157,
0.16132749617099762,
-1.0235798358917236,
0.4519355893135071,
0.008355969563126564,
-1.2584013938903809,
-0.19311662018299103,
-0.57023686170578,
0.14303313195705414,
0.015875833109021187,
0.8774985074996948,
0.31604084372520447,
-0.0562937892973423,
0.017214907333254814,
0.18630562722682953,
-0.5806676149368286,
-0.34489819407463074,
-0.7981781959533691,
-0.3646948039531708,
0.5872629880905151,
0.4907397925853729,
0.7586153149604797,
0.011243525892496109,
0.430508553981781,
0.1266922652721405,
-0.1289268583059311,
0.11386973410844803,
-0.4688858389854431,
0.3355138897895813,
0.09879643470048904,
-0.3807496130466461,
-0.4207993447780609,
-0.12597405910491943,
0.11076052486896515,
0.28414076566696167,
-0.5466922521591187,
0.322555273771286,
0.25281965732574463,
0.2861567437648773,
-0.4219897389411926,
0.0833728015422821,
-0.38109537959098816,
0.42343005537986755,
-0.37160152196884155,
0.10696414113044739,
0.04475468397140503,
-0.29499486088752747,
-0.15318191051483154,
-0.6056998372077942,
-0.285398006439209,
-0.009074357338249683,
0.6338948607444763,
0.43904247879981995,
-0.23605956137180328,
-0.005169600713998079,
-0.8206321597099304,
0.5409267544746399,
-0.6366444230079651,
0.2643185555934906,
0.12395599484443665,
0.3716534972190857,
-0.3297528624534607,
-0.3136608600616455,
-0.5939155220985413,
0.34266024827957153,
0.02279825136065483,
0.30772310495376587,
-0.3756909668445587,
0.012456372380256653,
0.20852117240428925,
0.20588740706443787,
-0.5297678709030151,
0.18314620852470398,
-0.2569236159324646,
-0.10663533955812454,
0.45565885305404663,
0.2877899408340454,
0.517881453037262,
0.26229941844940186,
-0.04144386202096939,
0.10812943428754807,
0.01097411010414362,
0.2052798718214035,
-0.30056139826774597,
0.08463232964277267,
-0.10013692080974579,
0.2971772849559784,
-0.14762315154075623,
-0.02226690761744976,
-0.16657012701034546,
-0.06331909447908401,
0.17126859724521637,
-0.09724196791648865,
-0.2833439111709595,
0.13587674498558044,
0.4405282437801361,
0.040377844125032425,
-0.104611337184906,
-0.04541473835706711,
-0.1756918877363205,
0.5609907507896423,
0.6839950084686279,
-0.5783005356788635,
-0.1685980260372162,
0.3306009769439697,
-0.5754840970039368,
-0.3077610731124878,
-0.21849380433559418,
-0.7039721608161926,
-0.755792498588562,
-0.2588655948638916,
0.18289850652217865,
-0.4512755870819092,
-0.6513071656227112,
-0.009641312062740326,
0.07271969318389893,
0.2514287829399109,
0.53975909948349,
-0.24862094223499298,
0.16480477154254913,
0.712599515914917,
0.9989677667617798,
-0.024903500452637672,
0.3176620900630951,
-0.5439022779464722,
0.051817987114191055,
-0.23903727531433105,
0.6422907710075378,
-0.4815683662891388,
-0.44984012842178345,
-0.021582741290330887,
-0.09351006895303726,
0.31379416584968567,
-0.5769822597503662,
0.8195565342903137,
-0.09859645366668701,
0.1607508361339569,
-0.0545802041888237,
-0.2664133906364441,
0.29982462525367737,
0.5643001794815063,
-0.31627365946769714,
1.2404444217681885,
0.2400275617837906,
-0.645049512386322,
0.426369309425354,
-1.2178680896759033,
-0.3330134153366089,
0.3529243767261505,
-0.082981176674366,
-0.6751983165740967,
0.36441662907600403,
0.20094521343708038,
0.3164433538913727,
0.08471689373254776,
0.0512036457657814,
-0.5581471920013428,
-0.5123409032821655,
0.06548696756362915,
-0.1129416972398758,
0.811189591884613,
0.29948243498802185,
-0.3408759534358978,
0.34037140011787415,
-0.4791669249534607,
0.12197328358888626,
0.33148375153541565,
0.1742371767759323,
-0.4619936943054199,
0.16450944542884827,
0.13504533469676971,
0.5239468812942505,
0.014672515913844109,
-0.6148922443389893,
-0.09761536121368408,
-0.053343579173088074,
-0.07332565635442734,
0.8155735731124878,
0.2582995891571045,
-0.3402544856071472,
-0.10913055390119553,
0.8169432878494263,
0.0066769421100616455,
0.6608385443687439,
0.0682217925786972,
-0.6194616556167603,
0.09981536120176315,
-0.8918560147285461,
-0.684221088886261,
1.009284257888794,
-0.3268335461616516,
0.7634857892990112,
-0.05057596415281296,
-0.7219207286834717,
-0.42746156454086304,
0.10825210809707642,
0.3240721523761749,
0.6221580505371094,
0.3871418535709381,
-0.4564630687236786,
-0.6368141770362854,
-0.5852069854736328,
-0.4023522138595581,
-0.13983537256717682,
-0.24866287410259247,
-0.02488647773861885,
0.161414235830307,
-0.7635807991027832,
0.8837476968765259,
-0.6790579557418823,
-0.3686002492904663,
-0.004031590651720762,
0.15846234560012817,
0.3656684458255768,
0.4640866816043854,
0.16189347207546234,
-0.5983887910842896,
-0.33012571930885315,
-0.23345878720283508,
-0.9323683381080627,
-0.1492599993944168,
0.13751928508281708,
-0.4588586688041687,
-0.3214987814426422,
0.29857325553894043,
-0.40846338868141174,
0.5313296914100647,
0.19844584167003632,
-0.5600889325141907,
0.6954963803291321,
-0.11377311497926712,
-0.16472409665584564,
-0.891712486743927,
0.14717833697795868,
-0.05169824883341789,
-0.37205663323402405,
-0.6455299258232117,
-0.6070865392684937,
-0.21474531292915344,
-0.6234802603721619,
-0.24491509795188904,
0.3368541896343231,
-0.03840610384941101,
0.25607630610466003,
-0.326888769865036,
-0.006171700544655323,
-0.2454703003168106,
0.31944161653518677,
-0.044545769691467285,
0.42963120341300964,
0.4169980585575104,
-0.46770647168159485,
0.14887727797031403,
0.4562067985534668,
-0.32503679394721985,
1.1944445371627808,
-0.49375003576278687,
-0.037943512201309204,
-0.13209185004234314,
0.5830532312393188,
-0.898439347743988,
-0.008577333763241768,
0.36429622769355774,
-0.4180132746696472,
-0.21805858612060547,
0.508764922618866,
-0.3591477572917938,
-0.7338674664497375,
-0.21678698062896729,
0.16019847989082336,
0.45702674984931946,
-0.09898275136947632,
0.23364630341529846,
0.7412465214729309,
-0.4663664400577545,
-0.2703007459640503,
-0.6249599456787109,
0.18370984494686127,
-0.36596810817718506,
-0.37785032391548157,
0.5394611954689026,
0.12822739779949188,
-0.24678291380405426,
-0.05262147635221481,
-0.5853322744369507,
-0.2344084233045578,
0.49655118584632874,
0.33634400367736816,
0.4957963228225708,
0.2213277518749237,
0.2199132740497589,
-0.08624280244112015,
-0.3150807321071625,
0.29788294434547424,
-0.33229708671569824,
0.28290778398513794,
-0.19941022992134094,
-0.3556285798549652,
-0.9399139881134033,
0.510942816734314,
0.5551319122314453,
-0.27835607528686523,
0.9217883944511414,
1.213088870048523,
-0.9825979471206665,
0.2926211357116699,
-0.5420240759849548,
-0.5040343999862671,
-0.43250125646591187,
0.32903584837913513,
0.053886860609054565,
-0.5510414242744446,
0.5164236426353455,
-0.33421871066093445,
0.28177425265312195,
0.035150498151779175,
0.4202221930027008,
-0.5579824447631836,
1.2272604703903198,
0.8686404228210449,
-0.18763746321201324,
1.0056960582733154,
0.13658396899700165,
0.598334014415741,
-0.48650413751602173,
-0.38061830401420593,
-0.21889227628707886,
-0.4558136463165283,
-0.24626116454601288,
-0.152553990483284,
0.5681679844856262,
0.050610076636075974,
-0.39980438351631165,
0.056795328855514526,
-0.8506218194961548,
-0.044048383831977844,
0.3887375295162201,
0.49632301926612854,
-0.09540852159261703,
-0.4258754253387451,
-0.3644675016403198,
-0.21352359652519226,
-0.38692933320999146,
-0.4663940966129303,
0.26346486806869507,
0.473102331161499,
0.6036697626113892,
0.09977751225233078,
0.8483593463897705,
0.7599585652351379,
0.7013048529624939,
-0.5773983597755432,
0.24063031375408173,
0.4636588394641876,
-0.6610978841781616,
-0.5442801117897034,
-0.2624417841434479,
-0.9264175295829773,
0.0845365971326828,
-0.4465161859989166,
-1.0281198024749756,
0.06747657060623169,
0.17533110082149506,
-0.5986101031303406,
-0.006869689095765352,
-0.7010549902915955,
1.1084519624710083,
-0.5401652455329895,
-0.6272552013397217,
-0.5901325345039368,
-0.5891175866127014,
0.2149793654680252,
-0.22310252487659454,
0.60049968957901,
-0.6853736042976379,
0.17472460865974426,
0.9266791939735413,
-0.22326311469078064,
0.9783720374107361,
-0.6369777917861938,
-0.242010235786438,
0.20809943974018097,
-0.09737265110015869,
0.4618048369884491,
0.3175460398197174,
-0.006020477972924709,
-0.22437037527561188,
0.2544146180152893,
-0.7400686144828796,
-0.6936178207397461,
0.1343342661857605,
-0.6232242584228516,
-0.30814290046691895,
-0.16804099082946777,
-0.23965509235858917,
-0.5939032435417175,
0.5302782654762268,
-0.2786107361316681,
0.04853649437427521,
-0.19562675058841705,
0.10901715606451035,
0.6520869731903076,
-0.32517722249031067,
0.09061918407678604,
0.27387291193008423,
-0.13555051386356354,
-0.1892600655555725,
0.48224660754203796,
-0.019213486462831497,
-0.3597410321235657,
0.03479232266545296,
0.35876864194869995,
-0.24874699115753174,
0.1411799192428589,
0.37305155396461487,
0.15443629026412964,
-0.41532695293426514,
-0.2176794409751892,
-0.4652600586414337,
0.08093083649873734,
-0.2630321979522705,
-0.5590320229530334,
-0.5654321908950806,
0.15194904804229736,
-0.061068348586559296,
-0.3567051589488983,
0.23442628979682922,
0.4232075810432434,
-0.055782683193683624,
0.18763133883476257,
-0.8887678384780884,
0.2575671076774597,
0.4349912106990814,
0.49643969535827637,
0.20552963018417358,
0.17856070399284363,
-0.7575278282165527,
0.020091073587536812,
-0.537695050239563,
-0.9752716422080994,
0.4207765460014343,
0.09916633367538452,
0.7126175165176392,
0.6075549125671387,
0.5247112512588501,
0.7340276837348938,
-0.15124693512916565,
0.6740051507949829,
0.4768751263618469,
-0.8462857007980347,
0.7371417880058289,
-0.1864384114742279,
0.4099779725074768,
0.7570617198944092,
0.3841918408870697,
-0.8622041940689087,
-0.40582993626594543,
-0.7114612460136414,
-0.9213210940361023,
0.4778612554073334,
0.35456302762031555,
-0.005632345099002123,
-0.0937134400010109,
0.060871969908475876,
-0.035995159298181534,
0.02230660989880562,
-0.37356725335121155,
-0.025069355964660645,
-0.24870933592319489,
-0.39182016253471375,
0.15010705590248108,
-0.04790879786014557,
-0.3181178569793701,
-0.31890174746513367,
0.6315701603889465,
0.0031517993193119764,
0.8867157101631165,
0.17072606086730957,
0.04222360625863075,
-0.09929774701595306,
0.31878870725631714,
0.37473800778388977,
0.5789163112640381,
-0.37684860825538635,
0.1953691691160202,
0.4708179533481598,
-0.5499930381774902,
-0.0005826748674735427,
0.016818350180983543,
0.6689421534538269,
-0.09376772493124008,
0.05775604024529457,
0.6332888007164001,
0.279845654964447,
-0.8638316988945007,
0.24000631272792816,
0.061015114188194275,
0.06765175610780716,
-0.40944209694862366,
0.2657518982887268,
0.1298268884420395,
0.5451413989067078,
0.6905555725097656,
-0.2709670066833496,
-0.00035137924714945257,
-0.5217933654785156,
0.5167322754859924,
0.4698777198791504,
-0.8116063475608826,
-0.30794164538383484,
0.6077781319618225,
0.16868555545806885,
-0.6362839937210083,
0.5672240853309631,
-0.011926578357815742,
-0.6503868103027344,
0.44697725772857666,
0.6253528594970703,
0.7351953387260437,
-0.4040412902832031,
0.11383143812417984,
0.09206655621528625,
0.12676560878753662,
0.17225252091884613,
0.503275454044342,
-0.17633330821990967,
-0.5716314315795898,
-0.047155577689409256,
-0.1527758687734604,
-0.6520147919654846,
-0.15278548002243042,
-0.7435532212257385,
0.20598110556602478,
-0.5745747089385986,
-0.60237056016922,
-0.2808990776538849,
0.21345771849155426,
-0.7177577018737793,
0.5824589729309082,
0.6749957203865051,
0.7618095278739929,
-1.0303767919540405,
0.609859049320221,
0.7093321681022644,
-0.07837844640016556,
-0.3487468957901001,
0.055964674800634384,
0.36819031834602356,
-0.6905222535133362,
-0.00015588973474223167,
0.4461652934551239,
-0.2551005482673645,
-0.12283442914485931,
-0.45020201802253723,
-0.48711273074150085,
1.1987457275390625,
0.2895091474056244,
-0.18296536803245544,
-0.012234300374984741,
-0.15705423057079315,
0.7205735445022583,
-0.12347853928804398,
0.4484921395778656,
0.15232567489147186,
0.5520569682121277,
-0.17943933606147766,
-0.6712110042572021,
0.10056920349597931,
-0.5770501494407654,
0.0020053009502589703,
-0.1270243376493454,
-0.4018005132675171,
0.055660489946603775,
0.1166008710861206,
-0.288396418094635,
-0.7741838097572327,
0.650833785533905,
0.4748336374759674,
0.40311047434806824,
0.7439925074577332,
0.4029490649700165,
1.452134370803833,
0.19903802871704102,
0.6131003499031067,
-0.4161057770252228,
0.21121546626091003,
0.8195944428443909,
-0.2917904257774353,
0.6571547985076904,
0.4711516797542572,
-0.35787564516067505,
0.6034964919090271,
0.8416457176208496,
0.21296240389347076,
0.37443941831588745,
0.2963029742240906,
-0.6407724022865295,
-0.16924017667770386,
-0.40133136510849,
-0.3409951329231262,
-0.0891290158033371,
0.6133738160133362,
0.05720258131623268,
-0.1949141025543213,
0.43473926186561584,
0.20954881608486176,
-0.1255214661359787,
-0.12255576997995377,
0.5740818381309509,
0.29424259066581726,
-0.31973087787628174,
0.48820599913597107,
-0.28328999876976013,
0.7665034532546997,
-0.6882348656654358,
0.217068150639534,
-0.029181839898228645,
0.3127165734767914,
-0.4116836190223694,
-0.6571065187454224,
0.806722104549408,
0.16948199272155762,
0.04392508044838905,
-0.5454051494598389,
0.8881965279579163,
0.014287219382822514,
-0.37062376737594604,
0.4369387626647949,
0.7030704617500305,
-0.18008045852184296,
-0.376094251871109,
-0.70701003074646,
-0.08498332649469376,
-0.5208104848861694,
-0.24209673702716827,
0.2648145854473114,
0.4967762231826782,
-0.04573798179626465,
0.6244368553161621,
0.6037795543670654,
-0.24721135199069977,
-0.03558262437582016,
-0.39679154753685,
0.6081036329269409,
-0.503894567489624,
-0.7694358229637146,
-0.747757077217102,
0.6999870538711548,
-0.34622466564178467,
-0.2521097660064697,
0.3158641755580902,
0.24408644437789917,
0.18972504138946533,
-0.06785808503627777,
0.7449355125427246,
-0.23718900978565216,
0.4044915735721588,
0.20685186982154846,
0.680472195148468,
-0.7527214288711548,
-0.30648672580718994,
-0.7508183717727661,
-0.588630735874176,
-0.48862236738204956,
0.7001651525497437,
-0.4041249752044678,
-0.4279419481754303,
0.44254353642463684,
0.6160275936126709,
0.15853287279605865,
0.15046285092830658,
0.2091847062110901,
-0.09949950873851776,
0.8421206474304199,
0.4130396842956543,
0.6696829199790955,
0.13608206808567047,
0.32136648893356323,
-0.1527365744113922,
-0.323354035615921,
-0.3647350072860718,
-0.847809910774231,
-0.20258037745952606,
-0.4123072326183319,
-0.5494939684867859,
-0.3265991508960724,
0.16383472084999084,
1.1330642700195312,
0.7783734202384949,
-0.7000356912612915,
0.04540162533521652,
-0.2598050534725189,
0.10357517749071121,
-0.8011947274208069,
-0.28670844435691833,
-0.06604783982038498,
-0.2525305449962616,
-0.0012430784991011024,
0.38213661313056946,
0.19107434153556824,
-0.18360723555088043,
-0.08220919221639633,
-0.08856803178787231,
-0.4240778088569641,
0.253824383020401,
0.583663821220398,
0.5225161910057068,
-0.2007003277540207,
-0.09477287530899048,
-0.0879376158118248,
-0.32110023498535156,
0.09504891186952591,
0.4313623607158661,
-0.6569758653640747,
0.214535191655159,
0.3398217260837555,
1.0315757989883423,
0.39981985092163086,
0.036710768938064575,
0.52899569272995,
-0.4666711688041687,
0.09925380349159241,
0.5105683207511902,
0.10076070576906204,
0.07409993559122086,
-0.8965674042701721,
0.6310072541236877,
0.49937915802001953,
-0.24097104370594025,
-1.0380324125289917,
0.020981166511774063,
-0.6385312080383301,
-0.03372764587402344,
0.1710066795349121,
-0.3114275336265564,
-0.11769400537014008,
-0.22201035916805267,
-0.3268097937107086,
0.7855731844902039,
-0.3821461796760559,
1.2091108560562134,
0.6478415131568909,
-0.5851575136184692,
-0.3066260516643524,
-0.4739874303340912,
0.19137297570705414,
0.5975918173789978,
-1.0924360752105713,
-0.10775215178728104,
0.12004783749580383,
-0.02258284017443657,
0.09967374056577682,
0.9322547316551208,
0.0491987019777298,
0.29753297567367554,
-0.10565527528524399,
0.2112927883863449,
0.014992285519838333,
-0.06814651936292648,
0.019736602902412415,
-0.08350055664777756,
-0.15110285580158234,
-0.32410866022109985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01591v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01591v2 | BAT: Learning to Reason about Spatial Sounds with Large Language Models | 2024-02-02T17:34:53 | 2024-05-25T17:05:11 | Zhisheng Zheng, Puyuan Peng, Ziyang Ma, Xie Chen, Eunsol Choi, David Harwath | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD | Spatial sound reasoning is a fundamental human skill, enabling us to navigate
and interpret our surroundings based on sound. In this paper we present BAT,
which combines the spatial sound perception ability of a binaural acoustic
scene analysis model with the natural language reasoning capabilities of a
large language model (LLM) to replicate this innate ability. To address the
lack of existing datasets of in-the-wild spatial sounds, we synthesized a
binaural audio dataset using AudioSet and SoundSpaces 2.0. Next, we developed
SpatialSoundQA, a spatial sound-based question-answering dataset, offering a
range of QA tasks that train BAT in various aspects of spatial sound perception
and reasoning. The acoustic front end encoder of BAT is a novel spatial audio
encoder named Spatial Audio Spectrogram Transformer, or Spatial-AST, which by
itself achieves strong performance across sound event detection, spatial
localization, and distance estimation. By integrating Spatial-AST with LLaMA-2
7B model, BAT transcends standard Sound Event Localization and Detection (SELD)
tasks, enabling the model to reason about the relationships between the sounds
in its environment. Our experiments demonstrate BAT's superior performance on
both spatial sound perception and reasoning, showcasing the immense potential
of LLMs in navigating and interpreting complex spatial audio environments. | [
-0.47925737500190735,
-0.6206511855125427,
0.774915874004364,
0.4167361557483673,
-0.13877320289611816,
0.11953310668468475,
-0.18455827236175537,
-0.5298277139663696,
0.13217118382453918,
0.6899917721748352,
-0.5895710587501526,
-0.6809303760528564,
-0.1741536259651184,
0.017122644931077957,
-0.16746845841407776,
0.46290451288223267,
0.2163056582212448,
0.08519938588142395,
0.09421868622303009,
-0.1928182989358902,
-0.8861173987388611,
-0.6031925082206726,
-0.8460153341293335,
-0.30107393860816956,
0.3170134723186493,
0.19273008406162262,
0.5410672426223755,
0.24903389811515808,
0.3588067591190338,
0.2691706717014313,
-0.2338879257440567,
0.29080796241760254,
0.04213976114988327,
0.0711466521024704,
-0.47959575057029724,
-0.4471968710422516,
0.16787351667881012,
-0.49844980239868164,
0.3266105353832245,
0.8484966158866882,
-0.34266340732574463,
-0.10253876447677612,
-0.5410910844802856,
0.5034639835357666,
-0.17437133193016052,
0.13953424990177155,
-0.496580570936203,
0.3136649429798126,
0.06182296946644783,
-0.3291350305080414,
-0.3955222964286804,
-0.24399089813232422,
-0.11485935747623444,
-0.6851227879524231,
0.031222136691212654,
0.3640255928039551,
0.4572882354259491,
0.5871403217315674,
-0.636838436126709,
-0.32314780354499817,
-1.0133132934570312,
0.3917253315448761,
-0.6066102981567383,
0.9195258617401123,
0.5603366494178772,
0.669464647769928,
-0.15626703202724457,
-0.39615997672080994,
-0.7364405989646912,
-0.06677694618701935,
0.16779865324497223,
0.1086646318435669,
-0.35916823148727417,
0.05308721587061882,
0.45745471119880676,
-0.1324501633644104,
-0.6506630182266235,
-0.05706126242876053,
-0.3795735239982605,
-0.11688443273305893,
0.5453356504440308,
0.10941070318222046,
0.4429759085178375,
-0.24024473130702972,
-0.22835391759872437,
0.05675011873245239,
-0.598682701587677,
0.31292542815208435,
0.32875919342041016,
0.3781372010707855,
-0.06020663306117058,
0.5962997674942017,
0.09441801905632019,
0.42329272627830505,
0.14649750292301178,
0.11439558863639832,
0.07195792347192764,
-0.31867173314094543,
-0.05027107894420624,
0.40748298168182373,
0.5785849690437317,
0.0679965689778328,
0.06269753724336624,
-0.3452858626842499,
-0.3042534291744232,
0.07874985784292221,
0.25363630056381226,
-0.5840347409248352,
-0.17880722880363464,
0.38135212659835815,
-0.2517109811306,
0.14058957993984222,
-0.3463265001773834,
-0.48121705651283264,
-0.5782213807106018,
-0.49245402216911316,
0.38739678263664246,
-0.6041095852851868,
-0.38192319869995117,
0.6503984332084656,
-0.25387638807296753,
0.26671847701072693,
0.12926633656024933,
-1.0525254011154175,
0.327114462852478,
0.7725034952163696,
0.6570577025413513,
0.2790379226207733,
-0.3361518085002899,
-0.2760346233844757,
0.3133809268474579,
-0.6648248434066772,
1.0878849029541016,
-0.6545153260231018,
-0.5282817482948303,
-0.24905720353126526,
-0.1918148249387741,
0.07930364459753036,
-0.7628222703933716,
0.5256154537200928,
-0.4529835283756256,
-0.15382465720176697,
-0.43178001046180725,
-0.13183057308197021,
-0.37381473183631897,
0.044521551579236984,
-0.6813702583312988,
0.9177314043045044,
-0.020753376185894012,
-0.6025789380073547,
0.721756637096405,
-0.7572726607322693,
-0.71836918592453,
0.04067384824156761,
-0.3726240396499634,
-0.14701394736766815,
0.04247182607650757,
0.6132614016532898,
0.061152826994657516,
-0.13749957084655762,
0.5419361591339111,
-0.3196302056312561,
-0.6689659357070923,
0.3259423077106476,
-0.15880797803401947,
0.8006906509399414,
0.2934962809085846,
-0.3327125012874603,
0.1585780382156372,
-0.6080897450447083,
-0.3745341897010803,
0.0681745857000351,
-0.47855228185653687,
-0.15939928591251373,
0.29832905530929565,
-0.01875205896794796,
0.052892930805683136,
0.09029537439346313,
-0.5641771554946899,
-0.043299585580825806,
-0.6813641786575317,
0.6016944050788879,
0.3409183919429779,
0.29496297240257263,
0.5459407567977905,
-0.16937166452407837,
0.4699559211730957,
-0.07254990190267563,
-0.05424775928258896,
0.055536899715662,
-0.33366647362709045,
-0.1233239471912384,
-0.45079946517944336,
-0.18137262761592865,
0.5527281165122986,
-0.5228379964828491,
0.6371538043022156,
-0.20566466450691223,
-0.41478320956230164,
-0.33737608790397644,
-0.14826031029224396,
-0.09385759383440018,
0.20420081913471222,
0.24291670322418213,
0.15046904981136322,
-1.1007788181304932,
-0.4633052349090576,
-0.16589786112308502,
-0.3033096194267273,
-0.164496511220932,
0.6381311416625977,
0.35919296741485596,
-0.5878371596336365,
1.1785774230957031,
-0.23382405936717987,
-0.12173240631818771,
-0.4631448984146118,
0.026941385120153427,
0.6308292150497437,
0.21770933270454407,
0.49891847372055054,
-0.7261250019073486,
0.06768109649419785,
0.12182661890983582,
-0.7691034078598022,
-0.45963624119758606,
-0.2367382049560547,
-0.296548068523407,
0.01296100951731205,
0.638884961605072,
-1.0227464437484741,
0.21131891012191772,
0.23782330751419067,
-0.7182849645614624,
0.7397367358207703,
-0.009221093729138374,
0.36491629481315613,
-0.7948645949363708,
0.07140761613845825,
-0.1072353720664978,
-0.014556445181369781,
-0.4417770802974701,
0.12665826082229614,
-0.43642961978912354,
-0.6431856155395508,
-0.16376373171806335,
0.584430456161499,
-0.17875197529792786,
-0.5919739603996277,
-0.27811676263809204,
0.08813264220952988,
0.1824038326740265,
0.5793816447257996,
0.3533470034599304,
0.81767338514328,
0.5105602741241455,
-0.36391475796699524,
0.44389280676841736,
0.5305705666542053,
-0.6191836595535278,
0.12408659607172012,
-0.5827677249908447,
0.2426629662513733,
-0.0022880686447024345,
0.48120400309562683,
-1.1799266338348389,
0.015367576852440834,
0.06786567717790604,
-0.5487217903137207,
-0.08251332491636276,
-0.24065999686717987,
-0.7330111265182495,
-0.47726356983184814,
0.33310967683792114,
0.5982008576393127,
0.395073264837265,
-0.8584735989570618,
0.9161349534988403,
0.5028263926506042,
-0.25608181953430176,
-0.1768866330385208,
-0.6994831562042236,
-0.04982491582632065,
-0.3751581013202667,
-0.585468590259552,
-0.24008700251579285,
-0.06703060865402222,
-0.43864497542381287,
-0.11542072892189026,
-0.464275598526001,
-0.3087146282196045,
-0.04648332670331001,
0.41234534978866577,
0.13574381172657013,
-0.34268632531166077,
0.13717511296272278,
-0.034938909113407135,
-0.0032441625371575356,
0.5723318457603455,
-0.517219066619873,
0.4855125844478607,
-0.06749152392148972,
-0.5540854334831238,
-0.0665104016661644,
0.3584900200366974,
0.5947870016098022,
-0.3391245901584625,
0.25250494480133057,
0.39295297861099243,
-0.45655786991119385,
-0.3273003101348877,
-0.4190610945224762,
-0.26514604687690735,
-0.4830563962459564,
0.5021851658821106,
-0.5381088852882385,
-0.9364588260650635,
0.7059692144393921,
-0.1678951531648636,
-0.16822963953018188,
-0.025713631883263588,
0.3620501756668091,
-0.35455819964408875,
1.0654200315475464,
0.2033553272485733,
-0.13356651365756989,
0.2591843605041504,
-0.01951996609568596,
0.7155223488807678,
-0.6810835599899292,
-0.40789464116096497,
-0.5122858881950378,
-0.23419687151908875,
-0.024134136736392975,
-0.7755761742591858,
0.2790902554988861,
0.013001538813114166,
-0.7843968868255615,
0.2300417125225067,
-0.4127633571624756,
0.6447217464447021,
0.3684841990470886,
0.13663993775844574,
-0.06079310178756714,
-0.019617076963186264,
-0.20864443480968475,
-0.05659310519695282,
-0.49022573232650757,
-0.20915086567401886,
0.601485550403595,
0.49590393900871277,
0.5585536956787109,
0.3620936870574951,
0.49873557686805725,
0.1780497431755066,
-0.5602952837944031,
-0.9387632608413696,
0.6320508122444153,
-0.003322357079014182,
-0.6833165287971497,
-0.5571674108505249,
-0.47216975688934326,
-0.8834036588668823,
0.3652149736881256,
-0.11997844278812408,
-0.597385585308075,
0.20644114911556244,
-0.16914808750152588,
-0.6758067607879639,
0.33431702852249146,
-0.5309785008430481,
0.6028605699539185,
-0.37066617608070374,
-0.07738661020994186,
-0.35370007157325745,
-0.3273923993110657,
0.1058516800403595,
0.014537806622684002,
0.5347609519958496,
-0.15123334527015686,
0.333858847618103,
0.6252856254577637,
-0.16872718930244446,
0.7521215677261353,
-0.5359470248222351,
-0.2119254767894745,
0.50215083360672,
0.40383923053741455,
0.18747028708457947,
0.10722564905881882,
0.06869449466466904,
0.45632755756378174,
-0.1712161898612976,
-0.01477950531989336,
-0.7786619663238525,
0.30597808957099915,
-0.8506229519844055,
-0.577226996421814,
-0.015292868949472904,
-0.7128345966339111,
-0.4407985806465149,
0.1599002331495285,
0.04811154678463936,
0.5941938161849976,
0.17809826135635376,
0.008811523206532001,
0.7864487767219543,
-0.5427932143211365,
0.006531757768243551,
0.5280541777610779,
-0.47783899307250977,
-0.43199872970581055,
0.6643002033233643,
-0.16294482350349426,
-0.40706536173820496,
0.715997040271759,
0.2890772521495819,
-0.7299303412437439,
-0.6289495825767517,
-0.16161134839057922,
0.19862735271453857,
-0.9007114171981812,
-0.05561298504471779,
-0.5968629717826843,
-0.1410488784313202,
-0.3313020169734955,
-0.5374542474746704,
-0.17453990876674652,
-0.09716890007257462,
0.06549102813005447,
-0.4041357934474945,
0.278070330619812,
0.7985833287239075,
-0.22887106239795685,
0.11658502370119095,
-0.6150794625282288,
0.5123201012611389,
0.2709660530090332,
0.2156931608915329,
-0.17668643593788147,
-0.7245503664016724,
-0.22128258645534515,
-0.04738475754857063,
0.2636168301105499,
-0.818885087966919,
0.46352264285087585,
-0.31801319122314453,
0.5998875498771667,
0.159246563911438,
-0.21710044145584106,
0.6406726837158203,
-0.6906362771987915,
0.622710108757019,
0.13662125170230865,
-1.000813364982605,
0.742695689201355,
-0.6731661558151245,
0.440702348947525,
0.2888406813144684,
-0.028155632317066193,
-0.5517765879631042,
-0.3086754381656647,
-0.23928570747375488,
-1.042122721672058,
0.5404805541038513,
-0.14905759692192078,
-0.30955997109413147,
-0.09386491030454636,
0.15889142453670502,
0.037061743438243866,
0.06576646119356155,
-0.6415002346038818,
0.283662348985672,
-0.4394109547138214,
-0.17594385147094727,
-0.08285615593194962,
-0.06238483265042305,
-0.1261172741651535,
-0.42620977759361267,
0.40181171894073486,
-0.10759003460407257,
0.4954279363155365,
0.1580325812101364,
-0.057357579469680786,
-0.04485217481851578,
0.3022238314151764,
0.4161258041858673,
0.4195939898490906,
-0.23799201846122742,
0.3075876235961914,
0.4362211227416992,
-0.15889829397201538,
0.2096845805644989,
-0.06957687437534332,
0.3957507014274597,
-0.0008953887736424804,
0.5560093522071838,
0.8841745853424072,
0.7084540128707886,
-0.9516258835792542,
0.4337674081325531,
0.0713927149772644,
-0.37463629245758057,
-0.40448492765426636,
-0.0944988802075386,
0.44234499335289,
0.7174612283706665,
0.2590096592903137,
0.287114679813385,
0.5239757895469666,
-0.510454535484314,
0.33150342106819153,
0.032978229224681854,
-0.16546854376792908,
-0.22769655287265778,
0.789304792881012,
0.14584149420261383,
-0.23722277581691742,
0.7080224752426147,
-0.13089610636234283,
-0.5562201142311096,
0.8563820719718933,
0.7609511613845825,
0.8525720238685608,
0.1496403068304062,
-0.06800442188978195,
0.5666779279708862,
0.4143008291721344,
0.19433031976222992,
0.3965718150138855,
-0.4861559271812439,
-0.9243224859237671,
-0.6652016043663025,
-0.641714334487915,
-0.46606355905532837,
-0.16906222701072693,
-0.45031407475471497,
-0.06811819225549698,
-0.7592173218727112,
0.036804549396038055,
-0.09245599806308746,
-0.057870909571647644,
-0.4417583644390106,
0.08727232366800308,
0.5739447474479675,
1.0716526508331299,
-0.945293128490448,
0.5108174085617065,
0.8256188035011292,
-0.3843376934528351,
-1.0635312795639038,
0.015887603163719177,
-0.24563591182231903,
-0.8288626074790955,
0.9761121869087219,
0.14264348149299622,
-0.4828178286552429,
-0.21335916221141815,
-0.6688992381095886,
-0.6926668286323547,
0.878929853439331,
0.42568984627723694,
-0.9081252813339233,
0.07709205895662308,
0.23055043816566467,
0.5189415812492371,
-0.13699695467948914,
0.14741477370262146,
0.7249898314476013,
0.5154080986976624,
0.39147502183914185,
-0.7123351097106934,
-0.006046637427061796,
-0.1692442148923874,
-0.114250548183918,
0.17882102727890015,
-0.42161232233047485,
0.4146347939968109,
-0.5727078914642334,
-0.15116600692272186,
-0.27478858828544617,
0.541551947593689,
0.8837369680404663,
0.3577992022037506,
0.642615795135498,
0.5934206247329712,
0.8832902908325195,
-0.18312384188175201,
0.7610288262367249,
-0.015094275586307049,
-0.0764753520488739,
1.0394405126571655,
-0.739215612411499,
0.9866040349006653,
0.293895959854126,
-0.2069265991449356,
0.6655985116958618,
0.6739978790283203,
-0.0013729911297559738,
0.6757998466491699,
0.2285119593143463,
-0.4785597622394562,
-0.5831559300422668,
0.04623591899871826,
-0.05638907849788666,
0.7199205756187439,
0.4002479612827301,
0.3107161521911621,
0.06857677549123764,
0.20488980412483215,
-0.4010657072067261,
0.2773185968399048,
-0.391825795173645,
0.8897267580032349,
0.07621213048696518,
-0.3793517053127289,
0.1866363137960434,
-0.23758579790592194,
0.4945562183856964,
-0.6178862452507019,
-0.10175779461860657,
-0.15598918497562408,
0.00002629609480209183,
-0.2730046510696411,
-0.9867119789123535,
0.598090410232544,
-0.11264067888259888,
-0.4052252173423767,
-0.09379331022500992,
0.6061244606971741,
-0.3792259097099304,
-0.107420414686203,
0.4946334660053253,
-0.11703572422266006,
0.2885274887084961,
-0.19116754829883575,
-0.4511655867099762,
0.18141350150108337,
0.0066237482242286205,
0.14188778400421143,
-0.06216255575418472,
0.982940137386322,
0.08417293429374695,
0.7666719555854797,
0.8314642906188965,
0.364522248506546,
-0.12746703624725342,
0.540630578994751,
0.38282084465026855,
-1.0237845182418823,
-0.9657370448112488,
-0.5878782272338867,
0.19257865846157074,
0.27028006315231323,
0.049016036093235016,
0.4328295588493347,
0.6937078237533569,
0.503792405128479,
-0.05718718841671944,
0.9455668926239014,
0.21106645464897156,
0.578423798084259,
-0.6783598065376282,
0.6740325689315796,
-0.2228347212076187,
0.38227227330207825,
0.14127831161022186,
-0.5822897553443909,
-0.27191492915153503,
1.061699628829956,
-0.5123319625854492,
0.0217596348375082,
0.7575236558914185,
0.758647620677948,
0.09804007411003113,
0.3678014576435089,
0.5127896666526794,
0.3047904372215271,
0.481828510761261,
0.6614408493041992,
1.136038064956665,
0.03738931566476822,
0.5369861721992493,
0.16357238590717316,
0.10673040896654129,
-0.007569082081317902,
-0.4392828643321991,
-0.8303738236427307,
-0.5702465176582336,
-0.08155574649572372,
-0.042948707938194275,
-0.05773233622312546,
1.0620687007904053,
0.6915932297706604,
-0.7415899038314819,
-0.301724910736084,
-0.2508750855922699,
0.03806038945913315,
-0.2515120208263397,
-0.25809377431869507,
0.05866444110870361,
-0.23847584426403046,
-0.3250284492969513,
1.0812023878097534,
0.4649665057659149,
-0.23371848464012146,
0.04336359351873398,
-0.27819570899009705,
0.10956960171461105,
0.2849443554878235,
0.6225087642669678,
0.4220454692840576,
-0.7088258862495422,
-0.46424204111099243,
-0.1703301966190338,
0.020214468240737915,
0.014703950844705105,
0.7451502680778503,
-0.7191897630691528,
0.44062379002571106,
0.295263409614563,
0.8028745055198669,
0.40414509177207947,
-0.29379260540008545,
0.545717716217041,
-0.721110999584198,
0.11360054463148117,
0.4288746416568756,
0.6802464127540588,
0.3746996819972992,
-0.29712921380996704,
0.44422945380210876,
0.12774889171123505,
-0.6916117072105408,
-0.7117660641670227,
0.13669288158416748,
-1.1336864233016968,
-0.4405234456062317,
1.464597463607788,
0.23477911949157715,
-0.12306451797485352,
-0.403655081987381,
-0.6580355167388916,
0.33324113488197327,
-0.3983762562274933,
0.60313481092453,
0.6203417181968689,
-0.06108776107430458,
-0.11045987159013748,
-0.4269123375415802,
0.20550324022769928,
0.34504514932632446,
-0.7153859734535217,
0.24502797424793243,
0.5881258249282837,
0.34175750613212585,
0.21059000492095947,
0.765565037727356,
0.013098301365971565,
0.5894825458526611,
0.5203253626823425,
0.3940648138523102,
-0.07397224754095078,
-0.5353718400001526,
-0.42223507165908813,
0.1044938787817955,
0.20226283371448517,
-0.15909427404403687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01586v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01586v2 | TrustAgent: Towards Safe and Trustworthy LLM-based Agents through Agent Constitution | 2024-02-02T17:26:23 | 2024-02-18T04:11:55 | Wenyue Hua, Xianjun Yang, Zelong Li, Wei Cheng, Yongfeng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.MA | The emergence of LLM-based agents has garnered considerable attention, yet
their trustworthiness remains an under-explored area. As agents can directly
interact with the physical environment, their reliability and safety is
critical. This paper presents an Agent-Constitution-based agent framework,
TrustAgent, an initial investigation into improving the safety dimension of
trustworthiness in LLM-based agents. This framework consists of threefold
strategies: pre-planning strategy which injects safety knowledge to the model
prior to plan generation, in-planning strategy which bolsters safety during
plan generation, and post-planning strategy which ensures safety by
post-planning inspection. Through experimental analysis, we demonstrate how
these approaches can effectively elevate an LLM agent's safety by identifying
and preventing potential dangers. Furthermore, we explore the intricate
relationships between safety and helpfulness, and between the model's reasoning
ability and its efficacy as a safe agent. This paper underscores the imperative
of integrating safety awareness and trustworthiness into the design and
deployment of LLM-based agents, not only to enhance their performance but also
to ensure their responsible integration into human-centric environments. Data
and code are available at https://github.com/agiresearch/TrustAgent. | [
-0.35779669880867004,
-0.21772031486034393,
0.6856619119644165,
-0.11033717542886734,
-0.11106649786233902,
0.22775740921497345,
0.37735715508461,
-0.8447368144989014,
-0.08975019305944443,
0.4344295859336853,
-0.4057476222515106,
-0.2644195854663849,
-0.4486005902290344,
-0.06156580150127411,
-0.1546255201101303,
0.8019740581512451,
-0.17330172657966614,
-0.2028486728668213,
-0.34903648495674133,
0.052355412393808365,
-0.2051030695438385,
-0.5835749506950378,
-0.8299497961997986,
-0.7817447781562805,
0.36690983176231384,
0.27580884099006653,
1.0860973596572876,
0.7756679654121399,
0.26197314262390137,
0.336911678314209,
0.039962220937013626,
0.4126436710357666,
-0.37749984860420227,
0.23213018476963043,
-0.4015645384788513,
-0.5246877074241638,
-0.9079267382621765,
0.3605290651321411,
0.17665044963359833,
-0.17036984860897064,
-0.23553505539894104,
-0.2766250967979431,
0.22956962883472443,
0.26261112093925476,
-0.5193318724632263,
0.34483587741851807,
-0.6806855797767639,
-0.07750247418880463,
0.40412792563438416,
-0.5923750996589661,
-0.2642052471637726,
-0.3633570373058319,
0.004370581824332476,
-0.7066662311553955,
-0.1766376495361328,
0.17690002918243408,
0.7256051898002625,
0.4882717430591583,
-0.3618016541004181,
-0.19748005270957947,
-0.3794334828853607,
0.4406261444091797,
-0.15435604751110077,
0.17050737142562866,
0.5066487193107605,
0.27446258068084717,
-0.43168333172798157,
-0.6788523197174072,
-0.47283247113227844,
-0.5675361156463623,
-0.044313084334135056,
0.020595574751496315,
0.0819050520658493,
0.15094247460365295,
-0.034411314874887466,
-0.2494915872812271,
-0.34438973665237427,
0.05496253818273544,
0.40532466769218445,
-0.7031831741333008,
0.614351212978363,
0.025514202192425728,
0.33195048570632935,
0.056645940989255905,
-0.7003489136695862,
-0.3330535292625427,
-0.6456601023674011,
0.24642008543014526,
0.4472627639770508,
0.09508904814720154,
-0.0810927227139473,
0.41551437973976135,
-0.2934077978134155,
0.016033753752708435,
0.20459870994091034,
-0.3606005311012268,
0.007754907011985779,
-0.42607662081718445,
-0.07937315851449966,
0.19699417054653168,
0.34039992094039917,
0.3768046498298645,
0.5069175362586975,
-0.16913363337516785,
-0.5057737231254578,
0.2117326557636261,
0.49287500977516174,
-0.6904574632644653,
-0.16376689076423645,
0.2749876081943512,
-0.3411242663860321,
-0.9778776168823242,
0.12789373099803925,
-0.17092083394527435,
-0.6839083433151245,
-0.27465954422950745,
0.5139209032058716,
-0.6830146312713623,
-0.33511215448379517,
0.07436766475439072,
0.15816445648670197,
0.588036835193634,
0.5341911315917969,
-0.2762536406517029,
0.16368424892425537,
0.899942934513092,
0.5727530717849731,
0.01042430754750967,
-0.7089127898216248,
-0.6053025126457214,
0.537844717502594,
-0.2674742639064789,
0.8047298789024353,
-0.13934014737606049,
-0.6621661186218262,
0.019945524632930756,
0.12752772867679596,
0.05087194964289665,
-0.06962049007415771,
0.4635009765625,
-0.6133714318275452,
-0.35303911566734314,
-0.11847138404846191,
-0.3763881027698517,
-0.12031000107526779,
0.8780076503753662,
-0.5793089866638184,
0.643768846988678,
-0.06225140020251274,
-0.3876841068267822,
0.3962843418121338,
-0.7652818560600281,
-0.3666706383228302,
-0.08415643870830536,
-0.06873972713947296,
-0.15029621124267578,
-0.2748652994632721,
0.03908831626176834,
0.4823439419269562,
0.09540959447622299,
-0.12734884023666382,
-0.2734757661819458,
-0.18928159773349762,
0.5775360465049744,
-0.30939823389053345,
0.5457337498664856,
0.17306922376155853,
-0.15409605205059052,
0.2894870340824127,
-0.5828642845153809,
0.35503455996513367,
-0.0019334055250510573,
-0.08368374407291412,
-0.028398124501109123,
-0.08084865659475327,
-0.12739475071430206,
0.30657410621643066,
0.5953258275985718,
-0.28225505352020264,
-0.34692782163619995,
-0.20738442242145538,
0.14878183603286743,
0.8533934950828552,
0.21789875626564026,
0.6348293423652649,
-0.959374189376831,
0.41054895520210266,
-0.02290177159011364,
0.6643008589744568,
0.06763718277215958,
-0.12910397350788116,
-0.39955464005470276,
-0.11421289294958115,
-0.18077228963375092,
0.638241171836853,
-0.565961480140686,
0.42823755741119385,
-0.050948113203048706,
-0.6594158411026001,
0.05767941102385521,
-0.05327314883470535,
0.5007399916648865,
0.4732501804828644,
0.05849026143550873,
-0.27146008610725403,
-0.18019182980060577,
-0.43079257011413574,
-0.11965431272983551,
-0.7048797011375427,
0.357646644115448,
0.026049891486763954,
0.5097233057022095,
-0.48711010813713074,
0.9149075150489807,
-0.1728554219007492,
0.029419314116239548,
-0.23429909348487854,
-0.4309256076812744,
-0.4629753828048706,
0.7283123135566711,
0.5789705514907837,
-0.7749496698379517,
-0.3032342791557312,
0.17050102353096008,
-0.6810437440872192,
0.19201704859733582,
0.22192396223545074,
-0.5616750121116638,
0.2881631553173065,
0.39930281043052673,
-1.0067386627197266,
0.46171215176582336,
-0.0036706889513880014,
-0.6236535906791687,
0.7250257730484009,
-0.32172268629074097,
0.10767614841461182,
-1.1875276565551758,
-0.12831148505210876,
-0.37243664264678955,
-0.6049959063529968,
-0.7084181904792786,
0.33786237239837646,
-0.07916101813316345,
0.03398123383522034,
-0.7588902115821838,
0.39790698885917664,
-0.2407740354537964,
0.19795715808868408,
-0.5087532997131348,
0.013960367068648338,
0.2167447954416275,
0.008200298063457012,
-0.09322187304496765,
0.8402088284492493,
0.4563344419002533,
-0.45904064178466797,
0.22649924457073212,
0.3259151577949524,
0.2742389738559723,
0.8271469473838806,
-0.6580607891082764,
0.42824316024780273,
0.007382519543170929,
0.17309674620628357,
-0.4768150746822357,
-0.34429389238357544,
0.4116879999637604,
-0.3942165970802307,
0.48992618918418884,
-0.06555156409740448,
-0.52271568775177,
0.21504947543144226,
-0.4457505941390991,
0.04973222315311432,
0.2599231004714966,
-0.3624458909034729,
0.8337054252624512,
0.43021291494369507,
0.25479939579963684,
-0.6983336210250854,
-0.41318780183792114,
0.006921892054378986,
-0.2622043490409851,
-0.8447966575622559,
0.08192142099142075,
-0.22247040271759033,
-0.5881611704826355,
-0.05793393775820732,
-0.3837381899356842,
-0.1487579643726349,
0.35873863101005554,
0.5543763637542725,
0.2643795907497406,
0.3984760344028473,
-0.13297954201698303,
-0.19451679289340973,
-0.6085762977600098,
0.29106390476226807,
-0.26234543323516846,
0.2747814357280731,
-0.5359700918197632,
-0.2429238259792328,
-0.45987239480018616,
0.20335277915000916,
0.6661285758018494,
-0.2296530306339264,
0.7931200861930847,
0.3432186543941498,
-0.2906550168991089,
-0.3611970543861389,
-0.38032251596450806,
-0.41110923886299133,
-0.5555439591407776,
0.06403371691703796,
-0.46539366245269775,
-0.7717128992080688,
0.5124208331108093,
-0.3323063552379608,
-0.0280680563300848,
-0.04031499847769737,
0.26932868361473083,
-0.1440400332212448,
0.5490565299987793,
0.7056235074996948,
-0.019345615059137344,
0.2355172485113144,
-0.018955467268824577,
-0.13828600943088531,
-0.18883109092712402,
-0.492737352848053,
-0.38743722438812256,
0.18586574494838715,
-0.560736358165741,
-0.5479283928871155,
0.3032864034175873,
-0.3206532299518585,
-0.4125712811946869,
0.20573082566261292,
-0.20474357903003693,
0.5121610760688782,
0.13046598434448242,
0.24135415256023407,
0.4917057752609253,
-0.3794219493865967,
-0.05154316872358322,
0.48696866631507874,
-0.3071760833263397,
-0.9515700340270996,
0.8239386677742004,
0.4471481144428253,
0.7816343903541565,
0.23272033035755157,
0.9965644478797913,
0.3701257109642029,
0.2020421028137207,
-0.6503857970237732,
0.7959175705909729,
0.5963854789733887,
-0.5834081768989563,
-0.39984825253486633,
-0.029737869277596474,
-0.6132550239562988,
0.22217075526714325,
-0.40306589007377625,
-0.5885041952133179,
0.1357971876859665,
0.178254172205925,
-0.10766755789518356,
-0.02875738963484764,
-0.5218967199325562,
0.4507766664028168,
-0.5042672753334045,
-0.5387700796127319,
-0.35516107082366943,
-0.7534155249595642,
0.07072808593511581,
-0.2639837861061096,
-0.03804668411612511,
-0.26614195108413696,
-0.3961399495601654,
-0.03980293124914169,
-0.6480028033256531,
0.5371699929237366,
-0.16886690258979797,
-0.07330508530139923,
0.4545787572860718,
0.23614242672920227,
1.0717778205871582,
0.2345072478055954,
-0.25375664234161377,
0.03916527330875397,
0.2309979349374771,
-0.24179640412330627,
-0.6115458011627197,
0.6115201711654663,
-1.0116686820983887,
-0.619240403175354,
-0.4491574466228485,
-0.6851944327354431,
-0.40557926893234253,
0.40095236897468567,
-0.09600813686847687,
0.11697754263877869,
-0.4503878653049469,
0.08979025483131409,
0.9090635776519775,
0.11930041760206223,
0.6532964110374451,
0.5627367496490479,
0.016322290524840355,
-0.23735842108726501,
0.5443761944770813,
-0.006223656237125397,
0.2976139783859253,
0.22623583674430847,
0.024182498455047607,
-0.4956441819667816,
-0.5877659320831299,
0.19489188492298126,
-0.04564569517970085,
-0.6507273316383362,
-0.16180254518985748,
-0.2219143956899643,
-0.4148658514022827,
-0.22035221755504608,
-0.3630022406578064,
-0.4762049913406372,
-0.1511281430721283,
-0.1076931431889534,
-0.478424072265625,
0.3661053776741028,
0.5084118247032166,
-0.2245786041021347,
0.3434605300426483,
-0.4162885844707489,
0.0013121208176016808,
0.2960853576660156,
0.24955683946609497,
-0.32245588302612305,
0.10711055994033813,
-0.3319527208805084,
-0.18874585628509521,
-0.2904900014400482,
-0.7528217434883118,
0.1358252912759781,
-0.1676282286643982,
0.9042054414749146,
0.6128978133201599,
0.3621240556240082,
0.1712767630815506,
-0.23681454360485077,
0.3910931646823883,
-0.06632485240697861,
-0.7401916980743408,
0.46311676502227783,
-0.5279607772827148,
-0.30433571338653564,
0.8946051597595215,
0.0942368432879448,
0.30810287594795227,
-0.2419588714838028,
-0.5677237510681152,
-0.39841771125793457,
0.36741700768470764,
0.6029815077781677,
-0.2502714991569519,
0.26180499792099,
0.5415501594543457,
0.02305559255182743,
0.28618165850639343,
-0.6387224793434143,
-0.10177309066057205,
-0.4860987961292267,
0.1301840990781784,
-0.151795893907547,
-0.35349830985069275,
-0.5472314953804016,
0.2078741192817688,
0.7567147016525269,
-0.3179992735385895,
0.11225605010986328,
0.32637980580329895,
-0.2935703694820404,
0.03488209471106529,
0.4355982542037964,
0.5110963582992554,
0.6313600540161133,
-0.24580897390842438,
0.3853064477443695,
0.18523207306861877,
-0.6839317679405212,
0.5993549227714539,
0.4094123840332031,
-0.08152065426111221,
-0.6747980713844299,
0.18374067544937134,
0.11546263843774796,
-0.014635808765888214,
-0.3418191373348236,
0.2979446053504944,
-0.046675197780132294,
-0.286006361246109,
-0.48469990491867065,
0.5434988141059875,
-0.11464264988899231,
0.6368916034698486,
0.19437097012996674,
0.055950943380594254,
-0.06799817830324173,
-0.3642898201942444,
0.4663647711277008,
0.4265810251235962,
-0.3356793522834778,
-0.2623971998691559,
0.5594158172607422,
0.31170061230659485,
-0.35336822271347046,
-0.07847055047750473,
-0.17571672797203064,
-0.37639784812927246,
0.6624186038970947,
0.42210307717323303,
1.0679588317871094,
-0.3165263235569,
0.285996675491333,
-0.2855266034603119,
0.821711540222168,
-0.07816225290298462,
0.5783526301383972,
0.10011029988527298,
-1.1244103908538818,
0.028546558693051338,
-0.24929489195346832,
-0.5696184635162354,
-0.24598851799964905,
-0.2997259497642517,
-0.12540161609649658,
-0.6392061710357666,
-0.3646283745765686,
-0.7100929021835327,
0.4626578688621521,
-0.46753185987472534,
0.20926108956336975,
-0.16082337498664856,
1.102789282798767,
-0.42626938223838806,
0.773571789264679,
1.0905017852783203,
-0.2250838428735733,
-1.2147990465164185,
0.32906627655029297,
0.15540944039821625,
-0.810487687587738,
0.03902719169855118,
0.21430295705795288,
-0.7703262567520142,
-0.07022148370742798,
-0.6123527884483337,
-0.723476767539978,
1.7592917680740356,
0.4840734302997589,
-0.14668287336826324,
0.13920795917510986,
0.37786561250686646,
0.5337694883346558,
-0.5068671703338623,
-0.06390737742185593,
0.4106294512748718,
0.7688670754432678,
0.06254164129495621,
-0.7110875248908997,
0.46548107266426086,
-0.24886010587215424,
-0.1543072760105133,
-0.12569169700145721,
-0.8273003101348877,
0.37027525901794434,
-0.25600510835647583,
0.10337840765714645,
0.27595844864845276,
0.5004262924194336,
0.7142114639282227,
0.7322815656661987,
0.7074620723724365,
0.5132416486740112,
0.9196882247924805,
0.1450672596693039,
0.9538959264755249,
-0.6546169519424438,
0.022585900500416756,
0.9460099339485168,
-0.44169244170188904,
0.4863077700138092,
0.45736849308013916,
0.3178854286670685,
0.4764772951602936,
0.3179481029510498,
0.4693372845649719,
0.5199851393699646,
-0.28422310948371887,
-0.5170267224311829,
-0.5548062920570374,
-0.2723775804042816,
-0.31774330139160156,
0.696346640586853,
-0.04271100461483002,
-0.18309015035629272,
-0.11629096418619156,
-0.28066468238830566,
0.2982984781265259,
-0.05978748947381973,
-0.4044419527053833,
0.46586719155311584,
0.19369938969612122,
-0.28054723143577576,
-0.2201721966266632,
-0.38276809453964233,
0.08953007310628891,
-0.5862962603569031,
0.08323252201080322,
0.008100791834294796,
0.17097264528274536,
-0.19814342260360718,
-0.7632796168327332,
0.16415928304195404,
-0.255444198846817,
-0.07779380679130554,
-0.3080631196498871,
1.2829304933547974,
0.0965459868311882,
0.12678110599517822,
0.32551488280296326,
0.891788125038147,
-0.04812835156917572,
0.05086149647831917,
-0.49267229437828064,
-0.1608467996120453,
-0.4969549775123596,
-0.12849591672420502,
0.39622002840042114,
0.5703423023223877,
-0.009158870205283165,
0.8980003595352173,
0.6919844746589661,
-0.08842001110315323,
-0.36226198077201843,
-0.31850185990333557,
0.7969211339950562,
-0.5072190165519714,
-0.8709892630577087,
-0.6877391338348389,
0.706748366355896,
-0.09645994007587433,
0.2864862382411957,
0.7366508841514587,
0.16489702463150024,
0.48104000091552734,
0.1106545627117157,
0.791976273059845,
0.15829898416996002,
-0.05322299152612686,
-0.33007362484931946,
1.257102370262146,
-0.25922077894210815,
0.3151271343231201,
-0.157062366604805,
-0.6651487946510315,
-0.06476719677448273,
0.5251872539520264,
0.05849756300449371,
0.170627623796463,
0.5455197691917419,
1.172359585762024,
0.2862223982810974,
-0.13213638961315155,
0.48911693692207336,
0.03271106258034706,
0.6603387594223022,
0.4524802565574646,
1.2140870094299316,
-0.06603622436523438,
0.6192094683647156,
-0.18978500366210938,
-0.20886915922164917,
0.02073698118329048,
-1.1898765563964844,
-0.9046292304992676,
-0.16297432780265808,
-0.08597487211227417,
-0.619307279586792,
0.23981237411499023,
0.9381360411643982,
0.8266748785972595,
-0.3883006274700165,
-0.013764538802206516,
-0.25724363327026367,
0.4646839499473572,
-0.022685861214995384,
-0.15431377291679382,
-0.06685557961463928,
-0.011457260698080063,
-0.28406500816345215,
0.5340752005577087,
0.16466811299324036,
0.40417197346687317,
-0.22002311050891876,
-0.6787120699882507,
0.24088065326213837,
0.3481656312942505,
0.394464373588562,
0.3199329674243927,
-0.4239667057991028,
-0.6652559638023376,
-0.20596814155578613,
-0.2572593688964844,
-0.19571363925933838,
0.46864500641822815,
-0.4886661171913147,
0.24396000802516937,
0.20254233479499817,
0.3598287105560303,
-0.04323657602071762,
0.2195127159357071,
0.6168660521507263,
-0.4584434926509857,
0.21062739193439484,
0.042405031621456146,
0.3920655846595764,
0.09716977179050446,
-0.8470891118049622,
0.7532146573066711,
0.08068127930164337,
-0.8200557827949524,
-0.6408436298370361,
0.47890299558639526,
-1.2327996492385864,
0.1318030059337616,
1.122471809387207,
-0.15485450625419617,
-0.09430079162120819,
-0.38412195444107056,
-0.31453052163124084,
0.3242532014846802,
-0.5432483553886414,
0.6482423543930054,
0.42633405327796936,
-0.46967050433158875,
-0.21355926990509033,
0.013944457285106182,
0.6677601933479309,
-0.1140991598367691,
-1.0960383415222168,
-0.31641003489494324,
0.4767685830593109,
0.4808792471885681,
0.22163110971450806,
0.5957351922988892,
-0.027762696146965027,
0.40349873900413513,
0.20781728625297546,
-0.09307418018579483,
-0.7133454084396362,
-0.625358521938324,
-0.11558627337217331,
0.5176315307617188,
0.5062206983566284,
-0.25595763325691223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01582v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01582v1 | Automating Sound Change Prediction for Phylogenetic Inference: A Tukanoan Case Study | 2024-02-02T17:20:16 | 2024-02-02T17:20:16 | Kalvin Chang, Nathaniel R. Robinson, Anna Cai, Ting Chen, Annie Zhang, David R. Mortensen | cs.CL | cs.CL | We describe a set of new methods to partially automate linguistic
phylogenetic inference given (1) cognate sets with their respective protoforms
and sound laws, (2) a mapping from phones to their articulatory features and
(3) a typological database of sound changes. We train a neural network on these
sound change data to weight articulatory distances between phones and predict
intermediate sound change steps between historical protoforms and their modern
descendants, replacing a linguistic expert in part of a parsimony-based
phylogenetic inference algorithm. In our best experiments on Tukanoan
languages, this method produces trees with a Generalized Quartet Distance of
0.12 from a tree that used expert annotations, a significant improvement over
other semi-automated baselines. We discuss potential benefits and drawbacks to
our neural approach and parsimony-based tree prediction. We also experiment
with a minimal generalization learner for automatic sound law induction,
finding it comparably effective to sound laws from expert annotation. Our code
is publicly available at https://github.com/cmu-llab/aiscp. | [
-0.28189346194267273,
-0.5731551647186279,
0.19473108649253845,
0.06543099880218506,
-0.3390336334705353,
0.04258406162261963,
-0.2873281240463257,
-0.7644661664962769,
0.6770361661911011,
0.10306139290332794,
-0.32647883892059326,
-0.2971687614917755,
-0.4108547568321228,
0.11027201265096664,
-0.34408146142959595,
0.35113325715065,
0.3368494510650635,
0.15410032868385315,
0.44732123613357544,
-0.23910032212734222,
-0.5395805835723877,
-0.18065550923347473,
-0.7583505511283875,
-0.17125864326953888,
0.35595330595970154,
0.49627771973609924,
0.7611029148101807,
1.2640631198883057,
0.24250343441963196,
0.24300658702850342,
-0.5062706470489502,
-0.20351697504520416,
0.09782296419143677,
0.23075151443481445,
0.03345216065645218,
-0.6250874996185303,
-0.28011950850486755,
-0.1364022046327591,
0.24734435975551605,
0.9469637870788574,
-0.2985648214817047,
0.24215087294578552,
-0.16875389218330383,
0.5902513265609741,
-0.25654637813568115,
0.4732074737548828,
-0.78648841381073,
0.39949455857276917,
-0.504145085811615,
-0.4688158631324768,
-0.1820928007364273,
-0.3632732033729553,
0.35061144828796387,
-0.714006245136261,
0.14743590354919434,
0.004648901987820864,
0.5780391097068787,
0.5541231632232666,
-0.13553330302238464,
-0.37212657928466797,
-0.6896264553070068,
0.5451856255531311,
-0.8678693175315857,
0.43414002656936646,
0.4989597201347351,
0.4173981249332428,
-0.514976978302002,
-0.5023568868637085,
-0.28856226801872253,
-0.6252842545509338,
0.10099228471517563,
-0.03520127013325691,
-0.1830221265554428,
0.3266379237174988,
0.13265837728977203,
0.7516291737556458,
-0.1673291176557541,
0.1576746553182602,
-0.3240429162979126,
-0.3094216585159302,
0.7131341695785522,
-0.3320242166519165,
0.47685644030570984,
-0.25601252913475037,
0.28902995586395264,
-0.22483232617378235,
-0.7153546214103699,
0.14559242129325867,
0.57667475938797,
0.35007092356681824,
-0.09477989375591278,
0.5451103448867798,
-0.23670819401741028,
0.6658869981765747,
0.468381404876709,
-0.1287699043750763,
0.2712446451187134,
-0.4030139148235321,
-0.12822338938713074,
0.6788328886032104,
0.8286159038543701,
-0.01231254730373621,
0.3287663757801056,
-0.012503867037594318,
-0.11985350400209427,
-0.0459066741168499,
-0.2872810661792755,
-0.2869269847869873,
-0.7307755351066589,
0.004279172979295254,
-0.6802442669868469,
-0.5016228556632996,
-0.5594735145568848,
-0.6417542099952698,
-0.7474365830421448,
-0.6731328368186951,
0.3589358627796173,
-0.5612371563911438,
-0.4993720054626465,
0.159030482172966,
-0.1334734559059143,
0.12494637072086334,
0.16147738695144653,
-1.1757426261901855,
0.2764151394367218,
0.3435165584087372,
0.9274371862411499,
0.12023866921663284,
-0.25253576040267944,
-0.41959214210510254,
0.030926765874028206,
-0.40848493576049805,
0.71550452709198,
-0.6400935649871826,
-0.4667988419532776,
-0.39834919571876526,
-0.21687304973602295,
-0.22611431777477264,
-0.6337408423423767,
0.23509272933006287,
-0.16287076473236084,
0.2729244828224182,
0.10566416382789612,
-0.562008798122406,
-0.34263861179351807,
-0.49019479751586914,
-0.8570227026939392,
0.8253849148750305,
0.03968726843595505,
-0.6895015835762024,
0.3176729381084442,
-0.6867673397064209,
-0.7213367223739624,
-0.04143635556101799,
-0.15282489359378815,
-0.5341228246688843,
0.053461067378520966,
0.10303773730993271,
0.09810879081487656,
-0.09040679037570953,
0.536434531211853,
-0.5346187353134155,
-0.2561454176902771,
-0.2992565631866455,
-0.20199348032474518,
1.37059485912323,
0.33833786845207214,
-0.8988342881202698,
0.15506130456924438,
-0.6883153319358826,
-0.32727691531181335,
-0.19055408239364624,
-0.37832334637641907,
-0.1907043159008026,
0.1016712635755539,
-0.4141523838043213,
-0.2753162086009979,
-0.0032763807103037834,
-0.4582383334636688,
0.48382994532585144,
-0.4165138900279999,
0.6785382628440857,
0.4393557608127594,
0.2586384415626526,
0.5076884031295776,
-0.346944659948349,
0.33318448066711426,
-0.12762294709682465,
0.10775810480117798,
-0.1650771200656891,
-0.8269910216331482,
-0.6494917273521423,
0.07309936732053757,
0.8111635446548462,
0.5713517665863037,
-0.2554289400577545,
0.4377341866493225,
0.015423043631017208,
-0.5770596265792847,
-0.38128069043159485,
-0.06887819617986679,
0.19498522579669952,
0.42515942454338074,
0.35295605659484863,
-0.6854985356330872,
-1.0662602186203003,
-0.6529736518859863,
-0.5216948986053467,
-0.7258795499801636,
0.12625786662101746,
0.06356432288885117,
0.1535567194223404,
0.059426937252283096,
0.9201828837394714,
0.10640297830104828,
-0.3234415650367737,
0.1685565859079361,
0.3938245177268982,
0.1067306250333786,
0.7284363508224487,
0.5914026498794556,
-0.5977106690406799,
-0.1444566249847412,
0.19800089299678802,
-0.4650251567363739,
-0.4350389838218689,
-0.24268390238285065,
0.10040502995252609,
0.07543247938156128,
0.845441460609436,
-0.5928784608840942,
0.39644351601600647,
0.2894907593727112,
-0.17815621197223663,
0.7116491198539734,
0.14039504528045654,
0.07964533567428589,
-0.9893589019775391,
-0.02570231445133686,
0.12433943897485733,
-0.030771175399422646,
-0.5255499482154846,
-0.21856513619422913,
-0.3434660732746124,
0.008808746002614498,
-0.2780686914920807,
0.32999634742736816,
-0.4773663878440857,
-0.54728102684021,
0.023180805146694183,
-0.47617778182029724,
-0.4360869228839874,
0.460981547832489,
0.2504209280014038,
0.7454802393913269,
0.5851227641105652,
-0.705857515335083,
0.5100298523902893,
0.22010758519172668,
-0.12846256792545319,
0.0752018466591835,
-0.3675922453403473,
-0.0891614481806755,
0.2947305738925934,
0.41395315527915955,
-0.8490722179412842,
-0.33615800738334656,
0.38661471009254456,
-0.6995081305503845,
0.12143397331237793,
-0.5990592837333679,
-0.36819136142730713,
-0.11392050981521606,
0.009450159966945648,
0.44562017917633057,
0.4043312668800354,
-0.4353325366973877,
0.6797385811805725,
0.7023198008537292,
-0.4383655786514282,
-0.1565486043691635,
-0.5030943751335144,
0.47391387820243835,
-0.6469912528991699,
-0.3999074101448059,
0.3716767430305481,
0.03995053470134735,
-0.4907061457633972,
-0.074027419090271,
-0.15788410604000092,
-0.36192309856414795,
0.40311527252197266,
0.10483142733573914,
-0.12772710621356964,
-0.5429904460906982,
0.23469935357570648,
0.27986252307891846,
0.07191573828458786,
0.25903114676475525,
-0.8562706708908081,
0.445740669965744,
-0.24492622911930084,
-0.010728300549089909,
-0.8667829036712646,
-0.2599847912788391,
0.5448036789894104,
-0.35422778129577637,
-0.02274780347943306,
0.34629756212234497,
-0.4828931987285614,
0.43415048718452454,
-0.5278606414794922,
-0.14177298545837402,
-0.4133882224559784,
-0.015316283330321312,
-0.486482173204422,
-0.32972532510757446,
0.522004246711731,
-0.34169965982437134,
0.17181168496608734,
0.5809414982795715,
0.46255260705947876,
-0.09643878042697906,
0.7975051403045654,
0.4238536059856415,
-0.18469120562076569,
0.8538665175437927,
-0.24528099596500397,
-0.2151278406381607,
-0.3414256274700165,
-0.16739021241664886,
-0.6006035208702087,
-0.27930712699890137,
-0.7536846399307251,
-0.12529556453227997,
0.208668053150177,
0.09071267396211624,
-0.0657115951180458,
0.8567704558372498,
-0.309889018535614,
0.40754154324531555,
0.8532887697219849,
-0.05598168447613716,
0.37918224930763245,
0.19652074575424194,
-0.30332374572753906,
0.37457528710365295,
-0.6904242038726807,
-0.08671431243419647,
1.0435583591461182,
0.2502785623073578,
0.4148007333278656,
0.02729371376335621,
0.9069086313247681,
0.5678189992904663,
-0.1907997727394104,
-0.816511869430542,
0.487657368183136,
0.011442644521594048,
-0.15865978598594666,
-0.5337275266647339,
-0.41366544365882874,
-1.0804331302642822,
0.07059186697006226,
0.03148522600531578,
-0.5089215040206909,
0.4970768988132477,
0.36922457814216614,
-0.5210190415382385,
0.4452490210533142,
-0.6629388928413391,
0.5078783631324768,
-0.19541241228580475,
-0.03533206507563591,
-0.3832470774650574,
-0.9337473511695862,
0.14733056724071503,
-0.11185996234416962,
-0.0531538687646389,
-0.11709921807050705,
0.21052107214927673,
1.025743842124939,
-0.3715500831604004,
0.8399972915649414,
-0.4950341582298279,
-0.20122089982032776,
0.5622413754463196,
0.5643628835678101,
0.17262203991413116,
-0.04873243719339371,
-0.4795213043689728,
0.25906985998153687,
0.19113194942474365,
-0.3057384490966797,
-0.11017043143510818,
0.39958804845809937,
-0.6506673097610474,
-0.4940943419933319,
-0.2605137228965759,
-0.575716495513916,
-0.3201213479042053,
0.3241735100746155,
0.3174460232257843,
0.4179309010505676,
-0.08934745192527771,
0.08094563335180283,
0.5912536978721619,
-0.012948980554938316,
0.6908172965049744,
0.34756577014923096,
0.0632295235991478,
-0.5674291253089905,
0.6704874038696289,
0.11407830566167831,
-0.09325090795755386,
0.27486178278923035,
0.647802472114563,
-0.4801301062107086,
-0.7247229814529419,
-0.8775879740715027,
-0.016503414139151573,
-0.40718090534210205,
-0.050443559885025024,
-0.24267232418060303,
0.2148789018392563,
-0.4671601951122284,
0.3127698600292206,
-0.1262713372707367,
-0.9713343381881714,
-0.171725332736969,
0.004626441281288862,
0.5252130031585693,
0.9247910976409912,
-0.4543682634830475,
0.29050371050834656,
-0.42727765440940857,
0.15989871323108673,
0.23378503322601318,
0.20467379689216614,
-0.1776961386203766,
-0.7409924268722534,
0.011016172356903553,
0.34145697951316833,
-0.07084846496582031,
-0.9015646576881409,
0.24254563450813293,
0.7732287645339966,
0.2961229085922241,
0.28120046854019165,
-0.21280792355537415,
0.8327709436416626,
-0.39507248997688293,
0.5299015045166016,
0.24081659317016602,
-1.0219112634658813,
0.6726530194282532,
-0.5467106699943542,
0.14750699698925018,
0.5632461905479431,
0.015253257937729359,
-0.719332754611969,
-0.4763811528682709,
-0.8127854466438293,
-0.451130211353302,
0.4081850051879883,
0.24007275700569153,
-0.22022666037082672,
0.3451261818408966,
0.481778621673584,
0.34717217087745667,
0.2474205493927002,
-0.43362313508987427,
-0.10492115467786789,
-0.3608827590942383,
-0.30553677678108215,
0.07525920122861862,
0.22541306912899017,
0.18435540795326233,
-0.641878068447113,
0.6948190927505493,
-0.10746962577104568,
0.21459200978279114,
0.2078978419303894,
-0.31796517968177795,
-0.32217949628829956,
-0.016519485041499138,
0.6834076046943665,
0.5348295569419861,
-0.09174225479364395,
0.1480666697025299,
0.30883336067199707,
-0.5629000067710876,
0.3462555408477783,
0.3015662431716919,
-0.15158088505268097,
0.4236363470554352,
0.36178725957870483,
0.7562981843948364,
0.20041818916797638,
-0.13339418172836304,
0.25331825017929077,
0.019477784633636475,
-0.2231251746416092,
-0.6391096115112305,
0.01724584959447384,
0.08585841953754425,
0.03721475228667259,
0.264522522687912,
0.4677455723285675,
0.38155388832092285,
-0.5445001125335693,
0.45824360847473145,
-0.08257412910461426,
-0.39679378271102905,
-0.5643917918205261,
0.7577493190765381,
0.19950047135353088,
-0.3451370596885681,
0.11184944212436676,
-0.24386397004127502,
-0.24444784224033356,
0.9252403974533081,
0.07866944372653961,
0.925050675868988,
-0.8674508929252625,
0.115864098072052,
0.2957075834274292,
0.1087321862578392,
-0.07833028584718704,
0.03114919923245907,
-0.33921605348587036,
-0.3500087261199951,
-0.4818834662437439,
-0.44145965576171875,
-0.5296618938446045,
0.21479365229606628,
-0.49265187978744507,
0.51437908411026,
-0.5561897158622742,
0.05019950866699219,
0.4525447189807892,
-0.06046229973435402,
-0.15221212804317474,
0.1883907914161682,
0.37003999948501587,
0.9564488530158997,
-0.7454010248184204,
0.9179275035858154,
0.7325625419616699,
-0.4001868963241577,
-0.7993337512016296,
0.12186338007450104,
0.2881624102592468,
-0.852877676486969,
0.5678337216377258,
0.08350488543510437,
-0.2918245494365692,
0.18656331300735474,
-0.3167983889579773,
-0.9325835108757019,
0.954269528388977,
0.5895676612854004,
-0.8618313074111938,
0.008280081674456596,
0.2936027944087982,
0.6533613204956055,
-0.19187933206558228,
0.412039190530777,
0.8060708045959473,
0.4193064272403717,
-0.17586743831634521,
-1.3504655361175537,
-0.24621151387691498,
-0.30888301134109497,
-0.07372752577066422,
0.3035164773464203,
-0.3549985885620117,
0.6515740752220154,
-0.2983357906341553,
-0.27079904079437256,
0.3009219467639923,
0.7667568325996399,
0.10225454717874527,
0.3424322307109833,
1.0095182657241821,
0.6493717432022095,
0.988579511642456,
0.04529113695025444,
0.6332668662071228,
-0.7271036505699158,
0.2127523124217987,
1.1504709720611572,
-0.0983407199382782,
0.612999439239502,
0.35638079047203064,
-0.040634699165821075,
0.6540855765342712,
1.2308382987976074,
-0.04696223884820938,
0.32025906443595886,
0.4520336389541626,
-0.39260193705558777,
0.006525718607008457,
-0.272651344537735,
-0.4714260697364807,
0.6734367609024048,
0.29181838035583496,
-0.3194727897644043,
-0.06277531385421753,
0.03272498771548271,
0.13365498185157776,
-0.27865758538246155,
-0.3919164836406708,
0.8707924485206604,
0.05252965912222862,
-0.7121439576148987,
0.7571110129356384,
-0.06462186574935913,
0.43524402379989624,
-0.27631136775016785,
-0.1214921772480011,
-0.15350551903247833,
-0.003003595396876335,
-0.3915558159351349,
-0.6346884965896606,
0.2324313074350357,
-0.4588526487350464,
0.16538608074188232,
0.02206490747630596,
0.7114382386207581,
-0.6217953562736511,
-0.06317336857318878,
0.28923723101615906,
0.2717602849006653,
0.335819810628891,
0.01547357439994812,
-0.8578971028327942,
-0.24922706186771393,
0.162693053483963,
-0.09132716804742813,
-0.15341335535049438,
0.2763233482837677,
-0.3719860315322876,
0.6353352665901184,
0.6594827771186829,
0.3980458080768585,
0.37472039461135864,
0.1014963909983635,
0.351016640663147,
-0.5562437176704407,
-0.6556131839752197,
-0.6714000701904297,
-0.22463580965995789,
0.040314916521310806,
-0.3095749318599701,
0.3640940189361572,
0.7764715552330017,
0.9997122883796692,
-0.09825636446475983,
0.8246512413024902,
-0.11090118438005447,
0.3732103407382965,
-0.553215742111206,
0.5026645660400391,
-0.23584076762199402,
0.331795871257782,
-0.09205187857151031,
-1.0220366716384888,
-0.29696783423423767,
0.4048207402229309,
-0.20101751387119293,
-0.2689448893070221,
0.7280160188674927,
0.8116732835769653,
-0.2809313237667084,
0.5100940465927124,
-0.05018366500735283,
0.33319106698036194,
0.05394590646028519,
0.36566075682640076,
0.5413180589675903,
-0.2719455063343048,
0.6502522230148315,
-0.6393882036209106,
0.032060448080301285,
-0.20181772112846375,
-0.6008087396621704,
-0.378758043050766,
-0.7237688302993774,
-0.6562103629112244,
-0.30630406737327576,
0.33856090903282166,
1.0067510604858398,
0.661176323890686,
-1.1233224868774414,
-0.8191338181495667,
-0.801863968372345,
-0.2390201836824417,
-0.4379054307937622,
-0.18403974175453186,
0.427854984998703,
-0.18189595639705658,
-0.4931606948375702,
0.8098886609077454,
0.07580628991127014,
0.30815351009368896,
-0.025529934093356133,
-0.1366536021232605,
-0.14726866781711578,
-0.22453458607196808,
0.24458682537078857,
0.8149744868278503,
-0.8694856762886047,
-0.3251379132270813,
-0.3097567856311798,
0.05598978325724602,
0.34901145100593567,
0.8084994554519653,
-0.7889522910118103,
0.5703017115592957,
0.6065531373023987,
0.6115829944610596,
0.24964630603790283,
-0.25328102707862854,
0.7391723394393921,
-0.4327763319015503,
0.03706753998994827,
0.23995158076286316,
0.6620466113090515,
0.2714303731918335,
-0.1950596123933792,
0.7467260360717773,
0.5873449444770813,
-0.288683146238327,
-0.7273121476173401,
0.36438652873039246,
-0.8277586698532104,
0.10136622935533524,
1.097621202468872,
-0.030714523047208786,
-0.3212321996688843,
-0.43611037731170654,
-0.3971356749534607,
0.6493102312088013,
-0.39745810627937317,
0.9187341928482056,
0.2963724732398987,
-0.1778637021780014,
-0.25999826192855835,
-0.29551443457603455,
0.8393542170524597,
0.7902014851570129,
-0.8711853623390198,
-0.019658075645565987,
0.29838842153549194,
0.2880520522594452,
0.3068806231021881,
0.26046761870384216,
-0.10570705682039261,
0.648958146572113,
-0.12784509360790253,
0.27522554993629456,
-0.0580131858587265,
-0.23577511310577393,
-0.5311982035636902,
-0.31189998984336853,
0.17015674710273743,
-0.30002325773239136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01579v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01579v1 | How Paralingual are Paralinguistic Representations? A Case Study in Speech Emotion Recognition | 2024-02-02T17:17:42 | 2024-02-02T17:17:42 | Orchid Chetia Phukan, Gautam Siddharth Kashyap, Arun Balaji Buduru, Rajesh Sharma | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Pre-trained Models (PTMs) have facilitated substantial progress in the field
of Speech Emotion Recognition (SER). SER is an area with applications ranging
from HumanComputer Interaction to Healthcare. Recent studies have leveraged
various PTM representations as input features for downstream models for SER.
PTM specifically pre-trained for paralinguistic tasks have obtained
state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance for SER. However, such PTM haven't been
evaluated for SER in multilingual settings and experimented only with English.
So, we fill this gap, by performing a comprehensive comparative study of five
PTMs (TRILLsson, wav2vec2, XLS-R, x-vector, Whisper) for assessing the
effectiveness of paralingual PTM (TRILLsson) for SER across multiple languages.
Representations from TRILLsson achieved the best performance among all the
PTMs. This demonstrates that TRILLsson is able to effectively capture the
various paralinguistic features from speech data for better SER. We also show
that downstream models using TRILLsson representations achieve SOTA performance
in terms of accuracy across various multi-lingual datasets. | [
-0.2665078938007355,
0.13968335092067719,
0.5192675590515137,
0.322561651468277,
-0.25676682591438293,
0.16067130863666534,
-0.33781948685646057,
-0.3109414279460907,
0.21567745506763458,
0.30024319887161255,
-0.11121081560850143,
-0.6289687156677246,
-0.5896578431129456,
0.46614301204681396,
-0.1793871968984604,
0.729376494884491,
-0.18274050951004028,
0.4468759596347809,
-0.06853705644607544,
-0.5073292851448059,
0.11612411588430405,
-1.1681079864501953,
-0.7132899761199951,
-0.3759063482284546,
0.6523146033287048,
0.07922190427780151,
0.4946591854095459,
0.1518709361553192,
0.12511993944644928,
0.3410226106643677,
-0.09852559119462967,
-0.13498462736606598,
-0.45552676916122437,
0.0786040872335434,
0.2817029058933258,
-0.5315458178520203,
-0.11758261919021606,
0.045360613614320755,
0.7148159742355347,
0.4900987446308136,
-0.16746138036251068,
-0.05381738767027855,
0.16636084020137787,
0.5017563104629517,
-0.6346027255058289,
0.3487366735935211,
0.005852318834513426,
0.37864741683006287,
-0.3624926209449768,
-0.3715541362762451,
-0.37820005416870117,
-0.4505886137485504,
0.6245995163917542,
-0.5777686238288879,
-0.2014472782611847,
0.0260333139449358,
0.5853567123413086,
0.2225831001996994,
-0.6046856641769409,
-0.33973515033721924,
-0.8035809397697449,
0.6914536356925964,
-0.7929157614707947,
0.9217805862426758,
0.3237758278846741,
0.3146056532859802,
0.3029884397983551,
-0.6507348418235779,
-0.2738853096961975,
-0.4766491949558258,
0.04319204017519951,
0.2534850239753723,
-0.359152227640152,
0.2936438024044037,
0.09999758005142212,
0.16602391004562378,
-0.6513707637786865,
0.1856069564819336,
-0.1054484099149704,
-0.17406179010868073,
0.38783904910087585,
0.003603752702474594,
0.2604975998401642,
-0.18545666337013245,
-0.07716112583875656,
-0.22253641486167908,
-0.5899875164031982,
0.16223938763141632,
0.3584924340248108,
0.3228718042373657,
-0.32561933994293213,
0.31615230441093445,
0.08236358314752579,
0.5390032529830933,
-0.07692777365446091,
-0.1856139749288559,
0.2937377691268921,
0.13202334940433502,
-0.10033300518989563,
0.2810807228088379,
0.8891669511795044,
0.2215401530265808,
0.5491071939468384,
-0.2804199755191803,
-0.009106232784688473,
-0.2438320368528366,
0.19063639640808105,
-0.3639511466026306,
0.045322317630052567,
0.10493882745504379,
-0.619534432888031,
0.22839200496673584,
-0.06304760277271271,
-0.7573415040969849,
-0.5747581124305725,
-0.24700167775154114,
0.2561846375465393,
-0.4041372537612915,
-0.5290262699127197,
0.12312627583742142,
0.28294339776039124,
0.14874859154224396,
-0.16719645261764526,
-0.5325068831443787,
0.3031034469604492,
0.403332382440567,
0.7252130508422852,
0.02596178464591503,
-0.4884602427482605,
-0.38430294394493103,
0.022213557735085487,
-0.47134047746658325,
0.5391237735748291,
-0.6505664587020874,
-0.42349159717559814,
0.4763076603412628,
-0.1624961495399475,
-0.15091906487941742,
-0.7194092869758606,
0.5528400540351868,
-0.38548293709754944,
0.17902255058288574,
-0.5005469918251038,
-0.4090026617050171,
-0.33706167340278625,
-0.23203033208847046,
-0.8171851634979248,
0.689777672290802,
-0.011040734127163887,
-0.7158964276313782,
0.23565331101417542,
-0.39644336700439453,
-0.30320870876312256,
-0.012763850390911102,
0.015877362340688705,
-0.32183635234832764,
0.3372361660003662,
-0.05174846947193146,
0.5986328125,
-0.24079930782318115,
-0.0847363993525505,
-0.28022369742393494,
-0.44790273904800415,
0.34991946816444397,
-0.2854619324207306,
0.34104278683662415,
0.19203436374664307,
-0.2347002476453781,
-0.05939473956823349,
-0.6031871438026428,
-0.18900088965892792,
-0.13844148814678192,
-0.13405275344848633,
-0.3900720179080963,
-0.006545630749315023,
0.0853331908583641,
0.3367305099964142,
0.12385666370391846,
-0.37338536977767944,
-0.4515552222728729,
-0.2339969128370285,
0.31645646691322327,
0.16293245553970337,
-0.19105477631092072,
0.30497977137565613,
-0.11893972009420395,
0.7249367237091064,
0.13355186581611633,
-0.1480167657136917,
0.14219973981380463,
-0.0890127494931221,
-0.8765340447425842,
0.0608898289501667,
0.343973845243454,
0.359795480966568,
-0.6855621337890625,
-0.09035906195640564,
-0.01038910262286663,
-0.4283892512321472,
-0.7494752407073975,
-0.3088996410369873,
0.6454557180404663,
0.4245293438434601,
0.367296427488327,
0.18261349201202393,
-0.6817625761032104,
-0.7105364203453064,
-0.4762728214263916,
-0.47343018651008606,
-0.014632992446422577,
0.15384000539779663,
-0.1849103420972824,
-0.0798608660697937,
0.4222675859928131,
0.13785697519779205,
-0.03293709084391594,
-0.4084644019603729,
0.8020325303077698,
-0.16833432018756866,
0.08955349028110504,
0.8177863359451294,
-0.8622202277183533,
-0.7491007447242737,
0.1528135985136032,
-0.8009799718856812,
-0.34313181042671204,
0.09194493293762207,
0.30487939715385437,
0.45968782901763916,
0.22798772156238556,
-0.23910392820835114,
0.4650457203388214,
0.5783601403236389,
-0.06237408518791199,
0.49613142013549805,
-0.40417054295539856,
0.56136155128479,
-0.9365463256835938,
0.03172045201063156,
0.20410273969173431,
-0.3826918303966522,
-0.8991066813468933,
-0.5467749834060669,
0.23862679302692413,
-0.5730906128883362,
-0.8044318556785583,
0.23496265709400177,
-0.6070282459259033,
-0.310154527425766,
-0.01975170522928238,
0.017224222421646118,
-0.31932610273361206,
0.5021011233329773,
0.524889349937439,
0.8424451351165771,
0.7703445553779602,
-0.6452491283416748,
0.399181067943573,
-0.07226376235485077,
0.04389775171875954,
0.7577149868011475,
-0.5829564332962036,
0.10869112610816956,
-0.2852332293987274,
0.038999252021312714,
-0.8384695053100586,
-0.16742682456970215,
0.06215457245707512,
-0.15654276311397552,
0.36147645115852356,
-0.06888202577829361,
-0.33985525369644165,
-0.19077089428901672,
-0.13549374043941498,
0.44338878989219666,
0.7300207614898682,
-0.38804545998573303,
0.6586860418319702,
0.38912537693977356,
-0.5373618602752686,
-0.19866850972175598,
-0.6761835813522339,
0.13371874392032623,
-0.6373677849769592,
-0.2456357777118683,
0.22007592022418976,
0.3682202994823456,
-0.03643718361854553,
-0.22836753726005554,
-0.10994448512792587,
-0.15988947451114655,
-0.301351398229599,
0.1265244483947754,
-0.11863337457180023,
-0.09171271324157715,
0.07805538177490234,
-0.32967790961265564,
-0.2017822563648224,
0.07238610088825226,
-0.07975783944129944,
0.5400242209434509,
-0.2800968885421753,
-0.3159303665161133,
-0.6286919116973877,
0.640504777431488,
0.8034681677818298,
-0.4282725155353546,
0.4880569577217102,
0.6694705486297607,
-0.33735477924346924,
0.26289352774620056,
-0.6419801712036133,
0.13709233701229095,
-0.3744491636753082,
0.3054790198802948,
-0.36084556579589844,
-0.9973598718643188,
0.7288274168968201,
-0.241716668009758,
-0.37314292788505554,
0.26982972025871277,
0.325914204120636,
-0.4065912663936615,
1.1547242403030396,
0.5071676969528198,
0.030516305938363075,
0.5909942984580994,
-0.0701431855559349,
0.1660267412662506,
-0.7612487077713013,
-0.38511398434638977,
-0.6578903794288635,
-0.19460217654705048,
-0.7295072078704834,
-0.0595540814101696,
0.6648153066635132,
-0.054636262357234955,
-0.006957676261663437,
0.3173812925815582,
0.06388367712497711,
0.08596052974462509,
0.31952983140945435,
-0.01614241488277912,
-0.18324007093906403,
0.0065527744591236115,
-0.09965485334396362,
-0.32344505190849304,
-0.7604671716690063,
-0.7032288908958435,
0.8619139194488525,
0.38826996088027954,
0.6328182220458984,
-0.0690210834145546,
0.913977861404419,
0.003492404008284211,
-0.11642223596572876,
-0.4899834394454956,
0.5325444936752319,
-0.529384970664978,
0.03752663731575012,
-0.019170189276337624,
-0.48288822174072266,
-0.8614010810852051,
-0.10215485095977783,
-0.05096135288476944,
-0.6531442403793335,
0.4084370732307434,
0.0015955856069922447,
-0.7047175765037537,
0.11855404078960419,
-0.7027662396430969,
0.8906769752502441,
-0.4039692282676697,
-0.19452349841594696,
-0.30711331963539124,
-0.6523305773735046,
-0.16978035867214203,
-0.07128898799419403,
-0.09521865844726562,
0.015766536816954613,
0.020780926570296288,
1.0620160102844238,
-0.2925623059272766,
0.6156973838806152,
-0.36607494950294495,
-0.06540293246507645,
0.2101169228553772,
-0.08835763484239578,
0.227498859167099,
-0.10724370926618576,
-0.2956606447696686,
0.3647668957710266,
0.2226400524377823,
-0.2657207250595093,
-0.8022077679634094,
0.3898226022720337,
-0.7751980423927307,
-0.3500402271747589,
-0.6439342498779297,
-0.43205007910728455,
-0.6563937664031982,
-0.16523393988609314,
0.3888498842716217,
0.5955923199653625,
-0.29176169633865356,
0.20777404308319092,
0.5046470165252686,
-0.3345736563205719,
0.5776578187942505,
0.6446553468704224,
-0.025723539292812347,
-0.37495535612106323,
0.8515573740005493,
0.37778177857398987,
0.14339995384216309,
0.4273831248283386,
0.07031787931919098,
-0.791032075881958,
-0.2748458981513977,
-0.0018150343094021082,
0.4121237099170685,
-0.6633110046386719,
0.04681112989783287,
-0.5355032682418823,
-0.24880491197109222,
-0.5319075584411621,
0.0671413242816925,
-0.24030806124210358,
-0.10763799399137497,
-0.5195313692092896,
0.0048614125698804855,
0.3114156126976013,
0.8722971081733704,
-0.35353946685791016,
0.4392003118991852,
-0.8710904121398926,
0.4632530212402344,
0.6092954277992249,
0.30326345562934875,
-0.14894932508468628,
-0.27874699234962463,
-0.3892548978328705,
0.13199929893016815,
0.06439048796892166,
-1.2147749662399292,
0.43512865900993347,
0.511784553527832,
0.5818567872047424,
0.4293583929538727,
0.02664772979915142,
0.7965502738952637,
-0.39365315437316895,
0.906349241733551,
0.217342808842659,
-1.1932592391967773,
0.3426080346107483,
-0.0450199730694294,
0.20506475865840912,
0.48171868920326233,
0.9056125283241272,
-0.8306941986083984,
-0.2859096825122833,
-0.4832586646080017,
-0.5044417977333069,
0.8260143399238586,
0.1448597013950348,
-0.026153091341257095,
0.21641935408115387,
0.233486607670784,
0.19527968764305115,
0.2635069191455841,
-0.6089924573898315,
0.013942175544798374,
-0.4148309826850891,
-0.4558459520339966,
-0.30453237891197205,
-0.5845299363136292,
0.12956739962100983,
0.06628621369600296,
0.2352927327156067,
0.22648057341575623,
0.36330848932266235,
0.10105108469724655,
-0.2639482915401459,
0.14339971542358398,
0.3129790723323822,
0.5013628602027893,
0.297015517950058,
-0.23982247710227966,
0.5718310475349426,
0.25478285551071167,
-0.23987413942813873,
0.4041686952114105,
0.27042216062545776,
0.3946971297264099,
0.4537115693092346,
0.6198523044586182,
1.1427676677703857,
0.6490011215209961,
-0.5891934633255005,
0.352939248085022,
-0.12529507279396057,
0.256798654794693,
0.10250616073608398,
-0.3814629316329956,
0.0513489693403244,
0.5004488229751587,
0.2188582420349121,
-0.2335239052772522,
0.40965232253074646,
-0.514801025390625,
-0.057399846613407135,
-0.006124500650912523,
-0.4386001229286194,
-0.5653606057167053,
0.44599658250808716,
0.2629309296607971,
-0.42345696687698364,
0.1641518771648407,
-0.1730116605758667,
-0.9271902441978455,
0.27581027150154114,
0.4721809923648834,
1.1202479600906372,
-0.743587076663971,
0.3549874424934387,
0.09608306735754013,
-0.18094201385974884,
-0.11730246245861053,
0.6100165247917175,
-0.3437265455722809,
-0.2685605585575104,
-0.22673121094703674,
-0.49855130910873413,
-0.6325867772102356,
-0.21723037958145142,
-0.8716250658035278,
0.1715291142463684,
-0.057459134608507156,
-0.21555233001708984,
-0.35293763875961304,
-0.13877730071544647,
-0.6814048290252686,
0.32224538922309875,
0.6444093585014343,
0.5185238718986511,
-0.9496908187866211,
0.6701796054840088,
0.9286940693855286,
-0.342180460691452,
-0.9959248304367065,
0.2797850966453552,
-0.19187606871128082,
-0.5642451047897339,
0.7922812104225159,
0.08924856036901474,
-0.2643333971500397,
-0.007062076590955257,
0.06031832844018936,
-0.6174789667129517,
0.5939837694168091,
0.8556115031242371,
-0.6321417689323425,
-0.03401784226298332,
0.8276508450508118,
0.7967799305915833,
-0.24835026264190674,
0.37421613931655884,
0.62247633934021,
0.26941290497779846,
-0.08927774429321289,
-1.0385611057281494,
-0.4669664800167084,
-0.2271134853363037,
0.3887157738208771,
-0.172287717461586,
-0.5191593766212463,
0.7811623811721802,
0.2672705352306366,
-0.3455219268798828,
-0.21633057296276093,
0.7096288204193115,
0.5241678953170776,
0.43041980266571045,
0.4575518071651459,
0.3221967816352844,
0.7177620530128479,
-0.2933914363384247,
0.9799256920814514,
-0.44555002450942993,
0.2883593440055847,
0.8558626770973206,
-0.5564691424369812,
0.8818385601043701,
0.307035356760025,
-0.3845788836479187,
0.32616716623306274,
0.9654054045677185,
0.6334331035614014,
0.6831245422363281,
0.06664998084306717,
-0.3925861716270447,
-0.22746384143829346,
-0.40532878041267395,
-0.42453011870384216,
0.4524153470993042,
0.1143745705485344,
-0.08412584662437439,
-0.2524671256542206,
0.6581224203109741,
0.017427444458007812,
-0.0325600765645504,
-0.4244145452976227,
0.8325568437576294,
0.3662424087524414,
-0.3200698494911194,
0.9061897993087769,
-0.4150361120700836,
0.5408706665039062,
-0.7744121551513672,
0.05154457315802574,
-0.20677518844604492,
-0.3074497878551483,
-0.26897817850112915,
-0.6700378060340881,
0.2897284924983978,
0.3359888792037964,
0.17701606452465057,
-0.44295868277549744,
0.633943498134613,
-0.9032857418060303,
-0.26867127418518066,
0.5997546315193176,
0.03584224358201027,
0.48639360070228577,
-0.1851426362991333,
-0.3197065591812134,
0.3513917624950409,
-0.35820069909095764,
-0.0021023948211222887,
-0.05416519194841385,
0.7280105948448181,
0.06318271905183792,
0.5620917677879333,
0.0021959226578474045,
0.4957956075668335,
0.3768521547317505,
0.3522803485393524,
0.43335989117622375,
-0.6068700551986694,
-0.6922776103019714,
-0.6746664643287659,
0.5679518580436707,
0.17766112089157104,
-0.24843379855155945,
0.6941617131233215,
0.2892986536026001,
0.535491406917572,
-0.2790880799293518,
0.7388069033622742,
0.32435110211372375,
0.4891524612903595,
-0.6091490387916565,
0.7972885370254517,
-0.6346478462219238,
-0.35265740752220154,
-0.3666878044605255,
-0.7715413570404053,
-0.21984975039958954,
0.6496689915657043,
-0.37226614356040955,
0.10708295553922653,
0.7154166102409363,
0.29169216752052307,
-0.0250156968832016,
0.20589818060398102,
0.47243061661720276,
0.17228162288665771,
0.0035052422899752855,
0.7517842650413513,
1.1149564981460571,
-0.19542555510997772,
0.3334355354309082,
-0.24891245365142822,
-0.06596863269805908,
-0.1996057778596878,
-0.7585268020629883,
-0.7091555595397949,
-0.8350734710693359,
-0.3614542484283447,
0.028012074530124664,
0.13146822154521942,
0.8932179808616638,
0.9456294178962708,
-0.888696551322937,
-0.5466681122779846,
0.05807213857769966,
-0.2604440152645111,
-0.01353863812983036,
-0.09345836192369461,
0.2014627903699875,
-0.33982667326927185,
-0.7869634628295898,
0.3615797460079193,
0.49104660749435425,
0.2857901155948639,
-0.26181477308273315,
-0.43134167790412903,
0.07486645877361298,
-0.08979405462741852,
0.4348786175251007,
0.4382118880748749,
-0.766175389289856,
-0.06604186445474625,
-0.06768107414245605,
-0.016408143565058708,
0.04959282651543617,
0.7728524804115295,
-0.6884052157402039,
0.48088452219963074,
0.41427668929100037,
0.5968163013458252,
0.5008667707443237,
-0.34506306052207947,
0.7998360991477966,
-0.6491252779960632,
0.41192924976348877,
0.4950462877750397,
0.5587197542190552,
0.5463480353355408,
-0.13212209939956665,
0.23909789323806763,
-0.11580511927604675,
-0.40676555037498474,
-0.8235962986946106,
0.10209992527961731,
-0.9135533571243286,
0.29499727487564087,
1.07267427444458,
-0.4948987662792206,
-0.045232243835926056,
0.08319760859012604,
-0.3190883994102478,
0.7087119221687317,
-0.23480968177318573,
0.5743775367736816,
0.8751256465911865,
-0.252898246049881,
-0.5870717167854309,
-0.16844211518764496,
0.7166863083839417,
0.6879900693893433,
-0.8067781925201416,
0.09284921735525131,
0.07198671251535416,
-0.010844812728464603,
0.15669476985931396,
0.3576226532459259,
-0.2055250108242035,
0.23250795900821686,
-0.35106390714645386,
0.1348334699869156,
0.19572001695632935,
-0.36356449127197266,
-0.8282082080841064,
0.22593149542808533,
0.05012151598930359,
-0.18977758288383484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01577v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01577v1 | Deep Active Learning for Data Mining from Conflict Text Corpora | 2024-02-02T17:16:23 | 2024-02-02T17:16:23 | Mihai Croicu | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, stat.ML | High-resolution event data on armed conflict and related processes have
revolutionized the study of political contention with datasets like UCDP GED,
ACLED etc. However, most of these datasets limit themselves to collecting
spatio-temporal (high-resolution) and intensity data. Information on dynamics,
such as targets, tactics, purposes etc. are rarely collected owing to the
extreme workload of collecting data. However, most datasets rely on a rich
corpus of textual data allowing further mining of further information connected
to each event. This paper proposes one such approach that is inexpensive and
high performance, leveraging active learning - an iterative process of
improving a machine learning model based on sequential (guided) human input.
Active learning is employed to then step-wise train (fine-tuning) of a large,
encoder-only language model adapted for extracting sub-classes of events
relating to conflict dynamics. The approach shows performance similar to human
(gold-standard) coding while reducing the amount of required human annotation
by as much as 99%. | [
-0.04801541566848755,
-0.9504512548446655,
0.3797720968723297,
-0.014007693156599998,
-0.24917030334472656,
0.3325679302215576,
-0.44402241706848145,
-0.356833279132843,
-0.10735653340816498,
0.569706916809082,
-0.44216999411582947,
-0.7079926133155823,
-0.7065340876579285,
-0.06085972115397453,
-0.45448848605155945,
0.8828257918357849,
-0.4765157699584961,
-0.16534100472927094,
0.486674427986145,
-0.3091720938682556,
-0.18936870992183685,
-0.6892317533493042,
-0.7033722400665283,
-0.3504137396812439,
0.5072820782661438,
0.5522584319114685,
0.7021843791007996,
0.6403519511222839,
0.46727585792541504,
0.30887389183044434,
-0.2537730932235718,
0.35659050941467285,
-0.5840447545051575,
0.5700773000717163,
-0.06543639302253723,
-0.21815979480743408,
0.039248544722795486,
0.23991580307483673,
0.515518307685852,
0.4699226915836334,
-0.11988469958305359,
-0.187001571059227,
-0.02755480445921421,
0.5564404726028442,
-0.6280157566070557,
0.19457826018333435,
-0.6933645606040955,
0.3154701888561249,
-0.3140984773635864,
0.038010936230421066,
-0.1280357986688614,
-0.059223439544439316,
0.130684494972229,
-0.661162257194519,
0.439500093460083,
-0.2354246824979782,
1.0941226482391357,
0.36749622225761414,
-0.40195778012275696,
-0.5519829988479614,
-0.7164323925971985,
0.46068671345710754,
-0.3604024052619934,
0.032860174775123596,
0.5156420469284058,
-0.19584503769874573,
-0.15572839975357056,
-0.8013992309570312,
-0.42174333333969116,
0.19518885016441345,
0.04960884526371956,
0.23742172122001648,
-0.22384199500083923,
0.04800265654921532,
0.10323040187358856,
0.19284678995609283,
-0.42434173822402954,
0.23674733936786652,
-0.31509920954704285,
0.061129819601774216,
0.6890378594398499,
0.06491108983755112,
-0.02632947266101837,
-0.19188715517520905,
-0.2852935791015625,
-0.033368539065122604,
-0.591067373752594,
0.0026135705411434174,
0.5218102931976318,
0.5497224926948547,
-0.12058330327272415,
0.5308753848075867,
-0.14782437682151794,
0.4496004283428192,
0.35831505060195923,
0.3547062277793884,
-0.08595628291368484,
-0.25930148363113403,
-0.2574678361415863,
0.31154656410217285,
1.0974076986312866,
-0.0927952453494072,
0.03262383118271828,
-0.06654506921768188,
-0.11749472469091415,
0.31115081906318665,
0.4116198718547821,
-1.0153831243515015,
-0.31405553221702576,
0.1508699655532837,
-0.46379759907722473,
-0.5333957076072693,
-0.03657810389995575,
-0.9468924403190613,
-0.6369779706001282,
-0.35573479533195496,
0.31875884532928467,
-0.33391979336738586,
-0.26830384135246277,
-0.03700454533100128,
0.26259666681289673,
-0.2532099485397339,
0.2955404818058014,
-0.48227664828300476,
0.08680330216884613,
0.5005056262016296,
0.9746322631835938,
-0.47102946043014526,
0.026557810604572296,
-0.8132569789886475,
-0.0948910266160965,
-0.48991864919662476,
0.6735230684280396,
-0.8054721355438232,
-0.2785532772541046,
0.309840589761734,
0.03832046687602997,
0.012808560393750668,
-0.6918429732322693,
0.9737173318862915,
-0.7600564956665039,
-0.05346199497580528,
0.04911196604371071,
-0.4953387677669525,
-0.053259119391441345,
0.10877776145935059,
-0.9271942973136902,
1.2266935110092163,
-0.2363104671239853,
-0.41598886251449585,
0.5660504698753357,
-0.6808045506477356,
-0.7785032987594604,
0.13180051743984222,
-0.3463869094848633,
-0.7535020709037781,
-0.13538461923599243,
0.02691136673092842,
0.7027953267097473,
-0.004035490565001965,
0.5908474326133728,
-0.17303495109081268,
-0.17257526516914368,
0.027922648936510086,
-0.20539255440235138,
0.41849446296691895,
0.4586889147758484,
-0.5535138249397278,
0.39812353253364563,
-0.9206869006156921,
-0.41720694303512573,
-0.01749810203909874,
-0.6718073487281799,
-0.19451801478862762,
0.3421017527580261,
-0.11987705528736115,
0.20682482421398163,
0.18226002156734467,
-0.35895779728889465,
0.42289361357688904,
-0.06017549708485603,
-0.09124618023633957,
0.6069790124893188,
0.24640029668807983,
0.6400654911994934,
0.068715400993824,
0.21923282742500305,
0.3293115496635437,
-0.1650724560022354,
-0.00521441176533699,
-0.43490004539489746,
-0.7121632695198059,
-0.2731912136077881,
0.5482733845710754,
0.6268789768218994,
-0.6505592465400696,
0.6049988269805908,
0.29394295811653137,
-0.4135401248931885,
-0.6958073973655701,
0.28009307384490967,
0.013477763161063194,
0.08995942026376724,
0.21535764634609222,
-0.23643505573272705,
-0.9398949146270752,
-0.31831589341163635,
-0.18626902997493744,
-0.3085276186466217,
0.1520950198173523,
0.08501460403203964,
0.21302619576454163,
-0.37022459506988525,
0.7051897048950195,
-0.310608446598053,
-0.5094420313835144,
-0.21907177567481995,
0.9422748684883118,
0.05757869407534599,
0.18889755010604858,
0.12374861538410187,
-1.029266119003296,
-0.47803500294685364,
0.1514841616153717,
-0.8188641667366028,
-0.3270646333694458,
-0.48030510544776917,
-0.1430017352104187,
0.2214670330286026,
0.7012419104576111,
-0.1762383133172989,
0.6404514908790588,
0.6424133777618408,
-0.6413474678993225,
-0.044250380247831345,
0.042311713099479675,
0.3274828791618347,
-0.7596587538719177,
0.1507808119058609,
0.18757420778274536,
-0.08825531601905823,
-0.6856676340103149,
-0.028202351182699203,
0.030766109004616737,
-0.4074190855026245,
-0.2978372871875763,
0.24993659555912018,
-0.49216559529304504,
0.34473472833633423,
-0.5490968227386475,
0.04760301485657692,
-0.3956223130226135,
0.3409149944782257,
0.3939431309700012,
0.4022352993488312,
0.3931163251399994,
-0.6575481295585632,
0.42090022563934326,
0.1757163405418396,
-0.35904887318611145,
-0.099772147834301,
-0.23880238831043243,
-0.1437658667564392,
-0.02584083378314972,
-0.1046200841665268,
-0.6674658060073853,
-0.08571884036064148,
0.11207848787307739,
-0.15335166454315186,
0.2522355914115906,
-0.42280617356300354,
-0.39402222633361816,
0.2389497607946396,
-0.0036804666742682457,
0.24208614230155945,
0.3421500027179718,
-0.3993473947048187,
0.497599720954895,
0.6348182559013367,
-0.047203656286001205,
-0.4795679450035095,
-0.3231048583984375,
0.31290191411972046,
-0.04768035188317299,
-0.11711294203996658,
0.3373236060142517,
0.06292328983545303,
-0.29223155975341797,
0.3294001817703247,
-0.048541828989982605,
-0.2621573209762573,
0.12442906945943832,
0.5970163941383362,
-0.07405117899179459,
-0.09316838532686234,
0.17177873849868774,
-0.2887877821922302,
-0.05219869315624237,
-0.08264798671007156,
0.24457238614559174,
0.3855263888835907,
0.1661754548549652,
-0.24023504555225372,
-0.4650780260562897,
0.7169005274772644,
0.6070600152015686,
-0.32321202754974365,
0.8062653541564941,
0.6312307119369507,
-0.5841920375823975,
-0.07950704544782639,
-0.14885574579238892,
-0.0023323018103837967,
-0.3775700330734253,
0.3171761929988861,
-0.026057003065943718,
-0.7243677973747253,
0.5609592199325562,
-0.7520139813423157,
0.20296092331409454,
0.6413187384605408,
0.7775078415870667,
0.1939883530139923,
1.0161616802215576,
0.5782495141029358,
-0.2362413853406906,
0.8823022842407227,
-0.23875105381011963,
0.15385806560516357,
-0.2648392915725708,
-0.3212558329105377,
-0.4874229431152344,
-0.565085768699646,
-0.2970742881298065,
-0.3857353627681732,
0.006448411848396063,
0.11365794390439987,
-0.28957051038742065,
0.125240758061409,
-0.35228151082992554,
0.25609099864959717,
0.3141956031322479,
-0.009245278313755989,
0.08593231439590454,
-0.0023424383252859116,
0.10153176635503769,
-0.07929164916276932,
-0.8292770981788635,
-0.45672571659088135,
0.6700723171234131,
0.2279583364725113,
0.9267178177833557,
0.06625265628099442,
0.6591761708259583,
0.34115153551101685,
0.1730617731809616,
-0.8578612208366394,
0.44009923934936523,
-0.21793098747730255,
-0.5445048213005066,
-0.25552812218666077,
-0.639009952545166,
-1.5402153730392456,
0.015694525092840195,
-0.6851867437362671,
-0.09737946838140488,
0.5297383069992065,
-0.2975572347640991,
-0.46190959215164185,
0.47431671619415283,
-0.4581299126148224,
0.8976706862449646,
-0.4356175363063812,
-0.4511377513408661,
-0.24952860176563263,
-0.33622217178344727,
0.011463101953268051,
-0.16376829147338867,
0.13239356875419617,
-0.08453213423490524,
-0.22802507877349854,
1.1030439138412476,
-0.0647258386015892,
1.12033212184906,
-0.08547534793615341,
-0.06239437311887741,
0.3926408588886261,
-0.026999246329069138,
0.5834457874298096,
0.10922351479530334,
-0.31765541434288025,
-0.034381456673145294,
-0.551235556602478,
-0.27669233083724976,
-0.19903352856636047,
0.7870787978172302,
-0.8995224237442017,
-0.1963931769132614,
-0.6683362126350403,
-0.240110844373703,
0.163569375872612,
0.060295019298791885,
0.23862673342227936,
0.37791895866394043,
-0.5041271448135376,
0.2884407341480255,
0.9588186740875244,
0.06163518875837326,
0.6114373207092285,
0.5911576151847839,
0.1878318339586258,
-0.17854879796504974,
0.6628119945526123,
0.3898252546787262,
-0.3087865114212036,
0.10459085553884506,
-0.005474574863910675,
0.09179988503456116,
-0.6334275603294373,
-0.6005683541297913,
-0.16781874001026154,
-0.44003891944885254,
-0.8356695175170898,
-0.5926943421363831,
-0.175665020942688,
-0.0581461563706398,
-0.21863412857055664,
-0.5251994132995605,
-0.12463486939668655,
-0.8371853828430176,
-0.080655537545681,
0.4485754072666168,
0.8011608123779297,
0.03909885883331299,
0.23692099750041962,
-0.7337560653686523,
0.7294427752494812,
0.10889968276023865,
0.5780519843101501,
-0.3249910771846771,
-0.3559955954551697,
-0.5293251872062683,
-0.15851067006587982,
-0.5111989974975586,
-1.257195234298706,
0.5501829385757446,
0.4450707733631134,
0.41016823053359985,
0.4906062185764313,
0.5594188570976257,
0.6975993514060974,
-0.41789016127586365,
0.836876392364502,
-0.13687890768051147,
-0.6512296199798584,
0.8414117097854614,
-0.135769784450531,
0.23781585693359375,
0.6559445858001709,
0.6218156814575195,
-0.24755032360553741,
-0.25399306416511536,
-0.8806582689285278,
-1.152703046798706,
0.6916650533676147,
0.10399338603019714,
-0.3475317358970642,
-0.023585300892591476,
0.5241640210151672,
0.03400009498000145,
-0.01052936352789402,
-0.40994518995285034,
-0.14336858689785004,
0.10376348346471786,
-0.4916035830974579,
0.17818163335323334,
-0.08863148838281631,
-0.36729758977890015,
-0.12478256970643997,
0.8991120457649231,
-0.1357082724571228,
0.020742084830999374,
0.22685487568378448,
-0.180495023727417,
-0.6343811750411987,
0.15384581685066223,
0.2303871363401413,
0.23990263044834137,
0.03269136697053909,
0.28205162286758423,
0.21752341091632843,
-0.549662172794342,
0.12951502203941345,
0.30915430188179016,
0.005727705545723438,
0.2741740047931671,
0.4440823495388031,
0.8462218046188354,
0.3817906379699707,
-0.8441236019134521,
0.6541523933410645,
-0.3064139783382416,
-0.4521879255771637,
-0.13186469674110413,
-0.006703807506710291,
-0.39565980434417725,
0.5583627223968506,
0.691098153591156,
0.11660903692245483,
0.15370267629623413,
-0.9358955025672913,
0.4786311686038971,
0.15343788266181946,
-0.5014501810073853,
-0.15329325199127197,
0.2642544209957123,
0.539305567741394,
-0.24913834035396576,
0.4761599600315094,
-0.2577715516090393,
-0.7278095483779907,
0.3438361585140228,
0.17522810399532318,
0.6631091833114624,
-0.197304368019104,
0.05876631289720535,
0.3533497750759125,
0.1400940716266632,
-0.1324719488620758,
0.25932613015174866,
0.1750383973121643,
-0.4522019028663635,
-0.7511463761329651,
-0.4528011083602905,
-0.5421047210693359,
0.5176575779914856,
-0.5925171375274658,
0.4465315341949463,
-0.4066696763038635,
-0.11869026720523834,
-0.21060805022716522,
0.7518347501754761,
-0.4553768038749695,
0.03923457860946655,
0.3544587790966034,
0.5866733193397522,
-0.8220160007476807,
0.7225402593612671,
0.7436173558235168,
0.02581542171537876,
-0.21699126064777374,
-0.06370925903320312,
-0.11377237737178802,
-0.20143431425094604,
0.39061620831489563,
-0.0013952439185231924,
0.2826944887638092,
-0.37583211064338684,
-0.5658251047134399,
-0.43885380029678345,
0.5772204995155334,
0.3819972574710846,
-0.5629366636276245,
0.13010255992412567,
-0.30691927671432495,
0.4810793697834015,
-0.19203154742717743,
-0.2931728959083557,
0.4803520739078522,
0.5254075527191162,
-0.1346721351146698,
-0.43577152490615845,
-0.061779893934726715,
-0.4027892053127289,
-0.7029883861541748,
0.6804314255714417,
-0.5333976149559021,
0.5287339091300964,
0.0802125409245491,
-0.6016286611557007,
-0.25790920853614807,
1.0714143514633179,
-0.18819238245487213,
0.4876559376716614,
0.5400723814964294,
0.49927520751953125,
0.882334291934967,
-0.2871305048465729,
0.5178189873695374,
-0.1747031807899475,
0.1715470552444458,
0.6248734593391418,
-0.3677268326282501,
0.9179283976554871,
0.07621400058269501,
0.2601202726364136,
0.4274718463420868,
0.7418240308761597,
-0.1355309784412384,
0.5798549056053162,
-0.006716069765388966,
-0.6054484248161316,
-0.5024783611297607,
0.06073206290602684,
0.05174729600548744,
0.5206547379493713,
0.5272729992866516,
-0.3835844099521637,
-0.2061302214860916,
0.009997020475566387,
0.025631612166762352,
0.4146631956100464,
-0.37225329875946045,
1.2126293182373047,
-0.26357319951057434,
-0.6281886696815491,
0.3715350329875946,
0.19954200088977814,
0.7311964631080627,
-0.6950541138648987,
-0.3078446388244629,
0.18304893374443054,
0.23423203825950623,
-0.2557196617126465,
-0.9400808811187744,
0.28217393159866333,
0.38611605763435364,
-0.22535574436187744,
-0.3478175401687622,
0.7767110466957092,
-0.8533112406730652,
-0.352617472410202,
0.36000993847846985,
0.3906349837779999,
-0.05497639998793602,
-0.11648266762495041,
-0.6959586143493652,
0.4393630027770996,
-0.1398918777704239,
-0.42181339859962463,
0.392354816198349,
0.9463798403739929,
-0.0837874710559845,
0.16966335475444794,
0.647703230381012,
0.25340721011161804,
-0.09889062494039536,
0.036114826798439026,
1.0629475116729736,
-0.6277637481689453,
-0.17213326692581177,
-0.7463431358337402,
0.26547855138778687,
-0.379058837890625,
-0.23897211253643036,
0.22873741388320923,
0.8364788293838501,
0.4730854630470276,
0.4497525990009308,
0.8813340067863464,
-0.08413322269916534,
0.4049224853515625,
-0.47888368368148804,
0.6747308373451233,
-0.2369055300951004,
-0.0006846433389000595,
0.047798752784729004,
-0.16488134860992432,
-0.4593745768070221,
0.8792285919189453,
0.04430624470114708,
-0.40875884890556335,
0.4187106192111969,
0.4333394169807434,
-0.13138973712921143,
0.009237376041710377,
0.17084814608097076,
0.19666382670402527,
0.24031327664852142,
0.4496018588542938,
0.6699275374412537,
-0.4778524339199066,
0.7940166592597961,
-0.11100947856903076,
-0.38861995935440063,
-0.4028824269771576,
-0.8839101195335388,
-0.9272662401199341,
-0.8891636729240417,
-0.5322167277336121,
-0.23082895576953888,
0.27016422152519226,
0.8905327320098877,
0.6818831562995911,
-0.7424109578132629,
-0.13477325439453125,
0.16590005159378052,
0.055340733379125595,
-0.29458990693092346,
-0.14009343087673187,
0.5283807516098022,
-0.5013726353645325,
-0.7449477910995483,
0.5538508296012878,
-0.19544371962547302,
-0.03339092805981636,
0.17152494192123413,
-0.05839597061276436,
-0.6379843950271606,
0.051173679530620575,
0.7262505292892456,
0.4032723903656006,
-0.27826783061027527,
-0.15386641025543213,
-0.27415814995765686,
-0.13989019393920898,
-0.011436903849244118,
1.1090822219848633,
-0.974571943283081,
0.24681182205677032,
0.37069424986839294,
0.9486280083656311,
0.7557989954948425,
-0.07906387746334076,
0.4879719614982605,
-1.0543665885925293,
0.28092679381370544,
0.4552801251411438,
0.20266170799732208,
0.31478145718574524,
-0.465298056602478,
0.6696590781211853,
0.13937021791934967,
-0.6383315324783325,
-0.8102546334266663,
0.10406216233968735,
-1.0279715061187744,
-0.3992912173271179,
1.3236396312713623,
-0.059869613498449326,
-0.03189755231142044,
-0.4050176441669464,
-0.6435908675193787,
0.8858607411384583,
-0.7057144045829773,
0.805051863193512,
0.6916639804840088,
-0.25492584705352783,
-0.07623354345560074,
-0.46007299423217773,
0.7430540919303894,
0.14533422887325287,
-0.7437772154808044,
0.5725609064102173,
0.4316374659538269,
-0.4382854104042053,
0.09300386905670166,
0.02320718951523304,
0.10550712049007416,
0.14433695375919342,
-0.22623422741889954,
-0.004579020664095879,
0.11801434308290482,
-0.38015851378440857,
-0.4656808078289032,
0.719455361366272,
-0.22675152122974396,
0.004591222852468491
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01825v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01825v2 | Fractal Patterns May Illuminate the Success of Next-Token Prediction | 2024-02-02T17:09:33 | 2024-05-22T16:19:13 | Ibrahim Alabdulmohsin, Vinh Q. Tran, Mostafa Dehghani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We study the fractal structure of language, aiming to provide a precise
formalism for quantifying properties that may have been previously suspected
but not formally shown. We establish that language is: (1) self-similar,
exhibiting complexities at all levels of granularity, with no particular
characteristic context length, and (2) long-range dependent (LRD), with a Hurst
parameter of approximately H=0.7. Based on these findings, we argue that
short-term patterns/dependencies in language, such as in paragraphs, mirror the
patterns/dependencies over larger scopes, like entire documents. This may shed
some light on how next-token prediction can capture the structure of text
across multiple levels of granularity, from words and clauses to broader
contexts and intents. In addition, we carry out an extensive analysis across
different domains and architectures, showing that fractal parameters are
robust. Finally, we demonstrate that the tiny variations in fractal parameters
seen across LLMs improve upon perplexity-based bits-per-byte (BPB) in
predicting their downstream performance. We hope these findings offer a fresh
perspective on language and the mechanisms underlying the success of LLMs. | [
-0.3419567942619324,
-1.1241931915283203,
0.6672349572181702,
0.3667243421077728,
-0.35467877984046936,
-0.2151583582162857,
-0.00019830958626698703,
-0.5965871214866638,
0.4985384941101074,
0.2501268982887268,
-0.41150522232055664,
-0.538275420665741,
-0.768591582775116,
0.22549298405647278,
-0.6544559597969055,
0.7513440847396851,
0.21337613463401794,
-0.159571573138237,
-0.18621550500392914,
0.04140155017375946,
-0.2995241582393646,
-0.7112603187561035,
-0.573703944683075,
-0.26060858368873596,
0.54997718334198,
0.17519411444664001,
0.9652301669120789,
1.1843221187591553,
0.36914077401161194,
0.2495444118976593,
-0.41051799058914185,
-0.38662949204444885,
-0.3636586368083954,
0.16982044279575348,
0.39371371269226074,
-0.6911202073097229,
-0.20241987705230713,
0.07587354630231857,
0.8318403363227844,
0.9607683420181274,
-0.16164322197437286,
-0.17296087741851807,
0.3807978928089142,
0.6384944915771484,
-0.04898330196738243,
0.4628274738788605,
-0.6299780011177063,
0.40227749943733215,
-0.8099978566169739,
-0.315682053565979,
-0.1833237111568451,
-0.08159182965755463,
-0.004047108814120293,
-0.16870832443237305,
0.11693058907985687,
0.45680534839630127,
0.6176900863647461,
0.15725064277648926,
-0.14867493510246277,
-0.6964073181152344,
-0.2879757285118103,
0.8226543068885803,
-0.6681357622146606,
0.6066619157791138,
0.5370289087295532,
0.03287741169333458,
-0.5021316409111023,
-0.8919501900672913,
-0.44010117650032043,
-0.35321345925331116,
-0.21542520821094513,
-0.27374157309532166,
-0.10812704265117645,
-0.19128663837909698,
0.1419627070426941,
0.3862166106700897,
-0.341884046792984,
0.2069566696882248,
-0.17880426347255707,
-0.5038314461708069,
0.22771087288856506,
0.5581713318824768,
0.011587010696530342,
-0.14535582065582275,
-0.4633818566799164,
0.4057253897190094,
-0.6527936458587646,
0.337623655796051,
0.18397153913974762,
0.48363345861434937,
-0.3159986138343811,
0.27749553322792053,
-0.04263802617788315,
0.6963024735450745,
0.021647045388817787,
-0.3864527940750122,
0.02915635146200657,
-0.2826703190803528,
-0.04174555465579033,
-0.022440815344452858,
0.6087641716003418,
-0.09965507686138153,
0.059537459164857864,
-0.10052080452442169,
-0.4081762135028839,
-0.5524888038635254,
-0.16503708064556122,
-0.9056051969528198,
-0.39580240845680237,
0.20245401561260223,
-0.7902905941009521,
-0.5643417835235596,
0.03534350171685219,
-0.6452792882919312,
-0.5042960047721863,
-0.20438715815544128,
0.2312578409910202,
-0.4700135588645935,
0.021055618301033974,
0.016757965087890625,
0.09656326472759247,
0.19288292527198792,
0.3947232961654663,
-1.0215831995010376,
0.4789634346961975,
1.1165517568588257,
1.492013931274414,
-0.2046186923980713,
-0.7398905158042908,
-0.662293553352356,
0.011855934746563435,
-0.34028640389442444,
1.0033413171768188,
-0.6880031824111938,
-0.5045680999755859,
0.09472104907035828,
-0.4045391380786896,
0.33322715759277344,
-0.3019190728664398,
0.316537469625473,
-0.5191755294799805,
0.2206203192472458,
-0.534473717212677,
-0.7202930450439453,
0.007728824857622385,
0.14360153675079346,
-1.0245132446289062,
0.5897324085235596,
-0.13923220336437225,
-0.952074408531189,
0.5974376797676086,
-0.5003113150596619,
-0.6689677834510803,
0.11091741174459457,
-0.6402039527893066,
-0.4421602487564087,
0.3055221438407898,
-0.256707102060318,
0.654222846031189,
-0.2633307874202728,
-0.24077419936656952,
-0.5493583083152771,
-0.538662850856781,
0.4525202810764313,
-0.6104799509048462,
0.7180941700935364,
0.13681478798389435,
-0.3385078012943268,
-0.13037781417369843,
-0.6040167212486267,
-0.20084400475025177,
-0.12528158724308014,
-0.576769232749939,
0.04887150600552559,
0.1859908401966095,
0.0016892164712771773,
0.206233412027359,
0.5599557757377625,
-0.23179492354393005,
0.042522720992565155,
-0.1603013426065445,
0.5181530714035034,
1.210361123085022,
-0.14368674159049988,
0.29594072699546814,
-0.3228527903556824,
0.5058164596557617,
0.1811688095331192,
0.385513037443161,
-0.3228304386138916,
-0.7439810037612915,
-0.3553004264831543,
-0.4381368160247803,
0.1505480706691742,
0.05633162707090378,
0.22647137939929962,
0.3918422758579254,
-0.14878490567207336,
-0.27145668864250183,
0.16066564619541168,
0.28789252042770386,
0.24206706881523132,
0.2891448140144348,
-0.01908649504184723,
-0.5400245189666748,
-0.6622220277786255,
-0.654151976108551,
-0.31654655933380127,
-0.3347231149673462,
0.3973431885242462,
0.2987435758113861,
0.3001419007778168,
-0.16061705350875854,
0.8989724516868591,
-0.4013024866580963,
-0.4632261097431183,
-0.06984392553567886,
0.22121533751487732,
0.4365541636943817,
0.02233535423874855,
0.39466193318367004,
-0.7409440875053406,
-0.4124903678894043,
0.1519472897052765,
-0.4862160384654999,
0.08323854207992554,
0.11796115338802338,
0.2681761384010315,
0.4913289248943329,
0.9174379706382751,
-0.28945350646972656,
0.19726619124412537,
0.7309074401855469,
-0.6201785206794739,
0.5376457571983337,
0.04426451027393341,
-0.26614224910736084,
-0.9947435259819031,
-0.12880253791809082,
-0.286056250333786,
-0.18143393099308014,
-0.47216784954071045,
-0.40329623222351074,
-0.2915158271789551,
0.20840179920196533,
-0.1837451159954071,
0.5054768919944763,
-0.38306519389152527,
-0.37992313504219055,
-0.11840274184942245,
-0.3127838671207428,
-0.43189099431037903,
0.2550215423107147,
-0.07874291390180588,
1.01256263256073,
0.5933265686035156,
-0.3500591516494751,
-0.06934033334255219,
-0.1562216728925705,
-0.5793647766113281,
0.10922648012638092,
-0.5830784440040588,
-0.04065680503845215,
0.1069905012845993,
0.12899887561798096,
-0.9894744157791138,
-0.2854885458946228,
-0.20956280827522278,
-0.36444756388664246,
0.11574844270944595,
-0.15170812606811523,
-0.6460574269294739,
0.06124785542488098,
-0.36423152685165405,
0.408464252948761,
0.6311933994293213,
-0.273103266954422,
0.6081563830375671,
0.23475401103496552,
-0.3365008533000946,
-0.6735467910766602,
-0.613929271697998,
0.11678791791200638,
-0.18511652946472168,
-0.44275394082069397,
-0.09882402420043945,
-0.16260623931884766,
-0.4007190465927124,
-0.19221901893615723,
0.002609403571113944,
-0.02155766263604164,
0.4420412480831146,
0.6101438999176025,
-0.09401722252368927,
-0.3680596649646759,
-0.05153597891330719,
-0.1670706570148468,
-0.10686750710010529,
0.2561452388763428,
-0.5910937190055847,
1.0243206024169922,
-0.5215758085250854,
-0.29965007305145264,
-0.43872424960136414,
0.2512688934803009,
0.7000701427459717,
0.16049766540527344,
0.6273037195205688,
0.5039979815483093,
-0.16915971040725708,
-0.11675678193569183,
-0.47629714012145996,
-0.07510077208280563,
-0.5212568044662476,
0.4920438528060913,
-0.6507442593574524,
-1.1593801975250244,
0.8221739530563354,
0.051795594394207,
-0.15839052200317383,
0.402252733707428,
0.7863969206809998,
-0.4194469451904297,
0.5707523226737976,
0.9737173914909363,
-0.2570100426673889,
0.8081880807876587,
-0.0771147683262825,
0.07636949419975281,
-0.3360482156276703,
-0.38587167859077454,
-0.3918883502483368,
-0.14365138113498688,
-0.5594090819358826,
-0.4382947087287903,
0.27713242173194885,
0.45253556966781616,
-0.07161537557840347,
-0.012083880603313446,
0.11537624150514603,
0.6548035144805908,
0.4328398108482361,
-0.34764349460601807,
0.29466089606285095,
0.3292984068393707,
-0.12342004477977753,
-0.053990233689546585,
-0.4944942593574524,
-0.5061318278312683,
1.0007250308990479,
0.4433814585208893,
0.5327941179275513,
0.03839408978819847,
0.9903271794319153,
0.63738614320755,
0.3620636463165283,
-0.6472305059432983,
0.4187646806240082,
-0.23569774627685547,
-0.19635455310344696,
-0.6518837213516235,
-0.21689720451831818,
-1.0103144645690918,
0.11261768639087677,
-0.003053203923627734,
-0.6495504379272461,
0.11482210457324982,
0.16112248599529266,
-0.1178460344672203,
0.2456437647342682,
-0.30409136414527893,
0.5162745118141174,
-0.04274969920516014,
0.0190252847969532,
-0.09845204651355743,
-0.5269692540168762,
0.049562230706214905,
-0.314639687538147,
0.375456839799881,
0.0028110311832278967,
-0.5678950548171997,
0.621823251247406,
-0.5210413336753845,
1.0559903383255005,
0.35503968596458435,
-0.44736453890800476,
0.22393228113651276,
0.37370145320892334,
0.5384880304336548,
0.15747594833374023,
-0.31411221623420715,
0.6378298401832581,
-0.20759406685829163,
-0.6458832621574402,
-0.5112215876579285,
0.7478064894676208,
-0.6661522388458252,
-0.7056027054786682,
-0.2416435182094574,
-0.4771404266357422,
0.02010919339954853,
0.5638121366500854,
0.4256535470485687,
0.6480869650840759,
-0.1722300797700882,
0.08961932361125946,
0.627714991569519,
0.5489485859870911,
0.904705286026001,
0.20029553771018982,
-0.25830885767936707,
-0.3679092228412628,
0.7937350869178772,
0.11924481391906738,
0.21484576165676117,
0.5628886222839355,
0.33677032589912415,
-0.38246574997901917,
-0.999925971031189,
-0.1182732805609703,
0.08399225026369095,
-0.7277801632881165,
-0.060970041900873184,
-0.6344068646430969,
0.05183052644133568,
-0.29977670311927795,
-0.32819855213165283,
-0.06167614832520485,
-0.4147457778453827,
-0.3207454979419708,
0.013937163166701794,
0.3319343030452728,
1.2129989862442017,
-0.10515840351581573,
-0.013456443324685097,
-0.6378700733184814,
-0.3325679898262024,
0.40183764696121216,
0.6080604791641235,
0.17490264773368835,
-0.6966407895088196,
-0.443934828042984,
-0.41649141907691956,
-0.01097935438156128,
-0.4887944161891937,
0.03435260429978371,
0.25746530294418335,
0.3160631060600281,
0.6542444229125977,
-0.6491695642471313,
0.6919524669647217,
-0.6842567324638367,
0.9539682269096375,
0.34594571590423584,
-1.0277339220046997,
0.46128833293914795,
-0.3101103901863098,
0.04327266290783882,
0.28516483306884766,
0.19277554750442505,
-0.4940231442451477,
-0.44303151965141296,
-0.6640244722366333,
-0.5107442736625671,
0.4495495557785034,
0.2410149872303009,
0.2862603962421417,
-0.19435900449752808,
0.43727898597717285,
0.4787456691265106,
0.19926132261753082,
-0.6823761463165283,
-0.3273444175720215,
-0.2460671067237854,
-0.017428893595933914,
0.0022318752016872168,
-0.5708454251289368,
-0.08221892267465591,
0.16099265217781067,
0.016206055879592896,
-0.0870647057890892,
0.28417542576789856,
-0.1173960492014885,
0.23141050338745117,
0.0032798948232084513,
0.009805836714804173,
0.9298048615455627,
0.6384657621383667,
-0.06320705264806747,
0.2069581300020218,
0.19130785763263702,
-0.7542127370834351,
-0.17582082748413086,
-0.14451716840267181,
0.0856417864561081,
0.14044687151908875,
1.092117428779602,
0.2344711571931839,
-0.046820856630802155,
-0.4305438697338104,
0.6146202683448792,
0.02077816240489483,
0.02346455678343773,
-0.4552619159221649,
-0.03336954116821289,
0.021061452105641365,
0.3537547290325165,
0.3209015429019928,
0.05516462400555611,
0.2441013902425766,
-0.7693756818771362,
0.4357512295246124,
0.40954962372779846,
-0.5271502733230591,
-0.5704031586647034,
0.35303181409835815,
0.1043224036693573,
-0.6198588609695435,
0.29613959789276123,
-0.0926288589835167,
-0.3067682981491089,
0.6131961941719055,
0.7049835324287415,
0.8012269735336304,
0.03499583899974823,
-0.1755707859992981,
-0.1888488233089447,
0.05360046401619911,
-0.14564061164855957,
0.5389808416366577,
-0.21476377546787262,
-0.4833572506904602,
-0.23836366832256317,
-0.9644535779953003,
-0.0039057014510035515,
-0.13859295845031738,
-0.3087761104106903,
0.2592604160308838,
-0.9557945132255554,
0.02384093590080738,
0.0333406887948513,
0.10028304159641266,
-0.4355948865413666,
0.05248401314020157,
0.25091853737831116,
1.003058671951294,
-0.7329533696174622,
0.9107270836830139,
0.5326807498931885,
-0.5138221979141235,
-0.7719453573226929,
0.342180997133255,
0.13235656917095184,
-1.0401573181152344,
0.8818715810775757,
0.18805256485939026,
-0.3885209858417511,
-0.24154430627822876,
-0.4090210199356079,
-1.173231601715088,
1.323081612586975,
0.22362366318702698,
-0.6329852342605591,
0.097018763422966,
0.34123799204826355,
0.628491222858429,
-0.5112301111221313,
-0.08984463661909103,
0.49299106001853943,
0.2373928278684616,
0.00578059209510684,
-0.7978734970092773,
0.17533054947853088,
-0.07260897755622864,
0.2918388545513153,
0.49878010153770447,
-0.6934846043586731,
1.2665338516235352,
-0.4596339762210846,
-0.1689511388540268,
0.29699820280075073,
1.1086281538009644,
0.07475690543651581,
0.23739247024059296,
0.5431968569755554,
0.37144923210144043,
0.904291570186615,
0.06538240611553192,
1.2521406412124634,
-0.5530350208282471,
0.3684109151363373,
0.7674792408943176,
0.23973017930984497,
1.00847589969635,
0.5333269238471985,
-0.37389853596687317,
0.8260964751243591,
0.46901383996009827,
0.2067389190196991,
0.4854746162891388,
0.17860698699951172,
-0.12267924100160599,
-0.24673691391944885,
-0.06856239587068558,
-0.4035795331001282,
0.2978975772857666,
0.4969968795776367,
-0.5710132122039795,
0.027103733271360397,
-0.3993944823741913,
0.22011089324951172,
-0.003994959406554699,
-0.319703072309494,
0.7592425346374512,
0.24968768656253815,
-0.075779490172863,
0.451403945684433,
-0.23024466633796692,
0.7508578300476074,
-0.4254530668258667,
0.031999845057725906,
-0.5875295996665955,
-0.08153998851776123,
-0.308781236410141,
-0.9666818976402283,
0.13332027196884155,
-0.5156107544898987,
-0.3660804033279419,
-0.07769940048456192,
0.38182803988456726,
-0.09247823059558868,
-0.4640723168849945,
-0.010610437020659447,
0.3489120602607727,
0.2709990441799164,
0.18251079320907593,
-0.6413663625717163,
0.1722031980752945,
-0.05143473297357559,
-0.11013289541006088,
0.38991084694862366,
1.0249617099761963,
-0.08269987255334854,
0.7434110641479492,
0.5695568323135376,
0.23003043234348297,
0.18500462174415588,
0.02466519922018051,
0.6507315635681152,
-0.9022635817527771,
-0.6516614556312561,
-1.0594978332519531,
-0.08668670058250427,
0.06237570568919182,
-0.5876753330230713,
0.6112864017486572,
0.6097248196601868,
0.7996523380279541,
0.163640096783638,
0.4637911319732666,
0.07957305014133453,
-0.06545022875070572,
-0.627044141292572,
0.5834950804710388,
-0.4284055233001709,
0.5366373658180237,
-0.07743421196937561,
-0.736399233341217,
-0.4030722975730896,
0.32942110300064087,
0.002217876259237528,
0.05642497539520264,
0.8811514377593994,
0.7537010908126831,
0.13411934673786163,
0.209947869181633,
0.4485153555870056,
0.49689191579818726,
0.3901698887348175,
0.1095517948269844,
0.8290066719055176,
-0.03644046187400818,
0.6824442148208618,
-0.17736440896987915,
-0.15169377624988556,
-0.3675316572189331,
-0.8042633533477783,
-0.9294843673706055,
-0.8986254930496216,
0.03949854522943497,
-0.4021989107131958,
0.012587770819664001,
0.6365019083023071,
0.45338836312294006,
-0.6799069046974182,
-0.4099530875682831,
-0.4179391860961914,
0.20231276750564575,
-0.17582489550113678,
-0.15837526321411133,
0.4517460763454437,
-0.6691195368766785,
-0.40163370966911316,
-0.11443908512592316,
0.8011444807052612,
0.40181341767311096,
-0.32477834820747375,
-0.12821993231773376,
0.4284437596797943,
0.20963740348815918,
0.8378109931945801,
0.09062151610851288,
-1.0986119508743286,
-0.21869857609272003,
-0.11157146096229553,
-0.3382832705974579,
0.03767813369631767,
1.2128067016601562,
-0.5473266839981079,
-0.1058262288570404,
0.31585752964019775,
0.36196842789649963,
-0.06756187975406647,
-0.23019905388355255,
0.38589635491371155,
-0.5252400040626526,
0.10069926828145981,
0.16874682903289795,
0.597955584526062,
-0.016605209559202194,
-0.508265495300293,
0.20742267370224,
0.18783289194107056,
-0.27889084815979004,
-0.6405463814735413,
0.5528417825698853,
-0.8685798048973083,
-0.31792229413986206,
1.1754812002182007,
-0.15978935360908508,
-0.2213965505361557,
-0.3874059021472931,
0.007818181067705154,
-0.44106242060661316,
-0.49289968609809875,
1.2095750570297241,
0.7989341616630554,
-0.46788492798805237,
-0.02493392489850521,
0.03315408155322075,
0.8089566230773926,
0.5788940787315369,
-0.5598602294921875,
0.2161119431257248,
0.41210663318634033,
0.3032490909099579,
0.2709621489048004,
0.9122283458709717,
-0.31729134917259216,
0.3073180019855499,
0.1900208592414856,
-0.6293702125549316,
-0.18276260793209076,
-0.31929904222488403,
-0.5096856355667114,
0.4659794270992279,
0.49303337931632996,
0.1628582924604416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01822v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01822v2 | Building Guardrails for Large Language Models | 2024-02-02T16:35:00 | 2024-05-29T12:57:01 | Yi Dong, Ronghui Mu, Gaojie Jin, Yi Qi, Jinwei Hu, Xingyu Zhao, Jie Meng, Wenjie Ruan, Xiaowei Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As Large Language Models (LLMs) become more integrated into our daily lives,
it is crucial to identify and mitigate their risks, especially when the risks
can have profound impacts on human users and societies. Guardrails, which
filter the inputs or outputs of LLMs, have emerged as a core safeguarding
technology. This position paper takes a deep look at current open-source
solutions (Llama Guard, Nvidia NeMo, Guardrails AI), and discusses the
challenges and the road towards building more complete solutions. Drawing on
robust evidence from previous research, we advocate for a systematic approach
to construct guardrails for LLMs, based on comprehensive consideration of
diverse contexts across various LLMs applications. We propose employing
socio-technical methods through collaboration with a multi-disciplinary team to
pinpoint precise technical requirements, exploring advanced neural-symbolic
implementations to embrace the complexity of the requirements, and developing
verification and testing to ensure the utmost quality of the final product. | [
-0.5830078721046448,
-0.8212270140647888,
0.7736863493919373,
0.19145165383815765,
-0.1597031056880951,
0.54312664270401,
-0.09245213866233826,
-0.5469892024993896,
0.22515366971492767,
0.682293176651001,
-0.4111979901790619,
-0.5302664637565613,
-0.7772114276885986,
-0.259200781583786,
-0.5005252957344055,
0.5677406787872314,
-0.4610259532928467,
-0.06475149840116501,
0.061007723212242126,
0.15651077032089233,
-0.45158451795578003,
-0.6418290138244629,
-0.457937628030777,
-0.36515283584594727,
0.45973286032676697,
0.18168342113494873,
0.4119844138622284,
0.403160959482193,
0.4582902789115906,
0.1902199387550354,
-0.544183075428009,
0.07523241639137268,
-0.030326098203659058,
0.39281827211380005,
-0.28629282116889954,
-0.2929287254810333,
-0.5486447811126709,
-0.2796114385128021,
0.5049575567245483,
0.4265039563179016,
-0.07583939284086227,
0.15403684973716736,
0.3164559006690979,
0.30679094791412354,
-0.6844146251678467,
0.1973264217376709,
-0.47136032581329346,
0.1481628715991974,
-0.4401170313358307,
-0.12237194180488586,
-0.3588026165962219,
-0.35793739557266235,
-0.007155760191380978,
-0.09872402995824814,
-0.2850986421108246,
0.2118193656206131,
0.7058165073394775,
0.07204074412584305,
-0.5908185243606567,
-0.10883539915084839,
-0.7497492432594299,
0.7430912852287292,
-0.7988905906677246,
0.26457056403160095,
0.26695993542671204,
0.48089781403541565,
-0.5149518847465515,
-0.34544622898101807,
-0.17842842638492584,
-0.3050146698951721,
0.056723639369010925,
-0.13202573359012604,
-0.10413923859596252,
0.08243224024772644,
0.04124416410923004,
-0.0061260247603058815,
-0.5708715915679932,
0.44044438004493713,
-0.2378338724374771,
-0.2524517774581909,
0.5482126474380493,
0.35954976081848145,
0.4829731583595276,
-0.05694393441081047,
-0.09629085659980774,
0.08224308490753174,
-1.2064415216445923,
-0.1843387335538864,
0.4075067639350891,
0.4766539931297302,
-0.20800922811031342,
0.37611088156700134,
-0.09637410193681717,
0.41665467619895935,
-0.3214606046676636,
-0.07236484438180923,
-0.17301806807518005,
-0.122722327709198,
-0.030683079734444618,
0.0518818274140358,
0.8103834986686707,
0.08872514963150024,
0.4921439588069916,
-0.24006149172782898,
-0.2865585386753082,
0.08697501569986343,
0.17416031658649445,
-0.6630710959434509,
0.08528795838356018,
0.4440261423587799,
-0.2135847955942154,
-0.3486011326313019,
-0.3534994423389435,
-0.9682043194770813,
-0.7893123626708984,
-0.5033478140830994,
0.17169426381587982,
-0.25330105423927307,
-0.5804029703140259,
0.39439359307289124,
0.17322999238967896,
0.39716872572898865,
0.2577884793281555,
-0.7987250089645386,
0.2331874519586563,
0.983727753162384,
1.1710323095321655,
0.08275105804204941,
0.022777294740080833,
-0.34224703907966614,
0.2678101062774658,
-0.4987333416938782,
0.788213312625885,
-0.41551467776298523,
-0.504981517791748,
0.32557034492492676,
-0.16879849135875702,
0.32615500688552856,
-0.21615564823150635,
0.6098303198814392,
-0.639683187007904,
-0.016458334401249886,
0.03721622750163078,
-0.2764752507209778,
0.13488119840621948,
0.5007417798042297,
-0.4778654873371124,
0.5188326239585876,
-0.25429409742355347,
-0.6665731072425842,
0.07365009188652039,
-0.5085874795913696,
-0.5222834348678589,
0.14980530738830566,
-0.17040236294269562,
-0.2349839210510254,
0.18599513173103333,
0.21514374017715454,
0.44623255729675293,
-0.5834780335426331,
0.49249032139778137,
-0.4256243407726288,
0.09233254194259644,
-0.04568884149193764,
-0.26955410838127136,
0.7404646873474121,
0.2711683511734009,
-0.4576433002948761,
0.5229867696762085,
-0.33585676550865173,
0.02520492859184742,
-0.020289083942770958,
-0.10450374335050583,
-0.26777511835098267,
0.3988058269023895,
0.2551508843898773,
0.2242482304573059,
0.3481478691101074,
-0.5111498832702637,
-0.11734464764595032,
-0.24840667843818665,
0.7034613490104675,
1.2426079511642456,
-0.07956627756357193,
0.3642156422138214,
-0.17844612896442413,
0.6864765286445618,
-0.2698703408241272,
0.5352098941802979,
-0.06975926458835602,
-0.4179386496543884,
-0.6521499156951904,
-0.18852874636650085,
0.10452423989772797,
0.37343746423721313,
-0.5779374837875366,
0.6494491696357727,
-0.25274842977523804,
-0.7690469622612,
0.043666575103998184,
0.1472092568874359,
0.3739868402481079,
0.03381163254380226,
0.033623695373535156,
-0.4137381315231323,
-0.6913887858390808,
-0.7341799736022949,
0.08009400963783264,
-0.2924615740776062,
0.04071570187807083,
-0.05457904934883118,
0.6642683148384094,
-0.21211841702461243,
0.935351550579071,
-0.5766650438308716,
-0.33906373381614685,
-0.16183659434318542,
-0.24674785137176514,
0.25516924262046814,
0.3298736810684204,
0.6689223647117615,
-0.42705968022346497,
-0.44556155800819397,
0.15711520612239838,
-0.8899727463722229,
-0.1076100543141365,
0.26028844714164734,
-0.2854907214641571,
-0.1365702748298645,
0.7687798738479614,
-0.7181791663169861,
0.08079973608255386,
0.5705601572990417,
-0.2054305225610733,
0.6197082996368408,
-0.0018001823918893933,
-0.29512104392051697,
-1.1820719242095947,
0.12562614679336548,
0.14515408873558044,
-0.12183777987957001,
-0.7106536030769348,
0.357076495885849,
-0.1118999496102333,
0.012699057348072529,
-0.4164303243160248,
0.8337432742118835,
-0.41166600584983826,
-0.02026529796421528,
-0.32553714513778687,
0.1850419044494629,
-0.08460881561040878,
0.2472209632396698,
-0.04996929690241814,
0.4819718599319458,
0.7308308482170105,
-0.6207486987113953,
0.3910870850086212,
0.2598194181919098,
-0.576836347579956,
0.6502224802970886,
-0.7832524180412292,
0.010259893722832203,
-0.10167324542999268,
0.27919095754623413,
-0.4999755620956421,
-0.4256051778793335,
0.22607915103435516,
-0.1373828649520874,
0.10227680951356888,
-0.36862510442733765,
-0.7469444274902344,
-0.4001440703868866,
-0.21275992691516876,
-0.10477983206510544,
0.5240640640258789,
-0.44741278886795044,
0.839263379573822,
0.9234975576400757,
-0.43631860613822937,
-0.5313392281532288,
-0.4634832739830017,
0.5790383219718933,
-0.24594955146312714,
-0.6951897144317627,
0.3494372069835663,
0.07301823049783707,
-0.5638357400894165,
-0.06896659731864929,
-0.2471695840358734,
-0.09559284895658493,
0.5778741240501404,
0.35109999775886536,
0.29446348547935486,
-0.23969165980815887,
0.0321330800652504,
-0.10367624461650848,
-0.128290593624115,
0.2805263102054596,
-0.2591766119003296,
0.8923019170761108,
-0.07105913758277893,
-0.5836864709854126,
-0.048837561160326004,
0.5264837741851807,
0.7171310782432556,
-0.6576648354530334,
0.7674618363380432,
0.19354677200317383,
-0.3572883903980255,
-0.5681378245353699,
-0.44157707691192627,
-0.035007428377866745,
-0.5553490519523621,
0.2688020169734955,
-0.22297076880931854,
-1.238743782043457,
0.5733806490898132,
-0.0650152787566185,
0.4278791546821594,
-0.04302515462040901,
0.5628088116645813,
0.08252877742052078,
1.1011748313903809,
0.7984272241592407,
-0.262942910194397,
0.8523892760276794,
0.16029663383960724,
0.46619102358818054,
-0.7386178970336914,
-0.3526028096675873,
-0.6584575176239014,
-0.11514598876237869,
-0.3563755452632904,
-0.17700761556625366,
0.5610123872756958,
-0.10586491227149963,
-0.5165700316429138,
0.4709368050098419,
-0.42453500628471375,
0.3873389959335327,
0.4458076059818268,
0.018064573407173157,
0.22603000700473785,
0.03361344709992409,
-0.15620042383670807,
0.3108925223350525,
-0.25352004170417786,
-0.9049041867256165,
1.000325322151184,
0.4593396782875061,
1.1094856262207031,
0.35223355889320374,
0.5648099780082703,
0.07726477086544037,
0.2676805853843689,
-0.665808379650116,
0.8353548645973206,
-0.04093194007873535,
-0.8609867095947266,
0.026332003995776176,
-0.3363801836967468,
-0.8880734443664551,
0.16611722111701965,
-0.12427861988544464,
-0.8155173659324646,
-0.15732671320438385,
0.04596179351210594,
-0.403862863779068,
0.4390563666820526,
-0.4772496521472931,
0.7195782661437988,
-0.7188694477081299,
-0.4280477464199066,
-0.3262622356414795,
-0.46645164489746094,
0.546471893787384,
-0.0974922850728035,
0.23857024312019348,
-0.2367725670337677,
0.15274879336357117,
0.5194836258888245,
-0.17631520330905914,
1.0323867797851562,
-0.11981173604726791,
-0.4325633645057678,
0.28227901458740234,
0.12992894649505615,
0.42393895983695984,
-0.16194622218608856,
0.14601443707942963,
0.04803965985774994,
-0.13256457448005676,
-0.21094100177288055,
-0.39267271757125854,
0.8147538900375366,
-0.7004480957984924,
-0.8021709322929382,
-0.405699223279953,
-0.1787208765745163,
-0.2780555784702301,
0.15898580849170685,
-0.430992066860199,
0.2743987739086151,
-0.27775466442108154,
0.18141351640224457,
0.8559709787368774,
-0.3474861681461334,
0.45869898796081543,
0.5357774496078491,
-0.6408053636550903,
-0.39605066180229187,
0.4826163053512573,
0.08290597051382065,
0.18127276003360748,
0.24334430694580078,
0.0680312067270279,
-0.1287718117237091,
-1.0367079973220825,
-0.2819172143936157,
0.21856193244457245,
-0.7263674139976501,
0.001726290094666183,
-0.4378011226654053,
-0.6366024017333984,
-0.5207500457763672,
-0.22891730070114136,
-0.18298819661140442,
-0.12872536480426788,
-0.1221725195646286,
-0.33594343066215515,
0.6504743695259094,
0.9289467334747314,
-0.005092457868158817,
0.5443016886711121,
-0.8359866142272949,
0.09728837013244629,
0.15439289808273315,
0.6199176907539368,
0.12429045140743256,
-0.343069463968277,
-0.20576629042625427,
-0.16915707290172577,
-0.3383444547653198,
-0.4124344289302826,
0.41563645005226135,
-0.31364697217941284,
0.8664132356643677,
0.19340813159942627,
0.010298383422195911,
0.31905171275138855,
-0.6750609874725342,
0.6936340928077698,
0.13479115068912506,
-0.8664013147354126,
0.5617966651916504,
-0.40204918384552,
-0.12692339718341827,
0.2191765159368515,
0.2934862971305847,
-0.7804731130599976,
-0.15467768907546997,
-0.14833950996398926,
-1.122182011604309,
0.47513705492019653,
0.10075311362743378,
0.31373360753059387,
0.23313957452774048,
0.044347647577524185,
-0.3824177384376526,
-0.017725639045238495,
-0.5750812888145447,
0.2663460373878479,
0.0584585964679718,
-0.23286038637161255,
-0.11058203876018524,
-0.06950073689222336,
-0.30872848629951477,
0.4199645221233368,
0.6257351040840149,
-0.0037486343644559383,
-0.22838959097862244,
-0.19554564356803894,
-0.0790906548500061,
0.14373531937599182,
0.5379684567451477,
0.4478362798690796,
0.37237629294395447,
-0.246806800365448,
0.3281456530094147,
-0.018363486975431442,
-0.2477222979068756,
0.31649544835090637,
-0.25542932748794556,
-0.21800313889980316,
-0.15668724477291107,
0.37218719720840454,
0.644948422908783,
-0.1187533512711525,
-0.6437622308731079,
0.36853891611099243,
0.17023241519927979,
-0.03980260342359543,
-0.5501731634140015,
0.05333320051431656,
0.22483576834201813,
0.15975382924079895,
-0.03075180947780609,
-0.11748281121253967,
-0.4052717983722687,
-0.5135151743888855,
0.17759831249713898,
0.7711400389671326,
-0.5884585976600647,
-0.38276436924934387,
0.5683814883232117,
0.4556345045566559,
-0.4042307436466217,
0.1032760962843895,
0.2604568898677826,
-0.5888451337814331,
0.5993106365203857,
0.1869957149028778,
1.2178587913513184,
-0.13482269644737244,
0.08223693072795868,
0.13141492009162903,
0.644788920879364,
-0.4452570974826813,
0.12393157929182053,
0.11283574253320694,
-0.5906822085380554,
-0.6210500597953796,
-0.7129226922988892,
-0.7594870328903198,
-0.10034573078155518,
-0.20712831616401672,
0.37957245111465454,
-0.9274160861968994,
-0.344625324010849,
-0.27395400404930115,
-0.32693150639533997,
-0.08883737027645111,
-0.21729838848114014,
0.393727570772171,
1.0667046308517456,
-0.8963187336921692,
0.6077526807785034,
0.4167879521846771,
-0.4485545754432678,
-0.5807234644889832,
-0.13617876172065735,
0.16535606980323792,
-0.5685999393463135,
0.7457098960876465,
0.029008574783802032,
-0.4231908619403839,
-0.3550703227519989,
-0.5810917615890503,
-0.822852373123169,
0.8222675323486328,
0.41808226704597473,
-0.42471596598625183,
-0.4229123890399933,
0.35265451669692993,
0.6964470148086548,
-0.013827051967382431,
0.21235215663909912,
0.48156818747520447,
0.4162759482860565,
-0.10156065970659256,
-0.8186408877372742,
0.1430208384990692,
-0.21736609935760498,
0.05209672451019287,
0.39930275082588196,
-0.7337415218353271,
0.7388700246810913,
0.4970088601112366,
-0.3338474929332733,
0.14726325869560242,
0.21090342104434967,
0.29390817880630493,
-0.14327983558177948,
0.24027115106582642,
0.3865334093570709,
0.22945648431777954,
-0.07725013792514801,
0.9547600150108337,
-0.5849581360816956,
-0.026835910975933075,
1.0555870532989502,
-0.6530945301055908,
0.9234148859977722,
0.47907769680023193,
-0.019326288253068924,
0.40138158202171326,
0.4825340807437897,
0.16068315505981445,
0.39198607206344604,
0.39693960547447205,
-0.5646496415138245,
-0.3878439664840698,
-0.5194035768508911,
-0.20486688613891602,
0.0798095241189003,
0.5509947538375854,
-0.24673797190189362,
-0.3931065499782562,
-0.29065608978271484,
0.3012814223766327,
0.1741400957107544,
-0.3311885595321655,
0.5019875764846802,
0.531361997127533,
-0.7080678343772888,
0.12162912636995316,
0.06784693151712418,
0.8275989294052124,
-0.9105664491653442,
0.3018578290939331,
-0.28506723046302795,
0.37596210837364197,
-0.11779260635375977,
-1.1438361406326294,
0.3963944613933563,
0.4493786692619324,
0.24582871794700623,
-0.6725846529006958,
0.44379618763923645,
-0.02134646661579609,
-0.348637193441391,
0.7063093781471252,
0.42042437195777893,
-0.2310113161802292,
0.022734887897968292,
-0.3637143671512604,
0.05480487644672394,
-0.41325661540031433,
-0.17708447575569153,
0.45315980911254883,
0.23804643750190735,
-0.2490038424730301,
0.935659646987915,
0.681537389755249,
0.2591295838356018,
0.174549862742424,
0.04755965620279312,
0.9983131885528564,
-0.43585315346717834,
-0.31534332036972046,
-1.1457256078720093,
0.48374056816101074,
-0.217539981007576,
-0.2542480230331421,
0.8104875683784485,
0.35773539543151855,
0.5375948548316956,
0.09566706418991089,
0.9313991665840149,
-0.09193411469459534,
0.22031269967556,
-0.5919862985610962,
0.8994682431221008,
-0.3258376717567444,
0.37866953015327454,
-0.3099769353866577,
-0.777423083782196,
-0.608874499797821,
0.379491925239563,
-0.3023165762424469,
-0.38770461082458496,
0.38445231318473816,
1.089868426322937,
-0.06072026118636131,
-0.1586378514766693,
0.24471785128116608,
0.04227041080594063,
0.9727265238761902,
0.7404593229293823,
1.1587332487106323,
-0.13148096203804016,
0.7601180672645569,
0.11399606615304947,
-0.1041451245546341,
-0.09817711263895035,
-0.9497637748718262,
-1.0952892303466797,
-0.16863490641117096,
-0.22615288197994232,
-0.2972068190574646,
0.007234481628984213,
0.8846169114112854,
0.7623710036277771,
-0.9262945652008057,
-0.48363184928894043,
-0.2662869393825531,
0.32009556889533997,
0.26173508167266846,
-0.11934469640254974,
0.15720444917678833,
-0.11487782001495361,
-0.3914503753185272,
0.3737332224845886,
0.49073174595832825,
0.1204799935221672,
-0.7358332872390747,
0.018382659181952477,
0.00025845272466540337,
0.22968080639839172,
0.487852543592453,
0.28672781586647034,
-0.6191818714141846,
-0.49008992314338684,
0.036931052803993225,
-0.15176744759082794,
-0.10059520602226257,
0.6514817476272583,
-0.2844996154308319,
0.04813671484589577,
0.7430859208106995,
0.7999716401100159,
0.39012372493743896,
-0.6744830012321472,
0.7743103504180908,
-0.5621494650840759,
0.04749729484319687,
0.19073644280433655,
0.8128332495689392,
0.33263057470321655,
0.2254440188407898,
0.5852150917053223,
-0.1987907737493515,
-0.4468817412853241,
-1.0089924335479736,
0.672496497631073,
-0.786623477935791,
-0.2083226889371872,
1.061347246170044,
-0.17528928816318512,
-0.38163039088249207,
-0.3425445258617401,
-0.26209354400634766,
0.03360438346862793,
-0.15046173334121704,
0.6752765774726868,
0.8326083421707153,
0.4274492859840393,
-0.2570103406906128,
-0.5342845916748047,
0.1983414739370346,
0.13150101900100708,
-1.0419094562530518,
0.3321540951728821,
0.43251878023147583,
0.3690166473388672,
0.4211222529411316,
0.28545719385147095,
-0.19548866152763367,
-0.1872294694185257,
-0.06584908813238144,
0.3163558542728424,
0.06979959458112717,
-0.37938565015792847,
-0.3357870578765869,
0.2950683534145355,
0.2877137064933777,
0.22595804929733276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01535v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01535v2 | An Empirical Analysis of Diversity in Argument Summarization | 2024-02-02T16:26:52 | 2024-02-14T10:51:08 | Michiel van der Meer, Piek Vossen, Catholijn M. Jonker, Pradeep K. Murukannaiah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Presenting high-level arguments is a crucial task for fostering participation
in online societal discussions. Current argument summarization approaches miss
an important facet of this task -- capturing diversity -- which is important
for accommodating multiple perspectives. We introduce three aspects of
diversity: those of opinions, annotators, and sources. We evaluate approaches
to a popular argument summarization task called Key Point Analysis, which shows
how these approaches struggle to (1) represent arguments shared by few people,
(2) deal with data from various sources, and (3) align with subjectivity in
human-provided annotations. We find that both general-purpose LLMs and
dedicated KPA models exhibit this behavior, but have complementary strengths.
Further, we observe that diversification of training data may ameliorate
generalization. Addressing diversity in argument summarization requires a mix
of strategies to deal with subjectivity. | [
-0.6922362446784973,
-0.3005366027355194,
0.5333545207977295,
0.14103876054286957,
-0.5443130135536194,
0.16844499111175537,
-0.11258578300476074,
-0.307207852602005,
0.27551543712615967,
0.10793734341859818,
-0.04655400663614273,
-0.6033483743667603,
-0.8762853741645813,
0.14908882975578308,
-0.1183418482542038,
1.4062719345092773,
0.08561281859874725,
0.06171458959579468,
-0.18973471224308014,
-0.7802453637123108,
-0.3184671401977539,
-0.7411032915115356,
-0.3030296564102173,
-0.07126975059509277,
0.8763337731361389,
0.6680909991264343,
0.5166202187538147,
0.4720449447631836,
0.32135137915611267,
0.291791707277298,
-0.43096262216567993,
-0.07079864293336868,
-0.4301608204841614,
0.3333824574947357,
-0.18202614784240723,
-0.5793096423149109,
-0.22473499178886414,
-0.15029382705688477,
0.784565806388855,
1.061598300933838,
0.30696582794189453,
0.19082340598106384,
0.08194801956415176,
0.750905454158783,
-0.7259413599967957,
-0.32213643193244934,
-0.5284259915351868,
0.2746198773384094,
-0.04874388501048088,
0.12044442445039749,
0.10874326527118683,
-0.5897064805030823,
0.49371469020843506,
-0.4435805082321167,
0.3796221911907196,
-0.47871845960617065,
0.6277364492416382,
-0.036890655755996704,
-0.8182693719863892,
-0.5703564286231995,
-0.7755221128463745,
0.7835814952850342,
-0.8182985782623291,
-0.22078756988048553,
-0.12185847014188766,
0.22636045515537262,
0.3204026520252228,
-0.49879807233810425,
-0.10737725347280502,
0.2753193974494934,
0.04898127168416977,
0.3208676278591156,
-0.11649022251367569,
-0.051449794322252274,
0.1955917775630951,
0.45103245973587036,
-0.19523711502552032,
0.09006424993276596,
-0.7696813941001892,
-0.03034856542944908,
0.8664900064468384,
0.19338609278202057,
0.12184827774763107,
-0.19796086847782135,
0.02654360607266426,
0.012958497740328312,
-0.5092911124229431,
0.270755410194397,
0.7665912508964539,
0.15419620275497437,
-0.31124892830848694,
0.5211567282676697,
-0.42793500423431396,
0.5073691010475159,
-0.03340543806552887,
-0.06484709680080414,
-0.0382208451628685,
-0.4250701665878296,
-0.0016700444975867867,
-0.036283571273088455,
0.6801594495773315,
0.6641076803207397,
0.25168776512145996,
0.07981391251087189,
0.36939918994903564,
-0.2617650330066681,
-0.03903103992342949,
-0.8454999327659607,
-0.03098469041287899,
0.3600231409072876,
-0.9410931468009949,
-0.2935876250267029,
0.114242784678936,
-1.158953070640564,
-0.6540140509605408,
-0.03389187157154083,
-0.1349499374628067,
0.12568767368793488,
-0.15403687953948975,
-0.17555053532123566,
-0.7426810264587402,
0.27111199498176575,
0.5102875232696533,
-0.8529036641120911,
0.3369453549385071,
0.8229490518569946,
1.0083459615707397,
-0.3419548571109772,
-0.049015458673238754,
-0.06579142063856125,
0.09581407904624939,
-0.21302083134651184,
1.1192805767059326,
-0.5607879161834717,
-0.6959208250045776,
-0.01008687261492014,
-0.27649158239364624,
0.17638535797595978,
-0.5597921013832092,
0.6338230967521667,
-0.19843462109565735,
0.3898252546787262,
-0.907390296459198,
-0.7405248880386353,
-0.32925543189048767,
0.1847638636827469,
-0.5978766679763794,
0.3831033408641815,
-0.23112434148788452,
-0.7636731266975403,
0.8202043771743774,
-0.8948504328727722,
-0.5151222348213196,
0.06885272264480591,
-0.3684251308441162,
-0.39296668767929077,
0.4341548681259155,
0.2915814220905304,
0.42813751101493835,
0.13273760676383972,
0.052251797169446945,
-0.5033429265022278,
-0.3344278335571289,
0.3415999114513397,
-0.026332059875130653,
0.7478196620941162,
0.26143431663513184,
-0.1686490774154663,
0.14905142784118652,
-0.549587607383728,
-0.49603164196014404,
0.05342378094792366,
-0.4097921848297119,
-0.40813276171684265,
0.37211889028549194,
-0.18651022017002106,
0.10311999171972275,
0.03551466017961502,
-0.40388911962509155,
0.24128921329975128,
-0.3726634681224823,
0.4132740795612335,
0.5519388914108276,
0.4316161870956421,
0.33654263615608215,
-0.4003992974758148,
0.4547661244869232,
0.16296164691448212,
-0.06756523251533508,
-0.2780527174472809,
-0.9086053967475891,
-0.4845160245895386,
-0.270755410194397,
0.21834947168827057,
0.40395885705947876,
0.1458086222410202,
-0.05565327778458595,
-0.30352047085762024,
-0.502087414264679,
-0.23192091286182404,
0.17179986834526062,
-0.07881546765565872,
-0.049174487590789795,
0.07073192298412323,
-0.20199032127857208,
-0.6201488375663757,
-0.9634788036346436,
-0.807315468788147,
-0.21540984511375427,
-0.1836458295583725,
0.281369149684906,
0.5468858480453491,
0.16190201044082642,
1.1258364915847778,
-0.3098599910736084,
0.06121499091386795,
-0.6008042097091675,
0.5707930326461792,
0.1394304633140564,
0.25766468048095703,
0.6698944568634033,
-0.6257233023643494,
-0.43650999665260315,
-0.06147325783967972,
-0.8839762806892395,
-0.05738149955868721,
-0.2234245240688324,
0.11584610491991043,
-0.25736305117607117,
0.05670595541596413,
-0.5005719661712646,
0.28467002511024475,
0.12919200956821442,
-0.17267198860645294,
-0.05102011561393738,
0.12527050077915192,
0.22229129076004028,
-1.1845290660858154,
-0.15489254891872406,
0.17917606234550476,
0.025423521175980568,
-0.6345270872116089,
0.07647961378097534,
-0.5111326575279236,
-0.32301947474479675,
-0.15341265499591827,
0.28172340989112854,
-0.284923255443573,
-0.060810744762420654,
-0.5459950566291809,
0.2294589877128601,
-0.034422051161527634,
0.19438941776752472,
0.005991000682115555,
0.21265137195587158,
0.12671607732772827,
-0.3333807587623596,
0.19368059933185577,
0.05399508401751518,
-0.025844046846032143,
0.8512338995933533,
-0.8167319297790527,
-0.03985866904258728,
-0.38469982147216797,
0.3046796917915344,
-1.2065536975860596,
-0.5278638005256653,
0.17404216527938843,
-0.34205392003059387,
-0.10808369517326355,
-0.28914088010787964,
0.13905102014541626,
-0.07939822971820831,
-0.8488115072250366,
0.5539756417274475,
0.2697755694389343,
-0.2648627758026123,
0.8117292523384094,
0.5869429111480713,
-0.5692981481552124,
-0.508037269115448,
-0.3999732434749603,
0.2755892276763916,
-0.7271966934204102,
-0.5659632682800293,
0.21712926030158997,
0.013859103433787823,
-0.7547604441642761,
-0.0389256626367569,
-0.0538928285241127,
-0.00611066073179245,
0.3419337868690491,
0.4199669063091278,
-0.09326214343309402,
-0.21767860651016235,
0.10419753938913345,
0.12725549936294556,
0.10810598731040955,
0.13138365745544434,
0.10425567626953125,
0.1840396523475647,
-0.1680263876914978,
-0.4945807456970215,
-0.07898993790149689,
1.0607327222824097,
0.43423759937286377,
0.19155748188495636,
0.410501629114151,
0.22612980008125305,
-0.1787591427564621,
0.05985544994473457,
-0.5406538248062134,
0.10492043197154999,
-0.35747748613357544,
0.46927759051322937,
-0.019636115059256554,
-0.9340954422950745,
0.7647603154182434,
-0.021240470930933952,
0.8440355062484741,
0.5573232173919678,
0.7891082167625427,
-0.4111161530017853,
0.8688467144966125,
0.22823309898376465,
-0.03575978800654411,
0.35810139775276184,
-0.046152397990226746,
0.25287771224975586,
-0.4724757969379425,
0.06735055148601532,
-0.5982615351676941,
-0.6938527226448059,
-0.46441909670829773,
-0.06217645853757858,
0.11861713230609894,
0.12528017163276672,
-0.11867766827344894,
-0.254570335149765,
-0.35560348629951477,
0.5703299045562744,
0.4161751866340637,
-0.2074781209230423,
0.4006848633289337,
0.021503007039427757,
0.2989064157009125,
-0.17138361930847168,
-0.5855758190155029,
-0.7946529984474182,
1.3605010509490967,
0.5859196782112122,
0.29850292205810547,
0.2219032198190689,
1.0597079992294312,
0.3440822660923004,
0.6472486853599548,
-0.9388787150382996,
0.5210449695587158,
-0.10231494903564453,
-0.6699750423431396,
-0.20666271448135376,
-0.3114040195941925,
-0.8893097639083862,
0.8155312538146973,
-0.14605823159217834,
-0.7445346713066101,
0.4446902871131897,
0.05942587926983833,
-0.49629759788513184,
0.338945597410202,
-0.5768697261810303,
0.8555049896240234,
0.032617367804050446,
0.11780565232038498,
-0.16201987862586975,
-0.6034612059593201,
0.6889250874519348,
0.24340187013149261,
0.31452542543411255,
-0.06394979357719421,
0.11341870576143265,
1.1355938911437988,
-0.30887970328330994,
0.8887218236923218,
-0.3451751470565796,
-0.023210404440760612,
0.440493643283844,
-0.4848073720932007,
0.06425672024488449,
0.060329288244247437,
0.3306463658809662,
0.048799339681863785,
-0.10392031073570251,
-0.5035111904144287,
-0.508310079574585,
0.39286866784095764,
-0.96211838722229,
-0.8584996461868286,
-0.2524275481700897,
-0.5552467703819275,
-0.1776648610830307,
-0.36543339490890503,
0.28664761781692505,
0.202321857213974,
-0.2643027603626251,
0.602469801902771,
0.48879939317703247,
0.07155756652355194,
0.5701513290405273,
0.04760153591632843,
0.1603953093290329,
-0.837157130241394,
0.9419500231742859,
0.5124514102935791,
0.12072698771953583,
-0.07012195140123367,
0.5406364798545837,
0.02341476082801819,
-0.7543031573295593,
-0.09451674669981003,
0.10727284103631973,
-1.3526023626327515,
0.11033795028924942,
-0.9769186973571777,
0.21820974349975586,
-0.2887304425239563,
-0.4594622850418091,
-0.06079534441232681,
-0.7739810943603516,
-0.1561153680086136,
-0.38635578751564026,
0.17818205058574677,
0.7069768309593201,
-0.034689538180828094,
0.5554882884025574,
-0.7353696227073669,
0.4103570878505707,
0.7947798371315002,
-0.042650919407606125,
0.052601881325244904,
-0.22448867559432983,
-0.10456513613462448,
-0.16862310469150543,
-0.5931435823440552,
-1.3538748025894165,
-0.2353043258190155,
0.16123750805854797,
0.7794901728630066,
0.5914560556411743,
-0.07581532001495361,
0.5447462201118469,
0.15348419547080994,
1.2083388566970825,
0.09547887742519379,
-0.8213892579078674,
0.5263179540634155,
-0.22990906238555908,
0.23261387646198273,
0.6934919953346252,
0.4191316068172455,
-0.510064423084259,
-0.6331062316894531,
-0.5538288354873657,
-0.9299761652946472,
0.28923299908638,
0.051496606320142746,
0.050050392746925354,
0.08341614902019501,
-0.0390283428132534,
0.19289334118366241,
0.13893230259418488,
-0.9299472570419312,
0.027073170989751816,
-0.6113507747650146,
-0.4869263470172882,
0.2858039438724518,
-0.31930509209632874,
-0.6505786776542664,
-0.10819825530052185,
0.19994308054447174,
-0.1315108835697174,
-0.123031385242939,
0.12637056410312653,
-0.17733801901340485,
0.11815083026885986,
0.6869659423828125,
0.9416678547859192,
0.8619244694709778,
-0.1702403575181961,
0.05927509814500809,
0.305096834897995,
-0.37091803550720215,
0.17523306608200073,
-0.04575653746724129,
-0.3283805847167969,
0.3886581063270569,
0.7659838795661926,
0.778621256351471,
0.1681717187166214,
-0.34220439195632935,
0.44730454683303833,
-0.10656296461820602,
-0.3841552734375,
0.12049125134944916,
-0.10141813009977341,
0.3145082890987396,
0.3287951648235321,
0.5091952085494995,
-0.042370107024908066,
0.18819493055343628,
-0.7209048867225647,
-0.1904887557029724,
0.5463154315948486,
0.030819786712527275,
-0.2403259128332138,
0.3615889251232147,
0.5077331066131592,
-0.18175262212753296,
-0.13821524381637573,
0.1577870398759842,
-0.4594707190990448,
0.7992314696311951,
0.09965389221906662,
1.0859516859054565,
0.15644140541553497,
0.19162699580192566,
0.2707715332508087,
0.17824015021324158,
0.23408856987953186,
0.28067746758461,
-0.34321513772010803,
-0.46342673897743225,
-0.24539226293563843,
-0.1616298407316208,
-0.7468671202659607,
-0.2113473266363144,
-0.5337014198303223,
-0.046857476234436035,
-0.5340065956115723,
-0.1609126329421997,
0.1115184873342514,
-0.07674930989742279,
-0.4061811566352844,
-0.0018460683058947325,
0.1716955006122589,
0.5108223557472229,
-1.1131247282028198,
0.01688738726079464,
0.7004488706588745,
-0.47304999828338623,
-0.25932350754737854,
0.3225989043712616,
-0.10299847275018692,
-0.26557254791259766,
0.8818444013595581,
0.01716039329767227,
0.10631629079580307,
-0.5465801358222961,
-0.5682156682014465,
-0.5401361584663391,
0.9310208559036255,
0.13658766448497772,
-0.2681223750114441,
0.16966979205608368,
0.33622047305107117,
0.34659942984580994,
-0.7458698749542236,
0.2302408069372177,
0.3154250979423523,
0.4914000630378723,
0.0561235137283802,
-0.2718691825866699,
-0.03735223039984703,
-0.1148635670542717,
0.04761550948023796,
-0.3333739936351776,
-0.47671017050743103,
0.9626551270484924,
-0.21396441757678986,
-0.30956462025642395,
-0.2926819622516632,
0.8101606965065002,
0.5975963473320007,
0.6273313760757446,
0.4719052314758301,
0.3265267312526703,
0.5664674043655396,
0.10079199075698853,
0.7017399072647095,
-0.11207298189401627,
0.3373585045337677,
1.0842955112457275,
-0.44412752985954285,
0.6356832981109619,
0.49927663803100586,
-0.3528384566307068,
0.3916439116001129,
0.6925528645515442,
-0.11197742074728012,
0.28301167488098145,
0.20543265342712402,
-0.23025169968605042,
-0.23508517444133759,
0.03640403226017952,
-0.591945469379425,
0.3511594235897064,
0.2812798321247101,
-0.3703632652759552,
-0.5933935046195984,
-0.1648106873035431,
0.004576066508889198,
-0.034846555441617966,
-0.3834487199783325,
1.0777416229248047,
0.01931566558778286,
-0.6277348399162292,
0.04039554297924042,
-0.08795994520187378,
0.5974317789077759,
-0.40689700841903687,
-0.05280925706028938,
-0.47637856006622314,
-0.3298321068286896,
-0.3826731741428375,
-0.7555691003799438,
0.25706779956817627,
0.2864401936531067,
-0.251903772354126,
0.23112566769123077,
0.8373791575431824,
-0.012763767503201962,
-0.4190775156021118,
-0.12840045988559723,
0.4112880229949951,
0.14274367690086365,
0.08824246376752853,
-0.21102410554885864,
-0.03548881411552429,
-0.22601406276226044,
-0.24074986577033997,
0.34779223799705505,
0.4190974831581116,
-0.1626099795103073,
0.22989609837532043,
0.5034273862838745,
0.07967735826969147,
0.3094235956668854,
0.10482042282819748,
0.7800601124763489,
-0.724253237247467,
-0.5412256121635437,
-1.1954469680786133,
0.7816634774208069,
-0.7751877307891846,
-0.70998215675354,
0.7649828195571899,
0.47939711809158325,
0.36752820014953613,
-0.1335115283727646,
1.0168101787567139,
0.29754638671875,
0.5053139328956604,
-0.08237887918949127,
0.4067327678203583,
-0.2802324891090393,
0.13017906248569489,
-0.24820373952388763,
-0.991827666759491,
-0.27856743335723877,
0.48105335235595703,
-0.2134166657924652,
-0.0018977279542014003,
0.4504436254501343,
0.12478913366794586,
-0.05309152603149414,
0.3523445427417755,
0.1184265986084938,
-0.18000435829162598,
0.44521909952163696,
0.38920459151268005,
1.146436095237732,
-0.180887371301651,
0.5675604939460754,
-0.022752735763788223,
-0.3494999408721924,
-0.5003323554992676,
-1.0114811658859253,
-1.0216045379638672,
-0.06204542517662048,
-0.6260796189308167,
0.014005709439516068,
-0.25414037704467773,
1.074912428855896,
0.5516862869262695,
-1.0952829122543335,
-0.4415518343448639,
0.10024755448102951,
0.4362737536430359,
-0.15361382067203522,
-0.15857237577438354,
-0.009873820468783379,
-0.36232346296310425,
-0.4254419803619385,
0.09987994283437729,
0.333437979221344,
-0.1713850200176239,
-0.3347231447696686,
0.06194836646318436,
-0.013252569362521172,
0.3232536017894745,
0.5640942454338074,
0.5820690989494324,
-0.9089834094047546,
-0.23176193237304688,
-0.4481183886528015,
0.1649806797504425,
0.31231689453125,
1.2360845804214478,
-0.22307778894901276,
0.3358069062232971,
0.6876173615455627,
0.7913716435432434,
0.29568055272102356,
0.2893267869949341,
0.6793444156646729,
-0.7278911471366882,
0.018594715744256973,
0.30532267689704895,
0.6333951950073242,
0.33078399300575256,
-0.04972095787525177,
0.3210659623146057,
0.44372639060020447,
-0.4179672598838806,
-0.7650403380393982,
0.22054554522037506,
-1.0292277336120605,
-0.4620862603187561,
0.918904721736908,
-0.4302123785018921,
0.23363283276557922,
-0.3069054186344147,
-0.27259087562561035,
0.052664194256067276,
-0.32302045822143555,
0.9580208659172058,
1.1969211101531982,
-0.124344103038311,
-0.22484202682971954,
-0.3313925862312317,
0.3351901173591614,
0.33219990134239197,
-1.0901827812194824,
0.11013220995664597,
0.5373665690422058,
0.23064102232456207,
0.3899573087692261,
0.4859558641910553,
0.01469113864004612,
0.21655865013599396,
-0.15333642065525055,
-0.2874181270599365,
0.24058131873607635,
-0.06547154486179352,
-0.5376905202865601,
0.9661867022514343,
0.1299619823694229,
-0.2516395151615143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01528v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01528v2 | Decoding Speculative Decoding | 2024-02-02T16:15:24 | 2024-04-26T04:52:57 | Minghao Yan, Saurabh Agarwal, Shivaram Venkataraman | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Speculative Decoding is a widely used technique to speed up inference for
Large Language Models (LLMs) without sacrificing quality. When performing
inference, speculative decoding uses a smaller draft model to generate
speculative tokens and then uses the target LLM to verify those draft tokens.
The speedup provided by speculative decoding heavily depends on the choice of
the draft model. In this work, we perform a detailed study comprising over 350
experiments with LLaMA-65B and OPT-66B using speculative decoding and delineate
the factors that affect the performance gain provided by speculative decoding.
Our experiments indicate that the performance of speculative decoding depends
heavily on the latency of the draft model, and the draft model's capability in
language modeling does not correlate strongly with its performance in
speculative decoding. Based on these insights we explore a new design space for
draft models and design hardware-efficient draft models for speculative
decoding. Our newly designed draft model for LLaMA-65B can provide 60% higher
throughput than existing draft models and can generalize further to the LLaMA-2
model family and supervised fine-tuned models. | [
-0.17147769033908844,
-0.675014078617096,
0.4888184070587158,
0.4323408007621765,
-0.5313902497291565,
0.42213356494903564,
0.11695746332406998,
-0.9887959957122803,
0.27690210938453674,
0.6677654385566711,
-0.3245352804660797,
-0.17692036926746368,
-0.5851368308067322,
0.21946687996387482,
-0.371102511882782,
0.4047471880912781,
-0.1143166720867157,
-0.21823707222938538,
0.029649339616298676,
0.6182167530059814,
-0.1284199208021164,
-0.764255166053772,
-0.4807005822658539,
-0.07425972819328308,
0.06923530995845795,
0.30807510018348694,
0.6847978234291077,
0.7035995125770569,
0.5607926249504089,
0.22734110057353973,
-0.3368820250034332,
0.14747615158557892,
-0.7408503890037537,
0.02438066340982914,
0.29297393560409546,
-1.0090032815933228,
-0.8135268092155457,
-0.37952664494514465,
0.5520559549331665,
0.3882085680961609,
0.014363405294716358,
0.11862347275018692,
-0.5602447986602783,
0.34664589166641235,
-0.8376258611679077,
0.1552370935678482,
-0.7735584378242493,
-0.01454425510019064,
-0.6098977327346802,
-0.5298525094985962,
-0.9102775454521179,
-0.2347119152545929,
-0.20467787981033325,
-0.6033896803855896,
0.41626736521720886,
0.3559108376502991,
0.5483536720275879,
0.21421784162521362,
-0.2586013078689575,
-0.028032150119543076,
-0.7322132587432861,
0.5917820930480957,
-0.9773246049880981,
0.5644891858100891,
0.6429067850112915,
-0.03478867560625076,
-0.2178504914045334,
-0.5694347023963928,
-0.5648588538169861,
-0.13151559233665466,
0.11498036980628967,
0.051911402493715286,
-0.26280245184898376,
0.23179756104946136,
0.36202704906463623,
0.3489512503147125,
-0.4377114772796631,
0.26470452547073364,
-0.5251602530479431,
-0.3796630799770355,
0.5642954111099243,
0.3889501690864563,
-0.10550215095281601,
-0.218713641166687,
-0.18554453551769257,
-0.07459162920713425,
-0.652108371257782,
0.06456945836544037,
0.6571104526519775,
-0.10018488764762878,
-0.14476414024829865,
0.5687997937202454,
-0.5696648359298706,
0.6357064247131348,
0.05892084911465645,
-0.09387736022472382,
0.08452240377664566,
-0.38492080569267273,
-0.0962010845541954,
0.09399081021547318,
0.4171668291091919,
0.40967443585395813,
-0.19254380464553833,
-0.45298099517822266,
-0.30133548378944397,
0.5549293756484985,
0.22039839625358582,
-0.903914749622345,
-0.23989196121692657,
0.23930738866329193,
-0.8616504073143005,
-0.4569886326789856,
-0.21723584830760956,
-0.5087912082672119,
0.048747915774583817,
0.15207336843013763,
-0.12628430128097534,
-0.4647982120513916,
-0.4783407747745514,
0.812858521938324,
-0.4151599407196045,
0.20537921786308289,
0.21500961482524872,
-1.1666080951690674,
0.41021355986595154,
0.6220234632492065,
0.6543118953704834,
-0.34290504455566406,
-0.1289881020784378,
-0.12440957129001617,
0.22313135862350464,
-0.7700724005699158,
1.1921926736831665,
-0.8207755088806152,
-0.6343618035316467,
-0.26507842540740967,
-0.368177205324173,
0.027935871854424477,
-0.23816218972206116,
0.8292105197906494,
-1.2026029825210571,
-0.5184222459793091,
-0.4351353943347931,
-0.583318293094635,
-0.12408454716205597,
-0.10149483382701874,
-0.9001513719558716,
0.6960722208023071,
-0.06324465572834015,
-0.8613304495811462,
0.5877223610877991,
-0.3639892041683197,
-0.3788021504878998,
0.13594503700733185,
0.050735678523778915,
0.06582076847553253,
0.5501171350479126,
0.21365107595920563,
0.36601799726486206,
-0.36957597732543945,
0.022539513185620308,
-0.3958001732826233,
-1.142417073249817,
0.36546745896339417,
-0.6326221227645874,
0.2865771949291229,
0.5822197794914246,
0.08805809170007706,
-0.32296040654182434,
-0.7119032144546509,
0.10833548754453659,
0.10688222199678421,
-0.7221559286117554,
-0.15714190900325775,
0.202682226896286,
0.008603988215327263,
-0.22429320216178894,
0.08319663256406784,
-0.5041922330856323,
0.2645580768585205,
-0.5065922737121582,
0.36836621165275574,
0.5312934517860413,
-0.11234869062900543,
0.3313142955303192,
-0.3463980555534363,
0.7008719444274902,
-0.037144169211387634,
-0.09695212543010712,
-0.2565572261810303,
-0.27868685126304626,
-0.7977011203765869,
-0.1351301074028015,
0.3266390860080719,
0.3362461030483246,
-0.8536667823791504,
-0.02021060697734356,
-0.08328740298748016,
-0.4130188226699829,
-0.5992686748504639,
-0.15313690900802612,
0.22749166190624237,
0.08729777485132217,
0.19438035786151886,
0.0016805347986519337,
-0.7682387232780457,
-0.697878897190094,
-0.32122525572776794,
-0.4404245913028717,
0.3719507157802582,
0.1903037279844284,
0.1215936541557312,
-0.4265042841434479,
0.4516843855381012,
-0.427563339471817,
0.5497522354125977,
-0.43750011920928955,
-0.13004273176193237,
0.3220905363559723,
0.314365416765213,
0.7776063084602356,
-0.44758015871047974,
0.05251503735780716,
-0.0654514878988266,
-0.6856152415275574,
-0.002162789460271597,
-0.08687323331832886,
-0.2750069499015808,
0.4129825532436371,
0.6824381351470947,
-0.784756600856781,
0.30756622552871704,
0.647986888885498,
-0.3858815133571625,
0.736413300037384,
-0.17382864654064178,
0.36664122343063354,
-0.797350287437439,
-0.05163549259305,
-0.4237985908985138,
0.1973804086446762,
-0.4197487533092499,
0.32601606845855713,
0.20713721215724945,
0.22908133268356323,
-0.3935869336128235,
0.19164694845676422,
-0.49539634585380554,
0.03771839663386345,
-0.3724227249622345,
-0.4632048010826111,
0.10591781884431839,
0.10186823457479477,
0.22303450107574463,
1.1278300285339355,
0.3572968542575836,
-0.4997636675834656,
0.02781766839325428,
-0.10024682432413101,
-0.3298228085041046,
-0.30488350987434387,
-0.7790420055389404,
0.2983469069004059,
-0.14441506564617157,
0.5450418591499329,
-0.9341687560081482,
-0.31209948658943176,
0.06738314777612686,
-0.08937255293130875,
0.15607739984989166,
-0.09911021590232849,
-0.6121062636375427,
-0.6134871244430542,
-0.19268877804279327,
0.9817218780517578,
0.4387725293636322,
-0.3030596077442169,
0.4832381010055542,
0.23039895296096802,
0.15317367017269135,
-0.7095298171043396,
-0.8210465908050537,
0.11446882039308548,
0.0054823122918605804,
-0.7351545691490173,
0.5551906824111938,
-0.127023383975029,
-0.2031295895576477,
0.0000741637559258379,
-0.04829109087586403,
0.05729604884982109,
0.09571260958909988,
0.18496455252170563,
0.38655078411102295,
-0.4467814564704895,
-0.11939795315265656,
0.46747589111328125,
-0.35406020283699036,
0.18613414466381073,
-0.3728742301464081,
0.5381335020065308,
-0.10038464516401291,
-0.18323765695095062,
-0.33139199018478394,
0.6622446179389954,
0.468837708234787,
-0.06933575123548508,
0.49870914220809937,
0.15996524691581726,
-0.242621511220932,
-0.4884878695011139,
-0.8107739686965942,
-0.15385980904102325,
-0.5423697233200073,
0.3781011998653412,
-0.8271385431289673,
-0.8658055067062378,
0.685340940952301,
-0.08552934229373932,
-0.007276315242052078,
0.4098103642463684,
0.5333907008171082,
0.1359815150499344,
0.6464030742645264,
0.9451512098312378,
0.1738552451133728,
0.26093578338623047,
-0.3117741644382477,
0.027004707604646683,
-0.5513874888420105,
-0.3740859925746918,
-0.5604824423789978,
-0.24236536026000977,
-0.24711687862873077,
-0.780423104763031,
-0.2373691350221634,
0.07575783133506775,
0.2904506027698517,
0.2245103418827057,
-0.12097246199846268,
0.7681141495704651,
0.3726838231086731,
0.19495519995689392,
0.5472100973129272,
0.2277006059885025,
-0.2567084729671478,
-0.010812513530254364,
-0.9847084283828735,
-0.5406653881072998,
1.2179094552993774,
0.35847604274749756,
1.3027795553207397,
0.08721957355737686,
0.505837619304657,
0.32824572920799255,
-0.09048611670732498,
-0.6818165183067322,
0.5235334634780884,
-0.4093988537788391,
-0.5839332342147827,
0.2179836928844452,
-0.27677997946739197,
-0.5851390957832336,
0.2601190507411957,
-0.20264708995819092,
-0.541588544845581,
0.49353915452957153,
0.2729795575141907,
-0.450548380613327,
0.4920864999294281,
-0.8466235995292664,
0.23012477159500122,
0.07011006027460098,
-0.22646455466747284,
-0.4757789373397827,
-0.17189402878284454,
0.7834477424621582,
-0.07826558500528336,
-0.2912352681159973,
0.005652141757309437,
0.07487384974956512,
0.8503633141517639,
-0.09608644992113113,
0.8061492443084717,
0.29210492968559265,
-0.220567986369133,
0.30104824900627136,
0.4874856472015381,
0.5651923418045044,
0.24952632188796997,
-0.7493389248847961,
0.31630533933639526,
0.20693716406822205,
-0.46581071615219116,
-0.2379751354455948,
0.4898380637168884,
-1.0603581666946411,
-0.6087818145751953,
-0.23042543232440948,
-0.6565465927124023,
-0.1668618768453598,
0.05425242707133293,
0.6204487681388855,
0.40988653898239136,
-0.12448439002037048,
0.01874278485774994,
0.6550456285476685,
0.015974564477801323,
0.4473797678947449,
0.4140195846557617,
0.010397234931588173,
0.1187971979379654,
0.7061833143234253,
0.03750978410243988,
0.3236520290374756,
0.6285800933837891,
-0.2711808383464813,
-0.3668249845504761,
-1.126830816268921,
-0.2891113758087158,
0.24347062408924103,
-0.7142910957336426,
-0.11870738118886948,
-0.7698366045951843,
-0.1611141860485077,
-0.2737217843532562,
-0.2507331967353821,
-0.5180488228797913,
-0.4653981924057007,
-0.46954333782196045,
-0.27923348546028137,
0.39940375089645386,
0.7098985314369202,
0.014765105210244656,
0.46911928057670593,
-0.646298885345459,
0.432954877614975,
-0.2158096432685852,
0.40865832567214966,
0.2801046371459961,
-0.6554880738258362,
-0.09588384628295898,
-0.07917395979166031,
0.05535498633980751,
-0.7168515920639038,
0.2726457118988037,
-0.23396910727024078,
0.5794953107833862,
0.4893108606338501,
0.24551205337047577,
0.7200939655303955,
-0.26218128204345703,
0.5184134840965271,
-0.2556568384170532,
-0.8754397630691528,
0.35272738337516785,
-0.37239983677864075,
0.2915601432323456,
0.3273025155067444,
0.1515892595052719,
-0.09293288737535477,
-0.24985836446285248,
-0.43890371918678284,
-0.6483888030052185,
0.7046619057655334,
-0.08912152796983719,
0.20446136593818665,
-0.06777594983577728,
0.5650020241737366,
0.5104421377182007,
-0.02603260800242424,
-0.19051840901374817,
0.016988467425107956,
-0.15343548357486725,
0.28017687797546387,
-0.10830002278089523,
-0.9082356095314026,
0.1778147965669632,
0.06127092242240906,
0.1544748991727829,
-0.10835303366184235,
0.5051926970481873,
-0.007834896445274353,
0.05893156677484512,
-0.29198798537254333,
0.2271222472190857,
0.5339528918266296,
0.4716448187828064,
-0.4397893249988556,
0.2800191044807434,
0.16592071950435638,
-0.5884454846382141,
0.16425395011901855,
-0.10419084876775742,
-0.22136405110359192,
-0.03191033750772476,
0.5960295796394348,
0.9941405057907104,
0.24336570501327515,
-0.5356334447860718,
-0.0891025960445404,
-0.5020896196365356,
-0.35140460729599,
0.11716269701719284,
0.44349926710128784,
0.07447052747011185,
0.299788236618042,
0.38913118839263916,
0.5717691779136658,
0.3538670539855957,
-0.3333113491535187,
0.022031962871551514,
0.27580681443214417,
0.3998225927352905,
-0.5640364289283752,
0.8099588751792908,
0.26210156083106995,
-0.0889563113451004,
0.7216432690620422,
-0.2037062644958496,
-0.2398165613412857,
0.6366263031959534,
1.0417137145996094,
0.6090697646141052,
0.36087489128112793,
0.18165011703968048,
0.07005215436220169,
0.41062062978744507,
-0.16003434360027313,
0.6083981990814209,
-0.18049196898937225,
-0.6834615468978882,
-0.7512694597244263,
-0.7854481935501099,
-0.41689661145210266,
-0.1887495219707489,
-0.5382139086723328,
-0.14243397116661072,
-0.4491446614265442,
-0.46878349781036377,
-0.3745976388454437,
0.020643340423703194,
-0.7104056477546692,
-0.005621389951556921,
0.06273537874221802,
1.3107730150222778,
-0.5203245878219604,
0.8179581165313721,
0.3742808699607849,
0.31552332639694214,
-0.9845303297042847,
0.13888269662857056,
-0.21463486552238464,
-0.7872653007507324,
0.7072604894638062,
-0.08243757486343384,
-0.3982764184474945,
-0.029411185532808304,
-0.2312251180410385,
-1.1776841878890991,
0.9214088916778564,
0.6418387293815613,
-0.6778362393379211,
-0.26398956775665283,
-0.09039202332496643,
0.3926951587200165,
-0.2601640224456787,
0.4535957872867584,
0.6088536977767944,
0.08712727576494217,
0.3546888530254364,
-0.6587769389152527,
0.2295902669429779,
-0.5441723465919495,
0.16005760431289673,
-0.08645402640104294,
-0.86002516746521,
0.9261515736579895,
-0.6812964081764221,
-0.30802199244499207,
0.2855586111545563,
0.7373080849647522,
0.5006240010261536,
-0.07318136841058731,
0.1330047845840454,
0.3513530492782593,
0.7210763692855835,
-0.07686538249254227,
1.3874326944351196,
-0.3394605219364166,
-0.09102536737918854,
0.46908217668533325,
-0.17384055256843567,
1.2140120267868042,
0.464620441198349,
-0.17577406764030457,
0.3677586615085602,
0.7350276112556458,
0.24299217760562897,
0.5180169939994812,
-0.0789816677570343,
-0.14221088588237762,
-0.5707461833953857,
-0.06847424805164337,
-0.6955375075340271,
0.6035654544830322,
0.5584967136383057,
-0.1312030404806137,
0.050284840166568756,
-0.46605929732322693,
-0.14917980134487152,
-0.3391592800617218,
-0.12553644180297852,
0.3012118339538574,
0.0736614242196083,
-0.6778407692909241,
0.7966470122337341,
0.36089226603507996,
0.9192991256713867,
-0.629019021987915,
0.2293618619441986,
-0.2691241204738617,
0.25548988580703735,
-0.13722510635852814,
-0.5254594683647156,
0.2720591723918915,
-0.16312646865844727,
-0.5013176202774048,
-0.005519933998584747,
0.7987646460533142,
0.1356186717748642,
-0.7624725103378296,
0.3753470182418823,
0.3963659107685089,
0.1557767242193222,
0.20125535130500793,
-0.16797025501728058,
1.0505582094192505,
-0.19051328301429749,
-0.2920588552951813,
0.04577769339084625,
0.460788756608963,
-0.02668934315443039,
0.7098387479782104,
1.057772159576416,
0.3264683485031128,
0.2672116756439209,
0.06503409892320633,
1.066631555557251,
-0.6692843437194824,
-0.8748738169670105,
-0.7649936079978943,
0.19316278398036957,
0.2903117835521698,
-0.3130386173725128,
0.680122971534729,
0.25029122829437256,
0.7045763731002808,
-0.320896178483963,
0.7893972396850586,
0.22715680301189423,
-0.11822843551635742,
-0.9496924877166748,
0.497600257396698,
-0.1723780333995819,
0.44159066677093506,
-0.3337453305721283,
-0.5847156643867493,
-0.009958828799426556,
0.33414217829704285,
-0.14394499361515045,
0.06788288056850433,
0.5485542416572571,
0.8567570447921753,
0.05311531946063042,
0.44475486874580383,
0.3528400659561157,
0.27060991525650024,
0.3371042311191559,
0.8621594905853271,
1.0875425338745117,
-0.5279165506362915,
0.42530298233032227,
-0.19491375982761383,
-0.2059791535139084,
-0.4447992742061615,
-0.8009985089302063,
-1.0150429010391235,
-0.1535370945930481,
0.09280577301979065,
-0.13874857127666473,
0.19809465110301971,
0.3595244884490967,
1.0081770420074463,
-0.4542781114578247,
-0.33959493041038513,
-0.007528554182499647,
-0.053116634488105774,
-0.18746818602085114,
-0.1634180247783661,
0.19382435083389282,
-0.05850442498922348,
-0.4671174883842468,
0.7155972719192505,
0.1268201619386673,
0.19183608889579773,
-0.08479700982570648,
-0.12025010585784912,
0.19628705084323883,
0.34994256496429443,
0.652418315410614,
0.10516060888767242,
-0.8962352275848389,
0.22511595487594604,
0.4467333257198334,
0.07698798924684525,
-0.3422967791557312,
1.0668209791183472,
-0.9942453503608704,
0.22195330262184143,
0.7554685473442078,
0.7502383589744568,
0.719862163066864,
0.11657481640577316,
0.7362840175628662,
-0.1428188681602478,
0.522243320941925,
0.1464122086763382,
0.2825501263141632,
-0.15772181749343872,
-0.7463486194610596,
0.05843424052000046,
0.2769988775253296,
-0.31598755717277527,
-0.845638632774353,
0.05798595771193504,
-1.0696946382522583,
-0.36149290204048157,
1.1022316217422485,
0.15917247533798218,
-0.2269432693719864,
0.012473913840949535,
-0.25239571928977966,
-0.1964815855026245,
-0.6722384095191956,
0.7904431223869324,
0.5806348919868469,
-0.16343079507350922,
-0.10044004023075104,
-0.4789626896381378,
0.3865529000759125,
0.34825825691223145,
-0.5639351010322571,
0.15994052588939667,
0.3066982626914978,
0.014373830519616604,
-0.009579098783433437,
0.8671905994415283,
0.035572297871112823,
0.599012017250061,
0.8037824630737305,
-0.5276919603347778,
-0.24477852880954742,
-0.36785888671875,
0.08079841732978821,
0.4687776267528534,
0.30291473865509033,
0.25336700677871704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01521v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01521v1 | K-Level Reasoning with Large Language Models | 2024-02-02T16:07:05 | 2024-02-02T16:07:05 | Yadong Zhang, Shaoguang Mao, Tao Ge, Xun Wang, Yan Xia, Man Lan, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated their proficiency in
complex reasoning tasks, their performance in dynamic, interactive, and
competitive scenarios - such as business strategy and stock market analysis -
remains underexplored. To bridge this gap, we formally explore the dynamic
reasoning capabilities of LLMs for decision-making in rapidly evolving
environments. We introduce two game theory-based pilot challenges that mirror
the complexities of real-world dynamic decision-making. These challenges are
well-defined, enabling clear, controllable, and precise evaluation of LLMs'
dynamic reasoning abilities. Through extensive experiments, we find that
existing reasoning methods tend to falter in dynamic settings that require
k-level thinking - a key concept not tackled by previous works. To address
this, we propose a novel reasoning approach for LLMs, named "K-Level
Reasoning". This approach adopts the perspective of rivals to recursively
employ k-level thinking based on available historical information, which
significantly improves the prediction accuracy of rivals' subsequent moves and
informs more strategic decision-making. This research not only sets a robust
quantitative benchmark for the assessment of dynamic reasoning but also
markedly enhances the proficiency of LLMs in dynamic contexts. | [
-0.310391366481781,
-0.93741375207901,
1.079388976097107,
0.09572077542543411,
0.08029725402593613,
0.8900464773178101,
-0.3620578944683075,
-0.5330678820610046,
-0.13062961399555206,
0.1816604882478714,
-0.8383817672729492,
-0.4544963836669922,
-0.3850586712360382,
-0.06074734777212143,
-0.011385127902030945,
0.3528617322444916,
-0.24042533338069916,
-0.15768852829933167,
-0.13193896412849426,
-0.06134964898228645,
-0.6967369914054871,
-0.45857787132263184,
-0.7371232509613037,
-0.5046435594558716,
0.5991404056549072,
0.4871155023574829,
0.8368692994117737,
0.470041960477829,
0.38675224781036377,
0.3208142817020416,
-0.4496902525424957,
0.17942118644714355,
-0.6413516402244568,
0.9593074321746826,
-0.33873045444488525,
-0.644437313079834,
-0.15178561210632324,
-0.19147881865501404,
0.7272142767906189,
0.668958306312561,
-0.21692056953907013,
-0.12728002667427063,
-0.373810350894928,
0.6535155177116394,
-0.5000070929527283,
0.45068588852882385,
-0.9280757308006287,
0.26106640696525574,
0.1907253861427307,
-0.11865036189556122,
-0.37921062111854553,
-0.15549661219120026,
0.42430973052978516,
-0.7370799779891968,
-0.45921552181243896,
0.09804968535900116,
0.7364498376846313,
0.20665615797042847,
-0.5475807785987854,
-0.4462159276008606,
-1.0608652830123901,
0.5568066239356995,
-0.5606556534767151,
0.6679220199584961,
-0.06104039400815964,
0.7206482291221619,
-0.4876764714717865,
-0.6067558526992798,
-0.3323039710521698,
-0.5481038093566895,
0.22949519753456116,
0.09472072869539261,
-0.058372121304273605,
-0.18984951078891754,
0.46737930178642273,
0.026743518188595772,
-0.23023442924022675,
0.2701084315776825,
-0.07396015524864197,
0.14652709662914276,
0.7307767271995544,
0.3454076051712036,
0.07501333206892014,
0.11505348235368729,
-0.05098797380924225,
0.003452329197898507,
-0.509217381477356,
0.22303703427314758,
0.19314603507518768,
0.21360735595226288,
0.02767566777765751,
0.2971462607383728,
-0.35895270109176636,
0.3059656322002411,
0.32216694951057434,
-0.26567086577415466,
-0.1258767545223236,
-0.042433906346559525,
-0.10988359898328781,
0.08295568078756332,
0.3180742561817169,
0.3203290104866028,
0.39941519498825073,
-0.3044358193874359,
-0.0990481898188591,
0.010592143051326275,
0.1481950283050537,
-0.5070009231567383,
-0.24239647388458252,
0.36899128556251526,
-0.44271355867385864,
-0.5081608295440674,
-0.40575119853019714,
-1.0634567737579346,
-0.6411217451095581,
-0.26610657572746277,
0.44608309864997864,
-0.2381269335746765,
-0.30323007702827454,
0.2588270604610443,
-0.1755618304014206,
0.30436599254608154,
0.5594243407249451,
-0.6190005540847778,
-0.0033084808383136988,
0.8193063735961914,
0.6311928033828735,
-0.1451282799243927,
-0.20202437043190002,
-0.3208814263343811,
0.4296976923942566,
-0.6051759123802185,
0.7745088338851929,
-0.7805301547050476,
-0.40862607955932617,
0.02129453793168068,
-0.21978767216205597,
0.22932672500610352,
-0.8008159399032593,
0.4653560221195221,
-0.7161109447479248,
0.07225692272186279,
-0.3412341773509979,
-0.5123165845870972,
-0.03266358748078346,
0.7416173815727234,
-0.40772974491119385,
0.9392091035842896,
-0.20481686294078827,
-0.3925457298755646,
0.6716004610061646,
-0.5190299153327942,
-0.5140376091003418,
0.3813207745552063,
-0.34831947088241577,
-0.2584341764450073,
-0.09711738675832748,
0.08720888197422028,
0.2686609625816345,
-0.20963360369205475,
0.2819558084011078,
-0.5497666597366333,
-0.20479610562324524,
0.17695079743862152,
-0.09639547765254974,
0.39887934923171997,
0.1493738293647766,
-0.4598848223686218,
0.04734325781464577,
-0.7430679202079773,
0.21790474653244019,
0.4048328101634979,
-0.5032824277877808,
-0.18119041621685028,
0.4712367355823517,
-0.9778022766113281,
0.24313050508499146,
0.3462706208229065,
-0.17071279883384705,
0.6700668931007385,
-0.19979120790958405,
0.5271577835083008,
0.7261956930160522,
0.0623495876789093,
0.5187223553657532,
-0.2125701904296875,
0.6730964183807373,
-0.14017562568187714,
0.13447022438049316,
-0.1546688973903656,
-0.42341017723083496,
-0.6727795600891113,
-0.09840923547744751,
0.2291833758354187,
0.6803193688392639,
-0.8392786979675293,
0.06455761939287186,
-0.231678307056427,
-0.6881117820739746,
-0.22515377402305603,
-0.3351346552371979,
-0.026953190565109253,
0.12168776988983154,
0.08748319745063782,
0.39784958958625793,
-0.5186420679092407,
-0.6715027689933777,
-0.5370835661888123,
-0.22822564840316772,
0.27357473969459534,
0.5773745775222778,
0.49490875005722046,
-0.10346376895904541,
0.4869737923145294,
-0.6350837349891663,
0.24714778363704681,
-0.4084930419921875,
0.07490144670009613,
0.17598581314086914,
0.2405901551246643,
0.14350207149982452,
-0.6891308426856995,
-0.4393974840641022,
0.23164010047912598,
-0.7629051804542542,
-0.16221877932548523,
-0.5452271699905396,
-0.34243863821029663,
-0.014845977537333965,
0.8908149600028992,
-0.7089452147483826,
0.05374733358621597,
0.15534357726573944,
-0.4801314175128937,
0.7430943846702576,
-0.3767758011817932,
0.1871345043182373,
-0.6584233045578003,
-0.2710895240306854,
-0.008688773028552532,
-0.1086299866437912,
-0.5147331357002258,
0.48339617252349854,
-0.25048521161079407,
-0.050455112010240555,
0.04656120762228966,
0.5514523983001709,
-0.48317623138427734,
-0.13523240387439728,
-0.1557358205318451,
0.2305946797132492,
-0.21736562252044678,
0.4258738160133362,
0.1024959534406662,
0.3399989902973175,
0.5336855053901672,
-0.41961470246315,
0.7602753639221191,
-0.06206287071108818,
-0.8488954901695251,
0.5829773545265198,
-0.3764016032218933,
-0.11174745857715607,
-0.1404821127653122,
0.44805625081062317,
-0.9823298454284668,
-0.0306797306984663,
0.04621081426739693,
-0.44881755113601685,
0.19652993977069855,
-0.2107665240764618,
-0.5934246182441711,
-0.4926941692829132,
0.13295313715934753,
0.36743879318237305,
0.5766959190368652,
-0.29884830117225647,
0.7317904233932495,
0.20602571964263916,
-0.2577163577079773,
-0.323469340801239,
-0.40982285141944885,
0.15276838839054108,
-0.4154755771160126,
-0.35319826006889343,
0.22724398970603943,
-0.1718747764825821,
-0.6284148097038269,
-0.0507771335542202,
-0.34139376878738403,
-0.15101712942123413,
0.26025697588920593,
-0.05268578603863716,
0.17725738883018494,
-0.28037476539611816,
-0.10454045981168747,
0.03697739169001579,
-0.07973102480173111,
0.2577696740627289,
-0.25782889127731323,
0.3627080023288727,
-0.015603220090270042,
-0.2698065936565399,
-0.2674877345561981,
0.3027169704437256,
1.02785325050354,
-0.17716102302074432,
0.5251500606536865,
0.038059744983911514,
-0.4000285863876343,
-0.5753204822540283,
-0.5707365274429321,
0.00111425353679806,
-0.5039224028587341,
0.5434693098068237,
-0.6932039856910706,
-1.0942833423614502,
0.818189799785614,
-0.5245072245597839,
0.05757791921496391,
0.36686980724334717,
0.9954681396484375,
-0.1948946714401245,
1.3259873390197754,
0.10668425261974335,
0.3038384020328522,
0.20177343487739563,
-0.12886305153369904,
0.5204679369926453,
-0.4156583845615387,
-0.8399271368980408,
-0.1755320280790329,
-0.7735353708267212,
-0.4211026430130005,
-0.4930298626422882,
0.4422996938228607,
0.06035713106393814,
-0.7361684441566467,
-0.022068042308092117,
-0.16535867750644684,
0.8452271223068237,
0.4965624213218689,
-0.19224923849105835,
0.30773401260375977,
-0.3767610788345337,
-0.5053688287734985,
-0.01725154183804989,
-0.723976731300354,
-0.22791193425655365,
0.5022697448730469,
0.5565956234931946,
0.6232543587684631,
0.263837993144989,
0.3015420436859131,
0.3101577162742615,
-0.09734245389699936,
-0.879906952381134,
0.7292381525039673,
0.1911497265100479,
-0.6371493339538574,
-0.3448587954044342,
-0.7785151600837708,
-0.8015969395637512,
0.3054142892360687,
-0.5761603713035583,
-0.7328348159790039,
0.20359787344932556,
-0.18860433995723724,
-0.6241574883460999,
0.6219717860221863,
-0.4193401038646698,
0.8025121688842773,
-0.4001622498035431,
-0.26423850655555725,
-0.30086255073547363,
-0.3634064793586731,
0.3094409108161926,
-0.08990547060966492,
0.20471324026584625,
-0.2098129689693451,
-0.12515462934970856,
0.26086580753326416,
-0.18250232934951782,
0.38008224964141846,
-0.06810230761766434,
-0.40229281783103943,
0.256785124540329,
0.7845726013183594,
0.6255412697792053,
-0.05030645802617073,
-0.041018374264240265,
-0.11742519587278366,
0.27836281061172485,
-0.20806114375591278,
-0.8880940675735474,
0.765937864780426,
-0.5253334641456604,
-0.7913441061973572,
-0.4413938820362091,
-0.8899298310279846,
-0.5809537768363953,
0.15849299728870392,
-0.1266653686761856,
0.06008955091238022,
0.0404721200466156,
0.3859173357486725,
0.4979269504547119,
-0.3011966049671173,
-0.017119096592068672,
0.7327214479446411,
-0.2213987410068512,
-0.31821611523628235,
0.6908778548240662,
0.2768627107143402,
0.45194944739341736,
0.4613415002822876,
0.5061798691749573,
-0.3556758463382721,
-0.5620112419128418,
-0.2459932565689087,
0.07528842985630035,
-0.7997696995735168,
0.01259421557188034,
-0.24287258088588715,
-0.1226426213979721,
0.07164723426103592,
-0.42283913493156433,
-0.34081390500068665,
-0.15429919958114624,
0.3360282778739929,
-0.011188413016498089,
-0.14686089754104614,
0.7935972213745117,
0.018230224028229713,
-0.03240858390927315,
-0.528164267539978,
0.15613530576229095,
0.48158326745033264,
0.5645716786384583,
0.5075340867042542,
-0.3878684639930725,
-0.16654552519321442,
-0.02409263327717781,
-0.16010653972625732,
-0.8001863360404968,
0.17959550023078918,
-0.41683468222618103,
0.8640070557594299,
0.2184731513261795,
0.0006166998646222055,
0.5613172054290771,
-0.6649265885353088,
0.7738563418388367,
-0.08307081460952759,
-0.820999026298523,
0.39966416358947754,
-0.6493508219718933,
0.39304789900779724,
0.3502553701400757,
0.3865591585636139,
-0.5173950791358948,
-0.3768167197704315,
-0.6560512185096741,
-0.6169604063034058,
0.5312389135360718,
0.12784343957901,
-0.3595581352710724,
0.023096363991498947,
0.6855378150939941,
-0.15396162867546082,
0.1087535098195076,
-0.4428826868534088,
-0.051912691444158554,
0.4200163781642914,
0.0015886531909927726,
0.24585318565368652,
-0.2822490334510803,
0.15648943185806274,
-0.522496223449707,
0.5794934630393982,
0.161817729473114,
-0.058660704642534256,
-0.12692905962467194,
0.3418751060962677,
-0.25929102301597595,
0.07354479283094406,
0.623368501663208,
0.6993679404258728,
-0.15384279191493988,
0.14901964366436005,
0.5594058036804199,
0.06675433367490768,
0.4046911597251892,
-0.18986080586910248,
-0.027319850400090218,
-0.27204981446266174,
0.3984357416629791,
0.5800617337226868,
0.405239075422287,
-1.0718096494674683,
0.34917423129081726,
0.10118322819471359,
-0.5432541966438293,
-0.1138148233294487,
-0.12054973840713501,
0.40907448530197144,
1.0013365745544434,
0.1993345022201538,
-0.23738478124141693,
-0.32310980558395386,
-0.9117717742919922,
0.02549348585307598,
0.3860040307044983,
-0.034551072865724564,
-0.022084198892116547,
0.6997603178024292,
0.2821913957595825,
-0.3850286602973938,
0.4129851758480072,
-0.4406417906284332,
-0.8919121623039246,
0.7373663783073425,
0.39015647768974304,
0.6031219959259033,
-0.10473860800266266,
0.1975201815366745,
0.2751683294773102,
0.23309454321861267,
-0.1856703758239746,
0.24702467024326324,
-0.01170425396412611,
-0.834693431854248,
-0.6216412782669067,
-0.2346542775630951,
-0.6966538429260254,
0.35305920243263245,
-0.31052061915397644,
0.23529694974422455,
-0.7121699452400208,
0.03739527612924576,
0.09950403869152069,
0.20144152641296387,
-0.23299084603786469,
0.058602217584848404,
0.6384364366531372,
0.8977342844009399,
-0.39353057742118835,
0.36781883239746094,
0.6421403288841248,
-0.1996503323316574,
-0.5472612380981445,
0.20806676149368286,
-0.022297261282801628,
-0.8827526569366455,
1.0223311185836792,
-0.2030918151140213,
-0.17495925724506378,
-0.2719101011753082,
-0.49707773327827454,
-0.9447985887527466,
1.049164056777954,
0.3479239046573639,
-0.7828657627105713,
-0.31937140226364136,
-0.014744086191058159,
0.39091750979423523,
-0.3983856737613678,
-0.09506835043430328,
0.8015691041946411,
0.5323156118392944,
0.584515392780304,
-0.9146353006362915,
-0.18730343878269196,
0.05835580453276634,
-0.38150548934936523,
0.44110107421875,
-0.7691552042961121,
0.7856859564781189,
-0.32534006237983704,
-0.12010467797517776,
0.08697028458118439,
0.5660836100578308,
0.45856785774230957,
0.2954414188861847,
0.7950705289840698,
0.6579980850219727,
0.8424218893051147,
-0.16029900312423706,
0.663817822933197,
-0.2909541726112366,
0.25999680161476135,
1.0256550312042236,
-0.5779372453689575,
0.8811132907867432,
-0.1810261756181717,
-0.20415239036083221,
0.9598267674446106,
0.6017405390739441,
-0.136506587266922,
0.35464438796043396,
0.6376923322677612,
-0.33452656865119934,
-0.8699241876602173,
0.14294074475765228,
-0.10472005605697632,
0.6913307905197144,
0.3687228560447693,
-0.03843047469854355,
-0.28297731280326843,
-0.2869729995727539,
0.3053988814353943,
0.17952638864517212,
-0.4742952585220337,
0.8053179979324341,
-0.10147295147180557,
-0.7295209169387817,
0.33898410201072693,
-0.016611620783805847,
0.47881725430488586,
-0.5396791100502014,
-0.04086407274007797,
-0.02986760064959526,
0.40950527787208557,
0.19503465294837952,
-1.1224242448806763,
0.11871223896741867,
0.06322895735502243,
-0.12300913035869598,
-0.2120303064584732,
0.6180725693702698,
-0.5452101826667786,
-0.46937867999076843,
0.3187655806541443,
0.6762964129447937,
0.0036075005773454905,
-0.020875293761491776,
-0.8222851753234863,
0.3607688248157501,
-0.08788122981786728,
-0.0022941671777516603,
0.31168854236602783,
1.0383220911026,
0.08772342652082443,
1.0025259256362915,
0.4768095016479492,
0.26734763383865356,
-0.18345658481121063,
0.00489119254052639,
0.7264081835746765,
-0.805480420589447,
-0.805527925491333,
-0.9268739819526672,
0.044295381754636765,
-0.22351862490177155,
-0.09048500657081604,
0.4408119320869446,
0.5117459893226624,
0.7345623970031738,
0.23230567574501038,
0.815392017364502,
0.34979233145713806,
0.5123694539070129,
-0.3482593595981598,
0.6042511463165283,
-0.5657896399497986,
0.13798202574253082,
-0.12065578997135162,
-0.6180762648582458,
-0.27146247029304504,
0.7258785367012024,
-0.6080787181854248,
0.07478342950344086,
0.5372324585914612,
0.27778175473213196,
0.09830530732870102,
0.12006175518035889,
0.32052069902420044,
0.626702606678009,
0.6371253728866577,
0.968567430973053,
1.2547935247421265,
0.22272849082946777,
0.6715986728668213,
-0.060843829065561295,
-0.2506476044654846,
-0.15255188941955566,
-1.159501552581787,
-0.8996939659118652,
-0.3645235002040863,
-0.4496917724609375,
-0.4422861337661743,
0.11466079205274582,
0.9292617440223694,
0.515083372592926,
-0.3592473268508911,
-0.3037686347961426,
0.0835748016834259,
0.24966034293174744,
-0.2506971061229706,
-0.22231604158878326,
0.09968502819538116,
-0.3078198730945587,
-0.5129404664039612,
0.5584899187088013,
0.39862677454948425,
-0.09662962704896927,
-0.5115280747413635,
-0.15134617686271667,
-0.3498031198978424,
0.47674545645713806,
0.9209729433059692,
0.29893115162849426,
-0.7751616835594177,
-0.3863500654697418,
-0.1422307789325714,
0.2954460084438324,
-0.11803186684846878,
0.8773475289344788,
-0.7467976212501526,
0.446831613779068,
0.5798143744468689,
0.7645534873008728,
0.2337527722120285,
-0.05900469049811363,
0.5989217162132263,
-0.19526265561580658,
-0.046112097799777985,
0.43888676166534424,
0.2305002510547638,
-0.0007567895809188485,
-0.16712112724781036,
0.19569680094718933,
0.4943341314792633,
-0.6350458860397339,
-0.9390586018562317,
0.46525096893310547,
-0.7526801228523254,
-0.7317188382148743,
1.2961301803588867,
-0.0048167407512664795,
0.0646182969212532,
0.12500952184200287,
-0.2744027376174927,
-0.03354256600141525,
-0.3219185471534729,
0.7867729067802429,
1.1779394149780273,
-0.06628678739070892,
-0.19052624702453613,
-0.6126798391342163,
0.5569852590560913,
0.2902228534221649,
-0.6776087284088135,
0.31550073623657227,
0.4514467120170593,
0.041983187198638916,
0.07460010051727295,
0.2756471037864685,
0.11079329997301102,
0.0688047707080841,
0.17469452321529388,
-0.6243254542350769,
-0.048154838383197784,
-0.5636497139930725,
0.11184840649366379,
0.44087520241737366,
0.05981329828500748,
0.10374892503023148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01513v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01513v1 | Multilingual Gradient Word-Order Typology from Universal Dependencies | 2024-02-02T15:54:19 | 2024-02-02T15:54:19 | Emi Baylor, Esther Ploeger, Johannes Bjerva | cs.CL | cs.CL | While information from the field of linguistic typology has the potential to
improve performance on NLP tasks, reliable typological data is a prerequisite.
Existing typological databases, including WALS and Grambank, suffer from
inconsistencies primarily caused by their categorical format. Furthermore,
typological categorisations by definition differ significantly from the
continuous nature of phenomena, as found in natural language corpora. In this
paper, we introduce a new seed dataset made up of continuous-valued data,
rather than categorical data, that can better reflect the variability of
language. While this initial dataset focuses on word-order typology, we also
present the methodology used to create the dataset, which can be easily adapted
to generate data for a broader set of features and languages. | [
-0.31028124690055847,
-0.33772799372673035,
0.19724741578102112,
0.6671859622001648,
-0.05101502686738968,
0.25347015261650085,
-0.19438038766384125,
-0.6000795960426331,
0.5618701577186584,
0.5590910315513611,
-0.27295824885368347,
-0.6511605978012085,
-0.4218904674053192,
0.0007159604574553668,
-0.3393457531929016,
1.2135555744171143,
0.12145725637674332,
0.014988292939960957,
0.022358110174536705,
-0.647550106048584,
-0.20599818229675293,
-0.9235044717788696,
-0.5396220088005066,
-0.2868475317955017,
0.6042661666870117,
0.31945091485977173,
0.7711825966835022,
0.6867125034332275,
0.2842724323272705,
0.15683041512966156,
-0.1445855051279068,
0.16202983260154724,
-0.3038150370121002,
0.20324401557445526,
-0.26516884565353394,
-0.28783032298088074,
-0.2485244870185852,
0.0694526731967926,
0.4952903091907501,
0.9025846719741821,
-0.4949876070022583,
0.37193813920021057,
0.06457647681236267,
0.8426055908203125,
-0.5447944402694702,
0.3943401277065277,
-0.6436157822608948,
0.2703244686126709,
-0.4447600245475769,
-0.5220306515693665,
-0.1457614153623581,
-0.4109030067920685,
0.2522011399269104,
-0.6454068422317505,
0.5229976177215576,
0.2193581610918045,
0.7007781863212585,
-0.16423892974853516,
-0.055590081959962845,
-0.4272680878639221,
-0.9847097396850586,
0.5970352292060852,
-0.27563902735710144,
0.40960314869880676,
0.35073867440223694,
0.07713688910007477,
-0.09739115089178085,
-0.6179270148277283,
-0.2822686433792114,
-0.12189949303865433,
0.10072575509548187,
0.0405268631875515,
0.20387348532676697,
0.05079087242484093,
0.027977224439382553,
0.502594530582428,
-0.6128055453300476,
0.06283192336559296,
-0.20561321079730988,
-0.13238310813903809,
0.4801672101020813,
0.2771490514278412,
0.31320634484291077,
-0.30250027775764465,
0.06062830984592438,
-0.22990141808986664,
-0.8133880496025085,
0.25271663069725037,
0.49326154589653015,
0.589338481426239,
0.013703104108572006,
0.5214179158210754,
-0.32848885655403137,
0.8097288012504578,
-0.1834639608860016,
-0.3089389204978943,
0.536771297454834,
-0.5737761855125427,
0.049782488495111465,
-0.0049283760599792,
0.5780317783355713,
0.15742997825145721,
0.5814265608787537,
-0.2936995327472687,
-0.042388640344142914,
0.018636712804436684,
0.07422509789466858,
-0.5169045329093933,
-0.24993281066417694,
0.36479490995407104,
-0.2798844277858734,
-0.5146902799606323,
0.14526811242103577,
-1.1573761701583862,
-0.40648141503334045,
-0.4481998682022095,
-0.2357034683227539,
-0.46022653579711914,
-0.20445328950881958,
0.10508351027965546,
-0.10719098895788193,
-0.00011231951793888584,
-0.011035763658583164,
-1.1264808177947998,
0.16355513036251068,
0.5235022902488708,
0.9569388628005981,
-0.03849458321928978,
-0.440064400434494,
-0.3802601993083954,
0.12104517221450806,
-0.4960671663284302,
0.8259803652763367,
-0.8114807605743408,
-0.2944709062576294,
0.27845194935798645,
-0.09040788561105728,
-0.015226120129227638,
-0.5976141691207886,
0.3838787078857422,
-0.4100455045700073,
0.465066134929657,
-0.14471220970153809,
-0.46436795592308044,
-0.19124466180801392,
0.1974494308233261,
-0.5920711755752563,
1.0970474481582642,
0.3628946840763092,
-0.9048412442207336,
0.7002586722373962,
-0.4965609014034271,
-0.3729054927825928,
0.34631940722465515,
-0.4815305471420288,
-0.1488882154226303,
0.04163239523768425,
0.03673063591122627,
0.25088730454444885,
-0.18133078515529633,
0.4510151445865631,
-0.332252562046051,
-0.001924085314385593,
-0.13761866092681885,
-0.21107381582260132,
0.9427382946014404,
-0.14441610872745514,
-0.17347070574760437,
-0.2298373579978943,
-1.4913533926010132,
0.12727715075016022,
-0.08169838041067123,
-0.5380208492279053,
-0.6059980988502502,
0.5409271717071533,
0.16727617383003235,
0.5559154748916626,
0.1554880440235138,
-0.5767845511436462,
0.4681142270565033,
-0.10258931666612625,
0.2378099411725998,
0.6895297765731812,
0.06471338123083115,
0.372271329164505,
-0.22954417765140533,
0.6943601965904236,
-0.13241992890834808,
0.18320104479789734,
0.24691534042358398,
-0.7454119920730591,
-0.7197823524475098,
-0.30317288637161255,
0.4706784784793854,
0.8320709466934204,
-0.7998919486999512,
0.20943541824817657,
-0.5275956988334656,
-0.2578699588775635,
-0.32411274313926697,
0.28248172998428345,
0.3164965808391571,
0.33938273787498474,
0.388065367937088,
-0.14480802416801453,
-0.8179624080657959,
-0.6697226762771606,
0.12722525000572205,
-0.16860848665237427,
-0.3041316568851471,
0.2787201404571533,
0.13467133045196533,
-0.08585495501756668,
0.9592580199241638,
-0.5188794136047363,
-0.28871726989746094,
-0.13644059002399445,
0.5154438614845276,
0.28039029240608215,
0.32922038435935974,
0.6440970301628113,
-0.675896167755127,
-0.37967395782470703,
0.023982886224985123,
-0.6266134977340698,
-0.263287216424942,
0.13854160904884338,
-0.2335798740386963,
0.09734708070755005,
0.4691891670227051,
-0.21123628318309784,
0.09435297548770905,
0.8690309524536133,
-0.5205075740814209,
0.7826183438301086,
-0.20620456337928772,
-0.19569970667362213,
-1.20878267288208,
0.1874576359987259,
-0.04221309721469879,
-0.06555311381816864,
-0.755942165851593,
-0.12417760491371155,
-0.07481113821268082,
0.05389880761504173,
-0.23385095596313477,
0.3270331025123596,
-0.28657570481300354,
0.0217349324375391,
0.1569390892982483,
-0.10987881571054459,
0.13951922953128815,
0.42071276903152466,
0.25522270798683167,
0.7167894840240479,
0.46280160546302795,
-0.741487443447113,
0.36335042119026184,
0.3635670244693756,
-0.6534942984580994,
0.6078814268112183,
-0.522670567035675,
-0.21112060546875,
-0.3209052085876465,
0.030544787645339966,
-0.559745728969574,
-0.33761295676231384,
0.1466360092163086,
-0.24591757357120514,
0.3451288640499115,
-0.2974837124347687,
-0.6939949989318848,
-0.2716282904148102,
-0.24508213996887207,
0.35302671790122986,
0.23642785847187042,
-0.34118080139160156,
0.06677068024873734,
0.2719886004924774,
-0.40214046835899353,
-0.6536690592765808,
-0.43579918146133423,
0.04427819326519966,
-0.1718079000711441,
-0.2647855579853058,
0.35204175114631653,
-0.07441361248493195,
-0.19178612530231476,
-0.07146324217319489,
0.232565239071846,
-0.17693383991718292,
-0.1635647565126419,
0.021845128387212753,
0.24307897686958313,
-0.1353970468044281,
0.5281487703323364,
-0.39667561650276184,
0.23335951566696167,
-0.1926485300064087,
-0.7960543036460876,
0.8008586168289185,
0.11286338418722153,
0.1797744780778885,
0.36646518111228943,
0.48679301142692566,
0.589381754398346,
-0.1813640296459198,
0.9654356241226196,
0.2337331771850586,
-0.21792824566364288,
-0.34707897901535034,
-0.2732519209384918,
0.5602058172225952,
-0.4047991931438446,
0.1598343551158905,
-0.1509774774312973,
-0.6682184338569641,
0.5105472803115845,
0.38676169514656067,
0.2160939872264862,
0.35583844780921936,
0.5246931910514832,
-0.1003253161907196,
0.8005433678627014,
1.011582612991333,
-0.3418321907520294,
0.6624436974525452,
-0.09027211368083954,
-0.172138974070549,
-0.6063262224197388,
-0.42920610308647156,
-0.5748791098594666,
0.05127543956041336,
-0.9802501797676086,
-0.2468082308769226,
0.08167784661054611,
0.13634520769119263,
-0.20725233852863312,
0.28559941053390503,
-0.3727973699569702,
0.19628602266311646,
0.3925819993019104,
-0.11736874282360077,
0.2857920825481415,
0.46735766530036926,
-0.4681123197078705,
-0.04075060784816742,
-0.7995725274085999,
-0.3461950421333313,
1.183993935585022,
-0.11195539683103561,
0.6077696084976196,
0.11059175431728363,
0.3780380189418793,
0.1937638819217682,
0.5084987878799438,
-0.5017516613006592,
0.054680097848176956,
-0.4247113764286041,
-0.6286585927009583,
-0.22522899508476257,
-0.4402003884315491,
-1.1764967441558838,
0.2674780786037445,
-0.25691449642181396,
-1.0545309782028198,
0.5559654831886292,
0.2322375476360321,
-0.1816529482603073,
0.19867375493049622,
-0.47559410333633423,
0.5017788410186768,
-0.12136474996805191,
-0.08261555433273315,
0.3974319398403168,
-0.3822021484375,
0.37848198413848877,
-0.25285911560058594,
0.4681847095489502,
-0.28745517134666443,
0.02553528919816017,
0.7699196934700012,
-0.6864790320396423,
0.5556190609931946,
0.08277218043804169,
-0.313463419675827,
0.20382604002952576,
0.14364412426948547,
0.29086625576019287,
0.14798659086227417,
-0.09867937862873077,
0.10374239087104797,
-0.05083444342017174,
-0.5301969647407532,
-0.48329347372055054,
0.4466854929924011,
-0.6099815368652344,
-0.33760151267051697,
-0.28483274579048157,
-0.7131808996200562,
-0.645850658416748,
0.030216574668884277,
0.6590880751609802,
0.6916765570640564,
-0.10013759136199951,
0.20317259430885315,
0.4855518937110901,
-0.22061441838741302,
0.6018888354301453,
0.4534391462802887,
-0.508253812789917,
-0.46480339765548706,
1.215042233467102,
0.49624043703079224,
0.2469397336244583,
0.5075492858886719,
0.06874897330999374,
-0.1716488003730774,
-0.42115479707717896,
-0.29149317741394043,
0.027569133788347244,
-0.5727127194404602,
-0.13202866911888123,
-0.5761180520057678,
-0.3891026973724365,
-0.16205094754695892,
-0.1121317520737648,
-0.26610085368156433,
-0.5742586851119995,
-0.1437593251466751,
0.004123241174966097,
0.5762321352958679,
0.8442177176475525,
-0.048916663974523544,
0.01442509051412344,
-0.9052179455757141,
0.34997519850730896,
0.25508248805999756,
0.7463036775588989,
-0.30275413393974304,
-0.3761770725250244,
-0.16891071200370789,
-0.04781684651970863,
-0.09630538523197174,
-0.6633117198944092,
0.4855176508426666,
0.5568433403968811,
0.47053098678588867,
0.5174896717071533,
-0.4120164215564728,
0.5081302523612976,
-0.7784568667411804,
0.8117895722389221,
0.25268658995628357,
-0.6837241053581238,
0.40332919359207153,
-0.626458466053009,
0.21449951827526093,
0.6004266738891602,
0.43041637539863586,
-0.9277441501617432,
-0.44698578119277954,
-0.7838366031646729,
-1.0742164850234985,
0.36377790570259094,
0.40084308385849,
-0.16176383197307587,
0.09816700965166092,
0.2525515556335449,
0.3200642466545105,
0.6016135215759277,
-0.7169684171676636,
-0.3863462209701538,
-0.45454180240631104,
-0.27504754066467285,
-0.6155195832252502,
-0.3836824595928192,
-0.08617299795150757,
-0.22753854095935822,
0.33184024691581726,
-0.13561087846755981,
0.026216398924589157,
-0.06171077862381935,
-0.044673092663288116,
0.15637122094631195,
0.26244300603866577,
0.6080647110939026,
1.0143983364105225,
-0.431356281042099,
0.13784651458263397,
-0.33654940128326416,
-0.6533101797103882,
0.4191470146179199,
0.13515116274356842,
-0.4578712284564972,
0.4192359745502472,
0.4331980347633362,
0.4367486834526062,
-0.0040986728854477406,
-0.49273011088371277,
0.20177455246448517,
0.22240561246871948,
-0.22870294749736786,
-0.1395675539970398,
-0.2162126749753952,
0.1131695881485939,
-0.1314893513917923,
0.31088101863861084,
-0.045685119926929474,
0.026810042560100555,
-0.5138000249862671,
0.2840741276741028,
0.20280557870864868,
-0.08703260123729706,
-0.2922983169555664,
0.35026347637176514,
0.033706750720739365,
-0.316447377204895,
0.5681791305541992,
-0.22021248936653137,
-0.39197978377342224,
0.6075685024261475,
0.3857767879962921,
0.6899867653846741,
-0.21869966387748718,
0.6713809967041016,
0.24602924287319183,
0.34657788276672363,
-0.16774743795394897,
0.6674090623855591,
0.13635525107383728,
-0.9384273886680603,
-0.379058301448822,
-0.9289907217025757,
-0.39051952958106995,
0.4749924838542938,
-0.7486153244972229,
0.01867912895977497,
-0.6819661855697632,
-0.05519382655620575,
0.04776778817176819,
-0.3525407910346985,
-0.7690798044204712,
0.23816300928592682,
0.22508874535560608,
0.7777341604232788,
-0.7174144983291626,
0.8536074161529541,
0.7165907621383667,
-0.4031861424446106,
-0.42863038182258606,
0.08273600786924362,
-0.17363813519477844,
-0.7668284773826599,
0.7818599939346313,
0.025949619710445404,
-0.04127945378422737,
-0.19127044081687927,
-0.5808004140853882,
-1.2588014602661133,
0.8504530787467957,
0.06415542960166931,
-0.5701624155044556,
-0.030800897628068924,
0.4104447662830353,
0.8845275640487671,
-0.4942489564418793,
-0.24548055231571198,
0.4463362395763397,
0.23878052830696106,
-0.27170220017433167,
-0.5426430702209473,
-0.25141021609306335,
-0.3828657269477844,
0.5834240913391113,
0.2446516901254654,
-0.5090067386627197,
0.9021994471549988,
0.2939547896385193,
-0.26436617970466614,
-0.2269158959388733,
0.5184616446495056,
0.3497672379016876,
-0.2203437238931656,
0.3227527439594269,
0.4815112352371216,
0.9049450159072876,
-0.15270209312438965,
0.9984118938446045,
-0.7382782101631165,
0.4891335964202881,
1.1658458709716797,
-0.08696866780519485,
0.7886586785316467,
0.4577118158340454,
-0.42450377345085144,
0.8033174276351929,
0.8871120810508728,
-0.13370411098003387,
0.44696319103240967,
0.43195199966430664,
-0.2431003451347351,
0.09660092741250992,
-0.22160089015960693,
-0.3696261942386627,
0.45612743496894836,
0.6762024164199829,
-0.28862830996513367,
-0.2803516685962677,
-0.058823831379413605,
-0.04099421575665474,
-0.23472535610198975,
-0.44684794545173645,
0.35750654339790344,
-0.1174321323633194,
-0.4898960590362549,
0.6921364665031433,
-0.10158465057611465,
0.7606547474861145,
-0.7526707649230957,
0.04570971056818962,
-0.5476885437965393,
-0.14378787577152252,
-0.2240123152732849,
-0.6484646201133728,
0.028137918561697006,
0.028874242678284645,
-0.4426243305206299,
-0.19517838954925537,
0.18938298523426056,
-0.5558418035507202,
-0.8771313428878784,
0.41384318470954895,
0.559391438961029,
-0.08398769795894623,
0.20940160751342773,
-0.4901721179485321,
-0.4531919062137604,
-0.326599657535553,
-0.43092408776283264,
0.23249495029449463,
0.39620479941368103,
-0.08896222710609436,
0.7479005455970764,
0.5122066140174866,
0.3740214705467224,
0.4319987893104553,
0.22021564841270447,
0.5403895378112793,
-0.6548686623573303,
-0.5311964154243469,
-0.5595216155052185,
0.08185373246669769,
-0.1391662210226059,
-0.5335898399353027,
0.5762196183204651,
0.40544506907463074,
0.8431726098060608,
-0.08330775052309036,
1.075187087059021,
-0.3538898825645447,
0.323294997215271,
-0.6156346201896667,
0.33741146326065063,
-0.4465167224407196,
-0.03216099739074707,
-0.26173436641693115,
-1.081764578819275,
-0.4759567975997925,
0.16548943519592285,
0.17067787051200867,
-0.11606616526842117,
0.7678196430206299,
0.5010122060775757,
0.03138197213411331,
-0.07899783551692963,
0.29127487540245056,
-0.012113174423575401,
0.21347802877426147,
0.38591429591178894,
0.5946568846702576,
0.04914631322026253,
0.6227955222129822,
-0.40085843205451965,
-0.2470967173576355,
-0.04879302531480789,
-0.9746708869934082,
-0.5762955546379089,
-0.557275652885437,
0.004818850662559271,
-0.6160804033279419,
0.09821680188179016,
0.9864007830619812,
0.49649691581726074,
-1.1662324666976929,
-0.3044024407863617,
-0.5595989227294922,
0.012295933440327644,
-0.2627486288547516,
-0.3126477301120758,
0.4091101288795471,
-0.5934303998947144,
-0.6594290733337402,
0.17753101885318756,
0.40369072556495667,
0.2862330973148346,
-0.30925652384757996,
0.30130550265312195,
-0.28731778264045715,
0.06540514528751373,
0.7642244696617126,
0.6805866360664368,
-0.40158700942993164,
-0.49575337767601013,
-0.19870798289775848,
-0.15560923516750336,
0.426329642534256,
1.0669689178466797,
-0.49011456966400146,
0.41743186116218567,
0.4140647351741791,
0.43826407194137573,
0.026715217158198357,
-0.17710189521312714,
0.7525783181190491,
-1.0753434896469116,
0.4881543219089508,
0.040015775710344315,
0.47873008251190186,
0.31002530455589294,
-0.3413632810115814,
0.4906211197376251,
0.6765132546424866,
-0.17564204335212708,
-0.2963230609893799,
0.5181418061256409,
-0.7391049861907959,
-0.23835155367851257,
1.5049344301223755,
-0.12509924173355103,
0.10196001827716827,
-0.4847218096256256,
0.04534732550382614,
0.056805264204740524,
-0.21278344094753265,
0.9551751017570496,
1.106207013130188,
-0.07340730726718903,
0.03818313777446747,
-0.5070577263832092,
0.8449013829231262,
0.26790571212768555,
-0.8731101751327515,
-0.02938864193856716,
0.43621188402175903,
0.3816300332546234,
0.44596606492996216,
0.7085697650909424,
-0.07253721356391907,
-0.12903819978237152,
0.1409250795841217,
0.26799476146698,
0.28089702129364014,
-0.5433383584022522,
-0.19220468401908875,
0.6250496506690979,
-0.09644478559494019,
-0.21819663047790527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01512v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01512v1 | Distractor Generation for Multiple-Choice Questions: A Survey of Methods, Datasets, and Evaluation | 2024-02-02T15:53:31 | 2024-02-02T15:53:31 | Elaf Alhazmi, Quan Z. Sheng, Wei Emma Zhang, Munazza Zaib, Ahoud Alhazmi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Distractors are important in learning evaluation. This paper surveys
distractor generation tasks using English multiple-choice question datasets for
textual and multimodal contexts. In particular, this paper presents a thorough
literature review of the recent studies on distractor generation tasks,
discusses multiple choice components and their characteristics, analyzes the
related datasets, and summarizes the evaluation metrics of distractor
generation. Our investigation reveals that more than half of datasets are
human-generated from educational sources in specific domains such as Science
and English, which are largely text-based, with a lack of open domain and
multimodal datasets. | [
-0.7703685164451599,
-0.7168221473693848,
0.45513349771499634,
-0.1292419284582138,
-0.03516733646392822,
-0.14830541610717773,
-0.13464875519275665,
-0.3069055676460266,
-0.07566045224666595,
0.43747174739837646,
-0.7234614491462708,
0.09863493591547012,
-0.343266099691391,
0.3186325430870056,
-0.19878169894218445,
1.1550037860870361,
-0.08466596156358719,
0.17752030491828918,
-0.5556753277778625,
0.08194897323846817,
-0.7920852303504944,
-0.3458641469478607,
-0.7368674278259277,
0.013084189966320992,
0.8208873271942139,
0.5295313000679016,
0.17070049047470093,
0.24051225185394287,
0.4791068434715271,
0.306624174118042,
0.22077013552188873,
0.3213039040565491,
-0.2398088127374649,
0.4670811593532562,
-0.272765189409256,
-0.16959910094738007,
0.46117445826530457,
-0.008177471347153187,
0.5293478965759277,
0.47768092155456543,
0.21491274237632751,
0.3598906099796295,
0.17812776565551758,
0.5239173769950867,
-1.0978809595108032,
-0.31894370913505554,
-0.3616410195827484,
0.10772677510976791,
-0.36914244294166565,
-0.2942296862602234,
-0.3854832053184509,
-0.4826732873916626,
0.32542696595191956,
-0.39017254114151,
0.5140860676765442,
0.009515028446912766,
0.5999709963798523,
0.38456428050994873,
-0.8647750020027161,
-0.8308794498443604,
-0.7742953896522522,
1.3412327766418457,
0.27678170800209045,
0.25430458784103394,
0.4784437417984009,
0.4001688063144684,
0.1340147703886032,
-0.5978435277938843,
-0.1755576878786087,
-0.20478682219982147,
-0.08184702694416046,
0.5510044097900391,
0.24734562635421753,
-0.5275252461433411,
0.13685430586338043,
0.16101840138435364,
-0.4493131637573242,
-0.18652455508708954,
-0.7359032034873962,
-0.0881713479757309,
0.8337845802307129,
0.37544336915016174,
0.2579248249530792,
-0.6472135186195374,
-0.4448581635951996,
-0.07045802474021912,
-0.3090905249118805,
-0.2546350955963135,
0.450221449136734,
-0.027852704748511314,
0.3414972722530365,
0.5856245756149292,
0.0944129005074501,
0.9118047952651978,
0.07346521317958832,
-0.3323060870170593,
0.1397349089384079,
-0.8567531108856201,
0.3906917870044708,
-0.25044798851013184,
0.7216893434524536,
0.32433661818504333,
0.16344274580478668,
0.1554492712020874,
0.02431720495223999,
0.027652671560645103,
0.5057170987129211,
-0.6209671497344971,
-0.18852469325065613,
0.45548659563064575,
-0.3099519908428192,
-0.3870297074317932,
-0.0005489199538715184,
-0.984592616558075,
-0.06076750159263611,
-0.23896458745002747,
0.13762064278125763,
-0.5160757303237915,
0.033678460866212845,
-0.13501429557800293,
-0.3137695789337158,
0.08948187530040741,
0.1395299881696701,
-0.738332986831665,
-0.04510650038719177,
-0.023390356451272964,
0.3057516813278198,
-0.5388175249099731,
-0.5696532726287842,
-0.24671955406665802,
-0.0827426090836525,
-0.20361867547035217,
1.018894910812378,
-0.4281161427497864,
-0.49103060364723206,
0.08756059408187866,
-0.22347751259803772,
-0.434763103723526,
-0.6179966330528259,
0.6192809343338013,
-0.35936644673347473,
1.1398450136184692,
-0.2359204739332199,
-0.4242534041404724,
-0.32097041606903076,
0.2454538643360138,
-0.8556722402572632,
1.3070192337036133,
0.05081653222441673,
-0.8047105669975281,
0.8476698994636536,
-0.8338468074798584,
-0.4282451570034027,
0.1682889610528946,
-0.25979694724082947,
-0.3760218322277069,
-0.2250816375017166,
0.2919231057167053,
0.440616250038147,
-0.19595913589000702,
0.3224550187587738,
0.29186317324638367,
-0.03773726522922516,
0.6538144946098328,
-0.5347910523414612,
0.8211149573326111,
0.47999873757362366,
-0.22305357456207275,
-0.03280589357018471,
-0.7240745425224304,
0.12948215007781982,
0.14647693932056427,
-0.5009586215019226,
-0.4276157319545746,
0.47487249970436096,
0.5462196469306946,
0.9039669036865234,
0.05871683731675148,
-0.486844927072525,
-0.553179919719696,
0.4464580714702606,
-0.1466999351978302,
0.5605183243751526,
0.6249585151672363,
-0.23453845083713531,
-0.7084131836891174,
0.6543118357658386,
0.1356286108493805,
-0.0011137935798615217,
-0.30811256170272827,
-0.44786378741264343,
-0.5551754236221313,
-0.4160313904285431,
0.0055036889389157295,
0.35293713212013245,
-0.7966971397399902,
0.40263834595680237,
0.15777301788330078,
-0.516716480255127,
-0.2521504759788513,
0.013338703662157059,
0.437074214220047,
0.409246563911438,
0.33588290214538574,
0.22094789147377014,
-0.606514573097229,
-0.7269213795661926,
-0.03733621910214424,
0.3218138813972473,
-0.16476351022720337,
0.5581247210502625,
0.8431385159492493,
0.24027372896671295,
0.8620944619178772,
-0.8262871503829956,
0.0006821657298132777,
-0.17574624717235565,
-0.07922634482383728,
-0.5748605728149414,
0.5719838738441467,
0.5750676989555359,
-1.0839067697525024,
-0.43609628081321716,
-0.46538111567497253,
-0.7042351365089417,
0.12621290981769562,
-0.3336027264595032,
-0.18659214675426483,
0.00656478013843298,
0.2675500512123108,
-0.20133870840072632,
-0.10583611577749252,
0.06749323755502701,
-0.289094477891922,
0.9082959890365601,
0.3516536355018616,
0.3168589472770691,
-1.331857442855835,
0.3191732168197632,
-0.04363635927438736,
0.15578842163085938,
-0.7054815888404846,
-0.08970002084970474,
-0.07679369300603867,
-0.0907304659485817,
-0.9082044363021851,
0.6755996942520142,
-0.4109659790992737,
0.3302707374095917,
-0.011167353950440884,
0.47121092677116394,
0.10979118943214417,
0.020476296544075012,
0.10983610153198242,
0.7307476997375488,
0.4450387954711914,
-0.7733069062232971,
0.2708623707294464,
0.5745537281036377,
-0.36796602606773376,
0.8129976391792297,
-0.29934751987457275,
0.043949536979198456,
-0.3579620122909546,
-0.1032988652586937,
-1.1561799049377441,
-0.6915387511253357,
0.2295665740966797,
-0.13739719986915588,
-0.09906601160764694,
0.4936656057834625,
-0.06007428467273712,
-0.7247896194458008,
-0.5863539576530457,
0.22585612535476685,
0.20647846162319183,
-0.643348217010498,
-0.030853942036628723,
0.19908159971237183,
-0.35432082414627075,
-0.8605183959007263,
-0.46066340804100037,
-0.39067211747169495,
-0.4153299629688263,
-0.22174116969108582,
-0.02531052567064762,
-0.5825002193450928,
-0.36288437247276306,
-0.14326900243759155,
-0.03879542276263237,
-0.14707648754119873,
0.01680143177509308,
0.1513051986694336,
0.43701788783073425,
0.13557857275009155,
0.23535525798797607,
-0.0950847864151001,
0.17276239395141602,
0.22290582954883575,
0.2158586084842682,
0.3476216495037079,
0.4515175521373749,
-0.5435802340507507,
0.15615685284137726,
0.47944730520248413,
0.18892399966716766,
-0.10032493621110916,
0.20934198796749115,
0.3782716691493988,
-0.2792082130908966,
-0.2900426387786865,
-0.660146176815033,
-0.19930413365364075,
-0.3910506069660187,
0.5734866857528687,
-0.4028443992137909,
-0.7284069061279297,
0.20903776586055756,
0.1553759127855301,
0.2077631801366806,
0.531721830368042,
0.7100095748901367,
0.10836680233478546,
0.9604619741439819,
-0.039429694414138794,
0.2655552625656128,
0.6478163599967957,
0.01442573219537735,
-0.36135637760162354,
-0.612512469291687,
-0.44885680079460144,
-0.5629181265830994,
-0.3170737326145172,
-0.3395836353302002,
-0.25098976492881775,
-0.005367008037865162,
-0.3243788480758667,
0.10042593628168106,
-0.016617421060800552,
-0.801317036151886,
0.6785208582878113,
0.6005632877349854,
-0.0714348778128624,
-0.04766206815838814,
-0.0022164788097143173,
-0.1492597609758377,
-0.15211085975170135,
-0.4441331923007965,
-0.5933590531349182,
1.4477016925811768,
-0.2587277889251709,
0.4204178750514984,
-0.1220531091094017,
0.8178149461746216,
0.05884339287877083,
0.2702619135379791,
-0.8975670337677002,
0.5169125199317932,
0.09211375564336777,
-1.1442922353744507,
-0.3778042495250702,
-0.2367297261953354,
-1.2704483270645142,
0.5449821949005127,
-0.07683239877223969,
-0.47157707810401917,
0.2183801680803299,
-0.2951844334602356,
-0.3568463623523712,
-0.16473650932312012,
-0.6307794451713562,
0.6735713481903076,
-0.4235748052597046,
-0.5195840001106262,
0.1045156866312027,
-0.4936107397079468,
0.6749547719955444,
-0.42783889174461365,
-0.06340775638818741,
0.06704139709472656,
0.11898288875818253,
1.1005256175994873,
0.15293215215206146,
0.44672831892967224,
-0.17802007496356964,
0.12034181505441666,
0.8776606321334839,
-0.19539840519428253,
-0.20039798319339752,
-0.014751899987459183,
-0.18197986483573914,
-0.40219271183013916,
-0.12762995064258575,
-0.28924795985221863,
-0.0828271433711052,
0.4996524751186371,
-0.7478639483451843,
-0.1490245759487152,
-0.3891697824001312,
-0.7709293365478516,
-0.08298954367637634,
0.24455741047859192,
0.5360196232795715,
0.41300374269485474,
-0.41946181654930115,
0.11089396476745605,
0.345557302236557,
0.003924054559320211,
0.7862274050712585,
0.2636360824108124,
-0.048819057643413544,
-0.5392136573791504,
1.1488468647003174,
0.5184823870658875,
0.10076192766427994,
0.07539715617895126,
-0.001490493305027485,
-0.3460266888141632,
-0.26439163088798523,
-0.3826649487018585,
0.10663765668869019,
-0.5780012011528015,
-0.1457791030406952,
-0.44512879848480225,
-0.3247351050376892,
0.026018377393484116,
-0.38707366585731506,
-0.0014124289155006409,
-0.35770827531814575,
-0.3964950144290924,
-0.3716794550418854,
-0.12834280729293823,
1.0722335577011108,
0.09566469490528107,
0.1630263477563858,
-0.39989474415779114,
0.28369203209877014,
0.5847300291061401,
-0.04555381461977959,
-0.257174015045166,
0.10627898573875427,
-0.3691565990447998,
-0.22095496952533722,
-0.8271381258964539,
-0.889247477054596,
0.12669305503368378,
0.09536426514387131,
0.656205415725708,
0.5423458218574524,
-0.02152945101261139,
0.25413092970848083,
-0.3395262658596039,
1.1577354669570923,
0.00368052558042109,
-0.4806031286716461,
0.6900765895843506,
-0.1487910896539688,
0.25503644347190857,
0.6003811359405518,
0.6940799951553345,
-0.32108333706855774,
-0.33806777000427246,
-0.6812856197357178,
-0.6872837543487549,
0.869388997554779,
0.11775585263967514,
-0.15194568037986755,
-0.3991181552410126,
0.03512541949748993,
0.4954613149166107,
0.24315719306468964,
-0.6469441056251526,
-0.38769999146461487,
-0.3479795753955841,
-0.13226807117462158,
-0.13414207100868225,
-0.28840646147727966,
-0.2671089768409729,
0.17337189614772797,
0.5246073007583618,
-0.04279138892889023,
0.021207600831985474,
0.03798380121588707,
-0.19605295360088348,
-0.060264166444540024,
0.6162421107292175,
0.7621400356292725,
0.7642988562583923,
-0.2336433082818985,
0.08347351104021072,
0.15244810283184052,
-0.7270681262016296,
0.40967392921447754,
0.11307738721370697,
-0.4335368275642395,
0.1411028355360031,
-0.06243694946169853,
0.3826751708984375,
0.03641347587108612,
-0.7772294878959656,
0.35145825147628784,
0.04381267726421356,
-0.4907020628452301,
-0.37424927949905396,
0.06705174595117569,
-0.243613600730896,
-0.3192818760871887,
0.5102443695068359,
0.2661453187465668,
0.26085129380226135,
0.026629522442817688,
0.4475834369659424,
0.2213927060365677,
-0.3294532299041748,
-0.29035231471061707,
0.6994763016700745,
0.23248045146465302,
0.018043767660856247,
0.41192626953125,
-0.06740623712539673,
-0.032587554305791855,
0.6117323040962219,
0.7182432413101196,
0.8433184623718262,
-0.563443660736084,
0.4223780333995819,
0.6445759534835815,
0.16327042877674103,
0.22141459584236145,
0.7429935932159424,
0.004270393401384354,
-0.723609447479248,
-0.2531377673149109,
-0.29441800713539124,
-0.49226298928260803,
0.5282968878746033,
-0.722438633441925,
0.14952637255191803,
-0.10779879242181778,
-0.2812598943710327,
0.28465867042541504,
-0.12814661860466003,
-0.8299030661582947,
0.6036388278007507,
0.10915880650281906,
0.45575177669525146,
-0.8728647828102112,
0.1523897796869278,
1.058051347732544,
-0.712674081325531,
-0.39391759037971497,
0.019730499014258385,
0.04422258213162422,
-0.1293771117925644,
0.8197522163391113,
0.18807080388069153,
-0.006272037513554096,
-0.19956927001476288,
-0.3564101755619049,
-0.9595807790756226,
0.8304218053817749,
-0.1298614889383316,
0.0007515267352573574,
-0.10695946961641312,
0.17389963567256927,
0.3065268397331238,
-0.17416790127754211,
0.6494390368461609,
0.34729671478271484,
0.5295100212097168,
-0.26002830266952515,
-0.19587892293930054,
-0.01858600415289402,
-0.30846506357192993,
-0.018542755395174026,
0.1259075105190277,
-0.7315626740455627,
0.8814241290092468,
-0.033095017075538635,
-0.2801385521888733,
-0.20256926119327545,
0.15504324436187744,
0.457079142332077,
0.03643208369612694,
0.33058962225914,
0.05878908932209015,
0.5570254921913147,
-0.11072606593370438,
0.8231639266014099,
-0.38816991448402405,
0.21867573261260986,
1.046701431274414,
-0.47779202461242676,
0.6920995116233826,
0.7393586039543152,
-0.06829552352428436,
0.3550315201282501,
0.6324747800827026,
-0.25613924860954285,
0.2921288013458252,
0.3968506157398224,
-0.32901567220687866,
-0.0843886286020279,
-0.27821069955825806,
-0.17856112122535706,
0.7873159646987915,
0.42246225476264954,
-0.37649378180503845,
-0.26040685176849365,
0.3668968081474304,
-0.05181710422039032,
-0.1648511290550232,
0.05073539912700653,
0.7852607369422913,
-0.3929153382778168,
-1.1009098291397095,
0.3004946708679199,
-0.36444997787475586,
0.5643115043640137,
-0.7408255338668823,
0.16278915107250214,
-0.0368560366332531,
0.03138461709022522,
-0.19193127751350403,
-0.7488030195236206,
0.18478739261627197,
-0.040791962295770645,
-0.3421509265899658,
-0.28193989396095276,
0.9763163328170776,
-0.4976661205291748,
-0.34332776069641113,
0.05865471437573433,
1.0154777765274048,
0.34980615973472595,
0.27333369851112366,
-0.509434700012207,
-0.5343518257141113,
0.11451053619384766,
-0.7413793802261353,
0.1649150252342224,
0.1467437744140625,
-0.047858405858278275,
0.5376982688903809,
0.49638932943344116,
-0.062467023730278015,
0.4026135206222534,
0.17727400362491608,
0.4967404305934906,
-0.6113620400428772,
-0.18154704570770264,
-0.4079115092754364,
0.8460382223129272,
-0.135505810379982,
-0.8374860286712646,
1.1241559982299805,
1.0373834371566772,
0.994648277759552,
-0.561657726764679,
1.1954326629638672,
-0.22736890614032745,
0.7614166140556335,
-0.1399950534105301,
0.5830422043800354,
-0.37644490599632263,
-0.47772321105003357,
-0.28792238235473633,
-0.8246800303459167,
-0.10274339467287064,
0.2742166817188263,
-0.35580265522003174,
0.4296098053455353,
1.1171993017196655,
0.4135599434375763,
0.025838876143097878,
0.09564347565174103,
0.42290568351745605,
-0.5999385714530945,
-0.09070122241973877,
0.24573539197444916,
1.3995392322540283,
-0.5725134611129761,
0.8031938672065735,
-0.3372541666030884,
0.04145849496126175,
-0.099403016269207,
-0.3214547634124756,
-0.9669868350028992,
-0.8781013488769531,
-0.4781786799430847,
0.06245360150933266,
-0.1285620927810669,
0.6226834654808044,
0.541038990020752,
-0.9458156228065491,
-0.3050524592399597,
0.2322779893875122,
0.22145164012908936,
-0.36157646775245667,
-0.3424559235572815,
0.3943098783493042,
-0.7183511257171631,
-1.0551410913467407,
0.37747129797935486,
-0.2706041932106018,
0.0424903929233551,
-0.21562620997428894,
0.2702956795692444,
-0.677030086517334,
0.1638585329055786,
0.7300965785980225,
-0.030672408640384674,
-0.5249226093292236,
-0.45682209730148315,
0.17772038280963898,
-0.15443338453769684,
-0.0384545624256134,
0.8624395132064819,
-0.6597852110862732,
0.5612432360649109,
0.4665987491607666,
0.2573406398296356,
0.300377756357193,
0.1360638290643692,
0.052619121968746185,
-1.192720890045166,
-0.168456569314003,
0.3187824785709381,
0.320374995470047,
0.32823413610458374,
-0.2682039737701416,
0.5577816367149353,
0.11539103835821152,
-0.7823678851127625,
-0.5675398111343384,
0.2531948387622833,
-0.45899462699890137,
-0.22024554014205933,
1.0240883827209473,
0.2665972113609314,
0.0752343013882637,
-0.5322373509407043,
-0.6548963189125061,
0.10915378481149673,
-0.22662614285945892,
0.6168393492698669,
1.0108894109725952,
-0.4256116449832916,
0.09125939756631851,
-0.6231374740600586,
0.577086329460144,
0.5765717625617981,
-1.1758373975753784,
-0.12413813918828964,
1.0645558834075928,
0.3405700623989105,
0.7113747000694275,
0.40696150064468384,
-0.07901448011398315,
0.3891074061393738,
0.4343871474266052,
0.3458874225616455,
0.08992046862840652,
-0.4790841042995453,
-0.06624092906713486,
0.5202019214630127,
-0.23422729969024658,
-0.5617432594299316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01510v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01510v1 | A Hybrid Strategy for Chat Transcript Summarization | 2024-02-02T15:44:28 | 2024-02-02T15:44:28 | Pratik K. Biswas | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68, I.7 | Text summarization is the process of condensing a piece of text to fewer
sentences, while still preserving its content. Chat transcript, in this
context, is a textual copy of a digital or online conversation between a
customer (caller) and agent(s). This paper presents an indigenously (locally)
developed hybrid method that first combines extractive and abstractive
summarization techniques in compressing ill-punctuated or un-punctuated chat
transcripts to produce more readable punctuated summaries and then optimizes
the overall quality of summarization through reinforcement learning. Extensive
testing, evaluations, comparisons, and validation have demonstrated the
efficacy of this approach for large-scale deployment of chat transcript
summarization, in the absence of manually generated reference (annotated)
summaries. | [
-0.1622387021780014,
-0.8699992895126343,
-0.01519191823899746,
0.33769309520721436,
-0.5076327919960022,
0.7838403582572937,
-0.1985139399766922,
-0.32765039801597595,
0.8257222771644592,
0.4630780518054962,
-0.48745909333229065,
-0.3852585554122925,
-0.12681050598621368,
0.21265631914138794,
-0.2882663309574127,
1.5789101123809814,
0.2090463489294052,
-0.18811669945716858,
-0.2971283197402954,
-0.03140851482748985,
-0.7374008297920227,
-0.7230870127677917,
-0.5233234167098999,
-0.3311384320259094,
0.16308529675006866,
0.5370058417320251,
0.7165870070457458,
0.2996678948402405,
0.3471875488758087,
0.36003243923187256,
-0.25294700264930725,
0.657242476940155,
-0.7533403038978577,
0.18627327680587769,
0.19306617975234985,
-0.6145331263542175,
-0.2346908152103424,
0.00820862129330635,
0.5189892053604126,
0.5661460757255554,
-0.3626290559768677,
0.03185302019119263,
0.04516768828034401,
0.4517187774181366,
-0.6796660423278809,
0.11077318340539932,
-0.3658231794834137,
0.23706397414207458,
0.15026737749576569,
-0.742081880569458,
-0.4930468797683716,
-0.5906291604042053,
0.16617432236671448,
-0.6023401618003845,
-0.05144772678613663,
0.20862193405628204,
0.521643877029419,
0.045794401317834854,
-0.4012203514575958,
-0.09046880900859833,
-1.1835359334945679,
0.8963544964790344,
-0.7861020565032959,
-0.24778173863887787,
0.2239198088645935,
0.5247169137001038,
-0.024852735921740532,
-0.7724561095237732,
-0.4199521839618683,
0.06258045881986618,
-0.5420342087745667,
0.5322008728981018,
0.03902788087725639,
0.1476496160030365,
-0.045667096972465515,
0.8133611679077148,
-0.35550954937934875,
0.042109325528144836,
-0.8595606088638306,
-0.48978233337402344,
0.8659310936927795,
0.5109896063804626,
0.47543641924858093,
-0.06372726708650589,
-0.5296642780303955,
-0.10360464453697205,
-0.2607960104942322,
0.20638838410377502,
0.28661414980888367,
0.2297576516866684,
-0.4062883257865906,
0.47896048426628113,
-0.35311558842658997,
0.2920190989971161,
-0.14254716038703918,
-0.6542608141899109,
0.31009334325790405,
-0.5763139128684998,
-0.1695525199174881,
0.33493539690971375,
0.9376283288002014,
0.6256033182144165,
0.10023412853479385,
-0.12764349579811096,
-0.06839266419410706,
0.027079718187451363,
-0.06353897601366043,
-0.45193615555763245,
-0.311562180519104,
0.3416603207588196,
-0.7189412713050842,
-0.4840923249721527,
0.06737736612558365,
-0.9179914593696594,
-0.0753621980547905,
-0.38898971676826477,
0.2149447500705719,
-0.6836752891540527,
-0.159234419465065,
-0.1029263436794281,
-0.5742316246032715,
0.19991417229175568,
0.33719319105148315,
-0.884705126285553,
0.6774669885635376,
0.49492186307907104,
1.2006665468215942,
-0.3904690742492676,
-0.26508456468582153,
-0.6487854719161987,
0.03918987885117531,
-0.15031391382217407,
0.9025062918663025,
-0.18803752958774567,
-0.7600875496864319,
-0.051311932504177094,
-0.47913265228271484,
-0.12938638031482697,
-0.6241947412490845,
0.36602240800857544,
-0.36931511759757996,
0.6145983338356018,
0.366770476102829,
-0.6688503623008728,
-0.40885040163993835,
0.1447698324918747,
-0.4020415246486664,
1.024593472480774,
0.07551909983158112,
-0.6164947152137756,
0.009661300107836723,
-0.5193060040473938,
-0.6668124794960022,
0.09713242202997208,
-0.025351347401738167,
-0.4718843698501587,
-0.06093480437994003,
0.3785085380077362,
0.31073904037475586,
0.2832142412662506,
-0.1370263397693634,
0.1886785477399826,
-0.4403586685657501,
0.3551816940307617,
-0.05480240285396576,
0.6138429045677185,
0.27311334013938904,
0.033180221915245056,
0.2869531512260437,
-0.6503503918647766,
-0.09876441210508347,
0.09695970267057419,
-0.256075382232666,
-0.44050833582878113,
-0.05527603626251221,
-0.08612129092216492,
0.20460696518421173,
0.057266030460596085,
-0.23520499467849731,
0.09644526988267899,
-0.6288153529167175,
0.30231818556785583,
0.39240267872810364,
0.5885319113731384,
0.4645428955554962,
-1.011964201927185,
0.5876953601837158,
0.0662064328789711,
0.19850631058216095,
-1.0165150165557861,
-0.24361146986484528,
-0.6621831655502319,
-0.5762901902198792,
0.22148600220680237,
0.84572434425354,
-0.9079743027687073,
0.6376984715461731,
-0.2114102989435196,
-0.6346135139465332,
-0.3054216802120209,
0.19125141203403473,
0.5131087303161621,
0.276218056678772,
0.2711234986782074,
-0.4314855635166168,
-0.684495210647583,
-0.7197632789611816,
-0.14526483416557312,
-0.23832465708255768,
0.1401277780532837,
-0.07690142095088959,
0.40495654940605164,
0.2850118577480316,
1.0332406759262085,
-0.48810499906539917,
-0.552057683467865,
-0.7719695568084717,
0.5914283990859985,
0.03589855134487152,
0.5068708062171936,
0.3963501751422882,
-0.7929956912994385,
-0.5065684914588928,
-0.14868491888046265,
-0.6280109882354736,
0.05281704291701317,
-0.5927200317382812,
-0.18336443603038788,
0.1311110258102417,
0.6479262709617615,
-0.4004749059677124,
0.5352465510368347,
0.41879358887672424,
-0.07047479599714279,
0.700022280216217,
-0.3100205659866333,
0.23283761739730835,
-1.0406626462936401,
-0.20835046470165253,
-0.3625945746898651,
-0.6290609240531921,
-0.49674704670906067,
-0.12017540633678436,
-0.32356539368629456,
-0.1285048872232437,
-0.6104885935783386,
0.025560062378644943,
-0.4457553029060364,
-0.12266163527965546,
-0.3212115168571472,
0.13791173696517944,
-0.038119759410619736,
0.8250831961631775,
0.1478220373392105,
0.8312740325927734,
0.057822491973638535,
-0.8117280602455139,
0.5707745552062988,
0.6662022471427917,
-0.1536014974117279,
0.34716668725013733,
-0.6777207851409912,
0.0348719097673893,
-0.17079325020313263,
0.6187232732772827,
-0.938229501247406,
-0.08507860451936722,
0.15175417065620422,
-0.47900161147117615,
0.016694439575076103,
0.1308542639017105,
-0.550388753414154,
0.014811526983976364,
-0.6110736727714539,
0.43127644062042236,
0.9170678853988647,
-0.2632189989089966,
0.866461992263794,
0.327808678150177,
-0.45476609468460083,
-0.10379908233880997,
-0.4446207880973816,
0.10464437305927277,
-0.2643339931964874,
-0.37720614671707153,
0.5102306008338928,
0.14146345853805542,
-0.2698853611946106,
-0.16338986158370972,
0.28922292590141296,
0.25702738761901855,
0.07716690003871918,
0.09653210639953613,
0.5125889182090759,
-0.029273878782987595,
-0.07369562983512878,
-0.018323956057429314,
-0.1682932823896408,
-0.13609378039836884,
-0.00846277829259634,
0.7428348660469055,
0.22084574401378632,
0.047583796083927155,
-0.6673285961151123,
0.7784451842308044,
0.40244293212890625,
-0.16092243790626526,
0.8837064504623413,
0.3677315413951874,
-0.05784974992275238,
-0.2304273545742035,
-0.38982734084129333,
-0.26177719235420227,
-0.40679797530174255,
0.09200917929410934,
0.04524693265557289,
-0.7119429707527161,
0.67223060131073,
-0.3300236761569977,
0.3984140157699585,
0.30335789918899536,
0.4688725769519806,
-0.26726362109184265,
0.7990589141845703,
0.7197215557098389,
-0.20503096282482147,
0.6011271476745605,
-0.18629398941993713,
0.25063204765319824,
-0.48541584610939026,
-0.42276352643966675,
-0.26292306184768677,
-0.3260337710380554,
-0.2852482497692108,
-0.1911509484052658,
0.5366535782814026,
0.030640924349427223,
0.2700596749782562,
0.24256974458694458,
-0.36636054515838623,
0.7236728668212891,
0.8222656846046448,
0.31203797459602356,
0.7998154163360596,
-0.17980170249938965,
-0.14143212139606476,
-0.030867494642734528,
-0.6273561120033264,
-0.3848111927509308,
0.6328120827674866,
0.09275948256254196,
0.4290132224559784,
0.17558886110782623,
0.8285233974456787,
0.5102360248565674,
-0.04534929618239403,
-0.7954504489898682,
0.3830600678920746,
0.33653953671455383,
-0.1183490976691246,
-0.2683577239513397,
-0.5621088743209839,
-0.7093735933303833,
0.3754355311393738,
-0.5883926153182983,
-0.7753006219863892,
-0.36507749557495117,
0.19449876248836517,
-0.5102635025978088,
0.1971844732761383,
-0.8124856948852539,
0.5012047290802002,
-0.1381942182779312,
0.2768886685371399,
-0.5135661959648132,
-0.7686809301376343,
0.7335456609725952,
0.05794619023799896,
0.2877660095691681,
0.1982012242078781,
-0.08307366818189621,
0.8973498940467834,
-0.7542241811752319,
0.9377143383026123,
0.3266138732433319,
0.3042847514152527,
0.3652493357658386,
0.23782134056091309,
0.5788471698760986,
-0.28064677119255066,
0.5644752979278564,
-0.24354709684848785,
0.10645166039466858,
-0.659345269203186,
-0.9680925607681274,
-0.0013156994245946407,
-0.7666279077529907,
-0.08663026243448257,
-0.3216131329536438,
-0.4064355790615082,
-0.212922140955925,
-0.08134070038795471,
0.4506373107433319,
0.5462701916694641,
-0.41101697087287903,
-0.1647544801235199,
0.47002947330474854,
-0.5948994159698486,
0.5173075199127197,
0.319410115480423,
-0.38227349519729614,
-0.663215696811676,
0.935886561870575,
-0.2160530984401703,
0.4382678270339966,
0.5935798287391663,
0.1724279224872589,
-0.023070432245731354,
-0.4864393174648285,
0.005853399634361267,
0.3178825080394745,
-0.5854189991950989,
-0.1294497847557068,
-0.7013261318206787,
-0.4821900427341461,
-0.5204848051071167,
-0.23444153368473053,
-0.178575336933136,
-0.45331257581710815,
-0.09033285826444626,
-0.13426633179187775,
0.5081416368484497,
0.5327082872390747,
0.05099919065833092,
0.6545377373695374,
-1.083241581916809,
0.2498590052127838,
0.18519802391529083,
-0.11221999675035477,
0.03425665199756622,
-0.5102359652519226,
-0.36183008551597595,
-0.10790324211120605,
-0.468217670917511,
-0.7584099173545837,
0.6749299168586731,
0.308686763048172,
0.3945399224758148,
0.3707938492298126,
0.5049682855606079,
0.6773905158042908,
-0.1178058609366417,
1.0769627094268799,
0.6052554249763489,
-0.8478152751922607,
0.7588768005371094,
-0.38615530729293823,
0.2605385482311249,
0.5097019076347351,
0.31118834018707275,
-0.7799192070960999,
-0.7351452112197876,
-0.7376851439476013,
-0.9822680950164795,
0.6642365455627441,
0.47385749220848083,
0.30840569734573364,
0.21151332557201385,
-0.05569164827466011,
0.32741737365722656,
0.2090790718793869,
-0.20995865762233734,
-0.4484492540359497,
-0.024608628824353218,
-0.2250792533159256,
-0.21067720651626587,
-0.2692526578903198,
-0.0211680568754673,
-0.13630841672420502,
0.8083418011665344,
0.08850095421075821,
0.2180156111717224,
0.09759675711393356,
-0.27147388458251953,
0.3651609718799591,
0.07954645156860352,
0.6511051654815674,
0.3433084785938263,
-0.19058741629123688,
-0.2431001514196396,
0.23061858117580414,
-0.47509995102882385,
-0.08652302622795105,
-0.2696361243724823,
-0.18857301771640778,
0.3842366337776184,
0.5862186551094055,
0.6948566436767578,
0.5604860186576843,
-0.7738580703735352,
0.6066271066665649,
-0.147847518324852,
-0.3880244493484497,
-0.5012168288230896,
0.0043621305376291275,
-0.41985073685646057,
0.05265893042087555,
0.49710333347320557,
0.0400027260184288,
0.3735582232475281,
-0.6875272393226624,
0.1912151724100113,
0.02689938060939312,
-0.005522636696696281,
-0.13105179369449615,
0.36324378848075867,
0.6616167426109314,
-0.32983502745628357,
0.6061549782752991,
-0.01024380698800087,
-0.6272067427635193,
0.21794280409812927,
0.4499918818473816,
0.6499316692352295,
0.1825931966304779,
0.556384265422821,
0.3296109437942505,
-0.15372517704963684,
-0.023965071886777878,
0.02169659361243248,
-0.4898351728916168,
-0.45883309841156006,
-0.8113155364990234,
-0.07585754245519638,
-0.9280645847320557,
-0.159858837723732,
-0.6776546835899353,
0.3109987676143646,
-0.4072347581386566,
0.160039484500885,
0.17242109775543213,
0.012298841029405594,
-0.0720784142613411,
-0.12093918770551682,
0.04346441477537155,
0.863602876663208,
-0.7980715036392212,
0.10066814720630646,
0.31603536009788513,
-0.6506595015525818,
-0.8112503290176392,
-0.3929520547389984,
0.1977677196264267,
-0.6535060405731201,
0.12805277109146118,
-0.09280025213956833,
0.04654395207762718,
-0.1023687869310379,
-0.5390667915344238,
-0.5539270639419556,
0.9823852181434631,
0.07840721309185028,
-0.185250386595726,
-0.16052238643169403,
-0.15772634744644165,
0.4564037024974823,
-0.13087469339370728,
0.6667523980140686,
0.6598985195159912,
-0.1159517765045166,
0.3482273817062378,
-1.1606786251068115,
-0.22396443784236908,
-0.46057116985321045,
-0.07566756755113602,
0.40661656856536865,
-0.9088394641876221,
0.3994928300380707,
-0.04667503759264946,
-0.4579640328884125,
0.11724842339754105,
0.8884944915771484,
-0.027527039870619774,
0.21770428121089935,
0.27017760276794434,
0.18515315651893616,
0.7133797407150269,
0.0649605542421341,
1.0033446550369263,
0.08692391216754913,
0.02737576887011528,
1.3180286884307861,
0.005372529849410057,
0.6817150712013245,
0.4571332037448883,
-0.07344070076942444,
0.8172767758369446,
0.5268522500991821,
0.15165844559669495,
0.5869343280792236,
0.03518234193325043,
-0.21211999654769897,
-0.055444419384002686,
-0.20804661512374878,
-0.034598689526319504,
0.5327407121658325,
0.14604853093624115,
-0.2726951539516449,
-0.36477363109588623,
0.18112841248512268,
0.09734082967042923,
0.5539476871490479,
-0.19327901303768158,
1.6952110528945923,
0.09221085906028748,
-0.9178123474121094,
0.30258533358573914,
-0.08743644505739212,
0.7969078421592712,
-0.47591277956962585,
-0.1665690541267395,
-0.39006510376930237,
0.040130864828825,
-0.34078991413116455,
-0.46643027663230896,
0.4924880862236023,
-0.13928386569023132,
-0.02861189842224121,
-0.2565893828868866,
0.5461344122886658,
-0.4469098746776581,
-0.0937126949429512,
-0.09290358424186707,
0.5805550217628479,
0.4023239016532898,
0.15285909175872803,
-0.4095759093761444,
-0.24672037363052368,
-0.13275960087776184,
0.1667167991399765,
0.35496872663497925,
0.4101884961128235,
-0.0706627145409584,
0.5838839411735535,
0.8047789931297302,
0.36321786046028137,
-0.1706494688987732,
0.034078992903232574,
0.7913021445274353,
-0.7037651538848877,
-1.2974549531936646,
-0.9198911190032959,
0.6143408417701721,
-0.4597671627998352,
-0.44423505663871765,
0.7857784032821655,
0.718168318271637,
0.6766740679740906,
0.07373210787773132,
0.9168621301651001,
0.19437947869300842,
0.7160124182701111,
-0.6846005916595459,
0.13649696111679077,
0.09159272164106369,
0.14491376280784607,
-0.2909058630466461,
-0.6215929985046387,
-0.16111637651920319,
0.35631242394447327,
-0.21053820848464966,
-0.35974493622779846,
0.7384482026100159,
0.3476639688014984,
0.1671620011329651,
0.3099100887775421,
0.3191136121749878,
-0.31103983521461487,
0.03834861144423485,
0.6468538641929626,
1.1279479265213013,
-0.41850242018699646,
0.8957248330116272,
-0.3993181884288788,
-0.39273789525032043,
-0.387765109539032,
-0.7032709717750549,
-1.2459038496017456,
-0.6215634942054749,
-0.5356432199478149,
-0.35104137659072876,
-0.12543334066867828,
1.2317970991134644,
0.7487867474555969,
-0.6496763229370117,
-0.12774527072906494,
0.19369624555110931,
0.10933912545442581,
-0.6202216744422913,
-0.32728472352027893,
0.1544775366783142,
-0.5089640021324158,
-0.5699107646942139,
-0.018754256889224052,
0.2818296253681183,
0.4136858284473419,
-0.10138821601867676,
-0.005533302202820778,
-0.01035421434789896,
0.11748316884040833,
0.5245851874351501,
0.42709028720855713,
-0.2821817100048065,
0.19652143120765686,
-0.318063348531723,
-0.06838328391313553,
0.2057705968618393,
1.0521764755249023,
-1.010866641998291,
0.2159087210893631,
0.434672087430954,
0.49557819962501526,
0.6139321327209473,
0.3689291179180145,
1.0240368843078613,
-1.0496288537979126,
0.3680470287799835,
0.34309250116348267,
0.11421368271112442,
0.20920953154563904,
-0.5063166618347168,
0.21299342811107635,
0.15992718935012817,
-0.3034325838088989,
-0.5525155663490295,
-0.041976429522037506,
-1.039178729057312,
-0.2612546682357788,
0.9371889233589172,
-0.08967993408441544,
-0.19794084131717682,
-0.3380737006664276,
-0.7391567826271057,
0.3202607333660126,
-0.6850004196166992,
0.9418051242828369,
0.32765504717826843,
-0.04042747616767883,
-0.2829514741897583,
0.013046440668404102,
0.6576437950134277,
0.17945729196071625,
-0.9590921401977539,
-0.16985613107681274,
0.4773761034011841,
-0.12826836109161377,
0.2391774207353592,
0.7969419956207275,
-0.12105586379766464,
0.3788098394870758,
0.02326824516057968,
-0.1368509829044342,
-0.20967262983322144,
-0.03740640729665756,
-0.21215344965457916,
0.023768186569213867,
-0.4632066786289215,
-0.5158186554908752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01505v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01505v1 | Code-Switched Language Identification is Harder Than You Think | 2024-02-02T15:38:47 | 2024-02-02T15:38:47 | Laurie Burchell, Alexandra Birch, Robert P. Thompson, Kenneth Heafield | cs.CL | cs.CL | Code switching (CS) is a very common phenomenon in written and spoken
communication but one that is handled poorly by many natural language
processing applications. Looking to the application of building CS corpora, we
explore CS language identification (LID) for corpus building. We make the task
more realistic by scaling it to more languages and considering models with
simpler architectures for faster inference. We also reformulate the task as a
sentence-level multi-label tagging problem to make it more tractable. Having
defined the task, we investigate three reasonable models for this task and
define metrics which better reflect desired performance. We present empirical
evidence that no current approach is adequate and finally provide
recommendations for future work in this area. | [
-0.2955300211906433,
-0.7317975163459778,
0.35349640250205994,
0.3751847743988037,
0.06608955562114716,
0.6507606506347656,
-0.39202702045440674,
-0.7876389026641846,
-0.18600624799728394,
0.49962344765663147,
-0.17486369609832764,
-0.41951385140419006,
-0.5987101197242737,
0.120448037981987,
-0.7427343130111694,
1.0253816843032837,
0.08137121796607971,
-0.11667627841234207,
-0.04122883826494217,
0.18105056881904602,
-0.6518778800964355,
-0.5852407217025757,
-0.6833997368812561,
-0.06397269666194916,
0.5199605226516724,
0.47893741726875305,
0.9504084587097168,
0.7447667121887207,
0.42376425862312317,
0.2759532332420349,
-0.1468648612499237,
0.06334328651428223,
-0.44272005558013916,
-0.3744424283504486,
0.009352099150419235,
-0.6143007278442383,
-0.10316152125597,
-0.2094975709915161,
0.5826590061187744,
1.0983089208602905,
0.2382790446281433,
0.18496732413768768,
-0.1245579868555069,
0.5896308422088623,
-0.6994588971138,
0.0012735376367345452,
-0.8526194095611572,
-0.04221618175506592,
-0.6479314565658569,
-0.20455391705036163,
-0.8101121187210083,
-0.09900961816310883,
-0.1687372624874115,
-0.36535486578941345,
0.47814783453941345,
0.11170811951160431,
1.188317060470581,
0.25531768798828125,
-0.2705899775028229,
-0.6132217049598694,
-0.9669575691223145,
0.9228469133377075,
-0.4741477072238922,
0.4401310980319977,
0.3278025984764099,
0.08892515301704407,
0.03994084522128105,
-0.6597197651863098,
-0.15551431477069855,
-0.2652171850204468,
-0.06564927846193314,
-0.25120359659194946,
-0.3423023521900177,
-0.19726529717445374,
0.20416967570781708,
0.1585022211074829,
-0.4266030490398407,
0.12086287140846252,
-0.8071826696395874,
-0.3669123649597168,
0.437785267829895,
0.021527711302042007,
0.7629705667495728,
0.0878557488322258,
-0.37349316477775574,
-0.05181919038295746,
-0.5516338348388672,
0.15024620294570923,
0.49481499195098877,
0.7351837158203125,
0.08538465946912766,
0.3093525469303131,
0.05941488966345787,
0.9637612700462341,
0.1442052721977234,
-0.23749040067195892,
0.3580215573310852,
-0.05887674540281296,
-0.31922614574432373,
0.15866240859031677,
0.39803141355514526,
0.0019889266695827246,
0.2008066177368164,
-0.5509361028671265,
0.04671695455908775,
0.4657732844352722,
0.5546074509620667,
-0.5536080002784729,
-0.2876954674720764,
0.2831713557243347,
-0.47899341583251953,
-0.3069492280483246,
0.08717826008796692,
-0.44565021991729736,
-0.15440526604652405,
-0.43860557675361633,
-0.15168829262256622,
-0.595807671546936,
-0.35439616441726685,
0.016330983489751816,
-0.15910324454307556,
0.607879638671875,
0.08037456125020981,
-0.8576194643974304,
0.46971768140792847,
0.7960353493690491,
0.6644467115402222,
-0.5669943690299988,
-0.28549861907958984,
-0.6267122626304626,
0.10014549642801285,
-0.7272889018058777,
0.7935820817947388,
-0.9640638828277588,
-0.2241605818271637,
0.10778771340847015,
0.2600019574165344,
0.020492704585194588,
-0.6361071467399597,
0.3426780104637146,
-0.8173142671585083,
-0.02135421335697174,
-0.1549590677022934,
-0.2962849736213684,
0.21523508429527283,
0.02256716415286064,
-0.7774458527565002,
1.248671054840088,
0.21425871551036835,
-0.8728748559951782,
0.46171271800994873,
-0.39157038927078247,
-0.6437312960624695,
0.47616472840309143,
-0.22063250839710236,
-0.42188093066215515,
-0.01342017762362957,
-0.09084883332252502,
0.3123719096183777,
-0.17556428909301758,
0.33238568902015686,
-0.22186356782913208,
-0.5918225049972534,
0.18705007433891296,
-0.09977947175502777,
1.253758192062378,
0.6218041777610779,
-0.17418590188026428,
-0.1712360680103302,
-0.8190466165542603,
0.1033380776643753,
-0.38464879989624023,
-0.4907248914241791,
-0.5314618945121765,
0.05635401979088783,
0.37134480476379395,
-0.04069022834300995,
0.33045849204063416,
-0.5741225481033325,
0.4652123749256134,
-0.0960862934589386,
0.2786474823951721,
0.3839181065559387,
-0.2962341904640198,
0.6294631958007812,
-0.1464385986328125,
0.6902045011520386,
0.13193868100643158,
-0.026006463915109634,
0.42153728008270264,
-0.5908128023147583,
-0.6432679295539856,
-0.5661791563034058,
0.6904153823852539,
0.969364583492279,
-0.9942140579223633,
-0.014233940280973911,
0.05789770931005478,
-0.6583791971206665,
-0.6934495568275452,
0.2425294667482376,
0.6237556338310242,
-0.12944653630256653,
0.4077526330947876,
-0.32475531101226807,
-0.6301790475845337,
-1.0029205083847046,
-0.4895961284637451,
-0.11857186257839203,
0.01964123360812664,
0.08603846281766891,
0.3174826502799988,
-0.36096444725990295,
1.0911773443222046,
-0.7712923288345337,
0.0107897212728858,
-0.3576279282569885,
0.45217588543891907,
0.1906154751777649,
0.35663771629333496,
0.5409874320030212,
-0.878793478012085,
-0.5911605358123779,
0.20070534944534302,
-0.4253532588481903,
-0.48230764269828796,
-0.6089897155761719,
-0.04268549755215645,
0.2395499348640442,
1.244307518005371,
-0.08593998104333878,
0.34284132719039917,
0.5911170840263367,
-0.10673994570970535,
0.7570656538009644,
-0.08683457225561142,
0.004363846033811569,
-0.7505347728729248,
0.07306285947561264,
-0.29730933904647827,
0.07695870846509933,
-0.7531858086585999,
0.2683696746826172,
0.252119243144989,
-0.1166699156165123,
-0.7535014152526855,
0.40177011489868164,
-1.0864660739898682,
-0.2354704588651657,
-0.49257829785346985,
-0.11821991950273514,
-0.4851868450641632,
0.6374884247779846,
0.15587744116783142,
0.6407397985458374,
0.8353657722473145,
-0.8975846767425537,
0.2049371600151062,
-0.05243496969342232,
-0.6030653119087219,
0.4734010100364685,
-0.29919397830963135,
0.0660073384642601,
-0.10655814409255981,
0.12320604175329208,
-0.8494225144386292,
0.1289154440164566,
0.14726819097995758,
-0.4263138771057129,
0.23420673608779907,
-0.49219122529029846,
-0.4395250082015991,
-0.3271820843219757,
0.24588800966739655,
0.7069941163063049,
0.1895303726196289,
-0.6324753761291504,
0.33584660291671753,
0.3740067481994629,
-0.00023373070871457458,
-0.7324772477149963,
-1.0117244720458984,
0.41542789340019226,
-0.3972035050392151,
-0.3542191684246063,
0.7482523322105408,
-0.16237974166870117,
-0.3835987448692322,
0.032483961433172226,
0.05892554670572281,
-0.787538468837738,
0.1603049784898758,
0.209041029214859,
0.14225831627845764,
-0.18283939361572266,
0.2979983687400818,
-0.044110339134931564,
-0.16235952079296112,
-0.12696151435375214,
0.05860573798418045,
0.2696099281311035,
-0.4369673430919647,
-0.08347711712121964,
-0.108510822057724,
0.6537735462188721,
0.46239596605300903,
-0.5007851123809814,
0.6088032722473145,
0.7281045317649841,
-0.3334006369113922,
-0.4625394642353058,
-0.23165471851825714,
0.2848767936229706,
-0.451133668422699,
0.23405857384204865,
-0.9775737524032593,
-0.7162387371063232,
0.41095659136772156,
-0.2350279837846756,
0.008975174278020859,
0.06537925451993942,
0.6766359806060791,
0.04638568311929703,
0.6468165516853333,
1.1031074523925781,
-0.03423808142542839,
0.657081127166748,
0.11848954856395721,
0.5674938559532166,
-0.4594833552837372,
0.2385219931602478,
-0.7617161870002747,
-0.17515060305595398,
-0.8524841666221619,
-0.7041879892349243,
0.033485330641269684,
0.1811015009880066,
0.21205450594425201,
1.1711817979812622,
-0.7273399233818054,
0.481184720993042,
0.5172052383422852,
-0.03998568654060364,
0.43541568517684937,
-0.29411977529525757,
0.007613772060722113,
0.1681826263666153,
-0.6412253379821777,
-0.46906670928001404,
0.7955719828605652,
0.13204419612884521,
0.7667682766914368,
0.13182787597179413,
0.833885908126831,
0.4398132562637329,
0.3768486976623535,
-0.5663908123970032,
0.5963037014007568,
-0.22716891765594482,
-0.8233881592750549,
-0.2529611885547638,
-0.32900118827819824,
-1.260514736175537,
0.1747792661190033,
-0.05618475750088692,
-0.6322411298751831,
0.44908761978149414,
-0.0453399159014225,
-0.19001300632953644,
0.305990993976593,
-1.0673658847808838,
0.8261314034461975,
-0.10371337831020355,
-0.11134164035320282,
0.08029172569513321,
-0.6760771870613098,
0.44324859976768494,
-0.08637037128210068,
0.6234695911407471,
-0.0387532077729702,
0.04319493845105171,
0.4410887360572815,
-0.43033653497695923,
1.1182726621627808,
0.11898729205131531,
-0.17617592215538025,
0.6289270520210266,
0.10478890687227249,
0.06369675695896149,
-0.15824979543685913,
-0.078056201338768,
0.121843621134758,
0.3865421414375305,
-0.6404532194137573,
-0.397177129983902,
0.6037681698799133,
-0.6105759143829346,
-0.2186422049999237,
-0.44906437397003174,
-0.5237473249435425,
-0.21594510972499847,
0.17534145712852478,
0.336031049489975,
0.49280351400375366,
-0.37982478737831116,
0.10740568488836288,
0.45916667580604553,
-0.3942635655403137,
0.6729984283447266,
0.6412029266357422,
-0.12751539051532745,
0.1646023541688919,
1.1636385917663574,
0.002195290056988597,
0.3407260477542877,
0.7454115152359009,
0.02900913543999195,
0.30929604172706604,
-0.26982638239860535,
-0.5885528326034546,
0.032783713191747665,
-0.41700735688209534,
-0.07193030416965485,
-0.56844562292099,
-0.23322083055973053,
-0.3028041422367096,
-0.5980644226074219,
-0.4642394483089447,
-0.20234322547912598,
-0.2096148580312729,
0.1392107754945755,
0.24355900287628174,
0.46375373005867004,
-0.15717695653438568,
0.2335934042930603,
-0.5448526740074158,
0.4405335783958435,
0.16445650160312653,
0.40488940477371216,
-0.1530924290418625,
-0.311625599861145,
-0.34605175256729126,
-0.2490243762731552,
0.0013733436353504658,
-1.254676342010498,
0.24501793086528778,
-0.0301077701151371,
0.30499812960624695,
0.28742337226867676,
0.16416382789611816,
0.6194412708282471,
-0.5617504119873047,
0.5590525269508362,
0.060183487832546234,
-1.118155598640442,
0.13071519136428833,
-0.1600906103849411,
0.583765983581543,
0.5946019887924194,
0.3439941704273224,
-0.7400619983673096,
-0.7896428108215332,
-0.5498591065406799,
-0.92888343334198,
0.5397770404815674,
0.1317407488822937,
-0.04526504501700401,
-0.32799676060676575,
-0.017303423956036568,
0.02717016637325287,
-0.056265365332365036,
-1.007676601409912,
-0.26206785440444946,
0.17744317650794983,
0.09772659838199615,
0.2490311861038208,
0.06514129042625427,
0.15906637907028198,
-0.2043364942073822,
0.6074818968772888,
-0.2389950156211853,
0.3384406566619873,
0.01238011009991169,
-0.4638064503669739,
0.2870160639286041,
0.5921735167503357,
0.3962212800979614,
0.5430418252944946,
-0.07076643407344818,
0.2669815719127655,
0.05505885183811188,
-0.13765516877174377,
-0.2479998618364334,
-0.31829822063446045,
-0.19502988457679749,
0.06317155808210373,
0.4029635787010193,
0.5671356320381165,
0.40411317348480225,
-0.7638621926307678,
0.46262142062187195,
0.2150905430316925,
-0.27236559987068176,
-0.21235807240009308,
-0.08508702367544174,
0.3077409863471985,
-0.1386546790599823,
0.12404315173625946,
0.10579679906368256,
0.2019534856081009,
-0.9210924506187439,
0.3224157392978668,
0.4127303659915924,
-0.6114062666893005,
0.11352632194757462,
0.3383170962333679,
0.3266829252243042,
-0.6525377035140991,
0.6769574284553528,
-0.4737279713153839,
-0.4748782813549042,
0.9822975993156433,
0.6654571294784546,
0.989389181137085,
-0.09110687673091888,
0.43722617626190186,
0.3260590136051178,
0.654780387878418,
0.09916765987873077,
0.026045700535178185,
-0.20784643292427063,
-0.8553653359413147,
-0.4579923152923584,
-0.43778371810913086,
-0.38743704557418823,
-0.1697533279657364,
-0.9690674543380737,
0.4760706126689911,
-0.2493170201778412,
-0.0035302492324262857,
0.1918802261352539,
-0.2682255804538727,
-0.7375355362892151,
0.243251234292984,
0.40027597546577454,
0.8374394178390503,
-1.0632810592651367,
1.0698057413101196,
0.48414677381515503,
-0.30874162912368774,
-0.4492986500263214,
-0.17138950526714325,
-0.032241091132164,
-0.6896020174026489,
0.6453431844711304,
0.01406159345060587,
-0.3796667754650116,
-0.2768165171146393,
-0.8371031880378723,
-0.8752625584602356,
0.5924167633056641,
-0.07174278050661087,
-0.525462806224823,
-0.119399294257164,
0.16960689425468445,
0.8595949411392212,
-0.5416823029518127,
0.30972057580947876,
0.7990931868553162,
0.4437219202518463,
-0.1569465845823288,
-0.9491264224052429,
-0.010496399365365505,
-0.30984097719192505,
0.1354653686285019,
0.36638203263282776,
-0.6026465892791748,
0.6189107894897461,
-0.49690914154052734,
-0.6322212219238281,
0.11744502931833267,
0.6732462644577026,
-0.11823353171348572,
0.17221447825431824,
0.7802491188049316,
0.3359403610229492,
0.8954053521156311,
0.08239457756280899,
0.8572920560836792,
-0.44407638907432556,
0.07085596024990082,
1.4540654420852661,
-0.1338636726140976,
1.0245096683502197,
0.43516188859939575,
-0.11760679632425308,
0.9288844466209412,
0.6303528547286987,
-0.3416140377521515,
0.290400892496109,
0.7175978422164917,
-0.07480572909116745,
-0.4301760792732239,
0.1447993814945221,
-0.42327049374580383,
0.6625062227249146,
0.4255104064941406,
-0.18892307579517365,
-0.12003947049379349,
0.11567306518554688,
0.23292873799800873,
0.10379988700151443,
0.021699903532862663,
0.4865497350692749,
-0.14113153517246246,
-0.7844198942184448,
0.5385001301765442,
0.3006460964679718,
0.6456608176231384,
-0.5091820955276489,
0.05625983700156212,
-0.028283366933465004,
0.06979850679636002,
-0.3265657126903534,
-0.3956676125526428,
0.5888011455535889,
0.1742061823606491,
-0.5387551784515381,
-0.7027239203453064,
0.41143062710762024,
-0.7587019205093384,
-0.5613560080528259,
0.5079793334007263,
0.4099154472351074,
0.5678003430366516,
0.1278940886259079,
-0.6913296580314636,
0.46284109354019165,
0.08899860829114914,
0.2668881118297577,
0.1913345456123352,
0.2864651679992676,
-0.43881717324256897,
0.6411431431770325,
0.5905316472053528,
-0.24581190943717957,
0.3570490777492523,
0.1562924087047577,
0.459347665309906,
-0.7604447603225708,
-0.4068431854248047,
-0.349386990070343,
0.21790273487567902,
0.01257795374840498,
-0.5745062232017517,
0.5784162282943726,
0.9109867811203003,
0.8641125559806824,
-0.40120142698287964,
0.8299362659454346,
-0.368047833442688,
0.5765109062194824,
-0.31440022587776184,
0.46822014451026917,
-0.37602317333221436,
0.36768555641174316,
-0.6374537348747253,
-0.8205030560493469,
-0.40376949310302734,
0.2180211991071701,
-0.18073564767837524,
-0.2604661285877228,
1.1611124277114868,
1.0454497337341309,
0.02095554955303669,
-0.23245769739151,
0.30803805589675903,
0.33414894342422485,
0.2476818710565567,
0.9496280550956726,
0.6352515816688538,
-0.5143721699714661,
1.0765149593353271,
-0.0470634363591671,
-0.5863457918167114,
-0.11759909242391586,
-1.0528018474578857,
-0.7148468494415283,
-0.7786893248558044,
-0.848827600479126,
-0.3162129521369934,
0.0657355785369873,
0.3445376455783844,
0.9340710043907166,
-0.8275026679039001,
-0.5205091834068298,
-0.13656871020793915,
0.3914451599121094,
-0.9043785929679871,
-0.3143887221813202,
0.1525615155696869,
-0.6089418530464172,
-0.9551421403884888,
0.572019100189209,
0.015112861059606075,
-0.520359456539154,
0.03801939636468887,
0.26897573471069336,
-0.2173352688550949,
0.0680600255727768,
0.5627375245094299,
0.8501254916191101,
-0.7987314462661743,
-0.22970139980316162,
-0.09258439391851425,
-0.5047701001167297,
0.016518667340278625,
1.1533076763153076,
-0.7939943671226501,
0.5113340616226196,
0.41219422221183777,
1.004804253578186,
0.5709647536277771,
-0.16829842329025269,
0.6307739019393921,
-0.6221776008605957,
-0.16071201860904694,
-0.11726964265108109,
0.04817977175116539,
0.28790998458862305,
-0.23436684906482697,
0.4933052062988281,
0.21639886498451233,
-0.40237146615982056,
-0.8086598515510559,
0.5236246585845947,
-1.4230111837387085,
-0.7377300262451172,
1.3260189294815063,
0.2893924117088318,
-0.25201520323753357,
-0.6609030365943909,
-0.35359230637550354,
-0.0689929947257042,
-0.08639176189899445,
0.640228271484375,
0.9219434857368469,
-0.12008491158485413,
0.030000360682606697,
-0.39853253960609436,
0.6906707286834717,
0.40978196263313293,
-0.903477668762207,
0.10022445768117905,
0.2595618665218353,
0.43841925263404846,
0.4760836362838745,
0.8096476197242737,
-0.04034792259335518,
0.2442595511674881,
0.2163192182779312,
0.45699042081832886,
0.3994978666305542,
-0.6426210403442383,
0.08557365834712982,
0.40995630621910095,
-0.12388201057910919,
-0.29513347148895264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01495v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01495v1 | A Comparative Analysis of Conversational Large Language Models in Knowledge-Based Text Generation | 2024-02-02T15:26:39 | 2024-02-02T15:26:39 | Phillip Schneider, Manuel Klettner, Elena Simperl, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generating natural language text from graph-structured data is essential for
conversational information seeking. Semantic triples derived from knowledge
graphs can serve as a valuable source for grounding responses from
conversational agents by providing a factual basis for the information they
communicate. This is especially relevant in the context of large language
models, which offer great potential for conversational interaction but are
prone to hallucinating, omitting, or producing conflicting information. In this
study, we conduct an empirical analysis of conversational large language models
in generating natural language text from semantic triples. We compare four
large language models of varying sizes with different prompting techniques.
Through a series of benchmark experiments on the WebNLG dataset, we analyze the
models' performance and identify the most common issues in the generated
predictions. Our findings show that the capabilities of large language models
in triple verbalization can be significantly improved through few-shot
prompting, post-processing, and efficient fine-tuning techniques, particularly
for smaller models that exhibit lower zero-shot performance. | [
-0.3045199513435364,
-1.074724555015564,
0.7596753239631653,
-0.006506064906716347,
-0.04626110941171646,
-0.17150208353996277,
-0.4476954936981201,
-0.7849319577217102,
-0.28030896186828613,
0.5822579264640808,
-0.24075201153755188,
-0.599329948425293,
-0.42225515842437744,
0.2749123275279999,
-0.33282923698425293,
0.8367751240730286,
0.23053604364395142,
-0.141535684466362,
-0.08298821747303009,
0.31576746702194214,
-0.6650742292404175,
-0.49069133400917053,
-0.7911980152130127,
-0.46653711795806885,
0.6302769780158997,
0.3922635614871979,
0.917838454246521,
0.29911789298057556,
0.3405055105686188,
0.301941841840744,
-0.018720204010605812,
0.2978164851665497,
-0.6232417821884155,
0.2259870022535324,
0.185735821723938,
-0.24940112233161926,
-0.34043553471565247,
-0.06484228372573853,
0.689146876335144,
0.8505270481109619,
0.11892232298851013,
-0.08585396409034729,
0.09691771119832993,
0.6757407784461975,
-0.43555930256843567,
0.538881778717041,
-0.7752878069877625,
-0.10436493903398514,
0.08098077028989792,
-0.1568024605512619,
-0.619234561920166,
-0.627643346786499,
0.500190019607544,
-0.650878369808197,
0.27121758460998535,
0.199637770652771,
0.8456666469573975,
-0.09612903743982315,
-0.3926938474178314,
-0.5522316694259644,
-0.8089309334754944,
0.6296627521514893,
-1.0087178945541382,
0.3605484068393707,
0.40266796946525574,
0.21874521672725677,
-0.19612672924995422,
-0.5440881848335266,
-0.7675542235374451,
-0.5124867558479309,
-0.15836800634860992,
-0.09295251965522766,
-0.3821565806865692,
0.18843065202236176,
0.35950034856796265,
0.07521720230579376,
-0.4095636010169983,
0.2869611084461212,
-0.30319714546203613,
-0.09999915957450867,
0.4395200312137604,
0.1517227441072464,
0.22535595297813416,
-0.5187631845474243,
-0.015267932787537575,
-0.21028387546539307,
-0.7564502954483032,
-0.2905677556991577,
0.5862953662872314,
0.6238653659820557,
0.00043020216980949044,
0.7296130061149597,
-0.44733017683029175,
1.181150197982788,
-0.1176280528306961,
-0.24261264503002167,
0.1014833003282547,
-0.5419355034828186,
-0.06433748453855515,
0.03235090896487236,
1.041635513305664,
0.6440684199333191,
0.6951069831848145,
-0.25344565510749817,
0.027148663997650146,
-0.06294632703065872,
0.10409064590930939,
-0.9048227667808533,
-0.26797211170196533,
0.1372179090976715,
-0.28617265820503235,
-0.39124318957328796,
0.014590093865990639,
-0.5562350153923035,
-0.39974159002304077,
-0.4375050663948059,
0.15984536707401276,
-0.7237575054168701,
-0.14863848686218262,
0.37670284509658813,
-0.412241131067276,
0.14266744256019592,
0.23431195318698883,
-0.8855310678482056,
0.20585326850414276,
0.554128885269165,
0.734686017036438,
-0.14684149622917175,
-0.20389872789382935,
-0.5057801008224487,
0.35048389434814453,
-0.45926135778427124,
0.7433315515518188,
-0.38219812512397766,
-0.268597811460495,
0.19589000940322876,
-0.5589290261268616,
-0.04723738878965378,
-0.47055119276046753,
0.3504190146923065,
-0.5486161112785339,
0.2596704065799713,
-0.45545142889022827,
-0.5440726280212402,
-0.10077936202287674,
0.43249645829200745,
-0.6832610368728638,
0.8457298874855042,
-0.25030338764190674,
-0.8917607665061951,
0.49867239594459534,
-0.7117568850517273,
-0.3677314221858978,
0.22541843354701996,
-0.127171128988266,
-0.10425237566232681,
-0.11555006355047226,
0.2444520890712738,
0.7548478245735168,
-0.5276014804840088,
0.3987199366092682,
-0.23055177927017212,
-0.02219170518219471,
0.32736825942993164,
-0.38377636671066284,
0.16699542105197906,
0.05662398040294647,
-0.23037327826023102,
-0.06349115818738937,
-0.9293073415756226,
0.3271275758743286,
0.3268398940563202,
-0.3838817775249481,
-0.2998794913291931,
0.0071488008834421635,
-0.202790766954422,
0.1269662231206894,
0.05851329490542412,
-0.486349493265152,
-0.08312346786260605,
-0.7400861978530884,
0.3594891428947449,
0.4668564200401306,
0.11893913894891739,
0.17541591823101044,
-0.2550908625125885,
0.2031005322933197,
-0.1169554740190506,
-0.3457214832305908,
-0.16933955252170563,
-0.5900413990020752,
-0.8090077042579651,
0.07153521478176117,
0.220589280128479,
0.20948347449302673,
-0.8968092203140259,
0.19036418199539185,
-0.4593040645122528,
-0.3176935017108917,
-0.09649718552827835,
0.05013129860162735,
0.5621922612190247,
0.6165395379066467,
0.13548223674297333,
0.2849791347980499,
-0.4815886616706848,
-0.9390886425971985,
-0.33557382225990295,
-0.3387422561645508,
-0.10158655047416687,
0.4098745584487915,
0.30611559748649597,
0.06344616413116455,
1.0530632734298706,
-0.6762415170669556,
0.17257145047187805,
-0.4475562870502472,
0.49482202529907227,
-0.05891101434826851,
0.035246673971414566,
0.557190477848053,
-0.5166582465171814,
-0.6765822768211365,
0.19136260449886322,
-0.8774592876434326,
-0.07612605392932892,
0.3384189307689667,
0.014535441994667053,
0.525538980960846,
0.351110577583313,
-0.7165586352348328,
0.4201962947845459,
0.5397887825965881,
-0.05900053679943085,
0.5476753115653992,
-0.11187022179365158,
0.13667665421962738,
-0.9678569436073303,
0.15788987278938293,
-0.16133536398410797,
-0.15869250893592834,
-0.913332462310791,
-0.18869049847126007,
-0.09603046625852585,
-0.2717198133468628,
-0.2853689193725586,
0.5139338970184326,
-0.5017949938774109,
-0.1416766494512558,
-0.2834569811820984,
0.6275662183761597,
0.1776449978351593,
0.34660789370536804,
0.2214699685573578,
0.6323727965354919,
0.274290531873703,
-0.9411054849624634,
0.4132707715034485,
0.35708552598953247,
-0.4287269413471222,
0.38388457894325256,
-0.8870781064033508,
0.2726227343082428,
-0.10757343471050262,
0.36331677436828613,
-0.9160014390945435,
-0.5133680105209351,
-0.03675456345081329,
-0.43602484464645386,
0.07321484386920929,
0.003903765929862857,
-0.7979228496551514,
-0.7127424478530884,
-0.12453588098287582,
0.07187018543481827,
0.2641599476337433,
-0.5158329606056213,
0.10785673558712006,
0.09522025287151337,
-0.34528958797454834,
-0.23157373070716858,
-0.48391246795654297,
0.31204938888549805,
-0.040085986256599426,
-1.0528931617736816,
0.09342709183692932,
-0.01616797223687172,
-0.44013771414756775,
-0.239146888256073,
0.28319239616394043,
0.17361357808113098,
-0.15902122855186462,
0.07802566140890121,
0.35398492217063904,
-0.34462055563926697,
0.48838505148887634,
-0.36902597546577454,
-0.1763610541820526,
0.06728265434503555,
-0.5006533265113831,
0.8724643588066101,
-0.24884170293807983,
-0.2249337136745453,
-0.497209757566452,
0.3071785271167755,
0.28854885697364807,
0.01868342235684395,
0.9964659810066223,
0.3763343095779419,
-0.19435623288154602,
0.09541931748390198,
-0.7724462151527405,
-0.24059747159481049,
-0.40497326850891113,
0.14360551536083221,
-0.3401254415512085,
-0.9358140230178833,
0.21579548716545105,
0.2701157033443451,
0.10808804631233215,
0.38384780287742615,
0.5260929465293884,
0.13267171382904053,
1.2915327548980713,
0.3950352370738983,
0.22360558807849884,
0.2567755877971649,
-0.08142341673374176,
0.491805762052536,
-0.368563175201416,
-0.14743418991565704,
-0.7123558521270752,
0.18760986626148224,
-0.43595340847969055,
-0.10439134389162064,
0.40479645133018494,
-0.016281012445688248,
-0.051567912101745605,
0.17665483057498932,
-0.2305576354265213,
0.43361231684684753,
0.5184370279312134,
-0.21484072506427765,
0.48465460538864136,
0.1401105672121048,
-0.07119917124509811,
0.16890114545822144,
-0.80427086353302,
-0.7458962202072144,
1.033814787864685,
0.09704159945249557,
0.5674812197685242,
0.15892545878887177,
0.45906129479408264,
-0.11388315260410309,
-0.12708085775375366,
-0.9038418531417847,
0.5347205400466919,
0.04840612784028053,
-0.4343903660774231,
-0.4416479766368866,
-0.7099338173866272,
-1.2327476739883423,
0.12284711748361588,
-0.44844260811805725,
-0.8674344420433044,
-0.3892133831977844,
0.20649340748786926,
-0.4793158769607544,
0.23555520176887512,
-1.0347838401794434,
0.7025342583656311,
0.08604522794485092,
-0.2099372297525406,
-0.07911910861730576,
-0.5620423555374146,
0.3607636094093323,
-0.051978155970573425,
0.22119520604610443,
-0.12422049790620804,
0.4063633680343628,
0.678734540939331,
-0.48558509349823,
0.832431972026825,
-0.05892009660601616,
-0.3538239002227783,
0.5233125686645508,
0.0690625011920929,
0.6643427014350891,
-0.1460113674402237,
-0.2604318857192993,
0.01659589633345604,
-0.09679051488637924,
-0.1789894998073578,
-0.42938709259033203,
0.6983181834220886,
-0.7962377071380615,
-0.5506450533866882,
0.10260830819606781,
-0.6770625710487366,
-0.5525449514389038,
0.43866264820098877,
0.3875328302383423,
0.7866209149360657,
-0.3159150779247284,
0.3253507912158966,
0.5590181350708008,
-0.3754664659500122,
0.6092783212661743,
0.41294464468955994,
-0.3391730487346649,
-0.09117450565099716,
0.7455257177352905,
0.12739408016204834,
0.7363684177398682,
0.29928940534591675,
0.48860788345336914,
-0.2351994514465332,
-0.5272940993309021,
-0.3348986506462097,
0.3353029191493988,
-0.5886374711990356,
-0.2660306990146637,
-1.0359593629837036,
-0.26263320446014404,
-0.8518514633178711,
-0.14459875226020813,
-0.1660861074924469,
-0.47196894884109497,
-0.17363899946212769,
-0.31762850284576416,
0.48189306259155273,
1.1605311632156372,
0.08280853927135468,
0.4554045498371124,
-0.9634072184562683,
0.339706689119339,
0.5636464953422546,
0.22648729383945465,
0.13227114081382751,
-0.01155798975378275,
-0.06255507469177246,
0.27879688143730164,
-0.14337140321731567,
-0.8903009295463562,
0.2287083864212036,
-0.01570340059697628,
0.34439095854759216,
0.2380693405866623,
-0.09223578870296478,
0.4835975468158722,
-0.4371831715106964,
0.9418724775314331,
0.47023266553878784,
-0.828586995601654,
0.6038607358932495,
-0.7768151760101318,
0.47646647691726685,
0.25303182005882263,
0.09232078492641449,
-0.5629208087921143,
-0.3449184000492096,
-0.6184204816818237,
-0.7005248069763184,
0.9782868027687073,
0.4484155476093292,
0.0992104634642601,
-0.3864344656467438,
0.06699272990226746,
0.0909208282828331,
0.3277168273925781,
-0.7228577733039856,
0.14982709288597107,
-0.0015665818937122822,
-0.028871219605207443,
0.14364488422870636,
-0.3877151310443878,
-0.17020069062709808,
0.17369310557842255,
0.6740376949310303,
-0.3909362852573395,
0.019277013838291168,
-0.043321531265974045,
0.09166156500577927,
-0.03339088335633278,
0.33824750781059265,
0.43760135769844055,
0.5951816439628601,
-0.09794390201568604,
0.08090361207723618,
0.15692304074764252,
-0.18161244690418243,
-0.24844925105571747,
-0.02722073532640934,
-0.14489158987998962,
-0.08148978650569916,
0.4295586347579956,
1.130400538444519,
0.2726130187511444,
-0.5489209294319153,
0.6027477383613586,
-0.042865801602602005,
-0.32867640256881714,
-0.08189558237791061,
0.05840199813246727,
0.14525939524173737,
-0.06492550671100616,
0.10273304581642151,
-0.2319502830505371,
0.08697037398815155,
-0.4910570979118347,
-0.20852819085121155,
0.5266628265380859,
-0.1735227406024933,
-0.14114773273468018,
0.35857298970222473,
0.2838200032711029,
-0.313321590423584,
0.6517525911331177,
-0.1855342984199524,
-0.3506084680557251,
0.37044277787208557,
0.7313669323921204,
0.4771973788738251,
0.26313501596450806,
0.4796087145805359,
0.5315389633178711,
0.0010081282816827297,
-0.10208909958600998,
-0.07704050838947296,
-0.007877345196902752,
-0.9361714720726013,
-0.38561972975730896,
-0.44539254903793335,
-0.20666752755641937,
0.1120043396949768,
-0.3959414064884186,
0.31384965777397156,
-0.3434576094150543,
-0.3285646140575409,
0.31149157881736755,
-0.08395460993051529,
-0.8471940159797668,
0.011491863988339901,
0.3108242452144623,
0.4898386001586914,
-0.5084068775177002,
0.5601027607917786,
0.30746105313301086,
-0.26584744453430176,
-1.148800015449524,
-0.00007133762846933678,
0.02277674712240696,
-0.7499032020568848,
0.7021018266677856,
0.28971680998802185,
-0.37608861923217773,
0.08086007833480835,
-0.726966142654419,
-0.8541678190231323,
0.8411285281181335,
0.25267237424850464,
-0.24765422940254211,
-0.2844434678554535,
0.3192351758480072,
0.636466920375824,
-0.25587964057922363,
0.20366738736629486,
0.7165132164955139,
0.5666947960853577,
0.5350067019462585,
-1.0144920349121094,
-0.05564478784799576,
0.027271242812275887,
0.1948791891336441,
0.23898838460445404,
-0.5135975480079651,
0.6755582094192505,
-0.2215110808610916,
-0.42525386810302734,
0.09287428855895996,
0.5555222034454346,
0.3650519549846649,
0.03544353321194649,
0.5039236545562744,
0.20900723338127136,
0.8967819809913635,
-0.030260832980275154,
1.2355870008468628,
-0.24307692050933838,
-0.015537550672888756,
1.115404486656189,
-0.5240790843963623,
0.6834568381309509,
0.2470475286245346,
0.09659735858440399,
0.4514959156513214,
0.04215097427368164,
0.29432687163352966,
0.017783774062991142,
0.0731225535273552,
-0.05523989722132683,
-0.16170942783355713,
-0.11801683902740479,
-0.36121347546577454,
0.4914412200450897,
0.4421257972717285,
-0.15279072523117065,
-0.2557661831378937,
-0.11713545024394989,
0.24351386725902557,
0.03016600012779236,
-0.017211319878697395,
1.1438344717025757,
-0.11322841048240662,
-1.0324153900146484,
0.6609138250350952,
-0.04546765983104706,
0.3563827872276306,
-0.6281033158302307,
0.03027426265180111,
0.09968925267457962,
-0.18299219012260437,
-0.10951831936836243,
-0.7371804118156433,
0.09545774757862091,
0.15491051971912384,
-0.1938495635986328,
-0.25538748502731323,
0.9233614206314087,
-0.32736390829086304,
-0.23516260087490082,
0.1250220388174057,
0.5150644779205322,
0.16050554811954498,
-0.0187006164342165,
-0.3063472807407379,
0.026306549087166786,
-0.005613971501588821,
-0.22790376842021942,
-0.041390009224414825,
0.525010883808136,
0.028065187856554985,
0.4957813620567322,
0.7429810762405396,
0.0043664355762302876,
0.1886146515607834,
0.3680507242679596,
0.6735293865203857,
-0.6296632289886475,
-0.3662812113761902,
-0.7097654342651367,
0.24025173485279083,
-0.4072088301181793,
-0.16568860411643982,
0.8605530261993408,
0.40914514660835266,
0.37160247564315796,
0.04878649115562439,
0.9299086928367615,
-0.09930021315813065,
0.6399403214454651,
-0.8446261882781982,
0.443167120218277,
-0.06613974273204803,
0.2252347767353058,
-0.47855833172798157,
-0.9225454330444336,
-0.310796856880188,
0.3996312916278839,
-0.5231139063835144,
0.14025314152240753,
0.7535455822944641,
0.73650723695755,
0.19632937014102936,
0.4684165418148041,
0.43958693742752075,
0.4946593940258026,
0.5238546133041382,
0.3747865855693817,
1.0105175971984863,
-0.18457703292369843,
0.6368799805641174,
0.14409685134887695,
0.04838705062866211,
-0.24724309146404266,
-0.88553786277771,
-1.1502526998519897,
-0.5143452286720276,
-0.07175042480230331,
-0.3511215150356293,
-0.09330172091722488,
0.7728398442268372,
0.7012525796890259,
-0.4599936306476593,
-0.03189735487103462,
-0.24262326955795288,
0.0850917249917984,
0.37720736861228943,
-0.24850472807884216,
0.13118208944797516,
-0.4711102545261383,
-0.6580271124839783,
0.45504969358444214,
0.17961814999580383,
0.25805115699768066,
-0.09664160758256912,
0.09675103425979614,
-0.07355464994907379,
0.2845251262187958,
0.8196420073509216,
0.09774860739707947,
-0.6701295375823975,
-0.6593521237373352,
-0.07298924773931503,
-0.30298832058906555,
-0.00004222103234496899,
0.8409472107887268,
-0.8094311952590942,
0.41950517892837524,
0.5397301316261292,
0.32940489053726196,
0.5939581394195557,
-0.13413433730602264,
0.871036946773529,
-0.8560914993286133,
0.09498697519302368,
0.02309565432369709,
0.09126056730747223,
0.6129138469696045,
-0.26678547263145447,
0.3990606665611267,
-0.04396094009280205,
-0.4854474365711212,
-0.5412892699241638,
0.32436543703079224,
-0.6655186414718628,
-0.3089328110218048,
1.5633454322814941,
0.20516309142112732,
-0.0018455182434991002,
-0.18804079294204712,
-0.4223730266094208,
0.21047310531139374,
-0.38856321573257446,
0.4671414792537689,
0.9377347826957703,
-0.08846432715654373,
0.2901768684387207,
-0.6286721229553223,
0.5219747424125671,
0.15411093831062317,
-0.9740657210350037,
0.28641068935394287,
1.003326177597046,
0.042805418372154236,
0.26288512349128723,
0.7039547562599182,
0.02680068463087082,
-0.08157023042440414,
0.02060510963201523,
0.02246919646859169,
0.053323596715927124,
-0.31697580218315125,
0.061979714781045914,
0.25362628698349,
0.1537594050168991,
0.37941065430641174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01469v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01469v1 | AMOR: A Recipe for Building Adaptable Modular Knowledge Agents Through Process Feedback | 2024-02-02T14:56:48 | 2024-02-02T14:56:48 | Jian Guan, Wei Wu, Zujie Wen, Peng Xu, Hongning Wang, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The notable success of large language models (LLMs) has sparked an upsurge in
building language agents to complete various complex tasks. We present AMOR, an
agent framework based on open-source LLMs, which reasons with external
knowledge bases and adapts to specific domains through human supervision to the
reasoning process. AMOR builds reasoning logic over a finite state machine
(FSM) that solves problems through autonomous executions and transitions over
disentangled modules. This allows humans to provide direct feedback to the
individual modules, and thus naturally forms process supervision. Based on this
reasoning and feedback framework, we develop AMOR through two-stage
fine-tuning: warm-up and adaptation. The former fine-tunes the LLM with
examples automatically constructed from various public datasets and enables
AMOR to generalize across different knowledge environments, while the latter
tailors AMOR to specific domains using process feedback. Extensive experiments
across multiple domains demonstrate the advantage of AMOR to strong baselines,
thanks to its FSM-based reasoning and process feedback mechanism. | [
-0.22516922652721405,
-0.7158236503601074,
0.7266033291816711,
0.052492283284664154,
0.2607037425041199,
0.08497326821088791,
-0.34577134251594543,
-0.29518789052963257,
0.03614423796534538,
0.7598227858543396,
-0.431368887424469,
-0.4634300768375397,
-0.23829160630702972,
-0.20731772482395172,
-0.14208020269870758,
1.1080485582351685,
-0.26980841159820557,
-0.28794240951538086,
-0.36042749881744385,
0.08845368772745132,
-0.05089452117681503,
-0.15515920519828796,
-0.6813679933547974,
-0.6547585725784302,
0.36914801597595215,
0.615617036819458,
0.8172054290771484,
0.40539029240608215,
0.23311501741409302,
0.3820103108882904,
0.2187223881483078,
0.4685313403606415,
-0.4242532253265381,
0.21057936549186707,
-0.6999103426933289,
-0.9463996291160583,
-0.8038315773010254,
-0.27816882729530334,
0.453683465719223,
0.4187232553958893,
-0.2832598388195038,
0.008969062007963657,
-0.07920488715171814,
0.8868505954742432,
-0.6243081092834473,
0.3949417471885681,
-0.7862439155578613,
-0.1344202160835266,
-0.047664906829595566,
-0.14541572332382202,
-0.7044796347618103,
-0.21971087157726288,
0.15891073644161224,
-0.6784793138504028,
-0.12900754809379578,
0.12513795495033264,
0.44546616077423096,
0.45795971155166626,
-0.17193734645843506,
-0.25039464235305786,
-1.1379239559173584,
0.7475436329841614,
-0.6868364214897156,
0.10047712177038193,
0.516619086265564,
0.331623911857605,
-0.3949054479598999,
-0.5158634185791016,
-0.2873373031616211,
-0.3425661623477936,
0.10653870552778244,
-0.11698522418737411,
-0.22307956218719482,
0.14914833009243011,
-0.05758756771683693,
0.4063558578491211,
-0.06127327308058739,
-0.15005314350128174,
-0.21911051869392395,
-0.19751502573490143,
0.5994313955307007,
0.27861326932907104,
0.3423086702823639,
0.5100600123405457,
-0.32146045565605164,
0.22777453064918518,
-0.5826278328895569,
-0.05905603617429733,
0.3055437505245209,
0.27119889855384827,
-0.0026592803187668324,
0.46441540122032166,
-0.42419707775115967,
0.5615378022193909,
0.21207588911056519,
-0.04107077792286873,
0.1319112628698349,
0.20320487022399902,
-0.2799825668334961,
-0.12977463006973267,
0.5185521245002747,
0.3687755763530731,
0.3138038218021393,
-0.3839423358440399,
-0.5615693926811218,
0.1461019515991211,
0.6344496011734009,
-0.5258926749229431,
-0.19904345273971558,
0.2523850202560425,
-0.13428832590579987,
-0.031664613634347916,
-0.007353815715759993,
-0.4700305759906769,
-0.5383977293968201,
-0.4220812916755676,
0.5480374097824097,
-0.5541964173316956,
-0.4153113067150116,
0.2378491312265396,
-0.11825010925531387,
0.2276407927274704,
0.6663206815719604,
-1.0402491092681885,
0.581936776638031,
0.7999178767204285,
0.7330611348152161,
-0.24873709678649902,
-0.37458857893943787,
-0.4677217900753021,
0.14559762179851532,
-0.49493539333343506,
0.9621398448944092,
-0.49962639808654785,
0.04918670654296875,
-0.08565419167280197,
-0.06363208591938019,
-0.19907528162002563,
-0.6565369963645935,
0.18857227265834808,
-0.7423238754272461,
0.012085349299013615,
0.19437308609485626,
-0.6230385899543762,
-0.18460842967033386,
0.3299134075641632,
-0.32835066318511963,
0.8494837880134583,
0.42131301760673523,
-0.4564158320426941,
0.12727521359920502,
-0.9392669796943665,
-0.4354449510574341,
-0.06076062470674515,
0.19232021272182465,
-0.014900144189596176,
0.14633959531784058,
0.047561462968587875,
0.3867085576057434,
-0.3260032832622528,
-0.12154267728328705,
-0.46093958616256714,
-0.0009121430921368301,
0.05167055502533913,
0.06824186444282532,
0.23197121918201447,
0.41478052735328674,
-0.3523346483707428,
0.6078433394432068,
-0.7792444229125977,
-0.03718728572130203,
-0.16481831669807434,
-0.3456074297428131,
-0.39242011308670044,
0.4160802960395813,
-0.5867121815681458,
-0.14885000884532928,
0.18095891177654266,
-0.20401430130004883,
0.45500022172927856,
-0.7082794308662415,
0.48888731002807617,
0.8614969849586487,
0.029744334518909454,
0.9809574484825134,
-0.6713002920150757,
0.5892012715339661,
0.10580994188785553,
0.04969855025410652,
-0.22535596787929535,
-0.28481385111808777,
-1.0080186128616333,
-0.23708802461624146,
-0.2627304196357727,
0.6623908877372742,
-0.9521641731262207,
0.2506672739982605,
0.10614881664514542,
-0.6712391972541809,
-0.48551878333091736,
0.4258550703525543,
0.23178386688232422,
0.32208141684532166,
0.08395278453826904,
-0.3779412508010864,
-0.38127297163009644,
-0.7741722464561462,
0.07969396561384201,
-0.4595567286014557,
-0.01780538074672222,
0.13372977077960968,
0.6395659446716309,
-0.46468228101730347,
1.0380350351333618,
-0.5274173617362976,
-0.2721646726131439,
-0.16480793058872223,
0.03427326679229736,
0.29331979155540466,
0.25557172298431396,
0.39868268370628357,
-0.41636258363723755,
-0.17830334603786469,
0.3404650390148163,
-0.7374557852745056,
-0.03698175773024559,
0.060963891446590424,
-0.5570812821388245,
0.22592782974243164,
0.45765388011932373,
-0.5080116987228394,
-0.13119590282440186,
0.38962996006011963,
-0.5979899168014526,
0.6549123525619507,
-0.2231873869895935,
0.05859439820051193,
-1.2331253290176392,
-0.1488737165927887,
-0.1031109020113945,
-0.3332822620868683,
-0.5732691287994385,
0.16086947917938232,
-0.23937901854515076,
0.26588496565818787,
-0.5322779417037964,
0.6330009698867798,
-0.43345510959625244,
-0.10155341029167175,
-0.4684522747993469,
-0.21212376654148102,
-0.08692660927772522,
0.7170926332473755,
-0.07911326736211777,
0.5910012722015381,
0.8212403655052185,
-0.8520824909210205,
0.8267114758491516,
0.10913635045289993,
-0.43387371301651,
0.7456689476966858,
-0.49628061056137085,
0.2954954504966736,
0.021738776937127113,
0.11570248752832413,
-0.5009626746177673,
-0.41525089740753174,
0.41495266556739807,
-0.2590319812297821,
-0.06260673701763153,
-0.2549234926700592,
-0.24236713349819183,
-0.24040821194648743,
-0.30927056074142456,
-0.11500304937362671,
0.4223009943962097,
-0.3203262686729431,
1.0470387935638428,
0.4677538275718689,
-0.11617662757635117,
-0.25695520639419556,
-0.6055118441581726,
-0.17068403959274292,
-0.025349874049425125,
-0.9688236117362976,
0.027997668832540512,
-0.2942698001861572,
-0.9034065008163452,
0.39975616335868835,
-0.17327408492565155,
-0.3365567624568939,
0.2959882616996765,
0.4111761152744293,
0.044374220073223114,
-0.5304785966873169,
0.22094684839248657,
0.15345390141010284,
0.1397349238395691,
0.12578065693378448,
-0.7482408881187439,
0.27912789583206177,
-0.5021077990531921,
-0.530208945274353,
-0.34299802780151367,
0.04862536862492561,
1.1059409379959106,
-0.15624001622200012,
0.5686822533607483,
0.2492028772830963,
-0.44751593470573425,
-0.7782465219497681,
-0.23192718625068665,
-0.22640933096408844,
-0.4520719349384308,
0.1485603004693985,
-0.4528900384902954,
-0.9770610928535461,
0.576901376247406,
-0.2524698078632355,
0.38687869906425476,
0.39095738530158997,
1.1629464626312256,
0.03703302890062332,
0.7558201551437378,
0.6903665065765381,
-0.10749264806509018,
0.6391814947128296,
-0.16521774232387543,
-0.2807072699069977,
-0.6589652299880981,
-0.1307179480791092,
-0.221229687333107,
-0.25953951478004456,
0.085688516497612,
-0.7776485681533813,
0.11309921741485596,
0.20534272491931915,
-0.14491389691829681,
0.2959206700325012,
-0.250479519367218,
0.5291672348976135,
0.6165842413902283,
0.07937847822904587,
0.33231642842292786,
-0.28881970047950745,
-0.04065225273370743,
0.4000675678253174,
-0.5807058811187744,
-0.596291720867157,
0.8610572218894958,
0.4426005482673645,
1.1998308897018433,
0.13024982810020447,
0.5091830492019653,
0.7973612546920776,
0.38251450657844543,
-0.9424251914024353,
0.3814401626586914,
0.16448919475078583,
-0.6354800462722778,
-0.3033488094806671,
-0.33342453837394714,
-0.6923984885215759,
0.21741563081741333,
-0.07947196066379547,
-0.8506154417991638,
-0.06739776581525803,
0.3744732141494751,
-0.4657858908176422,
0.4491029977798462,
-0.9565964937210083,
0.6017653942108154,
-0.18238064646720886,
-0.36813709139823914,
-0.4098200500011444,
-0.37143296003341675,
0.35298848152160645,
0.014230814762413502,
0.26829734444618225,
-0.5024673938751221,
0.11418042331933975,
0.3476412296295166,
-0.7267034649848938,
1.0940803289413452,
-0.27507415413856506,
-0.39151936769485474,
0.6751283407211304,
0.2788141071796417,
0.5840326547622681,
0.11585092544555664,
-0.3119222819805145,
-0.4147699177265167,
-0.18712115287780762,
-0.31862276792526245,
-0.8515004515647888,
0.5982952117919922,
-0.8838484883308411,
-0.8005304336547852,
-0.0783747062087059,
-0.749855637550354,
-0.45326176285743713,
0.03211042657494545,
-0.21151195466518402,
0.2672596871852875,
-0.1897907555103302,
-0.08839292824268341,
0.7356048226356506,
0.07031109929084778,
0.15032806992530823,
0.8974584937095642,
-0.5249575972557068,
-0.2909671664237976,
0.9149576425552368,
-0.297268807888031,
0.48589447140693665,
0.5918555855751038,
0.11414002627134323,
0.1257743537425995,
-0.30699360370635986,
-0.6941083669662476,
-0.054005347192287445,
-0.4746977984905243,
-0.11900525540113449,
-0.3475150167942047,
-0.1676802933216095,
-0.4421393871307373,
-0.24069778621196747,
-0.6534824967384338,
-0.2269468456506729,
-0.27348458766937256,
-0.08866782486438751,
0.6505787968635559,
0.9181269407272339,
-0.1231771782040596,
0.24352341890335083,
-0.8436501622200012,
0.2610900402069092,
0.5739391446113586,
0.4814845323562622,
-0.05814503878355026,
-0.5184475779533386,
-0.5326622724533081,
-0.05514942854642868,
-0.15030351281166077,
-0.6977273225784302,
0.09425889700651169,
0.472988098859787,
0.5341782569885254,
0.5795935988426208,
0.21465419232845306,
0.15335935354232788,
-0.410347044467926,
0.6161423921585083,
-0.08312539756298065,
-0.9461882710456848,
0.9263677000999451,
-0.5341913104057312,
0.3240220546722412,
0.2607373595237732,
0.15156297385692596,
-0.3766583800315857,
-0.730678915977478,
-0.2340174913406372,
-0.8149685263633728,
1.1134004592895508,
-0.03377840667963028,
0.14292877912521362,
0.1940988004207611,
0.4032858610153198,
0.2311265766620636,
0.1105562299489975,
-0.23206235468387604,
-0.010774029418826103,
0.18376560509204865,
-0.07653993368148804,
0.22506393492221832,
-0.03852584585547447,
-0.41430139541625977,
-0.12171120941638947,
1.0001873970031738,
-0.44032859802246094,
0.20292991399765015,
0.20873916149139404,
-0.4215361177921295,
-0.33861982822418213,
0.5001217722892761,
0.5223158001899719,
0.6626469492912292,
-0.04579102247953415,
0.3394736051559448,
0.23217003047466278,
-0.08293218165636063,
0.19174939393997192,
-0.1945919692516327,
-0.18270449340343475,
-0.4110996425151825,
0.3339383602142334,
1.1488330364227295,
0.24130301177501678,
-0.7469792366027832,
0.10984993726015091,
0.06137771159410477,
-0.3247394859790802,
-0.11675729602575302,
0.631657600402832,
0.16959336400032043,
0.8621637225151062,
0.19824203848838806,
0.3898272216320038,
-0.15967866778373718,
-0.8097107410430908,
0.4361690282821655,
-0.020837267860770226,
-0.5228307247161865,
-0.7456398010253906,
0.6374862194061279,
0.4448907971382141,
-0.38303741812705994,
0.3259309232234955,
-0.27207592129707336,
-0.4148324131965637,
0.40652480721473694,
0.5184885859489441,
0.7598035931587219,
-0.2438143938779831,
0.473595529794693,
-0.06697160005569458,
0.2998667359352112,
-0.45870402455329895,
0.3176753520965576,
-0.10922511667013168,
-1.1580506563186646,
-0.49665144085884094,
-0.7974113821983337,
-0.7434808611869812,
-0.4415685832500458,
-0.49881115555763245,
0.1397871971130371,
-0.6149569153785706,
-0.07238771766424179,
-0.2296372652053833,
-0.3413422107696533,
-0.2126893401145935,
0.05015173926949501,
0.2862115204334259,
0.9615634679794312,
-0.8408979177474976,
0.9659329056739807,
1.1208771467208862,
-0.37790632247924805,
-0.6041502356529236,
-0.1101718321442604,
0.2530651092529297,
-0.9814513921737671,
0.18071754276752472,
-0.16743744909763336,
-0.41730737686157227,
-0.07058082520961761,
-0.4563327729701996,
-0.7774795889854431,
0.9096589684486389,
0.8520955443382263,
-0.5122830271720886,
0.02687564305961132,
-0.12611016631126404,
0.8411391377449036,
-0.4659838080406189,
-0.003545495681464672,
0.7119571566581726,
0.3806823790073395,
0.17784498631954193,
-0.8664451837539673,
-0.18882611393928528,
-0.3823603689670563,
-0.2923767566680908,
0.3191184401512146,
-0.6903992891311646,
0.6449916958808899,
-0.5215930342674255,
-0.0031529858242720366,
-0.024789458140730858,
0.8928170204162598,
0.06549455225467682,
0.48113855719566345,
0.7255470752716064,
0.7875087857246399,
0.8462756872177124,
0.0705069750547409,
0.9835222959518433,
-0.3965870440006256,
0.14624446630477905,
1.263569712638855,
-0.4398837983608246,
0.7815263271331787,
0.23362956941127777,
-0.1978650838136673,
0.90723717212677,
0.3137094974517822,
0.22265255451202393,
0.4261549413204193,
0.3278703987598419,
-0.3623754680156708,
-0.36787867546081543,
-0.1544233113527298,
-0.032895710319280624,
0.275738000869751,
0.5989840626716614,
-0.3068203926086426,
-0.13187144696712494,
0.047575708478689194,
0.04213561862707138,
0.09478834271430969,
-0.6350423693656921,
0.8270151019096375,
0.24022836983203888,
-0.9466871619224548,
0.09838764369487762,
-0.013615542091429234,
0.5264326930046082,
-0.7243059277534485,
0.14918453991413116,
-0.21894285082817078,
0.5791206359863281,
-0.45944568514823914,
-0.7455862164497375,
0.7208719849586487,
0.08948945254087448,
-0.5868878960609436,
-0.37539446353912354,
0.8976330757141113,
-0.4332413077354431,
-0.13546036183834076,
0.4684428870677948,
0.5619779825210571,
0.10289616882801056,
-0.2534532845020294,
-0.4777321219444275,
-0.11954464763402939,
-0.057848475873470306,
-0.5648837685585022,
0.26206478476524353,
0.6742164492607117,
-0.24692396819591522,
0.7802411913871765,
0.5243180990219116,
0.1179211437702179,
0.03187263756990433,
0.05430079624056816,
0.8706455230712891,
-0.464622437953949,
-0.17440015077590942,
-0.83826744556427,
0.5180175304412842,
0.24005825817584991,
-0.31536760926246643,
0.46137309074401855,
0.3322252035140991,
0.7014920115470886,
-0.14265947043895721,
0.8813062906265259,
-0.2038828283548355,
0.2171301692724228,
-0.54071444272995,
0.6345607042312622,
-0.56705641746521,
0.2707009017467499,
-0.024754250422120094,
-0.9725192785263062,
-0.14450107514858246,
0.4386562705039978,
-0.22901451587677002,
-0.2972516119480133,
0.5436897277832031,
0.9677730202674866,
0.08951139450073242,
-0.22312471270561218,
0.3804619014263153,
0.5232440829277039,
0.16230352222919464,
0.6033836007118225,
0.9872738718986511,
0.09273314476013184,
0.44887277483940125,
0.031174512580037117,
-0.39688965678215027,
-0.18115104734897614,
-0.5655076503753662,
-0.7928263545036316,
-0.5829488635063171,
-0.3702290654182434,
-0.31795433163642883,
0.11648590862751007,
1.129777193069458,
0.8913198113441467,
-1.0085058212280273,
-0.2563140392303467,
-0.07407772541046143,
0.5123929977416992,
-0.24090103805065155,
-0.2316063642501831,
-0.10822850465774536,
-0.6006736159324646,
-0.7125668525695801,
0.7755933403968811,
0.7630881667137146,
-0.3674573600292206,
-0.3246990442276001,
-0.3602047860622406,
0.16895043849945068,
0.268947035074234,
0.6515924334526062,
0.3664427101612091,
-0.623656690120697,
-0.331304669380188,
-0.06465474516153336,
-0.17865359783172607,
0.010538722388446331,
0.8809266686439514,
-0.4557112753391266,
0.5376012325286865,
0.5984942317008972,
0.7265956401824951,
0.34192270040512085,
-0.37546077370643616,
1.066208004951477,
-0.6054778099060059,
0.0024255060125142336,
0.17436930537223816,
0.4979574382305145,
0.0789044201374054,
-0.17891766130924225,
0.5958120226860046,
0.26524072885513306,
-0.6417943239212036,
-0.4524027407169342,
0.386933296918869,
-1.0230623483657837,
-0.1537979245185852,
1.327864170074463,
-0.35000211000442505,
-0.5125122666358948,
-0.11229917407035828,
-0.3569887578487396,
0.01417375449091196,
-0.7273359894752502,
0.7871158719062805,
0.6838894486427307,
-0.3374303877353668,
0.020717933773994446,
-0.11203967034816742,
0.2630472183227539,
0.19400480389595032,
-1.190034031867981,
0.11592265218496323,
0.5351954102516174,
0.3773878216743469,
0.1467583030462265,
0.9482961297035217,
0.08619451522827148,
0.17503969371318817,
0.03704298287630081,
0.3600675165653229,
0.07995022088289261,
-0.45621374249458313,
-0.0863679051399231,
0.16087406873703003,
0.5048325657844543,
-0.02858027070760727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01453v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01453v1 | The Queen of England is not England's Queen: On the Lack of Factual Coherency in PLMs | 2024-02-02T14:42:09 | 2024-02-02T14:42:09 | Paul Youssef, Jörg Schlötterer, Christin Seifert | cs.CL | cs.CL | Factual knowledge encoded in Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) enriches
their representations and justifies their use as knowledge bases. Previous work
has focused on probing PLMs for factual knowledge by measuring how often they
can correctly predict an object entity given a subject and a relation, and
improving fact retrieval by optimizing the prompts used for querying PLMs. In
this work, we consider a complementary aspect, namely the coherency of factual
knowledge in PLMs, i.e., how often can PLMs predict the subject entity given
its initial prediction of the object entity. This goes beyond evaluating how
much PLMs know, and focuses on the internal state of knowledge inside them. Our
results indicate that PLMs have low coherency using manually written, optimized
and paraphrased prompts, but including an evidence paragraph leads to
substantial improvement. This shows that PLMs fail to model inverse relations
and need further enhancements to be able to handle retrieving facts from their
parameters in a coherent manner, and to be considered as knowledge bases. | [
-0.44934776425361633,
-0.4478381276130676,
0.7940676212310791,
-0.028285207226872444,
-0.4867408573627472,
0.1948506236076355,
-0.014993305318057537,
-0.4079812169075012,
0.04675084352493286,
0.49577271938323975,
-0.39563554525375366,
-0.34678155183792114,
-0.4832690954208374,
0.18414506316184998,
-0.2741231620311737,
0.6989330649375916,
0.060032282024621964,
0.20414462685585022,
-0.8509331941604614,
-0.32097917795181274,
-0.25174686312675476,
-0.6535623669624329,
-0.11818432807922363,
-0.19016362726688385,
0.1946406364440918,
0.577865481376648,
0.6320192813873291,
0.42479512095451355,
0.6289007067680359,
0.23597146570682526,
-0.008534610271453857,
0.5779877305030823,
-0.6336699724197388,
0.15470625460147858,
-0.4121180474758148,
-0.7157127261161804,
-0.1853160560131073,
0.08002985268831253,
0.4949879050254822,
1.1220253705978394,
0.05307811498641968,
0.10329993814229965,
0.23135636746883392,
0.6293923854827881,
-0.5702380537986755,
0.33518680930137634,
-0.6582498550415039,
0.011414242908358574,
0.043094657361507416,
-0.2718224823474884,
-0.41556644439697266,
-0.302826464176178,
0.6923949718475342,
-0.5048150420188904,
0.5215777158737183,
0.5903178453445435,
0.985526978969574,
0.11430282145738602,
-0.4287998080253601,
-0.5082178115844727,
-0.5613493323326111,
0.9090714454650879,
-0.38922542333602905,
0.6659359931945801,
0.3889816105365753,
0.033331338316202164,
-0.17774635553359985,
-0.4199243187904358,
-0.6468709111213684,
-0.6436777114868164,
-0.35671404004096985,
0.13075153529644012,
0.07399225234985352,
0.06312260776758194,
0.24735064804553986,
0.3607461154460907,
-0.3734583854675293,
-0.3419738709926605,
-0.08819274604320526,
-0.39444398880004883,
0.32020431756973267,
-0.009767228737473488,
0.31811365485191345,
-0.3334338963031769,
-0.7058866024017334,
0.21687579154968262,
-0.9147210717201233,
0.34748944640159607,
0.17929916083812714,
0.12110259383916855,
-0.1644006222486496,
0.577940821647644,
0.0896945595741272,
0.6255613565444946,
0.13912233710289001,
-0.6014991402626038,
-0.23764872550964355,
-0.4124625027179718,
0.05308006331324577,
0.10552690178155899,
0.5233783721923828,
0.09109096974134445,
-0.10462862998247147,
-0.4816772937774658,
-0.016533657908439636,
0.15737052261829376,
-0.05692314729094505,
-0.6269112825393677,
-0.4800623655319214,
0.1583944857120514,
-0.13542184233665466,
0.29735156893730164,
0.4205002188682556,
-0.2866900861263275,
-0.11580510437488556,
-0.37036213278770447,
0.5446372032165527,
-0.5618158578872681,
-0.16373980045318604,
0.11593426764011383,
-0.31216374039649963,
0.08935457468032837,
0.3744012415409088,
-0.6411141753196716,
0.1886758655309677,
0.8436663150787354,
0.6670312881469727,
-0.21194785833358765,
-0.21970117092132568,
-0.25815317034721375,
0.45947104692459106,
-0.4766075909137726,
0.84258633852005,
-0.3469119071960449,
-0.3986256420612335,
-0.30227676033973694,
0.04347144812345505,
0.09201245754957199,
-0.7202719449996948,
0.500771164894104,
-0.5643030405044556,
0.3030953109264374,
-1.0284947156906128,
-0.7736673951148987,
-0.2948044240474701,
0.1560148000717163,
-0.6422908902168274,
0.3611520230770111,
-0.14788036048412323,
-0.7401517629623413,
0.6428741216659546,
-0.19388718903064728,
-0.6165416240692139,
-0.07402358949184418,
-0.2737589478492737,
-0.46450960636138916,
0.08935043960809708,
0.14933571219444275,
0.3483467400074005,
-0.14841407537460327,
0.5490398406982422,
-0.5175721645355225,
-0.31471219658851624,
0.28035348653793335,
-0.19880779087543488,
0.5196666717529297,
0.006384382490068674,
-0.028711479157209396,
-0.3966423273086548,
-0.8336222767829895,
-0.3954441547393799,
-0.29681894183158875,
-0.35776281356811523,
-0.4758144021034241,
0.30614709854125977,
-0.9589852094650269,
0.09935719519853592,
0.26772424578666687,
-0.6431049108505249,
-0.3169042468070984,
-0.5192539095878601,
0.1800316721200943,
0.36911994218826294,
0.04141784459352493,
0.6096003651618958,
-0.8357831835746765,
0.14492805302143097,
0.3586069345474243,
-0.20804259181022644,
-0.10054495930671692,
-0.46469181776046753,
-0.9434179663658142,
-0.45822736620903015,
0.006192724220454693,
0.34166109561920166,
-0.8034107089042664,
0.5007973909378052,
-0.3079708218574524,
-0.2558121681213379,
-0.520110547542572,
0.0411517433822155,
0.4650568962097168,
0.926516056060791,
0.5201607346534729,
-0.3011353313922882,
-0.8837894201278687,
-0.7804365754127502,
-0.5483174324035645,
-0.4018392860889435,
0.27446767687797546,
0.268076092004776,
0.5559781789779663,
0.3700239658355713,
1.217756986618042,
-0.08858226239681244,
0.013300594873726368,
-0.18631497025489807,
0.29401153326034546,
0.0366414375603199,
0.43686604499816895,
0.2898603677749634,
-0.7246937155723572,
-0.43919637799263,
-0.3836953043937683,
-0.8033938407897949,
0.016821658238768578,
0.08550021052360535,
-0.1500803530216217,
0.2564789652824402,
0.06803716719150543,
-0.6548437476158142,
0.18856172263622284,
0.3858117163181305,
-0.29741013050079346,
0.5347747206687927,
-0.1569274365901947,
0.14879298210144043,
-0.7661992907524109,
0.04667898640036583,
-0.32298311591148376,
-0.4663817882537842,
-0.46503058075904846,
-0.2737087607383728,
0.00449778139591217,
-0.01270431000739336,
-0.22649501264095306,
0.258618026971817,
-0.7521229982376099,
-0.31336042284965515,
-0.22518862783908844,
0.2448568344116211,
0.5404642820358276,
0.24797925353050232,
0.32467177510261536,
0.8820741772651672,
0.39996278285980225,
-0.8589690923690796,
0.21436239778995514,
0.4541301727294922,
-0.47030946612358093,
0.8045689463615417,
-0.26550862193107605,
0.039220236241817474,
-0.29101628065109253,
-0.046870388090610504,
-1.0717159509658813,
-0.09427441656589508,
0.04603787139058113,
-0.3036251962184906,
0.32397782802581787,
-0.05333606153726578,
-0.26415157318115234,
-0.1568775624036789,
-0.27943846583366394,
-0.10597532987594604,
0.6131106615066528,
-0.7293495535850525,
0.4717715382575989,
0.43841949105262756,
-0.14469429850578308,
-0.6200007796287537,
-0.7722101211547852,
-0.08259329199790955,
0.22348062694072723,
-0.8760617971420288,
0.26908770203590393,
-0.04908802732825279,
-0.4942285120487213,
0.26019948720932007,
-0.4887223541736603,
-0.11327984929084778,
0.10220983624458313,
0.11786903440952301,
0.20563040673732758,
-0.40945225954055786,
0.23640355467796326,
-0.08005892485380173,
0.2168647050857544,
0.27337074279785156,
-0.13783296942710876,
0.2167050540447235,
0.01995840296149254,
-0.5660736560821533,
-0.6210136413574219,
0.19636324048042297,
0.3540591299533844,
-0.03115302324295044,
0.9749911427497864,
-0.07975327968597412,
-0.10344037413597107,
-0.30847564339637756,
-0.6385117173194885,
-0.2740550935268402,
-0.3923909068107605,
0.15619972348213196,
-0.5866501331329346,
-0.7670574188232422,
0.5223739743232727,
0.13688404858112335,
-0.2563755512237549,
0.4215672016143799,
0.13668173551559448,
-0.596308171749115,
0.8662272095680237,
0.6596335768699646,
0.27754679322242737,
0.032606661319732666,
-0.24284476041793823,
0.2000463306903839,
-0.5589182376861572,
-0.5444181561470032,
-0.38367632031440735,
0.05074677988886833,
-0.43749794363975525,
-0.19640520215034485,
0.46277719736099243,
0.21905234456062317,
-0.22619065642356873,
0.21051254868507385,
0.027746127918362617,
0.19062303006649017,
0.4340265989303589,
0.3882136344909668,
0.6155067086219788,
-0.1071537509560585,
-0.22518491744995117,
-0.1574687361717224,
-0.9867354035377502,
-0.6634314060211182,
0.7432864904403687,
0.23349638283252716,
0.6993550062179565,
0.2476920634508133,
0.48892447352409363,
-0.13163018226623535,
0.17767281830310822,
-0.6026532053947449,
0.6087451577186584,
-0.1417873054742813,
-0.5838602185249329,
-0.12409137189388275,
-0.5435997247695923,
-0.6966401934623718,
0.2725139260292053,
-0.22811900079250336,
0.005576774012297392,
0.44886523485183716,
0.25150588154792786,
-0.723046064376831,
0.3148549199104309,
-0.7051700353622437,
0.587797999382019,
-0.20167525112628937,
-0.5179767608642578,
-0.09034183621406555,
-0.48109957575798035,
0.43608954548835754,
0.0627843588590622,
0.1517595648765564,
-0.12056300044059753,
-0.2527374029159546,
0.7764462828636169,
-0.765008270740509,
0.7948245406150818,
-0.07650239020586014,
-0.05747396498918533,
0.4484703838825226,
0.07257428765296936,
0.4997643232345581,
-0.0063532814383506775,
0.11013031005859375,
-0.22877982258796692,
0.2910884618759155,
-0.5595126152038574,
-0.5604850649833679,
0.34470629692077637,
-0.8206601142883301,
-0.8412862420082092,
-0.45332714915275574,
-0.53305584192276,
-0.4858880937099457,
-0.11945684999227524,
0.17290645837783813,
0.5875299572944641,
-0.23895670473575592,
0.3750000596046448,
0.974960446357727,
-0.02248518355190754,
0.18546059727668762,
0.9097306728363037,
0.021403318271040916,
-0.24054329097270966,
0.9155530333518982,
0.5953919887542725,
0.30342617630958557,
0.6528633832931519,
0.09492430835962296,
-0.6052200794219971,
-0.66672283411026,
-0.008199522271752357,
0.28150463104248047,
-0.8549835681915283,
-0.14743153750896454,
-0.6627717018127441,
0.07826555520296097,
-0.5296868085861206,
0.1694830060005188,
0.020919475704431534,
-0.28519704937934875,
-0.48465466499328613,
-0.14834241569042206,
0.2580142617225647,
0.8600071668624878,
-0.033000558614730835,
0.11314117163419724,
-0.8395864367485046,
0.5070938467979431,
0.5760100483894348,
0.28841516375541687,
-0.30487456917762756,
-0.8278157711029053,
-0.08950940519571304,
0.004052887205034494,
0.005925656296312809,
-0.9850074648857117,
0.28614819049835205,
0.2815234661102295,
0.8113762140274048,
0.35251089930534363,
0.31670576333999634,
0.7637280821800232,
-0.3253950774669647,
0.8024522662162781,
0.02690613828599453,
-0.9054785370826721,
0.2818734645843506,
-0.011407339945435524,
-0.04455262050032616,
0.5524219274520874,
0.6758877635002136,
-0.02806471846997738,
-0.4874228835105896,
-0.7209997177124023,
-0.4055154025554657,
0.6588155627250671,
-0.17724467813968658,
-0.09068566560745239,
0.053244464099407196,
0.2958809435367584,
0.557794988155365,
0.7252281308174133,
-0.39230236411094666,
-0.15579715371131897,
-0.1875980794429779,
-0.26281818747520447,
-0.01225147396326065,
-0.7091935873031616,
-0.045790623873472214,
-0.3277477025985718,
0.8190807104110718,
0.11347715556621552,
0.17167288064956665,
0.5177549719810486,
-0.5636714696884155,
-0.18508285284042358,
0.21286433935165405,
0.48589080572128296,
1.1121208667755127,
-0.38467612862586975,
0.6761172413825989,
0.22039271891117096,
-0.5561402440071106,
0.09741858392953873,
0.038646161556243896,
-0.3110714852809906,
0.2170351892709732,
0.5527477860450745,
0.8474831581115723,
0.31138673424720764,
-0.5119877457618713,
0.5505266189575195,
0.26933637261390686,
0.012390718795359135,
-0.3146657645702362,
0.001636606059037149,
0.042565539479255676,
0.13038070499897003,
0.25635331869125366,
0.18439418077468872,
-0.1361277997493744,
-0.9964638948440552,
0.46688076853752136,
0.6650449633598328,
-0.16081058979034424,
-0.5872551202774048,
0.31903329491615295,
0.4064413011074066,
0.061585988849401474,
0.17534086108207703,
-0.4955442547798157,
-0.6634649038314819,
0.40857136249542236,
0.45629584789276123,
0.3593192398548126,
0.02075558342039585,
0.026060575619339943,
0.27651962637901306,
0.40411439538002014,
-0.22984574735164642,
0.720551609992981,
-0.050970036536455154,
-0.8678426742553711,
-0.5457703471183777,
-0.49510565400123596,
-0.7597166895866394,
0.025360096246004105,
-0.4545191526412964,
0.27047890424728394,
-0.5763370990753174,
-0.002521567279472947,
-0.3766791522502899,
0.3590678870677948,
-0.6547524929046631,
0.20108170807361603,
-0.046101752668619156,
0.901874840259552,
-0.6929959058761597,
0.7192701697349548,
0.46381160616874695,
-0.5884842276573181,
-0.9269689321517944,
-0.02258901484310627,
-0.4887867271900177,
-0.6600346565246582,
0.6388648748397827,
0.08496196568012238,
-0.18666914105415344,
0.019368603825569153,
-0.6441699266433716,
-0.843270480632782,
1.0917527675628662,
0.8840655088424683,
-0.6136392951011658,
0.0608314573764801,
0.3704332411289215,
0.3584103286266327,
-0.288332462310791,
0.21734994649887085,
0.45292964577674866,
0.39421823620796204,
0.15356723964214325,
-0.8218408823013306,
0.04044684022665024,
0.38826784491539,
-0.2830347716808319,
-0.13153356313705444,
-0.5888813734054565,
1.0116703510284424,
-0.18042166531085968,
-0.6192052960395813,
0.07591405510902405,
1.010259985923767,
0.12695948779582977,
0.29274484515190125,
0.35211268067359924,
0.8354550004005432,
1.0400049686431885,
-0.2291325032711029,
0.9700422883033752,
-0.39213982224464417,
0.26904356479644775,
1.1521854400634766,
-0.3743895888328552,
0.7646568417549133,
0.43847668170928955,
-0.3158016800880432,
0.7529252767562866,
0.3331013321876526,
0.07285421341657639,
0.6057894229888916,
-0.1859135925769806,
-0.29682213068008423,
-0.49987033009529114,
-0.2624550759792328,
-0.23848164081573486,
0.21689462661743164,
0.16861122846603394,
-0.23377299308776855,
-0.3336871862411499,
0.033078633248806,
-0.07050550729036331,
0.34706518054008484,
-0.4546446204185486,
0.8670084476470947,
0.22109726071357727,
-0.9233391880989075,
0.5077897310256958,
-0.36550384759902954,
0.579036295413971,
-0.38923004269599915,
-0.0010680360719561577,
-0.15999829769134521,
-0.07511664181947708,
-0.2563346326351166,
-0.7684938907623291,
0.4476727247238159,
-0.22955860197544098,
-0.3505255877971649,
-0.06061319261789322,
0.8958222270011902,
-0.719461977481842,
-0.15747451782226562,
0.06777149438858032,
0.8353240489959717,
0.1960296928882599,
-0.10028615593910217,
-0.3865686357021332,
-0.11772221326828003,
-0.28320175409317017,
0.03773445263504982,
0.006358631420880556,
0.6417480707168579,
0.2662445902824402,
0.5666038990020752,
0.5188577175140381,
0.09727262705564499,
0.07429630309343338,
-0.24144235253334045,
0.5737698674201965,
-0.5768455266952515,
-0.4998230040073395,
-0.8793866634368896,
0.35224953293800354,
-0.002850749297067523,
0.18563461303710938,
0.9666153788566589,
0.6417860388755798,
0.7702462077140808,
-0.03138391301035881,
0.9927933216094971,
0.1725451648235321,
1.0757416486740112,
-0.6041801571846008,
0.5459702014923096,
-0.17242668569087982,
0.37436044216156006,
0.35133376717567444,
-0.481113463640213,
0.1035148948431015,
0.3378397822380066,
-0.6836056709289551,
-0.20819582045078278,
0.7682071924209595,
0.8170136213302612,
-0.05711280182003975,
0.3433644473552704,
0.5747615098953247,
0.41271618008613586,
-0.11384202539920807,
0.2606458067893982,
1.2215689420700073,
-0.08996833860874176,
0.4810623824596405,
-0.37325945496559143,
0.09099744260311127,
-0.0929996594786644,
-0.8603116273880005,
-1.0333863496780396,
-0.5901749134063721,
-0.2641301453113556,
-0.33272695541381836,
0.3211141526699066,
1.0400243997573853,
0.660566508769989,
-1.0522509813308716,
-0.14059558510780334,
-0.22200149297714233,
0.3688817620277405,
0.20198595523834229,
-0.1127844750881195,
0.2866848111152649,
-0.5655824542045593,
-0.34130698442459106,
0.44014617800712585,
0.20298998057842255,
0.2659968137741089,
-0.4679489731788635,
0.022913848981261253,
-0.32617074251174927,
0.2291380912065506,
0.5686971545219421,
0.15122194588184357,
-0.6629878878593445,
-0.5700048208236694,
0.1186019703745842,
-0.22613084316253662,
0.3316975235939026,
0.53914475440979,
-0.8422434329986572,
0.42387253046035767,
0.9318998456001282,
0.42232587933540344,
0.024284860119223595,
0.2156343162059784,
0.5436695218086243,
-0.783723771572113,
0.0750318244099617,
0.43920978903770447,
0.56352299451828,
0.7138229012489319,
-0.2834782600402832,
0.010828517377376556,
0.784612238407135,
-0.3399154245853424,
-0.7984112501144409,
0.3057384192943573,
-0.8162040114402771,
-0.3631371855735779,
0.8038001656532288,
-0.46249625086784363,
-0.6041414737701416,
-0.6878894567489624,
-0.08566241711378098,
0.27382946014404297,
-0.2841522991657257,
0.49465397000312805,
0.8385090827941895,
-0.2686421275138855,
-0.058895111083984375,
-0.3455086946487427,
0.8015936017036438,
0.5109897255897522,
-0.4877818524837494,
-0.2738581597805023,
0.2823701798915863,
0.5118483304977417,
0.3899178206920624,
0.47702863812446594,
0.16673098504543304,
0.13547448813915253,
-0.06570320576429367,
-0.09929818660020828,
-0.09030888974666595,
-0.44895172119140625,
-0.15612559020519257,
0.46903401613235474,
0.3860364854335785,
-0.03719169646501541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01427v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01427v2 | The effect of diversity on group decision-making | 2024-02-02T14:15:01 | 2024-05-20T15:46:42 | Georgi Karadzhov, Andreas Vlachos, Tom Stafford | cs.CL | cs.CL | We explore different aspects of cognitive diversity and its effect on the
success of group deliberation. To evaluate this, we use 500 dialogues from
small, online groups discussing the Wason Card Selection task - the DeliData
corpus. Leveraging the corpus, we perform quantitative analysis evaluating
three different measures of cognitive diversity. First, we analyse the effect
of group size as a proxy measure for diversity. Second, we evaluate the effect
of the size of the initial idea pool. Finally, we look into the content of the
discussion by analysing discussed solutions, discussion patterns, and how
conversational probing can improve those characteristics. Despite the
reputation of groups for compounding bias, we show that small groups can,
through dialogue, overcome intuitive biases and improve individual
decision-making. Across a large sample and different operationalisations, we
consistently find that greater cognitive diversity is associated with more
successful group deliberation. Code and data used for the analysis are
available in the repository:
https://github.com/gkaradzhov/cognitive-diversity-groups-cogsci24. | [
-1.0532959699630737,
-0.6725785732269287,
0.3616264760494232,
0.20963700115680695,
-0.3222663104534149,
0.5014877915382385,
-0.4718858301639557,
-0.670542299747467,
0.4828037917613983,
0.09332305192947388,
-0.530619204044342,
-0.5411739945411682,
-0.7034163475036621,
0.08903996646404266,
-0.08168741315603256,
0.9970218539237976,
0.492662638425827,
0.2621960937976837,
0.11979600042104721,
-0.4194720387458801,
-0.6369379758834839,
-0.2170300930738449,
-0.9990367889404297,
-0.17363139986991882,
0.4931829273700714,
0.5779759883880615,
0.7216315269470215,
0.09667083621025085,
0.3276228606700897,
0.2976076304912567,
-0.5987818837165833,
-0.07992320507764816,
-0.8003873825073242,
-0.127198725938797,
-0.3290754556655884,
-0.7663989067077637,
-0.2589864432811737,
0.37475112080574036,
0.4604104459285736,
0.8996332287788391,
-0.33108264207839966,
-0.008301367983222008,
0.05705554410815239,
0.7037404775619507,
-0.42115283012390137,
-0.12592190504074097,
-0.8540169596672058,
0.36111122369766235,
-0.06152584031224251,
0.21754424273967743,
0.025588136166334152,
-0.4446367025375366,
0.5279632806777954,
-0.6651574969291687,
0.21989351511001587,
0.22939759492874146,
0.13472022116184235,
0.3078066110610962,
-0.504342794418335,
-0.5457482933998108,
-0.8423977494239807,
0.9002686738967896,
-0.255202054977417,
-0.03624790906906128,
0.6488844752311707,
0.2853653132915497,
-0.17218200862407684,
-0.47908303141593933,
-0.48324793577194214,
0.2786039412021637,
0.03151114657521248,
0.5796723961830139,
-0.2394203245639801,
-0.01008478831499815,
0.4032536745071411,
0.7770097255706787,
-0.27652010321617126,
0.16259872913360596,
-0.9760801196098328,
0.0511937290430069,
0.722278356552124,
0.2858962118625641,
0.40630894899368286,
0.005561442114412785,
0.2272784560918808,
0.09846717119216919,
-0.20129956305027008,
0.052702758461236954,
0.6729846000671387,
0.029122445732355118,
0.004284684080630541,
0.257562518119812,
-0.45059844851493835,
0.3346501588821411,
0.29466143250465393,
0.21780355274677277,
0.2021244615316391,
-0.6882801651954651,
-0.05675322934985161,
-0.012524010613560677,
0.49312442541122437,
0.5061265230178833,
0.15848468244075775,
0.12111595273017883,
0.22283247113227844,
0.22130614519119263,
0.24228982627391815,
-0.6322927474975586,
-0.33415722846984863,
0.13578243553638458,
-0.9388516545295715,
-0.0071206106804311275,
0.08634167909622192,
-1.0865800380706787,
-0.40704208612442017,
-0.12321333587169647,
-0.13996213674545288,
-0.23692412674427032,
-0.18478649854660034,
0.20841780304908752,
-0.8427639007568359,
0.27370527386665344,
0.7198660373687744,
-0.9627459645271301,
0.5790517330169678,
0.44210806488990784,
0.5475717186927795,
-0.6642547249794006,
-0.03415098041296005,
-0.24588921666145325,
-0.15412671864032745,
-0.06551069021224976,
0.7296946048736572,
-0.6201649904251099,
-1.1757529973983765,
-0.24633663892745972,
-0.47767773270606995,
-0.05241648852825165,
-0.874609649181366,
0.5282740592956543,
-0.33073803782463074,
0.678277313709259,
-0.56355220079422,
-0.39213863015174866,
-0.2935656011104584,
0.3875228762626648,
-1.0614120960235596,
0.4110132157802582,
0.09261445701122284,
-0.6389312148094177,
0.7782493233680725,
-0.7252525687217712,
-0.38151365518569946,
0.359783411026001,
-0.7679299712181091,
-0.16161707043647766,
0.12281778454780579,
0.25164109468460083,
-0.28346073627471924,
-0.2566766142845154,
-0.27499920129776,
-0.553864061832428,
-0.3927435278892517,
0.48806917667388916,
-0.09256397187709808,
0.9871745109558105,
0.47428780794143677,
-0.18368001282215118,
0.23257282376289368,
-0.2965828478336334,
0.19378376007080078,
-0.3030846118927002,
-0.4929904341697693,
-0.5374547243118286,
0.11359822005033493,
-0.27307555079460144,
0.15137328207492828,
-0.262777179479599,
-0.42582589387893677,
0.19667132198810577,
0.026700211688876152,
0.4047888517379761,
0.5173854827880859,
0.3172847628593445,
0.643078088760376,
-0.4045492708683014,
0.6520369648933411,
-0.14606107771396637,
0.7243360877037048,
0.4699521064758301,
-0.8907148838043213,
-0.5005085468292236,
-0.6637380123138428,
0.20640107989311218,
0.47455042600631714,
-0.537941038608551,
0.31518906354904175,
-0.007620250340551138,
-0.3768165707588196,
-0.3384060561656952,
0.078628771007061,
-0.05761288106441498,
-0.2284265011548996,
0.14970019459724426,
-0.7471039295196533,
-0.4728856086730957,
-0.6791768670082092,
-0.1789562702178955,
-0.35008788108825684,
0.12028385698795319,
0.4283987581729889,
0.5692349076271057,
-0.3620240092277527,
0.9450228214263916,
-0.5637351870536804,
-0.2965281307697296,
-0.4505307972431183,
0.1467617005109787,
0.19530954957008362,
0.3376326262950897,
0.38357359170913696,
-0.8092073202133179,
-0.29616838693618774,
-0.13985319435596466,
-0.45442312955856323,
0.23329095542430878,
0.08481349796056747,
-0.5233961939811707,
-0.0972844660282135,
0.33104830980300903,
-0.6952228546142578,
0.7800116539001465,
0.5384413599967957,
-0.34288614988327026,
0.04630403220653534,
0.0657159611582756,
0.48894813656806946,
-0.7260735630989075,
-0.3775598406791687,
-0.3380574882030487,
0.2957168519496918,
-0.28077757358551025,
-0.4396910071372986,
-0.37731489539146423,
0.11645617336034775,
-0.2293870896100998,
0.09721244126558304,
-0.28055229783058167,
-0.014816222712397575,
-0.13345883786678314,
0.2555645704269409,
-0.23903389275074005,
0.3486984968185425,
-0.3862105906009674,
0.4057396650314331,
0.19090686738491058,
-0.5790811777114868,
-0.06314510107040405,
0.599062442779541,
-0.7679199576377869,
0.593488872051239,
-0.39216816425323486,
-0.010240940377116203,
-0.06761915981769562,
0.4417428970336914,
-1.0950767993927002,
-0.13111896812915802,
0.25203076004981995,
-0.346764475107193,
-0.1559973955154419,
0.10811135172843933,
-0.06151304021477699,
-0.5142412781715393,
-0.5059829950332642,
0.860969066619873,
0.47130677103996277,
-0.30211883783340454,
0.7250499725341797,
0.7171070575714111,
-0.2352413386106491,
-0.3152952492237091,
-0.903278648853302,
-0.11944092810153961,
-0.5329788327217102,
-0.7701932191848755,
0.3154474198818207,
-0.6658775210380554,
-0.7948004007339478,
0.005414372310042381,
-0.09228795766830444,
-0.1260199248790741,
0.1101832389831543,
0.23176410794258118,
0.15639899671077728,
0.19887088239192963,
0.16750940680503845,
0.07628842443227768,
0.1660899966955185,
-0.16426868736743927,
-0.16949434578418732,
0.5345094799995422,
-0.45161107182502747,
-0.30461081862449646,
0.0487392358481884,
0.5091348886489868,
0.2930469810962677,
-0.2717980742454529,
0.5808317065238953,
0.41061562299728394,
-0.04098150134086609,
-0.41756218671798706,
-0.5102194547653198,
-0.19079460203647614,
-0.4297541379928589,
0.1578279733657837,
0.05332391709089279,
-1.2774934768676758,
0.9920609593391418,
0.06976762413978577,
-0.1264115422964096,
0.5255663394927979,
0.7202256321907043,
-0.2568359375,
0.5238562822341919,
0.36302450299263,
0.19229157269001007,
0.7352542877197266,
-0.250573992729187,
0.047447752207517624,
-0.436636358499527,
-0.12335388362407684,
-0.24297843873500824,
-0.740398108959198,
-0.826695442199707,
-0.33491408824920654,
0.41476625204086304,
-0.04051888734102249,
-0.0077303010039031506,
-0.436349093914032,
-0.42214977741241455,
0.7008460760116577,
0.5415751934051514,
0.16377457976341248,
0.36908644437789917,
-0.035870883613824844,
0.16435566544532776,
-0.01545840036123991,
-0.6945639848709106,
-0.18050046265125275,
1.0139851570129395,
-0.02353854663670063,
0.62934410572052,
0.33761081099510193,
0.9002944231033325,
0.6291931867599487,
0.43360215425491333,
-0.8356873393058777,
0.7850979566574097,
-0.08460874855518341,
-0.7928133606910706,
-0.4816354811191559,
-0.5228156447410583,
-1.317428708076477,
0.6973879933357239,
-0.4178009033203125,
-0.518307089805603,
0.3689338266849518,
-0.2277844101190567,
-0.5981484055519104,
0.14025482535362244,
-0.6324825286865234,
0.8167077302932739,
-0.11640463024377823,
0.01624075509607792,
-0.7783285975456238,
-0.34259700775146484,
0.5051258206367493,
-0.2570340633392334,
0.29689866304397583,
0.030294405296444893,
0.1465785950422287,
1.086167812347412,
-0.0046091810800135136,
0.7018855810165405,
0.10008147358894348,
0.14019128680229187,
0.9119603633880615,
-0.19462637603282928,
-0.049632441252470016,
0.10605110973119736,
-0.06981850415468216,
0.40836408734321594,
-0.1693011075258255,
-0.20350445806980133,
-0.6451414227485657,
0.5753615498542786,
-0.9077941179275513,
-0.8057635426521301,
-0.19933950901031494,
-0.49766984581947327,
0.13721320033073425,
-0.07463515549898148,
0.34764546155929565,
-0.10441497713327408,
-0.6485623121261597,
0.3644444942474365,
0.46493595838546753,
-0.11202093958854675,
0.6755188703536987,
0.35926634073257446,
-0.5009849667549133,
-0.9243715405464172,
0.3301215171813965,
0.5082385540008545,
0.4911198616027832,
-0.14063295722007751,
0.09562873840332031,
0.09404200315475464,
-0.5258733034133911,
0.10055222362279892,
0.014876682311296463,
-0.8747189044952393,
0.3249068856239319,
-0.49215489625930786,
0.41885319352149963,
-0.11483028531074524,
0.1269782930612564,
-0.05112558975815773,
-0.8748126029968262,
0.030489733442664146,
-0.29343047738075256,
-0.02059282548725605,
0.7364277243614197,
-0.11975888162851334,
0.5015746355056763,
-0.40264424681663513,
-0.08079846948385239,
0.7410762310028076,
0.30956926941871643,
-0.09532708674669266,
-0.22227303683757782,
-0.19897320866584778,
-0.2613949775695801,
-0.44848954677581787,
-0.8711247444152832,
0.008741612546145916,
-0.34207308292388916,
0.9024539589881897,
0.2824671268463135,
-0.12815973162651062,
0.23018577694892883,
0.13106483221054077,
0.7991958856582642,
0.21951475739479065,
-0.8548816442489624,
0.3600209355354309,
-0.3638404905796051,
0.4252433478832245,
1.0322152376174927,
-0.03157515451312065,
-0.5907782912254333,
-0.455584317445755,
-0.7714919447898865,
-0.5280194282531738,
0.6167735457420349,
0.5602737069129944,
-0.34410062432289124,
-0.28212156891822815,
-0.10028806328773499,
0.1194353774189949,
0.2446591705083847,
-0.5306996703147888,
-0.23243387043476105,
-0.11677924543619156,
0.11466050893068314,
0.1891724318265915,
-0.08617007732391357,
-0.4227130115032196,
-0.4167650043964386,
0.14373943209648132,
0.14796869456768036,
0.11418137699365616,
-0.00990627147257328,
0.3902573585510254,
-0.23790983855724335,
0.5065943002700806,
0.6345545053482056,
0.7432143688201904,
-0.013156919740140438,
0.06600496172904968,
0.6437498331069946,
-0.4709722399711609,
-0.27031439542770386,
-0.14971959590911865,
0.005401692818850279,
-0.25443172454833984,
0.21946050226688385,
0.4132711887359619,
-0.3149946928024292,
-0.3852520287036896,
0.15956714749336243,
-0.7037754058837891,
-0.30821308493614197,
-0.3248155415058136,
0.383786141872406,
-0.008628851734101772,
0.3757789433002472,
0.28188320994377136,
0.39681100845336914,
0.24204875528812408,
-0.8102898001670837,
0.10057156533002853,
0.5003190636634827,
-0.12059184908866882,
0.1010306179523468,
0.1353822499513626,
0.4902423620223999,
-0.34411850571632385,
0.8715541958808899,
-0.2859160602092743,
-0.4439648985862732,
0.9248117208480835,
0.00658304151147604,
0.9013712406158447,
-0.18126840889453888,
0.1315901279449463,
0.18383367359638214,
0.653977632522583,
0.01859232969582081,
0.27345606684684753,
-0.13066095113754272,
-0.8057694435119629,
-0.22723275423049927,
-0.12051121145486832,
-0.42195242643356323,
-0.1247110590338707,
-0.4801661968231201,
-0.2029142826795578,
-0.6444233059883118,
-0.7634407877922058,
-0.2523716390132904,
-0.04727233946323395,
-0.8158193826675415,
0.21126095950603485,
0.20042715966701508,
0.556892991065979,
-0.6425579190254211,
0.46998822689056396,
0.3913628160953522,
-0.4948577582836151,
-0.468227356672287,
0.15849117934703827,
-0.1485356241464615,
-0.44707390666007996,
0.8632020354270935,
0.13900266587734222,
-0.06836836785078049,
-0.4679241180419922,
-0.7012850046157837,
-0.9121434688568115,
1.087560772895813,
-0.07737208902835846,
-0.23853199183940887,
0.5228427052497864,
0.010427016764879227,
0.5669639706611633,
-0.5363991856575012,
0.44260573387145996,
0.4322498142719269,
0.5854595899581909,
0.23907321691513062,
-0.9091544151306152,
-0.2036919742822647,
-0.2635628581047058,
-0.1654956042766571,
0.022014550864696503,
-0.7788154482841492,
1.1245594024658203,
-0.13782143592834473,
-0.39246055483818054,
-0.3121318817138672,
0.8051959276199341,
0.2068423330783844,
0.3680751621723175,
0.8445913195610046,
0.3839409053325653,
1.3907091617584229,
-0.0050234743393957615,
1.095991849899292,
-0.04650326073169708,
0.12411200255155563,
1.1691309213638306,
-0.14143958687782288,
0.4267243444919586,
0.5193610191345215,
-0.18632791936397552,
0.5216898322105408,
0.5931997299194336,
0.10154321789741516,
0.35822010040283203,
0.45539578795433044,
-0.485460102558136,
-0.3271286189556122,
0.025211093947291374,
-0.23861396312713623,
0.6073331236839294,
0.6157013177871704,
-0.31630444526672363,
0.13386668264865875,
-0.15580502152442932,
-0.32960623502731323,
-0.09063370525836945,
-0.5556765794754028,
0.4891645014286041,
0.05328873172402382,
-0.8661753535270691,
0.1317811906337738,
-0.10562263429164886,
0.5466547608375549,
-0.44055625796318054,
0.07431992888450623,
-0.41413936018943787,
0.22206199169158936,
-0.39643236994743347,
-0.8571615815162659,
0.2767215669155121,
-0.3475489318370819,
-0.3905698359012604,
0.003893984016031027,
0.6189019680023193,
-0.46562206745147705,
-0.07989775389432907,
0.5015943050384521,
0.9348254799842834,
0.09744290262460709,
0.03623562306165695,
-0.3947122097015381,
0.3912593722343445,
0.32747727632522583,
-0.04472264274954796,
0.20108644664287567,
0.5197063088417053,
-0.40289923548698425,
0.39808058738708496,
0.37266457080841064,
-0.3077111840248108,
0.11321768909692764,
0.3321107029914856,
0.7245258688926697,
-0.7219669222831726,
-0.6752932071685791,
-0.9322232604026794,
0.2985774576663971,
-0.6169607639312744,
-0.49992141127586365,
0.7993244528770447,
0.6109049916267395,
1.0016311407089233,
-0.16846691071987152,
0.9218838214874268,
-0.08022352308034897,
0.04914959892630577,
-0.21592079102993011,
0.525691032409668,
-0.10409699380397797,
0.26233452558517456,
-0.16289925575256348,
-0.8522623181343079,
-0.26522859930992126,
0.6051711440086365,
-0.836470901966095,
0.2982492744922638,
0.906516432762146,
0.6231160163879395,
0.03833752125501633,
0.9745199680328369,
0.1454850286245346,
-0.0000935189236770384,
0.49811163544654846,
0.4374591112136841,
1.3859935998916626,
0.1742268055677414,
0.7094635367393494,
0.28469792008399963,
-0.449849396944046,
0.1193910539150238,
-0.5365257263183594,
-1.1609957218170166,
-0.09351261705160141,
-0.46544742584228516,
-0.06895317882299423,
-0.3873055875301361,
1.0708520412445068,
0.28173792362213135,
-0.5146294236183167,
-0.45302051305770874,
0.07916458696126938,
0.265912801027298,
-0.045645084232091904,
-0.16276299953460693,
-0.06750050187110901,
-0.12842722237110138,
-0.6487780809402466,
0.15399079024791718,
0.239217609167099,
-0.018603993579745293,
0.05923141539096832,
-0.21011371910572052,
-0.21038027107715607,
0.2246452420949936,
0.6500821113586426,
0.1899801641702652,
-0.5984708070755005,
-0.1307564377784729,
-0.41588571667671204,
-0.2299378216266632,
0.08160072565078735,
1.0488500595092773,
-0.38940274715423584,
0.44974303245544434,
0.5186017751693726,
0.6063793897628784,
0.813213050365448,
-0.08019429445266724,
0.385220468044281,
-0.1938600242137909,
-0.04172715172171593,
0.14113831520080566,
0.36162060499191284,
0.0953998863697052,
-0.08387702703475952,
0.8013340830802917,
0.41429951786994934,
-0.630517840385437,
0.06983066350221634,
0.34848564863204956,
-1.206957459449768,
-0.3889084458351135,
1.0334913730621338,
0.2269485592842102,
-0.003633205546066165,
-0.2508658170700073,
-0.7338606715202332,
0.18185323476791382,
-0.6174554824829102,
0.94655841588974,
1.1085470914840698,
-0.4714536666870117,
0.22340644896030426,
-0.2685896158218384,
0.5206248760223389,
0.6378912925720215,
-1.0781081914901733,
-0.2624700367450714,
0.7950510382652283,
-0.0797974094748497,
0.30386829376220703,
0.8229758143424988,
-0.09274265915155411,
0.12572459876537323,
0.02024814486503601,
-0.10327745974063873,
0.34522971510887146,
0.07798042893409729,
-0.24944354593753815,
0.3986414074897766,
-0.09315766394138336,
-0.0859847143292427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01423v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01423v1 | Different Tastes of Entities: Investigating Human Label Variation in Named Entity Annotations | 2024-02-02T14:08:34 | 2024-02-02T14:08:34 | Siyao Peng, Zihang Sun, Sebastian Loftus, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a key information extraction task with a
long-standing tradition. While recent studies address and aim to correct
annotation errors via re-labeling efforts, little is known about the sources of
human label variation, such as text ambiguity, annotation error, or guideline
divergence. This is especially the case for high-quality datasets and beyond
English CoNLL03. This paper studies disagreements in expert-annotated named
entity datasets for three languages: English, Danish, and Bavarian. We show
that text ambiguity and artificial guideline changes are dominant factors for
diverse annotations among high-quality revisions. We survey student annotations
on a subset of difficult entities and substantiate the feasibility and
necessity of manifold annotations for understanding named entity ambiguities
from a distributional perspective. | [
-0.7721080183982849,
-0.6397332549095154,
0.40734320878982544,
0.16627630591392517,
-0.19301298260688782,
0.26949143409729004,
-0.17268431186676025,
-0.8497541546821594,
0.39171040058135986,
0.49333328008651733,
-0.4412049353122711,
-0.5151998996734619,
-0.8391125202178955,
0.5431771278381348,
0.15283460915088654,
0.9004252552986145,
-0.5023132562637329,
0.2995181083679199,
-0.021265065297484398,
-0.6118831634521484,
-0.4398144483566284,
-0.6886952519416809,
-0.6251439452171326,
-0.4364481568336487,
1.0004435777664185,
0.4460204243659973,
0.5932857394218445,
0.45766040682792664,
0.5926501154899597,
0.19645331799983978,
-0.4596947729587555,
0.16081884503364563,
-0.06741553544998169,
0.4275510609149933,
-0.327031672000885,
-0.5494349002838135,
-0.16029314696788788,
0.031850963830947876,
0.47575753927230835,
0.9746946096420288,
0.17154619097709656,
0.04590391740202904,
-0.057542070746421814,
0.6218382120132446,
-0.6388635039329529,
0.003679275279864669,
-0.35725995898246765,
-0.0009300826932303607,
-0.6071776747703552,
0.004605220630764961,
-0.3498440980911255,
-0.16885794699192047,
0.5074262619018555,
-0.7897036075592041,
0.477491557598114,
0.052465759217739105,
1.3715273141860962,
0.44749996066093445,
-0.6235655546188354,
-0.3020944595336914,
-0.7108250856399536,
0.6740233302116394,
-0.4054744243621826,
0.771716833114624,
0.3050141930580139,
0.382347971200943,
-0.09644526243209839,
-0.48280298709869385,
-0.3209276795387268,
0.2233709990978241,
-0.11099612712860107,
-0.18241392076015472,
-0.11246369779109955,
-0.2882435917854309,
0.21332842111587524,
0.10796570032835007,
0.025133691728115082,
0.42694419622421265,
-0.19305165112018585,
-0.17122390866279602,
0.7628490328788757,
-0.08301779627799988,
0.3193052113056183,
-0.314353346824646,
-0.1606547236442566,
-0.1916758269071579,
-0.9150130748748779,
0.03677503764629364,
0.8125612735748291,
0.08420314639806747,
0.1179647296667099,
0.494014710187912,
-0.31942352652549744,
0.6000146865844727,
-0.04072920233011246,
0.03161944821476936,
0.694002628326416,
0.21582165360450745,
-0.10645052045583725,
0.27673256397247314,
0.6149668097496033,
0.18911580741405487,
0.2945234775543213,
-0.3692556619644165,
-0.38469070196151733,
-0.38679927587509155,
-0.07263315469026566,
-0.37589675188064575,
-0.4571656584739685,
-0.16908882558345795,
-0.2342078685760498,
-0.05571168288588524,
0.22729668021202087,
-0.6523674726486206,
-0.6790511608123779,
-0.45938464999198914,
0.07588589936494827,
-0.14398729801177979,
-0.3165595829486847,
-0.056860316544771194,
-0.30004754662513733,
0.034673526883125305,
0.7133849859237671,
-0.7951527833938599,
-0.031003952026367188,
0.5763995051383972,
0.4032771587371826,
-0.4625970721244812,
-0.3489457070827484,
-0.060759879648685455,
0.09778489917516708,
-0.3709624707698822,
1.1005865335464478,
-0.6910828351974487,
-0.40318796038627625,
-0.3356175124645233,
0.21869920194149017,
0.054579053074121475,
-0.8287479877471924,
0.6123811602592468,
-0.5351386070251465,
0.0988263413310051,
-0.6527257561683655,
-0.6582493185997009,
-0.30389586091041565,
0.048652395606040955,
-0.8057383298873901,
0.7475922703742981,
0.0411071851849556,
-1.1312083005905151,
0.9235121011734009,
-0.3419506847858429,
-0.3972492516040802,
0.43978938460350037,
-0.5539947748184204,
-0.12772104144096375,
0.28888389468193054,
0.3215785622596741,
0.24667587876319885,
-0.057468581944704056,
0.24901746213436127,
-0.13971614837646484,
-0.034461911767721176,
0.5750689506530762,
-0.47031956911087036,
0.7780345678329468,
0.09416086971759796,
-0.26822924613952637,
-0.1257922351360321,
-0.7750146389007568,
-0.27507084608078003,
-0.054400864988565445,
-0.5918693542480469,
-0.8230891227722168,
0.12902097404003143,
0.17330683767795563,
-0.09452580660581589,
0.011291527189314365,
-0.5014978051185608,
0.21161596477031708,
-0.16124677658081055,
0.3645521104335785,
0.7201417684555054,
0.5289905071258545,
0.2948630154132843,
-0.0973316952586174,
0.5122770071029663,
0.403387188911438,
-0.1402539610862732,
0.14817553758621216,
-0.7257920503616333,
-0.7881423234939575,
-0.19107961654663086,
0.8349389433860779,
0.39740535616874695,
-0.6704502105712891,
-0.01882840506732464,
-0.12328483909368515,
-0.44928982853889465,
-0.8594142198562622,
0.005070300307124853,
0.09757225960493088,
0.5541995167732239,
0.48576363921165466,
-0.050730857998132706,
-0.49919888377189636,
-1.2758275270462036,
-0.5370706915855408,
-0.1450273096561432,
0.044983506202697754,
0.7101708650588989,
0.4651465117931366,
-0.358624666929245,
1.0920665264129639,
-0.4853096902370453,
-0.05545331910252571,
-0.015321774408221245,
0.4339393675327301,
-0.025663308799266815,
0.42550188302993774,
0.4123026728630066,
-1.1078450679779053,
-0.4153848886489868,
0.14375999569892883,
-0.5149092078208923,
0.028174035251140594,
-0.19628097116947174,
-0.2274942696094513,
0.4113789200782776,
0.22928006947040558,
-0.30215638875961304,
0.25129246711730957,
0.1979220062494278,
-0.09966475516557693,
0.3624659776687622,
-0.027700066566467285,
0.1849050372838974,
-1.003781795501709,
-0.2885354459285736,
0.21400970220565796,
0.052235040813684464,
-0.3451187014579773,
-0.13717685639858246,
0.08085145056247711,
0.5309216976165771,
-0.5376468896865845,
0.8150809407234192,
-0.7353966236114502,
0.23911792039871216,
0.19275334477424622,
0.09472478181123734,
0.0260819960385561,
-0.042576808482408524,
0.31935039162635803,
0.49283087253570557,
0.41702499985694885,
-0.678847074508667,
0.23045095801353455,
0.3091736435890198,
-0.26109546422958374,
0.9096413850784302,
-0.4685101807117462,
0.014510788023471832,
-0.42852869629859924,
0.1378283053636551,
-0.6767978072166443,
-0.6950685381889343,
0.3885015845298767,
-0.34807682037353516,
0.4294372797012329,
-0.42982399463653564,
-0.4080757200717926,
-0.06620340049266815,
0.27758726477622986,
0.32362598180770874,
0.13306552171707153,
-0.5366701483726501,
0.3257955014705658,
0.4962862730026245,
-0.07519633322954178,
-0.78211909532547,
-0.8330943584442139,
0.2936277687549591,
-0.3851296901702881,
-0.46526992321014404,
0.1654566079378128,
0.030918864533305168,
-0.5674683451652527,
0.1493813842535019,
-0.24222153425216675,
-0.2941191792488098,
0.1756279319524765,
0.28516843914985657,
0.017957618460059166,
-0.13293980062007904,
0.3974418342113495,
0.19144828617572784,
-0.030242029577493668,
-0.03221835568547249,
0.016232550144195557,
0.06708402186632156,
0.10429700464010239,
-0.2027226984500885,
-0.19476108253002167,
0.28631705045700073,
-0.05056153982877731,
-0.2043367624282837,
0.4590100646018982,
0.40907448530197144,
-0.625146746635437,
0.0545683316886425,
-0.7878934144973755,
-0.05654894933104515,
-0.3712261915206909,
0.14259879291057587,
-0.7162001132965088,
-0.7359828948974609,
0.7872204780578613,
0.11892003566026688,
0.07636865973472595,
0.5834177136421204,
0.18378737568855286,
-0.2626633048057556,
0.7203761339187622,
0.45729801058769226,
0.37511008977890015,
0.2333693653345108,
0.07322411984205246,
-0.017483346164226532,
-0.8899605870246887,
-0.3561726212501526,
-0.6591458320617676,
-0.5191876888275146,
-0.977622389793396,
-0.11296600103378296,
-0.15462316572666168,
0.149652361869812,
-0.03101007640361786,
0.26434680819511414,
-0.4685579240322113,
0.6535173058509827,
0.37177857756614685,
-0.03593448922038078,
0.22821366786956787,
0.09048093110322952,
0.017041875049471855,
-0.52061527967453,
-0.134413942694664,
-0.7561171054840088,
0.6866078972816467,
0.4531720280647278,
0.7939873933792114,
0.3272998631000519,
1.2004246711730957,
0.1482035368680954,
0.44614389538764954,
-0.5982812643051147,
0.13267871737480164,
0.020256096497178078,
-0.8793896436691284,
-0.23939086496829987,
-0.4946107268333435,
-1.0995463132858276,
0.3420930802822113,
-0.15256480872631073,
-1.0029749870300293,
0.9015011191368103,
0.10426538437604904,
0.06829553097486496,
0.2890773415565491,
-0.742628276348114,
0.7248425483703613,
-0.05619111657142639,
-0.047089919447898865,
0.5711170434951782,
-0.6887820363044739,
-0.018272340297698975,
-0.21513663232326508,
0.16840294003486633,
-0.2681306302547455,
-0.15481163561344147,
0.9672759175300598,
-0.08336405456066132,
0.5755693912506104,
-0.1646210104227066,
-0.340603768825531,
0.19452691078186035,
0.15413640439510345,
0.42542871832847595,
0.35638508200645447,
-0.06970272213220596,
0.3191172480583191,
-0.13780750334262848,
-0.34312331676483154,
-0.34706559777259827,
0.5474448800086975,
-0.9204064607620239,
-0.7120661735534668,
-0.31725820899009705,
-0.24524623155593872,
-0.1676415205001831,
0.31539779901504517,
0.7366562485694885,
0.1678544133901596,
-0.01877993531525135,
0.13114570081233978,
0.7472934722900391,
-0.11035571992397308,
0.30164846777915955,
0.27960190176963806,
0.07486863434314728,
-0.4794672429561615,
0.8709923028945923,
0.5986655950546265,
-0.10466405004262924,
0.2604951560497284,
-0.11348915845155716,
-0.13042709231376648,
-0.42011550068855286,
-0.7847858667373657,
0.28731778264045715,
-0.9654290676116943,
-0.06315453350543976,
-0.8734857439994812,
0.060095176100730896,
-0.15122711658477783,
-0.26787668466567993,
-0.22985048592090607,
-0.4493321180343628,
-0.7303839921951294,
-0.2758248448371887,
0.3083047866821289,
0.9846758842468262,
0.2193162590265274,
0.1389061063528061,
-0.48285797238349915,
0.0448276549577713,
0.07098408788442612,
0.19356738030910492,
-0.366557776927948,
-0.23357658088207245,
0.027668310329318047,
0.10113416612148285,
-0.06095399335026741,
-1.6785143613815308,
0.08115488290786743,
-0.10739079117774963,
0.7517346739768982,
0.3230430781841278,
0.007028316147625446,
0.38079291582107544,
-0.2751000225543976,
0.6727263331413269,
-0.06123245880007744,
-0.7050786018371582,
0.35536661744117737,
-0.2204003632068634,
-0.011727710254490376,
0.6389897465705872,
0.5732148885726929,
-0.8112548589706421,
-0.40144896507263184,
-0.7359321117401123,
-1.1797823905944824,
0.5152560472488403,
-0.0978335440158844,
0.012440229766070843,
-0.11176034063100815,
0.5389781594276428,
0.4704529643058777,
0.1784324049949646,
-0.6578586101531982,
-0.5687916278839111,
-0.033581726253032684,
-0.08352278918027878,
-0.1817372739315033,
-0.1389603167772293,
-0.15986652672290802,
-0.012412698939442635,
0.5700197219848633,
0.14120665192604065,
-0.21385379135608673,
0.37814947962760925,
-0.31817254424095154,
0.0011152609949931502,
0.6432086229324341,
0.47981536388397217,
0.8633091449737549,
-0.11288315057754517,
0.4284905195236206,
0.27527061104774475,
-0.4603632688522339,
0.4027177393436432,
0.24281412363052368,
-0.5444855093955994,
0.37773045897483826,
0.15633149445056915,
1.0530734062194824,
0.038108132779598236,
-0.1462550163269043,
0.13682755827903748,
-0.2399958223104477,
-0.20856530964374542,
-0.2642805576324463,
0.04790957272052765,
0.2162235826253891,
0.17082269489765167,
0.4649701416492462,
0.18884709477424622,
0.254381388425827,
-0.02453799545764923,
0.07195597141981125,
-0.038245826959609985,
-0.6101721525192261,
-0.15371669828891754,
0.5084016919136047,
0.23523196578025818,
-0.3832021653652191,
0.6547769904136658,
-0.4379183053970337,
-0.15688346326351166,
0.4817681312561035,
0.1502881646156311,
0.7637949585914612,
0.09086067229509354,
0.36874476075172424,
0.06762006133794785,
0.30018070340156555,
0.03330923616886139,
0.08663693070411682,
0.12100046873092651,
-0.7371833920478821,
-0.2667652666568756,
-0.36312171816825867,
-0.6012423634529114,
-0.236069455742836,
-0.8079991936683655,
0.4307738244533539,
-0.1868898719549179,
-0.5021027326583862,
0.4040692448616028,
-0.4270791709423065,
-0.9493204355239868,
0.21625041961669922,
0.10803253948688507,
0.7176253795623779,
-0.7560232877731323,
0.44720736145973206,
1.5397967100143433,
-0.48913925886154175,
-0.7157730460166931,
0.15771503746509552,
-0.09106553345918655,
-0.1306939572095871,
1.1404558420181274,
0.08356581628322601,
0.318378746509552,
-0.011969289742410183,
-0.38369688391685486,
-0.757306694984436,
0.7160736918449402,
0.3055879473686218,
-0.634629487991333,
-0.044398773461580276,
0.015628743916749954,
0.5478906035423279,
-0.34386250376701355,
0.2842705547809601,
0.5354716777801514,
0.639009416103363,
-0.061530254781246185,
-0.548773467540741,
-0.085638627409935,
-0.0639885812997818,
-0.11240506172180176,
0.4388710856437683,
-0.41763705015182495,
0.854519784450531,
-0.29141324758529663,
-0.3627205491065979,
-0.5762603282928467,
0.5909020900726318,
0.276796817779541,
0.42490455508232117,
0.3709465265274048,
0.42870309948921204,
1.0834674835205078,
-0.42483481764793396,
0.6451308727264404,
0.24424070119857788,
0.34455832839012146,
1.2914519309997559,
-0.22631120681762695,
0.7530548572540283,
0.6556981205940247,
-0.10068203508853912,
0.6155602931976318,
1.2977410554885864,
-0.12986819446086884,
0.15859059989452362,
0.35919833183288574,
-0.1603013128042221,
-0.28064292669296265,
-0.1658778190612793,
-0.4135807156562805,
0.26002687215805054,
0.3532344102859497,
-0.20199692249298096,
-0.06506765633821487,
-0.07483985275030136,
0.307306706905365,
-0.3740573525428772,
0.15120919048786163,
0.860296905040741,
-0.10909253358840942,
-0.5548359155654907,
0.4232024848461151,
0.010773716494441032,
0.5312460064888,
0.15131191909313202,
0.008988617919385433,
-0.21653985977172852,
-0.14673832058906555,
-0.41688212752342224,
-0.8768879175186157,
-0.17435885965824127,
-0.09868740290403366,
-0.21381303668022156,
0.047107744961977005,
0.39018866419792175,
-0.17058631777763367,
-0.4593566358089447,
0.06617368012666702,
0.5138782858848572,
0.4466741681098938,
0.08494743704795837,
-0.5054397583007812,
-0.1955309808254242,
0.16091234982013702,
-0.4816988706588745,
-0.027467161417007446,
0.7167970538139343,
-0.25844162702560425,
0.4667941927909851,
0.17913226783275604,
0.22344115376472473,
0.38013774156570435,
0.17312143743038177,
0.5988481044769287,
-0.46370047330856323,
-0.3022792935371399,
-0.6565226912498474,
0.5171025991439819,
-0.1628304272890091,
-0.7927283048629761,
0.6788538098335266,
0.44171857833862305,
1.2541619539260864,
-0.01657828502357006,
0.7454124093055725,
0.06336305290460587,
0.49200284481048584,
-0.27660539746284485,
0.49445250630378723,
-0.6502887010574341,
0.20345918834209442,
-0.3378978967666626,
-1.208428144454956,
-0.4379040002822876,
0.5255861878395081,
-0.42225027084350586,
0.13641297817230225,
0.5292908549308777,
0.11311469972133636,
-0.026437677443027496,
0.01153525523841381,
0.035383470356464386,
0.03411443904042244,
0.5028312802314758,
0.04846819117665291,
0.9640604853630066,
-0.2412995845079422,
0.14914050698280334,
-0.3828350305557251,
0.16131187975406647,
-0.2937065064907074,
-0.672860324382782,
-0.5497681498527527,
-0.5391411185264587,
-0.8039644956588745,
-0.31144192814826965,
0.2555318772792816,
0.9645636081695557,
0.5272958278656006,
-0.8268962502479553,
0.16994227468967438,
-0.019955914467573166,
0.3230563998222351,
-0.018734099343419075,
-0.2756950855255127,
0.24890132248401642,
-0.1929263174533844,
-0.911790132522583,
-0.07672268152236938,
-0.023336052894592285,
0.6026663184165955,
-0.20652934908866882,
-0.23010629415512085,
0.07708387076854706,
-0.03966953232884407,
-0.04288237541913986,
0.3355095088481903,
-0.8672758936882019,
-0.39189139008522034,
-0.07593082636594772,
-0.13188369572162628,
0.22523455321788788,
0.7709963917732239,
-0.3441937267780304,
0.5317230224609375,
0.5583604574203491,
0.6775175333023071,
0.1767590045928955,
0.008537625893950462,
0.13639739155769348,
-0.949665904045105,
-0.016978709027171135,
0.22003644704818726,
0.5420286059379578,
0.7372626066207886,
-0.4835556149482727,
0.5148972868919373,
0.4009648859500885,
-0.5874328017234802,
-0.8630683422088623,
0.31543245911598206,
-0.6533172726631165,
-0.22974105179309845,
1.3581905364990234,
-0.28999876976013184,
-0.18397460877895355,
-0.3196408450603485,
-0.29867297410964966,
0.17256033420562744,
-0.47548094391822815,
0.4585871398448944,
1.1749008893966675,
-0.3718070387840271,
-0.19622522592544556,
-0.7578915357589722,
0.5536269545555115,
0.1853758692741394,
-0.7406691908836365,
-0.019741566851735115,
0.53404700756073,
0.3620012104511261,
0.27163589000701904,
0.33774200081825256,
0.0841967836022377,
-0.08648700267076492,
-0.17726674675941467,
0.25777193903923035,
0.244729682803154,
-0.4217360019683838,
-0.063943050801754,
-0.11729701608419418,
0.37842950224876404,
-0.013795223087072372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01416v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01416v1 | Sequence Shortening for Context-Aware Machine Translation | 2024-02-02T13:55:37 | 2024-02-02T13:55:37 | Paweł Mąka, Yusuf Can Semerci, Jan Scholtes, Gerasimos Spanakis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Context-aware Machine Translation aims to improve translations of sentences
by incorporating surrounding sentences as context. Towards this task, two main
architectures have been applied, namely single-encoder (based on concatenation)
and multi-encoder models. In this study, we show that a special case of
multi-encoder architecture, where the latent representation of the source
sentence is cached and reused as the context in the next step, achieves higher
accuracy on the contrastive datasets (where the models have to rank the correct
translation among the provided sentences) and comparable BLEU and COMET scores
as the single- and multi-encoder approaches. Furthermore, we investigate the
application of Sequence Shortening to the cached representations. We test three
pooling-based shortening techniques and introduce two novel methods - Latent
Grouping and Latent Selecting, where the network learns to group tokens or
selects the tokens to be cached as context. Our experiments show that the two
methods achieve competitive BLEU and COMET scores and accuracies on the
contrastive datasets to the other tested methods while potentially allowing for
higher interpretability and reducing the growth of memory requirements with
increased context size. | [
-0.41173505783081055,
-0.5411281585693359,
0.21653366088867188,
0.3095725476741791,
-0.6601579189300537,
-0.1428394764661789,
-0.41545289754867554,
-0.35891225934028625,
0.262156218290329,
0.2886902391910553,
-0.2453068047761917,
-0.1683139204978943,
-0.5756946802139282,
0.3067031502723694,
-0.420299768447876,
0.7768465876579285,
0.013219567947089672,
-0.04758533835411072,
-0.07563574612140656,
-0.5863556265830994,
-0.9231165647506714,
-0.6089295148849487,
-0.3966308832168579,
-0.029251782223582268,
0.6061500310897827,
0.5459880828857422,
0.8900185823440552,
0.7576127648353577,
0.417181134223938,
0.23315545916557312,
-0.1683812439441681,
0.18075355887413025,
-0.33774033188819885,
0.46235546469688416,
-0.06860800832509995,
-0.22514420747756958,
-0.17843088507652283,
-0.2589535713195801,
0.9248228669166565,
0.7435229420661926,
0.2103617936372757,
-0.028736243024468422,
0.26224157214164734,
0.7751997113227844,
-0.8470357656478882,
-0.05294397100806236,
-0.5052154064178467,
0.024428855627775192,
-0.3134354054927826,
-0.3908718228340149,
-0.5300678610801697,
0.1436806470155716,
0.16734950244426727,
-0.3458597660064697,
0.18824440240859985,
0.06585578620433807,
0.49204179644584656,
0.5416264533996582,
-0.6090428829193115,
-0.20057891309261322,
-0.5245168209075928,
0.8378965258598328,
-0.7348272800445557,
0.4193967282772064,
0.039705559611320496,
0.39222580194473267,
0.03823030740022659,
-0.5723947882652283,
-0.4266231954097748,
0.3828352093696594,
-0.5082099437713623,
0.23031862080097198,
0.39835646748542786,
-0.16753196716308594,
0.11044394224882126,
0.3692709803581238,
-0.7180872559547424,
0.20241233706474304,
-0.3604332208633423,
-0.1622571498155594,
0.42025119066238403,
0.07660209387540817,
-0.005217849742621183,
-0.18552449345588684,
-0.5232936143875122,
-0.16059991717338562,
-0.6961090564727783,
-0.1513064205646515,
-0.06990813463926315,
0.5566795468330383,
-0.12905235588550568,
0.5343301296234131,
-0.15793377161026,
0.6923582553863525,
0.07265546917915344,
0.45382943749427795,
0.3978685736656189,
-0.5379782915115356,
-0.2519265413284302,
0.3450549840927124,
0.6811981201171875,
0.28800469636917114,
-0.0717051550745964,
-0.20032000541687012,
-0.25272896885871887,
-0.10049013793468475,
0.11632473021745682,
-1.0685425996780396,
0.18124517798423767,
0.4018782079219818,
-0.6879611015319824,
0.18688780069351196,
0.1979966014623642,
-0.6931189298629761,
-0.04515186697244644,
-0.016283031553030014,
0.34488722681999207,
-0.3970039486885071,
0.3067333698272705,
0.16614581644535065,
-0.16595014929771423,
0.36975300312042236,
0.2311425805091858,
-0.7192595601081848,
0.26529213786125183,
0.41028863191604614,
1.0129457712173462,
-0.2988385856151581,
-0.3935045301914215,
-0.8686584234237671,
0.21820040047168732,
-0.12395848333835602,
0.31389063596725464,
-0.5502319931983948,
-0.5896145701408386,
-0.07955813407897949,
0.011339828372001648,
-0.2524108290672302,
-0.40649089217185974,
0.42628011107444763,
-0.7712084650993347,
0.44038820266723633,
-0.22813329100608826,
-0.680325984954834,
-0.29221466183662415,
0.16619904339313507,
-0.9102297425270081,
0.6743935346603394,
-0.052407246083021164,
-0.8060020208358765,
0.26717808842658997,
-0.7352138161659241,
-0.6291505098342896,
0.07253514975309372,
-0.02996101789176464,
-0.49527430534362793,
0.16528823971748352,
0.5272356271743774,
0.6378688812255859,
-0.10477946698665619,
0.23549678921699524,
0.03122100979089737,
-0.7217591404914856,
0.1674574464559555,
-0.45041295886039734,
0.3354545533657074,
0.39458534121513367,
-0.26060888171195984,
0.16740112006664276,
-0.28568726778030396,
-0.08517386019229889,
-0.11681125313043594,
-0.5254241824150085,
-0.402864545583725,
0.09261616319417953,
0.19562305510044098,
0.31591248512268066,
0.18630480766296387,
-0.18411438167095184,
0.08364756405353546,
-0.49306902289390564,
0.49209704995155334,
0.3862851858139038,
0.12596513330936432,
0.7390120029449463,
-0.36787664890289307,
0.13301301002502441,
0.2941179573535919,
-0.007229656912386417,
-0.7273491024971008,
-0.4967215359210968,
-0.6511620879173279,
-0.08917298167943954,
0.3983258008956909,
0.6301581263542175,
-0.66573166847229,
0.5371249914169312,
-0.637382447719574,
-0.03831982612609863,
-0.4287783205509186,
-0.0299154631793499,
0.5338320732116699,
0.5231334567070007,
0.8319487571716309,
-0.7252752184867859,
-0.34929388761520386,
-0.6543018817901611,
-0.16859307885169983,
0.36949434876441956,
0.16057755053043365,
0.35013988614082336,
0.5466423034667969,
-0.3878253698348999,
0.8864744901657104,
-0.2003866732120514,
-0.06954151391983032,
-0.012559236958622932,
-0.06939230114221573,
0.21347790956497192,
0.8974881172180176,
0.44456779956817627,
-1.3153902292251587,
-0.4560925364494324,
-0.11518590897321701,
-0.48709729313850403,
0.30632996559143066,
-0.1368449181318283,
0.0018382399575784802,
0.18877793848514557,
0.2770867645740509,
-0.5291136503219604,
0.5563827753067017,
0.5010513067245483,
-0.25056129693984985,
0.4807278513908386,
-0.32718023657798767,
0.40342244505882263,
-1.2807368040084839,
0.33083459734916687,
-0.4110250771045685,
-0.4879254400730133,
-0.5814528465270996,
0.14896807074546814,
0.17446821928024292,
-0.053574301302433014,
-0.8338510990142822,
0.6649233102798462,
-0.5790272951126099,
-0.28795021772384644,
-0.303865522146225,
0.24729961156845093,
0.2151590883731842,
0.27956849336624146,
-0.07233908772468567,
1.002561092376709,
0.3972240686416626,
-0.8877096176147461,
0.0028945577796548605,
0.3574911057949066,
-0.31508591771125793,
0.10590094327926636,
-0.6089817881584167,
0.1422717422246933,
-0.06465743482112885,
0.4352366626262665,
-0.6765490174293518,
-0.1693243533372879,
0.08254721015691757,
-0.28193044662475586,
0.3540394902229309,
-0.05369791388511658,
-0.565574586391449,
-0.20029613375663757,
-0.0983966737985611,
0.8334639668464661,
0.4074246883392334,
-0.6078686118125916,
0.12648063898086548,
-0.08030474185943604,
0.12440849840641022,
-0.8373903036117554,
-1.0335863828659058,
0.080277219414711,
-0.5480952858924866,
-0.5277063250541687,
0.856930673122406,
-0.22951854765415192,
0.1061759665608406,
0.023887185379862785,
-0.15045136213302612,
-0.131368950009346,
0.23903293907642365,
0.10571812838315964,
-0.11004295200109482,
-0.3176329433917999,
0.3254723846912384,
0.20736272633075714,
-0.1730770468711853,
-0.49140918254852295,
-0.4169767200946808,
0.4682500660419464,
-0.23438163101673126,
-0.316093772649765,
-0.3200870454311371,
0.5990886092185974,
0.42621612548828125,
-0.35241958498954773,
1.0873420238494873,
0.6243603825569153,
-0.4113984704017639,
0.13518330454826355,
-0.35555240511894226,
-0.4104548394680023,
-0.4284294545650482,
0.056753288954496384,
-0.5246118903160095,
-1.3312466144561768,
0.8139880299568176,
-0.2846177816390991,
-0.2317200005054474,
0.377760112285614,
0.4232199490070343,
0.12228568643331528,
0.5996421575546265,
0.40534353256225586,
-0.23714828491210938,
0.48948511481285095,
-0.2772580683231354,
0.19957579672336578,
-0.9789305925369263,
0.034983083605766296,
-0.4406876564025879,
-0.4487617015838623,
-0.6695945858955383,
-0.6707736849784851,
0.19965335726737976,
0.4330626428127289,
-0.10014093667268753,
0.4492945671081543,
-0.2657489776611328,
0.6337518692016602,
0.2814714014530182,
0.01630416326224804,
0.026095565408468246,
-0.3223939538002014,
-0.3408820331096649,
0.0814242884516716,
-0.7407340407371521,
-0.5434532165527344,
0.6723955869674683,
-0.2161770462989807,
0.06275930255651474,
0.2485358864068985,
0.6529342532157898,
0.27558228373527527,
0.04293888062238693,
-0.5645155310630798,
0.3042718172073364,
-0.2858342230319977,
-0.4608150124549866,
-0.31297945976257324,
-0.45698437094688416,
-1.1962199211120605,
0.7226518392562866,
-0.0823359414935112,
-0.5936040878295898,
0.18852420151233673,
0.12126286327838898,
-0.25874435901641846,
-0.005072713363915682,
-0.6009079217910767,
1.1649982929229736,
-0.23633117973804474,
-0.38938939571380615,
-0.2907028794288635,
-1.2496352195739746,
0.08930619060993195,
-0.12785711884498596,
0.31623390316963196,
0.18191327154636383,
-0.11513616144657135,
0.48225343227386475,
-0.6030532121658325,
0.5668663382530212,
-0.17879387736320496,
0.3651113212108612,
0.2617111802101135,
-0.03671626001596451,
0.43060123920440674,
0.12984636425971985,
-0.31900179386138916,
-0.021027082577347755,
-0.2533573806285858,
-0.6273722052574158,
-0.6334710121154785,
0.8020365834236145,
-0.43217432498931885,
-0.4952457845211029,
-0.08662392199039459,
-0.31611350178718567,
0.02633095718920231,
0.3889744281768799,
0.24676895141601562,
0.4562961757183075,
-0.2601585388183594,
0.3976384103298187,
0.4637652039527893,
-0.2945789396762848,
0.7909420132637024,
0.12409690022468567,
0.10772207379341125,
-0.28421488404273987,
0.432395875453949,
-0.16054023802280426,
0.15858833491802216,
0.8172635436058044,
0.254806250333786,
-0.21500396728515625,
-0.481830894947052,
-0.5755564570426941,
-0.06806164979934692,
-0.7662752270698547,
-0.25552791357040405,
-0.5598262548446655,
0.03439066931605339,
-0.454646497964859,
-0.3726942539215088,
-0.36754322052001953,
-0.5892667174339294,
-0.3089156448841095,
0.05381437763571739,
0.1423329859972,
0.20233313739299774,
0.06985929608345032,
0.7208560705184937,
-1.1308101415634155,
-0.03894605115056038,
0.047280773520469666,
0.11904910206794739,
0.000037689926102757454,
-0.46072959899902344,
-0.6001905798912048,
-0.08105882257223129,
-0.10906804352998734,
-0.9795436859130859,
0.5519415140151978,
0.3680184483528137,
0.3959357440471649,
0.3688878118991852,
-0.05170927196741104,
0.9604256749153137,
-0.7814895510673523,
0.8053160905838013,
0.016534948721528053,
-1.0780378580093384,
0.6375097632408142,
-0.12022356688976288,
0.5679270029067993,
0.6004586219787598,
0.22404760122299194,
-0.728804349899292,
-0.016278985887765884,
-0.25783419609069824,
-1.0928815603256226,
0.47022324800491333,
0.344134658575058,
0.1788460910320282,
-0.22514398396015167,
0.6393674612045288,
0.3140527904033661,
0.16402822732925415,
-0.3449254631996155,
-0.2826726734638214,
-0.30761411786079407,
-0.1053706482052803,
-0.4341551959514618,
-0.08409517258405685,
0.2621620297431946,
0.1773146241903305,
0.4676721692085266,
-0.2454310953617096,
0.13854046165943146,
0.3093893527984619,
-0.58602374792099,
0.2869485318660736,
0.5983479022979736,
0.5449512600898743,
0.469194233417511,
-0.14876878261566162,
0.12565581500530243,
0.18070685863494873,
-0.039957985281944275,
-0.10516168922185898,
0.0689726248383522,
-0.12265913188457489,
0.09591767936944962,
0.29920101165771484,
0.8350324630737305,
0.47831952571868896,
-0.563597559928894,
0.6633300185203552,
-0.0856475755572319,
0.43205398321151733,
0.04974135383963585,
-0.1465209424495697,
0.0503210574388504,
0.111235611140728,
0.27920252084732056,
0.31077176332473755,
0.36159107089042664,
-0.28911149501800537,
0.43650761246681213,
0.050756435841321945,
-0.37011149525642395,
-0.30424681305885315,
0.5377430319786072,
0.23566105961799622,
-0.10885925590991974,
0.7432173490524292,
-0.193870410323143,
-0.567127525806427,
0.4944412112236023,
0.5606499910354614,
0.6730166673660278,
-0.2875206768512726,
-0.22281412780284882,
0.40276408195495605,
0.024215474724769592,
-0.3298916518688202,
0.0888860672712326,
-0.2511245608329773,
-0.7620094418525696,
-0.6154794692993164,
-0.34796932339668274,
-0.32345545291900635,
-0.2460499256849289,
-0.843012273311615,
0.044877875596284866,
0.15531720221042633,
-0.09954919666051865,
-0.44518354535102844,
-0.011134348809719086,
-0.8398423790931702,
0.24269826710224152,
-0.0802321657538414,
0.8242316842079163,
-0.6795609593391418,
0.9526621699333191,
0.6219781637191772,
-0.4006401300430298,
-0.349523663520813,
0.196048304438591,
-0.09694799780845642,
-0.17425650358200073,
0.5332592725753784,
0.7940300703048706,
0.03861631080508232,
-0.11775971204042435,
-0.14946982264518738,
-0.8881800174713135,
1.2220723628997803,
0.1633458137512207,
-0.6479196548461914,
0.16154131293296814,
-0.10780046880245209,
0.3161942958831787,
-0.5815238952636719,
0.01001302246004343,
0.20411886274814606,
0.4320192337036133,
-0.04404302313923836,
-0.9176220893859863,
0.370093435049057,
-0.2556241452693939,
0.23986361920833588,
0.15442867577075958,
-0.6253292560577393,
0.7832732796669006,
-0.20727773010730743,
-0.5038423538208008,
0.22318094968795776,
0.6905936598777771,
0.20181535184383392,
0.2427581548690796,
0.32047855854034424,
0.3877125084400177,
0.8336197733879089,
-0.00047344263293780386,
1.1795463562011719,
-0.47985196113586426,
0.16021347045898438,
1.3608969449996948,
-0.2790469527244568,
0.9380269050598145,
0.6071714758872986,
0.4491577446460724,
0.5006358027458191,
0.6845744252204895,
0.35177066922187805,
0.8511426448822021,
0.20325912535190582,
-0.10138850659132004,
-0.06599585711956024,
0.11245191842317581,
-0.4479566216468811,
0.3226397633552551,
0.4840744435787201,
-0.37684449553489685,
0.042882200330495834,
0.1496095061302185,
-0.10985638946294785,
0.07802581787109375,
-0.13375124335289001,
0.546528697013855,
0.26816707849502563,
-0.6143546104431152,
0.3584026098251343,
0.394483357667923,
0.753353476524353,
-0.14232341945171356,
0.13724251091480255,
-0.31887248158454895,
0.15999174118041992,
-0.019834818318486214,
-0.4268019497394562,
0.5955218076705933,
-0.18576796352863312,
-0.26525959372520447,
-0.4147617816925049,
0.6702277064323425,
-0.46383926272392273,
0.0075075579807162285,
0.37584012746810913,
0.7879980802536011,
0.3881264925003052,
-0.0384988933801651,
-0.6181642413139343,
0.03396771475672722,
-0.5619939565658569,
-0.15639327466487885,
0.18669208884239197,
0.49387866258621216,
-0.24797718226909637,
0.37197786569595337,
0.38073137402534485,
-0.17399951815605164,
0.24657943844795227,
0.3032556176185608,
0.8048668503761292,
-0.7955087423324585,
-0.6546201109886169,
-1.0044958591461182,
0.5134962797164917,
-0.029796205461025238,
-0.16463865339756012,
0.7153591513633728,
0.892573893070221,
0.9333281517028809,
-0.11403478682041168,
0.4661605656147003,
0.0952698364853859,
0.027416499331593513,
-0.7339032888412476,
0.5228013396263123,
-0.4430274963378906,
0.1989831179380417,
0.05375385284423828,
-0.911128580570221,
-0.6589328646659851,
0.4571777880191803,
-0.04106990993022919,
0.028984876349568367,
0.9203822612762451,
0.5660846829414368,
-0.20338678359985352,
-0.0878220647573471,
0.22718751430511475,
-0.08159026503562927,
0.15486373007297516,
0.6165109872817993,
0.5311174988746643,
-0.7522816061973572,
0.34551239013671875,
0.06842706352472305,
0.09667325764894485,
-0.38798677921295166,
-0.9312950968742371,
-0.7095168232917786,
-0.5901713371276855,
-0.2877064347267151,
-0.13441751897335052,
0.21071287989616394,
0.6490843892097473,
0.9437785148620605,
-0.8200746178627014,
-0.10541315376758575,
0.03568420931696892,
0.3143507242202759,
-0.4952467978000641,
-0.15499170124530792,
0.5727914571762085,
-0.43902456760406494,
-0.5573217272758484,
0.7680755257606506,
0.33743396401405334,
0.04529431089758873,
0.14902423322200775,
-0.41910406947135925,
-0.18063803017139435,
-0.005947612226009369,
0.5376378297805786,
0.014609569683670998,
-0.6945924162864685,
-0.3723388910293579,
-0.27331340312957764,
-0.08577846735715866,
0.35019439458847046,
0.9055421948432922,
-0.992476761341095,
0.4565253257751465,
0.6116964221000671,
0.7773532867431641,
0.6694693565368652,
0.19659502804279327,
0.43134620785713196,
-1.168784499168396,
0.28301820158958435,
0.12167498469352722,
0.6116854548454285,
0.6750802397727966,
-0.32321861386299133,
0.40402597188949585,
0.07776857167482376,
-0.4318975806236267,
-0.33404117822647095,
0.2689077854156494,
-0.9060375094413757,
-0.41884902119636536,
0.8147728443145752,
-0.34673434495925903,
-0.2152009904384613,
0.01132136955857277,
0.20132848620414734,
0.4778117835521698,
-0.34236347675323486,
0.5133095979690552,
0.4060872793197632,
0.11445743590593338,
-0.00046780958655290306,
-0.28024181723594666,
0.22736318409442902,
0.6188408136367798,
-0.6157462000846863,
-0.22921881079673767,
0.5186808109283447,
0.005722150672227144,
0.21272535622119904,
0.5907583236694336,
-0.1336342841386795,
0.17514055967330933,
-0.25136807560920715,
-0.31700068712234497,
0.11960592120885849,
-0.3795471787452698,
-0.5719891786575317,
0.22511333227157593,
-0.3465608060359955,
-0.3197467029094696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01404v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01404v1 | On Measuring Context Utilization in Document-Level MT Systems | 2024-02-02T13:37:07 | 2024-02-02T13:37:07 | Wafaa Mohammed, Vlad Niculae | cs.CL | cs.CL | Document-level translation models are usually evaluated using general metrics
such as BLEU, which are not informative about the benefits of context. Current
work on context-aware evaluation, such as contrastive methods, only measure
translation accuracy on words that need context for disambiguation. Such
measures cannot reveal whether the translation model uses the correct
supporting context. We propose to complement accuracy-based evaluation with
measures of context utilization. We find that perturbation-based analysis
(comparing models' performance when provided with correct versus random
context) is an effective measure of overall context utilization. For a
finer-grained phenomenon-specific evaluation, we propose to measure how much
the supporting context contributes to handling context-dependent discourse
phenomena. We show that automatically-annotated supporting context gives
similar conclusions to human-annotated context and can be used as alternative
for cases where human annotations are not available. Finally, we highlight the
importance of using discourse-rich datasets when assessing context utilization. | [
-0.3577251136302948,
-0.8138543367385864,
0.6049582958221436,
0.49413421750068665,
-0.3085173964500427,
-0.319382905960083,
-0.2073918730020523,
-0.3397562801837921,
-0.051497116684913635,
0.4378417432308197,
-0.19572976231575012,
-0.3512905538082123,
-0.6828417181968689,
0.21115505695343018,
-0.5960245728492737,
0.7274276614189148,
-0.1174718365073204,
-0.010577945969998837,
-0.6053724884986877,
-0.44385775923728943,
-0.8287389278411865,
-0.4727630615234375,
-0.3560391068458557,
-0.508834183216095,
0.3788164556026459,
0.2696704864501953,
0.5455723404884338,
0.4069112241268158,
0.4151417315006256,
0.29116857051849365,
-0.22467440366744995,
0.04638117179274559,
-0.29036906361579895,
0.2184775173664093,
-0.23798054456710815,
-0.2027057260274887,
-0.6727794408798218,
-0.018214218318462372,
0.8579401969909668,
0.9425548315048218,
-0.13786251842975616,
0.17191848158836365,
0.4064823389053345,
0.2196025252342224,
-0.7657139897346497,
-0.2472221553325653,
-0.6747098565101624,
0.1046198382973671,
-0.1864987313747406,
-0.5610294938087463,
-0.45860254764556885,
0.14837825298309326,
0.3996686637401581,
-0.8077148795127869,
-0.10271734744310379,
0.11190339177846909,
0.6852858662605286,
0.423409104347229,
-0.7795612215995789,
-0.38915276527404785,
-0.7549453377723694,
0.9910268187522888,
-0.5494480729103088,
0.2769355773925781,
0.7384192943572998,
0.1889525055885315,
-0.06203656643629074,
-0.6731147766113281,
-0.45781129598617554,
-0.1548997163772583,
-0.5325259566307068,
0.2771300971508026,
-0.1978902816772461,
0.014184261672198772,
0.4469091594219208,
0.5054560303688049,
-0.12087088823318481,
-0.025867046788334846,
-0.05535055696964264,
-0.33250659704208374,
0.2785181999206543,
0.37798285484313965,
0.32903409004211426,
-0.47384849190711975,
-0.6450410485267639,
0.10547047853469849,
-0.4770812392234802,
-0.037446316331624985,
-0.006539839319884777,
0.11769194900989532,
-0.2448272705078125,
0.5436916351318359,
0.11926408112049103,
0.7291109561920166,
-0.2251262664794922,
-0.07550930231809616,
0.21648912131786346,
-0.7168138027191162,
-0.6308257579803467,
-0.3294355273246765,
0.5631479024887085,
0.2942548096179962,
-0.2555561065673828,
-0.11442139744758606,
-0.3493414521217346,
-0.33607447147369385,
0.5271390080451965,
-0.7981962561607361,
0.21425026655197144,
0.17692552506923676,
-0.2447454184293747,
-0.05243978649377823,
-0.10741621255874634,
-0.42359378933906555,
-0.505723237991333,
-0.24116437137126923,
0.2272314429283142,
-0.43091461062431335,
-0.14062653481960297,
-0.23097532987594604,
-0.27176931500434875,
0.10477415472269058,
0.4886789917945862,
-0.7033016681671143,
0.28535619378089905,
0.46055009961128235,
1.084877371788025,
-0.2778473198413849,
-0.2069413810968399,
-0.32945114374160767,
0.2878761291503906,
-0.4298771321773529,
0.7757890224456787,
-0.5486822724342346,
-0.7635470032691956,
0.10441960394382477,
0.037935830652713776,
-0.21520808339118958,
-0.5186867117881775,
1.0058411359786987,
-0.3005370497703552,
0.2541794180870056,
-0.6942493319511414,
-0.6118109822273254,
-0.24084033071994781,
0.4150767922401428,
-0.5495285391807556,
1.131462574005127,
0.5498900413513184,
-0.8773903846740723,
0.6510979533195496,
-0.8765577673912048,
-0.6852062344551086,
0.11415818333625793,
0.07537956535816193,
-0.19868707656860352,
0.46634024381637573,
0.05520463362336159,
0.3435175120830536,
-0.0687306746840477,
0.5115103125572205,
-0.02616819553077221,
-0.49969881772994995,
0.44488289952278137,
-0.4019620418548584,
0.5506826639175415,
0.2383423000574112,
-0.18102769553661346,
0.2462625801563263,
-0.6286430358886719,
-0.5024763941764832,
-0.3156566023826599,
-0.4544599950313568,
-0.8441048860549927,
0.19213025271892548,
0.2706760764122009,
-0.029331179335713387,
0.18607933819293976,
-0.381264328956604,
-0.08177544176578522,
-0.30338966846466064,
0.2842501103878021,
0.5142562389373779,
-0.032540131360292435,
0.5206336379051208,
-0.14007577300071716,
0.38677161931991577,
-0.04926638305187225,
-0.120149627327919,
-0.3892413377761841,
-0.14288905262947083,
-0.6208809018135071,
-0.2920174300670624,
0.48899903893470764,
0.4507124423980713,
-0.6323308348655701,
0.4521033763885498,
-0.271631121635437,
-0.060022588819265366,
-0.203484907746315,
-0.2893974781036377,
0.41863638162612915,
1.0617932081222534,
0.5820748805999756,
-0.4554195702075958,
-0.42645758390426636,
-1.0505967140197754,
-0.1901305764913559,
0.12025133520364761,
-0.16439653933048248,
0.6997319459915161,
0.47464314103126526,
-0.27724677324295044,
0.7538150548934937,
-0.16655953228473663,
-0.29682910442352295,
0.048103198409080505,
0.29431620240211487,
-0.16838569939136505,
0.4738433063030243,
0.684350311756134,
-0.8203148245811462,
-0.3630650043487549,
0.1459374874830246,
-0.8186257481575012,
-0.6226311326026917,
-0.05218752101063728,
-0.09847397357225418,
0.33971062302589417,
0.2728305160999298,
-0.07176286727190018,
0.37016022205352783,
0.6241168975830078,
-0.4908986985683441,
0.42280375957489014,
-0.2745008170604706,
0.37554097175598145,
-0.8589165806770325,
0.6800053715705872,
-0.07715550065040588,
-0.5131315588951111,
-0.8353051543235779,
-0.07078424096107483,
0.05340593308210373,
0.10623116046190262,
-0.4313010573387146,
0.783098578453064,
-0.3430574834346771,
-0.5199458599090576,
-0.3787621855735779,
0.4996497333049774,
0.19157734513282776,
0.05071203038096428,
-0.09073756635189056,
0.9288043975830078,
0.34088873863220215,
-0.4985688030719757,
-0.20722445845603943,
0.20069453120231628,
-0.388846755027771,
1.0579935312271118,
-0.4957210123538971,
-0.06547730416059494,
0.15849435329437256,
0.41156041622161865,
-1.1923810243606567,
-0.3373171389102936,
0.21392112970352173,
-0.3141865134239197,
0.2550821304321289,
-0.08492203801870346,
-0.4369846284389496,
0.06305684894323349,
-0.0440174862742424,
0.18763859570026398,
0.12566809356212616,
-0.1473633050918579,
0.5136466026306152,
0.5031278133392334,
0.059461068361997604,
-0.7278899550437927,
-0.8655147552490234,
0.3088149428367615,
-0.461670845746994,
-0.48915284872055054,
0.4441487789154053,
0.12250809371471405,
-0.11878657341003418,
-0.014297683723270893,
-0.41328170895576477,
-0.07200783491134644,
0.6997054219245911,
0.2433975487947464,
0.03144996985793114,
0.011838342063128948,
0.18068580329418182,
0.37392956018447876,
-0.05391668528318405,
0.05808749049901962,
-0.27720698714256287,
0.5039165019989014,
0.11926032602787018,
-0.17606760561466217,
-0.46327516436576843,
0.3911416232585907,
0.31952956318855286,
-0.05738803744316101,
0.569549024105072,
0.6975552439689636,
-0.47884801030158997,
0.20533592998981476,
-0.5758407115936279,
0.011217612773180008,
-0.36404159665107727,
0.16536852717399597,
-0.5252891778945923,
-0.9205850958824158,
0.7639756798744202,
-0.002023416804149747,
-0.04083476960659027,
0.569028913974762,
0.33485034108161926,
-0.11832589656114578,
0.8016552329063416,
0.490803599357605,
0.2701929807662964,
0.6680445075035095,
-0.1315729171037674,
-0.1395144760608673,
-1.348124384880066,
0.0691605880856514,
-0.559605062007904,
-0.41492369771003723,
-0.4577913284301758,
-0.3217201232910156,
0.4196071922779083,
0.26369529962539673,
0.03974908962845802,
0.2979891002178192,
-0.31980499625205994,
0.1030995175242424,
0.08489343523979187,
-0.32567840814590454,
0.4865579903125763,
0.0688495859503746,
-0.19494521617889404,
-0.02575608715415001,
-0.5154739022254944,
-0.894370973110199,
0.9160767197608948,
0.2192140519618988,
0.03991862013936043,
-0.11691780388355255,
0.3075477182865143,
0.3067420721054077,
0.8010568022727966,
-0.7268478870391846,
0.4378233253955841,
-0.10486983507871628,
-0.7333759665489197,
-0.39453139901161194,
-0.6117706298828125,
-1.0426353216171265,
0.7147167325019836,
-0.11390766501426697,
-0.9126375913619995,
0.14302504062652588,
0.16456176340579987,
-0.30466151237487793,
-0.10271281003952026,
-0.6106365919113159,
0.9606913328170776,
-0.007182775065302849,
-0.3666999042034149,
-0.24946218729019165,
-0.3768264055252075,
0.11745309829711914,
-0.023590100929141045,
0.3415428102016449,
0.04481644183397293,
-0.31342315673828125,
0.6002384424209595,
-0.19645169377326965,
0.6504043340682983,
-0.4052776098251343,
-0.26559463143348694,
0.32106220722198486,
0.18072964251041412,
-0.019889473915100098,
-0.03399056941270828,
-0.29721131920814514,
0.1839330643415451,
0.2526596486568451,
-0.44587036967277527,
-0.6871438026428223,
0.762411892414093,
-0.4492138624191284,
-0.6432605385780334,
-0.422660231590271,
-0.6254193186759949,
-0.2510862946510315,
0.3788556456565857,
0.2304345816373825,
0.3667680025100708,
-0.4827573001384735,
0.4538043439388275,
0.3038194477558136,
-0.2280111312866211,
0.3983425498008728,
0.5088816285133362,
-0.14669546484947205,
-0.16452062129974365,
0.6219848990440369,
0.4946988523006439,
0.12221556156873703,
0.3395173251628876,
0.5405793190002441,
-0.27829301357269287,
-0.6950812339782715,
-0.6584380269050598,
-0.18980930745601654,
-0.641281247138977,
-0.03238148242235184,
-0.687017560005188,
0.2298068255186081,
-0.020582787692546844,
-0.2417479306459427,
0.036079518496990204,
-0.3893527388572693,
-0.10321387648582458,
-0.19198739528656006,
-0.25879761576652527,
0.38667869567871094,
0.09475599974393845,
0.5523526072502136,
-0.5079325437545776,
-0.07028646022081375,
-0.014430628158152103,
0.28804662823677063,
0.120368093252182,
-0.522851288318634,
-0.4093814492225647,
0.02747313492000103,
-0.5531551837921143,
-0.920495867729187,
0.20711170136928558,
-0.1233406662940979,
0.512276291847229,
0.10748321563005447,
-0.06911928206682205,
0.6143333911895752,
-0.3197939693927765,
1.0489742755889893,
-0.11270808428525925,
-1.3160204887390137,
0.5303744673728943,
-0.5288549065589905,
0.29159682989120483,
0.5427433848381042,
0.24811400473117828,
-0.6352413296699524,
-0.30838286876678467,
-0.5153743028640747,
-0.9718623757362366,
0.74476158618927,
0.3958972990512848,
0.3205544054508209,
-0.06866829097270966,
0.36331138014793396,
-0.09193100780248642,
0.3874399960041046,
-0.7400891780853271,
-0.036762237548828125,
-0.1385299563407898,
0.1971602737903595,
0.013476536609232426,
-0.2762797474861145,
-0.35713309049606323,
-0.12662345170974731,
0.3888423442840576,
-0.08163738250732422,
-0.0004563154943753034,
0.5750766396522522,
-0.45387744903564453,
-0.08972860127687454,
0.44064730405807495,
0.805276095867157,
1.0406649112701416,
-0.16811683773994446,
0.19449062645435333,
0.5041264295578003,
-0.28030839562416077,
-0.14521397650241852,
-0.0795772597193718,
-0.3995884358882904,
-0.03174975514411926,
0.3378422260284424,
0.8656834363937378,
0.3994884788990021,
-0.36569449305534363,
0.5332286357879639,
0.12788711488246918,
0.08294534683227539,
-0.2888886630535126,
-0.10197357088327408,
0.120074063539505,
-0.028791580349206924,
0.2353508025407791,
-0.1694658249616623,
0.48234954476356506,
-0.534922182559967,
0.016342369839549065,
0.42044559121131897,
-0.7205483913421631,
-0.28188255429267883,
0.36793428659439087,
0.35005494952201843,
-0.24446648359298706,
0.21061848104000092,
-0.14761728048324585,
-0.2929607629776001,
0.4832439124584198,
0.6876612305641174,
0.7563255429267883,
-0.41681811213493347,
-0.07374822348356247,
0.32413896918296814,
0.17792974412441254,
0.00017841311637312174,
0.09094519913196564,
-0.298451691865921,
-0.6424960494041443,
-0.40956637263298035,
-0.47933030128479004,
-0.41797560453414917,
0.16491402685642242,
-0.7065868973731995,
0.06264035403728485,
-0.038591958582401276,
-0.4481819272041321,
0.053527310490608215,
0.11054345965385437,
-0.5146951675415039,
0.29764580726623535,
-0.12651506066322327,
0.7659595608711243,
-0.6821054816246033,
0.7622268795967102,
0.8264363408088684,
-0.2863008379936218,
-0.19650724530220032,
0.030556855723261833,
-0.09528126567602158,
-0.2638695240020752,
0.32893407344818115,
0.2539721429347992,
-0.23486670851707458,
-0.31862393021583557,
-0.28887322545051575,
-0.4967859089374542,
1.2613067626953125,
0.24855639040470123,
-0.30532601475715637,
0.28237563371658325,
-0.02784092351794243,
0.8731421828269958,
-0.5026302933692932,
0.3861049711704254,
0.5551385283470154,
0.7933607697486877,
-0.018336258828639984,
-0.869156539440155,
0.2523300349712372,
0.08014523237943649,
0.28577035665512085,
0.11248233914375305,
-0.315425843000412,
0.5430344343185425,
0.40077292919158936,
-0.6303956508636475,
-0.046647001057863235,
0.42535099387168884,
-0.2046840637922287,
0.713866114616394,
0.6581765413284302,
0.4287669360637665,
0.8020371198654175,
-0.11686238646507263,
1.449644923210144,
-0.15462635457515717,
0.3478507995605469,
1.0727829933166504,
-0.30017635226249695,
0.7260298132896423,
0.5788670778274536,
0.06800700724124908,
0.38668349385261536,
0.4335872232913971,
0.24570320546627045,
0.09142369031906128,
0.21815994381904602,
-0.0959627628326416,
-0.0739898681640625,
-0.36966976523399353,
-0.11590033024549484,
0.39234715700149536,
0.7005001902580261,
-0.34426000714302063,
-0.06959410011768341,
-0.0278328824788332,
0.12354902178049088,
0.18565510213375092,
0.012886857613921165,
0.858046293258667,
0.3061763644218445,
-0.963810384273529,
0.6344870328903198,
0.21626156568527222,
0.2967257797718048,
-0.36231836676597595,
0.31105631589889526,
-0.4129040241241455,
-0.24999545514583588,
-0.4516132175922394,
-0.7933989763259888,
0.8618069887161255,
0.03484388813376427,
-0.16393622756004333,
-0.28818562626838684,
0.6696963310241699,
-0.2294342964887619,
-0.26274678111076355,
0.45372337102890015,
0.7160201072692871,
0.0011065779253840446,
0.0525515042245388,
-0.22692422568798065,
-0.04449376091361046,
-0.3411705791950226,
-0.4646669328212738,
0.4865955412387848,
0.5120024085044861,
-0.2876083254814148,
0.316959947347641,
0.4206487834453583,
-0.0762879028916359,
-0.31994590163230896,
0.22409428656101227,
0.6338015198707581,
-0.4931003749370575,
-0.28911030292510986,
-0.9331135749816895,
0.685204267501831,
-0.44800058007240295,
-0.45069998502731323,
0.8156359195709229,
0.47620490193367004,
0.6984871029853821,
0.4043584167957306,
0.838412880897522,
-0.09705781936645508,
0.3083667755126953,
-0.3760603666305542,
0.5167101621627808,
-0.7802320122718811,
0.48854580521583557,
-0.436571329832077,
-1.0518463850021362,
-0.3549221158027649,
0.6876777410507202,
-0.596575915813446,
-0.26734548807144165,
0.7160301804542542,
0.39430922269821167,
-0.435226172208786,
0.056057147681713104,
0.5216950178146362,
0.10144232958555222,
0.13881416618824005,
0.09842272847890854,
0.9533721208572388,
-0.4146234095096588,
0.21468479931354523,
0.17489410936832428,
-0.5219382643699646,
-0.28327956795692444,
-1.1592692136764526,
-0.689318060874939,
-0.7068469524383545,
-0.16096343100070953,
-0.25175943970680237,
-0.10628902167081833,
0.4130153954029083,
0.6348294019699097,
-0.5557991862297058,
-0.4852009415626526,
0.21617081761360168,
0.26842233538627625,
-0.29790034890174866,
-0.19979991018772125,
0.3722793459892273,
-0.5820352435112,
-0.696774959564209,
0.5272020697593689,
0.39530321955680847,
-0.15550106763839722,
-0.32551416754722595,
0.2099303901195526,
-0.1040801852941513,
0.3597520589828491,
0.8895054459571838,
-0.11165531724691391,
-0.5713925957679749,
-0.44664549827575684,
-0.045464761555194855,
-0.16258974373340607,
0.2602512836456299,
1.0573419332504272,
-0.401734858751297,
0.5859765410423279,
0.7450499534606934,
0.6019675731658936,
0.6358309388160706,
0.3218485414981842,
0.6162945628166199,
-0.9674431681632996,
0.13838690519332886,
-0.0007590497261844575,
0.5566622614860535,
0.5944348573684692,
-0.22485370934009552,
0.5999726057052612,
0.15367917716503143,
-0.49451497197151184,
-0.9360270500183105,
0.3463738262653351,
-0.797640860080719,
-0.21745382249355316,
1.0967718362808228,
-0.5210856795310974,
-0.03191477805376053,
-0.1699475646018982,
-0.19595329463481903,
0.28768157958984375,
-0.37761205434799194,
0.6070419549942017,
1.0885560512542725,
-0.04330667853355408,
0.07878994941711426,
-0.897726833820343,
0.4447437524795532,
0.477274626493454,
-0.7248602509498596,
0.11120681464672089,
0.6181100010871887,
0.09951242059469223,
0.5381447672843933,
0.7825894355773926,
-0.2042461633682251,
-0.17505453526973724,
-0.24105998873710632,
-0.4605233669281006,
0.02063264697790146,
-0.17649762332439423,
-0.4014602303504944,
0.15290890634059906,
-0.08106058835983276,
0.15305988490581512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01812v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01812v1 | Distilling LLMs' Decomposition Abilities into Compact Language Models | 2024-02-02T13:23:15 | 2024-02-02T13:23:15 | Denis Tarasov, Kumar Shridhar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated proficiency in their reasoning
abilities, yet their large size presents scalability challenges and limits any
further customization. In contrast, compact models offer customized training
but often fall short in solving complex reasoning tasks. This study focuses on
distilling the LLMs' decomposition skills into compact models using offline
reinforcement learning. We leverage the advancements in the LLM`s capabilities
to provide feedback and generate a specialized task-specific dataset for
training compact models. The development of an AI-generated dataset and the
establishment of baselines constitute the primary contributions of our work,
underscoring the potential of compact models in replicating complex
problem-solving skills. | [
-0.29365164041519165,
-0.877873420715332,
0.9285743236541748,
-0.05390606448054314,
-0.10293605923652649,
0.3292706608772278,
-0.6313947439193726,
-0.028379959985613823,
-0.07816196978092194,
0.5255904793739319,
-0.7567689418792725,
-0.09502732008695602,
-0.5945723056793213,
0.20607194304466248,
-0.26592952013015747,
0.9031117558479309,
-0.11618582159280777,
0.03531273081898689,
-0.2962614595890045,
0.008264297619462013,
-0.2583089768886566,
-0.3726441562175751,
-0.765964925289154,
-0.4580727517604828,
0.14507657289505005,
0.4917057156562805,
0.2956484854221344,
0.6517817974090576,
0.11133740097284317,
0.4927101135253906,
-0.1856483817100525,
0.4965013861656189,
-0.8398757576942444,
0.119988813996315,
-0.32220569252967834,
-0.773573637008667,
-0.17070898413658142,
0.016440384089946747,
0.7174717783927917,
0.8452900648117065,
-0.5097814798355103,
-0.006822490133345127,
-0.12568321824073792,
0.32146885991096497,
-0.5197606086730957,
0.4353676438331604,
-0.7898426055908203,
-0.20816777646541595,
0.2381596565246582,
-0.09020702540874481,
-0.568957507610321,
-0.33911368250846863,
0.14685367047786713,
-0.7633641362190247,
0.21160900592803955,
0.07256157696247101,
0.6122323870658875,
0.5901726484298706,
-0.45420876145362854,
-0.6196238994598389,
-1.1268402338027954,
1.0175856351852417,
-0.7031510472297668,
-0.011781231500208378,
0.31086114048957825,
0.5901802778244019,
-0.38061752915382385,
-0.7158126831054688,
-0.5940902233123779,
-0.253887802362442,
-0.07957908511161804,
0.007632185705006123,
-0.006214031483978033,
-0.04378482326865196,
0.16567131876945496,
0.2722731828689575,
-0.25360023975372314,
0.26156240701675415,
-0.48960763216018677,
0.3082323968410492,
0.8580828309059143,
0.43203234672546387,
0.10513648390769958,
0.1110185906291008,
0.004145389888435602,
-0.16836348176002502,
-0.4869552254676819,
0.06041403487324715,
0.2326199859380722,
0.37278327345848083,
0.037134114652872086,
0.7136601805686951,
-0.22140558063983917,
0.7027090787887573,
0.35907265543937683,
-0.8454534411430359,
-0.06861460953950882,
-0.3751053214073181,
-0.23535841703414917,
0.0038549993187189102,
0.577913761138916,
-0.18551522493362427,
-0.12866994738578796,
-0.252593994140625,
-0.6343381404876709,
-0.03114696964621544,
0.21593376994132996,
-0.6562427878379822,
-0.42378175258636475,
0.21350857615470886,
-0.4249315559864044,
-0.25298717617988586,
-0.19614186882972717,
-0.28430524468421936,
-0.3401552736759186,
-0.642487645149231,
0.4662919044494629,
-0.20218181610107422,
-0.13955897092819214,
0.27625295519828796,
-0.297914981842041,
-0.11462473124265671,
0.48369020223617554,
-0.8168544769287109,
0.5666137933731079,
0.4441956877708435,
0.5613304972648621,
-0.22248810529708862,
0.020882487297058105,
-0.6251296401023865,
0.1603045016527176,
-0.09614544361829758,
0.7736265063285828,
-0.5610025525093079,
-0.4411108195781708,
-0.03195708245038986,
0.09328785538673401,
-0.12177661806344986,
-1.0220723152160645,
0.511458694934845,
-0.4101645350456238,
-0.032232366502285004,
-0.12597213685512543,
-0.7635330557823181,
-0.08601515740156174,
0.6105847358703613,
-0.6916930079460144,
0.8338297009468079,
0.3504227101802826,
-0.6104974746704102,
-0.10006768256425858,
-0.5496291518211365,
-0.2947395443916321,
0.0426555871963501,
-0.42668721079826355,
-0.7636358141899109,
0.0249786414206028,
0.10473506152629852,
0.7558049559593201,
-0.329775869846344,
0.3943037986755371,
-0.4982178509235382,
-0.23565740883350372,
0.2839711308479309,
0.01883859932422638,
0.5618426203727722,
0.06510098278522491,
-0.46220919489860535,
0.20525804162025452,
-1.0161417722702026,
-0.0594598650932312,
0.6339728832244873,
-0.5439590215682983,
-0.13643723726272583,
0.09207987785339355,
-0.1964014172554016,
0.3553483486175537,
0.2880876660346985,
-0.48852062225341797,
0.34115472435951233,
-0.2142505645751953,
0.6439451575279236,
0.4763403534889221,
0.01235914882272482,
0.5502430200576782,
-0.5172971487045288,
0.5822623372077942,
-0.12113767117261887,
0.0017838787753134966,
0.2073052078485489,
-0.11547359824180603,
-0.9908284544944763,
-0.5574779510498047,
0.04132626950740814,
0.5233672857284546,
-0.9210124015808105,
0.4663586914539337,
-0.26602768898010254,
-0.6580769419670105,
-0.13348567485809326,
0.21120554208755493,
0.5616136193275452,
0.20807431638240814,
0.3274773359298706,
0.21956072747707367,
-0.5712448954582214,
-0.7906815409660339,
0.270547479391098,
0.06137896329164505,
-0.10754774510860443,
0.3302786946296692,
0.6233105063438416,
-0.41062507033348083,
0.9031551480293274,
-0.8129555583000183,
-0.4531802833080292,
-0.8334049582481384,
0.16875116527080536,
-0.26615196466445923,
0.2188723385334015,
0.23624196648597717,
-0.7842134833335876,
-0.24216453731060028,
-0.20106488466262817,
-0.5246118903160095,
0.06680916994810104,
-0.2815885543823242,
0.25306329131126404,
-0.050611309707164764,
0.6301780939102173,
-0.5544041991233826,
0.2091182917356491,
0.5724180340766907,
-0.15615390241146088,
0.7406116724014282,
-0.5773128271102905,
-0.15411199629306793,
-1.002498984336853,
-0.014295903034508228,
-0.17805399000644684,
-0.4032403230667114,
-0.4201768636703491,
-0.014029564335942268,
-0.38785287737846375,
-0.0410211980342865,
-0.4251278042793274,
0.4740537703037262,
-0.4871910810470581,
-0.2950705587863922,
-0.3127957582473755,
0.5161104798316956,
0.0871475413441658,
0.6354494690895081,
0.2805015742778778,
0.3046274185180664,
0.14981777966022491,
-0.692814826965332,
0.5938407182693481,
0.4773086905479431,
-0.3010883927345276,
0.2674539387226105,
-0.7427186965942383,
-0.2132502645254135,
-0.05854388698935509,
0.5342536568641663,
-0.8241350650787354,
-0.36991816759109497,
-0.006865204311907291,
0.06027476117014885,
0.369829922914505,
-0.19973912835121155,
-0.6362541913986206,
-0.04694506898522377,
-0.12084314227104187,
0.27567148208618164,
0.626162588596344,
-0.44208675622940063,
0.8163684606552124,
0.5937039256095886,
-0.20467504858970642,
-0.16129367053508759,
-0.49868765473365784,
-0.5012338757514954,
-0.29460608959198,
-0.4123916029930115,
0.5246500372886658,
-0.11629290133714676,
-0.533538818359375,
0.14007310569286346,
0.21833620965480804,
-0.24423274397850037,
0.21364149451255798,
0.2951653003692627,
0.19733543694019318,
0.1252322793006897,
0.10196898877620697,
-0.025652028620243073,
0.12619982659816742,
0.001031072111800313,
-0.014152418822050095,
0.37766584753990173,
-0.11238957941532135,
-0.18819747865200043,
-0.17158612608909607,
0.31714826822280884,
0.47263193130493164,
-0.31965839862823486,
0.9679194688796997,
0.3079529404640198,
-0.20550404489040375,
-0.7946957945823669,
-0.22606289386749268,
-0.1473640501499176,
-0.46722331643104553,
0.3375511169433594,
-0.3023126423358917,
-0.9535242915153503,
0.5166829228401184,
-0.5149377584457397,
0.22828532755374908,
0.2614905834197998,
0.8809645771980286,
-0.09598717093467712,
1.1276417970657349,
0.743693470954895,
0.46647098660469055,
0.3757665157318115,
-0.6534371376037598,
0.2593754529953003,
-0.7198283672332764,
-0.5712130069732666,
-0.44623416662216187,
-0.13243363797664642,
-0.4342721104621887,
-0.6720475554466248,
0.24836772680282593,
0.24768252670764923,
-0.22228528559207916,
0.11042775958776474,
-0.3661315143108368,
0.4414615035057068,
0.2906969487667084,
0.2535872161388397,
0.2867625951766968,
-0.41329893469810486,
-0.05220818892121315,
0.4826093912124634,
-0.9400217533111572,
-0.43915271759033203,
1.0359570980072021,
0.3630419373512268,
0.8078393340110779,
0.020046813413500786,
0.7315901517868042,
0.021233510226011276,
0.06743475049734116,
-0.9493424892425537,
0.5784741640090942,
-0.19188615679740906,
-0.3966324031352997,
-0.5592180490493774,
-0.8350101709365845,
-0.8567885160446167,
0.09514950960874557,
-0.2775726914405823,
-0.4224812388420105,
-0.26056793332099915,
0.23635217547416687,
-0.39939361810684204,
0.33924421668052673,
-0.587913990020752,
0.6656983494758606,
-0.2822207808494568,
-0.028316181153059006,
-0.3780065178871155,
-0.510418176651001,
0.6570984721183777,
-0.23025953769683838,
0.4034894108772278,
-0.12606102228164673,
0.10211051255464554,
0.7265844345092773,
-0.6990211009979248,
0.9652729630470276,
-0.1505713164806366,
-0.1113884449005127,
0.3955642282962799,
0.19453345239162445,
0.8818839192390442,
0.11525939404964447,
0.20991134643554688,
-0.41668567061424255,
0.20166823267936707,
-0.44959312677383423,
-0.7322887778282166,
0.6249954700469971,
-1.0754773616790771,
-0.46205317974090576,
-0.1463296115398407,
-0.5710127949714661,
-0.3301228880882263,
-0.04877224192023277,
0.1334727257490158,
0.5188893675804138,
-0.22979164123535156,
0.014508006162941456,
1.0887749195098877,
-0.12629123032093048,
0.44566673040390015,
0.4489155411720276,
-0.17449580132961273,
-0.10749360918998718,
0.8663699626922607,
0.2056819051504135,
0.41837945580482483,
0.3453436493873596,
0.2733343243598938,
-0.52440345287323,
-0.7232808470726013,
-0.13679145276546478,
0.2880629897117615,
-1.119170904159546,
0.005310747306793928,
-0.6005446910858154,
-0.08620119094848633,
-0.052077703177928925,
-0.3255877196788788,
-0.7238666415214539,
-0.5366708040237427,
-0.3809606730937958,
-0.01812385395169258,
-0.012670464813709259,
1.122341513633728,
0.2588782012462616,
0.2599046230316162,
-0.9844170212745667,
0.31281954050064087,
0.48943471908569336,
0.08116566389799118,
-0.09929613769054413,
-0.6616089344024658,
-0.3576189875602722,
-0.04830373823642731,
-0.25488632917404175,
-0.4461544454097748,
0.319035142660141,
0.3113308548927307,
0.6635724306106567,
0.30974292755126953,
0.3146524727344513,
0.5073187947273254,
-0.41892796754837036,
0.6911383867263794,
-0.03104923851788044,
-0.9050441384315491,
0.4355553388595581,
-0.2640393376350403,
0.3204800486564636,
0.3690568804740906,
0.6281114220619202,
0.027510087937116623,
-0.4499448239803314,
-0.764286458492279,
-0.5434808135032654,
0.8550516366958618,
0.3176974952220917,
-0.2788572311401367,
0.05396062135696411,
0.38971462845802307,
0.2048334777355194,
0.012564700096845627,
-0.4993734061717987,
-0.17557726800441742,
-0.03289342671632767,
-0.18536119163036346,
-0.17885594069957733,
-0.13807140290737152,
-0.23074853420257568,
-0.17111283540725708,
0.8079385757446289,
-0.3231954574584961,
0.21110370755195618,
-0.15850509703159332,
-0.21337591111660004,
0.15874618291854858,
0.32527828216552734,
0.7499178051948547,
0.6644544005393982,
-0.04076297581195831,
0.15931816399097443,
0.27297261357307434,
0.061349932104349136,
0.4259378910064697,
-0.16219736635684967,
0.06601518392562866,
-0.17489291727542877,
0.40092939138412476,
0.8036126494407654,
0.343597948551178,
-1.2921128273010254,
0.47394391894340515,
-0.37262916564941406,
-0.3482067286968231,
-0.6591613292694092,
0.19895753264427185,
0.379986047744751,
0.4873504638671875,
0.005314406007528305,
0.030299657955765724,
0.07026340067386627,
-0.7331748008728027,
0.13760454952716827,
0.2400546669960022,
-0.03132195398211479,
-0.4652376174926758,
0.34559202194213867,
0.18885990977287292,
-0.02046569064259529,
0.7614526748657227,
-0.7384472489356995,
-0.6515724658966064,
0.5535891652107239,
0.6429210305213928,
0.518770694732666,
0.037080854177474976,
0.32046958804130554,
0.33516761660575867,
-0.05755150318145752,
-0.4696091413497925,
0.16807660460472107,
-0.06289487332105637,
-0.6146201491355896,
-0.5609181523323059,
-0.5701102614402771,
-0.41356363892555237,
0.19084058701992035,
-0.5996349453926086,
0.3540721833705902,
-0.7445773482322693,
-0.02385580912232399,
-0.18602117896080017,
0.10505431145429611,
-0.7009989619255066,
0.4219001233577728,
0.2971944510936737,
0.43947654962539673,
-0.9041939377784729,
1.0351778268814087,
0.6590176224708557,
-0.4114866852760315,
-1.2723618745803833,
-0.19400350749492645,
-0.05398580804467201,
-0.5306325554847717,
0.9771804809570312,
0.012052220292389393,
-0.07839410752058029,
-0.05175168812274933,
-0.3644518256187439,
-0.8694145679473877,
1.2460789680480957,
0.5895029306411743,
-0.6414895057678223,
-0.2209855318069458,
0.22246645390987396,
0.4426974952220917,
-0.5412155985832214,
0.3323219418525696,
0.794280469417572,
0.24640031158924103,
0.3148784637451172,
-1.2065538167953491,
0.0836651623249054,
0.042248401790857315,
-0.03125285729765892,
0.21110554039478302,
-0.6703035235404968,
0.9928581118583679,
-0.3014717698097229,
-0.19937613606452942,
-0.18352937698364258,
0.23338273167610168,
0.37808793783187866,
-0.13447915017604828,
0.5226675868034363,
0.7241737842559814,
0.8826533555984497,
-0.007839065045118332,
0.8702313303947449,
0.12972159683704376,
0.3982701897621155,
1.4786080121994019,
-0.3147059381008148,
1.0747146606445312,
0.3056706190109253,
0.0977797657251358,
0.6598869562149048,
0.46136966347694397,
0.038836028426885605,
0.7303905487060547,
0.46204546093940735,
-0.2847496569156647,
-0.573593020439148,
-0.19088074564933777,
0.2561427652835846,
0.664505124092102,
0.44578611850738525,
-0.14597724378108978,
-0.34886088967323303,
0.16976898908615112,
-0.12391528487205505,
0.22151389718055725,
-0.5268261432647705,
0.9849762320518494,
0.03404751420021057,
-0.7870272994041443,
0.6396476626396179,
0.41717860102653503,
0.4158644676208496,
-0.7171095609664917,
-0.07434651255607605,
-0.024809032678604126,
0.5377892851829529,
-0.2718805968761444,
-0.6094468832015991,
0.5823208689689636,
-0.24406589567661285,
-0.236728698015213,
-0.22585894167423248,
0.47355249524116516,
-0.5219181776046753,
-0.23563717305660248,
0.3629474341869354,
0.36050909757614136,
-0.008247317746281624,
-0.013795140199363232,
-0.6702998280525208,
0.24958445131778717,
0.0663166344165802,
-0.2735711634159088,
0.5121164917945862,
0.48657241463661194,
-0.20882411301136017,
1.0597968101501465,
0.49002763628959656,
-0.04702359810471535,
0.23952986299991608,
-0.22850638628005981,
1.1071833372116089,
-0.3726486265659332,
-0.5791319608688354,
-0.585713803768158,
0.5869336724281311,
0.07870100438594818,
-0.054527170956134796,
0.5609565377235413,
0.35817867517471313,
1.0865823030471802,
-0.24203495681285858,
0.944598913192749,
-0.11727312207221985,
0.40490612387657166,
-0.6608943939208984,
0.36394697427749634,
-0.5137233734130859,
0.3405539095401764,
0.3185606002807617,
-0.718464195728302,
0.03958930820226669,
0.34248435497283936,
-0.3450053036212921,
-0.04381543770432472,
0.6963433623313904,
0.5549092888832092,
-0.015395094640552998,
-0.3710753321647644,
0.43125513195991516,
0.0542261004447937,
0.4914414584636688,
0.7746995091438293,
0.8950223326683044,
-0.12730440497398376,
0.7514064311981201,
-0.35557085275650024,
-0.2572219669818878,
-0.38678786158561707,
-0.7040167450904846,
-1.3724790811538696,
-0.6465604901313782,
-0.44216543436050415,
-0.039813894778490067,
-0.4022570252418518,
1.1664907932281494,
0.8038517832756042,
-0.6665961742401123,
-0.07048411667346954,
-0.16183699667453766,
-0.17054226994514465,
-0.11892799288034439,
-0.1404813826084137,
0.3701583445072174,
-0.3789702355861664,
-0.5851446986198425,
0.6374597549438477,
0.1802046298980713,
0.10993697494268417,
-0.5299637317657471,
-0.3911811113357544,
-0.10175998508930206,
0.38663092255592346,
0.5895904898643494,
0.23476962745189667,
-0.7590972185134888,
-0.029307501390576363,
-0.11926446855068207,
-0.09891755878925323,
-0.1063297912478447,
0.951424241065979,
-0.7608798742294312,
0.4070121943950653,
0.5576892495155334,
0.7617213726043701,
0.6529116630554199,
-0.07716865837574005,
0.5928754210472107,
-0.9699985384941101,
0.1603856384754181,
0.3735295534133911,
0.5766610503196716,
0.33583319187164307,
-0.18796269595623016,
0.16794805228710175,
0.08209690451622009,
-0.693840742111206,
-0.7976455688476562,
0.3037799000740051,
-0.9094299674034119,
-0.6359615325927734,
1.1960675716400146,
-0.7091991305351257,
-0.20573961734771729,
-0.3189414441585541,
-0.1874314397573471,
0.4097973108291626,
-0.024075327441096306,
0.8293578624725342,
0.37227606773376465,
-0.3324224650859833,
-0.15582887828350067,
-0.17813462018966675,
0.6560587882995605,
0.17298102378845215,
-1.2104058265686035,
0.07261887192726135,
0.33034008741378784,
0.49354588985443115,
0.194060280919075,
0.46616169810295105,
0.14133289456367493,
-0.02520556002855301,
0.22267255187034607,
-0.03981452062726021,
-0.31150341033935547,
-0.41115602850914,
-0.2668069005012512,
0.25811532139778137,
0.34441736340522766,
0.13737516105175018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01391v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01391v2 | StepCoder: Improve Code Generation with Reinforcement Learning from Compiler Feedback | 2024-02-02T13:14:31 | 2024-02-05T13:28:23 | Shihan Dou, Yan Liu, Haoxiang Jia, Limao Xiong, Enyu Zhou, Wei Shen, Junjie Shan, Caishuang Huang, Xiao Wang, Xiaoran Fan, Zhiheng Xi, Yuhao Zhou, Tao Ji, Rui Zheng, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang, Tao Gui | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | The advancement of large language models (LLMs) has significantly propelled
the field of code generation. Previous work integrated reinforcement learning
(RL) with compiler feedback for exploring the output space of LLMs to enhance
code generation quality. However, the lengthy code generated by LLMs in
response to complex human requirements makes RL exploration a challenge. Also,
since the unit tests may not cover the complicated code, optimizing LLMs by
using these unexecuted code snippets is ineffective. To tackle these
challenges, we introduce StepCoder, a novel RL framework for code generation,
consisting of two main components: CCCS addresses the exploration challenge by
breaking the long sequences code generation task into a Curriculum of Code
Completion Subtasks, while FGO only optimizes the model by masking the
unexecuted code segments to provide Fine-Grained Optimization. In addition, we
furthermore construct the APPS+ dataset for RL training, which is manually
verified to ensure the correctness of unit tests. Experimental results show
that our method improves the ability to explore the output space and
outperforms state-of-the-art approaches in corresponding benchmarks. Our
dataset APPS+ and StepCoder are available online. | [
-0.38999852538108826,
-0.39601531624794006,
0.36946484446525574,
0.24504080414772034,
-0.18288137018680573,
0.5792820453643799,
-0.35198190808296204,
-0.1530623435974121,
-0.05490545555949211,
0.535718560218811,
-0.651289701461792,
-0.5934505462646484,
-0.4101562201976776,
0.008247639052569866,
-0.2755444049835205,
1.1010617017745972,
-0.2088213413953781,
0.09540452063083649,
-0.4507352411746979,
0.12131534516811371,
-0.23632577061653137,
-0.37898001074790955,
-0.7516643404960632,
-0.43913453817367554,
0.5195361375808716,
0.5555223226547241,
0.2763383984565735,
0.43634986877441406,
0.15658687055110931,
0.24126474559307098,
-0.00047055783215910196,
0.5139083862304688,
-0.6600690484046936,
0.1695438027381897,
0.16440917551517487,
-0.1407104730606079,
-0.07135841250419617,
-0.46352216601371765,
0.32997870445251465,
0.25716033577919006,
-0.3097461462020874,
0.18179956078529358,
0.03227856755256653,
0.7133703231811523,
-0.6742467284202576,
0.44375237822532654,
-0.22585058212280273,
0.33192744851112366,
0.21054553985595703,
-0.43652471899986267,
-0.5573124885559082,
-0.5090857148170471,
-0.5145423412322998,
-0.3186306953430176,
0.2314985990524292,
-0.06451211124658585,
0.4190513789653778,
0.4150776267051697,
-0.22841376066207886,
-0.5089409351348877,
-0.8332056403160095,
0.618665874004364,
-0.6015992760658264,
0.49504244327545166,
-0.006866297218948603,
0.14671611785888672,
-0.28591740131378174,
-0.5419942140579224,
-0.40115511417388916,
-0.5693289637565613,
0.027823979035019875,
-0.06826270371675491,
0.21500620245933533,
0.031957607716321945,
0.4520851671695709,
0.40977945923805237,
-0.45187634229660034,
0.07351285964250565,
-0.511918842792511,
-0.30059200525283813,
0.8039898872375488,
0.31713441014289856,
0.15800419449806213,
0.03870503976941109,
-0.2263561338186264,
-0.22422152757644653,
-0.8706945180892944,
0.4425233006477356,
0.3494507968425751,
0.230101078748703,
0.16102878749370575,
0.2542151212692261,
-0.2616491913795471,
0.5648629069328308,
0.13971032202243805,
-0.03411597013473511,
0.2843357026576996,
-0.1925939917564392,
0.12691161036491394,
0.03792109712958336,
0.6674190759658813,
-0.013311255723237991,
0.003379691857844591,
-0.10984114557504654,
-0.4563589096069336,
-0.012135593220591545,
0.581672191619873,
-0.8842489719390869,
-0.25275981426239014,
0.33194464445114136,
-0.05459759756922722,
-0.5322234034538269,
0.20933102071285248,
-0.574796736240387,
-0.3557305634021759,
-0.18531790375709534,
0.03771449252963066,
-0.3262695372104645,
-0.07238398492336273,
0.11099785566329956,
0.25251296162605286,
0.34592172503471375,
0.29873594641685486,
-0.791695773601532,
0.15333561599254608,
0.7831985950469971,
0.5086029767990112,
-0.27278074622154236,
-0.2843577563762665,
-1.0533719062805176,
-0.18550318479537964,
-0.6650485396385193,
0.2730463147163391,
-0.36621344089508057,
-0.5948957204818726,
0.18444159626960754,
-0.24532541632652283,
0.25845232605934143,
-0.5842651724815369,
0.17929838597774506,
-0.6996235847473145,
-0.14478252828121185,
0.12923374772071838,
-0.4660363793373108,
0.04116857424378395,
0.21532925963401794,
-0.5339123606681824,
1.2051222324371338,
0.2631644904613495,
-0.3811623156070709,
0.39821669459342957,
-0.6044753193855286,
-0.5743874311447144,
0.21549633145332336,
-0.574019730091095,
-0.5837284922599792,
0.16719815135002136,
0.38685843348503113,
0.34851494431495667,
-0.038998622447252274,
0.3910437226295471,
0.08385750651359558,
-0.5270548462867737,
0.2065427154302597,
0.055870912969112396,
0.2411489486694336,
0.35140982270240784,
-0.5517322421073914,
0.4358702301979065,
-0.7448853850364685,
0.3682941198348999,
0.036535270512104034,
-0.9033666253089905,
0.0935988575220108,
0.11579843610525131,
-0.15567386150360107,
0.4491496980190277,
0.14549730718135834,
-0.5035377144813538,
0.27466344833374023,
-0.2171417772769928,
0.23332561552524567,
0.6232905387878418,
0.11794339120388031,
0.31883081793785095,
-0.14756979048252106,
0.9193426966667175,
0.042018815875053406,
0.16228701174259186,
-0.33162471652030945,
-0.09678077697753906,
-0.9440084099769592,
-0.043274108320474625,
0.35712745785713196,
0.41660556197166443,
-1.1594220399856567,
0.49079206585884094,
-0.23301927745342255,
-0.2758960425853729,
-0.3757261633872986,
0.48944878578186035,
0.7295133471488953,
-0.02563204988837242,
0.34138625860214233,
-0.6108723878860474,
-0.5351166129112244,
-0.40150773525238037,
-0.0653550922870636,
-0.041181083768606186,
-0.0844004675745964,
0.4115634858608246,
0.5009348392486572,
-0.37006309628486633,
0.7538943290710449,
-0.4745095670223236,
0.08969292044639587,
-0.6757128834724426,
0.05290665477514267,
-0.022996073588728905,
0.5459800362586975,
-0.024904826655983925,
-0.527452826499939,
-0.18098323047161102,
-0.05207318440079689,
-0.35206466913223267,
0.022813808172941208,
-0.3559310734272003,
0.08878209441900253,
0.13367781043052673,
0.9009987115859985,
-0.10114187002182007,
0.19540825486183167,
0.6847268342971802,
-0.13961219787597656,
0.3811393976211548,
-0.35457319021224976,
0.07629232108592987,
-0.6468328833580017,
-0.03756462782621384,
-0.28250664472579956,
-0.3844866156578064,
-0.3210534155368805,
0.4729568064212799,
0.22566865384578705,
-0.3161267638206482,
-0.4946630299091339,
0.28761130571365356,
-0.3355582356452942,
-0.1683819741010666,
-0.24191473424434662,
-0.20681896805763245,
-0.10611562430858612,
0.7398428320884705,
0.1081097349524498,
0.9574537873268127,
0.23573802411556244,
-0.5884323716163635,
0.30860137939453125,
0.05499141663312912,
-0.43394842743873596,
-0.1961216926574707,
-0.4019851088523865,
0.4520799517631531,
0.027490532025694847,
0.4939873516559601,
-0.6259110569953918,
-0.24189618229866028,
0.10799656063318253,
-0.3688720464706421,
0.4471990764141083,
-0.03717408329248428,
-0.3544858992099762,
-0.5030000805854797,
-0.3473231792449951,
0.2873203456401825,
0.6477320790290833,
-0.7300015687942505,
0.3293222486972809,
0.05720648542046547,
0.017521005123853683,
-0.5247370600700378,
-0.5661881566047668,
-0.11712510138750076,
0.21061861515045166,
-0.28501901030540466,
-0.07413274794816971,
-0.20189732313156128,
0.19922637939453125,
-0.33757469058036804,
-0.340204119682312,
0.07510305196046829,
-0.05011223256587982,
0.3773157298564911,
0.03297115117311478,
0.03509121015667915,
0.01475469209253788,
-0.008341644890606403,
-0.23823274672031403,
0.22622345387935638,
-0.3128226697444916,
0.5630954504013062,
-0.040223993360996246,
-0.5203269720077515,
0.06464898586273193,
0.15035466849803925,
0.31925132870674133,
-0.3975357711315155,
0.1431920975446701,
0.5205504894256592,
0.15419825911521912,
-0.7977852821350098,
-0.17520815134048462,
0.023635923862457275,
-0.47880083322525024,
0.519038736820221,
-0.1434919387102127,
-1.3308576345443726,
0.14931939542293549,
-0.3580269515514374,
0.18851879239082336,
0.0025537877809256315,
0.42109695076942444,
0.2777339518070221,
0.9541743397712708,
0.6320022940635681,
-0.016433900222182274,
0.47655022144317627,
-0.4862557351589203,
0.28146836161613464,
-0.7753342390060425,
-0.39775538444519043,
-0.38480305671691895,
-0.05715849995613098,
-0.4548858404159546,
-0.8990674614906311,
0.14688634872436523,
0.08739051222801208,
-0.2651095986366272,
0.24741478264331818,
-0.5692363381385803,
0.7274054884910583,
0.5601414442062378,
0.39538881182670593,
0.14690175652503967,
-0.14619792997837067,
-0.23500879108905792,
0.03822571411728859,
-0.9255682826042175,
-0.14054706692695618,
0.981532633304596,
0.3701135516166687,
0.92915278673172,
-0.04635809734463692,
1.2292054891586304,
0.4254351258277893,
0.21699753403663635,
-0.7036387920379639,
0.5604295134544373,
-0.03217426687479019,
-0.2767588198184967,
-0.13391797244548798,
-0.7007800936698914,
-0.5822795629501343,
-0.036542825400829315,
0.035521719604730606,
-0.3122129440307617,
0.06665239483118057,
0.2982074022293091,
-0.5243838429450989,
0.1330948770046234,
-0.2459663450717926,
0.7747142910957336,
-0.46431291103363037,
-0.5642191767692566,
-0.1778799146413803,
-0.48271918296813965,
0.42652592062950134,
-0.13474027812480927,
0.2953599691390991,
0.3922988474369049,
0.00592393521219492,
0.477084219455719,
-0.6864265203475952,
0.7710927724838257,
-0.2634521722793579,
-0.3938571512699127,
0.4364849030971527,
0.30050796270370483,
0.776591420173645,
0.09677997976541519,
0.22740168869495392,
-0.24820095300674438,
-0.6065276265144348,
-0.3275364339351654,
-0.5016453862190247,
0.7595115900039673,
-0.5174883008003235,
-0.25108811259269714,
-0.34992459416389465,
-0.4116392731666565,
-0.3639261722564697,
-0.07699641585350037,
0.226261168718338,
0.43408137559890747,
-0.1019120141863823,
0.07656926661729813,
0.9141107797622681,
-0.5718550086021423,
0.2995487153530121,
0.2322172075510025,
-0.5361786484718323,
-0.46341264247894287,
1.0666389465332031,
-0.5753458142280579,
0.23426444828510284,
0.3256373107433319,
-0.05280714109539986,
-0.19812516868114471,
-0.7182551622390747,
-0.5577289462089539,
-0.19517582654953003,
-0.6154883503913879,
-0.26946666836738586,
-0.3268541991710663,
-0.4732891917228699,
-0.12553997337818146,
-0.26847267150878906,
-0.47004908323287964,
-0.045543525367975235,
-0.092913918197155,
-0.1819167584180832,
0.22188249230384827,
0.9495800137519836,
-0.03733972832560539,
0.04243176430463791,
-0.933556079864502,
0.1997603178024292,
0.3634813129901886,
0.36017709970474243,
-0.010450359433889389,
-0.2248530238866806,
-0.5374986529350281,
-0.12407202273607254,
-0.3632180094718933,
-0.3342511057853699,
0.28588345646858215,
0.025177597999572754,
0.26986268162727356,
0.26029467582702637,
0.029106302186846733,
0.577589750289917,
-0.5460226535797119,
0.9026166796684265,
0.29944124817848206,
-0.9104644060134888,
0.5414126515388489,
-0.1693493276834488,
0.3882836401462555,
0.6379287242889404,
0.08896372467279434,
-0.312085896730423,
-0.5985713005065918,
-0.6029977798461914,
-1.0289008617401123,
0.7132817506790161,
0.0871153324842453,
0.04093417897820473,
0.04093095287680626,
0.3288424015045166,
0.02687671408057213,
0.33932650089263916,
-0.7319334149360657,
0.09348879009485245,
-0.12291789054870605,
-0.08315256983041763,
-0.33232519030570984,
-0.13366660475730896,
0.013823654502630234,
-0.13949662446975708,
0.6823722124099731,
-0.2770230770111084,
0.20348548889160156,
0.05132381245493889,
-0.2295341044664383,
-0.29131922125816345,
0.31539952754974365,
0.8006618022918701,
0.4272753596305847,
0.016584675759077072,
-0.07818268984556198,
0.16798928380012512,
-0.4608081877231598,
0.29915323853492737,
-0.15385685861110687,
-0.20948460698127747,
-0.1288989782333374,
0.41374003887176514,
0.9080317616462708,
0.4630546569824219,
-0.8778632879257202,
0.554418683052063,
-0.08947572112083435,
-0.30604851245880127,
-0.34555211663246155,
0.6500535607337952,
-0.01439517829567194,
0.41643255949020386,
0.15756073594093323,
0.0980958491563797,
-0.0063678123988211155,
-0.29728421568870544,
0.5070302486419678,
0.0865943506360054,
-0.5360694527626038,
0.05119704827666283,
0.6538340449333191,
0.4162769913673401,
-0.317264586687088,
0.6365115642547607,
-0.47467419505119324,
-0.6844046711921692,
0.7380642294883728,
0.33342960476875305,
0.9232515096664429,
-0.014726748690009117,
0.3002079427242279,
0.4836510717868805,
0.2268199473619461,
-0.08455365896224976,
0.2796047329902649,
-0.37958428263664246,
-0.3028106689453125,
-0.7959141731262207,
-0.8082131147384644,
-0.479286789894104,
0.07136615365743637,
-0.6209567785263062,
0.13906803727149963,
-0.7361550331115723,
0.30116006731987,
-0.6297577619552612,
0.11794626712799072,
-0.49690407514572144,
0.14866629242897034,
0.31846705079078674,
0.9310758113861084,
-0.5773949027061462,
0.9308531284332275,
0.5115982294082642,
-0.44882360100746155,
-1.051374912261963,
0.057896457612514496,
-0.1351153701543808,
-0.660110354423523,
0.7549647688865662,
0.1577780395746231,
-0.24070410430431366,
-0.026418406516313553,
-0.6084747910499573,
-0.4730820059776306,
0.9779841899871826,
0.10500830411911011,
-0.7942972183227539,
-0.0500594861805439,
0.1729384958744049,
0.49033406376838684,
-0.6703166961669922,
0.08220936357975006,
0.38619470596313477,
0.172270730137825,
0.26499131321907043,
-0.39527130126953125,
0.09320107847452164,
-0.15368245542049408,
0.35006386041641235,
0.45814159512519836,
-0.5234476923942566,
0.5854261517524719,
-0.5415851473808289,
0.1191796138882637,
0.1704646646976471,
0.5133498311042786,
0.5462859272956848,
0.22917558252811432,
0.384995698928833,
0.4598245620727539,
0.3480776846408844,
-0.03805634751915932,
1.117963433265686,
-0.35495010018348694,
0.53660649061203,
1.2685883045196533,
-0.2470306158065796,
0.7584482431411743,
0.36718258261680603,
-0.14596904814243317,
0.6203595995903015,
0.631525993347168,
0.051808033138513565,
0.503861665725708,
0.7322301864624023,
-0.23022998869419098,
-0.3411535918712616,
0.33635276556015015,
-0.2876611053943634,
0.24471382796764374,
0.2135879546403885,
-0.3169470429420471,
-0.22700336575508118,
-0.13464029133319855,
-0.062000274658203125,
0.08075301349163055,
-0.29556387662887573,
0.9060462713241577,
-0.11654217541217804,
-0.6314684152603149,
0.5770670771598816,
-0.10176058113574982,
0.6159931421279907,
-0.7998944520950317,
-0.22064194083213806,
-0.5669302344322205,
0.3737584352493286,
-0.3000185787677765,
-0.3836587071418762,
0.050020668655633926,
0.1564333289861679,
0.16613061726093292,
-0.3505101799964905,
0.5546373724937439,
-0.5211586356163025,
-0.2778370976448059,
0.3468906283378601,
0.21893994510173798,
0.010210953652858734,
0.21174106001853943,
-0.6088165640830994,
0.23010773956775665,
0.3902103304862976,
-0.193233922123909,
0.39029791951179504,
0.35934555530548096,
0.1938621699810028,
0.5586195588111877,
0.7296571731567383,
0.1466096192598343,
0.18678417801856995,
0.02899441495537758,
0.9394441843032837,
-0.7836208939552307,
-0.5480661988258362,
-0.3716416358947754,
0.5715591907501221,
0.02868771180510521,
-0.2657097578048706,
0.5009714365005493,
0.7659444808959961,
1.135585904121399,
-0.32068541646003723,
0.8240255117416382,
-0.08178093284368515,
0.2508052885532379,
-0.7293006181716919,
0.45327484607696533,
-0.4241560399532318,
0.4829145669937134,
-0.22830024361610413,
-0.9166100025177002,
-0.28511500358581543,
0.5608164072036743,
-0.0682111382484436,
0.16363556683063507,
0.6781299710273743,
0.8739843964576721,
-0.13515934348106384,
-0.25763076543807983,
0.26915276050567627,
-0.14737319946289062,
0.4370032846927643,
0.9244456887245178,
1.0574243068695068,
-0.34734266996383667,
0.6617630124092102,
-0.24503853917121887,
-0.14897751808166504,
-0.3390800356864929,
-0.7868725657463074,
-0.6659626364707947,
-0.3017168641090393,
-0.4230272173881531,
-0.5369309782981873,
0.16914494335651398,
0.9909451007843018,
0.5805963277816772,
-0.8383022546768188,
-0.44886893033981323,
-0.5813458561897278,
-0.04379548877477646,
-0.25912895798683167,
-0.18414662778377533,
0.06773901730775833,
-0.6679360866546631,
-0.48055943846702576,
0.5887489318847656,
0.12863393127918243,
-0.22591614723205566,
-0.5350801944732666,
-0.809169590473175,
0.17978574335575104,
-0.04740824177861214,
0.5061638951301575,
0.5514274835586548,
-0.472263365983963,
-0.2104746699333191,
-0.14383448660373688,
-0.1440255492925644,
0.08948948234319687,
1.3282548189163208,
-0.8220469355583191,
0.38273340463638306,
0.3154660761356354,
0.8316448926925659,
0.5675324201583862,
-0.0470302551984787,
0.42864131927490234,
-1.0865870714187622,
0.053421106189489365,
0.2948077917098999,
0.14498750865459442,
0.22312411665916443,
-0.35166090726852417,
0.5930331349372864,
-0.26550859212875366,
-0.5721992254257202,
-0.6207801103591919,
0.3884028494358063,
-0.6978938579559326,
-0.2566336989402771,
1.1559020280838013,
-0.23974327743053436,
-0.2110074907541275,
0.16973087191581726,
-0.25142011046409607,
0.11556392908096313,
-0.6458818316459656,
0.7340549230575562,
0.4374019503593445,
-0.2746056616306305,
-0.1905786097049713,
-0.4936705231666565,
0.6585628390312195,
0.23947913944721222,
-0.8492199778556824,
0.15808768570423126,
0.7597770690917969,
0.25374412536621094,
0.13452443480491638,
0.5980070233345032,
-0.11861886829137802,
0.43731769919395447,
0.0361030250787735,
0.48953837156295776,
-0.26179516315460205,
-0.5128495693206787,
-0.5706570744514465,
0.11628054827451706,
0.3943130671977997,
-0.19604472815990448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01383v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01383v2 | LLM-based NLG Evaluation: Current Status and Challenges | 2024-02-02T13:06:35 | 2024-02-26T14:55:48 | Mingqi Gao, Xinyu Hu, Jie Ruan, Xiao Pu, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Evaluating natural language generation (NLG) is a vital but challenging
problem in artificial intelligence. Traditional evaluation metrics mainly
capturing content (e.g. n-gram) overlap between system outputs and references
are far from satisfactory, and large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT
have demonstrated great potential in NLG evaluation in recent years. Various
automatic evaluation methods based on LLMs have been proposed, including
metrics derived from LLMs, prompting LLMs, and fine-tuning LLMs with labeled
evaluation data. In this survey, we first give a taxonomy of LLM-based NLG
evaluation methods, and discuss their pros and cons, respectively. We also
discuss human-LLM collaboration for NLG evaluation. Lastly, we discuss several
open problems in this area and point out future research directions. | [
-0.5111412405967712,
-1.034009337425232,
0.3991388976573944,
0.3501928448677063,
-0.1830001026391983,
0.3674095869064331,
-0.6494782567024231,
-0.7350068688392639,
-0.00538374250754714,
0.36708638072013855,
-0.6515000462532043,
-0.5759733319282532,
-0.7292717695236206,
0.5153606534004211,
-0.37749332189559937,
0.8677628636360168,
0.08787418156862259,
-0.0423138290643692,
-0.5530287623405457,
0.10559796541929245,
-0.49445977807044983,
-0.5965086221694946,
-1.071906566619873,
-0.6664947271347046,
0.2973446249961853,
0.2934289574623108,
0.7012158632278442,
0.3748759925365448,
0.7577536702156067,
0.3683854341506958,
-0.1939750611782074,
0.2944876253604889,
-0.39046698808670044,
0.08535683900117874,
0.2144295871257782,
-0.23217371106147766,
-0.4806194007396698,
0.17909486591815948,
0.7613028883934021,
0.8207641839981079,
-0.17366673052310944,
0.33781588077545166,
0.16620385646820068,
0.8444900512695312,
-0.3228830397129059,
0.07477930188179016,
-0.6443350315093994,
0.39916327595710754,
-0.08591053634881973,
-0.22291599214076996,
-0.1764516681432724,
-0.6743471622467041,
0.4784005880355835,
-0.24954302608966827,
0.13417945802211761,
0.29053428769111633,
0.5767198204994202,
0.41370710730552673,
-0.2567400336265564,
-0.8351914882659912,
-0.7350634932518005,
0.9943771362304688,
-1.035494089126587,
0.2777133584022522,
0.22766734659671783,
0.28224366903305054,
-0.390762060880661,
-0.7095811367034912,
-0.5099989771842957,
-0.869648814201355,
0.13056331872940063,
0.24687746167182922,
-0.3886377513408661,
0.08038822561502457,
0.002483542775735259,
0.6616536378860474,
-0.5145708918571472,
0.47717082500457764,
-0.10628778487443924,
-0.14458730816841125,
0.9542942643165588,
0.37882867455482483,
0.44214338064193726,
-0.49614065885543823,
-0.4451454281806946,
0.37139102816581726,
-0.7342089414596558,
-0.426785409450531,
0.7267594933509827,
0.1976848840713501,
0.12506529688835144,
0.6190375685691833,
-0.1273261159658432,
0.8032064437866211,
-0.11323367059230804,
0.19225497543811798,
0.12127354741096497,
-0.495266854763031,
-0.20233044028282166,
-0.061338476836681366,
1.1384721994400024,
0.5436599850654602,
0.2948818504810333,
-0.36386457085609436,
-0.2177836298942566,
0.015946241095662117,
0.22735396027565002,
-0.4397454857826233,
0.08646956831216812,
0.06864620745182037,
-0.39247092604637146,
-0.41622671484947205,
-0.05410232022404671,
-0.9580702781677246,
-0.5036233067512512,
-0.3102492392063141,
0.36852505803108215,
-0.25553813576698303,
-0.18755441904067993,
0.10255405306816101,
-0.016950620338320732,
0.4680364727973938,
0.3350715637207031,
-0.8775331974029541,
0.3441613018512726,
0.7311680912971497,
0.7143339514732361,
-0.5176522731781006,
-0.12409894913434982,
-0.34720781445503235,
-0.3441091477870941,
-0.1374289095401764,
0.9170016646385193,
-0.22130076587200165,
-0.38746440410614014,
0.12882843613624573,
-0.294060617685318,
-0.054964419454336166,
-0.807385265827179,
0.6382083296775818,
-0.2610831558704376,
0.49334463477134705,
-0.023605041205883026,
-0.7824732661247253,
0.0218599084764719,
0.4988633096218109,
-0.5618422031402588,
1.2018545866012573,
0.09945053607225418,
-0.6987611651420593,
0.27662011981010437,
-0.795754075050354,
-0.39377573132514954,
0.3922112286090851,
0.007132220081984997,
-0.3725402057170868,
0.062188152223825455,
0.1755782812833786,
0.2688315808773041,
-0.6818497776985168,
0.4621511697769165,
0.060129065066576004,
-0.37329453229904175,
0.1605178266763687,
-0.7779116034507751,
0.6702945828437805,
0.24165289103984833,
-0.20496167242527008,
0.3114132285118103,
-0.835394561290741,
0.15606461465358734,
0.10188230872154236,
-0.6563433408737183,
0.21001741290092468,
0.24650798738002777,
-0.16183845698833466,
-0.1276783049106598,
0.445053368806839,
-0.38234010338783264,
0.21803689002990723,
-0.4192098081111908,
0.46376296877861023,
0.6055354475975037,
0.14147983491420746,
0.34123578667640686,
-0.41162025928497314,
0.808284342288971,
-0.6546984910964966,
0.12538693845272064,
0.23278209567070007,
-0.7098568677902222,
-0.9716740846633911,
0.1786516010761261,
0.49074605107307434,
0.6937318444252014,
-0.6489301323890686,
0.8460446000099182,
-0.10867740958929062,
-0.5879291296005249,
-0.5708381533622742,
0.35352185368537903,
0.22872307896614075,
0.279588907957077,
0.049399178475141525,
-0.44049766659736633,
-0.6589602828025818,
-0.8751600384712219,
-0.33859506249427795,
-0.40252453088760376,
-0.2374304234981537,
0.2944367825984955,
0.13491976261138916,
-0.30159708857536316,
0.9281891584396362,
-0.2084825038909912,
-0.13222649693489075,
-0.5690321326255798,
0.44793593883514404,
0.19209304451942444,
0.17918430268764496,
0.21762171387672424,
-0.31130626797676086,
-0.2941850423812866,
-0.07565118372440338,
-0.7719278931617737,
-0.550279974937439,
-0.08172591030597687,
0.060874976217746735,
0.223673477768898,
0.574332594871521,
-0.518348753452301,
0.12590256333351135,
0.7124527096748352,
-0.01905803196132183,
0.8091462850570679,
-0.12576521933078766,
0.03234168514609337,
-0.7033612132072449,
-0.18709157407283783,
0.02406471222639084,
-0.13823699951171875,
-0.7099305987358093,
0.047374144196510315,
-0.4483127295970917,
0.007111110258847475,
-0.6235705018043518,
0.6979160308837891,
-0.487368106842041,
-0.20269611477851868,
-0.33616989850997925,
0.6385984420776367,
-0.32011258602142334,
0.24403034150600433,
-0.1858198344707489,
0.5661196112632751,
0.3905409872531891,
-0.5674825310707092,
0.934658408164978,
0.08719786256551743,
-0.4652451276779175,
0.3035854697227478,
-0.5793812870979309,
0.43686166405677795,
0.03825190290808678,
0.14774827659130096,
-0.6828835010528564,
-0.10505911707878113,
0.3770119249820709,
-0.43823158740997314,
0.19272468984127045,
0.010310807265341282,
-0.8320637941360474,
-0.4668945372104645,
-0.3937107026576996,
0.1536702960729599,
0.6678640842437744,
-0.5179699659347534,
0.15674906969070435,
0.2847476303577423,
-0.18309547007083893,
-0.3808095157146454,
-0.4251384437084198,
0.565454363822937,
-0.3926609456539154,
-0.8212572932243347,
0.18536709249019623,
-0.19821161031723022,
-0.42657843232154846,
-0.07511508464813232,
0.03661487251520157,
0.370363712310791,
0.13034319877624512,
-0.01140406634658575,
0.0020659728907048702,
-0.14883017539978027,
0.07155204564332962,
-0.3549156188964844,
-0.1613854020833969,
0.17827650904655457,
-0.14885865151882172,
0.61812824010849,
-0.5867561101913452,
-0.5230128169059753,
-0.06450711935758591,
0.11775097250938416,
-0.014506726525723934,
-0.1796053797006607,
0.22028374671936035,
0.8480656743049622,
-0.37304067611694336,
-0.30845028162002563,
-0.4702121317386627,
0.16488416492938995,
-0.4507492780685425,
0.44395172595977783,
0.3947073221206665,
-1.074303150177002,
0.27142855525016785,
-0.3652324676513672,
0.014197121374309063,
0.4353005588054657,
0.9005817770957947,
-0.07117057591676712,
0.7778637409210205,
0.5596462488174438,
0.09020654112100601,
0.2870837450027466,
-0.04289553314447403,
0.3918137550354004,
-0.8300801515579224,
-0.09210950136184692,
-0.2894144356250763,
-0.31232741475105286,
-0.8124253153800964,
-0.24979537725448608,
0.2696665823459625,
0.3504910469055176,
0.23196320235729218,
0.17719393968582153,
-0.46335962414741516,
0.3722022473812103,
0.47593235969543457,
-0.2657778859138489,
0.5825114250183105,
-0.2940203845500946,
0.0530494786798954,
0.1636561006307602,
-0.8636807203292847,
-0.9668660759925842,
0.9621609449386597,
0.4253540337085724,
0.6003159284591675,
0.05172096937894821,
0.7315221428871155,
0.540931761264801,
0.5469271540641785,
-1.0763168334960938,
0.810958206653595,
-0.0915394276380539,
-0.39451518654823303,
-0.4585603177547455,
-0.5943553447723389,
-1.1044448614120483,
0.05606266111135483,
-0.30732041597366333,
-0.8011965155601501,
-0.5918678045272827,
-0.020375313237309456,
-0.27542561292648315,
0.22217434644699097,
-0.7677817344665527,
0.6291378736495972,
-0.5793039798736572,
-0.04906564950942993,
0.05552900582551956,
-0.5031328201293945,
0.5684747695922852,
-0.04546230286359787,
0.2020740509033203,
-0.37277495861053467,
0.2216120809316635,
0.8447476029396057,
-0.21200771629810333,
0.63373863697052,
0.08232850581407547,
-0.3898423910140991,
0.6169226169586182,
-0.17408478260040283,
0.11952796578407288,
0.05744042992591858,
-0.18051844835281372,
0.2461041510105133,
-0.2388358861207962,
-0.02714480645954609,
-0.622103750705719,
0.6839711666107178,
-0.5159108638763428,
-0.7700936198234558,
-0.37821164727211,
-0.5739350914955139,
-0.38718873262405396,
-0.01699933409690857,
0.38375324010849,
0.11520019918680191,
-0.4416579008102417,
0.10093538463115692,
0.12913267314434052,
-0.7068615555763245,
0.6468796730041504,
0.09159456938505173,
-0.5455683469772339,
-0.48864564299583435,
1.043995976448059,
-0.19361476600170135,
0.3524303436279297,
0.04099791496992111,
0.3910345733165741,
-0.309246301651001,
-0.7776976823806763,
-0.5363976955413818,
-0.0436101071536541,
-0.5115703344345093,
-0.24635857343673706,
-0.28735122084617615,
-0.5861015915870667,
-0.020224105566740036,
0.008543277159333229,
-0.2525143623352051,
-0.3838275372982025,
-0.31416335701942444,
0.009734014980494976,
0.262314110994339,
1.09812593460083,
-0.06643780320882797,
0.38626086711883545,
-0.7867357134819031,
0.31789085268974304,
0.3073843717575073,
0.6507138609886169,
0.036988142877817154,
-0.22630931437015533,
-0.20184066891670227,
-0.0921361893415451,
-0.46784111857414246,
-0.6773406267166138,
0.35571998357772827,
0.17474672198295593,
0.5695749521255493,
0.14959269762039185,
-0.15218377113342285,
0.41157543659210205,
-0.6024953722953796,
1.0082528591156006,
0.15777133405208588,
-0.9088939428329468,
0.42119306325912476,
-0.25409966707229614,
0.29331710934638977,
0.3420252203941345,
0.005589935462921858,
-0.7840027809143066,
-0.5239740014076233,
-0.44021955132484436,
-0.9759067893028259,
0.4054460823535919,
0.47637540102005005,
0.1976780742406845,
-0.2600206434726715,
0.18589496612548828,
0.16854944825172424,
0.048249006271362305,
-0.6984133124351501,
-0.11972611397504807,
0.11207151412963867,
-0.05992140620946884,
0.10884647071361542,
-0.016208190470933914,
0.09609624743461609,
-0.06919115036725998,
0.44447365403175354,
0.01183009147644043,
0.30367758870124817,
0.05902542546391487,
-0.18181198835372925,
-0.17026054859161377,
0.5690810084342957,
0.49197113513946533,
0.6196187138557434,
-0.30369797348976135,
-0.03853994235396385,
0.4795941710472107,
-0.22930917143821716,
0.14475899934768677,
-0.0844934806227684,
-0.04454401880502701,
-0.04164509102702141,
0.6491840481758118,
0.726073145866394,
0.0810103714466095,
-0.8078127503395081,
0.3813419044017792,
-0.18386714160442352,
-0.44210192561149597,
-0.43062281608581543,
0.14242710173130035,
0.1460200697183609,
0.12470728904008865,
0.4286259114742279,
-0.18717969954013824,
-0.05950256437063217,
-0.46124014258384705,
0.1533922553062439,
0.6655442118644714,
-0.32692503929138184,
-0.1457924246788025,
0.41210293769836426,
0.277023583650589,
-0.7437136173248291,
0.6574284434318542,
-0.44809311628341675,
-0.5904039740562439,
0.7208123207092285,
0.5620921850204468,
1.087417483329773,
-0.006459697149693966,
0.0404537096619606,
0.17387045919895172,
0.4620957672595978,
0.1893312931060791,
0.19443099200725555,
0.2069215327501297,
-0.7513100504875183,
-0.6426612138748169,
-0.9064903855323792,
-0.7715202569961548,
0.2909972369670868,
-0.3645210564136505,
0.36148154735565186,
-0.49438002705574036,
-0.34285813570022583,
-0.3424737751483917,
0.2614777386188507,
-0.7131472826004028,
0.10914471745491028,
0.5349085330963135,
0.7220617532730103,
-0.3713015615940094,
0.3847545087337494,
0.5699692368507385,
-0.03056567721068859,
-0.23760133981704712,
-0.05556816980242729,
-0.012299800291657448,
-0.6770700812339783,
0.4894578158855438,
0.158808171749115,
-0.2597595751285553,
0.07714580744504929,
-0.5135095119476318,
-0.6708813309669495,
1.051785945892334,
0.3002464771270752,
-0.46200087666511536,
-0.1080421432852745,
0.3108271360397339,
0.8546274900436401,
-0.3103713393211365,
0.2754841148853302,
0.725297212600708,
0.7351361513137817,
-0.111798495054245,
-1.0346412658691406,
-0.25757309794425964,
-0.2089919000864029,
0.0804804190993309,
0.14665010571479797,
-0.6159291863441467,
0.29226234555244446,
-0.08628591895103455,
-0.5189993977546692,
0.21940581500530243,
0.6541042327880859,
0.3654997646808624,
0.24908211827278137,
0.5559282302856445,
0.5132157206535339,
0.5627412796020508,
-0.11515433341264725,
0.9704539775848389,
-0.16497288644313812,
0.37344661355018616,
0.9308913350105286,
-0.33512017130851746,
0.5896167755126953,
0.3837983310222626,
-0.45200517773628235,
0.18218155205249786,
0.5874344110488892,
-0.3342092037200928,
-0.013029996305704117,
0.915012776851654,
-0.34426644444465637,
-0.04808425530791283,
-0.1268777847290039,
-0.15815351903438568,
0.6878992915153503,
0.2551206946372986,
-0.08985115587711334,
-0.4274516999721527,
-0.27232134342193604,
-0.18130278587341309,
0.05702397972345352,
-0.1980099081993103,
0.8740416765213013,
0.18098872900009155,
-0.6357585191726685,
0.4819982647895813,
0.19549675285816193,
0.9981131553649902,
-0.4542182981967926,
-0.10671791434288025,
-0.09675662964582443,
-0.2848634421825409,
-0.3431006371974945,
-0.7535637021064758,
0.4913146197795868,
0.4060070812702179,
0.26908189058303833,
-0.23880250751972198,
0.8346706032752991,
-0.33733657002449036,
-0.5122457146644592,
0.49351996183395386,
0.8454796671867371,
0.26695358753204346,
0.16854281723499298,
-0.5019448399543762,
0.03378676995635033,
-0.09807296097278595,
-0.3091139495372772,
0.24057318270206451,
0.36221176385879517,
0.03929635509848595,
0.7808619141578674,
0.728882908821106,
0.2104090303182602,
0.3742550313472748,
0.3283691704273224,
0.5054658055305481,
-0.8178548812866211,
0.038188718259334564,
-1.0604318380355835,
0.15148359537124634,
0.18448318541049957,
-0.2441432923078537,
0.7909929156303406,
0.33897918462753296,
0.6442936658859253,
0.1367824822664261,
0.9883489012718201,
-0.12278004735708237,
0.31445902585983276,
-0.7171763777732849,
0.8113734722137451,
-0.19081458449363708,
0.4268898367881775,
-0.31036826968193054,
-1.1686292886734009,
-0.45989808440208435,
0.3369094133377075,
-0.20170427858829498,
0.07090968638658524,
0.5456185936927795,
0.41839349269866943,
0.2698958218097687,
0.1809322088956833,
0.3561684191226959,
-0.14713288843631744,
0.4347267150878906,
0.543810248374939,
1.4756144285202026,
-0.21711033582687378,
0.6206982731819153,
0.016626067459583282,
-0.20380829274654388,
-0.016146501526236534,
-1.3921855688095093,
-0.7341019511222839,
-0.30154356360435486,
-0.34574782848358154,
0.1551293432712555,
-0.09028156846761703,
0.9905813336372375,
0.31642431020736694,
-0.5613517761230469,
-0.46062320470809937,
-0.1277226060628891,
0.24563142657279968,
0.09612751752138138,
-0.28787466883659363,
0.19011978805065155,
-0.4470251202583313,
-0.8283739686012268,
0.5449138879776001,
0.38449224829673767,
-0.09254787117242813,
-0.47051802277565,
-0.2278522551059723,
-0.1845254898071289,
0.02390994504094124,
0.8374075889587402,
0.12106789648532867,
-0.8886532187461853,
-0.45485416054725647,
-0.13339197635650635,
0.12166932225227356,
0.18418753147125244,
0.6114623546600342,
-0.6350569725036621,
0.2744685411453247,
0.33691930770874023,
0.8415912985801697,
0.20441365242004395,
0.13625916838645935,
0.7686414122581482,
-0.7948480248451233,
-0.2992844879627228,
0.45716196298599243,
0.19158314168453217,
0.617271363735199,
-0.1672837883234024,
0.5930129289627075,
0.013283955864608288,
-0.8285225033760071,
-0.6516486406326294,
0.4029444754123688,
-0.8424818515777588,
0.19319821894168854,
1.3465358018875122,
0.11599046736955643,
0.025037847459316254,
-0.012259223498404026,
-0.18945322930812836,
0.3616161346435547,
-0.10986551642417908,
0.6944767832756042,
1.0424556732177734,
-0.5972395539283752,
-0.2254895120859146,
-0.7659123539924622,
0.5584731698036194,
0.40405774116516113,
-1.1972880363464355,
0.01649324595928192,
0.39743974804878235,
0.003922237548977137,
0.15505072474479675,
0.4581065773963928,
-0.19038385152816772,
-0.06847353279590607,
-0.23035281896591187,
0.20630258321762085,
0.10936648398637772,
-0.04737752676010132,
-0.5292601585388184,
-0.11254172027111053,
0.36883270740509033,
0.04610669985413551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01376v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01376v2 | LoTR: Low Tensor Rank Weight Adaptation | 2024-02-02T13:00:38 | 2024-02-05T12:42:52 | Daniel Bershatsky, Daria Cherniuk, Talgat Daulbaev, Aleksandr Mikhalev, Ivan Oseledets | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper we generalize and extend an idea of low-rank adaptation (LoRA)
of large language models (LLMs) based on Transformer architecture. Widely used
LoRA-like methods of fine-tuning LLMs are based on matrix factorization of
gradient update. We introduce LoTR, a novel approach for parameter-efficient
fine-tuning of LLMs which represents a gradient update to parameters in a form
of tensor decomposition. Low-rank adapter for each layer is constructed as a
product of three matrices, and tensor structure arises from sharing left and
right multipliers of this product among layers. Simultaneous compression of a
sequence of layers with low-rank tensor representation allows LoTR to archive
even better parameter efficiency then LoRA especially for deep models.
Moreover, the core tensor does not depend on original weight dimension and can
be made arbitrary small, which allows for extremely cheap and fast downstream
fine-tuning. | [
-0.3123629689216614,
-0.7374826073646545,
0.08689866960048676,
0.1425935924053192,
-0.26763859391212463,
0.13360680639743805,
-0.20508825778961182,
-0.11615700274705887,
0.08703061938285828,
0.617888331413269,
-0.12676027417182922,
-0.22683757543563843,
-0.7358185052871704,
-0.1728580892086029,
-0.2302316278219223,
1.0794864892959595,
-0.08154242485761642,
0.2892908453941345,
0.34508293867111206,
-0.26234233379364014,
-0.2778967320919037,
-0.3824615180492401,
-1.0374884605407715,
-0.5561702847480774,
0.8718107342720032,
0.48725223541259766,
0.7450929284095764,
0.5532214641571045,
0.8793762922286987,
0.35587143898010254,
-0.2094084918498993,
0.02250281348824501,
-0.8941354751586914,
0.08280374854803085,
-0.10160662233829498,
-0.7559597492218018,
-0.8369038105010986,
-0.40141168236732483,
0.8329039812088013,
0.8179689049720764,
-0.16381946206092834,
0.31755539774894714,
0.21828147768974304,
1.0211540460586548,
-0.6623067855834961,
-0.2587685286998749,
-0.537789523601532,
-0.000259972846833989,
0.12918926775455475,
-0.502092182636261,
-0.34846386313438416,
-0.10625407099723816,
-0.3445582389831543,
-0.49064964056015015,
0.3896584212779999,
0.15089298784732819,
0.5048171877861023,
0.7002869248390198,
-0.15509682893753052,
-0.01435129251331091,
-1.0519170761108398,
0.8047633171081543,
-0.44347402453422546,
0.45711806416511536,
0.16938132047653198,
0.5085641741752625,
-0.28287097811698914,
-0.39171120524406433,
-0.47117236256599426,
0.09472688287496567,
0.03261702135205269,
-0.020634105429053307,
-0.41298097372055054,
0.06481054425239563,
0.15645235776901245,
0.6993499994277954,
-0.1279292106628418,
0.3831871747970581,
-0.49424758553504944,
0.06826886534690857,
0.4431534707546234,
0.0796271562576294,
0.09515184909105301,
-0.10272641479969025,
-0.3658369481563568,
-0.3246847987174988,
-0.9257787466049194,
-0.07884000986814499,
0.29350733757019043,
0.2645488977432251,
-0.3502025604248047,
0.5446016192436218,
-0.21504580974578857,
0.8244443535804749,
0.47082653641700745,
-0.27692779898643494,
-0.10488802939653397,
0.11276370286941528,
-0.3278888463973999,
0.11389236152172089,
0.5742185711860657,
0.040220215916633606,
-0.1340743750333786,
-0.3115669786930084,
-0.4022592306137085,
0.05078171566128731,
-0.12215094268321991,
-1.0746160745620728,
-0.03000910021364689,
-0.046846840530633926,
-0.6582416892051697,
-0.2588285803794861,
-0.1424626111984253,
-0.7799474596977234,
-0.6044780611991882,
-0.3447073996067047,
0.895808756351471,
-0.11384998261928558,
0.06607168912887573,
0.4247620701789856,
0.06343197822570801,
0.826984167098999,
0.4497925341129303,
-0.8506552577018738,
0.6134679317474365,
0.7237919569015503,
0.7707421779632568,
-0.30032041668891907,
-0.26359665393829346,
-1.0439448356628418,
0.12554605305194855,
-0.3111214339733124,
0.7891478538513184,
-0.3189583718776703,
-0.2586081027984619,
-0.2716027498245239,
0.0505717433989048,
0.062267910689115524,
-0.6805302500724792,
0.6222049593925476,
-0.8252738118171692,
0.18558740615844727,
-0.0021686155814677477,
-0.2010488659143448,
0.03978147357702255,
-0.04569225758314133,
-0.7813077569007874,
1.0673643350601196,
0.4915710389614105,
-0.534035325050354,
0.31465545296669006,
-1.0566259622573853,
-0.519557535648346,
-0.09186883270740509,
0.2362736016511917,
-0.4400733411312103,
0.4542880356311798,
0.2870539128780365,
0.5666964054107666,
-0.6325151920318604,
-0.05052079260349274,
-0.1572064608335495,
-0.6050499677658081,
0.31501662731170654,
-0.27965247631073,
0.4966875910758972,
0.2656845152378082,
0.008955877274274826,
0.01611972413957119,
-0.9036101698875427,
-0.38374027609825134,
-0.01820172555744648,
-0.7275333404541016,
-0.2967771589756012,
-0.019265606999397278,
0.04198237508535385,
0.17971228063106537,
0.20552757382392883,
-0.35013172030448914,
0.3689507842063904,
-0.2964119613170624,
0.524060070514679,
0.7293033003807068,
-0.006272403988987207,
0.7659258842468262,
-0.4184667468070984,
0.5980510711669922,
0.35914209485054016,
0.08992782235145569,
0.24513907730579376,
-0.07283470034599304,
-1.4759798049926758,
-0.4944860637187958,
0.5810944437980652,
0.2736892104148865,
-0.8802758455276489,
0.4310445487499237,
-0.8002879619598389,
-0.581560492515564,
-0.8273743987083435,
0.375887393951416,
0.11996987462043762,
0.18255272507667542,
0.3579905927181244,
-0.09675094485282898,
-0.5135937333106995,
-0.7990712523460388,
-0.07967722415924072,
0.05280284211039543,
-0.13370320200920105,
0.00711048673838377,
0.4712018668651581,
-0.05425408110022545,
0.763954758644104,
-0.6429005265235901,
-0.49360066652297974,
-0.4186418056488037,
0.03514527529478073,
0.5393964052200317,
0.6258373260498047,
0.5046178102493286,
-0.5379356741905212,
-0.3299178183078766,
0.24022836983203888,
-0.521718442440033,
0.1914440393447876,
0.20739568769931793,
-0.2788888216018677,
-0.05941007658839226,
0.6148191094398499,
-0.42495250701904297,
0.07030810415744781,
0.9648042917251587,
-0.34863510727882385,
-0.29911988973617554,
-0.37775275111198425,
-0.06624532490968704,
-1.388108730316162,
0.019627731293439865,
-0.05707045644521713,
-0.27564680576324463,
-0.7790506482124329,
0.17115554213523865,
-0.3021868169307709,
-0.3098606765270233,
-0.3732943832874298,
0.6623119711875916,
-0.4520408511161804,
-0.2214057594537735,
-0.41617444157600403,
-0.0052987802773714066,
0.020251912996172905,
0.5957229733467102,
-0.4544494152069092,
0.8223422169685364,
0.6201072931289673,
-0.6775410175323486,
0.165952667593956,
0.25599977374076843,
-0.38348373770713806,
0.6784067153930664,
-0.7639542818069458,
0.3851698338985443,
-0.445822536945343,
0.28670167922973633,
-0.746505081653595,
-0.017359403893351555,
0.21478942036628723,
-0.01908867061138153,
0.2659919857978821,
-0.5960955619812012,
-0.36814063787460327,
-0.07933651655912399,
-0.4500335156917572,
0.3914097249507904,
0.6627596616744995,
-0.696088969707489,
1.0444374084472656,
0.3301660716533661,
-0.15958184003829956,
-0.44990360736846924,
-0.7674280405044556,
-0.0816517099738121,
-0.44925010204315186,
-0.4283711016178131,
0.4913664162158966,
-0.3477499485015869,
-0.18157875537872314,
-0.18362127244472504,
0.08576425164937973,
0.07782477140426636,
0.12789198756217957,
0.20896819233894348,
0.2184283286333084,
-0.8187583088874817,
-0.16462770104408264,
0.067205511033535,
-0.250133216381073,
-0.4602566361427307,
-0.007844576612114906,
0.6674955487251282,
-0.10011515766382217,
-0.2115134447813034,
-0.14337711036205292,
0.08115825802087784,
0.594512939453125,
0.11040271073579788,
0.7321459650993347,
0.8564788103103638,
-0.25946441292762756,
-0.39555397629737854,
-0.5842840671539307,
-0.12351392954587936,
-0.5267549753189087,
0.38431310653686523,
-0.6466766595840454,
-1.0339486598968506,
0.7242507338523865,
-0.14150814712047577,
-0.38300633430480957,
0.5352084636688232,
0.7089938521385193,
0.06096574664115906,
0.6959105730056763,
0.8921051621437073,
-0.42788606882095337,
0.601247251033783,
-0.34146878123283386,
0.3019252419471741,
-1.0772207975387573,
0.3169870376586914,
-0.6258545517921448,
-0.9875168204307556,
-0.8556196093559265,
-0.8047091960906982,
0.3455977141857147,
0.5373429656028748,
-0.43895223736763,
0.22290562093257904,
-0.3937522768974304,
0.6056737303733826,
0.3802575469017029,
0.06853464245796204,
0.5936503410339355,
0.13036908209323883,
0.5597747564315796,
0.32093945145606995,
-0.7413076758384705,
-0.16646412014961243,
0.8530981540679932,
0.3469051718711853,
1.1723538637161255,
0.5543880462646484,
0.642061710357666,
0.4065089821815491,
0.41735151410102844,
-1.1178251504898071,
0.5164862871170044,
-0.6065419316291809,
-0.3550936281681061,
-0.42127642035484314,
-0.30904173851013184,
-0.9933713674545288,
0.41265732049942017,
-0.2015448957681656,
-0.5547879338264465,
0.552496075630188,
0.02021106891334057,
-0.44699421525001526,
0.3127879500389099,
-0.6909885406494141,
0.36889010667800903,
0.04668576642870903,
-0.2428121566772461,
-0.2116309404373169,
-0.22290034592151642,
0.11739636212587357,
-0.18996287882328033,
0.007981518283486366,
-0.014075429178774357,
-0.13810209929943085,
1.0930910110473633,
-0.18124665319919586,
0.76591557264328,
-0.3722490668296814,
-0.23420697450637817,
0.02469230256974697,
0.13637278974056244,
0.8061515092849731,
-0.13614264130592346,
-0.3907308578491211,
0.0654563382267952,
-0.282670795917511,
-0.5147591829299927,
-0.8208096027374268,
0.7550744414329529,
-1.2553528547286987,
-0.593890905380249,
-0.00021746009588241577,
-0.4971171021461487,
-0.3369081914424896,
0.06130822375416756,
-0.002766622230410576,
0.33795449137687683,
-0.22984690964221954,
0.42033398151397705,
0.622522234916687,
-0.16676753759384155,
0.5415118336677551,
0.6396848559379578,
-0.304364413022995,
-0.5537334084510803,
1.0789741277694702,
-0.07646054029464722,
0.13723737001419067,
0.8511382937431335,
0.35303986072540283,
0.2320210188627243,
-0.7830990552902222,
-0.39600425958633423,
0.3182782828807831,
-0.8909462690353394,
-0.50296950340271,
-0.2513631582260132,
-0.4392451047897339,
0.1232638955116272,
-0.2582428753376007,
-0.41592228412628174,
-0.41430777311325073,
-0.3215654790401459,
0.17801080644130707,
0.6326330304145813,
0.8459627032279968,
0.16344159841537476,
0.8745480179786682,
-0.3521885871887207,
0.6615122556686401,
0.41700509190559387,
0.6034128069877625,
-0.0759902149438858,
-1.0016748905181885,
-0.3599421977996826,
-0.29842624068260193,
-0.13753579556941986,
-0.03989019989967346,
0.08683054894208908,
0.39323291182518005,
0.21530169248580933,
0.27922654151916504,
-0.11504554003477097,
0.704850435256958,
-0.41737091541290283,
0.49579185247421265,
0.20836910605430603,
-0.9312217235565186,
0.1549203246831894,
-0.3509301543235779,
0.19290417432785034,
0.4121885299682617,
-0.05361328646540642,
-0.3724991977214813,
0.09061826020479202,
-0.19613352417945862,
-0.5448408722877502,
0.7053797841072083,
-0.09868977218866348,
0.40643835067749023,
0.5756435990333557,
0.3346311151981354,
0.1919335573911667,
-0.13127894699573517,
-0.6427117586135864,
-0.2799410820007324,
-0.11920390278100967,
-0.2175620049238205,
-0.26036176085472107,
-0.3334687352180481,
-0.245346337556839,
-0.4220779836177826,
0.6363459825515747,
-0.5125331282615662,
0.5253865122795105,
-0.01828898675739765,
-0.4513626992702484,
-0.35971593856811523,
0.5409128665924072,
0.6639472246170044,
0.5431687235832214,
-0.15124155580997467,
0.1959788054227829,
0.49339553713798523,
-0.43735843896865845,
0.19338031113147736,
0.10567323118448257,
-0.07802282273769379,
-0.358120322227478,
0.2197958081960678,
1.2814236879348755,
0.5874766707420349,
0.006647298112511635,
0.5215590000152588,
0.09033440798521042,
-0.17177894711494446,
0.08848921954631805,
0.226268008351326,
0.0836351066827774,
0.32332611083984375,
0.649064302444458,
0.17529116570949554,
-0.2061799019575119,
-0.22947685420513153,
-0.18467620015144348,
0.25094708800315857,
-0.5733776092529297,
-0.5055541396141052,
0.4562806487083435,
0.18201641738414764,
-0.3703402876853943,
0.004264644347131252,
0.05750394985079765,
-0.0404328852891922,
0.09699448198080063,
0.6643252372741699,
0.6921606063842773,
-0.32986879348754883,
0.16608461737632751,
0.014732317067682743,
0.07554295659065247,
-0.09012763202190399,
0.24535095691680908,
0.3382730484008789,
-0.930473268032074,
-0.777540385723114,
-1.060181975364685,
-0.2643637955188751,
0.3502277135848999,
-0.43526196479797363,
0.574088990688324,
-0.6308746933937073,
0.04526490345597267,
0.2182312160730362,
-0.13668334484100342,
-0.7460704445838928,
-0.015263623557984829,
0.032761070877313614,
0.7144763469696045,
-0.6576212644577026,
0.9806695580482483,
0.5744005441665649,
-0.3634982407093048,
-0.5842747688293457,
-0.08991583436727524,
-0.5492566823959351,
-1.1426488161087036,
0.8777281045913696,
-0.5598452091217041,
-0.4080524146556854,
0.4193950891494751,
-0.3482222855091095,
-1.0768167972564697,
1.2541661262512207,
0.7593706250190735,
-0.34814366698265076,
-0.18383245170116425,
0.426969051361084,
0.6793015599250793,
-0.34071585536003113,
-0.04534522816538811,
0.37510058283805847,
0.4260214865207672,
0.04508073627948761,
-0.522132158279419,
0.017412034794688225,
-0.0243252944201231,
0.3013644218444824,
0.33065491914749146,
-0.925093948841095,
0.9415925145149231,
0.052165437489748,
0.1672275960445404,
0.12890271842479706,
0.7184349894523621,
-0.07822299003601074,
-0.3025141954421997,
0.5136454105377197,
0.37293609976768494,
0.5351502299308777,
0.035657912492752075,
0.867436408996582,
-0.5114763379096985,
0.44108280539512634,
0.796159029006958,
-0.20428958535194397,
1.1913855075836182,
0.7861115336418152,
-0.3949330151081085,
0.6209220886230469,
0.07217000424861908,
-0.1290455311536789,
0.38470324873924255,
0.3361407220363617,
0.017272843047976494,
-0.06215159222483635,
-0.13061800599098206,
-0.2676253914833069,
0.7315995693206787,
0.10424917936325073,
-0.25049200654029846,
-0.11527609825134277,
0.043797414749860764,
-0.08928809314966202,
-0.43412065505981445,
-0.6730457544326782,
0.8310674428939819,
0.2200930118560791,
-0.4617059528827667,
0.900538980960846,
0.12735354900360107,
0.8709073662757874,
-0.4372568130493164,
0.1127038523554802,
-0.38963133096694946,
0.4819191098213196,
-0.18466491997241974,
-0.3569238781929016,
-0.1625017523765564,
-0.12425699830055237,
-0.4684922695159912,
-0.0907348021864891,
0.9153207540512085,
-0.26072755455970764,
-0.8584647178649902,
0.295322448015213,
0.7938002943992615,
-0.1889801025390625,
0.10755473375320435,
-0.4539504945278168,
0.14086240530014038,
-0.3878462612628937,
-0.5289682149887085,
0.6055680513381958,
0.33653557300567627,
0.058104634284973145,
0.6625078320503235,
0.7277194261550903,
0.26754897832870483,
-0.003455051453784108,
0.3601006865501404,
0.9532012939453125,
-0.8350849151611328,
-0.33404678106307983,
-0.6964229345321655,
0.345356822013855,
0.26386526226997375,
-0.13924671709537506,
0.18879260122776031,
0.4868569076061249,
0.327138215303421,
-0.22068531811237335,
0.5281014442443848,
0.07322905957698822,
0.33260831236839294,
-0.7277531027793884,
0.8554205298423767,
-0.49674391746520996,
0.2989899218082428,
-0.19797326624393463,
-1.2705315351486206,
-0.378225713968277,
0.32127711176872253,
-0.3010280728340149,
0.07606754451990128,
0.6834244132041931,
0.9473968744277954,
-0.4822053611278534,
-0.3416166603565216,
0.5622562766075134,
0.41247329115867615,
0.02085075154900551,
0.339323490858078,
0.812969446182251,
-0.9592862129211426,
0.5051377415657043,
0.0195225328207016,
-0.04786275327205658,
-0.46085798740386963,
-0.8752074241638184,
-0.8239838480949402,
-0.49541863799095154,
-0.34046608209609985,
-0.1999887377023697,
0.011378931812942028,
0.757325291633606,
0.7455992102622986,
-0.9235422015190125,
-0.33008697628974915,
0.15588067471981049,
0.08317863196134567,
-0.12084080278873444,
-0.20064033567905426,
0.6033727526664734,
0.017600039020180702,
-0.655965268611908,
0.4945235550403595,
0.21048924326896667,
-0.06809110939502716,
-0.4651390016078949,
-0.4412219822406769,
0.13251915574073792,
-0.002283942885696888,
0.8168022036552429,
0.01716878078877926,
-0.556456446647644,
-0.43458428978919983,
-0.1368093639612198,
-0.10577146708965302,
0.5556581020355225,
0.898294985294342,
-0.6701112985610962,
-0.12859323620796204,
0.49027639627456665,
0.8594077229499817,
0.6763010621070862,
-0.18607674539089203,
0.42124509811401367,
-0.6773141622543335,
0.1994549036026001,
-0.09660469740629196,
0.5048292279243469,
0.6653155088424683,
-0.16824641823768616,
0.5347565412521362,
-0.10509512573480606,
-0.3657631576061249,
-0.796305239200592,
0.000647968496195972,
-1.4583591222763062,
0.06195256486535072,
1.29118812084198,
0.30881720781326294,
-0.3940877914428711,
0.1169387549161911,
-0.2633991837501526,
0.23375722765922546,
-0.28573429584503174,
0.7309045791625977,
0.4558477997779846,
0.11386459320783615,
-0.30149418115615845,
-0.3723529875278473,
0.39715129137039185,
0.25708121061325073,
-0.7768341898918152,
0.09910254180431366,
-0.1134200170636177,
0.32289329171180725,
0.17544029653072357,
0.37177279591560364,
0.08424536883831024,
-0.07357585430145264,
-0.27791115641593933,
-0.01296242605894804,
0.21101227402687073,
0.09009986370801926,
-0.669578492641449,
0.1379087120294571,
0.595504105091095,
-0.00954565778374672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01375v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01375v1 | Dive into the Chasm: Probing the Gap between In- and Cross-Topic Generalization | 2024-02-02T12:59:27 | 2024-02-02T12:59:27 | Andreas Waldis, Yufang Hou, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained language models (LMs) perform well in In-Topic setups, where
training and testing data come from the same topics. However, they face
challenges in Cross-Topic scenarios where testing data is derived from distinct
topics -- such as Gun Control. This study analyzes various LMs with three
probing-based experiments to shed light on the reasons behind the In- vs.
Cross-Topic generalization gap. Thereby, we demonstrate, for the first time,
that generalization gaps and the robustness of the embedding space vary
significantly across LMs. Additionally, we assess larger LMs and underscore the
relevance of our analysis for recent models. Overall, diverse pre-training
objectives, architectural regularization, or data deduplication contribute to
more robust LMs and diminish generalization gaps. Our research contributes to a
deeper understanding and comparison of language models across different
generalization scenarios. | [
-0.6137465834617615,
-0.9884371161460876,
0.7009755969047546,
-0.3656086325645447,
-0.14385473728179932,
0.11034899204969406,
0.08995281904935837,
-0.21389703452587128,
-0.34371012449264526,
0.3533741235733032,
-0.4593713581562042,
-0.4972608685493469,
-0.9034132957458496,
-0.26549363136291504,
-0.4893835783004761,
0.913627028465271,
-0.09501530230045319,
-0.01911003701388836,
-0.15224966406822205,
-0.09250041842460632,
-0.3784077763557434,
-0.612652599811554,
-0.25514310598373413,
-0.35233646631240845,
0.3107638657093048,
0.1670716553926468,
0.8189160823822021,
0.5739403963088989,
0.6640472412109375,
0.21868537366390228,
0.01373530924320221,
-0.31157979369163513,
-0.2894322872161865,
-0.014074020087718964,
-0.27839016914367676,
-0.3235696852207184,
-0.11626042425632477,
0.17788748443126678,
0.576124370098114,
1.0085134506225586,
0.04410111904144287,
-0.18228934705257416,
0.0165727436542511,
0.2973794937133789,
-0.9612715840339661,
-0.21764250099658966,
-0.7240927815437317,
-0.07517151534557343,
-0.2588365972042084,
-0.00027965111075900495,
-0.18035899102687836,
-0.15189439058303833,
0.6505721807479858,
-0.294986367225647,
0.7352795004844666,
-0.20204241573810577,
1.1973919868469238,
0.15985842049121857,
-0.5580582618713379,
-0.45667630434036255,
-0.8503841161727905,
0.911200225353241,
-0.785544216632843,
0.6067441701889038,
0.5202189087867737,
0.2072991281747818,
0.004522230941802263,
-0.8262286186218262,
-0.39270859956741333,
-0.203402578830719,
-0.12914730608463287,
-0.2574271559715271,
-0.24650825560092926,
-0.059559136629104614,
0.16464202105998993,
0.5119640231132507,
-0.6908599734306335,
0.11688468605279922,
-0.1717776656150818,
-0.2307392656803131,
0.4054828882217407,
0.32477062940597534,
0.38950198888778687,
0.35879138112068176,
-0.2477821409702301,
-0.13381467759609222,
-0.894376814365387,
0.30074870586395264,
0.4362131655216217,
0.478026419878006,
-0.2713601887226105,
0.2954208254814148,
0.1028670147061348,
0.8817077875137329,
-0.21721236407756805,
0.36799290776252747,
-0.033916715532541275,
-0.6815696358680725,
-0.24587951600551605,
-0.21646851301193237,
0.5464595556259155,
0.11991352587938309,
0.2784978747367859,
-0.057801563292741776,
-0.051838524639606476,
0.2287648469209671,
0.39198288321495056,
-0.5882745981216431,
-0.10841099917888641,
0.26301297545433044,
-0.1837945282459259,
-0.05601350590586662,
0.2617380917072296,
-0.6863061785697937,
-0.25292083621025085,
-0.15423265099525452,
0.19825202226638794,
-0.14324453473091125,
-0.17337557673454285,
0.560533881187439,
-0.18617025017738342,
0.6333698630332947,
0.1419515460729599,
-0.9182855486869812,
0.5184600353240967,
0.8570279479026794,
0.9183633923530579,
-0.12238702178001404,
-0.34345388412475586,
-0.3566201627254486,
0.2664027810096741,
-0.4327174723148346,
0.657099187374115,
-0.8848758339881897,
-0.4074467420578003,
0.24272295832633972,
-0.00129752850625664,
-0.08947131037712097,
-0.4688669741153717,
0.2791649401187897,
-0.6131789684295654,
0.3201518654823303,
-0.3916618227958679,
-0.8230661153793335,
0.04558217525482178,
0.3744474947452545,
-0.3783438205718994,
0.7460877299308777,
0.015742547810077667,
-0.9072567224502563,
0.5678013563156128,
-0.48063045740127563,
-0.09567089378833771,
-0.3763841390609741,
-0.41853395104408264,
-0.553056538105011,
0.08453472703695297,
0.1908431202173233,
0.46444645524024963,
-0.4339863061904907,
0.2617201805114746,
-0.6356231570243835,
-0.4967805743217468,
0.2882677912712097,
0.09210549294948578,
0.6009640693664551,
0.14229841530323029,
-0.43246933817863464,
-0.09714014828205109,
-0.2579113841056824,
-0.27660107612609863,
0.13249266147613525,
0.06672543287277222,
-0.7757288217544556,
0.18610543012619019,
-0.26825764775276184,
0.17124727368354797,
-0.2509744167327881,
-0.500532329082489,
0.011896396055817604,
-0.4652386009693146,
0.325827956199646,
0.5808308124542236,
0.06284190714359283,
0.5812006592750549,
-0.29436472058296204,
0.5007389187812805,
0.32049164175987244,
0.035176776349544525,
-0.32823336124420166,
-0.30877551436424255,
-0.8600198030471802,
0.10571051388978958,
0.33034780621528625,
0.4898730516433716,
-0.23200246691703796,
0.4368766248226166,
-0.0461612343788147,
-0.5311212539672852,
-0.2770044505596161,
-0.023898614570498466,
0.3673941493034363,
0.3796968460083008,
0.32659655809402466,
-0.46263474225997925,
-0.10739855468273163,
-0.8538787961006165,
-0.461047500371933,
0.14525844156742096,
0.018572449684143066,
0.10981350392103195,
0.6968312859535217,
-0.49916398525238037,
1.0090917348861694,
-0.43199998140335083,
-0.07589656114578247,
-0.272997111082077,
0.020947113633155823,
-0.007970193400979042,
0.636250913143158,
0.5648888945579529,
-0.6815442442893982,
-0.5044770240783691,
0.03731216490268707,
-0.4575805068016052,
-0.1186651661992073,
-0.014068331569433212,
-0.011457033455371857,
-0.24427513778209686,
0.7663535475730896,
-0.4905255138874054,
0.7712134718894958,
0.46951183676719666,
-0.28290805220603943,
0.24248284101486206,
0.08570469170808792,
0.01349877193570137,
-0.950435996055603,
-0.16723118722438812,
0.07185355573892593,
0.0051846690475940704,
-0.9154131412506104,
0.17334721982479095,
0.013077186420559883,
-0.24025937914848328,
-0.4483610987663269,
0.4393186569213867,
-0.4965846538543701,
-0.2123526781797409,
-0.3040426969528198,
0.28430795669555664,
-0.09762164950370789,
0.18325689435005188,
-0.06941360980272293,
0.6451842188835144,
0.9805090427398682,
-0.8362414240837097,
0.01589016802608967,
-0.015582229010760784,
-0.3639170527458191,
0.04412952810525894,
-0.9910481572151184,
0.26617419719696045,
-0.07047932595014572,
0.19416910409927368,
-0.9822390079498291,
-0.06887086480855942,
0.3124306797981262,
-0.15760140120983124,
0.39135268330574036,
-0.1498398631811142,
-0.14652715623378754,
0.08198229968547821,
-0.2929879426956177,
0.5641443729400635,
0.3790232241153717,
0.007325250189751387,
0.3342382311820984,
0.5607512593269348,
-0.2004345804452896,
-0.6525078415870667,
-0.8361566662788391,
-0.2924453914165497,
-0.4750380516052246,
-0.46280041337013245,
0.23870886862277985,
0.08490778505802155,
-0.6808090806007385,
-0.09086529165506363,
-0.1346389204263687,
-0.054420534521341324,
0.042059045284986496,
0.13530905544757843,
-0.0938592255115509,
-0.3194045424461365,
0.4468517601490021,
0.03571515902876854,
-0.16643370687961578,
0.04824870452284813,
-0.14194367825984955,
0.8291237354278564,
-0.20092706382274628,
-0.7956399321556091,
-0.37396833300590515,
0.5031701326370239,
0.28343579173088074,
-0.42763552069664,
0.5368227362632751,
0.14663204550743103,
-0.23353363573551178,
-0.25667116045951843,
-0.5426870584487915,
-0.359970360994339,
-0.4902052879333496,
0.23181700706481934,
-0.46600186824798584,
-1.2380826473236084,
0.5910678505897522,
-0.18490518629550934,
0.1646403968334198,
0.2881525456905365,
0.5003662109375,
-0.10080298036336899,
0.5575278401374817,
0.9494756460189819,
-0.004598196130245924,
0.47219935059547424,
-0.2855483293533325,
0.28056812286376953,
-0.4472585916519165,
0.058806151151657104,
-0.9563359618186951,
-0.0927000492811203,
-0.5114336013793945,
-0.4747937321662903,
-0.009997043758630753,
-0.0949285477399826,
-0.38557079434394836,
0.2201462835073471,
-0.07591555267572403,
0.5198441743850708,
0.2690782845020294,
-0.20048631727695465,
0.12481093406677246,
-0.026417246088385582,
-0.028431618586182594,
-0.24911323189735413,
-0.6090266704559326,
-0.5492334961891174,
1.024499535560608,
0.5496068000793457,
0.9894809722900391,
0.008359366096556187,
0.5643225908279419,
0.32305312156677246,
0.030308930203318596,
-0.5813047289848328,
0.2502005398273468,
-0.1393224447965622,
-0.6318374872207642,
-0.4230363965034485,
-0.25061938166618347,
-1.29373037815094,
0.3772991895675659,
0.26954182982444763,
-0.5992932915687561,
0.5166054964065552,
0.0014354997547343373,
-0.3174965977668762,
0.38283300399780273,
-0.43291550874710083,
0.974605143070221,
-0.018765190616250038,
-0.22506599128246307,
-0.10241769254207611,
-0.7782971858978271,
0.2694159150123596,
-0.23792776465415955,
0.1944563090801239,
-0.2692866027355194,
-0.38663849234580994,
0.41477441787719727,
-0.38028523325920105,
0.8966321349143982,
0.07122854143381119,
-0.41447141766548157,
0.2496853470802307,
0.15170225501060486,
0.2792676091194153,
0.047821782529354095,
0.18086126446723938,
0.06334102898836136,
-0.2147030532360077,
-0.7352277636528015,
-0.7610519528388977,
0.4700607359409332,
-0.8724193572998047,
-0.9007360935211182,
-0.5831738114356995,
-0.463797003030777,
-0.6673450469970703,
-0.06761132925748825,
0.42651835083961487,
0.40806013345718384,
-0.3443847596645355,
0.2882484793663025,
1.0884156227111816,
-0.33903223276138306,
0.44870525598526,
0.6924533843994141,
-0.11347782611846924,
0.07290384918451309,
0.48885974287986755,
-0.08755338191986084,
0.5908238887786865,
0.3950570523738861,
0.16248449683189392,
-0.15127450227737427,
-0.7086731791496277,
-0.08275125920772552,
0.16938148438930511,
-0.5080327391624451,
0.22430257499217987,
-0.892050564289093,
-0.22035622596740723,
-0.6977262496948242,
-0.3644878566265106,
-0.5586186647415161,
0.1181735098361969,
-0.16551634669303894,
-0.11660601943731308,
-0.09815245121717453,
0.6801272630691528,
0.08007386326789856,
0.5535297989845276,
-0.9482360482215881,
-0.015537713654339314,
0.4221048057079315,
0.1028461903333664,
-0.16426824033260345,
-0.7326028943061829,
-0.33301252126693726,
0.06897416710853577,
-0.282123327255249,
-1.2380155324935913,
0.15195219218730927,
0.0714821144938469,
0.8401722311973572,
0.4400559663772583,
-0.08496949076652527,
0.5987569689750671,
-0.22276732325553894,
0.8389831781387329,
-0.1472628265619278,
-1.1589549779891968,
0.8929873108863831,
-0.5668827891349792,
0.46792829036712646,
0.46517887711524963,
0.702526330947876,
-0.30779778957366943,
-0.684414267539978,
-0.5607529282569885,
-0.5969727039337158,
0.5227363705635071,
0.2164476215839386,
0.4236566722393036,
0.4268523156642914,
0.24789664149284363,
0.3812658190727234,
0.0759051963686943,
-0.758245587348938,
-0.1536037176847458,
-0.056115590035915375,
0.33725404739379883,
-0.40282943844795227,
-0.1514829844236374,
-0.29852762818336487,
-0.13236437737941742,
0.4470854103565216,
0.015937376767396927,
-0.021873408928513527,
0.12985239923000336,
-0.2147260457277298,
0.11220450699329376,
0.3531720042228699,
0.7028628587722778,
0.6140686869621277,
-0.02172832190990448,
0.2783448100090027,
0.1334047019481659,
-0.45734915137290955,
0.46379899978637695,
0.031586527824401855,
-0.07515320926904678,
0.17030610144138336,
0.6653788089752197,
0.8614566326141357,
0.06360545009374619,
-0.4590507745742798,
0.5198343992233276,
0.00009147982200374827,
0.03545256331562996,
0.1416991502046585,
0.08655151724815369,
-0.14912550151348114,
0.11460117995738983,
0.007239994127303362,
-0.2932196259498596,
0.1541704386472702,
-0.7687363028526306,
0.3949328064918518,
0.43193694949150085,
-0.35881760716438293,
-0.28898051381111145,
0.20221731066703796,
0.08506894111633301,
-0.03670909255743027,
0.4970894455909729,
0.1437334269285202,
-0.30432313680648804,
0.6879919767379761,
0.4184643030166626,
0.9185336232185364,
-0.2989896535873413,
0.26659277081489563,
0.048195671290159225,
0.6765285134315491,
0.29260823130607605,
0.2484903484582901,
-0.20694978535175323,
-0.9354143738746643,
-0.21220333874225616,
-0.2945772111415863,
-0.4605517089366913,
0.23472176492214203,
-0.7638397812843323,
0.1745646893978119,
-0.29224467277526855,
-0.3801253139972687,
-0.3168378174304962,
-0.027727635577321053,
-0.4886683523654938,
0.16445192694664001,
-0.10581076890230179,
0.8058863282203674,
-1.065839171409607,
0.9592987298965454,
0.7004804015159607,
-0.21799254417419434,
-0.508897066116333,
0.46705538034439087,
-0.12499244511127472,
-0.47845128178596497,
0.3408178389072418,
-0.061121076345443726,
0.011671408079564571,
-0.3125235438346863,
-0.580527663230896,
-0.9327874183654785,
0.7061764001846313,
0.37053194642066956,
-0.5454890131950378,
-0.029867690056562424,
0.5971567630767822,
0.5105434060096741,
-0.433064728975296,
-0.11377415806055069,
0.8008081912994385,
0.2423912137746811,
-0.2709297239780426,
-0.7803120017051697,
-0.2720378041267395,
-0.15922662615776062,
0.10273075848817825,
0.4804231822490692,
-0.6398159861564636,
1.1287740468978882,
-0.05232834443449974,
-0.19624994695186615,
-0.22571955621242523,
0.47613605856895447,
0.2944681942462921,
0.5624710321426392,
0.35113367438316345,
0.7735769152641296,
0.2981698215007782,
-0.2913959324359894,
1.1048588752746582,
-0.06721509248018265,
0.4103032946586609,
1.3043627738952637,
-0.512889564037323,
0.5393354892730713,
0.5522007346153259,
-0.25855183601379395,
0.5407536029815674,
0.9555111527442932,
0.026067567989230156,
0.7134198546409607,
0.47078752517700195,
-0.04867801070213318,
-0.3314501941204071,
-0.03314363956451416,
-0.9490724802017212,
0.43515896797180176,
0.5425998568534851,
-0.4190963804721832,
-0.630065381526947,
-0.05902881920337677,
-0.1147732213139534,
-0.03556031361222267,
-0.14840838313102722,
0.645158052444458,
0.17943494021892548,
-0.3941987156867981,
0.13059598207473755,
-0.11237186938524246,
0.5523117184638977,
-1.080341100692749,
0.25285565853118896,
-0.5133453011512756,
0.11093959957361221,
0.24069634079933167,
-0.6060521602630615,
0.4760185480117798,
-0.1375395953655243,
0.0015481443842872977,
-0.1652022749185562,
0.9796581864356995,
-0.4456050395965576,
-0.12860119342803955,
0.46414491534233093,
0.9034468531608582,
0.14368212223052979,
-0.002339588711038232,
-0.6340655088424683,
0.4601936936378479,
-0.2693663239479065,
-0.28323420882225037,
0.5575345754623413,
0.46888622641563416,
-0.04421091079711914,
0.602921724319458,
0.5227121114730835,
0.020316531881690025,
0.33689451217651367,
-0.01197783462703228,
0.9186418652534485,
-0.6191262006759644,
-0.5578364133834839,
-1.0798799991607666,
0.5037857890129089,
0.10395029932260513,
-0.5811294913291931,
0.8969022035598755,
0.5462313890457153,
1.1586737632751465,
-0.13256749510765076,
0.7449762225151062,
0.3080824017524719,
0.4100542962551117,
-0.4390089809894562,
0.6824021339416504,
-0.6690932512283325,
0.23634007573127747,
-0.39417123794555664,
-0.9214074015617371,
-0.18374300003051758,
0.3493715822696686,
-0.37169674038887024,
0.21661050617694855,
0.5728620290756226,
1.041154384613037,
-0.24128557741641998,
-0.040722258388996124,
0.4991301894187927,
-0.2019413858652115,
0.367647647857666,
0.546413779258728,
1.3093438148498535,
-0.3760828971862793,
0.24119919538497925,
-0.22891739010810852,
-0.034621987491846085,
0.12336333096027374,
-0.7186546921730042,
-0.9985260963439941,
-0.6354914307594299,
-0.38843289017677307,
-0.0045196255668997765,
0.1298290193080902,
0.3945648670196533,
0.7604070901870728,
-1.0050238370895386,
-0.5365525484085083,
-0.281343013048172,
0.0582149438560009,
0.1083390936255455,
-0.21480610966682434,
0.19345559179782867,
-0.5588632822036743,
-0.8076230883598328,
0.2795887589454651,
0.24170687794685364,
0.5305959582328796,
-0.3006402552127838,
-0.02282821014523506,
-0.33544987440109253,
0.31998980045318604,
0.22159644961357117,
0.23006515204906464,
-0.7856232523918152,
-0.03538648039102554,
-0.07666890323162079,
-0.3622782528400421,
-0.2583659589290619,
1.5437848567962646,
-0.4671044945716858,
0.3882240653038025,
0.5510419011116028,
1.0985511541366577,
0.3261444568634033,
-0.24825836718082428,
0.9647798538208008,
-0.6694738864898682,
0.32743221521377563,
0.2660822570323944,
0.2758316397666931,
0.0818011537194252,
-0.0005211471579968929,
0.5480942726135254,
0.35585254430770874,
-0.5964342951774597,
-1.155261516571045,
0.45969823002815247,
-0.5476531386375427,
-0.5008764266967773,
0.9446496963500977,
-0.3373500108718872,
0.465939998626709,
-0.47642701864242554,
0.1696445196866989,
0.33201146125793457,
-0.02907457947731018,
0.6933838129043579,
1.0399565696716309,
-0.11578861624002457,
-0.19272984564304352,
-0.46800538897514343,
0.611965000629425,
0.6368468403816223,
-0.9007168412208557,
-0.15453888475894928,
0.2595829665660858,
0.2330394834280014,
0.08850546926259995,
0.5148378610610962,
-0.007228320464491844,
0.30476322770118713,
0.12463558465242386,
-0.3554230332374573,
0.25916773080825806,
-0.3026593327522278,
-0.6292880177497864,
0.2908245623111725,
-0.27186712622642517,
-0.2836022973060608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01364v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01364v2 | Continual Learning for Large Language Models: A Survey | 2024-02-02T12:34:09 | 2024-02-07T07:14:39 | Tongtong Wu, Linhao Luo, Yuan-Fang Li, Shirui Pan, Thuy-Trang Vu, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are not amenable to frequent re-training, due to
high training costs arising from their massive scale. However, updates are
necessary to endow LLMs with new skills and keep them up-to-date with rapidly
evolving human knowledge. This paper surveys recent works on continual learning
for LLMs. Due to the unique nature of LLMs, we catalog continue learning
techniques in a novel multi-staged categorization scheme, involving continual
pretraining, instruction tuning, and alignment. We contrast continual learning
for LLMs with simpler adaptation methods used in smaller models, as well as
with other enhancement strategies like retrieval-augmented generation and model
editing. Moreover, informed by a discussion of benchmarks and evaluation, we
identify several challenges and future work directions for this crucial task. | [
-0.003906986676156521,
-0.6008239984512329,
0.5353023409843445,
0.19547834992408752,
-0.1388353556394577,
0.38588958978652954,
-0.5956794619560242,
-0.4591890573501587,
-0.18588006496429443,
0.6904283761978149,
-0.6532720327377319,
-0.24367761611938477,
-0.4492036998271942,
0.13695013523101807,
-0.2602730095386505,
0.7764201760292053,
-0.14144745469093323,
0.27639254927635193,
-0.2516113817691803,
-0.2390889972448349,
-0.7667504549026489,
-0.7715631127357483,
-1.0944656133651733,
-0.3636985421180725,
0.919274628162384,
0.5726642608642578,
0.2946527302265167,
0.46609246730804443,
0.28845641016960144,
0.272360622882843,
-0.07533092796802521,
0.19761618971824646,
-0.6167452335357666,
0.5428064465522766,
-0.1125282272696495,
-0.4424612522125244,
-0.20350243151187897,
-0.009668522514402866,
1.1776403188705444,
1.15837562084198,
-0.33002999424934387,
0.10003871470689774,
0.25901758670806885,
0.698971688747406,
-0.6178355813026428,
-0.09134001284837723,
-0.7696841955184937,
-0.05338205769658089,
-0.2970014214515686,
0.08108443766832352,
-0.6352846622467041,
-0.4116693139076233,
0.10704261064529419,
-0.3026513159275055,
-0.03635500743985176,
0.14129391312599182,
0.4208775758743286,
0.3018897771835327,
-0.3897794485092163,
-0.37815147638320923,
-0.8584887385368347,
0.9184623956680298,
-0.5415014624595642,
0.6493814587593079,
0.16128073632717133,
0.16562828421592712,
-0.358235239982605,
-0.7652758955955505,
-0.30719801783561707,
-0.7492944002151489,
0.3231041431427002,
0.011444300413131714,
0.09940007328987122,
-0.0920829251408577,
-0.003429827280342579,
0.172037273645401,
-0.3930329382419586,
0.6008456945419312,
-0.1253587156534195,
-0.07404299080371857,
0.5792800784111023,
0.2616807222366333,
0.2016362100839615,
0.5186217427253723,
-0.22338992357254028,
0.04347626119852066,
-1.1199477910995483,
-0.3198036253452301,
0.05652349814772606,
-0.05669936537742615,
0.06256236881017685,
0.2908724248409271,
-0.020271699875593185,
0.797251284122467,
-0.04548659920692444,
-0.14457319676876068,
0.11959841102361679,
-0.12484084814786911,
-0.04336770251393318,
-0.17933420836925507,
0.5274079442024231,
-0.07564124464988708,
0.44263842701911926,
-0.38004767894744873,
-0.40937134623527527,
-0.297010213136673,
0.30740877985954285,
-0.3098641633987427,
-0.05762188881635666,
-0.08700305223464966,
-0.1889183223247528,
-0.08065935224294662,
-0.2878388464450836,
-0.6066325306892395,
-0.2791053354740143,
-0.5499898791313171,
0.46301716566085815,
-0.15325340628623962,
-0.15633855760097504,
0.15067078173160553,
0.2771572768688202,
0.2532180845737457,
0.5888781547546387,
-0.9252182245254517,
0.12071053683757782,
0.6734016537666321,
0.9081651568412781,
-0.29879480600357056,
-0.5439544916152954,
-0.6330333352088928,
0.24529452621936798,
-0.813386857509613,
0.7696373462677002,
-0.645490288734436,
-0.25927790999412537,
0.17826640605926514,
0.43433234095573425,
-0.1999148279428482,
-0.7384212017059326,
0.14215882122516632,
-0.6463287472724915,
0.1652459353208542,
-0.2761600613594055,
-0.5967795848846436,
0.001994193298742175,
0.3722933232784271,
-0.5026172399520874,
0.9022944569587708,
0.08125755935907364,
-0.24992243945598602,
0.42187416553497314,
-0.2987675666809082,
-0.22879967093467712,
0.32598695158958435,
0.07335596531629562,
-0.39629530906677246,
0.29059168696403503,
-0.30773693323135376,
0.5199427008628845,
-0.14792224764823914,
0.4534095823764801,
-0.5607025027275085,
-0.1643596589565277,
0.31586146354675293,
-0.4774157702922821,
0.32682865858078003,
0.16784362494945526,
0.002500771079212427,
0.19252066314220428,
-0.6317958831787109,
-0.3475631773471832,
0.10665208101272583,
-0.5955488085746765,
-0.07974059879779816,
0.27528926730155945,
-0.24757039546966553,
0.3368390202522278,
0.5175834894180298,
-0.3018816113471985,
0.5255419015884399,
-0.16827434301376343,
0.3571525514125824,
0.916991651058197,
0.10430080443620682,
0.3607470989227295,
-0.5883711576461792,
0.5704269409179688,
-0.13321900367736816,
0.18967020511627197,
-0.3079877495765686,
-0.21500223875045776,
-1.002851128578186,
0.03736592456698418,
0.4227508008480072,
0.4215121567249298,
-0.6593030095100403,
0.2163175344467163,
-0.4362924098968506,
-0.5364588499069214,
0.03619983419775963,
0.5458350777626038,
0.34964773058891296,
0.017563005909323692,
0.2978858947753906,
-0.39786210656166077,
-0.5435317158699036,
-0.40209275484085083,
-0.005041831638664007,
0.04734131321310997,
-0.026764746755361557,
-0.008347398601472378,
0.6344294548034668,
-0.42177218198776245,
0.6183002591133118,
-0.1671651303768158,
-0.05954840034246445,
-0.419368714094162,
0.03582926094532013,
-0.09660079330205917,
0.5692408084869385,
0.36777400970458984,
-0.36306360363960266,
-0.48451799154281616,
0.07660561800003052,
-0.7797086834907532,
0.11051763594150543,
-0.4181155562400818,
0.23467417061328888,
0.22457079589366913,
0.9616433382034302,
-0.4263051450252533,
-0.22221611440181732,
0.4765436053276062,
0.13020895421504974,
0.7947791218757629,
-0.43545103073120117,
-0.29221704602241516,
-0.8014693856239319,
-0.047663796693086624,
-0.10238441079854965,
-0.4154212474822998,
-0.7768593430519104,
0.09456247836351395,
-0.04352389648556709,
0.03911441192030907,
-0.3846559524536133,
1.0357803106307983,
-0.8472124338150024,
-0.05135316774249077,
-0.4350736439228058,
0.12508125603199005,
-0.4689948558807373,
0.3617312014102936,
0.22477634251117706,
0.567441463470459,
0.7149542570114136,
-0.8943988084793091,
0.5901402235031128,
-0.09702455252408981,
-0.3114963173866272,
0.21948401629924774,
-0.5092830061912537,
0.3203064799308777,
-0.17252834141254425,
0.4599066972732544,
-0.7370392084121704,
-0.3285582661628723,
0.36124947667121887,
-0.15472789108753204,
0.7245563864707947,
-0.10944492369890213,
-0.5913729667663574,
-0.37366384267807007,
-0.0720801055431366,
0.08901841938495636,
0.5561737418174744,
-0.7018019556999207,
0.32302436232566833,
0.24753734469413757,
-0.4375610053539276,
-0.45874905586242676,
-0.45440635085105896,
0.293086975812912,
-0.2858411967754364,
-0.16491226851940155,
0.030841657891869545,
-0.15224158763885498,
-0.2408088594675064,
-0.1661818027496338,
-0.17203187942504883,
0.13879625499248505,
0.1829991638660431,
-0.109959676861763,
0.07489966601133347,
-0.17514123022556305,
0.5651208758354187,
-0.2920454144477844,
-0.055324751883745193,
-0.022676873952150345,
-0.5864183902740479,
0.6263454556465149,
0.06708796322345734,
-0.2286957949399948,
-0.26989907026290894,
0.16300693154335022,
0.458586186170578,
-0.12594033777713776,
0.9616615176200867,
0.49519485235214233,
-0.2996513843536377,
-0.17977693676948547,
-0.9339849352836609,
-0.09192973375320435,
-0.4389590620994568,
0.39564067125320435,
-0.27454879879951477,
-1.2633976936340332,
0.36736127734184265,
-0.45130807161331177,
0.2559691369533539,
0.4340241551399231,
0.6981571912765503,
-0.2695186734199524,
0.7916248440742493,
0.8763872981071472,
-0.2231086790561676,
0.6386609077453613,
0.18726567924022675,
-0.19618691504001617,
-0.7347475290298462,
-0.3375120162963867,
-0.5661708116531372,
-0.11839296668767929,
-0.4253600239753723,
-0.2694864273071289,
0.09426502883434296,
0.305419385433197,
-0.3338916301727295,
0.051444679498672485,
-0.17090941965579987,
0.33060359954833984,
0.16553179919719696,
0.008646019734442234,
0.212727352976799,
-0.0863264873623848,
0.14222955703735352,
0.21723100543022156,
-0.8879342675209045,
-0.3187674582004547,
1.1112585067749023,
0.35544273257255554,
0.9120424389839172,
0.1702873855829239,
0.5951108336448669,
0.1581115573644638,
0.7387559413909912,
-0.6653544902801514,
0.455831378698349,
-0.07081297039985657,
-0.3582755923271179,
-0.44548413157463074,
-0.5779319405555725,
-1.1706823110580444,
0.13116459548473358,
-0.08338840305805206,
-0.6964977979660034,
0.04001764580607414,
0.3139383792877197,
0.023615622892975807,
0.23199398815631866,
-0.3135409951210022,
0.8312293887138367,
-0.49688541889190674,
-0.3376834988594055,
-0.3615185022354126,
-0.6220251321792603,
0.3177030682563782,
-0.603190541267395,
0.26259633898735046,
0.13156455755233765,
-0.1931486278772354,
0.7153593301773071,
-0.2997417747974396,
0.9867860674858093,
0.05055756866931915,
-0.23319987952709198,
0.22121365368366241,
-0.17526350915431976,
0.481723427772522,
-0.08640445023775101,
0.2083272784948349,
-0.06985913962125778,
0.09050443023443222,
-0.5028042793273926,
-0.34189799427986145,
0.6410329341888428,
-0.5410259366035461,
-0.6500310897827148,
-0.559772253036499,
-0.31181448698043823,
-0.5012690424919128,
0.12044069170951843,
0.038414306938648224,
0.4434256851673126,
-0.11517410725355148,
0.4409559965133667,
0.9193809628486633,
-0.29123541712760925,
0.36363837122917175,
0.36457693576812744,
-0.3116236627101898,
-0.35996267199516296,
1.0592443943023682,
0.22889137268066406,
0.42014703154563904,
0.2876467704772949,
0.2207099199295044,
-0.39512744545936584,
-0.7550718784332275,
-0.103312648832798,
0.5718406438827515,
-0.720729410648346,
0.040377210825681686,
-0.5551539659500122,
-0.19896557927131653,
-0.3364947736263275,
-0.125839963555336,
-0.2591210901737213,
-0.09824158996343613,
-0.4136609137058258,
0.23259441554546356,
0.23171807825565338,
0.8787245750427246,
-0.12894193828105927,
0.4596114456653595,
-0.9818660616874695,
0.0313558392226696,
0.44561338424682617,
0.4272943139076233,
0.1962849348783493,
-0.8493825793266296,
-0.4823605418205261,
-0.10432808101177216,
-0.31623783707618713,
-0.5896092653274536,
0.21817471086978912,
0.4433310031890869,
0.7357977628707886,
0.17683230340480804,
-0.22459913790225983,
0.6145553588867188,
-0.6943804621696472,
0.8405472040176392,
0.313886821269989,
-0.6980563998222351,
0.296474814414978,
-0.17938566207885742,
0.5379251837730408,
0.4245176613330841,
0.7195894718170166,
-1.0017600059509277,
-0.15910717844963074,
-0.2997305989265442,
-0.5450701713562012,
0.3887300491333008,
-0.45433637499809265,
0.4495629370212555,
-0.12774494290351868,
0.7270891666412354,
0.002483366522938013,
0.2033763974905014,
-0.7523168921470642,
0.1659037321805954,
0.16773106157779694,
-0.13394217193126678,
-0.3353947103023529,
-0.44314563274383545,
0.1342453509569168,
-0.23606351017951965,
0.7805549502372742,
-0.1586451381444931,
-0.060144051909446716,
-0.29619815945625305,
-0.4174433648586273,
0.08130447566509247,
0.35432785749435425,
0.7662599086761475,
0.9069439172744751,
-0.005719917826354504,
-0.18646025657653809,
0.6143170595169067,
-0.45075520873069763,
0.2803294062614441,
-0.4357281029224396,
0.19035561382770538,
-0.10807686299085617,
0.5463381409645081,
0.684353768825531,
0.5946579575538635,
-0.8195151090621948,
0.1880287528038025,
0.06507115811109543,
-0.40754687786102295,
-0.7615945935249329,
0.08995383232831955,
0.15653765201568604,
0.17452946305274963,
0.2848246395587921,
-0.19196198880672455,
-0.49238473176956177,
-0.7686767578125,
0.1463368535041809,
0.3582995533943176,
-0.4937412738800049,
-0.27806010842323303,
0.46500831842422485,
-0.03374418616294861,
-0.1121336966753006,
0.7524248957633972,
-0.2415027767419815,
-0.40494415163993835,
0.13919933140277863,
0.48537614941596985,
0.7526967525482178,
-0.46459588408470154,
-0.06763555109500885,
0.3315460681915283,
0.3490860164165497,
-0.8473765850067139,
-0.02836121991276741,
-0.04341790825128555,
-0.6612117290496826,
-0.6934417486190796,
-0.796873152256012,
-0.739482045173645,
0.38746389746665955,
-0.3810977339744568,
0.280868798494339,
-0.5388058423995972,
0.19052620232105255,
-0.4111775755882263,
-0.02093438431620598,
-0.3637925088405609,
0.2352387011051178,
0.15738092362880707,
0.8559894561767578,
-0.522368848323822,
1.1388025283813477,
0.6138983964920044,
-0.20980067551136017,
-0.5242424607276917,
-0.17423512041568756,
0.07387345284223557,
-0.36338186264038086,
0.6275539994239807,
0.1553078144788742,
-0.1077394187450409,
0.1691569834947586,
-0.7538191676139832,
-0.9310953617095947,
0.9388539791107178,
0.26370373368263245,
-0.9703522324562073,
-0.3303200602531433,
-0.1800364851951599,
0.5360389947891235,
-0.3846089541912079,
-0.1432936042547226,
0.4824858605861664,
0.39247074723243713,
0.2793166935443878,
-0.7263520956039429,
-0.37339645624160767,
0.053435664623975754,
0.11301407963037491,
0.06605596840381622,
-0.6393752694129944,
0.6134662628173828,
-0.032341353595256805,
-0.17226974666118622,
0.3400319814682007,
0.6307134628295898,
0.3486361801624298,
0.07255434989929199,
0.4767158031463623,
0.49426132440567017,
0.6962016820907593,
-0.1402023583650589,
0.7898510694503784,
-0.2332308292388916,
0.4479316771030426,
1.265344262123108,
-0.6117335557937622,
0.9195698499679565,
0.11242262274026871,
-0.05054710805416107,
0.3491166830062866,
0.9120426177978516,
-0.2910732626914978,
0.22829613089561462,
0.35574817657470703,
-0.4599962830543518,
-0.6842749118804932,
0.11584719270467758,
-0.3959728479385376,
0.3649369478225708,
0.48799562454223633,
0.026443708688020706,
-0.07198232412338257,
0.3817821741104126,
0.11907295882701874,
-0.16591192781925201,
-0.44612112641334534,
0.8054012656211853,
0.24846415221691132,
-0.7300450801849365,
0.5222030282020569,
-0.16395141184329987,
0.7374268174171448,
-0.8018973469734192,
0.16856487095355988,
-0.25216740369796753,
0.13492943346500397,
0.07421225309371948,
-0.4307980537414551,
0.2595180571079254,
0.04166078194975853,
0.004756018985062838,
-0.27267003059387207,
0.42460620403289795,
-0.5025022029876709,
-0.40702393651008606,
0.16235540807247162,
0.35022252798080444,
0.24603551626205444,
0.1049971878528595,
-0.6965838670730591,
0.3093683421611786,
-0.26197269558906555,
-0.3213702142238617,
0.577743411064148,
0.3123992383480072,
-0.1532323956489563,
1.1571662425994873,
0.7090852856636047,
0.23811906576156616,
0.2593613862991333,
0.30316948890686035,
0.6455397605895996,
-0.7240793704986572,
-0.1746450811624527,
-0.7744784951210022,
0.2803773283958435,
0.18537428975105286,
-0.2687775492668152,
0.6768303513526917,
0.27818945050239563,
1.0583564043045044,
-0.14937789738178253,
0.5628870129585266,
0.38281381130218506,
0.3649507761001587,
-0.8961166143417358,
0.5476647019386292,
-0.8619161248207092,
0.25848275423049927,
0.07165375351905823,
-1.1133638620376587,
-0.4083590507507324,
0.388972669839859,
-0.27769163250923157,
0.21015293896198273,
0.7459442019462585,
0.5531458258628845,
0.12465174496173859,
-0.33868274092674255,
0.48309510946273804,
0.2244773805141449,
0.17650049924850464,
0.5123945474624634,
1.135970115661621,
0.09059828519821167,
0.2561566233634949,
0.1325773000717163,
-0.03220677748322487,
-0.22822384536266327,
-0.8003041744232178,
-0.7391254901885986,
-0.6946120858192444,
-0.5349065661430359,
0.05009099096059799,
0.17107750475406647,
0.9770640134811401,
0.6845340132713318,
-0.6584951281547546,
-0.35310766100883484,
-0.09158587455749512,
-0.02726799249649048,
-0.20053650438785553,
-0.06943795830011368,
0.06633135676383972,
-0.9207903146743774,
-0.6302278637886047,
0.5423693060874939,
0.4173972010612488,
-0.06946423649787903,
-0.4610639214515686,
-0.11557905375957489,
-0.4046012759208679,
-0.1186738833785057,
0.7500224709510803,
0.6970058679580688,
-0.6737980842590332,
-0.5758777856826782,
-0.18466408550739288,
0.038004644215106964,
0.0021202098578214645,
0.6962793469429016,
-0.6180821657180786,
0.344373494386673,
0.16746509075164795,
0.9734192490577698,
0.5800372958183289,
-0.3484365940093994,
0.42468830943107605,
-0.6269516944885254,
-0.06894108653068542,
0.15588459372520447,
0.44789549708366394,
0.41077637672424316,
-0.020046725869178772,
0.29831641912460327,
0.33922290802001953,
-0.9116299748420715,
-0.8851968050003052,
0.34144073724746704,
-0.841763973236084,
-0.2852194011211395,
1.0798723697662354,
-0.12239081412553787,
-0.07653579860925674,
-0.38518133759498596,
0.1751682162284851,
0.1926628202199936,
0.16462500393390656,
0.4610096216201782,
0.8089657425880432,
0.08587658405303955,
-0.6826643943786621,
-0.6884801387786865,
0.3439774215221405,
0.27827587723731995,
-0.8569365739822388,
0.17693562805652618,
0.6311982870101929,
0.6342054009437561,
-0.0008506069425493479,
0.5966586470603943,
-0.05478844791650772,
0.22795289754867554,
-0.15015357732772827,
0.021353518590331078,
0.29236531257629395,
-0.7087177634239197,
-0.859973132610321,
-0.019762836396694183,
0.5800491571426392,
0.28226861357688904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01360v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01360v1 | What Makes Medical Claims (Un)Verifiable? Analyzing Entity and Relation Properties for Fact Verification | 2024-02-02T12:27:58 | 2024-02-02T12:27:58 | Amelie Wührl, Yarik Menchaca Resendiz, Lara Grimminger, Roman Klinger | cs.CL | cs.CL | Biomedical claim verification fails if no evidence can be discovered. In
these cases, the fact-checking verdict remains unknown and the claim is
unverifiable. To improve upon this, we have to understand if there are any
claim properties that impact its verifiability. In this work we assume that
entities and relations define the core variables in a biomedical claim's
anatomy and analyze if their properties help us to differentiate verifiable
from unverifiable claims. In a study with trained annotation experts we prompt
them to find evidence for biomedical claims, and observe how they refine search
queries for their evidence search. This leads to the first corpus for
scientific fact verification annotated with subject-relation-object triplets,
evidence documents, and fact-checking verdicts (the BEAR-Fact corpus). We find
(1) that discovering evidence for negated claims (e.g., X-does-not-cause-Y) is
particularly challenging. Further, we see that annotators process queries
mostly by adding constraints to the search and by normalizing entities to
canonical names. (2) We compare our in-house annotations with a small
crowdsourcing setting where we employ medical experts and laypeople. We find
that domain expertise does not have a substantial effect on the reliability of
annotations. Finally, (3), we demonstrate that it is possible to reliably
estimate the success of evidence retrieval purely from the claim text~(.82\F),
whereas identifying unverifiable claims proves more challenging (.27\F). The
dataset is available at http://www.ims.uni-stuttgart.de/data/bioclaim. | [
-0.16452272236347198,
-0.5905390381813049,
0.9997643232345581,
-0.04936956614255905,
-0.09463916718959808,
0.2122941017150879,
-0.04478365555405617,
-0.9219103455543518,
0.6481064558029175,
0.4938797950744629,
-0.04942771792411804,
-0.2677483558654785,
-0.7303618788719177,
0.3873356878757477,
-0.061575330793857574,
1.1634221076965332,
0.11389908939599991,
0.05958350747823715,
-0.6544565558433533,
-0.6401929259300232,
-0.04380304366350174,
-0.6740027666091919,
-0.28034263849258423,
-0.4368094205856323,
0.48077696561813354,
0.14646016061306,
0.8473538160324097,
0.6900812983512878,
0.51997971534729,
0.2658645212650299,
-0.2494472861289978,
0.3704926073551178,
-0.035440344363451004,
0.03939976170659065,
-0.31093934178352356,
-0.38708171248435974,
-0.33979007601737976,
-0.06597022712230682,
0.4377669394016266,
1.0532912015914917,
0.07276958972215652,
0.16072751581668854,
-0.44404837489128113,
0.6020702123641968,
-0.6893365979194641,
0.22608017921447754,
-0.6740912795066833,
0.04435482248663902,
-0.5614107847213745,
-0.32699060440063477,
-0.39109811186790466,
-0.24024039506912231,
0.34299319982528687,
-0.5903754234313965,
0.5662875175476074,
0.22890523076057434,
1.285571813583374,
0.3271288573741913,
-0.6030578017234802,
-0.3366791903972626,
-0.62997967004776,
0.4052242934703827,
-0.522857666015625,
0.26124662160873413,
0.6597763895988464,
0.06005494296550751,
-0.2614586651325226,
-0.7047616243362427,
-0.30496686697006226,
-0.5207629203796387,
-0.5820965766906738,
-0.1101585254073143,
-0.14807763695716858,
0.17974530160427094,
0.5986585021018982,
0.6811648011207581,
-0.21308426558971405,
0.038456279784440994,
-0.5365718007087708,
-0.7046518325805664,
0.7490295171737671,
-0.24356119334697723,
0.4707501530647278,
-0.24108122289180756,
-0.2985823452472687,
0.506811261177063,
-1.0021544694900513,
0.051073964685201645,
-0.021357327699661255,
0.023268597200512886,
0.20388448238372803,
0.8171144723892212,
-0.17598478496074677,
0.4438857138156891,
0.020777948200702667,
-0.10021880269050598,
0.36069750785827637,
-0.36430391669273376,
-0.024817774072289467,
0.4021507501602173,
0.5817248821258545,
0.12730342149734497,
0.008576820604503155,
-0.4249236285686493,
-0.01583031937479973,
0.005378621630370617,
0.22163157165050507,
-0.6522534489631653,
-0.19177773594856262,
0.3017003834247589,
-0.4343690872192383,
-0.01640525832772255,
-0.12646782398223877,
-0.18738451600074768,
-0.6056901216506958,
-0.23028340935707092,
0.43922945857048035,
-0.3768375515937805,
-0.24922223389148712,
0.040199194103479385,
-0.14567600190639496,
-0.27842751145362854,
0.30820727348327637,
-0.6445347666740417,
0.22302138805389404,
0.44283854961395264,
0.5739824771881104,
0.24940527975559235,
-0.002190078841522336,
-0.3893483877182007,
-0.036336980760097504,
-0.3848287761211395,
1.0293225049972534,
-0.37147167325019836,
-0.20948702096939087,
0.09974979609251022,
0.2852286696434021,
0.19489434361457825,
-0.6397058367729187,
0.6897771954536438,
-0.4731576442718506,
-0.011201858520507812,
-0.7041211128234863,
-0.8332259058952332,
-0.25393855571746826,
-0.020168201997876167,
-0.695072591304779,
0.5285730361938477,
0.07184270769357681,
-0.8773097991943359,
0.8121337294578552,
-0.5395030379295349,
-0.5806788206100464,
0.26535043120384216,
-0.5259950160980225,
-0.4684008061885834,
0.3661334216594696,
-0.12458968162536621,
0.3736925721168518,
-0.39101457595825195,
0.3002750277519226,
-0.48866480588912964,
-0.1152612492442131,
0.6334455013275146,
0.0740288570523262,
1.0154401063919067,
-0.07164959609508514,
-0.28732985258102417,
-0.2622467279434204,
-0.9328057169914246,
-0.28198063373565674,
0.22949691116809845,
-0.3102394640445709,
-0.5307018160820007,
0.09704875946044922,
-0.24264471232891083,
-0.12514302134513855,
-0.029868200421333313,
-1.180933952331543,
0.3848154842853546,
-0.29893210530281067,
0.38858601450920105,
0.20727264881134033,
0.17070919275283813,
0.05112472176551819,
-0.31825369596481323,
-0.00715500907972455,
0.006076772231608629,
-0.1540759652853012,
-0.012056116946041584,
-0.5693255066871643,
-0.2641463279724121,
-0.4537525177001953,
0.7870315909385681,
0.2831440567970276,
-0.6017313003540039,
-0.0004980697412975132,
-0.06027315929532051,
-0.28700894117355347,
-0.7247323989868164,
-0.00941164419054985,
0.48595964908599854,
0.8630542159080505,
0.5960820913314819,
-0.2561393976211548,
-0.6323946714401245,
-1.1622215509414673,
-0.36984822154045105,
-0.48684772849082947,
-0.16204583644866943,
0.22285990417003632,
0.7613423466682434,
-0.23555387556552887,
0.9096581935882568,
-0.4259623885154724,
-0.39812055230140686,
0.43471479415893555,
0.32980433106422424,
0.08513780683279037,
0.46946725249290466,
0.8721529245376587,
-0.796462893486023,
0.16105416417121887,
-0.10049907118082047,
-1.091208815574646,
-0.20282244682312012,
-0.007817873731255531,
0.15192915499210358,
0.4289441704750061,
0.1190924346446991,
-0.7748109698295593,
0.9074303507804871,
0.15414959192276,
-0.4484245479106903,
0.6802511215209961,
-0.5557639002799988,
0.1572556346654892,
-0.4328814148902893,
0.05052882432937622,
0.13324737548828125,
-0.3047654330730438,
-0.40129223465919495,
-0.1782786101102829,
0.0066461036913096905,
0.4507196843624115,
-0.17469452321529388,
0.3433397114276886,
-0.5510886907577515,
-0.03847586736083031,
-0.26591336727142334,
-0.06690318137407303,
0.0661400705575943,
0.09158370643854141,
0.09624622762203217,
0.4471457600593567,
0.5276182293891907,
-0.7436891198158264,
0.11013354361057281,
0.5878481268882751,
-0.11700840294361115,
0.8674806356430054,
-0.6849202513694763,
-0.10276740789413452,
-0.12196740508079529,
0.20268326997756958,
-0.7660566568374634,
-0.46621763706207275,
0.20967154204845428,
-0.652040421962738,
0.2729029059410095,
-0.19587132334709167,
-0.5404577851295471,
-0.27486011385917664,
-0.0260999146848917,
0.14437782764434814,
0.15924936532974243,
-0.6289969086647034,
0.5632675886154175,
0.6064074635505676,
0.0505761057138443,
-0.6637572646141052,
-0.841941237449646,
0.261710524559021,
0.004304082132875919,
-0.3852716088294983,
0.5329450368881226,
0.20774772763252258,
-0.4183637201786041,
0.2652018964290619,
-0.4062364101409912,
-0.34115394949913025,
0.16274063289165497,
0.6652756929397583,
0.4590965509414673,
-0.13391095399856567,
0.39548829197883606,
0.1550171673297882,
-0.20890478789806366,
0.5630424618721008,
0.030232269316911697,
-0.4481865167617798,
-0.029515689238905907,
-0.5611597299575806,
-0.22749768197536469,
0.304166704416275,
0.5351093411445618,
-0.08588479459285736,
0.6155336499214172,
0.2530513107776642,
-0.8829586505889893,
0.465317964553833,
-0.8154575824737549,
-0.25234225392341614,
-0.2894055247306824,
0.04530123993754387,
-0.13450419902801514,
-0.9617576599121094,
0.6746158003807068,
-0.06307896226644516,
0.32157596945762634,
0.7400175929069519,
0.30719247460365295,
-0.20075581967830658,
0.6759732365608215,
0.3542119264602661,
0.4533928334712982,
-0.3548659682273865,
-0.0292777381837368,
0.03938829153776169,
-0.6851102113723755,
-0.3808465898036957,
-0.6883245706558228,
0.10738726705312729,
-0.87981778383255,
0.0064509278163313866,
0.44639745354652405,
-0.12747925519943237,
-0.18564164638519287,
0.3053228557109833,
-0.523464024066925,
0.19878478348255157,
0.49311286211013794,
0.5204980373382568,
0.6317479014396667,
-0.14707203209400177,
-0.06392570585012436,
-0.17100809514522552,
-0.5256290435791016,
-0.47236189246177673,
1.112203598022461,
0.32122576236724854,
0.27053767442703247,
0.1702103614807129,
0.6631341576576233,
0.3783004581928253,
0.7272706031799316,
-0.49066004157066345,
0.31975817680358887,
0.12453919649124146,
-1.3108285665512085,
-0.06731701642274857,
-0.38307181000709534,
-0.8885733485221863,
0.05121658369898796,
-0.7865068912506104,
-0.9563907980918884,
0.523015558719635,
0.23990708589553833,
-0.4353949725627899,
0.2790554165840149,
-0.4406449496746063,
0.3604488968849182,
-0.3432691991329193,
-0.412806898355484,
-0.07521530985832214,
-0.9270838499069214,
0.29871121048927307,
-0.10721886157989502,
0.016787132248282433,
-0.1432768553495407,
0.030123047530651093,
0.7545315027236938,
-0.7606161832809448,
0.6554015874862671,
-0.23886731266975403,
0.07864999026060104,
0.2867829203605652,
0.04789526388049126,
0.15017899870872498,
0.4892623722553253,
0.029749425128102303,
0.35568252205848694,
0.4123287796974182,
-0.5498260855674744,
-0.4889557957649231,
0.2990361750125885,
-0.41031137108802795,
-0.757710874080658,
-0.6078594923019409,
-0.14416876435279846,
-0.24421869218349457,
0.2567238211631775,
0.3991555869579315,
0.3203924298286438,
-0.23141224682331085,
0.3685009777545929,
0.7765645980834961,
-0.17071974277496338,
0.14235736429691315,
0.8365620970726013,
-0.09043733775615692,
-0.4260113835334778,
0.7390387654304504,
0.5609054565429688,
-0.06941727548837662,
0.2813278138637543,
0.03676404803991318,
-0.41033920645713806,
-0.5388195514678955,
-0.41117149591445923,
0.43461906909942627,
-0.5748180150985718,
-0.3369997441768646,
-0.8484835028648376,
-0.11861636489629745,
-0.2486787587404251,
0.18526025116443634,
-0.3868561089038849,
-0.5002407431602478,
0.010625128634274006,
-0.4336751401424408,
0.5931767821311951,
0.6914893388748169,
-0.4181167781352997,
-0.13663987815380096,
-0.6277658939361572,
0.3992862403392792,
0.1688927859067917,
0.2449321448802948,
-0.5935061573982239,
-0.31471773982048035,
-0.21774446964263916,
0.02580614760518074,
0.057377852499485016,
-0.8952882289886475,
-0.23736250400543213,
-0.10077918320894241,
0.5100170373916626,
0.5892238616943359,
0.19675254821777344,
0.425776869058609,
-0.342041552066803,
0.49213507771492004,
0.025682760402560234,
-0.6958361864089966,
0.4141863286495209,
0.032968051731586456,
-0.5252737998962402,
0.6908006072044373,
0.5079442262649536,
0.03921173885464668,
-0.2401273399591446,
-1.1055330038070679,
-0.6125032305717468,
0.26177218556404114,
0.3234200179576874,
-0.27392464876174927,
-0.03152613714337349,
0.7383654713630676,
0.1366407722234726,
0.1309448778629303,
-0.26572003960609436,
-0.5984554886817932,
-0.11673738807439804,
0.2532915472984314,
0.3266519010066986,
-0.5424678325653076,
-0.41367894411087036,
-0.2643824517726898,
0.5011378526687622,
-0.08811464160680771,
0.26038631796836853,
0.6955504417419434,
-0.04109920188784599,
-0.06353851407766342,
0.22130781412124634,
0.5921423435211182,
0.8278365731239319,
-0.28951728343963623,
0.3601328432559967,
0.1560400128364563,
-0.48058468103408813,
0.2217971384525299,
0.5253726243972778,
-0.33803874254226685,
0.5373432040214539,
0.6307149529457092,
0.44001635909080505,
0.2665366232395172,
-0.47373804450035095,
0.5672131180763245,
-0.06297795474529266,
-0.32687437534332275,
-0.42657750844955444,
-0.178410604596138,
-0.019713884219527245,
0.14234411716461182,
0.5437424182891846,
0.17325055599212646,
0.2744510769844055,
-0.30264732241630554,
0.2682824730873108,
0.4351922273635864,
-0.21496163308620453,
-0.4318140745162964,
0.8677470088005066,
0.011076242662966251,
-0.022778140380978584,
0.4387231171131134,
0.022069714963436127,
-0.17758283019065857,
0.565186619758606,
0.27457374334335327,
0.4414480924606323,
-0.03548946976661682,
0.31693753600120544,
0.40374764800071716,
0.3179183304309845,
-0.08994384855031967,
-0.04225130379199982,
-0.01236097700893879,
-0.6004651784896851,
-0.5176111459732056,
-0.20599393546581268,
-0.7317955493927002,
-0.005722502246499062,
-0.6254336833953857,
0.009277043864130974,
-0.308109849691391,
-0.5541746616363525,
0.7164881229400635,
0.08880524337291718,
-0.5953537821769714,
0.2781337797641754,
-0.1341506391763687,
0.7384042739868164,
-0.866395115852356,
0.46289288997650146,
0.9333046674728394,
-0.8788423538208008,
-0.5205076932907104,
-0.31121811270713806,
0.21143274009227753,
-0.9115836024284363,
0.8136844635009766,
-0.03955718129873276,
0.11264995485544205,
-0.474556565284729,
-0.8910887837409973,
-0.571016252040863,
0.8286499977111816,
0.7071904540061951,
-0.10120612382888794,
-0.020399881526827812,
0.08355063945055008,
0.5551838874816895,
-0.36194056272506714,
0.28648221492767334,
0.18601933121681213,
0.503312885761261,
0.17506816983222961,
-0.8188400268554688,
0.45440107583999634,
0.024017563089728355,
-0.2654736340045929,
-0.129189133644104,
-0.23542149364948273,
0.4438585340976715,
-0.7472345232963562,
-0.11020943522453308,
-0.026973232626914978,
0.9067755341529846,
0.45543646812438965,
0.8027586936950684,
0.38007494807243347,
0.4787405729293823,
1.0326119661331177,
-0.217240110039711,
1.0494384765625,
-0.2530169188976288,
0.4096238911151886,
0.9682332277297974,
-0.24662084877490997,
0.441354900598526,
0.5450199246406555,
-0.2461734265089035,
0.5286327004432678,
0.6120861768722534,
-0.09735536575317383,
0.11644157022237778,
0.28393736481666565,
-0.27112528681755066,
-0.3517756462097168,
-0.6035231351852417,
-0.38535523414611816,
0.3414798974990845,
0.47486841678619385,
-0.5930917859077454,
-0.15079353749752045,
-0.07740037143230438,
0.48095205426216125,
-0.05135234445333481,
-0.0024684995878487825,
0.6632304787635803,
0.052406687289476395,
-0.5902639031410217,
0.36877021193504333,
-0.3534209728240967,
0.15340813994407654,
-0.3174111843109131,
-0.32863685488700867,
-0.054496362805366516,
-0.044585805386304855,
-0.7034539580345154,
-0.6885519027709961,
0.28914928436279297,
-0.1265728622674942,
-0.37454289197921753,
0.2236897349357605,
0.9630071520805359,
-0.1795434206724167,
-0.14374390244483948,
-0.07836354523897171,
0.5861560106277466,
0.2798183560371399,
-0.09370368719100952,
-0.3536991775035858,
-0.1998671442270279,
-0.22294332087039948,
-0.1831965148448944,
0.19855667650699615,
0.7968103289604187,
-0.06842417269945145,
0.6067251563072205,
0.5577670931816101,
0.2890527844429016,
-0.436940997838974,
-0.35274264216423035,
0.6450615525245667,
-0.4943017065525055,
0.20646056532859802,
-0.6900389790534973,
0.33365029096603394,
-0.22695723176002502,
-0.15952585637569427,
0.5557125806808472,
0.5515801310539246,
0.5014469027519226,
0.021751057356595993,
0.7182974219322205,
-0.24371789395809174,
0.6231988668441772,
-0.47378215193748474,
0.8299717903137207,
-0.47234073281288147,
0.014554117806255817,
-0.13382664322853088,
-0.28597012162208557,
-0.4919047951698303,
0.32928305864334106,
-0.1034359410405159,
-0.02214994840323925,
0.8190407156944275,
0.39697209000587463,
0.09585212916135788,
0.22857414186000824,
0.09879042208194733,
0.38489586114883423,
0.1849554032087326,
0.3394635021686554,
0.5965250730514526,
-0.3495098054409027,
0.1439952403306961,
-0.3006470799446106,
-0.4125129282474518,
-0.2555961012840271,
-0.9851423501968384,
-0.9332976937294006,
-0.51755291223526,
-0.8767886757850647,
-0.9043281078338623,
-0.021493392065167427,
0.7438820004463196,
0.7188340425491333,
-0.728689968585968,
0.4955998659133911,
0.11622320860624313,
0.2480390965938568,
-0.3024137020111084,
-0.08284381777048111,
0.5588585138320923,
-0.05002732202410698,
-0.12735727429389954,
0.07560446858406067,
0.26051121950149536,
0.07489484548568726,
-0.09111212193965912,
0.19126072525978088,
-0.24868009984493256,
-0.021562771871685982,
0.31875312328338623,
0.9396059513092041,
-0.7088508009910583,
-0.3241563141345978,
-0.12595494091510773,
-0.08100990206003189,
0.2435317188501358,
0.834214448928833,
-0.8532816767692566,
0.3439783453941345,
0.125766322016716,
0.9785485863685608,
0.3260633051395416,
-0.1496058702468872,
0.20277470350265503,
-0.5384570956230164,
-0.26661086082458496,
0.07871729880571365,
0.8137006759643555,
0.2937634289264679,
-0.558280348777771,
0.8645593523979187,
0.6900224685668945,
-0.7267533540725708,
-0.9222396016120911,
0.008177545852959156,
-0.9628944396972656,
-0.014885627664625645,
0.7378617525100708,
-0.34216445684432983,
-0.43801769614219666,
-0.3252604901790619,
-0.181688129901886,
0.1442098766565323,
-0.14650419354438782,
0.9301274418830872,
0.5849764943122864,
-0.5003469586372375,
0.21363896131515503,
-0.7306684851646423,
0.6044573783874512,
0.40456047654151917,
-0.543550431728363,
0.09487021714448929,
0.6305972337722778,
0.3883931040763855,
0.8442875742912292,
0.7360677123069763,
-0.2917599380016327,
0.3733903765678406,
-0.16011527180671692,
0.004389047157019377,
-0.29989323019981384,
-0.036921169608831406,
0.045184843242168427,
0.20686165988445282,
0.09547629952430725,
-0.26026681065559387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01352v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01352v1 | Describing Images $\textit{Fast and Slow}$: Quantifying and Predicting the Variation in Human Signals during Visuo-Linguistic Processes | 2024-02-02T12:11:16 | 2024-02-02T12:11:16 | Ece Takmaz, Sandro Pezzelle, Raquel Fernández | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | There is an intricate relation between the properties of an image and how
humans behave while describing the image. This behavior shows ample variation,
as manifested in human signals such as eye movements and when humans start to
describe the image. Despite the value of such signals of visuo-linguistic
variation, they are virtually disregarded in the training of current pretrained
models, which motivates further investigation. Using a corpus of Dutch image
descriptions with concurrently collected eye-tracking data, we explore the
nature of the variation in visuo-linguistic signals, and find that they
correlate with each other. Given this result, we hypothesize that variation
stems partly from the properties of the images, and explore whether image
representations encoded by pretrained vision encoders can capture such
variation. Our results indicate that pretrained models do so to a
weak-to-moderate degree, suggesting that the models lack biases about what
makes a stimulus complex for humans and what leads to variations in human
outputs. | [
-0.6376911401748657,
-0.6264029741287231,
0.34274178743362427,
0.007442670874297619,
-0.39168888330459595,
-0.1808284968137741,
-0.27200666069984436,
-1.0319267511367798,
0.4222669303417206,
0.24466688930988312,
-0.5032607913017273,
0.11743734776973724,
-0.895191490650177,
0.09780988842248917,
-0.4298087954521179,
0.48149383068084717,
-0.2296970784664154,
0.3499418795108795,
0.052417222410440445,
-0.1773523986339569,
-0.2456989735364914,
-0.21140925586223602,
-0.20944125950336456,
-0.3428114950656891,
0.65479576587677,
0.17827829718589783,
1.0579724311828613,
0.7078078985214233,
0.6295203566551208,
0.31558749079704285,
-0.05981089919805527,
-0.4315725564956665,
-0.5112206935882568,
0.099745973944664,
0.16404950618743896,
-0.886093020439148,
0.03493524715304375,
0.07796618342399597,
0.4998026192188263,
0.8829277157783508,
0.14010579884052277,
-0.008943403139710426,
0.0882580429315567,
0.6746518611907959,
-0.6960330009460449,
0.039120547473430634,
-0.36031052470207214,
0.2562211751937866,
-0.41818493604660034,
-0.4550907015800476,
0.01428287010639906,
-0.13383270800113678,
0.5783013701438904,
-0.7115132808685303,
0.6303863525390625,
0.08790241926908493,
1.3713027238845825,
0.155667245388031,
-0.3367820084095001,
-0.2503642439842224,
-0.927396833896637,
0.6953319907188416,
-0.4508494734764099,
0.3022148013114929,
0.4233633577823639,
0.40812948346138,
-0.014852729625999928,
-0.6302061676979065,
-0.5915623903274536,
-0.38610315322875977,
-0.24326854944229126,
-0.10706780850887299,
0.19746971130371094,
0.05980241671204567,
0.47686830163002014,
0.38101550936698914,
-0.3486989736557007,
0.20988576114177704,
-0.4583980143070221,
-0.3279588222503662,
0.5835590958595276,
0.4081508219242096,
0.23589949309825897,
0.26775410771369934,
-0.42275458574295044,
-0.3187893033027649,
-0.3148849904537201,
0.294394314289093,
0.6140961647033691,
-0.29943007230758667,
-0.25901490449905396,
0.5992000699043274,
-0.30608341097831726,
0.7416368722915649,
0.23230306804180145,
-0.04861525818705559,
0.42112693190574646,
-0.07206667214632034,
-0.09864622354507446,
-0.32964256405830383,
0.7860532402992249,
0.5636579990386963,
0.37465038895606995,
-0.08903790265321732,
-0.44897225499153137,
0.43535155057907104,
-0.07962501794099808,
-0.8749014735221863,
-0.1876128613948822,
-0.29039686918258667,
-0.7357417941093445,
-0.2888663709163666,
0.017867397516965866,
-0.9161465764045715,
-0.3774086833000183,
-0.5181058645248413,
0.40969011187553406,
-0.23659034073352814,
-0.22057361900806427,
0.4855100214481354,
-0.1849280744791031,
0.33527231216430664,
0.37869992852211,
-0.8959743976593018,
0.21804551780223846,
0.058686722069978714,
0.6228926777839661,
-0.16258499026298523,
-0.7099433541297913,
0.028998028486967087,
-0.14685580134391785,
-0.4586833119392395,
0.7684943675994873,
-0.5551856756210327,
-0.2810986042022705,
-0.0021731958258897066,
0.14806243777275085,
0.2103346586227417,
-0.4507834017276764,
0.047398075461387634,
-0.523852527141571,
0.07569118589162827,
-0.16579832136631012,
-0.38400888442993164,
-0.1585734337568283,
-0.14136558771133423,
-0.9499627947807312,
0.6371718645095825,
-0.08039405196905136,
-1.1435035467147827,
0.5880951285362244,
-0.44768303632736206,
-0.47447025775909424,
0.14074884355068207,
-0.2774871289730072,
-0.27119824290275574,
0.5501722097396851,
0.011936045251786709,
0.5374420285224915,
-0.3698754608631134,
-0.0666254460811615,
-0.27506372332572937,
-0.7722557187080383,
0.6825681328773499,
-0.3179410994052887,
0.6276869773864746,
0.3325812816619873,
-0.4063575863838196,
-0.03964044153690338,
-0.7271257638931274,
-0.141884446144104,
0.5034494400024414,
-0.2929896116256714,
-0.3305361866950989,
0.13464288413524628,
0.04414292052388191,
0.07268378883600235,
0.26693403720855713,
-0.4121295213699341,
0.028011716902256012,
-0.22032040357589722,
0.32530027627944946,
0.5084943771362305,
-0.13243360817432404,
0.47067517042160034,
-0.1327308714389801,
0.581406831741333,
0.4791387617588043,
0.4338791072368622,
-0.19494107365608215,
-0.4133579134941101,
-0.9062917828559875,
-0.01598888449370861,
0.0423111654818058,
0.4937925934791565,
-0.8435143828392029,
-0.16672907769680023,
-0.349376380443573,
-0.43361249566078186,
-0.6066417098045349,
0.06372983008623123,
0.30965203046798706,
0.32579392194747925,
0.22924862802028656,
-0.844566285610199,
-0.04506382346153259,
-1.0397645235061646,
-0.33365410566329956,
0.1229793056845665,
-0.19961653649806976,
0.3245406448841095,
0.3709776997566223,
-0.27133557200431824,
0.5514889359474182,
-0.507326602935791,
0.06337825208902359,
0.00297164567746222,
0.6310538649559021,
0.13622406125068665,
0.2922165095806122,
0.6261999607086182,
-0.9356163144111633,
-0.4216651916503906,
-0.40478822588920593,
-0.60491943359375,
0.2077743113040924,
-0.04732245206832886,
-0.2069462090730667,
-0.1551753729581833,
0.4851388931274414,
-0.5046307444572449,
0.7936070561408997,
0.04868896305561066,
-0.3495665192604065,
0.659888505935669,
-0.2603510320186615,
0.2378411591053009,
-0.559974193572998,
-0.1828507035970688,
0.07768844813108444,
0.00290757417678833,
-0.4029788076877594,
-0.06829424947500229,
-0.16381995379924774,
-0.00670747272670269,
-0.749271810054779,
0.23415063321590424,
-0.796862781047821,
-0.1422838270664215,
-0.21548515558242798,
-0.36425119638442993,
-0.05053240805864334,
0.5872311592102051,
0.3926146626472473,
0.5091441869735718,
1.3126494884490967,
-0.7585253715515137,
0.453290194272995,
-0.06927964836359024,
-0.6836988925933838,
0.649307131767273,
-0.7424623966217041,
0.11467872560024261,
-0.5226280093193054,
-0.1018151268362999,
-0.6008333563804626,
-0.4804762601852417,
-0.02061745524406433,
-0.2812899053096771,
0.422945111989975,
0.03339613974094391,
-0.38776424527168274,
-0.6090236306190491,
-0.1487918198108673,
0.588219404220581,
0.6813872456550598,
-0.2694108486175537,
0.5825042724609375,
0.24890577793121338,
0.29519161581993103,
-0.66379314661026,
-0.8737936019897461,
-0.18784154951572418,
-0.2976270616054535,
-0.4399797022342682,
0.12153902649879456,
-0.04572204872965813,
-0.05787372589111328,
-0.013450238853693008,
0.10682416707277298,
-0.4465181529521942,
0.022026870399713516,
0.2966002821922302,
0.17381878197193146,
-0.2972463369369507,
0.041981011629104614,
-0.5272682309150696,
0.07231701165437698,
0.06813424825668335,
-0.25357726216316223,
0.22388878464698792,
-0.06418906152248383,
-0.03450474888086319,
-0.5652124881744385,
0.41846492886543274,
0.6496430039405823,
-0.02670590579509735,
0.2810511589050293,
0.8656784296035767,
-0.11570676416158676,
0.277161568403244,
-0.308642715215683,
-0.3937060236930847,
-0.5065210461616516,
0.35502195358276367,
-0.4622337818145752,
-0.5563502907752991,
0.5370224118232727,
-0.05818445235490799,
-0.3670700490474701,
0.21019592881202698,
0.6420479416847229,
-0.4262162744998932,
0.9250676035881042,
1.0654340982437134,
0.3651229739189148,
0.8438423871994019,
-0.2955854833126068,
-0.08070209622383118,
-0.4628344476222992,
-0.15073060989379883,
-0.2696664035320282,
-0.7052825689315796,
-0.9274355173110962,
-0.19658203423023224,
0.107222780585289,
0.014024983160197735,
0.019510243088006973,
0.07345636934041977,
-0.5083828568458557,
0.7057904601097107,
0.7003880739212036,
0.20155024528503418,
-0.255190372467041,
-0.03158584609627724,
-0.061679791659116745,
-0.14664478600025177,
-0.5915688276290894,
-0.19155555963516235,
1.1762992143630981,
0.04211745411157608,
1.4550532102584839,
-0.3704756796360016,
0.381451278924942,
0.148537740111351,
0.042184218764305115,
-0.7040378451347351,
0.6892088651657104,
-0.1191001906991005,
-0.523637056350708,
-0.14221450686454773,
-0.29571184515953064,
-1.1379163265228271,
-0.03578602895140648,
-0.4504110813140869,
-0.5930840969085693,
0.5399858355522156,
0.5119822025299072,
-0.15927280485630035,
0.14331123232841492,
-0.6163843274116516,
0.8076915144920349,
-0.7480997443199158,
-0.6491029262542725,
-0.05921054258942604,
-1.2360273599624634,
0.3253101706504822,
0.10706105083227158,
0.07037118822336197,
-0.27899476885795593,
0.12084522098302841,
0.744318425655365,
-0.23223890364170074,
1.0369086265563965,
-0.22031547129154205,
0.2947887182235718,
0.45236775279045105,
0.14406494796276093,
0.14159898459911346,
-0.23093606531620026,
0.6164829134941101,
0.24909508228302002,
-0.06652513891458511,
-0.6754069328308105,
-0.3355494737625122,
0.39906415343284607,
-0.8455565571784973,
-0.3225805461406708,
-0.14431531727313995,
-0.40454161167144775,
0.014176834374666214,
0.04306473582983017,
1.0339775085449219,
0.2615712285041809,
-0.1384967714548111,
-0.05671127885580063,
0.6563538908958435,
-0.29485490918159485,
0.48748525977134705,
0.3350827097892761,
-0.1561543047428131,
0.051702503114938736,
0.6725707054138184,
0.09194153547286987,
0.22076551616191864,
0.48991021513938904,
0.21433797478675842,
0.018316147848963737,
-0.1206698790192604,
-0.08394595980644226,
0.10969779640436172,
-0.9200441837310791,
0.12252291291952133,
-0.28961119055747986,
0.40725451707839966,
-0.022874318063259125,
-0.1940288245677948,
-0.31744810938835144,
-0.32443609833717346,
-0.4489830434322357,
0.05008701607584953,
0.20516875386238098,
0.7478249669075012,
0.12605777382850647,
0.493369460105896,
-0.43920353055000305,
0.610064685344696,
0.7503942251205444,
0.40985071659088135,
-0.05787889286875725,
-0.36643654108047485,
-0.6517423987388611,
0.009488021954894066,
-0.16450601816177368,
-1.0398880243301392,
0.32388097047805786,
0.38479137420654297,
0.383259117603302,
0.6270541548728943,
-0.2701866030693054,
0.6397280693054199,
-0.5222319960594177,
0.9617096781730652,
0.5800706744194031,
-0.756578803062439,
0.5493030548095703,
-0.015929564833641052,
0.3394133746623993,
0.29035890102386475,
0.6065349578857422,
-0.047386400401592255,
-0.42829325795173645,
-0.5420241951942444,
-0.8315563797950745,
0.3382019102573395,
-0.0972321629524231,
0.24935683608055115,
0.19413448870182037,
0.31443992257118225,
0.2439190000295639,
0.11350461095571518,
-0.6804116368293762,
-0.19079981744289398,
-0.6579686999320984,
-0.06719207018613815,
-0.1249433383345604,
-0.342742383480072,
-0.16585299372673035,
-0.3545520305633545,
-0.10995647311210632,
-0.07012266665697098,
0.6971039175987244,
0.18150930106639862,
-0.39163216948509216,
-0.29662415385246277,
0.03178950026631355,
0.600335955619812,
0.49669599533081055,
-0.07277234643697739,
0.4087873101234436,
-0.2735249996185303,
-0.694713294506073,
0.2515190541744232,
-0.10595722496509552,
-0.2581879496574402,
0.4037204086780548,
0.43208491802215576,
1.2942899465560913,
0.07622059434652328,
-0.6740494966506958,
0.5952582955360413,
-0.21578843891620636,
-0.08030756562948227,
-0.20493321120738983,
0.15726880729198456,
-0.18286935985088348,
0.14276300370693207,
0.13497619330883026,
0.444656103849411,
0.30875322222709656,
-0.37860342860221863,
-0.219707190990448,
0.18744446337223053,
-0.4015425443649292,
-0.8639764785766602,
0.8917595148086548,
0.12185615301132202,
-0.15772540867328644,
0.6844436526298523,
0.04460780695080757,
-0.35083192586898804,
0.8271795511245728,
0.05723614618182182,
1.0848419666290283,
0.008706551045179367,
-0.10616519302129745,
0.09594032168388367,
0.21068093180656433,
-0.24653950333595276,
0.5255366563796997,
-0.24386794865131378,
-0.8564601540565491,
-0.2906268835067749,
-0.5755918622016907,
-0.17822758853435516,
-0.07214909046888351,
-0.9457313418388367,
0.3391247093677521,
0.06251495331525803,
-0.5691065788269043,
0.21602895855903625,
-0.5888972282409668,
-1.4790756702423096,
0.3253442943096161,
0.47480958700180054,
0.66929692029953,
-0.9536895751953125,
0.8287583589553833,
0.7281965017318726,
-0.49173521995544434,
-0.7024776339530945,
0.17374412715435028,
-0.3119606673717499,
-0.655696451663971,
1.0155082941055298,
0.3523135185241699,
-0.2425149381160736,
-0.279175341129303,
-1.1339242458343506,
-0.6755674481391907,
0.7904812693595886,
0.4623289406299591,
-0.6207651495933533,
0.06686471402645111,
0.05265800654888153,
0.5906403660774231,
-0.32729098200798035,
0.13742128014564514,
0.4328881502151489,
0.3318184018135071,
0.07261405140161514,
-0.908509373664856,
-0.2937154173851013,
-0.24542520940303802,
0.33120429515838623,
-0.08500984311103821,
-0.39435023069381714,
1.1065809726715088,
-0.751366913318634,
-0.38735657930374146,
0.01384830754250288,
0.3985774517059326,
-0.41785144805908203,
0.23233911395072937,
0.3618740439414978,
0.4396865665912628,
0.3550369441509247,
-0.17464251816272736,
1.2557402849197388,
-0.4452666640281677,
0.27901285886764526,
0.8605872392654419,
-0.13937515020370483,
0.5941392779350281,
0.754758894443512,
-0.07389148324728012,
0.43509674072265625,
0.7379673719406128,
0.011800047010183334,
0.6436206698417664,
0.1822461038827896,
-0.014495418407022953,
-0.28005823493003845,
0.13640141487121582,
-0.19813482463359833,
0.4273170530796051,
0.3495918810367584,
-0.458922415971756,
0.2929671108722687,
0.44599398970603943,
-0.4945274889469147,
-0.2985430359840393,
-0.36994069814682007,
0.660840630531311,
0.01462526060640812,
-0.547077476978302,
0.903022289276123,
-0.3986094295978546,
0.9090691208839417,
-0.5623124241828918,
0.19513222575187683,
-0.13751713931560516,
-0.04063163697719574,
0.04434714466333389,
-0.8722312450408936,
0.022337373346090317,
-0.31246164441108704,
-0.2265956848859787,
-0.23040392994880676,
0.5793208479881287,
-0.3471754789352417,
-0.19339965283870697,
0.35729527473449707,
0.37764424085617065,
0.4391098916530609,
0.36967775225639343,
-0.5913808345794678,
0.07521425187587738,
-0.2201041430234909,
-0.5717456340789795,
0.09525876492261887,
0.6339308619499207,
-0.10161913931369781,
0.6062461137771606,
0.2809239327907562,
0.30229881405830383,
0.6915019154548645,
0.006049409043043852,
0.5737993717193604,
-0.761113703250885,
-0.5611380934715271,
-0.5265730023384094,
0.28665947914123535,
0.1479918360710144,
-0.43359214067459106,
0.18967005610466003,
0.23081323504447937,
1.011907935142517,
-0.7897043228149414,
0.4770125448703766,
-0.017762785777449608,
0.12070253491401672,
-0.6256855130195618,
0.3365686535835266,
-0.5683903098106384,
-0.06291189789772034,
0.21638232469558716,
-0.9293811917304993,
-0.09035869687795639,
0.5896356701850891,
-0.05912156403064728,
-0.16565263271331787,
0.8090881705284119,
0.6691917181015015,
-0.1404719203710556,
-0.30763334035873413,
0.4647826850414276,
0.4436766803264618,
-0.22717861831188202,
0.4676581919193268,
0.9968032836914062,
-0.037033844739198685,
0.4185059368610382,
-0.3393617570400238,
-0.06951454281806946,
-0.40615299344062805,
-0.6956812739372253,
-0.6059738397598267,
-0.5529441237449646,
-0.44693291187286377,
-0.16747649013996124,
-0.07069960236549377,
0.3501022756099701,
0.952355682849884,
-0.587395966053009,
-0.40376320481300354,
-0.13097810745239258,
-0.26612406969070435,
-0.5219171047210693,
-0.2180681824684143,
0.11754798144102097,
-0.18805833160877228,
-0.6718431711196899,
-0.07492458075284958,
0.22637124359607697,
0.8365857005119324,
-0.4795279800891876,
-0.15559151768684387,
0.3068248927593231,
0.27895110845565796,
0.25104573369026184,
0.43944886326789856,
-0.7919560074806213,
0.035429272800683975,
0.005884187296032906,
-0.33137041330337524,
0.22114555537700653,
1.0461457967758179,
-0.7705944776535034,
0.7543155550956726,
0.6026821136474609,
0.015229628421366215,
0.7742642760276794,
-0.5350936055183411,
0.3928104639053345,
-0.6115338802337646,
0.8433665633201599,
0.20526368916034698,
0.6056950688362122,
0.5518248677253723,
-0.16620896756649017,
0.2799408733844757,
0.5517312288284302,
-0.30250194668769836,
-0.5245287418365479,
0.5590184926986694,
-0.965773344039917,
-0.29987019300460815,
0.7720410227775574,
-0.33147183060646057,
-0.5638601183891296,
0.10103844851255417,
0.04096745327115059,
0.12302851676940918,
0.03160843998193741,
0.8472974896430969,
0.660557746887207,
-0.27294814586639404,
-0.10878372937440872,
-0.6147981286048889,
0.5398054718971252,
0.22604580223560333,
-0.3656095564365387,
-0.2968115508556366,
0.672119677066803,
0.4401668906211853,
0.1795855015516281,
0.5578231811523438,
-0.07157722115516663,
0.4701995253562927,
0.1653018742799759,
0.24993441998958588,
0.3154708743095398,
-0.22859805822372437,
-0.11815936863422394,
0.11236818134784698,
0.128815695643425,
-0.5569027066230774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01349v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01349v2 | Beyond the Answers: Reviewing the Rationality of Multiple Choice Question Answering for the Evaluation of Large Language Models | 2024-02-02T12:07:00 | 2024-05-30T01:57:14 | Haochun Wang, Sendong Zhao, Zewen Qiang, Nuwa Xi, Bing Qin, Ting Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the field of natural language processing (NLP), Large Language Models
(LLMs) have precipitated a paradigm shift, markedly enhancing performance in
natural language generation tasks. Despite these advancements, the
comprehensive evaluation of LLMs remains an inevitable challenge for the
community. Recently, the utilization of Multiple Choice Question Answering
(MCQA) as a benchmark for LLMs has gained considerable traction. This study
first investigates the limitations of MCQA as an evaluation method for LLMs and
then analyzes the fundamental reason for the limitations of MCQA, that while
LLMs may select the correct answers, it is possible that they also recognize
other wrong options as correct. Finally, we propose a dataset augmenting method
for Multiple-Choice Questions (MCQs), MCQA+, that can more accurately reflect
the performance of the model, which underscores the need for more robust
evaluation mechanisms in assessing the performance of LLMs. | [
-0.8307015299797058,
-0.7313053607940674,
0.8597763776779175,
-0.07755786180496216,
0.018470821902155876,
0.27216270565986633,
-0.21292980015277863,
-0.3601432740688324,
-0.2551635205745697,
0.7083064913749695,
-0.723762571811676,
0.021474698558449745,
-0.4445604383945465,
0.417946994304657,
-0.14634205400943756,
0.8042840957641602,
0.10093530267477036,
0.15844187140464783,
-0.6032001376152039,
-0.2741573452949524,
-0.3998224437236786,
-0.7551072239875793,
-0.7388007044792175,
-0.2778913080692291,
0.4599016606807709,
0.330287367105484,
0.8372334241867065,
0.430000901222229,
0.4612024426460266,
0.3213694095611572,
0.01980123110115528,
0.4182489514350891,
-0.28711259365081787,
0.173335000872612,
-0.21848809719085693,
-0.500508189201355,
-0.22343868017196655,
0.15040722489356995,
0.8468557000160217,
0.7787190675735474,
0.055834993720054626,
0.4812238812446594,
-0.21976016461849213,
0.7083675861358643,
-0.7021554112434387,
-0.37266895174980164,
-0.6986907124519348,
-0.08106593787670135,
-0.07600611448287964,
-0.22694115340709686,
-0.46693187952041626,
-0.5823875665664673,
0.13055449724197388,
-0.2858545780181885,
-0.08960697054862976,
0.053009744733572006,
0.44747185707092285,
0.1555490642786026,
-0.5919634103775024,
-0.46731704473495483,
-0.622432291507721,
1.1524308919906616,
-0.7846097350120544,
0.3764055371284485,
0.20428307354450226,
0.49049630761146545,
-0.15963344275951385,
-0.4989859461784363,
-0.7403132915496826,
-0.5697158575057983,
0.1681002974510193,
0.02084692195057869,
-0.02184857428073883,
0.008225361816585064,
0.5709275603294373,
0.4975496530532837,
-0.5376653671264648,
-0.024319084361195564,
-0.21741828322410583,
-0.05056607350707054,
0.6094459295272827,
0.3576500415802002,
0.2571958005428314,
-0.1705736666917801,
-0.3910422921180725,
0.009270714595913887,
-0.5933660864830017,
0.21430322527885437,
0.4082719385623932,
0.17584796249866486,
0.5325140357017517,
1.0984197854995728,
-0.3019232153892517,
0.7998917698860168,
-0.1934981495141983,
-0.11398018151521683,
0.21048466861248016,
-0.3595828115940094,
-0.37361422181129456,
-0.3212069571018219,
0.4566403329372406,
0.33159977197647095,
0.3128404915332794,
0.003826764179393649,
-0.0014355930034071207,
0.030938906595110893,
0.2584035396575928,
-0.6879963278770447,
0.2515200972557068,
0.6084871292114258,
-0.2091306447982788,
-0.07813388109207153,
-0.23501694202423096,
-0.4410676956176758,
-0.42429256439208984,
-0.5496823191642761,
0.27997204661369324,
-0.28557288646698,
-0.41925114393234253,
0.29795846343040466,
-0.27378949522972107,
0.3305104672908783,
0.2133171409368515,
-0.4940204620361328,
0.41211313009262085,
0.773654043674469,
0.5360534191131592,
-0.10155758261680603,
-0.26935580372810364,
-0.619541585445404,
-0.06360888481140137,
-0.4294678866863251,
0.8662549257278442,
-0.7537845969200134,
-0.3110629618167877,
-0.17288243770599365,
-0.21809600293636322,
-0.18757493793964386,
-0.5775930881500244,
0.8537183403968811,
-0.87735515832901,
0.20897825062274933,
-0.7624533772468567,
-0.772624135017395,
-0.3171378970146179,
0.5422248840332031,
-0.7568606734275818,
1.1049489974975586,
0.061909280717372894,
-0.6207630038261414,
0.29513898491859436,
-0.7183902859687805,
-0.07367052882909775,
0.015487056225538254,
-0.14085495471954346,
0.0006303321570158005,
0.15532927215099335,
0.35398373007774353,
0.31697583198547363,
-0.46699410676956177,
0.3252456486225128,
-0.6247752904891968,
-0.10101612657308578,
0.758263885974884,
-0.8564332127571106,
0.9842386245727539,
0.16021135449409485,
0.12320634722709656,
0.0047204336151480675,
-0.879299521446228,
0.404745876789093,
-0.08831348270177841,
-0.5543886423110962,
-0.03355924412608147,
-0.10915666073560715,
-0.26756301522254944,
0.7010713815689087,
0.03292129933834076,
-0.5573543310165405,
-0.05259602144360542,
-0.38918161392211914,
0.3364157974720001,
0.6653245091438293,
-0.007041038945317268,
0.41884148120880127,
-0.7699368596076965,
0.831551730632782,
-0.3372431695461273,
0.06320951879024506,
-0.029708649963140488,
-0.5345472693443298,
-0.7835984230041504,
-0.08674187958240509,
0.2366134375333786,
0.4623626470565796,
-0.9052677154541016,
0.1510229855775833,
-0.18414545059204102,
-0.5654057860374451,
-0.6776655912399292,
0.09140019863843918,
0.2003384679555893,
0.5733522772789001,
0.4888773560523987,
0.06736584007740021,
-0.728868305683136,
-0.9909753203392029,
-0.41406580805778503,
-0.06497865170240402,
-0.163233682513237,
0.3885679543018341,
0.543283224105835,
-0.09633831679821014,
1.0424588918685913,
-0.34734606742858887,
0.4510510563850403,
-0.38311952352523804,
-0.14849010109901428,
0.2901836931705475,
0.328281968832016,
0.24196678400039673,
-0.6821672320365906,
-0.15821334719657898,
-0.20347997546195984,
-0.41400444507598877,
-0.15220382809638977,
-0.18424168229103088,
-0.061362601816654205,
0.10608723014593124,
0.27889764308929443,
-0.8786942958831787,
0.040837861597537994,
0.6730843782424927,
0.060852717608213425,
1.0591857433319092,
-0.0147765027359128,
0.23662954568862915,
-0.7527157068252563,
0.16484062373638153,
-0.16532310843467712,
-0.27279412746429443,
-0.5956228375434875,
0.29472097754478455,
-0.017402969300746918,
0.0568074956536293,
-0.4639292359352112,
0.6347686052322388,
-0.4228602349758148,
-0.1998300552368164,
-0.2603968381881714,
0.45570340752601624,
0.44954559206962585,
0.13631336390972137,
0.01598423160612583,
0.818503201007843,
0.3048267364501953,
-0.7134009599685669,
0.5295646786689758,
0.1337447315454483,
-0.38704270124435425,
0.46107158064842224,
-0.46740615367889404,
0.18332426249980927,
-0.36519286036491394,
0.41469964385032654,
-1.0923556089401245,
-0.10735592991113663,
0.07467131316661835,
-0.44112110137939453,
-0.022546693682670593,
0.059447288513183594,
-0.36427268385887146,
-0.4344205856323242,
-0.48949289321899414,
0.3734254837036133,
0.22210051119327545,
-0.5619479417800903,
0.5302718877792358,
0.3309582769870758,
-0.24602773785591125,
-0.7444580793380737,
-0.5851944088935852,
0.22362083196640015,
-0.24240288138389587,
-0.7528536319732666,
-0.12705057859420776,
-0.46891269087791443,
-0.5580378770828247,
-0.42499005794525146,
-0.049123525619506836,
0.0012530197855085135,
0.06863492727279663,
-0.21188753843307495,
0.2531036138534546,
-0.295430988073349,
0.46347275376319885,
0.10002335906028748,
-0.014664795249700546,
0.30443382263183594,
0.1776769757270813,
0.5975737571716309,
-0.25763246417045593,
-0.3578653931617737,
0.008838851936161518,
0.4457884728908539,
0.45936235785484314,
-0.2998695969581604,
0.6826808452606201,
0.4148409068584442,
-0.31250840425491333,
-0.09338272362947464,
-0.7715218663215637,
0.051709797233343124,
-0.45280328392982483,
0.36249446868896484,
-0.4760119318962097,
-0.9258964657783508,
0.37467923760414124,
0.0002862909168470651,
0.2111213207244873,
0.6625153422355652,
0.560195803642273,
-0.04473477974534035,
1.1782463788986206,
0.1725480705499649,
0.4450533390045166,
-0.07163835316896439,
0.033053506165742874,
0.07544118911027908,
-1.3461673259735107,
-0.11810752004384995,
-0.6782788634300232,
0.028503909707069397,
-0.49788421392440796,
-0.5366894602775574,
0.1388397067785263,
0.16213767230510712,
-0.3069516718387604,
0.06939104944467545,
-0.26795095205307007,
0.534855306148529,
0.28308215737342834,
0.034665223211050034,
0.5422327518463135,
-0.316882848739624,
-0.10899647325277328,
-0.13737556338310242,
-0.7813975811004639,
-0.9984877109527588,
1.325047492980957,
0.5083217620849609,
0.25102144479751587,
0.27680709958076477,
0.18000736832618713,
0.029826944693922997,
0.6652110815048218,
-0.7619782090187073,
0.5596330165863037,
0.17789329588413239,
-1.0076724290847778,
-0.4743872582912445,
-0.46536514163017273,
-0.6396211981773376,
0.6675082445144653,
-0.4252158999443054,
-0.5651035308837891,
0.000017700060197967105,
-0.06261816620826721,
-0.6533678770065308,
0.1995467245578766,
-0.6072785258293152,
0.4984220266342163,
-0.3852711617946625,
-0.21328604221343994,
-0.027450839057564735,
-0.5123547911643982,
0.7345088124275208,
-0.1922820657491684,
0.3361024856567383,
-0.09309058636426926,
-0.35865622758865356,
0.5946698188781738,
-0.23256869614124298,
0.32256853580474854,
0.10332196950912476,
-0.21713174879550934,
0.37133947014808655,
-0.20447158813476562,
0.2603468894958496,
0.43712401390075684,
-0.5464364290237427,
-0.21279366314411163,
0.1617921143770218,
-0.2637387216091156,
-0.6498821973800659,
0.7612152695655823,
-0.3142700791358948,
-0.7223081588745117,
-0.36815521121025085,
-0.623324453830719,
-0.746965765953064,
0.16098842024803162,
-0.003584872465580702,
0.5869130492210388,
-0.013242040760815144,
0.25396835803985596,
0.6783889532089233,
-0.5084052085876465,
0.4671897292137146,
0.22047016024589539,
-0.5457362532615662,
-0.5565895438194275,
0.5939152836799622,
0.2835972011089325,
0.48892056941986084,
0.19946499168872833,
0.33789190649986267,
-0.8505024909973145,
-0.6324813365936279,
-0.7388540506362915,
0.09795564413070679,
-0.9408391714096069,
0.035879794508218765,
-0.8350300788879395,
-0.214771568775177,
-0.3094092607498169,
0.011177384294569492,
-0.11770673841238022,
-0.5335736870765686,
-0.25332093238830566,
-0.1773528903722763,
-0.05332392081618309,
0.5038395524024963,
0.18888162076473236,
0.03487187251448631,
-0.9535717368125916,
0.42011916637420654,
0.548281192779541,
0.4558563828468323,
0.13807493448257446,
-0.4863138198852539,
0.06543023139238358,
0.3501495122909546,
-0.23940278589725494,
-0.7893060445785522,
0.01020733267068863,
-0.057719189673662186,
0.6929351091384888,
0.08997486531734467,
0.1043572947382927,
0.8020176291465759,
-0.47582513093948364,
0.8005999326705933,
0.0029678980354219675,
-0.8289830088615417,
0.08210932463407516,
-0.2985149919986725,
0.5200410485267639,
0.7124178409576416,
0.5321887135505676,
-0.3768061697483063,
-0.2944355607032776,
-0.654234766960144,
-0.6554093360900879,
0.4712570011615753,
0.3501933217048645,
0.23048827052116394,
-0.12381377071142197,
0.2525511384010315,
0.13567519187927246,
0.47289109230041504,
-0.8451757431030273,
-0.05905046686530113,
0.09302689880132675,
0.2417444884777069,
-0.19113893806934357,
-0.3301982283592224,
-0.05417638272047043,
-0.21214871108531952,
0.7991873621940613,
-0.07830128818750381,
-0.1199842020869255,
0.23743756115436554,
-0.1259191781282425,
-0.03330229967832565,
0.5923153758049011,
0.6921386122703552,
0.9974339604377747,
-0.1677151471376419,
-0.040506403893232346,
0.4970199167728424,
-0.04520857334136963,
-0.026738740503787994,
-0.053486306220293045,
0.0618320107460022,
-0.012689512223005295,
0.31405946612358093,
0.48520851135253906,
-0.1877998411655426,
-1.040360450744629,
0.3143976330757141,
-0.0826837569475174,
-0.14491333067417145,
-0.3000056743621826,
0.12713341414928436,
0.16470390558242798,
0.2145167589187622,
0.4061080813407898,
0.28296956419944763,
0.3518957197666168,
-0.7141535878181458,
0.1566934585571289,
0.692791223526001,
-0.2614178955554962,
0.2059272974729538,
0.31552281975746155,
-0.05160421133041382,
-0.29074960947036743,
0.41616788506507874,
0.0718521699309349,
-0.5043973326683044,
0.6666607856750488,
0.4150744378566742,
0.6128492951393127,
-0.07142550498247147,
0.26312223076820374,
0.4719412326812744,
0.5834419131278992,
-0.04495773836970329,
0.45033740997314453,
-0.042120106518268585,
-0.8028930425643921,
-0.8572903275489807,
-0.6086798310279846,
-0.4768540859222412,
0.3733716905117035,
-0.6194624304771423,
0.015800779685378075,
-0.445959210395813,
-0.4297623336315155,
0.02288954332470894,
0.1426945924758911,
-0.43627214431762695,
0.6432831287384033,
0.2381296455860138,
1.0837098360061646,
-0.45593681931495667,
0.4666450321674347,
0.4939729869365692,
-0.18348509073257446,
-0.5173569321632385,
-0.11619289964437485,
-0.23299375176429749,
-0.4548215866088867,
0.21443665027618408,
0.36447107791900635,
-0.20602837204933167,
-0.13263744115829468,
-0.5690682530403137,
-0.9008803963661194,
0.7308799624443054,
0.4416806101799011,
-0.44676434993743896,
0.1754237413406372,
0.4093919098377228,
0.6122256517410278,
-0.36892998218536377,
0.5506184697151184,
0.8307194709777832,
0.6809338331222534,
0.05075645446777344,
-0.715176522731781,
-0.007939736358821392,
-0.09325849264860153,
0.07206513732671738,
0.0701839029788971,
-0.4079757332801819,
0.750640869140625,
-0.2396763414144516,
-0.22801519930362701,
0.2096821665763855,
0.20269834995269775,
0.7196248173713684,
0.022698722779750824,
0.4023171663284302,
0.37668660283088684,
0.7573221921920776,
-0.01864968240261078,
1.2944769859313965,
0.1849181354045868,
0.28255537152290344,
1.255744218826294,
-0.33914077281951904,
0.9598541855812073,
0.6198974251747131,
-0.4371262192726135,
0.12716230750083923,
0.6515345573425293,
0.1383761465549469,
-0.07059979438781738,
0.5428152084350586,
-0.2769947946071625,
-0.6014144420623779,
-0.05561699718236923,
-0.38537946343421936,
0.33327236771583557,
0.34014472365379333,
-0.22129088640213013,
-0.2452433705329895,
-0.12315776944160461,
-0.15597906708717346,
0.15169940888881683,
-0.44309574365615845,
0.547839343547821,
0.003488476388156414,
-0.8793546557426453,
0.5010474324226379,
0.10125961899757385,
0.26485708355903625,
-0.461586058139801,
-0.052402742207050323,
0.14713920652866364,
-0.1750946044921875,
-0.26016202569007874,
-1.0171798467636108,
0.42177239060401917,
-0.004611076787114143,
-0.2528494894504547,
-0.07399266958236694,
0.5609084367752075,
-0.24331799149513245,
-0.7334611415863037,
0.06725741922855377,
0.610643744468689,
-0.11512114107608795,
-0.118282750248909,
-0.7931748032569885,
-0.0005681721959263086,
-0.1345696896314621,
-0.43747442960739136,
0.09346745163202286,
0.22601710259914398,
0.06991011649370193,
1.0053539276123047,
0.998801589012146,
-0.0345957949757576,
0.23012728989124298,
0.059123311191797256,
0.7666774392127991,
-0.4605221450328827,
-0.15676438808441162,
-0.9428930878639221,
0.6414007544517517,
-0.24725453555583954,
-0.5191981196403503,
0.9472259283065796,
0.6345881819725037,
0.6946869492530823,
0.039548855274915695,
0.9530931711196899,
0.11038918793201447,
0.8178000450134277,
-0.7090086340904236,
0.2685896158218384,
-0.4041772186756134,
0.5330658555030823,
-0.4158978760242462,
-0.9753870964050293,
-0.4356013834476471,
0.26023316383361816,
-0.5960433483123779,
0.2773241102695465,
0.6333951354026794,
0.6098089218139648,
0.2553349435329437,
0.19302698969841003,
0.4567393362522125,
-0.011220273561775684,
0.2901694178581238,
0.43016743659973145,
1.3622088432312012,
-0.41479724645614624,
0.6340183615684509,
-0.06560095399618149,
-0.07493170350790024,
0.181122288107872,
-0.903549313545227,
-0.9046823382377625,
-0.2826453745365143,
-0.028898950666189194,
-0.31456172466278076,
-0.35794347524642944,
0.9825066328048706,
0.3076637387275696,
-0.7354598045349121,
-0.1648092120885849,
0.08776659518480301,
0.17350909113883972,
-0.09380317479372025,
-0.22501401603221893,
0.12443919479846954,
-0.37848877906799316,
-0.6561876535415649,
0.406652569770813,
0.23255598545074463,
-0.16425825655460358,
-0.45010390877723694,
-0.06381744891405106,
-0.5217005610466003,
0.5464236736297607,
0.8776352405548096,
0.10474443435668945,
-0.6553254723548889,
-0.13499568402767181,
0.13916276395320892,
0.0830317959189415,
0.1721746176481247,
0.6231642961502075,
-0.6373224258422852,
0.4844602048397064,
0.45767995715141296,
0.9250417947769165,
0.03857509046792984,
0.21944084763526917,
0.6458009481430054,
-0.39981919527053833,
-0.40836063027381897,
0.47616201639175415,
0.23036371171474457,
0.43903154134750366,
-0.049752525985240936,
0.20502737164497375,
-0.2626924514770508,
-0.5744771361351013,
-0.9352059960365295,
0.4753663241863251,
-0.7473279237747192,
-0.32747581601142883,
1.2611230611801147,
0.22817985713481903,
0.1523095965385437,
-0.4905972182750702,
-0.5067764520645142,
-0.06662432849407196,
-0.11682293564081192,
0.4490290582180023,
1.0521844625473022,
-0.3012114465236664,
-0.33170294761657715,
-0.8839008212089539,
0.4998282790184021,
0.3719315230846405,
-0.9226282835006714,
0.041099634021520615,
0.7311692833900452,
0.1958409547805786,
0.19177162647247314,
0.633762001991272,
-0.14072804152965546,
0.30270352959632874,
-0.2080826312303543,
-0.4304867684841156,
0.06398481130599976,
-0.20631633698940277,
-0.4572329521179199,
0.42977145314216614,
0.32625627517700195,
0.13255628943443298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01345v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01345v6 | Skip \n: A Simple Method to Reduce Hallucination in Large Vision-Language Models | 2024-02-02T12:02:46 | 2024-05-08T02:15:45 | Zongbo Han, Zechen Bai, Haiyang Mei, Qianli Xu, Changqing Zhang, Mike Zheng Shou | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advancements in large vision-language models (LVLMs) have demonstrated
impressive capability in visual information understanding with human language.
Despite these advances, LVLMs still face challenges with multimodal
hallucination, such as generating text descriptions of objects that are not
present in the visual information. However, the underlying fundamental reasons
of multimodal hallucinations remain poorly explored. In this paper, we propose
a new perspective, suggesting that the inherent biases in LVLMs might be a key
factor in hallucinations. Specifically, we systematically identify a semantic
shift bias related to paragraph breaks (\n\n), where the content before and
after '\n\n' in the training data frequently exhibit significant semantic
changes. This pattern leads the model to infer that the contents following
'\n\n' should be obviously different from the preceding contents with less
hallucinatory descriptions, thereby increasing the probability of hallucinatory
descriptions subsequent to the '\n\n'. We have validated this hypothesis on
multiple publicly available LVLMs. Besides, we find that deliberately inserting
'\n\n' at the generated description can induce more hallucinations. A simple
method is proposed to effectively mitigate the hallucination of LVLMs by
skipping the output of '\n'. | [
-0.5153416395187378,
-0.8801535964012146,
0.7306823134422302,
0.346218466758728,
-0.364947646856308,
-0.43653979897499084,
-0.07692346721887589,
-0.6059238910675049,
0.3237292766571045,
0.8116388916969299,
-0.673980176448822,
-0.3072541058063507,
-0.49893006682395935,
0.17070792615413666,
-0.6731191277503967,
0.7387725710868835,
0.202697291970253,
0.36208978295326233,
-0.03729752451181412,
0.10632343590259552,
-0.5026465654373169,
-0.38166168332099915,
-0.5677306056022644,
-0.29318445920944214,
0.6923921704292297,
-0.13283811509609222,
0.7484973073005676,
0.6640113592147827,
0.5544238090515137,
0.19973737001419067,
-0.2684025764465332,
0.2577059864997864,
-0.525604248046875,
0.22932110726833344,
0.024215806275606155,
-0.24387836456298828,
-0.24956049025058746,
-0.3742428123950958,
0.584812581539154,
0.7761557698249817,
0.0010259029222652316,
-0.23062735795974731,
0.21142005920410156,
0.7455302476882935,
-0.7355131506919861,
-0.037698712199926376,
-0.629244327545166,
0.5040234923362732,
-0.10319644212722778,
-0.5510183572769165,
-0.8224856853485107,
-0.1558963507413864,
0.0977586880326271,
-0.5474900603294373,
0.4384039640426636,
0.09458229690790176,
0.7804628610610962,
0.5436651110649109,
-0.18651267886161804,
-0.12064851075410843,
-0.760275661945343,
0.6955174207687378,
-0.40451812744140625,
0.805860161781311,
0.3362433612346649,
0.08634781092405319,
-0.11349377781152725,
-0.645025908946991,
-0.7512065172195435,
-0.384835422039032,
-0.05464663356542587,
-0.20138709247112274,
0.2840467691421509,
0.121189184486866,
0.6110436916351318,
0.08724410086870193,
-0.4937210977077484,
-0.01403053104877472,
-0.606602132320404,
-0.47582295536994934,
0.3653837740421295,
0.4197728931903839,
0.20200063288211823,
-0.23635651171207428,
-0.37010928988456726,
-0.11884180456399918,
-0.582676887512207,
-0.35047611594200134,
0.12874175608158112,
0.09189838171005249,
0.30818048119544983,
0.7363264560699463,
-0.18246161937713623,
0.695243239402771,
-0.03670619800686836,
-0.3600476384162903,
0.4104224443435669,
-0.3803037703037262,
-0.294797420501709,
0.11060842126607895,
0.45308902859687805,
0.7996975779533386,
0.47726941108703613,
-0.21282526850700378,
-0.05323651060461998,
0.32658639550209045,
0.41990360617637634,
-0.8980419039726257,
-0.3922143578529358,
0.06576646119356155,
-0.9133487343788147,
-0.20262160897254944,
-0.1337900459766388,
-1.1972078084945679,
-0.9960016012191772,
-0.4563380479812622,
0.2321484088897705,
-0.6613215208053589,
0.0735003650188446,
0.27341553568840027,
-0.2372172772884369,
0.4374578297138214,
0.7121791243553162,
-0.764478325843811,
0.27339616417884827,
0.30804359912872314,
0.9267476201057434,
-0.31621915102005005,
-0.658748209476471,
-0.6718961000442505,
0.10550685971975327,
-0.29242879152297974,
0.7229371070861816,
-0.3622906804084778,
-0.2962043285369873,
0.17287509143352509,
0.08783263713121414,
0.12549705803394318,
-0.5583466291427612,
0.35020411014556885,
-0.21443898975849152,
0.25179049372673035,
-0.3425634205341339,
-0.4361553490161896,
-0.22332018613815308,
0.006308822426944971,
-0.8294411897659302,
0.6581168174743652,
-0.384624183177948,
-0.8704783916473389,
0.4661130905151367,
-0.29986798763275146,
-0.459888756275177,
-0.05320168659090996,
-0.1605667620897293,
-0.28011637926101685,
0.3481789529323578,
0.4347987174987793,
0.2652852237224579,
0.09746816009283066,
0.07432691752910614,
-0.18488122522830963,
-0.4631787836551666,
0.4326649606227875,
-0.5033983588218689,
0.6427710056304932,
0.1922881156206131,
-0.479769229888916,
0.2849602699279785,
-0.8848710060119629,
-0.24216942489147186,
0.1183064728975296,
-0.09705109149217606,
-0.4951884150505066,
0.3392745852470398,
0.2554026246070862,
0.18656080961227417,
0.01356712356209755,
-0.27806851267814636,
0.1024489626288414,
-0.27558040618896484,
-0.1432104855775833,
0.9550246000289917,
0.030161678791046143,
0.48337239027023315,
-0.1303284913301468,
0.14289718866348267,
0.11906991899013519,
0.40341320633888245,
-0.24413838982582092,
-0.40820786356925964,
-1.187411904335022,
-0.18945054709911346,
-0.24140995740890503,
0.5178515911102295,
-0.9813541769981384,
0.22597873210906982,
0.10809158533811569,
0.030410373583436012,
-0.631591260433197,
0.12506303191184998,
0.292839914560318,
0.42405492067337036,
0.7595569491386414,
-0.21442118287086487,
-0.6992896795272827,
-0.9122350811958313,
-0.16192087531089783,
0.10066305100917816,
-0.0025752331130206585,
-0.03093632310628891,
0.5186036229133606,
-0.3323519825935364,
0.5727627873420715,
-0.719028115272522,
-0.6511557102203369,
-0.246787890791893,
-0.10232184827327728,
-0.2275742143392563,
0.18363313376903534,
0.1806705743074417,
-0.9253581762313843,
-0.21097931265830994,
-0.16573479771614075,
-0.8589228987693787,
-0.08891758322715759,
-0.499297171831131,
-0.021122541278600693,
0.47022104263305664,
0.7376481294631958,
-0.7229448556900024,
0.8764992356300354,
0.11285057663917542,
-0.5703874826431274,
0.6142839789390564,
-0.13668471574783325,
-0.10507991164922714,
-0.819254994392395,
-0.3584767282009125,
-0.03739837929606438,
0.030294613912701607,
-0.6742225289344788,
0.022616200149059296,
-0.10629821568727493,
0.23789887130260468,
-0.4475845992565155,
0.4847896993160248,
-0.6166743636131287,
-0.01687443256378174,
-0.3368939757347107,
0.16936901211738586,
-0.047278329730033875,
0.4114345908164978,
0.3120794892311096,
0.22620345652103424,
0.7910662889480591,
-0.7865288853645325,
0.3187924921512604,
0.33078643679618835,
-0.3056843876838684,
0.40535059571266174,
-0.3711181879043579,
0.024508940055966377,
-0.49799907207489014,
0.27064818143844604,
-0.6574975848197937,
-0.15869785845279694,
0.4922536015510559,
-0.22207745909690857,
0.0414181612432003,
0.3657476007938385,
-0.38620683550834656,
-0.1366429328918457,
-0.4948295056819916,
0.2908114194869995,
0.5743415355682373,
-0.6894232034683228,
0.47095027565956116,
0.11611241847276688,
0.3046652674674988,
-0.6016311645507812,
-0.8933342099189758,
0.2563537657260895,
-0.2121117264032364,
-0.5038209557533264,
0.2594059109687805,
-0.42401087284088135,
-0.5342434048652649,
-0.094089575111866,
0.029202548786997795,
0.03585796058177948,
-0.1887272447347641,
0.1941177099943161,
0.3429053723812103,
-0.11771581321954727,
0.18668648600578308,
-0.1900574415922165,
0.02123483642935753,
0.16675503551959991,
-0.24792256951332092,
0.8266293406486511,
0.04525793343782425,
-0.25037217140197754,
-0.6242467761039734,
0.4109492301940918,
0.541289210319519,
-0.05139946565032005,
0.9237421751022339,
0.757895290851593,
-0.38611480593681335,
-0.2835575044155121,
-0.5882629752159119,
-0.5943679809570312,
-0.4131690561771393,
0.5897699594497681,
-0.3608744144439697,
-0.538020670413971,
0.436886727809906,
0.2985416054725647,
-0.3374617397785187,
0.2542891204357147,
0.6713453531265259,
0.1238640770316124,
0.978507399559021,
0.5353245139122009,
0.27100273966789246,
0.4335017502307892,
0.025966545566916466,
0.43240541219711304,
-0.9175407886505127,
-0.6677506566047668,
-0.24222122132778168,
-0.00526659470051527,
-0.4282335042953491,
-0.6325241327285767,
0.006278705317527056,
-0.10694514214992523,
0.2879396080970764,
-0.11273686587810516,
-0.7439894080162048,
0.5519006848335266,
0.1653817892074585,
0.24268744885921478,
0.27248960733413696,
0.15298298001289368,
0.055441077798604965,
-0.3145992159843445,
-0.4082319438457489,
-0.2546647787094116,
0.8414425253868103,
0.35465601086616516,
1.0759124755859375,
-0.09876871854066849,
0.6590989828109741,
0.34171223640441895,
-0.2568959593772888,
-0.7455682754516602,
0.9067147374153137,
0.07088915258646011,
-0.3057689368724823,
-0.49340569972991943,
-0.2905467450618744,
-0.6852957010269165,
0.6010162234306335,
-0.3639153838157654,
-0.979337215423584,
0.1964445859193802,
0.052308157086372375,
-0.14760445058345795,
0.27264758944511414,
-0.48877766728401184,
0.6230355501174927,
-0.1491898149251938,
-0.5338508486747742,
-0.12151391059160233,
-0.619793176651001,
0.5402788519859314,
0.08916826546192169,
0.17886006832122803,
0.18862786889076233,
0.056822363287210464,
0.7291314005851746,
-0.29543906450271606,
1.0258554220199585,
-0.19234758615493774,
-0.13165920972824097,
0.15097974240779877,
0.12199478596448898,
0.5319518446922302,
-0.09716643393039703,
0.4894655644893646,
0.0030564041808247566,
-0.4678252637386322,
-0.2474023550748825,
-0.4747031033039093,
0.6013370752334595,
-0.5231368541717529,
-0.4287165701389313,
-0.38198399543762207,
-0.7356204986572266,
0.14386093616485596,
0.033654145896434784,
0.5288456082344055,
0.37098950147628784,
-0.20162788033485413,
0.17572005093097687,
1.1895558834075928,
-0.3317663073539734,
0.5098389983177185,
-0.06356032937765121,
-0.7870829701423645,
-0.2136726826429367,
0.725296139717102,
0.15943731367588043,
0.11683013290166855,
0.3234001100063324,
0.12710385024547577,
-0.3792227804660797,
-0.71942138671875,
-0.0740962028503418,
0.31214389204978943,
-1.087447166442871,
0.33263489603996277,
-0.9525743126869202,
-0.21696799993515015,
-0.6528680920600891,
-0.1438109129667282,
-0.12260576337575912,
-0.3028383255004883,
-0.43683159351348877,
-0.08000501245260239,
0.20557446777820587,
0.6746036410331726,
0.04142892733216286,
0.15999191999435425,
-0.5143669247627258,
0.7507045269012451,
0.24697914719581604,
0.10204346477985382,
0.22630979120731354,
-0.5217862725257874,
-0.18388323485851288,
-0.2391977459192276,
-0.005903639364987612,
-0.9460871815681458,
0.6408718228340149,
0.02450471930205822,
0.487090140581131,
0.6487583518028259,
-0.007654222659766674,
0.937988817691803,
-0.6082314252853394,
0.8279577493667603,
0.36299628019332886,
-0.9823383688926697,
0.5620221495628357,
0.059967607259750366,
0.15905961394309998,
0.3142535984516144,
0.17312662303447723,
-0.538706362247467,
-0.5498480200767517,
-0.3891158699989319,
-0.9133118391036987,
0.4018270671367645,
0.17149457335472107,
0.02800900861620903,
-0.012218143790960312,
0.10956599563360214,
0.3530893623828888,
-0.02684263326227665,
-1.2044925689697266,
-0.09708206355571747,
-0.3084750175476074,
0.17362968623638153,
-0.033728741109371185,
-0.6134466528892517,
-0.05638258531689644,
-0.5146484375,
0.5696287751197815,
-0.0383010171353817,
0.23917753994464874,
0.3731253147125244,
-0.46554699540138245,
0.20075324177742004,
0.02200089953839779,
1.0968105792999268,
0.7882415652275085,
-0.2707865238189697,
0.4231714904308319,
0.1792619675397873,
-0.6400062441825867,
-0.19396957755088806,
-0.23538918793201447,
-0.4014449119567871,
0.3591868579387665,
0.5345404744148254,
1.150286316871643,
-0.17745251953601837,
-0.5382233262062073,
0.3308981955051422,
-0.08756902813911438,
-0.25027018785476685,
-0.6430844664573669,
-0.12312114983797073,
-0.20354411005973816,
0.2165186107158661,
0.29276973009109497,
0.16646410524845123,
0.2472732812166214,
-0.5037578344345093,
0.3662756681442261,
0.23016229271888733,
-0.3909716010093689,
-0.06306947022676468,
0.7613747715950012,
0.023273181170225143,
-0.548731803894043,
0.7062098383903503,
-0.06590282917022705,
-0.38246482610702515,
0.2987353503704071,
0.696329653263092,
1.0278708934783936,
-0.17859984934329987,
0.19192378222942352,
0.25187891721725464,
0.5668469667434692,
-0.3245067000389099,
0.14074596762657166,
0.031642332673072815,
-0.7855240106582642,
-0.3640335202217102,
-0.6831770539283752,
-0.043110188096761703,
0.2786288857460022,
-0.7193785309791565,
0.3692227900028229,
-0.35963305830955505,
0.1426946520805359,
-0.09196630865335464,
-0.7472677826881409,
-0.41047096252441406,
0.09577666223049164,
0.5683678388595581,
0.6953014731407166,
-0.9062749147415161,
0.8806740045547485,
0.15084019303321838,
-0.44343024492263794,
-0.2802518904209137,
0.508712649345398,
-0.10026659816503525,
-0.6864036321640015,
0.7117685675621033,
0.29677215218544006,
-0.15983012318611145,
-0.33055803179740906,
-0.6717041730880737,
-0.5065082907676697,
0.689763069152832,
-0.07371705025434494,
-0.47727519273757935,
-0.2984592020511627,
0.08597736805677414,
0.5486053228378296,
-0.4484784007072449,
-0.08930665999650955,
0.5904607176780701,
0.6156659126281738,
0.2510042190551758,
-0.559369683265686,
0.276114284992218,
-0.06128246709704399,
0.19368354976177216,
0.2704056203365326,
-0.19876019656658173,
1.0905911922454834,
-0.4503459334373474,
-0.026974428445100784,
0.08255340158939362,
0.5700100064277649,
0.27400699257850647,
0.5047428011894226,
0.5194212198257446,
0.4378400146961212,
0.8035508990287781,
0.06459978967905045,
1.1459628343582153,
0.09638959914445877,
0.2787262201309204,
1.1688557863235474,
-0.4810124933719635,
0.6631912589073181,
1.1473841667175293,
0.17333287000656128,
0.28998440504074097,
0.32306480407714844,
-0.2233125865459442,
0.8741785287857056,
0.32435348629951477,
-0.10723699629306793,
-0.2611393332481384,
-0.13016323745250702,
-0.5042916536331177,
0.4650965929031372,
0.247579425573349,
-0.544286847114563,
-0.11088476330041885,
0.5109869241714478,
0.03246617317199707,
-0.027951758354902267,
-0.43340951204299927,
0.7108082175254822,
0.04940004646778107,
-0.627005398273468,
0.6922803521156311,
-0.42449742555618286,
0.630260705947876,
-0.3752250373363495,
-0.2642127275466919,
-0.27262771129608154,
0.3475114703178406,
-0.23221689462661743,
-0.44955867528915405,
0.3802790641784668,
-0.1323511153459549,
-0.22692230343818665,
-0.33273300528526306,
0.8070542812347412,
-0.4938969910144806,
-0.514320969581604,
0.6029623746871948,
0.35327744483947754,
0.45598509907722473,
-0.14688251912593842,
-0.31884291768074036,
0.20399868488311768,
0.3783329725265503,
-0.19586607813835144,
0.3081880211830139,
0.45133650302886963,
-0.08845377713441849,
0.574742317199707,
0.5357483625411987,
0.20026783645153046,
0.47228196263313293,
0.34882524609565735,
0.764618456363678,
-0.9744271039962769,
-0.629361093044281,
-1.125763177871704,
0.5456368923187256,
-0.34811657667160034,
-0.17447014153003693,
0.7970442175865173,
0.5012242794036865,
0.7896698713302612,
-0.4709568917751312,
0.6734161972999573,
-0.04000503569841385,
0.2004036158323288,
-1.0536434650421143,
0.718957781791687,
-0.7395408153533936,
0.23212172091007233,
-0.31193357706069946,
-1.2091223001480103,
-0.486748069524765,
0.9077379703521729,
-0.0092706847935915,
-0.2290857434272766,
1.3523385524749756,
0.8757451176643372,
0.3080998361110687,
-0.19674864411354065,
0.6324465870857239,
0.4953257441520691,
0.07394306361675262,
0.428257554769516,
1.2500379085540771,
-0.20343858003616333,
0.6971374750137329,
-0.2533183991909027,
0.046792253851890564,
-0.48596498370170593,
-0.7278774380683899,
-1.153162956237793,
-0.6672559380531311,
-0.3873544931411743,
-0.6857865452766418,
0.017912397161126137,
0.5143653750419617,
0.3792412579059601,
-0.5660601854324341,
-0.10700470954179764,
-0.17859424650669098,
0.23513856530189514,
-0.16440875828266144,
-0.26554131507873535,
0.2796217203140259,
-0.3924092650413513,
-0.5610637068748474,
0.23377719521522522,
0.46707284450531006,
0.19289396703243256,
-0.6310039758682251,
-0.23621414601802826,
-0.0796831026673317,
0.10657916218042374,
0.8220417499542236,
-0.12084157764911652,
-1.1630219221115112,
-0.4740826487541199,
0.12329777330160141,
-0.1896851658821106,
0.22715100646018982,
0.8033975958824158,
-0.8296878337860107,
0.5284406542778015,
0.5045374631881714,
0.2333412617444992,
0.6957916617393494,
-0.43085405230522156,
0.17312508821487427,
-0.37669825553894043,
0.5761480927467346,
0.20382468402385712,
0.40568727254867554,
0.34800657629966736,
-0.4298388361930847,
0.44785410165786743,
0.46835535764694214,
-0.31715282797813416,
-0.9159764647483826,
0.3695712387561798,
-1.223638653755188,
-0.5731911063194275,
1.318415880203247,
0.4248717427253723,
-0.3647574484348297,
-0.2660423517227173,
-0.6162833571434021,
0.07269681245088577,
-0.2374783158302307,
1.1124526262283325,
0.6951577067375183,
-0.227739617228508,
-0.418379545211792,
-0.576484739780426,
0.7348130941390991,
0.444449782371521,
-0.7724912166595459,
0.10338196158409119,
0.8252110481262207,
-0.12954767048358917,
0.43175187706947327,
0.6488146781921387,
0.0678088441491127,
0.3091563582420349,
0.3166860342025757,
0.3820970952510834,
0.14782319962978363,
-0.7261493802070618,
-0.4189646542072296,
0.4527210295200348,
-0.13933710753917694,
-0.48682206869125366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03469v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03469v2 | Rethinking the Role of Proxy Rewards in Language Model Alignment | 2024-02-02T11:58:08 | 2024-04-29T01:09:06 | Sungdong Kim, Minjoon Seo | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Learning from human feedback via proxy reward modeling has been studied to
align Large Language Models (LLMs) with human values. However, achieving
reliable training through that proxy reward model (RM) is not a trivial
problem, and its behavior remained as a black-box. In this paper, we study the
role of proxy rewards in the LLM alignment via `reverse reward engineering' by
composing interpretable features as a white-box reward function. We aim to
replicate the ground truth (gold) reward signal by achieving a monotonic
relationship between the proxy and gold reward signals after training the model
using the proxy reward in reinforcement learning (RL). Our findings indicate
that successfully emulating the gold reward requires generating responses that
are relevant with enough length to open-ended questions, while also ensuring
response consistency in closed-ended questions. Furthermore, resulting models
optimizing our devised white-box reward show competitive performances with
strong open-source RMs in alignment benchmarks. We highlight its potential
usage as a simple but strong reward baseline for the LLM alignment, not
requiring explicit human feedback dataset and RM training. Our code is
available at https://github.com/naver-ai/rethinking-proxy-reward. | [
-0.09965331852436066,
-0.3053587079048157,
0.38714858889579773,
-0.03237605839967728,
-0.27682754397392273,
0.07046942412853241,
0.03795010223984718,
-0.11891487240791321,
0.4706101417541504,
0.5882337093353271,
-0.8278111815452576,
-0.16489052772521973,
-0.6049386858940125,
-0.08022534847259521,
-0.07226945459842682,
1.406528353691101,
-0.0818977952003479,
-0.2156049609184265,
-0.1448374092578888,
-0.21981264650821686,
-0.36992111802101135,
-0.5536559820175171,
-0.682071328163147,
-0.39855989813804626,
0.9687492251396179,
0.29854604601860046,
0.9281264543533325,
1.015081763267517,
0.1271049529314041,
0.23406630754470825,
0.010634380392730236,
0.09642711281776428,
-0.8667221069335938,
-0.10057983547449112,
-0.5349748134613037,
-0.41864603757858276,
-0.49502047896385193,
0.2600725293159485,
0.377938449382782,
0.6480274200439453,
-0.18512867391109467,
0.33217817544937134,
0.26286715269088745,
0.8038384914398193,
-0.7593048214912415,
0.10779023170471191,
-0.6804457902908325,
-0.04008927196264267,
-0.19168752431869507,
-0.12064051628112793,
-0.3664923310279846,
-0.33274686336517334,
-0.011041191406548023,
-0.5436010956764221,
0.09556521475315094,
-0.09605634957551956,
1.1292163133621216,
0.41177889704704285,
-0.2886391580104828,
-0.2410627156496048,
-0.26137876510620117,
0.6816512942314148,
-0.6340165734291077,
0.3887450397014618,
0.017088282853364944,
0.32770535349845886,
-0.39920350909233093,
-0.42693817615509033,
-0.5273832678794861,
-0.10772352665662766,
-0.1603735238313675,
0.23774966597557068,
0.27136561274528503,
-0.26404911279678345,
-0.055829234421253204,
0.29046717286109924,
-0.404623806476593,
0.04399867728352547,
-0.29787179827690125,
-0.23317500948905945,
0.5531725883483887,
0.1811603158712387,
0.21079163253307343,
0.19474272429943085,
-0.4623141586780548,
-0.533659040927887,
-0.8631178736686707,
0.43880629539489746,
0.5709977746009827,
0.7795841097831726,
-0.18396207690238953,
0.6420091986656189,
-0.16011783480644226,
0.6703519225120544,
-0.02665542997419834,
-0.2704909145832062,
0.2767818570137024,
-0.10504870116710663,
0.1114421859383583,
0.3370186686515808,
0.48174819350242615,
0.0895066037774086,
0.40204691886901855,
-0.24616089463233948,
-0.3853391110897064,
0.26869046688079834,
0.7119513750076294,
-0.5180131196975708,
0.06478562951087952,
0.1024753600358963,
-0.3333105146884918,
-0.4288615584373474,
0.3901899456977844,
-0.5888901948928833,
-0.28252995014190674,
-0.39662519097328186,
0.5325672626495361,
0.27037835121154785,
-0.4393176734447479,
0.3799039125442505,
-0.3045704960823059,
0.160349041223526,
0.2302297204732895,
-0.9150450229644775,
0.4332059621810913,
1.1665712594985962,
0.6164459586143494,
-0.03756149113178253,
-0.7122847437858582,
-1.0569273233413696,
0.22756782174110413,
-0.17312581837177277,
0.5301033854484558,
-0.3742583096027374,
-0.030191579833626747,
0.35786309838294983,
0.28494584560394287,
0.09653104841709137,
-0.31730934977531433,
0.49666330218315125,
-0.627971887588501,
0.09076143801212311,
-0.3821980953216553,
-0.20681366324424744,
0.2924819886684418,
0.22385060787200928,
-0.8111396431922913,
0.5271466970443726,
0.041050780564546585,
-0.6894857287406921,
0.15346136689186096,
-0.3159727454185486,
-0.38003119826316833,
-0.05294904485344887,
0.03953782096505165,
-0.5304273366928101,
0.16346120834350586,
0.07050851732492447,
0.08392614126205444,
-0.13560475409030914,
0.24487745761871338,
-0.3298933506011963,
-0.6858646869659424,
0.476081520318985,
-0.38477668166160583,
0.4543452262878418,
0.14794591069221497,
-0.5058209896087646,
0.007116949185729027,
-0.5247791409492493,
-0.13602744042873383,
0.12570972740650177,
-0.3474615514278412,
-0.4179469048976898,
0.06798902153968811,
-0.49566173553466797,
0.23546002805233002,
0.20410725474357605,
-0.6284395456314087,
0.37234318256378174,
-0.5209445953369141,
0.21795940399169922,
1.106238603591919,
-0.29057198762893677,
0.3633907437324524,
-0.37650266289711,
0.6593199372291565,
-0.1900625228881836,
0.11880598217248917,
-0.024575011804699898,
-0.2305017113685608,
-0.5044934153556824,
-0.4201318025588989,
0.6749131083488464,
0.46868211030960083,
-0.4911988377571106,
0.08301378786563873,
-0.5760585069656372,
-0.25521910190582275,
-1.3277003765106201,
0.17211097478866577,
0.5938587784767151,
0.6518964171409607,
0.37466639280319214,
-0.07317113876342773,
-0.2887980043888092,
-1.0048917531967163,
-0.3313030004501343,
-0.3637998402118683,
-0.06378965079784393,
-0.040613215416669846,
0.3945891857147217,
-0.01892929896712303,
0.864866316318512,
-0.5137441754341125,
-0.2103155255317688,
-0.03988806530833244,
0.2297109067440033,
0.26073339581489563,
0.45180392265319824,
-0.03362099081277847,
-0.7935724258422852,
-0.2118512988090515,
-0.07327669113874435,
-0.4534688889980316,
-0.49772757291793823,
-0.17729595303535461,
-0.3518218696117401,
0.1511968970298767,
0.3064666986465454,
-0.5126959681510925,
0.30298805236816406,
0.6131072044372559,
-0.3262766897678375,
0.4158298671245575,
0.17201173305511475,
0.21245403587818146,
-0.8222118020057678,
0.11076206713914871,
-0.15580183267593384,
-0.1649724692106247,
-0.3772146999835968,
0.04484505578875542,
0.21529559791088104,
-0.0554414838552475,
-0.5599910020828247,
0.9007813930511475,
-0.22598451375961304,
0.025331156328320503,
-0.6026930809020996,
0.2041347771883011,
-0.050501011312007904,
0.7020519375801086,
0.09579972922801971,
0.7274869680404663,
0.04074127599596977,
-0.5144069194793701,
0.08395057171583176,
0.27372559905052185,
0.07307062298059464,
0.6037165522575378,
-0.6511032581329346,
0.1409408301115036,
-0.24147650599479675,
0.1040349006652832,
-1.0914815664291382,
0.03459696099162102,
0.28524959087371826,
-0.5229835510253906,
0.1970285177230835,
-0.37866324186325073,
-0.2608673870563507,
-0.057362042367458344,
-0.5467332005500793,
0.43199869990348816,
0.5404003858566284,
-0.9096354246139526,
0.28848037123680115,
0.4402729868888855,
-0.2010183334350586,
-0.9831541776657104,
-0.5004097819328308,
-0.1414812207221985,
-0.24184417724609375,
-0.49170875549316406,
0.5913051962852478,
0.19138510525226593,
0.013084492646157742,
0.1642187386751175,
-0.34661251306533813,
0.6547118425369263,
0.30598071217536926,
0.22349682450294495,
0.24489040672779083,
-0.06930694729089737,
0.0794314369559288,
-0.0022310856729745865,
-0.3825618624687195,
0.053456392139196396,
-0.28108951449394226,
0.40911853313446045,
-0.11826930195093155,
-0.5885276794433594,
-0.203203484416008,
0.010812949389219284,
0.36455038189888,
-0.21119201183319092,
0.8903659582138062,
0.14968858659267426,
-0.11481980234384537,
-0.14049342274665833,
-0.4137067198753357,
-0.2232244610786438,
-0.43673473596572876,
0.09413864463567734,
-0.5455767512321472,
-0.9808980822563171,
0.44852548837661743,
-0.10482680052518845,
0.1264534741640091,
0.15580837428569794,
0.3841780722141266,
0.17422592639923096,
1.2683398723602295,
0.5041684508323669,
-0.2685990631580353,
0.24902166426181793,
0.3654036223888397,
0.0197895634919405,
-0.8397184014320374,
-0.3597290813922882,
-0.5668607354164124,
-0.3214942216873169,
-0.5326908826828003,
0.21632134914398193,
0.09116180986166,
0.2135794460773468,
-0.5181778073310852,
0.17455075681209564,
-0.23472845554351807,
0.2988690137863159,
0.4925391972064972,
0.060281798243522644,
-0.017008468508720398,
-0.10027358680963516,
-0.15092337131500244,
0.034922730177640915,
-0.5669911503791809,
-0.6363362669944763,
0.7188140749931335,
0.5746636390686035,
1.1419252157211304,
0.1357373148202896,
0.7904975414276123,
0.1411462277173996,
0.47185105085372925,
-0.4341842234134674,
0.32295113801956177,
-0.04550623521208763,
-0.0020255844574421644,
-0.4139976501464844,
-0.3096179962158203,
-1.1080074310302734,
0.4876703917980194,
-0.012181012891232967,
-0.5708815455436707,
-0.07738319039344788,
0.12294892966747284,
-0.09288997948169708,
-0.06217486038804054,
-0.5287603735923767,
1.1378791332244873,
-0.304997980594635,
-0.6937811374664307,
0.29037654399871826,
-0.7055162787437439,
0.18853284418582916,
0.1433025598526001,
0.28711748123168945,
0.26710638403892517,
-0.020304149016737938,
0.5993140935897827,
-0.5711987018585205,
0.9987859725952148,
-0.05311160162091255,
-0.34259918332099915,
-0.2271474003791809,
0.16536712646484375,
0.6296230554580688,
0.2255011647939682,
0.04488992691040039,
-0.10952351987361908,
-0.06346974521875381,
-0.6631656289100647,
-0.8489563465118408,
0.6477985978126526,
-0.6612163782119751,
-1.0810668468475342,
-0.437923401594162,
-0.4361121952533722,
-0.09796971082687378,
-0.11348415166139603,
-0.2857007086277008,
0.18454498052597046,
0.1640956997871399,
-0.11958096921443939,
0.6260697841644287,
-0.15455259382724762,
-0.127956822514534,
0.649772047996521,
-0.2345636934041977,
-0.519943118095398,
0.9316319823265076,
-0.22452209889888763,
0.46508026123046875,
0.5009027123451233,
0.17986233532428741,
-0.40345725417137146,
-0.010950619354844093,
-0.5693010091781616,
0.46838995814323425,
-0.47678104043006897,
-0.2877560257911682,
-0.2633374333381653,
-0.16886217892169952,
-0.4274386763572693,
-0.34532350301742554,
-0.5958045721054077,
-0.18289121985435486,
0.01879698969423771,
-0.20889106392860413,
-0.0822131559252739,
0.4434991776943207,
-0.16588623821735382,
0.22691620886325836,
-0.7415030598640442,
0.17881223559379578,
0.4100647270679474,
0.3646653890609741,
0.07546994090080261,
-0.45837849378585815,
-0.3328138589859009,
0.3798677921295166,
-0.010808861814439297,
-0.8299775123596191,
0.24835173785686493,
-0.4228184223175049,
0.6545434594154358,
0.16692186892032623,
0.015331110917031765,
0.9309996366500854,
-0.5396990776062012,
0.8460609316825867,
-0.05367373675107956,
-0.92713463306427,
0.34902918338775635,
0.17778772115707397,
0.45930323004722595,
0.6194403171539307,
0.2752944231033325,
-0.8028578758239746,
-0.6598250269889832,
-0.5311506986618042,
-0.6003227829933167,
0.7756698131561279,
-0.041741080582141876,
0.20787695050239563,
-0.1685485541820526,
0.5853255391120911,
0.2750410735607147,
0.34933191537857056,
-1.0369043350219727,
0.003341272007673979,
-0.39258354902267456,
-0.5536009669303894,
-0.1460382342338562,
-0.1815667748451233,
-0.3215319514274597,
0.15968559682369232,
0.7729097008705139,
-0.20806477963924408,
0.03708724305033684,
0.0012041787849739194,
-0.11600340157747269,
-0.29740607738494873,
0.36882248520851135,
0.7021280527114868,
0.43772485852241516,
-0.29758477210998535,
0.44738098978996277,
-0.23555029928684235,
-0.06125788018107414,
0.22245344519615173,
-0.07430092245340347,
-0.030942894518375397,
-0.4069480299949646,
0.3247419595718384,
0.7969968318939209,
0.2534949779510498,
-0.7960929870605469,
0.5819230079650879,
0.052628107368946075,
-0.13248351216316223,
-0.0029944961424916983,
0.008384793996810913,
0.15274101495742798,
0.30572065711021423,
0.18828469514846802,
-0.6382662057876587,
-0.25102105736732483,
-0.8028674721717834,
0.09688888490200043,
0.8879230618476868,
-0.5160977244377136,
-0.28207531571388245,
0.7073443531990051,
-0.25065967440605164,
-0.5749521851539612,
0.8181119561195374,
-0.19532832503318787,
-0.8644680976867676,
0.40134939551353455,
0.815976619720459,
0.5014498233795166,
-0.12436535209417343,
0.5382137298583984,
0.07225915044546127,
0.2403002381324768,
-0.3875124156475067,
0.2041027843952179,
0.07876453548669815,
-0.733130156993866,
-0.4555068016052246,
-0.6812516450881958,
-0.3794441521167755,
0.25926944613456726,
-0.6720326542854309,
0.32646000385284424,
0.12586094439029694,
0.24138948321342468,
-0.09316983819007874,
-0.34600409865379333,
-0.3257729411125183,
0.0260385163128376,
0.01931154914200306,
0.8129462599754333,
-1.1313016414642334,
0.7067210674285889,
0.7801436185836792,
-0.6790557503700256,
-0.7195032835006714,
-0.04644913598895073,
0.08316387981176376,
-0.7395489811897278,
0.9782414436340332,
0.1555095911026001,
-0.33200016617774963,
-0.21754267811775208,
-0.633783757686615,
-0.8128803372383118,
0.9382794499397278,
0.34136727452278137,
-0.10475113242864609,
0.14227443933486938,
0.5076433420181274,
0.7118584513664246,
-0.6082736253738403,
0.09243869036436081,
0.33578771352767944,
0.23398050665855408,
0.16007140278816223,
-0.7339113354682922,
0.31995630264282227,
-0.31120720505714417,
0.07203453779220581,
0.5303177237510681,
-0.6492705345153809,
0.8434257507324219,
0.1680576503276825,
-0.2752365469932556,
0.05646830424666405,
0.5277770161628723,
0.8023902177810669,
0.1696363240480423,
0.4812317490577698,
0.69186931848526,
0.5311158895492554,
0.10090719163417816,
0.9962363839149475,
0.057586897164583206,
0.17190192639827728,
0.8877758979797363,
-0.3958035409450531,
0.8019118905067444,
0.8771674633026123,
0.12950225174427032,
0.5973759889602661,
0.45304203033447266,
0.14661221206188202,
0.9277704954147339,
0.5980973839759827,
0.24006246030330658,
-0.1355481743812561,
-0.09065541625022888,
-0.18914903700351715,
0.03212855011224747,
-0.07817979902029037,
0.032178640365600586,
-0.3307406008243561,
-0.02606007643043995,
-0.13647761940956116,
0.23454616963863373,
-0.3889567255973816,
0.6821401715278625,
-0.017921745777130127,
-1.0759365558624268,
0.6288355588912964,
-0.026127805933356285,
0.5055957436561584,
-0.658580482006073,
-0.40876641869544983,
-0.33202502131462097,
0.24143821001052856,
-0.046324025839567184,
-0.6939353346824646,
0.05845911055803299,
-0.1757224053144455,
-0.04446832835674286,
-0.33952057361602783,
0.5119991898536682,
-0.6051468849182129,
0.006507851183414459,
0.1467214822769165,
0.33764368295669556,
0.0029896909836679697,
0.03407275304198265,
-0.6900553107261658,
0.2539089322090149,
-0.10414894670248032,
-0.1882195919752121,
0.754458487033844,
0.31300613284111023,
-0.12131208926439285,
0.6005210876464844,
0.6682273745536804,
0.17447105050086975,
-0.14244961738586426,
0.1074560359120369,
0.7005439400672913,
-0.6355239152908325,
-0.6232255101203918,
-1.0467069149017334,
0.8840315341949463,
-0.0026049946900457144,
-0.07918333262205124,
0.49219271540641785,
0.5702452063560486,
1.1850171089172363,
-0.16490449011325836,
0.416695773601532,
0.39540499448776245,
0.4564048945903778,
-0.8270363807678223,
0.2871207892894745,
-0.7857499718666077,
0.41129183769226074,
-0.27791735529899597,
-0.6724624633789062,
0.10761062800884247,
0.49399280548095703,
0.05633591115474701,
-0.3026357889175415,
0.5378010272979736,
1.0215421915054321,
-0.11649345606565475,
-0.062110234051942825,
0.02305273525416851,
-0.17347726225852966,
0.29617854952812195,
0.5840038657188416,
0.9908633232116699,
-0.2573016881942749,
0.46419480443000793,
-0.06347673386335373,
-0.2976815104484558,
-0.00945552159100771,
-0.956695020198822,
-0.6364409923553467,
-0.6856864094734192,
-0.3252680003643036,
-0.6776764988899231,
0.3127502501010895,
0.9951931238174438,
0.29161354899406433,
-0.6644162535667419,
-0.5854546427726746,
0.12782616913318634,
0.4078352153301239,
-0.6260551810264587,
-0.25501328706741333,
0.4316081404685974,
-0.6431576609611511,
-0.6711203455924988,
0.22651265561580658,
0.3022749423980713,
-0.04275232180953026,
-0.175741046667099,
-0.4574098289012909,
-0.19206503033638,
0.0573166199028492,
0.23859429359436035,
0.5603294968605042,
-0.7598127126693726,
-0.4665936827659607,
0.01206930074840784,
-0.3388834595680237,
-0.1668011099100113,
0.7419450283050537,
-1.011222243309021,
0.20386943221092224,
0.26503485441207886,
1.168872594833374,
0.46421563625335693,
0.42573174834251404,
0.7412136793136597,
-0.7030792832374573,
0.017057353630661964,
-0.2723527252674103,
0.2890181243419647,
0.1296529769897461,
-0.2976754903793335,
0.64312344789505,
-0.06296192109584808,
-0.4281010031700134,
-1.132941484451294,
0.3976796865463257,
-0.8872110843658447,
-0.42686912417411804,
1.1296958923339844,
-0.039195723831653595,
-0.5365628004074097,
0.15023961663246155,
-0.21341297030448914,
0.32046884298324585,
-0.26945772767066956,
1.2779390811920166,
0.8087955117225647,
0.159073144197464,
-0.2414707988500595,
-0.28799697756767273,
0.5809923410415649,
0.6133691668510437,
-0.5360605716705322,
0.11476978659629822,
0.22578787803649902,
0.23520296812057495,
0.27499496936798096,
0.48109206557273865,
-0.24728542566299438,
0.3419041335582733,
-0.29510238766670227,
0.059630099684000015,
-0.25248634815216064,
-0.21790370345115662,
-0.5310075879096985,
0.3298719823360443,
0.18535085022449493,
-0.19624748826026917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01300v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01300v1 | Two Approaches to Diachronic Normalization of Polish Texts | 2024-02-02T10:42:06 | 2024-02-02T10:42:06 | Kacper Dudzic, Filip Graliński, Krzysztof Jassem, Marek Kubis, Piotr Wierzchoń | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper discusses two approaches to the diachronic normalization of Polish
texts: a rule-based solution that relies on a set of handcrafted patterns, and
a neural normalization model based on the text-to-text transfer transformer
architecture. The training and evaluation data prepared for the task are
discussed in detail, along with experiments conducted to compare the proposed
normalization solutions. A quantitative and qualitative analysis is made. It is
shown that at the current stage of inquiry into the problem, the rule-based
solution outperforms the neural one on 3 out of 4 variants of the prepared
dataset, although in practice both approaches have distinct advantages and
disadvantages. | [
-0.040973249822854996,
-0.8640161752700806,
0.5658259987831116,
0.4999065399169922,
-0.4409063160419464,
-0.20889899134635925,
-0.610633134841919,
-0.5379473567008972,
0.18253818154335022,
0.5715387463569641,
-0.731785774230957,
-0.46985024213790894,
-0.49885138869285583,
0.3111966848373413,
-0.3113102912902832,
0.8881531953811646,
-0.13986621797084808,
0.36304014921188354,
0.1264677792787552,
0.22627589106559753,
-0.8063461184501648,
-0.5698540210723877,
-0.3444101810455322,
-0.5771826505661011,
-0.017803087830543518,
0.6114354133605957,
0.7213540077209473,
0.8573002815246582,
0.8582620024681091,
0.30124983191490173,
-0.16597498953342438,
-0.030572043731808662,
-0.21426326036453247,
0.22143913805484772,
0.11600164324045181,
-0.8220248222351074,
-0.4322521686553955,
0.12878289818763733,
0.3836354911327362,
0.8099537491798401,
-0.1582740992307663,
0.16435083746910095,
-0.12733499705791473,
0.8602654337882996,
-0.4172380268573761,
0.23751962184906006,
-0.3685677647590637,
0.2802060842514038,
-0.2604038715362549,
-0.06333988904953003,
-0.5484709739685059,
-0.4033232629299164,
-0.07223866879940033,
-0.7431890368461609,
0.3921256959438324,
-0.10028819739818573,
0.6652988791465759,
-0.10580835491418839,
-0.2642423212528229,
-0.5246259570121765,
-1.3591713905334473,
1.0080252885818481,
-1.0479625463485718,
0.19532735645771027,
0.32856640219688416,
0.3635735809803009,
0.18748396635055542,
-1.0407960414886475,
-0.43831944465637207,
0.1402883231639862,
-0.43602651357650757,
0.37721332907676697,
-0.13704264163970947,
-0.2928381562232971,
0.17400382459163666,
0.3270880877971649,
-0.5369340181350708,
0.2516959011554718,
-0.4873335063457489,
-0.14515741169452667,
0.7368687987327576,
0.375495046377182,
0.45606231689453125,
-0.11121104657649994,
-0.5222616195678711,
-0.08978524059057236,
-0.5113207101821899,
-0.11142721772193909,
0.4795592427253723,
0.5472827553749084,
-0.1056196540594101,
0.3319844901561737,
-0.4475855529308319,
0.6654945611953735,
0.4367586374282837,
-0.06990526616573334,
0.37455153465270996,
-0.758523166179657,
-0.08237510174512863,
0.2674137055873871,
0.8711430430412292,
0.8620620369911194,
0.6657096743583679,
-0.6429664492607117,
-0.2951776087284088,
0.1399356871843338,
0.4454590678215027,
-0.7570120692253113,
-0.22407285869121552,
-0.20957474410533905,
-0.9546162486076355,
-0.4258382320404053,
0.07317439466714859,
-1.0994282960891724,
-0.0889657586812973,
-0.688694417476654,
0.40804532170295715,
-0.41582873463630676,
0.06602173298597336,
0.3533305525779724,
-0.04820894077420235,
0.14676757156848907,
0.36070355772972107,
-1.512182354927063,
0.7627280950546265,
0.5000922083854675,
0.7045590281486511,
-0.012363129295408726,
-0.054142046719789505,
0.18550287187099457,
-0.24884934723377228,
-0.7839464545249939,
0.7117581367492676,
-0.3509913384914398,
-0.20156677067279816,
-0.028526773676276207,
-0.040485162287950516,
-0.01773194409906864,
-0.35108932852745056,
0.5547181963920593,
-0.7784155011177063,
0.5882923007011414,
-0.3099575340747833,
-0.3734249770641327,
-0.28101029992103577,
0.11038006097078323,
-0.7199069857597351,
1.1591062545776367,
0.0801737904548645,
-0.8488895297050476,
0.3917044997215271,
-0.4584866166114807,
-0.47557419538497925,
-0.025548510253429413,
0.050599195063114166,
-0.2327333688735962,
-0.09372083842754364,
0.04320276901125908,
0.1847359538078308,
-0.24470722675323486,
0.12972144782543182,
0.2081548124551773,
-0.6295841336250305,
0.030910400673747063,
-0.3708398640155792,
1.088952660560608,
0.15480680763721466,
-0.6090032458305359,
-0.15808872878551483,
-1.0699485540390015,
0.03403693437576294,
0.1132659912109375,
-0.41844379901885986,
-0.5963292717933655,
0.1581125259399414,
0.305203378200531,
0.5160146355628967,
0.3208979666233063,
-0.918912410736084,
0.20985998213291168,
-0.7969012260437012,
0.48225367069244385,
0.3454551696777344,
-0.06212756037712097,
0.8937920928001404,
-0.3626229166984558,
0.18906861543655396,
-0.04684373736381531,
0.4888390898704529,
0.18585965037345886,
-0.5076764822006226,
-0.7591774463653564,
0.36095136404037476,
0.46112480759620667,
0.9369631409645081,
-0.4098285734653473,
0.2925988435745239,
-0.23124812543392181,
-0.5747981071472168,
-0.3392139673233032,
-0.06342343240976334,
0.2756536900997162,
0.7139120697975159,
0.7047262787818909,
-0.30572956800460815,
-0.7986575961112976,
-1.0024309158325195,
-0.020908599719405174,
0.02123596891760826,
-0.017224431037902832,
0.09521184116601944,
0.17239606380462646,
0.13169029355049133,
0.9151616096496582,
-0.18975985050201416,
-0.3220987021923065,
-0.018300995230674744,
0.23779480159282684,
0.51173335313797,
0.4000406265258789,
0.7175511717796326,
-0.8200567960739136,
-0.7915798425674438,
0.07279033958911896,
-0.721397340297699,
-0.11115571111440659,
-0.2900354564189911,
0.07902427017688751,
0.11663101613521576,
0.826555609703064,
-0.13780686259269714,
0.6112436652183533,
0.19153785705566406,
-0.48382648825645447,
0.5022619962692261,
-0.45512109994888306,
0.42595601081848145,
-1.00374174118042,
-0.01367701031267643,
-0.4207025468349457,
-0.12991565465927124,
-1.3851585388183594,
-0.2727017402648926,
0.4334367513656616,
0.3639143109321594,
-0.397777795791626,
0.15571939945220947,
-0.4626176655292511,
0.12268494069576263,
-0.3585069179534912,
0.18090978264808655,
0.04588956758379936,
0.37970277667045593,
-0.10232328623533249,
0.7267728447914124,
0.2232666015625,
-0.3921070992946625,
0.5359894037246704,
0.7314035892486572,
-0.2137707620859146,
0.2910929024219513,
-0.732843816280365,
0.2510899305343628,
-0.3022479712963104,
-0.09100189059972763,
-1.0438514947891235,
0.4722336232662201,
0.4488937556743622,
-0.25100791454315186,
0.2367504984140396,
-0.07492122799158096,
-0.5044271349906921,
-0.07111098617315292,
-0.4716259837150574,
0.3269168436527252,
0.8313649296760559,
-0.3669968545436859,
0.3390507996082306,
-0.18183280527591705,
-0.2638157904148102,
-0.5953446626663208,
-1.0704846382141113,
0.4590572416782379,
-0.34135323762893677,
-0.6395869851112366,
0.9807807803153992,
-0.24599020183086395,
-0.5663636326789856,
-0.17165130376815796,
0.13579745590686798,
-0.16573454439640045,
0.11091630160808563,
0.005115589592605829,
0.5640271306037903,
-0.45574378967285156,
0.0714443102478981,
-0.06965292245149612,
-0.23373402655124664,
0.13671456277370453,
-0.04778321087360382,
0.6389470100402832,
0.16588400304317474,
0.16171476244926453,
-0.4828016459941864,
0.5070207715034485,
0.4850558638572693,
-0.17843982577323914,
0.5523402690887451,
0.45888781547546387,
-0.19462835788726807,
-0.07905092090368271,
-0.4248979389667511,
-0.27987241744995117,
-0.4278813898563385,
0.0071410080417990685,
-0.17201517522335052,
-0.34717097878456116,
0.7377789616584778,
-0.00803063903003931,
0.05641915276646614,
0.5406168103218079,
0.9070754051208496,
-0.17618457973003387,
0.9277381896972656,
0.7631479501724243,
0.12174076586961746,
0.6132879257202148,
-0.07826872169971466,
0.3256475627422333,
-0.7853201031684875,
-0.4247933030128479,
-0.6144711375236511,
-0.5459113121032715,
-0.5752306580543518,
0.012179610319435596,
0.036165010184049606,
0.4114980399608612,
-0.024582162499427795,
0.4597090780735016,
-0.5302303433418274,
0.4278014302253723,
0.39657020568847656,
0.3178388178348541,
0.5018281936645508,
0.028603767976164818,
-0.09400317817926407,
-0.16103847324848175,
-0.825630247592926,
-0.7363171577453613,
1.2208051681518555,
-0.0001464002998545766,
0.5157466530799866,
0.08283881098031998,
0.6331561207771301,
0.09978830069303513,
0.10007030516862869,
-0.833593487739563,
0.21398477256298065,
-0.5973772406578064,
-0.39945611357688904,
-0.4879886209964752,
-0.033404991030693054,
-0.9963542819023132,
0.12369348108768463,
-0.5017595291137695,
-0.5665094256401062,
0.6468510031700134,
-0.17472676932811737,
-0.18928852677345276,
0.14318950474262238,
-0.5906755924224854,
0.7522616386413574,
0.1435604989528656,
0.059787895530462265,
-0.00215021800249815,
-1.1337769031524658,
-0.032819703221321106,
-0.16192570328712463,
0.5104444026947021,
0.09926290065050125,
-0.11754098534584045,
1.0009430646896362,
-0.3059942424297333,
0.9619921445846558,
0.020255908370018005,
0.03844229876995087,
0.1427871286869049,
0.06360681354999542,
0.4028279483318329,
-0.11719830334186554,
-0.18582983314990997,
-0.051958490163087845,
0.04717090725898743,
-0.2492801696062088,
-0.6749430298805237,
0.2971835732460022,
-0.7096145749092102,
-0.2507401406764984,
0.04238423705101013,
-0.6679994463920593,
-0.14074791967868805,
0.5185074806213379,
0.6037080883979797,
0.6082181334495544,
-0.3884858191013336,
-0.08071336150169373,
0.6748022437095642,
0.30164337158203125,
1.0579646825790405,
0.5423257350921631,
0.06308170408010483,
-0.2533169686794281,
0.1974187195301056,
0.22038264572620392,
0.1968020349740982,
0.3161890506744385,
0.22750736773014069,
0.0013160132803022861,
-0.8285509347915649,
-0.6410014629364014,
0.1403096616268158,
-0.8049584627151489,
-0.12971539795398712,
-0.19820846617221832,
-0.17136700451374054,
-0.4485253691673279,
-0.1614667922258377,
-0.416340708732605,
-0.6302405595779419,
-0.485795259475708,
0.17822162806987762,
0.36383721232414246,
0.7588469386100769,
0.0026864707469940186,
0.1481195092201233,
-0.789456307888031,
0.21943430602550507,
0.21822068095207214,
0.3087391257286072,
-0.1908368319272995,
-0.4416104853153229,
-0.25606676936149597,
0.19463925063610077,
0.1571468561887741,
-1.0597347021102905,
0.3281257450580597,
0.14228935539722443,
0.2751198709011078,
0.09190447628498077,
0.00310508836992085,
0.2736559510231018,
-1.0740934610366821,
0.6555784940719604,
0.14807221293449402,
-0.7481395602226257,
0.5117915272712708,
-0.23990711569786072,
0.06150662899017334,
0.7087754607200623,
0.2527953088283539,
-0.8556089997291565,
-0.16655978560447693,
-0.580932080745697,
-0.6796538829803467,
0.6950058937072754,
0.15568667650222778,
0.5215217471122742,
-0.010629135183990002,
0.6352840065956116,
0.22044694423675537,
-0.19399328529834747,
-0.2621384859085083,
-0.32032471895217896,
-0.3415822982788086,
-0.2924274504184723,
-0.08734475821256638,
-0.18921424448490143,
-0.13129840791225433,
-0.0018158539896830916,
0.36160096526145935,
0.11909521371126175,
0.12269164621829987,
0.4749300479888916,
-0.3172164857387543,
-0.0968889445066452,
0.4641507863998413,
0.761173665523529,
0.7669408321380615,
-0.2319924235343933,
0.07102605700492859,
0.23722964525222778,
-0.9016974568367004,
0.2741980254650116,
-0.20583593845367432,
-0.5944311022758484,
0.27110376954078674,
0.5266417264938354,
0.6450861096382141,
0.2379196584224701,
-0.11846520006656647,
0.5881485939025879,
-0.06567136198282242,
-0.6535913348197937,
-0.04242774844169617,
-0.29585543274879456,
-0.0064006587490439415,
0.1589643657207489,
-0.03589189425110817,
0.1281949281692505,
0.36571386456489563,
-0.45910710096359253,
0.14606885612010956,
-0.05898067355155945,
-0.4243263304233551,
-0.5226994156837463,
0.41089293360710144,
-0.17940831184387207,
-0.547737181186676,
0.8644710183143616,
0.14226970076560974,
-0.43769124150276184,
0.7453128099441528,
1.128305435180664,
0.49964889883995056,
-0.38939547538757324,
0.19082428514957428,
0.33956921100616455,
0.23124255239963531,
-0.33462974429130554,
0.4091070592403412,
0.0436180904507637,
-0.8422681093215942,
-0.4431968927383423,
-0.3410417437553406,
-0.07794101536273956,
-0.2559354305267334,
-0.9737880229949951,
0.2716604173183441,
-0.3343992829322815,
-0.20414873957633972,
0.19688165187835693,
-0.036408547312021255,
-0.39553025364875793,
0.19467665255069733,
-0.04799703508615494,
0.9477360248565674,
-1.1480176448822021,
0.6932479739189148,
0.7813675999641418,
-0.2705315351486206,
-0.6446789503097534,
-0.3859159052371979,
-0.32878997921943665,
-0.6168105006217957,
0.7903301119804382,
-0.38297268748283386,
-0.00927351787686348,
-0.05947577953338623,
-0.04979947209358215,
-0.7932990193367004,
1.1229208707809448,
0.018716629594564438,
-0.7258816957473755,
-0.23113492131233215,
0.11629533767700195,
0.8015754818916321,
-0.18980398774147034,
-0.0016007060185074806,
0.8121993541717529,
0.5951070189476013,
-0.2497851401567459,
-0.952099621295929,
0.057892534881830215,
-0.46263623237609863,
0.2268979400396347,
0.5114646553993225,
-0.5122016072273254,
1.0297152996063232,
0.22575852274894714,
-0.38657766580581665,
-0.04469749704003334,
0.1589827984571457,
-0.6257059574127197,
0.015491791069507599,
0.3595135509967804,
0.4488486647605896,
0.3740370273590088,
0.13882970809936523,
0.6702269315719604,
-0.4899997115135193,
0.5059493184089661,
0.8856983184814453,
-0.02175733633339405,
0.6693119406700134,
0.6088128089904785,
-0.3853767514228821,
0.7296445965766907,
0.5641382336616516,
-0.1975805014371872,
0.7327237129211426,
0.046759963035583496,
-0.11073458939790726,
-0.05729266256093979,
0.3626619279384613,
-0.1626504808664322,
0.6316522359848022,
-0.041531890630722046,
-0.45627424120903015,
-0.6326079368591309,
-0.032358910888433456,
0.1982927918434143,
0.5131368637084961,
-0.296065092086792,
1.1228830814361572,
-0.23904140293598175,
-0.49004679918289185,
0.4631839692592621,
0.4700046479701996,
0.6770942807197571,
-0.28341662883758545,
-0.03810110688209534,
-0.20125806331634521,
0.06974324584007263,
-0.29121801257133484,
-0.48003628849983215,
0.7543674111366272,
-0.07921520620584488,
-0.681300163269043,
-0.567931592464447,
0.9481368660926819,
-0.5302422046661377,
-0.6022756099700928,
0.09117764234542847,
0.5671555399894714,
-0.15561532974243164,
0.41783607006073,
-0.5071107745170593,
-0.47922345995903015,
-0.23963375389575958,
-0.20708362758159637,
0.25305819511413574,
0.3777957260608673,
-0.4577788710594177,
-0.0288222786039114,
0.3920363187789917,
0.25363340973854065,
0.2517147660255432,
0.28792694211006165,
0.693337082862854,
-0.40929946303367615,
-0.6079156398773193,
-1.151779055595398,
0.303211510181427,
-0.004738569259643555,
-0.34832221269607544,
0.7535234689712524,
0.4820774495601654,
0.5223507285118103,
-0.20813314616680145,
0.36824822425842285,
0.11758026480674744,
0.3909672796726227,
-0.7224991917610168,
0.7277524471282959,
-0.006948909256607294,
0.1330081969499588,
-0.0632842481136322,
-0.9128096699714661,
-0.8041602969169617,
0.6618072390556335,
-0.3386503756046295,
-0.1479305475950241,
0.8801486492156982,
0.6067368388175964,
-0.1500135362148285,
0.21668511629104614,
0.08155590295791626,
0.05714326724410057,
-0.04042583703994751,
0.49387800693511963,
0.675487756729126,
-0.7042670249938965,
0.3446049392223358,
-0.6461659669876099,
-0.5055826306343079,
-0.11563339829444885,
-0.8075035810470581,
-0.6664583086967468,
-0.6005797982215881,
-0.036097511649131775,
-0.1394486427307129,
0.12868434190750122,
0.5487405061721802,
0.6080592274665833,
-0.7579839825630188,
-0.4427579641342163,
-0.25573956966400146,
-0.32390397787094116,
-0.43653127551078796,
-0.11813590675592422,
0.4880814254283905,
-0.7717754244804382,
-0.4975142776966095,
0.40212714672088623,
0.17223480343818665,
0.1617565006017685,
0.3018265664577484,
0.306770920753479,
-0.11095613241195679,
0.22620843350887299,
0.4994906485080719,
-0.22495050728321075,
-0.3082398474216461,
-0.32496413588523865,
0.27864378690719604,
-0.3492400348186493,
0.633211076259613,
1.088476538658142,
-0.6556256413459778,
0.526202917098999,
0.7464060187339783,
0.2077486515045166,
0.7031426429748535,
-0.04459031671285629,
0.44380849599838257,
-0.5340359807014465,
0.22994570434093475,
0.3015425205230713,
0.024992026388645172,
0.07562922686338425,
-0.4930541515350342,
0.29076632857322693,
0.2219194918870926,
-0.39423269033432007,
-0.3617917001247406,
0.1924070566892624,
-0.9564111828804016,
-0.4401555359363556,
0.8116530179977417,
-0.013954617083072662,
-0.2605811655521393,
-0.24616362154483795,
-0.14362333714962006,
0.4791449010372162,
0.377727210521698,
1.1090154647827148,
1.001194953918457,
-0.14706341922283173,
0.2902204394340515,
-0.5950459837913513,
0.5962302684783936,
0.16943520307540894,
-0.6735562086105347,
0.28914523124694824,
0.2599048912525177,
0.620567262172699,
0.302133709192276,
0.6417011618614197,
-0.5765095949172974,
0.45733553171157837,
0.1543138027191162,
0.14183922111988068,
-0.12631860375404358,
-0.36735132336616516,
-0.6374492645263672,
-0.07475727051496506,
-0.12921951711177826,
-0.034918464720249176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01293v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01293v2 | Can MLLMs Perform Text-to-Image In-Context Learning? | 2024-02-02T10:30:05 | 2024-04-15T21:30:10 | Yuchen Zeng, Wonjun Kang, Yicong Chen, Hyung Il Koo, Kangwook Lee | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The evolution from Large Language Models (LLMs) to Multimodal Large Language
Models (MLLMs) has spurred research into extending In-Context Learning (ICL) to
its multimodal counterpart. Existing such studies have primarily concentrated
on image-to-text ICL. However, the Text-to-Image ICL (T2I-ICL), with its unique
characteristics and potential applications, remains underexplored. To address
this gap, we formally define the task of T2I-ICL and present CoBSAT, the first
T2I-ICL benchmark dataset, encompassing ten tasks. Utilizing our dataset to
benchmark six state-of-the-art MLLMs, we uncover considerable difficulties
MLLMs encounter in solving T2I-ICL. We identify the primary challenges as the
inherent complexity of multimodality and image generation, and show that
strategies such as fine-tuning and Chain-of-Thought prompting help to mitigate
these difficulties, leading to notable improvements in performance. Our code
and dataset are available at https://github.com/UW-Madison-Lee-Lab/CoBSAT. | [
-0.35552600026130676,
-0.7366117835044861,
0.446882426738739,
0.17246022820472717,
-0.39088812470436096,
0.22859974205493927,
-0.3138658106327057,
-0.6052077412605286,
-0.6152747273445129,
0.20911523699760437,
-0.6347709894180298,
-0.4768412113189697,
-0.6160150766372681,
0.03332354500889778,
-0.31671056151390076,
0.8267672657966614,
-0.27263250946998596,
0.08284907788038254,
-0.44687196612358093,
-0.37870529294013977,
-0.702674150466919,
-0.3773173391819,
-0.7563878297805786,
-0.1145620122551918,
0.46927759051322937,
0.5988226532936096,
0.15834152698516846,
0.1982903927564621,
0.5954706072807312,
0.10935170203447342,
0.18734537065029144,
0.524223804473877,
-0.6034936904907227,
0.13215230405330658,
-0.2134532779455185,
-0.09520966559648514,
0.0891512855887413,
-0.2091093808412552,
0.6918008923530579,
0.6071401834487915,
0.34141412377357483,
0.3432081341743469,
0.1833382546901703,
0.6766734719276428,
-0.6244382262229919,
0.04022596776485443,
-0.8433316946029663,
-0.03206367790699005,
-0.1453717201948166,
-0.33624693751335144,
-0.7829232215881348,
0.04315099120140076,
0.38079532980918884,
-0.26229214668273926,
-0.049520667642354965,
0.5578635334968567,
0.9253711104393005,
0.3383542597293854,
-0.9569578170776367,
-0.7989135980606079,
-0.4473499059677124,
0.9287038445472717,
-0.2787533700466156,
0.5668922066688538,
0.2996045649051666,
0.16381223499774933,
-0.2359008938074112,
-0.80205899477005,
-0.15891185402870178,
-0.207571342587471,
-0.30504298210144043,
0.03564288839697838,
-0.09743352234363556,
-0.3034334182739258,
0.28928130865097046,
-0.07306177914142609,
-0.5934357047080994,
0.1528651863336563,
-0.2682178318500519,
-0.06250576674938202,
0.32766544818878174,
0.12002766132354736,
0.327544242143631,
0.023934094235301018,
-0.6945276856422424,
-0.18742109835147858,
-0.7147948145866394,
0.3583325147628784,
-0.3121192753314972,
0.060287389904260635,
-0.38498544692993164,
0.4478197693824768,
0.3349676728248596,
0.5486426949501038,
0.02825784496963024,
0.041861094534397125,
0.13350361585617065,
-0.14672012627124786,
-0.1824483871459961,
-0.07479654252529144,
0.5413100719451904,
0.3874360918998718,
-0.06489834189414978,
-0.34813588857650757,
-0.33289897441864014,
-0.13315361738204956,
-0.000950744841247797,
-0.9275592565536499,
-0.07865670323371887,
0.3006133735179901,
-0.3582485616207123,
0.007010884117335081,
-0.15002179145812988,
-0.5348466634750366,
-0.23021303117275238,
-0.2894066572189331,
0.7217113971710205,
-0.44263869524002075,
-0.1384834200143814,
-0.47429153323173523,
-0.15529850125312805,
0.28377464413642883,
0.2866295576095581,
-0.6112070083618164,
0.2724921405315399,
0.472804456949234,
0.8236162662506104,
-0.3451513350009918,
-0.1856430470943451,
-0.6462354063987732,
0.2994815409183502,
-0.5720958709716797,
0.804893970489502,
-0.4522482454776764,
-0.21673636138439178,
-0.06420543044805527,
-0.27737948298454285,
-0.09524911642074585,
-0.6551991105079651,
0.10052387416362762,
-0.49300670623779297,
0.1267642229795456,
-0.37224307656288147,
-0.6723439693450928,
-0.040152404457330704,
0.5364775657653809,
-0.5204734802246094,
1.1273574829101562,
0.11530386656522751,
-0.5723077654838562,
0.43509259819984436,
-0.6533192992210388,
-0.6147945523262024,
-0.060613296926021576,
-0.4565232992172241,
-0.6895090341567993,
0.20957741141319275,
0.16130128502845764,
0.6221852898597717,
-0.2766105830669403,
0.5023552775382996,
-0.25442177057266235,
-0.5509393215179443,
0.3700292408466339,
-0.4261349141597748,
0.7179656624794006,
0.1380729377269745,
-0.459134578704834,
0.03367232158780098,
-0.5990315079689026,
0.21071670949459076,
0.06395912915468216,
-0.1686108112335205,
-0.23560136556625366,
0.060109034180641174,
0.45414042472839355,
0.41528528928756714,
0.19451186060905457,
-0.4007355570793152,
0.06747220456600189,
-0.011459717527031898,
0.45196861028671265,
0.5942433476448059,
-0.2478073537349701,
0.37427762150764465,
-0.11523213237524033,
-0.1780150830745697,
0.18172314763069153,
-0.013895869255065918,
-0.4071142375469208,
-0.3006478250026703,
-0.7208253741264343,
-0.5106172561645508,
-0.016273073852062225,
0.3836517333984375,
-0.9170054197311401,
0.004880962427705526,
-0.11020854860544205,
-0.46931853890419006,
-0.33233442902565,
0.15829135477542877,
0.6318440437316895,
0.6194328665733337,
0.6265488862991333,
-0.12807197868824005,
-0.48751893639564514,
-0.968442976474762,
-0.20771628618240356,
0.11156323552131653,
0.11893748492002487,
0.5888441801071167,
0.7317361235618591,
-0.20156580209732056,
0.8668429255485535,
-0.11553123593330383,
-0.43332192301750183,
0.013043321669101715,
0.3999600112438202,
-0.17267349362373352,
0.5107123851776123,
0.4897676706314087,
-0.8572322726249695,
-0.8096405267715454,
0.04468671604990959,
-0.9872485399246216,
0.042418092489242554,
-0.09675417840480804,
0.10882773995399475,
0.5306707620620728,
0.8662540912628174,
-0.2749541997909546,
0.41017040610313416,
0.8314581513404846,
-0.4628167450428009,
0.24645984172821045,
-0.44310906529426575,
0.061031144112348557,
-1.1812808513641357,
0.2806480824947357,
-0.02731124870479107,
-0.31152433156967163,
-0.6315445899963379,
-0.06584502011537552,
0.4643266797065735,
-0.12648862600326538,
-0.43523842096328735,
0.8616712093353271,
-0.6523930430412292,
-0.2937735319137573,
-0.15179307758808136,
-0.13963092863559723,
-0.08871454000473022,
0.6545390486717224,
0.08183672279119492,
0.8703868985176086,
0.5282296538352966,
-0.5621492862701416,
-0.010768274776637554,
0.16882994771003723,
-0.6367318630218506,
0.5492870211601257,
-0.2913628816604614,
0.5238245129585266,
-0.3660733103752136,
0.4389306306838989,
-1.2425189018249512,
-0.2619069218635559,
0.14632242918014526,
-0.07634599506855011,
0.44824719429016113,
0.2096690833568573,
-0.5620392560958862,
-0.05465340614318848,
-0.14090010523796082,
0.7555726766586304,
0.4098195731639862,
-0.7963244915008545,
0.5271210670471191,
0.16956254839897156,
0.18574407696723938,
-0.6435505151748657,
-0.780661404132843,
0.37536635994911194,
-0.10077252238988876,
-0.35349154472351074,
0.4496150612831116,
-0.15870337188243866,
-0.1592494398355484,
0.11686922609806061,
0.18003159761428833,
-0.07126233726739883,
0.08059000968933105,
0.2378908097743988,
0.1504669338464737,
0.02214777283370495,
0.3710413873195648,
0.1384800225496292,
-0.04552236199378967,
-0.19732603430747986,
-0.14255690574645996,
0.4657502770423889,
-0.2911379933357239,
-0.3783431947231293,
-0.4773998260498047,
0.5305854082107544,
0.3287685215473175,
-0.2640094757080078,
0.3652172088623047,
0.7490012049674988,
-0.3249363601207733,
-0.17110790312290192,
-0.5238529443740845,
-0.044684041291475296,
-0.43596285581588745,
0.6287685632705688,
-0.4396668076515198,
-0.9962948560714722,
0.09484754502773285,
-0.24671408534049988,
0.1814509779214859,
0.15442924201488495,
0.7157213091850281,
-0.6564981937408447,
0.7936201095581055,
0.5454527139663696,
0.2159055471420288,
0.5034070014953613,
-0.27739816904067993,
0.06232659891247749,
-0.809043288230896,
-0.5291650295257568,
-0.10772961378097534,
-0.5713927745819092,
-0.529145359992981,
-0.46403276920318604,
0.6742377877235413,
-0.14795881509780884,
-0.2718012034893036,
0.13366368412971497,
-0.17474940419197083,
0.3599546253681183,
0.4606839120388031,
0.511872410774231,
0.12437034398317337,
0.23590850830078125,
-0.05777754262089729,
0.021579207852482796,
-0.5420994162559509,
-0.35352838039398193,
0.9974005818367004,
0.15856683254241943,
0.5942776799201965,
0.10996901988983154,
0.41099366545677185,
0.3410469591617584,
0.620942234992981,
-0.6181933283805847,
0.5792360901832581,
-0.35073134303092957,
-0.6413455605506897,
-0.21616221964359283,
-0.06429282575845718,
-0.8644616603851318,
0.14612606167793274,
-0.23176218569278717,
-0.7303059101104736,
0.10652292519807816,
0.3683568239212036,
0.09130289405584335,
0.23283177614212036,
-0.8411951661109924,
0.8867828249931335,
-0.5230929255485535,
-0.71231609582901,
-0.2775499224662781,
-0.8638337850570679,
0.03984298184514046,
-0.024410748854279518,
0.22572605311870575,
-0.14572282135486603,
-0.2964213490486145,
0.3550666272640228,
0.03952489793300629,
0.8636356592178345,
-0.1710396707057953,
0.008025914430618286,
0.27469146251678467,
0.07961686700582504,
0.5114113688468933,
-0.2064334601163864,
0.013356620445847511,
0.19366887211799622,
-0.07489108294248581,
-0.5811802744865417,
-0.3764890730381012,
0.48024243116378784,
-0.5959798097610474,
-0.1910121589899063,
-0.1304117739200592,
-0.7922954559326172,
-0.4679347276687622,
0.03535555303096771,
0.38539060950279236,
0.9870285391807556,
-0.16486069560050964,
0.4355362355709076,
0.5883505344390869,
-0.22330251336097717,
0.8019702434539795,
0.09537868946790695,
-0.1539374440908432,
-0.3407140374183655,
1.0685869455337524,
0.024969590827822685,
0.2846324145793915,
0.6358711123466492,
0.09592706710100174,
-0.40198811888694763,
-0.5493809580802917,
-0.6069285273551941,
-0.1157555803656578,
-0.8187251687049866,
-0.10668712854385376,
-0.45665377378463745,
-0.002605397952720523,
0.10306989401578903,
-0.19890658557415009,
-0.2011197805404663,
0.1849283128976822,
-0.3745785653591156,
0.46330973505973816,
-0.016198813915252686,
0.6686108708381653,
0.2730047106742859,
0.043332286179065704,
-0.570434033870697,
0.14756885170936584,
0.22467605769634247,
0.4350050985813141,
0.08565475046634674,
-0.451753705739975,
-0.3837278485298157,
-0.07149666547775269,
-0.30939000844955444,
-0.376173198223114,
0.10258613526821136,
0.42198190093040466,
0.19470462203025818,
0.1057552918791771,
-0.11470840126276016,
0.9044616222381592,
-0.5706583261489868,
0.6416780948638916,
0.24153074622154236,
-0.8388413786888123,
0.32472527027130127,
-0.1704723984003067,
0.34031781554222107,
0.4041062593460083,
0.3261094093322754,
-0.5254532098770142,
-0.25170865654945374,
-0.21727649867534637,
-0.632035493850708,
0.4511271119117737,
0.17285661399364471,
0.13499042391777039,
0.1381039023399353,
0.29050278663635254,
0.26848897337913513,
0.16668696701526642,
-0.6953866481781006,
-0.02631548047065735,
0.02153637260198593,
-0.5788314342498779,
-0.21343876421451569,
-0.34730565547943115,
0.01049966923892498,
-0.19338572025299072,
0.34915196895599365,
-0.3884274363517761,
0.31728339195251465,
0.3184669613838196,
-0.6666264533996582,
-0.15984103083610535,
0.3178582191467285,
0.8502722382545471,
0.6270069479942322,
-0.2749384641647339,
0.2104998528957367,
0.27222710847854614,
-0.15601219236850739,
0.19406141340732574,
-0.1926611065864563,
-0.14209136366844177,
-0.2865910530090332,
0.6415727138519287,
1.154707670211792,
0.31043878197669983,
-1.0503895282745361,
0.650490403175354,
-0.06905870139598846,
-0.39513272047042847,
-0.31666266918182373,
-0.3958072066307068,
-0.10242146998643875,
0.5132660865783691,
0.6346336603164673,
0.12539604306221008,
-0.010199194774031639,
-0.6610713601112366,
0.22980359196662903,
0.7257368564605713,
-0.5982481837272644,
-0.25428155064582825,
0.49705296754837036,
0.12759964168071747,
-0.2836267352104187,
0.6710346937179565,
-0.06702249497175217,
-0.3061050474643707,
0.6565105319023132,
0.7894816398620605,
0.707405149936676,
0.33711546659469604,
-0.09235829859972,
0.24242529273033142,
0.2688748240470886,
0.19294166564941406,
0.17303681373596191,
-0.10917016863822937,
-0.5747367739677429,
-0.234746053814888,
-0.13695628941059113,
-0.5175814032554626,
0.26936110854148865,
-0.4041053354740143,
0.4224412143230438,
-0.4745827913284302,
-0.01441858522593975,
-0.23800574243068695,
-0.13761068880558014,
-0.8061572909355164,
0.5314295291900635,
0.4315786063671112,
0.777298092842102,
-0.5427801012992859,
0.8339777588844299,
0.7898370623588562,
0.03984246775507927,
-0.6442165970802307,
0.14955835044384003,
-0.18242289125919342,
-0.8250483870506287,
0.9791345596313477,
0.6608161926269531,
-0.11899974942207336,
0.23823049664497375,
-0.734099268913269,
-0.6094759702682495,
1.350810170173645,
0.325548380613327,
-0.6169520020484924,
-0.06069518253207207,
0.31521862745285034,
0.5098055601119995,
-0.5306176543235779,
0.3109247088432312,
0.18422819674015045,
0.33330631256103516,
0.10539784282445908,
-0.7759828567504883,
-0.0039021915290504694,
-0.040865398943424225,
0.09290939569473267,
0.05551155284047127,
-0.889997124671936,
0.7494850158691406,
-0.3637019395828247,
-0.275295227766037,
0.08197549730539322,
0.5047503113746643,
0.16001145541667938,
0.7835015654563904,
0.6704243421554565,
0.3924102783203125,
0.5494807362556458,
-0.11174950748682022,
0.8947498202323914,
-0.09771814197301865,
0.4770115315914154,
1.1237117052078247,
-0.28737673163414,
1.1259713172912598,
0.8535670638084412,
0.23071588575839996,
0.43351659178733826,
0.8168258666992188,
-0.10363829880952835,
0.7382401823997498,
-0.09827466309070587,
-0.2598521411418915,
-0.33368831872940063,
-0.2729383707046509,
0.009390450082719326,
0.4052429795265198,
0.5705813765525818,
-0.22321340441703796,
-0.3568412959575653,
0.3325284719467163,
-0.47751399874687195,
-0.015133649110794067,
-0.28282874822616577,
0.9059232473373413,
0.07183478027582169,
-0.6526669859886169,
0.46938520669937134,
-0.43196019530296326,
0.6143126487731934,
-0.42182961106300354,
-0.1411333680152893,
0.04768988862633705,
0.2755082845687866,
-0.045831672847270966,
-0.925299882888794,
0.20688779652118683,
-0.12635254859924316,
-0.018339721485972404,
-0.3135678768157959,
0.8750534653663635,
-0.7078649997711182,
-0.35376882553100586,
0.38502034544944763,
0.3385384976863861,
-0.043460119515657425,
0.13809576630592346,
-0.6020660996437073,
0.20778629183769226,
-0.19857269525527954,
-0.2155323624610901,
0.3667064905166626,
0.15491794049739838,
-0.2951226830482483,
0.8129621744155884,
0.1891852617263794,
-0.5384876132011414,
0.029316723346710205,
-0.19439177215099335,
0.6096199750900269,
-0.49983343482017517,
-0.13670660555362701,
-1.0844377279281616,
0.6400715708732605,
0.02262907288968563,
-0.20703424513339996,
0.3078293204307556,
0.7731122374534607,
1.049487590789795,
-0.21283622086048126,
0.8692413568496704,
-0.3072609305381775,
0.2204485684633255,
-0.6818457245826721,
0.49381184577941895,
-1.1869312524795532,
-0.27875036001205444,
-0.05278147757053375,
-0.4406328797340393,
-0.30529552698135376,
0.07299024611711502,
-0.15541860461235046,
-0.12569615244865417,
0.9959656596183777,
0.8464537858963013,
-0.08270664513111115,
-0.20683492720127106,
0.5364095568656921,
-0.06010531261563301,
0.4433162212371826,
0.77996826171875,
0.849894642829895,
-0.7137734293937683,
0.6752385497093201,
-0.2420649230480194,
-0.03402715176343918,
-0.41949939727783203,
-1.120843768119812,
-1.195070505142212,
-0.9382001161575317,
-0.06581257283687592,
-0.29669418931007385,
0.09502752870321274,
1.3613828420639038,
0.7178352475166321,
-0.7359373569488525,
-0.3855789601802826,
-0.02029593475162983,
-0.15831413865089417,
-0.17580868303775787,
-0.06081971153616905,
0.5789871215820312,
-0.49011874198913574,
-0.7430644631385803,
0.15626326203346252,
0.5350825786590576,
0.072832852602005,
-0.025957075878977776,
-0.11407164484262466,
-0.27176088094711304,
-0.21687914431095123,
0.9687877297401428,
0.0854901596903801,
-0.7713977694511414,
-0.4181036949157715,
-0.10225097090005875,
-0.5065203905105591,
0.23092733323574066,
0.9085102677345276,
-0.44456514716148376,
0.4498041868209839,
0.10410135984420776,
0.9856379628181458,
0.7331450581550598,
-0.30934759974479675,
0.22608515620231628,
-0.9987846612930298,
0.23605769872665405,
0.02409188635647297,
0.13097859919071198,
0.3890915513038635,
-0.20060977339744568,
0.3789694905281067,
0.16721802949905396,
-0.3497287631034851,
-0.7601724863052368,
0.25220292806625366,
-1.0862300395965576,
-0.28882065415382385,
1.067676305770874,
0.028291989117860794,
-0.23277701437473297,
-0.052152641117572784,
-0.4515385329723358,
0.24851900339126587,
-0.12463415414094925,
0.6920300722122192,
0.6792536377906799,
-0.10793523490428925,
-0.5266171097755432,
-0.46328163146972656,
0.3683219254016876,
0.5540136098861694,
-0.9660700559616089,
-0.13824693858623505,
0.3229130506515503,
0.39777815341949463,
-0.20027241110801697,
0.551629364490509,
0.23283891379833221,
0.2879542410373688,
-0.25121229887008667,
-0.13553765416145325,
-0.14721201360225677,
-0.33632662892341614,
0.0493919663131237,
0.27581948041915894,
0.011558170430362225,
-0.023366732522845268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01806v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01806v1 | HQA-Attack: Toward High Quality Black-Box Hard-Label Adversarial Attack on Text | 2024-02-02T10:06:43 | 2024-02-02T10:06:43 | Han Liu, Zhi Xu, Xiaotong Zhang, Feng Zhang, Fenglong Ma, Hongyang Chen, Hong Yu, Xianchao Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Black-box hard-label adversarial attack on text is a practical and
challenging task, as the text data space is inherently discrete and
non-differentiable, and only the predicted label is accessible. Research on
this problem is still in the embryonic stage and only a few methods are
available. Nevertheless, existing methods rely on the complex heuristic
algorithm or unreliable gradient estimation strategy, which probably fall into
the local optimum and inevitably consume numerous queries, thus are difficult
to craft satisfactory adversarial examples with high semantic similarity and
low perturbation rate in a limited query budget. To alleviate above issues, we
propose a simple yet effective framework to generate high quality textual
adversarial examples under the black-box hard-label attack scenarios, named
HQA-Attack. Specifically, after initializing an adversarial example randomly,
HQA-attack first constantly substitutes original words back as many as
possible, thus shrinking the perturbation rate. Then it leverages the synonym
set of the remaining changed words to further optimize the adversarial example
with the direction which can improve the semantic similarity and satisfy the
adversarial condition simultaneously. In addition, during the optimizing
procedure, it searches a transition synonym word for each changed word, thus
avoiding traversing the whole synonym set and reducing the query number to some
extent. Extensive experimental results on five text classification datasets,
three natural language inference datasets and two real-world APIs have shown
that the proposed HQA-Attack method outperforms other strong baselines
significantly. | [
-0.4525851011276245,
-1.205636739730835,
0.3313825726509094,
0.035492051392793655,
-0.2716226875782013,
0.04003780335187912,
0.09292425215244293,
-0.23518167436122894,
0.2700742781162262,
0.587760865688324,
-0.4292050302028656,
-0.5432535409927368,
-0.6926440000534058,
0.05308804288506508,
-0.4326593279838562,
0.9615585207939148,
0.18675613403320312,
-0.2672854959964752,
0.2776220142841339,
-0.29149460792541504,
-0.5467010140419006,
-0.832460880279541,
-0.609164834022522,
-0.2200998216867447,
0.6562477350234985,
0.08687055110931396,
1.1268919706344604,
0.7499620318412781,
0.5794792175292969,
0.2581835091114044,
-0.261968731880188,
-0.10045728087425232,
-0.7257601022720337,
0.19013546407222748,
-0.1685376614332199,
-0.2938382029533386,
-0.21089668571949005,
0.1590774655342102,
0.5567246079444885,
0.40231767296791077,
-0.28508251905441284,
-0.11796384304761887,
-0.019669055938720703,
0.6915709972381592,
-0.9986156821250916,
-0.37817394733428955,
-0.9851047396659851,
0.1970953792333603,
-0.36150693893432617,
-0.06579524278640747,
-0.4042990505695343,
-0.006367851048707962,
0.05341758951544762,
-0.8342864513397217,
0.12205378711223602,
-0.010323502123355865,
1.306914210319519,
0.21034784615039825,
-0.3407931327819824,
-0.13775894045829773,
-0.5308979153633118,
0.6961677670478821,
-0.5953390598297119,
0.1315704584121704,
0.29042187333106995,
0.2264508157968521,
-0.6270308494567871,
-0.8397849202156067,
-0.7365895509719849,
-0.09687846153974533,
0.19134381413459778,
0.1527235060930252,
-0.4775480628013611,
0.02817828767001629,
0.1633882373571396,
0.1650080531835556,
-0.49073711037635803,
0.1319943070411682,
0.160674050450325,
-0.0660819336771965,
0.35344788432121277,
0.12602287530899048,
0.3153705894947052,
-0.4020366668701172,
-0.7733917236328125,
-0.3637606203556061,
-0.8211460709571838,
-0.23723219335079193,
0.33757689595222473,
0.09583339840173721,
0.03354482352733612,
0.47999221086502075,
-0.2414904087781906,
0.5702778100967407,
0.02674168162047863,
0.06277983635663986,
-0.05489097535610199,
-0.34062615036964417,
-0.36662107706069946,
-0.06978218257427216,
1.0097068548202515,
0.08919432014226913,
-0.24846062064170837,
-0.44283902645111084,
-0.20648224651813507,
0.3672488033771515,
0.6876348257064819,
-1.023485779762268,
-0.26351630687713623,
0.23303386569023132,
-0.1957855373620987,
-0.4086223840713501,
-0.07045194506645203,
-1.1588939428329468,
-0.41949889063835144,
-0.14847873151302338,
0.7345467209815979,
-0.21297933161258698,
0.21341519057750702,
0.04429572448134422,
-0.2205132395029068,
0.06659258157014847,
-0.01367772463709116,
-0.5347735285758972,
0.11296403408050537,
0.6008709073066711,
0.49735933542251587,
-0.135056734085083,
-0.2993687391281128,
-0.6252541542053223,
0.22817040979862213,
-0.4950103461742401,
0.7468857169151306,
-0.2752339541912079,
-0.42155367136001587,
0.00436454126611352,
-0.24534761905670166,
0.11257721483707428,
-0.37736448645591736,
0.6699061989784241,
-0.933597207069397,
0.2976686358451843,
-0.03353029489517212,
-0.43381819128990173,
-0.04911182075738907,
0.6384860873222351,
-0.7971698045730591,
0.8928321003913879,
-0.01245876494795084,
-0.8158982992172241,
0.18062427639961243,
-0.31312811374664307,
-0.4705784022808075,
0.18618719279766083,
-0.039257727563381195,
-0.7084522247314453,
-0.12549211084842682,
0.36305007338523865,
0.3813492953777313,
-0.41403189301490784,
-0.09289202839136124,
-0.3398602306842804,
-0.3175429105758667,
0.48307082056999207,
-0.5085694789886475,
0.9278048872947693,
0.11622533202171326,
-0.6783716678619385,
-0.049316562712192535,
-0.7032007575035095,
0.09435661137104034,
0.4994446933269501,
-0.2679044008255005,
-0.6508129239082336,
0.029528312385082245,
-0.09471400827169418,
-0.005518211051821709,
0.22322994470596313,
-0.3519810736179352,
0.2887380123138428,
-0.7384616136550903,
0.14533807337284088,
0.6302548050880432,
0.3798721730709076,
0.29365646839141846,
-0.1843433529138565,
0.48074331879615784,
-0.34153419733047485,
0.30125692486763,
0.13307690620422363,
-0.4766893684864044,
-0.40992701053619385,
-0.3428235650062561,
0.5079495310783386,
0.7495118975639343,
-1.1798590421676636,
0.4047175645828247,
-0.049062442034482956,
-0.48233896493911743,
-0.5964804887771606,
0.3125017285346985,
0.6444834470748901,
0.3291764259338379,
0.46705034375190735,
-0.25297605991363525,
-0.3430134654045105,
-0.6714516878128052,
-0.3089098334312439,
-0.02867833897471428,
-0.19631816446781158,
0.18719974160194397,
0.4480028450489044,
-0.40787777304649353,
0.5985087156295776,
-0.8226889967918396,
-0.4267638027667999,
0.09943414479494095,
0.34497395157814026,
-0.016085822135210037,
0.18857845664024353,
0.5833399891853333,
-0.9945089817047119,
-0.27378761768341064,
-0.2934965193271637,
-0.85074383020401,
0.24483951926231384,
-0.14694060385227203,
-0.653829038143158,
-0.08625232428312302,
0.35072362422943115,
-0.6652803421020508,
0.4034659266471863,
0.47081294655799866,
-0.3666975200176239,
0.48415547609329224,
-0.1620270311832428,
0.23675969243049622,
-1.2092353105545044,
-0.18219590187072754,
0.06474597752094269,
0.29767537117004395,
-0.7500269412994385,
0.7453470230102539,
-0.20680078864097595,
-0.3524065315723419,
-0.5527312159538269,
0.6127546429634094,
-0.2310025840997696,
0.4237178862094879,
-0.3884371519088745,
0.17380206286907196,
0.09387072920799255,
0.586123526096344,
-0.5024030208587646,
0.6177485585212708,
0.3446185886859894,
-0.4902109205722809,
0.3886154890060425,
0.3938717842102051,
-0.06544343382120132,
0.7529264688491821,
-0.5944927930831909,
0.3610864579677582,
-0.06779834628105164,
0.29879358410835266,
-0.8236436247825623,
0.010546267963945866,
0.44745752215385437,
-0.6042932271957397,
0.3386666774749756,
0.04586822912096977,
-0.565644383430481,
-0.144398495554924,
-0.45617958903312683,
0.1966208964586258,
0.3942844867706299,
-0.7627261877059937,
0.3893386423587799,
0.5614383816719055,
0.0045705256052315235,
-0.8933601975440979,
-0.5274669528007507,
0.8684414029121399,
-0.23765474557876587,
-0.21777081489562988,
0.6681594848632812,
-0.10362493246793747,
-0.10763143748044968,
-0.04486874118447304,
0.1554778814315796,
-0.3204156160354614,
0.3766951560974121,
0.03740055859088898,
0.25076523423194885,
-0.06042852997779846,
-0.29357674717903137,
-0.17803333699703217,
-0.06543900072574615,
0.010726304724812508,
-0.2843344807624817,
0.3362137973308563,
0.11057306826114655,
0.09384597837924957,
-0.665949285030365,
0.36534079909324646,
0.5174693465232849,
-0.10579803586006165,
0.8516884446144104,
0.540177047252655,
-0.7450875639915466,
-0.21974486112594604,
-0.30178481340408325,
-0.19659794867038727,
-0.47878873348236084,
0.3443722724914551,
-0.3491111695766449,
-0.36794570088386536,
0.06856638938188553,
0.2225169986486435,
0.15616077184677124,
0.27347052097320557,
0.4416935443878174,
-0.2047218531370163,
1.0078059434890747,
0.1545267403125763,
-0.24726741015911102,
0.372283935546875,
-0.39577409625053406,
0.03417398780584335,
-0.6531832814216614,
-0.022089384496212006,
-0.8208041787147522,
-0.0547514446079731,
-0.6237821578979492,
-0.18816311657428741,
0.18231114745140076,
0.16833467781543732,
-0.2763693332672119,
0.5701153874397278,
-0.594573974609375,
0.18774496018886566,
0.4269614517688751,
0.25861650705337524,
-0.08690604567527771,
0.40895870327949524,
-0.09744351357221603,
-0.24473066627979279,
-0.6948837637901306,
-0.3269484341144562,
0.9866586923599243,
0.2298690378665924,
0.6109582781791687,
0.25901147723197937,
0.6418080925941467,
0.4979332387447357,
0.572939932346344,
-0.7019409537315369,
0.5842564702033997,
-0.4349447786808014,
-0.5612106323242188,
-0.34954139590263367,
-0.5276339650154114,
-1.3621876239776611,
0.4325033724308014,
-0.5547166466712952,
-0.409207284450531,
0.1400463581085205,
0.09657678008079529,
0.005155263468623161,
0.34756457805633545,
-0.454135924577713,
0.893159031867981,
0.11438971757888794,
-0.337108314037323,
-0.010490176267921925,
-0.2959970533847809,
0.15190096199512482,
-0.17554153501987457,
0.21409256756305695,
0.2073609083890915,
-0.06737309694290161,
0.8489331007003784,
-0.28789278864860535,
0.6727555990219116,
-0.12803755700588226,
-0.1888374537229538,
0.3639061450958252,
0.18209649622440338,
0.6961559653282166,
-0.053965047001838684,
-0.019615590572357178,
0.24367496371269226,
-0.31342750787734985,
-0.7040320634841919,
-0.6711860299110413,
0.5854050517082214,
-0.5303474068641663,
-0.4503926634788513,
-0.4154132008552551,
-0.18084758520126343,
-0.1269901692867279,
0.2306055873632431,
0.4682924151420593,
0.6030178070068359,
-0.41563549637794495,
0.23651251196861267,
0.6507620811462402,
-0.1447523534297943,
0.2185075283050537,
0.26503193378448486,
0.5019857883453369,
-0.8423032760620117,
1.2145196199417114,
-0.04289320111274719,
0.10991741716861725,
0.7088483572006226,
0.20111580193042755,
-0.429470419883728,
-0.7410793900489807,
-0.7438011169433594,
0.07991380244493484,
-0.46438461542129517,
-0.45165127515792847,
-0.41180500388145447,
0.03864073380827904,
-0.3235306143760681,
-0.23316225409507751,
-0.2075396478176117,
-0.09789101779460907,
-0.3011195957660675,
0.22697557508945465,
0.08204006403684616,
0.3586583733558655,
0.4310780465602875,
0.5303647518157959,
-0.5905849933624268,
0.8744641542434692,
0.5878194570541382,
0.11595458537340164,
0.044026754796504974,
-0.34086498618125916,
-0.1738864630460739,
0.09612741321325302,
-0.6955889463424683,
-1.2350728511810303,
0.4438640773296356,
-0.07762173563241959,
0.3739582896232605,
0.2632383704185486,
0.3271273672580719,
0.33637771010398865,
-0.4448157846927643,
0.6177807450294495,
0.2698414921760559,
-0.6098921298980713,
0.3293560743331909,
-0.2598727345466614,
0.3828643560409546,
0.6579493880271912,
0.3658376634120941,
-0.16323542594909668,
-0.508669376373291,
-0.7202029824256897,
-0.8588682413101196,
0.20982977747917175,
0.6816843152046204,
0.06459460407495499,
-0.04554932191967964,
0.4843020737171173,
-0.3200317323207855,
0.22420479357242584,
-0.6737411022186279,
-0.5987371206283569,
-0.25685933232307434,
-0.16002137959003448,
0.08348460495471954,
-0.1305524706840515,
-0.2838174104690552,
0.0660170465707779,
0.9332515597343445,
-0.007089976686984301,
0.17212535440921783,
0.09703546017408371,
-0.07190029323101044,
0.20498360693454742,
0.6088818907737732,
0.09707410633563995,
0.28576213121414185,
-0.08927731961011887,
0.05556633695960045,
0.2136479765176773,
-0.7394765019416809,
0.4802365005016327,
0.5052064657211304,
-0.576108455657959,
-0.0662107765674591,
0.15922896564006805,
0.559199333190918,
0.33534830808639526,
-0.5185461044311523,
0.5124157071113586,
-0.32194194197654724,
-0.21625638008117676,
0.00816066563129425,
-0.1796971559524536,
-0.16684295237064362,
-0.10717383027076721,
0.4934826195240021,
-0.28051379323005676,
0.22576962411403656,
-0.45514416694641113,
0.3882904350757599,
0.7205782532691956,
-0.6551365852355957,
0.034013450145721436,
0.5900758504867554,
0.1605585366487503,
-0.5008225440979004,
0.44811955094337463,
-0.5361382961273193,
-0.7071648240089417,
0.7075091004371643,
0.4639229476451874,
0.8087156414985657,
-0.3409646451473236,
0.21814197301864624,
0.10024057328701019,
0.4195941090583801,
0.04624198377132416,
-0.02711411751806736,
0.19739758968353271,
-0.6055451035499573,
-0.1663418859243393,
-0.6236792802810669,
-0.44481170177459717,
0.5216377377510071,
-0.6146331429481506,
-0.03513210639357567,
-0.6237413287162781,
-0.2671565115451813,
0.2391810268163681,
0.1626708060503006,
-0.3920269012451172,
0.47682642936706543,
-0.20227713882923126,
0.5515097975730896,
-0.29338502883911133,
0.5424844622612,
0.7182224988937378,
-0.29458677768707275,
-0.36687740683555603,
0.17976607382297516,
-0.052865222096443176,
-0.3824230134487152,
0.2621476948261261,
-0.07318739593029022,
-0.09653744846582413,
-0.1564219892024994,
-0.3360868990421295,
-0.4724838435649872,
0.6896790862083435,
0.2232784926891327,
-0.4078783094882965,
-0.1969687044620514,
-0.08974366635084152,
0.5101169943809509,
0.11143270879983902,
-0.3251120448112488,
0.5785760283470154,
0.38171321153640747,
-0.12993548810482025,
-0.19232027232646942,
0.2924961745738983,
-0.05408760532736778,
-0.06799393892288208,
0.4798571467399597,
-0.37169525027275085,
0.5047651529312134,
0.023763561621308327,
-0.4876391887664795,
0.14816506206989288,
0.8557047247886658,
0.15294350683689117,
0.3753811717033386,
0.5008408427238464,
0.9030263423919678,
0.38514721393585205,
0.06350847333669662,
1.123913288116455,
-0.1456885188817978,
0.24199126660823822,
0.9184250831604004,
-0.1639159619808197,
1.0011210441589355,
0.15310223400592804,
-0.16220493614673615,
0.3412773311138153,
0.41274216771125793,
-0.19119013845920563,
0.4415813684463501,
0.3650985658168793,
-0.4096321761608124,
0.05523744970560074,
-0.08379462361335754,
-0.3388528823852539,
0.3099465072154999,
0.3431917726993561,
0.12979017198085785,
-0.149421826004982,
0.12770511209964752,
0.29788145422935486,
0.4326832890510559,
-0.12597119808197021,
0.887690544128418,
0.034119851887226105,
-0.534549355506897,
1.0830228328704834,
0.2819872498512268,
0.8051595687866211,
-0.5143461227416992,
-0.01815660297870636,
-0.11887304484844208,
0.10565875470638275,
0.22614847123622894,
-0.4489132761955261,
-0.09565198421478271,
-0.025403080508112907,
-0.17077581584453583,
0.1462182104587555,
0.45398786664009094,
-0.19082388281822205,
-0.273141086101532,
0.3732221722602844,
0.09524106234312057,
-0.15171784162521362,
-0.20991094410419464,
-1.0451620817184448,
-0.29835012555122375,
-0.24353618919849396,
-0.24364499747753143,
0.5694726705551147,
0.27607348561286926,
0.17674587666988373,
0.37307366728782654,
0.7717208862304688,
0.3442877233028412,
-0.20007292926311493,
-0.068015918135643,
0.5835587978363037,
-0.6650949716567993,
-0.6210135817527771,
-0.649915337562561,
-0.09937479346990585,
-0.23314185440540314,
-0.3235613703727722,
0.5852054357528687,
0.2952221632003784,
0.648314893245697,
0.2674054801464081,
0.5617638826370239,
0.28221067786216736,
0.20068594813346863,
-0.6850479245185852,
0.8930540084838867,
-0.5857043862342834,
0.09789343923330307,
-0.4835694432258606,
-0.8298112750053406,
-0.2738664448261261,
0.12333434075117111,
0.2151736170053482,
-0.24525493383407593,
0.8455073237419128,
0.7687215805053711,
0.11666639149188995,
-0.25883397459983826,
0.25429075956344604,
0.3534698188304901,
0.5689150094985962,
0.5163666605949402,
0.5816715359687805,
-0.8828516006469727,
0.9657468795776367,
-0.26742127537727356,
-0.40324828028678894,
-0.13872919976711273,
-0.8915824294090271,
-0.856908917427063,
-0.4850284159183502,
-0.29077741503715515,
-0.8063794374465942,
0.5180085897445679,
0.4742407202720642,
0.6730751991271973,
-0.5854182839393616,
0.058124031871557236,
0.18348948657512665,
0.27453210949897766,
-0.2944315969944,
-0.307295560836792,
0.7461989521980286,
-0.0593017153441906,
-0.5133548378944397,
0.4841689169406891,
0.04682660475373268,
0.2393793910741806,
-0.14980389177799225,
0.16655424237251282,
-0.27083584666252136,
0.3895629942417145,
0.5815380215644836,
0.5783085227012634,
-0.41789788007736206,
0.006665715016424656,
-0.31157350540161133,
-0.515230655670166,
-0.007811983115971088,
0.7313852906227112,
-0.7314401865005493,
0.35855376720428467,
0.37581297755241394,
1.200850009918213,
0.2529813051223755,
0.14149728417396545,
0.3255111277103424,
-0.7243967056274414,
0.16050903499126434,
0.19763068854808807,
0.17377477884292603,
0.3911334276199341,
-0.5595390796661377,
0.10168220847845078,
0.39515021443367004,
-0.27803754806518555,
-0.9446231722831726,
0.11913161724805832,
-0.8665907382965088,
-0.7524603009223938,
1.0590472221374512,
-0.024075781926512718,
-0.4115910530090332,
-0.18441836535930634,
-0.22646014392375946,
0.14141155779361725,
-0.38621577620506287,
1.1384855508804321,
0.4858795404434204,
0.4090734124183655,
0.5121188759803772,
-0.5359473824501038,
0.533224880695343,
0.4529176652431488,
-1.2117782831192017,
0.02412649616599083,
0.36389869451522827,
-0.0017615556716918945,
0.28389278054237366,
0.4096467196941376,
-0.10198815166950226,
0.4321509003639221,
0.1730279177427292,
-0.20506690442562103,
0.06591076403856277,
-0.4843222200870514,
-0.3430207371711731,
0.7141167521476746,
-0.22679051756858826,
-0.33750706911087036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01805v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01805v3 | Can LLMs perform structured graph reasoning? | 2024-02-02T09:45:33 | 2024-04-18T12:04:12 | Palaash Agrawal, Shavak Vasania, Cheston Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pretrained Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated various reasoning
capabilities through language-based prompts alone, particularly in unstructured
task settings (tasks purely based on language semantics). However, LLMs often
struggle with structured tasks, because of the inherent incompatibility of
input representation. Reducing structured tasks to uni-dimensional language
semantics often renders the problem trivial. Keeping the trade-off between LLM
compatibility and structure complexity in mind, we design various graph
reasoning tasks as a proxy to semi-structured tasks in this paper, in order to
test the ability to navigate through representations beyond plain text in
various LLMs. Particularly, we design 10 distinct problems of graph traversal,
each representing increasing levels of complexity, and benchmark 5 different
instruct-finetuned LLMs (GPT-4, GPT-3.5, Claude-2, Llama-2 and Palm-2) on the
aforementioned tasks. Further, we analyse the performance of models across
various settings such as varying sizes of graphs as well as different forms of
k-shot prompting. We highlight various limitations, biases and properties of
LLMs through this benchmarking process, such as an inverse relation to the
average degrees of freedom of traversal per node in graphs, the overall
negative impact of k-shot prompting on graph reasoning tasks, and a positive
response bias which prevents LLMs from identifying the absence of a valid
solution. Finally, we introduce a new prompting technique specially designed
for graph traversal tasks (PathCompare), which demonstrates a notable increase
in the performance of LLMs in comparison to standard prompting techniques such
as Chain-of-Thought (CoT). | [
-0.15517158806324005,
-1.0414179563522339,
1.13154137134552,
0.17267894744873047,
-0.35137227177619934,
0.46262815594673157,
-0.09596940875053406,
-0.419819176197052,
-0.149643212556839,
0.3971230685710907,
-0.7770921587944031,
-0.8140371441841125,
-0.46791020035743713,
0.48128166794776917,
-0.2527047395706177,
0.5474339723587036,
-0.5579060912132263,
-0.056746359914541245,
-0.3886725604534149,
0.060973480343818665,
-0.5713234543800354,
-0.4368468225002289,
-0.6137275695800781,
-0.731936514377594,
0.6342382431030273,
0.14683674275875092,
0.5380756855010986,
0.4188612103462219,
0.08909978717565536,
0.34199973940849304,
-0.3470079004764557,
0.4779256582260132,
-0.4458889663219452,
0.15956717729568481,
-0.21902188658714294,
-0.3457120656967163,
-0.23136945068836212,
0.09270612895488739,
0.6762317419052124,
1.1918820142745972,
0.24135805666446686,
-0.1063162311911583,
0.29358503222465515,
0.4872094988822937,
-0.3560580015182495,
0.36776095628738403,
-0.44303685426712036,
0.07081180065870285,
-0.11862664669752121,
-0.11444655060768127,
-0.614923357963562,
-0.12314998358488083,
-0.15955086052417755,
-0.6746658682823181,
-0.11363314837217331,
0.33780500292778015,
0.7569599151611328,
0.32243335247039795,
-0.6461092233657837,
-0.3225415349006653,
-0.648009717464447,
0.3102690875530243,
-0.4975700080394745,
0.4863104522228241,
0.09792041778564453,
0.10044322162866592,
-0.5313875675201416,
-1.0077881813049316,
-0.31302058696746826,
-0.3625769019126892,
-0.10814597457647324,
0.048505302518606186,
-0.2102222591638565,
0.36322009563446045,
0.561820387840271,
-0.02030578814446926,
-0.5623420476913452,
0.28700992465019226,
-0.07052836567163467,
-0.31764113903045654,
0.3175818920135498,
0.25828877091407776,
0.2151041030883789,
-0.3204548954963684,
-0.21141459047794342,
-0.05392971262335777,
-0.7980855703353882,
0.3036527633666992,
0.4460315704345703,
0.39611056447029114,
0.06914707273244858,
0.6587190628051758,
-0.31570643186569214,
0.9759970307350159,
-0.0622200109064579,
-0.0778876468539238,
-0.016756294295191765,
-0.2847663462162018,
-0.1379089206457138,
-0.11634397506713867,
0.7513361573219299,
0.13091157376766205,
0.6956928372383118,
-0.14591774344444275,
-0.1946234107017517,
0.13094042241573334,
-0.015209728851914406,
-0.5535131096839905,
-0.49817973375320435,
0.13443107903003693,
-0.20299643278121948,
-0.014269709587097168,
-0.28784483671188354,
-0.27828627824783325,
-0.2426128387451172,
-0.1259467750787735,
0.3181076645851135,
-0.3867753744125366,
0.2025044560432434,
0.2750130295753479,
-0.18601928651332855,
-0.08092427998781204,
0.4669140875339508,
-0.4841834008693695,
0.25075557827949524,
0.511965811252594,
0.8568893074989319,
-0.20835274457931519,
-0.2578112483024597,
-0.6374860405921936,
0.17455682158470154,
-0.37429696321487427,
1.0986698865890503,
-0.7572838068008423,
-0.5715053081512451,
-0.07230958342552185,
0.1501956433057785,
-0.3490748107433319,
-0.41223010420799255,
0.43267014622688293,
-0.4519541561603546,
-0.0846359059214592,
-0.39958783984184265,
-0.603446900844574,
-0.18269501626491547,
0.6736720204353333,
-0.3560841381549835,
0.9850144982337952,
0.33836695551872253,
-0.6683753132820129,
0.04421204701066017,
-0.362329363822937,
-0.5764261484146118,
0.10922828316688538,
-0.38477468490600586,
-0.05793480575084686,
-0.25199204683303833,
0.29206717014312744,
0.3351140320301056,
-0.026580501347780228,
0.10712584853172302,
-0.43116995692253113,
-0.5875515937805176,
-0.03495042398571968,
-0.15547381341457367,
0.5974912643432617,
-0.12302380055189133,
-0.1489505171775818,
0.2784774899482727,
-0.5427916646003723,
0.2484395056962967,
0.24119333922863007,
-0.41737690567970276,
-0.1517709642648697,
0.05167088657617569,
-0.4692280888557434,
0.12721553444862366,
0.07230868935585022,
-0.4767000377178192,
0.5138395428657532,
-0.4060786962509155,
0.6907595992088318,
0.8515328764915466,
0.02173837274312973,
0.22324247658252716,
0.007202007342129946,
0.5717441439628601,
0.01879381388425827,
-0.14750908315181732,
-0.08446410298347473,
-0.4940245449542999,
-0.42531949281692505,
-0.2597997784614563,
0.17201881110668182,
0.550555944442749,
-0.8373937010765076,
-0.06149948760867119,
-0.13152183592319489,
-0.23402857780456543,
0.018724020570516586,
0.2656691372394562,
0.48778828978538513,
0.8427099585533142,
0.24197064340114594,
-0.07164360582828522,
-0.304207980632782,
-0.5833557844161987,
-0.17858529090881348,
-0.22481931746006012,
-0.12741945683956146,
0.6066448092460632,
0.517665445804596,
-0.18993577361106873,
0.598682165145874,
-0.5886419415473938,
0.12891711294651031,
-0.2829355299472809,
0.04612649977207184,
0.34503141045570374,
-0.02820614166557789,
0.21517504751682281,
-0.36621999740600586,
-0.4534163177013397,
-0.1905810385942459,
-0.8410323858261108,
-0.36390817165374756,
0.13709230720996857,
0.10756397247314453,
0.01363295316696167,
0.8030014634132385,
-0.8551254272460938,
0.33411917090415955,
0.3849918246269226,
-0.331882119178772,
0.5887016654014587,
-0.2551380395889282,
-0.15026718378067017,
-0.6122379302978516,
-0.1003471314907074,
-0.06979832798242569,
-0.4556645154953003,
-0.36520954966545105,
-0.056754350662231445,
-0.09618782997131348,
-0.16031600534915924,
-0.43233153223991394,
0.5756134390830994,
-0.6578120589256287,
-0.29538238048553467,
-0.22539325058460236,
0.3680090606212616,
0.24594126641750336,
0.5511891841888428,
0.03909621015191078,
0.7258203625679016,
0.539978563785553,
-0.6061486005783081,
0.5112078189849854,
0.299567312002182,
-0.19219611585140228,
0.43425512313842773,
-0.9333752989768982,
0.44070184230804443,
-0.20346707105636597,
0.6535207033157349,
-1.239250898361206,
-0.034740786999464035,
0.27280423045158386,
-0.1462198942899704,
0.3436737060546875,
-0.3143514394760132,
-0.7401307821273804,
-0.6319105625152588,
-0.12272360920906067,
0.4128912091255188,
0.3946785628795624,
-0.5069448351860046,
0.5166366100311279,
-0.18016764521598816,
0.07129091024398804,
-0.30680525302886963,
-0.28851982951164246,
0.08125898241996765,
-0.022257031872868538,
-0.8301190733909607,
0.31388112902641296,
-0.04785417020320892,
-0.22025886178016663,
0.020622970536351204,
-0.25563400983810425,
0.3686576187610626,
0.019539816305041313,
0.31886669993400574,
0.32638654112815857,
-0.09262776374816895,
-0.06430002301931381,
-0.02465682104229927,
-0.20357108116149902,
0.15237298607826233,
-0.5458616614341736,
0.6228410005569458,
-0.20685048401355743,
-0.7770935297012329,
-0.16469232738018036,
0.1801219880580902,
0.12478170543909073,
-0.11976222693920135,
0.20448550581932068,
0.14373889565467834,
-0.15387672185897827,
-0.22536049783229828,
-0.15778787434101105,
-0.038005612790584564,
-0.48741623759269714,
0.1878681182861328,
-0.5857600569725037,
-1.1476161479949951,
0.5644916892051697,
-0.610441267490387,
-0.20870737731456757,
0.12128572165966034,
0.4634835124015808,
-0.428676038980484,
1.3480372428894043,
0.14236775040626526,
0.1755199283361435,
0.13414376974105835,
-0.3617797791957855,
0.29384317994117737,
-0.7895604968070984,
-0.4078822433948517,
-0.48488643765449524,
-0.3657139837741852,
-0.6081345081329346,
-0.3308200538158417,
0.5081401467323303,
0.2441408485174179,
-0.40081387758255005,
0.14947988092899323,
-0.5164459943771362,
0.5523485541343689,
0.3944844901561737,
0.12510539591312408,
0.3194575309753418,
-0.20963582396507263,
-0.6231479048728943,
0.3640652894973755,
-0.7467845678329468,
-0.6000235676765442,
0.6365299820899963,
0.15556488931179047,
0.8692047595977783,
-0.3221762478351593,
0.5583168268203735,
0.08118531107902527,
-0.0034961728379130363,
-0.8635687232017517,
0.8890457153320312,
-0.042549218982458115,
-0.3215942680835724,
-0.30204251408576965,
-0.2863177955150604,
-1.0775498151779175,
0.10632038116455078,
0.08448148518800735,
-1.0063624382019043,
-0.07765926420688629,
0.008877548389136791,
-0.08784331381320953,
0.4074188470840454,
-0.4949878454208374,
0.8301852941513062,
-0.0634196475148201,
-0.26077377796173096,
0.18772335350513458,
-0.706764280796051,
0.12034669518470764,
0.16634751856327057,
0.04295187070965767,
-0.2556094229221344,
0.09475738555192947,
0.3499446213245392,
-0.45993006229400635,
0.9798297882080078,
-0.1561272144317627,
0.05842512845993042,
0.37206995487213135,
0.3085622489452362,
0.8689687848091125,
-0.18025119602680206,
0.10538959503173828,
0.089924156665802,
0.10286831855773926,
-0.37984421849250793,
-0.7960578799247742,
0.4687710702419281,
-0.5605471134185791,
-0.865539014339447,
-0.26184913516044617,
-0.7726679444313049,
-0.5392946600914001,
0.42337626218795776,
0.24690817296504974,
0.4549252390861511,
0.12841083109378815,
-0.1342925727367401,
0.5990809798240662,
0.11592616885900497,
0.20075169205665588,
0.278629332780838,
-0.1731916069984436,
0.14094644784927368,
0.49790242314338684,
0.18124447762966156,
0.26859772205352783,
0.33854275941848755,
0.20420527458190918,
-0.5703884363174438,
-0.9841187000274658,
-0.4776070713996887,
0.2027430683374405,
-0.9736073017120361,
-0.15094827115535736,
-0.4455849826335907,
-0.325799822807312,
-0.16972459852695465,
-0.20305489003658295,
-0.0010325800394639373,
-0.248397096991539,
-0.25348737835884094,
-0.2790422737598419,
0.04072616994380951,
0.9121381640434265,
0.17592094838619232,
0.1499410718679428,
-0.6023039817810059,
0.20294609665870667,
0.28123101592063904,
0.3048914670944214,
-0.11299195885658264,
-0.2928476929664612,
0.2512098252773285,
-0.07168877869844437,
-0.36541444063186646,
-0.9624235033988953,
-0.06504537165164948,
-0.18902498483657837,
0.5535314679145813,
0.2858353555202484,
0.07649987190961838,
0.6473612189292908,
-0.7315126657485962,
0.7149272561073303,
-0.12194157391786575,
-0.7957056164741516,
0.5956035852432251,
-0.5725404024124146,
0.13601818680763245,
0.39138659834861755,
0.44558703899383545,
-0.24747532606124878,
-0.5102694034576416,
-0.42159345746040344,
-0.502036452293396,
0.4447406530380249,
0.17972701787948608,
0.04048975557088852,
-0.15342071652412415,
0.7299447655677795,
-0.28689420223236084,
-0.01290557999163866,
-0.5777190923690796,
-0.039065077900886536,
-0.22826799750328064,
-0.034851331263780594,
-0.06191351264715195,
-0.0710720494389534,
-0.12741106748580933,
-0.290448933839798,
0.26875361800193787,
-0.41168496012687683,
0.024152375757694244,
0.3400917947292328,
0.07083965837955475,
0.04864732176065445,
0.15679937601089478,
0.3153163194656372,
0.6836858987808228,
-0.023051602765917778,
0.5012422800064087,
0.2933163642883301,
-0.03298785910010338,
0.3176064193248749,
0.08385581523180008,
-0.218781515955925,
-0.10579447448253632,
0.7153262495994568,
0.6908470392227173,
0.2767167389392853,
-0.6178098320960999,
0.27142441272735596,
0.20032067596912384,
-0.3801509141921997,
0.14653347432613373,
0.21096378564834595,
0.4271043539047241,
0.43655282258987427,
-0.04033844545483589,
-0.4793854057788849,
0.009557563811540604,
-0.6184751987457275,
-0.18767289817333221,
0.6959794759750366,
-0.3119828999042511,
-0.20883508026599884,
0.6555535793304443,
0.0022156366612762213,
-0.5882452130317688,
0.9533941745758057,
-0.36024248600006104,
-0.5825322270393372,
0.5022248029708862,
0.7321768403053284,
0.3887964189052582,
0.07650288939476013,
0.15682901442050934,
0.10736782103776932,
0.12467344105243683,
0.00855842512100935,
0.304403156042099,
-0.17333754897117615,
-0.7123996019363403,
-0.5634869933128357,
-0.2830597162246704,
-0.5521268248558044,
-0.06695076823234558,
-0.24757491052150726,
0.054545000195503235,
-0.516883134841919,
-0.14550668001174927,
0.013536226004362106,
0.15416085720062256,
-0.539982259273529,
0.10521459579467773,
0.08913857489824295,
1.0608750581741333,
-0.7232046127319336,
0.560245156288147,
0.8921369314193726,
-0.2620314359664917,
-1.1299549341201782,
-0.1797453761100769,
0.07800664752721786,
-1.0657260417938232,
0.682750940322876,
0.20299062132835388,
-0.38164910674095154,
0.09451248496770859,
-0.75860595703125,
-0.397604376077652,
1.0955997705459595,
0.5427343845367432,
-0.338174432516098,
-0.3292708992958069,
0.317266583442688,
0.48784568905830383,
-0.24574631452560425,
0.17297862470149994,
0.46999090909957886,
0.5759727954864502,
0.6104368567466736,
-0.8496657013893127,
0.29313012957572937,
-0.09645023941993713,
-0.00656465906649828,
0.11374799907207489,
-0.598195493221283,
0.9302585124969482,
-0.2621193826198578,
-0.2932470142841339,
-0.05433465540409088,
0.4026477634906769,
0.7551256418228149,
0.47674065828323364,
0.6477860808372498,
0.3989897668361664,
1.0069069862365723,
-0.11635437607765198,
1.188175082206726,
-0.20820392668247223,
0.07511622458696365,
0.8714935779571533,
-0.571165144443512,
0.4776739776134491,
0.44893744587898254,
-0.2553105354309082,
0.8685877323150635,
1.0785646438598633,
0.09007174521684647,
0.2473442107439041,
0.47402945160865784,
-0.08282075077295303,
-0.6122325658798218,
-0.3241529166698456,
-0.09820384532213211,
0.31178027391433716,
0.13223892450332642,
-0.031065301969647408,
-0.46437978744506836,
-0.2522798776626587,
0.011096674017608166,
0.14398585259914398,
-0.31793344020843506,
0.5081838965415955,
0.4011530578136444,
-0.6792654395103455,
0.49645116925239563,
-0.03220965713262558,
0.21601495146751404,
-0.7026161551475525,
-0.11144964396953583,
-0.09977598488330841,
-0.055723439902067184,
-0.2454155832529068,
-1.1424120664596558,
0.15914680063724518,
-0.22203445434570312,
0.07719792425632477,
-0.3940752148628235,
1.0749050378799438,
-0.04263881593942642,
-0.377411812543869,
0.46909886598587036,
0.7678495049476624,
0.2962600290775299,
-0.17528873682022095,
-0.6226730942726135,
0.198092520236969,
-0.25725552439689636,
-0.3099369704723358,
0.26897993683815,
0.5619677901268005,
-0.27826496958732605,
0.8871090412139893,
0.6277251839637756,
0.04989466816186905,
-0.11066186428070068,
0.3613666296005249,
1.1191755533218384,
-0.5569441318511963,
-0.4494415521621704,
-0.9727531671524048,
0.05047404766082764,
0.08754438906908035,
0.13450324535369873,
0.784720778465271,
0.5468440055847168,
0.7649011611938477,
0.27367067337036133,
0.46525460481643677,
0.33794456720352173,
0.1276339441537857,
-0.8241273760795593,
0.14370757341384888,
-0.4135853946208954,
0.14385245740413666,
-0.32015129923820496,
-0.7965084314346313,
-0.09892335534095764,
0.545829713344574,
-0.5047940611839294,
0.28593289852142334,
0.8892759680747986,
0.6545338034629822,
-0.10718757659196854,
-0.016802692785859108,
0.25907471776008606,
0.1427740901708603,
0.42065945267677307,
0.9071802496910095,
1.1122043132781982,
0.1678459197282791,
0.6264703869819641,
0.17065371572971344,
0.03292534500360489,
0.07601466774940491,
-0.9830570816993713,
-1.2489900588989258,
-0.33776551485061646,
-0.2017778754234314,
-0.5097265839576721,
0.06343299895524979,
0.4824812710285187,
0.6594821810722351,
-0.27489617466926575,
-0.006653476972132921,
-0.26082804799079895,
0.5583238005638123,
0.048283208161592484,
-0.17795267701148987,
0.394151896238327,
-0.24711914360523224,
-0.5782389044761658,
0.6337363719940186,
0.4706968069076538,
0.22630761563777924,
-0.3164317011833191,
-0.05540715530514717,
-0.039958808571100235,
0.013131354004144669,
0.5997533798217773,
0.27836158871650696,
-0.5949639678001404,
-0.6659748554229736,
0.17972984910011292,
0.004297272767871618,
0.21206970512866974,
0.9749203324317932,
-0.7963098883628845,
0.21443971991539001,
0.5175845623016357,
0.353744775056839,
0.834255576133728,
0.05778229609131813,
0.25009885430336,
-0.7619386315345764,
0.012925234623253345,
0.26691296696662903,
0.5668410658836365,
0.22340115904808044,
-0.28638017177581787,
0.5028080344200134,
0.4751257598400116,
-0.43138664960861206,
-0.7381385564804077,
0.5602301955223083,
-0.9967157244682312,
-0.3894135653972626,
1.3173046112060547,
-0.23569121956825256,
-0.3060518205165863,
-0.2898976802825928,
-0.15472108125686646,
0.17796003818511963,
0.022304268553853035,
0.23471345007419586,
0.945813775062561,
-0.6538068652153015,
-0.11698082089424133,
-0.40424415469169617,
0.17090941965579987,
0.10209536552429199,
-0.7589755654335022,
-0.016210472211241722,
0.5287951231002808,
0.39819496870040894,
-0.019005130976438522,
1.0316230058670044,
0.02903650887310505,
-0.09944929927587509,
-0.018355445936322212,
-0.5479686856269836,
-0.5830250382423401,
-0.4152548015117645,
-0.03184621408581734,
0.11494872719049454,
0.19562016427516937,
0.060457464307546616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01267v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01267v1 | The Human and the Mechanical: logos, truthfulness, and ChatGPT | 2024-02-02T09:41:51 | 2024-02-02T09:41:51 | Anastasia Giannakidou, Alda Mari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The paper addresses the question of whether it is appropriate to talk about
`mechanical minds' at all, and whether ChatGPT models can indeed be thought of
as realizations of that. Our paper adds a semantic argument to the current
debate. The act of human assertion requires the formation of a veridicality
judgment. Modification of assertions with modals (John must be at home) and the
use of subjective elements (John is obviously at home) indicate that the
speaker is manipulating her judgments and, in a cooperative context, intends
her epistemic state to be transparent to the addressee. Veridicality judgments
are formed on the basis of two components: (i) evidence that relates to reality
(exogenous evidence) and (ii) endogenous evidence, such as preferences and
private beliefs. `Mechanical minds' lack these two components: (i) they do not
relate to reality and (ii) do not have endogenous evidence. Therefore they lack
the ability to form a belief about the world and a veridicality judgments
altogether. They can only mimic that judgment, but the output is not ground in
the very foundations for it. | [
-0.3055039346218109,
-0.508086085319519,
0.5370447039604187,
-0.23882417380809784,
-0.0533226914703846,
0.4871116876602173,
-0.10681860148906708,
-0.7924433946609497,
0.28925058245658875,
0.15345525741577148,
-0.5881019234657288,
0.1937272995710373,
-0.5094264149665833,
0.2989221513271332,
-0.020314322784543037,
0.7529704570770264,
0.04627605155110359,
-0.0800493136048317,
-0.043297238647937775,
-0.25862330198287964,
-0.19201911985874176,
-0.5592564344406128,
-0.12868142127990723,
-0.4854028820991516,
0.38650041818618774,
-0.0451485812664032,
1.008738398551941,
0.463705450296402,
0.28656432032585144,
0.5493178963661194,
-0.041505392640829086,
0.02244415134191513,
-0.17496345937252045,
0.35711097717285156,
-0.4310581684112549,
-0.6583292484283447,
0.023028109222650528,
0.6107063889503479,
0.35658520460128784,
0.698455274105072,
-0.1118500679731369,
0.24147939682006836,
-0.09224756062030792,
0.6480257511138916,
-0.40542781352996826,
0.18692535161972046,
-0.6150403618812561,
0.41863003373146057,
0.11441447585821152,
-0.17676974833011627,
-0.29525527358055115,
-0.5301856398582458,
0.24344269931316376,
-0.7135781049728394,
0.3529745638370514,
0.29935747385025024,
1.3491480350494385,
0.554329514503479,
-0.5569782853126526,
-0.19369104504585266,
-0.8661458492279053,
0.6655516028404236,
-0.09740788489580154,
0.3531368374824524,
0.4376967251300812,
0.44576165080070496,
-0.07254014909267426,
-0.923214316368103,
-0.8486887216567993,
-0.5094039440155029,
-0.047664206475019455,
0.7246154546737671,
-0.2944970428943634,
0.06926349550485611,
0.6655551195144653,
0.46560826897621155,
-0.37252846360206604,
-0.3311976194381714,
-0.7860963344573975,
-0.39530178904533386,
0.2882353365421295,
0.1255936175584793,
0.54068922996521,
-0.16627758741378784,
-0.686815083026886,
0.006672010291367769,
-0.5598525404930115,
-0.03261455148458481,
0.3728654086589813,
-0.1912120282649994,
-0.1302001178264618,
0.7550337314605713,
-0.17107871174812317,
0.48110684752464294,
0.13851898908615112,
-0.028093289583921432,
0.17091339826583862,
-0.19209307432174683,
-0.19984859228134155,
0.11548446118831635,
0.6157583594322205,
0.46700191497802734,
0.4471111297607422,
-0.5017727017402649,
0.06331093609333038,
0.6818159818649292,
0.8275065422058105,
-0.7350054383277893,
0.0017545726150274277,
-0.11543754488229752,
-0.5104798078536987,
-0.3748905658721924,
0.47776350378990173,
0.04022103548049927,
-0.31877222657203674,
-0.7709977626800537,
0.1506076604127884,
-0.3904207646846771,
-0.29505863785743713,
0.2185065597295761,
-0.39036548137664795,
0.09151770919561386,
0.511084258556366,
-0.6850656867027283,
0.31125497817993164,
0.6739377379417419,
0.5263985395431519,
0.4684355854988098,
-0.25761452317237854,
0.20981362462043762,
0.3080255687236786,
-0.35835349559783936,
1.0131138563156128,
-0.5052523016929626,
-0.5358333587646484,
-0.14190514385700226,
0.278631329536438,
-0.12932421267032623,
-0.5259894728660583,
0.6099140644073486,
-0.17402228713035583,
0.6142370104789734,
-0.7427650094032288,
-0.3534156382083893,
-0.6291791200637817,
0.06533228605985641,
-0.3307003676891327,
0.7888038754463196,
0.127897247672081,
-0.655741810798645,
0.5795630812644958,
-0.6147611737251282,
-0.5381998419761658,
0.05237126350402832,
-0.690041720867157,
0.055868297815322876,
0.453263521194458,
-0.6882683634757996,
0.1865549236536026,
-0.2981472313404083,
0.21690130233764648,
-0.6137242317199707,
-0.14681552350521088,
0.7880417704582214,
-0.5430692434310913,
0.8115153312683105,
0.4338131546974182,
-0.43267184495925903,
-0.5122635364532471,
-0.572542130947113,
0.008286583237349987,
-0.06382787972688675,
-0.3660506010055542,
-0.15978744626045227,
0.33212628960609436,
-0.0380329005420208,
0.5803555250167847,
0.07259603589773178,
-0.9900177717208862,
0.3035578429698944,
-0.6020340323448181,
0.7759881615638733,
1.013627052307129,
-0.16583338379859924,
0.36431220173835754,
-0.9193174839019775,
0.2625807523727417,
-0.23032081127166748,
0.17647883296012878,
0.2984999120235443,
-0.7188289165496826,
-0.6412270665168762,
-0.201432004570961,
-0.10727355629205704,
0.547923743724823,
-0.5837593078613281,
0.21755541861057281,
-0.20693136751651764,
-0.4850355088710785,
-0.31190118193626404,
-0.28773558139801025,
0.5226026773452759,
0.6219436526298523,
-0.1611413061618805,
-0.6577287316322327,
-0.5035609602928162,
-1.1867061853408813,
-0.612958550453186,
-0.6953378319740295,
-0.18706713616847992,
0.3197607398033142,
0.5921810269355774,
0.08649102598428726,
0.9021222591400146,
-0.35494619607925415,
0.16627098619937897,
0.402765691280365,
0.49494481086730957,
0.3548210561275482,
0.4320670962333679,
0.46545547246932983,
-0.8667883276939392,
-0.16215410828590393,
0.20973485708236694,
-1.1952178478240967,
0.06645101308822632,
-0.1327182948589325,
-0.024885697290301323,
0.07783286273479462,
0.04456692561507225,
-0.9968124032020569,
0.5614213347434998,
-0.001886557205580175,
-0.7974224090576172,
0.6818315982818604,
-0.13988983631134033,
0.224380761384964,
-1.0066417455673218,
-0.06097344309091568,
-0.13118040561676025,
-0.40605950355529785,
-0.45043665170669556,
-0.14122800529003143,
-0.27728724479675293,
-0.036818716675043106,
-0.3759150207042694,
0.34945207834243774,
-0.3534463346004486,
-0.14067088067531586,
-0.34854522347450256,
-0.07200592756271362,
0.06538108736276627,
0.3825807273387909,
0.12047620117664337,
0.6577026844024658,
0.2746399939060211,
-0.6356239914894104,
0.36388692259788513,
0.15465755760669708,
-0.15690800547599792,
0.992017924785614,
-0.7019332647323608,
0.07972690463066101,
-0.3541209101676941,
0.41459858417510986,
-0.8323785066604614,
-0.4732304513454437,
0.7487193942070007,
-0.7139521241188049,
0.2617422342300415,
0.18251891434192657,
-0.4664247930049896,
-0.32213103771209717,
-0.20707711577415466,
0.08356162905693054,
0.7876548171043396,
-0.012438004836440086,
0.7378039956092834,
0.5648509860038757,
-0.1460302174091339,
-0.1799164116382599,
-0.8577529788017273,
0.21512891352176666,
-0.005050139967352152,
-0.9538538455963135,
0.5062640309333801,
-0.12244588136672974,
-0.698077380657196,
-0.0006302730180323124,
-0.42843109369277954,
-0.3228423595428467,
0.08039173483848572,
0.7236645221710205,
0.3584020733833313,
-0.1288711130619049,
0.2373749166727066,
-0.19982419908046722,
-0.39167121052742004,
0.3083736300468445,
-0.213014617562294,
-0.000679721706546843,
-0.27912554144859314,
-0.3814759850502014,
-0.8345709443092346,
0.2217424064874649,
0.7054806351661682,
0.13996806740760803,
0.1743520051240921,
0.4423936903476715,
-0.4685252904891968,
0.569871187210083,
-0.6393361687660217,
-0.17644235491752625,
-0.46375012397766113,
0.02949405089020729,
-0.18541812896728516,
-0.6635110974311829,
0.23678407073020935,
-0.1732282042503357,
-0.09879258275032043,
0.48128193616867065,
0.9947830438613892,
-0.6879344582557678,
0.5908703804016113,
0.28965267539024353,
0.20496755838394165,
0.238652765750885,
-0.1617591679096222,
0.09445032477378845,
-0.8488474488258362,
-0.1772574633359909,
-0.9798040390014648,
-0.26700684428215027,
-0.9479646682739258,
-0.30109432339668274,
0.29240718483924866,
-0.5125765800476074,
-0.7250039577484131,
0.2891843914985657,
-0.652816116809845,
0.35059788823127747,
0.3870060443878174,
0.49347490072250366,
0.33584973216056824,
-0.08063631504774094,
-0.12127437442541122,
-0.23134683072566986,
-0.6424357295036316,
-0.9943546056747437,
0.6470949649810791,
0.17224808037281036,
0.6258344054222107,
0.3701956868171692,
0.1641089916229248,
0.3259766101837158,
0.5182930827140808,
-0.6852596402168274,
0.4076472222805023,
0.2209436148405075,
-1.28709077835083,
0.18161135911941528,
-0.1004648506641388,
-0.9442112445831299,
0.32992023229599,
-0.10894384980201721,
-1.0412789583206177,
0.49908724427223206,
-0.017172442749142647,
-0.29569458961486816,
0.26406389474868774,
-0.5599907040596008,
0.5145116448402405,
-0.06706247478723526,
-0.5241103172302246,
-0.43827956914901733,
-0.944871187210083,
0.6599240899085999,
0.27753838896751404,
0.2440706044435501,
-0.2698242962360382,
-0.1806313693523407,
0.7616925835609436,
-0.5650842785835266,
1.2981165647506714,
0.06717035174369812,
0.005191057920455933,
0.49680212140083313,
0.06505147367715836,
0.43507662415504456,
-0.09465868771076202,
0.2814415395259857,
-0.25205734372138977,
0.09078340977430344,
-0.3845078647136688,
-0.763874351978302,
0.0419154018163681,
-0.9043786525726318,
-0.6871504187583923,
-0.8181782960891724,
-0.2676893174648285,
-0.09331341832876205,
-0.0014807452680543065,
0.4125509262084961,
0.5776147842407227,
-0.30906450748443604,
0.13481152057647705,
0.777209460735321,
-0.11827991157770157,
0.4083268642425537,
0.4460621774196625,
-0.012271716259419918,
-0.23227685689926147,
0.8148707151412964,
0.2243209183216095,
0.47672244906425476,
0.1458737701177597,
0.11491397023200989,
-0.34973978996276855,
0.32610538601875305,
-0.19414359331130981,
0.3243567943572998,
-0.7412692308425903,
0.17619453370571136,
-0.42079412937164307,
0.055447276681661606,
0.1676577478647232,
-0.16551028192043304,
-0.521845281124115,
-0.6856696605682373,
0.12039250135421753,
-0.00008879442611942068,
0.08318152278661728,
0.7660830616950989,
-0.08746077120304108,
0.05973852798342705,
-0.5738096237182617,
0.5861579775810242,
0.4332553446292877,
0.005617766175419092,
-0.3619219660758972,
-0.526340901851654,
-0.08326230198144913,
0.12419943511486053,
-0.7075337767601013,
-0.7592312097549438,
-0.3471181392669678,
-0.03827028349041939,
0.5734843015670776,
0.5896965861320496,
0.11155034601688385,
0.5406947731971741,
-0.5128358006477356,
0.6566042900085449,
0.5027523636817932,
-0.8234456777572632,
0.21159261465072632,
-0.4172094762325287,
-0.16204087436199188,
0.37535360455513,
0.37996694445610046,
-0.6217344403266907,
-0.5378345847129822,
-1.1473662853240967,
-0.1890910118818283,
0.3276044726371765,
0.35043784976005554,
0.4660027325153351,
0.07173914462327957,
0.04992760345339775,
0.17291466891765594,
0.2887192666530609,
-0.7361177802085876,
-0.2297617346048355,
-0.3961655795574188,
0.16758552193641663,
0.4161989986896515,
-0.05307109281420708,
-0.2836667001247406,
-0.4287032186985016,
0.4230165481567383,
0.04868118092417717,
0.7128429412841797,
0.57063227891922,
-0.09063947200775146,
-0.1306849867105484,
0.12158290296792984,
0.6831328272819519,
0.9130092263221741,
0.08122606575489044,
0.15908128023147583,
-0.08832354843616486,
-0.637420117855072,
0.5407396554946899,
-0.3461546003818512,
-0.24785982072353363,
0.21899890899658203,
0.434110552072525,
0.5527636408805847,
0.34709984064102173,
-0.2534562647342682,
0.37250807881355286,
-0.16712194681167603,
-0.2698785662651062,
-0.5972369313240051,
0.08105041086673737,
-0.14799581468105316,
0.5527138710021973,
0.03472200781106949,
0.8455722332000732,
0.12927502393722534,
-1.0699694156646729,
-0.017691390588879585,
0.47450390458106995,
-0.5760557055473328,
-0.8404554128646851,
1.0032315254211426,
0.01681736297905445,
-0.35872530937194824,
0.3877026438713074,
-0.00029660214204341173,
-0.6636089086532593,
0.37861377000808716,
0.11149599403142929,
1.189490795135498,
-0.14908680319786072,
0.26325854659080505,
0.25289809703826904,
0.49371081590652466,
0.08600675314664841,
0.48780056834220886,
-0.35813257098197937,
-1.1510210037231445,
-0.5332763195037842,
-0.13352307677268982,
-0.5349326133728027,
-0.6804426312446594,
-0.5739079117774963,
-0.10509815067052841,
-0.3846244215965271,
-0.6196528077125549,
0.17194324731826782,
-0.18015871942043304,
-0.6592846512794495,
0.17862209677696228,
0.06569032371044159,
0.7437541484832764,
-0.6526272296905518,
0.7184383869171143,
0.7036709189414978,
-0.7481237649917603,
-0.5323099493980408,
-0.11330204457044601,
0.12667013704776764,
-0.8494418859481812,
0.9594735503196716,
0.11787388473749161,
-0.2716825306415558,
-0.25942298769950867,
-0.6993831992149353,
-0.43202537298202515,
1.0593159198760986,
0.5831778049468994,
-0.009669143706560135,
-0.0736117959022522,
-0.10636232048273087,
0.1705167293548584,
-0.018493708223104477,
0.21575409173965454,
0.044204726815223694,
0.9546071887016296,
0.10195174068212509,
-0.9071081876754761,
0.20969045162200928,
-0.2285170555114746,
-0.044779397547245026,
-0.029075603932142258,
-0.9406219124794006,
0.7364407777786255,
-0.30932605266571045,
-0.4893423318862915,
0.09314277023077011,
0.5214626789093018,
0.19513188302516937,
0.22304590046405792,
0.2681654989719391,
0.5518084764480591,
0.8276568055152893,
-0.20798707008361816,
1.5462932586669922,
-0.2919709086418152,
0.5089313983917236,
0.6081545948982239,
-0.30986329913139343,
0.24406860768795013,
0.6427214741706848,
-0.7414857745170593,
0.4679148197174072,
0.6026256084442139,
0.10368356853723526,
0.33901742100715637,
0.3910471200942993,
-0.5899440050125122,
-0.41391992568969727,
-0.29781264066696167,
-0.508708119392395,
0.8116405606269836,
0.12890833616256714,
-0.23901651799678802,
-0.18320323526859283,
-0.33434051275253296,
0.32725968956947327,
0.042247943580150604,
0.11953447014093399,
0.5922278165817261,
0.2585562467575073,
-0.5497252941131592,
0.5268332958221436,
-0.10488703846931458,
0.18054085969924927,
-0.35219159722328186,
0.0197125431150198,
0.1955399215221405,
-0.26422542333602905,
-0.10835480690002441,
-0.4266481399536133,
0.3799650967121124,
-0.15446065366268158,
-0.39349088072776794,
-0.42982521653175354,
1.0039929151535034,
0.41235414147377014,
-0.3941762447357178,
-0.3890976905822754,
0.6597997546195984,
0.4783029556274414,
0.004560923669487238,
-0.689771831035614,
-0.3266393840312958,
-0.21224047243595123,
-0.4683927595615387,
0.11844178289175034,
0.7095827460289001,
0.24138008058071136,
0.8251585960388184,
0.5497593879699707,
-0.08270572125911713,
-0.12525494396686554,
-0.3346399664878845,
0.7623396515846252,
-0.9803741574287415,
-0.24443289637565613,
-0.9515023231506348,
0.5720744729042053,
-0.09525472670793533,
-0.3363589942455292,
0.5373765826225281,
0.627765417098999,
0.710040807723999,
-0.2062043696641922,
1.1500749588012695,
-0.3212693929672241,
0.3151494562625885,
-0.6933985948562622,
0.76685631275177,
-0.22193452715873718,
-0.18935079872608185,
-0.31304797530174255,
-0.6824228763580322,
-0.008440311066806316,
0.9543240666389465,
-0.25081369280815125,
0.1815575808286667,
0.9319787621498108,
0.5775197744369507,
0.05667973309755325,
0.49727070331573486,
0.4298326373100281,
0.44958582520484924,
-0.14548997581005096,
0.3964742124080658,
1.5014681816101074,
-0.37545421719551086,
-0.05965372174978256,
0.08066965639591217,
-0.09922479838132858,
0.09531623870134354,
-0.7913551926612854,
-0.6242653131484985,
-0.6179980039596558,
-0.43314483761787415,
-0.6126590371131897,
-0.007710023317486048,
0.9405925869941711,
0.6942266225814819,
-0.13995400071144104,
-0.27400562167167664,
-0.027434909716248512,
0.1782861202955246,
-0.1676194965839386,
-0.10779361426830292,
0.051619984209537506,
-0.3365222215652466,
-0.6597878932952881,
0.06695348769426346,
0.6087138652801514,
0.20710521936416626,
-0.24611137807369232,
-0.16649729013442993,
0.004452986177057028,
-0.06552308052778244,
0.6659263372421265,
0.4474131464958191,
-0.9101548790931702,
-0.7324637174606323,
-0.11112887412309647,
-0.09153357893228531,
0.32809916138648987,
0.8290802836418152,
-1.0178953409194946,
0.34295961260795593,
0.36185312271118164,
0.28608664870262146,
0.3204478323459625,
0.0007074868772178888,
0.7124961614608765,
-0.07709536701440811,
0.256099671125412,
0.17500907182693481,
0.5506693720817566,
-0.0666080191731453,
0.06339432299137115,
0.7559824585914612,
1.1769510507583618,
-0.602568507194519,
-0.7123265862464905,
0.6475527882575989,
-1.0323758125305176,
-0.30307358503341675,
0.5624499917030334,
0.010494548827409744,
-0.4626522958278656,
-0.3717498183250427,
-0.36207255721092224,
0.4250977635383606,
-0.0708082765340805,
0.8356598615646362,
0.885190486907959,
-0.12326895445585251,
0.3989936411380768,
-1.1879464387893677,
0.06719852238893509,
0.0744001641869545,
-0.4027332067489624,
-0.1668556183576584,
0.40481796860694885,
0.29856160283088684,
0.304666668176651,
0.5302731394767761,
-0.07393445074558258,
0.381902813911438,
0.25502869486808777,
0.21721521019935608,
0.012890555895864964,
0.1326015442609787,
0.2687590718269348,
0.06005692109465599,
0.08329974114894867,
-0.3027121424674988
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03370v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03370v1 | Detection of tortured phrases in scientific literature | 2024-02-02T08:15:43 | 2024-02-02T08:15:43 | Eléna Martel, Martin Lentschat, Cyril Labbé | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DL | This paper presents various automatic detection methods to extract so called
tortured phrases from scientific papers. These tortured phrases, e.g. flag to
clamor instead of signal to noise, are the results of paraphrasing tools used
to escape plagiarism detection. We built a dataset and evaluated several
strategies to flag previously undocumented tortured phrases. The proposed and
tested methods are based on language models and either on embeddings
similarities or on predictions of masked token. We found that an approach using
token prediction and that propagates the scores to the chunk level gives the
best results. With a recall value of .87 and a precision value of .61, it could
retrieve new tortured phrases to be submitted to domain experts for validation. | [
-0.4125206172466278,
-0.9255340695381165,
0.6876348257064819,
0.3212047517299652,
-0.7242774367332458,
0.2896867096424103,
0.11861267685890198,
-0.1882733255624771,
0.34618034958839417,
0.9210121631622314,
-0.11297404021024704,
-0.4652820825576782,
-0.7600756883621216,
0.6383190155029297,
-0.7670639753341675,
1.1934175491333008,
-0.30501481890678406,
0.04464367404580116,
-0.4269082248210907,
-0.00448043504729867,
0.0660228431224823,
-0.5463246703147888,
-0.08106573671102524,
0.16787829995155334,
0.44238948822021484,
0.08926083892583847,
0.6299906373023987,
0.8409723043441772,
0.7909411191940308,
0.29170775413513184,
-0.2510426938533783,
0.2558884024620056,
-0.2795148193836212,
0.4491858184337616,
-0.021275728940963745,
-0.42188799381256104,
0.09033475071191788,
0.18253757059574127,
0.4235951602458954,
0.2770827114582062,
0.22130195796489716,
0.044784292578697205,
-0.017271175980567932,
0.4186081886291504,
-0.2971075475215912,
0.16441340744495392,
-0.7841322422027588,
0.19464489817619324,
-0.6185986995697021,
-0.3458082973957062,
-0.41370144486427307,
-0.47730904817581177,
-0.0319746732711792,
-0.49677765369415283,
0.4747184216976166,
0.45841845870018005,
0.8479083776473999,
0.304436594247818,
-0.0016320887953042984,
-0.6648508310317993,
-0.11197493970394135,
0.7543601989746094,
-0.571874737739563,
0.05564609542489052,
0.4718296229839325,
-0.15692098438739777,
-0.3311900198459625,
-1.162523865699768,
-0.46049410104751587,
-0.5774298310279846,
-0.3555077314376831,
-0.1050666868686676,
-0.09814304113388062,
-0.054426733404397964,
0.41427040100097656,
0.3098819851875305,
-0.6385823488235474,
-0.3175337016582489,
-0.7064522504806519,
-0.3551851809024811,
0.5708233118057251,
-0.04673110321164131,
0.3425033390522003,
-0.4742581248283386,
-0.4871155619621277,
0.12271948903799057,
-0.49129799008369446,
-0.22444112598896027,
0.383385568857193,
0.051843784749507904,
0.17541590332984924,
0.5287426114082336,
-0.030849305912852287,
0.32349106669425964,
0.14262983202934265,
0.16793490946292877,
0.25676703453063965,
-0.1340952068567276,
0.10254277288913727,
-0.21681369841098785,
0.9551738500595093,
0.2780499756336212,
0.15951594710350037,
-0.5953181385993958,
-0.2643004357814789,
-0.019367698580026627,
0.23743872344493866,
-0.5697803497314453,
-0.6311132907867432,
-0.025039708241820335,
-0.483005553483963,
-0.3597300350666046,
-0.0686253160238266,
-1.3078930377960205,
-0.6559768915176392,
-0.12808458507061005,
0.36330556869506836,
-0.5397096276283264,
-0.05889846384525299,
-0.03521766886115074,
-0.6494606733322144,
-0.15733523666858673,
-0.05994854122400284,
-0.21280208230018616,
0.3206383287906647,
0.6729880571365356,
1.2595609426498413,
-0.541047215461731,
-0.21078453958034515,
-0.6121112108230591,
-0.10875014960765839,
-0.08752837032079697,
0.9308013916015625,
-0.6682268977165222,
-0.43635544180870056,
-0.12519295513629913,
0.10312333703041077,
-0.00605213874951005,
-0.6320322155952454,
0.8423026204109192,
-0.4355480968952179,
0.10568012297153473,
-0.18085893988609314,
-0.6993833780288696,
-0.21518702805042267,
-0.08865869045257568,
-0.8180411458015442,
0.9828790426254272,
0.07259278744459152,
-1.0568687915802002,
0.09602800011634827,
-0.6679438352584839,
-0.35932695865631104,
0.11230701208114624,
0.16907310485839844,
-0.7169177532196045,
0.12201708555221558,
0.2647932469844818,
0.34382402896881104,
-0.24740304052829742,
0.4325108826160431,
-0.6069695353507996,
-0.2524033784866333,
0.6949000358581543,
0.1262044459581375,
0.6955967545509338,
0.47496187686920166,
-0.4835464358329773,
-0.09547458589076996,
-0.3460255265235901,
0.07055381685495377,
-0.07505352795124054,
0.01833253540098667,
-0.5571377873420715,
-0.06661101430654526,
0.12389881908893585,
0.1678522527217865,
-0.15367841720581055,
-0.7551193833351135,
0.09748461097478867,
-0.451106995344162,
0.599311888217926,
0.40215110778808594,
0.5614327192306519,
-0.01568080112338066,
-0.5503758788108826,
0.7340254187583923,
0.11848124116659164,
0.1714298129081726,
0.0992501825094223,
-0.5522356033325195,
-0.5836104154586792,
-0.40349137783050537,
0.34345757961273193,
0.17970198392868042,
-0.8835062384605408,
0.4040435552597046,
0.08624600619077682,
-0.5727510452270508,
-0.8248010277748108,
0.14462240040302277,
0.4502639174461365,
0.525361180305481,
0.695617139339447,
-0.05900512635707855,
-0.7398965358734131,
-0.784320056438446,
-0.8913114666938782,
-0.032523419708013535,
0.10655201971530914,
-0.16025695204734802,
1.1263841390609741,
0.19702517986297607,
0.857473611831665,
-0.4553287625312805,
-0.20560836791992188,
0.336582750082016,
0.6670661568641663,
-0.2510906755924225,
0.4516666531562805,
0.4163758158683777,
-1.197580337524414,
-0.39851313829421997,
-0.25517675280570984,
-0.8628736138343811,
-0.27062833309173584,
-0.22256703674793243,
-0.020259644836187363,
-0.04867509752511978,
0.9421811103820801,
-0.3802942633628845,
0.4133438766002655,
-0.04055936262011528,
-0.20977433025836945,
0.7999398112297058,
0.25741422176361084,
0.22098465263843536,
-0.585633397102356,
0.2620612382888794,
-0.1153857633471489,
-0.1695859581232071,
-0.4971531331539154,
0.26997894048690796,
0.1540243774652481,
0.12184858322143555,
-0.5574954152107239,
0.5633048415184021,
-0.7394823431968689,
0.27583542466163635,
-0.3183782994747162,
0.21100804209709167,
0.15347371995449066,
0.12298452854156494,
0.21237167716026306,
0.7100632190704346,
0.5427802801132202,
-0.36484774947166443,
0.2435152679681778,
0.381732702255249,
-0.175398588180542,
0.20030522346496582,
-0.5994064807891846,
0.36759430170059204,
-0.29634711146354675,
0.1251491904258728,
-0.8247433304786682,
-0.016495956107974052,
0.23076356947422028,
-0.4627946615219116,
-0.08240112662315369,
-0.15830101072788239,
-0.5661572813987732,
-0.5066432952880859,
-0.49879610538482666,
0.1115916445851326,
0.46980640292167664,
-0.1766238957643509,
0.20318660140037537,
0.4388037323951721,
-0.22641728818416595,
-0.3916224241256714,
-0.4735856056213379,
0.3428634703159332,
-0.7418188452720642,
-0.10226918756961823,
0.3682720363140106,
-0.13777919113636017,
-0.3467074930667877,
-0.13264304399490356,
0.11420302093029022,
-0.0852765142917633,
0.14324356615543365,
0.4610435962677002,
0.08178296685218811,
-0.06935656070709229,
0.13718590140342712,
0.08516443520784378,
0.23010198771953583,
0.3316876292228699,
-0.07153882086277008,
0.6177387833595276,
-0.12854982912540436,
-0.10558835417032242,
-0.06237851455807686,
0.5715857744216919,
0.754419207572937,
-0.2314930111169815,
0.28668439388275146,
0.6590613126754761,
-0.2669864296913147,
0.14942222833633423,
-0.5631940364837646,
-0.3263302445411682,
-0.46451663970947266,
0.12204190343618393,
-0.31487083435058594,
-0.47904300689697266,
0.6674340963363647,
-0.23872102797031403,
-0.23226000368595123,
0.31639811396598816,
0.2650151252746582,
-0.20182639360427856,
0.9030973315238953,
0.3380427360534668,
0.0015080564189702272,
0.0701722651720047,
-0.05783464387059212,
0.23052941262722015,
-0.884573221206665,
-0.31683146953582764,
-0.8652560710906982,
-0.2903587520122528,
-0.4086378514766693,
-0.5531474947929382,
0.5326767563819885,
0.49537715315818787,
-0.005653046537190676,
0.2115175426006317,
-0.697959840297699,
0.4264247715473175,
0.4750913083553314,
0.0078593073412776,
0.18641310930252075,
0.10022129863500595,
-0.4743553698062897,
-0.189486563205719,
-0.18356850743293762,
-0.5942597389221191,
0.7546073794364929,
0.17476797103881836,
0.43910297751426697,
-0.39695975184440613,
0.9986941814422607,
0.488857626914978,
0.45453521609306335,
-0.7500895857810974,
0.5591062903404236,
0.09166331589221954,
-0.6257978081703186,
-0.07806792110204697,
-0.12867382168769836,
-0.8554764986038208,
0.01639363542199135,
0.07229121029376984,
-0.772142231464386,
0.17000235617160797,
-0.3839156925678253,
-0.1329728662967682,
0.12779149413108826,
-0.3264273405075073,
0.559269368648529,
-0.12245818972587585,
-0.1304813176393509,
0.22395078837871552,
-0.7449255585670471,
0.4240005612373352,
-0.28532254695892334,
0.11777478456497192,
0.17780324816703796,
-0.17513850331306458,
1.265397310256958,
-0.09141747653484344,
0.7098531126976013,
-0.10438426584005356,
0.33285731077194214,
0.30547913908958435,
0.39127400517463684,
0.3104790449142456,
-0.032275762408971786,
-0.33556053042411804,
0.053575675934553146,
0.29653072357177734,
-0.3507857620716095,
-0.34920206665992737,
0.5537403225898743,
-0.4435657858848572,
-0.6548187136650085,
-0.4957307279109955,
-0.6609014272689819,
-0.12115747481584549,
0.21206901967525482,
0.5900501012802124,
-0.09527219086885452,
0.16699469089508057,
0.24616815149784088,
0.49786120653152466,
-0.022828372195363045,
0.526256799697876,
0.4426935911178589,
-0.35406094789505005,
-0.5979191660881042,
0.6881410479545593,
0.0564543753862381,
0.012074099853634834,
-0.028771180659532547,
0.2832239866256714,
-0.4386090040206909,
-0.8313791155815125,
-0.2675410807132721,
0.5267296433448792,
-0.54052734375,
-0.6102002263069153,
-0.9592683911323547,
-0.06915552169084549,
-0.6562961339950562,
-0.16497576236724854,
0.1887902170419693,
-0.19376936554908752,
-0.5219196081161499,
-0.151138573884964,
0.8549754619598389,
0.5290200114250183,
0.06575576961040497,
0.22619394958019257,
-0.9096488952636719,
0.4020184278488159,
-0.5041221380233765,
-0.10314951092004776,
-0.41209137439727783,
-0.7253206372261047,
0.11588787287473679,
-0.08406776934862137,
-0.4068945050239563,
-1.235783576965332,
0.8766540288925171,
0.3265957236289978,
0.4415236711502075,
0.4673619270324707,
0.5120052695274353,
0.7624269723892212,
-0.1481257677078247,
0.8369254469871521,
0.0067788176238536835,
-0.9094725251197815,
0.6816571354866028,
-0.2613906264305115,
-0.31600984930992126,
0.46362096071243286,
0.9109715223312378,
-0.5474768877029419,
-1.064898133277893,
-0.828066349029541,
-0.6686259508132935,
0.2394174188375473,
-0.0317692905664444,
-0.029416434466838837,
-0.2774210274219513,
0.6588408946990967,
0.5800493955612183,
0.38899147510528564,
-0.7624257206916809,
-0.11278463155031204,
-0.07905178517103195,
-0.2525310516357422,
0.17749996483325958,
-0.007689967751502991,
-0.34413227438926697,
-0.27059340476989746,
0.3445603847503662,
-0.2211991548538208,
0.2046690285205841,
0.4887174665927887,
-0.40614670515060425,
-0.24425393342971802,
-0.1341763138771057,
0.4708733558654785,
0.4427945017814636,
-0.01912005804479122,
0.3322458565235138,
-0.2128828763961792,
-0.5385829210281372,
-0.049032580107450485,
0.14627493917942047,
-0.5525303483009338,
0.31082701683044434,
0.24525246024131775,
0.425115704536438,
-0.004039273597300053,
-0.7551069259643555,
0.412538081407547,
0.26316097378730774,
-0.2994139492511749,
-0.14664018154144287,
-0.21333546936511993,
0.03490111976861954,
0.14489850401878357,
0.3976752758026123,
0.18907175958156586,
0.5521076321601868,
-0.4324575364589691,
0.7051196694374084,
0.48613038659095764,
-0.38059765100479126,
-0.4574081301689148,
0.5561321377754211,
-0.33409467339515686,
-0.37620607018470764,
0.3471237123012543,
-0.2925955057144165,
-1.0400688648223877,
0.5307828783988953,
0.6093529462814331,
0.7253637909889221,
-0.1646546870470047,
0.6070911884307861,
0.07514424622058868,
0.14796710014343262,
-0.14328250288963318,
0.40225228667259216,
0.091176837682724,
-0.13073377311229706,
-0.00011750426347134635,
-0.8886892199516296,
-0.08985868096351624,
0.40204402804374695,
-0.7844638824462891,
0.44351285696029663,
-0.28487345576286316,
-0.10295972228050232,
0.32617679238319397,
0.02898046188056469,
-0.37638911604881287,
-0.026073159649968147,
0.1060110554099083,
0.784314751625061,
-1.1555575132369995,
0.7503692507743835,
0.5391823649406433,
-0.6639058589935303,
-0.390298992395401,
-0.011034362018108368,
0.0402318574488163,
-0.5763841867446899,
0.736896276473999,
0.10659030824899673,
-0.019151659682393074,
-0.031568028032779694,
-0.7325144410133362,
-0.810451328754425,
0.46536678075790405,
0.16484110057353973,
-0.18559254705905914,
-0.019983254373073578,
0.0449368990957737,
0.676490068435669,
-0.22157175838947296,
0.16958756744861603,
0.7211901545524597,
0.7820562720298767,
-0.08910634368658066,
-0.7999730110168457,
0.3411085307598114,
-0.31578293442726135,
-0.543393611907959,
0.22262009978294373,
-0.4605475068092346,
1.031099557876587,
0.1874479055404663,
-0.1429421752691269,
0.5124388337135315,
0.6373870372772217,
0.07660193741321564,
0.7144721150398254,
0.41869890689849854,
0.12022282928228378,
0.8849737644195557,
-0.052193187177181244,
0.6171754002571106,
-0.1686364710330963,
0.3037834167480469,
0.5174839496612549,
-0.31480371952056885,
0.7296317219734192,
0.9188379049301147,
0.07473419606685638,
0.42985019087791443,
0.6464745402336121,
-0.44068095088005066,
0.7067123651504517,
0.4983288645744324,
-0.05453544482588768,
-0.01567363739013672,
-0.27264049649238586,
-0.225199893116951,
0.39484459161758423,
0.7236185669898987,
-0.5605644583702087,
-0.15382850170135498,
0.7202072143554688,
0.3887098729610443,
0.35062310099601746,
-0.17302758991718292,
0.8405729532241821,
0.20110951364040375,
-0.9168133735656738,
0.9233554005622864,
-0.20288696885108948,
0.6249973177909851,
-0.04961905628442764,
-0.0417507141828537,
-0.2842569649219513,
-0.14070528745651245,
-0.11055465042591095,
-0.7530996799468994,
0.4890200197696686,
0.04186669737100601,
0.12433908879756927,
-0.16336603462696075,
0.8111496567726135,
-0.4831835925579071,
-0.3971630930900574,
0.09191092848777771,
0.5618240237236023,
0.7140381932258606,
-0.23436133563518524,
-0.8817988038063049,
-0.08184034377336502,
0.06282860785722733,
-0.15724493563175201,
0.34978586435317993,
0.5263518691062927,
-0.2756580710411072,
0.6718704700469971,
0.5353907942771912,
0.5069229602813721,
0.21782033145427704,
-0.3528597056865692,
0.9250851273536682,
-0.6639065742492676,
-0.337047815322876,
-0.8133893609046936,
0.14020945131778717,
-0.420383483171463,
-0.35814571380615234,
0.8107171058654785,
0.5586059093475342,
0.393377423286438,
-0.3934399485588074,
0.8086856603622437,
-0.00985192321240902,
0.7298110127449036,
-0.4752526581287384,
0.7581450939178467,
-0.2920783460140228,
-0.12549346685409546,
-0.326066255569458,
-0.4753052592277527,
-0.5301823019981384,
0.40202128887176514,
-0.42736589908599854,
-0.37898725271224976,
1.1661396026611328,
0.9804790616035461,
-0.10737690329551697,
0.24387674033641815,
0.03861209377646446,
0.1594611406326294,
0.20861876010894775,
-0.04778867959976196,
0.8906077742576599,
-0.32851457595825195,
0.5078665018081665,
-0.35582393407821655,
0.059802208095788956,
-0.3939155340194702,
-0.824884831905365,
-0.8558670878410339,
-0.8615164160728455,
-0.7121625542640686,
-0.5077165365219116,
0.19916346669197083,
0.4573414921760559,
0.2582571804523468,
-0.9249227643013,
0.16667981445789337,
-0.06261567026376724,
0.15409725904464722,
-0.5141429305076599,
-0.31304416060447693,
0.6096334457397461,
-0.6107848882675171,
-0.6133589744567871,
0.3199697434902191,
0.10410280525684357,
-0.09087865054607391,
-0.09225401282310486,
0.2902335822582245,
-0.2805999517440796,
0.14112167060375214,
0.06476056575775146,
0.28242093324661255,
-0.8222194910049438,
-0.38320839405059814,
0.15126745402812958,
0.01982496865093708,
-0.10435333102941513,
1.2430622577667236,
-0.8086634278297424,
0.3126859664916992,
0.5732715725898743,
0.37205231189727783,
0.33645233511924744,
0.16526155173778534,
0.37021785974502563,
-0.7451454997062683,
0.07678200304508209,
0.8465577960014343,
0.2870934307575226,
0.3324170410633087,
-0.40924137830734253,
0.2670607268810272,
0.39811232686042786,
-0.572819709777832,
-1.4493790864944458,
-0.06900153309106827,
-0.7771322131156921,
-0.42555880546569824,
1.0093072652816772,
-0.664547860622406,
-0.5216585993766785,
-0.7209150195121765,
-0.18833257257938385,
0.3630005717277527,
-0.09892211109399796,
1.2365909814834595,
0.7105019092559814,
-0.11057016998529434,
0.036779895424842834,
-0.47935837507247925,
0.861772358417511,
0.45981696248054504,
-0.5359417200088501,
0.31779614090919495,
0.21709643304347992,
0.24646438658237457,
0.48633721470832825,
0.10260053724050522,
-0.37046676874160767,
0.16418570280075073,
-0.016577739268541336,
-0.02372646890580654,
-0.19221758842468262,
-0.04940824955701828,
-0.10859961807727814,
0.4332769513130188,
-0.14138881862163544,
-0.17426219582557678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01801v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01801v3 | Large Language Models for Time Series: A Survey | 2024-02-02T07:24:35 | 2024-05-06T20:48:41 | Xiyuan Zhang, Ranak Roy Chowdhury, Rajesh K. Gupta, Jingbo Shang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have seen significant use in domains such as
natural language processing and computer vision. Going beyond text, image and
graphics, LLMs present a significant potential for analysis of time series
data, benefiting domains such as climate, IoT, healthcare, traffic, audio and
finance. This survey paper provides an in-depth exploration and a detailed
taxonomy of the various methodologies employed to harness the power of LLMs for
time series analysis. We address the inherent challenge of bridging the gap
between LLMs' original text data training and the numerical nature of time
series data, and explore strategies for transferring and distilling knowledge
from LLMs to numerical time series analysis. We detail various methodologies,
including (1) direct prompting of LLMs, (2) time series quantization, (3)
aligning techniques, (4) utilization of the vision modality as a bridging
mechanism, and (5) the combination of LLMs with tools. Additionally, this
survey offers a comprehensive overview of the existing multimodal time series
and text datasets and delves into the challenges and future opportunities of
this emerging field. We maintain an up-to-date Github repository which includes
all the papers and datasets discussed in the survey. | [
-0.3134784400463104,
-0.8072080612182617,
0.6173557639122009,
0.09292721003293991,
-0.28988367319107056,
0.5034241080284119,
-0.32171404361724854,
-0.5410851240158081,
0.10621616989374161,
0.4887092709541321,
-0.5479210615158081,
-0.42394837737083435,
-0.6228218078613281,
0.04221656545996666,
-0.4437825083732605,
0.6719553470611572,
-0.1343258172273636,
0.18253085017204285,
-0.06664537638425827,
-0.006284745410084724,
-0.0896591767668724,
-0.7612901329994202,
-0.6562466621398926,
-0.46161240339279175,
0.6113754510879517,
-0.01289484091103077,
0.5221790671348572,
0.34114670753479004,
0.8168283104896545,
0.31885573267936707,
0.06729679554700851,
0.26785603165626526,
-0.2913094460964203,
0.2318771928548813,
0.15851804614067078,
-0.1535259485244751,
-0.4189913868904114,
-0.0668288916349411,
0.835092306137085,
1.0175371170043945,
-0.22254431247711182,
0.44826096296310425,
-0.12774692475795746,
0.5015508532524109,
-0.3211881220340729,
0.43440088629722595,
-0.32923945784568787,
0.115928515791893,
-0.5590168237686157,
-0.45893701910972595,
-0.13905811309814453,
-0.17502114176750183,
0.24322235584259033,
-0.23058079183101654,
0.036815620958805084,
0.288027822971344,
0.3480965793132782,
0.3769419193267822,
-0.6778292655944824,
-0.12160932272672653,
-1.1013929843902588,
1.1748405694961548,
-0.8938486576080322,
0.3407243490219116,
0.1027444452047348,
0.4838722348213196,
0.051084745675325394,
-0.7041848301887512,
-0.5215060114860535,
0.0013200489338487387,
0.14596103131771088,
-0.03170260414481163,
-0.017994431778788567,
-0.18875306844711304,
0.39732158184051514,
0.5134821534156799,
-0.45386242866516113,
0.32634276151657104,
-0.23519207537174225,
0.056200914084911346,
0.668819010257721,
0.570504903793335,
0.173371359705925,
-0.07876524329185486,
-0.26933619379997253,
-0.2100692242383957,
-0.5468552708625793,
-0.18927420675754547,
0.26842209696769714,
0.2541503310203552,
-0.32106706500053406,
0.6057534217834473,
0.045791350305080414,
0.8907144069671631,
-0.6555119752883911,
-0.40132078528404236,
0.09371288120746613,
-0.36929160356521606,
-0.37147006392478943,
-0.05409863591194153,
0.808396577835083,
0.32957449555397034,
0.2806642949581146,
-0.07212355732917786,
-0.19412241876125336,
-0.19311155378818512,
-0.22655817866325378,
-0.7628421783447266,
0.02780265361070633,
0.09797076135873795,
-0.4285247325897217,
-0.22897806763648987,
-0.16715189814567566,
-1.133581280708313,
-0.5560474991798401,
-0.8636773228645325,
-0.03372791036963463,
-0.05101823806762695,
-0.4005681276321411,
0.20293937623500824,
-0.012540776282548904,
0.3927531838417053,
0.2751633822917938,
-0.9666741490364075,
0.28696906566619873,
0.7091904878616333,
0.9450982213020325,
-0.1406019628047943,
-0.0032440503127872944,
-0.21704590320587158,
0.270832896232605,
-0.1730715036392212,
0.7025306224822998,
-0.4344883859157562,
-0.49525579810142517,
0.15822017192840576,
-0.06752537935972214,
-0.006681615021079779,
-0.3388841152191162,
0.0332498773932457,
-0.6933161020278931,
0.10886875540018082,
-0.061441920697689056,
-0.4421401619911194,
-0.24278278648853302,
0.41587263345718384,
-0.805945098400116,
0.944060742855072,
-0.1632404625415802,
-0.6814183592796326,
0.08891520649194717,
-0.6735891103744507,
-0.3216508626937866,
-0.2027934342622757,
-0.26310455799102783,
-0.40960952639579773,
-0.10697142779827118,
0.38610196113586426,
0.8790780305862427,
-0.8014192581176758,
0.5698609352111816,
-0.545711100101471,
0.08792568743228912,
0.3579326272010803,
-0.8498529195785522,
0.666290283203125,
0.3635658919811249,
-0.007191010285168886,
0.003291745437309146,
-0.7456074357032776,
-0.18932300806045532,
0.19571304321289062,
0.06249776855111122,
-0.4255900979042053,
0.271980881690979,
0.3820141553878784,
-0.09525234252214432,
0.2747465670108795,
-0.4398200511932373,
0.5057995915412903,
-0.2551024556159973,
0.8322386741638184,
0.7147275805473328,
0.10617657750844955,
0.17711496353149414,
-0.2332160770893097,
0.668994128704071,
-0.023101262748241425,
0.16381214559078217,
-0.5264748930931091,
-0.3000747561454773,
-0.4336971044540405,
-0.11306244134902954,
0.15972460806369781,
0.6941132545471191,
-0.8689475059509277,
-0.11052525043487549,
-0.620661735534668,
-0.5880188941955566,
-0.0024020953569561243,
0.10534653067588806,
-0.01950759068131447,
0.20679491758346558,
0.04977364465594292,
0.06610915064811707,
-0.48244112730026245,
-0.6450530886650085,
-0.05072353407740593,
-0.04887218400835991,
0.13920822739601135,
0.1496530920267105,
0.4663812220096588,
-0.1943228840827942,
0.8952449560165405,
-0.7944549322128296,
0.11166195571422577,
-0.184468612074852,
0.21437083184719086,
0.29762911796569824,
0.05569382384419441,
0.7215837240219116,
-0.8745474815368652,
-0.17911799252033234,
0.032077256590127945,
-0.7386472225189209,
-0.03855622187256813,
-0.07053834199905396,
0.3386857509613037,
0.27911168336868286,
0.8116732239723206,
-0.26028311252593994,
0.2095133364200592,
0.8827629089355469,
-0.13495829701423645,
0.45937925577163696,
0.14056767523288727,
0.20106323063373566,
-1.4486652612686157,
0.1794527918100357,
0.3153838813304901,
-0.3236709237098694,
-0.548374593257904,
-0.25726422667503357,
-0.3635020852088928,
-0.2700180411338806,
-0.3715558648109436,
0.9069994688034058,
-0.6627432703971863,
-0.1731223315000534,
-0.09064844995737076,
-0.011795478872954845,
-0.28018057346343994,
0.26587891578674316,
0.010941854678094387,
0.630728542804718,
0.49490872025489807,
-0.37595894932746887,
0.9595836400985718,
0.03923045098781586,
-0.6759186387062073,
0.1747492402791977,
-0.5472978949546814,
0.034754153341054916,
-0.2522084712982178,
0.03392994403839111,
-0.9905630946159363,
-0.22173026204109192,
0.09907152503728867,
-0.07647739350795746,
0.43063434958457947,
-0.10866974294185638,
-0.798922061920166,
-0.33480244874954224,
-0.2105644941329956,
0.6525552868843079,
0.3049507141113281,
-0.5540766716003418,
0.5263329744338989,
0.5106462240219116,
-0.5507398843765259,
-0.5060626864433289,
-0.7374572157859802,
0.2605316638946533,
-0.5593103170394897,
-0.47375208139419556,
0.20548655092716217,
-0.07999175041913986,
-0.7723982930183411,
-0.13590623438358307,
0.1229274719953537,
-0.1367531567811966,
0.025834277272224426,
0.07700882107019424,
0.5297213792800903,
-0.24838797748088837,
0.10244911164045334,
-0.402339905500412,
-0.053177233785390854,
0.04657750576734543,
-0.27477964758872986,
0.5393651723861694,
-0.11239573359489441,
-0.5118736624717712,
-0.2506992518901825,
0.34932923316955566,
0.7288955450057983,
-0.2097180038690567,
0.5701532363891602,
0.6885356307029724,
-0.30257031321525574,
-0.16409243643283844,
-0.5494682788848877,
-0.060010068118572235,
-0.4413958787918091,
0.19511067867279053,
0.07094094157218933,
-1.236973762512207,
0.3514845371246338,
-0.33099108934402466,
0.15132884681224823,
0.22708123922348022,
0.7161057591438293,
-0.008919847197830677,
0.6797914505004883,
0.7619866728782654,
-0.5402359962463379,
0.8196017146110535,
-0.4020688831806183,
0.4337381422519684,
-0.6297277212142944,
-0.2823852598667145,
-0.4089478552341461,
-0.2414741814136505,
-0.47409388422966003,
-0.4050366282463074,
0.5743594765663147,
-0.33045485615730286,
-0.23021040856838226,
-0.16429300606250763,
-0.07512965053319931,
0.26070162653923035,
0.1547233611345291,
-0.2705647349357605,
0.5364043116569519,
0.34305471181869507,
0.2642415761947632,
-0.17272984981536865,
-0.534005880355835,
-0.5066347122192383,
1.0755642652511597,
0.34914249181747437,
1.1503610610961914,
0.22992053627967834,
0.19078585505485535,
0.46650925278663635,
0.3522031903266907,
-0.8977482318878174,
0.5501503944396973,
-0.2658085823059082,
-0.3894973695278168,
-0.5298984050750732,
-0.47576865553855896,
-0.8456785678863525,
0.04920564964413643,
0.022861422970891,
-0.5013342499732971,
-0.06880742311477661,
-0.050229065120220184,
-0.3369326889514923,
0.6683399677276611,
-0.5067370533943176,
0.6824216246604919,
-0.4421142637729645,
-0.26728013157844543,
-0.22093045711517334,
-0.4724039137363434,
0.4462495744228363,
-0.19333024322986603,
0.31429964303970337,
-0.24070529639720917,
-0.10269860178232193,
0.6645936369895935,
-0.21223534643650055,
1.1870297193527222,
0.11086804419755936,
-0.39157217741012573,
0.3169506788253784,
-0.1822122484445572,
0.21178556978702545,
0.06730913370847702,
-0.04553678259253502,
0.42063435912132263,
0.2895885109901428,
-0.2609773874282837,
-0.4837200939655304,
0.7575052976608276,
-0.6237123608589172,
-0.4238381087779999,
-0.8589041829109192,
-0.5635368824005127,
-0.45673075318336487,
0.032534293830394745,
-0.2430109679698944,
0.8926472663879395,
-0.22384782135486603,
0.21805496513843536,
0.6562404036521912,
-0.07038015127182007,
0.919450044631958,
0.47500160336494446,
-0.48828041553497314,
-0.4232451915740967,
0.8615079522132874,
0.22644810378551483,
0.1532798707485199,
0.648403525352478,
0.06327279657125473,
-0.42236214876174927,
-0.6279452443122864,
-0.2357763946056366,
0.39841988682746887,
-0.4296792149543762,
-0.1271405816078186,
-0.16920305788516998,
-0.33207690715789795,
-0.5083369612693787,
0.1576317995786667,
-0.10296439379453659,
-0.37223750352859497,
-0.3165404796600342,
0.06283462047576904,
0.7645713090896606,
0.8296249508857727,
0.30338847637176514,
0.47479140758514404,
-0.9958615303039551,
0.34493622183799744,
0.324665367603302,
0.4152383506298065,
0.10552207380533218,
-0.10440795868635178,
-0.20373527705669403,
-0.10980482399463654,
-0.33344316482543945,
-0.5629384517669678,
0.7125850915908813,
0.11771383136510849,
0.49425169825553894,
0.37992048263549805,
-0.1602359563112259,
0.7220475673675537,
-0.5769252777099609,
1.0362896919250488,
0.2611466646194458,
-0.6666747331619263,
0.17317287623882294,
-0.6362582445144653,
0.22263745963573456,
-0.07554003596305847,
0.4819580614566803,
-0.9805828332901001,
0.12440841645002365,
-0.2159624546766281,
-0.8166629076004028,
0.36583584547042847,
-0.10777608305215836,
0.028280850499868393,
0.22053687274456024,
0.32712993025779724,
-0.11112154275178909,
0.48675042390823364,
-0.44866013526916504,
-0.139154314994812,
0.044058267027139664,
-0.37583911418914795,
-0.5340655446052551,
-0.020386194810271263,
-0.1300382912158966,
-0.06584188342094421,
0.381136029958725,
-0.2839006185531616,
0.0024069007486104965,
0.11951404809951782,
0.099996417760849,
0.1450498402118683,
0.28300803899765015,
0.4895736575126648,
0.734889805316925,
0.05552241951227188,
0.011549488641321659,
0.08633720874786377,
-0.41903257369995117,
-0.049111202359199524,
0.06685303896665573,
0.05238728225231171,
-0.10488244146108627,
0.5277913212776184,
0.7786391973495483,
0.1269325166940689,
-0.8136157989501953,
0.1985529661178589,
0.12327289581298828,
0.06685656309127808,
-0.6860076785087585,
-0.33139768242836,
0.07632775604724884,
0.4062350392341614,
0.3158998489379883,
-0.29028648138046265,
-0.054507412016391754,
-0.552489161491394,
-0.30615803599357605,
0.5129196047782898,
-0.09383641928434372,
-0.3697620928287506,
0.6008890271186829,
0.22024017572402954,
-0.025783535093069077,
0.5884642601013184,
0.2953760623931885,
-0.19230997562408447,
0.6488983035087585,
0.17387382686138153,
0.6798381209373474,
-0.10851898044347763,
-0.02336040884256363,
0.09778982400894165,
0.30303147435188293,
-0.24153448641300201,
0.37092477083206177,
0.06415600329637527,
-0.6251547336578369,
-0.8994119167327881,
-0.708929181098938,
-0.705574631690979,
0.3816707134246826,
-0.44914722442626953,
0.3183960020542145,
-0.4143369793891907,
-0.34460386633872986,
0.08666937053203583,
-0.018202517181634903,
-0.5364609956741333,
-0.008682538755238056,
0.46967747807502747,
0.9479209780693054,
-0.8465743064880371,
0.6887969970703125,
0.7439161539077759,
-0.08196564018726349,
-0.3930433392524719,
-0.21798795461654663,
0.23898884654045105,
-0.7679398059844971,
0.5851572155952454,
-0.23713384568691254,
-0.2342417985200882,
0.005839800927788019,
-0.7056801319122314,
-0.7859240174293518,
1.105408787727356,
0.11250670999288559,
-0.765537679195404,
-0.13809148967266083,
0.36097243428230286,
0.5144107937812805,
-0.2771044671535492,
-0.014414272271096706,
0.5495491027832031,
0.49756890535354614,
-0.011594287119805813,
-0.7860506772994995,
-0.29076942801475525,
-0.1964661031961441,
0.23468053340911865,
0.5899835228919983,
-0.9755842685699463,
0.47194385528564453,
-0.02150239236652851,
0.009761572815477848,
0.1852257251739502,
0.6336552500724792,
-0.054355036467313766,
0.665550708770752,
0.43878158926963806,
0.35924282670021057,
0.4818989336490631,
-0.12036234885454178,
0.8694131374359131,
-0.2800556421279907,
0.48056063055992126,
0.8387618064880371,
-0.5084587931632996,
0.7962448596954346,
0.7164836525917053,
-0.4641305208206177,
0.3273884952068329,
0.7204063534736633,
-0.18834169209003448,
0.17846201360225677,
0.19806231558322906,
-0.3283921480178833,
-0.3386034369468689,
-0.17323638498783112,
-0.3379409611225128,
0.24088703095912933,
0.7034182548522949,
-0.01615840010344982,
-0.22681254148483276,
0.19099374115467072,
-0.04544972628355026,
-0.026816774159669876,
-0.39049628376960754,
0.48813265562057495,
0.40422987937927246,
-0.3196116089820862,
0.11021269857883453,
-0.13332931697368622,
0.6543469429016113,
-0.9323281645774841,
-0.10294318944215775,
0.005224819760769606,
-0.02426113747060299,
-0.03016715496778488,
-0.8956894874572754,
0.44922757148742676,
0.10864568501710892,
-0.2176869511604309,
-0.5545072555541992,
0.48148128390312195,
-0.23869483172893524,
-0.7349345088005066,
0.11247711628675461,
0.5278220772743225,
0.11466256529092789,
0.23977959156036377,
-0.3435674011707306,
0.10860554873943329,
-0.23183640837669373,
-0.35861334204673767,
0.12092858552932739,
0.4808844327926636,
-0.22154630720615387,
0.9283764362335205,
0.6686597466468811,
0.29033002257347107,
0.22910462319850922,
0.3808597922325134,
0.6655699014663696,
-1.08268141746521,
-0.14730599522590637,
-0.9222482442855835,
0.16423827409744263,
-0.009819064289331436,
-0.13558614253997803,
0.8185104131698608,
0.5136359930038452,
0.5572224855422974,
-0.10499507933855057,
0.9642926454544067,
0.20284362137317657,
0.5963112115859985,
-0.8746334314346313,
0.4636097848415375,
-0.6252493858337402,
0.38792330026626587,
-0.13719499111175537,
-0.8638439178466797,
-0.4299740791320801,
0.013089700601994991,
-0.5217999219894409,
-0.0834098607301712,
0.5256422162055969,
0.5608406662940979,
-0.04494892433285713,
0.24813298881053925,
0.25485682487487793,
0.31282997131347656,
0.3720238208770752,
0.27317771315574646,
1.043103814125061,
0.019306885078549385,
0.4428848624229431,
-0.012582603842020035,
-0.20520254969596863,
-0.2533026337623596,
-1.2030324935913086,
-0.9324597716331482,
-0.5754179954528809,
-0.3271390199661255,
0.04768229275941849,
-0.2537685036659241,
0.8200097680091858,
0.6005143523216248,
-0.6261152029037476,
-0.48198094964027405,
0.3711298406124115,
-0.11421829462051392,
-0.00985743384808302,
-0.16093122959136963,
0.30798038840293884,
-0.06396830081939697,
-0.9371435046195984,
0.3339890241622925,
0.18303872644901276,
0.35526570677757263,
-0.7808137536048889,
0.2981238067150116,
0.21820691227912903,
-0.07490405440330505,
0.8843937516212463,
0.3470282554626465,
-0.570661723613739,
0.05730869621038437,
0.2513640820980072,
0.13851165771484375,
-0.18384557962417603,
1.1866096258163452,
-0.5211501121520996,
0.22661340236663818,
0.555040180683136,
0.68192058801651,
0.5822580456733704,
-0.21793663501739502,
0.40889230370521545,
-0.46509331464767456,
0.20375753939151764,
0.13549154996871948,
0.5503170490264893,
0.46895676851272583,
-0.06746457517147064,
0.4027354121208191,
0.4113835096359253,
-0.617022693157196,
-0.8420669436454773,
0.2792627215385437,
-1.3473602533340454,
-0.23328624665737152,
1.2559435367584229,
0.29565107822418213,
-0.2825377285480499,
-0.12611496448516846,
-0.09581553936004639,
0.027956858277320862,
-0.1421496719121933,
0.5637580752372742,
0.985289990901947,
-0.11646708101034164,
-0.123748779296875,
-0.9167705178260803,
0.10928456485271454,
-0.040320638567209244,
-0.8111022710800171,
0.18195989727973938,
0.45402345061302185,
0.32910478115081787,
0.03688361495733261,
0.3466203212738037,
-0.24906256794929504,
-0.4235754609107971,
-0.37831759452819824,
-0.1225937232375145,
-0.04729266092181206,
-0.3311591148376465,
-0.5855554938316345,
0.053033336997032166,
-0.009080551564693451,
0.12577104568481445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01183v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01183v1 | LINGO-Space: Language-Conditioned Incremental Grounding for Space | 2024-02-02T06:58:39 | 2024-02-02T06:58:39 | Dohyun Kim, Nayoung Oh, Deokmin Hwang, Daehyung Park | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | We aim to solve the problem of spatially localizing composite instructions
referring to space: space grounding. Compared to current instance grounding,
space grounding is challenging due to the ill-posedness of identifying
locations referred to by discrete expressions and the compositional ambiguity
of referring expressions. Therefore, we propose a novel probabilistic
space-grounding methodology (LINGO-Space) that accurately identifies a
probabilistic distribution of space being referred to and incrementally updates
it, given subsequent referring expressions leveraging configurable polar
distributions. Our evaluations show that the estimation using polar
distributions enables a robot to ground locations successfully through $20$
table-top manipulation benchmark tests. We also show that updating the
distribution helps the grounding method accurately narrow the referring space.
We finally demonstrate the robustness of the space grounding with simulated
manipulation and real quadruped robot navigation tasks. Code and videos are
available at https://lingo-space.github.io. | [
-0.012483474798500538,
-0.5674825310707092,
0.67073655128479,
0.6608830094337463,
-0.30931177735328674,
0.19667869806289673,
-0.051638614386320114,
-0.060027606785297394,
0.3151087760925293,
0.39364445209503174,
-0.6112084984779358,
-0.6795617938041687,
-0.3911241888999939,
-0.2731504440307617,
-0.1477500945329666,
0.6676344275474548,
0.20266807079315186,
-0.027097012847661972,
-0.35311028361320496,
-0.3907372057437897,
-0.9596850275993347,
-0.7070488929748535,
-0.3259282410144806,
-0.2516503930091858,
0.012475650757551193,
0.665233314037323,
1.3527458906173706,
0.5838146209716797,
0.5911043286323547,
0.27924805879592896,
-0.18080870807170868,
0.005265491548925638,
0.015889901667833328,
-0.09537079930305481,
-0.22791805863380432,
-0.4821781814098358,
-0.23330634832382202,
-0.07060489803552628,
0.7261177897453308,
1.088248372077942,
-0.4819069802761078,
-0.42530882358551025,
-0.7159460783004761,
0.6726283431053162,
-0.6106408834457397,
0.14082959294319153,
-0.5919855237007141,
0.37467196583747864,
0.13571174442768097,
-0.3473239839076996,
-0.2204780876636505,
-0.23751488327980042,
-0.2777611017227173,
-1.0650148391723633,
0.26737067103385925,
0.41568025946617126,
0.8772528767585754,
0.5239120125770569,
0.08308915048837662,
-0.3544461727142334,
-0.5981830358505249,
0.6939569115638733,
-0.45550230145454407,
0.5106828212738037,
0.39009276032447815,
0.307399183511734,
-0.16435252130031586,
-0.26930955052375793,
-0.6798979043960571,
-0.6205657720565796,
0.04813876375555992,
0.3080841898918152,
0.16707712411880493,
0.09358658641576767,
0.14887244999408722,
0.19652079045772552,
-0.258240282535553,
-0.2556327283382416,
-0.15792812407016754,
0.05222652852535248,
0.1381240040063858,
-0.3480018079280853,
0.5888500213623047,
-0.12133217602968216,
-0.5232834219932556,
-0.41231322288513184,
-0.7102704048156738,
-0.11889823526144028,
0.29106605052948,
0.24035778641700745,
-0.18909814953804016,
0.7953028082847595,
-0.20522257685661316,
0.5661459565162659,
0.5065596103668213,
0.14861425757408142,
0.4892277717590332,
-0.07278507947921753,
-0.1851930469274521,
-0.05941510200500488,
0.4862453043460846,
0.4265545606613159,
-0.04388886317610741,
-0.48649173974990845,
-0.13049617409706116,
-0.08954314142465591,
0.40599295496940613,
-0.1775742471218109,
-0.38344883918762207,
0.3450467586517334,
0.24157415330410004,
-0.08732795715332031,
0.24950389564037323,
-0.32556402683258057,
-0.47873327136039734,
-0.1911584585905075,
0.22710716724395752,
-0.7149820923805237,
-0.059168435633182526,
0.4692096412181854,
-0.27363741397857666,
0.0049431282095611095,
0.12248439341783524,
-0.7246346473693848,
0.13328416645526886,
0.6303092241287231,
0.8087713122367859,
0.19920115172863007,
-0.22607377171516418,
-0.48244509100914,
0.23102149367332458,
-0.6051031351089478,
0.8751651048660278,
-0.5912206768989563,
-0.3681100010871887,
0.012093941681087017,
-0.10675353556871414,
0.042712971568107605,
-0.8245832324028015,
0.5133417844772339,
-0.7013046145439148,
0.33941397070884705,
-0.14504288136959076,
-0.17871439456939697,
0.02250245399773121,
0.3316497504711151,
-0.5571836233139038,
1.0063109397888184,
0.5164647102355957,
-0.5881268382072449,
0.34345170855522156,
-0.4844222068786621,
-0.47936585545539856,
0.29269343614578247,
-0.021034663543105125,
-0.26241716742515564,
-0.10341978073120117,
0.06877998262643814,
0.12112954258918762,
-0.05027914419770241,
0.5266916751861572,
-0.08001670241355896,
-0.3491359353065491,
-0.05450175330042839,
0.2927199602127075,
0.6175084114074707,
0.23007437586784363,
-0.3032931089401245,
0.10639291256666183,
-0.5831876993179321,
-0.18498404324054718,
-0.05481806397438049,
-0.19820243120193481,
-0.5641246438026428,
0.23708103597164154,
-0.46233069896698,
0.14495202898979187,
0.3229468762874603,
-0.12378257513046265,
0.38287654519081116,
-0.8091123700141907,
0.008746963925659657,
0.3359594941139221,
-0.013079577125608921,
1.2536028623580933,
-0.1101086214184761,
0.697603166103363,
0.09080159664154053,
0.24347136914730072,
-0.21230284869670868,
-0.532241940498352,
-0.6517822742462158,
-0.30531394481658936,
0.003086944343522191,
1.1429500579833984,
-1.0402601957321167,
0.7296619415283203,
-0.3734595477581024,
-0.47832825779914856,
0.03247983008623123,
0.015189091674983501,
0.3607901334762573,
0.5284925103187561,
0.568372905254364,
0.2266835719347,
-0.2804982364177704,
-0.6435145735740662,
0.12906846404075623,
-0.2615315616130829,
-0.3882066309452057,
0.35013991594314575,
0.22852472960948944,
-0.30625155568122864,
0.8098945021629333,
-0.4534144401550293,
-0.12981785833835602,
0.24974985420703888,
0.23610959947109222,
0.42277055978775024,
0.42830753326416016,
0.633142352104187,
-0.8968501687049866,
-0.2707589864730835,
-0.016801517456769943,
-0.8128149509429932,
-0.35924848914146423,
-0.39817139506340027,
-0.2898084819316864,
-0.15540887415409088,
0.8036304712295532,
-1.1015034914016724,
-0.20624220371246338,
0.5370392203330994,
-0.4820321798324585,
0.33645784854888916,
-0.42380058765411377,
0.0704183354973793,
-0.7312904000282288,
-0.028878841549158096,
-0.20867091417312622,
-0.072291798889637,
-0.3152783215045929,
0.5594541430473328,
-0.020812485367059708,
-0.3521411418914795,
-0.4502716064453125,
0.35115060210227966,
-0.6863832473754883,
0.02643168531358242,
-0.023613298311829567,
0.5311743021011353,
-0.17884241044521332,
0.3630671501159668,
0.19176426529884338,
0.794323205947876,
0.6021054983139038,
-0.6279167532920837,
0.2055722177028656,
0.4011389911174774,
-0.049779631197452545,
0.5735677480697632,
-0.515347421169281,
0.09668983519077301,
-0.21768082678318024,
0.42550769448280334,
-1.1329777240753174,
-0.003776109777390957,
0.6671127080917358,
-0.4173072278499603,
0.03281402960419655,
-0.27345070242881775,
-0.5400139093399048,
-0.04006475955247879,
-0.2873404026031494,
0.4816970229148865,
0.4291587769985199,
-0.4479832947254181,
0.512407660484314,
0.6676312685012817,
-0.1791178286075592,
-0.6725109219551086,
-0.19014574587345123,
0.2175820916891098,
-0.36340948939323425,
-0.6160318851470947,
0.4138152003288269,
-0.2340015023946762,
-0.4415939450263977,
-0.31308305263519287,
-0.1774141937494278,
0.1071692630648613,
0.07502610236406326,
0.34727388620376587,
0.07463423907756805,
0.11243996024131775,
0.15598750114440918,
0.0555361770093441,
-0.31154540181159973,
0.10771564394235611,
-0.5407761931419373,
0.5643843412399292,
0.010380934923887253,
-0.3301180601119995,
0.13345086574554443,
0.25806790590286255,
0.5631124377250671,
0.34470072388648987,
0.5253588557243347,
0.19591358304023743,
-0.4237267076969147,
-0.1808694303035736,
-0.24509520828723907,
0.06711768358945847,
-0.5566814541816711,
0.04510500282049179,
-0.43044862151145935,
-0.48477575182914734,
0.38601264357566833,
-0.3742324411869049,
-0.1614391803741455,
0.2956661880016327,
0.02449263073503971,
-0.3358071446418762,
0.7920244336128235,
0.9098548293113708,
-0.03794686868786812,
0.34973159432411194,
-0.17698822915554047,
0.3895895183086395,
-0.3131387233734131,
-0.3008057177066803,
-0.5335251092910767,
0.03991314396262169,
-0.38545721769332886,
-1.2031861543655396,
0.424864798784256,
0.35100412368774414,
-0.21480397880077362,
0.3491600751876831,
-0.6181221604347229,
0.4845969080924988,
0.6054351925849915,
-0.24386882781982422,
-0.15714912116527557,
0.26490646600723267,
-0.2934405207633972,
-0.05915594846010208,
-0.9313607811927795,
-0.2032773643732071,
0.28131094574928284,
0.07925117760896683,
0.34544554352760315,
-0.0634455755352974,
0.37262487411499023,
0.4052197337150574,
0.6394792199134827,
-0.6829567551612854,
0.5961804986000061,
-0.1626581847667694,
-0.31623655557632446,
-0.3120752274990082,
-0.19625064730644226,
-0.7343863844871521,
0.16297006607055664,
-0.1485622227191925,
-0.3315286636352539,
0.026308134198188782,
0.21800090372562408,
-0.34862154722213745,
0.062409043312072754,
-0.5477695465087891,
0.5761933326721191,
-0.12081094086170197,
0.0179916825145483,
-0.13763096928596497,
-0.9325013160705566,
0.041186537593603134,
0.016212385147809982,
0.7653958201408386,
-0.06033305451273918,
-0.09020807594060898,
0.47382086515426636,
-0.4559677243232727,
0.648833692073822,
-0.6257505416870117,
-0.46158498525619507,
0.30056050419807434,
0.23263151943683624,
0.4874208867549896,
0.33949992060661316,
0.06432511657476425,
0.45593520998954773,
-0.415069043636322,
-0.21086633205413818,
-0.6765247583389282,
0.668724775314331,
-0.7590444684028625,
-0.49593624472618103,
-0.5441011190414429,
-0.6437753438949585,
-0.44605472683906555,
0.06286084651947021,
0.17858010530471802,
-0.16732725501060486,
0.06296930462121964,
0.0722416341304779,
0.7362542748451233,
-0.6902470588684082,
0.021539585664868355,
0.4962964653968811,
0.08196501433849335,
-0.6493368148803711,
0.8988436460494995,
-0.20274661481380463,
-0.10279998183250427,
1.0757901668548584,
0.17166182398796082,
-0.31991344690322876,
-0.24046221375465393,
-0.3790307641029358,
0.3917712867259979,
-0.7891960740089417,
-0.14904575049877167,
-0.500298798084259,
0.11317219585180283,
-0.17403468489646912,
-0.9477935433387756,
-0.3390656113624573,
-0.6757444143295288,
-0.0674591213464737,
-0.30271396040916443,
-0.047121357172727585,
0.11123019456863403,
-0.20589616894721985,
0.7538694143295288,
-0.5303625464439392,
0.6779217720031738,
-0.013416885398328304,
0.09756727516651154,
-0.8311891555786133,
-0.5792415738105774,
-0.043238166719675064,
0.21907103061676025,
0.07202206552028656,
-0.5863484144210815,
0.39941200613975525,
-0.038178831338882446,
0.32634246349334717,
0.12518921494483948,
-0.09855344891548157,
0.7491654753684998,
-0.854381263256073,
0.8180968761444092,
0.43764403462409973,
-0.858515739440918,
0.7325133681297302,
-0.642476499080658,
0.44953516125679016,
0.30679017305374146,
0.3109775185585022,
-0.5843198895454407,
-0.6358287930488586,
-0.8072490692138672,
-1.3217662572860718,
0.4549853801727295,
0.11093392223119736,
0.418461412191391,
-0.38428056240081787,
0.6620959043502808,
-0.10424436628818512,
0.30085310339927673,
-0.6346527934074402,
-0.36666980385780334,
-0.25505220890045166,
0.009601066820323467,
-0.24511951208114624,
-0.24519801139831543,
-0.4584101438522339,
-0.10116639733314514,
0.5660001039505005,
-0.1414673626422882,
0.5136345028877258,
0.00936844665557146,
-0.2658940553665161,
-0.1822657436132431,
-0.059967901557683945,
0.8066802024841309,
0.5369073748588562,
-0.24787397682666779,
0.10121050477027893,
0.10606234520673752,
-0.3378164768218994,
0.28719744086265564,
0.006208945997059345,
-0.4463270604610443,
0.48244473338127136,
0.139286071062088,
0.43979308009147644,
0.5600842237472534,
-0.662997305393219,
0.5309565663337708,
0.3476858139038086,
-0.1287483274936676,
-0.747219979763031,
0.022402312606573105,
-0.00030135439010336995,
-0.1051047295331955,
0.4622851312160492,
0.38317570090293884,
0.03440894931554794,
-0.29808738827705383,
0.21805831789970398,
0.4993274509906769,
-0.2283669263124466,
-0.3972780704498291,
0.9840319752693176,
0.05180015787482262,
-0.5334315299987793,
0.5829877853393555,
-0.3363225758075714,
-0.3781803250312805,
0.7795640826225281,
0.502524733543396,
0.6918599009513855,
-0.11365213245153427,
0.564588189125061,
0.5412793159484863,
0.44873547554016113,
-0.27306708693504333,
0.3182210326194763,
-0.3069740831851959,
-0.9939980506896973,
-0.27282699942588806,
-0.4068957269191742,
-0.709027111530304,
-0.3089143931865692,
-0.20696613192558289,
0.3134966492652893,
-0.7789303064346313,
-0.06653124839067459,
-0.39321431517601013,
-0.2865252196788788,
-0.2613369822502136,
0.5737448334693909,
0.534104585647583,
0.9386761784553528,
-0.8480067849159241,
0.3139318525791168,
1.1424641609191895,
-0.10238902270793915,
-0.47059857845306396,
0.011360861361026764,
-0.26270127296447754,
-0.7430545091629028,
0.6575058102607727,
0.03894766420125961,
-0.6856642365455627,
-0.20104598999023438,
-0.9382686018943787,
-1.1067328453063965,
0.9153332710266113,
0.3828185796737671,
-0.2963138222694397,
0.20624731481075287,
0.14467670023441315,
0.5313555002212524,
-0.05026402324438095,
0.03802507743239403,
0.10476605594158173,
0.5688932538032532,
0.019721798598766327,
-0.5381367802619934,
0.027473945170640945,
-0.3468530476093292,
0.011864090338349342,
0.021760670468211174,
-0.826516330242157,
0.4874175190925598,
-0.3023441433906555,
-0.46591901779174805,
0.03997691720724106,
0.6696817278862,
0.6576510071754456,
0.19069615006446838,
0.865507185459137,
0.714316189289093,
0.9013875126838684,
-0.1707988828420639,
0.8474855422973633,
-0.8124298453330994,
0.24359428882598877,
0.8477806448936462,
-0.436234712600708,
0.5018099546432495,
0.5874537229537964,
-0.034289438277482986,
0.7388226985931396,
0.14963991940021515,
0.22923950850963593,
0.8963333368301392,
0.1951216757297516,
-0.43283453583717346,
-0.09073292464017868,
0.1813194751739502,
-0.19395731389522552,
0.029688479378819466,
0.5525892972946167,
0.25192245841026306,
-0.2183353751897812,
0.07173540443181992,
0.09090293943881989,
0.17912141978740692,
0.151967853307724,
0.3287283182144165,
-0.13917820155620575,
-0.9197174906730652,
0.5662734508514404,
0.3426761329174042,
0.5712176561355591,
-0.7842447757720947,
-0.24549993872642517,
-0.5449124574661255,
0.04172305390238762,
0.004591507371515036,
-0.6134076714515686,
0.2884102463722229,
-0.5003727078437805,
-0.16332519054412842,
-0.795427680015564,
0.42465031147003174,
-0.21834717690944672,
-0.17327986657619476,
0.18876022100448608,
0.22699880599975586,
0.18327264487743378,
-0.13631173968315125,
-0.44553521275520325,
-0.24491167068481445,
-0.269766628742218,
-0.14359770715236664,
0.1786753535270691,
0.6833545565605164,
-0.2972576916217804,
1.0038481950759888,
0.7765575647354126,
-0.052356746047735214,
0.07983385771512985,
0.25360146164894104,
0.635637104511261,
-0.7140688300132751,
-0.8363719582557678,
-0.326925128698349,
0.6217193007469177,
0.10825645178556442,
-0.36675745248794556,
0.836135983467102,
0.3897568881511688,
0.6341356635093689,
-0.5267741680145264,
0.5078760981559753,
-0.3517036736011505,
0.12362747639417648,
-0.5875580906867981,
0.2518925070762634,
-0.2887110412120819,
0.31210950016975403,
-0.02496129646897316,
-0.7305977940559387,
-0.7290271520614624,
0.941906750202179,
-0.167073056101799,
-0.22501064836978912,
0.8223844170570374,
0.8057096600532532,
-0.11690147966146469,
-0.5975446701049805,
0.37195339798927307,
0.06830345094203949,
0.03305886313319206,
0.2913726270198822,
0.92365962266922,
-0.4010278284549713,
0.3237398862838745,
-0.37047621607780457,
-0.2739587724208832,
-0.1165233850479126,
-0.8164501786231995,
-0.24329827725887299,
-0.3548847436904907,
-0.6492102146148682,
-0.22890275716781616,
0.12346332520246506,
0.42417195439338684,
0.8664894700050354,
-0.714181125164032,
-0.04187144711613655,
-0.34522029757499695,
0.3268960416316986,
-0.4928174316883087,
-0.2741820812225342,
0.04989586025476456,
-0.45102623105049133,
-0.5091967582702637,
0.901357889175415,
0.4212891459465027,
-0.40353918075561523,
0.1322963535785675,
-0.06669291108846664,
-0.10641040652990341,
0.1101817637681961,
0.7152727246284485,
0.5149754285812378,
-0.46958523988723755,
-0.6198252439498901,
0.23895204067230225,
-0.12682701647281647,
0.22641180455684662,
0.7846482396125793,
-0.8082723021507263,
0.22728753089904785,
0.3388003408908844,
0.2690200209617615,
-0.036414019763469696,
0.47108224034309387,
0.5279340147972107,
-1.3169585466384888,
0.7096144556999207,
0.2816012501716614,
0.3183912932872772,
0.5150978565216064,
-0.6376767158508301,
0.6686568856239319,
0.4520602524280548,
-0.42501136660575867,
-0.5826416611671448,
-0.025671539828181267,
-1.2598307132720947,
-0.2062065154314041,
1.4000438451766968,
0.011652474291622639,
-0.05691622570157051,
0.01812480203807354,
-0.28869596123695374,
-0.0031283933203667402,
-0.059899307787418365,
1.077396035194397,
0.6367649435997009,
0.2336357831954956,
-0.005488999653607607,
-0.47623106837272644,
0.18996259570121765,
0.5789698362350464,
-0.6284105181694031,
-0.24012237787246704,
0.8798747658729553,
0.5101617574691772,
0.8367258310317993,
0.741377592086792,
-0.017294343560934067,
0.257768452167511,
0.2517271041870117,
0.39971596002578735,
0.355969101190567,
-0.6190038919448853,
-0.31383880972862244,
0.4189428687095642,
-0.19969651103019714,
-0.2882005274295807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01182v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01182v1 | In-Context Learning for Few-Shot Nested Named Entity Recognition | 2024-02-02T06:57:53 | 2024-02-02T06:57:53 | Meishan Zhang, Bin Wang, Hao Fei, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In nested Named entity recognition (NER), entities are nested with each
other, and thus requiring more data annotations to address. This leads to the
development of few-shot nested NER, where the prevalence of pretrained language
models with in-context learning (ICL) offers promising solutions. In this work,
we introduce an effective and innovative ICL framework for the setting of
few-shot nested NER. We improve the ICL prompt by devising a novel example
demonstration selection mechanism, EnDe retriever. In EnDe retriever, we employ
contrastive learning to perform three types of representation learning, in
terms of semantic similarity, boundary similarity, and label similarity, to
generate high-quality demonstration examples. Extensive experiments over three
nested NER and four flat NER datasets demonstrate the efficacy of our system. | [
-0.3938443958759308,
-0.39684683084487915,
0.31073716282844543,
-0.12536804378032684,
-0.47314298152923584,
-0.03743114694952965,
-0.20356503129005432,
-0.45538657903671265,
-0.06511818617582321,
0.19372735917568207,
-0.369546502828598,
-0.5952116250991821,
-0.43480435013771057,
0.36891043186187744,
-0.19177864491939545,
1.1567192077636719,
-0.05988185107707977,
0.07045862823724747,
-0.10995789617300034,
-0.1344224065542221,
-0.24321645498275757,
-0.3709295094013214,
-0.9519756436347961,
-0.6039498448371887,
0.2966603934764862,
0.6683236956596375,
-0.14255933463573456,
0.07075012475252151,
0.4101394712924957,
0.1440165638923645,
0.008028418757021427,
-0.047448597848415375,
-0.6694076061248779,
0.10936038196086884,
-0.06304910033941269,
-0.6366870403289795,
0.29883116483688354,
-0.4057646095752716,
0.6948938965797424,
0.5073679685592651,
0.0053731584921479225,
-0.05484301224350929,
0.24917307496070862,
0.2156611979007721,
-0.8046137690544128,
0.18226416409015656,
-0.8350934982299805,
0.14896894991397858,
-0.22368241846561432,
0.020409313961863518,
-0.5936172604560852,
-0.05220847204327583,
0.4672336280345917,
-0.616305947303772,
0.012976770289242268,
0.157206729054451,
0.8803295493125916,
0.14585666358470917,
-0.43647128343582153,
-0.1724368780851364,
-0.4944983720779419,
0.7981173396110535,
-0.8704695105552673,
0.4000263214111328,
0.12264034152030945,
0.6531944870948792,
-0.3106115758419037,
-0.7650566697120667,
-0.7018510103225708,
-0.14322489500045776,
-0.37694868445396423,
0.19120950996875763,
-0.2921319603919983,
-0.21916326880455017,
0.2683281898498535,
-0.05426890030503273,
-0.43234747648239136,
0.506805419921875,
-0.0547531396150589,
0.18341314792633057,
0.03951914235949516,
0.060963235795497894,
0.031734611839056015,
-0.03433941677212715,
-0.6211748123168945,
-0.11792459338903427,
-1.0486502647399902,
0.21236591041088104,
-0.015264400281012058,
0.7145951390266418,
-0.2878303825855255,
0.27652254700660706,
-0.17302484810352325,
0.5449697971343994,
0.3468577563762665,
-0.09706176817417145,
0.2572920322418213,
0.19734320044517517,
-0.42492273449897766,
0.32314637303352356,
0.5217776298522949,
0.29623502492904663,
-0.1258329451084137,
-0.20762938261032104,
-0.4022357761859894,
-0.11603885889053345,
-0.21786071360111237,
-1.0927035808563232,
-0.14237956702709198,
-0.12816639244556427,
-0.4272508919239044,
-0.13961248099803925,
0.07208504527807236,
-0.7458395957946777,
-0.16366633772850037,
-0.07916788011789322,
0.5543021559715271,
-0.47480538487434387,
-0.14390264451503754,
-0.20602978765964508,
-0.10135307908058167,
0.5431711077690125,
0.1564200073480606,
-0.8791940808296204,
0.7364869713783264,
0.4360767900943756,
0.6850093603134155,
-0.3249240517616272,
-0.18778620660305023,
-0.6853252053260803,
0.26810693740844727,
-0.3421279489994049,
0.9555729031562805,
-0.5918827056884766,
-0.26772141456604004,
-0.17903335392475128,
-0.13056084513664246,
0.025960462167859077,
-0.8098181486129761,
0.002441336400806904,
-0.687041699886322,
0.26743096113204956,
-0.07954847812652588,
-0.6267319321632385,
-0.2739958167076111,
0.6105101108551025,
-0.5701441764831543,
0.7805895805358887,
0.14082473516464233,
-0.8425036668777466,
0.8455176949501038,
-0.7341914772987366,
-0.2917996346950531,
0.35084161162376404,
-0.612369179725647,
-0.5995516777038574,
-0.02699526771903038,
0.19970591366291046,
0.5254566669464111,
-0.03833884745836258,
-0.13944010436534882,
-0.005475654732435942,
-0.48172420263290405,
0.0020224624313414097,
-0.06503314524888992,
0.5339154005050659,
-0.0917435958981514,
-0.6580580472946167,
-0.03397904336452484,
-0.8278127908706665,
-0.15955476462841034,
0.1814751774072647,
-0.2650693655014038,
-0.6121741533279419,
-0.31028714776039124,
0.16074387729167938,
0.3326858878135681,
-0.14211371541023254,
-0.5251772403717041,
0.02085951156914234,
-0.7506002187728882,
0.19535322487354279,
0.2957189381122589,
0.2767983078956604,
0.5684205889701843,
-0.1660654991865158,
0.3386813998222351,
0.5694833993911743,
-0.3673766851425171,
-0.3172335922718048,
0.03673180565237999,
-0.5688079595565796,
-0.37931111454963684,
0.33806151151657104,
0.37411442399024963,
-0.6667636036872864,
0.20252759754657745,
-0.08570007234811783,
-0.0664469450712204,
-0.04368546977639198,
-0.10506946593523026,
0.6109574437141418,
0.8908454775810242,
0.5782575011253357,
-0.1485871821641922,
-0.6549186110496521,
-0.9524615406990051,
0.1915089637041092,
0.03664996847510338,
-0.04479920491576195,
0.6301868557929993,
0.8693664073944092,
-0.17903068661689758,
1.050403118133545,
-0.1415214240550995,
-0.5611755847930908,
-0.326982706785202,
0.3247646987438202,
0.23762014508247375,
0.5074357986450195,
0.5850375294685364,
-0.8482022285461426,
-0.6418479084968567,
0.00549878878518939,
-0.7399540543556213,
0.26620426774024963,
-0.05025853216648102,
0.006825230084359646,
-0.01170541625469923,
0.6482986211776733,
-0.36826297640800476,
0.298671692609787,
-0.0007476556929759681,
0.14196962118148804,
0.34255450963974,
0.10295387357473373,
-0.05233676731586456,
-1.2384848594665527,
-0.27997520565986633,
0.018984686583280563,
-0.3409736454486847,
-0.4405953288078308,
0.1322634369134903,
0.03464184328913689,
-0.04330772906541824,
-0.8061680793762207,
0.7572013735771179,
-0.701984167098999,
-0.16004784405231476,
-0.1981479972600937,
0.26243290305137634,
-0.22352184355258942,
0.28481996059417725,
0.279642790555954,
0.6628562808036804,
0.8582179546356201,
-0.672827422618866,
-0.03862732648849487,
0.3000810742378235,
-0.26700636744499207,
0.8060057759284973,
-0.5015449523925781,
0.20908275246620178,
-0.43857312202453613,
0.42611071467399597,
-0.764750063419342,
-0.30272722244262695,
0.21242475509643555,
-0.10884515941143036,
0.7066773176193237,
-0.3466111719608307,
-0.3039416968822479,
0.0356927253305912,
-0.24296042323112488,
0.41683676838874817,
0.5005029439926147,
-1.0648655891418457,
0.4909486174583435,
0.03182598575949669,
0.1592838168144226,
-0.5831913948059082,
-0.8834325075149536,
0.062122464179992676,
-0.4922886788845062,
-0.07010836154222488,
0.6919236183166504,
0.07243754714727402,
-0.16510744392871857,
0.16479679942131042,
0.014350279234349728,
-0.18286938965320587,
-0.08303336054086685,
0.09185316413640976,
0.006204945035278797,
-0.5813105702400208,
0.17416000366210938,
0.032358840107917786,
-0.19216926395893097,
-0.2977447807788849,
-0.27741697430610657,
0.23754951357841492,
-0.38166138529777527,
-0.29952818155288696,
-0.3838169574737549,
0.5481537580490112,
0.1102803647518158,
-0.07151669263839722,
0.6467358469963074,
0.27309757471084595,
-0.9691528677940369,
-0.42069828510284424,
-0.25428253412246704,
-0.42608028650283813,
-0.3304114043712616,
0.1747562289237976,
-0.7397364377975464,
-0.9332728981971741,
0.47480329871177673,
-0.37292924523353577,
-0.06500671803951263,
0.15954309701919556,
0.24930748343467712,
0.05977232754230499,
0.7515642046928406,
0.680371105670929,
0.1280384361743927,
0.5362152457237244,
-0.4475386142730713,
0.2172454297542572,
-1.1120014190673828,
-0.2809038460254669,
-0.3229111135005951,
-0.29648011922836304,
-0.2773866355419159,
-0.00587347149848938,
0.33821702003479004,
0.4269545376300812,
-0.36647364497184753,
0.4763416051864624,
-0.3150891661643982,
0.9374326467514038,
0.43554607033729553,
0.23415426909923553,
0.11702746152877808,
-0.1028660461306572,
-0.5654825568199158,
-0.2730894088745117,
-0.532457709312439,
-0.7266836166381836,
0.7053902745246887,
-0.09121782332658768,
0.7703446745872498,
0.31234100461006165,
1.360092043876648,
-0.18542174994945526,
0.41689977049827576,
-0.7267225980758667,
0.3963523209095001,
-0.129433274269104,
-0.29202061891555786,
-0.27330610156059265,
0.045774899423122406,
-0.9471907019615173,
0.3263849914073944,
-0.2707373797893524,
-1.1172503232955933,
0.4469083547592163,
0.07355357706546783,
-0.6378729343414307,
0.14540567994117737,
-0.5426667928695679,
0.7679936289787292,
-0.12738089263439178,
-0.2556711733341217,
0.11545577645301819,
-0.8605308532714844,
0.31058815121650696,
0.00488950964063406,
-0.17223341763019562,
0.3034003973007202,
-0.07485394924879074,
0.4679912030696869,
-0.023272372782230377,
0.9238014221191406,
-0.17828784883022308,
0.41453227400779724,
0.11228477209806442,
0.07437388598918915,
0.712963342666626,
0.2445208728313446,
-0.13157473504543304,
-0.3158045709133148,
-0.38058343529701233,
-0.06899724155664444,
-0.6754380464553833,
0.7764632701873779,
-0.39822155237197876,
-0.21943038702011108,
-0.34319987893104553,
0.002905855653807521,
-0.029853681102395058,
0.39093077182769775,
0.6591846942901611,
0.5713836550712585,
-0.4202256500720978,
0.4240846335887909,
0.7197288274765015,
-0.010812981985509396,
0.708011269569397,
0.4016399383544922,
0.05676994100213051,
-0.16930407285690308,
0.6081609129905701,
-0.05057215690612793,
-0.051675595343112946,
0.7551379799842834,
0.08704520761966705,
-0.3826153874397278,
-0.7102952599525452,
-0.4288451373577118,
-0.06458580493927002,
-0.9914132952690125,
-0.542482316493988,
-0.6895557045936584,
-0.0930057168006897,
-0.17660336196422577,
-0.47858113050460815,
-0.21386556327342987,
0.07644689828157425,
-0.7762535810470581,
-0.2132224440574646,
0.03797038644552231,
0.5731337666511536,
0.13614323735237122,
0.5085023045539856,
-0.3281881809234619,
0.3377777934074402,
0.3994225263595581,
0.2948351502418518,
0.07048454135656357,
-0.424638956785202,
0.0029065259732306004,
-0.274458646774292,
-0.05209287628531456,
-0.9294955134391785,
0.26659420132637024,
0.47637227177619934,
0.8848163485527039,
0.5212438106536865,
0.1474737823009491,
0.5968969464302063,
-0.6270760893821716,
0.7513969540596008,
0.2997762858867645,
-0.8105412125587463,
0.7308495044708252,
0.12645797431468964,
0.17663151025772095,
0.7837452292442322,
0.6063441038131714,
-0.11059451848268509,
-0.0035913565661758184,
-0.6079825162887573,
-0.8387455940246582,
0.46162885427474976,
-0.04578742757439613,
0.0429074801504612,
-0.36945685744285583,
0.24901476502418518,
0.3862527310848236,
0.04451959580183029,
-1.0757904052734375,
-0.07727257162332535,
-0.09068512171506882,
-0.22790105640888214,
0.28582650423049927,
-0.14067278802394867,
-0.008344686590135098,
0.0957237258553505,
0.7667679786682129,
-0.42392951250076294,
-0.005671326536685228,
0.2696799337863922,
-0.5199460387229919,
0.10375436395406723,
0.7205101847648621,
0.3868502378463745,
0.4230141341686249,
-0.142403244972229,
0.319319486618042,
0.4951392114162445,
0.23006592690944672,
0.14624916017055511,
0.14164263010025024,
-0.3963789641857147,
-0.021567177027463913,
0.2879578769207001,
0.956851601600647,
0.805350661277771,
-0.509221076965332,
0.7160667181015015,
-0.03957671672105789,
0.06466085463762283,
-0.43258923292160034,
-0.20791877806186676,
-0.02208486571907997,
0.5725845694541931,
0.33926624059677124,
-0.23065492510795593,
0.4744626581668854,
-0.36794841289520264,
0.4204500913619995,
0.5759330987930298,
-0.5827587246894836,
-0.13719414174556732,
0.5756800174713135,
-0.09196335077285767,
-0.2910304069519043,
0.6634030342102051,
-0.6755542755126953,
-0.49584704637527466,
0.4862295687198639,
1.2251009941101074,
0.879305362701416,
0.04029220715165138,
0.0473075769841671,
0.47809338569641113,
0.05530589073896408,
-0.039396654814481735,
0.08428792655467987,
-0.21174873411655426,
-0.7421952486038208,
-0.018942471593618393,
-0.3610823154449463,
-0.4507658779621124,
0.27915409207344055,
-0.6693878769874573,
0.6563916206359863,
-0.33761709928512573,
0.09373980760574341,
-0.006233489140868187,
-0.16328361630439758,
-0.8236133456230164,
0.2100372314453125,
0.4492538571357727,
0.6831895709037781,
-0.8412598371505737,
0.477239727973938,
0.867182731628418,
-0.6309175491333008,
-0.6143504977226257,
0.129317045211792,
0.10571248829364777,
-0.25163590908050537,
1.1190296411514282,
0.5589744448661804,
-0.38746142387390137,
0.37006399035453796,
-0.7763209939002991,
-0.6995241045951843,
1.206879734992981,
0.27587753534317017,
-0.7142571210861206,
0.06551384180784225,
-0.4332377314567566,
0.4683348834514618,
-1.1036406755447388,
0.570250928401947,
0.40758225321769714,
0.12841656804084778,
0.11202861368656158,
-0.5300995707511902,
-0.02175528183579445,
-0.004801680333912373,
0.16971664130687714,
0.012569061480462551,
-0.44320207834243774,
0.7111650109291077,
-0.5187239050865173,
-0.4870869219303131,
-0.0286521315574646,
0.7315033674240112,
0.6445191502571106,
0.4787970781326294,
0.6025640964508057,
0.5489882826805115,
0.6562324166297913,
0.1449817270040512,
0.8056009411811829,
0.16863779723644257,
0.2424405813217163,
1.588530421257019,
-0.6789314150810242,
1.1100903749465942,
0.5500590801239014,
0.10731740295886993,
0.8798323273658752,
0.6577926874160767,
-0.05437856540083885,
0.9300273656845093,
0.38803181052207947,
-0.495307058095932,
-0.17057910561561584,
-0.3653204143047333,
-0.1223490759730339,
0.460379421710968,
0.4464084208011627,
-0.21548673510551453,
-0.7473155856132507,
0.349581241607666,
-0.25091126561164856,
0.025785746052861214,
-0.08405756205320358,
1.1160486936569214,
0.20027413964271545,
-0.11641319841146469,
0.28822773694992065,
-0.316328763961792,
0.9037755727767944,
-0.3478657305240631,
-0.5665752291679382,
-0.03844447061419487,
0.03506600484251976,
-0.2568148076534271,
-0.47125518321990967,
-0.15336261689662933,
-0.09910670667886734,
-0.2696034610271454,
0.12668509781360626,
0.8264675736427307,
-0.5102996230125427,
-0.09372933208942413,
0.4785328805446625,
0.31763356924057007,
0.37321847677230835,
0.09445929527282715,
-0.5370622277259827,
-0.5105645656585693,
-0.47768789529800415,
-0.17426228523254395,
0.38216567039489746,
0.4182083308696747,
-0.3021302819252014,
0.4752914011478424,
0.40024134516716003,
-0.12092559039592743,
0.12564584612846375,
0.40259772539138794,
0.9000312685966492,
-0.5791491270065308,
-0.7001147866249084,
-0.8026515245437622,
0.48997384309768677,
-0.1146121695637703,
-0.36540254950523376,
0.37199532985687256,
0.764072060585022,
1.1840964555740356,
-0.10196392238140106,
0.6803115010261536,
0.01357116736471653,
0.5207803845405579,
-0.5282571911811829,
0.22951270639896393,
-0.3705994486808777,
0.13800863921642303,
-0.16244877874851227,
-0.7910816073417664,
-0.6447924971580505,
0.6323500871658325,
-0.11850770562887192,
-0.08824145048856735,
0.8044275641441345,
0.7364850044250488,
-0.38192135095596313,
-0.2715499699115753,
0.5010510087013245,
0.06932192295789719,
0.3055137097835541,
0.7991179823875427,
0.9034491181373596,
-0.5698167681694031,
0.4238147735595703,
-0.37741413712501526,
-0.15102112293243408,
-0.2901824116706848,
-1.1254656314849854,
-0.9550771117210388,
-0.4544827938079834,
-0.38529741764068604,
0.030139144510030746,
0.17919500172138214,
1.2618203163146973,
0.8894917964935303,
-0.9613766670227051,
0.10644389688968658,
-0.16106382012367249,
0.03562992811203003,
-0.18027456104755402,
-0.2627691328525543,
0.35961049795150757,
-0.37956908345222473,
-0.6590864062309265,
0.6931208372116089,
0.40832415223121643,
0.32989057898521423,
0.1637876033782959,
-0.10086352378129959,
-0.26560109853744507,
-0.42174386978149414,
0.639951229095459,
0.462629497051239,
-0.8490458130836487,
-0.3298163115978241,
-0.2228269875049591,
-0.1452503651380539,
0.3093877136707306,
0.7544030547142029,
-1.16257643699646,
0.32122623920440674,
0.3457193076610565,
0.8055450916290283,
0.7513101696968079,
-0.1135869026184082,
0.07818735390901566,
-0.9967248439788818,
0.1433129757642746,
0.4804798662662506,
0.5216389298439026,
0.6023110747337341,
-0.43940120935440063,
0.31689319014549255,
-0.053338974714279175,
-0.2985243499279022,
-0.6740986108779907,
0.343712717294693,
-0.8315584063529968,
-0.08668756484985352,
0.8311008810997009,
-0.3593725264072418,
-0.1068151593208313,
-0.13520891964435577,
-0.029952410608530045,
0.1499646008014679,
-0.5216875672340393,
0.37956398725509644,
0.39516398310661316,
-0.481852263212204,
-0.5669549107551575,
-0.17113690078258514,
0.31632259488105774,
0.06864401698112488,
-0.9257438778877258,
-0.378797322511673,
0.42513781785964966,
0.37227606773376465,
0.017817722633481026,
0.6100797057151794,
-0.12446314841508865,
0.1304214894771576,
-0.01657642424106598,
-0.1088750958442688,
0.03417713940143585,
-0.46749982237815857,
-0.6794430613517761,
0.08200480788946152,
0.07918263226747513,
-0.2869175374507904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01176v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01176v2 | CorpusLM: Towards a Unified Language Model on Corpus for Knowledge-Intensive Tasks | 2024-02-02T06:44:22 | 2024-04-21T08:33:32 | Xiaoxi Li, Zhicheng Dou, Yujia Zhou, Fangchao Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Large language models (LLMs) have gained significant attention in various
fields but prone to hallucination, especially in knowledge-intensive (KI)
tasks. To address this, retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) has emerged as a
popular solution to enhance factual accuracy. However, traditional retrieval
modules often rely on large document index and disconnect with generative
tasks. With the advent of generative retrieval (GR), language models can
retrieve by directly generating document identifiers (DocIDs), offering
superior performance in retrieval tasks. However, the potential relationship
between GR and downstream tasks remains unexplored. In this paper, we propose
\textbf{CorpusLM}, a unified language model that leverages external corpus to
tackle various knowledge-intensive tasks by integrating generative retrieval,
closed-book generation, and RAG through a unified greedy decoding process. We
design the following mechanisms to facilitate effective retrieval and
generation, and improve the end-to-end effectiveness of KI tasks: (1) We
develop a ranking-oriented DocID list generation strategy, which refines GR by
directly learning from a DocID ranking list, to improve retrieval quality. (2)
We design a continuous DocIDs-References-Answer generation strategy, which
facilitates effective and efficient RAG. (3) We employ well-designed
unsupervised DocID understanding tasks, to comprehend DocID semantics and their
relevance to downstream tasks. We evaluate our approach on the widely used KILT
benchmark with two variants of backbone models, i.e., T5 and Llama2.
Experimental results demonstrate the superior performance of our models in both
retrieval and downstream tasks. | [
-0.15292733907699585,
-0.49224257469177246,
0.5190287232398987,
-0.1135861724615097,
-0.45920494198799133,
0.16005443036556244,
-0.38817837834358215,
-0.3196307122707367,
-0.0661814957857132,
0.8478490710258484,
-0.06099267676472664,
-0.6500124931335449,
-0.603514552116394,
-0.12936004996299744,
-0.6163263320922852,
1.035824179649353,
0.3293723165988922,
-0.03225591033697128,
-0.5690310001373291,
-0.015773849561810493,
-0.514940083026886,
-0.761119544506073,
-0.44138428568840027,
-0.2520517110824585,
0.6459752321243286,
0.2647026479244232,
0.4738280177116394,
0.4772912561893463,
0.3938432037830353,
0.21641820669174194,
-0.1956031173467636,
0.5490270853042603,
-0.7411777377128601,
0.5015332102775574,
-0.2800622582435608,
-0.35117223858833313,
-0.31203195452690125,
-0.3207739293575287,
0.5814451575279236,
0.9862217903137207,
-0.15437506139278412,
0.24583663046360016,
0.3092593848705292,
0.4746805727481842,
-0.7769606709480286,
0.1015736386179924,
-0.9326141476631165,
-0.3427259027957916,
-0.3516119420528412,
-0.2378653883934021,
-0.55643230676651,
0.07159862667322159,
-0.2690235376358032,
-0.6214672327041626,
0.3819766938686371,
0.1652001291513443,
0.6694437861442566,
0.2719891667366028,
-0.385408878326416,
-0.3554844856262207,
-0.7072828412055969,
0.7393710017204285,
-0.5296761989593506,
0.5314397811889648,
0.4444710612297058,
-0.08123591542243958,
-0.12890346348285675,
-0.8132138252258301,
-0.2592848539352417,
-0.24826215207576752,
-0.24642594158649445,
0.1879195123910904,
0.05989212915301323,
-0.012307175435125828,
0.15530821681022644,
0.15207187831401825,
-0.5365209579467773,
0.021810632199048996,
-0.4687148332595825,
-0.10474158078432083,
0.6005438566207886,
0.32717931270599365,
0.14424335956573486,
-0.20898954570293427,
-0.3734205961227417,
0.10637643933296204,
-0.7009997963905334,
-0.08489876985549927,
0.2628241777420044,
0.30112066864967346,
0.2250673621892929,
0.6612697243690491,
-0.09626568108797073,
0.8297647833824158,
-0.1684865802526474,
-0.23748205602169037,
-0.10384916514158249,
-0.2760635018348694,
-0.09210309386253357,
-0.2682717740535736,
0.5144465565681458,
0.02956625446677208,
0.12628208100795746,
-0.610405445098877,
-0.5301676988601685,
0.10001809895038605,
0.6304283142089844,
-0.5133825540542603,
-0.013310209847986698,
0.2995290458202362,
-0.25584647059440613,
-0.42955920100212097,
-0.08348624408245087,
-0.5756997466087341,
-0.4042324125766754,
-0.5700393319129944,
0.22993934154510498,
-0.6134711503982544,
-0.37770184874534607,
-0.12636874616146088,
-0.1591733694076538,
0.10175319015979767,
0.279996395111084,
-0.8189429640769958,
0.3286243975162506,
0.8173845410346985,
0.5687896013259888,
-0.4077604115009308,
-0.15177127718925476,
-0.7858206629753113,
0.47553834319114685,
-0.39063674211502075,
0.8847932815551758,
-0.5816123485565186,
-0.6769062876701355,
0.04233361780643463,
-0.3064948618412018,
-0.2783452272415161,
-0.5450155138969421,
0.876947283744812,
-0.9001464247703552,
-0.03782352805137634,
-0.1111418753862381,
-0.7366487979888916,
-0.11870445311069489,
0.19112883508205414,
-0.5464845895767212,
1.1106013059616089,
0.24108180403709412,
-0.8751938939094543,
0.11390892416238785,
-0.7430011034011841,
-0.46660447120666504,
0.4155721068382263,
-0.1353088617324829,
0.016939861699938774,
0.12126006186008453,
-0.12033502757549286,
0.5090253949165344,
-0.6134771704673767,
0.7186281085014343,
-0.19989633560180664,
-0.2721708416938782,
0.09628573805093765,
-0.3278556168079376,
0.6920722723007202,
0.4444686472415924,
-0.001963525777682662,
0.2128075212240219,
-0.6553382873535156,
-0.0020179639104753733,
0.14129649102687836,
-0.3710009753704071,
-0.6551056504249573,
-0.11655309796333313,
0.3734826445579529,
-0.06175565719604492,
0.3117893934249878,
-0.48266395926475525,
0.24027445912361145,
-0.15194807946681976,
0.05313629284501076,
0.6805486679077148,
-0.19149866700172424,
0.556921660900116,
-0.3407180905342102,
0.4004734754562378,
-0.07591457664966583,
0.03469504415988922,
-0.0072471220046281815,
-0.3306232988834381,
-0.5449256300926208,
-0.30838266015052795,
0.5084203481674194,
0.2809772193431854,
-0.4993683397769928,
0.2073199301958084,
-0.5167843699455261,
-0.4752364158630371,
-0.4679649770259857,
0.4530477523803711,
0.5621038675308228,
0.6530566215515137,
0.22588980197906494,
-0.15236195921897888,
-0.43685752153396606,
-0.4082131087779999,
-0.04235194995999336,
0.024325791746377945,
-0.18052063882350922,
0.25592491030693054,
0.2223881632089615,
-0.2753273546695709,
0.9002645611763,
-0.4441315829753876,
-0.38384097814559937,
-0.3824285566806793,
0.30739086866378784,
0.1501227170228958,
0.25453293323516846,
0.20255686342716217,
-1.1667215824127197,
-0.287279337644577,
0.047695208340883255,
-0.8703082799911499,
-0.22885866463184357,
0.21368847787380219,
-0.28282251954078674,
0.5582454800605774,
0.5450735688209534,
-0.8043186664581299,
0.21975891292095184,
0.3081248998641968,
-0.36629369854927063,
0.6395165920257568,
-0.42572012543678284,
-0.2535121440887451,
-1.027561068534851,
0.5902325510978699,
-0.46599194407463074,
-0.11310084909200668,
-0.600477933883667,
0.4943983256816864,
0.2184692770242691,
-0.1087380200624466,
-0.3641708791255951,
0.8147720098495483,
-0.6694987416267395,
-0.3113495111465454,
-0.2728238105773926,
0.23529039323329926,
0.1685251146554947,
0.469401478767395,
0.010955827310681343,
0.6685193181037903,
0.38243839144706726,
-0.8144402503967285,
0.16005170345306396,
0.16066262125968933,
-0.1873672753572464,
0.3361494243144989,
-0.47466427087783813,
0.09724319726228714,
-0.36290159821510315,
0.06067892909049988,
-0.8505300283432007,
-0.24065816402435303,
-0.16142341494560242,
-0.3634328246116638,
0.5705147981643677,
-0.11460481584072113,
-0.6749987006187439,
-0.3154350221157074,
0.029381955042481422,
0.31172338128089905,
0.6575159430503845,
-0.5371195673942566,
0.7974068522453308,
0.47754231095314026,
-0.08634389191865921,
-0.6913623213768005,
-0.08415879309177399,
0.025554804131388664,
-0.16315695643424988,
-0.7030043005943298,
0.5907623171806335,
-0.056307896971702576,
-0.3090658187866211,
0.2534242868423462,
-0.09280093014240265,
0.1071837767958641,
0.1489400863647461,
0.2681514322757721,
0.5579310059547424,
0.07705099135637283,
0.4076964855194092,
-0.021133800968527794,
-0.06508825719356537,
-0.13019652664661407,
-0.48615649342536926,
0.7457009553909302,
0.1947375386953354,
-0.2806498110294342,
0.29262301325798035,
0.540862500667572,
0.772767186164856,
-0.6185270547866821,
0.5578524470329285,
0.8995749354362488,
-0.17084163427352905,
-0.1757030189037323,
-0.8580490350723267,
-0.1068829670548439,
-0.3684735894203186,
0.22753819823265076,
-0.666287362575531,
-0.7095192670822144,
0.45544329285621643,
-0.19865165650844574,
0.12030570209026337,
0.5178576707839966,
0.5753345489501953,
-0.239143505692482,
0.8883577585220337,
0.599289059638977,
-0.10539425164461136,
0.032221920788288116,
-0.4268369674682617,
-0.15440250933170319,
-1.2269494533538818,
-0.25697043538093567,
-0.5074856877326965,
0.11381258815526962,
-0.16855651140213013,
-0.5147906541824341,
0.5238774418830872,
0.5617809891700745,
-0.15465232729911804,
0.16981160640716553,
-0.5567920804023743,
0.1143021360039711,
0.778769314289093,
-0.04677455872297287,
0.45930659770965576,
0.043010301887989044,
-0.617810845375061,
0.3936893939971924,
-0.9488741159439087,
-0.4909359812736511,
1.5613436698913574,
-0.15119631588459015,
0.7276063561439514,
0.12314026802778244,
0.7271900773048401,
0.40657734870910645,
0.5944168567657471,
-0.45182788372039795,
0.5125787854194641,
-0.38723325729370117,
-0.5738883018493652,
-0.386799693107605,
-0.35457733273506165,
-1.2912989854812622,
0.41053780913352966,
-0.18859541416168213,
-0.6063773036003113,
-0.16205109655857086,
-0.16780944168567657,
-0.09912298619747162,
0.33600932359695435,
-0.5188111066818237,
0.7842115163803101,
-0.2527948021888733,
-0.5107972025871277,
-0.28317025303840637,
-0.5942553877830505,
0.47137925028800964,
-0.26267531514167786,
0.3866257071495056,
-0.0004516449407674372,
-0.14903868734836578,
0.5202075839042664,
-0.44619208574295044,
0.7438043355941772,
-0.1763211190700531,
-0.15874262154102325,
0.43728628754615784,
-0.017955435439944267,
0.7097930312156677,
-0.030818618834018707,
-0.22486324608325958,
0.047892604023218155,
-0.0017990902997553349,
-0.4542643129825592,
-0.5879665017127991,
0.6452288627624512,
-0.6032158136367798,
-0.758560299873352,
-0.18655680119991302,
-0.8135961294174194,
-0.17452876269817352,
0.21420559287071228,
0.40023067593574524,
0.6900147199630737,
-0.23858542740345,
0.021918896585702896,
0.7312267422676086,
0.08743828535079956,
0.3309914171695709,
0.6816847324371338,
-0.308978796005249,
-0.026966208592057228,
0.8863728642463684,
0.03389377519488335,
0.12450078874826431,
0.5238379836082458,
0.03310871496796608,
-0.5955277681350708,
-0.5878854990005493,
-0.5610461235046387,
0.23345543444156647,
-0.6119352579116821,
-0.29710036516189575,
-0.9637174606323242,
-0.28234657645225525,
-0.7426304221153259,
0.07254091650247574,
-0.0909019485116005,
-0.11676240712404251,
-0.36893904209136963,
0.19680212438106537,
0.3285526633262634,
0.6725512742996216,
-0.06519629061222076,
-0.2920578718185425,
-0.9624989628791809,
0.5652079582214355,
0.20334233343601227,
0.25830554962158203,
0.08146335184574127,
-0.6757805347442627,
-0.10280021280050278,
-0.04593079164624214,
-0.1995861530303955,
-0.6170104146003723,
0.4949052929878235,
-0.036032721400260925,
0.6341042518615723,
0.2698878049850464,
0.4143279790878296,
0.3315853178501129,
-0.4339176118373871,
0.3832853138446808,
-0.017812231555581093,
-0.5933308005332947,
0.1836388111114502,
-0.5107861757278442,
0.21649231016635895,
0.25388163328170776,
0.3223523199558258,
-0.4853360950946808,
-0.5959965586662292,
-0.6337214112281799,
-0.9250853657722473,
0.4369962811470032,
0.12585940957069397,
0.14213916659355164,
-0.03762317821383476,
0.114475779235363,
0.20871129631996155,
0.10354994982481003,
-0.2516680359840393,
0.03326338902115822,
0.08304128795862198,
-0.24267837405204773,
0.016275139525532722,
-0.38803794980049133,
-0.19070439040660858,
-0.05590031296014786,
0.6331980228424072,
-0.17802539467811584,
0.16483540832996368,
0.22807776927947998,
-0.3086285889148712,
0.054752446711063385,
0.4588821828365326,
0.4110705554485321,
0.5452615022659302,
-0.2714371681213379,
0.07436560839414597,
-0.04937422275543213,
-0.5107401013374329,
-0.10573878139257431,
0.285288006067276,
-0.36309510469436646,
0.1405174732208252,
0.2332698404788971,
0.513615071773529,
0.28915640711784363,
-0.9190507531166077,
0.4076573848724365,
0.1857401579618454,
-0.08912362158298492,
-0.5422466993331909,
-0.017095264047384262,
0.3911837935447693,
0.09475388377904892,
0.5874161720275879,
-0.05402802303433418,
0.15282879769802094,
-0.3954795002937317,
0.1943506896495819,
0.6546980142593384,
-0.07077336311340332,
0.05088881030678749,
0.9035623073577881,
0.2432737797498703,
-0.11750852316617966,
0.6134124398231506,
-0.502023458480835,
-0.38400155305862427,
0.4779343903064728,
0.6276598572731018,
0.6208463311195374,
-0.03260903060436249,
0.17443332076072693,
0.2537960112094879,
-0.03605647012591362,
-0.046035781502723694,
0.22013124823570251,
-0.26778456568717957,
-0.6822978258132935,
-0.547219455242157,
-1.0782051086425781,
-0.2767374515533447,
0.07847770303487778,
-0.7161417603492737,
0.10453122854232788,
0.09686654061079025,
-0.008602459914982319,
-0.11904589086771011,
-0.16310422122478485,
-0.7774432897567749,
0.15944144129753113,
0.09369570016860962,
0.6805934906005859,
-0.20143422484397888,
1.1904913187026978,
0.6389264464378357,
-0.5122320055961609,
-0.8205498456954956,
-0.2000444233417511,
-0.23911893367767334,
-0.6951995491981506,
0.9555239677429199,
-0.10950423032045364,
-0.0051422202959656715,
0.1758103370666504,
-0.3310408592224121,
-1.0068225860595703,
1.1456440687179565,
0.20048707723617554,
-0.49592873454093933,
-0.3138505220413208,
0.06174229457974434,
0.47778528928756714,
-0.3968547582626343,
0.18011459708213806,
0.31015685200691223,
0.4432576894760132,
0.13004939258098602,
-0.6671020984649658,
0.08378998935222626,
-0.38481247425079346,
0.17281265556812286,
0.27531352639198303,
-0.3963439464569092,
0.730961263179779,
-0.3138892352581024,
-0.3455374538898468,
0.32972416281700134,
0.4602687954902649,
0.2776637077331543,
0.3156033456325531,
0.5734673142433167,
0.6488679051399231,
0.9202966690063477,
0.1050599068403244,
1.4017797708511353,
-0.5474960207939148,
0.13019514083862305,
1.124062418937683,
-0.32795920968055725,
0.8854841589927673,
0.29113703966140747,
0.004853029735386372,
0.3045991361141205,
0.25220370292663574,
0.0865851417183876,
0.3306237459182739,
0.22261834144592285,
-0.4256102442741394,
-0.30562257766723633,
-0.44582074880599976,
-0.23122797906398773,
0.5043190717697144,
0.5047281980514526,
-0.3180033266544342,
-0.22457264363765717,
0.19672256708145142,
-0.07904643565416336,
0.2534506022930145,
-0.3808478116989136,
0.8394262194633484,
-0.03163896128535271,
-0.9733327627182007,
0.9000696539878845,
0.02280980348587036,
0.7323246598243713,
-0.5806671380996704,
0.1374468207359314,
-0.32224342226982117,
-0.06798282265663147,
-0.012864083983004093,
-0.560555636882782,
0.39585080742836,
0.20480714738368988,
-0.3343464732170105,
-0.12330689281225204,
1.141376256942749,
-0.6586230397224426,
-0.5478519201278687,
0.5539021492004395,
0.6224806308746338,
0.27357351779937744,
-0.3113236427307129,
-0.3468921482563019,
0.04676990956068039,
-0.2488875389099121,
-0.15728643536567688,
0.599776029586792,
0.36708489060401917,
-0.17309845983982086,
0.6190853118896484,
0.8533759117126465,
-0.007785999681800604,
0.015980679541826248,
0.3019113838672638,
0.9000720381736755,
-0.5214670896530151,
-0.24936430156230927,
-0.3539115786552429,
0.46922966837882996,
-0.13413411378860474,
-0.034851714968681335,
0.4539933502674103,
0.5884057879447937,
0.7287845015525818,
-0.2114090621471405,
0.7721028923988342,
-0.09504720568656921,
0.7695327401161194,
-0.48517805337905884,
0.8110902905464172,
-0.7388167381286621,
0.27358826994895935,
-0.0652577355504036,
-0.8333178758621216,
-0.1772351861000061,
-0.19409221410751343,
-0.048810020089149475,
-0.2450868934392929,
0.7277649641036987,
0.7798606157302856,
-0.07380325347185135,
-0.17490260303020477,
0.6763642430305481,
0.12024658173322678,
-0.04261341318488121,
0.4052313268184662,
0.6196595430374146,
-0.14110033214092255,
0.9470332860946655,
-0.12214269489049911,
0.06778644025325775,
-0.2154640555381775,
-0.38861075043678284,
-0.7333398461341858,
-0.7754120826721191,
0.041211701929569244,
-0.2929915189743042,
0.22070065140724182,
0.5636782646179199,
0.5961453914642334,
-0.432280570268631,
-0.25580263137817383,
-0.2555249035358429,
0.21141715347766876,
-0.11838679015636444,
-0.25239527225494385,
0.4708995223045349,
-0.9887672066688538,
-0.8083386421203613,
0.3037218451499939,
0.14978444576263428,
-0.2609594762325287,
-0.19216740131378174,
-0.04699563980102539,
-0.11132843047380447,
-0.06338680535554886,
0.7598246335983276,
0.1557827740907669,
-0.8917471170425415,
-0.04673803970217705,
0.15228447318077087,
-0.40551188588142395,
-0.2454543113708496,
0.9194383025169373,
-0.8218044638633728,
0.3231036067008972,
0.3028741180896759,
0.8736342787742615,
0.6385942697525024,
0.10990244895219803,
0.48917025327682495,
-0.6131747364997864,
-0.043442271649837494,
0.3157068192958832,
0.35303518176078796,
0.35840699076652527,
-0.3748377561569214,
0.8953967690467834,
0.34269028902053833,
-0.46748825907707214,
-0.748563826084137,
0.1777483969926834,
-0.9427408576011658,
-0.5922671556472778,
1.4030215740203857,
-0.15728859603405,
-0.19639521837234497,
-0.3598758578300476,
-0.20585523545742035,
0.3908427953720093,
-0.27347901463508606,
0.7216185927391052,
0.4533384442329407,
0.19929823279380798,
0.09654641151428223,
-0.4188140630722046,
0.40568533539772034,
0.6045252084732056,
-0.6743453741073608,
0.25464993715286255,
0.4711589217185974,
0.23721782863140106,
0.2466692328453064,
0.7461053729057312,
-0.24324557185173035,
0.16280488669872284,
0.07080591470003128,
0.18740341067314148,
-0.18490682542324066,
-0.28925248980522156,
0.027562882751226425,
0.4974157512187958,
0.13874678313732147,
0.094230055809021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01173v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01173v1 | Efficient Prompt Caching via Embedding Similarity | 2024-02-02T06:34:11 | 2024-02-02T06:34:11 | Hanlin Zhu, Banghua Zhu, Jiantao Jiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved huge success in numerous natural
language process (NLP) tasks. However, it faces the challenge of significant
resource consumption during inference. In this paper, we aim to improve the
inference efficiency of LLMs by prompt caching, i.e., if the current prompt can
be answered by the same response of a previous prompt, one can directly utilize
that previous response without calling the LLM. Specifically, we focus on the
prediction accuracy of prompt caching for single-round question-answering tasks
via embedding similarity. The existing embeddings of prompts mostly focus on
whether two prompts are semantically similar, which is not necessarily
equivalent to whether the same response can answer them. Therefore, we propose
a distillation-based method to fine-tune the existing embeddings for better
caching prediction. Theoretically, we provide finite-sample guarantees for the
convergence of our method under different types of loss functions. Empirically,
we carefully construct a hard dataset based on Kwiatkowski et al. (2019) where
the existing embedding model (Wang et al., 2022) only achieves an AUC of 0.51.
We then fine-tune the above embedding model, which significantly improves the
AUC of caching prediction from 0.51 to 0.81. We also conduct simulations
demonstrating that our trained models achieve better caching efficiency than
the previous embedding model. | [
-0.33159714937210083,
-0.8436042070388794,
0.688590943813324,
0.12893645465373993,
-0.3732450306415558,
-0.038034163415431976,
-0.2625582218170166,
-0.054476380348205566,
0.280284583568573,
0.44008669257164,
-0.8646056652069092,
-0.38175442814826965,
-0.3906676769256592,
0.40081140398979187,
-0.1587458848953247,
0.4305843412876129,
0.07931863516569138,
-0.03126773610711098,
-0.5074309706687927,
0.08865438401699066,
-0.8299381732940674,
0.05608817934989929,
-0.9358664751052856,
-0.3244059979915619,
0.552523672580719,
0.29275208711624146,
0.35104620456695557,
0.5535557270050049,
-0.13668513298034668,
0.31273436546325684,
-0.1940252035856247,
0.3220824599266052,
-0.5094900131225586,
0.5092419981956482,
-0.20163396000862122,
-0.5431824922561646,
0.0689493715763092,
-0.14457163214683533,
0.36893996596336365,
0.580930233001709,
-0.4069053530693054,
-0.09763940423727036,
0.4439829885959625,
0.45441046357154846,
-0.5307682156562805,
0.23347386717796326,
-1.067221760749817,
0.018329747021198273,
0.2595099210739136,
-0.4134311378002167,
-0.5969575643539429,
-0.5913172960281372,
0.2301335483789444,
-0.5834405422210693,
0.4509168565273285,
0.1813863217830658,
0.4179416596889496,
0.6517118811607361,
-0.09437260776758194,
-0.3038693368434906,
-0.2322137951850891,
0.8404545783996582,
-1.171452522277832,
-0.1800331324338913,
0.6586445569992065,
0.23993702232837677,
-0.3295597434043884,
-0.7247323393821716,
-0.7373846173286438,
-0.167317196726799,
0.030904628336429596,
-0.005322094541043043,
-0.1058642789721489,
-0.060035571455955505,
0.24736817181110382,
0.16784745454788208,
-0.4712873697280884,
0.20535947382450104,
0.04397634044289589,
-0.0455588698387146,
0.18390707671642303,
0.3657578229904175,
0.12164796143770218,
0.053852301090955734,
-0.40087172389030457,
-0.0986354649066925,
-0.5384533405303955,
-0.07453107088804245,
0.09869249165058136,
0.6961932182312012,
0.16199469566345215,
0.3293446898460388,
-0.2459336817264557,
0.4059444069862366,
0.29559698700904846,
-0.08203359693288803,
0.18423138558864594,
-0.2727926969528198,
0.004566211253404617,
0.2724294066429138,
0.3601034879684448,
0.6113255023956299,
0.3244030475616455,
-0.006184652913361788,
-0.03598177805542946,
-0.2512351870536804,
0.23925089836120605,
-1.0865997076034546,
-0.39016464352607727,
0.2108169049024582,
-0.09979739040136337,
0.11399702727794647,
0.06174227222800255,
-0.5775836110115051,
-0.6755183339118958,
-0.1217244490981102,
0.23565974831581116,
-0.3129532039165497,
0.16548576951026917,
0.2756310701370239,
-0.03754367306828499,
-0.048977889120578766,
0.636269748210907,
-0.7718743085861206,
0.13379205763339996,
0.703659176826477,
1.0379154682159424,
-0.07206954061985016,
-0.07705380767583847,
-0.9349254369735718,
-0.0662354826927185,
-0.04202520102262497,
0.8189734816551208,
-0.6298484206199646,
-0.43184393644332886,
0.27249735593795776,
0.3137032091617584,
0.04503127560019493,
-0.4921649396419525,
0.45063987374305725,
-0.7135988473892212,
-0.0231038685888052,
-0.7551964521408081,
-0.8766244053840637,
-0.2503044903278351,
0.40853866934776306,
-0.9909086227416992,
1.0640097856521606,
-0.3907487392425537,
-0.8248875141143799,
0.2817617356777191,
-0.03033866360783577,
-0.22392956912517548,
-0.05927494913339615,
0.053651630878448486,
-0.32344383001327515,
0.1266103982925415,
0.628827691078186,
0.5997637510299683,
-0.46822747588157654,
0.16510149836540222,
-0.5289821028709412,
-0.4335680902004242,
0.08658603578805923,
-0.48345211148262024,
0.5349583625793457,
0.14858552813529968,
-0.24971099197864532,
-0.3220668435096741,
-0.45187273621559143,
0.0196792334318161,
-0.07334259897470474,
-0.21269819140434265,
-0.4757594168186188,
0.05363361909985542,
-0.49967214465141296,
-0.02614600583910942,
0.3291662037372589,
-0.7145148515701294,
0.5031783580780029,
-0.39036840200424194,
0.3984127342700958,
0.9439302086830139,
0.2213146984577179,
0.4266127347946167,
-0.3839555084705353,
0.5799883604049683,
0.14711785316467285,
-0.32124772667884827,
-0.8342330455780029,
-0.6878130435943604,
-0.3485702574253082,
-0.09233526885509491,
0.26433485746383667,
0.43827977776527405,
-0.6622396111488342,
0.44784262776374817,
-0.1859121322631836,
-0.34618738293647766,
-0.6139317154884338,
0.06973228603601456,
0.32902076840400696,
0.6561195850372314,
0.4487423896789551,
-0.1329280585050583,
-0.19882357120513916,
-0.4627598822116852,
-0.20863322913646698,
-0.052970144897699356,
-0.13233624398708344,
0.29511183500289917,
0.1401885747909546,
0.12180957943201065,
0.9152765274047852,
-0.6959547996520996,
0.08269240707159042,
-0.03327542170882225,
0.2569638788700104,
0.5461748242378235,
0.43009787797927856,
0.3509874641895294,
-0.4757274389266968,
-0.681839108467102,
-0.40132299065589905,
-0.3839080333709717,
-0.3791848123073578,
-0.12046502530574799,
0.13595667481422424,
0.13124850392341614,
0.6127784252166748,
-0.4569607973098755,
0.5210803151130676,
0.2585870027542114,
-0.3093285858631134,
0.3888458013534546,
-0.3621586263179779,
0.37170836329460144,
-1.1515105962753296,
-0.07854755222797394,
-0.14873433113098145,
-0.1308382898569107,
-0.2911459803581238,
-0.19572122395038605,
0.10855290293693542,
0.053859494626522064,
-0.37247878313064575,
0.9612326622009277,
-0.5405799746513367,
0.19516022503376007,
-0.39769309759140015,
0.20212489366531372,
0.2656371295452118,
0.4806068539619446,
-0.36838671565055847,
0.9117828011512756,
0.4691121280193329,
-0.701245129108429,
0.2301422506570816,
0.22296449542045593,
-0.3586845397949219,
0.29592129588127136,
-0.8837169408798218,
0.3232679069042206,
-0.3070632517337799,
0.5346812605857849,
-1.493547797203064,
0.3499816060066223,
-0.024868732318282127,
-0.22458337247371674,
0.32160767912864685,
-0.2947998046875,
-0.631597638130188,
-0.41251853108406067,
-0.5602118968963623,
0.23553285002708435,
0.4120480418205261,
-0.7665292620658875,
0.5248942971229553,
0.004192235879600048,
-0.4881458282470703,
-0.7010307312011719,
-0.8023631572723389,
-0.2431664615869522,
-0.17992578446865082,
-0.4108753204345703,
0.42789578437805176,
-0.20329122245311737,
0.17864716053009033,
-0.024059342220425606,
-0.253049373626709,
0.13036516308784485,
0.05515957623720169,
0.2999390959739685,
-0.13757289946079254,
-0.170435830950737,
0.47056838870048523,
0.1532829999923706,
-0.22459574043750763,
-0.17529836297035217,
-0.3443688452243805,
0.8249343633651733,
0.1795947402715683,
-0.49059274792671204,
-0.6494880318641663,
0.3709912598133087,
0.23572096228599548,
0.05405007675290108,
0.9281061887741089,
0.35623565316200256,
-0.3852554261684418,
-0.2481730878353119,
-0.8321921825408936,
-0.5023272633552551,
-0.5575634837150574,
0.04647204279899597,
-0.266576886177063,
-0.8070191740989685,
1.0206397771835327,
-0.08331195265054703,
0.2972923815250397,
0.1775190830230713,
0.4483814835548401,
-0.04842758923768997,
0.8100783228874207,
0.36893370747566223,
-0.16166409850120544,
0.5290724039077759,
-0.1508542150259018,
0.048025600612163544,
-0.4881507456302643,
-0.14432033896446228,
-0.8103113770484924,
-0.45814499258995056,
-0.42658019065856934,
-0.7043553590774536,
-0.00002160946314688772,
0.2102755606174469,
-0.3525254726409912,
0.18907977640628815,
-0.2905605733394623,
0.5299829840660095,
0.59852135181427,
0.17780204117298126,
0.3329141438007355,
0.19386105239391327,
-0.45104753971099854,
-0.09619556367397308,
-0.6707478761672974,
-0.525413990020752,
0.8468182682991028,
0.08648721128702164,
1.0292900800704956,
-0.3139929175376892,
0.7155948281288147,
0.4121037423610687,
-0.13276860117912292,
-0.4466007649898529,
0.43338125944137573,
-0.020504886284470558,
-0.3097708225250244,
-0.2982274293899536,
-0.34739363193511963,
-0.9995882511138916,
0.07713207602500916,
0.12649857997894287,
-0.8132395148277283,
0.0026801007334142923,
0.25183114409446716,
-0.5736424922943115,
0.5538532137870789,
-0.6149603724479675,
0.6024165749549866,
0.2928868234157562,
-0.36936670541763306,
-0.2770344316959381,
-0.5207833051681519,
-0.19595150649547577,
0.010405590757727623,
-0.1572527140378952,
-0.2846355736255646,
-0.0775177851319313,
0.5620790123939514,
-0.6256520748138428,
1.070716142654419,
-0.5241517424583435,
-0.1439129114151001,
0.49743416905403137,
0.0077207572758197784,
0.9061653017997742,
0.21375374495983124,
-0.5204150080680847,
-0.22300495207309723,
0.0973617434501648,
-0.6248675584793091,
-0.9213077425956726,
1.0021111965179443,
-0.41188639402389526,
-0.7194558382034302,
-0.26779016852378845,
-0.19428658485412598,
-0.11557526886463165,
0.06722816824913025,
0.10360731184482574,
0.49507224559783936,
-0.1924494355916977,
0.08242276310920715,
0.7655492424964905,
-0.4643903970718384,
0.6688737869262695,
0.4143025577068329,
-0.15446917712688446,
0.010105044580996037,
0.327915757894516,
-0.049961693584918976,
0.07948506623506546,
0.46272894740104675,
0.367669939994812,
-0.6212888956069946,
-0.35970771312713623,
-0.42905884981155396,
0.15176822245121002,
-0.7398490905761719,
-0.49087753891944885,
-0.9997966885566711,
0.27379631996154785,
-0.42745622992515564,
-0.22222046554088593,
-0.4151047170162201,
-0.30792200565338135,
-0.5983263254165649,
-0.12301071733236313,
0.9189576506614685,
0.4179037809371948,
0.14866790175437927,
0.45654356479644775,
-0.775978147983551,
0.12665961682796478,
0.285847008228302,
0.2548641264438629,
0.5955553650856018,
-0.7908322811126709,
-0.06995437294244766,
0.34093841910362244,
-0.26685553789138794,
-0.7952594757080078,
0.43365734815597534,
0.25056713819503784,
0.5039386749267578,
0.46250465512275696,
0.4799874722957611,
0.9824790954589844,
-0.6711779236793518,
0.9143205881118774,
0.12838183343410492,
-0.5792620778083801,
0.4843969941139221,
0.05212920531630516,
0.652249276638031,
1.0683387517929077,
0.44556665420532227,
-0.47671985626220703,
-0.17682410776615143,
-0.34230974316596985,
-1.0743308067321777,
0.35384848713874817,
-0.2242358773946762,
0.4581613838672638,
-0.480208158493042,
0.5924460887908936,
0.48531123995780945,
0.19150212407112122,
-0.19590610265731812,
-0.2025696188211441,
0.15675204992294312,
0.0019409710075706244,
-0.10867395251989365,
-0.131714329123497,
0.43528905510902405,
-0.15005531907081604,
0.710763692855835,
-0.20797483623027802,
0.2424776554107666,
0.05595700815320015,
0.07017210125923157,
0.031058046966791153,
0.14482218027114868,
0.1104951724410057,
0.3843722343444824,
-0.16575397551059723,
0.34219345450401306,
0.5299237370491028,
-0.42418172955513,
0.13991469144821167,
0.03616355359554291,
0.039356932044029236,
0.16900205612182617,
0.19255729019641876,
0.6001546382904053,
0.4806227684020996,
-0.7681278586387634,
0.4426012933254242,
-0.2548487186431885,
0.37180522084236145,
-0.2001718133687973,
-0.023902777582406998,
0.36757582426071167,
0.5157585740089417,
0.5007470846176147,
-0.34535497426986694,
0.04233068600296974,
-0.527397632598877,
0.353741317987442,
0.2516928017139435,
-0.2772180736064911,
-0.13044869899749756,
0.40385162830352783,
0.09664155542850494,
-0.10657516866922379,
0.9181835651397705,
-0.2900281846523285,
-0.3005094826221466,
0.6972425580024719,
0.5690414309501648,
0.9697723984718323,
-0.3257182836532593,
0.13105277717113495,
0.725365936756134,
0.00495678186416626,
-0.2693665325641632,
0.34749749302864075,
-0.0932757556438446,
-0.46628090739250183,
-0.474016010761261,
-0.7819017767906189,
-0.2963700294494629,
-0.2301264852285385,
-0.8123438954353333,
0.14264389872550964,
-0.29511427879333496,
-0.2131551057100296,
-0.30148741602897644,
0.3330095410346985,
-0.9003207683563232,
-0.1730959564447403,
-0.10663747042417526,
0.9927821755409241,
-0.7552521228790283,
0.6084311008453369,
0.3190123438835144,
-0.11246513575315475,
-0.6585851907730103,
0.06372696906328201,
0.04480673372745514,
-0.823301374912262,
0.1703125387430191,
0.6147472262382507,
-0.09874483197927475,
0.09420660883188248,
-0.41349875926971436,
-0.7292261719703674,
1.399100422859192,
0.3202964663505554,
-0.937110424041748,
-0.10162656009197235,
-0.24079261720180511,
0.41977399587631226,
-0.42411819100379944,
0.4646020233631134,
0.42835551500320435,
0.2809893488883972,
0.31296059489250183,
-0.6902298331260681,
0.5097754597663879,
-0.18103523552417755,
0.2599809169769287,
-0.07128361612558365,
-0.18228712677955627,
0.8237339854240417,
-0.46348047256469727,
-0.5511242747306824,
0.3566746711730957,
0.6368920803070068,
0.4252963066101074,
0.37254104018211365,
0.49444669485092163,
0.7645500898361206,
0.9661485552787781,
0.09250988066196442,
1.0509276390075684,
-0.1658601313829422,
0.3274146020412445,
1.5072298049926758,
-0.3434959352016449,
0.8847782015800476,
0.604276180267334,
-0.1927030235528946,
0.41655173897743225,
0.6530593633651733,
0.021531447768211365,
0.8749529719352722,
0.4737488031387329,
-0.28061702847480774,
-0.12448357790708542,
-0.2307758927345276,
-0.4049627184867859,
-0.09889975190162659,
0.09461106359958649,
-0.3151087462902069,
-0.5245947241783142,
-0.021185725927352905,
0.0219992958009243,
0.19287362694740295,
-0.22840836644172668,
0.8337331414222717,
0.1753770262002945,
-0.837668240070343,
0.6232563853263855,
-0.1432061642408371,
0.8267931938171387,
-0.32547417283058167,
-0.1744515746831894,
-0.4353276193141937,
-0.03346462547779083,
0.1287609040737152,
-0.6306629180908203,
0.02107386477291584,
-0.03672276437282562,
-0.31662413477897644,
-0.16518819332122803,
0.3962109386920929,
-0.5006412863731384,
-0.23142197728157043,
0.2938377559185028,
0.48536133766174316,
0.18641726672649384,
-0.18688304722309113,
-0.6782504916191101,
-0.02871229499578476,
0.009601952508091927,
-0.4403860569000244,
0.20449677109718323,
0.5609076619148254,
0.2248213291168213,
0.6996354460716248,
0.5621013045310974,
-0.11589998751878738,
0.31445735692977905,
0.21868695318698883,
0.9365491271018982,
-0.5965859889984131,
-0.8208285570144653,
-1.0103081464767456,
0.36713072657585144,
0.017585890367627144,
-0.23389855027198792,
0.5466707348823547,
0.29775023460388184,
0.5268833637237549,
-0.05172151327133179,
0.45602867007255554,
0.18462760746479034,
0.5058432221412659,
-0.7452306747436523,
0.4518742561340332,
-0.5289047360420227,
0.4908292591571808,
-0.3366735279560089,
-0.9674883484840393,
-0.038762155920267105,
0.5427601337432861,
-0.26357027888298035,
0.20759180188179016,
0.6072438955307007,
1.0854647159576416,
-0.0002870498283300549,
0.2855094373226166,
0.26615363359451294,
0.10243207961320877,
0.20526768267154694,
0.5111942887306213,
0.6673535704612732,
-0.2745535373687744,
0.22688384354114532,
-0.17150942981243134,
-0.09572066366672516,
-0.40612271428108215,
-1.282510757446289,
-0.9220186471939087,
-0.7299298048019409,
-0.22115887701511383,
-0.155774787068367,
-0.011878960765898228,
0.8019698262214661,
0.3700433075428009,
-0.8455058932304382,
0.39329972863197327,
-0.04383049160242081,
-0.07155925780534744,
-0.2523041069507599,
-0.19300183653831482,
0.4613780975341797,
-0.4142899513244629,
-0.6854618191719055,
0.18329229950904846,
0.12955805659294128,
-0.0165860652923584,
-0.09794510155916214,
0.0474197119474411,
-0.3776865005493164,
0.20559236407279968,
0.31564009189605713,
0.15662752091884613,
-0.905850350856781,
-0.3641186058521271,
0.05911465361714363,
-0.057906195521354675,
0.03131791204214096,
0.7962231636047363,
-0.8849666118621826,
0.6646618247032166,
0.6409180164337158,
1.0921647548675537,
0.7381442785263062,
0.11336012184619904,
0.449565052986145,
-0.8624647259712219,
0.08810834586620331,
0.20842711627483368,
0.5537726283073425,
0.4029444754123688,
-0.31895437836647034,
0.20018163323402405,
-0.206518292427063,
-0.46991902589797974,
-0.628778338432312,
0.07634278386831284,
-1.0895341634750366,
-0.4162009358406067,
1.005605936050415,
-0.6182821393013,
-0.14037318527698517,
-0.07008732110261917,
-0.24087774753570557,
0.46612033247947693,
-0.7880898118019104,
0.906212329864502,
0.5350629091262817,
0.2456381767988205,
-0.09841839224100113,
-0.4445406198501587,
0.22511079907417297,
0.5955601334571838,
-0.5423804521560669,
0.4228134751319885,
0.3607679307460785,
0.3006877899169922,
0.07574371248483658,
0.6423567533493042,
0.05129898712038994,
0.03872476518154144,
0.04221929982304573,
-0.2562766671180725,
-0.16151215136051178,
-0.233954519033432,
-0.44172418117523193,
0.16646158695220947,
-0.1497211754322052,
-0.06690860539674759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01172v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01172v1 | Streaming Sequence Transduction through Dynamic Compression | 2024-02-02T06:31:50 | 2024-02-02T06:31:50 | Weiting Tan, Yunmo Chen, Tongfei Chen, Guanghui Qin, Haoran Xu, Heidi C. Zhang, Benjamin Van Durme, Philipp Koehn | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | We introduce STAR (Stream Transduction with Anchor Representations), a novel
Transformer-based model designed for efficient sequence-to-sequence
transduction over streams. STAR dynamically segments input streams to create
compressed anchor representations, achieving nearly lossless compression (12x)
in Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) and outperforming existing methods.
Moreover, STAR demonstrates superior segmentation and latency-quality
trade-offs in simultaneous speech-to-text tasks, optimizing latency, memory
footprint, and quality. | [
-0.19102776050567627,
-0.4556324779987335,
0.2854698598384857,
-0.04731670022010803,
-0.40231576561927795,
0.767659604549408,
-0.08747109770774841,
-0.5134130120277405,
0.5096290707588196,
0.27919885516166687,
-0.591335654258728,
-0.05519059672951698,
-0.9813588857650757,
0.2512838542461395,
-0.7529274225234985,
0.49592792987823486,
0.17659889161586761,
-0.01134672574698925,
0.32126712799072266,
-0.0964134931564331,
-0.5801741480827332,
-0.5083370208740234,
-0.7815252542495728,
-0.06469599902629852,
0.45490705966949463,
0.5381082892417908,
0.8403784036636353,
1.2194652557373047,
0.7353333234786987,
0.3957883417606354,
-0.08314438909292221,
-0.025186797603964806,
-0.3882519602775574,
0.5358864068984985,
-0.09673228114843369,
-0.32882872223854065,
-0.3186417818069458,
-0.23348601162433624,
1.303838849067688,
0.7316358089447021,
0.35758695006370544,
0.5281802415847778,
0.08046955615282059,
0.8374086022377014,
-0.7274895906448364,
0.20518742501735687,
-0.5854318737983704,
-0.14426110684871674,
-0.2787216603755951,
-0.4396273195743561,
-0.38193264603614807,
-0.2941542863845825,
-0.0820050835609436,
-0.12362895160913467,
0.3305602967739105,
-0.1781170517206192,
0.7788520455360413,
0.9634366631507874,
-0.25307273864746094,
-0.4058572053909302,
-1.420006275177002,
0.39134952425956726,
-0.3158235251903534,
0.8073319792747498,
-0.10999034345149994,
0.7752411365509033,
0.14341340959072113,
-1.0333671569824219,
-0.5981526970863342,
0.33192968368530273,
0.1064666360616684,
-0.12097429484128952,
-0.22919151186943054,
0.005502394866198301,
0.3145082890987396,
0.6629731059074402,
-0.46542686223983765,
-0.10754526406526566,
-0.3471444547176361,
-0.09372315555810928,
0.8254697322845459,
-0.04899883270263672,
0.021357320249080658,
-0.1605214923620224,
-0.05536920949816704,
-0.5051206946372986,
-0.6209410429000854,
0.4748316705226898,
0.4210297167301178,
0.32902875542640686,
0.010829154402017593,
0.3016369938850403,
0.08593063056468964,
0.6154086589813232,
0.2935163974761963,
0.09404530376195908,
0.05497206747531891,
0.024701932445168495,
-0.11331737041473389,
0.5397736430168152,
0.570789635181427,
-0.008703405037522316,
-0.03160683438181877,
0.1418624371290207,
-0.28740760684013367,
0.491459459066391,
0.19850711524486542,
-0.573784351348877,
-0.28190183639526367,
0.3240300416946411,
-0.6191695928573608,
-0.31579825282096863,
0.2110910713672638,
-0.7999908924102783,
-0.1770009547472,
-0.14189524948596954,
0.5709667205810547,
-0.04566219821572304,
0.04982374608516693,
0.07136993110179901,
-0.3076964020729065,
-0.09502819925546646,
0.10898572951555252,
-0.7053893208503723,
0.48362791538238525,
0.2106538712978363,
0.5782055258750916,
-0.11955918371677399,
0.19590908288955688,
-1.2923790216445923,
0.19505222141742706,
0.07027754932641983,
1.109571099281311,
-0.9471247792243958,
-0.4472689628601074,
0.09451881051063538,
-0.08876152336597443,
0.10211075842380524,
-0.32861241698265076,
0.8224043250083923,
-0.6031370162963867,
-0.2961599826812744,
-0.13592924177646637,
-0.6939157247543335,
-0.5331690311431885,
-0.5034177899360657,
-0.9181972742080688,
0.688742458820343,
0.08223629742860794,
-0.08852256834506989,
0.1937711536884308,
-0.5903551578521729,
-0.32547420263290405,
0.34117355942726135,
-0.08453913778066635,
-0.15186895430088043,
0.1487305611371994,
0.2450220137834549,
0.4289107918739319,
-0.19840586185455322,
0.08133595436811447,
0.05006210878491402,
-0.6297181248664856,
0.272901713848114,
-0.5943048000335693,
0.04163582995533943,
0.4753882586956024,
-0.2751089930534363,
0.35952678322792053,
-0.9306348562240601,
-0.06652893126010895,
0.24173404276371002,
-0.57313072681427,
-0.03674368932843208,
0.41787445545196533,
0.2799304127693176,
0.10135666280984879,
-0.23666414618492126,
-0.7117325663566589,
0.4119969606399536,
-0.10701335221529007,
0.8761740922927856,
0.22321286797523499,
-0.05686887353658676,
0.4431494474411011,
-0.011355990543961525,
0.3678564429283142,
-0.14689894020557404,
0.02904568985104561,
-0.6094985008239746,
-0.3045254349708557,
-0.9961766600608826,
-0.023603349924087524,
0.37022915482521057,
0.5883095860481262,
-0.8971611857414246,
0.4558146893978119,
-0.5685203075408936,
-0.4873107373714447,
-0.7241464853286743,
-0.1200963482260704,
0.1279110312461853,
0.3391512632369995,
0.5645102262496948,
-0.14825983345508575,
-0.5711706280708313,
-0.7271631360054016,
-0.3519076704978943,
-0.09721484035253525,
0.13708418607711792,
-0.028489230200648308,
0.03217185288667679,
-0.21710699796676636,
0.5467819571495056,
-0.5113008618354797,
-0.24515998363494873,
-0.3467421233654022,
0.18680362403392792,
0.4299609065055847,
0.6574097871780396,
0.1439713090658188,
-0.8770235180854797,
-0.6947900652885437,
-0.44215670228004456,
-0.3180209696292877,
-0.15675042569637299,
-0.33126604557037354,
0.3302113711833954,
-0.09192190319299698,
0.4594179689884186,
-0.4608859419822693,
0.5589066743850708,
1.0145376920700073,
-0.6700499057769775,
0.1269751787185669,
0.056758198887109756,
0.15277035534381866,
-0.7193410992622375,
0.057907357811927795,
-0.2918124794960022,
-0.7254452705383301,
-0.8980119228363037,
-0.10569483786821365,
0.0811171606183052,
-0.5591371655464172,
-0.3234378397464752,
0.27709177136421204,
-0.7721176743507385,
-0.21148857474327087,
-0.584797203540802,
-0.23149994015693665,
-0.2173953354358673,
0.31709975004196167,
0.47230711579322815,
0.719298243522644,
0.5976293087005615,
-0.6615334153175354,
0.3215877413749695,
0.40097522735595703,
-0.026884205639362335,
0.12631046772003174,
-0.8110169172286987,
0.12359023094177246,
-0.24244575202465057,
0.36681193113327026,
-1.0355366468429565,
-0.13106517493724823,
0.12662947177886963,
-0.6926650404930115,
0.6920163631439209,
-0.2729319930076599,
-0.18733040988445282,
-0.633047342300415,
-0.15874771773815155,
0.632644772529602,
0.9639778733253479,
-0.440245121717453,
0.54158616065979,
0.4258451759815216,
-0.18436464667320251,
-0.3421006500720978,
-0.640207052230835,
0.18556223809719086,
-0.04469752684235573,
-0.612086296081543,
0.7382287979125977,
0.0938623771071434,
0.24684566259384155,
0.17355675995349884,
-0.3149038851261139,
0.025865964591503143,
-0.36136072874069214,
0.33291998505592346,
0.08477209508419037,
-0.39827248454093933,
-0.24434059858322144,
0.019696421921253204,
-0.3572477698326111,
-0.21189835667610168,
-0.4844835698604584,
0.5896204113960266,
-0.06218931823968887,
-0.4066244959831238,
-0.6263257265090942,
0.8945827484130859,
0.6034684181213379,
-0.1556307077407837,
0.3406451344490051,
0.7128725051879883,
-0.4312846064567566,
-0.33375057578086853,
-0.606301486492157,
-0.3613210618495941,
-0.5883902311325073,
0.013264842331409454,
-0.2566636800765991,
-1.1299810409545898,
0.6244129538536072,
-0.05117599293589592,
-0.06252084672451019,
0.5460155010223389,
0.21492263674736023,
-0.13763268291950226,
0.8073035478591919,
0.4912937879562378,
0.2666950523853302,
0.455655038356781,
-0.4030545651912689,
0.4423801600933075,
-0.6843647956848145,
0.07065427303314209,
-0.5203286409378052,
-0.8688661456108093,
-0.39885619282722473,
-0.9630325436592102,
0.4915713369846344,
0.24362827837467194,
-0.09142915159463882,
0.7101852297782898,
-0.941307783126831,
0.18189741671085358,
0.7203214168548584,
-0.2220294326543808,
0.24293489754199982,
-0.1798083782196045,
0.30248168110847473,
0.02825823239982128,
-0.9790809154510498,
-0.5517006516456604,
0.6434847712516785,
0.7185417413711548,
0.8408623337745667,
0.019115904346108437,
0.6008065938949585,
0.6376906037330627,
-0.10158737748861313,
-0.9930118322372437,
0.45910409092903137,
-0.2968456447124481,
-0.3123868405818939,
-0.3591337203979492,
-0.06033569574356079,
-0.7803924083709717,
-0.3315044641494751,
-0.4457041621208191,
-0.7450383901596069,
0.460704505443573,
0.5079856514930725,
-0.5361618995666504,
0.5550973415374756,
-0.38528570532798767,
0.41261258721351624,
0.13365159928798676,
-0.2772154211997986,
-0.12641118466854095,
-0.7130578756332397,
0.11527366936206818,
0.06728915125131607,
-0.23505552113056183,
0.04678158462047577,
-0.0796959400177002,
0.8279555439949036,
-0.6341555118560791,
0.5317056775093079,
-0.1999424546957016,
0.45395442843437195,
0.7481763958930969,
0.22234760224819183,
0.7628798484802246,
0.18015056848526,
0.37576985359191895,
0.3184725344181061,
-0.1336379498243332,
-0.16093869507312775,
-0.6899689435958862,
0.5468271970748901,
-0.5349317193031311,
-0.6481391191482544,
-0.5510542988777161,
-0.45906829833984375,
-0.006586119532585144,
-0.09990829974412918,
0.21736420691013336,
0.6325253248214722,
0.3574904501438141,
0.14575974643230438,
0.43848180770874023,
-0.08675634115934372,
1.0702589750289917,
0.3798570930957794,
0.3135985732078552,
-0.6941151022911072,
0.7295266389846802,
0.002647397108376026,
0.13311827182769775,
0.6806864738464355,
0.06258267909288406,
-0.6587356328964233,
-0.6967726945877075,
-0.5181624889373779,
0.3884968161582947,
-0.7890191078186035,
-0.4595475494861603,
-0.5740828514099121,
-0.7380496859550476,
-0.22315245866775513,
-0.3834104537963867,
-0.96112459897995,
-0.5405151844024658,
0.01011945866048336,
0.1993381679058075,
0.19865714013576508,
0.8035045862197876,
-0.17772603034973145,
0.5257784724235535,
-1.5532581806182861,
0.20015403628349304,
0.3167651891708374,
0.33045247197151184,
-0.07607024908065796,
-0.5347608327865601,
-0.15638674795627594,
-0.43043747544288635,
-0.2705582082271576,
-1.0136668682098389,
0.6406397223472595,
0.46975746750831604,
0.49806350469589233,
0.6708415746688843,
0.07235857099294662,
0.8920813798904419,
-1.1046967506408691,
0.9680301547050476,
0.3500240743160248,
-1.212349772453308,
0.6022116541862488,
-0.11699391901493073,
0.45930370688438416,
0.23766069114208221,
0.462116003036499,
-0.6157891750335693,
-0.1419757455587387,
-0.483197957277298,
-0.6136652827262878,
0.3991273045539856,
0.524000883102417,
-0.06390974670648575,
0.06599181145429611,
0.2811295986175537,
0.07549452036619186,
-0.012224594131112099,
-0.2957691252231598,
-0.43158185482025146,
-0.2979293465614319,
0.013452201150357723,
-0.3597000539302826,
-0.6021054983139038,
0.373335063457489,
-0.3466290235519409,
0.35503318905830383,
-0.14137880504131317,
1.1263957023620605,
0.597294270992279,
-0.13199111819267273,
-0.47376933693885803,
0.08583860844373703,
0.512941300868988,
0.2436586618423462,
-0.26295578479766846,
0.4201653003692627,
-0.22393399477005005,
-0.7454378604888916,
0.3697901666164398,
0.401828795671463,
-0.1719718873500824,
0.3870033323764801,
0.7263875603675842,
1.0018481016159058,
0.29008975625038147,
-0.3698768615722656,
0.22265352308750153,
0.04538414627313614,
0.04971616342663765,
-0.34538230299949646,
0.269157737493515,
0.002398381708189845,
0.4763077199459076,
0.7103185057640076,
0.43142372369766235,
0.2741321921348572,
-0.3569117486476898,
0.3951864540576935,
0.07311411947011948,
-0.6664404273033142,
-0.5415594577789307,
1.2782107591629028,
0.514075517654419,
-0.6702519059181213,
0.5458298921585083,
0.1712283194065094,
-0.5937921404838562,
0.05401657521724701,
0.4193234443664551,
1.144715666770935,
-0.6815954446792603,
-0.15532371401786804,
0.6367565393447876,
-0.14391888678073883,
0.14814341068267822,
0.5099883079528809,
-0.28342404961586,
-0.48495012521743774,
-0.835894763469696,
-0.8003761172294617,
-0.26009589433670044,
0.05769237130880356,
-0.5848471522331238,
0.5236467719078064,
-0.1876223236322403,
-0.22232472896575928,
0.24531954526901245,
-0.28460264205932617,
-0.6763401031494141,
0.08855141699314117,
0.7743971943855286,
1.2887548208236694,
-0.6019484996795654,
1.0801347494125366,
0.6844754815101624,
-0.3303816020488739,
-0.7703245282173157,
-0.18534427881240845,
0.23835080862045288,
-0.6300545930862427,
0.865750789642334,
0.17075558006763458,
-0.1293317824602127,
0.1203400269150734,
-0.13305453956127167,
-1.5071971416473389,
1.0104985237121582,
0.12297741323709488,
-0.8611725568771362,
-0.27774685621261597,
0.3767930865287781,
0.15457279980182648,
-0.36708664894104004,
0.1973867267370224,
0.42326629161834717,
0.381813645362854,
0.6047568321228027,
-0.8357580304145813,
0.00670637097209692,
-0.4246668815612793,
0.12586700916290283,
0.2908190190792084,
-0.4812612533569336,
0.7276604771614075,
0.11138596385717392,
-0.34701940417289734,
-0.29611554741859436,
0.9636910557746887,
-0.030935214832425117,
-0.03625287488102913,
0.6847583651542664,
0.12366002798080444,
0.5374723672866821,
-0.17435622215270996,
0.7845101952552795,
-0.5023170113563538,
0.018783675506711006,
0.7393036484718323,
0.06937314569950104,
1.0310537815093994,
0.6070806980133057,
-0.0011825168039649725,
0.46323299407958984,
0.4958702623844147,
0.013905812986195087,
0.5151048302650452,
0.04941419139504433,
-0.3333316743373871,
-0.33138307929039,
-0.04006475955247879,
-0.13887056708335876,
0.5740326046943665,
0.5321375727653503,
-0.5774590373039246,
-0.165099635720253,
-0.18625877797603607,
-0.1788528710603714,
0.24022281169891357,
-0.6283509731292725,
0.3580113649368286,
0.12232737988233566,
-0.7980800271034241,
0.910559356212616,
-0.13031744956970215,
0.6695849299430847,
-0.7677072286605835,
-0.3384486436843872,
0.0797916129231453,
0.18988651037216187,
-0.23469306528568268,
-1.0766561031341553,
0.9003028273582458,
0.1448875218629837,
-0.269537091255188,
-0.5402063727378845,
1.0486154556274414,
-0.3955685794353485,
-0.3167712986469269,
0.040208518505096436,
0.2743874192237854,
0.2652457058429718,
-0.22844725847244263,
-0.35245102643966675,
0.6674095988273621,
-0.18235048651695251,
-0.1908382624387741,
-0.14040057361125946,
-0.1757538765668869,
0.014106950722634792,
0.7513052821159363,
0.7088556289672852,
0.3604482114315033,
0.21742838621139526,
-0.07049560546875,
0.9651917815208435,
-0.9772526621818542,
-0.7687466740608215,
-0.6098182201385498,
0.8888829350471497,
-0.03420889005064964,
0.0052359336987137794,
0.4762592017650604,
0.33623379468917847,
0.5609529614448547,
-0.34574949741363525,
0.49961698055267334,
-0.010838765650987625,
0.46584266424179077,
-0.3722158670425415,
0.6908053159713745,
-0.19048736989498138,
0.060758452862501144,
-0.23786617815494537,
-1.1074825525283813,
-0.4563581347465515,
0.5276564359664917,
0.11737816780805588,
-0.4873277544975281,
0.8035951256752014,
0.2738249897956848,
-0.12619169056415558,
0.09563211351633072,
0.4560766816139221,
-0.16061076521873474,
0.4040678143501282,
0.982361912727356,
0.7289988398551941,
-0.8459838032722473,
0.6926047205924988,
-0.15282900631427765,
-0.1600019335746765,
-0.11621855944395065,
-1.0084530115127563,
-0.7818755507469177,
-0.9719537496566772,
-0.6038478016853333,
-0.31582680344581604,
0.010924458503723145,
1.010115146636963,
1.030347466468811,
-0.9631720781326294,
-0.33264800906181335,
-0.0025896835140883923,
-0.13615761697292328,
-0.5288810133934021,
-0.16535232961177826,
0.44425779581069946,
-0.3040730059146881,
-0.9135971665382385,
0.7444304823875427,
0.387643963098526,
-0.00157476298045367,
-0.2774815857410431,
-0.16626842319965363,
-0.13610997796058655,
0.15045851469039917,
0.6516932845115662,
0.4155765771865845,
-0.5377068519592285,
-0.5225508213043213,
-0.09422799944877625,
0.2845565676689148,
0.2844916582107544,
0.9334350824356079,
-0.9977268576622009,
0.2792969346046448,
0.823769748210907,
0.896432101726532,
0.594034731388092,
0.11817938089370728,
0.6991929411888123,
-0.5138983726501465,
0.09404932707548141,
0.5461648106575012,
0.31466948986053467,
0.27121278643608093,
-0.5591385364532471,
0.384433388710022,
0.5381612181663513,
-0.7311912775039673,
-0.669513463973999,
0.25917917490005493,
-1.350332260131836,
-0.02453593909740448,
1.145266056060791,
-0.019473975524306297,
-0.20045925676822662,
0.19989322125911713,
0.1937379390001297,
0.577092170715332,
-0.6009929776191711,
0.3451983630657196,
0.38008913397789,
-0.4729367196559906,
-0.5607474446296692,
-0.48774269223213196,
0.8706099987030029,
-0.11562249809503555,
-0.20430654287338257,
-0.17562982439994812,
0.31798267364501953,
0.05369142070412636,
0.4341854453086853,
0.07559164613485336,
0.0033431919291615486,
0.26404818892478943,
0.338813453912735,
-0.11499530076980591,
-0.42254602909088135,
-0.5009869933128357,
-0.5083217024803162,
0.3877561688423157,
-0.12770897150039673,
-0.5078146457672119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01799v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01799v2 | Faster and Lighter LLMs: A Survey on Current Challenges and Way Forward | 2024-02-02T06:29:34 | 2024-04-24T04:58:46 | Arnav Chavan, Raghav Magazine, Shubham Kushwaha, Mérouane Debbah, Deepak Gupta | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite the impressive performance of LLMs, their widespread adoption faces
challenges due to substantial computational and memory requirements during
inference. Recent advancements in model compression and system-level
optimization methods aim to enhance LLM inference. This survey offers an
overview of these methods, emphasizing recent developments. Through experiments
on LLaMA(/2)-7B, we evaluate various compression techniques, providing
practical insights for efficient LLM deployment in a unified setting. The
empirical analysis on LLaMA(/2)-7B highlights the effectiveness of these
methods. Drawing from survey insights, we identify current limitations and
discuss potential future directions to improve LLM inference efficiency. We
release the codebase to reproduce the results presented in this paper at
https://github.com/nyunAI/Faster-LLM-Survey | [
-0.3599008619785309,
-0.7025846838951111,
0.7566865086555481,
0.37896090745925903,
-0.3609668016433716,
0.08533551543951035,
-0.15783900022506714,
-0.7247312068939209,
0.11555243283510208,
0.4759954810142517,
-0.46951937675476074,
-0.29748621582984924,
-0.639101505279541,
0.22960682213306427,
-0.3053211271762848,
0.2620943784713745,
0.11547188460826874,
0.1615605354309082,
-0.5085979700088501,
-0.09139949083328247,
-0.4104051887989044,
-0.4036213755607605,
-0.6113133430480957,
-0.29090115427970886,
0.5939102172851562,
0.492979496717453,
0.42466625571250916,
0.7102839946746826,
0.6550974249839783,
0.3781214654445648,
-0.5553017854690552,
0.36855003237724304,
-0.4870392382144928,
0.2857513725757599,
0.35709255933761597,
-0.7142953872680664,
-0.33199790120124817,
-0.25095728039741516,
0.6020822525024414,
0.8258406519889832,
-0.2139531522989273,
0.43238896131515503,
-0.16170701384544373,
0.6536300182342529,
-1.096512794494629,
-0.2838408648967743,
-0.6186128258705139,
0.14121925830841064,
-0.23840709030628204,
-0.11186631768941879,
-0.3673921227455139,
-0.5173048973083496,
-0.11400188505649567,
-0.483656108379364,
0.3290362060070038,
0.3328825533390045,
0.4016333520412445,
0.6361814141273499,
-0.5862451791763306,
-0.19896364212036133,
-0.6618396043777466,
0.8835726976394653,
-0.6721627116203308,
0.3853980004787445,
-0.07878277450799942,
0.33244767785072327,
-0.2750217020511627,
-0.8985448479652405,
-0.29442843794822693,
-0.13874876499176025,
0.23683346807956696,
-0.0056401202455163,
-0.13571998476982117,
0.005901549477130175,
0.19478216767311096,
0.2577517330646515,
-0.3376198410987854,
0.5693192481994629,
-0.40814247727394104,
-0.14019213616847992,
0.67485511302948,
0.24107810854911804,
-0.12412344664335251,
0.03189669921994209,
-0.5514307022094727,
-0.13892757892608643,
-0.9470806121826172,
-0.35833415389060974,
0.6445966958999634,
-0.17558908462524414,
-0.18690595030784607,
0.37091556191444397,
-0.2880311906337738,
0.6139006614685059,
-0.24811239540576935,
-0.27941030263900757,
0.18863941729068756,
-0.1432202011346817,
-0.2387600541114807,
0.06164627894759178,
0.43443286418914795,
0.5039480328559875,
-0.13537751138210297,
-0.13283830881118774,
-0.3234858810901642,
0.18145830929279327,
0.037483420222997665,
-0.9287461042404175,
-0.033323582261800766,
0.0946657657623291,
-0.7243091464042664,
-0.2653876841068268,
-0.10351614654064178,
-0.7508411407470703,
-0.7551068663597107,
-0.19527049362659454,
0.2293584942817688,
0.13566167652606964,
-0.1267353892326355,
0.37562188506126404,
-0.4409745931625366,
0.4803375005722046,
0.6400037407875061,
-0.5318195223808289,
0.2670082151889801,
0.6893811225891113,
0.77845299243927,
-0.32016611099243164,
0.4058651924133301,
-0.31112203001976013,
-0.05359472334384918,
-0.22009433805942535,
1.1199356317520142,
-0.2570148706436157,
-0.6232227087020874,
-0.21441563963890076,
-0.22167542576789856,
0.2494538575410843,
-0.8432028889656067,
0.7285269498825073,
-0.4870966374874115,
-0.16534939408302307,
-0.230765700340271,
-0.570782482624054,
-0.3112375736236572,
0.1360231190919876,
-0.6479465365409851,
1.2578321695327759,
-0.11571016907691956,
-0.5869331955909729,
0.05299098789691925,
-0.07292868942022324,
-0.28917989134788513,
-0.1138487160205841,
-0.1940167099237442,
-0.49336478114128113,
0.5643656253814697,
0.242831289768219,
0.533791720867157,
-0.8119345903396606,
0.004294120240956545,
-0.7075069546699524,
-0.7841832041740417,
-0.11204269528388977,
-0.5267087817192078,
0.8020640015602112,
0.5796259045600891,
-0.1399456262588501,
-0.07379107177257538,
-0.7967150211334229,
-0.1185317412018776,
0.22164160013198853,
-0.38017410039901733,
-0.027540072798728943,
0.2808302640914917,
-0.18667857348918915,
-0.34473055601119995,
0.3228428363800049,
-0.32143232226371765,
0.42205652594566345,
-0.030423710122704506,
0.23932214081287384,
0.8654470443725586,
-0.0412692092359066,
0.5487891435623169,
-0.2699654996395111,
0.6636984348297119,
-0.2918775677680969,
0.342220276594162,
0.20041638612747192,
-0.44188055396080017,
-0.7266380190849304,
-0.24481382966041565,
0.23682989180088043,
0.6438901424407959,
-0.4923565089702606,
0.2454860508441925,
-0.23803123831748962,
-0.7410164475440979,
-0.18275538086891174,
0.2550778090953827,
0.33565816283226013,
0.5316995978355408,
0.2569524049758911,
-0.11405343562364578,
-0.6665931940078735,
-0.9008779525756836,
-0.24948732554912567,
-0.33542394638061523,
-0.06647750735282898,
0.3994297385215759,
0.2990601360797882,
-0.26359790563583374,
0.607911229133606,
-0.6278613805770874,
0.3343677818775177,
-0.4355373978614807,
-0.045361388474702835,
0.10808301717042923,
0.5169854164123535,
0.5289084911346436,
-0.7488281726837158,
-0.20861203968524933,
-0.4035554528236389,
-0.6656842231750488,
-0.5682555437088013,
0.019574958831071854,
-0.0006363157299347222,
-0.022709505632519722,
0.6389007568359375,
-0.5613409876823425,
0.42420127987861633,
0.5732308030128479,
-0.07095315307378769,
0.6282187104225159,
-0.17529679834842682,
0.03168238326907158,
-0.6961898803710938,
-0.33757609128952026,
-0.104498952627182,
-0.07489306479692459,
-0.39764103293418884,
0.1455596387386322,
0.17400237917900085,
0.29428830742836,
-0.6834067106246948,
0.5065873265266418,
-0.9136020541191101,
-0.45186367630958557,
-0.18692119419574738,
-0.16993612051010132,
0.025503557175397873,
0.07634466886520386,
-0.10918799042701721,
0.9307760000228882,
0.4298330247402191,
-0.7418795824050903,
0.2315538227558136,
0.030267613008618355,
-0.49241727590560913,
0.14926105737686157,
-0.7842802405357361,
0.2365955412387848,
-0.3309193253517151,
0.48405733704566956,
-0.9575551152229309,
-0.2617282569408417,
0.23030008375644684,
0.052608609199523926,
0.3059874475002289,
-0.06292862445116043,
-0.6744762063026428,
-0.2828267216682434,
-0.6274682879447937,
0.64425128698349,
0.9575805068016052,
-0.6864356994628906,
0.5904305577278137,
0.15688306093215942,
0.18596746027469635,
-0.7223066687583923,
-0.949714720249176,
0.04896775260567665,
-0.7463985681533813,
-0.6794466376304626,
0.339285671710968,
-0.29013341665267944,
-0.5282597541809082,
-0.3669669032096863,
-0.36998826265335083,
0.10335245728492737,
0.5242226123809814,
0.16236330568790436,
0.11526244878768921,
-0.17892320454120636,
-0.11330090463161469,
0.055184729397296906,
0.14653651416301727,
-0.03683929145336151,
0.02371295914053917,
0.2886172831058502,
0.10345162451267242,
-0.4934345483779907,
-0.33234164118766785,
0.14121520519256592,
-0.01883784681558609,
0.32513973116874695,
0.37910911440849304,
0.46955424547195435,
0.020579474046826363,
-0.23718328773975372,
-1.0610779523849487,
-0.2888108193874359,
-0.5274621248245239,
0.08518076688051224,
-0.11550223082304001,
-0.9209821820259094,
0.5768756866455078,
-0.6944546103477478,
-0.08472692966461182,
0.1482502818107605,
0.46978068351745605,
-0.08494208008050919,
0.8370767831802368,
0.49743300676345825,
-0.013063888996839523,
0.5243066549301147,
-0.34194764494895935,
-0.12933678925037384,
-0.7370889782905579,
-0.34412670135498047,
-0.8818015456199646,
-0.5776442885398865,
-0.47491389513015747,
-0.7874626517295837,
0.46127429604530334,
0.565929114818573,
-0.05328657850623131,
0.16725628077983856,
-0.5187241435050964,
0.38129922747612,
0.4221917390823364,
0.15786683559417725,
0.4149005711078644,
-0.0140825305134058,
0.06879372894763947,
0.35880929231643677,
-0.7532587051391602,
-0.5354604125022888,
1.0151848793029785,
0.22114339470863342,
1.0540831089019775,
0.3642193078994751,
0.6737914085388184,
0.20952993631362915,
0.39328205585479736,
-0.6622768640518188,
0.7610927820205688,
0.21994648873806,
-0.5223150253295898,
0.1468677669763565,
-0.6863242983818054,
-0.9953667521476746,
0.3172592222690582,
0.007077975198626518,
-0.7698397040367126,
0.3438555896282196,
0.1801166534423828,
-0.25929349660873413,
0.3548211455345154,
-0.9275617003440857,
0.35841304063796997,
-0.328125,
-0.2839820384979248,
-0.12134259194135666,
-1.017746090888977,
0.6261512637138367,
0.12072056531906128,
-0.011166942305862904,
-0.5189681649208069,
-0.6306794285774231,
0.5393931269645691,
-0.41361552476882935,
0.6794450283050537,
-0.19983942806720734,
-0.03632081672549248,
0.4876594841480255,
-0.26535430550575256,
0.5043670535087585,
0.15472730994224548,
-0.43459904193878174,
0.22408358752727509,
-0.17808383703231812,
-0.5646920204162598,
-0.6180934309959412,
0.5531690120697021,
-0.5893474817276001,
-0.651764988899231,
-0.21977795660495758,
-0.5532538294792175,
-0.2243345081806183,
-0.11252166330814362,
0.20829206705093384,
0.2863505184650421,
0.13250815868377686,
0.28396138548851013,
0.7475947737693787,
-0.290481299161911,
0.7040855288505554,
0.4438393712043762,
-0.03408881649374962,
-0.3463623523712158,
0.5097631216049194,
0.09559609740972519,
0.24844980239868164,
0.3766991198062897,
0.21547628939151764,
-0.4241206645965576,
-1.2281494140625,
-0.37773892283439636,
0.14704111218452454,
-0.6106432676315308,
-0.44485944509506226,
-0.39645326137542725,
0.30728715658187866,
-0.39025142788887024,
-0.10159775614738464,
-0.2698838412761688,
-0.6737123131752014,
-0.5097672343254089,
-0.10939288139343262,
0.42049044370651245,
0.7662897706031799,
-0.032163940370082855,
0.771862268447876,
-0.5060440897941589,
0.3935070335865021,
0.00203444785438478,
0.12988190352916718,
-0.03255436569452286,
-0.4344266355037689,
-0.06769776344299316,
-0.40593406558036804,
-0.41550564765930176,
-0.7790732979774475,
0.11310897022485733,
0.15725012123584747,
0.5259792804718018,
0.5808532238006592,
0.18390749394893646,
1.0071738958358765,
-0.18689419329166412,
0.8135626912117004,
-0.014817418530583382,
-0.39017271995544434,
0.2703409194946289,
0.07414919883012772,
0.1886315792798996,
0.5979326367378235,
0.31095972657203674,
0.02551746554672718,
-0.08367334306240082,
-0.5420055389404297,
-0.8301565051078796,
0.23032055795192719,
0.0037688217125833035,
0.039374928921461105,
0.13139566779136658,
0.792999267578125,
0.010586551390588284,
0.1811484694480896,
-0.3680724799633026,
-0.44207996129989624,
0.4625505208969116,
-0.12912297248840332,
-0.11019685119390488,
-0.4631849527359009,
0.1936989724636078,
-0.24497364461421967,
0.5172995328903198,
-0.12843438982963562,
0.34111618995666504,
0.22110694646835327,
-0.2258913218975067,
0.30122148990631104,
0.04195667430758476,
0.6031194925308228,
0.383083313703537,
-0.25927650928497314,
0.3285529613494873,
0.5329602956771851,
-0.23382920026779175,
0.3814850151538849,
0.06527654826641083,
-0.31600841879844666,
-0.1950543075799942,
0.528462290763855,
0.7642830610275269,
0.2928485572338104,
-0.7818787097930908,
0.29962217807769775,
-0.22204722464084625,
-0.3543708920478821,
-0.2326563000679016,
0.2896255850791931,
0.3233477473258972,
0.4927145838737488,
0.3867028057575226,
-0.03513025864958763,
0.44816383719444275,
-0.2108563780784607,
-0.4032183587551117,
0.5534698963165283,
0.023891642689704895,
0.021024029701948166,
0.8236707448959351,
0.06696564704179764,
-0.08086083829402924,
0.32583844661712646,
-0.18609674274921417,
-0.10233174264431,
0.7843146324157715,
0.3923855125904083,
0.686345100402832,
0.026851439848542213,
-0.3626003861427307,
-0.017706552520394325,
0.22346647083759308,
-0.5074427127838135,
0.4716750681400299,
-0.45454442501068115,
-0.5883743762969971,
-0.5287798047065735,
-0.6001508235931396,
-0.6379362940788269,
-0.2866327166557312,
-0.4860627353191376,
0.3025757968425751,
-0.37560901045799255,
-0.12904652953147888,
-0.4544665813446045,
0.30058977007865906,
-0.4983235001564026,
-0.04675743728876114,
0.2753070592880249,
1.316365122795105,
-0.465768963098526,
0.5464394688606262,
0.5172670483589172,
0.023177307099103928,
-0.8701502084732056,
-0.5650180578231812,
0.23147553205490112,
-0.7202650904655457,
0.3988145887851715,
0.2627699673175812,
-0.2597237825393677,
-0.011281672865152359,
-0.7198055982589722,
-0.7558961510658264,
1.4715955257415771,
0.9072915315628052,
-0.46496129035949707,
-0.02108016237616539,
0.03881169110536575,
0.12733228504657745,
-0.13467930257320404,
0.6552838683128357,
0.6511415839195251,
0.62734055519104,
0.056909818202257156,
-0.438400000333786,
-0.11013586074113846,
0.02982904762029648,
0.3216288685798645,
0.04318616911768913,
-0.9073184728622437,
0.6088390350341797,
-0.015084968879818916,
-0.17927612364292145,
0.5300039052963257,
0.8974753618240356,
0.4902135133743286,
0.5623804926872253,
0.7140516638755798,
0.8785206079483032,
0.6528055667877197,
0.006940120831131935,
1.07065749168396,
-0.19844244420528412,
0.2641793489456177,
1.0093231201171875,
-0.3468318283557892,
0.6742599010467529,
0.7291799783706665,
-0.23193155229091644,
0.4393133819103241,
0.9242016077041626,
0.04707137122750282,
0.1622067391872406,
0.4869699478149414,
-0.5813690423965454,
-0.2490667849779129,
-0.1833423376083374,
-0.3839881122112274,
0.30265238881111145,
0.14467062056064606,
-0.07661296427249908,
-0.22067388892173767,
-0.278696209192276,
-0.04517076164484024,
-0.21338115632534027,
-0.423389732837677,
0.6433945894241333,
0.1576145440340042,
-0.3872339129447937,
0.4255029559135437,
0.03808462247252464,
1.0346834659576416,
-0.45728886127471924,
0.08107634633779526,
-0.3172939717769623,
0.050057705491781235,
-0.275186687707901,
-0.30594339966773987,
0.11924998462200165,
0.05849296972155571,
0.01860908418893814,
-0.4090766906738281,
0.9812770485877991,
0.053291477262973785,
-0.4952637255191803,
0.32866039872169495,
0.641143798828125,
0.5204248428344727,
-0.04055347293615341,
-0.3746193051338196,
0.49902382493019104,
-0.2568112909793854,
-0.6186741590499878,
0.3157123327255249,
0.23898905515670776,
-0.09279822558164597,
1.017011046409607,
0.5360814929008484,
0.1610606163740158,
0.5394201874732971,
0.09639851748943329,
0.7516806721687317,
-0.4555005729198456,
-0.10634879022836685,
-0.7501683831214905,
0.2405405342578888,
-0.08261137455701828,
-0.10480234771966934,
0.8169262409210205,
0.6763104200363159,
0.6425400376319885,
-0.08418446779251099,
0.44605186581611633,
0.007114409003406763,
0.4492233395576477,
-0.6324602365493774,
0.29156494140625,
-0.6748200058937073,
0.6655101180076599,
-0.028566591441631317,
-0.9198782444000244,
-0.33664724230766296,
0.2549881041049957,
-0.09012798964977264,
0.06824813038110733,
0.33831867575645447,
1.0201140642166138,
-0.00675085699185729,
-0.09436875581741333,
0.13499318063259125,
-0.1692916750907898,
0.15568441152572632,
0.4768622815608978,
1.0213018655776978,
-0.36099058389663696,
0.5669738054275513,
-0.39346471428871155,
0.10783535242080688,
-0.4872205853462219,
-1.2569568157196045,
-0.4803234338760376,
0.15556946396827698,
-0.30883175134658813,
-0.03446283936500549,
-0.05535057559609413,
0.8150523900985718,
0.8408817648887634,
-0.31906214356422424,
-0.4049588441848755,
-0.39000698924064636,
0.49338826537132263,
-0.07509096711874008,
-0.1386980265378952,
0.031761717051267624,
-0.19671982526779175,
-0.7894502282142639,
0.734940767288208,
0.08936797827482224,
0.09680217504501343,
-0.24621166288852692,
-0.20864932239055634,
0.02991516701877117,
0.14200520515441895,
0.5021671056747437,
0.18860049545764923,
-0.6302064061164856,
-0.2529922127723694,
-0.20075608789920807,
0.041049763560295105,
0.00847351923584938,
0.923547625541687,
-0.909807026386261,
0.04123527929186821,
0.8175442218780518,
0.9236763715744019,
0.7450703978538513,
0.13432495296001434,
0.3483210802078247,
-0.6474982500076294,
0.40954381227493286,
0.21444135904312134,
0.39115408062934875,
0.19800586998462677,
-0.3739124536514282,
0.8348404765129089,
0.46875903010368347,
-0.6089991331100464,
-1.1267262697219849,
0.26594921946525574,
-1.1439887285232544,
-0.25923582911491394,
1.1068137884140015,
0.017882345244288445,
-0.24063022434711456,
0.1226174607872963,
-0.08650664240121841,
0.35676583647727966,
-0.2040882110595703,
0.4178119897842407,
0.2939635217189789,
-0.4607473313808441,
-0.29898303747177124,
-0.7127807140350342,
0.1477818489074707,
0.6596598625183105,
-0.8645825386047363,
-0.28942763805389404,
0.5902450084686279,
0.20869077742099762,
-0.2649131119251251,
0.525756299495697,
0.19275742769241333,
0.06467980146408081,
0.10281763225793839,
0.053829874843358994,
-0.06388738751411438,
-0.26751500368118286,
-0.5775718092918396,
0.32063016295433044,
0.15242233872413635,
0.1083715632557869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01158v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01158v1 | LLM-Detector: Improving AI-Generated Chinese Text Detection with Open-Source LLM Instruction Tuning | 2024-02-02T05:54:12 | 2024-02-02T05:54:12 | Rongsheng Wang, Haoming Chen, Ruizhe Zhou, Han Ma, Yaofei Duan, Yanlan Kang, Songhua Yang, Baoyu Fan, Tao Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL | ChatGPT and other general large language models (LLMs) have achieved
remarkable success, but they have also raised concerns about the misuse of
AI-generated texts. Existing AI-generated text detection models, such as based
on BERT and RoBERTa, are prone to in-domain over-fitting, leading to poor
out-of-domain (OOD) detection performance. In this paper, we first collected
Chinese text responses generated by human experts and 9 types of LLMs, for
which to multiple domains questions, and further created a dataset that mixed
human-written sentences and sentences polished by LLMs. We then proposed
LLM-Detector, a novel method for both document-level and sentence-level text
detection through Instruction Tuning of LLMs. Our method leverages the wealth
of knowledge LLMs acquire during pre-training, enabling them to detect the text
they generate. Instruction tuning aligns the model's responses with the user's
expected text detection tasks. Experimental results show that previous methods
struggle with sentence-level AI-generated text detection and OOD detection. In
contrast, our proposed method not only significantly outperforms baseline
methods in both sentence-level and document-level text detection but also
demonstrates strong generalization capabilities. Furthermore, since
LLM-Detector is trained based on open-source LLMs, it is easy to customize for
deployment. | [
-0.1268402487039566,
-0.7790933847427368,
0.6317034959793091,
-0.22499683499336243,
-0.40726742148399353,
-0.04924262687563896,
-0.3564680814743042,
-0.5494513511657715,
-0.2771185040473938,
0.6114838719367981,
-0.4006601572036743,
-0.7617873549461365,
-0.5696086287498474,
0.08122871816158295,
-0.35340365767478943,
0.8778806328773499,
0.0439043827354908,
-0.0823230966925621,
-0.05771590769290924,
0.24461421370506287,
-0.16306257247924805,
-0.39797648787498474,
-0.7214082479476929,
-0.2867141366004944,
0.2275819480419159,
0.4651528298854828,
0.39409786462783813,
0.6463248133659363,
0.5363876819610596,
0.22579996287822723,
0.05210408568382263,
0.7612263560295105,
-0.3954111337661743,
-0.019660212099552155,
0.26814207434654236,
-0.5629316568374634,
-0.5161862373352051,
-0.13213101029396057,
0.6368951201438904,
-0.21209292113780975,
-0.05501963570713997,
-0.1448971927165985,
0.07951024919748306,
0.37004154920578003,
-0.5998184680938721,
0.03454995155334473,
-0.980259120464325,
-0.0343390516936779,
-0.5284028649330139,
-0.5467385053634644,
-0.8315518498420715,
-0.10570843517780304,
-0.15414489805698395,
-0.5512372255325317,
0.41683581471443176,
0.20706424117088318,
0.889758825302124,
0.2530565559864044,
-0.33025437593460083,
-0.6327672600746155,
-0.4575783610343933,
0.6401877999305725,
-0.9956976175308228,
-0.015255807898938656,
0.4685284495353699,
0.17299534380435944,
-0.36211684346199036,
-0.6021810173988342,
-0.7365618944168091,
-0.282892644405365,
-0.02590293437242508,
0.33132198452949524,
-0.17491352558135986,
0.1498713195323944,
-0.06365906447172165,
0.5103137493133545,
-0.824794590473175,
0.4350407123565674,
0.08399789780378342,
-0.32083868980407715,
0.6152719855308533,
0.17472107708454132,
0.6887381076812744,
0.07475365698337555,
-0.24430237710475922,
0.12773890793323517,
-0.8205161690711975,
-0.13613814115524292,
0.5087222456932068,
0.2140991985797882,
0.012694471515715122,
0.46072474122047424,
-0.003807135159149766,
0.721308171749115,
-0.05516424775123596,
-0.11112981289625168,
-0.010733306407928467,
-0.1953379511833191,
-0.13215908408164978,
0.13260574638843536,
0.9470100402832031,
0.3426109552383423,
0.516772985458374,
-0.039454128593206406,
-0.3701036274433136,
-0.06642311066389084,
0.07769009470939636,
-0.8990362882614136,
-0.3763956129550934,
0.04084004834294319,
-0.479077011346817,
-0.4555639922618866,
0.14760814607143402,
-0.2881183326244354,
-0.5217718482017517,
0.053064778447151184,
0.2137352079153061,
-0.5373246073722839,
-0.08663410693407059,
0.28377148509025574,
-0.032541245222091675,
0.385665625333786,
0.3084896206855774,
-0.981884241104126,
-0.08796297013759613,
0.7037021517753601,
0.8160319924354553,
-0.33263686299324036,
-0.05431151017546654,
-0.7856572270393372,
0.17707133293151855,
-0.28144463896751404,
1.1307252645492554,
-0.4183492660522461,
-0.334061861038208,
0.2430821806192398,
-0.15367934107780457,
0.009582370519638062,
-0.7257673144340515,
0.6958591341972351,
-0.5527563691139221,
0.5354863405227661,
0.08577815443277359,
-0.6707873940467834,
0.21827994287014008,
0.4148470163345337,
-0.36611247062683105,
1.1942650079727173,
-0.07427871972322464,
-0.7998376488685608,
0.3261021375656128,
-0.6318437457084656,
-0.6055394411087036,
0.40192005038261414,
-0.19589926302433014,
-0.7011576294898987,
-0.041468922048807144,
0.6678999066352844,
0.43633976578712463,
-0.20348405838012695,
0.06563738733530045,
-0.047743991017341614,
-0.8098081350326538,
0.13490676879882812,
-0.6413431167602539,
0.7620158195495605,
0.19407059252262115,
-0.1155286580324173,
0.33215197920799255,
-0.6456162929534912,
0.03860773891210556,
0.1609451025724411,
-0.6328079700469971,
-0.3407186269760132,
0.16042670607566833,
-0.04129272699356079,
-0.23550750315189362,
0.421429842710495,
-0.6982195377349854,
0.09263047575950623,
-0.6249409317970276,
0.517611026763916,
0.7483013868331909,
-0.10647290199995041,
0.37560147047042847,
-0.3134012222290039,
0.3836447596549988,
0.0626116469502449,
0.015111404471099377,
-0.7058049440383911,
-0.7097831964492798,
-0.9202201962471008,
-0.3206079304218292,
0.004414318595081568,
0.6584699749946594,
-1.0041536092758179,
0.7122319936752319,
-0.01692386157810688,
-0.22316253185272217,
-0.4645935297012329,
0.16993150115013123,
0.4155188500881195,
0.36591073870658875,
0.2566714286804199,
-0.08061330765485764,
-0.18125109374523163,
-0.5052135586738586,
-0.5086249113082886,
-0.3937534987926483,
-0.35574573278427124,
0.36801183223724365,
0.4621922969818115,
-0.058243028819561005,
0.774015486240387,
-0.7092969417572021,
-0.5667128562927246,
-0.2967032790184021,
0.16604992747306824,
0.09150535613298416,
0.21305440366268158,
0.46134886145591736,
-0.6633750796318054,
-0.7845781445503235,
0.2322245091199875,
-0.6598772406578064,
-0.3429786264896393,
-0.13676723837852478,
-0.06634755432605743,
0.5731736421585083,
0.7928537726402283,
-0.4947110414505005,
0.4028894305229187,
0.22399874031543732,
-0.12771214544773102,
0.501423180103302,
-0.3584432005882263,
0.02398729883134365,
-1.1672930717468262,
-0.1914045810699463,
0.11018788814544678,
-0.2819846272468567,
-0.5807590484619141,
0.3086930215358734,
0.4073956608772278,
-0.05636253580451012,
-0.5027500987052917,
0.45196133852005005,
-0.4871017634868622,
0.1542646437883377,
-0.6574025750160217,
0.504210889339447,
0.094465471804142,
0.5267771482467651,
0.05733169987797737,
1.0977851152420044,
0.18241183459758759,
-0.5870427489280701,
0.2832978665828705,
0.017979279160499573,
-0.5319892764091492,
0.4564901888370514,
-0.47757601737976074,
0.4088205099105835,
-0.0440552793443203,
0.14437799155712128,
-1.1467022895812988,
-0.1748371422290802,
0.5793371796607971,
-0.697003185749054,
0.23869559168815613,
-0.07069173455238342,
-0.6822108030319214,
-0.18496665358543396,
-0.42987060546875,
0.05787663906812668,
0.4147815704345703,
-0.7912882566452026,
0.48588889837265015,
0.1766541302204132,
0.09659525007009506,
-0.36990121006965637,
-0.7833721041679382,
0.13781851530075073,
-0.16323889791965485,
-0.7228350639343262,
0.5083362460136414,
-0.19487717747688293,
0.01966055855154991,
-0.02554144337773323,
-0.06125587224960327,
-0.23361513018608093,
0.2068583071231842,
-0.18744531273841858,
0.3377683758735657,
-0.5566544532775879,
0.17798346281051636,
0.1353747844696045,
-0.027535149827599525,
0.03634878620505333,
-0.4032110571861267,
0.6283614635467529,
0.1522262990474701,
-0.48968079686164856,
-0.4898773729801178,
0.07373157143592834,
0.21359442174434662,
-0.4886009693145752,
0.494951069355011,
0.9535534977912903,
-0.29789429903030396,
-0.519648015499115,
-0.1768052726984024,
-0.02300262451171875,
-0.5552798509597778,
0.31668955087661743,
-0.022652706131339073,
-0.9331576228141785,
0.06186977028846741,
0.08389544486999512,
0.16688504815101624,
0.2085925042629242,
0.753804087638855,
-0.15092794597148895,
0.9599300026893616,
0.6860789060592651,
-0.32580795884132385,
0.6906800270080566,
0.13089673221111298,
0.3413623571395874,
-0.6384561657905579,
0.16243919730186462,
-0.522807776927948,
0.040086597204208374,
-0.45782116055488586,
-0.3395352065563202,
0.3202201724052429,
-0.23952117562294006,
-0.24575665593147278,
0.21629707515239716,
-0.6496490240097046,
0.8743383288383484,
0.7161391377449036,
0.38094109296798706,
0.536431610584259,
-0.0723186656832695,
0.2512461245059967,
0.17550237476825714,
-0.37445276975631714,
-0.6230142712593079,
1.136169672012329,
0.1319531947374344,
0.7452722787857056,
-0.05954691395163536,
0.7637661695480347,
0.37875375151634216,
0.3028861880302429,
-0.8764421343803406,
0.5994182825088501,
-0.5659568309783936,
-0.34461477398872375,
-0.1640813946723938,
-0.2539299428462982,
-0.8815348744392395,
0.2830658555030823,
-0.0340115986764431,
-0.658880352973938,
-0.4477839171886444,
0.07915626466274261,
-0.2010851353406906,
0.39642253518104553,
-0.6541160941123962,
0.7278032898902893,
-0.32474228739738464,
0.07485970854759216,
-0.022730425000190735,
-0.25283464789390564,
0.5252890586853027,
-0.028268083930015564,
-0.06464777141809464,
-0.19767722487449646,
-0.07772534340620041,
0.35202163457870483,
-0.2577473223209381,
0.9396834373474121,
0.023835962638258934,
-0.5871965289115906,
0.5323664546012878,
-0.16119585931301117,
0.573346734046936,
-0.03134206682443619,
0.010454365983605385,
0.06674093753099442,
-0.4685104787349701,
-0.24915467202663422,
-0.38501349091529846,
0.5971320867538452,
-0.6759979128837585,
-0.7543259263038635,
-0.29176175594329834,
-0.7314133644104004,
0.17053408920764923,
0.5049753785133362,
0.6326606273651123,
0.2837534248828888,
-0.2226727157831192,
0.009216612204909325,
0.9042791724205017,
-0.5654041767120361,
0.4914827346801758,
0.7450897693634033,
-0.2512139081954956,
-0.17004533112049103,
0.9399137496948242,
-0.392267644405365,
0.1720869392156601,
0.7071018815040588,
0.21590228378772736,
-0.02938847802579403,
-0.795206606388092,
-0.6230422258377075,
-0.05093067139387131,
-0.5488678216934204,
-0.23970991373062134,
-0.349128782749176,
-0.45406439900398254,
-0.3785361051559448,
-0.06534743309020996,
0.04768504947423935,
0.09181913733482361,
-0.6715772151947021,
0.2861730456352234,
0.19177770614624023,
0.39239269495010376,
0.3922872543334961,
0.7464282512664795,
-0.8116629123687744,
0.5835177302360535,
-0.08842650800943375,
0.2290043979883194,
-0.16707868874073029,
-0.8433917760848999,
-0.4058935046195984,
0.02624537982046604,
-0.5526643395423889,
-0.42188704013824463,
0.5273117423057556,
0.3562356233596802,
0.4247523546218872,
0.5807102918624878,
0.3768852949142456,
0.22261574864387512,
-0.4547276198863983,
0.8382994532585144,
-0.2196504771709442,
-0.9171860218048096,
0.6731910705566406,
-0.454759418964386,
0.4011479914188385,
0.04674669727683067,
0.0467582605779171,
-0.36962658166885376,
-0.6495153903961182,
0.04087008535861969,
-0.6166123747825623,
0.961615264415741,
0.19682452082633972,
0.3389085829257965,
0.04218093678355217,
0.3564589023590088,
-0.055673472583293915,
0.0029849098064005375,
-0.8150960206985474,
-0.09814568608999252,
0.014724517241120338,
-0.49510422348976135,
0.08050248771905899,
-0.16035062074661255,
0.1976243555545807,
0.23222555220127106,
0.6179738640785217,
-0.2811049818992615,
0.33658960461616516,
0.01971701718866825,
-0.2507064640522003,
-0.16585740447044373,
0.10973764210939407,
0.6551990509033203,
0.14131271839141846,
-0.20983682572841644,
-0.10925239324569702,
-0.14118437469005585,
-0.6839591264724731,
-0.12332450598478317,
-0.013869117945432663,
-0.36246317625045776,
-0.06119976565241814,
0.6042765974998474,
0.6133284568786621,
-0.21238358318805695,
-0.7960739731788635,
0.5560097694396973,
-0.20494477450847626,
-0.17912442982196808,
-0.3915802240371704,
0.40101638436317444,
-0.011286796070635319,
0.2160344421863556,
0.28810855746269226,
-0.06467052549123764,
0.058726027607917786,
-0.34818148612976074,
0.2108181118965149,
0.577243983745575,
-0.2266434282064438,
-0.02476808987557888,
0.7228151559829712,
0.3250773251056671,
-0.6117043495178223,
0.7837848663330078,
-0.20376679301261902,
-0.6644848585128784,
0.8030985593795776,
0.7259771227836609,
0.9379400610923767,
0.010057022795081139,
0.16888605058193207,
-0.017805974930524826,
0.5267950892448425,
0.0560075007379055,
0.12190143018960953,
-0.10542058944702148,
-1.1756688356399536,
-0.2853637635707855,
-0.19873039424419403,
-0.48272705078125,
0.4114364981651306,
-0.48517054319381714,
0.494653582572937,
-0.32890960574150085,
0.03693308308720589,
-0.19285742938518524,
0.0032762892078608274,
-0.16221849620342255,
-0.06724058091640472,
0.48107367753982544,
0.9646132588386536,
-0.3971913158893585,
1.106170654296875,
0.5465549826622009,
-0.22923988103866577,
-0.32057711482048035,
0.6043975353240967,
0.10645460337400436,
-1.244749665260315,
0.3747783303260803,
0.6103410720825195,
-0.22451287508010864,
0.12963303923606873,
-0.7509721517562866,
-0.36857208609580994,
1.0747084617614746,
0.3660939335823059,
-0.5076825022697449,
0.020218990743160248,
0.23151229321956635,
0.5866590738296509,
-0.28874802589416504,
0.28622400760650635,
0.5654749274253845,
0.3093355596065521,
-0.1824965626001358,
-0.6674061417579651,
-0.15885724127292633,
-0.21413961052894592,
-0.236119344830513,
0.32520923018455505,
-0.6788772344589233,
0.9544582366943359,
-0.07494381070137024,
-0.40533119440078735,
0.44908514618873596,
0.6538748145103455,
0.29016509652137756,
0.6010996103286743,
0.31760841608047485,
0.42942553758621216,
0.6737568974494934,
-0.06878076493740082,
0.9102879762649536,
-0.45609939098358154,
0.11987386643886566,
0.92146897315979,
-0.32882705330848694,
0.7203217148780823,
-0.03360336273908615,
0.048401910811662674,
0.4432995617389679,
0.630315899848938,
-0.2142985612154007,
0.38192304968833923,
0.2793683409690857,
-0.43716615438461304,
-0.2976086139678955,
-0.11046098172664642,
-0.20982816815376282,
0.3807799220085144,
0.4230094254016876,
-0.4006190598011017,
-0.2720549702644348,
-0.14300978183746338,
0.0672474205493927,
0.3447222411632538,
-0.39686915278434753,
0.6583451628684998,
0.025810573250055313,
-0.6185058355331421,
0.4915977716445923,
0.3012581765651703,
1.1617003679275513,
-0.5440860986709595,
0.04929548129439354,
-0.31903374195098877,
0.5004594922065735,
-0.06330639868974686,
-0.9180995225906372,
-0.12156923115253448,
0.2520084083080292,
0.052515313029289246,
-0.10418034344911575,
1.1900159120559692,
-0.6062642335891724,
-0.2859615981578827,
0.19572673738002777,
0.3482555150985718,
0.22109557688236237,
-0.3449227213859558,
-0.4373544752597809,
-0.05855274945497513,
0.08466178178787231,
-0.14167527854442596,
0.44977298378944397,
0.7894240021705627,
0.054323259741067886,
0.5599583983421326,
0.6747180223464966,
-0.14209452271461487,
0.036194927990436554,
0.0751371756196022,
0.8213404417037964,
-0.5081914067268372,
-0.3372464179992676,
-1.0729620456695557,
0.13363201916217804,
-0.03728542849421501,
-0.3856276273727417,
0.7150483131408691,
0.5300161838531494,
1.0976835489273071,
-0.1283845603466034,
0.9422678351402283,
0.26142990589141846,
0.2884993553161621,
-0.8268935680389404,
0.9114207029342651,
-0.5884497761726379,
0.4941025376319885,
-0.04216896742582321,
-0.6570556163787842,
-0.40572085976600647,
0.3962157964706421,
-0.1994573324918747,
-0.11255107074975967,
0.4939557909965515,
0.9002034068107605,
0.05218696594238281,
-0.04337023198604584,
0.3737340271472931,
-0.19630037248134613,
0.6437361836433411,
0.8448627591133118,
0.9001649022102356,
-0.487207293510437,
0.8934112191200256,
0.08547928184270859,
-0.09710486978292465,
-0.29490238428115845,
-0.9487360119819641,
-1.3341865539550781,
-0.26538345217704773,
-0.15702442824840546,
0.07619427144527435,
-0.011065639555454254,
0.5020793676376343,
0.38880133628845215,
-0.8356067538261414,
-0.10410171002149582,
-0.1890246570110321,
0.12251037359237671,
-0.01861460506916046,
-0.261306494474411,
0.4485887885093689,
-0.6297640204429626,
-0.9868041276931763,
0.5627419948577881,
0.3330104351043701,
-0.011816629208624363,
-0.15751974284648895,
-0.09466515481472015,
-0.09857182949781418,
0.2203262597322464,
0.6038525700569153,
0.06592745333909988,
-0.6546103954315186,
-0.2526406943798065,
0.1288689523935318,
-0.3015308976173401,
0.18782348930835724,
0.8396760821342468,
-0.47453373670578003,
0.33794519305229187,
0.5279269218444824,
0.6418120861053467,
0.28947338461875916,
0.08062858879566193,
0.483658105134964,
-0.8794198036193848,
0.08808774501085281,
0.03883844614028931,
0.23374979197978973,
0.25370892882347107,
-0.6990894675254822,
0.39648422598838806,
0.1069178581237793,
-0.7808714509010315,
-0.8323568105697632,
0.35812556743621826,
-0.6413428783416748,
-0.511552631855011,
0.9994813203811646,
-0.4712769091129303,
-0.1523323804140091,
-0.08293598145246506,
-0.5588610172271729,
0.28612998127937317,
-0.6086758971214294,
0.7393364906311035,
0.6175235509872437,
-0.10915227234363556,
-0.2390117198228836,
-0.33096933364868164,
0.31179314851760864,
0.23967212438583374,
-0.9391815662384033,
0.12380706518888474,
0.36600160598754883,
-0.031014010310173035,
-0.091214619576931,
0.7592475414276123,
0.04097567871212959,
0.30307528376579285,
-0.08047425746917725,
0.09694679826498032,
-0.3734654188156128,
-0.17293858528137207,
-0.15561458468437195,
-0.19341319799423218,
0.14036992192268372,
-0.5176566243171692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01155v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01155v3 | CABINET: Content Relevance based Noise Reduction for Table Question Answering | 2024-02-02T05:48:39 | 2024-02-13T09:11:01 | Sohan Patnaik, Heril Changwal, Milan Aggarwal, Sumit Bhatia, Yaman Kumar, Balaji Krishnamurthy | cs.CL | cs.CL | Table understanding capability of Large Language Models (LLMs) has been
extensively studied through the task of question-answering (QA) over tables.
Typically, only a small part of the whole table is relevant to derive the
answer for a given question. The irrelevant parts act as noise and are
distracting information, resulting in sub-optimal performance due to the
vulnerability of LLMs to noise. To mitigate this, we propose CABINET (Content
RelevAnce-Based NoIse ReductioN for TablE QuesTion-Answering) - a framework to
enable LLMs to focus on relevant tabular data by suppressing extraneous
information. CABINET comprises an Unsupervised Relevance Scorer (URS), trained
differentially with the QA LLM, that weighs the table content based on its
relevance to the input question before feeding it to the question-answering LLM
(QA LLM). To further aid the relevance scorer, CABINET employs a weakly
supervised module that generates a parsing statement describing the criteria of
rows and columns relevant to the question and highlights the content of
corresponding table cells. CABINET significantly outperforms various tabular
LLM baselines, as well as GPT3-based in-context learning methods, is more
robust to noise, maintains outperformance on tables of varying sizes, and
establishes new SoTA performance on WikiTQ, FeTaQA, and WikiSQL datasets. We
release our code and datasets at https://github.com/Sohanpatnaik106/CABINET_QA. | [
-0.29231739044189453,
-1.032323956489563,
0.705129086971283,
-0.049722351133823395,
-0.4671538174152374,
-0.09357401728630066,
-0.10016123205423355,
-0.041141293942928314,
0.09213429689407349,
0.9149680733680725,
-0.5429266095161438,
-1.0180683135986328,
-0.13401105999946594,
-0.18016290664672852,
-0.6808295249938965,
0.8128207325935364,
0.3387300372123718,
0.1799868941307068,
-0.8575074672698975,
0.04309817776083946,
-0.7843325734138489,
-0.15855373442173004,
-0.377259224653244,
-0.05935738608241081,
0.4053955674171448,
0.6935300230979919,
0.5980109572410583,
0.5205574631690979,
0.6021446585655212,
0.1619337499141693,
-0.2623569667339325,
0.02726416289806366,
-0.5690012574195862,
0.292315810918808,
-0.2926754653453827,
-0.570300817489624,
-0.4751617908477783,
-0.432973712682724,
0.2761256992816925,
0.4029587507247925,
-0.3860546350479126,
0.3065718114376068,
0.14734715223312378,
0.5760373473167419,
-0.3861921727657318,
0.656463086605072,
-1.0503137111663818,
0.11412376165390015,
-0.4108782708644867,
-0.2687183618545532,
-0.5866215825080872,
-0.21609212458133698,
-0.3395114839076996,
-0.5215712785720825,
0.125373974442482,
0.04323793575167656,
0.7733110189437866,
0.34227728843688965,
-0.36310091614723206,
-0.053667571395635605,
-0.6363804340362549,
0.5324909687042236,
-0.6343004107475281,
0.5460799932479858,
0.5429625511169434,
0.17668725550174713,
-0.22424137592315674,
-0.7922832369804382,
-0.5166921615600586,
0.028054477646946907,
-0.3543488383293152,
0.25482386350631714,
0.1115502342581749,
0.16460129618644714,
0.2634764313697815,
0.47035500407218933,
-0.7795076966285706,
-0.12946616113185883,
-0.35001567006111145,
-0.24883587658405304,
0.19775116443634033,
0.21793386340141296,
0.09998784214258194,
-0.23044437170028687,
0.10512842237949371,
-0.029467670246958733,
-0.8022951483726501,
0.19243943691253662,
-0.12009409070014954,
0.22931928932666779,
0.020369254052639008,
0.3235015571117401,
-0.3869483768939972,
0.8345635533332825,
-0.24138574302196503,
-0.299628883600235,
-0.05954649671912193,
-0.3362845182418823,
-0.00444444827735424,
-0.22419427335262299,
0.5030919909477234,
0.15272806584835052,
-0.17813408374786377,
-0.3399156630039215,
-0.15300212800502777,
0.16448478400707245,
0.3352546691894531,
-0.6728004813194275,
-0.15640461444854736,
0.05849241092801094,
-0.35805225372314453,
-0.2140888124704361,
0.06363671272993088,
-1.042054295539856,
-0.279498815536499,
-0.17142832279205322,
0.512855052947998,
0.12532654404640198,
0.24193011224269867,
-0.22599062323570251,
0.3452675938606262,
0.42193788290023804,
0.4575173854827881,
-0.7078967690467834,
0.5628893971443176,
0.637639582157135,
0.4819357693195343,
-0.469256192445755,
0.3117583394050598,
-0.9454752802848816,
0.2731625735759735,
-0.32950809597969055,
0.7760968804359436,
-0.44092029333114624,
-0.45383498072624207,
0.06698243319988251,
-0.038904353976249695,
0.34477582573890686,
-0.8040320873260498,
0.7926483750343323,
-0.8649940490722656,
-0.007961875759065151,
-0.5385174751281738,
-0.21008580923080444,
-0.017160607501864433,
0.24348828196525574,
-0.6892223358154297,
0.953100323677063,
0.28923019766807556,
-0.33775460720062256,
0.6131191253662109,
-0.5505788326263428,
-0.6997150778770447,
-0.0707535520195961,
-0.23996400833129883,
-0.7844198346138,
0.04304448887705803,
0.5118952989578247,
0.2785381078720093,
-0.47500842809677124,
0.471264123916626,
-0.03263935446739197,
-0.5091335773468018,
0.12012039124965668,
-0.2587137520313263,
0.03082563541829586,
0.25347840785980225,
-0.09780867397785187,
0.3220359683036804,
-0.547309160232544,
0.10332876443862915,
-0.2521282732486725,
-0.43024665117263794,
0.26472872495651245,
-0.029026217758655548,
-0.24038125574588776,
0.26396697759628296,
0.108200803399086,
-0.40748322010040283,
-0.22895747423171997,
-0.2575623691082001,
0.30732524394989014,
0.49576863646507263,
0.27704599499702454,
0.3660607933998108,
-0.4647761285305023,
0.5377122759819031,
0.30287352204322815,
0.2813507914543152,
0.21869097650051117,
-0.6316364407539368,
-0.5343242287635803,
-0.10742168128490448,
0.49121004343032837,
0.5685995221138,
-0.8747483491897583,
0.19076864421367645,
-0.2695876955986023,
-0.10601379722356796,
-0.40125611424446106,
0.4438021183013916,
0.4130009710788727,
0.8218105435371399,
0.7374725937843323,
-0.4201107323169708,
-0.4841379225254059,
-0.8316810727119446,
-0.22842161357402802,
-0.16486535966396332,
-0.05646929889917374,
0.5500994324684143,
0.22343787550926208,
0.22450968623161316,
1.0026966333389282,
-0.5878297090530396,
-0.6441487073898315,
-0.3461270034313202,
-0.13887818157672882,
0.5193065404891968,
0.26746416091918945,
0.07412876933813095,
-0.8666044473648071,
-0.6904551386833191,
-0.007000007200986147,
-0.5340068936347961,
-0.2875221371650696,
0.14847935736179352,
-0.3497108519077301,
0.03879197686910629,
0.7270866632461548,
-0.807998776435852,
0.8327277898788452,
-0.00045512584620155394,
-0.0427573025226593,
0.16688701510429382,
0.2157358080148697,
0.010145960375666618,
-1.1066056489944458,
0.02448597364127636,
-0.5592626333236694,
-0.2140434980392456,
-0.6130985021591187,
0.017156297340989113,
0.12388446182012558,
-0.3173535168170929,
-0.5099398493766785,
0.4616644084453583,
-0.4503152072429657,
-0.3085636496543884,
0.024483904242515564,
0.46792060136795044,
0.3633142113685608,
0.6285846829414368,
0.00442842859774828,
1.0273569822311401,
0.4133089780807495,
-0.685276985168457,
0.06838595867156982,
0.5753626227378845,
-0.4217960238456726,
0.5042412877082825,
-0.36943838000297546,
0.11951398104429245,
-0.004420080222189426,
-0.03544902056455612,
-1.1558597087860107,
0.05344097688794136,
0.2687303125858307,
-0.21209728717803955,
0.52956622838974,
-0.1643776297569275,
-0.4706087112426758,
-0.4369680881500244,
-0.3211001753807068,
0.20390290021896362,
0.5308136343955994,
-0.3775618076324463,
0.540921688079834,
0.6089876294136047,
-0.12996910512447357,
-0.6128630042076111,
-0.8365278244018555,
-0.09962303191423416,
-0.00367052317596972,
-0.3439488410949707,
0.5858559608459473,
-0.08475886285305023,
-0.23332564532756805,
0.005882804747670889,
-0.6551658511161804,
-0.25171682238578796,
0.0913645476102829,
0.09332103282213211,
0.14353971183300018,
-0.2997457981109619,
0.5466092824935913,
0.14458543062210083,
0.06869113445281982,
0.23000194132328033,
-0.21159245073795319,
0.6002848148345947,
0.003450605319812894,
-0.3155931234359741,
-0.2966877520084381,
0.1501944363117218,
0.2827186584472656,
-0.2839008867740631,
0.917655885219574,
0.7000834941864014,
-0.1479341983795166,
-0.10304097086191177,
-0.7502924799919128,
-0.4502408504486084,
-0.47250527143478394,
0.6296060085296631,
-0.34915345907211304,
-0.8357675671577454,
0.8484066724777222,
0.2642365097999573,
0.035816967487335205,
0.2847791016101837,
0.3230670392513275,
-0.037798769772052765,
0.5101107954978943,
0.11205669492483139,
-0.1475779265165329,
0.3937426209449768,
-0.04698342829942703,
0.24377970397472382,
-0.8549829721450806,
-0.34393957257270813,
-0.6893019676208496,
-0.2682347297668457,
-0.3937839865684509,
-0.5666516423225403,
0.476983904838562,
-0.24335241317749023,
0.2565152943134308,
0.04537605866789818,
-0.6313720345497131,
0.6841174364089966,
0.4332045316696167,
0.41915878653526306,
0.5779405832290649,
-0.019916346296668053,
0.11515341699123383,
-0.0011713352287188172,
-0.7422369718551636,
-0.09502726048231125,
1.2370574474334717,
-0.10995414108037949,
1.0857276916503906,
0.2717010974884033,
0.5507918000221252,
0.4624825417995453,
0.4730713963508606,
-0.6432529091835022,
0.8156651854515076,
-0.2773642838001251,
-0.42804503440856934,
-0.5417757630348206,
-0.8647670745849609,
-0.9112800359725952,
0.20733343064785004,
-0.07972210645675659,
-0.7296801805496216,
0.07963168621063232,
-0.09659668803215027,
-0.2398427426815033,
0.3122718632221222,
-0.5397079586982727,
0.9394879937171936,
0.09971072524785995,
-0.6220621466636658,
-0.1656646579504013,
-0.4578803479671478,
0.2788373529911041,
0.05122719705104828,
0.19301660358905792,
0.038016196340322495,
0.08770431578159332,
0.8221390247344971,
-0.34373918175697327,
0.6254900693893433,
-0.24023228883743286,
-0.08251306414604187,
0.6252605319023132,
0.23017741739749908,
0.5092211961746216,
0.4649495780467987,
-0.18576838076114655,
-0.0718427374958992,
-0.03477572649717331,
-0.16047009825706482,
-0.645979106426239,
0.7182773947715759,
-0.43120789527893066,
-1.0471923351287842,
0.1400110274553299,
-0.8380953669548035,
-0.3307236433029175,
-0.015107590705156326,
0.133149191737175,
0.6301788091659546,
-0.06497173011302948,
0.628466010093689,
0.862831175327301,
0.009649774990975857,
0.18385636806488037,
0.4888303279876709,
-0.244116872549057,
-0.23711137473583221,
0.7285841703414917,
0.34798282384872437,
-0.08814001083374023,
1.0216386318206787,
0.14671599864959717,
-0.7138903737068176,
-0.7773179411888123,
-0.13476471602916718,
-0.10822608321905136,
-0.8339164853096008,
-0.7901473045349121,
-0.5839587450027466,
-0.237341046333313,
-0.32974058389663696,
0.2038038820028305,
0.16119247674942017,
-0.4896840453147888,
-0.5294777750968933,
-0.14457345008850098,
0.45156019926071167,
0.5768397450447083,
0.33854761719703674,
0.45752230286598206,
-0.6401647329330444,
0.5984566807746887,
0.8241137266159058,
0.45772257447242737,
-0.27362969517707825,
-1.0619856119155884,
-0.23221325874328613,
-0.21314401924610138,
-0.4867972433567047,
-0.9701511263847351,
0.27296531200408936,
0.39219048619270325,
0.6943731904029846,
0.10123606026172638,
0.32483166456222534,
0.5631304979324341,
-0.014201442711055279,
0.6095454692840576,
-0.31472793221473694,
-1.1161751747131348,
0.6611539125442505,
-0.30984604358673096,
0.5487683415412903,
0.8948212265968323,
-0.32923707365989685,
-0.07286813855171204,
-0.4923093914985657,
-0.4052192270755768,
-0.8576590418815613,
0.7954541444778442,
0.18283811211585999,
-0.11096576601266861,
-0.01872132159769535,
0.5228443741798401,
0.1003679558634758,
0.5765041708946228,
-1.071652889251709,
0.01422965433448553,
0.14333675801753998,
-0.2467634230852127,
0.33504921197891235,
-0.39718660712242126,
-0.022453339770436287,
-0.2737795114517212,
0.7682830691337585,
-0.2410142719745636,
0.20255951583385468,
0.13888362050056458,
-0.4359470307826996,
-0.132550910115242,
0.7114580869674683,
0.529242217540741,
0.7269548177719116,
-0.2318240851163864,
0.08543772250413895,
0.623777449131012,
-0.5890867114067078,
-0.10513868182897568,
-0.20135809481143951,
-0.4710216522216797,
0.1319492608308792,
-0.06603897362947464,
0.4195316731929779,
0.22010070085525513,
-0.39760109782218933,
0.47392305731773376,
-0.22411684691905975,
-0.15513190627098083,
0.03687477856874466,
0.05705992132425308,
0.1669246107339859,
-0.047149088233709335,
0.16115103662014008,
-0.21805354952812195,
0.347726434469223,
-0.6969959735870361,
0.6111670136451721,
0.4636904001235962,
-0.5572726726531982,
0.011454861611127853,
0.6397497057914734,
0.026214733719825745,
-0.3277566134929657,
0.6085640788078308,
-0.36090609431266785,
-0.3093709647655487,
0.6324387192726135,
0.4457872807979584,
0.4464452266693115,
-0.10260134935379028,
0.38691356778144836,
0.1907540112733841,
0.27268466353416443,
0.11003443598747253,
0.6697235107421875,
-0.38247981667518616,
-0.42124471068382263,
-0.37828540802001953,
-0.6694568395614624,
-0.5461497902870178,
0.29824233055114746,
-0.779255211353302,
0.12097690999507904,
-0.46131178736686707,
-0.16045649349689484,
-0.5070604681968689,
-0.015730634331703186,
-0.5078884959220886,
0.1528865396976471,
-0.39019060134887695,
0.5955083966255188,
-0.5014888644218445,
0.6805071234703064,
0.384131520986557,
-0.21673771739006042,
-0.7737662196159363,
0.16150322556495667,
-0.28876134753227234,
-0.504263162612915,
0.4293068051338196,
-0.04925379529595375,
0.15157806873321533,
-0.07053861021995544,
-0.3825223445892334,
-0.6446985602378845,
1.076967477798462,
0.5457276701927185,
-0.4921518862247467,
0.363608717918396,
0.4249935448169708,
0.48521125316619873,
-0.048989780247211456,
0.2983647286891937,
0.697019636631012,
0.5592017769813538,
0.08401854336261749,
-0.6899508833885193,
0.1340104043483734,
-0.09727322310209274,
-0.3591625392436981,
0.34605956077575684,
-0.6630351543426514,
0.7666099667549133,
-0.0026112631894648075,
-0.08919437229633331,
0.07077481597661972,
0.6388885378837585,
0.02383306249976158,
0.4827638268470764,
0.2967867851257324,
0.621389627456665,
0.7138018608093262,
-0.5901145339012146,
0.5028332471847534,
-0.20653042197227478,
0.11083129048347473,
1.291638731956482,
-0.3856334686279297,
0.7378114461898804,
0.5185988545417786,
-0.29705604910850525,
0.3528536558151245,
0.316758930683136,
0.10146544873714447,
0.6248874068260193,
0.43442875146865845,
-0.16701336205005646,
-0.26743173599243164,
-0.43552693724632263,
-0.42369043827056885,
0.46808722615242004,
0.4877215325832367,
-0.13374720513820648,
-0.22609993815422058,
-0.26047059893608093,
-0.24502070248126984,
0.22337158024311066,
-0.43958401679992676,
1.1544880867004395,
0.20821592211723328,
-0.49548304080963135,
0.3532278537750244,
-0.4624704420566559,
0.13987472653388977,
-0.6435267329216003,
-0.16180606186389923,
-0.5553962588310242,
-0.19020292162895203,
-0.2881731390953064,
-0.9964037537574768,
0.42669010162353516,
-0.261322557926178,
-0.17782297730445862,
-0.13508830964565277,
0.6295554041862488,
-0.47665804624557495,
-0.16624753177165985,
0.11696543544530869,
0.7564919590950012,
0.02158639207482338,
-0.26317358016967773,
-0.3903157413005829,
-0.09548556059598923,
-0.07748929411172867,
-0.0936775654554367,
0.4338146150112152,
0.6288381814956665,
0.02177133783698082,
0.6191722750663757,
0.6347907781600952,
-0.0029412764124572277,
-0.2591524124145508,
0.2855728566646576,
1.071532964706421,
-0.44295647740364075,
-0.759463906288147,
-0.5877984166145325,
0.19751544296741486,
-0.18481238186359406,
-0.12563519179821014,
0.400884747505188,
0.7257435321807861,
0.5362136960029602,
-0.3274780809879303,
0.016011228784918785,
0.14993052184581757,
0.4470495879650116,
-0.9683063626289368,
0.8215910196304321,
-0.5682752132415771,
0.8650290966033936,
-0.34709057211875916,
-1.0297908782958984,
-0.4394678771495819,
0.41998425126075745,
-0.3937525451183319,
0.1319364607334137,
0.7154969573020935,
1.2414987087249756,
0.0037452776450663805,
0.01693413406610489,
0.7740930318832397,
0.3399595320224762,
0.02095259726047516,
0.3256450891494751,
0.8357603549957275,
-0.48157405853271484,
1.1730268001556396,
-0.23102064430713654,
0.30591121315956116,
-0.14239366352558136,
-0.39571020007133484,
-0.8164581060409546,
-0.5225526094436646,
-0.22834736108779907,
-0.22789238393306732,
0.15568329393863678,
0.3230597674846649,
0.8835868239402771,
-1.1238175630569458,
-0.28581807017326355,
-0.21454329788684845,
0.6482630968093872,
-0.07602544128894806,
-0.3639550507068634,
0.5752447843551636,
-0.322099894285202,
-0.10308001935482025,
0.3456537425518036,
0.3177114427089691,
-0.3898286819458008,
0.14714974164962769,
0.24926511943340302,
-0.15090009570121765,
0.04753737151622772,
0.4573659300804138,
0.046664003282785416,
-0.5680500268936157,
-0.15582679212093353,
0.0731983333826065,
0.025038566440343857,
0.5271233320236206,
0.5922735929489136,
-0.8028782606124878,
0.08295538276433945,
0.518953800201416,
0.6645668745040894,
0.6889671087265015,
0.16744324564933777,
0.09331021457910538,
-1.0455225706100464,
0.09097820520401001,
0.4217258393764496,
0.4105907678604126,
0.12705808877944946,
-0.874514102935791,
0.6667636632919312,
0.1052553802728653,
-0.6174098253250122,
-0.799018919467926,
0.28122273087501526,
-1.0186288356781006,
-0.07831206172704697,
0.771530270576477,
0.05065028741955757,
-0.5119271874427795,
-0.5155935287475586,
-0.28850916028022766,
0.09994373470544815,
-0.8359495401382446,
1.021254301071167,
0.5058315396308899,
0.029230201616883278,
-0.463992178440094,
-0.5420222282409668,
0.6376383304595947,
0.7844310402870178,
-1.2706514596939087,
0.18644773960113525,
0.24562790989875793,
-0.19297485053539276,
0.14784349501132965,
0.4792596101760864,
-0.376259982585907,
0.6290780305862427,
-0.17275577783584595,
-0.04079756885766983,
0.051197510212659836,
-0.438211590051651,
-0.028135215863585472,
0.45023539662361145,
0.28358352184295654,
-0.051263801753520966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01152v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01152v2 | AccentFold: A Journey through African Accents for Zero-Shot ASR Adaptation to Target Accents | 2024-02-02T05:38:59 | 2024-02-05T05:45:59 | Abraham Toluwase Owodunni, Aditya Yadavalli, Chris Chinenye Emezue, Tobi Olatunji, Clinton C Mbataku | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Despite advancements in speech recognition, accented speech remains
challenging. While previous approaches have focused on modeling techniques or
creating accented speech datasets, gathering sufficient data for the multitude
of accents, particularly in the African context, remains impractical due to
their sheer diversity and associated budget constraints. To address these
challenges, we propose AccentFold, a method that exploits spatial relationships
between learned accent embeddings to improve downstream Automatic Speech
Recognition (ASR). Our exploratory analysis of speech embeddings representing
100+ African accents reveals interesting spatial accent relationships
highlighting geographic and genealogical similarities, capturing consistent
phonological, and morphological regularities, all learned empirically from
speech. Furthermore, we discover accent relationships previously
uncharacterized by the Ethnologue. Through empirical evaluation, we demonstrate
the effectiveness of AccentFold by showing that, for out-of-distribution (OOD)
accents, sampling accent subsets for training based on AccentFold information
outperforms strong baselines a relative WER improvement of 4.6%. AccentFold
presents a promising approach for improving ASR performance on accented speech,
particularly in the context of African accents, where data scarcity and budget
constraints pose significant challenges. Our findings emphasize the potential
of leveraging linguistic relationships to improve zero-shot ASR adaptation to
target accents. | [
-0.5876481533050537,
-0.42064404487609863,
0.4149656891822815,
-0.11089934408664703,
-0.04329619184136391,
0.18323083221912384,
-0.30338054895401,
-0.37767428159713745,
0.6988217234611511,
0.5910733938217163,
-0.6428592801094055,
-0.5760913491249084,
-0.490515798330307,
-0.02591363899409771,
-0.06120559945702553,
0.688218355178833,
-0.10250876098871231,
0.06671218574047089,
0.1619621068239212,
-0.861717700958252,
-0.3238997757434845,
-0.7865160703659058,
-0.4926278591156006,
-0.22494558990001678,
0.5480632185935974,
0.8284491300582886,
0.40919163823127747,
0.6247307062149048,
0.06095772236585617,
0.19948330521583557,
-0.1036996841430664,
0.2820245623588562,
-0.3329925835132599,
0.2658791244029999,
0.033387940376996994,
-0.1811714470386505,
-0.1502056121826172,
-0.31348633766174316,
0.4410754442214966,
1.0975338220596313,
-0.1602286547422409,
0.0634649246931076,
-0.060093946754932404,
0.45437532663345337,
-0.646477460861206,
-0.054841555655002594,
-0.721782386302948,
-0.0638633444905281,
-0.32821741700172424,
-0.14154037833213806,
0.306071937084198,
-0.2861415147781372,
0.13407963514328003,
-0.42904824018478394,
0.5460619330406189,
0.11690408736467361,
0.5559555292129517,
0.15329277515411377,
-0.3910686671733856,
-0.40349283814430237,
-0.651190996170044,
0.242292582988739,
-0.3761453628540039,
0.32097822427749634,
0.3778698444366455,
0.6640427708625793,
-0.16365446150302887,
-0.3577987849712372,
-0.5620564222335815,
-0.09554433822631836,
0.3836858570575714,
-0.08672130852937698,
0.2308673858642578,
0.03523169830441475,
0.12455683946609497,
0.5154146552085876,
-0.4744693636894226,
-0.060614537447690964,
-0.42494603991508484,
-0.2510673403739929,
0.8417123556137085,
-0.2367440164089203,
0.6383516788482666,
0.06738796085119247,
-0.11162475496530533,
-0.28070396184921265,
-0.8109760880470276,
0.11674138903617859,
0.4466867446899414,
1.0458897352218628,
-0.17667390406131744,
0.5266481637954712,
-0.1971425861120224,
0.174702450633049,
0.24684059619903564,
0.2695397436618805,
0.42836886644363403,
0.13891202211380005,
0.26979804039001465,
0.6466532945632935,
0.28063929080963135,
0.034035950899124146,
0.47753816843032837,
-0.19168038666248322,
-0.037424467504024506,
-0.3760209083557129,
0.31548890471458435,
-0.5828906297683716,
-0.2878652811050415,
0.22137391567230225,
-0.0533384308218956,
0.37632572650909424,
-0.08315539360046387,
-0.5635871887207031,
-0.40737184882164,
-0.1312684714794159,
0.7283315062522888,
-0.5558685064315796,
-0.2429172247648239,
-0.1434229165315628,
-0.4460175037384033,
0.4613400101661682,
0.1773308664560318,
-1.1148333549499512,
0.49530842900276184,
0.4585757553577423,
1.1690548658370972,
0.06669279932975769,
-0.32149574160575867,
-0.29381075501441956,
0.20001454651355743,
-0.13854070007801056,
0.7690755128860474,
-0.43635496497154236,
-0.6722391247749329,
0.3384684920310974,
0.04617748036980629,
-0.28549492359161377,
-0.5721248984336853,
0.6593140959739685,
-0.35421809554100037,
-0.4001924991607666,
-0.4744037091732025,
-0.20755837857723236,
-0.5351755023002625,
0.049862440675497055,
-0.8329014182090759,
0.8563603162765503,
0.1934056580066681,
-0.008481565862894058,
0.495159387588501,
-0.8604608178138733,
-0.8295533657073975,
-0.03664323315024376,
-0.010011027567088604,
-0.4592011868953705,
0.30816182494163513,
0.6106324195861816,
-0.1578080803155899,
0.2015514373779297,
-0.4927694797515869,
-0.5864583253860474,
-0.2823374271392822,
-0.1926427036523819,
-0.189011350274086,
0.9881742596626282,
-0.019589094445109367,
-0.5160831212997437,
-0.2694028317928314,
-1.0311353206634521,
-0.05047053471207619,
0.17339815199375153,
-0.03300732746720314,
-0.4954870641231537,
-0.016527676954865456,
0.05110256373882294,
-0.03567960485816002,
-0.07064647227525711,
-0.7215774655342102,
0.21049951016902924,
-0.6249443292617798,
0.3561098575592041,
0.3802843689918518,
0.3358236849308014,
0.8569063544273376,
-0.12789326906204224,
0.3226069211959839,
-0.15384338796138763,
-0.09245419502258301,
-0.4020540416240692,
-0.26568466424942017,
-1.0321266651153564,
-0.24162589013576508,
0.021489137783646584,
0.3152717053890228,
-0.4113439619541168,
0.23929785192012787,
-0.3058481812477112,
-0.2605743408203125,
-0.5831009745597839,
0.07096921652555466,
0.17343872785568237,
0.38860270380973816,
0.5177062749862671,
-0.6569211483001709,
-0.4534386694431305,
-0.6392773389816284,
-0.28244203329086304,
-0.06051727011799812,
-0.2974036633968353,
0.7169831395149231,
0.48176994919776917,
0.04864099249243736,
0.7874470353126526,
-0.30425840616226196,
-0.6192213296890259,
-0.07100947201251984,
0.3891597390174866,
0.1717871129512787,
0.3800738751888275,
0.5559127926826477,
-0.6063688397407532,
-0.43934595584869385,
-0.06339726597070694,
-0.10408126562833786,
-0.23525969684123993,
0.11997512727975845,
-0.06988216936588287,
0.039163410663604736,
0.21909809112548828,
-0.23453538119792938,
0.462382048368454,
0.36860090494155884,
-0.24722939729690552,
0.14526107907295227,
-0.08660468459129333,
0.14993849396705627,
-0.6837789416313171,
-0.020074529573321342,
-0.3616647720336914,
-0.050434619188308716,
-0.8376956582069397,
-0.10864882916212082,
-0.2636694610118866,
-0.6137300729751587,
-0.18154989182949066,
0.5565876364707947,
-0.8441972732543945,
-0.43990349769592285,
0.09836146235466003,
-0.03641137480735779,
0.04301980882883072,
0.7117486000061035,
0.2144409865140915,
0.7663653492927551,
0.3979804217815399,
-0.2666710913181305,
-0.08790192753076553,
0.8231878876686096,
-0.221596360206604,
0.8095086216926575,
-0.47113168239593506,
0.6488406658172607,
-0.00033001802512444556,
0.1607569307088852,
-1.140143632888794,
-0.22857117652893066,
0.06756806373596191,
-0.5954743027687073,
0.5667521953582764,
-0.5451794266700745,
0.1204053983092308,
-0.09214711934328079,
-0.18693168461322784,
0.3662753701210022,
0.3583604693412781,
-0.6961997151374817,
0.9026181101799011,
0.6002888083457947,
-0.6429768204689026,
-0.22597700357437134,
-0.7869608998298645,
0.43130168318748474,
-0.08456394821405411,
-0.6115127205848694,
0.17279231548309326,
0.2892206907272339,
-0.11307504773139954,
-0.3093118965625763,
-0.23702751100063324,
-0.3836575448513031,
-0.07670099288225174,
0.43407365679740906,
-0.2838384509086609,
-0.38338664174079895,
-0.12058175355195999,
-0.15399791300296783,
0.2871400713920593,
0.028289588168263435,
-0.5581033825874329,
0.33132222294807434,
0.4718114137649536,
-0.5246517658233643,
0.18801768124103546,
0.8624584674835205,
0.5959888100624084,
-0.34718871116638184,
0.7217336297035217,
0.369821161031723,
-0.28941112756729126,
-0.5778167843818665,
-0.5472027659416199,
-0.1704431027173996,
-0.42408666014671326,
0.18348664045333862,
-0.47288501262664795,
-0.6879943609237671,
0.6545100212097168,
-0.042710091918706894,
-0.0029632234945893288,
0.09552718698978424,
0.20612621307373047,
-0.26951783895492554,
0.6349275708198547,
0.8061281442642212,
-0.08399901539087296,
0.5327089428901672,
-0.3676973879337311,
0.28089800477027893,
-0.9476186037063599,
-0.2980671226978302,
-0.6292551159858704,
-0.3889802098274231,
-0.43516242504119873,
-0.5989823341369629,
0.6518707275390625,
-0.28542378544807434,
-0.43354836106300354,
0.3623250722885132,
-0.17068825662136078,
0.1879812479019165,
0.6203629970550537,
0.1616130918264389,
-0.20966067910194397,
0.3898513615131378,
-0.2668627202510834,
0.08265062421560287,
-0.7998619675636292,
-0.17788353562355042,
0.9053109884262085,
0.08017165958881378,
0.35523083806037903,
0.19290392100811005,
0.6065237522125244,
0.4571673274040222,
-0.04541705548763275,
-0.8481069207191467,
0.10906866937875748,
-0.1517600566148758,
-0.5849562287330627,
-0.5765701532363892,
-0.031397297978401184,
-0.5765535831451416,
0.049448996782302856,
-0.09115175157785416,
-0.7134981155395508,
0.8953284025192261,
0.29419007897377014,
-0.48587796092033386,
0.15921679139137268,
-0.5467132329940796,
0.5462712645530701,
-0.3730066418647766,
-0.3595763146877289,
-0.020890044048428535,
-0.7908447980880737,
-0.2485654652118683,
-0.015146399848163128,
0.011934090405702591,
-0.056895796209573746,
0.14434173703193665,
0.39337673783302307,
-0.8249990344047546,
0.5685150623321533,
-0.45749935507774353,
0.16583475470542908,
0.36227256059646606,
0.011308643035590649,
0.3724011778831482,
-0.5872689485549927,
-0.30029869079589844,
0.842473030090332,
-0.40489184856414795,
-0.4226013123989105,
-0.6667033433914185,
0.48344317078590393,
-0.9016860723495483,
-0.39298710227012634,
-0.23411108553409576,
-0.5261414647102356,
-0.6086952090263367,
0.08243295550346375,
0.10065506398677826,
0.9093523025512695,
-0.5079569220542908,
-0.03294515982270241,
0.5254265069961548,
-0.2024717777967453,
0.3591492772102356,
0.6649739146232605,
0.4892406165599823,
-0.7716558575630188,
0.7334170341491699,
0.4743569493293762,
0.2036444991827011,
0.33395788073539734,
-0.13219040632247925,
-0.6424194574356079,
-0.7538091540336609,
-0.5585678219795227,
0.12719954550266266,
-0.5556036829948425,
0.10554055124521255,
-0.671845018863678,
-0.27205953001976013,
-0.6735292673110962,
-0.6070380806922913,
-0.2690446078777313,
-0.787433922290802,
-0.0003166510141454637,
-0.11401047557592392,
0.4370669722557068,
0.49991604685783386,
-0.4051622152328491,
0.4453052580356598,
-0.2589571475982666,
0.2525951862335205,
0.26111891865730286,
0.18163108825683594,
-0.18996259570121765,
-0.7747891545295715,
-0.334089994430542,
0.26162394881248474,
-0.06891362369060516,
-0.8232576847076416,
0.62767094373703,
0.8820907473564148,
0.43709596991539,
0.41349226236343384,
0.24025647342205048,
1.0174791812896729,
-1.0439815521240234,
0.6780449748039246,
-0.08150911331176758,
-0.8604498505592346,
0.3963048458099365,
-0.2655608057975769,
0.3200795352458954,
0.8279765248298645,
0.3664111793041229,
-0.42139074206352234,
-0.15406058728694916,
-0.3073593080043793,
-1.3175053596496582,
0.49070897698402405,
0.23136377334594727,
0.13121628761291504,
0.2731333076953888,
0.28095823526382446,
-0.04013597592711449,
0.16154931485652924,
-0.026473117992281914,
-0.17625218629837036,
-0.5702007412910461,
-0.1614617556333542,
-0.3554280698299408,
-0.21335236728191376,
-0.31240856647491455,
-0.11968029290437698,
0.5830683708190918,
-0.36169275641441345,
0.326877623796463,
0.5888617038726807,
-0.48111212253570557,
-0.16163747012615204,
0.13634853065013885,
0.2980979382991791,
0.2906234860420227,
-0.37629279494285583,
-0.033628910779953,
0.3451533317565918,
-0.5510403513908386,
0.2470131814479828,
0.2948618531227112,
-0.2425844967365265,
0.2696676552295685,
0.3174600303173065,
0.8754875063896179,
0.30529865622520447,
-0.1393720805644989,
0.5368115901947021,
0.14843955636024475,
-0.2432040125131607,
-0.6576640009880066,
-0.07529671490192413,
-0.1583232879638672,
0.18367476761341095,
0.6661651730537415,
0.015809904783964157,
0.5048623085021973,
-0.7602795362472534,
0.406269371509552,
0.4875505566596985,
-0.6868318319320679,
-0.34780481457710266,
0.7374736070632935,
0.6105044484138489,
-0.6619880199432373,
0.5262202620506287,
0.22981800138950348,
-0.8020811080932617,
0.738960325717926,
0.4526350498199463,
1.247740387916565,
-0.45048806071281433,
0.06940016150474548,
0.5447194576263428,
0.27244284749031067,
0.323242723941803,
0.1928999274969101,
-0.6689137816429138,
-0.6767714619636536,
0.09508614242076874,
-0.6732038259506226,
-0.7244353294372559,
-0.26299455761909485,
-0.8662208914756775,
0.3305950462818146,
-0.4228358566761017,
0.1236734688282013,
-0.07496315985918045,
0.11988142132759094,
-0.5797505378723145,
0.2505280673503876,
0.5685428977012634,
1.0636414289474487,
-1.047717571258545,
0.44514796137809753,
0.7378934621810913,
-0.40954259037971497,
-0.8309271931648254,
0.16479353606700897,
0.4045669734477997,
-0.9983505606651306,
0.19318534433841705,
0.2964460551738739,
-0.3427334427833557,
0.051422297954559326,
-0.29515090584754944,
-0.9475682973861694,
0.8500702381134033,
0.12260017544031143,
-0.6552201509475708,
0.30772608518600464,
0.523103654384613,
0.43749475479125977,
-0.4960678517818451,
0.46633434295654297,
0.6357401609420776,
0.3281763195991516,
0.5042682886123657,
-0.6869417428970337,
-0.1820899397134781,
-0.11349804699420929,
-0.01719420775771141,
0.2074914574623108,
-0.6340941190719604,
0.4739764332771301,
-0.38460785150527954,
-0.5346846580505371,
0.11435459554195404,
0.48462817072868347,
-0.05366077274084091,
0.3675355017185211,
0.6022068858146667,
0.28054672479629517,
0.6953065395355225,
-0.1606021374464035,
0.6211181879043579,
-0.46661362051963806,
-0.1994379460811615,
1.1896854639053345,
-0.7484444975852966,
0.9178993105888367,
0.30444759130477905,
-0.013990330509841442,
0.6800820231437683,
0.42408135533332825,
0.10364984720945358,
0.6892619132995605,
-0.0015619432087987661,
-0.5263438820838928,
-0.01244920864701271,
-0.27302855253219604,
-0.10525144636631012,
0.709379255771637,
0.4457795023918152,
-0.10310688614845276,
-0.15795347094535828,
-0.07693831622600555,
-0.033000122755765915,
0.1280389130115509,
-0.5955216288566589,
0.8615249395370483,
0.10896940529346466,
-0.23622190952301025,
0.5383737087249756,
-0.6588382124900818,
0.15751032531261444,
-0.7591168284416199,
-0.24457843601703644,
-0.48233717679977417,
0.050082508474588394,
-0.09914025664329529,
-0.3205617666244507,
0.3317272365093231,
-0.03530553728342056,
-0.2880236506462097,
-0.1285686492919922,
0.5656890869140625,
-0.8195981383323669,
-0.3380126953125,
0.22281138598918915,
0.20662301778793335,
0.15369074046611786,
-0.19225677847862244,
-0.3401443362236023,
-0.0029406400863081217,
-0.1810549646615982,
0.13887804746627808,
0.11909445375204086,
0.45925766229629517,
-0.11943749338388443,
0.3670918047428131,
0.7991094589233398,
0.5923969149589539,
-0.04919213429093361,
0.18147338926792145,
0.7000287771224976,
-0.559032142162323,
-0.7024299502372742,
-0.3982994854450226,
0.5145543217658997,
-0.2726024389266968,
-0.24292665719985962,
0.8136228322982788,
0.3167435824871063,
0.6728897094726562,
0.2678239047527313,
0.8913630843162537,
-0.020021408796310425,
0.6982479691505432,
-0.23514069616794586,
0.8946408629417419,
-0.4139319658279419,
-0.0644504576921463,
-0.06545892357826233,
-0.9735370874404907,
-0.30767011642456055,
0.5256302356719971,
-0.36324337124824524,
-0.15461963415145874,
0.3004077076911926,
0.992943286895752,
-0.11809515953063965,
-0.25471481680870056,
0.2769715487957001,
0.2242560088634491,
0.07026052474975586,
0.2950630784034729,
0.5075215101242065,
-0.30445265769958496,
0.5025897026062012,
-0.13579635322093964,
-0.23214755952358246,
-0.33686167001724243,
-0.6076078414916992,
-0.7289789319038391,
-0.44989821314811707,
-0.16551591455936432,
-0.059981878846883774,
0.6310819983482361,
1.0314120054244995,
0.9575707316398621,
-1.1855285167694092,
-0.2418496012687683,
0.20302130281925201,
-0.10394701361656189,
-0.24687477946281433,
-0.15595653653144836,
0.2774190306663513,
-0.013547989539802074,
-0.6208254098892212,
0.6051126718521118,
0.603327751159668,
-0.019313206896185875,
-0.13175250589847565,
0.12049530446529388,
-0.029624873772263527,
0.5203160643577576,
0.40256428718566895,
1.0436155796051025,
-0.18707378208637238,
-0.385617733001709,
-0.30218422412872314,
0.31855565309524536,
0.27909690141677856,
0.9888338446617126,
-0.45136815309524536,
0.7052159905433655,
0.08088452368974686,
0.5236490964889526,
0.5463333129882812,
0.2773634195327759,
0.9786907434463501,
-0.8339681029319763,
0.39431506395339966,
0.3428202271461487,
0.3867969214916229,
0.72207111120224,
-0.261290967464447,
0.2567569315433502,
-0.12321525812149048,
-0.6103086471557617,
-0.6422416567802429,
0.2015492469072342,
-0.7445615530014038,
0.20639289915561676,
1.2096916437149048,
-0.30941882729530334,
-0.34234318137168884,
-0.5426948666572571,
-0.19011974334716797,
0.18169796466827393,
-0.5557042956352234,
0.8525468111038208,
0.27176451683044434,
0.020204387605190277,
-0.18223020434379578,
-0.30041179060935974,
0.5548826456069946,
0.2509292960166931,
-0.3011942207813263,
-0.12739060819149017,
0.5975639820098877,
0.3419698476791382,
0.20396003127098083,
0.4129018783569336,
0.14952529966831207,
0.11345363408327103,
0.2707815170288086,
0.3369213044643402,
-0.061156563460826874,
-0.42219871282577515,
-0.7837997674942017,
0.23984089493751526,
-0.02454443648457527,
-0.5469824075698853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01796v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01796v2 | Speech foundation models in healthcare: Effect of layer selection on pathological speech feature prediction | 2024-02-02T05:09:42 | 2024-06-21T13:49:56 | Daniela A. Wiepert, Rene L. Utianski, Joseph R. Duffy, John L. Stricker, Leland R. Barnard, David T. Jones, Hugo Botha | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG | Accurately extracting clinical information from speech is critical to the
diagnosis and treatment of many neurological conditions. As such, there is
interest in leveraging AI for automatic, objective assessments of clinical
speech to facilitate diagnosis and treatment of speech disorders. We explore
transfer learning using foundation models, focusing on the impact of layer
selection for the downstream task of predicting pathological speech features.
We find that selecting an optimal layer can greatly improve performance (~15.8%
increase in balanced accuracy per feature as compared to worst layer, ~13.6%
increase as compared to final layer), though the best layer varies by predicted
feature and does not always generalize well to unseen data. A learned weighted
sum offers comparable performance to the average best layer in-distribution
(only ~1.2% lower) and had strong generalization for out-of-distribution data
(only 1.5% lower than the average best layer). | [
-0.20335622131824493,
-0.5052873492240906,
0.3195405602455139,
0.17122216522693634,
-0.10498715192079544,
-0.1925686150789261,
0.06736540794372559,
-1.0174431800842285,
0.23295016586780548,
0.8799368739128113,
-0.1959734559059143,
-0.22728905081748962,
-0.99894118309021,
-0.5696806311607361,
-0.739494800567627,
0.9113295674324036,
0.41774964332580566,
0.4042830765247345,
-0.24972498416900635,
-0.04134234040975571,
-0.4157801568508148,
-0.20469121634960175,
-1.1000609397888184,
-0.9440912008285522,
0.1072671189904213,
0.2525712251663208,
0.6387218832969666,
0.8554785847663879,
0.837121844291687,
0.252930223941803,
0.034743987023830414,
-0.5127516984939575,
-0.40249547362327576,
0.2591654062271118,
-0.02954072132706642,
-0.434019535779953,
-0.3583430349826813,
0.044799815863370895,
0.5739626884460449,
1.3439552783966064,
-0.379648894071579,
-0.09291086345911026,
-0.19903382658958435,
0.9812054634094238,
-0.401636004447937,
0.0027706800028681755,
-0.32634174823760986,
0.2783738076686859,
-0.008039696142077446,
-0.22414983808994293,
-0.3134840726852417,
-0.11661892384290695,
1.0039840936660767,
-0.35393157601356506,
0.24641112983226776,
-0.24828055500984192,
0.4834558963775635,
0.34886837005615234,
-0.32825931906700134,
-0.18593823909759521,
-0.7382694482803345,
0.46657538414001465,
-0.3913133442401886,
0.5900295376777649,
0.6544064879417419,
0.6215823292732239,
0.24702799320220947,
-1.1000076532363892,
0.25214359164237976,
-0.5481370091438293,
0.0335557758808136,
-0.0012540180468931794,
-0.41450533270835876,
0.1418098658323288,
0.17686045169830322,
0.2998611032962799,
-0.45006218552589417,
0.19100232422351837,
-0.6828954815864563,
-0.46106183528900146,
0.7313829064369202,
-0.08813582360744476,
0.4422754645347595,
-0.034640394151210785,
-0.258705735206604,
-0.07844182848930359,
-0.4765305519104004,
0.36681023240089417,
-0.21379531919956207,
0.3279891908168793,
-0.13318274915218353,
0.12382259219884872,
-0.22109732031822205,
0.8312730193138123,
0.05880565568804741,
-0.4271163046360016,
0.4083511531352997,
0.09364058822393417,
-0.39151665568351746,
0.6285455822944641,
0.3552621006965637,
-0.10529889911413193,
0.21633310616016388,
-0.3625882863998413,
-0.005024558398872614,
0.09793150424957275,
0.25750887393951416,
-0.8380413055419922,
-0.6308627724647522,
0.10926242172718048,
-0.585239052772522,
-0.6779748797416687,
0.017801515758037567,
-0.3826494514942169,
-0.5741132497787476,
-0.3886708915233612,
0.2223668098449707,
-0.539009153842926,
-0.2902258634567261,
0.22881515324115753,
-0.30154716968536377,
-0.1269335001707077,
0.31433624029159546,
-0.8797463178634644,
0.7051429152488708,
0.27913010120391846,
0.7779786586761475,
-0.32681217789649963,
-0.006674833595752716,
-0.9031007289886475,
0.3865887522697449,
-0.17816564440727234,
0.8153443336486816,
-0.6784541606903076,
-0.37176603078842163,
-0.447298139333725,
-0.24119389057159424,
-0.2100784182548523,
-0.70835280418396,
0.5106831192970276,
-0.008851268328726292,
0.10042949765920639,
-0.20321831107139587,
-0.2735230028629303,
-0.1732257604598999,
-0.476927250623703,
-0.8129787445068359,
0.5680669546127319,
0.5991784334182739,
-0.5621681809425354,
0.41265809535980225,
-0.6093276143074036,
-0.9475129246711731,
-0.06312338262796402,
-0.049011506140232086,
-0.2813316881656647,
0.09328199923038483,
0.18304109573364258,
0.5118703842163086,
-0.18556851148605347,
0.17594151198863983,
-0.14008481800556183,
-0.24717754125595093,
0.2222660928964615,
-0.017645785585045815,
0.8724087476730347,
0.2636353075504303,
-0.6537313461303711,
-0.048256367444992065,
-1.0272413492202759,
-0.02933489717543125,
-0.13805250823497772,
-0.1196044310927391,
-0.3207336366176605,
-0.09088154882192612,
-0.09172490239143372,
0.23272980749607086,
-0.49371016025543213,
-0.30723002552986145,
-0.4075276553630829,
-0.5958995819091797,
0.6256818771362305,
0.5489703416824341,
0.12025634199380875,
0.48049330711364746,
-0.7101468443870544,
0.6494337320327759,
0.34439414739608765,
0.024690840393304825,
0.3846593499183655,
-0.6879377365112305,
-0.39987871050834656,
-0.33590176701545715,
0.46383312344551086,
0.5838221311569214,
-0.34345489740371704,
0.017551977187395096,
-0.1066422238945961,
-0.42244917154312134,
-0.5907135605812073,
-0.08871929347515106,
0.5005512237548828,
1.0307908058166504,
0.40470537543296814,
-0.4936527609825134,
-0.42744550108909607,
-0.9475053548812866,
0.13425064086914062,
-0.15676766633987427,
0.13405585289001465,
0.47730377316474915,
0.13066890835762024,
-0.057393573224544525,
0.6479840278625488,
-0.3486349582672119,
-0.4685962498188019,
-0.1428278684616089,
-0.03592368960380554,
-0.12748529016971588,
0.5911509990692139,
0.7372507452964783,
-0.8696610927581787,
-0.44904428720474243,
0.24197837710380554,
-0.4981667995452881,
-0.2446044683456421,
0.27835747599601746,
-0.06466108560562134,
-0.17194342613220215,
0.20022879540920258,
-0.5665814280509949,
0.43157169222831726,
0.6685287356376648,
-0.1472833752632141,
0.2768809497356415,
0.08801742643117905,
0.006248558405786753,
-0.9783918261528015,
0.20291194319725037,
0.20078277587890625,
-0.3967386484146118,
-0.8074132800102234,
-0.2512058615684509,
-0.218842551112175,
-0.25864914059638977,
-0.29646214842796326,
0.3641360104084015,
-0.2754391133785248,
-0.32647064328193665,
-0.11268044263124466,
0.09832273423671722,
0.054422713816165924,
0.027749929577112198,
-0.06687627732753754,
0.6162410974502563,
1.063746452331543,
-0.7143045663833618,
0.31463661789894104,
0.07903558015823364,
-0.5211051106452942,
0.3809446692466736,
-0.6259675621986389,
0.08744435012340546,
-0.008808886632323265,
0.24911117553710938,
-0.8326460123062134,
-0.2724014222621918,
-0.06382326781749725,
-0.6420952081680298,
0.5089623928070068,
0.07578752934932709,
0.5377172231674194,
-0.10684512555599213,
-0.012360555119812489,
0.04378703236579895,
0.6330121755599976,
0.007690999656915665,
0.5664204955101013,
0.7581510543823242,
-0.2110542505979538,
-0.7853097915649414,
-1.351712942123413,
-0.13685347139835358,
-0.2011605054140091,
-0.7234171032905579,
0.8068968653678894,
0.16906499862670898,
-0.2533438801765442,
0.249421626329422,
-0.21460333466529846,
-0.09524279087781906,
0.39996737241744995,
0.3025805354118347,
-0.240066260099411,
-0.4222082793712616,
0.09493762999773026,
0.18379856646060944,
-0.20221979916095734,
0.1479566991329193,
-0.2965828478336334,
0.4122013449668884,
0.025391587987542152,
-0.29071304202079773,
-0.46469545364379883,
0.30854928493499756,
0.5756987929344177,
-0.2686995565891266,
0.4573337137699127,
0.4651219844818115,
-0.7811920046806335,
-0.465745747089386,
-0.41474393010139465,
-0.3788445293903351,
-0.39888808131217957,
0.5326855182647705,
-0.3899339735507965,
-0.6137327551841736,
0.6952974796295166,
-0.015622171573340893,
-0.37307149171829224,
0.5228663086891174,
0.2682242691516876,
-0.2681221067905426,
1.151833176612854,
0.7555056214332581,
-0.25222641229629517,
0.5062844157218933,
-0.3936194181442261,
-0.05544155463576317,
-0.8034408688545227,
-0.32687264680862427,
-0.7217457294464111,
-0.4207819700241089,
-0.4205840229988098,
0.08675133436918259,
0.48346325755119324,
0.11812931299209595,
0.11214625835418701,
-0.007674769498407841,
-0.6466330885887146,
0.1356370747089386,
0.34651803970336914,
0.737099289894104,
0.02721448242664337,
0.322451651096344,
-0.17581284046173096,
0.11604031175374985,
-0.6459037661552429,
0.04526086896657944,
1.062623381614685,
0.4854300618171692,
0.31862980127334595,
0.10093694925308228,
0.5549290776252747,
0.45243585109710693,
0.2482948750257492,
-0.7560552358627319,
0.2544448673725128,
-0.6532047986984253,
-0.2441883087158203,
-0.44712749123573303,
-0.48664191365242004,
-0.8388810157775879,
0.029154006391763687,
-0.293976366519928,
-0.6446621417999268,
0.5037422180175781,
0.14189226925373077,
-0.5251588821411133,
-0.06965313106775284,
-0.5626196265220642,
0.4749572277069092,
-0.22063905000686646,
-0.04127954691648483,
-0.3714140057563782,
-0.8638237118721008,
0.31497228145599365,
0.016670821234583855,
0.09336970746517181,
-0.006968352012336254,
0.07475956529378891,
0.8695678114891052,
-0.04672273248434067,
0.6286524534225464,
-0.2827286720275879,
0.3867678642272949,
0.04626525193452835,
0.04779460281133652,
0.08713346719741821,
-0.2831881046295166,
-0.40702447295188904,
0.01720006950199604,
-0.0759248286485672,
-0.29042312502861023,
-0.7273001074790955,
0.6802754998207092,
-0.9173297882080078,
-0.570825457572937,
-0.23082667589187622,
-0.4338915944099426,
-0.7583421468734741,
0.03388890624046326,
0.26635393500328064,
0.7644206285476685,
-0.10744623839855194,
0.5715414881706238,
0.7985107898712158,
0.14180506765842438,
0.22810907661914825,
0.17002931237220764,
0.034764938056468964,
-0.4464142620563507,
0.7699998617172241,
0.28401023149490356,
0.44443732500076294,
0.3652748763561249,
0.821272611618042,
-0.11362043768167496,
-1.1538888216018677,
-0.34948182106018066,
0.15403780341148376,
-0.9605743288993835,
-0.09683375060558319,
-0.8049454092979431,
-0.7128695249557495,
-0.6694433093070984,
0.03246733173727989,
-0.05096059665083885,
-0.7972733378410339,
-0.44044750928878784,
-0.4424591064453125,
0.08836280554533005,
0.5316967964172363,
-0.058507975190877914,
0.23105104267597198,
-0.6115838885307312,
0.0962447077035904,
0.28757381439208984,
0.1821322739124298,
0.0021348106674849987,
-0.721169114112854,
-0.19987896084785461,
0.026696234941482544,
-0.2453218251466751,
-0.8594732880592346,
0.23765160143375397,
0.6732884049415588,
0.9434534907341003,
0.5805667638778687,
-0.20870733261108398,
0.6323134303092957,
-0.1138167530298233,
0.5661917328834534,
0.38563618063926697,
-0.8816801905632019,
0.7718364000320435,
0.02855086885392666,
0.03270364925265312,
0.618475079536438,
0.4308353066444397,
-0.42225486040115356,
-0.2255394011735916,
-0.7577931880950928,
-0.39095959067344666,
0.8029281497001648,
0.08918759226799011,
-0.19006115198135376,
0.39196136593818665,
0.553093433380127,
0.03012089431285858,
0.11567866802215576,
-0.46300777792930603,
-0.30473852157592773,
-0.21311849355697632,
-0.03549038618803024,
-0.07884044200181961,
-0.0721067562699318,
-0.3754071295261383,
-0.5750466585159302,
0.5024719834327698,
-0.07352051138877869,
0.3418714702129364,
0.4777110517024994,
-0.06479969620704651,
-0.606033444404602,
-0.20192937552928925,
0.788707971572876,
1.0428824424743652,
-0.23940281569957733,
0.0753965824842453,
0.03028029017150402,
-0.7881169319152832,
-0.08501555025577545,
0.2550535202026367,
-0.08603479713201523,
-0.06167388707399368,
0.7937715649604797,
1.2119125127792358,
0.13992351293563843,
-0.3934778571128845,
0.5811941027641296,
0.2158174365758896,
-0.36303019523620605,
0.04428360238671303,
0.42701712250709534,
0.1463150531053543,
0.17213501036167145,
0.3062884211540222,
0.6273287534713745,
0.6477831602096558,
-0.5366411805152893,
0.6705102920532227,
0.511827290058136,
-0.6510764360427856,
-0.18855926394462585,
0.5319728851318359,
0.2770555317401886,
-0.3508344292640686,
0.7921133637428284,
0.6798883080482483,
-0.4662254750728607,
0.8919098377227783,
0.7869957089424133,
0.8486206531524658,
-0.7033153772354126,
0.34602171182632446,
-0.06645233184099197,
0.0946853905916214,
-0.0036462335847318172,
-0.02591380476951599,
0.09967382997274399,
-0.6833100914955139,
-0.280148446559906,
-0.6733661890029907,
-0.2949446737766266,
0.10696955770254135,
-0.6964502334594727,
0.2984698414802551,
-0.5198051929473877,
-0.300630122423172,
0.3925953507423401,
0.10578777641057968,
-0.3377121686935425,
0.7142641544342041,
0.29699259996414185,
0.8447555899620056,
-0.8119721412658691,
1.0719540119171143,
0.649903416633606,
-0.22564932703971863,
-1.0131173133850098,
-0.2783736288547516,
-0.15887171030044556,
-1.0237603187561035,
0.5733453631401062,
0.1147831380367279,
-0.2290961593389511,
0.12690232694149017,
-0.15460585057735443,
-1.1821743249893188,
1.1171741485595703,
0.9594169855117798,
-0.42583000659942627,
-0.15957054495811462,
0.2793971002101898,
0.6142106056213379,
-0.7409027218818665,
0.33880162239074707,
0.6331110000610352,
0.14504948258399963,
0.5614715218544006,
-1.1144261360168457,
0.056124497205019,
-0.08052575588226318,
-0.0004509227001108229,
-0.014143322594463825,
-0.2466381937265396,
0.9434834122657776,
-0.483630895614624,
-0.12947529554367065,
-0.4066464304924011,
0.27742576599121094,
0.08281498402357101,
0.4571226239204407,
0.5769190788269043,
0.5969698429107666,
1.0609380006790161,
-0.018214186653494835,
1.30626380443573,
-0.3764481246471405,
-0.08589658886194229,
0.549956202507019,
-0.08712772279977798,
0.7238167524337769,
0.07593689113855362,
-0.12526747584342957,
0.5005989074707031,
0.6987869143486023,
0.42794838547706604,
0.9306375980377197,
0.12016608566045761,
0.0055153947323560715,
-0.0903041884303093,
-0.15380136668682098,
-0.809326171875,
0.6927425265312195,
0.372116357088089,
-0.7631506323814392,
0.06692219525575638,
0.2058204561471939,
-0.31171372532844543,
-0.1913124918937683,
-0.291066437959671,
0.8178868889808655,
0.3537302017211914,
-0.5061309337615967,
0.5521314144134521,
-0.14265231788158417,
0.06884067505598068,
-0.6987858414649963,
-0.20748183131217957,
-0.14461925625801086,
0.08480633050203323,
-0.566114604473114,
-0.3789292871952057,
0.46665167808532715,
-0.7029954791069031,
-0.2274232655763626,
-0.1774107664823532,
1.0600451231002808,
-0.27220550179481506,
-0.4711410701274872,
0.45065298676490784,
0.376840204000473,
0.12318979203701019,
-0.05556472763419151,
-0.9483388662338257,
-0.12619782984256744,
0.07379485666751862,
-0.3776293396949768,
0.5479394793510437,
0.02689334936439991,
-0.21383045613765717,
0.9065515995025635,
0.7481884360313416,
0.6637533903121948,
-0.062422942370176315,
0.2467033714056015,
0.8098598718643188,
-0.2920264005661011,
-0.8304404616355896,
-0.6561505794525146,
0.4865745007991791,
-0.1290874034166336,
-0.250821977853775,
0.0039109098725020885,
0.18070602416992188,
0.5997337698936462,
0.20443278551101685,
0.7879303097724915,
0.18883644044399261,
0.5405372977256775,
-0.679122269153595,
0.8897553086280823,
-0.4990167021751404,
0.15790586173534393,
-0.2996177077293396,
-0.6998720765113831,
-0.2999325096607208,
0.6657085418701172,
-0.27424612641334534,
0.31780073046684265,
1.019447684288025,
0.3822948634624481,
-0.10883159190416336,
0.38194137811660767,
0.454452246427536,
0.14261335134506226,
0.343210905790329,
0.7814137935638428,
0.3827112317085266,
-0.2477462738752365,
0.09047030657529831,
-0.8994748592376709,
-0.5643956661224365,
-0.017413029447197914,
-0.8033541440963745,
-0.6872003674507141,
-0.5824794769287109,
-0.35552355647087097,
-0.43008333444595337,
0.2833384573459625,
0.7086052298545837,
1.3142814636230469,
-1.0888431072235107,
-0.2713189423084259,
0.035143859684467316,
0.007805572357028723,
-0.6142205595970154,
-0.16570599377155304,
0.5705651044845581,
0.06887411326169968,
-0.2295265644788742,
0.5944090485572815,
0.15879254043102264,
-0.054952554404735565,
-0.2332354187965393,
0.05396261438727379,
0.0612991601228714,
-0.263578325510025,
0.47081756591796875,
-0.0658414214849472,
-0.688377320766449,
-0.25814035534858704,
-0.15621165931224823,
-0.16716016829013824,
0.08889169245958328,
1.0183838605880737,
-0.946658730506897,
0.20281529426574707,
0.35212817788124084,
0.944418728351593,
0.5241747498512268,
0.050701942294836044,
0.5570144653320312,
-0.29958078265190125,
0.09992416203022003,
0.6903575658798218,
0.278923898935318,
0.38775521516799927,
-0.8553404808044434,
0.4920600354671478,
0.513494074344635,
-0.28456178307533264,
-0.9241881966590881,
0.0016144580440595746,
-1.0606725215911865,
-0.19577209651470184,
0.8804255723953247,
-0.008808803744614124,
-0.16117733716964722,
-0.01000012457370758,
0.13582825660705566,
0.11151815950870514,
-0.2771824598312378,
0.6818315386772156,
0.5791674256324768,
-0.8167742490768433,
-0.49593913555145264,
-0.6368300914764404,
0.9441709518432617,
0.36663705110549927,
-0.7012622356414795,
-0.44871968030929565,
0.461921364068985,
0.6927165389060974,
0.06922026723623276,
0.6033227443695068,
-0.05520186945796013,
0.6072704792022705,
-0.27557504177093506,
-0.43928003311157227,
-0.3111708164215088,
-0.5173854827880859,
-0.4915922284126282,
0.5696909427642822,
-0.09378150850534439,
-0.10983441770076752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01135v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01135v1 | A Multi-Agent Conversational Recommender System | 2024-02-02T04:20:13 | 2024-02-02T04:20:13 | Jiabao Fang, Shen Gao, Pengjie Ren, Xiuying Chen, Suzan Verberne, Zhaochun Ren | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Due to strong capabilities in conducting fluent, multi-turn conversations
with users, Large Language Models (LLMs) have the potential to further improve
the performance of Conversational Recommender System (CRS). Unlike the aimless
chit-chat that LLM excels at, CRS has a clear target. So it is imperative to
control the dialogue flow in the LLM to successfully recommend appropriate
items to the users. Furthermore, user feedback in CRS can assist the system in
better modeling user preferences, which has been ignored by existing studies.
However, simply prompting LLM to conduct conversational recommendation cannot
address the above two key challenges.
In this paper, we propose Multi-Agent Conversational Recommender System
(MACRS) which contains two essential modules. First, we design a multi-agent
act planning framework, which can control the dialogue flow based on four
LLM-based agents. This cooperative multi-agent framework will generate various
candidate responses based on different dialogue acts and then choose the most
appropriate response as the system response, which can help MACRS plan suitable
dialogue acts. Second, we propose a user feedback-aware reflection mechanism
which leverages user feedback to reason errors made in previous turns to adjust
the dialogue act planning, and higher-level user information from implicit
semantics. We conduct extensive experiments based on user simulator to
demonstrate the effectiveness of MACRS in recommendation and user preferences
collection. Experimental results illustrate that MACRS demonstrates an
improvement in user interaction experience compared to directly using LLMs. | [
-0.48151955008506775,
-0.5802192091941833,
0.5233094692230225,
0.3852204382419586,
-0.10674583911895752,
0.34003153443336487,
-0.10833951830863953,
-0.37529313564300537,
0.40595757961273193,
1.0238232612609863,
-0.5973407626152039,
-0.21867673099040985,
-0.424355149269104,
0.050825681537389755,
-0.026069622486829758,
1.0116571187973022,
0.044331662356853485,
0.24965405464172363,
0.06930247694253922,
-0.08747623860836029,
-0.6724613904953003,
-0.5935417413711548,
-0.873276948928833,
-0.5209896564483643,
0.7565922737121582,
0.6186200380325317,
0.8604121804237366,
-0.07018029689788818,
0.4623671770095825,
0.4112939238548279,
0.15878155827522278,
0.6719664335250854,
-0.4304172396659851,
0.47492820024490356,
0.09940515458583832,
-0.22205795347690582,
-0.7057231664657593,
-0.44146811962127686,
0.33523795008659363,
-0.021853387355804443,
-0.5863243341445923,
-0.31993773579597473,
0.08389275521039963,
0.46145936846733093,
-0.36343446373939514,
0.17142361402511597,
-0.5015986561775208,
-0.11616687476634979,
0.1890125274658203,
-0.454559326171875,
-0.5886077880859375,
-0.24313487112522125,
0.24895767867565155,
-0.3621212840080261,
-0.08638416230678558,
0.32926979660987854,
0.30832788348197937,
-0.07500003278255463,
-0.4600943922996521,
-0.2241775542497635,
-0.9607918858528137,
0.6705177426338196,
-0.7802318334579468,
0.2785882353782654,
0.1308346688747406,
0.5636725425720215,
-0.3952968716621399,
-0.25755858421325684,
-0.4784773290157318,
-0.47024664282798767,
-0.07000517845153809,
0.09559527784585953,
0.1372876763343811,
0.15000781416893005,
-0.12317443639039993,
-0.01313093677163124,
-0.24191731214523315,
-0.18526257574558258,
-0.06062089651823044,
-0.3577871024608612,
0.5593680143356323,
0.449737012386322,
0.19936691224575043,
0.17225997149944305,
-0.6466035842895508,
-0.23456767201423645,
-0.5450646877288818,
0.19290459156036377,
0.17808623611927032,
0.5437110662460327,
-0.05032902583479881,
0.7010283470153809,
-0.2466706484556198,
0.2794715166091919,
0.1432429701089859,
-0.3925532102584839,
0.0851404145359993,
-0.321835994720459,
0.10022152960300446,
-0.12096478044986725,
1.003286600112915,
0.5584344863891602,
0.45982038974761963,
-0.013137823902070522,
-0.21442291140556335,
-0.05769573897123337,
0.18225058913230896,
-0.8726524710655212,
0.15421508252620697,
-0.05060744658112526,
-0.17433184385299683,
-0.10135631263256073,
0.04748834669589996,
-0.5325575470924377,
-0.4863532483577728,
-0.34992682933807373,
0.231069415807724,
-0.3220476806163788,
-0.2204761803150177,
0.1364533007144928,
0.05532318353652954,
-0.04004720225930214,
0.6554203629493713,
-0.6493464708328247,
0.6497129797935486,
0.37536129355430603,
0.7454448938369751,
-0.024391543120145798,
-0.36710280179977417,
-0.3811822235584259,
0.3666918873786926,
-0.11577707529067993,
0.8586422801017761,
-0.8932449221611023,
-0.6371023058891296,
0.13679064810276031,
-0.03476198390126228,
0.12181884795427322,
-0.19975805282592773,
0.24892288446426392,
-0.5622314810752869,
-0.09165634214878082,
-0.3965420424938202,
-0.08350834250450134,
-0.2298288643360138,
0.46331900358200073,
-0.39198997616767883,
0.741185188293457,
-0.2155902087688446,
-0.4735640585422516,
0.067097507417202,
-0.8128799200057983,
-0.3197587728500366,
0.03584092855453491,
-0.21649712324142456,
-0.11793124675750732,
-0.21468055248260498,
0.3912704288959503,
0.4477214813232422,
-0.2782936990261078,
0.38666701316833496,
-0.44646111130714417,
-0.3894771337509155,
0.45122507214546204,
-0.41201379895210266,
0.10707063972949982,
0.18586482107639313,
-0.12006843090057373,
0.4209011197090149,
-0.293500691652298,
0.08369835466146469,
-0.19086436927318573,
-0.4053172469139099,
0.06107979640364647,
0.20843613147735596,
0.19043423235416412,
0.4021148085594177,
0.06007199361920357,
-0.4513813853263855,
0.22508229315280914,
-0.1402059942483902,
0.2984987795352936,
0.7896825075149536,
0.043154265731573105,
0.431791216135025,
-0.6925602555274963,
0.5422324538230896,
0.1897299587726593,
0.12084425240755081,
-0.22036506235599518,
-0.44014182686805725,
-0.7090019583702087,
-0.3069210946559906,
-0.23224297165870667,
0.5161040425300598,
-0.783540666103363,
0.15588034689426422,
0.056834086775779724,
-0.29588037729263306,
-0.36497873067855835,
0.2738792896270752,
0.5057587623596191,
0.03315119817852974,
0.17534343898296356,
-0.4836454689502716,
-0.42047178745269775,
-0.6835781931877136,
0.035101138055324554,
-0.2951834201812744,
0.10638866573572159,
0.9006863236427307,
0.02699935995042324,
-0.39431434869766235,
0.9670596122741699,
-0.44792699813842773,
-0.5880334973335266,
-0.5718254446983337,
-0.10542428493499756,
-0.19647806882858276,
-0.01700151152908802,
0.24319489300251007,
-0.5016390085220337,
-0.5385956168174744,
-0.07905983179807663,
-0.20597206056118011,
-0.05858096107840538,
0.10572763532400131,
-0.19662167131900787,
0.24094292521476746,
0.11755374819040298,
-0.509362518787384,
0.26293593645095825,
0.36142173409461975,
-0.2315450757741928,
0.5277130007743835,
-0.4500044882297516,
0.20349052548408508,
-1.0502427816390991,
-0.25122418999671936,
0.18127644062042236,
-0.2564651668071747,
-0.3855421245098114,
-0.36111921072006226,
-0.2807271182537079,
0.12302061170339584,
-0.46073660254478455,
0.641251266002655,
-0.24908997118473053,
0.11098482459783554,
-0.5288801789283752,
0.30264222621917725,
0.12169857323169708,
0.8225964307785034,
0.08748841285705566,
0.7039758563041687,
0.35397836565971375,
-0.6968581676483154,
0.4220182001590729,
0.5587625503540039,
0.13902123272418976,
0.5455507636070251,
-0.6469206213951111,
0.30120718479156494,
0.0463310070335865,
0.7961218357086182,
-1.058709979057312,
0.11715968698263168,
0.4097890257835388,
-0.11092247068881989,
-0.08916234225034714,
0.10066850483417511,
-0.19852276146411896,
-0.26316210627555847,
-0.3518840968608856,
0.04808715358376503,
-0.06993506848812103,
-0.4123990833759308,
0.9215745329856873,
0.3511943519115448,
-0.4055756628513336,
-0.7438308000564575,
-0.39431631565093994,
0.2685060203075409,
0.13664297759532928,
-0.715176522731781,
0.08081521838903427,
-0.5730781555175781,
-0.1487436294555664,
-0.30483052134513855,
0.28560808300971985,
0.14424467086791992,
-0.30890822410583496,
0.6487376689910889,
0.39045631885528564,
0.0356888547539711,
0.18168480694293976,
-0.18650805950164795,
-0.1622789204120636,
-0.14288099110126495,
0.015579886734485626,
0.6932123303413391,
-0.40734735131263733,
-0.36668166518211365,
-0.5968953371047974,
0.3445300757884979,
0.6448150873184204,
-0.23799274861812592,
0.48372209072113037,
0.5088225603103638,
0.3066989779472351,
-0.14456585049629211,
-1.027635097503662,
-0.49713003635406494,
-0.5138852000236511,
0.2398216724395752,
-0.5518827438354492,
-1.1151518821716309,
0.41383278369903564,
-0.12317811697721481,
0.20763565599918365,
-0.11804844439029694,
0.8586416244506836,
0.14118731021881104,
1.2895426750183105,
0.6686970591545105,
-0.2831440567970276,
0.5446629524230957,
-0.25185054540634155,
0.2984426021575928,
-0.9863977432250977,
-0.3153267800807953,
-0.5773711204528809,
-0.1456407904624939,
-0.31969302892684937,
-0.2044306844472885,
0.14729472994804382,
-0.3904331922531128,
-0.20088894665241241,
0.16994421184062958,
-0.3408307731151581,
0.26414626836776733,
0.49010682106018066,
0.3284793794155121,
0.4117860198020935,
-0.139712393283844,
-0.44905784726142883,
0.3195206820964813,
-0.461487740278244,
-0.7665700912475586,
0.7394872903823853,
0.20916491746902466,
0.9827763438224792,
0.22000595927238464,
0.3111013174057007,
0.30806222558021545,
0.20397065579891205,
-0.8178478479385376,
0.7732122540473938,
0.15647737681865692,
-0.5305811166763306,
-0.47802308201789856,
-0.24922893941402435,
-0.6434745192527771,
0.4684169590473175,
-0.3052496016025543,
-0.7064257860183716,
0.1269245445728302,
-0.022664980962872505,
-0.3392057716846466,
0.25004762411117554,
-0.4203000068664551,
0.24072036147117615,
-0.1702939122915268,
-0.36441704630851746,
-0.46889108419418335,
-0.6130920648574829,
0.16566906869411469,
0.10193885862827301,
0.3557921051979065,
-0.15906333923339844,
0.28129640221595764,
0.49537748098373413,
-0.5383846163749695,
0.8302531838417053,
-0.14246517419815063,
0.048688653856515884,
0.5438311100006104,
0.3169572353363037,
0.7610105872154236,
0.11437450349330902,
-0.2267715185880661,
-0.07760100811719894,
0.08585195243358612,
0.02987208031117916,
-0.5160412192344666,
0.7407733201980591,
-0.7701695561408997,
-0.6921172738075256,
-0.22127807140350342,
-0.6952651739120483,
-0.2310636192560196,
0.03674407675862312,
-0.3274122476577759,
0.6287218928337097,
-0.35255885124206543,
0.04014826565980911,
0.007543918211013079,
0.014628083445131779,
0.605230987071991,
1.0200210809707642,
-0.5159755349159241,
-0.5986705422401428,
0.7284939289093018,
-0.2797672152519226,
0.13545912504196167,
0.279980331659317,
0.3156542479991913,
-0.42899736762046814,
-0.3596118688583374,
-0.4795543849468231,
0.3143358528614044,
-0.4297439455986023,
-0.07190651446580887,
-0.7222533822059631,
-0.04965675622224808,
-0.29178473353385925,
-0.1442907750606537,
-0.126492440700531,
-0.046958405524492264,
-0.08905007690191269,
0.01743200421333313,
0.3331037163734436,
0.8585328459739685,
0.16253454983234406,
0.6741937398910522,
-0.6447210311889648,
0.23217636346817017,
0.24607300758361816,
0.37640485167503357,
0.10797078907489777,
-0.31416964530944824,
-0.24834044277668,
0.14553798735141754,
-0.7469983100891113,
-0.4121353328227997,
0.5818029642105103,
0.017024846747517586,
0.4328920841217041,
0.8685880899429321,
0.19548971951007843,
0.42296507954597473,
-0.5173916816711426,
0.6838365197181702,
0.3447430729866028,
-0.6238672733306885,
0.24036361277103424,
-0.17862872779369354,
0.1667092889547348,
0.5560618042945862,
-0.07579129934310913,
-0.5808749794960022,
-0.5997772216796875,
-0.2586967647075653,
-0.3724983036518097,
0.8926525712013245,
-0.015100567601621151,
0.22651946544647217,
0.03569917008280754,
0.1455216258764267,
-0.02279064990580082,
0.19797207415103912,
-0.509063184261322,
-0.16065968573093414,
0.0014108869945630431,
0.0554402619600296,
-0.48325827717781067,
-0.4688514173030853,
-0.13176465034484863,
0.22689124941825867,
0.8480047583580017,
-0.32026731967926025,
0.026263399049639702,
0.2775250971317291,
0.14879116415977478,
-0.4557001292705536,
0.6517254710197449,
0.6209326982498169,
0.6089944243431091,
-0.2519887685775757,
0.06789323687553406,
0.1791895031929016,
-0.36581143736839294,
0.3137931525707245,
-0.26230669021606445,
0.15998072922229767,
-0.22577965259552002,
-0.2929961383342743,
0.7420834302902222,
0.19573622941970825,
-0.4957296550273895,
0.537455677986145,
-0.419392466545105,
-0.07182499021291733,
-0.14978541433811188,
0.2072087824344635,
0.16360771656036377,
0.3466223180294037,
0.12972386181354523,
0.3930104076862335,
0.08261794596910477,
-0.5720959901809692,
-0.07785999774932861,
0.7286043167114258,
-0.6539920568466187,
-0.15360330045223236,
0.10741846263408661,
0.4683263301849365,
-0.7486966252326965,
0.24457396566867828,
0.23775076866149902,
-0.6911004185676575,
0.23815280199050903,
0.6131704449653625,
0.6195736527442932,
-0.41674521565437317,
0.4436399042606354,
0.015099897980690002,
0.026538461446762085,
-0.38916662335395813,
0.10967237502336502,
-0.047903917729854584,
-1.0082299709320068,
-0.33875489234924316,
-0.3808114528656006,
-0.8377032279968262,
-0.17996284365653992,
-0.20475922524929047,
0.3744134306907654,
-0.37724679708480835,
-0.42214637994766235,
-0.050716038793325424,
0.1148492619395256,
-0.4660932123661041,
0.034573499113321304,
-0.13383692502975464,
0.41915467381477356,
-0.31389495730400085,
0.7289196252822876,
0.4477342367172241,
-0.32577452063560486,
-0.9067752361297607,
-0.37548887729644775,
-0.012249668128788471,
-0.5649834871292114,
0.4370558261871338,
0.04408204182982445,
-0.9765429496765137,
-0.22908194363117218,
-0.44026830792427063,
-0.5378846526145935,
1.027500033378601,
0.2141212522983551,
-0.7400866150856018,
0.16456544399261475,
0.10756896436214447,
0.5905399918556213,
-0.7257245182991028,
0.9559832811355591,
0.0550306998193264,
0.5097126364707947,
0.6785432696342468,
-0.9888969659805298,
0.06810922175645828,
-0.11246444284915924,
0.032852787524461746,
0.23268082737922668,
-0.9907968044281006,
0.5343942642211914,
-0.5003788471221924,
0.08424334228038788,
0.13386692106723785,
0.2917012572288513,
0.43467801809310913,
0.4512598514556885,
0.571407675743103,
0.0972541943192482,
0.33925268054008484,
0.332298219203949,
0.9426738023757935,
-0.3560427725315094,
-0.055713918060064316,
1.0933470726013184,
-0.8832905888557434,
0.8848686218261719,
0.31582358479499817,
-0.047337230294942856,
0.7144583463668823,
0.16759808361530304,
0.21303553879261017,
0.3543453812599182,
0.16854152083396912,
-0.37915074825286865,
-0.3945750594139099,
-0.28942587971687317,
-0.22159443795681,
0.3969663083553314,
0.2598128318786621,
-0.07485514879226685,
0.031119853258132935,
-0.02782166562974453,
-0.035783447325229645,
-0.17473864555358887,
0.033958252519369125,
1.0277636051177979,
0.22794239223003387,
-0.7642008066177368,
0.10790874809026718,
0.07070175558328629,
0.7628527879714966,
-0.7993633151054382,
-0.19843710958957672,
-0.053225889801979065,
0.36220747232437134,
-0.12507203221321106,
-0.40708020329475403,
-0.3431631922721863,
-0.32167232036590576,
-0.19163161516189575,
-0.147101029753685,
1.005096197128296,
-0.4119429588317871,
-0.4447532594203949,
0.49257615208625793,
0.6036989092826843,
0.1790301501750946,
-0.0839272066950798,
-0.6011441349983215,
-0.10077985376119614,
-0.086510568857193,
-0.2025887668132782,
0.2030273824930191,
0.29865649342536926,
-0.19133269786834717,
1.1843949556350708,
0.7921396493911743,
0.1810937523841858,
-0.28427568078041077,
0.4093708395957947,
0.8285872340202332,
-0.6101617813110352,
-0.5569454431533813,
-0.6615259051322937,
0.1607048511505127,
0.16170048713684082,
0.02503499574959278,
0.6576881408691406,
0.38613080978393555,
0.3917457163333893,
0.10431463271379471,
0.7488078474998474,
0.37084922194480896,
0.5917981266975403,
-0.10562204569578171,
0.4641752541065216,
-0.2088724821805954,
0.6461893320083618,
-0.39284542202949524,
-1.0658314228057861,
-0.049661099910736084,
0.3132815957069397,
-0.15633593499660492,
0.3625231385231018,
0.5955523252487183,
1.1668306589126587,
0.19842150807380676,
0.154892235994339,
0.3906583786010742,
0.05066628381609917,
0.585469126701355,
0.4296536445617676,
1.0587056875228882,
0.01101800985634327,
0.7398582100868225,
0.14178574085235596,
-0.12632572650909424,
-0.5982238054275513,
-0.5447037220001221,
-0.8667470216751099,
-0.3444136083126068,
-0.054267700761556625,
-0.22465941309928894,
0.16318678855895996,
1.0729882717132568,
0.7743924260139465,
-0.7845937013626099,
-0.6078943610191345,
0.1584932804107666,
0.09859414398670197,
-0.14738072454929352,
-0.18841007351875305,
0.08934847265481949,
-0.252808153629303,
-0.49685990810394287,
0.5611439943313599,
0.40176522731781006,
0.012731799855828285,
-0.48016294836997986,
-0.771895706653595,
-0.1587514877319336,
0.4756416976451874,
0.5616245865821838,
-0.06798269599676132,
-1.0553480386734009,
-0.2995947003364563,
-0.13282860815525055,
-0.3610415458679199,
0.16438503563404083,
1.009648323059082,
-0.7340841889381409,
0.5205408334732056,
0.1533748209476471,
0.07204940170049667,
0.6292026042938232,
0.09853480011224747,
0.6607510447502136,
-0.30661770701408386,
-0.1671806275844574,
-0.018518853932619095,
0.35124778747558594,
0.15842501819133759,
-0.4032869040966034,
0.20902125537395477,
-0.3437202274799347,
-0.7810608148574829,
-0.3330284655094147,
0.0808219462633133,
-1.3394893407821655,
-0.12642645835876465,
1.1806471347808838,
0.041699234396219254,
0.16476960480213165,
-0.33140358328819275,
-1.0299657583236694,
0.0984765887260437,
-1.223510980606079,
0.7068122029304504,
0.7143502235412598,
-0.2706923484802246,
-0.19795197248458862,
-0.19148342311382294,
0.1536208540201187,
0.33739641308784485,
-0.5584811568260193,
-0.021481936797499657,
0.5913339257240295,
0.1848488599061966,
0.26819610595703125,
1.0199428796768188,
0.17319615185260773,
-0.09103413671255112,
-0.4105573296546936,
0.2821185886859894,
-0.35247603058815,
-0.6022743582725525,
-0.07193710654973984,
0.3728613257408142,
0.2687813937664032,
0.10197468847036362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01118v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01118v3 | PokeLLMon: A Human-Parity Agent for Pokemon Battles with Large Language Models | 2024-02-02T03:22:12 | 2024-04-02T15:46:35 | Sihao Hu, Tiansheng Huang, Ling Liu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We introduce PokeLLMon, the first LLM-embodied agent that achieves
human-parity performance in tactical battle games, as demonstrated in Pokemon
battles. The design of PokeLLMon incorporates three key strategies: (i)
In-context reinforcement learning that instantly consumes text-based feedback
derived from battles to iteratively refine the policy; (ii) Knowledge-augmented
generation that retrieves external knowledge to counteract hallucination and
enables the agent to act timely and properly; (iii) Consistent action
generation to mitigate the panic switching phenomenon when the agent faces a
powerful opponent and wants to elude the battle. We show that online battles
against human demonstrates PokeLLMon's human-like battle strategies and
just-in-time decision making, achieving 49% of win rate in the Ladder
competitions and 56% of win rate in the invited battles. Our implementation and
playable battle logs are available at: https://github.com/git-disl/PokeLLMon. | [
-0.38398244976997375,
-0.9156293272972107,
0.6767840385437012,
0.4969857335090637,
0.022974615916609764,
0.5165283679962158,
-0.3746819496154785,
-0.39834102988243103,
0.8241726160049438,
0.1976085901260376,
-0.44369980692863464,
-0.3542478084564209,
-0.3629021644592285,
0.06386055797338486,
0.011371168307960033,
0.593444287776947,
0.07342901080846786,
-0.025735411792993546,
0.058064285665750504,
0.009157567285001278,
-0.41781625151634216,
-0.6343734264373779,
-1.0502312183380127,
-0.7663052082061768,
0.5791245102882385,
0.460719496011734,
0.8343614935874939,
0.5189131498336792,
0.4528381824493408,
0.40090787410736084,
0.0295233316719532,
0.0869203731417656,
-0.5908235907554626,
0.15155743062496185,
-0.5803650617599487,
-0.8236297369003296,
-0.8956509232521057,
0.2447790801525116,
0.388864129781723,
0.4032193124294281,
-0.3633657395839691,
-0.16140761971473694,
-0.15247002243995667,
0.5588611960411072,
-0.1235637292265892,
0.0450538732111454,
-0.5218321084976196,
0.3150046169757843,
-0.20068350434303284,
-0.3166823983192444,
-0.18889276683330536,
0.03245163336396217,
0.2455129474401474,
-1.103860855102539,
0.33382174372673035,
0.3013923764228821,
0.8124815821647644,
-0.03243051841855049,
-0.05349593609571457,
-0.17031757533550262,
-0.4873817563056946,
0.5747721195220947,
-0.39583253860473633,
0.11081419140100479,
0.50877445936203,
0.4492703974246979,
-0.49126991629600525,
-0.6806324124336243,
-0.4079973101615906,
-0.35407310724258423,
0.29030171036720276,
0.41817396879196167,
-0.20675981044769287,
0.05821901559829712,
0.13256412744522095,
-0.01060099434107542,
-0.4234778881072998,
0.07040063291788101,
-0.16327472031116486,
0.11330869793891907,
0.922646701335907,
0.30488121509552,
0.4486214518547058,
0.009217238053679466,
-0.5568809509277344,
-0.1580422967672348,
-0.46732765436172485,
0.22332312166690826,
0.30211150646209717,
-0.04078609496355057,
-0.026975400745868683,
0.6234629154205322,
-0.23474861681461334,
0.004930762108415365,
0.4723578691482544,
0.04067255184054375,
-0.13719697296619415,
0.2352391928434372,
-0.11552339047193527,
0.6559589505195618,
0.8706033825874329,
0.39049506187438965,
-0.19816367328166962,
-0.49469318985939026,
-0.36603933572769165,
0.44471266865730286,
0.622036874294281,
-0.6973382830619812,
-0.4170948266983032,
0.3710058331489563,
-0.39707574248313904,
-0.492672324180603,
-0.10167479515075684,
-0.9732778072357178,
-0.829802393913269,
-0.05201006308197975,
0.7639096975326538,
-0.5856229662895203,
-0.39401087164878845,
0.3947921693325043,
-0.21468497812747955,
0.3918887972831726,
0.32269051671028137,
-0.8983404040336609,
0.40737929940223694,
0.9443274140357971,
0.7440162301063538,
-0.09241664409637451,
-0.706659734249115,
-0.42440518736839294,
0.06035599485039711,
-0.48089516162872314,
0.8971374034881592,
-0.26859429478645325,
-0.49058350920677185,
-0.32928821444511414,
-0.3894674777984619,
-0.2550634443759918,
-0.6605693101882935,
0.6235359311103821,
-0.292814165353775,
0.04952426999807358,
0.05487615615129471,
-0.8040510416030884,
0.15930962562561035,
0.45477789640426636,
-0.5965730547904968,
0.6003033518791199,
-0.0563979372382164,
-0.6192559599876404,
0.30909091234207153,
-0.8456853032112122,
-0.4434511959552765,
0.42935630679130554,
0.01500771939754486,
-0.3791000247001648,
0.1932319700717926,
-0.017879530787467957,
0.6370214819908142,
-0.24312520027160645,
0.090903140604496,
-0.44659942388534546,
-0.37136051058769226,
0.5588926076889038,
0.20415246486663818,
0.39029765129089355,
0.271553099155426,
-0.8606221079826355,
0.1317688524723053,
-0.4493417739868164,
-0.12364606559276581,
0.7469085454940796,
-0.23688293993473053,
-0.14211837947368622,
0.6746290326118469,
-0.4312393069267273,
0.05974593386054039,
0.11475329101085663,
-0.5601334571838379,
0.23813705146312714,
-0.2501072287559509,
0.25944676995277405,
0.5251383185386658,
-0.2622990608215332,
0.5620352029800415,
-0.8184828758239746,
0.2789939045906067,
-0.39758795499801636,
0.43754634261131287,
0.14404532313346863,
-0.8023365139961243,
-0.9045708775520325,
-0.434460312128067,
-0.127802774310112,
0.4689170718193054,
-0.8145763874053955,
0.5523494482040405,
-0.3491867482662201,
-0.41932669281959534,
-0.4607689082622528,
-0.041029833257198334,
0.21043768525123596,
0.42805585265159607,
0.14227637648582458,
-0.1032283753156662,
-0.4593816101551056,
-0.4278166592121124,
-0.42237338423728943,
-0.5728892087936401,
0.1136276125907898,
0.11091966927051544,
0.11433529853820801,
-0.6002227663993835,
0.7545589208602905,
-0.0418664775788784,
-0.20366153120994568,
-0.8359202146530151,
0.22030213475227356,
-0.03504627197980881,
0.37210583686828613,
0.2795369327068329,
-0.5274062156677246,
-0.3605961799621582,
0.12364678084850311,
-0.9666016697883606,
-0.14773592352867126,
-0.2789127826690674,
-0.5734735727310181,
-0.2376297265291214,
0.2702717185020447,
-0.7682509422302246,
0.2066914588212967,
0.3418879210948944,
-0.8325932025909424,
0.20781029760837555,
-0.2962220311164856,
0.3520750403404236,
-1.0846335887908936,
-0.22372102737426758,
0.06766294687986374,
-0.4372556209564209,
-0.963912844657898,
0.37494802474975586,
0.1939520388841629,
-0.19282667338848114,
-0.4900142550468445,
0.8145310878753662,
0.04651389643549919,
0.13132165372371674,
-0.09923288226127625,
0.5507775545120239,
0.06091511622071266,
0.2910231947898865,
0.3048405051231384,
0.6674025058746338,
0.20347759127616882,
-0.6951584219932556,
0.48558810353279114,
0.23752069473266602,
-0.07309751957654953,
1.1010454893112183,
-0.7964791655540466,
-0.03554556891322136,
0.09675834327936172,
0.0320858359336853,
-0.5441553592681885,
-0.4031340181827545,
0.20415768027305603,
-0.5683797001838684,
0.2531737983226776,
-0.03195488080382347,
-0.297852486371994,
-0.16469725966453552,
-0.6409192681312561,
-0.025711139664053917,
0.6452804207801819,
-0.7651066780090332,
0.7038004398345947,
0.565352737903595,
0.1789087951183319,
0.0742335170507431,
-0.22907565534114838,
0.28849220275878906,
-0.5982869863510132,
-0.7398463487625122,
0.21607442200183868,
-0.10740562528371811,
-0.4969298541545868,
-0.3823511302471161,
0.18938259780406952,
0.0980885848402977,
0.4597412049770355,
0.20724143087863922,
0.2812487483024597,
0.037421680986881256,
-0.23656873404979706,
-0.44839397072792053,
-0.03707423433661461,
0.24677930772304535,
-0.1258562058210373,
0.5645197629928589,
-0.09181220829486847,
-0.24930621683597565,
-0.3923146426677704,
0.18318645656108856,
0.31882983446121216,
0.2766386866569519,
0.5595932602882385,
0.5011079907417297,
-0.2277163416147232,
-0.25587010383605957,
-0.5387688279151917,
-0.09866426885128021,
-0.4322998523712158,
0.470527708530426,
-0.49485281109809875,
-0.4378005862236023,
0.4476451277732849,
-0.3666475713253021,
0.024085761979222298,
0.49695858359336853,
0.5097485780715942,
-0.5092340111732483,
1.2438405752182007,
0.15580163896083832,
-0.10574127733707428,
0.4776521921157837,
-0.20104525983333588,
-0.12148319184780121,
-0.7546114325523376,
-0.4973790943622589,
-0.19741550087928772,
-0.5922959446907043,
-0.29140594601631165,
-0.49616560339927673,
0.21150320768356323,
0.30949991941452026,
-0.345502644777298,
0.3284560739994049,
-0.010045827366411686,
0.4404865801334381,
0.44362130761146545,
0.40046948194503784,
-0.012142137624323368,
-0.09263116866350174,
0.04270031303167343,
-0.2550337612628937,
-0.8958055377006531,
-0.3350132703781128,
1.144936442375183,
0.5775777101516724,
1.08773672580719,
0.2876115143299103,
1.1650664806365967,
0.45734521746635437,
0.17075303196907043,
-0.6236017346382141,
0.5627668499946594,
0.48124200105667114,
-0.5332279205322266,
-0.22446995973587036,
-0.6649868488311768,
-1.2875549793243408,
0.2963888943195343,
-0.5514306426048279,
-0.525422990322113,
-0.2306327372789383,
0.05031152814626694,
-0.28883036971092224,
0.597651481628418,
-0.9023020267486572,
0.6667714715003967,
-0.5546634197235107,
-0.6110981106758118,
-0.3919420838356018,
-0.3223588168621063,
0.396043598651886,
0.18944941461086273,
0.04786995053291321,
-0.20696556568145752,
-0.2503724694252014,
0.6031565070152283,
-0.23651918768882751,
0.5798368453979492,
-0.10209312289953232,
0.16420088708400726,
0.13960003852844238,
0.4415441155433655,
0.7170372009277344,
0.342372328042984,
0.38317975401878357,
0.0893116220831871,
-0.29709291458129883,
-0.7013134360313416,
-0.36146849393844604,
0.6597303152084351,
-1.0362290143966675,
-0.5380343794822693,
-0.6195541024208069,
-0.0435151569545269,
-0.3396843373775482,
-0.06267146021127701,
0.22522473335266113,
0.11693946272134781,
-0.7219518423080444,
-0.05847984552383423,
1.2434301376342773,
-0.2504236102104187,
0.29697051644325256,
0.5231547355651855,
-0.4661511480808258,
-0.5515249967575073,
1.1661655902862549,
-0.5102340579032898,
0.03281579911708832,
0.44938749074935913,
0.3628534972667694,
-0.47303950786590576,
-0.09313471615314484,
-0.441327303647995,
0.35129353404045105,
-0.23991021513938904,
-0.11411990970373154,
-0.45536068081855774,
0.0154662961140275,
0.0702284723520279,
-0.48541459441185,
-0.6269965767860413,
-0.30501964688301086,
-0.1716863214969635,
0.2519514858722687,
0.10149168968200684,
1.0953562259674072,
0.002438189461827278,
0.2814629375934601,
-0.4563724994659424,
0.539158821105957,
0.7633997797966003,
0.41825851798057556,
-0.44416171312332153,
-0.3168325424194336,
-0.03164549171924591,
-0.11719535291194916,
-0.23234602808952332,
-0.7376030087471008,
0.3576718270778656,
0.0708082765340805,
0.6740914583206177,
0.45458880066871643,
-0.13870450854301453,
0.6145123839378357,
-0.43818482756614685,
0.6110158562660217,
0.33846336603164673,
-0.7073291540145874,
0.37851542234420776,
-0.37312939763069153,
0.137287899851799,
0.3819277584552765,
0.05713856965303421,
-0.6593894362449646,
-0.2671869695186615,
-0.8277722597122192,
-0.4609073996543884,
0.9256157875061035,
0.3290998041629791,
-0.236444890499115,
-0.01816205307841301,
0.12580138444900513,
-0.157034769654274,
-0.025097308680415154,
-0.3034813106060028,
-0.1712316870689392,
-0.20275184512138367,
-0.07773856818675995,
-0.3666030466556549,
-0.3270632028579712,
-0.1493234634399414,
-0.09525630623102188,
0.6537821292877197,
0.16264180839061737,
0.420441210269928,
0.37156015634536743,
-0.44562119245529175,
-0.05081883817911148,
0.16317524015903473,
0.6521018743515015,
0.33995485305786133,
-0.4321903586387634,
0.17407390475273132,
0.20487824082374573,
-0.7003974914550781,
0.2294115424156189,
0.09690690040588379,
-0.018276596441864967,
-0.16761696338653564,
0.3615504503250122,
0.616059422492981,
0.5507473945617676,
-0.8060234785079956,
0.538275957107544,
-0.662223756313324,
-0.4403160512447357,
0.0380612276494503,
0.19504736363887787,
-0.029526744037866592,
0.8370537757873535,
0.3671298027038574,
-0.16050167381763458,
-0.06391070038080215,
-0.4998798370361328,
0.10571983456611633,
0.36322519183158875,
-0.144102081656456,
-0.5539841651916504,
1.03506600856781,
0.4414638578891754,
-0.4559633433818817,
-0.2280675321817398,
-0.5464336276054382,
-0.6267294883728027,
0.34159916639328003,
0.5967077016830444,
0.9687908887863159,
-0.1634661853313446,
0.45915016531944275,
0.13056929409503937,
0.24182741343975067,
-0.3040149211883545,
0.22499525547027588,
0.11633744090795517,
-0.41931143403053284,
-0.004041466396301985,
-0.33016085624694824,
-0.6449208855628967,
0.029894933104515076,
-0.20720180869102478,
0.06256131082773209,
-0.8594188094139099,
-0.2868019640445709,
-0.27198320627212524,
0.48102957010269165,
-0.6600525975227356,
-0.3556087017059326,
0.43354129791259766,
1.0230202674865723,
-0.4394513666629791,
0.5447988510131836,
0.8960373401641846,
-0.2577223777770996,
-0.4798477292060852,
-0.1820428967475891,
-0.04551669955253601,
-0.6484299898147583,
0.4004376232624054,
-0.1767415851354599,
0.3329099118709564,
-0.039451323449611664,
-0.3905363082885742,
-0.4071216881275177,
1.3109573125839233,
0.4193383455276489,
-0.48430219292640686,
0.14953427016735077,
0.2022855579853058,
0.25266826152801514,
-0.20118948817253113,
0.286717027425766,
0.7600963115692139,
0.2599722146987915,
-0.21809056401252747,
-0.5753500461578369,
-0.4007306694984436,
-0.1911110281944275,
0.1915864795446396,
0.11567330360412598,
-0.8859323263168335,
0.9187135100364685,
0.23504769802093506,
-0.15748532116413116,
0.07038320600986481,
0.6025659441947937,
0.5204358696937561,
0.4636770188808441,
0.15713846683502197,
0.8151238560676575,
0.696114718914032,
-0.2601134181022644,
1.0837993621826172,
-0.19366593658924103,
0.3069433867931366,
0.6967513561248779,
-0.5257884860038757,
0.661104142665863,
0.16180673241615295,
-0.4543701708316803,
0.15388613939285278,
0.4427168071269989,
0.6865707635879517,
0.3619876801967621,
-0.0950961709022522,
-0.5878301858901978,
-0.25003841519355774,
0.04671435058116913,
-0.24116256833076477,
0.16465486586093903,
0.2277253419160843,
0.23651207983493805,
-0.1340291053056717,
-0.25313475728034973,
0.2913331389427185,
0.28447285294532776,
-0.5348268747329712,
0.9975394010543823,
-0.2640647292137146,
-0.5206338763237,
0.33550316095352173,
0.18043337762355804,
0.9941266775131226,
-0.8003683686256409,
0.036089640110731125,
-0.8156875967979431,
0.3865782618522644,
-0.010311088524758816,
-0.6009678840637207,
-0.4271984100341797,
-0.07702983915805817,
0.12159109115600586,
-0.0418664924800396,
0.72853022813797,
-0.3623195290565491,
-0.20624393224716187,
0.1973361372947693,
0.37090468406677246,
0.03427572920918465,
-0.11917545646429062,
-0.7356499433517456,
0.20633776485919952,
-0.343521386384964,
-0.1315629631280899,
0.7218384742736816,
0.6729570627212524,
0.011613035574555397,
0.6800005435943604,
0.3873674273490906,
0.4809274673461914,
0.4935828447341919,
-0.2868203818798065,
0.6870443224906921,
-0.6784058809280396,
-0.5625739693641663,
-0.6419280171394348,
0.13936693966388702,
-0.47977301478385925,
-0.06790309399366379,
0.8197683095932007,
0.5604006052017212,
0.5797698497772217,
0.10810715705156326,
0.6143891215324402,
-0.1210249811410904,
0.4251859188079834,
-0.3694967031478882,
0.8379472494125366,
-0.22917960584163666,
0.01426804717630148,
-0.1711161583662033,
-0.6795518398284912,
-0.1017153188586235,
0.7404562830924988,
0.15999427437782288,
-0.4981594383716583,
0.5648188591003418,
0.5312072038650513,
-0.24801085889339447,
-0.17936202883720398,
0.6433352828025818,
-0.28846895694732666,
0.4552600681781769,
0.8343753814697266,
1.2600566148757935,
-0.39281296730041504,
0.20950625836849213,
-0.3445613980293274,
-0.3766348958015442,
-0.5419511795043945,
-0.5692278146743774,
-1.4740042686462402,
-0.4106360673904419,
-0.07127021253108978,
-0.4319303333759308,
0.24294641613960266,
1.4810935258865356,
0.5434132814407349,
-0.5454484820365906,
-0.5301952362060547,
0.08508434146642685,
0.14327609539031982,
0.09494776278734207,
-0.1648225039243698,
-0.14567071199417114,
-0.7956010699272156,
-0.5927339792251587,
0.7324122190475464,
0.29983633756637573,
-0.058336809277534485,
-0.052434276789426804,
-0.880816638469696,
-0.22601383924484253,
0.1612175703048706,
0.7329102754592896,
0.7481145858764648,
-0.47249406576156616,
0.07665707170963287,
-0.08691731095314026,
-0.42798635363578796,
0.023365557193756104,
1.0347076654434204,
-0.7179006338119507,
0.7192128300666809,
0.21662390232086182,
0.9626125693321228,
0.23173564672470093,
-0.059055544435977936,
0.4478493332862854,
-0.5570252537727356,
0.5015827417373657,
0.19755826890468597,
0.4953363835811615,
0.09792988002300262,
-0.17537710070610046,
0.5675817131996155,
0.39100950956344604,
-0.4931529462337494,
-0.42966583371162415,
-0.22262117266654968,
-0.6172055602073669,
-0.09924659132957458,
1.1482093334197998,
-0.1300874799489975,
-0.4781467914581299,
0.055001482367515564,
-0.5772826671600342,
0.04465440660715103,
-0.5614288449287415,
1.0341345071792603,
0.3239419162273407,
-0.09309258311986923,
0.1904238909482956,
-0.5368027687072754,
0.6940656304359436,
0.33648237586021423,
-1.0005766153335571,
-0.1867617517709732,
0.3227975368499756,
0.005190644413232803,
-0.15298278629779816,
0.540911853313446,
0.1811145693063736,
0.4411362409591675,
0.09941437095403671,
0.26717710494995117,
0.022579137235879898,
-0.27744030952453613,
-0.3494565188884735,
-0.17424310743808746,
0.27452483773231506,
-0.12464410811662674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01117v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01117v1 | DTS-SQL: Decomposed Text-to-SQL with Small Large Language Models | 2024-02-02T03:21:00 | 2024-02-02T03:21:00 | Mohammadreza Pourreza, Davood Rafiei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.HC | Leading models for the text-to-SQL task heavily rely on proprietary Large
Language Models (LLMs), posing concerns over data privacy. Closing the
performance gap between small open-source models and large proprietary models
is crucial to mitigate this reliance. To this end, we introduce a novel
two-stage fine-tuning approach that decomposes the task into two simpler tasks.
Through comprehensive evaluation on two large cross-domain datasets and two
small LLMs, we show that this approach improves execution accuracy by 3 to 7
percent, effectively aligning the performance of open-source models with their
proprietary counterparts. | [
-0.038253672420978546,
-0.814233124256134,
0.5270455479621887,
-0.09864670038223267,
-0.4793857932090759,
-0.04378703609108925,
-0.4373018443584442,
-0.2890956699848175,
-0.2508220970630646,
0.7171070575714111,
-0.6177073121070862,
-0.7406393885612488,
-0.6879598498344421,
0.19104509055614471,
-0.5334939956665039,
0.8287078142166138,
0.21513855457305908,
0.07945582270622253,
-0.12608182430267334,
0.02665243297815323,
-0.3305397629737854,
-0.11888094991445541,
-0.7498847246170044,
-0.00897992867976427,
0.2425452321767807,
0.5220268964767456,
0.6757959723472595,
0.9436700344085693,
0.4871520400047302,
0.22081148624420166,
-0.27999943494796753,
0.5436727404594421,
-0.7282412052154541,
0.40944215655326843,
-0.5182538628578186,
-0.6975806951522827,
-0.5341953039169312,
-0.29480981826782227,
0.5667344331741333,
0.6385325789451599,
-0.10877840965986252,
0.41667792201042175,
0.32330822944641113,
1.0578551292419434,
-0.4705105423927307,
0.24512892961502075,
-0.6876616477966309,
-0.13832587003707886,
-0.25259116291999817,
-0.1879047304391861,
-0.6260508298873901,
-0.41235387325286865,
-0.006969723384827375,
-0.3313467800617218,
0.4353511333465576,
-0.07959137856960297,
0.5272645950317383,
0.4751981198787689,
-0.6487598419189453,
0.04791446030139923,
-0.9129499793052673,
0.9050328731536865,
-0.6108439564704895,
0.5063108801841736,
0.2335149645805359,
0.131303071975708,
-0.009145651943981647,
-0.6420593857765198,
-0.3262307345867157,
-0.05518113821744919,
-0.2879946231842041,
-0.38812875747680664,
-0.07365427911281586,
-0.028603868559002876,
0.17203201353549957,
0.2760998010635376,
-0.538677453994751,
0.43565332889556885,
-0.48060110211372375,
0.2865164577960968,
0.6719484925270081,
0.5539922714233398,
-0.13895757496356964,
0.05964216962456703,
-0.16484612226486206,
0.30937010049819946,
-0.8729336857795715,
-0.2943967282772064,
0.04259645193815231,
1.0413250923156738,
-0.08210191130638123,
0.9247725605964661,
-0.31257396936416626,
0.7425464391708374,
0.21030643582344055,
-0.013879014179110527,
-0.11054971814155579,
-0.504414975643158,
-0.47727012634277344,
-0.17828421294689178,
0.5734732151031494,
0.49431732296943665,
0.2201347053050995,
-0.48691824078559875,
-0.18447738885879517,
0.13862812519073486,
0.25499117374420166,
-0.9711833596229553,
-0.03282640874385834,
0.5461286306381226,
-0.6879642605781555,
-0.2780916690826416,
-0.22090567648410797,
-0.8193187117576599,
-0.579860508441925,
-0.6960980296134949,
0.37165120244026184,
-0.30060380697250366,
-0.269130140542984,
-0.1428118199110031,
0.04189449921250343,
-0.0371837317943573,
0.44335225224494934,
-0.700052797794342,
0.7034990787506104,
1.0936005115509033,
0.9713747501373291,
-0.5977171063423157,
0.09731791913509369,
-0.7848655581474304,
0.4161776304244995,
-0.6777783632278442,
0.44990602135658264,
-0.5244724154472351,
-0.4069731533527374,
-0.14714550971984863,
0.10730209946632385,
0.03735022991895676,
-0.5925469994544983,
0.388018935918808,
-0.5208926200866699,
0.1791943907737732,
-0.3003598749637604,
-0.6733231544494629,
0.23800165951251984,
0.045105475932359695,
-0.5877609252929688,
1.2432266473770142,
0.2041691690683365,
-0.5632822513580322,
0.27020367980003357,
-0.8122429251670837,
-0.514494001865387,
-0.17568284273147583,
-0.15918312966823578,
-0.46429523825645447,
0.41251569986343384,
0.11797928810119629,
0.6617269515991211,
-0.6540316343307495,
0.09552286565303802,
-0.14239434897899628,
-0.5240929126739502,
-0.311225563287735,
0.14596770703792572,
0.7360196709632874,
0.4403330385684967,
-0.33011049032211304,
-0.0555666945874691,
-0.8594930171966553,
0.09010401368141174,
0.1977459043264389,
-0.34531915187835693,
-0.572981059551239,
0.13968835771083832,
-0.1059647649526596,
0.016016559675335884,
0.16792871057987213,
-0.5671066045761108,
0.07385715842247009,
-0.6788803935050964,
0.5610933303833008,
0.5553172826766968,
-0.2346685230731964,
0.8707534670829773,
-0.013592595234513283,
0.31004586815834045,
0.335740864276886,
0.059434592723846436,
0.009427841752767563,
-0.233477383852005,
-0.6254615783691406,
-0.331903338432312,
0.3747137486934662,
0.4785674512386322,
-0.5730311870574951,
0.47290557622909546,
-0.4816274046897888,
-0.5334975719451904,
-0.35736244916915894,
-0.026642370969057083,
0.3023635149002075,
0.46194690465927124,
0.40847358107566833,
-0.09068533033132553,
-0.33776092529296875,
-0.9223803281784058,
-0.5689771175384521,
0.2654446065425873,
-0.3577476739883423,
0.10307559370994568,
0.4096009433269501,
-0.017529698088765144,
0.789783239364624,
-0.664344847202301,
-0.6830338835716248,
-0.040180597454309464,
-0.0789700374007225,
-0.053185608237981796,
0.6076750755310059,
0.4938168525695801,
-0.38168996572494507,
-0.5501429438591003,
-0.04692140221595764,
-0.3150870203971863,
0.12297553569078445,
0.29625433683395386,
0.14537078142166138,
0.6589738130569458,
0.619156002998352,
-0.6234192848205566,
0.47708797454833984,
0.3878820836544037,
-0.5609586238861084,
0.20919255912303925,
-0.2418774515390396,
0.10167748481035233,
-1.1584089994430542,
-0.1443806290626526,
0.06963774561882019,
-0.2297085076570511,
-0.676525354385376,
0.15394753217697144,
0.3273352384567261,
-0.2994295060634613,
-0.3095267713069916,
0.23544812202453613,
-0.6100543737411499,
-0.18278810381889343,
-0.0926494225859642,
-0.03968832269310951,
0.07097403705120087,
0.1834598183631897,
-0.018117418512701988,
0.9028235673904419,
0.467266708612442,
-0.7066242694854736,
0.023592254146933556,
0.3729885220527649,
-0.39263397455215454,
0.6666345000267029,
-0.7570251226425171,
0.24194982647895813,
-0.2486947625875473,
0.0656600371003151,
-0.9958865642547607,
0.01697155274450779,
-0.09928202629089355,
-0.22325213253498077,
0.5835109949111938,
-0.4040857255458832,
-0.6624860763549805,
0.025005927309393883,
-0.4005619287490845,
0.018092580139636993,
0.46382012963294983,
-0.4831424355506897,
0.7654047012329102,
0.22719812393188477,
-0.2124907225370407,
-0.40540391206741333,
-1.102843165397644,
0.21104638278484344,
-0.08303797990083694,
-0.6339062452316284,
0.5760847330093384,
0.41314414143562317,
-0.26281294226646423,
0.07291723787784576,
-0.28592002391815186,
-0.3435203731060028,
-0.0789603590965271,
0.09131018817424774,
0.05718689411878586,
-0.22993877530097961,
0.10878711938858032,
0.36486944556236267,
-0.1001671776175499,
-0.11191466450691223,
-0.28358370065689087,
0.2946210503578186,
0.27074748277664185,
0.023453017696738243,
-0.6141746044158936,
0.7404892444610596,
0.6237186789512634,
-0.31798800826072693,
0.9820148944854736,
0.21535950899124146,
-0.3772621750831604,
-0.601513683795929,
-0.33499112725257874,
-0.28584563732147217,
-0.500100314617157,
0.3392186760902405,
-0.5572223663330078,
-0.9372343420982361,
0.1634518802165985,
-0.24705761671066284,
0.062335386872291565,
0.5028973817825317,
0.5506729483604431,
0.030844002962112427,
0.929107666015625,
0.8854724764823914,
0.3392845392227173,
0.34943437576293945,
-0.1553928107023239,
0.39745399355888367,
-0.43553221225738525,
-0.48928648233413696,
-1.1070621013641357,
-0.1523178666830063,
-0.5890207290649414,
-0.6097478866577148,
0.20357710123062134,
-0.1765698939561844,
-0.5516337156295776,
0.451691210269928,
-0.8056018948554993,
0.6197329759597778,
0.46291881799697876,
0.3210989236831665,
0.713715136051178,
0.2484811395406723,
0.19105690717697144,
-0.0843198150396347,
-0.4113149344921112,
-0.560824453830719,
1.3074965476989746,
0.27505290508270264,
0.8711841702461243,
0.12100253999233246,
0.6667721271514893,
0.20398759841918945,
-0.1989978551864624,
-0.5452432036399841,
0.6125718951225281,
-0.8116296529769897,
-0.6676260232925415,
-0.4422364830970764,
-0.4079047739505768,
-0.6909193992614746,
0.07308230549097061,
-0.10066953301429749,
-0.6950061321258545,
0.16623613238334656,
-0.056605007499456406,
-0.29344841837882996,
0.25737807154655457,
-1.0675348043441772,
0.6396342515945435,
0.3093290627002716,
-0.4035223722457886,
-0.44708505272865295,
-0.721300482749939,
0.40835991501808167,
-0.1258671134710312,
0.14128413796424866,
-0.10886583477258682,
-0.4561448097229004,
0.7798956632614136,
-0.7686663866043091,
0.7101669311523438,
-0.31628933548927307,
-0.33868637681007385,
-0.024868054315447807,
0.41015690565109253,
0.7981755137443542,
-0.06195935979485512,
-0.3233014643192291,
0.33437103033065796,
0.4727708101272583,
-0.285089373588562,
-0.5795510411262512,
0.7777470350265503,
-0.44079217314720154,
-0.4473918378353119,
-0.20279547572135925,
-0.522450864315033,
-0.33134734630584717,
0.11126094311475754,
0.04476190358400345,
0.2923244833946228,
-0.0706365555524826,
0.2756443917751312,
0.760125458240509,
-0.12151237577199936,
0.25673845410346985,
0.7528387904167175,
0.13774031400680542,
-0.20142553746700287,
0.30986279249191284,
0.16496548056602478,
0.2815208435058594,
0.557300865650177,
-0.14717651903629303,
-0.48833078145980835,
-0.8477993011474609,
-0.13136638700962067,
0.23884476721286774,
-0.3784370720386505,
-0.30891337990760803,
-0.6418200731277466,
0.21623213589191437,
-0.5681750774383545,
0.12132135778665543,
-0.7352715134620667,
-0.7613216042518616,
-0.5069221258163452,
0.026911940425634384,
0.5352832674980164,
0.7161429524421692,
0.07327336072921753,
0.26880669593811035,
-0.9205304384231567,
0.5827252864837646,
0.01628822833299637,
0.9098265171051025,
-0.15065670013427734,
-0.44562020897865295,
-0.2681713104248047,
-0.08849692344665527,
-0.0564890094101429,
-0.7235826253890991,
0.17172452807426453,
0.28662633895874023,
-0.006821715272963047,
0.03932845965027809,
0.2927457094192505,
0.6372327208518982,
-0.7456896901130676,
0.9778317213058472,
-0.04486292600631714,
-1.0537186861038208,
0.6973403692245483,
-0.2330169677734375,
-0.03781763091683388,
0.5276646614074707,
0.2187781035900116,
-0.05652371421456337,
-0.2651878297328949,
-0.15758496522903442,
-0.621189534664154,
1.1564240455627441,
0.2520778477191925,
-0.08035429567098618,
0.2519647181034088,
0.415458083152771,
0.27497541904449463,
0.16450339555740356,
-0.2224767506122589,
-0.4518139660358429,
0.3178592920303345,
-0.2341180145740509,
-0.2942245900630951,
-0.5564092397689819,
-0.3321680426597595,
-0.43822529911994934,
0.340586394071579,
-0.04998985305428505,
0.35239177942276,
-0.12181605398654938,
0.10005325824022293,
-0.28939759731292725,
0.21854867041110992,
0.36463463306427,
0.7038296461105347,
-0.20559732615947723,
0.05855007842183113,
0.1581946164369583,
-0.40160539746284485,
0.059041209518909454,
0.09056897461414337,
-0.23792187869548798,
0.06196849048137665,
-0.14446359872817993,
0.3535390794277191,
-0.18912312388420105,
-0.4055212140083313,
0.3461131453514099,
-0.0453752726316452,
-0.1810101866722107,
0.10527202486991882,
-0.042974937707185745,
0.2274380326271057,
0.3072150945663452,
0.31275826692581177,
0.15354682505130768,
0.13548718392848969,
-0.2760862112045288,
0.23481886088848114,
0.30756300687789917,
-0.05933646485209465,
-0.18992957472801208,
0.971878707408905,
0.26600492000579834,
-0.29316920042037964,
0.3180515170097351,
0.13817675411701202,
0.005818160250782967,
0.5241576433181763,
0.3319138288497925,
0.9168281555175781,
-0.4516468644142151,
0.08469659835100174,
0.2275143414735794,
0.47739994525909424,
-0.40421587228775024,
0.6702519655227661,
0.15310829877853394,
-0.1911579817533493,
-0.6799951195716858,
-0.37010064721107483,
-0.2988240122795105,
0.05218514800071716,
-0.6166970729827881,
0.42422521114349365,
-0.32031404972076416,
0.05214409530162811,
0.09835617989301682,
0.18966487050056458,
-0.5925342440605164,
0.3311229348182678,
-0.196858212351799,
1.119490623474121,
-0.586692750453949,
1.0055159330368042,
0.252656489610672,
-0.16396431624889374,
-0.6418188810348511,
-0.18178345263004303,
-0.0788874551653862,
-0.3993813991546631,
0.7001211643218994,
-0.17186416685581207,
0.10667596012353897,
0.0391061045229435,
-0.32918182015419006,
-0.8434551954269409,
0.9315555095672607,
0.6492886543273926,
-0.859283983707428,
-0.4223790168762207,
0.590781569480896,
0.5334429144859314,
-0.2531173825263977,
-0.11236882209777832,
1.0374951362609863,
0.2971895933151245,
-0.17306797206401825,
-1.0405396223068237,
0.4082680344581604,
0.30225902795791626,
0.3321886658668518,
0.47200876474380493,
-0.44614022970199585,
0.7910700440406799,
-0.18973040580749512,
-0.33428558707237244,
0.020697668194770813,
0.4479573965072632,
-0.19209960103034973,
0.3073287308216095,
0.4086369574069977,
0.6070863604545593,
0.6098588109016418,
-0.20859958231449127,
0.8065930008888245,
-0.3717825710773468,
0.3876005709171295,
1.2344701290130615,
-0.3141433596611023,
0.8172821998596191,
0.3738328516483307,
-0.38660839200019836,
0.26495346426963806,
0.48084867000579834,
0.17324644327163696,
0.756245493888855,
-0.014504505321383476,
0.08095499873161316,
-0.07111682742834091,
0.11349279433488846,
-0.4443913996219635,
0.3912146985530853,
0.3623628616333008,
-0.5052030086517334,
-0.5783109664916992,
-0.2648840844631195,
0.03515598177909851,
0.24420541524887085,
-0.3215278089046478,
0.7738716006278992,
0.12584201991558075,
-0.4921703338623047,
0.5988959670066833,
0.2722892463207245,
0.587916374206543,
-0.39829516410827637,
0.13180987536907196,
-0.14671510457992554,
0.3437575697898865,
-0.4246959686279297,
-0.7640111446380615,
0.9011896848678589,
0.2488146871328354,
-0.18124480545520782,
-0.2458648979663849,
0.6712714433670044,
-0.6006853580474854,
-0.25458818674087524,
0.14495223760604858,
0.46178722381591797,
-0.10973460972309113,
-0.3536570370197296,
-0.5433342456817627,
0.13630908727645874,
-0.16067469120025635,
-0.36709290742874146,
0.30013933777809143,
0.6086354851722717,
0.0825827419757843,
0.4453836679458618,
0.3596506416797638,
-0.028979774564504623,
-0.09343555569648743,
-0.06971513479948044,
0.8377618193626404,
-0.7776656746864319,
-0.5965860486030579,
-0.8568610548973083,
0.5358898639678955,
-0.08084587007761002,
0.09710904210805893,
0.7602201104164124,
0.9913709163665771,
0.6151864528656006,
-0.22299718856811523,
0.6195706725120544,
-0.00247597205452621,
1.092400312423706,
-0.4629964828491211,
0.6889468431472778,
-0.6498296856880188,
0.4913875162601471,
-0.13314096629619598,
-0.8478877544403076,
-0.42510056495666504,
-0.09619554877281189,
-0.13749320805072784,
-0.11845347285270691,
0.8415794372558594,
1.0969003438949585,
0.11549639701843262,
0.0980876013636589,
0.20941203832626343,
0.27017539739608765,
0.24204833805561066,
0.4317387044429779,
0.3741861581802368,
-0.4923686981201172,
0.6594774723052979,
-0.2312672883272171,
-0.1474229246377945,
-0.07636703550815582,
-0.8617476224899292,
-0.9605953693389893,
-0.598365843296051,
-0.5003748536109924,
-0.5531136989593506,
0.1306557059288025,
0.7909882664680481,
0.6371059417724609,
-0.9637938737869263,
-0.04917294532060623,
-0.10821866989135742,
0.018476281315088272,
-0.3461088240146637,
-0.19177712500095367,
0.6039848923683167,
-0.41896528005599976,
-1.042081594467163,
0.4562873840332031,
0.3106473684310913,
-0.06041310355067253,
-0.021535448729991913,
0.28589972853660583,
0.20312082767486572,
0.2510615289211273,
0.8480715155601501,
-0.25244128704071045,
-0.5552394390106201,
-0.04814733937382698,
-0.008413698524236679,
-0.29833272099494934,
0.10083122551441193,
0.882453203201294,
-0.6913452744483948,
0.09550145268440247,
0.5613105893135071,
0.6361356973648071,
0.8250327706336975,
0.11970942467451096,
0.596799373626709,
-0.9137178063392639,
0.06993172317743301,
0.23143444955348969,
-0.06611817330121994,
0.10218393802642822,
-0.5892089009284973,
0.7611522078514099,
0.09590465575456619,
-0.40887486934661865,
-1.0750826597213745,
0.19153714179992676,
-1.0969133377075195,
-0.6050691604614258,
1.1886680126190186,
0.20909318327903748,
-0.0005269332323223352,
-0.13415008783340454,
0.009068270213901997,
0.29318034648895264,
-0.33754226565361023,
0.6654221415519714,
0.1648351401090622,
0.14027756452560425,
0.04471365734934807,
-0.2418050467967987,
0.809127151966095,
0.21717685461044312,
-0.7061483860015869,
0.43617871403694153,
0.4583473801612854,
0.5144866108894348,
-0.3227265179157257,
0.4480283558368683,
-0.39967960119247437,
-0.13800716400146484,
-0.01991802081465721,
-0.4048161506652832,
-0.32075464725494385,
-0.22616328299045563,
-0.532390296459198,
0.49053680896759033,
-0.12467578798532486,
-0.37346071004867554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01115v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01115v3 | Interpretation of Intracardiac Electrograms Through Textual Representations | 2024-02-02T03:15:13 | 2024-04-12T01:32:32 | William Jongwon Han, Diana Gomez, Avi Alok, Chaojing Duan, Michael A. Rosenberg, Douglas Weber, Emerson Liu, Ding Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.SP, I.2.7; J.3 | Understanding the irregular electrical activity of atrial fibrillation (AFib)
has been a key challenge in electrocardiography. For serious cases of AFib,
catheter ablations are performed to collect intracardiac electrograms (EGMs).
EGMs offer intricately detailed and localized electrical activity of the heart
and are an ideal modality for interpretable cardiac studies. Recent
advancements in artificial intelligence (AI) has allowed some works to utilize
deep learning frameworks to interpret EGMs during AFib. Additionally, language
models (LMs) have shown exceptional performance in being able to generalize to
unseen domains, especially in healthcare. In this study, we are the first to
leverage pretrained LMs for finetuning of EGM interpolation and AFib
classification via masked language modeling. We formulate the EGM as a textual
sequence and present competitive performances on AFib classification compared
against other representations. Lastly, we provide a comprehensive
interpretability study to provide a multi-perspective intuition of the model's
behavior, which could greatly benefit the clinical use. | [
-0.39921846985816956,
-0.9471785426139832,
0.653607964515686,
0.06993485987186432,
-0.6087847352027893,
0.1832258403301239,
-0.04927841201424599,
-0.6918275356292725,
0.2070113718509674,
0.6880663633346558,
-0.7099969983100891,
-0.7140753865242004,
-0.5252896547317505,
0.24344809353351593,
-0.4902479648590088,
0.8637517094612122,
-0.21180669963359833,
0.4025043547153473,
-0.3819347023963928,
0.06898994743824005,
-0.547546923160553,
-0.7226671576499939,
-0.3172173798084259,
-0.9535622000694275,
-0.10919812321662903,
0.11039665341377258,
0.24104861915111542,
0.4815116822719574,
0.6240931153297424,
0.24451453983783722,
0.14558710157871246,
-0.0005900597316212952,
-0.22071875631809235,
-0.2636359930038452,
0.4153699576854706,
-0.5312843322753906,
-0.27638694643974304,
-0.12476012110710144,
0.3969591557979584,
0.5599576234817505,
-0.17964333295822144,
0.13936105370521545,
-0.26517924666404724,
0.44832998514175415,
0.1916874796152115,
0.43505749106407166,
-0.317190945148468,
-0.1495412290096283,
-0.23948560655117035,
-0.4834142029285431,
-0.4902121424674988,
-0.18263663351535797,
0.20438213646411896,
-0.4112861156463623,
0.20862773060798645,
0.38949036598205566,
0.9320164322853088,
0.40546488761901855,
-0.45289209485054016,
-0.661171555519104,
-0.7000656723976135,
0.23769956827163696,
-0.416564404964447,
0.7023881673812866,
0.6842208504676819,
0.11810705810785294,
-0.04933204874396324,
-0.8888700008392334,
-0.38824713230133057,
-0.2922838032245636,
-0.45862820744514465,
-0.10290689021348953,
-0.23632143437862396,
0.36594632267951965,
0.018914084881544113,
0.4670133888721466,
-0.3412747085094452,
0.21855351328849792,
-0.5016390681266785,
-0.005965849384665489,
0.7716572284698486,
0.18214307725429535,
0.140812486410141,
0.04194408282637596,
-0.3374286890029907,
0.3949912190437317,
-0.5226180553436279,
0.09113700687885284,
0.5736124515533447,
-0.10887197405099869,
-0.4954146444797516,
0.41065749526023865,
-0.09807146340608597,
0.5295038819313049,
0.3460276424884796,
0.062408387660980225,
0.5048346519470215,
-0.12389615178108215,
-0.2582445442676544,
0.16928532719612122,
0.6539332270622253,
0.05664721131324768,
0.31988978385925293,
-0.010996810160577297,
-0.12374616414308548,
-0.3011513650417328,
0.5644460320472717,
-0.6695642471313477,
-0.44040945172309875,
0.5072712898254395,
-0.850475013256073,
-0.2505449652671814,
0.02137010358273983,
-0.5520508885383606,
-0.28585752844810486,
-0.4541686773300171,
0.3441113829612732,
-0.4623701572418213,
-0.05266887694597244,
0.2892632782459259,
0.12081173807382584,
-0.11232692003250122,
-0.054629646241664886,
-0.6625819206237793,
0.2942398190498352,
0.39864087104797363,
0.6716675162315369,
0.20770421624183655,
0.014701131731271744,
-0.061317745596170425,
-0.3096712529659271,
0.11216297745704651,
1.0742167234420776,
-0.15317662060260773,
-0.5008406043052673,
-0.0823310986161232,
-0.010235349647700787,
-0.06403487920761108,
-0.26214417815208435,
0.4306368827819824,
-0.5529081225395203,
-0.03448272868990898,
0.3878976106643677,
-0.6126202344894409,
-0.5061840415000916,
-0.13935503363609314,
-0.8966159224510193,
0.2976337671279907,
-0.10635394603013992,
-0.2933643162250519,
0.20488010346889496,
-0.7206726670265198,
-0.43206092715263367,
0.24301911890506744,
-0.3795417845249176,
-0.6581700444221497,
0.2946208119392395,
0.36871686577796936,
0.7275463938713074,
-0.2579813301563263,
0.22908152639865875,
-0.0890289694070816,
-0.36055299639701843,
0.6899176239967346,
-0.4676252603530884,
0.4686366617679596,
0.20535869896411896,
-0.2377239167690277,
0.2538922131061554,
-0.8574875593185425,
-0.13316784799098969,
-0.04275144636631012,
-0.019891999661922455,
-0.1041116788983345,
0.06581497937440872,
0.06446073949337006,
0.031184788793325424,
-0.1919410228729248,
-0.4166390597820282,
0.006576051469892263,
-0.48725685477256775,
0.41074222326278687,
0.6838688254356384,
0.17225055396556854,
0.13666991889476776,
-0.4092804491519928,
0.6552718877792358,
-0.1266581118106842,
0.10271427035331726,
-0.28197893500328064,
-0.5863408446311951,
-0.4186890721321106,
-0.7027643918991089,
0.339669406414032,
0.36720094084739685,
-0.6649248600006104,
0.584490954875946,
-0.24220377206802368,
-0.6678283214569092,
-0.7597900032997131,
-0.20090599358081818,
0.22688810527324677,
0.564820408821106,
0.4954462945461273,
-0.16333769261837006,
-0.1761350929737091,
-0.7842081785202026,
0.01175740733742714,
-0.2041318714618683,
0.14281539618968964,
0.26824235916137695,
0.20976993441581726,
-0.5272669196128845,
0.480557918548584,
-0.47119608521461487,
-0.4867212474346161,
-0.28140750527381897,
0.4110367000102997,
0.44202208518981934,
0.45065733790397644,
0.1979903131723404,
-0.5867562890052795,
-0.3026750087738037,
0.285320520401001,
-0.7667627930641174,
-0.5165496468544006,
-0.6083035469055176,
-0.13700366020202637,
-0.3015157878398895,
0.8794112205505371,
-0.08196420967578888,
0.6183819770812988,
0.35975679755210876,
-0.5724833607673645,
0.43969911336898804,
-0.2685592472553253,
0.24921301007270813,
-0.41661104559898376,
0.13459934294223785,
0.055952128022909164,
-0.2905506193637848,
-0.8007698059082031,
0.08237035572528839,
0.10719141364097595,
0.1414884775876999,
-0.29337096214294434,
0.8090952634811401,
-0.4299822151660919,
0.32530033588409424,
-0.16427215933799744,
-0.505251944065094,
0.1022082194685936,
0.437173455953598,
0.09922412782907486,
0.2229798585176468,
0.22684741020202637,
-0.41654178500175476,
0.20401115715503693,
0.5259287357330322,
-0.2511659860610962,
0.27074432373046875,
-0.5577623844146729,
-0.008526983670890331,
-0.31201714277267456,
0.35348913073539734,
-0.5328511595726013,
-0.39493563771247864,
0.05525195971131325,
-0.45582130551338196,
0.7145543694496155,
0.3135679066181183,
-0.20929183065891266,
-0.3656427562236786,
-0.15477587282657623,
0.6516464352607727,
0.6491991877555847,
-0.5132679343223572,
0.7993025779724121,
0.324285089969635,
0.05211574584245682,
-0.2547888159751892,
-0.7564241290092468,
-0.5371268391609192,
-0.3109860122203827,
-0.3539763391017914,
0.35089802742004395,
-0.10308124870061874,
-0.3715643286705017,
-0.09597571939229965,
-0.061943139880895615,
-0.30152860283851624,
0.39072418212890625,
0.6828867197036743,
0.3062455654144287,
0.02958773635327816,
0.5077204704284668,
0.10345965623855591,
-0.24461787939071655,
0.2161843180656433,
0.11663251370191574,
0.8643602132797241,
-0.1835651695728302,
-0.6946292519569397,
-0.9616199135780334,
0.37525156140327454,
0.28613361716270447,
-0.23010669648647308,
0.5951669216156006,
0.8607476949691772,
-0.5062891244888306,
0.027594203129410744,
-0.29823997616767883,
-0.08548936992883682,
-0.44303804636001587,
0.41952526569366455,
-0.2813876271247864,
-0.5228387713432312,
0.5824224352836609,
0.002806755481287837,
-0.19109377264976501,
0.510466456413269,
0.6642534732818604,
-0.49152418971061707,
0.8903756737709045,
0.8153347373008728,
0.252789169549942,
0.6324111223220825,
-0.3677588403224945,
0.07019823789596558,
-0.752303421497345,
-0.6737097501754761,
-0.5026401877403259,
-0.23900383710861206,
-0.17647290229797363,
-0.16378167271614075,
0.4832099378108978,
0.33646512031555176,
-0.17463448643684387,
-0.1780260056257248,
-0.3943553864955902,
0.46943503618240356,
0.1114693209528923,
0.563798189163208,
0.18056988716125488,
0.3387010395526886,
-0.08149244636297226,
0.0498749203979969,
-0.47581836581230164,
-0.5932326912879944,
1.4475351572036743,
0.676025927066803,
0.8596715331077576,
-0.17921888828277588,
0.7388455271720886,
0.5984543561935425,
0.8001077771186829,
-0.8678838610649109,
-0.0009461333393119276,
-0.0900762602686882,
-0.4494360387325287,
0.10569881647825241,
0.09727563709020615,
-0.9455339908599854,
-0.08043620735406876,
-0.5589863657951355,
-0.7916349768638611,
0.14657580852508545,
0.22745181620121002,
-0.6883280873298645,
-0.0028150107245892286,
-0.7276160717010498,
0.7409543991088867,
-0.4221438765525818,
0.01152005884796381,
-0.22610287368297577,
-0.5429031252861023,
0.30895888805389404,
-0.43009886145591736,
0.6386885046958923,
0.11989779025316238,
0.0634746253490448,
0.2813062071800232,
-0.2896338999271393,
0.6954154372215271,
0.1931535303592682,
-0.03458375856280327,
0.21107201278209686,
-0.20513547956943512,
0.26506656408309937,
0.25186866521835327,
-0.3495328724384308,
0.9806978106498718,
-0.24425451457500458,
-0.20592238008975983,
-0.18207161128520966,
0.3652827739715576,
-0.7063775658607483,
-0.32646307349205017,
-0.41649866104125977,
-0.15055030584335327,
-0.13166454434394836,
0.013018698431551456,
0.6040010452270508,
0.8602564930915833,
-0.2518770694732666,
-0.025529954582452774,
0.48570898175239563,
-0.22630105912685394,
0.11451130360364914,
-0.018352441489696503,
-0.3462854027748108,
-0.10509069263935089,
0.7338883876800537,
-0.14468921720981598,
0.1783851683139801,
0.3858107626438141,
-0.06777507811784744,
-0.5097553133964539,
-0.9890487790107727,
-0.5934147834777832,
0.47045910358428955,
-0.971098780632019,
-0.16899874806404114,
-0.7486447095870972,
-0.12359333783388138,
-0.027777424082159996,
-0.569743275642395,
0.27564796805381775,
0.13325715065002441,
-0.804250955581665,
-0.18252025544643402,
0.36931154131889343,
0.7381292581558228,
0.008894607424736023,
0.7438260912895203,
-1.0525457859039307,
0.3986072838306427,
-0.2195904403924942,
0.4911086857318878,
-0.2538556456565857,
-0.31502342224121094,
-0.5148283839225769,
-0.24938389658927917,
0.017211852595210075,
-1.0985686779022217,
0.3447147607803345,
0.3343493640422821,
0.8159735202789307,
0.3719024956226349,
-0.2837395668029785,
0.7738243341445923,
-0.42012104392051697,
0.7916094064712524,
0.18313564360141754,
-1.0302687883377075,
0.2653122544288635,
-0.11856409907341003,
0.17512431740760803,
0.5135354995727539,
0.39969655871391296,
-0.16942130029201508,
-0.24751824140548706,
-0.7460901141166687,
-0.8947204351425171,
0.7031394243240356,
0.13201439380645752,
-0.12781687080860138,
0.052835650742053986,
0.502973735332489,
0.4782656133174896,
0.35566166043281555,
-0.7247332334518433,
-0.44777238368988037,
-0.07973648607730865,
-0.807650089263916,
-0.20797154307365417,
0.013952978886663914,
-0.07807167619466782,
-0.20923663675785065,
0.6129757761955261,
-0.19930142164230347,
0.8171452283859253,
0.23777276277542114,
-0.44152581691741943,
-0.344605952501297,
-0.0016624159179627895,
0.5491753220558167,
0.49001479148864746,
-0.04151944816112518,
0.004104460123926401,
0.05173887312412262,
-0.6770387291908264,
0.007408798672258854,
0.4837132394313812,
0.11334937065839767,
0.031622834503650665,
0.9240787029266357,
0.8227711319923401,
-0.17785733938217163,
-0.9368491172790527,
0.4458666145801544,
-0.22152601182460785,
0.0776553824543953,
-0.43918293714523315,
-0.07957076281309128,
-0.06265637278556824,
0.315181702375412,
0.13181763887405396,
0.09264615923166275,
0.027431197464466095,
-0.3112029731273651,
0.3454364538192749,
0.28892022371292114,
-0.4934353828430176,
-0.30574777722358704,
0.7855321168899536,
0.29077595472335815,
-0.23800209164619446,
0.42808347940444946,
0.014599044807255268,
-0.4796088933944702,
0.8782595992088318,
0.43302759528160095,
0.8725516200065613,
-0.07943321019411087,
-0.02936515398323536,
0.13294567167758942,
0.4268803000450134,
0.39481306076049805,
0.4568595886230469,
0.007589736022055149,
-0.3957509696483612,
-0.18673284351825714,
-0.7860405445098877,
-0.006853387225419283,
0.08920691907405853,
-0.6222108006477356,
0.4888235330581665,
-0.5396167635917664,
-0.07409995049238205,
0.0849137008190155,
-0.15312279760837555,
-1.028113603591919,
0.42248451709747314,
0.44920167326927185,
0.6743857860565186,
-0.6485475301742554,
0.8162612318992615,
0.8036912083625793,
-0.2884182631969452,
-0.7865118980407715,
0.07948483526706696,
0.028007877990603447,
-0.8531779646873474,
0.3021678924560547,
0.37953439354896545,
0.11648209393024445,
0.12411198019981384,
-0.28015604615211487,
-0.6579499244689941,
1.0320466756820679,
-0.2170020192861557,
-0.3758189082145691,
0.29795417189598083,
0.11932749301195145,
0.8257154822349548,
-0.42887383699417114,
0.542660653591156,
0.41239550709724426,
0.3090232014656067,
-0.6306989789009094,
-0.9644707441329956,
-0.07975441962480545,
-0.24979466199874878,
-0.5529187917709351,
0.20975203812122345,
-0.5108630061149597,
1.0562446117401123,
0.13423392176628113,
-0.21876195073127747,
-0.07354220747947693,
0.5001286864280701,
0.01927328109741211,
0.5435214042663574,
0.3040584623813629,
-0.08273323625326157,
0.7202244400978088,
-0.18700677156448364,
1.0711803436279297,
-0.32251423597335815,
0.2559913098812103,
0.6985160112380981,
0.04559117555618286,
0.3436225652694702,
0.27372825145721436,
-0.011230360716581345,
0.7391203045845032,
0.7704190611839294,
0.14328716695308685,
0.5629687309265137,
0.11258623003959656,
-0.19307613372802734,
-0.32794877886772156,
0.05232144147157669,
-0.5096700191497803,
0.5254146456718445,
0.834550678730011,
-0.7007706761360168,
0.04693366214632988,
0.28596869111061096,
-0.17269660532474518,
0.16231323778629303,
-0.6378519535064697,
0.6292809844017029,
0.2575613856315613,
-0.28322651982307434,
0.43498891592025757,
-0.02752036601305008,
0.7235214710235596,
-0.6716338396072388,
-0.17684704065322876,
0.15289901196956635,
0.12758295238018036,
-0.3424939513206482,
-0.3721252381801605,
0.28213411569595337,
-0.040728263556957245,
-0.029589690268039703,
-0.44337522983551025,
0.7106720209121704,
-0.36562755703926086,
-0.4103808104991913,
0.16183088719844818,
0.5479788184165955,
0.32267293334007263,
0.01776200346648693,
-0.5789716243743896,
-0.028508717194199562,
0.3101825714111328,
-0.3604270815849304,
-0.0661356970667839,
0.1482856571674347,
-0.20549649000167847,
0.6375722289085388,
0.6730356812477112,
0.21013711392879486,
0.03431687131524086,
-0.1754971295595169,
0.6548619866371155,
-0.6143569350242615,
-0.7840125560760498,
-0.7240716814994812,
0.681686520576477,
0.04443586617708206,
-0.3688749670982361,
0.21473032236099243,
0.09496746212244034,
0.7632725834846497,
-0.010211716406047344,
0.544407069683075,
0.20308643579483032,
0.11396609246730804,
-0.8974602222442627,
0.989133358001709,
-0.5904324054718018,
0.3352136015892029,
0.11222223192453384,
-0.3167235851287842,
-0.49657392501831055,
0.544420599937439,
-0.13267529010772705,
-0.41826146841049194,
0.7673551440238953,
0.24568848311901093,
-0.008129369467496872,
0.25266486406326294,
0.1391030102968216,
0.18713662028312683,
0.39705464243888855,
0.10412468016147614,
0.6292811632156372,
-0.20392026007175446,
0.13835644721984863,
-0.2605557143688202,
-0.10718238353729248,
-0.504376232624054,
-0.6834421157836914,
-0.9082942008972168,
-0.5323298573493958,
-0.2018168568611145,
-0.16128218173980713,
-0.4176986813545227,
1.3909070491790771,
0.42868831753730774,
-0.5784687995910645,
0.05042753368616104,
0.13979315757751465,
0.18012754619121552,
-0.3019672930240631,
-0.08159134536981583,
0.510730504989624,
0.06834901124238968,
-0.5195873975753784,
0.3493686616420746,
-0.04800722375512123,
0.25213104486465454,
-0.14647942781448364,
0.042249906808137894,
-0.0815100371837616,
0.06530396640300751,
0.46164536476135254,
0.06655474752187729,
-0.6888742446899414,
-0.053756460547447205,
-0.21559365093708038,
0.04662518575787544,
0.03803533315658569,
0.7963817119598389,
-0.8769704103469849,
0.6802821755409241,
0.3421451151371002,
0.5677769184112549,
0.3547368049621582,
0.13816367089748383,
0.2859698534011841,
-0.6294581294059753,
0.2417251616716385,
0.3402594327926636,
0.5573316812515259,
0.1304372400045395,
-0.7635710835456848,
0.3581036925315857,
0.1133187934756279,
-0.51822829246521,
-0.9572908878326416,
0.06197424232959747,
-0.8083205819129944,
-0.23740191757678986,
1.1207997798919678,
-0.19104169309139252,
-0.09436064213514328,
-0.7071717977523804,
-0.19403821229934692,
0.47607412934303284,
-0.13763555884361267,
0.5657309889793396,
0.74782395362854,
-0.8260383605957031,
0.280464768409729,
-0.6756716966629028,
0.5027559995651245,
0.1180507242679596,
-0.9626963138580322,
-0.3816491663455963,
0.4493979215621948,
0.03975113853812218,
0.09821110963821411,
0.8240866661071777,
0.009459099732339382,
0.17327319085597992,
0.015255293808877468,
0.2245597243309021,
-0.5620147585868835,
-0.17154698073863983,
-0.9732708930969238,
0.128361314535141,
-0.14605830609798431,
-0.1136334091424942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.03369v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.03369v1 | Evaluation of Google's Voice Recognition and Sentence Classification for Health Care Applications | 2024-02-02T03:13:09 | 2024-02-02T03:13:09 | Majbah Uddin, Nathan Huynh, Jose M Vidal, Kevin M Taaffe, Lawrence D Fredendall, Joel S Greenstein | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | This study examined the use of voice recognition technology in perioperative
services (Periop) to enable Periop staff to record workflow milestones using
mobile technology. The use of mobile technology to improve patient flow and
quality of care could be facilitated if such voice recognition technology could
be made robust. The goal of this experiment was to allow the Periop staff to
provide care without being interrupted with data entry and querying tasks.
However, the results are generalizable to other situations where an engineering
manager attempts to improve communication performance using mobile technology.
This study enhanced Google's voice recognition capability by using
post-processing classifiers (i.e., bag-of-sentences, support vector machine,
and maximum entropy). The experiments investigated three factors (original
phrasing, reduced phrasing, and personalized phrasing) at three levels (zero
training repetition, 5 training repetitions, and 10 training repetitions).
Results indicated that personal phrasing yielded the highest correctness and
that training the device to recognize an individual's voice improved
correctness as well. Although simplistic, the bag-of-sentences classifier
significantly improved voice recognition correctness. The classification
efficiency of the maximum entropy and support vector machine algorithms was
found to be nearly identical. These results suggest that engineering managers
could significantly enhance Google's voice recognition technology by using
post-processing techniques, which would facilitate its use in health care and
other applications. | [
-0.1330520361661911,
-0.24169424176216125,
0.5181312561035156,
0.2294345647096634,
-0.14730103313922882,
0.03601738438010216,
0.08592607080936432,
-0.4852577745914459,
0.35039645433425903,
0.31568998098373413,
-0.23077836632728577,
-0.37651875615119934,
-0.5190335512161255,
0.23398210108280182,
-0.4136987328529358,
0.9376941919326782,
0.25706586241722107,
0.37749674916267395,
0.0068466016091406345,
0.10992520302534103,
-0.2948823869228363,
-0.7400140166282654,
-0.6315539479255676,
-0.3401648700237274,
0.5238160490989685,
0.5543819069862366,
0.7937845587730408,
0.3924899399280548,
0.7720410823822021,
0.3348819613456726,
-0.017899468541145325,
-0.12554894387722015,
-0.07295288890600204,
0.1649361401796341,
0.22665753960609436,
-0.3083556890487671,
-0.4289722442626953,
0.022586405277252197,
0.4491404592990875,
0.49665531516075134,
-0.416108101606369,
0.14557862281799316,
0.021427368745207787,
0.42328423261642456,
-0.547584593296051,
-0.07714547216892242,
-0.5551192164421082,
0.60747230052948,
-0.1858639419078827,
-0.6483272314071655,
0.07486126571893692,
-0.48952704668045044,
0.28046298027038574,
-0.47113779187202454,
-0.12800957262516022,
-0.1488659828901291,
0.9771852493286133,
0.3448798358440399,
0.01540148351341486,
-0.6511524319648743,
-0.8634878396987915,
0.36795786023139954,
-0.558650553226471,
0.5369868874549866,
0.3707267642021179,
0.43673276901245117,
-0.12594099342823029,
-0.6395339965820312,
-0.4985014796257019,
-0.09940747916698456,
0.10721585899591446,
0.32649001479148865,
-0.134309321641922,
0.17747686803340912,
0.3230684995651245,
0.6245197057723999,
-0.7209839224815369,
0.2621869444847107,
-0.6230762004852295,
-0.3292805850505829,
0.6023851633071899,
0.008828699588775635,
0.4030686914920807,
-0.11276977509260178,
-0.21932342648506165,
-0.1716180443763733,
-0.5632238984107971,
0.33202463388442993,
0.03883478045463562,
0.017502302303910255,
0.18985430896282196,
0.5593865513801575,
-0.3475264310836792,
0.3505343794822693,
-0.02141408994793892,
-0.6003437638282776,
0.7621012926101685,
0.09799738228321075,
-0.9192075729370117,
0.2739420533180237,
0.713241696357727,
0.17261120676994324,
0.11610619723796844,
-0.36540526151657104,
-0.04200896993279457,
0.1300514042377472,
0.6198332905769348,
-0.7622167468070984,
-0.17032374441623688,
0.1460496038198471,
-0.747955322265625,
-0.40164291858673096,
0.33632710576057434,
-0.2985094487667084,
-0.5728382468223572,
-0.06865385174751282,
0.16313256323337555,
-0.11006931215524673,
-0.11819060891866684,
0.3452836275100708,
-0.0712045207619667,
0.09389714896678925,
0.2016935646533966,
-0.6945620775222778,
0.24364186823368073,
0.5534266233444214,
0.9225475788116455,
0.14491800963878632,
0.036698680371046066,
-0.75965815782547,
-0.1194358691573143,
-0.2452716827392578,
0.7043842077255249,
-0.5338837504386902,
-0.8507047891616821,
0.023636044934391975,
0.0005371517036110163,
-0.2664561867713928,
-1.1716221570968628,
1.1907415390014648,
-0.2711440622806549,
0.22579123079776764,
0.14968672394752502,
-0.3261718451976776,
-0.15143249928951263,
-0.02888238988816738,
-0.3438355028629303,
0.4996340870857239,
-0.03884311392903328,
-0.404092937707901,
0.6048027873039246,
-0.9251724481582642,
-0.5999607443809509,
0.41422292590141296,
-0.3114146888256073,
-0.7261332869529724,
0.30545374751091003,
-0.0289458017796278,
0.7388622760772705,
-0.03105875849723816,
-0.2519809305667877,
-0.1011764332652092,
-0.5561546683311462,
0.2266978621482849,
0.1173790916800499,
0.6540366411209106,
0.516572892665863,
-0.10129347443580627,
0.1262238621711731,
-0.8503420948982239,
0.3600669503211975,
-0.2055291384458542,
-0.6020835638046265,
-0.09878244251012802,
0.01077913399785757,
-0.1309218406677246,
0.3483525812625885,
-0.23588508367538452,
-0.4750429093837738,
0.15265432000160217,
-0.198912113904953,
0.6531432271003723,
0.10357968509197235,
-0.19210121035575867,
0.4390477240085602,
-0.42779672145843506,
0.7879065871238708,
-0.3257335424423218,
0.33983951807022095,
0.09866505116224289,
-0.5922069549560547,
-0.181087926030159,
-0.2833980321884155,
0.18148840963840485,
1.1857596635818481,
-0.5845125913619995,
0.6034247279167175,
-0.2848712205886841,
-0.64063560962677,
-0.7001836895942688,
0.0821373388171196,
0.3705481290817261,
0.8334646821022034,
0.1545143723487854,
-0.368246853351593,
-0.6495423913002014,
-0.8014153242111206,
-0.15523022413253784,
-0.3882855176925659,
-0.6259285807609558,
0.6168947815895081,
0.031221691519021988,
-0.6118572354316711,
0.3897008001804352,
-0.3828057050704956,
-0.35795024037361145,
0.2227376103401184,
0.2330293506383896,
0.27118703722953796,
0.41851261258125305,
0.10648970305919647,
-0.9100939631462097,
-0.19592779874801636,
0.09247712045907974,
-0.674966037273407,
-0.42554256319999695,
0.2041400671005249,
0.1633458435535431,
-0.06101507693529129,
0.1471007615327835,
-0.3734504282474518,
0.5503378510475159,
0.7713096737861633,
-0.04629043862223625,
0.46299996972084045,
-0.1780225783586502,
0.4871120750904083,
-0.7802101373672485,
0.0558842234313488,
0.049865517765283585,
-0.17370621860027313,
-0.6613777279853821,
-0.6371662020683289,
-0.1856563687324524,
-0.507915735244751,
-0.3198856711387634,
0.0006164480000734329,
-0.3537224531173706,
-0.2712867856025696,
-0.5220515131950378,
-0.2982637882232666,
-0.19776476919651031,
-0.2057657688856125,
0.19024845957756042,
0.9646785855293274,
0.6093941330909729,
-0.7929871082305908,
0.3093182146549225,
0.3852643370628357,
-0.41969382762908936,
0.6764517426490784,
-0.6775344014167786,
0.4748454689979553,
0.3375622630119324,
0.026035290211439133,
-1.0246132612228394,
-0.22896426916122437,
0.06703845411539078,
-0.72466641664505,
0.012563659809529781,
0.22593581676483154,
-0.46218013763427734,
-0.601844072341919,
-0.10910540074110031,
-0.2812628149986267,
0.6853018403053284,
-0.21407701075077057,
0.3822021782398224,
0.5993103981018066,
-0.4689229726791382,
-0.09569960087537766,
-0.8598310351371765,
0.29218125343322754,
-0.5967580080032349,
-0.5369419455528259,
0.5543487071990967,
0.23447050154209137,
0.05914199352264404,
-0.4104217290878296,
-0.5430259108543396,
-0.5532894134521484,
0.18049253523349762,
0.555950939655304,
0.26338523626327515,
0.04438196122646332,
0.35172009468078613,
-0.06205291301012039,
-0.08389764279127121,
0.03140002489089966,
-0.3320154547691345,
0.40882226824760437,
-0.025486264377832413,
0.332706093788147,
-1.011843204498291,
0.20490963757038116,
0.6334144473075867,
0.05302625894546509,
0.3817479908466339,
0.8361365795135498,
-0.43317967653274536,
0.3164307475090027,
-0.6635400056838989,
-0.1593630313873291,
-0.4877254366874695,
0.09954815357923508,
-0.4505387544631958,
-0.9152621626853943,
0.4506334364414215,
-0.2937251925468445,
-0.22513480484485626,
0.12635491788387299,
0.22488507628440857,
-0.49709463119506836,
0.8931076526641846,
0.45251649618148804,
-0.10460583865642548,
0.7492343783378601,
0.056575898081064224,
0.17602220177650452,
-0.9871717095375061,
-0.24278885126113892,
-0.843290388584137,
-0.12055018544197083,
-0.8360936045646667,
-0.09727445989847183,
0.7439218759536743,
0.2505185008049011,
-0.14146409928798676,
0.46974995732307434,
-0.9802334904670715,
-0.35068899393081665,
0.5184060335159302,
0.3733370006084442,
0.11958828568458557,
0.3334167003631592,
0.08978508412837982,
0.06050046533346176,
-0.5053185820579529,
-0.8892297744750977,
0.752354621887207,
0.32415786385536194,
0.8445566296577454,
-0.21562540531158447,
0.6583364605903625,
0.30758222937583923,
0.2242487519979477,
-0.7210987210273743,
0.40702199935913086,
-0.559933066368103,
-0.206562340259552,
-0.2688373029232025,
-0.5025187134742737,
-0.911215603351593,
0.07463729381561279,
-0.2947046756744385,
-0.859421968460083,
0.053643953055143356,
0.25525644421577454,
-0.6869418621063232,
-0.059684570878744125,
-1.0850999355316162,
0.7594621777534485,
-0.47946950793266296,
0.06634058058261871,
-0.011240245774388313,
-0.5423210859298706,
-0.20094339549541473,
0.14167506992816925,
-0.20482413470745087,
0.3354890048503876,
-0.07157992571592331,
0.8057427406311035,
-0.5341680645942688,
0.2840653955936432,
-0.156657874584198,
-0.07817792892456055,
0.045030735433101654,
-0.36808717250823975,
0.23376810550689697,
-0.18545706570148468,
-0.09440366923809052,
0.17145639657974243,
0.10422153025865555,
-0.11736943572759628,
-0.673427402973175,
0.49070554971694946,
-0.48345065116882324,
-0.5092586874961853,
-0.21354973316192627,
-0.18309645354747772,
-0.5429969429969788,
0.08014024794101715,
0.4654703438282013,
0.0714009627699852,
0.16932262480258942,
0.5353273749351501,
0.40949851274490356,
-0.4986245036125183,
0.1752583086490631,
0.22355422377586365,
0.07959461212158203,
-0.5608981847763062,
0.6095864176750183,
0.3749493658542633,
-0.03566424176096916,
0.4625907242298126,
0.5204856991767883,
-0.5358968377113342,
-0.6646295189857483,
-0.27560752630233765,
-0.12230589985847473,
-0.11167342215776443,
-0.05180833488702774,
-0.6368319988250732,
-0.34837889671325684,
-0.5401607751846313,
-0.09488851577043533,
0.32670411467552185,
-0.13802646100521088,
-0.31230464577674866,
-0.07922189682722092,
-0.0902838185429573,
0.4249684810638428,
0.223051518201828,
0.6961991190910339,
-0.8331588506698608,
0.08601772785186768,
0.2807983160018921,
0.2289258986711502,
-0.5238178968429565,
-0.19300705194473267,
-0.16176150739192963,
-0.22414037585258484,
-0.585462212562561,
-0.9474685192108154,
0.025355620309710503,
0.22246727347373962,
0.4478754997253418,
0.5178222060203552,
-0.32802072167396545,
0.8783204555511475,
-0.4849434792995453,
0.7335981726646423,
0.48914408683776855,
-1.0156364440917969,
0.7203903198242188,
-0.16525404155254364,
0.3378502130508423,
0.5265812277793884,
0.31383663415908813,
-0.4700569808483124,
-0.00033593634725548327,
-0.5780954360961914,
-0.4171575903892517,
0.2503773272037506,
0.19155794382095337,
0.08686554431915283,
0.26125848293304443,
0.40209272503852844,
-0.18879280984401703,
0.6173194050788879,
-0.20565225183963776,
0.18872150778770447,
-0.2576664686203003,
-0.1992930769920349,
0.16418497264385223,
-0.25690168142318726,
0.19987069070339203,
-0.16860438883304596,
0.30926504731178284,
0.14898470044136047,
0.5708579421043396,
0.5098167657852173,
0.16840298473834991,
0.17856888473033905,
0.5733819007873535,
0.8811413645744324,
0.5694355964660645,
-0.1015213206410408,
-0.13065505027770996,
0.17920570075511932,
-0.8597899675369263,
-0.10266027599573135,
0.26828113198280334,
0.11553452908992767,
0.3043253719806671,
0.07298532128334045,
0.6062926054000854,
-0.23036980628967285,
-0.6729127764701843,
0.17679166793823242,
-0.07840972393751144,
-0.15176443755626678,
-0.3389798104763031,
0.3447269797325134,
-0.16533708572387695,
0.316302627325058,
0.44042208790779114,
0.01646316610276699,
0.8206267356872559,
-0.5951178073883057,
0.06493502855300903,
0.2658796012401581,
-0.3849705755710602,
-0.15201926231384277,
0.5771989226341248,
0.2137717306613922,
-0.6866374015808105,
0.22722023725509644,
-0.09076134860515594,
-0.5011942982673645,
0.3655272126197815,
0.3634752631187439,
0.9319930076599121,
-0.8923335671424866,
0.22830890119075775,
0.21217361092567444,
0.005807877518236637,
-0.21215547621250153,
0.6861581802368164,
-0.1499594748020172,
-0.49682968854904175,
-0.258566290140152,
-0.16192775964736938,
-0.4978574216365814,
0.3584293723106384,
-0.679437518119812,
0.3621421456336975,
-0.6038262248039246,
-0.6954863667488098,
0.23704606294631958,
0.04525214061141014,
-0.641890823841095,
0.7444239854812622,
0.28585702180862427,
0.5790767073631287,
-0.3872445821762085,
0.5490204691886902,
1.2927457094192505,
-0.2807231545448303,
-0.9842694997787476,
0.1846417486667633,
0.009402032941579819,
-0.6591747999191284,
0.7469521164894104,
0.20187903940677643,
-0.45040610432624817,
-0.3235451281070709,
-0.2072707563638687,
-0.32135170698165894,
1.052675724029541,
0.23023684322834015,
-0.8957887887954712,
-0.06359159201383591,
-0.1461038738489151,
0.6458835005760193,
-0.4541204869747162,
0.2513938546180725,
0.08661933988332748,
0.13343001902103424,
0.12942183017730713,
-1.7372546195983887,
-0.14283989369869232,
-0.38636890053749084,
0.12607324123382568,
-0.11847105622291565,
-0.18128080666065216,
0.509044349193573,
-0.09784586727619171,
-0.46671926975250244,
0.02591300755739212,
0.16037730872631073,
0.11651404201984406,
0.7258850932121277,
0.8147091865539551,
0.6047134399414062,
1.2281198501586914,
-0.17252464592456818,
1.0429325103759766,
-0.09515734016895294,
0.16905023157596588,
0.8319721817970276,
-0.47137436270713806,
0.7530476450920105,
0.1529918611049652,
-0.22858206927776337,
0.49874570965766907,
0.33930426836013794,
0.18342921137809753,
0.5617337822914124,
0.5542186498641968,
-0.41283613443374634,
0.24848002195358276,
-0.28306934237480164,
-0.44402286410331726,
0.5596857666969299,
0.28099045157432556,
-0.7348636984825134,
0.2814050316810608,
0.5789791345596313,
0.21918149292469025,
-0.12871140241622925,
-0.44394680857658386,
1.07215416431427,
0.13745209574699402,
-0.3800748586654663,
0.7563385963439941,
-0.3089968264102936,
0.7686194181442261,
-0.338249534368515,
0.025920521467924118,
0.501217246055603,
0.21541748940944672,
-0.8925469517707825,
-0.6004953980445862,
0.5650044083595276,
0.31046128273010254,
-0.07482507824897766,
-0.5896081328392029,
0.7481871843338013,
-0.08479233831167221,
-0.17078933119773865,
0.03891651704907417,
0.16486121714115143,
0.43496060371398926,
-0.19859030842781067,
-0.6031306385993958,
0.12787526845932007,
-0.26004254817962646,
0.2682948112487793,
-0.1312396377325058,
0.3267260491847992,
0.2112058699131012,
0.5354883074760437,
0.6323177814483643,
0.6206151843070984,
-0.07977648079395294,
0.15940332412719727,
0.7983673810958862,
-0.498099148273468,
-0.7866237163543701,
-0.6033008098602295,
0.44348329305648804,
-0.34688133001327515,
-0.5459973812103271,
0.5362246036529541,
0.681493878364563,
0.8362923860549927,
-0.10893949121236801,
0.8832029104232788,
-0.06174437329173088,
0.8939917087554932,
-0.4573439359664917,
0.5074049234390259,
-0.49638664722442627,
0.037227123975753784,
-0.39830732345581055,
-0.39587774872779846,
-0.4840506613254547,
1.1903223991394043,
-0.7658827304840088,
-0.06859514862298965,
0.7428231239318848,
0.5997011661529541,
0.11527366936206818,
0.1710403561592102,
0.39473673701286316,
-0.0659659132361412,
0.25638726353645325,
0.3813587725162506,
0.7837200164794922,
-0.3203888535499573,
0.5676104426383972,
0.019634399563074112,
-0.3074530363082886,
-0.3604552149772644,
-0.5114924311637878,
-0.5271434187889099,
-0.43755441904067993,
-0.4132961332798004,
-0.6596182584762573,
0.24558594822883606,
0.6797915101051331,
1.2207671403884888,
-0.5595869421958923,
-0.14307761192321777,
-0.07436015456914902,
-0.23874254524707794,
-0.3607810437679291,
-0.21882928907871246,
-0.11628218740224838,
-0.23164543509483337,
-0.5271410346031189,
0.3979925811290741,
0.5289515256881714,
-0.039901264011859894,
0.0907653346657753,
-0.07736936211585999,
0.3278748691082001,
-0.40876802802085876,
0.6830536723136902,
0.40753617882728577,
-0.5092799067497253,
-0.08230861276388168,
0.26809000968933105,
-0.13967236876487732,
0.3473477363586426,
1.0843299627304077,
-0.38596901297569275,
0.4234367609024048,
0.5406750440597534,
0.8854089379310608,
-0.002638068748638034,
0.4149300158023834,
0.30941444635391235,
-0.1509178876876831,
-0.10572000592947006,
0.6227128505706787,
0.3788814842700958,
0.35068655014038086,
-0.6087062358856201,
0.4742235541343689,
0.20259076356887817,
-0.8646107912063599,
-0.8062781691551208,
0.03857644274830818,
-0.9364384412765503,
0.25717493891716003,
0.9100273251533508,
-0.3226141035556793,
0.06530966609716415,
-0.1983637809753418,
-0.47295668721199036,
0.11114043742418289,
-0.49978509545326233,
0.8740257024765015,
0.7588573098182678,
-0.6388803720474243,
-0.38718876242637634,
-0.7970350384712219,
0.49837419390678406,
0.2611715793609619,
-1.1370136737823486,
-0.9110307097434998,
0.27528828382492065,
0.4006339907646179,
0.6113569140434265,
0.9244681000709534,
-0.30270031094551086,
0.3364848792552948,
-0.4301435649394989,
-0.13267730176448822,
0.010975660756230354,
-0.2600520849227905,
-0.39766013622283936,
0.2386627197265625,
-0.16806402802467346,
-0.9605249762535095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01109v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01109v3 | Vaccine: Perturbation-aware Alignment for Large Language Model | 2024-02-02T02:56:50 | 2024-02-29T07:15:13 | Tiansheng Huang, Sihao Hu, Ling Liu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The new paradigm of finetuning-as-a-service introduces a new attack surface
for Large Language Models (LLMs): a few harmful data uploaded by users can
easily trick the finetuning to produce an alignment-broken model. We conduct an
empirical analysis and uncover a \textit{harmful embedding drift} phenomenon,
showing a probable cause of the alignment-broken effect. Inspired by our
findings, we propose Vaccine, a perturbation-aware alignment technique to
mitigate the security risk of users finetuning. The core idea of Vaccine is to
produce invariant hidden embeddings by progressively adding crafted
perturbation to them in the alignment phase. This enables the embeddings to
withstand harmful perturbation from un-sanitized user data in the finetuning
phase. Our results on open source mainstream LLMs (e.g., Llama2, Opt, Vicuna)
demonstrate that Vaccine can boost the robustness of alignment against harmful
prompts induced embedding drift while reserving reasoning ability towards
benign prompts. Our code is available at
\url{https://github.com/git-disl/Vaccine}. | [
-0.0490926057100296,
-1.2033058404922485,
0.32289090752601624,
-0.11256657540798187,
-0.20098371803760529,
0.014010719023644924,
0.007308209780603647,
-0.23227167129516602,
0.2483205646276474,
0.6912313103675842,
-0.3328844904899597,
-0.6637820601463318,
-0.5321999788284302,
-0.23970963060855865,
-0.6546809077262878,
0.9319711923599243,
0.27823230624198914,
0.06289075314998627,
-0.27965500950813293,
0.10197938978672028,
-0.48061731457710266,
-0.2769969403743744,
-0.5819540023803711,
-0.09324650466442108,
0.5875794291496277,
0.6221359968185425,
0.7538380026817322,
1.0422054529190063,
0.576335608959198,
0.20387409627437592,
-0.3012394607067108,
-0.35580208897590637,
-0.6247843503952026,
0.6199765205383301,
-0.1737315058708191,
-0.7889466881752014,
-0.6180804371833801,
-0.2425961047410965,
0.6939716339111328,
0.31715643405914307,
-0.4285317659378052,
-0.0459398478269577,
-0.0030219005420804024,
0.38723722100257874,
-0.6661408543586731,
-0.6054286360740662,
-0.8480607271194458,
-0.0833955705165863,
-0.7994346618652344,
0.0042372639290988445,
-0.4946056604385376,
0.1111450046300888,
-0.26462802290916443,
-0.5644274950027466,
-0.12979412078857422,
-0.06514570116996765,
0.7751290798187256,
0.45027291774749756,
-0.28607866168022156,
0.06684492528438568,
-0.4683118462562561,
0.5473017692565918,
-0.8658897876739502,
0.26392269134521484,
0.23623992502689362,
0.4049812853336334,
-0.6218716502189636,
-0.48932233452796936,
-0.5504317283630371,
-0.02708827145397663,
0.47623154520988464,
0.04149298369884491,
-0.4418356716632843,
0.1505832076072693,
0.33754050731658936,
0.35265254974365234,
-0.5973958969116211,
0.7865747809410095,
0.1328793317079544,
-0.4072975516319275,
0.5033139586448669,
0.2770572900772095,
0.6863546371459961,
-0.08675432205200195,
-0.3471851050853729,
-0.03910791873931885,
-1.1895198822021484,
0.03582504391670227,
0.6037050485610962,
0.30307137966156006,
-0.27587196230888367,
0.6502209901809692,
-0.0006035261321812868,
0.6976613402366638,
0.5295425057411194,
0.0055218166671693325,
0.0007015315350145102,
-0.2665327489376068,
-0.1772761195898056,
0.27528369426727295,
0.8747357130050659,
0.22808238863945007,
-0.012604733929038048,
0.18486475944519043,
-0.07908138632774353,
-0.08607519418001175,
0.13660800457000732,
-0.8360137939453125,
-0.15288317203521729,
0.3945171535015106,
-0.0328705720603466,
-0.37995877861976624,
-0.08018527179956436,
-0.917206346988678,
-0.8566740155220032,
0.15055477619171143,
0.29220855236053467,
-0.5430788397789001,
-0.16270190477371216,
0.43123719096183777,
0.08391815423965454,
0.18712927401065826,
0.15229076147079468,
-1.0398399829864502,
-0.04645449295639992,
1.0827751159667969,
0.6183184385299683,
-0.14365816116333008,
-0.12756483256816864,
-0.7976914048194885,
0.4579867422580719,
-0.08612127602100372,
0.9886522889137268,
-0.5524130463600159,
-0.19164301455020905,
0.15575473010540009,
-0.14255185425281525,
0.3871193826198578,
-0.2815232276916504,
0.3800710141658783,
-0.527569055557251,
-0.10980232805013657,
-0.03326891362667084,
-0.5712231993675232,
0.12395191192626953,
0.2551790475845337,
-0.4919719099998474,
0.2786572277545929,
-0.48393136262893677,
-0.8808136582374573,
0.2493010014295578,
-0.42914119362831116,
-0.47820165753364563,
0.11391565948724747,
-0.29544755816459656,
-0.761522114276886,
-0.0039660390466451645,
0.2337944507598877,
0.30865928530693054,
-0.10251092165708542,
0.25226983428001404,
-0.6065078973770142,
-0.16241005063056946,
0.4572608172893524,
-0.42834925651550293,
0.8676831722259521,
0.19927451014518738,
-0.05652080103754997,
0.48673000931739807,
-0.5655199885368347,
-0.2527925670146942,
0.05923302844166756,
-0.16796042025089264,
-0.3998686373233795,
0.026462800800800323,
-0.24936576187610626,
-0.09715162217617035,
0.16582313179969788,
-0.5637578368186951,
0.654628574848175,
-0.7149696946144104,
0.5124077200889587,
0.7305986285209656,
0.3507051169872284,
0.4676997661590576,
-0.4733920395374298,
0.7729642987251282,
0.18700258433818817,
0.3135153353214264,
-0.28062868118286133,
-0.5851452350616455,
-0.2972754240036011,
-0.6306024789810181,
0.46645063161849976,
0.6266226172447205,
-0.4309971332550049,
0.38226211071014404,
-0.122637078166008,
-0.5249924063682556,
-0.625512421131134,
0.13169875741004944,
0.3878735899925232,
0.3710869252681732,
0.1806039959192276,
-0.1544262170791626,
-0.4919013977050781,
-0.8024280667304993,
-0.41262876987457275,
0.019659245386719704,
-0.11624966561794281,
-0.07020378857851028,
0.29931461811065674,
-0.655994713306427,
0.6168190836906433,
-0.5086225867271423,
-0.2362392246723175,
0.17888450622558594,
-0.20553991198539734,
0.2950611710548401,
0.7633249163627625,
0.4865152835845947,
-0.47452205419540405,
-0.24077990651130676,
-0.027202464640140533,
-0.2850227355957031,
-0.40124452114105225,
-0.13033786416053772,
-0.13295233249664307,
0.13838720321655273,
0.6937947273254395,
-0.7017414569854736,
0.3289436995983124,
0.6507753729820251,
-0.4823406934738159,
0.6130484342575073,
0.0632464811205864,
-0.08057193458080292,
-1.3684157133102417,
0.01572779193520546,
-0.2171739637851715,
-0.36231622099876404,
-0.6170992851257324,
0.2775851786136627,
0.011650149710476398,
-0.08001180738210678,
-0.5545644760131836,
0.3237816393375397,
-0.0846208781003952,
0.3579089343547821,
-0.04513561353087425,
0.02112375572323799,
-0.17190048098564148,
-0.30141425132751465,
-0.6392331123352051,
0.7911126613616943,
0.7879976630210876,
-0.5399936437606812,
0.24218691885471344,
0.5198405981063843,
-0.2339903861284256,
0.5335976481437683,
-0.5163367986679077,
0.13185326755046844,
-0.011126257479190826,
0.3146527111530304,
-0.8686595559120178,
-0.49083566665649414,
0.399109810590744,
-0.5563982725143433,
0.542657196521759,
-0.2297295331954956,
-0.3274865746498108,
-0.026373067870736122,
-0.5779287815093994,
0.4925432503223419,
0.39843490719795227,
-0.3738206923007965,
0.3119589686393738,
0.7488917708396912,
-0.08356118202209473,
-0.6984018683433533,
-0.9127142429351807,
0.19544045627117157,
-0.5449690222740173,
-0.6249068379402161,
0.4319145083427429,
-0.09448062628507614,
-0.13990236818790436,
-0.114288330078125,
-0.12147894501686096,
0.10549385100603104,
0.4187292754650116,
0.26699334383010864,
0.05496274679899216,
-0.30681517720222473,
0.13482166826725006,
0.22257089614868164,
-0.29574838280677795,
-0.13625240325927734,
-0.2951695919036865,
0.6242066025733948,
0.13507355749607086,
-0.6437561511993408,
-0.8098030686378479,
0.47413170337677,
0.7533879280090332,
-0.2693417966365814,
0.4543473720550537,
0.4708344042301178,
-0.5269327163696289,
0.052874140441417694,
-0.6017405390739441,
-0.15182510018348694,
-0.512823760509491,
0.4230102598667145,
-0.18704622983932495,
-0.9792857766151428,
0.6453487873077393,
-0.007942353375256062,
0.07523343712091446,
0.5267520546913147,
0.5879479646682739,
-0.37747111916542053,
1.1514182090759277,
0.6714940071105957,
-0.11893926560878754,
0.7375887632369995,
0.11574388295412064,
0.12532870471477509,
-0.801253080368042,
-0.06494663655757904,
-0.5389046669006348,
-0.3857204020023346,
-0.5912150144577026,
-0.2541727125644684,
0.2289505898952484,
0.4890327453613281,
-0.5572730898857117,
0.23756860196590424,
-0.570492684841156,
0.47914332151412964,
0.3656206429004669,
-0.08535049855709076,
0.2686694264411926,
0.063152976334095,
-0.3557177186012268,
-0.0038812931161373854,
-0.6061537861824036,
-0.5168539881706238,
0.9951916933059692,
0.4491140842437744,
1.198615550994873,
0.3905206620693207,
0.7645403742790222,
0.08647113293409348,
0.13030758500099182,
-0.8152021169662476,
0.42554226517677307,
-0.380525141954422,
-0.5271186828613281,
-0.24535277485847473,
-0.16428744792938232,
-1.1346513032913208,
-0.26282766461372375,
-0.40738213062286377,
-1.197709083557129,
0.08482342213392258,
0.5815105438232422,
-0.6636639833450317,
0.22772973775863647,
-0.5513714551925659,
0.8280166387557983,
-0.28587234020233154,
-0.45727160573005676,
-0.2968197166919708,
-0.49212050437927246,
0.2718258500099182,
-0.1717168539762497,
0.014466183260083199,
-0.08854024857282639,
-0.17823125422000885,
0.6288283467292786,
-0.3347604274749756,
1.0838252305984497,
-0.07929407060146332,
-0.3953954577445984,
0.1185675859451294,
0.3093869388103485,
0.4936962425708771,
0.3811403214931488,
-0.07748766988515854,
0.2041921466588974,
0.1518554836511612,
-0.3045908510684967,
-0.39914974570274353,
0.9387247562408447,
-0.40751349925994873,
-1.2222713232040405,
-0.428850919008255,
-0.4185117781162262,
-0.11889998614788055,
0.39083966612815857,
0.3845358192920685,
0.04542385786771774,
-0.05945592373609543,
0.30170395970344543,
0.7844110727310181,
-0.44226157665252686,
0.18583965301513672,
0.7369171380996704,
-0.42214107513427734,
-0.5851930975914001,
0.7142961025238037,
0.08855780214071274,
0.3832411468029022,
0.36400744318962097,
0.37796616554260254,
0.014404162764549255,
-0.8958158493041992,
-0.31529122591018677,
0.2617911100387573,
-0.3711144030094147,
-0.6808933019638062,
-0.45899516344070435,
-0.12276668846607208,
-0.6147339940071106,
-0.22860820591449738,
-0.3307541012763977,
-0.2395244836807251,
-0.3033561706542969,
-0.04264345020055771,
0.4238271713256836,
0.5641359686851501,
-0.042861539870500565,
0.4434269368648529,
-0.7382225394248962,
0.11165949702262878,
0.1357986032962799,
0.5784661769866943,
-0.435176283121109,
-0.4884854257106781,
0.01963358372449875,
0.3234280049800873,
-0.5744607448577881,
-1.036118507385254,
-0.008719382807612419,
0.08860815316438675,
0.4725480079650879,
0.9321776628494263,
-0.02960239350795746,
0.7429731488227844,
-0.648444414138794,
0.7197258472442627,
0.27216458320617676,
-1.040586233139038,
0.6131603717803955,
-0.5714541077613831,
0.6459795832633972,
0.37957045435905457,
0.10960819572210312,
-0.764046311378479,
-0.7371750473976135,
-0.4262242317199707,
-0.7610746026039124,
0.4040093719959259,
-0.30001935362815857,
0.21951431035995483,
-0.004910397343337536,
0.5957078337669373,
0.1634441763162613,
-0.033758312463760376,
-0.3650503158569336,
-0.10397659987211227,
-0.018496332690119743,
-0.266076922416687,
0.05102561414241791,
-0.6285913586616516,
-0.22821597754955292,
-0.2554095685482025,
0.6510021686553955,
0.04461553320288658,
0.2320476621389389,
0.08317042142152786,
-0.06360367685556412,
-0.37418460845947266,
0.2603415548801422,
0.8236271739006042,
0.14040260016918182,
0.08618760108947754,
0.2543516755104065,
-0.02125529944896698,
-0.5830814242362976,
0.17669948935508728,
0.05335687845945358,
-0.37538114190101624,
-0.44968515634536743,
0.3345615863800049,
0.46887561678886414,
0.17774410545825958,
-0.5931869149208069,
0.652476966381073,
0.18434061110019684,
0.13920502364635468,
-0.07115679979324341,
0.2246771901845932,
0.199286088347435,
0.16614913940429688,
0.027705064043402672,
-0.08812730759382248,
0.04626200348138809,
-0.2845252454280853,
0.5115487575531006,
0.6818562150001526,
-0.48857560753822327,
-0.5121548771858215,
0.8378617167472839,
0.09240038692951202,
-0.4667154848575592,
0.380145788192749,
0.09966900944709778,
-0.4089016616344452,
0.4440435469150543,
1.1026467084884644,
0.7172184586524963,
-0.8576741814613342,
-0.028914472088217735,
0.12782727181911469,
0.3654915690422058,
0.15782418847084045,
0.14926590025424957,
0.4449595808982849,
-0.7461663484573364,
-0.47299134731292725,
-0.4050309956073761,
-0.1868455857038498,
0.38662850856781006,
-0.3985217213630676,
0.5923206806182861,
-0.4787031412124634,
-0.2596959173679352,
0.26054131984710693,
-0.3906521499156952,
-0.16971628367900848,
-0.38655081391334534,
0.30482396483421326,
0.9327297210693359,
-0.8820988535881042,
0.7495137453079224,
0.8383499979972839,
-0.26547130942344666,
-0.32200586795806885,
0.32651862502098083,
0.4398864209651947,
-0.6397216320037842,
0.06642794609069824,
0.24551910161972046,
-0.04188838601112366,
-0.051130279898643494,
-0.6255487203598022,
-0.9547626376152039,
0.7761467099189758,
0.9500955939292908,
-0.8563198447227478,
0.16539207100868225,
0.05146494135260582,
0.4096965789794922,
-0.1616310477256775,
-0.3062596917152405,
0.4309864938259125,
0.40613412857055664,
-0.15621274709701538,
-0.7082149386405945,
0.2745152413845062,
0.00845777802169323,
-0.2010180652141571,
0.38903331756591797,
-0.42870092391967773,
0.5841260552406311,
-0.2254517823457718,
-0.45219436287879944,
0.1606484055519104,
0.4098016321659088,
-0.020345890894532204,
0.21580053865909576,
0.24842362105846405,
0.7508274912834167,
0.8743076324462891,
0.02144724130630493,
0.958871066570282,
-0.29280567169189453,
0.12425918877124786,
1.108978509902954,
-0.19425027072429657,
0.9074267148971558,
0.7269118428230286,
0.12395569682121277,
0.15183334052562714,
0.31334444880485535,
-0.0003850985085591674,
0.3880874514579773,
0.4334317147731781,
-0.1867692619562149,
-0.34046992659568787,
-0.09245111048221588,
-0.42266005277633667,
0.6515587568283081,
0.6755791902542114,
0.007190353237092495,
-0.06319934129714966,
0.27601268887519836,
0.21745514869689941,
0.23203592002391815,
-0.2479282021522522,
0.9601104855537415,
0.057416848838329315,
-0.5164196491241455,
0.6288246512413025,
-0.08084660768508911,
0.7075154185295105,
-0.4740406274795532,
-0.008615533821284771,
0.06857733428478241,
0.2311267852783203,
-0.4430408775806427,
-0.8880127668380737,
0.39873257279396057,
-0.06281035393476486,
-0.10757432132959366,
-0.049272581934928894,
0.7668437957763672,
-0.45773670077323914,
-0.0929098129272461,
0.11812623590230942,
0.09393883496522903,
-0.17703451216220856,
0.1755603849887848,
-0.5975757241249084,
0.25277337431907654,
0.0262106042355299,
-0.201136976480484,
0.37726879119873047,
0.13547883927822113,
-0.2758095860481262,
0.7378717660903931,
0.5765970349311829,
0.13301649689674377,
0.03601716086268425,
-0.046828627586364746,
0.8395993709564209,
-0.44934341311454773,
-0.32016196846961975,
-1.169821858406067,
0.5207042098045349,
-0.012014119885861874,
-0.24950987100601196,
0.6760175824165344,
0.6096463799476624,
0.5247659087181091,
0.07761185616254807,
0.40557655692100525,
0.19394633173942566,
0.10811009258031845,
-0.6221053600311279,
1.1237072944641113,
-0.37497803568840027,
0.4287577271461487,
-0.20370785892009735,
-0.5039175152778625,
-0.9663527607917786,
0.28682973980903625,
-0.37761467695236206,
-0.5742975473403931,
0.4844553470611572,
0.9948075413703918,
0.00038934373878873885,
-0.26199376583099365,
0.31440791487693787,
0.6870743632316589,
0.6760032773017883,
0.3803291618824005,
0.7899875640869141,
-0.12450634688138962,
0.36122360825538635,
-0.06702739745378494,
-0.3041531443595886,
-0.5316284894943237,
-1.1365388631820679,
-0.7123578786849976,
-0.5539063215255737,
-0.6045949459075928,
-0.5305644273757935,
0.3151746094226837,
0.8303195834159851,
0.3273622393608093,
-1.0172687768936157,
0.07960763573646545,
-0.13120031356811523,
0.24542315304279327,
-0.1437537521123886,
-0.15436647832393646,
0.21178901195526123,
-0.16354820132255554,
-0.4400518536567688,
0.41038084030151367,
0.41077369451522827,
0.34895947575569153,
-0.07170466333627701,
0.28108036518096924,
-0.31715938448905945,
0.0360771119594574,
0.13602080941200256,
0.5462551116943359,
-0.8384646773338318,
-0.4459133744239807,
-0.2680119574069977,
-0.29408136010169983,
0.11232469975948334,
0.5520350337028503,
-0.45420941710472107,
0.6478524804115295,
0.45736241340637207,
1.0144805908203125,
0.0922318771481514,
-0.04727490618824959,
0.731893002986908,
-0.6061280369758606,
0.17480459809303284,
0.30549436807632446,
0.3447730839252472,
0.18373878300189972,
-0.6600217819213867,
-0.10393030196428299,
-0.03581804782152176,
-0.48878389596939087,
-1.0069875717163086,
0.626778781414032,
-0.9940403699874878,
0.057975105941295624,
1.2610410451889038,
-0.010729394853115082,
-0.4204198122024536,
0.10679400712251663,
-0.2161204218864441,
0.4530359208583832,
-0.5095096230506897,
0.7991622090339661,
0.5120972394943237,
0.1962580680847168,
0.15715426206588745,
-0.3968067467212677,
0.5245336890220642,
0.5848020911216736,
-0.6489465236663818,
0.04312896728515625,
0.3520936965942383,
0.3978986144065857,
0.09027144312858582,
0.14413237571716309,
-0.3460289239883423,
0.40132781863212585,
-0.21030816435813904,
0.036570653319358826,
-0.19543658196926117,
-0.04455329105257988,
-0.9259230494499207,
0.000222113958443515,
0.30963125824928284,
-0.2734408378601074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01108v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01108v1 | Reasoning Capacity in Multi-Agent Systems: Limitations, Challenges and Human-Centered Solutions | 2024-02-02T02:53:11 | 2024-02-02T02:53:11 | Pouya Pezeshkpour, Eser Kandogan, Nikita Bhutani, Sajjadur Rahman, Tom Mitchell, Estevam Hruschka | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Remarkable performance of large language models (LLMs) in a variety of tasks
brings forth many opportunities as well as challenges of utilizing them in
production settings. Towards practical adoption of LLMs, multi-agent systems
hold great promise to augment, integrate, and orchestrate LLMs in the larger
context of enterprise platforms that use existing proprietary data and models
to tackle complex real-world tasks. Despite the tremendous success of these
systems, current approaches rely on narrow, single-focus objectives for
optimization and evaluation, often overlooking potential constraints in
real-world scenarios, including restricted budgets, resources and time.
Furthermore, interpreting, analyzing, and debugging these systems requires
different components to be evaluated in relation to one another. This demand is
currently not feasible with existing methodologies. In this postion paper, we
introduce the concept of reasoning capacity as a unifying criterion to enable
integration of constraints during optimization and establish connections among
different components within the system, which also enable a more holistic and
comprehensive approach to evaluation. We present a formal definition of
reasoning capacity and illustrate its utility in identifying limitations within
each component of the system. We then argue how these limitations can be
addressed with a self-reflective process wherein human-feedback is used to
alleviate shortcomings in reasoning and enhance overall consistency of the
system. | [
-0.6586212515830994,
-0.34243401885032654,
1.096549391746521,
0.33287957310676575,
-0.13399696350097656,
0.21522754430770874,
-0.4599253833293915,
-0.504768431186676,
0.10055026412010193,
0.6391856074333191,
-0.5634759664535522,
-0.020330950617790222,
-0.35459208488464355,
0.313006728887558,
-0.05996314436197281,
0.418984979391098,
-0.21937482059001923,
0.006161348894238472,
-0.5363515019416809,
-0.33921486139297485,
-0.8093056678771973,
-0.6867766976356506,
-0.2681955397129059,
-0.5632621645927429,
0.2483413815498352,
0.6258530616760254,
0.6403738260269165,
0.22697584331035614,
0.42776045203208923,
0.43965041637420654,
0.34710294008255005,
0.6404353976249695,
-0.026973554864525795,
0.4190317988395691,
-0.4163616895675659,
-0.13523654639720917,
-0.4124067425727844,
-0.05697697028517723,
0.6507021188735962,
0.8058988451957703,
-0.15878796577453613,
0.2660565674304962,
0.23178347945213318,
0.3907051086425781,
-0.9042944312095642,
0.06374248117208481,
-0.4459826648235321,
-0.0595235750079155,
0.1935574859380722,
-0.13524757325649261,
-0.44622111320495605,
0.09671530872583389,
0.14154529571533203,
-0.7171093225479126,
-0.2803959548473358,
-0.04853068292140961,
0.5353832840919495,
0.5465438365936279,
-0.38044634461402893,
-0.17077617347240448,
-0.9377416968345642,
0.9824985265731812,
-0.42483261227607727,
0.14968650043010712,
0.08724017441272736,
0.4289954900741577,
-0.15342405438423157,
-0.30298078060150146,
-0.5625197291374207,
-0.142204150557518,
-0.0395694263279438,
-0.08992379158735275,
-0.15103764832019806,
0.12509065866470337,
0.14990027248859406,
-0.20794877409934998,
-0.2775547504425049,
0.03650253638625145,
-0.15612360835075378,
-0.4066198468208313,
0.7630165219306946,
0.4748474657535553,
0.14084643125534058,
0.0323120579123497,
-0.3355504274368286,
0.16758300364017487,
-0.15788164734840393,
-0.3204288184642792,
0.1056729182600975,
0.3394347131252289,
0.36491063237190247,
0.5340461730957031,
-0.31936410069465637,
0.5019927024841309,
-0.21534723043441772,
-0.012383914552628994,
0.04808279126882553,
-0.37553873658180237,
-0.1180177852511406,
-0.33155038952827454,
0.6221441030502319,
0.05118763819336891,
0.31850558519363403,
-0.3084743916988373,
-0.28516197204589844,
0.296671062707901,
0.551642119884491,
-0.3063220679759979,
0.4533107280731201,
0.3343442976474762,
-0.1381736546754837,
0.21646128594875336,
0.06065027043223381,
-0.6375648975372314,
-0.5263205766677856,
-0.59294193983078,
0.434373676776886,
-0.06374802440404892,
-0.4550866186618805,
0.3086254298686981,
-0.26454973220825195,
0.2273249328136444,
0.4673495888710022,
-0.5446395874023438,
0.3586539030075073,
0.5530513525009155,
0.6428683996200562,
-0.11020129173994064,
-0.4196900725364685,
-0.30215755105018616,
0.36157941818237305,
-0.12869171798229218,
0.7452322244644165,
-0.33369725942611694,
-0.2184140384197235,
-0.21738563477993011,
-0.11414468288421631,
-0.11686725914478302,
-0.5899190306663513,
0.6564728617668152,
-0.36573487520217896,
-0.40828707814216614,
-0.44943517446517944,
-0.3982020616531372,
0.057285863906145096,
0.37163326144218445,
-0.6847314238548279,
0.5528679490089417,
0.11315653473138809,
-0.24701058864593506,
0.25825899839401245,
-0.744135856628418,
-0.31440064311027527,
0.20558033883571625,
-0.2700468599796295,
-0.0027441454585641623,
0.1573220044374466,
-0.06688086688518524,
0.39182665944099426,
-0.6867650151252747,
0.16017507016658783,
-0.3821759521961212,
-0.20568546652793884,
0.3607747256755829,
-0.33838918805122375,
0.5782634019851685,
0.5348842740058899,
-0.34575825929641724,
0.23987612128257751,
-0.622611939907074,
0.3675759732723236,
0.14077845215797424,
-0.2886115312576294,
-0.17545390129089355,
0.07119303196668625,
-0.3150511682033539,
0.12595920264720917,
0.42916014790534973,
-0.3791867196559906,
0.19892539083957672,
-0.09049335867166519,
0.5505041480064392,
0.6172751784324646,
-0.1614741086959839,
0.5648349523544312,
-0.2762996256351471,
0.708126425743103,
-0.1203216016292572,
0.4145258069038391,
0.06049754470586777,
-0.01184548158198595,
-0.7319981455802917,
-0.1375635415315628,
-0.21274453401565552,
0.6357218027114868,
-0.5555316805839539,
0.38191941380500793,
-0.003986170515418053,
-0.38858041167259216,
-0.5015523433685303,
0.4124549627304077,
0.24944253265857697,
0.18809010088443756,
0.3108579218387604,
-0.3215636610984802,
-0.6135180592536926,
-0.9355903267860413,
-0.10219041258096695,
-0.13242579996585846,
0.12769094109535217,
0.3331504762172699,
0.5107793211936951,
-0.2606714367866516,
0.9178661108016968,
-0.19788958132266998,
-0.29830196499824524,
-0.5793860554695129,
-0.1173289567232132,
0.06180593743920326,
0.29680418968200684,
0.18724291026592255,
-0.595223069190979,
-0.26025235652923584,
0.1194922924041748,
-0.9750176072120667,
-0.26321476697921753,
-0.32968270778656006,
-0.1525154560804367,
0.20046360790729523,
0.24525465071201324,
-0.9316396117210388,
0.34400227665901184,
0.3503907322883606,
-0.447969526052475,
0.9418280124664307,
-0.4367833733558655,
-0.020167535170912743,
-0.4593145549297333,
-0.06804113835096359,
0.0028258708771318197,
-0.08757822960615158,
-0.4858541190624237,
0.22038014233112335,
-0.24117855727672577,
0.029440762475132942,
-0.02771805226802826,
0.5970191955566406,
-0.8907687067985535,
-0.3627755045890808,
-0.35581785440444946,
0.5086049437522888,
0.5417872667312622,
0.3959774672985077,
-0.13753393292427063,
0.7153850793838501,
0.3248094320297241,
-0.6715113520622253,
0.7510400414466858,
0.051930442452430725,
-0.28033673763275146,
0.7175853848457336,
-0.5500121116638184,
0.08200909942388535,
-0.014921139925718307,
0.17472238838672638,
-0.593536376953125,
-0.21154196560382843,
0.231031134724617,
-0.15404726564884186,
-0.09122569859027863,
0.30754420161247253,
-0.5892578959465027,
-0.4610673785209656,
0.011131231673061848,
0.4414508640766144,
0.06667035818099976,
-0.2743649482727051,
0.8522731065750122,
0.5207377076148987,
0.34968942403793335,
-0.6802449226379395,
-0.6253889799118042,
0.2647191286087036,
-0.1546449363231659,
-0.9329570531845093,
0.012248022481799126,
0.0792476236820221,
-0.6525945067405701,
-0.06614772230386734,
-0.19019317626953125,
-0.06986049562692642,
0.3136896789073944,
0.06972324848175049,
0.21311639249324799,
0.03226026892662048,
0.530978798866272,
0.027799531817436218,
-0.13960406184196472,
0.22101812064647675,
-0.4356536865234375,
0.24144203960895538,
-0.6106891632080078,
-0.8085033893585205,
-0.5552162528038025,
0.6134723424911499,
0.8321000337600708,
-0.3331047296524048,
0.6329702734947205,
0.24040721356868744,
-0.30034953355789185,
-0.3662879168987274,
-0.8581291437149048,
-0.3054172992706299,
-0.39169415831565857,
0.35659900307655334,
-0.5586863160133362,
-0.7251628041267395,
0.6362379789352417,
-0.333931028842926,
-0.20490838587284088,
0.3435856103897095,
0.5360155701637268,
0.052544791251420975,
0.9587380290031433,
0.35648229718208313,
0.2563573718070984,
0.003527918830513954,
-0.19523215293884277,
0.18711477518081665,
-1.038580298423767,
-0.2798769176006317,
-0.5681310892105103,
-0.08479339629411697,
-0.14362500607967377,
-0.6219230890274048,
0.39000141620635986,
0.04661017283797264,
-0.42636582255363464,
0.1893460601568222,
-0.6338525414466858,
0.4475380480289459,
0.2682558298110962,
-0.10208482295274734,
0.6842379570007324,
-0.2819681465625763,
-0.2778147757053375,
0.16415493190288544,
-0.7738071084022522,
-0.9125929474830627,
0.7630292773246765,
0.3281101584434509,
0.6743371486663818,
0.21878336369991302,
0.3996562063694,
0.30333587527275085,
0.16733373701572418,
-0.7127426862716675,
0.7386218309402466,
0.09950312972068787,
-0.8010037541389465,
-0.8287718892097473,
-0.35839760303497314,
-0.9936471581459045,
0.6970381140708923,
-0.1829366683959961,
-0.850304365158081,
0.18949070572853088,
-0.058641139417886734,
-0.40343666076660156,
0.32931461930274963,
-0.9948198199272156,
0.8157486915588379,
-0.5323412418365479,
-0.5428978800773621,
-0.4028347134590149,
-0.5081233978271484,
0.07971449196338654,
0.11303050816059113,
0.26731783151626587,
-0.2456396371126175,
-0.07015900313854218,
0.26678258180618286,
-0.517685055732727,
0.8291751146316528,
-0.20713885128498077,
-0.06483165919780731,
0.737199068069458,
-0.15487490594387054,
0.39092978835105896,
-0.10675451159477234,
-0.32089728116989136,
-0.04709381237626076,
0.2213113009929657,
-0.4197733998298645,
-0.7546741366386414,
0.40615981817245483,
-0.8426293134689331,
-0.9354027509689331,
-0.3663519322872162,
-0.4759051501750946,
-0.5409680604934692,
0.14198489487171173,
-0.1396504044532776,
0.13721629977226257,
-0.16885919868946075,
0.12727074325084686,
0.34412050247192383,
-0.01663508452475071,
0.3321303129196167,
0.5008171200752258,
-0.09964469820261002,
-0.002786036115139723,
0.6673387289047241,
0.21774214506149292,
0.3412950038909912,
-0.06646538525819778,
0.060709528625011444,
-0.3403874933719635,
-0.3779037296772003,
-0.3935248553752899,
0.29854413866996765,
-0.8101385831832886,
-0.10628574341535568,
-0.34571021795272827,
-0.12710271775722504,
-0.23912696540355682,
-0.03218112140893936,
-0.4756258428096771,
-0.23514702916145325,
-0.42523193359375,
0.15297530591487885,
-0.20948873460292816,
0.6009714007377625,
-0.10122094303369522,
0.156615749001503,
-0.7287724018096924,
0.023660151287913322,
0.3815475404262543,
0.4799588918685913,
0.43014901876449585,
-0.24572743475437164,
-0.46528109908103943,
-0.08422286808490753,
-0.5001261234283447,
-0.9771690964698792,
0.2061007171869278,
-0.24072504043579102,
0.9672559499740601,
0.23200832307338715,
0.25796374678611755,
0.41587525606155396,
-0.048629045486450195,
0.2989215552806854,
0.16237753629684448,
-1.0560251474380493,
0.4037465453147888,
-0.1935345083475113,
0.290418803691864,
0.5543997287750244,
0.13156743347644806,
-0.24452610313892365,
-0.3087107539176941,
-0.23348884284496307,
-0.6949763894081116,
0.4880494177341461,
0.08001518249511719,
-0.0372001975774765,
0.14470769464969635,
0.5272122621536255,
-0.12562766671180725,
0.24086180329322815,
-0.5349111557006836,
0.12285106629133224,
-0.004580600652843714,
0.12226145714521408,
0.051013100892305374,
-0.16795150935649872,
-0.22700150310993195,
-0.27857112884521484,
0.6365294456481934,
-0.37304797768592834,
0.0493275485932827,
0.39658141136169434,
-0.1898859143257141,
-0.10338670760393143,
0.7764631509780884,
0.45018163323402405,
1.0372363328933716,
0.12201610952615738,
0.0630093663930893,
0.33574727177619934,
-0.037508774548769,
0.43769118189811707,
-0.15662238001823425,
0.13911299407482147,
-0.38472333550453186,
0.2343807965517044,
0.7557123303413391,
-0.2523418962955475,
-0.9599937796592712,
0.32430559396743774,
0.15365265309810638,
-0.14461468160152435,
-0.524352490901947,
0.06953360140323639,
0.06476031243801117,
0.643338680267334,
0.569038450717926,
-0.07405415922403336,
0.06292963773012161,
-0.618934690952301,
-0.11753528565168381,
0.6722388863563538,
-0.2203802764415741,
0.06686652451753616,
0.2145216166973114,
0.3273973762989044,
-0.15172824263572693,
0.5416222214698792,
-0.39819878339767456,
-0.5084032416343689,
0.7046642899513245,
0.2974666357040405,
0.9494152665138245,
-0.09288638085126877,
0.348370224237442,
0.12362068146467209,
0.6576284170150757,
-0.15966548025608063,
0.1725509762763977,
-0.007540795486420393,
-1.2120479345321655,
-0.871100127696991,
-0.519940197467804,
-0.5971038341522217,
-0.04888889193534851,
-0.49198272824287415,
0.043378327041864395,
-0.4364667236804962,
-0.5777224898338318,
-0.13899849355220795,
0.2347327321767807,
-0.48331084847450256,
-0.011872450821101665,
0.0939636081457138,
0.6229131817817688,
-0.519126832485199,
0.5462696552276611,
0.7847801446914673,
-0.3990837633609772,
-0.8565326929092407,
-0.4095955789089203,
-0.06417153775691986,
-0.5668620467185974,
0.5283117294311523,
0.03950575739145279,
-0.5900390148162842,
-0.3964681327342987,
-0.4040204584598541,
-0.5762192010879517,
1.1477986574172974,
0.6893550753593445,
-0.5970411896705627,
0.0063971239142119884,
0.17903339862823486,
0.6764586567878723,
-0.7458601593971252,
0.04130266234278679,
0.7631022930145264,
0.8930943608283997,
-0.008920207619667053,
-1.0979465246200562,
0.2504192888736725,
-0.045400917530059814,
-0.1918984353542328,
0.12461944669485092,
-0.8638336658477783,
0.6054049730300903,
-0.403955340385437,
-0.24629941582679749,
-0.015541011467576027,
0.3970736861228943,
0.433788537979126,
0.48883453011512756,
0.8302705883979797,
0.49326175451278687,
0.8184312582015991,
0.04051420837640762,
0.9020895957946777,
-0.053846295922994614,
0.2865092158317566,
0.9822859764099121,
-0.6922491192817688,
0.4292830526828766,
0.6298226714134216,
-0.2063148468732834,
0.5649035573005676,
0.13455957174301147,
0.05602060258388519,
-0.13242779672145844,
0.4868791997432709,
-0.36956214904785156,
-0.8142327070236206,
-0.43090659379959106,
0.009893415495753288,
0.5981364846229553,
0.33887746930122375,
0.08929473906755447,
-0.08620122820138931,
-0.027499618008732796,
-0.2700391113758087,
0.34015339612960815,
-0.2389536201953888,
0.6130072474479675,
0.123586006462574,
-1.0795552730560303,
0.2923958897590637,
-0.08424026519060135,
0.14962846040725708,
-0.3506799340248108,
0.0039176493883132935,
0.12621824443340302,
0.2692464292049408,
-0.20116710662841797,
-0.6984533667564392,
0.5315427184104919,
-0.202591672539711,
-0.2795862555503845,
-0.27625417709350586,
0.9678849577903748,
-0.046332117170095444,
-0.20875275135040283,
0.6964024901390076,
0.8575370907783508,
0.008256466127932072,
-0.2729112505912781,
-0.43141087889671326,
0.32909542322158813,
-0.26560819149017334,
-0.16234196722507477,
0.2886064946651459,
0.7362277507781982,
-0.10655400902032852,
1.0943055152893066,
0.2548331320285797,
0.19146357476711273,
-0.24333715438842773,
0.23157981038093567,
0.7584418654441833,
-0.5771135687828064,
-0.3455941081047058,
-0.7559911608695984,
0.36207491159439087,
-0.13703937828540802,
-0.023049794137477875,
0.4353565275669098,
0.1588648557662964,
0.442294180393219,
0.16091632843017578,
1.046134352684021,
0.07708965986967087,
0.4015847444534302,
-0.2721169590950012,
0.2860187590122223,
-0.7245733141899109,
0.5547550320625305,
-0.20905981957912445,
-0.8188873529434204,
-0.09859435260295868,
0.5644558668136597,
-0.2998937666416168,
0.13917796313762665,
0.7050548195838928,
0.4204002618789673,
0.3048371374607086,
-0.0051874276250600815,
0.46430814266204834,
0.030997447669506073,
0.1591409295797348,
0.7417571544647217,
1.2105498313903809,
0.14748547971248627,
0.7756961584091187,
0.02585073560476303,
-0.34479382634162903,
-0.21536846458911896,
-0.7539814114570618,
-0.619340717792511,
-0.6926025748252869,
-0.1650182604789734,
-0.2676030099391937,
-0.20476694405078888,
0.8256703019142151,
0.7557805180549622,
-0.49683046340942383,
-0.6052433848381042,
-0.018341436982154846,
0.4038534164428711,
-0.20992860198020935,
-0.19627262651920319,
-0.07295437157154083,
-0.5353474020957947,
-0.3715671896934509,
0.18329976499080658,
0.49299392104148865,
-0.15527911484241486,
-0.8669938445091248,
-0.37647807598114014,
-0.17096857726573944,
0.34843701124191284,
0.6071348190307617,
0.3859456181526184,
-0.762533962726593,
-0.440116822719574,
0.05415472015738487,
-0.08132711052894592,
-0.23313741385936737,
0.8682382702827454,
-0.6152330636978149,
0.41545751690864563,
0.33176037669181824,
0.7460906505584717,
0.428659588098526,
-0.06459662318229675,
0.528628408908844,
-0.4768623411655426,
-0.02443624846637249,
0.41123223304748535,
0.3982189893722534,
0.25896772742271423,
-0.21284852921962738,
0.586381733417511,
0.1798257678747177,
-0.749129056930542,
-0.7624542713165283,
0.5395011305809021,
-1.026058554649353,
-0.4392858147621155,
0.9758777022361755,
-0.004840898793190718,
0.10832245647907257,
-0.5215154886245728,
-0.12718158960342407,
0.19689364731311798,
-0.32749804854393005,
0.6830288171768188,
1.0504908561706543,
-0.507348895072937,
-0.21063284575939178,
-0.48940184712409973,
-0.009844258427619934,
0.6059543490409851,
-0.9397071599960327,
0.1444532573223114,
0.6342595815658569,
-0.08388400822877884,
0.5930483341217041,
0.6805840730667114,
0.12275152653455734,
0.18096502125263214,
-0.08878536522388458,
0.10515055805444717,
0.14668138325214386,
-0.4688590168952942,
-0.055666618049144745,
0.3607233762741089,
0.3631327152252197,
0.034429386258125305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01789v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01789v2 | The Political Preferences of LLMs | 2024-02-02T02:43:10 | 2024-06-02T04:48:36 | David Rozado | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | I report here a comprehensive analysis about the political preferences
embedded in Large Language Models (LLMs). Namely, I administer 11 political
orientation tests, designed to identify the political preferences of the test
taker, to 24 state-of-the-art conversational LLMs, both closed and open source.
When probed with questions/statements with political connotations, most
conversational LLMs tend to generate responses that are diagnosed by most
political test instruments as manifesting preferences for left-of-center
viewpoints. This does not appear to be the case for five additional base (i.e.
foundation) models upon which LLMs optimized for conversation with humans are
built. However, the weak performance of the base models at coherently answering
the tests' questions makes this subset of results inconclusive. Finally, I
demonstrate that LLMs can be steered towards specific locations in the
political spectrum through Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) with only modest
amounts of politically aligned data, suggesting SFT's potential to embed
political orientation in LLMs. With LLMs beginning to partially displace
traditional information sources like search engines and Wikipedia, the societal
implications of political biases embedded in LLMs are substantial. | [
-0.6771735548973083,
-0.9024831652641296,
0.8027905225753784,
-0.07102269679307938,
-0.3167317509651184,
0.17194785177707672,
-0.6699187159538269,
-0.09492506086826324,
0.4417322278022766,
0.863957405090332,
-0.4476887881755829,
-0.504715085029602,
-0.7029122114181519,
-0.15845438838005066,
-0.2552988827228546,
0.886611819267273,
0.42164701223373413,
0.1532285362482071,
-0.08471711724996567,
-0.05857839435338974,
-0.18340027332305908,
-0.7459688186645508,
-0.3083555996417999,
-0.7079107761383057,
0.5638633966445923,
0.6274798512458801,
1.0128458738327026,
0.7249833941459656,
0.3151318430900574,
0.17972810566425323,
-0.13564686477184296,
-0.08170479536056519,
-0.7905979752540588,
0.055636074393987656,
-0.4284572899341583,
-0.7500810027122498,
-0.25577500462532043,
0.6218540668487549,
0.28043538331985474,
0.6657525897026062,
0.025122953578829765,
-0.06501148641109467,
-0.1326863169670105,
1.0466548204421997,
-0.5346091985702515,
-0.13176366686820984,
-0.9768518209457397,
-0.05633800849318504,
-0.2493802011013031,
-0.39855557680130005,
-0.4229085445404053,
-0.5222707390785217,
0.2592686414718628,
-0.07932671159505844,
-0.02555996924638748,
0.01634921506047249,
0.6227208971977234,
0.033638741821050644,
-0.8511579632759094,
-0.2804647982120514,
-0.5360137820243835,
0.9237041473388672,
-0.42196786403656006,
0.4761216938495636,
0.3930657207965851,
0.18981391191482544,
-0.4187195301055908,
0.03088972344994545,
-0.402986079454422,
-0.2647268772125244,
0.08391306549310684,
0.00998037587851286,
-0.074062779545784,
0.3280763030052185,
-0.10057494044303894,
0.30598703026771545,
-0.32540950179100037,
0.2866453230381012,
-0.1257013976573944,
0.0831616148352623,
0.5959144234657288,
0.16192039847373962,
-0.008602213114500046,
-0.5819607377052307,
-0.20797018706798553,
0.09719258546829224,
-0.9463223218917847,
0.07984603941440582,
0.865314781665802,
0.5189206004142761,
-0.035790760070085526,
0.9234868884086609,
-0.28051283955574036,
0.7169165015220642,
0.4292171895503998,
0.06249942630529404,
-0.13744483888149261,
-0.2624817490577698,
-0.2094995528459549,
-0.20033308863639832,
0.8496119976043701,
0.5643110275268555,
0.7064770460128784,
0.2207001894712448,
-0.2263297289609909,
0.2161354124546051,
0.06756523251533508,
-0.660625696182251,
-0.11258834600448608,
0.2788463830947876,
-0.6043776869773865,
-0.3626752197742462,
0.09339622408151627,
-0.6300729513168335,
-0.9104649424552917,
-0.7671111226081848,
-0.23092004656791687,
-0.11738861352205276,
-0.2220260500907898,
0.11625118553638458,
0.036200422793626785,
0.3113132119178772,
0.19688990712165833,
-1.0117079019546509,
0.025656389072537422,
1.1287615299224854,
0.7258486151695251,
-0.5579574704170227,
0.26836875081062317,
-0.4055933356285095,
-0.3203710913658142,
-0.5145983099937439,
0.727476179599762,
-0.9120379686355591,
-0.40862980484962463,
0.17984259128570557,
0.046377286314964294,
0.1581386923789978,
-0.5988028645515442,
0.1101512461900711,
-0.5581969618797302,
0.29378461837768555,
-0.6881641745567322,
-0.5237031579017639,
0.22894811630249023,
0.5453341007232666,
-0.39014944434165955,
0.6869627833366394,
-0.28005892038345337,
-0.651459813117981,
0.3365309536457062,
-0.7590733766555786,
-0.021247996017336845,
-0.4154165983200073,
-0.5021287202835083,
0.14505599439144135,
0.1072329431772232,
-0.16685225069522858,
0.6827479004859924,
-0.2118859738111496,
0.662605881690979,
-0.45820125937461853,
-0.337925523519516,
0.46750587224960327,
-0.28046518564224243,
0.8187379240989685,
0.11111200600862503,
-0.41427287459373474,
0.4048764407634735,
-0.7643477916717529,
-0.34749075770378113,
-0.11075393855571747,
-0.5270014405250549,
-0.36323466897010803,
0.3951975703239441,
-0.098504938185215,
-0.022165708243846893,
0.5392549633979797,
-0.5729467272758484,
0.1085960641503334,
-0.39029350876808167,
0.42997461557388306,
1.3006833791732788,
-0.2264535129070282,
0.9239786863327026,
-0.1932704597711563,
0.4010084569454193,
-0.00814432930201292,
0.16024532914161682,
0.505039632320404,
-0.38749516010284424,
-0.8451208472251892,
-0.07741329818964005,
0.03119817189872265,
0.6327008605003357,
-0.1004900336265564,
0.5852316617965698,
-0.1204633116722107,
-0.49177923798561096,
-0.15787629783153534,
-0.03917147219181061,
-0.09540470689535141,
0.016143321990966797,
-0.16935350000858307,
0.17538706958293915,
-0.4428313672542572,
-1.4121360778808594,
-0.37006014585494995,
-0.25200048089027405,
-0.05579528212547302,
0.6016841530799866,
0.5702073574066162,
-0.10891047865152359,
0.8437897562980652,
-0.37669453024864197,
0.16235662996768951,
-0.0768190547823906,
-0.39253902435302734,
0.316635400056839,
-0.026747766882181168,
0.37925347685813904,
-0.7943193316459656,
-0.4151845872402191,
0.19796083867549896,
-0.16869251430034637,
-0.0754626914858818,
0.22907371819019318,
-0.3213338255882263,
0.15591219067573547,
0.296141117811203,
-0.4815731942653656,
0.16600297391414642,
0.8778810501098633,
-0.4258376955986023,
0.24143020808696747,
0.16835680603981018,
0.19842249155044556,
-1.079363465309143,
-0.21668031811714172,
-0.018197404220700264,
-0.354388952255249,
-0.49489524960517883,
-0.21922002732753754,
-0.1197979524731636,
0.3558666706085205,
-0.4858383536338806,
0.30764204263687134,
-0.1599339246749878,
-0.07372163236141205,
-0.3465232253074646,
0.42871350049972534,
-0.33024144172668457,
0.0380033515393734,
0.0982929989695549,
0.7537922859191895,
0.28929659724235535,
-0.39149466156959534,
0.3824142515659332,
0.06940251588821411,
-0.24546752870082855,
0.7180799245834351,
-0.464891254901886,
0.3598064184188843,
-0.3030853271484375,
0.20421715080738068,
-1.1471256017684937,
-0.4105818271636963,
0.10199883580207825,
-0.15419235825538635,
-0.03729262202978134,
-0.1261693686246872,
-0.229408860206604,
0.16058628261089325,
-0.41178590059280396,
-0.2172856479883194,
0.5086236000061035,
-0.52740478515625,
0.3258443772792816,
0.7105421423912048,
0.11121396720409393,
-0.6522530913352966,
-0.5579901933670044,
-0.0991235002875328,
-0.4213792085647583,
-0.4165891706943512,
-0.061815857887268066,
0.008468091487884521,
-0.6743975281715393,
-0.10185758024454117,
0.18585622310638428,
0.23752786219120026,
-0.03503774106502533,
0.42887452244758606,
0.208163321018219,
-0.2967924475669861,
0.2010052502155304,
-0.11648426204919815,
0.008318689651787281,
-0.0428418330848217,
-0.1553497165441513,
0.7628195881843567,
-0.32909008860588074,
-0.3110072612762451,
-0.10322294384241104,
0.4159073829650879,
0.908523678779602,
-0.1113160029053688,
0.6848018169403076,
-0.006632108241319656,
-0.18445754051208496,
0.02732182666659355,
-0.5910477638244629,
-0.18835502862930298,
-0.4695306420326233,
0.4090789556503296,
-0.05307132378220558,
-1.1352027654647827,
0.45120763778686523,
-0.10248588025569916,
0.13123786449432373,
0.3021168112754822,
0.8793466687202454,
-0.15894760191440582,
0.7952630519866943,
0.5812873244285583,
-0.28631865978240967,
0.6024523377418518,
-0.020078742876648903,
0.3655479848384857,
-0.45082175731658936,
-0.09524184465408325,
-0.6622205972671509,
-0.442444384098053,
-1.03782320022583,
-0.07298381626605988,
0.26564034819602966,
-0.5095744729042053,
-0.6538923978805542,
-0.11290571838617325,
-0.7129740715026855,
0.7992404699325562,
0.3755419850349426,
0.09927652031183243,
0.09538397192955017,
0.05330078303813934,
0.21821768581867218,
-0.3053038716316223,
-0.30593523383140564,
-0.8009322285652161,
1.0337408781051636,
0.2954009771347046,
0.8919793367385864,
0.014916547574102879,
0.49615785479545593,
0.09511612355709076,
0.20196351408958435,
-0.8414866924285889,
0.6793550848960876,
-0.4008845388889313,
-0.6971725225448608,
-0.3400285243988037,
-0.15685808658599854,
-0.7202253937721252,
0.12154186517000198,
-0.29279467463493347,
-0.6220043897628784,
0.23585955798625946,
0.0032755271531641483,
-0.07928089797496796,
0.5395033359527588,
-0.1804170310497284,
0.6691474318504333,
-0.3318972885608673,
-0.17434293031692505,
-0.26865220069885254,
-0.7136857509613037,
0.3999643623828888,
0.03026789054274559,
0.08804600685834885,
-0.5514591932296753,
-0.197159081697464,
0.7330845594406128,
0.08069712668657303,
0.9386589527130127,
-0.23611292243003845,
-0.06956224143505096,
-0.14866764843463898,
-0.13955353200435638,
0.313693642616272,
-0.016792310401797295,
-0.3269588053226471,
0.07025615870952606,
-0.03164355829358101,
-0.16829507052898407,
-0.30436423420906067,
1.0322564840316772,
-1.0307791233062744,
-0.9969520568847656,
-0.38221973180770874,
-0.6416061520576477,
-0.06514423340559006,
0.15044233202934265,
0.16059629619121552,
0.0028041901532560587,
-0.33772245049476624,
0.5871475338935852,
0.8703005313873291,
-0.16902920603752136,
-0.10341649502515793,
0.2432013601064682,
-0.37947583198547363,
-0.09363241493701935,
0.36769309639930725,
0.22486348450183868,
0.5569143295288086,
0.23990575969219208,
0.5684530138969421,
-0.40509065985679626,
-0.3830499053001404,
-0.14998269081115723,
0.2617463171482086,
-0.7027192115783691,
-0.009769968688488007,
-0.4183661937713623,
-0.049001652747392654,
0.10636881738901138,
-0.4633561968803406,
-0.6662318706512451,
-0.28275126218795776,
-0.5323426723480225,
-0.10607972741127014,
0.3346444070339203,
0.8987618088722229,
0.08528528362512589,
0.4236956834793091,
0.08088022470474243,
0.2462761104106903,
0.0723104253411293,
0.41867002844810486,
-0.7196601033210754,
-0.47347384691238403,
0.30369463562965393,
0.3441542088985443,
-0.3314153552055359,
-1.0087844133377075,
-0.05878707766532898,
-0.02822885289788246,
0.10232126712799072,
0.6445741653442383,
0.21920305490493774,
0.36909839510917664,
-0.5256301164627075,
1.02510666847229,
-0.06259910017251968,
-0.6157267689704895,
0.618148684501648,
-0.5498969554901123,
-0.05301209166646004,
0.6421442627906799,
0.5651485323905945,
-0.29718345403671265,
-0.7107943296432495,
-0.30236396193504333,
-0.40197527408599854,
0.40443065762519836,
-0.30200207233428955,
0.6549384593963623,
-0.28961655497550964,
0.48298510909080505,
0.17338569462299347,
0.23157957196235657,
-0.4923301339149475,
-0.3141883909702301,
-0.06410213559865952,
-0.05464582145214081,
-0.20891600847244263,
-0.2560930848121643,
-0.571808934211731,
-0.2349354326725006,
0.5152775645256042,
-0.15997406840324402,
-0.03120793215930462,
0.02020953595638275,
0.5310364961624146,
-0.20904873311519623,
0.6017740964889526,
0.6670852303504944,
0.8221571445465088,
-0.3030366003513336,
0.30858734250068665,
-0.16692396998405457,
-0.1086047813296318,
0.4357050657272339,
-0.43415990471839905,
-0.2759872376918793,
-0.13222555816173553,
-0.39002907276153564,
0.5192767381668091,
-0.11682330071926117,
-0.13541743159294128,
0.6290948987007141,
0.02242511324584484,
-0.1282360553741455,
-0.3820287883281708,
-0.00012899099965579808,
0.622875988483429,
0.27107566595077515,
0.2297402322292328,
0.12467021495103836,
-0.17448365688323975,
-0.8925777673721313,
-0.07189791649580002,
1.2183595895767212,
-0.35130372643470764,
-0.24657906591892242,
0.5360183119773865,
0.2557554543018341,
-0.5887834429740906,
0.3094944357872009,
0.011492237448692322,
-0.7307683825492859,
0.35703548789024353,
0.3596099615097046,
0.559390127658844,
-0.10415925830602646,
0.14382776618003845,
0.04155348241329193,
0.4750421941280365,
0.19090767204761505,
0.2640383541584015,
0.2967943847179413,
-0.8685045838356018,
-0.16139741241931915,
-0.3931557834148407,
-0.6603876352310181,
0.28495973348617554,
-0.34902700781822205,
0.42518624663352966,
-0.5934929251670837,
-0.4093722999095917,
-0.0236332006752491,
0.2627441883087158,
-0.40168070793151855,
-0.06815420836210251,
0.11817427724599838,
0.7925319075584412,
-0.9365652799606323,
0.6466239094734192,
0.4763779044151306,
0.28528347611427307,
-0.22117924690246582,
-0.12351307272911072,
0.25096261501312256,
-0.8388847708702087,
0.4576047360897064,
-0.020096423104405403,
-0.20181386172771454,
-0.38309505581855774,
-0.8088449835777283,
-0.5935609340667725,
0.7480308413505554,
0.7989206314086914,
-0.6434406638145447,
-0.02336231991648674,
0.44610825181007385,
0.2862338125705719,
-0.5484837293624878,
0.12171723693609238,
0.7616246342658997,
0.586509644985199,
-0.30275747179985046,
-0.7506511211395264,
-0.034829847514629364,
0.18811102211475372,
-0.20041635632514954,
0.38288018107414246,
-0.959261417388916,
0.8373463749885559,
0.06614147126674652,
-0.03211117535829544,
-0.2084883600473404,
0.495783269405365,
0.2975000739097595,
0.130903422832489,
0.639728307723999,
-0.0964847281575203,
0.8105762004852295,
-0.2490951269865036,
0.9218546152114868,
-0.5879684686660767,
0.09178698062896729,
0.7250104546546936,
-0.24071303009986877,
0.8532788753509521,
0.9133420586585999,
-0.013753965497016907,
0.2846825420856476,
0.9505095481872559,
0.299641877412796,
0.442762166261673,
0.3947109282016754,
-0.12948109209537506,
-0.3817637264728546,
-0.3201903998851776,
-0.18183420598506927,
0.5982896089553833,
0.31124061346054077,
-0.25278446078300476,
0.013900846242904663,
-0.27955934405326843,
0.19741009175777435,
0.39433783292770386,
0.05921553075313568,
0.3967228829860687,
0.1128191202878952,
-0.6693001985549927,
0.23496432602405548,
-0.17300483584403992,
0.9265335202217102,
-0.5718882083892822,
0.1510474681854248,
-0.2659679055213928,
-0.053870789706707,
-0.36303314566612244,
-1.1023283004760742,
0.26029708981513977,
-0.014153402298688889,
-0.2745150327682495,
-0.22905433177947998,
0.68702632188797,
-0.4063316285610199,
-0.01421896368265152,
0.3399924635887146,
0.6125356554985046,
0.168538898229599,
-0.07928622514009476,
-0.4928756356239319,
0.27153703570365906,
0.12303171306848526,
-0.7386382818222046,
0.4496678113937378,
0.36976906657218933,
-0.042422592639923096,
0.48192137479782104,
0.7973201870918274,
0.26979824900627136,
-0.10019472986459732,
-0.14748099446296692,
0.807064950466156,
-0.5779331922531128,
-0.2161392718553543,
-1.0380795001983643,
0.24311219155788422,
-0.07221636921167374,
-0.2222738265991211,
0.6083417534828186,
0.6400386095046997,
0.6707778573036194,
0.11530079692602158,
0.8637868165969849,
0.1673678755760193,
0.35870474576950073,
-0.470133513212204,
0.9095613956451416,
-0.3866167366504669,
0.11844659596681595,
0.07107158750295639,
-0.877947986125946,
-0.15290269255638123,
0.796161413192749,
-0.5952770709991455,
-0.0920569971203804,
0.35993337631225586,
0.9354026913642883,
-0.2970520257949829,
0.035519856959581375,
0.45209503173828125,
0.028854168951511383,
0.3257436156272888,
0.5166447758674622,
1.1519801616668701,
0.22834427654743195,
0.12128360569477081,
-0.3955102562904358,
-0.2616315484046936,
-0.12432070076465607,
-0.9073258638381958,
-1.104518175125122,
-0.6534034609794617,
-0.10144976526498795,
-0.3529497981071472,
-0.006554822437465191,
1.183134913444519,
0.6411939263343811,
-0.5933593511581421,
-0.4395866096019745,
0.13579295575618744,
0.2565576136112213,
0.7076454758644104,
-0.2672593593597412,
0.1705678105354309,
0.0644703283905983,
-0.9023209810256958,
0.14137186110019684,
0.2775193452835083,
-0.08352150022983551,
-0.5672742128372192,
-0.08220802992582321,
-0.2890598177909851,
0.39978745579719543,
0.6743091940879822,
-0.057584360241889954,
-1.0458285808563232,
-0.8627617359161377,
0.4164009690284729,
-0.27354076504707336,
0.2944251596927643,
0.7123667001724243,
-0.3283787667751312,
0.26803699135780334,
0.48677965998649597,
0.41258999705314636,
0.10943073779344559,
0.05788503959774971,
0.45787760615348816,
-0.25935250520706177,
0.17253020405769348,
0.1790381222963333,
0.21425139904022217,
0.46613380312919617,
-0.35473817586898804,
0.36383798718452454,
-0.07994422316551208,
-0.8815526962280273,
-0.8335724472999573,
0.39652591943740845,
-0.9681302309036255,
0.04838257655501366,
1.494102954864502,
0.37898191809654236,
-0.17370621860027313,
0.0645635575056076,
-0.3479671776294708,
0.07290996611118317,
-0.4646576941013336,
0.4618505835533142,
0.7717681527137756,
-0.3106886148452759,
0.0287996344268322,
-0.8446802496910095,
0.4310409128665924,
0.26680052280426025,
-0.5150874853134155,
0.16732248663902283,
0.47531625628471375,
0.5192567110061646,
0.14785116910934448,
0.7872248888015747,
-0.11568740010261536,
0.0022291529458016157,
-0.5373396277427673,
-0.29915371537208557,
0.36818280816078186,
-0.22979488968849182,
-0.40973469614982605,
0.07687363028526306,
0.10797123610973358,
-0.1716039627790451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01788v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01788v1 | LitLLM: A Toolkit for Scientific Literature Review | 2024-02-02T02:41:28 | 2024-02-02T02:41:28 | Shubham Agarwal, Issam H. Laradji, Laurent Charlin, Christopher Pal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Conducting literature reviews for scientific papers is essential for
understanding research, its limitations, and building on existing work. It is a
tedious task which makes an automatic literature review generator appealing.
Unfortunately, many existing works that generate such reviews using Large
Language Models (LLMs) have significant limitations. They tend to
hallucinate-generate non-actual information-and ignore the latest research they
have not been trained on. To address these limitations, we propose a toolkit
that operates on Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) principles, specialized
prompting and instructing techniques with the help of LLMs. Our system first
initiates a web search to retrieve relevant papers by summarizing user-provided
abstracts into keywords using an off-the-shelf LLM. Authors can enhance the
search by supplementing it with relevant papers or keywords, contributing to a
tailored retrieval process. Second, the system re-ranks the retrieved papers
based on the user-provided abstract. Finally, the related work section is
generated based on the re-ranked results and the abstract. There is a
substantial reduction in time and effort for literature review compared to
traditional methods, establishing our toolkit as an efficient alternative. Our
open-source toolkit is accessible at https://github.com/shubhamagarwal92/LitLLM
and Huggingface space (https://huggingface.co/spaces/shubhamagarwal92/LitLLM)
with the video demo at https://youtu.be/E2ggOZBAFw0. | [
-0.2414996474981308,
-0.38317328691482544,
0.5461851358413696,
0.2886463403701782,
-0.420916885137558,
0.28731876611709595,
-0.11859528720378876,
-0.327486127614975,
0.3308333456516266,
0.8044416904449463,
-0.2202485352754593,
-0.4736257791519165,
0.03867318853735924,
0.32760727405548096,
-0.4657473564147949,
1.445480465888977,
0.06145462393760681,
0.27138739824295044,
-0.2373516708612442,
-0.08933794498443604,
0.08498232066631317,
-0.07700888812541962,
-0.3671545386314392,
-0.5344024300575256,
0.9748474359512329,
0.06812766939401627,
0.7091624140739441,
-0.14988625049591064,
0.5700398087501526,
0.22961384057998657,
-0.38338518142700195,
0.46298879384994507,
-0.6456912755966187,
0.3855130672454834,
-0.2453846037387848,
-0.313933402299881,
-0.5825414657592773,
0.05783397704362869,
0.6761215925216675,
0.6742137670516968,
0.05017266795039177,
0.24935732781887054,
0.10612254589796066,
0.8554800152778625,
-0.4032266438007355,
-0.1971845179796219,
-0.7049310803413391,
0.24114994704723358,
-0.08278938382863998,
-0.6747813820838928,
-0.5556002855300903,
-0.6721439957618713,
-0.09069931507110596,
-0.598220944404602,
0.2806797921657562,
0.3141348659992218,
0.520290195941925,
0.06176534667611122,
-0.36029714345932007,
-0.4477550983428955,
-0.7540130615234375,
0.7640215754508972,
-0.6424736380577087,
0.11515644937753677,
0.215304896235466,
0.2878226637840271,
-0.30766114592552185,
-0.6729312539100647,
-0.40829092264175415,
-0.44209346175193787,
-0.30625754594802856,
0.38166171312332153,
0.49696868658065796,
0.17246805131435394,
0.2926788926124573,
0.509010374546051,
-0.6186913847923279,
-0.26439517736434937,
-0.6712407469749451,
-0.08584744483232498,
0.7824469208717346,
0.23008690774440765,
0.17225505411624908,
-0.42971354722976685,
-0.3599467873573303,
0.018739497289061546,
-1.0652159452438354,
-0.07283871620893478,
0.35721075534820557,
-0.08196147531270981,
0.4351489841938019,
0.8349846005439758,
0.21751932799816132,
0.5124737620353699,
-0.16698706150054932,
-0.31633424758911133,
0.27253279089927673,
-0.40753334760665894,
-0.15020056068897247,
0.11971964687108994,
0.582360029220581,
0.5566698908805847,
-0.377282053232193,
0.032762229442596436,
-0.6281885504722595,
-0.33427754044532776,
0.2420799285173416,
-1.025660514831543,
-0.046390216797590256,
0.2875755727291107,
-0.5392612218856812,
-0.49949342012405396,
0.06447486579418182,
-0.6930648684501648,
-0.671359658241272,
-0.10979878157377243,
0.4037376046180725,
-0.17143066227436066,
-0.2711853086948395,
-0.013703031465411186,
-0.065203458070755,
0.11861132085323334,
0.587257981300354,
-0.268728643655777,
0.15724772214889526,
0.44376665353775024,
0.921647846698761,
-0.2599208950996399,
-0.0070773218758404255,
-0.6775962710380554,
0.14686965942382812,
-0.5031428337097168,
0.6520904302597046,
-0.20786865055561066,
-0.6668450832366943,
0.0744476169347763,
-0.027503428980708122,
0.15307968854904175,
-0.45029139518737793,
0.424818754196167,
-0.8298647999763489,
0.33986446261405945,
0.00595121830701828,
-0.5043707489967346,
-0.010725772939622402,
0.23372770845890045,
-0.723146915435791,
1.116913914680481,
0.02479317970573902,
-1.015274167060852,
0.1799195259809494,
-0.5835095047950745,
-0.20363524556159973,
0.3447169363498688,
-0.18374836444854736,
-0.5115947723388672,
0.2707947790622711,
0.09825503826141357,
0.23295223712921143,
-0.47027871012687683,
0.4685077965259552,
-0.18878726661205292,
-0.4870642423629761,
0.28112635016441345,
0.11536650359630585,
0.839011013507843,
0.5651068687438965,
-0.07247061282396317,
0.3353654742240906,
-0.6293724179267883,
0.21190261840820312,
-0.03967486694455147,
-0.41077500581741333,
-0.38437584042549133,
0.007713187951594591,
0.3896833062171936,
-0.1382666528224945,
0.11851170659065247,
-0.5937966704368591,
0.24671123921871185,
-0.5926516652107239,
0.1788501739501953,
0.4560239017009735,
0.20891031622886658,
0.4529348611831665,
-0.5483692288398743,
0.6019372940063477,
-0.4165034294128418,
0.07297537475824356,
-0.38125985860824585,
-0.14591678977012634,
-0.6871711611747742,
-0.022746609523892403,
0.4017867147922516,
0.26309633255004883,
-1.0249016284942627,
0.39055564999580383,
0.0159629937261343,
-0.6271997094154358,
-0.6040289998054504,
0.3417074978351593,
0.35064154863357544,
0.33420270681381226,
0.2376989871263504,
-0.09199580550193787,
-0.5651646256446838,
-0.5009118318557739,
-0.18059329688549042,
-0.36557310819625854,
-0.21525023877620697,
0.3837239444255829,
0.42079415917396545,
-0.29880425333976746,
1.0117030143737793,
-0.42059239745140076,
-0.3743413984775543,
-0.24221163988113403,
0.22268207371234894,
0.28853657841682434,
0.1920270472764969,
0.20574142038822174,
-0.8452029228210449,
-0.45467787981033325,
0.10062012076377869,
-0.7842978835105896,
-0.7248695492744446,
-0.15112413465976715,
0.2396555095911026,
0.2896532416343689,
0.618316650390625,
-0.3896450996398926,
0.38754966855049133,
0.32452550530433655,
-0.16927240788936615,
0.745993435382843,
-0.13762043416500092,
0.09255281835794449,
-0.891501784324646,
0.5772458910942078,
-0.3601766526699066,
-0.138267382979393,
-0.3427261710166931,
0.09383457154035568,
0.007278917822986841,
-0.159297913312912,
-0.3076050877571106,
0.7820048928260803,
-0.6333547234535217,
-0.19654656946659088,
-0.45626628398895264,
0.22898532450199127,
0.2853138744831085,
-0.10651318728923798,
-0.03158877044916153,
0.7713648676872253,
-0.06702995300292969,
-0.42221757769584656,
0.17988444864749908,
-0.07267561554908752,
-0.42424798011779785,
0.4480871856212616,
-0.7133360505104065,
-0.002377823693677783,
-0.1316118687391281,
0.31508713960647583,
-0.8255497813224792,
-0.20155197381973267,
-0.17796804010868073,
-0.28534623980522156,
0.2659507393836975,
0.07984013855457306,
-0.6885305047035217,
-0.29825884103775024,
-0.7566423416137695,
0.31930360198020935,
0.5188956260681152,
-0.5657514333724976,
0.642739474773407,
0.35134613513946533,
-0.49155721068382263,
-0.5280338525772095,
-0.2321264147758484,
0.11375420540571213,
0.0025360106956213713,
-0.49189504981040955,
0.4370018243789673,
-0.39964067935943604,
-0.4369974732398987,
0.05186201259493828,
-0.019128819927573204,
0.22934281826019287,
-0.2894837260246277,
0.2067612111568451,
0.39927563071250916,
0.15077272057533264,
0.348345547914505,
0.08652015775442123,
0.1864461451768875,
0.04494423791766167,
0.10844757407903671,
0.280819833278656,
-0.21535339951515198,
-0.38061287999153137,
0.4049522578716278,
0.01529212761670351,
0.49381643533706665,
-0.03606811910867691,
-0.09281910955905914,
0.8416134715080261,
0.03131948038935661,
-0.2717280089855194,
-0.8400949835777283,
-0.46307677030563354,
-0.4318464696407318,
0.18408004939556122,
-0.021419048309326172,
-1.0308572053909302,
0.41382044553756714,
-0.07905895262956619,
0.4205346703529358,
0.2796967923641205,
0.5614371299743652,
-0.18809576332569122,
1.0129318237304688,
0.46101632714271545,
0.19550348818302155,
0.24881669878959656,
-0.09277225285768509,
0.1853620558977127,
-1.1092417240142822,
-0.2743989825248718,
-0.44998201727867126,
-0.04314123094081879,
-0.3635152280330658,
-0.5713769197463989,
0.8209332823753357,
0.11673015356063843,
0.1562533974647522,
-0.20643551647663116,
-0.7450869679450989,
0.4693760871887207,
0.19041043519973755,
-0.15596270561218262,
0.5628289580345154,
0.14261190593242645,
-0.574624240398407,
-0.15091833472251892,
-0.7404710054397583,
-0.6555647253990173,
0.9473593831062317,
0.24586302042007446,
1.1803511381149292,
-0.2724667191505432,
0.829711377620697,
0.251858651638031,
0.8301750421524048,
-0.6986971497535706,
0.8371376991271973,
0.310333251953125,
-0.648493766784668,
-0.19171933829784393,
-0.38497498631477356,
-1.0810083150863647,
0.477061927318573,
-0.21396636962890625,
-0.07187779992818832,
-0.09504706412553787,
0.007346754427999258,
-0.22639338672161102,
0.33551567792892456,
-0.2476343959569931,
0.035139068961143494,
-0.48279523849487305,
-0.7860196828842163,
-0.2805338203907013,
-0.6385109424591064,
0.6507763266563416,
-0.14891605079174042,
0.3659663796424866,
0.009953007102012634,
-0.17379605770111084,
0.7004294991493225,
-0.48696428537368774,
0.7497012615203857,
-0.2516458332538605,
-0.08462919294834137,
0.38567429780960083,
0.2478802353143692,
0.15924708545207977,
0.3685928285121918,
-0.1353495717048645,
-0.45374634861946106,
0.19224973022937775,
-0.07668290287256241,
-0.34775039553642273,
0.847366213798523,
-0.5138524174690247,
-0.5796169638633728,
-0.819240391254425,
-0.7523112893104553,
0.01458820328116417,
0.3935445547103882,
0.09855572134256363,
0.13218185305595398,
-0.3352903723716736,
0.35685086250305176,
0.7503937482833862,
-0.4410962760448456,
0.2678335905075073,
0.7986397743225098,
-1.176888346672058,
-0.7480995655059814,
0.7065007090568542,
0.10211917757987976,
-0.06827954202890396,
0.15154653787612915,
0.32919472455978394,
-0.1926838755607605,
-0.6044650673866272,
-0.28391599655151367,
0.362559974193573,
-0.5360974669456482,
-0.4551462233066559,
-0.667998731136322,
-0.42097675800323486,
-0.19148431718349457,
-0.13847564160823822,
-0.03475416824221611,
-0.40208083391189575,
-0.10096434503793716,
0.038187239319086075,
0.4279037117958069,
1.1058714389801025,
0.023163096979260445,
-0.0011732918210327625,
-0.6728212237358093,
0.24029827117919922,
0.2344890683889389,
0.2900054156780243,
-0.07854785025119781,
-0.4195147752761841,
-0.2727397382259369,
-0.45664921402931213,
-0.3431883752346039,
-0.7371406555175781,
0.6558862328529358,
0.13161830604076385,
0.3679947257041931,
0.20776575803756714,
0.21026815474033356,
0.3876867890357971,
-0.522434651851654,
0.8435431122779846,
0.19156889617443085,
-0.3605462610721588,
0.5246208906173706,
-0.350508451461792,
0.47888365387916565,
0.6656241416931152,
0.24793553352355957,
-0.3973175585269928,
-0.4799618721008301,
-0.3421861529350281,
-1.0373286008834839,
0.429618239402771,
0.08959686011075974,
-0.15040983259677887,
0.23602202534675598,
0.21628311276435852,
0.1938338726758957,
0.39369258284568787,
-0.8823022842407227,
0.21592964231967926,
-0.08282557129859924,
0.1459508091211319,
0.010626654140651226,
-0.42181992530822754,
-0.5167555212974548,
-0.05531309172511101,
0.962982177734375,
-0.3517790734767914,
-0.08594458550214767,
0.6233162879943848,
-0.3320133090019226,
-0.41947031021118164,
0.3652588725090027,
0.5208868980407715,
0.5843175053596497,
-0.47084832191467285,
0.28799545764923096,
0.08776377886533737,
-0.5498048067092896,
0.05516351759433746,
0.19975338876247406,
-0.6810621023178101,
0.26667553186416626,
0.15351788699626923,
0.2333625853061676,
0.3545497953891754,
-0.7666786909103394,
0.25359949469566345,
-0.07120461761951447,
-0.27002236247062683,
-0.4266000986099243,
-0.041825469583272934,
0.20653830468654633,
-0.011951270513236523,
0.7670386433601379,
-0.1881035715341568,
0.344566285610199,
-0.1573631763458252,
0.018769610673189163,
0.5751925110816956,
-0.13269080221652985,
-0.1945817470550537,
0.36300909519195557,
0.28857123851776123,
-0.3131546974182129,
0.04748517647385597,
-0.3273625075817108,
-0.41141483187675476,
0.33791840076446533,
0.35144174098968506,
0.8060922622680664,
-0.17054013907909393,
0.20922495424747467,
0.3098475933074951,
0.5458884239196777,
-0.007492868695408106,
0.37733086943626404,
0.12986038625240326,
-0.13680477440357208,
-0.5496416687965393,
-0.820949375629425,
-0.6840998530387878,
0.3023681044578552,
-0.3658533990383148,
0.405291885137558,
-0.5582400560379028,
-0.14951753616333008,
-0.15499690175056458,
0.26911935210227966,
-0.2246730625629425,
-0.10752931237220764,
-0.3775424063205719,
0.9110589027404785,
-0.4552149772644043,
0.6008148789405823,
0.666535496711731,
-0.4215453267097473,
-0.5094475746154785,
-0.4355776309967041,
0.09315606206655502,
-0.3641856908798218,
0.6168193817138672,
0.14672116935253143,
-0.41916748881340027,
-0.3083786964416504,
-0.6437218189239502,
-0.6362760663032532,
1.2574338912963867,
-0.03584762290120125,
-0.5667403936386108,
0.029142390936613083,
-0.26078420877456665,
0.8632896542549133,
-0.5450772643089294,
0.5675709843635559,
0.029844151809811592,
0.49994710087776184,
0.17953050136566162,
-0.8927120566368103,
-0.004358713515102863,
-0.5678517818450928,
0.11230722069740295,
-0.14599275588989258,
-0.5012636184692383,
0.601462721824646,
-0.14606371521949768,
-0.016616135835647583,
0.30158185958862305,
0.3423238694667816,
0.6818809509277344,
0.7329423427581787,
0.6051315069198608,
0.24414268136024475,
0.6200263500213623,
0.23046676814556122,
0.7834606766700745,
-0.39174318313598633,
0.2835858464241028,
1.0340684652328491,
-0.8420311212539673,
0.6513813138008118,
0.7885405421257019,
-0.11347108334302902,
0.3654734790325165,
0.48857319355010986,
-0.037715986371040344,
0.27702540159225464,
0.3712286353111267,
-0.33415278792381287,
0.09248746186494827,
-0.39082664251327515,
-0.5335752367973328,
-0.10122334212064743,
0.4825369119644165,
-0.5932503938674927,
-0.2743515372276306,
0.07825864106416702,
-0.12994815409183502,
0.23442181944847107,
-0.41316884756088257,
0.8541936874389648,
0.3328663408756256,
-0.8243131041526794,
0.6200068593025208,
-0.19364257156848907,
0.6907840371131897,
-0.7037202715873718,
-0.09538806229829788,
-0.12963315844535828,
-0.1186223104596138,
-0.6620845794677734,
-0.7343037128448486,
0.17908743023872375,
0.060615625232458115,
-0.15069425106048584,
-0.3563901484012604,
1.080890417098999,
-0.543967068195343,
-0.6366307735443115,
0.29649707674980164,
0.6049609780311584,
0.3298003077507019,
0.5319697260856628,
-0.6937875747680664,
0.2474517524242401,
-0.008654876612126827,
-0.5931523442268372,
0.32220396399497986,
0.1468563824892044,
-0.08929063379764557,
0.5650984048843384,
0.7572668790817261,
0.5418413877487183,
-0.2165379375219345,
0.31398823857307434,
0.944635272026062,
-0.535253643989563,
-0.34587526321411133,
-0.3590379059314728,
0.2487744837999344,
-0.3374110460281372,
0.07401740550994873,
0.761574923992157,
0.8592084646224976,
0.591160774230957,
-0.1373497098684311,
0.8002924919128418,
-0.00828700140118599,
0.8655288219451904,
-0.45966488122940063,
0.8685241937637329,
-0.6512353420257568,
0.6883656978607178,
-0.24381457269191742,
-1.1491602659225464,
-0.5895668864250183,
0.6657304763793945,
-0.26738855242729187,
0.10699889808893204,
0.7659358978271484,
1.0630848407745361,
0.12823964655399323,
-0.15917110443115234,
0.2998555600643158,
0.2636464536190033,
0.3885055184364319,
-0.01024739257991314,
0.8801090121269226,
0.005444185808300972,
0.6020327210426331,
0.025322483852505684,
-0.10176388919353485,
-0.5996869802474976,
-1.183842658996582,
-1.0473461151123047,
-0.3486424684524536,
-0.05237939953804016,
-0.6193459033966064,
0.02971564792096615,
0.9879372119903564,
0.5346747040748596,
-0.5750160813331604,
-0.40096575021743774,
0.12051140516996384,
0.2077857255935669,
0.18286828696727753,
-0.28021883964538574,
0.36404934525489807,
-0.6904483437538147,
-0.4329964518547058,
0.3612402677536011,
0.5171713829040527,
-0.15857475996017456,
-0.835835337638855,
-0.21274545788764954,
-0.15095123648643494,
0.06210606172680855,
0.6179085373878479,
0.25960856676101685,
-0.7665784358978271,
0.20344756543636322,
0.19271233677864075,
-0.2911801040172577,
-0.1670544445514679,
1.0391076803207397,
-0.7076806426048279,
0.8180003762245178,
0.7068594098091125,
0.45259758830070496,
0.7391407489776611,
-0.37069863080978394,
0.36534979939460754,
-0.6762740612030029,
-0.1647716611623764,
0.752034604549408,
0.3691445589065552,
0.5247855186462402,
-0.3066495656967163,
0.8207089304924011,
-0.040241751819849014,
-0.9521516561508179,
-1.253605842590332,
0.036574967205524445,
-0.8572555780410767,
-0.14106428623199463,
1.142459511756897,
0.026684828102588654,
-0.2516079246997833,
-0.16895869374275208,
-0.7426716089248657,
-0.10991387814283371,
-0.25899118185043335,
0.8650766015052795,
0.49956849217414856,
-0.13870549201965332,
-0.046365901827812195,
-0.5113938450813293,
0.723626971244812,
0.6501204967498779,
-0.7885633111000061,
-0.10459975898265839,
0.5476446747779846,
0.29614993929862976,
0.35888758301734924,
0.7590318918228149,
-0.43492478132247925,
0.49629974365234375,
-0.5196031332015991,
0.3345975875854492,
-0.12487195432186127,
-0.1534416675567627,
-0.401838093996048,
0.278804212808609,
0.4059293866157532,
0.8274992108345032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01097v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01097v1 | Let's Negotiate! A Survey of Negotiation Dialogue Systems | 2024-02-02T02:12:46 | 2024-02-02T02:12:46 | Haolan Zhan, Yufei Wang, Tao Feng, Yuncheng Hua, Suraj Sharma, Zhuang Li, Lizhen Qu, Zhaleh Semnani Azad, Ingrid Zukerman, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Negotiation is a crucial ability in human communication. Recently, there has
been a resurgent research interest in negotiation dialogue systems, whose goal
is to create intelligent agents that can assist people in resolving conflicts
or reaching agreements. Although there have been many explorations into
negotiation dialogue systems, a systematic review of this task has not been
performed to date. We aim to fill this gap by investigating recent studies in
the field of negotiation dialogue systems, and covering benchmarks, evaluations
and methodologies within the literature. We also discuss potential future
directions, including multi-modal, multi-party and cross-cultural negotiation
scenarios. Our goal is to provide the community with a systematic overview of
negotiation dialogue systems and to inspire future research. | [
-0.8700271844863892,
-0.18068893253803253,
0.5555165410041809,
0.07938961684703827,
-0.1164073795080185,
0.41435080766677856,
-0.18849119544029236,
-0.8002104163169861,
0.6668807864189148,
0.30296868085861206,
-0.5322299003601074,
-0.08250055462121964,
-0.6783814430236816,
0.23861998319625854,
0.004914387129247189,
0.42500996589660645,
0.37308168411254883,
0.3182835578918457,
0.10312812775373459,
-0.37797701358795166,
-0.5524664521217346,
-0.5744644999504089,
-0.9513739347457886,
-0.4465571641921997,
0.5241585969924927,
0.41331174969673157,
0.7680332660675049,
-0.2513677477836609,
0.6237008571624756,
0.459829717874527,
-0.2738814949989319,
-0.09293467551469803,
-0.20854690670967102,
0.7870579361915588,
-0.44969308376312256,
-0.11132144182920456,
-0.4423765540122986,
0.287506639957428,
0.2579081356525421,
0.7920755743980408,
-0.16686634719371796,
0.0695984810590744,
-0.20103950798511505,
0.4516718089580536,
-0.42806991934776306,
0.1560249626636505,
-0.7242074608802795,
0.311754435300827,
0.1395743042230606,
0.07071064412593842,
-0.22075898945331573,
-0.733809769153595,
0.4340611398220062,
-0.715146541595459,
-0.147316113114357,
0.08160295337438583,
0.5879530310630798,
0.050659045577049255,
-0.7333126068115234,
-0.21116264164447784,
-0.7000994086265564,
0.4915325939655304,
-0.39170411229133606,
0.30547261238098145,
0.39469295740127563,
0.6962031722068787,
-0.41292649507522583,
-0.9229235053062439,
-0.3094758093357086,
-0.2948670983314514,
-0.14949694275856018,
0.5012014508247375,
-0.12446946650743484,
0.20023134350776672,
0.24577532708644867,
0.10012946277856827,
-0.397792249917984,
-0.17914824187755585,
-0.6124466061592102,
-0.3327392041683197,
0.9257503151893616,
0.2089778631925583,
0.3195948004722595,
0.0007024005171842873,
-0.47556272149086,
0.08205589652061462,
-0.16070806980133057,
0.13533732295036316,
0.2686558961868286,
0.2941797375679016,
0.28123340010643005,
0.2877100706100464,
-0.6701793074607849,
0.5051725506782532,
0.06927980482578278,
0.08030074089765549,
-0.3231394290924072,
-0.5074582695960999,
-0.1344212144613266,
-0.23477518558502197,
0.8787192702293396,
0.6641973257064819,
0.06705528497695923,
-0.06826547533273697,
-0.21804027259349823,
0.17136256396770477,
0.3201849162578583,
-0.4934161603450775,
0.07593511790037155,
0.17186948657035828,
-0.6698026061058044,
-0.21868279576301575,
-0.040891747921705246,
-0.6621705293655396,
-0.23856978118419647,
-0.27660033106803894,
0.14129725098609924,
-0.13270337879657745,
-0.677028238773346,
0.24980059266090393,
-0.6758567690849304,
0.39505866169929504,
0.4453639090061188,
-0.6222766041755676,
0.9902310967445374,
0.42160263657569885,
0.45818743109703064,
0.395498663187027,
-0.305970698595047,
-0.13767381012439728,
-0.21187187731266022,
-0.4773986339569092,
0.9307984709739685,
-0.6804762482643127,
-0.7611757516860962,
0.042210377752780914,
-0.45148730278015137,
0.05572463572025299,
-0.4817662239074707,
0.6860248446464539,
-0.5687108039855957,
0.15515679121017456,
-0.4983983635902405,
-0.18821032345294952,
0.0549561083316803,
0.8822617530822754,
-0.6646524667739868,
0.4137149155139923,
-0.04872535169124603,
-0.2352752983570099,
0.2696552872657776,
-0.5224187970161438,
-0.2017858326435089,
0.39661967754364014,
-0.33687710762023926,
0.016030466184020042,
0.07304258644580841,
-0.052185047417879105,
0.073088139295578,
-0.6140648126602173,
0.27618101239204407,
-0.014219259843230247,
-0.3687756657600403,
0.7366658449172974,
-0.023518549278378487,
0.5577558875083923,
0.6100530028343201,
0.08043535053730011,
0.28691160678863525,
-0.04248446598649025,
0.09370172023773193,
0.02458634227514267,
-0.21031099557876587,
0.060509178787469864,
-0.07465315610170364,
-0.07573220133781433,
0.3939567506313324,
0.2952058017253876,
-0.6170618534088135,
0.6565474271774292,
0.024024231359362602,
0.46910926699638367,
0.5803287029266357,
-0.0054180314764380455,
0.6082708835601807,
-0.5557268857955933,
0.8252233862876892,
-0.2989691495895386,
0.5478853583335876,
0.028156975284218788,
-0.5487502813339233,
-0.7892072796821594,
0.2591739594936371,
0.3166497051715851,
0.3031619191169739,
-0.8820474147796631,
0.05189104750752449,
-0.14657405018806458,
-0.4474748373031616,
-0.30293458700180054,
-0.5091714262962341,
0.45108935236930847,
-0.03015219047665596,
0.004048582632094622,
-0.6416530609130859,
-0.4388325810432434,
-0.6167052984237671,
-0.408777117729187,
-0.5104984641075134,
0.040806110948324203,
0.16964636743068695,
-0.03365802392363548,
0.15194746851921082,
0.9698818922042847,
-0.21381986141204834,
-0.3656673729419708,
-0.45631393790245056,
0.39280882477760315,
-0.2748261094093323,
0.3043671250343323,
0.5663792490959167,
-0.7589644193649292,
-0.5869293212890625,
0.13286863267421722,
-0.49888208508491516,
0.41160130500793457,
-0.029670242220163345,
-0.07651298493146896,
-0.045841969549655914,
0.8780755400657654,
-0.5486100912094116,
0.49885961413383484,
0.3081759512424469,
-0.28314951062202454,
0.4508984684944153,
-0.014602147974073887,
0.4636678993701935,
-0.6699987053871155,
-0.20457808673381805,
-0.18385560810565948,
-0.22680898010730743,
-0.7007784843444824,
-0.0415574312210083,
-0.33580854535102844,
-0.6003246307373047,
-0.4135192632675171,
0.311189740896225,
-0.6006261706352234,
-0.004555955994874239,
-0.01633984036743641,
0.3536374270915985,
-0.16437852382659912,
0.5114045739173889,
0.28077369928359985,
0.3478378355503082,
0.4409189522266388,
-0.6032899022102356,
0.4874976575374603,
0.5274524688720703,
-0.3389055132865906,
0.9280922412872314,
-0.5208485126495361,
0.3246322572231293,
0.07615549117326736,
0.8033332228660583,
-0.5617963671684265,
-0.36186474561691284,
0.8290693759918213,
-0.5703617334365845,
0.13714759051799774,
-0.38109949231147766,
0.09222597628831863,
-0.17917364835739136,
-0.22723473608493805,
0.6493799090385437,
0.2385178804397583,
0.06958840787410736,
0.5850279927253723,
0.4138110280036926,
-0.47696980834007263,
-0.6205977201461792,
-0.2697387933731079,
0.6298395991325378,
0.06322620809078217,
-0.5770019888877869,
0.16765150427818298,
-0.14348836243152618,
-0.5912639498710632,
-0.20873291790485382,
-0.0005964442971162498,
-0.251907080411911,
-0.0006445498438552022,
-0.058461494743824005,
-0.19881777465343475,
0.16541637480258942,
0.2023417353630066,
-0.017116345465183258,
-0.48772409558296204,
-0.07765275985002518,
-0.027088429778814316,
0.530495822429657,
-0.11930753290653229,
-0.5081146359443665,
-0.45184528827667236,
0.8635702729225159,
0.6496061086654663,
-0.5166984796524048,
0.4159541130065918,
0.12491670995950699,
-0.3475256860256195,
0.38945820927619934,
-0.543505847454071,
-0.3797735571861267,
-0.46103635430336,
0.1410864144563675,
-0.6142111420631409,
-0.7977083325386047,
0.5350515246391296,
-0.7236579656600952,
0.059917815029621124,
0.05110795795917511,
0.08638707548379898,
-0.1114886924624443,
1.1122888326644897,
0.5115504264831543,
0.04853196442127228,
0.4997595548629761,
0.005928159691393375,
0.47490668296813965,
-0.5676383376121521,
-0.2921595275402069,
-0.8141739964485168,
-0.5612897872924805,
-0.5962831974029541,
-0.24769781529903412,
0.46632444858551025,
0.0971168577671051,
-0.07053329795598984,
0.22814752161502838,
-0.5360569953918457,
0.44448122382164,
0.21892261505126953,
-0.04100798815488815,
0.3734319806098938,
-0.6437417268753052,
0.0460655651986599,
-0.014846396632492542,
-0.5507959127426147,
-0.4649599492549896,
0.5629969835281372,
0.22706516087055206,
0.5554616451263428,
0.44018954038619995,
0.6444321274757385,
0.070980966091156,
0.2956256866455078,
-1.0803409814834595,
0.9875364899635315,
0.5821672081947327,
-0.6377319097518921,
-0.5485357046127319,
-0.28541848063468933,
-1.4417017698287964,
0.47328564524650574,
-0.17035448551177979,
-0.8163079619407654,
0.39638838171958923,
-0.4273044466972351,
-0.12569154798984528,
0.10158787667751312,
-0.33096206188201904,
0.5052999258041382,
-0.29211297631263733,
-0.05840744823217392,
-0.4990552067756653,
-0.8252453804016113,
0.1239529401063919,
0.5334206223487854,
0.2020142376422882,
-0.2507425546646118,
0.005576928146183491,
0.6083884239196777,
-0.1665453016757965,
0.6878944635391235,
-0.12283308058977127,
0.08812312036752701,
0.1425880342721939,
0.2931613028049469,
0.2918402850627899,
-0.1019667387008667,
-0.2624293565750122,
-0.055660102516412735,
0.15991653501987457,
-0.38290080428123474,
-0.7378498315811157,
0.3101074993610382,
-0.5066916942596436,
-0.7952632904052734,
-0.8628439903259277,
-0.48794129490852356,
-0.32759809494018555,
0.06918151676654816,
0.09520196914672852,
0.16204488277435303,
-0.7437541484832764,
-0.251093327999115,
0.24751335382461548,
0.4845336675643921,
0.4768906235694885,
0.44105246663093567,
-0.3857310712337494,
-0.32170769572257996,
0.9304715394973755,
0.21066418290138245,
0.2506471872329712,
-0.27069395780563354,
-0.05901763215661049,
-0.17488159239292145,
-0.6315826177597046,
-0.14471465349197388,
0.06874606013298035,
-0.7140059471130371,
-0.3716656565666199,
-0.06375909596681595,
-0.21123531460762024,
-0.5866249799728394,
-0.3846971392631531,
-0.28594067692756653,
-0.7572523355484009,
0.261542946100235,
-0.1728362739086151,
0.1496589630842209,
1.2892252206802368,
-0.2460024356842041,
0.23688997328281403,
-0.8777675628662109,
0.15876512229442596,
0.5954655408859253,
0.4213564991950989,
-0.19835732877254486,
0.05767691135406494,
-0.2754168212413788,
-0.04501252993941307,
-0.5694992542266846,
-1.08700692653656,
0.32693013548851013,
-0.15966635942459106,
0.8320813775062561,
0.3744756579399109,
0.4193724989891052,
0.5096107125282288,
-0.13448137044906616,
1.2072113752365112,
0.42379051446914673,
-1.0612030029296875,
0.6457068920135498,
-0.31217271089553833,
0.02645990066230297,
0.6477557420730591,
0.36740219593048096,
-0.9291526675224304,
-0.41607344150543213,
-0.7408885359764099,
-0.8519416451454163,
0.670824408531189,
0.13464200496673584,
0.0027654855512082577,
0.24096645414829254,
0.18102386593818665,
-0.1512802541255951,
0.2635330259799957,
-0.5214042067527771,
-0.040935102850198746,
0.1371358335018158,
0.4259161353111267,
0.23535268008708954,
0.06419988721609116,
-0.7623434066772461,
-0.11789896339178085,
0.38140079379081726,
-0.2583194077014923,
0.05588044226169586,
0.12020694464445114,
-0.007801440078765154,
-0.25536343455314636,
0.6857571601867676,
0.4547925293445587,
0.8440130949020386,
0.006871130783110857,
-0.22457928955554962,
0.20661652088165283,
-0.19319811463356018,
0.3120119273662567,
0.0761663168668747,
0.3727715015411377,
-0.14900946617126465,
-0.11171628534793854,
0.3863256275653839,
0.1794154793024063,
-0.5004557371139526,
0.40800100564956665,
-0.8964257836341858,
-0.7339270114898682,
-0.14065714180469513,
-0.17859576642513275,
-0.1571451872587204,
0.7241504192352295,
0.22992682456970215,
0.24340276420116425,
0.29450416564941406,
-0.754172682762146,
-0.23580840229988098,
0.6436997652053833,
-0.6391100287437439,
-0.059951696544885635,
0.09632918238639832,
0.8826208710670471,
-0.7974464297294617,
0.6731093525886536,
-0.14911243319511414,
-0.7036516070365906,
0.2616133987903595,
0.04114549607038498,
0.6586158871650696,
-0.3098785877227783,
0.5096902847290039,
0.03666631132364273,
0.3657683730125427,
0.1141490563750267,
0.35287535190582275,
-0.6626275181770325,
-0.8069121241569519,
-0.015296230092644691,
-0.1393439769744873,
-1.203648567199707,
-0.3025378882884979,
-0.9901208281517029,
0.12399303913116455,
-0.3632102906703949,
-0.6258218288421631,
-0.26787516474723816,
0.1543683409690857,
-0.8606762886047363,
0.03200012072920799,
0.0240955650806427,
1.0662786960601807,
-0.6693128943443298,
0.5257577300071716,
0.7113659381866455,
-0.5635277032852173,
-0.45079919695854187,
0.0430600605905056,
-0.25063231587409973,
-0.0623156800866127,
0.4016563296318054,
-0.17446990311145782,
-0.4559200704097748,
-0.24735887348651886,
-0.8000003695487976,
-0.5438388586044312,
0.945244550704956,
0.588252604007721,
-0.27742958068847656,
-0.07445934414863586,
-0.03641672059893608,
0.3565045893192291,
-0.08432003855705261,
0.555069088935852,
1.0854895114898682,
0.8586340546607971,
0.1043953150510788,
-1.2392579317092896,
-0.12285872548818588,
-0.44496309757232666,
-0.04254233464598656,
-0.032857589423656464,
-1.2438522577285767,
0.6406752467155457,
0.26019611954689026,
-0.20978279411792755,
0.5005136132240295,
0.5542562007904053,
0.1478676050901413,
0.3134807050228119,
0.5279760956764221,
0.1346375197172165,
0.6163401007652283,
-0.3867710828781128,
0.8468902111053467,
-0.15964719653129578,
0.17782925069332123,
0.7223445773124695,
-0.4636838436126709,
0.5060448050498962,
0.5701595544815063,
-0.08611676841974258,
0.36357057094573975,
0.8034689426422119,
0.7376378774642944,
0.023770703002810478,
0.5244536399841309,
-0.5712820291519165,
-0.7605893015861511,
-0.5550521612167358,
-0.45253291726112366,
0.5241057872772217,
0.6103952527046204,
0.3139163851737976,
-0.20817214250564575,
-0.18627005815505981,
-0.2949463129043579,
0.06859410554170609,
0.02007732354104519,
1.0817925930023193,
0.187420055270195,
-0.8428274989128113,
0.041806112974882126,
-0.1831873059272766,
0.4013514518737793,
-0.9338523745536804,
-0.25095561146736145,
-0.09425776451826096,
-0.42789220809936523,
-0.12635691463947296,
-0.6798954606056213,
0.04225250706076622,
-0.5812302231788635,
0.09473930299282074,
-0.8941370248794556,
0.9354169368743896,
-0.20929478108882904,
-0.082244873046875,
0.451355516910553,
0.6987309455871582,
0.4646967947483063,
0.09882154315710068,
-0.5745418071746826,
0.457303524017334,
-0.34753134846687317,
-0.29594606161117554,
0.5318268537521362,
0.4034523367881775,
0.062001269310712814,
0.6680293679237366,
0.46242755651474,
0.16417469084262848,
-0.12980395555496216,
0.0692920833826065,
1.1653627157211304,
-0.7812160849571228,
-0.2747418284416199,
0.02720560133457184,
0.8581034541130066,
-0.35133758187294006,
-0.3326079547405243,
0.38276928663253784,
0.19056406617164612,
0.7221859693527222,
0.3424428105354309,
1.0967122316360474,
0.028806088492274284,
0.2822023928165436,
-0.4082792103290558,
0.6755585670471191,
-0.27203211188316345,
-0.1495545506477356,
-0.04649326577782631,
-0.5325081944465637,
-0.1205369383096695,
0.7614220976829529,
-0.1339738965034485,
-0.12986145913600922,
0.7535931468009949,
0.40543416142463684,
0.07796904444694519,
0.5743597745895386,
0.5939324498176575,
-0.16572794318199158,
0.469168484210968,
0.259314626455307,
1.3965266942977905,
-0.492437481880188,
0.7495131492614746,
-0.08770687133073807,
-0.14046889543533325,
-0.3055063784122467,
-0.5381950736045837,
-0.4676520526409149,
-0.7631429433822632,
-0.18933503329753876,
-0.21533098816871643,
0.032598551362752914,
0.8535874485969543,
0.8018814325332642,
-0.28434818983078003,
-0.6614404916763306,
0.35319873690605164,
0.48022907972335815,
-0.4027762711048126,
-0.12751483917236328,
-0.39989858865737915,
-0.5331883430480957,
-0.9637045860290527,
0.8109431862831116,
0.22082220017910004,
0.07362046092748642,
-0.36526888608932495,
-0.21215428411960602,
-0.14486350119113922,
0.3920046389102936,
0.402653306722641,
0.6724220514297485,
-0.6621150374412537,
-0.4450574219226837,
0.026697790250182152,
-0.1076115295290947,
0.0029136573430150747,
1.545812964439392,
-0.8763138055801392,
0.5383199453353882,
0.5232746005058289,
0.31812548637390137,
0.5133580565452576,
-0.3335149586200714,
0.9128302335739136,
-0.4669840633869171,
0.33109039068222046,
0.720950722694397,
0.3560495972633362,
0.10071735084056854,
0.06737812608480453,
0.417054146528244,
-0.22171208262443542,
-0.748285174369812,
-0.4873737394809723,
0.6952605247497559,
-1.031014323234558,
-0.05316208302974701,
0.48381513357162476,
-0.14230825006961823,
0.312899112701416,
-0.6437880396842957,
-0.6259215474128723,
0.19631190598011017,
-0.6959054470062256,
0.5066555738449097,
0.8484950065612793,
-0.6483502984046936,
0.05959496274590492,
0.08278237283229828,
0.3781293034553528,
0.3683817386627197,
-0.6879422068595886,
-0.2980886399745941,
0.5801016688346863,
-0.24564334750175476,
0.4452383816242218,
1.2039611339569092,
0.25513210892677307,
0.392739474773407,
0.0693671926856041,
0.03900185227394104,
0.6068210601806641,
-0.5624814629554749,
-0.3223913908004761,
0.2086525708436966,
0.37997347116470337,
-0.03936855494976044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01093v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01093v1 | Specialized Language Models with Cheap Inference from Limited Domain Data | 2024-02-02T01:45:18 | 2024-02-02T01:45:18 | David Grangier, Angelos Katharopoulos, Pierre Ablin, Awni Hannun | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large language models have emerged as a versatile tool but are challenging to
apply to tasks lacking large inference budgets and large in-domain training
sets. This work formalizes these constraints and distinguishes four important
variables: the pretraining budget (for training before the target domain is
known), the specialization budget (for training after the target domain is
known), the inference budget, and the in-domain training set size. Across these
settings, we compare different approaches from the machine learning literature.
Limited by inference cost, we find better alternatives to the standard practice
of training very large vanilla transformer models. In particular, we show that
hyper-networks and mixture of experts have better perplexity for large
pretraining budgets, while small models trained on importance sampled datasets
are attractive for large specialization budgets. | [
-0.5338327884674072,
-0.551671028137207,
0.458877295255661,
0.2004973143339157,
0.20314334332942963,
-0.01389588974416256,
-0.4502844512462616,
-0.2392233908176422,
-0.07446905225515366,
0.8512448668479919,
-0.6513434052467346,
0.02167907916009426,
-0.6365553140640259,
0.07496780902147293,
-0.2094959169626236,
0.8018248081207275,
0.10571817308664322,
-0.01891169138252735,
-0.18270014226436615,
-0.06676841527223587,
-0.09506545960903168,
-0.7352701425552368,
-0.385320246219635,
-0.3717540502548218,
0.5150251388549805,
0.3785402178764343,
0.7901700735092163,
0.5127811431884766,
0.44731149077415466,
0.30737894773483276,
0.156637042760849,
0.17236338555812836,
-0.4090188145637512,
-0.2645750045776367,
-0.2084789276123047,
-0.4106830358505249,
-0.2464781552553177,
0.10231981426477432,
0.33921152353286743,
1.240316390991211,
0.2334301769733429,
0.0038587499875575304,
-0.18524864315986633,
0.509539008140564,
-0.7918853759765625,
0.26908522844314575,
-0.6422510743141174,
0.022121021524071693,
-0.23760515451431274,
0.2980656027793884,
-0.4180273711681366,
-0.09475672990083694,
0.5336474776268005,
-0.5562012791633606,
0.3888488709926605,
-0.1022324189543724,
1.021555781364441,
0.4153459072113037,
-0.4957764148712158,
-0.14046558737754822,
-1.0538756847381592,
1.207962155342102,
-0.6997783780097961,
0.592189371585846,
0.6574152112007141,
0.2629578113555908,
0.14920838177204132,
-0.8552680015563965,
-0.4869336485862732,
-0.1183595135807991,
-0.18089203536510468,
-0.020522385835647583,
-0.38624024391174316,
0.14894290268421173,
0.32979774475097656,
0.2037530392408371,
-0.3497008979320526,
0.3446972668170929,
-0.17563453316688538,
0.023686449974775314,
0.4490996301174164,
0.07725510746240616,
-0.07001800090074539,
0.0963098481297493,
-0.1120515838265419,
-0.05157164856791496,
-0.786180853843689,
-0.2410891056060791,
0.5392892956733704,
0.2610216736793518,
0.04456302523612976,
0.2698516845703125,
-0.16061082482337952,
0.6443023085594177,
0.155501589179039,
-0.2821701169013977,
0.14923985302448273,
-0.08095438778400421,
-0.29500919580459595,
-0.5151137709617615,
0.5098577737808228,
-0.061193909496068954,
0.7605598568916321,
-0.3656693696975708,
-0.37970009446144104,
-0.139522522687912,
0.17121994495391846,
-0.7009220123291016,
-0.42834535241127014,
0.15683984756469727,
-0.2248130440711975,
0.1910669207572937,
-0.2985568046569824,
-0.5188918709754944,
0.035583075135946274,
-0.5596442222595215,
0.30926910042762756,
-0.1999223679304123,
-0.19110646843910217,
0.11791645735502243,
-0.03926705941557884,
0.06629028171300888,
0.3099181354045868,
-1.0916813611984253,
0.4169269800186157,
0.40775734186172485,
0.47434327006340027,
-0.21749719977378845,
-0.15749502182006836,
-0.07557802647352219,
-0.03953564167022705,
-0.40289202332496643,
0.8817862272262573,
-0.6999969482421875,
-0.25873348116874695,
-0.012466182932257652,
-0.04142821580171585,
-0.30862149596214294,
-0.6724256277084351,
0.5250111818313599,
-0.7698894143104553,
-0.06573900580406189,
-0.11863650381565094,
-0.6200335025787354,
-0.06308246403932571,
-0.13947415351867676,
-0.9548371434211731,
0.646949827671051,
0.662921667098999,
-0.7618395090103149,
0.45615100860595703,
-0.31845107674598694,
-0.4781937003135681,
0.2200605273246765,
-0.12224295735359192,
-0.33852052688598633,
0.06755895912647247,
0.16559042036533356,
0.49855560064315796,
-0.5857590436935425,
0.43916887044906616,
-0.24876202642917633,
-0.11355109512805939,
0.14200066030025482,
-0.4848012328147888,
0.6669996380805969,
0.36255475878715515,
-0.26112571358680725,
-0.19678454101085663,
-0.8180428147315979,
-0.15462009608745575,
0.07113521546125412,
-0.3187420070171356,
-0.32007965445518494,
0.14005418121814728,
0.01550450548529625,
0.03757903352379799,
0.0668523758649826,
-0.17683778703212738,
0.0011537482496351004,
-0.5687862038612366,
0.6155138611793518,
0.517535924911499,
-0.20847982168197632,
0.7443274855613708,
0.13994236290454865,
0.6433985233306885,
0.05058065056800842,
0.12030062079429626,
0.039775703102350235,
-0.305829793214798,
-0.833915114402771,
-0.44377556443214417,
0.6163650751113892,
0.3325941562652588,
-0.730373203754425,
0.3526575565338135,
-0.19729848206043243,
-0.2820466160774231,
-0.34001463651657104,
-0.008587092161178589,
0.3432007133960724,
0.3023751676082611,
0.35599663853645325,
0.03057962656021118,
-0.4262184798717499,
-1.1680535078048706,
-0.3279675245285034,
0.20612958073616028,
-0.101553775370121,
0.4422490894794464,
0.6251591444015503,
-0.20542241632938385,
1.1725058555603027,
-0.6777635216712952,
-0.08869405835866928,
-0.5230519771575928,
-0.07655392587184906,
0.27031588554382324,
0.5378904938697815,
0.8131536841392517,
-0.8862386345863342,
-0.6095622777938843,
0.026222102344036102,
-0.2407246232032776,
0.10633106529712677,
0.008960925973951817,
0.2866780459880829,
-0.01753915101289749,
0.4239501655101776,
-0.7915740609169006,
0.21849524974822998,
0.7204262018203735,
0.10117233544588089,
0.5884807705879211,
-0.19363629817962646,
-0.29551512002944946,
-0.6327362656593323,
-0.09499354660511017,
0.2282787561416626,
-0.15503689646720886,
-0.8903313279151917,
-0.006806439254432917,
0.07674932479858398,
-0.1947213113307953,
-0.30334243178367615,
0.7172900438308716,
-0.452462375164032,
0.12743331491947174,
-0.25302961468696594,
-0.1710171103477478,
0.036195095628499985,
0.7516432404518127,
0.32136407494544983,
0.6665396094322205,
0.5255308151245117,
-0.4983183741569519,
0.13352589309215546,
0.19916464388370514,
-0.5698665976524353,
0.06392239034175873,
-0.823728084564209,
0.17989446222782135,
0.0408598929643631,
0.31916573643684387,
-0.5778016448020935,
-0.44600194692611694,
-0.12856213748455048,
-0.12156502157449722,
0.4537855088710785,
-0.5438997149467468,
-0.32587018609046936,
-0.43310678005218506,
0.19183604419231415,
0.46922820806503296,
0.6854441165924072,
-0.5255352854728699,
0.5137695074081421,
0.588968813419342,
-0.11044492572546005,
-0.6733575463294983,
-0.787416934967041,
-0.027724584564566612,
-0.3219658136367798,
-0.3659837543964386,
0.26486578583717346,
0.04772595688700676,
-0.331530898809433,
-0.08624374121427536,
-0.1109088733792305,
-0.592219352722168,
-0.026196857914328575,
-0.05668763071298599,
-0.04347334802150726,
-0.6408371925354004,
0.11819316446781158,
0.019994523376226425,
-0.3133552372455597,
0.0506431870162487,
-0.6360863447189331,
0.33861351013183594,
0.04214734584093094,
-0.3938796818256378,
-0.11714401096105576,
0.41379475593566895,
0.39478254318237305,
-0.3830231726169586,
0.8653945922851562,
0.09315232187509537,
-0.3364059627056122,
-0.5609495639801025,
-0.7707078456878662,
-0.17826053500175476,
-0.4526689350605011,
0.5020575523376465,
-0.7154422998428345,
-0.8552854061126709,
0.2875545024871826,
-0.24565930664539337,
0.02589423954486847,
0.5833933353424072,
0.5730865001678467,
0.20888948440551758,
0.9722732305526733,
0.6753382086753845,
-0.01516909059137106,
0.23316256701946259,
-0.3742312788963318,
0.5875335931777954,
-0.32539188861846924,
-0.008436481468379498,
-0.8155573010444641,
0.0361645482480526,
-0.42632752656936646,
-0.6049065589904785,
0.14473174512386322,
-0.009852266870439053,
-0.3980253040790558,
0.3812069892883301,
-0.10684045404195786,
0.6353301405906677,
0.6601712107658386,
-0.08679679781198502,
0.07441671937704086,
0.09716682881116867,
0.20140895247459412,
-0.17025910317897797,
-0.8773295879364014,
-0.46475210785865784,
1.0755749940872192,
0.3598179519176483,
0.8027777075767517,
-0.12904058396816254,
0.2548772692680359,
-0.13306035101413727,
0.22464518249034882,
-0.880776584148407,
0.18570522964000702,
-0.4432649314403534,
-0.7484595775604248,
-0.518739640712738,
-0.5684921145439148,
-0.9844076037406921,
0.3249076306819916,
-0.23639126121997833,
-0.5785813927650452,
0.5030058026313782,
0.4086686074733734,
-0.26011139154434204,
0.3362147808074951,
-0.8382877707481384,
0.872519314289093,
-0.04122551530599594,
0.0442475900053978,
-0.16835032403469086,
-0.5605425834655762,
0.22514577209949493,
-0.6164326071739197,
0.26539134979248047,
-0.04192211851477623,
-0.04977840185165405,
0.6666080951690674,
-0.4197848439216614,
0.8568742275238037,
-0.1369960606098175,
0.14185543358325958,
0.23043452203273773,
-0.07863280177116394,
0.5903500914573669,
-0.06339891254901886,
-0.1435370147228241,
0.08977403491735458,
-0.28108543157577515,
-0.6846098303794861,
-0.49525007605552673,
0.4925924837589264,
-0.9684280157089233,
-0.8009436726570129,
0.15341292321681976,
-0.7481642961502075,
-0.797725260257721,
0.22475628554821014,
0.5041274428367615,
0.5759887099266052,
-0.17277361452579498,
0.300762802362442,
0.9109382033348083,
-0.2811897397041321,
0.3452235460281372,
0.35597071051597595,
0.43136245012283325,
-0.15441565215587616,
0.8370418548583984,
0.2474684864282608,
0.47135183215141296,
0.48770588636398315,
0.32317107915878296,
-0.07976218312978745,
-0.6945881247520447,
-0.2634081244468689,
0.35525089502334595,
-0.7487518191337585,
-0.0994756668806076,
-1.0406723022460938,
-0.24432605504989624,
-0.4422989785671234,
-0.16066382825374603,
-0.6759028434753418,
-0.5497058033943176,
-0.19537252187728882,
-0.09203706681728363,
0.17892736196517944,
0.45956093072891235,
0.20996622741222382,
0.5656555891036987,
-0.5940741896629333,
0.1447150856256485,
0.41295772790908813,
0.1855102777481079,
0.08028388023376465,
-0.7425550222396851,
-0.6148107647895813,
-0.13069313764572144,
0.029067959636449814,
-0.5015515685081482,
0.41779473423957825,
0.2359929084777832,
0.6729159355163574,
0.6713125109672546,
0.18930983543395996,
0.4660896360874176,
-0.7438051700592041,
0.711868405342102,
0.1500692516565323,
-0.9633472561836243,
0.08323568850755692,
-0.12600117921829224,
0.18417957425117493,
0.38088107109069824,
0.7736442685127258,
-0.021227190271019936,
-0.31678226590156555,
-0.7610868215560913,
-0.8043367266654968,
0.5882337093353271,
0.18799173831939697,
0.5359733700752258,
-0.055510763078927994,
0.2757236361503601,
0.1911381036043167,
0.0822528749704361,
-0.6642475128173828,
-0.21046030521392822,
-0.2098926603794098,
-0.07449090480804443,
-0.36908161640167236,
-0.21099044382572174,
-0.14830143749713898,
-0.3321337401866913,
0.36670854687690735,
-0.29576587677001953,
-0.023571444675326347,
-0.1237899512052536,
-0.34229329228401184,
0.07071459293365479,
0.02683909237384796,
0.41528159379959106,
0.8897068500518799,
0.1391957551240921,
0.2042001336812973,
0.41869959235191345,
-0.2551385164260864,
0.11997295171022415,
-0.13527268171310425,
0.15223175287246704,
0.08719542622566223,
0.6986817717552185,
1.0820529460906982,
0.3979279100894928,
-0.7258025407791138,
0.6116424202919006,
0.18008066713809967,
-0.5842322111129761,
-0.28855931758880615,
0.022233404219150543,
0.3795028328895569,
0.278090238571167,
0.12203969806432724,
0.1545444130897522,
-0.07856074720621109,
-0.1698765754699707,
-0.1146848052740097,
0.2781517207622528,
-0.3777434229850769,
-0.5153005123138428,
0.511448085308075,
0.14532898366451263,
-0.19611413776874542,
0.5877975225448608,
0.18607410788536072,
-0.44332465529441833,
0.7123780846595764,
0.524649977684021,
0.7916445732116699,
-0.2819054126739502,
0.1299320012331009,
0.13726742565631866,
0.3490811884403229,
-0.32794302701950073,
-0.3002070486545563,
0.07602377235889435,
-0.884965717792511,
-0.6366651058197021,
-0.5586841106414795,
-0.4927108585834503,
0.40795034170150757,
-0.4465560019016266,
0.11968255043029785,
-0.3394607901573181,
-0.21032671630382538,
0.18803377449512482,
-0.11944945156574249,
-0.9416652321815491,
0.5290457010269165,
-0.20959541201591492,
0.9452181458473206,
-0.8880022168159485,
0.9712072014808655,
0.4497860372066498,
-0.29125118255615234,
-0.8019009232521057,
-0.08057752996683121,
-0.37721288204193115,
-0.6909167170524597,
1.0402263402938843,
-0.18490535020828247,
-0.11126168817281723,
0.05846073478460312,
-0.4771118462085724,
-0.9880209565162659,
0.30765992403030396,
0.5719127655029297,
-0.5198825001716614,
-0.31740447878837585,
0.1445835679769516,
0.47012513875961304,
-0.36938607692718506,
0.09928148984909058,
0.8972717523574829,
0.5233396887779236,
-0.11837843060493469,
-0.7408720850944519,
-0.3248324692249298,
0.08589693158864975,
-0.1356845200061798,
0.17885543406009674,
-0.5455300211906433,
1.1705985069274902,
-0.06476020067930222,
-0.040038276463747025,
-0.2474377304315567,
0.6770790219306946,
-0.2614023685455322,
0.04836772382259369,
0.6889501214027405,
0.40549376606941223,
0.565392017364502,
0.06960038095712662,
1.0656448602676392,
-0.20141206681728363,
0.42187073826789856,
0.8616958856582642,
-0.21095091104507446,
0.48785895109176636,
0.2832639813423157,
-0.4994749426841736,
0.24432094395160675,
0.7015377879142761,
-0.03895887732505798,
0.5039622187614441,
0.27553826570510864,
-0.11695287376642227,
-0.5008682608604431,
0.25190648436546326,
-0.20978133380413055,
0.2731182873249054,
0.42760488390922546,
-0.057690128684043884,
-0.06457577645778656,
0.10346971452236176,
0.11559802293777466,
-0.1679980754852295,
-0.045840319246053696,
0.7197064161300659,
0.2829487919807434,
-0.6631453037261963,
0.6613633036613464,
-0.02902555651962757,
0.3380860686302185,
-0.6686797738075256,
0.4843961000442505,
-0.47686415910720825,
0.3553050458431244,
-0.15271346271038055,
-0.22041073441505432,
0.270812451839447,
0.057311952114105225,
-0.31677955389022827,
-0.138019859790802,
0.5007548332214355,
-0.27755865454673767,
-0.3438788652420044,
0.14360366761684418,
0.6140167713165283,
0.16791559755802155,
-0.34183722734451294,
-0.4791998565196991,
-0.3202165961265564,
-0.25837546586990356,
-0.6587685942649841,
0.4974736273288727,
0.6336126923561096,
-0.21269570291042328,
0.6623459458351135,
0.3404307961463928,
0.13789257407188416,
-0.024862876161932945,
0.38903772830963135,
0.8699066042900085,
-0.5568694472312927,
-0.4864543080329895,
-0.6465560793876648,
0.23431867361068726,
0.13483653962612152,
-0.31037768721580505,
0.6470555067062378,
0.3990280330181122,
0.8720779418945312,
-0.5042809844017029,
0.8707390427589417,
0.38701027631759644,
0.45791810750961304,
-0.4608629047870636,
0.4074591398239136,
-0.4815315902233124,
0.013570215553045273,
-0.1703711599111557,
-0.9056238532066345,
-0.39762988686561584,
0.566001832485199,
-0.4660215377807617,
0.12201785296201706,
0.7505213618278503,
0.6941741108894348,
-0.3779177963733673,
-0.04395706206560135,
0.5331321358680725,
-0.058636970818042755,
0.1583724021911621,
0.4470325708389282,
0.9099922776222229,
0.05838964134454727,
0.4582492709159851,
-0.2085597664117813,
-0.33323121070861816,
-0.35771435499191284,
-0.6737806797027588,
-1.169353723526001,
-0.5573781132698059,
-0.31919950246810913,
-0.1581880897283554,
-0.18974891304969788,
0.9445482492446899,
1.163436770439148,
-1.024499773979187,
-0.29361259937286377,
0.09340270608663559,
0.12248695641756058,
-0.19126537442207336,
-0.14025069773197174,
0.45304203033447266,
-0.5156612992286682,
-1.0278464555740356,
0.3443908393383026,
0.12817220389842987,
-0.08777017891407013,
-0.2284570187330246,
0.06292650103569031,
0.16081832349300385,
0.6051961779594421,
0.6738187670707703,
0.36974337697029114,
-0.7289434671401978,
-0.27190834283828735,
0.010110514238476753,
-0.04466388374567032,
0.02850452810525894,
1.226600170135498,
-0.5453239679336548,
0.026355883106589317,
0.33571070432662964,
0.9581684470176697,
0.8021175265312195,
-0.31278637051582336,
0.6457224488258362,
-0.6676490902900696,
0.45033228397369385,
0.35419976711273193,
0.3166950047016144,
0.09797175973653793,
-0.12858228385448456,
0.43734803795814514,
0.3009626269340515,
-0.5424312949180603,
-0.8338784575462341,
0.48123979568481445,
-0.49313828349113464,
-0.6248365640640259,
0.8744061589241028,
-0.33834314346313477,
-0.006656828802078962,
-0.41372549533843994,
0.15785634517669678,
-0.10083276033401489,
0.1235266923904419,
0.3544429838657379,
0.6425660848617554,
-0.025402091443538666,
-0.10907963663339615,
-0.58375084400177,
0.694002091884613,
0.3582659959793091,
-0.6901012659072876,
0.14670006930828094,
0.2360476553440094,
0.17397932708263397,
0.032702576369047165,
0.3274891674518585,
0.23511835932731628,
-0.11671680212020874,
0.3109208345413208,
-0.10362334549427032,
0.2506181597709656,
-0.5271270871162415,
-0.07910268753767014,
0.336830198764801,
0.07402804493904114,
0.16789214313030243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01091v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01091v1 | Reading Between the Tweets: Deciphering Ideological Stances of Interconnected Mixed-Ideology Communities | 2024-02-02T01:39:00 | 2024-02-02T01:39:00 | Zihao He, Ashwin Rao, Siyi Guo, Negar Mokhberian, Kristina Lerman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI | Recent advances in NLP have improved our ability to understand the nuanced
worldviews of online communities. Existing research focused on probing
ideological stances treats liberals and conservatives as separate groups.
However, this fails to account for the nuanced views of the organically formed
online communities and the connections between them. In this paper, we study
discussions of the 2020 U.S. election on Twitter to identify complex
interacting communities. Capitalizing on this interconnectedness, we introduce
a novel approach that harnesses message passing when finetuning language models
(LMs) to probe the nuanced ideologies of these communities. By comparing the
responses generated by LMs and real-world survey results, our method shows
higher alignment than existing baselines, highlighting the potential of using
LMs in revealing complex ideologies within and across interconnected
mixed-ideology communities. | [
-0.697386622428894,
-0.6821338534355164,
0.690788209438324,
0.10322262346744537,
-0.5464423894882202,
0.7886141538619995,
-0.15532609820365906,
-0.3771969974040985,
0.4946986734867096,
0.5966454148292542,
-0.7594252824783325,
-0.5234993100166321,
-0.6756728291511536,
-0.2052425593137741,
-0.318803608417511,
0.8147271871566772,
0.2587581276893616,
-0.014173071831464767,
0.30509522557258606,
-0.35512834787368774,
0.04885398969054222,
-0.12583445012569427,
-0.5047225952148438,
-0.5777576565742493,
0.7655528783798218,
0.0939035713672638,
0.8010407090187073,
0.6546728014945984,
0.4417647421360016,
0.15295028686523438,
0.02284274622797966,
-0.0960720106959343,
-0.5540596842765808,
-0.01324421726167202,
-0.45133471488952637,
-0.24401581287384033,
0.14503589272499084,
0.16063883900642395,
0.40208813548088074,
0.9456751942634583,
0.08812809735536575,
0.25601741671562195,
0.23134750127792358,
0.2220281958580017,
-0.5091400146484375,
-0.27956801652908325,
-1.0252034664154053,
-0.1807268261909485,
-0.2894088327884674,
-0.20122289657592773,
-0.3193730115890503,
-0.5280627012252808,
0.14047691226005554,
-0.09565458446741104,
0.04377355799078941,
-0.0391097366809845,
0.9924986362457275,
-0.03843282163143158,
-0.6071887016296387,
-0.38290128111839294,
-0.6819663643836975,
0.9906126856803894,
-0.9300137758255005,
0.1254812777042389,
-0.002208622405305505,
0.03015824221074581,
0.05381138622760773,
-0.48131296038627625,
-0.711127758026123,
0.2525542676448822,
-0.14384222030639648,
-0.06586380302906036,
-0.08126810938119888,
-0.06893187016248703,
-0.23591378331184387,
0.047018393874168396,
-0.15631221234798431,
0.017779309302568436,
-0.16752231121063232,
0.2970820665359497,
0.5551331043243408,
0.10110610723495483,
0.42859768867492676,
-0.5053078532218933,
-0.7340893149375916,
0.17306388914585114,
-0.4384042024612427,
0.025153597816824913,
0.5190689563751221,
0.3531794548034668,
-0.24486561119556427,
0.4808652102947235,
0.15809988975524902,
0.5145225524902344,
0.16909390687942505,
0.1443275660276413,
-0.2585408687591553,
-0.43108251690864563,
-0.214049831032753,
-0.3229423463344574,
0.7451250553131104,
0.6126495003700256,
0.3321892321109772,
0.06551120430231094,
-0.05448918417096138,
-0.013465859927237034,
-0.019495783373713493,
-0.38336288928985596,
-0.22391636669635773,
0.5271094441413879,
-0.7504559755325317,
-0.17166867852210999,
0.18409736454486847,
-0.9124802350997925,
-0.6754881143569946,
-0.42738011479377747,
0.23375381529331207,
-0.20953544974327087,
-0.6935037970542908,
-0.07817260175943375,
-0.2920573651790619,
0.28399983048439026,
0.4307626783847809,
-0.7830655574798584,
0.31481248140335083,
1.1511216163635254,
0.9029275178909302,
0.24416106939315796,
0.15875044465065002,
-0.17795009911060333,
0.3037627339363098,
-0.389708548784256,
0.7880651950836182,
-0.9694411158561707,
0.06551304459571838,
0.16186021268367767,
-0.37990227341651917,
0.0848459005355835,
-0.2757188379764557,
0.009844804182648659,
-0.7108688354492188,
0.1614220291376114,
-0.445345401763916,
-0.7202450633049011,
-0.21402963995933533,
0.6241601705551147,
-0.6111095547676086,
0.7937809824943542,
-0.2341340333223343,
-0.9041035175323486,
0.3081247806549072,
-0.6033656001091003,
-0.035433098673820496,
-0.03495150804519653,
-0.34745538234710693,
-0.004229857586324215,
0.01841966062784195,
0.06280224025249481,
0.7357856035232544,
-0.01968442276120186,
0.31264233589172363,
-0.7938582301139832,
-0.10709414631128311,
0.23883497714996338,
-0.13642652332782745,
1.1780320405960083,
0.16151893138885498,
-0.31441229581832886,
0.1031157597899437,
-0.4040069580078125,
0.06698382645845413,
-0.22272217273712158,
0.03723425045609474,
-0.7527490258216858,
0.5082605481147766,
0.03036636859178543,
0.3447446823120117,
0.29396891593933105,
-0.6995141506195068,
0.4131647050380707,
-0.34635934233665466,
0.6509754657745361,
0.8450795412063599,
0.19994115829467773,
0.6218568682670593,
-0.1596018373966217,
0.21077023446559906,
-0.02393665909767151,
0.2783660888671875,
0.45228296518325806,
-0.40275996923446655,
-0.8161211013793945,
0.20793390274047852,
0.028541063889861107,
0.6349748373031616,
-0.6520217061042786,
0.30071592330932617,
-0.12929576635360718,
-0.6555182933807373,
-0.5255280137062073,
-0.2569464445114136,
0.09756870567798615,
-0.10874976217746735,
0.2236209511756897,
0.2984379231929779,
-0.4179733097553253,
-0.8834194540977478,
-0.8723275661468506,
-0.35947632789611816,
0.014364777132868767,
-0.0779159665107727,
0.6208772659301758,
-0.20500555634498596,
0.7877541780471802,
-0.37665992975234985,
0.10927003622055054,
-0.328244149684906,
0.41077131032943726,
0.11211904138326645,
0.16432148218154907,
0.3917255997657776,
-0.7921014428138733,
-0.8738566637039185,
0.29252099990844727,
-0.09528341144323349,
-0.06199726089835167,
-0.1971701979637146,
-0.16136154532432556,
-0.1859147548675537,
0.5468903183937073,
-0.07253398001194,
0.2339015156030655,
0.8961986899375916,
-0.5410483479499817,
-0.10467497259378433,
0.47128576040267944,
0.3946767747402191,
-1.4863895177841187,
-0.33608517050743103,
-0.09552804380655289,
-0.21091586351394653,
-0.6256968379020691,
-0.16664250195026398,
-0.3407227098941803,
0.563624382019043,
-0.45094063878059387,
0.5074612498283386,
-0.21690618991851807,
0.04846135154366493,
0.09619524329900742,
0.22426998615264893,
-0.002903431886807084,
-0.05116397514939308,
-0.20668110251426697,
0.2879175543785095,
0.12128030508756638,
-0.05078507959842682,
0.11251271516084671,
-0.031558889895677567,
-0.19323574006557465,
0.4616564214229584,
-0.18837937712669373,
0.16679821908473969,
-0.13109467923641205,
0.32159435749053955,
-1.265220284461975,
-0.34224990010261536,
0.3276367485523224,
-0.39763742685317993,
0.04027799516916275,
-0.33541545271873474,
-0.4798465371131897,
0.044155143201351166,
-0.32761773467063904,
0.3039111793041229,
0.1060490682721138,
-0.3941517472267151,
0.7659681439399719,
0.6185455918312073,
-0.05457966402173042,
-0.675388514995575,
-0.6207526326179504,
0.1255006045103073,
-0.4427128732204437,
-0.6461265683174133,
0.12062887102365494,
0.34134531021118164,
-1.168294906616211,
0.23524059355258942,
0.3936232328414917,
-0.2609541416168213,
-0.20763523876667023,
-0.055961672216653824,
0.0009260951192118227,
-0.1927308589220047,
0.30196505784988403,
0.007019088603556156,
0.17676377296447754,
-0.09860587865114212,
-0.22580291330814362,
0.7232784628868103,
-0.235573872923851,
-0.17581024765968323,
-0.39791616797447205,
0.9890957474708557,
0.4512145221233368,
-0.2424272745847702,
1.1807949542999268,
0.5720247030258179,
-0.512626588344574,
-0.3957746922969818,
-0.6685706973075867,
-0.22575372457504272,
-0.4525269865989685,
0.17025096714496613,
0.07703723013401031,
-0.871038556098938,
0.8076854944229126,
-0.20711874961853027,
0.6356362104415894,
0.46916571259498596,
0.5429322719573975,
-0.5981229543685913,
0.8730910420417786,
0.6168254017829895,
0.23651015758514404,
0.4339621663093567,
-0.1321703940629959,
0.5805174112319946,
-0.4541236460208893,
-0.20746533572673798,
-0.6078746318817139,
-0.5965419411659241,
-0.5430576205253601,
-0.4980680048465729,
0.01837969571352005,
0.10533270984888077,
-0.25636026263237,
0.14483174681663513,
-0.540339469909668,
0.624906063079834,
0.15763649344444275,
-0.0017178419511765242,
0.22442884743213654,
-0.14930114150047302,
0.25794291496276855,
-0.4525351822376251,
-0.30537644028663635,
-0.8018907308578491,
0.7160418629646301,
0.232744038105011,
0.6796571612358093,
0.3638029396533966,
0.6488142013549805,
0.4171997606754303,
0.7470574975013733,
-0.5976248383522034,
0.45366907119750977,
-0.45262131094932556,
-0.5434526205062866,
-0.06026841327548027,
-0.29509884119033813,
-0.6029061079025269,
0.3522528111934662,
-0.29800012707710266,
-0.6570903658866882,
0.12631450593471527,
-0.16564568877220154,
-0.3522885739803314,
1.117506742477417,
-0.4921353757381439,
0.7008963823318481,
-0.15862224996089935,
0.0024103233590722084,
-0.28644701838493347,
-0.9427103996276855,
0.30686700344085693,
0.19237039983272552,
0.49169838428497314,
-0.3328496813774109,
-0.3589874804019928,
0.7973470091819763,
-0.05124350264668465,
0.9330161213874817,
0.09992300719022751,
-0.10624603927135468,
0.0781034305691719,
-0.18192657828330994,
0.14569413661956787,
-0.017264150083065033,
-0.20346449315547943,
0.29430484771728516,
0.3206103444099426,
-0.35173800587654114,
-0.27321818470954895,
0.7297958731651306,
-0.9219986796379089,
-0.2888014316558838,
-0.34882909059524536,
-0.5039299726486206,
-0.046918440610170364,
0.22805994749069214,
0.34578561782836914,
0.5182610154151917,
-0.2613832950592041,
0.260500431060791,
0.6855579018592834,
0.245469868183136,
0.4711513817310333,
0.03336642310023308,
-0.17262913286685944,
-0.3943231403827667,
0.44908010959625244,
0.2637779414653778,
0.7292188405990601,
0.5197378396987915,
0.15731173753738403,
-0.27757492661476135,
-0.3829500079154968,
-0.28018853068351746,
0.3729219436645508,
-0.8415113687515259,
-0.1454799771308899,
-0.6909032464027405,
-0.007895383983850479,
-0.054912813007831573,
-0.5627321600914001,
-0.47374603152275085,
-0.052359603345394135,
-0.4041937291622162,
0.1535542756319046,
0.261845201253891,
1.273618459701538,
0.14153552055358887,
0.5722737908363342,
-0.781439483165741,
0.05318335443735123,
0.06843485683202744,
0.3534339368343353,
-0.1322212815284729,
0.049543581902980804,
-0.002695417497307062,
0.12318052351474762,
-0.19710272550582886,
-1.510076642036438,
0.0011507871095091105,
0.15717819333076477,
0.07963138818740845,
0.7434581518173218,
0.3536699414253235,
0.760077714920044,
-0.3301055133342743,
0.9486022591590881,
0.1418420374393463,
-0.9717536568641663,
0.3569546043872833,
-0.7111895084381104,
-0.017308155074715614,
0.7038272023200989,
0.3893059194087982,
-0.6567808985710144,
-0.8751233220100403,
-0.6379858255386353,
-0.5515356063842773,
0.4259195923805237,
-0.058485276997089386,
0.3962531089782715,
-0.12822209298610687,
0.2901305854320526,
0.16937470436096191,
-0.004394168965518475,
-0.9119889140129089,
-0.25475990772247314,
0.09144885092973709,
-0.3909282088279724,
0.3837408125400543,
0.03407261520624161,
-0.5462720990180969,
-0.027250366285443306,
0.33134588599205017,
-0.08989810198545456,
-0.04918625205755234,
-0.11559492349624634,
0.5036241412162781,
-0.38906750082969666,
0.340870201587677,
0.3121946156024933,
0.8024515509605408,
-0.27962103486061096,
0.40731188654899597,
-0.06862219423055649,
-0.27459803223609924,
-0.08663510531187057,
-0.2565387189388275,
-0.16888874769210815,
0.215711772441864,
0.5622333884239197,
0.41386374831199646,
-0.06897001713514328,
-0.10466545075178146,
0.5160711407661438,
-0.1293586939573288,
-0.1638839989900589,
-0.2927207052707672,
-0.23628577589988708,
0.6986060738563538,
0.60586017370224,
0.47030097246170044,
0.43019118905067444,
-0.1371360868215561,
-0.9145122766494751,
0.15181264281272888,
0.8309803009033203,
-0.5671640038490295,
-0.3806031048297882,
0.46688857674598694,
0.3790636956691742,
-0.4037184715270996,
0.21428819000720978,
-0.1227574497461319,
-0.7571300864219666,
0.6071707010269165,
0.14653733372688293,
0.8132140636444092,
-0.15786109864711761,
0.20497015118598938,
0.2935487627983093,
0.5368624329566956,
0.3653225302696228,
0.22015203535556793,
0.14681223034858704,
-0.7135559916496277,
-0.40100404620170593,
-0.5037394165992737,
-0.3589831590652466,
0.09478510171175003,
-0.6806303262710571,
0.327105849981308,
-0.6983306407928467,
-0.29070332646369934,
0.016400914639234543,
0.39170756936073303,
-0.3478940725326538,
0.22844865918159485,
0.14439383149147034,
0.6706006526947021,
-1.2042319774627686,
0.5838512778282166,
0.48719367384910583,
-0.06148247420787811,
-0.8314478993415833,
0.8106186389923096,
-0.09752215445041656,
-0.4871322810649872,
0.10085731744766235,
0.11831899732351303,
-0.40134111046791077,
0.006509306374937296,
-0.8094069957733154,
-0.6601618528366089,
0.8724445104598999,
0.10612495243549347,
-0.4942074418067932,
-0.1529262363910675,
0.31461673974990845,
0.2909959852695465,
-0.508305549621582,
0.0707840695977211,
0.35432738065719604,
0.4400102496147156,
-0.0881647914648056,
-0.6175482273101807,
-0.12504197657108307,
0.09720082581043243,
-0.43726423382759094,
0.7552753686904907,
-0.856451690196991,
1.0804115533828735,
0.14462661743164062,
-0.3703560531139374,
-0.24372310936450958,
0.691840410232544,
-0.038976818323135376,
0.45169487595558167,
0.7068116068840027,
0.28786230087280273,
0.4773247539997101,
-0.1275603324174881,
0.6098000407218933,
-0.2154298573732376,
0.5953950881958008,
0.7459390759468079,
-0.008438501507043839,
1.1875033378601074,
0.9212194681167603,
-0.17452087998390198,
0.7487984895706177,
0.7793252468109131,
0.4229658544063568,
0.4387633204460144,
-0.05487244576215744,
-0.491012305021286,
-0.3992062211036682,
-0.22682517766952515,
-0.26035594940185547,
0.19774273037910461,
0.7595379948616028,
-0.05803326517343521,
-0.5654663443565369,
-0.12981268763542175,
0.2538084089756012,
0.44075050950050354,
-0.222421795129776,
0.6960704326629639,
0.24051687121391296,
-0.7787917852401733,
0.09852790832519531,
-0.19607827067375183,
0.7110154032707214,
-0.6290419697761536,
-0.2422792911529541,
0.25610780715942383,
0.2456125169992447,
-0.41319212317466736,
-1.5065523386001587,
0.6273993253707886,
-0.15647099912166595,
-0.052505217492580414,
-0.3294309377670288,
0.39096081256866455,
-0.6405876278877258,
-0.39663633704185486,
0.7732888460159302,
0.4121165871620178,
-0.19589805603027344,
0.2585022747516632,
-0.8829801678657532,
0.3517778515815735,
0.2681303024291992,
-0.1465718299150467,
0.009134718216955662,
0.495973140001297,
-0.004613190423697233,
0.4689602255821228,
0.6479107141494751,
-0.020201301202178,
0.10971933603286743,
0.0016630056779831648,
0.8783593773841858,
-0.34482741355895996,
-0.2494969367980957,
-1.0705676078796387,
0.5539979934692383,
-0.2204698771238327,
-0.47604697942733765,
0.7199007868766785,
0.09859250485897064,
0.8969194293022156,
0.3286656141281128,
0.8014836311340332,
-0.1839444488286972,
0.8834190964698792,
-0.3896501958370209,
0.8478765487670898,
-0.7545490264892578,
0.33477988839149475,
-0.09108468890190125,
-0.5362081527709961,
-0.45790088176727295,
0.5246532559394836,
-0.48901015520095825,
-0.13989569246768951,
0.2809460163116455,
0.5051729679107666,
-0.39321547746658325,
0.049127958714962006,
-0.08227033168077469,
0.33221539855003357,
0.401261568069458,
0.46814048290252686,
1.0928949117660522,
-0.13719595968723297,
0.43250513076782227,
-0.3826850652694702,
-0.14250066876411438,
-0.19708411395549774,
-0.7676810026168823,
-0.9502615928649902,
-0.6689311265945435,
-0.22107692062854767,
-0.48969364166259766,
-0.26712334156036377,
0.9556519389152527,
0.41588377952575684,
-0.5756387710571289,
-0.2822999060153961,
0.005414292216300964,
0.11834228038787842,
0.14527128636837006,
-0.30548468232154846,
0.3088090419769287,
0.1782250851392746,
-0.8369924426078796,
-0.37376195192337036,
0.41704484820365906,
-0.4539377987384796,
-0.7332088351249695,
0.2948194742202759,
-0.7887181043624878,
0.6790439486503601,
0.3452131152153015,
-0.12399262189865112,
-1.208983063697815,
-0.7276808023452759,
0.07984092831611633,
-0.2989315986633301,
0.10735288262367249,
0.460024356842041,
-0.4174182116985321,
0.40298962593078613,
0.7782766222953796,
0.2978902757167816,
-0.08075892925262451,
0.36887094378471375,
0.2648852467536926,
-0.4997175633907318,
-0.03927531838417053,
0.8465065956115723,
-0.0012182920472696424,
0.49375057220458984,
-0.18361343443393707,
0.1304602026939392,
0.018885169178247452,
-0.6503168940544128,
-0.6638654470443726,
0.646328330039978,
-1.0544445514678955,
-0.36249950528144836,
1.0461170673370361,
0.1574486792087555,
-0.04430701211094856,
-0.5335565805435181,
-0.10278100520372391,
0.2842305898666382,
-0.24366463720798492,
0.5222617387771606,
0.7638773322105408,
-0.07709731161594391,
-0.20976847410202026,
-0.6272233128547668,
0.40178579092025757,
0.11972559988498688,
-0.7427179217338562,
-0.14785298705101013,
0.16912047564983368,
0.3147507607936859,
0.2124543935060501,
0.8031986951828003,
0.23638422787189484,
-0.1580844223499298,
-0.10250364989042282,
-0.33773767948150635,
0.817506730556488,
-0.12899795174598694,
0.14491422474384308,
0.2469649463891983,
-0.2987406849861145,
-0.18915434181690216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01065v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01065v1 | Evaluation Methodology for Large Language Models for Multilingual Document Question and Answer | 2024-02-01T23:46:05 | 2024-02-01T23:46:05 | Adar Kahana, Jaya Susan Mathew, Said Bleik, Jeremy Reynolds, Oren Elisha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the widespread adoption of Large Language Models (LLMs), in this paper
we investigate the multilingual capability of these models. Our preliminary
results show that, translating the native language context, question and answer
into a high resource language produced the best results. | [
-0.5314960479736328,
-0.8845930099487305,
0.824674129486084,
0.2669209837913513,
-0.22085091471672058,
0.11888513714075089,
-0.6339890956878662,
-0.6817460060119629,
0.07916723191738129,
0.7204274535179138,
-0.2797807455062866,
-0.2511960566043854,
-0.7121274471282959,
0.388444721698761,
-0.4819234311580658,
0.7257431149482727,
-0.34336942434310913,
0.4564310908317566,
-0.4156990051269531,
-0.3683859407901764,
-0.2615256905555725,
-0.7566971182823181,
-0.6805492043495178,
-0.4926900863647461,
0.45499563217163086,
0.287969708442688,
0.5933777689933777,
0.2623191773891449,
0.7228739261627197,
0.39056187868118286,
-0.32363811135292053,
0.08601806312799454,
-0.32380518317222595,
0.0541241392493248,
-0.17441515624523163,
-0.631493091583252,
-0.43541163206100464,
0.04671462997794151,
0.9430853724479675,
0.8844535946846008,
-0.16384932398796082,
0.4611303210258484,
-0.06419125199317932,
0.2888243794441223,
-0.4984342157840729,
0.012667736038565636,
-0.47334709763526917,
0.020420556887984276,
-0.004979237448424101,
-0.2725372612476349,
-0.5478874444961548,
-0.44006508588790894,
0.032135527580976486,
-0.36058303713798523,
-0.11229176819324493,
-0.10550780594348907,
0.35414960980415344,
-0.2979419231414795,
-0.7468395233154297,
-0.6726760864257812,
-0.8746051788330078,
0.9649192690849304,
-0.5225917100906372,
0.4617516100406647,
0.32114890217781067,
0.48044508695602417,
0.2213742583990097,
-0.6321102380752563,
-0.5574054718017578,
-0.41140592098236084,
0.0554211363196373,
0.09642987698316574,
0.147846058011055,
-0.11559589952230453,
0.20606274902820587,
0.5220567584037781,
-0.681309163570404,
0.21550221741199493,
-0.39911264181137085,
-0.07605890929698944,
0.7656200528144836,
0.34291762113571167,
0.3349868953227997,
-0.2856665551662445,
-0.14862684905529022,
0.08278203010559082,
-0.46401575207710266,
-0.2518520653247833,
0.22884781658649445,
0.35316920280456543,
-0.0835152268409729,
0.8667519688606262,
-0.16792145371437073,
0.7727785706520081,
-0.5489383339881897,
-0.5196724534034729,
0.12177851796150208,
-0.6629741787910461,
-0.1743253916501999,
-0.0292813703417778,
0.31510183215141296,
0.45206159353256226,
0.2908439338207245,
-0.14196358621120453,
-0.3503178358078003,
-0.23355315625667572,
-0.175490140914917,
-0.8897247314453125,
0.7620627880096436,
0.31772133708000183,
-0.5174142122268677,
0.033587746322155,
-0.32312166690826416,
-0.7320787906646729,
-0.4348790645599365,
-0.3200773000717163,
0.3048627972602844,
-0.06906460970640182,
-0.5105262994766235,
0.2722614109516144,
-0.09765158593654633,
0.4548305571079254,
0.49202218651771545,
-0.725484311580658,
0.25914597511291504,
0.6357760429382324,
0.7276752591133118,
-0.2356112152338028,
-0.39424777030944824,
-0.41034847497940063,
-0.02123192325234413,
-0.5107975602149963,
0.7281205058097839,
-0.3689975142478943,
-0.6859087347984314,
0.35909438133239746,
0.2243790626525879,
-0.13153311610221863,
-0.6567134261131287,
0.6086615324020386,
-0.9724437594413757,
0.41454505920410156,
-0.44570109248161316,
-0.4356954097747803,
-0.2994635999202728,
0.6417746543884277,
-0.6224862933158875,
0.9254599213600159,
0.17148326337337494,
-0.6017443537712097,
0.17019478976726532,
-0.8789372444152832,
-0.30482757091522217,
0.09801871329545975,
0.22689135372638702,
0.08144605159759521,
-0.059548474848270416,
0.1272798478603363,
0.4925648272037506,
-0.6164829134941101,
0.33931833505630493,
-0.195533886551857,
-0.20187947154045105,
0.4987267255783081,
-0.6494726538658142,
0.8328300714492798,
0.47740957140922546,
0.059039901942014694,
0.21875318884849548,
-0.7919328808784485,
0.016329754143953323,
0.3935849666595459,
-0.8610263466835022,
-0.24252338707447052,
-0.20581761002540588,
0.3011626601219177,
0.3389101028442383,
0.6338927745819092,
-0.5685098171234131,
0.16541896760463715,
-0.14368781447410583,
0.33049285411834717,
0.4217987656593323,
0.02651923894882202,
0.5786093473434448,
-0.27300432324409485,
1.0198208093643188,
-0.14332590997219086,
0.022083820775151253,
-0.19364920258522034,
-0.38477328419685364,
-0.6473847031593323,
0.10294359922409058,
0.28097856044769287,
0.5435637831687927,
-0.6850520372390747,
-0.09993461519479752,
-0.20812855660915375,
-0.40317749977111816,
-0.4580509662628174,
0.6069856286048889,
0.25796616077423096,
0.23762230575084686,
0.2147625833749771,
0.023849062621593475,
-0.3438664376735687,
-0.9495487213134766,
0.03460295498371124,
-0.20742246508598328,
0.06832566112279892,
0.42228835821151733,
0.5249406099319458,
-0.31801778078079224,
0.3750700056552887,
-0.34718987345695496,
0.36231327056884766,
-0.7594819068908691,
0.1901845782995224,
0.34364405274391174,
0.1374615877866745,
0.6125807166099548,
-0.9640774726867676,
-0.61729496717453,
0.18370188772678375,
-0.7467623949050903,
-0.01746409386396408,
0.08115772902965546,
-0.09933620691299438,
0.39219531416893005,
0.32760727405548096,
-0.5330847501754761,
-0.04474961385130882,
0.6933664083480835,
-0.07663683593273163,
0.8005787134170532,
-0.46701961755752563,
0.30431216955184937,
-1.2905174493789673,
0.29133090376853943,
-0.11133135855197906,
-0.347388356924057,
-0.6411651372909546,
0.5724863409996033,
0.31697139143943787,
-0.19030870497226715,
-0.6094710826873779,
0.9215835928916931,
-0.6454742550849915,
-0.49802619218826294,
-0.17131508886814117,
0.5381168127059937,
-0.003459085477516055,
0.0640328899025917,
0.146283820271492,
1.033468246459961,
0.461844801902771,
-0.6143794059753418,
0.8278139233589172,
0.21851108968257904,
-0.6995322704315186,
0.6910526156425476,
-0.5450863838195801,
0.08357109874486923,
-0.46904775500297546,
-0.08987383544445038,
-1.2614058256149292,
-0.4451692998409271,
-0.3700525164604187,
-0.10239963233470917,
0.31297171115875244,
0.02801571786403656,
-0.6734470129013062,
-0.6658124327659607,
-0.22419142723083496,
0.332358181476593,
0.10764838010072708,
-0.5202245712280273,
0.5238820314407349,
0.2929827570915222,
-0.5493901371955872,
-0.48143476247787476,
-0.5833984017372131,
0.27658411860466003,
-0.248738631606102,
-0.8609134554862976,
-0.16184385120868683,
-0.6191365122795105,
-0.6031385064125061,
-0.2918969988822937,
0.359975129365921,
-0.24832683801651,
0.1460493952035904,
-0.3303285539150238,
0.24966676533222198,
-0.5813596844673157,
0.33269307017326355,
-0.17725224792957306,
0.1225421205163002,
0.037821412086486816,
0.1970982849597931,
0.786975085735321,
-0.2577943503856659,
-0.3125048875808716,
0.005083198193460703,
0.7045122385025024,
0.9076908230781555,
-0.6462787389755249,
0.6870205402374268,
0.3094698488712311,
-0.24647822976112366,
0.08131995052099228,
-0.7201715111732483,
0.30360743403434753,
-0.4195501506328583,
0.7532801628112793,
-0.4250538647174835,
-0.8989710807800293,
0.8152687549591064,
-0.14647191762924194,
0.022126181051135063,
0.3902437090873718,
0.9718692898750305,
0.2514173984527588,
1.075110673904419,
0.5285847187042236,
0.005684023257344961,
0.30584970116615295,
-0.2755478620529175,
0.0742623507976532,
-0.8470380902290344,
-0.33761149644851685,
-0.723060131072998,
-0.13930581510066986,
-0.39540112018585205,
-0.6528690457344055,
0.5441358089447021,
0.2722832262516022,
0.02250288426876068,
0.11206642538309097,
-0.11364665627479553,
0.22457255423069,
0.22320882976055145,
-0.2270561009645462,
0.6436054706573486,
-0.031239116564393044,
-0.24063751101493835,
0.027432091534137726,
-0.4783502221107483,
-0.7460233569145203,
1.0513489246368408,
0.5417400002479553,
0.6856861710548401,
0.4127781391143799,
0.4911835789680481,
-0.11894502490758896,
0.6643463373184204,
-1.040094017982483,
0.6689155697822571,
-0.01665019989013672,
-0.9399011731147766,
-0.6077898740768433,
-0.21285350620746613,
-0.9295353293418884,
0.6751853227615356,
-0.13342830538749695,
-0.7849021553993225,
-0.20829465985298157,
-0.5563914775848389,
-0.1141255646944046,
0.3047412037849426,
-0.5931311249732971,
0.725568413734436,
-0.5504468083381653,
-0.1418924629688263,
-0.35030820965766907,
-0.27856767177581787,
0.4943247139453888,
-0.4361012279987335,
0.47684285044670105,
0.09162560105323792,
-0.13523384928703308,
0.8748311400413513,
0.023666663095355034,
0.2658248841762543,
0.077873595058918,
-0.4360102117061615,
0.5173185467720032,
0.13646933436393738,
0.2807692587375641,
0.11691531538963318,
-0.7564316391944885,
-0.13336274027824402,
0.17453517019748688,
-0.24673566222190857,
-0.6105663776397705,
0.6310410499572754,
-0.7390797138214111,
-0.8510239720344543,
-0.18961888551712036,
-0.8993510007858276,
-0.43119296431541443,
0.40590137243270874,
-0.0697854608297348,
0.5192087292671204,
-0.3478012681007385,
0.33872073888778687,
0.4647512137889862,
-0.5303512811660767,
0.7864038348197937,
1.0661298036575317,
-0.7609899640083313,
-0.2550950348377228,
0.43081924319267273,
0.318353533744812,
0.4072847366333008,
0.34557637572288513,
0.27674785256385803,
-0.6722844839096069,
-0.5463979840278625,
-0.6463502049446106,
0.5062627196311951,
-0.9500675201416016,
0.1479671448469162,
-0.6725636720657349,
-0.3979220688343048,
-0.40957266092300415,
-0.12240196764469147,
-0.2116120308637619,
-0.2131117433309555,
-0.05990111455321312,
-0.23814110457897186,
-0.003714065533131361,
1.0049524307250977,
0.20796772837638855,
0.2634347975254059,
-0.8971211314201355,
0.20748557150363922,
0.3348095715045929,
0.4341357946395874,
0.06429105252027512,
-0.6234930157661438,
-0.40542057156562805,
-0.07826557755470276,
-0.3085537254810333,
-0.9963127970695496,
0.27709972858428955,
-0.044588737189769745,
0.9045793414115906,
0.15993136167526245,
-0.4037279784679413,
0.30600711703300476,
-0.42248842120170593,
0.783322811126709,
0.2397703379392624,
-0.6721834540367126,
0.3430594205856323,
-0.4257998466491699,
0.5211948156356812,
0.39889609813690186,
0.7068436145782471,
-0.8852794766426086,
-0.05795250087976456,
-0.28868457674980164,
-0.5724918246269226,
0.4101545512676239,
-0.3775838017463684,
0.4567044973373413,
-0.06888148933649063,
0.23425345122814178,
0.058249253779649734,
0.29879245162010193,
-0.787827730178833,
0.058981023728847504,
0.4738452732563019,
0.3026411831378937,
-0.41758993268013,
-0.6443935036659241,
-0.00935094989836216,
-0.09027105569839478,
0.332118421792984,
-0.16297104954719543,
0.05584283545613289,
0.09102267771959305,
-0.25578573346138,
-0.35221126675605774,
0.7964417338371277,
0.7237940430641174,
1.216957688331604,
-0.12365221977233887,
0.02622891217470169,
0.4919770359992981,
-0.18203364312648773,
0.23444947600364685,
-0.17178522050380707,
0.10059719532728195,
0.004905113484710455,
0.5538280606269836,
0.4784236252307892,
0.12752798199653625,
-0.839914083480835,
0.4967172145843506,
-0.04820583760738373,
-0.26129838824272156,
-0.21005523204803467,
-0.3349224030971527,
0.48660990595817566,
0.0819830670952797,
0.3919641375541687,
-0.4413454234600067,
0.11721977591514587,
-0.8959096670150757,
-0.008926446549594402,
0.5298946499824524,
-0.06940046697854996,
0.021611224859952927,
0.43694671988487244,
0.15611697733402252,
-0.37269914150238037,
0.5148392915725708,
0.0078831035643816,
-0.7065640091896057,
0.5873920917510986,
0.8108320236206055,
0.5037758946418762,
-0.5900709629058838,
0.3027110993862152,
0.4661540687084198,
0.35120007395744324,
-0.15849174559116364,
0.6599068641662598,
0.16400840878486633,
-0.8147412538528442,
-0.7220898866653442,
-0.8831859230995178,
-0.39560386538505554,
0.27717456221580505,
-0.6753379702568054,
0.1332806795835495,
-0.29270586371421814,
-0.12025199085474014,
0.06474341452121735,
0.2365799844264984,
-0.6623457670211792,
0.3189482092857361,
0.25049418210983276,
1.2575201988220215,
-0.6073970794677734,
0.874652087688446,
0.9366517066955566,
-0.3946874141693115,
-0.6779894232749939,
-0.33584064245224,
-0.33866068720817566,
-0.8913685083389282,
0.9759625196456909,
-0.011225281283259392,
0.031156767159700394,
-0.24143390357494354,
-0.34302330017089844,
-0.9320985078811646,
0.8438339829444885,
0.49679896235466003,
-0.5123919248580933,
0.06761162728071213,
0.34267476201057434,
0.6375784277915955,
-0.2842573821544647,
0.410319983959198,
0.5318750739097595,
0.7446842789649963,
0.14425337314605713,
-1.2476826906204224,
-0.1722254455089569,
-0.14807142317295074,
0.15650586783885956,
0.02984771877527237,
-0.6557173132896423,
0.7391499876976013,
-0.1990705132484436,
-0.04380682110786438,
0.25529927015304565,
0.5040116310119629,
0.17728565633296967,
0.21876274049282074,
0.49395623803138733,
0.2918687164783478,
0.9720628261566162,
0.08486317098140717,
1.5230997800827026,
-0.38147345185279846,
0.30137932300567627,
0.8910364508628845,
-0.549648642539978,
1.1102638244628906,
0.37475934624671936,
-0.4542734622955322,
0.25146856904029846,
0.5893668532371521,
0.228859543800354,
0.02606423757970333,
0.3684413731098175,
-0.48496168851852417,
-0.2998296618461609,
-0.4014284014701843,
-0.32398003339767456,
0.7040988802909851,
0.11278699338436127,
-0.23777605593204498,
-0.2960817515850067,
0.09992276132106781,
-0.013835969381034374,
0.24527768790721893,
-0.4938947558403015,
0.6337767839431763,
0.08254823833703995,
-0.8296383023262024,
0.47958484292030334,
0.5159687399864197,
0.5085240006446838,
-0.6846386194229126,
0.1510564237833023,
-0.3319771885871887,
-0.02917715348303318,
-0.051523953676223755,
-1.087470293045044,
0.33981937170028687,
0.08836009353399277,
-0.31840646266937256,
-0.2033260464668274,
0.6139300465583801,
-0.5598888397216797,
-0.882276713848114,
0.5786447525024414,
0.7364096641540527,
0.14662252366542816,
0.15347257256507874,
-0.5833116769790649,
0.0003482967149466276,
-0.4622021019458771,
-0.43982475996017456,
0.3695038855075836,
0.260748028755188,
-0.1045694500207901,
0.8764563798904419,
0.4846751391887665,
0.19037483632564545,
0.11550016701221466,
0.14687849581241608,
0.5733824968338013,
-0.49470752477645874,
-0.5216192603111267,
-0.5680686235427856,
0.3049505352973938,
-0.054810404777526855,
-0.16369853913784027,
0.97956383228302,
0.8119359016418457,
0.7725058197975159,
0.023371275514364243,
0.8014280200004578,
0.1761566698551178,
0.5243792533874512,
-0.43159759044647217,
0.5853098034858704,
-0.7454795837402344,
0.12669949233531952,
-0.3066094219684601,
-1.0924705266952515,
-0.22559984028339386,
0.40246981382369995,
-0.6834542155265808,
0.23960614204406738,
0.7361236810684204,
0.711528480052948,
0.1337992250919342,
0.03236932307481766,
0.6718621850013733,
0.15010303258895874,
0.17520776391029358,
0.5103040933609009,
1.1405755281448364,
-0.22059540450572968,
0.43924587965011597,
-0.012815684080123901,
-0.30340445041656494,
-0.06800404191017151,
-0.9525949358940125,
-0.7610288858413696,
-0.43992316722869873,
-0.047529496252536774,
-0.4303344190120697,
-0.23687084019184113,
0.7885761260986328,
0.4937330186367035,
-0.7501962184906006,
-0.7848575711250305,
0.6974079608917236,
0.31630104780197144,
0.13514834642410278,
-0.14371584355831146,
0.2060355544090271,
-0.25419896841049194,
-0.8936439156532288,
0.4180406630039215,
0.21861910820007324,
-0.0041132522746920586,
-0.6463526487350464,
-0.3493999242782593,
-0.4615776240825653,
0.11811353266239166,
0.9446331262588501,
-0.025740191340446472,
-0.4738554358482361,
0.07089967280626297,
0.09778179973363876,
-0.3864475190639496,
-0.03491966426372528,
0.9036712050437927,
0.008714505471289158,
0.6143441796302795,
0.5705931186676025,
0.7651440501213074,
0.5121741890907288,
-0.19582834839820862,
0.668131411075592,
-0.25151902437210083,
0.2351972907781601,
-0.03239051625132561,
0.6382610201835632,
0.5168430209159851,
-0.41343384981155396,
0.5093830227851868,
-0.008107629604637623,
-0.5024256110191345,
-0.682727038860321,
0.0718795508146286,
-0.8046283721923828,
-0.4278688132762909,
1.373155951499939,
-0.17030878365039825,
-0.1094125285744667,
0.03364928066730499,
-0.3425748944282532,
0.15892378985881805,
0.16551783680915833,
0.3573881983757019,
1.1416873931884766,
0.18660791218280792,
-0.27407005429267883,
-1.0116894245147705,
-0.06643513590097427,
0.24689124524593353,
-0.8183888792991638,
-0.06670783460140228,
0.43444815278053284,
0.3812180757522583,
0.29755687713623047,
0.7540504932403564,
-0.45201706886291504,
0.15252606570720673,
-0.21981748938560486,
-0.13786040246486664,
0.21348626911640167,
-0.30763211846351624,
-0.6205229759216309,
0.3129452168941498,
0.7569661736488342,
0.4450925290584564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01053v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01053v1 | Plan-Grounded Large Language Models for Dual Goal Conversational Settings | 2024-02-01T22:56:39 | 2024-02-01T22:56:39 | Diogo Glória-Silva, Rafael Ferreira, Diogo Tavares, David Semedo, João Magalhães | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Training Large Language Models (LLMs) to follow user instructions has been
shown to supply the LLM with ample capacity to converse fluently while being
aligned with humans. Yet, it is not completely clear how an LLM can lead a
plan-grounded conversation in mixed-initiative settings where instructions flow
in both directions of the conversation, i.e. both the LLM and the user provide
instructions to one another. In this paper, we tackle a dual goal
mixed-initiative conversational setting where the LLM not only grounds the
conversation on an arbitrary plan but also seeks to satisfy both a procedural
plan and user instructions. The LLM is then responsible for guiding the user
through the plan and, at the same time, adapting to new circumstances,
answering questions, and activating safety guardrails when needed. We propose a
novel LLM that grounds the dialogue on a procedural plan, can take the dialogue
initiative, and enforces guardrails on the system's behavior, while also
improving the LLM's responses to unexpected user behavior. Experiments in
controlled settings and with real users show that the best-performing model,
which we call PlanLLM, achieves a 2.1x improvement over a strong baseline.
Moreover, experiments also show good generalization to unseen domains. | [
-0.14575599133968353,
-0.7939568161964417,
0.7668309211730957,
0.475480854511261,
-0.25869879126548767,
0.3846302628517151,
-0.5247528553009033,
-0.02965346910059452,
0.3278004229068756,
0.8757880330085754,
-0.7444031238555908,
-0.6183255314826965,
-0.35951393842697144,
-0.4358741343021393,
-0.023967748507857323,
0.7485183477401733,
-0.24543890357017517,
0.19312654435634613,
-0.0749255046248436,
-0.07783446460962296,
-0.949863076210022,
-0.609054446220398,
-0.7133928537368774,
-0.6306411623954773,
0.5633734464645386,
0.7086606621742249,
0.7870628833770752,
0.3023277819156647,
0.21309591829776764,
0.16916097700595856,
-0.03617890179157257,
0.288901686668396,
-0.7548589110374451,
0.225225567817688,
-0.18690530955791473,
-0.29937899112701416,
-0.44859519600868225,
-0.06860100477933884,
0.5304860472679138,
0.7982559204101562,
-0.6242345571517944,
-0.38255447149276733,
0.101312056183815,
0.1791275292634964,
-0.31320005655288696,
0.3804490566253662,
-0.6033114194869995,
-0.011877546086907387,
0.34029456973075867,
-0.4128446578979492,
-0.429251492023468,
-0.01944245770573616,
0.014572861604392529,
-0.34243881702423096,
-0.25115612149238586,
0.052455972880125046,
0.5191605091094971,
-0.022090818732976913,
-0.7186179757118225,
-0.3121492862701416,
-0.93825364112854,
0.7389250993728638,
-0.680955171585083,
0.09118469804525375,
0.21614521741867065,
0.29956093430519104,
-0.5707292556762695,
-0.3753877878189087,
-0.46208426356315613,
-0.27612927556037903,
-0.059160035103559494,
0.13241632282733917,
0.18143075704574585,
0.5031082630157471,
0.3390572667121887,
-0.0009306647116318345,
-0.3927757441997528,
0.5184947848320007,
-0.09455567598342896,
0.014470990747213364,
0.5374102592468262,
0.39421483874320984,
0.2761770188808441,
0.16313624382019043,
-0.5904698967933655,
-0.19601324200630188,
-0.8181997537612915,
0.35559508204460144,
0.35895445942878723,
0.48780304193496704,
-0.391431599855423,
0.6850053071975708,
-0.3163676857948303,
0.4976651668548584,
-0.019542550668120384,
-0.18195535242557526,
-0.2044750452041626,
-0.23794208467006683,
-0.065747931599617,
0.04256318882107735,
0.5977240204811096,
0.7748032212257385,
0.3299265503883362,
-0.10494910925626755,
-0.4481475353240967,
0.13543890416622162,
0.2818152606487274,
-0.8820880651473999,
-0.2148800939321518,
0.10973293334245682,
-0.23732410371303558,
-0.17769010365009308,
-0.2181084305047989,
-0.7925746440887451,
-0.46568456292152405,
-0.5969155430793762,
0.2568826675415039,
-0.16692256927490234,
-0.4063914120197296,
0.31728893518447876,
0.18231505155563354,
0.4970400333404541,
0.5377255082130432,
-1.07301664352417,
0.4823944866657257,
0.8905720710754395,
0.8207961320877075,
0.03221776708960533,
-0.1350225806236267,
-0.7467742562294006,
0.2580440640449524,
-0.5550244450569153,
0.4527021646499634,
-0.6010013222694397,
-0.6847579479217529,
0.36341261863708496,
-0.3863523006439209,
-0.22712577879428864,
-0.0676911249756813,
0.7914632558822632,
-0.4060249328613281,
0.24485912919044495,
-0.19803486764431,
-0.1543641984462738,
-0.09085144847631454,
0.41927769780158997,
-0.021118491888046265,
0.7324604988098145,
-0.24505984783172607,
-0.4114718735218048,
0.22798819839954376,
-0.598885715007782,
-0.5725101232528687,
-0.050366248935461044,
-0.5545046925544739,
-0.08669824153184891,
0.14163532853126526,
0.006998302880674601,
0.4407109320163727,
-0.24252578616142273,
0.6712779402732849,
-0.30459097027778625,
-0.2666056454181671,
0.20971718430519104,
-0.3551401197910309,
0.5339765548706055,
-0.17887012660503387,
-0.21441318094730377,
0.5143588781356812,
-0.48045405745506287,
0.4062407314777374,
0.1280016005039215,
-0.526598334312439,
-0.2459816336631775,
0.33430910110473633,
0.009399015456438065,
0.362997829914093,
0.1139642745256424,
-0.3672582805156708,
0.1505495309829712,
-0.3148286044597626,
0.48340898752212524,
0.8085300326347351,
-0.04496743157505989,
0.37722086906433105,
-0.3961048722267151,
0.39598169922828674,
-0.32445117831230164,
-0.2098323404788971,
-0.2784837782382965,
-0.3898497223854065,
-0.9160591959953308,
-0.15691350400447845,
-0.21218667924404144,
0.5511766076087952,
-0.5219282507896423,
0.4846726357936859,
-0.2700219452381134,
-0.18071803450584412,
0.016615496948361397,
-0.14542743563652039,
0.619592547416687,
0.5066067576408386,
0.21132369339466095,
-0.25339168310165405,
-0.3209235370159149,
-0.8595309853553772,
-0.2227022498846054,
-0.47696587443351746,
-0.04027143120765686,
0.5347405076026917,
0.21195173263549805,
-0.1305197924375534,
0.8553873300552368,
-0.5101242661476135,
-0.08202239871025085,
-0.5636659860610962,
0.24372021853923798,
0.21985390782356262,
0.4207828938961029,
0.17959313094615936,
-0.9371239542961121,
-0.668224036693573,
-0.04502958804368973,
-0.6490722894668579,
-0.17417296767234802,
-0.32758215069770813,
-0.13820894062519073,
-0.11016657948493958,
0.4618512988090515,
-0.7301434874534607,
0.3987336754798889,
0.5007174015045166,
-0.3456346094608307,
0.5904743671417236,
-0.3322574198246002,
0.1896335482597351,
-1.1860729455947876,
-0.22664953768253326,
-0.19543737173080444,
-0.25394853949546814,
-1.0791956186294556,
-0.005140000022947788,
-0.009819529950618744,
-0.3695017397403717,
-0.16886113584041595,
0.5882009863853455,
-0.35801491141319275,
0.003970552701503038,
-0.3973037004470825,
-0.07541044801473618,
-0.12335950881242752,
0.88449627161026,
0.5745008587837219,
0.735011637210846,
0.6938903331756592,
-0.5759774446487427,
0.17663900554180145,
0.48566925525665283,
-0.14392179250717163,
0.7097716331481934,
-0.7915143370628357,
0.2951321601867676,
0.017421018332242966,
0.4630424976348877,
-1.0044878721237183,
-0.39653876423835754,
0.10662046819925308,
-0.07969757914543152,
0.4456017315387726,
-0.40908411145210266,
-0.365953654050827,
-0.36662617325782776,
-0.19404570758342743,
0.019261997193098068,
0.38796624541282654,
-0.5305994153022766,
0.6761753559112549,
0.437220960855484,
-0.25056004524230957,
-0.34395739436149597,
-0.5665457844734192,
0.5590643286705017,
-0.45705047249794006,
-0.8152363300323486,
0.3713858425617218,
-0.25512316823005676,
-0.4378525912761688,
-0.5344671010971069,
-0.1206134483218193,
-0.015733415260910988,
-0.006878361571580172,
0.4445555806159973,
0.12872350215911865,
-0.15327978134155273,
0.01760776899755001,
-0.11891656368970871,
-0.05425676330924034,
0.23695150017738342,
-0.31722384691238403,
0.8388569355010986,
-0.06207038462162018,
-0.49359533190727234,
-0.42291995882987976,
0.8130203485488892,
0.5851538181304932,
-0.09133908152580261,
0.8471727967262268,
0.12204831838607788,
-0.22348864376544952,
-0.2207474559545517,
-0.4690304100513458,
-0.31082797050476074,
-0.4661458134651184,
0.3330540359020233,
-0.6439893841743469,
-0.9341416954994202,
0.4902285635471344,
-0.3289269804954529,
0.5177964568138123,
-0.31424370408058167,
0.5515546798706055,
-0.25653308629989624,
1.089773178100586,
0.7295317649841309,
0.19552986323833466,
0.33681389689445496,
0.014531474560499191,
0.5104582905769348,
-0.7867031097412109,
-0.3733668625354767,
-0.42641040682792664,
-0.3707619607448578,
-0.32260918617248535,
-0.463458776473999,
0.3102668821811676,
0.22922222316265106,
-0.07879655808210373,
0.2522689998149872,
0.04671541228890419,
0.28638869524002075,
0.54443359375,
0.11952891200780869,
0.12636934220790863,
-0.019374841824173927,
-0.3898177146911621,
-0.0007140946690924466,
-0.7795810103416443,
-0.7678191065788269,
0.7986414432525635,
0.4674094021320343,
0.9368975758552551,
0.22691123187541962,
0.7116610407829285,
0.1492886245250702,
0.017613723874092102,
-0.7381255030632019,
0.8154712915420532,
0.2558138370513916,
-0.38967248797416687,
-0.30116334557533264,
-0.534298837184906,
-0.6359248161315918,
0.4635307192802429,
-0.2867555618286133,
-0.8899280428886414,
-0.18580026924610138,
0.35139960050582886,
-0.17204760015010834,
0.23475317656993866,
-0.7468713521957397,
1.0416285991668701,
-0.6762188076972961,
-0.3542427718639374,
-0.5398337244987488,
-0.7271369695663452,
0.32739198207855225,
0.09541547298431396,
0.11500068008899689,
-0.2975883483886719,
0.11274126172065735,
0.607948899269104,
-0.38009199500083923,
1.0846139192581177,
-0.35301533341407776,
0.018542740494012833,
0.2783266007900238,
0.05442139506340027,
0.9092656373977661,
0.128187894821167,
0.20543606579303741,
0.061489176005125046,
-0.31507688760757446,
-0.32246655225753784,
-0.5533221364021301,
0.721213698387146,
-0.6441861987113953,
-1.0601052045822144,
-0.3039805293083191,
-0.6159840822219849,
-0.4874514639377594,
0.2133352905511856,
-0.1770724654197693,
0.47713640332221985,
-0.521209180355072,
0.16584445536136627,
0.8099241852760315,
-0.2404283583164215,
0.33395811915397644,
0.7059476375579834,
-0.3124575614929199,
-0.16578562557697296,
0.26822954416275024,
-0.3423420786857605,
0.6937816143035889,
0.35814860463142395,
0.3406202495098114,
-0.4649196267127991,
-0.7812131643295288,
-0.5121162533760071,
0.18501247465610504,
-0.5740975737571716,
0.1307845413684845,
-0.6915521025657654,
-0.2827485501766205,
-0.04586124047636986,
-0.34534305334091187,
-0.30348747968673706,
-0.3040597140789032,
-0.18367642164230347,
-0.21956831216812134,
0.1854400634765625,
0.43750423192977905,
0.13378341495990753,
0.5822283625602722,
-0.3276090621948242,
0.24487492442131042,
0.46829962730407715,
0.1455078423023224,
-0.32166531682014465,
-0.6991112232208252,
0.08293240517377853,
0.35295218229293823,
0.015300421044230461,
-0.61951744556427,
0.2914391756057739,
-0.06626227498054504,
0.6784064769744873,
0.461317777633667,
0.1779264509677887,
0.7886539697647095,
-0.7030897736549377,
0.3691827952861786,
0.5519409775733948,
-0.4043404459953308,
0.5770968198776245,
-0.697376549243927,
0.21414302289485931,
0.6516955494880676,
0.063102588057518,
-0.9210719466209412,
-0.2531050741672516,
-0.26321226358413696,
-0.6154085397720337,
0.8684368133544922,
0.09797415882349014,
0.6258910298347473,
0.23749852180480957,
0.07697558403015137,
-0.2147977203130722,
0.2588410973548889,
-0.8620594143867493,
0.07520008087158203,
0.020745713263750076,
-0.031160330399870872,
0.014040283858776093,
-0.5398047566413879,
-0.5779462456703186,
0.3443012833595276,
0.4726862609386444,
-0.28644147515296936,
0.10316777229309082,
-0.3235609531402588,
0.2314688116312027,
-0.23454296588897705,
0.6029552817344666,
0.7352024912834167,
0.7343065142631531,
-0.15639159083366394,
0.3251760005950928,
0.08928553014993668,
-0.04123494029045105,
0.09704355150461197,
0.014722706750035286,
-0.24288859963417053,
-0.49200451374053955,
0.22810514271259308,
1.0162893533706665,
0.54982990026474,
-0.7088823914527893,
0.41213780641555786,
-0.22546930611133575,
-0.10103213787078857,
-0.3358912765979767,
0.35517314076423645,
0.3248998522758484,
0.26642268896102905,
0.10457798838615417,
0.10890854150056839,
-0.38416844606399536,
-0.6432982087135315,
0.015966316685080528,
0.7694364190101624,
-0.4135560989379883,
-0.23050867021083832,
0.4131571352481842,
0.5754793882369995,
-0.8685904741287231,
0.3743557631969452,
-0.10466375946998596,
-0.7643724083900452,
0.35646140575408936,
0.6070368885993958,
0.8138450384140015,
-0.07073238492012024,
0.19017350673675537,
0.15662728250026703,
0.19935770332813263,
-0.14687377214431763,
0.28373369574546814,
-0.12543076276779175,
-0.8669676780700684,
-0.2411087155342102,
-0.5514898300170898,
-0.5295661687850952,
0.1632644534111023,
-0.4686461091041565,
0.44883567094802856,
-0.5292210578918457,
0.10022497922182083,
-0.3957403302192688,
-0.09841041266918182,
-0.32452309131622314,
-0.09669046849012375,
0.155861958861351,
0.7133851647377014,
-0.8704177141189575,
0.7593716382980347,
0.4752068817615509,
-0.0060231504030525684,
-0.8985074758529663,
0.15413649380207062,
0.21271221339702606,
-0.9060531854629517,
0.2763674259185791,
0.3678656816482544,
-0.4249128997325897,
-0.07066664844751358,
-0.1993652582168579,
-0.6091605424880981,
1.0591039657592773,
0.10204200446605682,
-0.8434594869613647,
-0.10936645418405533,
0.15521755814552307,
0.6166684627532959,
-0.5228617191314697,
0.0976695567369461,
0.2823024094104767,
0.26893165707588196,
0.55743408203125,
-0.9562364220619202,
-0.19571107625961304,
0.11741244047880173,
-0.053646303713321686,
0.3167937994003296,
-0.8488135933876038,
0.4215124547481537,
-0.3131464719772339,
-0.354784220457077,
0.09146875143051147,
0.6960301399230957,
0.36717382073402405,
0.2850755453109741,
0.6109313368797302,
0.4820713698863983,
0.654011070728302,
0.06293821334838867,
0.8314661979675293,
-0.10178891569375992,
-0.03690916672348976,
1.4326586723327637,
-0.7717848420143127,
0.7785828709602356,
0.48426488041877747,
0.1076732650399208,
0.3518419563770294,
0.5018413662910461,
0.5278315544128418,
0.5719107389450073,
0.1726836860179901,
-0.41749727725982666,
-0.3576927185058594,
-0.19413821399211884,
-0.062308914959430695,
0.5359199047088623,
0.5225200653076172,
-0.05780459940433502,
-0.16334231197834015,
-0.20630702376365662,
0.2916705906391144,
0.4737624228000641,
-0.3323060870170593,
0.7791422009468079,
0.16275319457054138,
-1.0551211833953857,
0.4880324602127075,
0.3120640218257904,
0.32444220781326294,
-0.733127772808075,
-0.10409122705459595,
-0.21120907366275787,
0.15622621774673462,
0.044796355068683624,
-0.8918541073799133,
0.09102308005094528,
0.1641533523797989,
-0.059055592864751816,
-0.7440175414085388,
0.6052744388580322,
-0.8057805299758911,
-0.35619887709617615,
0.4849245846271515,
0.254180908203125,
0.025162868201732635,
0.17069518566131592,
-0.6630197167396545,
-0.030520858243107796,
0.13364268839359283,
-0.1577383428812027,
0.3513987064361572,
0.43165040016174316,
-0.3542751371860504,
0.7885908484458923,
0.6553174257278442,
0.06779344379901886,
0.03988238424062729,
0.26178449392318726,
1.0113492012023926,
-0.47563159465789795,
-0.8269467353820801,
-0.6085708737373352,
0.5583736300468445,
-0.29665181040763855,
-0.26427793502807617,
0.6581916809082031,
0.5135053396224976,
0.5498660802841187,
0.20990370213985443,
0.5884984731674194,
0.11114528030157089,
0.42892566323280334,
-0.9139975309371948,
0.31826871633529663,
-0.10103197395801544,
0.4193705916404724,
0.1869133561849594,
-0.8682010173797607,
-0.17976026237010956,
0.6886425018310547,
-0.3691302239894867,
0.10541528463363647,
0.4514412581920624,
1.0922144651412964,
-0.32610785961151123,
0.03373967111110687,
0.4745121896266937,
0.05451156198978424,
0.6171340942382812,
0.7938297390937805,
1.2211707830429077,
0.31218627095222473,
0.477630615234375,
0.07682285457849503,
-0.47765877842903137,
-0.26419100165367126,
-0.7630075216293335,
-1.4463609457015991,
-0.19652681052684784,
-0.24445320665836334,
-0.15584376454353333,
0.11526430398225784,
0.9673541188240051,
1.0012257099151611,
-0.6869707703590393,
-0.5768237113952637,
-0.4435286819934845,
-0.013258672319352627,
0.17458301782608032,
-0.14595070481300354,
0.008212302811443806,
-0.3025232255458832,
-0.43971526622772217,
0.8443527817726135,
0.5158196687698364,
-0.10933110862970352,
-0.37181442975997925,
-0.5731233358383179,
-0.3959486186504364,
0.24942855536937714,
0.3306784927845001,
0.3666716516017914,
-0.8645392656326294,
-0.4792167544364929,
-0.15224161744117737,
-0.30477696657180786,
0.1779540777206421,
1.1114331483840942,
-0.3080025315284729,
0.5135717391967773,
0.09519369900226593,
0.5234681367874146,
0.7570405602455139,
0.10425486415624619,
0.7764748930931091,
-0.8834620118141174,
0.19864511489868164,
0.41986146569252014,
0.3296297788619995,
0.24597634375095367,
-0.2737654149532318,
0.3754355013370514,
-0.07140837609767914,
-0.5446545481681824,
-0.5755819082260132,
0.5280967950820923,
-1.0361289978027344,
-0.11229885369539261,
1.3618007898330688,
-0.20963755249977112,
0.24173906445503235,
-0.12316078692674637,
-0.4744737148284912,
-0.17398276925086975,
-0.5814093947410583,
0.6046735048294067,
0.6974210143089294,
-0.1160232424736023,
-0.31808382272720337,
-0.49094918370246887,
0.4400847554206848,
0.5388413071632385,
-0.8609927892684937,
0.42202675342559814,
0.713817298412323,
0.004470267798751593,
0.06423314660787582,
0.8023772239685059,
0.28916752338409424,
-0.0160233061760664,
-0.12293583154678345,
-0.19939571619033813,
0.014239780604839325,
-0.6888394355773926,
-0.2847806513309479,
-0.006024728529155254,
0.2392411231994629,
-0.04849856719374657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01051v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01051v1 | Generation, Distillation and Evaluation of Motivational Interviewing-Style Reflections with a Foundational Language Model | 2024-02-01T22:54:31 | 2024-02-01T22:54:31 | Andrew Brown, Jiading Zhu, Mohamed Abdelwahab, Alec Dong, Cindy Wang, Jonathan Rose | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Foundational Language Models are capable of performing many tasks at a
high level but are difficult to deploy in many applications because of their
size and proprietary ownership. Many will be motivated to distill specific
capabilities of foundational models into smaller models that can be owned and
controlled. In the development of a therapeutic chatbot, we wish to distill a
capability known as reflective listening, in which a therapist produces
reflections of client speech. These reflections either restate what a client
has said, or connect what was said to a relevant observation, idea or guess
that encourages and guides the client to continue contemplation. In this paper,
we present a method for distilling the generation of reflections from a
Foundational Language Model (GPT-4) into smaller models. We first show that
GPT-4, using zero-shot prompting, can generate reflections at near 100% success
rate, superior to all previous methods. Using reflections generated by GPT-4,
we fine-tune different sizes of the GPT-2 family. The GPT-2-small model
achieves 83% success on a hold-out test set and the GPT-2 XL achieves 90%
success. We also show that GPT-4 can help in the labor-intensive task of
evaluating the quality of the distilled models, using it as a zero-shot
classifier. Using triple-human review as a guide, the classifier achieves a
Cohen-Kappa of 0.66, a substantial inter-rater reliability figure. | [
-0.3473557233810425,
-0.6003225445747375,
0.7944561243057251,
0.2781389653682709,
-0.34147170186042786,
0.20666417479515076,
-0.33943307399749756,
-0.28242218494415283,
-0.026441257447004318,
0.4346555769443512,
-0.4345197081565857,
-0.4461554288864136,
-0.6035728454589844,
0.10658678412437439,
-0.3871084153652191,
1.358012080192566,
-0.026573963463306427,
0.21727924048900604,
0.34874653816223145,
0.13160350918769836,
-0.9597902297973633,
-0.2884613573551178,
-0.4093307852745056,
-0.45967793464660645,
0.2461119294166565,
0.3422115445137024,
0.2664465606212616,
0.19794505834579468,
0.282267689704895,
0.3117898404598236,
-0.03899991512298584,
-0.23272721469402313,
-0.7946527600288391,
0.37201428413391113,
-0.10530388355255127,
-0.5266748666763306,
-0.3420224189758301,
0.3726535439491272,
0.3863462507724762,
0.7117793560028076,
-0.5096552968025208,
0.37816789746284485,
0.4174436628818512,
0.4589666426181793,
-0.5527160167694092,
0.4297720491886139,
-0.8632580041885376,
-0.05707508325576782,
0.1828896552324295,
-0.34368449449539185,
-0.6564866900444031,
-0.3821406662464142,
0.33272022008895874,
-0.15332123637199402,
0.5461036562919617,
-0.29852432012557983,
0.5080471634864807,
0.12184522300958633,
-0.3159899115562439,
-0.32834020256996155,
-1.0169785022735596,
0.8819534778594971,
-0.6571682691574097,
0.10463008284568787,
0.3851150870323181,
0.5274850130081177,
0.014649402350187302,
-0.6097832322120667,
-0.4767075777053833,
-0.5596863031387329,
-0.04903213679790497,
0.19515182077884674,
-0.04016349837183952,
0.13274414837360382,
0.22573783993721008,
0.46064862608909607,
-0.3567042350769043,
-0.4902089536190033,
-0.4897214472293854,
0.018433986231684685,
0.3574739396572113,
0.2381996214389801,
-0.004354528151452541,
0.08255138248205185,
-0.11886577308177948,
0.01451197825372219,
-0.5332610011100769,
-0.19226694107055664,
-0.022376390174031258,
0.3974486291408539,
0.16810236871242523,
0.36396297812461853,
-0.25563758611679077,
0.6681835055351257,
0.5667275786399841,
-0.5322273373603821,
0.16514621675014496,
-0.38370925188064575,
0.04795757308602333,
0.26074808835983276,
0.7233750820159912,
0.5645332932472229,
-0.012116669677197933,
-0.0318743959069252,
-0.19028261303901672,
0.26843807101249695,
0.45279741287231445,
-1.1646074056625366,
-0.34445634484291077,
0.14393247663974762,
-0.49945005774497986,
-0.5389024615287781,
-0.3878459930419922,
-0.5575628280639648,
-0.22400043904781342,
-0.3429724872112274,
0.4244813024997711,
-0.48097649216651917,
-0.4777674973011017,
0.2844200134277344,
-0.27488577365875244,
0.234954833984375,
0.45334726572036743,
-1.0274417400360107,
0.36724093556404114,
0.5174567699432373,
1.0699245929718018,
0.15158259868621826,
-0.03357408568263054,
-0.43545395135879517,
0.13559512794017792,
-0.3211993873119354,
0.5238538980484009,
-0.45719659328460693,
-0.635132908821106,
-0.059345655143260956,
-0.24717475473880768,
0.09058137238025665,
-0.4643552005290985,
0.40518829226493835,
-0.15793916583061218,
0.5889634490013123,
-0.22565282881259918,
-0.42037835717201233,
-0.08810506016016006,
0.7035046219825745,
-0.4222784638404846,
0.7061843872070312,
0.47145718336105347,
-0.6477312445640564,
0.3958231508731842,
-0.7047097086906433,
-0.13998016715049744,
0.30018359422683716,
-0.5763968825340271,
-0.20876511931419373,
0.30937641859054565,
-0.036826688796281815,
0.2654286026954651,
-0.49821344017982483,
0.36489254236221313,
-0.14259910583496094,
-0.43905940651893616,
0.09505430608987808,
-0.4291439354419708,
0.6069049835205078,
0.09540756046772003,
-0.7291851043701172,
-0.20136716961860657,
-0.6510632038116455,
0.09200935065746307,
0.08747025579214096,
-0.3208247721195221,
-0.1732296347618103,
-0.1456494927406311,
-0.08005692064762115,
0.42696404457092285,
0.06783502548933029,
-0.7825391888618469,
-0.07403349131345749,
-0.3319055736064911,
0.4742923080921173,
0.5572016835212708,
0.3431081771850586,
0.07542149722576141,
-0.4177854657173157,
0.7404875755310059,
-0.07324974983930588,
0.17239652574062347,
-0.19671493768692017,
-0.42596235871315,
-0.6758044362068176,
-0.36309364438056946,
-0.023533010855317116,
0.1977054625749588,
-0.7407795190811157,
0.28530263900756836,
-0.2874480187892914,
-0.7140147686004639,
-0.5676296353340149,
0.1581188142299652,
0.6243986487388611,
0.9017794728279114,
0.310449481010437,
-0.38364189863204956,
-0.4140456020832062,
-0.8057429790496826,
-0.022081756964325905,
-0.32199761271476746,
-0.17428681254386902,
0.2845773994922638,
0.4174158275127411,
0.037383195012807846,
0.9878564476966858,
-0.5917333960533142,
-0.39576083421707153,
-0.47066786885261536,
0.4426928162574768,
0.48601120710372925,
0.5236280560493469,
0.711585283279419,
-0.5796179175376892,
-1.0414918661117554,
-0.12059881538152695,
-0.6642061471939087,
-0.1194181740283966,
0.06749820709228516,
-0.07878021895885468,
-0.1354662925004959,
-0.03708064928650856,
-0.4719657301902771,
0.4395766854286194,
0.40341269969940186,
-0.20031552016735077,
0.5956529974937439,
0.08949942886829376,
0.2965930700302124,
-1.0351344347000122,
0.2205643355846405,
-0.1034914180636406,
-0.2024008184671402,
-0.8487564325332642,
-0.19194646179676056,
-0.3950888514518738,
-0.08104587346315384,
-0.4125525653362274,
0.10608194768428802,
-0.5339770317077637,
0.38874107599258423,
-0.41464024782180786,
0.1840575933456421,
0.1770211011171341,
0.5628964900970459,
0.3525652587413788,
0.45453503727912903,
0.3996780514717102,
-0.24263064563274384,
0.3059018552303314,
0.38030362129211426,
-0.35346701741218567,
0.6808192729949951,
-0.8979869484901428,
0.46351736783981323,
0.029529863968491554,
0.3816366493701935,
-1.0364042520523071,
0.087245874106884,
0.08409976214170456,
-0.3180312514305115,
0.2849857211112976,
-0.41367200016975403,
-0.14131422340869904,
-0.17157240211963654,
-0.5053402185440063,
0.3437614142894745,
0.736167848110199,
-0.2472754418849945,
0.5343000292778015,
0.274437814950943,
-0.2897239923477173,
-0.4982440173625946,
-0.6664078235626221,
0.10349003970623016,
-0.32331711053848267,
-0.4900260269641876,
0.15449897944927216,
-0.18649357557296753,
-0.2189863920211792,
-0.176538348197937,
-0.10157627612352371,
0.13648167252540588,
-0.03427349030971527,
0.36008474230766296,
0.5295084118843079,
-0.21501293778419495,
-0.3508817255496979,
-0.05136951431632042,
-0.24339422583580017,
0.10732895880937576,
-0.21413974463939667,
0.6374192237854004,
-0.5313113331794739,
-0.3256174623966217,
-0.5849327445030212,
0.46138569712638855,
0.36554327607154846,
0.06506822258234024,
0.7059613466262817,
0.4950009882450104,
-0.0741763785481453,
-0.07215957343578339,
-0.8868300914764404,
-0.49768221378326416,
-0.47490403056144714,
0.1903444230556488,
-0.45838576555252075,
-1.0022982358932495,
0.3589826822280884,
0.04552876949310303,
0.1256876438856125,
0.10822542011737823,
0.95560222864151,
0.14507754147052765,
1.3002290725708008,
0.5251107811927795,
0.01739465445280075,
0.5946480631828308,
-0.32632267475128174,
0.35064321756362915,
-0.8527211546897888,
0.0006639024941250682,
-0.4421520233154297,
-0.2984693944454193,
-0.4181700646877289,
-0.14533793926239014,
0.6076406240463257,
0.008540637791156769,
-0.037430454045534134,
0.29671376943588257,
-0.9406224489212036,
0.4349171221256256,
0.4535716474056244,
0.045825015753507614,
0.48295721411705017,
-0.26043233275413513,
-0.037842731922864914,
-0.057744480669498444,
-0.2634808123111725,
-0.7844427824020386,
1.0997035503387451,
0.2771212160587311,
0.5287822484970093,
0.2982552647590637,
0.9290716052055359,
0.055873215198516846,
0.9058074355125427,
-0.7708026170730591,
0.5317617654800415,
0.34710514545440674,
-1.0308165550231934,
-0.23595817387104034,
-0.33279842138290405,
-0.6857200860977173,
0.5784190893173218,
0.13435295224189758,
-0.8044394254684448,
0.10388299822807312,
0.3567042648792267,
-0.4086959660053253,
-0.16792932152748108,
-0.6137245297431946,
0.839251697063446,
-0.022937608882784843,
-0.29117700457572937,
-0.28291112184524536,
-0.6496607661247253,
0.6668354868888855,
-0.11426886171102524,
-0.10336021333932877,
-0.22768805921077728,
0.466723769903183,
0.37284693121910095,
-0.6118442416191101,
0.8812416195869446,
-0.6352491974830627,
-0.1400720328092575,
0.5602497458457947,
0.4660544693470001,
0.2652026414871216,
-0.029461544007062912,
0.008567036129534245,
-0.04674629122018814,
0.47540920972824097,
-0.1571386754512787,
-0.7401459813117981,
0.36629265546798706,
-0.5119762420654297,
-0.7275630831718445,
-0.3224656283855438,
-0.19750529527664185,
-0.4792114794254303,
0.24991324543952942,
0.30261439085006714,
0.3285989463329315,
-0.48145702481269836,
0.4652869403362274,
0.28617608547210693,
0.10598502308130264,
0.14782306551933289,
0.9115551114082336,
-0.3187720477581024,
-0.13945166766643524,
0.8270242810249329,
0.018241094425320625,
0.42896464467048645,
0.06386332958936691,
0.4241522550582886,
-0.24811618030071259,
-0.6859884262084961,
-0.19981025159358978,
0.15470781922340393,
-0.5635799765586853,
-0.05952413007616997,
-0.3392372727394104,
-0.12126653641462326,
-0.4076749086380005,
-0.016823438927531242,
-0.46390295028686523,
-0.32645484805107117,
0.041013237088918686,
-0.24405039846897125,
0.05026651546359062,
0.5889438390731812,
-0.07851618528366089,
0.16889828443527222,
-0.7444884181022644,
0.11993541568517685,
0.31858086585998535,
0.12266157567501068,
0.0016110370634123683,
-0.5933039784431458,
-0.23940487205982208,
0.24804182350635529,
-0.5291624069213867,
-0.9380077719688416,
0.43372949957847595,
0.15790227055549622,
0.2830651104450226,
0.4316245913505554,
0.03993404284119606,
0.547299325466156,
-0.647047221660614,
0.9493756294250488,
0.4550359547138214,
-0.9790894389152527,
0.7284646034240723,
-0.51301509141922,
-0.026003720238804817,
1.0752261877059937,
0.17542549967765808,
-0.6143888831138611,
-0.4764505922794342,
-0.4398996829986572,
-0.6507610082626343,
0.6974133253097534,
0.21759943664073944,
0.18043498694896698,
-0.24816209077835083,
0.37628045678138733,
0.14667503535747528,
0.47740647196769714,
-0.7293323874473572,
0.16549262404441833,
-0.6214994788169861,
-0.26046112179756165,
0.04909863695502281,
-0.37125933170318604,
-0.551754355430603,
-0.06836768239736557,
0.7557350397109985,
-0.25144830346107483,
0.14373022317886353,
0.05761328712105751,
0.024571800604462624,
0.0759076476097107,
0.3128927946090698,
0.4316432774066925,
0.4761297404766083,
-0.47576817870140076,
0.12318107485771179,
-0.017609408125281334,
-0.6261053681373596,
0.36893266439437866,
-0.14070740342140198,
-0.14000467956066132,
0.1743786334991455,
0.2391039878129959,
0.6846897006034851,
-0.055809494107961655,
-0.5527490973472595,
0.7982195019721985,
-0.3416244387626648,
-0.3404325544834137,
-0.4475913345813751,
0.1878630369901657,
-0.03775365650653839,
0.1106247529387474,
0.1116417720913887,
-0.32665324211120605,
0.5109124779701233,
-0.6954110860824585,
-0.08353415131568909,
0.34475022554397583,
-0.480103999376297,
-0.44720426201820374,
0.4662770628929138,
0.2776583731174469,
-0.23034504055976868,
0.7370551824569702,
-0.22943434119224548,
-0.3256300687789917,
0.01315986830741167,
0.6391467452049255,
1.1610522270202637,
-0.3162377178668976,
0.35781869292259216,
0.2731730043888092,
-0.07819053530693054,
-0.2569654881954193,
0.3022539019584656,
-0.46866604685783386,
-0.8837168216705322,
-0.5096603035926819,
-0.5734151005744934,
-0.5618135929107666,
0.19919508695602417,
-1.0829174518585205,
-0.08831492811441422,
-0.32427534461021423,
-0.38391706347465515,
-0.014767232351005077,
-0.07380319386720657,
-0.5556601881980896,
-0.10572245717048645,
0.040328867733478546,
0.4472334086894989,
-0.808401346206665,
0.758007824420929,
0.2542327046394348,
-0.7643627524375916,
-1.054960012435913,
-0.23391956090927124,
0.2753840982913971,
-0.6888191103935242,
0.7520667910575867,
0.24003583192825317,
-0.5536410212516785,
-0.15412037074565887,
-0.5576010346412659,
-0.5346300601959229,
1.2386385202407837,
0.6038268804550171,
-0.5731832981109619,
-0.09501472860574722,
0.14295561611652374,
0.8625743985176086,
-0.4371225833892822,
0.3370412290096283,
0.9119459390640259,
0.34669530391693115,
0.3194103538990021,
-1.1486210823059082,
0.19295069575309753,
-0.4708646535873413,
0.24277038872241974,
-0.09335062652826309,
-0.5209053158760071,
0.6437021493911743,
0.04209032282233238,
-0.20256322622299194,
0.132747083902359,
0.09534282982349396,
0.5294573903083801,
0.07990611344575882,
0.6919357776641846,
0.19045709073543549,
0.3868741989135742,
-0.04761747270822525,
0.7558588981628418,
-0.6932951807975769,
0.44998762011528015,
1.447346568107605,
-0.7829862236976624,
0.7623447179794312,
0.5562129020690918,
-0.0991690531373024,
0.6416949033737183,
0.11807587742805481,
0.005720130167901516,
0.6366925239562988,
0.18380773067474365,
-0.5705825090408325,
-0.011201291345059872,
-0.12235124409198761,
-0.3159434199333191,
0.634397029876709,
0.3048781454563141,
-0.47118422389030457,
-0.09749414026737213,
-0.024704894050955772,
0.035886071622371674,
0.038128890097141266,
0.15418767929077148,
0.8590853810310364,
0.12020781636238098,
-1.0043208599090576,
0.7917373776435852,
-0.15076297521591187,
0.24187809228897095,
-0.5081344246864319,
-0.2842526435852051,
-0.07980891317129135,
0.4033466875553131,
-0.030527405440807343,
-0.5512831211090088,
0.23495984077453613,
0.13674834370613098,
-0.09914419054985046,
-0.5452201962471008,
0.41972067952156067,
-0.5467248558998108,
-0.3354176878929138,
0.16791430115699768,
0.506520688533783,
0.39822033047676086,
-0.17634129524230957,
-0.571651041507721,
0.023546317592263222,
0.14856451749801636,
-0.5087487101554871,
0.3275820016860962,
0.32313036918640137,
0.2997637391090393,
0.4178861677646637,
0.5757890939712524,
0.1573561728000641,
-0.29413437843322754,
0.43308350443840027,
0.9538280963897705,
-0.5253074765205383,
-0.3678058981895447,
-0.9555929899215698,
0.5516436696052551,
-0.13013871014118195,
-0.24676921963691711,
0.7679396867752075,
0.45253169536590576,
0.4725567400455475,
-0.041516661643981934,
0.8690364360809326,
-0.12179334461688995,
0.8495725989341736,
-0.3120427429676056,
0.5080897808074951,
-0.07109662890434265,
0.2272542417049408,
-0.5441306829452515,
-0.9136602282524109,
-0.019353223964571953,
0.9615835547447205,
-0.32530272006988525,
0.20676298439502716,
0.6352583169937134,
0.7789201140403748,
0.2296471893787384,
0.19633200764656067,
0.33861997723579407,
0.3092391788959503,
0.817353367805481,
0.6444297432899475,
1.0917510986328125,
-0.04790438339114189,
0.43988513946533203,
-0.23829521238803864,
-0.5348448157310486,
-0.1592286229133606,
-0.8903884887695312,
-0.7969847917556763,
-0.5337743163108826,
-0.3183572590351105,
-0.5712180733680725,
-0.24636556208133698,
0.7802708745002747,
0.8869543075561523,
-0.6524776220321655,
-0.25457534193992615,
-0.2086786925792694,
-0.5880736112594604,
-0.21781609952449799,
-0.24701888859272003,
0.12561960518360138,
-0.29674774408340454,
-0.6123623251914978,
0.4718080759048462,
0.4092409014701843,
-0.09002138674259186,
-0.6641587018966675,
-0.008061117492616177,
0.21668195724487305,
0.034689877182245255,
0.5853462219238281,
0.06043309345841408,
-0.561844527721405,
-0.4987342357635498,
-0.23319955170154572,
0.06530272960662842,
0.06851688772439957,
0.9365271925926208,
-0.683666467666626,
0.5595008730888367,
0.17421285808086395,
0.2599904537200928,
0.975949764251709,
0.1209392249584198,
0.7529869675636292,
-0.6737677454948425,
0.12839575111865997,
0.6599233150482178,
0.4047820270061493,
0.22992603480815887,
-0.18920640647411346,
0.6606751680374146,
-0.040739838033914566,
-0.610069990158081,
-1.0290547609329224,
0.27519673109054565,
-0.9267233610153198,
0.012061450630426407,
0.9404950141906738,
-0.3392273783683777,
0.0896991640329361,
-0.175090491771698,
-0.6129974126815796,
0.10485387593507767,
-0.3638189435005188,
1.0972925424575806,
0.8129427433013916,
-0.4353812634944916,
-0.06086130440235138,
-0.47892677783966064,
0.4974956512451172,
0.3529931902885437,
-0.35227999091148376,
0.06906747817993164,
0.7135809063911438,
0.6318399310112,
0.45892274379730225,
1.1184014081954956,
-0.3012005686759949,
0.14510969817638397,
0.19721661508083344,
0.20658795535564423,
0.0602637454867363,
0.02465561032295227,
-0.23223015666007996,
0.3134227395057678,
0.34004509449005127,
-0.21088197827339172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01786v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01786v2 | COA-GPT: Generative Pre-trained Transformers for Accelerated Course of Action Development in Military Operations | 2024-02-01T21:51:09 | 2024-03-28T15:22:42 | Vinicius G. Goecks, Nicholas Waytowich | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG, I.2.6; I.2.7; J.7 | The development of Courses of Action (COAs) in military operations is
traditionally a time-consuming and intricate process. Addressing this
challenge, this study introduces COA-GPT, a novel algorithm employing Large
Language Models (LLMs) for rapid and efficient generation of valid COAs.
COA-GPT incorporates military doctrine and domain expertise to LLMs through
in-context learning, allowing commanders to input mission information - in both
text and image formats - and receive strategically aligned COAs for review and
approval. Uniquely, COA-GPT not only accelerates COA development, producing
initial COAs within seconds, but also facilitates real-time refinement based on
commander feedback. This work evaluates COA-GPT in a military-relevant scenario
within a militarized version of the StarCraft II game, comparing its
performance against state-of-the-art reinforcement learning algorithms. Our
results demonstrate COA-GPT's superiority in generating strategically sound
COAs more swiftly, with added benefits of enhanced adaptability and alignment
with commander intentions. COA-GPT's capability to rapidly adapt and update
COAs during missions presents a transformative potential for military planning,
particularly in addressing planning discrepancies and capitalizing on emergent
windows of opportunities. | [
-0.43958672881126404,
-1.0622285604476929,
0.5812779664993286,
0.5051810145378113,
-0.27169525623321533,
0.5042666792869568,
-0.28362563252449036,
0.09998784959316254,
0.05236855521798134,
0.46874892711639404,
-0.9045587778091431,
-0.335940420627594,
-0.575017511844635,
-0.15093353390693665,
-0.1028338298201561,
1.2022948265075684,
-0.2646522521972656,
-0.2367449551820755,
0.21929390728473663,
0.029676180332899094,
-0.6922702193260193,
-0.6959107518196106,
-1.1013051271438599,
-0.1731678992509842,
0.09095898270606995,
0.2576121985912323,
0.7397648692131042,
0.5597971677780151,
0.7912185192108154,
0.30641674995422363,
0.2453026920557022,
0.37051430344581604,
-0.6179389953613281,
0.04350607842206955,
-0.3209211826324463,
0.02097754180431366,
-0.5659515857696533,
-0.03808906301856041,
0.32567834854125977,
0.25863608717918396,
-0.2593698799610138,
0.1594783514738083,
-0.20996877551078796,
0.4756122827529907,
-0.4632052183151245,
0.42257604002952576,
-0.5492479801177979,
0.05096015706658363,
0.14524860680103302,
-0.289470911026001,
-0.326250821352005,
0.05232209712266922,
0.5751276612281799,
-0.9784262776374817,
0.1824360489845276,
0.1090903952717781,
0.4688915014266968,
0.18646761775016785,
-0.18121635913848877,
-0.3877912163734436,
-0.9132382869720459,
0.5402294993400574,
-0.23145760595798492,
0.3900894522666931,
0.1693643182516098,
0.36918026208877563,
-0.4317798614501953,
-0.889788031578064,
-0.35883739590644836,
-0.20164388418197632,
0.15716205537319183,
0.6259221434593201,
0.02700209803879261,
0.0483098030090332,
0.3347451686859131,
-0.019530897960066795,
-0.6988972425460815,
0.17282143235206604,
-0.3200682997703552,
-0.04198267310857773,
0.7584770321846008,
0.2196957767009735,
-0.11224658042192459,
0.12482339888811111,
-0.6798130869865417,
-0.16523650288581848,
-0.8284091949462891,
0.21607205271720886,
0.1468796581029892,
-0.00584493950009346,
-0.5053772926330566,
0.5131180882453918,
-0.19662164151668549,
0.4124228358268738,
0.42260774970054626,
-0.03899316489696503,
-0.4292655885219574,
0.027698399499058723,
-0.3567960560321808,
0.032402317970991135,
0.6915419101715088,
0.15534937381744385,
0.11730612814426422,
0.041967906057834625,
-0.3546322286128998,
0.24519020318984985,
0.587995707988739,
-0.7479748725891113,
-0.21191950142383575,
0.1403275579214096,
-0.33174872398376465,
-0.5248870849609375,
0.08630292117595673,
-0.5619800686836243,
-0.23951570689678192,
-0.3662085235118866,
0.28549128770828247,
-0.38243675231933594,
-0.29199329018592834,
-0.07813652604818344,
0.08152412623167038,
0.37214815616607666,
0.22988329827785492,
-0.7450194954872131,
0.004231987986713648,
0.6801465153694153,
0.7408188581466675,
-0.4331265091896057,
-0.2285175621509552,
-0.8925813436508179,
0.2964847981929779,
-0.4696906507015228,
0.7992057800292969,
-0.6403872966766357,
-0.8691986799240112,
0.17884060740470886,
-0.1949571967124939,
0.28207123279571533,
-0.4947330355644226,
0.47207367420196533,
-0.8306320309638977,
-0.10779979825019836,
-0.0756097361445427,
-0.27553790807724,
-0.10638242959976196,
0.3695918619632721,
-0.3638536334037781,
0.852623701095581,
0.3802242577075958,
-0.1787782460451126,
0.6117987036705017,
-0.8900474309921265,
-0.6946094036102295,
0.3032275438308716,
-0.24295400083065033,
-0.6012193560600281,
0.07679633796215057,
0.41872379183769226,
0.5432421565055847,
-0.3995201289653778,
0.2517383098602295,
-0.09776677191257477,
-0.36383292078971863,
0.06485085934400558,
-0.34561410546302795,
0.31511932611465454,
0.18730364739894867,
-0.5870844721794128,
0.4751676619052887,
-0.39145684242248535,
0.09203831106424332,
0.0699295699596405,
-0.3152902126312256,
0.1768116056919098,
0.29031097888946533,
-0.43063509464263916,
0.42696624994277954,
-0.10174418240785599,
0.042949337512254715,
0.5605258941650391,
-0.257676362991333,
0.3466986119747162,
0.9714080095291138,
0.30405089259147644,
0.5525218844413757,
-0.11132582277059555,
0.5921959280967712,
-0.008847859688103199,
0.5936852097511292,
0.003538554534316063,
-0.38291850686073303,
-0.8724188804626465,
-0.21875132620334625,
0.017081715166568756,
0.599087655544281,
-1.2770583629608154,
0.3870132267475128,
-0.23583827912807465,
-0.6142734289169312,
-0.053118254989385605,
-0.06508281826972961,
0.38537731766700745,
0.31600823998451233,
0.6236535310745239,
-0.5553211569786072,
-0.45835402607917786,
-0.31063055992126465,
-0.06221986189484596,
-0.47967100143432617,
0.15126252174377441,
0.02686697617173195,
0.4471193850040436,
-0.2208358645439148,
0.6203134059906006,
-0.5739856958389282,
-0.16482862830162048,
-0.3727225661277771,
0.45907288789749146,
-0.3377779722213745,
0.26541855931282043,
0.221808522939682,
-0.8132904767990112,
-0.495195597410202,
0.12322356551885605,
-0.845257580280304,
0.18465764820575714,
-0.36257338523864746,
-0.20268037915229797,
0.006163730286061764,
0.5794480443000793,
-0.5389618873596191,
0.6009578704833984,
0.37297365069389343,
-0.18955330550670624,
0.6181979179382324,
-0.22215373814105988,
0.20352323353290558,
-0.5718347430229187,
-0.06292900443077087,
-0.3971079885959625,
0.07375284284353256,
-0.7799700498580933,
0.2322736382484436,
-0.03908204659819603,
-0.4910756051540375,
-0.6235440373420715,
0.3750643730163574,
-0.3907257318496704,
-0.05590343847870827,
-0.3674836754798889,
0.14244788885116577,
-0.44747331738471985,
0.7298603057861328,
0.38425561785697937,
0.9771580100059509,
0.4553319215774536,
-1.0135282278060913,
0.33516407012939453,
0.34993356466293335,
-0.03397306427359581,
0.7040298581123352,
-0.4857659935951233,
0.15396441519260406,
-0.00147536292206496,
0.431781142950058,
-0.37650901079177856,
-0.07343143969774246,
0.11448077112436295,
-0.03299858793616295,
0.11835440993309021,
-0.27929386496543884,
-0.046537164598703384,
-0.3147115409374237,
0.12792715430259705,
0.3933083415031433,
0.7421574592590332,
-0.4115263819694519,
0.7601288557052612,
0.2092977613210678,
-0.0784032866358757,
-0.5424367785453796,
-0.1311304122209549,
-0.3467746078968048,
-0.09638166427612305,
-0.26964911818504333,
0.2785286009311676,
-0.07470180839300156,
-0.005984741263091564,
-0.25943657755851746,
-0.24243347346782684,
0.05675336718559265,
-0.015323207713663578,
0.4750683009624481,
0.3413354456424713,
0.031029272824525833,
-0.0420474037528038,
-0.11829278618097305,
-0.12098725885152817,
-0.03039085865020752,
-0.5516608357429504,
0.8006718754768372,
-0.07560397684574127,
-0.45053309202194214,
-0.029487794265151024,
0.369920939207077,
0.4221765995025635,
-0.6866241693496704,
0.1763373613357544,
0.8042944669723511,
0.21368099749088287,
-0.4851476848125458,
-0.4261665940284729,
-0.06044875830411911,
-0.526443362236023,
0.3339804708957672,
-0.27070024609565735,
-0.6625096201896667,
0.1832374483346939,
-0.7384305596351624,
0.3286394476890564,
0.4478453993797302,
0.4234350621700287,
-0.04397863149642944,
0.7719660401344299,
0.6892826557159424,
0.0879402756690979,
0.5382886528968811,
-0.473258912563324,
0.18304188549518585,
-0.7308262586593628,
-0.23461295664310455,
0.14395907521247864,
-0.2988739609718323,
-0.57419753074646,
-0.661274790763855,
0.6300650835037231,
-0.03946369141340256,
-0.538346529006958,
0.1585276871919632,
-0.32314062118530273,
0.2992979884147644,
0.16371126472949982,
0.07267219573259354,
-0.08809477090835571,
0.21308119595050812,
0.07372996211051941,
0.17869584262371063,
-0.8231593370437622,
-0.15998853743076324,
1.0492188930511475,
0.02799944579601288,
0.5651687979698181,
0.12919582426548004,
0.7248936891555786,
0.4374867379665375,
0.7185433506965637,
-0.7862191200256348,
0.5853278040885925,
-0.2996574640274048,
-0.2660317122936249,
-0.242568239569664,
-0.23025313019752502,
-0.6591441631317139,
-0.18297290802001953,
-0.4899978041648865,
0.1992943286895752,
-0.05343914031982422,
0.06001538038253784,
-0.4449995756149292,
0.2140565663576126,
-0.6132668852806091,
0.6291525363922119,
-0.4517674148082733,
-0.4196561574935913,
-0.23503535985946655,
-0.6182882785797119,
0.10412115603685379,
-0.33332428336143494,
-0.04476121813058853,
0.19515380263328552,
-0.1475575566291809,
0.4872218370437622,
-0.27573445439338684,
0.46359795331954956,
-0.3974663317203522,
-0.10575585812330246,
0.6719650030136108,
0.3162986636161804,
0.956142783164978,
0.20925372838974,
0.0517767034471035,
-0.01198627706617117,
-0.7655579447746277,
-0.34073394536972046,
-0.9034278392791748,
0.540504515171051,
-0.6940057277679443,
-0.6560709476470947,
-0.41628599166870117,
-0.48652076721191406,
-0.32289785146713257,
0.23485445976257324,
0.18077564239501953,
0.2766951620578766,
-0.6821123361587524,
-0.17582449316978455,
0.6909602880477905,
-0.2765789031982422,
0.41554608941078186,
0.6939305067062378,
-0.10179217904806137,
-0.39098066091537476,
0.9159870147705078,
0.0802525132894516,
0.5462031364440918,
0.3438858985900879,
-0.11499174684286118,
-0.18394501507282257,
-0.5654726624488831,
-0.5709760785102844,
-0.009240793995559216,
-0.3803084194660187,
-0.22680209577083588,
-0.12308253347873688,
-0.23830781877040863,
0.09065581858158112,
-0.6204978823661804,
-0.4076560437679291,
-0.18901856243610382,
0.09309777617454529,
0.010377629660069942,
0.25875324010849,
0.9494182467460632,
0.1338156908750534,
0.6638669371604919,
-0.35551226139068604,
0.4066300094127655,
0.18876275420188904,
0.2526267468929291,
-0.35592225193977356,
-0.36261266469955444,
-0.10495907068252563,
0.09093895554542542,
-0.6808099746704102,
-0.4157566726207733,
0.19222775101661682,
0.13819359242916107,
0.2649673819541931,
0.23544587194919586,
-0.17011718451976776,
1.0429927110671997,
-0.6824764013290405,
0.9965517520904541,
0.16215212643146515,
-0.7591454982757568,
0.5854712128639221,
-0.26295390725135803,
0.3297995328903198,
0.22623661160469055,
0.5052309632301331,
-0.13873893022537231,
-0.24558475613594055,
-0.9282724261283875,
-0.6321511268615723,
0.4455615282058716,
0.11408677697181702,
-0.1901382952928543,
-0.16597312688827515,
0.35793551802635193,
-0.13583675026893616,
0.06252555549144745,
-0.12613578140735626,
-0.1576705127954483,
-0.3764820098876953,
0.17364180088043213,
-0.24657540023326874,
0.052835170179605484,
-0.21026423573493958,
0.023682037368416786,
0.8158406615257263,
-0.18943752348423004,
0.4319416880607605,
0.2827662229537964,
-0.232761412858963,
0.1532304286956787,
0.34109705686569214,
1.0537569522857666,
0.44772225618362427,
0.10112780332565308,
-0.07303472608327866,
0.5888327360153198,
-0.7141848206520081,
0.4926038980484009,
-0.14713145792484283,
-0.09782291203737259,
-0.3751353323459625,
0.32803258299827576,
0.822524905204773,
0.14571289718151093,
-0.46441060304641724,
0.6216217875480652,
0.05757918581366539,
-0.3109563887119293,
-0.3649541139602661,
-0.08258260041475296,
-0.3273189961910248,
0.33164772391319275,
0.11559701710939407,
0.4668055474758148,
-0.18007996678352356,
-0.5564501881599426,
0.3642556369304657,
0.29807424545288086,
-0.5843100547790527,
-0.23061294853687286,
0.5752962827682495,
0.34774503111839294,
-0.22065278887748718,
0.5744490027427673,
-0.3843979239463806,
-0.5220740437507629,
0.29197046160697937,
0.6980370879173279,
0.9971635341644287,
-0.39953547716140747,
0.4314393401145935,
0.26640528440475464,
0.2917283773422241,
-0.1747085005044937,
0.2688956558704376,
0.18386274576187134,
-0.18228866159915924,
-0.5265933871269226,
-0.630217432975769,
-0.10999086499214172,
0.16586962342262268,
-0.2542591094970703,
0.3790545165538788,
-0.9680725932121277,
-0.290837824344635,
-0.5863319039344788,
-0.14150100946426392,
-0.99266117811203,
0.2693270444869995,
-0.2129247635602951,
0.6898019313812256,
-0.48748818039894104,
0.5162412524223328,
0.4994661211967468,
-0.5741649270057678,
-1.106397271156311,
0.19364961981773376,
-0.17807798087596893,
-0.8877575397491455,
0.9806383848190308,
-0.3782130181789398,
-0.3215855062007904,
0.08087199926376343,
-0.12167967855930328,
-0.6076090335845947,
1.1939359903335571,
0.0061983210034668446,
-0.4859735071659088,
-0.12750355899333954,
0.3816479444503784,
0.4746171236038208,
-0.4885207712650299,
0.2523690462112427,
0.5706971287727356,
0.46083489060401917,
-0.08733250200748444,
-0.7244896292686462,
0.029736731201410294,
0.21223729848861694,
-0.008257066830992699,
0.32367366552352905,
-0.9129967093467712,
0.6640084385871887,
-0.313915878534317,
-0.3161618113517761,
-0.18049174547195435,
0.9235718250274658,
0.21476946771144867,
-0.09564513713121414,
0.48726287484169006,
0.4434904456138611,
0.3530811071395874,
-0.295245885848999,
0.9442573189735413,
-0.106868214905262,
0.12257761508226395,
0.6393147706985474,
-0.38612595200538635,
0.8578876852989197,
0.1903040111064911,
-0.06876708567142487,
0.6021677255630493,
0.2526349127292633,
-0.12633351981639862,
0.6835033893585205,
0.2394256889820099,
-0.5442454218864441,
-0.11778037995100021,
0.12491939216852188,
-0.3220072090625763,
0.5741333961486816,
0.3028365969657898,
-0.22429963946342468,
-0.05745553597807884,
-0.07996060699224472,
0.09588249027729034,
-0.15330204367637634,
-0.6360459327697754,
0.9504931569099426,
-0.1252886801958084,
-0.9821026921272278,
0.6958070993423462,
-0.015844915062189102,
0.5020518898963928,
-1.0201432704925537,
-0.2836759090423584,
-0.14933517575263977,
0.1929728090763092,
-0.22770456969738007,
-0.7259616851806641,
0.09150996804237366,
0.05973305553197861,
-0.05458388477563858,
-0.14441093802452087,
0.43306413292884827,
-0.3672944903373718,
-0.30865249037742615,
0.02137181907892227,
0.40165334939956665,
-0.18574774265289307,
-0.03352392464876175,
-0.5930249094963074,
0.2923845648765564,
-0.0893329307436943,
-0.04760061204433441,
0.24548977613449097,
0.4113618731498718,
-0.5423078536987305,
0.6585420966148376,
0.8210393190383911,
0.1342639923095703,
0.020605070516467094,
-0.14251112937927246,
0.8036567568778992,
-0.29669931530952454,
-0.5005480647087097,
-0.7074564099311829,
0.5900648236274719,
-0.12350311875343323,
-0.3501225411891937,
0.4227304458618164,
0.6120597124099731,
0.8821694850921631,
-0.4279712438583374,
1.0386000871658325,
-0.21332614123821259,
-0.1407725214958191,
-0.6547896862030029,
0.6236966252326965,
-0.04436630755662918,
0.2992316484451294,
-0.03665827214717865,
-0.7705498933792114,
-0.22950775921344757,
0.41354626417160034,
-0.42317497730255127,
-0.08346578478813171,
0.7127295136451721,
0.6813655495643616,
-0.41436415910720825,
-0.13104453682899475,
0.15395739674568176,
-0.24490904808044434,
0.7913808822631836,
0.5722147226333618,
0.7608156204223633,
-0.508174479007721,
0.6015434265136719,
-0.10415290296077728,
-0.39964115619659424,
-0.005389147438108921,
-0.811692476272583,
-0.9259160757064819,
-0.4301776587963104,
-0.04843955114483833,
-0.1342385858297348,
0.3992387652397156,
0.9644315242767334,
0.7344759702682495,
-0.4793122708797455,
-0.3856198787689209,
-0.14179563522338867,
-0.3493150770664215,
-0.6661454439163208,
-0.16615064442157745,
0.5912062525749207,
-0.4536871314048767,
-0.2219177484512329,
0.7323046922683716,
0.25328540802001953,
-0.06859772652387619,
-0.14376585185527802,
-0.5256267189979553,
-0.033239711076021194,
0.137647807598114,
1.1559137105941772,
0.4561004936695099,
-0.6583850979804993,
-0.5171592831611633,
0.06510326266288757,
0.2689698040485382,
-0.1887732297182083,
1.2552720308303833,
-0.72658771276474,
0.3727165758609772,
0.0530928298830986,
0.7852978110313416,
0.5671916604042053,
0.13401035964488983,
0.7996399998664856,
-0.956485390663147,
0.3233529031276703,
0.13376173377037048,
-0.05337867885828018,
-0.007518874481320381,
-0.31194716691970825,
0.7189558148384094,
0.13384126126766205,
-0.6350681781768799,
-0.4688222408294678,
0.6623678803443909,
-1.0259538888931274,
0.1359371393918991,
1.0478882789611816,
-0.1592521220445633,
0.22028164565563202,
0.07944676280021667,
-0.5438542366027832,
0.3574754595756531,
-0.2320677787065506,
0.5581540465354919,
0.6036387085914612,
-0.16217248141765594,
0.18166396021842957,
-0.45997652411460876,
1.07341730594635,
0.22710402309894562,
-0.9817530512809753,
0.20281565189361572,
0.2719845771789551,
0.12025199830532074,
-0.03582493215799332,
0.4451930522918701,
-0.10576805472373962,
0.5049214363098145,
-0.06691576540470123,
-0.2280445098876953,
-0.29703575372695923,
-0.49908608198165894,
0.12482303380966187,
0.19169382750988007,
-0.055537350475788116,
0.38579466938972473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01035v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01035v2 | Getting the most out of your tokenizer for pre-training and domain adaptation | 2024-02-01T21:49:34 | 2024-02-07T10:51:11 | Gautier Dagan, Gabriel Synnaeve, Baptiste Rozière | cs.CL | cs.CL | Tokenization is an understudied and often neglected component of modern LLMs.
Most published works use a single tokenizer for all experiments, often borrowed
from another model, without performing ablations or analysis to optimize
tokenization. Moreover, the tokenizer is generally kept unchanged when
fine-tuning a base model. In this paper, we show that the size,
pre-tokenization regular expression, and training data of a tokenizer can
significantly impact the model's generation speed, effective context size,
memory usage, and downstream performance. We train specialized Byte-Pair
Encoding code tokenizers, and conduct extensive ablations on the impact of
tokenizer design on the performance of LLMs for code generation tasks such as
HumanEval and MBPP, and provide recommendations for tokenizer hyper-parameters
selection and switching the tokenizer in a pre-trained LLM. We perform our
experiments on models trained from scratch and from pre-trained models,
verifying their applicability to a wide range of use-cases. We find that when
fine-tuning on more than 50 billion tokens, we can specialize the tokenizer of
a pre-trained LLM to obtain large gains in generation speed and effective
context size. | [
-0.5226079821586609,
-0.42804667353630066,
0.12464191764593124,
0.17165666818618774,
-0.6596969366073608,
0.07852786779403687,
-0.32899436354637146,
-0.45316165685653687,
0.12480179220438004,
0.37820908427238464,
-0.17835822701454163,
-0.39167433977127075,
-0.7476339340209961,
0.14482922852039337,
-0.05150840803980827,
1.152153730392456,
0.03309425711631775,
0.14023183286190033,
-0.2518785297870636,
0.04188546910881996,
-0.6678432822227478,
-1.1058284044265747,
-0.5825921297073364,
-0.10788940638303757,
0.5342873930931091,
0.1829642504453659,
0.36712846159935,
0.7595096826553345,
0.5911033749580383,
0.27036482095718384,
-0.1337321549654007,
0.13034886121749878,
-0.6234104037284851,
-0.12681397795677185,
-0.001616861904039979,
-0.5387908816337585,
-0.6275563836097717,
0.0031059877946972847,
0.49700379371643066,
0.6122690439224243,
0.19858765602111816,
0.5369755029678345,
-0.08138256520032883,
0.39518481492996216,
-0.8217591643333435,
-0.1790565401315689,
-0.9296957850456238,
0.09159177541732788,
-0.31204086542129517,
-0.4325859248638153,
-0.47054609656333923,
-0.10400919616222382,
-0.32731005549430847,
-0.5877441167831421,
0.2787149250507355,
0.14995642006397247,
0.6274138689041138,
0.351657509803772,
-0.4548397362232208,
-0.014586791396141052,
-0.8287439942359924,
0.854008138179779,
-0.670768141746521,
0.577686071395874,
0.14265725016593933,
0.05831800028681755,
-0.2915952801704407,
-1.0742812156677246,
-0.3927208483219147,
-0.05263855680823326,
-0.11835318058729172,
-0.06006055697798729,
-0.08470419049263,
0.3680286705493927,
0.5259877443313599,
0.2416182905435562,
-0.39106571674346924,
0.2262275516986847,
-0.2763153612613678,
-0.4545815885066986,
0.3901561498641968,
0.10294961929321289,
0.08478119224309921,
0.1884087324142456,
-0.3995162546634674,
0.19163723289966583,
-0.9659757614135742,
0.12178883701562881,
0.24429352581501007,
0.22958414256572723,
0.35252296924591064,
0.3989691138267517,
0.08798317611217499,
0.8425766229629517,
0.27295801043510437,
0.11724301427602768,
0.09728442877531052,
-0.6049268245697021,
-0.2879587411880493,
-0.1644105315208435,
0.37869924306869507,
0.2607029378414154,
0.3145812749862671,
-0.31308767199516296,
-0.433716744184494,
-0.021787961944937706,
0.45870286226272583,
-1.2576591968536377,
-0.05527229607105255,
0.12314798682928085,
-0.6290801167488098,
-0.18522821366786957,
-0.03304995968937874,
-0.3408088684082031,
-0.2282574325799942,
-0.3618730306625366,
0.38091549277305603,
-0.046540919691324234,
-0.15394949913024902,
0.20626778900623322,
-0.22487254440784454,
0.21828702092170715,
0.05753832310438156,
-1.1582579612731934,
0.281572163105011,
0.8437098264694214,
0.7296925783157349,
-0.470065712928772,
-0.4299825429916382,
-0.9170439839363098,
0.0315757691860199,
-0.5045508742332458,
0.6540733575820923,
-0.4471205174922943,
-0.5101671814918518,
-0.08248092979192734,
-0.084780253469944,
-0.14703483879566193,
-0.705675482749939,
0.18203204870224,
-0.8477829098701477,
-0.25773099064826965,
-0.2594471871852875,
-0.7149418592453003,
0.2289269119501114,
-0.009982294403016567,
-0.37147554755210876,
0.6814978718757629,
0.05038992315530777,
-0.6178234219551086,
0.9374855756759644,
-0.6888726949691772,
-0.516923725605011,
0.10909314453601837,
-0.0069643352180719376,
-0.28052106499671936,
0.8405828475952148,
0.05497342720627785,
0.5828489065170288,
0.1325613558292389,
0.21763840317726135,
-0.0614086389541626,
-0.6911572813987732,
0.292324960231781,
-0.16740365326404572,
0.35826101899147034,
0.20238320529460907,
-0.2372208833694458,
0.3777240216732025,
-0.8409451246261597,
-0.05306296423077583,
-0.11630243062973022,
-0.6724328994750977,
-0.16464991867542267,
-0.18048207461833954,
0.3579014837741852,
0.06683488190174103,
0.27938565611839294,
-0.5371156334877014,
0.28215500712394714,
-0.25950101017951965,
0.34393638372421265,
0.9733174443244934,
0.20643655955791473,
0.40604421496391296,
-0.2372904270887375,
0.5605618953704834,
0.1799621433019638,
0.29843196272850037,
-0.1930905431509018,
-0.13433320820331573,
-0.7650130391120911,
-0.4578900933265686,
0.7434258460998535,
0.007416079752147198,
-0.3033643960952759,
0.46660810708999634,
-0.25854405760765076,
-0.30845052003860474,
-0.28936484456062317,
0.272680401802063,
0.3188018202781677,
0.2771814465522766,
0.24522405862808228,
-0.6568378806114197,
-0.6790677905082703,
-0.7266837954521179,
-0.5252357721328735,
0.11128226667642593,
0.025581838563084602,
0.1315690279006958,
0.6285352110862732,
-0.31023523211479187,
1.0118753910064697,
-0.40329086780548096,
-0.11043085902929306,
-0.18495121598243713,
-0.10115543752908707,
0.16046814620494843,
0.7877907156944275,
0.60062575340271,
-0.7851384878158569,
-0.40644535422325134,
-0.09666546434164047,
-0.15356504917144775,
0.06193764507770538,
-0.306065171957016,
-0.4201976954936981,
0.009232776239514351,
0.5477607250213623,
-0.4206080734729767,
0.34415388107299805,
0.3850451409816742,
-0.40012672543525696,
0.5659976601600647,
-0.281986266374588,
-0.05740322172641754,
-1.0583745241165161,
0.28736481070518494,
-0.40162670612335205,
-0.29226091504096985,
-0.8756766319274902,
0.19710226356983185,
0.048101507127285004,
0.003505850210785866,
-0.5648348927497864,
0.7253724932670593,
-0.45954132080078125,
-0.26985111832618713,
-0.3107219934463501,
-0.23983721435070038,
-0.05760328844189644,
0.50882887840271,
-0.030222203582525253,
1.1188557147979736,
0.36624881625175476,
-0.7751955389976501,
0.07458534091711044,
0.1417880654335022,
-0.21558110415935516,
0.03447161987423897,
-0.6892284750938416,
0.4922276735305786,
0.11593282967805862,
0.059127580374479294,
-0.7184131145477295,
-0.08648547530174255,
-0.14362552762031555,
-0.3624017536640167,
0.3945366442203522,
-0.4052717387676239,
-0.5733820796012878,
-0.1532319337129593,
-0.2748843729496002,
0.47260910272598267,
0.5767351388931274,
-0.7276120185852051,
0.8257914781570435,
0.26896411180496216,
0.1992589682340622,
-0.6332102417945862,
-0.5443668365478516,
0.05660250410437584,
-0.2575836181640625,
-0.35593047738075256,
0.39357060194015503,
-0.46758440136909485,
0.20274938642978668,
-0.2679717242717743,
-0.44929152727127075,
-0.05526948347687721,
0.584421694278717,
0.4569154679775238,
0.1577005833387375,
-0.21692384779453278,
0.0632203221321106,
0.10869588702917099,
-0.26606085896492004,
0.05821668356657028,
-0.5108015537261963,
0.7349542379379272,
-0.010387283749878407,
-0.3124235272407532,
-0.2738092243671417,
0.032181769609451294,
0.5555801391601562,
-0.43677622079849243,
0.8577001690864563,
0.6434951424598694,
-0.24454446136951447,
-0.15382665395736694,
-0.5606736540794373,
-0.151678204536438,
-0.5029535293579102,
0.5908686518669128,
-0.7011744976043701,
-0.8555248975753784,
0.5508573651313782,
-0.49622759222984314,
0.3165389597415924,
-0.014973768964409828,
0.5997294783592224,
0.2743809223175049,
1.0693292617797852,
0.9349689483642578,
-0.21904709935188293,
0.8450314402580261,
-0.24248501658439636,
0.1206938624382019,
-0.8754687309265137,
0.07040439546108246,
-0.2880476117134094,
-0.2745184600353241,
-0.3818792998790741,
-0.3998735845088959,
0.01806786097586155,
0.3495107889175415,
-0.12577281892299652,
0.12177539616823196,
-0.39224541187286377,
0.6708080172538757,
0.5262752771377563,
-0.048669327050447464,
0.12972858548164368,
0.0414358414709568,
0.11770933866500854,
0.08323682099580765,
-0.6704980731010437,
-0.5882799625396729,
1.3834507465362549,
0.2600368857383728,
0.4260246455669403,
0.03613739088177681,
0.9301106333732605,
0.26735419034957886,
0.5016529560089111,
-0.8235284686088562,
0.5012825131416321,
-0.1604475975036621,
-0.6152295470237732,
-0.023907991126179695,
-0.35843467712402344,
-0.9913337826728821,
0.2747015655040741,
-0.2041575312614441,
-0.357228547334671,
0.1604968011379242,
0.3902781009674072,
-0.4352807104587555,
0.1708602011203766,
-0.6255873441696167,
0.9845378994941711,
-0.16733263432979584,
-0.12044216692447662,
-0.1586199253797531,
-0.38703590631484985,
0.0407271645963192,
-0.5950480103492737,
0.10630974173545837,
0.17489831149578094,
-0.2618217170238495,
0.7432423233985901,
-0.26925861835479736,
0.8638494610786438,
-0.43290984630584717,
0.15533402562141418,
0.0627235546708107,
-0.03610667958855629,
0.43683475255966187,
-0.07977624237537384,
-0.03404867649078369,
0.2361135482788086,
-0.004111127462238073,
-0.6298046112060547,
-0.5968049168586731,
0.38364237546920776,
-0.8451464772224426,
-0.833607017993927,
0.15566276013851166,
-0.21059603989124298,
-0.17610414326190948,
0.4886707067489624,
0.40949422121047974,
0.49943163990974426,
-0.3182704448699951,
0.09106919914484024,
0.4597228765487671,
-0.055533405393362045,
0.3240708112716675,
0.2999410033226013,
-0.22418054938316345,
-0.3132304251194,
1.000769853591919,
-0.040660105645656586,
0.28206345438957214,
0.15797476470470428,
0.2022223025560379,
0.01639246568083763,
-1.0602918863296509,
-0.46253469586372375,
0.12924283742904663,
-0.8350174427032471,
-0.22096027433872223,
-0.5826482772827148,
-0.07322539389133453,
-0.5464445948600769,
-0.33216920495033264,
-0.3227764368057251,
-0.3046109974384308,
-0.48347461223602295,
-0.2642175853252411,
0.10364875197410583,
0.5947254300117493,
-0.016222044825553894,
0.5517835021018982,
-0.9010862708091736,
0.11702337116003036,
0.21429628133773804,
0.3291442096233368,
-0.09958302229642868,
-0.6796194911003113,
-0.5690105557441711,
-0.2561297118663788,
0.10451524704694748,
-0.4288652241230011,
0.08104922622442245,
0.3143388032913208,
0.5329206585884094,
0.37683266401290894,
-0.17037945985794067,
0.8383175134658813,
-0.6083844304084778,
0.8151097297668457,
0.03577108681201935,
-1.1822270154953003,
0.3169780373573303,
0.1198490783572197,
0.10793597996234894,
0.5816462635993958,
0.21443644165992737,
-0.5297102928161621,
-0.0694437175989151,
-0.25046366453170776,
-0.7768889665603638,
0.4549652934074402,
-0.01160995289683342,
0.5569660663604736,
-0.042445506900548935,
0.8573204874992371,
0.3261297047138214,
0.4193545877933502,
-0.576999843120575,
-0.1959267407655716,
-0.1661294549703598,
-0.12068811804056168,
-0.1975678950548172,
-0.38220804929733276,
-0.1125950738787651,
-0.26775017380714417,
0.5080007314682007,
-0.2766577899456024,
0.2709777355194092,
-0.22486822307109833,
-0.5660974383354187,
-0.06248566135764122,
0.03058292530477047,
0.6496771574020386,
0.7213366627693176,
-0.024122821167111397,
0.15726672112941742,
0.3885202407836914,
-0.633244514465332,
0.062029819935560226,
-0.09377036988735199,
0.10381234437227249,
-0.043193917721509933,
0.4723125994205475,
0.9582861065864563,
0.14574836194515228,
-0.603306233882904,
0.6810933947563171,
-0.19732508063316345,
-0.14719848334789276,
0.032692428678274155,
0.3109291195869446,
-0.1351453959941864,
0.16394975781440735,
0.1643703728914261,
0.3377227485179901,
-0.05340806767344475,
-0.2722945213317871,
0.19304059445858002,
0.41166162490844727,
0.011704239062964916,
-0.43938183784484863,
0.6084821820259094,
0.3071712851524353,
-0.2433716207742691,
0.33094003796577454,
-0.03469168022274971,
-0.587527871131897,
0.5901588201522827,
0.6645373702049255,
0.8559021353721619,
0.06329365819692612,
-0.2324678897857666,
0.07409374415874481,
0.0875476747751236,
0.15361525118350983,
0.005519350059330463,
-0.4043811559677124,
-0.7926186323165894,
-0.5332159996032715,
-0.8564998507499695,
-0.20288288593292236,
-0.08001796156167984,
-0.6298973560333252,
0.17963217198848724,
-0.6099233627319336,
-0.565201997756958,
-0.09887083619832993,
0.11594764143228531,
-0.9558072686195374,
0.10939894616603851,
0.030077170580625534,
1.045607089996338,
-0.7908387780189514,
0.6736425161361694,
0.9753231406211853,
-0.24160560965538025,
-0.5792272686958313,
-0.07924343645572662,
-0.4054866135120392,
-0.817398726940155,
1.0143240690231323,
0.12100555747747421,
-0.0607731007039547,
0.3248210549354553,
-0.3832072615623474,
-0.8714088797569275,
0.9190691709518433,
0.18909235298633575,
-0.5529427528381348,
-0.03915895149111748,
0.18211151659488678,
0.5251222252845764,
-0.49050188064575195,
0.08782828599214554,
0.5893868803977966,
0.2640565037727356,
-0.1303800344467163,
-0.6482058763504028,
0.14411991834640503,
-0.15538498759269714,
0.34366387128829956,
0.19012333452701569,
-0.6045096516609192,
0.6141128540039062,
-0.15343575179576874,
-0.22489576041698456,
0.12708233296871185,
0.5529616475105286,
0.1783807873725891,
0.07018424570560455,
0.6070863008499146,
0.11391156166791916,
0.6537008881568909,
0.22011998295783997,
0.7958727478981018,
-0.7323201298713684,
0.09222455322742462,
0.9250941872596741,
-0.18676309287548065,
0.6853569149971008,
0.7030853033065796,
0.11014483124017715,
0.10280219465494156,
0.783486008644104,
-0.15698622167110443,
0.43402883410453796,
0.6198948621749878,
-0.2755992114543915,
-0.2505614161491394,
-0.001532818889245391,
-0.21056455373764038,
0.2900118827819824,
0.04089468717575073,
-0.3671219050884247,
0.21850624680519104,
0.3826375901699066,
-0.1051630899310112,
-0.28539660573005676,
-0.250256210565567,
0.968500018119812,
-0.03983189910650253,
-0.4430941641330719,
0.6591289043426514,
0.0557321235537529,
0.813209056854248,
-0.47011053562164307,
0.181270569562912,
-0.46302732825279236,
0.2400013506412506,
-0.2107665240764618,
-0.0006911321543157101,
0.12302561849355698,
0.26465901732444763,
-0.13644377887248993,
-0.38500964641571045,
0.8625391125679016,
0.011091710068285465,
-0.1560002565383911,
0.1277293860912323,
0.5455130338668823,
0.3444582521915436,
-0.1250617504119873,
-0.40567606687545776,
0.24758721888065338,
-0.08273808658123016,
-0.6365981698036194,
0.6387034058570862,
0.39507967233657837,
0.1057521253824234,
0.2690674960613251,
0.9545484781265259,
0.4293570816516876,
0.41468894481658936,
0.1593593955039978,
1.148360252380371,
-0.7399149537086487,
-0.197278693318367,
-0.9046149849891663,
0.4843621551990509,
0.10173433274030685,
-0.5435985922813416,
0.5255250930786133,
0.8268564343452454,
1.0443106889724731,
-0.19845086336135864,
0.5891348719596863,
0.2575102150440216,
-0.13262900710105896,
-0.5761458277702332,
0.6080872416496277,
-0.5491514205932617,
0.20895415544509888,
0.009726354852318764,
-1.0541623830795288,
-0.44917207956314087,
0.36577844619750977,
-0.0754857063293457,
0.06151963770389557,
0.3604574203491211,
0.674534797668457,
0.033037737011909485,
-0.29646795988082886,
0.6564139723777771,
0.061077944934368134,
0.5805748105049133,
0.1514536738395691,
0.8525557518005371,
-0.2435561865568161,
0.40413698554039,
-0.07937197387218475,
-0.2416118085384369,
-0.29321929812431335,
-0.8796248435974121,
-1.1700516939163208,
-0.3895606994628906,
-0.31994372606277466,
-0.13998065888881683,
0.061628155410289764,
1.1103854179382324,
1.093764066696167,
-0.6617695689201355,
-0.13953056931495667,
-0.1997324377298355,
-0.001445301459170878,
-0.11645863205194473,
-0.11253082007169724,
0.1618509143590927,
-0.7269473671913147,
-0.6820521354675293,
0.28150928020477295,
0.12342122942209244,
0.17664547264575958,
-0.0006287263240665197,
-0.0013534380123019218,
0.4421342611312866,
0.20474585890769958,
0.6912046074867249,
-0.0477551631629467,
-0.44356727600097656,
-0.3950791358947754,
0.022279459983110428,
-0.029597586020827293,
0.14275981485843658,
1.3586632013320923,
-0.5634158253669739,
0.4410516023635864,
0.2760418653488159,
0.8962557911872864,
0.5939399003982544,
-0.04162469878792763,
0.587462306022644,
-0.8591949343681335,
0.16403356194496155,
0.15327046811580658,
0.33879294991493225,
-0.01521516963839531,
-0.5581124424934387,
0.32659390568733215,
0.219577819108963,
-0.5712618827819824,
-1.0229618549346924,
0.2978738844394684,
-0.5269517302513123,
-0.33248665928840637,
0.9024850130081177,
-0.2838771939277649,
-0.14859771728515625,
0.007558723445981741,
-0.22835393249988556,
0.4157358407974243,
-0.1811000108718872,
0.5069509744644165,
0.6364904642105103,
-0.3014996349811554,
0.069785937666893,
-0.30910441279411316,
0.7413237690925598,
0.5824189186096191,
-0.7054957747459412,
0.29288381338119507,
0.29962214827537537,
0.47927653789520264,
0.06656445562839508,
0.7462335824966431,
0.055953651666641235,
0.13035590946674347,
0.08310689777135849,
0.24056832492351532,
-0.36144471168518066,
-0.2583351731300354,
-0.549340546131134,
-0.00045110401697456837,
0.5179950594902039,
-0.2821418046951294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01032v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01032v2 | Repeat After Me: Transformers are Better than State Space Models at Copying | 2024-02-01T21:44:11 | 2024-06-03T22:22:15 | Samy Jelassi, David Brandfonbrener, Sham M. Kakade, Eran Malach | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Transformers are the dominant architecture for sequence modeling, but there
is growing interest in models that use a fixed-size latent state that does not
depend on the sequence length, which we refer to as "generalized state space
models" (GSSMs). In this paper we show that while GSSMs are promising in terms
of inference-time efficiency, they are limited compared to transformer models
on tasks that require copying from the input context. We start with a
theoretical analysis of the simple task of string copying and prove that a two
layer transformer can copy strings of exponential length while GSSMs are
fundamentally limited by their fixed-size latent state. Empirically, we find
that transformers outperform GSSMs in terms of efficiency and generalization on
synthetic tasks that require copying the context. Finally, we evaluate
pretrained large language models and find that transformer models dramatically
outperform state space models at copying and retrieving information from
context. Taken together, these results suggest a fundamental gap between
transformers and GSSMs on tasks of practical interest. | [
-0.03558244928717613,
-0.5446327924728394,
0.9777626991271973,
0.10641326010227203,
-0.2749527394771576,
0.2535632252693176,
-0.06915348768234253,
-0.32266637682914734,
-0.00816959235817194,
0.3144879639148712,
-0.17843475937843323,
0.20242342352867126,
-0.7753369212150574,
0.01059768907725811,
-1.1625592708587646,
0.8574394583702087,
-0.04471069946885109,
-0.23106609284877777,
-0.376764178276062,
0.17389081418514252,
-0.033759474754333496,
-0.419046550989151,
-0.4120196998119354,
-0.3761131167411804,
0.2830290198326111,
-0.2348126322031021,
0.9031565189361572,
0.6225088834762573,
0.3945271670818329,
0.3280324935913086,
-0.4423053562641144,
-0.004651056602597237,
-0.28196007013320923,
0.07754593342542648,
-0.17716576159000397,
-0.4533376395702362,
-0.24877482652664185,
-0.005567324813455343,
0.8094475269317627,
0.784429132938385,
-0.20981112122535706,
0.3098670244216919,
0.0008484692079946399,
0.4954625964164734,
-0.5063751935958862,
-0.010697765275835991,
-0.46066591143608093,
0.14894583821296692,
0.13204658031463623,
0.006526957266032696,
-0.5852694511413574,
-0.5721496343612671,
0.30504125356674194,
-0.6049020290374756,
0.39973533153533936,
-0.06889685988426208,
0.8150456547737122,
0.33102744817733765,
-0.41436460614204407,
-0.23162011802196503,
-1.3703839778900146,
0.7479732036590576,
-0.4777141213417053,
0.5229775905609131,
0.02121315896511078,
0.2954881489276886,
-0.01971324533224106,
-0.9603677988052368,
-0.807108461856842,
-0.3685503602027893,
-0.30157625675201416,
-0.047002121806144714,
-0.5280911922454834,
-0.19632188975811005,
0.6359151005744934,
0.43505963683128357,
-0.5349984765052795,
-0.1664896458387375,
-0.6185471415519714,
-0.012519510462880135,
0.20749031007289886,
0.04022645577788353,
0.40812820196151733,
-0.23988302052021027,
-0.5657579898834229,
-0.25274816155433655,
-0.7085378170013428,
0.19709576666355133,
0.2149195671081543,
-0.02004414051771164,
0.06721168756484985,
0.5011447668075562,
0.25636985898017883,
0.6827772855758667,
0.3728048503398895,
0.14418144524097443,
-0.0762433260679245,
-0.40679696202278137,
-0.30109116435050964,
-0.50943922996521,
0.5496885776519775,
-0.02441084012389183,
0.15088099241256714,
-0.6574997305870056,
-0.2704075872898102,
0.31427931785583496,
0.8542459011077881,
-0.5813421010971069,
-0.13997773826122284,
-0.18442130088806152,
-0.4664364457130432,
0.2525799572467804,
0.09092560410499573,
-0.6736710667610168,
0.01932908408343792,
-0.5496633052825928,
0.49285808205604553,
-0.3253461718559265,
-0.12440507858991623,
0.0025444827042520046,
-0.3125131130218506,
0.28720730543136597,
0.11638513207435608,
-1.014792561531067,
0.5762742757797241,
0.9085551500320435,
1.0773433446884155,
-0.4865231513977051,
0.004964244086295366,
0.02472442016005516,
0.03629246726632118,
-0.5139122605323792,
0.8256903886795044,
-0.610099732875824,
-0.8068064451217651,
-0.2627497911453247,
0.0685696080327034,
-0.3471132516860962,
-0.5806674361228943,
0.19600802659988403,
-0.6841425895690918,
0.3346756398677826,
-0.26428282260894775,
-0.8138062357902527,
-0.027987735345959663,
-0.44490504264831543,
-0.6661205887794495,
1.0122703313827515,
0.42148473858833313,
-0.2984369099140167,
0.44786760210990906,
-0.6878085732460022,
-0.6703404784202576,
-0.14704449474811554,
-0.11541885882616043,
-0.2942536473274231,
0.4560188949108124,
-0.08455789089202881,
0.4421612024307251,
-0.18771423399448395,
0.40567395091056824,
-0.17692363262176514,
-0.6943070292472839,
0.2635686695575714,
-0.32989752292633057,
0.37377679347991943,
0.5569080114364624,
-0.42070361971855164,
0.2207263559103012,
-0.43813657760620117,
-0.14756859838962555,
0.11274801939725876,
-0.4228062927722931,
-0.3030112683773041,
0.36485931277275085,
-0.20855113863945007,
0.2798347771167755,
0.07771098613739014,
-0.6045424342155457,
0.4257272481918335,
-0.1104636937379837,
0.7478402853012085,
0.5769705772399902,
-0.4083220660686493,
1.0717999935150146,
-0.30040237307548523,
0.5454829931259155,
-0.07464656978845596,
0.09409603476524353,
-0.20610734820365906,
-0.1418529599905014,
-0.6726641654968262,
-0.1253272294998169,
0.12219949811697006,
0.6718745231628418,
-0.698610782623291,
0.47766923904418945,
-0.6681037545204163,
-0.6258564591407776,
-0.25676611065864563,
-0.30168604850769043,
0.2536725401878357,
0.33138662576675415,
0.6830765604972839,
-0.3567572832107544,
-0.3515022099018097,
-0.9596747756004333,
-0.3217633366584778,
0.0967218279838562,
-0.2765049338340759,
0.2269641011953354,
0.4757351577281952,
-0.12467324733734131,
1.0795190334320068,
-0.38473159074783325,
0.1765572428703308,
-0.48072996735572815,
-0.26043835282325745,
0.36068999767303467,
0.49052947759628296,
0.6287347674369812,
-0.7428641319274902,
-0.3055875897407532,
-0.2127210795879364,
-0.7630091905593872,
0.20304082334041595,
-0.17206424474716187,
0.16607682406902313,
0.1516897976398468,
0.37038105726242065,
-0.9441894292831421,
0.3625437319278717,
0.5898970365524292,
-0.564437210559845,
0.507473349571228,
-0.36528581380844116,
0.11545111984014511,
-1.0468751192092896,
0.27432844042778015,
0.0005787283298559487,
-0.2697458863258362,
-0.7768475413322449,
0.016663385555148125,
0.2299707531929016,
-0.27642136812210083,
-0.25975969433784485,
0.4064597189426422,
-0.46792662143707275,
-0.4879385232925415,
-0.37431326508522034,
-0.2743930220603943,
-0.18874596059322357,
0.4719020426273346,
-0.08316164463758469,
1.213026523590088,
0.33829444646835327,
-0.6217898726463318,
-0.002270065015181899,
0.2298157811164856,
-0.7404168844223022,
0.18822208046913147,
-0.7037224769592285,
0.23856815695762634,
-0.07332972437143326,
0.602955162525177,
-0.8361709117889404,
0.05535370111465454,
0.004412041045725346,
-0.09923042356967926,
0.47344839572906494,
-0.007263593841344118,
-0.30406463146209717,
-0.7159778475761414,
0.2990598976612091,
0.34552958607673645,
1.163942813873291,
-0.5818357467651367,
0.5657708048820496,
0.24161425232887268,
-0.2312924563884735,
-0.6585869193077087,
-0.7127107381820679,
-0.17706675827503204,
-0.28513890504837036,
-0.3631306290626526,
0.4858067035675049,
0.15499347448349,
0.07053595781326294,
0.14968296885490417,
-0.545154333114624,
-0.14697769284248352,
0.207767054438591,
0.18481098115444183,
0.2838888168334961,
-0.22152450680732727,
0.055877044796943665,
0.053951069712638855,
-0.24212394654750824,
-0.05932105705142021,
-0.7241401076316833,
0.4533163905143738,
-0.24127937853336334,
-0.35535958409309387,
-0.36765775084495544,
0.47781404852867126,
0.5318872332572937,
0.1111469492316246,
0.6686274409294128,
0.1543492078781128,
-0.08642779290676117,
-0.21044032275676727,
-0.2996775209903717,
-0.3020555078983307,
-0.4906114339828491,
0.34397125244140625,
-0.28748250007629395,
-1.274681568145752,
0.16586743295192719,
-0.09290078282356262,
0.08284208178520203,
0.43267175555229187,
0.1648893505334854,
-0.10068494081497192,
0.9142263531684875,
0.7921034097671509,
-0.1674862951040268,
0.6677125692367554,
-0.3901769816875458,
0.4724869132041931,
-0.7775923013687134,
0.0748535618185997,
-0.550115168094635,
-0.45772647857666016,
-0.33059531450271606,
-0.7539122104644775,
0.15089954435825348,
0.06275897473096848,
-0.2572114169597626,
0.8574657440185547,
-0.5090875029563904,
0.5341528058052063,
0.5262778401374817,
-0.1742940992116928,
0.06540951877832413,
0.27478837966918945,
0.08046127110719681,
-0.010066407732665539,
-0.8078342080116272,
-0.8432333469390869,
0.8697708249092102,
0.09886432439088821,
0.8278560638427734,
-0.0006921238382346928,
0.3767438232898712,
0.3153633177280426,
0.22696423530578613,
-0.6612371206283569,
0.634268045425415,
-0.6513683199882507,
-0.41940364241600037,
-0.2672605812549591,
-0.43982014060020447,
-1.015919804573059,
0.3997860848903656,
0.09589928388595581,
-0.9907163381576538,
0.022099638357758522,
0.27429190278053284,
-0.3804887533187866,
0.7983554601669312,
-0.4586181044578552,
0.5516287684440613,
0.18646658957004547,
-0.09453950822353363,
-0.33114588260650635,
-0.5472661256790161,
0.142487034201622,
0.11354304850101471,
0.07960958033800125,
0.17188028991222382,
0.0893683135509491,
0.5986062288284302,
-0.3102536201477051,
0.4406844675540924,
-0.20518328249454498,
-0.07033692300319672,
0.4096839427947998,
0.12149538099765778,
0.19869934022426605,
-0.5170634388923645,
0.07056834548711777,
0.020996510982513428,
0.008660377934575081,
-0.24631176888942719,
-0.7996801733970642,
0.449831485748291,
-0.5793737173080444,
-0.6718206405639648,
-0.060345087200403214,
-0.2648836672306061,
-0.008741681464016438,
0.0412348136305809,
0.5276069641113281,
0.5218203663825989,
-0.011942971497774124,
0.41772061586380005,
0.5580883622169495,
-0.057074014097452164,
0.6311272382736206,
0.21265630424022675,
-0.08814454078674316,
0.24267761409282684,
0.8141676187515259,
0.22159460186958313,
0.42981311678886414,
0.40762606263160706,
0.006851995829492807,
-0.4481017291545868,
-0.20817334949970245,
-0.4217754602432251,
-0.04253137484192848,
-0.6242289543151855,
0.25134459137916565,
-0.8783605098724365,
-0.2311755120754242,
-0.2041085660457611,
-0.21394623816013336,
-0.6418232917785645,
-0.6475066542625427,
-0.12515148520469666,
-0.06732447445392609,
-0.033032793551683426,
0.971314013004303,
-0.029640818014740944,
0.42703425884246826,
-0.7559735178947449,
0.5516260266304016,
0.38984036445617676,
0.44419750571250916,
0.30696776509284973,
-0.5955372452735901,
-0.15916301310062408,
-0.26543891429901123,
-0.4616187512874603,
-0.790627121925354,
0.08958911150693893,
-0.039261478930711746,
0.6211248636245728,
0.07915215939283371,
-0.5104854702949524,
0.47628501057624817,
-0.6973727345466614,
1.2197993993759155,
0.1193598210811615,
-1.1582437753677368,
0.0813068151473999,
-0.08067702502012253,
0.49921879172325134,
-0.026027599349617958,
0.5205529928207397,
-0.6298785209655762,
-0.3490804433822632,
-0.7605975270271301,
-0.8517439961433411,
0.5745670199394226,
0.13545607030391693,
0.40922409296035767,
-0.08873844146728516,
0.2943880259990692,
0.28581106662750244,
0.13200978934764862,
-0.590660572052002,
-0.2625712454319,
-0.17840777337551117,
-0.0705060064792633,
-0.44545745849609375,
-0.2219899296760559,
0.33741262555122375,
-0.13138319551944733,
0.5397312045097351,
-0.07324370741844177,
0.8729678392410278,
0.26038292050361633,
-0.31360960006713867,
-0.07648688554763794,
0.6884874105453491,
0.6946589350700378,
0.7176536917686462,
0.2521321475505829,
0.05554765462875366,
0.21906103193759918,
-0.46779751777648926,
0.5935348868370056,
-0.02309371717274189,
-0.34244588017463684,
0.09698111563920975,
0.29997217655181885,
1.032413125038147,
0.4243544638156891,
-0.23326250910758972,
0.4330684244632721,
0.011874104849994183,
-0.08508514612913132,
-0.14324145019054413,
0.3550715446472168,
0.14970971643924713,
0.3679458498954773,
0.41843199729919434,
0.2974057197570801,
0.18308699131011963,
-0.3383108973503113,
0.3407151997089386,
0.1882009655237198,
-0.3734447658061981,
-0.6072328090667725,
0.8668546676635742,
-0.14806081354618073,
-0.40813785791397095,
0.682407557964325,
0.1974833458662033,
-0.4189225733280182,
0.7366812229156494,
0.7332631945610046,
0.7713093757629395,
-0.16064617037773132,
0.12866416573524475,
0.3894825577735901,
0.11165635287761688,
-0.6805002689361572,
0.1868480145931244,
-0.37024107575416565,
-0.4222869575023651,
-0.5970883369445801,
-0.6742473244667053,
-0.3375234305858612,
0.08437574654817581,
-0.8047356009483337,
-0.3415021598339081,
-0.4761108458042145,
-0.34278878569602966,
-0.16086679697036743,
-0.5529804229736328,
-0.6701441407203674,
0.08616366237401962,
0.059163689613342285,
0.9767292737960815,
-0.5911751985549927,
0.754867672920227,
0.5233387351036072,
0.16014158725738525,
-1.0427265167236328,
-0.12473741918802261,
-0.24274802207946777,
-0.292182058095932,
0.4727048873901367,
0.270306795835495,
-0.04297658056020737,
-0.06978743523359299,
-0.40087881684303284,
-1.1451908349990845,
0.9708175659179688,
0.20420099794864655,
-0.7561598420143127,
-0.4291619062423706,
0.026239445433020592,
0.6510310173034668,
-0.139221653342247,
0.060940008610486984,
0.8160910606384277,
0.26835793256759644,
0.02090625837445259,
-0.8083527684211731,
-0.10097801685333252,
-0.18262836337089539,
0.15387755632400513,
0.553177535533905,
-0.41870298981666565,
1.067465901374817,
-0.29767632484436035,
-0.5251652598381042,
0.5215265154838562,
0.7508960366249084,
-0.0992620438337326,
-0.11642090976238251,
0.6838586926460266,
0.6639536023139954,
0.5070276260375977,
-0.2946404218673706,
1.5510430335998535,
-0.09030812978744507,
0.44951581954956055,
1.0959261655807495,
-0.3085302710533142,
0.8199390172958374,
0.34950703382492065,
-0.4385121762752533,
0.7259690165519714,
0.18898479640483856,
-0.2739406228065491,
0.4444521963596344,
0.20335286855697632,
0.12132237106561661,
-0.19828185439109802,
0.45823660492897034,
-0.3076624572277069,
0.27678927779197693,
0.20517535507678986,
-0.4056786596775055,
-0.15226225554943085,
-0.004982520826160908,
-0.046313971281051636,
0.11743107438087463,
0.009666499681770802,
0.751499354839325,
0.20708152651786804,
-1.0432554483413696,
0.23710300028324127,
-0.20969140529632568,
0.5800868272781372,
-0.6243838667869568,
0.24613218009471893,
-0.18152162432670593,
0.1981051117181778,
0.20295608043670654,
-0.7522796392440796,
0.6104546785354614,
0.22270914912223816,
-0.4702746272087097,
-0.5829028487205505,
0.7646821141242981,
-0.3083049952983856,
-0.15500682592391968,
0.26916465163230896,
0.4361693561077118,
-0.008121938444674015,
0.16219696402549744,
-0.427287220954895,
-0.40342873334884644,
-0.3155820369720459,
-0.46525025367736816,
0.18926666676998138,
-0.25733432173728943,
-0.19364698231220245,
0.6449914574623108,
0.5939406156539917,
0.041173096746206284,
0.19821982085704803,
-0.1590154469013214,
0.4564036726951599,
-0.9745053052902222,
-0.784626305103302,
-0.8187000751495361,
0.40277957916259766,
0.03170144185423851,
-0.1280992180109024,
0.572688102722168,
0.4692510962486267,
0.8907278180122375,
-0.5695316195487976,
0.754996657371521,
-0.18790942430496216,
0.5889617800712585,
-0.41705143451690674,
0.552012026309967,
-0.5548438429832458,
-0.15565332770347595,
-0.1470881551504135,
-1.2729616165161133,
0.2358948290348053,
0.5990492701530457,
-0.3930682837963104,
0.155697762966156,
0.7046294808387756,
0.46594786643981934,
-0.39544808864593506,
0.26141512393951416,
0.21857187151908875,
0.07542307674884796,
0.46842437982559204,
0.8104294538497925,
1.3454210758209229,
-0.279069185256958,
0.31915614008903503,
0.01806488260626793,
0.013049603439867496,
0.01617961749434471,
-0.69734126329422,
-0.46418681740760803,
-0.6586278676986694,
0.06012585386633873,
-0.012095032259821892,
-0.2146962732076645,
0.5723499655723572,
0.932522177696228,
-0.5949474573135376,
-0.24402454495429993,
-0.15923446416854858,
-0.1402462124824524,
-0.3056154251098633,
-0.21835952997207642,
0.2066536694765091,
-0.2692495882511139,
-0.7511874437332153,
0.6321156620979309,
0.32566264271736145,
0.3616267442703247,
0.01543701533228159,
0.26695922017097473,
0.10149987787008286,
0.3663150370121002,
0.601592481136322,
0.36644893884658813,
-0.8715025782585144,
-0.5225616693496704,
0.1575174182653427,
-0.33236151933670044,
-0.008983513340353966,
1.13666832447052,
-0.8632079362869263,
0.11473485827445984,
0.43775659799575806,
0.7095665335655212,
0.47369298338890076,
0.08984433859586716,
0.5770778059959412,
-0.3998238146305084,
0.10242395848035812,
-0.015448675490915775,
0.4810027778148651,
0.27924948930740356,
-0.1259295642375946,
0.4356323182582855,
0.14803223311901093,
-0.6102520227432251,
-0.36831992864608765,
0.25407642126083374,
-0.9201603531837463,
-0.6302984356880188,
1.08150053024292,
-0.2873869836330414,
-0.1678345799446106,
0.37712278962135315,
-0.028343403711915016,
0.5792574882507324,
-0.10437612980604172,
0.8305410146713257,
0.5499130487442017,
0.014517351984977722,
0.38233646750450134,
-0.39707815647125244,
0.5319684743881226,
0.7132691144943237,
-0.5479127764701843,
-0.2014494240283966,
0.3159245252609253,
0.385728120803833,
0.37698623538017273,
0.2808956503868103,
-0.01807880774140358,
0.40504175424575806,
0.04647541046142578,
-0.4868968725204468,
-0.01788770966231823,
-0.6938891410827637,
-0.5236643552780151,
0.28668177127838135,
-0.35714009404182434,
0.10417085140943527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01030v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01030v4 | Executable Code Actions Elicit Better LLM Agents | 2024-02-01T21:38:58 | 2024-06-07T01:53:07 | Xingyao Wang, Yangyi Chen, Lifan Yuan, Yizhe Zhang, Yunzhu Li, Hao Peng, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Model (LLM) agents, capable of performing a broad range of
actions, such as invoking tools and controlling robots, show great potential in
tackling real-world challenges. LLM agents are typically prompted to produce
actions by generating JSON or text in a pre-defined format, which is usually
limited by constrained action space (e.g., the scope of pre-defined tools) and
restricted flexibility (e.g., inability to compose multiple tools). This work
proposes to use executable Python code to consolidate LLM agents' actions into
a unified action space (CodeAct). Integrated with a Python interpreter, CodeAct
can execute code actions and dynamically revise prior actions or emit new
actions upon new observations through multi-turn interactions. Our extensive
analysis of 17 LLMs on API-Bank and a newly curated benchmark shows that
CodeAct outperforms widely used alternatives (up to 20% higher success rate).
The encouraging performance of CodeAct motivates us to build an open-source LLM
agent that interacts with environments by executing interpretable code and
collaborates with users using natural language. To this end, we collect an
instruction-tuning dataset CodeActInstruct that consists of 7k multi-turn
interactions using CodeAct. We show that it can be used with existing data to
improve models in agent-oriented tasks without compromising their general
capability. CodeActAgent, finetuned from Llama2 and Mistral, is integrated with
Python interpreter and uniquely tailored to perform sophisticated tasks (e.g.,
model training) using existing libraries and autonomously self-debug. | [
0.09380634874105453,
-0.626227617263794,
0.44852176308631897,
0.1493278443813324,
0.11633159220218658,
0.17551176249980927,
-0.2333412617444992,
-0.36950334906578064,
0.3803311884403229,
0.832470715045929,
-0.2979544401168823,
-0.5346267819404602,
-0.16810446977615356,
-0.08286595344543457,
-0.44630876183509827,
0.8722499012947083,
-0.053133975714445114,
-0.15664233267307281,
-0.1462416797876358,
-0.22594571113586426,
-0.38952532410621643,
-0.5342642068862915,
-0.4432147145271301,
-0.589521586894989,
0.36409780383110046,
0.08787557482719421,
0.8449605703353882,
0.5282381176948547,
0.4761962592601776,
0.5399594306945801,
0.2539166212081909,
0.3992443382740021,
-0.3727686107158661,
0.11320460587739944,
-0.2257581651210785,
-0.5307958126068115,
-0.7893705368041992,
0.0603533536195755,
0.1629316657781601,
0.18830206990242004,
-0.30088454484939575,
0.10372020304203033,
-0.07255031913518906,
0.3615758717060089,
-0.3283456563949585,
0.4928094148635864,
-0.34394386410713196,
-0.16115671396255493,
0.38118284940719604,
-0.2998410165309906,
-0.4112101197242737,
-0.330521821975708,
-0.14293518662452698,
-0.5649617910385132,
-0.24835722148418427,
-0.21538817882537842,
0.38200846314430237,
0.4690675139427185,
-0.3501948416233063,
-0.47148942947387695,
-0.47871455550193787,
0.4913255572319031,
-0.8987395167350769,
-0.18933789432048798,
0.030271466821432114,
0.029938045889139175,
-0.29644808173179626,
-0.8532046675682068,
-0.41606029868125916,
-0.264405220746994,
-0.13125863671302795,
-0.16285496950149536,
-0.3071317970752716,
0.17504647374153137,
0.18776798248291016,
0.10825925320386887,
-0.5392820239067078,
0.10461818426847458,
-0.13612313568592072,
-0.27891844511032104,
0.6647843718528748,
0.5269170999526978,
0.24807405471801758,
0.10596786439418793,
-0.1859203726053238,
-0.2908807694911957,
-0.6640274524688721,
0.318637490272522,
0.44037365913391113,
0.27684348821640015,
-0.07666020840406418,
0.5844780206680298,
-0.19368630647659302,
0.5423510670661926,
-0.19096572697162628,
0.15632934868335724,
0.07983608543872833,
-0.19746197760105133,
-0.4115436375141144,
-0.201132133603096,
0.7692131400108337,
0.36616215109825134,
0.17669250071048737,
-0.2367190569639206,
-0.4463472068309784,
0.06918329745531082,
0.5018272995948792,
-0.8404173254966736,
-0.30004844069480896,
0.6438632011413574,
-0.2843225598335266,
-0.4284394085407257,
0.1643185168504715,
-0.45102962851524353,
-0.48700588941574097,
-0.6249025464057922,
0.3857889175415039,
-0.3609142601490021,
-0.26915979385375977,
0.10443723201751709,
-0.21734482049942017,
0.4157836139202118,
0.39714086055755615,
-0.49436330795288086,
0.2728515565395355,
0.8372043371200562,
0.6002510190010071,
-0.16072365641593933,
-0.5153219103813171,
-0.8826152682304382,
0.24061782658100128,
-0.4343264400959015,
0.9149265885353088,
-0.6840082406997681,
-0.08948573470115662,
0.13085578382015228,
-0.070044606924057,
-0.04120080545544624,
-0.6828121542930603,
-0.09592525660991669,
-0.6460437178611755,
-0.29885703325271606,
0.28696373105049133,
-0.4017021059989929,
-0.06140737235546112,
0.2899884879589081,
-0.8279338479042053,
0.8923774361610413,
0.2940095365047455,
-0.04108002409338951,
0.22544847428798676,
-1.0858838558197021,
-0.4932796061038971,
0.06933625042438507,
-0.2302551120519638,
-0.1705382913351059,
0.052886903285980225,
0.27744588255882263,
0.5824062824249268,
0.14082521200180054,
0.16649334132671356,
-0.26670631766319275,
-0.5703707337379456,
0.7316765189170837,
-0.3440498113632202,
0.4933584928512573,
0.03312778100371361,
-0.3114137351512909,
0.4600934684276581,
-0.4670557975769043,
0.39637991786003113,
0.017220480367541313,
-0.6641225814819336,
-0.09412156045436859,
-0.15389896929264069,
-0.10714484006166458,
0.12298845499753952,
0.3907240629196167,
-0.12903176248073578,
0.7830560207366943,
-0.3019467294216156,
0.5933501720428467,
0.7141064405441284,
-0.16484467685222626,
0.5788128972053528,
-0.37835413217544556,
0.5281423330307007,
-0.4370216131210327,
0.15315890312194824,
-0.3210275173187256,
-0.17439614236354828,
-0.6082645058631897,
-0.5138037800788879,
-0.12761379778385162,
0.4232913553714752,
-0.8645816445350647,
0.27840685844421387,
-0.24280521273612976,
-0.4235801100730896,
-0.41363438963890076,
0.40998604893684387,
0.4682948589324951,
-0.0961189717054367,
0.24489842355251312,
-0.030235685408115387,
-0.4394848644733429,
-0.45100072026252747,
-0.2552560567855835,
-0.20689891278743744,
0.14535167813301086,
0.2991170883178711,
0.41021668910980225,
-0.5895843505859375,
0.8853358030319214,
-0.36531227827072144,
-0.11839429289102554,
-0.5563653111457825,
0.2341136634349823,
0.4879595935344696,
0.2302025556564331,
0.31398412585258484,
-0.6598198413848877,
-0.32852575182914734,
0.12457968294620514,
-0.8109092712402344,
-0.18142637610435486,
-0.1623748242855072,
-0.1889161318540573,
0.4161086678504944,
0.6194261908531189,
-0.6322241425514221,
0.4303424060344696,
0.6751545071601868,
-0.39484357833862305,
0.42455416917800903,
-0.5054263472557068,
0.24602890014648438,
-0.8854842782020569,
0.02778543159365654,
-0.34384167194366455,
-0.21474787592887878,
-0.6660512685775757,
0.5124242901802063,
0.21285919845104218,
-0.1639976054430008,
-0.46439436078071594,
0.575943112373352,
-0.3699217140674591,
-0.16119402647018433,
-0.47697922587394714,
-0.1436002403497696,
-0.053072068840265274,
0.7587788701057434,
0.18397408723831177,
0.9264697432518005,
0.49976587295532227,
-0.7548521161079407,
0.4569911062717438,
0.1188969612121582,
-0.16013461351394653,
0.041018590331077576,
-0.6580725312232971,
0.3605729341506958,
0.3986133635044098,
0.1369558870792389,
-0.7410428524017334,
-0.5173801183700562,
0.02320132590830326,
-0.31207311153411865,
0.14072644710540771,
-0.17212635278701782,
-0.675934910774231,
-0.2339942455291748,
-0.38647952675819397,
0.13592664897441864,
0.4233490526676178,
-0.7323505282402039,
0.7594133019447327,
0.25584325194358826,
0.028296928852796555,
-0.5359028577804565,
-0.6074004173278809,
0.21432283520698547,
-0.1666460931301117,
-0.42804625630378723,
-0.09442543983459473,
-0.11913725733757019,
-0.32958123087882996,
-0.022577334195375443,
-0.05749358981847763,
-0.1317220777273178,
-0.017811177298426628,
0.43186187744140625,
0.3448795974254608,
-0.07201080769300461,
0.018301011994481087,
0.020380478352308273,
-0.040720921009778976,
0.13917240500450134,
-0.17924253642559052,
0.8378553986549377,
-0.22169773280620575,
-0.5618056654930115,
-0.39173004031181335,
0.27826282382011414,
0.9170102477073669,
-0.45061731338500977,
0.3765188157558441,
0.16082510352134705,
0.12852804362773895,
-0.5859053730964661,
-0.17946314811706543,
0.01590949110686779,
-0.5842552185058594,
0.2794438898563385,
-0.08945322036743164,
-0.8457958698272705,
0.32830148935317993,
-0.3103058636188507,
0.294158011674881,
-0.21374280750751495,
0.74062579870224,
-0.05781300738453865,
0.863389253616333,
0.540564239025116,
-0.19712255895137787,
0.5663796663284302,
-0.46938222646713257,
0.22235007584095,
-0.5570887327194214,
-0.17198434472084045,
-0.1806921660900116,
-0.3278960883617401,
-0.2761366069316864,
-0.8188584446907043,
0.11394236981868744,
-0.08911727368831635,
-0.2493576556444168,
0.6929850578308105,
-0.5231989026069641,
0.5378139615058899,
0.44691023230552673,
0.07416039705276489,
0.21995940804481506,
0.09597641974687576,
0.1612035483121872,
0.4675261080265045,
-0.5513779520988464,
-0.7934873700141907,
1.1910086870193481,
0.21360094845294952,
1.1505428552627563,
0.2921419143676758,
1.0198761224746704,
0.5582597851753235,
0.4790513813495636,
-0.6969088315963745,
0.5288330912590027,
0.22211810946464539,
-0.2648455500602722,
-0.3549846112728119,
-0.3391425311565399,
-1.1185928583145142,
0.1907203495502472,
0.13049545884132385,
-0.6630239486694336,
-0.21486304700374603,
0.21652409434318542,
-0.5270688533782959,
0.011299754492938519,
-0.847296953201294,
0.6935683488845825,
-0.35467997193336487,
-0.3877486288547516,
-0.34943363070487976,
-0.07697466760873795,
0.1609794646501541,
0.08543063700199127,
0.22635000944137573,
0.009148324839770794,
-0.3028586804866791,
0.10694202780723572,
-0.5747989416122437,
0.984153151512146,
-0.17760230600833893,
-0.5533144474029541,
0.5218870043754578,
0.24706776440143585,
0.830290675163269,
0.21193793416023254,
-0.18661367893218994,
0.1291448324918747,
-0.10311000049114227,
-0.19062013924121857,
-0.8149896860122681,
0.5885492563247681,
-0.6985864043235779,
-0.33475327491760254,
-0.07449521124362946,
-0.7387109398841858,
0.044394366443157196,
-0.002304782858118415,
-0.23435074090957642,
0.7219175696372986,
-0.12291834503412247,
0.005299227312207222,
0.34574344754219055,
-0.26760685443878174,
0.7353690266609192,
1.0149695873260498,
-0.3580325245857239,
-0.33416157960891724,
0.8191906809806824,
-0.3322550654411316,
0.17060847580432892,
0.4691275358200073,
-0.18607839941978455,
-0.27015310525894165,
-0.3823947012424469,
-0.14059467613697052,
-0.0784270241856575,
-0.5482880473136902,
-0.49267539381980896,
-0.4493672251701355,
0.03501235321164131,
-0.6515077352523804,
-0.3265094459056854,
-0.3404741883277893,
-0.05666814371943474,
-0.05434368550777435,
0.023970846086740494,
0.47902029752731323,
0.8867011666297913,
-0.06566743552684784,
0.39586755633354187,
-0.7957940697669983,
0.4883801341056824,
0.3294419050216675,
0.31659990549087524,
-0.2503757178783417,
-0.32237863540649414,
-0.34866440296173096,
-0.07239285856485367,
-0.10012517869472504,
-0.5473229885101318,
0.6003288626670837,
0.13359276950359344,
0.6584838628768921,
0.45046526193618774,
0.11099639534950256,
0.6816276907920837,
-0.360110342502594,
0.45501697063446045,
-0.061061613261699677,
-0.9702281951904297,
0.6164087057113647,
-0.25694164633750916,
0.2704026699066162,
0.2853713929653168,
-0.23973993957042694,
-0.27260854840278625,
-0.7387201189994812,
-0.370543897151947,
-0.8279524445533752,
0.9013975262641907,
0.29092225432395935,
0.2989344000816345,
0.07486554980278015,
0.20163561403751373,
-0.06381453573703766,
0.2903676927089691,
-0.7219669222831726,
0.012938355095684528,
-0.031582482159137726,
-0.1772700697183609,
-0.011400713585317135,
0.21913237869739532,
-0.2604478597640991,
-0.09855734556913376,
0.40029066801071167,
-0.46854910254478455,
0.39146363735198975,
0.01806599460542202,
-0.4061885178089142,
0.10139823704957962,
0.2956426441669464,
0.336946964263916,
0.4316554367542267,
-0.02071908488869667,
0.0010518428171053529,
-0.0897737666964531,
-0.3873308598995209,
0.22357070446014404,
0.031673576682806015,
0.20041798055171967,
-0.42360740900039673,
0.7963142395019531,
0.3632366359233856,
0.2237662374973297,
-1.2739057540893555,
0.6138917207717896,
-0.23655478656291962,
-0.0567612387239933,
-0.3559264838695526,
0.7775092720985413,
0.06011740118265152,
0.9218710064888,
0.14096331596374512,
0.04519098252058029,
0.14713838696479797,
-0.6925128102302551,
0.3094160556793213,
0.30181440711021423,
-0.20990629494190216,
-0.11446330696344376,
0.24140633642673492,
0.4449865221977234,
-0.5458535552024841,
0.6289454698562622,
-0.4930848181247711,
-0.43489977717399597,
1.0270036458969116,
0.4339769780635834,
0.7576210498809814,
0.0780329704284668,
0.3114781975746155,
0.07900594174861908,
0.3758540451526642,
-0.05671694129705429,
0.3886435031890869,
-0.22275598347187042,
-0.6215997338294983,
-0.7537767887115479,
-0.5511706471443176,
-0.4323967695236206,
0.16787178814411163,
-0.5726203322410583,
0.0923977643251419,
-0.4275522232055664,
0.19442066550254822,
-0.5741774439811707,
0.11989710479974747,
-0.5847118496894836,
-0.19994157552719116,
0.1900843381881714,
0.8530775904655457,
-0.5075823664665222,
1.0569758415222168,
1.0484263896942139,
-0.3418853282928467,
-1.038731336593628,
-0.053193349391222,
-0.10411490499973297,
-0.8998011350631714,
0.3846176266670227,
0.4322985112667084,
-0.05719946697354317,
-0.28204286098480225,
-0.9535737633705139,
-0.7110978960990906,
1.2429869174957275,
0.4328927993774414,
-0.4583806097507477,
0.24755066633224487,
0.3288078010082245,
0.7760307788848877,
-0.4439728260040283,
0.27010583877563477,
0.6933698058128357,
0.4354977309703827,
-0.23453333973884583,
-0.5779444575309753,
0.06884010136127472,
-0.45673367381095886,
-0.25317880511283875,
0.29845911264419556,
-0.6505696177482605,
0.7654755711555481,
-0.3385523855686188,
0.013506603427231312,
0.29695847630500793,
0.5079017281532288,
0.35833948850631714,
0.3878895342350006,
0.29800137877464294,
0.3880390226840973,
0.7928875684738159,
0.09119656682014465,
1.1483542919158936,
-0.47745639085769653,
0.2971028685569763,
1.1736806631088257,
-0.4671730697154999,
0.7846286296844482,
0.2990424633026123,
-0.08814958482980728,
0.5123596787452698,
0.21694889664649963,
-0.03238692134618759,
0.4400249421596527,
0.05100606754422188,
-0.2104182243347168,
-0.34408631920814514,
0.29168370366096497,
0.17808133363723755,
0.7246739268302917,
0.3238576054573059,
-0.07104913145303726,
-0.16056376695632935,
-0.1456184983253479,
-0.046191759407520294,
0.09927541762590408,
-0.4699540436267853,
0.8106799125671387,
-0.17116636037826538,
-0.7679598331451416,
0.2372983694076538,
-0.18397405743598938,
0.6460809111595154,
-0.7619314193725586,
-0.36373233795166016,
-0.535481333732605,
0.421151727437973,
-0.12378770858049393,
-0.7773894667625427,
0.12049899250268936,
0.2257729023694992,
0.016807779669761658,
-0.3354634940624237,
0.6476765871047974,
-0.37574052810668945,
-0.09837677329778671,
0.5232859253883362,
0.30315518379211426,
0.3598156273365021,
-0.29819726943969727,
-0.6493428945541382,
0.1470378339290619,
0.001530231791548431,
-0.3205639123916626,
0.4087015986442566,
0.6089972257614136,
0.01905633695423603,
0.8057896494865417,
0.7082366347312927,
0.09130601584911346,
-0.016264621168375015,
0.03918091952800751,
1.0393779277801514,
-0.5694507956504822,
-0.265375554561615,
-0.6559606790542603,
0.5244142413139343,
-0.2226824313402176,
-0.19330856204032898,
0.4456121027469635,
0.5006186962127686,
0.5536569952964783,
-0.0836736187338829,
0.8125478029251099,
-0.19135726988315582,
0.10883887112140656,
-0.6146498918533325,
0.5863566994667053,
-0.45320844650268555,
0.43327009677886963,
-0.24799437820911407,
-0.6808989644050598,
-0.0029727963265031576,
0.5261219143867493,
0.05408671125769615,
-0.10247725248336792,
0.4957457184791565,
1.1322742700576782,
-0.02932446263730526,
-0.4933343529701233,
0.47141408920288086,
0.013643426820635796,
0.6214593052864075,
0.6332399845123291,
0.9563505053520203,
-0.18717791140079498,
0.8771547079086304,
0.038186702877283096,
-0.2469247430562973,
-0.2750376760959625,
-0.7446547150611877,
-1.0876171588897705,
-0.0710306316614151,
-0.2785753607749939,
-0.171757772564888,
-0.3467698097229004,
1.1863865852355957,
0.6193150877952576,
-0.6990442872047424,
-0.3189159631729126,
-0.1745649129152298,
0.08221207559108734,
-0.5166686773300171,
-0.21363143622875214,
0.09081526845693588,
-0.7284216284751892,
-0.8317071795463562,
0.6837021708488464,
0.5044516921043396,
-0.23680123686790466,
-0.16498257219791412,
-0.5097759962081909,
0.2834164798259735,
0.32210400700569153,
0.6647098064422607,
0.36038291454315186,
-0.4896368384361267,
-0.050211332738399506,
-0.004872837103903294,
-0.3678409159183502,
-0.10787778347730637,
1.2417465448379517,
-0.6524474024772644,
0.17862287163734436,
0.25803765654563904,
0.6464297771453857,
0.04021921381354332,
-0.055200085043907166,
0.6125331521034241,
-0.6492853760719299,
0.13867522776126862,
0.1284571886062622,
0.400521457195282,
-0.1476825773715973,
-0.4402768909931183,
0.6536470055580139,
-0.2907077670097351,
-0.5602039098739624,
-0.5799252390861511,
0.014927791431546211,
-0.7912639379501343,
-0.6003680229187012,
1.4503018856048584,
-0.29076921939849854,
-0.3133607506752014,
-0.006668856367468834,
-0.44846776127815247,
0.14834928512573242,
-0.8178650736808777,
0.6168924570083618,
0.37539973855018616,
-0.567706286907196,
0.0770501121878624,
-0.2831527888774872,
0.29019543528556824,
0.17897342145442963,
-1.228401780128479,
0.4003761112689972,
0.5852243304252625,
0.040023528039455414,
0.10549293458461761,
0.5879543423652649,
-0.02164917066693306,
0.3119948208332062,
0.10865713655948639,
0.38710343837738037,
-0.39781489968299866,
-0.45535653829574585,
-0.5909461975097656,
0.04413676634430885,
0.0788068026304245,
0.10320175439119339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01025v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01025v1 | Graph-based Clustering for Detecting Semantic Change Across Time and Languages | 2024-02-01T21:27:19 | 2024-02-01T21:27:19 | Xianghe Ma, Michael Strube, Wei Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the predominance of contextualized embeddings in NLP, approaches to
detect semantic change relying on these embeddings and clustering methods
underperform simpler counterparts based on static word embeddings. This stems
from the poor quality of the clustering methods to produce sense clusters --
which struggle to capture word senses, especially those with low frequency.
This issue hinders the next step in examining how changes in word senses in one
language influence another. To address this issue, we propose a graph-based
clustering approach to capture nuanced changes in both high- and low-frequency
word senses across time and languages, including the acquisition and loss of
these senses over time. Our experimental results show that our approach
substantially surpasses previous approaches in the SemEval2020 binary
classification task across four languages. Moreover, we showcase the ability of
our approach as a versatile visualization tool to detect semantic changes in
both intra-language and inter-language setups. We make our code and data
publicly available. | [
-0.444955050945282,
-0.8901804685592651,
0.5497045516967773,
0.21402008831501007,
-0.20383518934249878,
-0.012294420972466469,
-0.1580493003129959,
-0.5073054432868958,
0.5808144211769104,
0.11892357468605042,
-0.28489089012145996,
-0.9605639576911926,
-0.7790980935096741,
0.19804154336452484,
-0.32529282569885254,
0.5247051119804382,
-0.11711816489696503,
-0.2567545473575592,
-0.14376525580883026,
-0.647802472114563,
-0.5532498955726624,
-0.3519221246242523,
-0.6175623536109924,
-0.6203195452690125,
0.7758200764656067,
0.1305258870124817,
0.37816208600997925,
0.37067145109176636,
0.1249990314245224,
0.19593000411987305,
-0.3311251997947693,
-0.05872443690896034,
-0.33414900302886963,
0.013710458762943745,
-0.08231603354215622,
-0.195880725979805,
-0.11319731920957565,
-0.19776268303394318,
0.8134293556213379,
1.1458404064178467,
-0.09387851506471634,
0.04293845221400261,
-0.021166633814573288,
0.4965924918651581,
-0.5490448474884033,
0.6486400365829468,
-0.8299057483673096,
0.15400440990924835,
-0.34081006050109863,
-0.3162318468093872,
-0.2659221589565277,
0.004270482342690229,
-0.21905454993247986,
-0.5153441429138184,
0.16722522675991058,
-0.09531264752149582,
0.8254304528236389,
0.30753573775291443,
-0.5236997008323669,
-0.12521274387836456,
-0.41939225792884827,
0.5533816814422607,
-0.7012881636619568,
0.8196659088134766,
0.18721456825733185,
0.1894036829471588,
-0.15318746864795685,
-0.8643082976341248,
-0.5893897414207458,
0.07354887574911118,
-0.08641563355922699,
0.07103649526834488,
-0.39959028363227844,
-0.37115922570228577,
0.18473750352859497,
-0.203593909740448,
-0.2547169029712677,
0.10276717692613602,
0.03163308650255203,
-0.20025569200515747,
0.2408478856086731,
0.07288263738155365,
0.5435333847999573,
-0.24455580115318298,
-0.26290711760520935,
-0.3051062822341919,
-0.8086258769035339,
0.00043750545592047274,
0.147823765873909,
0.44638457894325256,
-0.043471477925777435,
0.47942984104156494,
-0.24928966164588928,
0.8150948882102966,
-0.18518498539924622,
0.15020371973514557,
0.4125005006790161,
-0.310907244682312,
0.08246243745088577,
0.2930872142314911,
0.4284932613372803,
0.6873185038566589,
-0.10629543662071228,
-0.33665502071380615,
0.06502163410186768,
0.6531734466552734,
-0.2204686999320984,
-0.6680743098258972,
-0.22439956665039062,
-0.05416028946638107,
-0.5100811719894409,
-0.3536588251590729,
-0.02350808121263981,
-0.6387423276901245,
-0.5083894729614258,
-0.20319709181785583,
0.1394725888967514,
-0.41636499762535095,
-0.2708137035369873,
0.16168314218521118,
-0.4629761874675751,
0.22484421730041504,
0.3726191520690918,
-0.7830231785774231,
0.3923887014389038,
0.6590037941932678,
1.0213651657104492,
-0.3722335398197174,
-0.4020233750343323,
-0.38994264602661133,
0.2066349983215332,
-0.5429349541664124,
0.943252444267273,
-0.7055500745773315,
-0.40945965051651,
-0.08659351617097855,
0.3460901379585266,
-0.16015848517417908,
-0.5903809070587158,
-0.0710037499666214,
-0.5101882815361023,
0.06726057827472687,
-0.34746164083480835,
-0.5938259959220886,
-0.2194633185863495,
0.4823894202709198,
-0.4401493966579437,
1.1624794006347656,
0.26788920164108276,
-0.9157027006149292,
0.7911136150360107,
-0.5210041999816895,
-0.4941101372241974,
0.22019606828689575,
-0.44923850893974304,
-0.4810982346534729,
0.04715445265173912,
0.20736387372016907,
0.29934316873550415,
0.3361356258392334,
0.13542324304580688,
-0.5449532270431519,
-0.4781741797924042,
0.10184164345264435,
0.010782570578157902,
0.6750275492668152,
-0.05439908429980278,
-0.3244820535182953,
0.12485451996326447,
-0.6935456991195679,
0.1087043359875679,
0.17511074244976044,
-0.11019109189510345,
-0.7741519808769226,
0.41039031744003296,
0.025468068197369576,
0.23459741473197937,
0.38862815499305725,
-0.7512881755828857,
0.15780745446681976,
-0.4773375988006592,
0.5862280130386353,
0.5353071093559265,
0.2647111117839813,
0.2693231701850891,
0.09470976889133453,
0.23714734613895416,
0.3760652244091034,
-0.09748472273349762,
-0.07993867248296738,
-0.7554489374160767,
-0.6621409058570862,
0.3185267448425293,
0.23131130635738373,
0.37503525614738464,
-0.6462301015853882,
0.5139813423156738,
-0.48995500802993774,
-0.29385292530059814,
0.04772012680768967,
-0.017163606360554695,
-0.2656688094139099,
0.5016770958900452,
0.5298395156860352,
-0.5382460355758667,
-0.15891678631305695,
-0.5475321412086487,
-0.36655065417289734,
-0.18355368077754974,
-0.031055863946676254,
0.38053181767463684,
0.591401219367981,
-0.7250052094459534,
1.0383855104446411,
-0.8198914527893066,
-0.2445073127746582,
0.0638471320271492,
0.283883661031723,
0.08376443386077881,
0.367691308259964,
0.7642914652824402,
-0.6250020265579224,
-0.15670610964298248,
0.34151774644851685,
-0.5584210157394409,
-0.3563348948955536,
0.19257117807865143,
0.03451945632696152,
0.2654433250427246,
1.0834202766418457,
-0.10364840924739838,
0.5178561210632324,
0.7695206999778748,
-0.689661979675293,
0.13692758977413177,
0.002304934663698077,
0.05632861331105232,
-0.9320383667945862,
0.1703706979751587,
-0.3980581760406494,
-0.24952806532382965,
-0.42550766468048096,
-0.28539931774139404,
-0.01571725308895111,
-0.39867162704467773,
-0.306995689868927,
0.7787735462188721,
-0.20736739039421082,
-0.34684017300605774,
-0.25377416610717773,
0.3338682949542999,
-0.08608215302228928,
0.5202499032020569,
-0.054268740117549896,
0.2758548855781555,
0.37118762731552124,
-0.5655184984207153,
0.2028140425682068,
0.27302733063697815,
-0.3369283378124237,
0.5475338101387024,
-0.6922226548194885,
0.1466926485300064,
-0.2842002213001251,
0.28406715393066406,
-0.825393795967102,
-0.03204698860645294,
0.42614346742630005,
-0.45325833559036255,
0.07273226231336594,
-0.33407726883888245,
-0.4772396981716156,
-0.1333228349685669,
-0.17125454545021057,
0.35508009791374207,
0.12354759871959686,
-0.5017188191413879,
0.6194800138473511,
0.5424522161483765,
-0.11116020381450653,
-0.2602483630180359,
-0.6538575887680054,
0.302906334400177,
-0.23948082327842712,
-0.6404762268066406,
0.4800184369087219,
0.22673097252845764,
-0.2732126712799072,
0.4915831685066223,
-0.3383788764476776,
0.04223678261041641,
0.22489629685878754,
0.3244931995868683,
-0.11936435103416443,
0.1714102178812027,
0.5006982684135437,
0.28292223811149597,
-0.5974566340446472,
-0.05977022275328636,
-0.6702786087989807,
0.8876073360443115,
-0.3906099796295166,
-0.5693766474723816,
-0.10367123782634735,
0.3449154794216156,
0.30802789330482483,
-0.4709137976169586,
0.72209233045578,
0.8256447315216064,
-0.5551540851593018,
-0.2608520984649658,
-0.21177759766578674,
-0.17406004667282104,
-0.3866947591304779,
0.24776317179203033,
-0.21287260949611664,
-1.2408899068832397,
0.7106705904006958,
-0.6047588586807251,
-0.2328609824180603,
0.6560314297676086,
0.4451967477798462,
-0.12040586769580841,
1.1742414236068726,
0.6188613176345825,
0.02760363556444645,
0.7817328572273254,
-0.30522993206977844,
0.3736579120159149,
-0.6819975972175598,
-0.11568403989076614,
-0.5281922817230225,
-0.4410785436630249,
-0.7795673608779907,
-0.5823284387588501,
0.68853360414505,
0.07108250260353088,
-0.057946816086769104,
0.1814422905445099,
-0.3569912314414978,
0.3623003661632538,
0.32888922095298767,
-0.04372846707701683,
0.2712554633617401,
0.17075245082378387,
-0.1035071611404419,
0.0045659663155674934,
-0.8504679799079895,
-0.2023588865995407,
0.478069543838501,
-0.0007164404960349202,
0.566696047782898,
0.03418845310807228,
0.8206800818443298,
0.4339926242828369,
0.0615495890378952,
-0.8000655770301819,
0.6204050183296204,
-0.2972167134284973,
0.03866318240761757,
-0.47557640075683594,
-0.5074517726898193,
-1.463478446006775,
0.289745956659317,
-0.1961594671010971,
-0.7408785223960876,
0.5154772996902466,
0.11861178278923035,
0.45028385519981384,
0.352129191160202,
-0.5257769227027893,
1.2385402917861938,
0.07559192180633545,
0.05578706040978432,
-0.4436439573764801,
-0.5912017822265625,
-0.37437543272972107,
0.02482645958662033,
0.226139098405838,
-0.4894740581512451,
0.10124636441469193,
0.7212006449699402,
-0.5351983308792114,
1.0304113626480103,
-0.43934905529022217,
-0.03805455565452576,
0.26460835337638855,
0.306070476770401,
0.47148269414901733,
-0.08662520349025726,
0.16662469506263733,
0.5805548429489136,
0.23379060626029968,
-0.5384874939918518,
-0.6360864639282227,
0.8146848678588867,
-0.4793459177017212,
0.02047036960721016,
-0.36075255274772644,
-0.38443154096603394,
-0.2514130473136902,
0.4789711833000183,
0.13305826485157013,
0.5522006750106812,
-0.3912326991558075,
0.054418157786130905,
0.13424909114837646,
-0.48666417598724365,
0.3333872854709625,
0.3774697184562683,
-0.5171467065811157,
0.014492616057395935,
1.0846633911132812,
0.27038413286209106,
0.01473892480134964,
0.22620636224746704,
0.5292167663574219,
-0.35705509781837463,
-0.4122066795825958,
-0.25071147084236145,
0.3558906614780426,
-0.7388126254081726,
0.04119240492582321,
-0.5259313583374023,
0.3464076817035675,
-0.46633729338645935,
-0.3709193468093872,
0.028138110414147377,
-0.3920065462589264,
0.11180099844932556,
0.0207993034273386,
0.4775206446647644,
0.7540912628173828,
-0.06769834458827972,
0.11908449977636337,
-0.7440537810325623,
0.11744505912065506,
0.36601167917251587,
0.5808315873146057,
-0.2262202650308609,
0.051914650946855545,
-0.1916043758392334,
-0.10362949967384338,
0.16927456855773926,
-0.9976476430892944,
0.45885705947875977,
0.2634047567844391,
0.32381123304367065,
0.19014476239681244,
-0.16873914003372192,
0.5900598168373108,
-0.4051911532878876,
0.7725735902786255,
0.12772873044013977,
-1.1874895095825195,
0.6733628511428833,
-0.3903096616268158,
0.7735223770141602,
0.4177279770374298,
-0.08632601052522659,
-1.3666375875473022,
-0.33939090371131897,
-0.5613738298416138,
-0.9684030413627625,
0.47990506887435913,
-0.2253095805644989,
-0.05804067477583885,
-0.34980645775794983,
0.07206261157989502,
-0.15213961899280548,
0.308327853679657,
-0.49779829382896423,
-0.0320921391248703,
-0.2778880298137665,
-0.195890873670578,
-0.2232697606086731,
0.03585648164153099,
-0.24098625779151917,
-0.22551864385604858,
0.2560056746006012,
-0.5527069568634033,
0.2913444936275482,
0.001927134464494884,
-0.31113865971565247,
0.10753720998764038,
0.2653118968009949,
0.20810922980308533,
0.6105681657791138,
-0.00673107011243701,
0.5441218018531799,
0.5324065089225769,
-0.19109608232975006,
-0.18913397192955017,
0.02760031819343567,
-0.4634420573711395,
0.2188260406255722,
0.49581602215766907,
0.9135377407073975,
0.521403431892395,
-0.4967600703239441,
0.6115155220031738,
0.15578965842723846,
0.02820301428437233,
-0.11878304928541183,
-0.2854442894458771,
0.2436690777540207,
-0.004993456415832043,
-0.15986958146095276,
0.12606947124004364,
0.04132842645049095,
-0.507237434387207,
0.15911057591438293,
0.20913173258304596,
-0.5588611960411072,
-0.368950754404068,
0.5330719351768494,
-0.026307791471481323,
0.0674528107047081,
0.45976829528808594,
-0.44768306612968445,
-0.5578123927116394,
0.5689837336540222,
0.6275191307067871,
0.6185193657875061,
-0.13944153487682343,
0.36456766724586487,
0.1852174699306488,
0.10077765583992004,
0.17040681838989258,
0.2816027104854584,
-0.0965246856212616,
-1.2194128036499023,
-0.3698015511035919,
-0.4526032507419586,
-0.22850212454795837,
-0.35434702038764954,
-0.5426377058029175,
0.11723531037569046,
-0.2636720836162567,
-0.2335040420293808,
-0.12111157923936844,
-0.2745421826839447,
-0.5724948644638062,
0.07548579573631287,
0.1317552924156189,
0.5095843076705933,
-1.0823935270309448,
0.6619641184806824,
0.9271572828292847,
0.013080689124763012,
-0.4830864667892456,
-0.24047130346298218,
0.08144252002239227,
-0.9615530967712402,
0.6291428208351135,
0.23851680755615234,
-0.495408833026886,
0.20748557150363922,
-0.5467787981033325,
-0.7359055280685425,
1.0581638813018799,
0.04536452144384384,
-0.3681992292404175,
0.23463861644268036,
0.09403230994939804,
0.7312183380126953,
-0.08848710358142853,
-0.41061365604400635,
0.43263736367225647,
0.6435962915420532,
-0.14567580819129944,
-0.4681577980518341,
-0.051235098391771317,
-0.24579739570617676,
0.17045645415782928,
0.8728148341178894,
-0.3336128294467926,
0.7811914682388306,
0.17096449434757233,
-0.8164116740226746,
-0.7070849537849426,
0.4823695421218872,
-0.1172257512807846,
0.6627601981163025,
0.9366518259048462,
0.9572328329086304,
0.959860622882843,
-0.36379680037498474,
0.909420371055603,
-0.7866029739379883,
0.5080429315567017,
1.004828691482544,
-0.34583696722984314,
0.7973002791404724,
0.40463581681251526,
-0.1912536919116974,
0.6888214945793152,
0.45834195613861084,
-0.060738738626241684,
0.36694827675819397,
0.13422386348247528,
-0.3338892161846161,
-0.2587074339389801,
-0.3543492555618286,
-0.4842284321784973,
0.41920506954193115,
0.7431797981262207,
0.0711868554353714,
-0.5300252437591553,
-0.015682093799114227,
0.18755653500556946,
-0.031110407784581184,
-0.21753045916557312,
0.6384670734405518,
0.1666375696659088,
-0.19808606803417206,
0.2996757924556732,
0.0970292016863823,
0.5669265985488892,
-0.6139501929283142,
-0.11409301310777664,
0.006292880978435278,
-0.008891182951629162,
-0.23486793041229248,
-0.7391543388366699,
0.4979245960712433,
-0.31809425354003906,
0.12686769664287567,
-0.3482831120491028,
1.1404492855072021,
-0.6231228709220886,
-0.5038509368896484,
0.861284077167511,
0.7228317856788635,
0.05876673012971878,
-0.027581240981817245,
-0.5751232504844666,
0.2798686623573303,
-0.3640058934688568,
0.12171164155006409,
0.21133966743946075,
0.37263262271881104,
-0.45940375328063965,
0.3323829174041748,
0.6325989961624146,
0.10453159362077713,
0.2247960865497589,
0.5264357924461365,
0.7385890483856201,
-0.6690446138381958,
-0.6507298946380615,
-0.576744019985199,
-0.16154898703098297,
-0.11320655047893524,
-0.3072299361228943,
0.7599191665649414,
0.3581768870353699,
1.1101070642471313,
0.04713263735175133,
0.59879469871521,
-0.2977747619152069,
0.35294923186302185,
-0.502862811088562,
0.46603238582611084,
-0.7437081933021545,
-0.04422491788864136,
-0.3291117250919342,
-0.8947010040283203,
-0.5596755146980286,
0.6261923909187317,
-0.27740907669067383,
-0.2468772679567337,
0.7274213433265686,
0.7568055987358093,
0.08069141209125519,
-0.16947445273399353,
0.19451038539409637,
0.49695131182670593,
0.4286801517009735,
0.17008695006370544,
0.6509192585945129,
-0.026546383276581764,
0.16972479224205017,
-0.14774544537067413,
-0.1207796111702919,
-0.1607200801372528,
-0.9205265641212463,
-0.47769853472709656,
-0.8269188404083252,
-0.43009769916534424,
-0.36253857612609863,
-0.01355560403317213,
0.6625991463661194,
0.2983076870441437,
-0.7916456460952759,
-0.09332472831010818,
-0.2038721740245819,
0.06637418270111084,
-0.6185654401779175,
-0.27005916833877563,
0.6372921466827393,
-0.3856861889362335,
-0.5126469731330872,
0.7137705087661743,
0.5196216106414795,
0.012606899254024029,
-0.02507045492529869,
0.15311215817928314,
0.00268990034237504,
-0.20391811430454254,
1.033684492111206,
0.376141220331192,
-0.49887964129447937,
-0.7509417533874512,
-0.13003167510032654,
0.1551351398229599,
0.0808228850364685,
0.9474020600318909,
-0.8290665149688721,
0.649681568145752,
0.9532442092895508,
0.5165101885795593,
0.9041792154312134,
-0.09034337103366852,
0.24698254466056824,
-0.8522527813911438,
0.25110188126564026,
-0.05309569835662842,
0.5613483786582947,
0.4029189348220825,
0.22841285169124603,
0.5793655514717102,
0.7799249887466431,
-0.35320454835891724,
-0.5985801219940186,
0.4419287145137787,
-1.1805702447891235,
-0.50401371717453,
0.9684205055236816,
0.09596461057662964,
-0.2525976300239563,
-0.3215777277946472,
-0.005850350949913263,
0.2764134705066681,
-0.11441328376531601,
0.79221111536026,
0.7194123268127441,
-0.3320857882499695,
0.32319775223731995,
-0.16227944195270538,
0.1084442138671875,
0.314860463142395,
-0.9363287687301636,
-0.251412570476532,
0.7253326773643494,
0.35051244497299194,
0.3581527769565582,
0.782018780708313,
-0.2982892692089081,
-0.09478146582841873,
0.19066330790519714,
0.06647729128599167,
0.09957640618085861,
-0.3700403869152069,
-0.38035550713539124,
0.13022489845752716,
-0.11132983863353729,
0.00396118825301528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01019v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01019v1 | Domain-Independent Deception: A New Taxonomy and Linguistic Analysis | 2024-02-01T21:13:04 | 2024-02-01T21:13:04 | Rakesh M. Verma, Nachum Dershowitz, Victor Zeng, Dainis Boumber, Xuting Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CY | Internet-based economies and societies are drowning in deceptive attacks.
These attacks take many forms, such as fake news, phishing, and job scams,
which we call ``domains of deception.'' Machine-learning and
natural-language-processing researchers have been attempting to ameliorate this
precarious situation by designing domain-specific detectors. Only a few recent
works have considered domain-independent deception. We collect these disparate
threads of research and investigate domain-independent deception. First, we
provide a new computational definition of deception and break down deception
into a new taxonomy. Then, we analyze the debate on linguistic cues for
deception and supply guidelines for systematic reviews. Finally, we investigate
common linguistic features and give evidence for knowledge transfer across
different forms of deception. | [
-0.5219956040382385,
-1.021510124206543,
0.19330750405788422,
0.22456984221935272,
-0.02050168067216873,
0.23320716619491577,
-0.06329914927482605,
-0.709311842918396,
0.4800211489200592,
0.9415868520736694,
-0.7556723356246948,
-0.1373092234134674,
-0.7942751049995422,
0.3644578754901886,
-0.42281028628349304,
0.8670726418495178,
0.1993171125650406,
0.06012380123138428,
-0.3587040901184082,
0.09221608936786652,
-0.14283335208892822,
-0.7698959708213806,
-0.5955421924591064,
-0.216216042637825,
0.4534851312637329,
0.14844681322574615,
0.5884931087493896,
0.20977747440338135,
0.891629695892334,
0.29339656233787537,
0.5420268177986145,
0.05841050669550896,
-0.374409556388855,
-0.04582497105002403,
-0.37039995193481445,
-0.3694685399532318,
-0.12967483699321747,
0.29901123046875,
0.15528276562690735,
0.6082508563995361,
-0.1305406540632248,
0.1061692163348198,
-0.2738298177719116,
0.734336256980896,
-0.7569772601127625,
0.0964580699801445,
-0.8247917890548706,
-0.24232949316501617,
-0.3488520681858063,
-0.19408628344535828,
-0.7427647113800049,
-0.3143514096736908,
0.3311183452606201,
-0.6204200983047485,
0.3161184787750244,
-0.006833554711192846,
0.8015592098236084,
0.29430729150772095,
-0.6305642127990723,
-0.6306948661804199,
-0.7427149415016174,
0.8580232858657837,
-0.2460881471633911,
0.20202332735061646,
0.44795408844947815,
0.4052552878856659,
-0.03420613706111908,
-0.8511027693748474,
-0.5219547748565674,
-0.09101754426956177,
-0.19698770344257355,
0.08018915355205536,
-0.6603057384490967,
-0.15694576501846313,
-0.07611825317144394,
0.2508919835090637,
-0.4056644141674042,
-0.062230098992586136,
-0.3084743022918701,
-0.4561946988105774,
0.7873287796974182,
-0.03665677458047867,
0.5707242488861084,
-0.033229801803827286,
-0.6736202836036682,
0.08196915686130524,
-0.7041937708854675,
-0.18012551963329315,
0.6679101586341858,
0.18273364007472992,
0.07572944462299347,
0.23642411828041077,
-0.19173264503479004,
0.6751070618629456,
0.13843698799610138,
-0.33256766200065613,
-0.09540930390357971,
-0.0425155907869339,
-0.3220156729221344,
0.2608102560043335,
0.6674965023994446,
0.2591201961040497,
0.20291565358638763,
0.012764723971486092,
-0.30064883828163147,
0.7219233512878418,
0.47530031204223633,
-0.5607419013977051,
-0.4237057566642761,
0.17064350843429565,
-0.546881914138794,
-0.5067095756530762,
-0.02220776677131653,
-0.7162572145462036,
-0.5814372301101685,
-0.16277025640010834,
0.40238088369369507,
-0.33805233240127563,
-0.49316340684890747,
0.3477078974246979,
-0.4051830470561981,
0.16583000123500824,
0.2824537456035614,
-0.5132322907447815,
0.773673951625824,
0.7529844045639038,
0.2732631266117096,
-0.4432102143764496,
-0.1572335809469223,
-0.3125840425491333,
-0.12581931054592133,
-0.26413679122924805,
0.8020249605178833,
-0.6287623643875122,
-0.13251590728759766,
0.19663675129413605,
0.17287050187587738,
-0.012242577970027924,
-0.40977197885513306,
0.48695775866508484,
-0.8902767896652222,
0.5583484768867493,
-0.17382483184337616,
-0.32001152634620667,
-0.6043834090232849,
0.3958686292171478,
-0.7106645703315735,
0.6107304096221924,
0.08359897136688232,
-0.7708881497383118,
0.0906231552362442,
-0.7203324437141418,
-0.46061304211616516,
0.23768050968647003,
-0.04112604260444641,
-0.25181135535240173,
0.21370266377925873,
-0.12228084355592728,
0.03279455006122589,
-0.5546362400054932,
0.20436549186706543,
-0.014242558740079403,
-0.02901426889002323,
0.8178185224533081,
-0.5650293827056885,
1.2134222984313965,
0.34020668268203735,
-0.6078618168830872,
-0.31375983357429504,
-0.6945452094078064,
-0.036345820873975754,
0.23968273401260376,
0.08633320033550262,
-0.671413779258728,
-0.10908809304237366,
-0.3477429747581482,
0.011422119103372097,
0.337879478931427,
-0.4762219786643982,
0.15012457966804504,
-0.45456352829933167,
0.23029929399490356,
0.5175660252571106,
0.3217466175556183,
0.3471151292324066,
-0.6399189233779907,
0.658630907535553,
0.12948937714099884,
0.38046202063560486,
0.04604087024927139,
-0.6341866850852966,
-0.746330738067627,
-0.2239081859588623,
0.3713953197002411,
0.4464465081691742,
-1.0838896036148071,
-0.009202406741678715,
-0.19465884566307068,
-0.3931165039539337,
-0.6126911640167236,
-0.4953898787498474,
0.369456946849823,
0.3453846871852875,
0.30063486099243164,
-0.6082829236984253,
-0.47546470165252686,
-0.8822784423828125,
-0.5991644859313965,
-0.06285344809293747,
0.18068541586399078,
-0.11601395905017853,
0.6575793623924255,
-0.32637277245521545,
0.9136354327201843,
-0.46729862689971924,
-0.5159891843795776,
0.06473209708929062,
0.28141701221466064,
-0.23606368899345398,
0.230661541223526,
0.40587615966796875,
-1.147709846496582,
-0.6751098036766052,
-0.15559670329093933,
-0.5853223204612732,
0.005432202946394682,
-0.30848759412765503,
0.08614066988229752,
0.34576407074928284,
0.0038167063612490892,
-0.6462790966033936,
0.28796207904815674,
0.40798813104629517,
-0.32380211353302,
0.7791471481323242,
0.279774934053421,
0.2568577527999878,
-0.4663303792476654,
-0.24612277746200562,
-0.0855410248041153,
0.16233518719673157,
-1.0985044240951538,
0.2980606257915497,
-0.23419521749019623,
0.17389839887619019,
-0.5595551133155823,
0.5042209029197693,
-0.8439688682556152,
0.25241971015930176,
-0.5021401047706604,
0.3056198060512543,
0.001231533009558916,
0.4065701365470886,
0.04197622463107109,
0.231047585606575,
1.0264180898666382,
-0.6020600199699402,
0.46469905972480774,
0.39722082018852234,
-0.4173465371131897,
0.8623297810554504,
-0.1957125961780548,
0.23916393518447876,
-0.1305909901857376,
0.34593674540519714,
-0.6937510967254639,
-0.4409111440181732,
0.691306471824646,
-0.8512219786643982,
0.2429438978433609,
-0.40507742762565613,
-0.1653277575969696,
-0.1884119063615799,
-0.24089117348194122,
0.27361828088760376,
0.46288740634918213,
-0.5480404496192932,
0.641526460647583,
0.5932427048683167,
0.037285469472408295,
-0.8725759983062744,
-0.923340380191803,
0.34669896960258484,
-0.27955153584480286,
-0.5823884010314941,
0.3707217276096344,
0.11751800775527954,
-0.905588686466217,
0.11476967483758926,
-0.08953670412302017,
-0.39694249629974365,
0.2849220037460327,
-0.013848378323018551,
0.1438199132680893,
-0.04451572522521019,
-0.21209444105625153,
-0.3133194148540497,
-0.15693961083889008,
0.6228032112121582,
-0.4406481683254242,
0.39482414722442627,
0.31504109501838684,
-0.4431314766407013,
-0.5506195425987244,
0.6306653618812561,
0.3350589871406555,
-0.19548940658569336,
0.5943683981895447,
0.2536641061306,
-0.4660634696483612,
-0.3964739441871643,
-0.5925812125205994,
-0.29379111528396606,
-0.5345379710197449,
-0.1436229646205902,
-0.3498552739620209,
-0.8217718005180359,
0.26290231943130493,
-0.21219326555728912,
-0.23208236694335938,
0.6905107498168945,
0.5774775147438049,
0.19874832034111023,
0.8856269717216492,
0.9901571273803711,
0.26416197419166565,
0.13377133011817932,
0.11245886236429214,
0.47434619069099426,
-0.1313430666923523,
-0.2677415907382965,
-0.46235406398773193,
0.011089554987847805,
-0.8708105087280273,
-0.3095046877861023,
0.1522601991891861,
-0.1647080034017563,
0.09035833925008774,
0.2758353054523468,
-0.714862048625946,
0.5314125418663025,
0.5608794689178467,
-0.41350501775741577,
0.4312773644924164,
0.23437535762786865,
0.16840803623199463,
-0.0031936990562826395,
-0.4667254090309143,
-0.3992552161216736,
1.0369502305984497,
0.14626869559288025,
0.6997050046920776,
0.3431170880794525,
0.545261025428772,
0.685656726360321,
0.6624021530151367,
-0.6312023997306824,
0.5758689641952515,
0.007360378745943308,
-0.8527690172195435,
0.020108306780457497,
-0.5001266598701477,
-1.127784252166748,
0.16787706315517426,
-0.013495388440787792,
-0.556357741355896,
0.18293650448322296,
-0.3083132803440094,
-0.029263922944664955,
0.2526187300682068,
-0.4409472942352295,
0.4357471466064453,
-0.4116615056991577,
0.05644683539867401,
-0.17685438692569733,
-0.6944770216941833,
0.6988064050674438,
-0.3005872666835785,
0.4052806794643402,
-0.2360789030790329,
0.09712501615285873,
0.6102424263954163,
-0.2289585918188095,
1.1471062898635864,
-0.2559448182582855,
-0.27192336320877075,
0.47857731580734253,
0.44084295630455017,
0.4302389919757843,
-0.16620033979415894,
0.24728237092494965,
0.29863911867141724,
0.09663546085357666,
-0.3807374835014343,
-0.35620400309562683,
0.6184250712394714,
-0.5801455974578857,
-0.6739352345466614,
-0.752157986164093,
-0.1495893895626068,
-0.4422457814216614,
0.26458802819252014,
0.3253867030143738,
0.19515444338321686,
-0.5494722723960876,
-0.15725044906139374,
0.8349803686141968,
-0.015450293198227882,
0.23431359231472015,
0.7896091341972351,
-0.15641960501670837,
-0.5387600660324097,
1.129831314086914,
-0.10962864756584167,
0.36034709215164185,
0.45861634612083435,
0.12942829728126526,
-0.2616176903247833,
-0.4414559006690979,
-0.10919907689094543,
0.23615875840187073,
-0.719733715057373,
-0.2106092870235443,
-0.44144827127456665,
-0.1990155428647995,
-0.5940013527870178,
-0.06969988346099854,
-0.16551631689071655,
-0.4545789062976837,
-0.057209789752960205,
0.29806825518608093,
0.31674376130104065,
0.9952821135520935,
-0.00916612520813942,
0.4604480564594269,
-0.6777329444885254,
0.39057591557502747,
0.27519097924232483,
0.12456579506397247,
-0.2832791209220886,
-0.28178587555885315,
-0.023211898282170296,
0.18557731807231903,
-0.20917744934558868,
-1.0163589715957642,
0.4129107594490051,
0.04543141648173332,
0.5820029973983765,
0.4149300754070282,
0.3919356167316437,
0.153159499168396,
-0.1791578084230423,
1.0254907608032227,
0.5653706789016724,
-0.8702525496482849,
0.2540905773639679,
-0.14007700979709625,
-0.1957998275756836,
0.22423018515110016,
0.9805155992507935,
-0.8068950176239014,
-0.2296779900789261,
-0.9249738454818726,
-0.49915260076522827,
0.4821329712867737,
0.14407065510749817,
0.07725731283426285,
-0.07999373227357864,
0.04161860793828964,
0.5065467357635498,
0.3515232503414154,
-0.9352213740348816,
-0.6754654049873352,
-0.0423215888440609,
-0.046318165957927704,
0.21188995242118835,
-0.2045748233795166,
-0.7507554292678833,
0.14268137514591217,
0.6634337902069092,
-0.3827274739742279,
0.4585503041744232,
0.10934131592512131,
-0.4102713167667389,
-0.18329888582229614,
-0.05983027443289757,
0.3876400887966156,
0.5848799347877502,
0.6273861527442932,
0.4777434170246124,
-0.36410558223724365,
-0.5085596442222595,
0.2126888483762741,
-0.032689083367586136,
-0.2882462739944458,
0.19520340859889984,
0.30801185965538025,
0.5339590907096863,
-0.08568861335515976,
-0.602558434009552,
0.8647751212120056,
-0.08481530100107193,
-0.6979374885559082,
-0.5304327011108398,
-0.1382617950439453,
-0.16783791780471802,
0.035455744713544846,
0.4881197512149811,
0.5030627846717834,
0.20990729331970215,
-0.5956947207450867,
0.23706871271133423,
0.6309095025062561,
-0.2828575372695923,
-0.5137672424316406,
0.5364950895309448,
0.1422235369682312,
-0.34684625267982483,
0.46377015113830566,
-0.4312551021575928,
-0.6922217011451721,
0.2990315556526184,
0.429350346326828,
0.9438424110412598,
-0.34459108114242554,
0.6426211595535278,
-0.240397647023201,
0.5313168168067932,
-0.14438143372535706,
0.3304503560066223,
0.019498754292726517,
-0.9272550344467163,
-0.3741830885410309,
-0.4501924514770508,
-0.6338677406311035,
0.15124623477458954,
-0.44323885440826416,
0.11207066476345062,
-0.358621746301651,
-0.08378750830888748,
0.1718340814113617,
0.08226928859949112,
-0.42906060814857483,
0.18141917884349823,
0.22930319607257843,
0.8072755932807922,
-0.5467788577079773,
0.6472129821777344,
0.23842114210128784,
-0.34574124217033386,
0.02701018750667572,
0.11640530824661255,
0.4175225496292114,
-0.7411499619483948,
0.5110654830932617,
0.11090532690286636,
-0.5013469457626343,
-0.2135770320892334,
-0.8928877711296082,
-0.9380726218223572,
0.43709224462509155,
0.2523516118526459,
-0.05529894307255745,
0.1110358014702797,
0.644411027431488,
0.47942453622817993,
-0.602148711681366,
-0.13815443217754364,
0.6788842678070068,
0.7298825979232788,
-0.2356593906879425,
-0.6808158755302429,
-0.008717698976397514,
-0.06310952454805374,
-0.380634069442749,
0.19956211745738983,
-0.7525538206100464,
0.8149805068969727,
0.20980995893478394,
-0.5784543752670288,
-0.10298585891723633,
0.4946233630180359,
-0.38731950521469116,
0.5047726035118103,
0.42551565170288086,
0.4013981819152832,
0.7946200966835022,
-0.32304465770721436,
0.6985925436019897,
-0.3036319613456726,
0.3244815766811371,
0.9520772099494934,
-0.3012286424636841,
0.3800261318683624,
0.13525809347629547,
-0.10821008682250977,
0.9253609776496887,
0.5826173424720764,
-0.1703745275735855,
0.4678347408771515,
0.465376615524292,
-0.4362757205963135,
-0.14625076949596405,
-0.06464755535125732,
0.010525860823690891,
0.6667134761810303,
0.6621884107589722,
-0.0842263251543045,
-0.11749619990587234,
0.28151461482048035,
0.03352855145931244,
0.15388436615467072,
-0.14350368082523346,
0.7404971122741699,
-0.010615648701786995,
-0.8465138077735901,
0.5643375515937805,
0.22042034566402435,
0.8632911443710327,
-0.8025087118148804,
0.15397970378398895,
-0.048342715948820114,
0.15229348838329315,
-0.2968345582485199,
-0.31058603525161743,
0.2669082581996918,
-0.2523000240325928,
0.09024156630039215,
-0.5321400761604309,
1.042819619178772,
-0.3589492440223694,
-0.07166910171508789,
0.2559374272823334,
0.8414639234542847,
0.19287240505218506,
-0.25020459294319153,
-1.0142302513122559,
0.10058871656656265,
0.010925084352493286,
-0.13236403465270996,
0.5220239758491516,
0.5519903898239136,
-0.0879383534193039,
0.762764036655426,
0.8599694967269897,
-0.06484103947877884,
0.18607890605926514,
-0.013705466873943806,
0.4657922089099884,
-0.6880360841751099,
-0.533927321434021,
-0.6580339670181274,
0.13484209775924683,
-0.20661817491054535,
-0.15439584851264954,
1.0990811586380005,
0.3678303062915802,
1.0993403196334839,
-0.13509513437747955,
0.8856615424156189,
-0.07275686413049698,
0.4982689619064331,
-0.2617069482803345,
0.5400977730751038,
-0.3889233469963074,
0.053159717470407486,
-0.049862366169691086,
-0.5791728496551514,
-0.32912272214889526,
0.14665688574314117,
-0.18552491068840027,
-0.1777079552412033,
0.8756505846977234,
0.5311115384101868,
0.11818177253007889,
0.3811781108379364,
0.19207201898097992,
0.25937455892562866,
0.11466888338327408,
0.1514272689819336,
1.1813852787017822,
-0.20279256999492645,
0.426550030708313,
-0.25255805253982544,
-0.13532836735248566,
-0.34097933769226074,
-0.6343790292739868,
-0.5581803917884827,
-0.6757259368896484,
-0.7259826064109802,
-0.46784910559654236,
-0.13388656079769135,
0.2689940929412842,
0.4840555489063263,
-0.6277589201927185,
-0.24307341873645782,
0.028145985677838326,
0.27064836025238037,
-0.5584254860877991,
-0.33538544178009033,
0.06271614134311676,
-0.2964304983615875,
-0.7246419191360474,
0.3851834237575531,
0.2599683403968811,
0.07208070904016495,
-0.7686722278594971,
0.28106123208999634,
0.03766690567135811,
0.7724471092224121,
0.5039514303207397,
0.21002918481826782,
-0.8104998469352722,
-0.2872932553291321,
0.0014969180338084698,
-0.09689892083406448,
0.06407585740089417,
1.1325443983078003,
-0.6727727651596069,
0.3405308127403259,
0.2687545716762543,
0.6256819367408752,
0.04082950949668884,
-0.166710764169693,
0.3586787283420563,
-0.6695724129676819,
-0.17946261167526245,
0.5522438883781433,
0.15027357637882233,
0.36326417326927185,
-0.5690858960151672,
0.4551607072353363,
0.7701476812362671,
-0.4565829932689667,
-0.8298752307891846,
0.5395240783691406,
-0.8118210434913635,
-0.7422515153884888,
0.9677677154541016,
0.07017379999160767,
-0.4960252642631531,
-0.4806436002254486,
0.06349249929189682,
-0.3666071891784668,
-0.10367308557033539,
0.9310303330421448,
0.7692679166793823,
-0.14886195957660675,
0.31873929500579834,
-0.2713121473789215,
0.9906050562858582,
-0.02230585366487503,
-0.8793675899505615,
0.12886980175971985,
0.6013604402542114,
0.4642265737056732,
0.5458078980445862,
0.7971250414848328,
-0.11360467225313187,
0.2882131338119507,
0.3353370428085327,
-0.0866183489561081,
0.32962918281555176,
-0.46600258350372314,
-0.2297784835100174,
0.5073328018188477,
-0.2236790806055069,
0.09099014103412628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01018v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01018v1 | HR-MultiWOZ: A Task Oriented Dialogue (TOD) Dataset for HR LLM Agent | 2024-02-01T21:10:44 | 2024-02-01T21:10:44 | Weijie Xu, Zicheng Huang, Wenxiang Hu, Xi Fang, Rajesh Kumar Cherukuri, Naumaan Nayyar, Lorenzo Malandri, Srinivasan H. Sengamedu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7 | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have been reshaping
Natural Language Processing (NLP) task in several domains. Their use in the
field of Human Resources (HR) has still room for expansions and could be
beneficial for several time consuming tasks. Examples such as time-off
submissions, medical claims filing, and access requests are noteworthy, but
they are by no means the sole instances. However, the aforementioned
developments must grapple with the pivotal challenge of constructing a
high-quality training dataset. On one hand, most conversation datasets are
solving problems for customers not employees. On the other hand, gathering
conversations with HR could raise privacy concerns. To solve it, we introduce
HR-Multiwoz, a fully-labeled dataset of 550 conversations spanning 10 HR
domains to evaluate LLM Agent. Our work has the following contributions: (1) It
is the first labeled open-sourced conversation dataset in the HR domain for NLP
research. (2) It provides a detailed recipe for the data generation procedure
along with data analysis and human evaluations. The data generation pipeline is
transferable and can be easily adapted for labeled conversation data generation
in other domains. (3) The proposed data-collection pipeline is mostly based on
LLMs with minimal human involvement for annotation, which is time and
cost-efficient. | [
-0.28491339087486267,
-0.6641234159469604,
0.3270401060581207,
0.24135012924671173,
-0.11380162835121155,
0.23131915926933289,
-0.24728132784366608,
-0.6195985078811646,
0.03133028373122215,
0.6802030801773071,
-1.097749948501587,
-0.5552828311920166,
-0.39289212226867676,
0.047126006335020065,
-0.16782332956790924,
1.1653881072998047,
0.3735603094100952,
-0.054326415061950684,
-0.16047786176204681,
-0.3371277451515198,
-0.4370756447315216,
-0.8106374740600586,
-0.6123380064964294,
-0.49776554107666016,
0.8026977181434631,
0.3410170078277588,
0.5710775852203369,
0.6642051935195923,
0.30097031593322754,
0.34357285499572754,
0.09036599844694138,
0.4213561415672302,
-0.418073445558548,
0.7329959273338318,
0.04409416392445564,
-0.24903981387615204,
-0.9247753024101257,
-0.11318496614694595,
0.44123420119285583,
0.5877400040626526,
-0.5782089829444885,
0.42190906405448914,
0.02813594974577427,
0.5959256291389465,
-0.4046843945980072,
0.2972913682460785,
-0.6617119908332825,
0.13425183296203613,
-0.5205427408218384,
-0.24537605047225952,
-0.2996584475040436,
-0.007062679156661034,
0.3165731728076935,
-0.23599481582641602,
0.2323339730501175,
0.09186051785945892,
0.3339208662509918,
0.24530450999736786,
-0.5419603586196899,
-0.37432795763015747,
-0.7831079959869385,
1.0631334781646729,
-0.7228735685348511,
0.6214851140975952,
0.30041971802711487,
0.1196184977889061,
-0.3924160301685333,
-0.42682623863220215,
-0.5874760746955872,
-0.0628877729177475,
0.2921183407306671,
0.010869123041629791,
-0.2796817719936371,
0.08497558534145355,
0.20637400448322296,
0.16545674204826355,
-0.3525295853614807,
0.25701403617858887,
-0.1939806044101715,
-0.2196839600801468,
0.6980068683624268,
0.6673608422279358,
0.2141282856464386,
-0.020919721573591232,
-0.5337415337562561,
-0.0012189412955194712,
-0.4704345166683197,
-0.07493022829294205,
0.4871782660484314,
0.5197787284851074,
-0.03880889341235161,
0.7125085592269897,
-0.5353008508682251,
0.7723311185836792,
-0.3826744854450226,
-0.458799809217453,
0.3620694875717163,
-0.224875345826149,
-0.21497711539268494,
-0.09341337531805038,
0.9691575169563293,
0.1667208969593048,
-0.035968001931905746,
-0.4075956344604492,
-0.0057784877717494965,
-0.22182928025722504,
0.5275421142578125,
-0.5323523283004761,
0.1427447646856308,
0.41393598914146423,
-0.2993020713329315,
-0.07749368995428085,
-0.2304222285747528,
-0.8568907380104065,
-0.5044698715209961,
-0.5311339497566223,
-0.12490111589431763,
-0.15819475054740906,
-0.06805623322725296,
-0.14182977378368378,
0.023951590061187744,
0.26655489206314087,
0.35936635732650757,
-0.5601370930671692,
-0.09291234612464905,
0.5357716679573059,
0.5789487957954407,
-0.398637980222702,
-0.5722943544387817,
-0.3953993022441864,
0.28265517950057983,
-0.35027244687080383,
0.6978773474693298,
-0.3509620130062103,
-0.38883253931999207,
0.1790316253900528,
-0.1703297644853592,
0.045978229492902756,
-0.41554662585258484,
0.6478166580200195,
-0.41260090470314026,
0.33248966932296753,
0.11304424703121185,
-0.22059553861618042,
0.09191540628671646,
0.6053528785705566,
-0.4910985827445984,
1.0514413118362427,
0.17959502339363098,
-0.5376484990119934,
0.10250896960496902,
-0.9090858697891235,
-0.321551114320755,
0.09680402278900146,
-0.12864066660404205,
-0.3763708174228668,
-0.10652415454387665,
0.04624637961387634,
0.4607098698616028,
-0.6155538558959961,
0.1993439942598343,
-0.2983326017856598,
0.053567253053188324,
0.5209912061691284,
-0.4561763405799866,
0.7252920866012573,
0.21707695722579956,
-0.17454417049884796,
0.3071973919868469,
-0.9418092966079712,
0.3618304431438446,
-0.04790148511528969,
-0.5336087942123413,
-0.1765773594379425,
-0.09259500354528427,
-0.18608111143112183,
0.4787740409374237,
0.2599646747112274,
-0.6774372458457947,
0.21690680086612701,
-0.14320074021816254,
0.1961531937122345,
0.9794100522994995,
-0.24101172387599945,
0.18016955256462097,
-0.25063005089759827,
0.6227739453315735,
-0.19915778934955597,
0.3529251217842102,
0.039009932428598404,
-0.6521461009979248,
-0.7394314408302307,
-0.28942182660102844,
-0.07228352129459381,
0.4660740792751312,
-0.8913072347640991,
0.45855826139450073,
-0.3476753532886505,
-0.6026906967163086,
-0.6857802271842957,
0.23668168485164642,
0.4817296862602234,
0.5533224940299988,
0.1531514823436737,
-0.0016274444060400128,
-0.5726757049560547,
-0.9646970629692078,
-0.16602657735347748,
-0.07518242299556732,
-0.04426594823598862,
0.4993317127227783,
0.24715690314769745,
-0.5680626034736633,
1.1292552947998047,
-0.39488887786865234,
-0.5127531290054321,
-0.3830793499946594,
0.13394998013973236,
0.10863665491342545,
0.24839317798614502,
-0.005357993766665459,
-0.6402645707130432,
-0.37821030616760254,
-0.1435387134552002,
-0.8330374956130981,
0.016163086518645287,
0.17897896468639374,
-0.5316265225410461,
0.1633751094341278,
-0.024662146344780922,
-0.7564697861671448,
0.24329105019569397,
0.7585014700889587,
-0.257363498210907,
0.4830661714076996,
-0.17401398718357086,
0.049518778920173645,
-1.1489347219467163,
0.002508599776774645,
0.03200366348028183,
-0.21186497807502747,
-1.0435245037078857,
-0.2587994337081909,
-0.40439102053642273,
-0.2869183421134949,
-0.5357609987258911,
0.6705840826034546,
-0.40205642580986023,
-0.22240377962589264,
-0.3341158330440521,
0.029974617063999176,
-0.2587684094905853,
1.0355924367904663,
0.031091855838894844,
0.7563466429710388,
0.3602577745914459,
-0.9455317854881287,
0.7289453148841858,
0.8789080381393433,
-0.31017184257507324,
0.788712203502655,
-0.361172080039978,
0.8120248913764954,
-0.010508386418223381,
0.23818720877170563,
-0.2745225727558136,
-0.1624542772769928,
0.49151933193206787,
-0.3241746425628662,
-0.07080261409282684,
-0.0861198678612709,
-0.5533810257911682,
-0.3313591778278351,
-0.323273241519928,
0.1083495244383812,
0.1371789425611496,
-0.38703688979148865,
0.5846262574195862,
0.6952803134918213,
-0.5234059691429138,
-0.8711687326431274,
-0.5686254501342773,
0.28362444043159485,
-0.282649427652359,
-0.5116047263145447,
0.3165644109249115,
0.004648520611226559,
-0.1937629133462906,
-0.18631748855113983,
-0.1731688380241394,
-0.3150629997253418,
-0.001386161195114255,
0.3784850537776947,
0.493390828371048,
0.17118704319000244,
0.11153186857700348,
-0.47416847944259644,
-0.06326555460691452,
0.016991136595606804,
0.03901975601911545,
0.8059208393096924,
0.0675024539232254,
-0.4263574182987213,
-0.47694623470306396,
0.5383995175361633,
0.48820826411247253,
-0.1358727067708969,
0.7679219841957092,
0.7566401958465576,
-0.31329745054244995,
-0.3228115141391754,
-0.4873863160610199,
0.15797308087348938,
-0.4458244740962982,
0.47073882818222046,
-0.25775009393692017,
-0.7057465314865112,
0.35238945484161377,
-0.06395707279443741,
0.3731156885623932,
0.22875335812568665,
0.8167650103569031,
-0.3799966275691986,
0.917341411113739,
0.8408963680267334,
-0.11843905597925186,
0.707095205783844,
-0.053326550871133804,
0.2282285839319229,
-1.0871535539627075,
-0.6135110855102539,
-0.6300352215766907,
-0.1670028269290924,
-0.3901810050010681,
-0.47987473011016846,
0.40971800684928894,
-0.23423753678798676,
-0.08898130804300308,
0.1662023663520813,
-0.3567107021808624,
-0.019431069493293762,
0.8206691145896912,
0.08791951090097427,
0.3134109675884247,
-0.08559306710958481,
0.5154969096183777,
0.04458951950073242,
-0.6861009001731873,
-0.6039866209030151,
1.2008650302886963,
0.309533953666687,
0.7398757934570312,
0.2530866861343384,
0.5095681548118591,
0.5870148539543152,
0.22408850491046906,
-0.7255401611328125,
0.5527610778808594,
0.14791707694530487,
-0.633847177028656,
-0.6300155520439148,
-0.4662758409976959,
-1.2003533840179443,
0.34520047903060913,
-0.3248673677444458,
-0.8452212810516357,
-0.0068724132142961025,
0.04301105812191963,
-0.2152576744556427,
0.1337313950061798,
-0.47000354528427124,
0.7475945949554443,
-0.2498323917388916,
-0.2014797478914261,
-0.20194809138774872,
-0.5876667499542236,
0.27818945050239563,
-0.169842928647995,
0.19430026412010193,
-0.6004471182823181,
0.18132944405078888,
1.021180272102356,
-0.44268032908439636,
0.8393857479095459,
-0.17419907450675964,
-0.35380372405052185,
0.3816045820713043,
-0.22379618883132935,
0.6978914737701416,
-0.2598538100719452,
-0.208060160279274,
0.2503063380718231,
-0.19146594405174255,
-0.2116643637418747,
-0.3853698968887329,
0.2319062352180481,
-0.4476664364337921,
-0.47391098737716675,
-0.3176088333129883,
-0.9737263321876526,
-0.8434383869171143,
0.11583857238292694,
-0.04132213443517685,
0.480811208486557,
-0.10572627186775208,
0.27928367257118225,
0.399187833070755,
-0.39049792289733887,
0.2753203809261322,
0.5611456632614136,
0.11907438933849335,
-0.29028037190437317,
0.8360701203346252,
-0.15565431118011475,
0.027858734130859375,
-0.0596797801554203,
0.06272067129611969,
-0.5314688682556152,
-0.43408507108688354,
-0.4583847224712372,
0.02213151939213276,
-0.6660708785057068,
-0.3632957935333252,
-0.6402407884597778,
-0.09281094372272491,
-0.393759161233902,
0.4031684994697571,
-0.34432730078697205,
0.016940275207161903,
-0.03073456883430481,
0.1745252162218094,
0.3703766167163849,
0.7685708999633789,
0.2053014189004898,
0.3289238512516022,
-1.0605499744415283,
0.5860486030578613,
0.4874330163002014,
0.39508846402168274,
-0.047676932066679,
-0.2033454030752182,
-0.47725820541381836,
0.4035499393939972,
-0.30393192172050476,
-0.7709224820137024,
0.4640660285949707,
0.16528409719467163,
0.7873521447181702,
0.07513149082660675,
0.19349195063114166,
0.8466508388519287,
-0.45096126198768616,
0.6787191033363342,
0.17091450095176697,
-0.7939077615737915,
0.49694979190826416,
-0.4668896794319153,
-0.053972307592630386,
0.3133588433265686,
0.004870241973549128,
-0.8164356350898743,
-0.5099908709526062,
-0.6231564283370972,
-0.8897649049758911,
1.259637475013733,
0.3361538052558899,
0.37158140540122986,
0.16686460375785828,
0.033831704407930374,
0.23503752052783966,
0.7180323600769043,
-0.4741446375846863,
-0.5151693820953369,
0.2823620140552521,
-0.24304959177970886,
-0.004932744428515434,
-0.3732863962650299,
-0.3450755178928375,
0.10645251721143723,
0.6648573875427246,
-0.0849357545375824,
0.5469098091125488,
-0.035982195287942886,
-0.046452462673187256,
0.16468441486358643,
0.7896965146064758,
0.3927823305130005,
0.7542024254798889,
-0.13577154278755188,
-0.21207115054130554,
0.1061270534992218,
-0.24992366135120392,
0.0982726514339447,
-0.13193771243095398,
0.24990929663181305,
0.08467694371938705,
0.1816045194864273,
0.9514771699905396,
-0.13231022655963898,
-0.9141746163368225,
0.32469305396080017,
0.22081655263900757,
-0.11341738700866699,
-0.1885477602481842,
0.09948688000440598,
-0.07888033241033554,
0.4720154404640198,
0.41789573431015015,
-0.14050748944282532,
0.1407419592142105,
-0.8978814482688904,
-0.0038898985367268324,
0.4379029870033264,
-0.2146569788455963,
-0.013440335169434547,
0.4482424855232239,
0.3533300757408142,
-0.6304927468299866,
0.9129496812820435,
-0.20810456573963165,
-0.4451282024383545,
0.35998812317848206,
0.40733572840690613,
0.6503434777259827,
-0.13408903777599335,
0.20111516118049622,
-0.07871497422456741,
-0.16041669249534607,
-0.0668860450387001,
0.3372909724712372,
-0.1373429298400879,
-0.9027504324913025,
-0.3725779950618744,
-0.33134400844573975,
-0.9051787853240967,
0.054236602038145065,
-0.8648934364318848,
-0.051632676273584366,
-0.020003486424684525,
-0.5215222835540771,
-0.0980745404958725,
-0.2151878923177719,
-0.9941376447677612,
0.12700369954109192,
0.27894124388694763,
0.3104702830314636,
-0.36862820386886597,
1.0709328651428223,
0.40539225935935974,
-0.016799284145236015,
-0.3667956292629242,
-0.11624018847942352,
-0.023347366601228714,
-1.037714958190918,
0.6592806577682495,
0.004241474438458681,
-0.23553189635276794,
0.048361051827669144,
-0.34427860379219055,
-0.5596562027931213,
1.0966284275054932,
0.5395700931549072,
-0.44355252385139465,
-0.27252334356307983,
0.18818317353725433,
0.5780044198036194,
-0.26104873418807983,
-0.18662677705287933,
0.4391988515853882,
0.26058369874954224,
-0.17279070615768433,
-0.9775663614273071,
-0.22732244431972504,
-0.19253863394260406,
-0.08227468281984329,
0.1158023476600647,
-0.6969779133796692,
0.8024367094039917,
-0.19090679287910461,
-0.2311168611049652,
-0.11598905175924301,
0.44202369451522827,
0.5096742510795593,
0.2994689345359802,
0.6108385920524597,
0.2218078076839447,
1.053865909576416,
-0.11477307975292206,
1.0201632976531982,
-0.13621661067008972,
0.29462915658950806,
1.3926935195922852,
-0.5243719220161438,
0.6585160493850708,
0.4314310550689697,
-0.3872992992401123,
0.35737764835357666,
0.3904688060283661,
-0.2345656007528305,
0.307504802942276,
0.2124624401330948,
-0.28588220477104187,
-0.22629877924919128,
-0.5877759456634521,
-0.21640288829803467,
0.609806478023529,
0.17423203587532043,
0.02151784859597683,
-0.09318692982196808,
0.18727028369903564,
-0.20694957673549652,
-0.3292265832424164,
-0.17014789581298828,
0.9645547270774841,
-0.009620847180485725,
-0.4781964421272278,
-0.004684514366090298,
0.10652459412813187,
0.8057553172111511,
-0.7320592403411865,
-0.03757992014288902,
0.017586393281817436,
0.02838149294257164,
-0.15541322529315948,
-0.8150025606155396,
0.2137858271598816,
0.34056103229522705,
-0.047423411160707474,
-0.6654703617095947,
0.5913180708885193,
-0.603722095489502,
-0.1142740249633789,
0.15797990560531616,
1.0272537469863892,
0.34495240449905396,
-0.08957865089178085,
-0.7401571273803711,
-0.03440601006150246,
0.038415100425481796,
-0.41576099395751953,
0.32442206144332886,
0.43841439485549927,
0.03712734580039978,
1.077791452407837,
0.8044753074645996,
0.2544764578342438,
0.3123253285884857,
0.21391507983207703,
0.5836808681488037,
-0.791749119758606,
-0.437319278717041,
-0.7307090163230896,
0.5743615031242371,
-0.11259636282920837,
-0.41823944449424744,
0.7173923254013062,
0.38674837350845337,
0.5562597513198853,
0.05100852996110916,
0.7861636281013489,
-0.035826824605464935,
0.7196303606033325,
-0.5865908265113831,
0.43380025029182434,
-0.23116092383861542,
0.044384993612766266,
-0.1018250584602356,
-0.859975278377533,
0.14401131868362427,
0.41254162788391113,
0.19562716782093048,
-0.06037212163209915,
0.46522748470306396,
0.4210257828235626,
0.40674734115600586,
-0.08950129896402359,
0.2333957403898239,
-0.19943919777870178,
0.4829472005367279,
0.43132880330085754,
1.0461887121200562,
-0.2745681405067444,
0.7608065605163574,
-0.37993931770324707,
0.37112927436828613,
-0.0429360494017601,
-0.6188977360725403,
-0.7559120655059814,
-0.607603132724762,
-0.3828437030315399,
-0.30860599875450134,
-0.11890879273414612,
1.0870479345321655,
0.7447636723518372,
-0.4208819568157196,
-0.20088927447795868,
0.2178621143102646,
0.16236890852451324,
-0.17533016204833984,
-0.16576287150382996,
0.18337753415107727,
-0.4111657440662384,
-1.0377342700958252,
0.6550294756889343,
0.20830360054969788,
0.0958823412656784,
-0.22609131038188934,
-0.298601359128952,
-0.000399555399781093,
-0.20363876223564148,
0.6079334616661072,
0.16758887469768524,
-0.5949531197547913,
0.03567091375589371,
-0.11025742441415787,
-0.28063395619392395,
0.2544493079185486,
1.000022530555725,
-0.3650149703025818,
0.4942418038845062,
-0.0022838490549474955,
0.7553552985191345,
0.35897305607795715,
0.0000060679549278574996,
0.7807103991508484,
-1.1485806703567505,
0.29541733860969543,
0.4103047549724579,
0.254585862159729,
0.24904216825962067,
-0.39335641264915466,
0.6809802055358887,
-0.060716092586517334,
-0.40062934160232544,
-1.0808186531066895,
0.03951938450336456,
-0.9733646512031555,
-0.06852692365646362,
1.1383352279663086,
-0.05669395998120308,
0.014375172555446625,
-0.5288841128349304,
-0.17647039890289307,
0.4270167648792267,
-0.6296923756599426,
0.7708083391189575,
0.7679218649864197,
-0.561207115650177,
0.004267440643161535,
-0.8509292006492615,
0.43694645166397095,
0.04974872246384621,
-1.2883572578430176,
0.5036654472351074,
0.5316688418388367,
0.05535763129591942,
0.09922652691602707,
1.076722264289856,
0.12424805015325546,
-0.04042370617389679,
-0.10769760608673096,
0.377900630235672,
-0.3030281364917755,
-0.38440385460853577,
-0.09573117643594742,
0.19061872363090515,
0.0031705121509730816,
-0.600558340549469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01783v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01783v1 | Hierarchical Multi-Label Classification of Online Vaccine Concerns | 2024-02-01T20:56:07 | 2024-02-01T20:56:07 | Chloe Qinyu Zhu, Rickard Stureborg, Bhuwan Dhingra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Vaccine concerns are an ever-evolving target, and can shift quickly as seen
during the COVID-19 pandemic. Identifying longitudinal trends in vaccine
concerns and misinformation might inform the healthcare space by helping public
health efforts strategically allocate resources or information campaigns. We
explore the task of detecting vaccine concerns in online discourse using large
language models (LLMs) in a zero-shot setting without the need for expensive
training datasets. Since real-time monitoring of online sources requires
large-scale inference, we explore cost-accuracy trade-offs of different
prompting strategies and offer concrete takeaways that may inform choices in
system designs for current applications. An analysis of different prompting
strategies reveals that classifying the concerns over multiple passes through
the LLM, each consisting a boolean question whether the text mentions a vaccine
concern or not, works the best. Our results indicate that GPT-4 can strongly
outperform crowdworker accuracy when compared to ground truth annotations
provided by experts on the recently introduced VaxConcerns dataset, achieving
an overall F1 score of 78.7%. | [
-0.38622674345970154,
-0.8217245936393738,
0.4897112250328064,
0.15253189206123352,
0.0019081023056060076,
-0.08663710951805115,
0.06918718665838242,
-0.7468145489692688,
0.057925980538129807,
-0.025874627754092216,
-0.2295244187116623,
-0.47007742524147034,
-0.6888799667358398,
0.17609411478042603,
-0.28039228916168213,
1.0502303838729858,
-0.008788450621068478,
-0.1297469288110733,
-0.2455766201019287,
0.3572978079319,
-0.092476025223732,
-0.6644372940063477,
-0.7766690254211426,
-0.5025214552879333,
0.896501898765564,
0.5324365496635437,
0.22887171804904938,
0.4708734154701233,
0.25134703516960144,
0.20415204763412476,
-0.27072757482528687,
0.1271204799413681,
-0.33388474583625793,
0.09482886642217636,
-0.06769293546676636,
-0.603166937828064,
-0.37783005833625793,
0.269313246011734,
0.07249277085065842,
0.12328936904668808,
-0.32802605628967285,
0.3890601098537445,
-0.13577471673488617,
-0.11070949584245682,
-0.9114195704460144,
0.17937341332435608,
-0.5036969780921936,
0.30443131923675537,
-0.3187693953514099,
-0.4408435821533203,
-0.5543069243431091,
-0.0650654062628746,
0.16995978355407715,
-0.5263968706130981,
0.2999892830848694,
-0.14898523688316345,
0.9479278326034546,
-0.026777371764183044,
-0.6375229358673096,
-0.15607775747776031,
-0.5381318926811218,
0.7118334770202637,
-0.6055284738540649,
0.27585551142692566,
0.8609285354614258,
0.23229363560676575,
-0.008030273020267487,
-0.6332241892814636,
-0.34006059169769287,
0.0923539400100708,
0.2144193798303604,
0.3346793055534363,
-0.8299267292022705,
0.2638590633869171,
0.2362568974494934,
0.15792834758758545,
-0.5942805409431458,
0.3523496389389038,
-0.36924996972084045,
-0.4952008128166199,
0.2946590483188629,
-0.08310893177986145,
0.04602232575416565,
-0.266763299703598,
-0.1982051134109497,
0.16686230897903442,
-0.6156901717185974,
0.30535057187080383,
0.08761168271303177,
-0.04104357957839966,
-0.39291831851005554,
0.28086864948272705,
-0.2506684958934784,
0.7121844291687012,
0.5390300750732422,
-0.3943622410297394,
0.04562986642122269,
-0.3503720760345459,
-0.22889810800552368,
0.08374600857496262,
0.5841407179832458,
0.5355138778686523,
-0.037336260080337524,
0.27096375823020935,
0.056456293910741806,
-0.04230852425098419,
0.3350060284137726,
-0.864366888999939,
-0.24704323709011078,
0.3582608699798584,
-0.2808834910392761,
-0.16028845310211182,
-0.10721773654222488,
-0.8867427110671997,
-0.6172165274620056,
-0.08581226319074631,
0.27056601643562317,
-0.12852658331394196,
0.12996958196163177,
0.13502854108810425,
-0.24982362985610962,
0.13849374651908875,
0.6720764636993408,
-0.7897576093673706,
-0.19015942513942719,
0.8210136294364929,
0.8774879574775696,
0.0001013362270896323,
0.38035324215888977,
-0.7544426321983337,
0.2241831123828888,
-0.2917397618293762,
1.203957200050354,
-0.5076410174369812,
-0.25119200348854065,
0.10077014565467834,
-0.1842091679573059,
-0.16216887533664703,
-0.4440297484397888,
0.4614667296409607,
-0.31938204169273376,
0.43893131613731384,
-0.29648128151893616,
-0.5481408834457397,
0.07524960488080978,
0.8596712946891785,
-0.23416665196418762,
0.6201707124710083,
-0.10283881425857544,
-1.079006552696228,
0.5328788161277771,
-0.4423429071903229,
-0.22881931066513062,
0.37410783767700195,
-0.41426536440849304,
-0.614635169506073,
-0.10149742662906647,
0.49415123462677,
0.5874620676040649,
-0.31023314595222473,
0.4463350772857666,
-0.3356362283229828,
-0.11616648733615875,
0.26539766788482666,
-0.5268704891204834,
0.3701068162918091,
0.011572053655982018,
-0.39848023653030396,
0.2165132761001587,
-0.5001606345176697,
-0.11958847939968109,
-0.27693459391593933,
-0.41390469670295715,
-0.3772338628768921,
-0.04677131399512291,
-0.3128747344017029,
0.08800013363361359,
0.033671822398900986,
-0.5163281559944153,
0.3425224721431732,
-0.42346513271331787,
0.3830645978450775,
0.5662978887557983,
0.5019010901451111,
-0.04117969423532486,
-0.4565373361110687,
0.824607253074646,
0.16634055972099304,
0.6122156381607056,
-0.22522372007369995,
-1.3154772520065308,
-0.6436350345611572,
-0.5296908020973206,
0.10745174437761307,
0.5844168066978455,
-0.6493757963180542,
0.22362367808818817,
0.0871138647198677,
-0.47953441739082336,
-0.3556618392467499,
-0.40490832924842834,
0.35488995909690857,
0.6000275611877441,
0.3793160617351532,
0.06670070439577103,
-0.2274339199066162,
-0.8496026992797852,
-0.175557479262352,
-0.5048781633377075,
-0.06755167245864868,
0.34041836857795715,
0.33961841464042664,
-0.2154884934425354,
0.6637067198753357,
-0.6799163818359375,
0.013745891861617565,
0.11214716732501984,
0.759075403213501,
-0.031215233728289604,
-0.06024599075317383,
0.38504576683044434,
-0.5901463031768799,
-0.46262189745903015,
0.31299063563346863,
-0.4606056213378906,
-0.33129629492759705,
-0.04751533642411232,
0.4933535158634186,
-0.046746980398893356,
0.36909082531929016,
-0.6635124087333679,
0.6386287212371826,
0.40398627519607544,
0.06054248660802841,
0.39424929022789,
-0.2493516504764557,
0.33194756507873535,
-0.9109891653060913,
-0.07141541689634323,
0.4020826816558838,
0.018795495852828026,
-0.9154569506645203,
-0.1463032215833664,
0.026648063212633133,
0.12390966713428497,
-0.6247735023498535,
0.453238844871521,
-0.119117870926857,
0.34113264083862305,
-0.041412755846977234,
-0.21186603605747223,
0.2819138169288635,
-0.09967416524887085,
-0.12896184623241425,
0.685487687587738,
0.5077582597732544,
-0.6591220498085022,
0.5993638038635254,
0.1583973467350006,
-0.22515222430229187,
0.7007209658622742,
-0.2791932225227356,
0.04385422542691231,
-0.14198185503482819,
0.639508068561554,
-0.7894145250320435,
-0.5246293544769287,
0.5640513896942139,
-0.48798492550849915,
0.19464156031608582,
0.03628493845462799,
-0.29042473435401917,
-0.712996244430542,
-0.4244830906391144,
0.3548392653465271,
0.09299007058143616,
-0.3486962616443634,
0.0824575424194336,
0.5750070214271545,
-0.21258476376533508,
-0.5643157958984375,
-0.7314004898071289,
0.22414398193359375,
-0.2853989601135254,
-0.20637398958206177,
0.2843479514122009,
0.15695999562740326,
-0.22095522284507751,
-0.3187198340892792,
-0.17644591629505157,
-0.4149133861064911,
-0.09134126454591751,
0.3068656027317047,
-0.027339091524481773,
-0.1366385817527771,
0.48435062170028687,
-0.013284855522215366,
-0.28317612409591675,
-0.12367944419384003,
-0.23004721105098724,
0.06964828819036484,
0.14632466435432434,
-0.44086167216300964,
-0.7572907209396362,
0.5241021513938904,
0.37882232666015625,
0.0028596650809049606,
0.4230850040912628,
0.6351158618927002,
-0.5522060990333557,
-0.04679371416568756,
-0.8025903105735779,
-0.2233305126428604,
-0.381136417388916,
-0.027339601889252663,
-0.23719394207000732,
-1.0343050956726074,
0.20509469509124756,
-0.09182072430849075,
-0.13069216907024384,
0.32567650079727173,
0.563983142375946,
-0.03551872819662094,
1.00957453250885,
0.35892027616500854,
-0.01568993180990219,
0.1763812154531479,
0.18513032793998718,
0.3188239634037018,
-0.26631638407707214,
-0.6043744087219238,
-0.7553289532661438,
0.09838958829641342,
-0.5797616243362427,
-0.7079934477806091,
0.5767666697502136,
0.03581175208091736,
-0.21703357994556427,
0.1953107714653015,
-0.6631981730461121,
0.15647774934768677,
0.5284654498100281,
0.07434701919555664,
0.29518774151802063,
0.05135060101747513,
0.014946079812943935,
-0.0059606353752315044,
-1.0984073877334595,
-0.09919118136167526,
0.6679860353469849,
0.42911994457244873,
0.7026333808898926,
0.03865532949566841,
0.42472192645072937,
0.2751506567001343,
0.38720884919166565,
-0.9571676254272461,
0.1526312679052353,
0.020178724080324173,
-0.828441858291626,
-0.027534322813153267,
-0.35833773016929626,
-1.2923136949539185,
0.1607704907655716,
-0.21326519548892975,
-1.0268765687942505,
0.6086133718490601,
0.42784759402275085,
-0.7526353597640991,
0.28525081276893616,
-0.6796697974205017,
0.6751057505607605,
-0.2761363387107849,
-0.15033604204654694,
-0.2517399489879608,
-0.54059237241745,
0.25721555948257446,
-0.4407927989959717,
0.31947246193885803,
-0.2048230916261673,
0.017342545092105865,
0.3726215958595276,
-0.3604404628276825,
1.1562879085540771,
0.2340874820947647,
-0.2131623774766922,
0.3958834111690521,
-0.4917669892311096,
0.24929921329021454,
-0.004563384223729372,
-0.06932975351810455,
0.33589550852775574,
0.09109551459550858,
-0.23769177496433258,
-0.01921694353222847,
0.43635961413383484,
-0.6494177579879761,
-0.9109023809432983,
-0.8224272727966309,
-0.15772221982479095,
-0.2048153579235077,
-0.054494984447956085,
0.5593916177749634,
0.3359139561653137,
-0.07640281319618225,
0.12656167149543762,
0.6121653914451599,
-0.6983819603919983,
0.1949291229248047,
0.567417323589325,
0.03833886981010437,
-0.2484498769044876,
0.7289897203445435,
0.39131665229797363,
0.18097679316997528,
0.7147536277770996,
0.6146680116653442,
-0.3274171054363251,
-0.19450783729553223,
-0.35933253169059753,
0.06801088899374008,
-0.6256820559501648,
-0.4277380406856537,
-0.6668427586555481,
-0.18458537757396698,
-0.617910623550415,
0.024812959134578705,
-0.017149990424513817,
-0.0022620840463787317,
-0.6507322192192078,
-0.25316566228866577,
0.5269820690155029,
0.9441002011299133,
-0.17146706581115723,
0.24427469074726105,
-0.8360604047775269,
0.3856615722179413,
0.6390029191970825,
0.35957032442092896,
-0.134402796626091,
-0.5091623067855835,
-0.20295679569244385,
-0.04708727449178696,
-0.5262453556060791,
-1.0738691091537476,
0.2801572382450104,
0.15162132680416107,
0.5262638330459595,
0.8887033462524414,
0.2684961259365082,
0.7390933036804199,
-0.32652103900909424,
0.7680992484092712,
0.37645888328552246,
-0.8492441773414612,
0.5661801695823669,
-0.42898139357566833,
0.601100742816925,
0.06380002945661545,
0.9030240178108215,
-0.7856568694114685,
-0.3040279746055603,
-0.39368894696235657,
-0.7231979370117188,
0.5800079703330994,
-0.0805632546544075,
-0.29537588357925415,
-0.4006926119327545,
0.14781557023525238,
0.09196276217699051,
0.13479997217655182,
-0.4443942606449127,
-0.09403756260871887,
-0.11761361360549927,
0.239676833152771,
0.1890508234500885,
-0.33668413758277893,
-0.24817156791687012,
-0.2810071110725403,
0.4392298460006714,
-0.112981416285038,
0.14048200845718384,
0.13745924830436707,
0.4681723713874817,
-0.2673710882663727,
0.6918017864227295,
0.7343478798866272,
0.7077218890190125,
-0.05646329000592232,
0.5215288400650024,
0.09611887484788895,
-0.3373945653438568,
0.3066326081752777,
-0.030525995418429375,
-0.33489707112312317,
0.027007749304175377,
0.43554773926734924,
0.9027246236801147,
0.22708480060100555,
-0.3115849196910858,
0.7605161070823669,
0.1540021449327469,
-0.329956591129303,
0.09924666583538055,
-0.25722962617874146,
0.1336064338684082,
0.13612355291843414,
0.24527092278003693,
-0.13673366606235504,
0.307217538356781,
-0.35943713784217834,
0.47062966227531433,
0.31057846546173096,
-0.4576632082462311,
-0.4228174388408661,
0.4079618752002716,
0.1857943832874298,
-0.08657249808311462,
0.2669045329093933,
-0.023049406707286835,
-0.2747664153575897,
0.5701073408126831,
0.5272687077522278,
0.5398359894752502,
-0.7406652569770813,
0.6481417417526245,
0.21695315837860107,
0.24283847212791443,
-0.31974413990974426,
-0.045535627752542496,
0.1920047402381897,
-0.5098164081573486,
-0.6365225911140442,
-0.2366400510072708,
-0.6169400811195374,
0.5916268825531006,
-0.6767435669898987,
0.2635258436203003,
-0.3117839992046356,
-0.7753670811653137,
0.35837221145629883,
-0.46460598707199097,
-0.2929166257381439,
0.26993441581726074,
0.48782190680503845,
0.7430519461631775,
-1.0287525653839111,
0.5989067554473877,
0.5759751200675964,
-0.28085967898368835,
-0.5620971322059631,
0.22093789279460907,
0.37802231311798096,
-0.5862231850624084,
0.44359090924263,
0.495991975069046,
0.05683746933937073,
-0.38869714736938477,
-0.6132888197898865,
-0.614361047744751,
0.7814000248908997,
0.33043235540390015,
-0.6150492429733276,
-0.052873626351356506,
0.053656045347452164,
0.4960138499736786,
-0.16234789788722992,
0.36134862899780273,
0.19800476729869843,
0.5496764779090881,
0.25841662287712097,
-1.0449700355529785,
-0.28964897990226746,
-0.030388668179512024,
-0.3271755278110504,
0.11015795171260834,
-0.5014968514442444,
0.8347257375717163,
-0.058174144476652145,
-0.4006804823875427,
-0.3378691077232361,
0.2516458332538605,
0.18304821848869324,
0.7736117839813232,
0.23002418875694275,
0.531061053276062,
0.948400616645813,
-0.1149723008275032,
1.0977063179016113,
-0.05984912067651749,
0.22158770263195038,
0.859731137752533,
-0.2369140237569809,
0.8113295435905457,
0.29146698117256165,
-0.1436709612607956,
0.1129414364695549,
1.0057142972946167,
-0.014433838427066803,
0.11322583258152008,
0.3672635853290558,
-0.5415689945220947,
-0.5859590172767639,
-0.512589693069458,
-0.7128151059150696,
0.3413960039615631,
0.6403346657752991,
0.07142087072134018,
-0.3263288140296936,
0.23319655656814575,
0.15247568488121033,
-0.3052304983139038,
-0.4065627455711365,
0.8090388178825378,
0.19073593616485596,
-0.7077886462211609,
0.383865088224411,
0.10455989092588425,
0.5962807536125183,
-0.4997042119503021,
-0.11529894918203354,
-0.006683599203824997,
0.22509895265102386,
-0.23895709216594696,
-0.6383596658706665,
0.06218845397233963,
0.10285615921020508,
-0.18914814293384552,
-0.23534120619297028,
0.7672129273414612,
-0.4902303218841553,
-0.37336307764053345,
0.3030425012111664,
0.5629128813743591,
0.304110050201416,
-0.2904083728790283,
-0.886981725692749,
0.16097983717918396,
-0.10812259465456009,
-0.15653401613235474,
0.371913880109787,
0.40224167704582214,
-0.4914920926094055,
0.6648959517478943,
0.533473014831543,
0.1371825933456421,
0.05792774632573128,
0.11913789063692093,
0.5265284180641174,
-0.29800713062286377,
-0.4208977520465851,
-0.6666383743286133,
0.3352375030517578,
-0.16444161534309387,
-0.36171188950538635,
0.7534863352775574,
0.37131649255752563,
0.6878221035003662,
-0.04719242453575134,
0.8604822158813477,
0.359214186668396,
0.49285203218460083,
-0.051380280405282974,
0.5371646285057068,
-0.38919997215270996,
-0.12116113305091858,
0.06741330772638321,
-0.14713065326213837,
-0.6474012136459351,
0.6311092972755432,
-0.5257986187934875,
-0.01943785697221756,
0.640955924987793,
0.5840879082679749,
0.2929610013961792,
-0.04532628133893013,
0.47066840529441833,
0.20946060121059418,
0.3968704342842102,
0.3483131229877472,
0.8756251335144043,
-0.05857895687222481,
0.37575531005859375,
-0.014055338688194752,
-0.3810974657535553,
-0.6253364086151123,
-1.0224303007125854,
-0.7699946761131287,
-0.3408285975456238,
-0.761537492275238,
-0.2566245496273041,
0.283291220664978,
0.9805058836936951,
0.8297063112258911,
-1.116681456565857,
0.01638837158679962,
0.12322036921977997,
-0.1332024335861206,
-0.06656890362501144,
-0.1908937245607376,
0.1634114384651184,
-0.1248822957277298,
-0.36539825797080994,
0.3177598714828491,
0.6102964878082275,
-0.00973181240260601,
0.023678136989474297,
0.32022324204444885,
-0.5529288053512573,
0.14928124845027924,
0.6805961728096008,
0.550944983959198,
-1.0376592874526978,
-0.3967492878437042,
-0.02165387012064457,
-0.36209219694137573,
0.20575730502605438,
0.5140951871871948,
-0.4032806158065796,
0.8442654013633728,
0.5892862677574158,
0.7245291471481323,
0.7295632362365723,
0.23610234260559082,
0.4874698519706726,
-0.5841769576072693,
-0.17037908732891083,
0.1341981738805771,
0.08109038323163986,
0.42406314611434937,
-0.40488460659980774,
0.04548253118991852,
0.49108633399009705,
-0.4456007182598114,
-0.4196026027202606,
0.36540037393569946,
-0.7355716228485107,
-0.26640409231185913,
1.3497687578201294,
-0.31390538811683655,
-0.07054638117551804,
-0.63576740026474,
-0.10749723017215729,
0.3561706244945526,
-0.6085474491119385,
0.7592437863349915,
0.7318735718727112,
-0.3427463471889496,
-0.34842708706855774,
-0.5737394690513611,
0.4302579164505005,
0.08015794306993484,
-0.9725816249847412,
-0.21333260834217072,
0.5106513500213623,
-0.07665921747684479,
0.25861918926239014,
0.8158701658248901,
0.1870962381362915,
0.16549937427043915,
0.010396535508334637,
0.15844117105007172,
0.27742427587509155,
-0.33291974663734436,
-0.4286900758743286,
0.4873247742652893,
-0.08752042800188065,
-0.09822279214859009
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00978v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00978v1 | An Information-Theoretic Approach to Analyze NLP Classification Tasks | 2024-02-01T19:49:44 | 2024-02-01T19:49:44 | Luran Wang, Mark Gales, Vatsal Raina | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IT, math.IT | Understanding the importance of the inputs on the output is useful across
many tasks. This work provides an information-theoretic framework to analyse
the influence of inputs for text classification tasks. Natural language
processing (NLP) tasks take either a single element input or multiple element
inputs to predict an output variable, where an element is a block of text. Each
text element has two components: an associated semantic meaning and a
linguistic realization. Multiple-choice reading comprehension (MCRC) and
sentiment classification (SC) are selected to showcase the framework. For MCRC,
it is found that the context influence on the output compared to the question
influence reduces on more challenging datasets. In particular, more challenging
contexts allow a greater variation in complexity of questions. Hence, test
creators need to carefully consider the choice of the context when designing
multiple-choice questions for assessment. For SC, it is found the semantic
meaning of the input text dominates (above 80\% for all datasets considered)
compared to its linguistic realisation when determining the sentiment. The
framework is made available at:
https://github.com/WangLuran/nlp-element-influence | [
-0.50022292137146,
-0.765030026435852,
0.30046001076698303,
0.33401596546173096,
0.08287988603115082,
-0.24668630957603455,
-0.18242213129997253,
-0.5334060192108154,
-0.09304387122392654,
0.38965681195259094,
-0.49153953790664673,
-0.25825557112693787,
-0.7951958179473877,
0.2006155252456665,
-0.2115699052810669,
1.2520649433135986,
-0.04845355823636055,
0.08193272352218628,
-0.35613247752189636,
-0.007399387191981077,
-0.3092058002948761,
-0.6832592487335205,
-0.7668110728263855,
-0.3135858178138733,
0.7430339455604553,
0.29237881302833557,
0.5097785592079163,
0.2996094822883606,
0.740547239780426,
0.22824417054653168,
-0.21801169216632843,
-0.16856782138347626,
-0.18741557002067566,
0.2635135054588318,
-0.5981613397598267,
-0.5907149910926819,
-0.002765773795545101,
0.04211155325174332,
0.5450447797775269,
0.6046299934387207,
-0.012577003799378872,
0.3426457941532135,
0.44681647419929504,
0.47897443175315857,
-0.746504008769989,
0.48548534512519836,
-0.36697205901145935,
0.09277960658073425,
-0.23243071138858795,
-0.6552174091339111,
-0.6894971132278442,
0.10421928018331528,
0.2969101369380951,
-0.32117268443107605,
0.20208857953548431,
0.09788677841424942,
0.659679114818573,
0.4016329348087311,
-0.4167036712169647,
-0.6378225088119507,
-0.7745285630226135,
1.0641263723373413,
-0.5165733695030212,
0.2621704041957855,
0.5262760519981384,
0.07181993126869202,
-0.0761946439743042,
-0.3137955069541931,
-0.721382200717926,
0.17843139171600342,
-0.38419634103775024,
0.1329692304134369,
0.015238477848470211,
0.18123900890350342,
0.20254859328269958,
0.19370722770690918,
-0.44316667318344116,
-0.09790924936532974,
-0.2561660706996918,
0.013586174696683884,
0.4852377474308014,
-0.02452908270061016,
0.5193936824798584,
-0.5580816864967346,
-0.2677386403083801,
-0.30011942982673645,
-0.1094784364104271,
0.37185874581336975,
0.0816723108291626,
0.47240594029426575,
0.09046850353479385,
0.7303595542907715,
-0.2445613145828247,
1.0237503051757812,
-0.03229011222720146,
-0.3675380349159241,
0.242995485663414,
-0.6064329743385315,
-0.2737288475036621,
0.266129732131958,
0.7003610134124756,
0.1458663046360016,
-0.1532330960035324,
0.08183857798576355,
0.12273988127708435,
0.14717888832092285,
0.45139825344085693,
-0.7931472659111023,
0.16888411343097687,
0.23107582330703735,
-0.3354290723800659,
-0.5416325330734253,
0.22236290574073792,
-0.8796079754829407,
-0.4594270884990692,
-0.5181047916412354,
0.28337687253952026,
-0.3768691122531891,
-0.24837790429592133,
0.15908020734786987,
-0.23230674862861633,
0.47818878293037415,
0.25807690620422363,
-0.9039864540100098,
0.3106672167778015,
0.6643278002738953,
0.617730975151062,
-0.34753838181495667,
-0.18049484491348267,
-0.37077227234840393,
-0.0609222874045372,
0.10990789532661438,
0.768765926361084,
-0.670652449131012,
0.05930427834391594,
-0.15722577273845673,
-0.12916213274002075,
-0.5145130753517151,
-0.1219995766878128,
0.8558319807052612,
-0.6230315566062927,
0.642194390296936,
-0.14632819592952728,
-0.6098929047584534,
-0.42126476764678955,
0.48308858275413513,
-0.7096312046051025,
1.1968201398849487,
0.17111143469810486,
-1.4614604711532593,
0.4210108816623688,
-0.8678158521652222,
-0.3989216387271881,
0.057916585355997086,
-0.16626428067684174,
0.017439236864447594,
-0.055485233664512634,
0.001438545761629939,
0.7968628406524658,
-0.29615622758865356,
0.26146799325942993,
-0.1667124629020691,
-0.055734556168317795,
0.38713663816452026,
-0.3654455542564392,
0.8553581237792969,
0.07734567672014236,
-0.48544254899024963,
-0.1490696221590042,
-0.9351328611373901,
0.16083504259586334,
-0.23592564463615417,
-0.5736833810806274,
-0.6009023785591125,
0.3008232116699219,
0.2496691793203354,
0.47019651532173157,
-0.1961943656206131,
-0.6563368439674377,
-0.07039936631917953,
-0.5561518669128418,
0.18734019994735718,
0.5228708982467651,
0.14642997086048126,
0.5079042315483093,
-0.17003875970840454,
0.6440253257751465,
-0.11548775434494019,
-0.06060653552412987,
0.11697644740343094,
-0.5825240015983582,
-0.59302818775177,
-0.06501588225364685,
0.5876383781433105,
0.7942518591880798,
-0.8980811834335327,
0.392204225063324,
-0.03472484275698662,
-0.34873366355895996,
-0.41798484325408936,
0.06799860298633575,
0.1474236398935318,
0.49919596314430237,
0.31815704703330994,
-0.21439343690872192,
-0.6415858268737793,
-0.6106513142585754,
-0.3252979815006256,
-0.4053879976272583,
0.004161356016993523,
0.06503254175186157,
0.4706229567527771,
-0.28611302375793457,
0.9891515970230103,
-0.4239315092563629,
-0.4083727300167084,
-0.4940887987613678,
0.15915490686893463,
0.22447584569454193,
0.4622972011566162,
0.5335322618484497,
-0.9440158009529114,
-0.26596567034721375,
0.14002420008182526,
-0.5999102592468262,
-0.168610081076622,
-0.3143666684627533,
-0.2971619963645935,
-0.09085147827863693,
0.3146497905254364,
-0.533755362033844,
0.5151539444923401,
0.5755711793899536,
-0.5446874499320984,
0.5427716970443726,
0.22237762808799744,
0.01756700873374939,
-0.977850079536438,
0.05493411421775818,
0.17292355000972748,
0.05123354122042656,
-0.8004685044288635,
0.2558784484863281,
-0.1765764355659485,
0.23415116965770721,
-0.2114240974187851,
0.5480399131774902,
0.17767855525016785,
0.2395886480808258,
-0.19633954763412476,
0.029441995546221733,
0.1975901573896408,
0.477154016494751,
0.0829709991812706,
0.4211030900478363,
0.3526000380516052,
-0.8864433765411377,
0.12288589030504227,
0.12063126266002655,
-0.3386286199092865,
0.6225151419639587,
-0.41462159156799316,
-0.264283686876297,
-0.366391658782959,
-0.025587067008018494,
-1.1296263933181763,
-0.25527819991111755,
0.4834676682949066,
-0.721567690372467,
0.2287648767232895,
0.3440881371498108,
-0.5806832313537598,
0.019981659948825836,
-0.1611029952764511,
0.2568381130695343,
-0.0769895687699318,
-0.4324396252632141,
0.9132730960845947,
0.3095690906047821,
-0.3133814334869385,
-0.7995080351829529,
-0.7693303823471069,
-0.31846532225608826,
-0.23262330889701843,
-0.37582799792289734,
0.3721204102039337,
-0.09637172520160675,
-0.4382323622703552,
-0.004322177730500698,
-0.01713542826473713,
-0.3793066442012787,
0.1374143809080124,
0.3040299713611603,
0.19682617485523224,
0.0012514221016317606,
0.45149457454681396,
0.25494515895843506,
-0.007254733704030514,
0.3073067367076874,
-0.08052556216716766,
0.4515370726585388,
-0.056194204837083817,
-0.05004747956991196,
-0.5068966150283813,
0.31171178817749023,
0.39326736330986023,
-0.11677964776754379,
0.8764722347259521,
0.7819856405258179,
-0.13361062109470367,
-0.5502244830131531,
-0.2031390368938446,
-0.01060769334435463,
-0.4048168361186981,
0.42040756344795227,
-0.25077658891677856,
-0.6636990308761597,
0.05136563628911972,
0.14309650659561157,
0.19146595895290375,
0.7129355669021606,
0.586854875087738,
-0.4658493399620056,
1.0100263357162476,
0.6176710724830627,
-0.10705612599849701,
0.5863684415817261,
-0.1508694291114807,
0.16389675438404083,
-0.7788475155830383,
-0.15869343280792236,
-0.6570264101028442,
-0.22415730357170105,
-0.4642644226551056,
-0.3379667103290558,
0.0467669703066349,
0.08873139321804047,
0.05347409471869469,
0.1567583680152893,
-0.6198605298995972,
0.19298000633716583,
0.4705392122268677,
0.0745861828327179,
0.09734851866960526,
-0.07389818876981735,
-0.16674713790416718,
-0.046464189887046814,
-0.8652656078338623,
-0.49067291617393494,
1.0343466997146606,
0.3055935800075531,
0.43205180764198303,
0.13892723619937897,
0.4278840720653534,
0.32600390911102295,
0.2271977663040161,
-1.1272296905517578,
0.38087448477745056,
0.13274112343788147,
-0.5900029540061951,
-0.19593545794487,
-0.3781321942806244,
-1.0111193656921387,
0.503546416759491,
-0.4836151599884033,
-0.4228225350379944,
0.09094282239675522,
0.04795665666460991,
-0.10897298902273178,
0.10408905893564224,
-0.6668041348457336,
0.7320833802223206,
-0.17136122286319733,
-0.10807838290929794,
0.003437609877437353,
-0.4823608100414276,
0.23742040991783142,
0.008460941724479198,
0.45014846324920654,
0.20860743522644043,
0.13720519840717316,
1.1090149879455566,
-0.014412395656108856,
0.9967135190963745,
-0.16975530982017517,
0.03537522628903389,
0.3473999500274658,
-0.11606188118457794,
0.1493317186832428,
-0.01867101527750492,
-0.37783434987068176,
-0.16409680247306824,
0.36614036560058594,
-0.2931946814060211,
-0.8363486528396606,
0.24428535997867584,
-0.6208165287971497,
-0.21728870272636414,
-0.6943270564079285,
-0.504255473613739,
-0.32205793261528015,
0.24347548186779022,
0.3601130247116089,
0.48732128739356995,
0.022051025182008743,
0.3600372076034546,
0.6923003196716309,
-0.12024720758199692,
0.4214397668838501,
0.1109066978096962,
-0.2489733099937439,
0.05956752598285675,
0.674454927444458,
0.04398859292268753,
0.27181899547576904,
0.6265562772750854,
0.4326784014701843,
-0.19827504456043243,
-0.39392149448394775,
-0.23279845714569092,
0.07171641290187836,
-0.9582494497299194,
-0.0917666032910347,
-0.5653539896011353,
-0.1514257937669754,
-0.19895894825458527,
0.02756522037088871,
0.17150524258613586,
-0.402524471282959,
-0.4673078954219818,
-0.19052322208881378,
0.1276024430990219,
0.8285766839981079,
0.3109751343727112,
0.5149123072624207,
-0.48253631591796875,
0.15225055813789368,
0.2622596323490143,
0.38641640543937683,
-0.005888255778700113,
-0.37852129340171814,
-0.1404840350151062,
-0.23260310292243958,
-0.33109450340270996,
-0.9709874391555786,
0.2267247885465622,
0.2764556109905243,
0.5864078998565674,
0.4926084578037262,
0.2036484181880951,
0.17705681920051575,
-0.19064858555793762,
0.710515022277832,
0.10710413008928299,
-1.015925645828247,
0.5140417218208313,
-0.029637405648827553,
0.41860488057136536,
0.9799675345420837,
0.41420289874076843,
-0.6263072490692139,
-0.37151557207107544,
-0.6336115598678589,
-0.5886900424957275,
0.826086163520813,
0.32572516798973083,
-0.19433322548866272,
0.14123760163784027,
0.3993178904056549,
0.012906890362501144,
0.2734966278076172,
-0.8403613567352295,
-0.18254302442073822,
-0.0013084260281175375,
-0.5230666995048523,
-0.026026200503110886,
-0.2420041859149933,
0.18027551472187042,
-0.4020686447620392,
0.6546964645385742,
-0.07287278026342392,
0.3727986812591553,
0.31733426451683044,
-0.13775044679641724,
0.24832691252231598,
0.4970369040966034,
0.4748721122741699,
0.6586865782737732,
-0.12554867565631866,
0.4059632122516632,
0.08202541619539261,
-0.6479523181915283,
-0.0807710811495781,
-0.2862235903739929,
-0.3798379600048065,
0.25830599665641785,
0.6574974060058594,
0.6748979091644287,
0.11292396485805511,
-0.5456907153129578,
0.4956870377063751,
-0.20583994686603546,
-0.24566152691841125,
-0.09213937819004059,
0.21102069318294525,
-0.16303882002830505,
-0.07566463202238083,
0.16482223570346832,
0.510085940361023,
0.4354732632637024,
-0.49618080258369446,
0.3468988537788391,
0.21892742812633514,
-0.8082663416862488,
-0.2610150873661041,
0.165873184800148,
-0.07771918922662735,
-0.1770927906036377,
0.17481178045272827,
-0.4275282323360443,
-0.7935209274291992,
0.49258142709732056,
0.43926799297332764,
0.5224120616912842,
-0.41039717197418213,
0.37847715616226196,
0.4097681939601898,
0.3139369487762451,
-0.03210530802607536,
0.36784932017326355,
-0.09317689388990402,
-0.9080685377120972,
-0.674369752407074,
-0.7911728024482727,
-0.3561522960662842,
-0.042512886226177216,
-0.9021969437599182,
0.27392423152923584,
-0.4814460873603821,
-0.16627894341945648,
0.31048911809921265,
-0.17075102031230927,
-0.802998960018158,
0.5853604078292847,
0.05099882557988167,
0.562685489654541,
-0.7458123564720154,
0.7206215858459473,
0.751950740814209,
-0.06984040141105652,
-0.8465318083763123,
-0.0801636353135109,
-0.04377082362771034,
-0.38706743717193604,
0.8785013556480408,
0.308774471282959,
-0.10978107154369354,
-0.18937988579273224,
-0.4388730823993683,
-0.9487063884735107,
0.5926161408424377,
-0.17316845059394836,
-0.030721057206392288,
-0.028753137215971947,
0.12483398616313934,
0.5789601802825928,
-0.4876149296760559,
0.3352486491203308,
0.5717865824699402,
0.5819031596183777,
0.047081612050533295,
-0.794223964214325,
-0.06268800795078278,
-0.5328361392021179,
-0.07120992243289948,
0.2425198256969452,
0.07887868583202362,
0.651098906993866,
0.10018297284841537,
-0.3265714943408966,
-0.49750858545303345,
0.3530377447605133,
0.099726602435112,
0.2857614755630493,
0.6547115445137024,
0.21053844690322876,
0.7272444367408752,
-0.05825880169868469,
1.2887182235717773,
-0.10563074052333832,
0.4116706848144531,
1.1783655881881714,
0.03533194959163666,
1.1890137195587158,
0.6966637372970581,
-0.32520103454589844,
0.6716957092285156,
0.6165832281112671,
0.1130894124507904,
0.4479324221611023,
0.4247318208217621,
0.028985995799303055,
0.16715657711029053,
-0.21536381542682648,
-0.1261792778968811,
0.8276176452636719,
0.4968012869358063,
-0.4751026928424835,
-0.13545620441436768,
0.40100181102752686,
-0.034087155014276505,
-0.06635314971208572,
-0.3011259138584137,
0.8616223931312561,
-0.18843384087085724,
-0.5438868403434753,
0.1491405963897705,
0.14640191197395325,
0.7276695966720581,
-0.6489161849021912,
-0.04044804349541664,
0.5041718482971191,
0.23014996945858002,
-0.45156967639923096,
-0.7548328042030334,
0.507642924785614,
-0.11207564175128937,
-0.4418141841888428,
-0.3708750605583191,
0.8309285044670105,
-0.24960018694400787,
-0.6277961730957031,
0.3490140438079834,
0.3070144057273865,
-0.05724777281284332,
-0.14363130927085876,
-0.7261262536048889,
-0.1338648647069931,
0.13553738594055176,
-0.4470248520374298,
0.3688059151172638,
0.29962101578712463,
0.2532402276992798,
0.3426382541656494,
0.454576700925827,
0.2224375158548355,
0.07699906826019287,
-0.24827830493450165,
0.5336139798164368,
-0.7277864813804626,
-0.6293269395828247,
-0.7688239216804504,
0.4461139738559723,
-0.10735274106264114,
-0.4024905562400818,
0.7481949925422668,
0.3184589147567749,
0.9255899786949158,
0.1626666784286499,
0.9792592525482178,
-0.3696451485157013,
0.6126001477241516,
-0.47029539942741394,
0.4646480977535248,
-0.3078431189060211,
0.250968337059021,
-0.5600569844245911,
-1.0014129877090454,
-0.4612870216369629,
0.6893470883369446,
-0.4004737138748169,
-0.31714871525764465,
0.9386948347091675,
0.27231481671333313,
0.2336094230413437,
0.45398956537246704,
-0.13619501888751984,
-0.15071512758731842,
0.09485117346048355,
0.2871852517127991,
0.8227691054344177,
-0.49805277585983276,
0.42915987968444824,
-0.4344499707221985,
-0.3186061680316925,
0.07678557932376862,
-0.7327589392662048,
-0.7702324986457825,
-0.7402244806289673,
-0.2539241909980774,
-0.28641486167907715,
-0.6420662999153137,
0.9248560667037964,
0.48795923590660095,
-0.9596549272537231,
-0.3268255293369293,
-0.10430703312158585,
0.2749313712120056,
-0.45926758646965027,
-0.3920062482357025,
0.43071234226226807,
-0.6693651676177979,
-0.5793337225914001,
0.051722459495067596,
0.1499873399734497,
-0.22373265027999878,
-0.08053173869848251,
0.2005743533372879,
-0.508098304271698,
0.1421731561422348,
1.0307990312576294,
-0.12883712351322174,
-0.6339735984802246,
-0.24912597239017487,
0.05597057193517685,
-0.07321766018867493,
0.08864648640155792,
0.8448710441589355,
-0.5944272875785828,
0.6210812926292419,
0.766120433807373,
1.0250905752182007,
0.20108820497989655,
0.09501677006483078,
0.5019798874855042,
-0.8213357925415039,
-0.00854519847780466,
0.29168614745140076,
0.15616832673549652,
0.02103326842188835,
-0.6690827012062073,
0.592664897441864,
0.04776022210717201,
-0.42921915650367737,
-0.6769022941589355,
0.16761237382888794,
-1.125622034072876,
-0.48969733715057373,
1.2838367223739624,
0.001752358628436923,
-0.2714249789714813,
-0.3809557855129242,
-0.39557480812072754,
0.03339410200715065,
-0.25313571095466614,
0.4661591053009033,
1.1598999500274658,
-0.5043612122535706,
-0.24878178536891937,
-0.7620531916618347,
0.671756386756897,
0.613987922668457,
-0.9761062264442444,
-0.17324306070804596,
0.17490988969802856,
-0.12448335438966751,
0.6143257021903992,
0.41658854484558105,
0.01046075765043497,
-0.017358768731355667,
-0.31611746549606323,
0.1184137836098671,
0.3989785313606262,
-0.28980422019958496,
-0.3477894067764282,
0.6761857867240906,
-0.08955179899930954,
-0.11095140874385834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00969v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00969v1 | SPARQL Generation with Entity Pre-trained GPT for KG Question Answering | 2024-02-01T19:38:32 | 2024-02-01T19:38:32 | Diego Bustamante, Hideaki Takeda | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.IR, 68P20, 68T50, H.2.3; H.3.3; I.2.7 | Knowledge Graphs popularity has been rapidly growing in last years. All that
knowledge is available for people to query it through the many online databases
on the internet. Though, it would be a great achievement if non-programmer
users could access whatever information they want to know. There has been a lot
of effort oriented to solve this task using natural language processing tools
and creativity encouragement by way of many challenges. Our approach focuses on
assuming a correct entity linking on the natural language questions and
training a GPT model to create SPARQL queries from them. We managed to isolate
which property of the task can be the most difficult to solve at few or
zero-shot and we proposed pre-training on all entities (under CWA) to improve
the performance. We obtained a 62.703% accuracy of exact SPARQL matches on
testing at 3-shots, a F1 of 0.809 on the entity linking challenge and a F1 of
0.009 on the question answering challenge. | [
-0.7613427639007568,
-1.2008615732192993,
0.5992135405540466,
0.09004306048154831,
-0.1773955374956131,
-0.0350952185690403,
0.1506344974040985,
-0.5564436316490173,
0.061618998646736145,
0.6512728333473206,
-0.6864994168281555,
-0.38516461849212646,
-0.6167867183685303,
0.2784106135368347,
-0.005265192128717899,
1.151361346244812,
-0.20865590870380402,
0.03737887367606163,
-0.1190493032336235,
-0.10988526791334152,
-0.5833178162574768,
-0.3643345534801483,
-0.868215799331665,
-0.20749901235103607,
0.44664663076400757,
0.12795235216617584,
0.6664460897445679,
0.294088214635849,
0.21982687711715698,
0.23329631984233856,
0.003220335580408573,
0.1569492220878601,
-0.5831799507141113,
0.09243928641080856,
-0.2447364330291748,
-0.29580479860305786,
-0.22717435657978058,
-0.23365725576877594,
0.42662692070007324,
0.7888810634613037,
-0.18309429287910461,
0.1519554853439331,
-0.1031760573387146,
0.8391736149787903,
-0.34972861409187317,
0.1050705835223198,
-0.9053764939308167,
0.18406465649604797,
-0.19925552606582642,
-0.08788840472698212,
-0.0812760442495346,
-0.5101580619812012,
0.227223739027977,
-0.9509500861167908,
0.41708454489707947,
0.2161714881658554,
0.9940267205238342,
0.35512253642082214,
-0.7079920768737793,
-0.5638864040374756,
-0.6504741907119751,
0.17467904090881348,
-0.1697581261396408,
0.5740253925323486,
0.3470168709754944,
0.5128194689750671,
-0.3460656404495239,
-0.8258326053619385,
-0.6373593807220459,
-0.2603767514228821,
-0.05535208433866501,
-0.026552299037575722,
-0.15973559021949768,
0.0482785664498806,
0.4181302487850189,
0.020524410530924797,
-0.8643428087234497,
-0.3371453285217285,
-0.1568966954946518,
-0.08362595736980438,
0.48701372742652893,
0.13932161033153534,
0.2860761284828186,
-0.14334584772586823,
-0.24270099401474,
0.06047351658344269,
-0.8226425647735596,
-0.25748997926712036,
0.46315303444862366,
0.0964004173874855,
0.5725590586662292,
0.7974684238433838,
-0.5077619552612305,
0.9307648539543152,
0.16701313853263855,
0.12483189254999161,
0.10189589112997055,
-0.3320055902004242,
-0.007808195427060127,
0.047857616096735,
0.712356448173523,
0.1198330745100975,
0.5541718006134033,
-0.45803385972976685,
-0.04032726585865021,
-0.21650467813014984,
0.3582342565059662,
-0.8584879636764526,
-0.3654809892177582,
0.04254788160324097,
0.0999268889427185,
-0.01348847895860672,
-0.1825437992811203,
-0.4663374423980713,
-0.1126462072134018,
-0.24569785594940186,
0.8174148201942444,
-0.5214917063713074,
-0.44653573632240295,
0.032470863312482834,
-0.06486160308122635,
0.19203093647956848,
0.18895286321640015,
-0.6248469948768616,
0.30110371112823486,
0.39101871848106384,
0.3632373511791229,
0.14853930473327637,
-0.05542006343603134,
-0.36081749200820923,
0.328413188457489,
-0.17861562967300415,
0.9248726963996887,
-0.32507947087287903,
-0.36989495158195496,
-0.41044893860816956,
-0.2550303041934967,
-0.2897503972053528,
-0.45067042112350464,
0.2291361391544342,
-1.0474992990493774,
0.31233298778533936,
-0.4610312581062317,
-0.8199096322059631,
0.13947831094264984,
0.4266887903213501,
-0.5631074905395508,
1.2517884969711304,
0.44115185737609863,
-0.9283439517021179,
0.5523642301559448,
-0.9132025241851807,
-0.4536474943161011,
0.2872147560119629,
0.008064988069236279,
-0.2849620282649994,
-0.3164205253124237,
0.5740992426872253,
0.2649171054363251,
-0.2839010953903198,
0.3545965552330017,
-0.06812787801027298,
-0.1101485937833786,
0.2712814509868622,
-0.05616161227226257,
0.447005033493042,
0.35013821721076965,
-0.31725627183914185,
-0.22988387942314148,
-0.7192439436912537,
0.5699177980422974,
0.294600248336792,
-0.210616797208786,
-0.13432399928569794,
-0.31756073236465454,
-0.3223310708999634,
0.258154034614563,
0.06995314359664917,
-0.29742854833602905,
0.20763787627220154,
-0.4997318983078003,
0.08003263175487518,
0.4902649223804474,
0.5740638971328735,
0.2737019956111908,
0.10979975014925003,
0.6990538835525513,
-0.06376870721578598,
0.12733498215675354,
0.45911484956741333,
-0.8032748699188232,
-0.404308557510376,
0.10988729447126389,
0.44421178102493286,
0.5910874605178833,
-1.346855640411377,
0.22341282665729523,
-0.27828726172447205,
-0.6965669393539429,
-0.49049511551856995,
0.2341316044330597,
0.5272290706634521,
0.8336189985275269,
0.5225040316581726,
-0.20460255444049835,
-0.31593024730682373,
-0.6186299324035645,
-0.44510069489479065,
-0.15014056861400604,
-0.13127996027469635,
0.5880422592163086,
0.5314152836799622,
0.002124365419149399,
1.2085201740264893,
-1.1071871519088745,
-0.21255990862846375,
-0.2896234095096588,
0.36690959334373474,
0.19851095974445343,
0.2921236753463745,
0.5375558733940125,
-0.965278685092926,
-0.883702278137207,
-0.03952169418334961,
-0.7064084410667419,
-0.09731105715036392,
0.5411865711212158,
-0.4540913999080658,
0.11352057754993439,
0.12301699817180634,
-0.9956644177436829,
0.21165651082992554,
0.03232390806078911,
-0.3212936520576477,
0.5105758905410767,
-0.07377216964960098,
0.31879156827926636,
-1.1015843152999878,
0.11240894347429276,
0.05873388424515724,
-0.0770624652504921,
-0.7856418490409851,
-0.11809927225112915,
-0.25476178526878357,
-0.4450782537460327,
-0.35968858003616333,
0.4247439205646515,
-0.5379252433776855,
-0.07339917868375778,
-0.024535231292247772,
0.23832403123378754,
-0.06894464045763016,
0.4252433776855469,
0.042722832411527634,
0.7399570345878601,
0.3629656136035919,
-0.730333149433136,
0.4980239272117615,
0.3581660985946655,
-0.24306727945804596,
0.6153709888458252,
-0.676521360874176,
0.42730841040611267,
-0.34309762716293335,
0.20094215869903564,
-0.8103718161582947,
-0.29240548610687256,
0.40540602803230286,
-0.517318606376648,
0.29280945658683777,
-0.46866974234580994,
-0.4234829545021057,
-0.4710221588611603,
0.1598469763994217,
0.17904941737651825,
0.31690099835395813,
-0.19438014924526215,
0.5132225751876831,
0.42463383078575134,
-0.18452376127243042,
-0.8038119673728943,
-0.17318083345890045,
-0.16435612738132477,
-0.03369441255927086,
-0.8379334211349487,
0.19613154232501984,
-0.12187490612268448,
0.09004849195480347,
0.5242443084716797,
-0.06509129703044891,
-0.4291672110557556,
0.04993360489606857,
-0.028550880029797554,
0.1519300788640976,
-0.41952118277549744,
0.2407359927892685,
-0.1534891277551651,
-0.2921314537525177,
-0.04799468815326691,
-0.45158442854881287,
0.5596671104431152,
-0.038042739033699036,
-0.3803594708442688,
-0.062399521470069885,
0.21998123824596405,
-0.10127609223127365,
-0.177228182554245,
0.8223708868026733,
0.7772329449653625,
-0.4235123097896576,
0.06249350309371948,
-0.766753613948822,
-0.013988656923174858,
-0.44102275371551514,
0.5264253616333008,
-0.5487995147705078,
-1.0554759502410889,
0.26284974813461304,
-0.018803095445036888,
-0.46570950746536255,
0.5041234493255615,
0.44974350929260254,
0.040080439299345016,
1.0468487739562988,
0.4189584255218506,
-0.03964222967624664,
0.15672069787979126,
-0.03241759538650513,
0.2735693156719208,
-0.3477817475795746,
-0.32383254170417786,
-0.6025592684745789,
0.1052437350153923,
-0.4510374963283539,
-0.16155186295509338,
0.6060247421264648,
0.49580442905426025,
-0.2955786883831024,
0.4049299657344818,
-0.636534571647644,
0.7761985063552856,
0.5239461064338684,
0.13591597974300385,
0.1522011011838913,
-0.0620635487139225,
-0.12457340955734253,
-0.05741870403289795,
-0.6518986821174622,
-0.16098491847515106,
1.1543331146240234,
-0.2570471465587616,
0.583053469657898,
0.1043839305639267,
0.6599668264389038,
0.07953285425901413,
0.5530868768692017,
-0.3709860146045685,
0.50931316614151,
0.4414253830909729,
-0.910317599773407,
-0.5596705675125122,
-0.9092373847961426,
-0.9763985872268677,
0.1310313642024994,
-0.4137539565563202,
-0.6876286268234253,
-0.48029446601867676,
0.3018130660057068,
-0.08762579411268234,
0.14564406871795654,
-0.9953837394714355,
1.1289141178131104,
-0.19262796640396118,
-0.10797813534736633,
0.2877790927886963,
-0.7531179785728455,
0.2560241222381592,
0.048098597675561905,
-0.06286564469337463,
-0.016189489513635635,
0.3569948077201843,
0.6421955227851868,
-0.3837830126285553,
0.2842714786529541,
-0.689407229423523,
0.18549476563930511,
0.5884886384010315,
-0.05592555180191994,
0.7163137793540955,
0.09490589052438736,
0.1585698127746582,
-0.3037727177143097,
-0.018645646050572395,
-0.29671716690063477,
-0.8493968844413757,
0.4152977764606476,
-0.8115072250366211,
-0.6499281525611877,
-0.1536276787519455,
-0.34593719244003296,
-0.5759546756744385,
0.30099567770957947,
0.37978479266166687,
0.1823454052209854,
-0.2926420569419861,
-0.1468603014945984,
0.9201253652572632,
-0.041144467890262604,
-0.14367423951625824,
0.6130577325820923,
-0.1910189837217331,
-0.4595676362514496,
1.01680326461792,
0.4658576548099518,
0.09740171581506729,
0.5777896642684937,
-0.1768229603767395,
-0.7699423432350159,
-0.5442985892295837,
-0.7128208875656128,
0.2190086841583252,
-0.7408214211463928,
-0.33097782731056213,
-0.9599296450614929,
-0.31230759620666504,
-0.7295129895210266,
0.09247934818267822,
-0.09672785550355911,
-0.374330073595047,
-0.19233907759189606,
-0.1566179096698761,
0.38639864325523376,
0.856433629989624,
0.25092339515686035,
0.11090439558029175,
-0.8147425055503845,
0.4828936755657196,
0.6495081782341003,
0.36383160948753357,
-0.2424890398979187,
-0.0716140866279602,
-0.049921587109565735,
-0.1554078310728073,
-0.4352796971797943,
-1.1535133123397827,
0.2917790114879608,
0.16221758723258972,
0.6143472790718079,
0.06067824736237526,
0.06868023425340652,
0.7860122919082642,
-0.5290827751159668,
0.6443402171134949,
0.06847525388002396,
-0.7063326835632324,
0.7370702624320984,
-0.13889741897583008,
-0.05185255408287048,
0.44428759813308716,
0.8468621373176575,
-0.4286651313304901,
-0.28372225165367126,
-0.86095130443573,
-0.8520596027374268,
0.5805550217628479,
0.48715028166770935,
-0.2041437178850174,
-0.12255749851465225,
0.6147519946098328,
-0.07359971851110458,
0.31608816981315613,
-0.7566763758659363,
-0.33287787437438965,
-0.32956933975219727,
-0.32054832577705383,
0.15154515206813812,
-0.20034171640872955,
-0.04517459124326706,
-0.17338529229164124,
0.9312092661857605,
-0.20293448865413666,
0.3552635908126831,
0.14676164090633392,
-0.3662177324295044,
-0.0002588752831798047,
0.44053003191947937,
0.26635652780532837,
0.7582839131355286,
-0.17670617997646332,
-0.10042034834623337,
0.5208249688148499,
-0.4668324291706085,
0.22611337900161743,
0.49665966629981995,
-0.11161373555660248,
-0.17929647862911224,
-0.04891778528690338,
0.6501688957214355,
-0.015987087041139603,
-0.46739083528518677,
0.4576944410800934,
-0.11053669452667236,
-0.29415592551231384,
-0.3085021674633026,
0.18953938782215118,
0.42360231280326843,
0.18142396211624146,
0.46512943506240845,
-0.32897183299064636,
-0.0016758415149524808,
-0.10426337271928787,
0.13075678050518036,
0.5389353036880493,
-0.3736574351787567,
-0.11361386626958847,
0.7577242851257324,
-0.03537936881184578,
-0.10562273859977722,
0.8028907179832458,
-0.6499470472335815,
-0.6457736492156982,
0.4883213937282562,
0.7561522126197815,
0.512913167476654,
-0.044729940593242645,
0.32715389132499695,
0.3183785676956177,
0.3072977364063263,
0.08320849388837814,
0.24404293298721313,
-0.05722092092037201,
-0.9938192367553711,
-0.4031960070133209,
-0.7131129503250122,
-0.4032275378704071,
0.005364564247429371,
-0.5214057564735413,
-0.012652508914470673,
-0.08658528327941895,
-0.1761920154094696,
-0.019968701526522636,
0.16983236372470856,
-0.7391616106033325,
0.44530239701271057,
-0.33711421489715576,
0.6660979986190796,
-0.6493940949440002,
0.7557915449142456,
0.7913371920585632,
-0.6017568111419678,
-1.0536057949066162,
-0.30156466364860535,
-0.41263413429260254,
-0.7871164679527283,
0.8752205967903137,
-0.02071494795382023,
0.11280324310064316,
0.524379312992096,
-0.5653505325317383,
-0.7863383889198303,
1.2116698026657104,
0.5528623461723328,
-0.010359483771026134,
-0.23043297231197357,
0.4769183397293091,
0.47331303358078003,
-0.10562372952699661,
0.23368044197559357,
0.44439756870269775,
0.46930256485939026,
0.3474063277244568,
-0.7519381642341614,
0.022957144305109978,
-0.1955542266368866,
-0.03150187432765961,
0.6002996563911438,
-0.16477757692337036,
0.5638493895530701,
-0.12577354907989502,
-0.2559155523777008,
-0.27950984239578247,
0.6164583563804626,
0.2131347954273224,
0.4185289442539215,
0.5670015811920166,
0.8955333828926086,
0.8567603826522827,
-0.29365813732147217,
1.0564711093902588,
-0.3144773542881012,
0.48291704058647156,
0.9113764762878418,
-0.3707749843597412,
0.4542587101459503,
0.23781730234622955,
-0.44580763578414917,
0.09222016483545303,
0.49080944061279297,
0.07469317317008972,
0.48526671528816223,
0.23558799922466278,
-0.49719828367233276,
-0.32074451446533203,
-0.15702183544635773,
-0.5945658087730408,
-0.03315974026918411,
0.32912886142730713,
-0.06562130898237228,
-0.4081823229789734,
0.006446290295571089,
0.10623639076948166,
-0.19044926762580872,
-0.25158560276031494,
0.8318772912025452,
-0.06863851845264435,
-0.7963570952415466,
0.2871718108654022,
-0.07269421219825745,
0.3223762512207031,
-0.83167964220047,
-0.12861762940883636,
-0.03768482431769371,
-0.2723810374736786,
-0.047623805701732635,
-0.88602215051651,
0.2334907054901123,
0.11195601522922516,
-0.09885083138942719,
0.006814986001700163,
1.1886465549468994,
-0.3586033880710602,
-0.33731943368911743,
-0.031975988298654556,
0.7242634892463684,
0.2821209132671356,
-0.45038270950317383,
-0.804375171661377,
-0.5885804295539856,
-0.07220598310232162,
-0.43581223487854004,
0.452083021402359,
0.809132993221283,
0.07075124233961105,
0.7170695066452026,
0.6357834935188293,
-0.08815282583236694,
0.4233528971672058,
-0.0981169119477272,
0.993754506111145,
-0.6259417533874512,
-0.3622084856033325,
-0.4764796197414398,
0.15831716358661652,
-0.13882696628570557,
-0.34957727789878845,
0.49665367603302,
0.48330122232437134,
0.8766811490058899,
-0.08136403560638428,
0.6049754023551941,
-0.34844058752059937,
0.4463145434856415,
-0.7136318683624268,
0.7949095368385315,
-0.2555162310600281,
-0.16792616248130798,
-0.3967762887477875,
-1.0143944025039673,
-0.10222034156322479,
0.344199538230896,
-0.2940390706062317,
0.2367054969072342,
0.690194308757782,
1.0273982286453247,
0.17320290207862854,
0.1784193068742752,
0.24863775074481964,
0.01577501744031906,
0.30983486771583557,
0.7179838418960571,
0.7537974119186401,
-0.2583249509334564,
1.0053791999816895,
-0.2485276162624359,
0.12182585150003433,
0.12976226210594177,
-0.7503247857093811,
-0.6732972860336304,
-0.4127357602119446,
-0.2039627581834793,
-0.5157063603401184,
0.1667068600654602,
0.7967333197593689,
0.3887811601161957,
-0.6179215312004089,
0.3113499879837036,
-0.197230726480484,
0.18906231224536896,
-0.026722842827439308,
-0.3271900415420532,
0.5208130478858948,
-0.41570329666137695,
-0.3989844024181366,
0.10256688296794891,
0.038401201367378235,
0.19732533395290375,
0.09072615951299667,
-0.09788930416107178,
-0.2705667018890381,
-0.27950164675712585,
0.45904541015625,
0.3905470669269562,
-0.16081847250461578,
-0.43982893228530884,
-0.08446764945983887,
-0.11356013268232346,
0.04135870188474655,
0.6716392040252686,
-0.7735900282859802,
0.2943563759326935,
0.2736397981643677,
0.9510277509689331,
0.9592739343643188,
0.06027979403734207,
0.3277255892753601,
-1.0829503536224365,
-0.18874597549438477,
0.2973378598690033,
0.08389031887054443,
0.31394070386886597,
-0.5110145807266235,
0.7390425205230713,
0.5972590446472168,
-0.6180248260498047,
-0.5421067476272583,
0.2780012786388397,
-0.7234134078025818,
-0.003176518715918064,
0.8720372915267944,
-0.05432337522506714,
-0.24037569761276245,
-0.45828089118003845,
-0.2252199947834015,
0.5148187875747681,
-0.10631721466779709,
0.5289186239242554,
0.7175725102424622,
-0.43492767214775085,
-0.016525980085134506,
-0.6596671342849731,
0.462034672498703,
0.18166044354438782,
-0.9017786383628845,
-0.41469520330429077,
0.4187462627887726,
0.7029983997344971,
0.07561993598937988,
1.1394742727279663,
-0.045431070029735565,
0.041788969188928604,
0.028526118025183678,
0.11217699199914932,
-0.17498351633548737,
0.007306766230612993,
0.3676488995552063,
0.626863956451416,
0.314060240983963,
0.15006156265735626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00956v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00956v2 | Exploring Spatial Schema Intuitions in Large Language and Vision Models | 2024-02-01T19:25:50 | 2024-05-27T14:29:31 | Philipp Wicke, Lennart Wachowiak | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the ubiquity of large language models (LLMs) in AI research, the
question of embodiment in LLMs remains underexplored, distinguishing them from
embodied systems in robotics where sensory perception directly informs physical
action. Our investigation navigates the intriguing terrain of whether LLMs,
despite their non-embodied nature, effectively capture implicit human
intuitions about fundamental, spatial building blocks of language. We employ
insights from spatial cognitive foundations developed through early
sensorimotor experiences, guiding our exploration through the reproduction of
three psycholinguistic experiments. Surprisingly, correlations between model
outputs and human responses emerge, revealing adaptability without a tangible
connection to embodied experiences. Notable distinctions include polarized
language model responses and reduced correlations in vision language models.
This research contributes to a nuanced understanding of the interplay between
language, spatial experiences, and the computations made by large language
models. More at https://cisnlp.github.io/Spatial_Schemas/ | [
-0.271777868270874,
-0.6979520320892334,
1.1390794515609741,
0.1869310885667801,
-0.0065745580941438675,
-0.03556203469634056,
-0.3139497637748718,
-0.6303985118865967,
0.30762749910354614,
0.4458853602409363,
-0.3937535583972931,
-0.6214919686317444,
-0.5806817412376404,
-0.15473245084285736,
-0.4691052734851837,
0.515399158000946,
0.16204668581485748,
0.07936906814575195,
-0.3888084888458252,
-0.35114362835884094,
0.048452798277139664,
-0.5870131850242615,
-0.29310575127601624,
-0.5391610264778137,
0.5223314166069031,
0.29441148042678833,
0.807405412197113,
0.3933284282684326,
0.44087323546409607,
0.2663297653198242,
-0.002633563941344619,
0.00847523845732212,
-0.17031130194664001,
-0.04401646554470062,
-0.11945801973342896,
-0.4896516501903534,
-0.1877242922782898,
-0.0994209423661232,
0.716316282749176,
1.1836826801300049,
-0.32473024725914,
-0.10714112222194672,
0.15968051552772522,
0.43564584851264954,
-0.6198887825012207,
0.4446084201335907,
-0.4214567244052887,
0.2435033768415451,
0.00961362011730671,
-0.11571131646633148,
-0.35230809450149536,
0.13914668560028076,
0.16730882227420807,
-0.6793732643127441,
0.15133756399154663,
0.19755497574806213,
0.6850017309188843,
0.27181476354599,
-0.5249844193458557,
-0.11503820866346359,
-0.9722805023193359,
0.6248081922531128,
-0.6292939186096191,
0.6842257380485535,
0.39640772342681885,
0.18399567902088165,
-0.10905387997627258,
-0.5412472486495972,
-0.9172678589820862,
-0.35487040877342224,
-0.2155405431985855,
0.1954968124628067,
-0.3215036690235138,
0.1819320172071457,
0.4088176488876343,
-0.19900114834308624,
-0.5357545018196106,
0.2436949908733368,
-0.3316705822944641,
0.05893312022089958,
0.5759630799293518,
0.2683585286140442,
0.38354891538619995,
-0.2043803334236145,
-0.40964415669441223,
-0.0698823556303978,
-0.8208821415901184,
-0.09565339237451553,
0.07905670255422592,
0.2330981343984604,
-0.5210409760475159,
1.0105565786361694,
0.04946248233318329,
0.6922348737716675,
-0.15859858691692352,
0.17037701606750488,
0.11553865671157837,
-0.19744239747524261,
-0.04508453235030174,
-0.1965394914150238,
0.8338436484336853,
0.41788148880004883,
0.3988458514213562,
-0.3632937967777252,
-0.038755785673856735,
0.193537175655365,
0.4482687711715698,
-0.2971383333206177,
-0.203899085521698,
0.1950335055589676,
-0.2737772464752197,
-0.04042907431721687,
0.05267490819096565,
-0.48937857151031494,
-0.7481356859207153,
-0.5435258746147156,
0.019818516448140144,
-0.3504233658313751,
-0.25755560398101807,
0.2760259509086609,
-0.24824340641498566,
0.7155162692070007,
0.40806207060813904,
-1.0914210081100464,
0.32076218724250793,
1.027692437171936,
0.6328838467597961,
-0.06951769441366196,
-0.8847952485084534,
0.2348358929157257,
0.3772903382778168,
-0.5358457565307617,
0.933426022529602,
-0.6263359785079956,
-0.3631010055541992,
-0.09516328573226929,
-0.08094405382871628,
-0.06577752530574799,
-0.35330528020858765,
0.18706372380256653,
-0.2606591582298279,
-0.02146899327635765,
-0.32369253039360046,
-0.2652624547481537,
-0.17473061382770538,
0.15523292124271393,
-0.5009728670120239,
1.0462229251861572,
0.029285920783877373,
-0.5396590232849121,
0.6225108504295349,
-0.741202712059021,
-0.39819204807281494,
0.27029454708099365,
-0.6936116814613342,
0.12208972126245499,
0.4615267813205719,
-0.02934386022388935,
0.38701000809669495,
-0.35679566860198975,
0.21645495295524597,
-0.6208705902099609,
-0.3726084530353546,
0.28776800632476807,
-0.004687265492975712,
0.7413765788078308,
0.052992597222328186,
-0.34230905771255493,
0.160169318318367,
-0.518301248550415,
-0.1652982532978058,
0.33482733368873596,
-0.059897180646657944,
-0.34758463501930237,
0.4255829453468323,
-0.10788741707801819,
0.0851423442363739,
0.18830086290836334,
-0.5596584677696228,
0.17393271625041962,
-0.5189105868339539,
0.6236189007759094,
0.6831739544868469,
-0.5332710146903992,
1.1491641998291016,
-0.020270857959985733,
0.4017411470413208,
-0.1438453197479248,
0.002942486898973584,
-0.011141099967062473,
-0.48319628834724426,
-0.7266650795936584,
-0.29885390400886536,
-0.43379732966423035,
0.4014381468296051,
-0.6049562692642212,
0.43386051058769226,
-0.41086268424987793,
-0.5575087666511536,
-0.19749459624290466,
0.10502307862043381,
0.046441204845905304,
0.14657537639141083,
-0.033878475427627563,
-0.010795188136398792,
-0.43092015385627747,
-0.9182341694831848,
-0.17799243330955505,
-0.35407885909080505,
-0.28152331709861755,
0.8212058544158936,
0.5725873112678528,
-0.3230888545513153,
1.0867414474487305,
-0.43859395384788513,
0.0030912309885025024,
-0.3841306269168854,
0.019301364198327065,
0.14318932592868805,
0.12389742583036423,
1.0118522644042969,
-0.5038151741027832,
0.07438445836305618,
0.1763678938150406,
-1.1734132766723633,
-0.1498018205165863,
0.003317264374345541,
-0.09544709324836731,
0.10489285737276077,
0.7044879794120789,
-1.0859956741333008,
0.5143671631813049,
0.7278738617897034,
-0.6713252067565918,
0.29246121644973755,
-0.42395320534706116,
-0.1884957253932953,
-0.7369540929794312,
0.04473789408802986,
-0.26009565591812134,
0.37307414412498474,
-0.431084543466568,
0.4079463481903076,
-0.07310694456100464,
-0.20552277565002441,
-0.44463253021240234,
0.7582463026046753,
-0.6858347058296204,
-0.8211324214935303,
-0.18012836575508118,
0.49140167236328125,
0.03670656308531761,
0.476082444190979,
0.2921634912490845,
0.40128225088119507,
0.6321935057640076,
-0.582683265209198,
0.2671578824520111,
0.1304534673690796,
-0.4712839126586914,
0.3862178921699524,
-0.842197835445404,
0.08422168344259262,
-0.2899070680141449,
0.3739769458770752,
-1.0773189067840576,
-0.23347865045070648,
0.42238321900367737,
-0.39128226041793823,
-0.029089536517858505,
-0.09787257760763168,
-0.6647889614105225,
-0.39839667081832886,
-0.003900026436895132,
0.5517461895942688,
0.22977319359779358,
-0.4348728060722351,
1.0971333980560303,
0.45128703117370605,
-0.07362531125545502,
-0.16418816149234772,
-0.9372390508651733,
0.20471377670764923,
-0.17181125283241272,
-0.5224676132202148,
-0.19041597843170166,
0.04041384160518646,
-0.7046430110931396,
-0.2917926013469696,
0.22705233097076416,
0.04344800487160683,
0.40466469526290894,
0.6064003109931946,
0.25316834449768066,
-0.26521676778793335,
-0.16389776766300201,
-0.08477715402841568,
-0.042038850486278534,
0.5042551159858704,
-0.3668588697910309,
0.5778747797012329,
-0.25190117955207825,
-0.9054164886474609,
-0.2767319679260254,
0.2112770974636078,
0.9118831753730774,
0.008113080635666847,
0.6207614541053772,
0.2672272324562073,
-0.44677475094795227,
-0.123794324696064,
-0.19235588610172272,
-0.27378204464912415,
-0.4470595717430115,
0.46843037009239197,
-0.3883111774921417,
-0.7096600532531738,
0.6535062193870544,
0.07636173069477081,
-0.06942655146121979,
0.05003970116376877,
0.4950307011604309,
-0.5178858041763306,
0.767280638217926,
0.4588909447193146,
0.07088767737150192,
0.5146026015281677,
-0.22537261247634888,
0.44424867630004883,
-0.8756335377693176,
-0.47695234417915344,
-0.5584897398948669,
-0.5035019516944885,
-0.5379903316497803,
-0.8264458775520325,
0.32755500078201294,
-0.1815609186887741,
-0.4170103669166565,
0.09065421670675278,
-0.09339072555303574,
0.4584685266017914,
0.5267528891563416,
0.07846830785274506,
-0.05816756561398506,
0.0560382716357708,
-0.17832578718662262,
-0.09395338594913483,
-0.8137863874435425,
-0.470654159784317,
0.9188907742500305,
0.2464151382446289,
0.8263478875160217,
0.11985320597887039,
0.35615774989128113,
0.12727290391921997,
0.02043410763144493,
-0.7876777648925781,
0.7980057001113892,
0.06469189375638962,
-0.4178481698036194,
-0.32813236117362976,
-0.004488723818212748,
-1.1241230964660645,
0.47752031683921814,
-0.34015026688575745,
-0.8264933228492737,
0.28302446007728577,
0.030557334423065186,
-0.2701818645000458,
0.2941665053367615,
-0.6262070536613464,
0.5466984510421753,
-0.5488104820251465,
-0.4305213689804077,
-0.25020724534988403,
-0.6020656824111938,
0.18290287256240845,
0.19028688967227936,
0.3661527931690216,
-0.08754768967628479,
-0.12113428115844727,
0.2620545029640198,
-0.09431060403585434,
1.1729222536087036,
-0.10446857661008835,
-0.5022836923599243,
0.26058295369148254,
0.38899070024490356,
0.22126588225364685,
-0.1364954560995102,
0.20636990666389465,
0.778378963470459,
-0.35645484924316406,
-0.5279425978660583,
-0.8094332218170166,
0.6198785305023193,
-0.8361901640892029,
-0.3259565234184265,
-0.34120815992355347,
-0.6904966831207275,
-0.1707163155078888,
0.14993980526924133,
0.0821952298283577,
0.08173904567956924,
-0.3459571599960327,
0.06193747743964195,
0.3762107789516449,
-0.41514548659324646,
0.26571914553642273,
0.6316062808036804,
-0.4939703941345215,
-0.06922723352909088,
0.5798093676567078,
-0.21767157316207886,
0.12051179260015488,
0.4252961277961731,
0.15547454357147217,
-0.19909265637397766,
-0.41994673013687134,
-0.35512274503707886,
0.4460509419441223,
-0.7138245701789856,
0.31735196709632874,
-0.4727514684200287,
-0.17547614872455597,
-0.3243701457977295,
-0.42705807089805603,
-0.30008456110954285,
-0.4291931390762329,
-0.12462440133094788,
-0.41802021861076355,
0.2528611719608307,
1.2920610904693604,
-0.05907239019870758,
0.3320886194705963,
-0.5850723385810852,
0.3225467801094055,
0.08015837520360947,
0.2158779501914978,
0.1260421723127365,
-0.47295230627059937,
-0.17169912159442902,
0.4210610091686249,
0.18930219113826752,
-0.5949684977531433,
0.2454916089773178,
-0.06284311413764954,
0.6485486626625061,
0.6584579944610596,
-0.25388243794441223,
0.5510062575340271,
-0.622643232345581,
1.019410252571106,
0.00015581258048769087,
-0.7591784000396729,
0.37406662106513977,
-0.7778276801109314,
0.35362574458122253,
-0.019488545134663582,
0.11767635494470596,
-0.29141750931739807,
-0.4551072418689728,
-0.5949519276618958,
-0.9926013946533203,
0.44116783142089844,
-0.07179153710603714,
0.13823202252388,
-0.05142660066485405,
0.4411372244358063,
-0.04992462322115898,
0.21013203263282776,
-0.7087262272834778,
-0.08417316526174545,
-0.015025689266622066,
-0.1591304987668991,
-0.44253385066986084,
-0.26999443769454956,
-0.32565855979919434,
-0.28358104825019836,
-0.2511001229286194,
-0.2815169095993042,
0.5476400852203369,
-0.03866611421108246,
-0.19743292033672333,
0.060699716210365295,
-0.021393144503235817,
0.7284322381019592,
0.6320117712020874,
0.2610827088356018,
0.3950519263744354,
0.2002715766429901,
-0.2584059238433838,
-0.30266180634498596,
-0.28357967734336853,
-0.2725922465324402,
-0.2815476953983307,
0.7947977781295776,
0.7157124280929565,
0.6526283025741577,
-0.7009477019309998,
0.4968467354774475,
0.08627936989068985,
-0.28348439931869507,
-0.45394080877304077,
-0.1059153601527214,
0.2579212486743927,
0.5541690587997437,
0.2108096480369568,
0.08768457919359207,
0.01505195815116167,
-0.5430713891983032,
-0.2399289757013321,
0.7311046123504639,
-0.20432312786579132,
-0.6787030100822449,
0.5045477747917175,
-0.04491642490029335,
-0.27276188135147095,
0.8228318095207214,
0.22653138637542725,
-0.5721794962882996,
0.6279247403144836,
0.38260725140571594,
0.9216992259025574,
0.20878911018371582,
0.02919652871787548,
0.17922183871269226,
0.5521889328956604,
0.22894689440727234,
0.34762677550315857,
-0.39585915207862854,
-1.244139313697815,
-0.19384035468101501,
-0.5573722124099731,
-0.42097213864326477,
-0.3229149580001831,
-0.6162370443344116,
0.0666811466217041,
-0.5560296773910522,
0.061809979379177094,
-0.3020195960998535,
-0.5683122873306274,
-0.7284732460975647,
-0.032701268792152405,
0.5580962896347046,
0.7059426307678223,
-1.1319844722747803,
0.6858936548233032,
0.8384422063827515,
-0.1788293719291687,
-0.6746747493743896,
-0.10104653239250183,
-0.1016838476061821,
-1.1137984991073608,
0.8052133321762085,
-0.24293111264705658,
-0.4998082220554352,
-0.32661452889442444,
-0.9216694831848145,
-0.818923830986023,
1.0899486541748047,
0.45237836241722107,
-0.47377899289131165,
-0.19376914203166962,
0.4950534701347351,
0.8028275966644287,
-0.13063104450702667,
0.2636774480342865,
0.5621851086616516,
0.5359447598457336,
-0.0423712283372879,
-0.7002884745597839,
-0.06474491953849792,
-0.1122688576579094,
-0.158904030919075,
0.0854339450597763,
-0.7933123707771301,
0.7225989699363708,
-0.715370774269104,
-0.18970948457717896,
0.2096884697675705,
0.6341637372970581,
0.48891234397888184,
0.5576343536376953,
0.3388528525829315,
0.7084723711013794,
0.5075833201408386,
-0.17830969393253326,
1.1986669301986694,
-0.3780336380004883,
0.012552585452795029,
1.1498974561691284,
-0.7415575981140137,
0.9567808508872986,
0.8826802372932434,
-0.2497156709432602,
0.695391058921814,
0.3471640944480896,
0.20855194330215454,
0.31510481238365173,
0.24267923831939697,
-0.08043844997882843,
-0.279361367225647,
0.08994811028242111,
-0.09209554642438889,
0.9648107290267944,
0.6445402503013611,
-0.13618414103984833,
-0.11324380338191986,
-0.02017412893474102,
-0.2395915389060974,
0.06991582363843918,
0.020859433338046074,
0.8213027715682983,
0.22056736052036285,
-0.5020229816436768,
0.06910911947488785,
-0.4874695837497711,
0.3795495927333832,
-0.7814688086509705,
-0.09280377626419067,
-0.3419581353664398,
0.1806180626153946,
-0.07450231909751892,
-1.0543086528778076,
0.22106866538524628,
-0.36862456798553467,
-0.16626131534576416,
-0.5576145648956299,
0.4777853786945343,
-0.11354635655879974,
-0.32999131083488464,
0.6961876749992371,
0.6230587363243103,
0.39965659379959106,
0.012971327640116215,
-0.4707961082458496,
0.14851821959018707,
-0.3692050576210022,
-0.12414458394050598,
0.2847888171672821,
0.9056060314178467,
-0.045214392244815826,
0.8603285551071167,
0.7391831278800964,
0.2918594777584076,
0.021611103788018227,
0.09304160624742508,
0.6291097402572632,
-0.9671874046325684,
-0.363421767950058,
-0.7493607997894287,
0.2477271854877472,
0.31394001841545105,
-0.16026900708675385,
0.9083492159843445,
0.46680280566215515,
0.8250369429588318,
-0.12211400270462036,
0.617082953453064,
-0.015757374465465546,
0.06483744829893112,
-0.5113959312438965,
0.8831363916397095,
-0.5405207872390747,
0.33788424730300903,
-0.39553287625312805,
-0.7970362901687622,
-0.34023720026016235,
1.065626621246338,
-0.42807456851005554,
0.09611140191555023,
0.6413485407829285,
0.6357871890068054,
0.08532558381557465,
-0.049996405839920044,
0.4345908761024475,
0.5957983136177063,
0.1369675099849701,
0.3917299509048462,
1.324574589729309,
-0.024650542065501213,
0.0713568925857544,
0.05001339316368103,
-0.026695491746068,
-0.13393957912921906,
-0.9040268063545227,
-0.6580133438110352,
-0.5480005145072937,
0.13351255655288696,
-0.22112427651882172,
-0.17976555228233337,
0.6027413010597229,
0.6564104557037354,
-0.447658509016037,
-0.5415177941322327,
-0.23940251767635345,
-0.04537735506892204,
0.04686592519283295,
-0.23971782624721527,
0.03406841680407524,
0.15391811728477478,
-0.6495693922042847,
0.5714372992515564,
0.43480682373046875,
0.31036025285720825,
-0.42029428482055664,
-0.265699177980423,
0.005846455227583647,
0.05088624358177185,
0.8995670080184937,
0.31497472524642944,
-0.9847401976585388,
-0.4435794949531555,
0.20858444273471832,
-0.11456459015607834,
-0.20536653697490692,
1.0070109367370605,
-0.7954986691474915,
0.19476623833179474,
0.3779233694076538,
0.39158421754837036,
0.386563777923584,
-0.25378546118736267,
0.866570234298706,
-0.51408451795578,
0.6280122399330139,
0.14915834367275238,
0.7317470908164978,
0.3106425404548645,
-0.16357393562793732,
0.46717631816864014,
0.23732896149158478,
-0.3372291326522827,
-0.7055649757385254,
0.35068976879119873,
-1.2315831184387207,
-0.2948954403400421,
1.492051601409912,
0.10685031116008759,
-0.3777296245098114,
0.1448257863521576,
-0.22991207242012024,
-0.1688758283853531,
-0.0731692984700203,
0.7722719311714172,
0.7869442701339722,
-0.2170403152704239,
-0.10124482214450836,
-0.339171439409256,
0.03509097918868065,
0.49544599652290344,
-0.5250810980796814,
0.21679455041885376,
0.7747742533683777,
0.02209554798901081,
0.17596301436424255,
0.5338847637176514,
0.17734315991401672,
0.2147979736328125,
0.22405442595481873,
0.23271295428276062,
0.21711723506450653,
-0.5687103867530823,
-0.4456355571746826,
-0.0452602244913578,
0.25823941826820374,
-0.01644938997924328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01781v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01781v2 | When Benchmarks are Targets: Revealing the Sensitivity of Large Language Model Leaderboards | 2024-02-01T19:12:25 | 2024-07-03T11:20:43 | Norah Alzahrani, Hisham Abdullah Alyahya, Yazeed Alnumay, Sultan Alrashed, Shaykhah Alsubaie, Yusef Almushaykeh, Faisal Mirza, Nouf Alotaibi, Nora Altwairesh, Areeb Alowisheq, M Saiful Bari, Haidar Khan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Model (LLM) leaderboards based on benchmark rankings are
regularly used to guide practitioners in model selection. Often, the published
leaderboard rankings are taken at face value - we show this is a (potentially
costly) mistake. Under existing leaderboards, the relative performance of LLMs
is highly sensitive to (often minute) details. We show that for popular
multiple-choice question benchmarks (e.g., MMLU), minor perturbations to the
benchmark, such as changing the order of choices or the method of answer
selection, result in changes in rankings up to 8 positions. We explain this
phenomenon by conducting systematic experiments over three broad categories of
benchmark perturbations and identifying the sources of this behavior. Our
analysis results in several best-practice recommendations, including the
advantage of a hybrid scoring method for answer selection. Our study highlights
the dangers of relying on simple benchmark evaluations and charts the path for
more robust evaluation schemes on the existing benchmarks. The code for this
paper is available at
https://github.com/National-Center-for-AI-Saudi-Arabia/lm-evaluation-harness. | [
-0.4354492127895355,
-0.8140993714332581,
0.5366543531417847,
0.19638271629810333,
0.011136428453028202,
0.01699945703148842,
-0.3972068130970001,
-0.4901326894760132,
-0.20813864469528198,
0.3064194321632385,
-0.3704169690608978,
-0.3385314643383026,
-0.7473548650741577,
-0.137139230966568,
-0.18861187994480133,
0.9683234095573425,
0.022978942841291428,
-0.031235449016094208,
-0.208379864692688,
-0.4257717728614807,
-0.43204882740974426,
-0.9050897359848022,
-0.4076176583766937,
-0.40712201595306396,
0.8434171080589294,
0.47322553396224976,
0.9176890850067139,
0.5288068652153015,
0.7648032307624817,
0.1746928095817566,
-0.3316137194633484,
-0.13196109235286713,
-0.5598292946815491,
0.29202333092689514,
-0.04693065583705902,
-0.5874006748199463,
-0.7240340113639832,
0.25030893087387085,
0.7704190611839294,
0.9331663250923157,
-0.21949975192546844,
0.5127788782119751,
0.23014892637729645,
0.7581121325492859,
-0.8688380718231201,
-0.016392385587096214,
-0.837103009223938,
-0.3405579924583435,
-0.49320298433303833,
-0.08614382892847061,
-0.546948254108429,
-0.20523828268051147,
-0.1254938840866089,
0.08311409503221512,
0.011177955195307732,
-0.06149864196777344,
0.6647642850875854,
0.2738609313964844,
-0.41544511914253235,
-0.029195420444011688,
-0.5089319944381714,
0.9278677701950073,
-0.4338622987270355,
0.40842393040657043,
0.3344212472438812,
0.7072641253471375,
-0.0919511690735817,
-0.39883917570114136,
-0.0400586873292923,
-0.32980555295944214,
0.19568121433258057,
-0.004696294665336609,
-0.016449693590402603,
-0.14313940703868866,
0.5700048208236694,
0.31337112188339233,
-0.3772003650665283,
0.42727869749069214,
0.005342070013284683,
-0.21070411801338196,
0.638053834438324,
0.2361954152584076,
-0.06877382844686508,
0.1269707977771759,
-0.1837310642004013,
-0.3736239969730377,
-1.1862341165542603,
0.2738546133041382,
0.4303489923477173,
0.4961891174316406,
0.1957002878189087,
0.5129997730255127,
-0.15856106579303741,
0.7783681750297546,
0.09988582879304886,
-0.011564895510673523,
0.1441064327955246,
-0.29710817337036133,
-0.11292098462581635,
0.01863667368888855,
0.4441803991794586,
0.5988215804100037,
0.3792133927345276,
0.14455382525920868,
-0.3223697245121002,
0.09187647700309753,
0.2406875193119049,
-0.8204161524772644,
-0.06573203951120377,
0.14285710453987122,
-0.3412712812423706,
-0.3506391644477844,
-0.1186252012848854,
-0.6167359352111816,
-0.3857119679450989,
-0.04211798310279846,
0.27776482701301575,
0.1792634129524231,
0.10396140068769455,
-0.23346976935863495,
0.1623157262802124,
0.2792681157588959,
0.34171098470687866,
-0.8648911714553833,
0.37301650643348694,
0.6033404469490051,
0.532002866268158,
-0.34098464250564575,
-0.5861423015594482,
-0.8024678230285645,
0.0341096892952919,
-0.4420512318611145,
0.9149217009544373,
-0.5705004930496216,
-0.6767732501029968,
-0.063416987657547,
-0.5254977345466614,
-0.08302976191043854,
-1.0852535963058472,
0.5301212072372437,
-0.47965431213378906,
-0.11892610788345337,
-0.5788744688034058,
-0.22070299088954926,
0.4134930372238159,
0.23416617512702942,
-0.6432980298995972,
1.0967265367507935,
-0.11104359477758408,
-0.7922120690345764,
0.2927025258541107,
-0.34617888927459717,
-0.4328518807888031,
-0.2926090955734253,
-0.32249900698661804,
-0.37936222553253174,
0.051883943378925323,
0.27174341678619385,
0.3613704741001129,
-0.24370941519737244,
0.1750328242778778,
-0.14124594628810883,
-0.45118647813796997,
0.5077118873596191,
-0.5649694204330444,
0.663940966129303,
0.08512884378433228,
-0.25503069162368774,
0.30700919032096863,
-0.6143325567245483,
0.14611585438251495,
0.017919668927788734,
-0.649135947227478,
-0.13335777819156647,
0.09100224822759628,
-0.06191035732626915,
0.2652147114276886,
0.21582050621509552,
-0.18394143879413605,
-0.05285276100039482,
0.11119409650564194,
0.13579896092414856,
1.1566462516784668,
-0.03528400883078575,
0.0023691467940807343,
-0.6877307295799255,
0.5918423533439636,
-0.2736016511917114,
0.39564207196235657,
0.0542447566986084,
-0.6885486245155334,
-0.6395748257637024,
0.11500010639429092,
0.2782709300518036,
0.37361395359039307,
-0.2800538241863251,
0.08783232420682907,
-0.17656098306179047,
-0.672547459602356,
-0.6401920318603516,
0.25999215245246887,
0.4003087878227234,
0.43635594844818115,
0.31817781925201416,
-0.05847148597240448,
-0.23824936151504517,
-1.0729504823684692,
-0.7121732831001282,
-0.4722255766391754,
0.14231206476688385,
0.4816223978996277,
0.2850911617279053,
0.03520359471440315,
0.6110218167304993,
-0.5925462245941162,
0.07333654910326004,
-0.04830193147063255,
0.061657410115003586,
0.39296773076057434,
0.21320652961730957,
0.4788145124912262,
-0.9165531396865845,
-0.5851078033447266,
-0.36873599886894226,
-0.32212206721305847,
-0.43392613530158997,
0.03668106719851494,
-0.09780636429786682,
-0.015122313983738422,
0.6886269450187683,
-0.46186941862106323,
0.1133297011256218,
0.817742109298706,
0.012578636407852173,
0.8576511144638062,
0.10441180318593979,
0.05721323937177658,
-0.6746495962142944,
0.2732354402542114,
-0.05147147923707962,
-0.15593495965003967,
-0.40858960151672363,
0.3883892893791199,
0.1901167929172516,
0.2188595086336136,
-0.39218735694885254,
0.49429380893707275,
-0.23564565181732178,
-0.17696695029735565,
-0.13658790290355682,
0.07131253182888031,
-0.35376235842704773,
0.18837611377239227,
-0.3310685157775879,
1.0813491344451904,
0.20757177472114563,
-0.6323613524436951,
0.19793519377708435,
0.17767855525016785,
-0.6656219363212585,
0.6364890933036804,
-0.4515663981437683,
0.30839845538139343,
0.13255898654460907,
0.009592210873961449,
-1.0609630346298218,
0.039379581809043884,
-0.18692156672477722,
-0.44880104064941406,
0.3396002948284149,
-0.10385716706514359,
-0.5723519325256348,
-0.2297801822423935,
-0.4730890393257141,
0.3252144455909729,
0.3881950378417969,
-0.5438136458396912,
0.07377196848392487,
0.5098391175270081,
-0.3152235746383667,
-0.6024936437606812,
-0.6788564920425415,
0.10947170108556747,
-0.18693283200263977,
-0.2671562433242798,
0.19968989491462708,
-0.7692489624023438,
-0.547960102558136,
-0.34035271406173706,
-0.38150519132614136,
0.16187217831611633,
0.6091353297233582,
0.41968756914138794,
0.21559922397136688,
-0.26327672600746155,
0.12855035066604614,
-0.25970080494880676,
-0.19905409216880798,
0.16459587216377258,
0.4222915768623352,
0.5097956657409668,
-0.2215261608362198,
-0.5321493744850159,
0.06116437166929245,
0.2203453928232193,
0.5329732298851013,
-0.328724205493927,
0.5354622006416321,
0.06784433126449585,
-0.17101934552192688,
-0.26680004596710205,
-0.6064191460609436,
-0.30424028635025024,
-0.5153316855430603,
0.43800127506256104,
-0.6156349182128906,
-0.776349663734436,
0.43522909283638,
-0.009273853152990341,
0.03343002125620842,
0.5820401310920715,
0.8611732125282288,
-0.00008699018508195877,
1.209384799003601,
0.5452888607978821,
-0.2708008587360382,
0.3743801712989807,
0.30635055899620056,
0.11146504431962967,
-1.0098944902420044,
-0.028643064200878143,
-0.9221383333206177,
-0.495140016078949,
-0.8117668032646179,
-0.3159984052181244,
0.5127702355384827,
-0.02679472416639328,
-0.19346141815185547,
0.1462249606847763,
-0.26321902871131897,
0.537564754486084,
0.3602418601512909,
-0.10820454359054565,
0.36000993847846985,
-0.19020655751228333,
-0.4350659251213074,
-0.29738155007362366,
-0.636462390422821,
-0.5584450364112854,
1.2012385129928589,
0.31139296293258667,
0.9303475618362427,
0.31163978576660156,
0.42004817724227905,
0.24328716099262238,
0.5865997672080994,
-0.7267720103263855,
0.7562652230262756,
-0.046881482005119324,
-0.8125592470169067,
-0.41519251465797424,
-0.3613552451133728,
-0.8540136218070984,
0.42812058329582214,
-0.03893259912729263,
-0.8372100591659546,
-0.0012746099382638931,
-0.11605693399906158,
-0.5178914666175842,
0.05239633470773697,
-0.5050229430198669,
0.715453028678894,
-0.3397642970085144,
-0.32910603284835815,
-0.10354997217655182,
-0.42181578278541565,
-0.050727084279060364,
-0.20088842511177063,
0.21480879187583923,
-0.22276650369167328,
0.009680899791419506,
0.6987861394882202,
0.008608387783169746,
0.7861965298652649,
0.06506854295730591,
-0.1719345897436142,
-0.11976837366819382,
0.17732656002044678,
0.3764103651046753,
-0.13825452327728271,
-0.4980791211128235,
-0.008987401612102985,
-0.2586052417755127,
-0.49064603447914124,
-0.4231394827365875,
1.0437904596328735,
-0.7687029838562012,
-1.0339268445968628,
-0.43620336055755615,
-0.511347770690918,
-0.5960317254066467,
0.1158190667629242,
0.24538666009902954,
0.18612882494926453,
-0.17663323879241943,
0.3112545311450958,
0.5368348956108093,
-0.14310763776302338,
0.33264273405075073,
0.5998062491416931,
-0.3203122615814209,
-0.030949648469686508,
0.4813092350959778,
0.5985106229782104,
0.4966582953929901,
0.34318211674690247,
0.25771841406822205,
-0.02749207615852356,
-0.8202774524688721,
-0.2549643814563751,
0.21098142862319946,
-0.911810040473938,
-0.0015535801649093628,
-0.19158817827701569,
-0.3146989941596985,
-0.3023150563240051,
-0.022640904411673546,
-0.4509722590446472,
-0.18664318323135376,
-0.013886027038097382,
-0.3595544397830963,
-0.12916819751262665,
0.7035951614379883,
0.19247430562973022,
0.025916380807757378,
-0.4364991784095764,
0.07424032688140869,
0.5558509826660156,
0.47708824276924133,
0.03815801441669464,
-0.6272422671318054,
-0.24736055731773376,
-0.2517779767513275,
-0.2596067786216736,
-0.6531521081924438,
-0.18608838319778442,
0.05340255796909332,
1.0063611268997192,
0.18647627532482147,
0.07551417499780655,
0.48679664731025696,
-0.5537707209587097,
0.5742248892784119,
-0.21754594147205353,
-0.6931957602500916,
0.6590745449066162,
-0.34698501229286194,
0.6535405516624451,
0.6919281482696533,
0.41505178809165955,
-0.475486159324646,
-0.48246607184410095,
-0.37189245223999023,
-0.7094085812568665,
0.5159380435943604,
0.022295167669653893,
0.1854488104581833,
0.0448920838534832,
0.26661303639411926,
0.15377077460289001,
0.3422914147377014,
-0.6233208179473877,
-0.5083028674125671,
0.33575940132141113,
0.15814317762851715,
-0.4667110741138458,
-0.5602055788040161,
-0.1774042248725891,
-0.03926178812980652,
0.5096732974052429,
-0.19591152667999268,
0.03002951294183731,
-0.021459290757775307,
-0.2346503883600235,
-0.45295557379722595,
0.36411309242248535,
0.5797304511070251,
0.9994087219238281,
-0.5237926840782166,
0.16599909961223602,
0.18141625821590424,
-0.25914034247398376,
-0.034354183822870255,
0.08473384380340576,
-0.08104696869850159,
-0.14702288806438446,
0.5287278890609741,
0.555052638053894,
0.47043052315711975,
-0.67435622215271,
0.5034520030021667,
0.1488891988992691,
0.1470012366771698,
-0.03596796840429306,
0.07757913321256638,
0.0700170174241066,
0.10815025120973587,
0.5235791206359863,
-0.12275773286819458,
0.018556060269474983,
-0.7861087322235107,
0.23335282504558563,
0.38552579283714294,
-0.3398216962814331,
-0.2696629464626312,
0.6167761087417603,
-0.035248637199401855,
-0.4175892770290375,
0.33718162775039673,
0.23385047912597656,
-0.6510465145111084,
0.6251153349876404,
0.3880954384803772,
0.44472306966781616,
-0.6311941146850586,
0.18627917766571045,
0.12549211084842682,
0.5271289944648743,
0.06565558910369873,
0.26932811737060547,
0.13216599822044373,
-0.703490674495697,
-0.23185858130455017,
-0.2871905565261841,
-0.7762195467948914,
0.1984950304031372,
-0.8680388331413269,
0.18338385224342346,
-0.7014811038970947,
-0.5051782131195068,
0.3610122799873352,
0.09137488901615143,
-0.5742719173431396,
0.13144885003566742,
0.4836743474006653,
0.8885094523429871,
-0.8965539932250977,
0.7500517964363098,
0.7601245641708374,
-0.23115506768226624,
-0.4391264021396637,
0.27989819645881653,
0.09087267518043518,
-0.8357166647911072,
0.6032641530036926,
0.24790319800376892,
-0.04255907982587814,
-0.2615070044994354,
-0.47808265686035156,
-0.7504209876060486,
0.8207493424415588,
0.48142319917678833,
-0.6758020520210266,
0.1684645265340805,
0.2571316957473755,
0.4937390387058258,
-0.1277039498090744,
0.42681044340133667,
0.5568907856941223,
0.4396936893463135,
-0.19335053861141205,
-1.2067204713821411,
0.1784333735704422,
-0.09087184071540833,
-0.0806499570608139,
0.26475048065185547,
-1.2373816967010498,
1.2756879329681396,
-0.21150408685207367,
0.09394645690917969,
0.07378898561000824,
0.04637248069047928,
0.4980481266975403,
0.1481180489063263,
0.38941627740859985,
0.2758100628852844,
0.7160705327987671,
-0.07597512751817703,
1.2547001838684082,
-0.04573195055127144,
0.16647368669509888,
1.256193995475769,
-0.671796441078186,
1.300855040550232,
0.6547300219535828,
-0.4681619703769684,
0.35257795453071594,
0.7005506157875061,
-0.06345523148775101,
0.5243123769760132,
0.39660781621932983,
0.09821431338787079,
-0.3948827385902405,
-0.10534659773111343,
-0.4611819386482239,
0.5109745264053345,
0.27203303575515747,
-0.2575277090072632,
-0.3756261467933655,
-0.24301999807357788,
0.05868321657180786,
0.26643866300582886,
-0.24290242791175842,
0.5474503636360168,
0.22489811480045319,
-0.623405396938324,
0.7643314003944397,
-0.021958880126476288,
0.36665037274360657,
-0.48413634300231934,
0.1576935201883316,
-0.3755132853984833,
0.21010152995586395,
-0.09908604621887207,
-0.8526889085769653,
-0.09566807746887207,
0.044760700315237045,
-0.2699235677719116,
-0.40106144547462463,
0.4686087369918823,
-0.052923694252967834,
-0.39612871408462524,
0.6967206597328186,
0.6973798274993896,
-0.0014212634414434433,
-0.3983386754989624,
-0.7346093058586121,
0.4638676345348358,
-0.1621607095003128,
-0.4006960988044739,
0.7271925806999207,
-0.06516903638839722,
-0.2369116097688675,
0.6580756902694702,
0.504429280757904,
0.14208948612213135,
0.007747869938611984,
0.16943395137786865,
0.881338894367218,
-0.603121817111969,
-0.3301830291748047,
-0.8298559188842773,
0.14772231876850128,
-0.044093821197748184,
-0.41692453622817993,
0.9018745422363281,
0.5462664365768433,
0.832426905632019,
0.3347436189651489,
0.5842410922050476,
0.4906369745731354,
0.6402088403701782,
-0.6162846684455872,
0.8986006379127502,
-0.39996764063835144,
0.5802407264709473,
-0.2063821256160736,
-1.21848726272583,
-0.32646140456199646,
0.2722697854042053,
-0.5759929418563843,
0.27542129158973694,
0.6532115340232849,
0.7712560892105103,
0.25084879994392395,
-0.28168222308158875,
0.553840160369873,
0.4784802198410034,
0.36529725790023804,
0.6080262660980225,
0.9397728443145752,
-0.22454266250133514,
0.5057812333106995,
-0.19591163098812103,
-0.1205543577671051,
-0.6301232576370239,
-0.837428092956543,
-0.8497820496559143,
-0.33442288637161255,
-0.4281361997127533,
-0.2655920684337616,
0.3401782810688019,
0.622201144695282,
0.6510491967201233,
-0.9666423797607422,
-0.5408209562301636,
0.6267316341400146,
0.2602179944515228,
-0.13806799054145813,
-0.1330542117357254,
0.4214515686035156,
-0.07822179794311523,
-0.5422006845474243,
0.5389440655708313,
0.04204507917165756,
-0.13135549426078796,
-0.18192453682422638,
0.08979777246713638,
-0.38080063462257385,
0.08512187004089355,
0.39519983530044556,
0.10541627556085587,
-0.6132007837295532,
-0.3651047945022583,
-0.09808975458145142,
-0.4896376430988312,
0.2748492360115051,
0.616257905960083,
-0.679474949836731,
0.2961907684803009,
0.15611092746257782,
0.714835524559021,
0.31784629821777344,
-0.004198942333459854,
0.3778601586818695,
-0.7139095664024353,
-0.00016863085329532623,
0.13407081365585327,
0.15315008163452148,
0.4665520191192627,
-0.25678303837776184,
0.390735387802124,
0.06417515873908997,
-0.5477167367935181,
-1.1072783470153809,
0.20335227251052856,
-0.685551106929779,
-0.2940559387207031,
1.193378210067749,
0.10241631418466568,
-0.12748438119888306,
0.3311949670314789,
-0.11409108340740204,
-0.15924523770809174,
-0.23396359384059906,
0.8577722907066345,
1.2526012659072876,
-0.0433773435652256,
-0.17129866778850555,
-0.9160134196281433,
0.4387708604335785,
0.6829676628112793,
-0.5890548229217529,
0.09519492089748383,
0.3476598858833313,
0.23071426153182983,
0.03936091810464859,
0.491496205329895,
-0.08525872230529785,
0.33628129959106445,
-0.020070571452379227,
-0.35933151841163635,
0.2000097781419754,
-0.38338661193847656,
-0.44849881529808044,
0.2652677297592163,
0.8624475598335266,
-0.018909288570284843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00861v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00861v2 | Evaluating Large Language Models for Generalization and Robustness via Data Compression | 2024-02-01T18:56:18 | 2024-02-04T01:16:25 | Yucheng Li, Yunhao Guo, Frank Guerin, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing methods for evaluating large language models face challenges such as
data contamination, sensitivity to prompts, and the high cost of benchmark
creation. To address this, we propose a lossless data compression based
evaluation approach that tests how models' predictive abilities generalize
after their training cutoff. Specifically, we collect comprehensive test data
spanning 83 months from 2017 to 2023 and split the data into training and
testing periods according to models' training data cutoff. We measure: 1) the
compression performance on the testing period as a measure of generalization on
unseen data; and 2) the performance gap between the training and testing period
as a measure of robustness. Our experiments test 14 representative large
language models with various sizes on sources including Wikipedia, news
articles, code, arXiv papers, and multi-modal data. We find that the
compression rate of many models reduces significantly after their cutoff date,
but models such as Mistral and Llama-2 demonstrate a good balance between
performance and robustness. Results also suggest that models struggle to
generalize on news and code data, but work especially well on arXiv papers. We
also find the context size and tokenization implementation have a big impact of
on the overall compression performance. | [
-0.4437386989593506,
-0.7243610620498657,
0.3689243793487549,
0.1834985613822937,
-0.2636992335319519,
-0.2190096080303192,
-0.6402654051780701,
-0.3187404274940491,
-0.18596415221691132,
0.19087186455726624,
-0.454856812953949,
-0.39223942160606384,
-0.6971249580383301,
0.06617765128612518,
-0.7528261542320251,
0.8203483819961548,
0.030548296868801117,
-0.09395693987607956,
-0.06910828500986099,
-0.03238539770245552,
-0.7112618684768677,
-0.5392696261405945,
-0.34165093302726746,
-0.010709295980632305,
0.1332494020462036,
0.011475262232124805,
0.9669522047042847,
0.8356018662452698,
0.44106408953666687,
0.1946176141500473,
-0.26220473647117615,
-0.2501671016216278,
-0.5240523815155029,
0.006516499910503626,
-0.028401199728250504,
-0.2639526426792145,
-0.19012966752052307,
-0.08099497854709625,
0.9114853739738464,
0.8468847274780273,
-0.15876369178295135,
0.22567103803157806,
0.19840729236602783,
0.34335288405418396,
-0.57066810131073,
0.11018353700637817,
-0.8528615236282349,
-0.023541489616036415,
0.06891317665576935,
0.029742827638983727,
-0.5250241160392761,
-0.29011645913124084,
-0.046747345477342606,
-0.2040196657180786,
0.4920867383480072,
-0.062237389385700226,
0.9384194016456604,
0.28367719054222107,
-0.35859623551368713,
-0.14925631880760193,
-0.8013930916786194,
0.8849180936813354,
-0.7997074127197266,
0.7309108376502991,
0.4879099726676941,
0.31632354855537415,
-0.04443468898534775,
-0.5440561175346375,
-0.4339756369590759,
-0.5115110874176025,
0.23292754590511322,
-0.2217816561460495,
-0.5500867962837219,
-0.03900124877691269,
0.49350690841674805,
0.6034472584724426,
-0.8361265659332275,
0.05591998249292374,
-0.27596306800842285,
-0.2164994180202484,
0.5793271660804749,
0.0038236554246395826,
0.4077182710170746,
0.021526986733078957,
-0.01320489402860403,
-0.3619420528411865,
-0.6033843755722046,
-0.07872796803712845,
0.6258934140205383,
0.4202295243740082,
-0.023737262934446335,
0.5116260647773743,
-0.17879192531108856,
0.9420700669288635,
-0.2756458520889282,
0.017335031181573868,
0.07371494174003601,
-0.3848133683204651,
-0.2390521615743637,
-0.5526718497276306,
0.7671798467636108,
0.39383435249328613,
0.3203818202018738,
-0.4405795633792877,
-0.28537511825561523,
0.1842234581708908,
0.11483708024024963,
-0.9506808519363403,
-0.08909227699041367,
0.1880563497543335,
-0.6632294654846191,
-0.36454349756240845,
-0.09559226036071777,
-0.8688250184059143,
-0.1969725489616394,
-0.22691693902015686,
0.33769717812538147,
-0.29742398858070374,
-0.11480049788951874,
0.43254634737968445,
-0.04196140915155411,
-0.04375062882900238,
0.16687947511672974,
-0.9831480979919434,
0.2859419882297516,
0.5762355923652649,
1.0467885732650757,
-0.1880762279033661,
-0.0793197900056839,
-0.6893226504325867,
-0.18175730109214783,
-0.35855552554130554,
0.577532947063446,
-0.6690793633460999,
-0.17447185516357422,
0.15039123594760895,
-0.07581112533807755,
-0.07069352269172668,
-0.5365009903907776,
0.9131551384925842,
-0.41460585594177246,
0.009343042969703674,
0.2571740448474884,
-0.5799718499183655,
-0.00011551447823876515,
0.4204067885875702,
-0.828733503818512,
0.7786147594451904,
0.23272168636322021,
-0.7746047973632812,
0.4002668261528015,
-0.42174196243286133,
-0.3076292872428894,
-0.08000031113624573,
0.02535669319331646,
-0.39893651008605957,
0.25020116567611694,
0.38282474875450134,
0.5829595923423767,
-0.4663151204586029,
0.3915504217147827,
-0.5473123788833618,
-0.5038912296295166,
0.08848825097084045,
-0.613762378692627,
0.5449038743972778,
0.11124983429908752,
-0.2373238503932953,
-0.14554259181022644,
-0.7870489358901978,
0.16682030260562897,
0.19553281366825104,
-0.602763831615448,
-0.3868137300014496,
0.0003023484896402806,
0.23099394142627716,
0.007815851829946041,
0.013829018920660019,
-0.40171343088150024,
0.6047778725624084,
-0.4326373338699341,
0.5203485488891602,
0.6716946959495544,
-0.24779640138149261,
0.059013236314058304,
-0.12080109864473343,
0.7577523589134216,
-0.3519485890865326,
0.46483296155929565,
-0.16486361622810364,
-0.32140791416168213,
-0.85055011510849,
0.012876939959824085,
0.7702505588531494,
0.3671795129776001,
-0.4919843077659607,
0.6816422343254089,
-0.7132100462913513,
-0.5352007746696472,
-0.09877762943506241,
-0.020735805854201317,
0.12942425906658173,
0.1679934412240982,
0.22568152844905853,
-0.42166388034820557,
-0.48118555545806885,
-0.935793936252594,
-0.2364989072084427,
-0.17073185741901398,
-0.4200794994831085,
0.15205501019954681,
0.5285624861717224,
-0.44595035910606384,
0.6785286068916321,
-0.4644826650619507,
0.2974093556404114,
-0.24874262511730194,
0.14783136546611786,
0.32573679089546204,
0.5126109719276428,
0.3162638545036316,
-0.8107370734214783,
-0.1654391884803772,
0.03328466787934303,
-0.3030742108821869,
-0.058808278292417526,
-0.008361035957932472,
0.3696279227733612,
-0.026900075376033783,
0.16014932096004486,
-0.5022489428520203,
0.5216315388679504,
0.9957388043403625,
-0.30885887145996094,
0.7284366488456726,
0.03491419553756714,
0.08208649605512619,
-0.8351811170578003,
0.40814679861068726,
-0.12421801686286926,
-0.2851141393184662,
-0.7025299668312073,
-0.055960480123758316,
0.1236678808927536,
-0.508269727230072,
-0.07233592122793198,
0.42183777689933777,
-0.3992403447628021,
-0.20101585984230042,
-0.11853484064340591,
-0.25114986300468445,
-0.10494208335876465,
0.24607160687446594,
-0.0806669071316719,
0.8449743986129761,
0.4616418182849884,
-0.7098436951637268,
0.033073268830776215,
0.0948745384812355,
-0.6558924317359924,
-0.03820504620671272,
-1.0495731830596924,
0.35640326142311096,
-0.08459726721048355,
0.10162484645843506,
-0.7763689160346985,
-0.26491087675094604,
-0.12141815572977066,
-0.4008369445800781,
0.2978496551513672,
-0.33849143981933594,
-0.6603509783744812,
-0.43778491020202637,
-0.2472814917564392,
0.43362662196159363,
0.504024863243103,
-0.3789386451244354,
0.37618231773376465,
0.14189447462558746,
-0.08830894529819489,
-0.5964395403862,
-0.6772304773330688,
0.27870073914527893,
-0.4181284010410309,
-0.6932827830314636,
0.1651267111301422,
-0.6082638502120972,
-0.09647578746080399,
-0.08512122184038162,
-0.0472450852394104,
-0.25193488597869873,
0.2435690313577652,
0.11933989077806473,
0.20436792075634003,
-0.009563989005982876,
0.2728648781776428,
-0.03279326856136322,
0.20520931482315063,
-0.18084515631198883,
-0.27400797605514526,
0.8809304237365723,
-0.14847718179225922,
-0.2020469456911087,
-0.12162665277719498,
0.14441151916980743,
0.5036013722419739,
-0.20385369658470154,
0.7879383563995361,
0.31040459871292114,
-0.45195356011390686,
-0.26599711179733276,
-0.6437077522277832,
0.058231618255376816,
-0.3871648907661438,
0.4060034453868866,
-0.22816628217697144,
-0.8597642779350281,
0.5728577375411987,
-0.08125656098127365,
-0.00437996257096529,
0.4522775411605835,
0.5165567994117737,
0.6792656183242798,
1.1418805122375488,
0.7604742646217346,
-0.12471266090869904,
0.41174787282943726,
-0.31869420409202576,
0.14274315536022186,
-0.5270963907241821,
0.0901719331741333,
-0.6257233023643494,
0.0716327354311943,
-0.17274148762226105,
-0.47287917137145996,
0.13250260055065155,
0.33801335096359253,
-0.06430359184741974,
0.5357338786125183,
-0.42123639583587646,
0.6405037641525269,
0.17470084130764008,
-0.20164789259433746,
0.3588676154613495,
0.036304816603660583,
0.22488300502300262,
0.08064056932926178,
-0.5869146585464478,
-0.49516814947128296,
1.4049474000930786,
0.6803178787231445,
0.6770111322402954,
0.06542451679706573,
0.19559158384799957,
0.503940224647522,
0.24917706847190857,
-0.9202240705490112,
0.19452248513698578,
-0.16716481745243073,
-0.4198228120803833,
-0.23732800781726837,
-0.6775270700454712,
-1.0849486589431763,
0.12461107224225998,
-0.08031543344259262,
-0.6509453058242798,
0.19767650961875916,
-0.044314444065093994,
-0.08141117542982101,
0.2760878801345825,
-0.6184306740760803,
0.7266562581062317,
-0.06809070706367493,
-0.033000700175762177,
-0.04302038997411728,
-0.4277462363243103,
0.5934274792671204,
-0.35161498188972473,
0.24029439687728882,
-0.011867259629070759,
-0.11085093021392822,
0.8848811984062195,
-0.21743705868721008,
0.5093329548835754,
0.08235791325569153,
-0.015870966017246246,
-0.13220176100730896,
0.12211369723081589,
0.4362671673297882,
-0.038841940462589264,
-0.174812451004982,
0.3718103766441345,
0.1244734451174736,
-0.40472936630249023,
-0.7974262237548828,
0.4206494092941284,
-0.49964848160743713,
-0.28775355219841003,
-0.10353247076272964,
-0.7482906579971313,
-0.46357232332229614,
0.24448668956756592,
0.3619535565376282,
0.5654265284538269,
-0.2715335786342621,
0.36352336406707764,
0.6234505772590637,
-0.22131669521331787,
0.272294819355011,
0.3764181137084961,
-0.20231597125530243,
-0.4931669533252716,
0.6476529836654663,
0.01936960406601429,
0.32686349749565125,
0.15215444564819336,
0.4230790436267853,
-0.2433270364999771,
-1.0017918348312378,
-0.46954014897346497,
0.05973445624113083,
-0.5940308570861816,
-0.29024043679237366,
-0.4535789489746094,
-0.0168398916721344,
-0.6901663541793823,
0.21283333003520966,
-0.3793347179889679,
-0.2627490758895874,
-0.00778175937011838,
0.11663699150085449,
-0.15991394221782684,
0.9199406504631042,
0.03894367069005966,
0.21457338333129883,
-0.7705564498901367,
-0.06501192599534988,
0.08179391920566559,
0.44227135181427,
0.17987866699695587,
-0.6894696354866028,
-0.3419549763202667,
-0.04732847586274147,
-0.18014834821224213,
-0.7756665945053101,
0.39961713552474976,
0.4147825837135315,
0.40596938133239746,
0.6758174896240234,
-0.05608486384153366,
0.4193950593471527,
-0.48889172077178955,
0.8195250630378723,
0.2080308198928833,
-1.106252908706665,
0.6522452235221863,
-0.4905714988708496,
0.22790749371051788,
0.5107561945915222,
0.3281555473804474,
-0.5361306667327881,
-0.16578590869903564,
-0.6030900478363037,
-0.6496120095252991,
0.2037980854511261,
0.2551809251308441,
0.41765129566192627,
0.14994481205940247,
0.4505613148212433,
0.21852348744869232,
0.2014702707529068,
-0.8486672043800354,
-0.04986915737390518,
-0.0052176364697515965,
-0.044792886823415756,
-0.2293323129415512,
-0.40434256196022034,
-0.1395612508058548,
-0.1567046046257019,
0.36425256729125977,
-0.20801545679569244,
0.09244972467422485,
-0.052528541535139084,
0.11002471297979355,
0.04771827906370163,
0.4836726486682892,
0.5364537835121155,
0.8041605949401855,
-0.2555570900440216,
0.02192581817507744,
0.16685089468955994,
-0.47027865052223206,
0.2130015343427658,
0.17362827062606812,
-0.19151358306407928,
0.056879136711359024,
0.6946273446083069,
0.8291699290275574,
0.00867042038589716,
-0.9377678036689758,
0.7732371091842651,
-0.3951805830001831,
-0.011858776211738586,
0.01063549891114235,
-0.061135828495025635,
-0.1979241818189621,
0.0022692023776471615,
0.17169949412345886,
-0.1093718633055687,
0.407823383808136,
-0.5825861692428589,
0.09028423577547073,
0.41645413637161255,
-0.12832121551036835,
-0.37042292952537537,
0.5557124018669128,
-0.21558749675750732,
0.052274517714977264,
0.5526028871536255,
-0.10927367955446243,
-0.5667542219161987,
0.4636479318141937,
0.5454426407814026,
0.7894276976585388,
-0.2625177800655365,
-0.019283631816506386,
0.35813266038894653,
0.5279873609542847,
-0.3958307206630707,
-0.13546150922775269,
0.003169991774484515,
-0.4795457720756531,
-0.6330839395523071,
-0.656256914138794,
-0.2688766419887543,
0.5379459857940674,
-0.7075619101524353,
0.35490038990974426,
-0.2601848542690277,
-0.2771224081516266,
-0.2991407811641693,
0.05029265955090523,
-0.794539749622345,
0.3801932632923126,
-0.0003445188922341913,
1.2703211307525635,
-0.9958996176719666,
0.5791091918945312,
0.30443915724754333,
-0.2976253032684326,
-0.8631783127784729,
0.31798988580703735,
-0.37564173340797424,
-0.6129820346832275,
0.5717817544937134,
0.3074064254760742,
0.27624690532684326,
-0.28101611137390137,
-0.6789957880973816,
-0.9181209802627563,
0.864093005657196,
0.8721172213554382,
-0.705305278301239,
-0.07506033778190613,
0.008804147131741047,
0.6009888648986816,
-0.1556103378534317,
0.18124417960643768,
0.6281809210777283,
0.3813243508338928,
0.03578302636742592,
-1.0617010593414307,
-0.04301901161670685,
-0.46507528424263,
0.23219823837280273,
0.12936118245124817,
-0.4323243200778961,
0.969403862953186,
0.15451057255268097,
-0.48895955085754395,
0.21105383336544037,
0.5186744928359985,
-0.1446043998003006,
0.04830658435821533,
0.7556690573692322,
0.7503021955490112,
0.8492831587791443,
0.06925136595964432,
1.3282314538955688,
-0.3176848292350769,
0.6317606568336487,
0.8730273842811584,
0.04853605479001999,
0.9669069647789001,
0.2131074219942093,
-0.32911476492881775,
0.17894141376018524,
0.5461853742599487,
-0.3346782326698303,
0.3750852644443512,
0.5974845886230469,
-0.10145968198776245,
-0.24056394398212433,
-0.4758065640926361,
-0.5592817068099976,
0.372815877199173,
-0.08785346150398254,
-0.3559287488460541,
-0.09801371395587921,
0.06184905394911766,
0.085403211414814,
-0.08410323411226273,
-0.25624746084213257,
0.33877623081207275,
-0.2805054187774658,
-0.5855743885040283,
0.9368990659713745,
0.12274032831192017,
0.7355489134788513,
-0.6948533654212952,
0.1736019104719162,
-0.2251386195421219,
0.08000018447637558,
0.013654179871082306,
-0.6006115078926086,
0.4158048629760742,
0.18530571460723877,
-0.14816969633102417,
0.035204462707042694,
0.7612277865409851,
-0.4652566611766815,
-0.6172695159912109,
0.2853522300720215,
0.19563093781471252,
0.33157655596733093,
-0.26599472761154175,
-0.44249942898750305,
0.6215434074401855,
-0.05096583068370819,
-0.30613696575164795,
0.38191431760787964,
-0.06052614748477936,
0.12294591963291168,
0.8403656482696533,
0.6549925804138184,
0.4035665690898895,
-0.08422012627124786,
0.16799363493919373,
1.1104421615600586,
-0.22516971826553345,
-0.32484114170074463,
-0.8188985586166382,
0.21533231437206268,
0.022153213620185852,
-0.34108904004096985,
0.6681758761405945,
0.6725489497184753,
0.6784343123435974,
-0.04997424781322479,
0.8598675727844238,
-0.0683278813958168,
0.3356199264526367,
-0.6075988411903381,
0.7028372883796692,
-0.5930312275886536,
0.05648517236113548,
-0.22491148114204407,
-0.9561175107955933,
-0.4700521230697632,
0.3075633645057678,
-0.28281715512275696,
0.13843992352485657,
0.4760093688964844,
0.6350566148757935,
-0.2959323525428772,
-0.1714951992034912,
0.5447098612785339,
-0.0233533326536417,
0.4590153396129608,
0.7034310102462769,
0.7383804321289062,
-0.6517544388771057,
0.6950376033782959,
-0.24317923188209534,
-0.31467676162719727,
-0.01183239370584488,
-0.927436113357544,
-1.1007379293441772,
-0.6374870538711548,
-0.20674572885036469,
-0.39509737491607666,
0.0769413411617279,
0.45801740884780884,
0.8901480436325073,
-0.7132472395896912,
-0.04036935791373253,
-0.12075436115264893,
-0.23169635236263275,
-0.02738190069794655,
-0.2171151340007782,
0.5670709609985352,
-0.1076590046286583,
-0.8177453875541687,
0.5039089322090149,
-0.03698400408029556,
0.17710858583450317,
-0.4943298399448395,
-0.012440619990229607,
0.2774275839328766,
0.04758478328585625,
0.46295487880706787,
0.12115521728992462,
-0.44356274604797363,
-0.39604222774505615,
-0.12871654331684113,
0.2866649329662323,
-0.28413358330726624,
0.8395586609840393,
-0.4189881384372711,
0.48473379015922546,
0.5476405024528503,
0.8302313685417175,
0.16246719658374786,
0.1407993882894516,
0.6766762733459473,
-0.626143217086792,
0.18370525538921356,
0.3138989210128784,
0.3724460005760193,
0.49367302656173706,
-0.3142220675945282,
0.7410812377929688,
0.06178797036409378,
-0.7829592227935791,
-1.1395128965377808,
0.08527207374572754,
-0.8259245157241821,
-0.16458751261234283,
1.2340161800384521,
-0.32823577523231506,
0.029718512669205666,
0.10038480162620544,
0.026631109416484833,
0.20018303394317627,
-0.1863572746515274,
0.8825954794883728,
1.0218266248703003,
0.22760024666786194,
-0.028053781017661095,
-0.8199812173843384,
0.3274906575679779,
0.3321872353553772,
-0.8737651705741882,
0.3817701041698456,
0.5203211903572083,
0.31641608476638794,
0.07441291213035583,
0.21551865339279175,
0.08284719288349152,
0.1200096607208252,
0.08594010025262833,
0.0449984073638916,
-0.07494037598371506,
-0.30928266048431396,
-0.8543705344200134,
0.21294473111629486,
0.0809696689248085,
0.043620675802230835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00858v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00858v1 | Can Large Language Models Understand Context? | 2024-02-01T18:55:29 | 2024-02-01T18:55:29 | Yilun Zhu, Joel Ruben Antony Moniz, Shruti Bhargava, Jiarui Lu, Dhivya Piraviperumal, Site Li, Yuan Zhang, Hong Yu, Bo-Hsiang Tseng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding context is key to understanding human language, an ability
which Large Language Models (LLMs) have been increasingly seen to demonstrate
to an impressive extent. However, though the evaluation of LLMs encompasses
various domains within the realm of Natural Language Processing, limited
attention has been paid to probing their linguistic capability of understanding
contextual features. This paper introduces a context understanding benchmark by
adapting existing datasets to suit the evaluation of generative models. This
benchmark comprises of four distinct tasks and nine datasets, all featuring
prompts designed to assess the models' ability to understand context. First, we
evaluate the performance of LLMs under the in-context learning pretraining
scenario. Experimental results indicate that pre-trained dense models struggle
with understanding more nuanced contextual features when compared to
state-of-the-art fine-tuned models. Second, as LLM compression holds growing
significance in both research and real-world applications, we assess the
context understanding of quantized models under in-context-learning settings.
We find that 3-bit post-training quantization leads to varying degrees of
performance reduction on our benchmark. We conduct an extensive analysis of
these scenarios to substantiate our experimental results. | [
-0.559424638748169,
-0.6636529564857483,
0.7215205430984497,
0.30072712898254395,
-0.5079584121704102,
-0.2341197282075882,
-0.5995507836341858,
-0.28402864933013916,
-0.546611487865448,
0.39662259817123413,
-0.5389504432678223,
-0.5269241333007812,
-0.5648201704025269,
0.27593064308166504,
-0.42568570375442505,
0.5297476053237915,
-0.050973061472177505,
0.1041913777589798,
-0.5928877592086792,
-0.2880461513996124,
-0.7604203820228577,
-0.6974091529846191,
-0.5248309373855591,
-0.23275496065616608,
0.09008318930864334,
0.05161507800221443,
0.39388078451156616,
0.4688519537448883,
0.23938442766666412,
0.3157668113708496,
-0.3180995583534241,
-0.1660698503255844,
-0.5693977475166321,
-0.00817874725908041,
-0.13325050473213196,
-0.3679850101470947,
-0.2756984829902649,
-0.18781207501888275,
0.8652418851852417,
0.8675960898399353,
-0.13423503935337067,
0.1267598569393158,
0.24141491949558258,
0.4996223747730255,
-0.8876626491546631,
0.10680332779884338,
-0.7468473315238953,
0.022991450503468513,
0.037045449018478394,
-0.1895340383052826,
-0.5484628677368164,
0.10493465512990952,
0.24358166754245758,
-0.638261079788208,
0.3088584840297699,
-0.05241687595844269,
0.6697789430618286,
0.4272463321685791,
-0.6967839598655701,
-0.08095813542604446,
-0.47519245743751526,
0.7110223174095154,
-0.6277320981025696,
0.5776227712631226,
0.3981921076774597,
0.453948974609375,
0.003963996656239033,
-0.6933473944664001,
-0.5775740742683411,
0.20941948890686035,
-0.13617487251758575,
-0.11179783195257187,
-0.20781220495700836,
-0.09851718693971634,
0.41847482323646545,
0.5849766731262207,
-0.6059042811393738,
0.16127608716487885,
-0.024494323879480362,
-0.03223656862974167,
0.3034411072731018,
0.0996561124920845,
0.001582849770784378,
-0.2287735939025879,
-0.4735015332698822,
-0.3441426157951355,
-0.7650583386421204,
0.016200415790081024,
-0.17048107087612152,
0.14497393369674683,
-0.39774519205093384,
0.06810855865478516,
-0.2807614207267761,
1.1460682153701782,
-0.29834598302841187,
-0.005854178220033646,
0.206849604845047,
-0.3830333948135376,
-0.6850392818450928,
-0.16271132230758667,
0.5533865690231323,
0.16350987553596497,
0.3654671609401703,
-0.19114013016223907,
-0.3060295581817627,
-0.21595759689807892,
0.23413565754890442,
-0.9818837642669678,
-0.009233172051608562,
0.04577232897281647,
-0.42179781198501587,
0.07116130739450455,
-0.1383598893880844,
-0.26993656158447266,
-0.4203234314918518,
-0.47215354442596436,
0.4202030301094055,
-0.507987380027771,
-0.10492147505283356,
0.4115005433559418,
0.1021321639418602,
0.49833691120147705,
0.35237616300582886,
-0.8580418825149536,
0.27313846349716187,
0.9131665825843811,
0.8970861434936523,
0.12113738805055618,
-0.22102680802345276,
-0.44518882036209106,
0.008067571558058262,
-0.2695871591567993,
0.7658856511116028,
-0.3592866361141205,
-0.3280833065509796,
-0.04082133620977402,
0.041567862033843994,
-0.048441868275403976,
-0.7617533206939697,
0.5276665687561035,
-0.7554035186767578,
-0.1673966646194458,
-0.3805534839630127,
-0.5946416258811951,
-0.2786564826965332,
0.2437022477388382,
-0.6581762433052063,
0.6180437207221985,
0.30086272954940796,
-0.5139086246490479,
0.6369131207466125,
-0.3196486830711365,
-0.4189336895942688,
0.17843672633171082,
-0.15248242020606995,
-0.10897228866815567,
0.5514105558395386,
0.3740936815738678,
0.6748970746994019,
-0.5345939993858337,
0.5210240483283997,
-0.3363575339317322,
-0.5676866173744202,
0.40415361523628235,
-0.5698695778846741,
0.6317988038063049,
0.19129769504070282,
-0.11165203154087067,
0.11306506395339966,
-0.6749835014343262,
-0.08831275254487991,
-0.031384825706481934,
-0.3172396719455719,
-0.34899911284446716,
-0.04450896009802818,
0.1289921998977661,
0.25622206926345825,
0.007399777416139841,
-0.10534307360649109,
0.14144840836524963,
-0.26502153277397156,
0.6978654265403748,
0.6884719133377075,
-0.2938719093799591,
0.47806835174560547,
0.06492450833320618,
0.4224506616592407,
-0.05528450384736061,
-0.20201608538627625,
-0.3390592634677887,
0.10833963006734848,
-0.6920120120048523,
-0.2569962739944458,
0.3646533787250519,
0.12240470200777054,
-0.7493836879730225,
0.5895709991455078,
-0.7175220251083374,
0.004056362900882959,
-0.25656846165657043,
0.11417198926210403,
0.40498873591423035,
0.42923110723495483,
0.30168384313583374,
-0.29029151797294617,
-0.5504017472267151,
-0.8023211359977722,
-0.3289434611797333,
0.1570451408624649,
-0.486850768327713,
0.5585880279541016,
0.5644769072532654,
-0.1533057540655136,
1.0481775999069214,
-0.3017909824848175,
0.04253607615828514,
-0.1159934401512146,
0.2813788056373596,
0.20300881564617157,
0.28532448410987854,
0.3900662958621979,
-0.8234843015670776,
-0.3071695864200592,
-0.12997181713581085,
-0.7878509759902954,
-0.08121997863054276,
0.09389372915029526,
0.05129792541265488,
-0.12033551186323166,
0.6257871985435486,
-0.3986700475215912,
0.3655688166618347,
0.8300292491912842,
-0.45047610998153687,
0.3348289728164673,
-0.23645341396331787,
0.09407231211662292,
-1.0019503831863403,
0.11938101798295975,
0.02941868081688881,
-0.5279916524887085,
-0.5695274472236633,
-0.015443378128111362,
0.4653058648109436,
-0.16588324308395386,
-0.5343294143676758,
0.7302913069725037,
-0.4529825448989868,
-0.6678460240364075,
-0.24513942003250122,
0.17930245399475098,
0.18227320909500122,
0.25103214383125305,
0.3083156645298004,
1.0420610904693604,
0.5367934703826904,
-0.5646304488182068,
0.018095694482326508,
0.1861923485994339,
-1.091482400894165,
0.6002826690673828,
-0.677284836769104,
0.11403468251228333,
-0.16717849671840668,
0.5164185762405396,
-0.7255035638809204,
-0.37194299697875977,
-0.3107507824897766,
-0.1700042188167572,
0.14089623093605042,
-0.24915744364261627,
-0.7010545134544373,
-0.03354296833276749,
0.13276325166225433,
0.7340651750564575,
0.39563173055648804,
-0.7004660964012146,
0.40303173661231995,
0.1571096032857895,
0.15892262756824493,
-0.34031862020492554,
-0.45071083307266235,
0.18241173028945923,
-0.5441833734512329,
-0.5159958600997925,
0.5662164688110352,
-0.1284816563129425,
-0.3455832898616791,
-0.3203992247581482,
-0.03519706055521965,
-0.1751091033220291,
0.5188859701156616,
0.17966188490390778,
-0.1783689260482788,
-0.27863121032714844,
0.18588009476661682,
-0.30467990040779114,
-0.035201575607061386,
0.21585403382778168,
-0.11185687780380249,
0.7191048264503479,
-0.31144145131111145,
0.007182119879871607,
-0.3433912992477417,
-0.1194784939289093,
0.4280241131782532,
-0.08519712835550308,
0.898688018321991,
0.5854259729385376,
-0.4348030090332031,
-0.22716231644153595,
-0.33971133828163147,
-0.20971402525901794,
-0.4869379997253418,
0.34286391735076904,
-0.7040107250213623,
-1.0967681407928467,
0.40078994631767273,
-0.288287878036499,
-0.4061618447303772,
0.26758408546447754,
0.5339921116828918,
-0.0005192530807107687,
0.7995880246162415,
0.6320894956588745,
-0.05719996243715286,
0.40679508447647095,
-0.20083564519882202,
0.11088460683822632,
-1.106408953666687,
0.058988217264413834,
-0.39264407753944397,
-0.09344899654388428,
-0.3933277726173401,
-0.4805237650871277,
0.380333811044693,
0.6652019023895264,
-0.2511729896068573,
0.34934723377227783,
0.0005347081460058689,
0.6203157901763916,
0.1292487233877182,
0.10388375073671341,
0.13602212071418762,
-0.15034393966197968,
0.233442485332489,
0.27022960782051086,
-0.6272247433662415,
-0.5129604935646057,
0.8771209120750427,
0.31276825070381165,
0.4214353561401367,
0.2773793041706085,
0.23818162083625793,
0.07820096611976624,
0.5141315460205078,
-0.6912679672241211,
0.342887818813324,
-0.05890592932701111,
-0.42451682686805725,
-0.18429194390773773,
-0.5251822471618652,
-0.884422242641449,
0.5768689513206482,
-0.16008535027503967,
-0.8036959171295166,
0.12032443284988403,
-0.012964056804776192,
-0.48366567492485046,
0.0098996227607131,
-0.7076861262321472,
1.1071486473083496,
-0.1132112443447113,
-0.26653069257736206,
-0.1724703013896942,
-0.4453792870044708,
0.4943699836730957,
-0.14079470932483673,
0.46471378207206726,
-0.24971699714660645,
0.047305524349212646,
0.7065486311912537,
-0.23417136073112488,
0.6786253452301025,
-0.058130212128162384,
-0.27212023735046387,
-0.06438665091991425,
-0.03534318134188652,
0.12435055524110794,
0.30558910965919495,
-0.210471972823143,
0.34963613748550415,
-0.0012552010593935847,
-0.45953369140625,
-0.7519372701644897,
0.6589218378067017,
-0.6306721568107605,
-0.44280967116355896,
-0.11087888479232788,
-0.5791252255439758,
-0.39187541604042053,
-0.027152352035045624,
0.270084410905838,
0.7493332028388977,
-0.23332834243774414,
0.6258128881454468,
0.6001695394515991,
-0.2993595600128174,
0.500925600528717,
0.5780748128890991,
0.12428741902112961,
-0.2659573554992676,
0.4587300419807434,
-0.4107425808906555,
0.1740923374891281,
0.46724095940589905,
0.20355673134326935,
-0.37959617376327515,
-0.6180148720741272,
-0.37299469113349915,
-0.06425972282886505,
-0.9692217707633972,
-0.13612432777881622,
-0.41809988021850586,
0.04266843572258949,
-0.42993786931037903,
-0.18364481627941132,
-0.08493785560131073,
0.16715437173843384,
-0.3488394021987915,
0.06980078667402267,
0.11729618906974792,
0.6593500971794128,
0.24203158915042877,
0.6865464448928833,
-0.7793673276901245,
0.2266741394996643,
0.3754119873046875,
0.4443186819553375,
0.15731841325759888,
-0.7926677465438843,
-0.41105517745018005,
-0.10293139517307281,
-0.041456226259469986,
-0.5759739875793457,
0.46089744567871094,
0.21451279520988464,
0.2736303508281708,
0.5422632694244385,
-0.13281889259815216,
0.8469289541244507,
-0.47396788001060486,
0.7486295104026794,
-0.18875326216220856,
-1.248427391052246,
0.4666421413421631,
-0.2750962972640991,
0.6276854276657104,
0.6024089455604553,
0.4653167426586151,
-0.4302697777748108,
0.42348340153694153,
-0.4720037281513214,
-0.6634061336517334,
0.6229874491691589,
0.11201464384794235,
0.08848174661397934,
-0.01020527072250843,
0.5925847887992859,
0.05126233398914337,
0.23585392534732819,
-0.9304001927375793,
0.053499240428209305,
0.11610633879899979,
-0.02832341007888317,
-0.600400447845459,
-0.47861799597740173,
-0.030674543231725693,
-0.2189437299966812,
0.07720485329627991,
-0.2747681140899658,
0.010889044031500816,
-0.15490710735321045,
-0.6154636144638062,
0.27015164494514465,
0.35609152913093567,
0.6503870487213135,
0.9959346055984497,
-0.3139992654323578,
0.33339980244636536,
0.3909134566783905,
-0.07681459188461304,
0.018292929977178574,
-0.08103068172931671,
0.32537439465522766,
-0.3680349886417389,
0.8806061744689941,
1.1213881969451904,
0.6934171319007874,
-0.7457836270332336,
0.7322283387184143,
-0.51300048828125,
-0.04291334003210068,
-0.1397983729839325,
0.01078492496162653,
-0.027763163670897484,
0.12783613801002502,
0.2222902476787567,
-0.2621433734893799,
0.19418276846408844,
-0.6346543431282043,
0.05675158277153969,
0.4550389051437378,
-0.35881829261779785,
-0.4322969913482666,
0.3847224712371826,
0.13148891925811768,
-0.20319394767284393,
0.5887455940246582,
-0.10776317119598389,
-0.5899315476417542,
0.5402551889419556,
0.5959272980690002,
0.7751834392547607,
0.0582599937915802,
-0.313786119222641,
0.41410547494888306,
-0.06467366218566895,
-0.0812322124838829,
0.05834343284368515,
-0.7018277645111084,
-0.9787143468856812,
-0.6505335569381714,
-0.807030200958252,
-0.21831290423870087,
0.4277868866920471,
-0.8854096531867981,
0.07341369986534119,
-0.1722852885723114,
0.0065161846578121185,
-0.09406188130378723,
-0.0883760154247284,
-1.072460412979126,
0.44782355427742004,
0.14842605590820312,
0.8112273812294006,
-0.9126253128051758,
0.9955909252166748,
0.45329421758651733,
0.10185572504997253,
-0.4144129455089569,
0.15728935599327087,
-0.1819004863500595,
-0.7987959384918213,
0.8649569153785706,
0.5827928781509399,
0.029807226732373238,
0.13251902163028717,
-0.47339963912963867,
-0.7313926219940186,
1.1179753541946411,
0.3770868480205536,
-0.5970596671104431,
0.38256824016571045,
-0.0376659594476223,
0.4394058883190155,
-0.36328884959220886,
0.3963565528392792,
0.9143050909042358,
0.28745418787002563,
-0.15505030751228333,
-0.7500792145729065,
0.11094455420970917,
-0.07160105556249619,
0.2569616138935089,
0.015097631141543388,
-0.2902284860610962,
0.93712317943573,
0.1908450573682785,
-0.5219148397445679,
0.01256474293768406,
0.5861318111419678,
0.3304564952850342,
0.1420789510011673,
0.7872739434242249,
0.6160460710525513,
0.536230742931366,
-0.1913459599018097,
1.3623367547988892,
-0.44501039385795593,
0.38636404275894165,
1.0961287021636963,
-0.25702008605003357,
1.0168548822402954,
0.37598979473114014,
-0.24076028168201447,
0.46363356709480286,
0.8008593916893005,
0.45774585008621216,
0.6076515913009644,
0.45416587591171265,
-0.49813544750213623,
-0.47234609723091125,
-0.06078367680311203,
-0.2655557096004486,
0.6388521194458008,
0.48457613587379456,
-0.16393664479255676,
-0.11335527896881104,
0.14406254887580872,
-0.3388702869415283,
0.004243969451636076,
-0.1766495257616043,
0.8887256979942322,
0.15467436611652374,
-0.608665943145752,
0.8366912603378296,
0.018790708854794502,
0.5859296321868896,
-0.38829371333122253,
0.1360858529806137,
-0.19808267056941986,
0.04486263543367386,
0.09167921543121338,
-0.6752162575721741,
0.1748371124267578,
0.020538168027997017,
-0.26084160804748535,
-0.37326720356941223,
0.38478606939315796,
-0.1542191356420517,
-0.1444815844297409,
0.24393633008003235,
0.2883949875831604,
0.13173328340053558,
-0.4466721713542938,
-0.35924434661865234,
0.5460803508758545,
-0.34360525012016296,
-0.22200843691825867,
0.4466269016265869,
0.6361664533615112,
0.04402865841984749,
0.5076638460159302,
0.46297475695610046,
-0.16686008870601654,
-0.3242397904396057,
0.3180268108844757,
0.7085380554199219,
-0.7065620422363281,
-0.40382078289985657,
-1.0115916728973389,
0.18125082552433014,
-0.008856034837663174,
-0.3744555115699768,
0.6201540231704712,
0.38417425751686096,
1.0742026567459106,
-0.017761459574103355,
0.5947071313858032,
0.211284801363945,
0.004039373714476824,
-0.8431317210197449,
0.5681785941123962,
-0.6062928438186646,
0.30891117453575134,
-0.006623531691730022,
-0.8638735413551331,
-0.2512170076370239,
0.7921602129936218,
-0.5351552367210388,
0.16213543713092804,
0.553819477558136,
0.4655347466468811,
-0.1428666114807129,
-0.02321351133286953,
0.5256063938140869,
0.15254122018814087,
0.21841615438461304,
0.6864151954650879,
1.0054130554199219,
-0.4510631859302521,
0.0727313682436943,
-0.24582818150520325,
-0.19520016014575958,
-0.14692381024360657,
-1.17522394657135,
-0.9295444488525391,
-0.6256473064422607,
0.026716535910964012,
-0.07383637875318527,
-0.10187317430973053,
0.5453316569328308,
1.1425433158874512,
-0.638591468334198,
-0.2234582006931305,
-0.28522032499313354,
-0.027881691232323647,
0.015865476801991463,
-0.21071328222751617,
0.4669565260410309,
-0.25374165177345276,
-0.5954911112785339,
0.7122044563293457,
0.19501163065433502,
-0.09598138928413391,
-0.2028001844882965,
-0.08828418701887131,
0.14558950066566467,
-0.2393556386232376,
0.8932244777679443,
-0.0454338975250721,
-0.8281489014625549,
-0.31948429346084595,
-0.3810778558254242,
0.04375327005982399,
0.05414148420095444,
1.071394920349121,
-1.0631920099258423,
0.39914950728416443,
0.441369891166687,
0.6754221320152283,
0.6595178246498108,
0.14821963012218475,
0.6333509087562561,
-0.9220946431159973,
0.2846413850784302,
-0.06696148961782455,
0.5620788335800171,
0.5423665046691895,
-0.21121478080749512,
0.438254714012146,
-0.05315951257944107,
-0.4442310035228729,
-0.7828617691993713,
0.1868492215871811,
-0.680081844329834,
-0.537090539932251,
1.0481207370758057,
-0.23870965838432312,
-0.2550584375858307,
0.13267934322357178,
0.1607130914926529,
0.20382755994796753,
0.15115438401699066,
0.5776097178459167,
0.7089905142784119,
0.1586046665906906,
-0.29860222339630127,
-0.8134809732437134,
0.5011062026023865,
0.5180148482322693,
-0.8587149381637573,
0.32920312881469727,
0.40860387682914734,
0.2241736650466919,
-0.35202932357788086,
0.5409191250801086,
0.24894917011260986,
0.10895755887031555,
-0.24794670939445496,
-0.11741172522306442,
0.2608461081981659,
-0.30475562810897827,
-0.9352359175682068,
0.04172094166278839,
0.15149371325969696,
0.1283469945192337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00856v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00856v4 | Towards Efficient Exact Optimization of Language Model Alignment | 2024-02-01T18:51:54 | 2024-06-05T08:15:12 | Haozhe Ji, Cheng Lu, Yilin Niu, Pei Ke, Hongning Wang, Jun Zhu, Jie Tang, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The alignment of language models with human preferences is vital for their
application in real-world tasks. The problem is formulated as optimizing the
model's policy to maximize the expected reward that reflects human preferences
with minimal deviation from the initial policy. While considered as a
straightforward solution, reinforcement learning (RL) suffers from high
variance in policy updates, which impedes efficient policy improvement.
Recently, direct preference optimization (DPO) was proposed to directly
optimize the policy from preference data. However, we show that DPO derived
based on the optimal solution of the problem leads to a compromised
mean-seeking approximation of the optimal solution in practice. In this paper,
we propose efficient exact optimization (EXO) of the alignment objective. EXO
is guaranteed to optimize in the same direction as RL algorithms asymptotically
for arbitrary policy parametrization. This leads to the same mode-seeking
solution, while enables efficient optimization by circumventing the
complexities of RL. We also compare our method to DPO with both theoretical and
empirical analyses, and further demonstrate the advantages of our method over
existing approaches on realistic human preference data. Code is available at
https://github.com/haozheji/exact-optimization. | [
-0.07740968465805054,
-0.5460234880447388,
0.5394576787948608,
0.04853742942214012,
-0.2205422818660736,
0.05274644121527672,
-0.5756073594093323,
-0.08619809150695801,
-0.013164849020540714,
0.5049691796302795,
-0.7515227794647217,
-0.2879701256752014,
-0.29978421330451965,
-0.18708306550979614,
0.20421616733074188,
0.6879005432128906,
-0.3052116334438324,
-0.23151183128356934,
0.11730141937732697,
-0.028823550790548325,
-0.1283813714981079,
-0.1449839174747467,
-0.6321703791618347,
-0.22301340103149414,
0.3968704342842102,
0.5011983513832092,
0.7607953548431396,
1.228615641593933,
0.2612263560295105,
0.2856229543685913,
-0.08970101177692413,
0.5337012410163879,
-0.5437524318695068,
0.2084842324256897,
-0.08187496662139893,
-0.125156968832016,
-0.268907755613327,
0.16159731149673462,
0.7071554064750671,
0.4497169554233551,
-0.3747066855430603,
-0.14961206912994385,
0.11227098852396011,
0.9497323036193848,
-0.6835448741912842,
0.035279933363199234,
-0.5277342796325684,
0.2111719846725464,
0.11942000687122345,
-0.20538543164730072,
-0.27161771059036255,
-0.5434902906417847,
0.2896265685558319,
-0.9970250129699707,
-0.27284500002861023,
0.33309996128082275,
1.1921073198318481,
0.37181681394577026,
-0.3523654639720917,
-0.17272710800170898,
-0.7093750238418579,
1.0287506580352783,
-0.5384392738342285,
0.37948551774024963,
0.3000766336917877,
0.2865701913833618,
-0.3986997902393341,
0.04766382277011871,
-0.5916538238525391,
-0.2899574637413025,
0.13039197027683258,
-0.023784425109624863,
-0.21069501340389252,
0.48315009474754333,
0.1473807990550995,
0.12303414940834045,
-0.7309316992759705,
0.2536845803260803,
0.09280873090028763,
-0.05597808584570885,
0.6332740187644958,
-0.06813283264636993,
0.2395612746477127,
0.06257134675979614,
-0.3987639546394348,
-0.3972621262073517,
-0.4530331790447235,
0.304171621799469,
0.8051624298095703,
0.39992183446884155,
-0.053641367703676224,
0.3396146893501282,
-0.23037321865558624,
0.9103383421897888,
0.21307483315467834,
0.007994409650564194,
0.29476502537727356,
-0.23629191517829895,
-0.01614379696547985,
-0.021930919960141182,
0.7892650365829468,
0.17401346564292908,
0.32712292671203613,
-0.20958824455738068,
-0.22111845016479492,
-0.1964249461889267,
0.5135987401008606,
-0.3288494646549225,
0.19376535713672638,
0.1957777589559555,
-0.10498373210430145,
-0.5789650678634644,
-0.03699556738138199,
-0.800236701965332,
0.0030124017503112555,
-0.6051088571548462,
0.29341921210289,
-0.2247004359960556,
-0.14642049372196198,
0.21901929378509521,
0.17804643511772156,
0.34841856360435486,
0.16213873028755188,
-1.0779329538345337,
0.26896148920059204,
1.0671006441116333,
0.631618857383728,
-0.2889973223209381,
-0.10875464230775833,
-0.7411286234855652,
0.25841835141181946,
-0.47315606474876404,
0.34103167057037354,
-0.5933988690376282,
-0.2150946855545044,
0.057109009474515915,
-0.4089995324611664,
-0.1378602534532547,
-0.3813096880912781,
0.8791822195053101,
-0.5474138259887695,
0.18184061348438263,
-0.22414790093898773,
-0.4776274263858795,
-0.13368995487689972,
0.35351094603538513,
-0.6103872060775757,
0.9081193208694458,
-0.09833525121212006,
-0.22682523727416992,
0.3620661795139313,
-0.6770934462547302,
-0.21886862814426422,
-0.38288646936416626,
-0.2866658866405487,
-0.5394461750984192,
0.10911353677511215,
0.09570014476776123,
0.01731701008975506,
-0.22977034747600555,
0.5947859883308411,
-0.2536102831363678,
-0.2969544231891632,
0.223348930478096,
-0.3685138523578644,
0.5714013576507568,
0.2576322555541992,
-0.5266937613487244,
0.47842299938201904,
-0.6205218434333801,
0.1376253217458725,
0.22145795822143555,
-0.3607543408870697,
-0.6298797130584717,
0.31192296743392944,
-0.26143667101860046,
0.08846583962440491,
0.44289159774780273,
-0.6603530645370483,
0.5249411463737488,
-0.7047876119613647,
0.16028858721256256,
1.2054611444473267,
-0.40993309020996094,
0.7791501879692078,
-0.16717903316020966,
0.5591376423835754,
-0.31148338317871094,
0.4610444903373718,
0.47553402185440063,
0.05285285413265228,
-0.4669553339481354,
-0.3417968153953552,
0.3278522789478302,
0.27583765983581543,
-0.2734270989894867,
0.7625762224197388,
-0.39233750104904175,
-0.06963099539279938,
-0.7576194405555725,
0.047530364245176315,
0.770248532295227,
0.557972252368927,
0.23497842252254486,
0.07946105301380157,
-0.563323974609375,
-1.0052094459533691,
-0.44630205631256104,
-0.14730490744113922,
0.28922587633132935,
0.5192973613739014,
-0.03199821338057518,
-0.10363925248384476,
0.9994455575942993,
-0.7432478666305542,
-0.07298620045185089,
-0.14016622304916382,
-0.285094678401947,
0.3097813129425049,
0.5742406249046326,
0.3239974081516266,
-1.0584619045257568,
-0.8391363620758057,
0.23836904764175415,
-0.3806843161582947,
-0.17446686327457428,
0.05795813724398613,
-0.5999287962913513,
0.35993456840515137,
0.08090212941169739,
-0.2571360170841217,
-0.0478530153632164,
0.59197998046875,
-0.18640588223934174,
0.38864508271217346,
-0.29694417119026184,
0.11546308547258377,
-0.7264127731323242,
0.3295552134513855,
-0.010517150163650513,
-0.4038648009300232,
-0.6949923038482666,
0.22311797738075256,
0.18535321950912476,
-0.20668798685073853,
-0.0704745426774025,
0.6959624886512756,
-0.3434630334377289,
0.2324298769235611,
-0.20530496537685394,
0.10352762043476105,
0.0026020300574600697,
0.8126827478408813,
0.2038881778717041,
0.46804502606391907,
0.44006335735321045,
-0.42851904034614563,
0.1320803314447403,
0.11295332759618759,
-0.09306079149246216,
0.18283097445964813,
-0.3680605888366699,
0.26958754658699036,
-0.12587054073810577,
-0.03682838752865791,
-0.7647472023963928,
-0.023429054766893387,
0.7089228630065918,
-0.1926678568124771,
0.6191538572311401,
-0.07256805896759033,
-0.016769908368587494,
-0.16817553341388702,
-0.533512532711029,
0.24042613804340363,
0.5439512729644775,
-0.6846911907196045,
0.3990662395954132,
0.3924127221107483,
0.213638037443161,
-1.107533574104309,
0.02313447929918766,
-0.3297233283519745,
-0.2527347803115845,
-0.21696272492408752,
0.5803062319755554,
0.07393287122249603,
-0.21294738352298737,
-0.06028040871024132,
-0.5740114450454712,
0.016412369906902313,
0.12999117374420166,
-0.07004139572381973,
0.3659929931163788,
0.06821810454130173,
-0.1590024083852768,
0.26186931133270264,
-0.34172987937927246,
-0.299590140581131,
-0.20982405543327332,
0.6715008020401001,
0.059556543827056885,
-0.2629185616970062,
-0.4710806608200073,
0.3616538345813751,
0.22477348148822784,
-0.007205500733107328,
0.2680061161518097,
0.05946285277605057,
-0.051159147173166275,
-0.28560173511505127,
-0.4822414517402649,
0.007687059696763754,
-0.5405647158622742,
0.5040642619132996,
-0.4342710077762604,
-0.48957791924476624,
-0.023651491850614548,
0.12240081280469894,
0.3501743972301483,
0.0821453258395195,
0.05345869064331055,
0.06716709583997726,
1.3172690868377686,
0.5501459240913391,
-0.24666576087474823,
0.7058907747268677,
0.04436755180358887,
0.1385045349597931,
-0.7260646224021912,
-0.12190835922956467,
-0.547678530216217,
-0.32808583974838257,
-0.39713332056999207,
-0.3012952208518982,
0.04842175915837288,
0.046460285782814026,
-0.36496075987815857,
0.4588530957698822,
-0.6986736059188843,
0.3736785054206848,
0.6494365930557251,
0.26623421907424927,
0.2368972897529602,
0.21152272820472717,
-0.2075597494840622,
-0.2353065460920334,
-0.5706760883331299,
-0.4238550662994385,
0.9521922469139099,
0.22581171989440918,
0.6096660494804382,
0.1396205723285675,
0.8139369487762451,
0.1698562502861023,
-0.3466217815876007,
-0.7886630296707153,
0.3975151479244232,
-0.13090066611766815,
-0.2749583423137665,
-0.5424931049346924,
-0.6421119570732117,
-0.9381772875785828,
0.3343159258365631,
-0.07630690187215805,
-0.5311334133148193,
0.15526872873306274,
0.5018967986106873,
-0.3046987056732178,
-0.0036658276803791523,
-0.360012024641037,
1.0979022979736328,
-0.56573486328125,
-0.3164777457714081,
-0.36182987689971924,
-0.72931307554245,
-0.07230733335018158,
-0.016743052750825882,
0.0571526475250721,
-0.2579367756843567,
-0.3052996098995209,
0.6155517101287842,
-0.3654381334781647,
0.31518515944480896,
-0.37358197569847107,
-0.01787274144589901,
-0.057304125279188156,
-0.0025947934482246637,
0.7494003772735596,
-0.43386173248291016,
-0.2098095566034317,
-0.2604157626628876,
-0.14245334267616272,
-0.46521589159965515,
-0.7993947267532349,
0.6919391751289368,
-0.9872589111328125,
-0.6917869448661804,
-0.4008515179157257,
-0.5049778819084167,
-0.2724474370479584,
0.1380452960729599,
-0.13597546517848969,
0.40572333335876465,
-0.37345486879348755,
-0.17389246821403503,
0.6772546172142029,
-0.23009756207466125,
0.30503594875335693,
0.6891286969184875,
-0.27143242955207825,
-0.1084032729268074,
1.0906015634536743,
-0.16164682805538177,
0.438355416059494,
0.756359338760376,
0.6027998328208923,
-0.30893653631210327,
-0.4537632465362549,
-0.6814970374107361,
0.27848607301712036,
-0.25029441714286804,
0.008365693502128124,
-0.5058335065841675,
0.17227284610271454,
-0.35280290246009827,
-0.4030319154262543,
-0.5780214667320251,
-0.26472315192222595,
-0.19780071079730988,
0.13614501059055328,
0.11282529681921005,
0.0029982959385961294,
-0.14375829696655273,
0.11128862202167511,
-0.3523448705673218,
0.13176406919956207,
0.21920473873615265,
0.31940335035324097,
-0.15267418324947357,
-0.5347309112548828,
-0.0048799701035022736,
0.3593929409980774,
-0.2915128469467163,
-0.6626276969909668,
0.46802255511283875,
0.36251938343048096,
0.6444339752197266,
0.6751515865325928,
0.18740609288215637,
0.7870578765869141,
-0.4348195493221283,
0.14336934685707092,
0.06659681349992752,
-0.8730878233909607,
0.571629524230957,
-0.31624695658683777,
0.014993487857282162,
0.8851150870323181,
0.6134377717971802,
-0.6027970910072327,
0.07674223184585571,
-0.3913653492927551,
-0.8545734286308289,
0.8900801539421082,
-0.04670995473861694,
0.12797659635543823,
0.08148181438446045,
0.426135778427124,
0.17938534915447235,
0.13589906692504883,
-0.4863564670085907,
-0.26717880368232727,
0.1897542029619217,
-0.4346461296081543,
0.10472703725099564,
-0.09684482961893082,
-0.23217757046222687,
-0.0977569967508316,
1.0014985799789429,
-0.24316631257534027,
0.15673239529132843,
-0.12809783220291138,
-0.016512976959347725,
-0.2725534439086914,
0.12925350666046143,
0.6405856609344482,
0.3119387924671173,
-0.38796696066856384,
-0.13737919926643372,
-0.24989065527915955,
-0.15494896471500397,
0.4083140790462494,
-0.050120171159505844,
-0.2622174918651581,
-0.19347475469112396,
-0.3108104467391968,
1.0021840333938599,
0.3754931390285492,
-1.0896942615509033,
0.7679853439331055,
0.06500852853059769,
-0.028001734986901283,
-0.2523699700832367,
0.26839956641197205,
-0.29633304476737976,
0.13108299672603607,
0.21361209452152252,
-0.032466400414705276,
0.13250598311424255,
-0.443911075592041,
0.062750443816185,
0.6725417971611023,
-0.812940239906311,
-0.1362924724817276,
0.4675900340080261,
0.13819469511508942,
-0.44469889998435974,
0.46294888854026794,
-0.14820648729801178,
-0.5082681179046631,
0.570837676525116,
0.660497784614563,
0.8609070777893066,
-0.1098572164773941,
0.274753600358963,
0.2683101296424866,
-0.09877973049879074,
-0.24650852382183075,
0.04724081978201866,
-0.22215458750724792,
-0.9712858200073242,
-0.42127367854118347,
-0.6365019679069519,
-0.5449187159538269,
-0.3928203880786896,
-0.7756237983703613,
0.44836968183517456,
-0.4335175156593323,
0.2810380756855011,
-0.3189863860607147,
0.06508170068264008,
-0.300861120223999,
-0.018320130184292793,
0.06205691769719124,
0.5490548014640808,
-0.6907751560211182,
0.9878988862037659,
0.5085575580596924,
-0.14466142654418945,
-0.9665228128433228,
-0.14722467958927155,
0.0489196851849556,
-1.0891679525375366,
0.4188048839569092,
-0.011203465051949024,
-0.07792796194553375,
0.15469376742839813,
-0.33862781524658203,
-0.9769780039787292,
0.7085621356964111,
0.35891181230545044,
-0.8660679459571838,
-0.3455062210559845,
-0.18121479451656342,
0.3577730059623718,
-0.374356746673584,
0.04364093393087387,
0.6136330962181091,
0.46572625637054443,
0.0690709576010704,
-0.7728506326675415,
0.2177993357181549,
-0.1297115832567215,
-0.05614427849650383,
0.6561321020126343,
-0.5670139193534851,
0.13641537725925446,
0.01189640536904335,
-0.11916304379701614,
-0.06354782730340958,
0.41263994574546814,
0.35018712282180786,
-0.07086358219385147,
0.601466715335846,
0.5696141123771667,
0.6300468444824219,
0.04174662381410599,
1.0287805795669556,
-0.16066980361938477,
0.4666314721107483,
0.9394679665565491,
-0.2423534095287323,
0.6497427821159363,
0.5889546871185303,
-0.1957617998123169,
0.17513689398765564,
0.6543242335319519,
0.21014679968357086,
0.8737980723381042,
0.2515931725502014,
-0.151023268699646,
-0.11214695870876312,
-0.01344707515090704,
-0.08182395994663239,
0.4223599433898926,
-0.03167407587170601,
-0.2889476418495178,
-0.00545052345842123,
-0.20913200080394745,
0.3074154853820801,
0.449271023273468,
-0.2347022294998169,
0.941225528717041,
-0.26339051127433777,
-1.0044084787368774,
0.666552722454071,
-0.012457214295864105,
0.7700265049934387,
-0.6958267688751221,
0.1746012568473816,
-0.043272122740745544,
0.1660633683204651,
0.021823564544320107,
-0.30178356170654297,
0.3044919967651367,
-0.19923058152198792,
-0.18484213948249817,
-0.32843267917633057,
0.3468361496925354,
-0.7318708896636963,
0.04327041655778885,
0.31716325879096985,
0.1025964766740799,
-0.02094249241054058,
-0.09553961455821991,
-0.8403874039649963,
0.1269223690032959,
0.5074948668479919,
-0.3568571209907532,
0.5648143291473389,
-0.11540688574314117,
0.07251422852277756,
0.5595526695251465,
0.3797653615474701,
0.23585855960845947,
-0.12130651623010635,
-0.3205256164073944,
0.5805853605270386,
-0.5395160913467407,
-0.5387872457504272,
-1.0373035669326782,
0.21624964475631714,
-0.2624678909778595,
-0.38911667466163635,
0.36462700366973877,
0.70277339220047,
0.7457049489021301,
0.020852426066994667,
0.6895850896835327,
-0.08094555139541626,
0.3883357644081116,
-0.4200842082500458,
0.42393526434898376,
-0.7119695544242859,
0.05275704711675644,
-0.3809506893157959,
-1.2233208417892456,
-0.24760761857032776,
0.7469256520271301,
-0.4552057981491089,
-0.3292250335216522,
0.518284022808075,
0.9573230147361755,
-0.17442800104618073,
-0.0859806090593338,
0.31444400548934937,
-0.26941850781440735,
0.18723395466804504,
0.6229130029678345,
0.5223843455314636,
-0.12695614993572235,
0.42798322439193726,
-0.4364602565765381,
-0.36449939012527466,
-0.19158624112606049,
-0.8255154490470886,
-0.2522875666618347,
-0.5101108551025391,
-0.48515620827674866,
-0.2878130376338959,
0.4774066209793091,
1.6180988550186157,
0.45403996109962463,
-0.5701104998588562,
-0.34057024121284485,
-0.19424784183502197,
0.20953455567359924,
-0.4420751631259918,
-0.2199360579252243,
0.5154473781585693,
-0.3672017455101013,
-1.0443342924118042,
0.42134714126586914,
0.3357175290584564,
-0.1678725928068161,
-0.004371565766632557,
-0.48911821842193604,
-0.316199392080307,
0.012762276455760002,
0.1506579965353012,
0.7778684496879578,
-0.706362247467041,
-0.4741610288619995,
0.04648193344473839,
-0.42289406061172485,
0.20098605751991272,
0.7819872498512268,
-0.3726810812950134,
0.6470315456390381,
0.5205459594726562,
0.796179473400116,
0.4908781051635742,
0.31333979964256287,
0.9312835335731506,
-0.512832522392273,
0.055262498557567596,
0.3363920748233795,
0.04989064112305641,
0.10638081282377243,
-0.2095290869474411,
0.49840158224105835,
-0.07244616001844406,
-0.640796422958374,
-0.8790139555931091,
0.30504322052001953,
-1.1006076335906982,
-0.2093868851661682,
1.2472599744796753,
-0.2235776036977768,
-0.3906908333301544,
-0.012156556360423565,
-0.3635637164115906,
0.3552621304988861,
-0.8059953451156616,
0.747494637966156,
0.1760758012533188,
-0.2062840461730957,
0.10566060245037079,
-0.2843681573867798,
0.7092857360839844,
0.6781734824180603,
-0.3668067455291748,
0.1295960545539856,
0.36648130416870117,
0.1419384777545929,
-0.20578554272651672,
0.5801690220832825,
-0.09524980932474136,
0.10392408072948456,
-0.3969719707965851,
0.2722395062446594,
-0.11574175953865051,
-0.16583409905433655,
-0.5152434706687927,
-0.005746286362409592,
0.2226567268371582,
-0.3808467984199524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00841v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00841v2 | Tiny Titans: Can Smaller Large Language Models Punch Above Their Weight in the Real World for Meeting Summarization? | 2024-02-01T18:31:34 | 2024-04-15T17:56:58 | Xue-Yong Fu, Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, Elena Khasanova, Cheng Chen, Shashi Bhushan TN | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities to
solve a wide range of tasks without being explicitly fine-tuned on
task-specific datasets. However, deploying LLMs in the real world is not
trivial, as it requires substantial computing resources. In this paper, we
investigate whether smaller, compact LLMs are a good alternative to the
comparatively Larger LLMs2 to address significant costs associated with
utilizing LLMs in the real world. In this regard, we study the meeting
summarization task in a real-world industrial environment and conduct extensive
experiments by comparing the performance of fine-tuned compact LLMs (e.g.,
FLAN-T5, TinyLLaMA, LiteLLaMA) with zero-shot larger LLMs (e.g., LLaMA-2,
GPT-3.5, PaLM-2). We observe that most smaller LLMs, even after fine-tuning,
fail to outperform larger zero-shot LLMs in meeting summarization datasets.
However, a notable exception is FLAN-T5 (780M parameters), which performs on
par or even better than many zero-shot Larger LLMs (from 7B to above 70B
parameters), while being significantly smaller. This makes compact LLMs like
FLAN-T5 a suitable cost-efficient solution for real-world industrial
deployment. | [
-0.4359023869037628,
-0.5995089411735535,
0.7592778205871582,
0.05422579497098923,
-0.4209444224834442,
0.01555644627660513,
-0.5599554777145386,
-0.8872204422950745,
0.3224860727787018,
0.2622408866882324,
-0.36997613310813904,
-0.26426711678504944,
-0.5291920900344849,
0.2544100284576416,
-0.30218300223350525,
0.6439483761787415,
0.091573067009449,
-0.325909823179245,
0.10526824742555618,
-0.2626498341560364,
-0.46506577730178833,
-0.42017683386802673,
-0.7454366683959961,
-0.3755612075328827,
0.8422439098358154,
0.6311204433441162,
0.9185618758201599,
0.7658522725105286,
0.6778080463409424,
0.26712486147880554,
-0.5016448497772217,
0.3355098068714142,
-0.5278358459472656,
-0.33086177706718445,
-0.013123567216098309,
-0.6999355554580688,
-0.712407648563385,
0.046369653195142746,
0.6977758407592773,
0.9942966103553772,
-0.10039917379617691,
0.3552566468715668,
-0.06195499375462532,
0.6121852397918701,
-0.43814757466316223,
0.03127842769026756,
-0.47087693214416504,
0.16227462887763977,
-0.23008817434310913,
0.2661707401275635,
-0.29453420639038086,
-0.2756046652793884,
-0.30740782618522644,
-0.2698372006416321,
0.13913322985172272,
0.5245772004127502,
0.9132895469665527,
0.1350100338459015,
-0.2596293091773987,
-0.14546789228916168,
-0.7756965160369873,
0.8375326991081238,
-1.058455228805542,
0.15422965586185455,
-0.07265094667673111,
0.5774097442626953,
-0.19431526958942413,
-0.8367734551429749,
-0.6370612978935242,
-0.11643596738576889,
-0.1753472536802292,
0.0556977204978466,
-0.1708744913339615,
0.14316990971565247,
0.24403230845928192,
0.5704083442687988,
-0.5009455680847168,
0.6703233122825623,
-0.4494427740573883,
0.2278110384941101,
0.5027560591697693,
0.5885419249534607,
0.11996981501579285,
-0.04276974871754646,
0.09836482256650925,
0.004940761718899012,
-0.9229709506034851,
-0.34164366126060486,
-0.04833048954606056,
0.7737080454826355,
-0.3904159367084503,
0.5534276962280273,
-0.156255304813385,
0.59835284948349,
-0.038210153579711914,
-0.4584950804710388,
-0.31104758381843567,
-0.48260748386383057,
-0.5271347761154175,
-0.06697621196508408,
0.7322747111320496,
0.49169987440109253,
0.2915084660053253,
-0.2076573669910431,
-0.37357157468795776,
-0.0886906310915947,
0.0025142012163996696,
-1.0979558229446411,
-0.21030031144618988,
0.2717720866203308,
-0.55308598279953,
-0.3157289922237396,
-0.28663891553878784,
-0.3705231547355652,
-0.36778804659843445,
-0.32184961438179016,
0.5024207234382629,
0.04488910734653473,
-0.021085767075419426,
-0.11436018347740173,
-0.043290089815855026,
0.18424242734909058,
0.5661655068397522,
-0.9093629717826843,
0.3532623052597046,
0.8172805905342102,
1.494796872138977,
0.13024809956550598,
-0.06079014763236046,
-0.6173760890960693,
0.12855251133441925,
-0.5670658946037292,
0.8317614793777466,
-0.006052689626812935,
-0.7101420164108276,
-0.21744470298290253,
-0.2289304882287979,
-0.09137217700481415,
-1.0208344459533691,
0.3677474558353424,
-0.19441042840480804,
-0.0030171284452080727,
-0.5157238841056824,
-0.3476168215274811,
0.14521484076976776,
0.24210309982299805,
-0.5033383369445801,
0.49066200852394104,
0.03005134128034115,
-0.5539292693138123,
0.4789404571056366,
-0.3862156271934509,
-0.5694551467895508,
0.13176628947257996,
-0.4671042561531067,
-0.5085221529006958,
0.2924749255180359,
0.050501443445682526,
0.5740892887115479,
-0.5104191303253174,
-0.1839018166065216,
-0.41511061787605286,
-0.6915439963340759,
0.14866599440574646,
-0.06306257098913193,
0.405656099319458,
0.307526558637619,
-0.15138977766036987,
0.14673921465873718,
-0.2898949086666107,
-0.13646045327186584,
0.041239939630031586,
-0.36498892307281494,
-0.044490426778793335,
0.038449376821517944,
0.013431686908006668,
0.20392678678035736,
0.123975969851017,
-0.4539024531841278,
0.18434590101242065,
-0.6928229928016663,
0.3135451078414917,
0.4820650815963745,
0.07682345807552338,
0.39167335629463196,
-0.7118875980377197,
0.5540958046913147,
-0.27903270721435547,
0.03910920396447182,
0.1146516427397728,
-0.29996809363365173,
-0.8873805403709412,
-0.6454235315322876,
0.3537243902683258,
0.23953019082546234,
-0.663165807723999,
0.09747454524040222,
-0.6872479319572449,
-0.7141522765159607,
-0.23257660865783691,
0.06670334935188293,
0.36900341510772705,
0.25878027081489563,
-0.046596329659223557,
0.1293509602546692,
-0.5475043058395386,
-0.9412439465522766,
-0.41165247559547424,
-0.0743517354130745,
-0.44733956456184387,
0.30053457617759705,
0.5364006161689758,
0.11127924919128418,
0.880343496799469,
-0.60970139503479,
-0.7439794540405273,
-0.8379873037338257,
0.0720544308423996,
0.4770772457122803,
0.1267293393611908,
0.7805575728416443,
-0.49332791566848755,
-0.6653831601142883,
0.22785484790802002,
-0.6891571283340454,
-0.05529811605811119,
0.043362200260162354,
0.5724345445632935,
0.37478113174438477,
0.4027431905269623,
-0.5453922748565674,
0.08548393845558167,
0.5495197772979736,
-0.07536391168832779,
0.5250843167304993,
-0.40091317892074585,
-0.12315746396780014,
-1.0914068222045898,
0.10254266113042831,
-0.08516331017017365,
-0.5677988529205322,
-0.4953750967979431,
0.07134086638689041,
-0.020683301612734795,
-0.238847553730011,
-0.590040385723114,
0.5888826251029968,
-0.5913485884666443,
-0.4125528931617737,
-0.5828037858009338,
0.5850245952606201,
-0.03395619988441467,
0.3892080783843994,
-0.08117092400789261,
1.115501880645752,
0.13418297469615936,
-0.8496749401092529,
0.0844506025314331,
0.18196523189544678,
-0.49974215030670166,
0.30678796768188477,
-0.904960036277771,
-0.1709456443786621,
-0.11705844849348068,
0.39986473321914673,
-0.6833954453468323,
-0.46341463923454285,
-0.1691446155309677,
-0.15927724540233612,
0.20943158864974976,
-0.09143973141908646,
-0.8964305520057678,
-0.1541188657283783,
-0.6679601669311523,
0.1638454794883728,
0.7893905639648438,
-0.6380437612533569,
0.38543036580085754,
0.41615188121795654,
-0.360531210899353,
-0.06220921501517296,
-1.1160075664520264,
0.35834014415740967,
-0.37123629450798035,
-0.47785699367523193,
0.12526097893714905,
0.1173999086022377,
-0.4627329409122467,
-0.2811429500579834,
-0.2199345827102661,
0.40535587072372437,
-0.07102879136800766,
0.21464994549751282,
0.0228891558945179,
-0.2976946234703064,
-0.02248852699995041,
-0.12102409452199936,
-0.1857348382472992,
-0.31225159764289856,
-0.06285438686609268,
0.353410542011261,
-0.37973907589912415,
0.0016457026358693838,
-0.40775066614151,
0.15633785724639893,
0.5609476566314697,
0.19957435131072998,
1.0427781343460083,
0.27212563157081604,
-0.4538351595401764,
-0.23448118567466736,
-0.48959919810295105,
-0.19011695683002472,
-0.5490755438804626,
0.2874148190021515,
-0.36461400985717773,
-0.8267807960510254,
0.6686633229255676,
-0.16921837627887726,
0.47009366750717163,
0.45476460456848145,
0.6139814257621765,
-0.3671988546848297,
0.7725595831871033,
0.7794901132583618,
-0.047040436416864395,
0.2666740119457245,
-0.21458977460861206,
0.4447254538536072,
-0.7908268570899963,
0.15202577412128448,
-0.6624179482460022,
-0.62947678565979,
-0.5153414607048035,
-0.4712817072868347,
0.7324348092079163,
-0.024114159867167473,
-0.0032144389115273952,
0.5004406571388245,
-0.07933816313743591,
0.6532921195030212,
0.21218276023864746,
-0.3404253423213959,
0.4688240885734558,
-0.2442908138036728,
0.11029774695634842,
0.0025337939150631428,
-1.0963740348815918,
-0.7223268747329712,
0.5657643675804138,
0.31302905082702637,
0.843000054359436,
0.5937386155128479,
0.5174055099487305,
0.196805939078331,
0.4197864532470703,
-0.8560335040092468,
0.7542305588722229,
-0.49568620324134827,
-0.3520200252532959,
-0.3534212112426758,
-0.5827809572219849,
-0.8814029693603516,
0.7602947354316711,
-0.08120517432689667,
-0.8165473341941833,
0.22569239139556885,
0.27366217970848083,
-0.6157561540603638,
0.609660804271698,
-0.789497971534729,
0.781432032585144,
0.043595679104328156,
-0.033814746886491776,
-0.18965460360050201,
-0.3811658024787903,
0.40511757135391235,
-0.20206385850906372,
0.6432592272758484,
-0.2391546219587326,
-0.26668229699134827,
0.7860909104347229,
-0.6474097371101379,
1.001375436782837,
0.06532309204339981,
-0.298265665769577,
0.12999871373176575,
0.1599474996328354,
0.6382633447647095,
0.008613277226686478,
-0.16683334112167358,
-0.01943577639758587,
0.20613829791545868,
-0.2448563426733017,
-0.5576756000518799,
0.9258005619049072,
-0.5495316982269287,
-0.3357047438621521,
-0.3337523341178894,
-0.5276033282279968,
-0.15426161885261536,
0.17436935007572174,
0.4353432059288025,
0.7222284078598022,
0.12204460054636002,
0.43163082003593445,
0.40654921531677246,
-0.04894063249230385,
0.8471834063529968,
0.5309138298034668,
-0.4019778370857239,
-0.22176088392734528,
0.9866613149642944,
0.5997303128242493,
0.4581336975097656,
0.4217321276664734,
0.26767975091934204,
-0.09742297977209091,
-0.8169078230857849,
-0.4529326856136322,
0.43958866596221924,
-0.584656834602356,
-0.29385849833488464,
-0.5421433448791504,
0.1259179562330246,
-0.20508073270320892,
-0.3566376268863678,
-0.5861504077911377,
-0.7912353277206421,
-0.057145051658153534,
-0.08344240486621857,
0.11326751857995987,
0.5483885407447815,
0.03409619629383087,
0.6863884329795837,
-0.8735324740409851,
0.31879714131355286,
0.11874181032180786,
0.450572669506073,
0.039996251463890076,
-0.7876951694488525,
-0.6251795291900635,
-0.036182574927806854,
-0.09069298952817917,
-0.3937692642211914,
0.3811827600002289,
0.32715195417404175,
0.15827657282352448,
0.31880682706832886,
0.14884406328201294,
0.8164620995521545,
-0.3243527412414551,
0.8789339661598206,
-0.0028982507064938545,
-0.6138699650764465,
0.21311220526695251,
-0.5488647222518921,
0.7723160982131958,
0.5887107253074646,
-0.1396361142396927,
-0.5798147320747375,
-0.5724592804908752,
-0.6433455944061279,
-0.7994138598442078,
0.9327635765075684,
0.36772286891937256,
-0.04867611080408096,
0.1579233855009079,
0.5590054988861084,
-0.11851952970027924,
0.34667903184890747,
-0.6629998683929443,
-0.24960792064666748,
0.6254820823669434,
-0.10905889421701431,
-0.2425202876329422,
-0.31372591853141785,
-0.13323423266410828,
0.1769634485244751,
0.6846829056739807,
-0.08799385279417038,
0.12409953027963638,
-0.11326659470796585,
-0.031234515830874443,
-0.18395210802555084,
0.24717019498348236,
0.8041099905967712,
0.6192569136619568,
-0.38074731826782227,
0.21281757950782776,
0.6272241473197937,
-0.2974676787853241,
-0.18265102803707123,
-0.39843621850013733,
-0.10993412137031555,
0.08036397397518158,
0.7030788660049438,
0.5725451111793518,
0.3188089430332184,
-0.9474523067474365,
0.49482372403144836,
-0.1606850028038025,
-0.17621281743049622,
-0.3367933928966522,
0.16038255393505096,
0.1683301329612732,
0.2935506999492645,
0.08988697826862335,
-0.22215893864631653,
0.017329726368188858,
-0.7742587924003601,
-0.2289586067199707,
0.35707613825798035,
-0.16709621250629425,
-0.26094332337379456,
0.7008610963821411,
0.2983894348144531,
-0.3343864679336548,
0.21791641414165497,
-0.10272844135761261,
-0.15543635189533234,
0.6125544309616089,
0.325877845287323,
0.6708372831344604,
0.2818911373615265,
-0.2739737033843994,
0.20085979998111725,
0.7572886347770691,
-0.0840991958975792,
0.15291737020015717,
0.059611592441797256,
-0.3588014841079712,
-0.5468805432319641,
-0.5183782577514648,
-0.8208206295967102,
0.014293679967522621,
-0.31863898038864136,
0.1683746874332428,
-0.6305932998657227,
-0.126416876912117,
-0.008151791989803314,
0.22332333028316498,
-0.31307804584503174,
0.29547804594039917,
0.16102159023284912,
0.8827070593833923,
-0.5919209718704224,
0.6467941403388977,
0.6798301935195923,
-0.39238792657852173,
-0.789406418800354,
-0.09893133491277695,
0.05734012648463249,
-0.26544737815856934,
0.234071746468544,
0.16438665986061096,
-0.2793564200401306,
-0.3932179808616638,
-0.17267775535583496,
-0.6487739682197571,
1.2979559898376465,
0.4633067548274994,
-0.770348846912384,
-0.1470300555229187,
0.29030072689056396,
0.618090033531189,
-0.1383352279663086,
0.022421114146709442,
0.5969906449317932,
0.281562477350235,
0.18591125309467316,
-1.4196267127990723,
0.02846367657184601,
0.2793474495410919,
0.1781105101108551,
0.39411792159080505,
-1.1922271251678467,
0.9226688742637634,
-0.3398197293281555,
-0.4409639835357666,
0.10295102745294571,
0.7483184337615967,
0.3020990490913391,
0.13145965337753296,
0.34747734665870667,
0.1627044975757599,
0.5737767815589905,
-0.1654566526412964,
1.2351274490356445,
-0.0309287142008543,
0.3222810924053192,
1.1948292255401611,
-0.4684283137321472,
1.0224555730819702,
0.46038028597831726,
-0.413129597902298,
0.018000967800617218,
0.4460780918598175,
0.25101619958877563,
0.2061481922864914,
0.05181875079870224,
-0.23735764622688293,
-0.13717252016067505,
-0.066776804625988,
-0.20542745292186737,
0.16702048480510712,
0.3558328449726105,
0.07273716479539871,
-0.3857060968875885,
-0.011771603487432003,
0.17119981348514557,
0.1573585569858551,
-0.4045296609401703,
0.9447144269943237,
0.6178287863731384,
-0.3269764184951782,
0.6001255512237549,
0.49928104877471924,
0.633682906627655,
-0.5885704755783081,
0.3939785361289978,
-0.48008689284324646,
0.44766896963119507,
-0.3096204698085785,
-0.5183223485946655,
0.6124438047409058,
0.13610385358333588,
-0.0012728010769933462,
-0.09840013086795807,
0.5985949635505676,
-0.2260756641626358,
-0.48081204295158386,
-0.12507332861423492,
0.18219546973705292,
0.18983526527881622,
-0.08069311082363129,
0.05148172751069069,
0.3038369119167328,
-0.2525925934314728,
-0.1627911925315857,
0.6117615699768066,
0.17597965896129608,
-0.052616383880376816,
0.934805154800415,
0.28769856691360474,
0.26936954259872437,
-0.14929461479187012,
0.1133427694439888,
0.6734917163848877,
-0.586233377456665,
-0.7646536827087402,
-0.7843865752220154,
0.21787911653518677,
-0.017405949532985687,
0.10721632093191147,
0.7416913509368896,
0.7474218606948853,
0.4037081301212311,
-0.12510257959365845,
0.6673604249954224,
-0.020454615354537964,
0.6931871175765991,
-0.5678948760032654,
0.6323855519294739,
-0.68961101770401,
0.4828023910522461,
-0.06746146082878113,
-1.0089473724365234,
-0.5385221838951111,
0.4131060838699341,
-0.24624334275722504,
0.19352352619171143,
0.5119152665138245,
0.7256656289100647,
-0.14434471726417542,
0.04148855432868004,
0.6245603561401367,
0.33013391494750977,
0.6762228012084961,
0.42502561211586,
0.4655284881591797,
-0.41202491521835327,
0.7067818641662598,
-0.14933429658412933,
-0.09395241737365723,
-0.5089493989944458,
-0.9363839626312256,
-0.9746758341789246,
-0.07302919775247574,
-0.3284255266189575,
0.07694507390260696,
-0.0502803772687912,
1.0236345529556274,
0.6402081847190857,
-0.6615434288978577,
-0.3500778079032898,
0.1719217449426651,
-0.05790924280881882,
-0.1731354296207428,
-0.14096976816654205,
0.3646644055843353,
-0.22111403942108154,
-0.9235883951187134,
0.4411088824272156,
0.5035794973373413,
0.3186006247997284,
-0.11679558455944061,
0.09145797044038773,
0.07472884654998779,
0.21952252089977264,
0.7528659701347351,
0.3409574031829834,
-0.6593635082244873,
-0.5032470226287842,
-0.3820858895778656,
-0.1074284017086029,
-0.23661524057388306,
0.6080899834632874,
-0.6805673241615295,
-0.09491276741027832,
0.39669451117515564,
0.3965923488140106,
0.5474222898483276,
-0.02632109262049198,
0.5325798392295837,
-1.108709454536438,
0.3962806463241577,
0.09485849738121033,
0.3824625015258789,
0.2096129059791565,
-0.1222698912024498,
0.5540672540664673,
-0.11491749435663223,
-0.5206052660942078,
-1.0333781242370605,
0.16042448580265045,
-1.0670602321624756,
-0.22541163861751556,
1.0276036262512207,
0.22322605550289154,
-0.040619488805532455,
0.13087458908557892,
-0.24909347295761108,
-0.0367518812417984,
-0.001443470478989184,
0.8206555247306824,
0.41402360796928406,
-0.2827718257904053,
-0.12313122302293777,
-0.5121021866798401,
0.39758536219596863,
0.40668076276779175,
-0.7987992763519287,
0.2914116382598877,
0.35788455605506897,
0.164894700050354,
0.052953507751226425,
0.7213482856750488,
0.030975714325904846,
0.2655654549598694,
0.08241412043571472,
-0.25179484486579895,
-0.280852735042572,
-0.2927304804325104,
-0.2724619209766388,
0.29552826285362244,
0.5467408895492554,
-0.11049530655145645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00838v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00838v4 | OLMo: Accelerating the Science of Language Models | 2024-02-01T18:28:55 | 2024-06-07T21:59:52 | Dirk Groeneveld, Iz Beltagy, Pete Walsh, Akshita Bhagia, Rodney Kinney, Oyvind Tafjord, Ananya Harsh Jha, Hamish Ivison, Ian Magnusson, Yizhong Wang, Shane Arora, David Atkinson, Russell Authur, Khyathi Raghavi Chandu, Arman Cohan, Jennifer Dumas, Yanai Elazar, Yuling Gu, Jack Hessel, Tushar Khot, William Merrill, Jacob Morrison, Niklas Muennighoff, Aakanksha Naik, Crystal Nam, Matthew E. Peters, Valentina Pyatkin, Abhilasha Ravichander, Dustin Schwenk, Saurabh Shah, Will Smith, Emma Strubell, Nishant Subramani, Mitchell Wortsman, Pradeep Dasigi, Nathan Lambert, Kyle Richardson, Luke Zettlemoyer, Jesse Dodge, Kyle Lo, Luca Soldaini, Noah A. Smith, Hannaneh Hajishirzi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LMs) have become ubiquitous in both NLP research and in
commercial product offerings. As their commercial importance has surged, the
most powerful models have become closed off, gated behind proprietary
interfaces, with important details of their training data, architectures, and
development undisclosed. Given the importance of these details in
scientifically studying these models, including their biases and potential
risks, we believe it is essential for the research community to have access to
powerful, truly open LMs. To this end, we have built OLMo, a competitive, truly
Open Language Model, to enable the scientific study of language models. Unlike
most prior efforts that have only released model weights and inference code, we
release OLMo alongside open training data and training and evaluation code. We
hope this release will empower the open research community and inspire a new
wave of innovation. | [
-0.1500047892332077,
-0.4797394275665283,
0.4352748394012451,
0.014213919639587402,
0.18049994111061096,
-0.4750839173793793,
-0.47147026658058167,
-0.6089799404144287,
-0.33297181129455566,
0.8064662218093872,
-0.20978790521621704,
-0.2854781746864319,
-0.5247710347175598,
-0.07246460020542145,
-0.35143351554870605,
0.9454762935638428,
-0.05364346131682396,
0.3689975440502167,
-0.5439253449440002,
-0.34505075216293335,
0.17970609664916992,
-0.4055445194244385,
-0.3473246991634369,
-0.41207894682884216,
0.7008395195007324,
0.14284124970436096,
0.6760996580123901,
0.8760426640510559,
0.7596721649169922,
0.28457000851631165,
-0.19224615395069122,
0.00010055044549517334,
-0.5043228268623352,
0.29066404700279236,
-0.3595259189605713,
-0.5565322637557983,
-0.8618096709251404,
0.1383032351732254,
0.6794121265411377,
1.125849723815918,
-0.05595757067203522,
0.35450679063796997,
-0.09349330514669418,
0.7233314514160156,
-0.6980196833610535,
0.4038260579109192,
-0.5416523218154907,
0.043770525604486465,
-0.36805659532546997,
0.026110703125596046,
-0.45992735028266907,
-0.5151992440223694,
0.14708176255226135,
-0.3675267994403839,
0.04836689308285713,
0.16657882928848267,
0.5519946813583374,
-0.09594016522169113,
-0.34600818157196045,
-0.301923006772995,
-0.9286685585975647,
0.9423821568489075,
-0.7775285840034485,
0.5177460312843323,
0.1697375625371933,
0.5459557175636292,
-0.28523409366607666,
-0.7899462580680847,
-0.3778183162212372,
-0.3632473647594452,
0.3396757245063782,
-0.26019296050071716,
-0.05286909267306328,
0.2144482433795929,
0.0643695592880249,
0.654041051864624,
-0.24325358867645264,
0.19156032800674438,
-0.8539023399353027,
0.3081294000148773,
0.5986334085464478,
0.06009106710553169,
0.4637112319469452,
0.48267924785614014,
-0.21749934554100037,
0.06219058856368065,
-0.8159078359603882,
-0.343523770570755,
0.4726007282733917,
0.5244705677032471,
0.001622548559680581,
0.8972954154014587,
-0.24091844260692596,
0.7862809300422668,
-0.6980196833610535,
0.036294225603342056,
0.41301676630973816,
-0.22764433920383453,
-0.3909802734851837,
0.06413480639457703,
1.1038037538528442,
0.1846960335969925,
0.1252136081457138,
-0.08362748473882675,
-0.31868329644203186,
-0.19222885370254517,
0.20126847922801971,
-0.7756659388542175,
0.1387706995010376,
0.4120984971523285,
-0.6352569460868835,
-0.34066241979599,
0.12068955600261688,
-0.8178459405899048,
-0.3845989406108856,
-0.02624116837978363,
0.46631142497062683,
-0.07844128459692001,
-0.5819292664527893,
0.6023344993591309,
-0.09478780627250671,
-0.36676618456840515,
0.15306319296360016,
-0.9666930437088013,
0.4717598855495453,
0.6741566061973572,
0.9707444906234741,
0.0787590816617012,
-0.050728581845760345,
-0.2874118983745575,
-0.03037513606250286,
-0.5182985663414001,
0.33552730083465576,
-0.4380819797515869,
-0.3784920275211334,
0.16955874860286713,
-0.13046589493751526,
0.10028515011072159,
-0.46518847346305847,
0.7225781083106995,
-0.6155915856361389,
0.444160133600235,
-0.018811330199241638,
-0.4862311780452728,
-0.005578577984124422,
-0.09897433966398239,
-0.7324915528297424,
0.9463155269622803,
0.0005813065799884498,
-0.40971794724464417,
-0.06817048043012619,
-1.3326137065887451,
0.18973036110401154,
-0.010601294226944447,
-0.07801924645900726,
-0.3749604821205139,
0.4970484972000122,
-0.2629380524158478,
0.2083205282688141,
-0.5241326093673706,
0.1588621288537979,
-0.5692707300186157,
0.11227649450302124,
0.4614230990409851,
0.011414958164095879,
0.9465041160583496,
0.6853221654891968,
-0.015986071899533272,
0.12678931653499603,
-0.6701093316078186,
0.07752168923616409,
0.44992148876190186,
-0.24977116286754608,
-0.546995997428894,
0.2429080456495285,
-0.22324323654174805,
0.16323751211166382,
0.2851892411708832,
-0.861626148223877,
0.36817049980163574,
-0.4828207492828369,
0.6188094615936279,
0.543792724609375,
-0.5910264849662781,
0.6420239806175232,
-0.06093435734510422,
0.4858517348766327,
-0.2161191701889038,
0.3653220236301422,
-0.5386440753936768,
-0.72695392370224,
-0.6158191561698914,
-0.3022117614746094,
0.32926473021507263,
0.0096072843298316,
-0.03704870492219925,
0.32625386118888855,
-0.29407554864883423,
-0.5638061165809631,
-0.9282807111740112,
0.12404129654169083,
0.4960601329803467,
0.40302956104278564,
0.1638954132795334,
-0.16921883821487427,
-0.5032908320426941,
-0.8461264967918396,
-0.31504347920417786,
-0.021110819652676582,
-0.17760436236858368,
0.2467372566461563,
0.6630609631538391,
-0.059558019042015076,
1.125157356262207,
-0.709454357624054,
-0.3663690686225891,
-0.25437644124031067,
-0.017038099467754364,
0.35691359639167786,
0.3230108320713043,
0.655750572681427,
-0.5409917831420898,
-0.2733250558376312,
0.2955895960330963,
-0.8850248456001282,
-0.29271605610847473,
0.6002804040908813,
0.016004905104637146,
0.1785854697227478,
0.5268305540084839,
-0.49150678515434265,
0.03889594227075577,
0.8451821804046631,
-0.24985714256763458,
0.3663778603076935,
-0.2612990438938141,
-0.04345327988266945,
-0.7971054315567017,
0.32561829686164856,
-0.43909531831741333,
-0.17757461965084076,
-0.70273357629776,
0.33787402510643005,
0.11837568134069443,
-0.29703351855278015,
-0.45656266808509827,
0.7435924410820007,
-0.5888813138008118,
-0.292845755815506,
-0.32050687074661255,
0.3563712537288666,
-0.002536138752475381,
-0.1697874516248703,
-0.01541197020560503,
0.4501308798789978,
0.6716588735580444,
-0.5715788006782532,
0.2571834623813629,
0.08177972584962845,
-0.6542114019393921,
-0.13392682373523712,
-0.9019930362701416,
0.12593072652816772,
-0.08835882693529129,
-0.03299502283334732,
-0.5176953673362732,
-0.16049402952194214,
0.32341238856315613,
-0.5118527412414551,
0.06547223776578903,
0.01988820731639862,
-0.44859957695007324,
-0.3921092450618744,
-0.11723487079143524,
0.4234600067138672,
0.6489312052726746,
-0.41870296001434326,
0.46930769085884094,
0.6090826392173767,
-0.04858214035630226,
-0.5482969880104065,
-0.6692600846290588,
-0.22698621451854706,
0.23252229392528534,
-0.6974932551383972,
-0.03150413557887077,
-0.16786052286624908,
-0.6357524394989014,
0.22098171710968018,
-0.12715035676956177,
-0.09324516355991364,
0.13578379154205322,
0.249007910490036,
0.08429691195487976,
-0.6852481365203857,
0.30967628955841064,
-0.1929360330104828,
-0.0012840534327551723,
0.26707419753074646,
-0.5709366798400879,
0.50841224193573,
-0.18024440109729767,
-0.31465384364128113,
0.0017874662298709154,
0.17643329501152039,
0.6340775489807129,
-0.4909803569316864,
1.212600588798523,
-0.018778562545776367,
-0.3225673735141754,
-0.3862227499485016,
-0.22092311084270477,
0.030404526740312576,
-0.47018030285835266,
0.5335975289344788,
-0.1195245310664177,
-0.9064400792121887,
0.31928905844688416,
0.020001491531729698,
0.30540427565574646,
0.23902465403079987,
0.5471047759056091,
0.1418229341506958,
1.1553823947906494,
0.8354087471961975,
0.12772320210933685,
0.5097967386245728,
0.056231286376714706,
0.4517933428287506,
-0.5947498083114624,
-0.5637400150299072,
-1.0537748336791992,
-0.05271988734602928,
-0.13676495850086212,
-0.5918120741844177,
0.34302330017089844,
0.25610312819480896,
0.04612160846590996,
0.09470584988594055,
-0.24766826629638672,
0.507745623588562,
0.6414933204650879,
-0.033159807324409485,
0.6221687197685242,
-0.10918571799993515,
-0.24495458602905273,
0.04602257162332535,
-0.5479147434234619,
-0.5807169079780579,
1.4329503774642944,
0.7118924856185913,
0.8453000783920288,
0.12259239703416824,
0.3523767292499542,
0.11887640506029129,
0.3781324028968811,
-0.6290642023086548,
0.5369653105735779,
0.02359890379011631,
-1.0450000762939453,
-0.18445809185504913,
-0.506104588508606,
-0.958466649055481,
0.2122962772846222,
-0.0738116204738617,
-0.4387029707431793,
-0.0806049108505249,
0.370388001203537,
-0.039958029985427856,
0.4185972511768341,
-0.5799713730812073,
0.8899940848350525,
-0.2967973053455353,
-0.24447515606880188,
-0.24984140694141388,
-0.5203691720962524,
0.7091598510742188,
-0.07612347602844238,
0.49479952454566956,
-0.33385834097862244,
-0.3473258912563324,
0.6849634051322937,
-0.6112838983535767,
0.7461353540420532,
0.062408991158008575,
-0.4267442524433136,
0.20186422765254974,
0.03676718473434448,
-0.0005299935000948608,
-0.369454950094223,
-0.20799081027507782,
0.525870144367218,
-0.2238662987947464,
-0.355299174785614,
-0.5734882950782776,
0.7848073840141296,
-0.7419586777687073,
-0.2954426407814026,
-0.46638795733451843,
-0.6194976568222046,
-0.06065794825553894,
0.27905693650245667,
-0.18774136900901794,
0.2085776925086975,
-0.37263819575309753,
0.43235957622528076,
0.8981984257698059,
-0.3385287821292877,
0.201584592461586,
0.7382598519325256,
-0.8956277966499329,
-0.3611406981945038,
0.7183886170387268,
-0.0071472967974841595,
0.7333133816719055,
0.2694193720817566,
0.36750033497810364,
-0.07966520637273788,
-0.5776849985122681,
-0.20761680603027344,
0.3625865578651428,
-0.5526581406593323,
0.09153986722230911,
-0.780829131603241,
-0.2510327398777008,
-0.5657536387443542,
0.07670491188764572,
-0.6952109932899475,
-0.6379491686820984,
0.05100851133465767,
-0.12873436510562897,
0.22132624685764313,
1.0012564659118652,
-0.1136191114783287,
0.29133257269859314,
-0.9272490739822388,
0.30061236023902893,
0.06869056820869446,
0.585870087146759,
-0.23477314412593842,
-0.30259522795677185,
-0.5029628872871399,
0.16716784238815308,
-0.29065778851509094,
-0.5379540920257568,
0.28582364320755005,
0.447117418050766,
0.6189432740211487,
0.7469308972358704,
-0.07757546007633209,
0.1365097463130951,
-0.6965222358703613,
0.7597270607948303,
0.3904235363006592,
-0.8552782535552979,
0.5577274560928345,
-0.42352548241615295,
0.17809079587459564,
0.08214858174324036,
0.6240503191947937,
-0.5294082760810852,
-0.35713744163513184,
-0.40148547291755676,
-0.6384013891220093,
1.0083354711532593,
0.18554572761058807,
0.13324354588985443,
-0.01548025757074356,
-0.07274783402681351,
0.3397798240184784,
0.6266436576843262,
-0.79296875,
-0.1732381284236908,
-0.21994982659816742,
-0.2856735289096832,
-0.07628761976957321,
-0.3634447455406189,
-0.3308489918708801,
0.0006804783479310572,
0.5904396176338196,
-0.053165171295404434,
0.16575105488300323,
-0.07192747294902802,
0.042884889990091324,
-0.4215906262397766,
0.18893304467201233,
0.6580463647842407,
0.6108487248420715,
-0.4889548420906067,
0.04673662409186363,
-0.4639362394809723,
-0.49064773321151733,
-0.2300514131784439,
-0.1309984028339386,
-0.26702064275741577,
0.05935752019286156,
0.27124497294425964,
0.8153209090232849,
0.14273400604724884,
-1.1504967212677002,
0.3632769286632538,
0.26174479722976685,
-0.13820277154445648,
-0.09077300131320953,
0.24236084520816803,
0.16060319542884827,
0.24617336690425873,
0.20755085349082947,
0.15536825358867645,
0.013113514520227909,
-0.8864990472793579,
-0.1003231406211853,
0.44051721692085266,
-0.4144977033138275,
-0.4663490355014801,
0.8864131569862366,
0.4636743664741516,
-0.3093845844268799,
0.3867132365703583,
0.25497832894325256,
-0.3072114884853363,
0.47064366936683655,
0.5055816173553467,
0.9097957015037537,
-0.47440552711486816,
-0.04207172617316246,
0.41694873571395874,
0.5131632089614868,
-0.4694468080997467,
0.25519120693206787,
0.14552384614944458,
-0.754421055316925,
-0.20827090740203857,
-0.882728636264801,
-0.34475845098495483,
0.14545801281929016,
-0.7435522675514221,
0.3549790680408478,
-0.30878496170043945,
-0.20653371512889862,
-0.30877676606178284,
-0.3311347961425781,
-0.195449560880661,
0.07095871865749359,
0.2799924314022064,
1.2756456136703491,
-0.678795337677002,
0.966648519039154,
0.5155515670776367,
-0.45289379358291626,
0.04536084085702896,
-0.5904964208602905,
0.022612623870372772,
-0.7295381426811218,
0.9542024731636047,
0.14688369631767273,
-0.13337896764278412,
-0.12453474849462509,
-0.7904080748558044,
-0.930000364780426,
0.841805100440979,
0.5422435402870178,
-0.6287447214126587,
-0.20399688184261322,
0.20160827040672302,
0.49771976470947266,
-0.6486974954605103,
0.40695276856422424,
0.16853250563144684,
0.4120071232318878,
-0.2580271363258362,
-1.0278993844985962,
-0.2895258963108063,
-0.10878531634807587,
-0.030722348019480705,
0.463797003030777,
-0.4308784604072571,
0.9970447421073914,
-0.43984466791152954,
0.06087531894445419,
0.29330554604530334,
0.7336650490760803,
0.09675230830907822,
0.301697313785553,
0.224642813205719,
0.3289947807788849,
0.6015120148658752,
-0.13232222199440002,
1.0818262100219727,
-0.16895581781864166,
0.370036244392395,
1.1026747226715088,
-0.5217042565345764,
0.90895676612854,
0.277447909116745,
-0.14076834917068481,
0.2455718070268631,
0.2030181735754013,
0.14689569175243378,
0.4498966932296753,
0.08005204051733017,
-0.34793755412101746,
-0.08073953539133072,
-0.42044225335121155,
-0.5645423531532288,
0.2403099685907364,
0.43688029050827026,
-0.8954156041145325,
-0.2171764224767685,
0.05077394098043442,
0.2223256379365921,
0.27659836411476135,
-0.4737849831581116,
0.3474678695201874,
0.32442912459373474,
-0.37265267968177795,
0.35346755385398865,
-0.009863211773335934,
0.3095182180404663,
-1.1761558055877686,
0.17280463874340057,
-0.0010796986753121018,
0.44126883149147034,
-0.06700117886066437,
-0.5380803942680359,
0.26289424300193787,
0.00014582989388145506,
-0.0915241688489914,
-0.4807172417640686,
0.4467020332813263,
-0.6857181787490845,
-0.18384237587451935,
0.7281087040901184,
0.3404695987701416,
0.246355801820755,
-0.00037910789251327515,
-0.43531081080436707,
0.4925144910812378,
-0.2930242419242859,
-0.472578227519989,
0.3952299952507019,
0.29886746406555176,
0.0880511924624443,
0.8959658145904541,
0.6131926774978638,
0.3295861780643463,
0.3489299714565277,
-0.1874934881925583,
0.9063002467155457,
-0.577390193939209,
0.0028325747698545456,
-0.7520774602890015,
0.5498464107513428,
-0.1495516151189804,
-0.4159718453884125,
0.8985053300857544,
0.7069157361984253,
0.866370677947998,
-0.36328211426734924,
0.8177937865257263,
-0.22274763882160187,
0.5292328000068665,
-0.6472820043563843,
0.9460704922676086,
-0.7384094595909119,
0.12382929027080536,
0.024254625663161278,
-0.8078235387802124,
-0.34132933616638184,
0.21704360842704773,
-0.2002030462026596,
0.007548508234322071,
0.8716667890548706,
0.6384273171424866,
-0.1862172931432724,
-0.03455553203821182,
0.567346453666687,
0.7402324080467224,
0.2577046751976013,
0.32929399609565735,
0.5105934143066406,
-0.39052197337150574,
0.6675617098808289,
-0.05467136576771736,
-0.4281333386898041,
-0.497496098279953,
-1.0116819143295288,
-1.1304892301559448,
-0.616040050983429,
-0.21883819997310638,
-0.3177397549152374,
0.276917040348053,
0.9314744472503662,
0.6045530438423157,
-0.8521618843078613,
-0.5966761112213135,
-0.024230698123574257,
-0.016109922900795937,
-0.19475999474525452,
-0.2211720496416092,
-0.1231105625629425,
-0.46856382489204407,
-1.0597854852676392,
0.7299412488937378,
0.4663407802581787,
-0.13205274939537048,
-0.5578262805938721,
-0.23520740866661072,
-0.08607584238052368,
0.4308461844921112,
0.4850609302520752,
0.5621798634529114,
-0.5402677059173584,
0.22376520931720734,
0.07464737445116043,
-0.2446342408657074,
-0.0929705873131752,
0.9961437582969666,
-0.5769591927528381,
0.7898935079574585,
0.820451557636261,
0.5476810336112976,
0.028367474675178528,
-0.4922117590904236,
1.2056218385696411,
-0.35866621136665344,
0.37107035517692566,
0.2570461332798004,
0.5158722996711731,
0.07522737234830856,
0.14153911173343658,
0.6917471885681152,
0.16714558005332947,
-0.6302930116653442,
-1.480589509010315,
0.3971395492553711,
-0.8044736981391907,
-0.3375527262687683,
0.8493296504020691,
-0.31438273191452026,
-0.6169694662094116,
0.1036486029624939,
-0.025024354457855225,
-0.005766973365098238,
-0.3391164541244507,
0.6539008617401123,
0.5380189418792725,
0.23718149960041046,
-0.022843481972813606,
-0.9984616637229919,
0.4423063099384308,
0.19664163887500763,
-0.6813598275184631,
0.045075710862874985,
0.3357847034931183,
0.10284461081027985,
0.44136595726013184,
0.5459848046302795,
-0.5254430770874023,
0.02111629769206047,
0.013049663044512272,
0.6047148704528809,
-0.48780253529548645,
-0.5326696634292603,
-0.47394508123397827,
0.33130210638046265,
0.280012309551239,
-0.27993088960647583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00835v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00835v1 | ALISON: Fast and Effective Stylometric Authorship Obfuscation | 2024-02-01T18:22:32 | 2024-02-01T18:22:32 | Eric Xing, Saranya Venkatraman, Thai Le, Dongwon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.2.0 | Authorship Attribution (AA) and Authorship Obfuscation (AO) are two competing
tasks of increasing importance in privacy research. Modern AA leverages an
author's consistent writing style to match a text to its author using an AA
classifier. AO is the corresponding adversarial task, aiming to modify a text
in such a way that its semantics are preserved, yet an AA model cannot
correctly infer its authorship. To address privacy concerns raised by
state-of-the-art (SOTA) AA methods, new AO methods have been proposed but
remain largely impractical to use due to their prohibitively slow training and
obfuscation speed, often taking hours. To this challenge, we propose a
practical AO method, ALISON, that (1) dramatically reduces training/obfuscation
time, demonstrating more than 10x faster obfuscation than SOTA AO methods, (2)
achieves better obfuscation success through attacking three transformer-based
AA methods on two benchmark datasets, typically performing 15% better than
competing methods, (3) does not require direct signals from a target AA
classifier during obfuscation, and (4) utilizes unique stylometric features,
allowing sound model interpretation for explainable obfuscation. We also
demonstrate that ALISON can effectively prevent four SOTA AA methods from
accurately determining the authorship of ChatGPT-generated texts, all while
minimally changing the original text semantics. To ensure the reproducibility
of our findings, our code and data are available at:
https://github.com/EricX003/ALISON. | [
0.14439469575881958,
-0.9443466663360596,
0.5957815647125244,
-0.12620486319065094,
-0.25103089213371277,
0.13891752064228058,
-0.09673010557889938,
-0.8026193380355835,
0.29117172956466675,
0.8435701727867126,
-0.44840919971466064,
-0.47170257568359375,
-0.7607929706573486,
0.14290891587734222,
-0.4622994065284729,
0.9980579614639282,
-0.06223888322710991,
-0.17782557010650635,
-0.04186752438545227,
-0.12269893288612366,
0.16045641899108887,
-0.2303071767091751,
-0.7529605627059937,
0.16458167135715485,
0.5410866737365723,
0.3387977182865143,
0.7623407244682312,
1.303985834121704,
0.7309974431991577,
0.3211442232131958,
-0.21022585034370422,
0.1282021552324295,
-0.578892171382904,
0.11398804187774658,
0.15661852061748505,
-0.39953938126564026,
-0.47379204630851746,
-0.055900607258081436,
0.4330030381679535,
0.5500628352165222,
-0.1749170422554016,
0.47838565707206726,
-0.03141945227980614,
0.5229100584983826,
-1.0171399116516113,
-0.014486675150692463,
-0.39973190426826477,
-0.14034992456436157,
-0.5499158501625061,
-0.1654493659734726,
-0.5555694103240967,
-0.5970192551612854,
0.10221205651760101,
-0.6993446350097656,
0.20132549107074738,
0.353321373462677,
0.8855461478233337,
0.4559716582298279,
-0.16089841723442078,
-0.2000649869441986,
-0.9022717475891113,
0.6544978022575378,
-0.569259762763977,
0.286683052778244,
0.48942431807518005,
0.2660244107246399,
0.29283812642097473,
-0.8930501937866211,
-0.5499539375305176,
-0.22401092946529388,
-0.07745752483606339,
-0.16291673481464386,
-0.2509845495223999,
0.11600245535373688,
0.29791539907455444,
0.5132637023925781,
-0.46397650241851807,
0.05118445307016373,
-0.35221946239471436,
-0.09922860562801361,
0.7779817581176758,
-0.28874489665031433,
0.42618635296821594,
0.05535704642534256,
-0.4325433075428009,
-0.19657829403877258,
-0.7680791020393372,
0.04128925874829292,
1.0063221454620361,
0.07197827100753784,
0.0036156107671558857,
0.4661189615726471,
0.13423798978328705,
0.12217977643013,
0.1251964420080185,
-0.04317371919751167,
0.06274924427270889,
-0.13425561785697937,
0.031125487759709358,
0.293353408575058,
1.0140451192855835,
-0.15625597536563873,
0.05761799216270447,
-0.2674049735069275,
0.1820346564054489,
-0.0015009914059191942,
0.1465347409248352,
-0.8072335720062256,
-0.5898405909538269,
0.14538879692554474,
-0.5363815426826477,
-0.53948974609375,
0.2217564433813095,
-0.5008295774459839,
-0.6270719170570374,
-0.10668384283781052,
0.5478345155715942,
-0.46651792526245117,
-0.07434237003326416,
0.04600725322961807,
-0.17176902294158936,
-0.13773027062416077,
0.010836388915777206,
-0.7457835078239441,
0.15697211027145386,
0.5824474096298218,
0.5888676047325134,
-0.0015672410372644663,
-0.2830646336078644,
-0.8531705737113953,
0.14085501432418823,
-0.3386740982532501,
0.43090298771858215,
-0.4349447190761566,
-0.05052913352847099,
-0.22027021646499634,
-0.1410910189151764,
0.27621278166770935,
-0.18053528666496277,
0.13824722170829773,
-0.662208080291748,
0.17028705775737762,
0.007498484570533037,
-0.3949878513813019,
-0.06332025676965714,
-0.2838471233844757,
-0.770557165145874,
0.8874353766441345,
-0.010935042053461075,
-0.3436200022697449,
0.29697903990745544,
-0.7877148389816284,
-0.35351741313934326,
0.1473727822303772,
0.11862540990114212,
-0.8851482272148132,
-0.11149902641773224,
0.371265709400177,
0.2142905741930008,
0.11495799571275711,
-0.12298756092786789,
-0.1662226915359497,
-0.2758396863937378,
0.07514017820358276,
-0.2612932026386261,
1.2207036018371582,
0.04074437543749809,
-0.48500752449035645,
0.11166422069072723,
-0.8455239534378052,
-0.1602020412683487,
0.27514031529426575,
-0.08984868228435516,
-0.49752065539360046,
-0.34491369128227234,
0.014593475498259068,
-0.6078316569328308,
0.18267026543617249,
-0.8865838050842285,
0.1500220149755478,
-0.6770166158676147,
0.2171895056962967,
0.7704550623893738,
0.010192587040364742,
0.6531545519828796,
-0.3454570770263672,
0.576407253742218,
-0.5343591570854187,
0.153090700507164,
-0.3081648051738739,
-0.5814364552497864,
-0.34346315264701843,
-0.8114119172096252,
0.5804676413536072,
0.45385921001434326,
-0.9194093346595764,
0.3628537356853485,
-0.28589528799057007,
-1.0067687034606934,
-0.9285291433334351,
0.2106718271970749,
1.0858343839645386,
0.21607348322868347,
0.4404301345348358,
-0.6278061866760254,
-0.3609355390071869,
-0.65346360206604,
-1.0930452346801758,
-0.019698744639754295,
-0.30724427103996277,
0.17691689729690552,
0.4363252520561218,
0.18014630675315857,
0.7888157963752747,
-0.7741290330886841,
-0.44039756059646606,
-0.03133188188076019,
0.4463995695114136,
-0.056867849081754684,
0.634178102016449,
0.6491686105728149,
-0.7631934285163879,
-0.6398083567619324,
-0.3131219744682312,
-0.7423235177993774,
-0.13421806693077087,
-0.030347583815455437,
-0.21317242085933685,
0.19647791981697083,
0.6139693856239319,
-0.6100631952285767,
0.9511284828186035,
0.25462451577186584,
-0.5904974341392517,
0.53080153465271,
-0.05104876309633255,
0.22806060314178467,
-0.6496318578720093,
0.08791008591651917,
-0.29693806171417236,
-0.28268054127693176,
-0.7884660959243774,
0.4273921549320221,
0.05425212159752846,
-0.15320396423339844,
-0.6743410229682922,
0.45325300097465515,
-0.7017457485198975,
0.4606444537639618,
0.12158477306365967,
-0.24096925556659698,
-0.03155827149748802,
0.6637909412384033,
-0.14367152750492096,
0.4563754200935364,
0.47586527466773987,
-0.3682587742805481,
0.19821719825267792,
0.7014526724815369,
-0.4978342354297638,
0.3610762059688568,
-0.6055755615234375,
0.6190632581710815,
-0.4024856388568878,
0.13318441808223724,
-1.1105440855026245,
-0.13626043498516083,
0.5472539663314819,
-0.4316723346710205,
0.395497590303421,
-0.3345778286457062,
-0.5871673822402954,
0.09766791760921478,
-0.45102331042289734,
0.6308967471122742,
0.46585002541542053,
-0.7586672306060791,
1.0368703603744507,
0.1512635201215744,
-0.3365471363067627,
-0.6348621845245361,
-0.752392053604126,
0.09352108836174011,
-0.16689947247505188,
-0.4658568203449249,
0.7403256297111511,
-0.019197963178157806,
-0.23957110941410065,
0.10752280801534653,
-0.2249833047389984,
-0.17579218745231628,
0.2129342406988144,
0.22990840673446655,
0.4383118748664856,
-0.029872793704271317,
-0.26070940494537354,
0.01556148286908865,
-0.3599315285682678,
-0.06510534882545471,
-0.010590726509690285,
0.13406211137771606,
0.2510402798652649,
-0.4079263210296631,
-0.827463686466217,
0.5191887617111206,
0.2680550813674927,
-0.3276095986366272,
1.0631418228149414,
0.4815002381801605,
-0.18991099298000336,
-0.2983277142047882,
-0.3244306445121765,
-0.5755248665809631,
-0.5256078839302063,
0.1654549539089203,
0.012298805639147758,
-0.606550395488739,
0.4411773979663849,
0.34062957763671875,
0.4865734279155731,
0.13503868877887726,
0.09137330204248428,
0.16717016696929932,
0.5516914129257202,
0.5229734182357788,
-0.02682872675359249,
0.7439959049224854,
-0.3222009241580963,
0.5873892307281494,
-0.44691744446754456,
0.04289799928665161,
-0.5181169509887695,
-0.39527249336242676,
-0.4891473352909088,
-0.07818175852298737,
0.5536383986473083,
-0.2690112888813019,
-0.17647261917591095,
0.5716994404792786,
-0.8422991037368774,
0.7464146018028259,
0.9269208312034607,
0.5005651712417603,
0.3740834891796112,
0.0014597317203879356,
0.6708692312240601,
0.0716620609164238,
-0.38178613781929016,
-0.4203355610370636,
1.5103613138198853,
0.26200586557388306,
0.6209390759468079,
0.6208425760269165,
0.8869708180427551,
0.23097188770771027,
0.3044794499874115,
-0.5500451326370239,
0.5932552218437195,
-0.21197214722633362,
-0.7178968191146851,
-0.6086163520812988,
-0.48120832443237305,
-0.7992957830429077,
0.12154864519834518,
-0.33018064498901367,
-0.8417608141899109,
0.16102643311023712,
0.48471400141716003,
-0.6082985997200012,
0.4982696771621704,
-0.6433990001678467,
0.6921859979629517,
0.21341745555400848,
-0.6994979381561279,
0.3112585246562958,
-0.984794557094574,
0.20190443098545074,
0.06768150627613068,
0.2608393728733063,
0.07575676590204239,
0.022277453914284706,
0.9606233239173889,
-0.6652488708496094,
0.8520777225494385,
-0.3598667085170746,
-0.1917348951101303,
0.1458791047334671,
0.23630519211292267,
0.8226780295372009,
-0.32964009046554565,
0.06603431701660156,
0.4761683940887451,
-0.11762643605470657,
-0.22856807708740234,
-0.4897477924823761,
0.30452001094818115,
-0.42979860305786133,
-0.4273282289505005,
-0.3241901099681854,
-0.3670762777328491,
0.0371999591588974,
0.35438263416290283,
0.4921754002571106,
0.48155349493026733,
0.10095109790563583,
0.42480963468551636,
0.5437328219413757,
0.061706554144620895,
0.3579828441143036,
0.14655017852783203,
0.27757030725479126,
-0.3567728102207184,
0.872495174407959,
0.1498606652021408,
0.27424687147140503,
0.28794065117836,
0.33985185623168945,
-0.19994327425956726,
-0.3793267011642456,
-0.5115653872489929,
0.19210094213485718,
-0.47206124663352966,
-0.15206703543663025,
-0.6976534128189087,
-0.01139759924262762,
-0.448913037776947,
-0.4061049520969391,
-0.5186493396759033,
-0.6855875849723816,
-0.18273836374282837,
0.16912513971328735,
0.5128025412559509,
0.38900578022003174,
0.21935917437076569,
0.7820168733596802,
-0.5561957359313965,
0.6249461770057678,
0.19696539640426636,
0.16078121960163116,
0.04033863544464111,
-0.4126819670200348,
0.0594610795378685,
0.054430413991212845,
-0.46984559297561646,
-0.9095190167427063,
0.1648150384426117,
0.2836041748523712,
0.324085533618927,
0.5731977224349976,
0.44437360763549805,
0.733705997467041,
-0.4843909740447998,
0.8563607335090637,
0.10753481090068817,
-1.1457594633102417,
0.3069908916950226,
-0.27876245975494385,
-0.14884263277053833,
0.6761857867240906,
0.1809881031513214,
0.03713070601224899,
-0.7560608386993408,
-0.7765535116195679,
-1.4226093292236328,
0.9367786645889282,
0.7489736676216125,
-0.1756650060415268,
0.5928023457527161,
0.33079594373703003,
0.31416749954223633,
0.3634462356567383,
-0.6510935425758362,
-0.5333496928215027,
-0.00015800738765392452,
-0.4576369524002075,
-0.05688447505235672,
-0.23428821563720703,
-0.19859139621257782,
-0.041167985647916794,
0.8119354248046875,
0.11245191097259521,
0.2837042212486267,
0.16566027700901031,
-0.03205294534564018,
0.0791827067732811,
0.05697019398212433,
0.10883117467164993,
0.4807082414627075,
-0.058269940316677094,
0.14996211230754852,
0.01270921342074871,
-0.7521843314170837,
-0.12288831919431686,
0.28135037422180176,
-0.353082537651062,
0.07971048355102539,
0.8191900253295898,
0.4145941138267517,
0.1248234212398529,
-0.3455774784088135,
0.7415471076965332,
0.18069152534008026,
-0.42778849601745605,
-0.43839558959007263,
0.35457170009613037,
-0.1602746546268463,
0.14647796750068665,
0.39925700426101685,
0.3224758207798004,
0.3469347655773163,
-0.4870351552963257,
0.03938298299908638,
0.2886074185371399,
-0.168757364153862,
-0.1877749264240265,
1.0126407146453857,
-0.017387162894010544,
-0.5389528274536133,
0.1579524278640747,
-0.05578145757317543,
-0.25549739599227905,
0.6968552470207214,
0.3384718894958496,
0.9056629538536072,
-0.6608827114105225,
-0.1260593980550766,
-0.0035519013181328773,
0.22233104705810547,
-0.1434834897518158,
0.30784669518470764,
-0.30252760648727417,
-0.36485418677330017,
-0.014811002649366856,
-0.39280545711517334,
-0.5614247918128967,
-0.2252909392118454,
-0.7514275312423706,
-0.014250163920223713,
-0.5281126499176025,
0.0916547030210495,
0.5824974775314331,
-0.31200265884399414,
-0.47357606887817383,
-0.12731720507144928,
-0.3116571605205536,
0.48125356435775757,
-0.7652711272239685,
0.21242858469486237,
0.4944753050804138,
-0.08172792196273804,
-0.7537704110145569,
0.0031305733136832714,
0.31349924206733704,
-0.7617273926734924,
0.10420563817024231,
0.0713106319308281,
-0.42212894558906555,
0.2850290834903717,
-0.9552204608917236,
-0.5839614868164062,
0.9407846331596375,
0.5155264139175415,
-0.3535914719104767,
-0.08575630187988281,
-0.06004601716995239,
0.29482313990592957,
-0.1419968456029892,
0.1060093566775322,
0.24005720019340515,
0.5589654445648193,
0.046989791095256805,
-0.7213460206985474,
0.17619433999061584,
-0.20947709679603577,
-0.17976754903793335,
0.31011223793029785,
-0.42659124732017517,
0.7399536371231079,
-0.10675165057182312,
-0.3825215995311737,
0.41491377353668213,
0.6016604900360107,
0.27901819348335266,
0.606504499912262,
0.6076462864875793,
0.445694237947464,
0.850577175617218,
0.04186687618494034,
0.9832185506820679,
-0.23851384222507477,
0.19349853694438934,
1.1109869480133057,
-0.11088016629219055,
0.6130384206771851,
0.5278139710426331,
-0.048932187259197235,
0.554609477519989,
-0.013673249632120132,
-0.11564010381698608,
0.6312280893325806,
0.14920610189437866,
-0.19672496616840363,
-0.15666267275810242,
0.03446020185947418,
-0.2631928324699402,
0.6067905426025391,
-0.2583400309085846,
-0.49981144070625305,
0.20540572702884674,
0.18193604052066803,
0.8073439598083496,
0.2660278081893921,
-0.07930097728967667,
0.7825919985771179,
-0.09157124161720276,
-0.44973719120025635,
0.2761232256889343,
-0.06234033405780792,
0.4487942159175873,
-0.7421256899833679,
-0.12400460988283157,
0.2524959146976471,
0.5079265236854553,
-0.3015509843826294,
-0.4784370958805084,
0.264689177274704,
0.11923863738775253,
0.07503623515367508,
-0.5917818546295166,
0.5258523225784302,
-0.5331161022186279,
-0.4435614049434662,
-0.20090767741203308,
0.11918020248413086,
0.2818736135959625,
-0.19057400524616241,
-0.002499047666788101,
-0.062494512647390366,
0.002830405021086335,
-0.4451889991760254,
-0.18020953238010406,
0.17782992124557495,
0.11448860168457031,
0.5550258755683899,
1.0654038190841675,
0.18447625637054443,
-0.37366771697998047,
-0.4192993938922882,
0.7482863068580627,
-0.43657803535461426,
-0.892678439617157,
-1.1127643585205078,
0.5203608870506287,
-0.16314685344696045,
-0.46515098214149475,
1.0747981071472168,
0.6043991446495056,
0.6049805879592896,
-0.1047053337097168,
0.6628732681274414,
-0.09555312246084213,
0.5735066533088684,
-0.5924835801124573,
1.204461932182312,
-0.6216755509376526,
0.3609727919101715,
-0.4798097312450409,
-0.6098014116287231,
-0.4944654405117035,
0.4810868501663208,
-0.23506596684455872,
0.06924690306186676,
0.6577578783035278,
0.8164096474647522,
-0.17055743932724,
0.2732895314693451,
-0.1147618219256401,
0.21229450404644012,
0.45373964309692383,
0.31073641777038574,
0.5266709327697754,
-0.7331031560897827,
0.6569557189941406,
-0.48668959736824036,
-0.5776799321174622,
-0.3771345317363739,
-0.9431299567222595,
-1.0464028120040894,
-0.3896656930446625,
-0.63907790184021,
-0.3354663848876953,
0.27598080039024353,
0.6085060238838196,
0.8556489944458008,
-0.6647108793258667,
0.34749847650527954,
0.03494984656572342,
0.06498930603265762,
-0.7691896557807922,
-0.18260768055915833,
0.7679623365402222,
0.5469251275062561,
-0.7394745349884033,
0.3827159106731415,
-0.09327095746994019,
-0.10020818561315536,
-0.02856471575796604,
0.1550617665052414,
0.045245010405778885,
0.13636213541030884,
0.14206542074680328,
0.17376768589019775,
-0.6200369596481323,
-0.48340097069740295,
-0.09730289876461029,
0.1978311538696289,
-0.13559728860855103,
0.5253770351409912,
-0.4700518250465393,
0.5744802355766296,
0.31211793422698975,
0.40189334750175476,
0.49142691493034363,
0.392545610666275,
0.19140975177288055,
-0.8500043153762817,
-0.009710317477583885,
0.4362879991531372,
0.10331869125366211,
0.03567881882190704,
-0.864501953125,
0.4713902473449707,
0.30286723375320435,
-0.5351219773292542,
-1.1124972105026245,
0.3469008803367615,
-1.0348598957061768,
-0.2227914184331894,
0.9665338397026062,
-0.328064501285553,
-0.595799446105957,
-0.3147132396697998,
-0.24278299510478973,
0.2720161974430084,
-0.6252717971801758,
0.9113587737083435,
0.3139473795890808,
-0.00405504833906889,
-0.0720522552728653,
-0.22797130048274994,
0.6672323346138,
0.323347806930542,
-0.5160326957702637,
0.34356364607810974,
0.19570273160934448,
0.1166408509016037,
0.49362489581108093,
0.6934707164764404,
-0.03633718565106392,
0.4219955503940582,
0.35668453574180603,
0.24179355800151825,
-0.8840157985687256,
-0.5805714726448059,
0.12126512080430984,
0.425939679145813,
-0.3690529465675354,
-0.5775414109230042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.01778v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.01778v1 | Introduction to speech recognition | 2024-02-01T17:54:15 | 2024-02-01T17:54:15 | Gabriel Dauphin | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | This document contains lectures and practical experimentations using Matlab
and implementing a system which is actually correctly classifying three words
(one, two and three) with the help of a very small database. To achieve this
performance, it uses speech modeling specificities, powerful computer
algorithms (dynamic time warping and Dijktra's algorithm) and machine learning
(nearest neighbor). This document introduces also some machine learning
evaluation metrics. | [
-0.3797786235809326,
-0.7710589170455933,
0.3406780958175659,
-0.004322021268308163,
-0.13438159227371216,
0.3197013735771179,
0.0768367275595665,
-0.3505156636238098,
-0.2098565399646759,
0.39090147614479065,
-0.3686677813529968,
-0.33747637271881104,
-0.5748217701911926,
-0.11656330525875092,
-0.78449946641922,
0.7110259532928467,
0.20838704705238342,
0.5599643588066101,
0.2302381694316864,
-0.35125088691711426,
-0.45309436321258545,
-0.47500938177108765,
-0.8051621913909912,
-0.48539790511131287,
0.32798710465431213,
0.6644791960716248,
0.47121375799179077,
0.696431577205658,
0.526050865650177,
0.3098197281360626,
-0.05076605826616287,
-0.18757623434066772,
-0.18683694303035736,
-0.2710864841938019,
0.19888977706432343,
-0.6520111560821533,
-0.03383488953113556,
0.36174461245536804,
0.8921286463737488,
0.6749300956726074,
-0.3450959622859955,
0.23904016613960266,
-0.037434473633766174,
0.7578821778297424,
-0.09870130568742752,
0.21007618308067322,
-0.2652469873428345,
0.3639620840549469,
-0.5260347127914429,
-0.1976957619190216,
-0.25017669796943665,
-0.5474750995635986,
0.015172135084867477,
-0.44322073459625244,
0.43169716000556946,
0.11361623555421829,
0.5553828477859497,
0.36260801553726196,
-0.07891561836004257,
-0.599868655204773,
-0.9950939416885376,
0.8864469528198242,
-0.36187776923179626,
0.6334167122840881,
0.5127045512199402,
0.9505891799926758,
-0.00003519109668559395,
-0.7386690974235535,
-0.7806651592254639,
-0.10497019439935684,
0.14611706137657166,
-0.2635226845741272,
-0.2434776872396469,
0.01859169825911522,
0.5116417407989502,
0.37374526262283325,
-0.6091503500938416,
0.30389928817749023,
-0.8088143467903137,
-0.5332437753677368,
0.5303263664245605,
0.16309361159801483,
0.3400306701660156,
0.10729432851076126,
0.08251621574163437,
-0.18736517429351807,
-0.23641686141490936,
-0.04925328865647316,
0.2971457540988922,
0.4893411695957184,
-0.19627349078655243,
0.5906294584274292,
0.08839230239391327,
1.1983882188796997,
-0.224305659532547,
-0.709948718547821,
0.4697743356227875,
0.06158304587006569,
-0.24812552332878113,
0.6205168962478638,
0.5408254861831665,
-0.10376454144716263,
0.2156621664762497,
-0.002980392426252365,
0.11864528059959412,
0.20496682822704315,
0.13502849638462067,
-0.4496443271636963,
-0.1542394608259201,
0.04930201917886734,
-0.5473416447639465,
-0.3040018081665039,
-0.11356090009212494,
-0.43438783288002014,
-0.34919098019599915,
-0.689475417137146,
0.49526530504226685,
-0.6162986159324646,
0.030435066670179367,
-0.06378582119941711,
-0.24321630597114563,
0.5370244383811951,
0.27031928300857544,
-0.5182794332504272,
0.7551378011703491,
0.55500328540802,
1.0172616243362427,
-0.168059840798378,
-0.3264533281326294,
-0.5208872556686401,
0.07350403070449829,
-0.03575235605239868,
0.6614500284194946,
-0.2598857879638672,
-0.7313424348831177,
-0.39580434560775757,
-0.042351964861154556,
0.14417555928230286,
-0.536853015422821,
0.7121923565864563,
-0.15009312331676483,
0.2756649851799011,
0.31180623173713684,
-0.7874607443809509,
-0.31308549642562866,
-0.24212536215782166,
-0.4710623621940613,
1.0428714752197266,
0.13992202281951904,
-0.6440719962120056,
0.1353536695241928,
-1.2216182947158813,
-0.5357020497322083,
0.22659556567668915,
-0.10372099280357361,
-0.2964884340763092,
0.006804001051932573,
-0.19432973861694336,
0.5032585263252258,
-0.11078161001205444,
-0.47843846678733826,
0.3022095859050751,
-0.4943840801715851,
0.24137718975543976,
-0.12176136672496796,
0.9138162136077881,
0.6644806265830994,
-0.012579897418618202,
-0.2226710319519043,
-1.2668172121047974,
0.12652261555194855,
0.16495628654956818,
-0.5532135367393494,
-0.06132665276527405,
0.14570605754852295,
0.05594518780708313,
-0.18816626071929932,
-0.01838698424398899,
-0.7114279866218567,
0.12075489014387131,
-0.5496668219566345,
0.6398648619651794,
0.16646255552768707,
-0.1465359330177307,
0.3796618580818176,
-0.13236363232135773,
0.34172698855400085,
-0.0768841803073883,
-0.12685495615005493,
0.013521750457584858,
-0.7674446702003479,
-0.8169995546340942,
0.015139149501919746,
0.5458251237869263,
0.9509623646736145,
-0.4248598515987396,
0.21972139179706573,
-0.061986133456230164,
-0.6871026754379272,
-0.4576111137866974,
0.1568114161491394,
0.3833943009376526,
0.5111380815505981,
0.20375540852546692,
0.08652114123106003,
-0.7178000211715698,
-0.8112984299659729,
0.20036646723747253,
-0.4596821367740631,
-0.2859431505203247,
0.2540864050388336,
0.05165606737136841,
-0.10173208266496658,
0.8061313629150391,
-0.831288754940033,
-0.36416682600975037,
-0.19736219942569733,
0.4206734895706177,
0.2652924358844757,
0.521493136882782,
0.4956248998641968,
-0.7013430595397949,
-0.2681451737880707,
-0.13706931471824646,
-0.2891806662082672,
0.07528908550739288,
0.5843625664710999,
0.314770370721817,
-0.0813554972410202,
0.558324933052063,
0.17757704854011536,
0.4440632462501526,
0.38019710779190063,
0.19654899835586548,
0.16064396500587463,
-0.18865181505680084,
-0.23843394219875336,
-1.0910547971725464,
-0.370685875415802,
0.021563293412327766,
-0.24886184930801392,
-0.9330060482025146,
-0.36590686440467834,
-0.09694729745388031,
-0.3869107663631439,
-0.6367321014404297,
0.34939637780189514,
-0.1569439321756363,
-0.3316928744316101,
-0.4896157383918762,
0.2128821313381195,
-0.35938113927841187,
0.21489673852920532,
0.06795354187488556,
0.770606279373169,
0.5921506881713867,
-0.9320690035820007,
0.6212063431739807,
0.3835061490535736,
-0.5493252873420715,
0.756170392036438,
-0.2701200544834137,
0.5653544068336487,
-0.1476188451051712,
-0.3184947371482849,
-0.9249854683876038,
-0.4047013521194458,
0.06884108483791351,
-0.7961058020591736,
0.6994504928588867,
0.03429396077990532,
-0.41744464635849,
-0.718233585357666,
0.15226946771144867,
0.13757377862930298,
0.6391827464103699,
-0.44395390152931213,
0.41345053911209106,
1.0901598930358887,
-0.09056996554136276,
-0.3521977365016937,
-0.7947217226028442,
0.14663700759410858,
-0.11777757853269577,
-0.11201212555170059,
0.15939463675022125,
0.00145523261744529,
-0.24098341166973114,
-0.34657615423202515,
0.451805979013443,
-0.4681547284126282,
0.10205002129077911,
0.37618353962898254,
-0.19976434111595154,
-0.1747170090675354,
0.335897296667099,
-0.3309788107872009,
-0.12254834920167923,
-0.31457456946372986,
-0.09377026557922363,
0.5337648987770081,
-0.47432437539100647,
-0.21683965623378754,
-0.6780325770378113,
0.13510587811470032,
0.4075399935245514,
0.2544940114021301,
0.07469523698091507,
1.0291516780853271,
-0.6305059790611267,
-0.0729542002081871,
-0.44905775785446167,
0.21586444973945618,
-0.40063735842704773,
0.43369945883750916,
-0.3619781732559204,
-0.570671021938324,
0.16172857582569122,
0.19253279268741608,
-0.2557581961154938,
0.48106831312179565,
0.4453185796737671,
-0.22778265178203583,
1.1668146848678589,
0.86681067943573,
-0.4029107391834259,
0.3924933671951294,
-0.16539937257766724,
0.1176549643278122,
-0.7939721345901489,
-0.32277584075927734,
-1.1453285217285156,
-0.3017978370189667,
-0.5036437511444092,
-0.283582866191864,
0.2203463613986969,
0.020856983959674835,
-0.09288255870342255,
0.5807480216026306,
-0.8727609515190125,
0.47374290227890015,
0.7861087918281555,
0.055068496614694595,
-0.1214098334312439,
0.05449061095714569,
-0.36109459400177,
-0.0790611058473587,
-0.5800731778144836,
-0.5736287236213684,
0.8316813111305237,
0.5024170279502869,
0.9462307095527649,
0.07030338793992996,
0.6399288773536682,
0.43076953291893005,
0.14964701235294342,
-1.1614491939544678,
0.6224709153175354,
-0.19983984529972076,
-0.4559442400932312,
-0.49992576241493225,
-0.2771543562412262,
-0.8948923945426941,
-0.3458130657672882,
-0.15394385159015656,
-0.780388355255127,
-0.05935624986886978,
0.06298958510160446,
-0.43251484632492065,
0.19612786173820496,
-0.7751251459121704,
0.2563074827194214,
-0.3723277151584625,
0.2078181803226471,
-0.20760264992713928,
-0.80451899766922,
0.12159991264343262,
-0.2392023503780365,
0.30665719509124756,
-0.2971835434436798,
0.06766694039106369,
1.307997226715088,
-0.08690153062343597,
0.5404477715492249,
-0.6612136363983154,
0.3594326674938202,
0.29234230518341064,
-0.030725035816431046,
-0.23273511230945587,
-0.4494313895702362,
-0.123243547976017,
0.20889794826507568,
0.31643593311309814,
-0.05903433635830879,
-0.3380536139011383,
0.45242375135421753,
-0.752010703086853,
-0.11660175025463104,
-0.44497787952423096,
-0.3997441232204437,
-0.4458085894584656,
0.46920087933540344,
0.014470042660832405,
0.4441970884799957,
-0.6205540895462036,
0.11138065159320831,
0.687640905380249,
-0.43045470118522644,
0.4476887285709381,
0.8942583799362183,
-0.3800903558731079,
-0.4984631836414337,
1.1696367263793945,
0.18843665719032288,
-0.3383783996105194,
0.4914513826370239,
0.7345060706138611,
-0.5634503960609436,
-0.7686895728111267,
-0.5099160671234131,
0.12172200530767441,
-0.5789284110069275,
-0.11189662665128708,
-0.5127120614051819,
-0.5404956340789795,
-0.41020146012306213,
0.12932410836219788,
0.011590486392378807,
-0.7822738289833069,
-0.4756946265697479,
-0.07660640776157379,
0.2004556953907013,
0.9276687502861023,
-0.28371110558509827,
0.7328130006790161,
-0.8578693866729736,
0.4298410415649414,
0.5596721768379211,
0.2991996109485626,
-0.39875948429107666,
-0.5669150352478027,
-0.4140312373638153,
-0.052542999386787415,
-0.44954612851142883,
-0.86896151304245,
0.20632728934288025,
0.530859112739563,
1.0069881677627563,
0.6133072376251221,
-0.5294448137283325,
0.32642462849617004,
-0.7256081700325012,
0.8971436023712158,
0.22006618976593018,
-0.9294470548629761,
0.9613237977027893,
-0.03795360401272774,
0.14242924749851227,
0.29425227642059326,
0.3190048038959503,
-0.24023738503456116,
0.1800299435853958,
-0.49015623331069946,
0.020122410729527473,
1.0413475036621094,
0.188405379652977,
-0.12533292174339294,
0.18032525479793549,
0.49513834714889526,
-0.15105374157428741,
0.2928330898284912,
-0.2722403109073639,
-0.5513355135917664,
-0.22061175107955933,
-0.39852818846702576,
-0.45291975140571594,
-0.27265143394470215,
-0.19131802022457123,
-0.48714950680732727,
0.6679093241691589,
0.08925686031579971,
0.4507165253162384,
-0.21734172105789185,
-0.19541035592556,
0.26197242736816406,
0.2034451812505722,
1.018345594406128,
0.1873113512992859,
-0.3841084837913513,
0.010375907644629478,
0.40304017066955566,
-0.9586790204048157,
0.5202739834785461,
0.18888920545578003,
0.23556403815746307,
0.3347577452659607,
-0.07106038928031921,
0.7655434608459473,
-0.014972849749028683,
-0.2629813253879547,
0.33372223377227783,
-0.3303353190422058,
-0.36959144473075867,
-0.2809551954269409,
0.327779084444046,
-0.06799641251564026,
-0.171263188123703,
0.3136892318725586,
-0.18490321934223175,
0.3914673924446106,
-0.4326227605342865,
0.14437250792980194,
0.284062922000885,
-0.5842761993408203,
0.03151772543787956,
0.5413762331008911,
0.036842621862888336,
-1.1775950193405151,
0.2943522036075592,
-0.11277277022600174,
-0.6580012440681458,
0.5622004866600037,
0.49770408868789673,
0.8913580775260925,
-0.9205877780914307,
0.07821004837751389,
0.5386688709259033,
0.1795347034931183,
-0.2571125328540802,
0.4091466963291168,
-0.40515658259391785,
-0.7623236775398254,
0.03934549167752266,
-1.0063716173171997,
-0.788186252117157,
0.05039310082793236,
-0.7710725665092468,
0.5900532007217407,
-0.595030665397644,
-0.32352912425994873,
0.7468538284301758,
0.21886415779590607,
-0.5416160225868225,
0.24389418959617615,
0.33694547414779663,
0.9791789650917053,
-0.6580677628517151,
1.1393136978149414,
0.71340411901474,
-0.11127083003520966,
-0.7351956367492676,
-0.5576589703559875,
0.3288254141807556,
-0.9736102819442749,
0.7685889005661011,
0.15974541008472443,
-0.5442448854446411,
0.24871934950351715,
-0.63179612159729,
-0.6935833096504211,
0.8471749424934387,
-0.05793457105755806,
-0.6586570739746094,
0.14578554034233093,
0.3249513506889343,
0.5754297971725464,
-0.3103441298007965,
-0.2076205313205719,
0.8673006892204285,
0.2274124026298523,
0.17832250893115997,
-1.0598061084747314,
-0.7340161800384521,
-0.05024217441678047,
0.04958206042647362,
0.0018111092504113913,
-0.183946892619133,
0.6049282550811768,
-0.17180097103118896,
-0.374127596616745,
0.21520745754241943,
0.45937585830688477,
-0.10717575252056122,
0.6012519598007202,
0.659741997718811,
0.6609258651733398,
1.171060562133789,
-0.5084717869758606,
0.7183947563171387,
-0.4038213789463043,
-0.003515330608934164,
1.4727329015731812,
-0.21621470153331757,
0.8456424474716187,
0.1739002913236618,
-0.8724009394645691,
0.2013159990310669,
0.5116258263587952,
-0.24796448647975922,
0.37804433703422546,
0.44696754217147827,
-0.24329805374145508,
0.4171220660209656,
0.04494456201791763,
-0.4566707909107208,
0.8072828054428101,
0.9255545735359192,
-0.3681785762310028,
0.02054481767117977,
0.5089510083198547,
-0.41387152671813965,
-0.1613585203886032,
-0.60221266746521,
1.0448291301727295,
0.07622623443603516,
-0.05836021155118942,
0.30283984541893005,
0.1569797694683075,
0.2823896110057831,
-0.4673975110054016,
-0.09503008425235748,
0.3989667296409607,
0.21959976851940155,
-0.12009909749031067,
-0.8270589113235474,
0.45669740438461304,
-0.013425404205918312,
-0.10385771840810776,
0.08609850704669952,
0.7688326239585876,
-0.12051986157894135,
-0.7503731846809387,
-0.23074603080749512,
0.18154068291187286,
0.727196455001831,
0.3954061269760132,
-0.7804808020591736,
0.09330741316080093,
-0.23518691956996918,
0.37291815876960754,
-0.10100399702787399,
0.19838640093803406,
0.2803174555301666,
0.6037495136260986,
0.5570499897003174,
0.28306999802589417,
0.20795123279094696,
0.3163122832775116,
0.4631425738334656,
-0.6499221920967102,
-0.6571545600891113,
-0.5241214036941528,
-0.2961270809173584,
-0.017818499356508255,
0.20422890782356262,
0.7452654838562012,
0.8036036491394043,
0.6062420010566711,
0.15404634177684784,
0.7728020548820496,
0.18799950182437897,
1.4751263856887817,
-0.333177387714386,
0.5492058396339417,
-0.24127349257469177,
0.14533627033233643,
-0.43360570073127747,
-0.7632312774658203,
-0.651968777179718,
0.9722335338592529,
0.01641043834388256,
-0.2156289964914322,
0.31197240948677063,
0.7768197655677795,
0.0694735050201416,
0.34815213084220886,
0.5420957207679749,
0.14237932860851288,
0.07520502060651779,
0.22614501416683197,
1.0036259889602661,
-0.3262822926044464,
0.4608302414417267,
-0.333025723695755,
-0.3021942377090454,
-0.26188400387763977,
-0.6571208238601685,
-0.5047094821929932,
-0.7579987049102783,
-0.2637256383895874,
-0.6212046146392822,
-0.11260104179382324,
0.7550787329673767,
0.9319348335266113,
-0.9629873633384705,
-0.30432578921318054,
0.04771360754966736,
-0.014834447763860226,
-0.023518234491348267,
-0.2006969451904297,
0.3770340085029602,
0.007209219038486481,
-0.916203498840332,
0.46812406182289124,
0.27319371700286865,
0.7061681151390076,
-0.3516862988471985,
-0.230339914560318,
-0.06302296370267868,
-0.016021715477108955,
0.4218645393848419,
0.7933349013328552,
-0.40331095457077026,
-0.061562441289424896,
-0.3525993227958679,
0.039578139781951904,
0.19542689621448517,
0.7968050837516785,
-0.8681625723838806,
0.6207481026649475,
0.4581403434276581,
0.321683794260025,
0.6151742339134216,
-0.17188376188278198,
0.12476145476102829,
-0.6364396810531616,
0.3616417944431305,
0.3010839819908142,
0.38586699962615967,
0.5793699026107788,
-0.05760499835014343,
0.5483237504959106,
0.10090751945972443,
-0.6075558662414551,
-1.0667082071304321,
0.05102802440524101,
-1.1277564764022827,
0.05996272340416908,
0.7850988507270813,
0.22807809710502625,
-0.14487233757972717,
-0.3963122069835663,
-0.7036362290382385,
0.5114516615867615,
0.10298310220241547,
0.3327147364616394,
0.8018109798431396,
-0.7140558958053589,
-0.049194660037755966,
-0.6248310208320618,
0.7285076379776001,
-0.33785948157310486,
-0.46690991520881653,
-0.5514307022094727,
0.4117267429828644,
0.46176832914352417,
0.5013375878334045,
0.5359705686569214,
-0.36164385080337524,
0.012394936755299568,
0.05430208146572113,
-0.08593136072158813,
-0.20218178629875183,
-0.34233614802360535,
-0.7489005327224731,
0.21110627055168152,
0.19397412240505219,
-0.7237548232078552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00798v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00798v3 | Formal-LLM: Integrating Formal Language and Natural Language for Controllable LLM-based Agents | 2024-02-01T17:30:50 | 2024-06-18T05:44:03 | Zelong Li, Wenyue Hua, Hao Wang, He Zhu, Yongfeng Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.FL | Recent advancements on Large Language Models (LLMs) enable AI Agents to
automatically generate and execute multi-step plans to solve complex tasks.
However, since LLM's content generation process is hardly controllable, current
LLM-based agents frequently generate invalid or non-executable plans, which
jeopardizes the performance of the generated plans and corrupts users' trust in
LLM-based agents. In response, this paper proposes a novel ``Formal-LLM''
framework for LLM-based agents by integrating the expressiveness of natural
language and the precision of formal language. Specifically, the framework
allows human users to express their requirements or constraints for the
planning process as an automaton. A stack-based LLM plan generation process is
then conducted under the supervision of the automaton to ensure that the
generated plan satisfies the constraints, making the planning process
controllable. We conduct experiments on both benchmark tasks and practical
real-life tasks, and our framework achieves over 50% overall performance
increase, which validates the feasibility and effectiveness of employing
Formal-LLM to guide the plan generation of agents, preventing the agents from
generating invalid and unsuccessful plans. Further, more controllable LLM-based
agents can facilitate the broader utilization of LLM in application scenarios
where high validity of planning is essential. The work is open-sourced at
https://github.com/agiresearch/Formal-LLM. | [
-0.19604338705539703,
-0.8514658808708191,
0.4567004144191742,
0.3789500892162323,
0.12199440598487854,
0.2902269959449768,
-0.1849297136068344,
-0.7734472751617432,
0.34399113059043884,
0.6358217597007751,
-0.4571573734283447,
-0.5147411227226257,
-0.18087613582611084,
0.07640207558870316,
-0.27555832266807556,
0.5624374151229858,
-0.5145253539085388,
-0.18577872216701508,
-0.19220109283924103,
0.296354740858078,
-0.008643027395009995,
-0.4182942807674408,
-0.5853882431983948,
-0.5978924632072449,
0.2514171600341797,
0.26731935143470764,
1.0367085933685303,
0.8199493885040283,
0.4914063811302185,
0.33710557222366333,
0.39323294162750244,
0.43692120909690857,
-0.2517786920070648,
0.14762578904628754,
-0.20893292129039764,
-0.40028876066207886,
-0.8356459736824036,
-0.137244313955307,
0.6474732756614685,
0.3458845019340515,
-0.31162717938423157,
-0.1543334722518921,
-0.1534050852060318,
0.48124217987060547,
-0.5783562660217285,
0.4892808794975281,
-0.5979263186454773,
0.08703078329563141,
0.07122624665498734,
-0.48595377802848816,
-0.2534344494342804,
-0.46817079186439514,
-0.2127590924501419,
-0.7477430701255798,
-0.16547057032585144,
0.11991816759109497,
0.7748045921325684,
0.4751354157924652,
-0.18785445392131805,
-0.535693883895874,
-1.199169635772705,
0.48065948486328125,
-0.8947696685791016,
-0.005620784591883421,
0.44786593317985535,
0.47897112369537354,
-0.493972510099411,
-0.6337648034095764,
-0.6950781941413879,
-0.682056188583374,
-0.1342444121837616,
0.04358889162540436,
0.1168113425374031,
0.3605479598045349,
0.24668973684310913,
0.23338431119918823,
-0.5570695400238037,
0.2794683575630188,
0.0242172759026289,
-0.3007235825061798,
0.9074165225028992,
0.30476850271224976,
0.48818856477737427,
0.06108754873275757,
-0.513392984867096,
0.4186381995677948,
-0.5207448601722717,
-0.046541862189769745,
0.4515138268470764,
0.35015013813972473,
-0.2143411934375763,
0.7829103469848633,
-0.6997168660163879,
0.41604822874069214,
-0.08534738421440125,
-0.13573704659938812,
-0.18117554485797882,
-0.35762834548950195,
-0.38259801268577576,
0.019693048670887947,
0.791781485080719,
0.1363600492477417,
0.6119565367698669,
-0.27841585874557495,
-0.5236329436302185,
0.25988897681236267,
0.14095550775527954,
-0.5385539531707764,
-0.00021805586584378034,
0.2967663109302521,
0.12236868590116501,
-0.5467661023139954,
-0.09192294627428055,
-0.21478445827960968,
-0.21994701027870178,
-0.3924826979637146,
0.13383755087852478,
-0.49337175488471985,
-0.06870773434638977,
0.2921329140663147,
0.35659974813461304,
0.7078709602355957,
0.4576498866081238,
-0.7376304268836975,
0.8110949397087097,
0.6778150200843811,
0.46013975143432617,
-0.03248724713921547,
-0.3005180358886719,
-0.6054885983467102,
0.5752550959587097,
-0.5549952387809753,
0.6630550026893616,
-0.4731755256652832,
-0.22151987254619598,
0.3001187741756439,
-0.287002295255661,
0.13561171293258667,
-0.27217796444892883,
0.423739492893219,
-0.6033918857574463,
0.204289048910141,
0.011936837807297707,
-0.5033696293830872,
0.0716525986790657,
0.573756754398346,
-0.5747663974761963,
0.9013022780418396,
-0.09894444048404694,
-0.2658078372478485,
0.3530692756175995,
-0.592324435710907,
-0.6063587665557861,
0.36773374676704407,
-0.517078697681427,
-0.105427086353302,
-0.46536076068878174,
-0.06453630328178406,
0.3935092091560364,
-0.28286734223365784,
0.5988513827323914,
-0.07438314706087112,
-0.13419434428215027,
0.19948764145374298,
-0.20520515739917755,
0.350690633058548,
0.15208804607391357,
-0.6150131225585938,
0.38656479120254517,
-0.6493551135063171,
0.19948187470436096,
0.08533722907304764,
-0.4810430407524109,
0.10109976679086685,
0.16424667835235596,
-0.09459959715604782,
0.39694342017173767,
0.6284234523773193,
-0.20416609942913055,
0.3061966598033905,
-0.582079291343689,
0.24183082580566406,
0.6637544631958008,
-0.03497561812400818,
0.8575197458267212,
-0.7095876336097717,
0.5686017274856567,
-0.5761095285415649,
0.10245678573846817,
-0.11095714569091797,
-0.05815079063177109,
-0.49688786268234253,
-0.2528409957885742,
-0.013791992329061031,
0.7874501347541809,
-0.660843014717102,
0.6644611358642578,
-0.16808876395225525,
-0.3822938799858093,
0.031376369297504425,
0.13811089098453522,
0.4172120690345764,
0.4644547998905182,
0.10096704214811325,
-0.14566707611083984,
-0.28687140345573425,
-0.753722608089447,
-0.11809755116701126,
-0.2630234360694885,
0.020160503685474396,
0.4051225483417511,
0.4135296642780304,
-0.4125882387161255,
1.106168270111084,
-0.24973170459270477,
-0.27449145913124084,
-0.34390971064567566,
0.13144774734973907,
-0.22152011096477509,
0.4775339365005493,
0.05051131919026375,
-0.6993791460990906,
-0.33054110407829285,
0.010851087048649788,
-0.8834707736968994,
-0.37870848178863525,
-0.5045188665390015,
-0.3507622480392456,
0.448175311088562,
0.49441900849342346,
-0.6979975700378418,
0.3537294864654541,
0.1468053013086319,
-0.23659661412239075,
0.8746139407157898,
-0.3655945956707001,
-0.1908925175666809,
-1.0480564832687378,
0.2314436137676239,
-0.19914495944976807,
-0.45871248841285706,
-0.5312094688415527,
0.3423113524913788,
-0.07293456047773361,
-0.1230139210820198,
-0.5243836641311646,
0.7476881146430969,
-0.39256611466407776,
-0.04162287339568138,
-0.17436763644218445,
0.2013852447271347,
0.020801862701773643,
0.5811861157417297,
0.15076909959316254,
0.5545489192008972,
0.4323804974555969,
-0.7140867710113525,
0.48828399181365967,
0.18811185657978058,
0.051074523478746414,
0.41749703884124756,
-0.6158231496810913,
-0.06400305777788162,
0.023201463744044304,
0.42638716101646423,
-0.5756410956382751,
-0.609796941280365,
0.4962489604949951,
-0.138874813914299,
0.42655983567237854,
0.11141375452280045,
-0.7475371956825256,
0.015449032187461853,
-0.2742670774459839,
0.08530685305595398,
0.35546907782554626,
-0.048098064959049225,
0.9600473046302795,
0.23938710987567902,
-0.24020640552043915,
-0.3601125180721283,
-0.8751469254493713,
0.3257354199886322,
0.1346546709537506,
-0.7309767603874207,
0.44731470942497253,
-0.15887852013111115,
-0.5599129796028137,
0.06585416942834854,
-0.0786508098244667,
-0.12482310086488724,
-0.0889633521437645,
0.3575172424316406,
0.21031919121742249,
0.09637017548084259,
-0.04715709760785103,
0.10228037089109421,
-0.2922709584236145,
0.21914717555046082,
-0.31272169947624207,
0.5086632966995239,
-0.23512479662895203,
-0.49325162172317505,
-0.6250719428062439,
0.21496106684207916,
0.6380754113197327,
-0.42434293031692505,
0.43332239985466003,
0.22754843533039093,
-0.4792279899120331,
-0.36028045415878296,
-0.4170904755592346,
-0.07474163919687271,
-0.48512715101242065,
-0.013236314989626408,
-0.26304569840431213,
-0.5884097218513489,
0.4580449163913727,
-0.3746238350868225,
0.38595542311668396,
0.18074721097946167,
0.43525129556655884,
-0.025659572333097458,
0.7200140953063965,
0.581201434135437,
-0.15761929750442505,
0.18465764820575714,
-0.16417725384235382,
-0.08725383877754211,
-0.2950873076915741,
-0.31804534792900085,
-0.39489808678627014,
-0.3463630974292755,
-0.6234785914421082,
-0.4921227991580963,
-0.19121384620666504,
0.008717093616724014,
-0.07829578220844269,
0.1090497374534607,
-0.32973161339759827,
0.29734185338020325,
0.23611284792423248,
-0.3006345331668854,
0.5425432920455933,
-0.22939065098762512,
-0.2938225269317627,
0.25572431087493896,
-0.5281420350074768,
-1.00454580783844,
0.585538387298584,
0.2998841106891632,
1.0981658697128296,
-0.02683205157518387,
0.8872935771942139,
0.5291962623596191,
0.09800481051206589,
-0.7617038488388062,
0.8305224180221558,
0.4337041974067688,
-0.4125549793243408,
-0.6177780032157898,
-0.3407136797904968,
-0.7525309324264526,
-0.13670770823955536,
-0.32511740922927856,
-0.4568275511264801,
-0.08897910267114639,
0.2517429292201996,
-0.17489401996135712,
0.247580885887146,
-0.34051233530044556,
0.40185490250587463,
-0.6526523232460022,
-0.49430352449417114,
-0.15051908791065216,
-0.5955583453178406,
0.387455552816391,
-0.1413055658340454,
0.2963419556617737,
-0.38513532280921936,
-0.3499738574028015,
0.31785300374031067,
-0.5726393461227417,
0.8821084499359131,
0.01699291355907917,
-0.3610335886478424,
0.30256742238998413,
0.5037820339202881,
1.2104772329330444,
0.14901696145534515,
-0.20736868679523468,
-0.02555212192237377,
-0.3004406988620758,
-0.40210023522377014,
-0.5897006988525391,
0.6630027890205383,
-0.5253866910934448,
-0.3018408715724945,
-0.32865986227989197,
-0.7976337671279907,
-0.10323856770992279,
0.48820769786834717,
0.020608942955732346,
0.4584270417690277,
-0.3702774941921234,
-0.3488128185272217,
0.353211909532547,
-0.26853954792022705,
0.3531840145587921,
0.5988275408744812,
-0.4591047167778015,
-0.12440046668052673,
0.71714848279953,
-0.06475046277046204,
0.5307369232177734,
0.6926543116569519,
0.14792969822883606,
-0.27288973331451416,
-0.6070785522460938,
-0.05079122260212898,
0.16907542943954468,
-0.29764410853385925,
0.11163895577192307,
-0.44640812277793884,
-0.44796159863471985,
-0.2912253141403198,
-0.6339908838272095,
-0.2543676793575287,
-0.5112958550453186,
0.021443286910653114,
-0.02928064577281475,
0.10658994317054749,
0.6930843591690063,
-0.060809530317783356,
0.10201042145490646,
-0.38930967450141907,
0.5132879614830017,
0.2075178325176239,
0.36027777194976807,
-0.5476333498954773,
0.03093571402132511,
-0.002706421772018075,
0.07298838347196579,
-0.06392192840576172,
-0.5317345261573792,
0.42665180563926697,
0.15734533965587616,
0.5744442343711853,
0.3036203682422638,
0.30134034156799316,
0.33871710300445557,
-0.4230743646621704,
0.41036534309387207,
-0.1744423657655716,
-0.5956602096557617,
0.6466417908668518,
-0.5819515585899353,
0.36101511120796204,
0.5154599547386169,
0.2658850848674774,
-0.2700017988681793,
-0.8261163234710693,
-0.7078865766525269,
-0.8825027942657471,
0.44895491003990173,
0.40103140473365784,
-0.0012276143534108996,
0.17677752673625946,
0.3601686954498291,
-0.07240137457847595,
0.403091162443161,
-0.6054863929748535,
-0.07072203606367111,
0.14156490564346313,
-0.043985165655612946,
0.18111607432365417,
-0.29654255509376526,
-0.29987964034080505,
0.17799395322799683,
0.5496535897254944,
-0.11394011229276657,
0.11448833346366882,
0.20570917427539825,
-0.3292637765407562,
-0.2726917564868927,
0.3865552842617035,
0.8495957851409912,
0.5343114137649536,
-0.17863790690898895,
0.31768906116485596,
0.03802509233355522,
-0.3314513862133026,
-0.029229624196887016,
0.27451083064079285,
-0.4345082938671112,
-0.28207024931907654,
0.4617234766483307,
0.31823915243148804,
0.3753404915332794,
-0.6927688121795654,
0.059794966131448746,
-0.03392734006047249,
-0.48763924837112427,
-0.6291799545288086,
0.2691420018672943,
-0.14179456233978271,
0.25050249695777893,
0.17314323782920837,
0.11335284262895584,
-0.09926050901412964,
-0.357454389333725,
0.39585161209106445,
0.4990348815917969,
-0.2756546139717102,
-0.20946413278579712,
0.6214306950569153,
0.4899008572101593,
-0.5846722722053528,
0.22501413524150848,
-0.5671956539154053,
-0.28541967272758484,
0.4737405776977539,
0.5540748238563538,
0.906033992767334,
-0.023391271010041237,
0.26990336179733276,
0.10224030166864395,
0.5812183618545532,
0.08015875518321991,
0.6370119452476501,
-0.11133518815040588,
-0.7497082948684692,
-0.5506912469863892,
-0.6894396543502808,
-0.49667292833328247,
-0.005402507726103067,
-0.18997947871685028,
0.21263857185840607,
-0.7816967368125916,
0.10579419136047363,
-0.586241602897644,
0.12078536301851273,
-0.3669842779636383,
0.02585347555577755,
0.16827595233917236,
1.0126113891601562,
-0.42851021885871887,
0.6121786236763,
0.6863169074058533,
-0.3231930732727051,
-0.978314995765686,
0.10163260251283646,
0.05207980051636696,
-0.7328668236732483,
0.4495840072631836,
-0.13306924700737,
-0.5179733633995056,
0.045468658208847046,
-0.5357383489608765,
-0.7683262228965759,
1.250812292098999,
0.34535104036331177,
-0.5164263844490051,
-0.29662084579467773,
0.5060052275657654,
0.451449453830719,
-0.33421725034713745,
-0.05888895317912102,
0.3314148187637329,
0.7784066200256348,
0.3464164137840271,
-0.8312697410583496,
0.3177540600299835,
-0.18987680971622467,
-0.26985159516334534,
0.35314038395881653,
-0.38546016812324524,
0.3743252158164978,
-0.1932065337896347,
-0.3914543092250824,
-0.007193665951490402,
0.6098020076751709,
0.5221574306488037,
0.2623932361602783,
0.1819537878036499,
0.2878078818321228,
0.9246396422386169,
0.06875435262918472,
1.0701930522918701,
-0.6678007245063782,
-0.12295109778642654,
1.2282752990722656,
-0.6358254551887512,
0.6013358235359192,
0.18656857311725616,
0.10097688436508179,
0.5279459357261658,
0.21103616058826447,
0.19128304719924927,
0.193216010928154,
0.3055814206600189,
-0.4415954649448395,
-0.045618437230587006,
-0.21178579330444336,
-0.14813931286334991,
0.3508251905441284,
0.2585197389125824,
0.03964729607105255,
-0.33907049894332886,
-0.4350038766860962,
0.07770240306854248,
0.39744022488594055,
-0.18989919126033783,
0.6397033333778381,
0.11168741434812546,
-0.4186473786830902,
0.4579583704471588,
0.02999517135322094,
0.6293948888778687,
-0.8506571650505066,
-0.024137506261467934,
-0.041649363934993744,
-0.07490706443786621,
-0.4543085992336273,
-0.5933063626289368,
0.4517233073711395,
-0.15028400719165802,
0.0900312140583992,
-0.46022576093673706,
1.0365056991577148,
-0.512299656867981,
-0.35966575145721436,
0.1911027878522873,
0.4928288757801056,
0.02251083217561245,
0.04917030408978462,
-0.6941959261894226,
-0.17562620341777802,
-0.46033939719200134,
-0.11033900827169418,
0.08141008019447327,
0.4341020882129669,
-0.3384735584259033,
0.9708082675933838,
0.7963810563087463,
0.49862149357795715,
0.08195672184228897,
-0.013857240788638592,
0.6926277875900269,
-0.6008203029632568,
-0.644623339176178,
-0.7678692936897278,
0.5329911708831787,
-0.027418294921517372,
0.14776059985160828,
0.5242376327514648,
0.6113560795783997,
0.5540839433670044,
0.21192480623722076,
0.768561065196991,
-0.04436996951699257,
-0.07455725222826004,
-0.6577866077423096,
0.7398436069488525,
-0.28696826100349426,
0.3759476840496063,
-0.05286867171525955,
-0.6484882831573486,
-0.3574259579181671,
0.2950947880744934,
-0.3386175334453583,
0.008412855677306652,
0.5076369047164917,
0.9106245636940002,
0.16323642432689667,
-0.429577112197876,
0.3878836929798126,
-0.02999013476073742,
0.6334800124168396,
0.4848213791847229,
0.9237658381462097,
0.13506434857845306,
0.44296905398368835,
-0.10204581171274185,
-0.38631516695022583,
-0.20440340042114258,
-1.006097435951233,
-0.6375194191932678,
-0.24678552150726318,
-0.19453740119934082,
-0.0005204692133702338,
-0.10944222658872604,
0.9422336220741272,
0.6403173804283142,
-0.4359368681907654,
-0.4806640148162842,
-0.5214877128601074,
0.2929013669490814,
0.05119713395833969,
-0.2630220949649811,
-0.13044989109039307,
-0.5978054404258728,
-0.5150266885757446,
0.5153974890708923,
0.5868641138076782,
0.1474769115447998,
-0.5175345540046692,
-0.5944972634315491,
-0.21942998468875885,
0.3629867732524872,
0.4638616442680359,
0.7024075984954834,
-0.7405552864074707,
0.06935607641935349,
-0.06721724569797516,
-0.6461416482925415,
-0.20865850150585175,
0.790708065032959,
-0.595878541469574,
0.2996618151664734,
0.42834779620170593,
0.6153168678283691,
0.3773488998413086,
0.02447342313826084,
0.9487651586532593,
-0.7658894658088684,
0.04252827912569046,
0.44529470801353455,
0.13022185862064362,
-0.007087494246661663,
-0.590972363948822,
0.507612943649292,
-0.09391968697309494,
-0.5959758758544922,
-0.48573365807533264,
0.5954362750053406,
-1.0320155620574951,
-0.017970068380236626,
1.2804864645004272,
0.3822132647037506,
-0.1689727008342743,
-0.17065779864788055,
-0.32893121242523193,
0.2883155345916748,
-0.5899329781532288,
0.718704879283905,
0.3427654802799225,
-0.34689831733703613,
0.16554200649261475,
-0.4671652615070343,
0.7420146465301514,
0.023893849924206734,
-1.1700108051300049,
0.05093139037489891,
0.5996063351631165,
-0.094805046916008,
0.18287277221679688,
1.0308464765548706,
-0.08857240527868271,
0.10262451320886612,
-0.320402592420578,
0.41596367955207825,
-0.5302257537841797,
-0.3748500347137451,
-0.09026560932397842,
0.07096070051193237,
0.3242565989494324,
0.1200326532125473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00794v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00794v2 | ReAGent: A Model-agnostic Feature Attribution Method for Generative Language Models | 2024-02-01T17:25:51 | 2024-02-07T21:01:16 | Zhixue Zhao, Boxuan Shan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Feature attribution methods (FAs), such as gradients and attention, are
widely employed approaches to derive the importance of all input features to
the model predictions. Existing work in natural language processing has mostly
focused on developing and testing FAs for encoder-only language models (LMs) in
classification tasks. However, it is unknown if it is faithful to use these FAs
for decoder-only models on text generation, due to the inherent differences
between model architectures and task settings respectively. Moreover, previous
work has demonstrated that there is no `one-wins-all' FA across models and
tasks. This makes the selection of a FA computationally expensive for large LMs
since input importance derivation often requires multiple forward and backward
passes including gradient computations that might be prohibitive even with
access to large compute. To address these issues, we present a model-agnostic
FA for generative LMs called Recursive Attribution Generator (ReAGent). Our
method updates the token importance distribution in a recursive manner. For
each update, we compute the difference in the probability distribution over the
vocabulary for predicting the next token between using the original input and
using a modified version where a part of the input is replaced with RoBERTa
predictions. Our intuition is that replacing an important token in the context
should have resulted in a larger change in the model's confidence in predicting
the token than replacing an unimportant token. Our method can be universally
applied to any generative LM without accessing internal model weights or
additional training and fine-tuning, as most other FAs require. We extensively
compare the faithfulness of ReAGent with seven popular FAs across six
decoder-only LMs of various sizes. The results show that our method
consistently provides more faithful token importance distributions. | [
-0.06219622865319252,
-0.589479923248291,
0.5072223544120789,
0.20082473754882812,
-0.24988636374473572,
-0.09681257605552673,
-0.08509364724159241,
-0.2177203893661499,
0.42478328943252563,
0.3092300295829773,
-0.6169716119766235,
-0.3787018954753876,
-0.6217426657676697,
0.10061433911323547,
-0.6474725604057312,
0.9281119704246521,
-0.16102653741836548,
-0.2116972953081131,
-0.29325586557388306,
-0.07073501497507095,
-0.09515101462602615,
-0.5337966680526733,
-0.8081144094467163,
-0.4580587148666382,
0.7257740497589111,
0.10459540039300919,
0.5383169651031494,
0.783827006816864,
0.3080984950065613,
0.2754251956939697,
-0.012210427783429623,
-0.07953452318906784,
-0.16991554200649261,
0.329403817653656,
-0.316610723733902,
-0.5880048871040344,
-0.44966554641723633,
0.18918460607528687,
0.6020865440368652,
0.3630979061126709,
-0.22963109612464905,
0.367872416973114,
-0.0026772096753120422,
0.4685496985912323,
-0.9854720830917358,
0.10606028139591217,
-0.9199590086936951,
0.17914360761642456,
-0.2988070845603943,
-0.3265211880207062,
-0.5186141729354858,
-0.5063766837120056,
-0.027885504066944122,
-0.45003634691238403,
0.8068758249282837,
-0.16593153774738312,
0.7436739802360535,
0.5201665759086609,
-0.1211555153131485,
-0.10536083579063416,
-0.5413478016853333,
1.0455284118652344,
-0.4399142563343048,
0.501330554485321,
0.30521178245544434,
0.14437296986579895,
-0.20495334267616272,
-0.6825079917907715,
-0.42714086174964905,
-0.2651628851890564,
0.11117202788591385,
-0.05398187041282654,
-0.29874372482299805,
-0.07893705368041992,
-0.03784864395856857,
0.6117550730705261,
-0.12618578970432281,
-0.1486085206270218,
0.14994321763515472,
-0.3130573332309723,
0.4455700218677521,
0.019463062286376953,
0.10706286132335663,
-0.14264096319675446,
-0.43021833896636963,
0.04285673424601555,
-0.8546622395515442,
-0.06536108255386353,
0.08172736316919327,
0.1447254717350006,
-0.04513468220829964,
0.49521657824516296,
0.21881189942359924,
0.686551034450531,
0.23119503259658813,
-0.024653606116771698,
0.43897703289985657,
-0.28574442863464355,
-0.1961917281150818,
-0.05334572494029999,
0.7879151701927185,
-0.058847568929195404,
0.3591771423816681,
-0.18916206061840057,
-0.5660186409950256,
0.0880490243434906,
0.4183528423309326,
-0.6297399997711182,
-0.29917511343955994,
0.08058509975671768,
-0.4555045962333679,
-0.8043361306190491,
-0.19006463885307312,
-0.7354280948638916,
-0.2410738319158554,
-0.0041673798114061356,
0.2070319652557373,
-0.3112300634384155,
-0.246337890625,
-0.21047702431678772,
-0.03818030282855034,
0.0751710757613182,
0.3307826519012451,
-1.0342535972595215,
-0.04081917926669121,
0.505125880241394,
0.9695022702217102,
-0.2827736735343933,
-0.26982444524765015,
-0.8047685027122498,
0.007202180568128824,
-0.32595333456993103,
0.7889498472213745,
-0.5308061838150024,
-0.22921088337898254,
-0.0012688415590673685,
-0.00574227562174201,
-0.05849486216902733,
-0.39816275238990784,
0.6153522729873657,
-0.42432713508605957,
-0.13981130719184875,
-0.03106910176575184,
-0.5472844839096069,
0.09080477058887482,
0.08869093656539917,
-0.8745941519737244,
0.8720729351043701,
0.32762202620506287,
-0.7024412155151367,
0.4119606018066406,
-0.7205734252929688,
-0.576561689376831,
-0.1524384617805481,
-0.33658427000045776,
-0.6556122899055481,
0.3358510732650757,
0.04533224180340767,
0.340922474861145,
-0.4901686906814575,
0.2642204761505127,
-0.07099343091249466,
-0.20359525084495544,
0.6451808214187622,
-0.9792540073394775,
0.6562116742134094,
0.21172375977039337,
-0.36130449175834656,
0.27620354294776917,
-0.8125377297401428,
0.12884488701820374,
0.22049829363822937,
-0.6306211352348328,
0.11078555136919022,
0.03586311265826225,
0.1352355182170868,
-0.14747847616672516,
0.18277551233768463,
-0.7313038110733032,
-0.07841383665800095,
-0.39054346084594727,
0.5912232995033264,
0.8168195486068726,
-0.1138300970196724,
0.40632104873657227,
-0.07763543725013733,
0.7413139939308167,
-0.1743106096982956,
0.016423318535089493,
-0.2233860045671463,
-0.6015381813049316,
-0.7396506071090698,
-0.4814886450767517,
0.4981551468372345,
0.4407750964164734,
-0.6325951218605042,
0.5882518291473389,
-0.322568416595459,
-0.3057957887649536,
-0.7676597833633423,
0.06387133151292801,
0.6239265203475952,
0.3612980842590332,
0.20307306945323944,
-0.29586464166641235,
-0.38981014490127563,
-0.999104380607605,
-0.33361074328422546,
-0.30738016963005066,
-0.2060796171426773,
-0.1075410321354866,
0.28566139936447144,
-0.22757117450237274,
1.1117808818817139,
-0.6615508794784546,
-0.21233786642551422,
-0.28931307792663574,
0.2425893396139145,
-0.10316222161054611,
0.38814079761505127,
0.5455881357192993,
-0.5927301645278931,
-0.40224748849868774,
-0.010725356638431549,
-0.46344301104545593,
-0.36938613653182983,
0.0790567398071289,
0.1295100748538971,
0.5024244785308838,
0.4128790497779846,
-0.6225999593734741,
0.6262755393981934,
0.5680354833602905,
-0.10805342346429825,
0.4523666203022003,
-0.14671717584133148,
0.1666884422302246,
-1.0040518045425415,
0.1818092316389084,
0.05835472047328949,
-0.4273283779621124,
-0.7539529204368591,
0.1588064432144165,
0.09372492879629135,
-0.08589325100183487,
-0.46621420979499817,
0.7132043838500977,
-0.23415423929691315,
-0.03342610225081444,
-0.3625735640525818,
-0.21182319521903992,
0.16514064371585846,
0.48057374358177185,
0.032648682594299316,
1.003182053565979,
0.5157681703567505,
-0.4539783000946045,
0.45117422938346863,
0.0073744370602071285,
-0.24090619385242462,
0.14282797276973724,
-0.619725227355957,
0.09407419711351395,
-0.009240799583494663,
0.046561576426029205,
-1.0689811706542969,
-0.014555834233760834,
0.43529778718948364,
-0.7806147336959839,
0.3940672278404236,
-0.17786642909049988,
-0.33491823077201843,
-0.03705485537648201,
-0.22468799352645874,
0.4233799874782562,
0.37589141726493835,
-0.5099759697914124,
1.0356850624084473,
0.10214245319366455,
-0.046983856707811356,
-0.5737337470054626,
-0.9844813346862793,
0.006277472712099552,
-0.26852595806121826,
-0.5643616318702698,
0.45385751128196716,
0.2840573489665985,
-0.10233884304761887,
0.09080930799245834,
-0.1973971277475357,
-0.13025949895381927,
0.25341811776161194,
0.145953968167305,
-0.08776067197322845,
-0.1481589823961258,
0.25540751218795776,
-0.14010022580623627,
-0.5853012204170227,
0.13044263422489166,
-0.060616012662649155,
0.3509368896484375,
0.06696849316358566,
-0.4740021824836731,
-0.33001673221588135,
0.46232330799102783,
0.6442776918411255,
-0.4712884724140167,
0.813880205154419,
0.7271623015403748,
-0.34715887904167175,
-0.1614091545343399,
-0.5519097447395325,
-0.2028869390487671,
-0.45025303959846497,
0.5770731568336487,
-0.47892341017723083,
-0.7372372150421143,
0.8278375864028931,
0.23655372858047485,
0.27079054713249207,
0.447731614112854,
0.4779704809188843,
0.30804017186164856,
0.6988638639450073,
0.6808260679244995,
-0.3101775348186493,
0.6648188829421997,
-0.029773889109492302,
0.2925416827201843,
-0.7241377830505371,
0.1460200846195221,
-0.4960770308971405,
-0.04034098982810974,
-0.17112843692302704,
-0.4832421541213989,
0.09737885743379593,
-0.13680684566497803,
-0.18777716159820557,
0.03454414755105972,
-0.4126710295677185,
0.325212299823761,
0.5246824026107788,
-0.0629686489701271,
0.267781525850296,
0.4740350544452667,
0.35148102045059204,
-0.1432618796825409,
-0.6120991110801697,
-0.22858084738254547,
1.2268822193145752,
0.4095678925514221,
0.8847759962081909,
0.4106307029724121,
0.685882031917572,
0.4330410957336426,
0.7941855192184448,
-0.8634382486343384,
0.35086676478385925,
-0.3168531060218811,
-0.491404265165329,
-0.373962938785553,
-0.3585992455482483,
-0.8419395685195923,
0.1891942024230957,
-0.12454727292060852,
-0.6494640707969666,
0.1835169494152069,
0.5075477957725525,
-0.32886630296707153,
0.2465946525335312,
-0.5896711349487305,
0.818034827709198,
0.11134985089302063,
-0.2968009114265442,
0.03448696434497833,
-0.36488696932792664,
0.17051661014556885,
-0.3466583788394928,
-0.1693546622991562,
0.24192021787166595,
-0.13366635143756866,
0.6598759293556213,
-0.4722927212715149,
0.9263696074485779,
-0.06881193816661835,
-0.4571760892868042,
0.4885287582874298,
0.2113066017627716,
0.7893669009208679,
-0.07190514355897903,
-0.21607163548469543,
0.032050181180238724,
-0.5905393362045288,
-0.055593717843294144,
-0.819203794002533,
0.7359350919723511,
-0.7474736571311951,
-0.9780546426773071,
-0.270272433757782,
-0.29349666833877563,
0.24260251224040985,
0.061305783689022064,
0.6066808104515076,
0.3769167959690094,
0.04403163492679596,
0.15949727594852448,
0.6653397679328918,
0.12337767332792282,
0.11017902940511703,
0.15576037764549255,
-0.10627523064613342,
-0.3833182752132416,
1.0502667427062988,
-0.1169552356004715,
0.6867311000823975,
0.26566922664642334,
0.22525547444820404,
-0.3632119596004486,
-0.5020939707756042,
-0.5862176418304443,
0.010494736954569817,
-1.0050296783447266,
-0.3730018734931946,
-0.7049152851104736,
-0.35663965344429016,
-0.2507816553115845,
-0.46081817150115967,
-0.721467137336731,
-0.2769433557987213,
-0.48062723875045776,
-0.1999930888414383,
0.7196674942970276,
0.283690869808197,
0.07882770895957947,
0.26489710807800293,
-0.6301997303962708,
0.21509455144405365,
0.3033561706542969,
0.29138949513435364,
0.2778821587562561,
-0.6679345965385437,
-0.1652107983827591,
0.032860562205314636,
-0.3922366499900818,
-0.9698097705841064,
0.3304528295993805,
0.35850989818573,
0.7072126269340515,
0.28214114904403687,
-0.2615154981613159,
0.4484938085079193,
-0.476267546415329,
0.7470535635948181,
0.2800014913082123,
-1.1007492542266846,
0.479776531457901,
-0.25072425603866577,
-0.026402121409773827,
0.46837571263313293,
-0.07463298738002777,
-0.3726416230201721,
-0.4482269585132599,
-0.6445010304450989,
-0.8964235782623291,
0.623734176158905,
0.4710642099380493,
0.050924237817525864,
-0.21352024376392365,
0.685085117816925,
-0.04467970132827759,
0.26516249775886536,
-0.7483695149421692,
-0.4865800440311432,
-0.5504186749458313,
-0.4304630160331726,
-0.17259196937084198,
-0.22539716958999634,
0.09470094740390778,
0.002177410526201129,
0.5010802149772644,
-0.10817182064056396,
0.49914315342903137,
0.2712605595588684,
0.07765068113803864,
-0.4131487011909485,
0.30785897374153137,
0.39086973667144775,
0.48308998346328735,
-0.20499002933502197,
0.17850080132484436,
0.07809564471244812,
-0.4930308163166046,
0.46028822660446167,
-0.017705177888274193,
-0.30894821882247925,
0.25431716442108154,
0.3615590035915375,
0.6646819710731506,
0.24062347412109375,
-0.2898845374584198,
0.5384480357170105,
0.2535046339035034,
-0.2031034231185913,
-0.46915334463119507,
0.12753435969352722,
0.1518101841211319,
0.04872296378016472,
0.3852398991584778,
0.1866929978132248,
0.12423212826251984,
-0.4341375529766083,
0.39153870940208435,
0.3683757483959198,
-0.5575169324874878,
-0.3017617166042328,
0.6615706086158752,
0.37512239813804626,
-0.38658955693244934,
0.46023598313331604,
-0.29339301586151123,
-0.5780672430992126,
0.6771862506866455,
0.674994170665741,
1.4368826150894165,
-0.6231803297996521,
0.170800119638443,
0.18634524941444397,
0.08068770170211792,
-0.05297083780169487,
0.07826531678438187,
0.2187717705965042,
-1.0691083669662476,
-0.4633961319923401,
-0.6792141795158386,
0.09083393216133118,
0.19679997861385345,
-0.4913848340511322,
0.05433686822652817,
-0.4320783317089081,
-0.4141812026500702,
0.07823888957500458,
-0.4572155475616455,
-0.395857572555542,
0.06481445580720901,
-0.1497960090637207,
0.6255546808242798,
-0.9411776065826416,
0.8002234101295471,
0.7123038172721863,
-0.3579319417476654,
-0.5552276968955994,
0.21699681878089905,
0.16767637431621552,
-0.6736617684364319,
0.8135305047035217,
-0.08765395730733871,
-0.46667394042015076,
0.2568798363208771,
-0.24184203147888184,
-1.040573000907898,
1.045415997505188,
0.3898475170135498,
-0.20992019772529602,
0.2374083548784256,
-0.050458356738090515,
0.3979399800300598,
-0.7078519463539124,
-0.11647957563400269,
0.35157305002212524,
0.2200292944908142,
0.2822273075580597,
-0.5417428016662598,
0.2453707903623581,
-0.1337973177433014,
0.1801176816225052,
0.514189600944519,
-0.3468334674835205,
1.0396552085876465,
-0.2252703160047531,
-0.4368904232978821,
0.22993627190589905,
0.8275104761123657,
0.5472226738929749,
-0.0777830109000206,
0.6274603009223938,
0.4225722551345825,
0.5727276802062988,
0.0958038792014122,
1.0489360094070435,
-0.14840185642242432,
0.5297784209251404,
0.9498327970504761,
-0.053378500044345856,
0.7019395232200623,
0.6193742752075195,
-0.3264489769935608,
0.32999348640441895,
0.4021129310131073,
0.012282043695449829,
0.6381241083145142,
0.44965291023254395,
-0.43273061513900757,
-0.3712807893753052,
-0.07003278285264969,
-0.18689709901809692,
0.14919070899486542,
0.2936916947364807,
-0.8107509613037109,
-0.32349693775177,
-0.23610003292560577,
0.08443451672792435,
-0.03130936622619629,
-0.23268768191337585,
0.35493576526641846,
0.08361410349607468,
-0.457202285528183,
0.7028397917747498,
0.18998855352401733,
0.8075319528579712,
-0.554220974445343,
-0.13033084571361542,
-0.15043509006500244,
0.36512285470962524,
-0.14333322644233704,
-0.7369075417518616,
0.39629724621772766,
0.16974490880966187,
-0.5628734230995178,
0.03372620418667793,
0.8082539439201355,
-0.3957957327365875,
-0.708716630935669,
0.07961468398571014,
0.3076837360858917,
0.037694089114665985,
-0.15308523178100586,
-0.6546844244003296,
0.018273063004016876,
0.46669459342956543,
-0.48075342178344727,
0.19801288843154907,
0.4902026057243347,
-0.16332127153873444,
1.0438878536224365,
0.6548677682876587,
0.06321226805448532,
0.001562590477988124,
0.27792268991470337,
0.7286393642425537,
-0.5856088995933533,
-0.3944845199584961,
-0.9098953604698181,
0.6204198598861694,
0.2368517816066742,
-0.24386084079742432,
0.5924918055534363,
0.15177124738693237,
0.36574459075927734,
-0.17987588047981262,
0.9537697434425354,
0.07044333219528198,
0.2181406170129776,
-0.5188803672790527,
0.6004547476768494,
-0.6574920415878296,
0.17182469367980957,
-0.13964775204658508,
-1.0437487363815308,
-0.293159157037735,
0.8254898190498352,
-0.023510504513978958,
0.061195891350507736,
0.5996096730232239,
0.681501567363739,
-0.022744419053196907,
-0.05710308998823166,
0.15313519537448883,
-0.08868399262428284,
0.6217571496963501,
0.4495028853416443,
0.4779947102069855,
-0.397372841835022,
0.34904372692108154,
0.20826782286167145,
-0.29425060749053955,
-0.24984407424926758,
-0.881392240524292,
-0.6149653196334839,
-0.5374740362167358,
-0.5245215892791748,
-0.20415379106998444,
0.060867827385663986,
0.9060623049736023,
0.22526133060455322,
-0.6270808577537537,
0.2195843905210495,
-0.3143112063407898,
-0.012234064750373363,
-0.14696864783763885,
-0.24326545000076294,
0.48970872163772583,
-0.3525198698043823,
-0.5685737133026123,
0.06011762470006943,
0.04857296869158745,
0.15119031071662903,
-0.5884281992912292,
0.0776192769408226,
-0.08441989123821259,
-0.059698719531297684,
0.46046918630599976,
0.09922347217798233,
-1.0923150777816772,
-0.6117480397224426,
-0.1733405590057373,
-0.03444705903530121,
0.014486321248114109,
0.9757147431373596,
-0.6849584579467773,
0.19294153153896332,
0.4864317774772644,
0.7133670449256897,
0.11568330228328705,
0.04142476245760918,
0.8973339796066284,
-0.9762019515037537,
0.1299080103635788,
-0.058905620127916336,
0.4453926384449005,
0.42506495118141174,
-0.5235843658447266,
0.40073421597480774,
0.28121691942214966,
-0.45706066489219666,
-0.6151977777481079,
0.5396109223365784,
-0.5782210230827332,
-0.06833626329898834,
1.1983083486557007,
-0.5167480707168579,
-0.5098788738250732,
-0.22162123024463654,
0.2226148247718811,
0.29764875769615173,
-0.6337760090827942,
0.5963435173034668,
0.6444380283355713,
0.16155703365802765,
-0.3181927800178528,
-0.19145312905311584,
0.6513423323631287,
0.5472269058227539,
-0.26098644733428955,
0.6477781534194946,
0.3161374032497406,
0.4398992955684662,
0.5610649585723877,
0.6771382093429565,
-0.18025381863117218,
0.12933306396007538,
-0.06991628557443619,
0.5460399985313416,
-0.23012688755989075,
-0.3595800995826721,
-0.32398223876953125,
-0.014946556650102139,
0.22310760617256165,
-0.2783524692058563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00786v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00786v4 | CroissantLLM: A Truly Bilingual French-English Language Model | 2024-02-01T17:17:55 | 2024-03-29T14:56:42 | Manuel Faysse, Patrick Fernandes, Nuno M. Guerreiro, António Loison, Duarte M. Alves, Caio Corro, Nicolas Boizard, João Alves, Ricardo Rei, Pedro H. Martins, Antoni Bigata Casademunt, François Yvon, André F. T. Martins, Gautier Viaud, Céline Hudelot, Pierre Colombo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We introduce CroissantLLM, a 1.3B language model pretrained on a set of 3T
English and French tokens, to bring to the research and industrial community a
high-performance, fully open-sourced bilingual model that runs swiftly on
consumer-grade local hardware. To that end, we pioneer the approach of training
an intrinsically bilingual model with a 1:1 English-to-French pretraining data
ratio, a custom tokenizer, and bilingual finetuning datasets. We release the
training dataset, notably containing a French split with manually curated,
high-quality, and varied data sources. To assess performance outside of
English, we craft a novel benchmark, FrenchBench, consisting of an array of
classification and generation tasks, covering various orthogonal aspects of
model performance in the French Language. Additionally, rooted in transparency
and to foster further Large Language Model research, we release codebases, and
dozens of checkpoints across various model sizes, training data distributions,
and training steps, as well as fine-tuned Chat models, and strong translation
models. We evaluate our model through the FMTI framework, and validate 81 % of
the transparency criteria, far beyond the scores of even most open initiatives.
This work enriches the NLP landscape, breaking away from previous
English-centric work in order to strengthen our understanding of
multilinguality in language models. | [
-0.05708328261971474,
-0.5272677540779114,
0.1558021903038025,
0.8545069694519043,
0.01894477754831314,
0.12845823168754578,
-0.6528298854827881,
-0.7047950029373169,
-0.13970209658145905,
0.7971554398536682,
-0.2703103721141815,
-0.449603408575058,
-0.8189221024513245,
0.1673458218574524,
-0.5587509274482727,
0.75604647397995,
-0.11765125393867493,
0.5017550587654114,
-0.06348968297243118,
-0.23922327160835266,
-0.33327990770339966,
-0.8319324254989624,
-0.6776213049888611,
-0.4791684150695801,
0.5016842484474182,
0.15202301740646362,
0.5035644769668579,
0.6635121703147888,
0.10835497081279755,
0.18665741384029388,
0.12282387912273407,
-0.024833694100379944,
-0.542148768901825,
-0.3523249924182892,
-0.14568251371383667,
-0.8675796985626221,
-0.5033200979232788,
0.07559938728809357,
0.46952739357948303,
0.7655728459358215,
-0.1621972620487213,
0.1229550912976265,
0.2491532564163208,
0.6185871958732605,
-0.4440072178840637,
0.2853076756000519,
-0.6601607203483582,
0.13752534985542297,
-0.27675604820251465,
-0.025875309482216835,
-0.5893552899360657,
-0.2991761267185211,
-0.047476112842559814,
-0.3095945417881012,
0.23839986324310303,
-0.1814815253019333,
0.8054311871528625,
-0.15661334991455078,
-0.5291036367416382,
-0.028598707169294357,
-0.9476025104522705,
1.062682032585144,
-0.5520797371864319,
1.0855611562728882,
0.5447661280632019,
0.27479982376098633,
0.23855699598789215,
-0.9062188863754272,
-0.32210177183151245,
-0.05081905797123909,
0.16003963351249695,
0.12137087434530258,
0.12872791290283203,
-0.3706408441066742,
-0.23856692016124725,
0.4971523582935333,
-0.9048325419425964,
-0.12278444319963455,
-0.3433590829372406,
-0.10435376316308975,
0.5239574313163757,
0.05936271324753761,
0.4202285706996918,
0.4608473479747772,
-0.4918513596057892,
0.047274891287088394,
-0.5291880965232849,
0.1441224068403244,
0.44839558005332947,
0.41796875,
-0.38765576481819153,
0.5154294371604919,
-0.027198201045393944,
0.42645299434661865,
-0.48007121682167053,
0.06503569334745407,
0.3750203549861908,
-0.4022866189479828,
-0.15513163805007935,
0.02276233397424221,
0.9185227155685425,
0.17201553285121918,
0.6243915557861328,
-0.353429913520813,
-0.2959215044975281,
0.0894007757306099,
0.020270245149731636,
-0.8799318075180054,
-0.40181103348731995,
0.23997355997562408,
-0.07711228728294373,
-0.0895257294178009,
-0.15340319275856018,
-0.4482949376106262,
0.3090049922466278,
-0.476220041513443,
0.15175798535346985,
-0.523449182510376,
-0.6428607702255249,
0.44740548729896545,
0.0702405497431755,
0.13336534798145294,
0.3166065216064453,
-0.9416623115539551,
0.49831652641296387,
0.8414952158927917,
0.7450612187385559,
-0.49214521050453186,
-0.601294994354248,
-0.24869947135448456,
0.14682039618492126,
-0.23986871540546417,
0.5090936422348022,
-0.6137766242027283,
-0.566078782081604,
0.24040070176124573,
0.3425152003765106,
-0.4025593101978302,
-0.5632818341255188,
0.6188697218894958,
-0.39270880818367004,
0.3115033805370331,
0.000005088894795335364,
-0.36346036195755005,
-0.24664632976055145,
0.4981254041194916,
-0.7044045925140381,
1.1666289567947388,
0.12928378582000732,
-0.6333581805229187,
0.2029263973236084,
-0.43230292201042175,
-0.5446375608444214,
0.08951666206121445,
-0.20793895423412323,
-0.0026429584249854088,
-0.06843949854373932,
0.3090307116508484,
0.12582194805145264,
-0.5242853164672852,
0.10912565886974335,
-0.014885173179209232,
0.14116553962230682,
0.04970664530992508,
-0.4309324622154236,
1.0505214929580688,
-0.019622595980763435,
-0.32793888449668884,
-0.13589584827423096,
-0.5567505955696106,
0.1949654519557953,
0.2510116696357727,
-0.32865869998931885,
-0.0011472764890640974,
-0.2013217657804489,
0.6040692925453186,
0.16552196443080902,
0.5049196481704712,
-0.6581079959869385,
-0.3406117856502533,
-0.5359893441200256,
0.5822845697402954,
0.4928760230541229,
-0.5170775055885315,
0.5081593990325928,
-0.26942554116249084,
0.5193987488746643,
0.08705895394086838,
0.36469781398773193,
-0.3474004864692688,
-0.58659827709198,
-0.5961049795150757,
-0.6967554688453674,
0.6589463353157043,
0.8894675374031067,
-0.0986490473151207,
0.23504120111465454,
-0.2404194474220276,
-0.45849159359931946,
-0.4269891083240509,
0.41655242443084717,
0.2792450487613678,
0.4081309139728546,
0.4119451940059662,
-0.22356806695461273,
0.0013528406852856278,
-1.1318621635437012,
-0.5640780329704285,
0.06771902740001678,
0.1825477033853531,
-0.01290959119796753,
0.1988096386194229,
-0.2977162003517151,
0.7212112545967102,
-0.1034683883190155,
-0.25818154215812683,
-0.6524569988250732,
0.21932409703731537,
0.1166028156876564,
0.6524273753166199,
0.7231282591819763,
-0.7030481100082397,
-0.7092536687850952,
0.3320173919200897,
-0.6131014823913574,
0.03040076233446598,
0.39778682589530945,
-0.2606768012046814,
0.346017450094223,
0.3134545385837555,
-0.6820892691612244,
0.3186182379722595,
0.6508412957191467,
0.1007731556892395,
0.4277631342411041,
-0.0013565006665885448,
0.30714184045791626,
-1.094972848892212,
-0.16127796471118927,
-0.03292349725961685,
-0.5363301634788513,
-0.4420352578163147,
0.13191534578800201,
0.3107720911502838,
-0.21446435153484344,
-0.712558388710022,
0.8051760196685791,
-0.40846195816993713,
0.3034220337867737,
-0.054795410484075546,
0.06320095807313919,
0.3140227198600769,
0.48768341541290283,
0.2956465482711792,
0.4593240022659302,
0.576433002948761,
-0.2682212293148041,
0.10324622690677643,
0.025426557287573814,
-0.2152237743139267,
0.3320613503456116,
-0.696303129196167,
-0.11000573635101318,
0.16741731762886047,
0.15078800916671753,
-0.7374058961868286,
-0.08503424376249313,
-0.12355099618434906,
-0.3785739839076996,
0.2488812804222107,
-0.23012854158878326,
-0.6480084657669067,
-0.14399586617946625,
-0.1477336436510086,
0.796532154083252,
0.34365737438201904,
-0.7119084596633911,
0.898872435092926,
0.2720218598842621,
-0.3434676229953766,
-0.43996405601501465,
-1.0653539896011353,
-0.047452833503484726,
0.21579578518867493,
-0.9155656695365906,
0.08776340633630753,
-0.11601914465427399,
0.00589353684335947,
-0.04339001327753067,
-0.04794863238930702,
-0.45581918954849243,
-0.04711086302995682,
0.09902497380971909,
0.12443331629037857,
-0.5443106889724731,
-0.21893605589866638,
-0.00932407658547163,
-0.11524917930364609,
0.12641145288944244,
-0.3564791679382324,
0.7011849880218506,
-0.19077551364898682,
-0.3833135664463043,
-0.5859165191650391,
0.324155330657959,
0.5134774446487427,
-0.8103408217430115,
0.7496275901794434,
0.5707963109016418,
-0.8043357133865356,
-0.5279930830001831,
-0.5789644122123718,
-0.018983272835612297,
-0.4052259922027588,
0.35254132747650146,
-0.3688657283782959,
-0.9124270677566528,
0.5381177067756653,
0.10422898828983307,
0.3343663215637207,
0.16349385678768158,
0.7782381176948547,
0.3727564811706543,
1.1629948616027832,
0.635869026184082,
-0.009986053220927715,
0.19270329177379608,
-0.23365212976932526,
0.5775349736213684,
-0.28445446491241455,
-0.315783828496933,
-0.6767942905426025,
0.055416904389858246,
-0.24180643260478973,
-0.5360091328620911,
-0.04236980900168419,
0.43140295147895813,
0.07785787433385849,
0.5258377194404602,
-0.326339989900589,
0.6183017492294312,
0.2645370066165924,
-0.13694323599338531,
0.5470315217971802,
0.07133249938488007,
-0.3138701319694519,
-0.1881464123725891,
-0.7047569155693054,
-0.6791005730628967,
1.0860652923583984,
0.39708754420280457,
0.6094872355461121,
0.04445762187242508,
0.5373868346214294,
-0.0012211310677230358,
0.428417444229126,
-0.4570360481739044,
0.34453409910202026,
-0.08730410784482956,
-0.6599557399749756,
0.02465476095676422,
-0.6186210513114929,
-0.7602251172065735,
0.2935393452644348,
-0.008944965898990631,
-0.6500582695007324,
-0.1658623069524765,
0.20563898980617523,
0.010781528428196907,
0.31721168756484985,
-0.8742966055870056,
1.2537685632705688,
-0.6676797270774841,
-0.4956592321395874,
-0.3169170022010803,
-0.1300414353609085,
0.5788209438323975,
-0.23687449097633362,
0.4351092278957367,
-0.39825963973999023,
-0.06516459584236145,
0.3392174243927002,
-0.2861437499523163,
0.5556643009185791,
0.13515813648700714,
-0.07114804536104202,
-0.0727580338716507,
0.5686690211296082,
0.28392523527145386,
0.4154439866542816,
-0.03883032500743866,
0.9002477526664734,
0.3222014605998993,
-0.6571865677833557,
-0.3455047309398651,
1.0790846347808838,
-0.8095768094062805,
-0.22202889621257782,
-0.3558036983013153,
-0.5632809996604919,
-0.3401930332183838,
0.27550581097602844,
0.3219020366668701,
0.5497639179229736,
-0.5266718864440918,
0.10765869170427322,
0.3525278568267822,
-0.14728394150733948,
0.3263387084007263,
0.5986643433570862,
-0.5013940930366516,
-0.4289982318878174,
0.9172042012214661,
-0.09523496776819229,
0.24874718487262726,
0.491177499294281,
0.007855260744690895,
-0.426413893699646,
-0.36199280619621277,
-0.5623183846473694,
0.4376484453678131,
-0.41097044944763184,
0.1569584757089615,
-1.114988923072815,
-0.4015962481498718,
-0.5198381543159485,
-0.2211254984140396,
-0.9598261117935181,
-0.6419835090637207,
-0.0606025792658329,
-0.07217101007699966,
-0.011583668179810047,
0.5637437701225281,
0.23112303018569946,
0.07571935653686523,
-1.0564395189285278,
0.09888887405395508,
0.1631617248058319,
0.31079575419425964,
-0.15775509178638458,
-0.3640314042568207,
-0.46037808060646057,
0.2553071081638336,
-0.26278290152549744,
-0.37747350335121155,
0.41444751620292664,
0.11624757200479507,
0.5967870354652405,
0.158514603972435,
-0.26675349473953247,
0.1890423595905304,
-0.7562745809555054,
1.0786583423614502,
0.22212223708629608,
-0.7515645027160645,
0.1897679567337036,
-0.30398938059806824,
0.2777332663536072,
0.5916653871536255,
0.6180256009101868,
-0.36525633931159973,
-0.5487430095672607,
-0.326437383890152,
-0.9433426260948181,
0.6735118627548218,
0.37419310212135315,
0.278033584356308,
-0.23317904770374298,
-0.05894525721669197,
0.29296591877937317,
0.32562199234962463,
-0.9445098638534546,
0.044301312416791916,
-0.4686752259731293,
-0.3676229417324066,
-0.18798695504665375,
0.04979060962796211,
-0.3308161199092865,
-0.3806825876235962,
0.9042723178863525,
0.08402150124311447,
-0.03207142651081085,
0.006989560555666685,
-0.5234501957893372,
-0.07618808001279831,
0.0016271925996989012,
0.6099594235420227,
0.9992087483406067,
-0.05616064369678497,
0.06983868032693863,
-0.07185708731412888,
-0.3491402864456177,
-0.10879415273666382,
0.16292144358158112,
0.22281838953495026,
0.007508192677050829,
0.5306580066680908,
0.4776706397533417,
0.08619753271341324,
-0.8072435855865479,
0.7851530313491821,
-0.38754886388778687,
-0.3241749107837677,
-0.5163487792015076,
0.001270103151910007,
0.4825761318206787,
0.2094685435295105,
0.08237025886774063,
-0.03618063032627106,
-0.25181227922439575,
-0.46464255452156067,
0.15904179215431213,
0.41670122742652893,
-0.5321297645568848,
-0.7273146510124207,
0.9410352110862732,
0.40285414457321167,
-0.6171513199806213,
0.29020002484321594,
0.07117892801761627,
-0.6555118560791016,
0.3874661326408386,
0.4365016520023346,
1.0720559358596802,
-0.5198280811309814,
0.19130803644657135,
0.47164997458457947,
0.8535022735595703,
-0.5011754035949707,
0.16021625697612762,
0.013702490366995335,
-0.75762540102005,
-0.20200009644031525,
-0.8155645728111267,
-0.17794595658779144,
0.2260877788066864,
-0.6329939961433411,
0.3008204698562622,
-0.4733702838420868,
0.012524518184363842,
-0.20213618874549866,
-0.40009215474128723,
-0.763373851776123,
0.13068385422229767,
-0.14526163041591644,
1.2805310487747192,
-0.858328104019165,
0.8632386326789856,
0.5096005797386169,
-0.15585537254810333,
-0.4873068630695343,
-0.10406605154275894,
-0.13206109404563904,
-0.6500189900398254,
0.5187031030654907,
0.25549930334091187,
-0.16462986171245575,
-0.09798631072044373,
-0.18289530277252197,
-0.38471463322639465,
0.7844069004058838,
0.5965992212295532,
-0.574658215045929,
0.2546030580997467,
0.7555692195892334,
0.4147945046424866,
-0.5450524091720581,
0.28598737716674805,
0.5250431299209595,
0.33934006094932556,
-0.37482017278671265,
-0.9536364078521729,
-0.42403849959373474,
-0.40766698122024536,
-0.1395900845527649,
0.3001200258731842,
-0.7163213491439819,
0.9363197088241577,
0.33014360070228577,
-0.14811398088932037,
0.06550667434930801,
0.4938971996307373,
-0.18010850250720978,
0.10887549072504044,
0.4157359004020691,
0.8015186190605164,
0.36243781447410583,
-0.28589385747909546,
1.1148548126220703,
-0.9877108931541443,
0.18934261798858643,
1.3130671977996826,
-0.7061089873313904,
0.8937325477600098,
0.37751996517181396,
0.15949392318725586,
0.20471541583538055,
0.5477376580238342,
0.554816722869873,
0.2921602427959442,
-0.23190173506736755,
-0.424874871969223,
-0.527958333492279,
-0.06413649022579193,
-0.404191792011261,
0.1379496455192566,
0.19406037032604218,
-0.21624958515167236,
-0.3924940824508667,
0.10924722999334335,
0.005493910983204842,
0.4209076464176178,
0.09257887303829193,
0.34959426522254944,
0.24129097163677216,
-0.4223378002643585,
0.6933078169822693,
0.22950921952724457,
0.3824244439601898,
-0.8507254123687744,
0.05388960242271423,
-0.33533334732055664,
0.342593252658844,
-0.08891835808753967,
-0.4716673195362091,
0.11480798572301865,
-0.0492195263504982,
-0.15548157691955566,
-0.31363192200660706,
0.18194933235645294,
-0.8922165632247925,
-0.8029342293739319,
0.8785818815231323,
0.5889130234718323,
-0.22835773229599,
-0.07194708287715912,
-0.9051610827445984,
0.3051171898841858,
-0.051744721829891205,
-0.347154438495636,
0.19555610418319702,
0.5291097164154053,
-0.07383468747138977,
0.5208104252815247,
0.6168925166130066,
0.1830253154039383,
0.3615421950817108,
0.28313854336738586,
0.5909838080406189,
-0.43041083216667175,
-0.5668011903762817,
-0.5912261605262756,
0.44449475407600403,
0.049792010337114334,
-0.4605993330478668,
0.7926924228668213,
1.2103790044784546,
1.2740199565887451,
-0.03991350531578064,
0.850974977016449,
0.4224340319633484,
0.6375200748443604,
-0.36388880014419556,
0.5874097943305969,
-0.7405566573143005,
0.16907773911952972,
0.2154490053653717,
-1.183849573135376,
-0.2332155406475067,
0.3721660077571869,
-0.1552623063325882,
0.07469349354505539,
0.8722714185714722,
1.2346566915512085,
-0.6280397176742554,
0.389702707529068,
0.3303493857383728,
0.3780392110347748,
0.25364968180656433,
0.4650067389011383,
0.6984400153160095,
-0.40117529034614563,
0.4456441402435303,
-0.3736422657966614,
-0.3628164231777191,
0.01723691262304783,
-0.7309088110923767,
-1.293579339981079,
-0.41954922676086426,
-0.2958572208881378,
-0.2932589650154114,
0.0738944411277771,
1.0101819038391113,
0.81760573387146,
-0.853202760219574,
-0.6864235997200012,
-0.037024859338998795,
-0.16175900399684906,
-0.14564692974090576,
-0.2530580461025238,
-0.11798027157783508,
-0.41440507769584656,
-0.932899534702301,
0.5410085320472717,
0.5803634524345398,
-0.19109806418418884,
-0.27856990694999695,
-0.2469128519296646,
-0.223600834608078,
0.4714791476726532,
0.7470313906669617,
0.3220590651035309,
-0.521268367767334,
0.1822212189435959,
-0.0217752605676651,
-0.379818856716156,
0.1074976995587349,
0.8771864771842957,
-0.1750614047050476,
0.35114505887031555,
0.4906734526157379,
0.7862598896026611,
0.8464682102203369,
-0.4116103947162628,
0.8093104362487793,
-0.5774161219596863,
0.5892979502677917,
0.3086877763271332,
0.36899277567863464,
0.44429248571395874,
-0.03645859658718109,
0.45349565148353577,
0.21755294501781464,
-0.40633466839790344,
-1.0760043859481812,
0.19634151458740234,
-0.9226301312446594,
-0.14369630813598633,
0.9155100584030151,
-0.10122962296009064,
-0.5667404532432556,
0.025227325037121773,
0.01171575952321291,
-0.10380882024765015,
-0.21270711719989777,
0.42565494775772095,
0.7251131534576416,
0.1449609398841858,
-0.23007264733314514,
-0.9091088771820068,
0.4339185357093811,
0.5711240172386169,
-0.6292064189910889,
0.20531336963176727,
0.07009195536375046,
0.5701077580451965,
-0.07465825974941254,
0.6703699827194214,
-0.5392938852310181,
0.17679353058338165,
-0.3969210684299469,
0.38542798161506653,
-0.003670389298349619,
-0.6362060308456421,
-0.09040168672800064,
0.11929880827665329,
0.12694603204727173,
0.020625848323106766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00746v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00746v6 | Health-LLM: Personalized Retrieval-Augmented Disease Prediction System | 2024-02-01T16:40:32 | 2024-03-19T22:12:19 | Mingyu Jin, Qinkai Yu, Dong Shu, Chong Zhang, Lizhou Fan, Wenyue Hua, Suiyuan Zhu, Yanda Meng, Zhenting Wang, Mengnan Du, Yongfeng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in artificial intelligence (AI), especially large
language models (LLMs), have significantly advanced healthcare applications and
demonstrated potentials in intelligent medical treatment. However, there are
conspicuous challenges such as vast data volumes and inconsistent symptom
characterization standards, preventing full integration of healthcare AI
systems with individual patients' needs. To promote professional and
personalized healthcare, we propose an innovative framework, Heath-LLM, which
combines large-scale feature extraction and medical knowledge trade-off
scoring. Compared to traditional health management applications, our system has
three main advantages: (1) It integrates health reports and medical knowledge
into a large model to ask relevant questions to large language model for
disease prediction; (2) It leverages a retrieval augmented generation (RAG)
mechanism to enhance feature extraction; (3) It incorporates a semi-automated
feature updating framework that can merge and delete features to improve
accuracy of disease prediction. We experiment on a large number of health
reports to assess the effectiveness of Health-LLM system. The results indicate
that the proposed system surpasses the existing ones and has the potential to
significantly advance disease prediction and personalized health management.
The code is available at https://github.com/jmyissb/HealthLLM. | [
-0.06541264057159424,
-0.676776647567749,
0.7089553475379944,
-0.17693467438220978,
-0.21778832376003265,
0.2546200156211853,
-0.0968613401055336,
-0.7101048827171326,
0.8416987657546997,
0.7194498181343079,
-0.1447324901819229,
-0.6422110199928284,
-0.5872973203659058,
-0.0045335483737289906,
-0.18575088679790497,
0.9811137318611145,
0.2576139271259308,
0.40384241938591003,
-0.4126662015914917,
-0.09072340279817581,
-0.2785033583641052,
-0.6278427839279175,
-0.4780825972557068,
-0.5948703289031982,
0.6669072508811951,
0.3583003580570221,
0.6492783427238464,
0.725634753704071,
0.9338347911834717,
0.21247020363807678,
-0.04410730302333832,
0.221954345703125,
-0.08777568489313126,
0.4081519842147827,
-0.16225820779800415,
-0.359560489654541,
-0.8007627725601196,
-0.26627254486083984,
0.3294360041618347,
0.6213300228118896,
-0.16193963587284088,
0.2518235743045807,
-0.11558002978563309,
0.8539318442344666,
-0.37792065739631653,
0.2157372683286667,
-0.35930192470550537,
0.20775951445102692,
-0.40121519565582275,
-0.46649906039237976,
-0.017614319920539856,
-0.265987753868103,
0.24588990211486816,
-0.21776489913463593,
-0.29507574439048767,
0.18042123317718506,
0.516352653503418,
0.4516569972038269,
-0.33837154507637024,
-0.04441452398896217,
-0.5258215069770813,
0.532079815864563,
-0.5907023549079895,
0.3521803915500641,
0.3224877417087555,
0.5688591003417969,
-0.1511845588684082,
-0.7597092986106873,
-0.08211570233106613,
-0.29365459084510803,
0.02278805524110794,
0.3033342957496643,
0.009406491182744503,
0.05614624544978142,
-0.09515638649463654,
0.4807378947734833,
-0.6434510946273804,
0.27888911962509155,
-0.19486954808235168,
-0.12283623218536377,
0.8284876346588135,
0.3635677695274353,
0.38553544878959656,
-0.37899595499038696,
-0.3920687139034271,
0.3828497529029846,
-0.7819218635559082,
-0.2475985437631607,
-0.357372909784317,
0.27254727482795715,
-0.0689394474029541,
0.5813822746276855,
-0.3273642659187317,
0.44465067982673645,
-0.029341189190745354,
-0.5562435388565063,
0.5110520720481873,
0.14946675300598145,
-0.40373677015304565,
0.14277416467666626,
0.6450076103210449,
0.18965961039066315,
-0.2871604263782501,
-0.29871153831481934,
-0.18422511219978333,
-0.218547984957695,
0.20093469321727753,
-0.7412012815475464,
-0.2324017435312271,
0.48711785674095154,
-0.7271763682365417,
-0.45260387659072876,
-0.2399750053882599,
-0.7437190413475037,
-0.8201521039009094,
-0.1444455236196518,
0.3356209993362427,
-0.390227347612381,
-0.019688669592142105,
0.07294437289237976,
0.1469801366329193,
-0.1991991400718689,
0.4149426221847534,
-0.5775060057640076,
0.20402877032756805,
0.5774012207984924,
0.6329860687255859,
-0.6070518493652344,
0.16517888009548187,
-0.7164881825447083,
0.39097097516059875,
-0.054607875645160675,
0.6500722169876099,
-0.6095739603042603,
-0.3911101222038269,
-0.1266055703163147,
-0.18681550025939941,
0.18798451125621796,
-0.9657462239265442,
0.32735082507133484,
-0.5919326543807983,
0.09291310608386993,
-0.07500751316547394,
-0.6099064946174622,
-0.14016853272914886,
0.5516289472579956,
-0.7346270680427551,
0.6859151124954224,
0.30146828293800354,
-0.7377709150314331,
0.1560593992471695,
-0.6754876971244812,
-0.4799762964248657,
0.6574085354804993,
-0.269322007894516,
-0.5323050618171692,
-0.007944181561470032,
0.09645035862922668,
0.5791134238243103,
-0.6975371837615967,
0.3567197322845459,
-0.44252195954322815,
-0.4088163673877716,
0.1265179067850113,
-0.010577861219644547,
0.34926527738571167,
0.3417329788208008,
-0.14575935900211334,
0.25967875123023987,
-0.7743862271308899,
0.06189003214240074,
0.18358492851257324,
-0.5733661651611328,
-0.385306179523468,
0.08484210073947906,
-0.20809069275856018,
-0.07200402766466141,
0.5997596383094788,
-0.23277679085731506,
0.18009904026985168,
-0.6006699204444885,
0.2593575716018677,
0.4493967890739441,
0.10406151413917542,
0.37247973680496216,
-0.6897395849227905,
0.6393600702285767,
0.11422204971313477,
0.2961113452911377,
-0.10170092433691025,
-0.6437338590621948,
-0.15800726413726807,
-0.39562085270881653,
0.401618093252182,
0.9074205756187439,
-0.47626835107803345,
0.7144467234611511,
-0.2563874125480652,
-0.20213808119297028,
-0.3651053309440613,
0.10340101271867752,
0.1805696338415146,
0.5911279320716858,
0.5044664740562439,
-0.2605295777320862,
-0.5121555924415588,
-0.6051667928695679,
-0.2095746248960495,
-0.1860262006521225,
-0.124779611825943,
0.511381983757019,
0.2757118046283722,
-0.7495120167732239,
0.6071093678474426,
-0.5597707033157349,
-0.4761340320110321,
-0.38957321643829346,
-0.38975462317466736,
0.2523048520088196,
0.35248634219169617,
0.20714937150478363,
-0.9710801243782043,
-0.35700616240501404,
0.20356933772563934,
-0.7878866195678711,
-0.06548750400543213,
0.4779922664165497,
-0.01318739727139473,
-0.2142648994922638,
0.10511372983455658,
-0.4046606421470642,
0.44545939564704895,
0.5256361365318298,
-0.14429983496665955,
0.4213767945766449,
-0.3737735152244568,
0.08008028566837311,
-1.3659230470657349,
0.2708617150783539,
-0.06449756026268005,
-0.4778965413570404,
-0.3953692615032196,
0.14392994344234467,
-0.14504405856132507,
-0.09498900920152664,
-0.24791733920574188,
0.9234747290611267,
-0.03685186430811882,
0.02683371864259243,
-0.24727146327495575,
-0.17156612873077393,
-0.03362857922911644,
0.01567758247256279,
-0.2588372826576233,
0.32241714000701904,
0.36391815543174744,
-0.47230619192123413,
0.5533924698829651,
0.1950652003288269,
-0.3123568594455719,
0.5072919726371765,
-0.4708925187587738,
0.06499169766902924,
-0.005144213326275349,
0.05076126754283905,
-0.3508121967315674,
-0.6705700159072876,
0.23575009405612946,
-0.4241822361946106,
0.357456237077713,
0.23406414687633514,
-0.39225679636001587,
-0.5526329278945923,
-0.31637775897979736,
0.17606382071971893,
0.7097324728965759,
-0.43504929542541504,
0.6065481305122375,
0.9157497882843018,
-0.25578436255455017,
-0.36947184801101685,
-0.6947376132011414,
0.1607309728860855,
-0.3057398200035095,
-0.40256303548812866,
0.6383993029594421,
-0.1405722051858902,
-0.36918574571609497,
0.20350685715675354,
0.051366254687309265,
0.006534120999276638,
0.17998449504375458,
0.37100037932395935,
0.3794955313205719,
0.05688484385609627,
0.36729151010513306,
0.06881250441074371,
0.00828212033957243,
-0.0985870212316513,
-0.21205437183380127,
0.3433644473552704,
0.15825557708740234,
-0.46033036708831787,
-0.4515911936759949,
0.3032850921154022,
0.6667795777320862,
-0.26311400532722473,
0.4284105598926544,
0.36690375208854675,
-0.6463084816932678,
0.1472712606191635,
-0.5573412775993347,
-0.16140873730182648,
-0.38420912623405457,
0.5875694155693054,
-0.07277975231409073,
-0.9652206301689148,
0.4973434805870056,
-0.4756733179092407,
-0.10546216368675232,
0.33319583535194397,
0.6871258020401001,
-0.29932963848114014,
1.279855489730835,
0.567525327205658,
-0.28652799129486084,
0.1632843315601349,
-0.01237080805003643,
0.001397373853251338,
-0.832737386226654,
-0.5608346462249756,
-0.3410862684249878,
-0.3574051260948181,
-0.6396014094352722,
-0.4036806523799896,
0.8622644543647766,
0.032031115144491196,
-0.41047418117523193,
-0.18916672468185425,
-0.6198095083236694,
-0.13266286253929138,
0.38534143567085266,
0.5283443927764893,
0.39337795972824097,
-0.17284239828586578,
-0.2833966910839081,
0.01596122607588768,
-0.43644359707832336,
-0.30907490849494934,
1.0987920761108398,
0.43985703587532043,
0.7798779010772705,
0.11196637153625488,
1.0414899587631226,
0.7002626061439514,
0.4934151768684387,
-0.9395943284034729,
0.243547260761261,
-0.6238664984703064,
-0.4738692045211792,
-0.17417602241039276,
-0.5066301226615906,
-0.8661564588546753,
-0.20520108938217163,
-0.4471224546432495,
-0.6772700548171997,
-0.1270323395729065,
0.2620658278465271,
-0.6263233423233032,
0.25809720158576965,
-0.49152520298957825,
0.4566637873649597,
-0.47635912895202637,
-0.21406590938568115,
-0.23548062145709991,
-0.6630433201789856,
0.22286760807037354,
-0.20216317474842072,
0.4570523202419281,
-0.27437055110931396,
-0.12063024938106537,
0.6718900203704834,
-0.40786561369895935,
0.5963266491889954,
-0.07074407488107681,
0.25638559460639954,
-0.09075994044542313,
-0.04890240356326103,
0.3656923472881317,
0.2502846121788025,
-0.3375561535358429,
-0.09360689669847488,
0.07855134457349777,
-0.21555274724960327,
-0.47903454303741455,
0.7466749548912048,
-0.5040547251701355,
-0.6905717253684998,
-0.4567479193210602,
-0.5964789986610413,
-0.46828821301460266,
0.45378202199935913,
-0.03073362074792385,
0.33493420481681824,
-0.2088053822517395,
-0.008791053667664528,
0.5302718877792358,
-0.45634105801582336,
-0.04886070638895035,
0.3691551387310028,
-0.5215545296669006,
-0.7173360586166382,
0.9103538393974304,
-0.016526097431778908,
-0.100945845246315,
0.6594899892807007,
0.68828284740448,
-0.15220490097999573,
-0.7043346762657166,
-0.2850601375102997,
0.1911361813545227,
-0.4652705788612366,
-0.578196108341217,
-0.5249409079551697,
-0.38350963592529297,
-0.38033682107925415,
0.08446121960878372,
0.015343103557825089,
0.10878893733024597,
-0.3335658311843872,
0.182578906416893,
0.48811835050582886,
0.9168096780776978,
-0.03531436249613762,
0.04507574439048767,
-1.1269018650054932,
0.415065735578537,
0.24180705845355988,
0.33193230628967285,
-0.2796991169452667,
-0.43251144886016846,
-0.418432354927063,
-0.07919391244649887,
-0.2221091091632843,
-0.8669208884239197,
0.7028835415840149,
0.10715384781360626,
0.5904288291931152,
0.46598947048187256,
-0.018499281257390976,
0.35154786705970764,
-0.5895095467567444,
0.5426195859909058,
0.4353722929954529,
-0.5285098552703857,
0.6110883355140686,
0.0017515838844701648,
0.31048154830932617,
0.4360846281051636,
0.30334869027137756,
-0.38834819197654724,
-0.15974731743335724,
-0.4062955677509308,
-0.4972573220729828,
0.18071191012859344,
-0.5379109382629395,
-0.1896355152130127,
-0.06699695438146591,
0.6389172673225403,
0.1211138367652893,
0.14941729605197906,
-0.19181649386882782,
-0.2947220504283905,
0.2243099808692932,
-0.5621534585952759,
0.147722065448761,
-0.2974841892719269,
-0.2468814104795456,
-0.3974481225013733,
0.5132383704185486,
-0.332411527633667,
0.30261197686195374,
0.27443039417266846,
-0.026741642504930496,
-0.1935717612504959,
0.2530110478401184,
0.20052796602249146,
0.628132700920105,
-0.3194091022014618,
0.08136752247810364,
0.19490452110767365,
-0.5962393879890442,
-0.10230716317892075,
0.28688010573387146,
-0.16816286742687225,
-0.12098868936300278,
0.30683591961860657,
0.5291538834571838,
0.31888818740844727,
-0.8513721823692322,
0.4163815677165985,
0.23234599828720093,
-0.004981514532119036,
-0.29319748282432556,
0.10785112529993057,
0.2759215235710144,
0.43820253014564514,
0.3920917212963104,
0.16753587126731873,
0.4930379390716553,
-0.4678044021129608,
0.38562121987342834,
0.47900962829589844,
-0.4714462459087372,
-0.317972332239151,
0.7867838144302368,
0.19084030389785767,
-0.38786283135414124,
0.2884317934513092,
-0.13572505116462708,
-0.4028661549091339,
0.5221809148788452,
0.3375718593597412,
0.4317029118537903,
-0.43789371848106384,
0.1481856405735016,
0.044248342514038086,
-0.23971083760261536,
-0.1435079276561737,
0.5246363878250122,
0.4246167838573456,
-0.528218686580658,
-0.6078537702560425,
-0.8050971627235413,
-0.49357637763023376,
0.25333961844444275,
-0.48871317505836487,
0.4866522252559662,
-0.30404868721961975,
-0.26817479729652405,
0.04504530876874924,
0.27685245871543884,
-0.5349429845809937,
0.44929060339927673,
0.43174320459365845,
0.8777065873146057,
-0.208771750330925,
1.068790078163147,
0.8163009881973267,
-0.2447752058506012,
-0.5903192162513733,
0.10536378622055054,
0.11060880869626999,
-1.0015796422958374,
0.5457731485366821,
0.08642859011888504,
0.2513856291770935,
-0.14736048877239227,
-0.283223420381546,
-0.9585317373275757,
1.1423615217208862,
0.45920905470848083,
-0.7667445540428162,
-0.29280775785446167,
-0.061318542808294296,
0.4194076657295227,
-0.4743984341621399,
0.09905658662319183,
0.5461500287055969,
0.4672444462776184,
0.26110634207725525,
-1.115244746208191,
0.021972505375742912,
0.04841357842087746,
-0.04662834107875824,
0.14447860419750214,
-0.5261731743812561,
0.5807080864906311,
-0.619866669178009,
0.13864725828170776,
0.25693121552467346,
0.4439868927001953,
0.34031540155410767,
0.5036125779151917,
0.2716526687145233,
0.7520188689231873,
0.9897556900978088,
0.16838125884532928,
1.0420823097229004,
-0.5351594686508179,
0.2855885326862335,
0.8655547499656677,
-0.5036754012107849,
0.7520584464073181,
0.12267760187387466,
-0.3471488058567047,
0.4275122880935669,
0.6111939549446106,
0.2165437638759613,
0.6579276323318481,
0.20099158585071564,
-0.5389737486839294,
-0.14415809512138367,
-0.2139739841222763,
-0.511084258556366,
0.5934348702430725,
0.5059528946876526,
-0.5233645439147949,
0.03488690406084061,
0.31598928570747375,
-0.09645714610815048,
0.017029976472258568,
-0.5191002488136292,
0.9080122113227844,
0.14770078659057617,
-0.20464551448822021,
0.3123890459537506,
-0.10859791934490204,
0.764361560344696,
-0.4772242605686188,
-0.26118847727775574,
-0.0271998830139637,
0.1335887610912323,
-0.30537477135658264,
-0.6390228271484375,
0.2976008653640747,
-0.34750938415527344,
-0.39923080801963806,
-0.02725740149617195,
0.8841630220413208,
-0.46871334314346313,
-0.40483590960502625,
0.425656259059906,
0.7246784567832947,
0.21017836034297943,
0.10682645440101624,
-0.7998554706573486,
0.026199473068118095,
-0.17565351724624634,
-0.03575484827160835,
0.56340491771698,
0.19213677942752838,
-0.00988709181547165,
0.6411117315292358,
0.534578800201416,
0.6417011022567749,
-0.3734487295150757,
0.07680869847536087,
0.7686271667480469,
-0.6331112384796143,
-0.36330774426460266,
-0.7269542813301086,
0.07670019567012787,
-0.09433658421039581,
0.0652240663766861,
0.27493107318878174,
0.5261893272399902,
0.20437034964561462,
0.17985239624977112,
1.0293163061141968,
0.03885506093502045,
1.1279425621032715,
-0.2430426925420761,
0.8547199964523315,
-0.8135437965393066,
0.32592231035232544,
0.13294221460819244,
-0.4920777380466461,
-0.6050776839256287,
0.0483967550098896,
-0.2230042815208435,
0.0597427673637867,
0.5762131810188293,
0.38529878854751587,
0.21649272739887238,
-0.2642567753791809,
0.6411458253860474,
0.299756795167923,
0.4161679446697235,
0.4441990256309509,
0.36439621448516846,
0.040428098291158676,
0.027937594801187515,
-0.32976922392845154,
-0.3975977897644043,
-0.6326525807380676,
-0.6502084136009216,
-0.4652876853942871,
-0.34398940205574036,
-0.21385590732097626,
-0.38728559017181396,
0.27697697281837463,
1.1909881830215454,
0.8243100047111511,
-0.883497416973114,
0.13595174252986908,
0.3521427810192108,
0.1324346661567688,
-0.13472038507461548,
-0.15799567103385925,
0.43258702754974365,
-0.09730088710784912,
-0.43629899621009827,
0.5450533628463745,
0.6164736151695251,
-0.2422870397567749,
-0.27558669447898865,
-0.2549763321876526,
-0.002680807840079069,
-0.16913296282291412,
0.6392696499824524,
0.3393956124782562,
-0.6712386608123779,
-0.20568488538265228,
0.15854477882385254,
-0.3204120099544525,
0.18394815921783447,
0.5834745764732361,
-0.903313398361206,
0.43698298931121826,
0.3175681531429291,
0.9037014245986938,
0.2039872109889984,
-0.09672315418720245,
0.2717123031616211,
-0.13886533677577972,
-0.07521985471248627,
0.6587657332420349,
0.45675182342529297,
0.35040172934532166,
-0.8480973243713379,
0.25478893518447876,
0.3666238784790039,
-0.5691480040550232,
-0.6330441236495972,
0.006645798683166504,
-0.9138952493667603,
-0.21814580261707306,
1.0180262327194214,
-0.08192645758390427,
-0.3155694603919983,
-0.14182046055793762,
0.01195131428539753,
0.24001707136631012,
-0.1694771945476532,
0.7871267795562744,
0.08833319693803787,
-0.6803410053253174,
0.07313163578510284,
-0.5912216901779175,
0.4852669835090637,
0.2841812074184418,
-1.182294249534607,
-0.39713814854621887,
0.2023116946220398,
0.428094744682312,
0.08547990024089813,
0.7648326754570007,
-0.3840716779232025,
0.3974088430404663,
-0.71968013048172,
0.10185772180557251,
-0.03578522428870201,
-0.2131011188030243,
-0.20843929052352905,
0.15151315927505493,
0.08688567578792572,
-0.09760930389165878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00745v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00745v1 | Enhancing Ethical Explanations of Large Language Models through Iterative Symbolic Refinement | 2024-02-01T16:39:51 | 2024-02-01T16:39:51 | Xin Quan, Marco Valentino, Louise A. Dennis, André Freitas | cs.CL | cs.CL | An increasing amount of research in Natural Language Inference (NLI) focuses
on the application and evaluation of Large Language Models (LLMs) and their
reasoning capabilities. Despite their success, however, LLMs are still prone to
factual errors and inconsistencies in their explanations, offering limited
control and interpretability for inference in complex domains. In this paper,
we focus on ethical NLI, investigating how hybrid neuro-symbolic techniques can
enhance the logical validity and alignment of ethical explanations produced by
LLMs. Specifically, we present an abductive-deductive framework named
Logic-Explainer, which integrates LLMs with an external backward-chaining
solver to refine step-wise natural language explanations and jointly verify
their correctness, reduce incompleteness and minimise redundancy. An extensive
empirical analysis demonstrates that Logic-Explainer can improve explanations
generated via in-context learning methods and Chain-of-Thought (CoT) on
challenging ethical NLI tasks, while, at the same time, producing formal proofs
describing and supporting models' reasoning. As ethical NLI requires
commonsense reasoning to identify underlying moral violations, our results
suggest the effectiveness of neuro-symbolic methods for multi-step NLI more
broadly, opening new opportunities to enhance the logical consistency,
reliability, and alignment of LLMs. | [
-0.05332106351852417,
-0.7966789603233337,
0.7146990895271301,
0.003784961998462677,
-0.345965713262558,
0.10403432697057724,
-0.3491837680339813,
-0.4344251751899719,
-0.06560090184211731,
0.4356217086315155,
-0.7756111025810242,
-0.3097148537635803,
-0.44986969232559204,
0.42183494567871094,
-0.2256910651922226,
0.9256704449653625,
0.01451138686388731,
0.3182826340198517,
-0.1096462607383728,
-0.25356951355934143,
-0.44024527072906494,
-0.250156432390213,
-1.0038269758224487,
-0.6448287963867188,
0.4532201886177063,
0.01575985923409462,
0.7859724760055542,
0.712881863117218,
0.08001209795475006,
0.3846449553966522,
-0.18184460699558258,
0.1958116739988327,
-0.5305788516998291,
-0.07081849873065948,
-0.5862317085266113,
-0.3066398501396179,
-0.2515498101711273,
-0.0438167080283165,
0.4289635121822357,
0.6745374202728271,
-0.32425543665885925,
0.13015027344226837,
-0.07289233803749084,
0.6385305523872375,
-0.683566689491272,
-0.17854665219783783,
-0.7030885219573975,
-0.1315324306488037,
0.33297574520111084,
-0.4060337543487549,
-0.6015675067901611,
-0.6704879999160767,
0.045702267438173294,
-0.754256010055542,
-0.022453375160694122,
0.09458538144826889,
0.7896213531494141,
0.3284059762954712,
-0.3349408507347107,
-0.2432730495929718,
-0.776602029800415,
1.2657418251037598,
-1.1268919706344604,
0.38039493560791016,
0.22824470698833466,
0.1651623398065567,
-0.24176114797592163,
-0.4528728723526001,
-0.8608303070068359,
-0.12878185510635376,
-0.3024282157421112,
-0.017024023458361626,
-0.16275432705879211,
0.18978802859783173,
0.37589097023010254,
0.2076595276594162,
-0.33987390995025635,
0.4031580984592438,
-0.27428075671195984,
-0.0884302631020546,
0.7943276166915894,
0.09841576963663101,
0.28604230284690857,
-0.01718335971236229,
-0.11803183704614639,
0.1683041751384735,
-0.7904672026634216,
-0.15652702748775482,
0.5606439709663391,
0.10927924513816833,
0.060870226472616196,
0.3534592092037201,
0.12398786842823029,
0.7013666033744812,
0.07512350380420685,
-0.10304458439350128,
0.14366105198860168,
-0.5531411170959473,
-0.2890455722808838,
0.39972832798957825,
0.6408185362815857,
0.5936886668205261,
0.6098170876502991,
-0.14598381519317627,
-0.13853302597999573,
0.27561429142951965,
0.3706423342227936,
-0.6366098523139954,
0.09008705615997314,
0.6466768383979797,
-0.7326148748397827,
-0.3733290433883667,
-0.08906658738851547,
-0.5550255179405212,
-0.5319890379905701,
-0.8491402864456177,
0.3068116009235382,
-0.6122595071792603,
-0.37167006731033325,
0.4794232249259949,
-0.2670547366142273,
0.3900594115257263,
0.4348768889904022,
-0.5419187545776367,
0.3561754822731018,
0.9658443331718445,
0.552639365196228,
0.25890809297561646,
-0.1562366634607315,
-0.6282635927200317,
0.3670744299888611,
-0.3785962462425232,
0.2797882854938507,
-0.6935628056526184,
0.00236978055909276,
-0.17500637471675873,
0.0826728418469429,
-0.039092086255550385,
-0.37390202283859253,
0.5962130427360535,
-0.428498774766922,
0.2733452320098877,
-0.3567536473274231,
-0.44445714354515076,
-0.6177960634231567,
0.205631285905838,
-0.5285777449607849,
0.7147342562675476,
-0.3530360162258148,
-0.7043595314025879,
0.3022410571575165,
-0.7686648964881897,
-0.5207791328430176,
-0.14080815017223358,
-0.2715168595314026,
-0.2694847583770752,
0.1930120289325714,
0.254177987575531,
0.208004429936409,
-0.5812548995018005,
0.7643687725067139,
-0.35042864084243774,
-0.5198690295219421,
0.2526813745498657,
-0.463819295167923,
1.3190749883651733,
-0.04946641996502876,
-0.5616891384124756,
0.36406490206718445,
-0.8488616347312927,
0.016183974221348763,
0.3427148461341858,
0.2538706362247467,
-0.5364474058151245,
0.09643910825252533,
-0.21553267538547516,
0.39695078134536743,
-0.04688403382897377,
-0.6824232339859009,
-0.35632243752479553,
-0.6053860187530518,
0.634367823600769,
0.9981521964073181,
-0.07295998930931091,
0.4364026188850403,
-0.4190071225166321,
0.24864359200000763,
-0.1657172292470932,
0.28540802001953125,
0.02401445433497429,
-0.32961738109588623,
-0.6268885135650635,
-0.19807922840118408,
0.05843280628323555,
0.528876543045044,
-0.5719741582870483,
0.6679481863975525,
-0.31760111451148987,
-0.016863036900758743,
-0.6649706959724426,
-0.06201258674263954,
0.3959594666957855,
0.665468156337738,
0.34236741065979004,
0.1488276720046997,
-0.49737200140953064,
-1.106015682220459,
-0.5791165828704834,
-0.1689273864030838,
-0.14738662540912628,
0.014038972556591034,
0.8031110167503357,
-0.07805684208869934,
0.7903250455856323,
0.2973327934741974,
0.34962713718414307,
-0.202596515417099,
0.16331201791763306,
0.3528897166252136,
0.5662640333175659,
0.14285720884799957,
-0.8506633043289185,
0.2714632451534271,
-0.12282547354698181,
-0.845119833946228,
-0.1163206547498703,
-0.45787563920021057,
-0.24227215349674225,
0.12539249658584595,
0.19062533974647522,
-0.43411698937416077,
0.4965836703777313,
0.3053981065750122,
-0.24817043542861938,
0.5317873954772949,
-0.24351240694522858,
0.1316194087266922,
-0.9041049480438232,
0.02501409687101841,
-0.05613160505890846,
-0.12300015985965729,
-0.5969567894935608,
0.19483909010887146,
-0.10403501987457275,
0.2827398478984833,
-0.2626623511314392,
0.4079202711582184,
-0.34663233160972595,
0.0937083438038826,
-0.26687178015708923,
0.3665083348751068,
0.09906221926212311,
0.3464456796646118,
0.056652896106243134,
0.3612973093986511,
0.5632628798484802,
-0.5786898732185364,
0.20121420919895172,
0.15901033580303192,
0.18769553303718567,
0.6839995980262756,
-0.7973327040672302,
0.16745620965957642,
-0.40678712725639343,
0.6304877400398254,
-0.6927486062049866,
0.08120198547840118,
0.32326674461364746,
-0.14913932979106903,
-0.17597725987434387,
-0.14222130179405212,
-0.7608774304389954,
-0.18314245343208313,
-0.5348622798919678,
0.5195866823196411,
0.4338383376598358,
-0.8513412475585938,
1.1900296211242676,
-0.032406795769929886,
0.21401603519916534,
-0.78533935546875,
-0.7600021362304688,
0.185440793633461,
-0.3106050193309784,
-0.6711487770080566,
0.31705528497695923,
-0.007989095523953438,
-0.6851961612701416,
0.011419599875807762,
-0.44683638215065,
0.06935354322195053,
0.18909427523612976,
0.14445312321186066,
0.3503094017505646,
-0.2766246199607849,
0.14194542169570923,
0.2654609680175781,
-0.26019230484962463,
0.4289132356643677,
-0.3744209408760071,
0.27862414717674255,
-0.38057518005371094,
-0.43735721707344055,
-0.7049719095230103,
0.49184322357177734,
0.43878647685050964,
-0.3773995041847229,
0.8787581324577332,
0.32928285002708435,
-0.6708642244338989,
-0.28493815660476685,
-0.7167823314666748,
-0.5381224751472473,
-0.4674784243106842,
-0.03745187073945999,
-0.14547517895698547,
-0.790649950504303,
0.4093721807003021,
-0.268770694732666,
0.3738040030002594,
0.35874420404434204,
0.28073087334632874,
0.19105151295661926,
0.9710919260978699,
0.41724610328674316,
0.2768406569957733,
-0.039873477071523666,
-0.09772296249866486,
0.6114979982376099,
-0.7279451489448547,
-0.2610274851322174,
-0.36253249645233154,
-0.41620954871177673,
-0.7318954467773438,
-0.23451091349124908,
-0.08847547322511673,
0.18106794357299805,
-0.5069910287857056,
0.09594255685806274,
-0.5642795562744141,
0.8815562725067139,
0.3460930585861206,
0.11901947855949402,
0.6499351263046265,
-0.07958132773637772,
-0.016041040420532227,
0.13496345281600952,
-0.48923978209495544,
-0.8593548536300659,
0.5261198282241821,
0.3239229917526245,
0.6092060208320618,
0.2167680710554123,
0.7244318723678589,
-0.21426832675933838,
0.36250215768814087,
-0.5935507416725159,
0.6431378722190857,
-0.08408589661121368,
-0.4318709671497345,
-0.10327237844467163,
-0.5154870748519897,
-0.6211990714073181,
0.3149569034576416,
-0.23310618102550507,
-1.1541345119476318,
0.25284743309020996,
0.24290607869625092,
-0.3778618276119232,
0.34562498331069946,
-0.568364143371582,
0.8238562941551208,
-0.4523684084415436,
-0.4557642340660095,
-0.6803091764450073,
-0.8777942657470703,
0.42052119970321655,
-0.06775546073913574,
0.234619602560997,
0.01919405907392502,
-0.043772727251052856,
0.664999783039093,
-0.5777413845062256,
0.9301530718803406,
-0.041376542299985886,
-0.4031948745250702,
0.02924715168774128,
0.22496004402637482,
0.5950847268104553,
0.25153687596321106,
-0.41003379225730896,
0.30519211292266846,
-0.09422635287046432,
-0.24790775775909424,
-0.9111806154251099,
0.6765570044517517,
-0.2266564518213272,
-0.7801441550254822,
-0.23511743545532227,
-0.6716238856315613,
-0.23704154789447784,
0.17110684514045715,
0.007244312670081854,
0.462527334690094,
0.2630423605442047,
0.029469816014170647,
0.7565462589263916,
-0.5709428191184998,
0.2809610962867737,
0.43497785925865173,
-0.01585693284869194,
-0.2071601301431656,
0.711866021156311,
-0.435639888048172,
0.3223094642162323,
0.20694252848625183,
0.6164383888244629,
-0.4465940594673157,
-0.5809023380279541,
-0.3945241868495941,
0.6217717528343201,
-0.9194762706756592,
0.11791442334651947,
-0.554880678653717,
-0.09295821934938431,
-0.01658044196665287,
-0.4279244840145111,
-0.16676151752471924,
-0.4189174473285675,
0.01911812834441662,
-0.24033477902412415,
0.6541659235954285,
0.5182962417602539,
0.055516067892313004,
0.11392786353826523,
-0.5325337052345276,
0.46636804938316345,
-0.11298280209302902,
0.4439953565597534,
0.26013508439064026,
-0.43386954069137573,
0.4374195635318756,
0.3032791018486023,
0.02021133154630661,
-0.6814806461334229,
0.019507447257637978,
-0.04616359993815422,
0.33504876494407654,
0.2563520073890686,
0.0814606174826622,
1.0578159093856812,
-0.5482594966888428,
0.5037241578102112,
0.31687188148498535,
-1.1192679405212402,
0.5179211497306824,
-0.2565957009792328,
0.11311240494251251,
0.5564039945602417,
0.3613707721233368,
-0.36555320024490356,
-0.7107734084129333,
-0.644071102142334,
-0.9007912278175354,
0.5693227052688599,
0.36587464809417725,
0.06968908756971359,
-0.04571064934134483,
0.4285276532173157,
0.33716872334480286,
0.0867423489689827,
-0.7904927730560303,
-0.16328337788581848,
0.08998497575521469,
-0.4414921700954437,
0.36546024680137634,
0.12361767888069153,
-0.4577537775039673,
-0.3799293041229248,
0.8952416181564331,
-0.24513337016105652,
-0.015575683675706387,
0.13902360200881958,
-0.10178989917039871,
-0.08411300927400589,
0.4143824279308319,
0.5113394260406494,
1.1501309871673584,
0.08024275302886963,
0.14571158587932587,
0.2708282172679901,
0.0003798780089709908,
0.12619858980178833,
0.18830931186676025,
0.002963237464427948,
-0.05207005515694618,
0.3724031448364258,
0.46844714879989624,
0.0346316322684288,
-0.8253740668296814,
0.39289677143096924,
-0.028721554204821587,
-0.04331783950328827,
-0.3361208736896515,
-0.18049979209899902,
0.17253217101097107,
0.23964132368564606,
0.1623373180627823,
0.07507045567035675,
0.21988674998283386,
-0.38307976722717285,
0.13125111162662506,
0.5030584931373596,
0.07595204561948776,
-0.13570952415466309,
0.6402462124824524,
0.03306032717227936,
-0.22451482713222504,
0.7016890645027161,
-0.04951418191194534,
-0.43700021505355835,
0.6535516381263733,
0.7436457276344299,
0.8724419474601746,
0.061743542551994324,
0.2314639389514923,
0.34230175614356995,
0.5423977971076965,
-0.2676137089729309,
0.33861395716667175,
-0.09616103768348694,
-0.8079507350921631,
-1.0201359987258911,
-0.35111141204833984,
-0.26408374309539795,
0.2206803262233734,
-0.5485982298851013,
0.0008488159510307014,
-0.5428721308708191,
0.2773287296295166,
0.13204462826251984,
-0.509983479976654,
-0.2554861307144165,
0.15764182806015015,
0.050901319831609726,
0.7837545275688171,
-0.6846387386322021,
0.44159379601478577,
0.34091153740882874,
-0.30943742394447327,
-0.7733865976333618,
0.1689564734697342,
0.2249555140733719,
-0.7263147830963135,
0.7060041427612305,
0.3901658356189728,
-0.8129613399505615,
-0.16464392840862274,
-0.5859281420707703,
-0.4830707311630249,
0.8329931497573853,
0.5996307730674744,
-0.7248435616493225,
-0.03288421779870987,
0.06100302189588547,
0.5616685748100281,
-0.12187062948942184,
0.2981798052787781,
0.5542546510696411,
0.6356435418128967,
-0.011219900101423264,
-0.7516000270843506,
0.7173492312431335,
-0.2370765060186386,
0.05026203393936157,
0.4251145124435425,
-0.15912269055843353,
0.3269514739513397,
-0.4523705840110779,
-0.2534657418727875,
0.10318128019571304,
0.42320430278778076,
0.5989898443222046,
0.370096892118454,
0.8214576244354248,
0.529775083065033,
0.9509633779525757,
-0.03674507886171341,
1.1456303596496582,
-0.13398830592632294,
-0.0022999749053269625,
1.1756595373153687,
-0.32361099123954773,
0.5190136432647705,
0.8140134811401367,
0.39810502529144287,
0.7550289630889893,
0.3761301636695862,
-0.023967262357473373,
0.0670175552368164,
0.4843783676624298,
-0.2333867847919464,
-0.3787986934185028,
-0.3646618723869324,
0.039559319615364075,
0.22708873450756073,
0.22586414217948914,
-0.5321932435035706,
-0.31325775384902954,
-0.17161603271961212,
0.04151838272809982,
0.25112831592559814,
-0.19412681460380554,
0.5380514860153198,
0.1378573477268219,
-0.5596176385879517,
0.7085916996002197,
0.027603838592767715,
0.5772327184677124,
-0.37832608819007874,
-0.3368607461452484,
0.1492796689271927,
0.217873215675354,
-0.3372204005718231,
-0.6264932155609131,
0.43806296586990356,
0.16286411881446838,
0.06803739070892334,
-0.5349193811416626,
0.5258454084396362,
-0.2654583752155304,
-0.3789091408252716,
0.49271541833877563,
0.3090027868747711,
-0.024338141083717346,
0.16077964007854462,
-0.8835452198982239,
0.006599052809178829,
-0.17779380083084106,
0.036958836019039154,
-0.18944509327411652,
0.5009251832962036,
-0.3168505132198334,
0.7972701787948608,
0.73357754945755,
-0.11990191042423248,
-0.27221348881721497,
0.4885604679584503,
0.6815164089202881,
-0.8078097701072693,
-0.4015703797340393,
-1.2764256000518799,
0.6016235947608948,
-0.356225848197937,
-0.11910485476255417,
0.49283093214035034,
0.3877277374267578,
0.8370699882507324,
0.07981809973716736,
0.5300970077514648,
0.01815449632704258,
-0.014475789852440357,
-0.7509604692459106,
0.4369911253452301,
-0.49227699637413025,
0.4088785648345947,
-0.16425780951976776,
-0.6592539548873901,
-0.3920705318450928,
0.8036080598831177,
-0.4537888765335083,
0.210275799036026,
0.9334011077880859,
0.8938499689102173,
-0.16698890924453735,
0.6706691980361938,
-0.09784723073244095,
0.32907769083976746,
0.10939747095108032,
0.4382126033306122,
1.0665773153305054,
-0.254958838224411,
0.3230070173740387,
-0.35918131470680237,
-0.15922734141349792,
0.3879263699054718,
-1.3046592473983765,
-0.7991476655006409,
-0.20374885201454163,
-0.6386262774467468,
-0.3372345566749573,
0.2135799676179886,
1.0629260540008545,
0.5596153736114502,
-0.7843655347824097,
-0.22891677916049957,
-0.5820638537406921,
0.31050917506217957,
-0.5973959565162659,
-0.2889319956302643,
0.18751020729541779,
-0.07591523230075836,
-0.4797115623950958,
0.4510353207588196,
0.3704303503036499,
-0.46001967787742615,
0.005629683379083872,
-0.08316315710544586,
-0.3284759223461151,
0.29526403546333313,
0.6026532649993896,
0.009669729508459568,
-1.268170714378357,
-0.3198225796222687,
-0.262195885181427,
0.35994449257850647,
0.01574481837451458,
1.0116615295410156,
-0.7331838011741638,
0.17897461354732513,
0.32312095165252686,
0.861549437046051,
-0.13853615522384644,
0.05886486545205116,
0.9175191521644592,
-0.36638203263282776,
-0.07597526907920837,
0.4791262447834015,
0.4639200270175934,
0.32097432017326355,
-0.413512259721756,
0.47364485263824463,
-0.02106349729001522,
-0.23409634828567505,
-0.824299156665802,
0.3735070526599884,
-1.0156489610671997,
-0.4586418867111206,
1.1826307773590088,
0.18078526854515076,
-0.42553892731666565,
-0.2333425134420395,
-0.1796463578939438,
0.2315196543931961,
-0.3302898406982422,
0.6797061562538147,
0.45543092489242554,
-0.02628515288233757,
-0.17189212143421173,
-0.4887777864933014,
0.2671796977519989,
0.5946338176727295,
-0.972193717956543,
0.4202836751937866,
0.6113079786300659,
0.3372785449028015,
0.14622662961483002,
0.2146441787481308,
-0.3759884238243103,
0.4093289375305176,
-0.3291807472705841,
-0.16644074022769928,
-0.03568229824304581,
-0.08637881278991699,
-0.5519976019859314,
-0.29151448607444763,
-0.3433821201324463,
0.007296318653970957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00744v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00744v1 | BATON: Aligning Text-to-Audio Model with Human Preference Feedback | 2024-02-01T16:39:47 | 2024-02-01T16:39:47 | Huan Liao, Haonan Han, Kai Yang, Tianjiao Du, Rui Yang, Zunnan Xu, Qinmei Xu, Jingquan Liu, Jiasheng Lu, Xiu Li | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | With the development of AI-Generated Content (AIGC), text-to-audio models are
gaining widespread attention. However, it is challenging for these models to
generate audio aligned with human preference due to the inherent information
density of natural language and limited model understanding ability. To
alleviate this issue, we formulate the BATON, a framework designed to enhance
the alignment between generated audio and text prompt using human preference
feedback. Our BATON comprises three key stages: Firstly, we curated a dataset
containing both prompts and the corresponding generated audio, which was then
annotated based on human feedback. Secondly, we introduced a reward model using
the constructed dataset, which can mimic human preference by assigning rewards
to input text-audio pairs. Finally, we employed the reward model to fine-tune
an off-the-shelf text-to-audio model. The experiment results demonstrate that
our BATON can significantly improve the generation quality of the original
text-to-audio models, concerning audio integrity, temporal relationship, and
alignment with human preference. | [
-0.39642831683158875,
-0.3917792737483978,
0.41675740480422974,
0.16497786343097687,
-0.25528568029403687,
0.1309875100851059,
-0.2772825360298157,
-0.325387567281723,
0.28523871302604675,
0.5761443376541138,
-0.5211277604103088,
-0.5840501189231873,
-0.4812760055065155,
0.004576564766466618,
-0.43020811676979065,
1.2312259674072266,
0.20417162775993347,
-0.02149154059588909,
0.01189895998686552,
-0.20712366700172424,
-0.8926742672920227,
-0.25289931893348694,
-0.8854687809944153,
-0.4348273277282715,
0.5483647584915161,
0.5499292612075806,
0.7165948152542114,
0.8243330121040344,
0.39083221554756165,
0.14443551003932953,
0.1630793809890747,
0.19644856452941895,
-0.17318996787071228,
0.04086064174771309,
-0.12333302944898605,
-0.028398023918271065,
-0.7968248724937439,
0.2562181055545807,
0.29781606793403625,
0.18799282610416412,
-0.2535145580768585,
0.2360149472951889,
0.3021072447299957,
0.79485684633255,
-0.27913638949394226,
-0.2667478621006012,
-0.5095187425613403,
-0.2557728588581085,
-0.16353341937065125,
-0.659552276134491,
-0.5271948575973511,
-0.39375039935112,
0.09324246644973755,
-0.7221198081970215,
0.2918702960014343,
0.42854031920433044,
0.8047372698783875,
0.47236698865890503,
-0.5531560778617859,
-0.3159150779247284,
-0.8376641869544983,
0.5532330274581909,
-0.5867761969566345,
0.227866068482399,
0.6012802124023438,
0.5268319249153137,
0.20958462357521057,
-0.4576983153820038,
-0.7085713148117065,
-0.21924953162670135,
0.20088925957679749,
0.3425455391407013,
0.46176859736442566,
0.09542687237262726,
-0.06994681060314178,
0.053053684532642365,
-0.43039730191230774,
0.1804468184709549,
0.028216032311320305,
-0.07072179764509201,
1.0620839595794678,
0.33481016755104065,
0.5100117921829224,
-0.24522583186626434,
-0.5539007186889648,
-0.2844637334346771,
-0.6997137665748596,
0.5301226377487183,
0.9653880000114441,
0.6103948354721069,
-0.3573463261127472,
0.6529455184936523,
0.13980409502983093,
0.8173359036445618,
0.567436695098877,
-0.1679902970790863,
0.055689044296741486,
-0.49027585983276367,
0.07967060059309006,
0.6904957890510559,
1.0402415990829468,
0.8549232482910156,
0.15113572776317596,
-0.02511683478951454,
-0.4163801074028015,
-0.07332869619131088,
0.7143110632896423,
-0.6555038690567017,
-0.27734124660491943,
0.4145342707633972,
-0.4538419246673584,
-0.5027157664299011,
0.0891985222697258,
-0.5055502653121948,
-0.688621461391449,
-0.6332283616065979,
0.4213101267814636,
-0.3794875741004944,
-0.14320018887519836,
0.11116810142993927,
-0.20654331147670746,
-0.13351204991340637,
0.5364118218421936,
-1.5914552211761475,
0.18821051716804504,
0.6117743253707886,
0.8716223835945129,
-0.3468162715435028,
0.009874699637293816,
-0.7373758554458618,
0.36299213767051697,
-0.18086937069892883,
0.8874132037162781,
-0.398469477891922,
-0.4104861617088318,
-0.14567157626152039,
-0.39362648129463196,
0.25842776894569397,
-0.5139685869216919,
0.8630552291870117,
-0.29341569542884827,
0.21675226092338562,
-0.22645559906959534,
-0.6592966914176941,
0.3176046907901764,
-0.047366026788949966,
-0.6675985455513,
1.134804129600525,
0.14985713362693787,
-0.7397574782371521,
0.5572677850723267,
-0.7452839016914368,
-0.47815367579460144,
0.029099425300955772,
-0.208433598279953,
-0.5241653919219971,
-0.3213900029659271,
0.5687483549118042,
0.21900050342082977,
-0.6576239466667175,
0.6169477105140686,
-0.20941436290740967,
-0.4683772027492523,
0.3055839240550995,
-0.41420575976371765,
0.7371117472648621,
0.057659246027469635,
-0.3969268202781677,
0.5457689166069031,
-0.7706202268600464,
-0.19338810443878174,
-0.18903593719005585,
-0.19144542515277863,
-0.07969684898853302,
0.14567841589450836,
0.5787866711616516,
-0.004536997061222792,
0.07658819109201431,
-0.614105224609375,
0.20225940644741058,
-0.35283133387565613,
0.5076068043708801,
0.9138316512107849,
-0.044849395751953125,
1.011781096458435,
-0.6468310356140137,
0.41595274209976196,
-0.21284279227256775,
0.025254786014556885,
-0.092049241065979,
-0.3371773064136505,
-0.06779583543539047,
-0.33850088715553284,
0.6052407026290894,
0.4945099651813507,
-0.2532782256603241,
0.7411261796951294,
-0.19905583560466766,
-0.3912868797779083,
-1.157483696937561,
0.13743548095226288,
-0.035175662487745285,
0.8590243458747864,
0.4898996651172638,
-0.3631325364112854,
-0.46380147337913513,
-0.7165082693099976,
-0.00020570574270095676,
-0.2850342094898224,
-0.4848535358905792,
0.5144805312156677,
-0.07553156465291977,
0.032687511295080185,
1.4584863185882568,
-0.2222033590078354,
-0.5112437009811401,
-0.11334986239671707,
0.4310055375099182,
0.12241969257593155,
0.5907324552536011,
0.6638895273208618,
-0.8811732530593872,
-0.44386860728263855,
-0.11966171115636826,
-0.38363298773765564,
-0.4832637906074524,
-0.33238357305526733,
-0.11099030077457428,
-0.24571442604064941,
0.2499413788318634,
-0.34738683700561523,
0.1647896021604538,
0.37552958726882935,
-0.17141996324062347,
0.7717322111129761,
0.09939812868833542,
0.6182205080986023,
-1.2599776983261108,
0.11677587032318115,
0.055001288652420044,
-0.2709314525127411,
-0.46352773904800415,
-0.6996150612831116,
0.12326548993587494,
-0.10863800346851349,
-0.14930753409862518,
1.0062180757522583,
-0.045350879430770874,
0.021283408626914024,
-0.5919122695922852,
0.5784268975257874,
0.2413948029279709,
0.32008224725723267,
0.27390235662460327,
0.9406078457832336,
0.26141253113746643,
-0.6935669779777527,
0.5523856282234192,
0.5662873983383179,
-0.2681000530719757,
0.9425430297851562,
-0.869867742061615,
0.14465086162090302,
0.15854182839393616,
0.30369600653648376,
-1.11141836643219,
-0.3722388744354248,
0.12790808081626892,
-0.8786134719848633,
0.3015640676021576,
-0.15629473328590393,
-0.2492067962884903,
-0.11407399922609329,
-0.3932964503765106,
0.654250979423523,
0.38170745968818665,
-0.8231332898139954,
0.45714235305786133,
0.5491529107093811,
-0.46738144755363464,
-0.5335215926170349,
-0.35043004155158997,
0.06858706474304199,
-0.3673904240131378,
-0.5796338319778442,
0.6609011888504028,
-0.21206353604793549,
-0.1514964997768402,
-0.2675064504146576,
0.030713733285665512,
0.16091634333133698,
-0.021551311016082764,
0.4693252742290497,
0.6459347605705261,
-0.12276671826839447,
0.3629921078681946,
0.268679678440094,
-0.2343912124633789,
0.027957158163189888,
-0.24912868440151215,
0.45020490884780884,
0.40559864044189453,
-0.3227316439151764,
-0.5911979079246521,
0.3241143226623535,
0.17812557518482208,
-0.4139522910118103,
0.32227829098701477,
0.5490717887878418,
0.019186656922101974,
-0.08136231452226639,
-0.257447212934494,
-0.3041522800922394,
-0.5464563369750977,
0.10335980355739594,
0.09771597385406494,
-0.6925920844078064,
0.19607193768024445,
0.11821633577346802,
0.16407211124897003,
0.11628138273954391,
0.6342881321907043,
-0.5137890577316284,
1.3548530340194702,
0.36398521065711975,
-0.24994124472141266,
0.7463874816894531,
0.09712405502796173,
0.12918789684772491,
-1.00388503074646,
-0.19349896907806396,
-0.6601943969726562,
-0.4762890040874481,
-0.14867952466011047,
0.23046498000621796,
0.40908804535865784,
0.1724211722612381,
-0.5974754691123962,
0.408134788274765,
-0.7293301820755005,
0.04130362346768379,
0.7157793045043945,
0.28882530331611633,
0.08447424322366714,
-0.22708748281002045,
0.04368621110916138,
-0.04581362009048462,
-0.47538191080093384,
-0.8421509861946106,
1.1272653341293335,
0.2612152397632599,
0.7507004141807556,
0.19734151661396027,
0.8587934374809265,
0.5785064697265625,
0.2020123302936554,
-0.8719407320022583,
0.21930420398712158,
0.14870715141296387,
-0.39298513531684875,
-0.507992148399353,
-0.31709733605384827,
-0.9223557114601135,
-0.43203210830688477,
-0.49296802282333374,
-0.8865497708320618,
-0.19220824539661407,
0.5180379748344421,
-0.6410152316093445,
0.03983157128095627,
-0.5545010566711426,
0.7023254632949829,
-0.27573543787002563,
-0.5562926530838013,
0.1296500414609909,
-0.7717174291610718,
0.14971862733364105,
0.2747664451599121,
0.17665155231952667,
-0.22987258434295654,
0.22075319290161133,
0.8378377556800842,
-0.5133329033851624,
0.5931913256645203,
-0.11224544793367386,
-0.43483227491378784,
0.4141036570072174,
-0.21654950082302094,
0.440370112657547,
0.45561447739601135,
-0.12192978709936142,
-0.3277815878391266,
-0.47939276695251465,
-0.19527971744537354,
-0.9013499021530151,
0.34565630555152893,
-0.7779070138931274,
-0.5251951217651367,
0.07521842420101166,
-0.848528265953064,
-0.33956339955329895,
0.02897750400006771,
0.573578417301178,
0.942237377166748,
-0.155075341463089,
-0.24104845523834229,
0.5118028521537781,
-0.08236627280712128,
0.568608283996582,
0.1639314889907837,
-0.34684744477272034,
-0.6603099703788757,
0.9462384581565857,
-0.35690823197364807,
0.2894877791404724,
0.46717166900634766,
0.03716349974274635,
-0.6646550893783569,
-0.5728737711906433,
-0.8548733592033386,
-0.1078752875328064,
-0.20503319799900055,
-0.24671754240989685,
-0.3776502013206482,
-0.1332530677318573,
-0.6810970306396484,
-0.5655511021614075,
-0.4709477424621582,
-0.48129743337631226,
-0.565468430519104,
-0.10987675189971924,
0.6180881261825562,
0.5067181587219238,
0.08501457422971725,
0.6693893074989319,
-1.1026018857955933,
0.6475953459739685,
0.22331704199314117,
0.3186824917793274,
-0.04574758931994438,
-0.8539444804191589,
-0.35558074712753296,
0.23865747451782227,
-0.4293290674686432,
-0.850014328956604,
0.32509946823120117,
-0.16656680405139923,
0.11143577843904495,
0.44611549377441406,
0.3737393021583557,
0.3547569811344147,
-0.5605966448783875,
0.9812078475952148,
0.5660461783409119,
-0.9701586961746216,
0.5211116671562195,
-0.8010669350624084,
0.19020351767539978,
0.5846514701843262,
-0.06172147020697594,
-0.4857020676136017,
-0.3469260036945343,
-0.4587806761264801,
-0.907023549079895,
0.6243337988853455,
0.21895799040794373,
-0.022195735946297646,
0.12958811223506927,
0.1543755829334259,
0.10597213357686996,
0.2949083149433136,
-0.6222504377365112,
-0.18626751005649567,
-0.5429961085319519,
-0.7132107615470886,
-0.17757447063922882,
0.07473907619714737,
-0.28226926922798157,
-0.10192259401082993,
0.6914448142051697,
-0.1748744547367096,
0.24364922940731049,
0.008866650983691216,
0.044586848467588425,
-0.11842147260904312,
0.48459717631340027,
0.6097412109375,
-0.06228701397776604,
-0.2500945031642914,
-0.039295971393585205,
-0.31172236800193787,
-0.4151301085948944,
0.6469063758850098,
-0.07824651151895523,
-0.17030008137226105,
-0.2629627287387848,
0.3260831832885742,
1.0184297561645508,
0.07359229773283005,
-0.510707437992096,
0.4920124113559723,
-0.053029660135507584,
-0.12396711856126785,
-0.11226149648427963,
0.2610083520412445,
0.18818478286266327,
0.17973370850086212,
0.34406042098999023,
0.31814584136009216,
0.29857325553894043,
-0.2945097088813782,
0.33351507782936096,
0.4330119490623474,
-0.6057383418083191,
-0.03783310577273369,
1.1342675685882568,
0.5453985333442688,
-0.8886092901229858,
0.5553655624389648,
-0.0090352613478899,
-0.30542200803756714,
0.6313820481300354,
0.6408994793891907,
0.8379865288734436,
-0.1909189224243164,
0.4584246575832367,
0.4977334141731262,
0.0822577029466629,
-0.025674641132354736,
-0.07992696017026901,
-0.39418530464172363,
-0.7271503806114197,
-0.0074843475595116615,
-0.39197492599487305,
-0.5090448260307312,
-0.2067105770111084,
-0.962769091129303,
0.5256854295730591,
-0.1986517757177353,
-0.4801289141178131,
-0.0800408124923706,
-0.1624870002269745,
-0.14806458353996277,
0.37332597374916077,
-0.10891007632017136,
0.7190650105476379,
-0.7224045395851135,
0.8990018963813782,
0.3061846196651459,
-0.4886297881603241,
-1.2551405429840088,
0.06499295681715012,
0.07396207004785538,
-0.4676544964313507,
0.4000559449195862,
0.22577936947345734,
-0.38602206110954285,
0.1576308161020279,
-0.5015528798103333,
-0.411660760641098,
1.0247606039047241,
0.3934909403324127,
-0.6148757934570312,
0.057994019240140915,
0.1452808827161789,
0.4938245117664337,
-0.5111684203147888,
0.36504819989204407,
0.4527609050273895,
0.5893226265907288,
-0.03874203935265541,
-0.9593127369880676,
-0.23890244960784912,
-0.4759843945503235,
-0.2470352202653885,
0.48249587416648865,
-0.4490269124507904,
0.5518196821212769,
-0.32361266016960144,
-0.046612031757831573,
0.2166355848312378,
0.722216784954071,
0.44632965326309204,
0.4632171094417572,
0.45878496766090393,
0.2528674006462097,
0.7134005427360535,
-0.10336934030056,
1.090315580368042,
-0.21662957966327667,
0.07041769474744797,
1.5014326572418213,
-0.5519134402275085,
0.7203807830810547,
0.4603065848350525,
0.09305836260318756,
0.3010217249393463,
0.6339472532272339,
0.04219326376914978,
0.6735759973526001,
-0.0937279462814331,
-0.3217919170856476,
-0.16553299129009247,
-0.34522002935409546,
-0.29967111349105835,
0.301841676235199,
-0.11341992765665054,
-0.2661387622356415,
0.26985466480255127,
0.13708606362342834,
-0.42045044898986816,
0.39129000902175903,
-0.40004754066467285,
0.7834164500236511,
-0.13027535378932953,
-0.7902376055717468,
0.2941107451915741,
-0.05783453956246376,
0.6255088448524475,
-0.5072335004806519,
-0.10558735579252243,
0.1087605282664299,
-0.1684022843837738,
-0.29040712118148804,
-0.9597306847572327,
-0.029143858700990677,
0.0776720866560936,
-0.5066489577293396,
-0.3007587790489197,
0.5009340047836304,
-0.8093867301940918,
0.037286218255758286,
0.25880882143974304,
-0.13534177839756012,
-0.41915586590766907,
0.03463646024465561,
-0.5510196089744568,
-0.19087345898151398,
-0.08742209523916245,
-0.05185914784669876,
0.3645446300506592,
0.1641143262386322,
0.15225203335285187,
0.5019788146018982,
0.46418529748916626,
0.00854944996535778,
-0.24484685063362122,
0.33243685960769653,
0.3497609794139862,
-0.6095048785209656,
-0.759763777256012,
-0.8138174414634705,
0.6778514981269836,
-0.18155895173549652,
-0.31375113129615784,
0.612324595451355,
0.6415162682533264,
0.5191224813461304,
0.06506437063217163,
0.986132025718689,
0.10535594075918198,
0.6289681792259216,
-0.7001301646232605,
0.857837975025177,
-0.5886620283126831,
0.4756358563899994,
-0.6284543871879578,
-0.7885979413986206,
0.100285604596138,
0.42518091201782227,
-0.06406300514936447,
0.07583044469356537,
0.46241673827171326,
0.8780685067176819,
-0.05146140605211258,
0.3412666916847229,
-0.028256705030798912,
-0.39412185549736023,
0.30520835518836975,
0.3496856093406677,
0.6820735931396484,
-0.3040038049221039,
0.2669563889503479,
-0.039973802864551544,
-0.0899466872215271,
-0.1856568157672882,
-0.9086920022964478,
-0.7439420819282532,
-0.8975004553794861,
-0.17181695997714996,
-0.46548992395401,
-0.2005591243505478,
1.2767202854156494,
0.6618791222572327,
-0.6789854168891907,
-0.5074302554130554,
-0.06229740008711815,
0.04383916035294533,
-0.36014917492866516,
-0.23443487286567688,
0.45899972319602966,
-0.14846721291542053,
-0.684383749961853,
0.48631200194358826,
0.40327590703964233,
0.22216930985450745,
0.2881658375263214,
-0.5551027059555054,
-0.00912906788289547,
0.24788843095302582,
0.37673357129096985,
0.10735388845205307,
-0.4459483325481415,
-0.5648327469825745,
-0.0759405717253685,
-0.32496824860572815,
0.488669216632843,
1.072187066078186,
-0.6591883897781372,
0.3665315508842468,
0.23032920062541962,
0.6788890957832336,
0.3991158902645111,
0.37191489338874817,
1.0052052736282349,
-0.9096387028694153,
-0.09629066288471222,
0.2310582846403122,
0.21183530986309052,
0.436014324426651,
-0.452219158411026,
0.31104567646980286,
-0.20464898645877838,
-0.7808700799942017,
-0.7680864334106445,
0.3071894645690918,
-1.4409795999526978,
0.19226907193660736,
1.0937238931655884,
0.17685100436210632,
0.0750027522444725,
-0.2157660275697708,
-0.8373622894287109,
0.756693959236145,
-0.8447404503822327,
1.0102375745773315,
0.550986111164093,
-0.13479021191596985,
-0.07541336119174957,
-0.24917256832122803,
0.7921274900436401,
0.5614761114120483,
-0.9586207270622253,
0.2585270404815674,
0.42278164625167847,
-0.005265905521810055,
-0.0037068831734359264,
0.8248857259750366,
0.04597420617938042,
0.6302233934402466,
-0.14136084914207458,
0.14915646612644196,
-0.1970222443342209,
-0.5308722257614136,
-0.3296709358692169,
0.20048066973686218,
0.11395640671253204,
-0.18912507593631744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00743v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00743v2 | Theoretical Understanding of In-Context Learning in Shallow Transformers with Unstructured Data | 2024-02-01T16:39:45 | 2024-06-18T13:11:32 | Yue Xing, Xiaofeng Lin, Chenheng Xu, Namjoon Suh, Qifan Song, Guang Cheng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Large language models (LLMs) are powerful models that can learn concepts at
the inference stage via in-context learning (ICL). While theoretical studies,
e.g., \cite{zhang2023trained}, attempt to explain the mechanism of ICL, they
assume the input $x_i$ and the output $y_i$ of each demonstration example are
in the same token (i.e., structured data). However, in real practice, the
examples are usually text input, and all words, regardless of their logic
relationship, are stored in different tokens (i.e., unstructured data
\cite{wibisono2023role}). To understand how LLMs learn from the unstructured
data in ICL, this paper studies the role of each component in the transformer
architecture and provides a theoretical understanding to explain the success of
the architecture. In particular, we consider a simple transformer with one/two
attention layers and linear regression tasks for the ICL prediction. We observe
that (1) a transformer with two layers of (self-)attentions with a look-ahead
attention mask can learn from the prompt in the unstructured data, and (2)
positional encoding can match the $x_i$ and $y_i$ tokens to achieve a better
ICL performance. | [
-0.39273566007614136,
-0.6930758953094482,
0.7273091673851013,
0.000707184721250087,
-0.20299947261810303,
0.0811910480260849,
-0.3466714024543762,
-0.37469807267189026,
-0.3292381763458252,
0.30518800020217896,
-0.494643896818161,
-0.40036872029304504,
-0.3529454469680786,
0.02847868576645851,
-0.662661612033844,
1.1458263397216797,
-0.07802566885948181,
0.004281329456716776,
-0.3415438234806061,
0.13507366180419922,
-0.4661520719528198,
-0.37631744146347046,
-0.42246317863464355,
-0.6374270915985107,
0.38672593235969543,
0.5255947113037109,
0.43823906779289246,
0.6520311236381531,
0.29009896516799927,
0.31531253457069397,
-0.12050771713256836,
-0.25801360607147217,
-0.5841777324676514,
0.02291942946612835,
-0.22264498472213745,
-0.5961500406265259,
0.18530243635177612,
-0.01760684698820114,
0.7475572824478149,
0.9478416442871094,
0.0215297844260931,
0.11359209567308426,
0.5263270735740662,
0.3670419752597809,
-0.43258917331695557,
0.21102392673492432,
-0.8230971693992615,
0.32548433542251587,
-0.220437690615654,
-0.11984235048294067,
-0.6934614181518555,
0.24754302203655243,
0.2648748755455017,
-0.3082583546638489,
0.2590302526950836,
0.07177111506462097,
0.6113781332969666,
0.35223424434661865,
-0.6729164123535156,
-0.25673216581344604,
-1.0200021266937256,
0.8802891969680786,
-0.5482982397079468,
0.39046093821525574,
0.1704336404800415,
0.32751554250717163,
-0.07847324013710022,
-0.9225000143051147,
-0.5993402004241943,
-0.08522733300924301,
-0.5757754445075989,
0.22135600447654724,
0.0021430503111332655,
0.09665246307849884,
0.3546592593193054,
0.42808306217193604,
-0.1477946639060974,
0.3798699975013733,
-0.44743213057518005,
0.1141853854060173,
0.4205787181854248,
0.06009313091635704,
-0.020255833864212036,
-0.18101541697978973,
-0.8598408699035645,
0.0019483917858451605,
-0.7969583868980408,
0.38638246059417725,
-0.09587036073207855,
0.35786327719688416,
-0.36234042048454285,
0.420786052942276,
-0.042181968688964844,
0.3209952414035797,
0.3607155978679657,
-0.25711557269096375,
0.11735798418521881,
-0.022484153509140015,
-0.34992897510528564,
0.1793982982635498,
0.6887913942337036,
-0.2549054026603699,
0.3324747383594513,
-0.5872583985328674,
-0.5532582998275757,
-0.13090582191944122,
0.48842328786849976,
-0.5659486651420593,
-0.07069011777639389,
0.10253690183162689,
-0.5336465835571289,
-0.1321912407875061,
0.16961902379989624,
-0.6275224685668945,
-0.07347725331783295,
-0.6661063432693481,
0.57844078540802,
-0.29896080493927,
0.23910926282405853,
-0.021198932081460953,
0.20869144797325134,
0.37401553988456726,
0.08537331968545914,
-0.7875593304634094,
0.5304233431816101,
0.5034981966018677,
0.6845584511756897,
-0.34687063097953796,
-0.34707337617874146,
-0.3347598612308502,
0.2580612003803253,
-0.0696193277835846,
0.8995267152786255,
-0.4232436716556549,
-0.2562844157218933,
0.173707515001297,
-0.12003975361585617,
-0.26887771487236023,
-0.3378988802433014,
0.531708836555481,
-0.6611846089363098,
0.42602166533470154,
0.024431901052594185,
-0.6474905014038086,
-0.1724240481853485,
0.034584540873765945,
-0.5728045701980591,
1.1168615818023682,
0.13967835903167725,
-0.8604360222816467,
0.40093186497688293,
-0.6736022233963013,
-0.5053567290306091,
0.08980929106473923,
-0.2682362198829651,
-0.3245464861392975,
0.4299546182155609,
0.020554356276988983,
0.6778222918510437,
-0.39874210953712463,
0.3249712586402893,
-0.1451481431722641,
-0.6775340437889099,
0.7055378556251526,
-0.6619965434074402,
0.4844333827495575,
0.14134728908538818,
-0.5531762838363647,
0.0356232225894928,
-0.5629509091377258,
-0.2088554948568344,
0.03730575740337372,
-0.5712384581565857,
-0.28061527013778687,
0.21466976404190063,
0.0882255956530571,
0.45740807056427,
-0.09685787558555603,
-0.691770076751709,
0.17759674787521362,
-0.48305240273475647,
0.5087123513221741,
0.825914740562439,
-0.1958722174167633,
0.8157413005828857,
0.12426281720399857,
0.2955929934978485,
0.20327092707157135,
0.27085480093955994,
-0.33002910017967224,
0.05720467492938042,
-0.7513017058372498,
-0.18412549793720245,
0.40025052428245544,
0.35659125447273254,
-0.5676984786987305,
0.08514977246522903,
-0.27010035514831543,
-0.12404067069292068,
-0.4101645052433014,
0.1710750162601471,
0.4875977337360382,
0.9531481266021729,
0.5507550835609436,
0.13136914372444153,
-0.40716004371643066,
-0.9694768786430359,
0.04476328194141388,
0.10141322761774063,
-0.23145750164985657,
0.4012746214866638,
0.5532324314117432,
-0.27606916427612305,
1.1963222026824951,
-0.3721045255661011,
-0.44067445397377014,
-0.4204293191432953,
-0.16719044744968414,
0.29474398493766785,
0.4509478211402893,
0.37254559993743896,
-0.8758801221847534,
-0.5197489261627197,
-0.06507803499698639,
-0.8805111646652222,
0.08573500066995621,
-0.17242121696472168,
0.06215893477201462,
0.13803061842918396,
0.8164699673652649,
-0.7859646677970886,
0.5715345144271851,
0.263039231300354,
-0.16219180822372437,
0.3204255700111389,
-0.2359800934791565,
-0.38283616304397583,
-1.1510066986083984,
-0.13608591258525848,
0.10077651590108871,
-0.027111895382404327,
-0.753976583480835,
0.013146813027560711,
0.25732842087745667,
0.06716327369213104,
-0.618148148059845,
0.5845124125480652,
-0.42603716254234314,
-0.35419127345085144,
-0.22374147176742554,
0.20182839035987854,
-0.0715116485953331,
0.7126737833023071,
-0.14247025549411774,
0.6849206686019897,
0.597650408744812,
-0.6803440451622009,
-0.08969957381486893,
0.16820058226585388,
-0.46345654129981995,
0.34411925077438354,
-0.8547317385673523,
0.11451343446969986,
-0.3667248785495758,
0.3029547929763794,
-1.1242388486862183,
-0.13228768110275269,
-0.05158011615276337,
-0.164237380027771,
0.5928720831871033,
-0.06095832586288452,
-0.4446028769016266,
-0.2723270356655121,
-0.06098301708698273,
0.6554944515228271,
0.5446600317955017,
-0.7859471440315247,
0.7802271246910095,
0.4123517572879791,
0.28711140155792236,
-0.6766894459724426,
-0.7736568450927734,
-0.10474207997322083,
-0.566211462020874,
-0.2795797884464264,
0.5667446851730347,
-0.07660911977291107,
-0.3463575839996338,
0.0048148902133107185,
0.03043873980641365,
0.041073065251111984,
0.1844998449087143,
0.35810762643814087,
0.2646264433860779,
-0.28359848260879517,
0.28215229511260986,
-0.05802908539772034,
-0.23133419454097748,
0.19222916662693024,
-0.5204247832298279,
0.5620300769805908,
-0.10717040300369263,
-0.4043031632900238,
-0.36258581280708313,
0.263685941696167,
0.444420725107193,
0.02212839014828205,
0.7030779719352722,
0.37808528542518616,
-0.3465898633003235,
-0.49439260363578796,
-0.2993159294128418,
-0.3104264438152313,
-0.5102648735046387,
0.278790146112442,
-0.4677034020423889,
-0.7832936644554138,
0.6130466461181641,
-0.022250499576330185,
-0.10027183592319489,
0.4000614583492279,
0.5275753140449524,
-0.45949018001556396,
0.9859496355056763,
0.7778194546699524,
-0.165314719080925,
0.25046858191490173,
-0.3647938072681427,
0.37365439534187317,
-0.9891173243522644,
-0.6403825283050537,
-0.38911712169647217,
-0.6725258231163025,
-0.491985946893692,
-0.20075172185897827,
0.4284747242927551,
0.1886303722858429,
-0.3654288351535797,
0.05849872902035713,
-0.2529807388782501,
0.6590086817741394,
0.4744946360588074,
-0.036142438650131226,
0.1854400336742401,
0.1314893364906311,
-0.23227627575397491,
0.053673528134822845,
-0.7140915393829346,
-0.3831286132335663,
0.7508738040924072,
0.5500913858413696,
1.0531941652297974,
-0.12709000706672668,
0.4093690812587738,
0.1472630798816681,
0.17735004425048828,
-1.0035394430160522,
0.3354686200618744,
-0.1545347422361374,
-0.27556347846984863,
-0.2602981626987457,
-0.007073435932397842,
-0.9862300157546997,
0.24355265498161316,
-0.029370935633778572,
-0.6874998211860657,
0.19628749787807465,
0.1935262829065323,
-0.06850529462099075,
0.3405510187149048,
-0.6437671780586243,
0.6107280254364014,
-0.30809053778648376,
-0.23190169036388397,
0.02203705720603466,
-0.8262531757354736,
0.22730664908885956,
-0.14574801921844482,
0.14920462667942047,
0.383829802274704,
0.11641470342874527,
0.49102410674095154,
0.08853016793727875,
1.025936245918274,
-0.17283089458942413,
-0.10396713763475418,
0.20014934241771698,
0.077579066157341,
0.4575716555118561,
0.23929129540920258,
0.14778342843055725,
0.3096216022968292,
-0.4279324412345886,
-0.23434922099113464,
-0.6728920340538025,
0.46324586868286133,
-0.8882457613945007,
-0.44272536039352417,
-0.25899431109428406,
-0.7928784489631653,
-0.2056208848953247,
0.10016202926635742,
0.4355902075767517,
0.6429318189620972,
0.09010358154773712,
0.6066927313804626,
1.0266180038452148,
0.016341259703040123,
0.7064301371574402,
0.475241482257843,
-0.02034139260649681,
0.23714154958724976,
0.36243942379951477,
0.12052794545888901,
0.1853162944316864,
0.88018399477005,
0.21698015928268433,
-0.5017428994178772,
-0.5302085876464844,
-0.18818800151348114,
0.1746596246957779,
-1.0402770042419434,
-0.322860985994339,
-0.7714503407478333,
-0.4268699586391449,
-0.02038409560918808,
-0.2330852746963501,
-0.244497612118721,
-0.06406818330287933,
-0.3653045892715454,
-0.30920159816741943,
-0.07935012876987457,
1.0547575950622559,
0.33288809657096863,
0.4748196303844452,
-0.4067033529281616,
-0.029871776700019836,
0.24106529355049133,
0.3854553699493408,
0.28738024830818176,
-0.7657607197761536,
-0.5058754682540894,
0.06491530686616898,
-0.05227552354335785,
-0.44899415969848633,
0.2059960663318634,
0.09650766849517822,
0.6690438389778137,
0.5130084753036499,
-0.060233741998672485,
0.7228549122810364,
-0.6825411319732666,
0.5407334566116333,
-0.2558491826057434,
-1.0220344066619873,
0.20615066587924957,
-0.1675986498594284,
0.37880927324295044,
0.500478208065033,
0.2764389216899872,
-0.4888729155063629,
-0.13324680924415588,
-0.45320457220077515,
-0.8186304569244385,
0.8788089752197266,
-0.03164627030491829,
0.3330424427986145,
0.1571875363588333,
0.600676953792572,
0.27077776193618774,
0.14567165076732635,
-1.0412565469741821,
-0.1661652773618698,
-0.273276686668396,
-0.38109463453292847,
-0.1117170974612236,
-0.43460431694984436,
0.005841517820954323,
-0.10296939313411713,
0.3251799941062927,
-0.428395539522171,
0.5512264966964722,
-0.023970456793904305,
-0.40993791818618774,
0.06738268584012985,
0.24829347431659698,
0.45064201951026917,
0.5122066140174866,
-0.014412854798138142,
0.5537364482879639,
0.2619956135749817,
-0.2010088860988617,
-0.07756602019071579,
-0.20928487181663513,
-0.3077106475830078,
-0.2970851957798004,
0.6000698804855347,
0.9668242931365967,
0.7201336622238159,
-0.5698283910751343,
0.47322359681129456,
-0.11123796552419662,
-0.009773503988981247,
-0.44703617691993713,
-0.1370180994272232,
-0.10297192633152008,
0.4001331329345703,
0.729763388633728,
0.0027221497148275375,
0.1088486984372139,
-0.542976438999176,
0.2742845416069031,
0.5859311819076538,
-0.6387529373168945,
-0.5286641120910645,
0.5998924374580383,
-0.23219652473926544,
-0.24422746896743774,
0.815033495426178,
0.17747856676578522,
-0.4770752191543579,
0.4578351080417633,
1.021643877029419,
0.7937692999839783,
-0.05084143206477165,
0.19186609983444214,
0.021428575739264488,
0.12458907812833786,
0.1141490563750267,
-0.22802509367465973,
-0.40577247738838196,
-0.734743595123291,
-0.5447044372558594,
-0.8676862120628357,
-0.038795195519924164,
0.29257649183273315,
-0.6215924620628357,
0.12742926180362701,
-0.21413253247737885,
0.48350924253463745,
-0.18770413100719452,
-0.33360499143600464,
-0.8353906273841858,
0.2852800488471985,
0.2554779052734375,
0.949226438999176,
-0.880164623260498,
0.9093284606933594,
0.4503873288631439,
-0.16848726570606232,
-1.0290632247924805,
0.2950710952281952,
-0.25949159264564514,
-0.9737811088562012,
0.9922415614128113,
0.300738126039505,
-0.10993243008852005,
-0.06372490525245667,
-0.5317015051841736,
-1.178362488746643,
1.2090015411376953,
0.27839207649230957,
-0.367623507976532,
-0.25700441002845764,
0.34388118982315063,
0.6146838068962097,
-0.6867706775665283,
0.20919443666934967,
0.4070431888103485,
0.16615715622901917,
0.09692595154047012,
-0.5866810083389282,
-0.08594748377799988,
-0.09158472716808319,
0.13037258386611938,
0.16941173374652863,
-0.4980502426624298,
1.2043625116348267,
-0.11755841970443726,
-0.3437216877937317,
-0.2269444763660431,
0.7084973454475403,
-0.05734747648239136,
0.2560804784297943,
0.4451606273651123,
0.26283204555511475,
0.33314821124076843,
-0.1350703090429306,
1.2967572212219238,
-0.2843968868255615,
0.5296216011047363,
0.9936822652816772,
-0.22203904390335083,
0.6454402208328247,
0.4650418162345886,
-0.016509803012013435,
0.744891345500946,
0.6024259924888611,
0.016559889540076256,
0.7604289054870605,
-0.1997969001531601,
0.045148011296987534,
-0.0740029364824295,
-0.21951372921466827,
0.037009160965681076,
0.8231848478317261,
0.3124646544456482,
-0.45307493209838867,
-0.20197604596614838,
0.2713342308998108,
-0.07190944254398346,
0.007464999333024025,
-0.42610687017440796,
0.9695876240730286,
0.08628394454717636,
-0.6628971099853516,
0.24359340965747833,
-0.025873085483908653,
0.5113400816917419,
-0.5226578712463379,
0.12424711138010025,
-0.26407310366630554,
0.4730414152145386,
-0.19705133140087128,
-0.8859257102012634,
0.166483536362648,
-0.3082156479358673,
-0.4707392752170563,
-0.3098573088645935,
0.8602250814437866,
-0.5458542704582214,
-0.4205116033554077,
0.4359767735004425,
0.3740544617176056,
-0.05593709647655487,
0.15120497345924377,
-0.6167963743209839,
-0.16510972380638123,
-0.1877761334180832,
-0.42594754695892334,
0.6308251619338989,
0.5452517867088318,
-0.2481546550989151,
0.654782772064209,
0.3861381411552429,
-0.20809423923492432,
-0.03771758824586868,
0.1477808803319931,
0.9299468994140625,
-0.40893474221229553,
-0.511470377445221,
-1.0007379055023193,
0.6792175769805908,
0.12029018998146057,
-0.06526206433773041,
0.9057561755180359,
0.46407604217529297,
1.1699347496032715,
-0.13525986671447754,
0.5814860463142395,
0.17856113612651825,
0.2768019735813141,
-0.7562979459762573,
0.34585025906562805,
-0.4104033410549164,
0.19612301886081696,
-0.12289533764123917,
-1.0696725845336914,
-0.18850812315940857,
0.5982143878936768,
-0.1750853955745697,
0.10378110408782959,
0.8040450215339661,
0.42553743720054626,
-0.3227105736732483,
-0.16079199314117432,
0.27028700709342957,
0.3546595871448517,
0.2887415289878845,
0.43553733825683594,
0.8682625889778137,
-0.32612746953964233,
0.34263646602630615,
-0.39436736702919006,
0.06871069967746735,
-0.07511372864246368,
-0.6488289833068848,
-1.0602747201919556,
-0.8150802850723267,
0.17585766315460205,
-0.1612710952758789,
-0.44445016980171204,
0.8403612375259399,
0.6647835373878479,
-0.6906778812408447,
-0.2918512523174286,
-0.02895663119852543,
0.15788748860359192,
-0.02666439116001129,
-0.30136406421661377,
0.517890453338623,
-0.46034982800483704,
-0.7739502787590027,
0.5330650806427002,
0.5656036138534546,
0.05614637956023216,
-0.42413970828056335,
-0.0032788922544568777,
-0.022630881518125534,
0.09600667655467987,
0.7939757108688354,
0.04977009445428848,
-0.7345141768455505,
-0.35573023557662964,
0.07322441041469574,
-0.08590098470449448,
0.19342079758644104,
1.0874837636947632,
-1.3123681545257568,
0.09147212654352188,
0.18619944155216217,
0.6849044561386108,
0.5510241389274597,
0.07623215764760971,
0.2582114040851593,
-1.0312622785568237,
0.26572054624557495,
0.09003841131925583,
0.516205906867981,
0.35532036423683167,
-0.5384801626205444,
0.3776077628135681,
0.06817306578159332,
-0.6211754083633423,
-0.9235053062438965,
0.28991732001304626,
-0.7064741253852844,
-0.4365416169166565,
1.052423119544983,
0.05669910088181496,
-0.2652316391468048,
-0.2487967610359192,
-0.04977865889668465,
0.19778557121753693,
-0.206756129860878,
1.1047207117080688,
0.30119678378105164,
-0.21089734137058258,
-0.1380341351032257,
-0.403312623500824,
0.46465837955474854,
0.25541606545448303,
-0.5841665267944336,
-0.029327955096960068,
0.15014837682247162,
0.13437847793102264,
0.17627809941768646,
0.21672439575195312,
0.05913896858692169,
-0.07104432582855225,
-0.39542850852012634,
-0.3343240022659302,
0.01075823325663805,
-0.6228941679000854,
-0.4325903654098511,
0.3549150228500366,
-0.21942003071308136,
0.03783521428704262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00742v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00742v1 | Transforming and Combining Rewards for Aligning Large Language Models | 2024-02-01T16:39:28 | 2024-02-01T16:39:28 | Zihao Wang, Chirag Nagpal, Jonathan Berant, Jacob Eisenstein, Alex D'Amour, Sanmi Koyejo, Victor Veitch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2 | A common approach for aligning language models to human preferences is to
first learn a reward model from preference data, and then use this reward model
to update the language model. We study two closely related problems that arise
in this approach. First, any monotone transformation of the reward model
preserves preference ranking; is there a choice that is ``better'' than others?
Second, we often wish to align language models to multiple properties: how
should we combine multiple reward models? Using a probabilistic interpretation
of the alignment procedure, we identify a natural choice for transformation for
(the common case of) rewards learned from Bradley-Terry preference models. This
derived transformation has two important properties. First, it emphasizes
improving poorly-performing outputs, rather than outputs that already score
well. This mitigates both underfitting (where some prompts are not improved)
and reward hacking (where the model learns to exploit misspecification of the
reward model). Second, it enables principled aggregation of rewards by linking
summation to logical conjunction: the sum of transformed rewards corresponds to
the probability that the output is ``good'' in all measured properties, in a
sense we make precise. Experiments aligning language models to be both helpful
and harmless using RLHF show substantial improvements over the baseline
(non-transformed) approach. | [
-0.2069557011127472,
-0.3605632483959198,
0.536359429359436,
-0.01977519877254963,
-0.022251611575484276,
-0.04446708783507347,
-0.6377804279327393,
-0.5325496196746826,
0.34603258967399597,
0.6978705525398254,
-0.36227020621299744,
-0.05499657243490219,
-0.805027425289154,
-0.30900534987449646,
-0.21827003359794617,
1.2831144332885742,
-0.05123200640082359,
0.06793145090341568,
-0.2621881663799286,
-0.3349648416042328,
-0.5356056690216064,
-0.7266877293586731,
-0.5316053628921509,
-0.6205021739006042,
0.6997082233428955,
0.43385887145996094,
0.8782448768615723,
0.5382883548736572,
0.6403156518936157,
0.29868292808532715,
0.1460440307855606,
0.12534590065479279,
-0.7169439196586609,
0.08070424944162369,
-0.34642285108566284,
-0.3539469242095947,
-0.36681175231933594,
0.3218979835510254,
0.37811943888664246,
0.8186556696891785,
-0.17321626842021942,
0.014893664047122002,
0.22251522541046143,
0.8841444849967957,
-0.708943784236908,
0.13330323994159698,
-0.3811919391155243,
-0.09430080652236938,
-0.1688648760318756,
-0.3601337969303131,
-0.48529908061027527,
-0.7032104134559631,
0.03942277282476425,
-0.33720213174819946,
-0.09196930378675461,
-0.020503345876932144,
0.7592146992683411,
0.2250245213508606,
-0.5841291546821594,
-0.1657952070236206,
-0.8206318616867065,
1.2096519470214844,
-0.576060950756073,
0.2993086278438568,
0.2864352762699127,
0.4378412067890167,
-0.17807714641094208,
-0.3040049970149994,
-0.30797961354255676,
-0.33468204736709595,
-0.3020709156990051,
0.051190633326768875,
-0.004822265822440386,
-0.010379113256931305,
-0.03755262494087219,
0.43470412492752075,
-0.5802109241485596,
0.23404750227928162,
-0.19418129324913025,
-0.2455701380968094,
0.9513212442398071,
0.157022163271904,
0.28414520621299744,
0.05780801177024841,
-0.37514325976371765,
-0.7771515250205994,
-0.7214309573173523,
0.5124356150627136,
0.46454161405563354,
0.6523129940032959,
0.015145747922360897,
0.6814517974853516,
-0.1901727318763733,
0.915246844291687,
0.03651909530162811,
-0.4170306921005249,
0.1486787050962448,
-0.5173817276954651,
0.05258338153362274,
0.1857661008834839,
0.5387049317359924,
0.4355902075767517,
0.40115243196487427,
-0.2502993941307068,
-0.46988850831985474,
0.2425827980041504,
0.239522784948349,
-0.39481425285339355,
-0.2230890393257141,
0.125929594039917,
-0.6145225167274475,
-0.43864205479621887,
0.19765900075435638,
-0.43443143367767334,
-0.42561987042427063,
-0.6188702583312988,
0.488881379365921,
-0.15013496577739716,
-0.31707027554512024,
0.4805600345134735,
-0.18965978920459747,
0.2002851814031601,
0.31972402334213257,
-1.49348783493042,
0.4100828170776367,
0.8981166481971741,
0.3982122540473938,
-0.38584446907043457,
-0.3742755353450775,
-0.6741119027137756,
-0.11030467599630356,
-0.1702621728181839,
0.8834579586982727,
-0.44258397817611694,
-0.3071421682834625,
0.12802383303642273,
-0.11805278807878494,
-0.05533343553543091,
-0.6385746002197266,
0.6488826274871826,
-0.4428550601005554,
0.38155397772789,
-0.44362133741378784,
-0.6187914609909058,
0.03958713263273239,
0.2331269234418869,
-0.8409897089004517,
0.8045090436935425,
0.2547434866428375,
-0.5842553377151489,
0.29058200120925903,
-0.7162460088729858,
-0.38632601499557495,
-0.24795635044574738,
0.21440093219280243,
-0.07238442450761795,
0.14435343444347382,
0.05514807626605034,
0.16646049916744232,
-0.29062190651893616,
0.5006768107414246,
-0.21272507309913635,
-0.12971386313438416,
0.5228606462478638,
-0.25287848711013794,
0.7470583915710449,
0.18907319009304047,
-0.002675367519259453,
0.39411461353302,
-0.34170272946357727,
-0.07302349805831909,
0.14031319320201874,
-0.42865413427352905,
-0.43003326654434204,
0.07826787233352661,
0.05992259085178375,
0.0130844134837389,
0.6382641196250916,
-0.3856053650379181,
0.5887117385864258,
-0.46477070450782776,
0.13033027946949005,
0.9291365742683411,
-0.18979960680007935,
0.8546941876411438,
-0.5060983300209045,
0.39312466979026794,
0.03183220326900482,
0.23225776851177216,
0.23740540444850922,
-0.39344874024391174,
-0.6226361989974976,
-0.03215465694665909,
0.6053895354270935,
0.48536866903305054,
-0.3878076374530792,
0.5013646483421326,
-0.3492186665534973,
-0.38075706362724304,
-0.7127024531364441,
-0.033321019262075424,
0.14719898998737335,
0.3856903910636902,
0.5143126845359802,
-0.32200491428375244,
-0.39461633563041687,
-1.0386221408843994,
-0.37354907393455505,
-0.3215307891368866,
-0.01445868331938982,
0.029260165989398956,
0.025675812736153603,
0.113580122590065,
0.9178241491317749,
-0.6800698637962341,
-0.0945025309920311,
-0.18501174449920654,
0.33876940608024597,
0.37941351532936096,
0.6705908179283142,
0.5406648516654968,
-0.9277880787849426,
-0.3835298717021942,
0.16699224710464478,
-0.3203199803829193,
-0.10454723238945007,
-0.14260117709636688,
-0.057914018630981445,
0.13072699308395386,
0.07780204713344574,
-0.22075773775577545,
0.1554088145494461,
0.6299569010734558,
-0.22426052391529083,
0.618535578250885,
-0.05325239524245262,
0.5369549989700317,
-0.941927969455719,
-0.11804764717817307,
-0.090399831533432,
-0.4212915599346161,
-0.5874540209770203,
-0.02217964082956314,
0.02688787877559662,
0.07476619631052017,
-0.24340176582336426,
0.6850875616073608,
-0.12767069041728973,
-0.04210711270570755,
-0.4626884162425995,
-0.12475699931383133,
-0.14310376346111298,
0.5033352971076965,
0.14038459956645966,
0.6545895934104919,
0.45146527886390686,
-0.6087191700935364,
0.6078237295150757,
0.20800070464611053,
-0.14169035851955414,
0.4451386332511902,
-0.31508031487464905,
0.13777278363704681,
-0.08174453675746918,
-0.04188426584005356,
-0.8832122087478638,
-0.1452978551387787,
0.11788789927959442,
-0.5161487460136414,
0.2798709273338318,
0.0024009994231164455,
-0.40062159299850464,
0.07045717537403107,
-0.34692028164863586,
0.47628167271614075,
0.5588648915290833,
-0.7179855704307556,
0.282022625207901,
0.40986114740371704,
-0.23526376485824585,
-0.6728457808494568,
-0.3958403766155243,
-0.04463885352015495,
-0.3516610860824585,
-0.6169615387916565,
0.7352374196052551,
-0.23297977447509766,
-0.24114254117012024,
0.2542000412940979,
-0.06486853212118149,
0.2898358702659607,
0.18341845273971558,
-0.08663099259138107,
0.4186379313468933,
-0.20276005566120148,
0.1286972463130951,
-0.08038222789764404,
-0.5124199390411377,
-0.1765156090259552,
-0.3339124321937561,
0.5005231499671936,
-0.013772120699286461,
-0.3348456621170044,
0.09813016653060913,
0.6073574423789978,
0.4980566203594208,
-0.3602626919746399,
0.8662289977073669,
0.2540688216686249,
-0.2688993215560913,
0.16449759900569916,
-0.5164652466773987,
-0.5077846646308899,
-0.38882511854171753,
0.1698620617389679,
-0.22657878696918488,
-1.0184613466262817,
0.4012955129146576,
-0.024783605709671974,
0.19420890510082245,
0.3808838129043579,
0.5069908499717712,
0.03808647394180298,
1.2818514108657837,
0.8931987285614014,
-0.3050958216190338,
0.6385919451713562,
0.28574037551879883,
0.4671783447265625,
-0.5004308819770813,
-0.2087778002023697,
-0.7330135703086853,
-0.4351229965686798,
-0.7394609451293945,
0.014509120024740696,
0.34833618998527527,
0.12491066753864288,
-0.08559880405664444,
0.619091272354126,
-0.38047635555267334,
0.4894905388355255,
0.6607916951179504,
0.050026554614305496,
0.17636094987392426,
0.0690319687128067,
0.16714440286159515,
-0.15389515459537506,
-0.5005014538764954,
-0.5234038829803467,
1.1771258115768433,
0.16325722634792328,
0.9144094586372375,
0.3887195885181427,
0.9587046504020691,
0.15785515308380127,
0.33629998564720154,
-0.8469110727310181,
0.28090718388557434,
-0.29591354727745056,
-0.34052884578704834,
-0.5395113229751587,
-0.40734437108039856,
-0.9504241943359375,
0.04424536973237991,
-0.4592643976211548,
-0.8703034520149231,
0.28018712997436523,
0.2732354700565338,
-0.2619023323059082,
0.04355721175670624,
-0.7905952334403992,
1.0403014421463013,
-0.555335521697998,
-0.42001399397850037,
-0.3794938623905182,
-0.6795876026153564,
0.4953823685646057,
0.12711971998214722,
0.01748880371451378,
0.0078041343949735165,
0.45970478653907776,
0.7715994119644165,
-0.1863236278295517,
0.4724509119987488,
0.02676449343562126,
-0.07256819307804108,
-0.28519758582115173,
0.10198402404785156,
0.37942636013031006,
-0.2000967264175415,
-0.1614442765712738,
-0.16395410895347595,
0.08354616165161133,
-0.5876704454421997,
-0.9573425054550171,
0.6415228247642517,
-0.8880831599235535,
-0.7795429229736328,
-0.3850361108779907,
-0.7277015447616577,
-0.27040132880210876,
-0.06133722886443138,
-0.05080292001366615,
0.3636164665222168,
-0.21056392788887024,
0.031429871916770935,
0.6183750629425049,
0.013053854927420616,
0.11341305822134018,
0.19711735844612122,
-0.4435405731201172,
-0.27579835057258606,
0.8823265433311462,
-0.15295688807964325,
0.5353055000305176,
0.6269529461860657,
0.44276297092437744,
-0.5582793951034546,
-0.21361571550369263,
-0.13211041688919067,
0.2053222507238388,
-0.7882537245750427,
-0.1426379531621933,
-0.18858212232589722,
-0.14863887429237366,
-0.7639031410217285,
-0.36728397011756897,
-0.39418289065361023,
-0.6090309619903564,
-0.05990281328558922,
-0.012896096333861351,
0.14063206315040588,
0.6114612221717834,
-0.2818804383277893,
0.09573236107826233,
-0.854957640171051,
0.17101210355758667,
0.5837447643280029,
0.1474243402481079,
-0.1863909214735031,
-0.6132018566131592,
-0.30391737818717957,
0.15000437200069427,
-0.2656070590019226,
-0.9625040888786316,
0.4319964647293091,
-0.2531340718269348,
0.6629891991615295,
0.27871447801589966,
0.08770715445280075,
0.6001988649368286,
-0.1880207657814026,
0.6429120302200317,
0.44041675329208374,
-0.834620475769043,
0.31976187229156494,
0.004648096393793821,
0.054315418004989624,
0.6787258982658386,
0.34556418657302856,
-0.8383702635765076,
-0.020548230037093163,
-0.574109673500061,
-0.5744658708572388,
0.7625446319580078,
-0.0025092693977057934,
0.1046343594789505,
0.21443268656730652,
0.12889429926872253,
0.2061498463153839,
0.052958905696868896,
-1.0213134288787842,
-0.2924719750881195,
-0.33314967155456543,
-0.32621341943740845,
-0.38212546706199646,
-0.15204869210720062,
-0.42372599244117737,
-0.28622502088546753,
0.7351135611534119,
-0.12058863788843155,
0.2198020964860916,
-0.2227531373500824,
-0.20937198400497437,
-0.2015065848827362,
0.5241817831993103,
0.7261432409286499,
0.5695483684539795,
-0.326052725315094,
0.37561315298080444,
-0.3046952784061432,
0.25574755668640137,
0.36775293946266174,
0.021917106583714485,
0.2667500972747803,
-0.49678391218185425,
0.25850775837898254,
1.0282282829284668,
0.2484952211380005,
-0.40093833208084106,
0.41588786244392395,
-0.004071114584803581,
-0.055798549205064774,
0.1127299964427948,
0.21967713534832,
0.3168545365333557,
0.0664595365524292,
0.1738547384738922,
0.13751226663589478,
0.132503941655159,
-0.756827712059021,
-0.03413160890340805,
0.5442413091659546,
-0.24394474923610687,
-0.24293187260627747,
0.2212347686290741,
0.06244726479053497,
-0.49350354075431824,
0.6186329126358032,
-0.1665021777153015,
-0.7061051726341248,
0.4035481810569763,
0.7619167566299438,
0.7381333708763123,
-0.476229727268219,
0.2987954020500183,
0.44315728545188904,
0.1658705174922943,
-0.393319308757782,
-0.15595164895057678,
-0.2002154141664505,
-1.1508163213729858,
-0.27959513664245605,
-0.5111371874809265,
-0.472910612821579,
-0.12443094700574875,
-0.7019023895263672,
0.3845677077770233,
0.18235920369625092,
0.0886186808347702,
0.298753559589386,
-0.22880984842777252,
-0.4157397747039795,
-0.07545360177755356,
0.2596679627895355,
0.5077784657478333,
-1.3584498167037964,
0.9023699164390564,
0.8987703919410706,
-0.5083229541778564,
-0.9941009879112244,
-0.1068117767572403,
-0.038058411329984665,
-0.7556694746017456,
0.6437264084815979,
-0.025542793795466423,
-0.09619048237800598,
-0.02530171535909176,
-0.6808048486709595,
-0.8149070739746094,
0.6863309741020203,
0.38577184081077576,
-0.32437920570373535,
0.17670400440692902,
0.2884069085121155,
0.40799206495285034,
-0.4661141335964203,
0.18795493245124817,
0.6360648274421692,
0.6604512929916382,
0.0854664221405983,
-1.024080753326416,
-0.11345474421977997,
-0.030001714825630188,
-0.23998017609119415,
0.6117586493492126,
-0.23618502914905548,
0.6604984402656555,
-0.0449080765247345,
-0.15904979407787323,
-0.17633499205112457,
0.3975127339363098,
0.39346635341644287,
0.014664966613054276,
0.6834191679954529,
0.44774091243743896,
0.6647101640701294,
-0.13814476132392883,
0.9994935393333435,
-0.19539088010787964,
0.6506410837173462,
0.769258439540863,
-0.42599692940711975,
0.7160680890083313,
0.8457530736923218,
-0.26723554730415344,
0.4145488739013672,
0.6250146627426147,
0.4517391324043274,
0.748080849647522,
0.06138073652982712,
-0.10864733904600143,
-0.6214486360549927,
-0.13822269439697266,
-0.2725048065185547,
0.44850239157676697,
0.07024867087602615,
-0.036898039281368256,
-0.4033072888851166,
0.005637709051370621,
-0.144516259431839,
0.36223235726356506,
-0.07026424258947372,
0.9080619215965271,
-0.014258262701332569,
-1.286071538925171,
0.5127919912338257,
0.26461511850357056,
0.5345520377159119,
-0.712571382522583,
-0.12423792481422424,
-0.2536589801311493,
0.13329747319221497,
-0.22769400477409363,
-0.8565815091133118,
0.29805052280426025,
-0.26820608973503113,
-0.3455873727798462,
-0.6124107241630554,
0.7425813674926758,
-0.7872467637062073,
-0.2835666239261627,
0.27336055040359497,
0.2867966294288635,
-0.06509052962064743,
0.20739519596099854,
-0.657058596611023,
-0.00650798948481679,
0.17839162051677704,
-0.04624581336975098,
0.6594135165214539,
-0.06304969638586044,
-0.22436518967151642,
0.33126261830329895,
0.743730366230011,
0.0853310376405716,
-0.22571490705013275,
0.02094314992427826,
0.7279930114746094,
-0.6210916638374329,
-0.6670833230018616,
-0.8752915263175964,
0.6356205344200134,
-0.0450214259326458,
-0.04629601165652275,
0.3277318477630615,
0.4617858827114105,
0.7723304629325867,
-0.12748776376247406,
0.4807412922382355,
0.12258680909872055,
0.28467822074890137,
-0.7850244045257568,
0.3651333749294281,
-0.6763623356819153,
0.0650937408208847,
-0.099329873919487,
-1.0740996599197388,
-0.24817414581775665,
0.561461329460144,
-0.32855626940727234,
-0.16097965836524963,
0.8974733352661133,
0.8391063213348389,
-0.1013718768954277,
-0.06857683509588242,
0.40910911560058594,
-0.3368898630142212,
0.3477467894554138,
0.7819750905036926,
0.8078715801239014,
-0.0860312357544899,
0.03608911484479904,
-0.2789401412010193,
-0.4071173667907715,
-0.2214789241552353,
-1.0080420970916748,
-0.2055201679468155,
-0.8539724946022034,
-0.3041747212409973,
-0.32241103053092957,
-0.07772519439458847,
1.253528356552124,
0.7570268511772156,
-1.0221374034881592,
-0.6045796275138855,
0.25842610001564026,
0.3624642491340637,
-0.6027868986129761,
-0.20148035883903503,
0.2662194073200226,
-0.44347384572029114,
-0.7694126963615417,
0.3604033589363098,
0.34347376227378845,
-0.04653983935713768,
-0.24643991887569427,
-0.35501083731651306,
-0.09425430744886398,
0.08088306337594986,
0.35631048679351807,
0.4355395436286926,
-0.6558323502540588,
-0.6393608450889587,
0.19532912969589233,
-0.24360282719135284,
0.2499268651008606,
1.0601712465286255,
-0.6894209384918213,
0.4727345407009125,
0.6183682680130005,
0.8261076211929321,
0.5602667331695557,
0.16649103164672852,
0.6483088135719299,
-0.5787703394889832,
0.06404521316289902,
0.02618541195988655,
0.469597190618515,
0.39558660984039307,
-0.3727723956108093,
0.3169150948524475,
-0.01786876656115055,
-0.6680800914764404,
-0.8699638247489929,
0.6268623471260071,
-1.1955853700637817,
-0.19919312000274658,
1.0118262767791748,
0.11073988676071167,
-0.06249810755252838,
0.1083824634552002,
-0.15382395684719086,
0.2826906442642212,
-0.17783495783805847,
0.940608561038971,
0.9175014495849609,
-0.288776159286499,
-0.13516709208488464,
-0.10194608569145203,
0.45557788014411926,
0.7725265026092529,
-0.7447094321250916,
0.18692836165428162,
0.3616422414779663,
0.1923639327287674,
0.4228038787841797,
0.45619601011276245,
-0.32945096492767334,
0.34547486901283264,
-0.5619757175445557,
0.3259727656841278,
0.19704598188400269,
-0.2549987733364105,
-0.7417194843292236,
0.07673966139554977,
0.5379575490951538,
-0.17994976043701172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00723v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00723v1 | Improving Semantic Control in Discrete Latent Spaces with Transformer Quantized Variational Autoencoders | 2024-02-01T16:14:35 | 2024-02-01T16:14:35 | Yingji Zhang, Danilo S. Carvalho, Marco Valentino, Ian Pratt-Hartmann, Andre Freitas | cs.CL | cs.CL | Achieving precise semantic control over the latent spaces of Variational
AutoEncoders (VAEs) holds significant value for downstream tasks in NLP as the
underlying generative mechanisms could be better localised, explained and
improved upon. Recent research, however, has struggled to achieve consistent
results, primarily due to the inevitable loss of semantic information in the
variational bottleneck and limited control over the decoding mechanism. To
overcome these challenges, we investigate discrete latent spaces in Vector
Quantized Variational AutoEncoders (VQVAEs) to improve semantic control and
generation in Transformer-based VAEs. In particular, We propose T5VQVAE, a
novel model that leverages the controllability of VQVAEs to guide the
self-attention mechanism in T5 at the token-level, exploiting its full
generalization capabilities. Experimental results indicate that T5VQVAE
outperforms existing state-of-the-art VAE models, including Optimus, in terms
of controllability and preservation of semantic information across different
tasks such as auto-encoding of sentences and mathematical expressions, text
transfer, and inference. Moreover, T5VQVAE exhibits improved inference
capabilities, suggesting potential applications for downstream natural language
and symbolic reasoning tasks. | [
-0.28532037138938904,
-0.13420706987380981,
0.30838194489479065,
0.2666519582271576,
-0.16107933223247528,
0.027391821146011353,
0.07003738731145859,
0.020690854638814926,
-0.08092319220304489,
0.5124830603599548,
-0.5472912788391113,
-0.5915520191192627,
-0.6196958422660828,
0.10920081287622452,
-0.43467819690704346,
0.5330860018730164,
-0.33323562145233154,
-0.408719539642334,
-0.32071036100387573,
-0.15053988993167877,
-0.5043062567710876,
-0.5113977193832397,
-0.07182701677083969,
-0.10428411513566971,
0.5035445094108582,
-0.16111180186271667,
0.6818104386329651,
0.5114893317222595,
0.3440413773059845,
0.31319865584373474,
-0.11672089993953705,
-0.03816940262913704,
-0.47188156843185425,
0.04441613703966141,
-0.39715567231178284,
-0.7488833665847778,
-0.2836045026779175,
-0.4391818940639496,
0.4969537854194641,
0.4677630662918091,
-0.5975018739700317,
-0.3861925005912781,
-0.2212023288011551,
0.24055427312850952,
-0.9774237275123596,
0.13721561431884766,
-0.4428532123565674,
0.29275229573249817,
0.1452445089817047,
-0.023869670927524567,
-0.18194355070590973,
-0.051582518965005875,
-0.0183268990367651,
-0.7443411350250244,
0.38235408067703247,
-0.27825120091438293,
0.924591600894928,
0.8791194558143616,
-0.41343429684638977,
0.25503775477409363,
-0.9383037686347961,
0.7609257698059082,
-0.669233500957489,
0.6190717220306396,
0.2955843508243561,
0.36376282572746277,
-0.09071743488311768,
-1.0895062685012817,
-0.6637769937515259,
0.035242959856987,
-0.07516054809093475,
0.3939981460571289,
-0.6688694357872009,
0.17393849790096283,
0.28914928436279297,
0.4394494891166687,
-0.3938359022140503,
0.09705884009599686,
-0.07452888786792755,
-0.15029777586460114,
0.19752581417560577,
0.19315606355667114,
0.23686766624450684,
-0.40036118030548096,
-0.4685947000980377,
-0.29786837100982666,
-0.3799353539943695,
0.10770717263221741,
-0.15040753781795502,
-0.3492085337638855,
-0.03915565833449364,
0.4952017366886139,
-0.32581108808517456,
0.5014119148254395,
0.12721092998981476,
0.3363688588142395,
0.14632606506347656,
-0.5196188688278198,
-0.42096543312072754,
-0.6051602363586426,
0.8573696613311768,
0.15363699197769165,
-0.19832271337509155,
-0.5362995862960815,
-0.23430240154266357,
0.336456298828125,
0.7483458518981934,
-0.6379082202911377,
-0.20045208930969238,
0.43516451120376587,
-0.39319467544555664,
-0.2741222083568573,
0.008485418744385242,
-0.30588775873184204,
0.03170131519436836,
-0.4123326241970062,
0.3784901797771454,
-0.7596587538719177,
-0.18960994482040405,
0.29566940665245056,
-0.2895866334438324,
0.872675895690918,
0.3473893702030182,
-1.1721609830856323,
0.5273462533950806,
0.43441662192344666,
0.499312162399292,
-0.3767918646335602,
-0.10751538723707199,
-0.2833687365055084,
0.35991254448890686,
-0.4858659505844116,
0.39474815130233765,
-0.464539498090744,
-0.559036910533905,
-0.197297602891922,
-0.09352197498083115,
-0.06764304637908936,
-0.5091044306755066,
0.38206541538238525,
-0.6493891477584839,
0.4001450836658478,
0.052823614329099655,
-0.6314802169799805,
0.026844540610909462,
0.022642651572823524,
-0.670572817325592,
0.8792529106140137,
0.34443023800849915,
-0.5394964814186096,
0.3685206174850464,
-0.39950478076934814,
-0.025872457772493362,
0.08553138375282288,
-0.6146451830863953,
-0.5729616284370422,
0.42845606803894043,
0.3725474774837494,
0.41549554467201233,
-0.1654881238937378,
0.2195378988981247,
-0.0883556455373764,
-0.0893160030245781,
0.1842840164899826,
-0.5659266114234924,
0.37312138080596924,
-0.08608731627464294,
-0.7422345876693726,
0.40128445625305176,
-0.6585087776184082,
-0.037182558327913284,
-0.0643090084195137,
0.1512584537267685,
-0.42495131492614746,
0.12472739070653915,
-0.2688462734222412,
0.4837856590747833,
0.1224919781088829,
-0.34540942311286926,
0.2505086064338684,
-0.49038174748420715,
0.48323944211006165,
0.5397793054580688,
0.10512197017669678,
0.6658289432525635,
-0.10683110356330872,
0.689784586429596,
0.24253211915493011,
0.31417590379714966,
-0.035669922828674316,
-0.038364458829164505,
-0.9306204915046692,
-0.2347353994846344,
0.503081202507019,
0.38403287529945374,
-1.18610680103302,
0.6737179756164551,
-0.25834161043167114,
-0.09231982380151749,
-0.6329833269119263,
-0.23273560404777527,
0.2102082520723343,
0.2526048421859741,
0.48023849725723267,
-0.35478317737579346,
0.01305130124092102,
-0.8512202501296997,
0.04674287885427475,
0.3723592758178711,
-0.4610888361930847,
0.3576827347278595,
0.4953483045101166,
-0.3027895987033844,
1.118269681930542,
-0.2126031517982483,
-0.26367226243019104,
0.32632479071617126,
0.22824856638908386,
-0.15097272396087646,
0.46281135082244873,
0.35690346360206604,
-1.1931403875350952,
-0.04832787811756134,
-0.15928591787815094,
-0.6466739177703857,
-0.19296038150787354,
-0.1612321436405182,
-0.2657116651535034,
0.07049872726202011,
0.6130739450454712,
-0.5732929110527039,
0.6918798685073853,
0.30865705013275146,
-0.49395519495010376,
0.13422556221485138,
-0.32996636629104614,
-0.15819935500621796,
-0.9124161005020142,
-0.08809199929237366,
-0.41300836205482483,
-0.4814643859863281,
-0.2077147364616394,
-0.08801814168691635,
0.39212989807128906,
0.1771065592765808,
-0.36139795184135437,
0.17718090116977692,
-0.22377103567123413,
-0.0004959988873451948,
-0.3297199308872223,
-0.020982353016734123,
0.0338665135204792,
0.6382868885993958,
0.15652956068515778,
0.684380292892456,
0.46460026502609253,
-0.6947664022445679,
0.36854875087738037,
0.23854225873947144,
0.26851531863212585,
0.5017887949943542,
-0.7766385078430176,
-0.1061885803937912,
-0.2971469759941101,
0.16822409629821777,
-0.8081729412078857,
0.009773253463208675,
-0.002453839173540473,
-0.596586287021637,
0.2984253764152527,
0.26152846217155457,
-0.26964470744132996,
-0.2746000587940216,
-0.21534797549247742,
0.22019968926906586,
0.6045514941215515,
-0.4129030704498291,
1.083046793937683,
0.011649268679320812,
0.25745081901550293,
-0.5065521597862244,
-0.6023369431495667,
0.021843038499355316,
-0.13480156660079956,
-0.32969003915786743,
0.806581437587738,
0.03683418780565262,
0.010411640629172325,
0.3755335211753845,
-0.28432267904281616,
0.07877408713102341,
-0.0031184572726488113,
0.16422079503536224,
-0.017268463969230652,
-0.0400439091026783,
0.39582544565200806,
0.29373130202293396,
-0.5180561542510986,
0.10242955386638641,
-0.9876073598861694,
0.3510003089904785,
-0.04089420661330223,
-0.2618405222892761,
-0.3998349905014038,
0.43606042861938477,
0.6188170909881592,
-0.5239272117614746,
0.7605410814285278,
0.7195354700088501,
-0.35140925645828247,
-0.5297955274581909,
-0.20973503589630127,
-0.14162606000900269,
-0.4923352599143982,
0.2592960000038147,
-0.7633001804351807,
-1.1899694204330444,
0.37145060300827026,
-0.2191716581583023,
-0.1669059842824936,
0.8977050185203552,
0.7772111296653748,
-0.09330661594867706,
0.793947696685791,
0.9845435619354248,
0.16635307669639587,
0.5096020698547363,
-0.5481562614440918,
0.0018940854351967573,
-0.7735512852668762,
-0.3258865475654602,
-0.24845239520072937,
0.044201456010341644,
-1.0205317735671997,
-0.9671427607536316,
0.31080856919288635,
0.047150030732154846,
-0.14191925525665283,
0.18478567898273468,
-0.552639365196228,
0.2962615191936493,
0.5442315340042114,
-0.137093186378479,
0.08751200884580612,
-0.20980262756347656,
-0.24498867988586426,
-0.3615058660507202,
-1.1041793823242188,
-0.3042278587818146,
0.6761946082115173,
0.2829112410545349,
0.8095859289169312,
0.3314272463321686,
0.5693585276603699,
0.34388017654418945,
-0.17573858797550201,
-0.5426033735275269,
0.10657164454460144,
-0.4438591003417969,
0.10012645274400711,
-0.5158913731575012,
-0.34867045283317566,
-1.0094869136810303,
0.588623583316803,
-0.05646450072526932,
-0.5958651900291443,
0.6395772099494934,
0.028880339115858078,
-0.4448370635509491,
0.041379280388355255,
-0.46887102723121643,
0.9042914509773254,
-0.001949236961081624,
-0.517306923866272,
-0.04720829799771309,
-0.8647250533103943,
0.0024586250074207783,
0.016821976751089096,
-0.09501897543668747,
0.1133776307106018,
-0.43227341771125793,
0.2821657657623291,
-0.7676243782043457,
1.0411081314086914,
0.06644802540540695,
-0.3028349280357361,
0.04901150241494179,
-0.10546883940696716,
0.46404752135276794,
-0.0026672903914004564,
0.38352829217910767,
0.07200802862644196,
-0.11494562774896622,
-0.7497665882110596,
-0.9601005911827087,
0.4864204525947571,
-1.0725260972976685,
-0.3285020589828491,
-0.2641662657260895,
-0.2869011163711548,
-0.11231055110692978,
0.1542891412973404,
0.49513983726501465,
0.21659722924232483,
-0.12028280645608902,
0.4134463965892792,
1.148454189300537,
-0.31416580080986023,
0.6912103891372681,
0.4142622947692871,
0.0726667195558548,
-0.4246674180030823,
0.8949797749519348,
-0.03021051548421383,
0.40231063961982727,
0.9646652936935425,
0.06665041297674179,
-0.4285915493965149,
-0.2966947853565216,
-0.22221122682094574,
0.10594884306192398,
-0.539197564125061,
-0.13434183597564697,
-0.8248986005783081,
-0.262451708316803,
-0.44064462184906006,
-0.13868790864944458,
-0.6339909434318542,
-0.42630743980407715,
-0.4481250047683716,
0.07451293617486954,
0.11324820667505264,
0.5466471314430237,
0.01036597415804863,
0.3822954595088959,
-0.5528005361557007,
0.6750259399414062,
0.6728767156600952,
0.426627516746521,
-0.24442720413208008,
-0.35129809379577637,
0.053669486194849014,
-0.39229467511177063,
-0.09646844118833542,
-0.7183225750923157,
0.6111534833908081,
-0.05242957919836044,
0.4174714684486389,
-0.037880267947912216,
0.07586224377155304,
0.11099715530872345,
-0.4194779396057129,
0.7583340406417847,
0.12388226389884949,
-1.2199889421463013,
0.4110746681690216,
-0.5066195130348206,
0.7502733469009399,
-0.012675181031227112,
0.18430331349372864,
-0.47565045952796936,
-0.48128023743629456,
-1.0469584465026855,
-1.0901798009872437,
0.47279396653175354,
0.8790931701660156,
0.28393876552581787,
0.2835792303085327,
0.3498777449131012,
0.0034261904656887054,
0.5212271809577942,
-0.6615468263626099,
-0.08342425525188446,
-0.701589822769165,
-0.2669239044189453,
0.2811827063560486,
-0.2775716483592987,
0.004119121469557285,
0.03688512369990349,
0.30429935455322266,
-0.21233728528022766,
0.5474634170532227,
0.3973047137260437,
0.24095569550991058,
0.12780050933361053,
0.2754845917224884,
0.5115493535995483,
0.38107168674468994,
0.14232444763183594,
0.2593006193637848,
0.28208693861961365,
-0.23545433580875397,
0.12389037013053894,
0.2775094211101532,
-0.21624313294887543,
-0.02958134189248085,
0.2720411717891693,
1.2677643299102783,
0.09226903319358826,
-0.20410145819187164,
0.6641950011253357,
-0.534695029258728,
-0.24555982649326324,
-0.49009111523628235,
0.39062684774398804,
-0.10032476484775543,
0.27409231662750244,
0.0493195578455925,
-0.19374629855155945,
0.14075294137001038,
0.21096055209636688,
0.35687851905822754,
0.05327697470784187,
-0.27706190943717957,
-0.11781132966279984,
1.0444457530975342,
0.08705884218215942,
-0.12549886107444763,
0.4776698350906372,
-0.025976018980145454,
-0.3587726652622223,
0.6519339084625244,
0.40269801020622253,
0.9883261322975159,
-0.40442895889282227,
0.07603442668914795,
-0.04994315654039383,
0.34478721022605896,
0.4074607491493225,
0.34518569707870483,
-0.45191237330436707,
-0.696538507938385,
-0.7051900625228882,
-0.6580846905708313,
-0.4127963185310364,
0.04140979051589966,
-0.5583575367927551,
0.08636842668056488,
-0.17992998659610748,
0.023156853392720222,
0.04751630872488022,
-0.49155858159065247,
-0.64234858751297,
0.6139281988143921,
0.18452970683574677,
0.5661211013793945,
-0.5414300560951233,
0.8423746824264526,
0.3806530237197876,
-0.4229488670825958,
-0.8651273846626282,
0.032532431185245514,
-0.5665547251701355,
-0.29845425486564636,
0.3927515745162964,
-0.2508348226547241,
-0.30534425377845764,
0.24843421578407288,
-0.6468713879585266,
-1.1764588356018066,
1.2215909957885742,
0.051900461316108704,
-0.6848333477973938,
-0.0733494982123375,
0.14135344326496124,
0.7750533223152161,
-0.08517231047153473,
0.208527073264122,
0.41376543045043945,
0.15373308956623077,
0.26908329129219055,
-0.7097178101539612,
-0.15078331530094147,
-0.2677641808986664,
0.7039309740066528,
0.4097576439380646,
-0.8100816011428833,
0.5842208862304688,
0.25752151012420654,
0.16124886274337769,
-0.28832805156707764,
1.220628023147583,
-0.15961524844169617,
-0.2918432056903839,
0.36341598629951477,
0.6330655217170715,
0.7340077757835388,
-0.0842207744717598,
1.4607335329055786,
-0.2001039981842041,
0.4097018539905548,
1.0289161205291748,
0.16050729155540466,
0.6170399188995361,
0.439095675945282,
-0.20359036326408386,
0.49244391918182373,
0.4026799499988556,
0.029387924820184708,
0.6419994831085205,
0.23068031668663025,
-0.41210243105888367,
-0.27759262919425964,
-0.03855649009346962,
-0.08838362246751785,
0.589091956615448,
0.6026266813278198,
-0.31644052267074585,
-0.06717325001955032,
0.2745390832424164,
-0.24621611833572388,
-0.05973207578063011,
-0.10211845487356186,
0.8839689493179321,
0.18550866842269897,
-0.40946662425994873,
0.7962807416915894,
0.19442012906074524,
0.43618056178092957,
-0.6040586233139038,
-0.04482598975300789,
-0.14351649582386017,
0.16735120117664337,
-0.011048835702240467,
-0.3163861930370331,
0.5565499663352966,
-0.2394382804632187,
-0.34812912344932556,
-0.3737178146839142,
0.7943822145462036,
-0.40385666489601135,
-0.10106078535318375,
0.2400018870830536,
0.4131784439086914,
-0.3603457510471344,
-0.009365365840494633,
-0.431963711977005,
-0.15358150005340576,
-0.2056230753660202,
-0.3023931384086609,
0.05803461745381355,
0.7291373014450073,
-0.34980645775794983,
0.4867056906223297,
0.29437872767448425,
-0.1822085827589035,
0.4345358908176422,
0.11850912123918533,
1.1015788316726685,
-0.9743179678916931,
-0.7263749241828918,
-0.6553896069526672,
0.5434619188308716,
-0.05392206087708473,
-0.31643372774124146,
0.5560446977615356,
0.12891067564487457,
0.9338952302932739,
-0.09148593246936798,
1.0251450538635254,
-0.12308883666992188,
0.14975440502166748,
-0.5692205429077148,
0.4365343153476715,
-0.5681581497192383,
0.05334552004933357,
0.11543513089418411,
-0.49531105160713196,
-0.39722976088523865,
0.4970918297767639,
-0.2874143123626709,
0.05996192246675491,
0.7287054061889648,
0.4402104318141937,
-0.01526615209877491,
-0.30079689621925354,
0.732171356678009,
0.3576469123363495,
0.5377615690231323,
0.6512105464935303,
0.7372855544090271,
-0.3633330166339874,
0.2463681846857071,
-0.3158697783946991,
-0.10464560240507126,
0.07049897313117981,
-0.7730892896652222,
-0.6393255591392517,
-0.5184440612792969,
-0.39600494503974915,
-0.24981682002544403,
0.0011719028698280454,
0.524387776851654,
0.586288571357727,
-0.7405079007148743,
0.15687881410121918,
-0.7941726446151733,
0.10093311220407486,
0.014237225987017155,
-0.2206595093011856,
0.5100408792495728,
-0.6314838528633118,
-0.8187078237533569,
0.060783106833696365,
0.588051974773407,
0.30530238151550293,
-0.34652042388916016,
0.1384717971086502,
0.2011091709136963,
0.13754650950431824,
0.6433699131011963,
0.15666131675243378,
-0.9122379422187805,
0.08900878578424454,
0.1868104785680771,
-0.5231161117553711,
0.10072525590658188,
0.8470766544342041,
-1.0837126970291138,
0.7285131216049194,
0.5080797672271729,
0.7656895518302917,
0.8001525402069092,
-0.06894586235284805,
0.9925678372383118,
-0.7778887748718262,
0.024054214358329773,
0.5833768248558044,
0.03941991552710533,
0.19957411289215088,
-0.2649073302745819,
0.4545736610889435,
0.36113250255584717,
-0.40248173475265503,
-0.00630965968593955,
0.1666828989982605,
-0.9706617593765259,
-0.42290616035461426,
1.0204092264175415,
-0.06905502825975418,
-0.6112523078918457,
0.027548285201191902,
-0.07785654067993164,
0.45344167947769165,
-0.24677735567092896,
0.6876638531684875,
0.5435934066772461,
-0.12106364965438843,
-0.37732547521591187,
-0.5315148830413818,
0.7161863446235657,
0.754711389541626,
-0.9590665698051453,
-0.1376558095216751,
0.46161845326423645,
-0.05473218858242035,
-0.09017124027013779,
0.6028016209602356,
-0.0983271449804306,
0.3444656431674957,
-0.025157423689961433,
0.39845845103263855,
0.28299975395202637,
-0.13046111166477203,
-0.7727487087249756,
0.33052870631217957,
-0.1991741955280304,
-0.40922248363494873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.00711v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.00711v2 | Explaining Text Classifiers with Counterfactual Representations | 2024-02-01T16:06:35 | 2024-04-29T16:04:38 | Pirmin Lemberger, Antoine Saillenfest | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, 62Fxx | One well motivated explanation method for classifiers leverages
counterfactuals which are hypothetical events identical to real observations in
all aspects except for one categorical feature. Constructing such
counterfactual poses specific challenges for texts, however, as some attribute
values may not necessarily align with plausible real-world events. In this
paper we propose a simple method for generating counterfactuals by intervening
in the space of text representations which bypasses this limitation. We argue
that our interventions are minimally disruptive and that they are theoretically
sound as they align with counterfactuals as defined in Pearl's causal inference
framework. To validate our method, we conducted experiments first on a
synthetic dataset and then on a realistic dataset of counterfactuals. This
allows for a direct comparison between classifier predictions based on ground
truth counterfactuals - obtained through explicit text interventions - and our
counterfactuals, derived through interventions in the representation space.
Eventually, we study a real world scenario where our counterfactuals can be
leveraged both for explaining a classifier and for bias mitigation. | [
-0.3651777505874634,
-0.9538969993591309,
0.888272225856781,
-0.05875327065587044,
-0.2588960826396942,
-0.36430591344833374,
0.04201947897672653,
-0.3030555248260498,
0.09214860200881958,
0.21244366466999054,
-0.8443427085876465,
-0.06377682834863663,
-0.4470149576663971,
-0.04045256972312927,
-0.48300474882125854,
1.232182502746582,
-0.230638325214386,
-0.1360643357038498,
-0.4328768253326416,
-0.2233283966779709,
-0.7279431223869324,
-0.6344729065895081,
-0.2614224851131439,
-0.5364612340927124,
0.651719331741333,
0.36584895849227905,
0.7761265635490417,
0.45848092436790466,
0.14830733835697174,
0.29464685916900635,
0.23650704324245453,
0.07945431768894196,
-0.5541478395462036,
0.01812414824962616,
-0.40847766399383545,
-0.4988856017589569,
0.024119723588228226,
0.45361435413360596,
0.3630172908306122,
0.614223062992096,
0.20144568383693695,
-0.05493304878473282,
0.1718290001153946,
0.30075281858444214,
-0.6023027896881104,
0.06136568263173103,
-0.5502328872680664,
0.3440359830856323,
0.02870415337383747,
-0.3306640386581421,
-0.6574306488037109,
-0.22486041486263275,
0.2478531152009964,
-0.8574676513671875,
0.38885536789894104,
0.030245743691921234,
0.8440465331077576,
0.3600634038448334,
-0.5515605211257935,
-0.26472145318984985,
-0.9152829647064209,
0.9690735936164856,
-0.15761637687683105,
0.2041613608598709,
0.29245084524154663,
0.1472114473581314,
-0.009065048769116402,
-0.4395299553871155,
-0.9831563234329224,
0.10759682208299637,
-0.5198769569396973,
0.3517613708972931,
-0.317533016204834,
-0.2165234237909317,
0.4168730080127716,
0.10755178332328796,
-0.7165101170539856,
0.0600685216486454,
-0.05477548763155937,
-0.24835313856601715,
0.5767833590507507,
0.09472565352916718,
0.2777056396007538,
-0.006062986329197884,
-0.4777396619319916,
-0.14570441842079163,
-0.7733266949653625,
-0.0332820862531662,
0.20758186280727386,
0.27394169569015503,
-0.20931462943553925,
0.47737789154052734,
0.3265877664089203,
0.3194907605648041,
0.17630267143249512,
0.05117739364504814,
-0.0008074197685346007,
-0.16169610619544983,
-0.391831636428833,
0.49093014001846313,
0.7090740203857422,
0.3553882837295532,
0.279729425907135,
-0.09732772409915924,
0.04305814206600189,
0.7119672894477844,
0.5034000873565674,
-0.8734190464019775,
-0.037586014717817307,
0.2327059507369995,
-0.6070360541343689,
-0.7420538663864136,
-0.25202393531799316,
-0.8064400553703308,
-0.541154682636261,
-0.1593410223722458,
0.8579511642456055,
-0.0024755310732871294,
-0.011153184808790684,
-0.20665930211544037,
-0.27249258756637573,
-0.16954608261585236,
0.23065915703773499,
-0.8674278855323792,
0.20875892043113708,
0.3848329782485962,
0.5628554224967957,
0.23697109520435333,
-0.06666334718465805,
-0.46095773577690125,
0.1542886346578598,
-0.6054484844207764,
0.7311179041862488,
-0.8273550868034363,
-0.6064356565475464,
0.04367499426007271,
0.02818090282380581,
-0.006077084690332413,
-0.2915044128894806,
0.5108883380889893,
-0.2894146144390106,
0.6528853178024292,
-0.6084898710250854,
-0.680730402469635,
-0.25851261615753174,
0.2564923167228699,
-0.5743855237960815,
1.073896884918213,
-0.3276407718658447,
-0.8354782462120056,
0.6549805998802185,
-0.796212375164032,
-0.4256628751754761,
-0.25398895144462585,
-0.29788848757743835,
-0.755024254322052,
0.011497928760945797,
0.1903848946094513,
0.3053045868873596,
-0.05151943117380142,
0.5808961391448975,
-0.21057763695716858,
-0.519331157207489,
0.5633395910263062,
-0.9830182790756226,
0.5559091567993164,
-0.07330003380775452,
-0.5339609980583191,
-0.0389595553278923,
-0.655005931854248,
-0.4583819806575775,
0.17384734749794006,
0.07439175248146057,
-0.6841515302658081,
0.25020864605903625,
0.080619215965271,
0.14712268114089966,
0.07960252463817596,
-0.6932807564735413,
0.22787146270275116,
-0.2321024090051651,
0.013502927497029305,
0.761512279510498,
0.11730485409498215,
0.4301440119743347,
-0.41995155811309814,
0.26990678906440735,
0.23053522408008575,
-0.01129043847322464,
-0.42679712176322937,
-0.4103383421897888,
-0.5254396200180054,
-0.21880336105823517,
0.15537641942501068,
0.45502087473869324,
-0.7438713908195496,
0.05018463730812073,
-0.15223880112171173,
-0.29535603523254395,
-0.016815567389130592,
-0.09569686651229858,
0.6434730887413025,
0.8848599791526794,
0.5250235795974731,
0.17737966775894165,
-0.8891947269439697,
-0.8832128047943115,
-0.6192487478256226,
-0.46339020133018494,
0.05620675906538963,
0.17290715873241425,
0.6194479465484619,
-0.19155140221118927,
1.2126892805099487,
-0.616509735584259,
-0.09976483881473541,
-0.10456851124763489,
0.6402128338813782,
0.1393209993839264,
0.7669203281402588,
0.700904369354248,
-1.2603111267089844,
-0.15126751363277435,
-0.21541255712509155,
-1.0489223003387451,
-0.24265754222869873,
-0.7137032151222229,
-0.01564747467637062,
0.2806359529495239,
0.6211787462234497,
-0.33897751569747925,
0.8376702666282654,
0.19367927312850952,
-0.4613354504108429,
0.5408745408058167,
0.05613226816058159,
0.18094591796398163,
-0.6230347156524658,
0.0072483522817492485,
0.12178514897823334,
-0.24780841171741486,
-0.8997757434844971,
-0.08105161041021347,
-0.004985546227544546,
-0.033284444361925125,
-0.25950396060943604,
0.6438190340995789,
0.2031814604997635,
0.313122034072876,
-0.15030640363693237,
0.3059718906879425,
0.04698989912867546,
0.47066354751586914,
0.43376293778419495,
0.6435229778289795,
0.10994987189769745,
-0.5640302896499634,
-0.14952415227890015,
0.22440366446971893,
0.0982678234577179,
0.7506254315376282,
-0.6128175854682922,
-0.35673731565475464,
-0.4418089985847473,
0.3598381578922272,
-1.2364572286605835,
-0.062275469303131104,
0.29943200945854187,
-0.32954058051109314,
-0.017176609486341476,
-0.2702811658382416,
-0.3196134865283966,
-0.16584943234920502,
-0.4019714593887329,
0.46351876854896545,
0.5150288343429565,
-0.9002878665924072,
0.5910260081291199,
0.031038440763950348,
0.2123948186635971,
-0.38651326298713684,
-0.9477581977844238,
0.017185047268867493,
-0.5781802535057068,
-0.05800975486636162,
0.4211619794368744,
-0.22319094836711884,
-0.2764384150505066,
0.08997607976198196,
-0.3278406262397766,
0.04979152977466583,
0.1975494921207428,
0.5691291689872742,
0.5257793664932251,
-0.12937934696674347,
0.5534366965293884,
0.39168044924736023,
-0.28669866919517517,
0.2447655200958252,
-0.22101138532161713,
0.08908247202634811,
0.1995033174753189,
-0.355642706155777,
-0.44063058495521545,
0.2526364326477051,
0.08156835287809372,
0.31293249130249023,
0.7868591547012329,
0.4945276379585266,
-0.5323994159698486,
-0.004721431992948055,
-0.30393847823143005,
-0.06970434635877609,
-0.48615410923957825,
0.18106266856193542,
-0.4539911448955536,
-0.52586430311203,
0.44005128741264343,
-0.08308095484972,
0.19112904369831085,
0.43565675616264343,
0.39961567521095276,
-0.1760423481464386,
1.1550792455673218,
0.6273263096809387,
0.24626335501670837,
0.528031051158905,
-0.010214758105576038,
0.43117424845695496,
-0.3688121438026428,
-0.29443904757499695,
-0.5191370248794556,
-0.18927223980426788,
-0.657156229019165,
-0.27387216687202454,
0.29284965991973877,
-0.04343566671013832,
-0.3835640847682953,
0.27755019068717957,
-0.34431973099708557,
0.522028386592865,
0.3782554268836975,
0.20266778767108917,
0.12823426723480225,
-0.030750775709748268,
-0.32657888531684875,
-0.43238866329193115,
-0.7599369287490845,
-0.7703728675842285,
0.7819162607192993,
0.16610056161880493,
0.6560551524162292,
0.13511887192726135,
0.721940815448761,
0.4111033082008362,
0.7684649229049683,
-0.6319728493690491,
0.31182581186294556,
-0.2522079050540924,
-0.7020021080970764,
-0.2621390223503113,
-0.27996018528938293,
-0.7786082029342651,
0.476717084646225,
-0.6382290720939636,
-0.718752384185791,
0.5448546409606934,
0.4147748053073883,
-0.09696201235055923,
0.060024142265319824,
-0.7008681297302246,
1.0976359844207764,
0.15480823814868927,
-0.6791698336601257,
-0.2988955080509186,
-0.26387718319892883,
0.31451621651649475,
-0.08420296013355255,
0.5659985542297363,
0.43864426016807556,
0.10592435300350189,
0.6880748271942139,
-0.670455813407898,
1.30299711227417,
-0.3390468955039978,
-0.23016008734703064,
0.13843591511249542,
0.30490922927856445,
0.3454858660697937,
0.0391576811671257,
0.0731472373008728,
-0.1456802785396576,
-0.1524689793586731,
-0.42523348331451416,
-0.8311862945556641,
0.5523969531059265,
-0.6426857113838196,
-0.5736921429634094,
-0.4105566442012787,
-0.4098317623138428,
-0.31071576476097107,
0.15058045089244843,
0.2116313874721527,
0.8150891661643982,
-0.5932026505470276,
-0.18549275398254395,
0.938148558139801,
-0.27910274267196655,
0.7068920135498047,
0.43290063738822937,
-0.26855891942977905,
0.05182012915611267,
0.97320556640625,
0.1263161301612854,
-0.07557398080825806,
0.5551919341087341,
0.5315291881561279,
-0.4847525358200073,
-0.007059396710246801,
-0.55120849609375,
-0.2459847629070282,
-0.7143594026565552,
-0.057832133024930954,
-0.5960180163383484,
0.11868755519390106,
-0.09856157004833221,
-0.5196106433868408,
0.04847855865955353,
-0.4813019931316376,
-0.38153916597366333,
-0.20379313826560974,
0.260562539100647,
0.8094176054000854,
-0.1925978809595108,
0.4758196771144867,
-0.5724419355392456,
0.5440050959587097,
0.6496796011924744,
0.10267055034637451,
0.24843832850456238,
-0.4570395350456238,
-0.21648059785366058,
0.08989347517490387,
-0.31325972080230713,
-0.9641204476356506,
0.14512206614017487,
0.12672889232635498,
0.49629083275794983,
0.583026111125946,
0.2100350260734558,
0.9810863733291626,
-0.693461537361145,
0.8834803104400635,
0.2040826976299286,
-1.3582086563110352,
0.6388627290725708,
-0.19617591798305511,
0.030897971242666245,
0.27092671394348145,
0.7355554103851318,
-0.5340492725372314,
-0.4271396994590759,
-0.7131386995315552,
-0.48074987530708313,
0.5261954069137573,
0.32079756259918213,
0.19164526462554932,
0.011377970688045025,
0.33087825775146484,
0.22007474303245544,
0.12336204200983047,
-0.9928369522094727,
-0.22458234429359436,
-0.7375941276550293,
-0.5410443544387817,
-0.03391338139772415,
-0.3590480387210846,
-0.23103637993335724,
0.08985484391450882,
0.7828406095504761,
-0.09521322697401047,
-0.06659866869449615,
0.5898851752281189,
-0.4447343647480011,
-0.09657546132802963,
0.25657424330711365,
0.707883358001709,
0.4203965365886688,
0.17689299583435059,
0.48273777961730957,
0.17696887254714966,
-0.3552865982055664,
0.1867712438106537,
0.022014141082763672,
-0.2812553644180298,
0.11277911067008972,
0.8563245534896851,
0.5527889728546143,
0.41714248061180115,
-0.5811142325401306,
0.5443689227104187,
-0.07748769968748093,
-0.11709924787282944,
-0.119377002120018,
-0.02033366449177265,
-0.1725238561630249,
0.12107409536838531,
0.496920645236969,
0.09657569229602814,
0.24563603103160858,
-0.7141867280006409,
0.1909690946340561,
0.2936231791973114,
-0.5806654691696167,
-0.25254344940185547,
0.9352028965950012,
0.06255815178155899,
0.01493404433131218,
0.06556800752878189,
-0.1993875354528427,
-0.7732219099998474,
0.5916072130203247,
0.7154844999313354,
0.5961192846298218,
-0.12511952221393585,
0.3747729957103729,
0.3131103813648224,
0.3631340265274048,
0.04029998183250427,
0.21159318089485168,
-0.15573154389858246,
-0.8264371752738953,
-0.3234393000602722,
-0.21277035772800446,
-0.42687615752220154,
-0.09065975993871689,
-0.5489266514778137,
0.01648588851094246,
-0.36475494503974915,
0.11506043374538422,
0.3070794641971588,
-0.08219097554683685,
-0.43757086992263794,
0.48940935730934143,
0.03894650936126709,
0.6416270136833191,
-1.4580990076065063,
0.454547643661499,
0.6614795327186584,
-0.4375579357147217,
-0.3304072320461273,
0.2951716184616089,
0.2802604138851166,
-0.6220805644989014,
0.7609891891479492,
0.2398245483636856,
-0.09117035567760468,
-0.6258510947227478,
-0.6645718812942505,
-0.2023158073425293,
0.5546939373016357,
0.048002589493989944,
-0.6923717856407166,
0.34480020403862,
0.2552214562892914,
0.7727623581886292,
-0.2177489697933197,
0.13762545585632324,
0.22802852094173431,
0.6344607472419739,
-0.20521500706672668,
-0.48477402329444885,
0.5224705338478088,
-0.19864116609096527,
0.08362969756126404,
-0.0948374941945076,
-0.23705700039863586,
0.5539395809173584,
-0.010639137588441372,
-0.2635857164859772,
0.024288661777973175,
0.6336537003517151,
0.08336952328681946,
0.6041513085365295,
0.7688459753990173,
0.4180982708930969,
0.6930858492851257,
-0.2532206177711487,
1.0459964275360107,
0.12054084986448288,
0.34081563353538513,
0.9837982058525085,
-0.12024575471878052,
0.4027748703956604,
0.4940941333770752,
-0.12871745228767395,
0.7915024161338806,
0.49186545610427856,
0.09579730033874512,
0.5693230032920837,
0.020624743774533272,
-0.25196465849876404,
-0.5434667468070984,
-0.2949831485748291,
-0.04314505681395531,
0.28310078382492065,
0.38499128818511963,
-0.14071470499038696,
-0.21432361006736755,
0.28235623240470886,
0.06594225019216537,
0.555938720703125,
-0.2826436460018158,
0.7581539750099182,
-0.14762642979621887,
-0.39172765612602234,
0.3572501242160797,
-0.2018311470746994,
0.5451815128326416,
-0.09618424624204636,
-0.4471299648284912,
-0.09684304147958755,
0.10488473623991013,
-0.25917571783065796,
-0.6256462335586548,
0.3545318841934204,
0.12400096654891968,
-0.4721784293651581,
-0.5281122922897339,
0.5936802625656128,
-0.556412398815155,
-0.47719016671180725,
-0.11110727488994598,
0.025294318795204163,
-0.014596167020499706,
0.17860394716262817,
-0.3522246181964874,
0.13121233880519867,
-0.10948947817087173,
0.044952716678380966,
0.06874654442071915,
0.6105616688728333,
-0.36312752962112427,
0.3255849778652191,
0.5484508275985718,
-0.3362773060798645,
-0.35418465733528137,
0.10452838987112045,
0.7292104959487915,
-0.671879768371582,
-0.6945554614067078,
-1.0842692852020264,
0.4442777931690216,
-0.031286079436540604,
-0.2356548309326172,
0.6604701280593872,
0.46011337637901306,
0.6238434910774231,
0.00009862826118478552,
0.8372613787651062,
0.111346036195755,
0.47192734479904175,
-0.52961266040802,
0.46814966201782227,
-0.651491641998291,
0.262824147939682,
-0.4153897762298584,
-0.3969225287437439,
-0.28757840394973755,
0.8163295388221741,
-0.36635148525238037,
-0.18117694556713104,
0.5397931933403015,
0.5184510946273804,
-0.215354323387146,
0.3974664509296417,
0.28312429785728455,
0.4759155511856079,
0.4112829864025116,
0.11437960714101791,
0.8056114912033081,
-0.5969058871269226,
0.4339778423309326,
-0.12231160700321198,
-0.20319166779518127,
-0.2831655442714691,
-1.0370415449142456,
-1.0908759832382202,
-0.5696354508399963,
-0.490372896194458,
-0.22794337570667267,
0.08326245099306107,
0.6954496502876282,
0.4892290532588959,
-0.7622191905975342,
0.24735470116138458,
-0.24552598595619202,
0.5908754467964172,
-0.14912572503089905,
-0.3377017080783844,
0.2636401951313019,
-0.31870806217193604,
-0.8426364064216614,
0.260232537984848,
0.10440783202648163,
0.22046715021133423,
-0.11655990034341812,
0.14312535524368286,
-0.00342643354088068,
0.4119137227535248,
0.831782341003418,
0.10807473212480545,
-0.441072940826416,
-0.6810780763626099,
-0.3805118799209595,
0.1439044028520584,
-0.16808919608592987,
1.0521646738052368,
-1.2614461183547974,
0.29660549759864807,
0.3139660060405731,
0.43904006481170654,
0.48225367069244385,
-0.1414078176021576,
0.540147066116333,
-0.958329439163208,
0.23705706000328064,
-0.055539246648550034,
0.24868535995483398,
0.003040744224563241,
-0.5246937870979309,
0.29896724224090576,
0.30430108308792114,
-0.09278854727745056,
-1.0802793502807617,
0.29444244503974915,
-0.6302548050880432,
-0.6313658952713013,
0.46159785985946655,
-0.17038443684577942,
0.09989321976900101,
-0.2742964029312134,
-0.16691939532756805,
0.41417378187179565,
-0.046046607196331024,
0.9105321764945984,
0.5490534901618958,
-0.08116528391838074,
0.08626195788383484,
-0.1919216811656952,
0.3879621922969818,
0.5335291028022766,
-0.7355896234512329,
0.11209037154912949,
0.4783853590488434,
0.042769309133291245,
0.36925008893013,
0.34450313448905945,
-0.05976467952132225,
0.364984929561615,
0.3095192611217499,
-0.14261597394943237,
0.12938958406448364,
-0.2413940131664276,
-0.34369298815727234,
-0.07666599005460739,
-0.5450029373168945,
-0.028528545051813126
] |
Subsets and Splits